id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01616v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01616v2
|
Towards Comprehensive Vietnamese Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T21:24:35 | 2024-03-05T18:15:49 |
Nguyen Quang Duc, Le Hai Son, Nguyen Duc Nhan, Nguyen Dich Nhat Minh, Le Thanh Huong, Dinh Viet Sang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our contributions towards advancing the state of
Vietnamese language understanding and generation through the development and
dissemination of open datasets and pre-trained models for Vietnamese
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) and Large Language Models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.0912007466,
-0.6558932662,
0.8116167188,
-0.0336331166,
-0.1336723417,
0.0565043353,
-0.3218512237,
-0.0296074804,
0.0959475562,
1.1501232386,
-0.1698471457,
-0.4931606054,
-0.5884170532,
0.1764661968,
-0.2822186947,
0.5985913277,
-0.1993470192,
0.0468204319,
-0.0978902802,
-0.1397713572,
-0.4221580923,
-0.7302448153,
-0.6520895362,
-0.335881114,
0.5296115279,
0.4576868713,
0.4062723219,
0.4855283797,
0.5768713355,
0.2744639516,
-0.1128251702,
0.3115753531,
-0.9050289392,
0.2924082577,
-0.4302117527,
-0.5328250527,
-0.6032170653,
-0.2384902984,
0.8975774646,
0.5634845495,
-0.1805541813,
0.3135067821,
-0.1211223453,
0.8093831539,
-0.8983857036,
0.0491205081,
-0.6550969481,
-0.3222381473,
-0.2650834024,
-0.4226211607,
-0.5507460237,
-0.2822196186,
0.0595198497,
-0.5338177681,
0.2209822685,
-0.4691419601,
0.5821705461,
0.094687365,
-0.8944125772,
-0.2610158026,
-0.8320732117,
0.8720850348,
-0.3777196407,
0.5815064311,
0.6075347662,
0.418282479,
-0.2556043565,
-0.8849298954,
-0.37325418,
-0.3378201127,
0.0399038047,
0.3260038495,
0.044138819,
0.2393791527,
0.0520094931,
0.6664583683,
-0.5803058743,
0.1202317178,
-0.4006486535,
-0.0063949209,
0.7846961021,
0.1162686199,
-0.0000619638,
-0.1745722741,
-0.3330699503,
0.2774578929,
-0.9382700324,
-0.4975103438,
0.000706813,
0.4347113967,
-0.1786524206,
0.9258019328,
-0.2734852433,
1.0966295004,
-0.4943913817,
-0.3017041981,
0.4160594642,
-0.711797893,
-0.4219282269,
-0.1506364644,
0.3572033346,
-0.143810764,
0.4052627385,
0.0662798062,
-0.4760793447,
-0.0735527873,
0.2399878651,
-0.3386822045,
0.3091935217,
0.1956878453,
-0.5483566523,
-0.1135297865,
0.5002843738,
-0.5460221767,
-0.4051684737,
-0.6658568382,
0.6247130036,
-0.0692839175,
-0.6432649493,
0.2957704067,
-0.260378629,
0.3287013769,
0.3443041742,
-0.3094829023,
0.0141546475,
0.8102118969,
0.8659284115,
-0.2259368896,
-0.3730471134,
-0.6508206725,
0.579359591,
-0.2724950016,
0.6632406116,
-0.6256600022,
-0.7333186865,
0.4285248816,
0.0417093858,
0.1163565442,
-0.8706259727,
0.577911973,
-0.6846555471,
0.0936004966,
0.0761248991,
-0.5914855599,
-0.1329737604,
0.1675699055,
-0.6597595215,
0.8801772594,
0.5833454132,
-0.7144220471,
-0.1078418121,
-0.651386261,
-0.1794906706,
0.1398312598,
0.1014452204,
-0.0608814768,
0.4172411859,
0.0783987641,
0.5215526819,
-0.3705587089,
0.3988784254,
-0.0173218679,
-0.3597063422,
0.1757469475,
-0.2663024664,
0.837182641,
0.6129400134,
0.0349013433,
0.2738344669,
-0.9132987261,
-0.150774166,
0.3077798784,
-0.585172832,
-0.5222659111,
-0.313513428,
0.1765556037,
0.0936469361,
0.5738819242,
-0.2749784589,
0.3454063535,
0.0378749892,
0.0311177392,
0.6662234664,
0.1029466912,
0.4930276275,
-0.0289919619,
0.7331790328,
0.3212318122,
-0.1167792678,
-0.8126232028,
-0.1079534218,
-0.8547003865,
-0.3610437512,
0.2649448514,
0.4907306433,
-1.1485300064,
0.4054838419,
-0.3405084014,
-0.4613506794,
-0.7918708324,
0.4051761627,
0.4397565126,
0.5151048303,
0.2664287686,
-0.1815485805,
-0.9942324162,
-0.704767406,
-0.1310469061,
-0.2461648136,
-0.3811295331,
0.3140186071,
0.4501492083,
-0.7392372489,
0.8054335117,
-0.5918134451,
-0.1147861481,
-0.4633880258,
-0.0881003961,
0.2192908525,
0.2462502718,
0.4511128366,
-0.9434858561,
-0.5612721443,
0.1837413758,
-0.7485745549,
-0.3097239435,
0.4225943387,
-0.2281129211,
0.3327783942,
0.6505596042,
-0.452257216,
0.4363163114,
0.5282669067,
-0.3880594969,
0.6134490371,
-0.2207764387,
0.0669207275,
-1.3110984564,
-0.0325311087,
-0.1055692062,
-0.3995227516,
-0.8553471565,
0.2745430171,
-0.2080191374,
0.0266488269,
-0.5136069655,
0.8732424974,
-0.5651953816,
-0.1598335654,
-0.5633804798,
0.1812078506,
-0.0726844743,
-0.2872287929,
0.3435813487,
0.9979069829,
0.6557230949,
-0.8267067671,
0.2883788943,
0.0278943237,
-0.1450267136,
0.6299666166,
-0.6693267226,
0.0647921562,
-0.3132809699,
0.1888526231,
-0.5820419788,
-0.3153539598,
-0.1691232771,
-0.4059692621,
0.3004452884,
-0.22165896,
-0.3602139354,
-0.3816449046,
-0.0774101391,
0.3238165379,
0.4770795703,
-0.6015595198,
0.3674014211,
0.673581183,
-0.0294156075,
-0.5608174801,
-0.318402499,
-0.0495957844,
-0.26065135,
-0.4460816085,
-0.0825106129,
0.250290513,
-0.7541213036,
-0.1861993074,
0.3316248953,
-0.2717030942,
-0.2571361661,
-0.237123847,
0.2032461017,
-0.7092295885,
0.4003403485,
-0.3732222915,
-0.0758100674,
-0.1207623258,
-0.564471364,
0.702066958,
0.1231468543,
-0.076624237,
-0.0675098673,
0.259270817,
0.3313694,
-0.5338905454,
0.8208095431,
0.6391940713,
-0.1565479636,
0.0456791557,
-0.7410664558,
0.1302334815,
-0.4714647532,
0.4316577613,
-0.4775228202,
-1.3575890064,
0.245515272,
-0.2681114674,
-0.1556823552,
0.5146973133,
0.9688739777,
0.1496335566,
0.7397313118,
1.1185668707,
-0.0942405388,
0.5043709278,
-0.1770420671,
-0.2812898159,
-0.823946774,
0.0944907814,
-0.6663485169,
0.2960334718,
-1.0251698494,
-0.924334228,
0.1997885853,
0.1274502426,
-0.6159895062,
-0.0004796982,
-0.3468055129,
0.2431137264,
0.6472514272,
0.0836766735,
0.563781023,
0.0327855013,
0.1648451984,
0.1302752048,
-0.5256280303,
-0.6169929504,
1.3719767332,
0.2859732211,
0.7806671262,
0.0587956384,
0.8248223662,
0.0936119184,
0.1346241087,
-0.616917789,
0.3640651703,
-0.1921318322,
-0.5417227149,
-0.2556465268,
-0.6963513494,
-1.1998217106,
0.1196176037,
0.1203251779,
-0.4328470528,
-0.0920884162,
-0.1638095677,
0.4157792926,
0.2119446993,
-0.7262750864,
0.5197720528,
-0.2291545272,
-0.0443289131,
-0.3688597381,
-0.4647515714,
0.5568286777,
-0.1566237509,
0.047131069,
0.1290079802,
-0.4562245309,
0.6075998545,
-0.1762853116,
0.4289248884,
-0.2522783875,
-0.312782526,
0.8367436528,
-0.0333662443,
0.2074041069,
0.2571146786,
-0.2672627866,
0.0381409116,
-0.4202997386,
-0.6455119848,
-0.3018738329,
0.5660949349,
-0.7867473364,
-0.6828218102,
-0.2930299938,
-0.5112317204,
-0.1013563424,
0.3911904395,
0.0850958154,
-0.0072432566,
-0.3748815954,
0.2036527991,
0.8924332261,
-0.5028660297,
-0.0104610762,
0.7643082738,
-0.6096299291,
-0.534224391,
1.0552641153,
0.165849939,
0.3455460072,
0.4810410142,
0.0680763647,
-0.2408868074,
-0.403269738,
0.1914553195,
0.7226391435,
-0.542175293,
-0.2129698992,
-0.5459087491,
-0.4251101315,
-0.6118142009,
0.0307544321,
-0.3294552267,
-0.4568621218,
-0.345381707,
-0.3204747736,
0.6275519133,
1.4332499504,
-0.3876576722,
0.6489182711,
-1.049529314,
0.6286103129,
0.1115194932,
0.4354226589,
-0.1224532276,
-0.7259711027,
-0.4310172498,
0.0209749546,
-0.3094196618,
-0.6199376583,
0.1836704016,
0.0734453648,
0.414747417,
0.2193003297,
-0.2548050284,
0.5515217185,
-0.4730668366,
0.7536542416,
0.014116101,
-0.7935632467,
1.0331751108,
-0.5945574641,
0.531829834,
0.2997434735,
0.5458420515,
-0.5724980831,
0.012414813,
-0.5415426493,
-0.7906546593,
0.5565333366,
0.1556531787,
0.0115769524,
0.112565279,
0.4521907568,
0.1737190634,
0.3897941113,
-0.4385692477,
-0.1813814044,
-0.0566240624,
-0.0217318982,
-0.5599052906,
-0.632550776,
0.1692682654,
-0.2319764197,
0.6105421185,
-0.1073370799,
0.2843092084,
0.0314693525,
0.0143918553,
0.0327916779,
0.3743440509,
0.5631173849,
1.0662641525,
-0.0992273837,
0.0038433766,
-0.039717488,
-0.7845280766,
0.3661474884,
-0.1004977673,
-0.0798857287,
0.2320169359,
0.6034166813,
0.6641178727,
-0.3581228554,
-0.7136390209,
0.3131228983,
-0.0362849012,
0.0588225238,
-0.4592734873,
0.0085624037,
0.0606734566,
-0.0205063894,
0.5137935877,
-0.718732357,
-0.098374255,
-0.6071975827,
0.4113588929,
0.2270650417,
-0.4866915047,
-0.3277264833,
0.388253659,
0.0844514892,
-0.2215771973,
0.8459256291,
0.1950455904,
-0.566074729,
0.3978942335,
0.6465523243,
0.9254116416,
-0.5635384321,
0.3982085288,
0.5131245255,
0.2154969424,
-0.1270604283,
0.7979735136,
0.0120394835,
-0.4259885252,
-0.67932266,
-0.846382618,
-0.3107567728,
0.2418183982,
-0.8119126558,
0.5065194368,
0.1536265314,
-0.1340925246,
-0.5933372378,
0.0634176955,
-0.6235805154,
0.2763533294,
0.1691044569,
1.2281761169,
-0.4477214813,
1.060287714,
0.769108057,
-0.45054847,
-0.5318682194,
0.0672895163,
-0.2292069942,
-0.7678849697,
0.8807822466,
-0.0231520366,
0.0982347429,
0.1235225573,
-0.6984170675,
-1.0142457485,
0.9584498405,
0.495927155,
-0.3659622371,
-0.0565183721,
0.4293666482,
0.6267533302,
-0.5163104534,
0.2644914091,
0.7976481318,
0.5013988018,
0.0406414904,
-1.1271692514,
-0.4526415169,
-0.0160781108,
0.2864442766,
0.1433005035,
-0.6114652157,
0.8269199133,
-0.1024196222,
0.029747121,
0.2083017975,
1.0238026381,
0.5345232487,
0.2914989889,
0.1415246278,
0.6793344617,
0.5900635123,
-0.1469037384,
1.0655732155,
0.0793404132,
0.1734261513,
1.1490068436,
-0.1497620046,
1.025911212,
0.4185048342,
-0.1420451999,
0.1381488591,
0.5322957039,
0.4111628234,
0.2334641218,
0.2693252861,
-0.5134502053,
0.0044580046,
-0.6514481306,
-0.6330822706,
0.7253316045,
0.6288478374,
-0.3638792932,
-0.0429825485,
0.1995014101,
-0.1560551375,
0.3108135462,
-0.709698081,
0.8619968295,
0.4027586281,
-0.5407698154,
0.7151194811,
-0.2451935261,
0.6109390259,
-0.6396487355,
-0.2529866695,
-0.0692091733,
0.1705894023,
-0.1876619905,
-1.1033655405,
0.2884019911,
0.1023405418,
-0.1165389121,
-0.071463488,
0.9350726008,
-0.5988242626,
-0.5048828721,
0.5099418163,
0.8430857658,
0.1285178065,
0.0334428586,
-0.5214431286,
0.3786984682,
-0.2213707566,
-0.2910828888,
0.1982335299,
0.7056480646,
0.0400872938,
0.5193235278,
0.3790463507,
0.2527195811,
0.2316168845,
0.1144085824,
0.8863637447,
-0.7661288381,
-0.3410950303,
-0.5676907897,
0.5311796069,
0.2429192215,
-0.0301542729,
0.8412349224,
0.656308651,
1.2814053297,
-0.2285297066,
1.005439043,
-0.0076767397,
0.8809912801,
-0.5232429504,
0.6621593833,
-0.6785786748,
-0.0180130806,
-0.1363056451,
-1.1977652311,
-0.2523905933,
0.2672779262,
-0.1169794127,
0.2052657157,
0.1749460101,
0.6035784483,
-0.0093655512,
-0.483707428,
0.3434460461,
0.6447253227,
0.3698031008,
0.2643403709,
0.9241319895,
-0.2241041511,
0.1822934151,
-0.1778357774,
-0.2154778242,
-0.1090549976,
-0.4604101479,
-0.7991374135,
-0.8292375207,
0.1728766263,
-0.3900047541,
0.180664897,
0.7653850317,
0.2656426728,
-0.7040610909,
-0.809581995,
-0.0024336423,
0.2721075118,
0.3364539444,
-0.2425418943,
0.4677984715,
-0.4378794134,
-0.8408195972,
0.4190069735,
0.2799300849,
0.0942915305,
-0.5892030001,
-0.3549013436,
-0.5892779231,
-0.0468435511,
1.2399932146,
0.2733166516,
-0.5441045165,
0.0569204427,
0.0801509544,
-0.1732015014,
0.1343427151,
0.9721772671,
-1.0579066277,
0.681732595,
0.7046340108,
0.7466904521,
0.2331733108,
0.0403862074,
1.0362514257,
-0.5611245036,
0.4823469818,
0.128940016,
0.2486745268,
0.4328738153,
-0.3530308604,
0.9062876701,
0.0437102094,
-0.7111610174,
-1.0917038918,
0.4519913197,
-0.6849581599,
-0.1273964942,
1.2056646347,
-0.0451962575,
-0.4116236269,
-0.139816761,
-0.3355552554,
0.5219747424,
0.0083040204,
0.2307737619,
0.2948995233,
0.0375638381,
-0.0783245936,
-0.7725681663,
0.3667974174,
-0.058920227,
-0.7884704471,
0.0542106554,
0.4859579206,
-0.2960698307,
0.052669026,
0.840484798,
-0.163588956,
0.353282392,
-0.1869714558,
-0.1829186976,
0.3504205048,
-0.5605400801,
-0.6047155857,
-0.1378268003,
0.3775731325,
0.1919833422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01599v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01599v1
|
SCHEMA: State CHangEs MAtter for Procedure Planning in Instructional Videos
| 2024-03-03T19:53:06 | 2024-03-03T19:53:06 |
Yulei Niu, Wenliang Guo, Long Chen, Xudong Lin, Shih-Fu Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of procedure planning in instructional videos, which
aims to make a goal-oriented sequence of action steps given partial visual
state observations. The motivation of this problem is to learn a structured and
plannable state and action space. Recent works succeeded in sequence modeling
of steps with only sequence-level annotations accessible during training, which
overlooked the roles of states in the procedures. In this work, we point out
that State CHangEs MAtter (SCHEMA) for procedure planning in instructional
videos. We aim to establish a more structured state space by investigating the
causal relations between steps and states in procedures. Specifically, we
explicitly represent each step as state changes and track the state changes in
procedures. For step representation, we leveraged the commonsense knowledge in
large language models (LLMs) to describe the state changes of steps via our
designed chain-of-thought prompting. For state change tracking, we align visual
state observations with language state descriptions via cross-modal contrastive
learning, and explicitly model the intermediate states of the procedure using
LLM-generated state descriptions. Experiments on CrossTask, COIN, and NIV
benchmark datasets demonstrate that our proposed SCHEMA model achieves
state-of-the-art performance and obtains explainable visualizations.
|
[
0.074874498,
-0.7315327525,
0.6144663692,
-0.0975608528,
-0.2498895973,
-0.4650957584,
-0.0737338811,
0.0985084847,
0.4645844102,
0.6097337604,
-0.6398948431,
-0.4312942922,
-0.4960028827,
-0.084189564,
-0.605804503,
0.9274430871,
-0.4912959337,
0.2123574913,
-0.0568197593,
0.1609645933,
-0.3832197487,
0.0962057486,
-0.2438430786,
-0.3336380422,
0.2750530243,
0.4549435079,
0.3897575736,
1.02214849,
0.4298604429,
0.3449478149,
-0.0610229485,
-0.0480545461,
-0.4049009383,
0.4029017985,
-0.3463895917,
-0.5175670385,
-0.3005675972,
-0.3304430246,
0.7989681363,
0.6867315173,
-0.4248749614,
0.1250151992,
-0.2740238309,
0.5818055272,
-0.5900917053,
0.6620052457,
-0.6456407905,
0.2152375132,
-0.0260314047,
-0.4474801719,
-0.2341573089,
-0.1308905184,
0.1545102,
-0.8485988975,
0.3591890931,
-0.2554239929,
0.4340563416,
0.3861555755,
-0.2189093828,
-0.3023796082,
-1.0825006962,
0.2298996598,
-0.418417573,
0.5956591964,
0.1096931845,
0.3266297579,
-0.3276278973,
-0.7149393559,
-0.6764960289,
-0.0769042969,
0.2270080447,
0.0178760029,
0.0061853258,
0.2497657537,
0.7857096791,
0.3178262711,
-0.2980131507,
0.0115040457,
-0.7017128468,
-0.3090792596,
0.5049667954,
0.6183519959,
0.2083071917,
-0.2560915649,
-0.519884944,
-0.186962083,
-0.820463717,
0.1246800199,
0.0768689364,
0.319103241,
-0.0954476073,
0.7166763544,
-0.4505178928,
0.825250566,
0.1045247838,
-0.4751313329,
-0.2363827825,
-0.382060647,
-0.6168380976,
0.0597118959,
0.3758529723,
0.4089096785,
0.016577173,
0.2935188115,
-0.0119618699,
0.1894139498,
0.3176165819,
-0.9493980408,
-0.287466079,
0.0042349873,
-0.2961657643,
0.063889347,
-0.0251567066,
-0.3613334894,
-0.6184930801,
-0.8284496069,
0.3178443611,
-0.5679063797,
-0.0646924824,
0.1393919587,
0.0442079492,
0.1593561023,
0.7863039374,
-1.0743396282,
0.4535726011,
0.7035915852,
0.4037924111,
-0.0599785075,
-0.4404701591,
-0.4761402309,
0.3875625432,
-0.4889476597,
0.7464074492,
-0.6184763312,
-0.3860792518,
0.529992342,
0.0538804382,
-0.0182567667,
-0.376500845,
-0.1337141097,
-0.2740269899,
-0.1951048225,
-0.4496751726,
-0.8688426018,
-0.0682259724,
0.0528033637,
-0.4971272647,
0.7136355639,
-0.0409656577,
-0.5745211244,
0.750546515,
-0.7523934245,
-0.6356991529,
-0.080263406,
-0.576644361,
-0.0338374339,
0.0047132359,
-0.2485774606,
0.5778226256,
0.1652095765,
0.2903020382,
0.1044914424,
-0.3815997541,
0.2775856256,
0.0814814642,
0.2579752803,
0.0662376583,
-0.0971168131,
0.5604367852,
-0.7337062359,
-0.4525224566,
-0.3559006155,
-0.3426740766,
-0.1924297214,
0.2043791413,
-0.4478867054,
0.4120038748,
-0.1015161127,
-0.2636570334,
0.4125460684,
0.0240702741,
0.4887872636,
0.6566156745,
0.2781425416,
0.9707883596,
0.2161262184,
0.4454000592,
0.198486805,
0.2727553248,
-0.6161957979,
-0.2556889951,
-0.8871326447,
0.1206559092,
-0.2134789377,
0.4295583069,
-0.7216998339,
-0.3156360686,
-0.0902389884,
-0.3736844063,
-0.1494537294,
-0.1069637761,
0.1924541593,
0.8810645342,
0.5401978493,
-0.2033963948,
-0.2626385987,
-0.8510039449,
-0.1670733541,
-0.2464883327,
0.0554880984,
-0.02251352,
0.8175471425,
0.3100289106,
0.5587385297,
-0.783420682,
-0.3791613281,
-0.2439590394,
0.127643168,
-0.0480095856,
0.2146679163,
-0.1534980983,
-0.5430634022,
-0.1849283278,
-0.3503650725,
-0.5061656833,
0.1942524463,
-0.568582654,
-0.1323809624,
0.2473440617,
0.8701618314,
-0.4728725255,
0.88259691,
0.0467896648,
-0.1209992617,
0.5387145877,
-0.3181339502,
0.2614546716,
-0.9186404347,
-0.3232589066,
0.1566937715,
0.4707728624,
-0.6895287037,
-0.0203497112,
0.3144530654,
-0.2745765448,
-0.7940737009,
0.3282346427,
-0.3378506303,
-0.5047547817,
-0.0005020649,
0.0619953647,
-0.3150516152,
0.551800549,
0.4770061374,
0.6110385656,
0.7571771741,
-0.7799569964,
0.0597704016,
0.306632638,
-0.2733648419,
0.8304874301,
-0.2096576095,
-0.3875540793,
0.1104518026,
0.4770563841,
-0.7539045811,
-0.3424478173,
0.495693475,
-0.0467959791,
0.3886913061,
-0.3731103837,
-0.3847727478,
0.040200565,
-0.0114268893,
-0.1066254899,
0.0316850469,
0.0718958154,
0.5981405973,
0.319159627,
-0.032622993,
-0.5526313782,
-0.5802417994,
-0.1798427552,
-0.0623009168,
-0.4466769993,
0.4878407717,
0.2144025862,
-0.2752675414,
-0.0208042059,
-0.5716733336,
-0.1877066642,
-0.2113894224,
0.5671105385,
0.2426628619,
0.0065636882,
0.3807574809,
0.4243116677,
0.0834505558,
0.4067731798,
-0.2308587879,
0.3813976347,
0.1904044896,
-0.3334515989,
-0.7500948906,
0.4346367121,
0.3620224297,
-0.1126538441,
0.370087564,
0.1969664693,
-0.4840956032,
-0.1818859577,
-0.1112066507,
-0.4319511652,
-0.4062567949,
0.520735085,
-0.2061156332,
-0.6125336885,
0.3724580109,
-0.0733727217,
0.3116821945,
-0.0077699353,
0.3975189626,
-0.452162832,
0.5239986181,
0.5600583553,
0.4867016971,
0.7551102042,
-0.5253047347,
-0.0220851898,
-0.8622741699,
-0.4003826082,
-0.2209129035,
-0.2929210365,
-0.6181779504,
-0.922678411,
0.4369120598,
-0.0476734862,
-0.4240395129,
0.4653989375,
-0.007972491,
0.3010327518,
0.2032772601,
0.033667054,
0.2455144823,
0.3261474073,
-0.0739858821,
-0.3613183498,
-0.7084386945,
-0.248813659,
1.032099843,
0.0120082963,
1.080704093,
-0.1994747072,
0.9285525084,
0.0284539741,
0.1017418131,
-0.8523907661,
1.1004668474,
-0.029508017,
-0.2500509322,
-0.638720274,
-0.0139201526,
-0.8555995226,
0.1851459146,
-0.4247615337,
-0.5395953059,
0.0437859707,
0.4668692052,
-0.0435355566,
0.4560922384,
-0.2249860466,
0.5526202917,
0.0559459254,
-0.6163849831,
-0.5769172907,
-0.6423074007,
0.2000515461,
0.4753341675,
-0.0408449173,
0.2708697915,
0.0552522615,
0.775415957,
-0.6866220236,
0.9065604806,
-0.0250715595,
-0.1621320397,
0.2937025726,
0.5280227661,
0.4601934552,
-0.2124619335,
0.3036250472,
-0.0693941787,
-0.3504915535,
-0.0737501159,
-0.7534900904,
0.5314123034,
-0.1719778776,
-0.737680614,
-0.528873384,
-0.68595016,
-0.0163082164,
0.1514852643,
0.0002301556,
0.4416386783,
-0.1355253458,
-0.1208849996,
0.8495291471,
-0.0353974253,
0.3039728105,
0.7169654965,
-0.1243854687,
-0.0455592647,
0.7222853899,
0.505659163,
0.4896831512,
0.5297909975,
-0.0073891198,
-0.2194428444,
-0.4796913564,
-0.4845575988,
0.4315160215,
-1.0141369104,
0.0976250544,
-0.1050617322,
-0.0165574066,
-0.3726824522,
-0.1970801204,
-0.2129788399,
-0.4891454577,
-0.2960546315,
-0.2007030547,
0.1100830808,
0.7993587255,
-0.0564882904,
0.0486237928,
-0.3373523951,
0.2062998414,
0.2741096616,
0.2278159857,
-0.2789194286,
-0.4040457904,
-0.3303853273,
-0.2193224281,
-0.3502513468,
-1.1509041786,
0.0456916988,
-0.0047675855,
0.450581193,
0.5946012139,
-0.2209612876,
1.0779043436,
-0.7203111649,
0.7497274876,
0.3296860158,
-0.734896183,
1.01057446,
-0.2710446715,
0.2130604237,
0.1554402113,
0.4366875589,
-0.8215033412,
-0.3731575012,
-0.6553413272,
-0.6975392699,
0.6778395772,
-0.0568809956,
0.0569136962,
-0.0372786783,
0.2912505567,
0.0994338393,
0.3217627704,
-0.3320123553,
-0.2183408439,
-0.1738871485,
0.2907597721,
0.3809383214,
0.0266221687,
-0.4969571829,
-0.0066957776,
0.2741183639,
-0.1701129675,
0.089571774,
0.1610764265,
-0.1953676045,
-0.2608017027,
0.4310142398,
0.8855267167,
0.8855516315,
0.2613027692,
-0.0069421586,
-0.0046571,
-0.4679899514,
-0.0730664581,
0.0280611124,
-0.4725783467,
-0.0900450498,
0.491315484,
0.9814204574,
0.7790589929,
-0.2284857333,
0.3310332596,
0.344053477,
-0.3477541506,
-0.1724838763,
0.4674766362,
0.0017563538,
0.3335261345,
-0.0197955705,
0.0744172707,
0.3679189086,
-0.6295050979,
0.0464478396,
-0.0382186957,
-0.3329579532,
-0.3220006526,
0.5726886392,
0.1542760283,
-0.5886102319,
0.4578264654,
0.0479683764,
-0.2361701131,
0.5488417745,
0.5433450937,
0.310718894,
-0.475107491,
0.7726569772,
0.4885413349,
0.1511349976,
-0.2243344635,
0.5637329221,
-0.4476847947,
-0.3022074699,
-0.2881133556,
-0.1899478137,
-0.5366905928,
0.132020846,
-0.8884771466,
0.4625096321,
-0.4022634923,
0.2253818959,
-0.3062617481,
-0.2648453712,
-0.6726087332,
0.3474335968,
0.062021073,
1.0541071892,
-1.2431765795,
0.5736819506,
0.6030616164,
-0.6844855547,
-1.1099225283,
-0.0585450493,
0.1382246464,
-0.6542232037,
0.7271419168,
-0.3366514146,
0.0282171536,
-0.5149635673,
-0.441514194,
-0.8291318417,
1.3298866749,
0.0847269595,
-0.6382568479,
-0.1277316064,
0.3071547747,
0.6636772156,
-0.367336005,
-0.2746294439,
0.4391658902,
0.097399123,
0.2469632775,
-0.5287008286,
0.0518468544,
0.229442209,
-0.0285860877,
0.4322941899,
-0.2189541757,
0.9222592711,
-0.5739545226,
-0.3799491525,
-0.2977187634,
0.7855768204,
0.518106401,
0.5939290524,
0.5875153542,
0.4813405275,
0.6168665886,
-0.1254439503,
0.7565433383,
-0.115478456,
-0.0179451685,
1.4683727026,
-0.3848083019,
0.9466906786,
0.844925046,
-0.2023185343,
0.6905370951,
0.6222125292,
0.1292257458,
0.3357954919,
0.4258678854,
0.1220238581,
-0.2919252217,
0.1223221943,
-0.3218990862,
0.4040978253,
0.6772508621,
-0.5535821319,
-0.2934458852,
-0.1426237822,
0.3614397943,
0.0606399253,
-0.5105181932,
0.561606288,
-0.2417031676,
-0.9363544583,
-0.0463035367,
-0.5493313074,
-0.2345058173,
-0.7273356915,
-0.556294322,
-0.3463439941,
-0.1658161134,
-0.2626462579,
-1.0967880487,
-0.0310830679,
-0.1668975353,
-0.0367820375,
-0.31533131,
0.4873833656,
-0.7115671635,
-0.2368526906,
-0.0434307046,
0.1501108259,
0.295562923,
0.3562590182,
-0.5739264488,
0.0870528296,
-0.2063868493,
-0.0497275405,
0.3855879605,
0.3212810159,
-0.5158173442,
0.653635025,
0.5117753148,
0.3320832849,
-0.0154433213,
0.2039946616,
0.7927575111,
-0.4556042254,
-0.723996222,
-0.3489379287,
0.6952605844,
-0.1493245959,
-0.3670408428,
0.2377268523,
0.4009829462,
1.087869525,
-0.2214278579,
0.4173895717,
0.0195711888,
0.1161248609,
-0.8728733659,
0.292431891,
-0.3950504363,
0.3622208238,
-0.4061133564,
-0.7766825557,
-0.1041389778,
0.5468125343,
-0.4433671534,
-0.3883462846,
0.8438156843,
0.9001460075,
0.1018389985,
0.0538436882,
0.1659054011,
0.2537285984,
0.245733127,
0.3216351271,
0.6414505839,
-0.208186537,
0.4269884527,
-0.330299139,
0.0087285694,
-0.378839016,
-0.9075179696,
-0.4223382473,
-1.0387603045,
-0.5514327288,
-0.2409378588,
-0.0576468185,
0.7370848656,
0.5781912208,
-0.356109947,
-0.6299838424,
-0.1571723074,
0.0766097307,
-0.2383362353,
-0.1877542734,
0.3795078397,
-0.1216411591,
-0.4573689401,
0.357521385,
0.5784219503,
-0.135585472,
-0.4567116499,
-0.0934394449,
-0.133963719,
0.0863499343,
0.538202107,
0.514977932,
-1.118336916,
-0.3006409109,
0.2336680442,
0.0749428496,
-0.1056966931,
1.3746327162,
-0.4732083082,
0.8038547635,
0.5309318304,
-0.0200249664,
0.9002074003,
-0.3195160031,
0.2817093432,
-0.3747501373,
-0.0651284978,
-0.1513440609,
0.5194812417,
0.144491747,
-0.1490650028,
0.5265461206,
0.0651167557,
-0.3733704984,
-0.5833844543,
0.6784105301,
-1.0175175667,
-0.0892468318,
1.0803726912,
-0.1162579879,
-0.1591923237,
0.2586507201,
-0.1982646734,
0.4985826313,
-0.367208302,
0.866602242,
0.6369160414,
-0.8021679521,
0.0894110948,
-0.3876116574,
0.6419492364,
0.0600500442,
-0.7955810428,
0.1074551865,
0.8160776496,
0.4358977079,
0.1876723021,
0.8241169453,
-0.0018572436,
0.4894630015,
0.1192031577,
-0.2769205272,
-0.091635935,
-0.7567127943,
-0.2264524251,
-0.0687078685,
-0.5580821633,
-0.2730110884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01580v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01580v1
|
Enhancing Neural Machine Translation of Low-Resource Languages: Corpus Development, Human Evaluation and Explainable AI Architectures
| 2024-03-03T18:08:30 | 2024-03-03T18:08:30 |
Séamus Lankford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the current machine translation (MT) landscape, the Transformer
architecture stands out as the gold standard, especially for high-resource
language pairs. This research delves into its efficacy for low-resource
language pairs including both the English$\leftrightarrow$Irish and
English$\leftrightarrow$Marathi language pairs. Notably, the study identifies
the optimal hyperparameters and subword model type to significantly improve the
translation quality of Transformer models for low-resource language pairs.
The scarcity of parallel datasets for low-resource languages can hinder MT
development. To address this, gaHealth was developed, the first bilingual
corpus of health data for the Irish language. Focusing on the health domain,
models developed using this in-domain dataset exhibited very significant
improvements in BLEU score when compared with models from the LoResMT2021
Shared Task. A subsequent human evaluation using the multidimensional quality
metrics error taxonomy showcased the superior performance of the Transformer
system in reducing both accuracy and fluency errors compared to an RNN-based
counterpart.
Furthermore, this thesis introduces adaptNMT and adaptMLLM, two open-source
applications streamlined for the development, fine-tuning, and deployment of
neural machine translation models. These tools considerably simplify the setup
and evaluation process, making MT more accessible to both developers and
translators. Notably, adaptNMT, grounded in the OpenNMT ecosystem, promotes
eco-friendly natural language processing research by highlighting the
environmental footprint of model development. Fine-tuning of MLLMs by adaptMLLM
demonstrated advancements in translation performance for two low-resource
language pairs: English$\leftrightarrow$Irish and
English$\leftrightarrow$Marathi, compared to baselines from the LoResMT2021
Shared Task.
|
[
-0.1165451631,
-0.3862245977,
0.2398279607,
0.2221475393,
-0.050194785,
0.0677457303,
-0.5079397559,
-0.4788177907,
0.1866874695,
0.5493646264,
-0.1154915616,
-0.3140401244,
-0.711270988,
0.3746150136,
-0.1443285197,
0.942138195,
-0.0371619426,
0.235734418,
0.0960190594,
-0.6730514169,
-0.5600273013,
-0.3007877171,
-0.6526709199,
-0.4841055572,
0.6017699242,
0.3262434006,
1.0335272551,
0.7217585444,
0.7911644578,
0.2807306647,
-0.2405369729,
0.2714188397,
-0.3125804663,
0.021043919,
-0.2547608316,
-0.4691003263,
-0.6195315719,
-0.3343213201,
0.3290137649,
0.748931706,
0.0548357852,
0.4949166179,
0.2498548478,
0.7387081981,
-0.4640980363,
0.2370453328,
-0.5860635638,
0.0072999415,
-0.2530072629,
-0.2559182048,
-0.4241253138,
-0.1358793825,
-0.0369617715,
-0.4337845147,
-0.047068283,
0.2494583577,
0.705647707,
0.5740998387,
-0.2737813592,
-0.1664418131,
-0.7182404399,
0.8767790794,
-0.7984066606,
0.543125391,
0.3344275057,
0.233934477,
-0.0093103601,
-0.6833931208,
-0.4166772366,
-0.1625680029,
-0.3877885342,
0.3323858678,
-0.4987596273,
-0.0285746604,
-0.1118471324,
0.4386875927,
-0.6532781124,
0.3079511821,
-0.5581214428,
-0.1711479425,
0.3336887956,
0.418675065,
0.4890361428,
-0.4483434558,
-0.1356694102,
-0.0625430048,
-0.5024012923,
-0.1328203231,
0.1648447812,
0.5784434676,
-0.2422849238,
0.6858933568,
-0.00847374,
0.5897067785,
-0.1594319344,
0.0230929889,
0.3578004539,
-0.7073040009,
-0.2894364297,
-0.032664869,
0.6942257881,
0.2911680639,
-0.045751296,
-0.3331951797,
-0.3111395836,
-0.0155719044,
0.3508256972,
-0.6924760938,
-0.0966184735,
0.002602255,
-0.8558052182,
-0.1123601645,
-0.6027283669,
-0.9292544723,
-0.2980018556,
-0.4153523743,
0.4139357805,
-0.4319938719,
-0.4151230156,
0.2036004663,
0.1560145169,
0.124358505,
0.0484659448,
-0.9302410483,
0.3828852475,
0.4640258849,
0.9221488833,
-0.3007632792,
-0.2727088332,
-0.2625782192,
-0.0748660788,
-0.1793641746,
0.3616220653,
-0.3495550752,
-0.1909431517,
-0.1626428068,
0.0509235971,
-0.3135204911,
-0.6974389553,
0.745431304,
-0.5197971463,
0.2172768563,
0.1511920094,
-0.0143002262,
-0.1800485253,
0.2261607051,
-0.6726141572,
0.9223024249,
0.3012833893,
-0.6597704887,
-0.0231845658,
-1.1905138493,
-0.5109629631,
0.1915398985,
0.3429284394,
-0.305072248,
0.2753347754,
0.2373103201,
0.1338731945,
-0.5129621625,
0.0056547471,
0.2183609456,
-0.2422711551,
-0.0484292731,
-0.6163009405,
0.8643011451,
0.3970432878,
-0.2372365743,
0.294221431,
-0.5553039312,
0.0697792619,
0.0390141159,
-0.4820916951,
-0.3796731532,
-0.2186607122,
0.4820728302,
0.2486362606,
0.1589071155,
-0.3599082232,
-0.1992495805,
-0.5170338154,
0.7694706917,
0.3375485837,
-0.2344722897,
0.6398983002,
-0.180850029,
0.5470360518,
0.1945279241,
0.2795580626,
-0.029599797,
-0.7046081424,
-0.6399720311,
-0.0840054452,
0.460182935,
0.7674447894,
-0.7887604833,
0.2916060686,
-0.5699623227,
-0.3301180601,
-1.4035705328,
0.3981427848,
0.3985615373,
0.7414140701,
0.8493583202,
-0.1199838296,
-0.4720892608,
-1.0191076994,
-0.2490433455,
-0.0909792259,
0.0371477976,
0.2083108723,
0.2154375762,
-0.6345673203,
0.4934689105,
-0.1651706845,
-0.180637151,
-0.3554216027,
-0.0240188166,
0.3788043261,
0.5132215619,
0.4845822752,
-0.9463939071,
-0.3991390467,
0.4375550151,
-0.5674924254,
0.0026231082,
0.1637456864,
-0.2424642742,
0.2994396985,
0.1783249229,
-0.5355916619,
0.355640471,
0.9183745384,
-0.1639603227,
0.3489093482,
-0.4564611912,
0.07102447,
-1.2177853584,
0.2082912475,
-0.1523206532,
-0.1224097833,
-0.5993893147,
0.2011924684,
0.0477209762,
-0.2307161987,
-0.6353504658,
0.5756236911,
-0.3025988936,
0.1339293122,
-0.2410850078,
-0.1327708364,
-0.0056552347,
0.3005517721,
-0.2771146297,
0.8248813748,
0.1241073012,
-0.2344659269,
0.1965322196,
0.3850491941,
-0.206292063,
0.3766358197,
-0.689370811,
0.1131904796,
-0.0099198651,
-0.0524110645,
-0.4796658158,
-0.1086319983,
0.2535481751,
-0.4746135175,
0.0619373471,
-0.0220617689,
-0.4607945383,
-0.2443543226,
0.1688898951,
0.4434606433,
0.7089890838,
-0.4414165318,
0.4924917221,
0.2792429328,
-0.0997699872,
-0.3602262139,
-1.1556292772,
0.414942354,
-0.2365881056,
-0.6771493554,
0.3378992975,
0.0582760237,
-0.340836972,
0.3192889392,
0.0602888092,
-0.2162831277,
0.0436672419,
0.021486111,
0.3550457358,
-0.6389148235,
0.136242047,
0.025813913,
-0.4188019335,
-0.192889899,
-0.6690191627,
0.3378445208,
-0.2853562534,
-0.1426934898,
-0.3690783381,
0.3577534854,
0.6749361753,
-0.4882239699,
0.8193492889,
0.9018105268,
-0.4964686334,
0.1045453027,
-0.2908263803,
-0.0701119825,
-0.3958767951,
0.4433564842,
-0.2483321428,
-0.8401134014,
0.3206083179,
-0.0034809199,
-0.0349567235,
0.592064321,
0.9098207355,
0.0658275485,
0.7319936752,
0.5779806972,
-0.1330782324,
0.2051157653,
-0.1289574355,
0.4279778898,
-0.9845596552,
0.0789365843,
-0.4547439218,
-0.5807732344,
-0.9072163701,
-0.4985665381,
0.443757683,
0.0027954052,
0.0718414783,
0.6938971281,
-0.671489954,
0.2361169308,
0.6029716134,
0.2837892175,
0.3312780857,
-0.2021591961,
-0.2239639312,
-0.2390826941,
-0.8347527385,
-0.6384880543,
0.9654514194,
0.2408775389,
0.4816624224,
0.112004295,
0.4689351022,
0.301242888,
0.3725745678,
-0.7727182508,
0.1653368473,
-0.4330615997,
-0.4656803906,
-0.2846709788,
-0.4425776303,
-1.1095869541,
0.2676392794,
-0.2016555369,
-0.3208965063,
0.033692155,
0.1308420599,
-0.4334663451,
0.3676793277,
-0.9517891407,
0.9362966418,
-0.4328255653,
-0.4007755816,
-0.3549457192,
-0.6361615062,
0.1196752414,
-0.1232424825,
0.1838888079,
0.0770660862,
-0.0271937829,
0.4034421444,
-0.1546505392,
0.5277824402,
0.0401324816,
0.1538316458,
0.0568341166,
-0.0289232507,
0.1912772208,
-0.0372167192,
-0.4560186863,
0.3397564888,
-0.206466198,
-0.563393712,
-0.4780665338,
0.763076365,
-0.6718059778,
-0.4750138521,
0.0745616779,
-0.8845905066,
-0.1051539704,
0.3798643351,
0.246106267,
0.1845704317,
0.0506104231,
0.2876010239,
0.4445463121,
-0.4448415935,
0.3846747279,
0.3506177962,
0.0970217362,
-0.4934301078,
0.9175139666,
0.0484255292,
0.2389516532,
0.4843800068,
0.3858504891,
-0.175508827,
-0.7462548018,
-0.7433860302,
-0.0431817286,
-0.3951143622,
-0.3825624883,
-0.7279977798,
-0.29731372,
-0.2732298672,
-0.0476709604,
-0.2784507871,
-0.4759765565,
-0.0585513189,
-0.02145328,
0.3419175446,
0.614880383,
0.0059981928,
0.2636445463,
-0.9538300633,
0.1840306073,
0.0682659075,
0.1873401105,
0.0316862613,
-0.4447897375,
-0.67621696,
0.1150692552,
-0.3196107745,
-0.5666170716,
0.502818346,
-0.048679214,
0.3874870241,
-0.0915903449,
-0.1622875333,
0.5533860326,
-0.6943717599,
0.6117354035,
0.0869769976,
-0.7424737215,
0.4759282172,
-0.186702773,
0.3688876927,
0.6470881701,
0.1048069373,
-0.6381599903,
-0.1543347239,
-0.3506343067,
-0.8179026246,
0.4175796211,
0.4613823593,
0.2533366978,
0.1029793993,
0.1528672874,
0.1548080742,
-0.0357775353,
-0.3625949323,
-0.1642484069,
-0.1923400164,
-0.4800048769,
-0.1483819634,
0.1480963081,
0.0036395199,
-0.3396015763,
0.4734756947,
-0.110828951,
0.2438671738,
0.1157606542,
-0.3427124918,
-0.1131880507,
0.4042823613,
0.6726404428,
0.4625230134,
-0.0328688286,
0.1718526632,
0.4191392958,
-0.532147944,
0.193656683,
0.0987447128,
-0.2771344483,
0.1605674177,
0.429422617,
0.8733099699,
0.2980533838,
-0.3340326548,
0.2265333086,
-0.0668350905,
0.2096141279,
0.1093110591,
-0.0623514764,
0.3868963718,
0.1157964468,
0.0563727953,
0.6471803784,
0.0545941815,
-0.2119772434,
0.0108947139,
0.053250365,
-0.4785884023,
-0.6599015594,
0.8272078037,
0.3894740939,
-0.7407172322,
0.666020453,
0.0137209669,
-0.3685745895,
0.3953875005,
0.6773570776,
0.9037323594,
-0.2886904478,
-0.0623791814,
0.2027780712,
0.683110714,
0.0873361602,
0.0895740092,
0.0878728256,
-0.5443634391,
-0.530752182,
-0.7631375194,
-0.3794793487,
0.0627669469,
-0.6570897698,
0.2321062684,
0.0632551014,
-0.3113048077,
-0.049686309,
-0.1793544143,
-1.0426999331,
0.0030789452,
-0.0913917348,
1.0775998831,
-0.6980856657,
0.9349165559,
0.8959255815,
-0.5030491948,
-0.5126595497,
-0.0499566197,
-0.1193992496,
-0.9012891054,
0.6861487627,
-0.1576372534,
0.0096558109,
0.1452253312,
0.0547428727,
-0.5551034212,
1.100487709,
0.5248666406,
-0.4695908725,
-0.2674769461,
0.4763669074,
0.871847868,
-0.1284125149,
0.2426066101,
0.5206667185,
0.7855485678,
-0.4477242827,
-1.0505592823,
-0.0455988944,
-0.3173476458,
0.187877968,
0.3444054723,
-0.6442661881,
0.4718823433,
-0.1292946637,
0.0733224303,
0.1378357857,
0.5141637325,
-0.2111717612,
0.2291973382,
0.3467033207,
0.5987428427,
0.6210576296,
-0.017050596,
1.1038444042,
-0.5405476689,
0.161429584,
0.9944432974,
-0.0816314965,
0.9119815826,
0.6676415801,
-0.1172293574,
0.2050019503,
0.2541312575,
0.2467882633,
0.3366609216,
0.2432721257,
-0.2363378406,
-0.0107900389,
-0.36091277,
-0.1960447282,
0.6318855286,
0.3796727955,
-0.582033813,
-0.2512541413,
0.2388969958,
-0.0128067089,
0.253754288,
-0.2097830921,
0.604801178,
0.2121807188,
-0.4624423981,
0.5612305999,
0.2120188773,
0.7622417212,
-0.3727144003,
0.064493522,
-0.3915166557,
0.3297437131,
-0.2683231533,
-0.5843625665,
0.8124139309,
0.0690644905,
-0.3297587931,
-0.5281001925,
0.7378422618,
-0.4750583768,
-0.5672098994,
0.6176437736,
0.7651437521,
-0.0490761288,
0.299936533,
-0.6611998081,
-0.0455018207,
-0.2597390115,
0.046014972,
0.2092057616,
0.473700583,
-0.1385333687,
0.3968403637,
0.6415345669,
0.4500688612,
0.0703329593,
-0.0686727166,
0.546325922,
-0.5083689094,
-0.1237834617,
-0.8117010593,
0.4151006341,
0.2305025607,
-0.4273384809,
0.6370780468,
0.6219226122,
0.6407197714,
-0.1866949946,
0.6165890694,
0.0588892773,
0.3331854045,
-0.3644398153,
1.1264958382,
-0.4651095271,
-0.1378210485,
0.1607476324,
-0.7844888568,
-0.4819029868,
0.1388340443,
-0.1351203471,
-0.3516710401,
0.670670867,
0.859177649,
-0.3019429147,
-0.1585097313,
0.4818230271,
0.1941477209,
0.1279907376,
0.6345582008,
0.5658051968,
-0.6593430638,
0.684615016,
-0.1406084895,
-0.1510122418,
-0.1701477319,
-0.6567780375,
-0.4988825917,
-0.4471750557,
-0.104321219,
-0.5104808807,
0.2241588682,
1.0293779373,
0.7146289349,
-0.8506684303,
-0.2185943276,
0.0748625994,
0.1118563637,
-0.4380008876,
-0.224826932,
0.2919208705,
-0.4369801581,
-0.7591793537,
0.5757481456,
0.5544423461,
-0.1449524164,
-0.2613081634,
-0.322145313,
-0.027011795,
-0.0708309263,
0.6362410188,
0.121214591,
-0.6497636437,
-0.1439440846,
0.2492399514,
-0.392480582,
0.2919519246,
0.5855146646,
-0.5757006407,
0.4243954122,
0.5122896433,
1.2105463743,
0.0998674557,
-0.3046434522,
0.4818675518,
-0.3600535989,
0.1979323626,
0.3691440821,
0.3700475395,
0.5481088758,
-0.4222522974,
0.6361999512,
0.120604001,
-0.5410822034,
-0.6384368539,
-0.0117672728,
-0.6966354251,
0.2780324817,
0.9011639953,
-0.0471973717,
-0.4516333044,
-0.149385944,
-0.1486650854,
0.4169880748,
-0.0676022395,
0.7246944904,
0.5873244405,
-0.0397796966,
-0.0325912274,
-0.8565517068,
0.1901924908,
0.7379616499,
-0.813544929,
-0.1512550265,
-0.0172436517,
0.0994844511,
0.3113497198,
0.3094266355,
-0.3277655542,
0.1700430065,
-0.2421660274,
0.0299370065,
-0.1107658371,
0.0850230306,
-0.5347973704,
-0.1313244402,
-0.0966258198,
-0.3890259564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01570v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01570v2
|
SERVAL: Synergy Learning between Vertical Models and LLMs towards Oracle-Level Zero-shot Medical Prediction
| 2024-03-03T17:35:52 | 2024-03-16T04:07:01 |
Jiahuan Yan, Jintai Chen, Chaowen Hu, Bo Zheng, Yaojun Hu, Jimeng Sun, Jian Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent development of large language models (LLMs) has exhibited impressive
zero-shot proficiency on generic and common sense questions. However, LLMs'
application on domain-specific vertical questions still lags behind, primarily
due to the humiliation problems and deficiencies in vertical knowledge.
Furthermore, the vertical data annotation process often requires
labor-intensive expert involvement, thereby presenting an additional challenge
in enhancing the model's vertical capabilities. In this paper, we propose
SERVAL, a synergy learning pipeline designed for unsupervised development of
vertical capabilities in both LLMs and small models by mutual enhancement.
Specifically, SERVAL utilizes the LLM's zero-shot outputs as annotations,
leveraging its confidence to teach a robust vertical model from scratch.
Reversely, the trained vertical model guides the LLM fine-tuning to enhance its
zero-shot capability, progressively improving both models through an iterative
process. In medical domain, known for complex vertical knowledge and costly
annotations, comprehensive experiments show that, without access to any gold
labels, SERVAL with the synergy learning of OpenAI GPT-3.5 and a simple model
attains fully-supervised competitive performance across ten widely used medical
datasets. These datasets represent vertically specialized medical diagnostic
scenarios (e.g., diabetes, heart diseases, COVID-19), highlighting the
potential of SERVAL in refining the vertical capabilities of LLMs and training
vertical models from scratch, all achieved without the need for annotations.
|
[
-0.0645740703,
-0.3230909109,
0.4556436241,
-0.5219309926,
-0.3812710941,
0.0650350302,
-0.0373720229,
-0.6658557057,
0.3071852326,
0.7875453234,
-0.747122705,
-0.8208936453,
-0.5938131809,
-0.0823537558,
0.1323171556,
1.4240156412,
0.1536869109,
0.2887901068,
-0.4468931258,
-0.459564954,
-0.5915967822,
-0.5413661003,
-0.4068829119,
-0.425670743,
0.5632158518,
0.6155827641,
0.3549669385,
0.3331919312,
0.4277301133,
0.193579182,
0.1025209799,
0.1135812253,
-0.4955747128,
0.5457585454,
-0.1190587282,
-0.5971425176,
-0.4304259717,
-0.1336226314,
0.5358110666,
0.9040434957,
0.033104796,
0.3434634805,
-0.1922560036,
0.5434299707,
-0.5099363327,
0.302455008,
-0.6785656214,
0.3151476085,
-0.1832089573,
-0.1308095753,
0.008103813,
0.1037540585,
0.4122890532,
-0.6119897366,
-0.042514082,
-0.0064464654,
0.5673553348,
0.5832081437,
-0.4602094293,
0.3155336976,
-0.4874822497,
0.7384837866,
-0.4483104348,
0.1329748034,
0.0142188752,
0.7708260417,
-0.0431903414,
-0.8168330193,
-0.2814656198,
-0.1125736088,
0.0992518812,
0.3755521476,
0.1043493003,
0.2803956866,
0.1400005668,
0.4301671386,
-0.4240499735,
0.4542913139,
-0.5216770768,
-0.2556318939,
0.4734439254,
0.4473879635,
0.1967330873,
-0.1404474378,
-0.518655479,
0.0933421552,
-0.6351040006,
0.2149461508,
-0.3384550512,
0.4652938843,
-0.0683395118,
0.597297132,
-0.170909673,
0.7306624055,
-0.0714394227,
-0.4729415774,
0.3901790679,
-0.2765070498,
-0.6570064425,
0.1716591418,
0.4871501625,
0.0990706906,
-0.2246348709,
-0.1675143987,
-0.0517305098,
0.3060525954,
0.1519822329,
-0.6513181925,
0.0382251032,
0.1273274422,
-0.2957437336,
-0.5165945292,
-0.3096140623,
-0.5301868916,
-0.811616838,
-0.2659204602,
0.6729979515,
-0.1118984669,
0.066066578,
0.2463012189,
0.031510938,
0.0797737092,
0.3461272418,
-0.647038281,
0.3630577624,
0.639765799,
0.4682348669,
-0.0590959825,
-0.1923793703,
-1.0947635174,
0.1633076519,
-0.1314580441,
0.628960371,
-0.5136008263,
-0.1087370217,
-0.2086062282,
0.0773083493,
0.1938803941,
-0.3807906508,
0.4984058738,
-0.232708931,
0.4011223018,
-0.0690107271,
-0.4995396435,
-0.3180746734,
0.1894934922,
-0.4158207774,
0.5879572034,
0.2341042757,
-0.9262977242,
0.7347183824,
-0.344532609,
-0.3656703234,
0.4440689087,
-0.7366738915,
-0.6501714587,
-0.0175494198,
0.3194331825,
0.5112938285,
-0.6408549547,
0.1586446166,
-0.4634066522,
-0.1571965814,
-0.312954098,
-0.0382716246,
0.7096078396,
-0.2964946926,
-0.261636287,
0.256547004,
-0.9586191177,
-0.2414159328,
-0.015468902,
0.351059705,
-0.4518737793,
-0.4734191,
-0.5780704021,
0.3564788997,
0.199124217,
-0.4283071756,
0.3409563601,
-0.7814138532,
-0.1588346064,
0.5180262923,
0.3583899438,
0.4932258427,
-0.4622865617,
0.7821135521,
0.1171948314,
0.3150734603,
-0.138079077,
-0.5823196769,
-0.4623218775,
-0.4402102828,
0.2713131011,
0.4805018008,
-1.0164102316,
0.1539349705,
0.1404339671,
-0.5534834266,
-0.8116996288,
0.2013033479,
0.4222713709,
1.1892669201,
0.4331238866,
-0.5981839299,
-0.7243187428,
-0.807074368,
-0.0766954795,
-0.141163677,
0.1050468907,
0.4821952581,
0.3581797183,
-0.2719396055,
0.3940635026,
-0.2621870339,
-0.7031267285,
-0.2180060595,
0.3642703295,
0.4145823121,
0.1676271409,
0.4619898796,
-0.4805430174,
-0.2800773978,
0.120215252,
-1.00259161,
-0.2189675719,
0.1143211126,
-0.0588645004,
0.1910243183,
0.1744302362,
-0.0352404267,
0.6689012051,
0.7076500058,
-0.1949800402,
0.6054469943,
-0.4338257909,
-0.1223427281,
-1.267275691,
0.0128918588,
0.1291591078,
-0.0915457606,
-0.5772463083,
-0.1918544024,
-0.3150244653,
-0.190180704,
-0.4612108767,
0.5522371531,
-0.3882862329,
-0.3897117376,
-0.1715639085,
-0.0924830139,
-0.0786786154,
0.287286222,
0.1346553862,
0.5760871768,
0.9623559117,
-0.3394742608,
0.4342708588,
0.1301306784,
-0.0869884342,
0.507204175,
-0.6217827797,
-0.3470740914,
-0.0703368932,
0.1905697286,
-0.7428973317,
-0.2566895783,
0.1779360026,
-0.4811160564,
0.1578598768,
-0.2782886624,
-0.3565325141,
-0.3673258126,
-0.1216505542,
0.2547408938,
0.7286297679,
-0.4882586002,
0.4785380065,
0.6916118264,
0.0153389508,
-0.8555203676,
-0.6929357648,
-0.1788425595,
-0.0369911827,
-0.676173389,
0.2283792645,
0.3533553183,
0.0121208197,
0.0444312692,
-0.2773368955,
-0.05069061,
0.0368831232,
0.6634454727,
0.6777408719,
-0.1566280425,
0.4707124531,
-0.0027628264,
-0.4023763835,
-0.1924493015,
-0.7580875158,
-0.0424052663,
-0.2448353171,
-0.4131926596,
-0.4028715193,
-0.0865426511,
0.7127304673,
-0.2656577229,
0.8687304854,
0.6074644923,
-0.4754371345,
-0.1834691316,
-0.4264277518,
-0.3943588734,
-0.3339168727,
0.0753746927,
-0.1821575761,
-1.1218485832,
0.5994468927,
-0.1572860628,
-0.1457294375,
0.5684617758,
0.6606933475,
0.0177616328,
0.8767835498,
0.8573153615,
-0.0767836347,
0.0580804981,
-0.3418034315,
-0.0148245506,
-0.6593621373,
-0.4910836518,
-0.1578784436,
-0.2343836427,
-0.7117902637,
-0.4524739683,
1.1116496325,
-0.1831556857,
-0.2739534676,
0.0264395345,
-0.5185852647,
0.1582657993,
0.4504508376,
0.1336397976,
0.3813158274,
0.106605567,
-0.6409591436,
-0.2593305111,
-0.8441374898,
0.1351153404,
1.1696246862,
0.2595520616,
0.716960609,
-0.3382579088,
0.9430293441,
-0.0467226319,
0.0711464062,
-0.6647894382,
0.3494464159,
-0.3755486012,
-0.3687805533,
-0.2569049299,
-0.3690670729,
-0.961130619,
0.0707589686,
-0.6507618427,
-0.6099361777,
0.0862347633,
-0.0377101563,
-0.7725396752,
0.3737499714,
-0.3648202717,
0.9929722548,
-0.3613122106,
-0.8126036525,
-0.0402942523,
-0.9785067439,
0.4006462693,
-0.0182719361,
-0.0463151634,
-0.0179463904,
-0.2374781221,
0.3487334847,
-0.6839351654,
1.1091039181,
-0.2492555976,
0.0663794354,
0.18552652,
-0.0470167324,
0.1444782764,
0.3293334842,
0.1200944856,
0.0738599151,
-0.0579993837,
-0.5154242516,
-0.6026755571,
0.5167738199,
-0.8289175034,
-0.4321104884,
-0.6761432886,
-0.5221167207,
-0.5034471154,
0.1711160392,
0.0378101766,
0.4171674252,
0.1736583561,
0.1533786952,
0.4783971608,
-0.3282538354,
-0.1094186977,
0.5185300708,
-0.1675184965,
-0.5046262145,
0.7435445786,
0.1168498397,
0.0671693534,
0.2390214652,
0.1489286423,
-0.2250270694,
-0.2658285201,
-0.2825854719,
0.2716660798,
-0.4312925041,
-0.4649565816,
-0.4058904946,
-0.5154242516,
-0.2409124374,
-0.1697155237,
-0.3086054623,
-0.4013821781,
-0.1541228145,
0.0432825796,
0.445964843,
0.5259435773,
-0.1606740355,
-0.0674446821,
-0.7731044888,
0.2806013227,
0.4962866902,
0.3736606538,
-0.1898875684,
-0.5885311961,
-0.1874559224,
-0.1196238771,
0.0258529466,
-0.5685426593,
0.4669659734,
-0.1020643637,
0.5519708991,
0.3025584817,
-0.0025612731,
0.7324578762,
-0.1136165857,
0.7238354683,
0.4806886017,
-0.5804131031,
0.6874084473,
-0.2555505335,
0.1229017749,
0.6409202814,
0.4235871434,
-0.4243090153,
-0.1176136956,
-0.7453644872,
-0.5894061327,
0.5771716833,
-0.1717373878,
-0.6483421326,
0.4320255518,
0.3334928453,
0.6202965379,
0.2996651232,
-0.463946104,
-0.0288788974,
0.1775316,
-0.0463726595,
-0.0573371872,
0.1971823424,
-0.2069504708,
-0.639621377,
0.6456962824,
-0.2606789172,
-0.0746561438,
0.0952801257,
0.0714697093,
-0.2913218141,
0.0499341115,
0.1867370754,
0.3077281415,
-0.1822203845,
-0.0684287474,
0.4120649993,
-0.1049976945,
0.0983048081,
0.2151619643,
-0.0096392166,
-0.1661058068,
0.3423269987,
0.9539234638,
0.3264207244,
-0.7103271484,
0.6966203451,
-0.1097279266,
-0.3094008565,
-0.2783268988,
0.0032856371,
-0.2095231563,
0.5515608191,
0.0615421422,
0.1844844967,
0.078989841,
-0.5134114623,
0.4054378569,
0.3664212227,
-0.6637963653,
-0.261054635,
0.7376176119,
0.2157151252,
0.4049016833,
0.3327825367,
-0.1772042215,
-0.3078972101,
0.6322385669,
0.310559839,
0.6663038731,
0.0699787661,
0.2181961089,
0.3036260903,
-0.0297026001,
0.0954632685,
0.2104642391,
-0.1151139215,
-0.3937816322,
-0.7495569587,
-0.5116296411,
-0.5327769518,
0.2594900429,
-0.575466156,
0.6322904825,
-0.4049949944,
0.0207083728,
0.1061534509,
0.5109875202,
-0.7205125093,
0.2836019397,
0.4435704052,
0.6760391593,
-1.0010097027,
0.9780513644,
0.9240527749,
-0.8976682425,
-0.6660224795,
-0.0685037822,
0.1574185044,
-1.0777286291,
0.8042402864,
0.0847607926,
0.0466235094,
-0.3250358701,
-0.4646516144,
-0.5080091357,
1.415553093,
0.3349999487,
-0.5608206391,
-0.1439369768,
0.0023285034,
0.9652203321,
-0.5908905864,
0.2496981472,
0.2823663354,
-0.007971609,
0.4526737034,
-1.0504714251,
0.0078203371,
0.0007737886,
-0.0493072644,
0.028666392,
-0.6792390347,
0.7355985045,
-0.525036931,
0.0633717477,
0.0798743293,
0.5175880194,
0.3537555933,
0.6037932634,
0.3053481579,
0.8145820498,
0.7984996438,
0.1963387281,
0.8760664463,
-0.4741552174,
0.0884638205,
1.052195549,
-0.6341376305,
0.5760214925,
0.3089333773,
0.2478156388,
0.629353404,
0.4098049402,
-0.0506157428,
0.5306738615,
0.0275384262,
-0.4937698245,
-0.4085820913,
-0.4412843585,
-0.5345631242,
0.5674459934,
0.5509610176,
-0.3151480854,
-0.4159474671,
0.2523520589,
-0.3740231693,
-0.0106755253,
-0.4913076758,
0.9825914502,
0.1848440021,
-0.5802090764,
0.7139896154,
-0.3830009699,
0.4517951608,
-0.4341801405,
-0.1049077436,
-0.1780716181,
0.2012217939,
-0.2253186107,
-0.5444701314,
0.058679726,
-0.2019730955,
-0.0405710749,
0.2063394934,
1.2533957958,
-0.533229053,
-0.3013220727,
0.5223414302,
0.7876503468,
-0.0359427296,
0.378719449,
-0.6135534048,
-0.1429899335,
-0.2432740927,
0.45797804,
0.4415652752,
0.6663473248,
-0.0255813021,
0.5540444255,
0.4551261067,
0.5660932064,
-0.2923416495,
0.1838725209,
0.9913823009,
-0.4232945442,
-0.3924691975,
-0.5073425174,
0.4339228868,
-0.0985651314,
-0.0182668455,
0.4026564658,
0.2470231652,
0.834869206,
0.1286482662,
1.0262589455,
0.3820363283,
0.681008935,
-0.1580867767,
0.4928249419,
-0.8830477595,
0.3612279594,
0.0253470447,
-0.3569863141,
-0.6021305919,
0.2521085441,
-0.6379363537,
-0.1473272145,
0.5811906457,
0.5094226599,
-0.0410987735,
-0.0551592782,
0.6409537792,
0.2680753171,
-0.0810298771,
0.9651552439,
0.5106050372,
-0.4177918434,
0.413726896,
-0.3762042522,
-0.4810407162,
-0.3674713075,
-0.7313043475,
-1.1532926559,
-0.426352948,
-0.1713234186,
-0.3699878454,
0.4422899783,
1.0133639574,
0.8387849927,
-0.6264373064,
-0.0303557776,
-0.2267137021,
-0.1022799388,
-0.1335237026,
-0.0650445893,
0.1998527497,
-0.5898329616,
-0.200115487,
0.2017795444,
0.7528281212,
-0.0217395313,
-0.3206444383,
-0.0691733509,
0.0391417071,
-0.3171288073,
0.4496869743,
0.6204800606,
-0.4969444573,
-0.0462444983,
-0.1544845402,
-0.0699652806,
0.006997651,
0.522206068,
-1.3896510601,
0.8369214535,
0.4702166021,
1.0719416142,
0.4882361293,
-0.1564198434,
0.4651286602,
-0.8072398901,
0.4226555228,
0.4510000646,
0.1891341507,
0.1724746674,
-0.2982747853,
0.4798576534,
0.5696777105,
-0.6185606122,
-0.7161620259,
0.041164726,
-0.7308758497,
-0.0963038132,
0.7972994447,
0.0437962972,
-0.4406462312,
0.1285589039,
-0.168526575,
0.5428424478,
-0.1922924668,
0.8216794133,
0.1670162827,
-0.3323066831,
-0.1104776412,
-0.666844368,
0.5967851877,
0.8771021962,
-0.7830610871,
-0.3666646779,
0.3544066846,
0.0345257446,
-0.1045425907,
0.4010154009,
-0.2722064257,
0.5115239024,
-0.0476657897,
0.1245716438,
-0.1901246011,
-0.5670236349,
-0.5259035826,
0.0923664868,
0.0327352993,
-0.2980991304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01548v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01548v3
|
In-Context Sharpness as Alerts: An Inner Representation Perspective for Hallucination Mitigation
| 2024-03-03T15:53:41 | 2024-03-12T09:49:28 |
Shiqi Chen, Miao Xiong, Junteng Liu, Zhengxuan Wu, Teng Xiao, Siyang Gao, Junxian He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate and produce factual
errors, yet our understanding of why they make these errors remains limited. In
this study, we delve into the underlying mechanisms of LLM hallucinations from
the perspective of inner representations, and discover a salient pattern
associated with hallucinations: correct generations tend to have sharper
context activations in the hidden states of the in-context tokens, compared to
the incorrect ones. Leveraging this insight, we propose an entropy-based metric
to quantify the ``sharpness'' among the in-context hidden states and
incorporate it into the decoding process to formulate a constrained decoding
approach. Experiments on various knowledge-seeking and hallucination benchmarks
demonstrate our approach's consistent effectiveness, for example, achieving up
to an 8.6 point improvement on TruthfulQA. We believe this study can improve
our understanding of hallucinations and serve as a practical solution for
hallucination mitigation.
|
[
-0.1424067914,
-0.565220356,
0.7870281935,
0.0773378685,
-0.4191363752,
-0.2070718557,
-0.3654164374,
-0.5020051003,
0.3235383034,
0.3409555256,
-0.552315712,
-0.4758217037,
-0.509013474,
0.2319239229,
-0.2638191581,
0.4871406853,
0.1418463141,
0.2247578353,
-0.2940186858,
0.0511470847,
-0.7954633832,
-0.7380666137,
-0.3433589935,
-0.2756930292,
0.2024274915,
0.4090078771,
0.5488461256,
0.31626755,
0.6944683194,
0.1398640424,
-0.048247695,
0.2485395819,
-0.7241020203,
0.4422799647,
0.0613116696,
-0.4252454937,
-0.0132107427,
-0.2556248307,
0.6024276018,
0.7864300609,
0.1045931429,
-0.1843930036,
0.3036550581,
0.6863015294,
-0.7647479773,
0.0695170984,
-0.9831075668,
0.3628207147,
0.0693676323,
-0.6642233729,
-0.4498053193,
-0.2581195831,
0.0581015386,
-0.2569478452,
0.219067052,
0.0650059208,
0.621075213,
0.7794719338,
-0.1392441541,
-0.4957583249,
-0.5509158969,
0.6499493718,
-0.6216849685,
0.6227416992,
0.5680676699,
-0.0206431448,
-0.1528908312,
-0.4323534369,
-0.2512988746,
-0.2519241273,
-0.1548275203,
-0.1917269528,
-0.1000431702,
0.1800728142,
0.3474116921,
0.4010852277,
-0.3309299052,
-0.0664173812,
-0.2994724214,
-0.4869913757,
0.4441308379,
0.266461879,
0.1334794164,
-0.1352035999,
-0.2846628129,
-0.0626936704,
-0.6155400276,
-0.2556119561,
0.1294526756,
0.3241715729,
0.1751962453,
0.4315775335,
-0.1025154665,
0.2259847671,
0.1031045169,
-0.1539320201,
0.1339881271,
-0.2250415981,
-0.2805385292,
0.4947423339,
0.2302294075,
0.5841307044,
0.1048276275,
-0.5365060568,
-0.5320721865,
0.0216263719,
0.4869491756,
-0.8067176938,
-0.2297624499,
0.1961178482,
-0.5304029584,
-0.1581074893,
0.2126390934,
-0.6925638914,
-0.843845427,
-0.3131547868,
0.5851095319,
-0.6104531884,
-0.1208943948,
0.2454753816,
-0.2196626663,
0.458386749,
0.0542756803,
-0.8778367043,
0.2008021623,
0.5605039001,
0.8925615549,
-0.0741273016,
-0.1300020665,
-0.2284435481,
0.0517190695,
-0.5547007918,
0.6849414706,
-0.4580536485,
-0.3038052022,
0.133816734,
-0.1964983642,
-0.0123941852,
-0.7803028822,
0.6005648375,
-0.2973605692,
-0.2483707219,
-0.5438026786,
-0.56913656,
-0.4590300918,
-0.0021802729,
-0.5066799521,
0.9338238835,
0.0196614359,
-0.5546088815,
0.6679927111,
-0.419752866,
-0.2616527975,
0.2957407534,
-0.2475498021,
-0.2154718488,
0.7789540291,
0.2411355823,
0.5144092441,
-0.0480832197,
0.2901688218,
-0.1334883869,
-0.7959479094,
0.4333182275,
-0.5789777637,
0.4635218978,
0.1763286889,
-0.5906979442,
0.1992104053,
-0.6222679019,
-0.1161710173,
0.0353645608,
-0.1348371655,
-0.4763400853,
0.0020909181,
-0.2188233286,
-0.0819690228,
0.0547437742,
-0.11785274,
0.0901659727,
-0.5252257586,
0.2629095614,
0.7969104648,
0.250864923,
0.3792759478,
-0.3112253249,
-0.0249366332,
0.2649378479,
0.3211715519,
0.0698200539,
-0.249818489,
-0.883028388,
-0.136426717,
-0.2623297572,
0.380325824,
-0.423666209,
0.5972595215,
-0.2942967415,
0.0514058135,
-0.5944525003,
-0.0905900151,
0.3167908192,
0.3803625107,
0.3048327863,
-0.3051419854,
-0.7032099962,
-0.788639009,
-0.2299562395,
0.0384509042,
0.0677117631,
-0.0249051172,
0.5764540434,
-0.621119082,
0.6497690082,
-0.1705922335,
-0.3445444107,
-0.0319721401,
-0.141842097,
-0.0328105874,
0.4408435822,
0.1384166181,
-0.7292663455,
0.0390057266,
-0.1716377437,
-1.0030323267,
0.0078030294,
-0.3105514348,
-0.0040437491,
0.3564223349,
0.9316811562,
-0.2832255363,
0.6186532974,
0.0497843288,
-0.5121639967,
0.5403906703,
-0.0690846965,
0.0772013813,
-0.7246629596,
-0.0637338832,
-0.276561439,
0.1601698548,
-0.6717570424,
0.1771721542,
0.0744669586,
0.1302413344,
-0.2499474585,
0.3789164126,
-0.4671151936,
0.0155350696,
-0.1599768698,
0.1289599836,
-0.0840359554,
0.5650515556,
-0.2893599868,
0.9084653854,
0.5197620988,
-0.6127721667,
0.0830317736,
-0.1161432713,
-0.5667632222,
0.5403055549,
-0.2091282457,
0.2259940654,
-0.4539463222,
-0.1344426125,
-0.7359804511,
-0.487621814,
0.2948773205,
-0.3116497397,
0.2817838192,
0.1619399339,
-0.5754308701,
-0.0718010888,
-0.4466586709,
0.5614827275,
0.487459451,
-0.657466352,
0.4064617157,
0.2481637746,
0.4219416976,
-0.5353218913,
-0.7592656016,
0.344434917,
-0.4617216289,
-0.5406045914,
0.4611261189,
-0.3509308994,
-0.7405094504,
-0.1964367181,
-0.3278936744,
0.1805540025,
0.1975475699,
0.3961794972,
-0.1074455604,
-0.0188312382,
0.3581116498,
-0.1202542186,
0.1075894162,
0.4202196896,
-0.3871294558,
0.7557743192,
-0.1583967209,
-0.2729769051,
-0.6826877594,
0.4056944847,
0.6436278224,
0.2216981947,
0.7182235718,
0.2306640297,
-0.7164525986,
-0.345379889,
-0.6765827537,
-0.7264313102,
-0.4528093934,
0.2265959829,
-0.6413373947,
-0.6444455385,
0.8675643206,
0.0032270956,
-0.3392849267,
0.3227724135,
0.4460939467,
0.0582082942,
0.9719447494,
0.7773980498,
0.1654008478,
0.3886675239,
-0.2711329162,
0.4911459386,
-0.8842411041,
-0.7527223229,
-0.3166496456,
-0.0645430237,
-0.3244494796,
-0.2672181427,
0.439301908,
0.2419410944,
-0.1831049621,
-0.2278863043,
-0.7693653107,
0.7029842138,
0.5173121095,
0.3790795505,
0.0979692563,
0.2004590333,
-0.2218545228,
-0.1962980479,
-0.6604469419,
-0.4708954394,
0.7469052076,
0.3375273347,
0.6732724905,
0.0148537392,
0.7545935512,
0.2418686002,
-0.1900225431,
-1.0700696707,
0.5386908054,
0.256309092,
-0.3603013456,
-0.342790544,
-0.3502092957,
-0.6203812361,
0.2024389952,
-0.1305503547,
-0.875246942,
0.461273104,
-0.1412533373,
-0.4192064106,
0.3888549507,
-0.5227251649,
0.5607185364,
-0.0157965571,
-0.2647816539,
-0.0824890658,
-0.6539303064,
0.3629940152,
-0.0076209377,
0.1272164136,
-0.1448756307,
0.1500852108,
0.6868128181,
-0.1703785211,
1.0298727751,
-0.0575165749,
-0.376102984,
0.1130444631,
0.1508716792,
0.5351365209,
0.0629127398,
-0.1176244691,
0.2238489836,
-0.2664888501,
-0.2628753781,
-0.5456750989,
0.5723569989,
-0.6707744598,
-0.6818348765,
-0.3556445241,
-0.7598605752,
-0.1191080734,
-0.0003315508,
0.6072067022,
0.525464654,
-0.127134487,
0.157998994,
1.0661220551,
0.0225193966,
0.4543919265,
-0.1856796741,
-0.0012354659,
-0.3368989825,
0.7468772531,
0.1205707341,
0.0024792019,
0.3128705919,
0.0787522122,
-0.2795824409,
-0.799865365,
0.001754281,
0.2177253962,
-1.3922958374,
-0.2866923511,
-0.5477397442,
-0.3024496734,
-0.5463531613,
-0.3791947663,
0.0035033748,
-0.0117704589,
-0.5712216496,
-0.127358824,
0.2746740878,
0.748449862,
-0.1407103986,
0.143377915,
-0.2857446074,
0.156942293,
0.2965770066,
0.461271435,
0.1524733454,
-0.6459561586,
-0.3731908202,
-0.0544284806,
0.0849473327,
-0.8586120009,
0.413715899,
0.0276533812,
0.5276811719,
0.7001390457,
0.337228775,
0.8347799182,
-0.1476124972,
0.823481977,
0.0710792765,
-1.1306676865,
0.4830413461,
0.1485603303,
0.3490913808,
0.7585504651,
0.1062163264,
-0.5279100537,
-0.6002642512,
-0.2909933627,
-0.7717193961,
0.3602715433,
0.0454657488,
0.2134483904,
-0.0462214351,
0.5035946965,
0.2826242149,
-0.0251239408,
-0.8874863386,
0.0032276246,
-0.2594345808,
-0.1223600283,
0.1127348319,
-0.7253585458,
-0.3632181287,
-0.4118850827,
0.4683327079,
-0.1640409082,
0.4806776345,
0.4779612422,
-0.3966192603,
-0.2409311682,
0.015500674,
0.8746651411,
0.6683811545,
-0.450701654,
0.6990988851,
0.3156541884,
-0.6621796489,
-0.0927202553,
-0.3698920608,
-0.0861903578,
0.0087607428,
0.5111661553,
0.9023169279,
0.2047119588,
-0.5638250113,
0.344563514,
-0.0034928301,
-0.0423087962,
-0.3648249805,
0.0673386306,
-0.5901038051,
0.4348171651,
0.7539191246,
0.0648160428,
0.3607222438,
-0.7134848237,
0.1396247596,
0.6133204699,
-0.6242102385,
-0.2037860006,
0.541719377,
-0.0982416421,
-0.2043560445,
0.8268475533,
-0.3471818566,
-0.690685451,
0.3838189542,
0.6511055827,
1.3162784576,
-0.0014997351,
-0.2040826827,
0.3205832541,
0.585988462,
-0.028918175,
0.362567246,
-0.0557281114,
-0.7288506627,
-0.1431469023,
-0.6735563278,
0.0220738389,
0.1643847972,
-0.5553538203,
0.1426000595,
-0.2958572507,
-0.0598871112,
-0.3702447712,
-0.089228794,
-0.4858068824,
0.0591124706,
0.3484101295,
0.6423001885,
-0.5304251909,
0.7057035565,
0.0891028419,
-0.3200802207,
-0.6026737094,
0.6750571132,
-0.0533456914,
-0.7916336656,
0.4905876517,
0.5478426218,
-0.4595460892,
-0.1331217438,
-0.7168633342,
-0.8460012078,
0.9024167657,
0.276696831,
-0.4146872163,
-0.0054555493,
0.0743576363,
0.2745324373,
-0.3682611287,
-0.2562812865,
0.7541376948,
0.4961537719,
0.0898318365,
-0.5524207354,
0.4829320908,
-0.1266922951,
0.0614472255,
0.1605406106,
-0.2690210044,
0.5969206691,
-0.4473031461,
-0.6763616204,
-0.1869048327,
0.502827704,
0.0755092427,
0.425411284,
0.2271178812,
0.4111475348,
1.0268326998,
-0.0731750056,
0.9316836596,
-0.478410393,
0.0380959511,
0.6831126809,
-0.0484782122,
0.429297477,
0.8863238692,
0.3695372939,
0.2880101204,
0.6032061577,
0.0452381,
0.9488443732,
0.2838239074,
-0.3777215183,
-0.1156805232,
-0.2656552494,
-0.3709556162,
0.2189017683,
0.6581167579,
-0.2952075005,
0.2460260689,
0.3401788175,
0.1289092451,
-0.0377353951,
-0.4625129104,
0.9973536134,
0.2199009955,
-0.6076032519,
1.0678018332,
-0.2152905464,
0.8062128425,
-0.1888062954,
-0.0543550923,
-0.5271180272,
0.0512854531,
-0.2340034395,
-0.5418743491,
0.4790453613,
-0.3433082998,
-0.2840200663,
-0.122461915,
0.6712141037,
-0.197313711,
-0.2999488413,
0.387160331,
0.1591539383,
0.4555823505,
-0.3418919146,
-0.1587040722,
0.5368310213,
0.007876127,
0.1335849464,
-0.0013453859,
0.728033185,
-0.1007467657,
0.4785835147,
0.2539102733,
-0.1082189828,
0.2352451235,
0.2469183654,
0.8414903879,
-0.7664970756,
-0.2534886301,
-1.0541969538,
0.2484554052,
0.0372429229,
-0.3015120327,
0.7288569212,
0.3762283623,
0.9063566923,
-0.1207427382,
0.5025590658,
0.2566690743,
-0.16063945,
-0.7778376341,
0.821223557,
-0.6817010045,
0.4073304236,
-0.1122502908,
-1.000105381,
-0.7852464914,
0.7252596617,
-0.1070208028,
-0.2313586324,
0.8650221229,
1.0782334805,
0.1986968666,
-0.0106689688,
0.6637097001,
0.2368295938,
-0.0701138899,
0.5315879583,
1.0375572443,
-0.2315438539,
0.2881384492,
-0.3544559479,
-0.032474231,
-0.7073868513,
-0.5898756385,
-0.9905924201,
-1.0113446712,
-0.1319329143,
-0.3519456089,
0.1982598752,
0.9621640444,
0.6190518141,
-0.671723187,
-0.0981396064,
-0.2430272996,
0.1213379502,
-0.35446316,
-0.2093624026,
0.4676478207,
-0.758146286,
-0.350917995,
0.5170826316,
0.4264139831,
0.333291322,
-0.3704487979,
-0.1141918302,
0.3397000432,
0.386798352,
0.8042173386,
-0.2109893709,
-1.0369366407,
-0.4768013358,
0.0600175075,
-0.2451861203,
0.3011610806,
0.9326544404,
-0.6868546605,
0.4754297435,
0.3299975395,
0.2694175839,
0.0891930461,
-0.4499077797,
0.2401808351,
-0.7657913566,
0.3132014871,
0.4946861267,
0.2715037763,
0.4751461446,
-0.7601054907,
0.3990264833,
0.1533626765,
-0.3960041404,
-1.1711591482,
0.1601049155,
-0.7365022898,
-0.662960887,
1.0948989391,
0.4371023178,
-0.219966203,
-0.230013445,
-0.209463492,
0.3158611655,
-0.2708282173,
1.2523249388,
0.6238406897,
-0.0095783537,
-0.1577443182,
-0.4929848313,
0.9296127558,
0.4048059285,
-0.5943174958,
0.2936866283,
0.5643863678,
-0.2498601526,
0.1952608526,
0.3254474103,
0.0412433743,
0.0164195374,
0.2507504821,
0.1382308006,
0.3070335388,
-0.7913063765,
-0.6889835,
0.3344436586,
0.0677862391,
0.0833077654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01528v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01528v2
|
Leveraging Biomolecule and Natural Language through Multi-Modal Learning: A Survey
| 2024-03-03T14:59:47 | 2024-03-05T11:12:47 |
Qizhi Pei, Lijun Wu, Kaiyuan Gao, Jinhua Zhu, Yue Wang, Zun Wang, Tao Qin, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.BM
|
The integration of biomolecular modeling with natural language (BL) has
emerged as a promising interdisciplinary area at the intersection of artificial
intelligence, chemistry and biology. This approach leverages the rich,
multifaceted descriptions of biomolecules contained within textual data sources
to enhance our fundamental understanding and enable downstream computational
tasks such as biomolecule property prediction. The fusion of the nuanced
narratives expressed through natural language with the structural and
functional specifics of biomolecules described via various molecular modeling
techniques opens new avenues for comprehensively representing and analyzing
biomolecules. By incorporating the contextual language data that surrounds
biomolecules into their modeling, BL aims to capture a holistic view
encompassing both the symbolic qualities conveyed through language as well as
quantitative structural characteristics. In this review, we provide an
extensive analysis of recent advancements achieved through cross modeling of
biomolecules and natural language. (1) We begin by outlining the technical
representations of biomolecules employed, including sequences, 2D graphs, and
3D structures. (2) We then examine in depth the rationale and key objectives
underlying effective multi-modal integration of language and molecular data
sources. (3) We subsequently survey the practical applications enabled to date
in this developing research area. (4) We also compile and summarize the
available resources and datasets to facilitate future work. (5) Looking ahead,
we identify several promising research directions worthy of further exploration
and investment to continue advancing the field. The related resources and
contents are updating in
\url{https://github.com/QizhiPei/Awesome-Biomolecule-Language-Cross-Modeling}.
|
[
-0.2009101063,
-1.0760966539,
0.3977703452,
-0.0879449695,
0.021008797,
0.506036222,
-0.2400161624,
-0.9192416668,
0.0916882381,
0.1361700892,
-0.2667973042,
-0.2377007604,
-0.4963125885,
0.2929645777,
-0.0715410337,
0.9390593171,
0.2047457397,
0.4617784321,
-0.3634670377,
-0.2640472651,
-0.2503993213,
-0.5087046027,
-0.1101334691,
-0.3010168672,
0.613237381,
-0.1123990789,
0.6258249283,
0.6418305635,
0.4716410637,
0.3944403231,
-0.2156692743,
0.0963635445,
-0.0483026356,
0.0302643981,
-0.3555115163,
-0.3776648939,
-0.5138021111,
0.1959000826,
0.7304024696,
1.3096694946,
0.233439222,
0.0215840004,
0.1045565903,
0.7275795341,
-0.5187417269,
0.2728336453,
-0.206091851,
0.0949034169,
-0.19865565,
-0.0810826942,
-0.2046101987,
-0.2031708509,
0.4666459262,
-0.3015789092,
0.1052734032,
0.0260928907,
0.6281324029,
-0.0164799746,
-0.9340758324,
-0.4810774028,
-0.7403801084,
0.9056561589,
-0.6631381512,
0.9498664141,
0.2313554734,
0.4852035344,
-0.2300019264,
-0.592053175,
-0.3671666086,
-0.868702054,
-0.0871498585,
0.2020703703,
-0.02260153,
0.3069936633,
-0.1099757105,
0.4763711095,
-0.7584543228,
-0.2775531411,
-0.6540178657,
-0.2088056356,
0.4743780494,
-0.0355857648,
0.5478039384,
-0.3524515033,
-0.5198107362,
-0.0999420807,
-0.236985147,
0.1211140305,
0.1565242708,
0.5248457789,
-0.2267897129,
0.7618291378,
-0.0808861926,
0.8394178152,
-0.339542985,
0.0090485485,
0.3027595878,
-1.0715128183,
-0.3733677268,
0.3275960684,
0.7516826987,
-0.0278117191,
-0.0150983408,
-0.0817537382,
0.0593775287,
-0.184763968,
0.2003917992,
-0.4585336149,
-0.0110176308,
0.4287160039,
-0.5771644115,
-0.1549028456,
0.1400849968,
-1.0882968903,
-0.2424734235,
-0.47331357,
0.2733348012,
-0.6373441815,
-0.0735527575,
0.0048209527,
-0.1937756687,
0.06058494,
0.1754371971,
-0.7975953221,
0.2740715444,
0.2731457055,
0.9198550582,
-0.1110046133,
-0.1177701727,
-0.3107040226,
0.5686805248,
-0.0231623948,
0.5114808083,
-0.6763266325,
-0.4182520211,
-0.2157006115,
-0.0082152551,
-0.0105962213,
-0.3751988411,
0.2349664867,
-0.2592781186,
0.1396912336,
-0.2303701788,
-0.3455921113,
-0.5580759048,
0.1636261046,
-0.9475117326,
0.5939432383,
0.0960979983,
-0.3752506971,
0.2392555326,
-0.7585365772,
-0.6116399169,
0.1453203708,
-0.2173081636,
-0.1761151552,
0.1235749796,
-0.1324581504,
0.3080350161,
-0.5377488136,
0.3981842101,
-0.4374518692,
0.2948803902,
0.6743971705,
-0.3316046298,
0.6041756272,
0.1774308383,
-0.016821919,
0.0931138322,
-0.755659461,
-0.122013323,
-0.3984544575,
-0.4977022111,
-0.1056851298,
-0.2522980273,
0.2563319504,
0.3014352024,
0.4356447458,
-0.529692471,
0.3583995402,
-0.3696312606,
0.5619207621,
0.5952630639,
0.0033992478,
0.6871803999,
-0.3000281751,
0.2611373365,
0.0185429063,
0.0781438723,
-0.0435064137,
-0.5350092649,
-0.0786022767,
-0.3238452971,
0.3417317867,
0.4517745078,
-0.5103922486,
0.107157886,
0.0834358335,
-0.4888812304,
-0.4507438242,
0.3487626016,
0.3188287616,
0.5624377131,
0.8441258669,
-0.3057283461,
-0.5738087296,
-0.8479932547,
-0.4022892714,
-0.3064666092,
0.0929020569,
0.3122705221,
0.5073809028,
-0.3014034331,
0.7984242439,
-0.2939812839,
-0.333711803,
-0.5819659829,
0.263038516,
0.2037267238,
0.4959801137,
0.4658394456,
-0.9420487285,
-0.4092254639,
0.6004895568,
-0.8402329683,
0.1728699803,
0.0022830262,
-0.0043832501,
0.1969719976,
0.1496405154,
-0.582031548,
0.2247300148,
0.3891994953,
-0.3927094042,
0.4792891443,
-0.2902408242,
0.258371979,
-0.9586158991,
0.3540960252,
0.388718307,
-0.0949372798,
-0.9001688361,
-0.2190948278,
0.0101460591,
-0.0285330601,
-0.5466150045,
0.6211662889,
-0.734210968,
-0.0597746521,
-0.0324144773,
-0.3671203554,
0.0079637552,
0.4211090803,
-0.0933447927,
0.462862879,
0.5709808469,
-0.4648807049,
0.4537777901,
0.1909359545,
0.0715923682,
0.4014586508,
-0.6613380313,
-0.3887777925,
-0.1540344805,
0.1910214275,
-0.8831857443,
-0.3051822782,
0.6827656627,
-0.4054229259,
0.4511936903,
-0.0062969443,
-0.2242451608,
-0.1775289476,
-0.3785148561,
0.4591811001,
0.1679662168,
0.0647965446,
0.8839259148,
0.4860944152,
-0.0985212252,
-0.0563746281,
-0.9284641743,
0.0591244623,
0.070509322,
-0.4135301411,
0.3022645712,
-0.3153881431,
-0.0226641092,
0.0331629068,
-0.3556134999,
-0.3858008981,
-0.2766512632,
0.0585139617,
0.4148407876,
-0.1882347614,
0.327090621,
0.0691188276,
0.0844822153,
0.0210624412,
-0.3111056089,
0.2027668655,
-0.3434893787,
-0.0928087682,
-0.3049269617,
0.4591727555,
0.5954273939,
-0.450961113,
0.6443644762,
0.4474845529,
-0.3363497257,
0.1723415554,
-0.0903751329,
-0.2387727946,
-0.455616504,
0.4060404599,
-0.1737866551,
-0.5008673072,
0.1284821481,
-0.0190379191,
-0.3976599574,
0.0068109776,
0.4942821562,
-0.1857270598,
0.7586807609,
0.8877593875,
0.0837291554,
0.4554874897,
-0.1950558722,
0.4348568022,
-0.6794677377,
-0.6345328093,
-0.4852501452,
-0.3478019536,
-0.5396918058,
-0.672742188,
0.5666391253,
0.0221315734,
0.1595700234,
0.249459818,
-0.2458495349,
0.1317426711,
0.2367709577,
0.1705030501,
0.2036715597,
-0.0692354068,
-0.4396117628,
0.164301455,
-0.7228628397,
-0.4691091478,
0.9339263439,
0.3090312481,
0.6854980588,
0.1357183754,
0.1765570343,
0.1983743161,
0.0784239769,
-0.6395181417,
0.4053970277,
0.1102924049,
-0.5255867839,
-0.2006639242,
-0.5530501604,
-0.9075653553,
0.1240754351,
-0.3857238293,
-0.4502796829,
0.4404617548,
0.2266509533,
-0.1031106785,
0.3294191658,
-0.5596147776,
0.9954274297,
-0.7646468878,
-0.5634099841,
-0.2699326575,
-1.039304018,
0.3567925096,
-0.0231339224,
0.4405283332,
0.027796153,
-0.204016462,
0.4438922107,
-0.1329187006,
0.8022478819,
0.2025274038,
-0.0700893104,
0.216969654,
0.0623034351,
-0.1687248349,
-0.067046389,
-0.0210038181,
0.4144006371,
0.2239401042,
-0.5343486071,
-0.419098556,
0.4421919882,
-0.4828452468,
-0.0534640066,
-0.6505929828,
-0.6296482682,
-0.2326005697,
0.3066188395,
-0.1548985541,
0.5865453482,
-0.0825572982,
0.1737957299,
0.442709446,
-0.3971185386,
0.5290616155,
0.3590846658,
-0.1590637863,
-0.4407774508,
1.153978467,
0.2746810615,
0.3662166893,
0.8328193426,
0.3017714024,
-0.3879334927,
-0.4064032733,
-0.1713770479,
0.3633395433,
-0.3798213303,
-0.21477516,
-0.6659507751,
-0.0761105716,
-0.5416562557,
-0.1921254694,
-0.3365397453,
-0.4164021611,
0.0269285999,
-0.1302538365,
0.3277134895,
0.6452691555,
-0.2695932984,
-0.3105653822,
-1.1780411005,
0.6290870905,
0.1025600508,
0.3147005439,
0.0711566284,
0.1898436546,
-0.6331964135,
0.4071090519,
-0.3082416058,
-1.2219352722,
0.5055497885,
0.4357845783,
0.9048988819,
0.0668010786,
-0.5163547993,
0.2586716712,
-0.2728378773,
0.7013060451,
0.05237877,
-0.7322307825,
0.7138789296,
-0.257945478,
0.5123097897,
0.3646423817,
0.825042665,
-0.5501869917,
-0.4482108653,
-0.265378505,
-0.924343586,
0.2368772328,
0.1247441471,
-0.29389745,
0.0700444132,
-0.0721710995,
0.387235105,
0.4439647794,
-0.6732085347,
-0.2016410232,
-0.3353784978,
-0.3870654106,
0.0558800511,
0.0465337746,
-0.0635014102,
-0.4150285721,
0.4890316129,
-0.3118183911,
0.2155928314,
0.0475998037,
-0.5117291808,
0.1251733005,
0.3112350106,
0.5740989447,
0.4336966872,
-0.3399756849,
0.2233207673,
-0.148870185,
-0.5433580875,
0.0188702419,
0.2681628764,
0.1466397196,
-0.1304915696,
0.5733616352,
0.4485052526,
0.3187718093,
-0.9061655402,
0.0173201282,
0.2322761863,
0.073984161,
0.3815900981,
-0.1787529141,
0.0250842199,
0.3853316009,
0.3419977129,
0.2445523739,
0.3498342931,
-0.8984640837,
0.1634994894,
0.5540386438,
-0.533146441,
-0.7247896791,
0.7024785876,
0.310967505,
0.155471459,
0.3119032085,
0.1933070868,
-0.3512869477,
0.3580290377,
0.4751963913,
0.7900605202,
-0.3699238002,
0.2160116732,
0.3444984853,
0.1472442448,
0.4137518108,
0.2155926079,
-0.3981666267,
-0.5592380166,
-0.0099926349,
-0.8563051224,
-0.1893389225,
-0.2602218091,
-0.1928249151,
0.1187833771,
-0.5293664336,
0.0323783346,
0.251265049,
0.0184915811,
-0.4285050929,
-0.0620678067,
0.3186804354,
0.801351428,
-0.9118902087,
0.8676735163,
1.0098139048,
-1.0255409479,
-0.2411719412,
-0.3007362485,
0.3673415482,
-0.2023076713,
0.9818332195,
0.0945573971,
0.0069873752,
-0.2946650088,
-0.4029882848,
-0.940333724,
0.9826987982,
-0.0057176789,
-0.2859119773,
-0.1401859969,
0.5966587067,
0.7419964671,
-0.2979325354,
0.2379366457,
0.4867273867,
0.7146303058,
0.032276433,
-0.9381724596,
0.0388488472,
-0.4482512772,
-0.0273675304,
0.1623023152,
-0.5593053102,
0.7414626479,
-0.0213992074,
-0.1829550862,
-0.0006308237,
0.7238588333,
0.221852839,
0.2390623093,
-0.1219401211,
0.1263227463,
0.6635715961,
0.0664311349,
1.1175088882,
-0.3744511306,
0.1086331159,
0.6003492475,
-0.2283162028,
0.5476992726,
0.7435565591,
-0.2441265285,
0.327022016,
0.3744113445,
-0.2538574636,
0.4216173887,
0.0930663198,
-0.3543807566,
-0.078154549,
-0.4384823442,
-0.3874177933,
0.3297792077,
0.4380391538,
-0.2480906993,
-0.3917259872,
0.3780117035,
-0.455614537,
0.0832149088,
-0.2286182344,
0.4666065872,
0.2201277316,
-0.0774038881,
0.1909336746,
-0.0591689423,
0.4627017975,
-0.8611078858,
-0.4493715763,
-0.0062717181,
-0.1334867179,
0.0367795788,
-0.7170392275,
0.2709917426,
-0.4193026423,
-0.2663275301,
-0.4151260555,
0.77386415,
-0.8372039199,
-0.5455837846,
0.4224110544,
0.5604382157,
-0.1190200225,
0.3816403449,
-0.6759469509,
0.0853316784,
-0.2555925548,
-0.0349647515,
0.1848718524,
0.3501093388,
0.0375745706,
0.8643642068,
0.7537282705,
0.102108717,
0.0767819136,
-0.3006449938,
0.8810878396,
-1.1115467548,
-0.2753662765,
-0.6141787171,
0.781554997,
0.1754619032,
-0.2361194789,
0.7079844475,
0.801581502,
0.9782805443,
-0.31930843,
0.9433392882,
-0.1448724568,
0.2948336601,
-0.5784721375,
0.5896790624,
-0.5929415226,
-0.0069295778,
-0.2707590461,
-0.6976190805,
-0.3904074132,
0.4259085059,
-0.0053353757,
0.2955679297,
0.9441511035,
0.8373315334,
-0.1463954896,
0.0577752329,
0.0233473592,
0.4095736444,
0.4290648997,
0.5891067982,
0.7412503362,
-0.3255715072,
0.1648186296,
-0.2725429833,
-0.0011123993,
-0.3543776572,
-0.8124701381,
-0.7929095626,
-0.5820664167,
-0.2624527216,
-0.1455379277,
0.0819284394,
1.0503417253,
0.4535526633,
-0.817640841,
-0.7492921352,
-0.1349869519,
0.1435388327,
-0.1597581953,
-0.1978878081,
0.0675444677,
-0.1875917912,
-0.6510307789,
0.6803546548,
0.7625056505,
0.4318236411,
-0.2951978445,
-0.0939436927,
-0.9605634809,
-0.0278251469,
0.8015199304,
0.7583397627,
-0.6177289486,
0.1097245663,
0.1189443246,
-0.3819110096,
0.0826578736,
0.7376294732,
-0.897172749,
0.5205250978,
0.7285946012,
0.8707122207,
0.1500478089,
-0.2982584834,
1.1370658875,
-0.4574966133,
-0.0904597342,
0.2086221576,
0.1816877425,
0.4087931514,
-0.3251975179,
0.4538966715,
0.4206323326,
-0.2007175982,
-0.6261161566,
0.1622496694,
-1.3854273558,
-0.6501402259,
0.7463067174,
0.5840764642,
-0.4528594017,
-0.1409018785,
-0.2520616353,
0.4649735689,
-0.3924430907,
0.5851994753,
0.6424459219,
-0.2800230384,
-0.0957062766,
-0.7478731275,
0.5332064629,
0.459395051,
-1.0307124853,
0.0047615352,
0.6506938338,
-0.1463866681,
0.1058516055,
0.0788299441,
-0.2076553106,
0.3145828247,
-0.3453923166,
0.0571987368,
-0.151446864,
-0.5412222147,
-0.5765611529,
0.1751193553,
-0.233013168,
0.1658028215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01518v1
|
Revisiting Dynamic Evaluation: Online Adaptation for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T14:03:48 | 2024-03-03T14:03:48 |
Amal Rannen-Triki, Jorg Bornschein, Razvan Pascanu, Marcus Hutter, Andras György, Alexandre Galashov, Yee Whye Teh, Michalis K. Titsias
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We consider the problem of online fine tuning the parameters of a language
model at test time, also known as dynamic evaluation. While it is generally
known that this approach improves the overall predictive performance,
especially when considering distributional shift between training and
evaluation data, we here emphasize the perspective that online adaptation turns
parameters into temporally changing states and provides a form of
context-length extension with memory in weights, more in line with the concept
of memory in neuroscience. We pay particular attention to the speed of
adaptation (in terms of sample efficiency),sensitivity to the overall
distributional drift, and the computational overhead for performing gradient
computations and parameter updates. Our empirical study provides insights on
when online adaptation is particularly interesting. We highlight that with
online adaptation the conceptual distinction between in-context learning and
fine tuning blurs: both are methods to condition the model on previously
observed tokens.
|
[
-0.3876393437,
-0.9152371287,
0.4948715866,
0.2183511853,
-0.1084108651,
0.2404485196,
-0.6735209227,
-0.7068252563,
-0.0520396046,
-0.0606293716,
-0.4584497511,
0.2357155979,
-0.3190811872,
-0.1510878056,
-0.4536946714,
1.0614886284,
-0.3322265744,
0.065724276,
-0.0657669455,
-0.250942111,
-0.4233744442,
-0.1087455377,
-1.0362530947,
-0.2794516981,
0.3652587831,
-0.1594442427,
0.4955897331,
0.7811187506,
0.376347512,
0.3349651396,
-0.1709689349,
-0.096890904,
-0.7897666693,
0.2825090885,
-0.1729883701,
-0.7225617766,
-0.2742539644,
-0.2767750621,
0.9164621234,
0.8734652996,
-0.3265078366,
0.1550486386,
-0.0499445014,
0.6000391841,
-0.996291697,
-0.0446620435,
-0.7363073826,
0.1672020108,
0.1380643398,
-0.4668028057,
-0.3143914044,
-0.4990906417,
0.461280942,
-0.8450925946,
0.1565933079,
-0.2509116828,
0.7777494788,
0.3008058965,
-0.2444425821,
-0.3274942636,
-1.1748367548,
0.6839808226,
-0.4829670191,
0.6684911847,
0.2681230307,
0.6195073724,
-0.141728282,
-0.8852677345,
-0.2436046451,
-0.5543184876,
0.5011362433,
0.2032671422,
0.0390628316,
0.0371504277,
0.3271415234,
0.4082300663,
0.169049114,
0.1001213491,
-0.3638281524,
-0.087108925,
0.5826081634,
0.1680126488,
0.106183365,
0.4372760057,
-0.0828869045,
-0.0452225283,
-0.3353016973,
0.1186235696,
0.3561997116,
0.2009717822,
-0.2520374358,
-0.1527544558,
-0.2173789144,
0.7597796917,
0.4112685621,
-0.0696125925,
0.257186085,
-0.3417324722,
0.1043765619,
0.0472990945,
0.1224102825,
0.3763142228,
0.2757073343,
-0.2485043555,
-0.2347520739,
-0.1565274894,
0.3110559583,
-0.8726146221,
-0.2459719777,
-0.0328589901,
-0.4997276664,
-0.137197271,
-0.0959500596,
-1.0449001789,
-0.5694558024,
-0.425516963,
0.7349215746,
-0.2746838927,
-0.1680407226,
0.2807189822,
-0.2045749426,
0.0106123043,
0.5692815781,
-0.9833860993,
0.574888587,
0.4502007067,
0.8665568233,
-0.3772836924,
-0.3132776022,
-0.7265180349,
-0.1690554917,
-0.2805998027,
0.7055241466,
-0.6096214056,
-0.102754645,
0.1035020351,
-0.0360909365,
-0.233762756,
-0.5280898213,
0.1619235128,
-0.6602275372,
0.1436698288,
-0.1722314507,
-0.5254677534,
0.0135217756,
0.0270425566,
-0.6595652699,
1.1278202534,
0.3027455807,
-0.5147300363,
0.6381965876,
-0.9369456768,
-0.3354824781,
-0.1962187141,
0.3886324763,
-0.2299559712,
0.5028902292,
0.063393414,
0.1328352988,
0.0010332365,
0.0894686878,
-0.5490766168,
-0.6387489438,
0.5583141446,
-0.2764570415,
0.5090045333,
0.3131025136,
-0.4630816281,
0.1343069822,
-1.0658322573,
0.136901319,
-0.1464050859,
-0.8760891557,
-0.3429842591,
0.5371213555,
-0.0593749359,
-0.0409776941,
-0.0001866535,
-0.2925477028,
0.1479855329,
-0.8172388077,
0.7119018435,
0.880956769,
0.0572784841,
0.5002537966,
-0.1251848638,
0.4405926764,
-0.2801972628,
0.2847225368,
-0.1816981733,
-0.097650066,
-1.0808484554,
-0.0855711251,
0.8098593354,
0.357157141,
-0.4307988286,
0.1764815152,
-0.3362258077,
-0.3902054727,
-0.4107574522,
-0.1300641447,
0.0826946273,
-0.0548343547,
0.161181137,
-0.5518174171,
-0.4701051414,
-0.5272545218,
-0.4806618989,
0.0428652503,
-0.1623581797,
0.3746013343,
0.3904660642,
-0.2547336519,
0.6928184032,
-0.3891870677,
0.1500019431,
-0.150527969,
0.1518368721,
-0.1672654897,
0.2521639168,
0.6697713733,
-0.3924055696,
-0.3626201153,
-0.0951877609,
-0.2496799231,
-0.1256193221,
-0.4780389369,
0.1848572642,
0.1173777804,
0.4668602347,
-0.180015102,
-0.0015563003,
0.5727820992,
-0.3135146797,
0.2051812857,
-0.6192896962,
0.1967092454,
-0.9161608815,
-0.1456150413,
-0.1612909585,
-0.2754899561,
-0.512204349,
0.4022904932,
0.0371512249,
-0.0558225214,
-0.595770359,
0.736851275,
-0.6500278711,
-0.3023871481,
-0.2841791213,
0.2505685091,
-0.1353127956,
0.1485975683,
-0.4792129397,
0.7194204926,
0.6254068017,
-0.8277936578,
0.3594658375,
-0.1956276298,
-0.6676766872,
0.297576189,
-0.1676055342,
0.261541158,
-0.1116445437,
0.3674242198,
-0.6491208076,
-0.1350817978,
-0.0243621729,
-0.0083738165,
0.3502764106,
0.2396746427,
-0.2827007771,
-0.0357434526,
-0.4038536847,
0.5940478444,
0.3687163591,
-0.4598681033,
0.4604222476,
0.3057989478,
0.2692719698,
-0.1170344874,
-0.5099540353,
-0.1359253973,
-0.3716997504,
-0.1493182927,
0.5429272652,
-0.2352096885,
-0.453304857,
-0.0495246872,
-0.0206973348,
-0.3198842108,
0.7097703815,
-0.0232317112,
-0.2214173526,
-0.3120522201,
0.3407757282,
0.0335052572,
0.1669951379,
0.0403637178,
-0.116121605,
0.4480371475,
-0.0725884885,
-0.115781121,
-0.3577404618,
0.1159635931,
0.4471684396,
-0.0108549912,
0.7722873092,
0.6279999614,
-0.5373881459,
-0.4297043979,
-0.3893714547,
-0.3803195059,
-0.4772658944,
0.634875834,
-0.3905799389,
-0.8249943852,
0.795478344,
-0.5114322901,
-0.3115942776,
0.4748148918,
0.6704282761,
-0.0182891395,
0.8930097222,
0.8915576935,
0.2948690653,
0.8853450418,
0.0824677646,
0.1965184212,
-0.7526658177,
0.0021743397,
-0.2854785621,
-0.582873106,
-0.8426690102,
-0.3288917243,
0.2141643316,
0.4031735361,
-0.1184820086,
0.0331294313,
-0.1416978687,
0.6055827141,
0.0098819612,
0.3512901962,
-0.0151801687,
-0.0771161467,
-0.0564818569,
-0.1611919999,
-0.6556168199,
0.170789212,
0.9666854143,
0.4787020087,
0.533646822,
-0.0436764173,
-0.0857170224,
0.3598490953,
0.2347033024,
-0.8523799777,
0.3629219532,
0.0873187184,
-0.6503592134,
-0.1316290349,
-0.1975953132,
-1.0292155743,
0.0309604649,
-0.3395656049,
-0.8182404637,
0.1528906226,
0.2950765193,
-0.6393072009,
0.2265536636,
-0.6668118834,
0.6746393442,
-0.5313177705,
-0.522636354,
-0.7983282804,
-0.4372156262,
0.1383468807,
-0.5750666857,
0.1337459236,
-0.0260970108,
-0.1989404112,
0.876421392,
-0.0522680022,
0.7771236897,
-0.2021708488,
0.1941919029,
0.0322835073,
0.1542653888,
0.4998458922,
-0.1688278615,
-0.3207575679,
0.0171801224,
0.326125294,
-0.220365569,
-0.8570373654,
0.7774886489,
-0.7021035552,
-0.3877186477,
-0.3624553382,
-0.6333166361,
-0.4158146083,
0.0198613442,
-0.1825017035,
0.4492762387,
-0.2108599544,
0.2966918051,
0.4950266778,
-0.5574160814,
0.4535086453,
0.5008388162,
-0.260533452,
-0.2329422385,
0.8621370196,
0.3037916422,
0.6434058547,
0.3544256091,
0.6025900841,
-0.247673884,
-0.716757834,
-0.4524364173,
0.1586039513,
-0.9621316791,
0.338940829,
-0.2417669743,
-0.0503499173,
0.0884556249,
-0.2229786664,
-0.4611712396,
-0.5713862181,
-0.3459018171,
-0.0709734783,
0.532048583,
0.7179274559,
0.0717127994,
0.3355500996,
-0.5708013177,
0.0037516633,
0.1060134321,
0.7896336317,
0.1019383073,
-0.7900482416,
-0.6178240776,
-0.0272397511,
-0.420905292,
-0.7679494023,
0.0976131409,
0.8439436555,
0.7034762502,
0.44325611,
-0.0557156876,
1.0810116529,
-0.6426166892,
0.7430128455,
-0.1904605478,
-1.0484081507,
0.3710200787,
-0.3210184574,
0.4484981,
0.6069899797,
0.415584296,
-0.4789089859,
-0.106110014,
-0.3881996572,
-0.8358920217,
0.5188910365,
-0.2117608935,
0.5749746561,
0.2856751978,
0.8138757944,
0.3592764735,
0.2807471156,
-0.4122892022,
-0.0155816507,
-0.0346350931,
0.0924448296,
-0.1012180299,
-0.3308317363,
-0.001395553,
-0.6952997446,
0.176800102,
-0.2913323343,
0.5672195554,
-0.1163611561,
-0.1225036457,
-0.3343531191,
0.1933359802,
0.818031311,
1.2270681858,
-0.2135362476,
-0.0509361178,
0.8230783343,
-0.2090282291,
-0.0271425415,
-0.1542635858,
-0.0356398486,
-0.3271048963,
0.4593493938,
1.3171408176,
0.7542106509,
-0.7417858839,
0.3574653268,
0.0062975865,
-0.0028450137,
-0.3677472472,
0.2484779358,
-0.1391168535,
0.2532253563,
0.2245746404,
0.0892625526,
0.136241436,
-0.918125093,
0.2869414091,
0.2006479949,
-0.4892603457,
-0.6583892107,
0.6757204533,
0.2483616024,
-0.4630516768,
0.366743058,
-0.0373738371,
-0.4922724366,
0.3825951815,
0.7960105538,
0.9944052696,
-0.328232646,
-0.1567548513,
0.3257186115,
-0.1176482663,
-0.2305659801,
0.1552080661,
-0.1077656001,
-0.524661243,
-0.4936107397,
-0.9346288443,
-0.300326705,
0.163150385,
-0.5451498032,
0.2755261362,
-0.6700231433,
-0.1985209882,
-0.0788175315,
-0.218689099,
-0.3672877252,
0.3314227164,
0.2011763752,
0.9570455551,
-0.6998178363,
0.8128123283,
0.4514716566,
0.0819021538,
-0.4821810126,
0.380271256,
-0.224733755,
-0.4630522132,
0.542997241,
0.1245808229,
-0.0021553354,
0.0673253685,
-0.0282397252,
-1.1563725471,
0.8451927304,
0.7350221276,
-0.4803628325,
0.1699511856,
-0.2029206753,
1.0296133757,
-0.2931842804,
0.5365531445,
0.6248480678,
0.3400968909,
-0.2509206235,
-1.2051161528,
0.0075721941,
-0.0242723767,
0.0072512315,
0.3552664518,
-0.6319097281,
0.7582294941,
-0.1095741242,
-0.3778621852,
-0.1524762064,
0.4340429902,
-0.3846572936,
0.0754141659,
0.5801917911,
0.3106345236,
0.804574132,
-0.1231033504,
1.366599679,
-0.3627141714,
0.4062183499,
0.8784435987,
-0.2922048569,
1.0847526789,
0.4539010227,
-0.3933766484,
0.6178465486,
0.9591240287,
-0.0192993395,
0.6756136417,
0.4702354968,
-0.083154045,
-0.2662522197,
-0.0565018654,
-0.4173725843,
0.3694655299,
0.1818781048,
-0.3085948229,
-0.2896854877,
0.1816132814,
-0.243088007,
0.0884248912,
-0.5222509503,
0.6406998634,
-0.0453420132,
-0.7497292161,
0.8329936862,
0.1970757395,
0.3235082924,
-0.5579502583,
0.2182413638,
0.0626499876,
0.6806986928,
-0.0453725159,
-0.4177383482,
0.5363129377,
-0.3487755954,
-0.0552433468,
-0.1434289813,
0.519960463,
0.0118720233,
-0.4808474183,
0.6295282245,
0.2791810632,
0.111927174,
0.1629284173,
-0.841019094,
0.3023726046,
-0.2257045507,
-0.3904680014,
0.6922188401,
0.146659255,
-0.2949781418,
0.8910108209,
0.6088062525,
0.2864329219,
0.5014945865,
0.2140337527,
0.8231363297,
-0.4787193835,
-0.5821064711,
-0.8479792476,
0.390184015,
0.183517009,
-0.5114011765,
0.5476050377,
0.4238635302,
1.1223777533,
-0.1372847259,
0.5193893313,
0.1157710031,
0.2800325453,
-0.6943640709,
0.7486719489,
-0.8271972537,
0.0167089235,
-0.0323350541,
-0.9571820498,
-0.3106894493,
0.5176586509,
-0.4374485612,
0.1274752766,
1.0501941442,
0.5072951317,
-0.2514975369,
-0.1236316115,
0.222715959,
0.3051644266,
0.0411518812,
0.4096418619,
0.8620598316,
-0.5468517542,
0.1683797091,
-0.0776058137,
-0.1269998997,
-0.3042422235,
-1.1138486862,
-0.769380033,
-0.5884045959,
-0.479239881,
-0.2440893501,
0.4594395757,
1.0300247669,
0.5979360342,
-0.9841848016,
-0.3570922017,
-0.0725471675,
-0.4247089624,
-0.542681098,
-0.1784248948,
0.2173104584,
-0.3373481333,
-0.7686479092,
0.5687491298,
0.2088138908,
-0.2368941456,
-0.4584518075,
-0.0876551569,
-0.1919898987,
0.2684105337,
0.5715125203,
0.1494837552,
-0.6697710752,
-0.5954287648,
-0.3358838558,
0.2371445894,
0.3360367119,
0.8600812554,
-0.6876606345,
0.8447781205,
0.7200234532,
1.0325580835,
0.6790604591,
-0.0549108572,
0.8032094836,
-0.2455212474,
0.1917008907,
-0.0599391125,
0.1162452102,
0.3105942905,
-0.1644223481,
0.0550006479,
0.4119794667,
-0.5558972955,
-1.1244122982,
0.2092195749,
-0.7412343621,
-0.254342258,
1.1249264479,
-0.0711750388,
-0.20033665,
-0.0367024913,
0.0641211644,
0.37977615,
-0.1110484898,
1.2062916756,
0.8200054169,
-0.1167970672,
-0.1284392774,
-1.0113582611,
0.6919969916,
0.3295633793,
-0.8069414496,
-0.0373447053,
0.1871810108,
0.466381222,
-0.0837417915,
0.2537774742,
0.2936115265,
0.2585202754,
-0.0245528873,
-0.257950902,
0.198109895,
-0.3602063656,
-0.8394976854,
0.1479746401,
0.3783196807,
-0.0565809719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01509v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01509v2
|
Fantastic Semantics and Where to Find Them: Investigating Which Layers of Generative LLMs Reflect Lexical Semantics
| 2024-03-03T13:14:47 | 2024-06-09T13:07:50 |
Zhu Liu, Cunliang Kong, Ying Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have achieved remarkable success in general language
understanding tasks. However, as a family of generative methods with the
objective of next token prediction, the semantic evolution with the depth of
these models are not fully explored, unlike their predecessors, such as
BERT-like architectures. In this paper, we specifically investigate the
bottom-up evolution of lexical semantics for a popular LLM, namely Llama2, by
probing its hidden states at the end of each layer using a contextualized word
identification task. Our experiments show that the representations in lower
layers encode lexical semantics, while the higher layers, with weaker semantic
induction, are responsible for prediction. This is in contrast to models with
discriminative objectives, such as mask language modeling, where the higher
layers obtain better lexical semantics. The conclusion is further supported by
the monotonic increase in performance via the hidden states for the last
meaningless symbols, such as punctuation, in the prompting strategy. Our codes
are available at https://github.com/RyanLiut/LLM_LexSem.
|
[
-0.398416549,
-0.6334599853,
0.8847746253,
0.0352131091,
-0.2941760719,
0.3672012687,
-0.0565204956,
-0.3775838614,
0.2188305706,
0.5708270073,
-0.7141941786,
-0.7856849432,
-0.6443939805,
0.0654163584,
-0.3701397777,
0.7881593704,
0.0921998546,
-0.201408729,
-0.1816914976,
0.0679393858,
-0.24745363,
-0.6969351768,
-0.3518419862,
-0.6325378418,
0.4505101442,
0.2582061589,
0.8647866845,
0.7325446606,
0.2005231082,
0.2026491612,
-0.763256669,
0.2814796865,
-0.5121646523,
0.1775045544,
-0.1721251011,
-0.7730754018,
-0.182325989,
-0.2220024318,
0.5940105319,
0.7338780165,
-0.1284121126,
-0.0378432944,
-0.1012161747,
0.3409844637,
-0.7384727597,
0.2971460223,
-0.8290888071,
0.2597170174,
-0.414097935,
-0.4235827327,
-0.2577475011,
-0.0952902138,
0.0778961182,
-0.4596696496,
0.1582505554,
0.1121508628,
0.8380118012,
0.28841272,
-0.2079259455,
-0.5521662831,
-0.4437640011,
0.7061157227,
-0.5122465491,
0.2835923731,
0.4324076176,
0.0785522833,
-0.3212849498,
-0.5626974702,
-0.6075095534,
-0.6475793719,
-0.0204409063,
0.2086813599,
-0.4607061744,
0.1403456777,
0.1256851852,
0.5296488404,
-0.1375496089,
0.5198450089,
0.0719615892,
-0.43201828,
0.1258119047,
0.1864583641,
0.4021575749,
-0.3351196051,
-0.6379870772,
0.0959783867,
-1.0570883751,
-0.2591583729,
0.3346537948,
0.0920573249,
-0.3287670612,
0.735580802,
-0.0523988865,
0.4213095009,
-0.4400142729,
-0.0625521168,
0.3835701346,
-0.4230124652,
0.0785601735,
0.1761004329,
0.2665297985,
-0.0581057183,
0.221307382,
-0.3269227743,
-0.4420914054,
0.3418714106,
0.0288857501,
-0.4741029441,
-0.1537730694,
-0.1151248366,
-0.2155526727,
-0.3762437403,
-0.1233245581,
-0.1507467926,
-0.5155758262,
-0.2844486535,
0.199585557,
-0.4930512607,
-0.2791872621,
0.2466870695,
-0.1508765817,
0.614320457,
0.2688809931,
-0.895588398,
0.2880041301,
1.053912282,
0.8950938582,
-0.1691580266,
-0.1879565418,
-0.3836745024,
0.1432075202,
-0.7989937067,
0.9433630109,
-0.7952890992,
-0.30148229,
0.131162256,
0.0048300233,
0.1949132085,
-0.7712082267,
0.6942237616,
-0.7226418257,
0.0825882703,
-0.4888879061,
-0.4746583402,
-0.260741055,
0.1983774751,
-0.4672697783,
1.1335020065,
-0.017413944,
-0.7715935111,
0.3292341828,
-0.6062374711,
-0.2601309717,
0.2292253077,
-0.1770895422,
-0.149984166,
0.6648905873,
0.1925614774,
0.5680503845,
-0.3671066463,
-0.0137814889,
-0.1798436791,
-0.4591432214,
0.4281786978,
-0.2930765748,
0.7131297588,
0.1192202941,
-0.4652245343,
-0.0306384061,
-0.6979658604,
-0.2357762605,
0.3007877767,
-0.3471615911,
-0.4476162791,
0.1304919124,
-0.2439359874,
0.0514376052,
0.377012223,
-0.4391818345,
-0.0660950467,
-0.4664823711,
0.5201284885,
0.8264400959,
-0.037576206,
0.3521664739,
-0.1366307586,
0.5124191046,
0.1644452959,
-0.2312799841,
-0.2175462395,
-0.5720219612,
-0.9401319027,
-0.2278988659,
0.1271226406,
0.4224261045,
-0.5786097646,
0.3895919025,
-0.1249049157,
-0.1946636736,
-0.4000369608,
0.2582469881,
0.6272959709,
0.2802023292,
0.2356287837,
-0.2955143452,
-0.2292835414,
-1.1631911993,
0.1085084528,
-0.3693790734,
-0.0369538516,
0.2048658133,
0.3585009873,
-0.5442747474,
0.6314591169,
-0.3353678584,
-0.0079196952,
-0.4775989652,
-0.0467535481,
0.1023989469,
0.0875357166,
0.4166163802,
-0.342816025,
0.2462555319,
0.0138162468,
-0.6804817319,
-0.4410102367,
0.058370132,
-0.3465783298,
0.0766669288,
0.3914631605,
-0.6134956479,
0.0311597884,
0.4633105993,
-0.1265284121,
0.5317875743,
-0.1373730004,
-0.4483170211,
-0.9522332549,
-0.1702985317,
-0.2747218609,
-0.1529983878,
-0.6455602646,
0.3845782876,
0.1574494988,
0.214025557,
-0.2640972733,
0.368004024,
-0.771294713,
-0.4472984374,
-0.2955768704,
0.3313829303,
-0.0849255994,
0.3199715614,
0.1208664849,
0.9424035549,
0.8514504433,
-0.4973441064,
0.0126891844,
0.1477122009,
-0.5344420075,
0.1045369506,
-0.3658007979,
0.1948813796,
-0.2496502399,
0.200595811,
-0.9767094851,
-0.2367626578,
0.0184711497,
-0.4088760614,
0.2562940717,
0.0692567825,
-0.7734853029,
-0.3536027074,
-0.4563963711,
0.2168090791,
0.5588274002,
-0.6444010139,
0.1908612698,
0.5035773516,
-0.0053405361,
-0.5011281371,
-0.8213531375,
0.3814190626,
-0.1279233098,
-0.2131249458,
0.4224531949,
0.1319241077,
-0.3334223628,
-0.099660933,
-0.1067436934,
0.4132996798,
0.3762404025,
0.2082914114,
0.2423564345,
-0.3832875192,
0.1301642209,
0.2685844004,
-0.249992311,
0.3415025771,
-0.4384607077,
0.8792374134,
-0.3114625812,
-0.2060505003,
-0.5010870695,
0.0276314318,
0.4721833467,
-0.210387364,
0.7165336013,
0.536395967,
-0.5158657432,
-0.4057152569,
-0.5434373617,
-0.0413218066,
-0.4448944032,
0.460144639,
-0.5295527577,
-1.034326911,
0.7297955155,
-0.0132072829,
-0.2230104804,
0.3263285458,
0.9054741859,
0.0915004164,
0.8154367805,
0.633050859,
0.1012891233,
0.1827511936,
-0.3356706202,
0.002072861,
-0.8576427698,
-0.4800925255,
-0.2900052965,
0.0113351215,
-0.6588128805,
-0.4833788276,
0.2443732917,
0.4501709044,
0.002922788,
0.3740407526,
-0.2776919603,
0.5991852283,
0.4948005378,
0.0482547246,
0.2767733037,
0.2612276375,
-0.5638910532,
0.1812193245,
-0.6288101673,
-0.5775285959,
0.7513563633,
0.5756926537,
0.654725492,
0.231152609,
0.8173937201,
0.1183203906,
0.0629653633,
-0.8726477027,
0.7420580387,
-0.0743122101,
-0.3600555658,
0.1322938055,
-0.1622271985,
-0.7942146063,
0.1859613359,
-0.0789688304,
-0.7324058414,
-0.0276807714,
-0.0283368491,
-0.2449413836,
0.2255611122,
-0.4671466649,
0.4657203257,
-0.1160471365,
-0.2332528979,
-0.2830275893,
-0.5262591243,
0.3533647954,
-0.0073541268,
0.0933818966,
-0.3528880775,
-0.5287430286,
0.5674265623,
-0.384989053,
0.7676233053,
0.0483953245,
-0.5106954575,
0.3033025861,
0.3802712262,
0.4613808095,
-0.0492679104,
0.0378172025,
0.2627816796,
-0.3264800608,
-0.4627374709,
-0.3869080544,
0.8588774204,
-0.7875679731,
-0.7623075843,
-0.198699832,
-0.3938977122,
-0.2568133175,
-0.0087761236,
0.2842379808,
0.5673735738,
0.2531889975,
0.0172649957,
0.7167589664,
-0.3688215315,
0.3429566324,
0.2154684216,
-0.1171840653,
0.0021687835,
0.8698663116,
-0.1691996157,
0.3356271386,
0.6854478717,
0.3662408888,
-0.5478093624,
-0.8172395825,
-0.289989531,
0.4318083823,
-0.9328688383,
-0.159614712,
-0.468306303,
-0.3026692569,
-0.0967617631,
-0.1103091016,
-0.199232623,
-0.3906124234,
-0.5969743133,
-0.4748393297,
0.226539284,
0.9646186233,
-0.1246018186,
0.2353034765,
-0.3568681777,
0.0885368437,
0.1671129018,
0.2451424748,
0.0751746595,
-0.5783282518,
0.1523903012,
-0.3919647038,
-0.0484408289,
-0.7894482017,
0.101304248,
0.2230730653,
0.5372288823,
0.5522828698,
-0.2617316246,
0.4943609536,
-0.4484404325,
0.8122838736,
0.1971745938,
-0.7996382117,
0.4403243959,
-0.2551421523,
0.4253620803,
0.2880124152,
0.3239204884,
-0.3891714811,
-0.5328475237,
-0.2844837606,
-0.7184488177,
0.6017578244,
0.2675297558,
0.6580097079,
-0.3359865248,
0.447583586,
0.4108211696,
0.1459225118,
-0.7100940943,
-0.2609269321,
-0.0170487985,
-0.0055155382,
0.1050584093,
-0.7043377161,
-0.0475946739,
0.0868474469,
0.2709994018,
-0.0324604362,
0.4272843897,
-0.057592269,
-0.1769765913,
0.2329759598,
0.4272619188,
0.5511808395,
0.6205658317,
0.0987814292,
0.6879319549,
0.2129808068,
-0.4263073802,
-0.1442665607,
-0.0804715604,
-0.1084520966,
-0.0667271316,
0.8134928346,
1.0301828384,
0.5398257971,
-0.6953036189,
0.4510196447,
0.4421647489,
-0.1593872756,
-0.5033127069,
0.326456368,
0.1967504621,
0.3057667911,
0.4241747558,
-0.3424903452,
0.1470686793,
-0.7143304348,
0.0725448355,
0.5898956656,
-0.2958180904,
-0.4738613069,
0.692428112,
-0.2359446734,
-0.0643240213,
0.3460049629,
-0.4959073663,
-0.7754135132,
0.3454745412,
0.7517337203,
0.7629806995,
0.3050016761,
0.3720366359,
0.0191513821,
0.2365366518,
0.2115843594,
0.2514974177,
-0.4355036914,
-0.8592572808,
-0.2738405168,
-0.9211102128,
-0.2327970117,
0.1464889348,
-0.4148836732,
0.1244253442,
-0.4089780748,
0.0333450437,
0.03199194,
-0.1704915762,
-0.5727698803,
-0.1364357173,
0.8017324209,
0.8849779963,
-0.4552456737,
0.7504124641,
0.6310123801,
-0.2574126422,
-0.4700497985,
0.074358128,
0.0594616085,
-1.4933751822,
0.7451547384,
0.2838094234,
-0.4759759009,
0.1930996627,
-0.6243590117,
-0.9844628572,
1.0049058199,
0.4741050899,
-0.4256410301,
-0.2328297496,
0.3441632986,
0.6351140738,
-0.2581914663,
0.3183462322,
0.6655312777,
0.1493480653,
0.2656541169,
-0.4749367833,
0.1386343241,
-0.099760212,
0.5718256235,
0.070739001,
-0.3536346853,
0.6447561383,
-0.4575746953,
-0.6532735229,
0.3491381109,
0.7090210319,
0.3742481172,
-0.0016367122,
0.2361658663,
0.7345264554,
0.6217287183,
-0.1783615649,
1.182331562,
-0.2917838097,
0.2952487469,
0.6134909391,
-0.1364561319,
0.8025196195,
0.3266928196,
-0.0696632415,
0.8421549797,
0.8635965586,
0.1665537804,
0.6137125492,
0.4497838318,
-0.4454187453,
-0.4007333219,
-0.3614811301,
-0.3574899137,
0.4569617212,
0.6709768176,
-0.3053777814,
-0.3539717495,
-0.0782362968,
0.2083214372,
-0.0717926025,
-0.4740040302,
0.90812397,
0.073706314,
-0.3823984265,
0.871309638,
-0.046773877,
0.6578595042,
-0.4498352408,
0.0459151752,
-0.529653132,
-0.0430949815,
-0.1852879822,
-0.9127173424,
-0.0990638733,
-0.1278378367,
0.1240034699,
0.0062755854,
0.6857648492,
-0.1789187342,
-0.3935806453,
0.6765288115,
0.5566048622,
0.2453138679,
0.3009297848,
-0.5695248842,
0.2350131422,
-0.3568072617,
-0.1973086596,
0.0807166174,
0.4593878686,
-0.0834462196,
0.5453945994,
0.5263171196,
0.0706078261,
0.3525681496,
0.3522717953,
0.8971050382,
-0.5919699073,
-0.4211048186,
-0.9326630831,
0.1304551363,
0.1347171813,
-0.416575253,
0.5116748214,
0.428963691,
0.9441942573,
0.0510259829,
0.4766117334,
0.2157407999,
0.1796939522,
-0.8678390384,
0.4441834688,
-0.6410397291,
0.4218575358,
-0.0521226674,
-1.1934294701,
-0.3921967745,
0.2729188502,
-0.2107819766,
-0.199740693,
0.6389555335,
1.0026046038,
-0.0016681777,
0.0918423682,
0.3374435902,
0.5094364882,
0.010021829,
0.5145887136,
1.3508040905,
0.1601743102,
0.0830943808,
-0.236822024,
-0.3418089747,
-0.0887415633,
-0.6141251922,
-0.7707951069,
-0.6279202104,
-0.1363345534,
-0.1530533582,
0.236215651,
0.7350560427,
0.4065019488,
-0.7917444706,
-0.0797485784,
-0.5415304899,
0.0737790763,
0.1918358654,
-0.2165822238,
0.3534777164,
-0.6418780684,
-0.4685061574,
0.4810868502,
0.4442503452,
-0.0423110649,
-0.5282905698,
-0.0167202242,
0.1307616979,
0.0434521846,
0.8401586413,
0.0525456108,
-1.2136495113,
-0.3840883076,
0.0308481436,
-0.1566493809,
-0.0511915535,
0.6746070981,
-0.7328787446,
0.2695206702,
0.2662100196,
0.7932381034,
0.4462201595,
-0.2489730269,
0.1899954379,
-0.5639593601,
0.0013611385,
0.0752625838,
0.4448780715,
0.4127092957,
-0.1058347449,
0.3961418569,
0.3832015097,
-0.0743992552,
-0.8172471523,
0.3454578221,
-0.8620740771,
-0.2166437805,
1.3565689325,
0.1602399051,
-0.2257093489,
0.0958210081,
-0.0498711839,
0.0185112525,
-0.1420926005,
0.6613376737,
0.6523866057,
-0.2768606544,
-0.2544947565,
-0.621016264,
0.4129697382,
0.4780050814,
-0.627412498,
0.0283073094,
0.4998264909,
0.066485025,
0.3273137808,
0.2829331458,
-0.2355071157,
0.0993614644,
-0.081280373,
-0.3064405024,
0.0123185897,
-0.4373192787,
-0.2600839436,
0.1763958186,
0.300306946,
-0.1569914967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01481v1
|
Infusing Knowledge into Large Language Models with Contextual Prompts
| 2024-03-03T11:19:26 | 2024-03-03T11:19:26 |
Kinshuk Vasisht, Balaji Ganesan, Vikas Kumar, Vasudha Bhatnagar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge infusion is a promising method for enhancing Large Language Models
for domain-specific NLP tasks rather than pre-training models over large data
from scratch. These augmented LLMs typically depend on additional pre-training
or knowledge prompts from an existing knowledge graph, which is impractical in
many applications. In contrast, knowledge infusion directly from relevant
documents is more generalisable and alleviates the need for structured
knowledge graphs while also being useful for entities that are usually not
found in any knowledge graph. With this motivation, we propose a simple yet
generalisable approach for knowledge infusion by generating prompts from the
context in the input text. Our experiments show the effectiveness of our
approach which we evaluate by probing the fine-tuned LLMs.
|
[
-0.2135259062,
-0.8316347003,
0.8524044156,
0.0002188869,
-0.2352313697,
0.091923736,
-0.2126141936,
-0.4904994369,
0.2734916508,
0.7533972859,
-0.6285025477,
-0.2825855613,
-0.3727201819,
0.2193912417,
-0.3466313481,
0.9905472994,
-0.0081081968,
-0.0214872137,
-0.8752861619,
0.1955497414,
-0.5641239285,
-0.6776974797,
-0.7772334218,
-0.6728008389,
0.5039781928,
0.4535598755,
0.3027395606,
0.1948842406,
0.1466593444,
0.191159904,
-0.1628297567,
0.5962824225,
-0.24964495,
0.370606035,
-0.3481261134,
-0.362144202,
-0.2342571318,
-0.2222825885,
0.6510143876,
1.0391212702,
0.1411491781,
-0.150253877,
0.5198718309,
0.4171238542,
-0.5176394582,
-0.0933304727,
-0.6292155385,
-0.0662616938,
-0.2244099826,
-0.5585295558,
-0.4177129269,
-0.3305208087,
0.6768596768,
-0.6151313186,
-0.0167398918,
0.2025700361,
0.6622159481,
0.2016879916,
-0.4279312789,
-0.5125501752,
-0.5905997753,
0.5933015943,
-0.747066021,
0.2053296417,
0.3092717528,
0.2634228766,
-0.3467356563,
-0.9866994619,
-0.7716347575,
-0.2131898701,
-0.3887222409,
-0.1831929237,
0.0438080393,
0.1380767375,
0.3274013698,
0.1436718702,
-0.3190069199,
0.0407826342,
0.1578927785,
-0.0773304403,
0.1306436658,
0.2690012455,
0.5035737753,
-0.080893077,
-0.5034124255,
0.1350878477,
-1.0802650452,
0.0061173318,
0.038805265,
0.4432192743,
0.0977134258,
0.5602554679,
-0.2553309202,
1.2933356762,
0.1038767695,
-0.4216586649,
0.0186735466,
-0.5206230879,
-0.3003205657,
0.1236697063,
0.5636104941,
0.2631778419,
0.2140347362,
-0.3646699488,
-0.1364873648,
-0.3726325035,
-0.0311159622,
-1.0183509588,
0.1069656536,
0.294451654,
0.1316716075,
-0.196603179,
-0.2097183615,
-0.5830065012,
-0.7005140185,
-0.3706544042,
0.3258366883,
-0.5497018099,
0.0734657645,
0.150179714,
-0.4458804727,
0.2603369355,
0.5183964968,
-1.116944313,
-0.0927034318,
0.4528456628,
0.7172055244,
-0.2914571762,
-0.2386829257,
-0.4900061488,
0.659291923,
-0.0916386321,
1.1019252539,
-0.7127370834,
-0.3362351954,
0.4390758276,
-0.0052150358,
0.1073835194,
-0.5559591055,
0.3385267258,
-0.6996606588,
0.400895834,
-0.4420363605,
-1.0065809488,
-0.1237421855,
0.4984265566,
-0.2023621947,
1.0784928799,
0.4151111245,
-0.7213987112,
0.49729231,
-0.7980704308,
-0.4310147464,
0.3346284032,
-0.1995098144,
0.2452559471,
-0.2167430371,
0.5732599497,
0.7306214571,
-0.4154985845,
0.5209450722,
-0.3091954291,
-0.037579447,
0.2701381445,
-0.2060437948,
0.8736006021,
0.0200393181,
-0.0602053441,
0.0400670096,
-0.6118466854,
-0.0921453908,
-0.0386953652,
-0.4013922811,
-0.5953004956,
-0.2757513523,
-0.3035811782,
0.0446135849,
0.2850764096,
-0.3773140907,
0.6185164452,
-0.9032153487,
0.4817889631,
0.5006200075,
0.5468297005,
0.8762975335,
-0.1278345734,
0.4480558336,
0.0306459907,
-0.1281275153,
-0.3557876945,
-0.4507806599,
-0.6355038881,
-0.4485414922,
0.1948336214,
0.560958147,
-1.2036651373,
0.5205736756,
-0.2259520292,
-0.3459395468,
-0.161193043,
0.3646121323,
0.0064394367,
1.3074166775,
0.3935550451,
0.105067037,
-0.4508115351,
-0.673297286,
-0.1258123517,
0.1613751203,
-0.3937261105,
0.4086863995,
0.2816261649,
-0.4613637924,
1.3510280848,
-0.5541787744,
-0.2700483799,
-0.4292095602,
-0.2630928457,
0.3334726095,
0.4643927515,
0.6219438314,
-0.357104212,
-0.5889679193,
0.0244848076,
-1.1121860743,
-0.1554785073,
-0.1188715026,
-0.2253786176,
-0.1145446301,
0.8603938222,
-0.6220584512,
-0.0156749859,
0.3988522589,
-0.5139017701,
0.3274089396,
-0.1568493396,
0.0648859665,
-1.3424118757,
0.0405113399,
-0.3176347315,
-0.3816047609,
-0.9936031699,
-0.056664966,
0.0885973647,
-0.2068289369,
-0.6067972779,
1.1410295963,
-0.3173471987,
0.2095213234,
-0.2244535536,
0.5344715118,
0.336430639,
0.3554472327,
0.1044587046,
0.6594723463,
0.7414237261,
-0.838504076,
0.4536234438,
0.4606189132,
-0.6217218637,
0.6921848059,
-0.6405547857,
0.2136823386,
-0.1393000931,
0.4907204509,
-1.0540519953,
-0.5081269741,
0.3771052957,
-0.241940856,
0.4774396122,
-0.0602323115,
-0.4812580645,
-0.0547940135,
0.0435053743,
0.43836689,
0.3885864913,
-0.924503386,
0.8705042601,
0.2350524366,
-0.2619273663,
-0.5349917412,
-0.6924635172,
0.1719842404,
-0.426109761,
-0.8045582771,
0.4733684063,
-0.0898472741,
-0.2475187033,
-0.071556218,
0.4607113898,
0.04670332,
0.144964993,
0.0069973003,
0.2005249113,
-0.0697007477,
0.3882700801,
0.3648619652,
0.0866270959,
0.0247276779,
-0.7542880177,
0.5505134463,
0.2441761345,
-0.401317656,
-0.4134807885,
0.4645365179,
0.3039551377,
-0.0912086889,
0.9029810429,
0.2522585392,
-0.5059173107,
-0.4423746765,
-0.6004382968,
-0.376257509,
-0.4957000017,
0.0658638179,
-0.1948747337,
-1.0498687029,
0.4537220299,
-0.4955970943,
-0.0585782491,
0.3593490422,
0.5573452115,
-0.2723604739,
0.869856298,
0.6273198724,
0.0242993403,
0.6410688162,
-0.1292616874,
0.1570949107,
-0.7629627585,
-0.249406144,
-0.4438429773,
-0.0060618916,
0.0854578912,
-0.4574528039,
0.3975723386,
0.2664280236,
-0.1609635353,
-0.1069399491,
-0.3487755656,
0.6107501984,
0.5308737755,
0.1829276085,
0.2754226625,
-0.0699901879,
-0.3067198694,
0.0870946422,
-0.9625259042,
-0.4752966166,
1.0377664566,
0.058267381,
0.4300479591,
-0.0979951248,
0.657307744,
0.0096790306,
0.4268069863,
-0.7639572024,
0.3707900643,
0.188037172,
-0.387039274,
-0.4951030314,
-0.096622467,
-0.941475749,
-0.1945064515,
-0.4324229956,
-0.6867892742,
0.1903532594,
0.3959328532,
-0.7423909903,
0.0896408409,
-0.7543727756,
0.6965534091,
0.0324254856,
-0.079482697,
0.1639633924,
-0.5120527148,
0.2936322391,
-0.1598176956,
0.1238015294,
0.2902217209,
-0.1253672093,
0.7082510591,
-0.760152936,
0.9323914051,
-0.3882095516,
-0.3356775641,
0.2953393757,
-0.2579326332,
0.8986297846,
0.0983701348,
0.0213637315,
-0.212981075,
-0.2702764571,
-0.3125356138,
-1.1174038649,
0.6889938116,
-0.4814760685,
-0.7528277636,
-0.066564478,
-0.6967384815,
-0.8238576055,
0.1780364662,
0.2255737334,
0.6788642406,
-0.0339429565,
0.1250119358,
1.1081876755,
-0.3424016237,
0.365745604,
0.3746946454,
-0.242092967,
-0.2873963118,
0.663364172,
-0.0745849684,
0.4053181112,
0.6415745616,
0.2915505469,
-0.5036542416,
-0.4710067809,
-0.6622774005,
0.1919137239,
-0.9888983965,
-0.3517352045,
-0.8420851231,
0.0172078572,
-0.5058643222,
-0.6084190011,
0.1381723434,
-0.2978501022,
-0.5417996049,
-0.1430878639,
0.6019809842,
0.6448462605,
0.2411690205,
0.4437904954,
-0.8837620616,
0.0336076953,
0.7345830798,
0.0866437331,
0.0910527334,
-0.6727882028,
-0.3452031612,
-0.0069889934,
0.1291877776,
-0.9764492512,
0.3226030469,
0.2446105182,
0.6133164763,
0.6540276408,
-0.0179705881,
0.7858091593,
-0.6457147002,
1.1160328388,
0.1745509803,
-0.9733318686,
0.7151896358,
-0.4700751305,
0.3995195031,
0.584952116,
0.4821132123,
-0.5478358865,
-0.4507012069,
-0.5070933104,
-0.8612108231,
0.4305268824,
-0.3852180243,
0.4118283689,
-0.1443891823,
0.5987801552,
0.0389913693,
0.1773660034,
-0.4048536718,
-0.1245229319,
0.0312543884,
-0.2189668864,
-0.0718053877,
-0.5147689581,
-0.363530755,
-0.3368423283,
0.594522655,
-0.2986808717,
0.1141565368,
0.3663316667,
-0.2993143797,
0.1966132224,
0.0504352972,
0.5337359905,
0.7180300951,
-0.015730476,
0.2583238482,
0.4416015744,
-0.1075946987,
-0.0168299731,
-0.0786540732,
-0.254024148,
-0.0861628279,
0.441770792,
0.7250891328,
0.4331758022,
-0.7151122093,
0.553073585,
0.1066786051,
-0.1560561508,
-0.1866074204,
0.0497806743,
0.3844241798,
0.3858998716,
0.3149483204,
-0.1699341685,
-0.0297200531,
-0.5863546133,
0.1016492024,
0.5642948151,
-0.3186445236,
0.1075158417,
0.4277933836,
0.3384323716,
-0.1605448723,
0.6525779366,
-0.1146246791,
-0.4607046545,
0.0780769289,
0.8111124635,
0.6887404919,
-0.0328607,
0.0361168794,
0.3747655451,
-0.0768835098,
0.0621128082,
-0.0167118739,
-0.1169369966,
-0.9677634835,
-0.5837392211,
-0.6675915718,
-0.4797911942,
-0.0538100675,
-0.2748948336,
0.2819641531,
-0.275893718,
0.0814711004,
-0.1039822102,
-0.1812496185,
-0.8045205474,
0.168212384,
-0.0672505498,
1.1060262918,
-0.7495378852,
1.0890953541,
0.6226056814,
-0.3214017451,
-0.87501508,
-0.1122948378,
-0.4548044205,
-0.9423211217,
0.7286164761,
-0.1664730906,
0.0876823887,
0.2099474669,
-0.7825670242,
-0.9299682379,
1.1553995609,
0.6204211712,
-0.1649091393,
-0.1477752179,
0.1972818971,
0.3703220189,
-0.5615823865,
0.1391943544,
0.5454542637,
0.5748358965,
0.1870262176,
-0.5016059279,
0.2641890943,
-0.0246325061,
0.0228458326,
-0.0443313383,
0.0332539864,
0.6351304054,
-0.1083982959,
-0.2064795941,
-0.2144334465,
0.9091864824,
0.1721776873,
-0.0702180564,
0.5705590248,
0.3948888183,
1.256426692,
0.1079218984,
1.2705416679,
-0.3435883224,
-0.1124783382,
1.0658977032,
-0.1649004072,
0.5747519732,
0.7771416903,
0.0864717513,
0.6741943359,
0.6019075513,
0.279324919,
0.6288599968,
0.0754589289,
-0.528411746,
-0.3198136985,
-0.6045396924,
-0.4229201674,
0.0824148431,
0.4937744141,
-0.275230974,
-0.1505327523,
0.2512748539,
0.218319878,
-0.1080783233,
-0.396997571,
1.0304125547,
0.067232281,
-0.9186733365,
0.6200525761,
-0.3010884821,
0.6138389111,
-0.9792574048,
-0.1372662932,
-0.2867508531,
-0.1742219627,
-0.244867757,
-0.7445527315,
0.2239420861,
-0.034739472,
-0.3187610805,
-0.6106050014,
0.9250409007,
-0.786356926,
-0.1500830352,
0.0935732946,
0.7013032436,
0.0499016419,
-0.2276993096,
-0.2383076251,
-0.465474695,
0.0103153782,
-0.3018031716,
0.5789456367,
0.6085676551,
0.1193334833,
0.5607969165,
0.7918127775,
0.0855846778,
-0.3314832747,
0.2605098486,
1.0709747076,
-0.3620226383,
-0.4836873412,
-0.9798004627,
0.6915794611,
-0.1650055051,
-0.2166433632,
0.8979561329,
0.0874643698,
0.6070997119,
-0.1988188922,
0.9475933909,
0.0707261562,
0.467038542,
-0.7252315283,
0.7066463828,
-0.7253032923,
0.1258681267,
-0.3156184852,
-0.6664674282,
-0.453006804,
0.3802966774,
-0.168222636,
-0.2797708213,
0.6909923553,
0.849969089,
0.3299630284,
-0.1417323798,
0.3251835704,
0.0642307103,
0.2860309184,
0.5070981979,
1.0017969608,
0.1086553186,
0.2265269011,
-0.0128345601,
-0.3901641965,
-0.1517882347,
-1.2173885107,
-1.1168451309,
-0.6331007481,
-0.039223928,
-0.3635987639,
-0.1498157084,
1.0451190472,
0.4214452803,
-0.6810124516,
0.0511000976,
0.0534593277,
0.3693165183,
-0.0814419314,
-0.1831593812,
0.3610883951,
-0.7138177156,
-0.7952191234,
0.7802322507,
0.2058398426,
0.2206326723,
-0.3619415164,
0.0214976091,
-0.1164335236,
0.1990055442,
0.807336092,
0.0788128152,
-0.3680657446,
-0.4256463051,
0.0197870526,
0.0124314306,
-0.1638274342,
0.9350034595,
-1.0539095402,
0.4836783409,
0.6385813355,
0.9981355667,
0.2494439781,
-0.1674702168,
0.9411841631,
-1.0825202465,
0.2315357178,
0.2335968018,
0.5762000084,
0.4730545282,
-0.5262176991,
0.2958778441,
0.2206030488,
-0.4313364625,
-0.9047646523,
0.2878686786,
-0.9055075645,
-0.2270045877,
1.5049505234,
-0.1566615701,
-0.0334440209,
-0.2657591403,
-0.2172919065,
0.1785271615,
-0.266928941,
0.3913691938,
0.7184614539,
-0.1121814921,
0.3422313035,
-0.3764104545,
1.0057780743,
0.2577972114,
-1.1167874336,
0.0260883179,
0.3519095182,
0.1527822465,
0.1644146889,
0.7529144287,
0.2540366948,
-0.1069898978,
-0.221722573,
-0.1505751312,
-0.0755776763,
-0.3666915596,
-0.2316054553,
0.3273537755,
0.1435197294,
0.3959825933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01479v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01479v3
|
Align-to-Distill: Trainable Attention Alignment for Knowledge Distillation in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-03T11:13:44 | 2024-03-25T08:46:15 |
Heegon Jin, Seonil Son, Jemin Park, Youngseok Kim, Hyungjong Noh, Yeonsoo Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The advent of scalable deep models and large datasets has improved the
performance of Neural Machine Translation. Knowledge Distillation (KD) enhances
efficiency by transferring knowledge from a teacher model to a more compact
student model. However, KD approaches to Transformer architecture often rely on
heuristics, particularly when deciding which teacher layers to distill from. In
this paper, we introduce the 'Align-to-Distill' (A2D) strategy, designed to
address the feature mapping problem by adaptively aligning student attention
heads with their teacher counterparts during training. The Attention Alignment
Module in A2D performs a dense head-by-head comparison between student and
teacher attention heads across layers, turning the combinatorial mapping
heuristics into a learning problem. Our experiments show the efficacy of A2D,
demonstrating gains of up to +3.61 and +0.63 BLEU points for WMT-2022 De->Dsb
and WMT-2014 En->De, respectively, compared to Transformer baselines.
|
[
-0.3603968322,
-0.4019064605,
0.5976285338,
0.209459573,
-0.197241649,
0.2168960422,
-0.549079299,
0.090933755,
-0.2224791795,
0.1724436283,
-0.3976605535,
-0.264750421,
-1.139554143,
-0.1509281844,
-0.4218966663,
0.9320639968,
-0.1837164015,
0.0222188998,
-0.5268139243,
-0.2985606194,
-0.8421205878,
-0.0966983885,
-0.60219419,
-0.560505569,
0.627340734,
0.5725773573,
0.6349289417,
0.8959163427,
0.8672229648,
0.4112733305,
-0.1587709785,
0.162681967,
-0.3851486742,
0.3669346869,
-0.4842772186,
-0.5161177516,
-0.2998569608,
-0.0860743746,
0.3326362669,
0.8020951152,
-0.2545670867,
0.3579470515,
0.6575790048,
1.1272300482,
-0.6400405765,
0.0791889355,
-0.7908526063,
0.0579174422,
0.0595752113,
-0.0090848841,
-0.3460987806,
-0.2217538804,
0.6093378663,
-0.4922830462,
0.135691613,
-0.1355844438,
0.642526269,
1.1448034048,
-0.3063793182,
-0.2276625931,
-0.7292419672,
0.6675850153,
-0.44144997,
0.262904346,
0.0964736268,
0.763571322,
0.0166060142,
-0.7884910107,
-0.5616119504,
0.4234276116,
-0.2537723482,
0.2969906628,
-0.0565503761,
-0.3047353923,
0.29542014,
0.3702786863,
-0.2982362807,
-0.0117978696,
-0.3907523155,
0.1516423523,
0.4271516204,
-0.0709385648,
-0.1112724319,
0.3621133864,
-0.6495428681,
-0.287768364,
-0.0823907703,
-0.0676480457,
0.1381952614,
0.261903584,
0.0964896232,
0.3684260547,
-0.0562968776,
0.7118450403,
0.7256602645,
-0.2649018168,
0.0863428265,
-0.0309762545,
-0.1567402184,
0.6734511256,
0.5871479511,
0.4814890027,
0.3654533327,
-0.2933009863,
-0.1286259741,
-0.0521703921,
0.620023489,
-0.8492289186,
-0.535892427,
0.203121081,
-0.1270893514,
-0.3519781232,
-0.2864988148,
-0.7478599548,
-0.3944356143,
-0.6059146523,
0.7806283236,
-0.3148160279,
-0.2120960206,
0.0058592991,
-0.3503544629,
0.0751385987,
0.0487185381,
-1.0282541513,
0.0775025636,
0.4507347345,
0.755069077,
-0.4414693117,
-0.4698919356,
-0.0622758158,
0.2983518541,
-0.1434443742,
0.4039243758,
-0.1194549873,
-0.0049076895,
-0.3018590212,
-0.1987207979,
-0.2844728529,
-0.7359669805,
0.3383747339,
-0.5276303887,
0.2650429904,
-0.402989924,
-0.4761167467,
-0.2789807022,
0.3199775517,
-0.4430118501,
1.006270647,
0.365055114,
-0.6675286889,
0.3348940611,
-0.685202539,
-0.3822933733,
-0.2156252563,
0.0495078489,
-0.7064401507,
0.146847859,
0.2880138457,
0.2249357104,
-0.1579480767,
0.4189506471,
-0.0089548808,
-0.0652304068,
0.2208613008,
-0.4609648585,
0.8204107285,
0.2207973152,
-0.5928500891,
-0.0518093333,
-0.5382525325,
-0.2133864909,
0.108576633,
-0.1842709184,
-0.4436626434,
-0.0929194465,
-0.358626157,
0.2370357215,
0.3201996386,
-0.0863732174,
0.3620984852,
-0.1025086343,
0.5170736909,
0.6393187046,
-0.202119723,
0.7782837152,
-0.1317332834,
0.2992563248,
0.6442005038,
-0.0584615394,
-0.1088143587,
-0.2871467769,
-0.7977925539,
-0.2562594712,
0.5797945261,
0.4960492551,
-0.7052007318,
0.6150944829,
-0.5402310491,
-0.4753299057,
-1.0649991035,
0.3084653914,
0.3141068816,
1.2069549561,
0.6757685542,
-0.1000429839,
-0.3630800843,
-0.7836992145,
-0.1533459723,
0.2741327882,
0.0859385207,
-0.1624782532,
0.0925132558,
-0.0340744779,
1.0010020733,
-0.8209634423,
-0.6730669737,
0.0792908743,
-0.0706559941,
-0.019056987,
0.5013682246,
0.6394606233,
-0.7012143731,
-0.9027570486,
0.0925253406,
-0.6415188313,
-0.0584983267,
-0.0485203937,
-0.5386071801,
-0.081172578,
0.4407456815,
-0.416185081,
0.200560376,
0.450702399,
-0.1255247146,
-0.1637966186,
-0.0490035787,
0.1202546805,
-1.4229961634,
0.0670595616,
-0.026936233,
-0.2145894319,
-0.4629018009,
-0.1104755104,
0.2521129251,
0.0183482934,
-0.2863970995,
0.1848632544,
-0.4937163889,
-0.0205946211,
-0.5097903609,
0.3874275088,
0.2451054901,
0.5681988001,
-0.0653895587,
0.6801185608,
0.6144926548,
-0.4276058376,
0.4608753622,
0.4774062932,
-0.3090436161,
0.905872345,
-0.3815020919,
0.2378388047,
-0.0759409145,
-0.0393203907,
-1.2579709291,
0.155946061,
0.0567257963,
-0.4446538389,
0.5829741359,
-0.1609677672,
-0.0271052402,
-0.4742643237,
0.0150852604,
0.5887406468,
0.7022725344,
-0.7539426088,
0.6783129573,
0.1230947301,
-0.0606974401,
-0.7932448983,
-0.7584006786,
0.040741697,
-0.586151123,
-0.4156175852,
0.6003864408,
0.1518649757,
0.0284305681,
0.2763744295,
-0.455199331,
-0.1662930101,
0.3349539042,
-0.0921125039,
0.2839125991,
-0.4034649432,
-0.1711686701,
0.208262518,
-0.2769627273,
0.0617835149,
-0.6545707583,
0.4078288376,
0.3745686114,
-0.2221850902,
-0.4776942134,
0.0606595911,
0.7539964318,
-0.2592394054,
0.7175782919,
0.7637081146,
-0.3119931519,
-0.1003257111,
-0.442953229,
-0.3408575654,
-0.5079419613,
0.4333475828,
-0.2874754071,
-0.3507444561,
0.4055519998,
-0.2225899994,
0.1298820227,
0.3518587351,
0.5006982684,
-0.3369213641,
0.947134912,
0.5238764882,
-0.3289292753,
0.4209689498,
-0.3528827429,
0.3250448108,
-1.0260483027,
-0.2722527683,
-0.4566250443,
-1.3797694445,
-0.2557686865,
-0.2794164121,
0.3578748107,
0.3200782537,
-0.0675207824,
0.5905476809,
-0.9478224516,
0.5411353707,
0.571582675,
0.1016809791,
0.2284589708,
-0.0292125903,
-0.0196718965,
-0.2629929781,
-0.6090710759,
-0.1347423196,
1.1372802258,
0.0604983494,
0.5195837021,
0.1138174459,
0.7422301173,
-0.1569532454,
0.2072734833,
-1.0603038073,
0.2591287196,
-0.1963865757,
-0.3388502002,
-0.4015359282,
-0.1536519974,
-0.7134590149,
0.2656191587,
0.0973618701,
-0.3167613149,
0.1818959564,
0.3272780478,
-0.4471391439,
0.104366079,
-0.9579631686,
1.049428463,
-0.4132654369,
-0.2635160387,
0.0149725508,
-0.8208585382,
0.1395583153,
-0.195934996,
-0.1618787497,
0.1487257779,
0.0817283541,
0.4109937251,
-0.2040013969,
0.462300688,
-0.4780891538,
-0.1832501739,
0.1351807415,
-0.1999890506,
0.3939914703,
-0.2232078761,
0.1384996474,
0.0824738964,
-0.3271823227,
-0.3046545088,
-0.94309479,
0.6941863894,
-0.8423554301,
-0.9242442846,
-0.2511252463,
-0.9255341291,
-0.1328097135,
0.1510393322,
0.260717541,
0.0135559458,
0.221159488,
0.3038211763,
0.9342409372,
0.3653742969,
0.5634896159,
0.4273916483,
-0.0565021187,
-0.5526148677,
0.9616584778,
0.3167156279,
0.4397599995,
0.4319016635,
0.2679981887,
-0.4509898722,
-0.5832816958,
-0.6740103364,
-0.3168593943,
-0.5595433712,
-0.4603780806,
-0.5478222966,
-0.4379101992,
-0.4857419431,
-0.1275616735,
-0.4839043915,
-0.4559625685,
-0.2038515657,
0.0228385366,
0.3520328403,
0.1112024561,
0.1899752319,
0.5345971584,
-0.545339644,
0.3591773212,
0.465521872,
0.0811035931,
0.0067705391,
-0.9516379833,
-0.3815397918,
0.118012704,
-0.821824789,
-0.71064502,
0.1224382371,
0.3499689698,
0.4246248007,
0.4700585604,
0.2020993829,
1.025762558,
-0.7207721472,
0.3009581268,
0.2021623552,
-0.8349166512,
0.4945217073,
0.1646825522,
0.4931150377,
0.8145846128,
0.6029961705,
-0.4268078506,
-0.3100281358,
-0.38173002,
-0.9250673652,
0.6789484024,
0.0680758953,
-0.0289977491,
0.4059402347,
0.3269955814,
0.0821330696,
0.3200592101,
-0.3079150915,
-0.4629479647,
-0.2760730088,
-0.9387311339,
-0.0299286917,
0.1467343271,
-0.3314220607,
-0.4604553878,
0.6350174546,
-0.2560580373,
-0.0547001101,
0.0354241282,
-0.2443397939,
0.0588866845,
-0.0746218339,
0.47522524,
0.5478579998,
-0.0311324727,
0.3694670796,
0.0766178817,
-0.576823175,
0.3066675961,
0.3019355237,
-0.1897618473,
-0.2103412598,
-0.0234569702,
0.8529846072,
0.1967763603,
-0.0555262752,
0.4369256198,
0.0751112178,
-0.3746286631,
0.0902217403,
0.2255133986,
0.4603401124,
0.5847423673,
0.3338733613,
0.327134639,
0.1343722939,
-0.1950033158,
0.2019080222,
0.2507926524,
-0.5434615016,
-0.130339995,
0.8386611938,
0.1895362884,
-0.3659648001,
0.7558150887,
0.0480723977,
-0.5849667788,
0.6232689023,
0.599491477,
1.0571269989,
-0.6079986095,
-0.0965791196,
0.3705939353,
0.1843633205,
-0.1835581511,
-0.0757922679,
-0.2048372924,
-0.6798582077,
-0.157556057,
-0.5303171277,
-0.0660282671,
-0.080159314,
-0.9588006139,
0.3897749484,
-0.0713517666,
-0.1397258788,
0.418990761,
-0.2289991081,
-0.5764684677,
0.0838551149,
0.0695315897,
0.5517151952,
-0.7768432498,
1.0015158653,
0.7266675234,
-0.2222103775,
-0.6761456132,
0.2099566162,
-0.0033700743,
-0.7477271557,
0.5671904683,
0.1464642882,
0.2344413102,
0.5083095431,
-0.0996311978,
-0.7857574821,
1.6225367785,
0.5950144529,
-0.9846428037,
-0.1678025872,
0.3806022704,
0.357147783,
-0.2968797088,
0.0219494756,
0.7981773019,
0.4715608358,
0.3689661026,
-0.7279018164,
-0.0866991207,
0.1797135174,
0.1003925428,
0.4193557799,
-0.6346196532,
0.4546666741,
-0.2199890167,
-0.0900714695,
-0.4958814681,
0.7319537997,
-0.0802175105,
0.2581422627,
0.600831449,
1.0804692507,
0.7319352031,
-0.3897766471,
0.3571347594,
-0.4784595668,
0.3313655853,
1.3383327723,
-0.275326401,
0.5692746043,
0.9885047674,
-0.1799349338,
0.2237949669,
0.3831267059,
-0.0866837054,
1.0547463894,
0.0904751644,
-0.0951265767,
0.0025520422,
0.1649401933,
-0.3241474926,
0.3935272992,
0.1229235306,
-0.4294896424,
-0.2429155409,
0.1798089445,
-0.2505174875,
0.3940969408,
-0.1041826233,
1.2273904085,
0.1277702451,
-1.0365298986,
0.676687479,
-0.2866849303,
0.4173883796,
-0.2411499619,
0.054390464,
-0.2785818875,
0.6345601678,
-0.1604212373,
-0.7071087956,
0.5609531403,
-0.1861907393,
-0.5716238618,
-0.3837703764,
0.3498946428,
-1.1494692564,
-0.3793268204,
0.1210527346,
0.1517059058,
-0.2775641978,
-0.1440988481,
-0.7050591707,
-0.1178800762,
0.0242626946,
-0.0934168994,
0.4890031219,
0.7331941128,
0.1628879458,
0.3657824695,
0.1816989928,
-0.2377292961,
0.1300109476,
-0.0387698896,
0.8693646789,
-0.2144725174,
-0.2365935296,
-1.1188760996,
0.8219242692,
-0.1016351059,
-0.238670826,
0.4713363647,
0.6056421995,
0.8523529768,
-0.0651022717,
0.5575761795,
0.0161549766,
0.1924665123,
-0.3697374463,
0.8769971132,
-0.4029452503,
0.155531317,
0.0471717678,
-1.278101325,
0.2248937637,
0.5556538701,
-0.0653411523,
-0.2335536182,
0.8228711486,
0.5357916355,
-0.3471431136,
-0.2576697469,
0.2202727944,
0.1233968511,
0.2407735139,
0.6389884353,
0.4877408445,
-0.733982861,
0.6003921628,
-0.4709361494,
-0.1915467381,
-0.0857561454,
-0.7922353745,
-0.7507060766,
-0.7372258306,
-0.7561106086,
-0.3286168873,
0.0019589523,
0.6696007252,
0.4266808629,
-0.6964758039,
0.0271929577,
-0.0386318639,
0.1710881293,
-0.681360364,
-0.1969199479,
0.49192518,
-0.7205358744,
-0.9774312973,
0.1190149337,
0.1895283014,
0.0792973936,
-0.1924077123,
-0.0117971031,
-0.1010817811,
-0.1684774011,
0.2982258797,
-0.2281872928,
-0.5168527961,
-0.1307681203,
0.0915036649,
-0.3046088219,
0.2307291329,
0.5816649199,
-0.5595266819,
0.4879131317,
0.2902870774,
1.230830431,
0.44583565,
0.1560492814,
0.4736410081,
-0.9698892236,
0.1974506527,
-0.0125619164,
0.1034460291,
0.3509116173,
-0.4013441205,
0.3872562647,
0.1281990856,
-0.6082689762,
-0.7117661238,
-0.1431511194,
-1.0349291563,
0.0581573918,
0.7756217122,
-0.3219542205,
-0.2924734056,
0.1784876883,
-0.3263820112,
0.5310130715,
-0.072898306,
1.206314683,
0.889873147,
0.3212328255,
0.0027545621,
-0.4081005454,
0.5543922186,
0.5324685574,
-0.5373601317,
0.0776855424,
0.0773635879,
0.3504729569,
0.3534640372,
0.091537714,
-0.0463473573,
0.1034821346,
-0.2560766339,
-0.0014770399,
-0.2285682112,
-0.5503752232,
-0.1456225216,
-0.031484548,
-0.0027209818,
-0.7079805136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12984v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12984v2
|
When SMILES have Language: Drug Classification using Text Classification Methods on Drug SMILES Strings
| 2024-03-03T11:09:32 | 2024-03-27T21:51:03 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Šerbetar Karlo, Raima Islam, Taki Hasan Rafi, Dong-Kyu Chae
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Complex chemical structures, like drugs, are usually defined by SMILES
strings as a sequence of molecules and bonds. These SMILES strings are used in
different complex machine learning-based drug-related research and
representation works. Escaping from complex representation, in this work, we
pose a single question: What if we treat drug SMILES as conventional sentences
and engage in text classification for drug classification? Our experiments
affirm the possibility with very competitive scores. The study explores the
notion of viewing each atom and bond as sentence components, employing basic
NLP methods to categorize drug types, proving that complex problems can also be
solved with simpler perspectives. The data and code are available here:
https://github.com/azminewasi/Drug-Classification-NLP.
|
[
-0.0421435647,
-0.8136464357,
0.7977498174,
-0.0388235375,
0.0251528267,
0.4186662138,
-0.5375989676,
-0.8270725608,
0.2471702099,
0.3250948787,
-0.5798067451,
-0.7220504284,
-0.6325743198,
0.3348083794,
-0.1455084831,
1.2559280396,
0.0725404024,
0.3709405661,
-0.4282391071,
-0.1832690388,
0.0348472856,
-0.2903788686,
-0.5426349044,
-0.6085942984,
0.8263943791,
0.4292366207,
0.6528119445,
0.4928970039,
0.7523186207,
0.4394737482,
-0.1153720394,
-0.0652224645,
0.1194583327,
0.0454934873,
-0.1302298307,
-1.1660957336,
-0.3810074329,
0.0060182274,
-0.0150662493,
0.8829010129,
-0.0993601233,
-0.0927664712,
-0.2993908823,
0.6888440251,
-0.4392834902,
0.3495608568,
-0.328558892,
0.3941122591,
-0.4138219953,
-0.2237915844,
-0.4104299247,
-0.4647085369,
0.2978973389,
-0.4580146968,
-0.0018080245,
0.2240043432,
1.0728253126,
-0.1446212679,
-0.8252384067,
-0.8096976876,
-0.5768868923,
0.693808198,
-0.6830337644,
-0.0137987332,
-0.0099339252,
0.5776134729,
-0.5988883972,
-0.8846210837,
-0.7559894323,
-0.3984455764,
-0.1337437481,
-0.0757017061,
0.0992948413,
0.5251963735,
0.1185860336,
0.7303944826,
-0.7923963666,
-0.1223210767,
-0.3620216548,
-0.195050925,
0.429433614,
-0.081363596,
0.9876981974,
-0.4061088264,
-0.6121635437,
0.0393995754,
-0.5773652792,
0.0815774202,
0.0307464413,
0.6819323897,
0.1819614768,
1.0398037434,
0.0695893615,
0.5907843113,
-0.2172600925,
-0.2813047469,
0.4673956633,
-0.0148651004,
-0.3541671932,
0.53990978,
0.8271835446,
0.4066573679,
0.5917724967,
-0.0674023703,
-0.1995386779,
0.4506592751,
0.2314737886,
-0.6498873234,
-0.1990428716,
0.511731863,
-0.4394177198,
-0.1977605373,
0.0279929079,
-0.6812059879,
-0.4147766531,
-0.2819125652,
0.5915218592,
-0.3999084234,
0.1483179182,
0.2984828353,
-0.4358521402,
0.2104132026,
0.0896560773,
-0.8764978647,
0.8769435287,
0.6224327087,
0.7933667302,
-0.2643053532,
0.0074037979,
-0.3354269862,
-0.1749912947,
-0.1033585146,
1.0513221025,
-0.3928135633,
-0.3152604103,
0.0755933002,
0.1049597785,
-0.1111002862,
-0.7544145584,
0.4333817661,
-0.2180285603,
0.518188417,
-0.1938735545,
-0.7347835302,
-0.1625971645,
0.0914298967,
-0.4697265923,
0.2905090749,
0.2902118266,
-0.7644399405,
0.300029099,
-0.7223528028,
-0.764813602,
0.1143785715,
-0.3056076765,
-0.4604261518,
0.1012430117,
-0.3322547674,
0.1321060658,
0.0301873796,
0.1232229024,
-0.3781397939,
-0.2720091641,
0.7600575089,
0.0450790487,
0.7579131126,
0.6696035862,
-0.5417804122,
0.184382081,
-0.7122765183,
0.0057089343,
-0.184231028,
-0.5999830365,
-0.2840772271,
-0.131790325,
0.5131773353,
0.2938039601,
0.2273798436,
-0.7239123583,
0.5857938528,
-0.6175498366,
0.4093430042,
0.5334278345,
0.0844107196,
0.417763412,
-0.1452729702,
0.3954545259,
0.015746763,
-0.0082343882,
0.0034408569,
-0.7219669223,
-0.82994169,
-0.1638423204,
0.4481776059,
0.7947197556,
-0.5294182301,
0.4155518413,
-0.0790244788,
-0.1134631932,
-0.3145866096,
0.117150493,
0.3874870241,
0.2577193379,
0.3711460531,
-0.1566585749,
-0.4627301395,
-0.8886227012,
-0.6236141324,
-0.1599463373,
-0.036120221,
0.327940464,
0.555706799,
-0.2510069609,
0.7073326111,
-0.9168658853,
-0.4867037833,
-0.2863394916,
0.4033737481,
0.050655093,
0.2160663605,
0.4695941508,
-0.9776275754,
-0.3880407512,
0.2139433473,
-0.7891042233,
0.0946779922,
-0.1907591075,
0.0454512723,
0.1060431749,
0.530189693,
-0.8337755203,
0.0674805939,
0.0144879874,
-0.5496483445,
0.0364754163,
-0.1213278025,
0.4433861077,
-0.9317651987,
-0.151295647,
0.3538442552,
-0.4494824409,
-0.6809253693,
-0.1141927391,
-0.2444698811,
-0.2605911493,
-0.4080092907,
0.2375812978,
-0.2683445811,
-0.0494319275,
-0.3324919045,
0.0246811714,
-0.0082315654,
0.3640762866,
0.0094700782,
0.4081160426,
0.6067928672,
-0.4487276673,
0.3661552668,
-0.0384841971,
-0.367942065,
0.7241691351,
-0.3088208139,
-0.3198637962,
-0.074044317,
0.2457525134,
-1.034742713,
-0.7143554688,
0.239770487,
-0.48281762,
0.6587393284,
0.2236561924,
-0.5245451331,
-0.5394060612,
-0.2950204015,
-0.1667129993,
0.4828264117,
-0.1767178178,
0.3202912211,
0.4432763755,
-0.0459458306,
-0.4249407649,
-0.9991037846,
0.0321683288,
-0.3693180978,
-0.3449882567,
0.4684827924,
0.0019381102,
-0.3865790367,
0.0914726779,
-0.2957088649,
-0.3279765248,
0.1041638106,
0.3504512906,
0.0605748072,
-0.2036547959,
0.4301208556,
0.338958472,
0.1861426532,
0.1014696136,
-0.0057600308,
0.458093524,
-0.3555775881,
0.1056058779,
-0.3707017303,
0.5103616714,
0.7630898952,
0.0305651296,
0.6239114404,
0.3545201421,
-0.4262626171,
-0.2951953113,
0.2439533919,
-0.0838272646,
-0.5078839064,
0.1281333268,
-0.3172376454,
-0.8342969418,
0.3334307969,
-0.3384869993,
-0.4602597356,
0.2251733243,
0.4527864754,
-0.5018476248,
0.8154259324,
0.5508255363,
0.3742052913,
0.3004804254,
0.0419467762,
0.3152871728,
-0.3102306426,
-0.6359249353,
-0.3418660462,
-0.3036525249,
-0.6803146005,
-0.1224664524,
0.2669762969,
0.1042231172,
-0.2201605737,
0.405649364,
-0.5144477487,
0.538880527,
0.2171617746,
0.2836454213,
0.087499693,
-0.0136894435,
0.1593272835,
0.0501186363,
-0.223993659,
-0.4628756344,
0.8040295243,
0.3045080304,
0.5412808657,
0.0530421026,
0.8967500925,
0.5465196371,
0.2979159653,
-1.1178871393,
0.707243979,
-0.3254023194,
-0.6868460178,
0.1461425871,
-0.5868420601,
-1.1090962887,
-0.1308668256,
-0.3659365475,
-0.857191205,
0.197224021,
-0.2056807578,
-0.3052534461,
0.0435419418,
-0.9509947896,
0.8852112293,
-0.1823716909,
0.3843738735,
-0.0509471297,
-1.032381773,
0.3516533673,
0.224418819,
0.3234060407,
-0.1131701544,
0.1861366034,
0.6484609246,
-0.5476238132,
0.5407617092,
0.0931337625,
-0.0066117006,
0.534285903,
-0.0771425143,
-0.2196689397,
-0.4198814631,
0.4763128161,
-0.3538042605,
0.0035432938,
-0.3708625734,
-0.9485729337,
0.9254834652,
-0.5440099835,
-0.2091590464,
-0.6959722042,
-0.0841895714,
-0.1816593111,
0.2755413353,
0.3067936301,
0.4563346207,
0.1230123788,
-0.1562129557,
0.7334794998,
-0.2963436246,
0.3595323861,
0.1679047644,
-0.5212935805,
-0.3077020347,
0.98957932,
0.2283656597,
0.3436460793,
0.7233700156,
0.218744725,
-0.2839622796,
-0.1628140956,
-0.0348634534,
0.2724785805,
-0.8294125795,
-0.2357856333,
-0.5088375211,
0.0231386367,
-0.4701337516,
0.0288534891,
-0.2666609585,
-0.5801633596,
-0.1051675677,
-0.2738879323,
0.6465578079,
0.7675508261,
0.0706416517,
0.2391319126,
-0.7874789834,
0.533005476,
0.3601304889,
0.5628062487,
-0.4264854491,
0.3541404903,
-0.0639447421,
-0.1265698969,
-0.1752355695,
-1.092805028,
0.1482430249,
0.4981273413,
0.4145174325,
0.2575961053,
0.0449993871,
0.2959961593,
-0.565184474,
0.7239586711,
0.2335211337,
-0.9750433564,
0.9317910671,
-0.420194149,
0.1437959671,
0.6147296429,
0.7030367255,
-0.573785007,
-0.4629127681,
-0.3850157857,
-0.865018785,
0.3988685906,
0.4549064636,
0.0152474446,
-0.3410001695,
0.5054501295,
-0.2115960419,
0.3626847565,
-0.74998492,
-0.8056228757,
-0.08856415,
-0.8069040179,
0.2046312243,
0.0321063399,
-0.1024496257,
0.0447368324,
0.0298033003,
0.0728619024,
0.4006611109,
0.3866611719,
-0.2719792128,
-0.0253274664,
0.7327445745,
0.413374871,
0.1927181035,
-0.5432406664,
0.441347599,
-0.383951664,
-0.7210457325,
0.3150344789,
-0.1828614622,
0.1448489279,
-0.1030469909,
0.3194206655,
0.3203656375,
0.1162688807,
-1.0353293419,
0.3373116255,
-0.042577967,
0.0910642743,
0.0329415798,
0.4367849231,
0.0465372875,
0.3695125282,
0.0967901796,
0.4188908041,
0.7976077795,
-1.4062199593,
0.6367384195,
0.043039877,
-0.7135756612,
-0.1583485752,
0.2661792338,
-0.0984206274,
-0.5966365933,
0.4855858088,
-0.1068798229,
-0.6876407862,
0.4665459991,
0.6252607107,
0.7935650945,
-0.3201783299,
0.5393020511,
0.1548092961,
-0.3576583564,
-0.0794767514,
0.3222492039,
0.0860794112,
-0.4605033398,
-0.1316591054,
-0.6063787341,
-0.0969232991,
-0.2005602419,
-0.6741881967,
0.2959697247,
-0.5812593699,
-0.2870029509,
0.5374050736,
0.1122792959,
-0.0547384657,
0.502815783,
0.6145120859,
0.5648891926,
-1.0806194544,
0.6871653795,
0.8839232922,
-0.5073785186,
-0.368037343,
-0.1110526472,
0.1877679974,
-0.081356518,
0.5346025825,
0.5473711491,
-0.2732515931,
-0.3491896391,
-0.9342649579,
-0.4065473378,
0.6918403506,
-0.1191152409,
-0.2917160392,
-0.0514484271,
0.1619907022,
0.8962342143,
-0.4354249835,
-0.0200987812,
0.4427591264,
0.3964613676,
0.1849296093,
-0.7734440565,
-0.0051987679,
-0.6438993812,
-0.1873093098,
0.1294718385,
-0.2353525013,
1.1243243217,
-0.2499103546,
-0.4765601158,
-0.0018020453,
0.6875548959,
0.2592875361,
0.5286923647,
0.4416237772,
0.3968907595,
1.0148404837,
-0.294955492,
1.2115073204,
0.2415817231,
0.5841769576,
0.7940490842,
-0.1225959286,
0.89323318,
0.4798003435,
-0.4647823572,
1.1044511795,
0.8630321622,
-0.1571796834,
0.6891195774,
0.6842768192,
-0.3821127117,
-0.1208262742,
-0.0373436548,
-0.0012365018,
0.3984373212,
0.6659606099,
-0.0130118951,
-0.2202227116,
0.7583512664,
0.2266556472,
0.3352456093,
-0.3007571101,
0.6850685477,
0.5137240887,
-0.4748057425,
0.1044971123,
-0.0646940842,
0.5232342482,
-0.4984003603,
-0.1965656132,
0.0362337455,
0.5116376877,
-0.3967963457,
-1.0722851753,
0.2128790021,
-0.2690186501,
-0.0892428234,
0.2673451602,
0.6329342127,
-0.6812301278,
-0.2543968856,
0.0679315999,
-0.1127386764,
0.1507862359,
0.0782167837,
-0.7372928262,
-0.3096539378,
0.023442667,
-0.2125621885,
0.4543393254,
0.5556351542,
0.0508573726,
0.9512268901,
0.3941129744,
0.0000029054,
0.0681920126,
0.0023661817,
0.643258214,
-0.9586295485,
-0.1815014482,
-0.7823509574,
0.4524387121,
-0.1444677263,
-0.3306919932,
0.9034613967,
0.6618226767,
0.441427201,
-0.2535318136,
0.3720027506,
0.0633559451,
0.3354817629,
-0.5172657371,
0.723074913,
-0.7512242794,
0.1255116612,
-0.4531140029,
-0.6976438165,
-0.9164671898,
0.7096899748,
0.1614341289,
-0.1685069501,
0.9063820243,
0.4178154171,
0.2218844891,
0.0005042567,
-0.2592361271,
0.1161466613,
0.3372958302,
0.5817503929,
0.6255341768,
-0.585179925,
0.1364085674,
0.000005862,
0.0441729836,
-0.2794570625,
-0.3010643423,
-0.8499728441,
-0.4904872179,
-0.5187699199,
-0.8992241025,
-0.1539870501,
1.2411829233,
0.145314455,
-0.963401258,
-0.4194533825,
-0.3804741204,
0.5131433606,
0.1065591425,
-0.2976876199,
0.4091213048,
-0.5621315837,
-0.6830968857,
0.1989860982,
0.467045188,
0.3967799246,
-0.2330786288,
0.1666072756,
-0.3648467064,
0.2204483449,
0.6172651052,
0.3424185514,
-0.5003945231,
-0.0013211085,
0.3019477427,
-0.5553227663,
0.4480588138,
0.9838975668,
-0.5912076235,
0.7129340172,
0.5954040885,
-0.0128821768,
0.4864721894,
-0.2687138319,
0.7052064538,
-0.4815849364,
-0.0925845578,
0.3105672598,
0.2520029843,
0.3202901185,
-0.2637588978,
0.1401832551,
0.1161305606,
-0.4435613751,
-0.9133800268,
0.3479405642,
-1.7016658783,
-0.8711916804,
0.9952768087,
-0.2867022753,
-0.9784010053,
-0.1964707971,
-0.320199579,
0.2667095065,
-0.3321224153,
0.5731115937,
0.5744660497,
-0.282746166,
-0.1382533461,
-0.3239910007,
0.860008657,
-0.2490757406,
-1.0379327536,
-0.3064977825,
0.1993758678,
0.1955614239,
0.7176423669,
0.4575660229,
-0.280372262,
-0.0290203951,
0.0584107228,
0.0559588932,
0.6648923159,
-0.4275957942,
-0.0576393344,
0.153378278,
-0.0373954736,
-0.0931340829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01472v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01472v2
|
WARDEN: Multi-Directional Backdoor Watermarks for Embedding-as-a-Service Copyright Protection
| 2024-03-03T10:39:27 | 2024-06-09T04:34:55 |
Anudeex Shetty, Yue Teng, Ke He, Qiongkai Xu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Embedding as a Service (EaaS) has become a widely adopted solution, which
offers feature extraction capabilities for addressing various downstream tasks
in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Prior studies have shown that EaaS can be
prone to model extraction attacks; nevertheless, this concern could be
mitigated by adding backdoor watermarks to the text embeddings and subsequently
verifying the attack models post-publication. Through the analysis of the
recent watermarking strategy for EaaS, EmbMarker, we design a novel CSE
(Clustering, Selection, Elimination) attack that removes the backdoor watermark
while maintaining the high utility of embeddings, indicating that the previous
watermarking approach can be breached. In response to this new threat, we
propose a new protocol to make the removal of watermarks more challenging by
incorporating multiple possible watermark directions. Our defense approach,
WARDEN, notably increases the stealthiness of watermarks and has been
empirically shown to be effective against CSE attack.
|
[
-0.5651656389,
-0.6026477218,
0.4100997448,
0.5919271708,
-0.2675796151,
0.4025300443,
0.1011473313,
-0.4801960289,
0.4148876667,
0.7213560343,
-0.4819122851,
-0.6869969964,
-1.0825151205,
0.1301878691,
-0.6463002563,
0.5340824723,
0.1144325212,
0.1639252901,
0.2275262326,
-0.2658080161,
-0.7413535118,
-0.4362174571,
-0.9649696946,
0.2130303979,
0.6149161458,
0.1224848256,
0.5627154708,
0.6794736981,
0.3605808318,
0.2298603952,
-0.0087920222,
-0.1993276179,
-0.0812209174,
0.4822215438,
-0.2622571886,
-0.2132835835,
-0.2252861857,
0.0960943252,
0.5340209007,
0.0389906503,
-0.0153916618,
-0.1157804281,
-0.0358042419,
0.7504853606,
-1.1153861284,
-0.2056540847,
-0.6381182075,
0.23359254,
-0.2078194916,
-0.0453621596,
-0.5411316752,
-0.1674447805,
0.1531323791,
-0.6042052507,
-0.1685741246,
0.2702713311,
0.8950659633,
0.1485537738,
-0.0451405048,
-0.2223354876,
-0.4278791547,
0.8541911244,
-0.3303242922,
0.3784913719,
0.3477891088,
0.5479259491,
0.1069663465,
-0.6059781909,
-0.2399879694,
0.3204474449,
0.1674879193,
0.2498310804,
-0.6285189986,
-0.568118155,
0.1517932564,
0.0260060504,
-0.2462619245,
0.1763853431,
0.0142431706,
-0.2333017886,
0.7326429486,
-0.068081215,
0.4700064063,
0.0459004045,
-0.6460167766,
-0.1478625089,
-0.9535080194,
0.1793211251,
0.6082074046,
0.036264576,
0.08515127,
0.342205286,
0.1727568805,
0.0166404899,
0.1818237007,
0.4171000719,
-0.0033002514,
0.2918488383,
0.1028313264,
0.310885936,
0.604772985,
0.3855726421,
-0.1435689777,
-0.6220204234,
-0.4194779694,
-0.0676919222,
0.4994513392,
-0.9286733866,
-0.0093102958,
0.4629641771,
-0.5584997535,
-0.5455363989,
0.5169046521,
-0.9669569135,
-0.4785563052,
0.1171494722,
0.4311071634,
-0.4374008477,
-0.2096081972,
-0.0784396827,
-0.6422322989,
0.7355386615,
0.0814416707,
-0.5706381798,
0.419960916,
0.8374364376,
0.8306355476,
-0.363586098,
-0.2253033966,
-1.0256459713,
0.8933586478,
-0.2068742216,
0.9307751656,
-0.880294323,
-0.668399334,
-0.0303240847,
0.293374747,
0.1825395823,
-0.3295309842,
0.0408856347,
-1.0119234324,
-0.1601986289,
-0.4256683886,
-0.5268310905,
-0.1950839013,
0.256367296,
-0.882116437,
0.5443629026,
-0.3572477698,
-0.563609302,
0.2582856119,
-0.6572416425,
-0.3108535707,
0.0793866366,
-0.3960094154,
-0.6562989354,
-0.0533895455,
0.6168370247,
0.3234499395,
-0.0305842143,
-0.0671139359,
-0.4108401537,
-0.2464045733,
0.3346173763,
-0.3740068376,
0.8900072575,
0.0725270435,
-0.5927786231,
0.0286446363,
-0.6886677742,
0.0773484707,
0.0703599453,
-0.0492678545,
-0.5628838539,
0.1460548937,
-0.0815844759,
0.2140032798,
0.2493065596,
-0.8699080944,
0.0578916036,
-0.1374803931,
0.4216845334,
1.1343799829,
0.2831057012,
0.5833127499,
-0.106973432,
0.696151793,
0.042773284,
0.5660682917,
0.0425308645,
-0.8907444477,
-0.162112534,
-0.9864045978,
0.2297397256,
0.5053834915,
-0.6078639627,
0.5157781839,
0.1386178434,
-0.5938413739,
-0.4654546678,
0.1014970317,
0.6262996197,
-0.1792513281,
0.6650496721,
-0.392491281,
-0.2008846104,
-0.852527082,
-0.7014748454,
0.4967672825,
0.0371353701,
0.192511946,
0.2941296697,
-0.5164602399,
1.107601881,
-0.6332493424,
-0.4040708244,
0.1537900567,
0.0644050837,
-0.2747146189,
0.5617970824,
0.6632091999,
-0.9877647161,
-0.6824153662,
-0.2271689177,
-0.7361590862,
-0.271638751,
0.2799953818,
-0.1897567958,
0.0120383296,
0.6977444291,
-0.3645133376,
0.8063740134,
0.6598784328,
-0.4715793133,
0.5104131103,
0.0503641441,
0.0061087771,
-0.7416941524,
0.00712599,
-0.3026720881,
-0.0065276055,
-0.2854040563,
0.3521649241,
0.2110663056,
-0.6228994727,
-0.2497071326,
0.5125833154,
-0.5267381668,
-0.1872988641,
-0.3415222764,
0.0347882435,
0.106100142,
0.2928469777,
-0.1052276418,
0.5871955156,
0.9024833441,
-0.5161243081,
0.2002920359,
0.4125424922,
0.3446974158,
0.8186312318,
-0.7450374961,
0.4211239815,
-0.1575149149,
0.2496173829,
-0.7521947622,
0.5394418836,
0.2922175527,
-0.233967334,
0.3955209255,
-0.3790196776,
-0.2256858796,
0.0732801482,
-0.8522140384,
0.1559602618,
0.1138266772,
-0.78137362,
1.0427149534,
0.3311600089,
-0.1134936213,
-0.7587862015,
-0.6980851889,
0.3243771493,
-0.1970898211,
-0.6321130395,
0.8654114604,
-0.0937132835,
-0.1004311666,
0.2090689987,
-0.09964104,
-0.2476427108,
0.2706513703,
0.5016712546,
-0.0635717809,
-0.1208807081,
-0.4041057527,
0.2753753364,
-0.6761385202,
0.1344642937,
-0.1691828221,
0.4099031091,
-0.0355631299,
-0.6528844237,
-0.411698252,
1.0807250738,
0.3709101975,
-0.6411732435,
0.7578569055,
0.6677883863,
-0.4097721279,
-0.2119124979,
-0.4908795059,
-0.3583286107,
-0.5504406095,
-0.0427423306,
-0.2255665511,
-0.5619570613,
0.7497878671,
0.1196247265,
0.4063489735,
0.1661090404,
-0.1675838828,
0.0229855441,
1.160094142,
0.6629862785,
-0.1539571285,
0.652154386,
-0.4101208746,
0.5399369001,
-1.0436122417,
-0.2633982897,
-0.6903716326,
-0.293453753,
-0.5517590642,
0.0801594108,
0.0305309091,
0.2581246197,
-0.1300127059,
0.6427900195,
-0.4916067719,
0.310477823,
0.4137707055,
0.2152730227,
0.2885801196,
0.0653735846,
-0.1415403634,
-0.1413982064,
-0.2873176932,
-0.6273403168,
0.9558535814,
0.3328556716,
0.5559093356,
0.4716226459,
1.099942565,
0.3947241604,
0.4384445548,
-0.5738129616,
0.5462431908,
-0.1366516799,
-0.5513674617,
-0.3702056706,
-0.0196325444,
-0.9512327313,
0.349360317,
-0.1685420871,
-0.6638547778,
0.386954248,
-0.081414111,
-0.351459831,
0.3132317662,
-0.6202612519,
0.7026926875,
-0.0612416863,
-0.5958579183,
-0.3680227697,
-0.4155242741,
-0.3945459127,
-0.1478018016,
0.4152359962,
0.1077969447,
-0.3908150494,
0.7440285087,
-0.5631873608,
0.6722533107,
-0.6041321754,
-0.2386943251,
0.1075860411,
0.2608441114,
0.7929185629,
0.4100903869,
0.1791342348,
0.2331709415,
0.0167683922,
-0.5274181962,
-0.650142312,
0.6018704772,
-0.530924499,
-0.7093058228,
-0.5745810866,
0.0363123454,
-0.1991640329,
0.1986032724,
0.1759463698,
0.5756306052,
0.026036365,
0.2961316705,
0.6202168465,
-0.5071552992,
0.8821512461,
0.7817060351,
-0.020555513,
-0.6854076385,
0.8777341843,
0.0207608361,
0.0523253456,
0.2247968614,
0.3453370333,
-0.2336470485,
-0.6239094734,
-0.2562947571,
-0.0117804687,
-0.6161731482,
-0.1989119351,
-0.7464814782,
-0.409604907,
-0.2047610581,
-0.671642065,
-0.5071572661,
-0.0809307322,
-0.0124307508,
0.2067825496,
0.4573014081,
0.7344965339,
0.0114277257,
0.4206020832,
-0.8126195669,
0.3492656648,
0.5925288796,
0.3942528963,
0.0515837036,
-0.2482887506,
0.1106811091,
-0.1850293726,
-0.63022995,
-1.0533715487,
0.350489974,
-0.1076461077,
0.7509296536,
0.6464545131,
-0.2037926614,
0.4265113473,
-0.7701570988,
0.7458215356,
0.3363860548,
-0.956304431,
0.4717831016,
-0.1780908704,
-0.0416305587,
0.3216171861,
0.1780209541,
-0.2701115608,
-0.6253560185,
-0.7449815869,
-1.0415973663,
0.1623375863,
0.2157917321,
0.0749885887,
-0.032272961,
0.0336162522,
0.0976940989,
0.3423384726,
-0.5570433736,
-0.2876139879,
-0.4395224452,
0.1979742199,
0.2301527113,
-0.2120542526,
-0.1152947024,
-0.0526648276,
0.9425370097,
0.0644541159,
0.5175956488,
0.2414061427,
-0.203905493,
0.2073418945,
0.4154814482,
0.1413983107,
0.3426492214,
-0.0180673543,
0.0784406364,
-0.0934475884,
-0.6926458478,
0.0173489209,
-0.1149283648,
-0.3188874424,
-0.0777389556,
0.2725942731,
0.0748829246,
0.4892688394,
-0.1102382913,
1.0109347105,
-0.1080138385,
0.1542483866,
-0.4295733273,
-0.2186901867,
-0.0831768662,
0.2129047811,
0.6799742579,
0.2701034844,
0.0751749948,
-0.2700991035,
0.3515822887,
0.6375638843,
-0.6533152461,
-0.2008701712,
0.3385941386,
0.2258785218,
-0.3301697671,
0.0643463731,
-0.274627924,
-0.6661913991,
0.5880021453,
0.5655474663,
1.3893836737,
-0.3185603023,
0.1364865005,
-0.0600368045,
0.5635654926,
0.1184257418,
0.4109663665,
0.0919804201,
-0.6238943338,
-0.1093771309,
-0.3919118345,
-0.3129913211,
-0.0893522203,
-0.9630578756,
0.1945115179,
-0.9669777751,
0.0129752783,
0.0803359449,
-0.2376782596,
-0.5129926801,
-0.1998420805,
-0.1467358321,
0.8676372766,
-0.647736907,
0.5368390679,
0.4148887396,
-0.354370445,
-0.5813292265,
0.0550138801,
-0.0485123917,
-0.6256340146,
0.3302146494,
0.4410572946,
-0.4482406676,
0.2157260478,
-0.7460129857,
-0.6921128035,
1.0906786919,
0.2823731303,
-0.5043602586,
0.3380251527,
-0.3911196589,
0.184826985,
-0.3719526827,
-0.2356195301,
0.3249052763,
0.6728494763,
-0.5047136545,
-0.091878213,
0.4516003132,
-0.1353697181,
0.0892558023,
-0.0807049274,
-0.5361361504,
0.5503413677,
0.1875260174,
-0.2324738204,
-0.0052921576,
0.3510155082,
0.3501867652,
0.2623157203,
0.4223557413,
0.5889864564,
0.2990644276,
-0.0022333392,
0.9008852243,
-0.2483524531,
-0.0433294401,
0.7035306692,
-0.4991386235,
0.9897921085,
0.9076368809,
0.1466192007,
0.8286799192,
-0.0408878773,
-0.4478595555,
0.9382346272,
-0.0758614019,
-0.2364765853,
-0.0782624483,
0.0616620295,
-0.5448735952,
0.3962516189,
0.2114195079,
-0.3082287908,
-0.0840938985,
0.1461138874,
-0.0377472863,
0.3919981718,
-0.352635473,
0.7924861908,
0.240572691,
-0.1885479242,
-0.0921789259,
0.4063233733,
0.8168670535,
-0.738543272,
0.0276403762,
0.0569688454,
-0.0084359702,
-0.3684302568,
-0.6072646379,
0.4251849651,
0.0019843641,
-0.1868758947,
-0.3795931339,
0.6239464283,
-0.0612928271,
0.0070064869,
0.8755555749,
0.2044906616,
-0.1097013429,
-0.4239961803,
-0.9585616589,
0.1773793697,
-0.4788582921,
-0.2079642713,
0.255028218,
0.1601989269,
-0.1195474789,
0.7111796141,
0.8315767646,
0.247636348,
0.3380380571,
0.3378900588,
0.8560324311,
-0.6524522305,
-1.0963704586,
-0.9247174263,
0.1826398075,
-0.5532854199,
-0.0794184357,
1.1346315145,
0.5348721147,
0.3490693867,
-0.0798059329,
0.8292326927,
-0.012809583,
0.0998070091,
-0.4330302477,
0.9404727221,
-0.264600575,
0.2682156265,
-0.697042644,
-0.7843674421,
-0.1169114932,
0.4540574849,
-0.2621051967,
-0.181465745,
0.936461091,
1.026632905,
-0.0043152077,
0.4911668897,
0.199671343,
-0.2348289937,
0.6840920448,
0.3280428946,
0.9285683632,
-0.8030584455,
0.5358620882,
-0.2182377577,
-0.3099587262,
0.0855517983,
-1.1697033644,
-0.9151992202,
-0.319889456,
-0.4109702706,
-0.3526367247,
0.0750493854,
0.5316435695,
0.644613862,
-1.1780840158,
0.2419444919,
0.0215855557,
0.1359604895,
-0.78593117,
-0.2019452453,
0.3657476902,
-0.0011594587,
-0.2302606255,
0.4481742978,
0.6448308825,
0.0833505839,
-0.350128144,
-0.1767597497,
-0.2404694259,
0.035179317,
0.4439224303,
0.2145047933,
-0.5415764451,
-0.4196902812,
-0.1639130414,
-0.2630045414,
-0.2592428625,
0.9704179168,
-0.2882628143,
0.1698754877,
0.1399764866,
0.9745494127,
0.377063781,
-0.2841478288,
0.6570497155,
-0.9158777595,
0.3074552715,
0.1290273219,
0.3571694791,
0.2564149499,
-0.5253891945,
0.0962747186,
0.4447297454,
-0.0437524542,
-0.7310537696,
0.2936762273,
-0.7335605025,
-0.4741511047,
0.931175828,
-0.3953652978,
-0.384862572,
-0.4831233919,
-0.1831501424,
-0.2007521391,
-0.6242297292,
0.7973795533,
0.7087936997,
0.5038351417,
0.0892590433,
-0.3757389784,
0.4583226144,
0.3614324927,
-0.6217557788,
0.0676113218,
0.0082409894,
0.48057127,
0.3875206411,
0.2126958221,
-0.7067032456,
0.5478956103,
-0.0796269476,
-0.0639142096,
-0.3532065749,
-0.5512614846,
-0.5194948316,
0.3630431592,
-0.2219385207,
-0.3980567157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01469v2
|
KorMedMCQA: Multi-Choice Question Answering Benchmark for Korean Healthcare Professional Licensing Examinations
| 2024-03-03T10:31:49 | 2024-03-05T09:58:08 |
Sunjun Kweon, Byungjin Choi, Minkyu Kim, Rae Woong Park, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce KorMedMCQA, the first Korean multiple-choice question answering
(MCQA) benchmark derived from Korean healthcare professional licensing
examinations, covering from the year 2012 to year 2023. This dataset consists
of a selection of questions from the license examinations for doctors, nurses,
and pharmacists, featuring a diverse array of subjects. We conduct baseline
experiments on various large language models, including
proprietary/open-source, multilingual/Korean-additional pretrained, and
clinical context pretrained models, highlighting the potential for further
enhancements. We make our data publicly available on HuggingFace
(https://huggingface.co/datasets/sean0042/KorMedMCQA) and provide a evaluation
script via LM-Harness, inviting further exploration and advancement in Korean
healthcare environments.
|
[
-0.6127195954,
-0.4302923381,
0.7228658199,
0.2060957551,
-0.137569055,
0.1292333901,
0.1578135937,
-0.1999745667,
0.0948405191,
0.8018459678,
-0.6339054704,
-0.5153127909,
-0.3127345741,
0.0823352188,
0.4521017373,
0.7573112249,
-0.2336294055,
0.423799485,
-0.6091071367,
-0.5566274524,
-0.1225506067,
-0.592443049,
-0.4398646951,
-0.4158838987,
0.8901646137,
0.5000513196,
0.6482283473,
0.2969284952,
0.2877225876,
0.1261308193,
0.0562853292,
-0.0048763752,
-0.0106064864,
0.0839650407,
-0.0276733153,
-0.1338030845,
-0.5962439179,
0.2585826516,
0.4871245921,
0.7314934134,
-0.0696420372,
0.6206992865,
-0.3421172798,
0.8671673536,
-0.7687142491,
-0.2237471342,
-0.1359752864,
0.1009883285,
0.1643649191,
-0.105486609,
-0.189400211,
-0.8180006146,
0.1323329061,
-0.4067084491,
-0.2264141738,
-0.3025126457,
0.9209499955,
0.2049903125,
-1.0753276348,
-0.3752467334,
0.0132336207,
0.4693986475,
-0.4539914727,
0.9091300368,
0.3396145403,
0.8058891892,
0.0108912243,
-1.1122390032,
-0.4147820175,
-0.5899157524,
0.3400243819,
0.5364281535,
0.2226114124,
0.1375813335,
-0.0752765536,
0.2961224914,
-0.5050302744,
-0.0750081316,
-0.453347683,
-0.5343821049,
0.6974290013,
0.1156526729,
0.3565704525,
-0.1850756407,
-0.5313460827,
-0.0916267931,
-0.6553955078,
0.1599232405,
0.2998833358,
0.0017554786,
-0.0359148905,
0.7706729174,
-0.5627282858,
0.4919773638,
-0.1346771568,
-0.1871944219,
0.5455554128,
-0.5213375688,
-0.2938504815,
0.256410569,
0.7414852977,
0.7397525907,
0.0149640692,
-0.0111646745,
0.3097955883,
0.0616963096,
0.3280585706,
-0.6565065384,
-0.8014459014,
0.7422406077,
-0.5492835641,
-0.2923862338,
-0.1907911897,
-0.9845396876,
-0.5344785452,
-0.4199816585,
0.4240502417,
0.1415272504,
-0.4673335254,
0.2488860339,
0.133820504,
0.3374871314,
-0.0396367684,
-0.123171784,
0.4082208276,
0.4459907711,
0.5150079727,
-0.3926861882,
-0.1565371156,
-0.563054204,
-0.4647085369,
-0.5027733445,
0.6161779165,
-0.1599503607,
-0.4810455143,
-0.1947305202,
0.2789776921,
-0.1823329479,
-0.8443080187,
0.8487006426,
-0.6462624073,
0.1083257943,
-0.5605506897,
-0.4240287542,
0.1016534045,
0.4136539102,
-0.5780123472,
1.1112014055,
0.4828474224,
-0.7222889066,
0.4539556205,
-0.5294072628,
0.1070262045,
0.0633073375,
-0.2394584864,
-0.5387708545,
-0.2334314287,
0.4278251231,
0.4732134342,
0.0394501872,
0.2640417516,
-0.5090420246,
0.1671240926,
0.4878029227,
-0.245629251,
1.1153423786,
0.3235650957,
0.3851830959,
0.0443499945,
-0.9849674106,
0.6030272841,
0.0129581867,
-0.5162540078,
-0.1097714826,
-0.5375301838,
-0.1324284077,
0.9749893546,
0.0791838393,
-0.7523032427,
0.0628546476,
0.0482304767,
-0.0002614201,
0.384624064,
0.5476464033,
0.2097972333,
-0.4143570364,
1.1941120625,
0.1304813325,
0.322284162,
-0.0296962056,
-0.6942569613,
-0.271861732,
-0.5445347428,
0.6306342483,
0.6958600283,
-0.9949974418,
-0.1626617759,
-0.0039693918,
-0.8294401169,
-1.1625888348,
-0.189973101,
0.5759509206,
0.7969115376,
0.4149338603,
-0.0139938416,
-0.4143114388,
-0.930254519,
-0.3836343586,
-0.1137187257,
-0.0926231444,
0.5781491399,
0.4224139154,
-0.2039723545,
0.5221297741,
-0.6090748906,
0.1385319829,
-0.0182528142,
-0.2500946224,
0.132777676,
0.2794740498,
0.5280434489,
-0.8551616073,
-0.7167766094,
-0.0135667454,
-0.4078774154,
-0.4575885534,
0.0098649375,
-0.3770868778,
-0.2033436596,
0.6802100539,
-0.4199799597,
0.0706423894,
0.8363613486,
-0.4325417876,
1.2990956306,
-0.0594279952,
0.4558376968,
-1.1424794197,
0.1181900129,
-0.3112941086,
-0.3224709332,
-0.8103477955,
0.3173490763,
0.4561097026,
-0.0461766347,
-0.7752014399,
0.7002459764,
-0.3822193444,
-0.0429899953,
0.0449410006,
0.3139231801,
-0.0003784369,
0.2138406336,
-0.2162984014,
0.8147345185,
0.5270036459,
-0.8457145095,
0.3148135841,
0.3508884013,
-0.423037678,
0.9387361407,
-0.6984540224,
0.0641476884,
0.0244079288,
0.129091233,
-1.0180153847,
-0.4620888531,
0.4293572307,
-0.6853676438,
-0.1251305491,
-0.3483026922,
-0.2983724773,
-0.500014782,
0.0317304544,
0.3510734141,
0.3187921345,
-0.4784265161,
0.3090320826,
0.5169335008,
-0.3028061986,
-0.6718059182,
-0.4559425116,
-0.2853283286,
-0.1502512395,
-0.2025009543,
-0.0672755241,
-0.2699543834,
-0.0454067588,
-0.1949878037,
-0.3128888011,
-0.4133142531,
0.0193707813,
0.101382032,
0.5111369491,
-0.4669553339,
0.0618910901,
0.2773730457,
-0.0780236572,
0.562419951,
-0.1085538119,
0.3942176402,
-0.0534901917,
-0.4823637605,
-0.3404600322,
0.1973467618,
0.7546083331,
-0.2326702327,
0.4711589515,
0.5677962899,
-0.1550054699,
0.3430054486,
-0.3927378058,
0.224056825,
-0.509775877,
0.5018587708,
-0.5411957502,
-1.0308099985,
0.5300946236,
-0.2377010435,
-0.0648891181,
0.3619396389,
0.8602359295,
0.1000853106,
1.1442888975,
-0.1308169961,
0.3708032668,
-0.3918811679,
0.4088390768,
-0.0198901352,
-1.0420980453,
-0.4985155463,
-0.3951266408,
-0.0144921672,
-0.8457066417,
-0.5486275554,
0.5640838146,
0.1014299095,
-0.3976204991,
0.0537518859,
-0.469923377,
0.4389687479,
0.4251374602,
0.3568223119,
0.2517991066,
-0.6322248578,
-0.8889356852,
-0.1415683925,
-0.5442053676,
-0.4264236093,
1.435030818,
0.4406208992,
0.2238742411,
0.0061428109,
0.6727351546,
-0.1270981729,
0.4098837078,
-0.7203771472,
0.5390889645,
0.3478985131,
-0.7492126822,
0.0839332342,
-0.5482424498,
-0.7819236517,
0.4763948023,
0.0106344251,
-0.6196545362,
0.2724212408,
0.1528968662,
-0.3933950365,
0.0930481553,
-0.5477671623,
1.1015496254,
-0.0760117918,
-0.0163314641,
0.6290289164,
-0.7962734699,
0.611821413,
-0.1598315388,
-0.0930182263,
-0.4667847753,
-0.4976927638,
0.5437257886,
-0.120599933,
0.104135111,
-0.4283206761,
0.0265895203,
0.2488452494,
-0.0802124068,
-0.1068594679,
0.598690033,
-0.1047877446,
-0.0859790966,
0.7674591541,
-0.6327317357,
-0.4529005289,
0.5240197778,
-0.6402643323,
0.0373822711,
-0.3747483194,
-0.3873417974,
-0.8272233605,
0.3802361488,
0.2845303118,
0.3838960826,
-0.24117814,
0.0073446315,
0.8049792647,
-0.5632887483,
-0.227056995,
0.5514679551,
-0.7523933053,
-0.7135193944,
0.651232779,
0.1017069519,
0.6153204441,
-0.1259628683,
0.1657359302,
-0.7156811357,
-0.3009319901,
-0.6028934121,
0.2938632071,
-0.8923122287,
-0.0212050863,
-1.1374098063,
-0.4682434499,
-0.2377943695,
-0.0111334119,
-0.5713569522,
-0.3368776739,
-0.0599973463,
-0.0546114407,
0.0059819976,
0.3356572092,
0.2062665522,
0.1872264743,
-0.8435471058,
0.6491347551,
0.3419031501,
0.7617968321,
-0.2184397578,
-0.3037852943,
-0.0112080937,
0.0140715875,
-0.2992286086,
-0.9141885638,
0.0881291255,
-0.1274251342,
0.7557945251,
0.2624413967,
0.2965526879,
0.4580453634,
-0.6054669023,
0.9538941979,
0.1338216364,
-0.4746641219,
0.0989038423,
-0.3158112764,
0.8498523235,
1.0707868338,
0.9091923237,
-0.8277341723,
-0.1517399102,
-0.52595824,
-0.6354846358,
0.1843784153,
0.0128029231,
-0.0932991132,
-0.0181539264,
0.3296595812,
0.1886255443,
0.4076418877,
-0.3595149815,
-0.4856144488,
-0.077771239,
-0.1471216083,
-0.0112019926,
-0.272749722,
-0.0743589476,
-0.4306592643,
0.5702767372,
-0.0606088452,
0.4890475571,
0.391681999,
0.1467855871,
0.2121297419,
0.5196353793,
0.5380230546,
1.0471788645,
-0.098443374,
0.0382838435,
0.147088483,
-0.9465432763,
0.3211473227,
0.2284823507,
0.1531174779,
0.1956108212,
-0.2482171953,
0.3074329495,
0.1129483134,
-0.9518281817,
0.2912465632,
-0.1336822361,
-0.8522803783,
-0.1869795769,
-0.1882430315,
0.3902148008,
0.188478753,
-0.0047544404,
-0.2382572293,
0.1634661853,
-0.2241971791,
0.7067947984,
-0.0236977264,
-0.7962992787,
-0.0315283127,
0.8624555469,
-0.381852299,
0.0598204173,
0.5360253453,
-0.0769810081,
-0.6604880691,
0.6239181757,
0.3090802431,
0.5406051874,
-0.4727523625,
0.6360167265,
0.6086724401,
0.1230593324,
-0.0762337148,
0.9953391552,
0.2151300013,
-0.454503119,
-0.2269215435,
-0.3896929026,
-0.7135490775,
0.1811346859,
-1.1638038158,
0.0259204116,
-0.351726681,
-0.318213284,
0.060383331,
0.2452845871,
-0.5893115401,
0.478071779,
0.0038999356,
1.281896472,
-0.6002990007,
0.6248922944,
0.8907681108,
-0.1643698215,
-0.6821780801,
-0.1886972934,
0.0857475176,
-0.6297383904,
0.0361215249,
0.0795784369,
0.1484519839,
-0.1023458317,
-0.5555707216,
-0.6189633608,
1.0338257551,
0.0344981775,
-0.1416082829,
0.3741558194,
0.3821906149,
0.5149203539,
-0.4006530941,
-0.0955791846,
0.9297103882,
0.2347618639,
-0.0984085798,
-0.9255114794,
-0.076635696,
-0.3960036337,
-0.3266350627,
0.229499042,
-0.4175547659,
0.7521867156,
-0.0621670596,
0.1527507454,
0.1761506945,
0.2594020069,
0.8735192418,
0.8935365081,
0.3425768614,
0.4277437925,
0.9163699746,
-0.0700178444,
0.9916663766,
-0.0588705689,
0.1673234254,
1.5666515827,
-0.3848259747,
0.7754758596,
0.4308504462,
-0.383369118,
0.2519651055,
0.9725914598,
0.182727024,
0.4726247489,
0.1703149378,
-0.3220696151,
-0.2931705117,
-0.1516534537,
-0.6514874101,
0.3406404555,
0.1503670514,
-0.2431619465,
0.0378111377,
0.260530591,
0.125241816,
-0.0368593708,
-0.5630021691,
0.5920621157,
0.1831483096,
-0.730404377,
0.3955971599,
-0.3437721133,
0.0280837584,
-0.5438678861,
0.203350395,
-0.0007051337,
0.0479651801,
-0.0010696346,
-0.958742857,
0.0356805697,
-0.3184610307,
0.1953061521,
0.0091804331,
0.7538112998,
-0.5901628137,
-0.421351701,
0.0252463631,
0.7092913389,
0.2998149693,
-0.1605829448,
-1.0582671165,
-0.2243465334,
-0.2962826788,
-0.0827054977,
0.4967311323,
0.3079266548,
0.1502480358,
0.8481326699,
0.5662685037,
0.2206308544,
0.4090822935,
0.0475720912,
1.0372269154,
-0.2063339353,
-0.8040545583,
-0.3073786795,
0.6508560777,
-0.1278821379,
-0.7179560661,
0.7286812663,
0.6292404532,
0.7702614069,
-0.2120923996,
0.6307753921,
0.2106673419,
0.8376040459,
-0.4243880808,
1.0788600445,
-0.7070747614,
-0.327156812,
-0.3593228161,
-0.5607219338,
-0.1293115467,
-0.1440865695,
-0.1007031351,
0.2032197416,
0.4917898774,
0.6865404844,
-0.1467541903,
-0.041583918,
0.5324773788,
-0.1876313239,
-0.0903023258,
0.4203018844,
0.797164917,
-0.5877348185,
0.4635058939,
-0.541144371,
0.0034094101,
-0.0857482702,
-0.7340999246,
-0.9196816087,
-0.5605778098,
-0.5488399863,
-0.7933843136,
-0.0405094996,
1.1873116493,
0.3860566914,
-1.0285563469,
0.1441754699,
0.4641250372,
-0.0719094127,
-0.4676943719,
-0.2454460263,
0.4691305459,
0.048384048,
-0.1619240642,
0.2227332592,
0.111069791,
-0.0118380319,
-0.1531271487,
-0.3051511049,
-0.4047058225,
0.2640317082,
0.5175067186,
0.5080197453,
-0.3201408088,
0.099929817,
0.3957740366,
-0.3618045449,
0.3697858453,
0.6393041611,
-0.5766913891,
0.9340283275,
0.25226143,
0.9008481503,
-0.0150604174,
0.1789396405,
0.3133865893,
-0.4210585058,
-0.2593697011,
0.477991432,
-0.1375439763,
0.0295406915,
-0.1984738261,
0.3280793428,
-0.0771424696,
-0.9475014806,
-0.8868796825,
0.2003770322,
-1.071734786,
-0.1363392025,
0.9380275607,
-0.2698431909,
-0.0470895804,
-0.6223774552,
-0.2967973351,
0.2817569971,
0.0874019265,
0.4653918445,
0.7510696054,
-0.1815683842,
-0.513718307,
-1.482722044,
0.76658988,
0.2052709311,
-1.0275192261,
-0.133703813,
0.4503301978,
0.4572178125,
-0.3305153251,
1.0337063074,
-0.5468099117,
0.8926220536,
0.077537477,
-0.1446877122,
-0.0090769958,
-0.3298425376,
-0.4923425317,
0.2129122168,
-0.2020262033,
-0.5382298231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01461v1
|
Answerability in Retrieval-Augmented Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-03T09:55:35 | 2024-03-03T09:55:35 |
Rustam Abdumalikov, Pasquale Minervini, Yova Kementchedjhieva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of Open-Domain Question Answering (ODQA) retrieval systems
can exhibit sub-optimal behavior, providing text excerpts with varying degrees
of irrelevance. Unfortunately, many existing ODQA datasets lack examples
specifically targeting the identification of irrelevant text excerpts. Previous
attempts to address this gap have relied on a simplistic approach of pairing
questions with random text excerpts. This paper aims to investigate the
effectiveness of models trained using this randomized strategy, uncovering an
important limitation in their ability to generalize to irrelevant text excerpts
with high semantic overlap. As a result, we observed a substantial decrease in
predictive accuracy, from 98% to 1%. To address this limitation, we discovered
an efficient approach for training models to recognize such excerpts. By
leveraging unanswerable pairs from the SQuAD 2.0 dataset, our models achieve a
nearly perfect (~100%) accuracy when confronted with these challenging text
excerpts.
|
[
-0.4626163542,
-0.8289244771,
0.5822800994,
-0.1528288722,
-0.0223036092,
0.0987526849,
0.0261697769,
-0.5607241392,
0.0093068508,
0.3609240949,
-0.6876722574,
-0.1758037955,
-0.3181375563,
0.1145912483,
-0.3804472685,
1.072193265,
-0.3349419236,
0.0371679589,
-0.4086733162,
-0.5384781957,
-0.3664931059,
-0.5769931674,
-0.335968256,
-0.2424621135,
0.2159115076,
0.309139818,
0.5317972302,
0.4388175905,
0.5653041005,
0.1727509946,
-0.1218325347,
0.2474067807,
-0.8112573028,
0.1742554903,
-0.2243277282,
-0.251799494,
-0.1526404917,
0.1978469044,
0.4420209527,
0.7599334717,
-0.1324294508,
0.1491011977,
-0.150602445,
0.5191307664,
-0.7238599658,
-0.1259875298,
-0.9545086622,
-0.0199534129,
0.1753459424,
-0.2277573794,
-0.4610437155,
-0.2786454856,
0.4254973233,
-0.7940959334,
0.4779832661,
0.0775853992,
0.6960193515,
0.1938018352,
-0.1743760556,
-0.4822689891,
-0.7088528275,
0.8244242668,
-0.3691542447,
0.0459697135,
0.6986562014,
0.1925056279,
-0.0538208075,
-0.5134087801,
-0.4933824837,
0.069813773,
-0.0108743627,
0.253680706,
-0.0800155774,
-0.0161506962,
0.0277555119,
0.28076455,
-0.5962822437,
0.0657204911,
-0.4123476446,
0.0673121065,
0.5138446093,
0.1041395813,
0.3868707716,
0.001387757,
-0.5370091796,
0.0511247143,
-0.339197576,
0.2587801218,
0.3423698246,
0.3028669953,
0.2942908406,
0.8400720954,
-0.4785858393,
0.5930779576,
0.1447475851,
0.4011739492,
0.0549447574,
-0.5050598383,
-0.1311042905,
-0.1833107471,
0.4831030965,
0.1987688392,
0.259529978,
-0.5172351599,
-0.19140625,
-0.3985157907,
0.4123673439,
-0.589445889,
-0.227750212,
0.6264303327,
-0.3024211526,
-0.1742850989,
0.3148036003,
-0.5510802269,
-0.1028591618,
0.0343037918,
0.8043236732,
-0.532066524,
-0.1343608797,
0.1020690128,
-0.4951779246,
0.3196495175,
0.3289281428,
-0.7269065976,
0.3943506181,
0.4759601653,
0.6014205813,
-0.4116160274,
-0.1651002616,
-0.790233016,
0.0489780717,
-0.2475461662,
0.7551556826,
-0.4174692333,
-0.2935190797,
0.0179497525,
-0.0502908789,
-0.4286536276,
-0.5979977846,
0.5296708941,
-1.1308459044,
0.1721879989,
-0.2662574053,
-0.7221054435,
-0.0454425924,
0.1597986966,
-0.6930202246,
0.9908615351,
0.3735699654,
-0.6957477331,
0.2689367533,
-0.3871903419,
-0.0562331565,
-0.1502520442,
-0.0776481405,
-0.301472038,
0.0923828557,
0.2689974308,
0.3237494826,
-0.1690285951,
-0.0765183344,
-0.4184142947,
-0.5855234265,
0.2705948055,
-0.150416255,
0.6141017675,
0.0602022558,
0.0366203673,
-0.1901281178,
-0.7143774629,
0.401639998,
0.1605767757,
-0.228212446,
-0.8002586961,
-0.119570747,
-0.1071940809,
0.1697046757,
0.1141339168,
-0.77042979,
0.129840374,
-0.4533542693,
0.3636081219,
0.6830706,
0.1605032235,
0.6802520156,
-0.5278230906,
0.5523604751,
0.0379539728,
-0.2009416819,
0.0706354156,
-0.5205284357,
-0.3589816093,
-0.3559463322,
0.3133583367,
0.540051043,
-1.1314200163,
0.1668312252,
-0.2446476966,
-0.4396367967,
-0.5057654381,
0.0764109045,
0.7484666109,
0.5756844878,
0.669421792,
-0.2612330019,
-0.3590127826,
-0.6705063581,
-0.483499676,
-0.2171112597,
0.0140593778,
0.3392134011,
0.7370098233,
0.4030698836,
1.1589142084,
-0.5902786851,
0.0282894876,
-0.2226102799,
0.0559308939,
-0.0994894505,
0.5917834044,
0.4638978839,
-1.2033590078,
-0.3626039922,
-0.2863889933,
-0.9097626209,
0.2348460704,
0.2651362717,
-0.2597713768,
0.0578291565,
0.6816909909,
-0.6059939861,
0.7406903505,
0.1724126488,
-0.1558938175,
0.4015633762,
-0.2002375126,
0.2040013522,
-0.7099409699,
0.1313108951,
-0.2510796189,
-0.0065180599,
-0.7893195748,
0.2041558474,
0.1517022997,
0.0462703146,
-0.5078007579,
0.8167339563,
-0.3282928169,
0.0087425541,
-0.0037263215,
0.1472783238,
-0.0931146666,
0.6006783843,
0.1548681259,
1.0351331234,
-0.0759985521,
-0.6816027164,
-0.046274431,
0.8040379286,
-0.5267688632,
0.5589011312,
-0.9780343175,
0.3316125274,
-0.411162138,
0.1647243798,
-1.2936067581,
-0.5780193806,
0.1467717141,
-0.5807477236,
0.0722443461,
-0.1635420918,
-0.1974790245,
-0.2422374487,
-0.36992535,
1.0382907391,
0.4503429532,
-0.7546110153,
0.2504955232,
0.1784876138,
-0.3049779534,
-0.799321115,
-0.427731216,
-0.7162637711,
0.1646246761,
-0.3723435104,
0.3316597342,
-0.1583808959,
-0.1890137792,
0.1740895659,
-0.3650820255,
-0.6800283194,
0.0964286029,
0.18102777,
0.3769051433,
-0.180582419,
0.3188972175,
0.0653810799,
0.3424880207,
-0.1354272366,
-0.2001370788,
0.3563717902,
0.2010270804,
-0.3743638992,
-0.1277658194,
0.5719075799,
0.1835875511,
-0.3627741039,
1.0834268332,
0.3494219184,
-0.2613201737,
-0.1278361678,
-0.2991772592,
-0.0522726737,
-0.4103059769,
0.5999313593,
-0.4045312703,
-0.8639394641,
0.5503424406,
0.5255215764,
0.000463447,
0.4686782956,
0.1921625137,
-0.2415200919,
0.8963734508,
0.3456105888,
0.2369701415,
0.2038413435,
-0.1965954602,
-0.1089660451,
-0.8869698048,
-0.4398213625,
-0.7081053853,
0.0262567531,
-0.4199627936,
-0.473133117,
0.3770137131,
0.3251744807,
-0.2417973131,
0.3187265694,
-0.342616111,
0.646175921,
0.7658078074,
0.5468581915,
0.3313320577,
0.1606127024,
-0.0487896539,
0.1278128177,
-0.8171983361,
-0.2345887721,
1.2201769352,
0.0899340212,
0.5633248687,
0.2226136625,
0.4751942456,
0.2815034986,
0.0488690026,
-0.588752687,
0.4550791681,
0.0385546014,
-0.8919623494,
-0.526689291,
-0.5726639628,
-0.8214372396,
0.0655985698,
-0.2082995027,
-0.7103453279,
0.2781552672,
-0.1382819265,
-0.5232092142,
0.304528445,
-0.6196727753,
0.5352799296,
0.3689981699,
-0.2073746175,
0.1849094778,
-0.8399790525,
0.3162461519,
-0.322427094,
0.013011653,
0.0768159404,
-0.2908634245,
0.8617116213,
-0.372256726,
0.4027557671,
-0.0114470422,
-0.0325793773,
0.5605454445,
-0.1951149553,
0.3311829269,
-0.0763759241,
-0.4709664285,
-0.1724216342,
0.1986068934,
-0.9906659722,
-0.7774390578,
0.4160194993,
-0.829222858,
-0.3254630268,
-0.441080302,
-0.6072311401,
-0.6363890767,
-0.0172222201,
0.3880109489,
0.650880456,
-0.5018935204,
0.1043754071,
0.9641672373,
-0.2079467326,
0.5119013786,
0.5533411503,
0.1219871789,
-0.6017105579,
0.7974188924,
0.1628280282,
0.6246417761,
0.4935003817,
-0.3441233635,
-0.4101716876,
-0.6295996904,
-0.5219592452,
0.1688013375,
-0.6737325191,
-0.0869074389,
-0.7190520167,
-0.4595608413,
-0.3092024922,
0.0640956163,
-0.0651103556,
-0.7318075299,
-0.3927121758,
-0.0536172912,
0.2601976097,
0.8212473989,
0.3575175107,
0.1691211313,
-0.7824736834,
0.4549900591,
0.4926239252,
0.3516099155,
0.0165807586,
-0.8419212699,
-0.2016909719,
0.1524025351,
-0.1629693359,
-0.6857905388,
0.0094466098,
0.315022856,
0.5497542024,
-0.1328595877,
0.6280804873,
0.4664650559,
-0.4078472257,
0.659132421,
-0.094228074,
-0.5727011561,
0.5635662675,
-0.4328027964,
0.2186937332,
0.8598586321,
0.7736632228,
0.3087446392,
-0.2285616249,
-0.6576541066,
-0.6977288127,
1.0125859976,
0.646399796,
0.0039694076,
-0.0975596607,
0.5861008763,
0.1820224375,
0.3642024994,
-0.2749052346,
-0.2735005319,
0.1493160129,
-0.267873168,
-0.182355985,
-0.2022829503,
-0.0605899878,
-0.0120693287,
0.6339579821,
0.0040080012,
0.3887384832,
0.5720853209,
-0.1164583489,
-0.0039342614,
0.1835223436,
0.5186391473,
0.447289288,
-0.6656025648,
-0.1878775805,
0.0503828526,
-0.6771976948,
0.3968504667,
0.1956999451,
-0.3537622094,
0.0124857388,
0.2792929709,
0.3530119359,
-0.0960080028,
-0.9422670603,
0.6982727051,
-0.0981162414,
-0.2831202447,
-0.1693585813,
0.0778275207,
-0.35221982,
0.1456251293,
0.5518953204,
0.3340515494,
0.1080901995,
-0.6832620502,
0.2357447594,
0.5586476922,
-0.8352288604,
-0.1672373116,
0.6344075203,
0.0705646351,
-0.2079732567,
0.5549449325,
-0.166414246,
-0.4304210842,
0.8131915927,
0.1870154738,
0.5680155158,
-0.0518876351,
0.2853604853,
0.2592656612,
0.1020239741,
-0.2155922204,
0.3113591373,
0.0010860119,
-0.673415184,
-0.1252178997,
-0.4016050994,
-0.5048961639,
0.031247627,
-1.1187778711,
-0.1101815924,
-0.3109223247,
0.0797524676,
-0.0665321201,
-0.1179867163,
-0.4763445258,
0.409704864,
-0.7725562453,
0.9552075863,
-0.5301252604,
0.6089403629,
0.8485488296,
-0.7620455027,
-0.72291255,
0.2001066208,
-0.4590247273,
-0.9751431942,
0.6197029352,
0.0534431376,
0.0922177061,
0.1451558024,
-0.5957775116,
-0.3946605325,
0.9437301159,
0.1046696827,
0.2144295573,
-0.2205042541,
0.1255536377,
0.4168419242,
-0.2619594634,
0.6073957086,
0.4747496247,
-0.0109714456,
0.2518210411,
-0.9592306018,
-0.0045541432,
-0.31436342,
-0.0926010311,
0.1207020208,
-0.6048252583,
0.7358884811,
-0.3833918869,
0.0893575177,
0.8110998869,
0.5614205599,
0.0647529289,
0.6189302802,
0.3749594986,
0.399384588,
0.7096329927,
0.0328361653,
1.0570470095,
0.1954152882,
0.3546940088,
1.3359742165,
-0.1842081994,
1.2075858116,
0.4326250851,
-0.0619194135,
0.2187212557,
0.4265778363,
0.3804404736,
0.7572098374,
0.0282687955,
-0.473818332,
-0.4004155695,
-0.200295791,
-0.4514923096,
0.3888430893,
0.017886674,
-0.4139426351,
-0.0995291471,
0.0377832204,
-0.2885760367,
0.378883332,
-0.3571220338,
0.932218194,
-0.2085477263,
-0.9202406406,
0.6668502688,
-0.225590229,
0.3280090988,
-0.4558534622,
-0.1433440149,
-0.2660501897,
0.0485492684,
-0.07572335,
-0.7432076335,
0.0024230562,
-0.1062503308,
-0.6302403212,
0.0263713021,
0.5897064805,
-0.5446884632,
-0.2383837402,
0.0187842026,
0.8810050488,
0.0366419293,
-0.2295198888,
-0.2589970529,
-0.3341144025,
-0.0262016561,
0.0736027732,
0.5538954139,
0.4764897525,
0.2047178298,
0.6786451936,
0.410548687,
-0.1543074548,
-0.0272106957,
-0.4925020635,
0.8289097548,
-0.3637902737,
-0.2263467759,
-0.4683723152,
0.320682615,
-0.138535127,
-0.3932888508,
0.7581712008,
0.5195931196,
0.8853725195,
-0.2739282846,
0.9097826481,
-0.0281203371,
0.9941104054,
-0.6660823822,
0.536355257,
-0.6728280187,
0.4169464409,
-0.3392387033,
-0.5982330441,
0.1796835661,
0.310992986,
-0.2747527957,
0.2018414587,
0.642783463,
0.6703503132,
-0.2194915563,
0.3593992889,
0.2362387776,
-0.1041137427,
-0.0826885626,
0.6300495863,
0.9630808234,
-0.8792390227,
0.9147092104,
-0.2150586247,
-0.1989230961,
-0.1795974821,
-0.422439158,
-1.1665402651,
-0.6290979385,
-0.2549471557,
-0.6599264741,
0.4376941621,
0.8434453011,
0.6540743113,
-0.8840210438,
0.1378043741,
-0.2078144103,
0.1443692595,
-0.102130197,
-0.17334719,
0.3989400566,
-0.3381741643,
-0.6097360253,
0.1993153244,
-0.165937081,
0.2554594576,
0.1497807503,
0.0633623153,
-0.4379248023,
0.2078881264,
0.3806892633,
0.6717962027,
-0.4239169061,
-0.3609289229,
0.3650947809,
-0.1384377182,
-0.0062749209,
0.624818027,
-0.8294247985,
0.3481966853,
0.4383204281,
0.9134883881,
0.1751506478,
0.5304527283,
0.6534783244,
-0.8516713977,
0.0263954774,
0.3850995004,
-0.1248903126,
0.0401858911,
-0.1085112169,
0.754181087,
0.3026965261,
-0.548801899,
-0.840213716,
0.1125091612,
-1.0575654507,
-0.3095390201,
1.2413415909,
-0.5257476568,
0.0106321387,
-0.4944335818,
-0.2789480984,
-0.0144886356,
-0.4379023015,
0.4969525635,
0.7258956432,
-0.1028711274,
0.2757401764,
-0.61458987,
0.5036303401,
0.6714151502,
-0.6838204265,
-0.2399440855,
0.2551024556,
0.1260837615,
0.0520370007,
0.7656570077,
0.1125457436,
0.4428879321,
-0.0619639158,
-0.5294311047,
-0.0887192413,
-0.1436458528,
-0.2437926233,
0.5173566937,
-0.0749938786,
-0.3998467326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01457v1
|
Logic Rules as Explanations for Legal Case Retrieval
| 2024-03-03T09:22:21 | 2024-03-03T09:22:21 |
Zhongxiang Sun, Kepu Zhang, Weijie Yu, Haoyu Wang, Jun Xu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we address the issue of using logic rules to explain the
results from legal case retrieval. The task is critical to legal case retrieval
because the users (e.g., lawyers or judges) are highly specialized and require
the system to provide logical, faithful, and interpretable explanations before
making legal decisions. Recently, research efforts have been made to learn
explainable legal case retrieval models. However, these methods usually select
rationales (key sentences) from the legal cases as explanations, failing to
provide faithful and logically correct explanations. In this paper, we propose
Neural-Symbolic enhanced Legal Case Retrieval (NS-LCR), a framework that
explicitly conducts reasoning on the matching of legal cases through learning
case-level and law-level logic rules. The learned rules are then integrated
into the retrieval process in a neuro-symbolic manner. Benefiting from the
logic and interpretable nature of the logic rules, NS-LCR is equipped with
built-in faithful explainability. We also show that NS-LCR is a model-agnostic
framework that can be plugged in for multiple legal retrieval models. To
showcase NS-LCR's superiority, we enhance existing benchmarks by adding
manually annotated logic rules and introducing a novel explainability metric
using Large Language Models (LLMs). Our comprehensive experiments reveal
NS-LCR's effectiveness for ranking, alongside its proficiency in delivering
reliable explanations for legal case retrieval.
|
[
-0.020489132,
-0.6887415648,
1.0827013254,
-0.0752160549,
-0.6124508381,
-0.2605148554,
-0.193415314,
-0.2765999138,
0.1298897415,
0.6843624115,
-0.4398152828,
-0.4189838767,
-0.3242715597,
0.101684235,
-0.6120948195,
1.0076087713,
0.3196660578,
0.3412952125,
-0.2493868172,
-0.2439989448,
-0.6782408357,
-0.7463226914,
-0.4898441732,
-0.3897394836,
0.4805872738,
-0.0449618138,
0.6652037501,
0.7832117081,
0.5185241699,
0.2863456309,
-0.2250549048,
-0.1694571674,
-0.2217610031,
0.0568904988,
-0.2966117561,
-0.6648809314,
-0.492200017,
-0.2034406662,
0.0760272071,
0.337061882,
-0.546102345,
-0.1350428164,
-0.5769250393,
0.8223779798,
-0.4847611189,
0.1916036606,
-0.6957710385,
0.4371896684,
0.0435310528,
-0.4697603583,
-0.5130870342,
-0.6932439208,
-0.0814795867,
-1.0428111553,
0.2039586306,
0.2144881785,
0.711784184,
0.2974025011,
-0.5267747045,
-0.3809407651,
-0.437042892,
0.4463577867,
-0.8261998296,
0.4818084538,
0.1720298529,
0.857783854,
0.090933226,
-0.6829181314,
-0.7510504723,
-0.5114790797,
-0.3182260394,
0.282515496,
-0.2706356645,
0.1979716271,
0.5689871311,
-0.0859015137,
-0.5132158399,
-0.3341398239,
-0.281093955,
-0.4256224036,
0.6564050913,
0.0142852236,
0.4103869498,
-0.0616849065,
-0.0177206136,
0.2244428992,
-0.6961126328,
-0.1568981558,
0.3571922779,
0.4396278858,
0.3196404278,
0.7523821592,
-0.1261128485,
0.6683531404,
0.2358731925,
0.0605093725,
0.1900635213,
-0.5400063396,
-0.0902448371,
0.5292469263,
0.5170197487,
0.4321718514,
0.524160862,
-0.3317311704,
-0.3279668987,
-0.2056656927,
0.3383466601,
-0.729796052,
0.1656629592,
-0.0025532744,
-0.9405199289,
-0.0448115319,
0.1969074011,
-0.5513026118,
-0.5000438094,
-0.6675727963,
0.4530404806,
-0.465516746,
-0.3221217394,
0.4292910695,
-0.4693598449,
0.3954295516,
0.4921585023,
-0.5007997155,
0.5065518618,
0.9414832592,
0.43703264,
0.3691860437,
0.3659791648,
-0.7136309147,
0.0530868173,
-0.3034753203,
0.4460497797,
-0.5779035687,
0.1434603184,
-0.0623445809,
-0.0435698368,
0.1451106071,
-0.5628856421,
0.825784564,
-0.866145134,
-0.1565541327,
-0.5808529854,
-0.4598691761,
-0.5199936032,
0.1179194003,
-0.4657310247,
0.3842095137,
-0.3835306764,
-0.5050839186,
0.6906990409,
-0.7017629147,
-0.7676174641,
0.2596904337,
-0.3332598209,
-0.247476086,
0.3176387548,
0.1013939679,
0.2153886259,
-0.181689322,
0.5718562007,
-0.2229853272,
-0.5186625719,
0.1345476806,
-0.1331481785,
1.1578698158,
0.4048131108,
-0.3943217695,
0.0755329505,
-0.3411366642,
-0.1232073978,
0.2561662793,
-0.1860314757,
-0.3827845454,
0.2091327757,
-0.3749013245,
0.4676810205,
0.0448373742,
-0.5289555192,
-0.2990958989,
-0.3147215545,
0.4724728465,
0.5645770431,
-0.1697403789,
0.3781712055,
-0.2409062684,
0.5325744748,
0.1507385522,
0.1771427393,
0.0494756177,
-0.2271291018,
-0.4749149978,
0.0232161004,
0.1193370447,
0.4893779755,
-0.5063225627,
0.3103848994,
-0.3768990636,
0.0835041031,
-0.6417977214,
-0.0405332632,
0.3855721056,
0.6528315544,
0.4873059988,
0.0560717173,
-0.6769534349,
-1.1517635584,
-0.6780070066,
-0.2011568695,
0.1381583363,
0.6457878351,
0.6674871445,
0.2275728434,
0.9265686274,
0.0994603857,
-0.1138229147,
-0.475466758,
-0.1847805232,
0.6331939697,
-0.0878662914,
0.4056089818,
-1.0308542252,
-0.1711740792,
0.1094898954,
-0.9822717309,
-0.3107303083,
-0.4269505143,
-0.1762301624,
-0.0019428335,
0.7864869237,
-0.605250001,
0.6005840302,
-0.5538882613,
-0.6541646719,
0.6598024964,
-0.2844296992,
0.0154759586,
-0.4885642827,
-0.1888533235,
0.1061204448,
-0.4014184773,
-0.4509356022,
0.3744675517,
0.1640488356,
0.3164998889,
-0.5477858186,
0.3271403611,
-0.4087236226,
-0.3220395148,
-0.3575614393,
0.456975162,
0.1759076864,
0.2135943472,
-0.1452199668,
0.4175850153,
0.391546905,
-0.5836507082,
0.4080342054,
0.0568065345,
0.0972796902,
0.7703091502,
-0.8124162555,
-0.2695630491,
-0.4862911403,
0.279735595,
-0.3792097569,
0.1627719849,
0.2134840488,
-0.1691548973,
0.1035429984,
-0.5225552917,
-0.7477784753,
-0.3354633749,
0.0189574249,
0.1688548774,
0.5577912331,
-0.6346647143,
1.120703578,
0.2230443954,
0.157665655,
-0.5026412606,
-0.4229717255,
0.0701846331,
-0.4137822986,
-0.208465606,
0.3017666638,
-0.0719877481,
-0.5234210491,
0.2686367929,
-0.3499462008,
-0.1120751724,
0.2844437361,
0.3391954005,
0.1437373161,
-0.4538732469,
0.2206078768,
0.1868644208,
0.0181435365,
0.7370331883,
-0.0657053143,
0.2103165239,
-0.3709682822,
-0.5567081571,
-0.5034184456,
0.2605520487,
0.3692645133,
-0.2181473821,
0.456508249,
0.1288521886,
-0.369579047,
-0.0513683259,
-0.6463246942,
-0.3795314133,
-0.4240070283,
0.1715588421,
-0.6173921227,
-0.6320732832,
0.4151697755,
-0.0264271088,
-0.0570717864,
0.544095993,
0.3642018437,
-0.0367566012,
1.1107805967,
0.3545356095,
0.1729290187,
0.2464947551,
0.2921296358,
0.453920573,
-0.5507981181,
-0.6517627239,
-0.5417147279,
-0.0891587958,
-0.2561028004,
0.1083215252,
0.034091156,
0.1518733203,
-0.4942455292,
0.3338027596,
-0.4111681283,
0.9134367704,
0.5370467901,
0.3238565028,
0.5126641989,
0.0272424612,
-0.6626192331,
0.085873872,
-0.5977405906,
-0.2070663869,
0.8086894751,
-0.0662714988,
0.3950288296,
0.3750780523,
0.602709949,
0.1877712756,
-0.0163525548,
-0.8745060563,
0.8309106231,
-0.2941345572,
-0.677609086,
0.0235995855,
-0.5991373658,
-0.6284934282,
0.3615932167,
-0.3857605159,
-0.5992645025,
0.0305848345,
-0.1013373062,
-0.5784826279,
-0.0440711677,
-0.334831804,
0.586276114,
-0.6319199204,
-0.4136017263,
-0.5084799528,
-0.6554662585,
0.4125863016,
-0.14854756,
0.3104980886,
-0.1446167976,
0.1866506934,
0.600854516,
-0.7475153208,
0.4315916002,
-0.2940396965,
0.416228503,
0.0037031712,
0.2871144414,
0.2199353278,
0.0350381099,
-0.4406948388,
-0.2149001807,
0.0089564938,
0.0498052612,
-1.0413519144,
0.6095573902,
-0.2943769395,
-0.8770372272,
-0.4312106967,
-0.5284074545,
0.4374489188,
0.3097564578,
-0.3870822787,
0.1785149127,
0.4012880027,
0.3733513951,
0.5334609151,
-0.3369214535,
0.20799236,
0.8463485241,
-0.0676430166,
-0.0112276394,
0.8705098629,
0.0132576926,
-0.3356919587,
0.3431710601,
0.4462658167,
-0.6931771636,
-0.6429818869,
-0.198751837,
0.4032265246,
-0.8935950994,
-0.0924850255,
-0.6004564762,
-0.2467722297,
-0.0859713703,
-0.1575357765,
0.1298281401,
-0.6190558672,
-0.1521113068,
-0.2834961712,
0.4612255394,
0.4643600583,
-0.0772450492,
-0.1108436584,
-0.4014089406,
0.6634787321,
0.0660630539,
0.3501940072,
-0.1093333066,
-0.8334795833,
0.1801023185,
0.0260032248,
0.1233545169,
-0.8717998862,
0.2898841798,
0.1577434093,
0.9378837943,
0.3907335699,
0.1399123073,
0.8942644596,
-0.6674680114,
0.2240033746,
0.0784111395,
-0.9442759156,
0.8973599076,
-0.1245772243,
-0.2116955817,
0.6589869261,
0.2184070349,
-0.2237035036,
-0.1639358401,
-0.473010242,
-0.8547359109,
0.7653228641,
0.2311586589,
0.2222194523,
-0.0370578654,
1.0983023643,
-0.0143071283,
0.1490744352,
-0.7742650509,
-0.0641003996,
-0.4430645704,
-0.3135351241,
0.4481942952,
0.0743649974,
-0.1304167956,
-0.5265962481,
0.7231629491,
-0.17056337,
0.2415267676,
0.1859228313,
-0.3971613646,
0.3423109055,
0.255412966,
0.4407843649,
0.6086666584,
-0.1728755087,
0.0986483023,
-0.0325040258,
-0.1464114338,
0.0030891765,
0.2272851169,
-0.2727105021,
0.0520572029,
0.1400889009,
0.5368483663,
-0.0308364909,
-0.824148953,
0.6145264506,
-0.3764202595,
-0.5011855364,
-0.501801312,
0.0728038549,
0.0885908231,
0.4880194366,
0.3819160461,
-0.0900908262,
0.4722910523,
-0.6184930801,
0.4406107664,
0.6272830367,
-0.432901144,
0.0328123495,
0.9603407979,
-0.1638061851,
-0.1594312191,
0.8584188223,
-0.0778688863,
-0.5856378078,
0.9725147486,
0.6061131358,
0.5193803906,
0.6313917041,
0.2154323757,
0.2820079029,
0.3627458811,
-0.4014036655,
0.4758678079,
-0.1968271434,
-0.5239438415,
-0.3844355941,
-0.4392663836,
-0.1075175554,
-0.2325147092,
-0.8325163722,
0.015720645,
-0.4482609928,
-0.0042763855,
0.1659840047,
-0.2870025039,
-0.5062285662,
0.0318413749,
-0.083533518,
1.0489031076,
-0.5829370022,
0.5600832105,
0.4375167191,
-0.776281178,
-0.7409412861,
-0.2650124133,
0.2705644965,
-0.8032785654,
1.0283869505,
0.2040524185,
-0.0024116654,
-0.2956382036,
-0.399400562,
-0.4729126096,
1.1079542637,
0.6351675391,
-0.6147167683,
0.0808653012,
0.1847112179,
0.7832762599,
-0.3038018942,
0.5678183436,
0.4957780242,
0.5917748809,
0.3420745432,
-0.4166467786,
0.6122564077,
-0.4808957875,
-0.073746331,
0.0096414527,
-0.1505337358,
0.3399546444,
-0.5741187334,
-0.0298490431,
-0.028220458,
0.4582501948,
0.5890117288,
0.4104575217,
0.4944354892,
0.5348634124,
0.6982380152,
-0.4914658368,
1.3644100428,
-0.3393774629,
-0.0075211669,
1.0889725685,
-0.3419883549,
0.6750642061,
0.6309764981,
0.2820010185,
0.621447444,
0.367236644,
-0.1704858392,
0.4785382152,
0.4629143178,
-0.0763782859,
-0.7241549492,
-0.4121132195,
-0.0115922019,
0.1776671708,
0.1978678256,
-0.8026624918,
-0.2586061656,
-0.1756238341,
-0.1874482185,
0.1506543159,
-0.3938785195,
0.7387849689,
0.06587331,
-0.4531038702,
0.113205336,
-0.072239466,
0.2626870275,
-0.3242852092,
-0.3501574695,
-0.328699708,
0.234563157,
-0.3437064886,
-0.8095323443,
0.342412889,
-0.0061858282,
-0.1926430017,
-0.4015104771,
0.7616553307,
-0.0001124562,
-0.5011790395,
0.530541122,
0.4305840433,
0.3061671555,
-0.1654751301,
-1.1178318262,
-0.2085900903,
-0.3185566366,
-0.0993173644,
0.2125949413,
0.667999804,
-0.2580008209,
0.8984999657,
0.7708298564,
-0.0314098634,
0.0912676901,
0.6015648246,
0.7667201757,
-0.7029080391,
-0.1749575585,
-0.9479461312,
0.3855024278,
-0.1915569901,
0.2907321155,
0.4279752672,
0.6036275625,
0.4643368721,
0.153256014,
0.5439053774,
0.023066856,
0.0605759509,
-0.6472933888,
0.794061482,
-0.6696177125,
0.5185544491,
0.0115060313,
-0.6959827542,
-0.420750618,
0.9199111462,
-0.178289026,
0.2364593148,
0.6601746082,
0.8291835189,
-0.3790864646,
0.1091205254,
0.2790374756,
0.2784847021,
0.0827068016,
0.4429871142,
0.6788271666,
-0.294298172,
0.8056566119,
-0.025388686,
0.1365711838,
-0.2891074419,
-1.0405236483,
-0.7137535214,
-0.0410540514,
-0.2735829651,
-0.3589250743,
0.4563103616,
0.6906971931,
0.7712501287,
-0.5868676901,
-0.0523421057,
-0.4940531254,
0.39377895,
-0.3516780436,
-0.2969196737,
0.0429770127,
-0.2448239326,
-0.0515885279,
0.5858620405,
0.1056661829,
-0.1890337765,
0.424967587,
-0.3745463789,
-0.2247822732,
0.1873477399,
0.4906617105,
0.3192068338,
-0.9277483225,
-0.1287097782,
0.0944023579,
0.0869236737,
0.0241063107,
0.9018728733,
-0.9190737605,
0.3555777371,
0.4386406243,
0.6175972223,
0.4092351198,
-0.0331390984,
0.664593339,
-0.3509203792,
-0.3139335811,
0.277013272,
0.7879687548,
-0.1276646256,
-0.3515200615,
0.5807012916,
0.1729151458,
-0.1680284888,
-0.5593450665,
0.1307730824,
-1.0823994875,
-0.4147188365,
0.9438617826,
-0.1417102963,
-0.218072027,
-0.3479694724,
0.0741069466,
0.2643418014,
-0.5427580476,
0.7783583403,
0.5283115506,
-0.166933924,
-0.4258244932,
-0.852709353,
0.13680242,
0.4220695794,
-0.7859822512,
-0.0322187506,
0.7216420174,
0.444301337,
0.0619870313,
0.3654251695,
-0.5819489956,
0.6642481089,
-0.3223800361,
-0.1855698079,
-0.41903162,
-0.2217259407,
-0.5360806584,
0.0842913687,
-0.3692686558,
0.4653747678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01456v1
|
Controlling Cloze-test Question Item Difficulty with PLM-based Surrogate Models for IRT Assessment
| 2024-03-03T09:18:05 | 2024-03-03T09:18:05 |
Jingshen Zhang, Jiajun Xie, Xinying Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Item difficulty plays a crucial role in adaptive testing. However, few works
have focused on generating questions of varying difficulty levels, especially
for multiple-choice (MC) cloze tests. We propose training pre-trained language
models (PLMs) as surrogate models to enable item response theory (IRT)
assessment, avoiding the need for human test subjects. We also propose two
strategies to control the difficulty levels of both the gaps and the
distractors using ranking rules to reduce invalid distractors. Experimentation
on a benchmark dataset demonstrates that our proposed framework and methods can
effectively control and evaluate the difficulty levels of MC cloze tests.
|
[
-0.8280908465,
-0.9178396463,
0.2330216318,
-0.0539996624,
-0.2072743922,
-0.1041498929,
-0.1362326145,
-0.1959724575,
-0.2513035834,
0.8150770068,
-0.7248390317,
-0.0776888505,
-0.5800722837,
0.3965806067,
0.0218790006,
1.1290779114,
-0.3298124969,
-0.1107176244,
-0.3351597786,
-0.2389542907,
-0.9321923256,
-0.4666263163,
-0.6057544947,
0.0012208819,
0.4963540137,
0.6875882745,
0.5125411153,
0.0384980068,
0.7908499241,
0.2239032835,
0.0206365213,
0.2729237378,
-0.3166234493,
0.2420942336,
-0.3293374777,
-0.307600081,
-0.2722634673,
0.1735221148,
0.2505876124,
0.6331493855,
-0.3137156069,
0.2271573395,
0.1656654626,
0.51952672,
-0.675301373,
-0.1624757797,
-0.6060093045,
-0.1703752279,
-0.0389241427,
-0.2441811115,
-0.6198167205,
-0.4081403613,
0.4277187288,
-0.4214815795,
0.3321351707,
0.1001546904,
0.6512982249,
0.3407726288,
-0.4858002961,
-0.5109243393,
-0.6803192496,
0.6246631145,
-0.4273720682,
0.3357571661,
0.4610889852,
0.058427956,
-0.1650832891,
-0.6755073667,
-0.2601382732,
-0.7865216732,
-0.148239091,
0.3352455199,
0.3723900914,
0.2340585738,
0.2610071301,
0.1385114342,
-0.7545014024,
-0.1686391532,
-0.7110300064,
0.0130553991,
0.553535521,
0.0791158825,
0.3885512054,
0.1364294291,
-0.6773574948,
0.0790658593,
-0.6502684355,
0.0838601813,
-0.1141017899,
0.1184408516,
0.5541105866,
0.6880001426,
-0.0994891971,
0.8009489179,
-0.0107672038,
0.0922477022,
0.0383970737,
-0.2588666677,
0.0567321703,
-0.1382982582,
0.3473037779,
0.1525275707,
0.3213551342,
0.1974565387,
-0.0716094077,
0.0496292189,
0.423917681,
-0.8483135104,
-0.2154997289,
0.2887651026,
-0.188000083,
0.175776124,
-0.054885339,
-0.7366842031,
-0.4291251302,
-0.1337696314,
0.736289978,
-0.6215624809,
0.0078240354,
0.249624446,
0.0157689583,
0.1140157059,
0.0413949788,
-0.517954886,
0.6109324098,
0.138591215,
0.6284897327,
-0.1478231996,
-0.5659644604,
-0.679081738,
-0.020228548,
-0.2338021249,
0.8635968566,
-0.7310672402,
-0.433051765,
-0.2311070412,
-0.16626288,
-0.6923981309,
-0.6352047324,
0.1958035678,
-0.4510761201,
0.4032685161,
-0.2715901434,
-0.7384073138,
-0.2222382575,
0.3679635227,
-0.4428319335,
0.9679509401,
0.4750946462,
-0.558404088,
0.2796553373,
-0.9557295442,
-0.4499077499,
0.0791810006,
0.2141519338,
-0.3209736943,
0.1820646077,
0.1781475991,
0.2540973127,
-0.1796396673,
-0.0834088475,
-0.2593725324,
-0.3287712932,
0.475720197,
-0.2242373377,
0.2202977687,
0.0925459713,
-0.2385647893,
-0.0042194333,
-0.6105588078,
0.1964334697,
-0.1510145217,
-0.3847985268,
-0.3451546729,
0.1573830247,
-0.3297349215,
0.2668119669,
0.0625220686,
-0.2842622697,
0.2120939493,
-0.0044741444,
0.293102324,
0.706002295,
0.2525955439,
-0.0163592473,
-0.6340788007,
0.7818650603,
-0.081264399,
0.3080793321,
-0.0229214169,
-0.4414153993,
-0.791497767,
-0.090892449,
0.43258515,
0.9474456906,
-0.7015340328,
0.1505207717,
0.292150259,
-0.4182324111,
-0.6425800323,
0.3229648173,
0.4061232209,
0.5064299107,
0.5736741424,
-0.5856726766,
-0.2604512274,
-0.5713905096,
-0.0458545275,
-0.0472162217,
-0.0481209308,
0.3448643386,
0.5845322609,
0.0754422918,
0.7793545127,
-0.5407915711,
-0.4347496927,
-0.5238304734,
0.4137337208,
-0.1174466237,
0.6709491611,
0.3620857596,
-1.1545379162,
-0.5736374259,
-0.2042562068,
-0.0634604096,
-0.4724856019,
-0.045893237,
0.1300767809,
0.0295264777,
0.5740019679,
-0.587880075,
0.4473660588,
0.068503879,
-0.2628940642,
0.75690341,
-0.1961713284,
0.1584208459,
-0.8267013431,
0.0059595336,
-0.2556506097,
-0.0879153758,
-0.9390614033,
0.1659363657,
0.0502001569,
-0.1076851264,
-0.6902373433,
0.3928078115,
-0.2947218418,
0.2708128393,
-0.3748958409,
0.1002286747,
0.0664088354,
0.5019321442,
0.3429427445,
0.9533827901,
0.265876174,
-0.9862554669,
0.1161055788,
0.3429539204,
-0.1626774073,
0.7441721559,
-0.6109128594,
0.2791942358,
-0.2301802337,
-0.0038472195,
-1.1758140326,
-0.1556780487,
0.1692530662,
-0.2855967581,
0.1720310748,
0.1080484018,
-0.1055703908,
-0.4594474733,
-0.2698665261,
0.393132776,
0.6001719832,
-0.1101433337,
0.6702008247,
-0.1190069616,
-0.6609182954,
-0.4908141196,
-0.4876668453,
-0.4426248372,
-0.4926412404,
-0.2880636156,
0.1473834962,
-0.8517801166,
-0.0194780976,
-0.3000365198,
-0.1335640997,
-0.3320018351,
0.3152305484,
0.0142379282,
0.1932541132,
-0.0358390026,
0.1600551158,
-0.3265216351,
-0.1270801723,
-0.1076646596,
0.0429782793,
0.6911607981,
-0.1743134409,
-0.5153051615,
-0.1971058697,
0.3906746507,
0.3632358611,
-0.5113714933,
0.4443134367,
0.455445528,
-0.2580985129,
-0.1384146065,
-0.7920229435,
-0.2631747723,
-0.4753408432,
0.3980442584,
-0.4998513162,
-0.7753280997,
0.6916589141,
-0.1075187325,
-0.0515079387,
0.0607639924,
0.4973639548,
-0.1308672875,
1.0727597475,
0.3968433738,
0.1701751202,
0.3433163762,
-0.0581282638,
0.018548768,
-1.0199047327,
0.0817280412,
-0.3892775178,
-0.3020965755,
-0.3942279518,
-0.204976365,
0.5034300685,
0.1759132147,
-0.3586195707,
0.2056064904,
-0.4014885426,
0.6265380383,
0.5999360085,
0.2924247384,
0.0251260269,
-0.371103853,
-0.1099976078,
0.1612893194,
-0.6482586861,
-0.186909005,
1.0196769238,
0.105175823,
0.6552093029,
-0.086648494,
0.580943644,
0.0526219234,
0.4992035329,
-0.528005898,
0.6153875589,
-0.1334346682,
-0.9446876645,
-0.3597882688,
-0.3499489725,
-0.830921948,
0.5008434653,
0.2444272488,
-0.9433637857,
0.3428367674,
0.0560716689,
-0.8863310814,
-0.0101230694,
-0.9153158069,
0.8039422035,
-0.2344036102,
-0.3780401349,
0.2354311645,
-0.7791259885,
0.1870916486,
0.0287209786,
0.1474621892,
-0.1398549676,
0.0307505373,
0.6870368719,
-0.4145205617,
0.7895156741,
-0.06970945,
0.4194222391,
0.7280721068,
0.6039550304,
0.5438394547,
0.1528529227,
-0.0300970711,
-0.4534892142,
0.0112498095,
-0.5375078917,
-0.4595154226,
0.218844384,
-0.4874296188,
-0.9334493876,
-0.465645045,
-0.9849309325,
-0.4016087055,
0.2996745706,
0.3782058656,
0.4109992981,
0.0192806181,
0.3241423666,
0.9776577353,
-0.0143117039,
0.3332490325,
0.8470303416,
0.0861285329,
-0.4543751776,
0.9111974835,
0.4903837442,
0.7318329811,
0.185079813,
0.3722963631,
-0.3106689453,
-0.8099933267,
-0.0175017845,
-0.1322725415,
-0.5641465783,
-0.2326011658,
-0.1363257915,
-0.3080972731,
-0.197124958,
-0.2530864179,
-0.2881503999,
0.0003600764,
-0.3459658027,
-0.3204630911,
0.3178571463,
0.6207454205,
-0.0635338724,
0.3827923834,
-0.5879631042,
0.312368989,
0.5030791759,
0.2995736599,
-0.5135060549,
-0.5862841606,
0.1658499092,
-0.1540303528,
-0.4863279164,
-0.9634200931,
0.3845977187,
0.1951361001,
0.2101647407,
0.204687804,
0.26327914,
0.8829046488,
-0.3756089211,
0.9240573049,
-0.0584033802,
-0.9268473387,
0.5069311261,
-0.0933520645,
0.0753129795,
0.8150796294,
0.4432308674,
-0.3675813377,
-0.4091622531,
-0.6419075131,
-0.7561654449,
0.6853391528,
0.3124622405,
0.0004365538,
-0.084153533,
0.3834748268,
0.2626296878,
0.367395103,
-0.9509388804,
0.06805785,
-0.137148574,
-0.2001078576,
0.0448384471,
-0.3787488341,
-0.0904158577,
-0.0617193803,
0.4573098123,
-0.0102685969,
-0.1387351155,
0.625092566,
-0.2879495621,
0.0069698454,
0.5295760632,
0.8340860605,
0.7372241616,
-0.5436502695,
0.2108062208,
0.6750730872,
-0.5642763376,
0.2178889811,
0.3187451363,
-0.2149477005,
-0.4015927017,
0.0843462944,
0.6439151168,
-0.0728843212,
-0.7411736846,
0.2493155599,
0.1082834303,
-0.3507521749,
-0.1820367426,
0.2162537277,
-0.2332425416,
-0.058614824,
0.1963320076,
0.0033694152,
-0.0025329499,
-0.2527662516,
0.4437980652,
0.2834156752,
-0.5233710408,
-0.0641781092,
0.545999825,
-0.0064299693,
-0.382327795,
0.5679470897,
-0.2500272989,
-0.6241922379,
0.8181931376,
0.7835891247,
0.4041290283,
-0.7948650718,
0.3058769107,
-0.0331860781,
0.7513341308,
-0.1899631321,
0.7470707297,
0.3034529388,
-0.5311986208,
-0.114253886,
-0.1979603767,
-0.5237062573,
0.5126700401,
-0.6944970489,
0.0838970765,
-0.3964291513,
0.0304874368,
-0.4742473364,
0.0747212395,
-0.7233135104,
0.5308526158,
-0.0585618652,
0.9060798287,
-0.6369022727,
0.3451218605,
0.6060171723,
-0.7119495869,
-0.7409545779,
-0.2446836978,
-0.5289095044,
-0.5831395388,
0.2488210648,
0.2739591002,
0.2531089485,
0.1652040333,
-0.4019602239,
-0.8118275404,
0.9203259349,
0.1609579325,
-0.2757542729,
0.2363112867,
0.4178366661,
0.4415279329,
-0.4173922241,
0.6713836789,
0.6670006514,
0.570967555,
-0.0650082603,
-0.9208315015,
0.0016814407,
-0.1344215423,
0.0569733009,
0.2004961818,
-0.8034502864,
0.9909860492,
-0.1630873978,
-0.0212919693,
0.174935624,
0.3744526803,
0.5949082375,
0.5412815213,
0.6552644968,
0.3313661814,
0.7212440968,
0.0377645195,
0.9171538949,
-0.1591571718,
0.2673954368,
1.1951624155,
-0.79313761,
0.8967837095,
0.451931715,
0.0438296907,
0.4777204692,
0.826782763,
0.0630867183,
0.4422159791,
0.6371182799,
-0.0796315819,
-0.4287133515,
-0.202948153,
-0.4363842905,
0.28266114,
0.5217007995,
-0.1000598222,
-0.0926526114,
0.4492247105,
-0.246778816,
0.0301791467,
-0.279967308,
0.6189525723,
-0.0442712791,
-0.841103971,
0.5499518514,
-0.4614031017,
0.1820228845,
-0.8871595263,
0.0097771799,
-0.3876634836,
-0.0054237186,
0.1845853776,
-0.4977275431,
0.0470858328,
-0.229328528,
-0.0839262381,
0.0355676152,
0.9722607136,
-0.5997709632,
-0.6096773744,
0.0815081447,
0.4934573472,
0.1196286306,
-0.0927620456,
-0.7170205116,
-0.2169358581,
-0.2269378901,
-0.7520026565,
0.2874740362,
0.1127605662,
-0.1004340053,
1.0660151243,
0.4763741791,
-0.1632125676,
0.2920658886,
-0.1416891515,
0.6531143188,
-0.6457902193,
-0.3933150172,
-0.8070849776,
0.70127666,
0.1620394588,
-0.351806879,
0.2845784724,
0.3269149065,
0.7346301079,
-0.2890355885,
0.8719510436,
-0.112762399,
0.6980686784,
-0.4906730652,
0.3975071013,
-0.4751119018,
0.1998388618,
-0.0389273241,
-0.6065715551,
-0.3068632782,
0.3478117287,
-0.3252189755,
0.2353273183,
1.0294787884,
0.8534688354,
-0.1145181507,
-0.1499759704,
0.2617966533,
0.1986045688,
0.1903700382,
1.0179309845,
1.0681128502,
-0.2379292995,
0.8357151151,
-0.4041412771,
-0.1368965656,
-0.1022452042,
-0.7306123972,
-1.1612380743,
-0.549100697,
-0.4490613341,
-0.2868159413,
0.0548993647,
1.0264987946,
0.5356777906,
-0.9050965309,
-0.1998249888,
-0.2174304426,
0.3702490628,
-0.6350250244,
-0.2510714233,
0.5225799084,
-0.4831417501,
-0.5738780499,
0.4257118702,
-0.027177101,
0.2135463506,
-0.0233368929,
0.1503731757,
-0.3018262982,
0.3818870187,
0.3748042881,
0.2053493261,
-0.6054404378,
-0.459468931,
0.1448116302,
0.2252000272,
0.0714847818,
0.9037340283,
-0.6359305978,
0.5081543326,
0.4319999218,
0.3410769403,
0.0083677899,
0.421015054,
0.4767890275,
-0.7616544366,
0.0101000173,
0.3623654246,
0.2638057172,
0.1103104278,
-0.4358566105,
0.5609036684,
0.2142755389,
-0.687517345,
-1.0477526188,
0.3698982298,
-0.8042424321,
-0.4195250273,
1.1224412918,
-0.2647351623,
-0.0434221141,
-0.3549516201,
-0.529215157,
0.0305714384,
0.0410498753,
0.9725515246,
0.8931174278,
-0.372564882,
-0.3479373753,
-0.74078089,
0.5584873557,
0.835842073,
-0.7127349973,
0.0795309469,
0.1475678235,
0.501157999,
0.3496805131,
0.7099932432,
0.2190147191,
0.4602876008,
-0.4097735584,
0.0558063611,
-0.1118357554,
-0.4840183258,
0.0240664389,
0.5235489011,
0.0331051424,
-0.3121136129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04787v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04787v2
|
Ever-Evolving Memory by Blending and Refining the Past
| 2024-03-03T08:12:59 | 2024-04-07T04:31:30 |
Seo Hyun Kim, Keummin Ka, Yohan Jo, Seung-won Hwang, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
For a human-like chatbot, constructing a long-term memory is crucial.
However, current large language models often lack this capability, leading to
instances of missing important user information or redundantly asking for the
same information, thereby diminishing conversation quality. To effectively
construct memory, it is crucial to seamlessly connect past and present
information, while also possessing the ability to forget obstructive
information. To address these challenges, we propose CREEM, a novel memory
system for long-term conversation. Improving upon existing approaches that
construct memory based solely on current sessions, CREEM blends past memories
during memory formation. Additionally, we introduce a refining process to
handle redundant or outdated information. Unlike traditional paradigms, we view
responding and memory construction as inseparable tasks. The blending process,
which creates new memories, also serves as a reasoning step for response
generation by informing the connection between past and present. Through
evaluation, we demonstrate that CREEM enhances both memory and response
qualities in multi-session personalized dialogues.
|
[
-0.2940884829,
-1.1671686172,
0.548497498,
0.1002997905,
0.0185814109,
0.6423237324,
-0.3773689568,
-0.5048886538,
0.4003149271,
0.7488711476,
-0.5698962212,
-0.3276071548,
0.0376326367,
-0.4451339245,
-0.2730753422,
0.8965784311,
0.2016248703,
-0.3088261187,
-0.1090413257,
-0.371558398,
-1.0901920795,
-0.7779302001,
-0.9805372953,
-0.3665671945,
0.3716059923,
0.3627741635,
0.7768833637,
0.2057708353,
-0.0914215222,
0.3190512061,
-0.0319811292,
0.3728414774,
-0.698466897,
0.5974190831,
-0.2920233309,
-0.5395175219,
-0.748801589,
-0.2831306756,
0.4268527925,
0.6842563748,
-0.2768425345,
-0.1728501916,
0.0297987349,
0.4996631444,
-0.5755476356,
-0.1784496009,
-1.1043833494,
0.105357185,
0.0447117276,
-0.3196634352,
-0.5553743839,
-0.2676566541,
0.2318012416,
-0.2687035799,
0.2086493969,
0.0585759655,
0.7476860881,
-0.2691363096,
-0.1050506383,
-0.2840383947,
-1.1488125324,
0.8946129084,
-0.5580087304,
0.0994199663,
0.3002855182,
0.3894505203,
-0.300164938,
-0.6673312187,
-0.5323633552,
-0.0513918288,
0.2132475376,
0.315651834,
-0.1292948723,
-0.0057418738,
-0.1905960292,
0.2490134388,
-0.3387588561,
-0.2615365982,
-0.6211479306,
-0.3313294947,
0.3302156627,
0.5164917111,
0.5005579591,
0.0570717342,
-0.7627492547,
0.1492601782,
-0.4986000657,
-0.2322205603,
0.2117777467,
0.3099897206,
0.2251718789,
0.1024909616,
0.0080523752,
0.5723475814,
0.0334725752,
-0.163487792,
0.1914459467,
-0.0636417493,
-0.2143296301,
0.1149221808,
0.7565636039,
0.4970355928,
0.0082828747,
-0.341135025,
0.0467436463,
-0.1516419798,
0.4603971243,
-0.5441252589,
-0.4355996847,
0.2820705175,
-0.5187141299,
0.0725973397,
0.0412568487,
-0.7138305306,
-0.0623471364,
-0.0084062731,
0.59357512,
-0.7616171837,
-0.4094316959,
0.2083543092,
-0.1945669204,
0.2405104041,
0.44540447,
-0.8632760048,
0.4305766821,
0.3252616525,
0.8232780099,
-0.399273634,
-0.1848823875,
-0.4939134717,
0.5086401105,
-0.165941596,
0.7189170718,
-0.6013778448,
-0.6505587101,
0.0257057473,
-0.1768060923,
0.2351137996,
-0.9777835608,
0.221498847,
-0.4447206855,
0.6653769612,
0.3647644222,
-0.5305566192,
-0.1423026174,
0.1964918375,
-0.3359618485,
1.0151221752,
0.5301105976,
-0.1090875268,
0.1785535961,
-0.4794736505,
-0.540294826,
0.3716192245,
-0.1463995278,
-0.3338484168,
0.0891394913,
-0.0224937797,
0.2717221677,
-0.0430247411,
0.3816183507,
-0.127751708,
-0.2346956134,
0.4164063036,
-0.3887627423,
0.4174697995,
0.2137047946,
0.0673093349,
0.0718934387,
-0.4312676787,
0.4485057294,
-0.1079535112,
-0.3215206861,
-0.0463331155,
-0.0064566061,
-0.1217291877,
0.1096197441,
0.3152855933,
-0.5888483524,
0.0111895613,
-0.4177531004,
0.8263608217,
0.791896224,
0.0424388498,
0.3851707876,
-0.652167201,
0.2740176618,
0.2934794426,
0.4084263146,
-0.9752181768,
-0.3221172988,
-1.157017231,
0.1781302989,
-0.1724275798,
0.4810798764,
-0.3081809878,
0.5808971524,
-0.153594166,
-0.0587971061,
-0.1772358865,
0.2745637894,
0.0028948816,
0.5000924468,
0.5747064948,
-0.6204431057,
-0.7807857394,
-0.853567481,
-0.0437583327,
-0.4500044584,
-0.3380950391,
0.4574741125,
-0.0930911303,
-0.2731157839,
1.2308613062,
-0.6336277127,
-0.1312025189,
-0.282340616,
-0.0254104454,
-0.0610804372,
0.4262587428,
0.2520450056,
-0.5053107738,
-0.3719234169,
-0.2014054656,
-0.4868537784,
0.3492630124,
-0.5910385251,
-0.3753220737,
0.2126041502,
0.5986588597,
-0.7222084403,
0.2250835747,
0.3017413616,
-0.2229397148,
0.1998589933,
-0.2382928878,
0.1178392917,
-1.1916465759,
-0.370654881,
-0.6635591984,
-0.363409251,
-0.4888490736,
-0.5323889852,
0.0832432285,
-0.2768504322,
-0.6085766554,
1.0083823204,
-0.6450001001,
0.4076840878,
-0.4866057932,
0.2696873844,
-0.0130718565,
0.7037332058,
-0.1685236394,
0.4694612026,
0.5485494733,
-0.7239271402,
0.4080932736,
0.1368920803,
-0.0392292589,
0.7987417579,
-0.3104998171,
0.4320374727,
-0.067736946,
0.1468020529,
-1.1441552639,
-0.178700909,
0.2373423427,
-0.5237686038,
0.450271219,
0.0577824637,
-0.1341236383,
-0.315110147,
-0.1938024759,
0.3494002819,
1.0025509596,
-0.4640985429,
1.0834200382,
0.3955108821,
-0.405241251,
0.0000388731,
-0.522382617,
0.6392190456,
-0.2847502232,
-0.7760850191,
0.5201494694,
-0.3104423285,
-0.0747077689,
-0.1383666396,
-0.2416905463,
-0.1392584741,
-0.2164025158,
0.3874981403,
0.4602689445,
-0.3541671634,
0.407497257,
-0.042590145,
-0.0051657883,
-0.1085534096,
-0.2805889845,
1.1225229502,
0.0052663046,
-0.206897676,
-0.4571522772,
0.4870010316,
0.4888921678,
0.0483825356,
0.6593329906,
0.4616732597,
-0.1362354457,
-0.3653096855,
-1.0266616344,
-0.3036589026,
-0.5231356621,
0.3632020652,
-0.1356978863,
-0.9904914498,
0.5454399586,
-0.2076337487,
0.0695886761,
0.2023160458,
0.5168756843,
-0.3672975898,
0.6636921763,
0.4019493461,
-0.0822066441,
0.7705997825,
0.266009897,
0.2802411914,
-0.929779768,
-0.3418625891,
0.0571911708,
-0.4316585362,
-0.0968418941,
-0.402901113,
-0.0228512697,
0.299513191,
-0.4859974384,
0.1724928916,
-0.4255430102,
0.6020871401,
0.4149381816,
0.3789676428,
0.2808896601,
-0.1742859185,
0.3672060966,
0.0701296031,
-0.5233949423,
-0.6501220465,
0.9195976853,
0.1303748339,
1.0482347012,
0.0013428845,
0.7272703052,
0.3140991032,
0.2889287472,
-0.5579238534,
0.7436192036,
0.2494941652,
-0.372990042,
-0.1320627332,
-0.2794222832,
-1.2114101648,
0.0386232138,
-0.1153427288,
-0.923605442,
-0.4416509569,
0.3150224388,
-0.637810111,
0.4069051445,
-0.8877131939,
0.427280724,
-0.4361535907,
-0.3772742152,
-0.2314175069,
-0.8456825614,
0.3260252178,
0.2321458906,
-0.2382128239,
-0.3296997249,
-0.0876392722,
0.4243305624,
-0.2141805887,
0.9257095456,
0.1457581669,
0.1880103052,
0.5941264033,
0.255015403,
0.0679483712,
0.1897427589,
0.2525331676,
-0.081484966,
-0.224639833,
-0.449699074,
-0.7670099735,
0.7731169462,
-0.5254101753,
-0.9414615631,
-0.1163261905,
-0.5061782598,
-0.3234370053,
0.033873722,
-0.1104826406,
0.2138518989,
-0.6354793906,
0.1327763945,
0.8000778556,
-0.5184521675,
0.4936636984,
0.3816868067,
-0.4742413461,
-0.4524084628,
0.5864405632,
-0.4313248992,
0.662759304,
0.3516622484,
0.121735923,
0.0968039334,
-0.3036741912,
-0.2675049305,
0.0327657051,
-0.4278087914,
-0.4401593506,
-0.8994028568,
-0.5391887426,
-0.0709429756,
-0.1638735086,
-0.3822266757,
-0.2921907008,
-0.166351378,
0.1134345904,
0.4266423583,
0.3374579847,
0.2143386006,
0.2935224473,
-1.0127111673,
0.3724584281,
0.5448766351,
0.2633444071,
0.1929574311,
-0.3838423193,
-0.1059772223,
0.2887262404,
-0.7072286606,
-0.5957790613,
0.2984942794,
0.380633533,
0.6094241738,
0.2289257348,
-0.2129800171,
0.7709969282,
-0.5538542867,
1.036213398,
0.5894382596,
-0.7615950108,
0.7047977448,
-0.2446564734,
0.6631623507,
0.3819600642,
-0.2184816003,
-0.8526903987,
-0.6065915823,
-0.7344064713,
-1.052043438,
0.4309323728,
0.104550764,
0.9071288705,
-0.4826166928,
0.4859104455,
0.273938328,
0.0312674791,
-0.3498957455,
-0.0995427668,
-0.0418950729,
-0.0849200264,
0.227913186,
-0.2519183159,
-0.1147011518,
-0.0560711622,
0.2924161553,
0.1519518644,
0.3800927997,
-0.2070527226,
-0.0656443536,
0.0418809764,
0.3951989412,
0.416085273,
0.7111491561,
-0.1773282588,
0.0709020346,
0.3431788087,
-0.4080475271,
-0.0252318922,
-0.6034443974,
0.081139937,
-0.0372769795,
-0.011438692,
0.6293427348,
0.2441829592,
-0.8946265578,
0.2674703002,
-0.1040275171,
0.036326468,
-0.5255900621,
0.6486680508,
0.5284155011,
0.2465455532,
0.6714041233,
0.205885157,
-0.3200016916,
-1.1849457026,
0.2624217272,
0.5040910244,
-0.4452121556,
-0.2608887255,
0.5695416927,
0.4252724946,
-0.6908895373,
0.9198997021,
0.1611040682,
-0.3572019041,
0.1703069359,
0.7272297144,
0.8342675567,
-0.4842959046,
0.1726331711,
0.417283982,
-0.3004935682,
-0.2279180884,
0.2104606479,
-0.2873818874,
-0.7889390588,
-0.0359207056,
-0.4941028655,
-0.3281241953,
0.171698615,
-0.5293595195,
0.1040193588,
-0.5499700904,
-0.5023675561,
-0.4676772058,
-0.4060999155,
-0.547121942,
0.1220065951,
-0.0461220071,
0.4086765051,
-0.2519055307,
0.5840623975,
0.0875245109,
-0.2209694088,
-0.1714481413,
-0.0803650841,
-0.2966941893,
-0.9027455449,
0.3956446648,
0.1095613316,
-0.4010951221,
-0.3136418164,
-0.479662329,
-0.7435871363,
1.0760102272,
0.289154917,
-0.4860032201,
-0.2116539627,
-0.1746156812,
0.4968012273,
-0.3584258556,
0.099571228,
0.3770223856,
-0.0656280592,
0.4491503537,
-0.7658151984,
-0.1343421042,
-0.1204302162,
0.116597116,
0.6970916986,
-0.8810415268,
0.8986542821,
-0.3488313258,
-0.8304234743,
0.4316979349,
0.9849054813,
-0.0289442595,
0.0179090872,
0.2090897858,
0.2133698761,
0.8825622201,
-0.0430319458,
0.3921696246,
-0.2881049514,
-0.1276947409,
1.5991439819,
-0.3539145887,
0.8475795388,
0.502725184,
-0.1054659486,
0.6719917655,
0.1594692767,
0.1869607866,
0.2675337195,
0.2290336192,
-0.5053656697,
-0.2741725445,
0.1989715993,
-0.2352989763,
0.3415248394,
0.4173365235,
-0.3289535344,
-0.1411184072,
0.1694741845,
0.1267490983,
0.1931415051,
-0.1120098606,
0.807956636,
0.0181598682,
-0.7722566724,
0.4543949068,
-0.3572963476,
0.9159650207,
-0.7121492624,
-0.0332977362,
-0.4675281942,
0.2661786675,
-0.0991276726,
-0.9407627583,
0.3700256944,
-0.3149484098,
-0.0555509403,
-0.3543777764,
0.6445439458,
-0.7493478656,
-0.1732422411,
0.1700991243,
0.8221868277,
0.0425467193,
0.087109603,
-0.41367957,
0.1221640632,
-0.0277933571,
0.0192142576,
0.3796087801,
0.4400422871,
0.0535120256,
0.8845340014,
0.3838376403,
0.0139133465,
-0.0050448296,
0.0356674269,
0.7106118202,
-1.096339345,
-0.3472223878,
-1.0184592009,
0.3830669522,
-0.2657726109,
-0.4889950454,
0.6726712584,
0.8336269855,
0.7182824016,
0.1326697022,
0.8503508568,
0.1389517039,
0.5688454509,
-0.6150789261,
0.5956665277,
-0.1412618011,
0.0305904709,
0.0678105876,
-0.7667586803,
-0.1707507372,
0.5276371241,
0.2378726751,
0.2539251745,
0.5767408609,
0.6950133443,
-0.0616919324,
0.119103156,
0.5161221027,
0.136995241,
0.5037133694,
0.9756746888,
1.1655085087,
-0.2388812751,
0.7819052339,
0.3708106577,
0.0554772168,
-0.0440533943,
-0.5399278402,
-0.9733929634,
-0.7573443055,
-0.1984378994,
-0.3039672375,
0.0946602821,
0.7532736659,
0.7436693311,
-0.4161642492,
-0.4100885391,
0.2312068343,
-0.1773678809,
0.0159657244,
-0.2525409162,
0.1307659149,
-0.5815215707,
-0.582899332,
0.310225755,
0.9549391866,
0.2712514102,
-0.4527748823,
-0.0453521721,
0.0227950811,
0.2739174962,
0.8208656907,
0.5056317449,
-0.7518507838,
-0.4256176949,
0.1528608352,
-0.117774412,
0.8772396445,
0.9005767107,
-1.0319205523,
0.8016535044,
0.1543697566,
0.3978180885,
0.8364858627,
-0.0498666726,
0.9546619058,
-0.3940795362,
0.0622800887,
0.5862840414,
0.1293947101,
0.4934798181,
-0.1698465943,
0.18141976,
-0.2226365358,
-0.4292956591,
-0.5340993404,
0.4887676239,
-1.070515871,
-0.4708028436,
0.8378185034,
0.243513912,
-0.2100635618,
-0.4463769794,
-0.6381022334,
-0.0129166916,
-0.5890597701,
0.9921232462,
0.8872358799,
-0.7044913173,
-0.1891020387,
-0.3201652169,
0.3778715134,
0.2504460216,
-0.7966048121,
0.0443922319,
0.5020419359,
0.3604129851,
0.1613311619,
1.0195055008,
-0.1093978509,
0.2281504422,
0.0811174437,
-0.138714835,
0.2069295496,
-0.17491965,
0.42861709,
0.1805617809,
-0.0993131474,
-0.1255034804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01432v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01432v2
|
Fine Tuning vs. Retrieval Augmented Generation for Less Popular Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T08:07:55 | 2024-03-07T11:24:09 |
Heydar Soudani, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) memorize a vast amount of factual knowledge,
exhibiting strong performance across diverse tasks and domains. However, it has
been observed that the performance diminishes when dealing with less-popular or
low-frequency concepts and entities, for example in domain specific
applications. The two prominent approaches to enhance the performance of LLMs
on low-frequent topics are: Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) and
fine-tuning (FT) over synthetic data. This paper explores and evaluates the
impact of RAG and FT on customizing LLMs in handling low-frequency entities on
question answering task. Our findings indicate that FT significantly boosts the
performance across entities of varying popularity, especially in the most and
least popular groups, while RAG surpasses other methods. Additionally, the
success of both RAG and FT approaches is amplified by advancements in retrieval
and data augmentation techniques. We release our data and code at
https://github.com/informagi/RAGvsFT.
|
[
-0.9747627974,
-1.1961870193,
0.5276532769,
-0.2130381614,
-0.1554415524,
0.3600243032,
-0.4372876287,
-0.6797919869,
0.2974179983,
0.6424896717,
-0.3964816332,
-0.2796519101,
-0.3254663944,
0.1958042085,
-0.2558958232,
1.0565037727,
0.14044936,
-0.1810984462,
-0.3966743946,
-0.2711043358,
-0.5822923779,
-0.4359326363,
-0.7514545321,
-0.3523335159,
0.6015805006,
0.6574254036,
0.6589705944,
0.7249471545,
0.500223577,
0.2853327394,
-0.3275723159,
0.8273714781,
-0.9349777102,
0.2296705395,
-0.3386332393,
-0.391153723,
-0.4517278075,
-0.2232127786,
0.4113312364,
0.8792336583,
-0.1381726563,
0.4259036779,
-0.0096443435,
0.7999557257,
-0.7041583657,
-0.2086113095,
-1.1477066278,
-0.39699018,
-0.272539407,
-0.4779581428,
-0.1727072895,
-0.2968564332,
0.0159700271,
-0.8736172318,
0.4960304499,
0.3303830922,
0.8821433783,
0.5156559944,
-0.1268248409,
-0.2825966775,
-1.0246064663,
0.886052072,
-0.4114203453,
0.4863010943,
0.3686423004,
0.2300486565,
-0.1778162569,
-0.59610641,
-0.5631978512,
-0.0833953321,
-0.0540759452,
-0.0816021785,
-0.1069391295,
-0.002306863,
0.4392411411,
0.5946636796,
-0.2736619115,
0.1032181829,
-0.3984558582,
0.0044836956,
0.5909039974,
0.2610791326,
0.027426729,
-0.2453624755,
-0.1848785877,
0.1197899878,
-0.8939079642,
-0.0894126371,
0.1597167403,
0.4652136862,
0.1782401949,
0.6925750375,
-0.5996909142,
0.8809433579,
0.4043833613,
-0.1248796955,
0.1391631514,
-0.3673492372,
-0.2835772932,
-0.2011906952,
0.2400425076,
0.3240525126,
0.3248106837,
-0.2471945584,
-0.4184427559,
-0.3465124667,
0.1777497381,
-0.6848113537,
0.0364189297,
-0.2101366669,
-0.3049408197,
0.0189321712,
-0.2334003747,
-0.7165292501,
-0.5270503759,
-0.8462216258,
0.461305052,
-0.3954338431,
0.0969889387,
-0.0307281371,
-0.1466596425,
0.1281351447,
0.6359272599,
-0.9019731879,
0.3353763819,
1.0537593365,
0.681656599,
-0.3281422257,
0.1239778623,
-0.7404107451,
0.1116437465,
-0.3661975861,
0.9857013226,
-0.7397475243,
-0.3581680357,
-0.2414665818,
-0.2083248645,
-0.0735882074,
-0.8941708207,
0.3803266585,
-0.9843699336,
0.0077355294,
-0.4520662129,
-0.7158869505,
0.0877120569,
0.201398924,
-0.6519941092,
1.1753274202,
0.2305294722,
-0.5775096416,
0.4659781158,
-0.3888544142,
-0.4725773633,
0.0899141207,
-0.0464029275,
-0.2214650065,
0.3003902435,
0.1578243822,
0.3734982312,
-0.5903096795,
-0.1036895365,
-0.3460979462,
-0.7052687407,
0.1929628253,
-0.2842965126,
0.0720598325,
0.580452323,
0.1281602979,
-0.2880526483,
-0.9112098217,
0.0886595398,
-0.1441497058,
-0.6113266945,
-0.6754490733,
-0.0104130423,
-0.1193507686,
-0.0848698914,
0.2789399326,
-0.4263655245,
0.1869170368,
-0.8002379537,
0.1899098754,
0.5418138504,
0.532581687,
0.6595155001,
-0.7855423093,
0.4223660827,
-0.131454289,
-0.1921728104,
0.220812887,
-0.3716794848,
-0.7169135809,
-0.0637913644,
0.414914459,
0.458406806,
-1.1189479828,
-0.1642803699,
-0.3452112079,
-0.5236631632,
-0.7666430473,
0.5569645762,
0.3264352083,
0.7347446084,
0.5922147036,
-0.0011056997,
-0.6440592408,
-0.9157966375,
-0.5393758416,
0.0790338293,
-0.0874372423,
0.8230947852,
0.1325936317,
-0.2003399134,
0.900241971,
-0.669539988,
-0.1887295991,
-0.314026624,
-0.0646909773,
0.2503438294,
0.4082459807,
0.5842837095,
-0.7777190804,
-0.6737260818,
0.0779825747,
-0.0153981932,
-0.0343094505,
0.1055871695,
-0.1470158398,
0.5685025454,
0.4757690728,
-0.5648589134,
0.1246474236,
0.2819261551,
0.0930067748,
0.166723296,
-0.0803611651,
0.425544709,
-1.0380398035,
0.0173480771,
-0.0577116311,
-0.2276352197,
-0.8675354123,
0.0248309243,
-0.1439637542,
0.1934408844,
-0.4450923502,
0.7248978615,
-0.3134345114,
0.0631876662,
-0.302857995,
0.2444965392,
0.0905014575,
0.2986878455,
-0.158383891,
1.172917366,
0.0758003369,
-0.988666594,
0.0481272414,
0.2236384749,
-0.4890810251,
0.3316666186,
-0.6770626307,
0.2581713796,
-0.2984499633,
-0.3300838768,
-0.8095923662,
-0.4170431793,
-0.1594846547,
-0.4265787899,
0.4685123265,
-0.369340688,
-0.6029971242,
-0.0238106418,
-0.2871110141,
0.2002182901,
0.6726910472,
-0.4321312904,
0.3838927746,
0.4426043034,
-0.0421223417,
-0.4225510955,
-0.5917242169,
-0.3189570904,
-0.4490619302,
-0.6020022631,
0.3673205376,
-0.0836534947,
-0.4539949,
-0.1978742778,
-0.2401261777,
-0.1102272123,
0.2629151344,
-0.0359420776,
0.1989603639,
-0.4715716243,
0.4432017505,
0.0757581666,
0.0308757275,
-0.4521249533,
0.0314687267,
0.6119486094,
-0.0914856195,
-0.1980107874,
0.1610698402,
0.1665249467,
0.2807894647,
-0.2513937652,
0.8736639619,
0.5555677414,
-0.2914308608,
-0.4208620787,
-0.8813093305,
-0.2416210324,
-0.5319653153,
0.1188033074,
-0.452350527,
-1.188362956,
0.4119823873,
-0.2502304614,
-0.0007541048,
0.4820152521,
0.6534863114,
-0.2999178171,
0.946182549,
0.5753124356,
0.0250621177,
0.5890985131,
-0.1088467762,
0.0135980565,
-0.917604804,
0.1458425671,
-0.5953718424,
-0.3539092541,
-0.8650327921,
-0.5515191555,
0.4575334489,
0.4145846665,
-0.1889693141,
0.0931063741,
-0.5578629971,
0.5898869038,
0.6138210297,
0.1008214355,
0.6148158908,
0.3177926242,
0.2695433497,
-0.0761936009,
-0.7577682137,
-0.4605102837,
1.1116353273,
0.0680409372,
0.896767199,
0.148724854,
0.7142288089,
0.0825740695,
0.2334278822,
-0.6815931797,
0.4693131447,
-0.5973406434,
-0.6999121904,
-0.3728631139,
-0.5295260549,
-1.0193192959,
0.0360070169,
-0.4026280642,
-0.4456731677,
0.2641534805,
0.4272361696,
-0.4744847119,
0.1807270497,
-0.8015284538,
0.3277466893,
0.163156867,
-0.2880057693,
-0.2819648087,
-0.2292689979,
0.3311759233,
-0.2414805889,
0.1177345216,
-0.0644948781,
-0.1598903239,
0.5578997731,
-0.2587428391,
0.5299384594,
-0.1593532711,
0.1297029704,
0.4084244967,
-0.0271518081,
0.7340903282,
0.3019257188,
-0.3511604965,
-0.2716056406,
0.057289537,
-0.2285778672,
-0.7412023544,
0.964594841,
-0.7070602179,
-0.8853929639,
0.0908477306,
-0.6252746582,
-0.6730160117,
0.1299742311,
0.1912273616,
0.3212625384,
-0.0102204001,
0.4690670967,
1.1407231092,
-0.2219970822,
0.0921185166,
0.7040554881,
-0.0775513127,
-0.3787950873,
1.1128150225,
0.3652582765,
0.5019850731,
0.4361847639,
-0.0173614863,
-0.044644054,
-0.7454111576,
-0.3917422891,
0.369767338,
-0.6333810687,
-0.3638390601,
-0.6853766441,
-0.1550820321,
-0.3669953346,
-0.0728394091,
-0.3563030362,
-0.7627447248,
-0.5108062625,
0.0810096338,
0.9019585252,
0.5709702373,
0.0684513897,
0.0947381556,
-0.7503762245,
0.665071249,
0.2635619044,
0.5148237944,
-0.1303810626,
-0.6063172221,
-0.3499721289,
0.1221333519,
-0.1069869474,
-0.4398462772,
0.1124412864,
0.3494973481,
0.4728500545,
0.0060105058,
0.1610673517,
1.0104398727,
-0.4973164201,
0.5377406478,
-0.3781939149,
-0.5296593308,
0.3447456956,
-0.4208316505,
0.1732377261,
0.9221046567,
0.2283247113,
-0.4905282855,
-0.4496450126,
-0.504793942,
-0.8446239233,
0.7147548199,
0.0357280672,
0.2640174925,
0.0092234164,
0.7421936989,
0.1573148072,
0.4894105494,
-0.0496540144,
-0.4965869486,
0.1702564806,
-0.0804361999,
-0.1744405925,
-0.2206754237,
-0.0818892866,
-0.313912034,
0.6885755658,
-0.1356867999,
0.1910464913,
0.1667509079,
-0.2166010588,
-0.3786423206,
0.4038651884,
0.7203068137,
0.589186132,
-0.1967620999,
-0.0784795061,
0.6020894647,
-0.3935258687,
-0.1692241132,
0.1667930782,
-0.6569619179,
-0.009849349,
0.1993933469,
0.8594715595,
0.0780384541,
-0.5351019502,
-0.0702731833,
0.1946323216,
-0.1150165424,
-0.1388959289,
0.5118771195,
0.1198258325,
0.2530540526,
0.3749408722,
0.2066791952,
0.1349250972,
-0.5405697823,
0.1390432715,
0.6041423082,
-0.0381118357,
-0.0812468454,
0.5180469155,
-0.0258217063,
-0.1373059154,
0.2048690021,
-0.1820332855,
-0.1571862847,
0.5383102298,
0.3256960511,
0.3844851255,
0.0601808354,
0.0653172955,
0.274938792,
0.2445461154,
0.025901353,
0.3801527619,
-0.0681996495,
-0.6523734331,
-0.6235886216,
-0.9018222094,
-0.3745551705,
0.3213840723,
-0.5452234745,
0.2827545404,
-0.4216584265,
-0.1307911724,
0.0988174975,
0.3451178372,
-0.7835886478,
0.2454219013,
-0.1010065749,
0.8842915297,
-0.3475391269,
0.735078156,
1.010994792,
-0.3453937173,
-0.8476291895,
-0.0193607993,
-0.2446169704,
-0.7641078234,
0.5979332328,
-0.4101454616,
-0.022837162,
0.2964541912,
-0.3850613534,
-1.2756999731,
1.1014182568,
0.3139337301,
-0.5372881293,
0.0045361123,
0.2918897867,
0.8758589029,
-0.2417293638,
-0.0583151504,
0.7765600085,
0.4703241289,
0.2404842079,
-0.9506033659,
-0.1167076379,
0.074247472,
0.1516426355,
0.4240792394,
-0.7351524234,
0.7827194929,
-0.0485430919,
-0.3605360985,
0.1261138171,
0.5828027725,
0.4268918633,
0.5259262323,
0.4602815211,
0.4534273744,
0.9038284421,
-0.2123811841,
1.1007368565,
-0.3680329323,
0.2328419238,
1.1134884357,
-0.096813485,
0.8245714307,
0.5021576881,
-0.0968281329,
0.0511175133,
0.5204973817,
0.0417412892,
0.5160694718,
0.0715965405,
-0.0450071506,
-0.3809709549,
-0.2375668585,
-0.3418335915,
0.2304876894,
0.5120510459,
-0.144328475,
-0.1842333078,
0.1645187289,
-0.0504369326,
0.2439650744,
-0.5966984034,
1.1453758478,
0.1237061843,
-0.8290073276,
1.0187407732,
0.0595803484,
0.6322159767,
-0.1793820113,
-0.053013932,
-0.4390488863,
0.0750071704,
-0.287620753,
-0.669536829,
0.5169605017,
0.1434503049,
-0.4946615398,
-0.1578342617,
1.0161727667,
-0.3919904828,
-0.2594738007,
-0.0302355811,
0.6812689304,
-0.1728031635,
0.0552813634,
-0.5333940983,
-0.0090500964,
-0.0325643867,
-0.4133915603,
0.4543811679,
0.5643517375,
-0.1572873741,
0.7012399435,
0.7717967033,
0.1922271997,
0.2087329179,
0.1521057338,
1.0911647081,
-0.4398925304,
-0.0004134563,
-0.5060494542,
0.2603256702,
0.0301741548,
-0.1813230515,
0.9217232466,
0.608093679,
0.9058377147,
-0.0929052234,
0.535292387,
0.0167623814,
1.2630308867,
-0.6730024815,
0.5943641663,
-0.8192034364,
0.5731630921,
-0.2361537367,
-0.9971703291,
-0.1038557291,
0.0872038007,
-0.4744826555,
0.1414546669,
0.2458705306,
1.0052011013,
-0.1451913118,
-0.1321448982,
0.3118112385,
0.3330093622,
0.0739564151,
0.2970952392,
0.9041560888,
-0.1926834583,
0.5501796007,
-0.3614409864,
0.1790840626,
-0.273688674,
-0.3992632329,
-0.8630322814,
-0.4548010826,
-0.1681866646,
-0.1651024222,
0.045543883,
0.924626112,
0.4626109302,
-0.8735212088,
0.2107908726,
-0.0356292427,
0.2971149981,
0.0976504162,
-0.2875202596,
0.1231078804,
-0.5310258865,
-0.8268949986,
0.4107495844,
0.0214481018,
0.0362013578,
0.0515929349,
0.0140690645,
-0.1713631302,
0.4225250781,
0.7108091116,
0.3033362925,
-0.636790216,
-0.2830089629,
0.3482437432,
-0.1360858828,
0.0786766559,
0.6777250767,
-0.9753926396,
0.1547245085,
0.749931097,
0.8490766287,
0.5942388177,
0.5726183057,
0.2872392237,
-0.9439770579,
-0.1424906999,
0.2160881907,
0.0386426225,
0.3268720508,
-0.4988628924,
0.4869072437,
0.1145436317,
-0.6963413954,
-1.0499562025,
0.21038948,
-0.8050498366,
-0.3282576203,
1.1811492443,
0.4031624794,
-0.1138249934,
-0.3147408366,
-0.1143434271,
0.1237330437,
-0.4388802648,
0.702942729,
0.5893665552,
-0.2793738246,
-0.0530708022,
-0.8511708379,
0.9368237853,
0.4818091393,
-0.6119596958,
-0.0743566751,
0.5328834653,
0.4706450701,
0.2444780767,
0.4605151117,
0.2322764546,
0.3320043087,
-0.4712624252,
-0.405218035,
-0.2285251021,
-0.1832229346,
-0.1810056269,
0.2118476182,
0.3746825755,
0.2950413227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01411v1
|
OVEL: Large Language Model as Memory Manager for Online Video Entity Linking
| 2024-03-03T06:47:51 | 2024-03-03T06:47:51 |
Haiquan Zhao, Xuwu Wang, Shisong Chen, Zhixu Li, Xin Zheng, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, multi-modal entity linking (MEL) has garnered increasing
attention in the research community due to its significance in numerous
multi-modal applications. Video, as a popular means of information
transmission, has become prevalent in people's daily lives. However, most
existing MEL methods primarily focus on linking textual and visual mentions or
offline videos's mentions to entities in multi-modal knowledge bases, with
limited efforts devoted to linking mentions within online video content. In
this paper, we propose a task called Online Video Entity Linking OVEL, aiming
to establish connections between mentions in online videos and a knowledge base
with high accuracy and timeliness. To facilitate the research works of OVEL, we
specifically concentrate on live delivery scenarios and construct a live
delivery entity linking dataset called LIVE. Besides, we propose an evaluation
metric that considers timelessness, robustness, and accuracy. Furthermore, to
effectively handle OVEL task, we leverage a memory block managed by a Large
Language Model and retrieve entity candidates from the knowledge base to
augment LLM performance on memory management. The experimental results prove
the effectiveness and efficiency of our method.
|
[
-0.6477997899,
-1.0395047665,
0.3543457687,
0.0902175903,
-0.3116582632,
-0.076051414,
-0.5214583874,
-0.5981069207,
0.2750379741,
0.2900227308,
-0.2939622104,
-0.3621869981,
-0.2911017537,
-0.3485263884,
-0.4443852603,
0.7057213783,
-0.3709993958,
0.0591420382,
-0.0973850489,
-0.4116205275,
-0.313387692,
-0.1655065119,
-0.7638030648,
0.2515693903,
0.4745116532,
0.0011212559,
0.5865852237,
0.9166972041,
0.5903352499,
0.294228524,
0.167280376,
0.4577236772,
-0.5073558092,
0.5333656669,
-0.3329467773,
-0.206496045,
-0.8215873837,
-0.732486546,
0.8694575429,
0.3030422926,
-0.2495476902,
0.3417077661,
-0.4083401859,
0.3255851269,
-0.9281213284,
0.187397927,
-0.8735660315,
0.1104171649,
-0.2845228016,
-0.1419969499,
-0.1850777417,
-0.3874435425,
-0.0312003233,
-0.67591995,
0.1228929609,
0.4126292765,
0.677488029,
0.3403403759,
-0.2447439432,
-0.1750488877,
-0.9527513385,
0.5216388106,
-0.5400879979,
0.6576660872,
0.4461471736,
0.7397558093,
0.1299099177,
-0.3946856558,
-0.6791532636,
-0.1542354077,
0.5108844638,
-0.2684639394,
0.2399052233,
0.0729608312,
0.32630229,
0.3704478741,
-0.1764468849,
-0.2100797445,
-0.3140568435,
-0.1273424476,
0.3369506001,
0.1353928596,
0.519425571,
-0.0139174191,
-0.5532582998,
0.3331349194,
-0.746625185,
-0.5601534843,
0.2173922062,
0.176232934,
-0.0643512011,
0.8917688131,
0.013101439,
0.8706151843,
-0.2104000598,
-0.524838388,
0.0923484191,
-0.3241839111,
-0.3577567637,
0.2626042366,
0.6979131699,
0.5491299629,
0.3221517205,
-0.1637718379,
-0.1366423666,
0.1450261772,
0.2934218943,
-0.7870611548,
-0.1468982995,
-0.1513320357,
-0.3347170949,
0.2788016498,
0.1038849652,
-0.8896797895,
-0.3716757894,
-0.008678318,
0.6274942756,
-0.6534310579,
-0.4000273943,
-0.0999071375,
0.3519880474,
-0.1325901002,
0.5495049953,
-0.7354519367,
0.2921790183,
0.3847617507,
0.8289248347,
-0.2333554924,
-0.3647333384,
-1.0413758755,
0.8519843221,
0.1868918091,
0.5647488236,
-0.4410485625,
0.0678367764,
0.5247383714,
-0.0849465653,
-0.1194778681,
-0.4791339338,
0.1905205846,
-0.931894362,
-0.1536195576,
-0.2315525562,
-0.5850815773,
-0.180405736,
0.5784118772,
-0.9322735071,
0.9705070853,
-0.173338607,
-0.6252663136,
0.4733637571,
-0.4885455668,
-0.4170731604,
-0.0896322131,
-0.2670072615,
-0.3385744691,
-0.2244939953,
0.1002618894,
0.5592834353,
-0.3246019185,
0.5781978965,
-0.4901609421,
-0.0949751362,
0.0979480669,
-0.2640319169,
0.1963013262,
0.2354908586,
-0.2786235809,
-0.0416555591,
-0.9637559652,
-0.5064594746,
-0.0208834577,
-0.5347729325,
-0.4401261806,
0.0354811698,
-0.0183208156,
0.330022186,
-0.1240008324,
-0.4766700566,
0.3009670675,
-0.0307656154,
0.4823395312,
0.4778345227,
0.1319522113,
0.5658482909,
0.0321062766,
0.4039314091,
0.0821394175,
0.2637006044,
-0.5365561247,
-0.485176146,
-0.857707262,
-0.2110522538,
0.0087433504,
0.2533593178,
-0.7725260258,
-0.2234468311,
-0.4918104708,
-0.0466760211,
-0.45062536,
0.4472382069,
0.3140152693,
0.5406817794,
0.5605567694,
-0.1610142291,
-0.482874155,
-0.5199882388,
0.0328469388,
-0.2029643506,
0.0061451746,
0.5107371211,
0.3396171033,
-0.1418886781,
0.8894944787,
-0.6682741642,
-0.7364397049,
0.1222522408,
-0.0552967191,
-0.2788777053,
0.030050857,
0.5407446623,
-0.917773962,
-0.4192855358,
-0.107954599,
-0.8424835205,
0.4621832669,
0.0652486831,
-0.1574146003,
0.2560580969,
0.4569486082,
-0.7111960649,
0.2131868303,
0.402392149,
0.0225208513,
0.1362594366,
-0.3627617657,
0.395506829,
-1.0542019606,
-0.0406439863,
0.0705240443,
-0.3278230131,
-0.0920621753,
0.0512065031,
-0.0589737445,
-0.1006757393,
-0.9220664501,
0.6931039095,
-0.6858187318,
-0.4712315798,
0.137252003,
0.5754302144,
-0.2363166362,
0.5255992413,
0.0482903011,
0.5422589779,
0.6819191575,
-0.9702774286,
0.8459755182,
0.231629476,
-0.4471097887,
0.8406361938,
-0.0930264667,
-0.2274664789,
-0.2323352993,
-0.0716755688,
-0.8847270608,
-0.3948295414,
0.3024258316,
-0.2539986372,
0.3538713157,
-0.2464802116,
-0.5083589554,
-0.0586546212,
-0.0597676225,
0.5338911414,
0.2350622714,
-0.3881977797,
0.9637151957,
0.6365935802,
-0.0592188463,
-0.3545681834,
-0.5667933822,
-0.0501937754,
-0.3297956884,
-0.6663285494,
0.4575769603,
-0.0779188275,
-0.3125861287,
0.3670506775,
-0.1229887083,
-0.2895855904,
-0.282212168,
0.3132880926,
0.3123672903,
-0.4189792573,
0.3765030801,
-0.2406817377,
0.111600183,
0.0879092962,
-0.1726257652,
0.3776682913,
0.4072645605,
-0.4877689779,
0.1212583706,
0.4111155272,
0.5556521416,
-0.3604226112,
1.2082121372,
0.7843392491,
-0.7022126913,
-0.0458381027,
-1.0228526592,
0.0214373097,
-0.3837480843,
0.34831357,
-0.1711414754,
-0.8511377573,
0.671644628,
-0.2013979852,
-0.0953563899,
0.1700167358,
0.4198610187,
-0.0519449562,
0.6707981825,
0.4492748976,
-0.1689776331,
0.5933043957,
-0.1740708202,
0.1178296581,
-0.8523608446,
-0.6046359539,
-0.2096922994,
0.053314615,
0.0476045199,
-0.8726481795,
0.4708732069,
0.3143225908,
-0.5762341619,
0.5103477836,
0.0931893736,
0.1395028383,
0.1790852845,
0.0195560735,
0.5730675459,
0.2342154235,
-0.2512949705,
0.0396203026,
-0.6964361072,
-0.1545202732,
0.7349008918,
0.3923362792,
1.0343357325,
0.4315621555,
0.0760093853,
0.4062947631,
0.1177348271,
-0.4937238991,
0.7708958387,
0.4057267308,
-0.7083487511,
-0.3208976984,
-0.2032109946,
-0.5764795542,
-0.1426568478,
-0.4614400268,
-0.7858869433,
-0.4734196365,
0.4578621686,
-0.3839730918,
0.8152598143,
-0.2253158391,
0.8048759103,
-0.4460299015,
-0.7444526553,
-0.3627429605,
-0.7596385479,
0.3710783124,
0.057986334,
0.488622427,
0.0319038704,
-0.2356108129,
0.5326679945,
-0.4110657573,
0.5381734967,
0.011177294,
-0.1312100887,
0.6069709659,
0.1636437327,
0.7187716365,
0.1865527779,
0.093197234,
-0.0884063989,
-0.4791378677,
-0.0390912592,
-0.4593061805,
1.1705439091,
-0.579757154,
-0.2288024276,
-0.1951515377,
-0.1540555358,
-0.2416613847,
0.1319547445,
-0.1483363211,
0.569993794,
-0.2772699893,
0.1218254268,
1.2168812752,
-0.4216173887,
0.7090248466,
0.500490725,
-0.5043689609,
-0.6671087742,
0.9564540386,
0.0544475242,
0.3575361073,
0.8153857589,
-0.360019058,
-0.3015472889,
-0.3648281693,
-0.9093119502,
0.3152466118,
-0.7810257077,
-0.3652724922,
-0.976967752,
-0.0717919916,
-0.3045226336,
-0.0383291207,
-0.6175912619,
0.1689036787,
-0.1636976302,
-0.1824815124,
0.6951853037,
0.3064451218,
0.3874104321,
0.1411143392,
-0.9900935292,
0.6847972274,
0.493124634,
0.7867816687,
0.3947824836,
-0.2147818059,
-0.5314928889,
-0.1818156093,
-0.0722078606,
-1.0601555109,
0.2211426944,
0.4432019293,
0.6260339022,
0.8192408085,
-0.106184572,
0.8126298785,
-0.7371023297,
0.7347280979,
0.2684556544,
-0.6800216436,
0.5408833623,
-0.6420215964,
-0.1081281379,
0.3353345096,
0.5923418999,
-0.3375314176,
-0.0856286362,
-0.3202367425,
-0.9863330126,
0.3765063882,
0.0453126244,
-0.0267471354,
-0.2780648768,
0.1014842987,
-0.0331098363,
0.553617239,
-0.4890471399,
-0.4686850309,
0.0880302861,
0.3456179798,
0.1039167494,
-0.1900082976,
0.0381316431,
0.0113209607,
0.6219163537,
0.0302400552,
0.4185988009,
-0.0889893621,
-0.502325058,
-0.4452649355,
0.1767330915,
0.5911194086,
0.7671836615,
-0.3263170421,
0.1783884317,
0.4540106058,
-0.3844603896,
0.0894766375,
-0.1200559512,
-0.180772841,
0.0791598856,
0.1769459248,
0.9151621461,
0.6989008784,
-0.8444698453,
0.5117961764,
0.3684805632,
0.312060535,
-0.7801195383,
0.0340767242,
0.1717543602,
0.3148646653,
0.3279393315,
0.126538828,
-0.0871591046,
-0.9348111153,
0.0629550815,
0.3161612451,
-0.4427333176,
-0.2167053819,
1.1358731985,
0.3516007364,
-0.4812105894,
0.5460580587,
-0.1513207257,
-0.3661612868,
0.1885176301,
0.4469366074,
0.5910009742,
-0.3138763309,
0.078508608,
0.5042229891,
-0.0663870201,
-0.5037617087,
0.1661883891,
-0.1033940986,
-0.545617938,
-0.6881831288,
-0.6566607952,
-0.1033914089,
0.0724561289,
-0.7058392167,
0.5579618216,
-0.2391928583,
-0.2455649227,
-0.2471870631,
-0.4273155034,
-0.7811154127,
0.4019880593,
0.3101986647,
1.0027040243,
-0.7192649841,
1.0367842913,
0.8703212738,
-0.7802936435,
-0.7723543048,
-0.4001556337,
-0.0883572772,
-0.601585269,
0.5846886039,
-0.2396456003,
-0.1350223422,
-0.0089031039,
0.094361037,
-0.7932651043,
1.2378853559,
0.4453189373,
-0.6209287047,
-0.2761782408,
-0.1075412184,
0.3454088271,
-0.3943199217,
0.4538988769,
-0.1289754808,
0.4292243123,
0.4003441632,
-0.9077754021,
0.0485555641,
0.0658600926,
-0.1110836044,
0.6618720889,
-0.7098662853,
0.7258777618,
-0.2989971638,
-0.0369214676,
-0.2540677786,
0.9138087034,
0.1891710907,
0.4114405513,
0.4139086008,
0.5822510719,
0.338211,
0.3877871633,
0.6933426857,
-0.1955186129,
0.2900403738,
1.3428561687,
-0.4186472893,
1.048281312,
0.5680433512,
-0.1710822284,
0.2977962792,
0.1527715772,
-0.0879388526,
0.5556415319,
0.1012540907,
-0.5300589204,
-0.419793427,
-0.2506664693,
-0.5576794744,
0.0411267802,
0.2685823739,
-0.6434185505,
-0.3391923606,
0.2934922278,
0.0195770934,
0.1672438383,
-0.7706364989,
0.5221253037,
-0.0375820473,
-0.7393992543,
0.1143448651,
0.0310417153,
0.5246424675,
-0.6061386466,
-0.1826316416,
0.0086064152,
0.2984934151,
-0.1394758075,
-0.5015689135,
0.3220928311,
0.2098991424,
-0.1399791837,
0.0183851011,
0.7200620174,
-0.7893291712,
-0.219284296,
0.4641595483,
0.3556262553,
0.1044390127,
-0.1483441442,
-0.373971045,
0.4856026173,
-0.3564275205,
-0.1192042306,
0.6484864354,
0.4115167856,
-0.2624842227,
0.9714425802,
0.2620669603,
0.2593850791,
0.2955042124,
-0.0082961367,
0.9958606362,
-0.7135135531,
-0.3656288087,
-0.9687588811,
0.4111278951,
-0.0722464398,
-0.0710390583,
0.9789868593,
0.9349896908,
1.0067294836,
-0.3415083587,
0.6627887487,
-0.2142723054,
0.2690405846,
-0.5665674806,
0.3889455497,
-0.3770580292,
0.2633329332,
-0.5647429824,
-1.3250813484,
-0.2106777281,
0.4621536136,
-0.0587647073,
-0.0478468612,
0.6681406498,
0.7366928458,
-0.5006006956,
-0.194553718,
0.4194319248,
0.2180391997,
-0.0216428991,
0.5797945857,
0.7143996954,
-0.4550604224,
0.8941887021,
0.0774189532,
0.277112931,
-0.5309789777,
-1.3405944109,
-1.249251008,
-0.5662094355,
-0.6071113944,
-0.3707847297,
0.2202337831,
1.130825758,
0.6999892592,
-0.5579701662,
0.0236774329,
0.2552882433,
-0.1316263974,
-0.100933373,
-0.1142691895,
0.2994780242,
0.3955466747,
-0.5636485815,
0.1637792438,
0.6735836267,
-0.2032321095,
-0.7461237907,
-0.1602185369,
-0.4374159873,
-0.1902821809,
0.5488126874,
0.3838502765,
-0.7021210194,
-0.3358179927,
0.0962121114,
-0.0100187417,
-0.010615197,
0.9359760284,
-0.6259619594,
0.5936875939,
0.6181829572,
0.6321973801,
0.9067103863,
0.0115643069,
0.5116801858,
-0.5069648027,
0.0208281614,
0.0227805749,
0.4379454255,
0.4487605393,
-0.1483236402,
0.2958475649,
0.1881426871,
-0.3209389448,
-0.72224617,
0.1673346758,
-1.1793658733,
0.1654474735,
1.2743418217,
-0.4743337929,
-0.2623651028,
-0.063593857,
-0.2493642718,
0.5857966542,
-0.5615059733,
0.6965799332,
0.4576425254,
0.3129395843,
-0.5094224215,
-1.1071815491,
0.3842586279,
-0.1703969538,
-0.7037281394,
-0.3602755666,
0.6224639416,
0.3839050829,
0.1120536029,
0.6523691416,
0.1487531364,
-0.0184058845,
-0.1025759578,
0.0101103345,
-0.5239185095,
-0.5857918859,
0.2335528433,
0.6213790178,
-0.0478236414,
-0.3206099272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01404v1
|
What Is Missing in Multilingual Visual Reasoning and How to Fix It
| 2024-03-03T05:45:27 | 2024-03-03T05:45:27 |
Yueqi Song, Simran Khanuja, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP models today strive for supporting multiple languages and modalities,
improving accessibility for diverse users. In this paper, we evaluate their
multilingual, multimodal capabilities by testing on a visual reasoning task. We
observe that proprietary systems like GPT-4V obtain the best performance on
this task now, but open models lag in comparison. Surprisingly, GPT-4V exhibits
similar performance between English and other languages, indicating the
potential for equitable system development across languages. Our analysis on
model failures reveals three key aspects that make this task challenging:
multilinguality, complex reasoning, and multimodality. To address these
challenges, we propose three targeted interventions including a translate-test
approach to tackle multilinguality, a visual programming approach to break down
complex reasoning, and a novel method that leverages image captioning to
address multimodality. Our interventions achieve the best open performance on
this task in a zero-shot setting, boosting open model LLaVA by 13.4%, while
also minorly improving GPT-4V's performance.
|
[
-0.2175542116,
-0.6105255485,
0.6104320884,
0.3607520759,
-0.08454144,
0.0229596887,
-0.2009323239,
-0.5794765949,
-0.2488647252,
0.2440785915,
-0.4587601721,
-0.2997719944,
-0.5575600266,
0.2584312558,
-0.0232802201,
0.6687130928,
-0.4977659881,
0.1637093872,
-0.3197899759,
-0.4342173636,
-0.8481036425,
-0.3723193705,
-0.4926425815,
-0.0876592398,
0.4973110557,
0.3837689459,
0.9256786108,
0.1415355951,
0.6927285194,
0.3018425703,
0.2163212746,
0.3833891153,
-0.1023723707,
0.0491205119,
-0.2678546011,
-0.6232110262,
-0.3409046829,
-0.1382791698,
0.4906629622,
0.5645250082,
0.0440590493,
-0.0954202786,
-0.0698523819,
0.3179423511,
-0.6309303045,
0.4721755683,
-0.426620543,
0.1980912387,
-0.0959918946,
-0.0724978,
-0.4042603374,
-0.0727148876,
0.0114323674,
-0.727107048,
0.0789272711,
0.133660689,
1.0043933392,
0.3684062064,
-0.5739780664,
-0.0282508302,
-0.7186760306,
0.9014347792,
-0.6306769252,
0.6120332479,
0.2348426878,
0.3857622743,
0.0161881335,
-0.4539362192,
-0.5958548188,
-0.2598032057,
0.1026446074,
0.2561907768,
-0.3595610857,
-0.121424444,
0.5031012297,
0.0612473078,
-0.8169145584,
-0.146300599,
-0.2660518289,
-0.2544588745,
0.3559759259,
-0.1083430126,
0.7247289419,
-0.2701609731,
-0.2335041612,
-0.027829349,
-0.5487937331,
0.0789314806,
0.3311014175,
0.4118470848,
-0.1794700325,
0.8656921387,
-0.0937013999,
0.8275251389,
-0.6154658198,
-0.3282799721,
0.3794567287,
-0.7021760345,
-0.2883521318,
-0.3935347795,
0.5160800815,
0.4921606183,
0.5143622756,
0.078333959,
-0.3018650115,
0.2456841469,
-0.0217603724,
-0.3256746531,
-0.1689151525,
0.080525279,
-0.3115958273,
0.198075816,
-0.3389304578,
-0.4768703878,
-0.0845738798,
-0.3828465044,
0.5147746801,
-0.6040100455,
-0.4932540357,
0.3476008475,
-0.2684063017,
0.171605885,
0.6434236169,
-0.9631642699,
-0.0334224142,
0.3915168345,
0.8696476221,
-0.0677503273,
-0.4719782174,
-0.4405293167,
0.1094733253,
-0.3962272108,
0.8076148629,
-0.4754033685,
0.047988452,
-0.0617989525,
0.0307346955,
-0.3608522713,
-0.3247406185,
0.3120503724,
-0.1032346934,
0.2567402124,
-0.5031199455,
-0.0837206766,
-0.2367483526,
0.6697128415,
-0.6233330965,
0.6817765236,
-0.042273432,
-0.8239760995,
0.4311963618,
-0.8857690096,
-0.1658685058,
0.1327468157,
-0.3155623376,
-0.1575870067,
-0.0396808349,
0.5716246367,
0.3118548691,
0.047313001,
0.1520880759,
-0.3033716977,
-0.3489418626,
-0.1651153266,
-0.4597864747,
0.7565866113,
0.0323140807,
-0.4585845768,
0.3775517642,
-0.5837370157,
0.0422859937,
0.4192878008,
-0.2584457695,
-0.3197450936,
-0.0615618043,
0.1715469509,
0.3081403673,
-0.0469425581,
-0.4397075176,
0.2409775406,
-0.4265579283,
0.4141223729,
0.7528604269,
-0.3689569533,
0.3665851057,
0.0962466002,
0.8371352553,
0.0791151226,
0.3204759955,
-0.432274431,
-0.9426125884,
-0.814853549,
-0.2213058919,
0.1730626971,
0.7570966482,
-1.4524784088,
-0.4758715332,
-0.1438610107,
-0.058797542,
-0.3797054887,
0.0772142261,
0.4476769567,
0.2763172388,
0.3618210554,
-0.2881490886,
-0.2559861243,
-1.1252535582,
-0.3502069116,
-0.2925562561,
0.0520431362,
0.1684689671,
0.8453757763,
-0.2231722921,
0.3804602623,
-0.2454203367,
-0.2084661424,
-0.3346275091,
0.0033115689,
0.1062563881,
0.3337087929,
0.6108185649,
-0.9506903887,
-0.2899450958,
0.2869319618,
-0.9715984464,
0.0900047719,
-0.2050948143,
0.0628704876,
0.3106431067,
0.3266210556,
-0.5475494862,
0.6255453229,
0.7152735591,
-0.4902066588,
0.7779839635,
-0.4112554193,
0.2710199058,
-0.570002377,
-0.2526397705,
0.128099069,
-0.2431273609,
-0.3848349452,
0.4499305487,
0.196962148,
-0.2223412544,
-0.5060511827,
0.4736299813,
-0.5669196248,
-0.1853468418,
0.0769563541,
0.1629122347,
0.0733050555,
0.4624460638,
-0.102716893,
0.7441958785,
0.6158069372,
-0.1537770182,
0.4697571695,
0.3054459393,
-0.2937650383,
0.6250389218,
-0.6220131516,
-0.2505229115,
-0.2680018842,
0.0187492166,
-0.9217604995,
-0.3429609537,
0.299968183,
-0.2799915075,
0.1203709841,
-0.1628545076,
-0.5964148641,
-0.3683089018,
-0.0183370169,
0.4236517251,
-0.0337559469,
-0.5487807989,
0.7578232288,
0.0812231302,
-0.1612137854,
-0.7846809626,
-0.7294302583,
0.3286449015,
-0.0237756837,
-1.0732744932,
0.0161655694,
-0.0956262648,
-0.3410993814,
-0.0798678249,
-0.0052780295,
-0.08092013,
0.0705119371,
0.0356608927,
0.2879163623,
-0.2022420913,
0.317681253,
-0.0753154308,
-0.0581989214,
-0.141866982,
-0.1628670841,
0.2107877582,
-0.7476960421,
-0.8418507576,
-0.1503059715,
0.563538909,
0.475243777,
-0.6890847087,
0.3700106442,
0.8295974731,
-0.2892599702,
-0.2049941272,
-0.3976920843,
0.0886766464,
-0.3632885516,
0.4331851602,
-0.7217891812,
-0.8606702089,
0.4113027155,
0.1471314579,
0.0374296717,
0.1926726997,
0.6299030781,
-0.0171205942,
1.2035263777,
0.7953665853,
0.5616437197,
0.17423518,
-0.1670045555,
0.5856141448,
-0.4822289646,
-0.382285893,
-0.1444087625,
-0.1945297718,
-0.5703682899,
-0.646677196,
0.5386713743,
0.1211644262,
-0.009085157,
0.2372487187,
-0.3650365174,
0.4533573091,
0.7245563269,
-0.0744452775,
0.4708498418,
-0.0958528891,
-0.6412862539,
-0.352946192,
-0.7857531905,
-0.4746851623,
0.8586080074,
0.2821255922,
0.5028440952,
0.4812308848,
0.2394121587,
-0.1542859375,
0.2076908052,
-0.6897348166,
0.4418615699,
-0.0222001672,
-0.5363740921,
-0.2343654931,
-0.2256731987,
-0.7521895766,
0.6738941669,
-0.2741770446,
-0.5801153183,
0.0793806836,
0.2574419677,
-0.0751545876,
0.4033054411,
-1.0626643896,
1.2801990509,
-0.3783221543,
-0.4069726169,
0.0562706515,
-0.5702608228,
0.607709229,
0.0443952344,
0.4453760386,
-0.1957318336,
0.1443747878,
0.1826631427,
-0.1094753966,
0.6516281366,
-0.143129915,
-0.1438142508,
-0.066792883,
0.0906038657,
0.1559936404,
-0.0029634084,
0.3264161944,
0.2992087901,
-0.0562336147,
-0.5051677227,
-0.7067886591,
0.5555877686,
-0.4313524961,
-0.5794476867,
-0.4698521197,
-0.7708984017,
-0.2909985483,
0.197922647,
-0.0958362743,
0.2640547156,
0.0705069378,
0.0462819524,
0.5070596337,
-0.6155138612,
0.638263464,
0.345764488,
-0.5190606117,
-0.0911787823,
0.7822719812,
0.0478169881,
0.4434712231,
0.0900150612,
0.0960569158,
-0.2849603593,
-0.6256956458,
-0.8213641644,
0.2240198851,
-0.9516227245,
0.0773955286,
-0.6020100117,
0.1492871195,
-0.3605422676,
-0.0153460149,
-0.3913668394,
-0.3890920281,
0.0136831943,
-0.1175560802,
-0.0723432675,
0.486284405,
-0.2192632705,
-0.170835644,
-0.6482799649,
0.4692706466,
0.3206493556,
0.4579115808,
-0.0560115352,
-0.2086944133,
0.0433484577,
-0.0950214192,
-0.4225661159,
-0.7964823842,
0.3616605401,
0.0132194143,
0.5390371084,
0.0647868216,
-0.3814225495,
0.6733794808,
-0.8360435367,
0.9177138209,
0.3836830258,
-0.8589361906,
0.7024875879,
-0.5036686063,
0.520891726,
-0.0088619981,
0.4098065197,
-0.5131839514,
-0.4186517298,
-0.2517162561,
-0.8354446292,
0.3057937622,
0.3845763505,
-0.0205851439,
-0.0710883886,
-0.0181967653,
-0.0131241875,
-0.0156774186,
-1.1717280149,
0.0425739735,
-0.4758177698,
0.0675723478,
-0.0441669598,
0.0177198015,
-0.1802565753,
-0.3466431797,
0.4040015042,
-0.4469024539,
0.1084340513,
0.2415828556,
-0.128436178,
0.1444049627,
0.3231793046,
0.8842324615,
1.0762145519,
-0.0344348587,
0.0304559246,
-0.0668798462,
-0.049187541,
0.0562005416,
0.0344098508,
-0.1620968133,
0.083172515,
0.6560925841,
1.0187902451,
0.2149618715,
-0.8498548269,
0.7689915299,
-0.2634949386,
-0.1667170227,
-0.2406841815,
-0.1692654639,
0.2222029418,
0.3700611293,
0.0860668048,
0.4396266043,
-0.0066782148,
-0.5514850616,
0.0746479854,
0.4841650426,
-0.3317360878,
-0.2235599458,
1.0155874491,
0.0679689273,
-0.085721761,
0.5182162523,
-0.238730073,
-0.5130453706,
0.46087569,
0.5135489702,
0.4701892734,
-0.1809433848,
0.4969966412,
0.3690218329,
0.8577854037,
-0.2304439694,
0.5993225574,
0.2210881561,
-0.8707528114,
-0.940916419,
-0.3345014751,
-0.4274534881,
-0.2225960344,
-0.3790919185,
0.1746591777,
-0.1183237955,
-0.0006413319,
0.0179779436,
-0.5167243481,
-0.8614457846,
0.2018316984,
0.2579863966,
0.6993080974,
-1.0973316431,
0.5763555169,
0.6534197927,
-0.7988855243,
-0.6912477016,
-0.4210317731,
0.1323647648,
-0.7836328149,
0.9810587168,
0.2283858806,
-0.0010623942,
-0.3556081355,
-0.5408979058,
-0.7802416086,
0.6933535337,
0.6153498888,
-0.4408625066,
-0.0160729401,
0.0851795748,
0.5024536252,
-0.2238072902,
0.3652747571,
0.333053261,
0.7714803815,
-0.0728066936,
-1.3282268047,
-0.1216587573,
-0.3340938389,
0.1150111184,
-0.00209273,
-0.3636827171,
0.9067986608,
-0.6016966105,
-0.0634401888,
-0.135387376,
0.4423096776,
0.3112750947,
0.2413540632,
0.5543590784,
0.7658785582,
0.6985099316,
-0.2862784863,
1.5092902184,
0.3109675348,
0.167314291,
1.0620340109,
-0.3404563069,
0.9194782972,
0.6840105057,
-0.0030722488,
0.3120914698,
0.4477616847,
-0.1140433475,
0.3941440284,
0.1398878992,
-0.1028629839,
-0.3866294324,
-0.1436886489,
-0.2101371139,
0.7120883465,
0.1861128062,
-0.0353498049,
-0.3878970444,
0.4559567273,
-0.1329603493,
0.2129383683,
-0.2397792786,
0.3038147092,
0.0781940892,
-0.636413455,
0.5912507176,
0.1160481423,
0.5294644237,
-0.4640682638,
-0.365367651,
-0.115289025,
0.2090020031,
-0.1170001924,
-0.6968672872,
0.4105876684,
-0.160495609,
-0.1250373125,
-0.4730508626,
0.6023880839,
-0.4760089517,
-0.6051095128,
0.5725600719,
0.7543979287,
0.1425924897,
-0.2512617707,
-0.8472043276,
0.212593928,
0.2413343191,
-0.0171802659,
0.1844365001,
0.4414488673,
-0.3692733347,
0.9569368362,
0.753911078,
-0.0043914397,
0.2328778803,
0.4351428449,
0.5449743271,
-0.5974017382,
-0.1989778578,
-0.7592192292,
0.6253727674,
0.0285099614,
-0.3724322915,
0.9106696248,
0.3889147341,
1.1755740643,
-0.2608009279,
0.7398581505,
0.1533627212,
0.0918632001,
-0.5880650282,
0.4590172768,
-0.8708863854,
0.1159873903,
-0.3183652163,
-0.8765984774,
-0.8367727399,
0.6913368106,
-0.2396472692,
-0.1305948198,
1.0005353689,
0.6617530584,
-0.1305408329,
-0.0980229899,
0.5903441906,
0.1119903773,
0.5903733373,
0.7692853212,
0.9133656621,
-0.4470354617,
0.6825089455,
-0.1418671906,
-0.3653496504,
0.2251146138,
-1.0351887941,
-0.889641583,
-0.4268197715,
-0.3723529279,
-0.2353610843,
0.0347662792,
0.4426831901,
0.5699440837,
-0.5616275072,
0.0198954958,
0.2205382288,
0.25345698,
-0.2969689965,
-0.2003871948,
0.2101990283,
-0.3127666116,
-0.7608780265,
0.4263392985,
0.6985329986,
-0.0115601206,
-0.3301436603,
0.0043156464,
-0.2767891884,
-0.1891511083,
0.8428774476,
0.1694402844,
-1.1046755314,
-0.4383744299,
0.0803439841,
0.1544880569,
0.1416412145,
0.6230421066,
-0.3756024837,
0.9207391143,
0.3937007487,
0.6195970774,
0.4961810708,
-0.2467602342,
0.7106621861,
-0.6159089804,
0.2478338778,
0.3616861999,
0.7623403072,
0.5986158252,
0.0657122955,
0.6012652516,
0.4088281989,
-0.4109321535,
-0.7670308948,
0.4814066887,
-1.0456562042,
-0.4081746042,
0.960179925,
-0.2960859537,
-0.1615962535,
-0.1731809676,
-0.2256572992,
-0.1567332149,
0.018826209,
0.3491117656,
0.9527640343,
-0.2071489543,
-0.5101070404,
-1.1349685192,
0.2065166235,
0.3884134889,
-0.7335797548,
-0.2584035993,
0.5995399952,
0.207011506,
0.3261366785,
0.7285003066,
-0.2398575544,
0.3578689098,
0.0803635344,
0.3401723206,
-0.0328430124,
-0.4650162458,
-0.2232202142,
0.2268691659,
-0.1511312276,
-0.068863824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01395v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01395v1
|
CR-LT-KGQA: A Knowledge Graph Question Answering Dataset Requiring Commonsense Reasoning and Long-Tail Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T04:47:01 | 2024-03-03T04:47:01 |
Willis Guo, Armin Toroghi, Scott Sanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.4, I.2.7
|
Knowledge graph question answering (KGQA) is a well-established field that
seeks to provide factual answers to natural language (NL) questions by
leveraging knowledge graphs (KGs). However, existing KGQA datasets suffer from
two significant limitations: (1) no existing KGQA dataset requires commonsense
reasoning to arrive at an answer and (2) existing KGQA datasets focus on
popular entities for which large language models (LLMs) can directly answer
without hallucinating and without leveraging the KG. In this work, we seek a
novel KGQA dataset that supports commonsense reasoning and focuses on long-tail
entities (e.g., non-mainstream and recent entities) where LLMs frequently
hallucinate, and thus create the need for novel methodologies that leverage the
KG for factual and attributable commonsense inference. We create a novel
Commonsense Reasoning (CR) and Long-Tail (LT) KGQA dataset with two subtasks --
question answering and claim verification -- that address both limitations (1)
and (2). We construct CR-LT-KGQA by building extensions to existing reasoning
datasets StrategyQA and CREAK over Wikidata. While existing KGQA methods are
not applicable due to their lack of commonsense inference support, baseline
evaluation of LLMs on CR-LT KGQA demonstrate a high rate of hallucination.
Thus, CR-LT KGQA poses significant challenges for hallucination-prone LLMs,
hence paving the way for future commonsense KGQA research to provide accurate
and factual answers for long-tail entities in the era of LLMs.
|
[
-0.5366601944,
-0.9238836169,
0.6518535018,
-0.0424031541,
-0.2276188731,
0.0031692474,
-0.122898452,
-0.2350848764,
0.0846377015,
0.8271997571,
-0.676271975,
-0.6494709253,
-0.5367094278,
0.2439413816,
-0.1384169608,
0.8334376812,
0.0533627793,
-0.2627154887,
-0.4627133906,
-0.4566767514,
-0.5547280312,
-0.3844504058,
-0.4692571163,
-0.3295952976,
0.8973474503,
0.4635642767,
0.9062660336,
0.2755726874,
-0.0424168259,
0.1700352579,
0.0340103768,
0.3194983006,
-0.6407012939,
-0.0397416167,
-0.1792144924,
0.0179296136,
-0.2937429547,
-0.3785001934,
0.5683506727,
0.8142081499,
-0.1062457487,
0.1259285808,
-0.1048649177,
0.8352617025,
-0.672940433,
0.2299457341,
-0.8806717396,
-0.0111423144,
-0.110686563,
0.0666082948,
-0.5210689306,
-0.433512181,
-0.0183068886,
-0.7860369682,
-0.0618208051,
0.0907403082,
0.8084322214,
0.3335719705,
-0.8000633121,
-0.5121462941,
-0.1444199532,
0.7339030504,
-0.6272822618,
0.797080338,
0.5151205063,
0.4808354378,
-0.1535684317,
-0.8488382697,
-0.9572411776,
-0.263168931,
-0.2542059422,
0.0276534837,
-0.1262425631,
-0.1081845015,
0.0811854973,
0.0426494069,
-0.9249588847,
0.1246666461,
-0.3603528738,
-0.448325634,
0.5122432709,
0.1701061726,
0.2104432732,
-0.5010479689,
-0.5065848231,
0.0978377238,
-0.6235284209,
-0.1328636259,
0.3808357716,
0.3245934546,
0.0419561937,
0.7036803365,
-0.6322190166,
0.8012911081,
-0.4345270097,
-0.1290011555,
0.2219244987,
0.1297427267,
-0.2099660784,
0.2129522562,
0.7529892325,
0.4358732104,
0.3432989717,
-0.3985012472,
-0.1330043077,
-0.1961951852,
-0.0433618203,
-0.7228730917,
-0.3822179139,
0.4604424834,
-0.2786958814,
-0.3553731441,
-0.4625561833,
-1.0163451433,
-0.5262590051,
-0.2289801985,
0.6468762755,
-0.289203018,
-0.4437399209,
0.2154209763,
-0.1397262961,
0.3129488826,
0.2086837888,
-0.4637146294,
0.2460054904,
0.7008786798,
0.5412103534,
-0.2009472251,
-0.1455079913,
-0.4109545052,
0.0898687914,
-0.2818901837,
0.6329054832,
-0.5430575609,
-0.2540955245,
-0.0932020992,
0.1050363854,
-0.0200027451,
-0.5316410065,
0.8426716924,
-0.9595755339,
0.1954703629,
-0.6592842937,
-0.4842482209,
-0.350264132,
0.588660717,
-0.8191217184,
1.0411633253,
0.2184215188,
-0.8622489572,
0.2060748637,
-0.649323225,
-0.4332610369,
0.1088188738,
-0.0806511268,
-0.2999573648,
-0.5024216175,
0.5459635258,
0.4592967629,
-0.3635565937,
0.521294117,
-0.4592287242,
-0.0977178961,
0.416118592,
-0.5520054102,
0.8997748494,
0.2814981937,
0.1028174907,
-0.3231441081,
-0.8236216903,
0.2060016543,
0.3393451273,
-0.0218954738,
-0.2340518236,
-0.2309812307,
-0.2985984087,
0.0483304933,
0.2766559422,
-0.5511127114,
0.1155883744,
0.0525386669,
0.4695473909,
0.6810584664,
0.1456341147,
0.1599458903,
-0.2857018709,
0.3164450824,
-0.001182655,
-0.0900868028,
0.4062032104,
-0.5505897403,
-0.4027848244,
-0.3546952307,
0.3325859606,
0.5187866688,
-1.2505776882,
0.1469717324,
-0.6704564095,
-0.4351080656,
-0.1001361161,
-0.044778116,
0.385014683,
1.0361884832,
0.5257433057,
0.0085701998,
-0.2781281471,
-1.0621381998,
-0.1757982373,
-0.0718913227,
0.0558908619,
0.5988403559,
0.6662282348,
0.0687570572,
1.0453518629,
-0.7984775901,
-0.0067434693,
-0.3645275831,
0.0769390911,
0.3095721006,
0.1057939455,
0.1680645645,
-1.0537421703,
-0.2118757516,
-0.1339249313,
-0.7607818246,
-0.0560269319,
-0.0326111391,
-0.1605681181,
0.1087338775,
0.2241678387,
-0.9322445989,
0.1972708255,
0.5100944638,
-0.3226127625,
0.7325333953,
0.2446828187,
0.21954225,
-0.9038119912,
0.1280951351,
-0.2715637982,
-0.0307589155,
-0.6499024034,
-0.0840673,
0.0479489006,
-0.1662924141,
-0.433784306,
0.8856806755,
-0.0439801663,
-0.1012236848,
0.0051429761,
0.371037215,
0.1972974539,
0.771186769,
0.163807258,
0.7118151188,
0.2766962647,
-0.6151275635,
0.4048371315,
0.5142647624,
-0.2934964895,
0.4460404515,
-0.6398847103,
0.166279003,
-0.257029146,
0.4011884332,
-0.9298428893,
-0.522584796,
0.4143548906,
-0.6329196692,
-0.0105910962,
-0.3616393805,
-0.5790696144,
-0.5488442183,
0.0412452482,
0.6137346029,
0.4169319868,
-0.6875878572,
0.8359097838,
0.1023179144,
-0.167305842,
-1.1319819689,
-0.5527580976,
0.2443663925,
-0.304240644,
-0.7159218788,
0.0217938386,
0.1837948114,
-0.0956569239,
0.3666230142,
-0.1586419046,
-0.3918792009,
-0.0572875328,
-0.0744114891,
0.2641330659,
-0.2502315044,
0.2963650823,
0.1009922847,
-0.0173613038,
0.1908964366,
-0.2618150413,
0.5219479203,
0.0713881627,
-0.2378962636,
-0.2788390517,
0.1321345568,
0.5679478049,
-0.1698146164,
0.7143089175,
0.5245830417,
-0.383446455,
-0.3786175847,
-0.5818148255,
-0.1641325355,
-0.4725373685,
0.6979374886,
-0.5544235706,
-1.0109101534,
0.4585238397,
0.0910283327,
-0.1111208051,
0.4063694179,
0.5721744299,
0.0980066434,
0.4767199755,
-0.2391527444,
0.06367971,
-0.4646781683,
-0.0114315627,
0.3281508684,
-0.6829452515,
-0.3398916423,
-0.4081742465,
-0.0697104707,
-0.4279072881,
-0.4158113599,
0.3395590782,
-0.0159878079,
-0.5205179453,
0.1613619328,
-0.4687695503,
0.5584773421,
0.3863579035,
0.2188513279,
0.3735038936,
-0.2192484587,
-0.102940321,
0.1869466603,
-0.6695276499,
-0.3843834102,
1.1213158369,
0.2261406481,
0.5388478041,
0.2884397805,
0.4686715901,
0.4685946405,
0.1624169797,
-0.6393321157,
0.8401558995,
-0.0243762061,
-0.7727627158,
-0.6587278843,
-0.8883572817,
-0.8201049566,
0.1821152419,
-0.1491132528,
-0.7341686487,
-0.1144316792,
0.1198908687,
-0.1165790111,
0.462274462,
-0.5644971132,
1.1028314829,
-0.0428527035,
-0.2632337809,
0.0644388869,
-0.7763515711,
0.7568435073,
-0.0234871209,
0.1907768399,
-0.2033789158,
0.1428201795,
0.8105682731,
-0.3795336783,
0.8113560081,
-0.4509360492,
-0.3710231781,
0.6829336882,
0.1742414832,
0.8605257273,
0.244307369,
0.0205667578,
0.0028605903,
0.1322940886,
-0.5378240943,
-0.8986083269,
0.6922758818,
-0.6380215287,
-0.4984192848,
-0.2699874043,
-0.7368931174,
-0.6422566175,
0.3406546712,
-0.095688507,
0.5604778528,
0.0356570333,
0.2363337129,
0.7792096138,
-0.3925887346,
0.0364130884,
0.1880240291,
-0.1617925167,
-0.7430259585,
1.0537391901,
0.1364678741,
0.412060231,
0.3626039922,
0.2153974921,
-0.765910089,
-0.5178328753,
-0.6161901355,
0.2874310315,
-1.0028408766,
-0.261465162,
-0.9048412442,
-0.2883890867,
-0.4118572176,
-0.0602818914,
-0.1924701929,
-0.7376057506,
0.1524206102,
-0.0198709331,
0.5466665626,
0.4796804786,
0.1065308601,
-0.1331751049,
-0.7917598486,
0.8539950252,
0.8222475648,
0.2814051211,
0.2688948214,
-0.3391255438,
0.1363024861,
0.1802327633,
-0.0493190214,
-0.8343769908,
0.0461946353,
-0.167310521,
0.5220780969,
0.0422901139,
0.5994397402,
0.5135471821,
-0.2731405497,
0.8703299761,
0.1376397461,
-0.6237961054,
0.0178777743,
-0.459515661,
0.0994919166,
0.5003578067,
0.5687999129,
-0.6507386565,
-0.1331959069,
-0.4564640522,
-0.6765220165,
0.3193287849,
0.4500705004,
0.0706321672,
-0.1308536381,
0.2123329639,
0.2647359073,
0.2671586275,
-0.883874774,
-0.2200790346,
-0.447761327,
-0.3698818088,
0.3623505533,
-0.1513336003,
-0.2804837227,
-0.1165986434,
0.8068864346,
-0.2283914834,
0.2094054669,
0.2173206508,
-0.0065905591,
0.2978689373,
0.5186697841,
0.2843554616,
0.5926474929,
-0.1685113311,
0.29750669,
0.6416273713,
-0.3835760355,
-0.1231824532,
0.1216417104,
-0.1454909742,
-0.1533314586,
0.281373322,
0.5287221074,
-0.0751361325,
-0.8348835707,
0.513343811,
0.210975498,
-0.5941110849,
-0.2926864326,
-0.0921331197,
0.4679170549,
0.2407431901,
0.4862601459,
-0.2913796902,
-0.0049828114,
-0.3159337938,
0.2598095238,
0.4907652438,
-0.2130777091,
0.126912266,
0.5600236654,
0.0380559899,
0.0709297135,
0.8356319666,
-0.4306135774,
-0.6356022358,
0.7209771872,
0.3762226403,
0.416757226,
0.4182958305,
0.3861337006,
0.5127822161,
0.1142351776,
0.1521705091,
0.2617638111,
-0.1669299304,
-0.8946988583,
-0.5459153056,
-0.5333607197,
-0.2969257832,
0.3603536785,
-0.5949980617,
0.2102841735,
-0.0308974516,
0.108550474,
-0.1896586716,
0.012333422,
-0.3808210194,
0.4859990478,
0.131194219,
0.9435298443,
-0.626152575,
0.677816391,
0.0326980092,
-0.1976945996,
-0.7501257062,
-0.0816603526,
-0.1103092656,
-1.0769246817,
0.7872719169,
0.0440403856,
-0.097125493,
0.088106297,
-0.646587491,
-0.665130794,
1.3574016094,
0.0806311816,
-0.2460000664,
-0.1770158559,
0.6383443475,
0.0425161012,
0.0001653802,
-0.2435776144,
0.4042985737,
0.7104285359,
0.5762884021,
-0.6361321807,
0.4239533246,
0.1242193133,
-0.445897907,
0.3055098653,
-0.6868287921,
0.4347388744,
-0.2028608024,
-0.155000627,
0.208673507,
0.7827834487,
0.6921262741,
0.7105146646,
0.6568912864,
0.9995979667,
0.8848049045,
-0.0393954553,
0.7029736638,
-0.0668347627,
0.38122347,
1.3882303238,
-0.3569776714,
0.6729903817,
0.3389011323,
-0.211511746,
0.3722972572,
0.3570593596,
-0.0392947607,
0.4875876904,
0.2454407364,
-0.386602968,
-0.5263047218,
-0.124987267,
-0.4329522848,
0.2938843966,
0.3081862628,
0.0046773534,
-0.3726858199,
-0.0364558063,
0.2137707472,
-0.0136565333,
-0.2122607082,
0.3677739203,
0.0104081696,
-0.6352685094,
0.7473533154,
-0.2809486687,
0.2195161432,
-0.5434142351,
-0.0940872282,
-0.1708630323,
-0.4104453325,
-0.1461402029,
-1.0821424723,
0.0686887801,
-0.0614425614,
0.1622218639,
0.1175334603,
0.7006095052,
-0.3144278228,
-0.4034549892,
-0.0290797614,
0.5562896132,
0.0497234464,
0.0397867747,
-0.6165383458,
-0.2271504253,
-0.0418663919,
-0.2717941403,
0.1810210496,
0.8779420853,
-0.0531301871,
0.9731381536,
0.6597353816,
-0.2495304942,
-0.0662844256,
-0.021884473,
1.0817043781,
-0.5351231098,
-0.3042341769,
-0.4762346148,
0.4175014198,
-0.2042165548,
-0.2751158476,
0.5646848679,
0.6564541459,
0.4890216887,
-0.0056575094,
0.7809263468,
-0.3874424994,
0.5274635553,
-0.872989893,
0.7852935195,
-0.5972250104,
-0.0211530924,
-0.1251547784,
-0.5925509334,
-0.2792426646,
0.0989877582,
-0.4404419065,
0.1023519337,
0.6848570704,
1.1566280127,
-0.0798965245,
0.2450572848,
0.348305881,
0.3461435735,
0.0850111097,
0.7796784043,
0.8785762787,
-0.2697610259,
0.9904868603,
-0.2595289052,
0.2514337599,
0.0661836043,
-0.9121847153,
-0.9351904392,
-0.6196708679,
-0.3113195598,
-0.7363482118,
0.2906813323,
0.6886689067,
0.2841944695,
-0.6930649281,
0.390427649,
-0.107875362,
0.2166440189,
0.048409123,
-0.3328362703,
0.7423132658,
-0.1281203628,
-0.3372507989,
0.1976210028,
-0.1664626449,
-0.1789723188,
-0.0513131991,
-0.2931077778,
-0.1041734591,
0.0130151138,
0.5253742933,
0.4687796831,
-0.7214593887,
-0.4988144636,
0.0717003271,
0.1200572476,
0.0652976483,
0.6259086728,
-0.8600398302,
0.1890999377,
0.3145113885,
0.8961851001,
0.3968392015,
-0.075975284,
0.1403430253,
-0.6617718935,
-0.0664412603,
0.5003125668,
0.1240058318,
0.2245026827,
-0.3400199115,
0.4538593888,
0.2875666618,
-0.5965739489,
-0.8886832595,
0.5177338123,
-1.254021883,
-0.4959297776,
1.3418200016,
0.1050108373,
-0.1927457601,
-0.4113998115,
-0.0740102604,
0.1761908233,
-0.331412077,
0.6788008213,
0.8301118612,
0.0001264488,
-0.2342130393,
-0.7341947556,
0.3876725137,
0.1905338466,
-0.6766204834,
0.4506483674,
0.5614777207,
0.3053156435,
-0.1151681691,
0.5898809433,
-0.1491743624,
0.2799277306,
0.1600696743,
-0.2864060402,
-0.4056496918,
-0.1811622232,
0.3564419448,
0.5314383507,
-0.0513075218,
0.0254450142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04786v2
|
Breaking Down the Defenses: A Comparative Survey of Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T04:46:21 | 2024-03-23T05:21:49 |
Arijit Ghosh Chowdhury, Md Mofijul Islam, Vaibhav Kumar, Faysal Hossain Shezan, Vaibhav Kumar, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a cornerstone in the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP), offering transformative capabilities in
understanding and generating human-like text. However, with their rising
prominence, the security and vulnerability aspects of these models have
garnered significant attention. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of
the various forms of attacks targeting LLMs, discussing the nature and
mechanisms of these attacks, their potential impacts, and current defense
strategies. We delve into topics such as adversarial attacks that aim to
manipulate model outputs, data poisoning that affects model training, and
privacy concerns related to training data exploitation. The paper also explores
the effectiveness of different attack methodologies, the resilience of LLMs
against these attacks, and the implications for model integrity and user trust.
By examining the latest research, we provide insights into the current
landscape of LLM vulnerabilities and defense mechanisms. Our objective is to
offer a nuanced understanding of LLM attacks, foster awareness within the AI
community, and inspire robust solutions to mitigate these risks in future
developments.
|
[
-0.4424279332,
-1.0901136398,
0.466579318,
-0.3106945753,
0.2224412262,
0.2550725043,
-0.0747729987,
-0.5822950602,
-0.1724508852,
0.8161382675,
-0.4417128861,
-0.3013772368,
-0.8102418184,
0.0818139687,
-0.7144188881,
0.8746861219,
0.3485886753,
0.1028111875,
-0.3757436574,
0.0576037131,
-0.2631720603,
-1.0347728729,
-0.6574124098,
-0.1699376851,
0.5952029824,
-0.2142058462,
0.6440958977,
0.2916954756,
0.9190163612,
0.39967978,
-0.350779742,
-0.3253605366,
-0.5203730464,
0.4828894436,
-0.1738125682,
-0.6188741922,
-0.4538511932,
-0.1631693095,
0.603900373,
0.5921679735,
0.0423935503,
0.0728339106,
-0.0046388158,
0.659147203,
-0.6737279892,
-0.3084580898,
-1.0361677408,
0.0457702167,
-0.5637159944,
0.0588154085,
-0.6295663118,
-0.0887616053,
0.1488432288,
0.1238707528,
-0.0137604307,
0.0067727109,
0.6214985251,
0.2053053081,
-0.5000969768,
-0.2484104782,
-0.5042047501,
1.0519316196,
-0.8617430925,
0.2614044547,
0.2956274748,
0.3127267957,
-0.4227416515,
-0.5234122872,
-0.2553046346,
-0.4739771187,
-0.0100070471,
-0.2452309579,
-0.8104178905,
0.2651241124,
0.3454657793,
0.4830011725,
-0.7082185745,
0.4943665862,
-0.293793112,
-0.0648884922,
0.7828140855,
0.3097382784,
0.7655097246,
-0.0779782757,
-0.4472822845,
-0.1009841338,
-0.9769180417,
-0.2008673549,
0.5070368648,
0.1338756084,
-0.1575750709,
0.669490397,
0.209055692,
0.7472746968,
-0.3563398719,
-0.2035343796,
-0.3888098001,
-0.1255365908,
-0.4757944643,
-0.1607368737,
1.0237978697,
0.2072731555,
0.1801707596,
-0.4306475222,
-0.3136378825,
-0.1820219606,
0.5430824757,
-0.5329357982,
-0.0076884693,
0.1779856235,
-0.3963259161,
-0.6441047788,
-0.023764316,
-0.812792182,
-0.8121107221,
0.0789870396,
0.0330421887,
-0.2826124728,
-0.1370966136,
-0.021115629,
0.0175305307,
0.3441735804,
0.0059272279,
-0.8833143711,
0.4837648571,
0.9448657036,
0.7927418351,
-0.1852956265,
-0.0260834247,
-0.3329373896,
0.1158695519,
-0.2285165489,
0.4252770841,
-0.2390491068,
-0.6167678833,
0.0459694751,
-0.3658230901,
-0.0187147949,
-0.5678990483,
0.5355432034,
-0.8488309979,
-0.0824677572,
-0.1699498594,
-0.5580127835,
-0.2185350209,
0.8642374873,
-0.9714536667,
0.6560539007,
-0.206682384,
-1.1138776541,
-0.3208143711,
-0.5298857093,
-0.4564848542,
-0.0742917657,
-0.199947387,
-0.204386428,
0.236386776,
0.1087663025,
0.6390603781,
-0.6909061074,
-0.1009037718,
-0.550933063,
0.0993408337,
0.4532320201,
-0.5426036119,
0.9568653703,
0.2811784148,
-0.1489676684,
0.2506433427,
-0.703532815,
-0.0964289904,
0.6386049986,
-0.1887608618,
-0.3034771085,
0.0524389483,
-0.3338542283,
-0.0409520157,
0.3402741253,
-0.314981848,
0.2754249871,
-0.6458345056,
0.7215729356,
0.7272524238,
0.2142458558,
0.4141272008,
-0.1365979314,
0.7359477282,
-0.3828422725,
0.3898241818,
-0.0391932689,
-0.3092511296,
-0.4578388631,
-0.1192528903,
0.1462394893,
0.5388172269,
-0.4691401422,
0.2555223107,
-0.1073835194,
-0.7486143112,
-0.3223414719,
0.291896075,
0.4117080271,
0.2719201744,
0.25385499,
0.0513535365,
-0.5247860551,
-0.8587872386,
-0.451493144,
-0.2797619104,
-0.1028383225,
0.0061712409,
0.489823401,
-0.2760029733,
0.6586538553,
-0.5104909539,
-0.1526694,
-0.5821995139,
-0.2328113616,
-0.0765613765,
0.2692156136,
0.7825781107,
-0.6350547075,
-0.2140808105,
-0.1416492909,
-0.7206263542,
0.1135420874,
0.046047166,
0.1776814908,
0.2224714607,
0.6792065501,
-0.8550606966,
0.2300610393,
0.6185510159,
-0.1424227357,
0.5017676353,
0.1787166446,
-0.146373257,
-1.0699369907,
-0.1300181001,
-0.0647433922,
-0.1003623381,
-0.8950925469,
0.6024038196,
-0.3279840052,
0.0224776138,
-0.5425882339,
0.5026354194,
-0.3607132435,
-0.1278087944,
-0.2114634663,
-0.1022657752,
0.0830999464,
-0.026632322,
-0.2000670731,
0.455876559,
0.5466624498,
-0.3588835895,
0.6564945579,
-0.0160738192,
-0.3507570326,
0.244497776,
-0.8865053654,
0.5145938396,
0.1336014271,
0.2265995443,
-0.755366385,
-0.1005732864,
0.3065940738,
-0.4851398766,
0.700976491,
-0.1668421477,
-0.5618978739,
-0.1083975732,
-0.6224571466,
0.2562067807,
0.3007898927,
-0.4638924003,
0.6365413666,
0.5770175457,
-0.1824861765,
-0.9177829623,
-0.8549126387,
0.6545920372,
-0.5360842943,
-0.8032631874,
0.145807758,
0.0158008281,
-0.9511075616,
-0.2853861153,
0.2205708921,
0.0981416404,
0.6844233274,
0.2365748435,
0.2663341761,
-0.0942263827,
-0.250335902,
-0.5563600063,
0.1134583056,
0.5183714032,
0.0577659421,
0.7960630059,
-0.079434596,
-0.5604159236,
-0.2934529781,
0.4403326213,
0.6173158288,
-0.2470908463,
0.9470510483,
0.2981491089,
-0.3781903982,
-0.1633150429,
-0.5271679759,
-0.2913744152,
-0.4407588243,
0.7481055856,
-0.21474424,
-0.952873528,
0.3200247288,
0.2110696435,
0.247969225,
0.5343426466,
0.66758883,
-0.0669739246,
0.988995254,
0.5033273697,
-0.5889899135,
0.2874869406,
-0.1112787798,
0.4156010151,
-0.6819980741,
-0.269020468,
-0.6705443263,
-0.0655798092,
-0.3692057133,
-0.226739347,
-0.0477897786,
0.0467564464,
-0.2523100674,
0.2220958173,
-0.2796460092,
0.4016571641,
0.2974250615,
-0.2887749076,
0.2754152119,
-0.2297157347,
0.2763467431,
0.0133562675,
-0.5371217132,
-0.6936027408,
1.2036130428,
0.7403252125,
0.9162207842,
0.5400053859,
0.5014160872,
0.531016767,
0.2153893858,
-0.7217134833,
0.7197169065,
-0.0654964224,
-0.762275517,
-0.1555098146,
-0.5060822964,
-0.8406654,
0.170286715,
-0.2283008546,
-0.8546980619,
-0.3821468949,
-0.107010901,
-0.1355181634,
0.803367734,
-0.5503956676,
0.7026298046,
-0.6475191712,
-0.1395960152,
-0.1048237383,
-0.6418927908,
0.6634892225,
-0.1394405663,
0.155679822,
0.0499784537,
0.0889695883,
0.6486814022,
-0.2153060734,
1.0208063126,
0.1554943323,
-0.4483043551,
0.1736704409,
0.1815357059,
0.4485000074,
0.0097257635,
0.0183151048,
0.3361857533,
-0.0316097513,
-0.3232104182,
-0.2974425852,
0.7275896668,
-0.614297092,
-0.9481605291,
-0.4307104349,
-0.4831402898,
-0.09177237,
0.1033224314,
0.2442401052,
0.1731870323,
-0.50381428,
0.2682368755,
0.8731763363,
-0.4442039132,
0.4474752843,
0.27199772,
-0.1270280629,
-0.3645587564,
0.6887142062,
-0.0185195543,
0.5763577223,
0.5476779342,
-0.0612464137,
-0.2070579976,
-0.8723377585,
-0.110968329,
0.0939921811,
-0.6988680363,
-0.3935579062,
-0.5861962438,
-0.3995869756,
-0.7409962416,
-0.0839160383,
-0.4106044173,
-0.1716094762,
-0.1496609896,
-0.322609216,
0.3930458128,
0.9680632949,
0.3560415506,
0.2549679279,
-0.7845374346,
0.066124849,
0.3381455243,
-0.1563693583,
0.1733221263,
-0.4656756818,
0.0207544584,
-0.2264353484,
-0.432166934,
-0.9126349688,
0.4205856025,
-0.0998784006,
0.4304386973,
0.4911399186,
0.1084704474,
0.0410742573,
-0.4002510905,
0.9645944834,
0.322049439,
-0.7100114226,
0.3520202041,
-0.2267076224,
0.1236301139,
0.3599989712,
0.3992768526,
-0.3178663552,
-0.3423464596,
-0.5708451867,
-0.756080687,
0.3813099563,
0.0452131182,
0.314460814,
0.1040634587,
0.1849320233,
-0.2250059545,
0.0107792867,
-0.8107784986,
-0.2918731272,
0.2110612541,
-0.0931307971,
0.0797045156,
-0.4805765748,
-0.5011873841,
0.1159179881,
0.6815580726,
0.1823018491,
-0.2395475954,
-0.1107125431,
-0.2266134322,
0.3739001155,
0.4538580775,
0.4694855511,
0.2266932875,
-0.0598004498,
0.3824161589,
0.4714183211,
-0.5421366096,
0.1439775974,
-0.0991867557,
-0.1811358035,
-0.2874100506,
0.8301861286,
0.5986423492,
0.236826539,
-0.8902916312,
0.4386034012,
-0.1768767685,
-0.1166657656,
-0.3795149028,
0.0404959694,
0.2296508849,
0.258154422,
0.0771906301,
-0.1642235965,
-0.0374490172,
-0.5657426119,
-0.0343250372,
0.8302620053,
-0.2843973637,
-0.2812589407,
0.4572535455,
-0.0499594696,
-0.4087505043,
0.4735127687,
0.2746503651,
-0.650942266,
0.5629226565,
0.5495340228,
0.814237833,
-0.2206175923,
-0.303147465,
-0.0761811733,
0.6589423418,
0.1291237324,
-0.2598591149,
0.1260900199,
-0.7693670392,
-0.1857154518,
-0.4736880064,
-0.536100626,
0.5309512615,
-0.6311994791,
-0.0277154911,
-0.8946149945,
-0.3741933703,
-0.1232991889,
0.0048426595,
-0.2476040423,
-0.0478742793,
0.5862956047,
0.9585111141,
-0.3923990726,
0.6112443209,
0.6344807744,
-0.3328989446,
-0.3155623972,
-0.0238773525,
0.4304798543,
-0.4702815711,
0.6314833164,
-0.0328544304,
-0.198293373,
-0.355260998,
-0.5236136317,
-0.6973446608,
0.7206676006,
0.559066534,
-0.5508172512,
-0.0720558465,
0.4716263115,
0.3337399662,
-0.0678732991,
0.0717030242,
0.8538895249,
0.4131019115,
-0.3179833889,
-0.4984542131,
-0.0777272061,
-0.0799719989,
-0.1209058017,
0.1617400348,
-0.7095770836,
0.6810311675,
-0.0501317382,
-0.1095997244,
0.0825409964,
0.5900760889,
0.316811651,
0.120083414,
0.41173473,
0.7624668479,
0.534640193,
0.0764276534,
1.2627547979,
-0.1717081368,
-0.0284937136,
1.061042428,
-0.3591254056,
0.8969192505,
0.4535215795,
-0.3352490664,
0.1160811558,
0.4400463402,
-0.2086077034,
0.1052762941,
0.5649982691,
-0.290939033,
0.0208662506,
0.0651423186,
-0.3241423965,
0.4500617087,
0.3081108928,
-0.3271318078,
-0.2632893324,
-0.1061709002,
0.5092740059,
0.1507939994,
-0.3303079903,
0.8992348909,
0.4287687838,
-0.2712956071,
0.3512746096,
0.303848803,
0.7593522072,
-0.8519275188,
0.3615188599,
-0.066094473,
0.2101758271,
-0.2375721335,
-0.6593966484,
0.3043091297,
0.4434427023,
-0.3139420748,
-0.1265177727,
0.8356272578,
-0.0356834754,
-0.2350618243,
0.5692021251,
0.2356299311,
-0.1323868483,
-0.2169684321,
-0.8813225627,
0.4828985631,
-0.0906967595,
-0.5064598918,
0.792952776,
-0.0548815913,
0.0966228098,
0.9182501435,
0.5476905704,
0.1794441789,
0.1663243324,
0.2106349617,
0.7432563901,
-0.5753012896,
0.0577479564,
-1.4603363276,
0.0734752789,
-0.3187071979,
-0.0096499259,
1.0384181738,
0.4094411433,
0.7206007838,
0.1882139891,
0.7445723414,
0.3044349551,
0.4145604372,
-0.6855940819,
1.0406860113,
-0.248864755,
0.7327506542,
-0.2148632854,
-0.772372663,
-0.4132610261,
0.1588731706,
-0.3675302267,
-0.0466469936,
0.2666820586,
0.6992300749,
0.3561499119,
-0.1316043139,
0.255343467,
0.4197269976,
0.7975611687,
0.4550261199,
1.1451212168,
-0.2408578694,
0.5308628082,
-0.1691549271,
0.1219968572,
0.00667954,
-0.8230287433,
-1.2042065859,
-0.2569949925,
-0.1569697708,
-0.2857219279,
0.0719603449,
0.6129870415,
0.4286078513,
-0.7685952187,
-0.1559814513,
0.1690880507,
0.2708963752,
0.2928671539,
-0.2167945802,
0.3862096071,
-0.2786336541,
-0.5287842155,
0.6710085869,
0.2842921615,
0.0230918024,
-0.7058112025,
0.0413999818,
-0.2367850095,
0.254542321,
0.4908554256,
0.4284244776,
-0.7841674089,
-0.0813207105,
-0.1324422359,
-0.3309922218,
-0.2738710642,
0.64270854,
-0.3283475041,
0.0999790728,
0.5296618342,
1.132068038,
-0.1803958118,
-0.1758909076,
0.6709213853,
-0.6203602552,
0.0433450863,
0.354488343,
0.5129198432,
0.5245734453,
-0.425649792,
0.45263201,
0.0695527121,
-0.4004261196,
-1.3514608145,
0.4310242236,
-0.8272036314,
-0.490296185,
1.0333383083,
-0.1353169233,
-0.3341560364,
0.0223338939,
-0.0321628153,
-0.1549184769,
0.0631299317,
0.7329009175,
0.7843677402,
0.2814808488,
0.0682680607,
-0.7423557639,
0.5405430794,
0.2883556783,
-0.844563961,
0.2694780529,
0.2369315028,
0.1024427488,
0.0337845497,
0.1392813325,
-0.363327235,
-0.1895621419,
-0.2074555606,
-0.0411357097,
0.0177020375,
-0.1753580421,
-0.5156360269,
0.4835786819,
0.2752091587,
0.0999536365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01390v1
|
Right for Right Reasons: Large Language Models for Verifiable Commonsense Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2024-03-03T04:22:13 | 2024-03-03T04:22:13 |
Armin Toroghi, Willis Guo, Mohammad Mahdi Abdollah Pour, Scott Sanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) methods seek to answer Natural
Language questions using the relational information stored in Knowledge Graphs
(KGs). With the recent advancements of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
remarkable reasoning abilities, there is a growing trend to leverage them for
KGQA. However, existing methodologies have only focused on answering factual
questions, e.g., "In which city was Silvio Berlusconi's first wife born?",
leaving questions involving commonsense reasoning that real-world users may
pose more often, e.g., "Do I need separate visas to see the Venus of Willendorf
and attend the Olympics this summer?" unaddressed. In this work, we first
observe that existing LLM-based methods for KGQA struggle with hallucination on
such questions, especially on queries targeting long-tail entities (e.g.,
non-mainstream and recent entities), thus hindering their applicability in
real-world applications especially since their reasoning processes are not
easily verifiable. In response, we propose Right for Right Reasons (R3), a
commonsense KGQA methodology that allows for a verifiable reasoning procedure
by axiomatically surfacing intrinsic commonsense knowledge of LLMs and
grounding every factual reasoning step on KG triples. Through experimental
evaluations across three different tasks--question answering, claim
verification, and preference matching--our findings showcase R3 as a superior
approach, outperforming existing methodologies and notably reducing instances
of hallucination and reasoning errors.
|
[
-0.571128428,
-0.9199587703,
1.0639762878,
-0.0943607837,
-0.1811643988,
-0.2112766504,
-0.103518188,
-0.3159659207,
-0.104124926,
0.7998425364,
-0.3886535168,
-0.5123353601,
-0.3731085658,
0.1919694692,
-0.0898334756,
0.5802598,
-0.196157217,
-0.1425489485,
-0.5287012458,
-0.3846326768,
-0.4076752067,
-0.4554917514,
-0.5298706889,
-0.4759308398,
0.7599968314,
0.716035068,
1.0598199368,
0.5981941819,
0.1731661856,
0.2134708613,
0.0352072977,
0.2699649036,
-0.3905289471,
0.0424826145,
-0.3512578011,
-0.3735239208,
-0.1099132597,
0.1092621163,
0.2436219603,
0.5233957767,
-0.0983491763,
0.120489344,
-0.371412158,
0.8129628897,
-0.6696558595,
-0.1348870248,
-0.4001182616,
0.164461568,
0.0091377441,
-0.3153223991,
-0.4673392475,
-0.6888356209,
-0.0244432483,
-0.6001284122,
0.0797389075,
0.3650016189,
0.9437232018,
0.2279626429,
-0.5925445557,
-0.4611028135,
-0.4067795873,
0.8981004953,
-0.8605931997,
0.8251454234,
0.7399986982,
0.5611250401,
-0.3507283926,
-0.7157242894,
-0.9494335055,
-0.3512137234,
-0.1907780915,
0.056768585,
-0.1427864879,
-0.0024326942,
0.5563907623,
0.0916995034,
-0.7278220654,
0.1023356542,
-0.2189833671,
-0.3731037378,
0.6958156228,
-0.0284366142,
0.4307409227,
-0.3235179186,
-0.142832458,
0.2346520871,
-0.9080326557,
-0.0928010792,
0.5443437099,
0.1378310174,
0.0574124083,
0.6315612197,
-0.4319924712,
1.049721837,
-0.1409451067,
-0.2486826628,
-0.1192769334,
-0.0724916235,
-0.1562682837,
0.0035895756,
0.6215701699,
0.4282916486,
0.5662514567,
-0.4775710702,
0.0100205876,
-0.4767977893,
0.1376157403,
-0.6784157753,
0.0046561509,
0.6507380009,
-0.4438848197,
-0.2332754433,
-0.4748390019,
-0.5793162584,
-0.3931598067,
-0.6215025187,
0.4213882089,
-0.339749217,
-0.3533998728,
0.1002054885,
-0.1328963488,
0.2672470212,
0.254309535,
-0.7994666696,
0.0561092421,
0.9259229302,
0.4783036411,
0.0273191389,
-0.2250605971,
-0.561663568,
0.1460668594,
-0.5220307112,
0.5164499283,
-0.5544041991,
-0.1796411425,
0.0660398677,
-0.1070095375,
-0.0256437697,
-0.6237956882,
0.6992125511,
-1.0423281193,
0.3761231005,
-0.6999782324,
-0.4608773887,
-0.3413222134,
0.6599751115,
-0.4973411262,
0.8842381835,
-0.0698870867,
-0.8954740167,
0.3175118566,
-0.6003700495,
-0.3432921469,
-0.0099868979,
-0.1359507889,
-0.1769533753,
-0.2321161479,
0.355360806,
0.5931342244,
-0.4259680808,
0.5396764278,
-0.4221734405,
-0.02184828,
0.431871146,
-0.3729425967,
0.9117828608,
0.5124359727,
-0.0718401819,
-0.1708420217,
-0.8255642653,
0.189492926,
0.0918878317,
-0.152429834,
-0.2892489135,
0.079822056,
-0.5491327643,
0.1987325102,
0.0463244766,
-0.5541812778,
-0.2417749316,
-0.3615936637,
0.4126715064,
0.5511137843,
0.1101718321,
0.1786690503,
-0.2764191031,
0.467106998,
-0.187779814,
0.1445724666,
0.5785281658,
-0.6863036156,
-0.3734709322,
-0.2816752493,
0.1846945733,
0.4882369339,
-0.8274965286,
-0.0346407816,
-0.4191035628,
-0.3450185061,
-0.155266881,
-0.0544170775,
0.3531942666,
0.9892024994,
0.2711680233,
0.2907446921,
-0.3730833232,
-0.9927024245,
-0.3727754951,
-0.4365853667,
0.2044550776,
0.5174252391,
0.7443204522,
0.0783427134,
1.2065948248,
-0.5394300222,
0.3949113488,
-0.380579263,
-0.0148705374,
0.3162093461,
0.1531118453,
0.2446479201,
-1.2603760958,
-0.3013192117,
0.0592357032,
-0.8394141793,
-0.0675402954,
0.2121867687,
-0.3398547769,
0.1767719835,
0.4004523158,
-0.7297725081,
0.3097305894,
0.4983977973,
-0.2337673306,
0.5909845829,
0.0218420569,
0.2787868977,
-1.044958353,
0.1844837815,
-0.1209343299,
-0.3916525543,
-0.7041424513,
0.184133932,
-0.0594866052,
-0.1276064515,
-0.4734104276,
0.6608604789,
0.0105250413,
-0.188490808,
-0.0759210885,
0.396833241,
0.1056392267,
0.4011059403,
0.1351587921,
0.5780491233,
0.3557217419,
-0.7591826916,
0.6745647788,
0.1739884168,
-0.3124818504,
0.6508213878,
-0.4361431599,
0.1742171645,
-0.2794400156,
0.1887298971,
-0.9665598273,
-0.4804707766,
0.6546518803,
-0.7133252621,
-0.0687443987,
-0.2769506872,
-0.5321435928,
-0.6678622961,
0.059465874,
0.3562352359,
0.3232359588,
-0.9035037756,
0.9708619118,
0.3682097495,
0.0173164345,
-0.9051879644,
-0.6325576305,
0.1512826383,
-0.4213830829,
-0.9255721569,
-0.1266346872,
0.0684820786,
-0.3872738183,
0.1267730743,
-0.1532503366,
-0.3741815686,
0.2185149044,
0.1212217435,
0.1837203801,
-0.1027652472,
0.0877738595,
-0.1293426454,
-0.2834871113,
0.1597204208,
-0.257371366,
0.2346902192,
0.068566747,
-0.3379164636,
-0.3881330788,
0.3101294339,
0.6093121767,
-0.159269765,
0.4562363923,
0.4011469185,
-0.4942457974,
-0.2181964368,
-0.7704665661,
-0.1435449123,
-0.423669517,
0.2824228108,
-0.4721607566,
-1.1855260134,
0.6142117977,
0.202129662,
-0.0334914625,
0.0937624052,
0.7496575117,
-0.0353982598,
1.0019096136,
0.0955582112,
0.0939137563,
-0.3656721115,
0.1839032024,
0.8206047416,
-0.5416679978,
-0.27518484,
-0.6565288901,
0.1194437444,
-0.3597083688,
-0.336384505,
0.2145474255,
-0.0024639834,
-0.2443873286,
-0.0112206778,
-0.3461763859,
0.8290858269,
0.3973337412,
-0.0185991786,
0.3276835084,
-0.2628665566,
-0.1785289198,
0.0695860162,
-0.8670241833,
-0.6314296722,
0.817343533,
0.3746013343,
0.4582227767,
0.3003192842,
0.6190603971,
0.1863961071,
0.411246866,
-0.7125133276,
0.8651271462,
0.2814373076,
-1.0461629629,
-0.5706191063,
-0.6501285434,
-0.8510184884,
0.2786002457,
0.1863479465,
-0.8389550447,
0.0250327624,
0.3738573194,
-0.4151129127,
0.2918600738,
-0.4523490965,
1.0275228024,
-0.0695512444,
-0.3782758713,
-0.1785297096,
-0.8267979622,
0.5533490181,
0.0630278513,
0.5144625902,
-0.0792885199,
0.2846461236,
0.8543136716,
-0.5493154526,
0.5696510077,
-0.3859434128,
-0.3087459505,
0.5037438273,
0.0514070429,
0.7548764348,
0.2795289755,
0.0090342006,
-0.2317704856,
0.1279088408,
-0.2811634839,
-0.9442695975,
0.8106004,
-0.6199560761,
-0.9066343307,
-0.2969267368,
-0.522862792,
-0.5554443598,
0.1958848983,
0.0216656402,
0.4764429927,
0.2613303959,
0.0675531253,
0.8960348368,
-0.1541797966,
0.1691057831,
0.3726555109,
-0.3801800311,
-0.4982754588,
0.8963357806,
0.2538849413,
0.3596324623,
0.2921996117,
0.4911901355,
-0.7354730368,
-0.6213537455,
-0.5406834483,
0.4550675154,
-1.0893604755,
-0.1005825102,
-0.7983525991,
0.148968786,
-0.6071930528,
-0.2343484163,
-0.1272905171,
-0.504152596,
0.0626340508,
-0.2315948904,
0.2275120318,
0.2637069821,
-0.2495673746,
-0.2381404638,
-0.6991435885,
0.7638312578,
0.7653819919,
0.2522298694,
0.077222243,
-0.4078814387,
-0.1213304028,
-0.0174975265,
-0.0416083895,
-0.9039496183,
0.0713428035,
-0.3884371519,
0.6991571784,
0.114767015,
0.2198729068,
0.6175373793,
-0.088544257,
0.7933183908,
-0.01639116,
-0.7378276587,
0.332174778,
-0.3723189235,
-0.1126261204,
0.4822596908,
0.739079237,
-0.682187736,
-0.3455921412,
-0.5627146959,
-0.5419550538,
0.6236575842,
0.1106692106,
-0.0770236701,
-0.0265647061,
0.3657848239,
0.0270046182,
0.0552872904,
-0.7628257871,
0.0975696594,
-0.3433353305,
-0.25240013,
0.4091306925,
-0.3118492663,
-0.511133194,
0.0210739654,
1.0682295561,
-0.2311760038,
0.0270589776,
0.3654587567,
0.1199237332,
-0.0065837875,
0.4222442508,
0.3808974028,
0.9315056205,
-0.100789994,
0.1809396744,
0.4146454334,
-0.0317762792,
0.0911655128,
-0.0367032103,
-0.3118422329,
-0.1455159336,
0.127653107,
0.5518773794,
-0.1720748693,
-0.7169572711,
0.5743830204,
0.0127352178,
-0.4440439343,
-0.2282878458,
-0.0364821926,
0.2629512846,
0.2501648366,
0.1154410318,
-0.3197027147,
0.0636669621,
-0.5054404736,
-0.0142973531,
0.3337985575,
-0.3183062673,
0.0507893004,
0.406514138,
-0.0294452608,
-0.0976451263,
0.7611759901,
-0.1564000398,
-0.6502574086,
0.4757532179,
0.5914742947,
0.5277232528,
0.2660560608,
0.4771438241,
0.4857684672,
0.0730268583,
-0.2472112626,
0.408008337,
-0.2290468961,
-1.1164306402,
-0.6691043377,
-0.343600601,
-0.4941185415,
0.0124817947,
-0.4082980454,
0.0792445168,
-0.2246365994,
-0.0749058276,
-0.1868699044,
-0.1708872914,
-0.2461915016,
0.574999094,
0.2396945953,
0.9613674283,
-0.7302244306,
0.4942170084,
0.4304395914,
-0.3182348609,
-1.1408737898,
-0.1990411133,
-0.15556705,
-0.838290453,
0.8760530949,
-0.0744465515,
-0.1740046591,
0.1768691093,
-0.865966022,
-0.791036427,
0.8807188869,
0.1336925179,
-0.2421953231,
-0.0194617752,
0.4662793577,
0.0416628867,
0.014798793,
-0.0819999054,
0.4985678494,
0.8276205063,
0.4583391249,
-0.548176825,
0.3078512251,
0.1978998184,
-0.1610859036,
0.1927381456,
-0.5874542594,
0.1243104339,
-0.3822582364,
-0.1868889034,
0.054919485,
0.7290092111,
0.7599244118,
0.7403659225,
0.4661482573,
1.0693018436,
1.1465213299,
-0.2165648937,
1.1943577528,
-0.1144489199,
0.3285445869,
0.7493028641,
-0.3172333539,
0.4456452727,
0.6098574996,
-0.0354818366,
0.2362911999,
0.5757484436,
0.2688502669,
0.4792628288,
0.4522702992,
-0.1623015851,
-0.5936453342,
-0.0614794344,
-0.3201531172,
0.2395644486,
0.1089612469,
0.0369019844,
-0.3169125319,
0.0496791452,
0.5505701303,
0.1158489957,
-0.2949033082,
0.2986226082,
0.0126098339,
-1.1132129431,
0.5966767073,
-0.0529313013,
0.0399359167,
-0.5944004059,
0.1358742565,
-0.1927963495,
-0.235005185,
-0.3615139127,
-0.9510794282,
0.2588233054,
0.052674789,
0.02867347,
-0.2214634567,
0.7744707465,
0.0132286306,
-0.2744553387,
-0.202082932,
0.4688090086,
0.2681193352,
0.1923021227,
-0.6356346011,
-0.1617891639,
0.0711628869,
-0.3643853366,
0.0441863835,
0.8145506978,
-0.1193387806,
0.9197449684,
0.8090581298,
-0.0783791989,
0.0289335884,
0.1766800284,
0.6380926371,
-0.6312784553,
-0.3340193927,
-0.8457160592,
0.3913972378,
-0.163680464,
-0.276389569,
0.8730430603,
0.6345641613,
0.5812003016,
0.1421754062,
0.8329696059,
-0.1807823032,
0.6516407728,
-0.9084531069,
0.4745009243,
-0.5217932463,
-0.0555838197,
-0.092054911,
-0.749614656,
-0.7558440566,
0.4762404263,
-0.6453914642,
-0.0067230701,
0.5988410115,
1.1749533415,
0.1783741564,
0.4248997867,
0.4358028769,
0.1497451067,
0.4984256327,
0.3917228878,
1.1628183126,
-0.0269913748,
0.4054634869,
-0.0032780785,
-0.0314681679,
-0.0890463144,
-0.9986243844,
-0.7168977857,
-0.3698760569,
-0.4405193031,
-0.723574996,
0.3553987443,
0.8976813555,
0.5588408709,
-0.5546491742,
0.1126624644,
-0.2354476005,
0.4648676813,
0.0720169097,
-0.2141144425,
0.3856512606,
-0.347435385,
-0.32775262,
0.1796765327,
0.1530843377,
-0.1501023471,
-0.0403968357,
-0.3596425653,
-0.1000212878,
0.1822079718,
0.3660098016,
0.6682061553,
-0.6723495126,
-0.6366913915,
-0.0695604458,
-0.0191366673,
0.0244835168,
0.6798687577,
-0.7684211135,
0.2304089963,
0.6853242517,
0.7276824713,
0.2210417986,
0.0755598322,
0.3126517534,
-0.2011412233,
-0.3406294584,
0.4766030908,
0.1478837579,
0.3287379742,
-0.1794198006,
0.5822918415,
0.312505275,
-0.8709241748,
-0.9888978601,
0.4984967709,
-0.9944178462,
-0.1762247831,
1.3542604446,
0.0794747695,
-0.3594861329,
-0.5274736285,
-0.1019336656,
0.1372832358,
-0.0146567272,
0.694190979,
1.0589646101,
-0.0990542546,
0.0301436651,
-0.6412937641,
0.4851036072,
0.4093591571,
-0.630616188,
0.361405164,
0.6856765747,
0.1764363348,
0.1460618228,
0.87973243,
-0.3050695956,
0.411904186,
-0.3863109648,
-0.4051728249,
-0.1831069738,
-0.2652541399,
0.3299696147,
0.4591912627,
0.2762279212,
0.0904570073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01384v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01384v2
|
On the Compressibility of Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T03:27:07 | 2024-05-06T02:29:14 |
Yu Mao, Weilan Wang, Hongchao Du, Nan Guan, Chun Jason Xue
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Deploying Large Language Models (LLMs) on edge or mobile devices offers
significant benefits, such as enhanced data privacy and real-time processing
capabilities. However, it also faces critical challenges due to the substantial
memory requirement of LLMs. Quantization is an effective way of reducing the
model size while maintaining good performance. However, even after
quantization, LLMs may still be too big to fit entirely into the limited memory
of edge or mobile devices and have to be partially loaded from the storage to
complete the inference. In this case, the I/O latency of model loading becomes
the bottleneck of the LLM inference latency. In this work, we take a
preliminary step of studying applying data compression techniques to reduce
data movement and thus speed up the inference of quantized LLM on
memory-constrained devices. In particular, we discussed the compressibility of
quantized LLMs, the trade-off between the compressibility and performance of
quantized LLMs, and opportunities to optimize both of them jointly.
|
[
-0.2847763598,
-0.7949155569,
0.6171386838,
0.1000779942,
-0.2942658067,
0.2019332051,
-0.2441101372,
-0.4205504656,
0.0118518434,
0.4630039632,
-0.2817395926,
-0.3402330577,
-0.526533246,
-0.1769826412,
-0.4175984561,
0.4132446349,
0.0234968103,
-0.2637267113,
-0.3882652223,
-0.024377143,
-0.0696525201,
-0.9907972813,
-0.689706862,
-0.0672744885,
-0.0499153212,
0.0741674602,
1.1296223402,
0.9333189726,
0.3898426294,
0.3019359708,
-0.2729709148,
-0.2720547616,
-0.4253869653,
0.3010325432,
0.2008464783,
-0.6972590685,
-0.4402610958,
-0.2619941831,
0.630502224,
0.851586163,
-0.3390720487,
0.1536949724,
-0.0620857179,
0.6410086155,
-0.7908192277,
-0.1137354523,
-0.4048268497,
0.1478278339,
-0.1813519448,
0.0007435666,
-0.4185896516,
-0.4427781403,
-0.0092643807,
-0.4553548396,
0.1172158569,
0.1369653642,
0.6957237124,
0.6757258177,
-0.5774592161,
0.0101882461,
-0.992844522,
0.9262279272,
-0.6715172529,
0.5890059471,
0.4404368103,
0.1574655771,
-0.0760095567,
-0.6762880087,
-0.5563158989,
0.1485907435,
0.2151343524,
-0.3425483108,
-0.2402047515,
0.2397836447,
0.5898885131,
0.6126547456,
-0.6418023705,
0.2078457624,
-0.1211206615,
-0.1994305551,
0.6514508128,
0.060909953,
0.2111289501,
0.1410223544,
-0.1759113222,
0.0187881552,
-0.9577348232,
0.0333743282,
0.2240203917,
-0.072882466,
-0.1133247018,
0.4178323448,
-0.3216753602,
0.8836758137,
-0.2571108937,
-0.4513086081,
-0.0663342923,
-0.2852205634,
-0.3517177701,
-0.0739806816,
0.7546461225,
0.306720525,
0.1995616108,
-0.0604400001,
-0.2089947015,
-0.003495967,
-0.166907683,
-1.1632413864,
-0.1741322577,
0.5360476375,
-0.686294198,
0.1348650008,
-0.3647581041,
-0.4650788605,
-0.2008755207,
-0.0793680325,
0.4752682745,
-0.2242820263,
-0.065325819,
0.4308960438,
0.1663365066,
-0.2104377449,
0.2243942767,
-0.9120426774,
0.4568511546,
0.6270158291,
1.1155591011,
-0.0039824233,
0.3714605868,
-0.6341612339,
0.2390410453,
-0.0266654976,
0.451115638,
-0.3639748693,
-0.5236692429,
-0.0331726559,
-0.3274844587,
-0.0257380456,
-0.5966791511,
0.7453629971,
-0.6271311641,
-0.3931077123,
0.0875230655,
-0.6969904304,
-0.2147751898,
-0.0355964489,
-0.8701803684,
0.7918733358,
0.116394043,
-0.452783972,
-0.1078315973,
0.0567449182,
-0.496881485,
-0.1216263622,
0.0068804063,
-0.5419462323,
0.4006192684,
0.2460688204,
0.630785346,
-0.4805619419,
0.1367904544,
-0.478728652,
-0.6611633301,
0.4606332183,
-0.3717496693,
0.7664016485,
0.3748381734,
0.0234791469,
-0.4598064423,
-0.7229858637,
0.2736726999,
-0.0964611918,
-0.5082572103,
-0.5015854239,
0.2638140917,
-0.3593732417,
0.0376135223,
0.1646490842,
-0.3375168443,
0.5523204207,
-0.1712304503,
0.7627213597,
0.3658261895,
-0.2251185626,
0.4300511181,
-0.124648422,
0.6142061949,
-0.1738184094,
0.2985724509,
-0.096448943,
-0.0548522472,
-0.7773355842,
-0.5170145631,
0.5648717284,
0.6661366224,
-0.9301770329,
0.1785421818,
-0.5505442023,
-0.3476616144,
-0.5145328045,
0.0363105051,
0.2518077195,
0.0179082621,
-0.0323904715,
0.1751614064,
-0.360575527,
-0.6782822013,
-0.1003151089,
-0.0487968512,
-0.0689452365,
0.1700443029,
0.221352905,
0.0746139139,
0.7548817396,
-0.5336746573,
0.2066997439,
0.0461558104,
0.1790829599,
0.2977485955,
0.5746029019,
0.1549975872,
-0.9572033286,
-0.446193397,
-0.2432131469,
-0.604663372,
-0.4522710443,
-0.0602980219,
0.3701755404,
0.2922799587,
0.7200108767,
-0.9808958769,
0.6010733843,
1.0653045177,
-0.1275890023,
0.3835296333,
-0.206066519,
0.0847925693,
-0.806884408,
-0.3349651098,
-0.1453657299,
-0.5202710032,
-0.6523007154,
0.0873260722,
0.0135153737,
-0.373589009,
-0.532363236,
0.4441428185,
-0.705263257,
-0.2390615344,
-0.1533025354,
0.0268893559,
0.1020538583,
0.2251378894,
0.140714854,
0.9858440757,
0.6802646518,
-1.0322706699,
0.030987164,
0.0150148943,
-0.3173622787,
0.4535934925,
-0.7486124635,
0.1125997156,
0.1420831233,
0.3070892096,
-0.5232266188,
0.1906495988,
-0.0671314076,
-0.1463022232,
0.2190617174,
-0.3391908705,
-0.9487684965,
-0.2132870406,
-0.3655057251,
0.7111033797,
0.7399219871,
-0.6060205102,
0.6024822593,
0.4070500135,
-0.1297057271,
-0.2293329388,
-0.8095377684,
0.0794666037,
-0.4760136008,
-0.7437974811,
0.6392789483,
-0.219482094,
-0.5450244546,
-0.0741510689,
-0.0222830493,
-0.0995362252,
0.2468620986,
0.4771299362,
-0.0242040474,
-0.0689305812,
0.3976273537,
0.2259925902,
-0.1417789906,
-0.1141049787,
-0.3084987104,
0.6098384857,
-0.0430389754,
-0.2018091977,
-0.4552558661,
0.3224108815,
0.3142934144,
0.0372048356,
0.8334065676,
0.3457312584,
-0.2194996029,
-0.1328180134,
-0.4549902976,
-0.0199775677,
-0.5212833881,
0.1498744041,
-0.5577851534,
-1.0809658766,
0.4920848012,
-0.450935632,
-0.3859203756,
0.0932944492,
0.446778506,
0.0149380527,
0.9579774737,
0.4986650646,
0.018146662,
0.3850125074,
-0.3677030206,
0.3629346192,
-0.904303968,
0.214792341,
-0.6533394456,
-0.2717139125,
-0.7231864333,
-0.6203922629,
0.524615705,
0.5008754134,
-0.0916562304,
0.1901944876,
-0.3467303514,
0.3981240392,
0.3536631763,
0.1276259422,
0.5548950434,
0.0647918954,
0.2853196859,
0.0876817182,
-0.8323417902,
-0.2984830439,
0.960930407,
0.4184494317,
0.9793556333,
0.3419708908,
0.5006908178,
0.0864510834,
-0.2297762781,
-0.7397376299,
0.7713733912,
-0.3394342959,
-0.2852170169,
-0.303447783,
-0.688398242,
-0.8881284595,
0.2957265675,
-0.1011374295,
-1.0658382177,
0.1309809983,
0.0514709577,
-0.7092075348,
0.2983828783,
-0.7049602866,
0.4026274979,
-0.030916689,
-0.5549363494,
-0.2682317495,
-0.4627557695,
0.290168792,
-0.0606836751,
0.4248944819,
-0.1274316758,
-0.28469643,
0.6428400278,
-0.9052679539,
0.728456378,
-0.1070931852,
-0.3429932892,
0.3810222745,
0.2488463819,
0.529147923,
0.0772016868,
-0.1703452617,
0.2941987514,
0.2090933025,
-0.4290877879,
-0.7953807116,
0.6169329882,
-0.3972778618,
-0.5322777033,
-0.142000109,
-0.7799255848,
-0.1793949306,
-0.125265792,
0.3336521983,
0.4918784499,
0.1714558005,
0.1584022045,
0.997097075,
-0.390714854,
0.8915446401,
0.2928901613,
-0.2860590219,
-0.3549790084,
0.9664245248,
0.406678319,
0.4373920262,
0.5458134413,
0.1422835439,
-0.1970605254,
-0.7550902963,
-0.3120078743,
0.1046508849,
-0.4334190488,
-0.2301817387,
-0.5705631375,
-0.1588553637,
-0.2625499964,
-0.1628067642,
-0.5329911113,
-0.7640228271,
-0.31758672,
0.2375605255,
0.4057990015,
0.2476501167,
-0.1427133381,
1.0514265299,
-1.0166705847,
0.192065835,
0.122019507,
0.1029008627,
-0.0043777502,
-0.4594503641,
-0.6135383844,
0.0111096492,
-0.1365834177,
-0.4503517449,
0.3641868532,
0.3128971457,
-0.0331729352,
0.3200645149,
0.1954717934,
0.7392822504,
-0.1255962104,
0.684335351,
-0.1119218096,
-1.2248110771,
0.1981378347,
-0.1101347208,
0.267174542,
0.2988567054,
0.5299960375,
-0.1824219823,
-0.1067208797,
-0.5110488534,
-0.8318966627,
0.1048370823,
0.0922946334,
0.2153214663,
0.2500503659,
0.4998149574,
0.0193075575,
0.3314313591,
-0.7143870592,
-0.0526688062,
0.4110247791,
-0.1267762482,
0.1345205158,
-0.4748623371,
0.3009470403,
-0.2202109843,
0.5283957124,
-0.0262452494,
0.3165886104,
0.1163223907,
-0.2622305751,
0.1766226739,
0.1537733525,
0.5010733008,
0.2115313262,
-0.0765870586,
0.3628219068,
-0.0515704341,
-0.4645522535,
0.433188498,
0.0578771718,
-0.3915309608,
0.0049271393,
0.3347225487,
0.9398012161,
0.0714674369,
-0.6667224765,
0.2987371087,
-0.1685008705,
0.0987716019,
-0.1491942853,
-0.0095495749,
0.0517820641,
0.4345551431,
0.2704967558,
-0.5005645752,
0.2285603583,
-0.4579052627,
-0.0145911276,
0.6129567623,
0.0825522542,
-0.2285778224,
0.4952559471,
0.1233481392,
-0.3260647357,
0.6391653419,
-0.2904368937,
-0.4327087402,
0.3426146209,
0.4817498922,
0.5959149599,
-0.3249049783,
-0.0998682976,
0.181010738,
0.0506621227,
-0.2925367057,
0.2693369091,
-0.2577174902,
-0.5459218621,
-0.9090908766,
-0.3615908027,
-0.2744663954,
-0.0361814015,
-0.5724058747,
0.1003907695,
-0.2201047093,
-0.5083805919,
-0.4656349421,
0.0381750986,
-0.2883338034,
0.2370646596,
0.1288949698,
0.8329547048,
-0.5767234564,
0.9285335541,
-0.0117777279,
0.1163329706,
-0.7787109017,
0.1336476952,
-0.1697036475,
-0.645483017,
0.7668753862,
-0.0473869964,
0.0264869612,
0.2908466458,
-0.5368881822,
-0.9173178673,
0.9955858588,
0.577737987,
-0.8927280903,
-0.0012711709,
0.2697341442,
0.3781794012,
0.1282906234,
0.3073958457,
0.5057136416,
0.2857354283,
0.0661464632,
-0.9498022795,
0.2550057471,
0.1010022238,
0.1021643206,
0.4667751789,
-0.8327205777,
1.0323400497,
-0.1215404496,
-0.3454365432,
0.1479473859,
0.5492453575,
0.2597441375,
0.26526618,
0.3927890658,
0.9568503499,
0.7780069709,
-0.0147503344,
1.2410240173,
-0.370333612,
0.4244436622,
0.8704084158,
-0.2854433656,
1.0130801201,
0.6256439686,
-0.4303616285,
0.2371862829,
0.7827219367,
0.2350571007,
0.3434762359,
0.6146250367,
-0.6122950315,
-0.1674635112,
-0.3207503259,
-0.3069892228,
0.2591575384,
0.2942472398,
-0.0595765673,
0.0189268645,
0.1813043058,
0.2242910117,
-0.1545031369,
-0.4043219984,
0.4024263322,
0.3292791843,
-0.343852222,
1.014046073,
-0.0509746149,
0.6252347231,
-0.0440285467,
0.1673741341,
-0.2128717005,
-0.1260516196,
-0.170615539,
-0.457528919,
0.4292791188,
-0.2239234895,
-0.1269132793,
-0.4059827328,
0.5501664877,
-0.3096188903,
-0.3655721247,
0.1471561491,
0.5561687946,
0.3158169985,
-0.4987131357,
-0.280908227,
0.6415334344,
-0.1493840218,
-0.5108623505,
0.4761323333,
0.5335588455,
-0.0939732194,
1.2421233654,
0.552846849,
0.2449233085,
0.0059034214,
-0.2916055322,
0.7755838037,
-0.6363294125,
-0.3518356979,
-1.1848018169,
0.2234530896,
0.1924657375,
0.2153047919,
0.5301591158,
0.6810081005,
0.4698127508,
0.0511772372,
0.6596682668,
-0.068513684,
0.3754635751,
-1.0928587914,
0.5336917043,
-0.4828962684,
0.5818097591,
0.0719690993,
-0.7315340042,
-0.2630885541,
0.477404952,
-0.1450889558,
-0.062044356,
0.8573797345,
0.7545742393,
0.2055407763,
-0.2808759809,
0.4906011224,
0.1482865214,
0.0927926749,
0.9598365426,
0.6409624815,
-0.5807667375,
0.5686190724,
-0.4417584538,
-0.0163604282,
-0.2092090696,
-1.1623258591,
-0.7622313499,
-0.6251395941,
-0.7671462297,
-0.3222271502,
-0.0440685079,
0.5075953603,
1.1093629599,
-0.2647966743,
-0.3390010893,
-0.1332808733,
0.3330914676,
0.0147746485,
-0.206870079,
0.3396285474,
0.3076047897,
-0.8447359204,
0.2413982451,
0.2481202632,
0.4418850243,
-0.1698612273,
-0.0097480379,
0.0408320203,
0.0578259937,
0.6480844021,
0.302313298,
-0.2889734805,
0.0466227084,
-0.1459887773,
-0.116122216,
-0.0112456614,
0.9105679393,
-1.0448987484,
0.0224533677,
0.4556011856,
0.5558283329,
0.6577609777,
0.0738184229,
0.6437295675,
-0.6264107823,
0.4541069269,
-0.0268140305,
0.1758902222,
0.1660043001,
-0.5149264336,
0.7024556398,
0.1744817495,
-0.7280324101,
-1.1116662025,
0.201830402,
-0.9806649089,
-0.3002293706,
1.213950038,
-0.1738352776,
-0.3762149513,
0.018986918,
-0.0457564965,
0.240197733,
-0.2129060179,
0.5982525349,
0.6215574145,
-0.2158503383,
-0.4907862246,
-0.9063826799,
0.4026372135,
0.4088639319,
-0.8058180213,
0.1129674762,
0.1716388315,
-0.1960586905,
0.014171904,
0.5401841998,
0.2384583652,
-0.1200852245,
0.1235097721,
0.2319711596,
-0.019142976,
0.0964635462,
-0.6375587583,
0.108787477,
0.0556850135,
-0.2232910395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01382v1
|
Automatic Question-Answer Generation for Long-Tail Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T03:06:31 | 2024-03-03T03:06:31 |
Rohan Kumar, Youngmin Kim, Sunitha Ravi, Haitian Sun, Christos Faloutsos, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Minji Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant attention for
addressing open-domain Question Answering (QA). While they exhibit high
accuracy in answering questions related to common knowledge, LLMs encounter
difficulties in learning about uncommon long-tail knowledge (tail entities).
Since manually constructing QA datasets demands substantial human resources,
the types of existing QA datasets are limited, leaving us with a scarcity of
datasets to study the performance of LLMs on tail entities. In this paper, we
propose an automatic approach to generate specialized QA datasets for tail
entities and present the associated research challenges. We conduct extensive
experiments by employing pretrained LLMs on our newly generated long-tail QA
datasets, comparing their performance with and without external resources
including Wikipedia and Wikidata knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.6590688825,
-0.8817687631,
0.7029946446,
-0.0413779989,
-0.2225890309,
0.1061039045,
-0.1506055295,
-0.3837510049,
0.3246051669,
0.8657850027,
-0.8090786934,
-0.5531169772,
-0.2005607784,
0.4309533238,
-0.2457053214,
1.043590188,
-0.1149108186,
-0.3338077366,
-0.1799564213,
-0.1435501128,
-0.4423353076,
-0.4515282214,
-0.6757723093,
0.170018211,
0.4624929726,
0.4490927458,
0.604391098,
0.3045464754,
0.2496868223,
0.1589549035,
0.3095293343,
0.4601918161,
-0.5580475926,
0.1429000497,
-0.1943902075,
-0.2732859552,
-0.4234156311,
-0.3118496835,
0.7400348783,
0.8185662627,
-0.0547890775,
0.4650329947,
-0.2085038126,
0.6972599626,
-0.5517615676,
0.089183256,
-0.9616946578,
-0.2452203035,
-0.3872097731,
-0.1619806141,
-0.1250169724,
-0.5623756647,
0.1923923641,
-0.9582653642,
0.2588483691,
0.0990899131,
0.9104189873,
0.3458307087,
-0.5566529632,
-0.5218906999,
-0.6372705698,
0.5954788923,
-0.7677959204,
0.3008239865,
0.1310918182,
0.2394038439,
-0.2843798399,
-0.6792917848,
-0.6437273622,
0.1234701127,
-0.0214050412,
-0.0960627869,
-0.1628613472,
-0.1884203553,
0.3097527027,
0.1035139486,
-0.7304208279,
0.2611943185,
-0.4211729765,
0.2114864588,
0.824924469,
0.390918225,
0.1052123755,
-0.2119592577,
0.1217106953,
-0.1161397919,
-1.0457133055,
0.0814386755,
0.505407393,
0.1293469965,
0.4597513676,
0.6864162683,
-0.4557801187,
0.8307273984,
0.1776355505,
0.1460929662,
0.3300014436,
-0.0832746327,
-0.0407260023,
-0.2142917365,
0.8566214442,
0.2840288281,
0.6310759187,
-0.3552233279,
-0.3907208145,
-0.6437072158,
0.1534143537,
-0.785882175,
-0.1443638653,
0.373862654,
0.0255249087,
-0.0279237237,
-0.1657375246,
-0.7779195905,
-0.0944265872,
-0.2760107815,
0.7094519138,
-0.2407274693,
-0.4838770032,
0.1312389821,
0.0934050903,
0.33173576,
0.0550412312,
-0.516659677,
0.4521621168,
0.2833881676,
0.293725729,
-0.5706219673,
-0.2210246325,
-0.7134503126,
0.2408392131,
-0.5341079831,
0.76039505,
-0.3362542093,
-0.2558290958,
0.1259844005,
0.1292250305,
-0.0926925018,
-0.6980982423,
0.0883100852,
-1.1074761152,
-0.028699493,
-0.3043188453,
-0.751318872,
-0.0518863201,
0.0614521392,
-0.8842785954,
0.868380487,
0.2500107884,
-1.0744899511,
0.2530152202,
-0.6894672513,
-0.3642978668,
0.1491336226,
-0.2524676323,
-0.3510472775,
-0.132965818,
0.628923893,
0.608432591,
-0.3333469331,
0.3785554767,
-0.0507663265,
-0.1512065083,
0.3408635259,
0.0646679029,
0.6826820374,
0.0745984614,
-0.1230233759,
-0.0240772497,
-0.9650455713,
0.3479133248,
0.4556268752,
-0.0292228311,
-0.5601194501,
0.0154917762,
-0.3881231844,
-0.0734854564,
0.3274445832,
-0.4401994348,
0.2234672606,
-0.2936472595,
0.2578990161,
0.6938018799,
0.4218995869,
0.1779082716,
-0.1306020021,
0.6899678707,
0.1488648653,
-0.1063333899,
0.0052714944,
-0.2370032817,
-0.7596045732,
0.0824415609,
0.304604739,
0.5148671865,
-0.9894371033,
0.4692271352,
-0.4945006967,
-0.3928979933,
-0.3902518153,
0.321823597,
0.1496133655,
0.5209354162,
0.4299219251,
-0.1333987415,
-0.4237440228,
-0.9170538783,
0.0392774902,
-0.0215701722,
-0.1543889642,
0.5890799165,
0.5833513737,
-0.0011136188,
1.2273128033,
-1.0504626036,
0.0064866114,
0.0895110816,
0.1289618462,
0.1347663403,
0.2090127021,
0.432814151,
-0.5748272538,
-0.329364866,
-0.4104301333,
-0.7604630589,
-0.047388915,
0.0207340363,
-0.2871504128,
0.1413798332,
0.4275188744,
-0.8886627555,
-0.0625991598,
0.3055085242,
-0.0138044534,
0.8532937765,
-0.0033550733,
0.0982257798,
-1.065341115,
0.2073468715,
-0.0927049145,
0.0317091718,
-0.451696068,
0.0970410481,
-0.0233969614,
-0.2265000194,
-0.411911428,
0.6182536483,
-0.5256327987,
-0.1723711789,
0.1124886647,
0.2297665328,
-0.1555551589,
0.5196222067,
0.3966976702,
0.8856173158,
0.4303978682,
-0.9818766117,
0.3479434252,
0.2935372591,
-0.126404658,
0.2737541497,
-0.8745697737,
0.3968369067,
-0.1237251014,
0.1294632107,
-0.5461791754,
-0.4324910939,
0.1309481263,
-0.1964875162,
0.2138887495,
-0.156122908,
-0.655605793,
-0.549175024,
-0.0255108066,
0.4302630126,
0.7662258744,
-0.437673986,
0.3601560295,
0.4508461356,
-0.4840036929,
-0.6608729362,
-0.0214298069,
-0.0785255656,
-0.2253802568,
-0.8963591456,
0.105954811,
-0.1692590863,
-0.1813526154,
0.0050097466,
0.1641171277,
-0.3272111416,
0.0573624335,
0.0531299114,
0.0631059334,
-0.479837507,
0.566336453,
0.2022118419,
0.2441961914,
0.4584137499,
-0.3919389844,
0.3432058394,
-0.1588566154,
-0.3610275388,
0.0992880613,
0.4068152308,
0.1444052458,
-0.6173236966,
0.4860967696,
0.3133819401,
-0.2679810822,
-0.5320459604,
-0.63604635,
-0.2262954712,
-0.4453433156,
0.4324384034,
-0.3521866202,
-0.7936859131,
0.4678965509,
0.1274293959,
0.3716980815,
0.5006195307,
0.4759473503,
0.0100461552,
0.8349340558,
0.4556138515,
0.2343512475,
-0.066911228,
-0.2228371948,
0.0093136402,
-0.4356380999,
0.0153038967,
-0.4548367262,
0.274730742,
-0.5318849087,
-0.3083217144,
0.4780404568,
0.1443964243,
-0.3642168045,
0.0621421374,
-0.4707501531,
0.4475007951,
0.5969750881,
-0.0151110087,
0.5380516052,
-0.0909889042,
0.2371359318,
0.3363422155,
-0.5642367601,
-0.5958123207,
1.486177206,
0.1203731447,
0.831189096,
-0.1354621798,
0.9431412816,
-0.0938669518,
0.1508570015,
-0.4766823649,
0.495190531,
-0.0105989454,
-0.5239490867,
-0.7495277524,
-0.5677960515,
-1.1007094383,
-0.2489529848,
-0.1298002303,
-0.1655571014,
-0.1728421748,
0.1110291258,
-0.5192320943,
0.2199315578,
-0.4895369112,
0.6463837028,
-0.3060074151,
-0.0531949475,
0.1163941771,
-0.6237655878,
0.6486701965,
-0.6181789041,
0.015219504,
-0.039949622,
0.0814483464,
1.2182596922,
-0.2974548638,
0.5720071197,
-0.3486901224,
-0.4164640903,
0.671007812,
-0.0585333146,
0.6568351984,
0.2273681909,
0.0291973613,
-0.1860286444,
0.254540354,
-0.3579701483,
-0.5266317725,
0.3573057652,
-0.8341963291,
-0.7934741378,
-0.0846110284,
-0.5350103974,
-0.7542621493,
0.2188448757,
0.1969143897,
0.1441257894,
-0.2789411545,
-0.1613214165,
1.1068102121,
-0.4276560545,
0.1328628212,
0.8692772985,
-0.29069525,
-0.2217440456,
0.917737484,
0.3479584455,
0.0639336556,
0.1955934167,
-0.1228788942,
-0.4358699322,
-0.7056464553,
-0.7182582617,
0.3591129482,
-0.5588688254,
-0.3135490417,
-0.7658492327,
-0.4809742272,
-0.2800247669,
0.2702484429,
-0.2025989443,
-0.36815238,
-0.3833535314,
0.0082954736,
0.6568713188,
0.7858928442,
0.1435071528,
0.1455286741,
-1.087146759,
0.6213616729,
0.7532533407,
0.1872843206,
0.0699168891,
-0.1427971423,
-0.2968424857,
0.1798821539,
-0.1387923062,
-0.8230773211,
0.2859749198,
0.2345171422,
0.520796299,
0.0866570771,
0.4790230691,
0.5108386874,
-0.6703950763,
0.7766380906,
-0.0174580608,
-0.5762286782,
0.566716969,
-0.4192278087,
0.026942445,
0.4014629722,
0.9303278923,
-0.1102790013,
-0.6030629277,
-0.6634396315,
-0.8899872899,
0.2589392066,
0.2407714427,
0.1971949637,
-0.1934836656,
0.4987094402,
0.5204213858,
0.3261246383,
-0.4768433869,
-0.0965485498,
-0.1405960768,
-0.2438934147,
-0.0260466076,
0.0027288627,
-0.0862255022,
0.1562502831,
0.6579860449,
-0.2990068495,
-0.1649681628,
0.1036618873,
-0.4026526213,
-0.2510142922,
0.2880787551,
0.0918255895,
1.1756654978,
-0.2680976391,
-0.1033406854,
0.2346663624,
-0.2720320821,
0.2043395191,
0.1773903221,
-0.3290894628,
0.0135965152,
0.0797903687,
0.4691307247,
-0.2977719605,
-1.0020010471,
0.4315058589,
-0.0410151109,
-0.2127284408,
-0.7195385098,
0.1488596946,
0.3400375545,
0.0204640608,
0.7880898118,
-0.7061958313,
-0.1725387424,
-0.1921958923,
0.3536960781,
0.4923307896,
0.179012835,
-0.2139625549,
0.3769156337,
0.3498288989,
0.0560720004,
1.0178490877,
-0.1658617556,
-0.3082182705,
0.6469978094,
0.2558427155,
0.5137398839,
0.0216338243,
0.1465529352,
0.4142288566,
0.1343733221,
0.0958815888,
0.2972524762,
0.2138558328,
-0.621031642,
-0.7312905788,
-0.7289191484,
-0.4550512433,
0.5124842525,
-0.7644023299,
0.1322684437,
-0.1372479796,
-0.0601287,
-0.2044608444,
0.0726633742,
-0.9820904732,
0.4351083636,
-0.115003027,
0.8975139856,
-0.6729813218,
0.5818027258,
0.6290803552,
-0.7416307926,
-0.9103511572,
0.0755762458,
-0.8248206377,
-0.7829265594,
1.0196563005,
-0.2068092078,
0.0163868312,
0.4234075844,
-0.7310286164,
-0.8051906824,
0.956797719,
0.3070033193,
-0.6347708702,
-0.7542747855,
0.4098044336,
0.4116042554,
-0.2942693233,
0.0953745544,
0.5213029385,
0.3813482225,
-0.2406482697,
-0.9618352056,
0.1830809265,
-0.0790171251,
-0.3924588859,
0.1408132911,
-0.5786365271,
0.8253589869,
-0.3436396122,
-0.1155646294,
-0.0591831431,
0.9138188362,
0.4527628422,
0.0695382506,
0.6349841952,
0.4983390868,
0.7924690247,
0.2986983359,
0.4806168675,
-0.3564407825,
0.1247659549,
1.1334123611,
-0.3875308931,
0.9377219081,
0.3458201289,
-0.1921223402,
0.4259898961,
0.7969610691,
-0.1192011237,
0.2232343405,
0.5638955832,
-0.1048008054,
-0.5684624314,
0.2300991416,
-0.5228090882,
0.2532660663,
0.2603282034,
-0.0845863745,
-0.3296898603,
-0.0984929949,
-0.2514177263,
-0.1167612076,
-0.359561801,
0.8600122333,
0.1748676747,
-0.8943358064,
0.8229165077,
-0.1367012262,
0.6849756837,
-0.7697588205,
-0.0750408396,
-0.2434589565,
-0.365329355,
-0.2074841857,
-1.0820041895,
0.2125153691,
0.2844443023,
-0.0498399027,
0.243283689,
0.507420361,
-0.3142051697,
-0.3808256984,
-0.0072417636,
0.9964042306,
0.3050857484,
-0.2679938078,
-0.4076847434,
-0.4930059314,
-0.2335615158,
-0.4714360535,
0.3422849178,
0.6943784952,
-0.2177340239,
0.863961041,
0.5491505265,
0.0269420203,
0.4199900329,
-0.2630325854,
0.9200531244,
-0.6269909143,
-0.4277764261,
-0.2393977791,
0.3154633045,
0.0170462411,
-0.2704502642,
0.4391105771,
0.5216870308,
0.8176229596,
-0.3461697102,
0.929540813,
-0.0460356958,
0.8868229985,
-0.8149875998,
0.9485176802,
-0.6112618446,
0.0656027123,
-0.022073254,
-0.7470679879,
0.2191505432,
0.1013133451,
-0.1203681901,
-0.0537273474,
0.5537352562,
0.7988620996,
-0.0076290481,
-0.2605345249,
0.1078318134,
0.1008119062,
0.2226386666,
0.8824829459,
0.8838391304,
-0.200396046,
0.8326359391,
-0.3090338409,
0.220611468,
0.0446693003,
-0.84695822,
-0.9969310164,
-0.7558795214,
-0.3396959007,
-0.2363010645,
0.2026989907,
0.7677807808,
0.4689562321,
-0.7678930163,
-0.1147518903,
0.010924588,
0.1465313137,
0.1323683411,
-0.3058308661,
0.8629691005,
-0.4849655628,
-0.5627700686,
0.1751279831,
-0.4736902118,
0.0283133779,
-0.4567610621,
0.0221615359,
0.0880519524,
0.0800074041,
0.3422430158,
0.4298602045,
-0.3936148882,
-0.230884552,
0.2276484817,
0.0058206832,
0.0831659436,
0.6711899042,
-0.8967829347,
-0.1588281393,
0.3127821982,
0.8596242666,
0.4230887294,
0.0175370667,
0.7079563737,
-0.7448409796,
-0.4546883702,
0.5358973742,
0.0043393793,
0.1521857977,
-0.297986418,
0.4510351121,
0.0114311352,
-0.4898021519,
-0.8906096816,
0.2125072479,
-0.7690344453,
-0.2182591408,
1.2359906435,
-0.2043852955,
-0.2646762729,
-0.192558378,
0.053388454,
0.3022854328,
-0.2219345272,
0.5389606357,
0.38011235,
-0.1602537483,
0.0313188583,
-0.5372456908,
0.6533928514,
0.0478275232,
-1.1108601093,
0.2364620566,
0.5347932577,
0.9033787847,
-0.0672212243,
0.6990122795,
0.0999685973,
0.2450543344,
-0.1971917003,
0.1858078539,
-0.3175036311,
-0.0581479184,
0.1752878875,
0.376483798,
0.3125217557,
0.0917963758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14666v1
|
SyllabusQA: A Course Logistics Question Answering Dataset
| 2024-03-03T03:01:14 | 2024-03-03T03:01:14 |
Nigel Fernandez, Alexander Scarlatos, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Automated teaching assistants and chatbots have significant potential to
reduce the workload of human instructors, especially for logistics-related
question answering, which is important to students yet repetitive for
instructors. However, due to privacy concerns, there is a lack of publicly
available datasets. We introduce SyllabusQA, an open-source dataset with 63
real course syllabi covering 36 majors, containing 5,078 open-ended course
logistics-related question-answer pairs that are diverse in both question types
and answer formats. Since many logistics-related questions contain critical
information like the date of an exam, it is important to evaluate the
factuality of answers. We benchmark several strong baselines on this task, from
large language model prompting to retrieval-augmented generation. We find that
despite performing close to humans on traditional metrics of textual
similarity, there remains a significant gap between automated approaches and
humans in terms of fact precision.
|
[
-0.1575797498,
-0.8190147281,
0.4227007926,
-0.2746402025,
0.1150711179,
0.0563835874,
0.1813943237,
-0.4963726699,
0.1246938556,
0.4798505902,
-0.8720389605,
-0.4458866119,
0.0910761058,
-0.0079935929,
-0.7323242426,
1.2513381243,
0.1078846008,
-0.2663069069,
-0.5695027709,
-0.367328614,
-0.6065046191,
-0.6811555028,
-0.6492646337,
-0.0459104143,
0.574586153,
0.3017653525,
0.8984286785,
0.5212000608,
0.532245338,
0.1899746954,
0.0211270843,
-0.1161602288,
-0.301358968,
0.082724914,
-0.3166740239,
-0.6280084252,
-0.5908061862,
-0.1270376593,
0.6278346181,
0.8824436069,
-0.685031116,
0.8588053584,
0.0409496874,
0.5278282166,
-0.8792803288,
0.0243922938,
-0.3582734466,
-0.1144349501,
-0.2914757729,
0.1714570969,
-0.3958353698,
-0.5892994404,
0.4167554379,
-0.9606354833,
0.3817550242,
0.0988263562,
1.0709195137,
0.471501112,
-0.4368953407,
-0.4373653531,
-0.6392418146,
0.7098571062,
-0.3813004494,
0.3448108137,
0.7452659607,
0.4705120921,
0.0502726622,
-0.7151917219,
-0.4681977928,
0.1682590842,
-0.2116715014,
0.2547953427,
-0.1448304355,
0.1890913695,
0.1037761047,
0.3683486581,
-1.0035796165,
0.0041784742,
-0.6753631234,
-0.1724056453,
0.8144019842,
0.6035865545,
0.2538320124,
-0.2717998326,
-0.2978157401,
-0.299950242,
-0.4057316482,
0.2188581377,
0.4458476901,
-0.1200527251,
-0.1648875624,
0.3660357893,
-0.5197626948,
0.9156380892,
-0.483826369,
0.1485217214,
-0.0668390319,
-0.3263257444,
-0.4330652356,
0.0441104434,
0.4704125226,
0.4130021632,
-0.1346192211,
0.0104008494,
0.0549461879,
-0.15124394,
0.3729328513,
-0.2144091278,
-0.5402413607,
0.5322461724,
-0.1560940295,
-0.027150223,
0.0192119926,
-0.8221924901,
-0.2250758559,
-0.3168466389,
0.5958140492,
0.0200975761,
0.1517212838,
0.1441507339,
-0.0994491652,
0.4374870062,
0.7200950384,
-0.5129804611,
0.2916700542,
0.5401036143,
0.7630950809,
-0.0495797247,
-0.0805202946,
-0.5810690522,
0.2092558891,
-0.3315032721,
0.7158324122,
-0.2241851836,
0.0059591061,
-0.0320324302,
0.115156427,
0.187242046,
-0.548794508,
0.4820583165,
-0.6594462991,
0.6017654538,
-0.2411936224,
-0.5854842663,
-0.5179902911,
0.2766302526,
-0.8616383076,
1.3055847883,
0.1089422479,
-0.3231725991,
0.229491815,
-0.5420688391,
-0.146323815,
0.3394303322,
-0.2601936758,
-0.2965647876,
-0.3877146244,
-0.0509925485,
0.525994122,
-0.4812726974,
0.5807567239,
-0.1122389957,
-0.2272586673,
0.2416347116,
-0.4231797457,
1.2627294064,
0.1309628189,
-0.0838775188,
-0.1938055456,
-0.7300795913,
0.102328904,
-0.217176795,
-0.4003066719,
-0.2961686552,
-0.1446632892,
-0.0035396304,
0.0861338526,
0.2884224057,
-0.4027473927,
0.1063858494,
-0.2812567949,
-0.0066452827,
1.0465909243,
-0.1834735572,
0.108222723,
-0.7272607684,
0.8393124938,
-0.1094017625,
0.2897748649,
0.0975229815,
-0.7553209066,
-0.8677431941,
-0.0438476242,
0.1251095682,
0.6729863882,
-0.6493346691,
0.2870656252,
-0.1783549339,
-0.7060979009,
-0.6787828207,
0.1958853155,
0.2865539491,
0.5063486695,
0.4145624638,
-0.383245796,
-0.3997374177,
-0.7071715593,
-0.0535890907,
-0.6410384178,
-0.1535796672,
0.0682099238,
0.3830546141,
0.2928426564,
1.0874152184,
-0.9866454005,
-0.0289586168,
0.098122783,
-0.0867508277,
0.2257508785,
0.2017964274,
0.3703757226,
-0.5510262251,
-0.000722094,
-0.248100549,
-1.0773237944,
0.2054724097,
-0.2679382563,
-0.4754622877,
0.2798466682,
0.1159548983,
-0.8086674809,
0.6577359438,
0.2565874755,
-0.4215571582,
0.4682523012,
-0.124577634,
-0.1034796163,
-0.9643532038,
0.2759552598,
-0.1401696652,
0.0294969156,
-0.5315764546,
0.0683061033,
-0.1041484252,
-0.27254498,
-0.281128794,
0.5952190757,
0.0680765435,
-0.2726017535,
0.2811455727,
0.1928017288,
0.1144242063,
0.3971762657,
-0.1094842777,
0.7551409006,
0.2881066203,
-0.6247105598,
0.8012732267,
0.6574448347,
-0.2965145111,
0.6039167047,
-0.5757743716,
-0.0492423549,
-0.4053224325,
0.5439420938,
-1.0248123407,
-0.3056830764,
0.3283379376,
-0.1712616533,
-0.4831543863,
0.0018519573,
-0.528200984,
-0.2685968578,
-0.0259312689,
0.3440654576,
0.4786967933,
-0.3912595809,
0.3413356841,
0.1529209912,
-0.359375447,
-0.811555922,
-0.3671783805,
-0.1309366226,
-0.1325064003,
-0.2908017933,
-0.3188687563,
-0.2504988313,
-0.2773153186,
-0.0754435882,
-0.4389421344,
-0.5109088421,
0.4414065778,
0.2507893145,
0.7023815513,
-0.2523255348,
0.6978279352,
0.0527507961,
0.1464199573,
0.4605699182,
-0.5146788955,
0.2518133521,
0.0983201414,
-0.3341774344,
-0.4478032589,
0.1731701493,
0.2434501499,
-0.0843167007,
0.7503020167,
0.3810633421,
-0.5288294554,
0.0471777543,
-0.3570052683,
-0.315348655,
-0.5013650656,
0.2769320011,
0.0579037108,
-0.5524818897,
0.0944508761,
0.50943923,
0.5661991239,
0.2855341434,
0.3652526736,
-0.4112406373,
0.2025194913,
0.3891633451,
-0.0427526012,
-0.0483401567,
-0.2472572476,
0.0778255612,
0.0810399726,
-0.6984989047,
-0.5643271208,
-0.2062848061,
-0.2889599502,
-0.3503448963,
0.3039881289,
-0.0512963682,
-0.3493131697,
0.3397452235,
-0.4294474721,
0.5300238729,
0.7539386153,
0.2528748512,
0.4928527474,
-0.0002062322,
0.2973831594,
0.3397303224,
-0.8228924274,
-0.6702367663,
1.1465885639,
0.0750707164,
0.6582819223,
0.3898591995,
0.2242200077,
0.5933328867,
0.079362303,
-0.4969101846,
0.7957226038,
-0.0605861172,
-1.0293956995,
-0.563886404,
-0.3585515618,
-0.9534476995,
-0.2838519514,
-0.1809383482,
-0.4261980057,
-0.065235734,
0.2269989699,
-0.4517533481,
0.2518805265,
-0.6846000552,
0.8435281515,
-0.0933580175,
-0.0694920346,
-0.1444507092,
-1.0231347084,
0.0695934594,
-0.3471713066,
0.1840990186,
-0.2809439003,
-0.0274333693,
1.1262178421,
-0.5577543378,
0.8383963108,
0.1723929644,
-0.5105415583,
0.4228496552,
-0.0175077412,
-0.0337933451,
0.1052328348,
-0.1168939769,
0.0772447586,
0.4209491611,
-0.8918518424,
-0.7778329253,
0.2826080918,
-0.8429418206,
-0.4976928532,
-0.4223791361,
-0.5672987103,
-0.091822654,
-0.0330832787,
0.147054404,
0.7447041869,
0.1526016295,
-0.1051346511,
0.6538013816,
-0.2576328218,
0.322793752,
0.3452700973,
0.0442694873,
-0.0492816009,
0.9263858795,
0.2303675562,
0.3951166272,
0.5774024725,
-0.1157024428,
-0.363237828,
0.1628495008,
-0.7180405855,
0.1235877275,
-0.9852741361,
-0.2803361118,
-0.6540759802,
-0.3676477671,
-0.2073016912,
-0.1424741447,
-0.058150053,
-0.8045836687,
-0.2058037072,
-0.2090406865,
0.7054358125,
0.9270758033,
0.2719914317,
0.3439216912,
-0.7366477251,
0.0611212999,
0.5640560389,
0.3453738093,
0.0303739011,
-0.3422179222,
-0.4790762961,
0.1180162951,
-0.5400989056,
-0.7687285542,
-0.0902536288,
0.1874397397,
0.3804720342,
0.2435295135,
0.4362462759,
0.5732859373,
-0.0711129308,
1.0386718512,
-0.0377682447,
-0.7833098769,
0.6420811415,
-0.1012235433,
0.185483411,
0.2440503687,
1.0883146524,
-0.4301688075,
-0.5344276428,
-0.830175519,
-0.6195405722,
0.8521137238,
0.6398496628,
0.014682943,
0.4653672278,
0.3168441951,
0.1221624091,
0.3630596697,
-0.3646523654,
-0.7148931026,
-0.1714049578,
-0.622328043,
-0.3339943886,
0.182167694,
-0.1274406463,
-0.1496666819,
0.5683168769,
0.1094451249,
-0.0593948923,
-0.0492765047,
0.1226339266,
0.1507057846,
0.4805126786,
0.4477801323,
0.807467103,
-0.4367737174,
0.0036205095,
0.5124967098,
-1.0070580244,
0.461786896,
0.0316292122,
-0.1262203753,
0.3139732182,
0.2534992397,
0.3045786321,
-0.2185107619,
-1.2622747421,
0.2469992936,
0.0937632471,
-0.0439876541,
-0.459939301,
0.2152543068,
-0.2241386324,
0.0642634332,
0.6811962128,
-0.2184855938,
0.3293220103,
-0.308383137,
0.323417753,
-0.049098257,
-0.3351343274,
-0.2945027947,
0.6850827336,
0.0884442106,
-0.1150793955,
0.5942111611,
0.2156386673,
-0.112681888,
0.7342668772,
0.0126408981,
0.4090108573,
-0.2183799297,
0.5465192795,
0.4622474015,
0.3351891339,
0.04861423,
0.3392727673,
-0.095205389,
-0.2927895486,
-0.2662630975,
-0.474860698,
-0.7469984889,
0.0581480078,
-0.9738522172,
0.3991535902,
-0.483345747,
-0.1715387404,
-0.1434937567,
-0.0135990111,
-0.5561954379,
0.6328787208,
-0.1456535906,
0.6387856007,
-0.8502386212,
0.5520310402,
1.2592182159,
-0.4639416635,
-0.8054093719,
-0.0678046271,
0.0319326185,
-0.3383595943,
0.7370746732,
-0.0971242264,
0.1947220713,
0.1077376977,
-0.4584110975,
-0.7366182208,
1.2819911242,
0.3900766969,
-0.3390106559,
-0.6454207897,
0.4414764047,
0.387060523,
0.3906511068,
0.3585773706,
0.4224671423,
-0.0916859657,
-0.2578385174,
-0.9074779749,
0.0353800058,
-0.1317612529,
-0.4168931246,
0.2937520742,
-0.6541080475,
0.753462553,
0.2250285894,
-0.2432676852,
0.0781467408,
0.5520341396,
0.3803126812,
0.6321826577,
0.3940545321,
0.5744996071,
1.156477809,
0.0388387367,
0.6271182895,
0.12489786,
0.3939827681,
1.0894932747,
-0.0641069934,
0.9126075506,
0.2424097359,
-0.3557032943,
0.7039983273,
0.5851873755,
0.2343343794,
0.0835679248,
0.1669510454,
-0.335754931,
-0.5432627201,
-0.265484035,
-0.3698186278,
0.4591916203,
0.2585541308,
0.2479543388,
-0.5254993439,
0.0157573298,
-0.1029602736,
-0.0292391963,
-0.1351858377,
0.688722074,
-0.1609675437,
-0.4144291282,
0.7094392776,
-0.1752697378,
0.0188800264,
-0.3619366288,
-0.1270134747,
-0.4621673524,
-0.2555860579,
-0.2123525441,
-1.148819685,
0.2656361163,
0.1939746588,
-0.0615900606,
0.0200363137,
0.2272207886,
-0.3124158084,
-0.2511416674,
-0.3322311044,
0.4375550747,
0.1642267257,
0.3638987243,
-0.5165093541,
-0.3289666772,
-0.3165300786,
0.3152536154,
0.0186057612,
0.4302456081,
-0.2370963395,
1.247303009,
0.4855384529,
-0.3117645979,
0.2358653247,
-0.586589396,
0.6162625551,
-0.5883142352,
-0.6374297142,
-0.4366076291,
0.494604677,
-0.0943523124,
-0.5487747788,
0.710039258,
0.7215212584,
1.2054358721,
-0.1688467711,
0.5295280218,
0.1069281772,
0.5223455429,
-0.6792116761,
0.6884522438,
-0.6817628741,
0.3733111322,
-0.3364937305,
-0.6647844315,
0.0347558334,
0.3179055452,
0.0313329995,
-0.3540098667,
0.5278466344,
0.7076083422,
-0.0267056618,
0.3958639503,
0.1321252882,
-0.2415422499,
0.0252252128,
0.7138431072,
1.1043901443,
-0.7865735888,
0.8909013271,
-0.3052503169,
0.1425819546,
-0.2632979155,
-0.399785459,
-0.9158507586,
-0.8712151647,
-0.6492651701,
-0.5851765275,
0.567030549,
1.0241825581,
0.6380770802,
-0.7711952925,
-0.7485155463,
0.147362113,
0.2038520128,
-0.1868510395,
-0.2438845634,
0.456099093,
-0.0299727097,
-0.2308748215,
-0.2360118628,
-0.0001660105,
0.2101749331,
-0.113191992,
0.1130078807,
-0.3228311241,
0.0379705355,
0.4228957593,
0.191926226,
-0.6463251114,
-0.1424986869,
0.2457740009,
-0.2289838493,
-0.100607641,
0.4655136466,
-0.8645554185,
0.1697328091,
0.4107768238,
1.0696313381,
0.0070734047,
0.1406696886,
0.5297963023,
-0.8810930252,
0.0637396947,
0.1180407852,
-0.187300995,
0.0289821681,
-0.4399554431,
0.6231128573,
0.4290929735,
-0.4765716791,
-0.9169436693,
0.1506354362,
-0.9902905226,
-0.144988656,
0.5187985897,
-0.1354177147,
0.0374721922,
-0.608848393,
-0.15323928,
0.1681860536,
-0.2840002775,
0.7516452074,
0.6790391803,
0.2565408647,
-0.0808764026,
-0.8944209218,
0.5340861678,
0.6773362756,
-1.2542401552,
-0.0101386933,
0.6564803123,
0.0225524474,
-0.0381110758,
0.6129488945,
0.5347133279,
0.6638625264,
-0.2960633934,
-0.1741704792,
0.4949506223,
-0.509376049,
-0.1062115878,
0.0691253319,
-0.0536987819,
-0.2456146479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01373v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01373v4
|
Quantity Matters: Towards Assessing and Mitigating Number Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-03T02:31:11 | 2024-05-06T13:39:12 |
Huixuan Zhang, Junzhe Zhang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large-scale vision-language models have demonstrated impressive skill in
handling tasks that involve both areas. Nevertheless, these models frequently
experience significant issues with generating inaccurate information, which is
hallucination. In this study, we concentrate on a specific type of
hallucination-number hallucination, referring to models incorrectly identifying
the number of certain objects in pictures. We perform quantitative evaluations
regarding number hallucination, showing it to be critical in major open-source
large vision-language models. Furthermore, we utilizes two related tasks to
conduct an in-depth analysis of number hallucination, revealing the severe
inner and outer inconsistency among all tasks. Based on this examination, we
devise a training approach aimed at improving consistency to reduce number
hallucinations, which leads to an 8% enhancement in performance over direct
finetuning methods. Our code and dataset will be released to the community.
|
[
-0.4399888217,
-0.6641645432,
0.3867972791,
0.6377307177,
-0.1570939422,
-0.3070434928,
-0.0821312815,
-0.5900011063,
0.0053405366,
0.5323896408,
-0.1788760573,
-0.041360762,
-0.6885892749,
0.1756538749,
-0.5383835435,
0.5291682482,
-0.0287437011,
0.6002062559,
-0.4690490365,
-0.3300284147,
-0.7642276287,
-0.5988188386,
-0.8681880236,
-0.0517316237,
0.4862308502,
0.0745973438,
0.8013504148,
0.4708018601,
1.0671374798,
0.3503959477,
0.1130562946,
0.1569426805,
-0.696770072,
-0.1893078536,
-0.1530593187,
-0.2540553212,
-0.5322774053,
-0.3426671922,
0.5181796551,
0.8488628864,
-0.0594855249,
0.2483654618,
0.0822381601,
0.9168995619,
-0.7980824113,
0.248831436,
-0.6096261144,
0.2342194915,
0.0078648254,
-0.1242763698,
-0.5055226088,
-0.1840071529,
-0.0467538945,
-0.5113666654,
0.4170231819,
-0.1346926838,
0.6281425357,
0.6391673088,
-0.0442968197,
-0.1961810589,
-0.6374245286,
0.7903230786,
-0.683537662,
0.5770228505,
0.7162764072,
-0.0241768714,
0.1233934015,
-0.2617700696,
-0.4941856563,
-0.2784599662,
0.0855442509,
-0.1149730086,
0.0358755551,
0.0565525964,
0.5075619817,
0.4049521685,
-0.5789048672,
-0.0861736014,
-0.6882707477,
-0.1375676841,
0.8184060454,
0.2721140683,
0.2571544647,
0.2266130596,
0.117295146,
-0.3438621461,
-0.4350582957,
-0.2787919939,
0.2605837882,
0.0480398349,
-0.01346788,
0.812672317,
-0.3253023624,
0.9288442731,
0.1658216417,
0.0458018221,
0.2558608651,
-0.2768083513,
-0.4848388731,
0.1408839375,
0.4217712879,
0.4383290112,
0.4240060747,
-0.2827419341,
-0.1784130037,
0.3118924499,
0.5720990896,
-1.0009213686,
-0.2071551085,
0.4204558432,
-0.2781980634,
-0.4531334937,
0.3004795015,
-0.5282139778,
-0.6883955598,
-0.5308434963,
0.8838400841,
-0.3691705465,
-0.1844293326,
0.61157161,
-0.0035672816,
0.0681895837,
0.4340601563,
-1.1396269798,
0.3991203606,
0.7035552263,
0.913634181,
-0.0669863373,
-0.4496804774,
-0.5843285322,
-0.1225735173,
-0.8291801214,
0.3606285155,
-0.2514965236,
-0.0720524862,
-0.3747681677,
0.0512511432,
0.1528982073,
-0.9537172318,
-0.0272423178,
-0.2820839584,
-0.2694444954,
-0.3005186319,
-0.4895777702,
-0.1879277378,
0.0893388465,
-0.9658112526,
0.8024840951,
0.1152256802,
-0.497689873,
0.5532023907,
-0.4217834771,
-0.2545010746,
0.2672293484,
-0.3720220029,
-0.512194097,
0.6755416989,
-0.1265910268,
0.4244742393,
0.0228932463,
0.5246153474,
-0.1764547676,
-0.7021539807,
0.4998286366,
-0.3853901923,
0.5875567794,
0.0388007723,
-0.4986876547,
0.0585851558,
-0.6785855889,
-0.1653852314,
0.0347777382,
0.1107955426,
-0.2716940939,
-0.0659834892,
-0.070192188,
0.0339874253,
0.153248772,
-0.3251039088,
0.1265483797,
-0.3902078271,
0.0568083487,
0.6736734509,
-0.0199658573,
0.5938411951,
-0.3326767981,
0.1662140638,
0.0731621236,
0.3659017086,
0.206911698,
-0.4652627707,
-0.9933575392,
0.1482010782,
0.1121575311,
0.3709606826,
-0.7604622245,
0.4624885023,
-0.1585096866,
-0.4386128783,
-0.4021021426,
0.0688847378,
0.2485612631,
0.2225242257,
0.2122757435,
-0.4894724786,
-0.4206931889,
-0.6085222363,
0.0596624725,
0.0377645977,
0.0202988368,
-0.0275841057,
0.6605939865,
-0.1824332029,
0.6464781165,
-0.4336645603,
-0.3757124543,
0.1435514688,
0.2025201321,
-0.1567751467,
0.5993908048,
0.4398963153,
-0.8804100752,
-0.1531453729,
0.0710364059,
-1.0133755207,
-0.0045031449,
-0.3457042575,
0.019553218,
0.6650952101,
0.4143552482,
-0.4843890667,
0.7777534723,
0.6290028691,
-0.4085769653,
0.2194485366,
-0.2624495029,
0.2258320302,
-0.5240388513,
-0.1499433815,
0.0678229108,
0.2312779576,
-0.6108305454,
0.1136208028,
0.1073532403,
-0.1983505338,
-0.4067484438,
0.5017872453,
-0.2095829397,
-0.3039562702,
-0.247784093,
-0.2536271513,
0.1144026592,
0.4029851854,
0.1673255414,
0.7686836123,
0.5406750441,
-0.5156747699,
0.3782756031,
-0.0357032605,
-0.5757372379,
0.3337891996,
-0.6018428802,
0.1212412864,
-0.2737321556,
-0.2231518626,
-0.8595575094,
-0.3707941175,
0.4259581864,
-0.3144207299,
0.064073965,
0.0016712757,
-0.5657303929,
-0.0654470474,
-0.0851541013,
0.6182098985,
0.2915356159,
-0.2482621819,
0.3138368726,
0.2875828147,
-0.0871411338,
-0.4574640989,
-0.6178659201,
-0.067847535,
-0.1153593883,
-0.6549863815,
0.0018266836,
-0.2242866904,
-0.7284047604,
-0.3330546319,
-0.3769860268,
-0.2349594086,
0.1319197267,
0.2916404009,
0.1610020995,
0.1225488484,
0.526219368,
-0.4058771729,
-0.0816097632,
0.1803715676,
-0.1926677525,
0.8483393192,
-0.2399148345,
-0.4880782366,
-0.4346002936,
0.2578443885,
0.5748654604,
-0.0712466016,
0.6989762783,
0.6977923512,
-0.6800117493,
0.1010849178,
-0.6435312033,
-0.4800117016,
-0.4662869275,
0.6851909757,
-0.5044490695,
-0.4765871465,
0.4121526778,
0.4889134467,
-0.2303876281,
0.3617429435,
0.4380315244,
0.1382379383,
1.0377539396,
0.5852458477,
0.2000140995,
0.3085333109,
-0.4106417298,
0.231719628,
-0.2793225348,
-0.4415158927,
-0.2640373409,
-0.1963745207,
-0.1406603009,
-0.5060274601,
0.1262872517,
0.051705502,
-0.3797964156,
0.2003279328,
-0.6714632511,
0.7800617814,
0.2360257953,
0.3839565814,
0.3357270062,
0.4062317014,
0.773033917,
-0.3390404582,
-0.489420414,
-0.2961834371,
0.8024761677,
0.2371514887,
0.9100446701,
0.1339198053,
0.3859324455,
0.3106660545,
0.0278839711,
-1.0060946941,
0.5798283815,
-0.2903594673,
-0.3206860423,
-0.7874473333,
-0.7406382561,
-0.7056643367,
0.173818022,
-0.2209711075,
-0.6604702473,
0.5042965412,
0.2265661508,
-0.2547188103,
0.3411972821,
-0.6097363234,
1.0421410799,
-0.4933878183,
-0.3768691719,
-0.4762544334,
-0.3116845489,
0.2242009789,
-0.4393652081,
0.0135513265,
-0.0889642313,
0.0238461196,
0.6861534715,
-0.3949068785,
0.9944120049,
0.0169892833,
-0.5238550901,
0.0413427725,
0.2458672374,
0.4551694393,
-0.0355223902,
0.0369691178,
0.5266045332,
-0.1296780556,
-0.5531742573,
-0.6925398707,
0.4579760134,
-0.8472598195,
-0.3557322025,
-0.3064710796,
-0.6942285299,
-0.0167434048,
-0.1204427257,
0.6540325284,
0.7334542274,
0.0009225251,
0.2792812288,
0.9648023248,
-0.2263300419,
0.2160435617,
0.0642889366,
-0.3721907139,
-0.3389549255,
1.2736669779,
0.6105093956,
0.5199056864,
0.3048622012,
-0.0540777594,
-0.0462626927,
-0.5279326439,
-0.3136239648,
0.08565972,
-0.6942572594,
-0.1538240761,
-0.510386169,
-0.3014324307,
-0.6146443486,
-0.209457472,
-0.4215914011,
-0.311837554,
-0.3193818629,
0.0493912287,
0.510972023,
0.758949101,
-0.0194047447,
0.162642166,
-0.5364670157,
0.5885013938,
0.5309047699,
0.4566492438,
0.2433426082,
-0.6845565438,
-0.4823344052,
0.0274978336,
0.0635013506,
-0.6652963758,
0.4175261259,
-0.1560563594,
0.0604766309,
0.5229628086,
0.0655746683,
0.9211632013,
-0.174562335,
0.4293570817,
0.3755612373,
-1.2545106411,
0.2131372839,
0.0039690547,
0.2853924334,
0.4672954679,
0.1652667969,
-0.5986301303,
-0.4042296708,
-0.7133134007,
-0.8215623498,
0.5850015879,
0.3113200963,
0.1260746568,
0.086989142,
-0.003237528,
0.0281560123,
0.1779996157,
-0.7137608528,
0.1569555998,
-0.2953947186,
-0.1316248327,
-0.0016076097,
-0.2980571687,
-0.1057894304,
-0.415117383,
0.5561731458,
-0.0048135915,
-0.0961557105,
0.0928591564,
-0.1666591167,
-0.1336620152,
-0.0874304995,
0.8800116181,
1.113530159,
-0.3075561225,
0.122584641,
0.3962076306,
-0.7803450823,
0.1611574143,
-0.3845638633,
-0.007653262,
0.0580648892,
0.1688896269,
0.755566597,
-0.016445851,
-0.755166471,
0.5416330695,
0.1180627272,
-0.2788383663,
-0.5425798893,
-0.0579107963,
-0.2749794126,
0.0739494041,
0.4320976436,
0.2932443321,
0.2689116001,
-0.3842352033,
0.0750446394,
0.1135795563,
-0.4959267974,
0.0524890013,
0.3654665053,
0.0366624705,
-0.2168395817,
0.8401662111,
-0.1981367469,
-0.0184760429,
1.1271573305,
0.282962501,
0.684197247,
0.0421223789,
0.3054524362,
0.3200688064,
0.5434818864,
-0.5722590685,
0.331517458,
0.2137982249,
-0.8899911642,
-0.747484982,
-0.3236538768,
-0.3976944685,
0.3011562228,
-0.7842022777,
0.1027279869,
-0.3768698871,
-0.2356245369,
0.0472619124,
-0.1458300799,
-0.3252871037,
0.1864662915,
0.3022266924,
0.5707555413,
-0.9108150601,
0.5385962725,
0.4545403421,
-0.6825156808,
-0.5084822178,
-0.2326148152,
-0.2338878363,
-0.5366037488,
0.9182710648,
0.2142980099,
-0.1264462322,
-0.0778658614,
-0.8059786558,
-0.6944825649,
0.7796481252,
0.4130043983,
-0.6852750778,
0.2680874467,
0.3087501526,
0.3488524258,
-0.069463484,
-0.2869074047,
0.3228794038,
0.5306765437,
0.2307503968,
-0.8268822432,
0.077295959,
-0.1345318854,
0.1169833317,
0.4013148248,
-0.5369356871,
0.8792473078,
-0.3284431994,
-0.1736106277,
0.2854082584,
0.3014285564,
0.3357374966,
0.4315190017,
0.3765426278,
0.6906447411,
0.7863304019,
-0.1864579469,
0.7573748827,
-0.0734570175,
0.3623275757,
0.9854888916,
-0.3651332557,
0.708966136,
0.6302080154,
-0.1258272529,
-0.3765721023,
0.4318280816,
-0.4388168156,
0.2672790885,
0.5704063177,
-0.2974401414,
-0.2888792753,
0.0011589363,
-0.4857737124,
0.2963169217,
0.2705022991,
-0.1752751321,
0.2509483397,
0.3067198992,
-0.1650273204,
-0.2443579286,
-0.5156742334,
0.8699705601,
-0.1075505912,
-0.3308620155,
0.7136400938,
-0.2769941688,
0.3265144527,
-0.2285406888,
-0.2709389031,
-0.5604729056,
0.2731537223,
-0.3713330328,
-0.6786761284,
0.5039780736,
-0.1745968312,
-0.2906281352,
-0.1061342284,
0.4369672835,
-0.377559036,
-0.7566140294,
-0.0473524444,
0.3205277622,
0.5910828114,
-0.661624372,
-0.1846866757,
0.4865578413,
0.0432644188,
0.4060895443,
0.2468667477,
0.6603915691,
-0.2283961028,
0.5446655154,
0.3828273714,
0.1203358993,
-0.0234398469,
0.4296518862,
0.4046169817,
-0.7871294022,
-0.0249583386,
-1.0579909086,
0.3420817554,
-0.279319644,
-0.3075924814,
0.5629220009,
0.6876459122,
1.0543284416,
-0.6285405755,
0.4011337757,
0.1165542826,
-0.3427257836,
-0.6238030195,
0.7312380672,
-0.4584719837,
0.2030610889,
-0.3063699901,
-1.1169515848,
-0.59423244,
0.8911004663,
-0.2031462044,
-0.2522167861,
0.5093199611,
0.804980278,
0.0989987254,
-0.1134877428,
0.7883763313,
0.1476228684,
-0.3364840448,
0.4645215273,
0.9894946814,
-0.5393738747,
0.571388483,
-0.3900445402,
-0.0376344919,
-0.3018028736,
-0.4478687942,
-0.6606007218,
-0.6896746755,
-0.6225454807,
-0.3282399774,
-0.0073841242,
0.5366860032,
0.8480585217,
-0.8328799009,
-0.5472493172,
-0.3402381539,
-0.048513364,
-0.2554055452,
-0.2599862814,
0.2156774849,
-0.4462940097,
-0.6589379907,
-0.1740873605,
0.5385710597,
0.6008453369,
-0.5101270676,
-0.0145497462,
0.5095185041,
-0.119622536,
0.7893738747,
0.0299617294,
-0.7790907025,
-0.0259868298,
0.1792450696,
-0.152824536,
0.1066292226,
0.7457519174,
-0.6034029126,
0.4202215075,
0.5643588901,
0.5796299577,
0.3345136046,
-0.0078278091,
0.4378089905,
-0.4887300432,
0.4265332222,
0.0581406467,
0.2999118268,
0.4075028598,
-0.4168646932,
0.9726214409,
0.1755526066,
-0.367500484,
-0.8012782931,
0.1443031579,
-1.1135542393,
-0.4977663457,
1.0216910839,
0.2873259783,
-0.0343851484,
-0.0914127305,
-0.3765854836,
-0.0769005194,
-0.1803656965,
1.15513134,
0.8137048483,
0.1464873254,
-0.2418498397,
-0.4884462655,
0.4572809339,
0.4085704684,
-0.8218165636,
0.1752207875,
0.6807739139,
-0.2807333767,
0.4937958121,
0.4925995171,
-0.1375112981,
0.2461124808,
0.2877624035,
0.358145386,
0.391931206,
-0.62859267,
-0.5180898309,
0.0962038636,
0.0470346361,
-0.0567536354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01364v1
|
Improving Cross-lingual Representation for Semantic Retrieval with Code-switching
| 2024-03-03T01:47:52 | 2024-03-03T01:47:52 |
Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Yuanhang Zheng, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yue Zhang, Wenpei Luo, Kaiyu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Retrieval (SR) has become an indispensable part of the FAQ system in
the task-oriented question-answering (QA) dialogue scenario. The demands for a
cross-lingual smart-customer-service system for an e-commerce platform or some
particular business conditions have been increasing recently. Most previous
studies exploit cross-lingual pre-trained models (PTMs) for multi-lingual
knowledge retrieval directly, while some others also leverage the continual
pre-training before fine-tuning PTMs on the downstream tasks. However, no
matter which schema is used, the previous work ignores to inform PTMs of some
features of the downstream task, i.e. train their PTMs without providing any
signals related to SR. To this end, in this work, we propose an Alternative
Cross-lingual PTM for SR via code-switching. We are the first to utilize the
code-switching approach for cross-lingual SR. Besides, we introduce the novel
code-switched continual pre-training instead of directly using the PTMs on the
SR tasks. The experimental results show that our proposed approach consistently
outperforms the previous SOTA methods on SR and semantic textual similarity
(STS) tasks with three business corpora and four open datasets in 20+
languages.
|
[
-0.4447987974,
-0.455111444,
0.1503984481,
0.2815935016,
-0.4075043201,
0.1323153228,
-0.1878858656,
-0.500205934,
0.3924332261,
0.7613161802,
-0.7186741233,
-0.5876764059,
-0.3006459475,
0.2776418924,
-0.3591595292,
1.0308055878,
-0.2042443603,
0.3820658624,
-0.051185675,
-0.1229225844,
-0.277395457,
-0.6893497109,
-0.3489761055,
-0.2132412195,
0.4961573184,
0.4266126752,
0.6491900086,
-0.0052192332,
0.1010853946,
0.1390482932,
0.4065545201,
0.0322075114,
-0.4951027036,
-0.2413978875,
-0.4311490357,
-0.5719118118,
-0.0624277741,
-0.2456202954,
0.4048965871,
0.691630125,
0.0865701362,
0.0826080814,
-0.2173870802,
0.6534198523,
-0.6250790358,
0.244056806,
-0.8661817312,
0.266946435,
-0.0983874202,
-0.4357154369,
-0.6694157124,
-0.1145016104,
0.3950587213,
-0.812009275,
0.0625565499,
0.1085049883,
1.1830272675,
-0.0056556882,
-0.4182919264,
-0.1523131579,
-0.6061629057,
0.7546438575,
-0.3425038755,
1.0172110796,
0.2843282819,
0.1706807017,
0.2929501832,
-0.7440066934,
-0.3982833624,
-0.1001089811,
-0.1315821707,
0.2685581446,
-0.2250560373,
-0.3992542922,
-0.0193172432,
-0.0571700372,
-0.6229129434,
-0.2227966189,
-0.094056882,
-0.3291225433,
0.3092685938,
0.0472986884,
0.3865137994,
-0.0075585586,
-0.8153636456,
-0.0365256593,
-0.8469789624,
-0.058256384,
0.1769994199,
0.3942221105,
0.3089186251,
0.3064050674,
-0.3410417736,
0.6201615334,
0.2942487895,
0.1462797672,
0.3677117825,
-0.597966969,
-0.1692758799,
0.1467168629,
0.4698646665,
0.2102225721,
0.3300216496,
-0.5604248643,
-0.051152166,
0.1243084967,
0.3492533863,
-0.5357421041,
-0.1709427387,
-0.2550942302,
-0.4825923145,
0.2282681912,
0.0278574806,
-0.6871117353,
0.3263449371,
-0.333766818,
0.4715986848,
-0.4493449628,
-0.4637621343,
0.2652855814,
0.1700949222,
0.5182479024,
0.0965376571,
-0.6162326932,
0.4366109669,
0.4770489037,
0.3475582898,
-0.2551368475,
-0.4745343029,
-0.6000913978,
0.2657668293,
-0.3882971704,
0.7343096733,
-0.7356337905,
-0.3829306066,
0.0727187768,
0.2157667726,
-0.3781096041,
-0.7350067496,
0.123628661,
-1.2239701748,
0.4046428204,
-0.2399235517,
-0.2278326005,
-0.0847166032,
0.4116185009,
-0.5545039773,
1.010042429,
0.0687562972,
-0.7428398132,
0.425621599,
-0.2063893676,
-0.5648266673,
-0.033442311,
-0.227981478,
-0.4267121553,
-0.3353021145,
0.1503792703,
0.1388087422,
-0.1167341843,
-0.1269756705,
-0.0182574168,
-0.4693827331,
0.0187991373,
0.0108192116,
0.5942264199,
0.3097696602,
-0.443836987,
-0.0648072138,
-0.3856594265,
0.413957268,
-0.0453584604,
-0.3022589386,
-0.7890044451,
-0.3992736638,
0.1778650135,
0.7290349007,
0.4674683809,
-0.4030594826,
0.0181590319,
-0.2671249807,
-0.0839972496,
0.2747463286,
-0.1886853874,
0.408863157,
-0.1580799818,
0.7855505943,
0.3107374012,
0.2071235627,
0.1977136135,
-0.4186356366,
-0.7212730646,
-0.1021738946,
0.5136463046,
0.7755234241,
-1.4490641356,
0.1534497887,
-0.5094645023,
-0.3946813941,
-0.4482236505,
0.1900913119,
0.8143121004,
0.1496579498,
0.5829581022,
-0.5749955773,
-0.521515429,
-0.6239619255,
-0.6807931662,
-0.183674708,
0.2150721848,
0.2935841978,
0.2991390228,
-0.4047400057,
1.215051651,
-0.4355726838,
-0.2742349505,
-0.5529615283,
0.1746189445,
-0.050478112,
0.3344296813,
0.3763675988,
-1.1795656681,
-0.783714354,
0.0350030325,
-0.2251920104,
-0.2889746726,
-0.2281290442,
-0.5199664831,
0.692332685,
0.6643237472,
-0.6486459374,
0.3660574555,
0.379416734,
-0.4431081414,
0.6890761852,
-0.0090326546,
0.4151101708,
-0.7569587827,
0.1915380955,
-0.2905112207,
-0.2197508961,
-0.5863241553,
-0.1109129637,
0.4048740268,
-0.0982697904,
-0.7339282632,
0.560443759,
-0.5243655443,
-0.4615436792,
0.0498532057,
0.1452844739,
0.2582357824,
0.7957659364,
0.4133071899,
0.6860327125,
0.1944326162,
-0.7213149071,
-0.0704733804,
0.4111332595,
-0.1926110834,
0.5476626754,
-0.2843305767,
0.0633720607,
-0.0179632958,
0.279335767,
-0.6391294599,
0.497141242,
0.4706497192,
-0.4000711739,
0.1782158315,
-0.4287003279,
-0.6627566814,
0.0414649472,
0.1157426909,
0.5344657898,
0.1874534786,
-0.5372036695,
0.6960536838,
0.1823990941,
-0.2516358495,
-0.5103157163,
-0.7688314319,
0.1624245793,
-0.0242106561,
-0.5948771238,
0.6605347395,
-0.0303575248,
0.1420623213,
0.1881966889,
-0.4818800688,
-0.2020267993,
-0.2673837245,
-0.3314314485,
0.5621612072,
-0.2194260508,
0.2532374263,
0.0446812361,
-0.430713743,
-0.0712633431,
-0.7074453831,
0.7768142223,
-0.205130294,
-0.4394020736,
-0.0857701898,
0.4742085934,
0.1227006987,
-0.6346550584,
0.4104624093,
0.4791435897,
-0.1042704955,
-0.1043657809,
-0.3866396844,
-0.0185462926,
-0.4048387706,
0.5286805034,
-0.577624321,
-0.9402584434,
0.3939894438,
-0.2056024969,
-0.1361799389,
0.1589444429,
0.4720616937,
0.2872523069,
0.9362731576,
0.6299022436,
0.2184920311,
0.609809339,
-0.0449901819,
0.5579522848,
-0.2785547972,
-0.3906363547,
-0.6075443029,
0.1541376859,
-0.3719620705,
-0.6791151166,
0.3363344371,
0.0788442716,
-0.200390473,
0.5653755665,
-0.0285082757,
0.1866660416,
0.2443586737,
0.0654469803,
0.589235127,
0.0262371767,
-0.2805769145,
-0.0954572558,
-0.8804082274,
-0.0746904984,
0.7255532146,
-0.0203437321,
1.0008909702,
-0.008028727,
0.7929818034,
0.0332080796,
0.1116670892,
-0.5147248507,
0.7656712532,
-0.4556213617,
-0.4652602971,
-0.2155294567,
-0.7209275961,
-1.0585930347,
0.5300705433,
0.0664813519,
-0.2320375443,
0.3064388335,
-0.0403746441,
-0.2030908912,
0.15607436,
-0.8803703189,
1.1098583937,
-0.4710304141,
-0.2119188309,
-0.2103342265,
-0.7668266296,
-0.0448386073,
0.028600812,
0.1608805507,
0.1592615843,
-0.200633809,
0.666590929,
-0.3353486061,
0.8502082825,
-0.1744754463,
-0.2241003513,
0.1028578132,
0.1368608773,
0.3940418065,
0.0036699497,
0.1996773928,
0.2187230736,
0.2901051044,
-0.427323401,
-0.7076137662,
0.5682141185,
-0.5848195553,
-0.5026886463,
-0.4515259564,
-0.448074013,
-0.7060494423,
0.4428524971,
0.222830832,
0.3419028223,
-0.1044727564,
-0.0765892863,
0.9097915292,
-0.3182056248,
0.0033662654,
0.8726543188,
-0.4838712513,
-0.0893302411,
1.0083253384,
0.1523413658,
0.5177448988,
0.7872437239,
-0.214125216,
-0.5109221339,
0.0067395754,
-0.5233132839,
0.2074903101,
-0.7324411869,
-0.1230308786,
-0.9195002317,
-0.0032632248,
-0.6062417626,
-0.0607423931,
-0.4368464053,
-0.2575838268,
-0.271904856,
0.2100442499,
0.2901002467,
0.1462143511,
0.2042077631,
-0.3434436023,
-1.1097974777,
0.5447734594,
0.269518733,
0.6149427295,
-0.1506071091,
-0.3375087976,
-0.5080314875,
-0.0993850753,
0.2242338508,
-0.7290887833,
0.4026639163,
0.125546217,
0.7087561488,
0.0978571251,
0.3002065122,
0.785785675,
-0.4543718398,
0.5093653798,
0.3359502852,
-1.0188833475,
0.2149387598,
-0.0170465391,
0.4863780737,
0.7217981815,
0.7316870689,
-0.8553963304,
-0.1953431815,
-0.4243003428,
-0.9369258881,
0.7152042389,
-0.0096157743,
0.145119071,
-0.1215618849,
-0.164669618,
0.4361355603,
0.2170075476,
-0.6393635273,
-0.2521131635,
-0.5987226963,
-0.0901766494,
0.2169784158,
0.1304492801,
0.1794100255,
-0.0912096724,
0.740654707,
-0.2853996754,
0.3301449418,
0.2948987186,
-0.5049421191,
0.0326739289,
0.497729063,
0.0845048875,
0.643686831,
0.1999533474,
0.0720132142,
0.1459331363,
-0.3357827663,
-0.160717845,
0.128670916,
-0.1683697253,
0.3338957429,
-0.143269971,
0.6801106334,
0.7854345441,
-0.9689225554,
0.3905275464,
-0.0589339435,
-0.1092180088,
-0.2314040959,
-0.1832047552,
0.1035405695,
0.1606897116,
0.3296491802,
0.1000359356,
0.041697599,
-0.7178923488,
0.4658833146,
0.2447261959,
-0.4412251115,
-0.0152935414,
0.2689600587,
0.1778573096,
-0.11146079,
0.5262815356,
-0.1756096929,
-0.743725121,
0.3793220222,
0.6694325805,
0.7084157467,
0.0477701537,
0.3987854421,
-0.1525385678,
0.1327507794,
0.0650876313,
0.5152952075,
-0.1374779046,
-0.8162615299,
-0.337228328,
-0.2529470921,
-0.3738626242,
-0.4453505874,
-0.8845021725,
0.3228873014,
-0.1825032532,
0.0469413102,
-0.6239597797,
0.0049650902,
-0.7973210216,
0.3025482297,
-0.0221951474,
1.1107165813,
-0.4428838193,
1.1223728657,
0.8013288379,
-0.3604062498,
-0.5980095863,
0.2987239063,
-0.4989691079,
-0.7659257054,
0.8853107691,
-0.1225538999,
-0.4800973833,
0.1471906751,
-0.1627039313,
-0.7343434095,
0.935393393,
0.2177298665,
-0.3847772479,
-0.0645956993,
0.4273590147,
0.5525006652,
-0.4455210567,
0.0419490784,
0.520159483,
0.2696883976,
-0.0995369703,
-0.916913569,
-0.067100808,
-0.4972900152,
0.156472072,
0.1458883882,
-0.7446209788,
0.7096089125,
-0.0582343712,
-0.2926202118,
-0.0133241285,
0.5587259531,
0.3426608145,
0.3304930329,
0.8433781266,
0.4270297289,
0.2723889649,
0.0189135168,
0.8211354017,
-0.480602622,
0.374132067,
1.0320866108,
-0.6781618595,
0.8904359937,
0.7029176354,
0.0864690766,
0.6470293999,
0.4241490662,
0.2257480174,
0.760737896,
0.0009218394,
0.0805797577,
-0.716799736,
-0.016269587,
-0.6197521687,
0.335563153,
0.1707663387,
0.0048892517,
-0.3831336498,
0.0558616482,
0.0771711171,
0.0184675306,
-0.2462230325,
0.6395398378,
0.031953495,
-0.733877182,
0.720795691,
0.0031894548,
0.8821088672,
-1.0713057518,
-0.068587549,
-0.2603903115,
-0.0599541962,
-0.1229885146,
-0.3984698951,
0.3611566424,
0.0128859207,
-0.0562270395,
-0.7081844807,
0.7175163627,
-0.6584089994,
-0.2522243261,
0.7466779947,
0.5650515556,
-0.0313868858,
0.0375704169,
-0.8154488802,
0.0322665833,
0.014011763,
-0.0766598806,
0.6220776439,
0.598287344,
-0.3235042989,
0.5129938126,
0.5487782955,
-0.2967017591,
0.4506509602,
0.2768279612,
0.9927306771,
-0.7747728229,
-1.0031788349,
-0.0961898863,
0.0742845237,
0.231103301,
-0.4496614337,
0.7510324121,
0.5817496777,
1.4009933472,
-0.3232925236,
0.7997176647,
-0.0872686654,
0.5493959188,
-0.7349041104,
0.6732180715,
-0.702667594,
0.2729513943,
-0.4226214886,
-0.6092267036,
-0.175205797,
0.3574590385,
-0.48440364,
0.1660975367,
0.7997890711,
0.8904764652,
-0.0451900102,
0.0722832829,
0.3955018222,
0.1265371144,
0.0234254524,
0.6991055608,
0.8382149339,
-0.4154343605,
1.2912786007,
-0.0074928561,
0.0317185484,
-0.3633244932,
-0.5279488564,
-0.6050621271,
-0.5536367893,
-0.4404154122,
-0.3157070875,
0.3462625444,
0.7748996019,
0.6039562821,
-0.8896115422,
-0.1555029899,
0.2456067353,
0.0520432964,
-0.5875180364,
-0.231963262,
0.1135291532,
-0.5151314735,
-0.6531431079,
0.173731938,
0.2813756764,
-0.3555823565,
-0.2320486605,
-0.300322324,
-0.4925922453,
-0.0295210294,
0.575511992,
0.4137084484,
-0.4778625071,
-0.2153595388,
0.4583342373,
-0.3888721764,
-0.0039210944,
1.12713027,
-1.0462396145,
0.1511044949,
0.6676382422,
0.9541731477,
0.5135574937,
-0.3985882699,
0.4921739995,
-0.5309726,
-0.0566793606,
0.3872669935,
0.2100524008,
0.1241268218,
-0.2528643608,
0.2895273566,
0.3995487094,
-0.1284583956,
-0.3182804585,
0.4758063555,
-0.8866341114,
-0.4892607331,
1.1201298237,
-0.3860833049,
-0.1016991436,
-0.8612089157,
-0.1427046657,
0.1671074629,
-0.2162181437,
0.720246911,
0.4225021899,
-0.1759120226,
-0.2011076063,
-0.1443580985,
0.2720806897,
0.9439662099,
-0.8081080914,
-0.0546855852,
0.2286807299,
0.3762203157,
0.1383029222,
0.8757792115,
-0.5004297495,
0.5347583294,
-0.2417491078,
0.1331468821,
0.1524222344,
-0.4538776875,
-0.0166878533,
0.052803196,
-0.2686373889,
-0.0613466837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01342v1
|
LM4OPT: Unveiling the Potential of Large Language Models in Formulating Mathematical Optimization Problems
| 2024-03-02T23:32:33 | 2024-03-02T23:32:33 |
Tasnim Ahmed, Salimur Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In the rapidly evolving field of natural language processing, the translation
of linguistic descriptions into mathematical formulation of optimization
problems presents a formidable challenge, demanding intricate understanding and
processing capabilities from Large Language Models (LLMs). This study compares
prominent LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama-2-7b, in zero-shot and
one-shot settings for this task. Our findings show GPT-4's superior
performance, particularly in the one-shot scenario. A central part of this
research is the introduction of `LM4OPT,' a progressive fine-tuning framework
for Llama-2-7b that utilizes noisy embeddings and specialized datasets.
However, this research highlights a notable gap in the contextual understanding
capabilities of smaller models such as Llama-2-7b compared to larger
counterparts, especially in processing lengthy and complex input contexts. Our
empirical investigation, utilizing the NL4Opt dataset, unveils that GPT-4
surpasses the baseline performance established by previous research, achieving
an F1-score of 0.63, solely based on the problem description in natural
language, and without relying on any additional named entity information.
GPT-3.5 follows closely, both outperforming the fine-tuned Llama-2-7b. These
findings not only benchmark the current capabilities of LLMs in a novel
application area but also lay the groundwork for future improvements in
mathematical formulation of optimization problems from natural language input.
|
[
-0.4345468581,
-0.9686686993,
0.9600515962,
0.4072854221,
-0.3121451437,
0.038821049,
-0.4774508476,
-0.5173386335,
-0.2093938291,
0.3420038521,
-0.5485326648,
-0.2801646888,
-0.5575319529,
0.5279672742,
-0.0591315106,
1.0048166513,
-0.3990698457,
-0.0597595312,
-0.1431865692,
0.1543459743,
-0.3024187386,
-0.4170804024,
-0.7517440319,
-0.488910079,
0.3735228479,
-0.0419288613,
0.81912148,
0.7181521654,
0.8133071065,
0.2644619942,
0.0308040306,
-0.0322683938,
-0.6507264972,
-0.1079375967,
0.0054154154,
-0.3648748994,
-0.3448037207,
-0.1078107059,
0.7574891448,
0.5776526332,
-0.2054181695,
0.0675773695,
-0.0358760506,
0.6594578028,
-0.4535915554,
0.422080785,
-0.8181411624,
0.3465155661,
-0.2082835585,
-0.2481163293,
0.0023308243,
-0.3711500764,
0.1424762905,
-0.8611832261,
0.0676952675,
-0.1643830985,
0.8475627303,
0.741689086,
0.0201496053,
-0.3428865671,
-0.5904246569,
0.9556962848,
-0.9724837542,
0.1444374621,
0.3354075253,
0.2570943832,
-0.1780951768,
-0.5989634991,
-0.4034785032,
-0.1318032146,
0.304153651,
0.0934944302,
-0.4675292075,
0.2663178444,
0.3694448173,
0.246052146,
-0.4731571078,
0.2799043357,
-0.3571567237,
-0.2101108283,
0.4603771269,
0.0209690295,
-0.1784850657,
-0.0022328289,
-0.2745504975,
0.2487205416,
-0.7306053042,
-0.2468318343,
0.2553556561,
0.2526071668,
0.0497549437,
0.5094091892,
-0.2109555155,
0.792981267,
-0.2203388363,
-0.3946349919,
0.1935410351,
-0.4668604136,
-0.2303978503,
-0.1435905546,
0.5513097644,
0.2936848402,
0.3946012557,
-0.0570632182,
-0.3920103312,
0.1391930282,
0.0018065294,
-0.8272699714,
-0.0374260023,
-0.0567884706,
-0.1089942977,
-0.2664887905,
-0.2998482883,
-0.6751150489,
0.1190672144,
-0.5438699722,
0.518451333,
-0.2582593858,
0.056339439,
0.3637098372,
0.2427444756,
0.2967406511,
0.3083901405,
-0.7757892609,
0.3365012109,
0.8817566037,
1.0348874331,
-0.3054718673,
-0.0334163755,
-0.3257845044,
0.1301715523,
-0.5224373341,
0.6203123927,
-0.5358358026,
-0.1533613056,
-0.133472234,
-0.6335000992,
-0.0684345961,
-0.5650970936,
0.7297031283,
-0.3898906708,
0.1117926836,
-0.2192534953,
-0.4677666128,
-0.3556774259,
0.4308780134,
-0.5754227638,
1.1027659178,
0.2401129454,
-0.5043337345,
0.1104761884,
-0.9315282702,
-0.1739042103,
0.0438943505,
-0.2082156241,
-0.6302841306,
0.2953926623,
0.224227041,
0.3279364705,
-0.5448854566,
0.1229450554,
-0.3097290993,
-0.3008593619,
-0.1521577984,
-0.533372581,
0.2451075912,
0.2401597053,
-0.4103242755,
-0.056357909,
-0.4799821973,
0.185683623,
0.495282948,
-0.429556191,
0.0026452986,
-0.0450823456,
-0.4978984892,
0.1607646942,
0.5048732758,
-0.2280613035,
0.266358912,
-0.5873203278,
0.7055904269,
0.7784511447,
0.0087385597,
0.2455501109,
-0.0538847595,
0.9138436913,
-0.494679451,
0.1075808108,
-0.1058669016,
-0.6415724754,
-0.5454290509,
-0.1203180552,
0.2527308166,
0.5281352401,
-0.6499265432,
-0.010532178,
-0.1343595088,
-0.1056849957,
-0.2979309261,
0.2870632708,
0.3770516515,
0.5761314631,
0.3812001348,
0.0821496621,
-0.450948745,
-1.1255099773,
-0.2759967744,
0.1459322721,
0.0678161234,
0.3118878901,
0.4632988572,
-0.159035489,
0.8030055761,
-0.5971615314,
-0.3812541068,
-0.2848931253,
-0.0550214276,
0.4421598315,
0.1807298958,
0.5646899343,
-0.5639451742,
-0.5355742574,
0.2337505966,
-0.6997776628,
-0.3027457297,
0.188726604,
-0.0167628843,
0.0865323246,
0.1652795076,
-0.5686892271,
0.23277165,
0.6555376649,
0.2801568806,
0.5130458474,
-0.1456934959,
-0.3157396317,
-0.734873414,
-0.1899998337,
-0.0780457407,
-0.1148917526,
-0.5078621507,
0.1193617061,
-0.1070725322,
-0.130068928,
-0.3506363332,
0.3332425058,
-0.5419774055,
-0.3393496871,
-0.0569734201,
0.2697055042,
-0.1897401214,
0.6497079134,
-0.1255004853,
0.8683643937,
0.481728673,
-0.3800319731,
0.2125609964,
0.0490923114,
-0.150234133,
-0.0004258678,
-0.7346621752,
0.3346677721,
0.0606824197,
0.2098306715,
-0.6984401941,
-0.1835871637,
0.15954189,
-0.15068914,
0.0507270619,
0.0188038182,
-0.6313450336,
-0.3963902891,
-0.537752986,
0.6173967123,
0.3320997953,
-0.2016541362,
0.3650885224,
0.0859916881,
-0.3129324615,
-0.5175392628,
-0.3539201915,
0.0159288347,
-0.4120194614,
-0.4998972118,
0.4310762882,
-0.1081807762,
-0.1333887726,
-0.1486390978,
-0.3066202402,
0.0480270274,
0.0760900453,
-0.3024722934,
0.081730023,
-0.3776906729,
-0.002672083,
-0.0500516482,
-0.3324575126,
0.0221798141,
-0.2481998652,
0.6204057932,
-0.245106861,
-0.1847742349,
-0.2983276546,
0.2346550524,
0.1650806516,
-0.3906326592,
0.2962054312,
0.4102785885,
-0.4932729006,
-0.1443603188,
-0.3544594049,
-0.1168892533,
-0.4906885624,
0.4518111944,
-0.6414856911,
-0.8576890826,
0.3311294317,
-0.1433929801,
0.1069872156,
0.5009171963,
0.7159415483,
0.2996891737,
1.2024829388,
0.6429418325,
-0.1368734837,
0.3899228275,
-0.3125672936,
0.4649819434,
-0.7601541281,
0.0466620512,
-0.4432634711,
-0.3210587204,
-0.5705766678,
-0.557670176,
0.6219128966,
0.2142065316,
-0.2399157137,
0.2234226763,
-0.4908362627,
0.735060215,
0.2448208928,
-0.2533421218,
0.4354610145,
0.0942439735,
-0.254255712,
-0.1461664587,
-0.7044810057,
-0.5366665721,
1.121961236,
0.421536237,
0.5493050814,
0.2615384459,
0.5485056043,
-0.0592303276,
0.2808632553,
-0.8411380053,
0.4138642848,
0.0505711026,
-0.5416104198,
-0.3310381472,
-0.5802907348,
-0.9780690074,
0.4321559966,
0.1194711104,
-0.713404119,
-0.3406580389,
0.2220160663,
-0.3981406093,
0.1869843304,
-0.5812236667,
0.9666957855,
-0.5260218978,
-0.3988627493,
-0.0634059161,
-0.4215744436,
0.3422347307,
-0.5492570996,
0.39748317,
-0.5157003403,
-0.4724209905,
0.4547394514,
-0.2450547516,
0.4593334198,
0.0359943695,
-0.4314787686,
0.0469553359,
0.1090549827,
0.5392811298,
0.1630889028,
-0.3466933072,
0.3375062644,
-0.1010576114,
-0.3927529752,
-0.5507538319,
0.7971823215,
-0.7973381877,
-0.5832139254,
-0.2557834983,
-0.4812733531,
-0.3248662949,
0.3512821496,
0.3788457513,
0.2389842421,
0.1138971224,
0.1136743352,
0.2924070358,
-0.1374775618,
0.5438020229,
0.2338223308,
-0.237895295,
-0.2494431734,
0.8553548455,
0.0993053317,
0.396021843,
0.4989530742,
0.4437220395,
-0.4560774565,
-0.8086290956,
-0.3165784776,
0.397141546,
-0.6677444577,
-0.5074678659,
-0.3409392536,
0.0274864212,
-0.0666378736,
-0.2358028442,
-0.5757462382,
-0.3904119134,
-0.1962881535,
-0.1043609381,
0.1766181588,
0.7760168314,
-0.1134782359,
0.3714135587,
-0.3246016204,
0.3108152747,
0.0254244339,
0.444218725,
-0.1668456495,
-0.2965448797,
-0.1957205087,
0.00266539,
-0.6016205549,
-0.8092859387,
0.4492576122,
0.4150908291,
0.5865291357,
0.4126395881,
-0.239444539,
0.7488384247,
-0.5809867978,
0.6143824458,
0.0569821149,
-0.9147288203,
0.5539543629,
-0.5725977421,
0.2792560458,
0.3863678575,
0.4357461929,
0.0720307827,
0.0009102503,
-0.3503189385,
-0.823662281,
0.5233281255,
0.5979205966,
-0.0008054629,
0.1070535928,
0.7133626938,
0.1811159849,
0.4916157722,
-0.9479196072,
0.1121641174,
-0.0215253476,
-0.1544811875,
-0.2652122378,
-0.1097819805,
-0.0043456196,
-0.237737909,
0.4764561951,
-0.2701842487,
0.3662346303,
-0.0690143779,
0.0941747203,
-0.2391695678,
-0.0454824455,
0.8714482784,
0.8881714344,
-0.1100021973,
-0.0085769836,
0.3259035945,
-0.2979565263,
-0.1575047523,
0.1502414942,
-0.1010738239,
-0.1215526313,
0.5547960997,
0.7807241082,
0.3960569501,
-0.5099126697,
0.2742941976,
0.2061111778,
-0.3206935823,
-0.2912456989,
-0.1172327325,
-0.0991422161,
0.0024014651,
0.2740207314,
-0.1800909489,
0.3930404186,
-0.3301793337,
-0.1391084641,
0.5866418481,
0.1452606171,
-0.4062362313,
0.6566846371,
0.0549953133,
-0.2647087574,
0.2534566522,
-0.1371317506,
-0.829485178,
0.5211060047,
0.7262917757,
0.6268417239,
-0.0678445473,
-0.1010085791,
0.4051939249,
0.4006000459,
-0.1336501837,
0.0597457029,
-0.0761925876,
-0.7912412882,
-0.7182606459,
-0.9170181751,
-0.4830650091,
0.2545936108,
-0.4619911313,
0.1723167747,
-0.5516479015,
-0.2108269334,
0.1427312344,
0.258195281,
-0.7482533455,
-0.0936459973,
-0.06370496,
0.3933208287,
-0.3632246852,
0.5259854198,
0.5762986541,
-0.2588427365,
-0.9435734749,
-0.1311049461,
0.1310675889,
-1.015786767,
0.3329170644,
0.1886632293,
-0.2913202047,
0.270565778,
-0.3673487902,
-1.1395235062,
0.961489439,
0.7177989483,
-0.6194686294,
-0.183026433,
0.2577672899,
0.4625916183,
-0.3529012799,
0.0185934734,
0.8498848677,
0.6554415822,
-0.0526462421,
-1.2284836769,
-0.193600893,
0.0823832303,
0.2386389971,
0.4470086694,
-0.6202130318,
0.9209712744,
-0.2580812573,
0.0971046463,
0.2457605302,
0.2749631703,
0.3931957185,
0.2092362791,
0.2609337568,
0.6069116592,
0.4858520329,
-0.2302220762,
1.2660765648,
-0.2038278282,
0.6414387226,
0.8020192385,
-0.2753135562,
0.887296617,
0.4676215649,
-0.5376685858,
0.1611765623,
0.8329665065,
0.13192752,
0.5732766986,
0.4423458576,
-0.2950495481,
-0.0688243359,
0.30270648,
-0.5414664149,
0.5447829366,
0.428460449,
-0.0483375788,
-0.3960843086,
-0.1287480146,
0.1209191829,
-0.0256759766,
-0.3361265361,
0.7945774198,
0.2238973528,
-0.63935256,
0.8279672265,
0.1732062101,
0.5523526073,
-0.7031881809,
-0.1079129875,
-0.212379247,
0.3488033414,
-0.1096187085,
-0.5994122624,
0.2433214933,
0.0479496233,
0.0969517678,
-0.0806600377,
0.5084336996,
-0.1343208402,
-0.589289844,
0.2421299964,
0.3643369973,
0.4034086168,
-0.2040136307,
-0.8577879071,
0.4236913025,
0.1396889687,
-0.2028228641,
0.0897515193,
0.5228697062,
-0.0939940587,
0.6864150167,
0.7398465276,
0.06095431,
0.1065576673,
0.027003292,
0.7009923458,
-0.5769856572,
-0.3992304206,
-1.042200923,
-0.1045235321,
0.1208918989,
-0.4222703278,
0.6189630032,
0.6933697462,
0.8056328297,
-0.0317854099,
0.674048841,
0.3223538995,
0.3842346072,
-0.7013520002,
0.1174550056,
-0.4772798419,
0.4698912799,
-0.476067692,
-1.4413671494,
-0.5237531662,
0.987688303,
-0.4279120564,
0.3185820878,
0.5423682928,
0.5156450868,
-0.0316567644,
-0.036180187,
0.4115982354,
0.2368130088,
0.4805616736,
0.7292984724,
0.6957513094,
-0.0749948621,
0.5995333791,
-0.2653311789,
-0.2696412802,
-0.2553813159,
-1.1030652523,
-0.6409164071,
-0.1610964835,
-0.0720002875,
0.3069940507,
-0.0061239232,
0.7640429735,
0.5472619534,
-0.5071127415,
-0.1230051145,
-0.2593038678,
-0.055104591,
-0.0713090673,
-0.211139217,
0.2309515029,
-0.421744138,
-0.7702943683,
0.48887676,
0.5909603238,
-0.0156813841,
-0.3522745371,
-0.236011222,
0.0453357175,
0.1660886258,
0.8496856093,
0.1743647903,
-1.0285773277,
-0.1711488962,
-0.0247329008,
0.2917097509,
0.193028301,
0.6940244436,
-0.5745393038,
0.2498043925,
0.0101600708,
0.7737850547,
0.7716308236,
0.0812338442,
0.6708860993,
-0.6250080466,
0.0989318341,
0.4434153438,
0.3306229711,
0.3629767895,
-0.2690205276,
0.9254487157,
0.09674979,
-0.6446086764,
-0.8339787722,
0.2838976383,
-1.048663497,
-0.0698368996,
1.1184396744,
0.1334855407,
0.0660147518,
0.1711039394,
-0.3569349945,
-0.0986443833,
-0.4178772867,
0.5419800878,
0.7304183841,
-0.5645136833,
-0.1372846365,
-1.1533237696,
0.6123908162,
0.5764052272,
-0.8680974841,
-0.2031833231,
0.3886197209,
0.2643536627,
0.0647102296,
0.5922356844,
-0.1337994933,
0.1244397014,
-0.3474259079,
-0.3351752162,
-0.0826964229,
-0.0727917776,
-0.2567408085,
0.2071171403,
0.1224239022,
0.0458398722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04785v1
|
Large Language Multimodal Models for 5-Year Chronic Disease Cohort Prediction Using EHR Data
| 2024-03-02T22:33:17 | 2024-03-02T22:33:17 |
Jun-En Ding, Phan Nguyen Minh Thao, Wen-Chih Peng, Jian-Zhe Wang, Chun-Cheng Chug, Min-Chen Hsieh, Yun-Chien Tseng, Ling Chen, Dongsheng Luo, Chi-Te Wang, Pei-fu Chen, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chronic diseases such as diabetes are the leading causes of morbidity and
mortality worldwide. Numerous research studies have been attempted with various
deep learning models in diagnosis. However, most previous studies had certain
limitations, including using publicly available datasets (e.g. MIMIC), and
imbalanced data. In this study, we collected five-year electronic health
records (EHRs) from the Taiwan hospital database, including 1,420,596 clinical
notes, 387,392 laboratory test results, and more than 1,505 laboratory test
items, focusing on research pre-training large language models. We proposed a
novel Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs) framework incorporating
multimodal data from clinical notes and laboratory test results for the
prediction of chronic disease risk. Our method combined a text embedding
encoder and multi-head attention layer to learn laboratory test values,
utilizing a deep neural network (DNN) module to merge blood features with
chronic disease semantics into a latent space. In our experiments, we observe
that clinicalBERT and PubMed-BERT, when combined with attention fusion, can
achieve an accuracy of 73% in multiclass chronic diseases and diabetes
prediction. By transforming laboratory test values into textual descriptions
and employing the Flan T-5 model, we achieved a 76% Area Under the ROC Curve
(AUROC), demonstrating the effectiveness of leveraging numerical text data for
training and inference in language models. This approach significantly improves
the accuracy of early-stage diabetes prediction.
|
[
-0.0741554871,
-0.8952649832,
0.7621449232,
-0.2071066648,
-0.3236522675,
0.0311851669,
-0.2720943987,
-0.5868951678,
0.3546984196,
0.6915919781,
-0.1711213887,
-0.6347850561,
-0.5886891484,
0.1670044661,
-0.1219637766,
1.0691176653,
-0.0232802667,
0.4160996079,
-0.273996681,
-0.0139900288,
-0.4776522517,
-0.6487801075,
-0.493526727,
-0.41916731,
0.8815002441,
0.3688230515,
0.3126381338,
0.374142319,
0.6554617286,
0.1914597303,
0.1254926622,
0.1450844556,
-0.1820768565,
0.1014857441,
0.3746375442,
-0.2278858721,
-0.5911257863,
-0.3703118265,
0.2286133021,
0.6510540843,
-0.0636081323,
-0.0204201527,
-0.1353278458,
0.4513226449,
-0.2397079915,
0.3708637953,
-0.2531977296,
0.3240738511,
-0.2196344584,
-0.285835892,
-0.4508321285,
-0.1901631951,
0.3554069996,
-0.4144960642,
0.1752489358,
-0.0971647725,
0.610109508,
0.2380587012,
-0.6609125733,
-0.2007049918,
-0.5805703402,
0.618745327,
-0.74974823,
0.4905329049,
0.4884680808,
0.3662923574,
-0.04005678,
-0.6538084149,
-0.3942766488,
-0.596301496,
-0.1380839497,
0.3713592291,
0.2174017429,
0.201962173,
0.0687694699,
0.3484902382,
-0.7331959605,
0.0057327449,
-0.532299161,
0.0041137738,
0.5358282924,
0.2620516121,
0.2898128033,
-0.1205618083,
-0.55526793,
-0.0071047843,
-0.3738324642,
-0.1761055142,
-0.4490356445,
0.272724092,
-0.2095511854,
0.5622646809,
0.0883460641,
0.3489061892,
0.1508225203,
-0.4006596208,
0.4678117633,
-0.554703474,
-0.2647893429,
0.373255372,
0.5913873315,
0.4094255865,
0.131661281,
-0.1777507663,
-0.0803793967,
0.1475971937,
0.2331855297,
-0.7743293047,
-0.4973858595,
0.5833598375,
-0.5927252173,
0.0049495571,
-0.1878354102,
-0.9040651917,
-0.4603025913,
-0.2786929607,
0.0267667249,
-0.5702804923,
-0.1302292794,
0.3416974843,
0.1291471869,
-0.27356565,
0.3757231832,
-0.6756911874,
0.2462940961,
0.447052896,
0.6271871924,
-0.1815351844,
-0.0817279741,
-0.5453285575,
0.1998222917,
0.0391646959,
0.6185595989,
-0.3765792847,
-0.2057996541,
-0.063882336,
0.01300357,
-0.1878384203,
-0.5217114687,
0.3500860333,
-0.3653577566,
-0.1229197234,
0.2367335707,
-0.5565903187,
0.1097974181,
0.24326092,
-0.9658891559,
0.9499904513,
0.1015781462,
-0.7035492659,
0.4669013023,
-0.3308616877,
-0.6058551669,
0.2183313668,
-0.0864311159,
-0.9620603919,
0.0674408302,
0.2697977126,
0.6928762794,
-0.2899306715,
0.999648571,
-0.5896969438,
0.1043756306,
0.4069052041,
-0.4388504922,
0.2900017798,
0.0798521861,
-0.1908421516,
0.2346450984,
-0.7201185822,
-0.2183602899,
-0.0271093175,
-0.2507929802,
-0.5992307663,
-0.1459580362,
0.3984114528,
0.3596938848,
0.0999816954,
-0.5451167226,
0.1375296563,
-0.3440224528,
0.3963117301,
0.4646634459,
0.0389783159,
-0.0330341421,
-0.4929525852,
0.3927749991,
0.4105621874,
0.3559137583,
-0.398666203,
-0.716075778,
-0.2236255109,
-0.2455956042,
0.2458479404,
0.54139781,
-0.4456730783,
0.6096251011,
-0.6267290711,
-0.3556296229,
-0.292521745,
-0.0379369184,
0.2696180642,
0.5133578777,
0.5380380154,
-0.4043975472,
-0.3529360592,
-0.7759165764,
0.2984376848,
-0.0422214568,
0.1092519611,
0.4534569383,
0.7264751196,
-0.4390779436,
0.3765760362,
-0.659311235,
-0.468198359,
-0.2919135094,
0.0206789393,
-0.0312443078,
0.5228455067,
0.2732843161,
-0.9644310474,
-0.5152662396,
0.2413067073,
-0.5358065367,
0.2095289677,
-0.0319310352,
0.1935488582,
-0.1050878987,
0.3813360333,
-0.4038659036,
0.3964425623,
0.7661340237,
-0.4181497097,
0.3823220134,
-0.3939234912,
-0.073392719,
-1.2265126705,
0.1823577285,
0.2819539011,
-0.2833151817,
-0.7368593812,
-0.203545332,
0.1127312481,
-0.1710271686,
-0.1402075887,
0.7276523709,
-0.272382468,
0.4133298397,
0.0462001525,
-0.0755442157,
0.0295698475,
0.1678213477,
0.0508643575,
0.1455420256,
0.2211121321,
-0.4834232926,
0.3247805238,
0.3935930729,
-0.5676189065,
0.2459635139,
-0.5461962819,
-0.2180788219,
-0.1636669934,
0.4948256314,
-0.9333171248,
-0.3500677049,
-0.0020493979,
-0.4339146018,
0.3937381506,
0.2767283618,
-0.508993268,
-0.5657553077,
-0.1520683169,
0.4935859442,
0.0771695003,
-0.1367737204,
0.5945090652,
0.5523746014,
-0.3440128863,
-0.3716411591,
-0.9714778066,
0.0070943572,
-0.2161505669,
-0.4769217372,
0.5773271918,
-0.18254219,
0.1027755067,
0.1354692876,
0.1372433454,
-0.4406137168,
0.1219628006,
0.2496383041,
0.4032256007,
-0.2232988179,
0.4626663029,
-0.2008148283,
-0.1758253574,
-0.1746500283,
-0.0935657173,
0.5193991065,
0.2933374047,
-0.3015184104,
-0.401351124,
0.5349308252,
0.8018800616,
-0.3746637106,
0.7029805779,
0.5156937242,
-0.5273113847,
0.3193906248,
-0.5978506207,
-0.2944393456,
-0.3162931204,
0.5578426123,
-0.0960149989,
-0.9259859324,
0.445482254,
0.0580417104,
-0.1354029775,
0.1622850895,
0.6635897756,
0.1937845498,
0.9711397886,
0.6141538024,
-0.089127101,
0.3670919836,
-0.0524210595,
0.1419091076,
-0.765167594,
-0.4697146416,
-0.2287625819,
0.0246265624,
-0.5704829693,
-0.6120361686,
0.8294734359,
-0.3863552511,
-0.3513440192,
-0.0774536431,
-0.2500004768,
-0.0623265579,
0.2148742974,
0.6665427685,
0.297521323,
-0.0393192247,
-0.3821515739,
-0.0307770465,
-0.6304550171,
-0.2343131453,
1.3361065388,
0.4995981455,
0.7000324726,
-0.0120884292,
0.5861263871,
0.2103539407,
0.716965735,
-0.708388567,
-0.1212727278,
-0.5655171275,
-0.627566278,
-0.3001031578,
-0.4216116071,
-1.0428657532,
-0.0609351024,
-0.1669462919,
-0.4727767706,
0.0326014161,
0.2065407336,
-0.7411423922,
0.2315242141,
-0.6621826291,
0.9680750966,
-0.7654311657,
-0.2889990211,
0.0035119401,
-0.7420831323,
0.4397682548,
-0.3338857889,
0.3047757149,
-0.0607428327,
0.1800585091,
0.3834401071,
-0.1507145315,
1.0721086264,
0.0709977373,
-0.1037563458,
-0.2117084414,
-0.4030309618,
0.3799241185,
0.2612287402,
0.0332388021,
-0.0306582414,
0.041465845,
-0.3113846183,
-0.2576448023,
0.6259652376,
-0.6372285485,
-0.2374724001,
-0.4415713847,
-0.3558600545,
-0.2551544011,
0.3191331625,
-0.1747926474,
0.6307370067,
-0.3024402261,
0.2025040388,
0.7777804732,
-0.4871005118,
0.0693076327,
0.3004613817,
-0.0270992834,
-0.6938605309,
0.6886504292,
-0.1357067674,
0.2476816922,
0.6315385103,
0.5332083702,
-0.2265630066,
-0.3435181081,
-0.4262418151,
0.2512188554,
-0.4193210006,
-0.2586754262,
-0.8225988746,
-0.1091964394,
-0.5177496076,
-0.0155039839,
-0.2058984041,
0.2101678401,
-0.3431780636,
-0.0495977178,
0.4514458776,
0.5624941587,
0.2616801262,
0.043362163,
-1.1303590536,
0.4689927101,
0.0329238251,
0.4427262247,
0.2813062072,
-0.2545650899,
-0.4759576023,
-0.0824520662,
-0.1678875089,
-0.7825146317,
0.7655006051,
0.2298858017,
0.5046260953,
0.4453620911,
-0.0397396274,
0.6905241609,
-0.6146993041,
0.5712416768,
0.5111911297,
-0.4594100416,
0.400141418,
-0.229513377,
0.4153818786,
0.498421073,
0.3901178241,
-0.7089541554,
-0.1580188274,
-0.526386261,
-0.9251740575,
0.2708219886,
-0.196320489,
-0.0696436688,
-0.007147904,
0.2718650997,
0.2934105098,
0.1406826824,
-0.6739417315,
-0.3562862277,
-0.1589734554,
-0.6524385214,
-0.5423684716,
-0.1890606433,
-0.0778224766,
-0.4119937122,
0.2761425972,
-0.307661593,
0.3947461843,
0.4025090933,
-0.057405211,
-0.1424713582,
0.3446353674,
0.7596511841,
0.4275909066,
-0.2774654031,
0.1836051941,
0.0254694484,
-0.7297750115,
0.0316874348,
0.4589369595,
0.0310920421,
-0.0712127313,
0.4036358595,
0.7834041715,
0.5264196396,
-0.9202923775,
0.5036087632,
-0.011560766,
-0.0811425894,
-0.7628099322,
-0.3957552016,
0.1891794503,
-0.0334069543,
0.1958920807,
-0.0707503781,
0.0500604361,
-0.4111221135,
0.5733478665,
0.164064154,
-0.6006249189,
-0.3585197628,
0.7910729647,
0.2704266012,
0.4045546055,
0.466676861,
0.2620045841,
-0.3969343603,
0.8306458592,
0.5114449263,
0.5747607946,
-0.3301389515,
0.2006171793,
0.3844856024,
0.1428065151,
-0.2550929785,
0.1818384081,
0.4030591846,
-0.5952270031,
-0.6287699342,
-0.662448585,
-0.1987605691,
0.5404655933,
-0.4609120488,
0.2961648107,
-0.2702555358,
-0.2235871255,
0.3027721643,
-0.0428694561,
-0.6393969059,
0.4497000575,
0.5126693845,
0.5599889159,
-0.8665166497,
1.0602283478,
0.602539897,
-0.4419325888,
-0.6010858417,
-0.0111368606,
-0.0270137209,
-0.5615269542,
0.7228180766,
0.403108269,
0.4154940844,
-0.157274276,
-0.1991632283,
-0.8885710239,
0.9722276926,
0.1654558927,
-0.8355999589,
-0.1740875244,
0.1365146935,
0.5919479728,
-0.4748854339,
0.1109579355,
0.3141001165,
0.6022199392,
-0.0626179799,
-1.1567704678,
0.0315718949,
-0.1883466989,
-0.1862214506,
0.3157522082,
-0.6243355274,
1.0124952793,
-0.2999249995,
0.0514892824,
-0.0001398572,
0.2989629805,
0.2843529284,
0.6914490461,
0.2017866224,
0.7149947882,
0.7992409468,
0.099951975,
1.201628089,
-0.4075119793,
0.3125525117,
1.0133405924,
-0.5790637136,
0.7390273213,
0.2900714278,
0.0082691284,
0.3561490774,
0.6249148846,
-0.1086698994,
0.5717688203,
0.2326317281,
-0.3574480414,
-0.2947360575,
-0.1230719164,
-0.3074543774,
0.2556835115,
0.5981657505,
-0.67995435,
0.0092525398,
0.4244423807,
-0.0856947228,
-0.1325010657,
-0.1762673855,
0.6205862761,
0.216406852,
-0.4533236921,
0.4394814968,
-0.1226301864,
0.683494091,
-0.4388363659,
-0.2080589384,
-0.0459988452,
0.5420726538,
0.0022259296,
-0.5079488158,
0.1597415805,
-0.3572912812,
-0.2062920332,
-0.0679367483,
0.6682475209,
-0.7604092956,
-0.7443616986,
0.4192345738,
0.4978204072,
-0.0579056516,
0.0668025017,
-0.7013539672,
-0.1405228227,
-0.2876910567,
0.0213535987,
0.3981262743,
0.5565829277,
-0.2258843184,
0.6940832138,
0.5400679708,
0.2746449113,
-0.1136645377,
0.0605751537,
0.9395778775,
-0.7910924554,
-0.2784515619,
-0.6953389049,
0.4245429039,
0.1796391159,
-0.3697947264,
0.2901925147,
0.5948269963,
0.5933750868,
-0.3147857785,
0.9743627906,
0.1791861802,
0.534574151,
-0.6305058002,
0.6869955659,
-0.6589046717,
-0.1768765301,
-0.2031769603,
-0.0691656545,
-0.6191132069,
0.2445463389,
-0.2228425592,
0.1114008278,
0.915604353,
0.436563015,
-0.0788902566,
-0.3311971128,
0.4186921418,
0.3750984371,
0.3353981376,
0.9196493626,
0.3020566106,
-0.3036588728,
0.2125585824,
-0.3221473694,
-0.0325189903,
-0.6247347593,
-0.5569673181,
-0.877543211,
-0.6265233755,
-0.269115448,
-0.3209130466,
0.1706112772,
0.8508974314,
0.540183723,
-0.9521226883,
0.115656808,
0.1261254549,
-0.2400548458,
-0.2956631482,
-0.163753584,
0.6495381594,
0.1840571016,
-0.474571228,
0.1209837049,
0.2390776873,
0.2244136184,
-0.4020367265,
0.0803077742,
-0.3463465273,
-0.4692932665,
0.7795538306,
0.0047218837,
-0.8435911536,
-0.2080871314,
0.2905802131,
-0.4327870905,
0.149371013,
0.822537601,
-0.6401597261,
0.4892986715,
0.1570756733,
0.6316296458,
0.3612733185,
-0.0805912688,
0.5355164409,
-0.3136717081,
0.022384407,
0.5357041359,
0.2974139154,
0.4721550941,
-0.5792149305,
0.1693669111,
0.2864099741,
-0.5079503059,
-0.4815472066,
-0.06792292,
-1.1429485083,
-0.3144814968,
1.0610334873,
-0.1669504791,
-0.3635257483,
-0.6219339371,
-0.0650147721,
0.4438769519,
-0.4823140502,
1.0412111282,
0.3594298363,
-0.2761039436,
-0.2337847054,
-1.0230563879,
0.3326956928,
0.4078892469,
-0.9921984673,
0.1409479976,
0.6411491036,
0.2950797677,
0.0707158968,
0.6510091424,
-0.15172337,
0.324486196,
-0.2621510923,
0.211637944,
0.0708967149,
-0.3640387058,
-0.1940704584,
0.0426069014,
-0.2559053302,
0.206827715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01309v1
|
VNLP: Turkish NLP Package
| 2024-03-02T20:46:56 | 2024-03-02T20:46:56 |
Meliksah Turker, Mehmet Erdi Ari, Aydin Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this work, we present VNLP: the first dedicated, complete, open-source,
well-documented, lightweight, production-ready, state-of-the-art Natural
Language Processing (NLP) package for the Turkish language. It contains a wide
variety of tools, ranging from the simplest tasks, such as sentence splitting
and text normalization, to the more advanced ones, such as text and token
classification models. Its token classification models are based on "Context
Model", a novel architecture that is both an encoder and an auto-regressive
model. NLP tasks solved by VNLP models include but are not limited to Sentiment
Analysis, Named Entity Recognition, Morphological Analysis \& Disambiguation
and Part-of-Speech Tagging. Moreover, it comes with pre-trained word embeddings
and corresponding SentencePiece Unigram tokenizers. VNLP has an open-source
GitHub repository, ReadtheDocs documentation, PyPi package for convenient
installation, Python and command-line API and a demo page to test all the
functionality. Consequently, our main contribution is a complete, compact,
easy-to-install and easy-to-use NLP package for Turkish.
|
[
-0.5115417242,
-0.5949485898,
-0.0082579497,
0.4383809566,
-0.6152769327,
-0.3803091347,
-0.4681396484,
-0.6575172544,
0.3463146389,
0.6298188567,
-0.3080912232,
-0.6590510011,
-0.4911844134,
0.1975572258,
-0.2114398926,
1.1598545313,
0.2264274955,
0.1273820698,
0.2139610797,
-0.1701797992,
-0.41114223,
-0.4717150033,
-0.6498805285,
-0.1291358471,
0.560654521,
0.1853047311,
0.4300595522,
0.4375802279,
0.4227939248,
0.2071965486,
-0.4542808235,
-0.1378796995,
0.1863196045,
0.2625462115,
-0.2428948432,
-0.1787471473,
-0.4143472612,
-0.3997172117,
0.6042010784,
0.4785823226,
-0.218136698,
0.6433543563,
0.0970134884,
0.7608970404,
-0.6953009367,
0.0690090656,
-0.5916308165,
0.2688126564,
-0.4212941229,
-0.2498119771,
-0.2691877484,
0.0155358315,
0.0298295226,
-0.3335976899,
-0.0660526752,
-0.0912435278,
0.6686682105,
0.3278166354,
-0.3916877508,
-0.4465171695,
-0.5138828158,
0.6844370961,
-1.1096929312,
0.2453771681,
0.0977041647,
0.50271523,
-0.2856070697,
-1.0510730743,
-0.6723646522,
-0.1477354169,
-0.0893700197,
-0.1394640356,
0.0062882537,
0.2281096429,
0.0289309788,
0.7545462847,
-0.6528457403,
0.0699149221,
-0.3332338035,
-0.0202446673,
0.3252145946,
-0.0184162892,
0.3107275963,
-0.2465987951,
-0.3927977383,
0.2202178985,
-0.3655954599,
0.2705914378,
0.1509335488,
0.5763972998,
0.1250558496,
1.0610207319,
-0.7643924356,
1.160902977,
-0.3953312337,
-0.0014942943,
0.041691307,
-0.3386668563,
-0.7125839591,
0.5062872767,
0.7565892339,
0.0721222162,
-0.1198013797,
0.1079268381,
-0.0146416901,
0.0002774266,
0.1242240295,
-0.4587062001,
0.056531705,
0.522266984,
-0.5269388556,
-0.539329648,
-0.1644423753,
-0.6925649643,
-0.2078798413,
-0.3383806646,
0.2967305779,
-0.1435167789,
-0.5148144364,
0.5661407113,
0.1147849783,
0.5011669397,
0.3028591871,
-0.9735102654,
0.5390295386,
1.0576349497,
0.9925229549,
-0.2179350704,
-0.0947545245,
-0.7465916276,
-0.1608530283,
0.0375459343,
0.7051877379,
-0.2198002189,
0.0265796166,
0.3527734876,
0.0381547101,
0.2145555317,
-0.3427656591,
1.2269016504,
-0.2758119702,
0.4998384416,
-0.2391824424,
-0.6261808276,
-0.1739403754,
0.3802258968,
-0.7529055476,
1.005589962,
0.0086842552,
-1.4952931404,
0.5226573348,
-0.7567675114,
-0.1206143573,
0.4791946411,
-0.0963143855,
-0.0960962251,
0.3002711236,
0.2257573903,
0.4195330143,
-0.0252857674,
0.0559116751,
0.0058007417,
-0.2105124444,
-0.2102309614,
-0.1119945273,
1.2123550177,
0.3656472266,
-0.3177844584,
0.4205819368,
-0.780264914,
0.1099954396,
-0.0675733313,
-0.9339141846,
-0.2790138721,
-0.0908074528,
0.7685782313,
0.4844759107,
0.5045503974,
-0.5899893045,
0.5470765829,
-0.6881661415,
0.0633754954,
0.6294987798,
-0.4634534419,
0.2878353596,
0.1337508559,
0.4052532017,
-0.0690110028,
0.0508414134,
-0.1852105707,
-0.7735280395,
-0.8718395829,
-0.2968652248,
0.3781561852,
0.7364962101,
-0.5294439793,
0.5822176933,
-0.1565330178,
-0.2656008303,
-0.5719828606,
0.0358998068,
0.097083278,
0.5506998301,
0.423530519,
-0.0353247523,
-0.8244608641,
-0.7806841731,
-0.373195231,
-0.2529263496,
-0.0787452459,
-0.1598330289,
0.3655371666,
-0.0794608891,
0.8323588371,
-0.1772248298,
-0.6687343121,
-0.6448987722,
-0.1573251784,
0.5137437582,
0.4979348481,
0.2766191363,
-0.6686080098,
-0.4820277989,
0.2750606835,
-0.5718730092,
-0.1663685143,
0.2567433715,
0.1485544592,
0.7356064916,
0.3891149461,
-0.9155318737,
0.3940811157,
0.5612747073,
-0.6750376225,
0.8975097537,
-0.0828446224,
-0.3084894717,
-1.3180788755,
0.3200810552,
-0.1438936889,
-0.4736177921,
-0.6072032452,
0.416570425,
-0.5572763681,
0.0534322783,
-0.8037160039,
0.7108424902,
-0.0491579212,
-0.1048137918,
-0.3792460859,
-0.3704146743,
-0.2796597481,
0.2856380939,
0.4522252977,
0.5098584294,
0.4675327241,
-0.5851680636,
0.4757837951,
0.0596074201,
-0.4489229023,
0.3441343307,
-0.6296066642,
-0.0522170551,
0.0632174388,
-0.0495706312,
-0.6780406237,
-0.0464361422,
0.6446815133,
-0.4742129445,
0.2964587212,
-0.2405886948,
-0.4478017092,
-0.1355314255,
-0.3440517187,
-0.0091526164,
0.3810422421,
-0.4145137668,
0.384162575,
0.2410561889,
-0.2994288206,
-1.0854101181,
-0.6518340707,
0.2717176378,
-0.2541406453,
-0.5001206994,
0.3538594246,
0.114868775,
-0.3187475801,
0.2791521549,
0.0063323891,
-0.3165127039,
-0.0036110731,
-0.0005450777,
-0.1435587853,
-0.632001102,
0.0922101066,
-0.0048841047,
-0.3889754415,
-0.3313812613,
-0.5837981701,
0.7892856002,
-0.6197507381,
-0.0492791906,
-0.5255909562,
0.4815962315,
0.2571073472,
-0.2090770304,
0.8562088013,
1.0702615976,
-0.4696007967,
-0.1277581304,
-0.3468986154,
0.2063021809,
-0.4185998142,
0.363384217,
-0.2571508884,
-0.9839466214,
0.0979317054,
-0.090239346,
0.5756331682,
0.5465074778,
0.5501018763,
-0.0598544478,
0.7085974813,
1.035623312,
-0.324837476,
0.1905418783,
0.1801355481,
0.1450115293,
-0.6190888286,
-0.047068987,
-0.7263090611,
-0.0527135767,
-0.5944910049,
-0.1617297828,
-0.1876409501,
0.3163998723,
0.0907900259,
0.3616941571,
-0.8701468706,
0.4232454598,
0.629868865,
-0.5435698628,
0.3577305079,
0.2252732813,
0.0135968542,
-0.0834474415,
-0.543331027,
-0.8349853158,
0.8940078616,
0.4564422667,
0.1863820106,
0.1087954268,
0.8586346507,
0.4404232204,
-0.155106172,
-1.0267213583,
0.7009843588,
-0.2134012729,
-0.3812475801,
-0.3847167194,
-0.0136167733,
-1.058850646,
0.2989321053,
-0.3769415319,
-1.1499539614,
-0.2486895323,
0.0059399498,
-0.2317519188,
0.3844515383,
-0.3101864755,
1.1109031439,
0.1862640828,
0.0505366474,
-0.1247440651,
-0.5448065996,
0.5961110592,
0.3734090924,
-0.0593624189,
-0.0259406827,
-0.0564248301,
0.7500029206,
-0.5916377902,
0.2876057029,
-0.2467412651,
0.2065063566,
0.2020080686,
-0.0145419203,
0.0856730118,
0.2778495848,
0.1159402058,
0.2806833386,
0.4311677217,
-0.4230733812,
-0.3236856163,
0.6842188835,
-0.5119390488,
-0.4078535736,
-0.7760906816,
-0.1620796025,
0.3282061517,
0.3016498387,
0.1504428387,
0.2144103944,
-0.2550449073,
0.2745545208,
0.5523195267,
-0.5469914675,
0.7700271606,
0.319652468,
-0.9032909274,
-0.3799350262,
0.6551234126,
-0.1821117699,
-0.1677580476,
0.4406217039,
0.3157105446,
-0.3819862008,
-0.672814548,
-0.4506961405,
0.0718550161,
-0.8195117712,
0.1019492075,
-0.7974461317,
-0.3658855259,
-0.3714022636,
-0.0723934919,
-0.5243735313,
-0.7753583789,
-0.07250949,
-0.0649144575,
-0.0220738277,
0.658890605,
-0.1042883843,
0.3308479786,
-0.5467150211,
0.4018922746,
0.4592131972,
0.0185123309,
-0.4573116302,
-0.1630853564,
-0.3629399538,
-0.3765746355,
-0.0420074388,
-0.7504600286,
0.5867967606,
0.2173504084,
0.4093390405,
0.3484063148,
0.0268298034,
0.0226160027,
-0.3496483266,
1.167521596,
0.0284569077,
-0.8383986354,
0.5560942888,
-0.2820894718,
0.6225224137,
0.5885279179,
0.0333491899,
-0.7931544185,
-0.0720932782,
-0.3809551597,
-1.0638902187,
0.7013783455,
0.3081620336,
-0.085541375,
0.1823367625,
0.195515722,
0.066649422,
0.4303061068,
-1.0332294703,
-0.3106266558,
-0.3494089544,
-0.2742961347,
0.0050641806,
-0.5921558738,
0.0213765018,
-0.2970918119,
0.7030869722,
0.0265919622,
0.348128885,
0.3255771995,
-0.2390045673,
0.1761354357,
0.5053012967,
0.9922943115,
0.51519382,
-0.5627040267,
0.271173954,
0.0572036617,
-0.6978002191,
-0.087675944,
0.0813090652,
-0.0545876324,
0.5635967255,
0.4804380536,
0.6512060165,
-0.362070322,
-0.5831927657,
0.6538642049,
-0.4067573249,
0.1728450954,
-0.6970744729,
-0.1149851307,
0.1584016383,
0.1527585387,
0.528826654,
-0.1185020357,
0.3930239677,
-0.3433267474,
0.3768394291,
0.1687642038,
-0.6120625138,
-0.2424085885,
0.5347977877,
-0.0298443306,
-0.7012118101,
0.4294268787,
-0.2983063757,
-0.3619408607,
0.3326226473,
0.4201899469,
1.0971529484,
-0.1099256873,
0.5671662092,
0.4352439046,
0.4765284061,
0.0791410282,
0.499130249,
-0.2633154988,
-0.5880323648,
-0.7593825459,
-1.0002924204,
-0.1457734406,
0.547985673,
-0.5829815865,
0.5966722965,
-0.6614952683,
-0.048829034,
-0.0017469309,
0.1289729178,
-0.6358014941,
0.2183695287,
0.4161914587,
1.1853221655,
-0.7197785974,
1.1169973612,
0.8879935145,
-0.2155872434,
-0.4241399467,
-0.1396393031,
-0.0605509877,
-0.3355311751,
0.8664227724,
0.5369260311,
0.1442732662,
0.0548544228,
-0.4756346643,
-0.4721724093,
0.6217986941,
0.1518250853,
-0.3821218014,
0.0818562508,
0.435067445,
0.5542154312,
-0.2135763764,
0.1589958072,
0.4813839495,
0.3181678951,
-0.2127005309,
-1.1276299953,
0.0440383181,
-0.3826076686,
-0.1477237195,
-0.0153405815,
-0.0867263153,
0.775875628,
0.2918966413,
-0.1168716177,
-0.0739650428,
0.889936924,
0.2769738734,
0.2878552675,
0.5203865767,
0.7654588819,
0.3396932781,
0.0584667437,
0.795372963,
-0.2624216378,
0.1483839154,
1.2477530241,
0.2917732596,
1.0538240671,
0.7530102134,
-0.1518178582,
0.3052195311,
0.5811405182,
0.4657236636,
0.5306332111,
0.1547361016,
-0.584030509,
-0.0475962274,
-0.3845283687,
-0.5755734444,
0.5211168528,
0.2295446098,
-0.0963732302,
-0.4395680726,
-0.2764707506,
0.1501101851,
-0.2704103887,
-0.2899267972,
0.6519694924,
0.2377092391,
-0.2580116391,
0.3542712331,
0.2785928845,
0.9193197489,
-0.7754129171,
-0.1008341089,
0.1090636104,
0.0119073205,
-0.3568377197,
-0.7944286466,
0.7055241466,
-0.1530427337,
0.1430488676,
0.002092086,
1.0417311192,
-0.2901296914,
-0.4419044852,
0.0590222478,
0.3287935853,
0.1834738255,
-0.2333611846,
-0.9048498869,
-0.05315971,
-0.066949673,
-0.7265635133,
0.2958702445,
0.1882467568,
0.1608799696,
0.4748661816,
0.7478440404,
0.4042726457,
0.3418628871,
-0.0762804747,
0.6765769124,
-0.7478535771,
-0.5832220912,
-0.9282969832,
0.9588772058,
-0.2257117778,
-0.5241645575,
0.5708001852,
0.5266615152,
0.8140477538,
-0.2757331431,
0.6536517143,
-0.1883857399,
0.3504601717,
-0.5196250677,
0.669791162,
-0.4902575612,
0.0840734765,
-0.3960187435,
-1.1164087057,
-0.5743079185,
0.62019521,
0.2034138441,
-0.6207472682,
0.6481592059,
0.2815287113,
0.0080204289,
-0.2798996568,
0.390439868,
-0.1072134674,
0.3461104333,
0.2846983075,
0.6403903961,
-0.2820553184,
0.2039583921,
-0.2273606658,
0.0312789641,
-0.1995311379,
-0.9338024259,
-0.9828294516,
-0.6853563786,
-0.2587872446,
-0.2252718955,
-0.1657200754,
1.3178935051,
0.4396044314,
-0.9173249006,
-0.2315451354,
-0.3816516101,
0.2012884021,
-0.3115284443,
-0.2654232383,
0.4423054755,
-0.5814247727,
-0.6071535945,
0.3053683043,
0.5171633363,
-0.0988666788,
-0.4459949732,
0.0194004588,
-0.387136966,
-0.0570825934,
0.5899114609,
0.5064171553,
-0.8560084701,
0.0635159835,
-0.2401507348,
-0.030242024,
0.1043279991,
0.5758494139,
-0.7706723213,
0.6552789211,
0.9111012816,
0.6025474668,
0.3395803571,
-0.4425349832,
0.5460798144,
-0.5607204437,
0.6827381849,
0.3083691597,
0.4610482752,
0.306209892,
-0.2864438295,
0.4721305966,
0.0988122523,
-0.4441582561,
-1.1385872364,
0.3631060719,
-1.2254121304,
-0.2475372702,
0.9656865597,
-0.1898680478,
-0.3577723503,
-0.4060508013,
-0.6879267693,
0.3630094826,
-0.0828765407,
0.8095480204,
0.7024160624,
0.2927011251,
-0.3884343505,
-0.8310248852,
0.940321207,
0.2988652289,
-0.669021368,
-0.2349773496,
0.1121999845,
0.093776077,
0.0935398638,
0.8557295203,
0.1137153059,
0.0111664766,
-0.0468630008,
0.3559332192,
-0.2456786186,
-0.2245469838,
-0.6109050512,
0.3627984226,
0.195014745,
-0.3760887384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01308v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01308v2
|
VBART: The Turkish LLM
| 2024-03-02T20:40:11 | 2024-03-14T16:37:37 |
Meliksah Turker, Mehmet Erdi Ari, Aydin Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present VBART, the first Turkish sequence-to-sequence Large Language
Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a large corpus from scratch. VBART are compact
LLMs based on good ideas leveraged from BART and mBART models and come in two
sizes, Large and XLarge. Fine-tuned VBART models surpass the prior
state-of-the-art results in abstractive text summarization, title generation,
text paraphrasing, question answering and question generation tasks. They allow
fine-tuning for future text generation tasks and datasets, carving a new path
for Turkish Natural Language Processing (NLP) research. Our work shows that
having a pre-trained LLM for Turkish outperforms up to 3x multilingual models,
improving existing results and providing efficient models for training and
inference. Moreover, we show that our monolingual tokenizer is up to 11x more
efficient than multilingual tokenizers. Last but not least, we introduce a
method to enlarge an existing pre-trained LLM and question the relevancy of
Chinchilla Scaling Law to sequence-to-sequence masked language models. Our
fine-tuned models, tokenizer and cleaned vngrs-web-corpus of 135 GB are
publicly available at huggingface.co/vngrs-ai.
|
[
-0.5895133018,
-0.6083733439,
0.2301298082,
0.2552177608,
-0.8084040284,
0.1177228913,
-0.3140669763,
-0.4139697254,
0.3546669781,
0.8679491878,
-0.4526496828,
-0.3858306408,
-0.6564857364,
0.214606896,
-0.4219409525,
1.2873251438,
0.0636625588,
0.1813298613,
0.182208389,
-0.1451803148,
-0.403517127,
-0.6633033752,
-0.5949087143,
-0.0384202115,
0.6112734675,
0.0208000746,
0.3159460127,
0.7303243876,
0.3723681271,
0.2467949539,
-0.2264150083,
0.107662715,
-0.2637923956,
0.0755138248,
-0.1501007676,
-0.2497656494,
-0.4973229766,
-0.4070364535,
0.5284827948,
0.6403833032,
-0.0439024046,
0.5833590031,
0.0409010574,
0.7733294368,
-0.3314658403,
0.1064516082,
-0.6691332459,
-0.1012678444,
-0.4433126152,
-0.1224863306,
-0.306974709,
-0.308506459,
-0.0097713601,
-0.2441157699,
0.146553278,
0.2110382169,
0.6000725031,
0.3062253296,
-0.7117230892,
-0.2247801572,
-0.628319025,
0.555606246,
-0.8603897691,
0.3948438466,
0.2597456872,
0.3018999398,
-0.3195341825,
-1.1646088362,
-0.5202060342,
-0.3497007787,
0.1471289843,
-0.0373822078,
-0.0072736363,
0.0878634974,
0.0649668574,
0.5429637432,
-0.7902737856,
0.0317941457,
-0.5649599433,
0.1039727554,
0.3621865809,
0.2134092003,
-0.0786613449,
0.0263939332,
-0.211883232,
0.1738547534,
-0.8709729314,
0.0290286653,
0.213441968,
0.5350914598,
0.2498351634,
0.9049872756,
-0.2790004313,
0.9454764128,
0.196787104,
-0.0398820713,
-0.0585501157,
-0.4314114451,
-0.3823311627,
0.3203789294,
0.7300444245,
-0.1342908144,
0.2330243886,
0.068783991,
0.0389118753,
-0.2643999159,
0.4008408189,
-1.0203123093,
0.0600421764,
0.1279025078,
-0.3314164579,
-0.3608927727,
-0.0479230322,
-0.3069136739,
-0.3817872703,
-0.3753671348,
0.4424567819,
-0.3013439178,
-0.2026834041,
0.5127426386,
0.3289868832,
0.4335893691,
0.4298668802,
-0.9316710234,
0.3693057895,
0.8866097927,
0.6532844305,
0.1242193505,
-0.1145264283,
-0.5172504187,
-0.1388828009,
-0.5480409861,
0.6280145049,
-0.0512537137,
-0.0584359467,
0.2481246144,
0.1618161201,
0.3060239851,
-0.4020954072,
0.6785339713,
-0.6310093403,
0.1184597835,
-0.2931461036,
-0.660333395,
-0.2331021726,
0.3413628936,
-0.7245286107,
0.9126924276,
-0.0109337121,
-1.0178847313,
0.5179550052,
-0.2699057758,
-0.6415600777,
0.2257650346,
-0.0035140757,
-0.4319991469,
0.3783229291,
0.3095132709,
0.6252418756,
-0.4578917325,
0.128110081,
-0.0952643007,
-0.2366668135,
-0.0615125149,
-0.2526738644,
0.8095110655,
0.2162656933,
-0.1688587964,
0.1663138866,
-0.7301290035,
-0.099543564,
0.0849387795,
-0.7462766171,
-0.2712895572,
-0.0667332709,
0.0856294408,
0.1615295559,
0.4292159379,
-0.4165942073,
0.3230788708,
-0.3858756721,
0.3923546374,
0.6092326641,
-0.1557254195,
-0.0208663531,
-0.3244709671,
0.5537829399,
-0.2276129574,
-0.2666156888,
-0.3832952976,
-0.2397016585,
-0.9045042992,
-0.6465953588,
0.4217308164,
0.5891258121,
-0.5105990767,
0.5232537985,
-0.416293323,
-0.5515376329,
-0.5053690672,
0.174491778,
0.1037444621,
0.2694172859,
0.1988688111,
-0.3851478994,
-0.8349593878,
-0.6258553863,
-0.2300780267,
-0.1700405777,
-0.0415543839,
-0.0687546059,
0.3458901048,
-0.0634538457,
0.855592072,
0.1620948166,
-0.2722257376,
-0.7169347405,
0.0480181947,
0.5533114076,
0.2823924422,
0.3800931871,
-0.5952078104,
-0.6215757132,
0.1398138106,
-0.4352843463,
-0.1381305903,
0.0813151821,
0.1889940202,
0.3329493999,
0.8353209496,
-0.6755708456,
0.2391248792,
0.5214414001,
-0.3256455064,
0.8858437538,
-0.2530945539,
0.0504238307,
-1.6248958111,
-0.0212015044,
-0.2285131514,
-0.6791039109,
-0.6253644228,
0.0539320633,
0.0349148735,
0.0564780198,
-0.6293347478,
0.774710834,
-0.4770571887,
-0.0482778624,
-0.3467085361,
-0.2166039646,
-0.3721984029,
0.2819804847,
0.1100639701,
0.868722856,
0.3079089522,
-0.6627157331,
0.4048388898,
0.2468272597,
-0.7290191054,
0.3469784558,
-0.6117293239,
-0.0521794222,
-0.104250595,
0.3051717579,
-0.8641605973,
-0.1752480119,
0.0202203337,
-0.450743556,
0.4891695678,
-0.3061586916,
-0.5456059575,
-0.5620308518,
-0.3513018191,
0.5342502594,
0.5796239376,
-0.6287244558,
0.3970208764,
0.0902261585,
-0.4734686017,
-0.8645499945,
-0.5707482696,
0.1334798336,
-0.3503934443,
-0.4274377227,
0.0480972305,
0.0522388443,
-0.0742541775,
-0.1966613233,
-0.1184511483,
-0.0498950146,
0.0107355332,
0.0269656926,
0.0317813791,
-0.7043139935,
0.1275294274,
0.0692282915,
0.0447839797,
-0.1547715813,
-0.724024415,
0.9562476277,
-0.4174672961,
-0.2413324714,
-0.2216413766,
0.0891376361,
0.37524575,
-0.5430555344,
0.9047180414,
0.7385754585,
-0.3081852496,
0.2066790462,
-0.6419603825,
0.1480837315,
-0.4575028419,
0.7085867524,
-0.4908082187,
-1.3036351204,
0.319889307,
-0.3009316027,
0.3939038217,
0.4046866,
1.0062274933,
0.0044039786,
0.7804698348,
0.8382576108,
-0.2160521597,
0.5251369476,
0.1440339535,
0.315441519,
-0.6229911447,
0.2169331163,
-0.4665214121,
0.2327430546,
-0.7127373815,
-0.433159858,
0.0227979608,
0.2872879803,
-0.3459275365,
0.4846555293,
-0.04203384,
0.5177392364,
0.5526842475,
-0.1903332323,
0.2282538712,
0.0542798825,
0.0310604647,
0.0737926736,
-0.4886159897,
-0.7404001355,
1.3964911699,
0.1531517506,
0.5219556689,
0.152174294,
0.8921539783,
0.3292675018,
0.2470924258,
-0.7562959194,
0.4646430314,
-0.2815836966,
-0.7700082064,
-0.3964359164,
-0.1434708536,
-1.138581872,
0.4088593125,
-0.2175532728,
-0.7158970237,
-0.4871932864,
0.168703407,
-0.4108333588,
0.3243041337,
-0.1692579538,
0.8375287056,
-0.1149396598,
-0.3299252987,
-0.1393713504,
-0.6483545899,
0.7045171857,
-0.3875294626,
0.1687685698,
-0.0349407643,
0.010599074,
0.6913788319,
-0.6940189004,
0.4890917242,
0.1979096681,
0.061099831,
0.2541763186,
0.1559489369,
0.3825996816,
0.0839231312,
0.104729034,
0.1155243441,
0.1911653131,
-0.6444286704,
-0.1793625206,
0.2940875292,
-0.5352705717,
-0.7447739244,
-0.473405838,
-0.1471171677,
-0.0796322674,
0.4298520088,
0.2590795159,
0.4058564603,
-0.4909892678,
0.3672806919,
0.7284545302,
-0.4697636962,
0.2626912296,
0.4663997293,
-0.5964180231,
-0.4162140191,
0.6636818051,
-0.1201186925,
0.14267461,
0.4678306282,
0.0876764953,
-0.1904050857,
-0.6644077301,
-0.6127366424,
0.3662961423,
-0.4256246686,
-0.1455675364,
-0.7597575188,
-0.3785966933,
-0.6531565189,
-0.1749301404,
-0.6936103702,
-0.495664537,
-0.0306756217,
-0.2882254422,
0.2566303611,
0.8245618939,
-0.3499649763,
0.5626465678,
-0.6870455146,
0.229307428,
0.3598141372,
-0.0933761969,
-0.3772545755,
-0.720228076,
-0.4579506218,
-0.2405897081,
-0.0830020532,
-0.4976968765,
0.741166234,
0.0949201807,
0.2603024542,
0.3726304471,
-0.0364073031,
0.4252257943,
-0.7763634324,
0.8239693642,
0.1004356295,
-0.7609494328,
0.1242074072,
-0.3829726279,
0.3425831795,
0.5421692133,
0.3003952503,
-0.7123547792,
-0.3908413947,
-0.2555019259,
-1.0432937145,
0.5330425501,
-0.0043613194,
0.3140413463,
-0.0043943315,
0.3397989273,
0.4262793958,
0.4557496607,
-0.8069903255,
-0.209756732,
-0.2136709094,
-0.3975272179,
-0.4457281232,
-0.6411584616,
0.289342612,
-0.2799969614,
0.7334391475,
0.0133719379,
0.2014014274,
-0.0347453505,
-0.3485918045,
0.152730152,
0.3392192423,
0.9285829067,
0.5357175469,
-0.4245378673,
0.2000677735,
0.3368360996,
-0.6433160901,
0.2501029074,
0.1986765265,
0.2254870236,
-0.0250404105,
0.5491654873,
0.8130875826,
-0.1837773323,
-0.6992807388,
0.5892528296,
-0.4102610052,
-0.291728586,
-0.5977350473,
-0.4562435448,
0.1464031786,
0.4181536138,
0.308382839,
-0.3772979379,
-0.0118906125,
-0.3660467863,
0.3850796819,
0.2345576584,
-0.3034515381,
-0.2434026748,
0.7379737496,
-0.0573522113,
-0.3046128154,
0.4073185921,
-0.0896583125,
-0.6852586269,
0.40454337,
0.5050969124,
0.7439077497,
-0.2284813672,
0.1718957424,
0.5147410631,
0.6008099914,
-0.2310246527,
0.0755610913,
-0.1813642383,
-0.5116207004,
-0.5948435068,
-0.9671259522,
-0.2495093644,
0.5170231462,
-0.5290408134,
0.5046221614,
-0.5964306593,
-0.013488573,
-0.30838269,
0.3224694729,
-0.7337866426,
0.1890124232,
0.0972091332,
0.9736031294,
-0.6760731936,
1.0959851742,
0.6627157331,
-0.3169025779,
-0.6112698317,
-0.1825775951,
-0.2064922899,
-0.8464847207,
0.5626713037,
0.3284917176,
0.1353814155,
0.1850400418,
-0.4345339835,
-0.9437258244,
0.8328514695,
0.3000513911,
-0.5644869208,
0.1036868244,
0.2856728137,
0.5737445354,
-0.1800356209,
0.1532798111,
0.5500682592,
0.2101523429,
0.0220838841,
-0.9979800582,
0.0085004987,
-0.0472537205,
-0.096429728,
0.229393512,
-0.466468811,
0.9625502229,
-0.1518127024,
0.1358191371,
0.4199212492,
0.8723152876,
0.2907529175,
-0.1714504212,
0.2921604216,
0.5818845034,
0.5397426486,
0.2551898062,
1.0094386339,
-0.2517342567,
-0.0295709968,
1.3017556667,
-0.1192696691,
0.8727510571,
0.5316495895,
-0.0529879443,
0.0938774198,
0.9609655738,
0.3528092802,
0.6746900678,
0.4798843861,
-0.4387111366,
-0.2702153623,
0.1556995362,
-0.4450425506,
0.3778312504,
0.2147011906,
-0.1540821046,
-0.2031846941,
0.1150876433,
0.1449348629,
-0.2446964979,
-0.3868398666,
0.7448455095,
0.1950553954,
-0.3792199492,
0.5204908252,
0.2484222353,
0.6925208569,
-0.5975173116,
0.3533559144,
-0.4755779803,
0.2977156639,
0.2384407222,
-0.2900442481,
0.1150545254,
0.150121972,
0.1668358147,
-0.089647904,
0.5609174371,
-0.3744721413,
-0.6887466311,
-0.0560892075,
0.5354402065,
0.3289219141,
-0.2245257199,
-0.3401587605,
-0.1862225235,
-0.0860060155,
-0.7156468034,
0.3473657072,
0.6429862976,
-0.2579705119,
0.5424779058,
0.5661759377,
0.2315031439,
0.5329778194,
-0.1188382208,
0.6343656182,
-0.7779402137,
-0.3348252475,
-0.9406939149,
0.4419738352,
0.2380383909,
-0.2061935961,
0.453333497,
0.6867825389,
1.0093812943,
-0.2132155299,
0.8951410651,
-0.0001216135,
0.6686885953,
-0.507075727,
0.756195724,
-0.7814176083,
-0.0934772119,
-0.099976331,
-1.008756876,
-0.3817125559,
0.5177615881,
-0.0049833301,
-0.1269914061,
0.5453465581,
0.5570734143,
-0.0633847415,
-0.3612489998,
0.5553394556,
0.2657337785,
0.4047192931,
0.4273981452,
0.8437020183,
-0.3867277801,
0.4299574196,
0.0679692626,
-0.0559994765,
-0.413967371,
-0.8385083675,
-1.2552355528,
-0.7433874011,
0.0309476387,
-0.1662783027,
0.1052125543,
1.2762087584,
0.5930210352,
-0.7875268459,
-0.3979895413,
-0.1868275255,
-0.1386965811,
-0.0232317895,
-0.0840981752,
0.2667632699,
-0.394592613,
-0.4624095857,
0.3029108942,
0.1072271392,
0.181099385,
-0.1019237638,
-0.1060055718,
-0.0325738788,
0.4401208758,
0.7873095274,
0.5122539997,
-0.7540996075,
-0.0972375274,
-0.2401302606,
-0.2438197136,
0.0602333434,
0.7428315878,
-0.7334136367,
0.2346659303,
0.3894931674,
0.9302310348,
0.9532900453,
-0.2871155143,
0.7088199258,
-0.5346031785,
0.3696356416,
0.0677077472,
0.4477515519,
0.2458537221,
0.1781744957,
0.480895251,
-0.1285352856,
-0.3857103884,
-1.0129578114,
0.1868254691,
-1.0401768684,
-0.2358629704,
0.9080219269,
-0.1077776402,
-0.2327575088,
0.0022346857,
-0.5670775175,
0.5608695149,
-0.0026026147,
0.8686411977,
0.6740908623,
0.3152636886,
-0.3493792713,
-0.7153683305,
0.5722437501,
0.4168119431,
-0.8325617909,
0.089569144,
0.2161079943,
0.3238512874,
-0.3807248771,
0.8234062791,
0.0362059437,
0.1295300126,
-0.1179648042,
0.2740901411,
-0.2083472461,
-0.2334959954,
-0.3838898838,
0.0184106901,
0.4904303849,
-0.1475829482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01304v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01304v1
|
Improving the Validity of Automatically Generated Feedback via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-02T20:25:50 | 2024-03-02T20:25:50 |
Alexander Scarlatos, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatically generating feedback via large language models (LLMs) in
intelligent tutoring systems and online learning platforms has the potential to
improve the learning outcomes of many students. However, both feedback
generation and evaluation are challenging: feedback content has to be valid
especially in subjects like math, which requires models to understand the
problem, the solution, and where the student's error lies. Feedback also has to
be pedagogically valid to reflect effective tutoring strategies, such as
explaining possible misconceptions and encouraging the student, among other
desirable features. In this work, we address both problems of automatically
generating and evaluating feedback while considering both correctness and
alignment. First, we propose a rubric for evaluating math feedback and show
that GPT-4 is able to effectively use it to annotate human-written and
LLM-generated feedback. Second, we propose a framework for feedback generation
that optimizes both correctness and alignment using reinforcement learning
(RL). Specifically, we use GPT-4's annotations to create preferences over
feedback pairs in an augmented dataset for training via direct preference
optimization (DPO). We show that our methods significantly increase the
correctness and alignment of generated feedback with Llama 2, an open-source
LLM, qualitatively analyze our generation and evaluation systems using case
studies, and outline several areas for future work.
|
[
-0.1878241897,
-0.743276,
0.5803851485,
0.4478683174,
-0.0834549665,
0.2002826184,
-0.4941543639,
-0.1530265659,
-0.0656551421,
0.181975171,
-0.574980855,
-0.4029604495,
-0.3709965348,
0.3271563649,
-0.0721176192,
1.3976356983,
-0.4287225008,
0.3165984154,
-0.5165500045,
0.0180225186,
-0.5830441713,
-0.440459013,
-0.6770214438,
-0.5181786418,
0.416983217,
0.4511422515,
0.4747473896,
0.6195374727,
0.5028871894,
0.3450674117,
0.4137011468,
0.5251005292,
-0.4592581987,
0.2515299022,
-0.0951187089,
-0.2879821062,
-0.4285237193,
0.0031135192,
0.6501410604,
0.3205043972,
-0.3384397328,
0.1523992717,
0.1896397471,
0.6961293817,
-0.2714351714,
0.2420010567,
-0.3983098567,
0.2356222123,
0.0491490625,
-0.2698827088,
-0.3222657442,
-0.9552136064,
0.1241910532,
-0.9671509862,
-0.1001409367,
-0.0526285209,
0.8403873444,
0.5466699004,
-0.0905765519,
-0.6449339986,
-0.7504848242,
0.7966300249,
-0.6731985807,
0.2131163627,
0.3956027925,
0.4980629086,
-0.3730316162,
-0.4059333503,
-0.5686796308,
-0.4518640339,
0.0915558636,
0.2218021154,
0.1354581267,
-0.1083940119,
0.3582488,
0.2031058073,
-0.2104940861,
0.1894530803,
-0.0822048932,
-0.3916336298,
0.8647920489,
0.1538067013,
0.1884061098,
-0.1423297673,
-0.1773898751,
-0.1640076041,
-0.8278872371,
0.1842551529,
0.9922463298,
0.2536546588,
0.1182908714,
0.6713038683,
0.0007589563,
0.6469205618,
0.4355773032,
-0.4640270174,
0.2415928543,
-0.2902399898,
0.1099442095,
-0.0107148401,
0.8244951963,
0.3931131065,
0.2249208987,
-0.181434527,
-0.4797742963,
0.2779017091,
0.2927183211,
-0.5984506607,
-0.1988991499,
0.1519933641,
-0.0480043292,
-0.5457386374,
0.1527398676,
-0.6784991622,
-0.2048369646,
-0.8078345656,
0.4224592745,
-0.3665694594,
-0.1651266515,
0.0362856574,
0.2865475416,
0.0690921843,
0.6643090248,
-1.0226584673,
0.4298788905,
0.7389464378,
0.4899377525,
-0.4145315289,
-0.269998461,
-0.7590942383,
-0.0012055559,
-0.337980032,
0.7682323456,
-0.3789092302,
-0.252810061,
0.0838129595,
-0.2829939425,
0.1448893398,
-0.5996376276,
0.2397000641,
-0.500487268,
0.5474159718,
-0.1664397418,
-0.8038278818,
0.0589517392,
0.4424195886,
-0.5881349444,
1.1116081476,
0.1862517148,
-0.4531797767,
0.3867275119,
-0.8225269318,
-0.2521239519,
0.0111519154,
-0.3838245869,
-0.8021305799,
-0.1108142883,
0.3444099426,
0.017285889,
0.0474362262,
0.5845220089,
-0.1628164351,
-0.2513639033,
0.4396502972,
-0.2474662662,
0.259796232,
0.0756220892,
-0.7271350622,
0.3915120959,
-0.7050261497,
0.1623350084,
0.0879152939,
-0.6416047812,
0.1178523898,
-0.0093113631,
-0.2796213329,
0.0930701867,
0.3155736625,
-0.5165902376,
0.3702572286,
-0.3273067772,
0.3342011273,
1.0696374178,
0.0322672315,
0.3215684891,
-0.2825278938,
0.6883525848,
0.0092059094,
0.1053863689,
0.0238723196,
-0.145359531,
-0.7503464222,
0.0841218457,
0.5273093581,
0.4824492037,
-0.9407013059,
0.4063680172,
-0.0730944574,
-0.2032438219,
-0.4337415993,
0.5534092784,
0.5972214341,
0.5027552843,
0.2164326161,
-0.2863369584,
-0.6867073774,
-0.5756660104,
-0.0677648783,
-0.3493086696,
0.1147713289,
0.2943618298,
0.3495385349,
-0.2724152207,
1.008040309,
-0.2981559336,
-0.0310708266,
-0.0280001909,
0.0606939159,
-0.1161744967,
0.5156723261,
0.3417719305,
-0.3461671472,
-0.3454214931,
-0.1643002629,
-0.5784035921,
-0.3078634441,
-0.0604809448,
-0.3661483228,
0.3965810239,
-0.030213723,
-0.2401902676,
0.3076866269,
0.3801107705,
-0.0815313086,
0.6395686269,
-0.1227101386,
0.0955963209,
-0.8135154843,
-0.0695778355,
0.1145976037,
-0.36692819,
-0.1162095964,
-0.2820551097,
-0.0809768811,
-0.0133288587,
-0.1043287441,
0.4106552899,
-0.1697077602,
-0.1834661067,
-0.2516905367,
0.357114166,
-0.0016553728,
0.5985255241,
0.036745958,
0.7980493307,
0.0300940257,
-0.3706441224,
0.7319564819,
0.2393351793,
-0.2731945515,
0.6541038156,
-0.5253508091,
0.3006990254,
0.2115218639,
0.4049660265,
-0.8217323422,
-0.302804172,
0.5052467585,
-0.5114254951,
0.2658972442,
-0.033051569,
-0.4887693822,
-0.3171132505,
-0.4042904675,
0.2968604565,
0.3634932339,
-0.6741870046,
0.2381207198,
0.2720883787,
-0.1198630333,
-0.7328400612,
-0.0790601671,
-0.1778496355,
-0.0543681085,
-0.3691227734,
0.1116348654,
-0.1922779679,
-0.2469361871,
0.0911030248,
-0.0899932906,
0.2194529921,
0.1004456952,
0.195818767,
0.4136101007,
-0.0026004701,
0.1927315295,
0.0603526644,
-0.2993502617,
0.1558411717,
-0.3716701567,
0.3727320433,
-0.279178381,
-0.5770325661,
-0.3486273885,
-0.0454021581,
0.1886615902,
-0.0354334824,
0.0524080172,
0.4430257678,
-0.2030571699,
-0.379211843,
-0.5245078802,
-0.2575951219,
-0.4130920768,
0.254347831,
-0.1463891715,
-0.9427904487,
0.3194555938,
-0.088460058,
0.4066985846,
0.297875315,
0.7586423159,
-0.0343084149,
1.2681829929,
0.5110991001,
0.1334090382,
0.4045045972,
-0.2402340323,
0.1184623614,
-0.8403669596,
-0.372112155,
-0.2379126996,
-0.1849969923,
-0.4399947226,
-0.11169862,
0.1790870428,
0.1326382607,
-0.2533572912,
0.1290987134,
-0.5488980412,
0.4992063344,
0.5890879631,
0.1735497415,
0.2828469574,
0.1446220875,
-0.3418725431,
-0.291613698,
-0.5123597383,
-0.7032604814,
1.1798728704,
0.4072732031,
0.7385379076,
0.2623386979,
0.8660173416,
0.1468196511,
0.6734076738,
-0.8391016722,
0.3979513943,
0.2920382321,
-0.2177489996,
-0.3229608536,
-0.6510403752,
-0.788166821,
0.0804174691,
-0.2352471501,
-0.3804770708,
-0.4802598059,
0.4160167873,
-0.4882197082,
0.1431162059,
-0.4601670504,
0.690485239,
-0.656771481,
-0.7111433744,
-0.0614847243,
-0.4300994277,
0.3217855692,
-0.0456944555,
0.0489637256,
0.0068083527,
0.0197968166,
0.7446447611,
-0.8721040487,
0.8029068708,
-0.234698087,
-0.5023022294,
0.3632623851,
0.1547551304,
0.3150885403,
0.2859930396,
0.0894585922,
-0.2830616236,
-0.1233485118,
-0.1643602699,
-0.9943276644,
0.7341079712,
-1.1709396839,
-0.6088775992,
-0.431440264,
-0.5941238999,
-0.287014395,
-0.1468740255,
-0.0918701813,
0.4862426221,
0.1240352094,
-0.3915458918,
0.5002126098,
-0.1636407226,
0.1589525044,
0.5011973977,
-0.5655750036,
-0.8954694867,
1.2727823257,
-0.0106511805,
-0.043345727,
0.0182093401,
0.199702546,
-0.5829544663,
-0.3863248229,
-0.9416331053,
0.3582631946,
-0.7618427277,
-0.3638112843,
-0.0056625651,
-0.1378257871,
-0.3340157568,
-0.0287938099,
-0.217240274,
-0.5761173964,
-0.1961935014,
-0.2091326416,
0.3331933022,
1.1293724775,
-0.2629122138,
0.0538413711,
-0.6026847959,
-0.1075790972,
0.3574048579,
0.4892020822,
0.0300347917,
-0.4197618365,
-0.1881720424,
-0.0187176913,
-0.7652781606,
-0.6594133377,
0.1570660323,
-0.0766973644,
0.400351733,
0.2025577426,
-0.3102584481,
0.6664801836,
-0.6398301125,
0.7673674822,
0.2407704145,
-1.052647233,
0.7065064311,
-0.2893137634,
0.025955651,
0.4969909489,
0.1555822492,
-0.3559902906,
-0.3537619114,
-0.7050893307,
-0.6836030483,
0.649811089,
0.1243890002,
-0.0429080389,
0.0361927487,
0.6127607822,
0.3498848379,
0.4540632963,
-0.9006804824,
0.0931480974,
-0.4346221685,
-0.6438260078,
0.2231754363,
-0.0902231112,
-0.349326551,
-0.1982725114,
0.9342520237,
-0.256326735,
0.0979339182,
-0.0313087553,
-0.1213278621,
-0.4177791476,
0.1047243476,
0.8739044666,
0.8449085355,
0.0541674346,
-0.1247199029,
0.0908034965,
-0.3285110593,
0.453666091,
0.0606119335,
-0.2831004262,
-0.0379177518,
0.2775734365,
0.8287500143,
0.2240774781,
-0.6363890767,
0.6072186828,
-0.1578880548,
-0.292087853,
-0.4356038272,
0.1211601347,
-0.3255202174,
0.0922021419,
0.0630092323,
-0.2174624354,
-0.1673027873,
-0.0756717473,
0.2050752342,
0.392316103,
-0.2393948287,
-0.4057609141,
0.3397777677,
0.530148983,
-0.2959514856,
0.5274866223,
-0.1886031181,
-0.790057838,
0.4819493294,
0.7335001826,
0.6877113581,
-0.0610111207,
0.3839614689,
0.6182662845,
-0.1059010625,
-0.0362511463,
0.0971295759,
-0.4079702795,
-0.6043675542,
-0.7347003222,
-0.5671318769,
-0.9427942038,
-0.0500230566,
-0.6089012027,
0.3296773434,
-0.587285459,
-0.2569276094,
-0.4013614953,
0.3788129687,
-0.3577131927,
0.0646250173,
0.0801188871,
0.291424185,
-0.654755652,
0.5010889173,
0.9983133078,
-0.5823898911,
-1.2104301453,
-0.2600108087,
-0.0389987454,
-0.8997260928,
0.995626688,
0.0985616222,
-0.1426978558,
-0.0465714633,
-0.6138816476,
-0.8135816455,
0.9026689529,
0.3194968104,
-0.6753231883,
0.0632962361,
0.2271851897,
0.6330263019,
-0.2730211914,
0.4950151145,
0.262453109,
0.459238708,
0.0137231881,
-0.9143318534,
-0.088517867,
-0.2778002322,
0.1326937824,
0.2775943875,
-0.5816685557,
0.4700090289,
-0.1520347148,
-0.0711627975,
0.1337139159,
0.6979125738,
0.6088329554,
0.191454038,
0.551433444,
1.0401440859,
0.7861317992,
-0.3233883083,
0.9746359587,
-0.217746079,
0.4211364985,
1.1283740997,
-0.2546505928,
0.6143746376,
0.5530519485,
-0.2985347211,
0.7910783291,
0.8053014278,
-0.0779575035,
0.32973212,
0.6818770766,
-0.1096740067,
-0.1790399253,
0.1100816727,
-0.2125315964,
0.0750551745,
0.1068709865,
-0.0433097295,
-0.2360331863,
-0.1701826304,
0.0216213427,
0.3670784235,
-0.2644814551,
1.0076076984,
-0.1081076637,
-1.0525791645,
0.3197916448,
-0.0729030669,
0.5583810806,
-0.4823621809,
-0.3891307414,
-0.249813661,
0.2223518789,
-0.479390949,
-0.6999425292,
0.0212872345,
0.3222801983,
-0.1018653437,
-0.0917753279,
0.3429358602,
-0.6105944514,
-0.4330987036,
-0.0014168691,
0.3797117472,
-0.0438860953,
0.6481980085,
-0.7741370201,
0.2860470116,
0.0895803347,
-0.1740292162,
0.2966809571,
0.3731538951,
-0.0636542514,
0.542350769,
0.8855779171,
0.2805902958,
-0.0707396716,
0.1933995187,
0.7672028542,
-0.2703183591,
-0.3120191693,
-0.8961350322,
0.3337952197,
-0.0977407321,
-0.3710602522,
0.8545680046,
0.4402607977,
1.0415347815,
0.094389841,
0.8823198676,
0.1389656216,
0.5695160031,
-0.6360607743,
0.1595238894,
-0.2414940894,
0.3803961575,
-0.345468998,
-1.2155674696,
-0.4003214836,
0.8924018145,
-0.613971293,
0.0711704716,
0.5689399242,
0.5358195901,
0.2308482081,
0.0157140121,
-0.1695643365,
-0.2177916467,
0.6463931203,
0.6789346933,
1.2886990309,
-0.408305794,
0.5359828472,
-0.3592233956,
-0.142672956,
-0.175540626,
-0.9862954021,
-0.7065401673,
-0.3324929774,
-0.5321410298,
-0.7116192579,
0.0589723177,
1.2477982044,
0.3782593906,
-0.8646893501,
-0.3761763871,
-0.2496350408,
0.2516652942,
0.0832826272,
-0.2545042038,
0.3834564984,
-0.7416371703,
-0.7221401334,
0.1265723854,
0.2253646553,
0.1823476851,
-0.5356462598,
-0.5152420998,
0.3485645652,
-0.1681756079,
0.3876719177,
0.3617987633,
-0.8908025026,
-0.5631705523,
-0.081231378,
-0.200273931,
0.1168553233,
0.813292563,
-0.6697315574,
0.3633192778,
0.2916748524,
1.0065425634,
0.1664372981,
0.2796058655,
0.7983729243,
-0.5819575191,
-0.1781605035,
0.3609267175,
0.2244667858,
0.6608499289,
-0.2918621004,
0.596647203,
0.2160868794,
-0.8606688976,
-0.8847833276,
0.2077419311,
-0.6376920938,
0.2623017132,
1.1379289627,
-0.2927499712,
-0.1631964147,
0.2910000086,
-0.495225817,
0.2484174073,
-0.48357144,
0.9979245067,
0.8392121792,
-0.4068251848,
0.1323462278,
-0.1999035627,
0.7057709694,
0.6743125319,
-0.8645662069,
-0.2192776054,
0.7874614,
0.3743411005,
0.2115987837,
0.4143057764,
-0.1679936945,
0.4771582782,
-0.4530606866,
0.0929462686,
-0.2022463381,
-0.3205074668,
-0.4088205695,
-0.0925608575,
0.3205289245,
-0.0194089022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01289v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01289v2
|
Greed is All You Need: An Evaluation of Tokenizer Inference Methods
| 2024-03-02T19:01:40 | 2024-05-31T08:07:45 |
Omri Uzan, Craig W. Schmidt, Chris Tanner, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While subword tokenizers such as BPE and WordPiece are typically used to
build vocabularies for NLP models, the method of decoding text into a sequence
of tokens from these vocabularies is often left unspecified, or ill-suited to
the method in which they were constructed. We provide a controlled analysis of
seven tokenizer inference methods across four different algorithms and three
vocabulary sizes, performed on a novel intrinsic evaluation suite we curated
for English, combining measures rooted in morphology, cognition, and
information theory. We show that for the most commonly used tokenizers, greedy
inference performs surprisingly well; and that SaGe, a recently-introduced
contextually-informed tokenizer, outperforms all others on morphological
alignment.
|
[
-0.0957676023,
-0.5857521892,
0.34544909,
0.1002550796,
-0.5546323657,
-0.2466718704,
-0.0737051666,
-0.3234733939,
0.6406623721,
0.1915505677,
-0.4770192504,
-0.1460660249,
-0.7529518604,
0.082097441,
-0.3887970448,
1.0399864912,
0.3867177367,
0.4352559447,
-0.0949680358,
0.0653486401,
-0.6171758771,
-0.4337304831,
-0.5512416363,
-0.2344290018,
0.5772223473,
-0.0395329371,
0.6135671139,
0.8559885025,
0.2232266814,
0.3296121955,
-0.2078857124,
0.0667554885,
-0.3291120529,
-0.2479652166,
-0.489985019,
-0.5427829623,
0.0603086539,
0.0474834144,
0.1618080884,
0.5851248503,
-0.052538842,
0.4299074113,
-0.1448975205,
0.3690773249,
-1.2332752943,
-0.1883361191,
-1.0479296446,
0.1422839761,
-0.4365195036,
-0.2675231993,
-0.5498846769,
-0.0806334093,
0.24858585,
-0.5715665817,
0.1196230799,
0.058939077,
1.1603022814,
0.3845033646,
-0.2128430009,
-0.6957486868,
-0.2446343452,
1.1684849262,
-0.5795482397,
0.3126990497,
0.3479489088,
0.045753371,
-0.0009426377,
-1.2319664955,
-0.4540949464,
0.0050970148,
-0.3042460978,
0.4303531647,
-0.1950974017,
0.4198468626,
-0.0432673581,
0.4322725236,
-0.2018574178,
0.1578142047,
-0.4544281065,
-0.5345182419,
0.2655384839,
-0.1214838773,
0.3762416542,
-0.672007978,
-0.6632475853,
-0.0472555012,
-0.3882441521,
-0.120257616,
0.3179634213,
0.2560127378,
0.4376886487,
0.9157779813,
0.5341622829,
0.8948047161,
-0.1486555934,
-0.0868838653,
-0.3078838885,
-0.523814559,
-0.4009117782,
0.1595686823,
0.5524021387,
0.4827040732,
0.1324284375,
-0.4551091492,
-0.2036500424,
0.3688510656,
0.5142576098,
-0.5098714232,
0.0903635025,
0.6085079312,
-0.6462071538,
-0.1845948845,
0.0891578645,
-0.9052440524,
-0.4154238701,
-0.194426477,
0.5139228106,
-0.4547666609,
0.0954231694,
0.3151084185,
-1.0611155033,
0.7245963216,
-0.0932944939,
-1.105348587,
0.1924511194,
1.0644613504,
1.0935213566,
-0.2993559539,
-0.4890888035,
-0.8932863474,
-0.0080100158,
-0.585093081,
1.075671792,
-0.5039777756,
-0.3527989984,
0.0923897028,
-0.2074992061,
-0.1982920766,
-0.3149931729,
1.1372921467,
-0.5836258531,
0.1044160575,
-0.3937958777,
-0.8732103705,
-0.2235559225,
0.164655149,
-0.6484378576,
0.7115386724,
0.0785906017,
-0.9924484491,
0.9810940623,
-0.4722059667,
-0.3971328139,
0.3848930001,
-0.0638072714,
-0.0885584876,
0.6015051007,
0.2034863979,
0.4185273051,
-0.2510032654,
0.3645175695,
-0.0582186393,
-0.5848116279,
0.0749127492,
-0.3637019694,
0.9436138868,
0.1018317938,
-0.4963545501,
0.1111485362,
-0.2282282114,
-0.0012514519,
-0.0707692206,
-0.2309695631,
-0.4739663899,
0.3464504778,
0.1462777257,
-0.2123838067,
0.3857504725,
-0.5602043867,
0.351300478,
-0.5891817212,
0.5485014915,
1.1330106258,
-0.0440300629,
0.3161031306,
-0.1942159534,
0.5919541121,
-0.182317704,
0.0773005262,
0.0961470082,
-0.2925531566,
-0.8202776313,
-0.6137232184,
0.7916893959,
0.4834243655,
-0.5332299471,
0.4298363924,
-0.3300537467,
-0.5341347456,
-0.4644340277,
-0.0852589086,
0.3129714131,
0.1847023219,
0.0681200102,
-0.2964196205,
-0.6924303174,
-1.025474906,
-0.7710549831,
-0.21116063,
-0.1138036549,
0.293859899,
0.4266774952,
-0.2090422362,
1.0247875452,
-0.4467303753,
-0.3732145727,
-0.3806027174,
0.0822093487,
0.1997300535,
0.21266146,
0.8376675844,
-0.4868784249,
-0.0923155621,
0.0382029749,
-0.1070721745,
-0.1035291702,
-0.3408969343,
-0.5491043329,
-0.0369336233,
0.3700640202,
-0.4905734956,
0.2439810038,
0.4114697874,
-0.5827203989,
0.6004259586,
0.1347801387,
-0.2398736179,
-0.914660275,
0.2414534986,
0.0224433485,
-0.0241070874,
-0.4564380944,
0.3768832088,
-0.0254744478,
0.1309145093,
-0.4331952035,
0.838062644,
-0.3811384737,
-0.1705406457,
-0.0234807767,
0.3972787559,
-0.011439994,
0.1887224168,
0.0788278207,
0.9734029174,
0.50961411,
-0.5410988331,
0.3159175515,
0.1039276347,
-0.457216382,
0.2374157459,
-0.6783105135,
-0.070517309,
-0.2803491056,
-0.0876017809,
-0.8276677728,
-0.2395447493,
-0.0840926245,
-0.4441172183,
0.2348900586,
-0.4002407193,
-0.2618729174,
-0.3628003299,
-0.4740065932,
-0.001388216,
0.3179500699,
-0.6610984206,
0.9360291362,
0.4443466067,
0.1430459917,
-1.0164462328,
-0.6407009363,
0.2629283667,
-0.4825259149,
-0.1779525727,
0.3318629265,
0.1461161524,
-0.2971211374,
-0.0352044441,
-0.2101537585,
0.1135667041,
0.2686707377,
-0.1559467167,
0.3216639161,
0.0657621101,
-0.0133001599,
0.1341152787,
-0.100980103,
0.0371497124,
-0.7748804092,
0.8175207973,
0.1978015304,
-0.3659028113,
-0.0998995602,
0.1820939928,
0.6526808739,
-0.2585449815,
0.4996398091,
0.5027776957,
-0.3142591417,
-0.1397506297,
-0.7132178545,
0.011792412,
-0.482545048,
0.4422796071,
-0.3393578529,
-0.5720411539,
0.5712261796,
-0.0116800796,
0.3414770067,
0.5365896225,
0.567754209,
0.6199530959,
0.9996833801,
0.3508650661,
-0.2331712246,
0.2970068157,
-0.2269008756,
0.5179854035,
-0.6153151989,
-0.0433895849,
-0.5874493122,
-0.3517660797,
-0.5756832957,
-0.4074588716,
0.1840613335,
0.1262947768,
0.0559336878,
0.3073274493,
-0.5711879134,
0.9157535434,
0.7117801309,
-0.1989279538,
-0.0904516429,
0.0392441899,
-0.2277850062,
-0.1912435889,
-0.7090348005,
-0.5819135308,
0.8796222806,
0.0601125881,
0.3343437612,
0.0545202307,
0.527834177,
0.3365754187,
0.3104933202,
-1.6322058439,
0.3239798844,
-0.3427634835,
-0.7724189758,
-0.0681923628,
-0.2091239691,
-1.0721721649,
0.44232288,
0.0060938732,
-0.8432388902,
0.2906047106,
0.0130921854,
-0.409173727,
0.3400891721,
-1.0660508871,
0.9783537984,
-0.2988491654,
-0.2283202708,
-0.018424226,
-0.3522865176,
0.4063012302,
0.0176632125,
0.0321027823,
0.2589685321,
-0.4717978835,
0.8005704284,
-0.4941425622,
0.7657340169,
-0.3346842229,
-0.0090358304,
0.4436487854,
0.2194679528,
0.3368835449,
-0.0372022241,
-0.2917607725,
0.2592875957,
0.3355419338,
-0.774974525,
-0.615901351,
0.4359949231,
-0.5667645931,
-0.4746566713,
-0.5439570546,
0.1198644787,
-0.1601348221,
0.4431577623,
0.6140242815,
0.4601867199,
-0.2015619427,
-0.057268247,
0.0189059768,
-0.0998358503,
0.5477026701,
0.0651509464,
0.1229485273,
-0.5447027087,
1.0842612982,
0.0798176378,
0.067447491,
0.332239747,
0.6275755763,
-0.4660164714,
-0.4608061016,
-0.6894272566,
0.2280667126,
-0.7519202232,
-0.3060410023,
-0.5937480927,
0.0105419708,
-0.4216246605,
-0.557579577,
-0.441493541,
-0.2219090015,
-0.2427860647,
-0.3112989366,
0.1569674462,
0.8113914728,
-0.1138122082,
0.2611102164,
-0.7543053627,
-0.0405038595,
0.4119318128,
0.2951218784,
0.1962706894,
-0.3151519895,
-0.1021076813,
-0.2331294715,
-0.0132287238,
-0.8848648667,
0.4051938951,
0.2158008516,
0.3585990071,
0.8426964879,
-0.0588791706,
0.9873117805,
-0.6033787727,
1.2874914408,
0.1043487787,
-1.4046207666,
0.2758119404,
-0.0810545683,
-0.3497533798,
0.62819767,
0.2510111034,
-0.7168691754,
0.1014202908,
-0.5589216948,
-1.0951582193,
0.4964760542,
-0.0577314906,
0.3162990808,
-0.6049422026,
0.5073412657,
0.1990047097,
0.247160852,
-0.7489324212,
-0.2075934708,
-0.3094609678,
0.0054511698,
-0.0138364313,
-0.502979517,
0.0262949746,
0.0410601459,
0.5979780555,
-0.2890263498,
0.2193183005,
0.1991482526,
-0.0377668701,
0.3198170662,
0.2005376816,
0.3751525283,
0.6977551579,
-0.0266368408,
0.1074100807,
0.1369842291,
-0.6040509343,
-0.0456465222,
-0.1933093518,
-0.1143350676,
0.2294487655,
0.5288556814,
0.6782828569,
0.1032886133,
-1.0978373289,
0.8867664933,
-0.1351894736,
-0.0615453906,
-0.3493514657,
-0.1293533593,
-0.160027191,
-0.1331116408,
0.1668364108,
-0.1964179575,
0.430853188,
-0.4592423439,
-0.0244660489,
0.8139337897,
-0.4745701551,
-0.1537845731,
0.5616633296,
-0.1174176037,
-0.0520822182,
0.4787239432,
-0.4598129392,
-0.739613831,
0.284480691,
0.5990996361,
1.0727821589,
0.2118963599,
0.2045221925,
0.4069431722,
0.4280939698,
-0.0102905557,
0.2350597233,
-0.2689154744,
-0.7188009024,
-1.0621583462,
-1.0110131502,
-0.3730855882,
0.0121057536,
-0.6527698636,
0.4486868978,
-0.247424528,
-0.1499425024,
-0.008005566,
-0.0509454906,
-0.397515595,
-0.0371070281,
-0.3438441157,
1.0279204845,
-0.7907010317,
0.0156869497,
0.7420226336,
-0.2615329027,
-0.7169829607,
0.1532299817,
-0.0284213796,
-1.1636916399,
0.7934414148,
0.0562226735,
-0.1455732137,
-0.0402892791,
-0.6383991838,
-0.8899981976,
0.7573420405,
0.2210924625,
-0.1343552619,
-0.2988235652,
-0.1765118241,
0.2744646966,
0.2712123096,
0.3219868839,
0.8792766333,
0.5949752331,
0.1199322566,
-0.5999335647,
-0.1658788919,
-0.301759243,
0.1305141151,
0.3775754571,
-0.587087214,
0.5000050068,
0.1340378076,
-0.6025741696,
0.2473271936,
0.4857212901,
0.0882269219,
-0.1042715684,
0.6223054528,
0.7237944603,
0.6694341302,
-0.1434255242,
1.1977990866,
-0.3717672229,
0.2041943669,
0.6536281705,
-0.0323678888,
0.5991461277,
0.5326113105,
-0.1679119319,
0.2034297436,
0.8375456929,
-0.1019134298,
0.330634892,
0.5462604761,
-0.0901800916,
-0.144434005,
-0.3565796018,
0.2079693824,
0.8245703578,
0.6083208323,
-0.2038408667,
-0.1802905053,
-0.1889730841,
0.1609814465,
-0.3233317137,
-0.3745561242,
1.0442897081,
-0.2276988626,
-1.0117720366,
0.4494265616,
0.1782687604,
0.9962878823,
-0.6676899195,
0.2504940629,
-0.14912121,
0.0101397727,
-0.1829772592,
-0.2423593253,
0.3411623538,
0.1222597957,
0.2794529796,
0.0484883562,
0.6639234424,
0.1166878566,
-0.3801676929,
0.1541381031,
0.3637279272,
0.2682492435,
-0.0437033214,
-0.4421765804,
-0.1783360094,
0.0087226629,
-0.2180156857,
0.1138556972,
0.502917707,
0.3109561205,
0.2705577612,
0.6672978997,
0.5079195499,
0.2886185646,
0.1897452325,
0.713214457,
-0.6352294087,
-0.3004313707,
-1.0821937323,
0.4927250147,
-0.1528579295,
-0.5141453147,
0.8735511303,
0.7664412856,
0.8058505058,
-0.0785941705,
0.717912972,
-0.1521112323,
0.2635002732,
-0.716578722,
0.3924175799,
-0.6941068769,
-0.2223581225,
-0.4498451054,
-0.8184202313,
-0.3227772713,
0.7168767452,
-0.0814208165,
-0.1195489615,
0.7154550552,
0.3532570004,
-0.0190027822,
-0.0459413491,
0.1282368749,
-0.048579026,
0.1917713732,
-0.0642958879,
0.7702673674,
-0.1972654164,
0.3778963387,
-0.1040828228,
-0.3022184968,
-0.0637288541,
-1.01115942,
-0.7724961042,
-0.5931028724,
0.1185866818,
-0.6105505228,
-0.2899080515,
0.9765703678,
0.6019293666,
-0.5548430681,
-0.2139021009,
-0.3558577001,
0.2158868462,
-0.3218685985,
-0.2857476175,
0.5573660135,
-0.7554796338,
-1.1553583145,
0.2125404775,
0.2916250527,
-0.0707366019,
-0.3603628576,
0.4036427736,
0.0809229314,
0.468735218,
0.7415807247,
-0.0128464522,
-0.8753695488,
-0.1934380084,
0.206292659,
0.3651879728,
-0.1604396254,
1.2433774471,
-0.4708707035,
0.5828082561,
0.6388812661,
0.882173121,
0.1552278996,
0.1461406797,
0.5581778288,
-0.6527784467,
0.2160824835,
0.4360350966,
0.7026481628,
0.0365403257,
-0.2842846811,
0.4936085045,
0.1488556117,
-0.5449906588,
-0.8075992465,
0.4447378516,
-0.6552545428,
-0.5620701909,
1.0203233957,
0.0600603782,
-0.6045221686,
0.0724105686,
-0.379152149,
0.0651042685,
-0.0890307575,
0.7818712592,
0.904063344,
0.0124573316,
0.3177697062,
-0.2307614833,
0.5077254176,
0.6044254303,
-0.4948163629,
0.2011487484,
0.5463829637,
-0.1188683957,
0.5087546706,
0.487053901,
-0.1933914572,
-0.053166382,
0.1160184667,
-0.0003630046,
0.5623250604,
-0.0022513815,
-0.2153676748,
-0.064105615,
0.2847075462,
-0.1007087976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01273v1
|
NoMAD-Attention: Efficient LLM Inference on CPUs Through Multiply-add-free Attention
| 2024-03-02T17:29:22 | 2024-03-02T17:29:22 |
Tianyi Zhang, Jonah Wonkyu Yi, Bowen Yao, Zhaozhuo Xu, Anshumali Shrivastava
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language model inference on Central Processing Units (CPU) is
challenging due to the vast quantities of expensive Multiply-Add (MAD) matrix
operations in the attention computations. In this paper, we argue that there is
a rare gem in modern CPUs, Single-Instruction-Multiple-Data (SIMD) registers,
which allow for ultra-low-latency lookups in batch. We leverage this unique
capability of CPUs to propose NoMAD-Attention, an efficient attention algorithm
that replaces MAD operations with in-register lookups. Through hardware-aware
algorithmic designs, NoMAD-Attention achieves the computation of attention
scores using repeated fast accesses to SIMD registers despite their highly
limited sizes. Moreover, NoMAD-Attention works with pre-trained attention-based
LLMs without model finetuning. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that
NoMAD-Attention maintains the quality of the original LLMs well, and speeds up
the 4-bit quantized LLaMA-7B-based model by up to 2$\times$ at 16k context
length. Our results are reproducible at
https://github.com/tonyzhang617/nomad-dist.
|
[
-0.2949186862,
-0.6645584106,
0.6446983814,
0.304890126,
-0.297445178,
0.0243404452,
-0.1812058985,
-0.300783962,
0.2166457474,
0.5121369958,
-0.6628203988,
-0.4775595665,
-0.2716020346,
-0.2252132446,
-0.1568549573,
0.7611624599,
0.0577181652,
-0.2780211568,
-0.3674766421,
-0.3068422675,
-0.1790055633,
-0.7180435061,
-0.4663753211,
0.1040339917,
0.5924037099,
0.4821200073,
0.5354992747,
0.7304013371,
0.5715914965,
0.1520357132,
0.0081238281,
0.3683453798,
-0.6308137774,
0.1185193881,
0.3886098564,
-0.489510417,
-0.9562079906,
0.0154771162,
0.7115253806,
0.5279740691,
-0.0934513807,
0.6343755126,
-0.2244800776,
0.5751866102,
-1.1345840693,
-0.049607072,
-0.5158670545,
0.1470189542,
-0.4322319329,
-0.2558217645,
-0.7456288934,
-0.1702486575,
-0.2916500866,
-0.6938635707,
0.303768605,
0.2173981518,
0.4185601771,
0.8836954236,
-0.285782218,
0.2926800847,
-0.6885546446,
1.1542650461,
-0.611769557,
0.6351152062,
0.1893454641,
0.2538346946,
-0.2852003276,
-0.53787148,
-0.4760124385,
-0.0654270425,
0.3227508068,
0.02720109,
-0.2756135166,
0.1156598628,
0.408308655,
0.474773258,
-0.3168174922,
-0.1357091665,
0.1337483674,
0.0514842495,
0.2693471909,
0.2537350655,
0.1185713559,
0.4589313865,
-0.5782140493,
0.1989839971,
-0.891149044,
0.1031681895,
0.1093980595,
0.2420912683,
-0.2208887637,
0.4067749381,
-0.3844696283,
0.9944370985,
0.2756754756,
-0.190494433,
0.0737979859,
-0.2603273094,
-0.6697573662,
0.2335577011,
0.6642306447,
0.1379861832,
0.055230245,
-0.4408459067,
-0.0231122337,
0.241216287,
0.3932496905,
-0.7328486443,
-0.1737053692,
0.2973615527,
-0.3870187104,
-0.1030011028,
-0.4069016278,
-0.5435660481,
-0.2136611342,
0.0132468166,
0.062932618,
-0.0939752162,
-0.1123716086,
0.2513870597,
0.1563596725,
0.4134752452,
0.3864486516,
-0.7791339159,
0.4310400486,
0.515756309,
0.8897163272,
-0.145630911,
-0.1042482629,
-0.9527394772,
0.3088431656,
-0.3547308445,
0.9840376973,
-0.6407541037,
-0.1621506065,
-0.640147686,
-0.265484482,
-0.3054316044,
-0.5559751987,
0.3132136762,
-0.8053453565,
-0.386726737,
-0.076846987,
-0.2361671031,
-0.1798324138,
0.2042981833,
-0.6650028825,
1.1523838043,
-0.0529053025,
-0.8299362659,
-0.2058678716,
-0.7646741867,
-0.5622152686,
-0.1378077418,
0.0652876943,
-0.3649718463,
0.3961116374,
0.2353246659,
0.2908498645,
-0.4997392297,
-0.1079527363,
-0.6817477942,
-0.4531515837,
0.3148588538,
-0.5395098329,
0.8101958632,
0.1655431539,
-0.279760927,
0.2320282608,
-0.7235803604,
0.0858873948,
-0.0442257077,
-0.4069573581,
-0.1476180702,
-0.1347005963,
-0.00744216,
0.1998516619,
0.4416743219,
-0.6281862259,
0.2798677683,
-0.2342513353,
0.1210213602,
0.6713228822,
-0.2298135161,
0.4732106328,
-0.0969397277,
0.6461566687,
-0.1044191197,
0.3697482049,
-0.2278018892,
-0.3171001077,
-0.9295960069,
-0.8145847917,
0.2432775646,
0.4596647024,
-0.5493046045,
-0.1354535818,
-0.106150642,
-0.400999099,
-0.9140763283,
0.2307404578,
0.5531045198,
0.4766931534,
0.3200401962,
-0.267763406,
-0.4091121852,
-0.7900093198,
-0.3154895902,
0.210349381,
-0.0402558856,
0.4560311139,
-0.2214541286,
-0.313098222,
0.5466572642,
-0.5659644604,
-0.1430689394,
-0.1396466643,
-0.2711821795,
0.1012654677,
0.1564766318,
0.2595291436,
-0.2105033994,
-0.415404886,
0.0970016345,
-0.7569692135,
-0.2156376094,
-0.0689499602,
-0.3706027567,
0.1109649166,
0.5349935889,
-0.7387648225,
0.3040650785,
0.5261639357,
0.0760077238,
0.3872939646,
-0.2182803154,
-0.1416153014,
-0.6654562354,
0.0905955061,
-0.2390951514,
-0.4441143572,
-0.7652826309,
0.1211135238,
0.2885031402,
0.125575766,
-0.6051598191,
0.6981115937,
-0.6511663198,
-0.3989126682,
-0.2791348398,
0.058368288,
-0.0085585425,
0.765286088,
-0.339746356,
0.8852570057,
0.5892966986,
-0.7119547725,
0.2688366175,
0.0299170539,
-0.0972465947,
0.5828958154,
-0.3386039436,
0.5595618486,
-0.1000409424,
0.1124441996,
-1.2396599054,
-0.0943613723,
0.1070983708,
-0.2701491714,
0.3393373787,
0.0696463138,
-0.4412416816,
-0.1910977662,
-0.4359223545,
0.7851797342,
0.2391031384,
-0.5873171687,
0.5713344216,
0.5829179883,
0.0780067444,
-0.6849316955,
-0.4880621433,
-0.0140837086,
0.0501115173,
-0.2445854992,
-0.0450409018,
-0.2260859907,
-0.2191433609,
-0.0357567146,
-0.4812189341,
-0.2175766677,
0.3079233468,
0.4089457393,
0.4346879721,
-0.4729630351,
0.1066404283,
-0.0236322042,
-0.1973475367,
-0.2352175266,
-0.3322737813,
0.5505604744,
-0.0569122173,
-0.3030005395,
-0.7353602052,
0.2383635044,
1.0035126209,
-0.4235890806,
0.4185403883,
0.310003221,
-0.205199182,
-0.2582012415,
-0.7085403204,
-0.0339363739,
-0.4091111124,
0.0681985542,
-0.2405987233,
-0.8978567123,
0.3058589101,
-0.1543959379,
0.0852283984,
0.3407880366,
0.696790278,
-0.1030411422,
0.8541224003,
0.6875239611,
-0.2101849616,
0.6030970812,
0.0084232194,
0.3034093082,
-1.3324047327,
-0.0458307229,
-0.2645928264,
-0.6000084877,
-0.2678793073,
-0.8831794262,
0.2909045815,
-0.2504199147,
-0.159396708,
-0.0173183475,
-0.4161851108,
0.5530191064,
0.5659366846,
0.0835671946,
0.3324186504,
-0.0555585474,
0.0660252422,
0.2034069151,
-0.8601769805,
-0.2909094393,
1.2397267818,
-0.0550803728,
0.9115177393,
-0.1677793264,
0.4635476768,
0.084626399,
0.5643250942,
-0.7609238029,
0.5766832829,
-0.088278465,
-0.4956607223,
-0.0857650116,
-0.3113952577,
-0.7398430705,
0.333455056,
0.3082365096,
-0.5671073794,
0.1424192041,
0.3089748919,
-0.9360688925,
0.4555204511,
-0.6460143328,
0.7994099259,
-0.084399648,
-0.4440758228,
-0.2173293382,
-0.6051889658,
0.58212924,
-0.1181253046,
0.1299167275,
-0.4374965131,
-0.2977639139,
0.5619361401,
-0.2644232512,
0.8895487785,
-0.0443591699,
-0.0254325736,
0.276437372,
-0.0170885641,
0.4301539361,
-0.1717246473,
-0.0764160231,
0.1800736636,
-0.2727224529,
-0.5558146834,
-0.345236212,
1.0606834888,
-0.7085760832,
-0.3730026186,
-0.1403893977,
-0.901830554,
-0.1599759161,
0.2706183791,
-0.1864227355,
0.335884124,
-0.1767674536,
-0.0961156264,
0.9466480613,
-0.1274394691,
0.4415289164,
0.5033999681,
0.0956031829,
-0.2819156945,
0.878195405,
0.14787893,
0.3841990829,
0.4325689077,
-0.2274566293,
-0.1484817863,
-0.1949354708,
-0.6929241419,
0.3463374376,
-0.3191596866,
-0.3321754634,
-1.0309239626,
0.1323814243,
-0.144387126,
-0.0997657925,
-0.7564954162,
-0.5602891445,
-0.3594233692,
0.1371497214,
0.3773248494,
0.4995241761,
0.1979514509,
0.7257710099,
-0.4815718532,
0.8391007185,
0.356918484,
0.5026755929,
0.3412630558,
-0.4542202652,
-0.3951855004,
-0.1122847125,
-0.4667301774,
-0.637283504,
0.2528757751,
0.11197602,
0.5453105569,
0.590523839,
0.2969096303,
0.8747928143,
-0.5910440087,
0.3020367324,
-0.0499954671,
-0.9395106435,
0.1555179209,
-0.1464251131,
0.5725890398,
0.4900800586,
-0.0336087085,
-0.5444192886,
-0.5038853884,
-0.6145183444,
-0.8031856418,
0.9698751569,
-0.0664135665,
-0.0668910071,
-0.0329388902,
0.3996606469,
-0.091291137,
0.6107198,
-0.2241305262,
-0.5058583021,
0.2302205563,
-0.0957227871,
0.0215093065,
-0.3652751744,
0.0708219558,
-0.1229339465,
0.5194833875,
-0.0213419721,
0.5719620585,
0.201917842,
-0.1958996952,
-0.2434986979,
0.1394293606,
0.6529220939,
0.2126405984,
-0.3011695147,
0.6058887243,
0.3353799284,
-0.4768346548,
0.22668989,
-0.1981026828,
0.0015799936,
-0.0961846113,
0.0849747211,
0.8597401977,
0.4390845299,
-0.5095710754,
0.2804669738,
-0.3383565545,
0.2599294782,
0.0862782672,
0.1132533476,
0.3464529812,
0.3317916989,
0.095561415,
0.2846252322,
0.2026261687,
-0.1351893246,
0.0205172803,
0.7082663774,
-0.445371598,
-0.4534736574,
0.9292933941,
-0.0190979932,
-0.2967522442,
0.5687040091,
-0.1789553612,
-0.1045354679,
0.7592046857,
0.6217774749,
1.1183037758,
-0.5941739082,
-0.1988967955,
0.0122309979,
0.4311164618,
-0.0354082361,
0.4971855283,
-0.3857682049,
-0.4297575653,
-0.6967722178,
-0.5336271524,
-0.5825811028,
-0.0157623943,
-0.6369847059,
0.0102392109,
-0.8527781367,
-0.2137416601,
0.0224253926,
-0.1616231501,
-0.7240031362,
-0.0262782648,
0.3437980711,
0.7260565162,
-0.5049251914,
1.0687696934,
0.4930394888,
0.2790578008,
-0.4271238446,
-0.0373929366,
-0.1096691638,
-0.7950912118,
0.2744879425,
0.4024515748,
-0.6352691054,
0.3601199985,
-0.5121938586,
-0.8558946848,
0.852889955,
0.8852840066,
-0.6564241648,
0.2890377045,
-0.297091186,
0.262840569,
-0.3370061815,
0.2952461839,
0.5683968067,
0.3182828426,
0.0316756889,
-0.7271317244,
-0.0608191118,
-0.1918718219,
-0.2877420485,
0.4678603113,
-1.025673151,
1.0284360647,
-0.6867336035,
-0.3506819308,
-0.2237712592,
0.5147723556,
0.2048926204,
0.4862942994,
0.1600182205,
0.7567284703,
0.9935972691,
0.2269092202,
1.3659726381,
-0.4023343921,
0.3585813642,
1.22488904,
-0.4880279601,
0.9564010501,
0.6941110492,
-0.1635889262,
0.3276442587,
0.5461515784,
0.4790476859,
0.6835454106,
0.1475830078,
-0.595202148,
-0.6020929813,
-0.290343076,
-0.1861524135,
0.1868180335,
0.1769876331,
-0.0030729512,
-0.2952918708,
-0.2737611234,
0.0210464057,
-0.5315877199,
-0.3974366188,
0.7838055491,
0.0975940004,
-0.2579493225,
0.9090075493,
-0.0901198536,
0.4224137068,
-0.3461109996,
0.0955603123,
-0.3399273753,
0.4113428593,
-0.0142476894,
0.0211761314,
0.1562495083,
-0.0414322577,
-0.7032687664,
-0.0312981606,
0.4697625041,
-0.281439811,
-0.6490384936,
0.2207036316,
0.4835398197,
0.3286114335,
-0.4102447033,
-0.2253252864,
0.3038074672,
-0.030371476,
-0.3850522637,
0.580065906,
0.4582308531,
-0.270935148,
0.7283546329,
0.8939353228,
-0.0538396873,
0.3301554322,
-0.2699659765,
1.0235728025,
-0.6572195292,
-0.4444085062,
-1.154602766,
0.1061873958,
0.2290365845,
-0.0582665503,
0.8022173047,
0.6341947317,
0.5640645623,
-0.1855240017,
0.7925087214,
0.4601798356,
0.1343239695,
-0.1063337848,
0.4895041883,
-0.5912281275,
0.0661875457,
0.0484111533,
-0.6703724265,
-0.6309258938,
0.6207845211,
-0.4649726152,
-0.3118979037,
0.5596036911,
0.7632697225,
-0.4279375374,
-0.3076556623,
0.5066267848,
0.2924007475,
0.0043778643,
0.8777812123,
0.5902311802,
-0.376507163,
0.3305528164,
0.0254140012,
-0.2825784385,
-0.5383535624,
-0.7811959386,
-0.8568148613,
0.1571300775,
-0.2398988605,
0.0473307967,
-0.0062955641,
0.7573251724,
0.6134055853,
-0.7241721153,
-0.3511784375,
0.3269444406,
0.4241304398,
-0.4004409015,
-0.0978075042,
0.462536633,
-0.4846630394,
-0.6776528955,
0.587839663,
0.926566124,
-0.1625696719,
-0.1178678647,
0.0210985113,
-0.2243466377,
0.3527866304,
0.7154807448,
0.235757485,
-0.6212813854,
0.2156172097,
0.3100091517,
-0.2786552608,
0.3139708042,
0.7823749781,
-0.7782591581,
0.5356906652,
0.2461646944,
0.860247016,
0.5781048536,
-0.001895379,
0.2172102779,
-0.7286378741,
0.4724731743,
-0.0702938288,
0.0576687157,
0.3425409794,
-0.4597378373,
0.1450867057,
0.1501139402,
-0.5019213557,
-0.919521153,
0.207155183,
-1.1207482815,
0.1463801116,
0.9879495502,
-0.1429753304,
-0.8402047157,
-0.1895634234,
-0.3956418037,
0.3052748442,
-0.5363535285,
0.6753158569,
0.3419720232,
-0.3904025257,
-0.1776793301,
-1.0152927637,
0.3063875139,
0.483677268,
-0.7157863379,
0.6623463035,
0.3416005671,
0.1444673091,
0.0135906115,
1.0064059496,
0.1351753324,
0.3518412709,
-0.0727125332,
0.515719533,
-0.1922273934,
-0.5081355572,
-0.3480451405,
0.3484211266,
0.1306900978,
-0.7218223214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01270v1
|
A comprehensive cross-language framework for harmful content detection with the aid of sentiment analysis
| 2024-03-02T17:13:47 | 2024-03-02T17:13:47 |
Mohammad Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's digital world, social media plays a significant role in
facilitating communication and content sharing. However, the exponential rise
in user-generated content has led to challenges in maintaining a respectful
online environment. In some cases, users have taken advantage of anonymity in
order to use harmful language, which can negatively affect the user experience
and pose serious social problems. Recognizing the limitations of manual
moderation, automatic detection systems have been developed to tackle this
problem. Nevertheless, several obstacles persist, including the absence of a
universal definition for harmful language, inadequate datasets across
languages, the need for detailed annotation guideline, and most importantly, a
comprehensive framework. This study aims to address these challenges by
introducing, for the first time, a detailed framework adaptable to any
language. This framework encompasses various aspects of harmful language
detection. A key component of the framework is the development of a general and
detailed annotation guideline. Additionally, the integration of sentiment
analysis represents a novel approach to enhancing harmful language detection.
Also, a definition of harmful language based on the review of different related
concepts is presented. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
framework, its implementation in a challenging low-resource language is
conducted. We collected a Persian dataset and applied the annotation guideline
for harmful detection and sentiment analysis. Next, we present baseline
experiments utilizing machine and deep learning methods to set benchmarks.
Results prove the framework's high performance, achieving an accuracy of 99.4%
in offensive language detection and 66.2% in sentiment analysis.
|
[
-0.3315401673,
-1.0082749128,
0.1422485113,
0.3494083285,
-0.474206835,
0.1106454059,
-0.3272764087,
-0.5048027635,
0.0445020907,
0.5526558161,
-0.4071828127,
-0.9808692336,
-0.7885124683,
0.0737378001,
-0.5207217932,
1.0751562119,
0.1016656831,
-0.0341606587,
0.1151401922,
-0.2758892179,
-0.2525919974,
-0.426777631,
-0.7814128399,
0.2524342239,
0.387915194,
0.2934217751,
0.6328594089,
0.3423698246,
0.6224248409,
0.3104496002,
-0.0684844032,
0.0242752526,
-0.3149307668,
0.3052363098,
-0.4697442055,
-0.1401200593,
-0.2898150682,
-0.3870992959,
0.3630157113,
0.3653866947,
0.0773729607,
0.1176656187,
0.1051485315,
0.5635207295,
-0.8115709424,
0.0597468205,
-0.4343947172,
0.2242662609,
-0.4744179845,
-0.2098620385,
-0.1126146913,
-0.3870471716,
-0.2968071401,
-0.4428490102,
-0.3250865936,
-0.2114024609,
0.5196037292,
0.2403346002,
-0.4319350123,
-0.5373635888,
-0.6313323975,
0.9568628669,
-0.7426691055,
0.3107966483,
0.4151180685,
0.3271551728,
0.0254619773,
-0.3488060534,
-0.6471886039,
0.0338124894,
-0.0368363261,
-0.1366159767,
-0.4963388145,
-0.1740128249,
0.0573404841,
0.2190411687,
-0.6758306623,
-0.0122607695,
-0.1093552336,
-0.4235742986,
0.8113025427,
0.0271269605,
0.7491010427,
-0.4929267764,
-0.404296726,
0.1177369282,
-0.3962824941,
-0.1540438831,
0.6876507998,
0.4321482182,
-0.2449777424,
0.1902935505,
-0.3295190036,
0.150216043,
-0.1085466892,
0.030741144,
0.44215554,
-0.3104083836,
-0.0025964745,
-0.0682876483,
1.1796928644,
0.5418329835,
0.4830465317,
-0.0011088232,
-0.1969261914,
0.3880035281,
0.1774432808,
-0.7364705801,
-0.1267336458,
0.02461344,
-0.419634074,
-0.7121489048,
-0.0461469181,
-0.9282120466,
-0.9565554857,
0.1230994761,
0.2090747803,
-0.2859057188,
-0.6984426975,
0.1481624544,
0.1446965635,
0.1535041481,
0.0930876508,
-0.4772883654,
0.2970557809,
0.5354902148,
0.6176732779,
-0.3492291868,
0.261329174,
-0.442759037,
0.0669882149,
-0.1498368084,
0.7931216955,
-0.6609914303,
-0.3506045341,
0.2753408253,
0.066300571,
0.344457984,
-0.4770905077,
1.1167446375,
-0.3936774135,
0.2205632776,
-0.3464673162,
-0.142171815,
-0.5837455988,
0.3981571198,
-0.5767316818,
0.9015766382,
0.0124304593,
-1.1539970636,
0.213147074,
-0.5305165648,
-0.891253233,
0.2691116333,
-0.0204546507,
-0.5269221067,
-0.2077531219,
0.0320891961,
0.542499423,
-0.1936503053,
0.3496543765,
-0.4884619713,
-0.3434079289,
0.2350173742,
-0.4965065122,
1.079862237,
0.4851375818,
-0.6647789478,
0.2997051179,
-0.4612231255,
-0.0819180608,
0.1769533902,
-0.155555293,
-0.572892189,
0.0557107553,
0.4013626575,
0.4037834704,
0.0980027542,
-0.6379063129,
-0.5459834337,
-0.2983868718,
0.1305353343,
0.6765539646,
0.324534446,
0.2876125872,
-0.0984301865,
0.7201839089,
0.1627019495,
0.4434368312,
0.0066492204,
-0.1916495413,
-0.542370677,
-0.0757256225,
-0.1637452841,
0.7941558957,
-0.6896273494,
0.7024764419,
-0.1485621035,
-0.3168748617,
-0.212119326,
0.4899194241,
0.5124657154,
0.2714861631,
0.2858921289,
-0.5609361529,
-0.7744944692,
-0.8227885962,
-0.4906142652,
-0.326350987,
0.1685079187,
0.1921255291,
0.2234154493,
-0.4245732725,
0.3993898034,
-0.1402367353,
-0.6972491145,
-0.3028591275,
-0.0286750384,
-0.0296601411,
0.409553498,
0.6604537964,
-1.0234993696,
-0.8707438707,
0.0170544665,
-0.9905341864,
-0.4473827481,
0.1647687703,
-0.317889452,
0.1210955605,
0.346147716,
0.0459780954,
0.3584059179,
0.549441874,
-0.4310593605,
0.2869413495,
0.4197326005,
0.276350826,
-0.9760116935,
0.0867391825,
0.4359043241,
-0.3162711263,
-0.7665864825,
0.1013753712,
-0.1750529557,
0.1076928452,
-0.6975267529,
0.4726048112,
0.0407565273,
0.6311705709,
-0.3775525391,
0.0537836663,
-0.0984577835,
0.3628875911,
0.0658154935,
0.4924273193,
0.5578265786,
-0.3862470388,
0.2906904519,
0.0654008538,
-0.0837278962,
0.7286166549,
-0.3617425263,
-0.1190449446,
-0.2015415728,
-0.0962361023,
-0.6956446171,
-0.0084464327,
0.8689197302,
-0.5947992206,
0.0676367953,
-0.1110028699,
-0.5912845135,
0.0114124557,
-0.7082132697,
0.3349766135,
0.2623097301,
-0.2109832317,
0.6050313711,
0.8320257068,
-0.2466326952,
-0.6451686025,
-0.6494776607,
0.2194092125,
-0.4900608659,
-0.5387619138,
-0.081744574,
-0.0784383565,
-0.4225109816,
0.1280304641,
0.0078644436,
-0.1914925873,
0.3882623911,
0.3981220424,
-0.1059964001,
0.042876441,
0.0030291276,
0.240779236,
-0.1445268542,
0.4075108171,
0.1087798029,
0.4728296697,
-0.2460559905,
-0.180517301,
-0.5122532845,
0.5832784176,
0.3910751045,
-0.3451457322,
0.3932747841,
1.0090810061,
-0.5075093508,
-0.2536759973,
-0.3712255955,
0.1271646768,
-0.5224128962,
0.3904134929,
0.0914867893,
-0.7538797855,
0.4014886022,
0.0297767948,
-0.117082648,
0.3374430835,
0.5068103075,
0.0537481382,
1.1295744181,
0.6776343584,
-0.4191453755,
0.5430673957,
0.0203560796,
0.3905752003,
-0.4499590993,
-0.0293414276,
-0.4501652122,
0.0940867737,
-0.7147666812,
-0.3471373916,
0.2508859634,
-0.0581876673,
-0.3420628309,
0.2000251412,
-0.3052111864,
0.4119259119,
0.1769789308,
0.0613990612,
0.3128420115,
0.0703978837,
-0.0579162836,
-0.0355580859,
-0.2580038607,
-0.8991217017,
0.7642269731,
0.4219834208,
0.728718996,
0.3897018731,
0.5517858267,
0.8581122756,
0.3684094548,
-0.725143075,
0.613587141,
-0.4074772596,
-0.8653818965,
-0.0876261964,
-0.3238020539,
-0.4568923116,
0.1838305444,
-0.3381947875,
-0.6422262788,
0.1293409169,
0.0818128288,
-0.1362479329,
0.4839422107,
-0.4403640926,
0.8491251469,
-0.3978414536,
-0.700284183,
-0.2579250634,
-0.5424381495,
0.4961305261,
-0.1546324939,
0.8216596842,
-0.3412274122,
-0.0366219655,
0.5656124949,
0.0889318064,
1.175008297,
-0.442229867,
-0.2749134004,
0.3774735332,
0.3562887013,
0.1076106057,
0.1008453369,
-0.1882733405,
0.3039241433,
-0.1490540355,
-0.2120850235,
-0.1144087613,
0.7036469579,
-0.3622396886,
-0.2710526288,
-0.3863280714,
-0.2056654096,
-0.1375635117,
0.4671184719,
-0.084303923,
0.0578004904,
-0.4143157601,
0.0628464818,
0.7036095262,
-0.6657768488,
0.2285369039,
0.3483405709,
-0.2572970986,
-0.315989852,
1.1881184578,
-0.2735930383,
-0.0572079793,
0.111680299,
0.2928294241,
-0.2805156112,
-0.5728758574,
-0.4708197415,
0.012825557,
-0.8300433755,
-0.3417075872,
-0.7246003151,
0.0044157328,
-0.4100034833,
0.0358124487,
-0.1035965756,
-0.053376615,
-0.0155851506,
-0.0320705436,
-0.0040542246,
0.5616958737,
-0.2742255032,
0.1611636132,
-0.9463171959,
0.2851006985,
-0.0064569847,
0.4397933483,
-0.0044838684,
-0.2161435336,
-0.1502714604,
0.0834025815,
-0.2404767424,
-0.9459724426,
0.3464749753,
0.1412475705,
0.5506855249,
0.7844521403,
0.4982641935,
0.1747943312,
-0.1061682478,
0.5475711823,
0.0528821126,
-0.8759011626,
0.5891726613,
-0.4698084295,
-0.1109247208,
0.6512219906,
0.6612432599,
-0.8897801042,
-0.6851988435,
-0.2624927163,
-0.8567361832,
0.3941490352,
0.1490140408,
0.6065022945,
-0.336730063,
0.0181406084,
0.1515499055,
0.1957569569,
-0.8618562222,
-0.1710603833,
-0.2913814187,
-0.3953348398,
0.2107560784,
-0.208075583,
-0.030620195,
-0.1135862544,
0.948225975,
-0.0303184297,
-0.0240119863,
-0.1344224513,
-0.5375285149,
-0.4118866324,
0.3880572915,
0.0565997809,
0.2209167033,
0.0916686654,
0.2211711258,
0.0563253239,
-0.5574968457,
-0.0631382465,
0.0143009294,
-0.4445951879,
-0.1538241357,
0.3860608637,
0.4071916342,
0.1027709767,
-0.8532385826,
0.9160860777,
-0.1672473699,
0.1429016739,
-0.4455626011,
0.1556440145,
-0.1337503046,
0.1384495348,
0.2792207897,
-0.1669235528,
0.5348724723,
-0.4696670473,
0.3809895813,
0.5259520411,
-0.7744442821,
-0.3679536879,
0.4547046721,
0.3926029205,
0.0139179472,
0.0257357955,
-0.5212714672,
-0.9646896124,
0.3198637664,
0.2383784801,
0.922528863,
-0.2122149915,
0.4750834107,
0.4381621778,
0.3839325011,
0.3891994357,
0.5527365208,
-0.1713077426,
-0.8529280424,
-0.2924775481,
-0.8630341887,
-0.0928261355,
-0.0113446666,
-0.6540850997,
0.1660764068,
-0.8299853802,
-0.0582501292,
-0.0111986939,
0.2035359293,
-0.336686939,
0.3687660694,
0.4384155273,
0.5665410161,
-1.2702852488,
0.5138271451,
0.8256953955,
-0.5216192007,
-0.4281444848,
0.1077959836,
0.4377927184,
-0.6108430624,
0.3486892283,
0.2174867988,
-0.4359422326,
-0.1988853663,
-0.445522517,
-0.2581836879,
0.498734206,
0.0488729812,
-0.2540608943,
0.4379891157,
0.3404346406,
0.7367251515,
-0.1000136212,
-0.0854355171,
0.3768812418,
0.5447983146,
-0.0781103373,
-0.5183867216,
0.5177677274,
-0.5569656491,
-0.1465983838,
0.2596466839,
-0.4802966118,
0.5110991597,
0.1532705724,
-0.5842341185,
-0.0455877222,
0.3239850402,
-0.1994566023,
0.2722605467,
0.7364068627,
0.4674064517,
0.3204302788,
0.0808702931,
0.6244705319,
-0.3148104548,
0.2459371984,
0.800337851,
-0.1806067079,
0.7071682811,
0.1854425073,
-0.030881349,
0.6622906327,
0.2761642933,
-0.0150745949,
0.5118663311,
0.2474576831,
-0.6342557669,
-0.4013084471,
-0.6930000782,
-0.1885050386,
0.4691364467,
0.5401641726,
-0.5361296535,
-0.3369850218,
0.1372165531,
0.2957206964,
0.590333581,
-0.3390474319,
0.8941321969,
0.0652660355,
-0.1045169905,
0.1550665498,
0.2832657397,
1.0220785141,
-0.4077729881,
0.064511925,
-0.192454651,
0.193630293,
-0.4515581727,
-0.8134037256,
0.6017837524,
0.27003932,
0.2233814299,
-0.1024813429,
1.2032123804,
-0.2584024966,
-0.4852708876,
0.6284329891,
0.6273685694,
-0.0071770721,
-0.1798902601,
-0.8636937737,
0.3091298342,
-0.0708708987,
-0.0098115904,
0.2163031995,
0.5025762916,
-0.398445189,
0.4510177672,
0.6387339234,
-0.0037567874,
0.0384854451,
0.2809203565,
1.0000312328,
-0.560544908,
-0.5975244045,
-0.7218059897,
0.5280682445,
-0.2990485728,
0.0453060716,
0.8545724154,
0.4774481058,
1.0570954084,
0.3519041538,
1.1046905518,
-0.3305665851,
0.4887266457,
0.0177092589,
0.8929691315,
-0.5965043902,
0.3154576123,
-0.6452250481,
-0.7784992456,
-0.7292495966,
0.7566193938,
-0.1609122604,
-0.0472600646,
0.4454169571,
0.9109856486,
0.0126184812,
0.1668767482,
0.2058095336,
0.2097785622,
0.3505234718,
0.3822317123,
0.8413311839,
-0.3242488503,
0.7752177715,
-0.6698035598,
-0.2020577788,
0.0334590971,
-0.8957064152,
-1.1379504204,
-0.3145020008,
-0.3988290727,
-0.4204043448,
0.2975048423,
0.8212595582,
0.4215610623,
-1.1746698618,
-0.1491080374,
0.1931818724,
0.1539186835,
-0.0218377113,
-0.234386757,
0.1878882349,
-0.0951415822,
-0.649518311,
0.0276113208,
0.321295023,
-0.2247738093,
-0.4572068751,
-0.1157527715,
-0.2766337395,
-0.0554159358,
0.7276457548,
0.3413395584,
-0.3730559647,
-0.465878129,
-0.0505493544,
-0.1565942615,
-0.1705021262,
0.5360572338,
-0.3370022774,
0.4604840577,
0.5281476378,
0.6591832638,
0.0078042368,
-0.1100202575,
0.2451372892,
-0.8659496307,
0.0563342497,
0.4376977086,
0.1967826039,
0.6175060272,
-0.5142011046,
0.4204850197,
0.1905140877,
-0.0359566435,
-0.7174124122,
0.329369843,
-0.8361067772,
-0.3214654624,
1.3046644926,
-0.203460142,
-0.229029119,
-0.5171371102,
-0.3369263709,
0.4755741954,
-0.5571892262,
0.9155769348,
0.4938468933,
0.2192998528,
0.0333411843,
-0.4476673305,
0.4068694711,
0.2342338413,
-0.8217835426,
0.1072254851,
0.5990293622,
0.4309441745,
0.0602495186,
0.5469202995,
-0.463380754,
0.3437581956,
-0.3982486725,
0.0430592373,
-0.0564043038,
-0.0662016124,
-0.4399915934,
0.2417870164,
-0.1326947808,
-0.0217299331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01267v1
|
Dissecting Language Models: Machine Unlearning via Selective Pruning
| 2024-03-02T17:10:44 | 2024-03-02T17:10:44 |
Nicholas Pochinkov, Nandi Schoots
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Understanding and shaping the behaviour of Large Language Models (LLMs) is
increasingly important as applications become more powerful and more frequently
adopted. This paper introduces a machine unlearning method specifically
designed for LLMs. We introduce a selective pruning method for LLMs that
removes neurons based on their relative importance on a targeted capability
compared to overall network performance. This approach is a compute- and
data-efficient method for identifying and removing neurons that enable specific
behaviours. Our findings reveal that both feed-forward and attention neurons in
LLMs are specialized; that is, for specific tasks, certain neurons are more
crucial than others.
|
[
-0.3413219452,
-0.9198458195,
0.3164637983,
-0.0621686503,
-0.3858834803,
0.3608089685,
-0.5195518136,
-0.0101952273,
0.0867620111,
0.66601789,
-0.8410899639,
-0.1356153041,
-0.516602993,
-0.1302693486,
-0.6809720397,
0.8481043577,
0.2197061479,
-0.0122968508,
-0.2942625582,
-0.0549744815,
-0.4339832664,
-0.5478222966,
-0.7358563542,
-0.813421905,
0.8284968138,
0.2660243213,
0.5244680047,
0.7209424973,
0.3364060521,
0.4492797256,
-0.6799116135,
0.2368550301,
-0.8229398727,
0.2167541385,
-0.2533166111,
-0.551333189,
-0.2727923989,
-0.0493056178,
0.8563034534,
0.9906414747,
-0.099380523,
0.0411853641,
0.4481242597,
0.6766661406,
-0.4324644804,
-0.0100823948,
-0.9533008933,
0.1042729318,
-0.2140659988,
-0.1305632591,
-0.6502385139,
0.0765872523,
-0.1273198873,
-0.2428541929,
0.4014842808,
-0.3795216382,
0.6598851085,
0.3154064417,
-0.3460918963,
0.0835370123,
-0.770636797,
1.0128231049,
-0.2471374124,
0.1634581536,
0.3885997832,
0.1170886457,
-0.2121559978,
-0.7718190551,
-0.1907885224,
-0.0139767099,
-0.2418691367,
-0.1315155327,
-0.263300091,
0.2097865492,
0.2823473215,
0.3828898966,
-0.5473787785,
0.3567443192,
-0.6720575094,
-0.2090234458,
0.5039770007,
0.0840600729,
0.4463793337,
0.0658719912,
0.0163785797,
0.2204702944,
-0.9438250065,
-0.1530461609,
0.5730497837,
0.0877089873,
0.5200169086,
0.7079117894,
-0.0623813719,
0.8831291795,
-0.2266355157,
-0.0922295004,
0.1275324076,
0.2017287314,
-0.40332672,
-0.1528460234,
0.728431046,
-0.0092394352,
0.6911996007,
-0.4986609221,
-0.5553653836,
0.0223324727,
0.5034604669,
-0.4797948301,
-0.2881999016,
0.2092947215,
-0.6091888547,
-0.4433597326,
-0.4206850231,
-0.4327131808,
-0.254447639,
-0.4443933666,
0.1966121048,
-0.4605690539,
-0.5282566547,
-0.1530861259,
-0.333142817,
-0.020543851,
0.1086860374,
-0.9779589772,
0.2907402813,
0.7498745322,
0.6616037488,
-0.3566198945,
-0.390653491,
-0.4286011457,
0.1219833717,
-0.295594573,
0.3780964613,
-0.8110562563,
-0.4131966233,
-0.2773943543,
0.361102283,
-0.0832303539,
-1.0112894773,
0.2758665681,
-0.7174901962,
-0.1964456886,
-0.0669654533,
-0.4190109074,
-0.54545331,
0.027488865,
-0.6998673677,
0.6430373192,
0.0897314623,
-0.5077111721,
0.0151003851,
-0.4804440141,
-0.7710599899,
-0.0118059106,
-0.0691790879,
-0.3450394869,
0.4376399815,
0.0617103912,
0.5724867582,
-0.1676953435,
0.620579958,
-0.2992464006,
-0.2634213567,
0.181480214,
-0.6065316796,
0.9862341285,
0.5025802255,
-0.0593470596,
0.4530204535,
-0.7521986365,
-0.0107223205,
0.3316565752,
-0.2638989389,
-0.2650796473,
0.295203954,
-0.3231767118,
0.0814642087,
0.1521070749,
-0.3569492698,
0.2036620826,
-0.6105763912,
1.2707672119,
0.7805310488,
-0.075311631,
0.6190989614,
-0.3533602655,
0.4021121264,
0.1417253017,
0.1258772761,
-0.1113618463,
-0.4192916155,
-0.8320538998,
-0.4826088548,
0.225321129,
0.1889119744,
-0.5255366564,
0.3197677732,
0.1029780284,
-0.4667729139,
-0.6195405126,
0.4709838331,
0.3587089181,
0.3280753195,
0.2452333272,
-0.2120170146,
-0.61423105,
-1.0938003063,
-0.4221853018,
-0.0488776565,
-0.1984289587,
0.0029992396,
0.2979513407,
-0.2228910178,
0.8735855818,
-0.3692616224,
-0.0116425734,
-0.5429952145,
-0.0909304991,
0.2059621811,
0.3100310266,
0.1712224185,
-0.8423016667,
-0.2050651759,
0.0447688214,
-0.7024363875,
0.154663384,
-0.1850769222,
0.2242758572,
-0.2590713203,
0.5765941143,
-0.6905839443,
0.4874873161,
0.4777573347,
0.1936622262,
0.3346599042,
-0.143146351,
-0.3901475668,
-0.5520547032,
0.1249399185,
-0.0409920216,
-0.2377552986,
-0.7382213473,
-0.0142719466,
0.0979693979,
-0.0915916115,
-0.5090253353,
0.524009347,
-0.8301507235,
-0.3490508497,
-0.4581083655,
0.0734131783,
0.0247795656,
0.6331489086,
0.1967048943,
0.5646947026,
0.606803,
-0.7827767134,
0.2930993438,
0.0038786232,
-0.4155417979,
-0.4595300853,
-0.6450222135,
0.1286109239,
-0.220722124,
-0.3340305984,
-1.0177201033,
0.1811229885,
0.0717962012,
-0.3558140993,
0.4938005209,
-0.2893554568,
-0.3573179543,
-0.270088315,
0.1041368246,
0.3666163683,
0.7454331517,
-0.5249772668,
0.4851385653,
0.7478402257,
-0.2476257682,
-0.4142905772,
-0.6297121644,
-0.116346173,
-0.329090178,
-0.3455273509,
0.5498960018,
0.0973009989,
-0.4580841064,
-0.0625620708,
-0.0417558216,
-0.273443222,
0.4040913582,
0.40391922,
-0.0158867408,
-0.0067772577,
0.2244301587,
0.0088257948,
-0.1457703412,
0.0734405816,
0.0767141804,
0.7926359177,
0.3165182471,
-0.4697482884,
-0.4202707112,
0.2371298969,
0.7358973622,
-0.6289004683,
0.5805703998,
0.4916144609,
-0.2476158738,
-0.560882628,
-0.2342290133,
-0.5849574208,
-0.5963938832,
0.6315677166,
-0.3149533272,
-0.8312388659,
0.3883526623,
-0.2639173567,
0.2843264341,
0.1553836912,
0.6473267078,
0.0915317535,
1.2834229469,
0.7361159325,
-0.3709009886,
0.6515259147,
-0.2091640681,
0.3730239868,
-0.9342780709,
-0.2633522749,
-0.4683091938,
-0.4936454594,
-0.3186600506,
-0.2071810812,
-0.0910195261,
0.2076645494,
-0.0197943803,
0.2100290656,
-0.8755844235,
0.6581904888,
0.4638302028,
0.1894538552,
0.1791775227,
0.1936618984,
-0.1612327844,
0.1420890689,
-0.7069032192,
-0.6612607837,
1.0203794241,
0.4656041563,
0.4960800409,
-0.0975622237,
0.4179838896,
-0.1464362592,
0.4877132773,
-0.9891101122,
0.7712828517,
-0.2513309717,
-0.7140130997,
-0.4270311892,
-0.5632151365,
-1.1268709898,
0.4510697126,
0.2125839144,
-0.8717956543,
-0.2851723135,
0.0460966416,
-0.204852283,
0.7078206539,
-0.8709463477,
0.5573483706,
-0.2537733018,
-0.2784007788,
-0.5095606446,
-0.2218393385,
0.4497608542,
-0.0012455152,
0.1187911853,
-0.1881194711,
-0.0335231461,
0.8069707155,
-0.268843174,
1.1736390591,
-0.0516249388,
0.1053071767,
0.4331701994,
0.4305369854,
0.4519568682,
-0.1637634635,
-0.1946103573,
0.1205867156,
-0.3129730523,
-0.2125329971,
-0.3488253355,
0.7703202963,
-0.843695879,
-0.8969409466,
0.0377319194,
-0.5470015407,
-0.2411567569,
0.1925685108,
-0.0608819723,
0.3014028966,
-0.2405115813,
0.1733554006,
0.7468111515,
-0.2511022091,
0.8995246887,
0.4831711948,
-0.2669176459,
-0.1040792167,
1.077047348,
0.2960305214,
0.0957931951,
0.3967113495,
-0.0296746623,
-0.0836469308,
-0.9104382396,
0.0054639746,
0.3669651449,
-0.6217963696,
0.0950186402,
-0.5972607136,
-0.4942873716,
-0.1161437854,
0.0892278627,
-0.315484494,
-0.2925123572,
-0.6986432672,
-0.2318698019,
0.2211761028,
0.9125196934,
0.1713341027,
0.6467460394,
-0.8534246683,
0.2886389196,
0.3653511703,
0.2203799784,
0.1710446477,
-0.6384634376,
0.1483796686,
-0.0000916885,
-0.397154808,
-0.8179979324,
0.8880071044,
0.2204494327,
0.8919845223,
0.7131605744,
-0.1948915422,
0.5770344138,
-0.5810878873,
0.3960445821,
0.3943012655,
-0.7562890649,
0.5312315226,
-0.226818487,
0.2668328881,
0.1985641569,
0.4427027702,
-0.5188325047,
-0.1815939397,
-0.749815762,
-0.8903000951,
0.8124161363,
0.0639026314,
0.0898777246,
-0.0187971424,
0.6043816209,
0.0527011305,
0.3671329916,
-0.5317343473,
-0.2673202753,
0.3267556727,
-0.1156784147,
-0.5272681713,
-0.4286258221,
-0.2476431727,
-0.41593346,
0.4715488255,
0.1457978189,
-0.0110618714,
-0.2480113506,
-0.4504857063,
-0.0659896731,
0.0015893528,
0.2519879341,
0.7934021354,
0.1097356826,
0.1605735868,
0.1647606641,
-0.460776329,
0.1580453813,
-0.6999791265,
-0.2096287459,
-0.0268674456,
0.3687365949,
0.5604307652,
0.0057481807,
-0.6407257915,
0.1752551049,
0.0095499549,
-0.2513908744,
-0.0478742644,
0.3631938994,
0.3035678864,
-0.0250928625,
0.066113092,
0.2089307308,
-0.0952742398,
-0.6044870019,
0.3728434741,
0.3590988517,
-0.7077248096,
-0.5162056684,
0.0595381409,
0.3351902366,
-0.6406812072,
0.8622844219,
-0.0073832404,
-0.3690689504,
0.849003911,
0.5477064848,
0.9344910383,
-0.3513292074,
0.2521804273,
0.1367459893,
0.5487254262,
-0.0573658422,
0.0571050569,
0.0454666279,
-0.8155201674,
-0.7553679347,
-0.6224673986,
0.0199416317,
0.5797266364,
-0.6649162769,
0.0408628844,
-0.7279827595,
-0.2483341694,
0.3432211578,
-0.1095632613,
-0.4059748054,
0.1474538893,
-0.0178374238,
0.7355353236,
-0.7146639228,
1.2818726301,
0.7634137869,
-0.0550328754,
-0.623894453,
-0.3171512485,
0.0989368409,
-0.9393753409,
0.665252924,
0.0962469876,
0.006352697,
0.121335268,
-0.4574501812,
-0.6382101178,
0.5995147228,
0.6242995262,
-1.0524065495,
0.140033409,
-0.1052915901,
0.1245082766,
-0.1145732254,
0.4271772802,
0.5707169771,
0.3755589426,
-0.1669303924,
-0.6488753557,
-0.1552839279,
-0.1851747781,
-0.1995102763,
0.4001816511,
-0.7138841152,
0.9594281316,
-0.1580711454,
-0.1936426759,
-0.202778399,
0.4363660514,
0.0760785863,
-0.0830205306,
0.6252273321,
0.3528677821,
1.0516092777,
-0.0808006525,
0.4897867739,
-0.2406174093,
0.0335497074,
0.9223921299,
-0.3861970901,
0.7088233829,
0.8183444738,
-0.08512225,
-0.0493408591,
0.7450928092,
0.2049215585,
0.6346482038,
0.6109978557,
-0.1503302008,
-0.5431836843,
0.1507586837,
0.1399615109,
0.5288787484,
0.5575128198,
-0.4840441346,
-0.2116633058,
0.0498774201,
0.0000656578,
0.0318334363,
-0.4841882885,
0.9230744839,
0.227215454,
-0.8237451911,
0.632131815,
0.164978534,
0.4076812267,
-0.574930191,
0.0440481454,
-0.1950968355,
0.4423775971,
-0.3114692271,
-0.601715982,
0.5459241867,
0.0210715029,
-0.4031781554,
-0.498478055,
0.807677567,
-0.2407660484,
-0.1946486086,
0.6786717176,
0.5475148559,
0.3239506483,
-0.2704683542,
-0.8190813065,
0.2297682166,
0.5245308876,
-0.6555333138,
0.7906691432,
0.4614591599,
-0.0663375556,
1.0897240639,
0.7361248732,
0.187682122,
-0.2381895632,
0.1815738827,
1.2337474823,
-0.7193927765,
-0.1201870739,
-1.1587052345,
0.4759640098,
-0.0531177483,
-0.2425013632,
0.5655095577,
0.4185681343,
0.6129257679,
0.1628873348,
0.8052162528,
0.3002192974,
0.3774290383,
-0.348228395,
0.9459890723,
-0.5364589691,
0.559874773,
0.3004055619,
-0.7919518948,
-0.1299595535,
0.5837237835,
-0.4805202484,
0.1410782784,
0.5988097191,
1.0948497057,
-0.1040805057,
0.0926182419,
0.6759040356,
0.2838865817,
0.2100936621,
0.2849926949,
1.0751515627,
0.1861888766,
0.6605327129,
-0.2962519825,
-0.2444974631,
-0.0811400265,
-0.6105494499,
-1.1089545488,
-0.3956534564,
-0.3719754815,
0.1192925647,
0.1253981739,
0.3051518798,
0.8748571873,
-0.7698223591,
-0.3710730374,
-0.2530702055,
0.5452756882,
-0.3063392639,
-0.1279946417,
0.2069357485,
-0.5480849147,
-0.5862483978,
0.8116294742,
0.3752641082,
-0.271147728,
-0.4360157549,
0.0820902959,
-0.0960106328,
-0.1393849552,
0.5093865991,
0.2920668721,
-0.6517831087,
0.0634640977,
-0.0833482966,
0.0536731333,
-0.0442414135,
0.9849455357,
-0.7208859324,
0.1215871423,
0.5559313297,
0.3523699939,
0.4179672003,
-0.2980320752,
0.7322694659,
-0.9779423475,
0.4617326558,
0.4913439751,
0.4809074998,
0.1212765127,
-0.1446618438,
0.2057928294,
0.1649729908,
-0.5216330886,
-1.1180999279,
0.278583914,
-0.4865160584,
-0.8802870512,
1.293399334,
-0.2345944047,
-0.8449414372,
-0.2156469524,
-0.1828023344,
0.2801886499,
-0.125780642,
0.3610554338,
0.4752821326,
0.1995116323,
-0.3357814252,
-0.5884198546,
0.3727698922,
0.6849377751,
-0.2908164561,
0.390435189,
0.1867314726,
0.4039489627,
-0.1226138547,
0.4252352715,
-0.1557733417,
-0.2030463815,
-0.1552561969,
0.2648509741,
-0.1619209647,
-0.6913850307,
-0.5354923606,
0.5377138853,
0.2281600386,
-0.2617075443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04783v1
|
AutoDefense: Multi-Agent LLM Defense against Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-03-02T16:52:22 | 2024-03-02T16:52:22 |
Yifan Zeng, Yiran Wu, Xiao Zhang, Huazheng Wang, Qingyun Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Despite extensive pre-training and fine-tuning in moral alignment to prevent
generating harmful information at user request, large language models (LLMs)
remain vulnerable to jailbreak attacks. In this paper, we propose AutoDefense,
a response-filtering based multi-agent defense framework that filters harmful
responses from LLMs. This framework assigns different roles to LLM agents and
employs them to complete the defense task collaboratively. The division in
tasks enhances the overall instruction-following of LLMs and enables the
integration of other defense components as tools. AutoDefense can adapt to
various sizes and kinds of open-source LLMs that serve as agents. Through
conducting extensive experiments on a large scale of harmful and safe prompts,
we validate the effectiveness of the proposed AutoDefense in improving the
robustness against jailbreak attacks, while maintaining the performance at
normal user request. Our code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/XHMY/AutoDefense.
|
[
-0.5810080767,
-0.9083226919,
0.3985454142,
0.1181538403,
-0.0066487784,
0.488104254,
0.0373907611,
-0.5607851148,
0.242719695,
0.7095587254,
-0.5641089082,
-0.5098304152,
-0.5593271255,
0.1897612214,
-0.3842706084,
0.8826703429,
0.1289987713,
-0.1133811474,
0.0715277717,
0.0458550826,
-0.6489607096,
-0.5408728123,
-0.687112093,
-0.0145815499,
0.4008877873,
0.3430604041,
0.5955941677,
0.4468499124,
0.6105141044,
0.3959229589,
0.3204018474,
-0.0628995672,
-0.0369393751,
0.7911636233,
-0.2589505911,
-0.2258670181,
-0.6841837764,
0.0403972752,
0.0077676955,
-0.1927086562,
-0.2650066614,
-0.1454376727,
-0.1372833103,
0.4711814523,
-0.7855221629,
-0.3841555715,
-0.6833794117,
-0.0640701726,
0.0570290796,
0.2872918844,
-0.546715796,
-0.2323986888,
-0.0890298858,
-0.1379399747,
-0.2494399101,
0.1779501289,
0.3829373419,
0.2889543176,
-0.2683182359,
-0.1667703837,
-0.1894735098,
0.3691157997,
-0.7430335879,
0.0603355542,
0.4238560796,
0.2354102433,
-0.5608496666,
-0.2724638581,
-0.464767307,
-0.4711990952,
0.088753365,
0.0100175766,
-0.5486270785,
0.3634831905,
0.0209223758,
0.068078056,
-0.804130733,
0.3080397546,
0.023442518,
-0.3993169367,
0.7263865471,
0.2622027695,
0.6994513869,
-0.0843504146,
-0.5992171764,
-0.1238677725,
-0.6557939053,
0.107937105,
0.5252619386,
0.0358060859,
-0.1475864053,
0.4207330346,
-0.1475620419,
0.6556305885,
0.233969301,
-0.0920663103,
-0.0621054359,
-0.2552898824,
-0.1944860518,
0.0570548587,
0.9571928978,
0.422038734,
0.1862942129,
-0.2898616493,
-0.2918489277,
-0.0231934283,
0.4652540088,
-1.0502882004,
-0.1007002518,
0.3088508844,
-0.2977573872,
-0.7046254277,
0.2656335235,
-0.9321604967,
-0.899520576,
0.2567453384,
0.1661156565,
-0.3531125188,
-0.2603988051,
0.3494678438,
0.073522754,
0.1673178822,
0.0205815118,
-0.616686523,
0.5085315704,
0.4680369496,
0.7303972244,
-0.2865714431,
-0.4213929474,
-0.9654762745,
0.2088427544,
-0.1037756056,
1.0045335293,
-0.2375710905,
-0.5534507036,
-0.4090290666,
0.0405514501,
-0.2566001117,
-0.5059397817,
0.2378611863,
-0.7933283448,
-0.3139550984,
0.2013493031,
-0.407338053,
-0.0360828899,
0.4728471339,
-0.7562631965,
0.5203970671,
0.0189701505,
-0.6029193401,
-0.0221480038,
-0.6157258153,
-0.6033437848,
-0.0575415604,
0.0545402318,
-0.3804065287,
-0.0907886103,
0.3383386433,
0.3083624542,
-0.3631125689,
0.2068334371,
-0.7614107132,
0.0590352155,
0.258243084,
-0.2894543111,
0.74966681,
0.5946040154,
-0.497687757,
0.4340287745,
-0.5036705136,
0.0099016037,
0.2948719859,
-0.1719993949,
-0.381152153,
0.1104907915,
-0.2827070057,
0.2462799102,
0.2444813997,
-0.8327282667,
0.2802351415,
-0.5567779541,
0.3522340357,
0.7509647608,
0.154349789,
0.4263526201,
-0.3539348245,
0.8099409342,
-0.0097479774,
0.5462787747,
-0.2344709486,
-0.3079682291,
-0.0727123469,
-0.5303096771,
-0.3114581406,
0.9123945236,
-0.650708735,
0.5763166547,
0.366034627,
-0.3761935532,
-0.3760409653,
0.4476744235,
0.3179651201,
0.3231263757,
0.4031640887,
-0.4447087944,
-0.5718696713,
-0.7196205258,
-0.3094853461,
-0.4373755157,
0.2614915073,
-0.0264029037,
0.3020198345,
-0.4828618467,
0.8933348656,
-0.5347394943,
-0.1247200817,
-0.2855058014,
-0.219506368,
-0.0099672666,
0.3495852351,
0.9719132185,
-0.2924792171,
-0.559689641,
-0.436203301,
-0.6891493201,
-0.5548537374,
0.0838092491,
-0.1048628092,
0.1276953965,
0.7502761483,
-0.6423586011,
0.397282958,
0.3463062048,
-0.8116357327,
0.6846390367,
-0.1202758774,
0.0704828352,
-1.1549019814,
-0.4373655617,
-0.1232983097,
-0.4592353404,
-0.6641581059,
0.2675999105,
-0.0458463281,
0.0144922193,
-0.4021398723,
0.6205732226,
-0.2081731856,
0.1662312448,
-0.7760763168,
0.2058523297,
0.1624495685,
-0.0504535995,
-0.352635771,
1.0040465593,
0.6165277958,
-0.3373894691,
0.9021853209,
0.1478486955,
-0.1660775095,
0.6994466186,
-0.7171257138,
0.2583297193,
-0.0566487312,
0.3800566494,
-0.9561550617,
-0.0993360654,
0.4596619606,
-0.3544878662,
0.0703874156,
-0.2499199808,
-0.5313827991,
-0.5156665444,
-0.6720199585,
0.1201172397,
0.1109972671,
-0.5690951943,
0.5974987149,
0.5337041616,
-0.3312345743,
-0.5848209858,
-0.3917638958,
0.5497823954,
-0.5328975916,
-0.7833858728,
0.0011187663,
-0.5272695422,
-0.536483705,
-0.1754755974,
0.0662441105,
-0.1473165005,
0.6524864435,
0.4115043283,
0.490272671,
-0.0128388274,
-0.166623801,
-0.1404968947,
0.0153512228,
0.5155828595,
-0.3045854568,
0.5671308637,
-0.1998183131,
-0.4267327189,
-0.2378608882,
0.5401124358,
0.9609559178,
-0.4257517755,
0.7392859459,
0.4956635833,
0.0443728603,
-0.273422271,
-0.5707250237,
-0.4049985111,
-0.5604791641,
0.3552163541,
-0.3146097362,
-0.9880101681,
0.4191133082,
0.1499108523,
0.0512743667,
0.0390248299,
0.5849395394,
0.0131422859,
0.8697013259,
0.3686202466,
-0.7794862986,
0.6294685602,
0.0505507737,
0.0907813609,
-0.5624654889,
-0.0414214619,
-0.455496937,
0.1394161582,
-0.3700736761,
0.1113112867,
0.1798677295,
-0.1514781266,
-0.4768174291,
0.6413677335,
-0.4168461263,
0.5466504097,
0.3193547726,
0.0642169043,
0.1515005231,
-0.1948551834,
-0.1920446455,
0.5277420878,
-0.3538458943,
-0.4823491275,
0.9848030806,
0.4530827403,
1.2226407528,
0.4986277521,
0.9060971141,
0.6901554465,
0.2819619775,
-0.6668205857,
0.6962186694,
-0.0401355438,
-0.786215961,
-0.184253931,
-0.217370972,
-0.8363848925,
0.5369427204,
0.0255381875,
-0.8417142034,
-0.0013696245,
0.0003367834,
-0.6289412975,
0.4195636809,
-0.7278827429,
0.722325325,
-0.5314646363,
-0.3578381836,
-0.3645007908,
-0.6043665409,
0.3582923412,
-0.2774117291,
0.4404402971,
-0.3467321396,
0.2461937517,
0.503031075,
-0.6987816095,
1.0317182541,
-0.4764565527,
-0.231268838,
0.6001064777,
0.3313440681,
0.673073113,
0.430634439,
-0.011103821,
-0.4074311256,
0.0486723371,
-0.163744539,
-0.3214898109,
0.704756856,
-0.6853587031,
-1.0079964399,
-0.3498811126,
-0.6353076696,
0.0677214563,
0.2383478582,
-0.0623473674,
0.0491134599,
-0.191821456,
-0.0960951522,
0.754003942,
-0.3247956932,
0.8570750356,
0.9281301498,
-0.2643842995,
-0.7264520526,
0.4993917048,
-0.3023968041,
0.2031994015,
-0.0744772404,
0.1407194287,
-0.2087774873,
-0.5912228227,
-0.4490641057,
-0.1341778636,
-0.4408552051,
-0.6833877563,
-0.5848225355,
-0.2110182792,
-0.6764134169,
0.0250243247,
-0.2776335478,
-0.1116311848,
0.1105424538,
-0.1791001707,
0.6307513714,
0.6267709732,
-0.2920082808,
0.4874872565,
-0.8418465257,
0.5499840379,
0.3045956492,
0.2220311612,
-0.1502426118,
-0.5219231844,
-0.1994167715,
-0.1458225697,
-0.4551931918,
-1.1104148626,
0.3375841081,
0.0189426728,
0.7103609443,
0.3486723304,
0.6300590038,
0.1970433742,
-0.4884659648,
0.3553362191,
0.1546527743,
-0.8133912683,
0.6069752574,
-0.1319942474,
0.1646953374,
0.7211928368,
-0.1997878253,
-0.1453740299,
-0.7729884386,
-0.1671341956,
-0.8061258197,
0.5616034865,
-0.01153439,
0.1833470166,
-0.1681883186,
0.2365607172,
-0.2537279427,
0.1352066249,
-0.7722609639,
-0.1807186157,
-0.3537155092,
-0.1714956909,
0.2635540962,
-0.1886493117,
-0.1436377317,
-0.0750928596,
0.6607186198,
0.1049743667,
-0.0259447657,
0.2077196091,
-0.4702002108,
0.055146154,
0.6021332741,
0.5959489346,
-0.1264671981,
-0.0884063989,
0.2848845124,
0.1584910452,
-0.9260457158,
0.8268507719,
0.2697015405,
-0.0530694872,
-0.506098628,
0.2802107036,
0.5544592142,
-0.2814538181,
-0.714169085,
0.582916081,
-0.2152882069,
0.1410208791,
-0.3084177971,
0.5543263555,
-0.2415193617,
0.4432761371,
0.235161677,
-0.0877960622,
0.1108976901,
-0.3137896359,
0.4678195119,
0.4777755737,
-0.2165013552,
-0.2354863435,
0.7329778075,
0.1629376858,
-0.1485189795,
0.3680675924,
-0.1536638886,
-0.5850240588,
0.9649450183,
0.6976715922,
1.1568515301,
-0.7768988609,
-0.0085520297,
0.0290383305,
0.7445527315,
0.1530132443,
0.2363673896,
0.0568988733,
-0.8341621757,
-0.3621610999,
-0.4359766543,
-0.2694885135,
0.2894800901,
-0.3813874424,
-0.1467039436,
-0.6731294394,
-0.4544726908,
-0.2548906505,
-0.246286422,
-0.1017091349,
0.0699504539,
0.1889671981,
0.9921987653,
-0.5357030034,
0.9882667065,
0.8298392296,
-0.3106248081,
-0.5161427855,
-0.002601716,
0.3717337847,
-0.5755665898,
0.4539719522,
0.2405610234,
-0.6035208702,
-0.198497355,
-0.5239859223,
-0.7532684207,
0.7491174936,
0.4284600914,
-0.4466309845,
0.2212132961,
0.0414141752,
0.1716849804,
-0.6175601482,
0.1499184221,
0.5582265854,
0.5297101736,
-0.3925205171,
-0.6713912487,
0.1757678688,
-0.2713216245,
-0.2991147339,
0.192031309,
-0.5477384329,
0.4683673978,
-0.3709421158,
0.2375753522,
0.1383320838,
0.3710647523,
0.3560383022,
0.3692896068,
0.7242134809,
0.6073698997,
0.2258973718,
0.1711572856,
0.7882763147,
-0.5566604137,
-0.0205389857,
1.3032875061,
-0.5589805245,
0.4492621124,
0.1829914451,
0.0745598078,
0.5375189781,
0.4319777489,
-0.3098132014,
0.6926981211,
0.4126443565,
-0.5826787353,
-0.0837845877,
0.0459383987,
-0.1716491729,
0.4573893845,
0.2620113194,
-0.1830260009,
-0.4197873771,
0.7207323909,
0.294107765,
0.094143495,
-0.229304105,
1.0078123808,
0.0797993615,
-0.4943531454,
0.3618993759,
0.2585386038,
0.6203519106,
-0.6018072367,
0.4566245675,
-0.2445611358,
0.2100726813,
-0.1946683377,
-0.7583293915,
0.3785764277,
0.3792765737,
-0.3613132536,
-0.0693279505,
0.9942544699,
-0.0762413442,
0.2217434049,
0.947375536,
0.3303586245,
-0.1008884087,
-0.2145144641,
-0.8640366793,
0.1165676489,
-0.130247429,
-0.4783107042,
0.4313689768,
-0.0276089944,
-0.0617215298,
0.7962552905,
0.5695628524,
0.0593519732,
0.2611582875,
0.0713460371,
1.0312774181,
-0.4651857615,
-0.4818099439,
-1.3363468647,
0.1367079616,
-0.1922528744,
0.356366694,
0.731108427,
0.4926628172,
0.5375215411,
0.0871099904,
0.9748159647,
-0.2559841275,
0.2707686126,
-0.2805409729,
1.0300277472,
-0.0141341705,
0.5814783573,
-0.3554048538,
-0.5754386783,
-0.1143991351,
0.4504294991,
-0.1961960644,
-0.0414149053,
0.5152571797,
0.8436954021,
0.1941599697,
-0.2099482417,
0.3552339673,
0.1956630349,
0.6577523947,
0.505985558,
0.8494600654,
-0.1549240947,
0.6364584565,
-0.0109210107,
-0.2968508601,
0.033820536,
-0.7372419834,
-1.1468424797,
-0.0718788728,
-0.1079913825,
-0.4935011864,
0.2405739874,
1.1371028423,
0.7645353079,
-0.9121675491,
-0.3715677261,
0.0424390659,
0.1461084485,
0.1215521395,
-0.2008085996,
-0.0633740723,
-0.5339061618,
-0.1041591913,
0.9605146646,
0.3173149824,
0.1165840104,
-0.1409069747,
-0.1301521063,
-0.2014208585,
0.3197588921,
0.5107342005,
0.3517511785,
-0.5655715466,
-0.2002760768,
-0.0733546838,
-0.4582955241,
-0.132414341,
0.5810460448,
-0.6849871278,
0.3599360287,
0.2457474619,
0.794268012,
-0.0698655173,
-0.131228283,
0.5288897753,
-0.4687816799,
0.2296645492,
-0.1147719324,
0.4577594995,
0.0820758119,
-0.5390987992,
0.3909545541,
0.1031346023,
-0.4993906915,
-0.6159808636,
0.6156365275,
-0.5433553457,
-0.5974357724,
0.922695756,
-0.4029785097,
-0.2430958748,
-0.4946537316,
-0.3207644224,
-0.0281645153,
-0.7202348709,
0.7652504444,
0.6909475327,
0.0685972273,
-0.2446795404,
-0.5216802955,
0.4111691713,
0.15063636,
-1.1534473896,
0.1864717305,
0.5013094544,
0.4891530573,
-0.0728670433,
0.38083902,
-0.2033511251,
0.3825350106,
-0.4695441425,
0.1022972167,
-0.3681301177,
-0.5105026364,
-0.2861945927,
0.2978998423,
0.2116184086,
-0.2556173503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01251v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01251v2
|
Accelerating Greedy Coordinate Gradient via Probe Sampling
| 2024-03-02T16:23:44 | 2024-05-27T07:02:28 |
Yiran Zhao, Wenyue Zheng, Tianle Cai, Xuan Long Do, Kenji Kawaguchi, Anirudh Goyal, Michael Shieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safety of Large Language Models (LLMs) has become a critical issue given
their rapid progresses. Greedy Coordinate Gradient (GCG) is shown to be
effective in constructing adversarial prompts to break the aligned LLMs, but
optimization of GCG is time-consuming. To reduce the time cost of GCG and
enable more comprehensive studies of LLM safety, in this work, we study a new
algorithm called $\texttt{Probe sampling}$. At the core of the algorithm is a
mechanism that dynamically determines how similar a smaller draft model's
predictions are to the target model's predictions for prompt candidates. When
the target model is similar to the draft model, we rely heavily on the draft
model to filter out a large number of potential prompt candidates. Probe
sampling achieves up to $5.6$ times speedup using Llama2-7b-chat and leads to
equal or improved attack success rate (ASR) on the AdvBench. Furthermore, probe
sampling is also able to accelerate other prompt optimization techniques and
adversarial methods, leading to acceleration of $1.8\times$ for AutoPrompt,
$2.4\times$ for APE and $2.4\times$ for AutoDAN.
|
[
-0.4295958877,
-0.7476962805,
0.482408762,
0.2599091232,
-0.3613653779,
0.1726691574,
-0.109966591,
-0.3020781875,
0.024801027,
0.3147892356,
-0.54512918,
-0.5216876864,
-0.6993641257,
-0.147952497,
-0.2007054687,
0.6614177227,
0.2283669114,
0.1960917413,
0.2483329177,
0.2243204415,
-0.2744163275,
-0.2815418243,
-1.1757147312,
-0.1745633483,
0.6298071742,
0.2999787033,
0.4239074886,
1.072802186,
0.438462019,
0.2756676674,
-0.3639255762,
0.1397377253,
-0.7385172248,
0.4320368469,
0.1434384882,
-0.6042920351,
-0.4470851421,
0.2153512686,
0.5399215221,
0.3985478282,
-0.3557982445,
-0.1033510193,
-0.0060554747,
0.5847058892,
-0.699580133,
-0.0891219229,
-0.7518569231,
-0.2568252981,
-0.450134784,
-0.5182053447,
-0.42251423,
-0.3031655848,
0.0878764689,
-0.8311155438,
0.4502896965,
0.2300979346,
0.6548081636,
0.2662330866,
-0.2816365063,
-0.0798190609,
-0.3192108274,
0.7410122156,
-0.4686970413,
0.1282408834,
0.2330278456,
0.5351955891,
-0.6444128156,
-0.8100479841,
-0.336850971,
-0.3030194342,
0.3422044218,
0.1451094896,
-0.0618351772,
0.2012692243,
0.5877242684,
0.0855355486,
-0.5408031344,
0.5149260163,
-0.3859804571,
-0.4291750789,
0.7053726912,
0.452154249,
0.1003668532,
-0.0452219434,
-0.6785473824,
-0.4738637507,
-0.898696363,
0.2831501663,
0.6413149834,
0.3605557978,
-0.1220138818,
0.1867012084,
-0.4627784193,
0.8370266557,
0.2271705419,
0.1876553297,
0.0912835598,
-0.2914568782,
-0.0409228168,
-0.0153796459,
0.915771842,
0.5289307833,
0.2345082015,
0.1238149256,
-0.1838939339,
0.2788502872,
0.2874646783,
-1.0454111099,
-0.3890237808,
0.2078644484,
-0.1572953165,
-0.3396064341,
-0.3173519671,
-1.0272612572,
-0.6822169423,
0.0860487372,
-0.0478692874,
-0.2687485516,
-0.0188807026,
0.1897497922,
-0.1070244834,
0.4421585798,
0.4457401931,
-0.6553777456,
0.0167996474,
0.7304137945,
0.7831742167,
-0.3626184464,
-0.2105434239,
-1.1716586351,
-0.1631304473,
-0.5059412122,
0.9149329662,
-0.4903715849,
-0.8006609082,
-0.0761704594,
-0.1685901284,
-0.0436316244,
-0.388148278,
0.7550694942,
-0.8594392538,
0.175163269,
-0.51824826,
-0.5037910938,
-0.0850625038,
0.4745111465,
-0.7994405627,
1.0242865086,
-0.0406625718,
-0.6781496406,
0.4719704092,
-0.4229662716,
-0.3169552982,
0.2064191401,
-0.2405098826,
-0.3809691668,
-0.2748925686,
0.6428644657,
0.6260828376,
-0.6569380164,
0.042440109,
-0.3158157766,
-0.6509568691,
-0.0672480091,
-0.2309277356,
0.9696076512,
0.1877209395,
-0.3228551149,
0.1357250214,
-0.4512441158,
-0.0402404182,
0.2369268835,
-0.5570610762,
-0.226846084,
-0.0779154301,
-0.4025132954,
0.0291735325,
0.039099779,
-0.510371089,
0.4243373871,
-0.4680297077,
0.048611369,
0.8945403099,
0.1886492968,
0.715875864,
-0.3738584816,
0.8950712085,
-0.0939529315,
0.0370078683,
-0.2231454402,
-0.5998026133,
-0.4739880562,
-0.526231885,
0.3768126667,
0.5969209671,
-0.8950054646,
0.208258763,
-0.1426364779,
-0.7427449822,
-0.39208588,
-0.1226878688,
0.5044668317,
0.611763835,
0.3037189543,
-0.0531533025,
-0.1880254745,
-0.5711027384,
-0.3351326883,
-0.3061282039,
-0.2443169504,
0.5089797974,
0.0200412944,
-0.0574741997,
0.3844499588,
-0.7155079246,
-0.1038851738,
-0.1033095792,
0.2398023307,
0.2972918451,
0.4038226604,
0.8036532998,
-0.493950963,
-0.4880024195,
-0.3585205078,
-0.3394879997,
-0.4420257211,
-0.0925364196,
-0.4905727804,
0.053198386,
0.8187691569,
-0.613913238,
0.1653939635,
0.3983091116,
-0.2191844881,
0.4999844134,
0.0575833432,
0.1135268137,
-0.9973112941,
0.0180633236,
0.0868987963,
0.0098264068,
-0.6370177269,
0.158050701,
0.3325431645,
0.1151967868,
-0.6343297958,
0.839628756,
-0.6660327315,
0.3813375533,
-0.4052398205,
0.4147391915,
-0.0580983199,
0.3414941728,
-0.2934782803,
0.8821514249,
0.9200417995,
-0.8410851359,
0.4367728233,
0.0252708197,
-0.1620331556,
0.4063456655,
-0.6196807027,
0.3430047929,
-0.0930709988,
0.3145727217,
-1.0340608358,
0.1199895218,
0.4851039052,
-0.6960995197,
0.5076038241,
-0.2699176669,
-0.0624340065,
-0.2349316329,
-0.5652034283,
0.5903614759,
0.5720477104,
-0.6691772342,
0.6316150427,
0.3655848205,
-0.0190507416,
-0.9601609707,
-0.1775009781,
-0.0843919963,
-0.2698441744,
-0.4487194419,
0.2157898545,
0.0406610966,
-0.1664655358,
-0.3242485225,
0.1183431968,
0.4738771617,
0.3074604273,
0.0444846191,
0.3624190092,
0.1274089217,
-0.1807632148,
0.0268774182,
-0.3093764782,
0.367836237,
-0.3810955584,
0.7828456759,
0.3654119372,
-0.2905813754,
-0.1222171336,
0.2063115388,
0.3700508475,
-0.0790348426,
0.4363771081,
0.6574134231,
-0.2073139846,
-0.6000372767,
-0.5073007941,
-0.4415942132,
-0.5675277114,
0.4909710884,
-0.2503119409,
-0.7535537481,
0.7821573615,
-0.0388927385,
0.074514769,
0.3141341507,
0.6530072093,
0.2426715493,
0.8262084126,
0.2973041236,
-0.5027106404,
0.5822990537,
-0.3035435379,
-0.0858686343,
-1.0278625488,
-0.2699755132,
-0.7000138164,
-0.3794512749,
-0.584698379,
-0.7245098948,
0.6031186581,
-0.0204958916,
-0.0589015074,
0.0922393948,
-0.334458679,
0.343051374,
0.8749803901,
0.0610525049,
-0.097817488,
-0.0155579476,
-0.5057661533,
0.1223619655,
-0.7394732237,
-0.0687207431,
1.2920175791,
0.1962294728,
1.0582053661,
-0.2502972484,
0.4893778563,
0.1844102144,
0.2302993536,
-0.8002616763,
0.9516479373,
0.0185514931,
-0.410012871,
-0.2108669877,
-0.5444649458,
-1.1261062622,
0.3196517527,
-0.0647162572,
-0.5350958705,
0.1342127919,
0.3593039811,
-0.3977653086,
0.1717564911,
-0.4608017504,
0.2670459747,
-0.0294703785,
-0.460817337,
-0.0786516666,
-0.6844873428,
0.3364592195,
-0.0163965747,
-0.3881771863,
-0.2475126535,
-0.0889123678,
0.91170156,
-0.0346568786,
0.567748487,
-0.6562373638,
-0.1846637279,
0.34673208,
0.3622429073,
0.9878584146,
0.1741273999,
-0.2675758898,
0.1719441116,
-0.5712859035,
-0.4691706598,
-0.5095321536,
0.6339302659,
-0.5062991977,
-0.85499084,
-0.4990892708,
-0.611309588,
-0.2744872272,
0.0837096199,
0.4143793285,
0.2346437275,
-0.0680838153,
-0.0390348248,
0.5402231812,
-0.2537085712,
0.4209243357,
0.6288904548,
0.0976597145,
-0.3409485221,
0.5703838468,
-0.1468676776,
0.4253948331,
0.1752585471,
0.1673536748,
-0.4846345186,
-0.8415299058,
-0.5431858897,
0.3430282474,
-0.4071956277,
-0.5269643068,
-0.6493452191,
-0.2029791027,
-0.3049834669,
-0.1845753938,
-0.2214741111,
-0.2138258368,
-0.3688713014,
-0.0461614616,
0.318808943,
0.0927167758,
-0.0944360644,
0.5665817857,
-0.6677946448,
0.3094128966,
0.2028591484,
0.025818564,
-0.1194901466,
-0.6869919896,
-0.0358144343,
0.0613245852,
-0.2167302519,
-0.7664006352,
0.3598035872,
-0.1471960843,
0.720680654,
0.5742282271,
0.2719179392,
0.5711982846,
-0.5028141737,
0.6715259552,
-0.0986891314,
-0.6092738509,
0.3051970303,
-0.788641572,
0.3449978828,
0.3073429763,
0.3342207074,
-0.4837207496,
-0.4244719744,
-0.3106540143,
-1.0989682674,
0.765655756,
-0.0371185131,
-0.1043852568,
0.0266557354,
0.5532993078,
-0.3214552999,
-0.0161135364,
-0.177837491,
-0.2262642235,
0.2722659111,
0.1175704896,
-0.0793599412,
-0.3871407211,
-0.3684128523,
0.1650084406,
0.6364300847,
-0.3695922196,
0.4630135596,
0.0655816421,
0.2249211073,
-0.213302061,
-0.033466652,
0.5865917206,
0.1388480514,
-0.0906426683,
-0.005495701,
0.2029941976,
-0.7696552277,
0.2359750867,
0.5188168883,
-0.262807548,
-0.4513889849,
0.175193727,
0.6173090339,
-0.3265292645,
-0.5921413898,
0.5438376069,
-0.4220970571,
-0.2896367311,
0.0371593162,
0.4206603467,
-0.0862594619,
0.3609076142,
0.5101169944,
-0.1153817475,
0.1415511072,
0.16610156,
0.1340975612,
0.8350509405,
-0.0136744678,
-0.1017867178,
0.8774210811,
0.291605413,
-0.2171741426,
0.7026355863,
-0.3684487343,
-0.6314818263,
0.804128468,
0.4399939775,
0.938473165,
-0.5495690107,
-0.0174698625,
0.4263318181,
0.3797873557,
-0.1743881255,
0.4244704545,
0.1300076097,
-0.7696151733,
-0.3707386851,
-0.4293430448,
-0.5357682109,
0.1579838991,
-0.573476553,
0.2076379061,
-0.4302298725,
-0.1106724814,
-0.4230016768,
0.115497753,
-0.481475383,
0.1880692393,
0.13271074,
1.1177374125,
-0.6446331739,
0.647577107,
0.4805174172,
0.5026456714,
-0.9912916422,
0.1642593294,
0.0964051411,
-1.0630230904,
0.5503707528,
0.1742789298,
-0.4407942593,
0.0482046753,
-0.5100622773,
-0.8744835854,
1.0735892057,
0.4602108896,
-0.6874595284,
0.0007049768,
-0.1674982458,
0.3903983235,
-0.0635022074,
0.2344423831,
0.5107625127,
0.267160356,
0.1445608586,
-0.5408167243,
0.3575112224,
-0.3718669713,
0.0331648067,
0.3403621018,
-0.7123664021,
0.877443552,
-0.3152409196,
-0.4077829421,
0.0145073347,
0.6397206783,
0.699096024,
0.0848609731,
0.808195889,
0.5840892792,
0.8754110336,
-0.3084799945,
1.0258580446,
-0.5466861129,
0.1213304177,
0.8025952578,
-0.4728520811,
0.3895328641,
0.3848153353,
0.001775233,
0.0521966778,
0.8208256364,
-0.03561984,
0.5194154978,
0.4852437377,
-0.3550208807,
-0.1383415461,
-0.1129473671,
-0.3736336827,
0.3512313068,
0.4049371183,
-0.2177508622,
-0.1747161299,
-0.1586722434,
0.3118064702,
-0.2122546732,
-0.2926430106,
0.4731392562,
-0.0675369278,
-0.9382568002,
0.7864502072,
0.0921833888,
0.627771318,
-0.5785500407,
0.1230448112,
-0.3602100611,
0.1748127043,
0.3024632335,
-0.5224640965,
-0.3128719032,
-0.1962935627,
0.2647351623,
-0.0971989557,
0.7175313234,
-0.330420047,
-0.2528117895,
0.5759952068,
0.4970022142,
-0.1629074961,
-0.1385261118,
-0.494348824,
0.0144851366,
-0.161371842,
-0.7206317782,
0.168066889,
0.3110627532,
0.0183603261,
0.929607451,
0.8807285428,
0.4547258914,
0.3449470103,
-0.0772509277,
1.3365844488,
-0.5773830414,
-0.6997321248,
-0.9650784135,
0.3421151638,
-0.0272575095,
-0.3331705034,
0.7750694156,
0.3799623847,
0.7490518093,
0.1954985112,
0.5492272973,
0.1128035486,
0.6184325218,
-0.842400372,
0.7464635372,
-0.3633041978,
0.4054026902,
-0.1447864622,
-0.7835081816,
-0.3298073709,
0.3010036051,
-0.2997450233,
0.2012916505,
0.6072050929,
1.1691731215,
0.1547866762,
-0.2695872784,
0.1207993552,
0.0881074816,
0.6633216143,
0.6930602789,
0.875895083,
-0.2977227569,
0.5488213897,
-0.2186774611,
-0.2713389993,
-0.2482490838,
-0.999158144,
-1.1294697523,
-0.2392110229,
-0.0761475191,
-0.5943183303,
0.1145468876,
0.7703562379,
0.7718489766,
-0.4785378873,
-0.0374915153,
-0.0764401928,
-0.1569992304,
-0.0354050733,
-0.2012391388,
0.4073542655,
-0.3491394222,
-1.052467823,
0.7097797394,
-0.0015666079,
0.0700321645,
-0.1781644374,
-0.0883419886,
-0.154365018,
0.0392452702,
-0.0284884069,
0.3256722689,
-0.3036218286,
0.0336367227,
0.2247314602,
-0.266646266,
-0.0608939268,
0.9302591681,
-0.8635140657,
0.4897083938,
0.6215523481,
0.9142787457,
0.4747257233,
0.42905882,
0.7285342813,
-0.6897291541,
0.4170945883,
0.4090816081,
0.3659283817,
0.1285380274,
-0.7152282596,
0.3478782475,
0.2585349083,
-0.7161001563,
-0.8233041763,
0.3522876799,
-0.9940707684,
0.0314622931,
1.4353111982,
-0.2802185118,
-0.2632748783,
0.1499637216,
-0.2908525765,
0.4359052181,
-0.7471493483,
0.9219244123,
0.3246898651,
-0.0392850153,
0.0086494945,
-0.2835554779,
0.7863529921,
0.6699222326,
-0.7453160882,
0.0574128479,
0.5138192773,
0.0570579804,
-0.0829495713,
0.6892957091,
-0.0000999486,
0.4178283215,
0.0468619689,
-0.1888186485,
-0.3519073725,
-0.3691202998,
-0.5237835646,
0.2020388246,
-0.074644953,
-0.4965571761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04782v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04782v1
|
A Survey on Temporal Knowledge Graph: Representation Learning and Applications
| 2024-03-02T16:21:45 | 2024-03-02T16:21:45 |
Li Cai, Xin Mao, Yuhao Zhou, Zhaoguang Long, Changxu Wu, Man Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge graphs have garnered significant research attention and are widely
used to enhance downstream applications. However, most current studies mainly
focus on static knowledge graphs, whose facts do not change with time, and
disregard their dynamic evolution over time. As a result, temporal knowledge
graphs have attracted more attention because a large amount of structured
knowledge exists only within a specific period. Knowledge graph representation
learning aims to learn low-dimensional vector embeddings for entities and
relations in a knowledge graph. The representation learning of temporal
knowledge graphs incorporates time information into the standard knowledge
graph framework and can model the dynamics of entities and relations over time.
In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive survey of temporal knowledge graph
representation learning and its applications. We begin with an introduction to
the definitions, datasets, and evaluation metrics for temporal knowledge graph
representation learning. Next, we propose a taxonomy based on the core
technologies of temporal knowledge graph representation learning methods, and
provide an in-depth analysis of different methods in each category. Finally, we
present various downstream applications related to the temporal knowledge
graphs. In the end, we conclude the paper and have an outlook on the future
research directions in this area.
|
[
-0.2892843783,
-0.5736982226,
0.7104626298,
0.0772053972,
-0.2157750279,
0.7178248167,
0.1745540053,
-0.5760418773,
0.2700806856,
0.0662190095,
-0.4458593428,
-0.7021540403,
-0.5431962609,
-0.266758889,
-0.1998223513,
0.364541769,
-0.2297509313,
-0.086666517,
-0.2207853049,
-0.3154678941,
-0.5000982881,
-0.5161601901,
-0.7487344146,
-0.7647222281,
0.812256515,
0.0235207677,
0.0309648197,
0.6735039353,
-0.1784444898,
0.278110832,
0.0174308475,
0.1082903668,
-0.3156641126,
0.2265316099,
-0.1354568899,
-0.1597077399,
-0.2160764337,
0.0763921812,
0.9091725349,
1.154543519,
-0.061327856,
0.3175480664,
0.0129614361,
0.3860791028,
-0.6669309139,
0.8587653637,
-0.232877478,
0.4102593362,
-0.5042897463,
-0.4228631258,
-0.3661408424,
-0.6870009303,
0.1661282778,
-0.5465378165,
-0.1091565266,
0.2902987897,
0.4807417989,
0.0417627878,
-1.1616885662,
-0.0856167227,
-0.828612268,
0.7054209709,
-0.292021513,
0.7248022556,
-0.1900903434,
0.9414878488,
0.0599717945,
-1.0530200005,
-0.2454340756,
-0.0266618542,
0.0048304275,
0.2485701889,
-0.2484986037,
-0.0991823599,
0.203517139,
0.1258357167,
-0.542996645,
0.1595089734,
-0.0020965037,
-0.2064265162,
0.2122320384,
0.5238860846,
0.0363527872,
-0.0192255471,
-0.5240571499,
-0.0336324349,
-0.46079579,
0.0978102982,
0.2301066369,
-0.1059696674,
0.0610562228,
0.5333423018,
-0.2711216509,
0.8564122915,
-0.2525850534,
-0.0325447731,
0.2109268904,
0.0077966126,
0.0001669177,
0.0290717781,
0.5291428566,
0.351736486,
0.1068254858,
-0.5666666627,
0.076249063,
-0.1667850763,
0.0068697846,
-0.5654556155,
-0.0346459225,
-0.0558037683,
-0.5997685194,
-0.1860489696,
-0.1394168735,
-0.5824224353,
-0.3652391434,
-0.3605363965,
-0.0583349802,
-0.5569210649,
-0.3639770746,
-0.2089639753,
-0.4441598356,
0.1634157002,
0.3136758506,
-0.5503077507,
0.377730161,
0.485781163,
0.7638955116,
-0.0625421032,
-0.1552384496,
-0.0688851029,
0.639842093,
-0.3225369453,
0.6471159458,
-0.5117794275,
-0.4440273046,
0.0037681863,
-0.0431761146,
-0.2430401444,
-0.3522843719,
-0.0619805865,
-1.1649308205,
-0.162870422,
-0.2385441512,
-0.8357852697,
-0.5485393405,
0.3455738723,
-0.6050719023,
0.6373704076,
0.3610611856,
-0.758272469,
0.6534218788,
-0.5724023581,
-0.2689037025,
0.1306428313,
-0.1663839668,
-0.1717159599,
-0.2582545578,
0.0514989085,
0.5753576756,
0.0283775758,
-0.0725097582,
-0.3024553359,
-0.0932641402,
0.0808724165,
0.0925195292,
0.6737489104,
0.4067721367,
-0.0458424613,
-0.1634743959,
-0.3924063146,
-0.1255704015,
0.364989996,
-0.1607065946,
-0.4107678235,
0.2776422203,
-0.3080916703,
-0.0022423575,
0.3078499734,
-0.5425630808,
0.3867966831,
0.1122358069,
0.7218290567,
0.6345412135,
0.7372691035,
0.4859902859,
-0.0660660639,
0.4615158439,
0.4490740597,
0.181574136,
0.2322880179,
-0.3422408104,
-0.2182679474,
0.4100230038,
0.6719250083,
0.3830017447,
-1.0005733967,
0.0590412356,
-0.6605079174,
-0.6751961112,
0.4289847612,
-0.12800695,
-0.0965356007,
0.7119930983,
0.2974149287,
-0.1313960999,
-0.5774691105,
-0.4732309878,
-0.1819029748,
-0.6257770658,
0.1838586032,
0.4585011601,
0.3379625082,
-0.3113604784,
1.1254640818,
-0.8021790981,
-0.07833042,
-0.0925191417,
0.4081724286,
-0.0456945188,
0.0652895793,
1.0352120399,
-0.66144979,
-0.0688800067,
-0.0059634726,
-0.7374140024,
0.3231412768,
0.0738814399,
-0.0872785524,
0.1030766591,
0.5380717516,
-0.1597926021,
0.1432302147,
0.3392809033,
-0.2435339838,
0.2053868473,
0.1459957063,
0.0323336348,
-0.7701382637,
-0.0414757915,
-0.0081625776,
-0.5535619259,
-0.0591584146,
-0.3620282412,
-0.0098326774,
-0.408637315,
-0.3286799788,
0.6670560837,
-0.3844368756,
-0.0746191218,
0.2740775645,
0.1913499236,
-0.3266755939,
0.4572789371,
0.1087838635,
0.1539733261,
0.3422445357,
-0.8253338933,
0.5031477213,
-0.00698234,
-0.226401493,
0.0991098061,
-0.413677007,
0.0806097761,
-0.0959699675,
0.0857190043,
-0.5427453518,
-0.084615007,
0.4111713171,
-0.5034627318,
0.5559301376,
-0.5714046955,
-0.5044481754,
-0.4055471122,
0.0907457769,
0.2837439477,
0.5065441132,
-0.3736694157,
0.6886652708,
0.6277766228,
0.2764582038,
-0.5195912719,
-0.4566294253,
-0.3203501403,
-0.0125833517,
-0.3362522423,
0.3243050575,
0.6001489162,
-0.1424193084,
0.5970443487,
-0.4679602385,
0.1484909356,
-0.1240013838,
0.0352761373,
-0.1427515596,
-0.1255449057,
0.4882026017,
-0.0427092053,
-0.2609861493,
0.0551659353,
-0.7448629737,
0.5072814226,
0.1532407999,
-0.464915216,
0.308956027,
0.0212636814,
0.2490580678,
-0.1093774959,
0.8909657001,
0.7465897202,
-0.4818765223,
-0.0114854369,
-0.1696321666,
0.1396180838,
-0.386688143,
0.2449522167,
0.1009404734,
-0.8038038611,
0.499253422,
-0.6495907903,
0.1082994267,
0.6203375459,
0.205900833,
-0.2548802793,
0.7656134367,
0.5567525029,
-0.2125486284,
0.898330152,
-0.7394407392,
0.1145986691,
-0.6932063103,
-0.6125515699,
-0.3979272544,
-0.4614048302,
-0.6311974525,
-0.0777008682,
0.4255336225,
0.1621295363,
-0.6493211389,
0.0759585574,
-0.2290839404,
-0.0146960942,
0.1391509324,
0.1415423602,
0.1912108511,
0.039338965,
-0.2067465931,
0.0127882725,
-0.679476738,
-0.3072397411,
0.766348958,
0.3456375003,
0.6411297917,
0.0471822396,
0.7397839427,
0.6213538647,
0.0316371061,
-0.8172588944,
0.4281252325,
-0.1122890338,
-0.2777087986,
-0.3289866745,
-0.8952174783,
-0.8648873568,
-0.4658249617,
0.0788209066,
-0.6092668176,
0.4547475874,
0.0368416607,
0.0212227236,
0.6932398677,
-0.8994583488,
0.7807064652,
-0.2322771549,
0.0152393244,
-0.2194275856,
-0.4357051253,
-0.0120886629,
0.4161827564,
-0.0357630514,
-0.0738441795,
-0.1189321652,
1.0490925312,
-0.3655432761,
0.9208269715,
-0.8201247454,
0.4094022214,
0.5363673568,
-0.0561949089,
0.3394906819,
0.2103054672,
0.1971892715,
0.2183736712,
0.213716194,
-0.436696887,
-0.8147649765,
0.3127565384,
-0.7686396837,
-0.3190806508,
-0.6562502384,
-0.1383595318,
-0.4510128498,
0.3205504417,
-0.0819676518,
0.5507092476,
-0.1488060951,
-0.0039747055,
0.5221921802,
0.0652719885,
0.4417724609,
0.1635610759,
-0.4129907191,
-0.2290103734,
0.9974012375,
0.5414101481,
-0.1138383001,
0.7409746051,
0.0908493847,
-0.5199938416,
-0.6049259305,
-0.0353080556,
0.1594729424,
-0.7993168831,
-0.1845971197,
-0.7714859843,
-0.2530907094,
-0.5184803009,
0.2817222476,
0.0804585218,
-0.8348743916,
-0.2217032909,
-0.0531418063,
0.7376561761,
0.9866629243,
0.056977395,
0.1767376065,
-0.7495678067,
0.184629783,
0.6667636037,
0.4507100582,
0.4955073893,
0.28544572,
-0.3627774119,
-0.1030148938,
-0.5326298475,
-0.935041368,
-0.0769619197,
0.1201436371,
0.9267876148,
0.4700675011,
0.0456597134,
0.5578063726,
-0.1820324659,
0.8460445404,
-0.0530868396,
-0.6346449256,
0.3621119857,
-0.3200740516,
0.0264034588,
-0.0391732305,
0.6760363579,
-0.881200552,
0.1307746768,
-0.4794830978,
-0.7582272291,
0.2368154079,
-0.0930867642,
-0.0865949839,
0.2169839442,
0.5678283572,
-0.1944403052,
0.1884846687,
-0.0467702113,
-0.3850288093,
-0.5462192297,
-0.0101190908,
0.0497028343,
-0.0887889937,
0.096821636,
-0.113441743,
0.4462973177,
-0.2372803092,
0.7730923891,
-0.1535051912,
-0.1275102496,
0.2220547646,
0.3088081181,
0.0444841385,
0.7664823532,
-0.231959179,
-0.0247394871,
0.1255208701,
-0.6197385192,
0.1343258023,
0.1180230752,
-0.0363217033,
0.0686332807,
0.6322729588,
0.5276893973,
0.119778499,
0.0277323164,
0.2880648375,
0.0471123494,
0.1862153411,
-0.5810147524,
-0.0643317327,
0.4236438572,
0.4308371544,
0.5383442044,
0.1320059001,
-0.0528726988,
-0.802593708,
-0.186724782,
0.0907670334,
-0.6272107363,
-0.1180288196,
0.6084570885,
-0.0922723487,
0.2418391705,
0.7682696581,
-0.5039294958,
-0.5221554041,
0.4824794233,
0.2123814672,
0.5220082402,
0.0903853253,
0.171971485,
0.214776814,
-0.1191150546,
0.4453883767,
0.4156754315,
-0.2873286605,
-0.6503328085,
-0.2292845249,
-0.4411963522,
-0.5168210268,
-0.3484883606,
-0.4379261732,
0.1419774294,
-0.5114912391,
-0.6430644989,
-0.1452604085,
0.3338272572,
-0.8907157183,
-0.1186136827,
-0.0677446425,
1.2178673744,
-0.7823858261,
0.6536566019,
1.0639797449,
-0.4664307535,
-0.5810511112,
-0.1386219263,
0.0166019257,
-0.5990882516,
0.9311212897,
-0.4194518328,
-0.1437778771,
0.1289589852,
-0.5701088309,
-0.518263936,
1.5137133598,
0.2589492202,
-0.2777463794,
-0.4292122424,
0.0303352755,
0.3985340595,
-0.504234612,
-0.0159492623,
0.3899359107,
0.3334343135,
0.152843222,
-0.1884601712,
-0.0738907456,
-0.2237774283,
0.2875309885,
0.1651147604,
-0.712449491,
0.5599597096,
0.1179772466,
-0.5166700482,
-0.3073673546,
0.8468328714,
0.1517784297,
0.4195864797,
0.4767486453,
0.3238844275,
0.6482220888,
-0.5961624384,
0.8930422664,
-0.1979246885,
0.2695586681,
0.7614132166,
-0.19719477,
0.2544407845,
0.2256600559,
-0.3530998528,
0.8715466857,
1.0434721708,
0.0784473047,
0.6390473247,
0.06583637,
-0.0708198324,
-0.2648239136,
-0.3181294203,
-0.5581945181,
0.0089442153,
0.7089321613,
-0.2496693581,
-0.543047905,
0.0125292744,
-0.2539509833,
-0.3833591044,
-0.5040943027,
0.6910119057,
0.1214087903,
0.0887061879,
-0.0422140248,
-0.1442306042,
0.0266800113,
-0.6969317198,
-0.4544749558,
0.0921923593,
-0.1152562872,
-0.3139364421,
-0.9935099483,
0.24323228,
-0.5118089318,
-0.0870585367,
-0.473064661,
0.8243759274,
0.1785303801,
-0.0295895915,
0.6122299433,
0.5216619968,
-0.1125852689,
0.2835087776,
-0.3533194959,
-0.2773824036,
-0.5034938455,
-0.1528500468,
-0.165317446,
0.6763589978,
-0.2281815857,
0.7049046159,
0.0482859984,
0.2679943442,
0.3800337315,
0.2041465789,
0.9210748672,
-0.7518036366,
-0.427130878,
-0.3530213833,
0.3444724977,
-0.0610623397,
-0.02285612,
0.6103231907,
0.5385254622,
0.8613449931,
0.0671060905,
0.8212332726,
-0.374394536,
0.5741304159,
-0.8956292868,
0.7714596987,
-0.313167572,
-0.0457462519,
-0.0473950654,
-0.8298522234,
-0.1026181057,
-0.1852850914,
-0.6646518707,
0.286467582,
0.5708189011,
-0.0446392298,
-0.0496565998,
0.2121602446,
0.0197814126,
0.0658232644,
0.1798676848,
0.4736123979,
1.1210825443,
-0.2353330851,
0.4604914188,
-0.4098985493,
-0.0649371371,
-0.2543881238,
-0.8845670223,
-0.7081556916,
-0.9380354285,
-0.3013711274,
-0.2081679851,
-0.0218224786,
0.7195126414,
0.7146459222,
-0.560479641,
-0.026804911,
0.2992735505,
0.4455460906,
-0.6207126379,
-0.2082161605,
0.546646297,
-0.2862546742,
-0.3028825521,
0.1383740902,
0.0237781517,
0.2956722975,
-0.258076638,
0.1575869918,
-0.0258022361,
-0.6747801304,
0.6500124931,
0.6010098457,
0.0926771015,
-0.4989753366,
0.2928122878,
0.2811796963,
0.0084723718,
1.3859387636,
-0.8919232488,
0.3410684168,
0.9371628165,
0.3686480224,
1.0684796572,
-0.3322915733,
0.3183421791,
-0.9007515311,
-0.039975293,
0.2845058143,
0.6999027729,
0.1361992657,
-0.3168782294,
0.5571613908,
0.5603387356,
-0.335834831,
-0.2284040004,
0.4244255126,
-0.9968384504,
-0.0826868042,
0.5534044504,
-0.0828993395,
-0.4539064169,
-0.5776276588,
0.4845510423,
0.9315688014,
-0.4667662382,
0.4962570369,
0.5292794108,
-0.5188439488,
-0.1530719846,
-0.4980721176,
0.099638015,
-0.6106424928,
-0.4563156366,
-0.1766299009,
0.1664336771,
0.3012528718,
0.3903412223,
0.4964977503,
-0.5336894393,
-0.116254963,
0.0045167292,
-0.2094736248,
-0.388618201,
-0.191501826,
0.03381446,
0.1958921105,
0.1779126376,
-0.2278323323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01248v1
|
SceneCraft: An LLM Agent for Synthesizing 3D Scene as Blender Code
| 2024-03-02T16:16:26 | 2024-03-02T16:16:26 |
Ziniu Hu, Ahmet Iscen, Aashi Jain, Thomas Kipf, Yisong Yue, David A. Ross, Cordelia Schmid, Alireza Fathi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces SceneCraft, a Large Language Model (LLM) Agent
converting text descriptions into Blender-executable Python scripts which
render complex scenes with up to a hundred 3D assets. This process requires
complex spatial planning and arrangement. We tackle these challenges through a
combination of advanced abstraction, strategic planning, and library learning.
SceneCraft first models a scene graph as a blueprint, detailing the spatial
relationships among assets in the scene. SceneCraft then writes Python scripts
based on this graph, translating relationships into numerical constraints for
asset layout. Next, SceneCraft leverages the perceptual strengths of
vision-language foundation models like GPT-V to analyze rendered images and
iteratively refine the scene. On top of this process, SceneCraft features a
library learning mechanism that compiles common script functions into a
reusable library, facilitating continuous self-improvement without expensive
LLM parameter tuning. Our evaluation demonstrates that SceneCraft surpasses
existing LLM-based agents in rendering complex scenes, as shown by its
adherence to constraints and favorable human assessments. We also showcase the
broader application potential of SceneCraft by reconstructing detailed 3D
scenes from the Sintel movie and guiding a video generative model with
generated scenes as intermediary control signal.
|
[
-0.3421560824,
-0.7587999701,
0.642555654,
0.3749980032,
0.1759516001,
0.2185244262,
0.3160553575,
-0.2834944427,
-0.111164771,
0.740701735,
-0.5695977211,
-0.6124377847,
-0.0390687361,
0.0617435351,
-0.532404542,
0.4048114717,
0.0078736618,
-0.1064569652,
-0.3521162271,
0.2319682389,
-0.1705907434,
-0.3569723666,
-0.6517124772,
-0.3794284165,
0.3339272439,
0.1276803911,
0.6848093271,
0.8532478213,
0.2911763191,
0.5212424994,
0.1022090316,
0.2203253359,
-0.4611980021,
0.0904100388,
-0.4064545333,
-0.0757540166,
-0.5540581942,
-0.1120416299,
0.4194456935,
0.5264921188,
0.0270319618,
0.2724191248,
0.0031392148,
0.6550738811,
-0.4208783805,
0.3826562464,
-0.3558180332,
0.3555459976,
0.2302211076,
-0.3633041382,
-0.1193416044,
-0.0335872956,
0.285536617,
-0.9385986328,
0.6247150302,
0.2893211246,
0.5099033713,
0.3190994859,
-0.0453838445,
0.1499566883,
-0.6584918499,
0.6807486415,
-0.4561243951,
0.0235679727,
-0.0178972185,
0.5903633833,
-0.44879511,
-0.8686263561,
-0.4056418836,
-0.1013763323,
0.1864690036,
0.1941016018,
0.0223255605,
0.2256289274,
0.3833286762,
0.4825784862,
-0.4109817743,
-0.1563145667,
-0.4723457396,
-0.4809331894,
0.5570011139,
0.5190487504,
0.6665552258,
-0.2524433732,
-0.6321559548,
-0.3342415988,
-0.6460267901,
-0.0362782143,
0.4140950143,
0.1022365987,
0.0905493572,
0.7762677073,
-0.2831601799,
0.6424459219,
-0.2081064582,
-0.2181891203,
0.0250800159,
-0.0165051967,
-0.3744091392,
0.25422135,
0.5660421848,
0.7732704282,
0.0100726262,
0.1768895239,
-0.3134297132,
-0.2273743898,
0.540615201,
-0.8853911757,
-0.4461446106,
0.460949868,
-0.2793479562,
-0.5149998069,
-0.1666613668,
-0.564386189,
-0.6449300051,
-0.4382839501,
0.2743856609,
-0.3403907418,
-0.2549637854,
-0.0303325336,
-0.3573426306,
0.3762722909,
0.7600626945,
-0.4777915478,
0.1417285204,
0.5106425881,
0.7725787759,
-0.2338380516,
-0.5948060751,
-0.3440415859,
0.4580723345,
-0.6068184376,
0.9947783947,
-0.1928082705,
-0.5133932829,
0.0462212525,
-0.0367991589,
0.4844407737,
-0.6921884418,
-0.2218838632,
-0.2887786627,
-0.0847587287,
0.0793245807,
-0.1913051158,
-0.2502551675,
0.7361217141,
-1.0650421381,
0.7216531634,
0.3657670915,
-0.4836995602,
0.0308353603,
-0.3544670045,
-0.1396017075,
0.0498018749,
-0.1684229821,
-0.0997316539,
0.1713225543,
0.3179405332,
0.3378590047,
-0.2577890754,
0.2472848296,
-0.1708811671,
-0.2177913189,
0.3876705766,
-0.4159339368,
0.1766720712,
0.5334794521,
0.1139728874,
0.2786343396,
-0.8561519384,
0.0157952979,
-0.0145177403,
-0.4330445826,
0.1893919855,
0.0367378518,
0.2203043401,
0.249759227,
0.381734699,
-0.3723876178,
-0.0786597133,
-0.6346575022,
0.1629256755,
0.7065660357,
-0.0805512369,
0.6247265935,
-0.4141219854,
0.6037627459,
-0.0204939265,
-0.1121147498,
-0.6303757429,
-0.2575850785,
-0.4991059601,
-0.1522557139,
-0.4917180538,
0.5076165795,
-0.9848672748,
-0.1779849082,
-0.0006338536,
-0.2396724671,
-0.0789524242,
0.0846024454,
0.3816672564,
0.2774526179,
0.16640535,
-0.1925175339,
-0.6420716047,
-0.9166895747,
-0.1898370683,
-0.0853856504,
-0.2072202861,
0.0530125685,
-0.0622491911,
-0.1884861588,
0.9895244241,
-0.4487557411,
-0.2875593305,
-0.7212437987,
-0.2290636599,
0.3746972084,
0.5355642438,
0.3026718497,
-0.4300090969,
-0.2822035551,
0.3348991871,
-0.856813848,
-0.1436034888,
0.0035184838,
-0.1723249555,
0.0278060213,
0.8381465077,
-0.2988910377,
0.4721386731,
0.5759234428,
-0.197980389,
0.6252864599,
-0.4738216996,
0.1233296394,
-1.0398625135,
-0.2064322829,
0.0150253056,
-0.3821943998,
-0.5508736968,
0.113298811,
-0.4974028766,
-0.7098587751,
-0.9409193993,
0.8277484775,
-0.3906196654,
-0.27083987,
-0.3241592944,
-0.0300550144,
0.1559633166,
0.7250956297,
0.1862700731,
0.6319932938,
0.6047692299,
-0.5791546106,
0.7285218835,
0.0300082248,
-0.4995471835,
0.5433599949,
-0.6148162484,
-0.0994696543,
-0.1127126738,
0.1559233218,
-1.0316035748,
-0.634935379,
0.1728422344,
0.0955185741,
0.012618538,
-0.3496460021,
-0.5035978556,
-0.0893177688,
-0.1302609146,
0.5335697532,
0.3514897823,
-0.5231922269,
1.0597336292,
0.4813604355,
-0.0833641812,
-0.2776077688,
-0.6103204489,
-0.0383251123,
-0.0743156746,
-0.4741372466,
0.3116119206,
-0.0483056232,
-0.3449931443,
0.0325626023,
-0.310965836,
-0.2677591145,
-0.3456872106,
0.5511040688,
0.2139638662,
0.0372161269,
-0.4614354968,
0.0002311129,
-0.2743739784,
0.2473089099,
-0.3664868176,
0.5170333385,
-0.1715904474,
-0.4413411915,
-0.1965807527,
0.0620614365,
0.6674654484,
0.232738778,
-0.0786570236,
0.5638022423,
-0.093601577,
-0.6313815713,
-0.4676015377,
0.2850637436,
-0.5601451397,
0.5886875987,
-0.6345408559,
-0.743765533,
0.5838498473,
-0.6124147773,
0.178065747,
0.2851283252,
0.4164854586,
-0.0874605253,
0.8563668132,
0.3678839505,
0.3058118522,
0.5469652414,
-0.5901479125,
-0.0240463521,
-0.8092671633,
-0.2550330162,
0.1022851467,
-0.3477823436,
-0.3072803915,
-0.8494509459,
0.498041302,
-0.241268903,
-0.4088585377,
0.2547589839,
-0.5780786872,
1.0292583704,
0.3019581735,
0.1227024272,
0.1848304123,
0.3693749607,
-0.0947305784,
0.2172420919,
-0.5518119335,
-0.5327893496,
0.7065010071,
0.3094342649,
1.009578228,
-0.0923550874,
0.6233274937,
0.3928695619,
0.0109324651,
-0.5303375721,
0.8490391374,
0.0698422194,
-0.477594763,
-0.332883507,
-0.1074326858,
-0.7320484519,
0.5044746399,
-0.0127474926,
-0.5355878472,
-0.0065747141,
0.2137693316,
-0.3160627782,
0.436340481,
-0.4802175462,
0.9777234793,
-0.1360719502,
-0.64934057,
-0.2992485166,
-0.1639552116,
0.3090788126,
0.094963707,
0.2029211372,
-0.369383812,
0.1249964908,
0.0838565007,
-0.5339337587,
0.9763870835,
0.0379601307,
-0.2529797852,
0.649123013,
0.8496459126,
0.3271466494,
0.1691411734,
0.0536130071,
0.125170067,
0.3449027538,
-0.2923954725,
-0.4930703938,
0.8154709339,
-0.9572060108,
-0.8300754428,
-0.4447924793,
-0.7569428682,
0.1904889792,
0.2342951447,
0.0733051524,
0.8105354309,
-0.8441279531,
-0.2054103017,
0.5916155577,
-0.8969278932,
0.3833303452,
0.1439439207,
-0.8734038472,
-0.559173286,
1.0904755592,
-0.319162637,
0.2306387424,
0.5220322609,
-0.0417588837,
0.0263963863,
-0.3496796489,
-0.5987148881,
-0.2188092768,
-0.856089592,
-0.2488579303,
-0.3307293952,
-0.6334733963,
0.0806871802,
-0.6569448709,
-0.6399466395,
-0.2753685117,
-0.1612374783,
-0.1182207689,
0.0917490348,
0.9609419703,
0.0991964415,
0.2365624309,
-0.6022917032,
0.4858129025,
0.5180323124,
0.2496497184,
-0.0784561187,
-0.1422755271,
-0.2136059254,
-0.2360588163,
-0.2086281627,
-0.2430146486,
0.7094778419,
-0.0848212689,
0.4384878278,
0.137729466,
-0.277649492,
0.8229256868,
-0.5995193124,
0.9508212805,
0.2531460524,
-0.666539073,
0.4466308355,
-0.4048514068,
0.6669449806,
0.1888106018,
-0.411536783,
-0.2044260353,
-0.5951539278,
-0.5446560979,
-0.8686316013,
0.8941533566,
0.147457853,
0.2823052406,
-0.0012909948,
0.0690311342,
-0.1716891974,
0.1021916196,
-0.5172644258,
0.0953031927,
-0.5995500088,
0.0081349984,
0.1236543059,
-0.2574701011,
-0.1993398517,
-0.0956288278,
0.2553881407,
-0.1539404094,
0.2027180195,
0.4354815483,
-0.1829420477,
0.027906362,
-0.0040683928,
0.2686442733,
0.6393179297,
-0.1195325926,
0.2222276628,
0.1866644919,
-0.2984905243,
0.1455310434,
-0.1440373808,
0.0495952033,
-0.143047139,
0.430606246,
0.5578213334,
0.3343436718,
-0.8466245532,
0.4396907985,
0.1115602925,
-0.3798284233,
-0.664440155,
0.302634716,
0.0403546654,
0.4972674549,
-0.0033690094,
0.1842384189,
0.2565796375,
-0.4706258178,
0.0211929604,
0.1750288308,
-0.2994401753,
-0.2815730572,
0.8468921781,
0.2935091555,
-0.1616162509,
0.707573235,
-0.0486890078,
-0.2096869648,
0.9008572102,
0.6629223228,
1.047109127,
-0.0469344705,
0.3927244246,
0.5165175796,
0.1049009264,
-0.1749701649,
0.0804474279,
-0.0219157692,
-0.7684531212,
-0.4453007579,
-1.0199841261,
-0.2930270433,
-0.1605156362,
-0.0667708814,
0.139108479,
-1.0421098471,
0.1468762159,
-0.4274871945,
-0.2974147797,
-0.7584130764,
0.0329954922,
0.1819026768,
0.8695867062,
-0.3894656897,
0.8074900508,
0.8231790066,
-0.4774671197,
-0.7314178944,
-0.4015775025,
0.2290674448,
-0.7836505771,
0.7473273277,
0.2134370059,
-0.3509773612,
0.1572422683,
-0.5845041871,
-0.9121396542,
1.1996362209,
0.3270880282,
-0.4683955312,
-0.0182329807,
0.3696526289,
0.5521321297,
-0.6252064705,
-0.0119680399,
0.3418918252,
0.216572836,
0.7009162903,
-0.425855726,
-0.0591191351,
-0.4182458222,
0.5597937703,
-0.2121991366,
-0.2752961218,
0.6547386646,
-0.1657694727,
-0.2911926508,
0.2813462019,
0.5649394989,
0.4676690698,
0.3544669151,
0.3184992075,
0.5688388348,
0.0999514982,
0.0426887497,
1.0856766701,
-0.2683495283,
-0.1697435677,
0.9901340008,
-0.2567310929,
0.3704285026,
0.2309323251,
-0.0705960169,
0.4958418012,
0.4850146472,
-0.0342094451,
0.5396485925,
0.3041342795,
-0.3303287923,
-0.214901194,
0.0863208249,
0.1040523127,
0.1788149178,
0.3728920519,
-0.1486972868,
-0.3679907918,
-0.0360606201,
-0.3065054417,
0.0433935523,
-0.5404332876,
0.9323814511,
0.1403262913,
-0.4970172346,
0.2100599855,
-0.160550639,
-0.0765476674,
-0.4557318091,
-0.4029214382,
-0.3542532027,
0.3074715137,
-0.3203097582,
-0.9137570858,
0.2495592237,
-0.2796697617,
-0.0996253192,
-0.4721110463,
0.6157001853,
-0.5158728957,
-0.4641234279,
-0.1100177318,
0.3921744823,
0.3804988563,
-0.2088800073,
-0.7104275823,
0.2740935385,
0.0203776229,
-0.2195343822,
0.4046849012,
0.7662429214,
-0.0733917654,
0.7696803808,
0.8543944955,
0.1509122849,
-0.0951080471,
0.2092052251,
0.9543955922,
-0.7021138072,
-0.4146784246,
-0.6750015616,
0.6627835631,
-0.0275650956,
0.1538005173,
0.6237181425,
0.7108995914,
0.9476554394,
-0.4178741276,
0.8105965853,
0.0553749613,
-0.1672496349,
-0.5598510504,
0.4701666832,
-0.3305125535,
0.55532974,
-0.3160024285,
-1.438985467,
-0.4638431668,
0.6460987926,
0.0403054021,
-0.410390377,
0.5901836753,
1.0337055922,
-0.2399332374,
-0.4792732298,
0.6891239882,
-0.1116539091,
0.5347182155,
0.3751729131,
1.1828751564,
-0.1063945666,
0.6378054619,
-0.1463310122,
0.0004510096,
0.0707516745,
-0.8704490662,
-1.0106281042,
-0.3565734625,
-0.3157826066,
-0.3888156414,
-0.2490356565,
0.805549562,
0.5934574008,
-0.5237261057,
-0.6891830564,
-0.2581950426,
0.2769000828,
-0.3275311291,
-0.2187891901,
0.1484371275,
-0.4136776328,
-0.8947784305,
0.5047039986,
0.7486594915,
0.1295249164,
-0.7528817058,
-0.1491069645,
0.3229849637,
0.0075068446,
0.8299288154,
0.3138412237,
-0.7340887785,
0.0677417815,
-0.3644270897,
-0.1311535835,
-0.0898555964,
0.7942297459,
-0.7963892817,
0.8323737383,
0.7035766244,
0.3842394054,
0.6504431963,
0.1843705624,
1.0543738604,
-0.7062917948,
0.4470134676,
-0.2449979633,
0.3619925082,
0.2898293138,
-0.2103110552,
0.505961597,
-0.0666496083,
-0.4621352553,
-0.4568176866,
0.4263557494,
-1.0525711775,
-0.464614749,
1.0269514322,
0.0458737686,
-0.7673376799,
0.0153517863,
-0.6413865089,
-0.154171288,
-0.2577035129,
0.5310122967,
0.4037578106,
0.047559008,
-0.3124589622,
-0.5313788652,
0.6297417879,
-0.4918875694,
-0.5627124906,
0.1002499908,
0.9682113528,
0.3081000745,
0.2096747756,
0.646649003,
-0.3396844268,
0.12629278,
0.257797569,
0.3750389516,
-0.4385017157,
-0.4449302256,
0.0113911349,
0.2767010927,
0.036532402,
0.0941521972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01244v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01244v2
|
Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Models with Self-Synthesized Rehearsal
| 2024-03-02T16:11:23 | 2024-05-25T12:17:29 |
Jianheng Huang, Leyang Cui, Ante Wang, Chengyi Yang, Xinting Liao, Linfeng Song, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from catastrophic forgetting during
continual learning. Conventional rehearsal-based methods rely on previous
training data to retain the model's ability, which may not be feasible in
real-world applications. When conducting continual learning based on a
publicly-released LLM checkpoint, the availability of the original training
data may be non-existent. To address this challenge, we propose a framework
called Self-Synthesized Rehearsal (SSR) that uses the LLM to generate synthetic
instances for rehearsal. Concretely, we first employ the base LLM for
in-context learning to generate synthetic instances. Subsequently, we utilize
the latest LLM to refine the instance outputs based on the synthetic inputs,
preserving its acquired ability. Finally, we select diverse high-quality
synthetic instances for rehearsal in future stages. Experimental results
demonstrate that SSR achieves superior or comparable performance compared to
conventional rehearsal-based approaches while being more data-efficient.
Besides, SSR effectively preserves the generalization capabilities of LLMs in
general domains.
|
[
-0.1475477517,
-0.5527234674,
0.4573614597,
0.5332430601,
-0.1068386063,
0.3632073998,
-0.3844085038,
0.0140214618,
0.2105739713,
0.713391602,
-0.7708083987,
-0.3395288289,
0.0612255968,
0.0647483468,
-0.4405007064,
0.8684632182,
-0.1061488092,
0.0654730499,
-0.275051713,
-0.0786683038,
-0.5739792585,
-0.6013228297,
-0.853333354,
-0.4636366367,
0.3983197212,
0.5876398087,
-0.0578857958,
0.4439827502,
-0.0688451454,
0.2974744439,
0.1732176393,
0.1580434442,
-0.995701313,
0.4885034561,
-0.3122632504,
-0.2299859375,
-0.3514381349,
-0.0494404286,
1.282164216,
0.5302882195,
-0.4456923604,
0.0589504205,
0.1682298928,
0.8478492498,
-0.6076231599,
0.0716601834,
-1.1727932692,
0.3035750091,
-0.0431586504,
-0.1887747049,
-0.6415454745,
-0.0350803807,
-0.1971773356,
-0.4545046389,
0.4152889848,
-0.1746133417,
0.2632418871,
0.0782567188,
0.0242295153,
0.0737122148,
-0.9524491429,
0.8215005994,
-0.6330431104,
0.456392318,
0.3568256795,
0.5212923288,
-0.4874353409,
-0.5779851079,
-0.5819776058,
-0.3249823153,
0.4187932611,
0.4252393842,
0.3015666604,
-0.0545455366,
0.0413284823,
0.3597427309,
-0.5954753757,
0.2416198701,
-0.2903859913,
-0.458337903,
0.4647043645,
0.320094496,
0.2165837735,
0.0496464819,
-0.3557356,
0.0058510294,
-1.2647556067,
-0.5387607813,
0.0745447725,
0.2969242036,
0.0627950355,
0.2849861681,
-0.0942339599,
0.4278225899,
0.1364315301,
-0.0909530073,
-0.0049156775,
-0.1707960814,
-0.145749405,
-0.0264988281,
0.5765298605,
0.0123565774,
0.2607685626,
-0.4757605195,
-0.4057762325,
-0.0705326125,
0.3855036795,
-0.5112181902,
-0.3344052732,
0.087663196,
0.1248180196,
-0.0313982628,
-0.4499715865,
-0.6590439677,
-0.0675682724,
-0.602376163,
0.5217074156,
-0.4730671346,
-0.1586911827,
-0.2238602936,
0.1371202618,
-0.0737843364,
0.1762046218,
-1.0685859919,
0.2863025665,
0.3392317891,
0.8823573589,
-0.1191221625,
-0.7393240333,
-0.6396676898,
0.688462615,
-0.733489275,
0.5697224736,
-0.008781055,
-0.2839448154,
-0.0112661095,
-0.1356202364,
-0.2497716546,
-0.8506655097,
-0.0097430591,
-0.3469802439,
-0.0524859019,
-0.0167363323,
-0.6278048158,
0.2570074201,
0.2140759379,
-0.5304648876,
0.9168458581,
0.1230747253,
-0.1600225717,
0.2153793871,
-0.0894932598,
-0.3583063483,
0.0552200638,
-0.3559972346,
-0.5760385394,
0.3294642866,
0.1282496452,
0.4913071692,
-0.2365759015,
0.2074847668,
-0.3053996265,
-0.4838006794,
0.2513978481,
-0.2114434391,
-0.0046211598,
0.176615417,
-0.2513236701,
-0.0254186075,
-0.8856187463,
0.0760928318,
0.1669586003,
-0.5047934055,
-0.0773986802,
0.146052748,
0.0607786402,
0.3666995466,
-0.1166687384,
-0.3619931042,
0.0115601048,
-0.4546300471,
0.6200820804,
1.0571768284,
0.1294448674,
0.5509722233,
-0.4818104208,
0.602719605,
0.0305670276,
-0.1217716709,
-0.4135588109,
0.2069886774,
-1.0312486887,
-0.2387512922,
0.0798828527,
0.222917527,
-0.6174345016,
0.2983873487,
-0.2884266376,
-0.4343447685,
-0.2802395821,
0.3461736441,
0.4414553046,
0.3639128208,
0.3635555804,
-0.253071785,
-0.7705609202,
-0.759732604,
-0.174315393,
0.0027503078,
-0.0463274792,
0.0523047,
0.3524005413,
-0.2833106816,
1.0613290071,
-0.0637682155,
-0.696724534,
-0.4383541346,
0.0622833967,
-0.0246092565,
0.8458477259,
0.370870024,
-0.2849678695,
-0.3964583278,
-0.1411240697,
-0.7720309496,
0.0947586149,
-0.6354371309,
-0.0440749377,
0.5990370512,
0.706787467,
-0.4504440427,
-0.0210120268,
0.7113382816,
0.2093964964,
0.7984676361,
-0.3150005043,
-0.1993869841,
-0.9628207684,
-0.0096527003,
-0.2727824748,
-0.2362453192,
-0.5995966792,
-0.0242483281,
0.3152101338,
-0.405593425,
-0.3953121006,
0.731587708,
-0.7158175111,
-0.0417755507,
-0.2944236994,
0.1893024892,
-0.2773704827,
0.5134491324,
-0.0653715357,
0.8473851681,
0.6442751288,
-0.8159990907,
-0.1064527333,
0.0532871,
-0.3731363416,
0.3444457054,
-0.4144032896,
0.5073218942,
-0.1487864256,
0.5759495497,
-0.8137220144,
-0.4285436869,
0.0261717904,
-0.1637002677,
0.7049646974,
-0.5746381283,
-0.4428916276,
-0.3384962678,
-0.0125653353,
0.2769093513,
0.6443255544,
-0.5907265544,
0.636290729,
0.3861812651,
-0.2343787104,
-0.2171280235,
-0.7175908089,
0.3353283405,
-0.309845835,
-0.3527447283,
0.3736228645,
-0.2920913696,
0.2222371548,
-0.3963814676,
-0.3943538666,
0.1373840868,
-0.1010184288,
0.2300584465,
-0.0034207979,
-0.008795077,
0.3540601432,
0.1503841728,
-0.2333972156,
0.0011705079,
-0.6204265356,
0.7513839006,
0.09425807,
-0.3420619071,
-0.246998474,
0.4315312803,
0.8108720183,
0.0588608086,
0.75843817,
0.2853378356,
-0.3279219568,
-0.8208758831,
-0.8877347708,
-0.3478611708,
-0.5148003101,
0.344168365,
-0.2285422385,
-0.8858705759,
0.8148995042,
-0.2309493273,
-0.1490006447,
0.1485357881,
0.5505510569,
-0.2584150732,
0.6914145947,
0.3159215152,
-0.2553898096,
0.5371733308,
-0.3538476229,
-0.0378547162,
-1.0587295294,
0.0131945154,
-0.1342795044,
-0.0499985367,
-0.2973735929,
-0.441631496,
0.5886769891,
0.0457761846,
-0.3162716627,
0.2126800716,
-0.0649739727,
0.6458590031,
0.3402248621,
0.1361404359,
-0.0166239254,
0.2214669287,
-0.3350550234,
-0.2789702117,
-0.8528912067,
-0.2478951812,
1.1424918175,
0.2139727771,
0.8068377972,
-0.151887849,
1.0435624123,
0.0351641066,
0.2819446623,
-0.3723220527,
0.6976490617,
0.0420919098,
-0.6057717204,
-0.40717417,
-0.7335197926,
-0.749104619,
0.3383627832,
-0.0591308251,
-0.6516539454,
-0.2451528907,
0.5921872854,
-0.0372582972,
0.1371132582,
-0.5507237911,
0.6383515,
0.018319713,
-0.5365362167,
-0.5504662991,
-0.2453055829,
0.3285821676,
-0.5519043207,
0.28904441,
-0.0236143507,
0.477999121,
0.6747688055,
-0.2535508275,
1.1297478676,
0.0000017057,
-0.061831709,
0.3982072175,
0.4246143997,
0.9110642672,
0.0487287305,
-0.0338681228,
-0.0110040568,
-0.3535910845,
-0.4470777214,
-0.5786015987,
1.037371397,
-0.5343074799,
-0.5974888802,
-0.2718244791,
-0.4568808973,
-0.5390264988,
0.1085099429,
0.2993939221,
0.5615980029,
-0.2839066982,
0.1495220214,
0.4935587943,
-0.1489328295,
0.5095567107,
0.6269869208,
-0.1952890903,
-0.8391814828,
1.1870588064,
0.4504528642,
0.6811846495,
0.0219374057,
0.2408222854,
-0.2138617188,
-0.8527874947,
-0.3874441385,
0.4056899548,
-0.8904964924,
-0.1734552979,
-0.5196830034,
-0.389123708,
-0.4045314789,
-0.2226917893,
-0.6830399632,
-0.4287417233,
-0.1690063179,
-0.1263722926,
0.0851170942,
0.5460814834,
-0.3526079655,
0.009348155,
-0.8141420484,
0.2014320791,
0.3700307906,
0.4501556754,
0.3544521332,
-0.7206215858,
-0.523035109,
-0.0170324016,
-0.3884733617,
-0.427229166,
0.5993871093,
0.4852021933,
0.6235089302,
0.0180834327,
0.0664366782,
0.971545279,
-0.8720546961,
0.6862084866,
0.2999930978,
-0.8825001717,
0.6766842604,
-0.6419143081,
0.5057736635,
0.5882386565,
0.0880223811,
-0.7023296356,
-0.7944729328,
-0.4237886965,
-1.1693360806,
0.6205419302,
0.2631655633,
0.3056543171,
-0.2860009074,
0.4381214082,
0.1348439157,
0.1321918666,
-0.9273068309,
-0.0011461129,
-0.2090989947,
0.0200677849,
-0.3175010383,
-0.3897100985,
-0.0764667094,
-0.1389816701,
0.7738448381,
-0.2592172325,
0.1991267949,
0.1391369849,
-0.2849449217,
-0.4217734933,
0.0877943859,
0.5854999423,
0.858004868,
0.0141385486,
0.1298213452,
0.5046967268,
-0.3855253458,
0.332501173,
-0.4963772595,
-0.1665961444,
-0.2923244536,
0.3931895196,
0.4835497141,
0.7551031709,
-0.6965736151,
-0.0642038658,
0.2863530517,
-0.0794347823,
-0.9629112482,
0.2451177388,
0.2329667211,
0.0141701493,
0.4796383083,
-0.1084211543,
-0.220320791,
-0.8016596437,
0.4808986187,
0.1980617642,
-0.2005241215,
-0.2965805829,
0.4590926766,
0.0042191367,
-0.2483545244,
0.8777565956,
0.0966323465,
-0.5078948736,
0.3986307681,
1.1569558382,
0.9979479313,
-0.5517801642,
0.1410969049,
0.5210369229,
0.0893067867,
-0.366129905,
0.0571496375,
-0.0193310473,
-0.526411593,
-0.4808048606,
-0.7011966705,
-0.3178628683,
0.4170981348,
-0.5349325538,
-0.0130672064,
-0.7745603919,
0.1974313408,
-0.4503314793,
-0.4348808229,
-0.3259763122,
0.3109411895,
-0.0404788293,
0.6273688674,
-0.7869688272,
0.9500517249,
0.2871599197,
-0.3716719747,
-0.684689343,
0.2222775966,
0.035022594,
-0.7015117407,
0.4330467284,
0.1264286935,
-0.0998596177,
0.1525895745,
-0.4655627906,
-1.1060020924,
1.0559130907,
0.5711004734,
-0.8975034356,
0.1611288339,
0.1523974389,
0.6576351523,
-0.2763225734,
-0.1740919948,
0.4919961393,
0.191624552,
0.420606941,
-0.7602647543,
-0.1052337289,
-0.0165659431,
0.0594770797,
0.0439421907,
-0.7372788191,
0.5972661972,
-0.0033337318,
-0.3794811964,
0.0961861685,
0.5497097373,
0.5985866189,
0.1611087024,
0.3317943513,
0.5930688381,
0.5740881562,
0.0596214235,
0.8727063537,
-0.0205906294,
0.3710918725,
1.403725028,
-0.4186625779,
0.839556694,
0.423624754,
-0.0477878787,
0.2838662565,
0.4149670899,
0.2217056602,
0.6920518279,
0.4783204794,
-0.4194868207,
-0.6310166717,
0.3850185573,
-0.2646236718,
0.381162405,
0.3417016566,
-0.1343960762,
-0.1843566597,
0.105289422,
-0.04639332,
0.1753490865,
-0.3486185968,
0.8281688094,
0.327875942,
-0.91394943,
1.081966877,
-0.3883546591,
0.0477578901,
-0.7242432833,
0.1001924872,
-0.5782017112,
0.4231542051,
0.1425258666,
-0.3529470861,
0.4107604623,
-0.2164457291,
-0.2051574141,
-0.2961220145,
0.381413281,
-0.7186030149,
-0.4097248912,
0.2709356546,
-0.0012602676,
-0.0159513652,
-0.118006736,
-0.3995323777,
0.2421697229,
-0.3114213943,
-0.1470653862,
0.8635081053,
0.4310882986,
-0.0138940075,
1.0859071016,
0.6343476176,
0.1136299446,
0.0973889083,
0.2244881988,
1.0061872005,
-0.8964022994,
-0.6870504618,
-0.666033864,
0.427087754,
0.1355731338,
-0.118791461,
0.7494010925,
0.4368997812,
0.8241208792,
-0.4228647947,
0.7631052732,
0.502309382,
0.4194236398,
-1.0818052292,
1.0125843287,
-0.4284014404,
0.3269916773,
-0.2720558941,
-0.9637852907,
-0.2933894396,
0.6286442876,
0.0278178398,
0.1225993037,
0.7126911283,
0.7448260784,
-0.0639115348,
-0.2688806057,
0.5571189523,
0.4724127948,
0.3615354896,
0.6581798792,
1.017829299,
-0.2457190752,
0.3484733701,
-0.0158689003,
-0.0981947109,
-0.1271219254,
-0.8900623322,
-0.9930043817,
-0.8056620955,
-0.2945863605,
-0.2663929164,
0.2369272262,
0.82943362,
0.8782852888,
-0.8567363024,
-0.3766925335,
-0.509839952,
-0.1253666282,
-0.1774552763,
-0.1473006904,
0.2413680702,
-0.7933304906,
-0.4812747538,
1.0616242886,
0.3726338446,
0.3197078705,
-0.4567039907,
-0.1333710253,
0.0385297053,
0.1676175743,
0.5633702278,
0.4902499914,
-0.6187716126,
-0.4267943799,
-0.3847916722,
0.2131574899,
-0.0973911732,
0.8503296971,
-0.9163922668,
0.4962762296,
0.0559818782,
0.4739973247,
0.8242198825,
-0.3509302139,
0.8913016915,
-1.001221776,
0.144435972,
0.2839618027,
0.3637609184,
0.4497158825,
-0.1797967851,
0.3678839803,
0.2285310179,
-0.6848310828,
-0.8418456316,
0.3463127911,
-0.8346870542,
-0.1004918441,
1.1317932606,
-0.1745083183,
-0.0667361394,
-0.0079276823,
0.1193646118,
-0.0377527289,
-0.1562106311,
1.1727771759,
0.5848026872,
0.2470145971,
-0.1874004304,
-0.2025387883,
0.5282595158,
0.4627794325,
-0.5181477666,
0.4452784956,
0.6115788221,
0.6715466976,
-0.1698670685,
0.7652921081,
-0.2100549489,
0.2715243995,
-0.1115043312,
-0.0508933291,
-0.0184629261,
-0.9195889831,
-0.3690051436,
0.0520729199,
-0.0211000331,
0.1424556822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01242v1
|
Augmenting Automation: Intent-Based User Instruction Classification with Machine Learning
| 2024-03-02T16:06:03 | 2024-03-02T16:06:03 |
Lochan Basyal, Bijay Gaudel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Electric automation systems offer convenience and efficiency in controlling
electrical circuits and devices. Traditionally, these systems rely on
predefined commands for control, limiting flexibility and adaptability. In this
paper, we propose a novel approach to augment automation by introducing
intent-based user instruction classification using machine learning techniques.
Our system represents user instructions as intents, allowing for dynamic
control of electrical circuits without relying on predefined commands. Through
a machine learning model trained on a labeled dataset of user instructions, our
system classifies intents from user input, enabling a more intuitive and
adaptable control scheme. We present the design and implementation of our
intent-based electric automation system, detailing the development of the
machine learning model for intent classification. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in enhancing user experience and
expanding the capabilities of electric automation systems. Our work contributes
to the advancement of smart technologies by providing a more seamless
interaction between users and their environments.
|
[
-0.2954188287,
-0.522251308,
0.6884006262,
-0.0064811464,
0.2974026203,
-0.1923111677,
-0.0050202115,
-0.1929456443,
-0.0414152741,
0.6479738951,
-0.5776453614,
-0.3027325571,
-0.4245837629,
0.0838251412,
-0.2807768881,
0.5885158777,
-0.392826885,
-0.3073793948,
-0.1851931959,
0.098441191,
-0.6342890859,
-0.1827472299,
-0.1317680031,
-0.5282902122,
0.4113999009,
0.858289957,
0.3379564285,
0.1876485646,
0.4571730793,
0.4141682088,
0.6513778567,
0.5065429211,
-0.0127596511,
0.2384882569,
-0.0244683549,
-0.48851946,
-0.3522287309,
0.106385015,
0.1416323781,
0.6064630747,
-0.0973489583,
-0.016124608,
-0.1708461046,
0.5662730336,
-0.657625556,
0.366043359,
-0.3955115676,
0.1957962662,
0.3336670399,
-0.8740113974,
-0.9231302738,
-0.2450349182,
0.1233691126,
-0.655969739,
-0.2163768113,
0.1599393636,
0.6570119262,
0.2879950106,
-0.6633328199,
-0.3479237854,
-1.1493060589,
0.806527853,
-0.1189123392,
0.5462967753,
0.2175393552,
0.5786570907,
-0.0817198306,
-0.8707527518,
-0.5096160769,
-0.3226044178,
-0.2751555443,
0.0761349723,
0.2210630029,
0.3331564069,
0.3739060462,
-0.0612580441,
-0.37286672,
0.2189322561,
-0.2368103564,
-0.0470359921,
0.7967233658,
0.3205577731,
0.5065185428,
0.1064130813,
-0.4925833344,
-0.0183564909,
-0.4332236946,
0.4512022436,
0.5905386806,
0.2435847521,
0.3272679746,
0.6789431572,
-0.2639321089,
0.4978896677,
0.3594761491,
0.0541225784,
0.3471559286,
0.2528631687,
-0.5099796057,
0.4612738788,
0.577542305,
0.3149321973,
0.111217238,
-0.1166755408,
-0.4573130906,
-0.2792985737,
0.7364133596,
-0.5675271153,
-0.3861479163,
0.1135765836,
-0.4970248342,
-0.2872166336,
0.6163765192,
-0.1487376094,
-0.3324920833,
-0.8302586675,
0.6448427439,
-0.1857411414,
0.2779097855,
0.2492032945,
-0.2233156562,
0.2798525989,
0.8149545193,
-1.2635483742,
0.3825839758,
0.6859003901,
0.3026393354,
-0.0294156652,
-0.3049508929,
-0.42030707,
0.2998832464,
0.0026256682,
0.6101411581,
-0.5469191074,
-0.5194288492,
-0.1277175248,
0.3472582996,
-0.2341392785,
-0.2583495975,
0.2684033215,
-1.0954418182,
0.4220014811,
0.444992274,
-0.5595538616,
-0.7261966467,
-0.1140646785,
-0.5538514256,
0.5911155939,
0.2903702855,
-0.4490446746,
0.4304666519,
-1.1253958941,
-0.7525937557,
0.2146456987,
-0.1061527058,
-0.4533334672,
-0.0735926852,
-0.3080752194,
0.5555481315,
0.4747074842,
0.0155891385,
-0.2706583142,
-0.2207374573,
0.3709738851,
-0.6785417199,
0.7072263956,
0.0982986018,
-0.4143327475,
0.471067369,
-0.7025604844,
0.0284190681,
-0.2034880668,
-0.1521605402,
-0.1774678826,
0.0267248657,
-0.0773948655,
0.1420500875,
0.5009325743,
-0.4208716154,
0.2573640645,
-0.2582135797,
-0.0604537427,
0.7886931896,
-0.1410926282,
0.6496115327,
-0.2561388612,
0.3996736109,
-0.303355962,
0.3260097802,
-0.2009272575,
-0.4727654159,
-0.7026093006,
0.0278253462,
0.2108926326,
1.1498566866,
-0.4186258614,
1.082100153,
-0.0689399391,
-0.2221686989,
-0.1560639441,
0.2459017634,
-0.2373337746,
0.5731440187,
0.4687775075,
-0.2949000597,
-0.4741900861,
-0.699126184,
0.0265089162,
0.0538594797,
-0.3718730509,
0.6844696403,
0.1689099669,
-0.4723548293,
0.9340872169,
-0.5750164986,
-0.3091695905,
-0.409119904,
0.2532575727,
0.0441891104,
0.3606444001,
0.0873823091,
-0.9993833303,
-0.5970780253,
0.5934114456,
-0.753367424,
-0.0612071231,
-0.2513656318,
0.1426623464,
0.0095390221,
0.4782498777,
-0.2439339161,
0.8134379387,
0.1358137131,
-0.1616675556,
0.5830518007,
-0.4443649054,
0.4067031145,
-0.5616188049,
-0.1101765484,
-0.2391003668,
-0.3400771022,
-0.7348380685,
-0.5861384273,
0.1732422858,
0.1289556026,
-0.7188263535,
0.2468004078,
-0.1796720028,
-0.0336734615,
-0.5838676095,
-0.4591832459,
0.1224255487,
0.5286979675,
-0.033946991,
0.7275656462,
0.6228033304,
-1.0325241089,
0.6488279104,
0.2286867946,
-0.1963055134,
0.1958686411,
-0.2795424461,
0.0203507077,
-0.0203962885,
0.0118401544,
-0.6591354012,
-0.6433220506,
0.2559835017,
-0.313449651,
0.5141847134,
0.0746324807,
-0.2303311974,
-0.4803174138,
-0.1012244225,
0.0750223175,
0.8870351315,
-0.734069109,
1.0908905268,
0.2252582759,
-0.1516498476,
-0.2040268183,
-0.3934338689,
-0.2500174344,
-0.3039698303,
-0.4156426191,
0.2325156331,
0.1598291844,
-0.1906660348,
-0.1355899423,
0.0731105804,
-0.0905576348,
0.3247418106,
0.4841311574,
0.2710589767,
0.1084742919,
0.3591337204,
0.3702335954,
-0.2013362944,
0.3142195344,
-0.6243211031,
0.500423491,
0.0476764888,
-0.6356003881,
-1.3558111191,
0.3200978339,
0.622187376,
-0.0942409337,
0.2359197885,
0.2202786058,
-0.0561331734,
-0.5038107634,
-0.0959116071,
-0.3999175429,
-0.6679752469,
0.0604952089,
-0.26242733,
-0.647324264,
0.0100859543,
-0.55756706,
0.2208310217,
0.3846868277,
0.4079220891,
-0.635792315,
1.2425433397,
0.993268609,
0.3102718592,
1.0130896568,
-0.2637051344,
0.2645403445,
-0.5224549174,
-0.4137729108,
-0.1397298127,
-0.7366744876,
-0.4661032259,
-0.0403611101,
0.0784376934,
-0.4083362222,
-0.2452098429,
0.4366163909,
-0.649956882,
0.2297679484,
0.5465907454,
0.4997920394,
0.096689567,
0.0184869245,
0.2451452911,
0.3371796608,
-0.4999038875,
-0.9034986496,
1.2092523575,
0.3848630488,
1.0825945139,
-0.0485853516,
0.5621857643,
0.787622869,
0.3678177893,
-0.9622393847,
0.3625491858,
0.0482146777,
-0.0616407543,
-0.6589906812,
-0.3880695701,
-1.1468652487,
-0.2800456882,
0.2596181631,
-0.9007730484,
0.3001293242,
0.4061183035,
-0.5077100992,
0.2297904938,
-1.1658724546,
0.7906403542,
-0.9028164744,
-0.0894534737,
-0.071573168,
-0.5781922936,
0.2632129788,
0.2343427986,
-0.1418384612,
0.1221978664,
-0.1992487758,
0.57983464,
-0.5272510648,
0.5850020051,
-0.2040952593,
-0.1650166214,
0.4397565722,
-0.2616606653,
0.4785638452,
0.098763451,
-0.1033640727,
-0.3572392166,
-0.6940637827,
-0.205208376,
-0.8266884685,
0.6181630492,
-0.5424487591,
-0.4202817082,
-0.1081050709,
-0.6357591152,
-0.080847308,
0.4927659929,
-0.024987027,
0.4444402456,
-0.0190383997,
0.1310437471,
1.1408871412,
0.1501392722,
0.4542176723,
0.1849821359,
-0.2841760814,
-0.0311032124,
0.9390311837,
-0.1589445472,
0.1242322102,
0.7935890555,
-0.0078553772,
-0.5582992435,
-0.2690027654,
-0.3772947192,
-0.4588036537,
-0.551584363,
0.118337661,
-1.0269109011,
0.0241988711,
-0.4498130977,
-0.5994526744,
0.1413297355,
-0.3953200579,
-0.6890898347,
-0.1175023317,
0.4632412195,
0.5498619676,
0.4429055154,
0.770234406,
-0.6436110139,
0.3810035288,
0.8154739738,
0.4804747105,
-0.4653099775,
-0.3235758543,
0.0224732608,
-0.2175677419,
-0.7549241781,
-0.789231658,
0.3712475896,
0.1206914857,
0.6346445084,
0.7481324077,
0.2608821094,
-0.1529249847,
-0.591385603,
0.3843031526,
0.4585689008,
-0.6469861269,
0.6652387977,
0.0400755517,
0.1387282908,
0.7350236177,
0.3971654475,
-0.1096519083,
0.1194556952,
-0.7318165302,
-0.6915299296,
0.8092769384,
-0.3008312583,
0.1479100436,
0.4547432363,
-0.0240904093,
0.3008841872,
0.1892009825,
-0.2601687014,
-0.3073097765,
-0.3056943119,
-0.5854396224,
0.0541408248,
0.3225094676,
-0.0594197176,
-0.1274546385,
0.7283207178,
-0.1587245464,
0.3936459124,
-0.1051246002,
-0.3518891335,
-0.0251171179,
0.382923156,
0.6240695119,
0.3762433231,
-0.1159957126,
0.0736567676,
0.3335822523,
-0.5172230601,
0.4244396687,
0.185142681,
-0.4675046802,
-0.0429248959,
-0.2997310758,
0.9872084856,
0.0137575762,
-0.6275018454,
0.2907592952,
-0.3871830106,
-0.32880193,
-0.4918150604,
0.8818131089,
-0.291785866,
0.0014528733,
0.1336355954,
0.4270402193,
0.6671715975,
-0.3217360675,
0.5285621881,
0.1376318038,
-0.7491025925,
-0.1276379526,
0.4427181482,
0.4891101718,
-0.7897821069,
0.3234307468,
-0.3829842508,
-0.5742955804,
0.7996489406,
0.2930226028,
0.9918037653,
-0.3328378201,
0.0479234941,
-0.0040355246,
0.2258342803,
0.3323154151,
0.4382332265,
-0.3232179582,
-0.2997969985,
-0.1696452796,
-0.2706688344,
-0.4723965526,
-0.0274577755,
-0.2624222934,
0.7582260966,
-0.5507472754,
0.1756488979,
-0.1535662562,
-0.1185329631,
-0.7801980376,
0.2537328303,
-0.0295523908,
1.0166122913,
-0.8085838556,
0.6732804775,
0.8949517012,
0.0145582538,
-0.8103186488,
0.0065447586,
-0.2478444874,
-0.3105193675,
0.6684939861,
0.725148499,
-0.195649758,
0.3472503424,
-0.3000792861,
-0.2972295582,
1.2745131254,
-0.4402288198,
-0.2901653051,
0.2695603371,
-0.1847385019,
0.2263984531,
-0.312294364,
0.4781310558,
0.2066933066,
0.8707956672,
-0.0343685113,
-0.6183282733,
-0.2385998219,
-0.0836768374,
-0.3783793747,
0.4139148593,
-0.2000332475,
0.3172224164,
-0.3185178339,
-0.2551300824,
-0.1814327538,
1.0587226152,
-0.164665848,
0.7075877786,
0.7175287008,
0.1173383519,
0.7392320633,
0.0190299153,
0.7566572428,
-0.1963933706,
0.2879050076,
0.8325639367,
-0.4822838008,
0.3563024402,
0.3213097453,
-0.2725474536,
0.752904892,
0.3318605423,
0.0795769989,
0.6126883626,
-0.1140568852,
-0.6488620639,
-0.2168859392,
0.1319255531,
0.0881378353,
0.3042133749,
0.6926717162,
-0.3673299253,
-0.1137922779,
0.4798672795,
-0.5789871812,
-0.1037341505,
-0.5092907548,
0.9547004104,
-0.2033634484,
-0.4492673576,
-0.015033273,
0.0082904566,
0.5801886916,
-0.4508049786,
-0.1966090351,
0.6142160296,
0.2497428805,
-0.5925226808,
-0.8311729431,
0.0720344707,
-0.094486326,
-0.2434987575,
-0.6016743779,
0.9947693348,
-0.2627469599,
-0.317519635,
-0.175710097,
-0.0044595213,
0.186943233,
0.4433693886,
-0.3830297589,
-0.4071006477,
0.0342195332,
-0.2215439826,
0.0538420528,
0.595957756,
-0.2182179838,
0.8535827994,
0.5643056035,
-0.314030081,
0.2107633948,
-0.0811644718,
0.5057219863,
-0.4222205281,
-0.6177761555,
-0.3719667196,
0.6764688492,
-0.2259152234,
-0.0397165716,
0.7125198245,
0.4547825456,
0.9165894389,
-0.1925018579,
1.2086412907,
-0.2636173964,
0.2272387445,
-0.3339438438,
0.3733291924,
-0.403611213,
0.3287397027,
0.2032127529,
-0.4166475832,
-0.2329279631,
0.2962029576,
-0.7008357644,
0.2779136598,
0.5166905522,
0.5492885709,
-0.648671031,
0.096273236,
0.5416178107,
-0.3777683973,
0.2811467946,
0.2582608759,
0.9906424284,
-0.0755231008,
0.1576659828,
-0.4267770946,
-0.6085159779,
-0.9133665562,
-0.5516290069,
-0.5448067188,
-0.3097271025,
-0.0697267205,
0.1576557606,
-0.3001512587,
1.0527516603,
0.5215839744,
-0.9277836084,
-0.1279587597,
-0.5660324693,
0.4488946199,
-0.4730469286,
-0.2953355908,
0.1035964489,
-0.7377050519,
-0.6406881213,
0.3531745374,
0.5853971243,
0.171437636,
-0.1554074436,
-0.4319884181,
-0.0552714169,
0.172280997,
0.8123142123,
0.506746769,
-0.5457735062,
-0.2455143929,
0.2037052065,
-0.2394245863,
-0.0061151721,
0.8561933637,
-0.7621612549,
0.4157286882,
0.6846724749,
0.6647180319,
-0.183386296,
0.3003539443,
0.4630656838,
-0.3752458096,
-0.2139745355,
0.2721378803,
0.3532810807,
0.0319533199,
-0.8500061035,
-0.2103896588,
-0.1293717623,
-0.7773561478,
-0.3660902679,
0.4397002459,
-1.2424298525,
-0.3131998479,
0.7443489432,
-0.1209532544,
-0.4204819202,
-0.529475987,
-0.624786675,
0.2800503671,
-0.4841240048,
0.9327816963,
-0.04948131,
-0.9234687686,
-0.0804466382,
-0.424216032,
0.1616822034,
0.1954784691,
-1.2490724325,
0.0023848119,
0.374576956,
-0.1546098441,
0.2766744196,
0.2137032449,
0.2297362983,
0.6974042058,
-0.5516480803,
0.275719583,
-0.320874691,
-0.9446080923,
-0.2922165692,
0.3739622533,
-0.1849464029,
-0.47512272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01241v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01241v2
|
IntactKV: Improving Large Language Model Quantization by Keeping Pivot Tokens Intact
| 2024-03-02T16:05:26 | 2024-05-25T10:33:03 |
Ruikang Liu, Haoli Bai, Haokun Lin, Yuening Li, Han Gao, Zhengzhuo Xu, Lu Hou, Jun Yao, Chun Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel in natural language processing but demand
intensive computation. To mitigate this, various quantization methods have been
explored, yet they compromise LLM performance. This paper unveils a previously
overlooked type of outliers in LLMs. Such outliers are found to allocate most
of the attention scores on initial tokens of input, termed as pivot tokens,
which are crucial to the performance of quantized LLMs. Given that, we propose
IntactKV to generate the KV cache of pivot tokens losslessly from the
full-precision model. The approach is simple and easy to combine with existing
quantization solutions with no extra inference overhead. Besides, IntactKV can
be calibrated as additional LLM parameters to boost the quantized LLMs further
with minimal training costs. Mathematical analysis also proves that IntactKV
effectively reduces the upper bound of quantization error. Empirical results
show that IntactKV brings consistent improvement over various quantization
methods across different LLMs and downstream tasks, leading to the new
state-of-the-art for LLM quantization. The codes are available at
https://github.com/ruikangliu/IntactKV.
|
[
0.1662754864,
-0.6727228761,
0.5616714954,
0.1542731524,
-0.69201684,
0.0676740482,
-0.5115675926,
0.0046115695,
0.0934372246,
0.6821183562,
-0.2313162982,
-0.5366030931,
-0.5622558594,
-0.2399720103,
-0.2808797359,
0.8385694623,
0.1096835956,
0.2111646235,
-0.2549576759,
-0.2160000354,
-0.3888657391,
-0.3937038183,
-0.373060286,
-0.2456737459,
0.1406509876,
0.3351801634,
0.645006001,
0.8397780061,
0.5448631048,
0.2887169719,
-0.2629909515,
0.1866145283,
-0.498275876,
0.5288786292,
0.1643932909,
-0.6538290381,
-0.4376635551,
-0.4252237976,
0.9991230965,
0.6293948889,
-0.3583744466,
0.0304663572,
-0.049976144,
0.9589118958,
-0.9662649035,
0.3131305873,
-0.8040232658,
-0.0791475996,
-0.4331905544,
0.2451530546,
-0.6966947317,
-0.3337358236,
-0.1936935931,
-0.5064697862,
-0.2255672961,
-0.2714732587,
0.6979546547,
0.5544871688,
-0.3406453729,
0.2138910294,
-0.6267018914,
0.6556989551,
-0.7857370377,
0.4619919062,
0.2804523706,
0.1511919647,
-0.3545988202,
-0.920732379,
-0.2572875619,
-0.0023766547,
0.1942469925,
0.1855545789,
-0.0857058316,
0.20707798,
0.0305674672,
0.4498570859,
-0.3322914243,
0.0197809301,
-0.3938209414,
-0.1968100518,
0.358831495,
0.2945289314,
0.2603884637,
-0.2095694989,
-0.1107320487,
-0.0152650801,
-0.9772546291,
0.2574936152,
0.3172888756,
0.2895410657,
0.1313717067,
0.8815302849,
-0.2880249023,
0.4481953382,
-0.0065192934,
-0.1495917886,
0.1427069753,
-0.4239956439,
-0.3594360948,
0.3157745898,
0.7556099892,
0.1061682403,
0.253628999,
-0.0529166535,
-0.0236927383,
-0.0422286838,
0.4274818897,
-0.8973072171,
-0.5661551952,
0.1735524237,
-0.3931126893,
-0.2539436221,
0.1835679263,
-0.3104960322,
-0.1128350645,
-0.3925825357,
0.3080921173,
-0.5659707189,
-0.2894411087,
0.0197746418,
0.2964820266,
0.1961596906,
0.3512021303,
-0.7516517639,
-0.0543153919,
1.1140533686,
0.8744604588,
-0.2247348279,
0.100366585,
-0.9154788256,
0.1600055844,
-0.5669649839,
0.5392534137,
-0.4983960092,
-0.1759156138,
-0.0187511444,
0.0137613891,
0.3891752362,
-0.4469425082,
0.6269091964,
-0.4021275342,
-0.127912432,
-0.2315102518,
-0.5575445294,
0.0286394469,
0.1352188587,
-0.5919517279,
1.3128528595,
0.0745230168,
-0.7982190847,
0.5283524394,
-0.3579436541,
-0.3132176697,
0.3759753108,
0.0806830078,
-0.7282819152,
0.5598580241,
0.2482565939,
0.3813174963,
0.0183239095,
0.4898967743,
-0.3516891003,
-0.3764593899,
0.273545891,
-0.5074931383,
0.7945641279,
-0.0758178458,
-0.0846276656,
0.2461169064,
-0.6426566243,
0.3096932471,
-0.1654977649,
-0.667114079,
-0.5267273188,
0.03388004,
-0.152648285,
-0.2230161428,
-0.0410441719,
-0.5732879639,
0.4621723592,
-0.9875556231,
0.5749909878,
0.856746316,
-0.0877589136,
0.560461998,
0.2578175962,
0.3379077613,
0.1683827937,
0.1357468218,
-0.6039186716,
-0.3914827108,
-0.8336516619,
-0.8184012175,
0.5680987835,
0.0286180433,
-0.773347497,
0.4405643642,
-0.7129993439,
-0.4655679464,
-0.7133208513,
0.0005221358,
0.2379980832,
0.4551665187,
-0.0534694791,
-0.1408690661,
-0.4586877227,
-0.9705209136,
-0.3715605736,
-0.1399116218,
-0.2485270947,
-0.285366863,
0.2446777523,
-0.0487308763,
1.0864528418,
-0.3544533849,
-0.2120573521,
0.0399786793,
-0.0729431212,
0.2450042814,
0.3396425843,
-0.0372971743,
-0.6685320735,
-0.8456915021,
0.2133144587,
-0.3017085493,
0.0036413823,
0.2762542963,
-0.3519197404,
0.3991000354,
0.5243643522,
-0.6795728803,
0.559661448,
0.3418142796,
-0.2836858034,
0.3711822927,
-0.2451916933,
-0.0041137924,
-1.1292257309,
0.0723117217,
-0.3617639244,
-0.750402689,
-0.592579782,
-0.1469147205,
0.6264526844,
0.204053238,
-0.7296817303,
0.2741951346,
-0.4392670095,
-0.081825912,
-0.3898869157,
0.0787379146,
0.0579344928,
0.4544345737,
-0.2935795188,
0.6429635286,
0.4928412139,
-0.3092801273,
0.4896785915,
0.1573197693,
-0.5105729103,
0.3263972998,
-0.6146181226,
0.0440245904,
-0.3124113679,
0.161839202,
-0.752997756,
-0.2146751136,
0.2574266791,
-0.4525417089,
0.5027566552,
-0.4625206292,
-0.7125939131,
0.2471312881,
-0.5296514034,
0.4992713034,
0.6708287597,
-0.3371903002,
0.6227349043,
0.4601821601,
-0.121516794,
-0.5115420222,
-0.7017578483,
-0.0172474328,
-0.1686028987,
-0.4865059555,
0.1742937714,
0.1133032143,
-0.1427138597,
-0.0027605714,
-0.2512645125,
-0.0019137602,
-0.0305398069,
0.3260585964,
0.2259320617,
-0.3392030895,
0.3710578978,
0.193126753,
-0.2705960274,
-0.0875051767,
-0.4802247286,
0.4858859479,
-0.341889739,
-0.4185054898,
-0.4060496092,
0.0954666808,
0.9103514552,
-0.3427748084,
0.8510332108,
0.4325031936,
-0.4511411786,
0.0498388261,
-0.4561629295,
0.0573229864,
-0.4838910103,
0.743751049,
-0.1612663269,
-0.8837952018,
0.3983013034,
-0.1339135468,
0.0039667441,
0.2896596789,
0.953653872,
0.0965652615,
1.0172593594,
0.5204530954,
0.0057791858,
0.5052465796,
0.0263417549,
0.3483555615,
-1.0416065454,
-0.3352304101,
-0.3670836985,
-0.1134267747,
-0.4034327865,
-0.4917651415,
0.5014783144,
0.3340831101,
-0.2925515175,
-0.0660388097,
-0.539919436,
0.6708394885,
0.3418129086,
0.074983418,
0.3038412035,
0.1023155972,
-0.1869324446,
-0.358881712,
-0.6976071596,
-0.4026421607,
1.1787568331,
0.2867625058,
0.6864883304,
0.0001990191,
0.2299785763,
0.0308760162,
0.4760893583,
-0.8816873431,
0.0918134227,
-0.2573670745,
-0.3922133446,
-0.4858062565,
-0.4238498807,
-0.8452720642,
0.4035492539,
-0.0084441956,
-0.836314559,
-0.075108543,
0.1618948132,
-0.304260999,
0.3213513196,
-0.6415528655,
0.8299714923,
-0.1317920238,
-0.2618956566,
0.1989855021,
-0.5437328219,
0.546870172,
-0.2447023392,
0.0277024452,
-0.3460286558,
-0.1979764104,
0.5759770274,
-0.7504807115,
0.7445377707,
-0.0957173333,
-0.0682396069,
0.2002816647,
0.0136119509,
0.9214043021,
0.3358853161,
0.0907675922,
0.1756364256,
0.0195212979,
-0.4702528715,
-0.666010797,
0.600102365,
-0.5643598437,
-0.35428828,
-0.0656552091,
-0.3738000989,
-0.0420994796,
0.3309214115,
0.2380458862,
0.369430542,
0.2263106257,
0.8447698951,
0.8009201884,
-0.0313910916,
0.5060658455,
0.355161339,
-0.0488500446,
-0.8232159615,
0.6986347437,
0.0267059747,
0.3361378312,
0.4120118916,
0.3459607065,
-0.2105365843,
-0.4630676806,
-0.2972380221,
0.1106278077,
-0.779802382,
-0.7811816931,
-0.6858274341,
-0.075861454,
-0.3113181889,
0.0142125105,
-1.3343046904,
-0.4938865006,
-0.1987112015,
-0.0766095519,
0.4893724322,
0.3338081241,
0.189124316,
0.4198366702,
-1.0184736252,
0.1644993722,
0.0341838747,
0.4668940306,
-0.0032238241,
-0.49683249,
-0.4732812047,
0.3212175965,
-0.1662406325,
-0.488056004,
0.5178110003,
0.334654063,
0.3048026562,
0.536736846,
0.3028042316,
0.9146648049,
-0.6277022362,
0.6294776797,
0.2760871649,
-1.1854419708,
0.4224637747,
-0.1295743436,
0.5799355507,
0.7280113101,
-0.0703998432,
-0.7115501761,
-0.4827837646,
-0.2542767823,
-1.2621639967,
0.866759181,
0.3038153052,
0.1900039762,
0.1378913075,
0.6517055035,
0.304669559,
0.227739349,
-0.962451756,
-0.2277225703,
-0.0489593185,
-0.5153448582,
0.3451036513,
-0.4511907101,
0.1893007159,
-0.3482103944,
0.6433239579,
-0.1717757881,
0.0521051437,
0.0982059538,
-0.2166930288,
-0.3430409729,
-0.0768517181,
0.6236432791,
0.7603853941,
0.1554688811,
0.2503170967,
0.1606403887,
-0.7220714688,
0.1106237397,
-0.438041389,
-0.1479619592,
-0.0860022157,
0.3637796342,
0.7094465494,
0.4840062559,
-0.8058963418,
0.6977064013,
-0.2717109025,
-0.0548848771,
-0.3400445282,
-0.1540772468,
0.1939453036,
0.3538253903,
0.3763276041,
-0.1868252009,
-0.2802624404,
-0.3799138367,
0.0820971951,
0.4900351763,
-0.4121491015,
-0.352817446,
0.6212034822,
0.0021890316,
-0.40110147,
0.9511808753,
0.0671310499,
-0.8247211576,
0.2547366321,
0.2037875503,
0.9899616838,
-0.1398387253,
-0.0747085065,
0.0482888483,
0.5609543324,
-0.2199186385,
0.0113092745,
-0.1551939398,
-0.425747484,
-0.9071633816,
-0.6464475393,
-0.1757581681,
-0.0843453184,
-0.4629686773,
0.4638986886,
-0.1183595061,
0.1655271649,
-0.3869964778,
-0.1447524428,
-0.3276634514,
-0.1721655279,
-0.0492747128,
0.451151222,
-0.6017917395,
1.1581457853,
0.6359875202,
-0.0233216509,
-0.5926847458,
-0.0954709202,
-0.4993804395,
-0.6405050159,
0.7024610639,
0.1296364963,
0.3350546062,
-0.1931898296,
-0.5844526291,
-1.1176977158,
0.9192410707,
0.8115863204,
-0.5788154006,
0.1624100506,
0.3389842808,
0.3264409304,
0.0144160567,
0.1716099232,
0.4395662844,
0.406026125,
0.1097438484,
-0.743241787,
-0.0255950876,
-0.0233754683,
0.026254816,
0.7811973095,
-0.6471219063,
0.5810099244,
0.2333203107,
-0.1656219661,
-0.1302602142,
0.6811813116,
0.3439388871,
0.017205365,
0.1948352903,
0.641009748,
0.6265407801,
-0.3185012341,
0.6886040568,
-0.2054935545,
0.4344688356,
0.8763382435,
-0.0777288154,
0.8653904796,
0.7622814775,
-0.3119300604,
-0.1662177593,
0.5140282512,
0.2066275328,
0.6300854683,
0.1766833961,
-0.2030769587,
-0.4350760579,
0.3296842277,
-0.1564135849,
0.6044377685,
0.2039534748,
-0.123770833,
-0.0899252966,
0.1040560603,
0.1738378704,
-0.2861292958,
-0.3348426819,
0.7647097111,
0.1533605158,
-0.597466886,
0.4847414196,
0.1995279342,
0.5179352164,
-0.6412757039,
0.0399638414,
-0.2973455191,
0.3867150247,
-0.0531913564,
-0.3571661413,
0.5617156625,
-0.1127337068,
-0.2003763914,
-0.2953864038,
0.6631585956,
-0.5327447057,
-0.8110314012,
-0.3106266856,
0.0161948539,
0.1338067502,
-0.4375841022,
-0.2231327891,
0.3296746612,
0.0986312926,
-0.4326874912,
0.3862869442,
0.8818922043,
-0.0609114878,
0.7279322743,
0.6444678903,
0.1480352283,
0.3693647683,
-0.4042430818,
0.9757964611,
-0.5215810537,
-0.5102236867,
-1.2541538477,
0.9530400634,
0.0724512711,
-0.2422302067,
0.5932307243,
0.6856080294,
0.5806407332,
0.0458617844,
0.3206115961,
0.4085656106,
0.0826435089,
-0.6183494925,
0.9282246232,
-0.4774905443,
0.247561276,
-0.1707575768,
-1.0943248272,
-0.5105003715,
0.4306329489,
0.1002783701,
-0.2783812284,
0.5929173231,
0.3955480754,
-0.0145023642,
-0.2155853063,
0.5455555916,
0.3131998181,
0.4702374637,
0.3746089339,
0.7297924161,
-0.4606935382,
0.7269928455,
-0.2614112198,
-0.030726783,
-0.2987081707,
-1.0783853531,
-0.6652824283,
-0.3979413211,
-0.5903596878,
-0.0421888903,
0.0696998015,
0.7586712837,
0.7447071075,
-0.5508515239,
0.1927087754,
-0.2880649567,
0.2655906081,
0.2554517388,
-0.2562276721,
0.5694369674,
-0.3828866482,
-0.78284657,
0.1624119878,
0.8294632435,
-0.244477421,
-0.2130827755,
-0.1222058982,
0.1124722436,
-0.1934241503,
0.6737603545,
-0.1521839947,
-0.796464026,
-0.1477300525,
-0.0724156946,
0.0765366405,
0.4011664689,
0.8944329023,
-0.7533839345,
0.7364305258,
0.4521998763,
0.8605453372,
0.615673244,
0.0154268639,
0.669706583,
-0.95173347,
0.2600201964,
0.368252337,
0.3251931369,
0.3325772583,
-0.3901427984,
0.2137004733,
0.169534862,
-0.6136864424,
-1.349421978,
0.0019585332,
-0.7603402138,
-0.1866703182,
1.0054664612,
-0.2120858133,
-0.5015776753,
0.0706994608,
-0.0912767574,
0.3935392201,
-0.3599689305,
0.5526370406,
0.8145503402,
0.1554156691,
-0.1821042448,
-0.406013757,
0.3399163783,
0.4127901495,
-0.5668202639,
0.4117702842,
0.2385727018,
0.2414302975,
-0.2336486727,
0.3570646644,
-0.4567008913,
0.1345758736,
-0.1833662689,
0.1772617102,
-0.084974356,
0.0142314276,
-0.3702120483,
0.1164889336,
0.0568061769,
-0.2253922671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01222v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01222v2
|
Emotion Analysis in NLP: Trends, Gaps and Roadmap for Future Directions
| 2024-03-02T14:38:03 | 2024-03-18T10:51:14 |
Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Alba Curry, Amanda Cercas Curry, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotions are a central aspect of communication. Consequently, emotion
analysis (EA) is a rapidly growing field in natural language processing (NLP).
However, there is no consensus on scope, direction, or methods. In this paper,
we conduct a thorough review of 154 relevant NLP publications from the last
decade. Based on this review, we address four different questions: (1) How are
EA tasks defined in NLP? (2) What are the most prominent emotion frameworks and
which emotions are modeled? (3) Is the subjectivity of emotions considered in
terms of demographics and cultural factors? and (4) What are the primary NLP
applications for EA? We take stock of trends in EA and tasks, emotion
frameworks used, existing datasets, methods, and applications. We then discuss
four lacunae: (1) the absence of demographic and cultural aspects does not
account for the variation in how emotions are perceived, but instead assumes
they are universally experienced in the same manner; (2) the poor fit of
emotion categories from the two main emotion theories to the task; (3) the lack
of standardized EA terminology hinders gap identification, comparison, and
future goals; and (4) the absence of interdisciplinary research isolates EA
from insights in other fields. Our work will enable more focused research into
EA and a more holistic approach to modeling emotions in NLP.
|
[
-0.71336025,
-0.5338203907,
0.2690479159,
0.5982182026,
0.1287135333,
0.1662294865,
-0.2524068952,
-0.9838531613,
0.3375794291,
0.2665281594,
-0.6127813458,
-0.5931931734,
-0.8107196093,
0.4221827686,
-0.3690965176,
0.7091309428,
-0.1454303414,
-0.2924567759,
-0.1425756365,
-0.5590757728,
-0.4388523996,
-0.8586745262,
-0.6216959357,
-0.2657660842,
0.5104942322,
0.2812118828,
0.309887439,
0.1224274561,
0.5679867268,
0.3669013381,
-0.4234232903,
-0.1797444969,
-0.2928856909,
0.2346748561,
0.1414173096,
-0.394492954,
-0.6185564399,
0.1223490164,
0.2268298268,
0.8059194684,
0.0266296975,
0.147747919,
0.0044436813,
1.2482795715,
-0.6356557012,
0.2454184741,
-0.2463903278,
0.4747757018,
-0.2464173436,
-0.2365525365,
-0.164564237,
0.0552409254,
0.4286946654,
-0.0366278552,
0.2402104139,
0.0009998409,
0.6148872972,
0.161292851,
-0.7438720465,
-0.5447781086,
-0.569781363,
0.891462326,
-0.6341391802,
0.3927899897,
0.1791688353,
-0.239161253,
0.181472823,
-0.5069214106,
-0.3355796635,
0.1063408926,
0.1148272231,
0.3373228014,
-0.6846886277,
0.1856724769,
0.2501625717,
0.3248966932,
-0.4749812186,
0.1157447025,
-0.1218655035,
0.2604450285,
0.7817577124,
0.3050529063,
0.4262781143,
-0.0377180539,
-0.3826481998,
0.2376700789,
-0.4210547507,
0.0863806084,
0.4475774169,
-0.1347287297,
-0.0209347941,
0.3972400427,
-0.2850455344,
0.4677804708,
0.0554380156,
0.4520593882,
0.1997597069,
0.0060565658,
-0.1552636772,
-0.2035760731,
0.766358614,
0.5762037635,
0.0388374217,
-0.2003568709,
-0.0503860489,
0.1485831439,
0.501606226,
-0.3782562912,
0.1245217025,
0.7492153049,
-0.5574693084,
-0.0619924292,
-0.1891682148,
-1.3034384251,
-0.2371248305,
-0.3201119304,
-0.2995757163,
-0.0227668751,
-0.4456311166,
0.0174903981,
0.0604406036,
0.2265651971,
0.1424862444,
-0.9152064919,
0.4696062207,
0.8518440723,
0.7203111053,
-0.3382905424,
-0.1644209474,
0.1719380319,
-0.5653253198,
-0.3188909292,
0.7593743205,
-0.4633886814,
-0.2759738266,
0.5159431696,
0.0703611672,
-0.0381192267,
-0.3391929269,
0.6081061959,
-0.3593555987,
0.333106041,
-0.5589668751,
-0.4226675034,
-0.406158179,
0.3098016083,
-0.7058120966,
1.0639159679,
-0.1468687803,
-0.7451549172,
0.162442252,
-0.8428502679,
-0.3089099228,
0.0481977127,
0.1997499913,
0.0649067089,
0.3291601241,
-0.1316816211,
0.4310543835,
-0.3858039081,
0.1440173239,
-0.2302913368,
-0.1870966852,
0.0341315381,
0.1298930049,
0.7155373693,
0.1613699794,
-0.6723988056,
-0.0642788559,
-0.5257469416,
-0.075464502,
-0.1810816675,
-0.0145448465,
-0.2485572547,
0.3607005775,
0.2923364639,
0.3591528237,
0.2103093266,
-0.4527056515,
-0.0442402922,
-0.4604099095,
0.24229002,
0.4864221811,
-0.1487033516,
0.5747041702,
0.2230187804,
0.8414378762,
-0.2532960773,
0.0404252261,
0.0226918701,
-0.7010037303,
-0.8299770951,
0.4198447168,
0.0699937865,
0.5846713185,
-0.0921119303,
0.6765646338,
0.3221303821,
-0.5011242628,
-0.5370150805,
-0.14366512,
0.137241438,
0.3524292409,
0.4079807103,
-0.3490071297,
-0.5165266991,
-0.6129943728,
-0.4955178797,
-0.3179711998,
0.161470145,
-0.0655863807,
0.2542853057,
-0.2389953583,
0.8829500079,
-0.4069935977,
-0.3814704418,
-0.3772320449,
0.6804665327,
-0.132582128,
0.279595226,
0.6769891381,
-0.8907753229,
-0.3928225636,
0.0250386298,
-0.8538455367,
-0.4539065659,
0.0140274633,
0.0839336812,
0.3883957863,
0.4219545126,
-0.618975997,
0.3926011026,
0.7350844145,
-0.3468107581,
0.3313184083,
0.1844100952,
0.0750258863,
-0.6458620429,
0.2949421108,
0.4412809312,
0.3785595596,
-1.0037769079,
0.0788386017,
-0.2361070961,
-0.101992391,
-0.2458544374,
0.5615605712,
-0.6584692597,
0.1053675562,
-0.4603097439,
0.1093878448,
-0.0367250815,
0.5018007159,
0.2066702992,
0.065427646,
0.4607857168,
-0.4516106248,
0.4573175013,
0.2836849093,
0.0280366298,
0.695761621,
-0.4894031286,
0.3013625741,
-0.3395326734,
0.1570521295,
-0.6958872676,
0.0659055039,
0.189093262,
-0.3499471545,
0.1773317307,
0.132257387,
-0.0183867291,
-0.3163750768,
-0.2102967799,
0.2337929308,
0.51854074,
-0.0134948175,
0.7749076486,
0.490881592,
-0.5700521469,
-0.7539741993,
-0.612744689,
0.2859893441,
-0.438546598,
-0.4471634924,
0.1501459479,
-0.1106359884,
-0.6647100449,
0.0259060729,
-0.2936882675,
-0.3713243604,
0.1764874607,
0.3958199322,
-0.1597768962,
-0.0855475515,
0.2087571621,
-0.1386394054,
-0.1284379214,
0.4367693961,
0.1427606791,
0.2623827755,
-0.5359991193,
-0.076662302,
-0.16131787,
0.8857740164,
0.2361284345,
-0.3526158035,
0.4234564602,
0.7739629149,
-0.4444929063,
-0.0541745052,
-0.5994354486,
0.2138777226,
-0.3191443384,
0.5161297321,
0.0159095638,
-0.8478697538,
0.5832948685,
-0.1187474057,
0.2257609516,
0.6417299509,
0.5580740571,
-0.3509336412,
0.9295094609,
1.0790094137,
-0.0589766167,
0.551635921,
-0.2263198793,
0.4310761094,
-0.8390929103,
-0.1136878952,
-0.785290122,
-0.6467578411,
-0.5976495147,
0.1212682948,
-0.0687602535,
-0.0270845611,
0.3204504848,
0.0895610601,
-0.2366425097,
0.2046596557,
0.1837501079,
-0.4887257814,
-0.000310963,
-0.4010287523,
0.560567379,
-0.2530373037,
-0.5938917994,
-0.6236503124,
0.6326472163,
0.5529485345,
0.2579838634,
0.0475488864,
0.6506639123,
0.2412580103,
0.5598440766,
-0.9451127052,
0.4958921373,
-0.076290153,
-0.7224318981,
-0.2317838073,
-0.1532104164,
-1.127374649,
0.3498222828,
-0.3422281742,
-1.1882419586,
0.435025543,
0.0252877641,
-0.0611661673,
0.153470099,
-0.6565129161,
1.0530982018,
-0.1350965351,
-0.1557341516,
0.0407280102,
-0.8360772729,
0.5631488562,
-0.1057005078,
0.3586528599,
-0.4994438291,
0.1436051875,
0.8491777182,
-0.1443979144,
0.719383657,
-0.1796390861,
-0.2079185992,
0.3659707606,
-0.093328692,
0.0695178583,
-0.2965925634,
-0.0718804449,
0.2801434994,
0.2827529013,
-0.2235960066,
-0.5757240057,
0.4159263074,
-0.356148988,
-0.5202066302,
-0.5834352374,
-0.3829392493,
-0.4355377853,
0.0164374392,
0.2438605428,
0.0992437154,
-0.3921899199,
0.0556103215,
0.4202751219,
-0.168362841,
0.4783598185,
0.2150481641,
0.1224888861,
0.0794182345,
0.6423566937,
0.0265713111,
0.0236325953,
0.2459528148,
0.0092233717,
-0.0946490318,
-0.4359182715,
0.028914595,
-0.018279247,
-0.6661503315,
-0.0543681197,
-0.8469253778,
0.2143615484,
-0.382576108,
-0.1299882829,
-0.3656642437,
0.0567313656,
-0.3919655383,
-0.0676963776,
0.2946249843,
0.8032345772,
0.0311081633,
0.2770128548,
-0.9082133174,
0.2765047848,
0.0499833785,
0.3925614059,
0.2226511836,
0.0289799124,
-0.2559752762,
-0.2175637335,
-0.240578711,
-1.2317994833,
0.7195636034,
0.1444031745,
0.1819077283,
0.3954955339,
0.2246089429,
0.4667128026,
-0.4031527638,
0.9727625251,
0.1814139336,
-1.1408404112,
0.2597003579,
-0.0376293585,
0.2183015496,
0.4925559461,
0.5454418063,
-1.0427681208,
-0.3612660468,
-0.7889134884,
-1.3433269262,
0.662084043,
0.0081293229,
0.2263766229,
-0.1106522605,
0.1751860082,
-0.0830609351,
0.2296048254,
-0.5246117115,
-0.353407532,
0.2418161035,
-0.4469485581,
-0.0106557021,
-0.2450818568,
-0.1952287108,
0.177540049,
0.2265312225,
-0.1089170948,
0.5135976076,
0.1185077429,
0.087603204,
-0.3311440051,
0.3146478236,
0.3332999051,
0.4840598404,
-0.3494576216,
-0.0494553521,
0.2604809999,
-0.3923246861,
0.0426359512,
0.0052566272,
0.1606889218,
0.2170573175,
0.5627491474,
0.7184488177,
0.3031687737,
-0.6029245853,
0.6160039902,
-0.013025932,
-0.2726216018,
-0.2598028481,
-0.4255848825,
0.0618142076,
0.442233026,
0.4213765264,
0.0158297122,
0.4064220786,
-0.7388472557,
-0.0793631077,
0.3386513293,
-0.5837715864,
-0.5497600436,
0.469650209,
0.4483510852,
-0.2509199977,
0.293952316,
-0.1167308018,
-0.639901042,
0.786763072,
0.0896541849,
1.2008458376,
-0.0979565606,
0.1064654961,
-0.0246500596,
0.3707116246,
-0.0258607939,
0.399671495,
0.1455350518,
-0.582675457,
-0.4785699546,
-0.5131220818,
-0.676653862,
-0.0674426332,
-0.8736715913,
-0.0162125062,
-0.1388351172,
-0.3753043711,
-0.0730583444,
0.1295798421,
-0.9947336912,
0.4123208821,
0.2035301924,
0.9797851443,
-0.9514610767,
0.3216657639,
0.7630496025,
-0.2009598315,
-0.3552644253,
0.1662387401,
0.3427187204,
-0.0993668661,
0.6665230393,
0.1539619267,
0.0506481268,
-0.1727754027,
-0.4606741369,
-0.7122902274,
0.7205001712,
-0.1508431435,
-0.1818267256,
-0.3085309863,
-0.1700256616,
0.9034238458,
-0.4042690992,
0.2652750909,
0.5816210508,
0.4663085938,
-0.3081758618,
-0.4707980752,
-0.4012548625,
-0.4881894886,
-0.1283233315,
0.2747462392,
-0.6814203858,
0.529211998,
0.2338596284,
-0.4230910838,
-0.0590139404,
0.7945162058,
-0.0523500703,
0.5561503172,
0.37619102,
0.3058806062,
0.5070650578,
-0.4668067992,
0.9553186297,
-0.3325999379,
0.3460194468,
0.5496307611,
-0.5904964805,
0.8610802293,
0.4190732837,
-0.4230502546,
0.3409339488,
0.7180724144,
0.1013069153,
-0.0727811977,
0.1941915601,
-0.0974877179,
0.1734497398,
-0.1711904705,
-0.2955685556,
0.5968710184,
0.5119577646,
-0.0177219324,
-0.1037683636,
-0.0345823988,
-0.0663937032,
-0.1190635189,
-0.2198490649,
0.7005292773,
0.1859735399,
-0.4123896658,
0.0337569676,
0.074874796,
0.6922342181,
-0.6349676251,
0.0559478365,
-0.3713315427,
-0.3245981932,
-0.4307989478,
-0.7794786096,
0.5871995091,
0.4198113382,
-0.0010146999,
-0.4755288661,
0.694997251,
-0.4867013693,
0.0605182312,
0.4813088477,
0.6009433866,
0.3268728256,
-0.1297773272,
-0.6081914306,
0.2018496543,
-0.2281014472,
-0.7122109532,
0.2678224444,
0.8078830838,
0.2339736372,
0.3918145001,
0.2734718323,
0.1634978801,
-0.0042469851,
-0.134751901,
0.3676964939,
-0.9521309137,
-0.2407451868,
-0.615791142,
0.7464654446,
0.0867686272,
-0.6396918893,
0.5277582407,
0.0052141235,
0.3993740976,
-0.0146762449,
0.6236005425,
-0.3380535841,
0.131108135,
-0.4345091283,
0.3224725723,
-0.5818805099,
-0.1535436064,
-0.7362589836,
-1.1576594114,
-0.444929719,
0.4769548476,
-0.1198212206,
0.0587587096,
0.7381311059,
0.0868997425,
0.4206044674,
0.2560659945,
0.1600394249,
0.0799126402,
0.0877315998,
0.5135634542,
0.9031563401,
-0.2798740864,
-0.0016346304,
-0.3194827735,
-0.2197881639,
-0.3589300811,
-1.0623202324,
-0.316121906,
-0.7770937085,
-0.4593570828,
-0.0338845327,
-0.3271398842,
0.7996149659,
0.4071224332,
-0.730394721,
-0.287581265,
0.1062082648,
0.2097470909,
-0.3635856509,
-0.25183779,
0.191137597,
-0.4404005408,
-0.9630524516,
0.1959097236,
0.490398258,
-0.1796619892,
-0.1374156922,
0.1036758646,
-0.2756750882,
0.010434729,
0.7342653871,
0.70459795,
-0.792558074,
-0.1736416966,
0.0769973472,
0.1411818713,
-0.0283419956,
0.6831507087,
-0.1610756665,
0.4126091301,
0.4713575244,
0.6812175512,
0.0458733253,
-0.0851180032,
0.6456533074,
-0.772501111,
-0.0596229546,
0.4445218444,
0.4696333706,
0.2105420679,
-0.329125464,
0.7285897732,
0.1298521161,
-0.6414107084,
-0.7983115911,
0.339615196,
-1.1569482088,
-0.050196521,
0.9639055133,
-0.0914437175,
-0.0975148529,
-0.0220531486,
-0.1365990639,
0.1533436477,
-0.1931708753,
0.7764408588,
1.198474884,
-0.482750237,
-0.2070329338,
-0.7017341852,
0.6486657858,
0.6635326147,
-1.0504697561,
0.2801975608,
0.4602791369,
-0.338034451,
0.4822620749,
0.5957868695,
0.0563271455,
0.0089152306,
-0.1791938841,
0.5346615314,
0.6740502715,
-0.2694957852,
-0.7228226662,
0.3268616498,
-0.0201790389,
0.3081977963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01216v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01216v2
|
API Is Enough: Conformal Prediction for Large Language Models Without Logit-Access
| 2024-03-02T14:14:45 | 2024-04-04T02:15:39 |
Jiayuan Su, Jing Luo, Hongwei Wang, Lu Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study aims to address the pervasive challenge of quantifying uncertainty
in large language models (LLMs) without logit-access. Conformal Prediction
(CP), known for its model-agnostic and distribution-free features, is a desired
approach for various LLMs and data distributions. However, existing CP methods
for LLMs typically assume access to the logits, which are unavailable for some
API-only LLMs. In addition, logits are known to be miscalibrated, potentially
leading to degraded CP performance. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a
novel CP method that (1) is tailored for API-only LLMs without logit-access;
(2) minimizes the size of prediction sets; and (3) ensures a statistical
guarantee of the user-defined coverage. The core idea of this approach is to
formulate nonconformity measures using both coarse-grained (i.e., sample
frequency) and fine-grained uncertainty notions (e.g., semantic similarity).
Experimental results on both close-ended and open-ended Question Answering
tasks show our approach can mostly outperform the logit-based CP baselines.
|
[
-0.3068991601,
-0.4774729013,
0.7894217372,
0.314185977,
-0.2976948023,
-0.1065978408,
-0.3867142498,
-0.5560827851,
0.0845891982,
0.4899353087,
-0.6535086632,
-0.5425440669,
-0.688955307,
0.0841812044,
-0.2657339275,
0.6915220618,
-0.0630439669,
0.0174597744,
-0.3738692105,
-0.0897421688,
-0.4623662829,
-0.270082891,
-0.2895461619,
-0.0129390471,
0.3092070222,
0.1767052859,
0.5670742393,
0.7252468467,
0.2566458881,
0.1269786358,
-0.1873498112,
0.1048824415,
-0.1877667308,
0.1266815662,
0.1685763747,
-0.7774406075,
-0.4079521,
-0.2232200652,
0.7425233126,
0.9178375602,
-0.0296730362,
0.3981637657,
0.1241444573,
0.7286286354,
-0.7462262511,
0.4904188812,
-0.9595032334,
-0.1972030103,
-0.0726426467,
0.2567777336,
-0.3951161504,
-0.3648188412,
0.3488314748,
-0.7780498862,
-0.0244565215,
0.2558508217,
0.4190186262,
0.429372102,
-0.299885422,
-0.2866585553,
-0.6995694637,
1.1027437449,
-0.8430066109,
0.731877923,
0.7746785283,
0.1760490835,
-0.2173713744,
-0.3240051866,
-0.5054816604,
-0.1876002401,
0.0609838627,
-0.0729292482,
-0.1698195636,
0.1410779953,
-0.0904860497,
0.1101904511,
-0.4864105284,
-0.1035184562,
-0.4937717915,
-0.3256171644,
0.453019172,
0.0037881075,
-0.0846463516,
0.1405940801,
-0.2075225562,
0.1536767632,
-0.6435868144,
0.2538394332,
0.2318905443,
0.5397322178,
-0.2454633415,
0.5666112304,
-0.0240235645,
0.5711936355,
-0.047495041,
0.0420303009,
0.113196373,
-0.219298467,
-0.3472184241,
-0.2305811048,
0.8000169992,
-0.0115743885,
0.2776696086,
-0.152992025,
-0.2576939464,
-0.1205455661,
-0.0523460284,
-0.5216248631,
-0.3060201108,
0.636752069,
-0.1639942378,
-0.072293736,
-0.122046113,
-0.8019452691,
-0.2578916252,
-0.4047050476,
0.0784927905,
-0.6038591266,
-0.4330564737,
-0.0914142057,
0.0739193186,
0.0678238571,
0.3540480137,
-0.8835870028,
0.3037037551,
0.7680985332,
0.9946754575,
-0.1362599581,
-0.2497512698,
-0.3589311838,
0.171541214,
-0.6332620382,
0.7848545909,
-0.6649494767,
-0.4782808423,
0.0574620888,
-0.1092153043,
-0.0292464979,
-0.3836607933,
0.5897484422,
-0.3896547556,
-0.3296850026,
-0.0825875849,
-0.9544957876,
0.0272018071,
0.1763767004,
-0.8065470457,
0.7333442569,
0.1878328025,
-0.4936707616,
0.2100579888,
-0.4111056626,
-0.1562136859,
-0.0704550371,
-0.1547813565,
-0.5429997444,
0.26622805,
0.1216888875,
0.2464295626,
-0.1098403484,
0.0866672173,
-0.7145723701,
-0.2062484175,
0.4235734642,
-0.4425200224,
0.4720007181,
0.1721095294,
-0.1009315923,
-0.0333790556,
-0.7399413586,
0.5750857592,
-0.328265518,
-0.2526925802,
-0.3572241664,
-0.006033055,
0.0852098987,
-0.1928397566,
0.4172003865,
-0.5969663858,
0.0019014991,
-0.7079548836,
0.4584350586,
1.1014425755,
-0.3159684837,
0.7049676776,
-0.3633809686,
0.4314761758,
-0.349037677,
0.2291946262,
0.0757870302,
-0.4479464293,
-0.3873074353,
-0.4072751403,
0.3489464521,
0.549959898,
-0.1955023706,
0.4222522676,
-0.3014928102,
-0.6729460359,
-0.3803963959,
0.4617628157,
0.6206615567,
0.112093769,
0.2716714144,
0.116450198,
-0.7085524797,
-0.6782379746,
-0.1200061515,
-0.6078516245,
-0.3723590672,
0.3637334704,
0.1528578103,
-0.2763395011,
0.8318225145,
-0.5558152199,
-0.3050413132,
-0.0833833069,
-0.1500952095,
0.30990237,
0.3018803895,
0.3852780163,
-0.7280883193,
-0.6654817462,
-0.1288278401,
-0.4545709789,
-0.1200355738,
0.1619022638,
-0.0223740749,
0.4081585705,
0.4925326109,
-0.5940691829,
0.2129447311,
1.074659586,
-0.1499794573,
0.6841836572,
-0.0732137039,
-0.2564911544,
-0.7312380672,
0.1279573888,
-0.043318972,
-0.3494506776,
-0.5927950144,
-0.1009373441,
0.2863062918,
-0.0730622113,
-0.3758047521,
0.713916719,
-0.240751192,
0.1848378032,
-0.2440847754,
-0.0872493535,
0.0194641929,
0.4272360504,
0.1796111465,
0.9043799639,
0.7204438448,
-0.6725972891,
-0.1366465688,
0.3053805828,
-0.2139146328,
0.3468321562,
-0.6856407523,
-0.0402613468,
-0.100422211,
0.2545526028,
-1.2023046017,
-0.1622240245,
-0.0899736285,
-0.5795637369,
0.1545091271,
-0.1573905796,
-0.1884147376,
-0.1557933539,
-0.3933923244,
0.578551054,
0.5383065343,
-0.1827577204,
0.6179214716,
0.3969151378,
-0.2440296561,
-0.411431849,
-0.7184049487,
-0.2306282222,
-0.0619690567,
-0.4095532,
-0.1251662523,
-0.5987640023,
-0.1160020381,
-0.1758408844,
-0.4870289862,
-0.4702342451,
0.0297439564,
0.3943407238,
0.481593281,
-0.227224797,
0.2556576133,
-0.0364093706,
0.0684323385,
0.0263030529,
-0.5720478892,
0.4051359296,
-0.5327791572,
-0.4241542518,
-0.3587093353,
0.186226964,
0.759657681,
-0.1097509116,
0.5579237938,
0.1260471642,
-0.4141405523,
-0.2429525703,
-0.5575296283,
0.0014662615,
-0.4590851068,
0.1166713238,
-0.2090741694,
-0.8889279366,
0.6042268872,
0.0229006968,
0.2880693972,
0.1814534515,
0.4369013906,
-0.1127780601,
0.6481910944,
0.7490726709,
-0.0896512717,
0.3397127986,
0.0760812759,
0.1875936389,
-0.7980644703,
-0.0788848102,
-0.4237733185,
0.0452360921,
-0.4907905757,
-0.361033529,
0.3890607655,
0.1417845786,
-0.3115340769,
0.3593884408,
-0.3075599968,
0.4434231818,
0.4448643327,
0.0219328124,
0.324539125,
-0.2315220982,
0.0303180255,
0.0908039436,
-0.0935379639,
-0.45748505,
1.6377869844,
0.3799481988,
0.8219092488,
0.1707472205,
0.483237803,
0.1738682985,
0.3091950715,
-0.7193946838,
0.3262164295,
-0.1214976758,
-0.5670436025,
-0.7653671503,
-0.3884816468,
-0.8494285345,
-0.045927193,
0.0117957108,
-0.9030747414,
0.2499766499,
0.4512420297,
-0.3609847426,
0.2344872504,
-0.6454917789,
0.3841797113,
0.0818778351,
0.142582342,
0.3136745095,
-0.5768413544,
0.2431595176,
-0.5953491926,
0.5775747299,
-0.3944661915,
-0.2983630002,
0.3022218049,
-0.3388089538,
0.9926755428,
-0.1011617035,
-0.226706937,
0.4750955999,
0.4018577933,
0.5948467255,
0.3524067104,
-0.2650389075,
0.5502182245,
0.6223620176,
-0.4530969262,
-0.5692636371,
0.5757766962,
-0.6793096066,
-0.3852310777,
-0.1385395974,
-0.6149453521,
-0.5203369856,
0.3331323266,
0.2290174067,
-0.0067298971,
-0.0808743387,
0.1147923842,
0.7953668833,
0.0821622759,
0.3254908919,
0.4708988667,
-0.1638178676,
-0.3851788342,
0.7690879107,
0.0140585592,
0.5728508234,
0.3233035803,
0.4552381039,
-0.5923007131,
-0.6252924204,
-0.362662524,
0.1838802993,
-0.4780843556,
-0.3510912359,
-0.4146680534,
-0.0892195702,
-0.6737958193,
-0.0556256026,
-0.5868732333,
-0.3557085395,
-0.1178834885,
-0.0107242512,
0.2896910012,
0.4134774506,
-0.0286805388,
0.3628423214,
-0.7634071112,
0.0957735777,
0.1432842314,
0.858296454,
-0.0513298362,
-0.4413405955,
-0.0392971784,
0.2545467615,
-0.1955283135,
-0.5921678543,
0.3454225063,
0.5973570347,
0.4338278472,
0.191672653,
0.3587611318,
0.5166085958,
-0.6442778707,
0.6723202467,
0.226647228,
-1.0927850008,
0.5116394758,
-0.3094743192,
0.1689817905,
0.6377522945,
0.2773164511,
-0.4122780263,
-0.9179305434,
-0.4665407538,
-0.8797765374,
0.2868775129,
0.3397003412,
0.2620046437,
0.0198904593,
0.3134194314,
0.2025785148,
0.4791780412,
-0.8829162121,
-0.1513817012,
-0.2399477959,
-0.3599646986,
0.0023932243,
-0.1662442237,
-0.0399641842,
-0.0832670555,
0.6148777604,
-0.3571596444,
0.2501188517,
0.2649958134,
0.2067030817,
-0.4735635817,
0.3964452147,
0.397801429,
0.984185338,
-0.4623917341,
0.0974960178,
0.3393943012,
-0.5847399831,
-0.0298568774,
-0.1372547597,
-0.1404869854,
0.0492663942,
0.3804496825,
0.5443740487,
0.0012524845,
-1.3072972298,
0.6221194267,
-0.0323067605,
-0.2311789542,
-0.9369338751,
-0.2297774255,
0.1268105209,
0.3777040243,
0.2778299153,
0.0034534894,
-0.0711252838,
-0.2086071074,
0.4244672954,
0.4944316447,
-0.6534433365,
-0.3567923903,
0.6591399312,
-0.2393718958,
-0.0436524414,
0.3300481737,
0.101211518,
-0.0298878793,
0.5816797614,
0.6397114396,
0.7488639355,
-0.3442498147,
-0.0113032842,
0.1871073991,
0.2343467623,
-0.2786724269,
0.2622627318,
0.2894724309,
-0.6342406273,
-0.4971083105,
-0.955501318,
-0.4791292548,
0.4216167033,
-0.5727074742,
0.3216298223,
-0.7925006151,
0.0328716822,
-0.0715909079,
-0.2653982639,
-0.5243730545,
0.0295771826,
0.1419450194,
1.1504460573,
-0.7547824979,
0.7704722285,
0.3912242949,
-0.1045780331,
-0.9540137649,
0.1909329891,
0.030978173,
-0.8561153412,
0.3579662144,
0.0582062006,
0.0947539359,
-0.2028387636,
-0.6530502439,
-1.0432248116,
0.9100417495,
0.5932573676,
-0.7115793228,
-0.0566009134,
0.2713357508,
0.4314095676,
-0.1251440793,
-0.0350434296,
0.5364817381,
0.5347182751,
0.2814369798,
-1.2387931347,
-0.0106931003,
0.0731180161,
0.0311721563,
0.3217501044,
-0.4571487606,
0.9236610532,
-0.0995743871,
-0.1283324957,
0.3822022676,
0.7239987254,
0.4725186229,
0.2983919382,
0.6713274121,
0.3086669147,
0.9938852787,
0.1999219358,
1.0730612278,
-0.4772696793,
0.5146780014,
1.0517423153,
-0.1033106297,
1.1219636202,
0.6038435102,
-0.4316073358,
0.1224786192,
0.7069427371,
0.1228960976,
0.6021615267,
0.2709797323,
-0.5097899437,
-0.3446499705,
0.1216602325,
-0.1189439744,
0.1968071908,
0.4564861953,
-0.0093253506,
-0.1660617888,
-0.0645036921,
-0.0670380965,
0.2464612722,
-0.4213441908,
0.7168676257,
0.2863415778,
-0.4637441337,
0.9120885134,
-0.2174244374,
0.6401191354,
-0.8181527853,
0.1570119858,
-0.0204725601,
0.0467877425,
-0.0626707226,
-0.7644026875,
0.5833186507,
-0.282918632,
-0.2126469016,
0.1163132489,
0.3480060995,
-0.468071878,
-0.8669823408,
0.2465056777,
0.453517735,
0.0454840548,
-0.2967244387,
-0.3891758919,
-0.0319468193,
-0.1061182916,
-0.1208745018,
0.2937781513,
0.6859488487,
-0.1668113917,
0.8951820731,
0.5980519056,
0.3867027164,
0.1906366497,
-0.3166035116,
0.8410633206,
-0.3012516499,
-0.4782955945,
-0.9104810953,
0.1776762307,
0.417240262,
-0.1859157979,
0.3232996464,
0.6027469039,
0.7682845592,
-0.1751539558,
1.1521567106,
0.0383465253,
0.5731501579,
-0.503281951,
0.360987395,
-0.50245893,
0.3387129605,
-0.209395498,
-0.8848273754,
-0.4797299504,
0.3322882056,
-0.1763477027,
-0.4349422455,
0.6112079024,
0.6760818362,
-0.1530759633,
0.013623029,
0.4959672987,
0.0834482387,
0.4012468457,
0.6531150937,
0.3430080414,
-0.166230768,
0.8811552525,
-0.0338747948,
-0.4008363783,
0.1472230554,
-0.9150848985,
-0.8538544178,
-0.6884849668,
0.123160556,
-0.3467469811,
-0.0027825276,
0.9120345712,
0.6007416844,
-1.0826921463,
-0.2592079937,
-0.3145766556,
0.1133554131,
-0.1820617318,
-0.130726397,
0.493632704,
-0.6416050196,
-0.9528697729,
0.1890202165,
0.0240429528,
0.2383765429,
-0.2124949694,
-0.0584228672,
0.153190136,
0.3832267821,
0.4048330486,
0.4079805315,
-0.7999669313,
-0.509724915,
0.1147498637,
0.1219074428,
0.0442204699,
0.6690069437,
-0.4394973814,
0.2168286741,
0.2554306984,
0.9497925043,
0.1202350929,
-0.0416433327,
0.7200688124,
-1.0882995129,
0.2514512241,
0.3588949144,
0.3531746864,
-0.0632930845,
-0.5596013069,
0.293140769,
0.0424379483,
-0.5727590322,
-0.7682153583,
0.590729475,
-1.1070507765,
-0.4030849934,
1.342079401,
-0.3514933288,
-0.4165051877,
-0.341208905,
0.0118157286,
-0.1243776903,
-0.6348338723,
0.7379001975,
0.8045759797,
-0.1939705163,
-0.1333135217,
-0.748161912,
0.4521529377,
0.2227635682,
-0.5538817644,
0.6624107957,
0.4672533572,
0.5308609009,
0.337962836,
0.7126868963,
-0.092502974,
0.0424408764,
-0.340983361,
-0.0807448998,
-0.0751819089,
-0.2744491994,
-0.0243573971,
-0.0088367518,
0.5013756156,
-0.0388923958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01203v1
|
Pseudo-Label Calibration Semi-supervised Multi-Modal Entity Alignment
| 2024-03-02T12:44:59 | 2024-03-02T12:44:59 |
Luyao Wang, Pengnian Qi, Xigang Bao, Chunlai Zhou, Biao Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Multi-modal entity alignment (MMEA) aims to identify equivalent entities
between two multi-modal knowledge graphs for integration. Unfortunately, prior
arts have attempted to improve the interaction and fusion of multi-modal
information, which have overlooked the influence of modal-specific noise and
the usage of labeled and unlabeled data in semi-supervised settings. In this
work, we introduce a Pseudo-label Calibration Multi-modal Entity Alignment
(PCMEA) in a semi-supervised way. Specifically, in order to generate holistic
entity representations, we first devise various embedding modules and attention
mechanisms to extract visual, structural, relational, and attribute features.
Different from the prior direct fusion methods, we next propose to exploit
mutual information maximization to filter the modal-specific noise and to
augment modal-invariant commonality. Then, we combine pseudo-label calibration
with momentum-based contrastive learning to make full use of the labeled and
unlabeled data, which improves the quality of pseudo-label and pulls aligned
entities closer. Finally, extensive experiments on two MMEA datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of our PCMEA, which yields state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.4159710109,
-0.6465581059,
0.6803042889,
-0.2437757254,
-0.415574044,
0.0847478956,
0.0029305366,
-0.4404911697,
0.5558003783,
0.0326090455,
-0.5617258549,
-0.4469876289,
-0.043773327,
-0.0502906814,
0.2805012465,
0.8557037115,
0.0391145498,
0.2028842568,
-0.3470336497,
-0.1512087286,
-0.5613655448,
-0.257232964,
-0.1269317716,
-0.1498482525,
0.4792731702,
0.199679628,
0.6442143917,
0.2353369594,
0.2195823342,
0.2962303162,
0.3251170814,
0.6957625151,
-0.636785388,
-0.3079846501,
-0.3343016207,
-0.2885943949,
-0.6930172443,
0.2644317746,
0.5621603727,
0.6067339778,
-0.0541635677,
0.2999810278,
-0.0930606201,
0.2215163857,
-0.6505774856,
0.3460552692,
-0.4507977366,
-0.0911474526,
-0.3164030015,
-0.4127088487,
-0.4007638097,
-0.1105203703,
0.2280196548,
-1.1223253012,
-0.3537179232,
0.2121484429,
1.0363018513,
0.4872733653,
-0.8992425203,
-0.0311628077,
-0.6697806716,
1.0950394869,
-0.4144457281,
0.7089501023,
0.3361771107,
0.3124462962,
-0.0563978106,
-0.6049733162,
-0.6834256649,
0.209897697,
-0.0919027627,
0.4859348536,
-0.1056557894,
0.0070638284,
-0.1003038734,
0.2305470258,
-0.5908603668,
-0.052886609,
-0.2966196239,
-0.7037309408,
0.1937423199,
-0.0606586076,
0.3030844927,
0.0030268268,
-0.8855348229,
-0.3278913498,
-0.6287418008,
-0.0965083987,
0.2946352363,
0.1941674054,
-0.0514264181,
0.6263529062,
0.1247143373,
0.8555855751,
0.3886098564,
-0.5402910113,
0.6666494012,
-0.7442210317,
-0.3913064897,
0.2392564565,
0.7843928337,
0.5016818643,
-0.374107331,
-0.216755867,
-0.2070925385,
0.278059274,
0.2709138989,
-0.7889555097,
-0.3298412561,
-0.148817718,
-0.5010583401,
-0.2081026882,
0.0981474891,
-0.943695724,
0.0343374722,
-0.8945850134,
0.7864351273,
-0.2571647763,
-0.1883945465,
-0.1507968456,
0.2179237306,
0.2157930136,
0.1417076886,
-0.3168562353,
-0.3266081512,
0.2524365783,
0.5872468352,
0.1536788344,
-0.1276512593,
-0.4199433327,
0.67153579,
-0.160185799,
0.6594145894,
-0.7422537804,
-0.2310677618,
-0.2494443357,
0.0821574628,
-0.3008415401,
-0.3543365598,
0.1801431477,
-0.7600881457,
0.4273611605,
-0.4042527974,
-0.414452821,
-0.4670264125,
0.2841363549,
-0.6766317487,
0.8058248758,
0.0889925882,
-0.6619747281,
0.4464259446,
-0.1983033419,
-0.2958699167,
-0.1882862598,
-0.4224520326,
-0.6656013131,
-0.0173012186,
0.1413929611,
0.2189493775,
-0.3834320903,
0.5587694645,
-0.5229480267,
-0.1513501704,
0.1447099,
-0.4227638543,
0.4614667296,
0.2288365066,
-0.2993308604,
0.2465097904,
-1.0363830328,
-0.0781055316,
-0.2501859069,
-0.0894223601,
-0.51726228,
-0.150848195,
-0.0898842514,
0.6518082619,
0.5756886601,
-0.3039824665,
0.0256428346,
-0.2008004189,
0.1612506807,
0.7245394588,
0.1546010375,
0.647855103,
-0.1893302798,
0.2393321246,
0.554653585,
0.0083313845,
0.0955356434,
-0.3140452504,
-0.2496709377,
-0.7448109984,
0.3161521554,
0.4659798145,
-1.2400504351,
0.5856518149,
-0.2613811791,
-0.4592548311,
-0.4709351063,
0.3584374785,
0.4137154222,
1.1022280455,
0.6193982363,
-0.5939190388,
-0.4500206113,
-1.1028500795,
0.3296182752,
-0.2509157062,
-0.0584030598,
0.3634781241,
-0.0139736608,
-0.4071008861,
0.9204785824,
-0.2447933555,
-0.6907377839,
0.4366107285,
0.6650194526,
-0.0812954679,
0.3654136658,
0.6624945402,
-0.9664773941,
-0.2258704901,
-0.112734504,
-0.6505907178,
-0.2139688879,
-0.414640069,
-0.4859009981,
-0.4100384712,
0.1383426487,
-0.3901274502,
0.1422781944,
0.431607455,
-0.1939285696,
0.1961295456,
-0.1736703962,
0.3321840465,
-1.4108304977,
0.1690843403,
0.4423324168,
-0.4789189398,
-0.4046214521,
-0.4260592163,
0.3318095207,
0.0120511167,
-0.4968348444,
-0.0370213464,
-0.8553429246,
-0.0018770039,
-0.2998353243,
0.257294029,
0.0103179077,
0.5744251013,
0.2284275889,
0.9764780998,
0.5740206838,
-0.6037647724,
0.1308488399,
0.1078203171,
0.0553335175,
1.0790555477,
-0.1877146214,
0.0868820995,
-0.0604238138,
0.4102601707,
-0.7677745223,
0.1275420189,
0.2507029772,
0.0763955936,
0.5820618272,
0.032250911,
-0.4023653567,
-0.0777804181,
-0.4213567674,
0.7327221632,
0.0179985724,
-0.37080881,
0.926204443,
0.697009027,
0.4666192234,
-0.4968639612,
-0.4925835431,
-0.1750387996,
-0.0605640896,
-0.4561424255,
0.7682091594,
-0.2266875654,
0.1201800928,
0.1172251329,
-0.3145629466,
-0.0910554454,
-0.3066636622,
0.3632437885,
0.6346840858,
-0.4409070909,
0.0201136936,
0.3408719301,
-0.1327444315,
-0.1240007505,
-0.2676431537,
0.2944338918,
-0.1965051591,
-0.3704349697,
-0.8128049374,
-0.0050334921,
0.4798301458,
-0.3047568202,
0.9129474759,
0.7108665705,
-0.442835182,
0.2686898708,
-0.4881067574,
-0.3756276667,
-0.4231490195,
0.2661952972,
-0.5148352981,
-0.5596325994,
0.2764125764,
-0.5784038305,
-0.0409885235,
0.3978753984,
0.5445878506,
-0.211507231,
0.940942049,
0.7040361166,
-0.1920044124,
0.3366007805,
-0.0928740576,
0.5137798786,
-0.7980514765,
-0.4725272059,
-0.1564989388,
-0.5905948877,
-0.4643304646,
-0.7004162073,
0.4487145245,
0.0370116979,
0.2319559753,
0.4340603054,
-0.3226462305,
0.3268762529,
0.5183600187,
0.4634031951,
0.1578055024,
-0.2397205085,
-0.0344229676,
-0.2704758346,
-0.3400872052,
-0.5032126904,
1.0525128841,
0.0260442458,
0.6168200374,
0.1832320243,
0.4213479459,
0.1086038798,
0.2515189052,
-0.5085829496,
0.3843468428,
0.2286861688,
-0.6548169851,
0.0975038633,
-0.6763608456,
-0.5531992316,
0.3093597591,
-0.4173788726,
-0.5499459505,
0.7376930118,
0.3196272254,
-0.2446313798,
0.1654391885,
-0.8357713819,
0.9548357725,
-0.1718630195,
-0.4051566124,
-0.1554426551,
-0.8813552856,
0.4434943199,
-0.4173043966,
0.3398623168,
0.1361286044,
-0.2062774152,
0.680817306,
-0.3026463389,
1.0175248384,
-0.1887537092,
-0.1317604333,
0.3303019106,
-0.0694529191,
0.4557493925,
-0.0509239957,
0.2711852193,
0.0306263603,
0.1838614941,
-0.3690232337,
-0.3743450344,
0.8186905384,
-0.7798136473,
-0.2225549221,
-0.2620417476,
-0.6548793912,
-0.5362493396,
0.3071944714,
-0.171525836,
0.4130814672,
-0.1615897268,
0.1295397133,
0.8288679719,
0.1124162674,
0.2899783254,
0.6092141271,
0.181714654,
-0.5323184729,
1.374688983,
0.1144867688,
0.0137344562,
0.5566555858,
-0.1814402491,
-0.4713772833,
-0.0535257421,
-0.5051290989,
0.4412741363,
-0.463065356,
-0.488147378,
-0.4521980286,
0.3413302004,
-0.3656544983,
-0.0421089046,
-0.4579977393,
-0.2729878426,
-0.7868441343,
-0.0142939454,
-0.2755290866,
0.1917172372,
-0.1814377308,
0.2994497716,
-0.6395820975,
0.4052443802,
0.4136808515,
-0.1493881345,
-0.2995103598,
-0.430639714,
0.0758813098,
0.1742468625,
-0.4080360234,
-1.3841253519,
0.0517255962,
0.2099857777,
0.5329133868,
0.7499937415,
0.116515331,
0.9792473912,
-0.2815923989,
0.5543174744,
0.5723398924,
-0.797457695,
0.448667258,
0.1083283052,
0.026797181,
0.8156368732,
0.5792192817,
0.1406567693,
-0.0389721505,
-0.3956302702,
-0.6921520829,
0.4927310944,
-0.0084311264,
-0.0830965787,
0.1150507331,
0.0684626773,
0.025655847,
0.3525851369,
-0.7849733829,
-0.5278919339,
-0.2978553772,
-0.565862596,
0.0338330604,
-0.254127115,
-0.2780844569,
-0.034111917,
1.0754927397,
-0.3244669735,
0.0122587727,
0.1096025854,
-0.6463424563,
-0.2493483573,
0.1179901063,
0.6124677062,
0.9754822254,
-0.166097641,
0.5144161582,
-0.091793865,
-0.2213367969,
0.1870674342,
0.4449679852,
-0.2524269521,
-0.1693611592,
-0.1519608945,
0.6474227905,
0.5157792568,
-0.4596889317,
0.7071146369,
0.0282723252,
0.0010498784,
0.3198589385,
-0.4239453971,
0.0683168545,
0.3087214828,
0.1391722262,
0.1666728556,
0.2783821523,
-0.5927147865,
0.4652519226,
0.5985289216,
-0.5293565392,
-0.738052845,
0.7616443634,
0.0978585258,
0.3463351429,
0.2099312693,
-0.2583075762,
-0.4146921337,
0.055107981,
0.642239213,
0.2862452865,
-0.3165039718,
0.3627257049,
0.2983714342,
0.4439606667,
0.3684616089,
0.176950708,
-0.3386959136,
-0.5336370468,
-0.4614894986,
-0.5575427413,
-0.2214010507,
0.0019991372,
-0.5638201237,
0.29371351,
-0.1636054516,
-0.3574565947,
0.1170649752,
-0.0348248109,
-0.7364426851,
0.4150854647,
0.1464684159,
0.2978263199,
-1.2043147087,
0.8657739758,
1.1075258255,
-0.758127749,
-1.0221321583,
-0.240612641,
0.3285315931,
-0.5403705835,
0.278804183,
0.1825266927,
-0.2656306624,
0.0398233756,
-0.0911737159,
-0.7255671024,
1.3499692678,
0.5135625601,
-0.8133362532,
-0.0648997575,
0.1344791502,
0.3309542537,
-0.1995134056,
0.3595996201,
0.1912948191,
0.5713150501,
0.2986488044,
-0.7629559636,
0.0224336963,
-0.1010876149,
-0.1417034417,
0.290903002,
-0.7765049338,
0.1460773498,
0.2347372174,
-0.14537099,
-0.5557373166,
1.1298097372,
0.2937877476,
0.6381278634,
0.7549282908,
0.8088431358,
0.8895897865,
0.0349986553,
0.4702907503,
-0.2766228914,
0.262724489,
1.188824892,
-0.3397507071,
0.4365819693,
0.8741198778,
0.0052862247,
0.3193860352,
0.7945058346,
0.1636676788,
0.7947232723,
-0.3121437132,
-0.2020500451,
-0.4598411918,
-0.3111834824,
-0.3375451267,
0.3965988457,
0.0355711319,
-0.411845386,
-0.2938689291,
0.1016381308,
-0.1608096361,
-0.1278930753,
-0.1316473037,
0.8381635547,
0.0362009183,
-0.2595368624,
0.1020795032,
-0.035289254,
0.4986708462,
-0.2610594928,
-0.0254059937,
0.1423863024,
-0.2256503701,
-0.0952807814,
-0.2960288525,
0.0465511605,
-0.449932754,
-0.3837025464,
-0.1660082489,
0.7857472897,
-0.6779692173,
-0.2663626671,
0.143707186,
0.5473077893,
0.0303796455,
0.0865010247,
-0.7306161523,
-0.0973135605,
0.0733496025,
-0.2475331277,
0.4553426504,
0.4878893495,
-0.0193320978,
0.091244787,
0.6778374314,
-0.0924395472,
0.2345247567,
0.0492747054,
0.9822078943,
-0.2786763012,
-0.409606874,
-0.5483342409,
0.3758422434,
-0.065683879,
-0.1168274805,
0.4352048934,
0.8732261062,
0.886367023,
0.1332640946,
-0.0776748359,
0.0421249568,
0.0911874026,
-0.493773222,
0.5103634,
-0.7983736396,
0.1585837454,
-0.1945420057,
-1.3565837145,
-0.2226457149,
0.4359071255,
-0.2688694596,
0.0026855217,
0.620926559,
0.9659943581,
-0.6022299528,
-0.0641450211,
0.4499119222,
0.0669169351,
0.3038998246,
0.6536636353,
0.4517210126,
-0.420743525,
0.4916786849,
-0.6814204454,
-0.4599304795,
0.0611735508,
-0.8075249791,
-0.7221753597,
-0.7813975811,
-0.6071605086,
-0.0080958419,
-0.2725811899,
0.6494566202,
0.9956125021,
-0.7343487144,
0.297159344,
0.3558228612,
-0.2061225921,
-0.1685265899,
-0.2500112355,
0.5309485793,
0.0201573726,
-0.8666307926,
0.7801071405,
0.4891993999,
0.1173711419,
-0.0408712141,
0.0205621663,
-0.4496774077,
0.0776144713,
0.3622616231,
0.1396271437,
-0.4974016845,
-0.0741659701,
-0.3317373991,
-0.1617938429,
0.0958746746,
0.6224806309,
-0.7362074852,
0.7660440803,
0.3033759296,
0.705952704,
0.4211356342,
0.163068518,
0.3935050964,
-0.7502706051,
0.0884768441,
0.116371043,
0.4584810436,
0.1051406935,
-0.3114689887,
0.1610558927,
0.3952427506,
-0.4146111012,
-0.7996584177,
-0.0946537703,
-1.3574354649,
0.0135110915,
0.5571736693,
-0.0198791046,
-0.4431971312,
0.0994091555,
-0.2435671687,
0.6656128168,
-0.3351726234,
0.5926350355,
0.4835368395,
0.1147149727,
-0.1351656914,
-0.1535560042,
0.137655586,
0.5505996346,
-0.9273564816,
-0.5884612799,
1.0077519417,
0.0636569187,
0.4145591855,
0.286899209,
-0.1194416061,
0.3345783055,
-0.4685642421,
-0.0150863137,
-0.1353928745,
-0.4749798775,
0.0441629142,
0.241391778,
-0.3347464502,
-0.3791471124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01197v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01197v2
|
DMoERM: Recipes of Mixture-of-Experts for Effective Reward Modeling
| 2024-03-02T12:31:22 | 2024-04-28T03:24:41 |
Shanghaoran Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of the reward model (RM) is a critical factor in improving
the effectiveness of the large language model (LLM) during alignment
fine-tuning. There remain two challenges in RM training: 1) training the same
RM using various categories of data may cause its generalization performance to
suffer from multi-task disturbance, and 2) the human annotation consistency
rate is generally only $60\%$ to $75\%$, causing training data to contain a lot
of noise. To tackle these two challenges, we introduced the idea of
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) into the field of RM for the first time. We propose
the Double-Layer MoE RM (DMoERM). The outer layer MoE is a sparse model. After
classifying an input into task categories, we route it to the corresponding
inner layer task-specific model. The inner layer MoE is a dense model. We
decompose the specific task into multiple capability dimensions and
individually fine-tune a LoRA expert on each one. Their outputs are then
synthesized by an MLP to compute the final rewards. To minimize costs, we call
a public LLM API to obtain the capability preference labels. The validation on
manually labeled datasets confirms that our model attains superior consistency
with human preference and outstrips advanced generative approaches. Meanwhile,
through BoN sampling and RL experiments, we demonstrate that our model
outperforms state-of-the-art ensemble methods of RM and mitigates the
overoptimization problem. Our code and dataset are available at:
https://github.com/quanshr/DMoERM-v1.
|
[
-0.4004559815,
-0.5249398947,
0.3870065808,
0.056490656,
-0.1288733184,
0.180060342,
-0.3128093481,
-0.3543074429,
0.1743269265,
0.6881266832,
-0.5331629515,
-0.2327878773,
-0.8243274093,
-0.1375343055,
0.0046539884,
0.8187081218,
-0.1338493079,
-0.1314713955,
-0.5136122108,
-0.1603405029,
-0.6923440695,
-0.5792172551,
-0.4555574059,
-0.5938519835,
0.7707542181,
0.6217013001,
0.3371967673,
0.8437303305,
0.5454133153,
0.3118638098,
-0.0665454939,
0.5536490679,
-0.6048634648,
0.1974194348,
-0.1424784362,
-0.5065085292,
-0.6103778481,
0.2992576659,
0.2990022898,
0.3938812315,
-0.4112759531,
-0.2069405466,
0.0295076109,
0.7268680334,
-0.7219067216,
0.1477836221,
-0.7749503851,
-0.1647852957,
-0.0883884355,
-0.4271946847,
-0.3143700957,
-0.0545471348,
-0.0336984582,
-0.5780715942,
-0.1043880433,
0.080120407,
0.5386433005,
0.7429544926,
-0.5345839262,
-0.1448564231,
-0.7315816283,
1.1155406237,
-0.6154457927,
0.083293207,
0.5116322637,
0.3098263741,
-0.3149638474,
-0.1199641302,
-0.5721501112,
-0.1586736143,
0.1914307028,
0.2057586908,
0.0956359431,
0.023384057,
-0.1449946761,
0.6827546954,
-0.2055549771,
0.5108073354,
-0.1548147798,
0.040693555,
0.9258078933,
0.3481587172,
0.1480147392,
0.1038024276,
-0.6810013056,
-0.3134047389,
-0.4773482084,
0.1089946628,
0.4338770509,
0.0190534648,
-0.0114435609,
0.5438994765,
-0.3324383199,
0.7174758315,
0.1476367563,
-0.4896597862,
0.1546523869,
-0.0990524516,
-0.0061847582,
0.0227784496,
0.7629035711,
0.4086880684,
-0.0165158901,
-0.2403030396,
-0.5234043002,
-0.0211459119,
0.2647414804,
-0.6111422181,
-0.4305406809,
0.3642475605,
-0.100220032,
-0.6051451564,
0.1872113943,
-0.4054521918,
-0.5325733423,
-0.6335389614,
0.6388235092,
-0.4021068215,
-0.6108647585,
0.4021603763,
-0.1929641962,
-0.273160696,
0.3316102624,
-1.0817190409,
0.2471631169,
0.9647182226,
0.5506683588,
-0.3777359128,
-0.2853879631,
-0.6242719889,
0.2467522919,
0.0183604341,
0.7534376383,
-0.4488738179,
-0.3022862673,
-0.3316113055,
-0.5066691637,
-0.2019084096,
-0.7333906293,
0.4933815002,
-0.4604193866,
0.195561111,
-0.3366715312,
-0.7470123172,
-0.2544185817,
0.4292996228,
-0.5842200518,
1.1159747839,
0.2260116637,
-0.6148672104,
0.4752426445,
-0.7518689632,
-0.2174038589,
0.0928311422,
-0.2488222718,
-0.1343802512,
0.1713915467,
0.2069454342,
0.4977573752,
-0.3138019443,
0.4315428138,
-0.1186902598,
-0.284017235,
0.4893987775,
-0.2124428153,
0.4854470491,
0.2016154826,
-0.267314285,
0.1905254722,
-0.7074767351,
-0.0523981079,
0.0838305131,
-0.6015723944,
-0.5726515055,
0.1042514071,
0.0197118949,
0.4016720355,
0.2892002463,
-0.5008023381,
0.4420188069,
-0.2145494223,
0.6062095761,
1.0289281607,
-0.2391677052,
0.5377586484,
-0.5235218406,
0.461751312,
0.3026494682,
-0.0079218149,
-0.0512833372,
-0.3586541116,
-0.6380811334,
-0.7739157677,
0.6202526689,
0.5698994398,
-0.5236132145,
0.9626284242,
-0.3725300729,
-0.4856717288,
-0.7621397972,
0.3302871287,
0.3476592302,
0.480817765,
0.3123844266,
-0.4648593068,
-0.294968456,
-0.9383946657,
0.0542940684,
-0.0318914317,
0.0080168815,
0.2615130246,
0.4766564667,
-0.233759135,
1.0868595839,
-0.5202512741,
-0.4246174395,
-0.259963274,
0.3204641938,
0.0657485351,
0.8538782597,
0.2694962919,
-0.7839873433,
-0.3386839628,
0.086559169,
-0.607550025,
-0.0471283793,
0.1559048146,
-0.3541744053,
0.0699174181,
0.0317657217,
-0.480152905,
-0.1328692287,
0.612108171,
-0.0031739261,
0.1822175831,
-0.1426199377,
0.2297073305,
-1.1545953751,
0.1073121279,
0.0875547826,
-0.2191412151,
-0.4170882404,
0.2028956562,
-0.0329115614,
0.2375628948,
-0.129445374,
0.5884885788,
-0.1926435828,
0.3671706021,
-0.5973658562,
-0.1329674721,
-0.0868570507,
0.7411722541,
0.0816664472,
0.4741009176,
0.4448956847,
-0.587105453,
0.4475759864,
0.0721362233,
-0.4622723758,
0.6567213535,
-0.6572884321,
0.2887242138,
0.0126022361,
0.2271772325,
-0.9601686001,
-0.5178394914,
0.342979759,
-0.2618392408,
0.5162747502,
-0.1432946473,
-0.6403378844,
-0.1825693697,
-0.20100905,
0.4715890586,
0.7725088596,
-0.3557485938,
0.6698983312,
0.6092716455,
-0.1862517297,
-0.6745541692,
-0.6502082944,
-0.0257698819,
-0.252846688,
-0.8178032637,
0.6201627254,
-0.2458395809,
-0.2102492005,
-0.0801142007,
-0.2389522195,
-0.1196069047,
0.3641327024,
0.3021392822,
0.1561257094,
0.0855484605,
-0.1089057922,
0.1572398543,
-0.3660591841,
-0.0991276205,
-0.2668457329,
0.4943201244,
0.1876091361,
-0.4806761146,
-0.5631712079,
0.3360504508,
0.5532490015,
-0.3052981794,
0.7562106848,
0.5965905786,
-0.1967817098,
-0.029508071,
-0.9549916387,
-0.2755227089,
-0.4249686003,
0.3065440655,
-0.2969047427,
-0.8639948368,
0.454184562,
0.0426723771,
0.2238639891,
0.3538113832,
0.6617905498,
0.0440468378,
1.1606515646,
0.6011182666,
-0.4029040933,
0.485870868,
-0.3066660464,
-0.0915471166,
-0.7475873232,
-0.4703131914,
-0.2520743608,
-0.6882982254,
-0.1022774056,
-0.4180551171,
0.5399994254,
0.2254762799,
0.0945916474,
0.0206127502,
-0.5857132077,
0.4843234718,
0.7972062826,
0.3820033669,
0.274967581,
0.1084092781,
-0.0049934289,
0.1106055826,
-0.9664220214,
-0.3849703968,
0.9572451115,
0.4891150594,
0.8861153722,
-0.1427785903,
0.8938919306,
0.2155789286,
0.0673350543,
-0.7802887559,
0.4345372915,
-0.0274477564,
-0.5984581113,
-0.2214700282,
-0.6298368573,
-0.5924969316,
0.3554807007,
-0.2493361086,
-0.3113430142,
0.1202489883,
0.4523617327,
-0.4470092356,
0.3282355666,
-0.5393818617,
0.7893712521,
-0.4168688357,
-0.4139977396,
-0.3975524902,
-0.6604583859,
0.4718003273,
-0.0128412787,
0.1268816888,
-0.283875823,
0.0078066587,
0.7313073277,
-0.4151261747,
0.7444117069,
-0.1624558568,
-0.2030713558,
0.1018487811,
0.0017731732,
0.6138367653,
-0.0883073807,
-0.0941510946,
0.0662192777,
-0.393183887,
-0.5348357558,
-0.5035142899,
0.8496024013,
-0.9635280371,
-0.5550221801,
-0.2281321138,
-0.990696907,
-0.0584987067,
-0.0653075278,
0.178799361,
0.3750634193,
0.2015628368,
0.2842223346,
0.8928351402,
0.0884746984,
-0.0580624677,
0.404074043,
0.1518745422,
-0.4955763817,
1.0319161415,
0.0412493274,
0.2032428384,
0.5355335474,
0.2321270406,
-0.2197657228,
-0.5731443763,
-0.5194139481,
-0.1753289998,
-0.4652158022,
-0.2282170653,
-0.8084309697,
-0.0246512834,
-0.1079159528,
-0.051796075,
-0.5113395452,
-0.4994487464,
-0.2256654501,
0.091028057,
0.4392267764,
0.7198386192,
-0.058900021,
0.2950048149,
-0.7031480074,
0.109000653,
0.4852901101,
0.255055517,
0.0515608005,
-0.4960811138,
-0.4277707934,
0.3640498817,
-0.4026303589,
-0.3323387504,
0.2005897313,
-0.1615770608,
0.8615732789,
0.3331227303,
0.0496017411,
0.5214173794,
-0.0434259363,
0.6484940648,
0.3313983381,
-0.6286448836,
0.319557488,
-0.4409798384,
-0.0688236803,
0.6083966494,
0.283428967,
-0.2653303742,
-0.415661186,
-0.3895028532,
-1.02257061,
0.8288916945,
0.0997766927,
-0.132736057,
0.1429635286,
0.1952628493,
0.5522705317,
0.3830118477,
-0.6340144873,
-0.1191032603,
-0.1496242136,
-0.5031866431,
-0.1696069539,
-0.4039028585,
-0.3903899193,
-0.2322886586,
0.623765409,
0.1330084801,
0.0173612144,
-0.1008575633,
-0.1503067613,
-0.3958505392,
0.3184076548,
0.7235395908,
0.7003316879,
-0.4218166769,
0.1411968321,
-0.1036458239,
-0.0462803729,
0.1709407121,
0.1410548985,
0.0666963309,
-0.4245159626,
0.1614415944,
0.82849437,
0.3438386917,
-0.6558771133,
0.4086644053,
0.2970849276,
-0.5163589716,
-0.1857848763,
0.5430194139,
0.1020966843,
0.1847352386,
0.544721663,
0.2255917937,
-0.1101780608,
-0.3951351643,
-0.0876361206,
0.4672175944,
-0.1950619221,
-0.2173726857,
0.7452428937,
0.4084194899,
-0.0397969075,
0.5907725096,
-0.1227709129,
-0.6304978132,
0.5156012774,
0.1758410633,
0.6570435166,
-0.1909916997,
-0.0634659007,
0.0715842918,
0.0942931995,
-0.5775685906,
0.186498642,
0.0443013459,
-0.6863511205,
-0.5074605346,
-0.4914215803,
-0.3942365944,
0.038098298,
-0.6687865257,
0.1614274085,
-0.1155629382,
0.0256657414,
-0.0801488012,
-0.116945073,
-0.5812206864,
0.0603611618,
0.1028573886,
0.7284920812,
-0.8285856247,
0.8668331504,
0.8518692255,
-0.3648788929,
-0.6229112148,
-0.396682471,
-0.0569978915,
-0.8290923834,
0.7322916389,
0.1229482144,
0.0708482936,
0.0365503468,
-0.5029510856,
-0.5435200334,
1.2258838415,
0.1860224009,
-0.6717866063,
0.1774310917,
0.0119932452,
0.2510133982,
-0.5715187192,
0.1902953833,
0.3250250816,
0.5770779252,
0.2072527409,
-0.8936119676,
-0.1598170996,
-0.2061951756,
-0.0917213857,
0.305829376,
-0.5843855739,
1.0617932081,
0.0175773315,
0.2170729339,
0.1212371439,
0.5077140927,
0.5994821191,
0.3680879474,
0.7679621577,
0.8713132143,
0.6587843299,
-0.0266216546,
1.0640699863,
-0.3419502378,
0.2354757786,
0.7712485194,
-0.3330285251,
0.7483552694,
0.5929726362,
-0.0214241035,
0.4235749245,
0.6059513688,
0.0282860063,
0.6800369024,
0.1652592719,
-0.1280863285,
-0.6357275248,
-0.1193290502,
-0.4468915761,
0.338530004,
0.0635927916,
-0.2792982459,
0.0905329362,
0.0442790575,
-0.27036798,
0.1620305032,
-0.376860559,
0.814149797,
-0.0295131691,
-0.7567791343,
0.5807886124,
0.1494350284,
1.046112299,
-0.622561574,
0.029602278,
-0.1366256028,
0.2522519231,
-0.2214098871,
-0.6864305735,
-0.2314097881,
-0.277887255,
-0.439940989,
-0.2297556698,
0.5409549475,
-0.7948381901,
-0.4722898304,
-0.0878816992,
0.4352459311,
0.0036082314,
-0.3628750145,
-0.5219377875,
-0.0153894741,
-0.0934091881,
-0.234168455,
0.5987114906,
0.3314692676,
0.120494388,
0.8095799685,
0.5047857761,
-0.1666089445,
-0.0383809991,
-0.1400320232,
1.0391653776,
-0.519320488,
-0.5558406115,
-0.8837251663,
0.8966584802,
-0.0064335847,
-0.2675887942,
0.5488333702,
0.5646182299,
0.8140988946,
-0.1662065983,
0.7588847876,
0.0144597488,
0.3943460584,
-0.6753524542,
0.5145933628,
-0.9246174097,
0.1878032237,
-0.1179798469,
-0.7922343612,
0.0482961722,
0.4909800291,
-0.1415700465,
0.1325317174,
0.3121297956,
0.7223224044,
-0.3796329796,
-0.139095366,
0.2166681141,
-0.064758718,
0.1263640225,
0.7515758872,
1.0901823044,
-0.156302914,
0.4085356891,
-0.5823786259,
-0.3288525343,
-0.6205816269,
-0.8638802171,
-0.8236487508,
-0.4963388145,
-0.453130722,
-0.0293194987,
-0.1301563531,
1.3215558529,
0.9311970472,
-0.6378079057,
-0.2403359562,
0.0096601713,
0.1035007238,
-0.5787556767,
-0.1863369197,
0.0456165038,
-0.2440489382,
-0.7373421788,
0.3886860311,
0.2628408968,
-0.0002135783,
-0.4049630761,
-0.3437388837,
0.0227508657,
-0.213926211,
0.4663955569,
-0.0940380916,
-0.8548279405,
0.0133366901,
-0.0260551088,
-0.2338425964,
0.043159306,
0.8567659259,
-0.5172427297,
0.3959412575,
0.4678105712,
0.6862697005,
0.2220726907,
0.2281660438,
0.6883172989,
-0.7355251908,
0.158408463,
0.2196991742,
0.3555155098,
0.2264281958,
-0.4541582763,
0.5424547195,
0.1522983015,
-0.7620682716,
-0.9540511966,
0.1812340617,
-1.447907567,
-0.2239728719,
1.150277257,
-0.1002391577,
-0.0119145233,
0.0445005745,
-0.3488053679,
0.1078533158,
-0.6787248254,
1.134945035,
0.8369339108,
0.0030172036,
-0.0485802442,
-0.4310083091,
0.1686985791,
0.5844805241,
-0.4822571278,
-0.0222292468,
0.4107800722,
0.4102250934,
0.0555818118,
0.4650191963,
0.0357160643,
0.1936636567,
-0.1854786575,
0.3447465599,
-0.7888225317,
-0.2794400156,
-0.1670608521,
0.1208055317,
0.3829939961,
-0.2852845788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01196v1
|
Machine Translation in the Covid domain: an English-Irish case study for LoResMT 2021
| 2024-03-02T12:29:28 | 2024-03-02T12:29:28 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Translation models for the specific domain of translating Covid data from
English to Irish were developed for the LoResMT 2021 shared task. Domain
adaptation techniques, using a Covid-adapted generic 55k corpus from the
Directorate General of Translation, were applied. Fine-tuning, mixed
fine-tuning and combined dataset approaches were compared with models trained
on an extended in-domain dataset. As part of this study, an English-Irish
dataset of Covid related data, from the Health and Education domains, was
developed. The highest-performing model used a Transformer architecture trained
with an extended in-domain Covid dataset. In the context of this study, we have
demonstrated that extending an 8k in-domain baseline dataset by just 5k lines
improved the BLEU score by 27 points.
|
[
0.1297728419,
-0.5070264935,
0.0718456954,
0.14934659,
0.0338045768,
0.1283815056,
0.0453796275,
-0.7980165482,
0.1003263742,
0.6406188011,
-0.4751293361,
-0.3707143366,
-0.6229817867,
0.1786114872,
-0.40440467,
1.2077786922,
-0.2233507335,
0.1300318688,
-0.3577602804,
-0.0114672072,
-0.6071495414,
-0.7017776966,
-0.6871091127,
-0.4067916572,
0.234366715,
0.7277277708,
0.5751330256,
0.1593364775,
1.2472681999,
0.0800636187,
0.2717793584,
0.3384659588,
-0.6738073826,
-0.0022942484,
-0.4819410443,
-0.3804844916,
-0.8481550813,
0.0863823667,
0.1357539147,
0.6826575398,
0.0789886639,
0.5423629284,
0.0521739461,
0.5074988008,
-0.3570452631,
0.0967920274,
-0.5507436991,
0.0652918294,
-0.0246037822,
-0.3303821981,
-0.7212604284,
0.1547325104,
0.5593937039,
-0.7232844234,
0.2483726442,
0.3850083351,
0.8945667148,
0.387373805,
-0.5075516701,
-0.3242558539,
-0.7500350475,
0.9123966694,
-0.3559556305,
0.4733372033,
0.3870400786,
0.1932973564,
-0.3057373464,
-0.7260926962,
0.0074893776,
-0.0590918511,
0.0153344255,
0.5559504032,
-0.8012269735,
-0.2139898092,
0.027308194,
0.2448195517,
-0.9519212842,
0.0146937575,
-0.9942957759,
-0.2091853321,
0.8856706023,
0.2365507036,
0.3128325939,
0.0566500686,
-0.6336625218,
-0.0872309506,
-0.5161027908,
0.0081507312,
-0.1230518669,
0.2761083245,
-0.3313651979,
0.6886590123,
0.0366532244,
0.6181069016,
0.2308863252,
-0.1178428158,
0.2998033166,
-0.302213192,
-0.6082658172,
0.2668880224,
0.1554110199,
0.5497663617,
0.0396616273,
-0.3616200089,
-0.0044693057,
0.1714086235,
0.462960124,
-0.6843078136,
-0.2631411552,
0.1532955617,
-0.3220148087,
0.0797047988,
-0.1378115714,
-0.5467227697,
-0.0547895059,
-0.3509024978,
0.5861138105,
-0.4121885598,
0.022720987,
0.5236526728,
-0.4303560853,
0.2775229812,
0.5517958999,
-0.5121135116,
0.5686023831,
0.4243474901,
0.5805871487,
-0.7720134258,
-0.1283710599,
-0.6229016781,
0.2867221236,
-0.3486376405,
0.4595242143,
-0.4891850352,
-0.2205944955,
-0.146738708,
0.1509707421,
-0.5021395683,
-0.6732528806,
0.7991975546,
-0.5271659493,
0.277821511,
0.1417502165,
-0.4980637431,
-0.3401633799,
0.2447947711,
-0.5776824951,
0.879363358,
0.3314807415,
-0.6137558222,
0.249017939,
-0.7296761274,
-0.5525833368,
0.1763012856,
0.4208814502,
-0.5144768953,
0.1310862452,
0.3028739989,
0.7404238582,
-0.4105421603,
0.2401621491,
-0.107799314,
-0.1032413617,
0.0746058822,
-0.2309333533,
0.7192648649,
0.3415278196,
0.0153770521,
-0.2351167053,
-0.7115100622,
-0.2574533522,
-0.1693670899,
-0.1196786389,
-0.4637457728,
-0.2899622619,
0.1913188696,
0.1742421985,
0.3913783729,
-0.4535070062,
0.1607217789,
-0.1542456001,
0.2973722517,
-0.0362382494,
0.0846722871,
0.5980780721,
-0.5375109911,
0.6159824133,
0.1903466731,
0.2680001259,
0.0999750271,
-0.7614780664,
-0.4402798116,
-0.433713764,
-0.040821597,
1.1161315441,
-0.6776550412,
0.2152057588,
-0.365073204,
-0.6009206176,
-0.8060695529,
-0.2328433841,
0.1608350873,
0.6022032499,
0.8463490009,
-0.1757131666,
-0.7185906768,
-0.7011948228,
-0.1028916985,
-0.0112964166,
0.2925529778,
0.2247296721,
0.8074710369,
-0.5486404896,
0.5765875578,
-0.3851781785,
-0.306622982,
-0.0932191089,
0.0810260549,
0.1318527162,
0.5858005881,
0.3127617836,
-1.0467689037,
-0.42678684,
0.5417244434,
-0.8480647802,
0.0282895807,
-0.0476633646,
-0.0600721911,
-0.0374641716,
0.4000530243,
-0.1602315009,
0.7490082383,
0.98647964,
-0.5375087261,
0.4945105612,
-0.2550081313,
0.3678592145,
-1.4261516333,
-0.0833236724,
-0.0808542371,
-0.5029193163,
-0.7856342793,
0.2828540206,
0.0000640354,
-0.4571284652,
-0.4999084473,
0.6255508661,
-0.0965559855,
0.2515179515,
0.0125215398,
-0.2677292824,
0.4691922963,
-0.0386044905,
-0.004892257,
0.9605311155,
0.5196198821,
-0.4752157331,
0.5259214044,
0.518149972,
-0.1073814183,
0.7554042339,
-0.5246391296,
0.0220954865,
0.3105071187,
0.1022894979,
-0.660939455,
-0.3734133244,
0.1269478798,
-0.4283403158,
0.0440878235,
-0.078969419,
0.1086457297,
-0.3303435743,
0.1812290549,
0.3078359365,
0.4165935516,
-0.5932300687,
0.2383991927,
0.2613326907,
-0.1817869842,
-0.3261813521,
-1.0664969683,
0.3380529881,
-0.4780478776,
-0.858774066,
0.7596703768,
-0.2912925482,
-0.3317960203,
0.1397124827,
0.0077137393,
-0.4211796224,
0.0693484917,
0.0836445093,
0.3044267893,
-0.426399678,
-0.0875523314,
0.1436240673,
0.2161399275,
-0.1342827082,
-0.5966246724,
0.1573327929,
0.0916609466,
-0.0528165251,
-0.5038240552,
0.6127199531,
0.6251065135,
-0.1375419348,
0.6897298098,
0.4422188103,
-0.5026504397,
-0.0866603628,
-0.2912610769,
0.1666181684,
-0.3520985842,
0.249880895,
-0.5879020691,
-1.0026984215,
0.4189870954,
-0.1870358884,
-0.2734455764,
0.6389511228,
0.5075187087,
-0.2010097206,
0.4394087493,
0.9419592619,
-0.0445641689,
0.1341710538,
-0.2237870097,
0.1603126377,
-0.6739435792,
-0.2058281302,
-0.489421159,
0.0641839132,
-0.5534849167,
-0.5381244421,
0.4066492915,
0.0965185836,
0.1090690792,
0.6941981912,
-0.4368705153,
-0.0978177264,
0.2249847054,
0.3745140731,
0.2279342711,
0.2166372389,
0.0384290852,
0.0375431255,
-0.8692296743,
-0.3507918119,
0.922239244,
0.2175162882,
0.693190217,
0.0914336815,
0.7299121618,
0.720985949,
-0.1587676108,
-0.5756639242,
-0.0007685171,
-0.6484845877,
-0.4645926952,
-0.4239205718,
-0.2150262743,
-1.1137094498,
-0.3496267796,
-0.0044744387,
-0.4150038958,
0.5563103557,
0.0108231921,
-0.3091649711,
-0.0341153182,
-0.9515440464,
0.7378836274,
-0.0372130722,
-0.3799214065,
-0.2952097356,
-0.3304856718,
-0.0121709099,
-0.4157659113,
0.2576160729,
-0.0113852564,
0.3184054792,
0.8408522606,
-0.2158239484,
0.7351770401,
0.1624879539,
-0.1134016812,
0.122088097,
-0.1520926058,
0.4514504075,
-0.0592713654,
-0.5299606323,
0.2284194976,
0.2398845404,
-0.7464061975,
-0.2994405925,
0.2799181938,
-1.0269978046,
-0.5654628277,
-0.3325611651,
-0.7672480941,
0.0054827831,
-0.1472834647,
0.3590687215,
0.5296373367,
-0.5999982953,
0.2074211389,
0.5875132084,
-0.2797606587,
0.134786725,
0.4384222925,
-0.0044699437,
-0.3288214505,
0.8000580668,
0.100457415,
0.341201216,
0.8096151948,
0.202850759,
0.2090267241,
-0.5841515064,
-0.5741325021,
-0.1816426814,
-0.4529294074,
-0.4103192985,
-0.4267640114,
-0.5563261509,
-0.6761488914,
-0.4554898739,
0.0011703762,
-0.3390423059,
-0.3434536755,
-0.0279304814,
0.844802916,
0.9437807798,
0.1410750747,
0.4626868069,
-0.7188237309,
0.282998383,
0.1687457412,
-0.1151496992,
-0.6308256388,
-0.9708839059,
-0.7856587172,
-0.0074251238,
-0.0510840453,
-0.5290110707,
0.8762072325,
0.390958786,
0.214319855,
-0.1428136975,
-0.0345138125,
1.0711165667,
-0.8134783506,
0.9577694535,
0.238241449,
-0.7573482394,
0.5573650599,
-0.2171526253,
0.2663679719,
0.3205050528,
0.5659264922,
-0.621550858,
-0.2187134475,
-0.4794421196,
-0.5492830873,
0.2563512325,
0.1621206701,
0.0046110074,
0.1934087425,
0.4179284275,
0.5793468356,
-0.216893658,
-0.126118958,
-0.029972652,
-0.0296391696,
-0.2703164518,
-0.3224628866,
0.0363071486,
-0.0640124828,
-0.5549401045,
0.628400743,
0.0066939127,
0.3284590542,
0.4628368914,
-0.4871152341,
-0.2066095769,
0.2630441487,
0.5966371894,
0.727461338,
-0.236557126,
-0.0344994478,
0.3201394677,
-0.9208009243,
0.1338943392,
0.2072196603,
-0.1496606469,
-0.0173076261,
0.5971791148,
0.9709794521,
-0.0014297588,
-0.2649251223,
0.475774169,
-0.077694267,
-0.207034409,
-0.2638964355,
0.1179145277,
-0.2515585423,
0.4202266335,
0.5898535252,
0.4838641286,
0.350320071,
-0.3408932388,
0.5646067858,
0.0698236302,
-0.4605068862,
-0.6028620005,
0.539104104,
0.2023939937,
-0.3933416307,
0.2451038808,
0.1087044701,
-0.1612537354,
0.4814962745,
0.9504265785,
0.6786675453,
-0.506953001,
0.2353055328,
0.1508316696,
0.2987086475,
-0.2362968177,
0.4128263593,
0.4987491071,
-0.6001243591,
-0.605360806,
-0.597584486,
-0.6264675856,
0.0480608046,
-1.144212842,
0.3595428765,
0.2444988936,
-0.0060946522,
-0.1095488667,
0.2851059735,
-1.1806377172,
0.6590911746,
0.0639355332,
1.238147974,
-1.0739182234,
1.0522129536,
0.9183484316,
-0.2192825675,
-0.5381550193,
-0.0199520029,
-0.4517764449,
-0.9208103418,
0.6969937682,
-0.1902012378,
-0.0700413957,
0.1948498338,
-0.5605949163,
-1.0487939119,
1.1902350187,
0.4241585433,
-0.6842986345,
0.0794729516,
0.4607342184,
0.5695995092,
-0.6004392505,
-0.2677922845,
0.5221127272,
0.2762332559,
-0.0382311903,
-1.1721440554,
-0.3465245366,
-0.2030615956,
-0.4845303893,
-0.1491716206,
-0.6015667319,
0.454220593,
0.0099794017,
0.2022429854,
0.0162929799,
0.6941403151,
-0.0906609893,
0.7520263791,
-0.0826718509,
0.6620227695,
1.1471344233,
0.0653850734,
0.9354508519,
-0.0597859733,
0.1268648654,
1.0550647974,
-0.3893841207,
0.8735275865,
0.3998081386,
0.0014201822,
0.3970682919,
0.5548830032,
0.0590725876,
0.5086122155,
-0.0023232512,
-0.2446706444,
-0.1405369788,
-0.415320158,
-0.2937948406,
0.6431072354,
0.6258237958,
-0.2188562751,
0.0479695946,
0.5421156883,
-0.0712102726,
0.0264110211,
-0.6020322442,
0.7208724022,
0.1987193376,
-0.5256875753,
0.5619055033,
0.0773007944,
0.3947829008,
-0.3208768964,
-0.0671776235,
-0.2298685014,
0.1042523757,
-0.3325532973,
-0.5771297812,
0.6049794555,
0.0903846845,
-0.5784733295,
-0.4435102344,
0.8733429909,
-0.4985259473,
-0.7743700743,
0.5063431263,
0.7374099493,
0.4408357441,
0.2813319266,
-0.6155902147,
0.0942763016,
-0.1212819889,
0.1030822769,
0.1467912644,
0.7122360468,
-0.5358538628,
0.4663899243,
0.3839081526,
0.2973123193,
0.2999067605,
-0.2001614124,
0.5641651154,
-0.4528296292,
-0.119769156,
-0.6478266716,
0.2939781845,
0.088725619,
-0.3641187549,
0.7422508597,
0.8236836195,
0.9556328654,
-0.2692591548,
0.980894208,
0.1185232624,
0.3896923959,
-0.4112412632,
0.4645117223,
-0.4626021981,
-0.2859849632,
0.0485952497,
-0.3307184279,
-0.6006338596,
0.2990797162,
-0.4765297174,
-0.7337093949,
0.7463136315,
0.638790071,
-0.2452853471,
-0.1407607794,
0.7994158864,
0.1531975865,
0.1229856312,
0.4892916977,
0.5510015488,
-0.8699333668,
0.3034184575,
0.0605359152,
-0.189192906,
-0.290106833,
-0.7987651229,
-0.8760870695,
-0.690274477,
-0.5011340976,
-0.4057693779,
0.7417129874,
0.9547818303,
0.7735540271,
-1.1247550249,
-0.3653428257,
0.4039278328,
-0.2669348717,
-0.6081082225,
-0.1509515345,
0.4813880026,
-0.2383591086,
-0.5612872243,
0.6414530277,
0.4764065444,
-0.1050124913,
0.089222841,
-0.1468728483,
-0.2385236323,
0.1251751781,
0.8636547327,
-0.1176494882,
-0.3476286232,
-0.4647462666,
0.4799329638,
-0.1418228745,
0.1307026595,
0.5626762509,
-0.6736912131,
0.3706945181,
0.2590004504,
0.8489226699,
0.4755606949,
-0.2636653185,
0.76714468,
-0.7056596279,
0.1231943667,
0.1733149737,
0.2750928104,
0.4296611845,
-0.7494745851,
0.5964412689,
0.2852494121,
-0.6566922665,
-0.5390852094,
-0.0077812169,
-1.1686215401,
0.0341333114,
1.0482928753,
-0.2672575712,
-0.306139648,
-0.5704817772,
-0.1614611,
0.49895522,
-0.3685990274,
0.516061902,
0.6294395924,
-0.0662647262,
0.1355049908,
-0.7479516268,
0.400690347,
0.1937937289,
-0.7843291163,
-0.1930969656,
-0.0177178439,
0.1118771508,
-0.04108366,
0.191926375,
0.1361332834,
0.424847573,
-0.2846533954,
0.1704976261,
0.3518688679,
-0.4454773068,
-0.4089235365,
0.1022615582,
-0.1324254274,
-0.0699171126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01193v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01193v3
|
RAGged Edges: The Double-Edged Sword of Retrieval-Augmented Chatbots
| 2024-03-02T12:19:04 | 2024-06-12T12:00:52 |
Philip Feldman, James R. Foulds, Shimei Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT demonstrate the remarkable progress
of artificial intelligence. However, their tendency to hallucinate -- generate
plausible but false information -- poses a significant challenge. This issue is
critical, as seen in recent court cases where ChatGPT's use led to citations of
non-existent legal rulings. This paper explores how Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) can counter hallucinations by integrating external knowledge
with prompts. We empirically evaluate RAG against standard LLMs using prompts
designed to induce hallucinations. Our results show that RAG increases accuracy
in some cases, but can still be misled when prompts directly contradict the
model's pre-trained understanding. These findings highlight the complex nature
of hallucinations and the need for more robust solutions to ensure LLM
reliability in real-world applications. We offer practical recommendations for
RAG deployment and discuss implications for the development of more trustworthy
LLMs.
|
[
-0.5043913126,
-0.9318004847,
0.8137353063,
0.1159136146,
-0.0743806735,
0.2985497713,
-0.2451656908,
-0.6384774446,
0.3104013205,
0.8276165128,
-0.5612581372,
-0.166808486,
-0.6316750646,
-0.025091121,
-0.6639692187,
1.0317304134,
0.3662541807,
-0.1309501678,
-0.2251766771,
0.0681291074,
-0.7027540207,
-0.7354862094,
-0.7427616715,
-0.3857886493,
0.4224303961,
0.1417299658,
1.1108615398,
0.1231003925,
0.5423676372,
0.2876311839,
-0.0818796307,
0.6473580599,
-0.7428054214,
0.5901601911,
-0.0504562557,
-0.4200586081,
-0.0819761381,
-0.1766722202,
0.2692973912,
0.4990371764,
-0.3235979974,
-0.2063904852,
0.0607587434,
0.8275899291,
-0.3886036575,
-0.3568312824,
-1.0398464203,
0.2092562169,
0.0394682139,
-0.3470510244,
-0.7140915394,
-0.3499404192,
-0.0005673465,
-0.4887791872,
0.1911475211,
0.3151471019,
1.0183104277,
0.7269363999,
-0.0613123924,
-0.7216270566,
-0.9328680038,
0.5135387182,
-0.2961968184,
0.4878136814,
0.6222547293,
0.5088306069,
-0.7001049519,
-0.8621057272,
-0.4854412377,
-0.5891492367,
-0.035797406,
0.0638658851,
-0.2201175839,
0.0108107775,
0.3219130039,
0.1169974282,
-0.4909798801,
-0.001420943,
-0.5094456077,
-0.2132107913,
0.5648548603,
0.1286564469,
0.3912523687,
-0.2416606396,
-0.3491816521,
0.0242469031,
-0.5820147395,
-0.5225981474,
0.4876309335,
0.3862173855,
0.3491309285,
0.7284884453,
0.2030023187,
0.419275403,
0.170666039,
-0.0331316553,
0.0805066228,
0.2029356211,
0.0253123436,
0.1443748623,
0.7095473409,
0.3216879964,
0.4546385407,
-0.5118433833,
-0.4111474454,
0.0634726509,
0.9289643168,
-0.4660673141,
-0.3968422413,
0.2866315842,
-0.2358341813,
-0.1852659732,
-0.1079033688,
-1.0452250242,
-1.0804708004,
-0.2192799151,
0.7230545878,
-0.6821042299,
-0.0494075418,
-0.1039776132,
-0.286534071,
0.1894707084,
0.2604823112,
-0.5594590902,
0.3768107891,
0.8101783991,
0.944488883,
-0.2741630375,
-0.094728291,
-0.5128775239,
-0.2033312619,
-0.4597562551,
1.0105549097,
-0.5286352038,
-0.6266459823,
0.0570505857,
-0.1477029771,
0.173203975,
-0.8508276939,
0.7521060705,
-0.5170009136,
0.3018427491,
-0.0898742154,
-0.1915848702,
-0.1573132277,
0.2831276953,
-0.4942184389,
1.2535054684,
-0.0368569866,
-0.6541564465,
0.0805951878,
-0.2917942703,
-0.4254772663,
0.1269069016,
-0.3158264756,
-0.4623627365,
0.290307045,
0.1954175383,
0.1816187352,
-0.0865953714,
0.1925514787,
-0.0707541704,
-0.6069144011,
0.3488437235,
-0.6574892998,
0.5588127375,
0.320009321,
-0.3417242467,
-0.0455782451,
-0.5829011202,
-0.0216586385,
0.25981161,
0.0605238229,
-0.3894863427,
0.0537224859,
-0.1885530353,
0.0446392894,
0.104758814,
-0.2382644713,
-0.0109702181,
-0.3872247934,
0.0194950998,
0.9771600366,
0.030161025,
0.1070182323,
-0.7429702282,
0.4106130004,
-0.1760971546,
-0.0039697075,
0.0674239695,
-0.5235882998,
-0.8475945592,
-0.1311020851,
-0.089311406,
0.6245830655,
-1.1182420254,
0.2784619629,
-0.0805476084,
-0.6083233953,
-0.6691958308,
-0.1178538948,
0.1703235507,
0.4891068935,
0.563991189,
-0.0090711741,
-0.6689912081,
-0.6719068289,
-0.488946557,
-0.0784616172,
-0.1167701706,
0.6775815487,
0.3212711215,
-0.6177082062,
0.6930472851,
-0.2988482416,
-0.3283671737,
-0.0550102368,
-0.0450107381,
0.0926860049,
0.2940506339,
0.1197836548,
-0.9975072742,
-0.2896741629,
-0.174701333,
-0.7678906322,
-0.1838849038,
-0.4199795723,
-0.2427241355,
0.4266543686,
0.3193563223,
-0.8028296828,
0.4310875535,
0.4096522629,
-0.3324815631,
0.8187000155,
-0.3151609004,
0.2051370591,
-0.8911546469,
-0.0690384805,
-0.3127941191,
-0.2061939836,
-0.6223208308,
0.0253557973,
-0.3629216254,
-0.1341820806,
-0.1487655938,
0.6507551074,
-0.2899884582,
-0.0909614712,
-0.4118321836,
0.5779214501,
0.0531023555,
0.326618582,
-0.0389021635,
0.9278965592,
0.1636701375,
-0.6649361849,
0.4156618714,
0.2960878015,
-0.0929900184,
0.6939646602,
-0.5679658651,
0.593883872,
-0.2727382779,
0.0744063556,
-0.8103141189,
-0.3312452734,
0.2563681602,
-0.7098813653,
0.3437609375,
0.0355335809,
-0.5106815696,
-0.3582902551,
-0.3851926029,
-0.0208125748,
0.8412663937,
-0.8213970661,
0.7495824695,
0.5908755064,
0.0375513546,
-0.6700863242,
-0.5908299685,
0.3924135566,
-0.2874348462,
-0.4598801434,
0.1948345304,
-0.0838295594,
-0.535138011,
-0.1918443292,
-0.1239556521,
0.1298069507,
-0.0047607273,
0.570766151,
0.1650606394,
0.0774970129,
0.2728604078,
-0.1153482646,
0.1313231587,
0.1885870844,
-0.1456075013,
0.9102658033,
0.1306418329,
-0.428376019,
-0.1089305058,
0.2475990653,
0.4193458259,
0.1652212888,
0.6519479156,
0.5097605586,
-0.4806663394,
-0.4188947082,
-1.0254064798,
-0.3631170392,
-0.5561785698,
0.3253531754,
-0.452548027,
-0.6433689594,
0.5809239745,
-0.1045147553,
-0.028713163,
0.3682304621,
0.5178952217,
-0.1716291159,
1.0145816803,
0.4899064302,
0.2763829231,
0.3931461275,
-0.0276699197,
0.2645988166,
-0.8649845719,
-0.5003510714,
-0.5466732383,
-0.0923956707,
-0.7726716995,
-0.3941330612,
0.4767799675,
0.019546859,
-0.1953644902,
0.067252107,
-0.9391977191,
0.4607228339,
0.594935596,
0.3698495626,
0.1985317022,
0.1233003512,
0.057744965,
0.0349168777,
-0.6049460769,
-0.6254945397,
0.7356852293,
0.3540870249,
0.9007980227,
-0.0498928875,
0.7119642496,
0.4020861685,
-0.013742228,
-0.8305367827,
0.5792210102,
0.035955485,
-0.6042627692,
-0.2500153482,
-0.5458550453,
-0.9793807864,
0.2899881899,
-0.2387102693,
-0.8442625403,
0.0916755646,
-0.0669751838,
-0.3212919831,
0.409332931,
-0.6145394444,
0.3041846454,
-0.2606553137,
-0.4117313325,
-0.0425841361,
-0.4631709158,
0.3671866953,
-0.1800743341,
0.2521847188,
0.0555215366,
0.0391286016,
0.7631991506,
-0.2725939155,
0.7825450897,
-0.1694256216,
-0.1599171609,
0.5629889369,
0.4298302531,
0.7284406424,
-0.0545404628,
0.015392324,
0.0370268412,
-0.0670053586,
-0.1498026848,
-0.7102547884,
0.674690485,
-0.756631732,
-0.905734241,
-0.4717392623,
-0.6820380688,
-0.294911325,
0.0610123314,
0.4426862299,
0.1966518611,
-0.0554978251,
-0.0805401206,
0.8922848701,
-0.505028367,
0.0581790246,
0.0261285324,
-0.4202130139,
-0.3298875988,
1.0843844414,
0.255674094,
0.2782336473,
-0.2285286635,
0.1232627109,
-0.2430404723,
-0.4230114222,
-0.3728691041,
0.2123814523,
-0.8226745725,
-0.2936467528,
-0.8728150725,
-0.5742484927,
-0.3272135556,
-0.1347889453,
-0.4105620682,
-0.3108009398,
-0.2292669713,
0.0247917268,
0.6786624193,
0.9563475847,
-0.191649124,
0.0658509359,
-0.758764565,
0.5132573247,
0.1916978955,
0.2619843781,
0.059778437,
-0.8414668441,
0.0799887702,
0.1961524934,
-0.2813276947,
-0.7787541747,
0.4649744332,
-0.1618992686,
0.3942536116,
0.1010943577,
0.2851500213,
0.7845196128,
-0.8229502439,
0.8152704239,
-0.1033846885,
-0.560059607,
0.3147837222,
-0.1454626769,
0.0564406514,
0.4262828529,
0.5244929194,
-0.7195075154,
-0.6530629396,
-0.66907233,
-0.7879354358,
0.3088958859,
0.0369116776,
0.5140308142,
-0.1329191327,
0.4038767517,
0.2866027355,
-0.0024774256,
-0.6030281186,
-0.0663699135,
-0.1421804279,
-0.1413433105,
0.4371712804,
-0.4666099846,
-0.0387728922,
0.1998335868,
0.7179142833,
0.1898097098,
0.4297442138,
0.3394506574,
-0.0737033412,
-0.0596720576,
0.0481306836,
0.6696199179,
0.4933016896,
0.0085940827,
0.3222848177,
0.3428181708,
-0.6930479407,
-0.0007427156,
-0.0278143845,
-0.1663908213,
0.0594317466,
0.3076497614,
0.6665802598,
-0.1606984138,
-0.8621183038,
0.1898059994,
-0.0099624246,
-0.0169544183,
-0.6325414777,
0.1087298095,
-0.2918913364,
0.4705046415,
0.6078232527,
0.1141248643,
0.2550926805,
-0.5748782158,
0.4303228557,
0.6424075365,
-0.5875116587,
-0.0514067337,
0.4936406314,
-0.1732489467,
-0.8673695922,
0.738629818,
-0.2769221067,
-0.8676105142,
0.2937332988,
0.6257970929,
0.8339374065,
-0.2015194893,
0.0887391791,
0.0786832869,
0.4726453424,
-0.1731243283,
0.0979296565,
0.0625365376,
-0.5533869863,
-0.2290338427,
-0.5322079062,
-0.5297263861,
0.0781953931,
-0.3476426601,
0.2247160822,
-0.3391470015,
-0.234052062,
-0.497607559,
-0.072429657,
-0.386054188,
-0.0547970943,
0.1654040068,
0.5866202712,
-0.256549865,
0.4807579517,
0.0920647755,
-0.3232560754,
-0.4596609473,
0.1655355245,
-0.0440193526,
-0.9254776239,
0.4706828594,
0.2232030183,
-0.3849360645,
-0.1696956456,
-0.5913354158,
-0.6687527895,
0.6641401052,
0.0776105225,
-0.4432647824,
-0.3044964671,
-0.0285671558,
0.5757690668,
0.0602022447,
0.191058889,
0.598834455,
0.390773952,
0.3690022826,
-0.9844571352,
0.1511622518,
-0.0129643762,
-0.1468141675,
0.2614881694,
-0.4517301023,
0.6363055706,
-0.5129734874,
-0.5200478435,
0.1427583247,
0.5245541334,
0.4431222081,
0.3184066117,
0.3109145463,
0.4203215539,
1.0027008057,
-0.0302412901,
1.020884037,
-0.1136741564,
-0.0385470614,
1.1807253361,
-0.2726344466,
0.7345501781,
0.5512733459,
0.0404247157,
0.4147038758,
0.3405852616,
-0.1638968736,
0.4342445731,
0.2772483528,
-0.0679905191,
-0.0442673899,
-0.3713386059,
-0.3425721526,
0.3201686442,
0.6227548718,
-0.1105793566,
0.0313175321,
0.2558211982,
0.1267402321,
0.3728691041,
-0.100231044,
1.0621973276,
0.3083260357,
-0.6872653961,
0.7395980358,
-0.4045584798,
0.7628589272,
-0.2539168298,
-0.3336653709,
-0.2375029027,
0.1357233822,
-0.2590483427,
-0.7161474228,
0.4261733294,
-0.0040078699,
0.2117341161,
0.1474639326,
0.9754635692,
-0.2395863086,
-0.3537880778,
0.391872108,
0.4854975343,
0.4487383962,
-0.2025243491,
-0.4842339754,
0.2942109704,
-0.0728894845,
-0.27633968,
0.136143297,
0.7677201033,
0.016095398,
0.9767279625,
0.5641348958,
0.2674359083,
0.0759100392,
-0.0241319593,
0.9376702905,
-0.6141121984,
-0.0998139158,
-0.9723961949,
0.3600388169,
-0.2222034633,
0.0331169814,
0.7906156182,
0.3444555402,
0.6434876323,
0.2432019413,
0.5913413763,
0.0998958945,
0.7327061296,
-0.5624366999,
0.9779374003,
-0.4228885472,
0.3276969492,
-0.1201824993,
-0.8366467953,
-0.3412190676,
0.6986990571,
-0.3168353736,
0.3247182071,
0.5225173235,
0.9876641631,
0.1559959054,
0.0071533727,
0.5945997834,
0.2135287821,
0.3484623432,
0.3710428476,
1.2391755581,
-0.3791168928,
0.7074804902,
-0.2366021723,
0.0224833377,
-0.2779941857,
-0.4559526443,
-1.1932061911,
-0.6870588064,
0.1309677511,
-0.8121884465,
0.3787827194,
0.9834445715,
0.4331016541,
-0.500589788,
0.0517113991,
0.1184558868,
0.291303277,
0.2062907964,
-0.2746922672,
0.3932576478,
-0.7587987185,
-0.5464019775,
0.438144654,
0.1436169893,
0.1763999611,
-0.3990499675,
-0.115675211,
-0.099538967,
0.3486508727,
0.6086664796,
0.0675437078,
-0.9017732143,
-0.586258471,
0.13190341,
-0.2249642909,
0.1203543693,
0.5324877501,
-1.1150696278,
0.407659173,
0.2524531484,
0.7782068253,
0.2276853621,
0.0837618858,
0.4680752754,
-0.6144159436,
0.1848852932,
0.6115483642,
0.0944505483,
0.5021080375,
-0.682002902,
0.6133334637,
-0.0009494242,
-0.7572214007,
-1.3172677755,
0.1142033339,
-0.4610427022,
-0.4160389006,
1.1171922684,
0.1973361075,
-0.1928121001,
-0.1302996278,
-0.6331717372,
0.1794331372,
-0.2715832293,
1.2863909006,
0.6291386485,
-0.0861811489,
-0.1107041836,
-0.7520642877,
0.810618937,
0.3130365908,
-0.6820716262,
0.272176981,
0.4673260748,
-0.3196254969,
0.564489305,
0.3759084046,
-0.0516020991,
0.1275141239,
0.3306338489,
-0.006531822,
-0.034740109,
-0.5990571976,
-0.3073647916,
0.0917878821,
0.1984640211,
0.076110132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01187v1
|
A Compositional Typed Semantics for Universal Dependencies
| 2024-03-02T11:58:24 | 2024-03-02T11:58:24 |
Laurestine Bradford, Timothy John O'Donnell, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Languages may encode similar meanings using different sentence structures.
This makes it a challenge to provide a single set of formal rules that can
derive meanings from sentences in many languages at once. To overcome the
challenge, we can take advantage of language-general connections between
meaning and syntax, and build on cross-linguistically parallel syntactic
structures. We introduce UD Type Calculus, a compositional, principled, and
language-independent system of semantic types and logical forms for lexical
items which builds on a widely-used language-general dependency syntax
framework. We explain the essential features of UD Type Calculus, which all
involve giving dependency relations denotations just like those of words. These
allow UD-TC to derive correct meanings for sentences with a wide range of
syntactic structures by making use of dependency labels. Finally, we present
evaluation results on a large existing corpus of sentences and their logical
forms, showing that UD-TC can produce meanings comparable with our baseline.
|
[
-0.0184165109,
-0.5244546533,
0.8686397672,
0.4627936482,
-0.0814225003,
0.1184943616,
0.0500785261,
-0.4574851394,
0.3976382315,
0.5443326235,
-0.325579524,
-0.3773672581,
-0.4508271813,
0.1598077416,
-0.3753355443,
0.9735766053,
-0.2842788398,
-0.0850797221,
-0.3160724044,
-0.3788868189,
-0.4804022014,
-0.5317700505,
0.1065100506,
-0.0511980392,
0.6682270169,
0.1685599387,
0.6887035966,
0.4675213993,
0.7898639441,
0.2813621163,
0.1733429879,
-0.4548531771,
-0.1157870144,
0.2800376415,
-0.2929719388,
-0.5142218471,
-0.1285283864,
-0.0941773728,
0.7295312881,
1.0055116415,
-0.1829001456,
-0.1014034003,
-0.2215603739,
0.6853978634,
-0.8449711204,
0.6739661694,
-0.4438904822,
0.0157454014,
-0.3936209381,
0.0366155654,
-0.4310527146,
-0.2840925157,
0.5425432324,
-0.5789248347,
-0.2901254594,
-0.3586407602,
0.6237434745,
0.1335611194,
-0.7407807708,
-0.2156822383,
-0.7224938869,
0.5209177732,
-0.1787533313,
0.5163597465,
-0.0068281512,
0.2478546947,
-0.1009943858,
-0.7661033273,
-0.3938954473,
-0.485991925,
-0.4239430428,
0.3867762089,
0.2005295008,
0.3538981676,
-0.0049024639,
0.3847314715,
-0.32084167,
-0.1041238457,
-0.1837785989,
-0.2169170082,
0.2449392676,
0.3074654043,
0.8778039217,
-0.2485930324,
-0.404682219,
0.3880712688,
-0.8813880682,
0.0431349687,
0.1896814257,
0.4783250988,
-0.4572815001,
0.7452648878,
-0.2430268973,
0.7205272913,
-0.4307700694,
-0.1971871108,
-0.1199938431,
-0.2185937613,
-0.3311239779,
-0.1103900522,
0.5188999176,
-0.1238664389,
0.5030980706,
-0.6525369883,
0.136208564,
0.3485955298,
0.1662012935,
-0.625923872,
-0.0858016536,
-0.0534395091,
-0.0496031679,
-0.1634236425,
0.3701481223,
-0.3427448869,
0.094240196,
-0.7669536471,
0.4054068327,
-0.2718807757,
-0.1469747275,
0.4134039283,
-0.0993330777,
0.1912326664,
0.306571126,
-1.0563820601,
0.4594063461,
0.4463036656,
0.5918381214,
-0.2193343341,
-0.1654411703,
-0.6659180522,
0.7409871221,
0.1376998127,
0.9460937977,
-0.7047046423,
-0.3757718801,
0.1178596467,
-0.2945046127,
-0.1737049967,
-0.2659941018,
0.4794231951,
-0.3768900037,
0.3881379664,
-0.2744376063,
-0.7140477896,
-0.2505798936,
-0.1896351576,
-0.6746717691,
0.5365884304,
0.5685712099,
-0.8424298763,
0.3866428733,
-0.605672121,
-1.023891449,
0.5669941306,
-0.5903505087,
0.3302250504,
0.138032347,
-0.5880378485,
0.2710790932,
-0.399882704,
0.3023151159,
-0.3514017761,
0.1355980486,
-0.0353483967,
0.0684632212,
1.1937400103,
0.0299727749,
-0.5625020266,
-0.1198179647,
-1.0824583769,
-0.138678804,
-0.2524623275,
-0.6625229716,
-0.4581218064,
0.2264482677,
-0.020648744,
0.0767911375,
0.1967445612,
-0.6304144859,
0.1591393799,
-0.3486440778,
0.5386611223,
0.7843675613,
-0.0724210069,
0.4827756286,
-0.0493060686,
0.4355641007,
0.1728001684,
-0.0470352508,
0.1294597387,
-0.5018185973,
-0.7906790972,
-0.5103908777,
0.0145187583,
0.6742891669,
-0.3859452307,
0.6726956367,
-0.0482406393,
0.0312756784,
-0.014859939,
0.0158505235,
0.2673954964,
0.654168129,
0.2494860142,
-0.2413044572,
-0.6197330952,
-0.7973333597,
0.1023923382,
-0.3712796569,
0.2560587823,
-0.0697273314,
0.352532655,
-0.1918508261,
1.1515336037,
-0.7819772363,
-0.4946335852,
-0.3003129661,
-0.1385897547,
-0.2636517584,
0.1261013448,
0.619512558,
-0.6681895852,
-0.5268867612,
0.1484594792,
-0.8537432551,
-0.2127372622,
0.0542952903,
-0.3632706702,
0.1680627018,
0.2071950287,
-0.6643404365,
0.5081859231,
0.1444993615,
-0.4157461822,
0.8306073546,
-0.0893855765,
-0.1488176286,
-0.8588317633,
0.1062954068,
-0.1295805424,
-0.1455800682,
-0.3898479044,
0.4057908654,
-0.2721180916,
0.2330722511,
-0.550308764,
0.5250291824,
-0.1101943776,
0.0126698827,
0.0686617345,
0.0306760222,
0.2282016277,
0.1466178447,
0.1462738961,
0.3757415414,
0.8593104482,
-0.7358289957,
0.82742697,
0.3569241762,
-0.071320951,
0.8607754707,
-0.5989123583,
-0.3927757144,
-0.1216589361,
0.2576197982,
-0.8004476428,
-0.1694941074,
0.1107365415,
-0.0781174079,
-0.0697185919,
-0.0695829242,
-0.6721852422,
-0.2659713328,
0.0689554513,
0.2654129863,
0.0775377601,
-0.1878893077,
0.8146082163,
0.2589853406,
0.1407234818,
-0.380897969,
-0.7771087885,
-0.1080233231,
-0.1803232729,
-0.7703584433,
0.1331741959,
-0.0538866892,
-0.7225129604,
0.285872221,
-0.2094653994,
-0.2766008675,
0.2378499359,
0.1871329695,
0.3892014623,
-0.2670153081,
0.3834308982,
0.0002010997,
-0.1878402531,
0.1619380414,
-0.5901483893,
0.3509261608,
-0.147392571,
-0.3376755118,
-0.2987708151,
0.6692119241,
0.4668512046,
-0.2033447474,
0.4633289576,
0.2464606613,
-0.2716442347,
-0.1617567241,
-0.3512678146,
0.0662158206,
-0.4231157303,
0.0078662848,
-0.7945215702,
-1.1091980934,
0.6495831609,
0.5512364507,
0.045490656,
0.6000773907,
0.6503624916,
0.0497308597,
0.4094527066,
0.7022200227,
-0.0405716859,
0.149868831,
0.0278060734,
0.1370715648,
-0.302696228,
-0.320104599,
-0.615957737,
0.004523952,
-0.6411786079,
0.0978764966,
0.1778975725,
-0.0141525427,
-0.3594442308,
0.6836506724,
-0.3191684186,
0.3734832406,
0.6754384637,
-0.2359714359,
0.4218370318,
-0.0694060922,
-0.663651228,
0.0916640684,
0.1024428084,
-0.1775565594,
0.9593400359,
-0.2577527463,
0.8770315647,
0.515717566,
0.6563979983,
0.3376921117,
0.0472220741,
-0.9140437245,
0.5621731877,
-0.6153714061,
-0.5885885358,
0.2067709267,
-0.5643026829,
-0.7473372817,
0.0512379631,
0.054158438,
-1.0619438887,
-0.159744516,
-0.3060516119,
-0.2027009577,
0.2314210087,
-0.9596591592,
0.7143340111,
-0.1568064243,
0.1921904981,
-0.094899565,
-0.6802873015,
0.3468509912,
0.1102339551,
-0.2926460803,
-0.1206078231,
0.1558717489,
0.4204019308,
-0.4801229835,
0.8445438743,
0.217959404,
-0.2325600982,
0.5493080616,
0.5754647851,
-0.0042221625,
0.2379051745,
0.3118757308,
-0.2895704806,
0.3345566988,
-0.3369212747,
-0.6915433407,
0.5840680599,
-0.7394413352,
-0.5469467044,
-0.2422427684,
-0.7117435336,
-0.3496120572,
0.5056678057,
0.0935814008,
0.8480136991,
-0.1452023536,
-0.1281840056,
0.3097782135,
0.1770469546,
0.5363931656,
0.6007601619,
-0.2368533611,
-0.3060328662,
0.7328662872,
-0.0628401935,
0.5756151676,
1.1246781349,
0.1943172216,
-0.4887831211,
0.035320513,
-0.2964751422,
0.2332349569,
-0.8598003387,
-0.0984404758,
-0.8135206103,
-0.3417315185,
-0.6433596015,
-0.4337232411,
-0.0268402826,
-0.8296858668,
-0.2763933837,
-0.3007186949,
0.5440276265,
0.9692410827,
-0.1816269606,
0.1417968422,
-0.8535966277,
0.4521603584,
0.6825743318,
0.4869560003,
-0.3530676067,
-0.0362312496,
0.0057154237,
-0.1757579595,
-0.3595121801,
-0.5600869656,
-0.1486275047,
0.2232783437,
0.6611504555,
0.5393180251,
-0.0906355157,
0.3547065556,
-0.4300031364,
0.4510624707,
0.4114034474,
-1.1506254673,
0.5666438937,
-0.5119023919,
-0.0140081421,
0.533126235,
0.2656471729,
-0.6377815008,
-0.6732202768,
-0.6629192829,
-0.404928863,
0.3533388376,
0.08902549,
-0.0390279591,
-0.2679570913,
0.4596404731,
0.1037897244,
0.0129308281,
-0.9373618364,
-0.3930569589,
-0.0118410271,
-0.4312532842,
0.3377204835,
-0.1030039191,
-0.2369559258,
-0.1713363677,
0.0602717325,
-0.0008383259,
0.1848543137,
0.0015432416,
-0.4288960397,
0.1709119827,
0.4399574697,
0.6638149619,
0.6703981757,
-0.2905621827,
0.604572773,
-0.6220712662,
-0.5899433494,
0.4143693149,
0.1306016743,
-0.4203300178,
-0.2011107653,
0.1574882567,
0.4202474952,
0.2487072051,
-0.5335252881,
0.2745726705,
0.3519032598,
-0.0559282526,
0.0807205588,
-0.0234052036,
0.4140253961,
-0.2375209928,
-0.0986905918,
-0.0826990232,
0.3780073822,
-0.8283978701,
0.669991374,
0.1915278733,
-0.5505627394,
-0.5967735648,
0.617209971,
0.2961188257,
0.3171701431,
0.4241846204,
-0.2292168587,
-0.425706774,
0.4680320919,
0.6872240305,
1.0500199795,
0.0091040749,
0.7519117594,
-0.0298238564,
-0.0585519075,
0.0489591956,
0.3777260482,
0.0271181408,
-0.8540700078,
-0.6058300734,
-0.7575283051,
-0.3817472756,
-0.3733009398,
-0.544893086,
0.2983906567,
-0.4954479039,
0.4205330312,
0.2227391154,
-0.4261598289,
-0.57600981,
0.2015328258,
0.0605329387,
0.3541786671,
-0.7040240169,
0.6933289766,
0.9355784059,
-1.0659019947,
-0.9800210595,
-0.2970154881,
0.1188849136,
-0.8922427297,
1.3010262251,
0.1459815055,
-0.2053042203,
0.0623437129,
-0.0703240037,
-0.7961323261,
0.5899887681,
0.5633886456,
-0.1273011118,
-0.2185634375,
0.7767279148,
0.5225914121,
-0.6496005058,
0.23961851,
0.7054254413,
0.5581566095,
0.0622254349,
-0.8101933002,
0.3036425412,
0.2067567706,
0.0549829341,
0.5013839006,
-0.3619867861,
0.6332861781,
-0.2172751129,
-0.4516600072,
-0.0003099139,
0.4865233004,
-0.113836877,
-0.4270807505,
0.2491978407,
1.1494327784,
0.2193062007,
-0.1283559799,
0.728585124,
-0.0612505116,
0.347615391,
1.0491312742,
-0.2610677183,
0.5202502012,
0.1381720155,
-0.4419162571,
0.9186350703,
0.1162783578,
0.1962954998,
0.4212405086,
0.5401416421,
-0.7733757496,
-0.2095405459,
-0.2657644153,
-0.1966994256,
0.6365172863,
0.3104534745,
-0.0322661139,
-0.8094703555,
0.0393133499,
-0.0126827452,
0.1421738565,
-0.0622498579,
0.7431634665,
0.2574313879,
-0.3802799881,
0.1563226283,
-0.4760592878,
0.2947823107,
-0.5024276972,
0.1339795142,
-0.1404509991,
0.0493322276,
-0.2413749546,
-1.0227109194,
0.4643535018,
-0.2628245056,
-0.1328729689,
-0.0652456358,
0.3453769088,
-0.289170444,
-0.5256456137,
0.5364128947,
0.5759519935,
-0.1563802212,
0.0767809153,
-0.3020872474,
-0.3946317732,
-0.1569611281,
0.2781277299,
0.2333017439,
0.7217230797,
0.0856956467,
0.6396275759,
0.1354475766,
0.1405462772,
0.244537279,
0.5419695377,
0.5830730796,
-0.7868334055,
-0.5216619372,
-0.6227978468,
0.6522244215,
0.4853208959,
-0.3347895145,
0.2127182782,
0.4355272949,
0.6863389015,
0.0125460736,
0.8574529886,
-0.5685353875,
0.1437614858,
-0.3862943351,
0.2629370987,
-0.3160419762,
-0.155218035,
-0.23949036,
-1.1018592119,
-0.8232015371,
0.1790174842,
-0.1425522864,
-0.4037258327,
1.1765053272,
0.1222119853,
-0.0318346433,
0.0691434667,
0.3452384472,
0.0535499603,
0.5907124281,
0.6018249989,
0.7776466012,
0.092217572,
0.6402845383,
-0.1255990118,
-0.1794754416,
0.1021133959,
-0.6121781468,
-0.5124489665,
-0.8980064392,
-0.4011798501,
-0.3286698461,
-0.2618486881,
0.520197928,
0.3487976789,
-0.867972374,
-0.3814339638,
-0.6559936404,
0.2360535711,
0.1847187728,
-0.3908509314,
0.3542783558,
-0.7880294919,
-0.3733577132,
0.0394607484,
0.9125266671,
0.2254934907,
-0.2133746594,
0.2883996964,
-0.1629015654,
-0.0638691634,
0.9322971106,
0.422708571,
-0.7546446323,
-0.9313512444,
-0.1771386713,
-0.3425804079,
0.1574875563,
1.0763773918,
-0.6278156638,
0.3782526553,
0.7045716047,
0.6052348614,
0.0181283634,
-0.4517948329,
0.6801389456,
-0.4115684628,
0.3100988269,
0.1428765804,
0.7044992447,
0.0368915685,
-0.1853099316,
0.5413237214,
0.7250986099,
-0.3397219777,
-0.1824510098,
0.9507120252,
-1.6408034563,
0.0263700951,
1.1647047997,
-0.374502182,
0.1527323127,
-0.3330537975,
0.1099151224,
-0.0270759668,
-0.2243497968,
0.5713706613,
0.6031534076,
-0.1535930037,
0.1257775426,
-0.0539897271,
0.2433900386,
0.1420747489,
-1.1252720356,
-0.1206875592,
0.7016817927,
0.5223211646,
0.2330617011,
0.6427175999,
-0.2516444027,
0.1020628661,
-0.1888494939,
0.2064017653,
0.4664066136,
-0.3332688212,
0.4488616288,
0.0248690806,
-0.2170142233,
-0.0735479221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01185v1
|
Balancing Exploration and Exploitation in LLM using Soft RLLF for Enhanced Negation Understanding
| 2024-03-02T11:54:55 | 2024-03-02T11:54:55 |
Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Ken Satoh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Finetuning approaches in NLP often focus on exploitation rather than
exploration, which may lead to suboptimal models. Given the vast search space
of natural language, this limited exploration can restrict their performance in
complex, high-stakes domains, where accurate negation understanding and logical
reasoning abilities are crucial. To address this issue, we leverage
Reinforcement Learning from Logical Feedback (RLLF) to create an effective
balance between exploration and exploitation in LLMs. Our approach employs an
appropriate benchmark dataset for training and evaluation, highlighting the
importance of exploration in enhancing negation understanding capabilities. We
compare the performance of our RLLF-enhanced LLMs with baseline models trained
without RLLF, demonstrating the value of this balanced approach. Furthermore,
we showcase the potential of our method in legal AI applications by employing
transfer learning and evaluating its impact on negation understanding. Our
experimental results exhibit the effectiveness of balancing exploration and
exploitation with RLLF in improving LLMs' negation capabilities. This has
implications for the development of more accurate, reliable, and logically
consistent language models in high-stakes domains.
|
[
-0.2476072013,
-0.9434927106,
0.3978226185,
0.2705714405,
-0.1822142601,
-0.0102527244,
-0.3563266098,
-0.4919092357,
0.1227946281,
0.8463776708,
-0.7697039247,
-0.5284204483,
-0.7140105367,
0.1157946214,
-0.203894183,
1.2731523514,
0.1388023943,
-0.0024045631,
-0.434880048,
-0.5400972962,
-1.0359381437,
-0.4090847671,
-0.7159230113,
-0.8576250076,
0.4534672797,
0.3812907636,
0.7773933411,
0.3788315654,
0.3983360827,
0.3167014122,
-0.1308060586,
0.2636119723,
-0.7473820448,
0.1784572005,
-0.636752665,
-0.5063843131,
-0.3286230266,
0.0114324503,
0.4707667232,
0.6737561226,
-0.5966620445,
-0.0681230053,
-0.0571126305,
0.7756084204,
-0.6071269512,
0.0629607141,
-0.6121535301,
0.4068649709,
0.2019316852,
-0.2957280576,
-0.3838241994,
-0.2067655921,
0.4961006343,
-0.7924689651,
-0.1693294793,
0.0071623782,
0.7554931641,
0.4576449692,
-0.4811119735,
-0.195713371,
-0.5964015126,
0.7621524334,
-0.711946249,
0.3068991899,
0.157334581,
0.2201423198,
-0.3063416481,
-0.6388391256,
-0.4253631234,
-0.5335575342,
-0.1648853868,
0.1939618587,
-0.1697987169,
0.2491295487,
0.3717719316,
-0.0471625365,
-0.2631445229,
0.4181886911,
-0.4131063521,
-0.3149944544,
0.7840487361,
0.1589492112,
0.1754993796,
0.053693179,
-0.5944237709,
-0.0672317743,
-0.7113012075,
0.1843583733,
0.4293294847,
0.3364200592,
0.050794214,
0.6650169492,
-0.1090524122,
0.7660139799,
0.0526468977,
-0.1100818142,
0.3466492295,
-0.2000686824,
-0.3058328927,
0.0981797501,
0.504660964,
0.4494538903,
0.3271046281,
-0.1941337138,
-0.6734696627,
-0.0591786988,
0.5097128749,
-0.6188566089,
0.1303067803,
0.0221387558,
-0.3977730572,
-0.4467602372,
-0.0368151143,
-0.7815598845,
-0.7435844541,
-0.4706400633,
0.5475640893,
-0.469684273,
-0.3803427219,
0.3967917562,
-0.15753676,
0.5191184282,
0.4522500038,
-0.7895359397,
0.5902959704,
0.9049619436,
0.4120518267,
-0.2723610997,
-0.2374277413,
-1.0899868011,
-0.1392597556,
-0.2699304521,
0.4952245951,
-0.4200255275,
-0.2892717421,
0.1225908771,
-0.2737310529,
-0.0812963396,
-0.853898108,
0.7818357944,
-0.5530096889,
0.140783146,
0.2370437384,
-0.453363955,
-0.6222378612,
0.5115634799,
-0.6521309018,
0.9097738266,
0.0933090448,
-0.4096361995,
0.5357273221,
-0.6005696058,
-0.6873088479,
0.0826276168,
-0.3015559614,
-0.4140608311,
0.1138209552,
0.2625022531,
0.197703898,
-0.1237007827,
0.5079315901,
-0.2190315872,
-0.3443423212,
0.3689914048,
-0.3497800827,
0.6249123216,
-0.0158166215,
-0.6383838058,
0.4988988638,
-0.5073509216,
-0.0313772447,
0.1110666692,
-0.408414036,
-0.2279607654,
0.1955083609,
-0.0523424596,
0.2662563026,
0.0368523635,
-0.2993305326,
-0.0991917551,
-0.7136579156,
0.2688476741,
0.8152576089,
0.0155735016,
0.4479242861,
-0.3441355228,
0.8835163116,
-0.1575189978,
-0.0778606236,
0.2609865367,
-0.2582640648,
-0.8380779028,
-0.013730295,
0.3694618046,
0.7882940173,
-0.6088318825,
0.3487122655,
-0.182346195,
-0.0012234073,
-0.6367244124,
0.4527148604,
0.3975453973,
0.8190602064,
0.599381566,
-0.3032872081,
-0.5433089733,
-0.8787087202,
-0.4540599585,
-0.0023387666,
0.2860016227,
0.6366395354,
0.3545294702,
-0.4014893174,
0.9671168923,
-0.1361788362,
-0.5732882619,
-0.6744534373,
0.2689048946,
0.4867227376,
0.4885160327,
0.3665090203,
-0.8782045841,
-0.1449241191,
-0.0403226092,
-0.6792559624,
-0.2863401473,
-0.5028602481,
-0.1657655537,
0.1636724621,
0.6524954438,
-0.5547559857,
0.3882393241,
0.1885942519,
-0.4622470438,
0.3343032598,
-0.2194720954,
-0.1786564142,
-0.2423417568,
-0.0274546798,
0.0807214305,
-0.6212671399,
-0.5071063042,
0.2694258094,
0.0025292898,
0.13413544,
-0.7428554296,
0.421955049,
-0.267785728,
-0.1240754575,
-0.4088190496,
0.6407997012,
-0.0517995209,
0.5488292575,
0.0325733535,
0.5397562981,
0.3730229735,
-0.6534734964,
0.3235007524,
-0.0101001766,
-0.0918005779,
0.5303574204,
-0.7039140463,
0.0073464946,
-0.1928101778,
0.1700982749,
-0.4549728036,
0.2604717612,
0.2604066133,
-0.3506786227,
0.4665436149,
-0.3138736784,
-0.2814733088,
-0.0578341149,
-0.3653053641,
0.1495656371,
0.5725972652,
-0.555680275,
0.8616541028,
0.3764420748,
-0.0216328446,
-0.9666321874,
-0.6532335877,
0.059939079,
-0.50721246,
-0.6083794832,
0.3116193712,
0.2706651986,
-0.3903962076,
0.2356756628,
-0.2176805586,
0.2567429841,
0.430942595,
0.1903571635,
0.3651311696,
-0.1707290262,
-0.065151684,
-0.1851583719,
-0.2329599112,
0.420366019,
-0.4053136408,
0.4428181648,
-0.2760841846,
-0.2409555912,
-0.2312397361,
0.010716917,
0.1467462033,
-0.3237055242,
0.5828465223,
0.5243422985,
-0.3339357078,
-0.5543293357,
-0.4609139562,
-0.2398762703,
-0.4472791553,
0.4087030888,
-0.135487318,
-1.1251432896,
0.3430754542,
-0.2277250141,
0.0873753577,
0.6421077847,
0.3237884641,
0.0003169048,
0.8347198963,
0.8549319506,
-0.1136385947,
0.3298358321,
-0.2229754478,
0.0688076392,
-0.7002401352,
-0.363458693,
-0.197097972,
-0.4505572617,
-0.5993568301,
-0.2597535551,
0.1006850451,
0.164841935,
-0.0568149947,
0.1071115583,
-0.2116001546,
0.5458003283,
0.4895618558,
0.2031012625,
0.2550622225,
0.0069044814,
-0.3448512554,
-0.158699587,
-0.8184499145,
-0.2605876625,
1.1020801067,
0.4408447146,
0.9136641622,
0.2003255635,
0.7131268978,
0.3375019729,
0.3001362681,
-0.9617227316,
0.5866332054,
0.0516655706,
-0.241749391,
-0.3861237764,
-0.5313230753,
-0.8607550859,
0.5313190818,
-0.6281131506,
-0.4730733335,
0.1178658009,
0.1415150464,
-0.5341505408,
0.0964649096,
-0.617084384,
0.8567562699,
-0.4674790502,
-0.8310792446,
-0.6667576432,
-0.5894799232,
0.4911239147,
0.3145357072,
0.3017502725,
0.0412626453,
-0.188451454,
0.737759769,
-0.2948234379,
0.8569865227,
-0.3310285807,
-0.1449905038,
0.3252227902,
0.1560397893,
0.5757986903,
0.3718547225,
-0.0074089952,
-0.2032725513,
-0.5152366757,
-0.1942560524,
-0.739952147,
0.6589356661,
-0.6641457081,
-0.8804718256,
-0.7282053828,
-0.4350045919,
-0.113390401,
0.2545349002,
-0.2842247784,
0.0469788946,
-0.057383962,
0.2206602395,
0.9298968911,
-0.3246649802,
0.1977498084,
0.5591463447,
-0.3014298677,
-0.4489588439,
0.8057291508,
-0.0992213488,
0.1977828741,
0.3073807657,
0.3034228384,
-0.5001340508,
-0.7466757298,
-0.251685977,
0.1668657362,
-0.7501903772,
-0.3271769881,
-0.5960258842,
-0.2414830327,
-0.290820986,
-0.0693390891,
-0.1009716317,
-0.3279661536,
-0.2037359476,
-0.3862540126,
0.4164524376,
0.6514753699,
-0.2922255099,
0.0921610594,
-0.5394646525,
0.4019586444,
0.3683981299,
0.2888515294,
-0.1681247205,
-0.6496193409,
-0.0808905959,
-0.1017388552,
-0.2349378914,
-0.8072664142,
0.4183601737,
0.1525840461,
0.8387119174,
0.0885344073,
-0.0073753372,
0.5941997766,
-0.22071518,
0.3835926056,
0.088211976,
-0.9131295681,
0.5714733601,
-0.1935590059,
0.0531491973,
0.7856021523,
0.0293682795,
-0.5584684014,
-0.1398685575,
-0.7372072935,
-1.1253250837,
0.8942000866,
-0.0280065108,
0.0504355505,
0.4173341095,
0.3915840685,
0.114001438,
0.2725152075,
-1.2219283581,
-0.0273513123,
-0.0009005045,
0.0199050382,
0.081074506,
-0.073637858,
-0.432462126,
-0.1824204326,
0.8275809884,
-0.2034856826,
-0.0628809109,
0.2814808488,
-0.6037141681,
0.0453217477,
0.2489705831,
0.5259565115,
0.6196098924,
-0.1101372093,
0.1536715478,
0.5300493836,
-0.2998979688,
-0.0833199695,
0.1648239195,
-0.1456779689,
-0.3443979025,
0.6129543185,
0.8305929899,
0.1351105869,
-1.0776389837,
0.5679296255,
0.0363735221,
-0.5807125568,
-0.2478533834,
0.430696249,
0.0682343394,
0.4557648003,
0.0854829624,
0.0729087964,
0.1467935145,
-0.4092270434,
0.3621977866,
0.4449980557,
-0.5413551331,
0.2920959592,
0.3327769935,
0.1541877538,
-0.3151905537,
0.8932476044,
-0.3137298822,
-0.7125819325,
0.8679633737,
0.5732220411,
0.8185123205,
0.4486482441,
0.1505497843,
0.1236764863,
0.6209264994,
0.1853120476,
0.3290356398,
-0.0830122456,
-0.723280251,
-0.6975149512,
-0.2476271391,
-0.4488219619,
0.2229259759,
-0.4891895056,
0.3557107449,
-0.7456477284,
0.0995431691,
-0.4273683429,
0.1302337497,
-0.6121335626,
0.1397709101,
0.1030552164,
0.8962268233,
-0.5842314363,
0.597712934,
0.6091499925,
-0.4608765244,
-0.6369206309,
-0.0805737376,
-0.0305485502,
-0.838807404,
0.7907636166,
0.3680821955,
-0.3212912083,
-0.2178609669,
-0.6298877597,
-0.636911869,
1.1911897659,
0.3286510706,
-0.4309893548,
0.4515372813,
0.0446593463,
0.5887932777,
-0.3876765072,
0.1785696298,
0.6976706982,
0.5048148036,
-0.091463834,
-0.4756542444,
0.1052286103,
-0.2386890054,
-0.2027635723,
0.0495655984,
-0.3871462941,
0.4608683884,
-0.3133110702,
-0.1458435655,
-0.384427458,
0.9194129705,
0.3944737017,
0.3276287615,
0.8691219091,
0.7439274788,
0.628108561,
0.0716475025,
0.7337775826,
0.0501616895,
0.1769020408,
1.3828656673,
-0.3520738184,
0.7027082443,
0.6028289199,
0.0387378968,
0.4180845022,
0.5177009106,
0.0803095847,
0.4569810331,
0.7242867351,
-0.1600429118,
-0.1981180757,
-0.3134806752,
-0.1213872433,
0.2028622031,
0.5869868994,
-0.0471366383,
-0.3309764862,
-0.0257179067,
0.0318499804,
0.5205481648,
-0.344563663,
0.9860053658,
0.003699776,
-0.8345102072,
0.4389587641,
0.271771431,
0.9755951762,
-0.5078419447,
-0.326030761,
-0.3754929006,
0.1414802819,
-0.4098469019,
-0.8573408723,
0.2828678191,
0.054904107,
0.2578105927,
-0.5788590908,
0.9531261325,
-0.3297297955,
-0.2015980035,
0.7700121403,
0.410425663,
-0.2075879425,
0.3466069102,
-0.8823871613,
-0.2998231053,
0.0366343521,
-0.1074687093,
0.1828714609,
0.5340918899,
-0.0292108003,
0.7021598816,
0.6495913267,
0.1164735481,
0.1559927315,
0.2440003157,
0.9025734663,
-0.7378382683,
-0.4335865676,
-0.9654966593,
0.3992883861,
-0.1013103351,
-0.3481685817,
0.3871869147,
0.3750016987,
0.885402739,
0.1728436649,
0.6303405762,
0.046115905,
0.1807617545,
-0.8813872337,
0.4132582843,
-0.4951152503,
0.4067589939,
-0.0328620523,
-0.7461408973,
-0.2949374914,
0.8205081224,
-0.3017216921,
-0.0572481006,
0.4930343032,
0.7905436754,
-0.1758071184,
-0.0817617327,
0.1511886716,
0.2893657684,
0.3369701505,
0.6437103152,
0.9587429166,
-0.047859028,
0.4673423171,
-0.252979815,
-0.2617012262,
-0.3527459502,
-1.1592258215,
-0.7721270919,
0.1759238839,
-0.2174941003,
-0.4732112586,
0.1710377932,
1.135918498,
0.5528463125,
-0.6123471856,
-0.4840277433,
-0.4256999791,
0.4490100443,
-0.393447578,
-0.2669581771,
0.0484835021,
-0.7238958478,
-0.4123108983,
0.702378273,
0.274630338,
-0.1596745104,
-0.3567881286,
-0.4161160588,
-0.6152204871,
-0.0086874031,
0.4677239954,
0.412999332,
-0.3833195865,
-0.0911145881,
-0.0616090037,
0.0098191435,
-0.0561485216,
0.8096153736,
-1.1090515852,
0.2140114456,
0.5556596518,
1.247231245,
0.628100872,
-0.2650907636,
0.8426346779,
-0.5013413429,
0.2185107172,
0.4326193035,
0.3098009229,
0.1464518607,
-0.4641710222,
0.7350372076,
0.2218649685,
-0.2417102009,
-0.5605249405,
0.1413550526,
-0.733197093,
-0.214886263,
1.0513054132,
-0.0496407747,
-0.0859381184,
0.1078824922,
-0.1850531548,
0.0805703029,
-0.4391601086,
0.4846096933,
0.7177994251,
-0.315495342,
-0.0903833807,
-0.8741796613,
0.4406754971,
1.1301490068,
-0.7774983048,
-0.1363795698,
0.4450556934,
0.0566002131,
-0.0370532461,
0.4877555668,
-0.0441187955,
0.2824493945,
-0.4755365551,
-0.2198810726,
-0.0403360166,
-0.3652659655,
-0.8059204817,
0.0728420094,
0.0674861446,
0.0844604075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01166v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01166v2
|
DINER: Debiasing Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis with Multi-variable Causal Inference
| 2024-03-02T10:38:31 | 2024-06-06T07:27:33 |
Jialong Wu, Linhai Zhang, Deyu Zhou, Guoqiang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Though notable progress has been made, neural-based aspect-based sentiment
analysis (ABSA) models are prone to learn spurious correlations from annotation
biases, resulting in poor robustness on adversarial data transformations. Among
the debiasing solutions, causal inference-based methods have attracted much
research attention, which can be mainly categorized into causal intervention
methods and counterfactual reasoning methods. However, most of the present
debiasing methods focus on single-variable causal inference, which is not
suitable for ABSA with two input variables (the target aspect and the review).
In this paper, we propose a novel framework based on multi-variable causal
inference for debiasing ABSA. In this framework, different types of biases are
tackled based on different causal intervention methods. For the review branch,
the bias is modeled as indirect confounding from context, where backdoor
adjustment intervention is employed for debiasing. For the aspect branch, the
bias is described as a direct correlation with labels, where counterfactual
reasoning is adopted for debiasing. Extensive experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed method compared to various baselines on the two
widely used real-world aspect robustness test set datasets.
|
[
-0.4858512282,
-1.3282589912,
0.8120765686,
0.4519040287,
-0.3338485062,
-0.4857269526,
0.1948654652,
-0.0927619115,
0.399125725,
0.5247403979,
-0.7141438723,
-0.6033012271,
-0.3158912063,
0.0981185064,
-0.0336827673,
0.7666530609,
0.2106928676,
0.5006091595,
-0.2330273986,
-0.3532235622,
-0.6927187443,
-0.5020822883,
-0.5787135959,
-0.2735600471,
0.7008141875,
0.3618659973,
0.5122295618,
-0.044093091,
0.3805182278,
0.1950501949,
0.0042173229,
0.1350878179,
-0.0785636306,
0.3110889196,
-0.4406537414,
-0.334759146,
-0.4050520957,
0.1704476327,
0.1113049388,
0.6257060766,
0.3108263314,
-0.0927929953,
0.1059071571,
0.7813493609,
-0.7754796147,
0.4343678951,
-0.3892363608,
-0.0645230412,
0.3110221326,
0.2585482001,
-0.3295626938,
-0.424631387,
-0.1557605714,
-0.4695610702,
-0.0245345403,
-0.1266760975,
0.6442728043,
0.3546816409,
-0.4503739774,
0.0270230714,
-0.8415379524,
0.899729073,
-0.9364596605,
0.1775256395,
0.5434004068,
0.0292418879,
0.100139983,
-0.1912583113,
-0.7969570756,
0.0122614643,
0.0036686284,
0.2782581449,
-0.0372231826,
-0.0699164495,
-0.0673894435,
0.1538879275,
0.0234527308,
0.0909824446,
0.1935362518,
0.3216901124,
0.43226403,
-0.0201803111,
0.0071789478,
-0.6494475603,
-0.6138939261,
-0.155283004,
-0.8890482187,
0.0982781574,
0.3929702342,
0.5633352399,
-0.1779417992,
0.4010451436,
-0.2598002553,
0.4478523135,
0.1720146537,
0.2259715199,
0.3723205924,
-0.4506800473,
-0.3078117967,
-0.1166718379,
0.8956321478,
0.78719455,
-0.248924315,
0.0514578409,
0.0456403755,
0.1879635751,
0.4152314365,
-0.4742248058,
-0.0207246542,
0.6179689169,
-0.4341550171,
-0.5563580394,
0.2313175648,
-1.1661723852,
-0.7235345244,
-0.2677859366,
0.3958661556,
-0.3366650939,
-0.314661473,
-0.2612437606,
-0.093039088,
0.2638299763,
0.2339562774,
-0.4896056056,
-0.2375147045,
0.8379952908,
0.7388392091,
0.1799368411,
-0.2877116799,
-0.3445508778,
-0.0142155997,
-0.4840323329,
0.8881115317,
-0.5842235684,
-0.2467723489,
0.0261805281,
-0.0245217942,
0.0167183708,
0.0434728973,
0.6066364646,
-0.3833684325,
0.0198162142,
-0.7906576395,
-0.0593297631,
-0.6492578983,
0.6789799929,
-0.8313212395,
0.5881378055,
0.0994957983,
-1.030811429,
0.6867713928,
-0.2842479348,
-0.4957037866,
-0.6566269994,
-0.2083110958,
-0.8220379353,
0.3217558563,
0.772918582,
0.3228876889,
-0.5538750887,
0.7154080272,
-1.0285186768,
-0.0323307104,
0.3644179702,
-0.6712347269,
0.5706928968,
-0.0226352327,
-0.5132082105,
0.4220600128,
-0.5144797564,
-0.3174300194,
-0.2700697482,
0.1945263296,
-0.8598641753,
0.19215554,
-0.1601828933,
0.4350003004,
-0.1289672107,
-0.6723917723,
0.0608423539,
-0.3329805136,
0.0656955987,
0.6680139303,
0.5663931966,
0.2836348116,
-0.1973570287,
0.3084561527,
0.6372095942,
0.4878730774,
0.0601964928,
-0.2269611955,
-0.6681466103,
-0.4412365556,
0.058865197,
0.3134300113,
-1.0465587378,
0.6471167803,
-0.001007017,
-0.3293286562,
-0.3882712424,
-0.2564694881,
0.6217138171,
0.6506925821,
0.5304663181,
-0.4036631286,
-0.358060956,
-1.056329608,
-0.2741769552,
-0.3734329343,
0.2995179594,
0.1758029163,
0.1693460047,
-0.1104487106,
0.8338922858,
-0.559843719,
-0.5195245147,
-0.3047784269,
0.3734788001,
0.3246239126,
0.5780892968,
0.7303565741,
-0.7308106422,
-0.083773233,
-0.4884615541,
-0.9114253521,
0.0014244107,
-0.4019636214,
-0.2226762176,
-0.018961966,
0.2757039666,
-0.3690186739,
0.5521520972,
0.1318817139,
-0.4916398823,
0.5452055931,
0.1740083992,
0.3753872216,
-1.0803979635,
-0.1440005451,
0.4337759316,
0.192531839,
-0.3003822863,
-0.0686684325,
-0.2075202912,
0.1517388374,
-0.2586418688,
0.2975127101,
-0.1246341392,
0.1707524061,
-0.3810304403,
-0.2194972932,
0.3733715713,
0.8605942726,
-0.0288125332,
0.2246521115,
0.6048070192,
-0.1975267678,
0.1991891414,
0.1760289073,
-0.0374592505,
1.0976605415,
-0.4820306599,
-0.0973325446,
-0.3850731552,
0.3150532842,
-1.1418793201,
0.1628598422,
0.667911768,
-0.1335866302,
0.1429357827,
-0.1338694692,
-0.0930928886,
-0.1573815495,
-0.8586348295,
0.1888090223,
-0.2974385023,
-0.5623710752,
0.7118458152,
0.2618120909,
-0.1673347801,
-0.7500972748,
-0.6426703334,
-0.0364242904,
-0.3716438413,
-0.1556037515,
0.0321437567,
0.2305278778,
-0.4860260487,
0.1714741588,
-0.343249619,
-0.1738703549,
0.0277852379,
0.5286827683,
0.1208688542,
-0.112345323,
-0.0827815831,
0.4377635419,
-0.2000191659,
0.3085649312,
-0.0878828019,
0.325968951,
-0.1628207266,
-0.4417486489,
-0.5211675763,
0.5951319337,
0.632900238,
-0.0284411479,
0.7350033522,
0.401951015,
-0.0747747123,
-0.005795171,
-0.4731436372,
-0.2984259725,
-0.3132827282,
0.5000511408,
-0.358114332,
-0.1246990785,
0.5657967329,
0.2479423136,
-0.1369954199,
0.4555800259,
0.3188783228,
0.1017743945,
0.6892437339,
0.2276041508,
-0.4930221736,
0.5590584874,
-0.214329198,
0.26626122,
-1.0283306837,
-0.2234044075,
-0.572198987,
-0.2586002648,
-0.4174840152,
-0.3578965962,
0.3602716625,
0.1210570931,
-0.4866810441,
-0.048727449,
-0.1102804765,
0.1855092943,
0.7801379561,
0.4891891181,
0.2547180355,
-0.2412584573,
-0.0748636425,
0.1709232181,
-0.2697251439,
-0.2130223364,
0.8397772908,
0.2471115887,
1.0406240225,
0.1802764833,
0.3971167505,
0.3286100626,
0.4992564917,
-0.7783761024,
0.1353352517,
-0.116021879,
-0.5944548845,
-0.2822476923,
-0.3851153553,
-0.3381828368,
0.5542673469,
-0.1737975031,
-0.5559064746,
0.8292078376,
0.0273567047,
-0.2933574915,
0.318521142,
-0.5278048515,
0.8525419831,
-0.2102117538,
-0.8295801282,
-0.2504588366,
-0.620323658,
0.4421993792,
0.0571711697,
0.519359529,
-0.1851798743,
0.4642997682,
0.4173256159,
-0.4931156337,
1.3559234142,
-0.7004626393,
-0.1474586874,
0.2245797366,
0.1640383601,
0.2794150114,
0.7411165237,
-0.2102722526,
0.6011704803,
-0.2290638089,
-0.0886439532,
-0.6633882523,
0.9991009235,
-0.7927923799,
-0.6601020098,
-0.5013660789,
-0.4649360776,
-0.6090760231,
0.227349937,
-0.0746715665,
0.4975608587,
-0.2897133827,
0.0264832657,
0.0469126701,
-0.2639041245,
0.5123492479,
0.5203551054,
-0.0049722283,
-0.7749496698,
0.6644540429,
-0.2435040325,
-0.175936684,
0.6472799182,
0.4835214019,
-0.2681801915,
-0.2766070366,
-0.4321688414,
0.0823146626,
-0.5542184114,
-0.441421628,
-0.4399421811,
0.3499212563,
-0.4693011642,
-0.1096505672,
-0.6392980814,
-0.3448423743,
-0.1397864968,
-0.1804181784,
0.1507025063,
0.5771818757,
-0.2863308489,
0.4134023488,
-0.3702018857,
0.447946161,
0.2450448573,
0.1877724081,
0.2457415015,
-0.08985845,
-0.0794581696,
0.1476018131,
-0.5040498376,
-1.1027629375,
0.4197846949,
-0.116867505,
0.2005318999,
0.7133552432,
0.3188175857,
0.4388932288,
-0.0415553637,
0.8435955048,
0.3791163862,
-0.9703317285,
0.4324759245,
-0.2405087799,
0.0093935858,
0.7821500301,
0.2853910327,
-0.3551322222,
-0.6095831394,
-0.3147545755,
-1.3203350306,
0.6097815037,
-0.1019789502,
0.0215329286,
-0.3051192462,
0.3215439022,
0.3572788537,
0.3401764035,
-0.7885553837,
-0.3059876263,
-0.6292100549,
-0.2043782771,
0.0653805658,
-0.3218212724,
-0.1048518941,
-0.2079353482,
0.9881329536,
-0.2765979767,
0.1162985638,
0.3795315325,
0.1518317312,
-0.0452057645,
0.3860102296,
0.2692222297,
0.6720407605,
-0.3326099217,
0.2771259248,
-0.1331728995,
-0.1659927666,
0.171916604,
0.1375930309,
-0.3754001558,
-0.1916429847,
0.4404772222,
0.7633326054,
0.2097877413,
0.0310252067,
0.7538890839,
-0.2759050429,
0.3598475158,
-0.3261594176,
-0.1986534894,
-0.121877268,
0.3898902833,
0.1931643635,
0.1262913644,
0.1709302068,
-0.4498771727,
0.1837848723,
0.5674713254,
-0.977573514,
-0.6194117069,
0.7203647494,
0.3416251838,
0.3926217556,
0.4978244603,
-0.1232673675,
-0.35719648,
0.618779242,
0.2644383013,
1.2537562847,
-0.240994975,
0.454828918,
0.3674952686,
0.2871076763,
0.1172609627,
0.4933519661,
0.1755402833,
-0.7986672521,
-0.4975504279,
-0.6190218329,
-0.3111210763,
0.2342099845,
-0.9943673015,
-0.0323448144,
-0.4006775022,
-0.3128122687,
0.0000235498,
-0.2972416878,
-0.4208672941,
0.3496414721,
-0.1347273439,
0.4423612952,
-1.2896629572,
0.576028645,
0.6215264201,
-0.8575029373,
-0.5686445236,
0.4348787367,
0.187291503,
-0.4676668644,
0.3818452358,
0.1684170514,
-0.2222868353,
-0.6302427053,
-0.3278324008,
-0.4851611257,
0.5765549541,
0.035309393,
-0.3545614481,
0.128910318,
-0.0658809319,
0.3396517038,
-0.3266541958,
0.2698274851,
0.4748969972,
0.5061812997,
-0.1025651321,
-0.4107375145,
0.31834355,
-0.0111685889,
-0.0669472739,
-0.0556969196,
-0.8586388826,
0.9541723728,
-0.0625260621,
0.530950129,
-0.2573275864,
0.7715599537,
0.0029725959,
0.5211693048,
0.5935159922,
0.5785797834,
0.2948258817,
-0.0672957748,
1.0103369951,
-0.1918972582,
0.5683377981,
1.4170638323,
-0.4166723788,
0.4939450324,
0.7373464704,
-0.0434108675,
0.8249511719,
0.52337569,
0.1956739277,
1.0092071295,
-0.175852105,
0.0239216182,
-0.1859917045,
-0.125991419,
-0.1901692152,
0.5555465817,
0.3385277092,
-0.4459905028,
-0.2220815122,
0.0577596463,
0.2860921621,
-0.1269664913,
-0.2671981454,
0.880129993,
0.2647549808,
-0.7741521001,
-0.0701958388,
0.1598351747,
0.4822902381,
-0.3783293962,
0.0975116864,
-0.5874944329,
0.3873388171,
0.0344354436,
-0.5178728104,
0.4594445229,
-0.2077710778,
-0.3881588876,
0.0431861356,
0.4322407246,
-0.1496038288,
-0.6760371923,
0.2738557458,
0.592715919,
-0.477239579,
-0.4577023089,
-0.5662299991,
-0.0090973908,
-0.058389578,
-0.4118452966,
-0.0083603766,
0.4905335903,
-0.1296769828,
0.0287635215,
0.3035908639,
-0.0099820336,
-0.6700538397,
0.3917194605,
0.9451190233,
-0.9883931875,
-0.9213529229,
-1.1020526886,
0.2052920908,
-0.0953506678,
-0.3156684339,
0.871070981,
0.3330470026,
0.4621908665,
-0.1387029141,
0.8516588807,
-0.1815880835,
0.3462087512,
-0.5366180539,
0.6285748482,
-0.4280183911,
0.324354738,
-0.7209590077,
-0.6591914296,
-0.3790538013,
0.5527356863,
-0.639939189,
0.1308330595,
0.8237441778,
0.6674603224,
0.056531027,
0.3051394522,
0.0242462531,
0.3973458111,
0.5662871003,
0.3002120554,
0.8002364039,
-0.1596353352,
-0.1636532843,
-0.5321173072,
-0.3272036612,
-0.2059981078,
-0.9466812611,
-0.8845794797,
-0.5190256238,
-0.3672732115,
-0.5712285042,
-0.019165054,
0.6906417608,
0.6236207485,
-0.9955231547,
0.2770898044,
-0.0601312853,
0.5327382684,
-0.9212502241,
-0.3015174866,
0.730755806,
-0.3897098601,
-0.6408625841,
0.3369500041,
0.2534728348,
-0.5079202652,
-0.4955386817,
0.5034311414,
-0.3605727255,
0.2700377405,
0.6013221741,
-0.1085335165,
-0.6089698076,
-0.563303113,
-0.4788695574,
0.1657723188,
0.2007004023,
0.8531134725,
-0.6589004993,
0.5533151031,
0.4324170351,
0.3218876123,
0.3022141159,
0.493192941,
0.5500531197,
-1.0664753914,
0.324970752,
-0.0096172094,
0.5325300694,
0.3937524557,
-0.4950828552,
0.1499189585,
0.3398343325,
-0.1558941305,
-0.4772046506,
0.381280452,
-0.9063289165,
-0.6828504205,
1.1743500233,
-0.3086920083,
-0.5147830248,
-0.2293859273,
-0.0325539075,
0.3449530602,
-0.5583762527,
1.1201754808,
0.4147971869,
-0.3498122692,
0.3885205388,
-0.0262396131,
0.189955011,
0.401604563,
-1.0856482983,
0.2925718725,
0.9300855994,
0.196272254,
0.179541111,
0.4315913022,
-0.1399046332,
0.0204355158,
0.2428826541,
0.0338449031,
-0.2910058796,
-0.6712381244,
-0.3971568942,
0.3899309337,
-0.0539987274,
-0.508035481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01165v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01165v2
|
STAR: Constraint LoRA with Dynamic Active Learning for Data-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-02T10:38:10 | 2024-06-06T07:31:39 |
Linhai Zhang, Jialong Wu, Deyu Zhou, Guoqiang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Though Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated the powerful
capabilities of few-shot learning through prompting methods, supervised
training is still necessary for complex reasoning tasks. Because of their
extensive parameters and memory consumption, both Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods and Memory-Efficient Fine-Tuning methods have been
proposed for LLMs. Nevertheless, the issue of large annotated data consumption,
the aim of Data-Efficient Fine-Tuning, remains unexplored. One obvious way is
to combine the PEFT method with active learning. However, the experimental
results show that such a combination is not trivial and yields inferior
results. Through probe experiments, such observation might be explained by two
main reasons: uncertainty gap and poor model calibration. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose a novel approach to effectively integrate uncertainty-based
active learning and LoRA. Specifically, for the uncertainty gap, we introduce a
dynamic uncertainty measurement that combines the uncertainty of the base model
and the uncertainty of the full model during the iteration of active learning.
For poor model calibration, we incorporate the regularization method during
LoRA training to keep the model from being over-confident, and the Monte-Carlo
dropout mechanism is employed to enhance the uncertainty estimation.
Experimental results show that the proposed approach outperforms existing
baseline models on three complex reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.2210713029,
-1.3788496256,
0.5432949662,
-0.3326288462,
-0.0946651697,
0.1465875804,
-0.4467433095,
-0.4446258545,
-0.0483071245,
0.4483175576,
-0.5697717071,
-0.3782161474,
-0.315125227,
-0.2768838108,
0.0116550224,
0.4980554879,
-0.5660736561,
-0.2503480315,
0.2759756446,
-0.1165151298,
-0.352185607,
-0.1437592059,
-0.4328130484,
-0.2961466908,
0.6914947629,
0.6002608538,
0.7816678286,
0.7841011286,
0.3328208029,
0.2421057522,
-0.3732366562,
0.8217183948,
-0.2598149776,
0.233076036,
-0.1541617513,
-0.5730168223,
-0.4295888543,
-0.0085122455,
0.8020159006,
0.9755583405,
-0.1908047497,
0.1137809008,
-0.1772481948,
0.43774122,
-1.0247424841,
0.1577305198,
-0.8490220308,
0.0873486549,
-0.0921724364,
0.1789229214,
-0.0343750343,
-0.1671360582,
-0.0556518547,
-0.823261857,
-0.2237084806,
-0.0743611157,
1.0735446215,
0.9291089177,
-0.4631703794,
-0.0442087762,
-1.1543838978,
0.8982617855,
-0.7431452274,
0.302162081,
0.4694850147,
0.2500771284,
-0.0842443854,
-0.3179794252,
-0.6534424424,
0.0218350533,
0.3664395511,
-0.0578423589,
-0.0236193202,
0.1215148568,
0.2040441483,
0.2841024995,
-0.02341347,
0.3889761865,
-0.2125717402,
-0.2184580564,
0.4399117231,
0.0027929954,
-0.2175245285,
0.1539485753,
-0.1799201518,
0.0098367352,
-0.807236433,
-0.0043430408,
0.5948921442,
0.6815573573,
0.053037215,
0.5281891227,
-0.2523649037,
0.8648356199,
0.1704460829,
-0.1843728572,
0.2617788315,
-0.0662343353,
-0.1715064347,
-0.071449168,
0.6150709391,
-0.3298785985,
-0.0062346482,
0.1206859648,
-0.3077480197,
0.1548372358,
-0.064099811,
-0.3886607587,
-0.0158238746,
0.1834236234,
0.1424786896,
-0.2757822573,
-0.0047790459,
-0.5029969215,
-0.2160094976,
-0.3440518975,
0.7457351685,
-0.2615366876,
-0.097548157,
0.4069606364,
0.6677170992,
-0.028958071,
0.583878994,
-0.6326875091,
0.1936840713,
0.4257013202,
0.3762994409,
-0.1852782965,
-0.1676341146,
-0.9706132412,
0.3810946941,
-0.2271342874,
0.6801367998,
-0.5488284826,
0.1133327857,
-0.0225979555,
-0.2193898857,
-0.1413946748,
-0.553480804,
0.7463772893,
-0.4985218644,
0.0023970134,
-0.0150839668,
-0.3721987605,
-0.2964591086,
0.3042775393,
-0.758372128,
1.243083477,
0.1108029783,
-0.469843328,
0.2550398707,
-0.4575939476,
-0.2985818088,
-0.0848221704,
-0.2692375481,
-0.7544590831,
0.0182776805,
0.2244191617,
0.3659150302,
-0.1869985461,
0.3768504858,
-0.2525626123,
-0.4907710254,
0.3198260963,
-0.4630550444,
0.2873498797,
0.3226530552,
-0.4554830492,
0.1022238284,
-0.8504219055,
0.0886058286,
0.0905373767,
-0.6520690322,
-0.1940796822,
0.1878292114,
-0.3156323433,
-0.0564284474,
0.5115793347,
-0.3490153551,
0.4094443321,
-0.4949909151,
0.402864188,
0.5593410134,
0.0397828817,
0.4154068232,
-0.0149414735,
0.4325560331,
0.0256124474,
0.1527192742,
0.0105627719,
-0.1405896246,
-1.0707057714,
-0.1105404943,
0.6557123065,
0.688413322,
-0.5290612578,
0.6409766674,
0.1831583232,
-0.295375526,
-0.3258881271,
0.4489886761,
0.3252658248,
0.3410614133,
0.2758882046,
0.2106028497,
-0.25514552,
-0.6896046996,
-0.1363878101,
-0.2151365876,
0.2950107157,
0.3770811856,
0.3839254975,
-0.1904003918,
0.7202049494,
-0.5939718485,
-0.3752990663,
-0.1449562162,
0.1095528528,
0.3337974548,
0.5518830419,
0.2474600077,
-0.7612563372,
-0.4255734682,
-0.0444180705,
-0.2584350109,
-0.1617331356,
-0.0837303177,
-0.140069291,
0.1147715747,
0.4959734976,
-0.6501778364,
0.3678126037,
0.5969945192,
-0.2543508708,
0.2952612638,
-0.2012975216,
-0.2084138542,
-0.7444658875,
0.0439827517,
-0.1793923378,
-0.1883898675,
-0.3809535503,
-0.0169130862,
0.1983986348,
-0.096196264,
-0.381698519,
0.5300853252,
-0.6839936376,
0.3163664043,
-0.2891367972,
0.1506186575,
-0.0676845983,
0.5342006683,
0.0654483214,
0.4034966826,
0.6588591337,
-0.5535994768,
0.3517617583,
0.0778936893,
-0.6050787568,
-0.0408153199,
-0.421833545,
0.0038451324,
0.2482894659,
0.0289751887,
-0.7903862596,
-0.4464993775,
0.3093169332,
-0.1102997139,
0.4416809082,
-0.1298063397,
-0.541294992,
-0.1319513023,
0.0842887089,
0.3833156228,
0.4529412687,
-0.3273867369,
0.7463818789,
0.310442239,
0.1441461146,
-0.7378786206,
-0.6932250261,
-0.2464421093,
-0.2672283649,
-0.2822581232,
0.3086000085,
0.0879621282,
-0.29754287,
-0.0463527031,
-0.4528546929,
-0.1229952574,
0.3919816315,
0.1151304692,
0.0836777166,
-0.0942808911,
0.2140876502,
0.4084630907,
-0.1245735586,
-0.2456714362,
0.000604224,
0.4187426865,
-0.0474548899,
-0.8355686069,
-0.5783188939,
0.0831793398,
0.4773461521,
-0.417702049,
0.8639876842,
0.4641670585,
-0.615932703,
-0.5120022297,
-0.7526371479,
-0.1490566283,
-0.4858770967,
0.1849755198,
-0.3154132068,
-0.8025943637,
0.7124683857,
-0.359069258,
0.1342254281,
0.3353151977,
0.4324100614,
0.0113139069,
0.9803822041,
0.5339722037,
0.2588342726,
0.7730072141,
-0.3388374448,
0.3023237288,
-0.5309811234,
-0.1022110656,
-0.3996644914,
-0.4458072186,
-0.1680777818,
-0.6770280004,
0.2943225503,
0.4596984386,
-0.4557078481,
-0.1164843738,
-0.1944975704,
0.4632315636,
0.4710816741,
0.2350462377,
0.3984744251,
-0.0236080177,
-0.1526945233,
0.1295880228,
-0.793250978,
-0.4043653905,
0.7251678109,
0.3483887613,
1.1202309132,
0.1234178469,
0.4333343506,
-0.1225719601,
-0.2967647612,
-1.0052783489,
0.5144585371,
0.0222063884,
-0.5614954233,
-0.5073012114,
-0.597029686,
-0.9924941063,
-0.065723829,
-0.3489819467,
-0.5895236135,
0.2978405654,
0.4450449049,
-0.8335729837,
0.5004544258,
-0.5699849725,
0.6586680412,
-0.3632280529,
-0.6473392248,
-0.0844162628,
-0.6380468607,
0.1669330448,
-0.3980376124,
0.1615708023,
-0.361705035,
-0.3429350555,
0.623693347,
-0.4058426321,
1.103282094,
-0.241801545,
-0.3801194429,
0.5249010921,
0.2200541049,
1.0024961233,
0.1183826178,
-0.2496798784,
-0.2196649313,
-0.3306491375,
-0.3541404307,
-0.5584733486,
0.7166442871,
-0.8353540897,
-0.5228062868,
-0.4095753729,
-0.747526288,
-0.6530382633,
0.182856217,
-0.1236624718,
0.0861946419,
0.1286285818,
0.1469233185,
0.9732738733,
-0.2338940948,
0.1326085031,
0.7177215815,
0.0321349464,
-0.1738982201,
0.5700622201,
0.3064664602,
0.4090043008,
0.3837563097,
0.3147261143,
0.008109686,
-0.8015064597,
-0.2365068644,
0.4358099103,
-0.4528499842,
-0.3984964192,
-0.4032283425,
-0.2117425501,
-0.0991436318,
-0.1607611328,
-0.8482277989,
-0.553598702,
-0.422315985,
-0.020211,
0.4729507267,
0.39372015,
-0.0331152752,
0.4787684977,
-0.5399898887,
0.1881697476,
0.4353471994,
0.4039391279,
-0.1738847941,
-0.5940724611,
-0.3986516297,
0.2048537135,
-0.1923133731,
-0.6200968623,
0.1581486017,
0.4449595809,
0.7419769764,
0.6460787654,
0.3375688493,
0.6903829575,
-0.2006042004,
0.5822623372,
-0.0802296251,
-0.9217105508,
0.8352349401,
-0.5098011494,
0.3954652846,
0.6872000098,
0.1146816239,
0.0510040782,
-0.3144066334,
-0.5564704537,
-0.9618545771,
0.5724104643,
0.1419225037,
-0.0817808956,
0.2594465017,
0.6866288185,
0.027545277,
-0.0190227162,
-0.5113248229,
-0.175223276,
0.3071572781,
-0.1704021245,
0.059700828,
-0.1276270449,
-0.1798757017,
-0.3173502386,
0.8018581867,
-0.3372158706,
0.015542523,
-0.1844021082,
-0.0250041038,
-0.5628370047,
0.1623360962,
0.2652768493,
0.5951588154,
-0.2966862321,
0.1535004675,
0.4597653151,
-0.3766435385,
0.0239557754,
0.1800219715,
-0.2266388983,
-0.1348702759,
0.1887859106,
0.9943404198,
0.2443073243,
-1.0018918514,
0.2921240628,
0.1495956033,
-0.3378432691,
-0.3589645922,
0.4337521195,
0.0017995433,
0.4138765037,
0.3972023129,
0.1170486286,
-0.3437300622,
-0.5187616944,
-0.0681100711,
0.3454658389,
-0.4640861154,
-0.1986674368,
0.6835464239,
0.2045226097,
-0.061325755,
0.4200671017,
-0.0317489021,
-0.5176456571,
0.5157396197,
0.3289994001,
0.4260608852,
-0.3740881681,
-0.0596925467,
0.3331826627,
0.1546765566,
-0.3770215809,
0.6460760832,
0.0084038563,
-0.8171221614,
-0.7848732471,
-0.638307929,
-0.650729537,
0.3009803295,
-0.6301159859,
0.5333989859,
-0.4456115663,
-0.1253287643,
-0.1879324317,
0.4186759889,
-0.2782683671,
0.1706762165,
0.1491016895,
0.7056179047,
-0.9574252963,
1.035523653,
0.7671662569,
-0.1669502109,
-1.0614470243,
-0.0186582692,
-0.1863140762,
-0.6526059508,
0.3955774903,
-0.1021433473,
-0.2372138947,
-0.051829841,
-0.5744996071,
-1.110465765,
0.8839486837,
0.6459422112,
-0.7449980378,
-0.0264975838,
-0.1489969045,
0.318534404,
-0.0900329202,
-0.4214287996,
0.4432462454,
0.6396539211,
0.3752951622,
-0.9018214345,
-0.0731988698,
-0.098312743,
-0.4967495799,
0.6686557531,
-0.8820788264,
0.9128062129,
-0.2421267182,
-0.1591774523,
0.1203370243,
0.6798503995,
0.2886427343,
0.0786911622,
0.821123898,
0.4791508913,
0.9839739203,
-0.2205836028,
0.46003142,
-0.2615653276,
0.3917301595,
1.1790540218,
-0.4345120788,
0.900242269,
0.524954319,
-0.0521137789,
0.2432703078,
0.7754152417,
0.0223324448,
0.4088360965,
0.1839761734,
-0.360486567,
-0.7658320069,
-0.0759251267,
-0.1003268734,
0.6159200072,
0.7773320079,
-0.1485729665,
-0.0521809459,
-0.0022264128,
0.0680462793,
0.1125499159,
-0.2415388525,
0.5065293908,
-0.0510039106,
-0.7102739215,
0.7636522651,
-0.0129915942,
0.4796260893,
-0.7807272077,
0.1254629195,
-0.0858405754,
0.4205470085,
-0.1286525279,
-0.4943738282,
0.1504555196,
-0.0396521837,
0.1235985234,
-0.0656922758,
0.5100098252,
-0.5312374234,
-0.5312594175,
0.0714044198,
0.7722883821,
0.0590051673,
-0.0412770621,
-0.6691854596,
0.254270345,
0.0468518138,
-0.4985193908,
0.1439907253,
0.668112278,
-0.1578014195,
0.6903740764,
0.3898873925,
0.294565767,
-0.0515357032,
0.0383653641,
0.9863610268,
-0.4683306515,
-0.3189537525,
-0.5976732969,
0.2603642642,
0.2389535755,
-0.26694718,
0.5924873948,
0.5828229189,
0.4745002389,
0.3051462173,
0.6638710499,
0.0065418198,
0.6996174455,
-0.6789466739,
0.452179879,
-0.7939209342,
0.5698266625,
-0.1297656894,
-1.0436712503,
-0.5779960752,
0.8420996666,
-0.3279446065,
-0.0706211925,
0.6481660604,
0.6942955852,
-0.3992239535,
-0.4223327637,
0.2469613701,
0.2957444489,
0.011154741,
0.6793383956,
0.7376630306,
-0.3602460921,
0.67897439,
-0.3025696278,
-0.1958643198,
-0.218520835,
-0.8312698603,
-0.8968601227,
-0.4375117421,
-0.6671379805,
-0.251690805,
-0.0032523149,
0.7574882507,
0.6400915384,
-0.7817318439,
0.0267948844,
-0.0422136597,
0.0576328821,
-0.398814261,
-0.1087414995,
0.5608251691,
-0.1518866569,
-1.0247753859,
0.5057985187,
0.0124685168,
0.325547874,
-0.4452375174,
0.0649924874,
-0.4917140603,
0.2798973024,
0.1866445541,
0.4008898735,
-0.710136652,
-0.2394095212,
-0.1042025164,
0.1091260836,
0.001909732,
0.510379374,
-0.8527052402,
0.2229973972,
0.4053758681,
0.5506336093,
0.7443723679,
-0.0279012993,
0.5145193338,
-0.6127519608,
0.3531410098,
0.3419175744,
0.2585030794,
0.0843738541,
-0.3099348843,
0.5525390506,
0.0687935203,
-0.4930110574,
-1.1612204313,
0.4110563397,
-1.2044526339,
-0.4446799755,
1.2860043049,
-0.152273342,
-0.254018873,
-0.1444846094,
-0.2157894969,
0.4343728423,
-0.4670339525,
0.7731614113,
0.457332164,
-0.1123126447,
-0.1416492313,
-0.6143218279,
0.2646026015,
0.5493195057,
-0.6801764369,
0.1341758519,
0.4810118377,
0.0477700271,
0.0744199082,
-0.1975343078,
0.2474934608,
0.1047714502,
-0.094086349,
-0.1044681668,
-0.2750205994,
-0.3171558976,
-0.2219357193,
0.2143339068,
0.2125335485,
0.0155869927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01163v1
|
BootTOD: Bootstrap Task-oriented Dialogue Representations by Aligning Diverse Responses
| 2024-03-02T10:34:11 | 2024-03-02T10:34:11 |
Weihao Zeng, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Dayuan Fu, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models have been successful in many scenarios. However,
their usefulness in task-oriented dialogues is limited due to the intrinsic
linguistic differences between general text and task-oriented dialogues.
Current task-oriented dialogue pre-training methods rely on a contrastive
framework, which faces challenges such as selecting true positives and hard
negatives, as well as lacking diversity. In this paper, we propose a novel
dialogue pre-training model called BootTOD. It learns task-oriented dialogue
representations via a self-bootstrapping framework. Unlike contrastive
counterparts, BootTOD aligns context and context+response representations and
dismisses the requirements of contrastive pairs. BootTOD also uses multiple
appropriate response targets to model the intrinsic one-to-many diversity of
human conversations. Experimental results show that BootTOD outperforms strong
TOD baselines on diverse downstream dialogue tasks.
|
[
-0.5169199705,
-0.2922888398,
0.2296583056,
0.4466972649,
-0.4763343632,
0.4424727559,
-0.1235411167,
-0.3064057231,
0.3409680128,
0.3994854391,
-0.8698472381,
-0.52305305,
-0.5333724618,
0.0377163589,
-0.2514935136,
1.2328152657,
0.2080163658,
0.4086957574,
-0.0106424084,
-0.5506560802,
-0.6441813111,
-0.4863535464,
-0.4650784135,
-0.3018645942,
0.3118742704,
0.3338977396,
0.2681158483,
0.2960218489,
0.2025136203,
0.333032161,
0.3758793771,
-0.3773528636,
-0.4408750832,
0.6014840603,
-0.2197442353,
-0.3348531723,
0.0009591218,
-0.0057905177,
0.4542717338,
0.751429379,
-0.1968273222,
-0.0494810268,
0.3938990831,
0.2915050685,
-0.6013997197,
-0.0801881552,
-0.5706573129,
0.0195426047,
0.143548131,
0.0456036925,
-0.1486409009,
0.0551247559,
0.1767487377,
-0.4822941124,
0.2486864924,
-0.0341516063,
0.4540267289,
0.2438995093,
-0.3725881875,
-0.1074616387,
-0.6661352515,
0.7790592313,
-0.6474561691,
0.3146911263,
0.0938432291,
0.3162550032,
0.1132347435,
-0.3489273489,
-0.4959631562,
0.0923718214,
-0.1069568396,
0.1578488648,
0.2088705152,
0.0690704808,
-0.0868746266,
0.4896281064,
-0.417734772,
0.2325542569,
-0.0061399029,
-0.1587907076,
0.1548546255,
0.3631314039,
0.0519868284,
-0.035513781,
-0.7030344605,
-0.1400518268,
-0.4874957204,
0.0074024247,
0.2961511016,
0.6299107075,
-0.332565397,
0.0710585415,
-0.3221924901,
0.6799995303,
0.3647095561,
-0.1907245815,
0.2548553646,
-0.3930032849,
-0.3166514039,
-0.1176247522,
0.9943705201,
0.3431091011,
-0.1537984312,
-0.1640939564,
-0.3507710397,
-0.0752666667,
0.4041680098,
-0.9223685861,
-0.0596359074,
0.2114217728,
-0.4764845967,
-0.3101760149,
-0.3368789256,
-0.8376109004,
-0.3928923905,
-0.147018075,
0.4049158692,
-0.3006652296,
-0.3438265324,
-0.045685064,
0.1474222392,
0.2253488451,
0.5345094204,
-1.0447034836,
0.7825508714,
0.2784558535,
0.5830786824,
-0.487542361,
-0.1728002727,
-0.7205792665,
-0.0720200613,
-0.0740423948,
0.5195226669,
-0.8010770082,
-0.4186451137,
0.0633187741,
-0.1437099725,
0.0284033343,
-0.4512153268,
0.1718451828,
-0.3409458399,
0.5065827966,
-0.2262149751,
-0.2395721078,
-0.0073206439,
0.5530275106,
-0.4480923712,
0.7459577918,
0.4059937894,
-0.8641684055,
0.3460866809,
-0.620616436,
-0.5809675455,
0.0558261089,
-0.5893142223,
-0.3910685182,
-0.0868996158,
0.2174092233,
0.4387439489,
-0.5595384836,
0.4215055108,
-0.1561729908,
-0.1342190206,
-0.0835155174,
-0.2385912389,
0.7401055098,
0.3867485225,
-0.6843528152,
0.4080689251,
-0.5924603343,
-0.1353852302,
0.0838910863,
-0.0346530117,
-0.3985410035,
-0.2721541226,
0.2431088686,
0.4082297981,
0.0094600711,
-0.7973216176,
0.0906052664,
-0.334618628,
-0.0159240142,
0.748703599,
-0.2532401383,
0.4354527891,
-0.3521933258,
0.7886304855,
0.4478596151,
-0.2665379643,
-0.5048678517,
-0.3756431043,
-0.7270265818,
-0.358913064,
0.2982526124,
0.4893635511,
-0.6513900757,
0.4123907685,
0.0237869453,
-0.337110877,
-0.6811264753,
0.1823803931,
0.6996857524,
0.5511617661,
0.4008834064,
-0.677981317,
-0.4033067524,
-0.9264765382,
-0.2940655649,
-0.3040111363,
-0.1162711531,
0.1828704774,
0.2874194682,
-0.1009083167,
1.0251969099,
-0.233749643,
-0.2850033939,
-0.4498565495,
0.3930140138,
-0.1248902306,
0.8886252642,
0.5065208077,
-0.8013095856,
-0.5198037028,
-0.165222764,
-0.3933417201,
-0.1464501619,
-0.3946577609,
-0.0391633585,
-0.1757766306,
0.278219521,
-0.496073246,
0.2819259465,
0.4902859628,
-0.2158593833,
0.5164400339,
0.1651658714,
0.484336555,
-1.5783075094,
-0.0717152804,
0.0286279488,
-0.6213400364,
-0.6294000745,
-0.1631767005,
-0.1575653702,
-0.3240179121,
-0.3866083026,
0.5607731342,
-0.4000838399,
-0.185285911,
-0.1798999608,
-0.0739214048,
-0.187525928,
0.7060890794,
0.3331130445,
0.8197544813,
0.5743901134,
-0.6626150608,
0.2826962173,
0.4187299311,
-0.3378607631,
0.8403739333,
-0.5113261938,
0.0486583896,
-0.0303241313,
0.3278116584,
-1.3419543505,
-0.0207676068,
0.4213146567,
-0.1098594666,
0.5083496571,
-0.2904421091,
-0.1769826114,
-0.150107801,
-0.1446723938,
0.9552897215,
0.5126739144,
-0.6247559786,
0.6638431549,
0.292798847,
-0.5967575312,
-0.6086887717,
-0.2868195474,
-0.2225327343,
-0.2427283525,
-0.2959621251,
0.3836356401,
-0.2721734941,
0.0060233902,
-0.3934645355,
-0.3306877017,
-0.1796292812,
-0.045156911,
0.289098382,
0.0524041615,
-0.2877652347,
0.2831510305,
-0.1056097373,
-0.0541628525,
-0.0488975607,
-0.4937872887,
0.9513968825,
-0.1236157641,
-0.6146037579,
-0.3855646253,
0.6364728808,
0.5772383213,
-0.2595533729,
0.5621564388,
0.667945683,
-0.0905316696,
0.1480969936,
-0.8373236656,
-0.3532192409,
-0.4645718932,
0.4947037399,
-0.2949683964,
-1.0945549011,
0.6075281501,
-0.1982155591,
0.1521666497,
0.2023891062,
0.5624031425,
-0.2350316495,
0.7754361629,
0.6599608064,
-0.0515505411,
0.704241693,
0.1342801601,
0.0702227131,
-0.8380874395,
-0.234551385,
-0.5789640546,
-0.4492385089,
-0.4887675345,
-0.3552994728,
-0.0102988444,
-0.1722384989,
-0.4278573692,
0.3943137825,
-0.4017404914,
0.3869282901,
0.4120996594,
-0.0794722214,
0.1443305016,
-0.1122086272,
-0.1626759768,
-0.2061518878,
-0.6503605843,
-0.3586647213,
0.9612377286,
0.3023581505,
0.943361938,
-0.2372322232,
1.055252552,
0.0932946652,
0.4640084505,
-0.5254051089,
0.4940336347,
0.0447331779,
-0.6221336722,
-0.3168907464,
-0.3530781269,
-0.8703510165,
0.4424883425,
-0.1213534772,
-0.9883943796,
0.2071573436,
0.1149164438,
-0.4130006731,
0.2464080602,
-0.5996929407,
1.1380786896,
-0.1771674901,
-0.2604225576,
-0.2234917432,
-1.0405123234,
0.1771180183,
0.1037991047,
0.1217267364,
-0.0412748083,
0.2344224751,
0.9217813015,
-0.4275639951,
1.1752775908,
-0.2636578381,
-0.0398084894,
0.2096035182,
0.2508661151,
0.3274132311,
0.051714994,
0.1968909055,
-0.2164574564,
0.0037338077,
-0.6826526523,
-0.6322687268,
0.5262366533,
-0.621545136,
-1.0011487007,
-0.3774674535,
-0.5585811138,
-0.5421695709,
0.1592752039,
0.3789881766,
0.5804128051,
-0.6138282418,
0.0433391854,
0.4180304706,
-0.0420526937,
0.5312862396,
0.5888406038,
-0.2953367531,
-0.3274722099,
0.8318844438,
-0.4787837565,
0.7208527923,
0.3443031013,
-0.0894534364,
-0.1728605777,
-0.5011414289,
-0.4221110344,
0.017812131,
-0.6927684546,
-0.2401041687,
-0.6600233912,
0.0077477014,
-0.2194552422,
-0.1145401374,
-0.5964647532,
-0.3910159767,
-0.1732273698,
-0.042159263,
-0.1185461208,
0.7262257338,
0.1176045164,
0.4655921161,
-0.6073821783,
0.5960123539,
0.5820816755,
0.4327431619,
-0.2057819515,
-0.3617781699,
-0.1744142622,
0.1457319111,
-0.5051427484,
-0.8635174036,
0.3128428161,
0.0300599113,
0.4978653789,
0.4705976248,
0.4053370059,
0.4221240282,
-0.4509693384,
0.8388235569,
0.9168519378,
-0.7782632113,
0.4503766,
-0.3883959949,
0.6005771756,
0.8341251612,
0.5181819797,
-0.4663999975,
-0.6455456018,
-0.4833823442,
-0.4478821456,
0.7338672876,
0.2760210037,
0.3362068832,
-0.1864547282,
-0.2573370934,
0.6510176063,
0.5168802738,
-0.8833639026,
-0.244231239,
-0.639253974,
-0.3024223149,
0.0661278963,
0.0093772616,
-0.3759104013,
-0.1339534074,
0.4050419033,
-0.2304741889,
0.4175985456,
0.1034807637,
-0.2308897227,
0.1401531249,
0.6662041545,
0.4044531584,
0.3104090691,
-0.0350084528,
0.0259756465,
0.0897837728,
-0.3107598126,
0.5766147375,
0.0824004486,
0.3311362267,
-0.04828275,
0.0858367309,
0.8036950827,
0.2956289053,
-0.5171657205,
0.6869572997,
-0.1879471242,
0.0961544439,
0.1947350502,
-0.0160064176,
0.0213452596,
0.3724999428,
0.4956149757,
0.3772377968,
0.1891547292,
-0.7015918493,
0.1320130378,
0.5467153788,
-0.5741184354,
-0.2069461644,
0.4851548672,
0.8228060007,
-0.5710843801,
0.5738856792,
-0.3592057526,
-0.7245249748,
0.4803227186,
0.816082716,
1.1097742319,
-0.5417178273,
0.3647660613,
0.2484498471,
-0.0644671544,
0.2983473837,
0.0751484856,
-0.5788120627,
-0.8506258726,
-0.2926175892,
-0.5731895566,
-0.3758558035,
0.2540496886,
-0.8255760074,
0.0285256468,
-0.5343985558,
-0.1355312765,
-0.3697585762,
-0.398106724,
-0.8842763305,
0.5832961798,
-0.106520921,
0.460219264,
-0.7869654298,
0.7191462517,
0.5165121555,
-0.2929815054,
-0.4175257087,
0.3782697022,
-0.128370434,
-0.6920164227,
0.7400339246,
0.4394848645,
-0.3329367638,
-0.027123712,
-0.4534439743,
-0.42250669,
0.6817560196,
0.529096067,
-0.6599243879,
-0.0101260226,
-0.0129866404,
0.2543003857,
-1.0714037418,
0.3196141422,
0.2847090065,
-0.0050317147,
0.2375045866,
-0.9749664664,
0.2402288616,
-0.5341694355,
-0.0743342638,
0.1009302139,
-0.5055682063,
0.5895445347,
-0.2078357637,
-0.1891497672,
0.2212808728,
0.5561336875,
0.1151736081,
0.0491501763,
0.8253839612,
0.2935781777,
0.4202220738,
-0.1128378958,
0.8569770455,
-0.3839284778,
-0.0386160314,
1.3568247557,
-0.2621146739,
0.5960404277,
0.4862302244,
-0.1296995878,
0.7712851763,
0.547018826,
0.2880982757,
0.7816511989,
0.0315705128,
-0.5163977742,
-0.7511741519,
0.1043450534,
-0.449570775,
0.2860379219,
0.2976336479,
-0.1307100356,
-0.2480568886,
0.1459542811,
-0.4550590813,
0.1853764653,
0.0164002404,
0.9217329621,
-0.0386987738,
-0.7959135175,
0.6620418429,
-0.2361025363,
0.7832459807,
-0.6818832755,
-0.0870041102,
-0.1164972335,
-0.1051847488,
-0.0631940812,
-0.5883780718,
-0.0558779538,
-0.1887674481,
-0.1316605061,
-0.4176183343,
0.4426263273,
-0.7452872396,
-0.1709309518,
0.3500692248,
0.3755221963,
-0.1129536405,
0.0343675762,
-0.5893890262,
-0.0961947516,
0.0621957481,
-0.055533018,
0.7021124959,
0.2559404671,
0.1892191917,
0.7444726229,
0.2382606417,
-0.4211684763,
-0.2449665964,
0.1945949942,
1.1439015865,
-0.6578734517,
-0.956599474,
-0.5399146676,
0.858271718,
-0.1867278963,
-0.4309058785,
0.3770635724,
0.4800682366,
0.7030712366,
-0.3044146597,
0.8490092158,
0.112948969,
0.5237897038,
-0.4013801217,
0.3349736035,
-0.3874192536,
0.3206332326,
-0.5119214058,
-1.1500239372,
0.0769836381,
0.8963640928,
-0.1458062679,
0.3967781961,
0.8461078405,
0.5617649555,
-0.2953853309,
0.1840226203,
0.3471729755,
0.1772568822,
0.2141413838,
0.4181010425,
0.9574890137,
-0.2301182747,
0.6088243127,
0.0399413221,
-0.1133003607,
-0.2236692607,
-0.7364862561,
-1.1132041216,
-0.8729463816,
-0.4094894826,
-0.301626265,
0.1765850782,
1.113918066,
1.0225982666,
-1.0044994354,
-0.4689098299,
-0.1276360005,
0.02257457,
-0.1068611145,
-0.1595567763,
-0.2166283578,
-0.8205439448,
-0.5635871887,
0.435757488,
0.3932545185,
0.1950201541,
-0.2035071105,
-0.3660396934,
-0.1031771675,
-0.1157307848,
0.242813915,
0.3621776998,
-0.6687151194,
-0.2136773765,
-0.3103106022,
-0.1102609336,
0.4814183414,
1.1169401407,
-1.0715816021,
0.6124500036,
0.0892166644,
0.6937855482,
0.853782475,
0.1155652925,
1.2322292328,
-0.9072494507,
0.3704518378,
0.4435487688,
0.2305252552,
0.5702579618,
-0.007293208,
0.2018485367,
0.1890183687,
-0.2713987231,
-0.4897198677,
0.6797459722,
-0.9554551244,
-0.2354103625,
0.9414736032,
-0.3268553913,
0.2638247013,
-0.3436555564,
-0.4783179462,
0.0707997158,
-0.4952125549,
0.6217471957,
0.6027750969,
0.0944496244,
-0.2281951904,
0.0661242157,
0.5356689095,
0.7952988148,
-0.8492317796,
0.1346542984,
0.3548831344,
0.4264665544,
0.2340979874,
0.9524570107,
0.096041806,
0.3591082096,
-0.0053290022,
-0.0911677107,
0.2500499487,
-0.3689977229,
-0.1114171371,
0.2078179568,
-0.0171166398,
-0.3304238319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01152v1
|
A Survey of AI-generated Text Forensic Systems: Detection, Attribution, and Characterization
| 2024-03-02T09:39:13 | 2024-03-02T09:39:13 |
Tharindu Kumarage, Garima Agrawal, Paras Sheth, Raha Moraffah, Aman Chadha, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We have witnessed lately a rapid proliferation of advanced Large Language
Models (LLMs) capable of generating high-quality text. While these LLMs have
revolutionized text generation across various domains, they also pose
significant risks to the information ecosystem, such as the potential for
generating convincing propaganda, misinformation, and disinformation at scale.
This paper offers a review of AI-generated text forensic systems, an emerging
field addressing the challenges of LLM misuses. We present an overview of the
existing efforts in AI-generated text forensics by introducing a detailed
taxonomy, focusing on three primary pillars: detection, attribution, and
characterization. These pillars enable a practical understanding of
AI-generated text, from identifying AI-generated content (detection),
determining the specific AI model involved (attribution), and grouping the
underlying intents of the text (characterization). Furthermore, we explore
available resources for AI-generated text forensics research and discuss the
evolving challenges and future directions of forensic systems in an AI era.
|
[
-0.1852301061,
-0.9128269553,
0.7098600864,
-0.2062367499,
-0.0485826805,
0.1400378495,
0.1019530445,
-0.8154655695,
0.1745708883,
0.7748963237,
-0.4259398878,
-0.2680563331,
-0.7253965139,
0.3433261812,
-1.0481244326,
1.3239133358,
0.0190451685,
-0.2420890778,
-0.4302330911,
-0.0033353027,
-0.2502498329,
-0.780868113,
-0.6625643969,
-0.2623261809,
0.2757664621,
0.1921625137,
0.4072414637,
0.9684531093,
0.7676081061,
0.3130848408,
0.0906290263,
0.1895722449,
-0.1531585455,
0.3377606571,
0.0415598713,
-0.4326117635,
-0.2497290969,
0.1829425395,
0.5051030517,
0.0736152753,
0.0691233799,
0.2128557861,
-0.2035128325,
0.2760051191,
-0.7696332932,
-0.3889277875,
-0.8360844254,
-0.0743475109,
-0.5958634615,
-0.2481296659,
-0.5534667373,
-0.4008049965,
0.1370384991,
-0.4224732518,
0.2941289544,
0.1555788964,
0.5559005141,
0.3668719828,
-0.5226264,
-0.8375115395,
-0.9376049638,
0.6212660074,
-0.4134496152,
-0.1110705361,
0.3380826712,
0.3673979044,
0.1871284842,
-0.8637034297,
-0.6119453311,
-0.1330074817,
-0.0691020414,
-0.1238071471,
-0.325535655,
-0.0471459925,
-0.1663107276,
0.5820856094,
-0.2723093629,
0.2485237271,
-0.0523261912,
-0.627099812,
0.7701424956,
0.5105071664,
0.699998498,
-0.2284514755,
-0.2116598189,
0.0186773986,
-0.9796272516,
-0.3671497405,
0.6390010118,
-0.0387016684,
0.155904904,
0.5404835939,
0.1764207929,
0.3701874018,
-0.2303630263,
-0.4415971935,
-0.0580137558,
-0.7004312277,
-0.0699790418,
0.2794976234,
1.2072240114,
0.0201799665,
0.1603150517,
0.0917520374,
-0.3939784467,
-0.1054279283,
0.4114333093,
-0.5649471879,
-0.1661283225,
0.0791803822,
-0.8037034273,
-0.8323817849,
-0.1113639027,
-0.463190645,
-0.7891439199,
-0.0339631736,
0.2633748353,
-0.564244628,
-0.1699111611,
-0.0752137154,
-0.2914319634,
0.1236951575,
0.3514019847,
-0.6843439937,
0.2269025445,
0.4906926751,
0.6824789047,
-0.2852729559,
-0.1225899085,
-0.2571382225,
0.3769876659,
-0.1771215349,
0.9222146869,
-0.2330931723,
-0.2554161549,
0.082514666,
-0.3077762127,
0.5569849014,
-0.6641571522,
0.4675267339,
-0.5366181731,
0.178692922,
0.108945109,
-0.3675673604,
-0.1141814888,
0.5486895442,
-0.711831212,
0.8581059575,
-0.2438582778,
-0.8063804507,
0.4238885343,
-0.6361887455,
-0.6913978457,
0.425744772,
-0.2635586262,
-0.4096748233,
-0.0667838976,
0.1457946748,
0.5278956294,
-0.5364981294,
0.4626736641,
0.1638507843,
-0.0897760615,
0.3319830894,
-0.8086012602,
0.8764445186,
0.3995660543,
-0.1656816453,
0.0706239864,
-0.9782029986,
-0.4263728261,
0.2929858565,
-0.426204294,
-0.2951674163,
0.3714340627,
0.1776650101,
-0.4194454253,
0.4633220136,
-0.6018149257,
-0.0735270381,
-0.3038054705,
0.4877570271,
0.561142683,
0.2155204564,
0.2510198653,
-0.1700505763,
0.4039404392,
0.0808933377,
-0.0600627214,
-0.5784142613,
-0.3204399943,
-0.5143701434,
-0.3503636718,
0.0828083977,
0.8794189692,
-0.6927519441,
0.514703691,
-0.1497161835,
-0.5885705948,
-0.2899667621,
-0.2768732607,
0.4033299387,
0.288677305,
0.2282767445,
0.0572701134,
-0.4169644713,
-1.0922772884,
-0.4820577502,
-0.5347816348,
-0.3462601304,
0.2364590615,
0.7083041072,
-0.2851210535,
0.8847928643,
-0.2973734438,
-0.3127931356,
-0.1414500773,
0.4696356654,
-0.1838137507,
0.3702777326,
0.6573559046,
-0.5927893519,
-0.2470633239,
-0.0637621582,
-0.8810932636,
-0.1152234003,
-0.1573177129,
0.536642015,
0.1135861501,
0.7558897138,
-0.4082880616,
0.3700515926,
0.0662924945,
-0.2452454418,
0.7801154256,
0.0434347279,
0.3350785971,
-0.9525117278,
0.2225371599,
-0.2135980129,
-0.4543942213,
-0.7168724537,
0.400141865,
-0.1490994841,
-0.0926645994,
-0.4106684923,
0.2844287753,
-0.4332201481,
-0.0417218693,
-0.3939519525,
0.0246613026,
-0.1525514871,
-0.1782681495,
-0.1907581985,
0.7662097812,
0.2857842147,
-0.424174726,
0.5902975202,
0.2613800466,
-0.4948158264,
0.4798905253,
-0.4303120673,
0.0843001828,
-0.0814524963,
0.1920596957,
-0.745046854,
-0.3811490238,
0.4453592896,
-0.7615985274,
0.2011814564,
0.0261420868,
-0.8596259952,
-0.0163656846,
-0.3618860543,
0.7832918763,
0.2609893382,
-0.1822777987,
0.699374795,
0.5004053712,
-0.3335939944,
-0.7132173777,
-0.7326273322,
0.5830574632,
-0.4052560925,
-0.5301545858,
0.4207021892,
0.3271772265,
-0.7377002835,
-0.0853677988,
0.5649086237,
0.0860297754,
0.4474996626,
0.1532442123,
0.1195204407,
-0.1665032059,
0.106563732,
0.0046433271,
0.0017576262,
0.3460606933,
0.0737600774,
0.4387994707,
0.1910518855,
-0.3970655501,
-0.4768390357,
0.5466935635,
0.6289207339,
-0.2450253665,
0.5688610673,
0.4895823896,
-0.5010221601,
0.0879835412,
-0.471878171,
-0.227537483,
-0.4117339253,
0.3780525625,
-0.1066992059,
-0.8031080961,
0.6678718328,
0.1107453629,
0.1888468266,
0.8293188214,
0.7606006861,
0.0211692434,
0.9556478262,
0.6640803218,
-0.3858095706,
0.3209408522,
0.2417388558,
0.4285767078,
-0.4118466079,
-0.2444171906,
-0.8023715615,
0.0382633135,
-0.5011730194,
0.1413438767,
0.5348414183,
-0.2450226545,
-0.4485715628,
-0.0700295493,
-0.4843500853,
0.5248606205,
0.6355922818,
-0.2056315541,
0.5270472169,
0.0744729638,
0.4661253691,
0.3721256852,
-0.1219028533,
-0.9245862365,
1.2930155993,
0.5605806708,
0.3999721408,
0.116256766,
0.7211256027,
0.7976295948,
0.294567734,
-0.9127952456,
0.4561775625,
-0.2205025554,
-0.93839252,
-0.3060640693,
-0.0847745687,
-0.6823064685,
-0.3039219379,
-0.3947854638,
-0.8200340867,
-0.3064080477,
-0.0705830231,
-0.3055747151,
0.3709101677,
0.0158011727,
0.1291948855,
-0.1414911002,
-0.0138704143,
-0.3372761309,
-0.6711524129,
0.4839269817,
-0.1939455718,
0.2428659201,
0.0522734411,
-0.0513408147,
0.9877278805,
-0.3995219469,
0.6462081075,
-0.0133606633,
-0.5643270612,
0.8365558386,
0.4959833026,
0.5200667977,
0.1393469423,
0.0905098096,
0.0857371464,
-0.0377670079,
0.1965583712,
-0.1227225736,
0.2830624282,
-0.5713126063,
-0.5036627054,
-0.2659109235,
-0.6672028899,
0.1278835386,
0.5635986328,
0.6744504571,
0.487534374,
-0.4718706906,
-0.0773150772,
0.8203550577,
-0.4322413802,
0.5381382108,
0.1601179093,
0.0162795912,
-0.3933426738,
1.3258625269,
-0.4936608374,
-0.0541730151,
0.2757184505,
-0.0552791394,
-0.0569359958,
-1.1517261267,
-0.6015934348,
-0.0562129021,
-0.7691330314,
-0.561862886,
-0.6773101687,
-0.29737553,
-0.4834382534,
-0.1547105759,
-0.3310740888,
-0.2180941403,
-0.8123284578,
0.0402223021,
0.3831329346,
1.0144459009,
0.1631064117,
0.4862598479,
-0.9936147928,
0.3410811424,
-0.0895191506,
0.0027504584,
-0.1180726886,
-0.3120416403,
-0.0881019235,
-0.0520299263,
-0.3613837957,
-0.7175468802,
0.3743064702,
0.0099294754,
0.2137733698,
0.5979552865,
-0.0772939399,
-0.1974115223,
-0.5681539178,
1.2808728218,
0.0606642812,
-0.7450120449,
0.5196976066,
-0.6314619184,
-0.3084192872,
0.4063754082,
0.294621706,
-0.3082213104,
-0.5677529573,
-0.3470305204,
-0.7564867139,
0.5235220194,
0.1938045025,
0.3494854271,
0.1031904519,
0.4438652694,
0.2813886106,
0.2133919746,
-0.8397051096,
-0.3850476742,
-0.0899380147,
-0.5265706182,
0.1639313102,
-0.209807843,
-0.3171866238,
0.2991845608,
0.491609633,
-0.1096661836,
0.445861876,
-0.0614412539,
-0.1580206603,
0.1730509847,
-0.0053378646,
0.5264278054,
0.115161024,
0.0623712204,
0.0342708267,
-0.2576101422,
-0.6871036887,
0.4181528687,
-0.1890522242,
-0.3702029288,
-0.2814213634,
0.8885861635,
0.3873355389,
-0.7421516776,
-0.75933218,
0.6694211364,
0.0238223374,
-0.4442388415,
-0.6549642682,
0.0508874618,
-0.3614505827,
0.0898880213,
0.7470184565,
0.0347799659,
0.5930617452,
-0.6675595641,
0.0241541285,
0.6294692755,
-0.0810734108,
-0.2033876628,
0.4980258048,
0.2562956512,
-0.427133292,
0.7969262004,
0.1089130566,
-0.4979614913,
0.5858964324,
0.4608254135,
0.9717988372,
0.0807950124,
0.0571799278,
-0.0527964607,
0.4800646901,
0.1280045807,
-0.1010040119,
-0.0121822758,
-1.0373492241,
0.0358462185,
-0.5198193192,
-0.1053528786,
0.3936961591,
-0.3788814545,
0.2297059745,
-0.5306313038,
-0.0822835192,
0.1215986088,
-0.3899188936,
-0.1833997518,
0.2262219489,
0.2809954882,
0.6902006865,
-0.8023067713,
0.3040100634,
0.479506433,
-0.256337285,
-0.2941066027,
0.0769858509,
0.4546533525,
-0.8482862115,
0.4726013243,
0.0285263266,
-0.3152464628,
0.1504084766,
-1.0234806538,
-0.7272586226,
0.9471001625,
0.2140441835,
0.1261433214,
-0.2199805677,
0.4378671348,
0.503601253,
-0.3879936934,
0.0464204997,
0.8159153461,
0.3337342739,
-0.3217056096,
-0.586591661,
0.0791847333,
-0.3050387204,
-0.312320888,
0.2551732063,
-0.2580702305,
0.8315961361,
0.0832312405,
-0.4584732056,
0.3054810762,
0.5843620896,
0.1524379849,
0.2499771565,
0.1700027585,
0.428948611,
0.4718919098,
0.0265558343,
0.9380871058,
-0.0627087057,
-0.1274414062,
0.6132916212,
-0.111463517,
0.429825753,
0.4047807455,
-0.1528116018,
0.5613287091,
0.6128619909,
-0.2984268367,
0.2444373965,
0.2076899856,
-0.2923616767,
-0.0410463102,
-0.3104713559,
-0.0235402118,
0.7910219431,
0.6927392483,
-0.7296775579,
-0.0521560311,
0.1998614222,
-0.1594315171,
0.0910140276,
-0.3415587842,
1.199393034,
-0.4198409617,
-0.5179123878,
0.1410787553,
0.3481328487,
0.8119276166,
-0.17843768,
0.0135373119,
0.077153191,
0.0011372879,
-0.1069396138,
-0.933790803,
0.3465513885,
0.0991260856,
-0.4442510009,
-0.3019998372,
1.1613453627,
-0.0382980183,
-0.2743561566,
-0.1557008475,
0.4026229978,
0.2677990496,
-0.2472358495,
-0.1947476864,
0.0124281636,
-0.0499721691,
-0.1661471874,
0.2171710134,
0.4090571404,
-0.0847137272,
0.8293684125,
0.3657851517,
-0.0359546766,
-0.0114982734,
-0.3191978037,
0.5719521642,
-0.5254533887,
-0.3028794527,
-1.0189105272,
0.252707243,
0.0814594328,
-0.0939837024,
0.3827734888,
0.3434235156,
0.6387562156,
0.0488128364,
1.195651412,
-0.2980898917,
0.5994023681,
-0.5642068386,
1.1918412447,
-0.6309390068,
0.2011020631,
-0.2541339099,
-0.6233530045,
-0.25298509,
0.0346533172,
0.1835405827,
-0.2177407593,
0.48112005,
0.4035781026,
0.0896650106,
0.1386055648,
-0.0866114199,
-0.2442178577,
0.5826613903,
0.3499253392,
0.9737819433,
-0.4770156443,
0.5597502589,
0.3771651089,
-0.0675498173,
-0.2245908231,
-0.8861513734,
-0.6746405959,
-0.8377059698,
-0.0891248956,
0.0031021498,
-0.2879197001,
0.281245321,
0.2069030851,
-0.6340093613,
-0.0694912896,
-0.2197458297,
-0.0532330349,
0.3602358401,
-0.1850139499,
0.2017783076,
-0.0688774884,
-0.6211871505,
0.1961152256,
0.1904813498,
0.3875204027,
-0.4558865726,
0.351177305,
-0.1870609075,
0.2052624226,
0.6724374294,
-0.0121126175,
-0.7404824495,
-0.4233312309,
-0.1906690449,
-0.2895704508,
-0.119504042,
1.1595499516,
-0.5771414042,
-0.002875048,
0.5592689514,
0.9486250877,
0.0185316354,
-0.0925284699,
0.7852796316,
-0.669334352,
-0.1029423997,
0.5112695694,
0.1350896508,
0.2210660577,
-0.7320814729,
0.2440330237,
0.2961441278,
-0.5587254763,
-1.012150526,
0.5130144954,
-0.3168579042,
-0.5022889376,
0.7680709362,
-0.0049521755,
0.0673530549,
-0.3173310757,
-0.0228610896,
0.3874237239,
-0.0858882219,
0.6343318224,
0.7890397906,
-0.0968983099,
0.0687463805,
-0.1065340713,
0.6928780675,
0.0690337941,
-0.8992441893,
0.4271412492,
0.9028735161,
0.0865594298,
0.5922131538,
0.60121876,
-0.3808840513,
0.0505994,
0.0253308062,
0.091204755,
-0.0427659675,
-0.5858048797,
-0.0858764723,
0.2961637378,
-0.0175239798,
0.0354186743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04780v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04780v2
|
MuseGraph: Graph-oriented Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models for Generic Graph Mining
| 2024-03-02T09:27:32 | 2024-03-13T15:52:33 |
Yanchao Tan, Hang Lv, Xinyi Huang, Jiawei Zhang, Shiping Wang, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Graphs with abundant attributes are essential in modeling interconnected
entities and improving predictions in various real-world applications.
Traditional Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), which are commonly used for modeling
attributed graphs, need to be re-trained every time when applied to different
graph tasks and datasets. Although the emergence of Large Language Models
(LLMs) has introduced a new paradigm in natural language processing, the
generative potential of LLMs in graph mining remains largely under-explored. To
this end, we propose a novel framework MuseGraph, which seamlessly integrates
the strengths of GNNs and LLMs and facilitates a more effective and generic
approach for graph mining across different tasks and datasets. Specifically, we
first introduce a compact graph description via the proposed adaptive input
generation to encapsulate key information from the graph under the constraints
of language token limitations. Then, we propose a diverse instruction
generation mechanism, which distills the reasoning capabilities from LLMs
(e.g., GPT-4) to create task-specific Chain-of-Thought-based instruction
packages for different graph tasks. Finally, we propose a graph-aware
instruction tuning with a dynamic instruction package allocation strategy
across tasks and datasets, ensuring the effectiveness and generalization of the
training process. Our experimental results demonstrate significant improvements
in different graph tasks, showcasing the potential of our MuseGraph in
enhancing the accuracy of graph-oriented downstream tasks while keeping the
generation powers of LLMs.
|
[
0.0096518211,
-0.6742883325,
0.5314859748,
-0.0957941487,
-0.1661746949,
0.4841925204,
-0.2100843191,
-0.2240961492,
0.1738323867,
0.4630275071,
-0.8116869926,
-1.0156935453,
-0.5999282002,
-0.122699894,
-0.1704958677,
0.7721791863,
-0.0522986501,
-0.0121489931,
-0.3599330485,
-0.12620309,
-0.5509418845,
-0.212171331,
-0.7471392155,
-0.3814108372,
0.5945871472,
0.2956992686,
0.4283798039,
0.7813608646,
0.1432348341,
0.3615542948,
0.2012637556,
0.7195693254,
-0.6810898185,
0.0223835558,
-0.270193696,
-0.5900530815,
-0.6686236858,
-0.1075045764,
0.6843136549,
0.7158449888,
0.1298496127,
0.278083384,
0.2456495911,
0.2314359695,
-0.333611697,
0.7268633246,
-0.7697533965,
-0.0363066383,
-0.3765954971,
-0.2219606936,
-0.6095741987,
-0.1693028808,
-0.1945566982,
-0.6817192435,
0.4512225986,
0.253334403,
0.7575076222,
0.1748909056,
-0.2441257536,
-0.2032732219,
-0.2316286117,
0.4395686984,
-0.4868133068,
0.1624708176,
0.174373582,
0.2847701907,
-0.3354410827,
-1.0984386206,
-0.2910636067,
0.0755177885,
-0.1226943731,
0.0355665646,
-0.2963089347,
0.1963644624,
0.1100443006,
0.3041130006,
-0.4889017642,
0.5308096409,
0.0388548076,
-0.3341138959,
0.1852020621,
0.3883253932,
0.3900739253,
-0.1444288939,
-0.0254982356,
0.1000721455,
-0.8454053998,
-0.1529161781,
0.5690968633,
0.6387143135,
0.1854017824,
0.463847816,
-0.2584063411,
1.0000783205,
0.0456651524,
0.0138655389,
0.3295635879,
0.056012921,
-0.1587309092,
-0.1097715348,
0.676476419,
0.1887208074,
0.1586204618,
-0.5279189348,
-0.0321398824,
0.0995789394,
0.2514439225,
-0.8443303108,
-0.4799953401,
-0.2410074323,
-0.1064014509,
-0.3742105961,
-0.2385923415,
-0.636084497,
-0.3996526599,
-0.2262191474,
0.1585458964,
-0.4791702926,
0.0785776377,
-0.0120475478,
-0.0465024039,
-0.0699346587,
0.177448824,
-0.9293141365,
0.2367419749,
0.7694861889,
0.843174696,
-0.2329249233,
-0.3649294972,
-0.7660377026,
0.3844871819,
-0.1066924781,
0.8101227283,
-0.8635393381,
-0.2771423459,
-0.0855922699,
0.135298714,
-0.5795241594,
-0.3973675966,
0.4355424047,
-0.6141324043,
0.0075721256,
-0.1168386564,
-0.5996705294,
-0.2615219355,
0.4139822721,
-0.5689051747,
1.0317275524,
0.5046964884,
-0.7452254891,
0.3240644634,
-0.75485605,
-0.7447916865,
0.2209537625,
-0.0243244134,
-0.4781309068,
-0.1763923317,
0.497706145,
0.4413782954,
-0.4267513752,
0.0714999437,
-0.3985007107,
-0.3338593841,
0.0083069829,
-0.3736921549,
0.7132939696,
-0.0391180143,
-0.4274805486,
0.384219408,
-0.6271637678,
0.2886429429,
0.1313655823,
-0.3453540504,
0.1101982594,
0.1077188551,
-0.37195158,
0.0097827315,
0.1618914455,
-0.4754013717,
0.3503928483,
-0.2095283121,
0.9094370008,
0.9736504555,
-0.0616016984,
0.1821876913,
-0.0362230577,
0.4486670494,
-0.2940075397,
-0.0175624527,
-0.1322909743,
-0.4383440912,
-0.900398016,
-0.4746441543,
0.3448536098,
0.626857698,
-0.6568834782,
0.3853963315,
-0.6208514571,
-0.2644156218,
-0.3437520862,
0.2718317509,
0.2686366141,
0.7523179054,
0.2558263242,
-0.25158903,
-0.4349583685,
-0.5797967911,
-0.041545134,
-0.0142643973,
0.0734739155,
0.8166686296,
-0.030543318,
-0.325342983,
0.8561560512,
-0.9179930687,
-0.2684331536,
-0.4636552036,
0.0627357736,
0.2458939254,
0.2857020795,
0.5062867403,
-0.3087497056,
-0.4004938006,
-0.0526796356,
-0.5830147862,
-0.272906214,
0.0915266722,
-0.4285804331,
-0.0828954801,
0.5494586825,
-0.7448801398,
0.1398515403,
0.4301878512,
0.0406791717,
0.341701448,
-0.1554190069,
-0.1239332631,
-0.9516023993,
-0.1946654618,
-0.2194601446,
-0.5751276016,
-0.1684053391,
0.2063329518,
-0.1537703425,
-0.5254181027,
-0.0131581174,
0.2674686909,
-0.5346836448,
-0.016674798,
-0.3502461016,
0.2856103182,
0.1937237382,
0.622207582,
-0.3027601242,
0.6502126455,
0.898900032,
-0.4396496117,
0.7282720804,
0.1251463443,
-0.2749979198,
0.5791870952,
-0.3141000569,
0.4672168493,
-0.0787720382,
0.4214686453,
-0.997856617,
-0.3299547434,
0.387460947,
-0.2965081036,
0.6945884228,
-0.4281581342,
-0.534019053,
-0.7370538712,
0.1144339889,
-0.0493324623,
0.2934122682,
-0.7052252889,
0.8464295268,
0.3495716453,
-0.0727633908,
-0.4137038589,
-0.4419626296,
0.2219278514,
-0.1174601018,
-0.7391284704,
0.4186966121,
0.1753535569,
0.4227883518,
0.4158446789,
-0.13128452,
0.117598094,
0.0972020254,
0.2283170223,
0.2547948062,
-0.2132142633,
0.2185756415,
0.0443704128,
-0.3110642731,
-0.1482105553,
-0.9715297222,
0.9214328527,
-0.0109224124,
-0.4818473756,
-0.1910929531,
0.0123002995,
0.3125381172,
-0.4513442218,
0.5075747371,
0.7735180855,
-0.1843342036,
-0.5004170537,
-0.0525365323,
0.1149877608,
-0.5086624622,
0.6469094157,
-0.3604876697,
-0.9135474563,
0.4398593605,
-0.614290297,
-0.0233747959,
0.314894259,
0.5454902649,
-0.0320739038,
1.0063482523,
0.4032407403,
-0.3805595338,
0.4461730421,
-0.5795738697,
0.3162896037,
-1.0282611847,
-0.1563756764,
-0.2897033393,
-0.6297239661,
-0.4104962051,
-0.539721787,
0.125363782,
-0.1513919681,
-0.3362220526,
0.2808092833,
-0.5674020052,
0.550888598,
0.624221921,
0.3056727946,
-0.1405178308,
0.0184591468,
-0.1982508898,
0.2937450111,
-0.9151834249,
-0.2919899225,
1.1369615793,
-0.1513404548,
0.7069199085,
-0.1347197741,
0.5464792848,
0.2386016399,
0.4341264963,
-0.6491186023,
0.7587982416,
-0.4376401007,
-0.1919582784,
-0.3228914142,
-0.6172442436,
-1.0258876085,
-0.0480607003,
-0.0520856567,
-0.9451463223,
-0.3173267543,
0.4325439036,
0.0496131293,
0.5578299165,
-0.7534147501,
1.0400102139,
-0.246334061,
-0.2531045973,
-0.1310717613,
-0.2605679631,
0.076968126,
0.2822199166,
-0.0688062981,
-0.2111643404,
0.1924586892,
0.2952176034,
-0.4153839946,
1.1482597589,
-0.3074765503,
0.2383969277,
0.4442291856,
0.0352134258,
0.9757041335,
-0.0441459641,
-0.0646998659,
0.0724413469,
-0.78188622,
-0.3387691081,
-0.7347710729,
1.0058745146,
-0.6797779799,
-0.9355524182,
0.1101249233,
-0.9922975302,
-0.3801309168,
0.4722816944,
0.3782685995,
0.653773725,
-0.1191818565,
-0.0018618236,
0.4416554868,
-0.0183309391,
0.0655367449,
0.0513539016,
0.0348633714,
-0.322840333,
1.2880060673,
0.1423612088,
0.2498808354,
0.5359100103,
0.0646625608,
-0.1557167619,
-0.7491673231,
-0.6917575598,
0.0440437607,
-0.7565498948,
-0.2899790704,
-0.7057538033,
-0.078455627,
-0.539732635,
-0.105204314,
-0.0308010168,
-0.3581167459,
-0.5439943075,
-0.286103785,
0.532720983,
0.2908407152,
0.2919895351,
0.3267499506,
-0.4365091026,
0.0550221279,
0.5663185716,
0.5477003455,
0.0672480687,
-0.1892447025,
-0.2034823149,
-0.0285143238,
-0.4191157222,
-0.6145601869,
0.0928786993,
0.3873947263,
0.7305838466,
0.2772822976,
-0.0849057063,
0.7010034323,
-0.7294959426,
0.4353550375,
-0.0905426294,
-0.8825141191,
0.2402127236,
-0.4514531195,
0.1000346467,
0.1038559601,
0.0817673653,
-0.4311196506,
-0.4013534784,
-0.549682498,
-1.025016427,
0.7799403071,
-0.1187908873,
0.2897856236,
-0.0483610295,
0.3079570234,
-0.147044152,
0.1717865318,
-0.5880900621,
-0.0628443658,
-0.5792630911,
-0.5929514766,
0.0363758765,
0.152336657,
-0.320802182,
-0.1203985512,
0.6115717888,
-0.5058512092,
0.3246791363,
-0.4179317355,
-0.3291379213,
0.1242360547,
0.0038984178,
0.0467110798,
0.5963649154,
-0.0163736418,
0.3111589253,
0.2806586027,
-0.4245054722,
-0.0397634581,
0.3553977907,
-0.3219801188,
-0.2680899501,
0.3358257413,
1.2407339811,
0.3354410529,
-0.4797103107,
0.2079542875,
0.3735856414,
0.1374175251,
0.0996298939,
0.545658052,
0.5369926095,
0.0982193202,
0.0346354656,
0.0723886341,
-0.0614331365,
-0.4298808277,
0.1079940945,
0.5479717851,
-0.4126725495,
-0.2545197904,
0.7104050517,
0.2316899896,
-0.4963717163,
0.9966045022,
-0.4593994617,
-0.5665020943,
0.4862856567,
1.0079797506,
0.8318089843,
0.0769595951,
0.3884843886,
0.187890619,
0.23796314,
0.5339167118,
-0.169391647,
0.1123770103,
-0.8049631119,
-0.4142214954,
-0.3952307403,
-0.2278528064,
-0.0165175386,
-0.3446674347,
0.0979343131,
-0.4833310544,
-0.1354731768,
0.0582091063,
-0.1150104329,
-0.6092861295,
0.0467770249,
-0.0856159255,
0.6440784335,
-0.5893116593,
0.6904768944,
0.6065163016,
-0.0744893402,
-0.8523158431,
-0.2055597156,
0.0546603017,
-1.0975099802,
0.459480077,
0.2713724375,
-0.1139955297,
0.3937419653,
-0.3912851512,
-0.8544127345,
1.2623124123,
0.6531068087,
-0.2910973728,
-0.0392443053,
0.2076235861,
0.3139264882,
-0.6248493195,
-0.2713418007,
0.5085884333,
0.237961784,
0.2946362793,
-0.3001686335,
0.1260145903,
-0.2912045717,
-0.0734196752,
0.4473764598,
-0.6841496825,
0.8913419247,
-0.1895218939,
-0.311699599,
-0.1151471362,
0.5522510409,
0.1769539416,
0.118036449,
0.5325508714,
0.7714198232,
1.229452014,
-0.3121694922,
1.1676604748,
-0.4501463771,
0.1891563982,
1.149135232,
-0.3223369122,
0.1319554448,
-0.2874786854,
-0.02257476,
0.7651226521,
0.6974726319,
-0.1431288272,
0.2878083289,
0.3943566084,
-0.2469236553,
-0.467536509,
0.0035432754,
-0.0099744247,
0.3517175019,
0.4538380504,
-0.3960507512,
-0.385401696,
-0.0646373779,
0.1647014618,
-0.0909487382,
-0.5319365263,
0.3937016428,
-0.2286263108,
-0.4258866012,
0.3539755642,
0.0557361543,
0.2293424606,
-0.6455042362,
0.019781027,
0.0893727988,
0.2006807029,
-0.1345725358,
-0.5915495157,
-0.1130836383,
0.0718983263,
-0.3474864364,
-0.0675053895,
0.8158872724,
-0.1731937528,
-0.6488993168,
0.0651801825,
0.1070712134,
-0.1089165062,
0.212241441,
-0.6110076904,
-0.1796325892,
0.0504886061,
-0.0343226045,
0.3961821198,
0.5988423824,
-0.2248116583,
0.754455626,
0.8430606127,
0.1575221419,
0.2164209783,
0.3293353319,
1.2501862049,
-0.2671456039,
-0.5315185785,
-0.5973265767,
0.2896051705,
-0.3155139089,
-0.1928206384,
0.8351025581,
0.6889326572,
0.5833791494,
0.1590712517,
0.794577837,
-0.0353712924,
0.2751395702,
-0.6240988374,
0.4056480825,
-0.0537675954,
0.1140167713,
-0.3047126532,
-0.9685729742,
-0.3030927479,
0.4504889548,
-0.4185443223,
0.0341221839,
0.4687963128,
0.8768956065,
-0.2194086462,
-0.1023194566,
-0.2138525546,
0.2351326644,
0.4918711782,
0.5906133652,
0.4138438404,
0.118599169,
0.7113133073,
0.2416286469,
-0.2348910421,
-0.0247805715,
-0.8323790431,
-0.8605625629,
-0.238369897,
-0.2488251179,
-0.2736645341,
-0.0434498973,
0.5578266382,
0.6710296273,
-0.4834107459,
0.0769282728,
-0.3734702468,
0.3191333711,
-0.3949750662,
-0.2150642723,
0.7689045072,
-0.6005917192,
-0.8600048423,
0.477884382,
0.5464085937,
-0.1342767626,
-0.1099855602,
0.0787309408,
0.0362268724,
0.0024703522,
0.489651382,
0.2428844571,
-0.2419699281,
-0.6194999814,
0.1454146057,
0.1103790775,
0.1157392487,
0.9774661064,
-0.6157001257,
0.5436844826,
0.326895684,
0.6261624694,
0.8176336288,
-0.1483784169,
0.3926479518,
-0.990790844,
0.251752764,
0.0835523605,
0.5366665125,
0.4672611654,
-0.4452147484,
0.3753410578,
0.4813325405,
-0.3507497907,
-0.810743928,
0.6158140302,
-0.8285192847,
-0.2106701285,
0.7903756499,
-0.4803869724,
-0.294600904,
-0.0259616282,
-0.1519960612,
0.404073745,
-0.0455040112,
0.6654162407,
0.5151671171,
-0.3169126511,
0.0477348119,
-0.0611193106,
0.1043398902,
-0.221219644,
-0.8180937171,
0.2527770102,
0.6275291443,
0.3712165654,
0.0109999441,
0.4946632981,
0.0955803543,
0.0061395159,
0.155423522,
-0.0677864552,
-0.6353737712,
-0.2122838646,
0.4262276292,
0.3342567682,
-0.0381215997,
-0.3384874761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01139v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01139v4
|
ParallelPARC: A Scalable Pipeline for Generating Natural-Language Analogies
| 2024-03-02T08:53:40 | 2024-05-14T16:41:24 |
Oren Sultan, Yonatan Bitton, Ron Yosef, Dafna Shahaf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Analogy-making is central to human cognition, allowing us to adapt to novel
situations -- an ability that current AI systems still lack. Most analogy
datasets today focus on simple analogies (e.g., word analogies); datasets
including complex types of analogies are typically manually curated and very
small. We believe that this holds back progress in computational analogy. In
this work, we design a data generation pipeline, ParallelPARC (Parallel
Paragraph Creator) leveraging state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) to
create complex, paragraph-based analogies, as well as distractors, both simple
and challenging. We demonstrate our pipeline and create ProPara-Logy, a dataset
of analogies between scientific processes. We publish a gold-set, validated by
humans, and a silver-set, generated automatically. We test LLMs' and humans'
analogy recognition in binary and multiple-choice settings, and found that
humans outperform the best models (~13% gap) after a light supervision. We
demonstrate that our silver-set is useful for training models. Lastly, we show
challenging distractors confuse LLMs, but not humans. We hope our pipeline will
encourage research in this emerging field.
|
[
-0.4030909836,
-0.5319116712,
0.741944015,
0.1969384253,
-0.2948379219,
0.0141426045,
-0.3153100908,
-0.1965928078,
0.2607029974,
0.1401940584,
-0.5907249451,
-0.2334839553,
-0.4405312538,
0.2782539427,
-0.504838407,
0.9163466096,
-0.0442697629,
0.0521149971,
-0.518851161,
-0.0713069215,
-0.4191640913,
-0.3571274281,
-0.6917811036,
-0.3573290408,
0.4786096811,
0.3035491407,
0.7672285438,
0.9901067019,
0.4016042054,
0.4256260395,
0.0115869045,
-0.0200950745,
-0.4456544816,
0.0485200547,
-0.4366036952,
-0.3960748911,
-0.1578141153,
0.0742226541,
0.596907258,
0.9927480221,
-0.0538993552,
0.2074401975,
0.1077303439,
0.5573256612,
-0.6265650988,
0.3958100677,
-0.8475058079,
0.1727191806,
-0.2490375191,
0.0216914695,
0.0611029528,
-0.3464467824,
0.0860495865,
-0.828650713,
0.4047098756,
0.5052566528,
0.7616757751,
0.1585153341,
0.1739492863,
-0.4583593607,
-0.6772741675,
0.834602356,
-0.5698596835,
0.0718784705,
-0.0136153419,
0.4064901769,
-0.2681845725,
-1.1425716877,
-0.9770281911,
-0.1875005662,
0.0891351402,
0.2346957773,
-0.070584029,
-0.1434092522,
0.2290506661,
0.4063767791,
-0.4933717549,
0.1685876548,
-0.3753600717,
-0.1075476035,
0.2864104807,
0.6762876511,
0.4673080742,
-0.0252128504,
-0.2833001912,
-0.1123841554,
-0.7938597798,
-0.2235934138,
0.3094443977,
0.0720415637,
0.2052767426,
0.4584819674,
-0.2306151688,
0.7192503214,
-0.079692103,
-0.0564945415,
0.1132063344,
-0.3318846524,
-0.0147682754,
0.210261479,
0.9328600764,
0.5724951029,
0.328507036,
-0.4212098718,
0.0177427605,
0.5820741653,
0.2163226157,
-0.7950586081,
-0.3622527122,
0.0789250955,
-0.2671225965,
-0.2865408659,
0.021338027,
-0.7617230415,
-0.4982479811,
-0.6968602538,
0.3059419096,
-0.3015432358,
0.1258327812,
0.2101104856,
-0.3684598804,
0.0645769313,
0.0851444602,
-0.8858286142,
0.7846919298,
0.8436995745,
0.8223842382,
-0.3751345277,
-0.9515874982,
-0.5029409528,
0.3408710659,
-0.3145975769,
1.0148297548,
-0.4836158752,
-0.2228050232,
-0.2549337447,
-0.1914790124,
0.0038707841,
-0.9091407657,
0.8510881662,
0.0773928165,
0.3519991636,
-0.1495380551,
-0.7593373656,
0.2213068902,
0.0094446689,
-0.5455828905,
0.598446846,
-0.1694958061,
-1.0347493887,
0.0651798621,
-0.4913573861,
-0.1558644027,
0.1276229471,
-0.3439831436,
-0.158951357,
0.1491566002,
0.2984599173,
0.2141107917,
-0.8847467303,
0.3342679739,
-0.4800865054,
-0.5092515349,
0.4098663926,
-0.2579469681,
0.5711468458,
0.3304924667,
0.1412285864,
0.2598986924,
-0.601195395,
-0.1440997869,
0.1708654165,
0.1511582136,
-0.3540786207,
0.106742017,
-0.1496684253,
0.4446128309,
0.0921799019,
-0.7785964012,
-0.2718925476,
-0.3263642788,
0.8598886132,
0.6288059354,
-0.0472228788,
0.3956377208,
-0.7408936024,
0.3798162341,
0.172397539,
-0.1550037414,
-0.3645777404,
-0.3451971114,
-0.9987527132,
-0.5678653121,
0.2767499387,
0.5182091594,
-0.5117631555,
0.4700980783,
-0.6606347561,
-0.5065138936,
-0.6469327807,
-0.1008873135,
0.2095106691,
1.0012360811,
0.1717500836,
-0.3194864988,
-0.607100606,
-1.002019763,
-0.4699108005,
-0.0437973365,
-0.7388781905,
0.1214666292,
0.2849628031,
0.0378017016,
1.1421298981,
-0.6640101075,
-0.3454521,
0.0279401354,
0.241247803,
0.196207121,
0.2446289062,
0.224838376,
-0.4008888006,
-0.3267948031,
-0.2237530649,
-0.9449950457,
-0.3380181193,
-0.3198436201,
-0.1718616933,
-0.5232622027,
0.6831890941,
-0.7589013577,
0.0153575279,
0.1867157072,
-0.0869147927,
0.6726177335,
-0.2116906792,
-0.1647327393,
-1.1095762253,
0.2305649817,
0.0279371254,
-0.0768858716,
-0.571637094,
-0.092660442,
-0.2145492285,
-0.4970726669,
-0.6492518187,
0.6810210347,
-0.1829395443,
-0.0509935468,
-0.2036970556,
0.2841868997,
0.1397536844,
0.3849626482,
0.1815959662,
0.931565702,
0.6636782289,
-0.2674614489,
0.3904440403,
0.2591062188,
-0.443087399,
0.5890244842,
-0.8413271904,
-0.0540224351,
-0.2559601068,
0.4615136981,
-0.5376626253,
-0.4259233773,
0.15902026,
0.0668548495,
-0.2525353134,
0.3661856651,
-0.7083406448,
-0.3541150987,
-0.4328767359,
0.3845134079,
0.8214021921,
-0.598082304,
0.3166845739,
0.4010078013,
-0.6375173926,
-0.1475357711,
-0.5812262893,
0.345577091,
-0.603330195,
-0.2883253098,
0.5082595348,
-0.1243282929,
-0.3312158287,
0.0017870141,
0.0712114722,
-0.1732375622,
-0.2487416565,
0.3377581537,
0.3081074357,
0.0482419729,
-0.0709363222,
0.0695110932,
-0.1170471087,
0.2841363847,
-0.1870519668,
0.3041133285,
-0.3618256152,
-0.3717507124,
-0.4351714849,
0.4469463527,
0.6473475099,
0.1582089365,
0.5989311337,
0.3007232845,
-0.3326190412,
-0.1027676836,
-0.3601321876,
-0.2371240407,
-0.4792855978,
0.1999477595,
-0.4039265513,
-0.7236785293,
0.5216193795,
-0.4667294323,
-0.1195559129,
0.1136319637,
0.6491793394,
-0.1579121947,
0.5550894737,
-0.0615375079,
0.1080084667,
0.0749458894,
0.1555520296,
0.3129223883,
-0.7851598263,
0.1282985061,
-0.2739040852,
-0.2570376694,
-0.3352350295,
-0.5126623511,
0.2459591627,
0.3577353656,
-0.2782488167,
0.3294343054,
-0.4087840319,
0.6835816503,
0.5560329556,
-0.12825194,
0.2683528066,
0.0172203146,
-0.1955326498,
-0.3277074993,
-0.9425956607,
-0.630803287,
0.9655153751,
0.2731393874,
0.6270182133,
-0.3987230957,
0.7017880678,
-0.0611422807,
0.3542393446,
-0.6287745833,
0.7699456811,
-0.2142048329,
-0.2114378512,
0.0002424817,
-0.2737800479,
-0.9446004033,
0.2424963415,
-0.3118099868,
-0.6727082729,
-0.021149341,
0.174390018,
-0.1108117923,
0.2414411604,
-0.8455348611,
0.849748075,
0.1615097523,
-0.3565349281,
-0.0874503702,
-0.6759159565,
0.368932724,
-0.3334206045,
0.2363367826,
-0.225794211,
-0.0422334149,
0.4849382937,
-0.5475500226,
0.6706315279,
0.3724427819,
0.4067766368,
0.5605934262,
0.1512590796,
0.3436007202,
-0.1294246912,
-0.1661515385,
0.2396176457,
-0.1546820998,
-0.4463343918,
-0.7132704854,
0.9116905332,
-0.4373720586,
-0.6047493219,
-0.3570076525,
-1.0392680168,
-0.0505032279,
0.0850355774,
0.0961782187,
0.1984191686,
-0.3533131778,
0.0341165885,
0.1829764396,
-0.0648057014,
0.5166923404,
0.0765923709,
0.0902566314,
-0.4103544652,
1.2941623926,
-0.2628780305,
0.0689371675,
0.2149317712,
0.4086230993,
-0.2518654764,
-0.4224050343,
-0.4566367865,
0.2128502131,
-0.5064685345,
-0.1624583751,
-0.4790332913,
-0.2357851565,
-0.143833369,
-0.3033490777,
-0.2765983641,
-0.6306042075,
-0.3680174649,
0.1009962037,
0.1613662988,
0.3383419812,
0.0021696903,
0.1303932816,
-0.5968618989,
0.5042527914,
0.7265622616,
0.1256827265,
-0.0553412773,
-0.2012919486,
-0.03087667,
-0.0560075119,
-0.4242982864,
-0.4784440696,
0.5305070281,
0.4075794816,
0.298619777,
0.2996468544,
0.0771093518,
0.696228385,
-1.0823463202,
0.7731826305,
0.4461686611,
-1.0617282391,
0.11278034,
-0.3937138617,
0.4667724371,
0.535528481,
0.3231540918,
-0.4367826879,
-0.5460745096,
-0.5313197374,
-0.6972109675,
0.4231780767,
0.6236342192,
-0.1313363612,
-0.1970220804,
0.1299036294,
0.2582366765,
0.4705817699,
-0.4247895479,
0.0239157062,
-0.3292622268,
-0.5047297478,
0.0503518097,
0.1466453522,
-0.2213636637,
-0.1593727916,
0.1467545927,
-0.1585233659,
0.2636702359,
-0.0988086909,
0.0671556666,
0.1296732575,
0.3005751073,
0.2937598228,
0.7421243191,
-0.05041245,
0.5444051027,
0.3902496099,
-0.2257682532,
0.0223220438,
0.2827631235,
0.0015532245,
0.002480905,
0.3336345553,
0.7844469547,
0.044741597,
-1.1963205338,
0.3519374132,
-0.0082105864,
-0.0844806209,
-0.3001226485,
0.1329129338,
0.5527634621,
0.0340477712,
0.0406497419,
0.1504295021,
0.2765702307,
-0.516908884,
0.153588593,
0.2913561761,
-0.0813783482,
-0.3154000938,
0.8629971147,
0.1099213958,
-0.5746894479,
0.5943700671,
-0.0700596496,
-0.1566645652,
0.5642377734,
0.6546645761,
0.8970934749,
0.1710329354,
-0.0269733127,
0.264328599,
-0.122705996,
-0.2589082718,
-0.0312051848,
0.0160671175,
-0.5993708968,
-0.3173699975,
-0.8354120851,
-0.4559438825,
0.1422372311,
-0.5857409835,
0.3555190265,
-0.4499643743,
0.0786795393,
0.2737954855,
-0.5279073715,
-0.6968579292,
0.0307090264,
0.1548396498,
0.6923132539,
-1.1234468222,
0.9484726787,
0.6830332875,
-0.2145385593,
-0.5056195855,
0.1413347721,
-0.2083303183,
-0.4151773751,
0.585080862,
0.1968418658,
-0.0922484919,
-0.1016557813,
-0.2992580533,
-0.5231432915,
1.1798810959,
0.6511719823,
-0.522811234,
-0.159517467,
0.4034968615,
0.922131598,
-0.7487473488,
0.1934265345,
0.6975098252,
0.0878991932,
0.0926407278,
-0.7595902085,
0.0198290776,
-0.0903869495,
0.3058052361,
-0.0808092579,
-0.4584195614,
0.9791349173,
0.0113370894,
-0.3123044372,
0.1540850401,
0.6299657226,
0.7307202816,
0.2750946283,
0.5697223544,
0.8952758908,
0.2876292467,
0.1421539783,
0.8980123401,
-0.1885587573,
0.1855714619,
1.5857627392,
-0.4750008583,
0.7007645369,
0.7961608171,
-0.2417105138,
0.434125185,
0.4385164082,
0.000909635,
0.4747957289,
0.4721542299,
-0.4703584313,
-0.1733356863,
-0.4658945799,
0.052071657,
0.0553453118,
0.5432070494,
-0.3024935722,
-0.4160629511,
-0.2651714981,
-0.0816380829,
0.4955305755,
-0.1362851113,
0.6311986446,
0.2901522219,
-0.7609020472,
0.5375189781,
-0.2341425419,
0.3311573565,
-0.4821550548,
-0.1074522808,
-0.1563623101,
0.1585267633,
0.1957989037,
-0.8329918385,
0.323053807,
-0.0181550831,
-0.1514346451,
-0.1678079069,
0.4862082899,
-0.5452700257,
-0.5893580317,
-0.0053165201,
0.4136862755,
0.3552594483,
0.0988616496,
-0.7820281386,
0.1602065861,
-0.2520051599,
0.1386027783,
0.4833860397,
0.3792979419,
-0.0922298655,
0.8760795593,
0.5447574854,
0.3484998047,
0.1245152652,
-0.1096246317,
1.0377092361,
-0.4435744286,
-0.4188115895,
-0.602735579,
0.162178427,
-0.2499729693,
-0.2267364562,
0.5682108998,
0.6438184381,
0.7861090899,
-0.4101025462,
0.6619773507,
0.0361594297,
0.5770024657,
-0.2462591678,
0.4485993087,
-0.1516291052,
0.1693897396,
-0.2733843029,
-1.1547940969,
-0.2704738081,
0.4072077274,
-0.1100992933,
-0.4884045422,
1.0443309546,
0.8836317062,
-0.4936123192,
0.0738696679,
0.1053543836,
0.1422228664,
0.260540247,
0.7414691448,
0.9019436836,
-0.4059518576,
0.6441533566,
-0.143867746,
0.0536956564,
0.2670531869,
-1.1399929523,
-1.0055930614,
-0.4768938422,
-0.3015282452,
-0.0733876079,
0.0882584304,
0.9154051542,
0.4135862291,
-0.7547721267,
-0.4744074941,
-0.7750116587,
-0.0831241086,
-0.2518687844,
-0.1489617825,
0.4079899788,
-0.3616650999,
-1.0334638357,
0.3502667844,
0.2477874756,
-0.0087523768,
-0.2883145809,
0.0564858206,
-0.0168647468,
0.2000179142,
0.3905303776,
0.3573112488,
-0.9022454023,
-0.1788882911,
-0.4200471342,
0.0080249095,
0.0171171315,
0.9555060267,
-1.0415607691,
0.600486517,
0.5987910032,
0.6332051754,
0.3629294932,
0.1203869432,
0.6993695498,
-0.5988608003,
0.6627907753,
0.302996695,
0.3077378273,
0.4604916275,
0.1249218211,
0.2938313484,
0.2684962451,
-0.5820216537,
-0.7447654009,
0.4152074158,
-0.881590426,
-0.3496019542,
0.8754277229,
-0.3662171364,
-0.3385782242,
0.0406585224,
-0.2666159868,
0.0392016806,
-0.3241383731,
0.9821367264,
0.6180464625,
-0.1789448261,
0.1050707772,
-0.2608165443,
0.4776903093,
0.53271842,
-0.9655786157,
0.1394527256,
0.5455466509,
0.3261879683,
0.1190955788,
0.2544547915,
-0.0449493118,
-0.0320406295,
0.3176635802,
-0.0733064339,
-0.0724734217,
-0.1769073755,
-0.2409152687,
0.2411584556,
-0.062375728,
-0.3183877468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01131v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01131v2
|
LLaMoCo: Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models for Optimization Code Generation
| 2024-03-02T08:21:59 | 2024-03-05T11:11:41 |
Zeyuan Ma, Hongshu Guo, Jiacheng Chen, Guojun Peng, Zhiguang Cao, Yining Ma, Yue-Jiao Gong
|
math.OC
|
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE, cs.SE
|
Recent research explores optimization using large language models (LLMs) by
either iteratively seeking next-step solutions from LLMs or directly prompting
LLMs for an optimizer. However, these approaches exhibit inherent limitations,
including low operational efficiency, high sensitivity to prompt design, and a
lack of domain-specific knowledge. We introduce LLaMoCo, the first
instruction-tuning framework designed to adapt LLMs for solving optimization
problems in a code-to-code manner. Specifically, we establish a comprehensive
instruction set containing well-described problem prompts and effective
optimization codes. We then develop a novel two-phase learning strategy that
incorporates a contrastive learning-based warm-up procedure before the
instruction-tuning phase to enhance the convergence behavior during model
fine-tuning. The experiment results demonstrate that a CodeGen (350M) model
fine-tuned by our LLaMoCo achieves superior optimization performance compared
to GPT-4 Turbo and the other competitors across both synthetic and realistic
problem sets. The fine-tuned model and the usage instructions are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/LLaMoCo-722A.
|
[
-0.1753793508,
-0.5717658997,
0.5081470013,
0.393113941,
-0.3767773211,
0.0212996118,
-0.5097264051,
-0.1913155317,
-0.0974263847,
0.5558897853,
-0.7043228745,
-0.6153717637,
-0.3529936969,
0.2379480451,
-0.0667832419,
0.9118160009,
0.0228620451,
0.1385763437,
-0.3208562136,
0.3446478546,
-0.1470996886,
-0.1815478355,
-0.7608914375,
-0.1647091955,
0.407373935,
0.6484666467,
0.1620626152,
0.9529437423,
0.3005912304,
0.2917601764,
-0.1249937117,
0.531534493,
-0.787263453,
0.1283722073,
0.0666613877,
-0.6295286417,
-0.4050279558,
-0.4769618511,
0.5106803775,
0.4273119867,
-0.2798355222,
0.0308390502,
0.1309965998,
0.7005194426,
-0.6869376302,
0.2005248964,
-0.9888485074,
-0.0222962014,
0.0017615338,
-0.7080811262,
-0.3550302684,
-0.4287391901,
-0.3670078218,
-0.6054784656,
0.3711546063,
0.0934619009,
0.3664646149,
0.5811769366,
-0.2279951274,
-0.5411782265,
-0.4925394356,
0.9403167367,
-0.7113983631,
0.1681709886,
0.050198894,
0.0155918868,
-0.2415387034,
-0.5516587496,
-0.1239867732,
-0.3014787138,
0.5106533766,
0.1376578659,
-0.0340546258,
0.1551100165,
0.1961395293,
0.3494612277,
-0.3730089962,
0.5089936256,
-0.4088152647,
-0.1076550335,
0.5798572302,
0.3337254822,
-0.1082894132,
0.267411679,
-0.1588928401,
0.1436282396,
-0.892390132,
-0.2039241493,
0.5101401806,
0.3149927855,
-0.0888932496,
0.3556599021,
-0.1656677425,
0.5542191267,
0.0918405056,
-0.0332085714,
-0.0631259829,
-0.0792696029,
-0.0713939071,
0.1087555289,
0.4004411697,
0.2879913747,
0.3345786035,
-0.0226505119,
-0.4374901652,
-0.0444419459,
0.4432917833,
-1.0384926796,
-0.0852876008,
0.0173048954,
-0.1226495653,
-0.6724666953,
-0.2453292161,
-0.8607238531,
-0.1888913512,
-0.4087928534,
0.1670645624,
0.0614986904,
0.0044714664,
0.2628730536,
0.3129243851,
0.4707887173,
0.1676746011,
-1.1193223,
0.2907367051,
0.8467108011,
0.7618353963,
-0.1773969829,
-0.1020227745,
-0.6689011455,
0.0411069095,
-0.5406802297,
0.6382697225,
-0.6853907704,
-0.6129178405,
0.3588272035,
-0.0446102321,
0.1565698534,
-0.7316408753,
0.3311294913,
-0.6364567876,
-0.2272549868,
-0.1162851974,
-0.5544362068,
0.088581726,
0.0005778997,
-0.3966489732,
0.917868197,
0.1263035536,
-0.3306119442,
-0.1876017302,
-0.5352364779,
-0.6653065681,
-0.001252931,
-0.1866265237,
-0.5019912124,
0.5666595101,
-0.040624056,
0.2100332379,
-0.7204473019,
-0.1251284927,
-0.1323098391,
-0.4287215173,
0.055716373,
-0.1599226743,
0.4889294803,
0.3892124593,
-0.2424312383,
0.2723751664,
-0.6389297247,
0.26088956,
0.3427633345,
-0.3692702949,
0.0087937079,
0.0439525954,
-0.4390429258,
-0.1789098382,
0.5265578628,
-0.0093980543,
0.3771133423,
-0.3398833573,
0.6622111201,
0.8577275276,
-0.0098662889,
0.1900249273,
-0.2142753899,
0.8577548862,
-0.2310040146,
0.1555508971,
-0.3761551082,
-0.2332945168,
-1.001847744,
0.0424635671,
0.1854910702,
0.6275034547,
-0.5995210409,
0.2560835481,
0.1315843165,
-0.1877703369,
-0.3457168341,
0.4883162975,
0.5852946043,
0.4433582127,
0.2057214975,
-0.0737145022,
-0.5151407123,
-0.7768586874,
0.022369558,
0.2864355743,
0.1900300682,
0.5200585127,
0.577636838,
-0.1766934991,
0.2208345383,
-0.8515874147,
0.010937185,
-0.218361482,
-0.0502904393,
0.1686848402,
0.4809125066,
0.3672450781,
-0.4575006366,
-0.4073289335,
0.2012726516,
-0.400483042,
-0.4290254414,
0.1550677568,
-0.3245207965,
0.1692489833,
0.7867925167,
-0.0313437469,
-0.0478195585,
0.7542655468,
0.2813993692,
0.6146323681,
-0.4098551869,
-0.0543448441,
-1.1482890844,
-0.1416448206,
0.0041174525,
-0.1094877198,
-0.4294547141,
0.1684238762,
0.0382318422,
-0.2445872873,
-0.4493815303,
0.2936784029,
-0.4717896283,
-0.0989833027,
-0.4848006666,
-0.0254555903,
-0.0195212029,
0.6054311395,
-0.0962148681,
1.1894620657,
0.6114038229,
-0.8064399362,
0.2748440504,
-0.1145469919,
-0.3494625688,
0.2064613551,
-0.8470726609,
0.6804728508,
-0.0111871064,
-0.1555991918,
-0.6043275595,
-0.3471797109,
-0.0241980869,
-0.0805943534,
0.3988262713,
-0.1954082549,
-0.4224731624,
-0.2192494422,
-0.2112178802,
0.6363310218,
0.6344620585,
-0.5740701556,
0.2277652919,
0.1573384851,
-0.1828532666,
-0.2612243891,
-0.3332055509,
-0.3282776475,
-0.2122700512,
-0.3171320856,
0.3020378947,
-0.2214237899,
0.0264749415,
-0.4329423308,
-0.2246289849,
-0.184459433,
0.2405682206,
-0.1112757176,
0.2070067972,
-0.2153291702,
0.1357554197,
0.3705020249,
-0.1314243227,
0.09253636,
-0.6306416988,
0.7359306216,
-0.1300615966,
0.0230433829,
-0.316218704,
0.4010466933,
0.2361909449,
-0.3311294317,
0.549869597,
0.1946641803,
-0.2170629948,
-0.6348311901,
-0.3409786224,
-0.1351901591,
-0.5225391984,
0.6747147441,
-0.4701301157,
-0.812417686,
0.260166198,
-0.5733206868,
0.0220081843,
0.1059840471,
0.8825193048,
0.0510715358,
1.0594419241,
0.8888041973,
0.0848076418,
0.618198812,
-0.3190782964,
-0.0792963952,
-0.8876613379,
-0.1975505948,
-0.8261429071,
-0.1797038615,
-0.706276834,
-0.5428497791,
0.4315096438,
0.2445698529,
-0.2608423531,
0.1194470897,
-0.560441792,
1.0693230629,
0.3635526896,
0.2481957674,
0.2245331705,
-0.0141599076,
-0.0153749846,
0.0902472213,
-0.8187043071,
-0.2638645172,
1.0573004484,
0.0028178231,
0.8955487609,
-0.0666297451,
0.7823274136,
0.2103007883,
0.1061565578,
-0.787481606,
0.3795250952,
-0.3373070061,
-0.3359098136,
0.173361659,
-0.7260864377,
-0.8037493229,
-0.017911775,
0.0710582137,
-0.4999509156,
-0.0909686163,
0.4917707145,
-0.3505788147,
-0.0238495059,
-0.5954863429,
0.7666553259,
-0.6332663894,
-0.5911454558,
-0.4231260419,
-0.2706588209,
0.3275295496,
-0.2398306876,
0.1968096048,
-0.022065198,
-0.425696671,
0.3055619299,
-0.3219252825,
0.7902943492,
0.0614863895,
-0.4496674836,
0.1224333718,
0.2509063482,
0.5844495296,
0.0299436655,
-0.1858926713,
-0.0416624323,
-0.2767319083,
-0.475022316,
-0.6165689826,
0.9325319529,
-0.6179617643,
-0.6350308657,
0.0622723177,
-0.5711385608,
-0.2430853993,
0.336556524,
0.3651190698,
0.5473227501,
0.0042363587,
0.2493350059,
0.9043183327,
-0.2783188224,
0.062451113,
0.3615973592,
-0.1299114674,
-0.4409405291,
0.9863925576,
-0.493500948,
0.4412703216,
0.5040841699,
0.3508216143,
-0.1369456947,
-0.6815819144,
-0.2212202102,
0.2542616129,
-0.5369169116,
-0.3635387421,
0.0478034951,
-0.1406231821,
-0.2269194871,
-0.3579139113,
-0.587906003,
-0.0058040968,
-0.5119745135,
0.2348488867,
0.1569505185,
0.6464844346,
0.1235165149,
0.362080574,
-0.506426096,
0.1501014978,
0.1885863394,
0.3764497042,
-0.1532831788,
-0.5700258017,
-0.4999730587,
-0.0005347027,
-0.3774265647,
-0.5577594638,
0.2232837975,
0.3742943406,
0.2622358203,
0.3682972491,
0.0111683272,
0.5614461303,
-0.6119232178,
0.271594584,
0.0340181999,
-0.8683118224,
0.770716846,
-0.2570598423,
0.3842509389,
0.436042726,
0.4068434834,
-0.004937462,
0.0123457108,
-0.2596889734,
-0.6791303158,
0.4654241502,
-0.0104763415,
0.4452116191,
0.0194863714,
0.784683466,
0.1425079256,
0.4756037891,
-0.4269836545,
-0.1316739917,
0.0460787527,
-0.3264655471,
-0.0661844239,
-0.3498471677,
-0.3123657405,
-0.1792516708,
0.6808712482,
-0.5102931857,
0.2556295395,
-0.1540943533,
-0.091916658,
-0.2468796223,
0.094208777,
1.0768530369,
0.5061757565,
0.0432430394,
-0.1431266367,
0.194025442,
-0.2660514414,
-0.0391861685,
-0.123843804,
-0.1386447996,
-0.5198919177,
0.2119874805,
0.9866130352,
0.4631892741,
-0.6753786206,
0.152614072,
-0.0287118442,
-0.2857607603,
-0.1599339545,
0.5379068851,
-0.1074356288,
0.3267499804,
0.0247596316,
-0.2695009112,
0.0333192013,
-0.427316606,
-0.0592170991,
0.5313900113,
-0.023883231,
-0.0984323025,
0.7470742464,
0.5656154752,
-0.4400216043,
0.4695883989,
-0.2440787554,
-0.6732093096,
0.803884089,
0.9089428782,
0.9914860129,
-0.0967224613,
-0.07508564,
0.3807035983,
0.2522206903,
0.0505454913,
0.2028363347,
-0.2577150166,
-0.5881240368,
-0.3550210893,
-0.7134203911,
-0.5220310092,
-0.0392155126,
-0.7797634006,
0.2930786014,
-0.7436594963,
0.0787984952,
-0.326328963,
0.2596915364,
-0.5058934689,
-0.040668942,
0.1226931736,
0.8346232772,
-0.5546233654,
0.8314133883,
0.5216366053,
-0.0202375408,
-0.6116065979,
0.0490339845,
-0.0298146922,
-1.1188007593,
0.264079988,
0.1542752236,
-0.5118778348,
0.5974327326,
-0.78890872,
-0.5200546384,
1.031824708,
0.4886909723,
-1.0329127312,
0.0245378129,
0.0275758542,
0.3904711902,
-0.7240366936,
-0.0962510258,
0.6879801154,
0.0875202566,
0.2802430987,
-0.5633080006,
-0.2009594887,
-0.0885151774,
0.3697341681,
0.3157092333,
-0.976241231,
0.6541380882,
-0.5352571607,
0.1026228964,
0.3633705676,
0.5796001554,
0.2747439742,
0.0384711064,
0.3199962974,
0.3972168565,
0.7746686339,
-0.0119524393,
1.1689069271,
-0.598020792,
0.4147927165,
1.0550601482,
-0.2708523571,
0.576107502,
0.2622890472,
0.0254044347,
0.3098074794,
0.5302155614,
0.0037665905,
0.6255304813,
0.4730317891,
-0.3377652764,
-0.3845460117,
-0.0735688806,
-0.401167959,
0.3574254811,
0.3726190925,
-0.2762667835,
0.0405278616,
-0.4066103399,
0.0704140738,
0.1541880369,
-0.5292320251,
0.7883573174,
0.1544041038,
-0.6625837684,
0.8643068671,
0.0057542245,
0.3534067571,
-0.587542057,
-0.06381841,
-0.4686008692,
0.254235059,
-0.1321801394,
-0.3129479289,
-0.0538977832,
0.2811749279,
-0.2418916076,
0.0969609916,
0.2666838169,
-0.4149173796,
-0.5833626986,
0.0202310998,
0.0882221162,
0.046425011,
0.1481742859,
-0.6937451363,
0.5248164535,
0.3014428616,
0.035408888,
0.2346353233,
0.3848783076,
0.151570648,
0.6950981617,
0.5457646847,
0.1289712787,
0.1182820797,
0.2406207919,
0.8121331334,
-0.5834249258,
-0.3007952869,
-0.6389008164,
0.1698303223,
0.1839591116,
-0.4623530805,
0.3051309288,
0.5907379389,
0.8575463295,
-0.1631082445,
0.6442020535,
0.2429719716,
0.0057698456,
-1.0804507732,
0.1937283576,
-0.8346379995,
0.5420050621,
0.1186567917,
-1.0893781185,
-0.1731074303,
0.6014733315,
-0.1784451306,
0.2928209007,
0.6505722404,
1.1112974882,
0.0869931281,
-0.1482112855,
0.2020777762,
0.3020808697,
0.2313436866,
0.8777538538,
0.7075701952,
-0.1420623064,
0.5561280847,
-0.3768874109,
-0.3415299654,
-0.3849003315,
-0.9895003438,
-0.816498816,
-0.2544853389,
-0.3142308891,
-0.1795134097,
0.2072991878,
0.9516369104,
0.5872129798,
-0.6516499519,
-0.4720729291,
-0.3434814513,
0.023226453,
-0.0668150336,
-0.134597227,
-0.0613936931,
-0.7861927152,
-0.964497149,
0.4365319312,
0.2231356949,
-0.0935697556,
-0.2025230229,
-0.3588292003,
0.3395088613,
0.2142725438,
0.3992401361,
0.4311109483,
-0.4054033756,
0.1332310736,
0.0565701686,
-0.1305268556,
0.1436213553,
1.1608476639,
-0.2305459082,
0.3886347413,
0.1120284572,
0.6355316639,
0.6419650316,
0.0773507282,
0.5821015239,
-0.8079109192,
0.3368268609,
0.2566836178,
0.1590991616,
0.0660798028,
-0.3562182188,
0.3221419454,
0.0470547639,
-0.6930851936,
-0.74068892,
0.4460783899,
-0.8424639702,
-0.1999431252,
1.1767252684,
0.2125075012,
-0.3562522829,
0.5449427366,
-0.2241743654,
0.1927768588,
-0.3354500234,
0.9112812281,
0.3134415746,
-0.1875471324,
-0.2810072005,
-0.6286420226,
0.4255245328,
0.4305827916,
-0.9462387562,
0.0201789625,
0.4171698987,
0.2889853418,
-0.3181451261,
0.1637255698,
0.0690633282,
0.4146868885,
0.0520582832,
-0.077921845,
-0.3285467029,
-0.5665588379,
-0.3640277684,
-0.116057165,
0.338041544,
-0.1808536947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01116v1
|
MulCogBench: A Multi-modal Cognitive Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating Chinese and English Computational Language Models
| 2024-03-02T07:49:57 | 2024-03-02T07:49:57 |
Yunhao Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Chong Li, Shaonan Wang, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained computational language models have recently made remarkable
progress in harnessing the language abilities which were considered unique to
humans. Their success has raised interest in whether these models represent and
process language like humans. To answer this question, this paper proposes
MulCogBench, a multi-modal cognitive benchmark dataset collected from native
Chinese and English participants. It encompasses a variety of cognitive data,
including subjective semantic ratings, eye-tracking, functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI), and magnetoencephalography (MEG). To assess the
relationship between language models and cognitive data, we conducted a
similarity-encoding analysis which decodes cognitive data based on its pattern
similarity with textual embeddings. Results show that language models share
significant similarities with human cognitive data and the similarity patterns
are modulated by the data modality and stimuli complexity. Specifically,
context-aware models outperform context-independent models as language stimulus
complexity increases. The shallow layers of context-aware models are better
aligned with the high-temporal-resolution MEG signals whereas the deeper layers
show more similarity with the high-spatial-resolution fMRI. These results
indicate that language models have a delicate relationship with brain language
representations. Moreover, the results between Chinese and English are highly
consistent, suggesting the generalizability of these findings across languages.
|
[
-0.4314642847,
-0.7487229109,
0.4946011007,
0.36822474,
-0.1033128276,
-0.1300846338,
-0.6304067969,
-0.5515132546,
-0.0870874897,
0.231475696,
-0.4852167964,
-0.3003852367,
-0.2733462155,
-0.053044118,
0.0424361601,
0.5706474781,
0.1582545638,
0.4509689808,
-0.2484961003,
-0.3134511411,
-0.4936653078,
-0.5678107738,
-0.5347242355,
-0.3752644658,
0.284651041,
-0.163240999,
0.9068489075,
0.5627937317,
0.3252541125,
0.3435052335,
0.1284513921,
0.1105521172,
-0.3581041098,
-0.0833386406,
-0.1866338402,
-0.2291656584,
-0.4356639385,
0.1483203322,
0.6777881384,
0.9310413003,
-0.3496529758,
-0.1332604736,
0.3401925862,
0.2319983244,
-0.4773631394,
0.449237138,
-0.817245543,
-0.2124553919,
-0.2065146714,
0.0207030699,
-0.3312300444,
-0.051962804,
-0.1918197274,
-0.4984631836,
0.2531527281,
0.1396598965,
0.7222530842,
-0.0526643991,
-0.4311592281,
-0.2938356698,
-0.1356909573,
0.9914734364,
-0.7051927447,
0.6978429556,
0.4564613104,
0.3773400486,
-0.141769141,
-0.3034510612,
-0.6558116078,
-0.7393301129,
-0.4307837784,
0.2675329149,
0.187858969,
-0.0340694524,
0.2870789468,
0.1789733469,
-0.9375812411,
-0.0760391429,
-0.3053682745,
-0.4021787047,
0.5656916499,
0.3714648485,
0.3121447861,
-0.2358607799,
-0.3944070041,
-0.2919794917,
-0.3022203147,
0.1350974143,
0.2235177755,
0.4715471566,
-0.2594454885,
0.150046885,
-0.003143348,
0.8206678033,
-0.2903827131,
-0.1268891096,
0.5403978825,
-0.3998686969,
-0.0426933132,
-0.1001291648,
0.9817087054,
0.3336196244,
0.3254317045,
-0.2989103496,
-0.0587789975,
0.3530629575,
0.0989567637,
-0.6011743546,
-0.1884450316,
-0.0216927342,
-0.547780633,
0.083398886,
0.1910578758,
-0.6699628234,
-0.4603340626,
-0.4874496758,
-0.051507704,
-0.6082974076,
-0.4944303334,
0.1902118474,
0.1336757392,
0.2125507593,
0.0496027805,
-0.9908040762,
0.298642844,
0.8244804144,
0.5033898354,
-0.3016774952,
-0.9299123883,
-0.1433173716,
0.1405336559,
-0.3321126997,
0.7964919209,
-0.7230464816,
-0.209881708,
-0.2416428775,
0.1933483928,
-0.3341243863,
-0.4781627357,
0.4668061435,
-0.2402764559,
0.0179329049,
-0.2000648528,
-0.2779802978,
-0.1574803144,
0.4308611751,
-0.922467351,
1.0464655161,
0.0620821416,
-0.6504040956,
0.2931806147,
-0.4752541482,
-0.4591962397,
0.0319592543,
-0.5671234131,
-0.0662029311,
0.2237743139,
0.1190883145,
0.5951958895,
-0.7851842046,
0.4286735058,
-0.5882692337,
-0.2556068897,
0.508962512,
-0.6278161407,
0.7302235365,
0.3014520109,
-0.0861372352,
-0.2317623645,
-0.8664612174,
0.3534607887,
0.1428049356,
-0.4194303751,
-0.548704505,
0.1109634116,
0.3662714064,
0.5945389271,
0.2228526324,
-0.7099219561,
-0.0018324961,
-0.0820152164,
0.5868373513,
0.5029917359,
-0.4533424675,
0.0976986811,
-0.3539913595,
0.1138476878,
0.2280985415,
0.0211778004,
-0.4646107554,
-0.35735479,
-0.207663551,
-0.4367476702,
0.119794555,
0.3641940951,
-0.4831766486,
0.1570708454,
-0.6825692654,
-0.5292150974,
-0.8364082575,
-0.0372346416,
0.2450197488,
0.4028636515,
0.3967170715,
-0.2869209051,
-0.1084259301,
-1.1314017773,
-0.4324255288,
0.0025841189,
-0.3210392892,
0.5360530019,
0.1379978508,
-0.327219367,
0.4909482598,
-0.3482704461,
-0.0451922379,
0.0882162377,
0.3069306314,
0.182618469,
0.4742922187,
0.6371617913,
-0.7084804773,
-0.4016649127,
0.2720250785,
-0.7536107898,
0.0611713789,
-0.1081760526,
-0.0313213468,
0.0922518671,
0.5880292654,
-0.2494132966,
0.093678087,
0.764865756,
-0.22175093,
0.3659427762,
-0.2303443402,
0.7260348201,
-0.8522909284,
0.2726458013,
-0.319465816,
-0.0301892757,
-0.5546385646,
0.0216785017,
0.3588782549,
-0.2679174244,
-0.2740704715,
0.4877963066,
-0.5106675029,
0.154047057,
-0.1311885417,
0.2436757535,
-0.1077437699,
0.8627058268,
0.2674430907,
0.611784637,
0.7576856017,
-0.4835821092,
0.3327884674,
-0.1588705182,
-0.5955210328,
0.7124112248,
-0.587397933,
0.1685395688,
-0.1059018448,
-0.2451636344,
-1.1635856628,
0.013656022,
-0.2484498471,
-0.3151034415,
0.2220217586,
0.4069531858,
-0.4508148432,
-0.1473006755,
-0.4163712561,
0.6231924295,
-0.0107539501,
-0.2804498374,
0.9394387603,
0.4123580456,
-0.1628076285,
-0.3350157142,
-1.1067569256,
-0.1588058919,
0.1573058218,
-0.7642077804,
0.5231321454,
-0.2701649368,
0.1441782117,
-0.0538941659,
0.2364078611,
-0.2702692747,
0.0349344797,
0.2181362063,
0.2059967816,
-0.4334107041,
0.1531535685,
-0.1331678927,
-0.1123323813,
0.0237304885,
0.255634129,
0.6103028059,
-0.3382470608,
-0.4029688835,
0.0810789615,
0.5194543004,
0.7269060016,
-0.3760331273,
0.763548255,
0.5078238249,
-0.4983457625,
0.1388192326,
-0.5793921947,
-0.2830925882,
-0.4452612102,
0.6254417896,
-0.8112684488,
-0.7263883352,
0.5020294785,
-0.0123452907,
-0.0842988566,
0.1421842724,
0.6839733124,
-0.0220539775,
1.0396130085,
0.4195944667,
-0.3540476859,
0.4036410451,
0.1771675795,
-0.0214655995,
-0.8749272227,
-0.0922872424,
-0.4275363982,
-0.0314467289,
-0.5723953247,
-0.264959842,
0.0001221789,
-0.1433635652,
-0.2697877288,
0.5274603963,
-0.2784152627,
0.4286473393,
0.3373981118,
0.078316696,
0.1792992502,
0.0998191833,
-0.5618243814,
-0.2622244656,
-0.6749697328,
-0.3478275537,
0.8206495047,
-0.1039625853,
0.8613343835,
-0.0478797965,
-0.1201896518,
0.1971788853,
0.1899836659,
-0.4114818871,
0.5101674795,
-0.1582196355,
-0.5984621644,
-0.1386986226,
-0.4805450439,
-1.2982445955,
0.6224037409,
-0.3468435705,
-0.6825335622,
-0.0609446391,
-0.218180269,
-0.0463183485,
0.096588932,
-0.5144174099,
1.0840802193,
-0.4468391538,
-0.3670030832,
-0.5762796998,
-0.5443677902,
0.3844180703,
-0.1875591129,
0.5177004933,
-0.3064027429,
-0.0493830666,
0.4681613147,
0.094765842,
0.4619186521,
0.2419121116,
0.0219416767,
0.1351124644,
0.2513441443,
0.0356299765,
-0.1688207239,
-0.3924764097,
0.6190885305,
0.2030325532,
-0.5221952796,
-0.518885076,
1.0539200306,
-0.7676158547,
-0.4003138542,
-0.4130283594,
-0.6215433478,
-0.2654186785,
0.256533742,
0.0335184634,
0.3595149219,
-0.5441638231,
0.1499018371,
0.0545229092,
-0.0540735014,
0.4881278276,
0.8202946782,
-0.1521805376,
-0.3928242326,
0.8375509977,
0.1156038418,
0.175640747,
0.4091777205,
-0.0053939698,
-0.2448779494,
-0.1102168784,
-0.382314384,
0.4527914524,
-0.6122426987,
0.1739533395,
-0.4336469173,
-0.0965126604,
-0.3885959685,
-0.0422573015,
-0.3959338963,
0.0468318127,
0.2741841376,
0.1468687505,
-0.0924029723,
0.4708683789,
0.0715088993,
-0.0127339233,
-0.8550862074,
0.3961689472,
0.3070184588,
0.4978766441,
0.1859543324,
-0.1085390374,
-0.4418719411,
0.3610028327,
-0.217426762,
-0.9063966274,
0.0180430841,
0.1577522755,
0.9286521673,
0.4224591851,
-0.3479753435,
0.680553019,
-0.5119565129,
0.7389896512,
0.1461806744,
-0.9906440973,
0.2168883979,
-0.2962969542,
0.5208985209,
0.6193861961,
0.3052253127,
-0.9509281516,
-0.2177702785,
-0.3296733201,
-0.3049565852,
0.8400102854,
0.0916757658,
0.1314174086,
-0.1534374803,
-0.0295487363,
0.0371864811,
0.2492791712,
-0.6857792735,
-0.1255730838,
-0.2906076908,
-0.1777919978,
-0.2243487239,
0.0781299174,
0.1315808296,
-0.0276774913,
0.3008963466,
-0.2007414252,
0.29649055,
-0.1925195307,
-0.2639112771,
0.2022984177,
0.2704024017,
0.4663996696,
0.5063749552,
0.1487791091,
0.2960297763,
0.433873117,
-0.6133170724,
0.0168608502,
0.0772702768,
0.2944970131,
-0.2539557219,
0.5524690151,
0.5646612048,
0.3513376713,
-0.8586993217,
0.5770891905,
-0.2453431338,
0.2963598073,
0.2252376378,
-0.1073847339,
0.2746003568,
-0.1042096168,
0.0316619426,
0.124547638,
0.18083556,
-0.6105304956,
0.0245567858,
0.4750979543,
-0.371897012,
-0.5130150318,
0.5258424282,
0.0211126935,
0.0208703224,
0.8674627542,
-0.0517440438,
-0.4401950836,
0.4852932394,
0.4765850902,
0.5949385762,
-0.5595648289,
-0.2266948074,
0.5456140637,
0.5007649064,
0.0401278362,
0.3459255993,
-0.1042862162,
-0.9376404285,
-0.2058508098,
-0.343627423,
-0.0216802321,
0.1706866175,
-0.6949885488,
0.4848205745,
-0.2321467549,
-0.2226470262,
0.1016671434,
-0.2168584615,
-0.8629877567,
0.2319890261,
0.3395349681,
0.5437995195,
-0.8353390694,
1.1689243317,
0.7050915956,
-0.2197311521,
-0.6399160028,
-0.2316906005,
-0.0907133594,
-0.6736195087,
0.1823823452,
0.3558084071,
-0.4262673557,
-0.373395741,
-0.3270476162,
-0.7476336956,
1.0303316116,
0.6413612366,
-0.4057355225,
0.3487097621,
0.4405787289,
0.6025580764,
-0.4432340264,
0.5674360394,
0.7036775947,
0.518196106,
-0.2972323,
-0.8692572713,
0.1566731036,
-0.5056396127,
0.1750846356,
0.2208725363,
-0.816722393,
1.2016123533,
0.1734847128,
-0.4921834767,
-0.1997826993,
0.5685335994,
0.2910675108,
0.0107173882,
0.44859308,
0.3382668495,
0.8076198697,
-0.0261385161,
0.975423038,
-0.6343666315,
0.3409848511,
1.1897007227,
-0.3594432175,
0.8253723979,
0.3143018484,
-0.2401608974,
0.5623232722,
0.428896606,
-0.0315320715,
0.5034927726,
0.0859237388,
0.166861549,
-0.3779631853,
-0.0688687488,
-0.4216169417,
0.3650624752,
0.3815115392,
-0.1125227734,
-0.3344996274,
0.1393253803,
0.1932751685,
0.2408684194,
-0.1847830266,
0.6336379647,
-0.0687148124,
-0.7908391356,
0.7474969625,
0.0686669052,
0.7886937857,
-0.8937450647,
0.1453855336,
-0.1557374597,
0.1635522991,
0.0330881923,
-0.6592738628,
0.2579726279,
-0.2687138021,
-0.3154412508,
0.2592918873,
0.3650785685,
-0.7481333017,
-0.4184985161,
0.668561995,
0.457652688,
0.1952441484,
-0.2415111065,
-1.0551234484,
0.147202298,
-0.1463322043,
-0.1684187502,
0.2568139136,
0.3706991673,
-0.2780176997,
0.5252909064,
0.5966505408,
-0.0333757177,
0.2560132742,
0.0579122007,
0.7775854468,
-0.8273454309,
-0.4940120876,
-0.9559884667,
0.2228903919,
-0.0600558482,
-0.3138448894,
0.710136354,
0.6772876382,
0.8896622062,
-0.2883632183,
0.7107178569,
0.0601331964,
0.3364289105,
-0.388930589,
0.765006721,
-0.6070101261,
-0.1114388183,
-0.2252427936,
-0.9323111773,
-0.1470918357,
0.5911872387,
-0.1688397676,
0.3312510848,
1.0172760487,
1.241560936,
-0.4620603919,
0.1430657506,
0.6582688689,
0.2830272913,
0.1575735807,
1.0041381121,
0.8551589251,
-0.3434779048,
0.388500005,
-0.0547254644,
-0.2773762047,
0.0917982683,
-0.954428792,
-0.9295625091,
-0.7764940262,
-0.1021239385,
0.0545044318,
-0.3993061185,
0.9043958187,
0.740950942,
-0.9393125176,
-0.4967415035,
0.2532978952,
-0.2132769227,
-0.6787627339,
-0.1868381798,
0.4644063115,
-0.2843827307,
-0.7822906971,
0.4394292235,
0.3078721762,
-0.0105229057,
-0.3959589005,
-0.0898458734,
-0.2148346901,
0.3104071021,
0.5484669209,
-0.1147710681,
-0.8027380109,
-0.0743608251,
0.1409022957,
-0.6882572174,
0.1178031117,
1.0226155519,
-0.7009985447,
0.5750246644,
0.6157720089,
0.4857797921,
0.4396196604,
-0.3174804151,
0.4263754785,
-0.3552487791,
0.3929633498,
-0.0427505225,
0.6524122953,
0.4809193313,
-0.0742242411,
0.502620995,
-0.0809911564,
-0.4217818379,
-0.4059701264,
0.1215680763,
-1.0313444138,
-0.5080983639,
0.8117671013,
-0.2827609181,
-0.3231139183,
-0.2007208765,
-0.3878150582,
-0.0867902264,
-0.2675988972,
0.8068341017,
1.1135933399,
0.0936047882,
-0.0237818975,
-0.3767342567,
0.2330060899,
0.3805222809,
-0.6871840954,
0.3064915836,
0.3468063474,
0.1639974266,
0.2391328067,
0.469121784,
-0.1942861527,
0.3306743801,
0.2072019875,
0.1168770492,
-0.1747848392,
-0.2098949254,
-0.3329633176,
0.2276572287,
-0.1988277435,
0.03750493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01106v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01106v2
|
Distilling Text Style Transfer With Self-Explanation From LLMs
| 2024-03-02T06:38:15 | 2024-05-04T17:23:21 |
Chiyu Zhang, Honglong Cai, Yuezhang, Li, Yuexin Wu, Le Hou, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text Style Transfer (TST) seeks to alter the style of text while retaining
its core content. Given the constraints of limited parallel datasets for TST,
we propose CoTeX, a framework that leverages large language models (LLMs)
alongside chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to facilitate TST. CoTeX distills
the complex rewriting and reasoning capabilities of LLMs into more streamlined
models capable of working with both non-parallel and parallel data. Through
experimentation across four TST datasets, CoTeX is shown to surpass traditional
supervised fine-tuning and knowledge distillation methods, particularly in
low-resource settings. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation, comparing CoTeX
against current unsupervised, supervised, in-context learning (ICL) techniques,
and instruction-tuned LLMs. Furthermore, CoTeX distinguishes itself by offering
transparent explanations for its style transfer process.
|
[
-0.1856890619,
-0.6932687163,
0.7892153859,
0.3672190607,
-0.4217094481,
0.4612179697,
-0.4303319454,
-0.2066096067,
0.1318523735,
0.6970591545,
-0.9397255778,
-0.5452585816,
-0.4552324712,
0.2725334466,
-0.7668136358,
1.0777410269,
-0.4139495194,
-0.4325450063,
-0.039671503,
0.1468784511,
-0.4571827054,
-0.4997732937,
-0.7402511835,
-0.4818868935,
0.5109598637,
0.6385486722,
0.3741035461,
0.6782003045,
0.1541816592,
0.2674860656,
0.0988332182,
0.2807244062,
-0.6376793385,
0.1124704555,
-0.5557612777,
-0.428163439,
-0.4200839996,
-0.0207375772,
0.4334453642,
0.3432298899,
0.0485138893,
0.1124090031,
0.3594352007,
1.0706753731,
-0.4236947596,
-0.1162336767,
-0.6923948526,
-0.0280532092,
-0.1680158824,
-0.2313328236,
-0.4460382462,
-0.2417887747,
0.3416257501,
-0.3459872007,
0.2446973175,
0.2204001993,
0.5163971782,
0.2505168021,
-0.4936271608,
-0.1629729271,
-0.7365376353,
0.8628180027,
-0.4399772584,
0.143156752,
0.2601510584,
0.3324693739,
0.1942820996,
-1.077277422,
-0.6371440291,
0.1141863912,
-0.2006292343,
0.2259143591,
-0.0663845837,
-0.1317149103,
0.1278831959,
0.3946253061,
-0.4547676146,
0.0320617259,
-0.2161232382,
-0.0816542357,
0.6425684094,
0.018250132,
0.2665189505,
-0.0460084714,
-0.7879944444,
0.0968098044,
-0.7011094093,
-0.3092111647,
-0.0502396151,
0.2122113109,
-0.1804768443,
0.0703576803,
-0.1879066974,
0.6823055148,
0.2004377395,
-0.1243430525,
-0.2126109004,
-0.4772279263,
-0.2197124809,
0.378749609,
0.835807085,
0.5460495949,
0.3514574468,
-0.2860351503,
-0.422755748,
-0.2922802269,
0.0699953586,
-0.7876227498,
-0.2304403931,
0.0970688611,
-0.4434972107,
-0.3158726394,
-0.2399681509,
-0.9063999653,
-0.4405395389,
-0.9744958282,
0.2361227423,
-0.2699813843,
-0.2568999231,
0.0882208049,
-0.2524181306,
0.2285356373,
0.556930542,
-0.8198721409,
0.4580536187,
0.587649405,
1.1795300245,
-0.6325173974,
-0.0808918029,
-0.2230621725,
0.1435158849,
-0.2502237558,
0.9023429751,
-0.3373380899,
-0.3379025757,
-0.1510791034,
-0.0375538617,
0.0766676739,
-0.2754961252,
0.3704123795,
-0.1425754577,
-0.2086109221,
-0.5349235535,
-0.4115438163,
0.1914117932,
0.0385348573,
-0.5683745146,
0.98555094,
0.1360039115,
-0.6960378885,
0.0789585859,
-0.4287415445,
-0.6296600699,
-0.154715389,
0.0390667915,
-0.2978657782,
0.1810604036,
0.43228513,
0.4706442952,
-0.4563968182,
0.2314538211,
-0.3042196929,
-0.2000284642,
0.4621636271,
-0.444280237,
0.6505756378,
0.4105964899,
-0.3599749804,
0.0312096067,
-0.6859397888,
-0.0559327081,
-0.0372865051,
0.2136454433,
-0.4540143609,
-0.2771392465,
0.1472578943,
0.4249487221,
0.221151486,
-0.5090619922,
0.2371792644,
0.1190829575,
0.943764925,
0.9872905612,
-0.0533609428,
0.5633827448,
-0.5086752176,
0.3430911899,
-0.2512626648,
0.0945933312,
-0.0505223833,
0.0392148867,
-0.8385281563,
-0.0468503013,
0.1456630081,
0.2963536084,
-1.0170693398,
-0.0987134725,
-0.0087785348,
-0.347176522,
-0.3497506976,
0.1647093743,
0.3484604359,
0.6354253888,
0.548377037,
0.0489172637,
-0.5059298873,
-0.9564971924,
-0.3814817667,
0.2522242963,
0.1928163916,
0.1158588976,
0.310152024,
0.0541757718,
0.932867229,
-0.4948105514,
-0.192440033,
-0.6306149364,
0.522354126,
-0.0378671139,
0.4835250974,
0.6664846539,
-0.6613568068,
-0.8342584372,
0.044111494,
-0.4901252091,
-0.4088585675,
-0.3853096664,
-0.3054133654,
0.1034830213,
0.8567054868,
0.2482918799,
0.5361561775,
0.472635299,
-0.0996274352,
0.7808197737,
-0.1461064667,
0.1902998686,
-1.4108675718,
-0.1774633527,
0.2182876021,
-0.453017801,
-0.5604868531,
-0.3662003279,
0.2629905045,
0.0224032383,
-0.393940419,
0.640194416,
-0.6045410633,
0.0487446897,
-0.5142601132,
0.3162635863,
0.3620486557,
0.4671550095,
0.3117463291,
0.9726784229,
0.4759596288,
-0.5582447648,
0.3841307759,
0.0361847207,
-0.3198318779,
0.9793199301,
-0.7088196278,
0.3983037472,
-0.1179849207,
0.3464945257,
-1.0164319277,
0.1540423632,
-0.2857855856,
0.2750943005,
0.3432114422,
-0.4387367666,
-0.4531431496,
-0.2865094841,
-0.1350459903,
0.3977691233,
0.4461351037,
-0.8550409675,
0.4769269526,
0.0413477123,
-0.1870123297,
-0.5807425976,
-0.7603846788,
0.2744916975,
-0.3891381919,
-0.3933716714,
0.6224551201,
-0.2337820828,
-0.3310192525,
-0.2774523199,
-0.3385273218,
-0.30513978,
0.1131927669,
-0.1219030395,
0.3531009555,
-0.1379667819,
0.3158150613,
0.3160725534,
0.0171350911,
-0.0288548581,
-0.6085799336,
0.4451228082,
-0.2506186366,
0.1093272865,
-0.7471256852,
0.2956047952,
0.6104565859,
-0.2466435432,
0.5991412997,
0.5082857609,
0.0393707752,
-0.8349511623,
-0.5458536744,
-0.2736899853,
-0.4882305861,
0.048209656,
-0.5113370419,
-0.83230865,
0.4412761033,
-0.4550545216,
-0.0023040844,
0.3396289051,
0.2877518535,
-0.1727537215,
0.4976378679,
0.6710209846,
0.0493939035,
0.6893694997,
-0.2355808318,
0.097083874,
-0.9751243591,
0.0466610156,
-0.444984436,
-0.6227707863,
-0.5624570847,
-0.182120949,
0.2553850114,
-0.1515927464,
-0.0775383487,
0.4942310452,
-0.5672138333,
0.8704590797,
0.552638948,
0.3464986384,
0.4843333364,
0.0680368245,
-0.0144742085,
0.1098794714,
-0.5478026867,
-0.3434388041,
1.0905860662,
0.0687726885,
1.1768382788,
0.0254978854,
0.8933896422,
0.4090662897,
0.3228852153,
-0.6910165548,
0.3896086216,
-0.607414186,
-0.2598869205,
-0.1583228707,
-0.2879201174,
-0.6491273642,
-0.056416858,
-0.2275090367,
-0.8134349585,
0.2598594427,
0.1636864245,
-0.2855140865,
0.3753613532,
-0.6081502438,
0.6528030634,
-0.2395409346,
-0.7607120275,
-0.05704524,
-0.4768990278,
0.4701352715,
-0.2121389508,
0.1824522465,
-0.1206387728,
0.0220459849,
0.6868087649,
-0.6549562812,
0.9774802923,
0.4761052728,
-0.3461012244,
0.4986497164,
0.5115454197,
0.4871851802,
-0.0463806354,
-0.1490575373,
0.0745207518,
0.1037640795,
-0.1016944498,
-0.9465597272,
1.01042521,
-0.705406487,
-0.5616062284,
-0.219783023,
-0.6295891404,
-0.2167979479,
0.1787492037,
0.2779988348,
0.939478755,
-0.0003976208,
0.1805315763,
0.7069553137,
0.0444796197,
0.5535053015,
0.3939552009,
-0.2358300835,
-0.2277888507,
0.8820031881,
0.1260775328,
0.670224309,
0.5033883452,
0.5617488027,
-0.6245592237,
-0.4733564854,
-0.443782419,
0.1993242055,
-0.7407842875,
-0.1326874197,
-0.4759212732,
-0.2917055786,
-0.3166549206,
-0.4310561419,
-0.4267016947,
-0.6404064894,
-0.2688131034,
-0.0491233245,
0.5860584974,
1.0478440523,
0.0395284444,
0.5640727878,
-0.5684633851,
0.2554316223,
0.4500110745,
0.3995272517,
-0.1361857057,
-0.6525949836,
-0.0272754654,
-0.0378877632,
-0.1788983196,
-0.8989089131,
0.3838948011,
0.1897173375,
0.1555178761,
0.081931822,
0.366581738,
0.7271542549,
-0.5089467764,
0.5664730668,
0.2638835609,
-1.2132279873,
0.6624804735,
-0.220795244,
0.3382636607,
0.6385561228,
0.2614741623,
-0.8060839176,
-0.0877913088,
-0.5217585564,
-0.671818018,
0.7296005487,
0.2250920534,
-0.2539609969,
0.0888426974,
0.6704806685,
0.3157491982,
0.1268940866,
-0.5897649527,
-0.2089075148,
-0.4169721901,
-0.420851022,
-0.0573256128,
-0.1573585421,
-0.1160234734,
-0.0549710989,
0.5367143154,
-0.2333470583,
-0.0689546689,
0.3958360255,
-0.3474140167,
0.274454087,
0.501868844,
0.6251402497,
0.7822067738,
0.0632388294,
0.5938892365,
0.0986467898,
-0.2385133803,
0.1164231673,
-0.2797938883,
-0.1307579279,
-0.1014005691,
0.2429869026,
0.807020247,
0.1397977173,
-0.1449674815,
0.3582962751,
-0.31516096,
-0.2423868328,
0.1344633549,
-0.0452986509,
-0.1003450677,
0.0228186231,
0.0391178094,
-0.0895482153,
0.2278531641,
-0.5716364384,
0.3158516288,
0.1912870854,
-0.5284098387,
-0.2246244103,
0.464055419,
0.4031796753,
-0.0228307303,
0.3544309139,
0.1736352891,
-0.3851570487,
0.6205599904,
0.7791047692,
1.0298477411,
-0.1169263944,
0.4239412546,
0.4316045642,
0.3018873334,
-0.344227761,
-0.0618896373,
-0.3850646615,
-0.4513153732,
-0.44007653,
-0.7099815607,
-0.3827012777,
0.0891325101,
-0.6261797547,
0.3062911034,
-0.5683779716,
0.0610814318,
0.0108588524,
-0.3299759626,
-0.6260018349,
0.0154906036,
0.0509140193,
0.9158887267,
-0.8959835768,
0.8494479656,
0.3725272417,
-0.1715888381,
-0.7979977131,
0.2329854071,
0.0980005041,
-0.8812612295,
0.7532681227,
0.0275588445,
-0.5564264059,
0.2447669655,
-0.6446963549,
-0.8455544114,
1.1168786287,
0.3628448546,
-0.9699469209,
0.2106786668,
0.1000648662,
0.4443185925,
-0.2890406251,
0.1293715239,
0.8824384809,
0.3459152877,
0.3915752172,
-1.0952973366,
0.2293311357,
0.2170386165,
0.2087554783,
0.0621268228,
-0.6519969702,
0.7475779653,
-0.068648465,
-0.3804148138,
0.0160439499,
0.7051122189,
-0.2308258116,
0.2187128812,
0.3146569431,
0.246018365,
0.7641459107,
-0.270303309,
1.0004040003,
-0.2751559913,
0.3200995624,
1.4781630039,
-0.2225825936,
0.5412167311,
0.43892169,
-0.0957249552,
0.9200805426,
0.557693541,
0.57057935,
0.4611052573,
0.2197993696,
-0.2062381804,
-0.3888348341,
-0.2740855515,
-0.1736764908,
0.3264597356,
0.2354150414,
-0.3194924891,
-0.3654921055,
0.0490311161,
0.1693037003,
0.4709922373,
-0.5195216537,
1.0089902878,
0.3424135447,
-0.822871089,
0.6291295886,
-0.3268758357,
0.5364980102,
-0.5482958555,
-0.0669860542,
-0.3480986655,
0.285895735,
-0.1351886839,
-1.1872509718,
0.2116285712,
-0.1673688143,
-0.0782491118,
-0.7987039089,
0.9316891432,
-0.6941198111,
-0.529512763,
0.0914030001,
0.5260189176,
-0.0204014834,
-0.1219999343,
-0.6786025763,
0.1096230447,
-0.0661670193,
0.1269506663,
0.2829087973,
0.8939762712,
-0.0604082681,
0.6156161427,
0.4003730118,
-0.1209246218,
-0.2969118953,
0.1821392626,
0.7963546515,
-0.4773133993,
-0.5075529218,
-1.1766186953,
0.2581892014,
-0.3714368045,
-0.1231513247,
0.735571444,
0.2300761044,
0.5165476799,
-0.0782213584,
1.0300414562,
0.1799963415,
0.2525641322,
-0.7674789429,
0.7215164304,
-0.5162760615,
0.1688922644,
-0.3711734712,
-0.7437437177,
-0.0393290296,
0.4789640903,
-0.3190056086,
-0.0829691663,
1.0400196314,
0.4806814492,
-0.0884416476,
0.2493612319,
0.1900557578,
0.3270378411,
0.2380762547,
0.4383603036,
0.7224491239,
-0.0087192748,
0.27981776,
-0.5446704626,
-0.5081005096,
-0.0401322022,
-1.2950980663,
-1.2203059196,
-0.7289307117,
-0.5019493103,
-0.4680995047,
0.1386239082,
0.9719027877,
0.6520759463,
-0.5460733175,
-0.3977398574,
-0.26066944,
0.3261133432,
-0.4721438885,
-0.1949059367,
0.4418114424,
-0.4212990701,
-0.7643421888,
0.3337799311,
0.4007971883,
0.1877202094,
-0.212680012,
0.2847500741,
-0.0107660918,
0.1633675545,
0.8171150088,
0.1067117155,
-0.5308315754,
-0.251740545,
-0.0759832114,
-0.051388815,
0.0381309837,
1.2015346289,
-0.6913238764,
0.5461673737,
0.4468145072,
0.4287448227,
0.5862475634,
0.0629283786,
0.7047162056,
-0.9451198578,
-0.1596986651,
-0.1564498842,
0.3668573797,
0.2457721382,
-0.4035157859,
0.3939084113,
0.2988728583,
-0.4576248825,
-0.4387149811,
0.3881253302,
-1.1821364164,
-0.5453621149,
1.3750238419,
0.0370473228,
-0.5322636962,
-0.2509078681,
-0.5851522684,
0.0608232692,
-0.3809268475,
0.7234979868,
0.5235808492,
-0.0959470198,
-0.3149768412,
-0.1679325104,
0.8180636764,
0.0200085584,
-0.9616667032,
0.4931627512,
0.2292340845,
0.4830049276,
-0.2780751288,
0.55655092,
0.0200801566,
0.042329587,
-0.4151721895,
-0.0622534454,
-0.159168154,
-0.4423342049,
0.0219441224,
-0.1333866119,
-0.2501701117,
0.1536149383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01081v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01081v3
|
LAB: Large-Scale Alignment for ChatBots
| 2024-03-02T03:48:37 | 2024-04-29T18:55:34 |
Shivchander Sudalairaj, Abhishek Bhandwaldar, Aldo Pareja, Kai Xu, David D. Cox, Akash Srivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work introduces LAB (Large-scale Alignment for chatBots), a novel
methodology designed to overcome the scalability challenges in the
instruction-tuning phase of large language model (LLM) training. Leveraging a
taxonomy-guided synthetic data generation process and a multi-phase tuning
framework, LAB significantly reduces reliance on expensive human annotations
and proprietary models like GPT-4. We demonstrate that LAB-trained models can
achieve competitive performance across several benchmarks compared to models
trained with traditional human-annotated or GPT-4 generated synthetic data.
Thus offering a scalable, cost-effective solution for enhancing LLM
capabilities and instruction-following behaviors without the drawbacks of
catastrophic forgetting, marking a step forward in the efficient training of
LLMs for a wide range of applications.
|
[
-0.0369772688,
-0.9662116766,
0.3859359324,
-0.0555434525,
0.1431040317,
0.7189637423,
-0.1921182573,
-0.1356152594,
-0.0626216978,
0.5375671387,
-0.6664792895,
-0.4074425995,
-0.3471992612,
0.0032876758,
-0.5664816499,
1.0069899559,
0.1823706925,
0.0970937088,
-0.1621926725,
-0.0583427586,
-0.6025231481,
-0.5049270391,
-0.9801514745,
-0.3092396855,
0.6254997253,
0.5637649298,
0.7324714661,
0.8613789082,
0.5410601497,
0.3922828138,
0.0799414366,
0.3219731152,
-0.8026605844,
0.067868948,
0.0352539495,
-0.6073790789,
-0.6984273791,
-0.0444980375,
0.801699996,
0.4870483279,
-0.2655344307,
0.0989600345,
-0.1998676062,
0.8325207233,
-0.2775846422,
0.1782954186,
-0.9326159358,
0.0151523249,
-0.0367574915,
-0.220508486,
-0.7308342457,
-0.300945431,
-0.0282694753,
-0.5906254649,
0.4423511326,
0.3674628139,
0.7762915492,
0.4525026679,
-0.3566851318,
0.0436330289,
-0.7010175586,
0.7495363951,
-0.6016290188,
0.360331893,
0.061877165,
0.5934739113,
-0.4435620606,
-0.5715402365,
-0.7861965299,
0.0020837362,
0.1583987325,
0.0592668653,
0.1771549284,
0.1805907339,
0.3066062927,
0.1783725321,
-0.610850513,
0.3970767856,
-0.3968263566,
-0.3057200313,
0.6687492132,
0.2682214081,
0.2196099162,
0.3704444468,
-0.0424645916,
-0.2882444263,
-0.7927892208,
-0.2554859221,
0.2992520332,
0.5254993439,
-0.1363334954,
0.6982944012,
-0.0920631886,
0.6657480597,
0.2431231737,
-0.2117489576,
0.4195402563,
-0.3191311657,
-0.1906473488,
0.2545431256,
0.970882833,
0.2172799706,
0.1972932518,
-0.198706463,
-0.0342201404,
-0.1745584607,
0.4643049836,
-0.7302080989,
-0.3301821649,
0.3664913476,
0.1119708121,
-0.3597809374,
-0.4334323704,
-0.7596921921,
-0.5916341543,
-0.6065109968,
0.5035155416,
-0.5158673525,
0.0290862527,
-0.180326432,
-0.0657281503,
0.4538274407,
0.4484903216,
-1.2305202484,
0.1010164246,
0.8721072674,
0.9423804879,
-0.1837280989,
-0.2347872406,
-0.6637657881,
0.2147709578,
-0.5520026684,
0.4700425565,
-0.5131988525,
-0.2329205275,
0.0272468738,
0.0691702887,
0.0076911668,
-0.477968812,
0.1145147681,
-0.51047647,
0.0566613264,
0.217016384,
-0.7639064789,
0.1185883358,
0.3279640675,
-0.4723965824,
1.0891430378,
0.1378072351,
-0.4287185073,
0.1575906575,
-0.5437402725,
-0.4428649843,
0.1977285892,
-0.1601820737,
-0.571803987,
-0.2496636808,
0.2250350118,
0.5049521923,
-0.3453088403,
0.2623354793,
-0.110169962,
-0.2081542015,
0.3341352046,
-0.1590178609,
0.3446729481,
-0.06940189,
-0.2722641528,
0.7108346224,
-1.007109046,
-0.0859547779,
-0.0446006097,
-0.2587669194,
0.0809175596,
0.1441659629,
-0.1923996359,
0.1253040433,
0.4019946456,
-0.6449103951,
0.2870259583,
-0.4170179367,
0.7677889466,
0.9105378985,
-0.3891789913,
0.6410494447,
-0.2260624617,
0.5706977248,
-0.2062697411,
0.2007093579,
-0.2212448567,
-0.4577097595,
-0.8488985896,
-0.4824216962,
0.2882751226,
0.6393505335,
-0.6352472901,
0.6345840693,
-0.4302648306,
-0.7877327204,
-0.6000035405,
0.3439207673,
0.4267804325,
0.6461569667,
0.3228366673,
-0.0063172602,
-0.4926300645,
-1.0092067719,
0.1804804951,
0.2006345838,
-0.1721617877,
0.1532920003,
0.4763072431,
-0.4151357412,
0.9134151936,
-0.4673154354,
-0.1993937343,
-0.2382037193,
0.1979591548,
0.1071969122,
0.6175951958,
0.1080843955,
-0.5831494927,
-0.5593022704,
0.2652831674,
-0.3414450586,
0.0300510246,
-0.1314277947,
-0.5016671419,
0.3505555093,
0.8969199061,
-0.6283544898,
-0.005909482,
0.8662593365,
0.0729188845,
0.4824460149,
-0.2966814935,
-0.004667392,
-1.2522569895,
-0.0216056537,
-0.0956750512,
-0.4694985747,
-0.6254442334,
-0.1719194055,
0.3338931203,
-0.1909645498,
-0.2956044674,
0.5735923052,
-0.2065483928,
0.120336175,
-0.2525953054,
0.4055089951,
-0.1268724054,
0.5073230267,
-0.1078033224,
1.0194057226,
0.4579182267,
-0.4434357584,
0.5161079764,
0.3209736645,
-0.0803988054,
0.5593925714,
-0.6133160591,
0.3328239322,
0.0133755645,
0.5582069159,
-1.1320607662,
-0.6337760687,
-0.0115267914,
-0.4483026862,
0.5529244542,
-0.0374967642,
-0.8469957113,
-0.3697661757,
-0.2153562158,
0.2828322053,
0.7507069111,
-0.5853686929,
0.747066915,
0.420512557,
0.0142322509,
-0.5663312674,
-0.3089384139,
-0.0807182789,
-0.278139621,
-0.443426609,
0.1561572552,
-0.0452864282,
0.217076242,
-0.5792270899,
0.0032459288,
0.0756053329,
-0.0068535721,
0.2640708089,
0.4714689255,
-0.138176322,
0.3516428471,
-0.0896270797,
0.0551177971,
-0.127025038,
-0.129094243,
0.8833451271,
0.0711270198,
-0.2032507956,
-0.5552964807,
0.0174879804,
0.6505606174,
-0.0545399375,
0.9040942192,
0.6462203264,
-0.0600102246,
-0.2075272948,
-0.5732375979,
-0.1254368871,
-0.5602463484,
0.5604243279,
-0.0113993334,
-1.1217559576,
0.4067919254,
-0.188862592,
0.3808264732,
0.3621791601,
0.71106112,
-0.2349736392,
1.4151732922,
0.5202764869,
-0.1160692573,
0.5773680806,
0.160555914,
0.3805575073,
-0.9609183073,
-0.1201959699,
-0.5725470781,
-0.5047774315,
-0.7323932648,
-0.6200749278,
0.4369816482,
-0.200231418,
-0.8485566974,
0.3136755228,
-0.7475566268,
0.5828009248,
0.6797302365,
0.094845213,
0.05890394,
-0.259871304,
0.2256927043,
0.2338941395,
-0.6765555739,
-0.4161062837,
1.2766736746,
0.2424456924,
0.58764112,
0.1506066769,
0.462000668,
-0.1471727341,
0.3762642443,
-0.8740319014,
0.5861746073,
-0.0228139963,
-0.7907530665,
-0.723508954,
-0.4898890853,
-1.1544674635,
0.1189168841,
-0.2931895554,
-1.0551408529,
-0.6163928509,
0.3685203493,
-0.1925406456,
0.1560790092,
-0.8190359473,
0.9026395082,
-0.2781741917,
-0.3150763512,
-0.2889607549,
-0.8348866105,
0.4404337406,
-0.5450200438,
0.2965537012,
-0.2002451569,
0.109270826,
0.6796334386,
-0.432320863,
1.0255521536,
0.1239850447,
-0.2672207654,
0.0049573975,
-0.088893488,
0.5671980977,
-0.0810891986,
0.1589048654,
-0.114968434,
0.0088863485,
-0.4846277237,
-0.5096494555,
0.6566867828,
-0.9555566907,
-0.6904143691,
-0.235199824,
-1.0265479088,
-0.6268794537,
0.1623729914,
-0.0514631569,
0.2557636201,
-0.1520739198,
0.3997150064,
0.8086070418,
-0.5818266273,
0.1850585938,
0.3654097915,
-0.3554846346,
-0.3741141856,
0.9191464782,
-0.3135550022,
0.7392229438,
0.660648942,
0.1871617138,
-0.2207586914,
-0.3535249233,
-0.5247814655,
0.2108784169,
-0.4711034298,
-0.2674908936,
-0.5824635029,
-0.4414803982,
-0.5161132812,
-0.4808004797,
-0.6516144872,
-0.3202679455,
-0.2103157043,
0.104111135,
0.65201056,
0.3322823346,
0.3379958868,
0.7392775416,
-0.9547998905,
0.2736642361,
0.3285164833,
0.2144933641,
-0.1426637024,
-0.6105969548,
-0.2743287981,
0.1203741431,
-0.5682729483,
-0.3482806087,
0.3497162163,
0.3061352372,
0.2617281377,
0.1653879583,
-0.3025924265,
0.7972640991,
-0.8767303228,
0.7600508928,
0.3606996834,
-0.9168912768,
0.6439193487,
-0.5729673505,
0.602760613,
0.4338593781,
0.2852954268,
-0.4877734482,
-0.5005345345,
-0.4833023846,
-0.9916390181,
0.7805003524,
0.0913218185,
0.3448714614,
0.1679941714,
0.380087018,
0.1075281799,
0.3035622239,
-0.4913501441,
-0.1455185115,
0.0303788669,
-0.6444491148,
-0.4373824298,
0.1219185293,
-0.4020170271,
-0.3906270266,
0.8152543306,
-0.4215450585,
0.0782034621,
-0.368231684,
0.1056551561,
-0.0455479696,
0.1244186983,
0.5406873822,
0.5193771124,
-0.20883964,
-0.1993184686,
0.1529406607,
-0.4742273986,
0.2165699452,
-0.0752782747,
0.0811303332,
-0.3976568878,
0.2001784891,
0.7148111463,
0.4365137517,
-0.9395936728,
0.2536498606,
0.0147904968,
-0.2739091218,
-0.2368333638,
0.4276948273,
0.3815888464,
0.316119194,
0.0902067721,
-0.343639642,
-0.2596718371,
-0.668292582,
0.025599679,
0.5949823856,
-0.2141439766,
-0.1571504325,
0.7521011829,
0.2132182866,
-0.6044424772,
0.8761371374,
-0.0806141719,
-0.4013966322,
0.7333329916,
0.6301931739,
0.6453579068,
-0.2101771683,
0.2348026931,
0.5864551067,
0.0209221039,
-0.2688251138,
-0.0277069546,
0.2078482062,
-0.7619533539,
-0.5406768918,
-0.7376826406,
-0.8079764247,
0.0666407123,
-0.3429234326,
0.4891579151,
-0.6085147858,
-0.0147428019,
0.3060206473,
-0.3118854165,
-0.5543814898,
0.0699547976,
0.1043487191,
0.537959218,
-0.5269509554,
1.0278052092,
0.4077672958,
-0.0711305067,
-0.9577453732,
-0.4159900844,
0.3216601908,
-0.9376137257,
0.5527786016,
0.2161611617,
-0.0138099995,
0.2221987545,
-0.7768492103,
-1.0521680117,
1.2166961432,
0.1463615149,
-1.1331989765,
-0.0656520873,
0.1921581924,
0.8121836185,
-0.3739513159,
-0.0004585547,
0.7913870215,
0.1436165571,
0.55534482,
-1.1433361769,
-0.0355222337,
0.0223583542,
-0.1457402259,
0.5388227701,
-0.8399795294,
0.722863555,
0.0408830419,
0.0039835479,
0.0693390369,
0.4217686057,
0.4026745856,
-0.0374723114,
0.3336473405,
0.3770057261,
1.0256514549,
-0.1269175857,
0.730720818,
-0.3765660524,
0.1087422296,
1.4228143692,
-0.4592687786,
0.8716638088,
0.2711746097,
-0.2257893682,
0.2922646105,
0.5456068516,
-0.1674877107,
0.2501603365,
0.4229606092,
-0.0379223302,
-0.1488698423,
0.2908465564,
-0.0934986025,
0.4809820652,
0.5790930986,
-0.1488742381,
0.1995666027,
-0.1954851747,
-0.0395509042,
-0.1364770383,
-0.2728734016,
0.804376781,
-0.1316895187,
-0.7099347115,
0.6515566707,
-0.4218002856,
0.6232830286,
-0.5831929445,
0.1298470199,
0.0142930718,
0.2992369831,
-0.0889206752,
-0.6351404786,
0.0322655402,
-0.0654968619,
0.1534909159,
-0.142143026,
0.1921280175,
-0.3618252873,
-0.5365694761,
-0.1014283597,
0.2632998228,
0.0737770274,
0.1553091854,
-0.6083492637,
-0.0676918477,
-0.096234791,
-0.1201702654,
0.5808329582,
0.5443691611,
-0.109218508,
0.877591908,
0.5851665139,
-0.1208079532,
0.1526415497,
0.2163640857,
0.6987181902,
-0.6651997566,
-0.0398457833,
-0.8600449562,
0.373336941,
-0.2151033282,
-0.2232081741,
0.6012502909,
0.6187888384,
0.6870374084,
0.1120086908,
0.7213440537,
0.0778806061,
0.4807510376,
-0.5064798594,
0.4367853403,
-0.3983328938,
0.1068585664,
-0.1425653994,
-0.9735600948,
-0.3747715354,
0.3626344502,
-0.0859541297,
-0.1260099709,
0.6555649638,
0.9731809497,
0.1262637377,
0.0251497496,
0.2997457683,
0.3100716174,
0.5988643169,
0.464199841,
0.7420488,
-0.160745129,
0.4464356303,
-0.0467187688,
-0.2864646018,
-0.2339302897,
-0.6693711281,
-1.1596488953,
-0.6205032468,
-0.4820222855,
-0.2754583359,
-0.2138806581,
0.9799738526,
0.7171004415,
-0.7099354863,
-0.1330126971,
-0.1974046379,
-0.1721093357,
-0.04345157,
-0.1873108298,
0.2687790394,
-0.7708601356,
-0.9618993402,
0.2946853638,
0.2817543149,
0.1391662508,
-0.2703474462,
0.1174501851,
-0.2500859499,
0.2068118155,
0.6855107546,
0.3085528612,
-0.629925251,
-0.4584240615,
0.010444819,
-0.2467264682,
0.4032962918,
0.4630292058,
-0.4913084209,
0.5044752359,
0.2446981072,
0.7529594898,
0.5667749047,
0.0434361026,
0.8840847015,
-0.9406626821,
0.1751243323,
0.1227109134,
0.1989866793,
0.4055289626,
-0.2819370329,
0.5759289265,
-0.2980861068,
-1.0316251516,
-0.7758128643,
0.1065602005,
-1.2535783052,
-0.1000942215,
1.2808632851,
0.1897213012,
-0.3538703322,
0.0356535614,
-0.4712284803,
0.4690444469,
-0.3498426974,
1.0452359915,
0.7821218967,
-0.2518110275,
-0.0947664827,
-0.7660797834,
0.4772008955,
0.3074187934,
-0.9312974215,
0.2185401618,
0.6798189878,
0.1989891231,
0.1899329424,
0.3585686088,
-0.0084190257,
0.0294924714,
-0.0243404116,
0.2818666995,
0.3244213462,
-0.0470966324,
-0.0851226747,
-0.0598499142,
0.1162611544,
-0.1768308878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01069v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01069v2
|
LLMCRIT: Teaching Large Language Models to Use Criteria
| 2024-03-02T02:25:55 | 2024-06-04T15:30:20 |
Weizhe Yuan, Pengfei Liu, Matthias Gallé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans follow criteria when they execute tasks, and these criteria are
directly used to assess the quality of task completion. Therefore, having
models learn to use criteria to provide feedback can help humans or models to
perform tasks better. However, existing research in this field tends to
consider only a limited set of criteria or quality assessment aspects. To fill
this gap, we propose a general framework that enables large language models
(LLMs) to use comprehensive criteria for a task in delivering natural language
feedback on task execution. In particular, we present a model-in-the-loop
framework that semi-automatically derives criteria from collected guidelines
for different writing tasks and constructs in-context demonstrations for each
criterion. We choose three tasks from real-world scenarios to operationalize
this idea: paper introduction writing, Python code writing, and Reddit post
writing, and evaluate our feedback generation framework using different LLMs.
The results reveal the fine-grained effects of incorporating criteria and
demonstrations and provide valuable insights on how to teach LLMs to use
criteria more effectively.
|
[
-0.1793827862,
-0.8507620096,
0.7877266407,
0.222644791,
-0.3741695285,
-0.1700477153,
-0.5121176839,
-0.3501285911,
-0.1208560169,
0.7947546244,
-0.3798404932,
-0.5866752863,
-0.2583515942,
0.1168353707,
-0.6794752479,
1.1533893347,
-0.3608264625,
0.0070081633,
-0.4171190262,
0.2379296273,
-0.5455770493,
-0.6081932187,
-0.6451883912,
-0.5193042159,
0.5784268379,
0.6007403731,
0.2639154494,
0.1915008873,
0.5723487735,
0.2610858679,
0.2016410977,
0.4430693984,
-0.2811491191,
0.0985252783,
-0.3120277226,
-0.5002081394,
-0.3352896273,
0.1137521639,
0.7011278272,
0.738006711,
-0.2760986686,
0.317987293,
0.3438350856,
0.3458096683,
-0.3266526163,
0.1399742365,
-0.4455449283,
0.0177408513,
0.0144294882,
-0.3506399393,
-0.541697979,
-0.6708102822,
-0.0121130142,
-0.4821282923,
0.0189265907,
-0.0218927711,
0.6741148233,
-0.0081437035,
-0.3624926805,
-0.7488073111,
-0.7091645002,
0.7753018141,
-0.895732224,
-0.083418332,
0.515178442,
0.3164657652,
-0.086241141,
-0.6473628879,
-0.6086688042,
-0.8974622488,
-0.0905114636,
-0.1644571275,
0.2384896874,
0.0918953866,
0.4175569117,
0.3423537314,
-0.2135932893,
0.1780379266,
-0.3643788397,
-0.1573816985,
0.5583981276,
0.2525992095,
0.1688271463,
-0.1909669489,
-0.0204537213,
0.2207347304,
-0.7779273391,
0.0943279043,
0.3869838715,
0.5102701783,
-0.2741906345,
0.7920055985,
-0.2799071372,
0.9892019629,
0.0107595799,
-0.2557302713,
-0.281506598,
-0.4299628437,
-0.1511461139,
-0.3645250797,
0.6937923431,
0.4157703519,
0.2955241501,
-0.2041003406,
-0.5311927199,
0.2590293288,
0.462608844,
-0.7904279232,
0.0624278486,
-0.0890586153,
-0.4110050499,
-0.3115638494,
0.064540796,
-0.7290042639,
-0.4524797201,
-0.9108121991,
0.5065012574,
-0.1077983528,
-0.1005927101,
0.0252440646,
0.0812604427,
0.2060043216,
0.4948663116,
-0.7270982862,
0.4017851055,
0.7088491917,
0.8046290278,
-0.3025992513,
-0.349750191,
-0.9151781797,
0.0001654312,
-0.3771916032,
0.7552124858,
-0.8323099017,
-0.277751565,
0.2358824909,
-0.1164544895,
0.0551063828,
-0.5393100381,
0.5479648709,
-0.1027088612,
0.316725105,
-0.2052267939,
-0.6582742333,
-0.0736584067,
0.3193860352,
-0.3017704189,
0.9159263372,
0.3022340536,
-0.5349562168,
0.4580810368,
-0.7522004247,
-0.621568203,
0.0657768846,
0.0166126844,
-0.1115682498,
0.3605270684,
0.0812245607,
0.7543272972,
-0.4494713545,
0.4842176437,
-0.1363449395,
-0.4499139786,
0.3057774901,
-0.2377332449,
0.2075483054,
0.2390491217,
-0.3865916431,
0.5119926333,
-0.625246346,
0.1068874821,
-0.2635335326,
-0.753447175,
-0.0324272178,
-0.0444712751,
0.1431179941,
0.1402966827,
-0.1106007323,
-0.3456674218,
0.269050777,
-0.2166895121,
0.7237395644,
0.3895421326,
0.0967173353,
0.4197746515,
-0.6298713684,
0.7210860848,
-0.2811174095,
-0.0588320084,
-0.1298542619,
-0.1120380014,
-0.9807958603,
-0.0786732957,
0.262426883,
0.2787037194,
-0.7671039701,
0.4974374771,
-0.0124540627,
-0.5712249875,
-0.4327327609,
0.6709560156,
0.4564562142,
0.3693563938,
-0.054717727,
-0.4622643888,
-0.5249207616,
-0.612416327,
0.0860257745,
-0.1762830615,
-0.0958231241,
0.1051887944,
0.5721874237,
-0.2338714153,
0.6819238663,
-0.0391024165,
-0.244089514,
-0.7080652714,
0.1740823388,
0.349000901,
0.4053553641,
0.2657531798,
-0.3514672518,
-0.3238846362,
-0.1276549697,
-0.671889782,
-0.2510568202,
-0.3887562752,
-0.3334502578,
0.340898484,
0.453653872,
-0.5798736811,
0.1498006135,
0.4778916836,
-0.1161341071,
0.7106723785,
-0.3109010756,
0.2276743203,
-0.9005437493,
0.1642978042,
0.269677043,
-0.4220384955,
-0.4169785082,
0.3182438314,
-0.0420013778,
-0.2268873602,
-0.3151983917,
0.4426660538,
-0.2533090711,
0.105160743,
-0.4602986574,
0.2019025832,
0.0559471771,
0.362739265,
0.1042419598,
0.6301656365,
0.4076906741,
-0.8397935033,
0.293220073,
-0.0717132092,
-0.8026775122,
0.8245325089,
-0.7074049115,
0.2125295252,
0.0123455273,
0.3394181728,
-0.6941198111,
-0.3165206313,
0.0652270541,
-0.2177400589,
0.3955984414,
-0.036522653,
-0.7217030525,
-0.580221951,
-0.1654949337,
-0.1748524606,
0.4215790629,
-0.3483282626,
0.3312810361,
0.322727263,
-0.0483547673,
-0.1140489951,
-0.5237733126,
0.180837661,
-0.2373575568,
-0.3086595535,
0.0571093597,
-0.1874391735,
-0.229678601,
-0.1382861882,
0.1468430459,
0.0921751708,
0.2702773511,
0.329898566,
0.1687106788,
-0.0121005997,
0.0883766115,
-0.2062701732,
0.0739468187,
0.1681962907,
-0.2756635547,
0.6116671562,
0.0369885564,
-0.5936535001,
-0.6685500741,
0.4001727104,
0.6246071458,
-0.2572845221,
0.3067833483,
0.5493435264,
-0.3104987442,
-0.5037853122,
-0.6529849768,
-0.2067391872,
-0.4388340712,
0.4196252525,
-0.1522612125,
-1.0844808817,
0.1422814727,
0.0630706847,
0.3371058106,
0.1955320835,
0.9737119079,
-0.1664990038,
0.8634089828,
0.7531439066,
-0.082211107,
0.3951310515,
-0.208048597,
0.402069509,
-0.9875574708,
-0.048535645,
-0.5383482575,
-0.0462329686,
-0.1413129568,
-0.6185947657,
0.0647086948,
0.2918433249,
-0.2204673588,
0.3175213635,
-0.5725724101,
0.4231928885,
0.6027418375,
0.0229850728,
0.021088019,
0.0117274821,
-0.3533667624,
0.0920398682,
-0.5616188645,
-0.9950509667,
0.941100955,
0.2815644145,
0.9083015919,
-0.1991583556,
0.7367210984,
0.5476469994,
0.7500932217,
-0.8731940985,
0.6835184693,
0.0255890694,
-0.4274765849,
-0.1905151159,
-0.4508158565,
-0.5893552899,
0.0259056352,
-0.0702968463,
-0.6943389773,
-0.4415076077,
0.2351187766,
-0.4062312245,
0.1688022912,
-0.6272032261,
0.7135094404,
-0.3692015111,
-0.4096877277,
-0.2465569675,
-0.1964883208,
0.4502424002,
-0.0470719747,
0.2900609374,
-0.078628473,
0.259588629,
0.7140218616,
-0.3802922368,
1.3604066372,
-0.2714234889,
-0.3929304481,
0.690656662,
0.2012231797,
0.4803606272,
0.0785849914,
-0.3239668012,
-0.4615762234,
0.0181683376,
-0.0271642692,
-0.5776167512,
0.695928216,
-0.4234115779,
-0.6548062563,
-0.0671921372,
-0.57011801,
-0.2555704713,
-0.0387593359,
0.0216748044,
0.6688418388,
0.0513703711,
0.1654982269,
0.0949534625,
-0.2049946487,
0.3017772734,
0.5391598344,
-0.3078031242,
-0.2080589533,
0.9194470644,
-0.0725648552,
0.4350776374,
0.2789373994,
0.2249924392,
-0.2613164186,
-0.603087008,
-0.4380154908,
0.31392923,
-0.9497668147,
-0.2432747185,
-0.3435151875,
-0.0943050981,
-0.3291801214,
-0.2966967523,
0.0939000621,
-0.2080956995,
-0.2450795174,
-0.0161062982,
0.0481321663,
0.984182179,
0.1962603778,
0.2792495787,
-0.8089460135,
0.1043967679,
0.3206963241,
0.2680952549,
0.3380101323,
-0.7658621073,
-0.2211889774,
0.1184498146,
-0.5061747432,
-0.4441177547,
0.3424023986,
0.3234269619,
0.8057011366,
0.2234895974,
-0.035152033,
0.5654557943,
-0.3985828757,
0.8967629075,
0.1676072031,
-1.2042609453,
0.7950260639,
-0.4058381617,
0.3608413637,
0.5111460686,
0.2839208543,
-0.7611505389,
-0.7542527318,
-0.0210121181,
-0.6009321213,
0.5128087401,
0.0492887795,
0.4855525792,
-0.0077286381,
0.6798505783,
0.2289147973,
0.406029135,
-0.8428671956,
0.3757326901,
-0.0172765944,
-0.3929339647,
-0.0910182372,
-0.3811111152,
-0.1601597667,
-0.3566164672,
0.5642161369,
-0.3682880998,
0.2654154301,
0.1580086052,
-0.4073676169,
-0.1464261562,
0.4397716522,
0.7888404131,
1.1684755087,
0.0673864558,
0.074824065,
0.1577255577,
-0.0401891135,
0.0915003791,
-0.2155219018,
-0.1962748766,
-0.1694976389,
0.691881299,
0.7345951796,
0.4152477086,
-0.8637473583,
0.2809453011,
0.086406827,
-0.4006736279,
-0.1388223171,
0.3502446115,
0.1658602059,
0.1051591709,
0.018690059,
-0.4387559295,
-0.0137571013,
-0.8330440521,
0.2236659229,
0.2726622522,
-0.6068760753,
-0.332542032,
0.4345312417,
0.3572023809,
-0.4007332325,
0.5462502837,
-0.3146738112,
-0.6908437014,
0.6104519367,
0.6411038637,
0.6317533851,
0.1282025874,
0.395697087,
0.4966937006,
0.207493335,
-0.3000750244,
0.2989587486,
-0.3532850146,
-0.2600548863,
-0.7159054875,
-1.0876514912,
-0.6609131694,
-0.0787656531,
-0.5545197725,
0.3382914364,
-0.4878761768,
-0.1439938992,
0.0909440592,
0.1080083102,
-0.5955653191,
0.0294276923,
0.2511090934,
0.6192527413,
-0.6644468904,
0.8551183939,
0.7825695276,
-0.5019698143,
-0.9251029491,
-0.1591389924,
0.0041336678,
-0.5128438473,
0.7027809024,
0.349845022,
0.0902222991,
-0.3259013593,
-0.6908649206,
-0.5071538091,
0.6965966821,
0.211220488,
-0.6609475017,
0.0471850522,
0.1001264676,
0.7254874706,
-0.7356138825,
0.2962086201,
0.441747129,
0.5683287382,
0.1266080737,
-1.1105458736,
0.1334061325,
-0.2773435712,
-0.0039426018,
-0.0239022691,
-0.3563372493,
0.54018718,
-0.4317423999,
-0.1540670991,
0.3594399989,
0.5652318597,
0.2212516665,
0.0646047145,
0.5378875732,
0.4070103765,
0.7713221908,
-0.0435277224,
1.3329178095,
-0.1297252178,
0.250297755,
1.1751612425,
-0.5282608867,
0.9285879135,
0.3064542115,
-0.1153329089,
0.4723677337,
0.5495796204,
-0.1363242716,
0.2248167992,
0.8821758032,
0.0093653584,
-0.4554371536,
-0.3831299245,
0.0055449768,
0.3937547207,
0.2748872042,
-0.2982370853,
-0.1354300231,
0.1735608876,
0.031568937,
0.298463136,
-0.3596210182,
0.6479761004,
0.2049080282,
-1.1644341946,
0.5103821754,
0.053612221,
0.861867547,
-0.6340652108,
-0.253672272,
-0.1369432211,
0.2166692913,
-0.2290140241,
-0.7845340371,
0.38216874,
0.3045581877,
-0.2097034305,
-0.1731297076,
0.3736782968,
-0.5485574603,
-0.8019684553,
0.1099218056,
0.0542113185,
0.0887229592,
0.0642115101,
-0.3513824344,
0.1134376079,
-0.1463173777,
-0.0733201876,
0.2845433354,
0.3345839977,
-0.1206741706,
0.7687394619,
0.6181209683,
0.2936641276,
-0.1928129941,
0.572473526,
0.7138218284,
-0.5544492006,
-0.215956226,
-0.7176969647,
0.3734151125,
-0.1814183742,
-0.2405996174,
0.7817806602,
0.4038959444,
0.8598232269,
0.0427829251,
0.9293375611,
-0.135189414,
0.5405845642,
-0.6861894727,
0.655857563,
-0.5699924827,
0.3156204522,
-0.2270960212,
-1.12880826,
-0.3018912673,
0.6566334963,
-0.191435039,
0.1554417312,
0.8588023186,
0.7934600711,
0.075198628,
-0.1351929158,
0.3256036043,
-0.0366507061,
0.5842089653,
0.5996053815,
1.0891629457,
0.0828254819,
0.4443283975,
-0.2934824526,
-0.0547245368,
-0.1932349056,
-0.8981016278,
-1.233810544,
-0.5783926845,
-0.5263017416,
-0.3068842888,
0.0492290817,
1.0586389303,
0.8686594367,
-0.776047349,
-0.5176455975,
0.0777094141,
0.0643579438,
-0.0579586215,
-0.202617839,
0.1539196521,
-0.7698555589,
-0.6465485692,
0.1803542972,
0.2413231283,
-0.1949716955,
-0.4577189386,
-0.1067720577,
0.0000388447,
0.1147003174,
0.6792468429,
0.0093253329,
-0.7952402234,
-0.4337438643,
-0.2246333361,
-0.2496490479,
-0.2944507897,
1.2550904751,
-0.4000348747,
0.3196369112,
0.3901843727,
0.5450122952,
0.2534869313,
-0.2639599741,
0.7775535583,
-0.4643414617,
-0.1718895286,
0.1811681241,
0.2692125142,
0.6169290543,
-0.1304875612,
0.4091021121,
-0.0434733033,
-0.6288500428,
-0.9064413905,
0.0256368592,
-0.8741041422,
-0.046606414,
1.4758731127,
-0.2554341555,
-0.1859784722,
-0.0453759097,
-0.3952079415,
0.0782327056,
-0.2357643396,
0.871295929,
0.8658949733,
0.1203129813,
-0.1257043332,
-0.7564318776,
0.3387897313,
0.2516593635,
-1.053866744,
0.2250995487,
0.5051848292,
0.3212349415,
-0.1573541462,
0.5364390612,
-0.0310112964,
0.2749299705,
-0.3644322157,
0.0357471928,
0.0407843776,
-0.3438945413,
-0.2160093486,
0.2250655442,
0.5004028678,
0.3034698367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01063v1
|
FaiMA: Feature-aware In-context Learning for Multi-domain Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-02T02:00:51 | 2024-03-02T02:00:51 |
Songhua Yang, Xinke Jiang, Hanjie Zhao, Wenxuan Zeng, Hongde Liu, Yuxiang Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-domain aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) seeks to capture
fine-grained sentiment across diverse domains. While existing research narrowly
focuses on single-domain applications constrained by methodological limitations
and data scarcity, the reality is that sentiment naturally traverses multiple
domains. Although large language models (LLMs) offer a promising solution for
ABSA, it is difficult to integrate effectively with established techniques,
including graph-based models and linguistics, because modifying their internal
architecture is not easy. To alleviate this problem, we propose a novel
framework, Feature-aware In-context Learning for Multi-domain ABSA (FaiMA). The
core insight of FaiMA is to utilize in-context learning (ICL) as a
feature-aware mechanism that facilitates adaptive learning in multi-domain ABSA
tasks. Specifically, we employ a multi-head graph attention network as a text
encoder optimized by heuristic rules for linguistic, domain, and sentiment
features. Through contrastive learning, we optimize sentence representations by
focusing on these diverse features. Additionally, we construct an efficient
indexing mechanism, allowing FaiMA to stably retrieve highly relevant examples
across multiple dimensions for any given input. To evaluate the efficacy of
FaiMA, we build the first multi-domain ABSA benchmark dataset. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that FaiMA achieves significant performance
improvements in multiple domains compared to baselines, increasing F1 by 2.07%
on average. Source code and data sets are anonymously available at
https://github.com/SupritYoung/FaiMA.
|
[
-0.7546858788,
-0.6804010868,
0.2967189252,
0.4723367989,
-0.3489927351,
0.0874541923,
-0.2220298648,
-0.4550219476,
0.2836103439,
0.3913433552,
-0.4890477359,
-0.6839832664,
-0.6939560175,
0.1575310677,
-0.1698334813,
0.9627799392,
-0.1393089443,
-0.0202891752,
-0.5521443486,
-0.7370393276,
-0.3613986671,
-0.6695746183,
-0.3855953515,
-0.1512497663,
0.2501895726,
0.5897869468,
0.2598498762,
0.0929434747,
0.5412634611,
0.2386137992,
0.0758976266,
0.6081832647,
-0.3259163797,
0.1883280873,
-0.2143359631,
-0.030853454,
-0.5483159423,
-0.1620101035,
0.5821787715,
0.7457768321,
0.2613925338,
-0.0535484478,
0.3882104754,
0.8249013424,
-0.6690832376,
0.4739948511,
-0.6166300178,
-0.1898435056,
-0.1323538423,
-0.1320652217,
-0.2827052474,
-0.1485360116,
0.23335509,
-0.5300945044,
0.1085732803,
0.0331324041,
0.874802947,
0.1351624429,
-0.3340895176,
-0.3155283034,
-0.1556877643,
0.7834456563,
-0.4235491455,
0.4869590998,
0.3278881907,
-0.0582363829,
0.1181765124,
-0.5674377084,
-0.490018487,
0.3026905656,
-0.0853541493,
0.1165691838,
-0.0317221172,
-0.2047336251,
-0.2244307399,
0.4474562407,
-0.3611836433,
-0.2279151529,
0.0821626708,
-0.0086246002,
0.4926789701,
-0.0915758163,
0.0201511551,
0.0288092736,
-0.6193554401,
-0.0266247783,
-0.7641243935,
0.3269823194,
0.0471171774,
0.7804038525,
-0.3265811205,
-0.0659591705,
-0.2669411898,
0.4783222675,
0.0339842848,
-0.0525478125,
0.6280930042,
-0.0908024013,
-0.2970335782,
-0.088791512,
0.8981370926,
0.0993027166,
-0.1144464239,
0.0426100194,
-0.2348756939,
-0.0420023128,
0.2630577683,
-0.9251073003,
-0.177162528,
0.2960225046,
-0.2529404461,
-0.1154174805,
0.254642874,
-0.7508820891,
-0.4092992842,
-0.1617670953,
0.4035586119,
-0.6867880821,
-0.157769233,
0.0609159544,
0.3003786802,
0.0205612071,
0.2379654646,
-0.6221437454,
0.1795560718,
0.8671277165,
0.9624031186,
-0.1293627024,
-0.4574619532,
-0.5953972936,
-0.2027447671,
-0.2880738676,
0.8671959639,
-0.6803039908,
-0.3916400373,
0.0899532139,
-0.0851058066,
-0.2134623826,
-0.6508107185,
0.428391248,
-0.5710659027,
0.032725472,
-0.2870678008,
-0.4706819057,
-0.8321889043,
0.4415358305,
-0.5801405907,
0.8455812335,
0.3551504016,
-0.7294389009,
0.2919713259,
-0.8926994801,
-0.7730970383,
-0.2401884645,
-0.06737905,
-0.7712957859,
0.0469081923,
0.4722626209,
0.7691466212,
-0.2802125812,
0.2136016339,
-0.5295145512,
-0.1928059608,
0.4003683031,
-0.2181829959,
0.6057946682,
0.1264833361,
-0.2027575523,
0.3418362439,
-0.2744395733,
-0.3647041023,
-0.0493442379,
-0.058206819,
-0.4268575013,
-0.2181983888,
0.184055984,
0.3541137278,
0.0962369144,
-0.505148828,
-0.0557116792,
-0.5295774341,
0.2337680757,
0.5708260536,
0.1920788139,
0.3891142011,
-0.3030623794,
0.3977140486,
0.6030116081,
0.12441165,
-0.4090830982,
-0.4797737598,
-0.6753404737,
-0.5933951139,
0.1813039184,
0.1420829594,
-0.6606782079,
0.536685288,
-0.2368373275,
-0.0874598995,
-0.5087823868,
0.49702546,
0.4143440127,
0.5726917982,
0.4689573348,
-0.6955138445,
-0.1723169237,
-0.7458027005,
-0.0868970454,
-0.0497097783,
0.3634222746,
0.4406335354,
0.4680248797,
-0.3546750844,
1.1237050295,
-0.4591077864,
-1.0285013914,
-0.3810454905,
0.0730331764,
-0.1562321931,
0.2159972191,
0.8299399614,
-0.967045188,
-0.5897668004,
0.1901839077,
-0.8883619308,
0.0467042513,
-0.0407665111,
-0.2004089355,
0.2817283571,
0.171833083,
-0.3155779839,
0.1036487222,
0.5020744801,
-0.1913965195,
0.0062809545,
0.2294024527,
0.0773747787,
-1.3534933329,
0.0766118392,
0.4408670068,
-0.2582954168,
-0.4339397848,
0.1904058903,
0.1797185242,
0.040862143,
-0.5026930571,
0.5187813044,
-0.2604523301,
-0.0655754954,
-0.5053668618,
0.2540232539,
0.3948121369,
0.6955899,
0.0285040736,
0.7921215296,
0.7435991168,
-0.552349925,
-0.0436471999,
0.3071640134,
-0.1833589077,
0.7466438413,
-0.0254192334,
0.0917870179,
-0.0536844023,
0.3052212596,
-0.827446878,
-0.2527850866,
0.3679846227,
-0.4200834036,
0.3559964597,
0.0575930923,
-0.0703523532,
0.0996865779,
-0.5586551428,
0.3279144466,
-0.0443437546,
-0.7679616809,
0.9099932313,
0.722474575,
-0.2198679,
-0.8631604314,
-0.2756480277,
-0.0208353158,
-0.3053799272,
-0.360553205,
0.4202267528,
0.0028540154,
-0.2153703719,
0.0337504745,
-0.0656537935,
-0.1879732609,
0.3813112974,
0.3921268284,
-0.1613301337,
-0.2102000415,
0.1447689831,
0.3802702427,
-0.0518657528,
0.0682502612,
-0.3867093623,
0.4585620761,
-0.5366936922,
-0.2213790715,
-0.5299375057,
0.4479659796,
0.4897052348,
-0.4581221044,
0.5307853222,
0.588650763,
-0.5718976259,
-0.5513306856,
-0.0701241568,
-0.1444066316,
-0.4609771371,
0.4295621216,
-0.5772582889,
-1.0591094494,
0.4587404132,
-0.3994797766,
-0.0216366816,
0.4108801782,
0.504863441,
-0.081010133,
0.50175035,
0.7616969943,
-0.3902356923,
0.4714670777,
-0.6670498848,
0.2939071655,
-1.0167815685,
-0.1661787331,
-0.3318937123,
-0.2049492151,
0.0343424976,
-0.4435072839,
0.3879007399,
0.2634129226,
-0.1651478857,
0.059435796,
-0.2030133307,
0.3961995542,
0.2201018333,
0.081864357,
0.1348500401,
-0.1060472131,
0.0571360141,
0.1718463451,
-0.6039218307,
-0.2663008869,
0.9683561921,
0.3057650924,
0.4008080661,
0.1053921878,
0.5627384186,
0.3717117012,
0.792160809,
-1.0541424751,
0.3216561973,
-0.4563702941,
-0.052414462,
0.0107769482,
-0.3331844509,
-0.473515749,
0.4525652528,
-0.1911962926,
-0.383023113,
0.4064081609,
-0.101745978,
-0.3168163896,
0.2949038148,
-0.2654527426,
0.9369269013,
-0.0750127509,
-0.2532783747,
-0.1005120575,
-0.5448126793,
0.4327482283,
-0.4743068516,
0.3538527489,
-0.2610800564,
0.0366690196,
0.4145630896,
-0.1981928796,
1.0862627029,
-0.2582589984,
-0.1589906663,
0.3486295044,
0.0530311875,
0.0847251862,
0.4475856125,
-0.0134804426,
0.615206182,
-0.4893619716,
-0.0643764287,
-0.4829328954,
1.0265597105,
-0.8266193867,
-0.3443933129,
-0.3696659803,
-0.5555328131,
-0.6456887722,
0.1075866669,
0.1115359738,
0.6137679815,
-0.3938203752,
0.3445628881,
0.6247531772,
0.0204496253,
0.4841811955,
0.3783267736,
-0.1691977531,
-0.4457607865,
1.1611845493,
-0.1767085046,
-0.1665697247,
0.6412450075,
0.1055355892,
-0.3238771558,
-0.5080402493,
-0.5272715688,
0.0880668983,
-0.86552459,
-0.7114548087,
-0.8853740096,
-0.0187123418,
-0.3234548867,
-0.2589878142,
-0.3104714751,
-0.1096338257,
-0.4271642566,
0.0392867997,
0.5313213468,
0.6240073442,
0.2264704853,
0.4260263145,
-0.7015212178,
0.2836146653,
0.0805941895,
0.4397851527,
0.0715316981,
-0.3911338151,
-0.485538125,
-0.1500797421,
-0.5224828124,
-0.5234031081,
0.5470007062,
0.7109537125,
0.3076348007,
0.703742981,
0.1737897247,
0.3617303967,
-0.1110978797,
0.6750490069,
-0.0672772825,
-1.1914497614,
0.4063790441,
-0.08290869,
0.0732122436,
0.636318922,
0.5087077618,
-0.4908778965,
-0.4720871747,
-0.2303379178,
-0.9065666795,
0.7703570724,
-0.1025988609,
0.2332512438,
-0.1672045439,
0.4044813514,
0.4214286506,
0.146298632,
-0.3646981418,
-0.3039687574,
-0.471927911,
-0.6078708172,
-0.0148372957,
0.0556251071,
-0.2344729453,
-0.060065791,
0.8697295785,
-0.898012042,
0.086399138,
0.1772504449,
-0.4266782105,
0.1184216514,
0.1359693557,
0.4899005294,
0.6346820593,
-0.0110030081,
-0.0095897531,
0.1168726385,
-0.3378186524,
-0.0808555484,
0.1882242411,
-0.1282467693,
-0.1700143814,
0.3177012205,
0.8693096042,
0.2938033342,
-0.4627175033,
0.7671691775,
-0.103316009,
-0.1443621367,
-0.0317703485,
-0.0619336925,
0.017512057,
0.2993657887,
0.4502019882,
0.3127606511,
0.2025486231,
-0.4263271093,
0.5122087002,
0.5014545918,
-0.7632834911,
-0.4099066257,
0.5830497146,
0.2913021743,
-0.0130708804,
0.2102083117,
-0.1593071073,
-0.6173564196,
0.5810431242,
0.4545943141,
1.281768918,
-0.1442421526,
0.3599232137,
-0.0365597866,
-0.0577046722,
0.1677120477,
0.2646351755,
-0.0339840725,
-1.0372684002,
-0.1086626351,
-0.7663542628,
-0.5988665819,
-0.142010659,
-0.573176384,
-0.0655204132,
-0.6067152023,
-0.1571474671,
-0.0788738057,
-0.0715755597,
-0.5116971731,
0.3042082489,
-0.0701000616,
0.6504006982,
-0.745755136,
0.9681118727,
0.8303449154,
-0.4074961245,
-0.3951410353,
0.4694546461,
0.04340446,
-0.3700495362,
0.2651370466,
0.6025605202,
-0.5097222328,
-0.2921899855,
-0.1382845491,
-0.5738111138,
0.9798013568,
0.2929801643,
-0.0724953711,
0.7265233397,
0.1169458106,
0.4568485916,
-1.1551378965,
-0.1575794071,
0.3704515398,
0.0417973064,
-0.2477664202,
-0.4947024882,
-0.004646448,
-0.2022234499,
-0.0353064053,
0.1520923227,
-1.1723710299,
0.859561801,
-0.1100929826,
0.0009748549,
-0.3281512558,
1.1774948835,
0.1156356484,
0.5367774963,
0.4694293141,
0.3619480431,
0.7420397997,
-0.0904721692,
0.8710523248,
-0.6660521626,
0.4292036891,
0.8642743826,
-0.549728632,
0.9712129831,
0.2229663134,
0.2180221081,
0.7193661928,
0.5815571547,
0.6227064729,
0.6466786861,
-0.376762867,
-0.4117676616,
-0.2259448469,
-0.2358211726,
-0.1537076384,
0.6187897921,
0.7400146723,
-0.338835299,
-0.0080945883,
0.3509859145,
0.0837031677,
0.2532538772,
-0.2706420124,
0.8392924666,
0.3922905028,
-0.1971699595,
0.2492029369,
0.2530593276,
0.8967599273,
-0.6436222196,
0.0763228983,
-0.617880702,
0.3566021025,
-0.1942024529,
-0.6644937992,
0.3908157051,
-0.088591285,
-0.3239227831,
-0.1338115335,
0.5858262181,
-0.5188724399,
-0.4065778553,
0.5374181867,
0.4498894811,
-0.2953802943,
-0.3994961977,
-0.7732676864,
0.1278356165,
-0.2118376344,
-0.3004027009,
0.5963255167,
0.5266041756,
-0.3381937146,
0.5954748392,
0.3177156448,
-0.3640602529,
-0.6205448508,
0.2624974251,
1.0183411837,
-0.4677515924,
-0.7468532324,
-0.6733236313,
0.107981585,
0.0624820106,
-0.5495954752,
0.6723963618,
0.7025561929,
1.018050909,
0.0587638468,
0.9195951819,
0.2681087255,
0.2823856175,
-0.45140329,
0.8582369089,
-0.7133648396,
0.206460312,
-0.233463034,
-0.987003386,
-0.6297941804,
0.6017878652,
0.0464435294,
0.1041374281,
0.7280178666,
0.7177667618,
-0.1964623481,
0.2486528903,
0.1015041173,
0.076242052,
0.3611403704,
0.4726513922,
0.4050860405,
-0.4824110866,
0.1366968155,
-0.4337481856,
-0.1708753109,
-0.1933937371,
-0.7009740472,
-0.7210562825,
-0.8445501924,
-0.4410073161,
-0.2617228627,
-0.1701717377,
1.1148612499,
0.6893787384,
-1.0350081921,
-0.1674657464,
0.4276561737,
0.3240860105,
-0.7115660906,
-0.2835144997,
0.6592757702,
-0.5779815912,
-0.7366560102,
0.6648077965,
0.5991157889,
-0.3915990889,
-0.2729792893,
-0.1342511922,
-0.1543399245,
0.2748173773,
0.893297255,
0.0632516444,
-0.5434264541,
-0.4093401432,
-0.2893396914,
-0.079998523,
0.3839968443,
0.9091331363,
-0.7720660567,
0.3714698553,
0.3883036375,
0.9183247685,
0.0818417892,
0.222669512,
0.3127613962,
-1.2131664753,
0.10661906,
0.1034866348,
0.6025524139,
0.7021675706,
-0.4093701243,
0.2986461222,
0.3600022793,
-0.1210764349,
-0.548065722,
0.0642345995,
-1.0675715208,
-0.5071163177,
0.9336788654,
-0.4353839755,
-0.226002574,
-0.3238555193,
-0.0502592288,
-0.0205750037,
-0.6228126287,
0.8105196357,
0.4736995399,
-0.244323194,
-0.0163142737,
0.0547684506,
0.638263762,
0.1193634048,
-0.9936854243,
0.311863631,
0.5224218965,
0.1788017154,
0.0337718762,
0.7472391129,
-0.0444677994,
0.1205678508,
-0.2593907416,
-0.0833347961,
-0.3312693238,
-0.9240807295,
-0.6588480473,
0.6943141818,
-0.0416523963,
-0.1129262522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01061v1
|
Reading Subtext: Evaluating Large Language Models on Short Story Summarization with Writers
| 2024-03-02T01:52:14 | 2024-03-02T01:52:14 |
Melanie Subbiah, Sean Zhang, Lydia B. Chilton, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We evaluate recent Large language Models (LLMs) on the challenging task of
summarizing short stories, which can be lengthy, and include nuanced subtext or
scrambled timelines. Importantly, we work directly with authors to ensure that
the stories have not been shared online (and therefore are unseen by the
models), and to obtain informed evaluations of summary quality using judgments
from the authors themselves. Through quantitative and qualitative analysis
grounded in narrative theory, we compare GPT-4, Claude-2.1, and LLama-2-70B. We
find that all three models make faithfulness mistakes in over 50% of summaries
and struggle to interpret difficult subtext. However, at their best, the models
can provide thoughtful thematic analysis of stories. We additionally
demonstrate that LLM judgments of summary quality do not match the feedback
from the writers.
|
[
-0.1118369773,
-0.6652134657,
1.082783699,
0.3473098278,
-0.5562267303,
0.195144847,
-0.0552890077,
-0.8618884087,
0.2869920731,
0.6065194011,
-0.5491189957,
-0.3291475773,
-0.6843972206,
0.3574332297,
-0.6009584069,
1.1881016493,
-0.1970674247,
-0.0936771482,
-0.4653847814,
-0.1093412936,
-0.239597261,
-0.4697593451,
-0.4066716135,
-0.5206972361,
0.5827248096,
0.1448775083,
0.8322450519,
0.4498588741,
0.4847424328,
0.2545960844,
-0.3538605571,
0.0078733945,
-0.7912752032,
0.0522659309,
-0.2077846229,
-0.3595755696,
-0.6363461614,
-0.0418555923,
0.4970838428,
0.6179458499,
0.1309469938,
0.1910921484,
0.0040420252,
0.6581625938,
-0.2361673415,
0.095236294,
-0.185842067,
0.0250077564,
-0.0769836307,
-0.0410098694,
-0.2705673873,
-0.5562622547,
0.3598965704,
-0.3597948551,
0.3049944043,
0.0687004253,
0.66975528,
0.075591661,
-0.6296389699,
-0.474599272,
-0.655916512,
0.8373536468,
-0.828584075,
0.0339981243,
0.5969028473,
0.062061362,
0.1335619986,
-0.8648051023,
-0.4146118462,
-0.5114707351,
-0.3272350729,
0.2633735836,
-0.3633683324,
-0.1350705326,
0.0729538277,
0.6298320293,
-0.664280653,
0.0991792828,
-0.5132104158,
-0.1112475097,
0.6874867082,
0.5217480659,
0.3188789487,
-0.2082592547,
-0.2701346278,
0.2647162676,
-0.7584322691,
-0.053808026,
0.6423752904,
-0.1526271701,
-0.2843053043,
0.7720358968,
-0.0752475187,
0.3155546188,
-0.2629412413,
-0.3593726158,
0.0291600209,
-0.7128558159,
-0.1265789568,
-0.0589974336,
0.8405646086,
0.7491505742,
0.5406556726,
-0.1080632359,
-0.3229781687,
-0.2915864289,
0.0227651577,
-0.6569828987,
-0.065311037,
0.2149245441,
-0.6587008238,
-0.3060265481,
-0.1665056795,
-0.4777862132,
-0.4999397099,
-0.2920060456,
0.1912053078,
-0.2896845341,
0.1244354919,
0.1388955116,
-0.2700216174,
0.068227686,
0.478366673,
-0.9339932799,
0.2857985497,
0.6162779927,
0.9549366236,
-0.1254916042,
-0.4677512944,
-0.1634147316,
0.1511608362,
-0.3555482924,
0.8541024923,
-0.213080734,
-0.635522604,
-0.2251048982,
-0.127463609,
0.0601890087,
-0.3204140961,
0.5154297948,
-0.3010870814,
0.2993130088,
-0.28690359,
-0.5546201468,
-0.169312641,
0.2255861312,
-0.7397393584,
0.7359351516,
0.1532336175,
-0.7811616659,
-0.0322199278,
-0.2243421823,
-0.4138102233,
-0.2125741094,
0.1157059595,
-0.1753983498,
0.4220439494,
0.6094846725,
0.4600323737,
-0.3591378331,
0.2101850212,
-0.0955858678,
-0.4417930543,
0.2328565568,
-0.2313872576,
0.5727947354,
0.0229740869,
-0.0110259885,
0.2522718608,
-0.2560342252,
-0.2517952025,
0.3075635135,
-0.2814001143,
-0.3342988491,
0.0246988591,
0.1122756973,
-0.1296162605,
0.325443238,
-0.2622800767,
0.2239584178,
-0.3516968191,
0.4639281034,
0.4858834743,
0.1313968599,
0.2299853563,
-0.5718135238,
0.7324901819,
-0.1111986041,
0.1865138113,
-0.4401590228,
-0.3700876534,
-0.6621341705,
-0.1533312351,
0.3511791527,
0.4700137377,
-0.7865697742,
-0.1190763786,
-0.231739372,
-0.697040081,
-0.376868248,
0.1561781168,
0.5571761131,
0.312348187,
0.3584067225,
-0.2724583447,
-0.36270383,
-0.9621191621,
-0.581237793,
-0.2992949188,
-0.1575205326,
0.0499912761,
0.8511915803,
-0.297796011,
0.8023851514,
-0.4976706803,
-0.1097042412,
-0.9033072591,
0.3394964337,
0.2239758223,
0.2131733894,
0.8316017985,
-0.5389701724,
-0.4508716166,
-0.2496514469,
-0.7046103477,
-0.1934145093,
0.0716309994,
0.4033943415,
0.1935561597,
0.5299406648,
-0.6017476916,
0.4050250053,
0.7373895049,
-0.3791102469,
0.723115027,
-0.1727036685,
0.2131583393,
-0.9479342699,
-0.1720051914,
0.0966674685,
-0.5173259974,
-0.2918344438,
0.0077425218,
-0.0510991998,
0.2522235513,
-0.422498256,
0.4741280675,
-0.3993619382,
-0.2280431092,
-0.3444885314,
0.2355676889,
0.1264259368,
0.1855521351,
0.0145327765,
0.6329904199,
-0.0548629612,
-0.2137381881,
0.3687567413,
0.114307642,
-0.6663557291,
0.3211334348,
-0.983786881,
0.0376511589,
-0.2034306973,
0.5764120817,
-0.796700418,
-0.3690592349,
0.0353130177,
-0.3273609579,
0.1487053484,
-0.0894324109,
-0.6415814757,
-0.0277093891,
-0.3825274408,
0.4990879595,
0.5084007978,
-0.2712674141,
0.5108792186,
0.2962290347,
-0.5638756752,
-0.4607568681,
-0.8103387952,
0.2144841701,
-0.172151804,
-0.2810825706,
0.1856359988,
-0.0769779757,
-0.5101243854,
0.148845613,
-0.1924877465,
-0.0677100122,
-0.106582433,
-0.0833344981,
0.0575271212,
-0.2201505452,
-0.2020524293,
0.1853204519,
-0.1606307775,
0.1020357162,
0.0856051445,
0.2903399765,
-0.1761370897,
-0.1957424581,
-0.3494403064,
0.4802342057,
0.6345115304,
-0.1067472398,
0.566534698,
0.3621388674,
-0.2458587885,
0.152862072,
-0.431063056,
0.0547179654,
-0.3719550371,
0.4227355123,
-0.2014357001,
-1.0673786402,
0.5065075159,
0.2404800355,
0.0020664374,
0.6921756268,
0.5556502938,
-0.2808641195,
0.799880445,
1.0391175747,
-0.0981362686,
0.3752858341,
-0.0818471089,
0.1417262107,
-0.6289169192,
-0.0891414732,
-0.4588450789,
-0.1724369973,
-0.2012909502,
-0.2405199558,
0.3258674443,
0.1224132031,
0.0451226309,
0.2489531636,
0.1282036752,
0.9064179063,
0.3683989346,
-0.0211658739,
0.6755708456,
-0.2190196961,
-0.0360136069,
-0.2685694396,
-0.3983459175,
-0.7922218442,
0.7705700994,
0.6289638877,
1.0187300444,
0.341899842,
0.4230163991,
0.3532567024,
0.324059993,
-0.8575699925,
0.4970366359,
-0.1836722791,
-0.4672951996,
-0.2639967203,
-0.5261400342,
-0.6921426654,
0.294225961,
-0.0562071577,
-0.7785258889,
-0.026642574,
-0.0875658095,
-0.267380923,
0.180483982,
-0.6364936829,
0.6823212504,
-0.2028484643,
0.046435304,
-0.1981873959,
-0.8087580204,
0.7006589174,
-0.1749260724,
0.2089745551,
-0.1505047679,
-0.2046939582,
0.649956584,
-0.2378585041,
0.9431848526,
0.4281159341,
-0.2053628415,
0.3396060169,
0.3347829282,
0.2834501863,
0.2916892767,
0.0915419385,
0.2215313315,
0.3003098667,
-0.5215691924,
-0.5779895782,
0.5445659757,
-0.729691565,
-0.5156351924,
-0.5933899879,
-0.7273316979,
-0.180021435,
0.271009475,
0.3892022669,
0.4488836825,
-0.377821207,
0.2579799891,
0.3898651004,
-0.1878171861,
0.5479406714,
0.4168767929,
-0.3893172741,
-0.5595549941,
0.3435949981,
0.0926649794,
0.4133711159,
0.4868662059,
0.2176053524,
-0.3679412901,
-0.7583833337,
-0.339938134,
0.5025664568,
-0.802682817,
0.0456858501,
-0.6540817022,
-0.0710151568,
-0.2099959999,
-0.1132080108,
-0.3288522959,
-0.5308862329,
-0.2629023194,
-0.36088112,
0.1875686646,
1.24708426,
0.2134949118,
0.4566853344,
-1.0432467461,
0.2738941014,
0.0933870375,
0.0488869213,
-0.0709727481,
-0.5461726189,
-0.4404683411,
-0.1658666581,
-0.2781944573,
-0.9006834626,
0.408618629,
-0.1937185675,
0.2150495648,
-0.0384360962,
0.0639062896,
0.5788536072,
-0.4319198132,
1.0757154226,
0.0947103053,
-1.1905345917,
0.3734422326,
-0.6013170481,
0.4877923429,
0.4166088104,
0.5546116233,
-0.4198934734,
-0.5942853689,
-0.4370172322,
-0.9090123177,
0.4953478575,
0.3461238742,
0.2570229471,
0.1434915811,
0.3718713224,
0.2416163981,
0.3150775135,
-0.9009771347,
-0.0794733539,
-0.1340545416,
-0.3625555038,
-0.6176514626,
-0.9391151071,
-0.080963634,
-0.0196570903,
0.5406912565,
-0.0414158739,
-0.0289647467,
0.3050326109,
-0.2861515284,
-0.1176815629,
0.2511113286,
1.0375757217,
1.132083416,
-0.2388661951,
0.1023551971,
0.3829033375,
-0.6220111847,
-0.0905192271,
-0.2468456179,
-0.0146179907,
0.1929625869,
1.1712247133,
0.5722667575,
0.368105948,
-0.7202649117,
0.5560861826,
-0.4744764268,
-0.1930180043,
-0.2522254586,
-0.2036882043,
0.2536128759,
0.4801680446,
0.2321729958,
-0.3303090334,
0.0636854991,
-0.7080639005,
-0.1559937447,
-0.0007176326,
-0.3850272894,
-0.3748725951,
0.5107412338,
0.1013552025,
0.0061009247,
0.5506814122,
0.1319600493,
-0.3959547877,
0.6528014541,
0.5720307231,
0.9454116225,
0.0953365043,
0.1281879842,
0.0150800049,
0.8199600577,
-0.2179780751,
0.0507975258,
0.2781137228,
-0.3907865882,
-0.8230243325,
-0.5431770682,
-0.8452786803,
0.2447606176,
-0.620164156,
-0.0239107497,
-0.1334817708,
0.0212184619,
-0.1604326516,
-0.0292862505,
-0.0642834753,
0.1185041592,
-0.255594492,
0.9065238833,
-0.7514743805,
0.5608472824,
0.5510160923,
-0.4789266586,
-0.5090488195,
0.3389686048,
-0.0465446748,
-0.3597066104,
0.4001128674,
-0.0706170797,
-0.0720613971,
0.0714969039,
-0.4676419497,
-0.7088127732,
1.1784040928,
0.5389789343,
-0.5328959823,
-0.0661246702,
-0.0991395488,
0.8143641353,
-0.31698367,
0.2713972926,
0.5110163689,
0.3065207601,
-0.0329888277,
-1.1289877892,
-0.0697962269,
0.05213264,
-0.1359982938,
0.0444016829,
-0.7455073595,
0.8861151338,
-0.3306574523,
-0.0778101981,
0.5006322861,
0.787048161,
0.25980708,
0.5348471403,
0.3309726119,
0.4803052843,
0.4350978732,
-0.0518166162,
1.4371609688,
0.1907206178,
0.5532096028,
1.2623209953,
-0.1769313067,
0.6766739488,
0.4507438838,
-0.1630872488,
0.4344817996,
0.7555981874,
0.230488345,
0.5003381968,
0.1447795928,
-0.0550518371,
-0.1243800819,
-0.0190896112,
-0.3943377435,
0.2485203147,
0.1971258372,
-0.416106075,
-0.3614500463,
-0.1636931002,
0.0674159601,
0.1187349483,
-0.4291205108,
0.7015483379,
0.5501610637,
-0.5639567971,
0.0940646231,
0.3013700545,
0.2972082198,
-0.4402034581,
0.1287444234,
-0.605658412,
0.1093247235,
-0.1412008256,
-0.8723031282,
0.4549571574,
0.3569101095,
-0.4523104429,
-0.250038296,
0.4340931475,
-0.2721442282,
-0.4470566213,
0.1952674687,
0.6086380482,
0.2792941034,
0.0427011438,
-0.4849065542,
0.1781276166,
-0.1968690157,
-0.4851820767,
0.3300610781,
0.3765625656,
-0.2197238058,
0.5549461246,
0.4869360924,
-0.1128460839,
-0.3048662841,
0.1876194477,
0.591588974,
-0.9383817911,
-0.4903260767,
-1.0930964947,
0.4113796651,
0.1419382691,
-0.4012292325,
0.8561318517,
0.5504923463,
0.7461438179,
-0.2405424118,
0.631870091,
0.2606319785,
0.4629777074,
-0.8910087347,
0.6829768419,
-0.458150506,
0.4569917321,
-0.3326821625,
-1.0641947985,
-0.261003077,
0.3720562756,
-0.4003161192,
0.1953339428,
1.0530693531,
0.2400631607,
-0.0466353968,
0.1578398496,
0.3052377105,
0.3785605729,
0.2450963706,
0.5362419486,
1.281031847,
-0.3004225492,
0.4170251191,
-0.0499424376,
-0.0116214948,
-0.256113708,
-1.1611202955,
-1.1784166098,
-0.3487925231,
-0.2184758931,
-0.3039257228,
0.0315660089,
0.5392490625,
0.1828214526,
-0.5515972376,
-0.2161207944,
0.1852082014,
0.4117386341,
-0.0852315649,
-0.1978038549,
0.2821110785,
0.1333561391,
-0.8912216425,
0.4642679393,
0.4369964302,
0.3687419295,
-0.2971268594,
-0.0265393276,
0.0994687527,
0.2892485857,
0.7070994973,
-0.1123277918,
-0.8369711041,
-0.2283305377,
-0.2284891307,
-0.2691291869,
-0.329874903,
0.9327729344,
-0.4391452968,
0.052578032,
0.6922766566,
0.41938743,
0.6183791161,
0.1927133054,
0.6181835532,
-0.5403226614,
-0.1076352149,
0.3490271568,
0.5728315115,
0.2153979242,
-0.2885266542,
0.56445086,
0.2226261795,
-0.6608530879,
-0.9634898901,
0.2649055421,
-1.0178598166,
-0.3829116523,
1.0275261402,
-0.3421051502,
-0.2211944908,
-0.0950684249,
-0.299134165,
-0.0857125148,
0.04843124,
0.5729727149,
1.031613946,
-0.2072309852,
-0.3022686541,
-0.8344953656,
0.3151318133,
0.3024594188,
-0.7438628078,
-0.1351053566,
0.5925520062,
0.4077284634,
-0.0759210512,
0.8347153068,
-0.1830525398,
0.2162593007,
-0.0693542287,
-0.3206029236,
-0.2000120878,
-0.4100611806,
-0.37377882,
0.0651877895,
-0.0396913625,
0.4621185362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01031v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01031v2
|
Peacock: A Family of Arabic Multimodal Large Language Models and Benchmarks
| 2024-03-01T23:38:02 | 2024-05-24T20:24:36 |
Fakhraddin Alwajih, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Gagan Bhatia, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have proven effective in a wide
range of tasks requiring complex reasoning and linguistic comprehension.
However, due to a lack of high-quality multimodal resources in languages other
than English, success of MLLMs remains relatively limited to English-based
settings. This poses significant challenges in developing comparable models for
other languages, including even those with large speaker populations such as
Arabic. To alleviate this challenge, we introduce a comprehensive family of
Arabic MLLMs, dubbed \textit{Peacock}, with strong vision and language
capabilities. Through comprehensive qualitative and quantitative analysis, we
demonstrate the solid performance of our models on various visual reasoning
tasks and further show their emerging dialectal potential. Additionally, we
introduce ~\textit{Henna}, a new benchmark specifically designed for assessing
MLLMs on aspects related to Arabic culture, setting the first stone for
culturally-aware Arabic MLLMs.The GitHub repository for the \textit{Peacock}
project is available at \url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/peacock}.
|
[
-0.5048769116,
-0.5574763417,
0.0618903935,
0.5283499956,
-0.1807841063,
0.2154253572,
-0.2113302946,
-0.6934687495,
-0.1435173154,
0.2816279233,
-0.2417329699,
-0.4861552417,
-0.2758584321,
0.253508836,
-0.3292885721,
0.5669338107,
0.0186042786,
0.156987682,
0.3766779006,
-0.6019238234,
-0.2341527939,
-0.352363646,
-0.4602990746,
-0.0037571888,
0.9711125493,
0.2688868642,
0.9906778932,
0.6056440473,
0.3295700848,
0.3050988913,
0.0621704273,
0.5306465626,
-0.2351887375,
0.3905542195,
-0.3609470725,
0.0436720103,
-0.1681923568,
-0.1533504426,
0.8506319523,
0.9069428444,
0.0082869437,
0.4161807597,
-0.0083312355,
0.7290712595,
-0.9780498147,
0.2410760522,
-0.6859815121,
0.1809745282,
-0.2083590478,
-0.0998468399,
-0.3875768483,
-0.1217413321,
0.0592282005,
-0.3788105845,
-0.3282153606,
0.4142922163,
0.7208189368,
-0.0640358329,
-0.9788300991,
0.1549367458,
-0.461322248,
1.1057082415,
-0.5259454846,
0.7023334503,
0.2515809238,
0.7098470926,
0.0240174048,
-0.682149291,
-0.5411789417,
-0.2786550224,
0.2764561176,
-0.050682392,
-0.1258086413,
-0.3710307479,
0.1131686047,
0.149805069,
-0.5255405903,
-0.2963390648,
-0.0545216575,
-0.2400960624,
0.4286504686,
0.180840373,
0.4207178652,
-0.0825282857,
-0.2147361934,
0.142599389,
-0.8226639628,
0.3120658994,
0.227767095,
0.4839171767,
-0.1528598666,
0.644331038,
-0.3152669668,
0.7195967436,
-0.2950015366,
-0.0671414733,
0.0814691335,
-0.2729027569,
-0.2119751871,
-0.1852379441,
0.4458576143,
0.3455407023,
0.4282507002,
-0.0096788621,
-0.1301989555,
-0.0311538968,
-0.0972248912,
-0.9499844909,
-0.1077328175,
0.1558416486,
-0.8787578344,
-0.1677227914,
-0.2597831488,
-0.68166399,
-0.7870725393,
-0.3366685808,
0.1138537154,
-0.4278233349,
-0.7729025483,
-0.1270957738,
-0.0520129129,
0.5888306499,
0.460740447,
-0.7419692278,
-0.0722525492,
0.5536333919,
0.6547628641,
-0.1372530013,
-0.6237086058,
-0.7735291719,
0.1885108799,
-0.7050438523,
0.5992164612,
-0.961666286,
-0.2230952084,
0.4999659359,
-0.0706624091,
0.0784884021,
-0.4839897752,
0.63658005,
-0.7030854821,
-0.3857986629,
-0.582238853,
-0.1485803276,
-0.5112307072,
0.5551607013,
-0.7535640597,
0.6746439934,
0.0808510408,
-0.8620503545,
0.3962658346,
-0.3168362081,
-0.4847372174,
0.1010200381,
-0.2786634564,
-0.1690356433,
-0.1388212591,
0.2131901681,
0.3600581884,
-0.4205549955,
0.0378056839,
-0.6427312493,
-0.4041674733,
0.5065865517,
-0.5474158525,
0.998621583,
0.4731545746,
-0.3587247133,
0.5836595893,
-0.9105426669,
0.2403697073,
-0.1492716521,
-0.4690487087,
-0.0922110453,
0.0140883727,
0.8164309859,
0.3476215303,
0.2226128727,
-0.3550231159,
0.0297783595,
-0.0629332885,
0.3753089905,
0.6715782881,
-0.3448581696,
0.0573775321,
-0.3240838349,
0.5276032686,
0.2093805522,
0.2659406364,
-0.2707735002,
-0.4596027732,
-0.977381289,
-0.5094357133,
0.1607692391,
0.3621766567,
-0.9983965755,
-0.2398413718,
0.0019955884,
-0.4478277266,
-0.4589889348,
0.1481086165,
0.3940038681,
0.2027863264,
0.3278368115,
0.2019525915,
-0.5509070754,
-1.1146322489,
-0.4614229202,
0.0575110875,
0.377782017,
0.3043956757,
0.5435881019,
-0.383107394,
0.7050387859,
0.1901901364,
-0.0445998646,
-0.3555268347,
0.2755429745,
0.1399157792,
0.4390099347,
0.6393406987,
-1.099096179,
-0.7776920199,
0.4848062992,
-0.8106067181,
0.1275425106,
0.0772168934,
-0.1395832151,
0.4738681316,
0.1838082671,
-0.4547364712,
0.4434544146,
0.6862810254,
-0.5295466781,
1.0523539782,
0.1088046506,
0.453507334,
-0.9246178865,
0.2204075158,
0.0247226376,
-0.3623467684,
-0.5151383877,
0.2918565273,
0.2143830657,
-0.1914239973,
-0.6070395112,
0.7414150834,
-0.7368168831,
-0.2494219244,
-0.1553565264,
-0.3035292029,
-0.0765499249,
0.5670593977,
0.1226963475,
0.9941607118,
0.8645278215,
-0.3559865057,
0.486697197,
0.0038678348,
-0.6530854702,
0.6500666142,
-0.6722958684,
-0.1235699281,
0.1323494315,
-0.13163656,
-0.886734724,
-0.0913261697,
0.0455564447,
-0.1501178741,
0.2769451439,
-0.1130316556,
-0.5024212599,
-0.198061794,
-0.4868487418,
0.7052672505,
0.4326516688,
-0.5838467479,
0.9063494802,
0.1835511476,
-0.197982356,
-0.9485276341,
-0.4762562513,
0.453866154,
-0.1847797781,
-0.6796040535,
-0.0827944949,
0.1085620224,
-0.4689383209,
-0.1363394707,
0.2027571946,
-0.2013594806,
-0.1516900212,
0.1340333968,
0.2569127679,
-0.5719548464,
0.1506875902,
-0.1215313971,
0.0587837324,
-0.156251207,
-0.3700109422,
0.3998211622,
-0.6989623308,
-0.6252106428,
-0.3075217605,
0.7130424976,
0.9339906573,
-0.8881214261,
0.8657120466,
0.9355822206,
-0.2785396576,
-0.240794614,
-0.767559886,
0.1567706764,
-0.4503999054,
0.5834060311,
-0.7046396732,
-0.6204417944,
0.562217474,
-0.1020660475,
-0.0231541581,
0.2297451198,
0.5991271138,
-0.1350340396,
1.4663044214,
0.6439518929,
0.0135334106,
0.2826267183,
-0.1603345871,
0.0102686752,
-0.999519825,
0.0299542341,
-0.4155120254,
-0.1935394406,
-0.6252600551,
-0.5685429573,
0.3467488587,
0.0863342732,
-0.6941344738,
-0.1342170388,
-0.1332246959,
0.389090687,
0.6734076738,
-0.0531468876,
0.4304219484,
-0.0267345253,
-0.2960422933,
-0.0051867655,
-0.6409199834,
-0.7413228154,
1.1117702723,
0.1517865062,
0.6762930155,
0.5374211669,
0.0135058668,
0.3468368948,
0.3903608024,
-0.4618271589,
0.6577050686,
-0.0362217501,
-0.5259393454,
-0.3003259003,
-0.19140248,
-0.9460628629,
0.66193223,
-0.2778689563,
-0.6133975387,
0.2016966045,
0.0475690998,
-0.0164408945,
0.37375471,
-0.3347771168,
1.0805058479,
-0.2828039229,
-0.9633075595,
-0.3904601634,
-0.5265136361,
0.4672603011,
-0.0275716353,
0.2987674475,
-0.2678624392,
-0.2615201771,
0.3718784153,
-0.4340063632,
0.8051413894,
-0.003890052,
-0.044168815,
0.3211298287,
0.2203591466,
0.4416553676,
-0.2290733755,
-0.3431309164,
0.15073511,
0.229177326,
-0.80826056,
-0.404913187,
0.7699653506,
-0.7894673347,
-0.3418924809,
-0.4928140938,
-0.7009301782,
-0.581851542,
0.2890550494,
-0.2638637722,
0.7032968998,
-0.021546673,
0.4531825781,
0.2953723669,
-0.3957110345,
0.5324184299,
0.6056400537,
-0.7328621745,
-0.3417476714,
0.9550996423,
0.0476038381,
-0.034429092,
0.2198437601,
0.2214155793,
-0.6143755317,
-0.7664360404,
-0.8665565848,
0.0179616734,
-0.9694884419,
0.0518663377,
-0.3838274479,
-0.0426680408,
-0.2506279945,
-0.0059039025,
-0.0997622162,
-0.2166516185,
0.1271496266,
0.4119377136,
0.1348568946,
0.7166113257,
0.0969178528,
-0.3192429841,
-0.8262555599,
0.3015283048,
0.6595273018,
0.267377466,
0.3124654293,
-0.3383207321,
-0.2025111318,
0.2220908701,
-0.1776708364,
-0.9355067015,
0.281305939,
0.2038971037,
0.6703915596,
0.611328125,
0.0470587984,
0.6954630613,
-0.5710217357,
0.7123052478,
0.3088315725,
-0.9334278107,
0.2357505262,
-0.8624684215,
0.3934565485,
0.3039123118,
0.2868815958,
-0.6816840768,
-0.1578930914,
0.1664773822,
-0.576914072,
0.0955301225,
0.23358652,
-0.0008177767,
0.0018229042,
-0.1790756136,
0.1272147,
0.4839090407,
-0.7589352727,
-0.1459093243,
-0.4975424707,
-0.190585494,
0.0421511196,
-0.3884862363,
0.0715567395,
-0.555131495,
0.7119844556,
-0.2752451003,
-0.2954365909,
0.0131475413,
-0.281283915,
-0.0034658255,
0.377540946,
0.5970982909,
0.9761688709,
0.1153571829,
0.2687212825,
0.0375851616,
-0.2517115474,
0.0347200148,
0.0413070992,
-0.0704781041,
-0.2035115212,
0.622690022,
0.4203354418,
0.2941482961,
-1.0319844484,
0.4559077024,
0.1781580895,
0.2471446097,
-0.230302006,
-0.3249451816,
0.2998605669,
0.5971195102,
0.4338083565,
0.0641065761,
0.3392285705,
-0.8997995853,
0.0404525213,
0.7723190784,
-0.2676951587,
-0.0281999204,
0.5422987342,
0.5442240834,
-0.2148971707,
0.4559275806,
-0.3333905637,
-0.710631609,
0.4567845762,
0.502454102,
0.7268336415,
-0.1459646523,
0.2222039849,
0.2956376672,
0.2354144901,
0.34393242,
0.606588304,
-0.2799277604,
-0.7732231617,
-0.4293392003,
-0.8182582855,
-0.5002678633,
-0.1589940041,
-0.386007458,
0.1292535663,
-0.2822088301,
-0.03936854,
-0.0227793101,
-0.0220667105,
-0.62561059,
-0.0522705764,
0.3143707216,
1.0944250822,
-0.4289201796,
0.9240516424,
0.8580117226,
-0.594682157,
-0.7749732137,
-0.2772678137,
0.0021427071,
-0.8173291683,
1.0734013319,
0.2688027024,
-0.7628593445,
-0.1007342935,
-0.2644233406,
-0.6927527189,
0.6542758346,
0.2028736025,
-0.536993444,
0.3363123536,
0.2820838988,
0.3988012075,
-0.4612314105,
0.2389467657,
0.3189795911,
0.8231874108,
0.1737454534,
-0.9807654619,
-0.0882481784,
-0.6929936409,
0.1424403489,
-0.0554878302,
-0.6941176057,
1.2391601801,
-0.393132478,
-0.0965315178,
0.4541319013,
0.7293336987,
0.2589278817,
0.2219079584,
0.4508136511,
0.104388684,
0.7224423885,
0.0402272418,
0.927548945,
-0.3841565549,
0.1688621193,
1.0500633717,
-0.6292649508,
1.3027281761,
0.4734699726,
-0.3451004922,
0.5965203047,
0.6812315583,
0.126628831,
0.2131870538,
0.3044810891,
-0.4137315452,
-0.6119783521,
-0.4913998842,
-0.590531528,
0.5605312586,
0.0117773935,
-0.149193123,
-0.1221833378,
0.1879887432,
-0.2386307269,
0.29101789,
-0.6314787269,
0.3392444849,
-0.1830244064,
-0.4676452577,
0.8567633629,
-0.1613935381,
0.6530843973,
-0.6262863874,
-0.3161318898,
-0.0096399402,
0.2715641856,
-0.1124822423,
-0.6880321503,
0.0665662587,
-0.0877892151,
-0.0632205978,
-0.0776960924,
0.6620313525,
-0.5953841209,
-0.9562982917,
0.2095927596,
0.6164354086,
0.0947052315,
-0.2724470794,
-0.6682723165,
0.3792794049,
-0.1987444907,
-0.2153308988,
0.0421227105,
0.4576654732,
-0.1655358672,
0.9970516562,
0.6885511279,
0.1232765019,
0.2621883154,
0.282027781,
0.6165040731,
-0.7823189497,
-0.4241396487,
-0.7987526655,
0.3940790892,
-0.3261448145,
-0.3084045947,
1.0653357506,
0.795301497,
0.2987047136,
-0.2775861919,
0.7737457752,
0.3625200391,
0.4639175236,
-0.3482798338,
1.0731374025,
-0.9292579293,
-0.0509290546,
-0.2022667378,
-0.8513375521,
-0.0862348676,
0.7507241964,
-0.0686871186,
0.2777440548,
0.7437850833,
0.6092882752,
0.0026359761,
0.2186766267,
0.6456922889,
0.4112468958,
0.2408814281,
0.5725799203,
1.4275393486,
0.0199482627,
0.5657593012,
-0.089256458,
-0.1417296231,
-0.3367234468,
-1.0584748983,
-1.2268291712,
-0.6791655421,
-0.2237672061,
-0.082903333,
0.1048685461,
1.0161163807,
1.0998113155,
-0.9333850741,
-0.3569257259,
0.1443423629,
0.1875984371,
-0.3994001448,
-0.1704286933,
0.3343197703,
-0.282857269,
-0.6658066511,
0.16398637,
0.5357733965,
0.1524502784,
-0.7241532207,
-0.154201895,
-0.2992661297,
0.1814976037,
0.9759430289,
0.2276007384,
-1.0735343695,
-0.2493015379,
-0.1598397493,
-0.1883419305,
-0.2704636455,
0.6345722079,
-0.7395654321,
0.323623538,
0.1987348348,
0.6791574955,
0.2943148017,
-0.3571356535,
0.4607890844,
-0.1698694527,
0.2965591252,
0.315027833,
0.7113208175,
0.512794435,
0.2389701456,
0.3887266815,
-0.0388152413,
-0.2220724225,
-0.8272234201,
0.5607908368,
-0.9678539634,
-0.4843926728,
1.134334445,
-0.1319889575,
-0.2128933072,
-0.4486635327,
-0.6149562597,
-0.0251509603,
-0.145367682,
0.6185309887,
0.7423282862,
0.0949248821,
-0.3496935964,
-0.4253148139,
0.4332652688,
0.3956342936,
-0.8532360792,
0.1811908931,
0.6013582349,
0.123070702,
-0.000654955,
0.2621691525,
0.2151426822,
0.611184299,
0.144294709,
-0.0825200528,
-0.3168648183,
-0.4451052845,
0.0767635033,
0.4822944999,
0.27898103,
-0.1750076264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01002v1
|
Attribute Structuring Improves LLM-Based Evaluation of Clinical Text Summaries
| 2024-03-01T21:59:03 | 2024-03-01T21:59:03 |
Zelalem Gero, Chandan Singh, Yiqing Xie, Sheng Zhang, Tristan Naumann, Jianfeng Gao, Hoifung Poon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Summarizing clinical text is crucial in health decision-support and clinical
research. Large language models (LLMs) have shown the potential to generate
accurate clinical text summaries, but still struggle with issues regarding
grounding and evaluation, especially in safety-critical domains such as health.
Holistically evaluating text summaries is challenging because they may contain
unsubstantiated information. Here, we explore a general mitigation framework
using Attribute Structuring (AS), which structures the summary evaluation
process. It decomposes the evaluation process into a grounded procedure that
uses an LLM for relatively simple structuring and scoring tasks, rather than
the full task of holistic summary evaluation. Experiments show that AS
consistently improves the correspondence between human annotations and
automated metrics in clinical text summarization. Additionally, AS yields
interpretations in the form of a short text span corresponding to each output,
which enables efficient human auditing, paving the way towards trustworthy
evaluation of clinical information in resource-constrained scenarios. We
release our code, prompts, and an open-source benchmark at
https://github.com/microsoft/attribute-structuring.
|
[
0.2756057382,
-0.463621974,
0.7115618587,
0.3774708211,
-0.3878525496,
-0.0295510031,
-0.1800681949,
-0.513525784,
0.1346698105,
0.3573675156,
-0.314971745,
-0.645280838,
-0.5244951844,
0.1150787473,
-0.0352258235,
1.3709447384,
-0.0822370946,
0.0667750239,
-0.8812625408,
-0.4269781113,
-0.2873341441,
-0.4929209054,
-0.6470822096,
-0.6225571632,
0.5796104074,
0.3943086565,
0.7873877287,
0.8819063306,
0.8959003091,
0.288069278,
-0.2455171943,
0.1520699561,
-0.3121842444,
0.3438298106,
0.111874193,
-0.2819570601,
-0.9694237113,
-0.1555465758,
0.5621197224,
0.9035516381,
-0.0747709274,
0.1765855849,
0.2160103023,
0.9278357029,
-0.6594964862,
0.1153136343,
-0.2990728319,
0.0219452456,
0.1554646343,
-0.5036563873,
-0.3262600899,
-0.1914824247,
0.3409059644,
-0.236232087,
0.2268340141,
-0.0514883548,
0.8151689172,
0.302803576,
-0.4105542898,
-0.2886715829,
-0.1828071475,
0.6029273272,
-0.5649772286,
0.3172214627,
0.6023418307,
0.0873760432,
0.1147491485,
-0.5446473956,
-0.0834930241,
-0.4469481111,
-0.3957581818,
0.2616880238,
-0.0799773633,
0.3020290136,
-0.0280271918,
0.5441408753,
-0.4207235873,
0.2603748441,
-0.3360010087,
-0.4736914933,
0.8937666416,
0.33302477,
0.3664367795,
-0.2674737275,
-0.2522990704,
-0.0130490409,
-0.8261730075,
-0.2030429989,
0.0236156601,
0.067000255,
-0.3707828224,
0.5810725689,
-0.1388599724,
0.1224533692,
-0.1007343903,
-0.4633810222,
0.411326766,
-0.3956058919,
-0.3895451427,
0.1560088098,
0.7276828289,
0.9048890471,
-0.1288923174,
-0.4228301644,
-0.0218045376,
0.0650515184,
0.3021241426,
-0.9720588326,
-0.3253732324,
0.589245975,
-0.7926577926,
-0.6741307974,
-0.2179152369,
-0.347178787,
-0.5428573489,
-0.2852092981,
0.1723000109,
-0.6256352067,
0.1639753431,
-0.0806101784,
-0.1120031476,
-0.1327950954,
0.7687012553,
-0.5210624337,
0.3579053879,
0.5284571052,
0.8552412391,
-0.3290522099,
-0.1463121027,
-0.737089932,
0.2544793189,
0.0240849797,
0.8298074603,
-0.305885613,
-0.5088467598,
-0.1422465891,
-0.2544011176,
0.2728807926,
-0.5455498099,
0.5305623412,
-0.0801839083,
0.1012856513,
-0.0438673794,
-0.3060401976,
0.2052451223,
0.178849414,
-0.6730208397,
0.9201713204,
0.0711490959,
-0.6169016361,
0.47168836,
-0.5398419499,
-0.7563006878,
0.020752646,
-0.2727422714,
-1.0221960545,
0.440268755,
0.306233108,
0.4691010416,
-0.3908997178,
0.0670395195,
-0.0815391988,
-0.0724937469,
0.3778509796,
-0.1059632301,
0.4295400083,
0.1480026543,
0.1222279444,
0.3896078467,
-0.8612785339,
0.0616738535,
-0.1744755358,
-0.2432237417,
-0.4326684177,
0.1355614364,
0.0836722851,
-0.0212200247,
0.0245740339,
-0.2126932293,
-0.0700113624,
-0.3945675194,
0.1748222411,
0.4671858251,
0.2382636964,
0.6129742861,
-0.5691793561,
0.4552898705,
0.0794484615,
-0.0427837595,
-0.3093294501,
-0.130527705,
-0.5362983346,
-0.5987814069,
0.0518137366,
0.350194633,
-0.5767353177,
0.4893014729,
-0.3841119409,
-0.5046419501,
-0.5797119141,
-0.0459901094,
0.8778763413,
0.6438029408,
0.4552276134,
-0.2085997015,
-0.2850345969,
-1.1383441687,
-0.3993412852,
-0.4423183501,
-0.4877415895,
0.1232945696,
0.6024464369,
-0.2261189222,
0.7474137545,
-0.678892374,
-0.6018576026,
-0.6620153785,
0.4241149724,
-0.1260605156,
0.4613149166,
0.4623534679,
-0.5435115695,
-0.1902832985,
0.0035350167,
-0.5720879436,
-0.6199735403,
-0.2598286867,
-0.0659284443,
0.0089209042,
0.2381930351,
-0.4569932222,
0.8716265559,
0.0127027854,
-0.3809542656,
0.7405791283,
-0.3977066875,
0.3308773935,
-0.7163572907,
0.2413094789,
-0.2103931457,
-0.3210234344,
-0.5552236438,
0.1795400977,
0.2318631709,
0.0826414824,
-0.26947245,
0.3285230696,
-0.4737996757,
0.2112192065,
-0.1652356982,
0.0819444954,
0.2672343254,
0.2733215094,
0.0869391784,
0.6667809486,
0.1187329367,
-0.6601825356,
-0.0777159631,
0.3860788345,
-0.2033959776,
0.8201286793,
-0.8477844,
-0.1051398516,
-0.4195316732,
0.1484108865,
-0.6779155135,
-0.2590661347,
-0.2337305993,
-0.4215411544,
0.2315082848,
0.1418123245,
-0.4037357569,
0.0627001971,
-0.9313809872,
0.3662120998,
0.0777694285,
-0.0063164262,
0.5818812251,
0.5087631941,
-0.2632506192,
-0.2334095985,
-0.8797242045,
0.1652083695,
-0.2210434824,
-0.6161575317,
0.6377471089,
-0.0378105454,
-0.3621135652,
0.0277077686,
-0.3595437407,
-0.1255468875,
0.4346629083,
0.2673765123,
0.400313884,
-0.0853349119,
0.4007833004,
0.0769478753,
-0.1874507368,
0.1018434986,
0.3241800666,
0.1539311111,
-0.0892341435,
-0.3803469539,
-0.5583744049,
0.540289104,
0.4622299671,
-0.2335730046,
0.8448013067,
0.1705487221,
-0.4605220556,
-0.2262227088,
-0.4620925486,
-0.0943234637,
-0.332375139,
0.7141962051,
-0.1071279943,
-0.7382662296,
0.6293281913,
0.2426450551,
-0.0292998105,
0.5323557854,
0.6807373166,
-0.266895026,
0.6423450708,
0.4931722879,
0.0665845573,
0.146373108,
0.116469875,
0.1584853232,
-0.884950161,
-0.3267403543,
-0.4832513332,
-0.2164392769,
-0.2109195441,
-0.4026127756,
0.9472809434,
0.0293700285,
0.1065682098,
-0.1123865992,
-0.4010752141,
0.5507784486,
0.0699363053,
0.4781111777,
0.5923956037,
0.0393373407,
-0.0780366436,
-0.1437833011,
-0.3710921407,
-0.6227397323,
1.0368168354,
0.5977569222,
0.6450234056,
0.211691618,
0.5678634048,
0.3441039622,
0.7948082685,
-0.712046802,
0.4049437642,
0.0452352315,
0.0085989451,
-0.2406978309,
-0.4881266356,
-0.5695416331,
0.459087342,
-0.3430716395,
-0.8544615507,
-0.1914645284,
0.1869240403,
-0.4687616229,
-0.1129238009,
-0.5813412666,
0.5748237967,
-0.2636760175,
-0.4381854236,
-0.2163388729,
-0.6766260862,
0.1893522888,
0.0242857113,
0.0101899346,
-0.0650761127,
-0.1418323368,
0.6206230521,
-0.8924079537,
0.619322896,
0.2272620797,
-0.0667121559,
-0.0136865107,
0.0410107523,
0.2899137437,
0.1860301793,
-0.0787406042,
0.0172478464,
0.1139691621,
-0.1138484925,
-0.8406729102,
0.3142385483,
-0.4845110476,
-0.4621526301,
-0.5433287621,
-0.5568168163,
-0.3502924442,
0.0897363052,
0.162382856,
0.6040991545,
-0.3101154268,
0.4403498769,
0.4190329611,
-0.3737382889,
0.1791906506,
0.4366903901,
0.106687434,
-0.7380577922,
0.4037871659,
-0.1194820702,
0.462490797,
0.5262399316,
0.283171922,
-0.2639467418,
-0.765424788,
-0.0997927561,
0.3337806761,
-0.7469897866,
-0.5239080787,
-0.592154026,
-0.1938436925,
-0.3138888478,
-0.2398663908,
-0.0455683433,
-0.489608705,
-0.116232127,
-0.3612312376,
0.2502337992,
0.5728849769,
0.227766484,
0.4489104152,
-0.7353518009,
0.253084898,
-0.0486505739,
0.4128844142,
0.1563615352,
-0.2504881024,
-0.4160470366,
-0.1874135137,
-0.4244198203,
-0.7806797028,
0.226622954,
0.3432810307,
0.42105937,
0.4633530676,
0.269310981,
1.0409626961,
-0.6916089058,
0.5925347209,
0.4416659772,
-0.9153139591,
0.6221846342,
-0.1116347238,
0.2455372214,
0.9392818809,
-0.1425124258,
-0.4235106707,
-0.6797571182,
-0.3499896526,
-1.1822115183,
0.5474544764,
0.646661222,
-0.4819846451,
0.1633726656,
0.1972641647,
0.0020035321,
0.3523107469,
-0.6855406165,
-0.3370730579,
0.1660915315,
-0.5318230391,
0.0209189039,
-0.6701819897,
-0.3571926355,
-0.2625565231,
0.3722602427,
-0.1455827504,
0.2350154072,
0.5434290767,
-0.5952529907,
0.0516779013,
0.4210301936,
0.5957747102,
0.7432947159,
-0.2512171865,
0.4004141092,
0.2046335191,
-0.688624084,
-0.0226083137,
-0.1609975994,
-0.0765767768,
-0.1306535453,
1.0520319939,
0.6061643362,
0.5267830491,
-0.6062081456,
0.6439108253,
0.0097293872,
-0.1728043854,
-0.0890291408,
-0.1060714871,
-0.146912843,
-0.0186752323,
0.4092354774,
-0.1982478499,
0.2344910204,
-0.3554872274,
0.2609724104,
0.3060373664,
-0.1732374579,
-0.3638584316,
0.6842170954,
0.1950057149,
-0.114046365,
0.3019336462,
0.1690706164,
-0.4032308757,
0.549454689,
0.5449331403,
1.1210976839,
-0.0939389244,
0.300080955,
-0.0472471751,
0.4002833962,
0.235725522,
0.1624400318,
-0.3591085374,
-0.3003764749,
-0.3122764826,
-0.6104876995,
-0.4988642633,
-0.0148296617,
-0.7165462375,
0.2216763645,
-0.3333548903,
0.098723948,
0.0430760011,
-0.1237642318,
-0.4376029074,
0.3176601231,
-0.0401796624,
0.846865356,
-0.790217936,
0.4279889762,
0.6757891178,
-0.5344847441,
-0.4678239226,
-0.06266509,
0.212235406,
-0.5753147006,
0.5101830959,
0.2857147753,
-0.0186462402,
-0.6058700085,
-0.3032284677,
-0.6264469624,
1.2427127361,
0.2900173962,
-0.045014251,
-0.0912842676,
0.3390268981,
0.8898824453,
-0.469366461,
0.4620016217,
0.5072826743,
0.2554157674,
0.0926143825,
-1.0219097137,
0.3104580343,
-0.4129288197,
0.0065863123,
-0.0237133056,
-0.2686142623,
0.4311569631,
-0.2746886611,
-0.2314834893,
0.1091898978,
0.6267668605,
0.2585529685,
0.54413414,
0.323825717,
0.516985476,
0.9555578232,
-0.103384614,
1.1320966482,
0.010441334,
0.1461934,
1.2568974495,
-0.3525754213,
0.5321992636,
0.3958755732,
-0.288559556,
0.3517303765,
0.21373716,
0.2951417267,
0.4624316394,
0.1276767254,
-0.2134448737,
-0.1180489063,
-0.2734079361,
-0.2620117664,
0.3619026244,
0.2316587567,
-0.5873150229,
-0.3424290717,
-0.1635228992,
0.2776471674,
0.0314907432,
-0.3878497779,
0.9764069319,
0.20370619,
-0.5688713789,
0.2195693851,
-0.0543931872,
0.0866289809,
-0.64431566,
-0.0240757931,
-0.1577204764,
0.2186216116,
-0.6041748524,
-0.6401145458,
0.4782868028,
0.1866805404,
-0.2702344656,
-0.4211735725,
0.6453151703,
-0.5341184139,
-0.4768067002,
-0.1293252707,
0.20890598,
-0.0109572392,
0.0409003347,
-0.2246440053,
0.094600752,
-0.1965036243,
-0.1170339808,
0.4131097198,
0.5437434316,
-0.3646296263,
0.6518999934,
0.5818968415,
0.4003654122,
-0.762671411,
0.2717800438,
1.0209827423,
-0.6859615445,
-0.8795666695,
-1.1160987616,
0.8661875129,
-0.4648981988,
-0.2912278175,
0.6907835603,
0.7024012208,
0.0936387703,
0.1146082208,
0.5476529598,
0.2077415437,
0.3796871006,
-0.6069610715,
1.2552486658,
-0.5512184501,
0.5175675154,
-0.4797694981,
-0.4206867218,
-0.8532336354,
0.5363427997,
-0.1742978394,
-0.2083255798,
0.9142974615,
0.4292989671,
0.2513907254,
-0.1434094161,
0.1111445948,
0.2610477209,
0.5372087359,
0.4342001081,
0.4642050564,
-0.1981346458,
0.1473108977,
-0.101107277,
-0.5193897486,
-0.2531032264,
-1.2368708849,
-1.0538799763,
-0.2670054436,
-0.5684775114,
-0.4745415449,
-0.0998797417,
0.9203116894,
0.3333699703,
-0.8178951144,
-0.0175563302,
0.2781708837,
0.3311454058,
-0.1969262511,
-0.162551403,
0.8411899209,
-0.2471547127,
-0.0988614559,
0.0630268529,
0.7491259575,
-0.1407232136,
0.0258686505,
-0.0918621048,
0.1840231717,
-0.2364244312,
0.7510067821,
-0.1099762842,
-0.5118806362,
-0.4359174371,
-0.2504093349,
-0.1844304353,
0.1257140189,
0.7831286192,
-0.6813600063,
0.3580057621,
0.2814433873,
0.6135444641,
0.1252341866,
0.2776162326,
0.7145431638,
-0.9453200102,
0.068147555,
0.3517186046,
0.3299150467,
0.2697965205,
-0.5280241966,
0.5226129293,
0.0646454021,
-0.3906395435,
-1.1061962843,
0.0497084633,
-0.9468541145,
0.0496121608,
1.0676002502,
-0.0093843378,
-0.3782963753,
-0.0084024724,
-0.1689225137,
0.0603102259,
-0.2347146124,
0.903219521,
0.578358233,
-0.241355285,
0.0171790421,
-0.0501212515,
0.6990743279,
0.4255053699,
-0.9934469461,
0.0798082128,
0.6567361355,
0.1038502455,
0.1232258603,
0.7650768757,
-0.2377353907,
0.5001448989,
-0.5660189986,
-0.101150617,
-0.3417107165,
-0.1340397298,
-0.413878262,
0.2107090056,
-0.2367768288,
-0.0589524508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00998v1
|
Predictions from language models for multiple-choice tasks are not robust under variation of scoring methods
| 2024-03-01T21:48:08 | 2024-03-01T21:48:08 |
Polina Tsvilodub, Hening Wang, Sharon Grosch, Michael Franke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper systematically compares different methods of deriving item-level
predictions of language models for multiple-choice tasks. It compares scoring
methods for answer options based on free generation of responses, various
probability-based scores, a Likert-scale style rating method, and embedding
similarity. In a case study on pragmatic language interpretation, we find that
LLM predictions are not robust under variation of method choice, both within a
single LLM and across different LLMs. As this variability entails pronounced
researcher degrees of freedom in reporting results, knowledge of the
variability is crucial to secure robustness of results and research integrity.
|
[
-0.1857457459,
-0.7395894527,
0.4098881781,
0.089871943,
-0.0943397507,
0.0938774273,
-0.2584286034,
-0.6757606268,
0.0802037492,
0.1986203343,
-0.4987576306,
-0.3341861069,
-0.6356322765,
0.1281994581,
-0.0613228716,
0.9090282321,
-0.1304694563,
0.3372126222,
-0.387557447,
-0.0534517169,
-0.3157151937,
-0.3971231282,
-0.3279358149,
-0.2401335686,
0.5137688518,
0.3863851726,
0.829967618,
0.4877990186,
0.7819001675,
0.1948622018,
0.0046499353,
0.0628916249,
-0.1737621576,
0.4469417632,
-0.026386166,
-0.850748539,
-0.3330297172,
0.2539922893,
0.4308924973,
0.2692080736,
-0.1878234148,
0.1066669822,
0.1588113457,
0.1338525116,
-0.5790753365,
0.1819017082,
-0.7199728489,
-0.292755723,
-0.1637393385,
0.0541110002,
-0.3985902965,
-0.2801204324,
0.2476278394,
-0.208090663,
0.1133652255,
0.1437420249,
0.7996624708,
0.1170503274,
-0.173056215,
-0.4960818589,
-0.6827751994,
1.2292183638,
-0.8532297611,
0.0432271138,
0.755651176,
0.5054716468,
0.0607478619,
-0.470202893,
-0.2397277802,
-0.5297543406,
0.2110836655,
0.1646285802,
0.2041024268,
0.0171042234,
0.0802092031,
0.4293288589,
-0.4842088223,
0.2265440822,
-0.1487720758,
-0.1417239159,
0.7509459257,
0.1920218617,
-0.0243518241,
-0.4096308649,
-0.4730739295,
-0.1298930496,
-0.5529729128,
0.3971891701,
0.5397284627,
0.6137881875,
-0.0954789296,
0.7143819928,
-0.1489825547,
0.8202386498,
-0.1149557978,
-0.6443198323,
0.3295525014,
-0.2886733413,
-0.3172344863,
-0.6076239944,
0.7872610092,
0.4503352344,
0.0624268092,
0.0323124826,
-0.2226901054,
0.0315068737,
-0.0378867388,
-0.2375714034,
-0.0407293513,
0.1970811784,
-0.5160498023,
-0.3789319992,
-0.0110294838,
-0.9249612689,
-0.3441778123,
0.0429217257,
0.2335027456,
-0.3630212843,
-0.2435395867,
0.0823974386,
0.0099723451,
0.2368852794,
0.4604273438,
-0.6601889133,
0.0944396034,
0.4186848998,
0.5751873255,
-0.4939306974,
-0.5751255155,
-0.2631984651,
-0.3852517605,
-0.3738929927,
0.8277643323,
-0.6649419069,
-0.6359528303,
0.0487984642,
-0.2587476671,
-0.098176308,
-0.4620887935,
0.6885324121,
-0.2642228305,
0.3840252459,
-0.315384686,
-0.4057534039,
-0.11721652,
0.0873403996,
-0.5238383412,
0.9028853774,
0.1969212592,
-0.9864977598,
0.6383210421,
-0.2135380805,
-0.2229426652,
-0.024247326,
-0.4134784341,
-0.3403356373,
0.2625447512,
-0.1431513876,
0.3081930578,
-0.1439516395,
0.339220047,
-0.6752173901,
-0.1259186119,
0.7272791266,
-0.7045840621,
0.7644221783,
0.2803654075,
-0.2164669484,
0.0532644354,
-0.7662656307,
0.2177441418,
0.0453335941,
-0.6295241117,
-0.1869176179,
0.292853415,
-0.0956165344,
0.4804724455,
0.3699005246,
-0.5917935967,
0.0483756661,
-0.343467921,
-0.0014013726,
0.8313645124,
-0.2886933088,
0.2617696524,
-0.8281693459,
0.9098414183,
-0.1061807871,
-0.1355528533,
0.3257097006,
-0.7757992744,
-0.4768998623,
-0.1282041818,
0.3772056103,
0.7252134681,
-0.4873781502,
0.0014772275,
-0.1436378211,
-0.585544467,
-0.6910125613,
-0.0741324574,
0.4655170441,
0.2602766454,
0.167401433,
-0.2065447569,
-0.5283660889,
-0.8814641237,
-0.7865368724,
-0.3849908412,
-0.0836022571,
0.3970009685,
0.4271045625,
0.2306897938,
0.8072081208,
-0.3092100024,
0.1095287129,
-0.441644609,
0.2647892237,
0.1136295944,
0.2897359431,
0.5384577513,
-0.6742097139,
-0.4930588305,
-0.297760576,
-0.4364553988,
0.1003082991,
0.1893442422,
0.4084481299,
0.170862034,
0.1236597523,
-0.515651226,
0.4598209262,
0.706831336,
-0.2957199216,
0.8929978013,
0.1016716436,
0.1502497196,
-1.0668456554,
-0.3172146082,
0.1039000526,
-0.1554335505,
-0.6978572607,
0.1716972142,
-0.0340338238,
0.1987868249,
-0.5040620565,
0.4363131225,
-0.1530910134,
-0.0240038261,
-0.2939076424,
-0.0696469769,
-0.0877813026,
0.2076378912,
0.034166012,
0.8208333254,
0.5913984179,
-0.4122484922,
0.1207026243,
0.0021828956,
-0.4923756421,
0.3309700489,
-0.3059522808,
0.1373586357,
-0.1249449104,
-0.1960451603,
-1.2078216076,
-0.3515619338,
0.0633193552,
-0.6846876144,
0.4937635362,
0.2534412742,
-0.3767172694,
-0.2650621533,
-0.609102428,
0.1043562517,
0.3651421964,
-0.0792385414,
0.4804457128,
0.1696854979,
-0.2619192302,
-0.9460710287,
-1.2456005812,
-0.4195581377,
-0.5587047338,
-0.3260654807,
0.0850736797,
-0.4974090159,
-0.7585622072,
-0.2120807618,
-0.4148564339,
0.0208992716,
0.4177617431,
0.2344893813,
0.4362668395,
-0.1207552031,
0.0341448672,
-0.1745252758,
-0.0229604859,
-0.0119592957,
0.2075390518,
0.1728409827,
-0.0904345959,
-0.5959361196,
0.0789625198,
0.547308743,
0.4212900102,
0.0219437331,
0.674089551,
0.1509861052,
-0.2898937464,
-0.138776049,
-0.471811235,
0.0140734473,
-0.4346790314,
0.2326768488,
-0.568878293,
-1.0382614136,
0.4427441359,
0.3748477399,
0.3222001493,
0.5851397514,
0.753937602,
-0.2438286394,
1.0336425304,
0.4347093105,
0.268127799,
0.4898673892,
0.2785459757,
0.1717530042,
-0.5132903457,
0.0370039046,
-0.9108144641,
-0.1510873437,
-1.0075862408,
-0.4435088634,
0.0138125736,
0.1144087017,
-0.0564189926,
0.1426701695,
-0.2963706851,
0.2857930362,
0.6985330582,
-0.2167573273,
0.2955593765,
0.1864245683,
-0.2387944907,
-0.2761602998,
-0.5592923164,
-0.5655992627,
1.5329493284,
0.2699992657,
0.9750025272,
0.1188892499,
0.8121204376,
-0.024823267,
0.3633188605,
-0.7160156369,
0.5137078166,
-0.1821765006,
-0.7638739347,
-0.4676680863,
-0.3896095157,
-0.767865181,
0.5311088562,
-0.0958018675,
-1.0840591192,
0.1945032775,
-0.3488659561,
-0.268142432,
0.2246063501,
-0.5409474373,
0.2777934074,
-0.1882365197,
-0.1688788384,
0.1983649433,
-0.6418176889,
0.1959370822,
-0.0626070052,
0.547000885,
-0.36401546,
0.0762570724,
0.8218511939,
0.2124845088,
0.9026236534,
0.0651637465,
-0.0912957788,
0.4034744799,
0.4286871552,
0.2578222752,
0.1485708505,
-0.6474843025,
0.056079261,
-0.1567294598,
-0.3682995439,
-0.2302350849,
0.6711617112,
-0.8552104831,
-0.9611603022,
-0.6035715938,
-0.8002583385,
-0.4993296266,
0.1398878098,
0.7282006741,
0.2199734598,
-0.1401248872,
0.1495952755,
0.4117450714,
0.0099036498,
0.6500815749,
0.3674793243,
-0.1089021787,
-0.3348158896,
0.538862586,
0.3626357019,
0.4720241129,
0.438873142,
0.1498644054,
-0.3754106164,
-0.7010943294,
-0.017255079,
-0.0468597226,
-0.9084618688,
-0.261480093,
-0.0692863166,
-0.0641255006,
-0.3663958907,
-0.1060977429,
-0.0910815895,
-0.585606873,
-0.508997798,
-0.6152772307,
0.0914687961,
0.7108717561,
-0.1789511144,
0.0259048063,
-0.2958842218,
0.020693427,
0.2457505018,
0.4144287705,
-0.2774918079,
-0.585913837,
-0.2511609495,
0.0806269795,
-0.4497876465,
-1.0477371216,
0.3994362354,
0.1705967337,
0.8195744157,
0.2845428884,
-0.0878864974,
0.28688398,
-0.0767161921,
1.1544684172,
0.2432920486,
-0.6799226999,
0.5620240569,
-0.3039970696,
0.1391324997,
0.5190314054,
0.4155079126,
-0.0239552222,
-0.589256227,
-0.779019773,
-0.5818176866,
0.6957064271,
-0.1210491061,
0.0076109869,
-0.0892134681,
-0.0080820257,
0.6752700806,
0.3535269499,
-1.1028465033,
-0.4881329834,
-0.1751061827,
-0.0859177411,
-0.4151605666,
-0.4320906103,
-0.1565680653,
0.0370432995,
0.4299823046,
-0.0706365928,
0.3778659701,
0.2322997749,
0.1197747886,
-0.2628175914,
0.5529728532,
0.6333602667,
0.9789738059,
-0.2257840931,
0.2181999534,
0.3009446263,
-0.2270540744,
0.084404327,
-0.0044328729,
-0.0520762093,
0.1683391631,
0.5605459213,
0.8854923844,
-0.0087701976,
-0.6223733425,
0.2827090025,
-0.0349831581,
-0.4652760327,
-0.0066752033,
0.0878694132,
0.0798325613,
0.1118441075,
0.1903437078,
0.1194006801,
0.0431977771,
-0.3866077065,
0.0338720642,
0.3900419772,
-0.2892476022,
-0.2521198392,
0.4783683121,
-0.3155415356,
-0.5987946391,
0.3083713651,
-0.2300368994,
-0.0150608886,
0.6268273592,
0.6275007129,
0.7936679125,
-0.7165879607,
0.2865374982,
-0.0036460396,
0.1613000333,
-0.1739819199,
0.7697073817,
0.3732841611,
-0.7657626271,
-0.4925667644,
-0.6747921109,
-0.4575501978,
0.3756518364,
-0.7052870989,
-0.0143409828,
-0.2904922366,
-0.4836563766,
-0.2115893215,
0.0069513009,
-0.6577432752,
0.2968879938,
-0.0071890932,
0.9176626205,
-0.8256049752,
0.7173103094,
0.8562479019,
-0.3046203554,
-1.0606513023,
0.1511985511,
0.058650326,
-0.670437634,
0.3558172882,
0.0580489114,
-0.0615466684,
-0.4984688461,
-0.4297794104,
-0.9756480455,
0.9059435725,
0.3390665054,
-0.4140331447,
-0.2105494291,
0.225961253,
0.4517044723,
-0.4926144779,
0.393992275,
0.3242864609,
0.3255878389,
-0.1945910603,
-1.1263136864,
-0.1692659557,
0.0749950856,
0.0408359729,
-0.0704286844,
-0.4614190459,
1.2797567844,
-0.1726207286,
-0.0445867851,
0.115531221,
0.4796145856,
0.5164830685,
0.2959115505,
0.2111559957,
0.3675516546,
0.8076607585,
-0.1131417602,
1.1376607418,
-0.1823205352,
0.6591435075,
1.0444819927,
-0.2774320543,
1.0435265303,
0.4854563773,
-0.4754044712,
0.6651751399,
0.8007516265,
-0.000409738,
0.623495996,
0.263368696,
-0.0951069295,
-0.3201577961,
0.1810958833,
-0.219566524,
0.6748110056,
0.4190528691,
-0.3391360343,
-0.1937651038,
-0.0760655776,
-0.1371836066,
-0.0375179015,
-0.1943498552,
0.6293056011,
0.2440146059,
-0.8444965482,
0.4560487866,
0.1188064069,
0.8475580812,
-0.4205719829,
0.320429951,
-0.0681178272,
-0.0728846043,
-0.164478004,
-0.9760827422,
0.2260140181,
-0.1700762063,
-0.0974772498,
-0.1818261892,
0.9967550635,
-0.0416634642,
-0.37471053,
0.3495394588,
1.03967309,
-0.0284657571,
0.3536570966,
-0.8432796001,
-0.2473831773,
0.1976965815,
-0.608854115,
0.7247314453,
0.1211635843,
-0.0750427917,
0.8931110501,
0.4593533278,
0.1523037553,
0.1600244194,
-0.1891603172,
0.3662044108,
-0.3734616041,
-0.3869609535,
-0.9167568684,
0.450003475,
0.299639672,
-0.3900678456,
0.7742016912,
0.2861412168,
0.7929288745,
-0.1914274991,
1.002802372,
0.0228266232,
0.7782803178,
-0.2436077297,
0.11282067,
-0.4857019782,
0.3142487407,
-0.1942343563,
-0.6041396856,
-0.2107007354,
0.5086494684,
-0.6387637258,
0.3109861314,
0.8255375028,
0.6118135452,
0.1768781841,
0.0858412534,
0.4104442,
0.0639969558,
0.0214064866,
0.358084023,
0.9449773431,
0.1210908815,
0.566619873,
-0.1146766916,
-0.2444432229,
-0.3314068913,
-0.824249208,
-0.6922553778,
-0.5402895808,
-0.1582285911,
-0.4750338197,
-0.0820339173,
0.6376973987,
0.5202149749,
-0.8638496399,
-0.4518725276,
-0.1017192304,
0.2612983584,
-0.486278832,
-0.2814432085,
0.1812545508,
-0.3034547865,
-0.6094378829,
0.5617867112,
0.0955840573,
0.0823820159,
-0.1834767014,
0.1130911335,
-0.1198711544,
0.2606452107,
0.0412867926,
0.0534949824,
-1.0437791348,
-0.4334274828,
0.0644051209,
-0.174077332,
0.3870458007,
0.5218334198,
-0.4439574182,
0.2575655282,
0.7069596648,
0.2595937252,
0.1343173534,
-0.0632336885,
0.5345820189,
-0.7295651436,
-0.1234867647,
0.4411844909,
0.4776861668,
0.2135166824,
-0.2832634151,
0.1866591424,
0.0088546621,
-0.7270098329,
-0.8183376193,
0.818789959,
-0.8194056153,
-0.5345891118,
1.3047508001,
-0.6026115417,
0.1016517207,
-0.2632344067,
0.0558018461,
0.1336967796,
-0.3667826653,
0.6768915653,
1.1424455643,
-0.3225666583,
-0.0975251049,
-0.7638106942,
0.626553297,
0.4276130199,
-0.4713464081,
0.045410946,
0.1529568434,
0.5400626063,
0.3748387694,
0.5452930331,
0.0338098407,
0.21312204,
0.16461505,
-0.3398686349,
0.2255452424,
-0.1791853756,
-0.4961493015,
0.4830886722,
0.7313068509,
-0.1012521461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00994v1
|
Leveraging Prompt-Based Large Language Models: Predicting Pandemic Health Decisions and Outcomes Through Social Media Language
| 2024-03-01T21:29:32 | 2024-03-01T21:29:32 |
Xiaohan Ding, Buse Carik, Uma Sushmitha Gunturi, Valerie Reyna, Eugenia H. Rho
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
We introduce a multi-step reasoning framework using prompt-based LLMs to
examine the relationship between social media language patterns and trends in
national health outcomes. Grounded in fuzzy-trace theory, which emphasizes the
importance of gists of causal coherence in effective health communication, we
introduce Role-Based Incremental Coaching (RBIC), a prompt-based LLM framework,
to identify gists at-scale. Using RBIC, we systematically extract gists from
subreddit discussions opposing COVID-19 health measures (Study 1). We then
track how these gists evolve across key events (Study 2) and assess their
influence on online engagement (Study 3). Finally, we investigate how the
volume of gists is associated with national health trends like vaccine uptake
and hospitalizations (Study 4). Our work is the first to empirically link
social media linguistic patterns to real-world public health trends,
highlighting the potential of prompt-based LLMs in identifying critical online
discussion patterns that can form the basis of public health communication
strategies.
|
[
-0.1711231768,
-1.2023143768,
0.8421404958,
0.3859294951,
-0.2544156313,
0.1605307758,
-0.2111507356,
-0.3416607082,
0.6646620035,
0.1827532202,
-0.7882515788,
-0.6635228395,
-0.7064424753,
0.2631645799,
-0.3659272194,
0.9455993176,
0.2076707184,
0.3029465973,
-0.1878446341,
0.3873730898,
-0.3785177767,
-0.3360953927,
-1.0886861086,
-0.2165693641,
0.9146559238,
0.8931767344,
0.5521988869,
0.3941348195,
0.5414412022,
0.1195646524,
-0.1566998065,
-0.0699585006,
-0.3914716542,
0.232300967,
-0.2048468739,
-0.223745808,
-0.1968718767,
0.1111506522,
0.1620948911,
0.4865531027,
-0.2584102154,
0.3169108629,
0.132800743,
0.3317600787,
-0.238602981,
0.2344408035,
-0.3283153772,
-0.1200382411,
0.0565937646,
-0.4289103746,
-0.16966708,
-0.4311471283,
0.2320663035,
-0.3015466332,
0.0815854967,
-0.4143355787,
0.5517553687,
0.0010182979,
-0.5159066916,
-0.5155875683,
-0.5444009304,
0.4286126494,
-0.7480334044,
0.2668773532,
0.7542900443,
0.4172421396,
-0.3591513336,
-0.6318569779,
-0.3230090141,
-0.1383634061,
0.234292537,
0.0644081756,
-0.1085026711,
0.0469594486,
0.0977236629,
0.02684463,
-0.6388453245,
-0.0515576713,
-0.3177992702,
-0.0760041773,
0.8086878657,
0.1638596356,
0.5202512145,
-0.3562530875,
-0.1387083232,
0.3695858419,
-0.4059253037,
0.4899728298,
-0.123554714,
0.4444226325,
-0.5684063435,
0.2362446636,
-0.1641099602,
0.3686939776,
0.2950342,
-0.6563176513,
-0.0944751799,
-0.5576040149,
-0.0278656743,
0.2412157804,
0.7084037662,
0.3775475919,
0.1031932011,
0.0746879727,
0.3359040022,
0.1297191828,
0.2205170095,
-0.7746243477,
-0.1904443055,
0.2530040443,
-0.5473687649,
-0.1394766569,
0.1281022578,
-0.8606482744,
-0.812297821,
-0.2109680474,
0.12832883,
-0.3795284331,
-0.1677626967,
0.071397379,
-0.144603461,
0.2828325927,
0.5966402888,
-0.4377660155,
0.1281998158,
0.8827542663,
1.0746951103,
0.0676620752,
0.0975597501,
-0.5634704232,
-0.2001173794,
-0.4779919088,
0.8377354741,
-0.6043661833,
-0.2882788181,
0.3822593689,
-0.1128085405,
-0.056303326,
-0.2351607233,
0.5748448968,
-0.2609080672,
0.1364329755,
-0.5615587234,
-0.305562675,
-0.0640872791,
0.3227573931,
-0.3851523995,
0.6632006168,
-0.2224195153,
-0.837738812,
0.4154578149,
-0.4123638272,
-0.8337495923,
0.123135604,
-0.3008692563,
-0.4040501416,
-0.1444039047,
0.3640046418,
0.8604815006,
-0.7544817924,
0.607899487,
-0.6770557761,
-0.1758028418,
0.1660281718,
-0.2828988135,
0.6850401163,
0.2151733041,
-0.3567616642,
0.2484989166,
-0.5111546516,
-0.2804263532,
-0.0486878939,
-0.1961878687,
-0.3560250401,
0.3455910087,
-0.4137090147,
0.3197952509,
-0.0665677339,
-0.0779199004,
0.0836193413,
-0.1713853031,
0.6527327299,
0.3608136177,
0.7232230306,
0.2134705335,
-0.5177872777,
0.7031741142,
-0.0871447772,
0.64814502,
-0.4304017425,
-0.9255139232,
-0.1848058552,
-0.5799304247,
-0.3343993127,
0.6361670494,
-0.7058746815,
0.4090717733,
-0.2429062426,
-0.6784310341,
-0.2805019915,
-0.019841861,
0.0354270414,
0.5614180565,
0.3485680819,
0.002243395,
-0.4632927179,
-0.6031136513,
-0.347089529,
-0.376642704,
0.3420046866,
0.1959369332,
0.1863798946,
-0.3174159527,
0.7034822106,
-0.1468482465,
0.0336593278,
-0.5416943431,
0.3783825934,
0.2476654351,
0.0098224254,
0.2546399534,
-0.6209366322,
-0.6298040748,
-0.1223503202,
-0.6880421638,
-0.4012539983,
-0.2636052072,
0.1474040449,
-0.1982453465,
0.6997409463,
-0.3975450695,
0.5270570517,
0.5477021337,
-0.4356413484,
0.4048677981,
0.0993736312,
0.5706428289,
-1.2975150347,
-0.2438946962,
0.4911819696,
-0.0964211375,
-0.83748734,
-0.3377864063,
-0.0685965642,
-0.2165188938,
-0.3401131928,
0.4623661935,
-0.2398062944,
0.2756757438,
-0.1940138936,
-0.1832059026,
-0.1473233551,
-0.1954837292,
-0.2272173762,
0.7015365362,
0.6665964723,
-0.6211118698,
0.2987308204,
0.0537494533,
-0.4732892215,
0.609269619,
-0.6583983898,
-0.4091014564,
-0.166493535,
0.4811589718,
-1.0074197054,
-0.5709070563,
0.452078104,
-0.5591643453,
-0.0806921571,
0.0196643248,
-0.3942794204,
-0.6458932757,
-0.3798024952,
0.0038652148,
0.2981996834,
-0.1908002943,
0.2613659203,
0.623993814,
-0.6372125745,
-0.2314145267,
-0.6377606392,
0.2031228691,
-0.3156523705,
-0.7446754575,
-0.1087003946,
-0.0302715991,
-0.5387618542,
-0.2618927956,
-0.0729824007,
-0.1643587202,
0.3715897202,
0.3481644988,
0.0602864958,
-0.1424916536,
0.2597125769,
0.03605932,
0.174249962,
0.2083507776,
-0.0711370409,
0.615093112,
0.0432716906,
-0.32697016,
-0.6913356185,
0.7105680704,
0.6386063695,
0.1227034852,
0.6283337474,
0.4060639143,
-0.2887366712,
0.1548957229,
-0.5378356576,
-0.3325846195,
-0.3708486259,
0.0544868484,
0.1845299006,
-0.8329448104,
0.606464386,
-0.0557394177,
-0.3135154843,
0.0929703116,
0.5657855272,
-0.0506816916,
0.8935843706,
0.403747946,
-0.1055115983,
0.6162696481,
0.0065138866,
0.1808452308,
-0.200018242,
-0.2976841629,
-0.4655429423,
0.0087140528,
-0.5303385258,
-0.5336169004,
0.6407677531,
0.3256228268,
-0.3439263701,
0.1488471478,
-0.2328514457,
0.0763407052,
0.4547379017,
0.3123520613,
0.0227271579,
-0.2037319541,
-0.1068708301,
0.0498206876,
-0.8964425325,
-0.420488894,
0.4608199,
0.2119241804,
0.9229226112,
0.0672899187,
0.6075576544,
0.6286796331,
0.2017824799,
-0.8568056226,
0.4532631934,
0.1877756864,
-0.3801603913,
-0.1914027929,
-0.3460382223,
-1.052339077,
-0.1904785931,
-0.2820704877,
-0.7162483335,
0.1123478636,
0.0787218884,
-0.5804125667,
-0.0992768705,
-0.6237286329,
0.6053655744,
-0.2690913677,
-0.4084922373,
-0.3544121683,
-0.8724920154,
0.1753670275,
0.0684937611,
0.6363525391,
-0.3624366522,
0.1620389372,
0.4603711665,
-0.3234145343,
1.1346398592,
0.1974472702,
-0.1271854192,
0.5028269887,
-0.2720297873,
0.4120742083,
0.6033686996,
-0.1382886469,
0.2568723857,
-0.030891221,
-0.4340868294,
-0.3323676884,
0.8284347057,
-0.6629937291,
-0.9231973886,
-0.5825157762,
-0.0197990984,
-0.24736844,
0.0569344088,
0.0459987223,
0.4757735729,
-0.4507330358,
-0.0516811199,
0.6275771856,
-0.4424388111,
0.4936367571,
0.4871345162,
-0.0175646562,
-0.5908170938,
0.5447016954,
0.1265953183,
0.1270386577,
0.4440788925,
0.7642073035,
-0.0502477996,
-0.2042159736,
-0.1162892953,
0.3186662495,
-0.6421610713,
-0.3257082701,
-0.6213807464,
-0.2271181047,
-0.9371052384,
-0.4245293736,
0.1713770628,
0.1451860219,
-0.5515754223,
-0.1562633812,
0.7051010728,
0.9147416353,
-0.4769394696,
0.2314536422,
-0.9630484581,
0.2075705677,
0.3024012148,
0.2154341191,
0.039117869,
-0.2737772167,
-0.4026781619,
0.2332197875,
-0.0305540748,
-1.3940997124,
0.3530739248,
0.025823338,
0.6648765802,
0.7023411393,
0.0968217924,
0.7405579686,
-0.5450100303,
1.0686937571,
0.4361333549,
-0.7806558609,
0.7850785851,
-0.6618607044,
0.3686214983,
0.5452542901,
0.7132379413,
-1.1187295914,
-0.3375165164,
-0.5408015251,
-0.8133546114,
0.4977422357,
-0.4505479634,
-0.0402994789,
-0.5989417434,
0.1253881752,
0.1849923581,
-0.0258621853,
-0.1458458304,
-0.1896698177,
-0.1566252261,
-0.1163463071,
-0.0440989509,
-0.4911490679,
-0.0594959855,
-0.3951352835,
0.5913128257,
-0.0898733139,
0.1811158061,
0.4194217026,
0.1622778326,
-0.2188093513,
0.447897613,
0.7635350823,
0.6886576414,
0.0680951178,
0.3077940643,
-0.1535887122,
-0.3943789899,
0.1277165264,
0.0535996407,
-0.0718994141,
0.0643518046,
0.5457744002,
0.6754385829,
0.3836333156,
-0.5388328433,
0.6305837035,
0.051013004,
0.0499382652,
-0.2833367288,
-0.0057258415,
0.319249481,
0.388426125,
0.441587925,
-0.1965911686,
0.1670577675,
-0.6106179357,
0.573048234,
0.4535262585,
-0.4235816598,
-0.5832127929,
0.4376583397,
0.3251484036,
-0.4123733044,
-0.0325608402,
0.1303485036,
-0.1372803897,
0.5746976733,
0.2515021265,
0.7066183686,
-0.444070816,
0.7576680779,
0.5073176026,
0.2236705422,
-0.5128726363,
0.3924378753,
0.1080749631,
-0.2945096195,
-0.6424654722,
-0.2884224057,
-0.2928050458,
0.2265766859,
-0.6852859855,
0.5803631544,
-0.4923011065,
-0.3538772762,
0.236169219,
-0.1113448516,
-0.5978041291,
0.0227482654,
0.4193793237,
0.9838536978,
-1.0410963297,
0.638023138,
0.6358925104,
-0.627210319,
-0.9192473888,
0.5994873047,
0.2978649437,
-0.7851985097,
0.2501633465,
0.3610619307,
0.0254666582,
-0.2015235722,
-0.8504208326,
-1.0130449533,
1.0533419847,
0.3171763122,
-0.3375397325,
0.1396094561,
0.2357692868,
0.4990758002,
-0.3885154128,
0.2983707488,
0.1470810622,
0.4650181234,
0.2271198779,
-1.0336230993,
-0.0562349819,
-0.1051447242,
-0.0722483918,
-0.1425991803,
-0.5389489532,
0.6067636609,
-0.4959208071,
-0.5123471022,
-0.2461927384,
0.5325332284,
0.019097073,
0.6804571152,
0.179448694,
0.2793252766,
0.852371335,
0.2640593946,
1.17019701,
-0.3338024914,
0.1879737973,
0.9997313023,
-0.2461959124,
0.671969533,
0.3390921354,
0.0769413039,
0.6284911036,
0.7797754407,
0.4670285285,
0.5709883571,
0.1033906713,
-0.3755264878,
-0.4798291028,
-0.3455830216,
-0.4160017967,
0.1892046481,
0.6612017155,
-0.5344329476,
-0.4374588728,
0.2462503761,
0.3186921775,
0.1604287028,
-0.5057269335,
0.9708794355,
0.2452911288,
-0.6174574494,
0.4276921451,
-0.1301400959,
0.5908327103,
-0.6144731045,
-0.1589425355,
-0.1456245482,
-0.0780700445,
-0.0188891683,
-0.7244834304,
0.3934245706,
-0.1140936017,
-0.354676187,
-0.2309143543,
0.8864302039,
-0.6080246568,
-0.4996813238,
0.397213757,
0.9040037394,
0.0002692948,
-0.0338047445,
-0.8154546618,
0.129486382,
-0.3788997829,
-0.1305394322,
0.3053724766,
0.5617957711,
-0.2486084402,
0.6243390441,
0.6454874277,
0.194240272,
-0.0534214824,
0.0106533868,
0.5371147394,
-0.532486558,
-0.6333708763,
-1.0311532021,
0.1707440466,
-0.2257173359,
-0.0645541027,
0.8278357387,
0.1299292594,
0.4790491462,
0.1385342181,
1.1026732922,
0.0083874092,
0.6832590699,
-0.1479165405,
0.7570957541,
-0.3706148565,
0.0530942902,
-0.0328739956,
0.018011475,
-0.429068625,
0.5428173542,
-0.6815891862,
-0.3553648293,
0.5472747684,
0.6609658003,
0.4184719026,
0.1051043794,
0.2586782873,
0.2229105681,
0.4179596901,
-0.0498078205,
0.7565584183,
0.0986161157,
0.3010336757,
0.0119478004,
-0.3530631661,
-0.4923501611,
-0.8245835304,
-0.9904913306,
-0.5384904742,
-0.3181485832,
-0.6016369462,
0.4478919506,
1.4883055687,
0.2939526737,
-0.7993983626,
-0.071034871,
-0.2270334512,
0.2713378966,
-0.3958422244,
-0.3154240251,
0.1614166796,
-0.284416616,
-0.1797054112,
0.3040372133,
0.4681412876,
-0.1682823598,
-0.1617216468,
0.1442284137,
-0.5943405628,
0.3999101818,
0.8332254291,
0.3652332127,
-0.8309777379,
-0.2976330817,
0.2178870738,
-0.5890785456,
0.0108776353,
0.9475111961,
-0.5316695571,
0.2598624527,
0.6922034621,
0.5315440893,
-0.2423327714,
0.0242658071,
0.5566954613,
-0.355981797,
-0.2369154245,
0.2321445942,
0.2784154713,
0.5399882197,
-0.4077655077,
0.3515712619,
0.4488822222,
-0.3455834389,
-0.4193587601,
0.1952293515,
-0.8859564662,
-0.3482476473,
1.909697175,
0.0159337781,
-0.2225348204,
-0.4542602897,
-0.1680636555,
0.4189085662,
-0.8278167248,
0.9727607369,
0.665219605,
-0.1521343291,
-0.255751878,
-0.4908643067,
0.5800508261,
-0.0425342731,
-0.9352160692,
-0.0683712587,
0.4686416984,
0.205970183,
-0.0940321609,
0.9511116147,
0.216970861,
0.1955430955,
-0.2439780086,
-0.1941576153,
0.1798123866,
-0.3325168192,
-0.2533432841,
0.0052196262,
-0.175456509,
0.2207406163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00990v1
|
Formulation Comparison for Timeline Construction using LLMs
| 2024-03-01T21:24:24 | 2024-03-01T21:24:24 |
Kimihiro Hasegawa, Nikhil Kandukuri, Susan Holm, Yukari Yamakawa, Teruko Mitamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Constructing a timeline requires identifying the chronological order of
events in an article. In prior timeline construction datasets, temporal orders
are typically annotated by either event-to-time anchoring or event-to-event
pairwise ordering, both of which suffer from missing temporal information. To
mitigate the issue, we develop a new evaluation dataset, TimeSET, consisting of
single-document timelines with document-level order annotation. TimeSET
features saliency-based event selection and partial ordering, which enable a
practical annotation workload. Aiming to build better automatic timeline
construction systems, we propose a novel evaluation framework to compare
multiple task formulations with TimeSET by prompting open LLMs, i.e., Llama 2
and Flan-T5. Considering that identifying temporal orders of events is a core
subtask in timeline construction, we further benchmark open LLMs on existing
event temporal ordering datasets to gain a robust understanding of their
capabilities. Our experiments show that (1) NLI formulation with Flan-T5
demonstrates a strong performance among others, while (2) timeline construction
and event temporal ordering are still challenging tasks for few-shot LLMs. Our
code and data are available at https://github.com/kimihiroh/timeset.
|
[
-0.0972406492,
-0.628790915,
0.5982359648,
0.6539088488,
-0.2677928507,
-0.0754908472,
0.0702692196,
-0.5220009089,
0.1862405837,
0.2076312453,
-0.8338827491,
-0.5625682473,
-0.4457866549,
0.0892035514,
-0.2512612343,
0.8039172292,
-0.3307320774,
-0.2620091438,
-0.1536920369,
-0.2722264528,
-0.1240963563,
-0.2380948514,
-0.6683946848,
-0.4408074021,
0.593993187,
-0.0490809418,
0.6423177123,
0.9139477015,
0.5532604456,
0.2253871709,
-0.2199224532,
0.4199765325,
-0.2743749619,
-0.0672633424,
0.1040972471,
-0.3236649334,
-0.8312042356,
0.069269672,
0.6083715558,
0.6641280651,
0.0768601149,
0.5601679087,
-0.212955609,
0.3874088228,
-0.8440656662,
0.2827642858,
-0.360024333,
0.7960584164,
-0.6241503954,
-0.4867669344,
-0.2053681165,
-0.3999260366,
0.1901204735,
-0.8018624187,
0.1514625847,
0.1500941068,
0.7524360418,
0.3852260113,
-0.3483238816,
0.0152184013,
-0.6321494579,
0.7615876198,
-0.6765218377,
0.4394631088,
0.0095599545,
0.4527570307,
-0.2829459906,
-0.9035345316,
-0.3292073309,
-0.0415783897,
0.1324349791,
0.4024226069,
0.0567106493,
0.0347186625,
0.5480960011,
0.3784222901,
-0.6632630825,
0.3171572387,
-0.2094516605,
-0.1163812354,
0.3757875264,
0.3565496802,
-0.085829787,
-0.414270401,
-0.7626812458,
0.0350375436,
-0.7974864841,
-0.148083955,
0.2620004714,
0.2006952316,
-0.230003953,
0.8128801584,
-0.2014069259,
0.4863851368,
0.0666975677,
-0.3596138954,
0.3415600657,
-0.4255109429,
-0.5799389482,
-0.103504248,
0.5873915553,
0.7198823094,
0.1152533144,
-0.2504740953,
-0.1749349535,
0.1847357452,
0.2038918287,
-0.6551331878,
0.3066328466,
0.4102745652,
-0.450689882,
-0.2793446481,
0.0838924572,
-0.5923621058,
-0.3694917858,
-0.3024342358,
0.2034906,
-0.0463814065,
0.1701411307,
-0.3260087073,
-0.0884902254,
0.1952383667,
0.3650964499,
-0.279070437,
0.0794940516,
0.7589017153,
0.9652745128,
-0.2296461612,
-0.3216072619,
-0.8720780611,
0.3915036321,
-0.5671720505,
0.6137263775,
-0.3302546442,
-0.350908637,
0.0855919719,
-0.3336857259,
0.1465446055,
-0.5046645999,
0.6414886713,
-0.618563652,
0.2421739846,
0.0290382598,
-0.5598395467,
0.2507899702,
0.1583341658,
-0.760725975,
1.3035857677,
0.1740490645,
-0.716103375,
0.7285500765,
-0.7477167249,
-0.4696545303,
-0.1337702274,
-0.2555474937,
-0.4477855265,
-0.0306295399,
0.4001354873,
0.4534272552,
-0.1405871212,
0.1582136303,
-0.3592917323,
-0.3068662584,
0.0308639761,
-0.1624105722,
0.5018529892,
0.3710910082,
-0.4442438781,
0.1521858424,
-0.59415555,
0.1415707767,
0.0270166323,
-0.3103239834,
0.0925115198,
0.0635824502,
-0.1453259587,
0.1882770956,
0.3276917636,
-0.3411006927,
0.2084478289,
-0.6741030812,
0.1586090922,
0.7674753666,
0.377295047,
0.3946366012,
-0.3906340599,
0.4890033305,
0.128290534,
0.4965415001,
-0.0859903842,
-0.2206816822,
-0.8435744047,
0.1308465898,
0.0697906017,
0.6946900487,
-0.8271821141,
0.1083241925,
-0.4860837758,
-0.2911606431,
-0.0870073512,
0.0553168468,
0.632150948,
0.3247598708,
0.261503011,
-0.2062306553,
-0.8869021535,
-0.837515831,
0.00958768,
-0.1579320431,
-0.1493345201,
-0.0311879404,
0.2589049935,
0.1354762316,
0.8460988998,
-0.3701409996,
-0.0937349126,
0.0932124406,
0.3990993798,
0.2791819572,
0.0704718903,
0.7078168392,
-0.6084799767,
-0.0255068131,
-0.0905635729,
-0.916229248,
-0.1171007156,
-0.1206505075,
-0.1286725849,
0.3452377021,
0.2980602682,
-0.2923546433,
0.7886126637,
0.1535293609,
-0.2469322681,
0.4298115373,
0.0681964457,
0.2385220379,
-0.9563646317,
0.1231668741,
-0.2729354203,
-0.2579372227,
-0.5295431018,
-0.0930845439,
-0.0075337426,
-0.1251883805,
-0.7122830749,
0.8267228007,
-0.4818760455,
-0.4621723592,
-0.0173063222,
0.4294270575,
-0.0816247091,
0.5879144669,
-0.1263895333,
0.630141139,
-0.0044538616,
-0.6953378916,
-0.0720050856,
0.2674790323,
-0.4472308159,
0.5123516321,
-0.5932460427,
0.2421516925,
-0.0126360897,
0.076794304,
-0.6207349896,
-0.1186694577,
0.3639577031,
-0.1385225803,
0.080815345,
-0.2522975802,
-0.7715844512,
-0.5009843707,
-0.6678073406,
0.2679476142,
0.2010400295,
-0.5385741591,
0.5585399866,
0.0713170171,
-0.1115972698,
-0.8759109974,
-0.7369741201,
-0.0794594735,
-0.2305516899,
-0.6331517696,
0.5383365154,
-0.1693582535,
-0.4144089222,
-0.0805369243,
-0.6939780712,
-0.0201462395,
0.1634568423,
0.4531120956,
0.2318941057,
-0.2268280238,
-0.1684947759,
0.1925683767,
-0.1921395361,
-0.2018957883,
-0.2528470159,
0.0190770868,
0.2023894489,
-0.4047988653,
-0.2782506049,
0.2008902133,
0.4123234451,
-0.1621871144,
0.3641208112,
0.6569259763,
-0.5345411897,
-0.2318027765,
-0.7596412301,
0.331176579,
-0.3704209626,
0.0564626455,
-0.4244489968,
-0.6941384077,
0.4187013209,
0.0795331001,
0.5778779984,
0.5024077296,
0.4904295802,
-0.0318799987,
0.378092736,
0.247079134,
-0.0604978763,
0.7385807037,
-0.2746940553,
-0.188318491,
-0.6285848022,
-0.0583552495,
-0.1938512474,
-0.3276959658,
-0.1360913515,
-0.4984587431,
0.594778955,
0.2113562375,
-0.3232042193,
0.331710428,
0.0038864582,
0.4115748405,
0.3306877911,
0.072565034,
0.522354126,
0.1338051111,
-0.128529653,
0.0101609575,
-0.6418544054,
-0.8107862473,
1.0387172699,
0.1003253832,
0.2068496197,
0.1284579486,
0.7592886686,
0.5714448094,
0.4671976268,
-0.2892058194,
0.6072126031,
-0.2003608942,
-0.4682120085,
-0.2163600028,
-0.2910830677,
-0.8960714936,
0.0491980091,
-0.1107406095,
-0.8357679248,
0.1714238971,
-0.0914444774,
-0.5193032026,
0.1741530299,
-0.7047249675,
0.7794689536,
-0.2671554983,
-0.422624439,
-0.0445130691,
-0.796389997,
0.0048433049,
0.2221318483,
0.0877340138,
-0.523971796,
-0.272556752,
0.7831929922,
-0.6903741956,
0.8485668898,
-0.0725970566,
0.075192973,
0.4139727354,
0.15588139,
0.4885926843,
0.2469766289,
-0.4373005033,
0.14412269,
-0.0109604169,
-0.1431419551,
-0.8219340444,
0.6044200659,
-0.5001656413,
-0.1895885468,
-0.2623900175,
-0.5413137674,
0.009138261,
0.1914737374,
0.1594313979,
0.8921480179,
-0.3655081391,
-0.4713743925,
0.0661799461,
0.2658400834,
0.8280331492,
0.2722837627,
-0.1505774409,
-0.5165631771,
0.4422832727,
0.1797754019,
0.0871929601,
0.7667332292,
-0.2019102126,
-0.2262432575,
-0.6272698641,
-0.3938690126,
0.209070757,
-0.8058626652,
-0.3269587457,
-0.2638907731,
-0.0292030983,
-0.2781863511,
-0.3209086955,
-0.3229128122,
-0.728767395,
-0.2783742249,
-0.1188783348,
0.1463413537,
0.8649403453,
0.1528460085,
0.1177096665,
-0.4808080494,
0.3323097229,
-0.1543011218,
0.4660364389,
-0.002825218,
-0.09767396,
-0.0398998857,
-0.277785778,
-0.5671095848,
-0.6127714515,
0.0101191523,
0.0171862952,
0.7076207399,
0.3697706461,
-0.0257584378,
1.0217162371,
-0.6144854426,
0.6363573074,
-0.0767268687,
-0.8765667081,
0.793481648,
-0.3250940144,
0.3321481943,
0.3855624199,
0.1930411458,
-0.3358473182,
-0.3010526299,
-0.7760379314,
-0.9235761166,
0.7356573343,
0.7275835276,
-0.7792380452,
-0.0404700972,
0.6928902864,
0.0159752071,
0.4226630032,
-0.6267282963,
-0.4205060303,
-0.0413568579,
-0.0753662139,
-0.0121080214,
-0.4419417381,
-0.2538037002,
0.4839726686,
0.3031278849,
0.08148399,
0.512678206,
0.3259202838,
-0.229626298,
-0.1556636989,
0.480843246,
0.544999361,
1.0379542112,
-0.4124161899,
-0.0482973717,
0.4716285765,
-0.092494145,
-0.1422887743,
0.3718493581,
-0.1344375759,
-0.0628262311,
1.0064007044,
0.8543307781,
0.6504104733,
-0.2844054997,
0.3684166968,
0.297091186,
0.0519921035,
-0.2764580846,
-0.1303996295,
-0.2415764183,
0.6716681719,
0.4335311353,
-0.36560148,
0.0505184419,
-0.2573343515,
0.1242986917,
-0.0442599766,
-0.014193546,
-0.2463117093,
0.7382062078,
0.131445542,
-0.3667443991,
0.4548037648,
-0.2977688909,
-0.1799278259,
0.6622415185,
0.2211408764,
0.8006148338,
0.001130856,
-0.0943061337,
0.2356199324,
0.3472560048,
0.0215133149,
0.4675360024,
0.0174596962,
-0.1770243198,
-0.5365864635,
-0.6205549836,
-0.4464624822,
-0.0522794686,
-0.5007098317,
0.2763128579,
-0.6264928579,
-0.3445567191,
-0.0539922602,
0.2828027904,
-0.9044107199,
-0.0189144518,
0.026315473,
0.9899764061,
-0.7050606608,
0.2673921883,
0.7428852916,
-0.4070234299,
-0.3717601299,
0.1153885126,
0.4044021964,
-0.4653341472,
0.5982558131,
0.1177272275,
-0.0602533668,
-0.3180195987,
-0.0633647516,
-0.7716709971,
1.6622313261,
0.3435301185,
-0.3953684866,
-0.3559564948,
-0.0464710519,
0.5665451884,
-0.4746165276,
0.3371568918,
0.2606878281,
0.5754823685,
0.1333376318,
-1.0991219282,
0.052587945,
-0.1582964212,
0.213454321,
0.3732601702,
-0.4615823925,
0.4176762104,
-0.2645002902,
-0.7008274794,
0.5291250944,
0.9980736971,
0.1739841253,
0.8363272548,
0.4735177755,
0.4529716074,
0.6049306393,
-0.2919907272,
1.2388573885,
-0.0325217918,
0.1903438866,
1.3398213387,
-0.3739541173,
0.658089757,
0.3909473419,
-0.5189934969,
0.1823872179,
0.874350667,
0.0837014839,
0.4445668757,
-0.0511576943,
-0.0425884835,
-0.1078932881,
-0.0892361403,
-0.3881408572,
-0.0219861995,
0.1174188033,
0.0525950007,
-0.5794968009,
-0.2087496966,
-0.0196702387,
-0.2233754247,
-0.2625406682,
0.4681255817,
0.1479236782,
-0.4064870477,
0.1875856519,
-0.0321615376,
0.3097860515,
-0.6831566691,
0.0453038998,
-0.3845418692,
-0.0454217233,
-0.2468176186,
-0.6188803911,
0.3893416226,
-0.0747322068,
-0.1934552044,
-0.118680276,
0.3027651906,
-0.2499504834,
-0.3933693767,
0.1492155641,
0.4766812921,
0.0236287564,
0.3998863399,
-0.5937788486,
0.2260317653,
-0.4402990043,
-0.3294048905,
-0.1098641232,
0.355586648,
-0.4025853872,
0.5134313703,
0.2477640361,
-0.1788752973,
0.0689659491,
0.4226435125,
0.5504459739,
-0.5313571095,
-0.428737849,
-0.7050542831,
0.4700146317,
-0.0811907053,
-0.4487683475,
0.7379410267,
0.7599443793,
0.7235931754,
0.0132935066,
0.3774005473,
-0.0792390928,
0.4754653275,
-0.8656549454,
0.1036669612,
-0.6261519194,
0.4388912022,
-0.5634716153,
-0.9844747186,
-0.5604519248,
0.186646387,
-0.4402306676,
0.126026392,
0.8296722174,
0.6775588393,
-0.09230268,
0.0609403551,
-0.0981319621,
0.1837488115,
0.2136898041,
0.6715828776,
0.799796164,
-0.3865543902,
0.5336695313,
-0.3217630684,
-0.055709295,
-0.139801085,
-1.4399180412,
-1.0261546373,
-0.5059494972,
-0.3591226339,
-0.2241345197,
0.5002550483,
1.1097617149,
0.5367489457,
-0.4863987565,
-0.2695024908,
0.3526304066,
0.1644626856,
-0.3467442691,
-0.1956176907,
0.5642431974,
-0.1296354085,
-0.7700789571,
0.8809642196,
0.5079165697,
0.2225088328,
0.0897122473,
0.2780597508,
-0.2800015509,
-0.2566128969,
0.7443746328,
0.2197950333,
-0.7992975712,
-0.3772621751,
-0.1445402205,
0.1864894331,
0.2439406812,
0.9302935004,
-0.5461470485,
0.3850996792,
0.2884591222,
0.464037329,
0.8265066147,
-0.087442711,
0.5067030787,
-1.2835357189,
0.2214417011,
-0.0982497483,
0.3754400015,
0.1684993953,
-0.3379573226,
1.1196266413,
0.1396131366,
-0.1725553125,
-0.7056347132,
0.2459204048,
-1.3569706678,
0.1484504938,
0.7917269468,
0.0202224161,
-0.0622835904,
0.0104172165,
0.2799563706,
0.3546441793,
-0.2907825112,
0.4968798459,
0.5432401299,
-0.3228717744,
0.3979748189,
-0.5162963271,
0.2003967762,
0.1738539338,
-0.7539850473,
-0.249197036,
0.4910580814,
0.0626187474,
0.198211208,
0.7717465162,
-0.1330314577,
0.4166180491,
-0.2774534523,
-0.1871641427,
-0.5362355709,
-0.5346494317,
-0.1611717492,
0.3066123426,
-0.0395600535,
-0.08374504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00986v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00986v2
|
Merging Text Transformer Models from Different Initializations
| 2024-03-01T21:16:29 | 2024-03-07T18:45:09 |
Neha Verma, Maha Elbayad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work on one-shot permutation-based model merging has shown impressive
low- or zero-barrier mode connectivity between models from completely different
initializations. However, this line of work has not yet extended to the
Transformer architecture, despite its dominant popularity in the language
domain. Therefore, in this work, we investigate the extent to which separate
Transformer minima learn similar features, and propose a model merging
technique to investigate the relationship between these minima in the loss
landscape. The specifics of the architecture, like its residual connections,
multi-headed attention, and discrete, sequential input, require specific
interventions in order to compute model permutations that remain within the
same functional equivalence class. In merging these models with our method, we
consistently find lower loss barriers between minima compared to model
averaging for several models trained on a masked-language modeling task or
fine-tuned on a language understanding benchmark. Our results show that the
minima of these models are less sharp and isolated than previously understood,
and provide a basis for future work on merging separately trained Transformer
models.
|
[
-0.6231685877,
-0.5055453181,
0.5821228027,
-0.3098974824,
0.0048118704,
-0.2066957206,
-0.1229830235,
-0.4310394824,
-0.2046720684,
0.5812242031,
-0.7964711189,
-0.2399435937,
-0.8192058206,
-0.0466150418,
-0.5273663402,
0.9670236707,
-0.0290206578,
-0.2222120315,
-0.166736722,
-0.3967401683,
-0.5343962312,
-0.3332817256,
-0.4613066614,
-0.691598773,
0.542350471,
0.3135296702,
0.6603803635,
0.642667532,
0.655685246,
0.3206180632,
-0.2949739695,
-0.1054336354,
-0.5396891236,
-0.2380091399,
-0.0635449663,
-0.4481668174,
-0.2348961085,
-0.0086826338,
0.7112206817,
0.9639243484,
0.1337952167,
0.2453992069,
0.4083987176,
0.3838983178,
-0.5875056386,
-0.1578994095,
-0.6619321704,
0.3055329025,
-0.1163126379,
-0.0007001344,
-0.6912320852,
0.1279584169,
0.3006281555,
-0.1584139168,
0.4248582721,
-0.2290190607,
0.985891819,
0.4126261175,
-0.5576218963,
0.1091984659,
-0.8351876736,
0.7206392288,
-0.6137806773,
0.5797272325,
-0.0336551107,
0.3892703652,
0.2896266282,
-0.3342590928,
-0.7250429988,
0.1483509094,
-0.5735087395,
-0.09056779,
-0.6658788919,
-0.0208501276,
0.04479504,
0.1320587844,
-0.5719757676,
0.3747148812,
-0.4769716859,
-0.1378301978,
0.2683671117,
0.3622937799,
0.0813767239,
-0.1530901343,
-0.4112099707,
-0.4013572931,
-0.7970907092,
0.0406102389,
0.2993240356,
0.3996842504,
-0.5702569485,
0.4535273612,
0.0671321079,
0.6837587357,
0.0480164699,
-0.2366179377,
0.177201286,
-0.5249465704,
-0.4006343782,
-0.2071177512,
0.8612902761,
0.0786480829,
0.0022723291,
-0.2041906565,
-0.1179844588,
0.0503502004,
0.2311864197,
-0.5935419798,
-0.3776561916,
-0.2854294479,
-0.8196188807,
-0.4398569465,
-0.2278413326,
-0.3418290913,
-0.338770777,
-0.2491412461,
0.4567994475,
-0.4150207043,
-0.1508083045,
0.0629020929,
0.0285923257,
0.4191722572,
0.0318475664,
-0.8945342302,
0.4301677644,
0.6340732574,
0.7874701023,
-0.1579245925,
-0.4135784805,
-0.1637599915,
-0.1282142848,
-0.1071086898,
0.8004996777,
-0.4059207141,
-0.2670654655,
-0.0420214832,
-0.1313583702,
-0.3861137331,
-0.5263575315,
0.2675985098,
-0.5168370605,
0.4275092483,
0.1219172105,
-0.2955589592,
-0.4543824196,
0.2223129123,
-0.7891861796,
0.7448300719,
0.1026065797,
-0.8811072707,
0.1637643874,
-0.5500770807,
-0.3640176952,
-0.1907084882,
-0.207363978,
-0.5061728358,
0.284094274,
0.0419206843,
0.2230360508,
-0.3887166977,
-0.1966154873,
0.0172649715,
-0.2635284364,
0.103989847,
-0.5825574994,
0.9032052755,
-0.0496149436,
-0.0845524892,
0.2367845774,
-0.769038558,
-0.3652471006,
0.158230409,
-0.1706919372,
-0.5372974873,
-0.0963534191,
0.1751721501,
0.2838935554,
0.1271671504,
-0.2107737809,
0.253636986,
-0.4768206477,
0.3023987412,
0.5925882459,
0.0227166712,
0.9032978415,
-0.6282262206,
0.3545923829,
0.3777958453,
0.0189993363,
-0.473082602,
-0.5297335386,
-1.1341634989,
-0.2272929102,
0.3909837604,
0.5081887245,
-0.5657691956,
0.4112452865,
-0.500041008,
-0.5558984876,
-0.6202275753,
0.0264479537,
0.5524625778,
0.7733338475,
0.3579904735,
-0.3258141875,
-0.4674470127,
-1.0733727217,
-0.2798935473,
-0.1165593714,
-0.2400043607,
0.3120528162,
0.2411433756,
-0.3804818094,
1.0808618069,
-0.5384681225,
-0.4513566494,
-0.4289998412,
0.0520445108,
0.3296815157,
0.5065151453,
0.7940776348,
-0.5456038117,
-0.6460926533,
0.1429597586,
-0.3890314996,
0.0806541741,
-0.1174017116,
-0.0046100346,
-0.2034374028,
0.2821374536,
-0.544909656,
0.3979176283,
0.6049514413,
-0.0560150295,
0.15160954,
-0.0082157832,
0.1504581571,
-0.9783040285,
-0.2417212874,
0.0585174225,
-0.0655250028,
-1.0740600824,
-0.0933251008,
-0.018855961,
-0.0969250873,
-0.6014131308,
0.5884452462,
-0.3247128427,
0.1461125016,
-0.3324901462,
0.2186305225,
-0.1375525892,
0.5798015594,
-0.2760714591,
0.5307775736,
0.5949351192,
-0.6695572734,
-0.1968601346,
0.5770872831,
-0.0854610279,
0.1310769022,
-0.3892707527,
0.3345633447,
-0.3423320353,
-0.0267466772,
-1.2219780684,
0.0752498657,
0.3632269204,
-0.2491409779,
0.1354814321,
-0.2573169172,
-0.1924284846,
-0.1687301397,
-0.2595157623,
0.6437014341,
0.7745091319,
-0.4880546629,
0.8694279194,
0.2724731565,
-0.0932746157,
-0.2684353888,
-0.8204939961,
-0.1317742467,
-0.2676165402,
-0.855997622,
0.6568478346,
-0.0049876468,
0.030949669,
0.1722618937,
-0.055240836,
-0.2234351337,
0.0193536468,
0.1973497868,
0.2872477174,
-0.4639084041,
0.0191875976,
0.2693179548,
-0.1808950603,
-0.3401657939,
-0.0708712935,
0.5837363601,
0.0955671817,
-0.2791921198,
-0.6135248542,
0.3658284545,
0.4800559878,
-0.268489182,
1.1337717772,
0.2262495309,
-0.5442486405,
-0.0751831681,
-0.6425038576,
-0.3887282908,
-0.4949168563,
0.2573157847,
-0.8504921794,
-1.0482108593,
0.7208891511,
0.033196833,
0.1022657752,
0.6678732634,
0.4878975153,
-0.0785467103,
0.7455542684,
1.3860749006,
-0.0826184005,
0.6304768324,
-0.3152904212,
0.4499903619,
-0.7472382188,
-0.1353135258,
-0.523453474,
-0.5023027658,
-0.6325602531,
-0.3205046654,
0.2540388405,
-0.065693453,
-0.102355808,
0.6918497682,
-0.4721803069,
0.5477510095,
0.2665804923,
0.0728061795,
0.5219600201,
0.2160551846,
-0.129987061,
-0.2182249725,
-1.0738790035,
-0.4896814823,
0.8641717434,
0.4164679348,
0.6860617995,
0.0626236424,
0.781502068,
-0.0996272415,
0.6401329041,
-0.7656068802,
0.4183204472,
-0.4817000329,
-0.2463601232,
-0.2850189209,
-0.551762104,
-0.8967548609,
0.5332933664,
-0.4406901002,
-0.787627697,
0.2726570368,
0.2118753642,
-0.5071282983,
0.1484042108,
-0.6394822598,
1.0352885723,
0.2769151926,
0.2797050774,
-0.1961925775,
-0.619633019,
0.7533692122,
-0.1484535187,
0.1304728985,
0.0852581039,
0.0962133929,
0.6993393302,
-0.2945139408,
0.7086666822,
0.3704276085,
-0.1404049098,
0.1654583812,
0.1589183509,
0.3508130908,
-0.4456267357,
0.3383521736,
0.3469534218,
-0.2661480606,
-0.1136480421,
-0.5149394274,
0.4126770496,
-0.7055600882,
-0.4796713591,
-0.0287538506,
-0.4656481743,
-0.127290383,
0.2861956656,
0.4936642647,
0.4081940055,
-0.1241455153,
0.1193788797,
0.7028118968,
0.0449921191,
0.5266444087,
0.6281250715,
0.0613408647,
-0.2721337676,
0.5663584471,
-0.1452686042,
0.1543140858,
0.6217826009,
0.1144821793,
-0.0442561135,
-0.4733844697,
-0.0423696376,
0.3993838727,
-0.7649697661,
-0.288592279,
-0.6949132681,
-0.5887649655,
-0.3610826433,
-0.1236806959,
-0.4218320549,
-0.1812058687,
-0.1765380055,
0.044926215,
0.0090125781,
0.6161348224,
0.2717188001,
0.9155977368,
-1.1165175438,
0.2662119865,
0.1987717152,
0.2568736076,
0.2375851125,
-0.9100208282,
-0.3667351305,
-0.1813979894,
-0.3863942623,
-1.1703294516,
0.2195940167,
0.19078587,
0.4368343353,
0.5011541843,
-0.1865659207,
0.6907696724,
-0.9026407003,
0.3648301065,
0.5470411777,
-1.0596048832,
0.2483430505,
-0.0745074153,
0.4791127741,
0.65243119,
0.3149659932,
-0.664013803,
-0.3788553774,
-0.5403347611,
-0.4835096896,
0.7843618989,
0.3076924086,
0.0710792392,
0.3694066107,
0.0674612224,
0.0894069597,
-0.053533528,
-0.8516697884,
-0.5238569379,
0.18241629,
-0.4705198109,
-0.0397032946,
-0.0832216293,
-0.3543324769,
-0.234808594,
0.2515169382,
-0.0056651379,
0.2478493154,
-0.214066714,
-0.4545205832,
0.0393141694,
0.214217037,
0.5491349101,
0.2435622066,
0.2009923309,
0.3879638314,
0.4159153402,
-0.3082795143,
0.4086712301,
0.0431451015,
-0.3866325617,
0.0838493183,
0.5674911737,
1.0461760759,
0.4131130278,
-0.432534188,
0.5896071792,
-0.1071922407,
-0.2376592159,
0.2828917503,
0.0339608788,
0.0182921495,
0.3289108574,
0.2398935705,
0.5388990045,
0.0937160254,
-0.3496430218,
0.3373045325,
0.4180348814,
-0.4293479323,
-0.3661414981,
0.6084172726,
0.2060285211,
-0.4414562285,
0.5887660384,
-0.0933043584,
-0.5355751514,
0.5482596755,
0.4465481937,
1.1677224636,
-0.1497599036,
0.005699499,
0.153265506,
0.7327836752,
0.0271950718,
-0.3906998038,
-0.0430078618,
-0.8702495694,
-0.5472596288,
-0.4548378587,
-0.2284578234,
0.1543506086,
-0.3186034858,
0.5199843645,
-0.107841447,
-0.1503411233,
0.1400232315,
-0.4046400189,
-0.8839651346,
0.001765208,
0.164397493,
0.8338239789,
-1.2146334648,
0.7501326203,
0.6277614236,
-0.3113017082,
-0.807264626,
0.1097197533,
-0.0853438228,
-0.2388059944,
0.5271742344,
0.2390996516,
-0.2057438493,
-0.1116565689,
-0.0006591816,
-0.7705072165,
1.0169364214,
0.47275424,
-0.5604163408,
-0.2698640823,
0.2009125948,
0.3528402448,
-0.6824734211,
0.2316335887,
0.6968758106,
0.1819390506,
0.0118863871,
-0.9904593229,
0.0940961093,
-0.0210812036,
0.1237790287,
0.3869771361,
-0.573851347,
0.9833524823,
0.0797518715,
-0.6901895404,
0.0292620007,
0.6083797812,
-0.0982843265,
0.1428375393,
0.7688021064,
0.4951269925,
0.3767152429,
-0.0174900759,
0.6248916388,
-0.3881381452,
0.6942394972,
1.2264889479,
-0.0203911979,
0.7972649336,
0.2249856144,
-0.0915237814,
0.3923062682,
0.2916948795,
0.1344248652,
0.6957710385,
-0.1642233878,
-0.0781303644,
-0.1774862409,
0.1713341326,
-0.2219892889,
0.5186630487,
-0.1461155117,
-0.3639988005,
-0.4539506435,
0.2186262459,
-0.0905489996,
-0.0099157849,
0.0126696089,
0.8805351257,
-0.0418387726,
-0.4616362751,
0.6121706367,
0.261623919,
0.8427335024,
-0.483117789,
0.1773185283,
-0.4134183526,
0.1242016479,
-0.0688403621,
-0.395509392,
0.5859882832,
0.0348424055,
-0.5585291386,
-0.4014605284,
0.7440119386,
-0.7081162333,
-0.3190469444,
0.2691047192,
0.4277021289,
-0.1967642903,
0.1626693904,
-0.3851132393,
0.2392435223,
0.0030166095,
-0.0494468063,
0.3322391212,
0.004898035,
0.1906432509,
0.5252468586,
0.3397097588,
-0.2931650579,
0.419033736,
0.0749665946,
0.9954115748,
-0.5022010803,
-0.5908344388,
-0.9172070026,
0.6740862727,
0.034093041,
-0.2225006968,
0.631569922,
0.5193684697,
0.8190079331,
-0.3145754039,
0.5980612636,
0.2219730765,
0.2484987378,
-0.3827033639,
0.965013504,
-0.6120123267,
0.2333477587,
-0.0177205168,
-1.1700842381,
-0.1598237604,
0.4923610091,
-0.0155006088,
-0.228879869,
0.8036206365,
0.8402104974,
-0.3664229214,
-0.4140593708,
0.4239718616,
0.1996361315,
0.2219801098,
0.7880750895,
0.5064925551,
-0.7781609297,
0.7555910945,
-0.2763285041,
-0.2714018822,
-0.1701580882,
-0.7036613226,
-0.9334071279,
-0.6692345142,
-0.4103688002,
-0.1233772561,
-0.1422814727,
0.4376497567,
0.5800939202,
-0.6495613456,
-0.1261350513,
0.0057884576,
0.3772378862,
-0.2684223056,
-0.1939018816,
0.1393964738,
-0.2214870155,
-0.7106075883,
0.370249331,
0.4605973065,
0.1872458309,
-0.2420820594,
-0.0360563323,
-0.0850755423,
0.4980058074,
0.4694468677,
0.236880064,
-0.6215453744,
-0.3130892217,
0.036527317,
-0.3261794746,
0.1885147691,
0.9697592854,
-0.9084382057,
0.3185884953,
0.7983660102,
0.8221629858,
0.557760179,
-0.2456739098,
0.2943049073,
-0.85426265,
0.3916190565,
0.0174190197,
0.3058853447,
0.25197348,
0.0343652591,
0.2733627558,
0.1411462873,
-0.0518684536,
-0.9178822041,
0.5329963565,
-0.9291675687,
-0.0520521402,
0.6534002423,
0.1016643122,
-0.0453349464,
0.2540238202,
-0.0024970702,
0.315338105,
0.266498059,
0.6220824122,
0.6678142548,
-0.1480558813,
-0.5130054951,
-0.0450211838,
0.4366194308,
0.3653330505,
-0.7426900268,
-0.1846583635,
0.015530902,
0.3291345835,
0.4803480208,
0.499248296,
0.1726034284,
0.1104454026,
0.2187130451,
0.0120097948,
0.1637744457,
-0.5594547987,
-0.6357808113,
0.2920027375,
-0.1764653921,
-0.2326435894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00982v1
|
LocalRQA: From Generating Data to Locally Training, Testing, and Deploying Retrieval-Augmented QA Systems
| 2024-03-01T21:10:20 | 2024-03-01T21:10:20 |
Xiao Yu, Yunan Lu, Zhou Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented question-answering systems combine retrieval techniques
with large language models to provide answers that are more accurate and
informative. Many existing toolkits allow users to quickly build such systems
using off-the-shelf models, but they fall short in supporting researchers and
developers to customize the model training, testing, and deployment process. We
propose LocalRQA, an open-source toolkit that features a wide selection of
model training algorithms, evaluation methods, and deployment tools curated
from the latest research. As a showcase, we build QA systems using online
documentation obtained from Databricks and Faire's websites. We find 7B-models
trained and deployed using LocalRQA reach a similar performance compared to
using OpenAI's text-ada-002 and GPT-4-turbo.
|
[
-0.5748329759,
-0.8389252424,
0.4834493995,
-0.0116686951,
0.2786885202,
0.1229632348,
0.3767399788,
-0.2850154638,
0.1924263984,
0.5033758283,
-0.1792846769,
-0.0759133697,
0.2381660044,
0.1255629361,
-0.4207636118,
0.7027981281,
-0.2923273444,
0.134350881,
-0.4237931371,
-0.164212659,
-0.4792422354,
-0.5967294574,
-0.5220236182,
-0.0152431512,
0.4814379811,
0.3875415027,
1.0907770395,
0.4368067682,
0.4254788458,
0.1224202737,
-0.0576661341,
-0.1973207742,
-0.2800931334,
0.1229079664,
-0.2608975768,
-0.5305024981,
-0.282897979,
-0.0996700674,
0.5701755881,
0.4889068902,
-0.4143221974,
0.6095380187,
-0.62016505,
0.5342801213,
-0.9320459366,
-0.3412262499,
-0.2626675069,
-0.0658291653,
-0.0790015161,
0.2481101155,
-0.1514664292,
-1.0476561785,
-0.0424365513,
-0.6582993865,
0.0948098153,
-0.050240647,
0.6941127181,
0.1366265118,
-0.6955090761,
-0.1401963532,
-0.6651241779,
0.666811049,
-0.7950928807,
0.7796265483,
0.5185860991,
0.8166829348,
-0.2185152918,
-0.9317362309,
-0.5839957595,
-0.1865641475,
0.1767024994,
-0.005828259,
-0.0890659168,
-0.2473320216,
0.1797613353,
0.7909011841,
-0.7878403068,
-0.2469222695,
-0.5548167825,
-0.1400946528,
0.3942755163,
0.1287258267,
0.2075478584,
-0.2239203006,
-0.1378173083,
-0.0273354836,
-0.985519886,
0.0859682336,
0.2377308756,
0.2196635008,
0.2206486166,
0.6171653271,
-0.7649544477,
0.6647520661,
0.0815923288,
0.0689406469,
0.3185397983,
-0.5035467148,
-0.3331466019,
-0.1993987262,
0.4580948055,
-0.3390142918,
-0.3556915522,
-0.2287859619,
-0.4482325017,
0.0247664806,
0.2707948983,
-0.7632269263,
-0.2626807392,
0.2082232684,
-0.4057199061,
-0.3010367453,
-0.3035123944,
-0.343867898,
-0.3300287426,
-0.288944602,
0.8546597958,
-0.0718148723,
-0.4432209432,
0.0138503201,
-0.096308589,
0.3597760797,
-0.0364639349,
-0.3701598048,
0.2751910388,
0.2078191638,
0.7125571966,
0.0528958105,
-0.0097305188,
-0.7638305426,
-0.2232999206,
-0.5012572408,
0.6097329855,
-0.4651333094,
-0.2701128721,
0.1992235929,
-0.0583791323,
0.2543433309,
-0.7283964753,
0.3503107131,
-1.0978441238,
0.3989225328,
-0.4113875031,
-0.3190019429,
-0.0966901556,
0.2561156154,
-0.6759914756,
1.4441542625,
0.4860650003,
-0.690136373,
0.1542459428,
-0.7264323235,
-0.1966684461,
0.0685875192,
0.0179143958,
0.0522221588,
-0.0202505589,
0.5110260248,
0.438439548,
-0.3700236082,
-0.0339756534,
-0.0373707339,
-0.5351873636,
0.0106669664,
-0.0417369679,
0.9846588373,
0.7313963771,
-0.0683997348,
0.0764492303,
-0.707156837,
0.1470304877,
0.0971861258,
-0.4245249927,
-0.066746287,
-0.2144107074,
-0.1365026981,
0.1589143574,
0.4015251398,
-0.6088127494,
0.1576242894,
-0.5542503595,
0.3301791251,
0.1171441823,
0.1904911697,
0.6910524368,
-0.4900964797,
0.9551193714,
-0.1621080339,
0.490655303,
-0.0984942243,
-0.5803823471,
-0.5143055916,
-0.2142904699,
0.3932224512,
0.6701601744,
-1.1938993931,
-0.2702269554,
-0.0832571462,
-0.9085949659,
-0.6899492145,
0.185226202,
0.2972126305,
0.3522207439,
0.2584387958,
-0.4058228433,
-0.3085571527,
-0.7563354969,
0.0159071367,
-0.1053715795,
-0.1995057017,
0.0836758092,
0.336334765,
-0.2397905886,
1.2715697289,
-0.4260055721,
0.040940199,
0.0437792167,
0.0789659396,
0.0448385365,
0.2478577197,
0.4584387243,
-0.8820601106,
-0.1690503657,
0.0131098721,
-0.5713146329,
-0.0103382999,
0.3382017314,
-0.0887393132,
0.062209148,
0.1523788571,
-0.4972806871,
0.4847578406,
0.3977837265,
-0.118652001,
0.7412112355,
-0.0490497537,
0.4044371247,
-1.1744554043,
0.2754200995,
-0.3265319765,
-0.3561211526,
-0.533190608,
0.5258308649,
0.0384559631,
-0.3638658226,
-0.5649012923,
0.9183908105,
-0.3986139894,
-0.402957499,
-0.0066574318,
0.221696049,
0.1177737489,
0.2201181501,
-0.0810303167,
1.1592035294,
0.2845622301,
-0.5947037339,
0.4971144199,
0.6804350019,
-0.5568230152,
0.3806545436,
-0.5312833786,
0.4400190115,
-0.0070775393,
-0.0491535552,
-0.5070711374,
-0.4625044167,
0.0592666678,
-0.4345484078,
-0.2082894892,
-0.3094957173,
-0.6693702936,
-0.3111200929,
-0.1491894275,
0.7924019694,
0.709913373,
-0.7391884327,
0.6415328383,
0.5867512226,
-0.307258755,
-0.5538357496,
-0.4286754727,
-0.2799294591,
0.1402429342,
-0.5849265456,
-0.1290168613,
0.0348024964,
-0.3686955273,
-0.0857382044,
0.0433374159,
-0.6235215068,
0.123657845,
0.2306259423,
-0.0444324762,
-0.4849650562,
0.2461841106,
0.0461314023,
0.3774396479,
0.0345241018,
0.1426858902,
0.1719262302,
-0.3189708292,
-0.3735979497,
-0.1907191575,
0.3219323754,
0.2839758396,
-0.7199605703,
0.4297889173,
0.3743561208,
-0.4127840102,
0.0087485984,
-0.6572244763,
-0.1903156489,
-0.5097613335,
0.1436620206,
-0.3922814727,
-0.8057980537,
0.6305854321,
0.0265185628,
0.1555970311,
0.1452132314,
0.461435765,
0.1484279633,
1.2513241768,
0.491286695,
0.2895323932,
0.4894150198,
-0.0663665384,
0.2677002251,
-0.610648036,
-0.2050108016,
-0.7221159339,
0.1172045916,
-0.1050225794,
-0.6398547888,
0.2659579217,
0.3284370005,
-0.7678539157,
0.2344874144,
-0.6261748672,
0.5180583,
0.8247171044,
-0.0835296363,
0.2892507911,
0.0054404014,
0.0251840148,
0.2527318001,
-0.8285951614,
-0.4773412645,
0.9144618511,
0.3619302809,
0.7080484033,
0.1566171944,
0.5928657055,
0.2028797418,
0.5007799268,
-0.4709346592,
0.3067914844,
0.4214195609,
-0.9963190556,
-0.1715190411,
-0.6610310078,
-0.7803777456,
-0.3022182584,
-0.0200426523,
-0.5424460769,
0.4292087257,
0.0842383355,
-0.4887183905,
0.2331477404,
-0.8782476783,
0.9766359329,
-0.0919218808,
0.1294649541,
0.0678359047,
-0.4623723924,
0.3435179889,
-0.2121013254,
0.2624538541,
0.0312401112,
0.212500006,
0.6423768997,
-0.2923022211,
0.5299609303,
-0.3992714584,
-0.232571587,
0.6200901866,
0.5059388876,
0.4090062082,
0.0788285434,
-0.1903827339,
-0.0670595765,
0.8151269555,
-0.7019931078,
-0.7247160077,
0.6606403589,
-0.6538684964,
-0.2238713801,
-0.3094840348,
-0.4426322281,
-0.513487637,
0.076816529,
-0.0665247366,
0.7038921714,
-0.1372993141,
-0.0810720026,
0.6031380296,
-0.3139944971,
-0.1217303053,
0.2980186045,
-0.8403134346,
-0.5097963214,
0.967481792,
-0.0020441674,
0.2817415893,
0.3613528907,
-0.0614770018,
-0.4040746093,
-0.4356588721,
-0.41788885,
0.0627110228,
-0.9648020864,
-0.4167481661,
-0.0237069037,
-0.1293741316,
-0.4329393208,
-0.1451919973,
-0.3234223425,
-0.7165879607,
-0.0836151391,
-0.044257693,
0.5317581296,
1.2707015276,
0.0377801582,
0.3798618019,
-0.9385035038,
0.4028074741,
0.4698195755,
0.4568969607,
-0.0307656657,
-0.5372674465,
-0.4784640968,
0.2429066449,
-0.3328932524,
-1.0656769276,
0.2283541858,
-0.0049713468,
0.410433352,
-0.0358744487,
0.1222846285,
0.2918891907,
-0.2175859511,
0.9927532077,
-0.1905989945,
-0.7852380872,
0.6796451211,
-0.4255002737,
0.4645524919,
0.625985384,
0.564786613,
-0.4207992852,
-0.2790855169,
-0.2751692235,
-0.637157321,
0.3876082301,
0.0961123556,
0.1733221114,
-0.1977882832,
0.809101522,
0.110773176,
0.1412900984,
-0.3861409426,
-0.2167886347,
-0.3573364019,
-0.371787101,
0.4068619609,
-0.144250527,
-0.0287488289,
-0.0437474772,
1.0614100695,
-0.2757580876,
0.4171123803,
0.3393256664,
-0.2334524989,
0.1285345852,
0.225716874,
-0.0106286928,
0.9043653011,
-0.2630616724,
-0.1207919419,
0.2641276419,
-0.3657898605,
0.2770908773,
0.0965456739,
-0.4729667902,
-0.1368768662,
-0.3245764375,
0.5919667482,
0.0725791603,
-0.9219585061,
0.4915460646,
-0.2972375154,
-0.0623299256,
-0.1768058389,
-0.0427792072,
0.0001478322,
0.3703421652,
0.4940654337,
-0.2004336715,
0.3041484058,
-0.5107911229,
0.215310052,
0.2135243565,
-0.3844429851,
-0.2606655359,
0.6806825399,
0.1362689286,
-0.3533273339,
0.5858315825,
-0.4302624166,
-0.3245534599,
0.4145468175,
0.3364342749,
0.6116374731,
-0.1419536918,
0.6733418703,
0.4215918183,
0.0369841345,
-0.2590747476,
0.7482665777,
-0.0554549843,
-0.3844206929,
-0.7455843091,
-0.6253583431,
-0.6558952332,
-0.1407816559,
-0.77951473,
0.004347431,
-0.4680370688,
-0.1585180163,
-0.2124801427,
0.1277570724,
-0.7266790271,
0.3652180731,
-0.118066892,
1.2978218794,
-0.4350855947,
0.5798905492,
0.9983857274,
-0.7138656974,
-1.1503325701,
-0.327763021,
-0.4808585942,
-0.4412487149,
0.5854485035,
-0.15263547,
0.0649401769,
0.1720020175,
-0.4273457229,
-1.1426291466,
1.179662466,
0.5201867223,
-0.0749432072,
-0.1389074922,
-0.1178366244,
0.4518444836,
-0.1403108984,
0.5320753455,
0.4248654842,
0.1414403021,
-0.052528441,
-1.2798287868,
0.097717993,
-0.1326231658,
-0.0952714011,
0.2749715447,
-0.3641057014,
0.585319221,
-0.1626206189,
-0.2227048427,
0.4443981946,
0.6270315051,
0.0836925507,
0.0877182707,
0.0833512023,
0.5133988261,
0.9301007986,
-0.0217641294,
1.1438590288,
-0.0241158698,
0.1281638294,
1.0558558702,
-0.2709357142,
1.3558936119,
0.2124581486,
-0.0986967459,
0.5810794234,
0.6361498833,
0.2547960579,
0.3739518225,
-0.0634581894,
-0.3010065258,
-0.2954539359,
-0.1832381338,
-0.3804948628,
0.201078251,
-0.1769136488,
0.0572251827,
-0.2277741134,
0.1666397005,
-0.4260660112,
0.0233596284,
-0.5088941455,
0.5528045297,
-0.0782445669,
-0.4972855449,
0.7312542796,
-0.0009106284,
0.2997487783,
-0.4241087437,
0.0539877228,
-0.6085385084,
-0.0533901006,
-0.136621654,
-0.5875627398,
0.2831238508,
0.0857940242,
-0.1661656499,
0.1292897016,
0.5895087123,
-0.1834738255,
-0.3654184937,
-0.1159169227,
0.8032612205,
0.3175409734,
-0.278338939,
-0.5661494136,
-0.3827160299,
-0.1511545479,
-0.1764851362,
0.263040632,
0.2416297048,
-0.3034824729,
0.9390391111,
0.6041896343,
0.0028842092,
0.4274481535,
0.0020616231,
0.6543136835,
-0.6414650083,
-0.2705057263,
0.1238430068,
0.3362230659,
0.2764825225,
-0.309771508,
0.6156066656,
0.6739961505,
0.86520648,
0.0635903776,
0.5877167583,
-0.185597524,
0.8629186153,
-0.2869530022,
0.7417276502,
-0.6019325256,
0.0229762718,
0.3096910119,
-0.93322891,
-0.2434540242,
0.4655435383,
-0.3351263702,
0.1159250215,
0.3328495324,
1.0330919027,
-0.1014272496,
-0.0683161318,
0.2253852636,
0.0976263955,
0.1676264852,
0.3407872021,
1.139411211,
-0.7890118361,
0.7008606195,
-0.3147204816,
0.0209263414,
0.1092736349,
-0.6173716784,
-0.8837231398,
-0.6112579703,
-0.1693631411,
-0.2333046943,
0.123061657,
0.8039858341,
0.749802053,
-0.8706193566,
-0.0242502894,
0.1260114163,
0.1370875537,
-0.0826444328,
-0.248153761,
0.2306073308,
-0.3276685476,
-0.3295089304,
0.6504698396,
-0.2112587392,
0.0592344776,
-0.4843322933,
-0.3108620346,
-0.2696371377,
0.1984684765,
0.2383030355,
0.7106745243,
-0.3840037882,
-0.111105755,
0.2856649458,
-0.0984957889,
0.1303162724,
0.5065310001,
-1.3861569166,
0.5088909864,
0.6258009076,
0.9248508811,
0.3579910696,
-0.0056738397,
0.8327031136,
-0.8376868963,
-0.1861526817,
0.3917691708,
0.1516516209,
0.5949366689,
-0.2164913267,
0.5301972628,
-0.2883411646,
-0.8867122531,
-1.0827363729,
0.1827657223,
-0.523519218,
-0.0055726715,
1.0213327408,
-0.0026212118,
-0.2256489396,
-0.3308369219,
-0.3798493445,
0.1379389316,
-0.1962350756,
0.5656370521,
0.2458782792,
0.1847133189,
0.0497382358,
-0.7855120897,
0.7303165793,
0.301868856,
-0.99118191,
-0.1398453265,
0.6561251879,
0.4989680052,
0.3477801383,
0.746091485,
-0.0430966839,
0.7559397221,
-0.0321097262,
0.3009321094,
-0.057974156,
-0.083448261,
-0.4304355979,
0.2257215977,
0.42446509,
0.0644663572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00964v1
|
MALTO at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Leveraging Synthetic Data for LLM Hallucination Detection
| 2024-03-01T20:31:10 | 2024-03-01T20:31:10 |
Federico Borra, Claudio Savelli, Giacomo Rosso, Alkis Koudounas, Flavio Giobergia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In Natural Language Generation (NLG), contemporary Large Language Models
(LLMs) face several challenges, such as generating fluent yet inaccurate
outputs and reliance on fluency-centric metrics. This often leads to neural
networks exhibiting "hallucinations". The SHROOM challenge focuses on
automatically identifying these hallucinations in the generated text. To tackle
these issues, we introduce two key components, a data augmentation pipeline
incorporating LLM-assisted pseudo-labelling and sentence rephrasing, and a
voting ensemble from three models pre-trained on Natural Language Inference
(NLI) tasks and fine-tuned on diverse datasets.
|
[
-0.426872164,
-0.8890003562,
0.7148154974,
-0.0030331276,
-0.406789124,
-0.1619830728,
-0.0684420913,
-0.5835621357,
0.4429162741,
0.993761301,
-0.9631625414,
-0.5144990683,
-0.5202919841,
0.7150403261,
-0.3652880788,
0.7047880888,
0.1718278974,
0.1256929934,
-0.2940919697,
0.0887688994,
-0.7784901261,
-0.7376823425,
-0.356292814,
-0.3091197014,
0.396548599,
0.3619965315,
0.5467193723,
0.5218757391,
0.2901466489,
0.3870374262,
0.2606692016,
0.623939395,
-0.2779355645,
0.52178967,
0.0442184433,
-0.3313647509,
-0.2576037049,
-0.1671245545,
0.161627546,
0.5561873317,
-0.0895072147,
-0.3557162583,
0.0707853138,
0.4407705665,
-0.4561187625,
0.1170952395,
-0.9666051865,
0.1975547522,
-0.2912771404,
-0.4433405399,
-0.4270541966,
-0.2288035899,
-0.1405659914,
-0.3881671131,
0.3260526359,
0.1653751284,
0.6375530958,
0.7477689981,
-0.2763715684,
-0.7028049827,
-0.4081175327,
0.6770296097,
-0.8619375229,
0.5223805308,
0.5142840147,
0.1876196563,
-0.3264144063,
-0.9735528827,
-0.6352103353,
-0.259455353,
-0.2038006186,
-0.0176081732,
0.0787201524,
0.1081289053,
0.2088661641,
0.337996006,
-0.6071960926,
-0.0171367228,
-0.5219125152,
-0.4449045658,
0.7373373508,
0.363953054,
0.2763320208,
-0.4080692232,
-0.0566157699,
0.0843821764,
-0.2511666715,
-0.721763432,
0.4561475217,
0.3524070382,
0.3716893792,
0.7251982093,
-0.0788973197,
0.6498582363,
-0.0944468528,
0.2410117239,
0.4230186343,
-0.4245165288,
-0.2904779613,
0.4331300259,
0.6279820204,
0.2296442389,
0.1317540556,
-0.123260349,
-0.4701293409,
0.2457448095,
0.6354608536,
-0.574676156,
-0.4496637881,
0.1706549227,
-0.2213596702,
-0.735517323,
-0.0913977772,
-0.9288487434,
-0.8445555568,
-0.5459756851,
0.8440583944,
-0.4027753472,
0.1677132845,
0.0939315185,
-0.2296964973,
0.2033600807,
0.1887730509,
-0.7768090963,
0.1776471883,
0.5790439844,
0.6617198586,
-0.3581343889,
-0.2397615016,
-0.5989365578,
0.0109579032,
-0.3112757802,
0.8298155665,
-0.5818254352,
-0.3489364684,
-0.1547933221,
0.3354285657,
-0.0659293905,
-0.7752310038,
0.7941921949,
0.066366829,
0.5928875804,
-0.1895293444,
-0.4872394502,
-0.1086707488,
0.1820689738,
-0.6436855793,
1.0475019217,
0.2801860273,
-0.6865183115,
0.2619760633,
-0.3269435763,
-0.5008949637,
0.2371002585,
-0.3726575673,
-0.5339357853,
0.4768739343,
0.3565060496,
0.4197941422,
-0.1232894138,
0.5832875967,
-0.1851439327,
-0.5417205095,
0.1232173592,
-0.614377439,
0.4890851676,
0.198873058,
-0.4487227499,
0.3771538138,
-0.9860358834,
-0.2353562862,
0.0579696819,
-0.0198715199,
-0.15058887,
-0.0743429363,
0.0271505918,
0.0378203131,
0.1620807201,
-0.2280284017,
0.0892303512,
-0.5928422213,
0.3797226548,
0.8805436492,
0.3439676464,
0.1755821854,
-0.438768059,
0.4459872544,
-0.1524114013,
0.0307426061,
-0.2400704473,
-0.5792403817,
-0.8007301092,
-0.1883033216,
0.0340700895,
0.5237460136,
-0.9140844941,
0.6863793731,
-0.1375975907,
-0.3439022601,
-0.6290801764,
0.082172446,
-0.1626759768,
0.4970094264,
0.4948999584,
-0.0395318754,
-1.0320012569,
-1.0656783581,
-0.1924792379,
0.0889294147,
-0.15572083,
0.2571255863,
0.5401846766,
-0.683105588,
0.482549727,
-0.2949061394,
-0.6121046543,
-0.2433823496,
0.3080829084,
0.0780175552,
0.350050211,
0.0996387824,
-0.583652854,
-0.0246318486,
-0.0578429997,
-0.9951440096,
-0.7050023675,
-0.2469832152,
0.0398434252,
0.538618207,
0.8010038137,
-0.3552521169,
0.4132860601,
0.4154908955,
-0.0531936288,
0.4880001247,
-0.093594566,
0.3425880671,
-1.2502688169,
-0.3190211654,
-0.4030848145,
-0.1559338272,
-0.8378086686,
-0.2119325548,
-0.171203807,
-0.0591530912,
-0.2284094989,
0.3629443645,
-0.3173247576,
0.120477736,
-0.4675254822,
0.0822158754,
-0.0692526475,
0.4770143032,
0.2132011801,
0.733340621,
0.1973535866,
-0.4788437784,
0.3282615244,
0.0696901307,
-0.1626045555,
0.2943029702,
-0.3901751935,
0.3670327067,
-0.0296658427,
0.0534633659,
-1.027838707,
-0.7142139077,
0.4407437742,
-0.5425229669,
0.0415182412,
0.2120845467,
-0.4815880358,
-0.3901118636,
-0.3850536048,
0.1741787046,
0.3598385751,
-0.5059555173,
0.8873815536,
0.4199858904,
0.1865177602,
-0.4078204036,
-0.792630434,
0.4346231222,
-0.377784729,
-0.5730723739,
0.3965822458,
0.198303774,
-0.2730223238,
-0.2473903745,
-0.2289543599,
0.1360963434,
0.0944817588,
0.417855978,
0.2115410268,
-0.0744744912,
0.0460617281,
0.0598053858,
-0.0840471163,
0.2795674205,
-0.2637678683,
0.8538748026,
0.0673040748,
-0.4064588249,
-0.4400244057,
0.0819003135,
0.5608700514,
0.2155834287,
0.5577105284,
0.6700663567,
-0.8608862758,
-0.4252892435,
-0.7189306617,
-0.6380140781,
-0.5167494416,
0.2995350361,
-0.4030892253,
-0.8150920868,
0.5243508816,
0.1299267262,
-0.1491917521,
0.3937101662,
0.6726676226,
-0.0155077344,
1.078848958,
0.13950333,
0.2106314451,
0.0341349915,
-0.0682099313,
0.509516716,
-0.5154514909,
-0.3921258748,
-0.4479431808,
-0.2921968102,
-0.6600514054,
-0.6384157538,
0.2623339295,
-0.1420009583,
0.3269974291,
0.5074368119,
-0.7137150168,
0.3903157115,
0.4875080287,
0.0223309081,
0.3066368699,
-0.0006131965,
-0.0693526566,
-0.3052616715,
-0.4119783044,
-0.599159658,
0.8762947321,
0.1307643205,
0.560159862,
-0.2542919219,
0.9528998137,
0.5035052299,
0.0606294274,
-0.7788595557,
0.696410656,
0.0105423974,
-0.4213236868,
-0.3324263692,
-0.3274392784,
-0.7325106859,
0.4121153355,
-0.214241758,
-0.6464980841,
0.2179545909,
-0.2346330583,
-0.0899634287,
0.1161925271,
-0.5202509761,
0.6244128346,
-0.2235437036,
-0.308836937,
-0.0579208098,
-0.4041948915,
0.5916385055,
-0.4147618711,
0.1959830672,
0.129391849,
0.1132830828,
0.6772729158,
-0.4642573595,
0.761709094,
-0.0795985386,
-0.2739880681,
0.3380024135,
0.1255764514,
0.6105850339,
0.1187680662,
-0.1323825717,
0.0311568025,
-0.1150549874,
0.0217148419,
-0.6289957762,
0.669067502,
-0.3746162653,
-0.748534441,
-0.5189077854,
-0.4969670177,
-0.3852184117,
-0.0504051,
0.5974754095,
0.2905781865,
0.0201231632,
0.3178644776,
0.4878352284,
-0.2959868014,
0.2367379367,
-0.0627814084,
-0.2967957854,
-0.6997287273,
0.996876359,
0.0330448076,
-0.0989335105,
-0.0081325816,
0.1099988148,
-0.5820251107,
-0.671135366,
-0.2323201001,
0.1685144901,
-0.625199914,
-0.23496373,
-0.9519605637,
-0.6351308823,
-0.6033974886,
-0.2711732388,
-0.1900617331,
-0.410736084,
-0.4778831601,
-0.3110499382,
0.1039404348,
0.7497595549,
-0.2186956853,
0.3403191864,
-0.7669810653,
0.3976069093,
0.3366818428,
-0.1240457147,
-0.2445967197,
-0.735542953,
0.047760807,
-0.0041276184,
-0.319612205,
-1.0233002901,
0.8517444134,
-0.0230290163,
0.5966754556,
0.3871587217,
0.0361878537,
0.8884447813,
-0.2609994411,
0.7922462225,
-0.0893201679,
-0.8834322691,
0.8625789285,
-0.2278187275,
0.0060196593,
0.763784945,
0.1794855595,
-0.4613939524,
-0.7304543853,
-0.5722520351,
-0.7602131367,
0.5622078776,
0.5426205993,
0.3054549992,
-0.3040917814,
0.2906001508,
0.3671465516,
0.2747174203,
-0.8485341072,
0.2121994346,
-0.0419875272,
-0.41866225,
0.1568317562,
-0.2776788175,
0.1729146689,
-0.2111236602,
0.7295635343,
-0.0565000847,
0.033844538,
0.3515861332,
-0.309730649,
0.0013467226,
0.1441158354,
0.7648541331,
0.4367645383,
-0.2920714021,
0.275760293,
0.5754976273,
-0.4685458243,
0.0270325374,
-0.1340461373,
0.0393785089,
0.2307704091,
0.6956427097,
0.8379580379,
0.0890254602,
-0.8042144179,
0.246509105,
0.0141763659,
-0.6482120156,
-0.3921100199,
0.2778238058,
-0.1914174706,
0.2221201658,
0.4570490122,
0.0331033543,
0.3802365661,
-0.5524564981,
0.7911021113,
0.2753736079,
-0.6603222489,
-0.3417417407,
0.755212903,
-0.0822696909,
-0.6304783225,
0.6740857363,
-0.2893256843,
-0.748619616,
0.4507780671,
0.5251374245,
0.9875165224,
-0.3108337522,
0.0939700454,
0.3895072341,
0.4875757396,
-0.0323053002,
0.3673011065,
0.0097966325,
-0.7249554396,
-0.1869921535,
-0.6910063624,
-0.0568125546,
0.7288906574,
-0.4363352954,
0.7069686651,
-0.1643311977,
-0.0873236805,
-0.1666755974,
-0.0750788823,
-0.2470879406,
0.1104098111,
0.3376999795,
0.3608425856,
-1.0100437403,
0.7128760219,
0.2658846974,
-0.1259881556,
-0.4248447418,
-0.0144619374,
0.1601658612,
-0.6986231208,
0.3177719116,
0.5320590138,
-0.1699721217,
0.0225792974,
-0.5612562299,
-0.2130138725,
0.9852046371,
0.0722689033,
-0.6983031034,
-0.2158777565,
0.3148159087,
0.6189432144,
-0.3876365721,
-0.0964755639,
0.772407949,
0.6861625314,
0.2921608686,
-0.5806526542,
-0.0273515545,
-0.1336309761,
-0.1707583666,
0.0953996852,
0.0641980767,
0.5015215874,
-0.0439777263,
-0.2571699023,
-0.0351431444,
0.6696227193,
0.6187012792,
0.6335900426,
0.7241819501,
0.766620934,
0.9086460471,
-0.1321683973,
0.6751006842,
-0.2436551303,
-0.1499079317,
1.3183661699,
-0.4217064083,
0.522325635,
0.692468524,
0.1218740493,
0.0463992096,
0.830065012,
-0.3365099132,
0.5144597888,
0.4266727269,
-0.162374258,
-0.3339956403,
-0.2623603046,
-0.3583184183,
0.5885503292,
0.5461028814,
-0.4006973803,
0.001467315,
0.393214494,
-0.3384562731,
0.1709069908,
0.0957997665,
0.8899003267,
0.1779907346,
-0.6920278072,
0.4292297363,
-0.0512395389,
0.7354525328,
-0.1962491572,
-0.259912461,
-0.3834791481,
-0.0623763278,
-0.1506983042,
-0.4637320042,
0.7072406411,
-0.2192023396,
0.2908026278,
-0.1219846681,
0.9438741803,
-0.3647043407,
-0.5879510641,
0.2957327664,
0.5101968646,
0.2697760165,
-0.2982343435,
-0.3211458027,
0.1951774508,
0.2133995742,
-0.0329783447,
-0.0380223356,
0.6806598902,
-0.2776916623,
0.6018522978,
0.5749226809,
0.103269577,
0.2373971492,
0.5033503771,
0.6704583764,
-0.5753022432,
-0.2357527465,
-1.0292470455,
0.2269084454,
-0.1642133296,
-0.0196039397,
0.5997906327,
0.6974701285,
0.6624470353,
-0.2402110398,
0.5966724753,
0.1256551147,
0.1184426174,
-0.6455245614,
0.6302815676,
-0.7077710629,
0.4378032088,
-0.161787644,
-1.0463311672,
-0.304492265,
0.8263897896,
-0.078498058,
-0.0921545178,
0.8655459285,
1.2066522837,
0.1229492798,
0.3779532611,
0.4785002768,
0.1517769545,
0.09151081,
0.4149721563,
1.2029601336,
-0.5671899319,
0.3772738576,
-0.3364483714,
0.3214191794,
-0.226684913,
-0.5884568691,
-1.0180727243,
-1.0922870636,
-0.3491947353,
-0.3943091631,
0.0523433499,
0.8860431314,
0.4787682295,
-1.1104471684,
-0.0393420719,
-0.5022955537,
0.0634183809,
0.1628855467,
-0.3057144284,
0.1532903016,
-0.6082824469,
-0.8305895925,
0.6168023944,
0.4382712543,
0.262563467,
-0.2433242798,
0.055163458,
-0.090836294,
0.3520650268,
0.5109111071,
-0.5783695579,
-0.8140403628,
-0.3329668045,
0.1137861237,
-0.0718532577,
0.0093823215,
0.7656750083,
-0.7412538528,
0.3271330893,
0.7378194928,
0.7117235065,
0.3387918174,
0.0894747898,
0.5845864415,
-0.6362274289,
0.0231249519,
0.5607334971,
0.2055105567,
0.212609455,
-0.5410533547,
0.863687396,
0.4922925532,
-0.4588536024,
-1.3637987375,
-0.1204432473,
-0.7788561583,
-0.4894349575,
0.8000075221,
0.6339557171,
-0.311325103,
-0.3666148186,
-0.3867247999,
0.2914554179,
0.0420035049,
1.0940009356,
0.9924347997,
-0.0552781597,
-0.3518100083,
-0.7764051557,
0.7876104712,
0.4322297573,
-1.0211001635,
0.0428755209,
0.6538239717,
-0.2408004105,
0.1419500262,
0.6116078496,
-0.1564177126,
-0.0230534282,
-0.0444189534,
-0.0874858797,
-0.0604035109,
-0.6117350459,
-0.4500159323,
0.1766902655,
-0.4131824374,
-0.2022177577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00953v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00953v1
|
AutoRD: An Automatic and End-to-End System for Rare Disease Knowledge Graph Construction Based on Ontologies-enhanced Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T20:06:39 | 2024-03-01T20:06:39 |
Lang Cao, Jimeng Sun, Adam Cross
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Objectives: Our objective is to create an end-to-end system called AutoRD,
which automates extracting information from clinical text about rare diseases.
We have conducted various tests to evaluate the performance of AutoRD and
highlighted its strengths and limitations in this paper.
Materials and Methods: Our system, AutoRD, is a software pipeline involving
data preprocessing, entity extraction, relation extraction, entity calibration,
and knowledge graph construction. We implement this using large language models
and medical knowledge graphs developed from open-source medical ontologies. We
quantitatively evaluate our system on entity extraction, relation extraction,
and the performance of knowledge graph construction.
Results: AutoRD achieves an overall F1 score of 47.3%, a 14.4% improvement
compared to the base LLM. In detail, AutoRD achieves an overall entity
extraction F1 score of 56.1% (rare_disease: 83.5%, disease: 35.8%,
symptom_and_sign: 46.1%, anaphor: 67.5%) and an overall relation extraction F1
score of 38.6% (produces: 34.7%, increases_risk_of: 12.4%, is_a: 37.4%,
is_acronym: 44.1%, is_synonym: 16.3%, anaphora: 57.5%). Our qualitative
experiment also demonstrates that the performance in constructing the knowledge
graph is commendable.
Discussion: AutoRD demonstrates the potential of LLM applications in rare
disease detection. This improvement is attributed to several design, including
the integration of ontologies-enhanced LLMs.
Conclusion: AutoRD is an automated end-to-end system for extracting rare
disease information from text to build knowledge graphs. It uses
ontologies-enhanced LLMs for a robust medical knowledge base. The superior
performance of AutoRD is validated by experimental evaluations, demonstrating
the potential of LLMs in healthcare.
|
[
-0.3028572202,
-0.7950440645,
0.4115273654,
-0.4371738732,
-0.2888940573,
0.2210894972,
0.1237960905,
-0.6075207591,
0.5512937307,
0.4799286127,
-0.2242632359,
-0.6896755099,
-0.7191773653,
0.3459858,
-0.4194891751,
0.9947527051,
0.0441077799,
0.1976669431,
-0.0113047473,
-0.1753489375,
0.0492529012,
-0.4203579724,
-0.4701866508,
-0.2978016436,
0.2054193318,
0.6071182489,
0.9731043577,
0.8846670389,
0.7510630488,
0.2645706236,
0.042953115,
0.1765630394,
-0.6856316924,
0.3745731413,
-0.0218292698,
0.0374699794,
-1.0610393286,
-0.1654616892,
0.2735333741,
0.7787174582,
-0.1242167279,
-0.1071036384,
0.0081140529,
0.7251828313,
-0.1525404602,
0.1377566755,
-0.2702614069,
0.4181327224,
-0.3557625115,
-0.2448950857,
0.1041701958,
-0.2396201491,
0.306311816,
-0.7677205205,
0.0314567983,
0.2740772963,
0.7975067496,
0.4397457242,
-0.4757124484,
-0.5305930972,
-0.5140929222,
0.3337374926,
-0.641405046,
0.3076718152,
0.2056718171,
0.4863459766,
-0.1866275817,
-1.1356563568,
-0.4725309014,
-0.1361184865,
-0.0970508531,
0.2487481833,
-0.4154142439,
0.3026506305,
0.1867344081,
0.7633740902,
-0.9189002514,
0.2854869962,
-0.2956423163,
-0.2632573545,
0.6227422357,
0.6235227585,
0.414277494,
-0.4446714818,
-0.4001647532,
0.2597842515,
-0.6621317267,
-0.5404643416,
0.0992088467,
-0.0785999596,
0.047432702,
0.8083326221,
-0.6083344221,
1.1193733215,
0.041928146,
-0.0098503027,
0.5210857391,
-0.4724915326,
-0.2389078438,
0.026178617,
0.8885594606,
0.3868820965,
0.3046583533,
-0.3304499686,
-0.1431467086,
-0.1349337399,
-0.0638499483,
-0.554072082,
-0.6263877749,
0.2191586792,
-0.831007421,
-0.4429006279,
-0.3675706685,
-0.7855489254,
-0.2379500568,
0.0805423409,
0.3666105568,
-0.5504856706,
-0.16109927,
-0.0521055758,
-0.1366157234,
0.0517966151,
0.4667239785,
-0.4568750262,
0.4569145143,
0.132573083,
0.6845915318,
-0.7221381664,
-0.0334838852,
-0.5216197968,
0.3359354734,
-0.032902766,
1.0555477142,
-0.4823932648,
-0.5521655679,
-0.4964883029,
0.0886535347,
0.0570651516,
-0.4557839036,
0.1763891727,
-0.485216558,
0.1564840078,
-0.0445436537,
-0.7825050354,
0.0649871901,
0.1255306005,
-0.8426947594,
0.6899867058,
0.4343822598,
-0.656408608,
0.3780688345,
-0.5189344287,
-0.5397045016,
0.4743797779,
-0.4278825223,
-0.0012562637,
-0.2804574668,
0.1015968993,
0.3407366276,
-0.652557373,
0.0270911232,
-0.3391048014,
0.0957919881,
-0.0374582894,
-0.3152469397,
0.6505968571,
0.5771889687,
-0.3314637244,
-0.3631953299,
-0.898858726,
0.2856147587,
0.2062601745,
-0.2328542471,
-0.3567750752,
-0.287063241,
-0.1701765507,
0.2809093893,
0.4019375145,
-0.4774456918,
0.3246159852,
-0.7408136725,
0.1423906386,
0.4229522645,
0.1333494782,
0.2784404755,
-0.4505082965,
0.7382523417,
-0.0715700164,
0.3230640888,
0.0529947765,
-0.8048200011,
-0.4562761188,
-0.1972634047,
0.5374296308,
0.6731182337,
-0.5323913097,
0.8750938177,
-0.2998441458,
-0.2108393013,
-0.369309485,
0.1193664074,
0.4526925087,
0.8507492542,
0.3558322191,
-0.8189581037,
-0.3802017272,
-0.5343239307,
-0.0429274179,
-0.1660525799,
0.3436674476,
0.525452435,
0.3627634346,
-0.4033054709,
1.0029414892,
-0.8707000017,
-0.7403059602,
-0.1925178766,
-0.118783325,
0.0844039768,
0.3619033396,
0.4804522991,
-0.4217745066,
-0.7587314844,
0.2784313858,
-1.0847870111,
-0.301594466,
0.5869845748,
0.1918382049,
0.3394109905,
0.477317065,
-0.532333076,
0.6277816892,
0.524699986,
-0.4737101495,
0.463624239,
-0.5415158868,
0.0954893157,
-0.8003219962,
0.3327568471,
-0.5180062652,
-0.5326415896,
-0.3795770705,
-0.1985723376,
-0.3204431832,
-0.0087316344,
-0.0016431654,
0.6480922699,
-0.650005877,
-0.0783362091,
-0.2012886554,
0.2006931156,
0.1554669887,
-0.0831027925,
-0.1449917257,
0.2502048016,
0.5534749031,
-0.4307589829,
0.6355093122,
0.2526576519,
-0.2570258081,
0.5794605017,
-0.7186684608,
-0.1553785205,
0.2456210554,
0.2131482959,
-1.1515489817,
-0.2688471675,
0.2360213846,
-0.7216920853,
0.5409193039,
-0.0374187902,
-0.6028262377,
-0.6595677733,
0.2502351403,
0.1295377612,
0.467684269,
-0.0489486866,
0.4587619603,
0.8714882731,
-0.3490759432,
-0.5133656859,
-0.8190800548,
0.2396287173,
0.0696166456,
-0.5847119689,
0.1524371505,
-0.0875886604,
-0.2827335,
0.5300982594,
0.0236599781,
-0.4106391966,
-0.0255645625,
0.0192058105,
-0.048147615,
-0.1384048164,
0.326877296,
0.1546494812,
-0.3908865452,
-0.198920995,
-0.264763087,
0.497426033,
-0.1178880706,
-0.5777242184,
-0.2345830202,
0.3012767136,
0.5167637467,
-0.0322360434,
0.1467321664,
0.2171232551,
-0.3379737139,
-0.0338183753,
-0.4802066684,
-0.0718617439,
-0.4228993356,
0.3261214793,
-0.2233700007,
-0.7040540576,
0.6892970204,
-0.0940315425,
-0.0936170667,
0.835257411,
0.5147101879,
-0.1059157401,
0.8909741044,
0.5145078301,
-0.0380416997,
-0.2408592105,
-0.2326277345,
0.0220029708,
-0.5059944391,
-0.2455086261,
-0.301396966,
-0.1161910295,
-0.429056555,
-0.5970992446,
0.5766375065,
-0.0072486554,
-0.017320374,
0.0019771096,
-0.7971262932,
0.0646870956,
0.0200020466,
0.0864211917,
0.8151174784,
0.0326238312,
-0.3217051923,
-0.1102707013,
-1.05245471,
-0.3570871353,
1.7003536224,
0.2023742795,
0.939283669,
0.0157628879,
0.7908097506,
0.5671214461,
0.5088357329,
-0.7005816102,
0.283434242,
-0.4448926747,
-0.7882162929,
-0.5863522887,
-0.4603621662,
-1.1520340443,
-0.0426130071,
-0.0712089539,
-0.4636397958,
0.2815959454,
0.2159470916,
-0.5723884702,
0.1634586155,
-0.4815224409,
0.6833688021,
-0.5786812901,
0.0405401513,
-0.094575718,
-0.8822983503,
0.2692886293,
-0.4177362025,
0.3205407262,
0.2062381208,
-0.0819524229,
0.7773218155,
-1.0118492842,
0.70356071,
0.02313786,
-0.0738924071,
0.1198834032,
-0.0354240388,
0.6387165189,
0.1473009735,
-0.1766482592,
0.2495141923,
-0.0523991138,
-0.0130008198,
-0.467491895,
0.8260357976,
-0.751239419,
-0.4198747575,
-0.6342897415,
-0.5320062637,
-0.0811532363,
0.5851607919,
0.3454947174,
0.6059135199,
-0.5982932448,
-0.1996422708,
0.7478280067,
-0.3189276159,
0.0548399389,
0.8544061184,
-0.2106545419,
-0.6376157999,
0.8725961447,
0.3871383965,
0.4559744596,
0.2760353088,
0.1284603477,
-0.1233498529,
-0.4491307437,
-0.6711584926,
0.1102015674,
-0.9979125261,
-0.3067496419,
-1.2820620537,
-0.318726927,
-0.7506766319,
0.080648534,
-0.3651736975,
-0.7988035083,
-0.4658770263,
0.1226359755,
0.701875329,
0.995518446,
-0.4513204992,
0.0123794852,
-0.6511196494,
0.5122795701,
0.2116717398,
0.1602035016,
-0.0936744362,
-0.6608187556,
-0.0775055587,
-0.2197512835,
-0.0611022301,
-0.8820632696,
0.6764518619,
0.3478145003,
0.9206315279,
0.5329160094,
0.2516120672,
0.7448968887,
-0.3172871768,
0.4637742937,
0.2080714554,
-0.6236110926,
0.3618040383,
-0.1744805276,
0.1989113986,
0.5718381405,
0.4589289725,
-0.2240864336,
-0.4057278335,
-0.9630846977,
-1.0081702471,
0.5534409285,
0.067130059,
-0.5472438931,
-0.0604806878,
0.2718577385,
0.1348320097,
0.1000871211,
-0.4277672172,
-0.8684693575,
-0.0613747425,
-0.1678720415,
-0.0731392801,
-0.2096401304,
-0.4190962017,
-0.3368970156,
0.2751683295,
-0.1178145707,
0.2616530657,
0.5673688054,
-0.4038796723,
-0.400847584,
-0.0681454465,
0.0035808219,
0.5724347234,
-0.0754979029,
0.0307944119,
0.3042633832,
-0.6181442738,
-0.1035519764,
0.6194571853,
0.0410433486,
0.1588183939,
0.2980014086,
0.3011028767,
0.0861960575,
-0.635971427,
0.7263547778,
-0.0801656172,
-0.0678948537,
-0.3609725237,
0.0006871949,
-0.0262198206,
0.0522207879,
0.4074676931,
-0.1559174359,
0.3145006895,
-0.2055311352,
0.7292554975,
0.5357281566,
-0.5609611273,
-0.1365532279,
0.6187770963,
0.2636580169,
0.0235601589,
0.4681423903,
-0.3905046284,
-0.2043180466,
0.8124709725,
0.4484982193,
0.4794220924,
-0.2923153937,
-0.0016309423,
0.0371868722,
0.4370152056,
0.1601816416,
0.503301084,
0.113981992,
-0.3599627912,
-0.3660470843,
-0.6670891047,
-0.2272550464,
-0.0888442323,
-0.4060280323,
0.3460728526,
-0.0334170945,
-0.1216340736,
0.012579428,
0.0160289761,
-0.6002286077,
0.4890619218,
-0.2067056149,
0.7943916917,
-0.5434858799,
0.9894835353,
0.7568413615,
-0.3908222318,
-0.675496161,
-0.1327096373,
0.0501638129,
-0.9973164797,
1.0740714073,
-0.3604178727,
0.1113381386,
0.5516543984,
-0.1934817135,
-1.3734567165,
1.2108803988,
-0.0762171447,
-0.6239495873,
-0.1482666284,
0.1257131249,
0.7074567676,
-0.4440277517,
0.5279994011,
0.3745610118,
0.5682203174,
0.0781897828,
-1.3346834183,
0.1978983134,
-0.1775950789,
-0.5569124818,
0.1390464455,
-0.5049609542,
0.718706131,
-0.4263593554,
-0.2015061975,
0.1861798465,
0.3191087544,
-0.0075759492,
0.2685089111,
0.3545167744,
1.0478159189,
0.941324234,
0.0673471093,
1.0022280216,
-0.7797071338,
0.3190253377,
0.7464764118,
-0.4759429991,
0.1169900522,
-0.0225751493,
-0.0411484726,
0.4712997675,
0.3487445414,
0.1092247441,
0.5649337173,
0.2509454489,
-0.001920187,
-0.2850517035,
0.1236269996,
-0.78689605,
0.4210177958,
0.7014165521,
-0.66590029,
-0.4814153612,
0.0343496688,
-0.1031819209,
-0.4184523225,
0.0783693865,
0.7556174994,
0.2133560777,
-0.3609229624,
0.801961422,
-0.3719400465,
0.1983953416,
-0.6531586051,
-0.0959818438,
-0.0971227363,
0.155618012,
-0.3692145944,
-0.852445066,
0.3354044855,
-0.11618983,
-0.2203859985,
0.0675441921,
1.0305988789,
-0.2155506611,
-0.3163630664,
0.4206435382,
0.9596020579,
0.6260019541,
0.4319007993,
-0.7681009173,
-0.1079951003,
-0.1128661186,
-0.3662163615,
0.4235161543,
0.8476260304,
-0.1217534989,
0.6678435802,
0.5939303041,
0.4868632257,
-0.3479620516,
-0.1400178373,
1.0575568676,
-0.8069501519,
-0.3884117305,
-0.5328784585,
0.015147578,
-0.1504665613,
-0.5285255313,
0.7742376924,
0.7121311426,
0.4606918097,
0.3821637928,
1.1096024513,
-0.441973418,
0.6574102044,
-0.1826536059,
1.200596571,
-0.719617486,
0.317168951,
-0.4234071374,
-0.4217631817,
-0.5707381368,
0.4497353733,
-0.1869297326,
0.0704368278,
0.9922178984,
0.6492022872,
0.0536546148,
-0.1814357936,
0.462641567,
0.5084059834,
0.1572294831,
0.5964100957,
0.4255116582,
-0.3402414024,
0.8478440046,
-0.0076163425,
-0.6216372252,
-0.359075129,
-0.7131205797,
-0.4799151421,
-0.2333670408,
-0.2979070842,
-0.6089913249,
0.5287060738,
0.5359834433,
0.4526313841,
-0.6305849552,
-0.1623387486,
-0.1304887533,
0.0719330907,
-0.0462198742,
-0.2049998641,
0.542778492,
-0.2337076962,
-0.3626180291,
0.5093257427,
0.4974436164,
-0.0705702677,
-0.2751554251,
-0.1796677709,
-0.0709680542,
-0.6082206964,
0.4513342977,
0.5717987418,
-0.3910708427,
0.1238103583,
0.0758754387,
-0.4296469986,
0.0966170356,
0.5167784691,
-1.0000162125,
0.8249846697,
0.6006147861,
0.2490989268,
0.3935638368,
-0.0679575205,
0.8173880577,
0.0672635511,
-0.2499946505,
0.5522883534,
0.2708999217,
0.1029130593,
-0.5196246505,
0.457349658,
0.6707843542,
-0.8503571153,
-0.7280836105,
0.1747473478,
-0.8576260209,
-0.3020807803,
1.4766905308,
-0.1237395853,
-0.1272279173,
-1.019543767,
0.1606928259,
0.4521570802,
-0.3025993407,
0.7231720686,
0.1176667139,
-0.63671422,
0.3277491629,
-0.5342102051,
0.6626292467,
0.3473903835,
-0.8770942092,
-0.1279270649,
0.5597929955,
0.513640821,
-0.1106722429,
1.1970221996,
-0.6245876551,
0.4184166193,
-0.3719771504,
0.2491651922,
-0.0200146921,
0.0199788362,
-0.3382627368,
0.0365541577,
-0.0181791689,
0.3232583702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00952v1
|
MediSwift: Efficient Sparse Pre-trained Biomedical Language Models
| 2024-03-01T20:03:44 | 2024-03-01T20:03:44 |
Vithursan Thangarasa, Mahmoud Salem, Shreyas Saxena, Kevin Leong, Joel Hestness, Sean Lie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are typically trained on general source data for
various domains, but a recent surge in domain-specific LLMs has shown their
potential to outperform general-purpose models in domain-specific tasks (e.g.,
biomedicine). Although domain-specific pre-training enhances efficiency and
leads to smaller models, the computational costs of training these LLMs remain
high, posing budgeting challenges. We introduce MediSwift, a suite of
biomedical LMs that leverage sparse pre-training on domain-specific biomedical
text data. By inducing up to 75% weight sparsity during the pre-training phase,
MediSwift achieves a 2-2.5x reduction in training FLOPs. Notably, all sparse
pre-training was performed on the Cerebras CS-2 system, which is specifically
designed to realize the acceleration benefits from unstructured weight
sparsity, thereby significantly enhancing the efficiency of the MediSwift
models. Through subsequent dense fine-tuning and strategic soft prompting,
MediSwift models outperform existing LLMs up to 7B parameters on biomedical
tasks, setting new benchmarks w.r.t efficiency-accuracy on tasks such as
PubMedQA. Our results show that sparse pre-training, along with dense
fine-tuning and soft prompting, offers an effective method for creating
high-performing, computationally efficient models in specialized domains.
|
[
-0.1054048538,
-0.6153873801,
0.7672099471,
0.1011145785,
-0.2994961739,
0.0709397346,
-0.4616435766,
-0.2900505364,
0.4022536278,
0.5954160094,
-0.7568979263,
-0.413723141,
-0.6714040041,
0.0899627134,
-0.3567528427,
1.1449154615,
-0.0221545175,
0.2449045032,
-0.2074754089,
-0.2622823417,
-0.0712813735,
-0.36545825,
-0.4522690177,
-0.5121501684,
0.9233862758,
0.2619589269,
0.7516999245,
0.4061468244,
0.4441217184,
0.2636632323,
0.0874904543,
0.2908454835,
-0.6610040665,
0.0761272535,
-0.1082101613,
-0.1797894835,
-0.5373743176,
-0.0242023617,
0.458527416,
1.1833415031,
-0.1920507401,
0.1935888976,
0.1492780447,
0.7942304015,
-0.512250185,
-0.2216569185,
-0.6136642694,
-0.1534430832,
-0.2567139268,
-0.1943175793,
-0.3133566976,
-0.1521104425,
0.1780327857,
-0.7407509089,
0.1391574442,
-0.1709217429,
0.9124724269,
0.4473160207,
-0.1192655936,
0.1197509989,
-0.4470009506,
0.6958423257,
-0.4387132525,
0.6382587552,
0.4301126599,
-0.130489409,
-0.3903646469,
-1.1711139679,
-0.1460896134,
-0.1828662753,
0.0709867477,
0.0021432224,
-0.3561604619,
0.2676835954,
0.0546459369,
-0.0901889578,
-0.8171818256,
0.1995035112,
-0.3457468748,
0.0482268073,
0.2539544702,
0.1029127166,
0.0383664258,
0.2782827318,
-0.0877523646,
-0.0267891586,
-0.7480410337,
-0.2014862895,
-0.1201929599,
0.2419253737,
-0.1048334464,
0.4729396701,
0.0774325058,
0.5464859009,
0.1409838498,
-0.155163914,
0.4144837856,
-0.092024982,
-0.2314812541,
-0.4323997796,
0.6188122034,
-0.0926228985,
0.4579026401,
-0.3422261775,
-0.1459364891,
-0.0982406586,
0.4041630328,
-1.0134943724,
-0.3115809858,
0.3466929495,
-0.7103352547,
-0.199464187,
-0.7095110416,
-0.4188843668,
-0.3795393705,
-0.4478680193,
0.5008209944,
-0.5913630724,
-0.2101224214,
0.424697727,
0.1779095978,
-0.2703645825,
0.276824832,
-0.7692927122,
0.5670531392,
0.3124606311,
0.9131947756,
-0.3813520074,
-0.2215336561,
-0.5905916691,
0.199715957,
-0.2090432495,
0.9216789603,
-0.3941278756,
-0.3738266528,
-0.1395816356,
0.0310013853,
-0.2714417577,
-0.4630083144,
0.4052853286,
-0.4030213058,
-0.2290573865,
-0.0105633009,
-0.5737451315,
0.3651635051,
-0.1102604717,
-0.4756627381,
0.8027207851,
0.2865885496,
-0.5972762108,
0.428093642,
-0.6091020107,
-0.6315802932,
0.4260763824,
-0.4335576594,
-0.5370326042,
0.235168606,
0.1206877306,
0.7258558273,
-0.3446767032,
0.3569038212,
-0.4246405065,
-0.4714917243,
0.3538897038,
-0.2158364654,
0.4830194414,
0.3614123166,
-0.1419264227,
0.0450856723,
-0.7256052494,
0.1382441074,
0.1945511997,
-0.3181719482,
-0.4307681322,
0.154680416,
0.3867176175,
-0.0253159627,
0.1251176894,
-0.3396870494,
0.1847904623,
-0.6899846196,
0.4064728618,
0.5030016899,
-0.2107932568,
0.4453362525,
-0.228731215,
0.3728670478,
-0.2867681384,
0.2162052095,
0.1880855113,
-0.291087836,
-0.3244237602,
-0.9097578526,
0.4610372484,
0.4060594738,
-0.6746066213,
0.3343031406,
-0.2462597638,
-0.496604234,
-0.5125590563,
0.1460874528,
0.2479518503,
0.4202042818,
0.5695356727,
0.049773261,
-0.2084005624,
-0.8297038674,
-0.3457085192,
0.1935223192,
-0.2679854035,
0.3296396434,
0.3992630541,
-0.6248810291,
0.715210855,
-0.5269373059,
-0.1547811031,
-0.2503538132,
0.226739496,
0.3040138781,
0.5966387391,
0.6914337277,
-0.6963436604,
-0.2573959529,
-0.1852169931,
-0.1884633601,
-0.3644736707,
-0.0853540599,
-0.0410553738,
-0.0348669514,
0.5307061672,
-0.849965632,
0.2213283926,
0.6715693474,
-0.4214423895,
0.3526177406,
-0.5908051133,
0.1416421384,
-0.9331700802,
0.3319011033,
-0.0577545613,
-0.2913673818,
-0.6822344661,
-0.379532069,
0.2354949564,
-0.0962212384,
-0.227169618,
0.5689188242,
-0.3834410608,
0.1476739198,
-0.3445120752,
-0.1173004285,
-0.011712037,
0.4337120354,
0.1900319308,
0.7700089216,
0.3879767656,
-0.4412860572,
-0.2904763222,
0.1670023948,
-0.2369503081,
0.1623484194,
-0.9316068292,
-0.1623576134,
-0.1576622874,
0.1419463456,
-0.7718964219,
-0.1494843215,
-0.0921441093,
-0.2493754625,
0.5631318092,
-0.1551831067,
-0.5377179384,
-0.3622520864,
-0.1222618446,
0.4362126887,
0.7174726129,
-0.4784128368,
0.4935537875,
0.4789720476,
-0.3887636364,
-0.512013793,
-0.7219362855,
-0.1649395227,
0.0233518481,
-0.3957968652,
0.5230303407,
-0.1701262742,
0.1393007785,
-0.1514180601,
-0.014674277,
-0.1651219428,
0.1128596812,
0.2605809569,
0.2937447429,
-0.0467395671,
0.2707048953,
0.4301284254,
-0.2171576619,
-0.2370682955,
-0.5016431808,
0.4084872007,
0.0952572897,
-0.4139696658,
-0.1019889042,
0.34820804,
0.4864595532,
-0.180011794,
0.754945755,
0.505741477,
-0.4818382561,
-0.2150452882,
-0.6551088095,
-0.2600231469,
-0.5136466026,
0.8591564894,
-0.2143890411,
-1.053912878,
0.1141330227,
-0.508918047,
0.0868334621,
0.267664969,
0.649848938,
-0.1937411278,
1.3324517012,
0.7551845312,
0.1001532599,
0.3374749422,
0.0135075822,
-0.033320874,
-0.1693772078,
-0.1577487439,
-0.7228285074,
-0.1582333446,
-0.3118828535,
-0.571639061,
0.601149857,
-0.1641278118,
-0.4075528979,
0.0542752519,
-0.4939090014,
0.482770741,
0.1146535501,
0.2176418006,
0.0107832598,
0.4296505153,
-0.2555685639,
-0.1818400323,
-0.9286242723,
-0.3715804815,
1.0509362221,
0.4358088076,
1.0324287415,
-0.3675208986,
0.5095384717,
0.1779935807,
0.4637581408,
-0.5080456734,
0.2823877931,
-0.5338881612,
-0.1488347203,
-0.1153548434,
-0.5695605278,
-1.2020440102,
0.0142469527,
-0.6376032829,
-0.5945183039,
0.1561682969,
0.2820972502,
-0.6061767936,
0.1914305985,
-0.5951282978,
0.79144454,
-0.1779537946,
-0.3800546825,
-0.3686705232,
-0.5659825802,
0.1211130098,
-0.4123878479,
0.3150937855,
-0.0882964954,
-0.4051333666,
0.817686975,
-0.4530273974,
0.6957649589,
-0.1880272329,
0.1619348377,
-0.0848207921,
0.0807959437,
0.3478405774,
-0.0389952287,
0.2191809267,
0.3636638522,
0.2713931203,
-0.4937169552,
-0.2502597868,
0.7383207083,
-0.8374970555,
-0.0534363724,
-0.2301224172,
-0.5940562487,
-0.7719028592,
0.265171349,
0.4212252796,
0.5318002701,
-0.0890933871,
0.1019785255,
1.0588593483,
-0.4620997906,
0.0160715226,
0.7125105262,
0.097270757,
-0.4217312634,
0.6698905826,
0.1321516931,
0.1538057178,
0.1763294786,
-0.0305642094,
-0.2386005968,
-0.8495851159,
-0.322845459,
0.4959678054,
-0.2394013107,
-0.5066913962,
-0.9576147795,
-0.1770909876,
-0.3544799089,
-0.4019839764,
-0.5293365121,
-0.3874085844,
-0.2853042185,
0.2746142447,
0.5300387144,
0.5588137507,
-0.0693384707,
0.4504835308,
-1.0433593988,
0.400745064,
-0.0289817899,
0.7194651365,
-0.3720351458,
-0.5675441623,
-0.5315598845,
-0.1289213449,
-0.0211305004,
-0.7303330898,
0.3859757185,
0.2914427221,
0.4224532843,
0.3064435124,
-0.3438129127,
0.6927724481,
-0.8351584673,
0.518936336,
0.5159167647,
-0.5560319424,
0.3186211586,
-0.3045296073,
0.2932755649,
0.7389222383,
0.5376214385,
-0.1087672114,
-0.2999888957,
-0.477214098,
-0.8357390761,
0.4615302682,
0.1020055115,
0.0194009878,
-0.0336646065,
0.7156325579,
0.1664932221,
0.1092986092,
-0.4255493283,
-0.2516416609,
0.2313017696,
-0.6202229261,
-0.1146785989,
-0.1937165707,
0.0080852667,
-0.3532043993,
0.6402557492,
-0.3417221606,
0.1654784977,
0.1985492855,
-0.1643717736,
-0.3013733029,
0.0447711572,
0.4099803865,
0.3101685643,
-0.025056133,
0.0264490601,
0.2471830398,
-0.9137622714,
0.0595844463,
0.468523562,
0.0888562128,
0.0117962714,
0.2823929787,
0.3943881691,
0.3946489692,
-1.0736167431,
0.7147136927,
-0.197410658,
-0.4991447628,
0.064834021,
-0.0824233592,
0.2178181261,
0.3307041228,
0.2788267136,
0.2177673727,
0.2212592959,
0.1642285436,
0.246974811,
0.484411478,
-0.1118190885,
-0.0862706676,
0.8129906654,
0.0297201201,
0.1425876617,
0.3299420774,
0.3418304324,
-0.0463668816,
0.2460211366,
0.4228131771,
0.6571156979,
-0.2102430463,
0.0046102093,
0.1701311469,
0.174027279,
-0.2339241952,
0.2910419703,
-0.0736026987,
-0.4724918306,
-0.8872284293,
-0.8880811334,
-0.1896148175,
0.3232419193,
-0.2834322453,
0.2784557939,
-0.3479509354,
-0.44864586,
0.1181268245,
0.0817116573,
-0.6893640161,
0.2664961517,
0.2060669959,
1.1753476858,
-0.7167425752,
0.9590204358,
0.6053883433,
-0.2022886872,
-0.7642732859,
-0.3476698697,
-0.3683234453,
-0.7543302774,
0.6626225114,
-0.1768404394,
-0.2761047184,
-0.0677568913,
-0.7978608608,
-1.005620122,
0.786295712,
0.6170114279,
-0.812956214,
-0.0744934157,
0.2239714861,
0.5661162138,
-0.1233337075,
0.1357409507,
0.5691378117,
0.1177298725,
-0.1062762141,
-0.8412011266,
-0.0509208031,
-0.3166748881,
-0.1599034816,
0.2081966549,
-0.3481414914,
0.7794702649,
-0.1727138609,
0.1029083654,
0.3190511763,
0.5842998624,
0.3301360607,
0.1409085095,
0.5409779549,
0.2657175362,
0.8123669028,
0.0290536229,
0.8382037282,
-0.4152514935,
0.0610026941,
0.7013590336,
-0.453384608,
0.6189402938,
0.5984012485,
-0.1702418923,
0.34953776,
0.4995591342,
0.2060189396,
0.4699596763,
0.2315603793,
-0.2622071803,
-0.4828327298,
0.0310969409,
-0.3989243805,
-0.0115646925,
0.708773613,
-0.2237931043,
-0.0873603672,
0.3639894128,
0.1296846122,
0.0794003606,
-0.3856724799,
0.6489369273,
0.1957950741,
-0.5031445026,
0.7087783813,
-0.0493125468,
0.6663728952,
-1.1274431944,
0.067311801,
-0.0867525935,
0.4585606158,
-0.1324869096,
-0.416218847,
0.0769997239,
0.1897885054,
-0.182826966,
-0.3337147534,
1.0538592339,
-0.4915120006,
-0.3556458056,
0.3654434681,
0.6569143534,
0.11456085,
0.0283399075,
-0.9346373081,
0.0916154385,
-0.3341777325,
-0.5583342314,
0.5975766182,
0.3169795275,
0.0977734625,
0.5585970283,
0.6027041674,
0.5223192573,
-0.2907693386,
0.3114413023,
1.0615397692,
-0.4147576392,
-0.3585846424,
-0.5517094731,
0.239808917,
-0.0848306566,
-0.1673490256,
0.2631904483,
0.4872730374,
0.3276360035,
-0.1110545099,
0.6741558313,
0.2861587405,
0.8823506832,
-0.4350057244,
0.9833549261,
-0.8183236122,
0.0056313495,
-0.2750419676,
-0.4225274622,
-0.5280064344,
0.567717135,
-0.1567240208,
0.2503113151,
0.6006110907,
0.8015361428,
-0.1845497936,
-0.1071445942,
0.4295972288,
0.2235630304,
-0.0392676257,
0.5754650235,
0.5894833803,
-0.1346440464,
0.3416277468,
0.0626979172,
-0.5233519077,
-0.0400958247,
-0.6780264378,
-0.967212379,
-0.4299762845,
-0.2736049592,
-0.4796549082,
0.2099985927,
1.3239248991,
0.9952754378,
-0.7304161787,
-0.0467578024,
0.031286072,
-0.4152761102,
-0.0225527808,
-0.0781320035,
0.5108468533,
-0.6949447393,
-0.3329223096,
0.572552979,
0.4038451016,
0.1591697335,
0.0075598741,
-0.1358125955,
-0.0856049731,
0.3784122467,
0.5482490659,
0.3315098882,
-0.2209509462,
0.058597032,
0.1479841322,
-0.3868648708,
-0.3374736309,
1.0258898735,
-0.9938243032,
-0.1734233499,
0.1385240108,
0.9157643318,
0.673897028,
-0.3102123737,
0.39974159,
-0.5854718685,
0.3101290762,
0.3156600595,
0.4757692814,
0.1514974535,
-0.2723711133,
0.442335099,
0.2792512476,
-0.7183096409,
-0.8234102726,
-0.0752205029,
-0.8761295676,
-0.7112826705,
1.0235227346,
0.1256772578,
-0.2898394465,
-0.2145598978,
-0.2497035265,
0.1566142291,
0.0334690735,
0.5075299144,
0.0744950473,
-0.1691428125,
0.3197475374,
-0.4543503225,
0.8533973098,
0.8641169667,
-0.8021076322,
0.0364137068,
0.5083244443,
0.4818405509,
-0.3106161654,
1.0472848415,
-0.1942963898,
0.3340804875,
-0.1726207584,
0.0842108801,
0.0415104218,
-0.3481118679,
-0.323771596,
0.1268485039,
0.021990994,
0.2171291709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00932v2
|
Differentially Private Knowledge Distillation via Synthetic Text Generation
| 2024-03-01T19:22:24 | 2024-06-05T03:07:44 |
James Flemings, Murali Annavaram
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language models (LLMs) are achieving state-of-the-art performance in
many different downstream tasks. However, the increasing urgency of data
privacy puts pressure on practitioners to train LLMs with Differential Privacy
(DP) on private data. Concurrently, the exponential growth in parameter size of
LLMs necessitates model compression before deployment of LLMs on
resource-constrained devices or latency-sensitive applications. Differential
privacy and model compression generally must trade off utility loss to achieve
their objectives. Moreover, simultaneously applying both schemes can compound
the utility degradation. To this end, we propose DistilDP: a novel
differentially private knowledge distillation algorithm that exploits synthetic
data generated by a differentially private teacher LLM. The knowledge of a
teacher LLM is transferred onto the student in two ways: one way from the
synthetic data itself -- the hard labels, and the other way by the output
distribution of the teacher evaluated on the synthetic data -- the soft labels.
Furthermore, if the teacher and student share a similar architectural
structure, we can further distill knowledge by aligning the hidden
representations between both. Our experimental results demonstrate that
DistilDP can substantially improve the utility over existing baselines, at
least $9.0$ PPL on the Big Patent dataset, with strong privacy parameters,
$\epsilon=2$. These promising results progress privacy-preserving compression
of autoregressive LLMs. Our code can be accessed here:
https://github.com/james-flemings/dp_compress.
|
[
-0.182549268,
-0.3641771674,
0.6565936804,
0.1123422608,
-0.3043495715,
0.5940147638,
-0.2270553112,
-0.2009571046,
-0.0289420541,
0.3839245737,
-0.3980691731,
-0.6328086257,
-0.8988412619,
-0.0338092335,
-0.5233159661,
0.906484127,
0.1755299419,
-0.0765702873,
0.0255954154,
0.1035176963,
-0.0841330364,
-0.8067455292,
-0.1730556935,
-0.100605011,
0.3118638098,
0.1575214118,
0.4532296658,
0.6505119801,
0.0535745658,
0.4533680379,
-0.2735077143,
0.3747607768,
-0.599812448,
0.3618658483,
-0.1903551817,
-0.3240044713,
-0.3701127768,
0.2010307461,
0.5971979499,
0.7129075527,
-0.2221650183,
0.2061433494,
0.5395094156,
1.0026859045,
-0.7057006359,
0.313734591,
-0.7809832096,
0.1645357907,
-0.0294750296,
-0.0961898044,
-0.3711776137,
-0.6186035872,
0.0321625844,
-0.2062405497,
0.3730812073,
-0.150066793,
0.4651894867,
0.5879366994,
-0.2883353531,
0.0686933026,
-0.8073275685,
0.633035779,
-0.5419534445,
0.1863675267,
0.2951160371,
0.3376526237,
-0.2694566846,
-0.8233705163,
-0.6744655371,
0.0446059182,
-0.1559411883,
-0.1018550321,
-0.0594015606,
0.0222229026,
0.19466497,
0.8038447499,
-0.2358465046,
0.1248552129,
-0.4571397603,
-0.0722940713,
0.8397420049,
0.0026210085,
-0.0791455209,
0.0087205553,
-0.4090092778,
-0.1972461939,
-0.4890765846,
-0.2064166665,
0.7173238993,
0.0105468417,
-0.1440778375,
0.4956445992,
-0.1547642499,
0.6175291538,
0.0954884514,
-0.2701839209,
0.0480237417,
-0.0393282287,
-0.2238376141,
0.3091615736,
0.8278806806,
0.2524244487,
0.1321689039,
-0.0609332696,
-0.0240990743,
0.0274223089,
-0.1038807258,
-0.7904595137,
-0.5192182064,
0.1556204408,
-0.0607744008,
-0.6447136402,
-0.0767776147,
-0.9405978322,
-0.7126752734,
-0.4421291947,
0.2758770287,
0.0094661172,
-0.2101949453,
0.2935948074,
-0.3333427608,
-0.4885419011,
-0.0271232072,
-1.0705928802,
0.562035799,
0.6502628922,
0.8486144543,
-0.0583830178,
-0.0577004626,
-0.4537631273,
0.5107847452,
0.0888729244,
0.1105712429,
-0.2149237096,
-0.5608378649,
-0.1962486953,
-0.0655735433,
0.4185683429,
-0.5335425735,
0.2147076279,
-0.4689079821,
0.2628630698,
0.1521431357,
-0.5297074318,
0.0790087208,
0.0188551601,
-0.6708387136,
0.6665650606,
0.0721828565,
-0.7722936869,
0.1312466413,
-0.296530664,
-0.1704166234,
-0.0189503934,
-0.41774863,
-0.5853278041,
0.210911572,
0.195830375,
0.6555761099,
-0.2015750706,
0.5171985626,
-0.357321918,
-0.2209219486,
0.4199633896,
-0.704095304,
0.8985701799,
0.1676326245,
-0.4652062058,
-0.5314666629,
-1.0087749958,
-0.0226294026,
0.1692943871,
-0.3750426173,
-0.7271111608,
-0.329924494,
-0.5320903659,
-0.0358389616,
0.4901200831,
-0.5302193761,
0.4885696173,
-0.3712690771,
0.5309027433,
1.1260403395,
-0.1276769936,
0.6457148194,
-0.1271107495,
0.3327860236,
-0.1283467412,
0.2891585231,
0.2552551031,
-0.3676076829,
-0.3397045732,
-0.5699252486,
0.5602679849,
0.1483788043,
-0.3661438525,
0.4849290848,
-0.2898715734,
-0.4558328986,
-0.3141918778,
0.1201283485,
0.3414137959,
0.5643976927,
0.3206188679,
-0.0219723321,
-0.3254108131,
-0.7390692234,
-0.3059012294,
0.0182410683,
-0.101479359,
0.29047665,
0.0162984021,
0.0178148877,
0.7992896438,
-1.0332444906,
-0.5416001081,
0.0175907575,
0.2029426694,
0.2488516718,
0.603974402,
0.4764278829,
-0.7023645639,
-0.7504166365,
-0.3617069423,
-0.3336128592,
-0.370480597,
0.214990288,
-0.2968433499,
0.2251345366,
0.0681313053,
-0.449143976,
0.3839166462,
1.0764364004,
-0.313881129,
0.3011361063,
-0.5148208141,
0.0447814129,
-1.2504501343,
-0.1798293144,
-0.2507579327,
-0.4365281165,
-0.2524803877,
-0.153439343,
0.0612580515,
-0.2425293326,
-0.5015672445,
0.3701732457,
-0.687374711,
0.1384590119,
-0.4109883308,
-0.0808204859,
0.2794127166,
0.3566391766,
0.120572567,
0.5556154251,
0.5078742504,
-0.682807982,
0.3840172887,
0.139282003,
-0.1411187351,
0.0436606966,
-0.4587265849,
0.4082586169,
-0.0200149231,
0.2342516482,
-0.7549549341,
-0.1160969064,
0.1725850403,
-0.165965721,
0.6349137425,
-0.4632930458,
-0.6189551353,
-0.1668535471,
-0.3858936727,
0.1817793995,
0.9728265405,
-0.9149345756,
0.4206956625,
0.5806390047,
-0.0920267403,
-0.7273123264,
-0.980914712,
0.0679427609,
-0.3285876811,
-0.4710099101,
0.7833385468,
0.0190771874,
-0.2512147129,
0.1113760099,
-0.3205592036,
-0.3775839508,
0.0151102562,
0.3107492626,
0.3096466959,
0.3325137496,
-0.0903720334,
0.6645519733,
-0.2243595123,
0.1569815427,
-0.5235254765,
0.4608866274,
0.229023844,
-0.1015188769,
-0.4131444097,
0.2331198901,
0.259047538,
0.2799199522,
0.9999992847,
0.0253295898,
-0.0709063113,
-0.7424640656,
-0.3321377337,
-0.3417322934,
-0.6423154473,
-0.0252957847,
-0.0652111396,
-0.6906712651,
0.0464773737,
-0.5508275032,
0.088907674,
0.0048572049,
0.4335695505,
0.3282746077,
0.773665309,
0.6301183105,
-0.1778062284,
0.1774823219,
-0.5359506011,
0.2781328857,
-0.325650394,
-0.2235009372,
-0.4570854008,
-0.6010580063,
-0.7710245252,
-0.4424562752,
0.4746223092,
0.076336965,
0.0757452846,
0.2286036313,
-1.1230179071,
0.8078563809,
0.6210246682,
0.1762101203,
0.8100433946,
0.1661263257,
0.0828521624,
-0.1896229535,
-0.4479128122,
-0.5280822515,
1.2318435907,
0.2692780197,
0.9385582805,
0.2506616712,
1.3795431852,
0.1966843754,
0.075347282,
-0.27346012,
0.7180992961,
-0.6181100011,
-0.529800117,
-0.1984877735,
-0.519777298,
-0.5960408449,
0.0936281681,
0.0650416613,
-0.5782917738,
0.242404744,
0.3284983635,
-0.2169158757,
0.2508674264,
-0.8756340146,
0.2900656462,
-0.1611507237,
-0.746774137,
-0.1788245291,
-0.5495586395,
0.5746694803,
-0.3852258623,
0.1688509583,
-0.1492959857,
0.0582175851,
0.5122513175,
-0.6667224765,
0.8870609403,
-0.5669233203,
-0.2083912492,
-0.036867395,
0.1980404258,
0.5578426123,
0.502918601,
-0.0103877289,
0.4871189296,
0.0601605885,
-0.0924107879,
-0.8278213739,
1.0333049297,
-0.637889564,
-0.8914583921,
-0.5722593665,
-0.3975703716,
-0.1303502768,
-0.0485515669,
0.1117996573,
0.1285018474,
0.2948062122,
0.1143079326,
0.6264446974,
-0.29867962,
0.341388166,
0.7552928925,
-0.070982784,
-0.1455066502,
0.8080968261,
0.2753603458,
0.2088855803,
0.2798760235,
0.5531621575,
-0.7694271207,
-0.5655619502,
-0.2100054324,
0.1622119546,
-0.5022252798,
-0.2997301221,
-0.6029928327,
-0.5086764693,
-0.4780387878,
-0.0354851335,
-0.6663951278,
-0.8607361317,
-0.3662525117,
-0.1332843304,
0.5731469393,
0.5276899338,
-0.6229081154,
-0.0679984465,
-0.8693255782,
0.5584945679,
0.4837578535,
0.2203133553,
-0.213964656,
-0.3907012343,
0.1601122022,
0.1986978948,
-0.5017074943,
-0.708073318,
0.5713598728,
0.3300639391,
0.2348246127,
0.1044355184,
0.8423143029,
0.509447813,
-0.6024178863,
0.7629269361,
0.1458408087,
-0.9049469829,
0.3548029959,
0.0739571825,
-0.1079397798,
0.5090619922,
0.5451714993,
0.074231863,
-0.7962934971,
-0.5608187914,
-0.9263316393,
0.581213057,
0.2344670743,
0.5615633726,
0.4257539511,
0.3498979509,
0.5119901299,
0.3971886933,
-0.7242177725,
-0.5080861449,
-0.0886090025,
-0.510489881,
0.0847388729,
-0.2680069804,
-0.3927134275,
-0.3646917939,
0.564093411,
0.222871244,
0.0353113562,
0.1496311277,
0.2797740102,
0.5145312548,
0.3040828705,
0.1556708515,
0.251287818,
-0.060205441,
0.5513735414,
-0.1872508526,
-0.7318003178,
0.6855111718,
0.6268099546,
-0.1276897788,
0.0486436225,
-0.3401252627,
0.208373338,
-0.1829165369,
-0.3039573729,
0.4537742138,
-0.3213202357,
-0.4756961465,
-0.3517066538,
0.3617422283,
-0.0450151637,
0.472735554,
0.23108913,
-0.1649275273,
0.3584827185,
-0.1818535626,
0.0396363176,
0.0386105254,
0.1410123706,
-0.2684676051,
0.9311308861,
0.3080253601,
-0.0977438539,
0.2978458703,
-0.0575940125,
-0.2367743403,
0.0741038471,
0.2690106928,
0.9157396555,
-0.1932625771,
0.2040437311,
-0.0038690839,
-0.2048285753,
-0.2079235166,
0.0749657899,
-0.557962954,
-0.3237686753,
-0.2963213623,
-0.7091380358,
-0.2802192271,
0.4665887058,
-0.3342874348,
0.2480427772,
-0.6599644423,
-0.1759658158,
-0.04543861,
0.101615496,
-0.3735978007,
-0.0569007173,
0.2040924877,
0.360232383,
-0.4816876054,
0.9862638116,
0.1205299646,
0.012140722,
-0.9800050259,
0.2126665711,
0.0345905907,
-0.5901293755,
0.9917274714,
-0.0399968177,
-0.1842117757,
0.1078884825,
-0.3801059723,
-0.5721697807,
0.9911984801,
0.844207108,
-1.2367866039,
-0.0275106635,
0.6611189246,
0.607773304,
0.2168234736,
-0.489916414,
0.2084071338,
0.2757305205,
0.0190815832,
-0.748411119,
0.2645808458,
0.0302839,
-0.1234057099,
0.0774680153,
-0.5465583801,
0.6929821372,
0.0668135285,
-0.2298603207,
-0.1833134592,
0.2956676185,
0.4378451407,
0.4522207975,
0.324734807,
0.5017049909,
0.8131816387,
0.1235505193,
0.7348594666,
-0.6919865608,
0.3146719635,
1.2537039518,
-0.302464813,
0.3460158706,
0.7281590104,
-0.2252498269,
0.3504190743,
0.1750772446,
0.1692634523,
0.9827647209,
0.5412722826,
-0.6245968938,
0.2381583154,
-0.0140329134,
-0.6394839287,
0.2427684814,
-0.1441440135,
-0.673774302,
-0.1051626727,
-0.149022907,
-0.0348330848,
0.43699646,
0.1145339832,
0.7106202245,
0.2868930399,
-0.3895373642,
0.7950599194,
0.0618489683,
0.6779370904,
-0.4728737175,
-0.0176914502,
-0.1768879294,
0.4344856441,
-0.1890096962,
-0.6643694639,
0.525515914,
0.2592190206,
-0.0910892636,
-0.6405792236,
0.6006476283,
-0.5555345416,
-0.2769209743,
0.1854676902,
0.2032165527,
0.1684659719,
-0.0446803272,
-0.5053436756,
-0.0946285352,
-0.0652083084,
-0.2832425833,
0.5202496648,
0.5917620659,
0.4391746223,
0.2753000259,
0.617546916,
0.3379857838,
0.1913750619,
0.0762999505,
1.3349529505,
-0.2432799041,
-0.6393805742,
-1.1626906395,
0.4764476717,
-0.3581585884,
0.0446899012,
0.7968963385,
0.5324819088,
0.7612514496,
-0.0613455549,
0.7821770906,
0.1331378371,
0.6018434167,
-0.6726860404,
1.0499260426,
-0.4610645175,
0.6221705079,
-0.2213472873,
-0.8332598209,
-0.0803269744,
0.3377204537,
-0.2721450925,
-0.3981600106,
0.4764594138,
0.7298672199,
-0.1073879227,
-0.0703107715,
0.2546516359,
0.1080038995,
0.439137131,
0.4483788311,
0.9468389153,
-0.3187121153,
0.3924660981,
-0.837736845,
-0.2769750059,
0.3000250161,
-0.9590570331,
-0.8910562992,
-0.6215940118,
-0.5429283381,
-0.2789630294,
0.1748799831,
0.5858048201,
0.8280797005,
-0.2623831332,
0.0975502506,
-0.5679080486,
0.0262603424,
0.1712888628,
-0.2285274267,
0.304746747,
0.0566715449,
-1.1409758329,
0.3641632497,
0.0822176486,
0.5465292335,
-0.6605151892,
-0.0483221896,
0.3723335266,
-0.0626247525,
0.2296089828,
-0.0473219566,
-0.1181267053,
0.1765033454,
-0.2916098833,
0.0088963211,
-0.291816622,
0.7677189112,
-0.8089488745,
0.2751104534,
0.4732813537,
0.5040314198,
0.7069827914,
0.0050219889,
0.6434779167,
-1.1793165207,
0.6533349156,
0.4857631326,
-0.0624472238,
0.1646993309,
-0.8300839663,
0.2826978564,
0.2681155205,
-0.7197018266,
-1.1746815443,
0.0528694689,
-0.6530601978,
-0.5540451407,
1.0632151365,
-0.456934005,
-0.3441295922,
-0.0407901667,
-0.2211020142,
0.2813924849,
-0.6220478415,
1.4524228573,
0.2881798148,
0.1146467626,
0.1322452724,
-0.1345641017,
0.6876326203,
0.0504473448,
-0.5521964431,
0.3119179606,
0.5002454519,
0.2132264078,
-0.1250110865,
0.5275277495,
-0.2802064419,
-0.3261353374,
0.0207442958,
-0.3620910048,
-0.6664982438,
-0.3481873274,
-0.2760009766,
0.3334140182,
-0.1084872037,
-0.5468814373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00923v1
|
An Interpretable Ensemble of Graph and Language Models for Improving Search Relevance in E-Commerce
| 2024-03-01T19:08:25 | 2024-03-01T19:08:25 |
Nurendra Choudhary, Edward W Huang, Karthik Subbian, Chandan K. Reddy
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7; J.7
|
The problem of search relevance in the E-commerce domain is a challenging one
since it involves understanding the intent of a user's short nuanced query and
matching it with the appropriate products in the catalog. This problem has
traditionally been addressed using language models (LMs) and graph neural
networks (GNNs) to capture semantic and inter-product behavior signals,
respectively. However, the rapid development of new architectures has created a
gap between research and the practical adoption of these techniques. Evaluating
the generalizability of these models for deployment requires extensive
experimentation on complex, real-world datasets, which can be non-trivial and
expensive. Furthermore, such models often operate on latent space
representations that are incomprehensible to humans, making it difficult to
evaluate and compare the effectiveness of different models. This lack of
interpretability hinders the development and adoption of new techniques in the
field. To bridge this gap, we propose Plug and Play Graph LAnguage Model
(PP-GLAM), an explainable ensemble of plug and play models. Our approach uses a
modular framework with uniform data processing pipelines. It employs additive
explanation metrics to independently decide whether to include (i) language
model candidates, (ii) GNN model candidates, and (iii) inter-product behavioral
signals. For the task of search relevance, we show that PP-GLAM outperforms
several state-of-the-art baselines as well as a proprietary model on real-world
multilingual, multi-regional e-commerce datasets. To promote better model
comprehensibility and adoption, we also provide an analysis of the
explainability and computational complexity of our model. We also provide the
public codebase and provide a deployment strategy for practical implementation.
|
[
-0.2372529954,
-0.784612298,
0.609344542,
0.2210946083,
-0.3052249849,
0.1589119285,
-0.2332826257,
-0.6077225804,
0.2244226933,
0.2823349535,
-0.4311989844,
-0.6478850245,
-0.364530772,
-0.1554592997,
-0.5752355456,
0.85731107,
0.1024605632,
-0.3697511256,
-0.2828475535,
-0.1122873053,
-0.1821433008,
-0.4942787588,
-0.4845119119,
-0.2166003585,
0.5611009598,
0.0035299635,
0.8623980284,
0.3330572248,
0.2782613933,
0.2781731188,
-0.2270250767,
0.2968817651,
-0.7366441488,
-0.0481955037,
-0.0869263783,
-0.3535128832,
-0.559853375,
-0.21026057,
0.259419173,
0.8313460946,
-0.4089670777,
0.148616612,
0.211224854,
0.1890201867,
-0.519292295,
0.3831386864,
-0.6997831464,
-0.3384630382,
0.1282631308,
-0.2071539611,
-0.6812042594,
-0.3679093122,
0.2437248677,
-1.0063170195,
0.3542171121,
0.3241448402,
0.9167148471,
-0.3556987941,
-0.4665252864,
-0.419811815,
-0.8463941216,
0.669002831,
-0.7014836669,
0.4337585568,
0.3086616397,
0.3691960871,
-0.3519389033,
-1.0693141222,
-0.3971925974,
0.0249415375,
-0.5201807022,
0.1752415299,
-0.3345272541,
0.014011601,
-0.0333142467,
0.3584164381,
-0.9408336282,
0.0725923926,
-0.2221623808,
-0.2142567933,
0.4987645149,
0.1297564656,
0.6424057484,
0.1457901746,
-0.0436294004,
0.1964103281,
-0.5396201015,
0.1224994436,
0.5520417094,
0.5630341768,
-0.0652764291,
0.3275398314,
-0.2876821756,
0.9398790002,
-0.0167579241,
0.0851328745,
0.076919809,
-0.4326805174,
-0.1019741744,
-0.1171303093,
0.530312717,
0.3409256339,
0.0052942662,
-0.4610295892,
-0.0544311069,
0.0831823573,
0.4983153045,
-0.6872938275,
-0.2467082143,
0.3471761346,
-0.694317162,
-0.258547008,
-0.0234434884,
-0.7740226984,
0.0052224658,
-0.3147747219,
0.4201104939,
-0.0947403982,
-0.4013658166,
0.3225288391,
-0.0488125794,
0.0537058972,
0.3013373315,
-0.9514517188,
0.5907759666,
0.9506341219,
0.9797716141,
-0.0304424278,
-0.1236698106,
-0.3097002208,
0.0724168345,
-0.2632012069,
0.6439118981,
-0.6933861971,
-0.2001078129,
0.1523749977,
0.2455260009,
-0.3757308424,
-0.4102620482,
0.5109941959,
-1.2085829973,
0.3448083103,
0.0946517289,
-0.7000368237,
-0.6235306859,
0.2216028422,
-0.7881837487,
0.6553487182,
0.2157601714,
-0.554410398,
0.4291770458,
-0.4996501505,
-0.5224767923,
0.3036298752,
-0.0948248357,
-0.5982673168,
0.2218053192,
0.2628447413,
0.2464260906,
-0.2673779726,
0.2172474116,
-0.5803545713,
-0.8034920692,
-0.0235399883,
-0.0904103294,
0.7343431115,
0.2250836492,
-0.2422809154,
0.0284557343,
-0.4960190654,
0.1716287583,
0.3126683831,
-0.3320294321,
-0.2687705457,
0.2440466434,
0.1529450715,
0.2268190682,
0.2708020806,
-0.1033224985,
0.2425686419,
-0.4923408926,
0.6117705703,
0.5794475079,
-0.1472826749,
0.4749403596,
-0.0534080975,
0.8200143576,
-0.2400226742,
0.3512411714,
-0.2504567802,
-0.9350113273,
-0.3548658192,
-0.0635293499,
0.3623975217,
0.4283618927,
-0.5596548319,
0.3075045049,
-0.446942389,
-0.430629164,
-0.3703336716,
0.1164008006,
0.0619274862,
0.6375228763,
0.2620769441,
-0.4448599517,
-0.2026910782,
-0.742092371,
-0.2732901871,
-0.2722764909,
-0.2092950493,
0.8441019654,
0.1519146711,
-0.2853951752,
0.8861336708,
-0.6128787398,
-0.0484046973,
-0.2636449337,
0.1215024218,
0.7443614602,
-0.0348572247,
0.5097880363,
-1.1017495394,
-0.5129693151,
0.3574011624,
-0.5581115484,
-0.1122840121,
0.2550718188,
-0.0126252715,
-0.0465942211,
0.2057769597,
-0.3631909788,
0.4773016274,
0.5246992707,
-0.2385382801,
0.5276179314,
-0.4494371414,
0.162359044,
-0.7238036394,
0.35060063,
0.0636315495,
-0.2327492684,
-0.7944198847,
0.2165700793,
0.0241350457,
-0.3223277032,
-0.4352886379,
0.5270297527,
-0.1791097671,
-0.4271246791,
-0.1006506532,
0.4793688953,
0.5740252733,
0.4865720272,
-0.2442069054,
0.8035445213,
0.4925787151,
-0.9888209105,
0.1728690714,
0.2122505605,
-0.5301243067,
0.2233529985,
-0.8391606808,
0.0807317123,
-0.0385968685,
0.2512152195,
-1.1538034678,
-0.1766808778,
0.1897320896,
-0.2773401141,
0.1254331917,
-0.5831552744,
-0.6152803302,
-0.4814503193,
0.1767425537,
0.6839159131,
0.5078671575,
-0.6706041098,
0.7190095782,
0.3094890714,
-0.2135925442,
-0.3846571445,
-0.3124325573,
0.0535141416,
-0.4865590036,
-0.8750233054,
0.5835071802,
-0.0275262222,
0.0830857158,
-0.0069913208,
0.1739715636,
-0.0091060111,
0.4337966144,
-0.3044529855,
0.3757172823,
-0.2499319464,
0.3808369935,
-0.1594401002,
-0.1745894402,
-0.1739995182,
-0.7557576299,
0.6877301335,
-0.12902008,
-0.5125386715,
-0.041157268,
0.167061612,
0.3362732828,
-0.3023946285,
0.5797814727,
0.6052908897,
-0.2790548801,
-0.1169198453,
-0.1955458671,
-0.1070954725,
-0.5140909553,
0.3641521633,
-0.1994942725,
-0.7859869599,
0.7908015847,
-0.3575469255,
-0.2549217045,
0.2423048764,
0.5032938719,
0.0391344577,
1.5887298584,
0.6517586708,
0.0858377218,
0.3560224473,
-0.0849157348,
0.8426554799,
-0.7763744593,
-0.2607970834,
-0.457061857,
-0.3680973649,
-0.8543367386,
-0.2835904658,
0.2150814682,
0.2126628757,
-0.1014516428,
0.3876210749,
-0.6871396303,
0.4303575158,
0.4443280995,
0.1964520067,
0.2867054343,
0.3697525561,
-0.2090323418,
0.119083479,
-0.8290290236,
-0.4039896727,
1.1262216568,
0.1042833775,
0.7284123302,
0.4206780493,
0.2670356631,
0.1775175333,
0.0276947636,
-0.8178299665,
0.276887089,
-0.4541077614,
-0.5398817658,
-0.0472607315,
-0.4168893397,
-1.2394556999,
0.3592332602,
0.12915802,
-1.260748744,
0.3434844911,
0.2283975631,
-0.3271009028,
0.0848993063,
-0.6841343045,
1.0024286509,
-0.5157932043,
-0.5212265253,
-0.2040512115,
-0.3625298738,
0.2246241421,
0.0018271654,
0.5350072384,
0.1049947143,
0.0039545735,
0.355160892,
-0.1550501436,
0.5258007646,
0.1662406474,
-0.0902332366,
0.2627572119,
0.1723515689,
0.808331728,
-0.2197456658,
-0.1085326821,
0.1396868229,
-0.3927865326,
-0.4333359301,
-0.9622526169,
0.6319480538,
-0.4820830226,
-0.4526305795,
0.151019901,
-0.2989888489,
-0.1793331504,
0.313149482,
0.2395496368,
0.4957231581,
-0.1912167966,
-0.0184590742,
0.5576292276,
-0.362154901,
0.1849313378,
0.3097132146,
-0.8474625349,
-0.1523384005,
1.2445987463,
0.1157229766,
0.1893299967,
0.2357454598,
0.3021663129,
-0.5633069873,
-0.4853293002,
-0.3392564952,
0.0654602572,
-0.8264747262,
0.2387233973,
-0.6893906593,
0.0489597581,
-0.3479036391,
-0.1581230015,
0.2157011926,
-0.340775311,
-0.3050300479,
-0.0094169574,
0.2441756725,
0.7902263999,
0.1649057269,
0.3804188073,
-0.5183884501,
0.2204979956,
0.4413641095,
0.6863552928,
0.2998290062,
-0.4413105547,
-0.6116680503,
0.0575385168,
-0.1029964611,
-0.7391281128,
0.4515504837,
0.258220613,
0.7015061378,
0.4648502171,
-0.2815673649,
0.6503413916,
-0.3791491091,
0.6541680694,
0.0084790913,
-0.8532603979,
0.5198170543,
-0.6394024491,
-0.0487096272,
0.202088818,
0.4876108468,
-0.5419277549,
-0.0987702608,
-0.7534915805,
-1.3623765707,
0.7602552176,
0.2809310555,
0.0903539807,
0.0830677077,
0.3396908045,
-0.0070437766,
0.4845322073,
-0.4817618132,
-0.1338643432,
-0.1804713458,
-0.1478156745,
-0.1183636189,
-0.0377881266,
0.0306878779,
-0.1571966708,
0.7471274734,
-0.4549830854,
0.3030411601,
-0.2488157302,
-0.3024006486,
0.185091868,
0.132584855,
0.4751959145,
0.8927214742,
-0.1678359061,
-0.0565689653,
-0.1562265307,
-0.3200426102,
0.0011088102,
0.1247762516,
-0.3485756516,
0.0328935757,
0.1300534904,
0.7727631927,
0.3853197992,
-0.529463172,
0.4715493619,
-0.2905454636,
0.2714139223,
-0.0103431214,
-0.0768204257,
0.2981168032,
0.0898664966,
0.1472852379,
-0.2454351932,
0.607981503,
-0.6063696146,
0.2700457275,
0.3658605516,
-0.3195958138,
-0.4009867013,
0.7040768862,
-0.0653961301,
-0.4474821687,
0.8763823509,
-0.4604344964,
-0.669408083,
0.810354054,
0.7132143974,
0.7739608884,
-0.0080435416,
0.4703143239,
0.2429533601,
0.2113546133,
-0.013563484,
0.1044495851,
0.1177092567,
-0.7623098493,
-0.4337362051,
-0.5179550052,
-0.3719055057,
0.0776178315,
-0.6650160551,
0.4220359325,
-0.1655329466,
-0.2607599795,
-0.0215892345,
-0.2263534367,
-0.9236278534,
0.1108284071,
0.0030759892,
0.4459438622,
-0.7806480527,
0.4685354829,
0.6158325076,
-0.4586352408,
-0.7901323438,
-0.1426390111,
-0.1369416267,
-0.9343698621,
0.5133861899,
0.2869981527,
0.0668791533,
-0.0103111621,
-0.343641758,
-0.9303100109,
1.1865785122,
0.4083229303,
-0.5437067747,
0.0157415997,
0.0933524892,
0.7210123539,
-0.6772330999,
0.5974532366,
0.4916477799,
0.3373299539,
0.0207017343,
-0.8123217225,
-0.1431683749,
-0.3262848258,
0.0860722661,
0.1486672014,
-0.4968150854,
0.9144016504,
0.0821955055,
-0.3508029282,
-0.0848281458,
0.028349014,
0.2280923277,
0.5173780322,
0.4103253186,
0.5348217487,
1.0050274134,
-0.0111224269,
1.2112944126,
-0.5811920166,
0.8244726062,
1.1915961504,
-0.4436770082,
0.8103893399,
0.0521360338,
-0.2764249146,
0.7383058667,
0.7822098732,
-0.0148915714,
0.4293800294,
0.2611324489,
-0.1754600108,
-0.5145331621,
-0.2257395387,
-0.1643704027,
0.265563041,
0.5937618017,
-0.5184336305,
-0.3425462246,
-0.2686294913,
-0.2428299487,
-0.0842318162,
-0.28450647,
0.7137243152,
0.0548865721,
-0.3477333188,
0.3253367841,
-0.1887766719,
0.185237363,
-0.4911841452,
-0.133042708,
0.0882936269,
0.1244312227,
-0.3264915943,
-0.4772605896,
0.079740487,
-0.3227205276,
-0.1128108501,
0.0212342106,
0.9717546701,
-0.1916681528,
-0.7379224896,
0.8039448261,
0.600897491,
0.0878207684,
-0.017261209,
-0.7602473497,
0.0240320619,
-0.2439456582,
-0.0731140375,
0.3790512979,
0.2199290693,
-0.0002258343,
0.7289271951,
0.6916400194,
-0.0110307857,
0.0354699753,
0.1955284476,
0.8157070279,
-0.2208259255,
-0.8321569562,
-0.6147480011,
0.5398293138,
-0.163224414,
0.1196459681,
0.6664656401,
0.6445521116,
0.6709030271,
0.2240020186,
0.8323218822,
0.1928466856,
0.1728355736,
-0.4006038308,
0.727222085,
-0.7566910386,
0.4620399475,
-0.324391067,
-1.0329787731,
-0.2529973686,
0.6524236798,
-0.3783283234,
0.2793406546,
0.4047813416,
0.7182680964,
-0.5864624381,
0.1632996351,
0.3454270065,
0.288294524,
0.4776477814,
0.3708799779,
0.6124233603,
-0.4862694442,
0.6887968183,
-0.0546925291,
-0.2463281751,
-0.5636268854,
-0.9948066473,
-0.4379531443,
-0.3418965638,
-0.3242683411,
-0.4143897891,
-0.0157708488,
0.5884287953,
0.7246266007,
-0.7027103901,
-0.357942611,
-0.1443480998,
0.354480654,
-0.4692489207,
-0.2209207565,
0.4516548812,
-0.3802244961,
-0.5306452513,
0.3458844423,
0.4554731548,
-0.1023258939,
-0.221843645,
-0.046358604,
-0.1233985573,
0.178456977,
0.6898261309,
0.1382245272,
-0.6751313806,
-0.3455489874,
0.308845818,
0.381578356,
0.1659067869,
0.7840929031,
-0.8267390728,
0.8001487255,
0.5212166905,
0.4497075081,
0.4976541102,
-0.0506701581,
0.7105072737,
-0.5764902234,
-0.1237489283,
0.1245379746,
0.5704277754,
0.1915598065,
-0.3958771527,
0.5894291997,
0.051426474,
-0.634357214,
-0.6283475757,
0.5565550327,
-0.6256640553,
-0.2347851992,
0.9705166221,
-0.436101526,
-0.2775476873,
-0.5281834006,
0.1151027009,
0.1003811359,
-0.270560354,
0.8911693096,
0.693220973,
-0.0372352637,
0.0737568662,
-0.4534525573,
0.0118156401,
0.0164782964,
-0.4887031913,
0.0106634246,
0.2512320876,
0.1045836806,
0.4270942807,
0.4328481853,
0.0773331001,
0.3837065697,
-0.1626127362,
-0.3077180982,
0.1026147902,
-0.2731294036,
-0.4973607659,
0.2436118871,
0.1719729304,
0.2237666249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00758v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00758v3
|
Mitigating Reversal Curse in Large Language Models via Semantic-aware Permutation Training
| 2024-03-01T18:55:20 | 2024-03-20T07:37:24 |
Qingyan Guo, Rui Wang, Junliang Guo, Xu Tan, Jiang Bian, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance
across diverse tasks, recent studies showcase that causal LLMs suffer from the
"reversal curse". It is a typical example that the model knows "A's father is
B", but is unable to reason "B's child is A". This limitation poses a challenge
to the advancement of artificial general intelligence (AGI), as it suggests a
gap in the models' ability to comprehend and apply bidirectional reasoning. In
this paper, we first conduct substantial evaluation and identify that the root
cause of the reversal curse lies in the different word order between the
training and inference stage, namely, the poor ability of causal language
models to predict antecedent words within the training data. Accordingly,
permutation on the training data is considered as a potential solution, since
this can make the model predict antecedent words or tokens. However, previous
permutation methods may disrupt complete phrases or entities, thereby posing
challenges for the model to comprehend and learn from training data. To address
this issue, we propose Semantic-aware Permutation Training (SPT), which
addresses this issue by segmenting the training sentences into semantic units
(i.e., entities or phrases) with an assistant language model and permuting
these units before feeding into the model. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that SPT effectively mitigates the reversal curse since the performance on
reversed questions approximates that on the forward ones, and significantly
advances the performance of existing works.
|
[
-0.1144254804,
-0.8204057217,
0.4860967696,
0.2887017727,
-0.478351742,
0.1308491528,
-0.0724227354,
-0.3771909475,
0.2463555783,
0.8692973256,
-0.7226680517,
-0.1534888893,
-0.9185208082,
0.3061218262,
-0.6625980139,
1.017742753,
0.1437993199,
0.3796930015,
-0.2916049063,
-0.0338965841,
-0.7376340032,
-0.3962387443,
-0.8303520083,
-0.4919062555,
0.3999300003,
0.4517828822,
0.7011401653,
0.4919684827,
0.3056306839,
0.3268129826,
0.0736424103,
0.1199055985,
-0.7653805017,
0.2078837305,
-0.3340114355,
-0.6300641894,
-0.2070943862,
-0.10290014,
0.7355548739,
0.9397333264,
0.0762517825,
-0.0215764232,
-0.1352975816,
0.4046872258,
-0.6398726106,
-0.0746852905,
-1.34136343,
0.0508267321,
-0.1353404969,
-0.3662326634,
-0.3660133779,
-0.0585902333,
0.1117139459,
-0.5251354575,
0.3312393725,
-0.0964217633,
0.8782798052,
0.4590535462,
-0.4344347715,
-0.1711342186,
-0.7706807852,
0.7436289787,
-0.5962021947,
0.4811670482,
0.4433913827,
0.072687,
-0.4586482048,
-0.3958781362,
-0.9457525611,
0.0046882285,
-0.0218443125,
0.2948221266,
-0.0181022249,
-0.1253691763,
0.1457372755,
0.0450148769,
-0.5662999749,
0.3756467104,
-0.101656124,
-0.1475775838,
0.4594901502,
0.2152853161,
0.4492454231,
0.0463678837,
-0.6547349691,
0.0356813632,
-1.1148651838,
-0.3038270175,
0.6471784115,
0.3322173655,
0.4164676666,
0.5376117826,
0.0110700419,
0.5868167281,
0.0704149902,
-0.0825866684,
0.2223123014,
-0.2119887471,
-0.1713722348,
0.3485936224,
0.2925804257,
0.0281373654,
0.2425077409,
-0.3943379819,
-0.252259165,
0.3257982731,
0.4031560719,
-0.6796385646,
-0.0059839291,
0.0569139011,
0.0645619631,
-0.160723865,
-0.0029195568,
-0.3892576098,
-0.6777374744,
-0.3810404539,
0.6632726789,
-0.5330341458,
-0.2503209114,
0.2377666682,
-0.0401335098,
0.4291104674,
0.3341574073,
-0.7140058875,
0.1242450401,
0.9220740199,
0.1967713237,
-0.0934739858,
-0.6702845693,
-0.575316906,
0.2950857878,
-0.113580741,
0.718947351,
-0.7209656239,
-0.4588866532,
-0.3055841029,
-0.0684033185,
-0.4331694543,
-0.4750252962,
0.3528932333,
-0.6114709973,
0.1993579268,
0.0025863808,
-0.5124247074,
-0.276465565,
0.1889700294,
-0.3104583323,
0.4423035085,
-0.2968710363,
-0.9194641113,
0.3322707117,
0.0443338007,
-0.6936381459,
-0.1287726611,
-0.3303923905,
-0.8061848283,
0.2643460631,
0.2538269162,
0.1663313061,
-0.3980046511,
0.3385123909,
-0.1713279337,
-0.3525848687,
0.1247930154,
-0.7402642965,
0.8304106593,
-0.0244268309,
-0.4353683591,
0.1880348474,
-0.8197247982,
-0.4184521139,
0.2917798162,
-0.012636113,
-0.6330407858,
0.1013218313,
-0.5567458272,
0.1899634004,
0.1106902286,
-0.4891664088,
0.0516348183,
-0.6284093261,
0.075868994,
1.0058399439,
-0.107250683,
0.3856875598,
0.1486056745,
0.4639044404,
0.3016524911,
0.1841976941,
0.0758432671,
-0.5174931884,
-0.910505414,
-0.1612655073,
0.0597306304,
0.7950556278,
-1.0267343521,
0.4455435872,
-0.3992079794,
-0.1273536831,
-0.6164619923,
0.15973562,
0.6974252462,
0.7014161348,
0.4210908115,
-0.4769009948,
-0.5062223077,
-0.82901752,
-0.46034199,
-0.184401229,
0.248687014,
0.1539335549,
0.5623067617,
-0.2242663354,
1.0060979128,
-0.5438044071,
-0.0767485723,
-0.2794662714,
0.2336474508,
0.0195575841,
0.4861073792,
0.054136049,
-1.1326766014,
0.0433009155,
-0.2997677624,
-0.4533210695,
-0.1969717294,
-0.2153266221,
-0.2730855644,
0.2295469791,
0.54371804,
-0.5992945433,
0.6648180485,
0.3246507347,
-0.8679141402,
0.8621572256,
-0.1730794311,
-0.2050296366,
-0.8859468102,
-0.0721278712,
-0.642344892,
-0.0134033319,
-0.6525537372,
0.0478825755,
-0.2551848888,
0.1085210964,
-0.1010001227,
0.5783236623,
-0.4229813218,
-0.177634716,
-0.2885559201,
0.0295197479,
-0.1873367876,
0.1566567719,
0.0257811025,
0.561329782,
0.4214575887,
-0.6986705065,
0.0279831309,
0.3680038452,
-0.0115169846,
0.5380871892,
-0.2423093319,
0.2032775879,
-0.2473294288,
0.1955190152,
-1.10663867,
0.1444858313,
0.1690517664,
-0.6348383427,
0.5574590564,
0.0705287084,
-0.3943286836,
-0.4364318848,
-0.0868504196,
0.4343700707,
0.1341575235,
-0.63109231,
0.8247357011,
0.1395854652,
0.0227841102,
-0.9266378284,
-0.6390588284,
0.2557473183,
-0.1744220406,
-0.6382358074,
0.2758835256,
0.1633896828,
-0.0411126576,
-0.0005704698,
-0.4493440092,
0.110161297,
0.398380816,
0.1540372223,
0.2120286226,
0.0037091132,
0.2026582509,
0.0607305132,
-0.4448911548,
-0.0753499791,
-0.5843875408,
0.7609882951,
0.1041845456,
-0.4223864079,
0.0370491482,
0.0999371111,
0.3874155581,
-0.4063406587,
0.9191333055,
0.5208924413,
-0.2630689144,
-0.1572173685,
-0.7774659991,
-0.3301714957,
-0.3986191154,
0.4857016802,
-0.5005930066,
-0.8048919439,
0.7069259882,
0.0487826988,
-0.2279160917,
0.2859683335,
0.4888752997,
0.3672798574,
1.0933096409,
0.4624532759,
-0.2351229191,
0.4346913993,
-0.1822365373,
0.5474643111,
-0.6533794999,
0.0858476236,
-0.456042558,
-0.1372144371,
-0.4880258739,
-0.3941015601,
0.3413920999,
0.296952039,
-0.3376327455,
0.2895048559,
-0.2617528141,
0.4998973012,
0.5184331536,
0.205269143,
0.6060063839,
-0.043807812,
-0.1841411293,
0.5127373934,
-0.5838729143,
-0.3562669456,
0.8520419002,
0.0054880851,
0.6087350845,
-0.0299446862,
0.9039529562,
-0.342682153,
0.1902276725,
-0.547006309,
0.8990697861,
-0.4988502562,
-0.5765157342,
-0.4597344995,
-0.6749324799,
-1.255063653,
0.4743636549,
-0.1883478016,
-0.718339026,
0.1102917343,
-0.0211281907,
-0.1977838427,
0.4071594477,
-0.8901687264,
0.7977278233,
-0.2709757686,
-0.3665048778,
-0.533059895,
-0.8413496017,
0.3958449066,
0.0033726306,
0.0632916987,
0.0517194793,
0.1869502813,
0.445489347,
-0.7131697536,
0.874147296,
-0.2349314243,
-0.1721082628,
0.0890453756,
0.2171737999,
0.6688476801,
-0.0479679294,
0.2500236332,
-0.1703858078,
-0.3753800988,
-0.5103333592,
-0.6067929864,
0.7545871139,
-0.8005408645,
-1.0048743486,
-0.2618463337,
-0.5113733411,
-0.5510553718,
0.1944121569,
0.2625617683,
0.2659313083,
0.1282889843,
-0.3655154705,
0.6081058383,
-0.5799129009,
0.0555664934,
0.7279524207,
-0.2100239396,
-0.2329653949,
1.1625574827,
0.1654902101,
0.2893927395,
0.4208239615,
0.3928864896,
-0.0036499507,
-0.6321883202,
-0.3641639352,
0.3572023213,
-0.6198728085,
-0.1553653181,
-0.5870807171,
0.0129773226,
-0.4283355474,
-0.0945856646,
-0.2950499952,
-0.5942102671,
-0.2935828865,
-0.259765029,
0.1846221685,
0.3203266859,
0.3535871506,
0.1350765824,
-0.362116307,
0.3070093691,
0.4520032406,
0.3980859518,
0.3202527463,
-0.5968689919,
0.2951136827,
-0.1845956296,
-0.0589063913,
-0.6795476675,
0.2094249874,
-0.1168900952,
0.386007458,
0.5176475644,
-0.1836832911,
0.9166422486,
-0.6317572594,
0.5688000321,
0.3531450927,
-0.7466782928,
0.3632309437,
-0.151266709,
0.2253075838,
0.5100228786,
0.1226842925,
-0.4403475821,
-0.7807763815,
-0.6820465922,
-1.2224494219,
0.6552214026,
0.2241428047,
0.2216016352,
-0.1457108855,
0.22496894,
0.4140998423,
0.2128625363,
-0.4443983734,
-0.1737570018,
-0.2253501266,
-0.1190386489,
-0.202016592,
-0.1673385054,
0.1363896579,
-0.3458729982,
0.9915112257,
0.1384779513,
0.2503862083,
0.1258662641,
-0.5231032372,
0.062333703,
0.2146749943,
0.5531005263,
0.6369653344,
0.0504583456,
0.3576282263,
0.1661487371,
-0.6540229321,
-0.0747380555,
0.3416825235,
-0.42059654,
-0.3524292111,
0.4784722924,
0.9646777511,
0.1175545454,
-0.3920144439,
0.3863696158,
0.1056639776,
0.1571817398,
-0.3698126972,
-0.0597570799,
0.1208136529,
0.1437719911,
0.28630656,
-0.1290881187,
0.0219262,
-0.5870243907,
0.1508006006,
0.5317776799,
-0.1545482129,
-0.2909176052,
0.5126138926,
0.0573288202,
-0.1254556626,
0.8578671217,
-0.1540165395,
-0.9208375812,
0.6877645254,
0.8939713836,
1.0042948723,
-0.4274685979,
0.0365549736,
0.0530031361,
0.2295302451,
0.0070260856,
0.203252241,
0.1434755176,
-1.3081511259,
-0.3973860443,
-0.6905842423,
-0.0788903534,
-0.1112917885,
-0.3751287162,
0.1526885778,
-0.2931605279,
0.1186363623,
-0.090868108,
-0.2345679402,
-0.7642820477,
0.2230433375,
0.2188213617,
0.7091598511,
-0.7743278742,
0.8046576381,
0.6450119615,
-0.6446927786,
-0.8302769661,
0.1095705926,
-0.2171532065,
-1.1106973886,
0.7546470761,
0.1015635729,
-0.4749271274,
0.1656021327,
-0.701115787,
-0.4791767001,
0.9084966779,
0.3945210874,
-0.3812338114,
-0.0360808112,
0.2588391304,
0.4459887445,
-0.2249940038,
0.1923259646,
0.8048879504,
0.510135293,
0.2383730859,
-0.7485780716,
0.1072971225,
0.0558431968,
0.0183025301,
0.422085911,
-0.4366856813,
0.6434380412,
-0.2101919651,
-0.1871759593,
0.0760502368,
0.397577852,
0.1238859892,
0.3992421031,
0.8482276797,
0.8576850891,
0.6653297544,
-0.0602314249,
1.1302409172,
0.09226311,
0.1333487779,
1.3974577188,
-0.3722541332,
0.5502255559,
0.7205325365,
0.0772762969,
0.4454812706,
0.0494069159,
0.1694045216,
0.303730011,
0.3946686685,
-0.2393105179,
-0.4115327299,
0.073763065,
-0.0765552372,
0.6925708055,
0.4122891128,
-0.2788310647,
-0.361418277,
0.2956810594,
0.2530616224,
0.1442962885,
-0.5550314188,
0.8680149317,
0.0233075488,
-0.6179475188,
0.5820062757,
-0.1041370481,
0.6219634414,
-0.630764842,
0.0139935445,
-0.3786352575,
0.393596679,
-0.2035991699,
-0.4941152632,
0.3413228095,
-0.1561413109,
-0.0826853588,
-0.1388164312,
0.8908530474,
-0.5093284845,
-0.5023669004,
0.5059726238,
0.3588575125,
0.0086629726,
0.0031856133,
-0.5563308597,
-0.1993017644,
-0.138105318,
-0.2291731983,
0.3062318265,
0.4481057823,
-0.3976569176,
0.7460471988,
0.3423092663,
0.2357207686,
0.1326743513,
0.3453697264,
0.8504805565,
-0.6103234887,
-0.463431716,
-0.8579195142,
0.2791665196,
0.1303229034,
-0.226026997,
0.7694257498,
0.3907594383,
0.9446161985,
-0.1570852995,
0.457973361,
0.2324188352,
0.4911983013,
-0.5482146144,
0.5449519157,
-0.3511017561,
0.4623545408,
-0.4962012172,
-0.6548868418,
-0.5851562023,
0.4770168066,
-0.9182602763,
-0.1780780852,
0.4793096483,
0.8775400519,
0.1046757996,
0.25247401,
0.2379362434,
0.7472484112,
0.2617496252,
0.5417132974,
0.9582942724,
-0.1335366368,
0.5739163756,
0.0317607522,
-0.0469918847,
-0.1044854373,
-0.6889356375,
-0.5874617696,
-0.4976767302,
-0.1111611649,
-0.4275334775,
0.3953755498,
0.7569460273,
0.2134362012,
-0.8576952219,
-0.0781958178,
-0.5004993081,
0.6327539682,
-0.3534948528,
-0.2069630474,
0.4667849839,
-0.3859717846,
-0.3387423754,
0.1823782623,
0.3085415959,
-0.1358549148,
-0.1969080716,
0.1024334431,
-0.5536039472,
0.1295084804,
0.7147481441,
0.1114584357,
-0.6711545587,
-0.6000925303,
-0.3450689912,
0.1773543209,
-0.1884633899,
0.9056526423,
-0.9570689797,
0.5007930994,
0.5289493203,
0.9001297951,
0.3193387389,
0.0334518105,
0.5810637474,
-0.6460327506,
0.1534747183,
0.3364689052,
0.2101081014,
0.3144421279,
-0.4345602095,
0.4716655612,
0.4903624356,
-0.291959554,
-0.7737377286,
0.5800297856,
-0.6501789689,
-0.6539409757,
1.0276494026,
0.0707185641,
-0.0929816589,
-0.1740189046,
-0.1462900192,
0.5227714777,
-0.0283507686,
0.9158042669,
0.6425101161,
-0.0243103169,
0.185054183,
-0.1700244546,
0.1995694935,
0.9311050773,
-0.390984416,
0.2026769966,
0.3483497202,
0.2988053858,
0.1723173708,
0.3777825236,
-0.3393972218,
0.0482798629,
-0.1422337145,
0.0144061148,
-0.0062799607,
-0.4293994606,
-0.5039795637,
-0.2265103757,
0.0438667424,
-0.1193699762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00745v1
|
AtP*: An efficient and scalable method for localizing LLM behaviour to components
| 2024-03-01T18:43:51 | 2024-03-01T18:43:51 |
János Kramár, Tom Lieberum, Rohin Shah, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Activation Patching is a method of directly computing causal attributions of
behavior to model components. However, applying it exhaustively requires a
sweep with cost scaling linearly in the number of model components, which can
be prohibitively expensive for SoTA Large Language Models (LLMs). We
investigate Attribution Patching (AtP), a fast gradient-based approximation to
Activation Patching and find two classes of failure modes of AtP which lead to
significant false negatives. We propose a variant of AtP called AtP*, with two
changes to address these failure modes while retaining scalability. We present
the first systematic study of AtP and alternative methods for faster activation
patching and show that AtP significantly outperforms all other investigated
methods, with AtP* providing further significant improvement. Finally, we
provide a method to bound the probability of remaining false negatives of AtP*
estimates.
|
[
-0.0652099624,
-0.9554743171,
0.4621969759,
0.6434720755,
0.0992994234,
0.1848925054,
-0.1711275727,
-0.3701130748,
0.4657449424,
0.2974422872,
-0.4826904535,
-0.0527847968,
-0.4669685662,
-0.2037639767,
-0.3361715078,
0.3327082694,
-0.3513846993,
0.2136607915,
-0.1216069534,
-0.127983734,
-0.0963460207,
-0.4185955226,
-0.9275085926,
-0.8029106259,
0.6606669426,
0.4680707455,
0.3067226708,
0.8635627627,
0.6425886154,
0.2979313135,
-0.0579326302,
-0.2040863484,
-0.3229010403,
-0.0190255214,
0.0817141011,
-0.811003387,
-0.7066616416,
0.2202677876,
0.7958109379,
0.6463593245,
-0.0759477243,
0.164668411,
-0.4697193205,
0.7705465555,
-0.8176238537,
-0.0016230552,
-0.4971885681,
-0.023600433,
-0.4120212197,
-0.4422774315,
-0.559512198,
-0.5241808891,
-0.2606269419,
-0.3044893742,
-0.025495952,
0.0550116673,
0.5306614637,
0.1857117265,
-0.6868318319,
-0.1136349067,
-0.6163986921,
1.0830762386,
-0.5850328803,
0.1292048842,
0.4951983094,
0.5043723583,
-0.2634607553,
-0.4765715301,
-0.3246863186,
-0.2906766832,
0.0381683223,
-0.4839443266,
-0.1591972262,
0.0802867189,
0.2309579998,
0.6086725593,
-0.0396663621,
0.0695359185,
-0.1991655827,
-0.4492647648,
0.2624536753,
-0.1433497965,
0.5597373247,
-0.0455522425,
-0.6855977774,
-0.0317671336,
-1.1725401878,
0.064746283,
0.5934841633,
0.3118662238,
0.2784123421,
0.6540982127,
-0.1694049835,
0.7065812945,
0.1251986623,
-0.114232257,
0.2160682529,
-0.4190450013,
-0.1864998639,
0.3041534126,
0.4980264902,
0.1827838272,
0.1619702727,
-0.0984601229,
-0.3935888708,
0.1169408783,
0.1844249517,
-0.7039553523,
-0.2576723695,
0.2967062593,
-0.2131025791,
-0.377758652,
-0.5567452312,
-0.5031996369,
-0.1700602621,
-0.229471907,
0.5523265004,
-0.4908747077,
-0.2596590221,
0.149741888,
0.1496268064,
0.0651147217,
0.0921213478,
-0.8426206112,
0.3875747919,
0.4254591465,
0.8315032721,
-0.1680400223,
-0.3820811212,
-0.6784359813,
0.0850363672,
-0.3256631196,
1.2342208624,
-0.6092577577,
0.0713633597,
0.0631417334,
-0.0876990259,
-0.2753634453,
-0.6429155469,
0.1348710507,
-0.873726666,
-0.2083493024,
-0.4291692972,
-0.5419399738,
-0.1961631626,
0.3770158589,
-0.7422126532,
1.0561888218,
0.186202541,
-0.3811369836,
0.2695272267,
-0.7856642008,
-0.4797171652,
-0.3691949248,
0.4712745547,
-0.5311444998,
-0.0734380633,
0.0957540423,
0.171033591,
-0.1629453003,
0.0522639379,
-0.1903039515,
-0.3100748658,
0.3289062679,
-0.2584778666,
0.8621220589,
-0.0044643329,
-0.5633593798,
0.3367168605,
-1.2202948332,
-0.0036827009,
-0.0496823825,
-0.5508958697,
-0.4273240864,
0.1026396453,
-0.1474014819,
0.1553740799,
0.0619368367,
-0.5656689405,
0.4485186636,
-0.291017741,
0.3990215063,
0.9721946716,
0.1346497983,
0.7465398312,
-0.1510296017,
0.6902778149,
-0.057883583,
0.0259155426,
-0.4123128355,
-0.5496096015,
-0.7717898488,
-0.5386996269,
0.1458700299,
0.4338148534,
-0.7753931284,
0.0786095038,
-0.1525427401,
-0.6905155778,
-0.0810288861,
0.1118275896,
0.9438124895,
0.5387854576,
0.4746714234,
-0.2306293994,
-0.4182299078,
-1.060090065,
-0.5444559455,
-0.3090103269,
0.0429791883,
0.2212701738,
0.4089732766,
-0.1675600708,
0.761956811,
-0.3655379117,
-0.2690936625,
-0.1677103192,
0.3343022466,
0.0284652021,
0.7164559364,
0.4929453433,
-0.2635599971,
-0.551892519,
-0.2234206349,
-0.3480359316,
-0.3075085282,
-0.0219181199,
0.0211311579,
0.2067071199,
0.5901593566,
-0.4593335092,
0.1243541092,
0.7411916256,
-0.4720882475,
0.4283491969,
-0.1474384218,
0.4370533824,
-0.5434699059,
0.0257733483,
-0.0121438345,
-0.3928338587,
-0.937419951,
0.15323098,
0.4261499047,
-0.0323248692,
-1.0153825283,
0.5753520131,
-0.6415951848,
-0.0008577595,
-0.0680951551,
-0.2445816547,
-0.2811872065,
0.7910188437,
-0.4095440805,
1.0155158043,
0.5539212823,
-0.6184117794,
0.5887455344,
0.0585764237,
-0.4165615141,
0.3832481205,
-0.3921204507,
0.0496386588,
0.0372441672,
0.6006338,
-0.9542346597,
-0.1829392165,
0.2380733043,
0.0117643913,
0.4358109534,
-0.3905730844,
-0.511923492,
-0.113352932,
-0.6320026517,
1.2757527828,
0.5251395702,
-0.7029136419,
0.5346574783,
0.4139464498,
0.0790605545,
-0.1658654064,
-0.690577507,
-0.0665164888,
-0.3958654106,
-0.8486657143,
0.1178070381,
0.196012646,
-0.2913272977,
-0.3594052792,
-0.0898868516,
-0.2346295863,
0.0497690327,
-0.0609662235,
-0.1803618073,
-0.413254559,
-0.0647954196,
-0.2362241745,
-0.5961238146,
0.1204062179,
-0.1921965927,
0.6563426256,
-0.1141594648,
-0.7063627243,
-0.3653720021,
0.2881823182,
0.660158217,
-0.1385160685,
0.6337345243,
0.2521417141,
-0.3348701,
-0.0152930785,
-0.5889115334,
-0.3396362662,
-0.5037943125,
0.2481063306,
-0.0991638526,
-0.3676362634,
0.8025164008,
-0.3376641572,
-0.3683043122,
0.3743784726,
0.6298958659,
0.150353983,
0.8074577451,
0.5481525064,
-0.0484224334,
0.8115296364,
-0.294475913,
0.3817901313,
-0.9082893729,
-0.0136319557,
-0.4594479501,
-0.6302728653,
-0.1798464656,
-0.7863942981,
0.379645139,
0.1944722682,
-0.1728923619,
0.4942612946,
0.0093137994,
0.7357631326,
0.6787763238,
0.0558348075,
0.2188838273,
0.3048411906,
0.1695102751,
-0.0293358788,
-0.7788348794,
-0.1423282474,
1.1979285479,
0.3410127461,
0.6434727311,
0.320638597,
0.5000513196,
0.1532384455,
0.8244646192,
-0.5642900467,
0.5386627316,
0.2549027801,
-0.7842983603,
-0.403699249,
-0.3348110616,
-0.8238942623,
-0.1040431261,
-0.0099400189,
-0.9367718101,
0.2907568216,
0.7314892411,
-0.1222081855,
0.6585860848,
-0.8260025978,
0.8090550303,
0.261597991,
-0.4028805196,
-0.202926591,
-0.3933030069,
0.5869028568,
-0.1709287465,
0.2298496813,
0.0179409124,
0.0217918251,
0.6530514359,
-0.5617564321,
0.8150840402,
-0.2956053019,
-0.4291427732,
0.3705956638,
0.2385595292,
1.1359159946,
-0.3372033536,
-0.1204991117,
0.161627844,
-0.4632209539,
-0.8517308235,
-0.7571876645,
0.8029492497,
-0.3463347256,
-0.4105001092,
-0.2615059316,
-0.4198365211,
-0.2775965035,
0.1176338792,
0.0279887263,
0.7233841419,
0.2185201049,
-0.079703182,
0.779800117,
-0.1646703631,
0.4913760126,
0.6822510362,
-0.2595335543,
-0.2123659104,
1.4689906836,
0.0962485746,
0.6036841869,
0.3593051732,
0.1241737083,
-0.0758828148,
-0.3864828348,
-0.4555376768,
0.2896677852,
-0.6872631907,
-0.2088416368,
-0.4735363424,
0.1543305814,
-0.0460948795,
-0.414029479,
-0.930778563,
-0.7317623496,
-0.0083916252,
-0.0878225639,
0.3354024291,
0.2281664759,
-0.2236436009,
0.3698385656,
-0.5910420418,
0.3919795156,
0.4286812842,
0.6634595394,
-0.0628213957,
-0.1621907353,
-0.2909867465,
-0.0234074965,
-0.3217445612,
-0.9789942503,
0.1348493099,
0.2919244468,
0.3550263643,
0.2563561499,
-0.1280559152,
0.7677096725,
-0.782630384,
0.9610163569,
0.2909014225,
-0.911565423,
0.6372856498,
-0.4680041969,
0.0029403057,
0.345415324,
0.0021942409,
-0.1929205507,
-0.5501766801,
-0.6022752523,
-1.2533075809,
0.7001159191,
0.4008386433,
0.0635574237,
-0.3234014809,
0.3498252928,
-0.29542768,
-0.1065173522,
-0.6615402699,
-0.7440266609,
0.1991472691,
0.2197170407,
-0.3192583919,
-0.6959748268,
-0.2912441194,
-0.1038410738,
1.0768162012,
-0.0919319838,
0.3956646919,
0.1347196847,
-0.3431930542,
-0.6388449073,
0.2504520416,
0.9336425066,
0.572237432,
-0.3844632506,
0.3970378935,
-0.0092189778,
-0.2736536562,
0.6715734601,
-0.3877016306,
-0.1471600235,
-0.149991408,
0.5726082325,
0.5179744363,
0.5219465494,
-0.6559021473,
0.6296139956,
0.1776173115,
0.0638458431,
-0.0260874927,
-0.0163603388,
-0.0854441747,
0.2128187865,
0.1150383279,
0.4339192808,
0.0833735168,
-0.686866045,
0.1792927235,
0.3570737243,
-0.6341790557,
-0.4235064089,
0.6188451648,
0.2644663751,
-0.6093989611,
0.4085617065,
-0.0129535859,
-0.5765416622,
0.8487999439,
0.7561335564,
0.9199427366,
-0.4278851748,
0.0133030722,
0.2827302814,
0.1787786335,
-0.334612757,
0.1177185029,
0.0265727099,
-0.5303177834,
-0.6969302297,
-0.5750579834,
-0.2352741659,
-0.2680122852,
-0.4839395881,
0.0058068829,
-0.2228091061,
-0.0236263536,
-0.0945469588,
-0.1827990115,
-0.1350832433,
0.0217918549,
-0.2660458088,
1.1496655941,
-1.1660354137,
0.9250406027,
0.7931367755,
-0.1185983345,
-0.6923939586,
-0.0324908532,
0.1302416474,
-1.0141916275,
0.9097008109,
-0.1238175035,
0.0063604517,
0.1317554563,
-0.2292171717,
-1.088316679,
1.0089082718,
0.6660419106,
-0.2136007845,
0.3969685435,
-0.0317058228,
0.3777739406,
-0.1214310601,
0.2142439634,
0.6565923691,
0.7763977647,
-0.0129481386,
-0.7270003557,
0.2236014754,
-0.333419323,
-0.2063596696,
0.3965273499,
-0.6767982244,
1.0027314425,
-0.0158788711,
0.050118234,
-0.0815197676,
0.2842427194,
0.29264009,
0.1229749396,
0.6402672529,
0.5280796885,
0.5795295835,
0.0378211029,
1.5312786102,
-0.5961377025,
0.5892896056,
0.6542081833,
0.1788012832,
0.5753856301,
0.9158928394,
-0.5391888618,
0.4393647909,
0.5079116225,
0.2778264284,
0.6032683849,
0.583697319,
-0.409781158,
-0.3762132823,
0.0891028047,
-0.3587090373,
-0.2153936177,
-0.1268226504,
-0.1293859035,
-0.1968730986,
-0.0975148901,
0.0948279724,
-0.1898569912,
-0.4362734556,
0.4238372445,
-0.0585777946,
-0.5989491343,
0.663713932,
0.1187078133,
0.3724810481,
-0.6902099848,
-0.0873502046,
-0.4202656746,
0.3113444448,
-0.2573630214,
-0.1842063665,
0.4250175059,
-0.1871395558,
-0.5785533786,
-0.6256338358,
0.6490017772,
-0.492975086,
-0.6299107075,
0.2850134373,
0.0239553433,
0.0510590971,
-0.1247408986,
-0.2150412351,
0.0257321652,
-0.0357396416,
-0.7667729259,
0.6048033834,
0.1800329089,
-0.3401454985,
1.0725343227,
0.7592297196,
0.2942599952,
0.3728295863,
-0.1943633854,
1.0643166304,
-0.5412673354,
-0.3258880377,
-0.9157224894,
0.6320495009,
0.1991603822,
0.0446358174,
0.7768524885,
0.493737638,
0.2884800434,
-0.0801471397,
0.2424226105,
0.2028759867,
0.0646053925,
-0.7976589799,
0.3931167722,
-0.6549429893,
0.8716725707,
-0.2206250429,
-1.1044881344,
-0.6332192421,
0.4581491053,
-0.4222474098,
-0.2901068926,
0.9298804402,
0.9140765071,
-0.3817218542,
-0.3255467713,
0.1455115676,
0.5637338758,
0.6180665493,
0.436647296,
0.5183098316,
-0.6559040546,
0.3089894652,
-0.1733479053,
-0.5471862555,
-0.3287293613,
-1.0541746616,
-0.6188094616,
-0.2437161803,
-0.4881379306,
-0.5982365012,
-0.0340903327,
0.8593426347,
0.6803378463,
-0.9592236876,
0.0115715424,
-0.2938717306,
0.4800903797,
-0.357431531,
-0.1783785969,
0.5655758977,
-0.6915479302,
-0.4887804985,
0.6075962782,
0.5233514905,
-0.2180143148,
-0.4476371706,
-0.1362993419,
-0.3472001553,
0.4074508846,
0.4137776494,
0.5499613881,
-0.5228853822,
-0.449098587,
-0.3232865632,
-0.1028421372,
0.2137945592,
1.3706870079,
-0.7677212358,
0.3355572224,
0.3258160651,
0.5403635502,
0.4110555947,
-0.2636457384,
0.861289382,
-0.9545493126,
0.4014717937,
-0.0982830375,
0.4660434425,
0.1388740987,
-0.1403628141,
0.2949360311,
0.5216359496,
-0.5842577815,
-1.0224055052,
0.5252802968,
-0.9450545311,
-0.0547793247,
1.4418001175,
-0.4641135037,
-0.6003127098,
-0.0458261222,
-0.0883276835,
-0.1739422977,
-0.290803194,
1.0201034546,
0.4696810246,
-0.1684356183,
0.1563807875,
-0.1809131801,
0.6330536604,
0.500041306,
-0.4361972511,
0.1555353999,
0.4011910558,
0.3829723001,
0.4268456995,
0.9853358865,
0.0176185388,
0.1635949612,
0.0497456491,
-0.0195568465,
-0.0721423328,
-0.1693034321,
-0.2639210224,
0.32733652,
-0.1213891581,
0.0679860711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00742v1
|
Dialect prejudice predicts AI decisions about people's character, employability, and criminality
| 2024-03-01T18:43:09 | 2024-03-01T18:43:09 |
Valentin Hofmann, Pratyusha Ria Kalluri, Dan Jurafsky, Sharese King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Hundreds of millions of people now interact with language models, with uses
ranging from serving as a writing aid to informing hiring decisions. Yet these
language models are known to perpetuate systematic racial prejudices, making
their judgments biased in problematic ways about groups like African Americans.
While prior research has focused on overt racism in language models, social
scientists have argued that racism with a more subtle character has developed
over time. It is unknown whether this covert racism manifests in language
models. Here, we demonstrate that language models embody covert racism in the
form of dialect prejudice: we extend research showing that Americans hold
raciolinguistic stereotypes about speakers of African American English and find
that language models have the same prejudice, exhibiting covert stereotypes
that are more negative than any human stereotypes about African Americans ever
experimentally recorded, although closest to the ones from before the civil
rights movement. By contrast, the language models' overt stereotypes about
African Americans are much more positive. We demonstrate that dialect prejudice
has the potential for harmful consequences by asking language models to make
hypothetical decisions about people, based only on how they speak. Language
models are more likely to suggest that speakers of African American English be
assigned less prestigious jobs, be convicted of crimes, and be sentenced to
death. Finally, we show that existing methods for alleviating racial bias in
language models such as human feedback training do not mitigate the dialect
prejudice, but can exacerbate the discrepancy between covert and overt
stereotypes, by teaching language models to superficially conceal the racism
that they maintain on a deeper level. Our findings have far-reaching
implications for the fair and safe employment of language technology.
|
[
-0.3813872933,
-0.6091331244,
0.6106242537,
-0.1162345707,
0.1204738915,
-0.2311318368,
-0.3185423613,
-0.6379057169,
0.4523181319,
0.7619265914,
-0.1113876253,
-0.0986632034,
-0.4101186395,
-0.4230415523,
-0.5947864056,
0.7796183825,
0.5348159075,
0.2924529016,
0.2468032837,
-0.1780066192,
-0.2518752813,
-1.0044157505,
-0.5561189055,
-0.2971682847,
0.426564604,
0.3300036788,
1.0054154396,
0.3944597542,
0.0512282662,
0.3019858003,
-0.0002083164,
-0.5439617634,
-0.4646502137,
0.2263723463,
-0.3556292355,
-0.833635807,
-0.1045446396,
0.2902156115,
-0.0599066988,
0.9727301598,
-0.1051293388,
-0.1369906813,
-0.3120369613,
0.6477944851,
-0.5134208202,
-0.0150814177,
-0.8573637605,
-0.2127483636,
-0.5599964261,
0.5041114688,
-0.3849196732,
-0.4716083705,
-0.1598065197,
-0.2499849349,
0.6393550038,
0.1924456805,
0.8645756245,
0.1108854562,
-0.7426105142,
-0.2773146927,
-0.8247466087,
0.7033730149,
-0.9236217737,
0.4586587548,
0.6368494034,
0.5605612397,
0.3085089326,
-0.3320696056,
-0.9030394554,
-0.6409990788,
-0.1265466958,
0.083808884,
0.2201058716,
0.2229051739,
0.439666152,
0.2068862468,
-0.5498154163,
0.1458899975,
-0.7287532687,
-0.2112209499,
0.7216482759,
0.1814278215,
0.3267606497,
-0.1241328865,
0.0528946854,
-0.086840868,
-0.5981182456,
-0.0722204074,
0.6191551685,
0.5168614984,
0.0747941956,
0.3561814725,
-0.1146272197,
0.2764668763,
-0.2945891023,
0.2079877555,
0.0774465725,
0.1185586154,
0.0832185149,
-0.0156027889,
0.4013070166,
0.497867018,
0.8564897776,
-0.1154543161,
-0.1935148984,
0.8222976327,
0.3367645741,
-0.4127136767,
-0.1082576066,
-0.0164864492,
-0.1472301781,
-0.1760580242,
0.0488613322,
-0.8827953935,
-0.6889847517,
0.0429230593,
0.0964004472,
-0.3127031326,
-0.2083974779,
0.1723994762,
-0.4848297834,
0.1455899924,
0.1641193181,
-0.967875123,
0.2626023293,
0.7777454257,
0.377363503,
0.2400818318,
-0.1619642824,
0.1675607264,
0.1122620553,
-0.5182862282,
0.1664714068,
-0.6662580371,
-0.3247898221,
0.2892324328,
0.0694900975,
0.1160751432,
-0.6422773004,
0.6405044198,
-0.3503725231,
0.135117054,
-0.4042622447,
-0.1986836046,
-0.2557072639,
-0.019678954,
-0.4361252487,
0.6028717756,
-0.0574134812,
-0.5597782135,
0.5256941319,
-0.2081923932,
-0.4939204454,
-0.0991818681,
-0.1536171436,
-0.4699860811,
0.317809552,
-0.0696183369,
0.0341142863,
-0.1838740855,
0.3167233467,
-0.739916563,
-0.3052709997,
0.3049708903,
-0.2392597198,
1.1404541731,
0.325707078,
-0.6620151997,
-0.4901432693,
-0.4880171418,
-0.3932585418,
0.2630197108,
-0.0155787133,
-0.8007664084,
0.077725172,
-0.3452875614,
0.1231277958,
-0.2665601075,
-0.830132246,
-0.0292289946,
-0.4777435958,
0.1327071339,
0.7605878711,
-0.2077485174,
0.5844805837,
-0.4868305027,
0.4704428613,
-0.2152331769,
0.3380996287,
0.20542337,
-0.6206975579,
-1.3034018278,
0.1895980984,
0.0677068755,
0.4701539874,
-0.4150092304,
0.1600710303,
-0.0335807204,
-0.313670367,
-0.5206159353,
-0.113048777,
0.2366086692,
0.3995648324,
0.2708582282,
-0.2514383197,
-0.3072338104,
-1.0783588886,
-0.6613391042,
-0.4933202267,
-0.0630131885,
0.4963435829,
0.344784081,
-0.1946703792,
0.7561783791,
-0.317712903,
-0.319383055,
-0.1724036187,
0.2019455284,
0.0619578809,
0.3117308021,
0.8471364975,
-0.4798115492,
-0.4578403234,
-0.0091644637,
-0.4769967496,
-0.3882050216,
-0.0350739434,
0.0331565365,
0.1600951552,
0.5913412571,
-0.4891684949,
0.4470437169,
0.2613568902,
-0.5587330461,
0.5706237555,
0.3406232297,
0.0096165258,
-0.7011735439,
-0.289444983,
-0.1414598227,
0.0667912737,
-0.7144280076,
0.2559414506,
-0.0358419567,
-0.4065500796,
-0.049746938,
0.7276565433,
-0.299148351,
0.1698708832,
-0.0378282629,
0.0076461392,
0.3022698164,
0.2532983422,
0.0485219546,
0.3775342703,
0.3847505748,
-0.3872420788,
0.1648618132,
-0.0169386473,
-0.4493919611,
0.257735163,
-0.517244637,
0.2283455133,
-0.4701098502,
-0.0387929752,
-0.8244056702,
0.0035974905,
-0.2279425114,
-0.5736100078,
0.3202658296,
-0.1313950121,
0.3137063086,
-0.5422670245,
-0.1961979866,
0.2302503288,
0.6490046978,
-0.2775921524,
0.3129649758,
0.3506883085,
-0.5580479503,
-0.6005159616,
-1.2046880722,
0.1424316913,
-0.1485071033,
-0.6317443252,
0.0970998257,
0.2995224297,
-0.9986122847,
-0.2109816074,
0.0685830563,
-0.2022472471,
-0.0789033845,
0.2916499376,
0.0923931748,
-0.1864528656,
0.0548729077,
-0.0457901247,
0.1678647697,
0.277972877,
-0.0169881955,
0.3384248018,
0.4660801888,
-0.3923527896,
0.2625951469,
0.6239568591,
0.7694603801,
-0.0622801967,
0.7587122917,
0.0568471253,
-0.0539068915,
-0.5210501552,
-0.9875227809,
-0.5715354681,
-0.4427983761,
0.5024240017,
-0.1519201845,
-0.689512372,
0.5042504072,
0.3026487827,
-0.0462161601,
-0.034749683,
0.2990523279,
-0.2111549079,
0.861158967,
0.8132251501,
-0.3296735883,
0.7119014263,
-0.197157383,
0.3827611506,
-0.2407758683,
-0.1588454843,
-0.8846642971,
-0.0987824574,
-0.4429703355,
-0.3375590444,
0.3288972676,
-0.0600238629,
-0.3075819016,
0.0491947904,
-0.1715853363,
0.4905199707,
0.6267108917,
0.0871129334,
-0.1442513764,
-0.0218721367,
-0.2853743136,
-0.2628086507,
-0.339886874,
-0.4606744647,
1.0097333193,
0.3172751665,
0.8706429601,
0.2412405014,
0.5210460424,
0.5000224113,
0.339869827,
-0.5078536272,
0.4786309898,
-0.1378623396,
-1.1964156628,
-0.3446836174,
-0.2659088075,
-0.7486987114,
0.1658701301,
0.0434835218,
-0.5558822751,
0.7495622635,
0.3392121792,
-0.0352763273,
0.1692717671,
-0.9849079847,
0.7689621449,
-0.3316972554,
-0.3778312206,
-0.4345938563,
-0.5661454201,
0.5758550763,
-0.1153096408,
0.4938452244,
-0.2060513198,
0.3574793339,
0.3745692074,
-0.8176667094,
0.9471669197,
-0.3399404883,
0.1166988164,
-0.0383876376,
0.3857802153,
0.5387020707,
-0.2408056557,
-0.6613848209,
0.3715796173,
-0.580085218,
-0.5280866623,
-0.5957030654,
0.3656741679,
-0.6786109209,
-1.0120594501,
-0.3475985527,
-0.2930208743,
-0.216758579,
0.0242995676,
0.232216686,
0.2182353735,
-0.2471685708,
-0.2670578957,
0.2651937008,
-0.4223769307,
0.1906716526,
0.6360504627,
-0.138162151,
-0.0376980416,
0.7962456346,
0.0356293917,
0.7197895646,
-0.024447849,
0.2154679596,
-0.187605381,
-0.4540133774,
-0.0480258875,
0.4866423905,
-0.7290953994,
0.0383357964,
-0.5070416927,
-0.009764092,
-0.906426549,
-0.5217689872,
-0.2216496468,
-0.7736795545,
0.27030918,
-0.2245747298,
0.132176742,
0.8955059052,
-0.1163142473,
0.3525974751,
-0.1602346152,
0.363258332,
0.8430244327,
-0.00875556,
-0.0890075564,
-0.9082514644,
-0.193248719,
0.1706619859,
-0.1995598078,
-0.9748391509,
0.4034291506,
0.1618755907,
0.550637424,
0.6358630657,
0.3843876421,
0.1619063914,
-0.494263649,
0.8814166188,
-0.0449632816,
-0.7890465856,
0.3644636571,
-0.244839251,
-0.1872138828,
0.5255074501,
0.5382934213,
-0.773899436,
-1.0243270397,
-0.3871318102,
-0.7292428017,
0.7528874874,
-0.0648305267,
0.534723103,
-0.1797290593,
0.0918213651,
-0.0795142055,
0.0644681826,
-1.070148468,
-0.4210087359,
-0.6939983964,
0.1053127125,
-0.2578295767,
-0.5940805674,
-0.0462300852,
-0.3289138675,
0.5645573735,
0.171992287,
0.0200373158,
-0.122291021,
-0.1504817903,
0.0232271142,
0.4713695049,
0.3948711753,
0.3542711437,
-0.1339119375,
0.2319752574,
-0.024429569,
-0.2437768728,
0.343960315,
0.009238312,
-0.4393451512,
0.1692808419,
0.4027793705,
0.837356329,
-0.458001703,
-0.2369818687,
0.5841579437,
0.1528957039,
0.0375905633,
-0.2525491416,
0.0289526451,
0.0422785021,
0.1559819132,
0.1684356928,
0.1038728654,
0.2950861454,
-1.1309463978,
0.0148226786,
0.8067097664,
-0.2577227652,
-0.3220126629,
0.8300510049,
0.5645834208,
-0.3817324638,
0.5845551491,
-0.1424329728,
-1.0564391613,
0.6564347744,
0.4881727397,
0.8265427351,
-0.6410982609,
0.1172707304,
0.1968789846,
0.7791146636,
0.2259036899,
-0.0484179631,
-0.0104457838,
-1.1848016977,
-0.0247866306,
-0.7561665177,
-0.2474898398,
0.017070381,
-0.4844742417,
0.2790125906,
-0.4047475159,
-0.3174508214,
0.0505359583,
-0.3524235487,
-0.189858526,
0.2462245077,
0.3743847311,
0.7876683474,
-1.2048227787,
0.9187550545,
0.3939811587,
-0.4405061007,
-0.5655369163,
0.2373430282,
0.1898651719,
-0.7588600516,
0.8903018236,
0.1122638583,
0.0542324968,
-0.2979412675,
-0.2491256744,
-0.371371448,
0.207581684,
0.6930705309,
-0.4966156483,
-0.2341573536,
0.607242167,
0.4145498872,
0.0056628957,
0.4378311932,
0.6392182708,
0.5174080729,
-0.1444860399,
-0.9906109571,
-0.1150797755,
-0.2190581113,
0.0378291942,
0.1096948907,
-0.5795403123,
1.1443414688,
-0.3361509144,
-0.2199415267,
-0.2812066078,
0.1822686195,
-0.3308104575,
0.153355211,
0.4812461138,
0.4806502163,
0.4747911394,
-0.1805055737,
0.9995322227,
-0.1902769506,
0.0340131968,
0.810061872,
-0.530005753,
0.1523636431,
0.2017105967,
-0.2525625527,
0.6996446848,
-0.0312748738,
0.3687222302,
0.4758930504,
0.2747517526,
-0.4208520949,
-0.1846949309,
-0.2256012857,
-0.3245535493,
0.4695539176,
0.563233614,
-0.3797540367,
-0.041560851,
0.0061031291,
0.1645266712,
0.5544965863,
-0.2395484149,
0.4534884393,
0.1399908811,
-0.5636237264,
0.6812907457,
-0.0355403386,
0.7376689315,
-0.5866779685,
0.108803086,
-0.7950136065,
0.3305858672,
-0.0756897628,
-0.1955411285,
0.3728829622,
-0.3229146302,
-0.3439412713,
-0.0748371109,
0.4556213915,
-0.5591808558,
-0.2926437557,
0.5073999763,
0.2028706968,
0.1164772063,
-0.2638990581,
-0.684214592,
-0.0272431877,
0.2037745118,
-0.0235328674,
0.0934590697,
0.4385762513,
-0.2528502941,
0.6622443199,
0.3904117644,
0.6614236832,
0.4492401481,
0.3512612879,
0.627859652,
-0.8947826624,
-0.5565187335,
-0.645581305,
0.2822744548,
-0.3472200036,
0.1384607553,
0.8057586551,
0.3382095397,
0.9467138052,
0.0246584322,
0.9196207523,
0.0020385522,
0.7455444336,
-0.3564486206,
0.8770796061,
-0.4705075622,
0.2520444691,
-0.4573003352,
-0.7737317681,
0.0447884575,
0.5925127268,
-0.437835604,
0.4967494011,
0.6859286427,
1.1769567728,
0.000006928,
-0.0643361583,
0.7154507637,
0.4959619939,
0.1929233968,
0.2462798655,
0.9312415719,
0.0083904648,
0.4368000031,
-0.457003057,
-0.1593837738,
-0.2806921601,
-0.2714156806,
-0.9435225725,
-0.3197578788,
-0.0430245623,
-0.3310060501,
0.3903729916,
0.3306649923,
0.8777102828,
-1.0008757114,
-0.476716131,
0.0830752775,
0.130650878,
0.1503982395,
-0.3366562426,
-0.3599205017,
-0.2737011015,
-0.8249462247,
0.271689415,
0.0718009099,
0.1502988487,
-0.2665096521,
-0.0235405881,
0.0842844099,
0.4157454073,
0.385086447,
0.487632513,
-0.7540878057,
-0.2916368544,
-0.3435033858,
-0.2751311064,
-0.3230937123,
1.065849185,
-0.5896251798,
0.5249605775,
0.2063874453,
0.1822661012,
0.3884036243,
-0.0772817507,
0.8790260553,
-0.801997304,
0.74426651,
0.5577605367,
0.5628516674,
0.3006888032,
-0.3607314229,
0.3625845313,
0.3976281285,
-0.4910120964,
-0.9212446809,
0.5766506195,
-0.2271860838,
-0.5426748395,
0.9706327319,
0.0762228519,
0.0921950713,
-0.668408215,
-0.0406679809,
0.1176323816,
-0.4179156721,
0.9934998155,
0.4658625424,
0.137125507,
0.012093652,
-0.531063199,
0.758539021,
0.8964586258,
-0.3532681167,
0.3455314636,
0.6779915094,
0.0959977731,
0.2576196194,
0.5013872981,
0.1349389404,
0.2021624148,
0.2656226754,
0.4721872509,
0.0271836407,
-0.2417436987,
-0.3511742949,
-0.0604752712,
0.3010219336,
0.0871574953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00724v1
|
Few-Shot Relation Extraction with Hybrid Visual Evidence
| 2024-03-01T18:20:11 | 2024-03-01T18:20:11 |
Jiaying Gong, Hoda Eldardiry
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The goal of few-shot relation extraction is to predict relations between name
entities in a sentence when only a few labeled instances are available for
training. Existing few-shot relation extraction methods focus on uni-modal
information such as text only. This reduces performance when there are no clear
contexts between the name entities described in text. We propose a multi-modal
few-shot relation extraction model (MFS-HVE) that leverages both textual and
visual semantic information to learn a multi-modal representation jointly. The
MFS-HVE includes semantic feature extractors and multi-modal fusion components.
The MFS-HVE semantic feature extractors are developed to extract both textual
and visual features. The visual features include global image features and
local object features within the image. The MFS-HVE multi-modal fusion unit
integrates information from various modalities using image-guided attention,
object-guided attention, and hybrid feature attention to fully capture the
semantic interaction between visual regions of images and relevant texts.
Extensive experiments conducted on two public datasets demonstrate that
semantic visual information significantly improves the performance of few-shot
relation prediction.
|
[
-0.4207968414,
-0.9458209872,
0.6600160599,
-0.2838962972,
-0.4676349461,
-0.2418464422,
-0.0178978387,
-0.7631771564,
0.1894384623,
0.4289791286,
-0.8289401531,
-0.2672091722,
-0.6278365254,
0.1907743812,
-0.0978365391,
0.9238625765,
0.2601765096,
0.1235563233,
-0.2721551657,
-0.1245710105,
-0.391212821,
-0.204501614,
0.1143648028,
-0.2472954094,
0.6197511554,
0.4250441194,
0.6603505015,
0.5417480469,
0.7572728395,
0.3341983557,
0.225704968,
0.3602384031,
-0.6745853424,
0.0991820842,
0.0352247581,
-0.2960435152,
-0.2369600832,
0.0466971919,
0.7000836134,
0.2011849582,
0.421523869,
0.121318616,
-0.2412518263,
0.1755019128,
-1.0149717331,
0.36183092,
-0.6984854937,
-0.1561956257,
-0.5380782485,
-0.363735646,
-0.3825629056,
0.2756485641,
0.3602915108,
-0.8198667169,
-0.068757996,
0.2007923126,
1.1791404486,
0.0817398131,
-0.6881716251,
0.3440075517,
-0.7106825113,
0.7839276195,
-0.3202126324,
0.5635489821,
0.4159134626,
0.4515762925,
-0.2147511989,
-0.3717433512,
-0.7010717392,
-0.0566045791,
-0.542449832,
0.2877525985,
-0.1177688316,
0.0316426829,
0.229719162,
0.2434103489,
-0.2456140071,
-0.1798280627,
-0.3671451211,
-0.2039099336,
0.4242582619,
0.3777741194,
0.1897863001,
-0.8455032706,
-0.9611081481,
0.0603437573,
-0.551412344,
0.0509148277,
-0.1958504915,
0.22301431,
-0.3002755344,
0.9559063911,
-0.2048944235,
0.8025099635,
-0.1517235637,
-0.9540293813,
0.1277690977,
-0.7495715618,
-0.4088181853,
-0.3355047405,
1.0958338976,
0.2457211465,
0.1005666181,
-0.128615573,
-0.1158903763,
0.2499543577,
-0.2191558778,
-0.7637024522,
-0.0282753445,
-0.2200392932,
-0.6952679753,
-0.2501740456,
0.2276806682,
-1.1341087818,
-0.2810009718,
-0.2030777484,
0.4933624864,
-0.6588252783,
-0.3228002489,
-0.4158600569,
-0.6008356214,
0.399763912,
0.3601906896,
-0.7722920179,
0.1686268002,
0.5489386916,
0.7382688522,
-0.3082304895,
-0.5665003061,
-0.8004467487,
0.6710141301,
0.2966889739,
1.0655038357,
-0.8825300336,
-0.2718622386,
-0.0922911093,
0.0041901283,
-0.1732650995,
-0.1943812221,
0.1704703122,
-0.4928907752,
0.4462403655,
-0.1822797954,
-0.5178778172,
-0.0489046127,
0.3245935738,
-0.8188480139,
0.9115024209,
0.0604251176,
-1.0150405169,
0.577547133,
-0.3593126237,
-0.3451880515,
0.0660845265,
-0.6587116718,
-0.41586712,
-0.1591098756,
0.2382485867,
0.5367601514,
-0.4127402604,
-0.212621361,
-0.4583827555,
-0.0777008533,
0.1835965365,
-0.2087080181,
0.3830933571,
-0.1158238873,
0.1678836048,
0.0737134442,
-0.9472622275,
-0.4311726391,
0.2005414814,
-0.3684802651,
-0.6065584421,
-0.322907418,
0.2499830425,
0.5573749542,
-0.026790848,
-0.7844869494,
0.0809445605,
-0.4073093235,
-0.1819948852,
0.4093362391,
0.5166974068,
0.7175658345,
-0.1940735579,
0.5354460478,
0.4512207508,
-0.0256302413,
-0.7098758221,
-0.5235638618,
-0.5885562897,
-0.7140777111,
0.1719740331,
0.372164607,
-1.2164561749,
0.1184497476,
-0.3828061223,
-0.0163418334,
-0.2999100089,
0.5486775637,
0.4865370691,
0.5674415231,
0.3428473473,
-0.1542177349,
-0.4193588495,
-0.9872220159,
-0.1455232948,
-0.1262546778,
0.2021450549,
0.3947520554,
0.6904675364,
-0.0572669134,
1.3127955198,
-0.6720043421,
-0.8800961971,
-0.3801013231,
0.3568670452,
-0.1494937837,
0.2048803717,
0.5708268285,
-0.8474174142,
-0.1360569447,
0.0953144133,
-0.9001951218,
0.6026637554,
-0.1493993998,
-0.3688451648,
-0.0668883845,
0.1539373249,
-0.8397749066,
0.5084322095,
0.1275212318,
-0.2300972342,
0.3194205463,
0.2266700268,
0.119115606,
-1.1233320236,
-0.2737608552,
0.4488646388,
-0.4957448542,
-0.3685475886,
-0.156486243,
0.0153054222,
-0.0116604799,
-0.778608501,
0.6274855733,
-0.5881097317,
-0.2120049298,
-0.2093438208,
0.2648985386,
0.1074283868,
0.495139122,
0.2833611071,
0.349579215,
0.4583737552,
-0.3105415404,
0.4324586987,
0.5288926959,
-0.0227478426,
0.5506008267,
-0.1036999077,
-0.1299283952,
-0.243486613,
0.1688856781,
-0.8083716631,
-0.4811565876,
0.2646148205,
-0.3265177906,
0.3290541172,
-0.3867898583,
-0.4190096855,
-0.1286369562,
-0.4786885083,
0.3815783262,
0.0349296927,
-0.328265816,
0.770134151,
0.3286517859,
0.1057397351,
-0.4686266482,
-0.7458044887,
-0.0932332352,
0.0119312434,
-0.7024347782,
0.2843678892,
0.5487676859,
-0.0730819479,
0.2905713916,
0.0277220309,
-0.574534297,
-0.1976445168,
0.3304826915,
0.7405225635,
-0.4197930992,
0.4230981469,
-0.125144437,
-0.3232030869,
-0.2476081103,
0.3754880428,
0.1204136014,
-0.0027643302,
-0.0336350016,
-0.5826127529,
0.6399630308,
0.6327352524,
-0.3628662527,
0.7665452957,
0.8203371763,
-0.6582529545,
0.2049469054,
-0.5874001384,
-0.4385115206,
-0.3383080065,
0.3250235915,
-0.6823281646,
-0.7106662393,
0.2045698017,
-0.2839942873,
-0.3168956041,
0.4728882909,
0.4283212423,
-0.2246114314,
0.6945763826,
1.0062055588,
-0.0600544363,
0.6735836267,
-0.4681268036,
-0.0940016508,
-0.649392128,
-0.4307581484,
-0.1282189935,
-0.1399765909,
-0.2901219726,
-0.1214944869,
0.586815536,
0.0638579652,
0.3181242943,
0.5659613609,
0.0001040358,
0.5706219077,
0.4179475307,
0.3864020705,
0.6695670485,
-0.1234453693,
0.0165799614,
-0.3739048541,
-0.6327229142,
-0.3376662135,
0.7794371247,
0.2499650866,
0.8450819254,
0.1365128607,
0.9618512988,
-0.1823089421,
0.1336486936,
-1.1063606739,
0.2947220206,
0.0526808575,
-0.6793413162,
-0.2008313984,
-0.3250940442,
-0.8777102232,
0.5657384396,
-1.123801589,
-0.6993068457,
0.3429422677,
-0.1015420109,
-0.5233116746,
-0.1016745493,
-0.7540582418,
0.9625168443,
-0.2090454996,
-0.4669991434,
-0.1094941571,
-0.7935492396,
0.8264347315,
0.0283124316,
0.0797966719,
-0.1905024201,
-0.0941876099,
0.7173089981,
-0.314933002,
0.8241055608,
0.2062725425,
0.3820399642,
0.0505872741,
0.05678799,
0.2706735432,
-0.0519159958,
0.2479422837,
-0.1113578752,
0.1533489674,
-0.1741067469,
-0.4972013235,
0.4878573716,
-0.4714684784,
-0.1392778158,
-0.5038161278,
-0.4515171945,
-0.1875083297,
0.3617681563,
0.3986838162,
0.3763232529,
-0.3481250405,
0.0076509626,
0.2188754231,
0.3065019846,
0.7895644307,
0.1537405401,
-0.1266281605,
-0.5845409036,
0.7710080147,
-0.058372844,
0.2551953793,
0.47747913,
0.2305718064,
-0.1089821458,
0.0646652877,
-0.4993675947,
0.4679223597,
-0.7015200853,
-0.5887958407,
-0.5767451525,
0.0286107976,
-0.311842978,
0.1014088467,
-0.3618813455,
-0.2920866907,
-0.4556671381,
0.124758482,
0.5452579856,
0.5707476735,
0.3400374353,
0.3859994709,
-1.1880683899,
0.9296525121,
0.4999755621,
-0.1391437203,
-0.3222728074,
-0.1393968016,
0.0032341373,
-0.367685467,
-0.4260656536,
-1.2313867807,
0.3182998896,
0.4109013975,
0.440067023,
0.7000177503,
-0.0580741502,
0.8854683638,
-0.2819295228,
0.6145669818,
0.8173813224,
-0.6185944676,
0.7626571655,
-0.2815940082,
0.2010722905,
0.6816471815,
0.3455993533,
0.0138437971,
-0.0916416943,
-0.5196441412,
-0.2171910852,
0.7805120945,
0.3203981221,
-0.1755185574,
0.1642123908,
0.125188902,
0.2259617746,
0.1778498739,
-0.9173384905,
-0.2375345677,
0.1548321247,
-0.126500234,
0.3083140552,
-0.2707297802,
-0.3140625358,
-0.3383826911,
0.2196055949,
-0.2611735761,
0.2592969537,
0.1372292787,
-0.4491730332,
-0.2556245625,
0.2928853333,
0.4039638042,
0.5797687769,
-0.2164431065,
0.3089160025,
0.0646686703,
-0.0865640268,
0.0831694081,
0.1042450741,
-0.0991836414,
0.1749850363,
0.6988916993,
0.6395688057,
0.5697507262,
-0.3061826825,
1.1411597729,
0.0970618427,
-0.01909706,
0.0428465642,
-0.1142588854,
-0.0945372507,
0.4358354807,
0.157246843,
0.1963182092,
0.2519415915,
-0.8556466699,
0.4243834317,
0.5505252481,
-0.262604326,
-0.2549203932,
0.3952904642,
0.352432847,
0.075171642,
0.2038308233,
-0.1151629388,
-0.4536269307,
0.179143697,
0.5194987059,
0.6724276543,
0.3105897307,
0.2115216404,
0.2488265038,
0.1402278394,
0.0249108095,
-0.0056628766,
-0.2518298626,
-0.7733140588,
-0.3816122711,
-0.4688723683,
-0.2085023224,
0.0117477654,
-0.4653812051,
0.7192071676,
-0.3738802671,
-0.2576952279,
0.3334871829,
-0.2036948502,
-0.7821350098,
0.021885775,
0.4064842165,
0.4724685848,
-1.0003743172,
1.0017052889,
0.5524608493,
-0.9786636233,
-0.480819881,
-0.1755491644,
0.3371647298,
-0.6236831546,
0.8420215249,
0.1238963306,
-0.3876739442,
-0.2196665108,
-0.4697816372,
-0.7538622618,
1.1931377649,
0.4962287247,
-0.3836955428,
-0.026807854,
-0.129791528,
0.1499320269,
-0.7131019235,
0.2337101996,
0.5866365433,
0.4538804889,
0.4304634929,
-0.7328724265,
-0.0206787046,
0.0580472276,
-0.0504001118,
0.3205698133,
-0.5471246839,
0.5863264203,
-0.2707082629,
-0.3897651732,
0.0302908979,
0.8047614098,
0.128700614,
0.4258750081,
0.4427945614,
0.3721332252,
0.4181115031,
0.045900844,
1.0789005756,
0.1950470209,
0.4545862675,
1.2981590033,
-0.241762504,
1.0387284756,
0.8016819358,
0.0775168985,
0.4844428003,
0.3920791745,
-0.0782527775,
0.7206345201,
-0.5795654058,
-0.2464908212,
-0.6830798984,
-0.2773948014,
-0.1091864035,
0.8901693225,
0.0682096481,
-0.5489328504,
-0.5019627213,
0.2272292376,
-0.1292777508,
-0.2442731559,
0.0886500925,
1.2395817041,
0.1446438879,
-0.2462993115,
0.3199889362,
-0.2183093578,
0.7293869257,
-0.4883713126,
-0.3084379733,
0.313675195,
-0.019662872,
-0.377420634,
-0.3972297609,
-0.0756208748,
-0.1631981432,
-0.5265854001,
0.2394757122,
1.1195827723,
-0.7143978477,
-0.5062875152,
0.3335063159,
0.8855499029,
-0.1073637456,
0.01852029,
-0.5726673007,
-0.101428926,
-0.3112743199,
-0.1301920265,
0.3278545737,
0.3694687784,
0.1750274897,
0.3289733529,
0.6303769946,
0.0795879662,
0.2199836969,
0.0231632702,
1.071865201,
-0.8147233725,
-0.2563220561,
-0.8894580007,
0.5779171586,
-0.3035016954,
-0.5117182136,
0.4069685936,
0.3615082502,
0.4539686441,
-0.1463314444,
0.6685140133,
0.0896335244,
0.2093769461,
-0.6750269532,
0.2759439051,
-0.5588663816,
-0.0751787871,
-0.4030589163,
-0.9572119117,
-0.3537487984,
0.3828064799,
-0.1729156673,
-0.3160960376,
1.0541477203,
0.648643434,
-0.3832089305,
-0.0473882034,
0.5218046308,
-0.1358333975,
0.1173649654,
0.5542267561,
0.9570379257,
-0.6621564627,
0.7919291854,
-0.606595695,
-0.2410318106,
-0.1278903186,
-0.8600073457,
-1.0430397987,
-0.4472557902,
-0.4262065589,
-0.1221364662,
-0.2991372943,
0.9812409878,
0.8517949581,
-0.4197086096,
0.1164264679,
0.3829805851,
0.1450655162,
0.0370881632,
-0.2643915117,
0.22571446,
-0.1128175333,
-0.4902646244,
0.4674127102,
0.6449487209,
0.2038408965,
-0.1292623878,
-0.0306319688,
-0.7007406354,
-0.3584288955,
0.8202219605,
0.1200874597,
-0.8303750157,
-0.3176662922,
-0.0704192296,
-0.2467695773,
0.2889705002,
0.8557241559,
-0.781272471,
0.5839189291,
0.7146216035,
0.6080464721,
0.8300248981,
0.1060249954,
0.4598529339,
-0.8542720675,
0.4063866138,
0.0739240944,
0.5002339482,
0.1779212356,
-0.4380027354,
0.2437991202,
0.5709642768,
-0.0511162207,
-0.3940714002,
0.276171118,
-1.3465943336,
-0.0746706203,
1.2880284786,
-0.0588091575,
-0.3953928351,
-0.1437747031,
-0.2836917043,
0.0997551084,
-0.6455099583,
0.18798168,
0.6539573073,
-0.4460327029,
-0.6070632339,
-0.3621344566,
0.3647179604,
0.1206817031,
-0.920643568,
-0.2537116408,
0.8105605245,
0.1217399016,
0.2803285122,
0.4910876751,
-0.1238033473,
0.4706351459,
0.0997707546,
-0.1492212862,
-0.0977196768,
-0.4660853744,
-0.2380216271,
0.3147561848,
-0.2160729617,
-0.5442904234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00696v1
|
Self-Consistent Decoding for More Factual Open Responses
| 2024-03-01T17:31:09 | 2024-03-01T17:31:09 |
Christopher Malon, Xiaodan Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-consistency has emerged as a powerful method for improving the accuracy
of short answers generated by large language models. As previously defined, it
only concerns the accuracy of a final answer parsed from generated text. In
this work, we extend the idea to open response generation, by integrating
voting into the decoding method. Each output sentence is selected from among
multiple samples, conditioning on the previous selections, based on a simple
token overlap score. We compare this "Sample & Select" method to greedy
decoding, beam search, nucleus sampling, and the recently introduced
hallucination avoiding decoders of DoLA, P-CRR, and S-CRR. We show that Sample
& Select improves factuality by a 30% relative margin against these decoders in
NLI-based evaluation on the subsets of CNN/DM and XSum used in the FRANK
benchmark, while maintaining comparable ROUGE-1 F1 scores against reference
summaries. We collect human verifications of the generated summaries,
confirming the factual superiority of our method.
|
[
-0.2608155608,
-0.3677402437,
0.5792845488,
0.2943501472,
-0.1295204908,
-0.0926270112,
-0.3353345394,
-0.3781152964,
0.3716716468,
0.4514354467,
-0.3081766367,
-0.4301811159,
-0.3278582096,
0.5816965699,
-0.2964782715,
1.0300301313,
0.0025228027,
-0.0226395018,
-0.3664398789,
-0.2372926474,
-0.0963031426,
-0.6340004802,
-0.1827729344,
-0.0669038668,
0.5013773441,
0.4320221245,
0.5761423707,
0.8180544972,
0.5969260931,
0.2765836418,
0.2221236527,
0.3927608132,
-0.5724733472,
0.1218644008,
-0.25113976,
-0.4586144686,
-0.3514644802,
0.1387200952,
0.4329237938,
0.3125070333,
-0.2895739675,
0.1965981275,
0.050532952,
0.7075586915,
-0.9445952177,
0.0274602957,
-0.5792486668,
0.0233229399,
-0.1808588356,
-0.3505522311,
-0.7674838305,
-0.5850275755,
-0.233628571,
-0.3027852774,
0.710642159,
-0.1034228578,
0.7170854807,
0.3879538774,
-0.1896461844,
-0.5541765094,
-0.8452655673,
0.5753634572,
-0.701880753,
0.3951132596,
0.3429815471,
0.303920716,
0.0307124257,
-0.6314060092,
-0.7477678657,
-0.1779297292,
-0.3074259162,
0.5319295526,
-0.0837559327,
-0.0016355183,
0.1960006803,
0.4264001548,
-0.5811966062,
-0.3436344862,
-0.5103635788,
-0.4509421289,
0.6780877113,
0.1740667969,
-0.0019606987,
-0.3616197407,
-0.2634948194,
-0.4140358865,
-0.5587407351,
0.1192260161,
0.3873115182,
0.4663231969,
0.1170698628,
0.8807677031,
-0.525829792,
0.6039332151,
0.3400353193,
0.0129781282,
0.3461780548,
-0.7307499647,
-0.2688604593,
0.0992174521,
0.8513096571,
0.3697254956,
0.1333935559,
-0.21407938,
-0.1064498276,
-0.0231141448,
0.198484689,
-0.8073309064,
-0.3373553455,
0.4587158263,
-0.6758241057,
-0.0903602839,
0.5933596492,
-0.8003270626,
-0.0137662617,
-0.1985213906,
0.1267174929,
-0.2454782724,
-0.2800264657,
0.3323706388,
-0.1393599212,
0.239061296,
0.3740639091,
-0.8117645383,
0.4208844304,
0.3968435526,
0.7938255668,
-0.2120256573,
-0.1720495671,
-1.0447750092,
-0.068369396,
-0.5768864155,
0.8747102618,
-0.2586431205,
-0.1498734504,
-0.1058915257,
-0.2122516334,
0.1106519327,
-0.7724081278,
0.4323441684,
-0.5500876904,
0.2955280542,
-0.6802110672,
-0.4393332303,
0.1773215681,
0.3211108148,
-0.7895721793,
0.9312132597,
-0.0718891248,
-0.7715726495,
0.3966207504,
-0.3724130392,
-0.1512642056,
-0.3242275715,
-0.3033944964,
-0.2431969047,
0.2253738344,
0.4881723821,
0.2413614094,
0.2712639868,
0.002662973,
-0.4284056723,
-0.3290886581,
0.3953856826,
-0.4003454745,
0.6417325735,
0.3720404208,
-0.3238404393,
0.1214475483,
-0.6866089702,
0.2224300653,
0.0089299306,
-0.4477179348,
-0.0137985451,
-0.139129594,
-0.1832861155,
0.2197990566,
0.046205692,
-0.8646685481,
0.0272263195,
-0.4987250268,
-0.0219966285,
0.7453299761,
-0.0358754396,
0.2153816521,
-0.3815167248,
0.3380490541,
0.175877586,
-0.1900533438,
-0.3773423135,
-0.2681597173,
-0.5332651734,
-0.3050236702,
0.5831151009,
0.4272677898,
-0.5296180844,
0.5853781104,
-0.3750859499,
-0.1919274479,
-0.8021212816,
0.0014269387,
0.2533767521,
0.4374321997,
0.45081532,
-0.1741817147,
-0.6301235557,
-0.6493174434,
-0.1871245503,
-0.3116303086,
-0.1721157134,
0.1911490262,
0.3263175488,
0.2564187944,
1.2508103848,
-0.6248379946,
-0.1925896853,
-0.0838460028,
-0.0697477609,
0.1844907999,
0.3157015741,
0.4439893663,
-0.6150355339,
-0.4894003868,
-0.247468099,
-0.8647289276,
0.1257909089,
-0.0504197143,
-0.1482172459,
0.294153899,
0.4845407307,
-0.5134381056,
0.5413082838,
0.4406419992,
-0.2817830741,
0.3903954327,
-0.3115280867,
0.4563230574,
-0.9472468495,
0.1816793829,
-0.2728068233,
-0.5906763673,
-0.2927411795,
0.1278381795,
0.0982044116,
0.3166163862,
-0.2916277945,
0.4389951527,
-0.4307566881,
-0.0575803518,
-0.29914698,
0.2949950993,
0.0281547587,
0.2722915411,
0.1040322334,
0.9506309032,
0.0205394682,
-0.5050412416,
0.3703931868,
0.4646095932,
-0.3156138957,
0.0492471829,
-0.9171897173,
0.3942130506,
-0.4354648292,
0.3294380009,
-1.2152167559,
-0.2645746469,
0.4482186437,
-0.6214205623,
0.0308881383,
0.1574336141,
-0.2990012765,
-0.2410705537,
-0.3621709049,
0.4054442346,
0.5397031903,
-0.8473176956,
0.4807677269,
0.0104025537,
0.0740442351,
-0.8346605301,
-0.6659185886,
-0.1393836439,
0.3790184557,
-0.4213290513,
0.084901765,
-0.4582383633,
-0.3137933612,
0.1712764502,
-0.3440882862,
0.0838394612,
-0.368629843,
-0.0894069746,
0.0939280242,
-0.3839046061,
-0.0624015108,
-0.1648318321,
-0.0676138178,
0.101925768,
-0.0816681162,
0.4496489167,
-0.1465934515,
-0.5150002241,
-0.2443300933,
0.4586089253,
0.3917563856,
-0.4952803254,
0.5065287352,
0.2664178312,
-0.1114510074,
-0.0656054094,
-0.5503605604,
-0.3944271803,
-0.4124062657,
-0.0351228416,
-0.5133679509,
-0.8698775768,
0.5263805389,
0.4650175571,
0.0434934087,
0.3603190482,
0.5568450689,
0.0593837611,
0.9189605117,
0.4298650026,
0.1106126755,
0.0410888866,
-0.0402239822,
0.1661509722,
-0.4850882292,
-0.1682221591,
-0.711342454,
-0.0904477388,
-0.4745632112,
-0.439770937,
0.3172930479,
-0.0515267849,
0.2964840829,
-0.0364982076,
-0.4920850694,
0.6558506489,
0.6779105663,
0.4125187695,
0.4267557561,
0.1402395815,
-0.078895472,
-0.1615555286,
-0.565289557,
-0.3598255217,
1.1985760927,
0.0983153805,
0.7600656152,
0.238658011,
0.9874194264,
0.3926300704,
0.2388607413,
-0.5650326014,
0.4650439322,
0.0443411954,
-0.6860808134,
-0.4235039651,
-0.6062052846,
-0.7955613732,
0.3285081387,
-0.1887037456,
-0.3371903002,
0.2123535573,
0.2662014365,
-0.5886228681,
0.1034397408,
-0.358856529,
0.6170628071,
0.1676674038,
-0.1892437488,
-0.1286107153,
-0.6754477024,
0.4012985528,
0.2611380219,
-0.1664515287,
-0.1353150755,
0.196673274,
0.4566502571,
-0.2713646889,
0.7120914459,
-0.0266200118,
0.0309696402,
0.4984017611,
-0.1305613816,
0.3682417274,
0.2125691921,
-0.2278740853,
-0.0093701314,
-0.0100821443,
-0.5755161047,
-0.9769646525,
0.3756504357,
-0.6247691512,
-0.5868588686,
-0.5828603506,
-0.2310171723,
0.0032614998,
0.1381395459,
0.44854936,
0.7047274709,
-0.3734693527,
0.3878389001,
0.7877060175,
0.1779222637,
0.4966949522,
0.3721809685,
-0.1990020126,
-0.7890179157,
0.6134285927,
-0.0811660662,
0.2434683889,
0.512616694,
0.1945762187,
-0.5399845839,
-0.410518378,
-0.5894446969,
0.3522718549,
-0.7319392562,
-0.3703954518,
-0.7591745853,
-0.2026109248,
-0.828574419,
0.1316299587,
-0.3277263343,
-0.3222593069,
0.0121949092,
-0.3521359563,
-0.0268112253,
0.7425482869,
-0.4457562566,
-0.1760394871,
-0.9169255495,
0.7555085421,
0.2796488106,
0.3440602124,
-0.1470918804,
-0.3085986674,
-0.0763927028,
0.2061770856,
-0.0233868491,
-1.0186139345,
-0.0317192152,
0.1275176108,
0.6412617564,
0.3864981234,
0.6816669106,
0.5502817035,
-0.4289707839,
0.7882826328,
0.0725374147,
-0.7979553342,
0.491096735,
-0.0074395379,
0.368861109,
0.7603926063,
0.2734138966,
-0.1801817715,
-0.6517773271,
-0.5501564741,
-0.4454719424,
0.6101207733,
0.3766040206,
0.1639237404,
-0.5216021538,
0.3600537777,
0.1483682692,
0.1853164136,
-0.6797397733,
-0.1880694777,
-0.4793414474,
-0.4758118689,
-0.0398644321,
-0.328423202,
-0.326494813,
0.0045344499,
0.5534020066,
-0.5080049038,
0.238150537,
0.8871667385,
0.1049233824,
-0.1258478612,
0.2821431458,
0.6976388097,
0.7590575814,
-0.4085631669,
0.1849781275,
-0.0157072898,
-0.461461097,
0.1220957264,
-0.1834325194,
-0.3103055656,
0.2973510325,
0.3848324418,
0.4411739409,
-0.1904926449,
-0.6694273949,
0.7985434532,
-0.2656867206,
-0.2257962078,
-0.065019615,
0.0922834128,
-0.3412017226,
0.1422870159,
0.3026519716,
0.3071897924,
0.3243475854,
-0.5755303502,
0.4661861956,
0.3487717509,
-0.2582145333,
-0.2051029354,
0.6229412556,
0.0292396359,
0.0044645118,
0.8196085691,
-0.1958412081,
-0.2507807612,
0.4358747005,
0.6559218168,
0.8428826332,
-0.1707537323,
0.4205046594,
0.7188872099,
0.4436095059,
-0.2067714036,
0.4827692807,
-0.2333543152,
-0.9268374443,
-0.6430482268,
-0.5463910103,
-0.4749643505,
-0.0991101265,
-1.053588748,
-0.005273663,
-0.292657584,
0.0987636223,
-0.2777270973,
-0.1175823957,
-0.3362980783,
0.4320660532,
-0.0203754213,
1.0829838514,
-0.7104110122,
0.6431441307,
0.3807233572,
-0.4324191511,
-0.8421791792,
0.4429897964,
-0.228609845,
-0.4752182662,
0.3407213688,
0.2149329036,
-0.373867631,
-0.2552337646,
-0.6592999697,
-0.9441464543,
0.7332942486,
0.4963785112,
-0.3043435812,
-0.0302924495,
-0.0729839057,
0.4073065519,
-0.3958506286,
0.4578624368,
0.4659739137,
0.2410438508,
0.2966526151,
-0.6444101334,
0.2661016881,
-0.1837089807,
-0.217337057,
0.0038828372,
-0.5691346526,
0.5024046302,
-0.4905368686,
-0.3208800256,
0.2706962824,
1.3260322809,
0.4705791473,
0.4267709553,
0.5584067702,
0.3329745531,
0.8205414414,
0.0267774947,
0.9122393727,
-0.284021318,
0.2484454513,
1.2984155416,
-0.2803873718,
1.093293786,
0.3738631308,
-0.0481072254,
0.4309321642,
0.318702966,
0.0434034877,
0.623706758,
-0.0673315227,
-0.1408055127,
-0.3051243126,
0.2252453119,
-0.3652625084,
0.6056214571,
-0.1597528458,
0.0243529007,
-0.4722107053,
-0.1713881791,
-0.0923907384,
0.5834767222,
-0.0185788963,
0.8171159625,
-0.1667636186,
-0.9398282766,
0.5673556328,
-0.1358352304,
0.4319183528,
-0.6333616376,
-0.2104746848,
-0.3284007907,
0.1247560158,
-0.223331064,
-0.8072936535,
0.4849737883,
-0.0076722787,
-0.5924001932,
-0.1134455651,
0.5282986164,
-0.5670180917,
-0.2285659164,
0.1127746105,
0.4807683825,
0.2223094106,
-0.0058991006,
-0.2091514021,
0.080001384,
0.0930373669,
-0.1394202262,
0.0015493872,
0.2257546037,
0.3363345563,
0.2346945852,
0.7372989655,
0.0506824255,
0.2260254025,
-0.0556444786,
0.7548474073,
-0.5760006905,
-0.6272283196,
-0.7834184766,
0.4967067838,
-0.3714487255,
-0.3262380958,
0.8844596148,
0.7952077389,
1.0666085482,
-0.2034055889,
0.8480859399,
-0.1371290088,
0.7127199769,
-0.7848303914,
0.3804318309,
-0.29342255,
-0.1170024648,
-0.0940126181,
-0.8235557675,
-0.1525502205,
0.5419300795,
-0.0902023241,
0.0487487614,
0.7646798491,
0.7651689649,
-0.1149664968,
0.0432971716,
0.3851223886,
0.1427667588,
0.2935564518,
0.1498458087,
0.7171405554,
-0.5004128814,
0.7297158241,
-0.1466928273,
-0.3155422807,
-0.1263719797,
-0.8117464781,
-0.8442605734,
-0.4325397015,
-0.2591494918,
-0.8424500823,
-0.0233993493,
0.9453651905,
0.6698664427,
-1.035862565,
-0.2377517223,
0.1451190263,
-0.0023934103,
-0.4976193607,
-0.2096210122,
0.1995679587,
-0.5962799191,
-0.6471048594,
0.5032881498,
0.2565279007,
-0.1008515656,
-0.0972983837,
-0.0908563212,
0.1763298362,
0.3331161439,
0.3953254521,
0.3389844,
-0.807392776,
-0.4210158288,
0.4580538869,
-0.2887361944,
0.4791052341,
1.0220185518,
-0.8161044717,
0.5185490847,
0.7369903922,
0.6704665422,
0.424705714,
0.4603402317,
0.5577461123,
-0.6667016745,
-0.1532791406,
0.2016606033,
0.1447084546,
0.355555743,
-0.4503768384,
0.4648284912,
0.1747609675,
-0.5094268322,
-0.6946702003,
0.2604629695,
-1.0975307226,
-0.1481657475,
0.9197388887,
-0.1886488199,
-0.3588153422,
-0.0072492817,
-0.1677410603,
0.0032253917,
-0.3585663736,
0.9393979311,
0.6256297827,
-0.1961874068,
-0.0479770824,
-0.1946831644,
0.4703586102,
0.2883011699,
-0.7589042187,
0.2022613585,
0.5356065631,
0.3458105624,
0.3893087208,
1.160710454,
-0.1425943971,
0.4283340275,
-0.0095572099,
-0.0303293299,
-0.0137123764,
-0.6705050468,
-0.3040831685,
0.575707674,
-0.1600329429,
-0.442943275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00686v1
|
A Bit of a Problem: Measurement Disparities in Dataset Sizes Across Languages
| 2024-03-01T17:20:11 | 2024-03-01T17:20:11 |
Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How should text dataset sizes be compared across languages? Even for
content-matched (parallel) corpora, UTF-8 encoded text can require a
dramatically different number of bytes for different languages. In our work, we
define the byte premium between two languages as the ratio of bytes used to
encode content-matched text in those languages. We compute byte premiums for
1155 languages, and we use linear regressions to estimate byte premiums for
other languages. We release a tool to obtain byte premiums for any two
languages, enabling comparisons of dataset sizes across languages for more
equitable multilingual model development and data practices.
|
[
-0.4809608459,
-0.3831191063,
0.3264455497,
0.5543215871,
-0.172604546,
0.0956231207,
-0.1313584298,
-0.724716723,
0.3027223051,
0.2259586155,
-0.2679831386,
-0.227028206,
-0.5976907015,
0.3052159846,
0.0033539229,
0.7236620188,
0.0096476106,
0.3988308311,
-0.437276274,
-0.5509742498,
-0.8723521829,
-0.2967933416,
-0.1629190743,
-0.0029465877,
0.5011412501,
0.6734449863,
1.014346242,
0.6231791973,
1.0003135204,
0.2728239,
0.0010057156,
0.261530757,
-0.3259675205,
-0.0885076895,
-0.1679538786,
-0.3657811284,
-0.2894616425,
-0.1301590204,
0.8357648253,
1.051672101,
-0.0623871461,
0.4496637881,
-0.1594615877,
1.0182806253,
-0.8517372608,
0.1000253037,
-0.3253160715,
0.3283029497,
-0.3185587823,
-0.0713629574,
-0.4272708297,
-0.247916609,
-0.2676840425,
-0.5116211176,
0.0479004607,
0.4579108953,
0.625561595,
0.0775397941,
-0.4204527438,
-0.398497045,
-0.4819675684,
0.9484423995,
-0.4440646768,
0.5342231989,
0.4293908775,
0.1309200674,
0.0224942286,
-0.283510983,
-0.5501802564,
-0.1248968393,
-0.3168871701,
-0.2611012161,
-0.3530909419,
-0.1387514323,
0.4544297159,
0.7222607136,
-0.8996416926,
0.1308863759,
-0.535689652,
-0.4032880366,
0.7610031366,
0.3858607709,
0.4753098488,
-0.105935365,
-0.278701365,
-0.2139018476,
-0.7600376606,
-0.0399160311,
0.8757445812,
0.365062505,
-0.2384026945,
0.5435111523,
0.0079094525,
0.8143270016,
-0.1531460583,
-0.1117334887,
0.4542754889,
-0.4785427451,
-0.2865620553,
0.3644986153,
0.602042079,
0.457871139,
0.3100499213,
-0.1743646413,
-0.1654725373,
0.2063385993,
-0.0014628752,
-0.8287885785,
0.0550610758,
0.1661696285,
-0.3757824302,
0.1397051215,
-0.139628619,
-0.8291703463,
-0.5195530057,
-0.2439328283,
0.4373455644,
-0.1387425512,
-0.3885461986,
0.5553609729,
-0.3367580175,
0.1934544146,
-0.3030276597,
-1.0187051296,
0.1914451718,
0.3890466392,
0.7644666433,
-0.0336773731,
-0.162730813,
-0.2743073404,
-0.1476195753,
-0.6132252216,
0.6227918863,
-0.6233979464,
-0.3812513947,
0.2090598643,
-0.0205724165,
-0.0516425893,
-0.6341619492,
0.4892807007,
-0.5251039267,
-0.0336313844,
-0.5502901673,
-0.6778957248,
0.1032025367,
0.1675640345,
-0.9581400156,
0.9846803546,
0.4031205773,
-1.1193015575,
0.6152941585,
-0.0843377262,
-0.3202090859,
0.2483129799,
-0.3964247406,
-0.5708855391,
0.13931638,
-0.0152677232,
0.1700886935,
-0.4681113958,
0.0782046095,
-0.476914525,
-0.6003325582,
0.4235250056,
-0.3041802943,
0.9433875084,
0.3402642012,
0.0275954716,
-0.1421443522,
-0.8781919479,
0.1870539635,
-0.075864993,
-0.2233201116,
-0.5168870687,
-0.0209538862,
0.2564528286,
0.011696388,
0.4918335676,
-0.6815594435,
0.0982142985,
-0.0388310887,
0.4595547318,
0.3083662987,
-0.3719733655,
0.431453228,
-0.3654288352,
0.3048531413,
0.1562485844,
0.0930025056,
-0.1009884328,
-0.1244385168,
-0.5949335694,
-0.4336449802,
0.6171008945,
0.4362850189,
-0.4682449102,
0.3264760971,
-0.4830733538,
-0.3801412284,
-0.7727918625,
-0.0403973386,
0.4393486977,
0.0408165678,
0.3057954609,
-0.4348461032,
-0.5934326649,
-1.3231681585,
-0.0544058233,
-0.1733665019,
-0.0260658134,
0.0415030308,
0.2964937687,
0.0266368743,
0.7363965511,
-0.4017117023,
-0.2397806346,
-0.3548685908,
0.0194443334,
0.0380029567,
0.5256337523,
0.8374986649,
-0.9481359124,
-0.9259209633,
0.1050276086,
-0.631547749,
-0.1085259169,
0.0806969851,
-0.1259065568,
0.1930652559,
0.4118338525,
-0.2431640923,
0.2095110118,
0.8043372035,
-0.5535564423,
0.5433910489,
-0.4116154611,
0.6293287873,
-0.9755139947,
-0.042091798,
0.0810749829,
-0.3150856793,
-0.3579331636,
0.0428970642,
0.3479376733,
0.0343015641,
-0.4399896562,
0.2138560116,
-0.682184577,
-0.6055978537,
-0.0295034032,
0.0335588455,
0.1986175627,
0.0321627371,
-0.1153898612,
1.2808818817,
0.5578408241,
-0.3861408234,
0.2851932347,
0.4527308047,
-0.6222418547,
0.7581331134,
-0.638969183,
-0.1780968159,
-0.1993230283,
0.0377422422,
-0.9629403353,
-0.0689987466,
-0.2315916121,
-0.5537849665,
0.2140633315,
-0.2344542295,
-0.6396806836,
-0.1989859343,
-0.418065697,
0.6289391518,
0.3587520123,
-0.3578569591,
0.0501053706,
0.7313386202,
-0.1351375133,
-0.935367167,
-1.0691198111,
-0.0519831106,
-0.3060258031,
-0.9541122913,
0.382422924,
-0.2634769082,
-0.2664101422,
0.087663278,
-0.0422302224,
-0.3157477081,
-0.1489355266,
-0.1203246787,
0.4109662175,
-0.3977747262,
0.3025975227,
-0.0234001931,
0.0099129593,
-0.0190535448,
-0.3549433649,
0.4146149457,
-0.1934017986,
-0.2965132594,
0.0650847554,
0.8021894097,
0.300655365,
-0.1288922727,
1.0249019861,
0.4246176183,
-0.2074316442,
-0.0246569905,
-0.4961202443,
0.2307019085,
-0.4988442063,
0.2992459834,
-0.4688557684,
-0.8676151633,
0.6741342545,
0.6201182604,
0.021526318,
0.3899304271,
0.4868161082,
0.1105556265,
1.0301097631,
1.0017943382,
-0.2274281532,
0.3168212473,
0.2683021724,
0.1812660843,
-0.3408142924,
-0.1031381339,
-0.8570861816,
-0.3561983109,
-1.0682210922,
-0.3317140043,
0.2671697438,
0.1118216291,
-0.491607964,
0.6185997128,
-0.3777817786,
0.7873649597,
0.4338369071,
-0.1228055432,
0.3091287911,
0.4193941653,
-0.0441387221,
-0.3372702599,
-0.5409261584,
-0.5083533525,
0.8435275555,
0.268340081,
0.6102532744,
0.4597688019,
0.2727334201,
0.6675603986,
-0.2288693041,
-0.7408288717,
0.1927033067,
-0.5371038914,
-0.6965742111,
-0.2899816334,
-0.7517961264,
-1.0110378265,
0.2339648753,
-0.0637193695,
-0.6682114601,
0.3508523107,
0.0634457096,
0.0883098021,
0.1830593497,
-0.9152441025,
1.101955533,
0.2310738713,
-0.2494058311,
-0.3260512948,
-0.5476775765,
-0.1208781824,
0.1469796151,
0.2834143341,
-0.4584614635,
0.1133041382,
0.6652483344,
-0.1011498123,
0.422617197,
-0.010373625,
0.0521778762,
0.3493388891,
0.2270829529,
0.0629486144,
0.004316024,
-0.1232229173,
0.2922857702,
0.4511819184,
-0.9272912741,
-0.1988714039,
0.4507245719,
-0.8122657537,
-0.1013591513,
-0.4316465259,
-0.7453846335,
-0.3368460536,
0.0506851301,
0.2998570204,
0.5798659921,
-0.3066290319,
0.237132743,
0.849583149,
-0.431584537,
0.6674561501,
0.8811674118,
0.0961752683,
-0.0087668626,
0.9673659801,
0.1209002808,
0.4118417203,
0.773524642,
0.032050062,
-0.3774830401,
-0.3220681548,
-0.6164080501,
-0.100904204,
-0.6980268359,
-0.3376841247,
-0.4608741999,
-0.0108154314,
-0.368015945,
-0.1378578544,
-0.4454746842,
-0.2865085602,
0.2120802701,
-0.0601741187,
0.3318437338,
0.592002213,
-0.3407852352,
0.2277614176,
-0.9374688864,
-0.0623213276,
-0.1495024711,
0.3365758955,
-0.1844504029,
-0.5291201472,
-0.4521548152,
0.0144474944,
-0.1037474424,
-0.8384341002,
0.4841925204,
-0.0236033555,
0.5208808184,
-0.019165935,
0.0376406945,
0.4843191206,
-0.6603156328,
0.7134213448,
0.4377247691,
-1.0073267221,
0.0129389344,
-0.0465507209,
0.0406545624,
0.5849338174,
0.7139133215,
-0.9495637417,
-0.137494415,
-0.2657412589,
-0.7597256303,
0.439882189,
0.1431337595,
0.2019371837,
-0.1695195287,
-0.1959734559,
0.3453547359,
0.1420331895,
-0.702350378,
-0.4201519191,
0.0571734123,
-0.488231957,
-0.2606641054,
-0.4000003934,
0.1100596637,
0.0463901088,
0.4213634729,
-0.097868368,
0.3494942188,
-0.0292459689,
-0.3611782789,
0.014555892,
0.5491696,
0.2592211068,
0.6593462229,
-0.0657059401,
0.3943184912,
0.0855399966,
-0.7871869206,
0.2962830961,
0.1505824476,
0.061842937,
0.0521993712,
0.2599067092,
0.9044240713,
-0.0766916052,
-0.7561721802,
0.5501458645,
-0.2142918259,
-0.0513445251,
-0.0830267817,
-0.3591407537,
0.1669004261,
-0.0426910408,
0.0501483083,
-0.4005765021,
0.3814418912,
-0.3591708243,
0.3508272469,
0.075099647,
-0.5689023137,
-0.1116825566,
0.1538480818,
0.1974372268,
-0.0195644461,
0.8467875123,
-0.4415426552,
-0.1048782542,
0.8928224444,
0.4675255418,
0.31738621,
-0.0890694633,
0.4663384855,
0.4012515247,
0.439955622,
-0.1977394819,
0.3203428686,
0.3020790219,
-0.9053575397,
-0.485876143,
-0.6971815228,
-0.2529647648,
-0.0521915741,
-0.8563687801,
0.1552177072,
0.209531486,
-0.0082099373,
0.6281985641,
0.3238936365,
-0.7218008041,
0.0552304238,
0.2572670281,
0.9636427164,
-1.2291909456,
0.605163455,
0.6302378774,
-0.7144735456,
-0.6948916316,
-0.2530100942,
-0.2585812807,
-0.7458263636,
0.5884756446,
0.3353291452,
0.1121739075,
-0.4151958823,
-0.2603043318,
-0.7853499651,
0.7406035066,
0.6179855466,
-0.844972074,
0.4001116157,
0.9045625925,
0.5195243359,
-0.2750793099,
0.4006085694,
0.6565093994,
0.3406831324,
-0.3733837008,
-1.1455459595,
-0.3027908504,
-0.0535043329,
-0.0546461456,
0.549100399,
-0.6338766217,
1.0850698948,
0.157167688,
-0.1343496442,
-0.2671631873,
0.5808017254,
0.034245193,
0.2843657732,
0.4956248403,
0.3112138808,
0.6574040055,
0.0455876067,
1.0329784155,
-0.3309694827,
0.5020595193,
0.915383637,
-0.3384003043,
0.6681224108,
0.490565747,
-0.3975622356,
0.2103390843,
0.7681277394,
0.027793508,
0.4155736864,
0.3810005784,
-0.3307683468,
-0.2221286297,
-0.3125734329,
-0.3431767523,
0.13531138,
0.2789391279,
-0.0549579263,
-0.2299846113,
-0.0231452473,
-0.1338463277,
0.4768842757,
-0.3947532475,
0.5075774193,
-0.0556131229,
-0.5175706148,
0.3764522672,
0.3346691132,
0.5922782421,
-0.420279026,
0.1954912245,
-0.6176641583,
0.3501891494,
-0.1010874733,
-1.1502282619,
0.5824926496,
0.0910130069,
-0.5942460895,
0.1623712182,
0.4823190868,
-0.6188037395,
-0.5367302895,
0.3659570813,
0.4725632071,
0.305886358,
0.1083848774,
-0.6319057941,
0.415756315,
-0.0454686172,
0.1784421951,
0.5975301862,
0.4717718661,
-0.2160521299,
0.4450982511,
0.0562811494,
0.0261552855,
0.245040372,
0.2054426074,
0.5277019739,
-0.4362154901,
-0.6872068048,
-0.7231812477,
0.3519245982,
-0.3329969347,
-0.2407284826,
0.6680925488,
0.9724294543,
1.2657558918,
-0.2171849459,
0.7880899906,
-0.4422067702,
0.3813328147,
-0.3881540596,
0.2918925285,
-0.5633991957,
0.1204895303,
0.1001009122,
-0.9039642811,
0.0043345946,
0.7008512616,
-0.1241291761,
-0.2813674808,
0.6962381601,
0.9613819718,
-0.179429397,
-0.0487186834,
0.5178067088,
-0.2074490041,
0.0884139314,
0.6284456849,
0.6568924189,
-0.5191842914,
0.5655660033,
-0.0995624736,
-0.1782446206,
0.1220015958,
-0.9617509842,
-0.875467062,
-0.6669996381,
-0.3296771646,
-0.3598435521,
0.2291800827,
0.9136232734,
0.6077745557,
-0.8858587146,
-0.4294818342,
0.0695853904,
0.047026962,
-0.2250640988,
-0.1646665335,
0.3130326569,
-0.4445490837,
-0.8172815442,
0.046327848,
0.1023430079,
0.0628874078,
-0.473023802,
0.1737605929,
0.161161989,
0.3302887976,
0.3327737749,
0.129103139,
-0.0325776935,
-0.2736255527,
-0.0505164377,
-0.6403506398,
0.2498030812,
0.9652150273,
-0.2253683507,
0.2827429771,
0.6442260146,
0.6611018777,
0.3849384785,
-0.526705265,
0.4399056733,
-1.2732838392,
0.6233789325,
-0.104985401,
0.3320156932,
0.6391000748,
-0.4471541643,
0.4548864663,
-0.0027384791,
-0.5222498775,
-0.8506167531,
0.4161135554,
-0.953576386,
-0.4298549294,
1.0403131247,
-0.2709774971,
0.0136676896,
0.0384993479,
-0.0894671232,
-0.0884189531,
-0.2236302346,
0.676481545,
0.9553287625,
0.4708321691,
0.2843116522,
-0.7041761279,
0.5989929438,
0.1867336184,
-0.5965809226,
0.2539930046,
0.4758767784,
0.2785564661,
0.123052828,
0.6243699789,
-0.2365708947,
0.1664254814,
0.6904634237,
0.2695372701,
0.1578619033,
-0.3642651141,
-0.0922968015,
-0.0592851043,
-0.0740800574,
-0.3408130109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00662v1
|
Modeling the Quality of Dialogical Explanations
| 2024-03-01T16:49:55 | 2024-03-01T16:49:55 |
Milad Alshomary, Felix Lange, Meisam Booshehri, Meghdut Sengupta, Philipp Cimiano, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Explanations are pervasive in our lives. Mostly, they occur in dialogical
form where an {\em explainer} discusses a concept or phenomenon of interest
with an {\em explainee}. Leaving the explainee with a clear understanding is
not straightforward due to the knowledge gap between the two participants.
Previous research looked at the interaction of explanation moves, dialogue
acts, and topics in successful dialogues with expert explainers. However,
daily-life explanations often fail, raising the question of what makes a
dialogue successful. In this work, we study explanation dialogues in terms of
the interactions between the explainer and explainee and how they correlate
with the quality of explanations in terms of a successful understanding on the
explainee's side. In particular, we first construct a corpus of 399 dialogues
from the Reddit forum {\em Explain Like I am Five} and annotate it for
interaction flows and explanation quality. We then analyze the interaction
flows, comparing them to those appearing in expert dialogues. Finally, we
encode the interaction flows using two language models that can handle long
inputs, and we provide empirical evidence for the effectiveness boost gained
through the encoding in predicting the success of explanation dialogues.
|
[
-0.5315793157,
-0.9506841898,
0.8804484606,
0.0907722116,
-0.4073723555,
-0.0920074582,
-0.0949438065,
-0.4882292449,
0.1383818388,
0.1862528324,
-0.8442088366,
-0.2266897261,
-0.4968675673,
0.2706923783,
-0.415789783,
0.7714906931,
0.0265824776,
0.2855378091,
-0.4951479435,
0.0121518383,
-0.5518273711,
-0.3694555461,
-0.7722260952,
-0.5071083307,
0.6412071586,
0.3193463683,
0.8087590337,
0.5749419928,
0.2389474362,
0.3764963448,
-0.2867168784,
0.1034175903,
-0.8424383402,
0.2191520333,
-0.236685127,
-0.4119957089,
-0.2666450441,
0.055373881,
0.2650875151,
0.9990907907,
-0.1328002512,
-0.0543630309,
0.0024256459,
0.2479915321,
-0.162047103,
0.129855141,
-0.3345434964,
-0.032321196,
0.3021975756,
-0.4675727487,
-0.3675101101,
-0.3735524714,
0.1517215371,
-0.6744722128,
0.3653247952,
-0.1294553578,
1.0385502577,
0.1705380529,
-0.0802444294,
-0.4979779422,
-0.7696948647,
0.5631966591,
-0.805077076,
0.1735512018,
0.3960033655,
0.5729359388,
-0.3813961446,
-0.5845927596,
-0.8214546442,
0.2248552293,
-0.2732656598,
0.2700517476,
-0.1119105294,
0.1688295156,
0.0582551919,
0.284016639,
-0.357989639,
-0.0020885074,
-0.5578877926,
-0.2106329054,
0.637586832,
0.1900431961,
0.3273966312,
-0.2813564539,
-0.277754575,
0.2456597984,
-0.2866632342,
0.3234559298,
0.3517339528,
-0.3098330498,
-0.0437125117,
0.3162283599,
-0.0385460556,
0.7362874746,
0.4333779216,
-0.2072264403,
-0.2227577269,
-0.7177346945,
-0.1323427111,
-0.3276734054,
0.7138404846,
0.6530489326,
0.4946441054,
-0.0158742443,
0.1286934465,
-0.2113683373,
0.2724024653,
-0.8199009895,
-0.1509561837,
0.5458233356,
-0.9310247302,
-0.308917731,
-0.2181097716,
-0.7278099656,
-0.4384040833,
-0.3495528698,
0.5161320567,
-0.4777124822,
-0.4478719831,
0.1472337842,
-0.2163440585,
-0.0943277329,
0.5009690523,
-0.9528665543,
0.3501476943,
0.5931159854,
0.4549753666,
0.1390191913,
-0.1982651651,
-0.3850928545,
-0.090277642,
-0.2151449025,
0.8637923002,
-0.5704012513,
-0.2913928926,
-0.0001399907,
-0.0140820034,
-0.2788854241,
-0.438020885,
0.4777956605,
-0.543160677,
0.4196721017,
0.0183179416,
-0.9057132602,
-0.6443169117,
-0.0308513101,
-0.4731366038,
0.152368784,
-0.1624293178,
-0.4376942515,
0.1900500655,
-0.9313623905,
-0.0495657362,
0.0629759505,
-0.0376204066,
-0.0622338839,
0.1974034458,
0.2376587987,
0.388164252,
-0.0617749356,
0.2683999836,
-0.1895405948,
-0.4367362559,
0.9423373342,
-0.583060205,
0.6832459569,
0.2761817873,
-0.0775895342,
0.0335513391,
-0.3996310532,
-0.0657266304,
-0.0249124914,
0.0842047483,
-0.1391171515,
0.0592019744,
-0.5233815908,
0.1998974383,
0.1927245855,
-0.3276785612,
-0.1530358195,
-0.4184171855,
0.7938783169,
0.3130691648,
0.5072089434,
0.3174107969,
-0.1542683244,
0.6346549392,
0.1189791262,
0.4262721837,
-0.5755528212,
-0.4614203274,
-0.6661689878,
0.0781999975,
0.3941762745,
0.0984741971,
-0.4379579425,
-0.1208251938,
-0.2905034125,
-0.1288524717,
-0.7339566946,
0.1259292662,
0.4132390916,
0.3399414122,
0.2147122622,
-0.1745170653,
-0.2079857439,
-0.8005692363,
-0.4306735098,
-0.2731390893,
-0.1614134014,
0.2426784486,
0.2801337242,
-0.0572353341,
1.1661150455,
-0.1174134016,
0.3831899762,
-0.5058778524,
0.5389025807,
0.2784536481,
0.3287291527,
0.4576024115,
-0.8269938231,
-0.2096809596,
-0.2771520317,
-0.736610651,
-0.0353005789,
-0.2805334628,
-0.2176501304,
0.0251396634,
0.4655196667,
-0.6257952452,
0.4280572236,
0.4367368817,
-0.4525391757,
0.5874854326,
-0.2210799456,
0.3377175033,
-0.8894930482,
-0.2606666684,
-0.0594076179,
-0.3601756096,
-0.8635072112,
-0.0480078347,
-0.3295672238,
-0.1834566593,
-0.2988085151,
0.4979184866,
-0.3850743473,
0.0465368852,
-0.0774093047,
0.2777014673,
0.0853241459,
0.5981938839,
0.0462203287,
0.5926067829,
0.2933939397,
-0.5699368119,
0.0666465163,
0.1921825409,
-0.005058107,
0.4813134372,
-0.9648247361,
0.0576712899,
-0.1436828673,
0.2393440306,
-1.2215754986,
-0.5831421614,
0.297290802,
-1.0156162977,
-0.1170938909,
-0.4407166541,
-0.2737379372,
-0.3904412687,
-0.0017395908,
0.3278028965,
0.495298326,
-0.4990013242,
0.7417982817,
0.0951647013,
-0.2279886454,
-0.2628296018,
-0.2979334295,
-0.1173160672,
-0.4047592282,
-0.9031934142,
0.05093069,
-0.3609907925,
-0.3807244599,
0.0569770001,
-0.2146535516,
-0.5237820148,
0.1741390824,
0.3768452108,
-0.066683799,
-0.3013857901,
0.2652763426,
0.0735114887,
-0.2736999393,
0.5183674693,
0.102309972,
0.4740620255,
0.138965115,
-0.5069639683,
-0.9536020756,
0.4480803609,
0.8633867502,
-0.064244844,
1.1396259069,
0.5846605897,
-0.1732454747,
0.0833714083,
-0.5180897713,
-0.5719841719,
-0.4449704587,
-0.0126763303,
-0.737007618,
-0.6564374566,
0.8418553472,
-0.0004944669,
0.1880281568,
0.4591290057,
0.2277870327,
-0.4948739409,
1.4602487087,
0.3404710591,
0.4877476692,
0.3040782511,
-0.1302940547,
0.7391334176,
-0.4576950669,
-0.329100877,
-0.3852187395,
-0.0551865213,
-0.4151584208,
-0.4490148127,
0.237477079,
0.6183812022,
0.0672730058,
0.2224965245,
-0.1468942463,
0.535256803,
0.3925090432,
-0.0761537179,
0.3771317601,
0.0988209546,
0.1533335447,
-0.0736746714,
-1.0248992443,
-0.6587466002,
0.5410941243,
0.8214152455,
0.8334674239,
0.1776442081,
0.6883645058,
0.136735037,
0.065966472,
-0.5491476059,
0.4399615526,
0.0995856896,
-0.3969779313,
-0.5170679092,
-0.4081162512,
-1.0139381886,
0.202418074,
-0.2407977432,
-0.7012297511,
0.1178394482,
0.3961139023,
-0.5745212436,
-0.2539514899,
-0.9190217257,
1.1257309914,
-0.0716772154,
-0.4725443423,
-0.6528872252,
-0.7494570613,
0.3025053442,
0.4412153065,
0.4721774161,
-0.0225599539,
0.6343568563,
0.6734944582,
-0.5968046784,
0.7706592679,
-0.1538292766,
0.046930939,
0.3726095557,
0.2496134788,
0.1232363284,
0.2796019912,
-0.0103757307,
0.158104673,
-0.0019453849,
-0.4825228751,
-1.1107157469,
0.3170570731,
-0.6729406714,
-0.6464911699,
0.2553718388,
-0.2713731825,
0.1746766269,
-0.2831407487,
0.2850372493,
0.7995942235,
0.060235925,
-0.1359671652,
0.7926725149,
-0.2363749444,
0.2472542077,
0.6316036582,
0.0042739385,
-0.1245091632,
0.9465075731,
-0.0980519131,
0.5662133098,
0.0221267454,
0.192898199,
-0.4461217523,
-0.6314325929,
-0.6291643977,
0.4883272648,
-0.8750340343,
0.1883917153,
-0.7993943095,
-0.3680653572,
-0.1853281558,
-0.229833737,
-0.0845035166,
-0.5127825737,
-0.1478200108,
-0.1087983772,
0.3249643743,
0.9138545394,
-0.0856506303,
0.1851065755,
-0.6270889044,
0.2085200101,
0.583994329,
0.266287297,
0.3840972483,
-0.6398919821,
-0.3624740243,
0.4123229384,
-0.1352401376,
-1.1413788795,
0.2872484624,
0.0720063895,
0.6726359725,
0.8454611897,
-0.2140884548,
0.8201187849,
-0.198595807,
1.0706788301,
0.1528956145,
-0.9986326694,
0.5940431952,
-0.3686900437,
0.3109083772,
0.3485998213,
0.331867516,
-0.6979882121,
-0.7093233466,
-0.7406589985,
-0.7597928047,
0.493442893,
0.462924391,
0.10022825,
0.0356095023,
0.567938745,
0.4069747329,
0.1258053929,
-0.67578125,
-0.1881483495,
-0.4131934047,
-0.3124466538,
0.2444930971,
-0.6078179479,
-0.3474516571,
0.0310978591,
0.5624222755,
0.0002751639,
0.6070045829,
0.1131756604,
-0.2670139372,
-0.1633457541,
0.3119335771,
0.9748073816,
1.0999723673,
-0.0421174504,
0.2953666747,
-0.1560723186,
-0.0561030582,
-0.2355819196,
0.0566284023,
0.3352428079,
0.3410795927,
0.7639833093,
0.7527091503,
0.0790079087,
-0.5563064218,
0.3404709995,
-0.3010187745,
-0.1487034559,
-0.1714725345,
0.2284267992,
0.3310062289,
0.1196875349,
0.3063847125,
-0.2676957846,
0.3066516519,
-0.7318133712,
-0.0755511224,
0.2364842892,
-0.4199073613,
-0.535892725,
0.6441375613,
0.8012289405,
-0.5557689071,
0.5020565391,
-0.2548416257,
-0.7016075253,
0.6866119504,
0.2785135806,
0.4825512767,
-0.0212063398,
0.452524662,
0.5458829403,
-0.1908893585,
0.2426999211,
-0.0332121402,
-0.2283688486,
-0.7367355824,
-0.8078716397,
-0.4984888136,
-0.5826824307,
0.1423569322,
-0.5602140427,
-0.2050247788,
0.2005181611,
0.1293005198,
0.4995475411,
-0.2635893226,
-0.5956088901,
-0.0050295913,
-0.1879224032,
0.8649744987,
-0.9613355398,
0.088382341,
0.4531688392,
-0.6812405586,
-0.8324435353,
0.0758868232,
-0.0630374998,
-0.6910400987,
0.5505129099,
0.1868552864,
-0.2959268987,
-0.1830404699,
-0.5928786993,
-0.5409203172,
0.6559525728,
0.1064455584,
-0.408451736,
0.1906605065,
-0.0178131517,
0.9248746037,
-0.4929250777,
0.7807592154,
0.5585669875,
0.5355037451,
0.0478713997,
-0.9424758554,
-0.1491489708,
-0.3091038764,
-0.1081112698,
-0.0056862207,
-0.3713237941,
0.3844852448,
-0.2688906491,
-0.1875641495,
0.2028007507,
0.6032915711,
-0.021009922,
0.552890718,
0.5714375377,
0.0989819095,
0.4624673128,
-0.1800032109,
1.060872674,
-0.4284211695,
0.4070190787,
0.8883066773,
0.4071527123,
0.5331762433,
0.4692385197,
0.1190772504,
0.9976329207,
1.1462702751,
0.4827990234,
0.2979023457,
0.0535611361,
-0.1676504314,
-0.6321401596,
-0.1526438147,
-0.1737234592,
0.265738219,
0.5106796026,
-0.6597402692,
-0.0405473933,
0.0921810344,
-0.0637673438,
0.1258596629,
-0.2152720988,
0.9857640266,
-0.1120835915,
-0.9151918292,
0.7678691745,
-0.3290557265,
0.0207280666,
-0.1799754202,
-0.3101028502,
-0.4960810244,
-0.1104243919,
-0.2385063767,
-1.0143847466,
0.0915229619,
-0.1094074696,
-0.4595993757,
-0.3609136045,
0.5540372133,
-0.7360383868,
-0.0984024554,
0.0958966166,
0.6398530006,
0.8370193839,
0.3943307698,
-0.4994411767,
-0.0168198384,
-0.1006707102,
-0.0206063353,
-0.1241192743,
0.6267638206,
0.0161052812,
0.7680463195,
0.3527394831,
-0.3743535578,
-0.1040695757,
0.4393302202,
0.6082886457,
-0.4961806536,
-0.3623606861,
-0.7453553677,
0.7805142999,
-0.3608785868,
-0.1899374872,
0.4743014872,
0.1724032313,
0.379152447,
-0.1177492291,
0.4277832508,
0.1555300504,
0.7065662146,
-0.5792563558,
0.5267642736,
-0.4252901375,
0.2582254708,
0.1851508468,
-0.6864245534,
0.2692882717,
0.7535713315,
-0.0797589794,
0.0662722066,
0.7627794743,
0.6243060827,
-0.1826726049,
0.2606022954,
0.2372327596,
0.7294777632,
0.1749255955,
0.3484191,
0.9698734879,
-0.0132312858,
0.5178678632,
0.0061228313,
-0.0798199549,
-0.5866405964,
-0.6131743193,
-1.0769585371,
-0.4889362156,
-0.3395507038,
-0.2485649735,
0.3053128719,
0.6145935059,
0.9642183781,
-0.5449159145,
-0.0539025739,
-0.3817175031,
0.5409191847,
-0.4607296884,
-0.2810001969,
-0.0072828066,
-0.3344732225,
-0.7920113802,
0.2939748466,
0.1551018953,
-0.0089880954,
-0.4833876491,
-0.1592199802,
0.3428039551,
0.4189188182,
0.4692615271,
0.1057084873,
-0.9719457626,
-0.3677628636,
0.0644055605,
0.280759424,
0.0436935723,
0.7832617164,
-0.675175488,
0.7965165377,
0.4869148731,
0.3228188455,
0.4486947954,
0.3482986987,
1.1094374657,
-0.1583471745,
-0.4466555417,
-0.1010363474,
0.1017892957,
0.2767352164,
-0.3092044294,
0.4810689986,
-0.0238802154,
-0.6557548046,
-0.5204423666,
0.2632335424,
-0.7982473373,
-0.3621026874,
1.0689115524,
-0.3870207667,
-0.031783767,
-0.3749715388,
-0.2772230208,
0.2534582615,
-0.5285791755,
1.0283491611,
1.0864839554,
-0.705550313,
-0.3786392808,
-0.6512150764,
0.5950229764,
0.5072844625,
-0.7614126205,
0.037752185,
0.4219011962,
0.3773803413,
0.3276942372,
0.427862525,
0.1089091375,
0.7656110525,
-0.1667134315,
-0.2784615755,
0.0133385211,
-0.1360233426,
-0.4818867147,
0.1926575601,
0.2006626725,
-0.2045577317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00632v1
|
Metamorpheus: Interactive, Affective, and Creative Dream Narration Through Metaphorical Visual Storytelling
| 2024-03-01T16:09:32 | 2024-03-01T16:09:32 |
Qian Wan, Xin Feng, Yining Bei, Zhiqi Gao, Zhicong Lu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Human emotions are essentially molded by lived experiences, from which we
construct personalised meaning. The engagement in such meaning-making process
has been practiced as an intervention in various psychotherapies to promote
wellness. Nevertheless, to support recollecting and recounting lived
experiences in everyday life remains under explored in HCI. It also remains
unknown how technologies such as generative AI models can facilitate the
meaning making process, and ultimately support affective mindfulness. In this
paper we present Metamorpheus, an affective interface that engages users in a
creative visual storytelling of emotional experiences during dreams.
Metamorpheus arranges the storyline based on a dream's emotional arc, and
provokes self-reflection through the creation of metaphorical images and text
depictions. The system provides metaphor suggestions, and generates visual
metaphors and text depictions using generative AI models, while users can apply
generations to recolour and re-arrange the interface to be visually affective.
Our experience-centred evaluation manifests that, by interacting with
Metamorpheus, users can recall their dreams in vivid detail, through which they
relive and reflect upon their experiences in a meaningful way.
|
[
-0.3805231452,
-0.3932238519,
0.4980663657,
0.2447672784,
-0.6563729048,
-0.0351297222,
0.0507674627,
-0.6333357692,
1.1279258728,
0.3030803502,
-0.8895557523,
-0.2747843266,
-0.2714013457,
0.0944445953,
-0.1165628433,
0.7145360112,
-0.2421995103,
-0.4061219692,
-0.1985881478,
-0.3335010707,
-0.7139415741,
-0.2074300647,
-0.3390228748,
-0.0840544477,
0.6745295525,
0.1740949154,
1.0496424437,
0.16883789,
0.2783297598,
0.2677791119,
0.4453995526,
0.2825629413,
-0.2415637225,
0.5084682107,
0.0049265386,
-0.3984111547,
-0.1769649386,
0.1677578241,
0.4351438284,
0.2378272712,
-0.4060072601,
0.2562948763,
0.2530417144,
0.6018099189,
-0.8966706395,
0.1298703849,
-0.0291152373,
0.6890957952,
-0.0532856695,
-0.3473692834,
-0.1519882977,
-0.3751074672,
-0.1611703634,
-0.7567512989,
-0.1752407998,
0.1472534984,
0.5252534151,
0.476890564,
-0.3682252169,
-0.4098750949,
-0.8751268387,
0.4341450632,
-0.4629143178,
0.4268849194,
-0.0267650541,
0.4947502911,
0.2427078784,
-0.6991007328,
-1.0065302849,
-0.1285417676,
-0.217945978,
0.4016548991,
-0.2680318952,
0.1320754886,
0.0822374523,
0.4039922357,
-0.5961499214,
-0.2956725061,
-0.2788418233,
-0.0882196873,
0.4785629809,
0.7090963721,
0.7811876535,
-0.4733807445,
-0.1972776949,
-0.2209714651,
-0.3024116158,
-0.1866919249,
0.2282927483,
-0.0046589305,
-0.2787158489,
0.7676695585,
0.2545286417,
0.7357240319,
-0.2851426899,
-0.225190863,
0.3642067015,
0.3679763079,
-0.4038348198,
0.0074933707,
0.7432706952,
0.7929728031,
-0.0858317912,
-0.163822338,
-0.0441660546,
0.2309410721,
0.712729454,
-0.7672028542,
0.0374524035,
0.2795405388,
-0.9310489297,
-0.2934895754,
0.0353476219,
-1.1381390095,
-0.610070467,
-0.4610985518,
0.4848705232,
-0.6475912333,
-0.4709813297,
-0.0349716544,
-0.4158669114,
0.0397924967,
0.3249643445,
-0.8609004021,
-0.1196357235,
0.4317210913,
0.7323949337,
0.0220543817,
-0.3849161863,
-0.0301306043,
0.4667300284,
-0.1169845462,
0.4458440542,
-0.8453353643,
-0.5917758942,
0.1090147942,
-0.2659655809,
-0.1148371994,
-0.3609893322,
0.553312242,
-0.0425499305,
0.403340131,
0.0394853093,
-0.3239859641,
-0.2791397572,
0.2913092673,
-0.6885579228,
0.3283250034,
0.0166795962,
-0.7562128305,
0.1400052011,
-0.929580152,
-0.2973668277,
0.4044076502,
-0.486202389,
-0.0216539148,
0.5252129436,
-0.1995549649,
0.2597844303,
-0.0479747131,
-0.2214735448,
-0.0068417648,
-0.3974476159,
0.1958101541,
-0.3580868542,
0.351869911,
0.6234273314,
-0.5205391645,
0.2546127439,
-0.4567598104,
-0.0271317232,
0.1748944521,
0.0508134477,
-0.3680393696,
-0.1422932893,
0.2777528167,
0.3162579834,
-0.1356072724,
-0.5549429059,
0.1970028579,
-0.0605227835,
0.3877244294,
0.4112903178,
-0.1940341294,
0.1204767227,
-0.5177727938,
1.0670928955,
-0.0127544804,
0.2125393599,
-0.5196459889,
-0.4400073588,
-0.6694435477,
-0.1480861455,
-0.260055691,
0.3261618912,
-0.9824476242,
-0.2177005261,
-0.2107478231,
-0.5132982135,
-0.8420693874,
-0.1859975308,
0.1103141978,
0.3451660573,
0.2877670228,
-0.0866556987,
-0.5018299818,
-0.8888756633,
-0.3058459759,
-0.2524032295,
-0.3016732931,
0.5813071728,
0.3276120722,
-0.707382977,
0.7150371671,
-0.6556580067,
-0.3566344976,
-0.1852090061,
0.5665231347,
0.0576065183,
0.4871468842,
0.6670216322,
-0.9161942005,
-0.1310091466,
-0.2719829977,
-1.0713187456,
0.1230612323,
-0.5350552797,
-0.0568775348,
0.1039750203,
-0.0271888468,
-1.0107500553,
0.4772208631,
0.6228650808,
-0.6540626884,
0.6360347271,
-0.3083561659,
0.7244873047,
-1.0999295712,
0.3074002862,
-0.3842128813,
0.0837918669,
-0.2023684978,
0.215621084,
-0.2240973711,
-0.6072115898,
-0.5423419476,
0.5930489302,
-0.3746594191,
0.0040069064,
-0.3060765862,
-0.0103534162,
0.0046933452,
0.4726668596,
0.3566765487,
0.3397701383,
0.4019375145,
-0.1322523355,
0.6276629567,
0.3218231797,
-0.2245995104,
0.7289922833,
-0.2024956197,
0.2700681388,
-0.2912989855,
0.224594757,
-0.8478288054,
-0.1869902015,
0.6374154091,
-0.2819291651,
0.0695047006,
0.4413214326,
-0.4253978431,
-0.5364589691,
-0.1497595757,
0.658909142,
0.6315143108,
-0.4328831732,
1.4179253578,
0.1730458438,
-0.0428263731,
-0.1745932251,
-0.6772142053,
0.5171246529,
-0.5666912198,
-0.4699896276,
0.4170714319,
-0.3523750603,
-0.1644790471,
0.142354697,
0.2241656035,
0.1752516031,
-0.2892524302,
0.9959638119,
0.1523716599,
0.111103639,
0.2061030269,
0.2765535414,
-0.1418452263,
0.3262291253,
-0.0485226586,
0.3286231756,
-0.2463512868,
-0.4188388288,
-0.7039444447,
0.7097183466,
1.0691947937,
-0.0118434057,
0.600075841,
0.7252421379,
-0.5750513077,
0.0483089089,
-0.69306463,
0.0050624604,
-0.3913207054,
-0.2320266664,
-0.6051662564,
-0.6219322085,
0.3561282456,
-0.0681699589,
0.1030430347,
0.314669013,
0.3863260448,
-0.6664162874,
0.7095806599,
0.4615430832,
0.1463607401,
0.412938714,
-0.1508851945,
-0.0450827219,
-0.8499788642,
-0.4083890617,
0.0999616459,
-0.8750160336,
-0.2718264461,
-0.5636042356,
0.3973332942,
-0.3439075649,
-0.0248695314,
-0.0308500081,
-0.6164770722,
0.1222149953,
0.5686885715,
0.340893656,
0.1854669303,
-0.2123993486,
-0.0965152234,
-0.4243486822,
-0.2143895179,
-0.6001976728,
0.5812563896,
0.0518874228,
0.7440078259,
0.0345096514,
0.7690527439,
0.5606907606,
0.6270429492,
-0.5330960155,
0.5634514093,
0.3372507691,
-0.4383177161,
-0.2242900133,
-0.123802416,
-0.8687130213,
0.1992851198,
-0.5169938207,
-0.6556243896,
0.243105635,
0.3361308277,
-0.5431673527,
0.5171049237,
-0.3580960333,
0.8378453851,
-0.3585746288,
-0.1997516155,
-0.9081953168,
-0.6073620915,
0.260987252,
0.3796762526,
0.1708570421,
0.1689187735,
-0.0539725907,
0.5713645816,
-0.1971505284,
0.8780667186,
-0.1008824408,
0.1054866761,
0.5483141541,
0.6859728694,
0.1212989837,
-0.153176561,
-0.0455712527,
0.005989647,
-0.0288101789,
-0.1892200708,
-0.7058396935,
0.6083766222,
-0.4987677038,
-0.6070429087,
-0.2794907391,
-0.5207930207,
0.0380364023,
0.0207714438,
0.130577147,
0.162866652,
-0.6309570074,
0.0048066294,
0.3128660619,
-0.4235993624,
0.6199860573,
0.2000691742,
-0.481965363,
-0.5670413375,
0.7756121159,
-0.0644098446,
-0.3403942585,
0.3982310593,
0.2907466888,
-0.0093809981,
0.0252003912,
-0.4231534898,
0.1723946631,
-0.4517679811,
-0.1699250191,
-0.7231181264,
-0.0308467038,
-0.02864483,
-0.328335315,
-0.2018653899,
-0.3156467378,
-0.1651093215,
-0.4408047497,
-0.0382517911,
0.5085480213,
-0.3256546855,
-0.1338437498,
-0.8940529227,
0.6735213995,
0.8535836339,
0.3245948255,
0.270783931,
0.0661910772,
-0.2866058946,
0.2233567089,
-0.444534719,
-1.0326932669,
0.592250824,
0.1108560562,
0.3531296551,
0.6894021034,
0.0740020126,
0.6218791604,
-0.2750981748,
0.8110899329,
0.5233897567,
-0.857981801,
0.9379647374,
-0.3534408212,
0.3398338854,
0.2962452769,
0.3577153087,
-1.0025132895,
-0.1956615597,
-0.6586334109,
-0.5595803261,
0.2623001635,
0.4434311986,
0.4694411457,
-0.0812790543,
0.6819016933,
0.355070442,
0.4548769593,
-0.863150239,
-0.1582517773,
-0.6653416753,
-0.4173307717,
-0.060064882,
-0.5871938467,
-0.1735748798,
-0.1788171977,
0.2456537336,
-0.1143731251,
0.5491406322,
0.1641300321,
-0.0062767426,
-0.3827439249,
0.0184778608,
0.4328512549,
0.4700837433,
-0.1172572225,
0.2997355759,
0.0326436274,
-0.3723782897,
-0.046252314,
-0.0934217572,
0.1340384781,
0.143520534,
0.3775711358,
0.8566672802,
0.1455523074,
-0.847714901,
0.1800352633,
-0.1885095388,
0.033838205,
-0.3945610821,
0.1123759672,
0.2725580037,
0.5039260983,
0.3184995651,
-0.0154570956,
0.5153233409,
-0.7291770577,
-0.132019937,
0.1361643523,
-0.6501437426,
-0.4021186531,
1.0104483366,
0.5696184039,
-0.658347249,
0.9744896293,
0.1489947289,
-0.2367290705,
0.4796250761,
0.5233339071,
1.3418233395,
-0.5612514019,
0.4798894525,
0.3265892565,
0.1440850794,
0.5740988851,
0.5285535455,
-0.48466447,
-0.6537206173,
0.1402271092,
-0.621855557,
-0.5580106378,
-0.2092354,
-0.6995973587,
0.0067326073,
-0.0739652142,
-0.037115328,
-0.2668924332,
-0.6195052266,
-0.6864728332,
0.4963458478,
0.8557633162,
0.6285387874,
-1.0399255753,
0.4115263224,
0.7356187701,
-0.3786795437,
-0.4761472642,
0.0764834508,
0.0693318471,
-0.5389130712,
0.4910981953,
0.5305668712,
-0.2383976877,
-0.1064251661,
-0.1468567401,
-0.391633898,
1.2507933378,
0.3890781105,
-0.587351501,
-0.0850723237,
0.3345329463,
0.7253088355,
-0.6575509906,
0.4296729863,
0.286074847,
0.5690836906,
0.2720729709,
-0.5116798282,
0.1487135142,
-0.4528893232,
0.0089628026,
0.0968870297,
-0.7585768104,
0.2820402384,
-0.4921967685,
-0.3126651347,
-0.1097910777,
0.895072937,
0.2119292617,
0.5500109196,
0.7222880721,
0.8010674119,
0.4755428731,
0.0512804575,
1.1114797592,
-0.2915977836,
-0.016404761,
1.0271780491,
0.1041376516,
0.6488533616,
0.698982358,
0.063648589,
0.8100714684,
0.6723207235,
0.2189496756,
0.4540578425,
0.1838324517,
-0.413762778,
-0.2983738482,
-0.1033460796,
-0.2845377326,
0.3073119521,
0.2053707987,
-0.2838002145,
0.0554682314,
0.8194139004,
-0.2661859989,
-0.0365051515,
-0.1311303228,
0.6765595078,
0.202190727,
-0.6090222597,
-0.0276155472,
-0.5239396095,
0.2964432538,
-0.4191366434,
-0.5152014494,
-0.3217647076,
-0.2005428076,
-0.1961734295,
-0.8823900223,
0.6294237971,
-0.2763589621,
0.0095394021,
-0.641944766,
0.5231715441,
-0.3025079966,
-0.4780957997,
0.1802227199,
0.3155349791,
0.1476018429,
-0.2545291483,
-0.6587227583,
0.247899279,
-0.1055271998,
-0.2349550426,
-0.0711605176,
0.4729150832,
0.2935542464,
0.9430776834,
0.0940928608,
-0.260527283,
-0.393094182,
0.0128518622,
0.6695669293,
-0.9988290668,
-0.7719938755,
-0.7658509016,
0.8466566205,
0.209240213,
-0.3355886936,
0.4023471773,
0.5050629973,
0.1151379645,
-0.3944054246,
0.5944204926,
-0.4126033485,
-0.0112046376,
-0.2233518809,
0.6955577731,
-0.6608800888,
-0.2606396675,
-0.5209282041,
-1.073179841,
-0.1276119351,
0.4223242402,
0.2129592001,
-0.1892468184,
0.5299451947,
0.1508258283,
0.0834147409,
0.158123374,
0.4292367697,
0.2986890674,
0.2106475234,
0.4638530612,
1.1800880432,
-0.0434041061,
0.2121017724,
-0.1123767272,
-0.3053044677,
-0.3321140409,
-0.8648491502,
-0.5696102977,
-0.895155251,
-0.4380229414,
-0.1792981923,
0.0979074612,
0.983080864,
0.4730706215,
-0.3860166073,
-0.228314057,
-0.0395146012,
0.0919796154,
-0.3463090062,
-0.2651756108,
0.2682684958,
0.0040882258,
-0.6877470613,
0.2123187333,
0.6466837525,
0.2910245955,
-0.4091754556,
-0.1190600544,
0.4353963733,
0.1128949076,
0.5645836592,
0.1872394681,
-0.6354385018,
-0.2726437449,
-0.5624448657,
-0.0013635185,
0.0148442406,
1.0378733873,
-1.080254674,
0.8533663154,
0.272611618,
0.2289952934,
0.8343367577,
-0.2425632328,
0.78619349,
0.0018995266,
0.1426944733,
0.4585524797,
0.3659712374,
0.0220294204,
-0.4470655918,
0.5847840905,
0.1298023909,
-0.1295157671,
-0.5660706758,
0.1480503529,
-1.0783532858,
-0.4094181955,
0.7384639978,
-0.0115957912,
-0.0228799228,
0.5337770581,
-0.7220872641,
0.1075679138,
0.1570634842,
1.2325794697,
0.5644458532,
-0.5809491873,
-0.3381172419,
-0.2242000252,
0.3594072461,
0.2827811539,
-0.8186354637,
-0.1051438451,
0.7522462606,
-0.0534507409,
0.2424358726,
0.342705369,
0.2042057663,
0.2463933527,
0.2337220311,
0.5228950381,
-0.2393515557,
-0.2261282206,
0.03557349,
0.3737371862,
-0.3562600613,
-0.4162731767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00896v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00896v2
|
DiaHalu: A Dialogue-level Hallucination Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T15:38:55 | 2024-06-17T15:11:20 |
Kedi Chen, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Yishen He, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Since large language models (LLMs) achieve significant success in recent
years, the hallucination issue remains a challenge, numerous benchmarks are
proposed to detect the hallucination. Nevertheless, some of these benchmarks
are not naturally generated by LLMs but are intentionally induced. Also, many
merely focus on the factuality hallucination while ignoring the faithfulness
hallucination. Additionally, although dialogue pattern is more widely utilized
in the era of LLMs, current benchmarks only concentrate on sentence-level and
passage-level hallucination. In this study, we propose DiaHalu, the first
dialogue-level hallucination evaluation benchmark to our knowledge. Initially,
we integrate the collected topics into system prompts and facilitate a dialogue
between two ChatGPT3.5. Subsequently, we manually modify the contents that do
not adhere to human language conventions and then have LLMs re-generate,
simulating authentic human-machine interaction scenarios. Finally, professional
scholars annotate all the samples in the dataset. DiaHalu covers four common
multi-turn dialogue domains and five hallucination subtypes, extended from
factuality and faithfulness hallucination. Experiments through some well-known
LLMs and detection methods on the dataset show that DiaHalu is a challenging
benchmark, holding significant value for further research.
|
[
-0.47714746,
-1.0685323477,
0.5690187812,
0.3645592332,
-0.3821907341,
0.0793948323,
-0.2511432469,
-0.4719814062,
0.1343552172,
0.5201340318,
-0.539163053,
-0.7573227286,
-0.3943005204,
0.4183083475,
-0.5972697735,
0.627346158,
0.0957188159,
-0.0841627494,
-0.2880095243,
0.0199494418,
-0.6601223946,
-0.5893151164,
-0.4362569451,
-0.2506830692,
0.3055176735,
0.2202518433,
0.5866500735,
0.1470223367,
0.423306495,
0.3176834285,
-0.0018376567,
0.3340550065,
-0.6779701114,
0.3318606317,
0.3317148089,
-0.3285209835,
-0.5187621117,
-0.0083927978,
0.7605715394,
0.7091492414,
-0.271989435,
-0.1496025771,
0.0951317847,
0.4282314777,
-0.5379950404,
0.2433570325,
-0.6804868579,
0.0825351551,
-0.2472118437,
-0.2079519629,
-0.5838805437,
-0.6680659652,
0.0671995878,
-0.4500713944,
0.0575582683,
0.0503488965,
0.7735925913,
0.5508545041,
-0.0926319361,
-0.3762849867,
-0.8298700452,
0.8081457615,
-0.8146218657,
0.6645989418,
0.4538167417,
0.3130293787,
-0.2811295688,
-0.3912143409,
-0.7192599773,
-0.470356524,
-0.3019195199,
-0.0232965462,
-0.2727340162,
0.0234720428,
0.327783972,
0.3143868744,
-0.774318099,
0.0351602547,
-0.0080268523,
-0.2413659692,
0.3736965358,
0.3250438869,
0.231416449,
-0.1092232093,
-0.2103510648,
-0.0198614802,
-0.602674067,
-0.4321938753,
0.2411687225,
-0.0247362889,
-0.05193251,
0.2807402611,
-0.2556621134,
0.6994817257,
-0.2260816842,
-0.1465587467,
0.3945547342,
-0.3641749024,
-0.2275594324,
0.2795162797,
0.8913878202,
0.3721467853,
0.3249432743,
-0.2492364347,
-0.2382610291,
0.2440714836,
0.2201235741,
-0.982870698,
-0.3912240863,
0.2355873138,
-0.3663783371,
-0.2729213834,
-0.0491643846,
-0.9906656146,
-0.5887672901,
-0.0836373419,
0.1788970679,
-0.4627980292,
-0.3628265262,
0.2481637746,
0.3875463009,
0.4096824527,
0.4380472302,
-0.7639719248,
0.5466083288,
0.8387311101,
0.8682973981,
-0.4549023509,
-0.382594645,
-0.6270227432,
-0.0520780496,
-0.5339323878,
0.9017910957,
-0.7469815612,
-0.4628582299,
0.0407510176,
-0.1617092937,
-0.1083486527,
-0.9195324779,
0.6308627129,
-0.4025223851,
0.1172801554,
-0.1264333576,
-0.5142658949,
-0.2099394202,
0.3380817175,
-0.6958833933,
0.9227870703,
0.0042489185,
-0.6367055178,
0.2968529165,
-0.3972860873,
-0.3194929361,
0.1789237559,
-0.42514503,
-0.5889802575,
-0.0717353895,
0.0287247524,
0.2896473408,
-0.4761699736,
0.6108376384,
-0.310118705,
-0.7388525605,
0.4025735855,
-0.6404386163,
0.4571847916,
0.0023970453,
-0.3306708038,
0.0552160181,
-0.733448863,
-0.3713280857,
0.0468718074,
-0.1743819118,
-0.3173590899,
-0.1071594507,
-0.0943730548,
-0.0164790768,
0.1111209616,
-0.4787223339,
0.2608032525,
-0.315674603,
0.1622166634,
0.7085294127,
-0.0277502611,
-0.1376636326,
-0.2838208973,
0.4203669727,
0.1463181078,
0.0904445276,
0.024046164,
-0.4879637063,
-0.8895784616,
-0.3709390163,
0.2554228902,
0.4780100286,
-0.47924757,
0.504311502,
-0.2349558026,
-0.2985495925,
-0.6903252602,
0.1303748637,
0.4195905328,
0.2907226682,
0.3218832016,
-0.2970785499,
-0.5945870876,
-0.9371652603,
-0.0398329906,
-0.5083729625,
0.0470265262,
0.3689688444,
0.4061178267,
-0.4400297999,
0.722618103,
-0.3918487132,
-0.3745799959,
-0.2298489064,
0.3038080633,
0.1800267845,
0.1711815447,
0.2603287399,
-0.6629880071,
-0.3049140871,
-0.195844546,
-1.1390168667,
-0.4057461321,
-0.327180773,
-0.0793103725,
0.3341788054,
0.5582486987,
-0.7520283461,
0.3254877329,
0.5196466446,
-0.1705674529,
0.7818400264,
-0.0007443567,
0.3651551008,
-0.8502180576,
0.0577522889,
-0.1560302973,
-0.1025545076,
-0.7684400082,
-0.2425970286,
-0.2409302294,
0.1619482934,
-0.1598032266,
0.3477397859,
-0.1204460636,
-0.2397825122,
-0.0583949797,
0.3615228534,
-0.088062197,
0.4737998247,
0.170477137,
0.795819521,
0.5238892436,
-0.4975351691,
0.4775750339,
0.5554341674,
-0.649381578,
0.5484933853,
-0.7491082549,
0.27363047,
0.1740666777,
0.3274747729,
-0.9550640583,
-0.011376488,
0.3569939137,
-0.1775847822,
0.0603379831,
0.0792634711,
-0.6206173301,
0.0115746483,
-0.2955837846,
0.6375194192,
0.4072502553,
-0.4493951499,
0.3406096399,
0.2908677757,
-0.0480265319,
-0.3569330573,
-0.3119361401,
0.458936125,
-0.5274543166,
-0.483659029,
0.24209553,
-0.3583897948,
-0.4277468026,
-0.5290647745,
-0.0508656837,
0.2931781411,
0.1195037141,
0.2608435154,
0.3452406228,
-0.1907670349,
-0.0911405385,
-0.1302260756,
-0.3152664006,
0.2727407217,
0.0544735044,
0.9943248034,
-0.1811511666,
-0.47172153,
-0.7886343598,
0.1349880993,
0.5552559495,
0.0049535264,
0.4309805036,
0.6133377552,
-0.4836846292,
0.0295270048,
-0.7600536942,
-0.364826858,
-0.4218578041,
0.3067628443,
-0.74462533,
-0.6991312504,
0.3922785521,
-0.2846646607,
0.124290809,
0.0447913893,
0.7293045521,
0.1687619239,
0.9332604408,
0.2501198053,
-0.1578191966,
0.1309337616,
-0.1668281406,
0.3756686747,
-0.844301641,
-0.2845382392,
-0.5209759474,
-0.1459918469,
-0.7081058621,
-0.3965364099,
0.422329098,
0.2139757872,
0.1192136183,
0.4448857307,
-0.2343356162,
0.1888393462,
0.2602434754,
-0.0042314953,
0.6529352665,
-0.1117416099,
-0.1206635684,
-0.1014240459,
-0.4220848978,
-0.6838529706,
0.7085410357,
0.3099967837,
0.8478018045,
0.2238410562,
0.9204970002,
0.5245477557,
0.1363323182,
-0.6538926959,
0.873729229,
0.2092486769,
-0.1893906146,
-0.4038694203,
-0.597566247,
-1.0033003092,
0.2534245849,
-0.0114768595,
-0.8885871172,
0.2041939646,
-0.2075397223,
-0.3819403946,
-0.0156575833,
-0.2606295347,
0.9330108762,
0.0655892566,
-0.216162324,
-0.3758814335,
-0.4372873604,
0.547904253,
-0.2564508021,
0.2641386986,
-0.2381218523,
0.2322160602,
0.7486489415,
-0.1355917752,
0.8800500035,
0.008990394,
-0.5591683984,
0.0632073283,
0.5623269677,
0.3438589275,
0.3406123519,
-0.0477085188,
0.370498538,
-0.006875325,
-0.0869007707,
-0.4619152248,
0.8460518122,
-0.6803887486,
-0.6760139465,
-0.4955839813,
-0.4689184725,
-0.2814879119,
-0.0059548914,
0.0083716698,
0.4010819793,
-0.550128758,
0.0514620021,
0.8379432559,
-0.4675266743,
0.2313436419,
0.5081360936,
-0.5369052887,
-0.2555363774,
1.1734323502,
-0.3521325886,
0.2269873619,
0.3535650671,
0.1549269408,
-0.2308118939,
-0.5464326739,
-0.617574811,
0.3177400231,
-0.5997311473,
-0.0672390014,
-0.7683148384,
-0.4200702012,
-0.3110713065,
0.1504749358,
-0.3311405778,
-0.1384962052,
-0.224219799,
0.0668682382,
0.0817498043,
0.7301080227,
-0.008379274,
-0.1499000043,
-0.6601996422,
0.6800858378,
0.3223439157,
0.2816498876,
-0.0581513643,
-0.54369241,
-0.0501227565,
-0.0155161275,
-0.1990703046,
-0.5617879033,
0.2494406402,
0.2043580711,
0.5653671622,
0.6284062266,
0.2078847289,
0.6340091228,
-0.3917523623,
0.7709196806,
0.0670759454,
-0.8641031981,
0.5103535056,
-0.0820829123,
0.1812724769,
0.5045491457,
0.3538161814,
-0.6854278445,
-0.5346143842,
-0.2563997805,
-0.2688367963,
0.5080648065,
0.4779287577,
0.0666708648,
-0.1306523979,
0.0458389148,
0.4371631444,
0.161606282,
-0.4861717522,
-0.0964291617,
0.0126848156,
0.0161763448,
-0.0336930677,
-0.3534271121,
-0.1170142815,
-0.2726286948,
0.5034999847,
0.0265868865,
0.280146718,
0.0955085084,
-0.3568792641,
-0.1129274666,
0.1859252453,
0.7021385431,
0.6675748825,
-0.3836060762,
0.2069856972,
0.2424288839,
-0.5440793037,
0.0761320069,
0.0274943057,
-0.1896944642,
0.2825642228,
0.4895241261,
0.8401462436,
0.1946819425,
-0.8024707437,
0.3261792064,
-0.34852916,
-0.0701707155,
-0.220933944,
0.0487500243,
-0.100125365,
0.2259810418,
0.1566145569,
-0.4216695428,
0.3459247053,
-0.6811084747,
0.3141098917,
0.4834792912,
-0.4279254377,
-0.3076935112,
0.531896472,
0.1986923069,
-0.4197024703,
0.7985672951,
-0.2445371449,
-0.541883707,
0.1292099804,
0.433377862,
1.0783680677,
-0.3156446218,
0.4040296376,
0.3410716355,
0.3211732805,
0.0964060351,
0.3225754797,
-0.1171572432,
-0.8152889609,
-0.2295911908,
-1.0526753664,
-0.5098587275,
0.3706855476,
-0.5062407255,
0.3961239755,
-0.0458725542,
0.0182033852,
-0.0748897716,
-0.0553369485,
-0.2463966459,
-0.1546967775,
0.329818517,
0.523555696,
-0.6917517185,
0.84833318,
0.1172842458,
-0.1740956455,
0.0505846739,
0.2555840313,
-0.0467261598,
-0.707978189,
0.3862399161,
0.3909097016,
-0.328204453,
-0.030751897,
-0.2827406526,
-0.251645267,
0.8681789637,
0.2897976935,
-0.6858894825,
-0.0063752439,
0.5940950513,
0.455232501,
-0.4030179381,
0.3332165182,
1.1297590733,
0.5567132235,
0.0862422511,
-0.9447799921,
0.2887203097,
-0.2277284116,
-0.0016233935,
0.0682943389,
-0.6471662521,
0.5775114298,
-0.0344930366,
-0.2752612531,
0.3336780369,
0.6263605952,
0.5010827184,
0.3037389815,
0.7099835873,
0.6389375329,
0.6210954785,
-0.1164396629,
0.5847550035,
-0.3800721467,
0.1653142124,
0.8987162709,
-0.5790139437,
0.6153253913,
0.3834202886,
-0.1835909188,
0.7049549222,
0.6791981459,
-0.0372912399,
0.5419605374,
0.3956121206,
-0.4301015437,
-0.4537746906,
-0.2275453061,
-0.4351103604,
0.5060138106,
0.5175825953,
0.0348438434,
-0.1501487643,
-0.0249669086,
-0.1392080337,
-0.1183496565,
0.3599372208,
1.1451479197,
0.1449375749,
-0.56035465,
1.1640760899,
-0.1447959393,
0.4272795916,
-0.3516966105,
-0.4616702497,
-0.5883965492,
0.0014436105,
-0.1026118919,
-0.4216649532,
0.1244910881,
0.0317662507,
0.2783226669,
-0.0471993722,
0.473433882,
-0.4176892042,
-0.3004852533,
0.4133504629,
0.4621897638,
0.686999619,
-0.1344195157,
-0.5197651982,
0.7014716268,
-0.1483328193,
-0.134609893,
0.2305847853,
0.5352519751,
-0.0247437526,
0.6069621444,
0.4955915809,
-0.1212291643,
-0.1469505429,
0.6113838553,
0.9311130047,
-0.5383551717,
-0.0463829041,
-1.0432543755,
0.0618279316,
-0.1599040329,
-0.323007226,
0.7266454101,
0.7767057419,
0.8154481649,
0.1143949851,
0.7452617288,
0.1682698429,
0.1598148942,
-0.6524278522,
0.6678899527,
-0.4037650526,
0.4906810224,
-0.512837708,
-1.3325222731,
-0.1844674051,
0.7977801561,
-0.1426585019,
0.0114165191,
0.8668108582,
1.0064128637,
-0.0798587799,
0.3507971168,
0.6615650058,
0.5175257921,
0.3114594519,
0.6855118275,
1.1502524614,
-0.4084501266,
0.4823449552,
-0.214893505,
-0.4236097038,
-0.4028559625,
-0.5510387421,
-1.1366558075,
-0.6524358392,
-0.4872394502,
-0.3725770414,
0.1301742047,
0.7019006014,
0.5110925436,
-1.001342535,
-0.5427225232,
-0.1713699698,
0.1153808311,
-0.2411157191,
-0.186652422,
0.2709719241,
-0.2617206872,
-0.827182889,
0.561389327,
0.4612598121,
-0.0789830089,
-0.8097676635,
-0.3067461252,
-0.1937656999,
0.131938681,
0.5938541889,
-0.124743931,
-0.8871092796,
-0.2286380082,
0.0651676804,
-0.1004922464,
0.2066025138,
0.8322094083,
-0.7850914598,
0.4239166677,
0.2911562324,
0.5334342718,
0.4440248907,
-0.0894511044,
0.4245632589,
-0.4338867664,
-0.087057732,
0.2356037796,
0.2384351939,
0.3724300861,
-0.0815882832,
0.503410399,
0.3680969477,
-0.5360305309,
-1.1531742811,
0.1862371117,
-0.9307890534,
-0.0638207495,
1.2238172293,
-0.0362714082,
0.0148580391,
-0.3193990588,
-0.2918846309,
0.2429419756,
-0.299446255,
1.3207458258,
0.8904889822,
-0.0908693597,
-0.1899715811,
-0.6505713463,
0.6333668232,
0.4098676443,
-1.0070284605,
0.5349307656,
0.4515298009,
-0.2221653759,
0.1690747589,
0.5348271132,
-0.0170583185,
0.1094174236,
0.0050465837,
-0.0246055853,
0.3214044273,
-0.6710811257,
-0.2257322371,
-0.2022389174,
0.0051466483,
-0.0191284865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00894v1
|
A systematic evaluation of large language models for generating programming code
| 2024-03-01T14:43:06 | 2024-03-01T14:43:06 |
Wenpin Hou, Zhicheng Ji
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
We systematically evaluated the performance of seven large language models in
generating programming code using various prompt strategies, programming
languages, and task difficulties. GPT-4 substantially outperforms other large
language models, including Gemini Ultra and Claude 2. The coding performance of
GPT-4 varies considerably with different prompt strategies. In most LeetCode
and GeeksforGeeks coding contests evaluated in this study, GPT-4 employing the
optimal prompt strategy outperforms 85 percent of human participants.
Additionally, GPT-4 demonstrates strong capabilities in translating code
between different programming languages and in learning from past errors. The
computational efficiency of the code generated by GPT-4 is comparable to that
of human programmers. These results suggest that GPT-4 has the potential to
serve as a reliable assistant in programming code generation and software
development.
|
[
-0.2299606353,
-0.5035783648,
0.7958384156,
0.4420025349,
0.0324872956,
0.1906137764,
-0.3707088232,
-0.2388609499,
-0.1201919764,
-0.0031222245,
-0.4140639603,
-0.453039974,
-0.3372343183,
0.5796636343,
-0.3473834991,
1.0870940685,
0.0418958664,
0.1276043653,
0.1966769248,
0.41465047,
-0.6500296593,
-0.7347337008,
-0.6472098231,
0.0221859459,
0.3071289062,
0.2686704099,
0.5949489474,
0.2208016664,
0.7496770024,
0.3956276178,
0.4405677021,
-0.2841646373,
-0.4661358893,
0.0803084373,
-0.1944944859,
-0.2793135345,
-0.3627888262,
0.1229766011,
0.4394321442,
0.1916005611,
-0.2371855527,
0.1609137505,
-0.0789652392,
0.4995213151,
-0.0942770764,
0.3296555579,
-0.5386614799,
-0.0962360352,
-0.3950371742,
-0.3086180091,
-0.3943914473,
-0.7280106544,
-0.1713410914,
-0.4998444617,
0.3427232206,
-0.0807719454,
0.6028306484,
0.022132922,
-0.0394486897,
-0.7384306788,
-0.5307115912,
0.5724337101,
-0.7614654303,
0.2182895988,
0.1166938692,
0.2923871577,
-0.1392567754,
-0.9628067613,
-0.6260309815,
-0.5644472241,
0.4531004131,
0.1226241067,
-0.2283464372,
0.052101668,
0.6433615088,
0.2799831927,
-0.7791684866,
0.0196875185,
-0.6163138747,
-0.177365914,
0.4062501788,
0.0688331947,
0.5206836462,
-0.3527349234,
0.1496229619,
0.0413953252,
-0.7379714847,
-0.1417534053,
0.6683998108,
-0.0037621579,
0.0431890525,
0.5503945947,
-0.2112662941,
0.6573631763,
0.0628973022,
-0.2476437986,
0.3376332819,
-0.6008111835,
-0.0354164317,
-0.2961642444,
0.7418878675,
0.3986532688,
0.2191746086,
-0.1663870364,
-0.4809923172,
0.2484292835,
0.3646503687,
-0.8176131248,
-0.5011098981,
0.0333273113,
-0.4900692701,
-0.2835522592,
-0.0295955464,
-0.4461861849,
-0.0822366625,
-0.137718901,
0.2164191157,
-0.4018764496,
-0.273676604,
-0.058101356,
-0.2924181223,
0.2912319303,
0.2073096335,
-0.8028949499,
0.1055690199,
0.6170386672,
0.9138611555,
-0.2736984789,
-0.2932736576,
-0.4658074081,
-0.1974962056,
-0.554946661,
0.4110810757,
-0.5400851369,
-0.4681004286,
-0.0455544293,
-0.3575577438,
0.1781908125,
-0.4085212052,
0.4316380322,
-0.5859460235,
0.015394913,
-0.384501636,
-0.4984029531,
0.1085102037,
0.1943432689,
-0.6597948074,
0.7023171186,
0.5402733088,
-0.6746140122,
0.2493841499,
-0.8815444112,
-0.1588572562,
0.3972747624,
-0.428512156,
-0.1817551702,
0.1156522632,
-0.0427326821,
0.4566751719,
-0.4774737656,
0.2038793713,
-0.0307383724,
-0.4892414808,
0.31337291,
-0.1738959849,
0.5384204984,
0.3410528898,
-0.6825326085,
0.1121819466,
-0.5524067879,
0.0727184862,
0.3197206557,
-0.5889615417,
0.1186663583,
-0.3915831149,
-0.2134389579,
0.3177473545,
0.2215774953,
-0.5128111839,
0.5520967245,
-0.1076014563,
0.5771647096,
0.7095164061,
0.2095926851,
0.210422501,
0.1082337052,
0.9833874702,
-0.4976654947,
0.0928990245,
-0.2766044736,
-0.8017643094,
-0.3105020225,
0.0097823013,
0.3110843003,
0.48869133,
-1.206612587,
0.0069442494,
-0.0247262232,
-0.3536461592,
0.0161796659,
0.2296727002,
0.6015120745,
0.3093316555,
0.0410955623,
-0.3010979593,
-0.404823035,
-0.816021204,
-0.0240800902,
-0.0920784771,
-0.0810888335,
0.1613442749,
0.4585264921,
-0.4103702009,
0.5758015513,
-0.4067195356,
0.4574911892,
-0.4888572395,
0.2407447845,
0.4993365407,
0.4161728024,
0.7078934312,
-0.4252278507,
-0.6370531321,
0.1025570258,
-0.5768709779,
-0.2361789048,
-0.0929519683,
-0.071957849,
0.4243800044,
0.2554314435,
-0.6039093733,
0.2659466565,
0.7046371102,
-0.2870230079,
0.9777770042,
-0.2956266701,
0.4094113708,
-0.7000694275,
0.2719724774,
-0.2579796314,
-0.1094043851,
-0.4268732369,
0.2549855709,
0.2197033316,
-0.4011378884,
-0.0551472194,
0.150189653,
-0.5947449803,
-0.3375708759,
-0.1084480062,
0.0594405793,
-0.367526859,
0.3647461236,
0.0231459253,
1.1153358221,
0.6142366529,
-0.377383858,
0.6711514592,
-0.0288200025,
-0.3850896358,
0.2792080641,
-0.8851647377,
0.5175849199,
0.2502264977,
0.2290388942,
-0.9479469061,
-0.3587473929,
-0.0971284658,
-0.5457440615,
0.4403566718,
-0.0579906963,
-0.5136306882,
-0.9007815719,
-0.3200698197,
0.3250692487,
0.8579913378,
-0.3000047207,
-0.0898341611,
0.0150525421,
-0.4951615632,
-0.3693961799,
-0.2437154502,
0.219905749,
-0.0700634271,
-0.4807996154,
-0.0383244753,
-0.14785932,
-0.025545951,
-0.2904318571,
0.0873420015,
0.2228256315,
-0.1306906492,
0.0763534755,
0.3656107187,
-0.1050858498,
-0.2372693717,
-0.3376760781,
-0.2339491248,
0.0979630426,
-0.4940347373,
0.6907776594,
-0.2512152791,
-0.4145077765,
-0.1631504446,
0.3681561053,
0.3237856925,
-0.1323376894,
0.2729375064,
0.3774386644,
0.0323534347,
-0.1886164546,
-0.475628823,
0.0134808654,
-0.4864251316,
0.4709563851,
-0.6692441702,
-0.6940200329,
0.4311646223,
-0.0284924489,
0.185394451,
0.3390409648,
0.8150264025,
0.4438129067,
1.1804897785,
0.5984147787,
-0.0283850878,
0.3513679504,
-0.2579518259,
0.3049051762,
-0.3928702474,
-0.1165134683,
-0.7188203335,
0.0444690436,
-0.636580646,
-0.5001106262,
0.3792574704,
0.0269582532,
-0.479160428,
0.3417601883,
-0.7797029614,
0.5366418362,
0.6926954985,
-0.2242460251,
0.1089477539,
-0.1079650223,
-0.2068957984,
-0.0321727842,
-0.7237013578,
-0.528382659,
1.2210621834,
0.3322422206,
0.7843921781,
0.3459874988,
0.8407606483,
0.1919214278,
0.4728411138,
-0.3086568713,
0.3322328031,
0.1314921379,
-0.6215440631,
-0.1953938454,
-0.6938356757,
-0.7234047055,
-0.2328153849,
0.195437789,
-0.6053541303,
-0.2609383762,
0.2002822608,
-0.4305172861,
-0.0798255801,
-0.9422940612,
0.9380407929,
-0.2524862587,
-0.2603654563,
-0.0195505973,
-0.5658769011,
0.5224472284,
-0.4192377925,
0.0749180317,
0.2455223501,
0.0451327264,
0.7153679132,
-0.2901227772,
0.4181155264,
-0.3212145269,
-0.2186991572,
0.4091821313,
0.2765961587,
0.5691760778,
0.1066467911,
-0.2134454846,
-0.008581087,
-0.2007781267,
-0.3560020328,
-0.4977612495,
0.8870306611,
-0.843026042,
-0.388454169,
-0.3373993039,
-0.2817754149,
-0.1505932063,
0.3090105057,
0.5999354124,
0.7181860209,
-0.1536822468,
-0.0319205038,
0.3035438657,
-0.6844227314,
0.6688123345,
0.3167950511,
-0.3553827703,
-0.3350736797,
0.8186809421,
-0.0696224645,
0.2939728498,
0.0399613157,
-0.012969587,
-0.358741641,
-0.7147393823,
-0.6385549307,
0.153315112,
-0.6981300116,
-0.3848142922,
-0.4942010343,
-0.0763569102,
-0.4613769352,
-0.4248900115,
-0.2686613202,
-0.3118925393,
0.2682010233,
-0.1503296494,
0.13662076,
1.3149260283,
-0.0469189286,
0.1344573647,
-0.8354924321,
0.2718311846,
0.3016984165,
0.3153772354,
-0.1236262619,
-0.1003978103,
-0.1697347909,
-0.2490913421,
-0.4024371803,
-1.0920722485,
0.2850682437,
-0.2263898849,
0.5668606758,
0.1616949439,
-0.3324494362,
0.3707205355,
-0.7445965409,
1.2723238468,
0.5325899124,
-1.1175658703,
0.4396539927,
-0.7523019314,
0.469820559,
0.2902305126,
0.2305484563,
-0.3040494025,
-0.3208543062,
-0.7659642696,
-0.5634251237,
0.7251088023,
0.5099830627,
0.0902508125,
-0.243584618,
0.4782229364,
0.1292488426,
0.3593392074,
-0.844859004,
0.1166920811,
-0.4628300965,
-0.0042559067,
-0.0315488428,
-0.1189684868,
0.2338447422,
-0.0652475059,
0.4528650343,
-0.1620983332,
0.6048822403,
-0.0764245167,
0.1769944578,
0.0821300894,
0.1600684524,
0.6781929731,
0.9454964399,
0.0858774558,
-0.0384002887,
-0.1377338171,
-0.5076182485,
0.030594945,
0.0031469241,
-0.1199283302,
-0.0602380745,
0.4441443086,
0.5172340274,
-0.0072962507,
-0.57566154,
0.6726022363,
-0.1825844049,
-0.2630251348,
-0.1070331782,
0.2324088067,
0.1995232403,
0.0459366441,
0.29727754,
-0.011917253,
0.4583344758,
-0.6545521617,
0.1303816587,
0.3269012272,
0.2132353187,
-0.4456722438,
0.6316447854,
0.5304504633,
-0.1998602748,
0.7773278952,
-0.7063806653,
-0.7181478143,
0.5819262266,
0.8580710292,
0.7232872248,
-0.4296133518,
0.2788999677,
0.6434278488,
0.2490681261,
-0.1889586151,
0.4754203856,
-0.008827243,
-0.339227289,
-0.7274392247,
-0.5915400982,
-0.3066154718,
-0.0714681521,
-0.2478654385,
0.1359326392,
-0.4383552074,
-0.259845227,
-0.094977513,
0.1437500864,
-0.7928463221,
-0.1874942929,
0.2193259746,
0.8129004836,
-0.5336172581,
0.7390486002,
0.764960289,
-0.5239624977,
-1.3508404493,
-0.1552791744,
-0.0025914661,
-0.4821969867,
0.7265689969,
0.0981573388,
-0.0766205043,
0.0923055112,
-0.6758203506,
-0.8387490511,
0.8583440781,
0.3342085183,
-0.6136310101,
-0.0693330541,
-0.2234429717,
0.3912857771,
-0.2738344669,
0.4167191386,
0.7311595678,
0.441978246,
0.2178348154,
-1.3155273199,
-0.0586797185,
-0.3602387309,
0.2919267714,
0.1907826811,
-0.3727024794,
0.9806563854,
-0.4040301442,
-0.136344716,
0.4015412629,
0.3537150919,
0.5310450792,
0.0408614352,
0.0189875718,
0.0669043884,
0.8141253591,
-0.1683375984,
1.3641819954,
-0.4304328859,
0.3612730205,
0.6037125587,
-0.4205605984,
0.4598255157,
-0.0493573248,
-0.390085876,
0.4522412717,
0.4237011969,
0.0279240999,
0.4279565215,
0.3435655832,
0.070214875,
0.1362873018,
0.6388111115,
-0.5606612563,
0.2354294807,
0.126043424,
-0.1791678518,
-0.0838559568,
-0.0426538028,
0.2872220874,
-0.2218044847,
-0.2975118756,
0.6045141816,
-0.0744063854,
-1.0536623001,
0.6906071901,
0.2809680104,
0.6311860085,
-0.658088088,
-0.2467865795,
-0.2381587774,
0.2846907973,
-0.183184579,
-0.6873111725,
0.0618005022,
0.3879719377,
0.0373011157,
-0.0865318701,
0.5427763462,
-0.1201486439,
-0.2932803929,
-0.1921284795,
0.4141340256,
0.3218599558,
0.0068671983,
-0.7841286063,
0.2224186063,
0.351816088,
-0.3967486322,
0.1186677068,
0.5581068993,
0.0129269399,
0.4443292916,
0.7361311913,
0.0843190849,
0.1917120069,
0.1176044494,
0.7835761309,
-0.6749959588,
-0.8097686172,
-0.7257858515,
0.2195623368,
-0.2193675488,
-0.345389694,
1.1080709696,
0.5910463929,
0.4770130217,
-0.4192163348,
1.0015717745,
-0.4520834088,
0.3922875226,
-0.5184721947,
0.3142406642,
0.0806943253,
0.1889950633,
-0.7675700188,
-1.2543171644,
-0.1803019643,
0.6814568639,
-0.2866520882,
0.4772177041,
0.8429640532,
0.6168928742,
0.1195246503,
0.0249923039,
0.3424125016,
0.1772765666,
0.6586614251,
0.7783538699,
0.9511166215,
0.0259515047,
0.3917784393,
-0.0369817466,
-0.6195585132,
-0.0677924678,
-0.8653063178,
-0.79301548,
-0.4525121748,
-0.0897763446,
-0.4578538537,
-0.1052421704,
0.7073350549,
0.6134709716,
-0.4729853272,
-0.0454191081,
-0.168642655,
-0.3123749793,
-0.111643061,
-0.1518260837,
0.2964792252,
-0.5070337653,
-0.6926885247,
0.3403715193,
0.2164021432,
-0.1836070418,
-0.3757027686,
-0.5399309993,
0.3494038582,
-0.0037116113,
0.7105846405,
0.2469312847,
-0.4388649464,
-0.16200836,
0.2554970086,
-0.2357859462,
-0.2905658185,
1.1654715538,
-0.5350158811,
0.2495785058,
0.5624397993,
0.4840499759,
0.3761635125,
0.2623451352,
0.7544159889,
-0.5336575508,
-0.0406686589,
0.14151223,
0.337556392,
0.3898775876,
-0.4793260396,
0.7173101902,
0.1048260704,
-1.0463562012,
-0.5250256658,
0.1734743118,
-0.7879193425,
-0.2787250876,
1.4946813583,
-0.1227053031,
0.1070120633,
-0.1276460588,
-0.5171656013,
-0.0806417018,
-0.5463464856,
0.4758556485,
0.6559412479,
-0.4790215492,
-0.0285282377,
-0.9602308273,
0.7326290011,
-0.072947897,
-0.7776885033,
-0.2218624502,
0.9163417816,
0.4667144418,
0.3818314672,
1.0400149822,
-0.2939119935,
0.656732738,
0.3109499216,
0.3130748868,
-0.110881187,
-0.1905290335,
-0.1447047591,
0.2878843248,
0.4526779056,
0.1441410482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00553v1
|
Standardizing the Measurement of Text Diversity: A Tool and a Comparative Analysis of Scores
| 2024-03-01T14:23:12 | 2024-03-01T14:23:12 |
Chantal Shaib, Joe Barrow, Jiuding Sun, Alexa F. Siu, Byron C. Wallace, Ani Nenkova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The diversity across outputs generated by large language models shapes the
perception of their quality and utility. Prompt leaks, templated answer
structure, and canned responses across different interactions are readily
noticed by people, but there is no standard score to measure this aspect of
model behavior. In this work we empirically investigate diversity scores on
English texts. We find that computationally efficient compression algorithms
capture information similar to what is measured by slow to compute $n$-gram
overlap homogeneity scores. Further, a combination of measures -- compression
ratios, self-repetition of long $n$-grams and Self-BLEU and BERTScore -- are
sufficient to report, as they have low mutual correlation with each other. The
applicability of scores extends beyond analysis of generative models; for
example, we highlight applications on instruction-tuning datasets and
human-produced texts. We release a diversity score package to facilitate
research and invite consistency across reports.
|
[
-0.5663886666,
-0.287247926,
0.1014395952,
0.6120541692,
-0.2328180075,
0.1187917367,
-0.324503243,
-0.7096289992,
0.3990306258,
0.0163920261,
0.0184748881,
-0.6200249791,
-0.8320359588,
0.4149828851,
-0.6374521255,
0.9650460482,
0.2308589816,
-0.2010427713,
-0.2751155198,
-0.3965579271,
-0.2743175626,
-0.3081659377,
-0.1196946353,
-0.0893248394,
0.7888758779,
0.3530249894,
0.7663189769,
0.6089354753,
0.5926020145,
0.3206637502,
-0.2436992079,
0.0809290409,
-0.5739728808,
0.3966962695,
-0.2542569935,
-0.2352698743,
-0.1675759256,
0.2894007564,
0.846339941,
0.8281168342,
0.0312719643,
0.2158390135,
0.5828136206,
0.4972700477,
-0.5404906273,
-0.2066652626,
-0.1306487769,
-0.0332972556,
-0.2499970943,
-0.1236168891,
-0.3578628898,
-0.5734794736,
-0.0948579982,
-0.1918957233,
0.2695296705,
-0.0416868366,
0.7956705093,
-0.0352158025,
-0.5116393566,
-0.5393568277,
-0.6119040251,
1.2575111389,
-0.3705600798,
0.3071407378,
0.0778599605,
0.2511594594,
0.1584848762,
-0.2807307243,
-0.2890580595,
-0.0730690584,
-0.1690456718,
0.2308258861,
-0.1696457416,
-0.2203851491,
-0.0596318357,
0.8883091807,
-0.6979063749,
0.2567929327,
-0.4885830283,
-0.2003430128,
0.9285366535,
0.2316463143,
0.3670189381,
-0.1209737659,
-0.1493482292,
-0.3542570174,
-0.2367367744,
0.1534839123,
0.7741990089,
0.2038324177,
-0.1571227461,
0.301002115,
-0.1666661799,
0.6695095897,
-0.2348497957,
-0.0502020605,
0.3926115334,
-0.3901312351,
-0.1126928255,
-0.4513946772,
0.9570973516,
0.3835347295,
0.1497283876,
-0.195904851,
-0.2354647964,
-0.1550091207,
0.1176207066,
-0.84004879,
-0.1933519691,
-0.1302620769,
-0.6323463917,
-0.167797938,
0.386759311,
-1.1023539305,
-0.171311751,
-0.0441163667,
0.2752762139,
-0.2651570737,
-0.0471429117,
0.2528685927,
-0.5599666238,
0.2218305767,
0.3193313777,
-0.9625335336,
0.430737406,
0.4985029101,
0.8663395047,
-0.5207317472,
-0.454896003,
-0.1002590284,
-0.401473105,
-0.2922890484,
0.7002488375,
-0.6326257586,
-0.7908837795,
-0.1670033932,
-0.2865206003,
0.328966707,
-0.6409336925,
0.5412506461,
-0.1329234838,
0.5358684063,
-0.3754352033,
-0.6863886118,
-0.0041045551,
0.2893349528,
-0.6563397646,
1.1271152496,
0.2516330481,
-0.6836528778,
0.5082675815,
-0.218309015,
-0.3397775888,
0.1319919676,
-0.2180109918,
-0.2156668752,
0.2229503989,
-0.0015460372,
0.1874367446,
-0.3461381793,
0.0003490041,
-0.1274679452,
-0.636233449,
0.1134837195,
-0.5203042626,
0.7272291183,
0.2065872997,
0.028501099,
-0.2482019067,
-0.5013585091,
0.1157207862,
-0.1396687478,
-0.6570594311,
-0.4378029406,
-0.356231153,
0.1183149144,
-0.0878933743,
0.3651002944,
-0.489533633,
0.1971262842,
-0.2222983986,
-0.1486384422,
0.5917329192,
-0.2328251898,
0.3012934625,
-0.6545063853,
0.530739069,
-0.186628297,
0.1549471468,
-0.3678706288,
-0.8278219104,
-0.4112848938,
-0.4563227594,
0.694960475,
0.2498149276,
0.0959102958,
0.8257689476,
-0.2954849303,
-0.8728273511,
-0.7045899034,
0.1232247949,
0.0235661715,
-0.0911124498,
0.3593919873,
-0.5851200223,
-0.3642049432,
-0.7603641748,
-0.8579889536,
-0.0067299376,
-0.466250509,
0.3983048797,
0.4034543037,
-0.0755243376,
1.0473953485,
-0.3477556705,
0.074240379,
-0.1377108544,
0.6652923226,
0.309122324,
0.5577824116,
0.6678920984,
-0.5586428642,
-0.6636728644,
-0.2445176244,
-0.4716335535,
-0.4252994061,
0.1038919985,
0.2193393409,
-0.1299613118,
0.0744891316,
-0.1354931444,
0.1704962552,
1.1464071274,
-0.5012139082,
0.5973408222,
-0.0830813348,
0.7595742941,
-0.8565765619,
-0.0960309356,
-0.0535792112,
-0.296015501,
-0.2913395464,
0.1575249583,
0.0289795101,
0.1828989685,
-0.0947510749,
0.520557642,
-0.4075888097,
-0.1071400568,
-0.1222084016,
-0.0014358968,
0.4425890446,
-0.0012532467,
-0.5309057236,
0.8296743631,
0.1048797891,
-0.4392966926,
0.1384637505,
-0.0920969173,
-0.4487576187,
0.3564298451,
-0.6280180812,
0.2175423503,
-0.2714676857,
-0.0843905061,
-1.0589666367,
-0.1048898771,
-0.2447902262,
-0.6617262363,
0.1378615499,
0.0738732964,
-0.4205755293,
0.0081428494,
-0.6222134829,
0.7466401458,
0.8659020066,
-0.460855633,
0.4239800572,
0.2715621293,
-0.110939987,
-0.5094280243,
-0.9640438557,
0.0282039456,
-0.0789354667,
-0.6372284293,
0.4063691497,
-0.6010203958,
-0.3358061016,
-0.0137863327,
-0.2542709708,
-0.0606874414,
0.1297937185,
0.1319485754,
0.0272224639,
-0.141683951,
0.3103871346,
0.3032416701,
0.4455157816,
-0.0980750695,
-0.1206222251,
0.4177293181,
0.0361275338,
-0.321721673,
0.1592582166,
0.7649118304,
0.4335303903,
0.0910283327,
0.8063726425,
0.1542774588,
-0.1216471046,
-0.3185662627,
-0.382060051,
-0.0930862874,
-0.4772331715,
0.0374778993,
-0.1051712483,
-1.365170598,
0.4670023322,
0.2408861667,
0.2472616136,
0.6127414107,
0.5312486887,
-0.1125930697,
0.7928006053,
0.5874198079,
-0.0225981902,
0.3136768937,
0.3626807332,
0.2650639415,
-0.1600564569,
0.007009137,
-0.912452817,
-0.5513162017,
-0.6942925453,
-0.3895561993,
0.2659604847,
0.4023722708,
0.1531706601,
-0.0338395461,
-0.6004339457,
1.0619841814,
0.2446432561,
-0.4587736726,
0.3483804166,
-0.1330007613,
-0.0571869798,
-0.230278492,
-0.3621066511,
-0.5136131644,
0.9496076703,
0.4285060763,
0.6309898496,
0.2607748806,
1.1477185488,
0.5270670056,
0.4825824797,
-0.5967657566,
0.3708738089,
-0.7008707523,
-0.3965149522,
-0.3790927529,
-0.8692449331,
-1.1289442778,
0.3251817822,
-0.1456814855,
-0.6876682043,
0.1620488316,
-0.0565599389,
-0.096715197,
-0.125237152,
-0.7213277817,
0.7785019875,
0.1261900812,
-0.037348669,
-0.0638597831,
-0.1248556226,
0.4580890834,
0.0395006165,
0.3392825127,
-0.2476689517,
0.0774560198,
0.9766114354,
0.1911401302,
0.6942386031,
0.4271202385,
-0.1210438982,
0.1684745699,
0.160078004,
-0.0537268184,
-0.0112791369,
-0.2405565381,
0.4900793731,
-0.0390122235,
-0.4970180988,
-0.6644579172,
0.7928954363,
-0.8415433168,
-0.3829751313,
-0.3166011572,
-0.6793617606,
0.0669339225,
-0.0022824018,
0.4853622317,
0.237619549,
-0.4085844755,
0.3522110283,
0.4191324711,
-0.2952659428,
0.3971267045,
0.5577489734,
-0.2402743697,
-0.268592298,
0.7748424411,
0.3527996838,
0.276214838,
0.2304608077,
0.5093064308,
-0.0739428028,
-0.3544584811,
0.0695529133,
-0.0301968772,
-0.8460257053,
-0.2170743346,
-0.5023280382,
-0.300496906,
-0.3912499547,
-0.2222862542,
-0.1769041121,
-0.388158977,
-0.1223824322,
-0.1204720438,
0.0895350054,
0.9824854136,
-0.0666501224,
-0.0544784777,
-1.1265006065,
0.0703597963,
0.5948354602,
0.5321455002,
-0.0801793039,
-0.6546539068,
-0.2461955547,
-0.3419574797,
-0.3346912563,
-1.1216921806,
0.2143923193,
0.201499328,
0.5372374058,
0.258367449,
-0.052577395,
0.1676624864,
-0.081144385,
1.1147066355,
0.1176174954,
-1.1940854788,
0.3073321879,
-0.0803058892,
0.6069826484,
0.5175055265,
0.5187117457,
-0.8194766045,
-0.9745842218,
-0.4504443109,
-0.7362899184,
0.2583375275,
0.2711543441,
0.4544711411,
-0.2283451557,
0.0478069931,
0.4845821559,
0.0143750105,
-0.7021446228,
-0.3166599274,
-0.2530012727,
-0.7094127536,
-0.1890714318,
-0.3192166388,
-0.0344666652,
-0.2270679921,
0.1272633076,
-0.0115251075,
-0.1922070086,
0.2125286013,
-0.1525969505,
0.2216683477,
0.6605201364,
0.4229887128,
0.3622243702,
-0.0456468128,
0.4000963271,
-0.0283147804,
-0.7017475367,
0.2084638923,
-0.0875281394,
-0.1180491224,
0.2197860181,
0.460801214,
0.1882022768,
0.0835998505,
-0.6755101085,
0.4887785614,
-0.2899718583,
-0.1852232516,
0.3808736205,
0.2423426211,
-0.0819175765,
0.0289693661,
0.1291281134,
-0.0278468225,
0.5125291944,
-0.5904587507,
0.306617409,
0.1755686104,
-0.3639247715,
-0.2688629925,
0.0116595021,
0.4346113503,
-0.3731788397,
0.4198092818,
-0.602335453,
-0.2529145777,
0.6416113973,
0.4603536129,
0.7027564645,
-0.56223768,
0.2158724368,
0.4346525669,
0.5727074146,
-0.3360289037,
0.2493002713,
0.0420393683,
-0.781453371,
-0.2824713588,
-0.7809804082,
-0.4332307279,
-0.1437083185,
-0.5944905877,
0.1766644567,
-0.3272838891,
0.0506508499,
-0.0190480407,
-0.1268397123,
-0.4911864996,
0.2150120735,
0.1804270297,
1.0230447054,
-0.9706225395,
0.5858783722,
0.4204255641,
-0.4012359381,
-0.6591380835,
0.1984971613,
-0.0801227614,
-0.3140210807,
0.5286591649,
0.4464432001,
-0.0532181486,
-0.3509239852,
-0.3277412951,
-0.5764081478,
0.6644929051,
0.2955926359,
-0.6717406511,
0.2703820169,
0.2172248811,
0.6549534798,
-0.383440882,
0.6330092549,
0.6932137012,
0.4333844781,
-0.2371752411,
-0.8211813569,
-0.1657155007,
-0.4463365376,
-0.2418803722,
0.3668658137,
-0.4679414928,
1.0424185991,
0.2443109006,
-0.4868522882,
-0.0357740633,
0.43587327,
0.0576439165,
0.188923195,
0.5850729942,
0.4172923863,
0.9512917995,
-0.014405923,
0.9808170199,
-0.1364832669,
0.5767638683,
0.794580698,
0.0328252837,
0.6307240129,
0.3121160567,
-0.1825640053,
0.6142602563,
0.2734310031,
-0.2638097107,
0.0760185644,
0.4377464652,
-0.1898550987,
-0.1712155789,
0.031505093,
-0.1184493005,
0.4884757698,
0.0872856975,
-0.4740069509,
-0.3689246178,
-0.1850398481,
-0.240314424,
0.4100574553,
-0.1708926558,
0.6546521783,
0.0302663818,
-0.7254402637,
0.4862435758,
0.0990659893,
1.0050172806,
-0.4525646865,
0.0768149421,
-0.5590849519,
-0.3684976995,
-0.1590504646,
-1.1957527399,
0.4643313587,
0.1242634282,
-0.6356447339,
-0.1825542301,
0.3249092698,
-0.583108902,
-0.3582419753,
0.4050177336,
0.3846660852,
0.313480109,
0.0917502493,
-0.2857564986,
0.1448936015,
-0.1522988826,
-0.0652370304,
0.3957521021,
0.3131887913,
0.1071391329,
0.1967560798,
0.2835583091,
-0.1104664207,
0.3236567676,
0.279030323,
0.5696465373,
-0.7040631771,
-0.5799900293,
-0.8674716353,
0.4163104296,
-0.4804218113,
-0.7805869579,
0.9084873199,
0.6191853881,
0.7191849947,
0.2006049603,
0.6687183976,
0.1298828423,
0.4764105678,
-0.2829052508,
0.5520725846,
-0.6239870787,
0.3324120939,
-0.0942315534,
-0.9381833673,
-0.3374333084,
0.2417236865,
-0.0696951672,
0.10621766,
0.6262710094,
0.5997834206,
-0.1144015715,
0.06032243,
0.4051637948,
-0.0333462656,
0.2718779445,
0.2566311955,
0.8920433521,
-0.3271017671,
0.7506405115,
0.260309875,
-0.3847669363,
-0.1700751334,
-0.749596715,
-0.7271152735,
-0.4012435377,
-0.2435245663,
-0.162822634,
-0.0972037092,
0.4936989248,
0.5673770905,
-0.735976398,
-0.3635185957,
0.1629537046,
0.3796789646,
-0.3095948398,
-0.2647161782,
-0.1687410474,
-0.4780500531,
-0.640722394,
0.2715632617,
0.4726715088,
0.1720518917,
-0.4104791582,
-0.2492365241,
0.3068658113,
0.6483334303,
0.2037109286,
0.1367556602,
-0.4275897443,
-0.3461726904,
-0.0791287422,
-0.4207361639,
0.2978090644,
0.9065724611,
-0.3911364079,
0.4736493826,
0.9268421531,
0.5113262534,
0.0285954271,
-0.0706589073,
0.6429230571,
-1.2443999052,
-0.0242377836,
0.4512844086,
0.2926583886,
0.4749384522,
-0.2152464241,
0.117871955,
0.0552653447,
-0.6700190902,
-0.6581513286,
0.4445117414,
-0.816064775,
-0.5690137744,
0.8815672994,
-0.3736668229,
-0.0421469957,
-0.0656092465,
0.0988106355,
-0.2332468927,
-0.4414785206,
1.0881137848,
1.0144940615,
0.327870518,
-0.2289728522,
-0.0892796963,
0.4879106581,
0.4889631867,
-0.9043806195,
-0.1015380174,
0.1237290204,
0.287276566,
0.4411124885,
0.3560272157,
-0.1682797521,
0.2516517937,
0.1412801296,
0.1828942299,
0.3407592177,
-0.2855924964,
-0.6049597263,
0.4610871673,
0.1186515465,
-0.0381404608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00528v1
|
Large Language Models for Simultaneous Named Entity Extraction and Spelling Correction
| 2024-03-01T13:36:04 | 2024-03-01T13:36:04 |
Edward Whittaker, Ikuo Kitagishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, H.3.3; H.3.4; I.2.7; I.7.1; I.7.5
|
Language Models (LMs) such as BERT, have been shown to perform well on the
task of identifying Named Entities (NE) in text. A BERT LM is typically used as
a classifier to classify individual tokens in the input text, or to classify
spans of tokens, as belonging to one of a set of possible NE categories.
In this paper, we hypothesise that decoder-only Large Language Models (LLMs)
can also be used generatively to extract both the NE, as well as potentially
recover the correct surface form of the NE, where any spelling errors that were
present in the input text get automatically corrected.
We fine-tune two BERT LMs as baselines, as well as eight open-source LLMs, on
the task of producing NEs from text that was obtained by applying Optical
Character Recognition (OCR) to images of Japanese shop receipts; in this work,
we do not attempt to find or evaluate the location of NEs in the text.
We show that the best fine-tuned LLM performs as well as, or slightly better
than, the best fine-tuned BERT LM, although the differences are not
significant. However, the best LLM is also shown to correct OCR errors in some
cases, as initially hypothesised.
|
[
-0.1476081759,
-0.7687214613,
0.7655767798,
-0.0312393866,
-0.2900721729,
0.0403717421,
-0.709256947,
-0.9182926416,
0.316068083,
0.9852693677,
-0.3112943172,
-0.6401032209,
-0.6318692565,
0.5748817921,
-0.498069495,
0.8317930698,
-0.0734394416,
0.1888539493,
0.1451421082,
0.1825352013,
-0.2102464586,
-0.5711676478,
-0.9500725865,
-0.1216703355,
0.7512680888,
0.1953266859,
0.5880650878,
0.5702961683,
0.339674592,
0.3263057768,
-0.1385907978,
0.5657836199,
-0.2515973747,
0.2729492188,
-0.1200578138,
-0.6401104927,
-0.5838341713,
-0.3510758281,
0.8511796594,
0.6366757154,
0.0085587362,
-0.2287725955,
0.0717944875,
0.4184257388,
-0.5450728536,
0.1817319244,
-0.8152177334,
-0.1785680205,
-0.3138091564,
-0.020795539,
-0.8186284304,
-0.2828234136,
0.1023620814,
-0.5247061849,
0.3742980063,
0.0816714019,
1.0973199606,
0.1153865978,
-0.1837910116,
-0.5074548125,
-0.8402189612,
0.8102525473,
-0.9056699872,
0.4728232026,
0.0939453691,
-0.0087417923,
-0.4207614362,
-0.5585362911,
-0.6762884259,
-0.1128633097,
-0.0767490193,
0.0387542322,
-0.0208657682,
0.370251298,
0.5842735171,
0.2834175229,
-0.1672367156,
0.6217804551,
-0.2177925259,
-0.2685076296,
0.551418066,
-0.123643294,
0.7845230103,
-0.2782763839,
-0.3013004959,
-0.0792449862,
-0.8750712276,
-0.3356822133,
0.2819716632,
0.6707219481,
0.3975930214,
0.8864665627,
0.1643361598,
0.572542429,
-0.1903560609,
-0.5835818648,
-0.0380662531,
0.114121221,
-0.3854631186,
0.4032407701,
0.6847682595,
0.1152396798,
0.291097939,
-0.4476352632,
-0.5248206854,
-0.2383487821,
0.0304336119,
-0.5968501568,
-0.3483293056,
-0.0071331416,
-0.4268611372,
0.057054624,
0.0461883172,
-0.7675356865,
-0.4405505657,
-0.4739549458,
0.54922539,
-0.4575996399,
-0.1730886549,
0.0099060955,
-0.1779740453,
0.0621646643,
0.6288340688,
-0.9167074561,
0.058987692,
0.6957535744,
0.6966143847,
-0.0700617433,
-0.1246162057,
-0.534909308,
0.1939494312,
-0.4750537276,
0.9426445961,
-0.3531535268,
-0.1641334891,
0.041673068,
0.1404867321,
-0.1077077612,
-0.6716085672,
0.4657240808,
-0.866194129,
0.0814503953,
-0.3569045961,
-0.8448681235,
-0.1182589382,
0.1229974553,
-1.0802744627,
0.8439615965,
-0.1903121471,
-0.5717608929,
0.4993562102,
-0.3899341822,
-0.5331582427,
0.2455170453,
0.0254924353,
-0.3709979653,
0.2662908733,
0.4437283278,
0.5497527122,
-0.1270840019,
0.295684129,
-0.1606856138,
-0.2460382581,
0.1609024405,
-0.4960411489,
0.7055214643,
-0.0713762641,
-0.3600405455,
-0.1296249032,
-1.0322079659,
0.0344273038,
0.1995806247,
-0.7650708556,
-0.698707521,
0.2285377085,
0.1240269318,
-0.1740467697,
0.3111534715,
-0.7658723593,
0.3686086535,
-0.385661602,
0.4990622997,
0.7009150386,
-0.3030350804,
0.2557014227,
-0.0565885119,
0.1905969977,
-0.201272741,
-0.4564142823,
-0.2208811641,
-0.4289877415,
-1.1883798838,
-0.7591466904,
0.7231491208,
0.4959919453,
-1.0049475431,
0.5141795278,
-0.4275257885,
-0.327129364,
-0.4980299175,
-0.0511184856,
0.2740172446,
0.3738522232,
0.2040756643,
-0.208648324,
-0.5830728412,
-0.8250728846,
-0.2968685925,
-0.0102996044,
-0.0407480448,
0.2046741992,
0.2170904726,
-0.114888303,
0.7733926177,
-0.2865175903,
-0.3851505816,
-0.1618431956,
0.2073528171,
0.2087257504,
0.1891792864,
0.2960007489,
-0.5789632201,
-0.4269714952,
-0.0079662083,
-0.5751900077,
-0.1322051734,
-0.107798405,
0.0243440047,
0.8000717759,
0.5877664685,
-0.6383864284,
0.3150086999,
0.2966140211,
0.098159723,
0.491376251,
-0.548596859,
0.0553921908,
-1.0203031301,
0.0146983517,
0.0234117191,
-0.3874514401,
-0.6145688891,
0.1801811308,
0.3687014282,
0.028692456,
-0.117482245,
0.5530105829,
-0.8826737404,
-0.2922265232,
-0.31905514,
0.187744379,
0.0366400704,
0.2959091365,
0.4229430556,
0.8476266265,
0.3632746339,
-0.6987048388,
0.2950766981,
0.1467769444,
-0.8293606043,
0.4381139874,
-0.4071749449,
0.2036827058,
-0.5133937001,
0.1000787988,
-0.8625066876,
-0.3495287001,
0.2335004956,
-0.1382976472,
0.7160684466,
-0.0981560424,
-1.0730651617,
-0.3407868147,
0.152195394,
-0.0514567904,
0.3879666626,
-0.9760919213,
0.6797967553,
0.3528271914,
-0.3434202671,
-0.3997195661,
-0.7835154533,
0.2331911772,
0.0671160817,
-0.2937229276,
0.4196104705,
0.0620945431,
0.1322364807,
0.0996280015,
0.0988215134,
-0.1208293959,
0.1113196984,
0.0531163216,
0.5278286338,
-0.3909034729,
0.3641441464,
0.0876353532,
-0.0014561296,
-0.1219481006,
-0.1580593735,
0.5028907061,
0.3650749624,
-0.2956276834,
-0.2219573855,
0.2645939887,
0.639021337,
-0.1689391732,
0.9196934104,
0.3831542134,
-0.7341138124,
-0.27368173,
-0.839325726,
0.0481050275,
-0.3904547989,
0.4485958815,
-0.5742337108,
-0.9634383917,
0.5884105563,
0.0421239361,
0.2048411369,
0.6360521913,
0.3537074625,
-0.1099139675,
1.0587121248,
0.6239293218,
-0.0791763514,
0.310698092,
0.05530582,
0.7545599937,
-0.941596806,
-0.4047288001,
-0.6454362869,
-0.2413469106,
-0.5413523316,
-0.1361384541,
0.2230715901,
0.3099051118,
0.0983511508,
0.5169972777,
-0.4296791553,
0.565636754,
0.8496550918,
0.3228335679,
0.3932558596,
0.3579237759,
-0.2128064036,
-0.1360106766,
-0.4422474504,
-0.6752566099,
0.921887517,
0.2861780822,
0.6142302752,
0.0792302042,
0.9919557571,
-0.1499648988,
0.3099010587,
-1.0131032467,
0.7364339828,
-0.6895080209,
-0.6922278404,
-0.3265579641,
-0.4038899541,
-1.0794744492,
0.1617808342,
-0.3323637843,
-0.8727063537,
0.2336368859,
-0.001755403,
-0.4206289649,
0.732932806,
-0.5374691486,
0.5507301092,
-0.4905839264,
-0.0072475341,
-0.0366779454,
-0.1842780709,
0.1860758066,
-0.3680397868,
0.1187667251,
-0.2586476207,
-0.0828098953,
0.6825001836,
-0.436177969,
0.664899528,
-0.0383136421,
-0.5388701558,
0.0772281736,
0.0014285549,
0.4955755174,
-0.2898481488,
-0.1338763088,
0.4388841987,
-0.0076549477,
-0.0613205954,
-0.4792940915,
0.760093987,
-0.7772762775,
-0.5442039967,
-0.2645731568,
-0.2816996872,
0.0422665365,
0.641160965,
0.4030184448,
0.5410791039,
0.0090299184,
0.1272123605,
0.8079537153,
-0.377605021,
0.4145224988,
0.584888041,
-0.1949284375,
-0.448392868,
0.8216039538,
0.3132732809,
0.09059342,
0.6758606434,
-0.0615425594,
-0.2872247994,
-0.5687305331,
-0.5792204738,
0.351727277,
-0.8233752847,
-0.2805151045,
-0.7393978834,
-0.362600863,
-0.3850513399,
0.136329487,
-0.3747141957,
-0.1375341862,
-0.6599820256,
0.2568724155,
0.1494234502,
0.7238575816,
-0.0140185086,
0.1122395396,
-1.0812618732,
0.4000184536,
0.324563086,
0.3882191479,
0.1284045428,
-0.2912726104,
-0.0021462832,
0.2366355509,
0.1737207025,
-0.806445241,
0.4917828441,
0.2098697424,
0.4814841151,
0.25704211,
-0.0556277595,
1.0256155729,
-0.7127351165,
0.7625798583,
0.228561759,
-0.9339768291,
0.3714044988,
-0.0897792354,
-0.0591930151,
0.2932324409,
0.2958027124,
-0.5286816955,
-0.3196121156,
-0.4095574617,
-0.9130225182,
1.0429202318,
-0.0713246167,
0.141084671,
-0.3896161318,
0.5107829571,
0.1633225679,
0.1274873167,
-0.718047142,
-0.1504459679,
0.4912946522,
-0.3176033497,
-0.0565501489,
-0.6092591882,
0.2398972809,
0.0671648085,
0.9620966911,
0.1387102157,
0.3319818079,
0.2909008861,
-0.3634772897,
-0.2338023484,
0.3225525022,
0.4248001575,
0.4684808254,
-0.0593027547,
0.06885764,
0.0024687853,
-0.1988416761,
-0.1077133045,
0.1997692734,
-0.3397307396,
0.2860354483,
0.3888570964,
0.8570339084,
0.540540278,
-0.809337914,
0.2388936579,
0.0212159995,
-0.1046419293,
-0.4104458392,
0.0156574957,
-0.0322555602,
0.2956137359,
0.3284082115,
-0.0761376992,
0.1179560572,
-0.5759245753,
-0.0940459296,
0.5475896001,
0.3156239986,
-0.030206237,
0.5447744727,
0.0102764638,
-0.4513832033,
1.0031473637,
-0.1658201367,
-0.7288509607,
0.6905664802,
0.6804876328,
0.8004259467,
-0.1303594261,
0.0059897564,
0.4693953693,
0.2953213155,
-0.6258198023,
0.0256666169,
0.0378203206,
-1.0117459297,
-0.4977440536,
-0.8123123646,
-0.3891300857,
0.4679788649,
-0.7694063783,
0.4883030951,
-0.4157203734,
-0.1260314286,
0.3979115784,
-0.1914042234,
-0.714050293,
0.1406444907,
0.5449877381,
0.6202024817,
-0.4892531931,
0.8658744097,
0.8319942951,
-0.2380847931,
-1.0520365238,
-0.0438454337,
-0.3605234921,
-0.9462736249,
0.7460027337,
0.3124470115,
0.0605170764,
0.17168504,
-0.4046476483,
-1.1339344978,
0.7547346354,
0.3690420091,
-1.1631709337,
-0.3500380218,
0.0514186136,
0.5501112938,
0.0408204198,
0.2370151132,
0.4432711899,
0.41782552,
0.0770148933,
-1.1330322027,
-0.2100782245,
0.0481902063,
0.3010779917,
0.543212235,
-0.2766773701,
0.7594357133,
-0.1585393101,
-0.573661983,
0.556779623,
0.4969892204,
0.2207400501,
-0.04567983,
0.5417169929,
0.6875074506,
1.0207856894,
-0.1658676863,
0.7711394429,
-0.1580621898,
0.3795228601,
1.0726764202,
-0.4121348262,
1.1066615582,
0.2345230877,
-0.1789372563,
0.5413999557,
0.5398296714,
-0.2351231873,
0.4450176954,
0.1177198514,
-0.0645638481,
-0.3360365629,
0.2846775949,
0.0176586211,
0.4665037692,
0.4556007385,
-0.6199427843,
-0.2336532176,
0.2688725591,
0.0615483597,
-0.106520541,
-0.5303797126,
0.933031261,
0.0215545036,
-0.8289419413,
0.4422807992,
0.3662163615,
0.772739172,
-0.2715049088,
0.0006602448,
-0.0075379903,
0.3198440373,
-0.0707307905,
-0.5944107771,
0.0021684021,
0.1937118918,
-0.4109474123,
-0.0517226867,
0.9030186534,
-0.7840410471,
-0.63276124,
0.2776342928,
0.0652883202,
0.3997873068,
-0.1060775742,
-0.3806151748,
0.1837875545,
0.0212657768,
-0.0923470184,
0.1226662248,
0.4507629871,
0.1039246395,
0.3904233277,
0.5257616043,
0.3534615338,
0.2369645983,
0.2277135551,
0.3638935089,
-0.5833235979,
-0.2644297481,
-0.9149509072,
0.2864232957,
-0.1181851178,
0.1212972626,
0.579567492,
0.5179204941,
0.9572594166,
-0.2510666847,
0.7214689851,
0.0819053203,
0.6048641801,
-0.9124265909,
0.5619857907,
-0.6916196346,
0.2400145829,
-0.298058033,
-1.2912404537,
-0.4609334469,
0.6907309294,
-0.130023703,
-0.1081932038,
0.6089550853,
0.7183044553,
0.1219461337,
-0.0014416283,
0.3236508071,
0.1990525126,
0.2763330638,
0.5764437318,
0.6231545806,
-0.4912099242,
0.3241829872,
-0.2162220478,
-0.0488654785,
-0.3566873074,
-0.8423503637,
-0.9439288378,
-0.5364948511,
-0.5257642269,
-0.3174746633,
0.1499766707,
0.9374181032,
0.4966432452,
-0.9152595401,
0.1550212204,
-0.0397629403,
0.0191017911,
0.0895474926,
-0.2157193869,
0.4651099145,
-0.3332225084,
-1.2822027206,
0.3369100988,
0.348210752,
0.1047277451,
-0.0251772646,
0.2814349234,
0.1509463042,
-0.017766932,
0.6775451899,
0.1449366361,
-1.1947951317,
-0.4562628567,
-0.0336029455,
-0.2741945982,
0.0415530838,
0.5889163017,
-0.5137203932,
0.6612479687,
0.3612293601,
0.7428793907,
0.2630354166,
-0.3501111269,
0.2988621891,
-0.6016614437,
-0.1581382006,
0.1343618035,
0.6219936013,
0.4079367518,
-0.5236675143,
0.0566279888,
0.0788375437,
-0.5056647658,
-0.8196835518,
-0.0454475917,
-0.8842973113,
-0.3335858881,
1.259375453,
-0.2323963791,
-0.4223130643,
0.1439936161,
-0.349624455,
0.4294647276,
-0.256809026,
0.690829277,
0.9507083893,
0.314648211,
-0.4307955503,
-0.1937645227,
0.1691032797,
0.254398644,
-0.6682453752,
-0.0044968645,
0.5831054449,
0.5487769842,
0.3816501796,
0.4687711,
-0.1331373155,
0.0658974573,
-0.2795855403,
0.4464837611,
0.0440025553,
-0.4344177842,
-0.2402359545,
0.0492238216,
0.2498416156,
-0.0812537968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00510v3
|
ROME: Memorization Insights from Text, Logits and Representation
| 2024-03-01T13:15:30 | 2024-06-16T13:53:44 |
Bo Li, Qinghua Zhao, Lijie Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous works have evaluated memorization by comparing model outputs with
training corpora, examining how factors such as data duplication, model size,
and prompt length influence memorization. However, analyzing these extensive
training corpora is highly time-consuming. To address this challenge, this
paper proposes an innovative approach named ROME that bypasses direct
processing of the training data. Specifically, we select datasets categorized
into three distinct types -- context-independent, conventional, and factual --
and redefine memorization as the ability to produce correct answers under these
conditions. Our analysis then focuses on disparities between memorized and
non-memorized samples by examining the logits and representations of generated
texts. Experimental findings reveal that longer words are less likely to be
memorized, higher confidence correlates with greater memorization, and
representations of the same concepts are more similar across different
contexts. Our code and data will be publicly available when the paper is
accepted.
|
[
-0.2580204904,
-0.7768002152,
0.6993393302,
0.0980225354,
-0.1829166263,
0.1560639292,
-0.5046383142,
-0.3591711521,
0.1246375293,
0.1230372861,
-0.1952240616,
-0.5262912512,
-0.5112764835,
0.1633242667,
-0.51409477,
1.2137775421,
-0.1771471649,
0.2628917098,
-0.5205498338,
-0.4093206227,
-0.3289887607,
-0.6565483809,
-0.5907495022,
-0.2657805383,
0.7345007062,
0.3794232607,
0.1627858132,
0.9540508986,
0.5994703174,
0.2589426637,
-0.2076330036,
0.0856726393,
-0.7038904428,
-0.2688600421,
-0.0504501574,
-0.4570257664,
-0.2615136206,
0.0314546078,
1.0247379541,
0.6082431674,
-0.0129174981,
0.3751552999,
-0.0855466053,
0.8739058375,
-0.775850594,
0.1500902325,
-0.7538589835,
0.0970390588,
-0.0968284532,
-0.4836556017,
-0.7478405833,
-0.29682073,
-0.0455571711,
-0.8136062622,
0.7082733512,
-0.0706095174,
0.6366915107,
0.1798963845,
-0.2232041955,
-0.7155222297,
-0.9397873282,
0.5392986536,
-0.1443719119,
0.3831007779,
0.3338163793,
0.0578820035,
0.2312910259,
-0.8348215222,
-0.5499811172,
-0.1024027914,
-0.3980041444,
0.1704733968,
0.2052838951,
-0.0998874754,
0.6232432127,
0.4256225228,
-0.449450016,
-0.303865999,
-0.6721538305,
-0.0789767131,
0.5319359303,
0.0143607557,
0.3008486629,
0.1803376228,
-0.4566572011,
-0.2894169092,
-0.6693014503,
-0.1864490509,
0.0791053921,
-0.0441557094,
0.1934014112,
0.5279170871,
0.1605557203,
0.3881625533,
-0.0798866898,
-0.1512901038,
0.2548909485,
-0.038312111,
-0.3687719405,
0.1596558541,
0.5165386796,
0.0937847942,
0.2318231463,
-0.5591750741,
-0.0754034445,
-0.094320789,
0.1990911067,
-0.8919091225,
-0.0283682831,
-0.066445671,
-0.243163839,
0.2543855608,
0.2913559079,
-0.6624349356,
-0.3429504633,
-0.294567734,
0.2468509972,
-0.7055796385,
0.0747727305,
-0.0828140751,
-0.2882146537,
-0.1543723345,
0.2973692119,
-1.0727576017,
0.5274578929,
0.6208857298,
0.922662437,
-0.1604904979,
-0.3520083725,
-0.7227215767,
0.4395797849,
-0.5731339455,
0.544904232,
-0.4731355309,
-0.4841728508,
0.0088199498,
-0.1046537161,
-0.5198135972,
-0.6076152921,
0.4187978208,
-0.6108157635,
0.1110080406,
-0.3826372325,
-0.9519594312,
-0.2535177767,
0.3155525625,
-1.1183873415,
1.0886573792,
0.0315530635,
-1.0895320177,
0.3735359609,
-0.5473265648,
-0.2991257608,
-0.0164208803,
-0.4380621612,
-0.3751907349,
0.4092213809,
-0.0780251175,
0.2735745609,
-0.027584549,
0.1617369354,
-0.0738318712,
-0.7754505277,
0.4106268585,
-0.3474229872,
0.3644726276,
0.1318096817,
-0.4751150012,
-0.1993833184,
-0.8284165263,
-0.0205558427,
-0.0618716441,
-0.4087980688,
-0.5852799416,
0.1324795187,
-0.1123036593,
-0.1230828464,
0.3673077226,
-0.5089495182,
0.1428654492,
0.0406862833,
0.3119558394,
0.4162409604,
-0.1565879285,
0.5860673189,
-0.3376094401,
0.0752949268,
0.0738924816,
-0.1936316192,
-0.1969382614,
0.0021459039,
-0.8830333352,
-0.255464375,
0.3960155845,
0.5158626437,
-0.4939833283,
-0.2528226972,
-0.6667467356,
-0.3096393645,
-0.1851605028,
0.3711328506,
0.5634915233,
0.2985979021,
0.4061565697,
-0.2555422485,
-0.4850886166,
-0.8525771499,
-0.1870983392,
-0.4854187071,
0.0835467577,
0.1122068539,
0.8670613766,
-0.1411045194,
0.808054924,
-0.6780513525,
-0.2088100165,
-0.0715458617,
0.4578799009,
-0.2147340924,
0.4285529554,
0.3245820701,
-1.0307209492,
-0.311945647,
-0.0139634404,
-0.6929867268,
0.5463958383,
-0.3878785372,
0.1032809168,
0.322355926,
0.9664785266,
-0.3868922293,
0.6010546684,
0.1487779915,
-0.1892597675,
0.2827037275,
-0.524853766,
0.0807468668,
-0.8328294754,
0.4724841416,
-0.4232305884,
-0.0840271786,
-0.5108266473,
-0.0604017042,
0.2757251263,
0.0832920745,
-0.2133403867,
0.4488888383,
-0.6369974017,
-0.179028824,
0.1187866703,
0.1034159437,
0.0694507137,
0.4805859923,
0.3965946734,
1.217718482,
-0.1691682488,
-0.6431010962,
-0.0876123756,
0.244264394,
-0.4210179746,
0.159896031,
-0.5158675313,
0.3213751614,
-0.2935978472,
-0.023771951,
-0.8322158456,
-0.1145451367,
-0.1841263324,
-0.4675062001,
0.2603192329,
0.0081382738,
-0.6829727292,
-0.1041745469,
-0.0960149691,
0.4416609704,
0.2620899379,
-0.4038772583,
0.3389053345,
0.1100887582,
0.0276227836,
-0.6145023108,
-0.6813744307,
-0.1729725599,
-0.4565379322,
-0.2011281401,
0.4189299345,
-0.5456789136,
-0.5836363435,
-0.1083234102,
-0.1831531525,
-0.5072510242,
0.0785226375,
0.2821007073,
0.1991674751,
-0.0170323551,
0.6084465384,
-0.3248312473,
0.1813395172,
0.03166252,
-0.1622516364,
0.4496932924,
-0.3074688911,
-0.0879946053,
-0.1115609705,
0.4831435084,
0.7014791369,
-0.2477097511,
0.921648562,
0.6307762861,
-0.4092213213,
-0.2153994292,
-0.4625730813,
-0.0506387092,
-0.4119783342,
0.2742101848,
-0.2934616506,
-0.8001864552,
0.3865685761,
0.0649707317,
0.2493073791,
0.0405766554,
0.3119055033,
-0.0782056451,
0.5217785239,
0.8604794145,
0.1178058907,
0.5993005633,
-0.4265933633,
0.0315451398,
-0.6964861155,
-0.415182054,
-0.3509678841,
-0.0703385398,
-0.4735473692,
-0.5733337998,
0.107541278,
0.128806144,
-0.1652695686,
0.2158521265,
-0.217537865,
0.6146399975,
0.5200238228,
0.0475246944,
0.4139477313,
0.2687470317,
-0.1586012095,
-0.059553083,
-0.5570650101,
-0.7063250542,
1.0063663721,
0.2445446104,
0.2089462578,
-0.118896991,
0.9591361284,
0.3512749672,
0.5860595107,
-0.7957866788,
0.606295526,
-0.1943993121,
-0.9884415269,
-0.2797859013,
-0.6638955474,
-0.6019881964,
0.055839289,
-0.0839486346,
-0.5993782878,
-0.0720051304,
0.0065873466,
-0.3983699381,
0.4398722649,
-0.8617685437,
0.6857607961,
-0.02301367,
-0.5547891259,
-0.1412322819,
-0.4030408859,
0.1497530937,
-0.0571162775,
0.3456425965,
0.0269272029,
0.0816408545,
0.9296350479,
-0.0795469433,
0.5267589688,
0.1247960329,
0.016728485,
0.5353555083,
0.024539331,
0.1291402578,
0.4354660213,
-0.0427122042,
-0.2517339289,
0.0074246647,
-0.3340705931,
-0.7952350378,
0.565213263,
-0.6353453994,
-0.4160434008,
-0.5965274572,
-0.5880099535,
-0.184954375,
0.1512061805,
0.495341748,
0.5487256646,
-0.7993617654,
0.0151356217,
1.0767444372,
0.1137227193,
0.6470224857,
0.5028274059,
0.111770682,
-0.6052519679,
0.9222564697,
0.3604957461,
0.1923798174,
0.6740088463,
-0.4059442282,
-0.1560733616,
-0.5402742028,
-0.3294846714,
0.3869377375,
-0.7700644135,
0.2502034307,
-0.3247015178,
-0.0770786628,
-0.189521268,
-0.0328005292,
-0.3637727797,
-0.4936103821,
-0.4813842773,
-0.323400557,
0.1246905103,
0.9586406946,
-0.050966613,
0.3306420445,
-0.6367986798,
0.3653841913,
0.3851891756,
0.499101907,
-0.1935222745,
-0.0561969429,
-0.5717422962,
-0.0517813861,
-0.0848536566,
-0.801894486,
0.1638413519,
0.2648612857,
0.1570462286,
0.5306224823,
-0.0789238662,
0.9018340111,
-0.7818852663,
0.4904080033,
0.2388789505,
-1.0011601448,
0.2056419253,
-0.1138024405,
0.0039764722,
1.0669332743,
0.3483093381,
-0.5340387821,
-0.1527726948,
-0.7686659694,
-0.687743485,
0.5025980473,
0.4554495215,
0.0277898479,
-0.2591243386,
0.5426807404,
-0.0219956879,
0.2065793574,
-0.6071923375,
-0.1830003113,
-0.0292060729,
-0.1457152218,
-0.441712141,
-0.3433189094,
-0.396791786,
-0.3258319199,
0.4766561389,
0.0277008172,
0.4781130552,
0.5391216874,
-0.5679495931,
0.332008779,
0.4760511816,
0.8408594728,
0.9119675756,
-0.2717033327,
0.3035987318,
0.5200971365,
-0.8505459428,
0.1203613579,
-0.1199355051,
-0.253767997,
0.4608727694,
0.5465098619,
0.6627320051,
0.0781860352,
-0.7384955287,
0.2907162309,
-0.4453763068,
-0.1307175606,
-0.9741800427,
0.0281440038,
0.1207658723,
-0.0606135391,
0.3424994051,
-0.0666370168,
0.0744976923,
-0.7076358199,
0.2786198258,
-0.0626731962,
-0.6019246578,
-0.3189178705,
0.5106608868,
-0.0636750162,
-0.0853577033,
0.766612649,
-0.1726422012,
-0.2160765976,
0.6874053478,
0.4620064199,
0.5910366178,
0.077305235,
0.427847445,
0.6838088036,
0.2370706648,
-0.3157128394,
0.0279218312,
-0.0987093747,
-0.4602516294,
-0.1537109464,
-0.3556141257,
-0.1818581671,
0.2262265086,
-1.0906623602,
0.1341941357,
-0.7829229236,
-0.2253640592,
-0.1112184227,
0.2434466034,
-0.5402810574,
0.4694484174,
0.2451882362,
1.0890830755,
-0.7352080345,
0.8418921232,
0.8084247112,
-0.4839897454,
-0.6568998098,
0.1087300926,
-0.3102279305,
-0.4024871588,
0.7269420624,
0.4853739738,
-0.1273663044,
-0.0909610987,
-0.5097104311,
-0.4585120082,
1.2771781683,
0.4697252214,
-0.7138528228,
-0.276861608,
0.185988158,
0.6004799604,
-0.3482889831,
0.3618626595,
0.8267477155,
0.2565642595,
0.1005527973,
-0.5738549232,
-0.2288840264,
-0.5252624154,
-0.0312223211,
0.0911762193,
-0.66159904,
0.816649437,
-0.2903320789,
-0.6663523316,
0.1973857284,
0.7451773286,
0.1676561832,
0.6829842925,
0.3647370338,
0.6484125257,
1.0989515781,
-0.1040190384,
0.8018206358,
-0.1844351739,
0.3266623914,
1.3465383053,
-0.0492857546,
0.8671874404,
0.7002153397,
0.1833306849,
0.7837011814,
0.4737811685,
0.0984526128,
0.3717156649,
0.2880967259,
-0.566640377,
-0.1226172224,
0.099015817,
-0.3917795718,
0.2640601993,
0.4440484047,
-0.4992211461,
0.0489677452,
-0.1593187749,
0.3537120521,
0.398372829,
-0.2029586136,
0.9415609837,
-0.0220288653,
-0.8589822054,
0.7986097336,
-0.1881343275,
0.1585556865,
-0.6151341796,
-0.0302478969,
-0.3841908574,
0.394220978,
-0.0401763283,
-0.3704133928,
0.3864759505,
0.1903536469,
-0.4535670877,
-0.2548978031,
0.1487183571,
-0.5328339338,
-0.4416829944,
0.4194020331,
0.2308299243,
0.1923348755,
0.1151418835,
-0.2105384022,
0.1261375695,
-0.1242546886,
0.0428752713,
-0.0614743792,
0.5704645514,
-0.0697064027,
0.5425564051,
0.221734494,
0.0223919936,
0.2222202122,
-0.1665589064,
0.7563787699,
-0.7712323666,
-0.3236317933,
-1.0040918589,
0.301903367,
-0.321538955,
-0.4957129359,
0.7154263854,
0.9849707484,
0.940859735,
-0.1478690207,
0.7799759507,
-0.0746380612,
0.3667443693,
-0.61060673,
0.6322717667,
-0.4365391433,
0.2135340124,
-0.3037326634,
-0.6773480177,
-0.1865848303,
0.631947875,
-0.3912218213,
-0.3819111884,
1.1337049007,
0.4649131596,
-0.0934503675,
0.1326714158,
0.1251881868,
-0.0502725244,
0.1010864228,
0.7557858825,
0.7681603432,
-0.4380157292,
0.7900947928,
0.013820135,
-0.0968447998,
-0.0364652984,
-0.5999977589,
-1.2488443851,
-0.9006601572,
-0.1689123809,
-0.2215801477,
0.2210835218,
0.5294079781,
0.4522891045,
-0.6700618863,
-0.3935798109,
-0.2645466924,
0.2196909636,
-0.1537760645,
-0.0963482708,
0.4645791054,
-0.4220448434,
-0.7938643694,
0.1366630048,
-0.1105495021,
0.2570459247,
0.0694755688,
-0.1024863422,
0.068400681,
0.1037441939,
0.4378521144,
0.37157166,
-0.2303795516,
-0.1087316871,
0.1856770068,
-0.2345456481,
0.2826565504,
1.308362484,
-0.6488516927,
0.3771276474,
0.6268960834,
0.3717361093,
0.7881988883,
-0.0108818915,
0.5463753343,
-0.7496628165,
0.3382124007,
0.2076686174,
0.3644353747,
0.477999419,
-0.2645264566,
0.5636745691,
0.2577988803,
-0.1875012964,
-0.6759990454,
0.23960419,
-0.6464868784,
-0.4870637357,
1.1400737762,
-0.5021148324,
-0.3596699238,
0.0816027373,
-0.0932207182,
0.4860369265,
-0.1355819255,
0.9482149482,
1.0867116451,
0.2444460392,
0.1076396629,
-0.5883160233,
0.6162865758,
0.4866002202,
-0.6698768139,
0.2732779086,
0.5650323033,
0.4417365491,
0.6663017869,
0.8096863031,
-0.2613892853,
0.2800020874,
-0.059481252,
-0.0892747939,
-0.1220408753,
-0.8187674284,
-0.194941327,
0.2862842083,
-0.0439223237,
-0.1235202178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00509v1
|
Surveying the Dead Minds: Historical-Psychological Text Analysis with Contextualized Construct Representation (CCR) for Classical Chinese
| 2024-03-01T13:14:45 | 2024-03-01T13:14:45 |
Yuqi Chen, Sixuan Li, Ying Li, Mohammad Atari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
In this work, we develop a pipeline for historical-psychological text
analysis in classical Chinese. Humans have produced texts in various languages
for thousands of years; however, most of the computational literature is
focused on contemporary languages and corpora. The emerging field of historical
psychology relies on computational techniques to extract aspects of psychology
from historical corpora using new methods developed in natural language
processing (NLP). The present pipeline, called Contextualized Construct
Representations (CCR), combines expert knowledge in psychometrics (i.e.,
psychological surveys) with text representations generated via
transformer-based language models to measure psychological constructs such as
traditionalism, norm strength, and collectivism in classical Chinese corpora.
Considering the scarcity of available data, we propose an indirect supervised
contrastive learning approach and build the first Chinese historical psychology
corpus (C-HI-PSY) to fine-tune pre-trained models. We evaluate the pipeline to
demonstrate its superior performance compared with other approaches. The CCR
method outperforms word-embedding-based approaches across all of our tasks and
exceeds prompting with GPT-4 in most tasks. Finally, we benchmark the pipeline
against objective, external data to further verify its validity.
|
[
-0.453528583,
-0.547236979,
0.610067606,
-0.0288473591,
-0.2576354742,
0.0267555565,
-0.6003771424,
-0.2061404437,
0.1108201221,
0.3422557116,
-0.5972200036,
-0.5110014677,
-0.3830918372,
0.0403677262,
0.056971278,
1.0225126743,
0.0746945143,
0.3077333868,
-0.1131083742,
0.0213812813,
-0.1111780033,
-0.9131693244,
-0.7621031404,
-0.3063756526,
0.3093936741,
-0.1098587885,
0.5454310179,
0.3129685223,
0.4326100647,
0.203243807,
0.0348082408,
0.1100470573,
-0.5785729885,
0.0239846483,
-0.0477990471,
-0.239370659,
-0.197135672,
0.0575628206,
0.4453414083,
0.8184168339,
0.0765178651,
0.079015106,
0.1256011426,
0.5315400958,
-0.8633159995,
0.1693465859,
-0.4581024051,
0.354883045,
-0.0757465288,
-0.5582901239,
-0.6135922074,
-0.342294246,
0.2696403563,
-0.4751060009,
0.5470358133,
-0.3333194554,
0.5025350451,
0.2076476365,
-0.4364008605,
-0.2277928591,
-0.5872849226,
1.0576597452,
-0.6870438457,
0.2863225043,
0.3894984722,
0.181225121,
-0.0864903107,
-0.8220690489,
-0.4083782434,
-0.3724035025,
-0.3317648768,
0.4189311266,
-0.0339088552,
-0.1042429134,
0.2604752779,
0.4582021534,
-0.6321808696,
-0.1527768075,
-0.5323655605,
-0.4750303924,
0.7021644711,
0.4051673412,
0.5210497975,
-0.1910873801,
-0.0550559796,
-0.1769377142,
-0.3887673616,
-0.0658424795,
0.1036524475,
0.27297315,
-0.2013345808,
0.266730845,
-0.1475487947,
0.651165843,
0.2942032218,
-0.1541671753,
0.002942509,
-0.2864279747,
-0.0665770099,
0.0515525788,
0.904461205,
0.4820718169,
0.2029490769,
-0.2809874713,
0.1620047092,
0.2152534872,
0.3099646568,
-0.6777928472,
-0.6238856316,
0.1326334327,
-0.5063712597,
0.0512024835,
-0.1939574629,
-0.5885332227,
-0.5199737549,
-0.4277187288,
-0.2736504376,
-0.6937012076,
-0.3376553953,
-0.2609227598,
-0.2012775689,
0.4090324938,
0.2790065408,
-0.9286676049,
0.1378321052,
0.5046467185,
0.95644629,
-0.3742535412,
-0.1327062249,
-0.3954916596,
0.1251364052,
-0.4629443288,
0.6577194929,
-0.3135591447,
-0.2708698809,
0.3109467626,
0.0899466053,
0.1149275675,
-0.2966539264,
0.705516398,
-0.3835122287,
0.639154017,
-0.4199627042,
-0.1888242364,
-0.0909592807,
0.4067728221,
-0.6831318736,
1.0029746294,
0.0272032451,
-1.0056306124,
0.1985403597,
-0.1175660715,
-0.2721900046,
0.1288597584,
-0.5169854164,
-0.1430878192,
-0.085106492,
0.3011113703,
0.6289715171,
-0.0140393553,
0.2423481345,
-0.2793428302,
-0.7350486517,
0.110533908,
-0.2186165154,
1.18222785,
0.3305847943,
-0.267997086,
-0.159097299,
-0.7851151228,
-0.1019132733,
-0.1795666963,
-0.09267921,
-0.7574689388,
0.254519254,
0.3837500513,
0.1646384299,
0.3611049652,
-0.4382989705,
-0.1554747075,
-0.551158607,
0.2507032752,
0.512483716,
0.0395260267,
0.3226301074,
-0.0962854102,
0.3255310655,
-0.0361528695,
-0.3461068571,
-0.1961382776,
-0.0472199023,
-0.5228809714,
-0.0846788436,
-0.2642061114,
0.4359125495,
-0.8502327204,
0.5546535254,
-0.2396290004,
-0.6370390654,
-0.114236474,
-0.1936102808,
0.1540915221,
0.4926591814,
0.4363138676,
-0.4042788446,
-0.7203081846,
-0.7289412618,
-0.0852731168,
-0.4876661599,
-0.5051552057,
-0.1038023382,
0.3113088608,
-0.0151715837,
0.8407427669,
-0.61445117,
-0.2547541261,
-0.0061790994,
0.3626399636,
0.1302890033,
0.4902556539,
0.4595440626,
-0.7695624828,
-0.2265368551,
0.1814990193,
-1.0038053989,
0.0938500315,
-0.2166899294,
-0.2492922693,
0.0910704136,
0.4798704386,
-0.2237872928,
0.1212788299,
0.3745193481,
-0.1228704676,
0.7014927268,
-0.0504540205,
0.1952438951,
-1.0677582026,
0.3346672952,
0.1592160463,
0.1626701057,
-0.6268847585,
0.1848103255,
0.1726678908,
-0.2234253138,
-0.450388521,
0.2539836168,
-0.6880468726,
0.3684590757,
-0.2882696688,
0.329811722,
-0.6019156575,
0.757034719,
0.6610122919,
0.5061144829,
0.223202765,
-0.5702828169,
0.3663268685,
0.115418762,
0.1098770201,
0.8328166008,
-0.2239914984,
0.201993525,
-0.2606099844,
0.3070415854,
-1.0523091555,
-0.1649585366,
0.2942000329,
-0.6033082604,
-0.0050536804,
0.170694977,
-0.2646575868,
-0.3018217981,
-0.3869129419,
0.4391270578,
0.4364136159,
-0.3064770103,
0.6264750957,
0.1979751736,
-0.090349704,
-0.6342096329,
-0.8728407025,
0.1428555846,
-0.2878595591,
-0.2855370641,
0.2969883084,
-0.2408058494,
-0.2251518518,
-0.0869225115,
-0.0082530575,
-0.3630695939,
-0.1695706397,
0.0261032023,
0.4738211632,
-0.3685682118,
-0.057893008,
0.011472946,
-0.076449126,
0.4353966117,
-0.0233461484,
0.4053903818,
0.0456684679,
-0.2472536713,
-0.3065265715,
0.1048890874,
0.3806805015,
-0.1959628016,
0.6260231137,
0.7220370173,
-0.6193813682,
0.0168362968,
-0.6620450616,
-0.06149102,
-0.3770066798,
0.3857127726,
-0.1213454679,
-0.8723968267,
0.3647352755,
-0.0223461241,
0.1047482491,
0.2861942649,
0.7134355307,
0.088093549,
0.8075519204,
0.726398468,
-0.4151097536,
0.5164281726,
-0.0549673028,
0.0891610757,
-0.6597926021,
0.0936496034,
-0.2341053039,
-0.0637885854,
-0.6783518791,
-0.1543888152,
0.4248576462,
-0.2811414599,
-0.4986458719,
0.1413320005,
-0.6635437012,
0.1358833611,
0.2456901222,
0.4204831421,
0.5642334819,
-0.0642729998,
0.1308227628,
-0.5318878889,
-0.1310716569,
-0.7101656199,
0.951782763,
0.09942168,
0.3925891221,
-0.2353283465,
0.5448753238,
0.3133414686,
0.6429308057,
-0.7877426744,
0.3622692823,
-0.1216219291,
-0.4936175346,
-0.1904239804,
-0.1405470371,
-0.6733462214,
0.4824473262,
-0.0055660889,
-0.7600784898,
0.2483163774,
-0.0337762237,
-0.4470449388,
0.2896353602,
-0.2690280974,
0.7118381262,
-0.1644093096,
-0.4166669548,
-0.1251378655,
-0.7900795937,
0.7995603085,
-0.0374928303,
0.0502462722,
0.353346616,
0.000753156,
0.7599987388,
-0.1731763631,
0.8097826242,
-0.1221798509,
-0.2235922217,
0.0873244107,
0.1089258417,
0.29402861,
-0.1385017931,
-0.255027771,
-0.1353863329,
0.4751370847,
-0.5753094554,
-0.4752029181,
0.6355315447,
-0.7059871554,
-0.3519156277,
-0.6492965817,
-0.4554664493,
-0.2700918913,
0.1572645158,
0.4463328421,
0.2307853401,
-0.7801808715,
0.2280273885,
0.4818830192,
-0.2325535119,
0.3860675097,
0.5325291753,
0.1732359231,
-0.3753798902,
0.5849604011,
-0.0090185143,
-0.0337256975,
0.5260504484,
-0.213151589,
0.0147263827,
-0.4467075169,
-0.202771917,
0.2960179448,
-0.5392110944,
0.2409785986,
-0.4657593369,
-0.196801126,
-0.2982182205,
-0.2451933771,
-0.3718781173,
0.2801800966,
-0.4140328765,
-0.1791828722,
-0.053953141,
0.2965167463,
-0.2015865147,
0.2378789037,
-0.3652767837,
0.3006638587,
-0.0474691018,
0.0256182719,
0.2770448625,
-0.146669507,
-0.5675418377,
0.0431964286,
-0.4661827683,
-1.0440210104,
0.5658474565,
-0.3259049356,
0.3731299341,
0.6482557058,
0.4006491303,
0.7690569162,
-0.3846033216,
1.1163643599,
0.1669246852,
-0.716791451,
0.4264132977,
-0.4761247933,
0.1172565967,
0.6234703064,
0.6842072606,
-0.9292867184,
-0.5924699306,
-0.3880234659,
-0.6587477326,
0.5647862554,
-0.0239688642,
0.1858844161,
-0.2118963599,
0.2834727168,
0.0313039087,
-0.1336750388,
-0.8370591998,
-0.4598158598,
-0.3179462552,
-0.2674047351,
-0.2271936238,
0.1319382936,
-0.0309827626,
-0.1726462245,
0.3215203881,
-0.3255189657,
0.2107055187,
0.4478706717,
-0.102208063,
-0.1892415881,
0.2651044428,
0.043210391,
0.8645207286,
-0.4100114703,
0.3607492447,
0.3584638238,
-0.5797320604,
0.0964140221,
0.2917347848,
-0.2470126748,
0.0792403519,
0.4864750206,
0.425113678,
0.1897032261,
-0.8415745497,
0.4017324448,
-0.0596423745,
0.0740277395,
-0.9621524215,
-0.2257776409,
0.0642022267,
0.1337562352,
0.8267482519,
-0.2470883578,
0.3520953953,
-0.6720614433,
0.0870780796,
0.4268188179,
-0.6778172851,
-0.3904314339,
0.7225376368,
-0.1591880023,
0.0901662186,
0.7284930944,
-0.056351237,
-0.4219110906,
0.2621280849,
0.4007766247,
0.8452144265,
0.0262860227,
0.3314535022,
0.7758476138,
0.2592584193,
-0.2172850817,
-0.1795218587,
-0.3436181247,
-0.6859523058,
-0.4454548359,
-0.3178150952,
-0.5707259178,
0.413695991,
-0.9241734147,
0.2214276195,
-0.314145714,
-0.0175829455,
-0.5354076028,
0.2846987545,
-0.6500120759,
0.5232399106,
0.432392031,
0.5288435817,
-0.9401737452,
0.5886381269,
0.6777685881,
-0.7596212626,
-0.3986310661,
0.2316061109,
0.0107751852,
-0.4572432041,
0.6926265359,
-0.0703258216,
-0.0756685063,
-0.0206606351,
-0.7688384056,
-0.6624642015,
1.0806446075,
0.2841205597,
-0.3223572969,
-0.2214923799,
-0.2843858004,
1.071657896,
-0.0602915064,
0.5190576911,
0.5601950884,
0.3787103891,
-0.3263328373,
-0.4637401998,
0.4385639429,
-0.4111144841,
-0.103881605,
-0.0789151266,
-0.6178175807,
0.6892448068,
0.0790955201,
-0.8367768526,
0.5058583617,
1.1571825743,
0.6637066603,
0.5124634504,
0.1823795736,
0.265607655,
0.7337220907,
-0.0646607354,
0.968550384,
-0.35727036,
0.1765431613,
0.8826950192,
-0.0768036395,
0.9232094288,
0.5797169209,
-0.4325447083,
0.8078782558,
0.8217855692,
-0.0374389105,
0.4979235828,
0.3018115163,
-0.301992029,
-0.0768709779,
-0.1250852495,
-0.5410069227,
-0.0170301385,
0.1314257234,
-0.3397239447,
-0.1340371519,
-0.0963125303,
0.0753346235,
0.4451998472,
-0.1858433038,
0.4732981324,
0.1635917574,
-0.6985525489,
0.638343215,
-0.148457244,
1.0236667395,
-0.672267139,
0.1153618991,
-0.437258184,
0.1689972728,
-0.1334130317,
-0.3909700513,
0.2288040668,
-0.1314434558,
0.0173033327,
-0.012391109,
0.5505990386,
-0.4944588244,
-0.4443321526,
0.2951287031,
0.7075197697,
0.2763932943,
-0.1801403761,
-0.2728290856,
-0.1819650084,
-0.1427793652,
-0.1658800244,
0.3010773957,
0.6091085076,
-0.0979963019,
0.3766261041,
0.5470589399,
0.3660210967,
-0.3547806442,
-0.039091453,
0.6905283928,
-1.1712428331,
-0.6514622569,
-0.8975802064,
0.3523537517,
0.0102121625,
-0.2788717747,
0.7801611423,
0.5668442845,
0.9733973742,
-0.2507898211,
0.983821094,
0.0048020906,
0.42747733,
-0.2514052987,
0.8635614514,
-0.3585215211,
-0.1732174456,
-0.646345675,
-0.5996752977,
-0.4320163131,
0.4944024086,
-0.4745235145,
-0.1925183833,
0.9554793239,
0.6468138695,
-0.0225065611,
0.0853213444,
0.1847254932,
0.0615218505,
0.124247767,
0.9191611409,
1.1726708412,
-0.4217690825,
0.521045208,
-0.2920139134,
-0.2877210081,
0.2958999276,
-0.8339144588,
-0.9165424705,
-0.799316287,
-0.2396981418,
-0.113816902,
0.1383374929,
0.7848872542,
0.3787133396,
-0.8735767603,
-0.5507554412,
0.2095388025,
-0.1012442261,
-0.5417050719,
-0.3021827936,
0.7556878328,
-0.3422058523,
-0.8849603534,
0.1611044854,
0.048298642,
-0.3127939999,
-0.5827869773,
-0.1395582557,
0.0745110661,
-0.3726867437,
0.6666043997,
0.3318165541,
-0.8669965863,
-0.1505949795,
-0.0570952967,
-0.247137785,
0.0162399821,
1.1424957514,
-0.8998078108,
0.3712921143,
0.6223903894,
0.6979442239,
0.505833745,
0.0482783057,
0.8099632263,
-0.4920368195,
0.0534841903,
0.1982005835,
0.3994881809,
0.6386819482,
-0.492972374,
0.6597160697,
0.4462341666,
-0.2474414855,
-0.7560318112,
-0.2303845137,
-1.1375609636,
-0.5039755702,
0.7616721988,
0.0411097407,
-0.0662402362,
-0.3294501901,
-0.4873962402,
0.667126298,
-0.2921547592,
0.9811288714,
0.9201171398,
-0.2813397646,
-0.3614380062,
-0.3896698356,
0.4590363204,
0.2767771482,
-0.5474408865,
0.0524518676,
0.8950816989,
0.0528521389,
0.3827748597,
1.0206171274,
-0.2258164287,
0.3032691479,
-0.1142561808,
0.1795237213,
0.2663714588,
0.4034827054,
-0.0530851297,
0.5578795671,
-0.2803899348,
0.1146862581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00506v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00506v1
|
PoTeC: A German Naturalistic Eye-tracking-while-reading Corpus
| 2024-03-01T13:07:39 | 2024-03-01T13:07:39 |
Deborah N. Jakobi, Thomas Kern, David R. Reich, Patrick Haller, Lena A. Jäger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Potsdam Textbook Corpus (PoTeC) is a naturalistic
eye-tracking-while-reading corpus containing data from 75 participants reading
12 scientific texts. PoTeC is the first naturalistic eye-tracking-while-reading
corpus that contains eye-movements from domain-experts as well as novices in a
within-participant manipulation: It is based on a 2x2x2 fully-crossed factorial
design which includes the participants' level of study and the participants'
discipline of study as between-subject factors and the text domain as a
within-subject factor. The participants' reading comprehension was assessed by
a series of text comprehension questions and their domain knowledge was tested
by text-independent background questions for each of the texts. The materials
are annotated for a variety of linguistic features at different levels. We
envision PoTeC to be used for a wide range of studies including but not limited
to analyses of expert and non-expert reading strategies. The corpus and all the
accompanying data at all stages of the preprocessing pipeline and all code used
to preprocess the data are made available via GitHub:
https://github.com/DiLi-Lab/PoTeC.
|
[
-0.6389634013,
-0.8027170897,
0.4898104966,
0.0543780923,
-0.4682366252,
0.2438125908,
-0.4172253013,
-0.4132295549,
0.1264400631,
0.4585471749,
-0.3751277626,
-0.9304252863,
-0.3456917405,
0.5144333243,
-0.4212685525,
0.6897909045,
0.1108592078,
0.3226944506,
0.144634366,
0.1365913153,
-0.2599481344,
-0.1347943395,
-0.2412201464,
0.0859329551,
0.6928155422,
1.0328555107,
0.4003641307,
0.4834710658,
0.7266845107,
0.2137471288,
0.2325108498,
0.0852014348,
-0.2463191301,
-0.1929977089,
0.0056198779,
-0.6852452159,
-0.5078624487,
0.1025348678,
0.9272730947,
0.9071817398,
-0.0191167612,
0.2400776446,
0.2322123647,
0.6160214543,
-0.8089202642,
0.0985775888,
-0.0575762093,
0.0105463723,
-0.6376442313,
-0.5471467376,
-0.9016529918,
-0.0871899053,
0.3789951205,
-1.0068774223,
0.5360491276,
0.2340781242,
0.8923231363,
0.1645503491,
-0.3808396757,
-0.1933998317,
-0.4029389024,
0.6820111275,
-0.3851124346,
0.4060558379,
0.7209541202,
0.2040919513,
0.0589410476,
-0.8984254599,
-0.8068549633,
-0.1569385976,
-0.1594060957,
0.4422613978,
0.1443642527,
-0.117004402,
0.0004701756,
0.1424004287,
-0.6903312802,
-0.0162201244,
-0.5718501806,
0.0038889737,
0.4753582776,
-0.2030431181,
0.2895645201,
-0.1905996948,
-0.3561965823,
-0.2109369189,
-0.2302007973,
-0.0272316486,
0.3804938495,
0.2025301307,
-0.1401755959,
0.5515385866,
-0.2097915113,
0.7286019325,
0.092049405,
0.0855439901,
0.2648037076,
-0.2900280058,
-0.1519862115,
0.0669993013,
0.7963452339,
0.3861327469,
0.4551474154,
-0.3001003265,
0.284586817,
0.1789425313,
0.5777839422,
-0.450533241,
-0.4949881732,
0.3332368731,
-0.1629500687,
-0.4015536904,
0.37231341,
-1.2931828499,
0.0407089703,
-0.4923936725,
0.0982377753,
-0.7014051676,
0.0490211174,
0.0977255553,
0.0389217921,
0.3772876263,
0.377476871,
-1.1002300978,
0.4717595875,
0.5289523005,
0.9855451584,
-0.4564086795,
-0.5711792111,
-0.4782792032,
0.0813018456,
-0.6043302417,
1.2553329468,
-0.5049523115,
-0.4863408208,
0.0015502349,
0.4232435822,
-0.0975408927,
-0.0185707398,
0.5321779251,
-0.5779114962,
0.4723967314,
-0.3972572684,
-0.7428380251,
-0.2445182502,
-0.0995975882,
-0.7666276693,
1.1218879223,
0.0734249577,
-0.9676590562,
0.7881492376,
-0.8459023833,
-0.3520122468,
0.6783427596,
0.0130296592,
-0.2852804065,
-0.4107084274,
0.1086822897,
0.138386786,
0.0565371215,
0.0092358971,
-0.1576901227,
-0.3348859847,
0.2711966634,
-0.114188008,
1.0323728323,
0.1861194223,
-0.4838505089,
0.3215710223,
-0.61930269,
-0.0638156608,
-0.3250081837,
0.1642233878,
-0.4058501422,
0.0489801951,
0.166973725,
-0.1781096756,
0.1357339174,
-0.7660147548,
0.4386771619,
-0.0116750877,
0.2900259495,
0.6110473871,
0.0614674836,
0.4877741039,
0.1472677588,
0.2580024898,
-0.3965931833,
0.4809351563,
0.0396635011,
-0.383108288,
-0.6751203537,
-0.6818182468,
0.6609023213,
0.8112205863,
-0.8110491037,
0.2137194872,
-0.0422962122,
-0.5022153258,
-0.4512718618,
0.0867912844,
0.1332072318,
0.5603809953,
0.2780455649,
-0.3236487508,
-0.208983168,
-0.7693468928,
0.3594530821,
-0.2392529845,
-0.4197358787,
0.2643403411,
0.7582830191,
-0.261762619,
0.6527227759,
-0.600050509,
-0.4935888052,
-0.1122304872,
0.3549656868,
-0.3204863369,
0.3280346096,
0.5368897915,
-0.8288621306,
-0.6859997511,
0.1775500327,
-0.9070693254,
-0.5200831294,
-0.0944008008,
-0.7310566306,
0.2581077218,
0.6937279701,
-0.4621762633,
0.3924058378,
0.4236531854,
-0.7156764865,
0.6853296757,
-0.3153011501,
0.5024736524,
-0.9507976174,
0.6113385558,
0.0585097149,
-0.204748556,
-0.5956847072,
0.1948942095,
0.3656793833,
0.3173063397,
-0.587086916,
0.37471807,
-0.4270253181,
0.051299043,
-0.1956800669,
0.2748923004,
-0.0340121314,
0.3346914351,
0.3050556183,
1.0481684208,
0.8184012175,
-0.7033900023,
0.0776484385,
0.5899657011,
-0.380256325,
0.7896947265,
-0.5009514093,
0.0818168148,
0.1282336712,
-0.0762748122,
-0.7831250429,
-0.692402184,
0.2375606298,
-0.5223546028,
0.359795481,
0.4221827984,
-0.5997971296,
-0.3044120967,
-0.4730440676,
0.3062610328,
0.1081900522,
-0.3003171384,
0.5625540018,
0.5264193416,
-0.1769744605,
-0.6276939511,
-0.5906148553,
0.2628002167,
-0.2163645923,
-0.299346298,
0.3831540644,
-0.0560131222,
-0.3309611082,
-0.0461921766,
0.1444184929,
-0.1761538088,
-0.2139176875,
-0.0324038602,
0.7550463676,
0.0916999951,
0.0691618472,
-0.1108905002,
-0.1019394845,
-0.0373770744,
-0.0328763127,
0.3404968381,
-0.295781523,
0.190907985,
-0.6361166835,
0.3781969547,
0.4185247123,
-0.0242999811,
0.497259587,
0.5651736856,
-0.1572027206,
-0.2748536468,
-0.3626343906,
-0.3963085115,
-0.4475944638,
-0.0847326666,
-0.3803546131,
-0.6012554765,
0.4331336319,
0.1215515882,
0.2021341622,
0.3458587527,
0.7138049006,
-0.6430332065,
0.4744931161,
0.9422307014,
0.2199273109,
0.605776608,
-0.2536371946,
-0.1265398264,
-0.8697680235,
-0.2957977057,
-0.3381052911,
-0.1258095354,
-0.5418191552,
-0.4121422768,
0.1368118972,
-0.1299710423,
0.0780941993,
0.610165298,
-0.5638275743,
0.4482008517,
0.9435580969,
0.3577971756,
0.5383597612,
-0.1052435264,
-0.2074009329,
-0.0194099657,
-0.6989101171,
-0.9051903486,
1.5547348261,
-0.0100114513,
0.3159127533,
-0.1966376305,
0.3615548015,
0.7520002723,
0.6511259079,
-0.8532499075,
0.7249245644,
0.0568039194,
-0.9016814828,
-0.541061759,
-0.1313272864,
-1.2135447264,
0.1724007279,
-0.1313523948,
-0.9638557434,
0.4125451148,
0.0225182641,
-0.272190541,
0.1931995004,
-0.7884960771,
1.2565479279,
-0.0973865986,
-0.5011751056,
-0.1894207448,
-1.0437712669,
0.2433954775,
-0.3819093406,
0.0032671408,
0.258431524,
-0.4372215271,
0.7101127505,
-0.3725850582,
0.8589912057,
0.2996237278,
0.1504802853,
0.7430636287,
0.0650224537,
-0.0178018883,
0.1516748667,
0.2384230047,
0.5611459017,
0.358046025,
-0.734356463,
-0.0705507919,
0.3989859521,
-0.6962558627,
-0.1449023187,
-0.9710503221,
-0.3829929233,
-0.0420507304,
0.5745857954,
0.4445149601,
0.1035406217,
-0.3498776555,
0.4036320746,
0.4245089293,
0.1190227494,
0.4577663541,
0.9521446228,
-0.0377414152,
-0.419016093,
0.7223233581,
0.0747580752,
0.2429451644,
0.4580335617,
-0.0549020283,
-0.1927665323,
-0.4175272584,
-0.427577734,
0.3137440979,
-0.4488079846,
0.2027036101,
-0.4575056732,
0.2574023306,
-0.169944182,
-0.3069684207,
-0.1441088021,
0.0958027542,
-0.3487771451,
-0.1839873344,
0.0326275304,
0.0604616404,
-0.2004078925,
0.5673683882,
-0.2655153871,
0.6585857868,
0.2948850989,
0.3350969255,
-0.6956970096,
-0.1197594926,
-0.2078507692,
-0.2828886509,
-0.3055220842,
-1.0601131916,
0.6349753737,
0.2353075147,
0.0860121921,
0.4507230222,
0.2950030565,
0.25706622,
-0.4887789786,
0.6856408119,
-0.0913643092,
-0.8466974497,
0.4248752594,
-0.3516878188,
0.4397718906,
0.9735944867,
0.3653311133,
-0.1913393885,
-0.6723625064,
-0.5510228276,
-0.7534807324,
0.7585831285,
0.5018330812,
-0.5215531588,
-0.0757169053,
0.1330852956,
0.5480370522,
0.3641795814,
-0.4622837603,
-0.1202528104,
-0.2243992537,
-0.1573596001,
-0.1081218496,
-0.0084070545,
-0.1624558717,
-0.4152938426,
0.6832457781,
-0.3628808558,
0.1485549062,
0.5790898204,
-0.296007514,
-0.3184611797,
0.1502060294,
0.3597259521,
0.7833465338,
-0.552004993,
0.142798692,
0.0992381275,
-1.1309056282,
-0.4563636482,
0.1484732777,
-0.7272112966,
0.0336187594,
0.364269644,
0.500987649,
0.2522384226,
-0.8621492982,
0.1310511976,
-0.0776201785,
-0.333366245,
-0.5818933845,
-0.1979188919,
-0.3941942751,
0.0184202772,
0.5173646212,
-0.0374544002,
0.5891510248,
-0.4894936383,
0.6108971238,
0.114035733,
-0.1435553581,
-0.4055730104,
0.7020736337,
0.276139617,
-0.0719400644,
0.3487506509,
-0.1410914361,
-0.2973994613,
0.5436325669,
-0.0342797711,
0.9452739358,
-0.1484506428,
0.7306209803,
0.4569383264,
0.472953558,
0.1619424969,
0.4544779956,
-0.3567302823,
-0.5132293701,
-0.6480628848,
-0.5447685122,
-0.8474104404,
0.0689789951,
-0.7044357657,
0.5589898229,
-0.1967677623,
-0.3920429051,
0.3828377128,
0.0739409626,
-0.5413460135,
0.1061930209,
0.2639200687,
0.9184911251,
-0.6612734199,
0.9469418526,
0.6182985902,
-0.3119128346,
-0.4779610932,
0.1483811736,
-0.0370679051,
-0.3835529089,
0.3115186989,
0.1644531339,
-0.0928750709,
0.1962134689,
-0.5690761805,
-0.5782472491,
0.8947364688,
0.0726022497,
-0.6928139925,
0.0026361747,
0.197360009,
0.8620986342,
-0.1538156867,
0.1487269998,
0.7238392234,
0.7417294979,
-0.1614366025,
-0.8538797498,
-0.3357109427,
-0.2219808847,
-0.6613298059,
0.2256973684,
-0.8376292586,
0.4782087505,
-0.1028662324,
-0.4844197035,
-0.0532638691,
0.5649734139,
-0.241424188,
0.6090630889,
0.3543021977,
0.4059900343,
0.6822993755,
-0.1825110465,
1.1896657944,
-0.6837378144,
0.3693272769,
0.9036349654,
-0.2276804745,
1.0758699179,
0.6936952472,
-0.2105516344,
0.6392562389,
0.8773540258,
-0.1552079171,
0.6384829283,
-0.5156407356,
-0.2772193551,
-0.2348277569,
0.0673848763,
-0.1402895153,
0.3058570325,
0.2774021924,
-0.0954939276,
0.1731273085,
0.1927134097,
-0.2336172312,
-0.1198446825,
-0.183648929,
0.6587481499,
0.0713120699,
-0.815669179,
0.3617803156,
-0.3797606826,
0.2039057612,
-0.7150456309,
0.2058266103,
0.1052825898,
0.2484108955,
-0.156149745,
-1.1180315018,
0.1011649743,
0.1778491437,
0.1470444053,
0.0471383519,
0.2616799772,
-0.3617537618,
-0.7736420631,
0.1840545982,
0.4884662926,
0.2702503204,
0.2181879878,
-0.3712844551,
-0.2274541557,
-0.2401063591,
-0.6431363225,
0.0852478296,
0.5433661938,
-0.1450509876,
0.7392379642,
0.7418707013,
0.1488759816,
0.0368178785,
0.2823981345,
0.5521870255,
-0.6218265295,
-0.719099164,
-0.6103690267,
0.504437387,
-0.1903972328,
-0.6066057086,
0.9809277058,
0.5419586301,
0.7756569982,
-0.33442083,
0.4344551265,
-0.0309927259,
0.2664379179,
-0.2035855651,
0.5139306784,
-0.487018466,
-0.1871172041,
-0.4688321054,
-1.1606223583,
-0.5067993402,
0.6893939972,
-0.4010622203,
-0.4760617018,
1.2848279476,
0.27360484,
0.0998491868,
0.0950033218,
0.0640196353,
0.001036593,
-0.0936233401,
0.3312148452,
0.1942936778,
-0.163647607,
0.3696337044,
-0.5121856332,
-0.696792841,
-0.3546945453,
-0.5135452747,
-1.0158689022,
-0.5323072672,
-0.610994041,
0.0398973227,
0.0238372814,
0.4816483259,
0.6548829079,
-1.0371514559,
-0.340092212,
-0.5498465896,
-0.4322793484,
-0.504501462,
-0.3365449309,
0.638115108,
-0.3763234615,
-1.0801044703,
0.1354685426,
0.3872398138,
-0.1102062017,
-0.28679353,
0.1707814336,
-0.5349236131,
0.0631948709,
0.5674421191,
0.5924485922,
-0.4923380017,
-0.1427508593,
0.4750907123,
-0.2127240747,
0.1392148137,
0.5833147168,
-0.5898195505,
0.9440665245,
0.4673988521,
0.2127903402,
0.7065653205,
0.1758051664,
0.4784310758,
-0.3855929673,
0.4028491974,
0.4606265128,
0.3181344867,
0.1984327137,
-0.299036026,
0.7717867494,
0.4255584776,
-0.6968356371,
-0.9560260177,
0.0015776367,
-1.5816007853,
-0.3536067903,
0.8967028856,
0.0526059829,
-0.7187182903,
-0.1483162344,
-0.6036602855,
0.4301774204,
-0.5692634583,
1.2571800947,
1.1172708273,
-0.0109272571,
-0.2328721285,
-1.1160829067,
0.4089545906,
0.4181885421,
-1.062713623,
0.0109014548,
0.6002612114,
0.1241683662,
0.2496028692,
0.3346433342,
-0.1438570321,
0.48262012,
0.2757775486,
0.3761917651,
0.2207446545,
-0.6929607987,
0.3185427487,
0.3079710603,
-0.4043693244,
-0.40098387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00891v1
|
A Regularization-based Transfer Learning Method for Information Extraction via Instructed Graph Decoder
| 2024-03-01T13:04:12 | 2024-03-01T13:04:12 |
Kedi Chen, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Shunyu Liu, Liang He
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Information extraction (IE) aims to extract complex structured information
from the text. Numerous datasets have been constructed for various IE tasks,
leading to time-consuming and labor-intensive data annotations. Nevertheless,
most prevailing methods focus on training task-specific models, while the
common knowledge among different IE tasks is not explicitly modeled. Moreover,
the same phrase may have inconsistent labels in different tasks, which poses a
big challenge for knowledge transfer using a unified model. In this study, we
propose a regularization-based transfer learning method for IE (TIE) via an
instructed graph decoder. Specifically, we first construct an instruction pool
for datasets from all well-known IE tasks, and then present an instructed graph
decoder, which decodes various complex structures into a graph uniformly based
on corresponding instructions. In this way, the common knowledge shared with
existing datasets can be learned and transferred to a new dataset with new
labels. Furthermore, to alleviate the label inconsistency problem among various
IE tasks, we introduce a task-specific regularization strategy, which does not
update the gradients of two tasks with 'opposite direction'. We conduct
extensive experiments on 12 datasets spanning four IE tasks, and the results
demonstrate the great advantages of our proposed method
|
[
0.0745345652,
-0.6889997721,
0.0382669456,
0.0083849533,
-0.3071775138,
0.1322710067,
-0.4136758149,
-0.5340735912,
0.0817818567,
0.1275327802,
-0.2721639872,
-0.6565138698,
-1.0257778168,
0.2771506906,
-0.2184871286,
1.0132181644,
-0.4024181068,
-0.1904158741,
0.0759769753,
0.3108571768,
-0.7212080956,
-0.0785882398,
-0.602127254,
-0.1393505484,
0.3875460923,
0.62926507,
-0.0995033085,
1.0005501509,
0.5213671923,
0.1491291076,
0.3699926436,
0.6185734868,
-0.9170078635,
-0.1765535027,
-0.2278250009,
-0.375402689,
-0.0961249918,
0.1001905799,
0.4046733975,
0.8013205528,
0.1986379474,
0.298738569,
0.5573076606,
0.5118405223,
-0.8372142911,
0.848674953,
-0.6565095186,
-0.018467484,
-0.0305747911,
-0.4644878209,
-0.7449141145,
-0.3486011326,
0.1326746047,
-1.1509344578,
0.1308087111,
0.0778697133,
1.1519526243,
0.1713416129,
-0.4867721796,
-0.2762300074,
-0.7371804118,
0.6389178634,
-0.1893910617,
0.4023058116,
0.4865079224,
0.024370404,
0.1156790257,
-0.9703714252,
-0.3022116423,
0.34307459,
-0.3210489154,
0.3275782764,
-0.3370272219,
-0.0810944811,
0.0683122128,
-0.2503381371,
-0.5533588529,
0.0278008152,
-0.5330997705,
-0.0818645507,
0.318135798,
-0.2245512009,
0.2069503069,
-0.0041206074,
-0.6260741949,
-0.2128843814,
-0.2984284759,
0.3386217654,
-0.1993051916,
0.4192164242,
0.0923908576,
0.1152437329,
-0.1265090555,
0.7170596123,
0.422565639,
-0.1201432794,
0.1623364091,
-0.0012162906,
-0.2819862366,
0.3128884435,
0.7472362518,
0.3029841483,
0.532799542,
-0.6333643794,
0.0885402784,
-0.1845940053,
0.0925074443,
-0.7283370495,
-0.3129818439,
-0.2252034992,
-0.2457470894,
-0.0590585768,
0.4812023938,
-0.7130820155,
0.0540439151,
-0.295032531,
0.2319385707,
-0.3859438598,
0.1840967983,
0.1639977545,
-0.045455303,
0.2320687622,
0.4532289207,
-0.6501191258,
0.3488621414,
0.424274832,
0.6109935641,
-0.528748095,
-0.312469393,
-0.8584134579,
0.7077480555,
-0.2535502613,
0.7996432781,
-0.5345652103,
0.074738957,
-0.1120583788,
0.3923664987,
-0.5665920377,
-0.0804211274,
0.2429410368,
-0.6582990289,
0.0512018614,
0.0094339717,
-0.7063676715,
-0.467798382,
0.388694644,
-0.5128410459,
0.7873363495,
0.2010783851,
-0.9990532994,
0.1107390299,
-0.5104742646,
-0.6269791722,
0.1464372426,
-0.2540760636,
-0.1782948673,
-0.5674426556,
0.3104331493,
0.5099990368,
-0.2506982684,
0.1903236061,
-0.0332860239,
-0.6619143486,
-0.2461984009,
-0.2008315027,
0.7228012085,
0.008516429,
-0.5062435269,
-0.245572567,
-0.6091347337,
-0.1203644946,
0.1374814361,
-0.4880990982,
-0.4091058671,
-0.3995690942,
-0.2336216867,
-0.0704607964,
0.3483785093,
-0.6211103201,
0.6561748385,
-0.0857961774,
0.1282992214,
0.971565485,
0.2707353234,
0.4173155427,
-0.0521719567,
0.4001467526,
-0.1771935523,
-0.0867142305,
0.1617985219,
-0.3505392075,
-0.6077239513,
-0.3934741914,
0.6651592255,
1.1653709412,
-0.7703464031,
0.4857925177,
-0.5571093559,
-0.1820894331,
-0.5128563046,
0.0701895058,
0.3863152266,
0.9948291779,
0.5719144344,
-0.0306523573,
-0.3804107904,
-0.5181866288,
-0.203000471,
0.1251352131,
-0.0208143443,
0.2920349836,
0.1052230224,
-0.1551956683,
0.7526774406,
-0.8449234962,
-0.6345385909,
-0.105167456,
0.4699952006,
0.019973116,
0.6424462199,
0.2347972393,
-0.6738753319,
-0.7135877609,
0.4334356189,
-0.9558076859,
0.0983579755,
-0.4015245438,
-0.3234138489,
-0.4559067488,
0.5576328039,
-0.2429800183,
0.5553041697,
0.1833151579,
-0.0817832574,
0.1577477157,
-0.0122258961,
0.2197969109,
-1.1858202219,
0.2291288078,
0.0576125011,
-0.4954225719,
-0.3762531579,
-0.3280741274,
0.0072291587,
-0.0647331998,
-0.0712005496,
0.4758068621,
-0.6592903733,
0.3114272356,
-0.1387170702,
0.2976727188,
0.3575762808,
0.8099383712,
-0.2990268767,
0.5556538105,
0.7479311228,
-0.6218878627,
0.4314005077,
0.5003104806,
0.1475359946,
0.2587183714,
-0.3086749911,
0.7007554173,
-0.4119944274,
0.0746103525,
-0.9769245386,
0.0240585003,
0.5221097469,
-0.4518856108,
0.9550048113,
-0.444008708,
-0.1388468295,
-0.096658498,
-0.0411376208,
0.0868775249,
0.3995874226,
-0.4537602365,
0.6707453132,
0.1782813966,
-0.3573608398,
-0.7491355538,
-0.4940428734,
-0.1438290179,
-0.0661632046,
-0.4978121817,
0.5172284245,
-0.0286242776,
0.2982618213,
0.303940028,
-0.4069121778,
-0.5653731823,
0.2032887489,
-0.0329320394,
0.2149705887,
-0.0595897883,
0.0300441068,
0.3477859199,
-0.1578056216,
-0.2582763135,
-0.4745305479,
0.0458769463,
0.0636572242,
-0.0146817109,
-1.0002235174,
0.3551002145,
0.1194717959,
-0.390399456,
0.5176939964,
0.7491560578,
-0.4977460802,
-0.0353554748,
-0.1498844922,
-0.2494744509,
-0.3769395947,
0.4478967488,
-0.5357041359,
-0.662283659,
0.2229121923,
-0.7241239548,
0.1945034266,
0.2663559914,
-0.2730964124,
-0.2732500434,
0.9041371942,
0.9365077615,
-0.3059701324,
0.6463230848,
-0.5779483914,
0.0860401392,
-0.8000090122,
-0.3527824283,
-0.4546113014,
-0.3926202655,
0.0117328083,
-0.0155657222,
0.0079066688,
0.7003631592,
0.0017405852,
0.3725482225,
-0.5677425861,
0.3595140576,
0.3547956347,
0.4747457206,
0.2223068923,
0.4832942784,
0.1272478998,
0.165533036,
-0.7688005567,
-0.2154842615,
0.9531747699,
0.0153363375,
0.7616174221,
-0.2399067581,
0.779145658,
0.5986942053,
0.3277952969,
-0.7238186002,
0.1607401818,
-0.3110462725,
0.4432865083,
-0.4081172943,
-0.5917586088,
-1.387614727,
-0.136336416,
-0.1477440298,
-0.9747102261,
0.5904601812,
-0.0422249548,
0.1024531499,
0.209583059,
-0.6771898866,
0.6887435913,
0.250263989,
-0.2373887748,
0.4205877185,
-0.7772821188,
-0.1712166071,
-0.0088996086,
0.2595048845,
0.1327929795,
0.2499940544,
1.091378212,
0.0901856869,
0.8047624826,
-0.3164840937,
0.1427343041,
0.2075114548,
0.2665573955,
1.2987602949,
-0.2533772886,
-0.063160561,
-0.0219192058,
-0.4175792933,
-0.3908787072,
-0.7850986719,
0.2912327349,
-0.7943557501,
-0.3503214121,
0.020218337,
-0.6821383834,
-0.1834068,
0.634085834,
0.5326399803,
0.3874664307,
0.1706921458,
0.1303588152,
0.6283493042,
0.4946516752,
0.1159698814,
0.3133846521,
0.5510234237,
-0.2639742792,
1.1305574179,
0.2078708708,
-0.0393322892,
0.6024623513,
0.2359380871,
0.0496325046,
-0.4000395834,
-0.2915149629,
0.0404475518,
-0.8316512108,
-0.5432895422,
-0.7634372711,
-0.0525991619,
-0.5883689523,
-0.2694417536,
-0.2518358529,
-0.1622271389,
-0.5637549758,
-0.1675210446,
0.2283646017,
0.5808573961,
0.1770167202,
0.0734429955,
-0.8119368553,
0.2082184851,
0.3289515674,
0.0011267614,
-0.2045571804,
-0.5457637906,
-0.2534838617,
0.035403084,
0.008920854,
-1.115111351,
0.0092067942,
0.3578880429,
0.6313358545,
0.512910068,
0.522508502,
0.6672736406,
-0.2695558965,
0.2081428468,
0.0448324382,
-0.7767851949,
0.4323576391,
-0.0510981306,
-0.1936727315,
0.5866823196,
0.6853918433,
-0.1612264067,
-0.2337263077,
-0.503934145,
-0.7027800679,
0.8825165033,
0.1805389673,
-0.3129841387,
0.0196695235,
0.5357584357,
0.1394848824,
-0.0384677611,
-0.7701402307,
-0.3582448959,
-0.1168228909,
-0.428358674,
0.369346112,
0.1287446171,
-0.1253741384,
-0.1378159523,
0.678574264,
-0.4219661057,
0.2783443928,
0.5256857276,
-0.5272066593,
-0.0301942751,
0.1627753377,
0.1804390848,
0.6418110728,
-0.264264822,
0.2145909369,
0.002199908,
-0.5364647508,
0.157055214,
0.4916866124,
-0.295727849,
0.0087747714,
0.4585749209,
0.8116976023,
-0.0719910935,
-0.1185447201,
0.8080893159,
0.0053441008,
-0.149122715,
0.3417592347,
-0.223023802,
-0.235428825,
0.026378613,
0.4209646583,
0.1365093887,
0.284665525,
-0.0745986998,
0.3425507545,
0.0404150262,
-0.6181405187,
-0.1486335546,
0.291097939,
0.1312464774,
-0.1430471092,
0.8101690412,
-0.4488895833,
-0.3112615645,
0.5867398977,
0.9027553797,
0.7610270381,
-0.2617092431,
0.0594486296,
0.4228782058,
0.3306235075,
0.1134695634,
0.1237551197,
-0.0931065902,
-0.5954551697,
-0.5270759463,
-0.1181635782,
0.1667843014,
-0.0728815049,
-1.0648248196,
0.1677146256,
-0.1847764999,
0.2094925046,
-0.1924960911,
-0.2676600814,
-0.8471701741,
0.0604652464,
-0.1089275703,
0.7240103483,
-0.7892548442,
0.7896750569,
0.6274777651,
-0.2413288951,
-1.1138269901,
0.112415269,
-0.4250690937,
-0.7264498472,
0.789714992,
0.2558967471,
-0.2378307879,
0.4754209518,
-0.6024820209,
-0.7277433872,
1.2687563896,
0.6722621322,
-0.6584179401,
-0.3860206604,
-0.2696636617,
-0.0738087818,
-0.4727985561,
-0.167642653,
0.1477149427,
0.5109740496,
0.0898807347,
-0.6110427976,
0.2292927504,
-0.2790332735,
-0.2608940601,
0.0813029781,
-0.5204965472,
0.6809459329,
-0.2001919448,
-0.586366415,
-0.4347051084,
0.6273006201,
-0.257750839,
0.0943868607,
0.4569898844,
0.0605578683,
1.1848590374,
0.2057875842,
0.8720828295,
-0.413852185,
0.7506750822,
1.2903300524,
-0.0968969837,
0.4823525548,
0.3163845241,
0.0772751197,
0.5089532733,
0.5493038297,
-0.1689845622,
0.6343528628,
0.1244537532,
0.0345398411,
-0.2358935475,
-0.3159978986,
-0.2321792841,
0.5012347102,
0.2441068739,
-0.1750876904,
-0.46083197,
0.2029516399,
0.1337607801,
-0.1312855482,
-0.3038676977,
1.1397141218,
-0.2471802682,
-0.3707968593,
0.7498978972,
-0.0704892352,
0.3117661476,
-0.6912102103,
-0.6428278089,
-0.1459298134,
-0.0925201625,
-0.2312064022,
-0.4042232633,
-0.0326555632,
-0.1156457737,
-0.2604433,
-0.143659994,
0.99165833,
-0.5689203739,
-0.2203501761,
0.3035990596,
0.2234157473,
0.3854491711,
0.0556471571,
-0.5665051341,
-0.2157052755,
0.4275245667,
-0.1327130198,
0.1022584438,
0.545263648,
-0.0684529617,
0.2850722075,
0.6475280523,
0.1346452981,
0.1992328167,
-0.3883196414,
0.9248363972,
-0.3289312422,
-0.6891155243,
-0.4725297689,
0.3468422592,
-0.1080100536,
-0.0118781859,
0.5115140676,
0.5776734948,
0.7811358571,
-0.0687900707,
0.9579367042,
0.0062955366,
0.1023951843,
-0.6722199917,
0.4194253385,
-0.1920345724,
0.0823100358,
-0.3157721162,
-0.918956399,
-0.1520189196,
0.6550917029,
-0.1293021441,
-0.3142067492,
0.7534710169,
0.342382282,
-0.2722513378,
-0.2161408216,
0.006648954,
0.1656913161,
0.2942916155,
0.727473855,
0.2325982898,
-0.6002845764,
0.8012108803,
-0.1313735396,
-0.6601822376,
-0.0886764526,
-0.725835979,
-0.6477107406,
-0.3577013016,
-0.5780414343,
-0.3657541871,
0.4092520475,
0.6565494537,
0.8732979894,
-0.5851888061,
0.127611205,
-0.2355773151,
0.1195961908,
-0.5564785004,
-0.3418363035,
0.9984418154,
-0.369207263,
-0.7406689525,
0.4471383095,
0.0938220099,
0.1207356229,
0.5258404016,
0.1968591213,
-0.5561965108,
-0.2850133777,
0.2399321049,
0.4540032148,
-0.2137037963,
-0.5501279831,
-0.1171902791,
-0.1746359318,
0.3850391209,
0.6257354617,
-0.4860613048,
0.6788570285,
0.4221880138,
1.1457320452,
0.6891655922,
0.1683321744,
0.3604499996,
-1.1272251606,
0.1066523641,
-0.0128580937,
0.1286589652,
0.1640950292,
-0.9523010254,
0.5000163913,
0.457806468,
-0.1778283566,
-0.4590356946,
0.0948337093,
-1.1402076483,
-0.2210424095,
0.9305325747,
-0.8243173957,
-0.2953046858,
-0.345687896,
-0.1533256918,
0.758782804,
-0.4669517875,
0.6418651938,
0.2925498188,
-0.2716040909,
0.0081696352,
-0.0756377801,
0.307903111,
-0.1490405053,
-0.9718837738,
0.1310156137,
0.0464410186,
0.5830609798,
0.3173440099,
0.528480649,
0.2508568168,
0.1153675318,
-0.0749730542,
0.216872856,
-0.5661893487,
-0.6475293636,
-0.0149665056,
0.1914393157,
-0.3269861639,
-0.6451550126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00499v1
|
Do Zombies Understand? A Choose-Your-Own-Adventure Exploration of Machine Cognition
| 2024-03-01T12:42:47 | 2024-03-01T12:42:47 |
Ariel Goldstein, Gabriel Stanovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in LLMs have sparked a debate on whether they understand
text. In this position paper, we argue that opponents in this debate hold
different definitions for understanding, and particularly differ in their view
on the role of consciousness. To substantiate this claim, we propose a thought
experiment involving an open-source chatbot $Z$ which excels on every possible
benchmark, seemingly without subjective experience. We ask whether $Z$ is
capable of understanding, and show that different schools of thought within
seminal AI research seem to answer this question differently, uncovering their
terminological disagreement. Moving forward, we propose two distinct working
definitions for understanding which explicitly acknowledge the question of
consciousness, and draw connections with a rich literature in philosophy,
psychology and neuroscience.
|
[
-0.5013532043,
-0.6207301021,
1.0546078682,
0.0083984928,
-0.38636145,
0.1653317064,
-0.2603121996,
-0.7237740755,
0.312318176,
0.3195617795,
-0.7042861581,
-0.1357193142,
-0.6119692922,
0.3370953798,
0.0033198735,
0.7736554146,
0.0622163452,
0.0004245308,
-0.5582897067,
-0.0126104774,
-0.2528790832,
-0.4853727221,
-0.8045241833,
-0.550133884,
0.7687739134,
0.2414362729,
0.7945263982,
0.3263176978,
0.4006306529,
0.4094898701,
-0.050741002,
-0.0229764096,
-0.4639017284,
-0.018121101,
-0.1344225258,
-0.8877956271,
-0.0818256959,
-0.1621775478,
0.3483015001,
0.7638438344,
0.1843294799,
-0.0452343859,
-0.1938794255,
0.5140971541,
-0.6535611749,
-0.085813731,
-0.6924727559,
0.421972543,
0.2183971256,
-0.0442308411,
-0.5569343567,
0.3080866337,
-0.048111055,
-0.5029822588,
0.2671848238,
0.0610199869,
0.5287914872,
0.4534038007,
-0.3912452459,
-0.2884941697,
-0.661534667,
0.4549813867,
-0.5239885449,
0.3119358122,
0.4466153085,
0.4453828931,
0.009458649,
-0.4773611426,
-1.0629153252,
-0.035519626,
0.0786732361,
0.6184997559,
-0.3610002697,
0.1429691613,
0.0126813529,
0.4843125343,
-0.4877294302,
0.2613558471,
-0.4321295321,
-0.1759628952,
0.6161645651,
-0.0242989212,
0.6066803336,
-0.3356201351,
-0.7739523649,
0.1860924959,
0.1673384756,
0.1158224866,
0.3177556396,
-0.1051405966,
-0.2601124644,
0.652535975,
0.0177775957,
0.9255415797,
-0.5547642112,
0.3432616889,
0.2362839133,
0.0201816987,
-0.7086367011,
-0.0269139111,
0.6463356018,
0.5961815119,
0.4258819818,
-0.6068649888,
-0.1407462656,
0.0348461419,
0.8005586863,
-0.2344553918,
-0.5262015462,
0.5853614807,
-0.5492453575,
0.0874033943,
-0.1916000843,
-0.1962456554,
-0.6224067807,
-0.2528160512,
0.4916037321,
-0.4788561761,
-0.3696986735,
0.5476688743,
-0.677698791,
0.1882282794,
0.8198367357,
-0.6447986364,
0.0379256085,
0.6207872033,
1.0814502239,
-0.3636829853,
-0.1746873856,
0.1718731523,
-0.0313933939,
-0.4391391277,
1.1243752241,
-0.4060474336,
-0.7167797685,
-0.4141234457,
-0.1069567502,
-0.2398249954,
-0.2631530464,
0.3720319867,
-0.49550125,
0.2104109824,
-0.2044580728,
-0.4330511391,
-0.550675869,
0.1851693094,
-0.238236323,
0.2499385029,
-0.0132860709,
-0.5937457085,
0.2183889598,
-0.4815491438,
-0.0320687592,
0.3141211271,
-0.3528035581,
0.3896461129,
0.3135307133,
-0.2444308996,
0.304207921,
0.261549294,
-0.2760257125,
-0.1870386302,
-0.3796770275,
0.7127339244,
-0.3448093832,
0.9035499096,
0.0252076592,
0.0935012326,
0.0037824139,
-0.643915832,
0.270931989,
0.225508824,
0.1301798224,
-0.4420415759,
0.3975627422,
-0.2485392839,
0.1781024784,
0.3517413735,
-0.5916237831,
0.039609842,
-0.5876126289,
0.7243055105,
0.9761582613,
-0.0604398847,
0.6186408401,
-0.4511688352,
0.2961936295,
0.0500379764,
0.0382987522,
-0.1880224347,
-0.6910507679,
-0.8579413891,
-0.1019869819,
-0.1079435274,
0.5789167881,
-0.4724678695,
0.3791809976,
0.0850638822,
-0.4885499179,
-0.7737369537,
0.0091632977,
0.1415766031,
0.7499372959,
0.601203084,
-0.3498539031,
-0.4156901836,
-1.0916427374,
-0.2046062201,
-0.435161829,
-0.4376512468,
0.6342125535,
0.4655437768,
-0.3560832143,
0.9281446934,
-0.5633651018,
0.0846957564,
-0.2963074446,
-0.0215815976,
-0.0578349978,
0.3936829567,
0.3905652165,
-0.7103807926,
0.1033620089,
0.0665942654,
-1.0219976902,
0.3513831496,
-0.3262841403,
-0.1730057299,
-0.5107045174,
0.3111287951,
-0.4482189119,
0.5236389041,
0.3170881867,
-0.4246615171,
-0.1283183396,
-0.5891683698,
0.0341402926,
-0.7775921822,
-0.4717729688,
-0.2667017281,
-0.1519121677,
-0.6279763579,
-0.0943748429,
0.1134197041,
0.2807600796,
-0.4741734266,
0.3301896751,
-0.2696011662,
-0.5246321559,
-0.464170903,
1.0585186481,
0.0677464604,
0.4409686625,
0.164422527,
0.7419762611,
0.3746478856,
-0.7937927246,
-0.0487376302,
0.4323101044,
-0.5429012775,
0.236267224,
-0.6258510947,
0.7324519753,
-0.5984307528,
0.2071666867,
-1.4146085978,
-0.0543215461,
0.5205232501,
-0.8931568861,
-0.4209661782,
-0.0375756323,
-0.1947210282,
-0.2124228179,
0.1564950049,
0.0902347863,
0.6657119393,
-0.1002140939,
0.4970500171,
0.4058776796,
0.3789974451,
-0.4877541959,
-1.140298605,
0.2504752576,
0.0673480928,
-0.4902460277,
0.2686347961,
-0.4601389468,
-1.101198554,
-0.1432702541,
-0.1523585767,
-0.1604641676,
0.3997350335,
0.5003170371,
0.0477658771,
-0.2353071272,
0.4308983088,
-0.069128938,
-0.0384332091,
0.1484665722,
-0.3185812831,
0.4767414927,
0.262141943,
-0.3629250526,
-0.473754853,
-0.0129044121,
0.2596108913,
-0.0246196147,
0.5152782202,
0.2003708333,
-0.1803000867,
-0.3380190134,
-0.2553105354,
0.1761398166,
-0.4835054278,
0.0431517176,
-0.3699988127,
-0.6421772242,
0.6333877444,
0.1378438175,
0.1503687352,
0.5983438492,
0.6859670281,
-0.6442113519,
0.5367705822,
0.7509146333,
0.3884107769,
0.207248196,
-0.0631081015,
0.1204219386,
-0.8458881974,
-0.4721619487,
-0.4992889464,
-0.6128207445,
-0.2900294662,
-0.6276499629,
-0.0104788691,
0.0981111452,
-0.1371343136,
0.1188592315,
-0.4556987882,
0.4583733976,
-0.0017907271,
0.4066218436,
0.3195349574,
-0.4811494052,
0.1348337978,
0.226380527,
-0.5002600551,
-0.8273586631,
0.6483931541,
0.02066564,
0.2846385241,
0.2036782801,
0.6563277841,
0.5949833989,
0.1042495444,
-0.8981798887,
0.5945337415,
0.3366377652,
-0.5105718374,
-0.2655099928,
-0.0628876165,
-1.0489372015,
0.5944335461,
0.0585207678,
-1.0065978765,
0.1702620685,
-0.2451121956,
-0.482457757,
0.7511050701,
-1.1206297874,
0.6844374537,
-0.2622469664,
0.1638149172,
-0.3982816935,
-0.7355373502,
0.4245656431,
0.2340431213,
0.4804565609,
-0.428824842,
-0.8205621839,
0.8406339884,
0.0022766897,
0.7319339514,
0.1255236119,
-0.3537308872,
0.3515521288,
0.0689219683,
-0.2809667885,
0.3450141549,
-0.2511948049,
0.373669982,
-0.2053468078,
-0.5690684915,
-0.7523865104,
0.2081077099,
-1.046557188,
-0.7799987793,
-0.2701367438,
-0.5345575809,
-0.1014466658,
0.1960430741,
0.2805328667,
-0.0942174643,
-0.3423272371,
-0.085089758,
0.7411760092,
-0.1488389969,
0.694681704,
0.6330451965,
-0.1638152897,
-0.1150685251,
0.5092049837,
-0.0605869032,
0.4913767278,
0.5284599662,
-0.0142282574,
0.1213805079,
-0.6309639812,
-0.620213449,
-0.1434641927,
-1.1392998695,
0.2350787818,
-1.2043280602,
-0.2853340805,
0.1181758195,
-0.4196253419,
0.0188828129,
-0.2639774382,
-0.5182363987,
-0.2835428715,
0.4784792066,
1.0158653259,
-0.0519451238,
0.4173337817,
-0.6468061805,
0.5241408348,
0.3783873618,
-0.0257047098,
0.2991962731,
-0.4295085967,
-0.137448445,
0.2895250022,
0.015396188,
-1.1791679859,
0.0466231294,
-0.1986173391,
0.628041327,
0.5181523561,
0.1060460731,
0.4212842882,
-0.5910716057,
1.1574503183,
0.1879965365,
-1.0779211521,
0.6417966485,
0.0581703968,
0.1651171595,
0.5259586573,
0.3768971264,
-0.6587908268,
-0.4140748978,
-0.8886763453,
-0.3389533758,
0.4311822355,
0.3369333148,
0.4808869958,
-0.1766663939,
0.526843071,
0.4093438685,
0.1161942706,
-0.577998817,
-0.2271606773,
-0.0453436486,
0.2047014087,
-0.6725296974,
-0.0034635973,
-0.0007581432,
-0.0251092464,
-0.0723736659,
0.05867498,
0.5895800591,
0.5095088482,
-0.228118673,
-0.1259610653,
0.0770684257,
0.532022953,
0.9955933094,
0.032259915,
0.4057292938,
0.2078255713,
-0.6956111789,
0.0215895399,
-0.6427179575,
-0.0385885835,
-0.0325943232,
0.5208941698,
0.7696617246,
0.176407665,
-0.8101517558,
0.2496817559,
-0.3074357212,
-0.2123327851,
-0.3701671064,
0.7227411866,
0.1921985298,
0.3802530468,
0.3103676438,
0.6943356395,
0.0712385923,
-0.5659706593,
0.2004116774,
0.427628547,
-0.5796935558,
-0.2098213136,
0.5156969428,
-0.0076028197,
-1.1167067289,
0.5552809834,
-0.0622402541,
-0.3691236675,
1.1566954851,
0.3215662241,
1.0022270679,
0.1628263295,
0.1489619017,
-0.0427640863,
0.600697279,
0.3569783568,
0.5086113214,
-0.5999351144,
-1.3102869987,
-0.3139187992,
-0.2317404896,
-0.7897593379,
-0.1153119057,
-0.4301649332,
-0.0295029469,
-0.4821781814,
-0.1426088065,
0.2900575101,
-0.2781870365,
-0.6406069994,
0.3112778664,
0.2727704048,
1.0279374123,
-0.3956270218,
0.6242788434,
0.3980299234,
-0.6087207198,
-0.0350599252,
0.4994141459,
-0.261158824,
-1.1510570049,
0.5783891678,
0.0979395732,
-0.3708501756,
0.1422077268,
-0.6978180408,
-0.5470142961,
0.8249640465,
0.0853204876,
-0.2944218516,
-0.0845471919,
-0.7162871957,
0.4003956616,
-0.3556268513,
0.417722106,
0.111657083,
0.4450864792,
-0.2524796128,
-0.3853968084,
-0.5500978231,
-0.0456963181,
-0.2405566573,
-0.0124058761,
-0.8505374789,
0.7696319818,
-0.6493800879,
-0.2358847111,
-0.1800332814,
0.9382654428,
-0.5089191794,
0.7121191025,
0.5311093926,
0.3216651976,
0.9357395172,
0.2064507306,
0.8928486705,
-0.1420506686,
0.0794398636,
1.0084084272,
-0.0652921796,
0.9145413041,
0.2910382152,
-0.452358216,
0.6984552145,
1.0233995914,
0.3311598003,
0.3214247525,
0.3204059601,
-0.330394417,
-0.6728942394,
0.4563259482,
-0.2832776904,
0.6144494414,
0.4949359596,
-0.3497046232,
-0.1093164161,
0.3046735227,
-0.318269819,
0.1581631452,
-0.3741425276,
1.1027028561,
0.2161754966,
-0.4400925636,
0.3127071857,
-0.1593174189,
0.3303164542,
-0.4589734375,
0.1683326662,
0.0643117577,
-0.1646336764,
-0.1987238675,
-1.0685696602,
0.1613233835,
-0.0409443602,
-0.1044031531,
-0.3895972073,
0.6132362485,
0.1634833515,
-0.2060520351,
0.4090740383,
0.9105495214,
0.6685916185,
0.3168809712,
-0.5817662477,
0.1749631166,
0.0145828491,
0.1627424657,
0.1666439176,
0.6453425288,
0.5538678765,
0.8440726399,
0.4124691486,
-0.2377623916,
-0.181417793,
-0.3370812833,
0.6608836055,
-0.6317901611,
-0.4797757268,
-1.1829324961,
0.3625639975,
-0.1416530311,
-0.5393972397,
1.0006642342,
0.4534257054,
0.9904158711,
0.0686990991,
1.0325478315,
-0.0852239206,
0.0585409366,
-0.42764166,
0.7701500058,
-0.6557314396,
-0.1826852709,
-0.0485524535,
-0.3386588693,
-0.0753337443,
0.8920327425,
-0.5634733438,
-0.0710169226,
0.426312536,
0.0799883902,
0.1124944389,
0.6189274192,
0.6370633841,
0.1898641139,
-0.224945873,
0.6727258563,
1.0107200146,
0.0621153004,
-0.0122979134,
0.0429757386,
-0.3191436827,
-0.0208922178,
-0.5166462064,
-1.0533072948,
-0.7426370382,
-0.1864334643,
-0.3065150976,
-0.0063646417,
0.899308145,
0.3282870948,
-0.2472293973,
-0.2504436076,
-0.3358841538,
0.6700023413,
-0.2724154592,
-0.0632690042,
0.0614647493,
-0.8012752533,
-0.7824821472,
0.4999529719,
0.6398895383,
0.1489688009,
-0.5226435065,
0.1157017872,
-0.1738345921,
0.4301650822,
0.5353953242,
0.1889934391,
-0.8438957334,
-0.3946845829,
-0.0405738205,
-0.0372800566,
0.5663548112,
1.0018532276,
-1.0419082642,
0.84503299,
0.536241293,
0.7825374603,
0.3058291078,
-0.3307393193,
0.44023633,
0.0988449603,
0.2363677621,
0.4826476276,
0.158645913,
0.0865418389,
-0.5386326909,
0.4260475338,
0.2596961558,
-0.4468418956,
-0.5864837766,
0.5209980607,
-1.1147192717,
-0.6823474765,
0.8770309091,
-0.0096625248,
-0.5383173227,
-0.4239952564,
-0.2756682336,
0.3180904388,
0.0279840026,
0.5411915779,
0.7767617702,
-0.4885978997,
-0.2053857595,
-1.1542652845,
0.4737824202,
0.1937624365,
-0.4190936089,
0.0007832597,
0.1222555786,
-0.0575501025,
0.0724225938,
0.9721043706,
0.3793211877,
-0.0883900523,
0.0434397422,
-0.0489867516,
0.3081064224,
-0.0077230176,
-0.2950154543,
0.095878154,
-0.0727255717,
-0.4459202588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00888v1
|
Margin Discrepancy-based Adversarial Training for Multi-Domain Text Classification
| 2024-03-01T11:54:14 | 2024-03-01T11:54:14 |
Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-domain text classification (MDTC) endeavors to harness available
resources from correlated domains to enhance the classification accuracy of the
target domain. Presently, most MDTC approaches that embrace adversarial
training and the shared-private paradigm exhibit cutting-edge performance.
Unfortunately, these methods face a non-negligible challenge: the absence of
theoretical guarantees in the design of MDTC algorithms. The dearth of
theoretical underpinning poses a substantial impediment to the advancement of
MDTC algorithms. To tackle this problem, we first provide a theoretical
analysis of MDTC by decomposing the MDTC task into multiple domain adaptation
tasks. We incorporate the margin discrepancy as the measure of domain
divergence and establish a new generalization bound based on Rademacher
complexity. Subsequently, we propose a margin discrepancy-based adversarial
training (MDAT) approach for MDTC, in accordance with our theoretical analysis.
To validate the efficacy of the proposed MDAT method, we conduct empirical
studies on two MDTC benchmarks. The experimental results demonstrate that our
MDAT approach surpasses state-of-the-art baselines on both datasets.
|
[
-0.4681847394,
-0.7744550109,
0.4601492882,
-0.0737034753,
-0.0160059929,
0.4899042547,
-0.2682061195,
-0.2451774627,
-0.419262439,
0.2858247757,
-0.6422196031,
-0.5471081138,
-1.109647274,
-0.033991389,
0.088298887,
1.1147252321,
-0.4128032029,
-0.11804948,
-0.0300627165,
-0.6564941406,
-0.4453763068,
-0.7648791671,
-0.420235455,
-0.0706646442,
0.4199516177,
0.3442314863,
0.4902878702,
0.6371011734,
0.5658427477,
0.206515491,
0.0793013573,
0.7814968228,
-0.1488981098,
-0.0168006811,
0.0395478569,
-0.3997781873,
-0.2648009658,
0.1836473495,
0.3094675541,
0.339407891,
-0.3260948956,
-0.3185269237,
0.3715614676,
0.9173336625,
-0.8403161168,
0.0675303116,
-0.481096983,
-0.019169271,
-0.2819741666,
-0.4084074795,
-0.7151437998,
-0.3645620644,
0.1824363172,
-0.7512267232,
0.7016477585,
-0.2115354985,
0.8043587804,
0.2605769038,
-0.9683535695,
-0.4528405964,
-0.8140990734,
0.8722240329,
-0.3248337507,
0.3927140236,
0.2981427014,
0.3393655121,
-0.0039013103,
-0.4954890311,
-0.3401946127,
0.096933268,
0.2814626992,
0.2365697473,
-0.4312404394,
0.0347145647,
-0.052017767,
0.3363865912,
-0.7218459845,
0.1269576699,
-0.1161349043,
-0.0114826756,
0.3468295038,
0.0395670719,
0.0471216701,
0.4520392418,
-0.801158011,
-0.4832039475,
-0.5620007515,
0.0423242971,
0.5562059283,
0.2804934382,
-0.0268945862,
0.1290999949,
0.1276172847,
0.3356785774,
0.2124085277,
0.0483870283,
0.1323433369,
-0.0274078753,
-0.1175677255,
-0.0143563226,
0.5904338956,
0.3235608935,
-0.0412986949,
0.0295016039,
0.0235855747,
0.1687025875,
0.5369650126,
-0.58222574,
-0.2812232375,
0.0752980709,
-0.2937554717,
-0.3594045937,
0.2513036132,
-0.8805798292,
-0.7658557296,
-0.2783825099,
0.3438435197,
-0.4959892035,
-0.3517372608,
0.1041196361,
-0.0572373718,
-0.4026956558,
0.4212830961,
-0.6091974974,
0.3967804611,
0.5549221039,
0.9028277397,
-0.514210999,
-0.3435724378,
-0.0644389242,
-0.0069132159,
-0.2019530982,
0.8757957816,
-0.2833750844,
-0.4034709334,
0.0959395543,
-0.3311453164,
-0.438334614,
-0.4063392878,
0.8872035742,
-0.6466451287,
0.1719769984,
-0.2188206315,
-0.4573739767,
-0.5074671507,
0.4868064821,
-0.7377992272,
0.5552120209,
-0.0108723743,
-1.2182226181,
0.4187405109,
-0.5580586791,
-0.5317146182,
-0.3526490033,
-0.0881261677,
-0.8855562806,
0.0435012691,
0.3973169029,
0.441018194,
-0.2230239213,
0.1003530622,
-0.3251356184,
-0.2257001549,
0.5401076674,
-1.0487213135,
0.766960144,
0.2282167673,
-0.4336761236,
-0.1454709619,
-0.7911278605,
-0.0624106377,
0.0195922665,
-0.3552512527,
-0.6230889559,
-0.1920181364,
0.0643386245,
0.0308095701,
-0.0890181959,
-0.3080289066,
0.4145648181,
-0.2096017748,
0.1889068484,
0.9875366688,
0.119064942,
0.4952027202,
-0.5146463513,
0.4616567492,
0.203937456,
0.0059126709,
0.278119266,
-0.2529032826,
-0.6244319677,
-0.5486386418,
0.5164300799,
0.5657080412,
-0.9805628657,
0.2189880162,
-0.1110816523,
-0.4613271654,
-0.2546193302,
-0.2914078832,
0.3975892067,
0.119987987,
0.6722605824,
-0.2005663067,
-0.5459046364,
-0.7130385637,
-0.2768650949,
0.0492519327,
0.2862889767,
0.1506614536,
0.2746765316,
-0.2478930056,
0.6218776703,
-0.7466086149,
-0.7800283432,
-0.1002020314,
0.3951639533,
-0.1214951575,
0.3649791777,
0.4563318491,
-1.0432186127,
-0.5396161675,
0.1802919358,
-0.6176823974,
0.4201002419,
-0.2489874661,
0.1234124154,
0.4519360662,
-0.048866082,
-0.4769816697,
0.5832969546,
0.5957942605,
0.0364401825,
0.6639059782,
-0.3811510205,
0.5004063845,
-0.843397975,
-0.2551352978,
0.2512580156,
0.1361064613,
-0.8737887144,
-0.0376843624,
0.3286775649,
0.2318005264,
-0.0957260802,
0.2512097955,
-0.422909826,
0.5188550949,
-0.4669618309,
-0.1644614786,
0.1305568516,
0.638066411,
-0.0706886724,
0.9041880369,
0.4745299518,
-0.9215270281,
-0.0406626128,
0.1633142382,
0.1850042939,
0.8259673119,
-0.0946961492,
0.1365357339,
0.2301718444,
0.5350505114,
-0.772095561,
0.0799221098,
0.1808777153,
-0.6867184043,
0.5925939083,
-0.1884931177,
-0.3251141012,
-0.2065953016,
-0.3334307671,
0.4852750897,
0.2036938369,
-0.8045712709,
0.6106035709,
0.3440170288,
0.1611235887,
-1.1363258362,
-0.6983730793,
-0.0573661663,
-0.3727881014,
-0.3893719316,
0.3735990524,
0.0386864692,
0.0116040651,
-0.2708919942,
-0.4174555838,
-0.4062649012,
0.1344095916,
0.3256049156,
0.125009954,
-0.1039348766,
0.0047746152,
0.2323669046,
-0.0684724972,
-0.0769810081,
-0.5557376742,
0.2712191939,
-0.1571249217,
-0.4326909184,
-0.4119740725,
0.2713122964,
0.4723924398,
-0.2532882392,
0.6630109549,
0.6327722669,
-0.2503218949,
-0.6080958843,
-0.4940005839,
0.2123463303,
-0.4478435814,
0.2044525594,
-0.5009042621,
-0.6690897942,
0.277585566,
-0.2846087813,
-0.1421509087,
0.5529153347,
0.3388946354,
0.2059892863,
0.9779528379,
0.7546207905,
0.2458216101,
0.1986419559,
-0.5684178472,
0.0193419978,
-0.7567029595,
-0.0150359767,
-0.5352423787,
-0.0062831091,
-0.5624337196,
-0.2230993658,
0.0910156146,
-0.1806288809,
-0.2151517123,
0.5334861875,
-0.5956546664,
0.3554772735,
0.6402286291,
0.282974124,
0.2945732176,
0.2164634317,
-0.216601789,
-0.2144295275,
-0.6489735842,
-0.2742784321,
1.1833382845,
0.2808153927,
0.6158719659,
0.3255953789,
0.5770677924,
0.57490623,
0.3059590757,
-0.4347864985,
0.1324222982,
-0.4928932786,
-0.4144600928,
0.1169493943,
-0.6575371027,
-0.8150709271,
0.3150890768,
0.106262669,
-0.2940477133,
0.554925561,
-0.1268061101,
-0.0251302607,
0.7428879142,
-0.5869647861,
0.6610934734,
-0.0666542649,
-0.1540791094,
-0.2201101184,
-0.5423896313,
0.3734788299,
-0.2526632547,
0.2871361673,
0.1475675702,
0.0723979101,
0.7719740272,
-0.1692582965,
0.7948074341,
-0.468134284,
-0.1654466093,
0.2150183469,
0.2515526116,
0.5090095401,
-0.0921761468,
0.0597848184,
0.3670785427,
-0.1670020968,
-0.3751353621,
-0.5313493013,
0.6033179164,
-0.9896050096,
-0.3222663403,
-0.8753196001,
-0.5077166557,
-0.555277884,
0.0645706877,
0.4225378335,
0.4034182429,
-0.4077358544,
0.0241736341,
0.7594425678,
-0.124040857,
0.2434409857,
0.4185082912,
0.6866445541,
-0.6115958095,
0.9863647819,
0.0810176954,
0.2209377438,
0.6103734374,
0.041629646,
-0.523516953,
-0.8708121181,
-0.4438108504,
-0.1601966172,
-0.8317947388,
-0.5483008623,
-0.5862526298,
-0.2509017289,
-0.3143234551,
-0.2177636921,
-0.3164484203,
-0.4215739667,
-0.4187918007,
0.0361786261,
0.3180783987,
0.7391303182,
-0.1851546466,
0.3816159666,
-0.69259727,
0.0804622993,
-0.0206651613,
0.3125270307,
0.1047356054,
-0.5495875478,
-0.3568205833,
0.2922708988,
-0.8958202004,
-0.6185394526,
0.2720355392,
0.0857987925,
0.5476929545,
0.3638083041,
0.4908087552,
0.456402272,
-0.5374117494,
0.3667927682,
0.3760100603,
-0.8093882799,
0.3284864426,
-0.1812361032,
-0.1615671366,
0.5860764384,
0.4592842162,
-0.3179925978,
-0.3144448102,
-0.7642477155,
-0.5618566275,
0.5777603388,
0.2812047601,
-0.1978206336,
0.3106802106,
0.0449953973,
0.5347518921,
0.0020979801,
-0.4905117154,
-0.4011072814,
-0.2756302655,
-0.4509887099,
0.0658595413,
0.0889501274,
-0.2615765333,
0.2997276187,
0.7669168711,
-0.1811025888,
0.1195228547,
0.2802477777,
-0.2635412812,
0.1038534194,
0.4697443247,
0.8155072331,
0.6469994187,
-0.1162493005,
0.336925447,
0.1949269921,
-0.8227595687,
0.6534737349,
0.5196862221,
0.0741670802,
-0.1439187229,
0.3261192441,
0.5606402159,
-0.3695979118,
-0.2130687088,
0.7714592814,
-0.5403305292,
-0.5429308414,
0.0113279736,
-0.1580727249,
-0.544526875,
0.2972947657,
0.7249033451,
0.9256741405,
0.2368879467,
0.1270193607,
0.4921974838,
0.2463685274,
-0.5312668681,
-0.0294997711,
0.5183205009,
0.0322429612,
-0.0772480518,
0.1093689799,
-0.1827605218,
-0.7339918613,
0.5926184058,
0.1965093315,
0.9456979632,
-0.3407091796,
0.3548764288,
-0.0753439888,
0.2989745736,
-0.2880005538,
-0.5312811136,
-0.0094971051,
-0.5712643266,
-0.1908902079,
-0.187406674,
-0.5856890678,
-0.0806744695,
-0.6938676834,
0.1066937819,
-0.4674399197,
-0.1871722937,
-0.0680097416,
0.3388678133,
-0.3988706768,
0.1606657803,
-0.151630789,
0.608738482,
-0.6680202484,
0.8411899805,
0.5211181641,
-0.3635085821,
-0.3829524219,
0.4125120938,
0.2488745302,
-0.5212150216,
0.5356744528,
0.3209870756,
-0.4025291204,
-0.2282123864,
-0.0786130652,
-0.3456121087,
0.9287876487,
-0.069568418,
-0.3829123974,
0.2254824638,
0.1814185083,
0.4338790476,
-0.163551122,
-0.2102513313,
0.2494327575,
0.2486130744,
-0.0839726031,
-0.5985969305,
0.2219553888,
0.1005403176,
-0.0709068328,
0.1376110613,
-0.5477845073,
0.8445398808,
-0.2483527809,
-0.5396232009,
-0.0495297238,
0.5248715281,
0.2466947287,
0.6090306044,
0.5378689766,
0.5132293105,
0.8284900784,
-0.202245757,
0.8626518846,
0.1055821776,
0.7390723825,
0.8945515752,
-0.3959122896,
0.5040530562,
0.1012630463,
-0.4102347493,
0.2853812873,
0.7227808833,
-0.0711202547,
0.6958375573,
0.1005377248,
-0.3904457688,
0.1663520485,
0.1894050837,
-0.5683147907,
0.0920918211,
0.2576280832,
-0.015787309,
-0.2101475,
0.3613100946,
0.0223186016,
0.3605292141,
-0.0156439282,
0.6554375887,
0.0613708645,
-0.2467848957,
0.7067301273,
0.3318615556,
0.9058532715,
-0.4103170633,
0.0759949386,
-0.1622141004,
1.0296043158,
0.0742658377,
-0.6656827927,
0.208640784,
-0.1416913718,
-0.197430402,
-0.0793324709,
0.6712561846,
-0.2700738907,
-0.2725220323,
0.2908635139,
0.3763066232,
-0.4715599418,
-0.3645115197,
-0.7626527548,
-0.0956019089,
0.0633614287,
0.0095287906,
0.4132689238,
0.831396997,
0.1900552511,
0.5543501973,
0.6302735209,
-0.0670832023,
-0.1659937352,
-0.0848600566,
0.7271165848,
-0.3302608728,
-0.591109395,
-0.8915721178,
0.1479708254,
-0.0304972492,
-0.3871748745,
0.7428705096,
0.5012019873,
0.8113988042,
-0.1341016889,
1.026170969,
0.1497512758,
0.5224899054,
-0.5613999963,
0.7065509558,
-0.5489397645,
0.2727685273,
-0.1069874689,
-0.6153744459,
-0.6407412291,
0.3345544338,
-0.0457019098,
0.0425734185,
1.1282534599,
0.4262926579,
-0.2653708756,
0.2037649155,
0.1734637469,
-0.0170461759,
0.506167233,
0.6914595366,
0.9490498304,
-0.6987971663,
1.0054453611,
-0.247722432,
-0.3985994458,
-0.2223291397,
-0.5081941485,
-0.9929728508,
-0.7110059857,
-0.4015690982,
-0.6346740723,
0.5550677776,
0.5608038902,
0.7921919227,
-0.7962511778,
0.0669992566,
-0.1627611369,
0.0846803635,
-0.6593556404,
-0.2311354131,
0.789736867,
-0.1824767739,
-0.4566769302,
0.1915499121,
0.018337192,
0.3508476019,
-0.0582361035,
-0.08139994,
-0.266208142,
-0.0137955956,
0.270185709,
0.1577127278,
-0.5008586645,
-0.1150754765,
-0.1135813519,
-0.290828526,
0.3880141675,
1.0409058332,
-0.3378908634,
0.0198654775,
0.0933248922,
1.0711717606,
0.3601588011,
0.0825849026,
0.4158283472,
-1.1164550781,
-0.1315511465,
0.1497146487,
0.0702063665,
0.3289705515,
-0.470728755,
0.4054460227,
0.4046995342,
-0.5816810131,
-0.7979646921,
0.2179776579,
-0.9631088972,
-0.5966701508,
0.9340427518,
-0.2178378552,
0.0313871466,
-0.2157678753,
-0.4036694765,
0.2882241905,
-0.4339652956,
0.7197791934,
0.8306519389,
-0.0200330857,
-0.0534332842,
-0.4227036238,
0.5349188447,
0.0769943371,
-0.7067679763,
0.5312157869,
0.222425133,
0.1565703154,
0.2773757279,
0.276396513,
0.0592442192,
0.239671737,
0.3237166703,
-0.0648377314,
-0.2710697949,
-0.5069114566,
-0.5167958736,
0.3598157465,
-0.1341860294,
-0.3675079942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00462v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00462v2
|
LUCID: LLM-Generated Utterances for Complex and Interesting Dialogues
| 2024-03-01T11:33:53 | 2024-05-03T16:57:07 |
Joe Stacey, Jianpeng Cheng, John Torr, Tristan Guigue, Joris Driesen, Alexandru Coca, Mark Gaynor, Anders Johannsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Spurred by recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs), virtual
assistants are poised to take a leap forward in terms of their dialogue
capabilities. Yet a major bottleneck to achieving genuinely transformative
task-oriented dialogue capabilities remains the scarcity of high quality data.
Existing datasets, while impressive in scale, have limited domain coverage and
contain few genuinely challenging conversational phenomena; those which are
present are typically unlabelled, making it difficult to assess the strengths
and weaknesses of models without time-consuming and costly human evaluation.
Moreover, creating high quality dialogue data has until now required
considerable human input, limiting both the scale of these datasets and the
ability to rapidly bootstrap data for a new target domain. We aim to overcome
these issues with LUCID, a modularised and highly automated LLM-driven data
generation system that produces realistic, diverse and challenging dialogues.
We use LUCID to generate a seed dataset of 4,277 conversations across 100
intents to demonstrate its capabilities, with a human review finding
consistently high quality labels in the generated data.
|
[
-0.3434984684,
-0.7431250215,
0.5809694529,
0.0448869914,
-0.2157707065,
0.3073319197,
-0.1318996549,
-0.4034595191,
0.3972244561,
0.8460940719,
-0.5805193186,
-0.6580054164,
-0.2379850149,
0.1052745134,
-0.2924023867,
1.0437492132,
0.2584890723,
0.058138229,
-0.4738514721,
-0.1069744527,
-0.5326144695,
-0.5581178069,
-0.6062697768,
-0.1435230523,
0.3159118593,
0.8272814751,
0.5563284755,
0.28863132,
0.225519672,
0.3034991026,
0.09488675,
0.7923398018,
-0.8496217132,
0.6131257415,
-0.0355911963,
-0.269398421,
-0.6420841813,
-0.3456785381,
0.5996461511,
0.8233012557,
-0.1858321279,
-0.0566520952,
0.0376039445,
0.4597001374,
-0.0958423913,
0.1035729051,
-0.8310368061,
-0.1872425377,
-0.091725111,
-0.1627599895,
-0.3909514844,
-0.0797246471,
0.1222934201,
-0.7008878589,
0.0723395869,
0.1563687474,
0.8393630981,
0.2785913348,
-0.196088329,
-0.3676614165,
-1.1170874834,
0.9012976289,
-0.6374199986,
-0.0332676619,
0.2299812883,
0.3135257959,
-0.3084736764,
-0.6953708529,
-0.6563604474,
-0.2343868017,
0.2326531857,
-0.1203541532,
-0.0402352884,
0.2983048558,
0.2619569898,
0.1349984705,
-0.2968265414,
0.1106207967,
-0.2400349081,
0.0924507007,
0.9803974628,
0.6862685084,
0.2990415394,
-0.2553682625,
-0.0919031799,
0.0986862332,
-0.5946882963,
-0.1322647035,
0.4323157072,
0.2194389701,
0.0256278366,
0.5785557032,
-0.3399055004,
0.7135679126,
-0.1116659716,
-0.370174408,
0.2138233334,
-0.7197531462,
-0.0546224974,
-0.0013880061,
0.8208031654,
0.5221591592,
0.3317727447,
-0.0654867962,
-0.3532352448,
-0.4025495648,
0.3787223697,
-0.8646121621,
0.0499862693,
0.6105536819,
-0.0289951302,
-0.3013540506,
0.0077358093,
-0.4428991079,
-0.254314661,
-0.4533647895,
-0.1170445308,
-0.2890446782,
-0.2086723596,
0.0567681752,
0.1724386513,
0.1100096256,
0.665058732,
-0.8621426225,
0.3400027454,
0.7119492888,
0.6348667741,
-0.4220321178,
-0.0222623274,
-0.5688211322,
0.2257355303,
-0.3891592324,
0.7936034203,
-0.5910316706,
-0.6679921746,
-0.0112077454,
-0.1625214964,
0.1148701161,
-0.7405975461,
0.6267545223,
-0.1412654966,
0.0535427779,
-0.1592180282,
-0.471631974,
0.1353336871,
0.1854730994,
-0.4750925303,
0.7681299448,
0.2202235907,
-0.6221880913,
0.2740876377,
-0.5816814899,
-0.3085530698,
0.5281983614,
-0.6984021664,
-0.3052262068,
0.095249258,
0.1147115231,
0.4399293363,
-0.6917794347,
0.5975366831,
-0.0620580055,
-0.3165772557,
0.5197957158,
-0.4658678174,
0.4308421016,
0.2821000218,
-0.2452650517,
0.3697177768,
-0.7939280272,
0.0608934313,
-0.0546998903,
0.0684615001,
-0.0727433264,
0.0300610252,
0.2262171805,
0.1405625492,
0.0932024345,
-0.6965002418,
0.4020687044,
-0.4511660337,
0.5543706417,
0.7244053483,
0.1782223284,
0.0925797746,
-0.5422513485,
0.6123183966,
0.1845994145,
0.098595731,
-0.2287128717,
-0.6175608039,
-0.8224162459,
-0.3784509897,
0.1309356987,
0.5590587258,
-0.8427576423,
0.3590622544,
-0.6697200537,
-0.4051035047,
-0.8442915082,
0.3797761798,
0.2564554811,
0.3413197994,
-0.0906932577,
-0.3585869074,
-0.465023607,
-1.0970116854,
0.3231745958,
-0.168594569,
-0.2652478516,
1.0219701529,
0.260758996,
-0.434240371,
1.1498138905,
-0.3759208918,
-0.1911369264,
-0.4674757719,
0.2003926188,
0.1812250018,
0.3899877667,
0.0927155316,
-0.9109730124,
-0.3579065502,
0.0696758926,
-0.8701712489,
-0.1809708625,
-0.4775748551,
-0.0607360676,
0.106468901,
0.2849274576,
-0.859556675,
0.0997302979,
0.382717818,
-0.0315388888,
0.532220304,
-0.2026019692,
0.2142744064,
-1.4788591862,
0.0630612448,
-0.4160141647,
-0.2579771578,
-0.7345181108,
-0.5123214126,
-0.5480621457,
-0.3334354162,
-0.6146492958,
0.5398800373,
-0.3534018993,
-0.3236996233,
-0.0239511151,
0.3411924541,
-0.0244686883,
0.3939074874,
0.0853593946,
1.0157245398,
0.3146154284,
-0.4099317193,
0.5753451586,
0.5364233851,
-0.5219893456,
0.6250990033,
-0.8290743828,
0.2506739497,
0.0207169428,
0.2439917475,
-1.0227799416,
-0.6125354767,
-0.0498098135,
-0.4019059837,
0.1186025739,
-0.0581703149,
-0.5025558472,
0.0218373332,
-0.1291943192,
0.6269057989,
0.4842630923,
-0.3447690606,
0.5302805305,
0.620857954,
-0.6616150141,
-0.5646951795,
-0.2930101454,
0.5599104762,
-0.0886068195,
-0.8500168324,
0.3963166177,
-0.3893773258,
-0.5026609302,
-0.2737080455,
0.2818586826,
-0.0141651751,
-0.0824242607,
0.7483847141,
0.1779002845,
0.0120887263,
0.0055335043,
0.1209065244,
-0.1170944199,
0.0356426165,
-0.2268423736,
0.4980704784,
-0.0936069191,
-0.555795908,
-0.6749609113,
0.5433824062,
0.9812704325,
0.1544284225,
0.3976466656,
0.3860024512,
-0.2351908833,
-0.4021368325,
-0.6352747083,
-0.1190684438,
-0.4410477281,
0.1905556023,
-0.564507544,
-0.8019104004,
0.3503261507,
-0.0894256458,
0.2838284671,
-0.0930011868,
0.5903247595,
-0.1799352318,
1.0383718014,
0.4331886172,
0.1832319796,
0.2173448801,
-0.1798172891,
0.2086013556,
-0.7818007469,
-0.3321601748,
-0.053483326,
-0.1064538807,
-0.4871731102,
-0.6287750006,
0.5457924008,
-0.1824375391,
0.2946910262,
-0.0133219836,
-0.4686823189,
0.1928185523,
0.4457826316,
-0.0972274095,
0.3473957777,
0.0975866467,
0.2204184681,
-0.2325769067,
-0.7148630619,
-0.8242182136,
1.2415839434,
0.2032189369,
0.7076147795,
0.1098522469,
0.7125545144,
0.4802682698,
0.3025757968,
-0.8100654483,
0.7963688374,
0.1277537048,
-0.3147170246,
-0.3855801225,
-0.4629686475,
-1.0360072851,
-0.0784210563,
-0.2823196352,
-0.5370383263,
0.0360812582,
0.0800539702,
-0.5313208699,
0.1239972115,
-0.5548340082,
0.6284717321,
-0.2768858075,
-0.5925046802,
-0.2414539903,
-0.5156118274,
0.439501971,
-0.1213939413,
0.0850122645,
-0.2842029035,
0.0374341123,
0.5378867388,
-0.5699499846,
0.8381065726,
0.0451771356,
-0.1708721668,
0.5269826651,
0.098287873,
0.406421572,
0.2830656767,
-0.0614958555,
0.1176709458,
-0.2037211061,
-0.4928783774,
-0.522028923,
0.8766389489,
-0.689376235,
-0.7064187527,
-0.0909115598,
-0.7986503243,
-0.3637136221,
-0.070741795,
-0.0178255066,
0.4489447773,
-0.4902552664,
0.2729138732,
0.8575621843,
-0.2525479198,
0.1281085461,
0.3505744934,
-0.0538818054,
-0.4218727052,
1.1894329786,
0.1864843667,
0.4919294119,
0.1443647891,
-0.2383812815,
-0.0580038503,
-0.6812292337,
-0.711135745,
0.2640150189,
-0.4229058921,
-0.1151730195,
-0.7479547262,
-0.352550894,
-0.4583832026,
-0.2082134485,
-0.3844043612,
-0.4499438107,
-0.4036495686,
-0.1834891737,
0.2337132096,
0.9776291847,
0.0624298416,
0.087972559,
-0.6838677526,
0.3085906506,
0.5404118299,
-0.0203432217,
-0.4520305097,
-0.3756040037,
-0.1309356987,
0.2189990133,
-0.0912328809,
-0.5385673046,
0.7171307206,
0.2507303357,
0.4382975399,
0.4614625275,
0.1505531967,
0.4311198592,
-0.3736426234,
1.0511679649,
-0.0079193059,
-0.6053031683,
0.587528348,
-0.4763992131,
0.1047134921,
0.5329806209,
0.2920093536,
-0.3138333559,
-0.3130433559,
-0.886732161,
-0.9030221105,
0.62423563,
0.3760612607,
0.2440245003,
0.0580516346,
0.4008432925,
0.257209003,
0.4231893718,
-0.2528447807,
-0.0370317735,
-0.0323256105,
-0.2516421974,
-0.0164514165,
-0.5522283912,
-0.3418856263,
-0.0480856933,
0.4323082566,
-0.2052636445,
0.0543439537,
0.2200553119,
0.0615379736,
-0.0186476167,
0.4000149071,
0.8013284206,
0.7219058275,
-0.1861727089,
-0.230930984,
0.1891172975,
-0.2665517032,
0.0324313939,
-0.094502233,
-0.188422814,
0.2144085169,
0.2091500014,
0.8897092342,
0.1152479723,
-1.3160918951,
0.525274694,
-0.3007659316,
-0.2595666945,
-0.5238196254,
0.2753138244,
0.0417058766,
-0.0646896213,
0.2009065449,
-0.2502672672,
0.137514621,
-0.4347006083,
0.2877066433,
0.3941458762,
-0.1950973272,
-0.1842507422,
0.4418821335,
0.6933948994,
-0.4976068139,
0.8661898971,
-0.2423066497,
-0.0592969805,
0.3888882697,
0.1906992793,
0.9056739807,
-0.1888729036,
0.3532116413,
0.3014991283,
0.0514510646,
0.2785042524,
0.2668161988,
-0.4449150562,
-0.7748733759,
-0.2739602029,
-0.5858765244,
-0.86192137,
0.3636136353,
-0.6019243598,
0.142481938,
-0.4185255766,
-0.2050441504,
-0.0040487945,
-0.128149122,
-0.4956658483,
0.0173642877,
0.1397973895,
0.4603973925,
-0.6685491204,
0.9245896935,
0.2741746008,
-0.3270047307,
-0.4965322316,
-0.3364389241,
-0.195050925,
-0.7761282921,
0.8338510394,
0.0742700323,
-0.3705781102,
0.0679942742,
-0.6310346127,
-0.509088397,
1.1276426315,
0.4150861502,
-0.8425306082,
-0.2119726688,
0.3913734555,
0.5564104319,
-0.8027030826,
0.3514541984,
0.5370836854,
0.1987350136,
0.3011941314,
-0.99564749,
-0.2809082568,
-0.4379352927,
0.0432071276,
-0.2185941637,
-0.4659247696,
0.5747178197,
-0.4412300289,
-0.3380106688,
0.0848632306,
0.6018375754,
0.240884468,
0.1853201538,
0.5496713519,
0.3987977803,
0.6306825876,
-0.0411108769,
0.8847113252,
-0.496160239,
-0.2161399871,
1.1857391596,
-0.5649459958,
0.8493767977,
0.4928232729,
0.2766638696,
0.4577632248,
0.5298663974,
0.2168193758,
-0.0280194562,
0.3803627789,
-0.6955782175,
-0.5570390224,
-0.7478165627,
0.0597662814,
0.3048301637,
0.9511973858,
-0.1278232038,
0.2745532691,
0.2176796794,
-0.2833242714,
0.1943478733,
0.1169500351,
1.1669278145,
0.0391740911,
-0.8852393627,
0.8600809574,
-0.3493428528,
0.4677666724,
-0.5436903834,
-0.4270020723,
-0.351698786,
-0.1384269446,
-0.2712616026,
-0.7909179926,
0.0374534242,
0.1314845234,
-0.0005745076,
-0.5750852823,
0.4091807008,
-0.7029491067,
-0.2656529248,
0.0583348982,
0.5573146343,
0.6209192872,
0.2528114617,
-0.67015481,
0.4122068584,
0.1819959879,
-0.1706663966,
0.1004364938,
0.5239933133,
-0.0219103862,
1.0425965786,
0.5856224298,
0.1497621834,
-0.2202865183,
0.1821836829,
0.967412293,
-0.5529201031,
-0.1614634097,
-0.2173679769,
0.6517169476,
-0.3948818445,
-0.3670660257,
0.5672369599,
0.6143879294,
0.6740826368,
0.1821847856,
0.9558247924,
0.1517729908,
0.5604742169,
-0.4807460904,
0.4210948348,
-0.2973099053,
0.5565746427,
-0.0560566299,
-0.6574864984,
0.107580252,
0.4010690451,
-0.1298542172,
-0.1188618839,
0.2826466262,
1.0578066111,
0.0237153918,
-0.1092258617,
0.7556993365,
0.4183508456,
0.6676089764,
0.7161554694,
0.9177888632,
-0.1562134922,
0.5693539381,
0.0976225585,
-0.1572272927,
-0.4299773872,
-0.5544366241,
-0.8867968917,
-0.8494767547,
-0.262216121,
-0.4000790417,
0.1338597238,
1.0858329535,
0.9897668958,
-0.6448963881,
-0.4500344396,
-0.2239464372,
0.1406108141,
0.2025592774,
-0.229052186,
-0.0071209422,
-0.4051678181,
-1.0972160101,
0.7321612835,
0.3831357956,
0.2117468417,
-0.5691393018,
-0.1706204563,
0.250669241,
0.2948209941,
0.5761477947,
0.3332140148,
-0.7408951521,
-0.1087934449,
-0.2165167183,
-0.2883914709,
0.0352921635,
0.8622912765,
-0.6686897278,
0.7879477739,
0.2829014957,
0.8713764548,
0.5774491429,
0.0777021796,
0.9466395974,
-0.6789702177,
0.0861586034,
0.5382245779,
0.052163247,
0.5226899981,
-0.3916394413,
0.317614615,
0.2254951149,
-0.5911977291,
-1.1563907862,
0.3675607443,
-1.2897365093,
-0.0917351097,
1.2050868273,
-0.1189303324,
-0.1402690113,
-0.3339722753,
-0.5918807983,
-0.2498997152,
-0.5037020445,
0.7143021226,
0.5592429638,
-0.5401210189,
-0.0215585083,
-0.6913204789,
0.8367041349,
0.5416895747,
-1.1088706255,
0.3670987189,
0.6838182211,
0.0838129073,
0.152605027,
0.7984332442,
0.226327613,
0.1456656605,
0.1229977831,
0.0785778463,
-0.0983460546,
-0.5526291132,
-0.0606077462,
0.2861189246,
0.2424742579,
-0.0257707965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00887v1
|
SEGAA: A Unified Approach to Predicting Age, Gender, and Emotion in Speech
| 2024-03-01T11:28:37 | 2024-03-01T11:28:37 |
Aron R, Indra Sigicharla, Chirag Periwal, Mohanaprasad K, Nithya Darisini P S, Sourabh Tiwari, Shivani Arora
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
The interpretation of human voices holds importance across various
applications. This study ventures into predicting age, gender, and emotion from
vocal cues, a field with vast applications. Voice analysis tech advancements
span domains, from improving customer interactions to enhancing healthcare and
retail experiences. Discerning emotions aids mental health, while age and
gender detection are vital in various contexts. Exploring deep learning models
for these predictions involves comparing single, multi-output, and sequential
models highlighted in this paper. Sourcing suitable data posed challenges,
resulting in the amalgamation of the CREMA-D and EMO-DB datasets. Prior work
showed promise in individual predictions, but limited research considered all
three variables simultaneously. This paper identifies flaws in an individual
model approach and advocates for our novel multi-output learning architecture
Speech-based Emotion Gender and Age Analysis (SEGAA) model. The experiments
suggest that Multi-output models perform comparably to individual models,
efficiently capturing the intricate relationships between variables and speech
inputs, all while achieving improved runtime.
|
[
-0.3371689022,
-0.4670378864,
0.5922621489,
0.2393012494,
0.024656361,
0.1400970072,
0.1686552465,
-0.4191335738,
-0.1514249891,
0.3566096425,
-1.064686656,
-0.5780531764,
-0.6069785357,
-0.0972022861,
-0.1209584475,
0.4212491214,
0.5046124458,
0.4830627143,
0.0909423307,
-0.0177923404,
-0.8110823035,
-0.5371502638,
-0.9788698554,
-0.2794671953,
0.5046556592,
0.5955930948,
0.3016637266,
0.1048000678,
0.0199589469,
0.3781917691,
-0.0025552877,
0.0631175786,
-0.2817051411,
0.4327204823,
0.3924042284,
-0.4235299528,
-0.483089596,
0.1656566709,
0.4010405242,
0.8367995024,
-0.3594070971,
0.0124360267,
-0.1583581865,
1.0086320639,
-0.5853249431,
0.4074045122,
-0.5703314543,
0.3637377024,
-0.0099620176,
-0.0092124101,
-0.3263069987,
-0.3872249722,
0.3540482521,
-0.2547188401,
0.1770091504,
-0.3399415016,
0.3461683095,
0.3514870107,
-0.650978446,
-0.3906214237,
-0.8706507087,
0.6269859672,
-0.9235035777,
0.453332305,
0.0954592526,
0.4933587909,
0.0621611439,
-0.4514238536,
-0.3283515573,
-0.0795237422,
0.2798328698,
0.4130607247,
-0.4956093729,
-0.0472437888,
-0.101419948,
0.0445294604,
-0.3846226335,
0.3375528753,
-0.6387031674,
0.3645176589,
0.5682678223,
0.198260501,
0.4839044809,
-0.2404363453,
-0.2451412976,
-0.2591694891,
-0.4473979473,
0.1024490148,
0.6846998334,
0.6459060311,
-0.227388978,
0.3527100384,
-0.121485576,
0.1311379522,
0.370811671,
0.2686534524,
0.2903757393,
0.2701457143,
-0.3909902871,
0.4502934515,
0.941208899,
-0.1499189734,
0.1222737283,
-0.069008559,
0.3500018716,
0.1085620597,
0.4983585775,
-0.8180275559,
0.0383804105,
0.5055327415,
-0.6211557388,
-0.364664644,
0.1253530234,
-1.3699442148,
-0.7619592547,
-0.5348249674,
-0.0108883129,
-0.396107465,
-0.340721786,
0.060094811,
0.093014136,
-0.2856891155,
0.2302442789,
-0.8154656887,
0.2520782053,
0.5966961384,
0.4908326268,
0.104297705,
-0.0586358719,
-0.3283673823,
-0.2146896571,
-0.4618608952,
0.4445092976,
-0.7127858996,
-0.2904034853,
-0.0796301588,
-0.2502223253,
-0.1495693028,
-0.4120916128,
0.6214170456,
-0.2295568287,
0.3902743161,
-0.0018492142,
-0.4002203047,
-0.5433334708,
-0.6823694706,
-0.7978220582,
0.4690241814,
0.0140773002,
-0.4420038462,
0.5629942417,
-0.796359241,
-0.1532411128,
-0.0984329209,
-0.1927359253,
-0.4786942601,
0.6223750114,
0.3543577194,
0.68249017,
-0.4013493955,
0.6874801517,
-0.7106135488,
-0.2341201305,
0.3751239181,
-0.5701169372,
0.5709376931,
0.3797215223,
-0.3630676568,
0.2009702772,
-0.8719270825,
-0.1459743232,
0.0874729306,
0.1121899039,
-0.0753683597,
0.2377708852,
-0.2184684277,
0.2926294208,
-0.0198406707,
-0.4617363214,
-0.0995797217,
-0.2163212299,
0.3156988323,
0.697479248,
-0.2665017247,
0.3998098969,
0.22070463,
0.7911996245,
0.3216080666,
0.2149721682,
0.033135917,
-0.513718307,
-0.2843654454,
-0.204910025,
0.0948023051,
0.44882828,
-0.1214877144,
0.371858716,
0.0400990844,
-0.8825598359,
-0.8136402369,
-0.090767473,
0.1342551112,
0.301023066,
0.0619171746,
-0.3552674949,
-0.9465884566,
-0.8008372188,
-0.1753498167,
-0.3446294069,
-0.0495456606,
0.5754256248,
-0.0455013327,
-0.2757570446,
0.643614471,
-0.3700859249,
-0.3544505835,
-0.1606591493,
0.7124533653,
0.151173085,
0.3444215655,
0.4966490865,
-0.5963488221,
-0.135136649,
-0.0695002675,
-0.7295895219,
-0.2645819783,
-0.0140481004,
0.0770603865,
-0.0388162248,
0.0846028477,
-0.3724855185,
0.3526510596,
0.7755678296,
-0.2864265144,
0.3432232738,
-0.0281884167,
0.4437358379,
-0.8500593305,
-0.1086429656,
0.2995710075,
0.2779245079,
-0.7815179229,
-0.546556294,
-0.0478118621,
-0.6093403697,
-0.4243967533,
-0.0165798943,
-0.2748839259,
-0.4296156168,
-0.3459511697,
-0.2124151587,
-0.1588018984,
0.5150709152,
-0.0211940613,
0.7262047529,
0.4785600305,
-0.4299089611,
0.3199926913,
0.1068009064,
-0.1472436339,
0.6340963244,
-0.5507748127,
0.5932086706,
-0.5010388494,
0.231496349,
-1.1334614754,
-0.0974386558,
0.0791262314,
-0.7842196226,
0.514028132,
-0.0632446408,
0.0366079733,
-0.2679967582,
-0.1500787139,
0.1164955199,
0.4406438172,
-0.414321363,
1.1052010059,
0.5538645983,
-0.4769646823,
-0.6580030918,
-0.262008518,
0.0827475563,
-0.5812478065,
-0.5876240134,
0.0537081659,
0.0537298359,
-0.111012578,
-0.0811074078,
-0.1039287373,
-0.383354336,
0.3854295313,
0.6905652881,
0.2444520444,
-0.4019808471,
0.2461243719,
0.2574909627,
-0.1749422699,
0.3119163513,
0.2065831125,
0.5125394464,
-0.1993856579,
0.0156039558,
-0.6298010945,
0.7350791693,
0.8250118494,
-0.0292822737,
0.6656314135,
0.9629227519,
-0.4006115794,
-0.0916136131,
-0.3246653676,
0.0215177629,
-0.4098674059,
0.4871817231,
-0.4008494914,
-0.4876191318,
0.4420343637,
-0.3299970925,
-0.2458110452,
0.6756336689,
0.5405468345,
-0.3800849915,
1.5984910727,
0.5655339956,
-0.1568088681,
0.5229996443,
-0.1445908546,
-0.0013322143,
-0.9047830105,
-0.3133465648,
-0.8948639035,
-0.3047449589,
-0.4639399052,
-0.0544909239,
0.1648250371,
-0.1721183807,
-0.5591005683,
0.0016138317,
-0.3840361536,
-0.1443528533,
0.4668741524,
-0.0620577,
-0.0657844841,
-0.2178711146,
0.2717533708,
-0.302464664,
-0.5262100101,
-0.5204929113,
0.9434199333,
0.5160089135,
0.8677290678,
0.1942499578,
0.5125914812,
0.3653972447,
0.2453040928,
-0.6539282799,
0.2187436521,
-0.7890780568,
-0.6354012489,
-0.1608957052,
-0.7304850221,
-1.1455619335,
0.3421290517,
-0.1681586653,
-1.0210050344,
0.6808746457,
-0.174992308,
-0.5009868741,
0.2531145215,
-0.8674644232,
0.7878404856,
-0.3945195973,
-0.0264489893,
-0.2111847997,
-0.5988816023,
0.7207022905,
-0.1519059241,
0.200842604,
-0.5952983499,
0.136902377,
0.8182991147,
0.1842146963,
1.155018568,
-0.3142890036,
-0.2003981769,
-0.0769315213,
0.0611959919,
-0.2420448512,
-0.0654363856,
-0.0861878917,
0.4038234949,
-0.0345657617,
0.1344060451,
-0.5879856348,
0.7409473062,
-1.1729048491,
-0.2627406418,
-0.4576508403,
-0.598790884,
-0.5259664059,
-0.2879334688,
-0.0925416723,
0.4874221981,
-0.3498002589,
0.1675553918,
0.4036977887,
-0.5502897501,
0.1686411202,
0.4404069483,
-0.0684178919,
-0.5741640925,
0.57028687,
-0.045028694,
0.1325825155,
0.0909117982,
0.4968655109,
-0.4574395716,
-0.0478092991,
-0.4936318994,
0.1104002744,
-0.6750198007,
-0.0504381694,
-0.6846624017,
0.0084765777,
-0.6403793693,
0.2694983482,
-0.604406774,
-0.033955887,
-0.7413338423,
0.0001062305,
0.0784643888,
0.9713719487,
-0.0937783197,
0.2592377067,
-0.8808566332,
0.5063839555,
0.5550686121,
0.1131854504,
0.2718009949,
-0.0925456733,
0.2847003639,
0.0951160416,
-0.3874285221,
-1.4847557545,
0.8165879846,
0.4023403823,
0.3683867455,
0.5849033594,
-0.1868940145,
0.6103218794,
-0.3210194111,
0.6883593202,
0.3824496269,
-1.1976312399,
0.6965959072,
-0.0723214522,
0.1385827065,
0.4957331717,
0.3811217248,
-0.7782883048,
0.1310151219,
-0.7743996978,
-0.8000573516,
0.7958881855,
-0.0506993905,
0.0742268488,
0.2704093754,
0.1896375865,
0.5210608244,
0.3156184852,
-0.0697697625,
-0.3402644396,
-0.170824945,
-0.6043561101,
-0.0939143896,
-0.2070396543,
0.1897847354,
-0.0846237615,
0.657971561,
-0.24137263,
0.5891165733,
-0.1237203479,
0.1075644791,
-0.5161908269,
0.4817847908,
0.4511837065,
0.5404301882,
-0.4820460975,
-0.039685268,
0.0726345703,
-0.2372646332,
0.2757507861,
0.0714242235,
0.2145620137,
0.0531934351,
0.1192529723,
1.2905350924,
0.3479222953,
-0.5563216805,
0.1797711104,
-0.4246551096,
0.1200513616,
-0.3547998965,
-0.1498014033,
0.2690305412,
0.3639914095,
0.5044060349,
0.1372495741,
0.4976237118,
-0.9164200425,
0.0551069528,
0.1567522734,
-0.7971031666,
-0.2947053611,
0.8010225296,
0.1505583972,
-0.1491238326,
0.6893453598,
0.2163799852,
-0.5673635006,
1.0346579552,
0.2996719778,
1.2485269308,
-0.5685667992,
0.4433210194,
0.3939664662,
0.0107644424,
0.264882952,
0.3430364132,
0.2632607222,
-0.6242044568,
-0.393316865,
-0.199557662,
-0.5217576027,
0.1478040367,
-0.9934992194,
0.0425722972,
-0.1930081099,
-0.4267824292,
0.2308104634,
0.2053022683,
-0.9841122031,
0.3762177527,
0.7876853347,
0.2242626846,
-1.1552120447,
0.4815161824,
0.3174182773,
-0.3870160282,
-0.841011405,
-0.3623645902,
0.2391484231,
-0.6328098178,
0.932279408,
0.2644399703,
-0.1526897252,
-0.2444288135,
-0.4414812326,
-0.6977246404,
0.9886034131,
0.5281882286,
-0.7018666267,
0.006994253,
-0.1003228277,
0.4553991854,
-0.6893821359,
0.4528465569,
0.7581318617,
0.4231577814,
-0.0202744827,
-0.4744263291,
-0.1678991467,
-0.1201526225,
0.0179429762,
-0.0876574069,
-0.3668872118,
1.0242533684,
-0.1893862486,
-0.4612594843,
0.0778668523,
0.9197580218,
0.4003587365,
0.6024375558,
0.7112281322,
0.3805415928,
0.9291425347,
-0.1326563358,
0.9572049379,
0.207656458,
0.1660479307,
1.167792201,
-0.462471962,
0.6608269215,
-0.013431292,
-0.4596028924,
0.5678647161,
0.6798359156,
0.1688310802,
0.4891789854,
0.1789675802,
0.0235862732,
-0.0803620815,
-0.151862964,
-0.3975511193,
0.8036338091,
0.5415773988,
-0.387368679,
0.0932017863,
0.1666914821,
0.0259634946,
-0.3183068037,
-0.0797387362,
0.928839922,
0.2208052427,
-0.373282969,
-0.010418402,
-0.3005312383,
0.555295229,
-0.5421420336,
-0.1742483228,
-0.0530853719,
0.0958379954,
-0.0235949084,
-0.4219963253,
0.0695492551,
0.0264066793,
-0.056722369,
0.1492180973,
0.7365938425,
-0.5384189487,
-0.6343343854,
0.5252500176,
0.7361820936,
0.1553716809,
-0.2765126824,
-0.9056036472,
0.1338262856,
-0.2216629237,
-0.0652492493,
0.1886817664,
0.6046680808,
0.439966917,
0.5843743682,
0.5909743309,
0.2008786201,
0.2131339908,
0.4764424264,
0.2047070414,
-0.6043646336,
-0.4139043391,
-0.5610353351,
0.3522818685,
-0.0164460186,
-0.4493388236,
0.2189641744,
0.1122792363,
0.112931706,
-0.1067694351,
0.725469768,
0.2206732929,
0.4375937581,
-0.3102325797,
0.6891815066,
-0.4540188313,
-0.0642311648,
-0.4781730473,
-0.7051633596,
0.1690006703,
0.5382987261,
-0.0597384237,
0.3498302698,
0.552613914,
0.237468034,
0.1427581906,
0.5192540884,
0.2963754535,
0.1661295891,
0.4005289078,
0.7894529104,
0.9994354248,
-0.3386084139,
0.0918565691,
-0.5005879402,
0.0242004637,
-0.2009164244,
-0.8149939179,
-0.338588953,
-0.7486709952,
-0.3124333918,
-0.0527319871,
-0.0943103507,
0.8132641912,
0.9006401896,
-0.7682000399,
-0.2958770692,
0.2959940732,
-0.1654999256,
-0.6060192585,
-0.1951219141,
0.3585597873,
-0.2170163095,
-0.9922395945,
0.7578538656,
0.0665885583,
-0.1553546637,
-0.5099188089,
-0.002812101,
0.0029837044,
0.3090295792,
0.397134304,
0.0362838097,
-0.771235168,
-0.1741938889,
-0.2365988791,
0.0505422242,
0.1496143639,
0.8691516519,
-0.8508054614,
0.475140214,
0.3766829073,
0.5492805839,
0.3986830711,
-0.0108398963,
0.9753956199,
-0.5943059325,
-0.3352799416,
0.3406943381,
0.6427742243,
0.4851461053,
-0.5911309719,
0.6435844302,
-0.1751698405,
-0.351878196,
-0.6435848475,
0.0408941209,
-1.2226510048,
-0.3861688077,
0.6695938706,
-0.1346957237,
-0.205233708,
0.0512105227,
-0.4034430981,
0.7633563876,
-0.7713739872,
0.8932170272,
0.5581024289,
0.0162437353,
-0.3413962722,
-0.7208459377,
0.0668994635,
0.4455200732,
-1.1017662287,
-0.0208271053,
0.5145812631,
0.0050727399,
0.0173164308,
0.2660671771,
-0.1437432766,
0.3360859752,
-0.0625090897,
0.2735338211,
0.0602854639,
-0.4826750457,
-0.8174256086,
0.5892128348,
-0.4545077085,
-0.2941396832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00438v1
|
Your Model Is Not Predicting Depression Well And That Is Why: A Case Study of PRIMATE Dataset
| 2024-03-01T10:47:02 | 2024-03-01T10:47:02 |
Kirill Milintsevich, Kairit Sirts, Gaël Dias
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the quality of annotations in mental health datasets
used for NLP-based depression level estimation from social media texts. While
previous research relies on social media-based datasets annotated with binary
categories, i.e. depressed or non-depressed, recent datasets such as D2S and
PRIMATE aim for nuanced annotations using PHQ-9 symptoms. However, most of
these datasets rely on crowd workers without the domain knowledge for
annotation. Focusing on the PRIMATE dataset, our study reveals concerns
regarding annotation validity, particularly for the lack of interest or
pleasure symptom. Through reannotation by a mental health professional, we
introduce finer labels and textual spans as evidence, identifying a notable
number of false positives. Our refined annotations, to be released under a Data
Use Agreement, offer a higher-quality test set for anhedonia detection. This
study underscores the necessity of addressing annotation quality issues in
mental health datasets, advocating for improved methodologies to enhance NLP
model reliability in mental health assessments.
|
[
-0.3727041185,
-0.5993553996,
0.4389827549,
0.703881979,
-0.4200753272,
-0.014786738,
-0.0141060231,
-0.571459353,
0.5757035613,
0.2492558509,
-0.5550664067,
-0.6236698627,
-0.9390249252,
0.4675841928,
-0.5115594864,
1.128324151,
0.1451879442,
-0.1426263601,
-0.2965905964,
-0.1808992922,
-0.3313517869,
-0.5941642523,
-0.8012242913,
-0.2549314499,
0.3811765015,
0.2704630196,
1.1042188406,
0.291549921,
0.7008268833,
0.0040238029,
-0.514836669,
0.2480713278,
-0.5871116519,
-0.1149048805,
0.021087613,
-0.1951093376,
-0.48072806,
0.2630752921,
-0.0421611331,
0.6191484332,
-0.0300663449,
0.3349984288,
-0.0328874402,
0.4041001797,
-0.5784380436,
-0.0262895282,
-0.142318055,
0.5338691473,
-0.2387367636,
0.0861940905,
-0.0739462376,
-0.3300808668,
-0.0677359477,
-0.5967985988,
0.2234445959,
-0.0785450488,
0.9227970243,
0.8352419138,
-0.2643003464,
-0.2043034285,
-0.5193795562,
0.6128070951,
-1.1048755646,
-0.16526483,
1.300467968,
0.1387995929,
-0.1352117062,
-0.3665546775,
-0.4128052592,
-0.2048930675,
-0.3080760539,
0.0870553628,
-0.0250547156,
-0.2675747871,
0.6134083867,
0.5462384224,
-0.3994206488,
0.0735845491,
-0.3877596259,
-0.2607939839,
0.9659867883,
0.1593180746,
0.3806953728,
-0.6201018095,
-0.0975309908,
0.4810785055,
-0.1582624465,
0.2890900373,
0.1849012077,
0.0642336756,
-0.4253343642,
0.7860404849,
0.0390448868,
0.4892778993,
-0.0974912345,
-0.2051579505,
0.2741777003,
-0.0322656929,
-0.1028669402,
-0.060455855,
0.8132830262,
0.7479888201,
0.2787109315,
-0.1394491643,
-0.2452904433,
0.1740314066,
0.6057339311,
-0.572222054,
-0.6592901945,
0.6188984513,
-0.6884443164,
-0.2525762916,
-0.3739396632,
-0.7121768594,
-0.7601341605,
-0.209209308,
0.2282457054,
-0.4963654876,
-0.4751806855,
0.0479612164,
-0.1545990407,
-0.5844182968,
0.4561200738,
-0.8094418049,
0.2908564806,
0.5472695231,
1.146966815,
-0.036922235,
0.0280520581,
-0.0148679344,
-0.266734153,
-0.6475865245,
0.7438727021,
-0.3484355509,
-0.3616612554,
-0.1997225434,
0.2910363674,
0.0021930339,
-0.4809829891,
0.8014977574,
0.1420795321,
0.3297320008,
-0.4700033367,
-0.4964330792,
-0.2639908493,
0.2357967049,
-0.7538291812,
1.0046005249,
0.3650467098,
-1.3497799635,
0.2965899706,
-0.4412698448,
-0.4935960472,
-0.0133738806,
-0.069900468,
-0.3956636786,
0.2404174656,
0.2661078274,
0.6025149822,
0.0238774326,
0.4360111058,
-0.8449058533,
-0.4174605012,
0.4712355733,
-0.031102879,
0.9167464375,
-0.1116694286,
0.0072340509,
-0.3616906404,
-0.8156306148,
-0.365609169,
-0.1270048469,
-0.2115918398,
-0.4500634372,
0.2607853413,
0.1326144785,
0.4682774544,
0.0665881261,
-0.6970005035,
0.0289361533,
-0.1218434423,
0.6655387878,
0.3545169532,
0.1341254562,
-0.1577697843,
-0.3431598544,
0.40481776,
-0.0060159583,
0.3165224791,
0.2822645009,
-0.873241663,
-0.0547424965,
-0.5886767507,
0.4249127805,
0.4920284152,
-0.4101343155,
0.6288998723,
0.1463667154,
-0.5557587743,
-0.5856489539,
-0.1240729243,
-0.0310737714,
0.663025856,
0.6971263885,
-0.48830989,
-0.4404049814,
-0.8641270995,
0.1801742762,
-0.2073311061,
-0.1340222061,
0.1431009024,
0.5405170918,
-0.4397526085,
0.8315628767,
-0.2124660909,
-0.4463703334,
-0.0210729148,
0.5082189441,
0.1859449148,
0.5012501478,
0.5677843094,
-0.7205756903,
-0.0526212193,
-0.374547869,
-1.008204937,
0.0167505816,
-0.0785002708,
-0.1063332558,
-0.0888486728,
-0.3422490954,
-0.6391109228,
0.7112308741,
0.5695769191,
-0.2425666898,
0.5220025778,
0.1161642894,
0.0834436789,
-0.7711132169,
0.1842986494,
0.2854788601,
-0.0394792072,
-0.5269031525,
-0.7788302302,
-0.017658066,
-0.226255253,
0.0053386623,
0.2080409676,
0.1868181676,
0.1186967194,
-0.4773541093,
0.1311935782,
0.2119124234,
0.1680627912,
0.0962237641,
0.3729446828,
0.6787543297,
-0.4288302958,
0.1924171001,
0.6991940737,
-0.1210495532,
0.5319814682,
-0.5701851249,
-0.2311545163,
-0.166875869,
0.1948650181,
-0.8958904147,
-0.4644570053,
0.4371373057,
-0.6369922161,
0.0706010461,
0.2688532472,
-0.3305497766,
-0.4751902819,
-0.2274578512,
0.3294997215,
-0.0100100413,
-0.2700381875,
0.0821857378,
0.4514116347,
-0.1153909937,
-0.6371575594,
-0.9157317281,
0.2784132659,
-0.4174272716,
-0.4691022038,
0.4393522739,
0.3178378046,
-0.2078882903,
0.1222916096,
-0.2635456026,
-0.3308210671,
0.5469321609,
0.4809243977,
0.0229199808,
0.1211490929,
0.5263311863,
-0.0470865406,
-0.1315815151,
0.3050379157,
0.565634191,
0.0583133996,
0.5278126001,
0.0979766548,
-0.9462606907,
0.274515301,
0.3042447567,
0.0648390055,
0.6844448447,
0.569734633,
-0.9952189326,
0.0239737108,
-0.3139863908,
-0.1165854186,
-0.2509226501,
-0.0344788209,
-0.0382632501,
-0.5709087253,
0.7003263235,
0.0664332658,
-0.0486844406,
0.4134589434,
0.1035337895,
-0.2267912477,
1.2935011387,
0.8040101528,
-0.2267751396,
0.1505129635,
-0.1746368855,
0.3660106361,
-0.7997857332,
0.0203597043,
-0.3241477311,
-0.2448429316,
-0.6560377479,
-0.0178914517,
-0.174121052,
0.439712435,
-0.2912807465,
0.389490813,
-0.6647529602,
-0.2677861154,
0.2292357534,
0.3669632971,
0.2224152982,
-0.1886585057,
0.385699451,
-0.4146214724,
-0.4412202239,
-0.8922807574,
0.7566350698,
0.5341756344,
0.5621342063,
-0.0295156538,
0.4787272215,
0.7564900517,
0.5180596113,
-0.525537312,
0.1200972199,
-0.366463542,
-0.7620093226,
-0.3635634184,
-0.5231109858,
-0.6232609749,
-0.0568547025,
-0.3724584877,
-1.0929095745,
0.6287670135,
0.0592379309,
-0.7834284902,
-0.039806325,
-0.3930335641,
1.0329494476,
-0.1915747076,
0.0731562376,
-0.0283199251,
-0.6196275949,
0.7138596773,
-0.3608900011,
0.2764127553,
-0.8982664347,
0.047851488,
0.9785932899,
-0.4550253451,
0.7808101177,
-0.0986129045,
0.083352536,
0.2061840594,
0.0802323893,
-0.0378465466,
0.5447713733,
-0.5386395454,
0.2915454805,
0.3660788536,
-0.5499402285,
-0.3339887559,
0.2182616144,
-0.9737312794,
-0.4286421537,
-0.2659160793,
-0.2627004683,
-0.1043254808,
-0.1336791962,
0.3221173584,
0.3984456956,
0.0891734734,
-0.107969366,
0.0337939523,
-0.4116114974,
0.2181252986,
0.0055114417,
-0.0865020975,
-0.6993530989,
0.7356009483,
0.3168608546,
-0.0326269008,
-0.0963057578,
0.1183925867,
-0.0584384203,
-0.2891180217,
-0.2869943678,
0.3964151442,
-0.5797299743,
-0.3220252097,
-0.6736956835,
-0.0766198635,
-0.6507537961,
0.1224976182,
-0.394490093,
-0.6871460676,
-0.5867573619,
-0.3459113836,
0.6376101971,
0.7793409824,
-0.4729478061,
0.2050947547,
-0.4847995639,
0.5470082164,
-0.1612264961,
0.2250319123,
0.0874816254,
-0.4696341157,
-0.3475942612,
0.1859522313,
-0.4261275232,
-1.0929175615,
0.8121221066,
0.1036114767,
0.3349469006,
0.6049039364,
0.5591318011,
0.7857524753,
0.1131824479,
0.8523607254,
0.0855945647,
-1.0712912083,
0.7642646432,
0.0197501704,
-0.0941851065,
0.6682133079,
1.076920867,
-0.8400180936,
-0.5605467558,
-0.6609783769,
-0.8937542439,
0.7736368775,
0.3985940516,
0.0156133464,
-0.2876341045,
0.755854547,
0.3366093934,
0.2942710519,
-0.7855175734,
-0.3357082009,
-0.8069508672,
-0.0866442248,
-0.3575411439,
-0.4239056706,
-0.0286582261,
-0.2195311487,
0.642221868,
-0.0251444038,
0.2255496383,
0.4064719975,
0.2504297495,
-0.3653047681,
-0.3174214661,
0.2469798774,
0.8436759114,
-0.5722932816,
0.2989905477,
-0.0538478158,
-0.4493501186,
-0.0377600826,
0.2606739998,
-0.2000181973,
0.3495304883,
0.5667586327,
0.6267149448,
-0.1318769157,
-0.4975106418,
0.4971796274,
-0.1172970608,
-0.0331067927,
-0.3287624717,
-0.0573477373,
0.1578859389,
0.026828276,
0.2586356103,
-0.1161325201,
0.4086856246,
-0.2198443115,
0.0532547012,
0.1183867902,
-0.6322355866,
-0.5330986977,
0.5960134268,
-0.0576961339,
-0.5291897058,
0.8213712573,
-0.1507608145,
-0.2369778603,
0.6511986256,
0.0982524157,
0.4006747603,
-0.1187848598,
0.5894209146,
0.6346578002,
0.3814871907,
-0.3932024837,
0.3084615171,
0.1468318552,
-0.4737606049,
-0.4460658431,
-0.6269723177,
-0.5797698498,
0.3456186056,
-0.7900600433,
0.3222819865,
-0.4354617894,
-0.8696398735,
0.0976701304,
0.0618338324,
-0.2466110587,
0.6643587351,
0.3250998855,
0.7210068107,
-1.1488126516,
0.4880338907,
0.5871835351,
-0.7347747087,
-0.4541120231,
0.1896984577,
-0.0507046841,
-0.2769479752,
0.4011695385,
0.7215261459,
0.5252434015,
-0.3494282961,
-0.5690861344,
-1.0507310629,
0.9229687452,
0.2746094465,
-0.1422507018,
0.228262797,
0.2363333255,
0.7821544409,
-0.3980595469,
0.3088851273,
0.2315737307,
0.3907815516,
-0.0714643076,
-0.7753642201,
0.1906895936,
-0.3420680165,
0.0761626288,
-0.2353108376,
-0.337385118,
0.8082885742,
-0.2239273787,
-0.5538780093,
0.0619826689,
0.4303235114,
0.0359324962,
0.5474581718,
0.2851650119,
0.8214499354,
0.9259819984,
0.1194653809,
0.9167096615,
-0.1178306863,
0.6148594022,
0.9900159836,
-0.2980313003,
0.9572854638,
0.0613624491,
-0.1202427968,
0.2411395609,
1.5034818649,
-0.1443710923,
0.4985106885,
0.3377870619,
-0.0631714761,
-0.5561063886,
-0.2878299654,
-0.3195528984,
0.0429414921,
0.5420206189,
-0.5757958889,
-0.1779046506,
0.1809110641,
-0.1264658421,
-0.1222103611,
-0.0635476038,
0.6401321888,
0.3798532784,
-0.1087097675,
0.6542206407,
-0.1075664684,
0.453815043,
0.2068232149,
0.0848665759,
-0.3719712794,
-0.1558026969,
-0.6244193316,
-0.6378270388,
0.7142233253,
-0.0356033221,
-0.3383243084,
0.0837304145,
0.616922915,
-0.0495436639,
-0.6136368513,
0.449193269,
0.590796411,
0.6120875478,
-0.1419582963,
-0.8409895301,
-0.3088988662,
-0.2876239717,
-0.2651484013,
0.1233170927,
0.7840707898,
-0.1793277115,
0.7330628633,
0.300729543,
0.0567132086,
-0.4201365411,
-0.0181810204,
0.6411970258,
-0.74175632,
-0.1217276305,
-0.7685700059,
0.3751570582,
-0.227666989,
-0.6431392431,
0.5934507251,
0.2955440581,
0.5313263535,
0.3154643476,
0.6766932607,
-0.1631579995,
0.7816014886,
0.0456954837,
0.6822013259,
-0.6416683197,
0.0980654135,
-0.0382479057,
-0.6917827725,
-0.5777036548,
0.8866975904,
-0.6458291411,
-0.156460464,
0.480155021,
0.5649086237,
0.0824942142,
0.5113630891,
0.3002998531,
0.4407614172,
0.0866767615,
0.2641158998,
1.0283516645,
-0.1430371404,
-0.0297549963,
-0.9297656417,
-0.1894290298,
-0.0693123415,
-0.8148332238,
-0.9968627095,
-0.2750805616,
-0.8145403266,
-0.3841684461,
0.2269919366,
0.7321049571,
0.4917453527,
-0.7326876521,
-0.0221300665,
0.1580570638,
0.0625439957,
-0.4609731138,
-0.2199430168,
0.4431868494,
-0.3822860122,
-0.1249061003,
-0.2599921227,
0.1579153091,
0.0356130786,
-0.2543905377,
0.3284143209,
-0.3012313843,
-0.3468898237,
0.305785954,
0.0973852426,
-0.6235004663,
-0.2951724529,
-0.3654655218,
-0.2277031392,
0.2192152143,
0.1543307304,
-0.4535634518,
0.0307829026,
0.1190924793,
0.2740787864,
0.1565114409,
0.3495393693,
0.3554981649,
-0.3115488291,
-0.3583446145,
0.4299982786,
0.3457339704,
0.7870745659,
-0.7165851593,
0.742708087,
0.3077860177,
-0.6361439228,
-0.7568845153,
-0.2828363776,
-0.8912953138,
-0.2943287194,
0.9882840514,
-0.683776319,
-0.4374787211,
-0.5069768429,
-0.2911512554,
0.2396231592,
-0.4710049033,
1.5465033054,
0.8014038205,
-0.5205177069,
0.1256682128,
-0.8461869955,
0.7623946071,
0.3155625165,
-0.6008453965,
0.2724484205,
0.3547101021,
-0.0687001124,
0.3893131912,
0.5516090989,
0.1638682187,
0.3234607577,
-0.0743175521,
0.2139447629,
0.1686744839,
0.1388637871,
-0.2531288266,
0.110264048,
-0.0438216254,
0.0217858609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00435v1
|
Hierarchical Indexing for Retrieval-Augmented Opinion Summarization
| 2024-03-01T10:38:07 | 2024-03-01T10:38:07 |
Tom Hosking, Hao Tang, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a method for unsupervised abstractive opinion summarization, that
combines the attributability and scalability of extractive approaches with the
coherence and fluency of Large Language Models (LLMs). Our method, HIRO, learns
an index structure that maps sentences to a path through a semantically
organized discrete hierarchy. At inference time, we populate the index and use
it to identify and retrieve clusters of sentences containing popular opinions
from input reviews. Then, we use a pretrained LLM to generate a readable
summary that is grounded in these extracted evidential clusters. The modularity
of our approach allows us to evaluate its efficacy at each stage. We show that
HIRO learns an encoding space that is more semantically structured than prior
work, and generates summaries that are more representative of the opinions in
the input reviews. Human evaluation confirms that HIRO generates more coherent,
detailed and accurate summaries that are significantly preferred by annotators
compared to prior work.
|
[
-0.3341178894,
-0.5790787339,
0.4815954864,
-0.0719758198,
-0.2748208642,
0.2852658033,
-0.0941156745,
-0.5235705972,
0.7530514002,
0.3816067874,
0.038126938,
-0.5947233438,
-0.4743004739,
0.0642287135,
-0.3811567128,
1.4233350754,
0.2224120945,
-0.2511506081,
-0.1480812728,
-0.0354561582,
0.2433053255,
-0.6442424655,
-0.1899749041,
-0.4440841675,
0.5827608109,
0.4403912425,
0.7407939434,
0.5407534242,
0.540228188,
0.2795891762,
-0.3407402039,
0.2387445569,
-0.5665248632,
0.0234197062,
-0.0960499048,
-0.4591941535,
-0.7567248344,
-0.01233075,
0.7347072363,
0.8530094028,
-0.3149074614,
0.1177695021,
0.1005023792,
0.9198586345,
-0.7374313474,
0.1219790876,
-0.5787528157,
0.110899128,
-0.0794922039,
-0.3379144073,
-0.2155388594,
-0.5811960101,
0.2899830639,
-0.6169040799,
0.0693233237,
0.16332376,
0.5641009212,
-0.0599217042,
-0.3222673237,
-0.3620007038,
-0.6504299045,
0.9239982367,
-0.6393683553,
-0.0413433947,
0.1457402706,
0.2649410963,
0.1660260707,
-0.5912181735,
-0.3558315039,
0.224968791,
-0.1558753252,
0.5534804463,
-0.1447052807,
0.0969856232,
-0.2254046649,
0.9039456248,
-0.3584900796,
-0.0610124618,
-0.2580795288,
0.0493476689,
0.5482466221,
0.1041587219,
0.0530809313,
-0.7096678019,
-0.2986643016,
-0.0269285832,
-0.7487133145,
0.1039807051,
0.3764276206,
0.0156684294,
0.2132420242,
0.7039060593,
-0.5434054136,
0.1586400568,
0.2738398612,
-0.3077552319,
0.5405440331,
-0.3461407423,
-0.1198704988,
0.1025748923,
0.8622282743,
0.5307562351,
0.0363408923,
-0.1149051487,
-0.3758188188,
-0.1194378957,
0.3230547011,
-0.7896935344,
-0.0494414493,
0.2844945788,
-0.6952004433,
-0.5878894925,
0.3812035024,
-1.0468137264,
-0.2162353545,
-0.0903479978,
0.4094102979,
-0.0289966576,
-0.1360759586,
-0.009413884,
-0.3306863308,
-0.075077571,
0.3140559196,
-1.1141747236,
0.4602174163,
0.8408948183,
0.6841192245,
-0.4374591112,
-0.2785187364,
-0.359611541,
0.1939091384,
-0.4641842246,
1.0839782953,
-0.6090014577,
-0.5096398592,
0.0410513282,
-0.1966696233,
0.0575348884,
-0.8288260102,
0.1222715527,
-0.6108321548,
0.2402740866,
-0.0882676393,
-0.3681155741,
-0.263435483,
0.4243899584,
-0.4348460734,
1.1913734674,
0.0289138611,
-0.9291069508,
0.2638129294,
-0.6741600633,
-0.6004732847,
-0.0689303279,
-0.1858666986,
-0.3203690946,
0.3667292893,
0.5116356611,
0.3778289855,
0.0461004935,
0.0930522829,
-0.0048936009,
-0.3749783635,
-0.1480233222,
0.113085106,
0.3302040994,
0.1571628451,
-0.1089366674,
0.4496513307,
-0.6469413042,
-0.1350077242,
-0.2879563868,
-0.5181974173,
-0.6123618484,
0.226446569,
-0.1631743908,
-0.1133102328,
0.5318222642,
-0.5434747338,
0.0756854638,
-0.8948807716,
0.3330935538,
0.6491655707,
0.5125954151,
0.555945158,
-0.1958046108,
0.3430216014,
0.2586064041,
0.11356657,
-0.3979038596,
-0.2193551511,
-0.6606487036,
-0.2743732333,
0.1111181751,
0.4145469666,
-0.5282476544,
0.715362072,
-0.3233006001,
-0.3944729865,
-0.6770213842,
0.0065127425,
0.3854576945,
0.5280048847,
0.3780228496,
-0.4749771953,
-0.6169400215,
-1.0215901136,
-0.2125083804,
-0.5060793161,
0.0475075841,
0.1871887445,
0.858751893,
-0.2701174617,
0.8276370764,
-0.5524466038,
-0.0556355789,
-0.3857014179,
0.7464603186,
0.3599263132,
0.1787713468,
0.2295323163,
-0.5242001414,
-0.2895291746,
0.2503886223,
-0.8261024356,
0.1735544652,
0.1563374847,
-0.0900056511,
-0.070400767,
0.3344652355,
-0.3220784366,
0.2370065898,
0.0118208081,
0.3372788727,
0.4173729718,
-0.3106443882,
0.4559887052,
-1.3547948599,
0.1091489941,
-0.1466017962,
-0.2425585836,
-0.1844778508,
0.2084812224,
-0.2500127256,
-0.0115631577,
-0.2579448819,
0.1213326007,
-0.3819583952,
-0.3417160809,
-0.435547024,
0.162227422,
0.0012900407,
0.6401536465,
0.1788861752,
0.7332474589,
0.1418011039,
-0.3588233292,
0.097487554,
0.3441863954,
-0.6829442382,
0.3781405091,
-0.9525328279,
0.061059311,
-0.3951873779,
0.1796359718,
-0.9340248108,
-0.4244607985,
-0.280844003,
-0.3359728158,
-0.0360300541,
0.0533627309,
-0.4456867278,
-0.1642100364,
-0.881275773,
0.2142873704,
0.5992023349,
-0.6622034907,
0.3530629873,
0.9140449762,
-0.437100172,
-0.7901470065,
-0.2722843587,
0.0637230575,
-0.1873810738,
-0.1189228669,
0.4427793324,
0.050186336,
-0.4811567068,
-0.0077731386,
-0.0249299966,
-0.0341286734,
0.1090606377,
0.135753274,
0.2281682491,
-0.1864056736,
-0.1250375956,
0.2127358913,
-0.0440267548,
0.122575596,
0.1237399727,
0.1369216591,
-0.443225652,
0.1174171343,
-0.1911706477,
0.7512406111,
0.7103857398,
-0.2176006883,
0.3312246203,
0.1564252377,
-0.4364847243,
-0.0578555204,
-0.3622873724,
0.023608597,
-0.3341238499,
0.6369935274,
-0.1618082225,
-0.8983356357,
0.5341361761,
-0.0807756409,
0.309553057,
0.7415201068,
0.7593467236,
-0.4777281284,
1.2977164984,
0.6926292181,
-0.4702343345,
0.5511578918,
-0.2956343293,
0.2868537605,
-0.9753732085,
-0.1553684473,
-0.5667000413,
-0.2426227927,
-0.4709975123,
0.0046197316,
0.901705265,
0.0981016085,
0.043160066,
-0.1283444017,
-0.2383677959,
0.7316887379,
0.3962062001,
0.0724732503,
0.5718724132,
0.1766734719,
-0.0241611823,
0.0158449356,
-0.491638422,
-0.5498342514,
0.8290472627,
0.2116042972,
0.7032018304,
0.0683685765,
0.8223460913,
0.3526019752,
0.4045059681,
-1.0521985292,
0.4623959064,
-0.0888925567,
-0.4233368635,
-0.1801880598,
-0.3039465845,
-0.8623232245,
0.5521999002,
-0.403527081,
-0.5583791733,
0.4006971121,
0.0005778616,
-0.4704597592,
0.1335104555,
-0.4453468323,
0.5746765733,
0.144730106,
-0.0632622689,
-0.6127435565,
-0.8013588786,
0.4447877705,
0.0556863435,
0.2057224214,
0.3036369383,
-0.0183205865,
1.064261198,
-0.6624646187,
0.7580289245,
0.1750982106,
0.1967984736,
0.1949547678,
-0.2297964394,
0.0893890187,
0.0164396092,
-0.2174420059,
0.0839134157,
-0.0233911332,
-0.1962314397,
-0.8056682348,
0.5866258144,
-0.9386755228,
-0.6018601656,
-0.5334079862,
-0.4967360198,
-0.2390766144,
0.3507334292,
0.2369289398,
0.6338627934,
-0.418664217,
0.3687015176,
0.6025074124,
0.1409237534,
0.4026493728,
0.2920942008,
-0.2457078248,
-0.7667079568,
0.6888669133,
0.1748879999,
-0.0632791892,
0.769115448,
0.4509858191,
-0.2178057283,
-0.7035775185,
-0.3088603318,
0.1990078837,
-0.6346503496,
-0.0099596363,
-0.6270458102,
-0.1031124964,
-0.2251555473,
-0.0596918538,
-0.2693408132,
-0.6798166633,
0.1103929356,
-0.2644108236,
0.0965269879,
1.151715517,
0.0570531599,
0.3158620596,
-0.7272335887,
0.3555336595,
0.3021739721,
0.1291821599,
0.2234975696,
-0.4499319494,
-0.6538582444,
-0.2456479222,
-0.2338990718,
-0.6318312287,
0.4722879529,
0.1814268976,
0.3609443605,
0.4677968323,
0.1224604174,
0.8678343296,
-0.4815931022,
0.8006942272,
0.1382558495,
-0.6867633462,
0.8061916828,
-0.3595719039,
0.3916524649,
0.878785491,
0.6037454605,
-0.1897231936,
-0.4047192633,
-0.5001408458,
-0.909609139,
0.19637312,
-0.1982175261,
-0.1444342285,
-0.3882411718,
0.3550594747,
0.4084605575,
0.5947816372,
-0.3776248693,
0.0445569977,
-0.0644769743,
-0.3635272086,
-0.1124583706,
-0.6469060779,
-0.1650206894,
-0.2655471861,
0.6264346242,
-0.0520870462,
-0.0410331972,
0.3671774566,
-0.3089955449,
-0.1446039677,
0.484229058,
0.0255149752,
0.837927103,
-0.4638308585,
0.4061188698,
-0.1670562774,
-0.5228605866,
-0.2146594971,
-0.3613846898,
-0.3133591115,
-0.0021354384,
0.5337952375,
0.5279294848,
0.4684384763,
-0.4403921068,
0.6049544811,
-0.005440332,
-0.1124829724,
-0.0857542232,
-0.1685488224,
-0.2652088106,
0.0441259369,
0.3830870986,
0.224795118,
0.655033052,
-1.1004678011,
0.0822296813,
0.3607821465,
-0.2618462145,
-0.5538651347,
0.3124603927,
0.3684031963,
-0.0036913888,
0.3709585071,
0.2025348246,
-0.5106835961,
0.2295817137,
0.4372462928,
1.056840539,
-0.0070464774,
0.0712698698,
0.4048219025,
0.0972515568,
-0.1310454756,
0.182945773,
-0.4338208139,
-0.4944345653,
-0.4886282384,
-0.5965931416,
-0.7011790872,
-0.2750455737,
-0.946667254,
-0.3387173712,
-0.3065627813,
0.1337328851,
0.1879671663,
0.0518937707,
0.1494175941,
0.1366724074,
-0.2921020091,
0.4869562984,
-0.8089091778,
0.4451617897,
0.776932478,
-0.4454756379,
-0.2703299522,
0.1529536843,
-0.2353516668,
-0.5840344429,
0.2476807982,
-0.0147117637,
-0.5112134218,
-0.1465880275,
-0.438511312,
-0.5800334811,
0.8568238616,
-0.0890459493,
-0.1910187304,
-0.0788845792,
-0.2665021718,
0.7629160881,
-0.6079018116,
0.4177287817,
0.4842719436,
0.0404975116,
0.0968934223,
-0.6458926797,
-0.3770612478,
-0.5465709567,
-0.140086025,
0.2013086379,
-0.4642285407,
0.5875658393,
-0.3336578012,
-0.1535983384,
0.0857008994,
1.0205504894,
0.1121022031,
0.2092448473,
0.5127695203,
0.4589419365,
0.9721198082,
0.116842635,
1.19267869,
-0.2258658558,
0.2371492535,
1.0450236797,
-0.1241157353,
1.5163321495,
0.4949988723,
-0.0268301703,
0.8447456956,
0.6012687683,
0.4718795121,
0.5735398531,
-0.1561923623,
-0.1392301321,
-0.0362171717,
-0.2405230105,
-0.2695542872,
0.2345728427,
0.1501748413,
-0.1117438823,
-0.1408832371,
-0.2973994911,
-0.0277098902,
0.2758635879,
-0.6534410119,
1.135043025,
0.080795601,
-0.8566893339,
0.3747880459,
-0.0913996026,
0.7195678949,
-0.4609359801,
-0.170464918,
-0.2206947356,
0.1400431693,
-0.534306109,
-0.7782235146,
0.4222379625,
0.2853786647,
-0.6372722387,
-0.2431233823,
0.3793732822,
-0.3887760937,
-0.4954487979,
-0.1091114208,
0.6068494916,
0.3698535562,
0.2001895905,
-0.2232198417,
-0.3491189778,
-0.2608380914,
-0.3763613999,
0.4027216434,
0.2324482352,
-0.2334922105,
0.153837055,
0.3906003833,
0.1048280001,
-0.3185571134,
0.3414718509,
0.6762014031,
-0.667083323,
-0.8314242959,
-0.767889142,
0.3553158045,
-0.257751286,
-0.2155532092,
0.9074854851,
0.8873702288,
0.647413075,
0.0098868953,
0.7368059158,
0.2244580686,
0.7784971595,
-0.423068583,
0.6390817761,
-0.6452574134,
0.2686299086,
-0.2768608034,
-0.9187332392,
-0.2276816964,
0.6695646644,
-0.3542571962,
-0.0766538307,
0.9988110662,
0.7302132249,
0.0617914274,
0.0585305803,
0.021767009,
0.464046061,
-0.0887359604,
0.4651654959,
0.9357872605,
-0.4524542987,
0.1719456613,
-0.0270386562,
-0.4836626351,
-0.2439920306,
-0.6898578405,
-0.8422296643,
-0.4519912004,
-0.2818737924,
-0.1384394765,
0.0862613171,
0.7465104461,
0.6425471902,
-0.7961787581,
-0.6524192095,
0.1054242551,
0.3471708,
-0.3035682738,
-0.1810984164,
0.5195025206,
-0.2128816843,
-0.7773578167,
0.4374371469,
0.5701517463,
-0.3780718744,
-0.3287411034,
0.1372530907,
-0.1322458386,
0.0723663941,
0.8572121859,
0.1011062935,
-0.5518399477,
-0.3772669137,
-0.1271670014,
-0.0253482554,
0.4337272644,
0.8122768998,
-0.6913804412,
0.5003777146,
0.8483441472,
0.4711469412,
0.6926147342,
0.3559898734,
0.5580429435,
-0.6294616461,
-0.0820392594,
0.1054603234,
0.4035485387,
0.1252536029,
-0.30389449,
0.3498515785,
0.0545981899,
-0.5133488178,
-0.6474043131,
-0.0253074877,
-1.0570812225,
-0.0636315644,
0.7654878497,
-0.0540033542,
-0.5831403136,
0.033337459,
-0.0982271731,
-0.1606665999,
-0.4270519912,
0.9844535589,
0.4528121352,
-0.2879274786,
0.0466437526,
-0.1220710129,
0.2430081517,
0.2219957709,
-0.9879119992,
-0.0578036048,
0.5262829065,
0.0318905935,
0.3365205824,
0.6963879466,
-0.533236444,
0.268111527,
-0.2348753214,
0.1259106249,
0.0709395632,
-0.5904906988,
-0.5225292444,
0.5755231977,
0.1281584203,
0.0084680319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00418v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00418v2
|
LLMs for Targeted Sentiment in News Headlines: Exploring the Descriptive-Prescriptive Dilemma
| 2024-03-01T10:10:34 | 2024-05-28T11:04:32 |
Jana Juroš, Laura Majer, Jan Šnajder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
News headlines often evoke sentiment by intentionally portraying entities in
particular ways, making targeted sentiment analysis (TSA) of headlines a
worthwhile but difficult task. Due to its subjectivity, creating TSA datasets
can involve various annotation paradigms, from descriptive to prescriptive,
either encouraging or limiting subjectivity. LLMs are a good fit for TSA due to
their broad linguistic and world knowledge and in-context learning abilities,
yet their performance depends on prompt design. In this paper, we compare the
accuracy of state-of-the-art LLMs and fine-tuned encoder models for TSA of news
headlines using descriptive and prescriptive datasets across several languages.
Exploring the descriptive--prescriptive continuum, we analyze how performance
is affected by prompt prescriptiveness, ranging from plain zero-shot to
elaborate few-shot prompts. Finally, we evaluate the ability of LLMs to
quantify uncertainty via calibration error and comparison to human label
variation. We find that LLMs outperform fine-tuned encoders on descriptive
datasets, while calibration and F1-score generally improve with increased
prescriptiveness, yet the optimal level varies.
|
[
-0.2652817369,
-0.7663190961,
0.8779245019,
0.5874122381,
-0.6473407149,
0.2556599379,
-0.2657650709,
-0.164755255,
0.4175293446,
0.2634071112,
-0.5489754677,
-0.890634954,
-0.7292283177,
0.398209095,
-0.2663885653,
1.1810697317,
0.0441871323,
0.1362179071,
-0.3608767986,
0.1743252724,
-0.2138965726,
-0.4098615646,
-0.5901238918,
0.1501554549,
0.8936951756,
0.1905267686,
0.8028128147,
0.3637627959,
0.6238772273,
0.1629064679,
-0.2465340346,
0.0600566082,
-0.2861014605,
-0.1568825841,
-0.0899608284,
-0.5236709118,
-0.3967794776,
0.109437272,
0.5727324486,
0.604554534,
0.1589505523,
0.2463575602,
0.0723083243,
0.7762383223,
-0.3791297674,
-0.1412541717,
-0.3771421015,
0.0879272893,
-0.1932680458,
-0.4311410189,
-0.1750225127,
-0.6801509261,
0.2974770367,
-0.6340921521,
-0.032483831,
0.2359014153,
1.0819944143,
0.4548082352,
-0.6159858108,
-0.5362877846,
-0.7127519846,
0.8574766517,
-0.5805072784,
0.367759943,
0.1372079849,
0.0647211373,
-0.1385385096,
-0.3856669068,
0.0202835295,
-0.3458609879,
0.0201549642,
0.2865405977,
-0.3848054707,
0.0827043056,
0.2745646536,
0.1459496766,
-0.6208913326,
0.543094039,
-0.3156043887,
-0.308562398,
0.3116285503,
0.1054469571,
-0.1011516824,
-0.3979053795,
-0.6013737321,
0.2171458602,
-0.8128668666,
0.3003256023,
0.6669639349,
0.5946231484,
-0.1250356138,
0.5808086395,
-0.4558511078,
0.859389782,
0.2643107474,
-0.3007775843,
0.24687998,
-0.3087152839,
-0.1487281024,
0.1384526789,
0.8773244023,
0.6906241179,
0.31780532,
-0.0049388623,
-0.4293743372,
0.0496490337,
0.3397370279,
-0.5597929955,
0.3829428256,
0.3031659126,
-0.4161351621,
-0.5339266658,
0.1310393214,
-0.9621068239,
-0.4323914945,
-0.432061553,
0.368370086,
0.0246823449,
0.1454791874,
0.231471926,
0.0001363363,
0.4921132624,
0.3323787749,
-0.3595444262,
-0.1425353885,
0.4088747501,
0.7751643062,
-0.2167738229,
0.0469255522,
-0.316267103,
-0.2670258582,
-0.4561241567,
0.9842725396,
-0.4810376465,
-0.3924433589,
0.0728348419,
-0.2698806524,
0.0778405294,
-0.4345808327,
0.8489695191,
-0.4845660329,
0.2468723506,
-0.4778133929,
-0.2907987535,
-0.0191636868,
0.5783298016,
-0.5690255761,
0.6237659454,
0.1515414417,
-0.6442628503,
0.5625727773,
-0.4102818966,
-0.7560905218,
-0.3861501813,
0.0746850669,
-0.4068798125,
0.4088689387,
0.5620141029,
0.5092843771,
-0.2893730402,
0.376047343,
0.0305100512,
-0.2404058725,
0.435510844,
-0.2809953988,
0.2086744159,
0.5144799352,
0.0854340494,
0.1244198978,
-0.6932810545,
-0.3299840093,
-0.0651776791,
-0.430118829,
-0.2833241224,
-0.1961464137,
-0.1109357402,
0.1973716915,
0.4630196393,
-0.4262187481,
-0.1565260142,
-0.2907762229,
0.1308261603,
0.6717041731,
0.2197631598,
0.567104876,
-0.4369964004,
0.8236292601,
0.3887418509,
0.2790251672,
-0.0884759501,
-0.2098146975,
-0.4003578424,
-0.0962973833,
0.2326279283,
0.6135168076,
-0.5458543897,
0.4388094544,
-0.1222067028,
-0.3937756419,
-0.3024295568,
-0.1040167212,
0.3055834472,
0.5628678203,
0.3144235611,
0.0029697681,
-0.7476241589,
-0.7849525213,
-0.769074142,
0.0192302763,
-0.0400862843,
0.0731011182,
-0.0064712744,
-0.0258690584,
1.1235440969,
-0.4417039156,
-0.440297693,
-0.408964932,
0.0383618549,
0.4770519733,
0.1827788353,
0.4792800546,
-0.6961082816,
-0.2887423635,
-0.3269948363,
-0.6883538961,
-0.3118616045,
-0.3191283047,
0.1745655686,
0.0955396071,
0.4538002908,
-0.6993788481,
0.1902991235,
0.2398398966,
-0.224026382,
0.6403371692,
0.1368124634,
0.2065133154,
-1.2228392363,
-0.2331058681,
0.493270874,
-0.1266781241,
-0.6147850752,
-0.3034048975,
-0.0617093332,
0.0248977672,
-0.7887060046,
0.4611370564,
-0.3013531268,
-0.0914466903,
-0.1766790301,
0.1472453773,
0.1424276829,
0.1520187855,
0.0911506563,
0.6576008201,
0.6048507094,
-0.7508482933,
0.2787947059,
-0.0947399139,
-0.4040936232,
0.7750400305,
-0.4983008206,
-0.2169403881,
-0.6111076474,
0.307554096,
-0.8971630335,
-0.2319635004,
0.2927411795,
-0.5743556023,
0.1979195923,
0.1103693023,
-0.4234978259,
-0.35954386,
-0.4525152147,
0.2262370884,
0.6498548985,
-0.1876190305,
0.535528779,
0.1344446093,
-0.0384257808,
-0.6198647022,
-0.6666194797,
0.2008355111,
-0.5706618428,
-0.0451477505,
0.0924317837,
0.1064602882,
-0.3870943189,
-0.1235625446,
-0.2655280232,
0.1957253963,
0.1110498831,
0.0620518215,
0.1102802679,
-0.1688925326,
0.0241628978,
0.0611337125,
-0.107463181,
0.3198392987,
-0.2090027183,
0.3935466707,
-0.1068910286,
-0.0784255415,
-0.5526034832,
0.0391817652,
0.5437404513,
-0.0808849335,
0.4721723795,
0.5478799343,
-0.2678538263,
-0.0010055401,
-0.5677264333,
-0.1976987869,
-0.417773962,
0.352707684,
-0.3592846394,
-0.526385963,
0.5353347063,
-0.1704180092,
-0.2197704315,
0.4414461553,
0.3813983202,
-0.3756465018,
0.9190526009,
0.3412648737,
-0.2412773222,
0.4533605576,
0.0446980372,
0.0680748671,
-0.5754970908,
-0.2294183969,
-0.5631224513,
-0.3625617623,
-0.4643183947,
0.017027691,
0.4178842008,
-0.1380511671,
-0.17288284,
0.0152615327,
-0.2907795608,
0.5508739948,
0.5603072047,
0.2742076218,
0.2715250552,
0.0181287676,
0.2945270836,
-0.036733631,
-0.3871228695,
-0.7222958207,
1.0592308044,
0.4241167307,
1.1409934759,
-0.2113721371,
0.5967524052,
0.2515324354,
0.0300397445,
-1.0378779173,
0.5956835747,
-0.2696681917,
-0.2884666026,
0.014860196,
-0.3913511634,
-0.8525849581,
-0.1523743123,
-0.1463277638,
-0.2964062989,
0.1088704988,
0.0097250547,
-0.7250810266,
0.1646670252,
-0.3688293993,
0.6720032096,
-0.3797312975,
0.067396149,
0.2025068551,
-0.6401966214,
0.1740238667,
-0.1411805749,
0.3413845599,
-0.3537048101,
-0.4221585989,
0.7252470851,
0.1499860883,
1.0851303339,
-0.2727441788,
-0.4307131469,
0.2747113109,
-0.240418449,
0.4562609792,
0.1118825749,
-0.0171961356,
0.1686909795,
-0.2626049817,
-0.3074331284,
-0.4653618634,
0.4593381882,
-0.8585574031,
-0.7489753962,
-0.4159285724,
-0.5019107461,
-0.4537320137,
0.1179879531,
0.7105314136,
0.5281951427,
-0.3421371281,
-0.0344030447,
0.595036149,
-0.1421110183,
0.2736797333,
0.4916843474,
-0.1058673337,
-0.3830631971,
0.767919302,
0.2731756568,
0.0157961901,
0.8129733801,
0.3195936382,
-0.4737445116,
-0.8115438223,
-0.2925357521,
0.0652444512,
-0.6189089417,
-0.4412616789,
-0.5391941071,
-0.0116027128,
-0.3045064509,
-0.4407424331,
-0.2603470981,
-0.1490563899,
-0.8236117363,
-0.3010800481,
0.2485546321,
0.5695144534,
0.1865984499,
0.369966656,
-0.857157886,
0.3167238832,
-0.0547631197,
0.1997705698,
-0.6141557693,
-0.7052761316,
-0.151026547,
0.0894661397,
-0.1973709911,
-0.986246109,
0.3120226562,
-0.0953699425,
0.402120918,
0.5150280595,
0.4560978413,
0.4581661522,
-0.1101696715,
0.927913487,
0.0265511516,
-0.7110908031,
0.826457262,
-0.4675254822,
0.4641472399,
0.5615344644,
0.6310979724,
-0.2207945585,
-0.6900855899,
-0.1292743981,
-0.532987833,
0.4342105985,
-0.2081766874,
0.2481432706,
-0.2761045992,
0.4045309126,
0.1188038364,
0.3234713674,
-0.5881716609,
-0.0945816189,
-0.2587797642,
-0.5016258359,
-0.2410759926,
-0.4588312507,
-0.0529363267,
0.1627402306,
0.3899991512,
-0.120719552,
0.0837581754,
0.3322490752,
-0.151149556,
-0.0960494503,
0.4537431002,
0.8165433407,
0.5269067287,
-0.2965005934,
0.1301697493,
0.1190326735,
-0.3985951543,
0.374579072,
0.017354589,
-0.3338935673,
0.1204484254,
0.332308799,
0.844851613,
0.3857640624,
-0.54532516,
0.563801825,
0.0083979741,
-0.1255295128,
-0.1784122288,
-0.3491820097,
-0.2735163569,
0.2355315983,
0.5145754218,
0.1807356328,
0.1614648104,
-0.3870827258,
-0.1413427144,
0.5171747804,
-0.2548682392,
-0.4901045561,
0.5309235454,
0.32102561,
-0.1124718264,
0.311190486,
-0.2509806752,
-0.4300049245,
0.7329746485,
0.5035724044,
1.0119198561,
-0.0898588523,
0.3516332209,
0.327269882,
0.5236462355,
-0.0772575513,
0.3374600708,
0.1881091744,
-0.8757179976,
-0.2456576228,
-0.6789964437,
-0.4808285236,
-0.0988806859,
-0.7888367772,
0.35045591,
-0.6183264256,
-0.4922139645,
-0.3780485392,
0.0320625231,
-0.7633218765,
0.404292047,
0.0943848416,
0.8299827576,
-0.8139224648,
0.373501271,
1.0183542967,
-0.2946282029,
-0.6006013155,
0.3581591547,
-0.0653396025,
-0.630025208,
0.5453336239,
0.3869597018,
0.0972386673,
0.2498658001,
-0.3335090578,
-0.7739856839,
0.8480887413,
0.4014861286,
-0.6566489935,
-0.2637460232,
0.4757814109,
0.4446555972,
-0.3042348325,
0.1178162917,
0.6313209534,
0.682161212,
0.1880480647,
-0.840056181,
0.0103556346,
0.4093883038,
-0.1904126406,
-0.0323759615,
-0.6477966905,
0.6274793148,
-0.4416216314,
-0.283220768,
-0.1901790202,
0.7001603246,
0.0793532059,
0.5442162156,
0.391623944,
0.5895104408,
0.5269410014,
-0.3255839944,
1.1070296764,
-0.2591982484,
0.1804392785,
0.6578115225,
-0.1469438821,
0.5476005673,
0.5238258243,
-0.3264354169,
0.4719528556,
0.9519811869,
0.1987367868,
0.6147712469,
0.1049753055,
-0.21594432,
-0.0900979862,
-0.3601487577,
-0.1267422289,
0.5108283758,
0.3777546287,
-0.3272613883,
-0.4266036749,
0.3854064643,
0.1043345928,
0.1841724515,
-0.8664677739,
0.839758575,
0.2794881165,
-0.676471889,
0.2282435745,
0.0300894994,
0.9426439404,
-0.6747194529,
0.6997320056,
-0.37621966,
-0.1533649564,
-0.3885585368,
-0.9742106199,
0.3995795548,
0.1869000196,
-0.1959363371,
-0.1405561417,
0.7113984227,
-0.3855011165,
-0.4654305875,
-0.0094301859,
0.6352561116,
0.0216482934,
-0.2921642959,
-0.5062469244,
0.2989186347,
-0.217873022,
-0.567008853,
0.2632475197,
0.3766168356,
0.0730633363,
0.4570601881,
0.6236070991,
0.2153679132,
0.0660029575,
0.2058383673,
0.712603569,
-0.8712246418,
-0.6685104966,
-0.9611608982,
0.2687603831,
0.2245551944,
-0.3944764137,
0.8268103004,
0.4933270216,
0.5538568497,
-0.4317999184,
0.5298417807,
0.2457396686,
0.4560595751,
-0.8790632486,
0.285959065,
-0.2989927232,
0.2109354287,
-0.0875540227,
-0.9742242694,
-0.7195470333,
0.3358470798,
-0.4070612788,
0.1252625734,
0.5331778526,
0.7755014896,
0.3477025926,
-0.2241243422,
0.3187001646,
0.0511620939,
0.1628213823,
0.6071455479,
1.161912322,
-0.0402075574,
0.4958559275,
-0.1012736484,
-0.0472494662,
-0.2150908262,
-1.1704597473,
-0.9117925763,
-0.1847072691,
-0.2870575488,
-0.1670292318,
0.1139471307,
1.2050081491,
0.4615837634,
-0.6675642133,
0.1756986082,
-0.0640355423,
0.3549801111,
-0.1238187402,
-0.3024263382,
0.3110033274,
-0.8078995347,
-0.9120560288,
0.3352083266,
0.1780337989,
0.2603639662,
-0.182820037,
0.1051843092,
0.1813836247,
0.3273480237,
0.5615749955,
0.1478082389,
-0.7902354598,
-0.2197959721,
0.1112444848,
-0.316216439,
-0.0036932928,
0.8713410497,
-0.9716194272,
0.1141981855,
0.3709199131,
0.6890105605,
-0.1789291352,
0.3697542548,
0.3363152146,
-1.078592062,
0.0883433968,
0.3526394963,
0.2257550657,
0.3378751278,
-0.611042738,
0.0948377848,
0.0825475305,
-0.3795797527,
-0.8039707541,
0.1780252159,
-1.1892442703,
-0.0959132016,
1.4406000376,
0.1914545596,
-0.1475353241,
-0.022832565,
-0.2860139906,
-0.0414261669,
-0.5751350522,
0.463216573,
0.527748704,
0.1904218346,
-0.185255304,
-0.2999615967,
0.6723650098,
0.2117482275,
-0.7218550444,
-0.2751607597,
0.3629505038,
0.1619843692,
-0.1048288271,
0.586515069,
0.0280440878,
0.1923089474,
-0.3994466364,
-0.2296969146,
-0.2189687788,
-0.5280511379,
-0.558062315,
0.1807158589,
0.0099664656,
-0.4374453127
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.