id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18756v1
|
How Much Annotation is Needed to Compare Summarization Models?
| 2024-02-28T23:34:51 | 2024-02-28T23:34:51 |
Chantal Shaib, Joe Barrow, Alexa F. Siu, Byron C. Wallace, Ani Nenkova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern instruction-tuned models have become highly capable in text generation
tasks such as summarization, and are expected to be released at a steady pace.
In practice one may now wish to choose confidently, but with minimal effort,
the best performing summarization model when applied to a new domain or
purpose. In this work, we empirically investigate the test sample size
necessary to select a preferred model in the context of news summarization.
Empirical results reveal that comparative evaluation converges quickly for both
automatic and human evaluation, with clear preferences for a system emerging
from under 100 examples. The human preference data allows us to quantify how
well automatic scores can reproduce preference rankings across a variety of
downstream summarization tasks. We find that, while automatic metrics are
stable at smaller sample sizes, only some automatic metrics are able to
moderately predict model win rates according to human preference.
|
[
-0.7463391423,
-0.298245579,
0.505212009,
0.3212826848,
-0.2576389313,
-0.3067121804,
-0.3613432348,
-0.5530328751,
0.1222792938,
0.1587024927,
-0.0694337189,
-0.1564245373,
-0.6634503007,
0.4295839369,
-0.463588804,
1.3575294018,
0.0936672837,
-0.0613963157,
-0.6446794271,
-0.0387320034,
-0.285726428,
-0.419867456,
-0.6265100241,
-0.4530867338,
0.5336881876,
0.2796448171,
0.7072198987,
0.6523371339,
0.8576057553,
0.2333204448,
-0.2910580337,
0.1389179975,
-0.20638749,
-0.0188164767,
0.1819936484,
-0.5582066774,
-0.6405009031,
0.5890963674,
0.4094392061,
0.9675204158,
0.2513309717,
0.7446805239,
0.0263829697,
0.8475530148,
-0.674859345,
0.0545791239,
-0.2662913203,
-0.0022534186,
0.2181526124,
-0.0098626167,
-0.3995479941,
-0.6773226857,
0.4705545306,
-0.5224965811,
0.3499893546,
0.1962066442,
0.8765948415,
0.18807064,
-0.6546908617,
-0.0280677117,
-0.4415386021,
0.7707285285,
-0.7752056718,
0.0528630279,
0.3817334771,
0.4469168186,
0.2763954997,
-0.4740555882,
-0.2574452162,
-0.5130653381,
-0.1199521571,
0.2060830295,
-0.1541687101,
-0.0221119821,
0.3257137835,
0.3852002919,
-0.5448114872,
0.1346476078,
-0.6168604493,
0.0256671458,
1.0145242214,
0.2265137583,
0.0859560072,
-0.452824533,
-0.1287574172,
-0.1994102597,
-0.3412279487,
0.0297816042,
0.4652788639,
0.2353959084,
-0.1976276189,
0.6550803185,
-0.7281797528,
0.8514657021,
0.1892871708,
0.0895785764,
0.1196572408,
-0.3182552159,
-0.3847932816,
-0.0298155993,
0.7667025924,
1.1693891287,
0.4459804893,
0.0252617225,
-0.3781014383,
0.093527481,
0.272541374,
-0.9857136607,
-0.2608719468,
0.136506632,
-0.6561966538,
-0.4184200764,
0.1316900253,
-0.5211077929,
-0.3210393786,
-0.5727292299,
0.2826862633,
-0.0674106702,
-0.0410693176,
-0.0779985934,
-0.6620684266,
-0.1668015718,
0.594831109,
-1.0058079958,
0.1333332956,
0.5559847355,
1.0284626484,
-0.575783968,
-0.1435368955,
-0.283762753,
-0.367811203,
-0.8170875311,
1.0450139046,
-0.2484236807,
-0.3608647883,
-0.4224000573,
-0.2600933909,
-0.0816871896,
-0.5113059282,
0.2352995425,
-0.4777847826,
0.4095720351,
-0.4509479702,
-0.7919958234,
-0.2427440137,
0.1583965123,
-0.7908015251,
0.5975262523,
0.2267187685,
-0.9832133651,
0.9348679185,
-0.6778376102,
-0.4482835829,
-0.3423242271,
0.1904312819,
-0.578556776,
0.4292165637,
0.1630474478,
0.5824769735,
-0.046735473,
-0.0019279767,
-0.3246343434,
-0.5263981223,
0.0873288363,
-0.2865663171,
0.5385565162,
0.3336103261,
-0.17643179,
0.1959905028,
-0.5426617265,
-0.054160431,
0.0313339047,
-0.4680321217,
-0.493204385,
-0.00062717,
-0.1012481526,
-0.1274265051,
0.1916338056,
-0.259572953,
0.1734946668,
-0.2186549306,
0.2693268955,
0.4931454062,
0.1433312744,
0.6367201805,
-0.7898929715,
0.4906514287,
-0.3959698379,
0.0750191361,
-0.2126380056,
-0.3598946631,
-0.7166871428,
-0.0870780125,
0.832988739,
0.3566476405,
0.006851777,
0.3565916121,
-0.4257734716,
-0.6077668071,
-0.3812869489,
-0.1090913713,
0.1674317718,
0.2982784212,
0.2199582309,
-0.3890680373,
-0.4741403461,
-1.2014405727,
-0.3034461737,
-0.1753313094,
-0.2772570848,
0.2291854322,
0.4621227384,
0.3165344596,
1.0527994633,
-0.5586858392,
-0.0535031445,
-0.7274612784,
0.3816119432,
-0.0375104696,
0.1199213713,
0.8851788044,
-0.750952065,
-0.2336964756,
-0.3026482463,
-0.7750350237,
-0.1622397453,
-0.1177568212,
0.0418224819,
0.310538739,
0.2811666727,
-0.3373500109,
0.5395222902,
0.4803074002,
-0.1149750724,
0.4095486701,
-0.2793207467,
0.5590437055,
-0.8681863546,
0.2132586092,
0.1576073766,
-0.5153874755,
-0.3112877905,
-0.0223572534,
0.2016637474,
0.0243136995,
-0.1967400908,
0.5039147735,
-0.5089632273,
-0.3706120253,
-0.50567168,
0.4218812883,
0.0902876556,
0.1902904809,
0.1973816454,
0.9326400161,
-0.3118748367,
-0.8425799608,
0.0500227958,
0.2370472848,
-0.4198863804,
0.1412631869,
-0.8546301723,
-0.1285250783,
-0.1765339971,
0.3359215558,
-0.9745972157,
-0.5881976485,
-0.557895124,
-0.6305501461,
0.0827872753,
0.1654679626,
-0.2319296449,
-0.2722174525,
-0.6819007397,
0.116227068,
0.6945173144,
-0.2590688467,
0.2219744623,
0.4158822596,
-0.3095570207,
-0.3188692629,
-0.6351366639,
-0.0528290421,
-0.119211264,
-0.2750706375,
-0.1112584695,
-0.1007466763,
-0.5258252621,
-0.2054407448,
-0.1973339766,
0.2074321508,
0.4375807345,
0.3778084815,
0.3459666371,
-0.1896737516,
0.2468940914,
0.289367944,
-0.2998062372,
-0.0210609492,
0.2020725161,
-0.0063649323,
0.0802676976,
-0.1549933255,
-0.2619064748,
0.3487392962,
0.6078004837,
-0.3909947574,
0.5446022153,
0.0129078524,
-0.1283963025,
-0.0764920563,
-0.5672394037,
-0.2840410769,
-0.2700236738,
0.4386453331,
-0.0376831256,
-0.5100007653,
0.2620956004,
0.2126253992,
0.466240406,
0.8015438914,
0.514177382,
-0.0150809037,
1.2866441011,
0.562417984,
-0.2851208448,
0.4107375145,
-0.0984012708,
-0.1496975273,
-0.6106857657,
0.2303356081,
-0.4715485275,
-0.4764548838,
-0.329818368,
0.2202272117,
0.5402285457,
-0.1494202614,
0.0607075654,
0.2164761424,
-0.6060212255,
0.6486781836,
0.6986895204,
-0.1907492876,
0.5361308455,
-0.248173669,
0.1425955445,
0.0630611628,
-0.4813020229,
-0.795196712,
1.3015466928,
0.0487864688,
0.3299744427,
0.0527998582,
0.5998330116,
0.3986652792,
0.6862657666,
-0.561897397,
0.4777764082,
-0.2921341062,
-0.6288523078,
-0.393050164,
-0.1976505667,
-0.7967553735,
0.3525882065,
-0.4964210093,
-0.29501158,
-0.1051925495,
0.3558166921,
-0.9459356666,
0.1352273971,
-0.9564913511,
0.6953203082,
0.1453646421,
0.1637144536,
-0.0368117988,
-0.7369441986,
0.5449771285,
0.067214489,
0.0828235596,
-0.2735294402,
-0.1410999447,
0.9701578617,
-0.1156407371,
0.5543023348,
0.0449305139,
0.3095671535,
0.0675052479,
-0.0203233901,
0.0541680008,
-0.0991767645,
-0.1429448724,
-0.1266452521,
0.0233848765,
-0.1738387197,
-0.6709011197,
0.2136304229,
-0.7072252631,
-0.6042075753,
-0.4465839267,
-0.458263576,
0.0049661244,
0.1409876347,
0.7231695056,
0.5069697499,
-0.1711522639,
0.2630129457,
0.4870773852,
0.0555354208,
0.5811656713,
0.3250726461,
-0.4564871192,
-0.1103359088,
0.7505985498,
0.3480826318,
0.5491942763,
0.2424856722,
0.2740891278,
-0.0664121136,
-0.8292004466,
-0.6090931296,
0.0165269207,
-0.4282358587,
-0.2144744396,
-0.827702105,
-0.2363874614,
-0.1931658685,
-0.2172829807,
-0.4294262826,
-0.7234182358,
-0.2468861043,
-0.4875620306,
0.1223820224,
0.7495936155,
0.040004909,
0.0910356864,
-0.6451410055,
0.3421476185,
0.4066252708,
-0.0375796221,
-0.0660768002,
-0.5880340934,
-0.2623816431,
-0.148536697,
-0.2629628479,
-0.8153879642,
0.2177568674,
0.0715139955,
0.3669807017,
0.3807917833,
0.301705122,
0.3463304639,
-0.1982215941,
0.9293375611,
-0.1386961788,
-0.6240407228,
0.5948317647,
-0.2151225954,
0.3872073591,
0.900067091,
0.3359605074,
-0.3870575726,
-0.5637238026,
-0.5994322896,
-0.7746536136,
0.3528116941,
-0.003297539,
0.0618399568,
0.0133291986,
0.2236162126,
0.3891581893,
0.3809132576,
-0.286960423,
-0.121099323,
-0.0040138699,
-0.1699899286,
-0.2748926878,
-0.2464461476,
0.0122844642,
-0.1516800374,
0.4672667384,
-0.0851872265,
0.1378777325,
0.2521716356,
-0.2272530049,
-0.0048224069,
0.1775663942,
0.8182266355,
0.9773325324,
-0.3817003965,
-0.0001975928,
0.2518440783,
-0.4465150237,
0.0403341167,
0.1219192371,
-0.6015483737,
0.2164263129,
0.7479843497,
0.9689825773,
0.3144171834,
-0.6327124834,
0.7359161973,
-0.173015058,
-0.3179860413,
-0.1762934327,
0.3767099679,
-0.0667364374,
0.0124615161,
0.3695950806,
0.1188322976,
0.4998587072,
-0.2599496543,
0.1677210182,
0.2564784884,
-0.1225020289,
-0.1872783154,
0.880053401,
0.2804464698,
-0.1126337573,
0.3897631466,
-0.3426322639,
-0.3436699212,
0.6632804275,
-0.0338251702,
0.6990513206,
-0.0642037243,
0.1844532639,
0.6252816319,
0.132316485,
-0.4625297189,
-0.1572013199,
-0.0221731029,
-0.3021258712,
-0.2033458948,
-0.4095468521,
-0.6226966381,
-0.2472099364,
-0.8305427432,
0.2172957957,
-0.2482538223,
-0.5840262771,
0.2739122212,
0.2163807303,
-0.2976076305,
0.5071512461,
0.0527173467,
1.0698388815,
-1.0194313526,
0.0867008567,
0.5930852294,
-0.4730080068,
-0.7938280106,
-0.2346730232,
0.1741064936,
-0.2391280532,
0.4435842335,
0.2105891109,
0.3651374578,
-0.2537940741,
-0.3428433239,
-0.5416247845,
1.0690302849,
0.2849431932,
-0.5259612203,
-0.280412674,
-0.648394227,
0.4180197418,
-0.5105448365,
0.7113041878,
0.7425612807,
0.3015677035,
-0.1177890003,
-1.1474083662,
-0.228851825,
-0.1582850218,
-0.0645675436,
0.2410057187,
-0.7327364087,
1.0066204071,
-0.6283858418,
-0.010591466,
0.073745355,
0.8320734501,
0.1779365689,
0.558635354,
0.6834233999,
0.1786527932,
0.5117481351,
-0.0219051521,
1.5024719238,
-0.0846869126,
0.1632947177,
1.3313498497,
0.0823615566,
1.0546355247,
0.0978061408,
-0.3026423156,
-0.0103497384,
1.0197885036,
0.0000246189,
0.3535005748,
0.0944182873,
0.2278075218,
-0.3513689935,
0.0177443828,
-0.4559617043,
0.4640447497,
-0.4474150538,
-0.5977567434,
-0.1823818982,
-0.1099415347,
0.1005346105,
0.0633054674,
-0.1602236331,
0.9127200246,
0.0127049219,
-0.983289957,
0.1694934815,
-0.0321654864,
0.4252938032,
-0.4854981303,
0.1583485007,
-0.4710659087,
-0.1449116617,
-0.1751073301,
-0.3631007671,
0.1206054911,
0.077109769,
-0.2942442894,
0.2176600397,
0.4821439087,
-0.2450392395,
-0.4740238488,
-0.173530072,
0.4708441794,
0.2392669171,
-0.1038192213,
0.0695126802,
-0.0249688439,
-0.0666747987,
-0.7213252783,
0.4717565477,
-0.0471304841,
-0.3621633351,
0.5942655802,
0.5602756143,
0.3345852792,
0.0168174505,
-0.0039827479,
0.5408608913,
-0.4572938085,
-0.7418294549,
-0.9049793482,
0.4596522748,
-0.5414399505,
-0.5712903142,
0.9146760106,
0.7893683314,
0.5127624869,
0.040878877,
1.00383389,
0.2540279329,
0.7981007099,
-0.3973244727,
0.833471477,
-0.5794035196,
-0.0142184058,
-0.1679778844,
-0.9607700706,
-0.24880068,
0.6134158969,
-0.4671010971,
0.2732830048,
0.5788304806,
0.1903397292,
0.0474510975,
0.2515973449,
0.1277070642,
-0.3302866518,
0.0714967996,
0.485144347,
0.5169532895,
-0.148821339,
0.1186236218,
-0.1838263869,
-0.5319923162,
-0.4895861447,
-0.9801591635,
-1.0978748798,
-0.5583491921,
-0.4220067263,
0.0177252609,
0.027064845,
1.1737934351,
0.8891922832,
-0.6349227428,
-0.0403075516,
0.4365568161,
0.0610764846,
-0.2467720956,
-0.1374974847,
0.3306027651,
-0.3440566659,
-0.8304821253,
-0.1533593833,
0.1564108133,
0.3830356002,
-0.1470278352,
0.2382931113,
0.2391564995,
0.3737213314,
0.5084602237,
0.0982840806,
-0.431520611,
-0.310343653,
-0.1445897818,
-0.1529677659,
-0.1087276116,
0.8063892126,
-0.593282342,
0.3444276452,
0.5589441657,
0.6330063343,
0.3803961873,
0.4824692011,
0.7833983898,
-0.4156681597,
0.0052789752,
-0.0660934076,
0.0865064263,
0.2473598868,
-0.132380873,
0.6623235941,
0.0026167403,
-0.6357226372,
-0.9560037851,
-0.1344593018,
-0.7350273132,
-0.243935734,
1.0726253986,
0.0546479784,
-0.1868583411,
0.2320421785,
-0.3087046444,
0.1566267014,
-0.479197681,
0.7570598125,
0.7386069894,
-0.2659423053,
-0.0460946038,
-0.8577381968,
0.6946218014,
0.1462176889,
-0.7805863619,
0.1212951019,
0.4739406705,
0.210599184,
0.2170279473,
0.6513831019,
0.2393852621,
0.465536654,
0.0342195742,
-0.0467548482,
-0.4178836048,
-0.3580621779,
-0.2391899824,
0.3508241475,
0.1485188305,
-0.2470760494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18747v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18747v2
|
Fine-Tuned Machine Translation Metrics Struggle in Unseen Domains
| 2024-02-28T23:01:24 | 2024-06-04T04:14:16 |
Vilém Zouhar, Shuoyang Ding, Anna Currey, Tatyana Badeka, Jenyuan Wang, Brian Thompson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce a new, extensive multidimensional quality metrics (MQM)
annotated dataset covering 11 language pairs in the biomedical domain. We use
this dataset to investigate whether machine translation (MT) metrics which are
fine-tuned on human-generated MT quality judgements are robust to domain shifts
between training and inference. We find that fine-tuned metrics exhibit a
substantial performance drop in the unseen domain scenario relative to metrics
that rely on the surface form, as well as pre-trained metrics which are not
fine-tuned on MT quality judgments.
|
[
-0.3513347507,
-0.5228753686,
0.405734688,
-0.0548928417,
-0.2946490645,
0.4902900457,
-0.0775181279,
-0.4890496731,
-0.0765644163,
0.6421846151,
-0.6400068402,
-0.6536715031,
-0.9588800073,
0.3024953008,
-0.0914570093,
1.016982317,
-0.1165338457,
0.2236814499,
-0.3553560376,
-0.6573690176,
-0.3723382056,
-0.6263740063,
-0.3503545225,
-0.3867850304,
0.5080718994,
0.3563429415,
1.1203962564,
0.7444924116,
0.9409058094,
0.1888100654,
0.0769399107,
0.9631570578,
-0.3304208517,
0.0004640493,
-0.2376750112,
-0.5801813602,
-0.6423271894,
0.1278019696,
0.8194875717,
1.1267079115,
0.2717549801,
0.3109977245,
0.2043284476,
0.9318699241,
-0.4398529232,
-0.0224874076,
-0.4800051749,
0.1781849116,
-0.4761115015,
-0.3853406608,
-0.2401782423,
-0.122228235,
-0.0615373738,
-0.6916666627,
0.3976782262,
0.3090578318,
0.9921981096,
0.688560009,
-0.6445367932,
0.265214324,
-0.5904976726,
0.8169121742,
-0.5186804533,
0.6557214856,
0.5220963359,
0.3322729766,
-0.3967426419,
-0.6090576053,
-0.233280465,
0.0897619352,
-0.0678982437,
0.1828826219,
-0.2376303524,
-0.1195377707,
0.1345673054,
0.3030334711,
-0.5210439563,
0.2808278799,
-0.4088977873,
-0.3224755526,
0.4627423882,
0.5672601461,
0.1083945781,
-0.04627195,
-0.1822406054,
-0.1546017677,
-1.0205988884,
0.1263467968,
0.1701841354,
0.3456265628,
-0.0824929699,
0.7843019962,
-0.2269158512,
0.6707304716,
-0.2472873479,
-0.1578654647,
0.4032301009,
-0.4296397865,
-0.2200752199,
-0.4862046242,
0.8511710763,
0.6116386056,
0.0525964871,
-0.338429302,
-0.2273276001,
-0.0599665493,
0.3459363878,
-0.7231884599,
-0.4255197048,
0.1828926653,
-0.6400680542,
-0.0055566784,
-0.0853755325,
-0.1479284763,
-0.0959672034,
-0.3975014985,
0.3495238721,
-0.5631073713,
0.1063424572,
0.1791326404,
-0.1033704951,
-0.0220266227,
0.2684852183,
-0.4900472164,
0.2402304709,
0.5873560905,
0.9968258142,
-0.5787526369,
-0.3835997581,
-0.533780098,
-0.0714698732,
-0.5009571314,
0.7133137584,
-0.4273634553,
-0.3602622747,
-0.166976735,
0.3310317993,
-0.3244755566,
-0.8217644691,
0.7793047428,
-0.2926635146,
-0.0320023112,
-0.0046846047,
-0.5554174781,
-0.1067597941,
0.044731915,
-0.3614043295,
0.6533862948,
0.2751293778,
-0.4893256128,
0.6461466551,
-0.4968954027,
-0.5996861458,
-0.0478966832,
0.0593491755,
-0.6510933638,
0.4094210565,
0.090641208,
0.5882927775,
-0.1813414395,
0.0118035944,
-0.4453451633,
-0.1519762725,
0.6145746112,
-0.2188536674,
0.3507397771,
0.4399891198,
0.039524205,
-0.1728328913,
-0.9508600235,
0.3975635469,
-0.2502014339,
-0.320122242,
-0.3790017366,
0.001874986,
0.0446675159,
0.3940117359,
0.025724588,
-0.4342840612,
0.1739629805,
-0.3637454808,
0.6130471826,
0.3756016195,
-0.0565436669,
0.2653064728,
-0.2234376222,
0.4232503772,
0.2399780452,
0.1073276326,
0.3774140775,
-0.6152089238,
-0.5224948525,
-0.4540866017,
0.5457298756,
0.3416841328,
-0.7703083158,
0.3965468705,
-0.4204344749,
-0.4741570354,
-1.203139782,
0.0358074382,
0.6967930198,
0.3598561883,
0.6446290612,
-0.4311484993,
0.1021223888,
-1.101374507,
-0.5228223205,
0.2832414508,
-0.1057146862,
0.3464313745,
0.4010033906,
-0.5351093411,
0.428951174,
-0.5171992183,
-0.4796338975,
0.2893011272,
0.1706324518,
0.1327866316,
0.7536458969,
0.5837883353,
-0.5195398331,
-0.2810087204,
0.099468939,
-0.5987805724,
-0.2029470503,
0.0502985753,
-0.4576278925,
-0.0357474238,
0.4581678212,
-0.6240581274,
0.1846631318,
0.8474667668,
-0.4069286585,
0.5376170874,
-0.337782234,
0.4576230049,
-1.0784232616,
0.2481543273,
-0.0891181156,
-0.3237749636,
-0.4202097654,
-0.0240130275,
0.2915061116,
0.1757417172,
-0.4716252983,
0.538194716,
-0.3847886324,
-0.0768588558,
-0.2237145454,
0.0356089883,
0.3595427275,
0.298681587,
-0.1707968265,
0.9122002125,
0.3491995335,
-0.8857228756,
-0.1716341823,
0.7205675244,
-0.377997309,
0.9771077633,
-0.5768246651,
0.0685425103,
0.2969359756,
-0.0178095978,
-0.7099921703,
-0.2345250398,
0.1160920709,
-0.8282594681,
0.5436045527,
-0.1552389413,
-0.7161697149,
-0.2728867829,
0.0097101778,
0.4133622944,
0.2286223173,
-0.342055589,
-0.165688321,
0.3789916337,
0.081812501,
-0.4569267333,
-0.7827444077,
0.1952541769,
-0.1769608408,
-0.3634035885,
0.3112472296,
-0.0185671616,
0.0886019766,
-0.1449947655,
-0.2397372574,
-0.1500222534,
0.3668048084,
0.432633847,
-0.0694588199,
-0.4246003628,
-0.0411258489,
0.7041957974,
-0.2204618901,
0.1624526829,
-0.4428272843,
0.0675602406,
0.0807507038,
-0.4122859538,
-0.4587904215,
0.1828203499,
0.720973134,
-0.3775659502,
0.9435991645,
0.6802609563,
-0.4329864085,
0.0070155622,
-0.046570234,
-0.0891222581,
-0.3931986392,
0.4949606657,
-0.7929005623,
-1.0121423006,
0.5447892547,
-0.3059356511,
-0.0503489971,
0.8650197983,
0.4309896529,
-0.2482953221,
1.5230411291,
0.5356077552,
0.2975883186,
-0.0827649832,
-0.2025111914,
0.1323897392,
-1.2140774727,
-0.1895557642,
-0.6937457919,
-0.5211541057,
-0.8062564731,
-0.4110736251,
0.3997729421,
0.3422712684,
-0.1619140059,
0.2953079045,
-0.3712843657,
0.2516328692,
0.637917161,
0.1773968488,
0.4306717217,
0.016864052,
-0.2640107572,
-0.3592815399,
-0.7026453018,
-0.6883555651,
1.0569000244,
0.2656370699,
0.4352396727,
0.1757244319,
0.2455694079,
0.3271667957,
0.1261573732,
-0.5713481307,
0.043083705,
-0.5282042623,
-0.4870491624,
-0.1466786116,
-0.7974890471,
-1.2272657156,
0.2912800014,
-0.4518733025,
-0.2137001604,
0.106523484,
0.1301944703,
-0.4707706273,
0.3218218982,
-0.3679204881,
0.9301507473,
-0.313495636,
-0.1874416023,
-0.2225639671,
-0.9263128638,
0.0425045937,
-0.3454233706,
0.0696580037,
-0.5938051939,
-0.0601771735,
0.5943739414,
-0.3426289856,
0.5474216342,
0.0487781949,
0.0336519554,
-0.1727021188,
0.3811907768,
0.0274615586,
0.212415576,
0.0653061271,
0.6246098876,
0.1857922226,
-0.7333320975,
-0.2704023421,
0.5871023536,
-1.0171096325,
-0.0749753192,
-0.0473424606,
-0.4593761861,
-0.5973539352,
0.4593059719,
0.6858769059,
0.385052532,
-0.2111504823,
0.2016704679,
0.4066883326,
-0.4417454302,
-0.2912056148,
0.6875182986,
0.31046018,
-0.5389964581,
0.8851181865,
0.1100852937,
0.4138611555,
0.4684659839,
0.0195038058,
-0.443369478,
-0.9956563115,
-0.8033419251,
0.2183326334,
-0.4743242562,
-0.6875138879,
-0.7246431112,
-0.1784212589,
-0.2401177883,
0.0831736922,
-0.5582829118,
-0.6532226205,
-0.1599098295,
0.0507077016,
0.344027698,
0.6483536959,
-0.0567799136,
0.4184733629,
-1.2680624723,
0.3705797493,
-0.363132596,
0.4735866785,
-0.704136014,
-1.0330872536,
-0.6899460554,
0.395489186,
-0.3643941879,
-0.1073877737,
0.5475718379,
0.5432199836,
0.5011054277,
0.3093923032,
0.0713063776,
0.6418918371,
-0.6392655373,
0.7393594384,
0.0654950589,
-0.5984901786,
0.4061095417,
-0.2992757857,
0.2637425363,
0.6620130539,
0.3052799404,
-0.3344129622,
-0.8021407723,
-0.448922962,
-0.6688451767,
0.3923574984,
0.1947238892,
0.1356564164,
-0.0059284233,
0.5186176896,
0.5469655395,
0.489215374,
0.0312807187,
-0.6156462431,
0.0813130587,
0.0445061475,
-0.5933464766,
0.2188797593,
-0.1179374456,
-0.4768569171,
0.351613909,
-0.3162839711,
0.201015234,
0.0465153083,
-0.1672172844,
-0.2874576151,
-0.1286285669,
0.7245622873,
0.5415284038,
-0.1115070432,
0.1564314514,
-0.065714024,
-0.4624381065,
0.0229741633,
-0.0301312562,
-0.028548222,
0.1297138035,
0.2864199579,
0.7377690673,
0.0153891351,
-0.3757773936,
0.2936257422,
-0.0574102402,
-0.4611919224,
0.2309577167,
-0.0265166014,
-0.2461352497,
0.1827356517,
0.0073408955,
0.7135238647,
0.2557861805,
-0.0255387798,
0.3073277473,
0.3860476613,
-0.6977156401,
-0.5080370903,
1.0412999392,
0.1254533827,
-0.145736739,
0.705033958,
-0.0646159202,
-0.2711691558,
0.2152016163,
0.2460575402,
0.6554743648,
0.0468674488,
0.0606680699,
0.1542591602,
0.3602071702,
-0.0153483618,
-0.0519499332,
0.3416498899,
-0.6262993217,
-0.5479465723,
-0.5143694878,
-0.6082351208,
0.057202436,
-0.7277002335,
-0.0339245759,
-0.0930245966,
-0.583268702,
0.049236089,
0.0961856544,
-0.998426497,
0.3545168936,
-0.1505440176,
0.5847219229,
-0.7151082158,
0.9140822887,
0.8229178786,
-0.2314202636,
-0.3005349338,
-0.2872353196,
-0.1604207009,
-0.7919626236,
0.3993118703,
-0.0450352132,
-0.37839517,
0.0244838037,
-0.5264617205,
-0.7662997246,
0.8285671473,
0.515566051,
-0.2289620787,
0.4885201752,
0.5184093118,
0.7684993744,
-0.1745177954,
-0.2675102353,
0.7023678422,
0.3133168519,
-0.6643167734,
-1.1442302465,
-0.1525571197,
-0.2739676237,
-0.3244931102,
0.4564918876,
-0.9464224577,
0.6733920574,
-0.2259448916,
-0.134516567,
0.3153501153,
0.4009304643,
-0.0851509199,
0.4528204799,
-0.0941906944,
0.5945206285,
0.8300714493,
-0.260653913,
0.9421691298,
-0.4820613861,
0.2343189865,
0.8644825816,
-0.0060816626,
0.8816151619,
0.4492556155,
-0.2148691714,
-0.0630346611,
0.8712834716,
0.0131505914,
0.4782180786,
0.238422215,
0.1341369748,
-0.4210425615,
-0.0504351705,
-0.5110313296,
0.4479805827,
0.5852381587,
-0.3286404908,
0.2487580031,
-0.0135733727,
-0.1664323211,
0.1544674486,
-0.1230100691,
0.618132174,
0.4261075258,
-0.3945324421,
0.8609675169,
0.172802031,
0.4695880115,
-0.1907501519,
0.0911509916,
-0.5031486154,
0.3244862854,
-0.2985053957,
-0.8529388905,
0.369487375,
-0.3274742961,
-0.2494523823,
-0.1872105449,
0.3150416315,
-0.2532291412,
-0.2751710117,
0.1807948053,
1.2401089668,
0.4584505558,
-0.2866738141,
-0.7342557311,
-0.2690268159,
-0.178838715,
-0.1162540093,
0.5672093034,
1.1241436005,
-0.0735726804,
0.7472323775,
0.639224112,
0.220473215,
0.0681839734,
-0.0288691521,
0.5819611549,
-0.6849691272,
-0.0601176433,
-0.6302855015,
0.0837670639,
0.1158908904,
-0.6914496422,
0.7882928848,
0.7206380963,
0.9226633906,
-0.189265132,
0.5713276267,
0.5855360031,
0.8011405468,
-0.5463165641,
0.9963029623,
-0.8882240653,
-0.0505518466,
-0.1548715085,
-0.9565812349,
-0.6831794381,
0.3781695366,
0.2787024081,
-0.3097940385,
0.6728962064,
0.5326754451,
-0.1846982986,
-0.5838380456,
0.7219929695,
0.0610448606,
0.1544438452,
0.3927633762,
0.7048523426,
-0.6770161986,
0.2913236916,
-0.0108091757,
0.1659696996,
-0.2987058163,
-0.6186122298,
-0.7856619358,
-0.5068145394,
-0.5083239079,
-0.4379942715,
0.1146728322,
0.7019603848,
0.8201272488,
-0.9267992973,
0.1202783287,
0.3498004675,
-0.1484791785,
-0.3833969235,
-0.111058861,
0.4086248875,
-0.397341162,
-0.6397739649,
0.3954385817,
0.2544059157,
0.1719710827,
0.0310291667,
-0.1960060596,
0.3615718484,
-0.1735552698,
0.7689009905,
0.1199949235,
-0.5272861719,
-0.4390674233,
0.2892083228,
-0.5063387752,
0.2389725745,
0.6249796748,
-0.3219451308,
0.3055061102,
0.1330756992,
0.8859164119,
0.0683378503,
0.1196028665,
0.787812531,
-0.8601690531,
-0.1552625448,
0.065397568,
0.3038753867,
0.4772525728,
-0.0974055827,
0.6781954169,
0.2629944086,
-0.7138956189,
-0.7953314185,
-0.0348227881,
-0.8130041361,
-0.1459272653,
1.0159658194,
-0.1264338493,
-0.0423597209,
-0.3543180823,
-0.0382105634,
0.2603343129,
-0.1480692029,
0.7372242808,
0.5999843478,
-0.3611004651,
0.2103764862,
-0.9191759229,
0.7799375057,
0.6687931418,
-0.5387657881,
-0.0913015679,
0.4897638857,
0.0717013478,
0.1264627576,
0.240765512,
-0.2335318923,
0.1635999084,
-0.2630997002,
-0.0488393977,
0.0664509982,
-0.3335038424,
-0.1684238613,
-0.2757304609,
0.4092868268,
-0.5238751769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18734v1
|
Priority Sampling of Large Language Models for Compilers
| 2024-02-28T22:27:49 | 2024-02-28T22:27:49 |
Dejan Grubisic, Chris Cummins, Volker Seeker, Hugh Leather
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Large language models show great potential in generating and optimizing code.
Widely used sampling methods such as Nucleus Sampling increase the diversity of
generation but often produce repeated samples for low temperatures and
incoherent samples for high temperatures. Furthermore, the temperature
coefficient has to be tuned for each task, limiting its usability. We present
Priority Sampling, a simple and deterministic sampling technique that produces
unique samples ordered by the model's confidence. Each new sample expands the
unexpanded token with the highest probability in the augmented search tree.
Additionally, Priority Sampling supports generation based on regular expression
that provides a controllable and structured exploration process. Priority
Sampling outperforms Nucleus Sampling for any number of samples, boosting the
performance of the original model from 2.87% to 5% improvement over -Oz.
Moreover, it outperforms the autotuner used for the generation of labels for
the training of the original model in just 30 samples.
|
[
-0.3921982348,
-0.3711135983,
0.4893322289,
0.0648990571,
-0.1041287407,
0.1304502934,
-0.3731060028,
-0.2825636566,
-0.020359531,
0.6287401319,
-0.2850955427,
-0.5452882648,
-0.5064796209,
-0.1131379902,
-0.4120108187,
0.6407271028,
0.277741015,
-0.2007327974,
-0.0025924298,
0.1786030382,
-0.1927950829,
-0.880233705,
-0.7354414463,
-0.1017361879,
0.3729364574,
0.6930844188,
0.5786509514,
0.6205419302,
0.3283059895,
0.2937589884,
-0.2015914917,
-0.2919506729,
-0.6368815899,
0.4830268919,
0.0397453979,
-0.4084193408,
-0.3636655807,
0.096423313,
0.7450348139,
0.7166022062,
-0.2699134052,
0.3176100552,
-0.0800247416,
0.6745730042,
-0.8841820359,
0.0430980846,
-0.645929575,
0.0684108511,
-0.5323792696,
-0.3845717311,
-0.6560208797,
-0.3493575752,
-0.2523925602,
-0.1486728936,
0.4524452984,
-0.0143647511,
0.4176741838,
0.3632756174,
-0.2412123829,
0.0678501427,
-0.9283265471,
1.1041306257,
-0.5184744596,
0.1905676574,
0.3616264164,
0.2521091402,
-0.1660346091,
-0.64623034,
-0.3211098015,
-0.3559832871,
0.4156970084,
-0.0855242312,
0.0281750448,
-0.0416115299,
0.5274567604,
0.337202698,
-0.6044771075,
0.1704757959,
-0.1524011195,
-0.1248272881,
0.6784069538,
-0.027529059,
0.2792305052,
-0.2175960243,
-0.1041057184,
-0.6365389228,
-0.6807774305,
0.2918418348,
0.6445545554,
0.3170760572,
0.3939804733,
0.5757455826,
-0.4996930957,
1.2309648991,
-0.0554657653,
0.1834122837,
0.2496075183,
-0.3282444775,
-0.1925160438,
0.04386051,
0.4805060029,
0.137200892,
0.2419413179,
0.0966829658,
-0.1282226443,
-0.0686806738,
0.2679335773,
-0.7386369109,
-0.4810706973,
0.496173352,
-0.2915425301,
-0.3786259592,
0.1453724056,
-0.8396605849,
0.0904504061,
-0.2681047022,
-0.3402174115,
-0.0595632903,
-0.3088404536,
0.2245770097,
-0.0803024694,
-0.0933459178,
0.1111335084,
-0.9521760345,
0.1637404859,
0.5274886489,
0.3220728636,
-0.3566781878,
-0.1500282288,
-0.8089145422,
0.0539983846,
-0.5303316116,
0.979747951,
-0.9149239063,
-0.3098404706,
-0.3530168831,
-0.3397032917,
0.1494625509,
-0.5083536506,
0.3165789843,
-0.7149285674,
-0.2043908387,
-0.1496445537,
-0.295835793,
0.1758596748,
-0.1371203661,
-0.891684413,
1.324105382,
0.3696177304,
-0.5126879215,
0.5190126896,
-0.3552093208,
-0.2205447853,
0.190495342,
-0.0590876676,
-0.3291999698,
0.1642503589,
0.1198961213,
0.2603779435,
-0.365896523,
0.30338341,
-0.2345208079,
-0.162349537,
0.2397810072,
-0.279769361,
0.7642377019,
0.5981513858,
-0.2973951399,
0.2721461654,
-0.6684395075,
0.6861336231,
-0.1356939822,
-0.6007133722,
-0.4123151302,
-0.0208880696,
0.2272186726,
0.4560166597,
0.2747440338,
-0.4862207174,
0.5117121339,
-0.3203146756,
0.3175413013,
0.650064528,
-0.0764354616,
0.5645862818,
-0.2490165085,
0.7973335385,
-0.1439930648,
0.1330057383,
0.2832831144,
-0.592987299,
-0.6296815276,
-0.2123356313,
0.719658792,
0.5027372241,
-0.6141031384,
0.7724319696,
-0.1882673204,
-0.6262061,
-0.3599560261,
0.1200542152,
0.4107955396,
0.0052078627,
0.2060425878,
-0.3919785917,
-0.4637844265,
-0.7599995136,
0.0907618329,
0.0142503893,
-0.1231963038,
0.2190909535,
0.064257957,
0.1627367884,
1.0499219894,
-0.6340765953,
0.5081108809,
-0.5926054716,
0.3299278915,
0.3824794292,
0.7028939128,
0.6335995793,
-1.0663659573,
-0.4726503193,
-0.3768263161,
-0.3147095144,
-0.3732999563,
0.1313210726,
-0.4248058796,
0.3127517998,
0.6279958487,
-0.3803798854,
0.1673824936,
0.785972476,
-0.1116117835,
0.2915225327,
0.0594671108,
0.1890120059,
-1.1138678789,
0.2848652899,
-0.3028399348,
-0.1805930883,
-0.4951850772,
0.5601372123,
-0.1031623259,
-0.2851476669,
-0.5131384134,
0.6109288931,
-0.4878303707,
-0.2195170522,
-0.3431101441,
-0.3506293595,
-0.2139609456,
0.074353233,
0.1055947691,
0.7135944963,
0.5917189717,
-0.6980625391,
0.2431547046,
-0.168589294,
-0.5806086659,
-0.0967012793,
-0.4175131023,
0.2692430615,
-0.0185487252,
0.3193433881,
-1.0135666132,
-0.1107537523,
-0.0635968968,
-0.3373728096,
0.4292666018,
-0.3262778521,
-0.57512784,
-0.6265198588,
-0.0834816247,
0.5338122845,
0.6302915215,
-0.317361623,
0.3461583853,
0.6042256951,
-0.4928777516,
-0.7487217188,
-0.300168246,
-0.0914728791,
0.0747164637,
-0.2006917447,
0.1421885192,
-0.4441284835,
-0.2788966596,
0.0707871765,
-0.0907267556,
-0.0404154286,
0.2967640162,
0.2083066553,
0.0355216637,
0.0923484936,
-0.0673129484,
-0.1867457181,
-0.380438447,
-0.2988744676,
-0.5103421807,
1.2478758097,
0.3014377952,
-0.3593972921,
0.0325835757,
0.6024372578,
0.5018097162,
-0.206632942,
0.2231993675,
0.1547687203,
-0.2515928447,
-0.3079653084,
-0.5981669426,
-0.2702385187,
-0.4310958087,
0.1970520467,
-0.4244065285,
-0.8768473864,
0.3736402094,
0.2720912099,
0.2112370878,
0.5481503606,
0.7494382858,
0.3145516217,
1.2542325258,
0.708424449,
-0.3959700167,
0.5289851427,
-0.1009934694,
0.187117219,
-0.5650582314,
0.2916059196,
-0.8292211294,
-0.3310875297,
-0.6273935437,
-0.601641655,
0.2270752043,
0.0769813061,
0.0283548757,
0.384549737,
-0.8283979893,
0.6039928794,
1.2232943773,
-0.1202268153,
0.2416661084,
0.2700206637,
-0.2328612059,
0.1139101237,
-0.9455996156,
-0.2835738361,
1.2005422115,
-0.181679368,
0.6340674162,
-0.1028814092,
1.0400513411,
0.0152590713,
0.4533959627,
-0.5503290296,
0.7055857778,
-0.2814939022,
-0.7963607907,
-0.4948126078,
-0.6035662293,
-0.9416869283,
-0.0381386094,
0.0876411572,
-0.593121469,
0.3256092668,
0.2190774977,
-0.6368176937,
0.2282388806,
-0.6350547671,
0.6350767612,
0.0506845862,
-0.2533437908,
-0.2424523085,
-0.3559424877,
0.304582566,
-0.1487200707,
-0.0918163881,
-0.1175632402,
0.5032834411,
0.6011077166,
-0.2625962496,
0.5989168882,
-0.0918716118,
-0.0019316562,
0.5476115346,
0.1108334139,
0.3223935962,
0.077285409,
-0.487380147,
0.0460642874,
-0.1551939547,
-0.480184257,
-0.2043736279,
0.7040046453,
-0.5612232089,
-0.6193290353,
-0.6441979408,
-0.6869692206,
-0.0385896079,
0.1543632597,
0.5293966532,
0.3590107858,
0.0865217298,
0.303088516,
0.3000768423,
-0.4046851099,
0.4575585425,
0.4842815697,
-0.1128413007,
-0.0846035928,
0.8561890125,
0.2074614912,
0.3859606683,
0.3565058708,
0.1115624905,
-0.009633882,
-0.6524234414,
-0.2796543539,
-0.1635155082,
-0.5391564965,
-0.2661161423,
-0.7686837316,
-0.4232773185,
-0.5990421176,
-0.2333621383,
-0.459061861,
-0.6517069936,
0.0770739913,
-0.0625700727,
0.3811940849,
0.4809602499,
-0.2464490235,
0.1519761384,
-0.8157957196,
0.4314427972,
0.517565906,
0.1758860648,
-0.1598177999,
-0.1353744715,
0.0105346702,
-0.1804769039,
-0.1338800043,
-0.451701194,
0.6025006175,
-0.1298910379,
0.6967021823,
0.1104714423,
0.2575996518,
0.4183067083,
-0.5083674788,
0.8289418817,
-0.2768461108,
-0.7260509133,
0.5159390569,
-0.2500912547,
0.680527389,
0.8569082618,
0.3454138935,
-0.2921480834,
-0.7597068548,
-0.9006027579,
-1.314656496,
0.5947829485,
0.1528476626,
-0.1596110314,
-0.1881641299,
0.2910663486,
-0.2346523702,
0.2805049121,
-0.4279601872,
-0.0660566241,
0.0922624543,
-0.079180412,
-0.2850653827,
-0.5108755827,
-0.1157649308,
-0.2141333073,
0.5083573461,
-0.0897437483,
0.2234704942,
-0.1601160914,
0.006940743,
-0.3134190738,
0.4353706837,
0.5009478927,
0.5614256859,
-0.478615582,
0.0885253176,
-0.2888744771,
-0.5649710298,
0.1210113838,
0.0795533806,
-0.4518205523,
-0.1188582033,
-0.0484551676,
0.4096187353,
0.0922631547,
-0.6277430654,
0.0856961608,
-0.143072933,
0.1561038494,
-0.3694061935,
0.3914772272,
-0.029594738,
0.039760083,
0.3690643013,
0.0759885982,
0.3717720509,
-0.5341587067,
0.3571766019,
0.3073978424,
0.0214282498,
0.1217391863,
0.5165876746,
-0.0468199514,
-0.0456246622,
0.8682354093,
-0.3979604244,
-0.4387013912,
0.9941475391,
0.4138929248,
0.786157012,
-0.4611898363,
0.0194465313,
0.7031905651,
0.2138723582,
-0.4677762091,
0.6978681087,
-0.0091963494,
-0.6806967854,
-0.5673897266,
-0.8781001568,
-0.5560831428,
0.0858081207,
-0.8385775089,
0.0980859026,
-0.252322942,
-0.3500570357,
-0.201015234,
-0.1620491594,
-0.5662289858,
0.214490369,
0.111838609,
0.8983829021,
-0.8260979056,
1.0083737373,
0.3919498026,
-0.0949501619,
-0.909103334,
0.0868622512,
-0.1399991065,
-0.5219216347,
1.0295072794,
-0.0020625745,
-0.0906826928,
0.3432878852,
-0.5777167082,
-1.3810248375,
0.6539754868,
0.2260741591,
-0.7424445152,
-0.0571748987,
-0.1415155977,
0.3864797354,
-0.1383646727,
0.2490343004,
0.5541349649,
0.5080267787,
0.1312462687,
-0.5586736798,
-0.1083826497,
-0.6141475439,
0.2061655521,
0.266610384,
-0.4303019047,
1.0801948309,
0.0669147819,
-0.1985915601,
0.1931646168,
0.4794180691,
0.5641363263,
-0.2355411202,
0.6762956977,
0.6457968354,
0.7157168984,
-0.1344689578,
1.4634997845,
-0.9222167134,
0.2744537592,
1.1021798849,
-0.5497430563,
1.0007685423,
0.2444456369,
0.0543855391,
0.040341381,
0.7282060981,
-0.0212363675,
0.4757725894,
0.4061073363,
-0.2786486149,
-0.5301730037,
-0.1752472669,
-0.4395396113,
0.4609490633,
0.3719445169,
-0.1630809158,
-0.2259242237,
-0.1089160368,
-0.2674508691,
-0.1324275732,
-0.218602106,
0.5163260102,
-0.0828275755,
-1.1400796175,
0.6592440009,
-0.0271874201,
0.499470979,
-0.4541547894,
-0.0189671461,
-0.0405684449,
0.0362404026,
-0.0229461156,
-0.8096655011,
0.0511781983,
0.0157839581,
-0.3724612594,
-0.6077669859,
0.3370161355,
-0.4247078598,
-0.6920045018,
0.1554668993,
0.2241695225,
0.2011341453,
-0.0233865175,
-0.3543247879,
0.0240432806,
-0.1324514747,
-0.5918654203,
0.3390804231,
0.1401563287,
-0.1281456798,
0.4676097929,
0.9289450049,
0.5503414273,
0.1645286381,
0.2797748446,
0.7773829103,
-0.5382532477,
-0.4673553705,
-0.6103702784,
0.291857779,
-0.2004776746,
-0.270755589,
0.6975420713,
0.6473391056,
0.9689239264,
-0.2285290807,
0.9337493181,
-0.2047669739,
0.5954774618,
-0.8515881896,
0.6086688638,
-0.2860074639,
0.025825223,
-0.2975996733,
-1.2308859825,
-0.3023451567,
0.6474850774,
-0.4433225095,
0.2161667496,
0.7915570736,
0.7105358839,
0.013977929,
-0.4084799886,
0.2722842693,
0.0090801548,
0.2546496689,
0.8556452394,
0.633731544,
-0.0400673263,
0.235590145,
-0.4180855155,
-0.3202415109,
-0.4067490399,
-0.9267807603,
-0.469781369,
-0.5500854254,
-0.2049173117,
-0.3506345749,
-0.0900128186,
1.0894204378,
1.0060789585,
-1.0644580126,
-0.2952733636,
-0.065292418,
-0.0754387155,
-0.3498947918,
-0.2553569376,
0.1349586695,
-0.3918693662,
-1.051646471,
0.5137435198,
0.1451239735,
-0.0833292082,
-0.1608423144,
0.4623196125,
-0.0851876959,
-0.1834146827,
0.3952610493,
0.5397108197,
-0.2809546292,
-0.1603933126,
0.0549668297,
-0.3345784843,
0.1421792209,
1.1326566935,
-0.5620687604,
0.4640967548,
0.8673125505,
0.5751857162,
0.4811760187,
0.1480601281,
0.7467064261,
-0.775379777,
0.3833251297,
0.4256854951,
0.3345237076,
0.1404361129,
-0.4519406259,
0.4474841952,
-0.0282612331,
-0.6622924805,
-0.7706774473,
0.6148635149,
-1.166519165,
-0.4344839156,
1.4387749434,
0.209649086,
-0.2222724557,
-0.1541365236,
-0.0143304905,
0.3487232029,
-0.6233830452,
0.915884316,
0.7701032162,
0.0031877814,
-0.0150768124,
-1.0090037584,
0.4995665848,
0.5067583919,
-0.7376533747,
0.1869592518,
0.4495732784,
0.3512254655,
0.354423672,
0.896429956,
-0.1297049522,
0.3132296503,
-0.2480968237,
0.4654079378,
0.2394823283,
-0.6414887905,
-0.3178345561,
0.5647802949,
0.3655166924,
0.2956228852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01306v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01306v3
|
NeuroPrune: A Neuro-inspired Topological Sparse Training Algorithm for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T22:21:47 | 2024-06-05T16:07:13 |
Amit Dhurandhar, Tejaswini Pedapati, Ronny Luss, Soham Dan, Aurelie Lozano, Payel Das, Georgios Kollias
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based Language Models have become ubiquitous in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) due to their impressive performance on various tasks. However,
expensive training as well as inference remains a significant impediment to
their widespread applicability. While enforcing sparsity at various levels of
the model architecture has found promise in addressing scaling and efficiency
issues, there remains a disconnect between how sparsity affects network
topology. Inspired by brain neuronal networks, we explore sparsity approaches
through the lens of network topology. Specifically, we exploit mechanisms seen
in biological networks, such as preferential attachment and redundant synapse
pruning, and show that principled, model-agnostic sparsity approaches are
performant and efficient across diverse NLP tasks, spanning both classification
(such as natural language inference) and generation (summarization, machine
translation), despite our sole objective not being optimizing performance.
NeuroPrune is competitive with (or sometimes superior to) baselines on
performance and can be up to $10$x faster in terms of training time for a given
level of sparsity, simultaneously exhibiting measurable improvements in
inference time in many cases.
|
[
-0.3272503912,
-0.835536778,
0.068103455,
0.3069193661,
0.0219041631,
-0.3119916916,
-0.3790884912,
-0.2131204903,
0.6937507987,
0.2169965059,
-0.6267440915,
-0.0694015995,
-0.8585320711,
0.2040760517,
-0.6466668844,
1.1977087259,
0.5880441666,
-0.0940285772,
-0.0877300128,
-0.2719853818,
-0.3377895653,
-0.5381348729,
-0.7262353301,
-0.4780137539,
0.7105946541,
0.2602622807,
1.0123256445,
0.5926677585,
0.4096963704,
0.3650421202,
-0.540761888,
0.3043852448,
-0.6669829488,
0.0915484056,
-0.10884431,
-0.1971394867,
-0.34028247,
-0.2982009351,
0.6792257428,
1.0951105356,
-0.3870182633,
-0.2478430122,
0.326738745,
0.7012684941,
-0.337965548,
-0.4159293473,
-0.6487001181,
0.206428349,
-0.089388065,
-0.1611933112,
-0.1234982237,
-0.3013912737,
0.1661377549,
-0.7482397556,
0.5514853597,
0.0494601764,
1.0364972353,
0.4115433395,
-0.1390250325,
-0.023685379,
-0.547878325,
0.4929665625,
-0.6588536501,
0.3993399441,
0.2187319249,
0.1553318352,
-0.4847934842,
-0.7635070086,
-0.4739542603,
-0.1324777901,
-0.2155732661,
-0.2424290627,
-0.5169735551,
0.1608686894,
0.2403396666,
0.3625515103,
-0.9023885727,
0.1220570132,
-0.2597118318,
0.2614286244,
0.3065892458,
-0.0196095705,
0.5633883476,
-0.1692800373,
-0.0453032665,
-0.0737224743,
-0.5482868552,
-0.3660240769,
0.2721253932,
0.2905830145,
-0.056983728,
0.3020516932,
0.0905380398,
0.9243189096,
-0.1764407456,
0.2337423414,
-0.0686600059,
0.1472238302,
-0.2036010623,
-0.1166186556,
0.8064833283,
-0.0333846882,
0.4814184606,
-0.8814963698,
-0.2088654339,
0.0949386656,
0.6086341739,
-0.6161190867,
-0.4916319847,
0.0955373868,
-0.2694486976,
-0.3099912405,
-0.2579345107,
-0.8356551528,
-0.3814913034,
-0.3161046505,
0.4015122354,
-0.6737494469,
-0.5607703328,
0.2964071929,
-0.3570829928,
-0.1218981519,
0.2126832604,
-1.0380754471,
1.0481104851,
1.0882301331,
1.3360989094,
-0.3242591619,
-0.5970364809,
-0.3118833899,
-0.0016447845,
-0.2883469164,
0.7978610396,
-0.4789771736,
-0.0413364395,
-0.4572088718,
-0.0442110263,
-0.3629339933,
-0.5293378234,
0.2768997848,
-0.3798203468,
-0.2299013734,
0.0759069771,
-0.2600407004,
-0.3039723635,
0.2616834044,
-0.8361091018,
1.0405678749,
-0.0090999547,
-0.8772408962,
0.2340312749,
-0.6784822345,
-0.6321085095,
0.0375395305,
0.083810471,
-0.3952818513,
0.420725435,
0.0409167334,
0.3747490048,
-0.2326117456,
0.6699333787,
-0.3853405118,
-0.5813058019,
0.2003315091,
-0.2731997967,
0.6508181095,
-0.0671662539,
-0.3585786819,
0.1274498105,
-0.5868278146,
-0.2831904292,
0.1873369664,
0.3026691973,
-0.529761076,
0.1311690509,
0.2841269672,
0.0667029396,
-0.3730933666,
-0.3819563091,
0.3298203051,
-0.9628949165,
0.8277509809,
0.6889243722,
-0.0472272709,
0.6367025971,
-0.1418413818,
0.4108521342,
-0.2828690112,
0.0350666344,
0.6215948462,
-0.4175771773,
-0.7359938622,
-0.2657532692,
0.3705341816,
0.2528740168,
-0.3445320129,
0.4757578373,
-0.5540217161,
-0.5937452316,
0.0290818699,
-0.0918087438,
0.0152712008,
0.3211610317,
0.3112984598,
-0.4260953069,
-0.3413021564,
-0.8054746985,
-0.4246676266,
0.4748902023,
0.2029392868,
0.3393379152,
0.7063321471,
0.0310416203,
0.7738011479,
-0.4805619419,
-0.1671352088,
-0.5086100698,
0.1162402034,
0.7701470256,
0.6883484125,
0.4933282733,
-0.7073448896,
-0.0050973142,
0.0934186056,
-0.4067810476,
0.0297361072,
-0.0381645486,
-0.151589781,
-0.1941654533,
0.3898566961,
-0.917247057,
0.3775753379,
0.6201360822,
-0.1129914373,
0.3915271759,
-0.1810576469,
-0.3563995957,
-0.9961178303,
0.3744430244,
0.1221857816,
-0.0985386744,
-0.6899800897,
-0.0911071002,
-0.4347269833,
-0.5944743752,
0.1911892295,
0.5837180018,
-0.629550159,
-0.3984338045,
-0.3692317605,
0.305591166,
0.0060648243,
0.7172805071,
0.2238858342,
0.6319381595,
0.5574413538,
-0.6465337276,
-0.0582000986,
0.2544791698,
0.0378245115,
0.3256661892,
-1.150026083,
-0.0231095199,
-0.192249015,
0.2647721171,
-0.8240481615,
-0.0819579512,
0.0686947927,
-0.615357101,
0.436473906,
-0.4138920605,
-0.5198130608,
0.0337210149,
0.1747584939,
0.4650917649,
0.2523632944,
-0.465276897,
0.587084949,
0.4749197662,
-0.0615015142,
-0.6478235722,
-0.7838009596,
0.3778823912,
-0.17487818,
-0.5635812283,
0.313488096,
0.3910428882,
0.0982927084,
-0.016448807,
-0.1531065851,
-0.4724968076,
0.3660097718,
0.3494684696,
-0.1173961386,
-0.2130772024,
0.2323355675,
-0.0171857085,
-0.3537617922,
-0.0050024665,
-0.5999048948,
0.7105380297,
-0.1101419628,
-0.2187622488,
-0.3420566022,
0.3478370905,
0.4786655605,
-0.3166762292,
0.6749759912,
0.3264942169,
-0.5835433006,
-0.6088830233,
-0.4066084623,
-0.7141435146,
-0.4663217366,
0.5975777507,
-0.0494565181,
-0.8227820992,
-0.0569074489,
-0.1915383935,
-0.0281280708,
0.2347273529,
0.2164688259,
0.1627826691,
0.4849802554,
0.8053150177,
-0.1953218579,
0.3068609834,
-0.4949384034,
0.6513639092,
-0.5655426383,
-0.0398268439,
-0.7044962049,
-0.7995700836,
-0.4331556857,
-0.3803202808,
0.604483068,
-0.0591138117,
-0.0872482955,
0.5753265023,
-0.8699285984,
0.3718722761,
0.3477461934,
0.1303860247,
0.0272396896,
0.4879642129,
0.0440881737,
-0.2564010322,
-1.5018556118,
-0.0961752981,
0.532222569,
0.2181769758,
0.4826217592,
0.0033498029,
0.4662125409,
0.0625629425,
0.151062116,
-0.7151304483,
0.459957391,
-0.1658722162,
-0.3111148179,
-0.3246201873,
-0.5820376873,
-1.2073944807,
0.2525444031,
-0.4008020759,
-0.815345943,
0.4650442898,
0.2233283967,
-0.1578313112,
0.5788747072,
-0.3849024773,
0.9982634187,
-0.0235824063,
-0.5216826797,
-0.5543284416,
-0.5341297388,
0.2548509836,
0.3810728788,
-0.0602723174,
0.0791932568,
-0.0578581765,
0.6331836581,
-0.4246033728,
0.9061509371,
0.0968150571,
0.5455027819,
-0.0442900546,
0.5158010721,
0.3710650206,
0.1399527937,
-0.1093761399,
0.518376112,
-0.2734200656,
-0.3564763367,
-0.8001891375,
0.7077769041,
-0.7529215217,
-0.0950910076,
-0.6295831203,
-0.7501544952,
-0.3236796856,
0.1802827865,
0.2963392437,
0.9117205739,
-0.0870432183,
0.242153734,
0.8941375613,
-0.3190086484,
0.3039700091,
0.0464314297,
0.2627028227,
-0.7414047718,
1.1308144331,
0.230339095,
0.0602166168,
0.5028069019,
0.1578276753,
-0.0278869271,
-0.6266271472,
-0.3199786842,
0.4486327469,
-0.1746029854,
-0.2767035961,
-1.0276744366,
-0.3897849917,
-0.2727479041,
-0.2819723189,
-0.4951687455,
-0.7768729329,
-0.075203076,
0.0654428303,
0.6134989858,
0.8591729403,
-0.203083843,
0.5386180878,
-0.4311071932,
0.2717618644,
0.0008793352,
0.5032792687,
0.3162229657,
-0.5893936157,
-0.1387635469,
-0.2589368522,
-0.2667865753,
-0.8967421055,
0.6750727892,
0.4160900414,
0.3330638111,
0.1080980748,
-0.3651210666,
0.6968947649,
-0.5762940049,
0.3544073999,
0.2058337331,
-0.7778295875,
0.2716701627,
-0.2513935268,
-0.0087685334,
0.4249795973,
0.4672886431,
-0.8073746562,
-0.1439346522,
-0.9129499793,
-0.946434617,
0.4426443279,
0.2818638086,
0.1209658906,
-0.0848613158,
0.4423343241,
-0.1178207919,
0.1901289821,
-0.8903231025,
-0.1360433847,
-0.1915083528,
0.0980409905,
0.05825001,
-0.1585477293,
-0.0815660357,
-0.3857427239,
0.6305301189,
-0.2196690887,
0.2201704234,
0.4567329288,
-0.0191368666,
0.2563685477,
0.0265931282,
0.3995749354,
0.5077317953,
0.1329153627,
-0.0882557109,
0.2770571113,
-0.4768996537,
0.0504375286,
0.0342043713,
-0.1729342192,
0.325594753,
0.3102348149,
0.5833589435,
0.4717918336,
-0.356051743,
0.7308853269,
-0.0361374952,
-0.3384719789,
-0.0966444612,
-0.0618369021,
0.1595537513,
0.0259567518,
-0.0636031479,
0.4871900976,
0.4105328023,
0.1300096959,
0.2304385602,
0.5604550242,
-0.4778550565,
-0.3169252574,
0.3683086038,
-0.0303784814,
-0.3985228539,
0.7594919205,
0.025188487,
-0.4068548977,
0.6079233885,
0.5884259343,
1.0841960907,
0.0807723552,
0.1038059965,
0.564326942,
0.606315732,
-0.1847159714,
-0.1651152074,
-0.1492304057,
-0.5965255499,
-0.5117099881,
-0.7350100279,
-0.2818972766,
0.0410426371,
-0.4112674594,
0.1648285985,
-0.7044285536,
-0.2082694024,
-0.2801993787,
-0.3257371783,
-0.0178113189,
0.2365329564,
-0.2070467174,
1.2303549051,
-0.8681372404,
0.5998626947,
0.527154088,
0.0439896286,
-0.7471061945,
-0.1442793906,
-0.1948255599,
-0.3408027589,
0.5689677596,
0.1999543905,
-0.2249997854,
-0.0472677909,
-0.526050508,
-1.0080444813,
0.593085587,
0.5073387027,
-0.5099035501,
-0.1949306875,
-0.2201505601,
0.5273509622,
0.1632163078,
0.2240545005,
0.3637483716,
0.1376513541,
-0.1887968779,
-0.6881366372,
-0.1240883917,
-0.7196961641,
0.0592316613,
0.5001762509,
-0.4283646047,
0.6857973337,
0.033654552,
-0.1554805189,
-0.0011696925,
0.7698858976,
0.2520622313,
-0.0082500242,
0.459880501,
0.8658602834,
0.5936178565,
-0.2111323625,
1.0823743343,
-0.6186723709,
0.1702808887,
0.9085419178,
0.0358923823,
0.5638403296,
0.5897541642,
0.1278890669,
0.4500693083,
0.2518294752,
-0.0937489644,
0.1762394756,
0.4616295099,
0.1343486309,
-0.1829555184,
-0.2054232508,
-0.3105730116,
0.2953341603,
0.4222045541,
-0.0053773536,
-0.4016664028,
-0.4124835432,
0.0657683015,
0.3682900965,
0.0144162904,
0.6702753305,
0.3015550673,
-0.686727345,
0.6976228952,
-0.0909911022,
0.652466774,
-0.8280300498,
-0.1784009635,
-0.2525048554,
0.1418161839,
-0.3578384221,
-0.2325868309,
0.6941953897,
-0.2776019275,
-0.0763326734,
-0.1546548903,
0.7133194208,
-0.0533211157,
-0.3268724978,
0.2251901627,
0.2613955438,
0.1528795809,
-0.197686106,
-0.7438930869,
-0.0830826163,
-0.5471892953,
-0.197386995,
0.3150134087,
0.6109557152,
0.13430053,
0.8276478052,
0.5803031325,
0.5242145658,
-0.09988112,
-0.1294794232,
1.0864486694,
-0.4397619367,
-0.5198017955,
-0.7451665401,
0.1406038702,
-0.3907365501,
-0.7408682108,
0.5560474992,
0.5628547668,
0.3056895733,
0.1878277212,
0.3454729617,
-0.0481807142,
0.288610518,
-0.3390673697,
0.8139587045,
-0.6655349731,
-0.027006831,
-0.5043901205,
-0.8105196357,
-0.4686748683,
0.8571591973,
-0.4516028762,
0.077240631,
0.7753827572,
1.2163094282,
-0.4751197398,
0.2264346778,
0.0969979614,
0.211505264,
-0.1182870865,
0.7029467821,
0.5376679301,
-0.3740922511,
0.2748654783,
-0.3321175873,
-0.1784369797,
0.0361676142,
-0.9135465026,
-0.8225082755,
-0.3697778285,
-0.0751288235,
-0.4427707195,
0.4346007109,
0.8351228237,
1.0793992281,
-0.5688492656,
-0.5995010734,
-0.687905848,
0.2282737046,
-0.4742421508,
-0.2281349748,
0.2735283971,
-0.4574648142,
-0.3725045621,
0.4637351632,
0.5330736637,
-0.2603066266,
-0.0849524885,
0.1302603334,
-0.2715601325,
-0.1777415127,
0.2801343203,
0.3763633966,
-0.3520879745,
0.3549902439,
0.0532669723,
-0.0756158978,
0.080619812,
1.0662065744,
-0.5645770431,
-0.1919217408,
0.5412508845,
0.9515505433,
0.311689198,
-0.2199956626,
0.925773561,
-0.6306716204,
0.5509051681,
0.5967561007,
0.3492004871,
0.3807962239,
-0.3771912456,
0.5678551197,
0.5799726844,
-0.6977615356,
-1.0311720371,
0.0503205881,
-0.7989899516,
-0.4595656693,
1.000983119,
0.2872434855,
-0.6524288654,
-0.0733659193,
0.0996837616,
0.0043673823,
-0.0857346207,
0.5944572091,
0.1974730641,
0.0456447527,
-0.120889686,
-0.6345122457,
0.6146966815,
0.9190655947,
-0.5385987163,
0.1356968135,
0.3214783072,
0.3039681613,
0.0305986423,
0.3324945271,
0.0323913768,
0.4616764784,
0.123803921,
0.1965663284,
-0.0094317496,
-0.7213208675,
-0.5507986546,
0.3259903491,
-0.0463973992,
0.4110779166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18700v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18700v2
|
Learning to Compress Prompt in Natural Language Formats
| 2024-02-28T20:41:21 | 2024-04-02T02:38:31 |
Yu-Neng Chuang, Tianwei Xing, Chia-Yuan Chang, Zirui Liu, Xun Chen, Xia Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are great at processing multiple natural
language processing tasks, but their abilities are constrained by inferior
performance with long context, slow inference speed, and the high cost of
computing the results. Deploying LLMs with precise and informative context
helps users process large-scale datasets more effectively and cost-efficiently.
Existing works rely on compressing long prompt contexts into soft prompts.
However, soft prompt compression encounters limitations in transferability
across different LLMs, especially API-based LLMs. To this end, this work aims
to compress lengthy prompts in the form of natural language with LLM
transferability. This poses two challenges: (i) Natural Language (NL) prompts
are incompatible with back-propagation, and (ii) NL prompts lack flexibility in
imposing length constraints. In this work, we propose a Natural Language Prompt
Encapsulation (Nano-Capsulator) framework compressing original prompts into NL
formatted Capsule Prompt while maintaining the prompt utility and
transferability. Specifically, to tackle the first challenge, the
Nano-Capsulator is optimized by a reward function that interacts with the
proposed semantics preserving loss. To address the second question, the
Nano-Capsulator is optimized by a reward function featuring length constraints.
Experimental results demonstrate that the Capsule Prompt can reduce 81.4% of
the original length, decrease inference latency up to 4.5x, and save 80.1% of
budget overheads while providing transferability across diverse LLMs and
different datasets.
|
[
-0.3320232332,
-0.7741658688,
0.6615116,
0.4075297117,
-0.3377073407,
-0.0311650559,
-0.7390201688,
-0.282176882,
0.1798085719,
0.4555369318,
-0.8199123144,
-0.393381834,
-0.5315113068,
0.6857218146,
0.2492683828,
0.7902373075,
-0.0143600665,
-0.5536541343,
-0.4121133089,
0.0738911107,
-1.0183823109,
-0.4201224446,
-0.8008149862,
-0.0672021508,
0.3968811929,
0.4972905517,
0.4488207102,
0.5821297169,
0.0866826549,
0.3103556335,
-0.2357626557,
0.2796261013,
-0.2328825444,
0.3144682348,
-0.0653276667,
-0.4490070045,
-0.0360565931,
-0.1346766949,
0.4993084371,
0.7048898935,
-0.1280977726,
-0.0091440389,
0.2724838853,
0.5878782868,
-0.5313635468,
0.4953893125,
-0.3950200081,
0.167868346,
0.0729123801,
-0.2680318952,
-0.5885618925,
-0.6174167395,
0.171624139,
-0.8795800805,
-0.0100641092,
0.5099419355,
0.5737118721,
0.3966225088,
-0.292411238,
-0.4061328173,
-0.3681699336,
0.9500023723,
-0.6455974579,
0.0586010553,
0.1997011453,
0.5361892581,
-0.1989514232,
-0.4771832228,
-0.6604195237,
-0.2482806146,
-0.2123666555,
-0.3463002741,
-0.2157565504,
0.2402988374,
0.25477314,
0.2713515162,
-0.7835482359,
0.3173010647,
-0.1144127473,
-0.4411030114,
0.2210302949,
0.2288447022,
0.4659786224,
-0.4240494072,
-0.3740826547,
-0.1336535364,
-0.608643353,
0.251715064,
0.1915751249,
0.7800207734,
-0.2359727621,
0.3241184056,
-0.1420624703,
0.7435383201,
0.0192721132,
-0.1806025058,
0.2143175602,
-0.2914928794,
-0.2398344129,
0.2995533049,
0.8293811083,
0.3886375427,
0.3441424668,
-0.3280294836,
-0.0420698784,
-0.1196986064,
0.034933608,
-0.9426079988,
0.2122062743,
0.2712492347,
-0.4501778483,
-0.0533420555,
-0.1275164634,
-0.8051494956,
-0.4317728281,
-0.5586892366,
0.3417002559,
-0.3343710899,
0.3464725912,
0.5750118494,
-0.1458726823,
-0.2339081317,
0.3012201488,
-1.1235049963,
0.5151495934,
0.7168723941,
1.1200033426,
-0.2414382398,
-0.0210946798,
-0.7948052287,
0.1707054228,
0.2031870186,
0.7386764288,
-0.3338279426,
-0.3842732012,
0.217127502,
0.2180580497,
0.0229506604,
-0.4768482447,
0.8061733842,
-0.1028725579,
0.2350040078,
-0.2752494514,
-0.6376243234,
0.0199123789,
0.4501327872,
-0.776643157,
0.6036197543,
0.0272106323,
-0.4941492677,
0.0824273676,
-0.6149196029,
-0.5503864288,
-0.0063084853,
0.0404834561,
-0.2787770033,
-0.0146538839,
0.6532326937,
0.6035990119,
-0.5434195399,
0.2492038459,
-0.0676090568,
-0.6032133102,
0.363288343,
-0.4977230132,
0.6128076315,
0.0648378953,
-0.1227179766,
0.1150731817,
-0.6098689437,
-0.4346598983,
-0.0725573823,
-0.4448515773,
-0.1988261491,
-0.5932677984,
-0.0774143264,
-0.0399753526,
0.2963747084,
-0.8769529462,
0.6137600541,
-0.4538773298,
0.6830611825,
0.7438026667,
0.1061472595,
0.817563653,
-0.3438858688,
0.7040762305,
-0.2197375447,
0.2460734695,
-0.4259637892,
-0.300437063,
-0.4323473275,
-0.6566777229,
0.1102620512,
0.7077214122,
-0.8180674314,
0.7209439874,
-0.3838545978,
-0.223941043,
-0.4816387594,
0.0196121316,
0.1001282707,
0.7839155197,
0.5726538897,
0.338457495,
-0.4569301605,
-0.8012762666,
-0.1700441539,
0.1133231521,
-0.1054555103,
0.4449706972,
0.2036131918,
-0.0092019513,
0.9776831269,
-0.605279088,
-0.3451067209,
-0.4191199243,
0.4342022836,
0.8268334866,
0.5654517412,
0.2061996162,
-0.509878993,
-0.2366727144,
-0.4099868536,
-0.4612495303,
-0.4768418074,
-0.4568930864,
0.1244707778,
0.0553588271,
0.5508046746,
-1.1126533747,
0.3369462788,
0.3403737247,
-0.449940294,
0.7360325456,
-0.4178614616,
0.2341036946,
-0.9333409667,
0.0049199341,
-0.122545965,
-0.2652513385,
-0.3861059546,
-0.2932196558,
0.1645558625,
-0.2769621611,
-0.6119679213,
0.9082061052,
-0.4939816594,
0.258084625,
-0.3386035562,
0.006372558,
0.4240520895,
0.5539183021,
-0.027741259,
0.7601618767,
0.5559618473,
-0.9138866067,
0.3537489176,
0.5775057077,
-0.1590189636,
0.7826775908,
-0.7912665009,
0.0473012514,
-0.2585462928,
0.7122381926,
-0.6465432048,
0.0564986244,
0.499233216,
-0.3856823146,
0.3311465085,
-0.2405413389,
-0.7631992698,
-0.2661337852,
-0.5389391184,
0.4362795651,
0.6044771075,
-0.6905386448,
0.4609351158,
-0.1978173405,
-0.415753454,
-0.5014430881,
-1.0472980738,
0.277985245,
-0.3806143403,
-0.4731420875,
0.5884273648,
-0.3946140707,
0.1844270676,
-0.095411703,
0.1978044957,
0.2922120988,
0.0621828698,
0.4147762358,
0.2541665435,
-0.0959771499,
0.4486905634,
0.3208294213,
-0.3054567873,
-0.0350357629,
-0.3190312088,
0.5749537349,
0.0762221962,
-0.0877190679,
-0.6623278856,
0.6116498113,
0.3417372108,
0.0802368522,
0.9988308549,
0.3217764795,
-0.4300585091,
-0.39058128,
-0.3215918541,
-0.259842068,
-0.5168768167,
-0.0850311518,
-0.2287081033,
-1.1951881647,
0.4608931243,
0.0270701516,
-0.0834096298,
0.0558773875,
0.3193685114,
0.2475792021,
0.5831005573,
0.4821959138,
-0.0014839803,
0.29539451,
-0.0210341178,
0.2186309844,
-0.8659123182,
-0.2607916594,
-0.6658445597,
-0.3924332261,
-0.2292319238,
-0.5085536838,
0.1878126711,
0.0375140682,
-0.3703612387,
0.3870483637,
-0.6946178079,
0.5138288736,
0.4671640396,
-0.002689393,
0.1009053737,
-0.1164447516,
0.050148502,
-0.1407208741,
-0.6123457551,
-0.441029042,
0.5390776396,
0.3884918094,
0.6843539476,
0.2079971582,
0.6603794694,
0.263245672,
0.031266477,
-0.875251472,
0.5945624709,
-0.080913417,
0.0272921026,
-0.3583446443,
-0.5481285453,
-1.1238596439,
-0.1972245425,
-0.2447760254,
-0.9011371136,
0.1678295434,
0.0613454506,
-0.6862307787,
0.0930942819,
-0.5542051792,
0.7471758723,
0.0631213635,
-0.2216972411,
0.2251593471,
-0.6289896369,
0.0825799108,
0.3061049581,
0.3766792119,
-0.246439606,
-0.3058909774,
0.6132224798,
-0.5376313925,
0.9586178064,
-0.2182964683,
0.0046046111,
0.1465109736,
0.1240534261,
0.6211194992,
0.3233499527,
-0.0432756506,
-0.119406715,
-0.348336339,
-0.2833421528,
-1.0405827761,
0.741165936,
-0.297686398,
-0.4571552873,
-0.3574653864,
-0.7149782181,
-0.1610971838,
0.0388597958,
0.2961021066,
0.680409193,
0.1468535364,
-0.0736720487,
0.7944779992,
-0.6689920425,
0.7331314087,
0.1723769158,
0.0604701936,
-0.5560295582,
0.7265864611,
-0.0746106207,
0.0235750116,
0.5471417904,
0.5641860962,
-0.5057898164,
-0.4684638977,
-0.5091384649,
0.2110218704,
-0.6859295964,
-0.5906552076,
-0.5540763736,
0.1427167952,
-0.6543185711,
-0.6165689826,
-0.013681327,
-0.468945086,
-0.7658369541,
-0.096923776,
0.65280056,
0.3278078437,
-0.1316676736,
0.4585052133,
-0.996812284,
0.3724373579,
0.2938336134,
0.2641671896,
-0.1054764986,
-0.5729475021,
-0.0326327533,
-0.3441795707,
0.2463106364,
-0.8019458055,
0.6595959663,
0.1689602882,
0.3479689658,
0.1531788707,
0.451073736,
0.5834641457,
-0.4404747486,
0.9553917646,
0.3102487326,
-1.0380319357,
0.4624322653,
-0.1197700649,
0.6831473708,
0.8170345426,
0.1543813348,
-0.6868884563,
-0.1725490838,
-0.2412834466,
-1.0662022829,
0.5059800744,
0.0079987282,
0.2922121584,
-0.3785634339,
0.4711590111,
0.5601475835,
0.2148490548,
-0.5301718712,
-0.1090936363,
0.0936317593,
-0.5200710297,
0.0713983476,
-0.2515437007,
0.1835991442,
-0.0206369478,
0.3338329494,
-0.3509771824,
0.3567163646,
0.4014489651,
-0.3474170268,
0.4342698455,
0.5496452451,
0.4783478677,
0.01947302,
-0.2372386307,
0.4580588341,
0.0491811782,
-0.2018935382,
0.2530396879,
0.2667581439,
-0.0503898971,
0.0314812809,
0.2953163385,
0.9723897576,
0.528753221,
-0.8632477522,
0.6159642339,
-0.2837051153,
0.0837840363,
-0.0967155099,
-0.2464451194,
-0.0210334212,
0.1827719808,
0.2252385467,
-0.13036111,
0.4413301349,
-0.4191088378,
-0.0212870706,
0.1941672266,
-0.1591664255,
-0.0865414441,
0.4258265495,
0.3882524371,
-0.4319741726,
0.635248065,
-0.378567636,
-0.5209860206,
0.4533204138,
0.683378458,
0.862511456,
0.174325332,
0.2082377225,
0.4546228945,
0.1952216625,
-0.2224463373,
0.0741173699,
-0.4764069915,
-0.3508626819,
-0.6492613554,
-0.5433890224,
-0.3903637826,
-0.2455139607,
-0.6155537963,
0.230267331,
-0.4098606408,
-0.0933297947,
-0.4032739401,
-0.0234068111,
-0.7482722402,
-0.1033156142,
0.3711788356,
1.235211134,
-0.785517931,
0.2823458016,
0.2486584634,
-0.1771066934,
-0.6357341409,
-0.3468718231,
-0.1037286371,
-0.4535856843,
0.5820680857,
0.7278236151,
0.0275734365,
-0.1607343256,
-0.4561167955,
-0.6245937943,
1.0232902765,
0.6965147853,
-0.6365562081,
-0.0306370892,
0.368026346,
0.1879816204,
-0.3225139976,
0.2161583602,
0.5424226522,
0.7070724964,
0.0345453359,
-0.9741489887,
0.6047870517,
0.0068755536,
-0.0173658598,
0.1149679646,
-0.3418570459,
0.6744151115,
-0.1708009988,
-0.3704369068,
0.2991748452,
0.6616503,
0.5126036406,
0.329269141,
0.4448829889,
0.4188303649,
0.9537419081,
0.04853471,
1.1615867615,
0.0032123125,
0.1239164025,
0.9064894319,
-0.0303165726,
0.6055124998,
0.7929441333,
0.1899181157,
0.5478991866,
0.551946044,
0.1346351057,
0.441026181,
0.6389631033,
-0.2885655463,
-0.0218840521,
-0.506481111,
0.0100170188,
-0.1029236913,
0.211263448,
-0.0827578232,
-0.0551746897,
0.483297497,
0.2816166878,
0.3085914552,
-0.3282172084,
0.4842047095,
0.1346923411,
-0.6948928237,
0.5022338033,
-0.1620237082,
1.133409977,
-0.4536082149,
-0.2186508924,
-0.2366673648,
-0.23346591,
0.0059912396,
-0.7589185238,
0.2525439262,
-0.0694649145,
-0.1601068527,
-0.6017473936,
0.6929439306,
-0.3989373446,
-0.2022827566,
-0.092670992,
0.2209896594,
0.1062571257,
-0.2014617473,
-0.4852818847,
0.3131487966,
-0.376676321,
-0.398581028,
0.1620887667,
0.5893948078,
0.2427440882,
0.7379690409,
0.7079689503,
0.2219507247,
-0.1515686661,
0.0179677214,
0.7725499272,
-0.8820496798,
-0.7670016885,
-0.9089607,
0.499887228,
-0.156040296,
-0.3542431593,
0.5178905129,
0.3252431154,
-0.0039959215,
-0.1275793016,
0.5851872563,
0.0973963439,
0.2813902199,
-0.916272521,
0.4124107063,
-0.1596386433,
0.3322574198,
0.1534193605,
-0.7978242636,
-0.5799536109,
0.3093544245,
-0.0204013232,
-0.3557866216,
0.6146285534,
0.5380932689,
0.2232453376,
-0.0884299427,
0.1040491909,
-0.0940896571,
0.3819754124,
0.9415787458,
0.5003566742,
-0.0369990878,
0.5536860824,
-0.2471411079,
-0.158777982,
-0.3367978036,
-1.2816951275,
-0.9174790382,
-0.3468578756,
-0.4921513498,
-0.1735312343,
-0.0395090654,
1.2240014076,
0.7753109336,
-0.5322957635,
0.1391538233,
-0.2103260458,
0.2082032412,
-0.1062597856,
-0.2818821967,
0.5069846511,
-0.4282671511,
-0.7160941958,
0.6123808622,
0.3785179257,
0.0923169702,
-0.1721772403,
-0.0821453407,
0.1248124093,
0.3095178902,
0.5248390436,
0.5015257001,
-0.5120930076,
-0.4859353006,
0.0705369711,
-0.0139528271,
0.0180233512,
0.8900691867,
-1.2575725317,
0.2702589333,
0.5227695107,
0.8076679707,
0.1395236254,
-0.1610510945,
0.6319028139,
-0.9874404669,
0.2747305036,
0.3133792877,
0.4476007223,
0.6454446316,
-0.6806125045,
0.1726689935,
-0.0012767341,
-0.6060718894,
-0.9124522805,
0.1560477316,
-1.4039235115,
-0.3916490674,
1.2649468184,
-0.1372909844,
-0.4490031898,
-0.1025038585,
-0.5351939797,
0.3676832318,
-0.7478705049,
0.5535405278,
0.4180270731,
-0.1557736099,
-0.3121034205,
-0.2719339728,
0.5108144283,
0.274271816,
-0.9617325664,
0.3017290235,
0.2708610594,
0.0692827851,
0.1640170962,
0.1722884774,
0.1778920591,
0.2107231319,
-0.170648247,
0.1029809117,
-0.5316514969,
-0.0635798052,
-0.7748884559,
0.2852686346,
-0.266681999,
-0.2859943509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18695v1
|
Grounding Language Models for Visual Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-28T20:22:17 | 2024-02-28T20:22:17 |
Zilin Xiao, Ming Gong, Paola Cascante-Bonilla, Xingyao Zhang, Jie Wu, Vicente Ordonez
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We introduce AutoVER, an Autoregressive model for Visual Entity Recognition.
Our model extends an autoregressive Multi-modal Large Language Model by
employing retrieval augmented constrained generation. It mitigates low
performance on out-of-domain entities while excelling in queries that require
visually-situated reasoning. Our method learns to distinguish similar entities
within a vast label space by contrastively training on hard negative pairs in
parallel with a sequence-to-sequence objective without an external retriever.
During inference, a list of retrieved candidate answers explicitly guides
language generation by removing invalid decoding paths. The proposed method
achieves significant improvements across different dataset splits in the
recently proposed Oven-Wiki benchmark. Accuracy on the Entity seen split rises
from 32.7% to 61.5%. It also demonstrates superior performance on the unseen
and query splits by a substantial double-digit margin.
|
[
-0.6239246726,
-0.7880685329,
0.3251205683,
-0.0758523121,
-0.2368642539,
-0.1003772169,
-0.2277784646,
-0.6361967921,
0.1099162921,
0.6031235456,
-0.226890102,
-0.4120658934,
-0.5640743971,
0.1491887122,
-0.3719362915,
0.2887938619,
-0.1684024036,
-0.1704713702,
-0.1559206694,
-0.3168343008,
-0.5622820854,
-0.3189122975,
-0.4506567121,
-0.0579330176,
0.0805291981,
0.4562823474,
0.6741328239,
0.9988839626,
0.421081394,
0.4157468677,
0.4078615308,
0.3409895301,
-0.2642837763,
0.4522103369,
-0.4825452566,
-0.2282319069,
-0.0037490458,
0.122456409,
0.7147960663,
0.6562359333,
-0.0787713975,
-0.0427273549,
-0.2145182937,
0.6773120165,
-0.9695495963,
0.3952777982,
-0.9596749544,
0.001433055,
-0.0944636017,
-0.1340058744,
-0.5531110168,
0.0519471653,
0.0325074792,
-0.573320508,
0.5045279264,
0.3519259393,
1.2127593756,
0.5794245005,
-0.6116395593,
-0.0513425544,
-0.6145672798,
0.5101135373,
-0.200225085,
1.0061123371,
0.4725708663,
0.330626756,
-0.144793421,
-0.667717576,
-0.7069934607,
-0.326502353,
-0.0443767346,
-0.0573219918,
-0.151395753,
-0.0850464031,
0.5017899275,
0.4868173301,
-0.6078343987,
-0.1690398306,
-0.0372334942,
-0.0281942617,
0.528919816,
0.0123696066,
0.4657667875,
-0.3945404291,
-0.3145695031,
-0.3451814055,
-0.6318618059,
-0.0959402695,
0.0022073968,
-0.0537431166,
0.2826716602,
0.68042624,
-0.2426046282,
0.9152746797,
0.3861663043,
0.0121297827,
0.2487644702,
0.0402190164,
-0.4463537633,
-0.2475512475,
0.7303636074,
0.3534517884,
0.1807632893,
-0.1368593276,
-0.3617484272,
0.2000827044,
0.1546196491,
-0.760610342,
-0.7835054398,
-0.3267335594,
-0.4232113957,
0.0867139697,
-0.016846763,
-0.5183383226,
-0.2859120071,
-0.4093682468,
0.2941564918,
-0.5814048648,
-0.3648669422,
-0.1961165667,
-0.0885609463,
0.3300982714,
0.587911129,
-0.7975685,
0.3383845985,
0.1467558891,
0.4541914165,
0.0486657992,
-0.2497796118,
-0.5964696407,
0.415590167,
-0.5235741735,
0.7958940268,
-0.5005752444,
-0.2744076848,
-0.3683614135,
0.2682985663,
-0.1401986629,
-0.5798404813,
0.0574373528,
-0.8236418962,
0.1114323065,
-0.2467583418,
-0.6816803217,
-0.2657139003,
0.1448046118,
-0.9875856638,
0.866358459,
0.1232156083,
-0.6954759359,
0.9260135293,
-0.0851089284,
-0.4855434299,
0.3084151447,
-0.6175063252,
-0.3555063009,
0.1097073928,
0.3820792139,
0.3047698438,
-0.4023136795,
0.3347731233,
-0.2964846492,
0.1483302861,
-0.0836143717,
-0.5724716187,
0.4124137461,
0.4396176636,
-0.6228705049,
-0.3235282004,
-1.1705015898,
0.061171893,
0.2936237454,
-0.302239418,
-0.7226350904,
0.1775729656,
0.0242956001,
0.310082078,
0.0227076542,
-0.3900013566,
0.2348491848,
-0.3756897748,
0.2223092467,
0.3547159433,
0.1276811808,
0.5700600743,
0.3936076462,
0.2927801013,
0.1158988625,
-0.0651072785,
-0.3174473345,
-0.2689648867,
-1.0366003513,
-0.4028260708,
0.1886518002,
0.4504741728,
-1.1237280369,
0.395588845,
-0.0164813083,
-0.1437018663,
-0.2956591249,
0.2244309932,
0.4935134053,
0.71225214,
0.5357123017,
-0.526245296,
-0.4247841239,
-0.9951550364,
-0.1036382169,
-0.2992239892,
0.3651135564,
0.5994643569,
0.4096886814,
-0.2905068398,
0.8237817883,
-0.5198476315,
-0.1011003554,
0.2085111141,
0.2813615501,
-0.0669058263,
0.6850938797,
0.605006218,
-1.183760047,
-0.7516633868,
-0.1248171329,
-1.0158895254,
-0.0732674152,
0.0865077674,
-0.200847432,
0.3410311639,
0.6466475725,
-0.7503004074,
0.6583044529,
0.1243279278,
-0.4806267917,
-0.0319212973,
-0.1159574017,
0.3551617861,
-0.8998767138,
-0.0941348076,
0.2066453099,
-0.5482079983,
-0.2209533304,
0.1673308462,
0.3542644978,
-0.1807404906,
-0.0594825596,
0.6080526114,
-1.2470047474,
-0.2111950815,
-0.4063610435,
-0.0697713494,
0.2720358074,
0.1183900163,
0.3470798135,
0.8601072431,
0.6573648453,
-0.7157084942,
0.5159953833,
0.2927692235,
-0.3069060445,
0.6902155876,
-0.4548998773,
-0.0540366992,
-0.2805791199,
0.1849276125,
-1.1190234423,
-0.4300053716,
0.1619336456,
-0.3998584747,
0.7353806496,
-0.4520978332,
-0.5840044022,
-0.3832522333,
0.3945623338,
0.6413537264,
0.4036220014,
-0.7703632116,
0.8036103845,
0.5413842797,
0.2327358723,
-0.5318152308,
-0.5936260223,
0.3020724654,
-0.0348931029,
-0.6031863093,
0.2162741572,
0.1512026638,
-0.2619449794,
0.0990149379,
-0.0525133461,
-0.1323847473,
-0.0191246308,
0.3002549112,
0.2067985684,
-0.2526703179,
0.2861834466,
-0.2417585105,
-0.0792710707,
-0.019000221,
-0.5308152437,
0.25014171,
-0.1606103629,
-0.3915349245,
-0.2762528956,
0.4099702835,
0.4282022119,
-0.5576902628,
0.6233537197,
0.3539334536,
-0.5957971215,
-0.2174503505,
-1.0137200356,
0.1669526547,
-0.4897189736,
0.0472584777,
-0.7947863936,
-0.4807299972,
0.3580428958,
0.0285630841,
-0.3369914591,
0.5697764754,
0.3744085133,
0.1008248627,
1.1273978949,
0.6377817392,
0.1162599325,
0.5956614614,
-0.3100619018,
-0.0108506689,
-0.5934249163,
-0.189074263,
-0.1909923404,
0.1099441797,
-0.5118503571,
-0.5054402351,
0.1321130097,
0.4240916669,
-0.0342910811,
0.595277369,
-0.5853763819,
0.5742132068,
0.5446360707,
0.1075351685,
0.1796095818,
0.0289555881,
-0.3553456664,
-0.1266493797,
-0.4990583956,
-0.2513640225,
0.7575346231,
0.1480630487,
0.9702015519,
0.1109109297,
0.7076890469,
0.2743571103,
0.2947827876,
-0.5137084126,
0.5291820168,
-0.0370058604,
-0.5772958994,
-0.2899723053,
-0.5420593619,
-0.7177380323,
0.3872033954,
-0.0685983375,
-0.4951507151,
0.4727077186,
0.3787097335,
0.1258567572,
0.154451564,
-0.821136415,
0.8402709365,
-0.2651079893,
-0.5964682698,
0.159677729,
-0.5716990829,
0.2024625242,
0.2412299067,
-0.0007811692,
-0.0299092345,
0.1702734232,
0.2467916161,
-0.4684228897,
0.6403392553,
-0.4081381261,
-0.1410537362,
0.4216663837,
0.3846526742,
0.7173933387,
0.2286235243,
0.3088126183,
-0.2039516568,
-0.4283100069,
-0.3094777763,
-0.6057699919,
0.8449723125,
-0.7181989551,
-0.7134280205,
-0.4038881361,
-0.257950902,
-0.1381245553,
0.4249583781,
0.4818881452,
0.3740094304,
-0.230257079,
0.024472205,
0.9342442751,
-0.0748455524,
0.373677671,
0.6862530708,
-0.1121513024,
-0.7307616472,
0.8121500611,
0.2585958838,
0.0232361928,
0.4957339168,
-0.3402398825,
-0.341257602,
-0.2989225388,
-0.8177255988,
0.2119463533,
-1.0870062113,
-0.2700521946,
-0.9559442997,
-0.019769378,
-0.5867169499,
0.0077856248,
-0.4482494891,
-0.3900771141,
-0.3201364577,
-0.0549017452,
0.2567764223,
0.6454686522,
-0.1917080283,
-0.0961618572,
-0.5197805166,
0.6406760216,
0.5084208846,
0.3170973957,
-0.1128973588,
-0.3746257126,
-0.1573909521,
-0.3452226818,
0.0657728687,
-1.0085844994,
0.5544092059,
0.4245022833,
0.6987670064,
0.3710280359,
-0.1151975021,
0.783377707,
-0.8850501776,
0.4679416716,
0.2606216073,
-0.9351991415,
0.8547160029,
-0.1268958449,
0.1797489971,
0.5222889185,
0.319041431,
-0.1533742249,
-0.3359742165,
-0.7122480273,
-1.0465636253,
0.3308234513,
0.078992717,
-0.1861058325,
-0.4984008372,
0.4343645573,
-0.0660779327,
0.2798659503,
-0.7767099738,
-0.2789716423,
-0.4581212401,
-0.0077771163,
-0.0888662115,
-0.1641748995,
-0.0281705167,
-0.3594574928,
0.6265025735,
-0.1682670265,
0.194530502,
0.3704298735,
-0.7918435335,
-0.391017586,
-0.0577151142,
0.2347413749,
0.5132098198,
-0.0096678166,
0.4377931058,
-0.0260487385,
-0.2400854975,
0.3544024527,
0.3420220315,
-0.2186466604,
0.2395302206,
0.2358391732,
0.8667402267,
-0.0775570944,
-0.2603571713,
0.6487062573,
-0.1720373929,
0.0360286236,
-0.5588563681,
0.1707122922,
-0.3462428749,
0.4130751193,
0.4054478407,
0.0627010614,
0.4452949464,
-0.2956302762,
0.4993162751,
0.5200309753,
-0.2837045491,
-0.2239942551,
0.982506156,
0.1076697409,
0.0382904001,
0.6703050733,
-0.3033003211,
-0.4170691967,
0.6549804807,
0.5088057518,
0.9604462981,
-0.2932271957,
-0.0201445688,
0.4257186651,
0.2975873947,
-0.0543211624,
0.2925822437,
-0.3808203936,
-0.7621360421,
-0.1051007211,
-0.5083822012,
-0.1033819541,
-0.0251867659,
-0.7086120844,
0.2400732338,
-0.5031426549,
-0.3076963425,
0.1537730694,
-0.2306793928,
-1.0088194609,
0.7296852469,
0.5019251108,
0.752366066,
-0.8442237377,
0.7970965505,
0.8873012066,
-0.7581233978,
-0.7331892252,
-0.1570609957,
-0.1747979075,
-0.7367675304,
1.1789784431,
0.2036901712,
-0.245500356,
0.1172767431,
-0.6966819763,
-1.2809538841,
0.9401879311,
0.134496212,
-0.5838652253,
-0.1680345237,
-0.3240806758,
0.4444734752,
-0.5123409033,
0.2886974216,
0.2004641145,
0.3101150692,
0.1377228498,
-0.7614006996,
0.1840706021,
-0.4576900601,
0.423959434,
0.408013761,
-0.7556941509,
0.9123690724,
-0.0578805655,
-0.5259084702,
-0.1647007465,
0.9320266247,
0.0187520143,
0.1958224624,
0.7525525689,
0.8764442205,
0.6472250819,
0.0210833978,
0.7093703747,
-0.502677083,
0.4342720211,
1.2327245474,
-0.5559763312,
0.6465108395,
0.4366383851,
0.1738452762,
0.4954156578,
0.4513625205,
-0.3016204536,
0.7924576402,
0.05978477,
-0.137072742,
-0.5628149509,
0.0155080734,
-0.4181066751,
0.480825007,
0.55044806,
-0.7783338428,
-0.234363988,
0.2931842506,
-0.3622224629,
0.0868482515,
-0.0703083575,
0.833243072,
-2.84e-7,
-0.7678562403,
0.8830832839,
-0.0543881729,
0.1625132114,
-0.0302564446,
-0.358671844,
0.0249143355,
0.1233354285,
-0.0930476785,
-0.477609545,
-0.0836030617,
-0.13982822,
-0.5137459636,
-0.1594244689,
1.0798469782,
-0.5662029386,
-0.2682961226,
0.3642404675,
0.5773009658,
0.0315528102,
0.1200223938,
-0.7169352174,
-0.0868102983,
-0.1647341549,
-0.5215148926,
-0.005335778,
0.9918637276,
-0.1717517823,
0.6596868038,
0.4763280749,
-0.1648693979,
0.3358883262,
0.1248939186,
0.9942427874,
-0.8793601394,
-0.5799153447,
-0.602011919,
0.198728174,
-0.1905760765,
-0.0550096259,
0.7603759766,
0.6428294778,
0.9650409818,
-0.0598432794,
0.7282614708,
-0.1333972365,
0.3953254223,
-0.6455562711,
0.4947373271,
-0.6673555374,
0.1439815015,
-0.3111620545,
-1.0117880106,
-0.1227853373,
0.7680947185,
-0.2729435861,
0.0502229817,
0.6029911637,
0.4862846136,
-0.2256196588,
-0.3727539182,
0.4754990041,
0.0878227726,
0.2644484043,
0.4030056,
0.932806015,
-0.6182029843,
0.2783670127,
-0.2870113552,
-0.2002028972,
-0.1769419461,
-0.6757190824,
-0.9134033918,
-0.6164742112,
-0.5043177009,
-0.4986174703,
0.1393246949,
0.9110401273,
0.8373377323,
-0.6385235786,
0.0686699599,
-0.3696297705,
-0.3031876683,
0.1656619906,
-0.2949892282,
0.180081889,
-0.3975250423,
-0.6067836881,
0.4346964955,
0.3359215558,
0.3021839559,
-0.2683983743,
0.2539022863,
-0.3368463218,
-0.0982156768,
0.4711937904,
0.5485031605,
-0.7639850378,
-0.3347711563,
-0.1244139969,
-0.431394428,
0.2352960557,
0.6631994843,
-0.940710485,
0.6781960726,
0.4165669978,
0.6004562974,
0.6530562639,
0.0271745306,
0.5959839225,
-0.6366946697,
0.2413123399,
0.1796053797,
0.6641505957,
0.5727921128,
-0.5725257397,
0.5517958999,
0.5066910386,
-0.5876029134,
-0.5336973071,
0.4580592513,
-0.5123398304,
-0.1889580488,
1.1503756046,
-0.1517459005,
-0.3948850036,
-0.007586441,
0.2013751566,
0.3980132043,
-0.3663212955,
0.4907382429,
0.5980554819,
-0.0071249334,
-0.4495730996,
-0.3997179866,
0.4656556249,
0.2996304333,
-0.5444552302,
-0.0994188488,
1.0746058226,
0.4486458004,
0.2040126622,
0.6687313914,
0.0223055724,
0.2694810629,
0.0890558958,
0.2768721879,
0.0418272875,
-0.7463725805,
-0.1451108903,
0.062696524,
0.2054136246,
-0.1908811629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00835v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00835v4
|
CLLMs: Consistency Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T20:17:04 | 2024-06-13T08:41:28 |
Siqi Kou, Lanxiang Hu, Zhezhi He, Zhijie Deng, Hao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Parallel decoding methods such as Jacobi decoding show promise for more
efficient LLM inference as it breaks the sequential nature of the LLM decoding
process and transforms it into parallelizable computation. However, in
practice, it achieves little speedup compared to traditional autoregressive
(AR) decoding, primarily because Jacobi decoding seldom accurately predicts
more than one token in a single fixed-point iteration step. To address this, we
develop a new approach aimed at realizing fast convergence from any state to
the fixed point on a Jacobi trajectory. This is accomplished by refining the
target LLM to consistently predict the fixed point given any state as input.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing
2.4$\times$ to 3.4$\times$ improvements in generation speed while preserving
generation quality across both domain-specific and open-domain benchmarks.
|
[
-0.1055424213,
-0.4558303356,
0.6711814404,
0.4261032045,
-0.0907948241,
0.1148811951,
-0.5620422363,
-0.1266881078,
0.123550497,
0.5090370178,
-0.4216934741,
-0.5639399886,
-0.7620527148,
0.3283935785,
-0.4947267473,
0.6232292056,
-0.1846408844,
0.0907285139,
-0.0686736405,
-0.0750916004,
-0.0906818211,
-0.4943535328,
-0.6342147589,
-0.3240065873,
0.6512362957,
0.2446501404,
0.6785286069,
0.9535118937,
0.3167980015,
0.2153814584,
-0.2877258062,
0.4494751394,
-0.7717018127,
0.4526425898,
-0.190026179,
-0.4634008408,
-0.2405625582,
-0.4377105236,
1.0621156693,
0.7995595932,
-0.1335450858,
0.2136418372,
0.1190472022,
0.8536446691,
-0.9614389539,
0.1384364367,
-0.680452168,
-0.1897176504,
-0.1661298275,
-0.1778444648,
-0.9224591255,
-0.7035719752,
-0.03382238,
-0.4882597029,
0.2217152864,
0.0519719236,
0.8131160736,
0.0508432053,
-0.3809942305,
-0.1802635193,
-0.8698556423,
1.0768619776,
-0.8978142738,
0.5178262591,
0.1247403994,
0.1564890295,
-0.3463495076,
-0.7608470917,
-0.4496578276,
-0.0223664567,
-0.0272882041,
-0.2472142577,
-0.0284867287,
0.1011484265,
0.5376883149,
0.1202635765,
-0.554115355,
-0.1143132672,
0.0068872706,
-0.2760307193,
0.7576408982,
0.5110383034,
-0.312825352,
0.2562468946,
-0.2111039609,
-0.1409956068,
-0.9059069753,
0.2659647763,
0.1592234224,
0.3350888193,
0.1343763024,
0.5371003747,
-0.2272945195,
0.8341620564,
0.1121064499,
-0.4757262766,
0.3659082353,
-0.4622017145,
-0.0625305697,
-0.2627959549,
0.4457116425,
0.3523805141,
0.2633369267,
-0.0342711918,
-0.4354245663,
-0.1117562652,
0.0100236451,
-0.8293817639,
-0.1509525925,
0.1284778863,
-0.6718944907,
0.147963956,
0.1326810271,
-0.4803179204,
-0.1714850813,
-0.6522836089,
-0.0100959288,
-0.5940256119,
-0.2058405876,
0.1710324883,
0.2229640037,
0.2020181268,
0.2346600443,
-1.0121705532,
0.3009952307,
0.7615261674,
0.8449137211,
-0.3747057915,
-0.3420249224,
-0.6779511571,
0.1314469129,
-0.4859762192,
0.4228878021,
-0.3796129227,
-0.3267173469,
0.2095078677,
0.1307947189,
-0.2304419726,
-0.5417485833,
0.2269438654,
-0.5714092851,
-0.5378593802,
-0.4854031503,
-0.832901001,
-0.1464558691,
0.1564996839,
-0.2839046717,
0.6331930757,
-0.1191878542,
-0.5708187222,
0.2787452936,
-0.5368830562,
-0.4164187014,
-0.3378361464,
0.1138597131,
-0.4990383685,
0.3051986396,
0.153856799,
0.363878876,
-0.1022379398,
0.5376014709,
-0.2827266157,
-0.58125633,
-0.0198712852,
-0.3867665231,
0.5867233872,
0.5499088168,
-0.2324097008,
0.1567259878,
-0.8357906342,
0.2190250307,
0.0927407965,
-0.4275718629,
-0.0434418134,
0.2929396331,
-0.144637391,
-0.2935115993,
0.4351322651,
-0.6522509456,
0.328039974,
-0.2699778676,
0.0879167095,
0.5133338571,
-0.2215790749,
0.3299539387,
-0.2524746656,
0.2818898857,
0.1632280648,
-0.0373188369,
-0.4129634798,
-0.2591650188,
-0.870606482,
-0.3418432176,
0.5466620326,
0.3921427727,
-0.7898657322,
0.5128913522,
-0.4010352194,
-0.3512358665,
-0.3822774887,
-0.0263214167,
0.6209079623,
0.3500928879,
0.2528930902,
-0.1703903824,
-0.7330320477,
-0.8748080134,
-0.2979406416,
0.1460597068,
-0.1362606287,
-0.0241288524,
0.3632373512,
-0.2536284626,
0.9049298167,
-0.3816224337,
0.4628061354,
-0.3061150014,
0.4133832753,
0.3470512331,
0.5974938273,
0.3275926411,
-0.4009535313,
-0.7391247749,
-0.2100043893,
-0.7579199672,
-0.0286107361,
0.0508481301,
0.0976852849,
0.3841161728,
0.4609074295,
-0.3413766921,
0.3779625893,
0.6839110851,
-0.3786713183,
0.517293036,
-0.2025352716,
0.231051445,
-0.7938606739,
0.0545288213,
-0.1413288116,
-0.4718352854,
-0.8526456952,
-0.0380064361,
0.2384313792,
0.0453249402,
-0.3794950545,
0.2217641473,
-0.6947001815,
-0.3573358357,
-0.5963295102,
-0.0460735969,
0.0117279887,
0.1612052321,
-0.0263746083,
1.0677000284,
0.7493795753,
-0.6654987931,
-0.0314846449,
0.0663708895,
-0.1450584084,
0.1677887291,
-0.6115787625,
0.1440583169,
-0.3243427575,
0.3930782974,
-0.7215089202,
0.0997128114,
-0.1533489078,
-0.2185804397,
0.3512893021,
0.2603691518,
-0.5892352462,
-0.3507685661,
-0.0756445378,
0.7027547956,
0.7751586437,
-0.8029921055,
0.7714235187,
0.084633559,
0.2297118902,
-0.7360083461,
-0.4784353077,
-0.2003015727,
0.2911005318,
-0.6892102361,
-0.0338655859,
-0.128118217,
-0.3283266127,
-0.1433795094,
0.1792257577,
0.1365334541,
-0.0352711827,
0.1414517909,
0.0497918092,
-0.4435383081,
-0.2285202742,
-0.1859550476,
-0.1917949915,
-0.1106145382,
-0.4805502594,
0.6594136357,
-0.4398241043,
-0.4295016229,
-0.6766815186,
0.4613560438,
0.8343041539,
-0.1406228095,
0.8462636471,
0.4021279812,
-0.1663845181,
-0.098758854,
-0.5213038325,
-0.0937390924,
-0.4112279117,
-0.0150159672,
-0.666501224,
-0.9473392367,
0.711602211,
-0.2443830967,
0.1790709943,
0.2949815691,
0.5236847997,
0.1223620996,
1.1373972893,
0.6513781548,
-0.0810650885,
0.0576524585,
-0.2899049222,
0.3052015007,
-0.6734080911,
-0.1684349924,
-0.3380072117,
-0.3747386634,
-0.3606930673,
-0.3135596514,
0.0484270565,
0.3156010211,
-0.4017499983,
0.6245376468,
-0.3961697519,
0.5008669496,
0.8253595829,
0.0203696173,
0.3620291948,
-0.0820578486,
-0.2353304178,
-0.0913867652,
-0.8403642774,
-0.3422822654,
1.0909018517,
0.4795238674,
0.7452682853,
0.0085677383,
0.8232018352,
0.1914699078,
0.3660615981,
-0.4023101032,
0.6276031733,
-0.290376991,
-0.3680345118,
-0.2335760742,
-0.2231108546,
-1.0098011494,
0.2188004404,
-0.1585624963,
-0.7086000443,
0.3400764763,
0.3648211062,
-0.2065854818,
0.6261480451,
-0.4080169201,
0.3473696411,
0.1688361764,
-0.3566170633,
-0.1127363741,
-0.6990058422,
0.5444970727,
-0.0052236277,
0.0361060277,
-0.2581314147,
0.1378535777,
0.4136148393,
-0.5696535707,
0.6363241076,
-0.3655371964,
-0.105718635,
0.4055670798,
0.0719041005,
0.7883105278,
-0.1235742345,
-0.3982031047,
0.3604902327,
0.1081321612,
-0.7337169647,
-0.6207280159,
0.7352334857,
-0.4523640573,
-0.5067875981,
-0.1983413249,
-0.9571252465,
-0.143010363,
0.129856199,
0.2307236642,
0.4972945452,
0.184193179,
0.1976706535,
0.710259378,
0.1442535967,
0.5619082451,
0.555711031,
-0.3434099257,
-0.4018215239,
0.958327949,
-0.0020069499,
0.3893875182,
0.0444164835,
-0.1474593431,
-0.3469400406,
-0.952629745,
-0.2161662579,
0.39988482,
-0.7382033467,
-0.2733245194,
-0.225852564,
-0.3903764188,
-0.39049685,
-0.38259992,
-0.6376946568,
-0.0211445186,
-0.193021968,
0.2304861397,
0.0690935552,
0.9283635616,
-0.1062062755,
0.3389760256,
-1.1079250574,
0.1427679807,
-0.1645613164,
0.3147296906,
-0.082645312,
-0.4835329056,
-0.2856535017,
-0.015363262,
0.0413722955,
-0.3491326869,
0.4337031841,
0.0795546547,
0.4335322082,
0.4841093719,
0.1604646593,
0.6942449212,
-0.7409225106,
0.873875916,
0.3796513975,
-1.1062549353,
0.3563584089,
-0.1949157715,
0.5940003991,
0.6857959628,
0.334066391,
-0.1527834684,
-0.4064309597,
-0.4087804854,
-0.6037364602,
0.332095176,
0.2547563612,
-0.1578875184,
-0.4101159573,
0.4552297592,
0.2929925025,
0.2246320993,
-0.5070870519,
-0.4812655449,
-0.0029200341,
-0.3705169857,
-0.1074754968,
-0.7338092923,
-0.2683231533,
-0.3193061054,
0.5474491715,
-0.20025374,
0.24528642,
0.2463604957,
0.058161512,
-0.1730509549,
0.0718233064,
1.0097981691,
1.0148457289,
-0.1966747642,
0.3384083211,
0.1760293394,
-0.2046197504,
0.4121827185,
-0.0580226965,
-0.6382807493,
0.3208649158,
0.2299214602,
0.9367666841,
0.1090830266,
-0.7165493965,
0.5633377433,
0.0034878131,
-0.534247458,
-0.3229233921,
-0.104738079,
-0.0958852991,
0.586786747,
0.3359807432,
0.1957148761,
-0.0768837258,
-0.208204627,
0.5445510745,
0.4885427952,
0.0153261693,
-0.1789644808,
0.7170264125,
0.2023325115,
-0.3907428086,
0.4367993772,
-0.3731143773,
-0.2973810732,
0.3403581083,
0.7851521373,
0.9003419876,
-0.0305346642,
-0.2010961622,
0.6842617393,
-0.0636548549,
-0.6276822686,
0.4476138055,
0.1325624138,
-0.6579274535,
-0.7304058075,
-0.8455274105,
-0.4150685072,
-0.0731623694,
-0.7901983261,
0.0169140529,
-0.5892186761,
-0.1003333107,
-0.4708629549,
-0.3768537939,
-0.305198878,
0.230394125,
0.2996596992,
1.0684853792,
-0.4269863367,
1.1791907549,
0.0790119097,
0.1419361234,
-0.9344930053,
0.3228925765,
-0.0249975473,
-0.7496888638,
0.8273361325,
0.1111072302,
-0.4889702797,
0.2341010123,
-0.6083045602,
-1.3803068399,
1.2388797998,
0.2994980812,
-1.2025794983,
-0.0326465853,
-0.1286322773,
0.3422433436,
-0.7227870822,
0.0638793781,
0.8359209895,
0.4875117838,
0.0369798429,
-0.9363370538,
0.2208472937,
0.1051130667,
0.4409742653,
0.3011007309,
-0.3938455582,
0.7920481563,
-0.3683428764,
-0.2263644189,
0.464517206,
0.9819087982,
0.4882247448,
0.417326808,
0.5997119546,
0.6457770467,
0.8572810292,
-0.25718081,
1.1521013975,
-0.873390615,
0.6534379125,
0.9257197976,
-0.2254188806,
1.0207885504,
0.4003646076,
-0.1312895566,
0.6104064584,
0.358686775,
-0.1390829682,
0.6165435314,
0.3275140524,
-0.4867616892,
-0.3341544867,
-0.0387831591,
-0.1531274319,
0.1297282726,
0.2407735586,
-0.5644275546,
-0.2233422548,
0.1148033217,
-0.0122907758,
0.4303230345,
-0.4149372876,
0.3493931592,
-0.1625077873,
-0.8274969459,
1.3123965263,
-0.1653185487,
0.7645327449,
-0.627538681,
0.0757125393,
-0.0498900674,
0.2824852169,
-0.0209800173,
-0.6960455775,
0.5152973533,
-0.358006835,
-0.4894907773,
-0.2063242197,
0.572979033,
-0.7825241685,
-0.3237309158,
0.4482630789,
0.1950867027,
0.2076942921,
0.3384406567,
-0.438942045,
0.4644202292,
0.1473873705,
-0.2893380225,
0.1535682231,
0.081433855,
0.2412142009,
0.7382214665,
0.5564668775,
-0.068893753,
0.197608754,
0.0733078271,
0.6759034991,
-0.7368786335,
-0.0261127204,
-0.8207136989,
0.6096944213,
-0.0535544865,
-0.1345739514,
0.7509975433,
0.5640673041,
0.6830856204,
-0.2687143087,
0.6121681929,
0.1262021065,
0.7489545941,
-0.7542874217,
0.3808895051,
-0.3821596205,
0.2993688285,
0.4079852998,
-0.9038498402,
-0.4379646778,
0.2168429643,
-0.2313873768,
-0.2719941139,
0.9365907311,
0.7317428589,
0.2448296994,
-0.1601079255,
0.6567514539,
0.2759708166,
0.2518748343,
0.5032471418,
0.4976242483,
-0.3183026612,
0.3521733284,
-0.2305545807,
-0.0654931664,
-0.1467238218,
-0.7612661719,
-0.7665613294,
-0.304636389,
-0.0572259091,
-0.6692690253,
0.2925764322,
0.8773703575,
0.692650795,
-1.1958776712,
-0.253128916,
-0.4643129408,
-0.1788533926,
-0.2624955177,
-0.2230796069,
0.1532506347,
-0.787956059,
-1.0040038824,
0.6212665439,
0.4599281251,
-0.1642590761,
-0.2436211854,
-0.3328303397,
-0.2185082883,
0.2536877096,
0.6848967671,
0.4959135056,
-1.1611561775,
-0.5197315216,
0.0470729321,
-0.2329421043,
0.1567643136,
1.175067544,
-0.5257989764,
0.3515797853,
0.4899057448,
0.9230051041,
0.7073454857,
0.3782199919,
0.8343267441,
-0.4697515965,
0.1770539284,
0.1686088443,
0.5914116502,
0.2570121288,
-0.156107232,
0.3459426463,
0.4547545016,
-0.8649519086,
-0.6280187964,
0.4174900949,
-1.002251029,
-0.3072733879,
1.2195829153,
-0.6039972901,
-0.4243606329,
-0.230565384,
0.0166202579,
0.1131523922,
-0.3314862549,
0.4238377512,
0.47671628,
-0.3512951434,
-0.1654203534,
-0.188522771,
0.3890713155,
0.6938274503,
-0.230302453,
0.283062607,
0.3310252428,
0.4134544134,
0.3754183054,
0.6005412936,
0.0232767295,
0.0510136597,
0.1660468131,
0.1011313498,
-0.0400553532,
-0.4577577412,
-0.3840881884,
0.409529835,
0.1964160204,
-0.1942571849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18678v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18678v3
|
RORA: Robust Free-Text Rationale Evaluation
| 2024-02-28T19:46:21 | 2024-06-15T00:32:04 |
Zhengping Jiang, Yining Lu, Hanjie Chen, Daniel Khashabi, Benjamin Van Durme, Anqi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Free-text rationales play a pivotal role in explainable NLP, bridging the
knowledge and reasoning gaps behind a model's decision-making. However, due to
the diversity of potential reasoning paths and a corresponding lack of
definitive ground truth, their evaluation remains a challenge. Existing
evaluation metrics rely on the degree to which a rationale supports a target
label, but we find these fall short in evaluating rationales that inadvertently
leak the labels. To address this problem, we propose RORA, a Robust free-text
Rationale evaluation against label leakage. RORA quantifies the new information
supplied by a rationale to justify the label. This is achieved by assessing the
conditional V-information \citep{hewitt-etal-2021-conditional} with a
predictive family robust against leaky features that can be exploited by a
small model. RORA consistently outperforms existing approaches in evaluating
human-written, synthetic, or model-generated rationales, particularly
demonstrating robustness against label leakage. We also show that RORA aligns
well with human judgment, providing a more reliable and accurate measurement
across diverse free-text rationales.
|
[
-0.2083382607,
-0.5156900287,
0.5563470721,
0.049115289,
-0.2102527022,
-0.2423866391,
-0.0232135002,
-0.3740701973,
0.1186073944,
0.397020489,
-0.7290584445,
-0.3225019276,
-0.5708692074,
-0.0370242149,
-0.2303408384,
1.0407947302,
-0.1350675374,
-0.2062101513,
-0.4402318001,
-0.6994865537,
-0.7720673084,
-0.2376040518,
-0.4232566357,
-0.5021898746,
0.9716818929,
0.3522113264,
0.7730802894,
0.8021633029,
0.3405622244,
0.1403995305,
-0.040467672,
0.1582968086,
-0.1901979893,
0.5393902063,
-0.6724187136,
-0.5372361541,
-0.4260515869,
0.1681330353,
0.3983539343,
0.1688298434,
-0.185986042,
0.4937999249,
-0.0324524902,
0.9351608157,
-0.9516563416,
-0.0762635693,
-0.6459205747,
-0.014730786,
-0.0639917552,
-0.2373911142,
-0.6914957166,
-0.3113434315,
0.3468630314,
-0.7677661777,
0.0070935744,
0.0687128156,
1.3421453238,
0.6287905574,
-0.0668708459,
-0.4059604406,
-0.6496370435,
0.8204700351,
-0.3443623781,
0.4280987382,
0.5724021792,
0.5576572418,
-0.0774259344,
-0.719748199,
-0.5131677985,
-0.3407970965,
0.0082646683,
0.1798343062,
-0.5084036589,
-0.3458301425,
0.1966225654,
0.1374699175,
-0.3876898587,
-0.3237082958,
-0.0282358918,
-0.277223587,
0.4225117266,
-0.1040120348,
0.4928875566,
-0.1288832873,
-0.8514671922,
-0.3542790711,
-0.4257682562,
0.0026102772,
0.2806781232,
0.1441402733,
-0.0035753446,
0.5920271873,
-0.0440074354,
0.4632139504,
-0.3300680816,
-0.1613977253,
-0.0677135587,
-0.3990666866,
-0.3213936388,
-0.1571279317,
0.9814538956,
0.2767634094,
0.3147529364,
-0.1628628373,
-0.0721506402,
0.3928505778,
0.1557174176,
-0.7821033597,
-0.0650466755,
0.2736276984,
-0.4282155931,
-0.3453130126,
0.1108774319,
-0.848737359,
-0.4685378373,
-0.1048726067,
0.3143512607,
-0.6064348221,
-0.0471179672,
0.1590505093,
-0.4408102632,
0.1834670752,
0.2581156492,
-0.6150226593,
0.0099701518,
0.5064662099,
0.8149400353,
0.0314867683,
-0.0448319912,
-0.8028628826,
0.250772059,
-0.1633322388,
1.2986472845,
-0.5624290109,
-0.1786550581,
-0.3555258512,
-0.3221919239,
-0.3035446405,
-0.4393630624,
1.2170006037,
-0.3936988711,
0.3509563506,
-0.4220399559,
-0.2611330748,
-0.3223944306,
0.1213012189,
-0.8069586754,
0.7650029659,
0.2929467857,
-1.1737691164,
0.5856191516,
-0.6978060603,
0.0281920396,
0.056973625,
-0.0506684072,
-0.583969295,
-0.1400165707,
0.3460012078,
-0.2278565615,
-0.4454576075,
0.39955917,
-0.431843102,
0.0245722253,
0.6806825995,
-0.7436081767,
0.9699546695,
0.3899683058,
-0.1730271578,
0.755628705,
-0.6373685598,
0.3013009131,
-0.0418501683,
-0.1710636318,
-0.56927526,
0.0416942053,
-0.3268969357,
0.1486881822,
-0.0050761825,
-0.2683391571,
0.043064069,
-0.2116305679,
0.3393639326,
0.6563924551,
0.0727420002,
0.5669452548,
-0.4759336412,
0.8893919587,
-0.2888763249,
0.2676775157,
-0.1606098115,
-0.8067607284,
-0.7011172771,
-0.6881275177,
0.7135494947,
0.9820066094,
-0.5040650368,
0.3282105625,
-0.1634252667,
-0.4815286398,
-0.4839627743,
0.1664421558,
0.4294176102,
0.7993304729,
0.4933097064,
-0.1490890831,
-0.4960438609,
-1.1109831333,
-0.7351187468,
-0.0888895169,
-0.454136759,
0.1608366817,
0.393763423,
-0.5116832256,
1.3156514168,
-0.22031115,
-0.4127723873,
-0.3028339446,
0.2057099789,
-0.1294399202,
0.4149873257,
0.3219538331,
-0.355115205,
-0.267167449,
-0.14049308,
-0.8062687516,
-0.4399102628,
-0.3455971181,
-0.6130838394,
0.086953342,
-0.0385529585,
-0.8494427204,
0.8050174117,
0.2747234702,
-0.715277195,
0.4979760647,
-0.3025585413,
-0.3685738444,
-0.6185649633,
0.195475325,
0.2240099013,
-0.153781265,
-0.2157370597,
0.1284181625,
0.172724247,
0.1297741681,
-0.176224649,
0.7028150558,
-0.256555289,
0.0432873629,
-0.040461272,
0.3081047833,
0.3611024916,
0.0556635521,
0.0006761618,
0.7101581097,
0.1661619991,
-0.4038041532,
-0.2104826123,
0.2909021378,
-0.4637716115,
0.3594142199,
-0.7245827317,
0.0716285408,
-0.0743529797,
0.6003412008,
-0.4820714593,
-0.2221367955,
0.6705394983,
-0.537125051,
0.0105658351,
-0.2191275954,
-0.1451009661,
0.0263963621,
-0.3946812153,
0.2414885908,
0.2674347162,
-0.4416885376,
0.8052479625,
0.2434908897,
0.0192559157,
-0.9137631655,
-0.6181915998,
-0.0268113948,
-0.4768648446,
-0.8581678867,
-0.0076246262,
-0.0560374931,
-0.5656041503,
0.1074109301,
-0.4592419267,
-0.2603095174,
0.1336310655,
0.0908616185,
0.4043065608,
-0.2035571039,
-0.2098880708,
0.2063347548,
-0.6300122738,
0.1773602217,
-0.2465215623,
0.2276569903,
-0.2735227942,
-0.0718623623,
-0.7108231187,
0.3400273323,
0.5829754472,
-0.3233747482,
0.7665166855,
0.466575563,
-0.4139934778,
-0.5311506391,
-0.1209037453,
0.0549160577,
-0.3839434981,
-0.1250763983,
-0.1586107016,
-0.4618750811,
0.6007419825,
0.3041317463,
-0.167209819,
0.6017845273,
0.3182224929,
0.0881055146,
0.7370683551,
0.5873954892,
0.6357981563,
0.2750433981,
-0.1570376754,
0.4518676102,
-0.6272211075,
-0.4427587986,
-0.5771886706,
-0.0906167924,
-0.1430724114,
-0.6977360249,
-0.0470347926,
0.6129865646,
0.113280803,
0.2539952099,
-0.6414394379,
0.8006248474,
0.5331792235,
-0.1858785152,
0.3397862315,
-0.0459831357,
-0.2265548259,
-0.1097423136,
-0.718560636,
-1.0557450056,
0.8165209293,
0.6679480076,
0.5111097097,
0.1663588285,
0.4477633536,
0.2767530084,
0.8841062188,
-0.880644381,
0.3919825256,
0.3017883301,
-0.6347125769,
-0.1208906025,
-0.470883131,
-0.80312711,
0.4517632723,
-0.3560956717,
-0.8758171797,
0.4734704196,
0.2152157128,
-0.5217313766,
0.1276882738,
-0.7947663665,
1.0326474905,
-0.1437403858,
-0.4882307947,
0.0234762914,
-0.6838505268,
0.6490286589,
-0.0380630717,
0.3241520226,
-0.3130916953,
-0.1702478379,
0.8766168356,
-0.6711172462,
0.5721735358,
-0.1040416807,
-0.1907301098,
0.5394346118,
0.1928653568,
0.0737770945,
0.4565773904,
-0.1019361541,
0.1098678112,
0.0954669267,
-0.2663841844,
-0.7565033436,
0.5379639864,
-0.4942159951,
-0.1991960406,
-0.7704726458,
-0.709821403,
-0.2927031815,
0.2079109848,
0.365045011,
0.2395917177,
0.0290112924,
0.174106881,
0.712952733,
-0.3303212225,
0.13435027,
0.2159193456,
-0.3489227891,
-0.8100304008,
0.969804287,
0.0247037988,
0.2006441206,
0.1975770444,
0.8151147962,
-0.5891470909,
-0.2771421373,
-0.6818362474,
0.1031128615,
-0.8487076163,
-0.5117522478,
-0.4782952666,
0.0441182181,
0.0774869248,
-0.0478280745,
-0.1186343357,
-0.8697524667,
-0.1835718751,
-0.3591322899,
0.3154919446,
0.6325185895,
-0.1421699971,
0.0477520712,
-0.8191131353,
0.4512251914,
0.2511012554,
0.4001147151,
-0.0748563856,
-0.3077635169,
0.2212160975,
0.0767272115,
-0.4299654365,
-1.1334189177,
0.4957380295,
0.0236981176,
0.6574826241,
0.4627093077,
0.3564225137,
0.3515467346,
-0.1296833605,
0.5020541549,
0.19235681,
-1.0585955381,
0.5903427601,
-0.5319164395,
-0.0841304362,
0.7560814023,
0.1479104012,
-0.0547194257,
-0.1862195879,
-0.7703149319,
-1.152136445,
0.3885116577,
0.3080071509,
-0.355597496,
0.0579578429,
0.2020860016,
0.1792966425,
-0.0373308063,
-0.9046376944,
-0.1839658469,
-0.5119559169,
-0.1691473722,
0.4711716473,
-0.5218765736,
-0.2857521772,
-0.1428292394,
0.6222785115,
0.023952635,
0.0580948442,
0.477717191,
-0.0865630358,
0.0687616915,
0.6461974978,
0.8425603509,
0.6830140352,
-0.4347518682,
-0.0028250285,
-0.005217216,
-0.3427505195,
-0.0487506278,
-0.0319848657,
-0.6697759032,
0.1157776043,
0.3637339473,
0.7966390252,
-0.1082472503,
-0.8336013556,
0.5016044974,
-0.3646892607,
-0.3972199559,
-0.1776597649,
0.0282347258,
0.0574797951,
-0.0688163638,
0.1115714014,
0.6270084381,
-0.0863278583,
-0.4429729581,
0.4355556369,
0.3745055795,
-0.6601102948,
-0.0670103952,
0.868758738,
-0.0693570152,
-0.4019375443,
0.3497798145,
-0.1824018806,
-0.4221972823,
0.4115203023,
0.5494741797,
1.0998553038,
-0.1801690012,
0.317951113,
0.4590781629,
0.4937520921,
0.0757858008,
0.2162001878,
-0.1089229509,
-0.6477610469,
-0.3650599122,
-0.6303364038,
-0.5715346932,
0.0842705518,
-0.787899375,
0.1170196161,
-0.6897319555,
-0.1815738827,
-0.2286739796,
-0.4096880555,
-0.1014823467,
0.1232400835,
-0.195205301,
1.3388533592,
-0.6693822145,
0.8918779492,
0.1618914306,
-0.6372680664,
-0.9064355493,
0.0920201316,
-0.1559715569,
-0.3372318745,
0.4751925468,
0.3535248935,
-0.63757056,
-0.5782296658,
-0.3726946115,
-0.6985081434,
0.9951639175,
0.6087480783,
-0.2641220987,
0.143655315,
-0.2531084418,
0.4265565872,
-0.3185307384,
0.2094231695,
0.5281846523,
0.8594279885,
0.0336128399,
-0.4786291718,
0.2015461177,
-0.3122549355,
-0.2230391651,
0.114726074,
-0.1975517422,
0.4326563776,
-0.3781302273,
-0.5058004856,
0.1548167914,
0.7814927697,
0.4553596973,
0.6505184174,
0.748113811,
0.7012472749,
1.181170702,
-0.0649655312,
1.3222860098,
0.0070535317,
0.0961888731,
1.1071587801,
-0.2263811082,
1.1937997341,
0.3994643688,
0.1264069527,
0.863851428,
0.2126448452,
0.2540833354,
0.4916591942,
0.2343016416,
-0.3904749453,
-0.247690767,
-0.1240297705,
-0.2677340508,
0.2489855289,
0.6289871335,
-0.1454537958,
-0.1816153675,
-0.3596717119,
0.1730440855,
0.3756150901,
0.0223421678,
0.4202776551,
0.181177184,
-0.8778594732,
0.5785830617,
0.0442380644,
0.4594267309,
-0.8361193538,
0.1482027769,
-0.0704523772,
0.4069724679,
-0.451406002,
-0.5794816017,
0.7606624961,
0.2074504495,
-0.35583058,
-0.3944447041,
0.9475856423,
-0.1504908502,
-0.3589592576,
0.406526804,
0.4754195511,
-0.2358567119,
0.0920346305,
-0.7312374711,
0.0550373048,
0.0992002636,
-0.2224764675,
0.2958541811,
0.3397539258,
-0.4311635494,
1.0897431374,
1.0466244221,
-0.1909763068,
-0.0108687831,
0.1176787913,
0.5957421064,
-0.6341394782,
-0.3814018369,
-0.7456331253,
0.4786596894,
-0.0976583958,
-0.404599756,
0.8831856251,
0.5194442868,
0.2385985702,
0.1293164343,
0.9246328473,
0.233635664,
0.5571573377,
-0.4722358882,
0.9189294577,
-0.2865496278,
0.4579558969,
-0.2006769627,
-0.7806513309,
-0.5031007528,
1.0957826376,
-0.1848045439,
-0.3553192019,
0.9841659665,
0.4876757562,
-0.0281403214,
0.2776292861,
-0.1713651866,
-0.1172033027,
0.3304965198,
0.3072301149,
1.0914596319,
-0.3419763148,
0.7836071849,
-0.1716294736,
-0.4632103443,
0.1480592936,
-1.4617100954,
-0.6508260369,
-0.1380464584,
-0.4056578577,
-0.6880455017,
-0.2683926225,
0.5265631676,
0.4023889303,
-0.662381947,
0.0749479905,
-0.2239233851,
0.5995464325,
-0.2957315147,
-0.254432112,
0.2255084813,
-0.1924007535,
-0.171465829,
0.6913259029,
0.2768589556,
-0.1026154831,
-0.0974503085,
-0.1239611208,
0.0108852545,
0.5911551118,
0.4151663184,
0.6257267594,
-0.7550691962,
-0.335440129,
-0.0694500729,
0.0218232796,
0.0443296544,
0.8822809458,
-1.0111099482,
0.1374543607,
0.789268136,
0.4673684239,
0.008229943,
0.2668263018,
0.8284493089,
-0.3579075634,
0.0893137231,
0.28397578,
0.4359146655,
0.3650706708,
-0.0136328526,
0.5871784687,
0.1413881183,
-0.4847181737,
-1.0876222849,
0.3982562721,
-1.4660693407,
-0.2627288699,
1.0633491278,
-0.1391557455,
-0.2949567735,
-0.2742791474,
-0.2084900141,
0.0799736604,
-0.4538491666,
0.4712632596,
0.5908617973,
0.0082627246,
0.0178263783,
-0.8050667048,
0.4241287708,
0.4821051061,
-0.694645822,
0.3473950028,
0.5168632865,
0.3658762276,
0.4149120748,
0.6789471507,
-0.16417858,
0.1720111519,
0.0870346129,
-0.3003525734,
-0.0978211239,
-0.5269335508,
-0.0893367678,
0.2982814014,
0.0748983473,
-0.0821509287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18668v1
|
Simple linear attention language models balance the recall-throughput tradeoff
| 2024-02-28T19:28:27 | 2024-02-28T19:28:27 |
Simran Arora, Sabri Eyuboglu, Michael Zhang, Aman Timalsina, Silas Alberti, Dylan Zinsley, James Zou, Atri Rudra, Christopher Ré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown that attention-based language models excel at recall,
the ability to ground generations in tokens previously seen in context.
However, the efficiency of attention-based models is bottle-necked during
inference by the KV-cache's aggressive memory consumption. In this work, we
explore whether we can improve language model efficiency (e.g. by reducing
memory consumption) without compromising on recall. By applying experiments and
theory to a broad set of architectures, we identify a key tradeoff between a
model's state size and recall ability. We show that efficient alternatives to
attention (e.g. H3, Mamba, RWKV) maintain a fixed-size recurrent state, but
struggle at recall. We propose BASED a simple architecture combining linear and
sliding window attention. By varying BASED window size and linear attention
feature dimension, we can dial the state size and traverse the pareto frontier
of the recall-memory tradeoff curve, recovering the full quality of attention
on one end and the small state size of attention-alternatives on the other. We
train language models up to 1.3b parameters and show that BASED matches the
strongest sub-quadratic models (e.g. Mamba) in perplexity and outperforms them
on real-world recall-intensive tasks by 6.22 accuracy points. Implementations
of linear attention are often less efficient than optimized standard attention
implementations. To make BASED competitive, we develop IO-aware algorithms that
enable 24x higher throughput on language generation than FlashAttention-2, when
generating 1024 tokens using 1.3b parameter models. Code for this work is
provided at: https://github.com/HazyResearch/based.
|
[
-0.2193740904,
-0.4663228691,
0.6361713409,
0.13721627,
0.0516221374,
-0.3473480642,
-0.1777804792,
-0.5004593134,
0.3056977689,
0.5260144472,
-0.3493067026,
-0.0314216241,
-0.2818274796,
-0.3902803361,
-0.3556990325,
0.7643615007,
-0.0270635318,
-0.4032699168,
-0.1928688735,
-0.273553282,
-0.5349028111,
-0.4411194921,
-0.746778965,
-0.3432516456,
0.7281795144,
0.3182271123,
0.5310491323,
0.7957253456,
0.3342413604,
0.2103093117,
-0.2006040663,
-0.1437713653,
-1.0523421764,
-0.0796275362,
-0.1962686628,
-0.4804341197,
-0.572334528,
-0.0197615232,
0.5369192958,
0.4780090749,
-0.2148279548,
0.2127647698,
-0.0405255817,
0.725456655,
-0.9496215582,
-0.0370265394,
-0.9645992517,
0.1088144854,
-0.0071137357,
-0.0768834576,
-0.7037480474,
-0.2542788684,
0.2749761343,
-0.3925069869,
0.0823523253,
0.0153701007,
0.830429256,
0.3118119836,
0.0247252025,
-0.1796078682,
-0.8252891898,
0.8819484711,
-0.70826298,
0.4513364732,
0.3182126284,
0.0474031307,
0.1745390296,
-0.829944551,
-0.277397722,
-0.1927488744,
0.0239059776,
0.0911800116,
-0.3640407622,
0.0926807746,
0.3197022378,
0.3695273101,
-0.4847792983,
-0.0795074627,
-0.4623312652,
-0.1862818748,
0.1042817086,
0.3612837195,
0.0817909539,
0.1252427995,
-0.4825558662,
0.2046900392,
-0.8911109567,
0.2023398876,
-0.114689298,
0.1558949798,
0.1790205687,
0.3052117527,
-0.1140007153,
0.6078261137,
0.1641793996,
-0.1515810192,
-0.0966169015,
-0.3064166903,
-0.3045847714,
-0.1219019517,
0.3773519099,
0.1714707464,
0.2281594425,
-0.18908149,
-0.1658991575,
0.1157056317,
0.5594267845,
-0.7123880982,
-0.2278432548,
0.1136182994,
-0.5499735475,
-0.0718778223,
-0.3777129352,
-0.6610121131,
-0.019716043,
-0.1401538253,
0.7484235168,
-0.4275572598,
0.1010224074,
0.2497829795,
0.0636871532,
0.108897008,
0.3836522698,
-1.0304592848,
0.4810580313,
0.5349463224,
0.7454630136,
-0.0697082281,
-0.0764986202,
-0.7189946175,
0.208564654,
-0.1249345839,
0.5356037021,
-0.6154325604,
0.0062586516,
-0.1900728345,
-0.5916103721,
-0.3266836703,
-0.4459816217,
0.1064722836,
-0.5650507808,
0.1592417061,
-0.4438522756,
-0.5446210504,
-0.2545641959,
0.0982957035,
-0.6915921569,
1.0339460373,
-0.1990877092,
-0.7307248712,
0.2132731676,
-0.3839217424,
-0.4134037793,
-0.0639291555,
-0.0041831643,
-0.3361445963,
0.216711238,
0.080201678,
0.3059575558,
-0.3139032423,
-0.1205005869,
-0.2322968394,
-0.5968927145,
0.1016046777,
-0.3724855185,
0.4309940934,
0.280495584,
-0.2904817164,
0.0827573389,
-0.7767095566,
0.0054479716,
0.0169513971,
-0.8089680076,
-0.4535943568,
0.0912320316,
-0.0980330184,
0.3039313853,
0.4685531855,
-0.4124786258,
0.0166072268,
-0.4561372399,
0.4929164648,
0.6163319945,
-0.2292336971,
0.4939844906,
-0.1142759994,
0.5172377229,
-0.02106761,
0.1967735142,
-0.3658312261,
-0.1936837137,
-1.229780674,
-0.4204243422,
0.3113297522,
0.5657088161,
-0.5854868889,
-0.0126000904,
-0.194762364,
-0.1471271366,
-0.7406213284,
0.2801557779,
0.7417048812,
0.4747555554,
0.0520409234,
-0.4638056159,
-0.4299065471,
-1.0528868437,
-0.0441220216,
0.0798933655,
0.1890263557,
0.5378872156,
0.0851952285,
0.0800585523,
0.8655780554,
-0.5568295717,
-0.0259724744,
-0.4785319269,
-0.0118074594,
0.1051549166,
0.2255232185,
0.4720487297,
-0.4685210884,
-0.5025165677,
-0.0814345032,
-0.5474351048,
0.0163196214,
-0.1792107373,
-0.045223821,
0.3297096789,
0.5319687724,
-0.6260764599,
0.4735383093,
0.2118763924,
-0.1831353009,
0.1059830636,
-0.3656289577,
-0.2022392899,
-0.7114005089,
0.5089872479,
-0.1486179233,
-0.4257000983,
-0.8362303376,
0.188495487,
0.286439836,
-0.2728287876,
-0.520668447,
0.6152209044,
-0.477064997,
-0.3063225448,
-0.4005329311,
0.216194734,
-0.0906456783,
0.8781246543,
0.0029288123,
0.7599105835,
0.2703831792,
-0.6839901209,
-0.1357213408,
-0.1862144917,
-0.1707178354,
0.2454832196,
-0.5295681357,
0.3190667629,
-0.2026300579,
0.0176247377,
-1.0810563564,
0.1741978377,
0.0385059156,
-0.268482089,
0.3881187737,
0.1070644632,
-0.3711796403,
-0.4061838984,
-0.434631139,
0.2643945813,
0.6278474331,
-0.4530967176,
0.5187547207,
0.2158498466,
-0.2790650427,
-0.7545572519,
-0.4897314012,
-0.04118995,
-0.228329882,
-0.5080137253,
-0.0010714646,
-0.0540425889,
0.0648185834,
-0.0027707412,
-0.2772868574,
0.0598459281,
0.0899092257,
-0.1018512025,
0.1667444408,
-0.3714753389,
0.27742818,
-0.3398358822,
-0.2945133746,
-0.2193066031,
-0.5237960815,
0.7605298162,
-0.2540360391,
0.1163882613,
-0.4090173244,
0.2939485312,
0.80397892,
-0.3740291893,
0.5700291395,
0.0936321244,
-0.3026520908,
-0.0233933274,
-0.6815004349,
-0.1858184934,
-0.4187372923,
0.2407798618,
-0.3385892212,
-0.8454331756,
0.7224021554,
0.2593889534,
0.1209466234,
0.2509951293,
0.6409608722,
0.0311670247,
0.8046113849,
0.5912594795,
-0.3862442076,
0.5958207846,
-0.0102835428,
0.186802417,
-0.7284744382,
0.15068838,
-0.3066316247,
-0.5075733662,
-0.1071662083,
-0.3396308124,
0.223259449,
-0.1650867462,
-0.2086111158,
0.5223984718,
-0.1994488239,
0.4718184471,
0.7991250157,
0.0524251685,
0.2578078806,
0.0337294564,
-0.2176904976,
-0.3396731317,
-1.1069552898,
-0.2237005085,
1.0527098179,
0.5430102944,
0.939040184,
-0.1068682522,
0.5754918456,
0.0063134423,
0.0330153257,
-0.5947797894,
0.6170990467,
-0.1961140633,
-0.7021874189,
-0.2158128321,
-0.4138219655,
-0.8391566277,
0.417186141,
-0.0254506208,
-1.0639076233,
0.2635753453,
0.504963398,
-0.6264258623,
0.1948072761,
-0.7856914997,
0.8588140011,
-0.0147987269,
-0.7418395281,
-0.5304663181,
-0.5663490295,
0.4963741601,
0.0756615773,
-0.1420890689,
0.1794192642,
0.1800697446,
0.3607638478,
-0.2044588476,
0.8967782855,
0.0002960979,
0.0365002379,
0.2525258362,
0.1224307269,
0.6121017337,
-0.3504258692,
0.0957276672,
-0.212925747,
-0.343659997,
-0.4959417284,
-0.4760896564,
0.8072098494,
-0.3975862861,
-0.5100131631,
-0.130141452,
-0.7423223257,
-0.0472244769,
0.2261424959,
0.1641471237,
0.4851263463,
-0.1780052483,
0.2344874442,
1.2588664293,
-0.2128814757,
0.4783110917,
0.5674273968,
-0.2837802768,
-0.1734556556,
1.2973406315,
0.1731682122,
0.5787959695,
0.6490758657,
0.1401636302,
-0.0889976919,
-0.3001852036,
-0.1746079624,
0.1810712367,
-0.6315093637,
-0.033604417,
-0.7377228141,
-0.2058045864,
-0.1804422885,
-0.1932626814,
-0.6786921024,
-0.5156507492,
-0.1844614297,
0.0776309744,
0.2374635637,
0.5893973112,
-0.1385374665,
0.2316711247,
-0.4235916436,
0.3614955246,
0.4943302274,
0.3645852804,
0.4705896974,
-0.4492547512,
-0.4404445291,
-0.3288160563,
-0.3004134297,
-0.4679091573,
0.4041822851,
0.1150550321,
0.5826282501,
0.5153779984,
-0.2999485135,
0.6138737202,
-0.5210850239,
0.3365662694,
0.3111167848,
-1.0102081299,
0.486325711,
-0.2546030879,
0.5887266397,
0.5026625395,
0.0385291688,
-0.5601019263,
-0.5207613707,
-0.594817102,
-0.8595617414,
0.9731327891,
0.3570070565,
-0.0958489701,
0.053971801,
0.3643441796,
-0.0021941077,
0.1447827667,
-0.843742907,
-0.179080382,
0.0235694367,
-0.3429269791,
0.0892212465,
-0.4255658984,
0.2234907746,
-0.0724936053,
0.5070577264,
0.2381567955,
0.2827052176,
0.0278592091,
-0.2149593681,
0.0122238966,
0.1761094183,
0.7965040207,
0.4640471637,
-0.4803511202,
0.2289453596,
0.0656048283,
-0.5924827456,
-0.0662293285,
-0.0468422361,
-0.6461107731,
-0.229654938,
0.0075721792,
1.0169398785,
0.7927367687,
-0.662435174,
0.1062793583,
-0.1415359825,
0.0713701472,
0.098795943,
0.2194004506,
0.5008643866,
0.1944240183,
0.1594621539,
-0.0203075707,
0.2430939823,
-0.5276017785,
0.2109307498,
0.4068601727,
-0.419429481,
-0.0912026539,
0.8045451045,
0.3811532855,
-0.2780632079,
0.4919936657,
0.1295741349,
-0.3147315979,
0.5512458682,
0.4458226562,
0.6545050144,
-0.19350034,
-0.1816848367,
0.2926133275,
0.4072222114,
-0.0234794263,
0.3213022947,
-0.154215619,
-0.5229548216,
-0.2284817696,
-0.3673268557,
-0.1183041334,
0.3831323087,
-0.7283740044,
-0.1046255678,
-0.7239925265,
-0.0337486826,
0.0819992051,
0.073332198,
-0.5601314902,
0.1023706496,
0.3568895161,
0.9042503834,
-0.5570827723,
1.0901533365,
0.3662136495,
-0.3710412681,
-0.4107698202,
-0.060308028,
-0.06216041,
-0.7742579579,
0.4016736746,
0.3036468029,
-0.2738849223,
0.0441771001,
-0.3876689076,
-1.0980114937,
1.0753253698,
0.3296538591,
-0.7093117833,
0.0876748636,
-0.3809256852,
0.528049767,
-0.4008684158,
-0.161637336,
0.692569375,
0.011283908,
0.1782367229,
-0.7908940315,
-0.0970008746,
-0.0592602938,
0.207381174,
0.491320312,
-0.7528840899,
0.8129404187,
-0.3246642649,
-0.2620574236,
0.105909355,
0.7825993299,
0.2693711519,
0.3088636696,
0.3203143179,
0.8661453724,
0.6342484951,
0.2164217532,
1.1434260607,
-0.0516211316,
0.3615295887,
1.2305166721,
-0.3411884308,
1.0882737637,
0.5889512897,
-0.0488540716,
0.196885705,
0.1854003668,
0.3716281652,
0.7697253823,
0.0682217032,
-0.1327716112,
-0.413593173,
0.1911232471,
-0.022266075,
0.2417188734,
0.4735155404,
-0.3555923402,
-0.2253974229,
-0.0771140531,
0.0603543408,
0.1143510491,
-0.4183165431,
0.686907649,
0.1295282543,
-0.7436034679,
0.5025547743,
-0.1059623286,
0.5050439835,
-0.5963644981,
0.1275645047,
-0.4929083288,
0.6342179775,
0.3651958704,
-0.4459100962,
0.0547722206,
-0.0317232534,
-0.6833099127,
-0.1420630515,
0.8047505021,
-0.6818964481,
-0.3853248954,
0.3570134342,
0.0539227761,
0.0686770827,
0.195017755,
-0.5579671264,
0.1628019065,
0.2236775607,
-0.2859221995,
0.4819919169,
0.0904755294,
0.0290586986,
0.8426221013,
0.2620004117,
-0.007667697,
0.323237896,
-0.1326487511,
0.6989585161,
-0.6986088753,
-0.6193720102,
-0.6829164624,
0.3285429776,
-0.0612396188,
-0.213438049,
0.4904227555,
0.5304487944,
0.4597987533,
-0.1854084134,
0.6210923791,
0.1561102569,
0.652936697,
-0.6136492491,
0.5733698606,
-0.6501950622,
0.1764995903,
-0.0638113096,
-0.6768028736,
-0.0004746207,
0.6291884184,
-0.2658866346,
-0.0553510636,
0.4890423715,
0.6986752152,
-0.2747149467,
-0.3557060957,
0.5705768466,
0.465116173,
0.112533696,
1.2795211077,
0.4734498858,
-0.4422808588,
0.6422208548,
0.1035266072,
-0.2447873801,
-0.5821560025,
-0.6694900393,
-0.8404356837,
-0.2954007685,
-0.0843377113,
-0.1853115112,
0.1866844594,
0.5187647939,
0.6931570172,
-0.6234427094,
-0.2407426089,
-0.0170596372,
0.0688251555,
-0.1973247677,
-0.2131525278,
0.3197107911,
-0.4226882458,
-0.6015856266,
0.3122065067,
0.7808306217,
-0.0278946813,
-0.369643867,
-0.0660243779,
-0.3781818151,
0.4919758439,
0.7587490678,
0.7359913588,
-0.9520122409,
-0.2621826828,
0.1174535006,
-0.4413858056,
0.0552707165,
0.8683582544,
-0.835665226,
0.6039748788,
0.527860105,
0.6374736428,
0.9659508467,
-0.1804994494,
0.7800827622,
-0.6835885644,
0.3929786384,
-0.0081833163,
0.3493943512,
0.1921412051,
-0.2695407569,
0.2844153047,
0.1224276498,
-0.434392184,
-0.5442885756,
0.249275893,
-0.9364469647,
-0.4249980748,
0.9976893067,
-0.247748524,
-0.1823929548,
-0.0397635251,
-0.2885299325,
-0.2462770194,
-0.414208591,
0.8925362825,
0.8127958179,
0.0417069905,
-0.4456212223,
-0.6008402109,
0.398027122,
0.6849497557,
-0.4714631438,
0.3146162331,
0.4261525273,
0.265630424,
0.2675889134,
0.9186578989,
0.1396045536,
0.5440295935,
0.0913763344,
0.1671261489,
0.2245677114,
-0.6238954663,
-0.3951963782,
0.1744199842,
-0.0559423082,
-0.1378393918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18667v1
|
FOFO: A Benchmark to Evaluate LLMs' Format-Following Capability
| 2024-02-28T19:23:27 | 2024-02-28T19:23:27 |
Congying Xia, Chen Xing, Jiangshu Du, Xinyi Yang, Yihao Feng, Ran Xu, Wenpeng Yin, Caiming Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents FoFo, a pioneering benchmark for evaluating large
language models' (LLMs) ability to follow complex, domain-specific formats, a
crucial yet underexamined capability for their application as AI agents.
Despite LLMs' advancements, existing benchmarks fail to assess their
format-following proficiency adequately. FoFo fills this gap with a diverse
range of real-world formats and instructions, developed through an AI-Human
collaborative method. Our evaluation across both open-source (e.g., Llama 2,
WizardLM) and closed-source (e.g., GPT-4, PALM2, Gemini) LLMs highlights three
key findings: open-source models significantly lag behind closed-source ones in
format adherence; LLMs' format-following performance is independent of their
content generation quality; and LLMs' format proficiency varies across
different domains. These insights suggest the need for specialized tuning for
format-following skills and highlight FoFo's role in guiding the selection of
domain-specific AI agents. FoFo is released here at
https://github.com/SalesforceAIResearch/FoFo.
|
[
-0.1502747536,
-0.4324869215,
0.5037292838,
0.5523606539,
-0.0398451202,
0.1047262102,
-0.3827232718,
-0.4481876194,
-0.1556984931,
0.565197885,
-0.5451043844,
-0.6251360178,
-0.6083692312,
0.4083675742,
-0.2698142827,
0.6446020603,
-0.3476890922,
-0.1731654555,
-0.5196268559,
-0.1722238064,
-0.4938623905,
-0.2348822206,
-0.354293853,
-0.4068135023,
0.3033781946,
0.394741416,
0.9007895589,
0.9134643674,
0.5562378168,
0.3463190496,
0.1858305931,
0.3766828775,
-0.6072669625,
0.1229207963,
0.0437317602,
-0.4535726309,
-0.8274480104,
0.1988934427,
0.9307576418,
0.5829043984,
-0.1592157036,
-0.1512389034,
-0.2505543828,
0.7225415707,
-0.6161669493,
0.2821790278,
-0.6932727695,
0.073417902,
-0.0630540028,
0.0671475381,
-0.5321494341,
-0.4736920595,
0.1322202235,
-1.0212948322,
-0.0913586691,
0.184300229,
0.4731589556,
0.4682514369,
-0.3014277518,
-0.3662702739,
-0.7132074237,
0.6399370432,
-0.6625993252,
0.7437217236,
0.527309835,
0.4191663563,
-0.2590101361,
-0.841892004,
-0.5834231973,
-0.4495058656,
0.2279030085,
-0.1617699564,
-0.0821758211,
-0.0499646626,
0.1771111637,
0.5301216245,
-0.4458288848,
0.0435222462,
-0.2115299255,
-0.1992826909,
0.8742079139,
0.1524800658,
0.0667923763,
0.5823527575,
-0.5382088423,
-0.2214792669,
-0.7181213498,
-0.0639957413,
0.3626908958,
0.0433102958,
-0.2132663578,
0.5134900808,
-0.4869502485,
0.6200371981,
-0.2310477346,
-0.1505176574,
0.4034604728,
-0.2741996646,
-0.3364133835,
-0.1418268532,
0.6879711747,
0.4479908347,
0.5209600329,
-0.4378474951,
-0.6165471077,
-0.4265319407,
0.3232284486,
-0.8358789682,
0.0299591105,
0.1758078039,
-0.469617039,
-0.079883337,
0.2910618782,
-0.3962785602,
-0.4354661405,
-0.2406794578,
0.3649884462,
-0.5274142027,
-0.1578232199,
-0.1057336107,
-0.0309020001,
0.4002222717,
0.5513964891,
-0.8558081388,
0.2776101232,
1.1279170513,
0.9519156814,
-0.4764279425,
-0.722425282,
-0.8726644516,
-0.0153352078,
-0.4375911355,
0.8371573687,
-0.6644195318,
-0.3820622861,
0.103084445,
-0.0754943117,
0.0903170854,
-0.7618588805,
0.315910697,
-0.4531053901,
-0.2079664171,
-0.0171996318,
-0.6403343081,
-0.0975778699,
0.2767068148,
-0.7508956194,
0.825450182,
0.4321089089,
-0.1150384024,
0.3260861635,
-0.3997362256,
-0.436168611,
0.0217678435,
-0.2389266044,
-0.1432693601,
0.0585017055,
-0.1965883076,
0.3846318126,
-0.5539901257,
0.2286672145,
-0.2874783278,
-0.66463238,
0.1259988993,
-0.3680294454,
0.293545723,
0.1465720236,
-0.1485665888,
0.5124915838,
-0.9239259958,
-0.1296769977,
0.2324564904,
-0.2910411358,
-0.2101449221,
0.1862131208,
-0.1004882976,
0.1099839732,
0.2406970114,
-0.4358485639,
0.3465055823,
-0.1446118355,
0.3174311221,
0.7744576931,
-0.4445233941,
0.4478610754,
-0.5031192303,
0.6281712055,
-0.4815553427,
0.179021582,
-0.2893480361,
-0.4746243954,
-0.3330551088,
-0.3560452163,
0.2114877254,
0.5392331481,
-0.571400106,
0.3145251274,
-0.1642570794,
-0.8256282806,
-0.5254884362,
0.4190582335,
0.4118793905,
0.4119620025,
0.2940400839,
-0.4170603454,
-0.2176445276,
-0.6414504051,
-0.0855302811,
-0.0998718664,
-0.2033518851,
0.2691784203,
0.4011654258,
-0.4266651273,
0.7553679347,
-0.3915088475,
-0.2889450192,
0.0972274989,
0.039219182,
-0.0503337681,
0.2583418489,
0.6585400105,
-0.7978813648,
-0.4843193591,
0.1126599461,
-0.7297823429,
-0.1579253525,
0.1621915698,
-0.0377252661,
0.452334106,
0.6831464171,
-0.3275745213,
0.2306495309,
0.649884522,
-0.3719329238,
0.5158441067,
-0.203679651,
0.1523682028,
-0.6082597971,
0.2742757201,
-0.2180332989,
-0.1443904042,
-0.5831089616,
-0.0115624638,
-0.0212445986,
0.1639072597,
-0.5038334131,
0.7424322963,
-0.5005488396,
-0.401666373,
-0.21193479,
0.1588389724,
-0.0015222856,
0.2090680152,
0.1363859475,
1.1041288376,
0.2532306612,
-0.3182755709,
0.2327662855,
0.2693651319,
-0.2885860205,
0.3937380314,
-0.7163314223,
0.4139940739,
0.1903361082,
0.077954486,
-0.9779150486,
-0.0572990142,
0.0457536913,
-0.1429184079,
0.2013379335,
-0.1148699075,
-0.7895483971,
0.0826830789,
-0.4782328308,
0.3067114353,
0.3459315598,
-0.1379813403,
0.7106645107,
-0.0113694668,
-0.0286636818,
-0.5923408866,
-0.3650074899,
-0.2269851416,
0.0660366565,
-0.8196628094,
0.3884019852,
-0.3799394369,
-0.4791338444,
-0.3314652145,
-0.3083425164,
0.1427448541,
0.3631492555,
0.2945908904,
0.0785468146,
-0.5781893134,
-0.297336936,
0.0028106167,
0.1400281191,
0.1041495278,
-0.0226915497,
0.5260801315,
-0.3081364036,
-0.189781636,
-0.3554125428,
0.2772833109,
0.5586998463,
-0.4204054475,
0.6650179625,
0.3544454277,
-0.2056627572,
-0.3402261138,
-0.3812529445,
-0.0353719406,
-0.4948782027,
0.0587294549,
-0.3059048057,
-0.7083692551,
0.4993685782,
-0.0437658913,
0.1504518986,
0.3627610207,
0.4455190897,
0.0883714333,
0.5730882287,
0.7833909392,
0.0151153654,
0.7369651794,
-0.1530452669,
-0.3131325245,
-0.5588240623,
-0.3174152374,
-0.3851478994,
-0.0692208484,
-0.5017458797,
-0.5864928365,
0.0397643372,
0.1722835004,
-0.1517257094,
0.0636376292,
-0.1866021901,
0.340601176,
0.4123308659,
-0.4512557387,
0.6132323146,
-0.1367990971,
-0.0682397336,
0.3572714925,
-0.348620683,
-0.6834922433,
1.1026822329,
0.561938405,
0.6803976297,
0.1900023669,
0.4833105206,
0.7362374067,
0.82172966,
-0.8093400002,
0.5400166512,
-0.2743857205,
-0.0990212038,
-0.3669929206,
-0.1421723217,
-0.7996097803,
0.2022243589,
-0.122236006,
-0.5611890554,
-0.1721502542,
0.0056575001,
-0.1530483365,
0.0685296878,
-0.5372061133,
0.8388134241,
-0.1042729914,
-0.1881633103,
0.0454032533,
-0.7154964209,
0.1103372574,
-0.1246906742,
0.0142641906,
-0.3191080391,
-0.3835655153,
0.6604633331,
-0.5911616683,
0.5565665364,
-0.0441077352,
-0.3707432747,
0.3603230417,
0.127185449,
0.3043590188,
-0.1145963222,
-0.3823442459,
0.3540097177,
-0.1484841108,
-0.159167707,
-0.5300447941,
0.6057363153,
-0.912057519,
-0.5576214194,
-0.3446638286,
-0.5755354762,
-0.4540028274,
0.4569658637,
-0.0146371918,
0.1478317231,
-0.4491507411,
0.3448613286,
0.5754798055,
0.2793981433,
0.3937889338,
0.5882363915,
-0.1695078313,
-0.6798033714,
0.7467902303,
-0.0642323121,
0.3870494366,
0.548289597,
0.1504464597,
-0.2374835014,
-0.8744390011,
-0.5854768157,
0.4641440511,
-0.63863796,
-0.2597610056,
-0.2436440736,
-0.0973007977,
-0.410568893,
-0.2465005666,
-0.3510022163,
-0.0631857365,
-0.3719024658,
0.2228479534,
0.3467465639,
0.8721987009,
0.3217239976,
0.3559229076,
-0.8850628138,
0.1259413809,
0.0215332378,
0.7011844516,
0.0485566854,
-0.4106246531,
-0.0549567752,
-0.1280605495,
-0.3916677237,
-0.6903293133,
-0.0441268571,
0.2137609869,
0.8021860123,
0.4841385186,
-0.0044563622,
0.3430038989,
-0.5378433466,
0.5566974282,
-0.2165101767,
-0.9952225685,
0.5575814843,
-0.4686325788,
0.1030299291,
0.6016728282,
0.5354636312,
-0.4861115217,
-0.1603756398,
-0.2986121774,
-0.6984319687,
0.9325165749,
0.3239271939,
-0.148681134,
0.0828712806,
0.4247671962,
0.4689544141,
0.5358864665,
-0.1319507658,
-0.26734519,
-0.2974506915,
-0.1333266944,
-0.2223567516,
0.0956341997,
-0.0075842808,
0.2603140473,
0.3966032565,
-0.4667747319,
0.204328537,
0.2858850658,
-0.2120716423,
-0.2069747448,
-0.0747665614,
1.0528490543,
0.7263537645,
-0.5001176,
-0.3161833882,
-0.2016455233,
-0.6113524437,
-0.0536938533,
0.4891350567,
-0.1433148533,
-0.2666411698,
0.606254518,
0.6706763506,
-0.1219664812,
-1.030523181,
0.4617187977,
-0.1076832488,
-0.2614407539,
-0.3939070702,
0.4417610466,
-0.0873918757,
0.3638494015,
0.6318492293,
-0.1737634838,
-0.0169654004,
-0.8058436513,
0.1743176132,
0.2866329551,
-0.340308547,
-0.3688569963,
0.6973493099,
0.3023397326,
-0.7238058448,
0.7190074921,
-0.0084953513,
-0.0616249964,
0.8118489385,
0.4650196135,
0.7661079764,
-0.2253268659,
-0.0634298921,
-0.2634214461,
0.2962234616,
-0.2669485211,
0.5354759693,
-0.2213493586,
-0.6038624644,
-0.2399362922,
-0.3668959439,
-0.667096436,
0.1604084224,
-0.5327812433,
0.2951663136,
-0.7831780314,
0.1225721091,
0.0389384404,
0.1914983541,
-0.6794964671,
0.1779448241,
0.3017799854,
1.5808194876,
-0.6746903658,
0.8273841143,
0.8718230128,
-0.4159052074,
-0.4785571992,
0.2980046868,
0.1962025911,
-0.6886669993,
0.2519833446,
0.4465526938,
-0.3618052602,
-0.1225448921,
-0.4931463897,
-0.7607370615,
1.5869950056,
0.3222581148,
-0.5022269487,
0.0198774189,
0.1386619955,
0.6403021216,
-0.8653597236,
0.3063971996,
0.5412151814,
0.4643009305,
0.1155163646,
-1.0244570971,
0.3010903597,
-0.0996828154,
-0.0091042006,
0.1433665156,
-1.0883040428,
0.5803126097,
-0.1975577176,
0.1278978288,
0.5127814412,
0.9239937663,
0.3001024127,
0.804279387,
0.5796367526,
0.0439517573,
0.6908016205,
-0.024912253,
0.9596505761,
-0.0893093646,
-0.0126387337,
1.0140842199,
-0.6756024957,
1.1183217764,
0.3659631312,
-0.043684449,
0.4165145755,
0.2989644706,
-0.1545458436,
0.5704930425,
0.1877599061,
0.1562822461,
0.0619120523,
-0.0692935809,
-0.3097311854,
0.5580130816,
0.2467597723,
-0.3361438513,
0.1456117332,
-0.313706398,
0.1476147622,
0.3059229851,
-0.2012478858,
0.7528973818,
-0.0405732729,
-0.8777436614,
0.6427438855,
-0.083732225,
0.5237573385,
-0.802251935,
-0.2372636944,
-0.5710221529,
0.0752369538,
-0.080099076,
-0.9616069198,
0.4164218605,
-0.0838098228,
-0.1747565717,
-0.1971587539,
0.3510822058,
-0.1238484308,
-0.0156668853,
0.5267741084,
0.4556499124,
0.0679332614,
-0.2244001031,
-0.3912859559,
0.5106055737,
-0.0824387968,
-0.3097814023,
0.3170655966,
0.5434221625,
-0.4421869218,
0.6342955232,
0.5888363123,
-0.1843320131,
-0.2169768512,
0.0815276057,
0.6803401113,
-0.6272620559,
-0.1370631009,
-0.6567954421,
0.3011507988,
0.0751637071,
-0.5621408224,
0.561357379,
0.5748945475,
1.119715333,
-0.0287830234,
0.4916974902,
0.1189318001,
-0.0800703168,
-0.5308746696,
0.7923837304,
-0.7613992691,
0.1811291575,
-0.2129220217,
-1.0050033331,
-0.2380382866,
0.3139022887,
-0.2276337296,
0.0980284438,
0.3755733073,
0.5692826509,
0.0333639905,
0.1005967483,
0.4352016151,
0.1880861074,
0.2060709,
0.1589202881,
0.8452884555,
-0.2866560221,
0.6025688052,
-0.1790642887,
-0.2985468209,
-0.5367535949,
-1.1031987667,
-0.8594229817,
-0.6575858593,
-0.1800405681,
-0.1340601295,
0.0224538613,
1.0274410248,
0.7363838553,
-0.6309922934,
-0.1822008491,
0.2512216568,
0.2394406348,
-0.5372809172,
-0.1518706381,
-0.0060138735,
0.0751064047,
-0.7963967323,
0.592502892,
0.2103746384,
0.0460940227,
-0.2643346786,
-0.236047864,
-0.0928775519,
0.2165130079,
0.7440295219,
0.3908014596,
-0.8840790391,
-0.1516288519,
0.3374620378,
-0.1315157861,
0.304736644,
0.9478401542,
-0.509308815,
0.2052085698,
0.5675840974,
0.6172864437,
0.2004285902,
0.134031713,
0.7560236454,
-0.7035856843,
-0.0595430583,
0.1836227477,
0.2281915843,
0.4341436028,
-0.3720575273,
0.7347942591,
0.1613664478,
-0.5423276424,
-0.7932881713,
-0.0680581927,
-1.0189124346,
-0.0919008628,
1.2222498655,
-0.3341673017,
-0.0582836568,
0.1172620431,
-0.0226589795,
0.0115366112,
-0.8380448818,
0.4514397383,
0.5905876756,
-0.1881948262,
0.0200252049,
-0.6233371496,
0.3640314639,
0.1091403812,
-0.7361095548,
0.1187866479,
0.5130476356,
0.4952858686,
0.1575433314,
0.8575616479,
0.1642204076,
0.326569885,
0.0268259645,
-0.0182004571,
-0.4840469956,
-0.627720654,
-0.4172429144,
-0.0474727899,
0.370670408,
-0.0560887046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18659v1
|
Large Language Models and Games: A Survey and Roadmap
| 2024-02-28T19:09:08 | 2024-02-28T19:09:08 |
Roberto Gallotta, Graham Todd, Marvin Zammit, Sam Earle, Antonios Liapis, Julian Togelius, Georgios N. Yannakakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Recent years have seen an explosive increase in research on large language
models (LLMs), and accompanying public engagement on the topic. While starting
as a niche area within natural language processing, LLMs have shown remarkable
potential across a broad range of applications and domains, including games.
This paper surveys the current state of the art across the various applications
of LLMs in and for games, and identifies the different roles LLMs can take
within a game. Importantly, we discuss underexplored areas and promising
directions for future uses of LLMs in games and we reconcile the potential and
limitations of LLMs within the games domain. As the first comprehensive survey
and roadmap at the intersection of LLMs and games, we are hopeful that this
paper will serve as the basis for groundbreaking research and innovation in
this exciting new field.
|
[
-0.462856859,
-0.7349539995,
0.7837098241,
0.1761381924,
-0.0432278812,
0.283567369,
-0.3819413483,
-0.6335226893,
0.2327029109,
0.7773638964,
-0.5392200351,
-0.5981751084,
-0.8655834794,
-0.0471460335,
-0.5431776643,
0.4949775636,
-0.0548227839,
0.0920747519,
-0.539970696,
-0.0277223848,
-0.3888504207,
-0.8534407616,
-0.7150348425,
-0.4408026338,
0.5913981199,
0.1564858258,
0.5616172552,
0.5428464413,
0.6752095819,
0.39655599,
-0.3561142981,
0.0563855842,
-0.7358592153,
0.491108954,
-0.0217843447,
-0.4894093871,
-0.469606787,
0.085886769,
0.7624344826,
0.71864748,
-0.0486975349,
0.1779315621,
0.010062051,
0.3776315749,
-0.3820828795,
0.2492518127,
-0.2794732749,
0.1637271941,
-0.4793221951,
-0.1709243804,
-0.1331898123,
-0.221084401,
0.1745260209,
-0.4549741149,
-0.2631132603,
0.0597674735,
0.3833515942,
-0.1267010719,
-0.3867549896,
-0.6349214315,
-0.9496517777,
0.9216393828,
-0.918939352,
0.4577115774,
0.0716765001,
0.2034479529,
-0.5829564929,
-0.5463975072,
-0.3605023921,
-0.1571288258,
0.4420835972,
-0.0933120251,
-0.4636850655,
0.1964571923,
0.2625389397,
0.3406687379,
-0.3136054873,
0.6929500699,
-0.1563119292,
0.1288853437,
0.8610439301,
0.5308580399,
0.3686456978,
0.3078140318,
-0.3902307749,
0.4058804512,
-1.0651830435,
0.0116402665,
0.2118279487,
0.1795405,
-0.0720676258,
0.7691619992,
0.0048449025,
0.8299102187,
-0.2000982165,
-0.2683773041,
-0.1274368614,
-0.1267602742,
-0.1042272225,
-0.2049301416,
0.9086862803,
0.4930990338,
0.1384178251,
-0.2524537742,
-0.2866954803,
-0.004996486,
-0.1323891729,
-0.6549354196,
0.1977610439,
0.306677103,
-0.4479088783,
-0.0613148548,
-0.2169819474,
-0.9870658517,
-0.9443050623,
-0.1592827737,
0.0337800086,
0.1540546268,
-0.5115664005,
0.3227627277,
-0.0860535055,
0.4231579304,
0.1745489687,
-0.9766358137,
0.4534808993,
0.9565160275,
0.9366388321,
-0.3662091494,
-0.1536705345,
-0.2241511196,
0.2486722767,
-0.4677348733,
0.7142860889,
-0.5849105716,
-0.7031010985,
0.4820492566,
-0.1777369529,
0.4949843287,
-0.6624209285,
0.3732637465,
-0.5381941795,
0.0069399667,
-0.3469157815,
-0.8364991546,
0.0219084583,
0.7015013695,
-0.6981301308,
0.5712994337,
-0.2929004133,
-0.458091557,
0.1142285541,
-0.8427135944,
-0.5177794099,
0.226583302,
-0.1418897957,
-0.1523719728,
0.4276769161,
0.0072029331,
0.4875071943,
-0.7395643592,
0.1748552769,
-0.4492741525,
-0.4920464754,
0.2901988029,
-0.1991241872,
0.6133314371,
0.0460024215,
-0.0741488412,
0.1859663874,
-0.2906461954,
-0.1088465452,
0.1907083541,
-0.422776252,
-0.2074826211,
0.6687788963,
-0.060785789,
0.3805103004,
0.3294686675,
-0.4184669256,
0.3753142655,
-0.3187305331,
0.7245425582,
0.4391210973,
-0.0543040633,
0.4372888505,
-0.0748565197,
0.709746182,
-0.1939927042,
0.2084453106,
-0.0508411787,
-0.6262258887,
-0.4255478084,
-0.1290979683,
0.3333562911,
0.3180472851,
-0.5507226586,
0.3460493386,
-0.2273910195,
-0.5610292554,
-0.169920817,
-0.0313109197,
-0.0850484073,
-0.1075090393,
-0.0882776007,
-0.3412602246,
-0.642919004,
-0.5955507755,
-0.1920302212,
-0.3316327035,
0.1256392449,
0.471965611,
0.2380418777,
-0.3459186256,
0.9140654802,
-0.326156348,
-0.439884156,
-0.5505584478,
-0.0008690917,
0.1667933911,
0.1158750653,
0.369391799,
-0.7607992291,
-0.1979322881,
-0.2881520092,
-0.6751918793,
-0.1528940946,
0.2776343822,
0.1344655603,
-0.221091032,
0.7520946264,
-0.7932819128,
0.0404988974,
0.9637631774,
-0.2365452498,
0.41925928,
0.0323664695,
0.3293423653,
-0.8331752419,
-0.1706697792,
-0.0275525693,
0.0512519814,
-0.9011303782,
0.2425174564,
-0.3758734167,
-0.04844236,
-0.387090385,
0.7198139429,
-0.845946908,
-0.3649435341,
-0.5297552347,
0.4797585011,
-0.3183372617,
-0.1595462859,
0.2021149546,
0.5374872088,
0.82081604,
-0.5986457467,
0.7125310898,
0.2116280049,
-0.5072357655,
0.3077961802,
-0.706531167,
-0.1107363552,
0.0376701765,
0.2455615401,
-0.9606190324,
-0.1084964499,
0.1043218076,
-0.2366611958,
0.072211206,
-0.1749455333,
-0.7456522584,
-0.7062031031,
-0.1605227739,
0.2910814285,
0.6007144451,
-0.239175275,
0.4806891978,
1.2323006392,
-0.2972868085,
-0.2229496986,
-0.6858659387,
0.4489456117,
-0.4772574902,
-0.5252812505,
0.1304031312,
-0.089446798,
-0.4446516931,
-0.3180243075,
0.1670052558,
-0.1670607179,
0.3053752482,
0.2861247063,
0.0770053193,
-0.420658052,
0.0405317135,
-0.4240284562,
0.0888120532,
0.3069757819,
-0.2062081099,
0.6948955059,
0.0916858315,
-0.3363745809,
0.2945465446,
0.4158868194,
0.4983680844,
-0.2655701339,
0.3489008844,
0.0904526711,
-0.5229642987,
0.0184152313,
-0.540892601,
0.1441209316,
-0.4739772081,
0.7183404565,
-0.1107506901,
-1.4013992548,
0.5741691589,
-0.5355499387,
0.2285910249,
0.2572155595,
0.8464246988,
0.0023536123,
1.0862613916,
0.8850122094,
-0.305020541,
0.354192853,
-0.0261660796,
0.3009591997,
-0.8832722902,
-0.1728966087,
-0.5626903772,
-0.461316973,
-0.5236106515,
-0.6884483695,
0.2046184689,
-0.0192432329,
-0.0563639328,
0.0397781059,
-0.0153518785,
0.6911880374,
0.1713310778,
-0.4031147957,
0.1893608421,
-0.2584343851,
0.2665543556,
-0.1654987484,
-0.846411109,
-0.5081918836,
0.8214227557,
0.5161392689,
0.6932826638,
0.2547455132,
0.6752172112,
0.1475685388,
0.3430044651,
-0.7786319852,
0.8189453483,
-0.1775112599,
-0.9745901227,
-0.5846765041,
-0.4100773036,
-1.0544638634,
0.2585692704,
-0.3199645877,
-0.7574797869,
-0.2120192349,
-0.0811017454,
-0.3760185838,
0.6915620565,
-0.4058719277,
0.7909839153,
-0.2647353411,
-0.3529291153,
-0.0543915108,
-0.2438310236,
0.6324251294,
0.1494296342,
0.4813933969,
-0.2443342656,
-0.2274163067,
0.7593820095,
0.2198747396,
0.7071430087,
-0.0863457844,
-0.6042749882,
0.4311023057,
0.1508855075,
0.3303815424,
-0.0752244368,
0.0544337593,
0.3314703405,
-0.0884752199,
-0.1573066711,
-0.1579423994,
0.9759424329,
-0.5265932679,
-0.7366380692,
-0.7235761285,
-0.6096624732,
-0.7246000171,
0.2699652016,
-0.1714469194,
0.1842635572,
-0.6750944257,
0.1932211369,
0.7650896907,
-0.4171549082,
0.4944740236,
0.5346506834,
-0.4847458601,
0.007007618,
0.8539617658,
-0.0843979046,
0.1774599701,
0.3207382858,
0.1280010343,
-0.4309982657,
-1.0815569162,
-0.1046376824,
0.194810003,
-0.4386085272,
-0.0402537547,
-0.2783820331,
-0.1895582378,
-0.3215933442,
-0.0638152808,
-0.3240335584,
0.0425147712,
-0.3186395168,
0.0988887623,
0.0998727381,
1.3146698475,
-0.0895899236,
0.3503516912,
-0.8029058576,
0.2653361857,
0.2513122559,
0.6406185627,
0.0210243687,
-0.1813418418,
-0.1049984545,
0.0846208557,
-0.0006133111,
-0.7162098885,
0.3792502582,
-0.1215515882,
0.7228341699,
0.3390626609,
-0.4103049934,
0.5904871225,
-0.8900693655,
1.2255160809,
0.5366638899,
-0.6724262834,
0.0328182504,
-0.4830650091,
0.3749806583,
0.1311750561,
0.4525176883,
-0.983805716,
-0.2873469889,
-0.3771176338,
-0.7479049563,
0.6949272156,
-0.1816298813,
0.2506161928,
-0.0175312012,
-0.0375159718,
-0.0477090441,
0.3605881631,
-0.5420301557,
-0.1765516847,
0.6103060842,
-0.0124140717,
-0.4283717573,
-0.4609819949,
-0.2174092233,
0.1159255728,
0.4448071718,
0.1501529664,
0.3302008808,
-0.5002569556,
0.0606694184,
-0.316547215,
0.2222128659,
0.5230112076,
0.7271540761,
0.1469767541,
0.0341933332,
0.1715227962,
-0.4014521837,
0.1481149346,
-0.0032049294,
-0.2218514532,
-0.1406016052,
0.3853527904,
0.5195857286,
0.4596102536,
-0.8938325644,
0.4506377876,
0.0406551361,
-0.2739172578,
-0.1152087599,
-0.0066046664,
0.5629461408,
0.581838429,
0.1628281623,
-0.5414840579,
0.1084951907,
-0.772867918,
-0.0356764011,
0.7452799082,
-0.3677537441,
-0.0972418562,
0.590108037,
0.3780430555,
-0.4493186474,
0.1977978498,
0.0317485705,
-0.4356721938,
0.4480631649,
0.4703094661,
0.70422405,
0.0878720582,
0.1346920133,
0.042969998,
0.2421032339,
-0.1570220739,
0.2049997151,
0.4414074421,
-0.6300574541,
-0.5163645744,
-0.5109478235,
-0.5305171609,
0.3449015319,
-0.1047202051,
0.1495264173,
-0.39618209,
-0.3529510498,
-0.2111107558,
0.2672372758,
-0.3481554985,
-0.1032153293,
0.8958684206,
0.8663429618,
-0.4866168797,
0.4404083788,
0.5159777403,
-0.2486811429,
-0.219975397,
-0.0690852925,
0.0068785017,
-0.5942872167,
0.4831783772,
-0.3991760612,
-0.0957865044,
-0.0692756474,
-0.7175190449,
-0.9834655523,
0.9369440079,
0.1623702943,
-0.8277693391,
-0.3367815912,
0.4857749641,
0.470322758,
-0.4574690759,
0.1248040795,
0.6151375771,
0.3559845686,
0.1864126027,
-0.645034194,
-0.3159479201,
0.1358104199,
0.1534126699,
0.2767964005,
-0.7050200105,
0.7003722191,
-0.0795250908,
-0.1868844926,
0.4555433989,
0.8510785699,
0.3324276805,
0.0274016149,
0.3271757364,
0.2536222041,
0.3294332623,
-0.3794366717,
0.8217797279,
-0.122498177,
0.2209739536,
0.7094522119,
-0.7476166487,
0.7393246293,
0.418661952,
-0.421554178,
0.1692882031,
0.5641772151,
0.0579071455,
0.2422952205,
0.6639865637,
-0.2060112506,
-0.3006371856,
-0.0017372736,
-0.3195925057,
0.34594208,
0.7181604505,
-0.1266426593,
-0.6003441811,
-0.1727937013,
-0.0689592734,
0.0568220057,
-0.6339649558,
0.6418175697,
0.1933452189,
-0.4421685934,
0.0317409076,
0.1817025542,
0.8785592914,
-0.8690130711,
-0.0813703984,
-0.1189151332,
0.1442076117,
0.1834579408,
-1.0810843706,
-0.1371182203,
0.1582222432,
0.054318808,
-0.2837919891,
0.7680253386,
-0.5054477453,
-0.284347415,
0.3969351351,
0.6265371442,
0.1254520714,
0.0523996763,
-0.719842732,
0.6468462944,
-0.3476858437,
-0.221853137,
0.5017511845,
0.6903611422,
0.1395545304,
0.6389765143,
0.4067349136,
0.3919357955,
0.2413426787,
-0.0192026719,
0.6006721854,
-0.8015783429,
-0.4048213065,
-0.7375341654,
0.1551281363,
-0.0564728677,
-0.5726494193,
0.9382697344,
0.654109776,
0.5542336702,
-0.037297748,
0.8574979305,
-0.0763558894,
0.4025051594,
-0.387926966,
0.718360424,
-0.320646137,
0.0333077796,
-0.3118670583,
-0.834980011,
-0.3408540785,
0.2700381875,
-0.3436292112,
-0.0143170357,
0.1999311447,
0.4984765053,
0.0097765764,
0.1562811434,
0.6336096525,
0.2576723695,
0.4855228961,
0.7384358048,
1.2763940096,
-0.1103920564,
0.1383851916,
0.2613943815,
-0.1595611423,
-0.3525575697,
-0.8707194328,
-1.0529597998,
-0.5912664533,
-0.1655861437,
-0.1234818175,
0.0346767157,
0.8261086345,
0.572152257,
-0.670386374,
-0.823707521,
0.1525187939,
0.1902117133,
-0.0106943334,
-0.065256238,
-0.1901886165,
0.0175822731,
-0.8897258639,
0.4818788767,
0.3538638651,
0.0201202072,
-0.7700018287,
-0.2019692808,
-0.4020811617,
0.3720565438,
0.9946679473,
0.6564677358,
-0.7955100536,
-0.0350930952,
0.1876061261,
-0.2101916373,
-0.1119567379,
1.0693136454,
-0.4174708426,
0.1409003586,
0.4562207758,
0.7953323126,
0.3515192866,
-0.4888659418,
0.7511382103,
-0.3112121224,
-0.0029158692,
0.4920317531,
0.3318048716,
0.4024662375,
0.101503998,
0.3948590457,
-0.0292609315,
-0.3351979256,
-1.0134904385,
0.3199479878,
-0.7747915387,
-0.1409965158,
1.4571062326,
0.1040239409,
-0.1941855252,
0.0731161982,
-0.0580256656,
0.0120056057,
0.0544791073,
0.5103363991,
1.2063564062,
-0.0729993284,
-0.065426968,
-0.5484954715,
0.4543612301,
-0.2286903709,
-0.7751292586,
0.3710275292,
0.6671493649,
-0.0615120903,
0.0578991324,
0.6527770758,
-0.2920539975,
-0.0363925323,
-0.1518032849,
0.0567749552,
0.0831584036,
-0.3120098412,
-0.3861910999,
0.2362363636,
0.3680115044,
0.1034165695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18571v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18571v3
|
Arithmetic Control of LLMs for Diverse User Preferences: Directional Preference Alignment with Multi-Objective Rewards
| 2024-02-28T18:58:25 | 2024-03-06T08:07:02 |
Haoxiang Wang, Yong Lin, Wei Xiong, Rui Yang, Shizhe Diao, Shuang Qiu, Han Zhao, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Fine-grained control over large language models (LLMs) remains a significant
challenge, hindering their adaptability to diverse user needs. While
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) shows promise in aligning
LLMs, its reliance on scalar rewards often limits its ability to capture
diverse user preferences in real-world applications. To address this
limitation, we introduce the Directional Preference Alignment (DPA) framework.
Unlike the scalar-reward RLHF, DPA incorporates multi-objective reward modeling
to represent diverse preference profiles. Additionally, DPA models user
preferences as directions (i.e., unit vectors) in the reward space to achieve
user-dependent preference control. Our method involves training a
multi-objective reward model and then fine-tuning the LLM with a
preference-conditioned variant of Rejection Sampling Finetuning (RSF), an RLHF
method adopted by Llama 2. This method enjoys a better performance trade-off
across various reward objectives. In comparison with the scalar-reward RLHF,
DPA offers users intuitive control over LLM generation: they can arithmetically
specify their desired trade-offs (e.g., more helpfulness with less verbosity).
We also validate the effectiveness of DPA with real-world alignment experiments
on Mistral-7B. Our method provides straightforward arithmetic control over the
trade-off between helpfulness and verbosity while maintaining competitive
performance with strong baselines such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO).
|
[
-0.4440742135,
-0.5061163902,
0.5042411089,
0.309481293,
-0.1068718657,
0.1556036174,
-0.2592937946,
-0.2345104516,
0.2555858791,
0.3445337713,
-0.689157486,
-0.4043245316,
-0.6922639012,
0.1846443117,
0.2511926591,
0.8486646414,
-0.1515329182,
0.0487210229,
-0.2281324416,
-0.373800993,
-0.5218135715,
-0.6162487864,
-0.5731570125,
-0.4888810217,
0.9415653348,
0.808095634,
0.7506167293,
0.6518908739,
0.616369009,
0.3367753923,
-0.0541138053,
0.4309158623,
-0.632645607,
0.0047460995,
-0.1514254808,
-0.508949995,
-0.5124515295,
-0.110007152,
0.4781841934,
0.4202187955,
-0.5885928869,
-0.0093787648,
-0.1423627883,
1.0751253366,
-0.6564352512,
0.055300612,
-0.5845925212,
0.0827119946,
-0.1456669867,
-0.3231708109,
-0.2786390185,
-0.5738531351,
-0.1259467453,
-0.6815564632,
-0.3694447577,
-0.0036969164,
0.5934493542,
0.5619169474,
-0.5084712505,
-0.4183939695,
-0.6353075504,
0.93390131,
-0.6553457975,
0.4547997117,
0.3270974755,
0.3036887646,
-0.2593339682,
-0.2010206282,
-0.5850130916,
-0.1810666621,
0.0468303934,
-0.0206056908,
0.0057294341,
0.1380971074,
0.0923788175,
0.0788997114,
-0.3767857254,
0.4695027471,
-0.3431006372,
-0.1724430919,
0.602553606,
0.3527572453,
0.1178699359,
0.028810069,
-0.4847091138,
-0.2051455379,
-0.8867799044,
0.5084770918,
0.5139276981,
0.3253730536,
-0.0988581032,
0.7727745771,
-0.4696746171,
0.7674011588,
0.60458076,
-0.5707603097,
0.3201808035,
-0.0380438268,
-0.0186888296,
0.1981746554,
0.7645197511,
0.4355067611,
0.220926255,
0.0135324616,
-0.4404097497,
0.1406889856,
0.2078988403,
-0.8669348359,
0.1615193784,
0.1360848546,
-0.2799040675,
-0.4396452308,
-0.138037622,
-0.5463095903,
-0.4524691105,
-0.7867266536,
0.2997477949,
-0.2367573678,
-0.016466001,
0.2382973433,
0.1370130926,
0.2116928995,
0.3559595942,
-1.5487266779,
0.2748857737,
0.8965964317,
0.6359910369,
-0.3552160561,
-0.4321031272,
-0.8641387224,
-0.0092058582,
-0.1275900602,
0.6431029439,
-0.6645314693,
-0.2742673755,
-0.1241933033,
-0.466326952,
0.042363964,
-0.6206858754,
0.4746744037,
-0.697681725,
0.1497241557,
-0.4596937895,
-0.3134307861,
-0.143792659,
0.3022392392,
-0.4368201792,
0.7940268517,
0.0004789293,
-0.5086711645,
0.4007061422,
-0.2620468438,
-0.2055680305,
-0.2680158317,
-0.3729463816,
-0.391091764,
0.2164297402,
0.2673463225,
0.2609743774,
0.0315317623,
0.3636757731,
-0.5153402686,
-0.3206480145,
0.394353807,
-0.3480839133,
0.4460165501,
0.2312424034,
-0.3730564713,
0.476485312,
-0.7946254015,
-0.1596092582,
-0.1085321456,
-0.5701124072,
-0.3104734123,
0.1229169443,
-0.296595782,
0.4059730768,
0.371306926,
-0.4000189006,
0.4236844778,
-0.294051975,
0.2331811935,
1.1222945452,
-0.3272178471,
0.6091716886,
-0.4206605256,
0.525380075,
0.0359845832,
0.0609765612,
0.3595557511,
-0.1729314029,
-0.6495445967,
-0.4665547609,
0.1171380281,
0.496632725,
-0.643348217,
0.5219863653,
-0.2278431654,
-0.1441254765,
-0.4544138312,
0.3833736479,
0.36971277,
0.5756224394,
0.2732530832,
-0.3182231486,
-0.2160454392,
-0.9156347513,
0.0470460616,
-0.1948277205,
0.0114549203,
0.5314384103,
-0.1188358888,
-0.1841712445,
0.8883438706,
-0.539346993,
-0.4665619731,
-0.2421397716,
0.1822816133,
0.1295997202,
0.243541196,
0.4210944474,
-0.7608149052,
-0.4359046817,
0.0013608853,
-0.3671483099,
-0.3808936179,
-0.116788201,
-0.2422792315,
0.226231724,
0.0322511569,
-0.5544175506,
0.0377357751,
0.7278302908,
-0.4462698698,
0.3701173067,
-0.1216796041,
0.2030834854,
-0.6725344062,
-0.0952062607,
0.0507540852,
-0.347099334,
-0.4523649216,
-0.1227801368,
0.2277368307,
0.2951135337,
-0.5778794885,
0.4858506918,
-0.1002376303,
-0.0833897293,
-0.4220863581,
-0.0506919175,
-0.068299897,
0.9202133417,
0.2532961071,
0.7995655537,
0.1735473275,
-0.6469349861,
0.264559716,
0.2565081418,
0.1063051894,
0.8000816703,
-0.628718257,
0.0140199373,
-0.1837494671,
0.2048777193,
-0.7682156563,
0.0077465717,
0.4642881155,
-0.3591225147,
0.3514020145,
-0.0045391368,
-0.0294133741,
0.1612826586,
-0.5294067264,
0.4393220246,
0.4129785597,
-0.7426071763,
0.6100477576,
0.378900677,
-0.3687013984,
-0.8736804128,
-0.2792354822,
-0.2148661017,
-0.4427134991,
-0.3588964939,
0.3470141888,
-0.21183002,
-0.31190449,
-0.3571387231,
-0.2156980634,
0.2593847215,
0.111978896,
0.378983438,
0.3929369748,
0.0984776542,
-0.0318978019,
0.2239236981,
-0.2977803349,
-0.0516277887,
-0.220129326,
0.4932177663,
-0.2083025575,
-0.4771922529,
-0.3826975226,
0.0443178006,
0.3935102224,
-0.3146315515,
0.3667623103,
0.5552831888,
0.0419406034,
-0.0521778017,
-0.5402767062,
-0.1968678981,
-0.5340039134,
0.3120793402,
-0.4250079691,
-0.9285415411,
0.2448722571,
0.136238426,
0.1962459534,
0.3011312783,
0.8127824664,
0.0121602546,
1.1475585699,
0.5365108252,
-0.2461865991,
0.6602377892,
0.0590314679,
-0.1607232541,
-0.7127045393,
-0.2497732043,
-0.471249193,
-0.6868886948,
-0.5267278552,
-0.2049735337,
0.2803068459,
0.1156558245,
-0.4673981369,
-0.058722917,
-0.49190256,
0.5043101311,
0.585513413,
0.1863670945,
0.3722574711,
0.1316216588,
-0.0272021685,
-0.1494998932,
-0.4796482921,
-0.3976098299,
0.9824213386,
0.4355665743,
1.1395144463,
0.3385391533,
0.9414302111,
0.1913750023,
0.2752628624,
-0.8826982379,
0.3594117463,
-0.2147015333,
-0.0505686291,
-0.4524148405,
-0.6416900754,
-0.6423338056,
0.3944059312,
-0.123511225,
-0.5717385411,
0.4190428853,
0.4435616732,
-0.4676316082,
0.1147468388,
-0.4974331856,
0.5260967016,
-0.6587322354,
-0.4895759821,
-0.3681482375,
-0.5950245261,
0.3226433992,
0.1544796228,
0.0885443985,
-0.4073411524,
-0.135797292,
0.462995708,
-0.2016655356,
0.888585031,
-0.2628598809,
-0.2564394772,
-0.1528849602,
0.101415664,
0.6846274734,
0.203189671,
-0.0623406917,
0.2350960523,
-0.2286996096,
-0.24615933,
-0.4719841182,
0.9299309254,
-1.0452767611,
-0.6454356909,
-0.5104600191,
-0.5962059498,
-0.3300604224,
0.2372049689,
-0.1048397645,
0.3610886335,
-0.048813533,
-0.0966216102,
0.7190261483,
-0.0573051013,
0.2424081564,
0.6016312242,
-0.3840486407,
-0.6929700375,
1.0807404518,
-0.2439489365,
0.3932106495,
0.7864596844,
0.416249156,
-0.5682524443,
-0.5200901628,
-0.867513895,
0.1225131899,
-0.5648890138,
-0.1886941493,
-0.326072216,
0.1998082101,
-0.1508577168,
-0.2621139586,
-0.3696731627,
-0.564753294,
-0.4491557777,
-0.0877506733,
0.2244661152,
0.7498391271,
-0.1154335067,
0.172517091,
-0.6575100422,
0.5406658053,
0.4795944095,
0.5007508397,
-0.1580737084,
-0.5454211235,
-0.0151405185,
0.157869935,
-0.4786979854,
-0.6611918807,
0.4334700108,
0.0175657496,
0.3603568673,
0.4476467669,
-0.080034785,
0.6202468276,
-0.4927870929,
0.4075147212,
0.5042336583,
-0.7760155797,
0.0452266745,
-0.1586336941,
0.2285658121,
0.7595088482,
0.3249072134,
-0.5106340051,
-0.0809176043,
-0.1170317903,
-0.6535658836,
0.8614296317,
-0.2370765507,
-0.0717688352,
0.2881508768,
0.3365263343,
0.2213457525,
0.2270758748,
-0.7715425491,
-0.3363585174,
-0.308026433,
-0.4895201921,
-0.1410891116,
-0.3011498749,
-0.4200787842,
0.0080053201,
0.5580368042,
-0.3441329002,
-0.1712613255,
0.0286197867,
-0.0347681232,
-0.3030477166,
0.3484137952,
0.8782699108,
0.7212717533,
-0.3013421893,
0.2030931115,
-0.0039815428,
-0.2786974311,
0.5322483778,
0.1275724322,
-0.2807226777,
-0.4460141361,
-0.1281036139,
0.996360898,
0.2421026677,
-0.5587126613,
0.3060538471,
-0.2103349417,
-0.2697202563,
0.0496075526,
0.2808566988,
0.1703247577,
0.1696272045,
0.1401287466,
0.0649962574,
0.1179773062,
-0.1364319772,
-0.137784645,
0.61859411,
-0.4948139489,
-0.2922556102,
0.4978964627,
0.2984653115,
-0.1920321286,
0.4279516935,
-0.2047150433,
-0.3553331792,
0.4780130088,
0.4290414453,
0.7868561149,
-0.0106633399,
0.2615860701,
0.1558436453,
0.1005747616,
-0.0438998751,
0.2172905356,
-0.1730161458,
-0.7866165638,
-0.2884212136,
-0.7350680232,
-0.6291377544,
-0.2812044024,
-0.5663655996,
0.1994591504,
-0.4063919783,
-0.0475516059,
0.0965422392,
-0.0554504506,
-0.4803052545,
-0.0768338442,
0.3995546699,
0.6247388124,
-0.6229751706,
0.8797227144,
0.6303927302,
-0.389832288,
-0.7762554884,
-0.1819751412,
0.3148208559,
-0.9493051767,
0.7368893027,
0.1200569645,
-0.4591993988,
-0.0692620352,
-0.2077769637,
-0.8276370764,
1.1368180513,
0.2884394228,
-0.8771343827,
0.1472949684,
0.3298937082,
0.4051695466,
-0.3013755679,
0.2102220058,
0.57711941,
0.5397996306,
0.3317991793,
-0.7440778017,
0.0050893272,
0.1169614494,
-0.0343158394,
0.4014361203,
-0.8520094156,
0.5469973683,
-0.3680687547,
0.0174399428,
-0.1185909361,
0.6454803348,
0.7233514786,
0.304464221,
0.6638512611,
0.7642707229,
0.5874768496,
0.0318171047,
0.8073388934,
-0.2095756829,
0.1489600837,
0.9595845342,
-0.4564870894,
0.8564332724,
0.8328377008,
-0.3024506867,
0.4458680451,
0.6323888898,
0.5453529358,
0.6655316949,
0.1813188493,
-0.1993314028,
-0.1732113361,
-0.0336342938,
-0.2662786543,
0.2946572006,
0.1853076071,
0.1665882766,
0.023286229,
-0.3194408119,
-0.0799880773,
0.1363503635,
-0.3566550314,
1.0556231737,
0.0516720414,
-0.9590951204,
0.6911257505,
0.2165323943,
0.9713059664,
-0.9007923603,
-0.0042459304,
-0.4635840952,
0.4136390686,
-0.3459807634,
-0.6629979014,
0.0462467149,
-0.0551687032,
-0.2713421583,
-0.1516231745,
0.4761750102,
-0.752679348,
-0.380661279,
0.0491709188,
0.1866757125,
-0.3958368301,
0.1244164407,
-0.6693786979,
0.1420241445,
0.2419601977,
-0.3112953305,
0.6626810431,
0.3076347113,
-0.1670289338,
0.6536462307,
0.7387650013,
0.1993445009,
0.0281618554,
0.1160063148,
0.8298777938,
-0.6554518342,
-0.5263158083,
-0.9451096654,
0.2149314582,
0.2427690029,
-0.3494197428,
0.5540988445,
0.31529513,
0.7979835868,
0.0343527347,
0.5665969849,
0.1204164699,
0.2126763761,
-0.6187870502,
0.2241963893,
-0.5928896666,
0.3692782521,
0.090246737,
-0.7994583249,
-0.2355854064,
0.4798755944,
-0.1396785527,
-0.1421522498,
0.3011193871,
0.8542535901,
-0.1769224107,
-0.3257240653,
0.1662278771,
-0.1842219085,
0.4806329012,
0.6934806108,
0.8961726427,
0.3665050268,
0.3843398988,
-0.4829103351,
-0.5008519888,
-0.2649959922,
-0.9567303658,
-0.4837032557,
-0.0535575449,
-0.0082358746,
-0.1410482377,
-0.0406242609,
1.370844245,
0.6226210594,
-0.9376531243,
-0.5069698691,
-0.026307188,
0.4410106242,
-0.3643839061,
-0.1607805192,
0.2142190188,
-0.5610206723,
-0.8492960334,
0.2960218191,
0.5349969864,
-0.0940719247,
-0.474978447,
-0.7185840011,
-0.0015137884,
0.0262860321,
0.489279151,
0.5202749968,
-0.83384794,
-0.1181341335,
0.0441788472,
-0.3742162287,
0.2403777391,
0.8386309147,
-0.6090853214,
0.4158274531,
0.6085229516,
0.7862485051,
0.2793081701,
0.3406341374,
0.6158672571,
-0.5573855042,
0.1322610676,
0.0010526926,
0.3124799728,
0.2067256123,
-0.4404232502,
0.2066312283,
-0.1225612387,
-0.8006151915,
-0.4555476606,
0.2863193154,
-1.1418230534,
-0.0557323098,
1.4019451141,
0.0554800741,
0.0271605831,
0.2462192029,
-0.5222246647,
-0.1091656685,
-0.8108474016,
1.0329726934,
0.466496557,
-0.3068065345,
0.144528836,
0.0185951255,
0.631025672,
0.6982346177,
-0.7084947228,
0.0394768752,
0.8870486021,
0.1974850446,
-0.1075806394,
0.7955172062,
-0.0090064611,
0.3169558048,
-0.6033451557,
0.2735159695,
-0.3854315877,
-0.467242986,
-0.6911841035,
0.1050412804,
0.5519565344,
-0.2228347212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18563v1
|
Approaching Human-Level Forecasting with Language Models
| 2024-02-28T18:54:18 | 2024-02-28T18:54:18 |
Danny Halawi, Fred Zhang, Chen Yueh-Han, Jacob Steinhardt
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Forecasting future events is important for policy and decision making. In
this work, we study whether language models (LMs) can forecast at the level of
competitive human forecasters. Towards this goal, we develop a
retrieval-augmented LM system designed to automatically search for relevant
information, generate forecasts, and aggregate predictions. To facilitate our
study, we collect a large dataset of questions from competitive forecasting
platforms. Under a test set published after the knowledge cut-offs of our LMs,
we evaluate the end-to-end performance of our system against the aggregates of
human forecasts. On average, the system nears the crowd aggregate of
competitive forecasters, and in some settings surpasses it. Our work suggests
that using LMs to forecast the future could provide accurate predictions at
scale and help to inform institutional decision making.
|
[
-0.2980540693,
-0.3988222778,
0.5002650619,
0.0224114247,
0.1446169168,
0.3132699728,
-0.2206299603,
-0.9362351894,
0.2275574207,
0.5428363085,
-0.4033337831,
-0.1948693246,
-0.3239662945,
-0.0781586021,
-0.749943316,
0.4245285988,
0.307567507,
0.061769329,
-0.2314361334,
0.3400520682,
-0.5292797089,
-0.8517765403,
-0.9068216085,
-0.6122609377,
0.4838804305,
0.3742403388,
0.9870271683,
0.6117485762,
0.2644563317,
0.33443138,
-0.2111608833,
0.0096143642,
-0.3950434327,
0.3737190068,
-0.2393439561,
-0.4156310558,
-0.4633938372,
0.1925903112,
0.7004179358,
0.7921856642,
-0.4564619064,
0.1501473635,
0.0083900411,
0.5291618705,
-0.5207292438,
0.3136267662,
-0.8617349863,
0.0610022396,
-0.1324688047,
-0.0221895315,
-0.5017806888,
-0.1584518701,
0.5631842613,
-0.3080972135,
0.1078782752,
0.5736865997,
0.7318586707,
-0.1463593543,
-0.2370047122,
-0.0855505243,
-0.6372562647,
0.8474830389,
-0.6503946781,
0.6654090285,
0.5866843462,
0.6064838171,
-0.304718703,
-0.732775867,
-0.3585343361,
-0.1194434315,
0.0550757498,
0.1455874443,
-0.1285333782,
-0.1625202894,
-0.1790376008,
-0.0541266389,
-0.5718624592,
0.1728307903,
-0.3562817276,
0.0352853313,
0.7623512149,
0.5118437409,
0.3415536582,
-0.1150297523,
-0.2406809032,
0.0404885896,
-0.6071211696,
-0.0561689176,
0.1099696979,
0.5639054775,
0.1383471489,
0.3087349236,
-0.3063781559,
0.7403103113,
-0.1303066164,
-0.0369435474,
-0.1061530039,
-0.0730424523,
-0.1036154479,
-0.0282022003,
0.6284105778,
0.5436667204,
0.4448168874,
-0.420150578,
-0.5208465457,
-0.1414059997,
0.0940392539,
-0.5555319786,
-0.177172631,
0.1787631512,
-0.3465860486,
-0.4040931463,
-0.1740655154,
-1.0167170763,
-0.6725109816,
-0.3550185263,
0.4474797547,
-0.0118419472,
-0.2069615126,
0.2127314508,
-0.19650729,
-0.0940102711,
0.1847754717,
-0.9229647517,
0.4853760302,
0.5282617211,
0.6754197478,
-0.125199303,
-0.3073951304,
-0.5524010062,
0.086642243,
-0.5720359087,
0.9368373156,
-0.6093739867,
-0.5985127687,
0.2177366912,
-0.205595836,
0.1107349694,
-0.8120595217,
0.3457763195,
-0.8277794719,
0.34129107,
-0.0969794244,
-0.4300332665,
0.2082749307,
0.1816762537,
-0.6522234678,
0.7966333032,
-0.1198640764,
-0.343118459,
0.5618349314,
-0.454588294,
-0.3080925941,
0.2279011607,
-0.1278639436,
-0.1908884197,
-0.1700777709,
0.4317809641,
0.5015693307,
-0.396017462,
0.5483740568,
-0.3169127107,
-0.1584886611,
0.2818294168,
-0.3174800575,
0.2202015519,
0.2670890093,
0.0044061691,
0.0148439761,
-0.5129463077,
-0.0267306603,
0.1161280423,
-0.4340208769,
-0.1916082203,
0.7754615545,
0.0160310324,
0.4097687304,
0.465826273,
-0.4275251627,
0.1386745274,
-0.4927472174,
0.2615444064,
0.9733273983,
-0.2331566066,
0.8703596592,
-0.3910140097,
0.8129307628,
-0.1762866825,
0.2516836524,
-0.0686098039,
-0.6006009579,
-0.5359861851,
0.2967630029,
0.191664964,
0.5781072974,
-0.684196949,
0.069713749,
-0.3259402215,
-0.5477412343,
-0.2195696533,
-0.2135744691,
0.0726578906,
0.4254586399,
0.2161046118,
0.2440285385,
-0.8660977483,
-0.4699501693,
-0.7502201796,
-0.3373945951,
0.0345326923,
0.4224171937,
0.1738657504,
-0.1352712065,
1.1177282333,
-0.4789912403,
-0.1485872567,
-0.4200832546,
0.1878129244,
0.337625742,
0.0219291355,
0.3311288953,
-0.8169297576,
-0.4103246033,
-0.0891932473,
-0.5267679691,
-0.0552196987,
0.1503435224,
0.043072965,
0.2170035839,
0.3092088103,
-0.0416655764,
0.0788231194,
0.7384536862,
-0.6467522383,
0.5666723847,
-0.1834785193,
-0.1781552881,
-0.9820734262,
-0.2124496102,
0.2078362554,
-0.4298187792,
-0.6582275033,
-0.245267719,
-0.1350831538,
-0.3201280236,
-0.2411394268,
1.1524403095,
-0.4398202598,
-0.39402017,
-0.1811702698,
0.3200008571,
-0.1690032184,
-0.1361743659,
0.4090434611,
0.9610267282,
0.3781798184,
-0.5187119246,
0.0870556012,
-0.1381682456,
-0.8439483643,
0.0766957328,
-0.5737898946,
-0.1516693532,
-0.0645421669,
0.1859620512,
-0.3655353487,
-0.3260812163,
-0.3344130218,
-0.6164824367,
0.0264523625,
0.0837107748,
-0.3973083496,
-0.6859232187,
0.2138124853,
0.1181535497,
0.6814323068,
-0.4258804023,
0.7016545534,
0.9490500093,
-0.4364180565,
-0.7113773823,
-0.5055416822,
0.3259342015,
-0.1099720597,
-0.4421527684,
0.048189126,
0.0748429894,
-0.5616824627,
-0.196198225,
0.2802717686,
-0.1041359007,
0.2409954071,
0.0852620378,
0.5663329959,
-0.0064300154,
0.0353771523,
-0.4365882576,
0.007547501,
0.1388729662,
-0.5590819716,
0.6176956296,
-0.0707164258,
-0.0965922102,
-0.174201414,
0.1556944847,
0.4082766175,
-0.3297100365,
0.8521860242,
0.2621407211,
-0.690942049,
0.000312703,
-0.7505286932,
-0.141450569,
-0.4824694991,
0.6280089021,
-0.2536124289,
-0.6787531972,
0.7307459116,
0.0588821992,
0.063915126,
0.4680951238,
0.5653405786,
-0.1762840152,
1.65421772,
0.5073555112,
-0.4626630843,
0.6690711379,
-0.1853302568,
0.0379721709,
-0.4999857545,
-0.5125674605,
-0.5723049641,
-0.280623436,
-0.3025730252,
-0.4667606652,
0.4896749854,
0.112799868,
-0.297793895,
0.2376945615,
-0.1437969655,
0.6381040215,
0.5338658094,
-0.1454793513,
0.1943208724,
-0.0772473589,
-0.0301308688,
-0.0061200876,
-0.6817397475,
-0.6474397182,
0.8579551578,
0.2985364497,
0.9515157938,
-0.1446713507,
0.6762021184,
0.3640007675,
0.6108127832,
-0.4425969422,
0.4344605803,
-0.1511669159,
-0.8406228423,
-0.6489632726,
-0.5537442565,
-1.0632362366,
0.3270314336,
-0.3149698973,
-0.9301815629,
0.5690353513,
0.0224109795,
-0.3822571933,
0.4531359076,
-0.4252162278,
0.5108700395,
-0.2240850478,
-0.0480055772,
-0.3512063324,
-0.4858987927,
-0.0792114437,
-0.0063744043,
0.8682624698,
-0.4508219659,
-0.290466398,
0.9632563591,
-0.0678290576,
0.642431736,
-0.1058997512,
-0.0240743179,
0.2156372666,
0.1963159889,
0.4736791253,
-0.1522818357,
-0.7894662023,
-0.1251733154,
0.0748014525,
-0.3849679232,
-0.3826427162,
0.6716556549,
-0.9772702456,
-0.5355942845,
-0.3529594839,
-0.5132684708,
-0.2597399652,
0.1173043326,
0.0799641982,
0.6555149555,
-0.458445549,
-0.0638291165,
0.1524398923,
-0.0671551898,
0.4264071882,
0.8079922795,
-0.6133937836,
-0.3332232535,
1.1571458578,
0.3310536444,
0.147192046,
0.4720345736,
0.3802790046,
-0.5220602155,
-0.4017297029,
-0.4270352423,
-0.0067159706,
-0.5206870437,
-0.2902404666,
-0.3758371472,
-0.0454477146,
-0.5642133355,
-0.1604819,
-0.2450089455,
-0.218228519,
-0.4034242034,
-0.0146301156,
-0.0858581811,
1.1333528757,
-0.0216403026,
0.0487530455,
-0.8282526135,
0.0192921069,
0.1323665977,
0.4847033024,
0.1947627664,
-0.5119925141,
-0.6392745376,
0.1135606244,
-0.205987826,
-0.8143821955,
1.0633639097,
0.2384442389,
0.6488815546,
0.3057623506,
0.052623108,
0.5191095471,
-0.6664757133,
0.8805067539,
0.1496732533,
-0.7643502355,
0.5266670585,
-0.5104415417,
0.1603604853,
0.2122885734,
0.3289635181,
-0.9933428168,
-0.4125327766,
-0.4529980719,
-0.9216914177,
0.7836425304,
-0.2999176085,
0.1779828817,
-0.3660843074,
0.1612310261,
-0.1281142533,
0.0866081864,
-0.4169207513,
-0.1831487864,
0.1837421656,
0.0229170322,
-0.4452645481,
-0.3227753341,
0.3773994744,
-0.1779610962,
0.6745232344,
0.0812738761,
0.0086527811,
-0.0964490846,
0.2023007572,
-0.5740136504,
0.3105128407,
0.3268451393,
0.9638439417,
-0.3620129824,
-0.2058443278,
0.3955371678,
-0.0405576415,
0.0552127846,
0.1878490299,
0.0727294162,
0.0473661944,
0.2349589616,
0.5237308741,
0.2654482126,
-1.1070551872,
0.3243834972,
-0.1302485764,
-0.0441150106,
-0.5210236907,
-0.2534093857,
0.3052784503,
0.5054024458,
0.7949659824,
-0.1352121085,
0.1311038882,
-0.8421313763,
0.0501060523,
0.3177859187,
-0.3551812768,
-0.2545901835,
1.0272715092,
0.3981471956,
-0.5246050954,
0.6042503119,
0.1511729807,
-0.7362394333,
0.6152923703,
0.5610256195,
0.4980500042,
-0.5090536475,
-0.0836849809,
0.2232968211,
0.0042623458,
-0.4805161953,
0.4030827582,
0.5300889015,
-0.8629506826,
-0.4843649268,
-0.9077909589,
-0.5969569683,
-0.0990685895,
-0.6512477398,
0.2989417315,
-0.0340635292,
-0.4782925248,
-0.214443922,
0.1416269541,
-0.7850517631,
0.4160417318,
0.5213127732,
1.1386315823,
-0.6678963304,
0.6796776652,
0.7318092585,
-0.3169071078,
-0.6734540462,
-0.2712832391,
-0.2334386855,
-0.8446999788,
0.7346063256,
-0.2600383461,
-0.0896216482,
-0.0791064054,
-0.2366573215,
-1.1172823906,
1.1712675095,
0.3374380171,
-0.7847782969,
-0.598333776,
0.0024544748,
0.4983479083,
-0.3743451834,
0.2446177155,
0.5070545673,
0.400383234,
-0.1699701399,
-1.205100894,
-0.421050936,
-0.0503280982,
-0.0816555023,
0.3496924639,
-0.372556746,
1.0653880835,
-0.2340860218,
-0.2331280112,
0.2241665721,
1.1190675497,
0.0165101271,
0.4197183847,
0.4897208512,
0.1956994683,
0.8518275023,
-0.0907202736,
1.3548116684,
-0.5639469624,
0.2569297254,
1.0812221766,
-0.4016026855,
1.2890849113,
0.0843054801,
-0.2772272825,
0.7386612296,
0.7686893344,
0.3794963062,
0.3926148415,
0.0496103689,
-0.3211112022,
-0.6667251587,
-0.2447252423,
-0.3430511355,
0.3448152542,
0.508800149,
-0.3510187268,
-0.0734699667,
-0.0617846251,
-0.2435502857,
0.3906300366,
-0.5280063152,
0.9411703348,
0.0872421265,
-0.8123830557,
0.3875567317,
0.0822534114,
0.5550994277,
-0.1821110845,
0.2547313273,
-0.1617586315,
0.3703916669,
0.2245456129,
-0.9486874342,
0.0726052821,
-0.148844108,
-0.2114493847,
-0.3135328293,
0.77514714,
-0.6504202485,
-0.5639774799,
0.5421488285,
0.9402758479,
0.1476106495,
-0.1594533771,
-0.5339859128,
-0.2128180265,
-0.335454613,
-0.2656207383,
0.5943706632,
0.1459122896,
-0.1915214807,
1.3325705528,
0.3474847972,
0.4962138534,
0.0651284531,
0.1706253141,
0.7692299485,
-0.6487044692,
-0.5907325745,
-0.790715456,
0.0536864623,
-0.0467874929,
0.1235782057,
0.3176428378,
0.6247292757,
0.6286520362,
0.1341536641,
0.8915195465,
0.4495764375,
0.8905883431,
-0.1067171618,
0.677993834,
-0.6876229644,
0.1946798861,
0.0231005568,
-0.5818396807,
0.0505925529,
0.2059200555,
-0.6078962088,
-0.0032966083,
0.0707208067,
0.5571926236,
0.2443774492,
0.0643445998,
0.5853703022,
0.0097092642,
0.3347714245,
0.1525675356,
0.9871504307,
-0.0128752766,
0.7434573174,
-0.1367065161,
0.0841966793,
-0.347181499,
-0.7405622005,
-0.7143930197,
-0.6168086529,
0.3256755173,
-0.1379790008,
0.5839688182,
1.1657090187,
0.8166339397,
-0.7881145477,
-0.8205960393,
0.2662237287,
0.0508456342,
0.059151765,
-0.2590260208,
0.2420923412,
-0.3617212176,
-0.8727294803,
0.4417668581,
0.0603928305,
-0.0106908074,
-0.431470722,
-0.2414295077,
-0.1779168099,
0.2374339104,
0.6338477731,
0.1417969018,
-0.8692455888,
-0.1861772239,
0.1183610633,
-0.1724602729,
-0.3470571339,
0.6801223755,
-1.2178288698,
0.4529019892,
0.5118867159,
0.3384796679,
0.068880491,
0.0984797627,
1.1323782206,
-0.6037418842,
-0.0834250376,
0.4749454856,
0.5190171599,
0.2561895251,
-0.2377737015,
0.4013708234,
-0.0562331453,
-0.8230773807,
-0.6754658222,
-0.1203137934,
-0.1663018018,
-0.1902380288,
0.9772902131,
0.0970450416,
-0.0940752998,
-0.1893695146,
0.0178242512,
0.1603761911,
-0.7494092584,
0.7906212211,
0.6980718374,
-0.015006111,
-0.2707310021,
-0.676569283,
0.4619910419,
0.1161972955,
-0.5031119585,
0.1966101825,
0.2915496826,
0.0589081272,
0.0005393585,
0.6868337989,
0.1242102981,
0.1939199865,
-0.1911563277,
0.003501287,
0.2434374988,
-0.3903950155,
0.0236598589,
-0.0579933859,
0.3759353161,
0.2800226808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18551v1
|
Implicit Bias of Next-Token Prediction
| 2024-02-28T18:34:53 | 2024-02-28T18:34:53 |
Christos Thrampoulidis
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Next-token prediction (NTP), the go-to training paradigm in training large
language models, involves predicting the next token in a sequence. Departing
from traditional one-hot classification, in NTP, multiple tokens with varying
frequencies follow each given context. This work frames NTP training as
cross-entropy minimization over distinct contexts, each associated with a
sparse empirical probability vector across a finite vocabulary. It then
addresses the following question: do gradient-based optimizers exhibit a bias
towards solutions with specific structure as the NTP training loss reaches its
lower bound (entropy)? Specifically, for linear NTP models trained using
gradient descent (GD), we make the following contributions: Firstly, we
determine NTP-separability conditions on the data, under which GD can attain
its lower bound. We also demonstrate that these conditions hold under
overparameterization. Secondly, we establish that the parameters of GD
projected onto an appropriate data subspace converge to the unique solution of
a system of linear equations, which requires the logits' difference of
in-support tokens to be equal to the log-ratio of their respective
probabilities. Meanwhile, on the orthogonal subspace, the parameters diverge
and converge in the direction of the solution of a max-margin quadratic
program, minimizing the Euclidean norm of parameters satisfying the
\NTP-separability conditions. Akin to prior research on implicit bias of
one-hot classification, our work opens exciting avenues for future research
that can lead to better understanding optimization, generalization and
robustness principles of models trained with NTP.
|
[
-0.4120224118,
-0.354244858,
0.314178139,
-0.027037235,
-0.1515625119,
-0.1148907021,
-0.1460419893,
-0.6182892919,
0.1177341789,
0.0569818802,
-0.6192792058,
-0.4546463788,
-0.5793340802,
-0.0872966796,
-0.3021451533,
1.0812454224,
0.1285624653,
0.4162717462,
-0.0979774147,
-0.1808121353,
-0.512667954,
-0.6938960552,
-0.5203582048,
-0.2845976651,
0.2826378345,
0.1671020389,
0.6082113385,
0.5955215693,
0.0655569211,
0.2253119797,
-0.144528985,
-0.3085749149,
-0.3122359514,
0.1482398808,
0.053236939,
-0.8425065279,
-0.0144930594,
0.1862476766,
0.6778981686,
0.7303773165,
-0.0348445103,
0.2073016614,
0.1057654694,
0.5533081889,
-0.7638123035,
-0.0440928079,
-0.8396344781,
0.4884163439,
-0.1901872456,
-0.3713774383,
-0.299431175,
-0.4007614553,
0.3981186152,
-0.3775015473,
0.4823060334,
0.088682048,
0.6409619451,
0.2963185012,
-0.3861037195,
0.1808609515,
-0.6415240765,
0.8865495324,
-0.5471335053,
0.5773410797,
0.363062799,
0.2085434794,
0.2249877602,
-0.5348029137,
-0.333147198,
-0.1479665041,
0.240315482,
-0.2578512132,
0.0150664644,
0.1324165314,
0.3043999374,
0.112606436,
-0.4441688061,
0.1781529933,
-0.5146471858,
-0.2956268191,
0.1900022328,
0.285310775,
-0.0288974959,
0.1303441375,
-0.5868587494,
0.2315837294,
-0.5552885532,
0.0093004722,
0.4142120779,
0.2857917547,
-0.1604103297,
0.3192716241,
-0.0157178026,
0.3452719748,
0.301325947,
0.1878423542,
0.3873277307,
-0.240246132,
-0.1081974879,
0.256513834,
0.3600132465,
0.4089393616,
0.3049777746,
-0.2877161503,
-0.1264250875,
0.0526027046,
0.0134296939,
-0.7509309649,
-0.0528623722,
0.1992754936,
-0.580481112,
-0.3785862029,
-0.2353716195,
-0.555739522,
-0.2759099305,
-0.4901695251,
0.0103052128,
-0.197887063,
-0.1162126884,
-0.0083484929,
-0.2452275008,
0.0985839143,
0.1078936383,
-0.9239886999,
0.3364488482,
0.6950101256,
1.2221581936,
-0.2066554129,
-0.3079073727,
-0.5236298442,
-0.0336266458,
-0.5277040005,
0.5086628795,
-0.7762024403,
-0.2355374992,
0.2470570803,
-0.3759609759,
-0.0147946263,
-0.2768218517,
0.3828721642,
-0.5616236925,
0.3090203702,
-0.5219134092,
-0.3604599535,
0.0832334235,
0.2255529165,
-0.4825124145,
0.9375892878,
-0.0201323573,
-1.2069921494,
0.8677315712,
-0.436863482,
-0.0923192129,
-0.2445636094,
-0.2930142879,
-0.1491711289,
0.4066528082,
0.1217619479,
0.2656590641,
-0.4159175456,
0.0655320287,
-0.7522227764,
-0.0990392938,
0.0568017736,
-0.5342245698,
0.7448404431,
-0.0040086736,
-0.4483726919,
-0.0551311448,
-0.7754440308,
0.2121798247,
-0.2202205658,
-0.34740749,
-0.4181552529,
-0.1182234138,
0.194568187,
0.5356121063,
0.1204337478,
-0.5822587013,
0.1575957686,
-0.2425104827,
0.3200052381,
1.2594807148,
-0.1655727178,
0.6065506935,
-0.0762203783,
0.5712757111,
0.0255635045,
0.2747545838,
0.1429358125,
-0.4962561429,
-0.4664696753,
0.1667243391,
0.3168117106,
0.3953552246,
-0.4402884543,
0.0645537823,
-0.0892790034,
-0.1166753769,
-0.0795484185,
-0.1197554469,
0.532440424,
0.7124973536,
0.3831694126,
-0.4792797565,
-0.7253214717,
-0.7483640313,
-0.1692503691,
-0.4070504904,
0.2041757703,
0.1736669242,
0.3381752372,
-0.1342224181,
0.9539696574,
-0.4931334555,
-0.3463474214,
-0.0514615849,
0.1409787387,
0.2048080564,
0.6820046306,
0.6718558073,
-0.6212581396,
-0.5168449879,
0.0610001869,
-0.4648950696,
-0.0237417873,
0.1609639823,
-0.1584771872,
0.532166183,
0.7338637114,
-0.5113703609,
0.497651428,
0.2833711207,
-0.3117129505,
0.6733127236,
0.068032518,
-0.5210606456,
-0.8838943243,
0.0623525716,
0.3062992096,
-0.0550520755,
-0.783742547,
-0.2152903378,
-0.4337998331,
0.2194674611,
-0.3546319306,
0.6464409828,
-0.3273386061,
-0.3011756241,
-0.1763299406,
-0.4104096591,
-0.3216061294,
0.6562668085,
0.4749241769,
0.4951554239,
0.7267563939,
-0.6134178042,
0.0455832519,
0.0007557727,
-0.1200720444,
0.4803363383,
-0.7748824358,
0.2524657547,
-0.3765583634,
0.4175069034,
-0.7993063331,
0.2997354269,
0.0295004882,
-0.5697630644,
0.4044297636,
-0.4113127291,
-0.0994971916,
-0.10573823,
-0.5014091134,
0.7251826525,
0.409537375,
-0.5557595491,
0.2838108838,
0.2929774225,
-0.0223595407,
-1.2075676918,
-0.7759073973,
-0.143132478,
-0.2113673985,
-0.3605066836,
0.2100997418,
0.0489865243,
-0.1438059062,
-0.0622005984,
-0.337597847,
-0.1451994032,
-0.1293143183,
0.1990097612,
0.115003027,
-0.345197618,
0.1596181691,
-0.1689462215,
-0.2930079997,
0.3009614944,
-1.0525814295,
0.889359355,
-0.2008182853,
-0.1470063776,
-0.2733849883,
0.3163666725,
0.1879901141,
0.0607338622,
0.7537114024,
0.9322206378,
-0.4617692828,
-0.2700832784,
-0.5556313396,
-0.1738706082,
-0.4181562662,
0.5926098824,
-0.2714594305,
-0.5992974043,
0.7285032868,
0.3536744118,
0.2306074649,
0.5354582667,
0.6804009676,
0.2065461427,
1.0757479668,
0.7876264453,
-0.4468853474,
0.695355773,
-0.5573518872,
-0.2108263671,
-0.8686799407,
-0.4195939004,
-0.7674452662,
-0.5467900038,
-0.6993967891,
-0.3627927303,
0.2901194096,
-0.2017656565,
-0.4660094976,
-0.1407959759,
-0.3016723096,
0.5858699679,
0.7799149752,
-0.0633963272,
-0.1018173024,
0.0202689562,
-0.4496138394,
-0.165332675,
-0.836643219,
0.1339993775,
1.4107621908,
0.4498037994,
0.6866451502,
-0.2614744306,
0.6060931087,
0.385301441,
0.0420883447,
-0.3959365189,
0.3189233243,
0.1717407107,
-0.8542567492,
-0.3554514349,
-0.4213623703,
-0.7431960702,
0.3421870768,
-0.1457580179,
-1.0219190121,
0.6488329768,
0.2168472409,
-0.1368811429,
0.430207938,
-0.4440146089,
0.5988730788,
-0.0338233896,
-0.4144249856,
-0.1012281999,
-0.9231190681,
0.4421258271,
0.1130412892,
-0.0802020803,
-0.0549988113,
-0.2528076768,
0.7243998051,
-0.6160790324,
0.8980565667,
-0.5417694449,
-0.0099691795,
0.0592707209,
-0.0400476865,
0.4490333796,
0.2629082203,
-0.0587533787,
0.2231941223,
-0.0592338592,
-0.5399190784,
-0.4168137908,
0.5472687483,
-0.8365736604,
-0.4353151917,
-0.5629469752,
-0.3303543627,
-0.4246017039,
0.1100906879,
0.5778339505,
0.6701107025,
0.0500321835,
0.0474733859,
0.5154312849,
-0.0248564146,
0.5207898021,
0.121939525,
-0.0551547483,
-0.2304067314,
0.7518237829,
0.1494405568,
0.3509168029,
0.2886678576,
0.3270829916,
-0.5249932408,
-0.7491437197,
-0.1897859722,
-0.0653580725,
-0.9909264445,
-0.1307189614,
-0.4762137234,
-0.0987659171,
-0.3590163291,
-0.0720831454,
-0.2282476872,
-0.6526995301,
-0.1953309327,
-0.3126389086,
-0.0009553209,
0.3435538411,
-0.3673016131,
0.0385849066,
-0.5334042311,
0.1358509213,
0.1539604366,
0.3717353046,
0.1120075062,
-0.6025490761,
-0.3808353543,
-0.2042866647,
0.0007965106,
-0.6496318579,
0.2465960234,
0.3675660491,
0.5313755274,
0.6623238325,
-0.0552860275,
0.4475207627,
-0.6350411773,
0.7693980336,
0.4438284934,
-0.9111952782,
0.2392522991,
-0.1832135916,
0.103300415,
0.602812469,
0.4651371539,
-0.6138800979,
-0.2155395299,
-0.6609538198,
-0.8045957685,
0.8394690156,
-0.1306217909,
0.241731286,
0.0273303296,
0.3421979845,
0.2083830535,
0.3291600347,
-0.6902362108,
-0.4730855525,
-0.058205612,
0.1734215319,
0.0346847884,
-0.2818484008,
0.0250839852,
-0.1209672391,
0.6929077506,
-0.3600233495,
0.4580720365,
0.0346245989,
0.1501644105,
-0.1834826022,
-0.1166683063,
0.5750595927,
0.6342744231,
-0.30883798,
0.0304833483,
0.2910859585,
-0.5657141209,
0.1186024696,
-0.0546407066,
-0.273144871,
0.2979900241,
0.4610290527,
0.9144562483,
-0.2539264262,
-0.1436588168,
0.5108851194,
-0.1510013342,
-0.1327435225,
-0.2888912559,
-0.1403383911,
-0.5071566105,
0.3475795984,
0.6540437341,
0.4912054837,
0.2910037935,
-0.5102334619,
0.1372782886,
0.7623503804,
-0.5817588568,
-0.6771616936,
0.8857140541,
0.1009320989,
0.1522659957,
0.3471830189,
-0.0217660517,
-0.830824554,
0.632884264,
0.4572657645,
1.2048072815,
-0.1885823756,
0.1719817817,
0.2321767807,
0.3178751469,
-0.1228301153,
0.2081293613,
-0.2447815835,
-0.7374842763,
-0.5058028102,
-0.39230147,
-0.1682251841,
0.0596894138,
-0.5944453478,
0.2728360593,
-0.6903348565,
-0.362347573,
0.002790689,
0.0418310948,
-0.7130570412,
0.306981802,
0.4313437045,
0.8402685523,
-0.8886489868,
0.7176898718,
0.4388802946,
-0.1909390837,
-0.5309472084,
0.2416416407,
0.0717986003,
-0.9765948057,
1.0094881058,
0.1224440858,
-0.0321659073,
-0.4548366964,
-0.6286889911,
-1.0677229166,
0.7076762915,
0.5593779087,
-0.2190071493,
-0.5183517337,
0.1516094953,
0.4494796395,
-0.1833365858,
0.3876834214,
0.525447607,
0.20066984,
0.0256342329,
-0.9222198725,
0.0022029062,
-0.3421572149,
0.2269286215,
0.2533228397,
-0.5696669817,
0.9749782085,
-0.3395040631,
-0.0034833278,
-0.268756628,
0.8413693309,
0.0756802782,
0.4631085098,
0.4531628788,
0.4845266938,
0.6349614263,
0.0625735372,
1.0090502501,
-0.4462253451,
0.2761441171,
0.9605031013,
-0.0323428623,
0.4875451922,
0.5912215114,
-0.3165029883,
0.4425694644,
0.6887595057,
0.3846513629,
0.6685143709,
0.380902797,
-0.0523860566,
0.0365020223,
-0.2646113336,
-0.7556724548,
0.1471089572,
0.1103927866,
-0.3622929156,
-0.1079487577,
-0.220181495,
-0.1703374684,
-0.337358892,
-0.4429069757,
0.4721809626,
0.0442102402,
-0.3132431805,
0.7140111923,
0.105081737,
0.7955547571,
-0.404269278,
0.257604003,
-0.371013701,
0.1071441546,
-0.3112550378,
-0.2362652272,
0.1636082381,
-0.2280251682,
-0.1838313788,
0.0798179209,
0.514015317,
-0.2702690661,
-0.397952348,
0.0332626887,
0.2425039858,
-0.1237610206,
0.0785725489,
-0.585983634,
-0.1792933196,
-0.0859808102,
-0.4089174867,
0.4490785003,
0.4963249862,
-0.1572143137,
0.7143986225,
0.6411242485,
0.2911123931,
0.6119326353,
-0.1172543466,
0.7979625463,
-0.3113495708,
-0.8920589685,
-1.0137540102,
0.1297501624,
0.1356641352,
-0.6328483224,
0.456350863,
0.7069377303,
0.9736683965,
0.0774903819,
0.9098661542,
0.2581952214,
0.1795551628,
-0.8085167408,
0.0014753079,
-0.4483404756,
0.1931708157,
-0.3465253413,
-1.1526244879,
-0.2314390391,
0.3501675427,
-0.2873750031,
0.3706791401,
0.7408599257,
0.4395368695,
0.0714243352,
-0.0612370409,
0.0466783457,
-0.1521838456,
0.1226557642,
0.649494648,
0.7553701997,
-0.1114131138,
0.3755295575,
-0.1755711436,
0.2351261526,
-0.1995130032,
-0.7487479448,
-1.0146591663,
-0.7700356245,
-0.2151028961,
-0.5603785515,
0.1119812801,
1.2635436058,
0.9237214923,
-0.7707160115,
0.0140770869,
-0.2922546268,
0.1499833316,
-0.122400105,
-0.1842315495,
0.4438520074,
-0.5336152911,
-0.800776422,
-0.0718191937,
0.1134313941,
0.0362253115,
-0.4294681549,
-0.1715653688,
0.1435886025,
-0.0227482636,
0.2137997895,
0.4732120037,
-0.4369520545,
-0.1193583384,
-0.1727423966,
0.1003264487,
0.1341895163,
1.0706281662,
-0.7756673098,
0.1242623553,
0.6483525634,
0.7511200905,
0.6969743371,
-0.0762719586,
0.728426218,
-1.0981756449,
0.4362929165,
0.3295275867,
0.3552983105,
-0.0013626289,
-0.3740481734,
0.4691084027,
0.3713784516,
-0.2600758374,
-1.0683348179,
0.2017210126,
-0.4103910923,
-0.0988981575,
1.335162878,
0.1391758323,
-0.1316874921,
-0.1969247311,
0.0487137847,
-0.006320348,
-0.5860258937,
0.6963824034,
0.5805805922,
-0.0443573035,
-0.0451751053,
-0.5762479901,
0.8538187742,
0.5876063704,
-0.4196956158,
0.0802775249,
0.4146416485,
0.1620852947,
0.1655678004,
0.7995665669,
0.1584821939,
0.3157816827,
0.0602790341,
-0.1549541354,
-0.0671216697,
-0.4353075624,
-0.5472150445,
0.2349761277,
0.095805347,
-0.4285345674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18540v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18540v1
|
Keeping LLMs Aligned After Fine-tuning: The Crucial Role of Prompt Templates
| 2024-02-28T18:23:49 | 2024-02-28T18:23:49 |
Kaifeng Lyu, Haoyu Zhao, Xinran Gu, Dingli Yu, Anirudh Goyal, Sanjeev Arora
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Public LLMs such as the Llama 2-Chat have driven huge activity in LLM
research. These models underwent alignment training and were considered safe.
Recently Qi et al. (2023) reported that even benign fine-tuning (e.g., on
seemingly safe datasets) can give rise to unsafe behaviors in the models. The
current paper is about methods and best practices to mitigate such loss of
alignment. Through extensive experiments on several chat models (Meta's Llama
2-Chat, Mistral AI's Mistral 7B Instruct v0.2, and OpenAI's GPT-3.5 Turbo),
this paper uncovers that the prompt templates used during fine-tuning and
inference play a crucial role in preserving safety alignment, and proposes the
"Pure Tuning, Safe Testing" (PTST) principle -- fine-tune models without a
safety prompt, but include it at test time. Fine-tuning experiments on GSM8K,
ChatDoctor, and OpenOrca show that PTST significantly reduces the rise of
unsafe behaviors, and even almost eliminates them in some cases.
|
[
-0.3723540008,
-0.5757180452,
0.49761796,
-0.0116641177,
-0.5077700615,
-0.1957346499,
0.0255491659,
-0.2941356897,
-0.4706335366,
0.3774959147,
-0.5732238293,
-0.3921597302,
-0.3924396038,
-0.0703329816,
-0.361382395,
1.1941652298,
-0.1916611791,
0.035092514,
-0.0416293703,
-0.113455601,
-0.7982868552,
-0.4364043474,
-0.951644361,
-0.0601985231,
0.6194566488,
0.3439310789,
0.7062847018,
1.0588923693,
0.4125810564,
0.1589002907,
-0.3791701198,
0.303773731,
-0.6308102608,
0.4327510893,
-0.1866067499,
-0.6468143463,
-0.6969400048,
0.208051607,
0.3467454314,
0.3178457022,
-0.3140742183,
-0.0205796137,
0.5789704323,
0.4783776104,
-0.6382178664,
-0.0519434661,
-0.5686363578,
-0.1471585333,
-0.3022232652,
-0.3815409243,
-0.43116799,
-0.670045495,
-0.233748585,
-0.6512819529,
-0.0148398019,
0.2377574444,
0.9186440706,
0.6516860127,
-0.7703683376,
0.0326876082,
-0.6660655141,
0.7309163213,
-0.5319559574,
0.1474235058,
0.4754010737,
0.2801866531,
-0.6501950026,
-0.4169837534,
-0.3594324887,
0.1120819226,
0.1537135988,
0.205185771,
-0.1562539488,
0.450671196,
0.338657558,
0.1240865886,
-0.3646832407,
0.6291719675,
-0.2977718413,
-0.1998337209,
0.4091275036,
0.5029963255,
0.1541322172,
0.1594845355,
-0.40764606,
-0.1563183665,
-1.325576663,
0.2079064995,
0.3036141694,
0.300106436,
-0.1348721981,
0.5690500736,
-0.134970367,
0.6782843471,
0.3013267815,
-0.3730877638,
-0.193035692,
-0.4056665003,
-0.2659093738,
0.2469897121,
0.5452085137,
0.8701466322,
0.5266346335,
0.0235928036,
-0.3650449812,
0.3235312402,
0.2245199382,
-0.4854824841,
0.0357973017,
0.1485531628,
-0.299698323,
-0.5904276371,
-0.0081240144,
-0.4388229549,
-0.5774372816,
-0.6401503086,
0.2843916118,
-0.4141082764,
-0.1278240085,
0.137375474,
0.1194495782,
0.5747371912,
0.4294252992,
-0.8628765941,
0.2158783823,
1.3211345673,
0.6450715065,
-0.1463920325,
-0.2749124765,
-0.8915849328,
0.2373911291,
-0.6118279696,
0.7815144062,
-0.0623994134,
-0.4695268273,
0.0284239296,
0.0363533087,
-0.1561347544,
-0.3362606168,
0.7007015347,
-0.3761448264,
0.2017224729,
-0.4904661775,
-0.7184514403,
-0.0250199046,
0.3905389011,
-0.038125474,
0.8239008188,
-0.3341373503,
-0.6618180275,
0.3962570131,
-0.2831445932,
-0.2498282939,
-0.519954145,
-0.0661482587,
-0.3244729638,
0.1970731318,
0.281624943,
0.3159053624,
-0.2224092036,
0.3023911119,
-0.4345790148,
-0.531725347,
0.2688534558,
-0.3786066175,
0.6930991411,
0.367808193,
-0.280757159,
0.2429038286,
-0.4008369148,
-0.0174944028,
-0.1964367628,
-0.2514204383,
-0.2614129186,
0.0742049068,
-0.3079193532,
0.2519909143,
-0.1889997274,
-0.426751256,
0.1842561066,
-0.3179994524,
0.4212536514,
1.1498237848,
0.1869704276,
0.4277963638,
-0.8231843114,
0.4443885386,
0.2355390936,
0.4773643911,
-0.2456894964,
-0.538079977,
-0.8939929008,
-0.2207993716,
0.1677021533,
0.7164096832,
-0.2091260403,
0.6326647401,
0.0165918805,
-0.5621832609,
-0.4845368862,
0.1056323797,
0.4260720909,
0.7328458428,
-0.0101017766,
-0.2108567655,
-0.3904527724,
-0.74641186,
-0.2894098461,
-0.0577226095,
-0.0521288291,
-0.1479068547,
-0.0670145079,
-0.1675102115,
0.8652559519,
-0.1812959015,
0.1098063961,
0.119308494,
-0.0175236315,
0.0455007404,
0.9251211882,
0.6312977076,
-0.4062927365,
-0.2756944597,
-0.2767459154,
-0.5853976011,
-0.2552052736,
-0.1795748025,
-0.4083681405,
0.093725197,
0.6268241405,
-0.7608429193,
0.619494319,
0.3017733395,
-0.3563257754,
0.2634391189,
0.0997121632,
0.0223637652,
-1.1415011883,
-0.2179145515,
-0.0480040982,
-0.4002974033,
-0.6561685801,
-0.0889900997,
0.2701761127,
0.016990371,
-0.5658330321,
0.4788218439,
-0.1458258927,
0.1299691796,
-0.3701885641,
-0.0374068953,
0.0398332477,
0.1624633521,
-0.2898952663,
1.1368079185,
0.6561843157,
-0.9444684386,
-0.0908356532,
0.4476438463,
-0.2260293067,
0.8318430185,
-0.7493702173,
0.4000516534,
-0.261292845,
0.109314315,
-1.0055501461,
-0.0751945227,
0.3910135031,
-0.1840769053,
0.3550299704,
-0.2577423155,
-0.5088419318,
0.1703778058,
-0.4117843211,
0.1726694554,
0.7916317582,
-0.5147814751,
0.0373851396,
0.3111518621,
-0.1193846017,
-0.4530194104,
-0.2854474485,
-0.1811448485,
-0.6611440182,
-0.5012328625,
0.0579666644,
-0.0948330238,
-0.2384987473,
-0.5136224627,
-0.4377635419,
0.1132396683,
0.6626031995,
0.5312630534,
0.316957593,
-0.1674073637,
0.0058606924,
0.271143645,
-0.5176401138,
-0.0935053006,
-0.213867262,
0.4827869534,
-0.1574323773,
-0.5532884598,
-0.8644105196,
0.1619063169,
0.5708557367,
-0.1954372227,
0.5603924394,
0.4009751379,
-0.2797155082,
0.4661487341,
-0.6912730932,
-0.3124099672,
-0.5073949099,
-0.1565082371,
0.0463309325,
-0.9461306334,
0.4582667947,
-0.2052471042,
0.2413347811,
0.1911451519,
0.5008622408,
-0.5570178628,
1.1503539085,
0.7933880091,
-0.032078132,
0.6908995509,
0.3160051107,
0.193270728,
-0.8594974279,
-0.0263671502,
-0.5670335889,
-0.4142377377,
-0.6798645854,
-0.1243164986,
0.6044209003,
0.3572581112,
-0.8232668638,
0.0072733909,
-0.377268672,
0.6327094436,
0.6564273834,
0.075379923,
0.1655555665,
-0.0549505837,
-0.1389286667,
-0.113080658,
-0.5003764033,
-0.7785467505,
0.9616934061,
0.3645926714,
0.9269682765,
-0.0833485872,
0.8353814483,
-0.3170131147,
0.1300022602,
-0.6882891059,
0.4610317349,
0.2894931734,
-0.5434394479,
-0.0648180023,
-0.1157552227,
-0.9620856643,
-0.0576973967,
-0.0391428918,
-0.7555461526,
0.2454872429,
0.5026969314,
-0.6213654876,
0.1907658279,
-0.4987590313,
0.6182565093,
-0.3286856711,
-0.2517442405,
0.0434052907,
-0.7732216716,
0.4685612023,
0.0398431011,
-0.0880435631,
-0.387914598,
-0.1605688781,
0.7431309223,
-0.213289097,
1.092304945,
-0.0648596808,
-0.1629723459,
0.2777349651,
0.3651160896,
0.7551935911,
0.0412063301,
0.0878128037,
-0.1076332405,
0.1561090648,
-0.3167836666,
-0.5093128085,
0.5110719204,
-0.8304383755,
-0.834952116,
-0.395200938,
-0.4449067712,
-0.3723326325,
0.1999228299,
0.3703858554,
0.1774985641,
0.0132420827,
0.1352958083,
0.9864014983,
-0.037599273,
0.3017916679,
0.3803215027,
0.0689671189,
-0.3127772212,
0.5180678964,
-0.1761919856,
0.3479884267,
-0.0224281829,
0.2985876203,
-0.1080729067,
-0.7256458998,
-0.1331736147,
0.0836772248,
-0.5814996362,
-0.6456001997,
-0.3170020878,
-0.0264354106,
-0.4433896542,
-0.2246122062,
-0.4029075205,
-0.5547681451,
-0.4370943606,
-0.4536034763,
0.6031002402,
0.5646256208,
-0.2249977738,
0.681818068,
-0.8929975629,
-0.0465834402,
0.1924777478,
0.3203544915,
-0.2144902349,
-0.3529774547,
0.2219606638,
-0.0191893857,
-0.4586587548,
-0.6116138697,
0.1738503873,
-0.0319269709,
0.5300312638,
0.7023616433,
0.284319222,
0.881172657,
-0.4379636943,
0.7104251981,
0.1318168491,
-0.7299685478,
0.7160041332,
-0.7812341452,
0.057588812,
0.7736648917,
0.2139226645,
-0.8171355128,
-0.3420114219,
-0.3742221594,
-0.7246721387,
0.46470505,
0.1348351389,
0.0826036036,
-0.0632464066,
0.6216627359,
0.1919548661,
0.3196673393,
-0.3686121106,
0.0365750343,
-0.1940858811,
-0.412384212,
0.0514608286,
-0.4378354549,
-0.7235763073,
-0.3144879639,
0.3577907085,
-0.1055874005,
0.2364392579,
-0.0266160928,
0.0671560317,
-0.2940960824,
0.2812741101,
0.8929290771,
0.4090716541,
-0.1206747144,
0.1022955999,
0.1587477475,
-0.3364681005,
0.4410985708,
-0.2177022696,
-0.2780274749,
-0.6997677684,
0.1259510666,
0.6860867143,
0.3465717733,
-0.2896562219,
0.3399776518,
-0.1780412048,
0.0117868027,
-0.0603124648,
0.5222666264,
-0.0216445867,
0.1011076719,
-0.0384245813,
0.3427772224,
-0.3262822926,
-0.2489983141,
0.1867946684,
0.3510556519,
-0.4481100738,
-0.3165042102,
0.8584534526,
0.2556653619,
-0.2680325806,
0.7531660199,
0.0225953199,
-0.327069819,
0.5329402089,
0.546298027,
0.8287891746,
-0.2758913934,
-0.2667641044,
0.1316501796,
0.4805640876,
-0.3604929149,
0.2941511869,
0.1102775112,
-0.6296224594,
-0.090171583,
-0.248620823,
-0.4143341184,
-0.0225522257,
-0.8258051276,
0.3467687666,
-0.7293374538,
-0.1283410341,
-0.5033681393,
-0.202493459,
-0.6376113296,
-0.0040235254,
0.1306264102,
1.0442011356,
-0.7534604669,
0.7181473374,
0.4604560435,
0.0563261919,
-0.9110032916,
0.0829106718,
0.5659680367,
-0.9609906077,
0.2575469315,
0.1599601805,
0.1192767471,
-0.0212020036,
-0.7206175923,
-1.0183984041,
1.1999493837,
0.5829683542,
-0.7279908657,
-0.0183391068,
0.0140323387,
0.3087436557,
-0.0417475961,
-0.0643180013,
0.7018259764,
0.482516706,
-0.0408512652,
-1.0499663353,
0.1483105421,
0.0605516434,
-0.0579372868,
0.1548241824,
-0.7120215893,
0.8140075803,
-0.0720238835,
-0.2668747008,
0.3532600701,
0.4879371524,
0.5773720145,
0.3166677356,
0.5150786042,
0.5925707817,
1.0498723984,
-0.3015812933,
0.9498514533,
-0.3923735917,
0.0357566178,
0.9621477127,
-0.366438359,
0.5330688357,
0.6222864389,
0.2300872952,
-0.1863257736,
1.1233003139,
0.2110090703,
0.687402904,
-0.0300871097,
0.0522396713,
-0.4784150124,
-0.0881481692,
-0.4965627193,
0.4839704037,
0.3387362659,
0.0486989506,
-0.2909465432,
-0.2335119992,
0.3196202815,
-0.163410604,
-0.2500190139,
0.9251076579,
0.2343651801,
-0.7096806765,
0.5884218812,
-0.235330373,
0.6392329335,
-0.3561627865,
0.2927760184,
-0.5542960167,
0.1189416647,
-0.0172198489,
-0.699677825,
0.290281266,
-0.0324779414,
0.1068945304,
-0.2809726,
0.674246192,
-0.0633465871,
-0.1097554341,
-0.0893134996,
0.4368695617,
-0.1614199877,
0.0913735926,
-0.5713877082,
0.0405428149,
-0.2175787687,
-0.3418400586,
0.6469691992,
0.5418766141,
-0.2698218524,
0.6717479825,
0.6094188094,
-0.1152878851,
0.0256151967,
-0.3159127235,
1.0336225033,
-0.6631804109,
-0.5894528627,
-0.8393122554,
0.6072140932,
0.1208289042,
-0.4728934467,
0.7048644423,
0.2929862738,
0.5628670454,
0.2017050385,
0.5426760316,
0.4413526058,
0.3943161964,
-0.8136199713,
0.8099998236,
-0.3122725189,
0.2063644826,
-0.0782830343,
-0.6912896037,
-0.3321944773,
0.4728901386,
-0.1691577286,
-0.225489527,
0.4771608412,
1.0027146339,
-0.1278148741,
0.0683738887,
0.1829277426,
0.0541270152,
0.676943481,
0.3457732499,
1.0746921301,
-0.4046960175,
0.5184772015,
-0.2428376079,
-0.1136960313,
-0.215588659,
-1.2094750404,
-0.8231091499,
-0.3763889074,
-0.3522878587,
-0.4410304427,
0.1755340397,
0.9844393134,
0.6206179261,
-0.7242864966,
-0.0855418444,
-0.0353593752,
0.2021358907,
-0.3400648534,
-0.0671432689,
0.1532699615,
-0.4950116277,
-0.4835111797,
0.5089122057,
0.2971973121,
0.6506072879,
0.2599814236,
-0.0062838164,
0.1912287921,
-0.056285575,
0.2049729675,
0.387981385,
-0.5797641873,
-0.5301480889,
0.0324450061,
-0.3419936001,
0.2660906911,
0.8730445504,
-0.5244402289,
0.0865387246,
0.3934678435,
0.4973852634,
-0.0272648279,
0.1557290703,
1.0440382957,
-0.652187407,
0.3903803229,
0.2247586995,
0.4183030128,
0.2202785164,
-0.5333064795,
0.5080067515,
-0.0242498275,
-0.7200665474,
-1.1746989489,
0.3219424486,
-1.0325903893,
0.2111528665,
1.0887613297,
-0.0112473397,
-0.2639403939,
-0.2099547982,
-0.4178329408,
0.5823685527,
-0.3608687222,
1.0064512491,
0.3862196207,
-0.1908380985,
-0.2133778334,
-0.5084332228,
0.8882594109,
0.5074666739,
-0.6630843282,
0.1593792588,
0.1873351187,
0.4152234793,
-0.2901398838,
0.4444531798,
-0.00832179,
0.451613158,
-0.3416767418,
-0.4502100945,
-0.254632175,
-0.2229866385,
-0.6127012968,
-0.2252723128,
0.3346122205,
-0.4095154405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18510v3
|
RNNs are not Transformers (Yet): The Key Bottleneck on In-context Retrieval
| 2024-02-28T17:38:06 | 2024-05-10T08:55:21 |
Kaiyue Wen, Xingyu Dang, Kaifeng Lyu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
This paper investigates the gap in representation powers of Recurrent Neural
Networks (RNNs) and Transformers in the context of solving algorithmic
problems. We focus on understanding whether RNNs, known for their memory
efficiency in handling long sequences, can match the performance of
Transformers, particularly when enhanced with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting.
Our theoretical analysis reveals that CoT improves RNNs but is insufficient to
close the gap with Transformers. A key bottleneck lies in the inability of RNNs
to perfectly retrieve information from the context, even with CoT: for several
tasks that explicitly or implicitly require this capability, such as
associative recall and determining if a graph is a tree, we prove that RNNs are
not expressive enough to solve the tasks while Transformers can solve them with
ease. Conversely, we prove that adopting techniques to enhance the in-context
retrieval capability of RNNs, including Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
and adding a single Transformer layer, can elevate RNNs to be capable of
solving all polynomial-time solvable problems with CoT, hence closing the
representation gap with Transformers.
|
[
-0.6370551586,
-0.3653766215,
0.5943676829,
0.2573367059,
-0.1776960492,
0.4535945058,
-0.3062725365,
-0.4443366826,
0.1679056883,
0.3826644123,
-0.5645052195,
0.2039603144,
-0.6794615984,
0.5152514577,
-0.6732884645,
0.7333635092,
0.0965486988,
-0.3264459074,
-0.2511748374,
-0.2668190897,
-0.6378675103,
-0.4935922325,
-0.6113806963,
-0.5968899131,
0.5904715657,
0.2603736222,
0.4510591328,
0.3935441375,
0.6257712245,
0.377209574,
-0.2767195702,
0.2951773107,
-0.5685663223,
0.5173835158,
-0.2234495133,
-0.3307298124,
0.1047098413,
-0.3428763449,
0.5084982514,
0.639834404,
-0.0968236625,
0.2851244509,
0.0111454111,
1.0979561806,
-0.5846016407,
-0.011223698,
-0.8986210823,
0.3628672659,
-0.0207007695,
-0.5107709765,
-0.5435100198,
-0.0909805447,
0.5446703434,
-0.4361492395,
0.4005181491,
0.0397866182,
0.604588747,
0.658662498,
-0.100302361,
-0.2647248209,
-0.9157230258,
0.7776636481,
-0.362590313,
0.0569384396,
0.0184929315,
0.3485404849,
-0.3292241991,
-0.9178726673,
-0.4284998477,
0.0274796858,
-0.1357512921,
-0.052362971,
-0.3460282087,
-0.0541634113,
0.7448082566,
0.3950125873,
-0.181591019,
-0.3396199048,
-0.4622322917,
0.1061605141,
0.3340507448,
0.1239538863,
0.0118397893,
-0.3517387509,
-0.5369455218,
-0.063747339,
-0.5307304263,
-0.1077626869,
-0.1397644281,
0.2866455913,
0.1679307818,
0.3562205434,
0.2959342301,
0.8002030849,
0.0125732366,
0.3303620815,
0.1630431116,
-0.2389700711,
-0.0311767403,
0.1463185102,
0.5983806252,
-0.1050573736,
0.520031929,
-0.4095712602,
-0.3600835204,
-0.1295746118,
0.8180886507,
-0.4746017754,
-0.1440118402,
-0.0678054988,
-0.3952164054,
-0.1261981428,
0.3012257516,
-0.7878265977,
-0.2015874684,
-0.2784160972,
0.4248023629,
-0.1098700985,
-0.1702402681,
-0.1460820287,
-0.4672822058,
0.1851988435,
-0.0416234061,
-0.645369947,
0.3031973541,
0.7619722486,
1.014959693,
-0.0137144746,
0.0250814892,
0.0252934098,
-0.1716443151,
-0.451197356,
0.5533883572,
-0.4802821279,
-0.4314068556,
-0.2642917037,
-0.217021808,
-0.1692579985,
-0.7314587235,
0.0202052332,
-0.7146126032,
-0.0851724073,
-0.3984788954,
-0.3617784977,
0.0345050357,
-0.0261349585,
-1.0899932384,
1.0700229406,
0.3013058305,
-0.5834565163,
0.0757169798,
-0.4690499306,
-0.4680733085,
-0.076875262,
-0.4984895587,
-0.4217997789,
0.2574990392,
0.1144767627,
0.1369162947,
-0.3900538385,
0.2198473215,
0.1997481287,
-0.7459306121,
0.3898447752,
-0.5166612267,
0.3891225457,
0.1997120231,
-0.6893156171,
-0.2320394069,
-0.3429657519,
0.2147883922,
0.0648079738,
-0.1583961397,
0.0030476241,
0.0522869416,
-0.2739358246,
0.356815666,
0.0472146943,
-0.5173377395,
0.2950944901,
-0.340542078,
0.8333537579,
0.8897596598,
-0.1640038937,
0.4005322158,
-0.3428819478,
0.4263891578,
-0.0853760615,
-0.2760831416,
-0.2628467977,
-0.6536263824,
-0.8260841966,
0.3616849184,
0.2855172455,
0.2936472297,
-0.9320579767,
0.223413825,
-0.3959524333,
0.0363268517,
-0.4582543373,
-0.1712559313,
0.6179164052,
0.6079474688,
0.4773094952,
-0.4383972287,
-0.9977524877,
-0.8668370843,
-0.4501934648,
0.1148231477,
-0.0164048858,
0.5267839432,
0.518263042,
0.0738895908,
1.0259037018,
-0.0591207929,
-0.2001158148,
-0.4135953784,
0.2796289325,
0.5233273506,
0.441075623,
0.0160087887,
-1.0773345232,
-0.2345459908,
-0.0465133078,
-0.8055788279,
0.1616219729,
-0.200511381,
0.2988935113,
0.2572030127,
0.589179039,
-0.6712496877,
0.7699740529,
0.191062957,
0.004912009,
0.2147653252,
-0.2892221808,
-0.188353911,
-0.6557196975,
0.2884982824,
-0.1819354445,
-0.2288544327,
-0.5455905199,
-0.1175603196,
-0.0089068944,
-0.2396420091,
-0.2048433423,
0.33106938,
-0.3987163305,
-0.2992718816,
-0.332265079,
0.2879154682,
-0.0037304836,
0.6598545909,
0.0522932597,
1.0075212717,
0.1994208395,
-0.7630909085,
0.0818784088,
0.0758066848,
-0.3230595887,
0.121299237,
-0.6408514977,
0.4228258431,
-0.4327012002,
0.553833127,
-0.6374514103,
0.0226819944,
0.0117589077,
-0.4293269515,
0.3818974793,
-0.0273667239,
-0.3100544512,
-0.6804669499,
-0.0387533531,
1.0172207355,
0.5908415914,
-0.7086609602,
0.519169271,
-0.0076821558,
0.535535574,
-1.0156327486,
-0.8737931252,
0.0647246391,
-0.0403478108,
-0.2960483134,
0.7612534761,
0.4795530736,
-0.0009648805,
0.1679778993,
-0.5680465102,
0.2070003301,
-0.179784894,
0.080612056,
-0.0264389217,
-0.2102607936,
0.3130326271,
-0.5779880881,
-0.5818197727,
0.0521098264,
-0.4128388464,
0.4613129497,
-0.4277586937,
-0.2164529413,
-0.2079054713,
0.3520331979,
0.4776836038,
-0.252155602,
0.4917400479,
0.2877887189,
-0.2911665142,
-0.4253627062,
-0.5227521658,
-0.2755150795,
-0.4962798059,
0.2553881109,
-0.3077844977,
-0.8609952927,
0.4135069251,
-0.1631748527,
-0.2187723517,
0.3073811531,
0.1562882364,
-0.1770081669,
0.7493878007,
0.3868226707,
-0.1400977969,
0.4011406898,
-0.8210471869,
0.5945905447,
-1.3454880714,
-0.3243011236,
-0.3154909909,
-0.9692877531,
-0.790789783,
-0.4558338523,
0.5098834634,
-0.029359838,
-0.5321919918,
0.5833726525,
-1.0116226673,
0.6175637841,
0.5589434505,
0.188262254,
0.1449048519,
-0.0667121485,
0.0968627706,
0.1107754335,
-1.1214549541,
-0.164300397,
0.886926353,
0.0686140582,
0.5687736869,
-0.1400918067,
0.5798987746,
0.0594228171,
0.0295159891,
-0.5958904028,
0.5363659263,
-0.2813363969,
-0.6374973655,
-0.2608600557,
-0.6563194394,
-1.2604523897,
0.1409683228,
0.0865654647,
-0.8212703466,
0.4969117641,
0.1398937404,
-0.3983179927,
0.7499296665,
-0.290569365,
0.6099987626,
-0.0647220016,
-0.1946616173,
-0.2865877748,
-0.9007817507,
0.0564902723,
0.3453451395,
-0.1690410376,
0.1630430818,
0.0356002823,
0.645530045,
-0.4877299368,
0.3514997661,
0.0343158469,
0.4030620754,
0.6101912856,
0.0875913352,
0.43128106,
-0.1806619167,
-0.1061225981,
0.0321516953,
-0.3270981908,
-0.3411014378,
-1.1582291126,
0.6171601415,
-0.3535401225,
-0.700348258,
-0.5837724805,
-0.4854912162,
0.0480199456,
-0.0108383847,
0.4011681974,
0.6945385933,
0.268650502,
0.4434095919,
0.8435817361,
0.0574924201,
0.6825933456,
-0.3032427132,
-0.0231341161,
-0.1019741967,
1.0122328997,
0.22570391,
0.368339479,
0.4222998321,
0.0653190911,
-0.2260767519,
-0.0990338773,
-0.5058872104,
-0.0663090795,
-0.6847591996,
-0.4965550005,
-0.3069029748,
-0.5753103495,
0.3762963116,
-0.0420643389,
-0.4484392107,
-0.6161099672,
-0.1424288899,
0.092466563,
0.6369348764,
0.9293635488,
0.0322335847,
0.0529792532,
-0.3342830837,
0.5249766707,
0.2163659483,
0.5430619121,
0.7532883286,
-0.2358159721,
-0.2365037948,
-0.1325141639,
-0.5951315165,
-0.5368192792,
0.0678507313,
-0.0082391808,
0.2151900679,
0.1319953352,
-0.166124627,
0.9615673423,
-0.4533273578,
0.6556302905,
0.0391592085,
-0.682143867,
0.2093506753,
0.1032868847,
0.3630987406,
0.5733023882,
0.2219214439,
-0.4378341734,
-0.0255891792,
-0.7509282231,
-1.0168873072,
0.7113021016,
0.5706519485,
0.1926928163,
-0.1947941333,
0.6207203865,
-0.2307090908,
0.3521909416,
-0.5065103769,
-0.5422024131,
-0.2529666424,
-0.0159447603,
0.0541606247,
-0.0120768864,
0.2128628045,
-0.3719914556,
0.2718999982,
0.2177331895,
0.7660791278,
0.7583065629,
0.1268551201,
-0.1631324589,
0.1831554323,
0.3731127977,
0.7114542723,
-0.1359255165,
0.1892099231,
0.2082941532,
-0.3623334467,
0.2208529711,
-0.3181583881,
-0.0444538556,
0.1491231024,
0.4794232547,
0.7459995151,
0.6328220367,
-0.5599342585,
0.3635946512,
0.0071550598,
0.0885928422,
-0.4538949132,
-0.006054325,
-0.1338001043,
0.2819499075,
0.7572653294,
0.5346747637,
-0.0450811982,
-0.5755376816,
0.395765394,
0.6039265394,
-0.4842541218,
0.1228324547,
0.3445444107,
-0.0950570628,
-0.877822578,
1.0538473129,
0.0219299607,
-0.7304957509,
0.9791318774,
0.7574881911,
0.8792814016,
0.0763910711,
-0.1484868824,
0.4959824681,
0.1022559181,
-0.1554082632,
0.1952083558,
-0.3575381041,
-0.4678909481,
-0.5408158898,
-0.2352698296,
-0.071998544,
0.0640591383,
-0.7679932117,
-0.1298661679,
-0.4689334333,
-0.4097390473,
-0.2807240486,
-0.2365981936,
-0.695607245,
-0.0824834034,
-0.1912330538,
1.0912914276,
0.0582661144,
0.4127824903,
0.0257318076,
-0.1835423559,
-0.8274449706,
-0.1094609499,
-0.3693386018,
-0.4525022507,
0.6304236054,
0.5503211021,
-0.3181104064,
0.0069883801,
-0.307972461,
-1.0152133703,
1.2070661783,
0.071481891,
-0.5638224483,
-0.3806169331,
0.0234779865,
0.7283332944,
-0.5274410844,
0.293102175,
0.6376912594,
0.4948898852,
0.0194918476,
-0.9931389689,
-0.0565493964,
-0.3550821841,
0.4191554189,
0.5909003019,
-0.4477421939,
0.9745765924,
-0.2837168872,
-0.410258919,
0.3438092172,
0.5433933735,
0.2704004943,
0.4891893566,
0.3518859148,
0.6118301153,
0.4484440684,
-0.2052407712,
1.4315111637,
-0.1000969559,
0.2208370268,
1.0182788372,
0.1813437641,
0.6583835483,
0.7109062076,
-0.1532740295,
0.9483478665,
0.1942640394,
0.1188433841,
0.4351039827,
0.4769592583,
-0.257113874,
-0.1284216642,
0.0705548897,
-0.3863426149,
0.1735563278,
0.4135031104,
-0.6482953429,
-0.2146279663,
0.0311406236,
-0.4944215119,
0.3540552855,
-0.4423164129,
0.7417823672,
0.5106117129,
-0.8432240486,
0.7854213715,
-0.3467579186,
0.4952846467,
-0.3573619425,
-0.4206396341,
0.1667619497,
0.0623557791,
-0.3204458356,
-0.7655339241,
0.4245489538,
-0.2059226334,
-0.2484442592,
-0.2745824158,
0.6834337115,
-0.0439532213,
-0.3487727642,
0.4001806974,
0.4284182489,
0.0792925134,
0.1027497128,
-0.497641325,
0.0514229164,
-0.233069703,
-0.1295106113,
0.0661958084,
0.3089579642,
-0.1350611746,
1.0699105263,
0.252756089,
-0.0695268363,
0.0838890076,
0.0822923779,
0.8319289684,
-0.8996395469,
-0.0740430728,
-0.8637716174,
0.3165249228,
0.0106808338,
-0.2919409275,
0.4337410331,
0.3428323567,
0.9309928417,
0.0431425124,
0.4985371232,
-0.2638073266,
0.2103037089,
-0.3395839334,
0.4169806242,
-0.3356007636,
0.3860729933,
-0.2373686135,
-0.9768614173,
-0.1404565871,
0.8650538325,
-0.2235379666,
0.3700689673,
0.7060223222,
0.7397946715,
-0.2078435719,
0.3759660125,
-0.096286051,
0.0203181766,
0.0121843312,
0.9730212092,
0.8797075152,
-0.6541197896,
0.4794869721,
-0.3696404397,
0.0481874049,
0.0067900103,
-0.8194776773,
-0.6112746,
-0.8265897632,
0.2133267969,
-0.4780828655,
0.1817599833,
0.9113227129,
0.6617068648,
-0.5601012707,
-0.2674224675,
-0.6344506741,
0.5775689483,
-0.4149525464,
-0.2516936362,
0.323207587,
-0.5798691511,
-0.266631633,
0.432030946,
0.2627511322,
-0.2129152119,
-0.425968796,
-0.0084156692,
-0.0856680721,
-0.2019690424,
0.5531495214,
0.5946024656,
-0.825694859,
-0.2938826382,
0.1697787195,
0.1069563106,
0.3838299811,
1.3975752592,
-1.5753544569,
0.5614943504,
0.3476341665,
0.848724246,
0.6615480185,
0.1376833767,
0.5866453648,
-0.8784786463,
0.1651221812,
0.6002902389,
0.1376018375,
0.1729673743,
-0.3342168927,
0.5263679624,
-0.1232241467,
-0.755397737,
-0.7311484814,
0.483401835,
-0.7339435816,
-0.2478133589,
0.6748728156,
0.2172421217,
-0.3984198868,
-0.241600439,
0.0585988984,
0.1661975831,
-0.2148778737,
0.8900361061,
0.4648688734,
-0.5869221687,
-0.082946606,
-0.5141726732,
0.7231045961,
0.5873104334,
0.0033823715,
-0.0240359306,
-0.1586786956,
-0.225300625,
0.5946175456,
0.430895716,
-0.246611625,
0.5235046148,
-0.2561006248,
-0.4639594853,
-0.1293151677,
-0.6889671087,
-0.3990908563,
0.0186066218,
-0.2512043715,
0.1508799046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18502v1
|
Few-Shot Fairness: Unveiling LLM's Potential for Fairness-Aware Classification
| 2024-02-28T17:29:27 | 2024-02-28T17:29:27 |
Garima Chhikara, Anurag Sharma, Kripabandhu Ghosh, Abhijnan Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Employing Large Language Models (LLM) in various downstream applications such
as classification is crucial, especially for smaller companies lacking the
expertise and resources required for fine-tuning a model. Fairness in LLMs
helps ensure inclusivity, equal representation based on factors such as race,
gender and promotes responsible AI deployment. As the use of LLMs has become
increasingly prevalent, it is essential to assess whether LLMs can generate
fair outcomes when subjected to considerations of fairness. In this study, we
introduce a framework outlining fairness regulations aligned with various
fairness definitions, with each definition being modulated by varying degrees
of abstraction. We explore the configuration for in-context learning and the
procedure for selecting in-context demonstrations using RAG, while
incorporating fairness rules into the process. Experiments conducted with
different LLMs indicate that GPT-4 delivers superior results in terms of both
accuracy and fairness compared to other models. This work is one of the early
attempts to achieve fairness in prediction tasks by utilizing LLMs through
in-context learning.
|
[
-0.1858090609,
-0.4293757975,
0.678396225,
0.0168320406,
-0.030819742,
-0.0932143778,
-0.0576050431,
-0.5368500352,
-0.4983008504,
0.3589926958,
-0.2920419574,
-0.3972047567,
-0.7527577281,
0.0836243704,
-0.4058582783,
1.2832542658,
0.1706003696,
0.3534983695,
-0.1407146901,
-0.1836089194,
-0.5196763873,
-0.5631353855,
-0.822987318,
-0.6737774014,
0.4324136078,
0.4792450964,
0.3480052054,
0.5595132113,
0.4438277185,
0.3922446966,
-0.0781788751,
-0.3442413807,
-0.5342559218,
-0.1691545993,
-0.2187137157,
-0.7963292599,
-0.4821000397,
0.4182023108,
0.7545731068,
0.6823551059,
-0.213757351,
0.3082183599,
0.3677570522,
0.4917367101,
-0.8000558615,
0.0848383382,
-0.9198243022,
0.4718414247,
-0.466216296,
-0.1109818965,
-0.3816757798,
-0.3622440994,
-0.1156871915,
-0.4608643353,
0.0969171673,
0.2725981176,
0.6610792875,
0.3574414551,
-0.4827502072,
-0.2005216032,
-0.4320210516,
1.0854765177,
-0.7811892629,
0.1718295962,
0.2559758723,
0.8454725742,
-0.2064323723,
-0.8456892967,
-0.6948540211,
0.1545419097,
-0.1789019853,
0.1774964184,
0.0536919162,
0.2564898431,
0.4109508097,
0.1796242595,
-0.2367511094,
0.5843453407,
-0.1804626733,
-0.2746453285,
0.3516729772,
0.2912799716,
-0.2019645125,
-0.2854033709,
-0.3173145056,
0.4004344642,
-0.768641293,
0.1706130952,
0.474514097,
0.4785028994,
-0.3245688081,
0.4264810383,
-0.3204956949,
0.5928553939,
-0.0611463226,
-0.4801362157,
0.2496056259,
0.0669854581,
-0.5510078073,
0.1986054927,
0.5015469193,
0.2480895966,
0.1419245601,
0.0129224788,
-0.5482365489,
-0.0689820275,
0.0121290814,
-0.8574280739,
0.274751991,
-0.052528441,
-0.7184583545,
-0.4044121802,
-0.0666904449,
-0.7379680872,
-0.5694939494,
-0.3623492122,
0.5590708852,
0.2462448627,
-0.0557691157,
-0.0631637126,
-0.1053397283,
0.5443742871,
0.4620507658,
-0.8781710863,
0.3944218159,
1.0579612255,
0.7228471637,
-0.0877851993,
-0.1278936714,
-0.9682237506,
0.269846797,
-0.1685074121,
0.5411844254,
-0.5003418326,
-0.0947365463,
-0.0618236847,
-0.2413149029,
0.2803726494,
-0.5113108754,
0.5667660236,
-0.5592401624,
0.2911140919,
-0.157602638,
-0.6993244886,
-0.2749322057,
0.478877157,
-0.3510919809,
0.296856761,
0.2446923256,
-0.8249623179,
0.7963870168,
-0.925747335,
-0.3076073527,
0.3526212871,
-0.7286484838,
-0.4883036911,
0.0442112833,
-0.2502366006,
0.6373810768,
-0.0197463557,
0.0010654497,
-0.4833578169,
-0.7024832964,
0.1550813615,
-0.7231916785,
0.6920169592,
0.3511783481,
-0.6049240828,
-0.0164339282,
-0.2473684102,
-0.1400734931,
-0.0499301888,
-0.4672418535,
0.0895774737,
-0.2201530039,
-0.0605489127,
0.3461093307,
-0.0803292394,
-0.3861396015,
-0.2645737529,
-0.5248169899,
0.2462315708,
1.3394254446,
-0.5504904985,
0.9476476312,
-0.4057353139,
0.6345771551,
-0.0536123216,
0.4096913636,
0.158986941,
-0.6206637621,
-0.4945727587,
-0.4822589755,
0.4378617406,
0.5225608945,
-0.536896944,
-0.0410250984,
-0.3239368796,
0.0699378029,
-0.4104598761,
0.1922989637,
0.3748733103,
0.7739508152,
-0.0738482997,
-0.2114443779,
-0.3102554381,
-0.8639153838,
-0.260813266,
0.0640882626,
0.003898801,
0.5764291883,
0.3806307614,
-0.1551547796,
1.05260396,
-0.1039275602,
-0.6362579465,
-0.2611323893,
-0.0736155659,
0.3720778823,
0.1750896275,
0.7237589955,
-0.8464748859,
-0.4035274982,
0.0823270604,
-0.8217014074,
-0.1618262976,
0.2991690338,
-0.1665050089,
0.4185010195,
0.5373648405,
-0.136828512,
0.6125302911,
0.435583055,
-0.147708863,
0.2662818134,
0.0994410664,
0.2500357032,
-0.6968562603,
-0.1910808533,
-0.0628237948,
-0.6366629601,
-0.3370723426,
-0.0207694862,
-0.1374244988,
0.1991169602,
-0.9776188135,
0.9127099514,
0.0572306998,
-0.5998740792,
-0.6083916426,
0.181096226,
-0.2570991814,
0.2813111246,
-0.3080187142,
0.5925745368,
0.4884572625,
-0.7211511135,
-0.0472360738,
-0.1401291341,
-0.2391103804,
0.7974455953,
-0.1583516896,
-0.0204013679,
-0.3137707412,
0.3923687339,
-0.4929668009,
-0.3939968348,
0.2579065561,
-0.2833551168,
0.2609812617,
-0.5930095911,
-0.5039019585,
-0.078333348,
-0.2955676913,
0.6524267793,
0.7936456203,
-0.7085003257,
0.7339799404,
0.5351477861,
-0.1210575178,
-0.8078834414,
-0.8937868476,
-0.1416213214,
-0.7477511168,
-0.3246997595,
0.310592562,
-0.0510381497,
-0.3672841489,
-0.2996703088,
-0.0024777649,
-0.0698847845,
0.4025171101,
0.382243067,
0.0196332,
0.1498665512,
0.016147444,
0.1167254224,
-0.1311452985,
-0.1746624112,
-0.0385969952,
0.2740854919,
-0.2103435546,
-0.4771021307,
-0.4465699196,
0.1271615773,
0.0566144474,
0.2848100662,
0.2355286479,
0.764944613,
-0.5885301828,
-0.337156415,
-0.3912759721,
-0.1472366601,
-0.5751161575,
0.1999141574,
-0.383563906,
-1.2628126144,
0.5123532414,
-0.0971404091,
0.2436998934,
0.1092264578,
0.6050798297,
-0.1967406124,
0.8963614702,
0.9183344245,
-0.1041514054,
0.5303047895,
-0.0020224317,
0.2109040618,
-0.4613155425,
-0.1930160969,
-0.5304390788,
-0.5285946727,
-0.8822132945,
-0.2775177956,
0.4549579918,
0.1147941351,
-0.6502518654,
-0.428902775,
-0.1590685993,
0.9443315268,
0.6202577949,
-0.0788598955,
0.4144990146,
0.0447962396,
-0.0068788258,
-0.0999754667,
-0.6734918952,
-0.8342680931,
1.1331317425,
0.568751514,
0.7087625265,
0.3778380752,
0.911180079,
0.4186881781,
0.9064401388,
-0.9517871737,
0.4810541868,
-0.5119043589,
-0.5715144873,
-0.1530650258,
-0.6612536311,
-0.7446599603,
0.1835234761,
-0.1970166117,
-0.5231413841,
-0.0533615276,
0.2639703155,
-0.4326291382,
0.3329913616,
-0.8078783751,
0.719512403,
-0.2823517323,
-0.3472781479,
-0.2775215209,
-0.567317009,
0.620942235,
-0.3327293694,
0.5953319073,
-0.4302109778,
-0.1640599966,
0.5875730515,
-0.086849004,
0.8515632749,
-0.4854713678,
0.0274497923,
0.0455208458,
0.100324586,
0.1256890446,
0.0817763582,
-0.272721678,
0.444414854,
-0.4430461526,
-0.382856518,
-0.4733968377,
0.7402324677,
-0.4259486496,
-0.4638139307,
-0.5725045204,
-0.3082953393,
-0.1020851061,
0.2017956525,
0.0796444193,
0.0576185621,
0.080400303,
-0.0531748794,
0.4552332461,
-0.3682699203,
0.7880384922,
0.5268344879,
-0.3698145449,
0.0532563142,
0.6750237942,
-0.1262435466,
0.1872961372,
0.2346587032,
0.3075249493,
-0.4812345505,
-0.6450259089,
-0.1454178095,
-0.1610217243,
-0.9717162251,
-0.6791527271,
-0.3460516632,
-0.2196344882,
-0.272836864,
-0.2545084953,
-0.1229472831,
-0.3042054772,
-0.2019704878,
-0.0771137178,
0.143864423,
0.9230357409,
-0.1760746241,
0.4474411011,
-0.4586958885,
0.2955150902,
0.6494575143,
0.7616677284,
-0.1360267103,
-0.7949790359,
-0.0562237576,
-0.0701795369,
-0.4681608975,
-0.3340052068,
0.1089019552,
0.1380274594,
0.8621883988,
0.3065158725,
-0.2275518626,
0.3877021372,
-0.7463302016,
0.6414561868,
0.3027020097,
-1.0704761744,
0.3694716096,
-0.0902902558,
-0.1122839227,
0.4286495447,
0.1998935044,
-0.2027587891,
-0.3910039663,
-0.2508172989,
-0.6747316718,
0.8586691618,
0.1687648743,
0.3615420461,
0.0929996744,
0.4930355251,
0.3682417572,
0.3122990727,
-1.1955932379,
-0.0896133184,
-0.1542035192,
-0.3631318212,
0.180631727,
0.0116084581,
-0.1483413279,
-0.0694083795,
0.408118993,
-0.3104571104,
0.1952851415,
-0.2700566947,
-0.2161923349,
0.0817394331,
0.5217919946,
0.4923928082,
0.6161225438,
-0.0482001528,
0.0854013711,
0.3658748269,
-0.1039693281,
0.095030345,
-0.0084512215,
-0.1432816088,
-0.369174093,
0.0449128523,
0.5517126918,
0.0772170946,
-0.5798489451,
0.8443999887,
-0.1972762048,
-0.1124903187,
-0.1206294373,
0.2618424296,
-0.2281772345,
0.672252357,
0.3251453042,
-0.1508228779,
0.6221227646,
-0.4261416197,
0.1965169609,
0.5728641152,
-0.171250388,
0.2415828556,
0.7166760564,
0.3336139023,
-0.102145426,
0.4574109912,
-0.7486829758,
-0.494538039,
0.4294441938,
0.2849213183,
0.8023493886,
0.1395614147,
-0.0377734341,
0.006392139,
0.0708269775,
-0.0960604548,
-0.102509968,
0.0797557458,
-0.8519611955,
-0.4227851629,
-0.8613353968,
-0.3810616136,
-0.0680936426,
-0.2160714865,
0.4839346111,
-0.6937140226,
-0.3826786876,
-0.1603699476,
-0.1237060428,
-0.9668464065,
0.0640358776,
0.5192328691,
0.6452323794,
-0.7670651078,
0.5732984543,
0.4984067678,
-0.3570019901,
-0.5205925703,
0.0897587985,
0.2233051658,
-0.6943826675,
0.9104375243,
0.4083150923,
-0.2479529232,
-0.0943514854,
-0.7716004848,
-0.1900359541,
1.247926712,
0.7366378903,
-0.6647182107,
0.2023608983,
0.1812685132,
0.1837976277,
-0.4353001118,
0.3952763677,
0.5834624767,
0.2784045339,
-0.0810502023,
-1.2542155981,
-0.1871042997,
0.3147264719,
0.1049053296,
-0.2629276216,
-0.5703099966,
0.7791349292,
-0.2669498622,
-0.1627172232,
-0.2201758474,
0.6145951748,
0.6751772165,
0.6921323538,
0.6684858799,
0.4328930974,
0.7799328566,
-0.2109764218,
1.1330450773,
0.3559522927,
0.2693759501,
1.1881870031,
-0.458368659,
0.6978741288,
0.3553473651,
-0.2263602763,
0.3652103245,
0.6139665246,
0.2687828541,
0.5525962114,
0.3671048582,
-0.5275558829,
-0.0883099064,
-0.1989915818,
-0.1752973646,
0.636446178,
0.2376505584,
-0.0816993043,
-0.2592135668,
0.1728458554,
0.0034000897,
0.1758603454,
-0.8588171601,
0.8413575888,
0.3731945455,
-0.1494731903,
0.0107234698,
0.2911350727,
1.4219073057,
-0.3365948796,
-0.2184111476,
-0.3176481128,
0.264698267,
-0.4165838659,
-1.0889464617,
0.1008796617,
0.2205571681,
-0.2693787515,
-0.2787708342,
0.5651398301,
-0.1378322393,
-0.2753870487,
0.3110437393,
0.3249613047,
0.398486793,
0.0522573628,
-0.8063514829,
-0.0801042467,
-0.2317981869,
0.1692163497,
0.5831051469,
0.5691507459,
-0.1724427342,
0.6922730207,
0.2580231428,
-0.108592771,
0.3223741949,
0.4207487702,
0.4899260104,
-0.6048314571,
-0.5781522393,
-0.8867588043,
0.5162934065,
-0.0506075658,
0.204521209,
0.5553648472,
0.5205770731,
1.1251074076,
0.1568570882,
0.8216561675,
0.1514055133,
0.3831685483,
-0.6520718336,
0.8097686768,
-0.6363319755,
0.4443870187,
-0.291809231,
-0.7329623699,
-0.3665838242,
0.6848623157,
-0.202998355,
0.6517311335,
0.3168930113,
0.6726002693,
-0.2549216151,
-0.1896205246,
0.4503435791,
-0.0301987976,
0.4712676704,
0.5682905316,
0.8368153572,
-0.3105767369,
0.5070141554,
0.0970906317,
-0.3562693,
-0.2132650018,
-1.3160564899,
-0.6417379975,
-0.0092981616,
-0.164007321,
-0.2775655389,
0.039313484,
0.959284246,
0.8748235703,
-0.6454055309,
-0.3471560776,
0.0578395166,
0.4031480551,
0.3684140444,
-0.2747779787,
-0.1609539688,
-0.5613228679,
-0.8438984156,
0.0461159609,
0.3718975186,
0.2767130435,
0.0478073508,
-0.5470754504,
0.2164969593,
-0.1744405031,
0.9175284505,
0.0177833084,
-0.6089112759,
-0.1556069255,
-0.6549785733,
-0.1441678703,
-0.0373241752,
0.6870188713,
-0.9930157065,
0.2083172202,
0.2957886159,
0.7278398871,
0.3230657578,
-0.20657067,
0.3780364394,
-1.0673960447,
0.3799219131,
0.4349682927,
0.4169809222,
0.4851852953,
-0.2750336528,
0.4674262106,
0.1969643533,
-0.6668381691,
-0.8816031814,
0.3429577947,
-0.7418982983,
-0.2491112649,
1.1577731371,
0.048186183,
-0.0487216823,
-0.1241795793,
0.023396384,
0.1204822809,
-0.4885919392,
0.6426135898,
0.4535506666,
-0.2165955901,
-0.0867564827,
-0.7926131487,
0.7129709721,
0.1375430077,
-1.0477262735,
-0.237631157,
0.5776235461,
0.4812144339,
-0.4277455211,
1.1236197948,
-0.3861626089,
0.271389544,
-0.6280310154,
-0.1668535173,
0.2759194374,
-0.1355658919,
-0.7604395151,
0.1139630228,
0.3412125111,
-0.0600479282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18496v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18496v3
|
Language Models Represent Beliefs of Self and Others
| 2024-02-28T17:25:59 | 2024-05-30T12:43:01 |
Wentao Zhu, Zhining Zhang, Yizhou Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Understanding and attributing mental states, known as Theory of Mind (ToM),
emerges as a fundamental capability for human social reasoning. While Large
Language Models (LLMs) appear to possess certain ToM abilities, the mechanisms
underlying these capabilities remain elusive. In this study, we discover that
it is possible to linearly decode the belief status from the perspectives of
various agents through neural activations of language models, indicating the
existence of internal representations of self and others' beliefs. By
manipulating these representations, we observe dramatic changes in the models'
ToM performance, underscoring their pivotal role in the social reasoning
process. Additionally, our findings extend to diverse social reasoning tasks
that involve different causal inference patterns, suggesting the potential
generalizability of these representations.
|
[
-0.3451711535,
-0.6445760727,
1.210523963,
0.0338320397,
-0.1525093317,
0.0329829901,
-0.4411925673,
-0.4667836428,
0.4127350748,
0.2380319089,
-0.3504636288,
0.0257606711,
-0.6509899497,
0.0389062241,
-0.204879269,
0.4881368577,
0.1338053346,
0.1921465993,
-0.0308761951,
-0.0649139285,
-0.2282514274,
-0.7627412677,
-0.7250176668,
-0.8802684546,
0.7044724226,
-0.2929441631,
0.7514263988,
0.3474372029,
0.2469199598,
0.2457184941,
0.1342784017,
0.0874140635,
-0.3754149079,
0.3099573851,
-0.6632258892,
-0.9135236144,
-0.2707503438,
0.2078445405,
0.8479053974,
0.7069641948,
0.0108384825,
0.017121708,
0.2983846664,
0.3614099622,
-0.3258470297,
0.4538779557,
-0.9217985272,
-0.2136149406,
0.2188773155,
-0.2773605287,
-0.6261820197,
-0.3000082076,
0.2137740403,
-0.2407190502,
0.1636160463,
-0.0648710951,
0.8110679388,
0.2007126212,
-0.5181075335,
-0.2271689177,
-0.8359917402,
0.6852568388,
-0.6768923402,
0.2448130548,
0.5754826069,
0.2440333366,
-0.3205171227,
-0.2341950536,
-0.8229352236,
-0.2983992398,
-0.2337937057,
-0.2452340722,
-0.156790629,
0.4030034542,
0.2943222523,
0.1988054514,
-0.1901505142,
-0.3825434446,
-0.0895504281,
-0.0855764076,
0.5832282305,
0.013042599,
0.48470065,
-0.1807826608,
0.0004459938,
-0.1471329778,
-0.4460333288,
-0.0172095895,
-0.0172159895,
0.3677900434,
-0.1300288737,
0.3187346756,
0.0161456633,
0.4638945162,
0.1141162589,
-0.0329553746,
0.0044663674,
0.1783636361,
-0.651088357,
-0.2338474244,
0.4968664944,
0.118757695,
0.5236189365,
-0.092778042,
-0.2920210063,
0.5214220881,
0.4015185535,
-0.16962035,
0.0293638967,
0.1120511293,
-0.6524362564,
-0.1451493055,
0.0357247405,
-0.2811798155,
-0.7084510922,
-0.3019790053,
0.4798366427,
-0.4899983704,
-0.7097815275,
0.2935295105,
-0.2709325254,
0.3224676251,
0.4519907236,
-0.9264332056,
0.4363790452,
0.5631774664,
0.5824677348,
0.2953549027,
-0.3790147007,
0.2375477403,
0.4013490081,
-0.7030231357,
0.6980193257,
-0.7256614566,
-0.259650439,
0.000777512,
0.1725813597,
-0.1769496053,
-0.1608245373,
-0.026701292,
-0.4755116105,
-0.0225592181,
-0.8948230743,
-0.5897330642,
-0.5155914426,
0.1901255697,
-0.4675530791,
0.5213759542,
-0.2342392653,
-0.2870659828,
0.1212757751,
-0.4655666649,
-0.2123056054,
0.061664734,
-0.6337742805,
0.2484382987,
0.6454514861,
-0.038466569,
0.800021708,
-0.6962773204,
0.5021237731,
-0.7256112695,
-0.3105454743,
0.6521401405,
-0.4685652554,
0.951320231,
0.1955156326,
-0.4603040814,
-0.0415015668,
-0.3378424048,
-0.0504651256,
0.495650351,
-0.1532821059,
-0.6629313827,
0.237514779,
-0.6214091182,
0.1364232302,
0.1204325706,
-0.4359419048,
0.2572716177,
-0.3378398418,
0.3843175769,
0.9720306396,
0.0176316313,
0.5687793493,
-0.3243746758,
0.3746656179,
0.0015853746,
-0.1651974469,
-0.0788528472,
-0.7722084522,
-0.9641215205,
0.0188376401,
-0.2665194869,
0.1294356585,
-0.5648674965,
0.1690496951,
-0.2285109162,
-0.1313457042,
-0.5631946325,
0.0046100705,
0.4848804772,
-0.0077497438,
0.0982553586,
0.0573288426,
-0.3266430199,
-1.1495212317,
-0.4667164981,
-0.5143022537,
0.0070963758,
0.1337520778,
0.5865774155,
-0.2324792892,
0.8269814253,
-0.4384950697,
0.079954274,
-0.4794749022,
0.2048614472,
0.2477281839,
0.3698358834,
0.7061177492,
-0.4295915067,
0.0111434823,
0.0674154758,
-1.1398048401,
0.1951495111,
-0.4643812776,
-0.1399447173,
0.0682256445,
0.3756313622,
-0.6114783287,
0.5910774469,
0.3879190981,
-0.5705671906,
0.2317172885,
-0.3831698298,
0.2536951303,
-0.9949876666,
-0.4435918331,
0.2288080901,
-0.133173272,
-0.5949286222,
0.2480778396,
0.1513115168,
0.1674641073,
0.0727557763,
0.5675210953,
-0.7147663236,
-0.1118378565,
-0.3097190857,
0.1607962996,
-0.0322999321,
0.7000998855,
-0.0043262737,
0.5135185719,
0.6787717938,
-0.6499039531,
0.1927454323,
-0.2704532743,
-0.1981132925,
0.4176897705,
-0.6745178103,
0.2814791501,
-0.6657924652,
0.2003616095,
-1.2451968193,
-0.4330961406,
0.2496084273,
-0.4179016352,
0.1439977288,
-0.0959805027,
-0.537501514,
-0.3434315324,
0.1829839349,
0.1633693874,
0.5732643008,
-0.3203613162,
0.873234868,
0.6010388136,
0.2909440398,
-0.0572130531,
-1.0087058544,
0.0184620768,
-0.1673664749,
-0.4792634845,
0.1475589871,
0.0380682461,
-0.8284434676,
0.0239391997,
0.0925305411,
-0.1361577362,
-0.0270356834,
0.3373172879,
0.1156064942,
-0.1969637275,
0.5584244728,
0.2359794825,
0.0661022365,
0.4575399756,
-0.4201196134,
0.5007200837,
-0.1859534681,
-0.5050503016,
-0.463814348,
0.3066102862,
0.707550168,
-0.187338084,
0.9004547,
-0.0662927777,
-0.8181782365,
-0.4756945968,
-0.6036520004,
-0.37589854,
-0.4408873618,
0.2050366849,
-0.6384087205,
-0.7938464284,
0.7063907385,
0.1356691718,
-0.3333207965,
0.1932990253,
0.5496597886,
-0.1326985806,
1.174665451,
0.4872586429,
-0.0394876115,
0.3567914665,
-0.1835791767,
0.2769555449,
-0.79766047,
-0.0166700818,
-0.2046587467,
-0.197884649,
-0.2533874512,
-0.7016547918,
0.2448171973,
-0.0209211912,
-0.2700121999,
0.0883231983,
-0.4551489651,
0.5230669379,
0.3688891232,
0.397575289,
0.0241458807,
-0.0879090056,
-0.3258007765,
0.1038513407,
-0.3606018722,
-0.7801631689,
1.1323106289,
0.6090225577,
0.6241153479,
0.1984363198,
0.4894400835,
0.4111898541,
0.3441771269,
-0.4925816953,
0.7984970212,
0.2234126478,
-1.0827702284,
-0.2929597199,
0.0573525913,
-0.7793095708,
0.5341205597,
-0.1392644644,
-1.1234866381,
0.4401270449,
0.1596642733,
-0.3568437397,
0.4971836209,
-0.6827626228,
0.5171298981,
-0.0354707725,
-0.1723309457,
-0.875048697,
-0.3665705919,
0.4442199469,
0.1776408255,
0.0956481174,
-0.3186565638,
0.2866192758,
0.5261964202,
-0.080227904,
1.1052678823,
-0.3211290836,
-0.4430899024,
0.3733914793,
0.2674993873,
0.4733505249,
-0.0561594777,
-0.25131163,
0.0763816461,
-0.1136422083,
-0.362036258,
-1.0042937994,
0.5792358518,
-0.7690836787,
-1.0883247852,
-0.3973736763,
-0.5664426684,
-0.2353655994,
0.117440775,
-0.1572295129,
0.4124002457,
-0.2117068619,
0.2005074769,
0.7030995488,
-0.18153584,
0.2525667846,
0.3158413768,
-0.5868549347,
-0.0826219618,
0.644962728,
0.2127267271,
0.6045767069,
0.219614476,
0.0825421959,
-0.1371278167,
-0.3255647123,
0.2573557496,
0.6073162556,
-1.0920804739,
0.2749894857,
-0.5901818275,
0.044171758,
-0.3735291362,
-0.2122040242,
-0.2806406319,
-0.1361424178,
-0.1473370492,
-0.3690817058,
0.072462447,
1.1986814737,
-0.1355417818,
0.3789407611,
-0.1647226661,
0.4786896408,
0.5933138728,
0.3963919878,
0.442325592,
-0.268938601,
-0.3276302218,
0.4926407933,
0.1045769975,
-1.3056561947,
0.2089408636,
-0.2219275683,
0.7629697323,
0.5952363014,
-0.2208486944,
0.7495525479,
-0.3024594486,
0.6230575442,
-0.0071321526,
-1.0468711853,
0.647104919,
-0.6541275978,
0.1783010513,
0.0643595979,
0.3128254414,
-0.4995250404,
-0.6454909444,
-0.5287555456,
-0.1302611977,
0.6233690977,
0.0207263269,
0.2843916118,
-0.4191555381,
0.4195790291,
-0.1169342101,
-0.1229460239,
-0.934476316,
-0.3255032599,
-0.2057626098,
-0.039680589,
-0.1275711954,
-0.4381007552,
-0.1514269263,
-0.4928818345,
0.3455230892,
-0.248793453,
0.7680754066,
0.414744705,
0.0029554521,
-0.3270480633,
0.2125028372,
0.4079814851,
0.8099619746,
-0.133227095,
0.3127114475,
0.1282313317,
-0.0406251512,
0.2409214377,
-0.341171056,
0.0278730802,
-0.2141010165,
0.3807917535,
0.6774696112,
0.3625105023,
-0.2601950467,
0.2472123057,
-0.1103530675,
-0.0384054966,
-0.5389514565,
0.1883084625,
0.2585366368,
0.6497555971,
0.657998085,
0.0954938605,
-0.0689219311,
-1.0212489367,
-0.0512836054,
0.6305715442,
-0.3072583377,
-0.7083926797,
0.8143039346,
-0.0480330586,
-0.3036572337,
0.1357609332,
-0.3093706071,
-0.3999826908,
0.5663186312,
0.752687037,
1.2159045935,
-0.2999855876,
0.361913532,
0.2508644164,
0.5536965728,
-0.1668504477,
0.4327536821,
0.1293363869,
-1.5750671625,
-0.3027226627,
-0.4044068754,
0.0137639046,
0.1454183757,
-0.6733276248,
-0.153045699,
-0.7105115652,
-0.4277154803,
0.0926764235,
-0.3850642443,
-0.7326468825,
0.2832553685,
0.5880564451,
0.446210593,
-0.736399591,
1.3609930277,
0.6340618134,
-0.6047825813,
-0.9026831985,
0.2723217905,
0.2302549928,
-0.9154424667,
0.8396638632,
0.0132681103,
-0.4919358194,
-0.0356278829,
-0.7188481688,
-1.0773453712,
0.7988861203,
0.6678243876,
-0.2821289301,
-0.409735173,
0.033651486,
0.735817492,
-0.7845466137,
0.1414525062,
0.4836711287,
0.3934769332,
-0.3840459585,
-0.7222287059,
0.3974646926,
-0.2166376412,
0.2240915447,
-0.1217190325,
-0.5994511247,
1.0210016966,
-0.1112469584,
-0.3656439185,
-0.235792473,
0.7419931889,
0.2387211174,
-0.0784332976,
0.4406637549,
0.2150884569,
0.8434276581,
0.0458711088,
1.3593745232,
-0.404579103,
0.2447550744,
0.8170318604,
-0.1957087517,
0.5254275203,
0.3317482471,
-0.2726776302,
0.7051928639,
0.2593062222,
0.3896206021,
0.4524545074,
-0.0619724467,
-0.1566234678,
-0.7202188969,
0.0727887303,
-0.1013991237,
0.4197645187,
0.8456918001,
-0.6915075779,
0.0918489546,
-0.0484868586,
0.0890518576,
0.2447429299,
-0.3464681804,
0.4589597583,
0.2760789096,
-0.7602091432,
0.6743643284,
-0.2527048886,
0.4859754741,
-0.5323600173,
-0.2025865167,
0.0979922786,
0.3197126985,
0.241347909,
-0.8673397303,
0.2055620998,
-0.3954548836,
-0.210098505,
-0.6163905859,
0.9610081315,
-0.2042006999,
-0.2644804418,
0.8224547505,
0.4663841426,
0.1263198107,
-0.1569287628,
-0.5467948318,
-0.0048153461,
0.2866119444,
-0.3773739934,
0.1998243034,
0.5738614798,
-0.0758719295,
0.9290094376,
0.4292902946,
0.2775819004,
0.0185628943,
0.0313409157,
0.8520071507,
-1.0283380747,
-0.4082114995,
-1.1112445593,
0.3804932237,
-0.0505658202,
-0.0704000816,
0.7774982452,
-0.1818974614,
0.817458272,
-0.1454248726,
0.9993549585,
0.0760338902,
0.413456589,
-0.3284709454,
1.0654438734,
-0.6049619317,
0.1862880588,
-0.5233502388,
-0.5494416952,
-0.06190525,
0.9247909188,
-0.6220892072,
-0.0539149754,
0.7845097184,
0.6004166007,
0.2870443463,
0.2519958317,
0.6428416967,
0.5979093909,
0.4224635959,
0.3976011276,
0.8785347939,
-0.0127225295,
-0.028355198,
-0.082182534,
-0.2432262003,
0.0346973054,
-0.539334476,
-1.3391412497,
-0.9680011868,
0.0021301198,
-0.2458121181,
0.1408476233,
1.1627446413,
0.652155757,
-0.5804212689,
-0.409365952,
-0.1153594926,
0.2769356072,
-0.2185296863,
-0.2221380472,
-0.0200537574,
-0.3960182667,
-0.5520640016,
0.4353368282,
0.4723218679,
0.1228925884,
-0.7416477203,
0.0015474381,
-0.3514868617,
0.6266773343,
0.6468987465,
0.0810310096,
-1.276676178,
-0.7052586675,
-0.2827985287,
-0.125426203,
0.0160526354,
0.8596163392,
-0.8628971577,
0.4476734698,
0.4368551672,
0.302815944,
0.1624448895,
-0.3034104109,
1.0329920053,
-0.1951208711,
0.3461175263,
0.1169047207,
0.8171381354,
0.0229944028,
-0.4364195466,
0.3589783311,
0.2421175689,
-0.3568581641,
-0.818867147,
0.4769068658,
-0.5550147295,
-0.5894170403,
1.0605634451,
-0.1568390429,
-0.4989295304,
-0.0837042406,
-0.0637938827,
0.299172163,
-0.3435682058,
0.8673124909,
0.9473823309,
-0.1671228707,
-0.3238823116,
-0.5218729377,
0.458430171,
0.38108477,
-0.5509170294,
0.1597364694,
0.4655208886,
0.1106370538,
0.3594070673,
0.9668018818,
0.1014714912,
-0.0338962413,
0.1347711533,
0.1046773195,
0.4780825377,
-0.2770008147,
-0.2579277754,
0.2221728712,
0.1661191434,
0.096859999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18479v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18479v2
|
NewsQs: Multi-Source Question Generation for the Inquiring Mind
| 2024-02-28T16:59:35 | 2024-06-15T15:30:53 |
Alyssa Hwang, Kalpit Dixit, Miguel Ballesteros, Yassine Benajiba, Vittorio Castelli, Markus Dreyer, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present NewsQs (news-cues), a dataset that provides question-answer pairs
for multiple news documents. To create NewsQs, we augment a traditional
multi-document summarization dataset with questions automatically generated by
a T5-Large model fine-tuned on FAQ-style news articles from the News On the Web
corpus. We show that fine-tuning a model with control codes produces questions
that are judged acceptable more often than the same model without them as
measured through human evaluation. We use a QNLI model with high correlation
with human annotations to filter our data. We release our final dataset of
high-quality questions, answers, and document clusters as a resource for future
work in query-based multi-document summarization.
|
[
-0.67437464,
-0.7019999027,
0.482694149,
-0.1271678954,
-0.3490850925,
-0.041902516,
0.1050831601,
-0.1423837543,
0.2515066266,
0.6506388187,
-0.6352615952,
-0.3842977285,
-0.1875385791,
0.2687266171,
-0.7470522523,
1.2565897703,
0.2423478514,
0.0969422311,
-0.4929519892,
-0.313470453,
0.1593983024,
-0.3985394537,
-0.6667696238,
0.1648690403,
0.6758450866,
0.6105930805,
0.7813503742,
0.0750576928,
0.3577629626,
0.0963160321,
0.0447581373,
0.4646163881,
-0.3177678287,
0.2012067288,
0.0297675412,
-0.6147266626,
-0.0492907763,
0.1862449199,
0.6082627773,
0.5860990882,
0.0195116103,
0.4568364322,
-0.254154712,
0.7724425793,
-0.5372318029,
-0.4367934167,
-0.6354412436,
-0.022069307,
-0.0832251385,
-0.3229248226,
-0.146734491,
-0.8890037537,
-0.16952838,
-0.5613002181,
0.5093071461,
0.0806063116,
0.8732048273,
0.2182299197,
-0.8914167285,
-0.3737267554,
-0.3507093191,
0.5710862875,
-0.5648832917,
0.4142274857,
0.3342875242,
0.3223181069,
0.050337676,
-0.6254225373,
-0.6239623427,
0.1487501562,
-0.1068274528,
0.2927511036,
-0.0219993982,
-0.4456430376,
0.1935844868,
0.3232119381,
-0.7799024582,
-0.4910340607,
-0.7575616241,
0.0203560553,
0.716730535,
0.3540508151,
0.1103785932,
-0.3940543234,
0.0748606846,
0.0465563908,
-0.658085525,
0.1880917102,
0.5166668296,
0.0710100085,
0.1803532988,
0.6075798273,
-0.469181031,
0.9359185696,
0.2387693077,
-0.0069697443,
-0.0475735888,
-0.8026289344,
0.2219909579,
-0.2127715945,
0.6345245242,
1.008654356,
0.0887822881,
-0.2139927,
0.154336229,
-0.2262336165,
0.3433436155,
-0.5619258285,
0.0529354922,
0.6873455644,
-0.233982712,
-0.5797949433,
0.1319428682,
-0.6085420847,
-0.4839434922,
-0.288013339,
0.2534942925,
-0.1265588403,
-0.2254887074,
0.0690066889,
-0.7616395354,
0.5200120807,
0.4566263855,
-0.6104729176,
0.0046800002,
0.2321254164,
0.4434688389,
-0.0338611864,
-0.1594863385,
-0.5078270435,
0.2912412882,
-0.503757894,
0.8974824548,
-0.2656335831,
-0.2999616265,
-0.0703190416,
-0.0967318267,
0.1727149636,
-0.2680942714,
0.4518932402,
-0.6834375858,
0.8295017481,
-0.7281123996,
-0.5595340133,
0.0981229246,
0.5206369758,
-0.6235097647,
0.925817132,
0.2228961885,
-1.0712860823,
0.2224544138,
-0.5812551975,
-0.5376607776,
-0.0805145279,
-0.2455864996,
-0.1744845212,
-0.0148202563,
0.470254451,
0.291541934,
-0.4126410782,
0.2827790976,
-0.0456340648,
-0.0543846227,
0.5145906806,
-0.2249925733,
0.7455455661,
0.3645407856,
0.3120573759,
0.1361777931,
-0.7554050684,
0.2686534524,
-0.0228439942,
-0.5071673989,
-0.3450500369,
-0.0921009704,
-0.1587619781,
0.3345016241,
0.1832986772,
-0.5176149011,
-0.0437377058,
-0.0098762652,
0.6319920421,
0.0636218786,
0.6145364642,
0.433709234,
-0.6757679582,
0.4616401792,
0.0617177971,
0.4703747928,
-0.3001419604,
-0.448104769,
-0.6573652625,
0.4312882423,
0.0769901201,
0.4295838177,
-0.9624091983,
0.2825040817,
0.1116552427,
-0.7306888103,
-0.5876522064,
-0.0154758934,
0.1191021129,
0.6734740734,
0.4266419113,
0.1468510032,
-0.3440799415,
-0.810094893,
-0.2599517703,
0.1009506658,
-0.1821338981,
0.2333520949,
0.1796250343,
0.6248736978,
1.0348645449,
-0.7157991529,
0.2674475014,
-0.2537237704,
0.4437493086,
0.0973353609,
0.4082004428,
0.6469672918,
-1.1298708916,
-0.0977945849,
-0.6093788147,
-0.7253881097,
0.010640569,
-0.1768823117,
-0.4251473248,
-0.0980904847,
0.7071664929,
-0.7556307316,
-0.0407109857,
0.2532370687,
-0.2619499862,
0.5943975449,
0.142572239,
0.5108129978,
-1.6095333099,
0.0379008166,
-0.0883508623,
-0.0216393135,
-0.4831596613,
0.238665536,
0.2781211138,
-0.4182400703,
-0.6033812165,
0.4520902336,
-0.2401617467,
-0.1135353372,
-0.0213987697,
0.4210399687,
0.7067871094,
0.3337370753,
-0.2782516778,
0.794113338,
0.2990444303,
-0.8825849295,
0.7225902677,
0.3070921004,
-0.2403890193,
0.6304154992,
-0.8168407679,
0.2824266851,
-0.5612086654,
0.3025723398,
-1.147742033,
-0.476780206,
-0.0548598208,
-0.6331064105,
-0.1979782432,
0.0725284517,
-0.529863894,
-0.501680553,
-0.6672392488,
0.2608335614,
0.1151815951,
-0.2687741518,
0.2602193952,
0.4142746031,
-0.2666145265,
-0.4843919575,
-0.6851949692,
-0.0593886226,
-0.0054956456,
-0.6189889908,
0.1037360951,
-0.3547568917,
-0.2350152135,
0.3533989787,
-0.0352640077,
-0.2680132091,
0.102701664,
-0.0718803182,
0.0806708336,
-0.2356437296,
0.4645425677,
0.5914835334,
0.4993000925,
0.1064554751,
-0.2493912131,
0.3052558601,
0.0677122474,
-0.3296719491,
0.004874954,
1.0338782072,
0.8818512559,
-0.8403204083,
0.3714120984,
0.5687075257,
-0.3382932842,
0.0896008536,
-0.5496488214,
-0.1985391527,
-0.3538771272,
0.2299422622,
-0.2720130682,
-1.0772277117,
0.4009147882,
0.305711925,
0.3569924533,
0.4027673602,
0.4344952404,
-0.2155093998,
1.1152844429,
0.0915379599,
-0.0434569865,
0.3314878047,
-0.0389457382,
-0.2354746759,
-0.5005782843,
-0.127768293,
-0.6353962421,
-0.1838459969,
-0.1494594961,
-0.2105309516,
0.5731710792,
0.1954908818,
-0.2114753574,
0.0044891913,
-0.4271298349,
0.6539080143,
1.0359011889,
0.1535126567,
0.5415122509,
-0.3648823798,
0.1041123345,
0.3200778663,
-0.6361226439,
-0.3439983428,
1.2532505989,
-0.164239049,
0.7283720374,
0.1803993136,
0.570094049,
0.1776625514,
-0.1010698974,
-0.4807024896,
0.3134448826,
0.0993918478,
-1.0307807922,
-0.5898912549,
-0.3975942731,
-0.8144338131,
0.1649394184,
-0.3967956305,
-0.2775425017,
0.1245123222,
-0.1489774585,
-1.0453163385,
0.1028810069,
-0.8574528098,
0.5782141685,
-0.2665678263,
-0.2276894003,
-0.1283967942,
-0.7707406878,
0.6611828208,
0.0713835955,
0.1216766089,
-0.1574490219,
0.0424831733,
0.6174892783,
-0.0238222703,
0.4180693924,
-0.0182117652,
-0.0524442233,
0.6860759258,
-0.3227749169,
0.080599077,
0.5527377725,
-0.1018813327,
-0.3898511231,
0.1718353182,
-0.4098971188,
-0.8148069978,
0.4830596745,
-0.6347167492,
-0.7196342945,
-0.0515118577,
-0.7457315326,
-0.4092233777,
0.2934441566,
0.3938228488,
0.7619154453,
-0.0669282302,
0.254100889,
0.683303833,
-0.3131170571,
0.3388245404,
0.7629967332,
-0.3239927292,
-0.3473932147,
0.5294455886,
0.1240124181,
0.2063597292,
0.5010076761,
-0.014670386,
-0.3783693016,
-0.3484978676,
-0.7449651361,
0.1045951769,
-0.5367098451,
-0.4424149692,
-0.6382728219,
-0.3473927677,
-0.7265161276,
0.1485504061,
-0.1443289369,
-0.6201803684,
-0.3664168417,
-0.2742796838,
0.461894542,
0.5117044449,
0.2759419382,
-0.0019637251,
-1.2822736502,
0.6404883862,
0.7351594567,
0.1489552706,
-0.3726058006,
-0.2579483688,
-0.3252135813,
0.0634390637,
-0.5015318394,
-1.1213148832,
0.0041943025,
0.0117366966,
0.4153986871,
0.3336422145,
0.5957792401,
0.2019858807,
-0.3068856895,
0.9414678216,
0.0379447378,
-0.6717092395,
0.8602233529,
-0.7018887997,
0.5083340406,
0.7415710092,
0.5539588332,
-0.722379148,
-0.9362617135,
-0.5533702374,
-0.580516398,
0.5368316174,
-0.032000307,
0.3150234222,
-0.1955995411,
0.684433043,
0.0341451503,
0.426526159,
-0.2279974371,
-0.0862284973,
-0.3486247957,
-0.1853264421,
0.3001101613,
-0.2180613428,
-0.4340277016,
-0.2814773917,
0.3539924324,
-0.2913024724,
0.1458761245,
0.3137288094,
0.0657516792,
-0.4616228342,
0.5183052421,
0.6638603806,
0.7388967872,
-0.2389815301,
0.0993661657,
0.0134235565,
-0.1750576645,
-0.1010923386,
0.1769123226,
-0.4263117909,
0.0802305266,
-0.0325691923,
0.6339981556,
0.0408755802,
-0.5820159912,
0.5659059882,
-0.4814124405,
-0.4985122979,
-0.2077035457,
0.2340024114,
0.3796381652,
0.2943582237,
0.6461011171,
0.0181406271,
0.2084801048,
-0.5063310266,
0.3397455215,
0.3322499096,
-0.0329522938,
-0.1378787905,
0.8206984997,
0.341454953,
0.0967280194,
0.4993133545,
-0.3450197577,
-0.1436262131,
0.5774369836,
0.1431472152,
0.3160459697,
-0.01208294,
0.5142282248,
0.4741755426,
0.2585116327,
-0.0512997471,
0.83181566,
0.0059656291,
-0.8874414563,
-0.3836401105,
-0.2636370659,
-0.7563331127,
0.3490017354,
-0.8084970713,
0.2876161337,
-0.4250050485,
-0.1965428293,
0.0731128752,
0.0601880774,
-0.3527858555,
0.5276043415,
-0.0285148676,
0.9246330261,
-0.8139051795,
0.7479622364,
0.854581058,
-0.9702031612,
-0.7986204624,
0.1536351591,
-0.2996766567,
-0.3892937601,
-0.0313883126,
-0.1547214836,
0.2732727826,
0.2959098518,
-0.9355803132,
-1.1119014025,
1.2132139206,
0.4354693592,
-0.0921110883,
-0.2942437828,
-0.0036636619,
0.2648759186,
-0.0419605263,
0.2912184,
0.4563735723,
0.3891739547,
0.0334307663,
-0.459202677,
-0.1071764976,
-0.4394856393,
-0.4886161685,
0.2705027461,
-0.8617330194,
1.1164326668,
-0.3911654353,
-0.0773513541,
-0.1228633597,
0.684156239,
0.1847893596,
0.4022762179,
0.392382443,
0.4609907269,
0.9852409363,
-0.0254158489,
1.1336369514,
-0.5613604188,
0.0755529404,
1.2189238071,
-0.015901804,
0.5875427723,
0.4045088589,
-0.1007666066,
0.1008634046,
0.6361166239,
0.0422484241,
0.408593446,
0.1600723267,
-0.1502270252,
-0.2455583066,
-0.3227094114,
-0.5118867755,
0.3435922563,
0.2984924614,
-0.1322173625,
-0.5269423127,
-0.0122553529,
-0.1302888244,
0.0607370101,
-0.2276954502,
0.6708984971,
-0.1802614331,
-0.9144507051,
0.2010498941,
0.0516851395,
0.413410455,
-0.5991173387,
0.2263389975,
-0.771943152,
-0.367076993,
-0.1816511005,
-0.9377406836,
0.3010138273,
0.0583410524,
-0.5260986686,
0.1082456633,
0.6662800312,
-0.7005202174,
-0.5544506311,
-0.4098629653,
1.0444760323,
0.1533227414,
-0.3176295161,
-0.5897478461,
-0.4384767413,
-0.0697824657,
-0.3407171071,
0.2273839563,
0.6745111346,
-0.0511703007,
0.4165789783,
0.6210371256,
-0.2134249806,
0.2682308853,
0.4523589313,
0.9336904883,
-0.7351626754,
-0.5360332131,
-0.2641071677,
0.4364004135,
-0.2811318934,
-0.6284290552,
0.7619962692,
0.6640059352,
0.5645949841,
0.0136668049,
1.1228723526,
0.0346275903,
0.8502191901,
-0.5254232287,
0.8230600953,
-0.8091404438,
-0.2033834457,
-0.093101263,
-0.4174549878,
-0.2033720911,
0.0990642607,
0.129723683,
-0.1114128754,
0.7252042294,
0.8172721267,
0.3948376775,
0.3888367414,
0.1900904328,
-0.2188159078,
0.1563821435,
0.5362924337,
1.0871561766,
-0.5060779452,
0.8394731879,
-0.2068503499,
0.0823733881,
0.0612163655,
-0.6119542718,
-0.8509876728,
-0.7321107984,
-0.2790485024,
-0.1684701592,
-0.1047680601,
0.8136974573,
0.3451204598,
-0.8935552239,
0.119885467,
-0.1075459197,
0.4737339914,
-0.0847693682,
-0.2584304512,
0.3238759041,
-0.6112600565,
-0.667814672,
0.266474396,
-0.0463695563,
0.0772293285,
-0.3841947317,
0.2788721025,
-0.4240926802,
0.0860229433,
0.4120230973,
0.0372125171,
-0.1909859627,
-0.2655417919,
0.3784035444,
-0.3150517642,
-0.1368846148,
0.9150978327,
-0.4512139261,
0.080506891,
0.5483829975,
0.6556445956,
0.2622782886,
0.2730132341,
0.4850780368,
-1.1579871178,
-0.0486852676,
0.1381583363,
0.1031419337,
0.3905873001,
-0.5673092604,
0.3623532951,
0.0966679305,
-0.31769225,
-0.4011527896,
0.1669005454,
-0.7932415009,
-0.4607712924,
1.1984581947,
0.2216678113,
-0.1583316177,
-0.3284307718,
-0.2738159001,
0.4613479376,
-0.5937740207,
0.6727209687,
0.8445814252,
-0.2129616588,
-0.4634479284,
-0.5143821239,
0.4760899544,
0.2743825018,
-0.9976068735,
0.0217346717,
0.7481921911,
0.1360679716,
0.1988144964,
0.6813230515,
-0.2371545285,
0.4947849512,
-0.0223213974,
-0.0084494911,
-0.1871871352,
-0.1007925346,
0.0484956726,
0.6215177178,
-0.056064453,
-0.3121496141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18458v1
|
Meta-Task Prompting Elicits Embedding from Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T16:35:52 | 2024-02-28T16:35:52 |
Yibin Lei, Di Wu, Tianyi Zhou, Tao Shen, Yu Cao, Chongyang Tao, Andrew Yates
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we introduce a new unsupervised embedding method, Meta-Task
Prompting with Explicit One-Word Limitation (MetaEOL), for generating
high-quality sentence embeddings from Large Language Models (LLMs) without the
need for model fine-tuning or task-specific engineering. Leveraging meta-task
prompting, MetaEOL guides LLMs to produce embeddings through a series of
carefully designed prompts that address multiple representational aspects. Our
comprehensive experiments demonstrate that embeddings averaged from various
meta-tasks yield competitive performance on Semantic Textual Similarity (STS)
benchmarks and excel in downstream tasks, surpassing contrastive-trained
models. Our findings suggest a new scaling law for embedding generation,
offering a versatile, resource-efficient approach for embedding extraction
across diverse sentence-centric scenarios.
|
[
-0.3836247623,
-0.7874589562,
0.7942193151,
0.3483752608,
-0.4582521617,
-0.3111601472,
-0.2627127767,
0.1965398341,
0.4363179505,
0.6347845793,
-0.8853586912,
-0.6086717844,
-0.5641390085,
0.1830530167,
-0.2246023268,
0.8317420483,
-0.0171379969,
-0.349458158,
-0.7205494046,
0.0118212486,
-0.7240471244,
-0.0413595065,
-0.0523317493,
-0.0276881307,
0.5129357576,
0.5609105825,
0.5259768367,
0.5983785987,
-0.0474320464,
0.1974259168,
0.1946269125,
0.37195912,
-0.1331390589,
0.4270036221,
-0.1787513644,
-0.1106450781,
-0.2174869627,
0.0476935022,
0.6715869308,
0.5806356072,
-0.1193486527,
0.4635779858,
0.5422791839,
0.3407962918,
-0.9693261385,
0.2546191812,
-0.5693795681,
0.1024973318,
-0.0696778297,
-0.2285859287,
-0.7211154103,
-0.0382991768,
0.1284287125,
-0.5712855458,
0.0366477109,
-0.0065401695,
0.4946017563,
0.411187768,
-0.4084565639,
-0.369119525,
-0.1768005192,
0.6730898023,
-0.505015254,
0.3548528552,
0.0676427782,
-0.1367311478,
0.1994005442,
-0.7114438415,
-0.4888111949,
-0.3342474103,
-0.0856396705,
-0.0499831736,
-0.3463566601,
-0.1363161355,
0.2534404993,
-0.168960169,
-0.4715957642,
-0.0153564261,
0.0820517316,
0.1102128252,
0.181572184,
0.1992312968,
0.2312421203,
-0.4942240417,
-0.2199112326,
-0.1664504409,
-0.8278625011,
-0.2385010272,
0.0981463492,
0.5059276223,
0.1472629756,
0.7328289151,
0.0184001978,
0.4922877252,
0.1139313653,
0.3676503897,
0.2738720477,
-0.1235561073,
-0.1314447671,
-0.0293194558,
1.1293139458,
0.3289569914,
0.3775024414,
-0.1632851958,
-0.1798463613,
-0.1198320836,
0.3804238141,
-0.7606437802,
0.2004521191,
0.1019785106,
-0.3913779557,
-0.2944260836,
0.2806791663,
-0.8200131059,
-0.2218562365,
-0.0601880327,
0.634367764,
-0.2647432089,
-0.1386559755,
0.0771803856,
-0.2478157431,
0.0280591454,
-0.1194942743,
-0.8859875798,
0.0107228607,
0.5871179104,
0.7837864757,
0.050241597,
-0.4915818274,
-0.8734508157,
0.2819592059,
-0.4762947261,
0.4781098962,
-0.7108191848,
-0.4538907707,
0.3645144999,
-0.0236472413,
0.0384010859,
-0.5078573823,
0.3062615097,
-0.2704103589,
0.1094519198,
-0.5664633512,
-0.454682529,
0.1099341735,
0.2660133839,
-0.6275237203,
1.1174942255,
-0.0766697526,
-0.7016733289,
0.4988502264,
-0.8773013353,
-0.4317649007,
0.1974065155,
-0.303065449,
-0.1049896032,
0.4275228679,
0.5782281756,
0.895363152,
-0.2797537744,
0.2096907943,
-0.1840902567,
-0.0000425396,
-0.0153776463,
-0.4360392988,
0.2237181365,
-0.0055772834,
-0.3702740967,
0.1161801219,
-0.2649878561,
0.1063882709,
0.1646066606,
-0.2736496925,
-0.376500994,
0.0500733107,
-0.0388745256,
0.2163691223,
0.4800524414,
-0.7106618285,
0.3800590336,
-0.1840079129,
0.6763049364,
0.6215456128,
-0.0584140755,
0.3503390849,
-0.0564689822,
0.5124009252,
-0.2494205683,
-0.2196938843,
-0.6632228494,
-0.1880928129,
-0.4278613925,
-0.4830574691,
0.3161362708,
0.390063554,
-0.6655499339,
0.5852045417,
-0.519390583,
-0.1712368131,
-0.6806234717,
0.2692647278,
0.3286784291,
0.1603874415,
0.4288826287,
0.1994556934,
-0.4318481684,
-0.8797893524,
-0.3097484112,
0.2649025321,
-0.1569363624,
0.3807911873,
0.5224621296,
-0.3308687508,
0.9940663576,
-0.6850224733,
-0.2256780714,
-0.5029476285,
0.4920044243,
-0.0198026169,
0.3939633667,
0.4238684773,
-0.4461855292,
-0.6713160872,
-0.2635798752,
-0.7388019562,
-0.2663540542,
0.0016316656,
0.0441710725,
-0.0005183276,
1.0251526833,
-0.8577869534,
0.1043998152,
0.6087822914,
-0.440985471,
0.3299916387,
-0.4575418532,
0.1035837606,
-1.3763440847,
0.11748714,
-0.2818941772,
-0.4398394823,
-0.1963795722,
0.1995245665,
0.2089336067,
-0.4013656974,
-0.4584094286,
0.6017814875,
-0.5881047845,
0.0543369763,
-0.3546737432,
0.3017468154,
-0.0188456662,
0.1736377478,
0.0363805071,
0.7369847298,
0.5827456713,
-0.6169453859,
0.094178766,
0.4202083945,
-0.172015965,
0.2681038082,
-0.9384067655,
0.0263513923,
-0.2148406506,
0.3527763188,
-0.8998826742,
-0.1293001026,
-0.0120686023,
-0.1898513287,
0.0830933228,
-0.053572569,
-0.7400032282,
-0.455319941,
-0.40912202,
0.371568054,
0.6176495552,
-0.625946939,
0.5934230089,
0.029524263,
-0.2843738496,
-0.4571549594,
-0.8115690351,
0.1034569964,
0.0082358662,
-0.4634799361,
0.4794408083,
0.0510850959,
0.2015555054,
0.2588671148,
0.1959436238,
0.3308720291,
-0.054679323,
0.3626842797,
0.1047977656,
-0.1618303955,
0.3981389999,
0.3776591718,
-0.1711181253,
0.2307794839,
-0.6016798019,
0.6836630702,
0.0824209675,
-0.4953338802,
-0.3790459633,
0.7118382454,
0.7532221079,
-0.5299793482,
0.6547404528,
0.5598768592,
-0.3353303373,
-0.3235619068,
-0.4357223213,
-0.3194178939,
-0.5049782395,
0.3363344371,
-0.3774957359,
-1.0894640684,
0.0087942006,
-0.2544478476,
0.2231980562,
0.4330966473,
0.6003875136,
-0.0070389672,
1.2641967535,
0.5492384434,
0.1043309942,
0.4657848477,
-0.0688184723,
-0.0670239329,
-0.898042202,
-0.0773246363,
-0.3375368714,
-0.2629085481,
-0.6091216803,
-0.653955102,
0.350389719,
-0.2061126232,
-0.2002766728,
0.4471489191,
-0.4240068793,
0.5465611219,
0.6116619706,
0.0598263182,
-0.1778482497,
-0.1699496955,
-0.4957829416,
-0.0981357843,
-0.718891561,
-0.6008152366,
1.0242830515,
0.062321052,
0.6128410697,
-0.0519364849,
0.9390725493,
0.4097049534,
-0.0204961058,
-0.6368152499,
0.5662607551,
-0.3589242399,
-0.2741353214,
-0.3412283063,
-0.3101975322,
-1.0852196217,
0.2389701754,
-0.519672513,
-0.5863199234,
-0.0778159127,
0.1082433611,
-0.582896769,
0.0966042727,
-0.3432827294,
0.9557279348,
0.2735460699,
-0.1331829727,
-0.2126169056,
-0.2596774399,
-0.0874797925,
0.2383015752,
0.1421301365,
0.0006606357,
-0.3678119183,
0.6252841949,
-0.2626505494,
0.8705057502,
-0.2634802163,
-0.0952488184,
0.4170960486,
0.3531751037,
0.7792045474,
0.1495870948,
0.0472936593,
-0.4182154834,
-0.2930942476,
-0.3203892708,
-0.5734399557,
0.7105306983,
-0.2465922236,
-0.6307558417,
-0.032963559,
-0.6223053336,
-0.291890353,
0.1370370537,
0.5257791877,
0.5391669273,
-0.3421633244,
0.4249583483,
0.7962098718,
-0.3326206505,
0.720538795,
0.2633012235,
-0.0511607528,
-0.3729765713,
0.852447331,
-0.0894392207,
0.1009269357,
0.5516155362,
0.2912230194,
-0.3581042588,
-0.1219904944,
-0.4460718334,
0.2139619738,
-0.4916527271,
-0.1396882385,
-0.9912829995,
0.127809763,
-0.7041386366,
-0.3541624844,
-0.5193067193,
-0.1793450713,
-0.3934540153,
-0.2378029972,
0.0578164421,
0.948682189,
0.0049997875,
0.1516892463,
-1.1269319057,
0.0699297711,
0.7127074599,
-0.085434638,
0.0601736046,
-0.3320157528,
-0.098859489,
-0.1454419494,
-0.3275660872,
-0.7835028768,
0.2652709782,
0.232713908,
0.5836792588,
0.5713771582,
0.1801629961,
0.3575670421,
-0.9719629884,
1.0298724174,
0.2467427105,
-1.332896471,
0.7744137645,
-0.4119594991,
0.4888232648,
0.4229102135,
0.471709758,
-0.4346269667,
-0.3083868325,
-0.6340399384,
-0.823736608,
0.2832452655,
-0.1314996928,
0.782535553,
-0.5291888118,
0.2124608606,
0.1346142292,
0.3956505358,
-0.6259298921,
0.0585539155,
-0.1845256984,
-0.3399128616,
0.0269057788,
-0.4178983569,
0.085091792,
0.1045922488,
0.3003132641,
-0.3843096495,
0.3285845518,
0.2491995692,
-0.4446548522,
0.0167912971,
0.4232232869,
0.6324682832,
0.4761281312,
0.1711718142,
0.2481927574,
0.4018206894,
-0.1191757098,
0.0009677697,
-0.0819129348,
-0.0569288433,
0.133325249,
0.646607995,
0.726360321,
0.4657509029,
-0.6915482879,
0.897690773,
0.2153846025,
-0.4512797594,
0.1999571472,
-0.138595745,
0.2047611326,
0.337488234,
0.3329958618,
-0.4145904779,
0.0171128456,
-0.5794639587,
0.408387512,
0.668757081,
-0.5059370995,
-0.1913864613,
0.6822112203,
0.3886811435,
-0.0675667375,
0.6800231934,
-0.3635630906,
-0.5465257764,
0.1629884988,
0.5777654648,
0.8857468963,
-0.1514166743,
0.614767015,
0.4494069219,
0.3030068874,
-0.1659475267,
0.2614372671,
-0.0991965756,
-0.4162140787,
-0.5800420046,
-0.4196341038,
-0.1723209769,
-0.1635365784,
-0.7708244324,
0.2134595513,
-0.3877235055,
-0.0334240869,
-0.2807916701,
-0.4234719276,
-0.6216973066,
-0.0210000314,
0.2913896143,
0.8494490981,
-0.9174140692,
0.4015887976,
0.6766212583,
-0.1947314292,
-0.6668015122,
0.1430506408,
-0.1059166864,
-0.6540433764,
0.4738407731,
0.3683303893,
0.13644813,
0.1039425284,
-0.5353538394,
-0.53805089,
1.3046683073,
0.5851400495,
-0.56957376,
-0.2379351258,
0.2051009089,
0.221479401,
-0.8217376471,
0.1207589358,
0.1593540609,
0.5150660872,
-0.1569559127,
-0.6084151864,
0.5929427147,
0.0026077286,
-0.0501598045,
0.2697981596,
-0.364991188,
0.9658302069,
-0.37474069,
-0.2371652424,
-0.0393402427,
0.6067983508,
0.2710182667,
-0.0472320542,
0.7466752529,
0.6459389925,
0.7319172025,
0.0326877348,
1.0058877468,
-0.2739377916,
0.2301158011,
1.1533973217,
-0.2016996741,
1.0520983934,
0.4645015895,
0.2523711026,
0.7652561665,
0.2950537205,
-0.0712867975,
0.5939046741,
0.0543253832,
-0.2148301303,
-0.6671105623,
-0.3428817689,
-0.2632728219,
0.3992834091,
0.2191476077,
-0.6095405817,
-0.3530685604,
0.4359827638,
-0.0196520817,
0.0217109695,
-0.070982717,
0.838111937,
0.1003680825,
-0.7572568059,
0.1842695326,
-0.1743981391,
0.8019599319,
-0.5901330113,
-0.0220574252,
0.098030448,
-0.3130072653,
0.1539758891,
-0.7468728423,
0.1222101301,
0.0658668429,
-0.3376641273,
-0.5652914047,
0.4060840011,
-0.6278771162,
-0.2813063264,
0.3224971294,
0.7659308314,
-0.117816925,
-0.3663261235,
-0.4622909129,
-0.1259511411,
-0.2120331824,
-0.3771145344,
0.2098018378,
0.7551572323,
0.1569932997,
0.5354752541,
0.5589827299,
-0.1214692444,
-0.1398391873,
0.0889628232,
0.7757507563,
-0.654188931,
-0.5437173247,
-0.9480095506,
0.5717796087,
0.0944033191,
-0.2382743359,
0.5270701051,
0.2289417088,
0.3723459244,
-0.3367681503,
0.7976956964,
-0.1921937913,
0.1649103463,
-0.5744892955,
0.47139588,
-0.792768538,
-0.0117815686,
-0.2920046747,
-0.9059026241,
0.070861645,
0.3329465389,
-0.01214197,
-0.0886478946,
0.8989809155,
0.740873754,
-0.0834780261,
-0.2106274068,
0.4263415039,
-0.0220686123,
0.1397053599,
0.4751564562,
0.6156166196,
-0.1581534296,
0.6901421547,
0.3708609641,
-0.0370416157,
-0.2370124906,
-1.1289846897,
-0.9227397442,
-0.7566120028,
-0.3087547123,
-0.2806795537,
-0.0838119015,
1.1962295771,
0.6828585863,
-0.4755654931,
0.2132392824,
-0.2042295039,
-0.0011541909,
-0.234964028,
-0.2025942206,
0.3105660081,
-0.5589545369,
-0.7742246389,
0.5198066831,
0.2099160403,
-0.0472032987,
-0.2670775354,
0.0121562816,
-0.1086042523,
0.3769893944,
0.650619328,
-0.0951436833,
-0.6442686319,
-0.3427860737,
0.018723445,
-0.1950552613,
-0.3464221954,
1.0522890091,
-0.6404243708,
0.0852083042,
0.691829741,
0.7557213902,
0.2281685919,
-0.2557933927,
0.6517223716,
-1.209240675,
-0.1071148291,
0.0235613212,
0.384272635,
0.1729592979,
-0.2376631945,
0.2668825984,
-0.050018169,
-0.3310249448,
-0.6240059137,
0.1745641828,
-0.6292325854,
-0.5043787956,
1.2303061485,
-0.2343218774,
-0.1365434527,
0.353925705,
-0.1457060575,
0.0925435349,
-0.4765038192,
0.3587444425,
0.7781249881,
0.2279262394,
-0.1908589751,
-0.3790729642,
0.3466741443,
0.6132521033,
-0.8136136532,
0.4463562369,
0.1843181998,
0.3339006901,
0.3138510585,
0.2784117162,
0.0571063161,
0.3300469816,
0.0960019678,
-0.0254653692,
-0.4037368596,
-0.4485352635,
-0.1212898195,
0.3517200053,
-0.1969085187,
-0.265504241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18449v1
|
HOP to the Next Tasks and Domains for Continual Learning in NLP
| 2024-02-28T16:21:02 | 2024-02-28T16:21:02 |
Umberto Michieli, Mete Ozay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Continual Learning (CL) aims to learn a sequence of problems (i.e., tasks and
domains) by transferring knowledge acquired on previous problems, whilst
avoiding forgetting of past ones. Different from previous approaches which
focused on CL for one NLP task or domain in a specific use-case, in this paper,
we address a more general CL setting to learn from a sequence of problems in a
unique framework. Our method, HOP, permits to hop across tasks and domains by
addressing the CL problem along three directions: (i) we employ a set of
adapters to generalize a large pre-trained model to unseen problems, (ii) we
compute high-order moments over the distribution of embedded representations to
distinguish independent and correlated statistics across different tasks and
domains, (iii) we process this enriched information with auxiliary heads
specialized for each end problem. Extensive experimental campaign on 4 NLP
applications, 5 benchmarks and 2 CL setups demonstrates the effectiveness of
our HOP.
|
[
-0.1320634782,
-0.4531581998,
0.6470659971,
0.5635896325,
-0.0931913257,
0.1332020015,
-0.2135352939,
-0.547457099,
0.0802537501,
0.4917578697,
-0.7159006596,
-0.4712592661,
-0.7036947608,
0.1355115324,
-0.1257961839,
1.0455600023,
0.0696203336,
-0.2508738637,
-0.3497431874,
-0.2896426916,
-1.1869204044,
-0.6145203114,
-1.0001186132,
-0.2129596472,
0.6073545814,
0.5286875963,
0.4358838797,
0.136076957,
0.5049311519,
0.1737511456,
-0.0190290362,
0.2964078784,
-0.5387812853,
0.3674268723,
-0.597822547,
-0.4145011604,
-0.1363556236,
-0.1400533617,
0.5512151718,
1.1507968903,
0.2550390065,
0.1856907755,
0.3628713787,
0.740637064,
-0.6026008129,
0.0825459734,
-0.6792734265,
0.0927174538,
-0.1230772659,
-0.4912739396,
-0.5491598248,
-0.0550384186,
0.3230366707,
-0.6246026754,
-0.052922491,
0.0384303592,
0.545907259,
0.3331612349,
-0.2104145885,
-0.4894592762,
-0.8869245052,
0.8671107888,
-0.2409087569,
0.6349970698,
0.2026720494,
0.1170776188,
-0.1274030656,
-1.0416151285,
-0.1835754514,
-0.1141561866,
0.2283130437,
0.1874201447,
-0.0584467649,
-0.3863280416,
0.0911414623,
-0.2579327822,
-0.5571271181,
-0.0931372494,
-0.2156759948,
0.0310503375,
0.4672800601,
0.1835284978,
0.2502572536,
0.4844461977,
-0.4813774526,
-0.0252618473,
-0.6999939084,
0.1056080014,
-0.2393297106,
0.3831889927,
0.1276555061,
0.3557374477,
0.1282136142,
0.8368248343,
0.0916131735,
-0.1616920829,
0.355458498,
-0.0916926265,
0.075786531,
-0.2759748995,
0.1977597773,
0.0622172505,
0.3408948481,
-0.5430903435,
-0.1594369859,
-0.3547903299,
0.5699522495,
0.0263927486,
-0.2458144426,
0.2417611033,
-0.2964208424,
0.0826663971,
-0.2792280316,
-0.6060084701,
-0.1345183849,
-0.6444613934,
0.5259454846,
-0.5837007761,
-0.1466777921,
0.1155022904,
-0.0491065793,
0.205348745,
0.373542577,
-0.5693439245,
0.4925280511,
0.7754915953,
1.2843410969,
-0.7451156378,
-0.631183207,
-0.8903002143,
0.2930043042,
-0.290158093,
0.767416656,
-0.6172435284,
-0.5568333864,
0.1646564454,
0.134774223,
-0.4667792916,
-0.6131900549,
0.2672492564,
-0.7231832743,
-0.2716809213,
-0.1700064838,
-0.6548852921,
-0.2185324728,
0.2046904117,
-0.3766935766,
0.7406872511,
0.1650317311,
-0.7332574725,
0.3572567403,
-0.7114285231,
-0.3933136761,
0.2761692107,
0.0557627231,
-0.2822895348,
-0.007096068,
-0.2051000148,
0.4393548965,
0.1757521629,
0.1624429971,
-0.3305680156,
-0.1601088792,
-0.0538761802,
-0.0088971257,
0.915903151,
0.0838554651,
-0.2552597821,
-0.0553446636,
-0.4982761145,
-0.0843486041,
0.1894829571,
-0.2504376471,
-0.6503716707,
0.1115561277,
-0.0305123311,
0.2386807352,
0.2230654061,
-0.1696444899,
0.3200525045,
-0.2328496724,
0.0072828317,
0.657769978,
0.5042228103,
0.3375074863,
-0.5273746252,
0.5098078251,
0.2263612449,
-0.0218742695,
-0.1546331644,
-0.8230381608,
-0.6688686013,
0.1107985526,
0.1806892753,
0.7189448476,
-0.505219698,
0.4148272872,
-0.3395016193,
-0.2936497629,
0.2018028647,
0.2735680044,
0.1072618216,
0.3371005058,
0.6146032214,
-0.3672264814,
-0.4321905375,
-0.0102629615,
-0.3182528615,
-0.0232478343,
-0.0935896635,
0.3249940276,
0.7697731853,
-0.4962285459,
1.0278644562,
-0.4644378722,
-0.3598550558,
-0.2269520313,
0.2747118771,
0.2100535035,
0.7075271606,
0.4731819928,
-0.9387498498,
-0.6959662437,
0.0386525914,
-0.6644838452,
0.114118576,
-0.9400934577,
-0.3148114085,
-0.1478333324,
0.616719842,
-0.4509732127,
0.2004190385,
0.2791111469,
-0.231656298,
0.8528269529,
-0.0321574956,
-0.4117787778,
-0.7330362797,
0.1580048651,
-0.1746802032,
-0.3860092759,
-0.7013266683,
-0.0427675433,
-0.2775118947,
-0.0683661625,
-0.2679102123,
0.6623235345,
-0.4143440723,
-0.1259154528,
-0.2910797,
0.1704879552,
-0.1975251585,
0.6036843657,
0.3410392404,
0.5943574905,
0.7892793417,
-1.1041841507,
0.2081838399,
0.3463667333,
0.0829459876,
0.4259580076,
-0.726541996,
0.3068719506,
0.113516897,
0.0685660467,
-0.6431745291,
0.2332591116,
0.2575840056,
-0.5777407289,
0.3058496416,
-0.1470710039,
-0.1954293698,
-0.3461034,
0.164461866,
0.4158320129,
0.4532430768,
-0.6418477297,
0.4259710908,
0.3353314996,
-0.2451784164,
-0.669107914,
-0.3394020796,
0.0513880067,
-0.3172867596,
-0.2456947267,
0.3576142788,
-0.2562224865,
-0.2123833448,
0.0142974602,
-0.2532953322,
-0.2071787715,
0.0938492343,
0.3185761273,
-0.0611881353,
-0.039206408,
0.3169969916,
-0.1844570339,
-0.1850604266,
0.0949176028,
-0.9938973784,
0.6210120916,
-0.1267297119,
-0.3791128993,
-0.1263085008,
0.5366295576,
0.2684940398,
-0.1131456643,
0.5649741888,
0.5396123528,
-0.3784230649,
-0.4456368685,
-0.2166018188,
0.1848160326,
-0.4156505764,
0.1311881691,
-0.4430294931,
-0.8469105959,
0.3830286562,
-0.6040159464,
0.4726375043,
0.3484564424,
0.4744537473,
-0.3436960876,
0.3497203588,
1.2800188065,
-0.1821348518,
0.3090653419,
-0.3513131142,
0.1932577938,
-0.7791224718,
-0.1748436838,
-0.3848903775,
-0.1385295838,
-0.1299230456,
-0.5498631001,
0.4282016456,
0.6037735939,
-0.2916798592,
0.6143488288,
-0.158353135,
0.2618318796,
0.582062304,
0.1113628,
0.2270908952,
-0.1794675142,
-0.1777331829,
0.1160922125,
-0.7330762744,
-0.0281573106,
1.0299210548,
0.2424614727,
0.3152411282,
-0.0332713388,
0.9361901879,
0.5565750003,
0.1280401796,
-0.8705019355,
0.3287814856,
0.1207244024,
-0.223067224,
-0.3222512007,
-0.2541447282,
-1.1285130978,
-0.0208284296,
0.0804605559,
-0.8687360287,
0.348811388,
0.2548734248,
-0.4422098398,
0.2583773732,
-0.1921103001,
0.7388247252,
-0.2209681123,
-0.4352896512,
-0.2241532952,
-0.8764489889,
0.188039422,
-0.2691232562,
0.133898288,
0.166991204,
-0.0532984659,
0.7313159704,
-0.1572939605,
0.9661682248,
-0.1468418986,
0.1659980714,
0.5121810436,
0.1548056453,
0.4698497355,
0.2555628717,
0.3625791967,
0.1686802953,
-0.1669823974,
-0.3681928813,
-0.42165187,
0.3144474924,
-0.50806427,
-0.4026442766,
-0.529121995,
-0.5676828027,
-0.5666201711,
0.3532109857,
0.1677653939,
0.4691978693,
0.0714265779,
0.099600859,
0.7237503529,
-0.2571451962,
0.5208331347,
0.164481461,
-0.0121744731,
-0.0845267177,
0.853684783,
-0.1175709292,
0.3016215861,
0.5096055269,
0.0325186998,
-0.2664373815,
-0.5559950471,
0.0435705744,
0.2155158222,
-0.8274105787,
-0.3828878105,
-0.8791454434,
-0.268231988,
-0.5347714424,
-0.5322606564,
-0.3057795167,
-0.0547912717,
-0.4117475152,
0.3864468038,
0.29349944,
0.5173321962,
-0.3891326189,
0.3244997263,
-1.1361938715,
0.3893490136,
0.3893349767,
0.3203148246,
0.0433952324,
-0.7362371087,
-0.4278097153,
-0.1674719304,
-0.3718344867,
-0.8167040348,
0.6542716026,
0.5073279142,
0.631696403,
0.2968733311,
0.0323830955,
0.7874975204,
-0.8913263679,
0.830796957,
0.2070545703,
-0.8167365789,
0.6061021686,
-0.2637466192,
0.2952499688,
0.5788104534,
1.0502194166,
-0.7353589535,
-0.0990903974,
-0.6753324866,
-0.9424036145,
0.1789952666,
0.043437019,
0.0074235322,
-0.1109039634,
0.6187992692,
0.1429762095,
-0.0298925135,
-0.7248930335,
-0.1777105778,
0.0011749926,
0.1889860481,
-0.0497014634,
-0.0433127955,
-0.1085207984,
-0.1514848769,
0.6489102244,
-0.2549267411,
0.4733068049,
0.1845258027,
-0.5148829818,
0.2573817968,
-0.1648143828,
0.3107885718,
0.9952180982,
-0.0412973762,
-0.031051036,
0.2371243984,
-0.5520620942,
-0.0556411073,
-0.5190973878,
0.0622324347,
0.2508545816,
0.601796627,
0.5709631443,
0.1805824041,
-0.6208099127,
0.4981687367,
0.3413332403,
-0.1371151954,
-0.5521116257,
0.0159341544,
0.0030224074,
0.4656406939,
0.2717218399,
0.5024138093,
0.1990148276,
-0.448433578,
0.8423910141,
0.1833143979,
-0.3171505034,
-0.2700073123,
0.5029478669,
-0.0398612916,
-0.3235056102,
0.5708909631,
-0.2947202325,
-0.5050769448,
0.4329420924,
0.9123128057,
0.8823223114,
-0.01640868,
0.1677297354,
0.4643582404,
0.0470053963,
-0.2663614154,
0.1820659637,
-0.3837191761,
-0.7804319263,
-0.5765814185,
-0.5661484599,
-0.6593253016,
-0.110755831,
-0.7652544975,
0.1714548767,
-0.3096428514,
0.0375350975,
-0.4001979232,
-0.1998849362,
-0.7327516079,
0.3301147819,
0.0974107981,
0.8253728747,
-0.8135576248,
0.8235176206,
0.5885937214,
-0.2349904031,
-0.3206034303,
0.3545680046,
-0.088395603,
-0.6539271474,
0.9192686677,
0.1758656949,
-0.3149098754,
0.0635926574,
-0.612975657,
-1.028631568,
0.8339751959,
-0.3342835903,
-0.5294378996,
-0.1499114633,
-0.1668550372,
0.2561292052,
-0.5011488199,
-0.2391361445,
0.5398507118,
0.092542477,
0.0434631519,
-0.5725771785,
-0.3406809866,
-0.1480156779,
0.0589842722,
-0.2127582431,
-0.3171058297,
0.5230865479,
-0.3850879371,
-0.2092998624,
-0.1286383569,
1.0284445286,
0.4624604583,
0.4391601682,
0.8468998671,
0.200731501,
0.7888786793,
0.1606702656,
0.5935851932,
-0.395686239,
0.4445895553,
1.430967927,
-0.2090235054,
0.8746413589,
0.359145999,
-0.2078570724,
0.464592129,
0.6832769513,
0.1073517129,
0.6366029382,
0.1496135294,
-0.2408026159,
-0.2575350106,
0.0890989155,
-0.2541004717,
0.3267506063,
0.742824018,
0.1862541139,
-0.2004496753,
0.4461785555,
-0.0405223854,
-0.1024969518,
-0.4800061882,
0.6437347531,
0.232881844,
-0.5026051998,
0.4633451998,
-0.3730966151,
0.6318594813,
-0.6662805676,
-0.2043489367,
-0.073819235,
0.0753245726,
-0.0353760645,
-0.7033415437,
0.7618928552,
-0.0654957592,
-0.1133394688,
-0.404314518,
0.6460097432,
-0.1448330581,
-0.1953178942,
0.4134229422,
0.4757329524,
0.3551364839,
-0.0913736224,
-0.7251848578,
-0.1328230053,
-0.156165719,
-0.2650119066,
0.2676936984,
0.5619642138,
0.0321334451,
0.7944360375,
0.5266404152,
0.134074986,
0.3540669084,
-0.0560469776,
0.7640585303,
-0.7012106776,
-0.611399889,
-0.4373420477,
0.5168657303,
0.0339349844,
-0.6099083424,
0.5110675097,
0.2135434449,
1.016289115,
-0.1553819329,
0.8156496286,
-0.1197211519,
0.549223125,
-0.6126346588,
0.1160179302,
-0.5089570284,
0.1264062077,
-0.1885926574,
-0.873188436,
-0.6151095629,
0.6516588926,
-0.0346091948,
-0.1325182617,
0.9484336972,
0.0535496846,
-0.0727791861,
-0.1610540897,
0.3740612268,
0.0242733229,
0.1769769788,
0.7157405019,
0.5061882138,
-0.1490048915,
0.2566888034,
-0.3229879439,
-0.1574236602,
0.0619691759,
-0.7482438087,
-0.664429903,
-0.8412885666,
-0.356325686,
-0.3502229154,
0.1306098551,
0.9081682563,
0.629522562,
-0.8460714221,
-0.2272480577,
-0.3098315895,
0.1605801731,
-0.811224103,
-0.2070424557,
0.3227621317,
-1.1826770306,
-0.5598333478,
0.5286553502,
0.3237455785,
-0.3460256755,
0.1622063071,
0.001846486,
-0.3506041169,
-0.1646617651,
0.7780652642,
0.6526622772,
-0.2154707015,
-0.5018223524,
0.0630625933,
0.3145948648,
0.1174434498,
1.0537822247,
-0.7774566412,
0.2506991029,
0.2393208891,
1.2360191345,
0.3923294544,
-0.1996550858,
0.4663651884,
-0.8041093946,
-0.0338993818,
0.5757964849,
0.2343168557,
-0.0190061927,
-0.503950417,
0.6522475481,
0.5730881691,
-0.8324813843,
-0.5471253395,
0.4583413899,
-1.1982830763,
-0.3559302986,
1.2050430775,
-0.5041194558,
0.0717214569,
-0.6556758881,
0.3336950839,
0.1003338695,
0.2630963922,
0.4619690776,
0.3972619176,
-0.5218629241,
-0.0182316322,
-0.6247411966,
0.5172381401,
0.3871954679,
-0.6608428955,
0.0133865019,
0.183462739,
0.3749279976,
0.3965231776,
0.7843885422,
0.0064250403,
0.2411064804,
0.0406914726,
-0.1561240852,
0.3843325377,
-1.236651063,
-0.288130939,
0.1755463034,
-0.0389868766,
-0.2797893882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18439v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18439v3
|
Beyond Natural Language: LLMs Leveraging Alternative Formats for Enhanced Reasoning and Communication
| 2024-02-28T16:07:54 | 2024-06-19T01:42:22 |
Weize Chen, Chenfei Yuan, Jiarui Yuan, Yusheng Su, Chen Qian, Cheng Yang, Ruobing Xie, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural language (NL) has long been the predominant format for human
cognition and communication, and by extension, has been similarly pivotal in
the development and application of Large Language Models (LLMs). Yet, besides
NL, LLMs have seen various non-NL formats during pre-training, such as code and
logical expression. NL's status as the optimal format for LLMs, particularly in
single-LLM reasoning and multi-agent communication, has not been thoroughly
examined. In this work, we challenge the default use of NL by exploring the
utility of non-NL formats in these contexts. We show that allowing LLMs to
autonomously select the most suitable format before reasoning or communicating
leads to a 3.3 to 5.7\% improvement in reasoning efficiency for different LLMs,
and up to a 72.7\% reduction in token usage in multi-agent communication, all
while maintaining communicative effectiveness. Our comprehensive analysis
further reveals that LLMs can devise a format from limited task instructions
and that the devised format is effectively transferable across different LLMs.
Intriguingly, the structured communication format decided by LLMs exhibits
notable parallels with established agent communication languages, suggesting a
natural evolution towards efficient, structured communication in agent
communication. Our code is released at
\url{https://github.com/thunlp/AutoForm}.
|
[
-0.3288131058,
-0.8097541928,
0.7396190166,
0.2782628536,
-0.320892483,
0.1531569213,
-0.6276936531,
-0.645668745,
0.2432394028,
0.442730099,
-0.3762058616,
-0.3982456625,
-0.3161732554,
0.4437147379,
-0.0319295451,
0.669244051,
-0.028497275,
-0.1359397024,
-0.4115365744,
-0.2909332812,
-0.5408730507,
-0.8175238371,
-0.7833254337,
-0.6827061772,
0.4700058103,
0.1577830613,
0.746925056,
0.7213221192,
0.446015954,
0.4097358882,
0.1809031963,
0.582123816,
-0.1706759483,
0.191638127,
-0.0554564781,
-0.5173735619,
-0.6696891189,
0.1901179552,
0.6633614302,
0.8077365756,
-0.1912209988,
-0.014411239,
-0.1443357617,
0.9570635557,
-0.5301729441,
0.4184786975,
-0.6098313332,
0.060786631,
-0.1114923805,
-0.5412607193,
-0.602588594,
-0.2134381682,
-0.0245431289,
-0.8268868327,
-0.4324616194,
0.1630732417,
0.5503963232,
0.4177351594,
-0.4701429904,
-0.4633128941,
-0.8515496254,
0.5207046866,
-0.688185811,
0.631716013,
0.3338986039,
0.427911371,
-0.313013643,
-0.7804607749,
-0.6996694803,
-0.4727772772,
-0.1637948602,
0.026793696,
-0.3369063437,
0.2314320952,
0.2009592801,
0.1660071611,
-0.5848838091,
0.3042468131,
-0.0205072667,
-0.2424480915,
0.726208508,
0.1987953484,
0.1553382725,
-0.0828347802,
-0.2727022469,
-0.0910677537,
-0.6954323053,
0.0099762185,
0.3468769789,
0.3434670269,
-0.2128860056,
0.6290075183,
-0.1826830804,
0.940690279,
0.0219786409,
-0.2070414424,
0.0834578201,
-0.4520522952,
-0.4490600526,
-0.0119770523,
0.7474643588,
0.2567575872,
0.2805938721,
-0.1967202127,
-0.2225092947,
0.1177105159,
0.2149335444,
-0.4419057071,
-0.3315688968,
-0.0582374297,
-0.5079723597,
0.0523367524,
-0.1850820482,
-0.2427919358,
-0.3753674924,
-0.7102252245,
0.2925187945,
-0.3719158769,
-0.1596033126,
0.3700481355,
-0.0676429644,
0.3859007359,
0.6751505733,
-0.7578171492,
0.2561082542,
0.5010385513,
0.615540266,
-0.084445782,
-0.091669336,
-0.5662636757,
0.2165479511,
-0.5733664036,
1.0268298388,
-0.6441935897,
-0.1841145456,
-0.285482347,
-0.174212724,
-0.1192448363,
-0.4455846846,
0.3982824981,
-0.5155104399,
0.4535159469,
-0.1031493768,
-0.6313827634,
-0.077564761,
0.3630530536,
-0.830273211,
0.9806227088,
-0.0638682321,
-0.3235708177,
0.2988108993,
-1.1413064003,
-0.5319868326,
0.1192244962,
-0.3331944346,
-0.1511506885,
-0.0617794804,
0.0987873822,
0.2861351371,
-0.2398472428,
0.3097548783,
-0.3436589241,
-0.2987446785,
0.2556256652,
-0.5668229461,
0.5655210018,
0.2653901279,
-0.263302803,
0.2808782756,
-0.717232883,
0.0954960063,
0.3381602466,
-0.5388664603,
-0.2744275033,
-0.1106437296,
-0.4337064922,
0.4083146751,
0.2311645299,
-0.3479264975,
0.2649083138,
-0.4671645463,
0.5596510172,
0.7334635258,
-0.2987844646,
0.9265685081,
-0.5128656626,
0.3890624344,
-0.3453482985,
0.2492250651,
-0.0960490182,
-0.3832525313,
-0.7501036525,
-0.3437831998,
0.0159199368,
0.500672102,
-0.7229408622,
0.5063296556,
-0.0167115405,
-0.472695142,
-0.5512257814,
0.2040770948,
0.1950164735,
0.4428087175,
0.3752044141,
-0.1115136519,
-0.8910038471,
-0.8646637201,
-0.2174236774,
-0.3795125186,
0.3187067509,
0.2669187784,
0.2383597493,
-0.1828100383,
1.1581380367,
-0.129768461,
0.0994574726,
-0.6955971122,
-0.1455996037,
0.1342902482,
0.3066600263,
0.4787869751,
-0.7006044388,
-0.4886281192,
-0.2309897989,
-0.779163897,
-0.2127344906,
-0.6632473469,
-0.306196332,
0.7075400352,
0.6141447425,
-0.760289073,
0.5377182364,
0.4825076461,
-0.2873003781,
0.5771694183,
-0.4735282362,
-0.1201423779,
-0.7250342369,
-0.0175191071,
-0.1436303407,
-0.5392103195,
-0.6383653283,
-0.2515660226,
0.0623204559,
0.2210514843,
-0.2774933279,
0.8768023252,
-0.879270792,
-0.2062398046,
-0.4814956784,
0.1266415119,
0.4413092136,
0.4440316856,
0.3962417543,
0.8608314395,
0.3825717866,
-0.5903580785,
0.4131419957,
0.270070523,
-0.0455869362,
0.5393722057,
-0.6600678563,
0.393823266,
-0.4682115912,
0.5757923126,
-0.624317348,
0.1293740869,
0.2985358238,
-0.3215461969,
0.3492747545,
0.1158894449,
-0.80155164,
-0.0686253384,
-0.3678208292,
0.0649486482,
0.3353511989,
-0.5330521464,
0.6937443614,
0.1991143078,
0.1380611509,
-0.3357270956,
-0.6870372295,
0.5924934149,
-0.3396177292,
-0.6717353463,
0.1683098376,
-0.4223680198,
-0.4424168468,
-0.2308881581,
-0.2079736292,
0.1440333277,
0.3001531959,
-0.0856261849,
0.4008295536,
-0.4029683173,
0.3481019735,
0.0058387904,
-0.1608940959,
0.0328521095,
-0.4181063473,
0.6087234616,
-0.430716455,
-0.4830284119,
-0.4240624905,
0.6270743012,
0.153008312,
-0.3303925097,
1.0279107094,
0.3767671585,
-0.2045233101,
-0.249711588,
-0.5094669461,
-0.2596225441,
-0.5469473004,
0.0397091061,
-0.3111107647,
-0.8458999991,
0.1918843389,
-0.0875044838,
0.0804709718,
0.2691034973,
0.4698751271,
-0.077686429,
0.676854074,
0.7458718419,
0.4093033373,
0.5172639489,
0.0105578899,
0.4795928001,
-0.8158115149,
-0.3455444872,
-0.2815401256,
-0.0910886377,
-0.5732609034,
-0.5985290408,
0.1609570831,
0.185344249,
-0.2611961663,
0.4296596348,
-0.3838159442,
0.4318861365,
0.4040360153,
-0.2341582477,
0.6466680169,
-0.2978152633,
-0.115273647,
0.0843787119,
-0.8019378185,
-1.0574061871,
0.9198576212,
0.3660707474,
0.6607254148,
0.2102152407,
0.8312544227,
0.2162331939,
0.4680556357,
-0.8098933101,
0.6990116835,
0.0943322927,
-0.3283624649,
-0.3900257945,
-0.3402417302,
-0.9665642977,
0.3532983065,
-0.2886939645,
-0.579520762,
-0.0115383314,
0.0455370694,
-0.2974197268,
0.2348137498,
-0.9097660184,
0.7305386066,
-0.3405679464,
-0.0507131591,
0.2415566593,
-0.837149024,
-0.0096430499,
-0.06162972,
0.2195544541,
-0.1041530967,
-0.2718925774,
0.5271592736,
-0.3187893629,
0.9607220292,
0.2683431208,
-0.2651043534,
0.3740706444,
-0.0852355883,
0.6505628228,
0.2393976301,
-0.1608391702,
-0.084319137,
-0.3060040772,
-0.2161445469,
-0.9362760782,
0.2989424765,
-0.6514385939,
-0.7102946639,
-0.4078384042,
-0.6244501472,
-0.247941196,
0.2757917047,
-0.0405336544,
0.5227777958,
0.0237683821,
0.1265647709,
0.6394588947,
-0.1752560437,
0.7302982807,
0.7374876738,
0.1003477499,
-0.0473097786,
0.5969533324,
-0.1261585951,
0.5071268678,
0.564517498,
0.3593850434,
-0.6845334768,
-0.6468647718,
-0.3561435938,
0.2353861928,
-1.0420486927,
-0.2482072711,
-0.8205837607,
-0.1522372216,
-0.5982538462,
-0.2195123434,
-0.4058718085,
-0.5615959764,
-0.3910504282,
-0.2272093147,
0.2752296925,
0.6251767278,
-0.3418892324,
0.114655599,
-0.7840409279,
0.1910950691,
0.2322145849,
0.3136875629,
-0.1750666648,
-0.2919552028,
0.0930408165,
0.0721661747,
-0.0401674621,
-0.9151725173,
0.2895085812,
0.3933982253,
1.0045671463,
0.1375872642,
0.0647985116,
0.6548039913,
-0.453651458,
0.4972062409,
0.0577818416,
-0.816375196,
0.3650355935,
-0.2166305482,
0.2449195236,
0.4483115077,
0.0241450649,
-0.6591229439,
-0.3983433247,
-0.5599569678,
-0.73756212,
0.5929402113,
0.3338493407,
0.0857448131,
-0.1907253563,
0.2904319465,
0.2390667349,
0.2419078797,
-0.8607684374,
-0.4312642217,
-0.3719753325,
-0.0789285675,
-0.1652287692,
0.1350290477,
-0.1989230067,
-0.2872219384,
0.1758627445,
-0.3564918637,
0.5012388825,
0.3636904955,
-0.2739136219,
0.1746552438,
0.473344028,
0.7100159526,
0.5550372601,
0.1579872519,
0.3292760849,
0.0075011756,
-0.1441017985,
-0.0481490456,
0.1573684514,
0.2904707193,
-0.0741153359,
0.4886248708,
0.9761023521,
-0.1437476724,
-0.6541606784,
0.1885108948,
-0.0960903391,
-0.1742018759,
-0.3687722385,
0.0254605561,
0.3032948673,
0.364405334,
0.1964608431,
0.0616066642,
0.0371420719,
-0.7163770795,
0.1193724275,
0.5242940784,
0.0779599696,
-0.1962997615,
0.3349896073,
0.2375652492,
-0.4367684126,
0.2484914958,
-0.5776074529,
-0.2667119801,
0.4814628065,
0.7851448655,
0.7246505618,
0.2703499496,
0.385896951,
-0.053127382,
0.5356284976,
-0.0116286492,
0.2178883255,
-0.2610455453,
-0.8494057655,
-0.6683411598,
-0.5215044022,
-0.3653580248,
0.0479275659,
-0.2419346124,
0.0317742117,
-0.463555187,
-0.0196890365,
-0.0628386587,
0.1616590917,
-0.6856606603,
-0.0190923233,
0.592779994,
1.0672758818,
-0.5980708003,
0.9338740706,
1.0531463623,
-0.0453147031,
-0.9603472948,
-0.2660599053,
-0.0299744178,
-0.7216536999,
0.4704426825,
0.2650514543,
-0.3184235692,
-0.1734009087,
-0.5605871081,
-0.9034202695,
1.009469986,
0.5338187814,
-0.3726038635,
-0.0068643102,
0.3169844747,
0.6520375609,
-0.6064999104,
0.3467512131,
0.5837982893,
0.7222238183,
0.243447721,
-1.0891312361,
0.2715578675,
-0.3686870635,
0.0469563305,
0.3755654693,
-0.5865613222,
0.6836705208,
-0.2761026621,
-0.3161716163,
-0.1328094453,
0.8150531054,
0.3813375831,
0.2998137474,
0.4440861046,
0.1271398962,
0.9668115377,
0.1370538771,
0.9614630342,
0.1354261488,
-0.1803899407,
1.2183635235,
-0.4535143971,
0.4976118803,
0.5995449424,
0.0878416598,
0.683000803,
0.4690015316,
0.2811886072,
0.2200264633,
0.2184181809,
-0.1114673913,
-0.5436307788,
-0.1364250034,
-0.1146738604,
0.8375553489,
0.3278473616,
0.1458566636,
-0.3990333378,
-0.0952121243,
0.1235997379,
0.4463709891,
-0.0431209616,
0.8724523783,
0.145769611,
-0.4856303632,
0.5447357297,
0.0014506647,
0.7956895828,
-0.5226786137,
-0.1868685633,
-0.1887992918,
-0.2264567763,
-0.2010486126,
-0.7291286588,
0.6271739006,
-0.212820977,
0.0622133538,
-0.5879950523,
0.9996466041,
-0.4276402891,
-0.0044866116,
0.2180997431,
0.8176578283,
-0.0065479861,
-0.1110418662,
-0.7567616105,
0.0127034951,
-0.4088495076,
-0.3808043301,
0.2520827055,
0.6546186209,
-0.3503020406,
0.8168137074,
0.884462297,
0.056531705,
0.0477524698,
0.1314301789,
0.9804911017,
-0.6686848402,
-0.5956837535,
-0.9641301632,
0.3346005976,
-0.2998157442,
-0.0764326602,
0.7966575623,
0.4609117508,
0.6264474392,
0.24088642,
0.6322202086,
0.0482651815,
0.052784808,
-0.6899968982,
0.5304876566,
-0.398750037,
0.333440125,
-0.1066901162,
-0.735473752,
-0.2795187831,
0.691704154,
-0.2343664914,
0.0771340802,
0.8211774826,
0.3568379879,
0.2935164869,
0.1993989497,
0.1937950552,
-0.2924503982,
0.5523065329,
0.7160608172,
0.9915235639,
0.1131418496,
0.5253310204,
-0.1000578627,
-0.1422118396,
0.0637177899,
-1.2348129749,
-1.1603665352,
-0.3903940618,
-0.1693861037,
0.0464139991,
-0.1283837259,
1.3506371975,
0.6361723542,
-0.2069244385,
-0.1561711133,
-0.1028164029,
0.1796355695,
-0.0040970487,
-0.174602598,
0.0547660515,
-0.4553055167,
-0.4533891678,
0.6851273179,
0.6060764194,
0.385314852,
-0.1531236619,
-0.2416497171,
-0.2413787395,
0.3370794654,
0.9127501249,
0.3781441152,
-0.5317457318,
-0.2718855441,
0.3797337413,
-0.3146281242,
0.3369107246,
0.8462272286,
-0.8527042866,
0.2337787151,
0.3810659647,
0.568590045,
0.1035350561,
-0.1153058559,
0.8219592571,
-0.5878673196,
0.2686226666,
0.387999922,
0.227016896,
0.5544906855,
-0.4706474841,
0.3292630613,
0.0365637802,
-0.2858375907,
-0.7476814389,
0.3235141337,
-0.9678166509,
-0.3637287021,
1.3529418707,
0.0883745104,
-0.1563625187,
-0.401385814,
-0.2541517317,
0.2945294976,
-0.6451590061,
0.5351114273,
0.5663762689,
-0.4976141453,
-0.2753776908,
-0.5162507892,
0.7583239675,
0.3375488818,
-1.2230300903,
-0.1082632765,
0.3822175562,
0.0378925614,
-0.0254986044,
1.0667908192,
-0.0629056394,
0.1536090672,
-0.346476227,
-0.2451388091,
-0.4544469714,
-0.3934611678,
-0.2572330832,
-0.2041339725,
0.1755633354,
0.0182061214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18428v1
|
Leveraging Diverse Modeling Contexts with Collaborating Learning for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-02-28T15:55:02 | 2024-02-28T15:55:02 |
Yusheng Liao, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Autoregressive (AR) and Non-autoregressive (NAR) models are two types of
generative models for Neural Machine Translation (NMT). AR models predict
tokens in a word-by-word manner and can effectively capture the distribution of
real translations. NAR models predict tokens by extracting bidirectional
contextual information which can improve the inference speed but they suffer
from performance degradation. Previous works utilized AR models to enhance NAR
models by reducing the training data's complexity or incorporating the global
information into AR models by virtue of NAR models. However, those investigated
methods only take advantage of the contextual information of a single type of
model while neglecting the diversity in the contextual information that can be
provided by different types of models. In this paper, we propose a novel
generic collaborative learning method, DCMCL, where AR and NAR models are
treated as collaborators instead of teachers and students. To hierarchically
leverage the bilateral contextual information, token-level mutual learning and
sequence-level contrastive learning are adopted between AR and NAR models.
Extensive experiments on four widely used benchmarks show that the proposed
DCMCL method can simultaneously improve both AR and NAR models with up to 1.38
and 2.98 BLEU scores respectively, and can also outperform the current
best-unified model with up to 0.97 BLEU scores for both AR and NAR decoding.
|
[
-0.3506221771,
-0.5351986885,
0.2618589997,
0.0164904781,
-0.433744967,
0.3948815167,
-0.2658671737,
-0.2553709149,
0.0113630528,
0.3534209728,
-0.4617152512,
-0.6098356247,
-0.6865516901,
0.0847191736,
-0.1452524066,
0.9876924157,
-0.1195892915,
0.3379602134,
-0.2578774393,
-0.5343878269,
-0.6535208821,
-0.7302105427,
-0.4777004421,
-0.367572546,
0.6504743695,
0.2000319064,
0.6263418794,
0.61872226,
0.480266422,
0.3274039924,
-0.1755880862,
0.4344606698,
-0.1662155539,
0.3088800609,
-0.3578847647,
-0.4167273939,
-0.5099502206,
-0.0092943078,
0.3041893244,
1.0329891443,
-0.2253615558,
-0.011287448,
0.4230102003,
0.6008860469,
-0.5464128256,
0.2738828361,
-0.6774610281,
0.2544554174,
0.4807091355,
0.0099964309,
-0.3478090763,
-0.1750126183,
0.3967729807,
-0.3319908679,
0.370344609,
-0.0658598542,
0.2867936194,
0.314227283,
-0.7007834315,
-0.3205539584,
-0.4993632436,
0.8576220274,
-0.555343926,
0.3188061714,
0.0211277399,
0.4092992246,
0.0648443922,
-0.6064165831,
-0.4313670993,
-0.228203401,
-0.1964032054,
0.3216850162,
-0.1268643141,
0.1019970402,
-0.2654970586,
0.4690785408,
-0.4788913727,
-0.0404831432,
-0.0415222198,
0.0534429662,
0.4876749218,
0.3353197277,
0.2265039086,
-0.0821041837,
-0.6668618917,
-0.2345504761,
-0.1613184661,
-0.1192912087,
-0.265481323,
0.4513893127,
-0.6025487185,
0.2378675044,
0.0620666519,
0.6912541986,
0.2023840249,
0.284684211,
0.2427960485,
-0.436078012,
-0.3251606524,
-0.3835068941,
0.8900542855,
0.2459022105,
-0.2756652236,
-0.694591403,
-0.2529675961,
-0.2001911849,
-0.0119397389,
-0.3857842982,
-0.3921805322,
-0.2361944616,
-0.5064874291,
-0.2967508137,
0.0234876778,
-0.8281123042,
-0.0013980186,
-0.6910656691,
0.4713764787,
-0.0957430378,
-0.4003663659,
-0.4908918738,
0.1361063719,
-0.138876617,
0.3873441219,
-0.8237941265,
0.4193166494,
0.3975308239,
1.1597793102,
-0.6608762741,
-0.5461722612,
-0.6484899521,
0.0074211564,
-0.4283783138,
0.2564997673,
-0.1626527756,
-0.5318512321,
-0.2586660981,
-0.1929603666,
-0.5439881682,
-0.5766126513,
0.0412314497,
-0.708470881,
0.0727664083,
-0.3957143724,
-0.2760504782,
-0.3772670627,
0.3399766386,
-0.6608331203,
0.6130029559,
0.2971389592,
-0.6979390979,
0.3956318796,
-0.5469486117,
-0.3004317284,
-0.1408313513,
-0.2876375616,
-0.3903951347,
0.0524636433,
0.2899042368,
0.4840077162,
-0.1759843379,
0.7802031636,
-0.1539378762,
0.0014511935,
0.1377025992,
-0.4467337132,
0.664504528,
0.3609348238,
-0.5141094327,
0.2047583014,
-0.4842363596,
-0.2568734586,
-0.1769346893,
-0.3680808842,
-0.2658490837,
-0.3692134023,
0.180711776,
0.6097977757,
0.1261679679,
-0.1952341944,
0.1611416042,
-0.1355063915,
0.2606824636,
0.5135711432,
0.1116256192,
0.7621033192,
-0.5402526855,
0.5955605507,
0.3677997589,
0.0247283448,
0.0338925496,
-0.3587557375,
-0.8226226568,
-0.3022157848,
0.2625011504,
0.3557037115,
-0.9880731106,
0.3938803971,
-0.0887339786,
-0.2770926654,
-0.4809101224,
0.1998341829,
0.5116198659,
0.8775339127,
0.8456425667,
-0.4705854654,
-0.6979207993,
-0.5439912081,
-0.0828582197,
0.0012515974,
0.1286285669,
0.4658022225,
0.4293709397,
-0.1485103071,
0.9566004872,
-0.0006991434,
-0.1984853446,
-0.3272933364,
0.4990229607,
0.1788664758,
0.6653145552,
0.338702023,
-0.9527512789,
-0.8537685871,
0.0363046266,
-0.8421669006,
0.0099611031,
-0.0802100003,
-0.1282994002,
0.2716560364,
0.5098161697,
-0.216204226,
0.3228708506,
0.9791820049,
-0.0955710039,
0.2817687988,
-0.2867556214,
0.278575927,
-1.437076807,
0.1050528958,
-0.2885605991,
-0.3060946465,
-0.4067029655,
0.1976737678,
0.0286429543,
0.0628048256,
-0.2778891921,
0.4176563919,
-0.7652885318,
-0.0692985207,
-0.3610484302,
0.0157455262,
0.09183909,
0.4968695045,
0.3155223131,
0.714910984,
0.4236066639,
-0.5401366353,
0.115273796,
0.1975248903,
0.0017251685,
0.2805300057,
-0.4669838548,
0.132743746,
0.1340590864,
0.3473986983,
-1.0156778097,
0.1447154284,
0.2079516649,
-0.5373350978,
0.2476698309,
-0.3864684701,
-0.5635078549,
0.0808060914,
0.5142859221,
0.4645583332,
0.3792075515,
-0.8707513809,
0.6962245107,
0.1169661507,
0.0871139392,
-0.5354419351,
-1.0138765574,
0.1544830054,
-0.0051099542,
-0.3780729175,
0.4356755018,
-0.0555503443,
-0.0062176869,
0.184706524,
-0.0331135057,
-0.2523615062,
0.0623920634,
0.2785788774,
0.5233830214,
-0.2450211644,
-0.0135355406,
0.1097177118,
-0.1747099608,
-0.1384657919,
-0.3408583999,
0.5496907234,
-0.1808090806,
-0.3281591833,
-0.2014032453,
0.6329286098,
0.5407921076,
-0.4408708215,
1.0399564505,
0.7357712984,
-0.1220786124,
-0.2504397929,
-0.4356625974,
-0.1486958861,
-0.4384039342,
0.2145939618,
-0.3085203767,
-0.94664675,
0.5991363525,
-0.0371893607,
-0.0878587514,
0.281866461,
0.6202299595,
0.3591555953,
1.0148456097,
0.8219828606,
-0.2499890476,
0.3713483214,
-0.5968430638,
-0.0892390758,
-1.0685056448,
-0.4555384219,
-0.013554723,
-0.2777130008,
-0.4430431426,
-0.6806688309,
0.3830568492,
0.2286465019,
-0.0226492845,
0.5031856894,
-0.524585247,
0.2385929525,
0.5197343826,
0.0955275521,
0.4630638063,
-0.0227910094,
-1.0209172964,
-0.0213503968,
-0.9465891719,
-0.0955530852,
0.8892675638,
-0.0827652588,
0.4224062562,
0.2963827252,
0.887319684,
0.0075736032,
0.4721252322,
-0.5739235282,
0.3024033904,
-0.1824910641,
-0.383449316,
0.1219766065,
-0.7335958481,
-0.8579631448,
0.6489745975,
-0.1667918116,
-0.3811630607,
0.4990665615,
-0.0028052693,
-0.2427675277,
0.555390656,
-0.5143688917,
0.7068933249,
-0.1606204361,
-0.4990133643,
-0.0919844732,
-0.8955968022,
0.2362673879,
0.0618660152,
0.2549086511,
0.2867680788,
-0.2468976974,
0.2048732787,
-0.3072367907,
0.9552356005,
-0.102035746,
0.2156638652,
0.1885566413,
0.3439958394,
0.4225900173,
0.1472564489,
-0.2334662676,
0.248761341,
-0.3867018223,
-0.2780109346,
-0.5121578574,
0.8498045802,
-0.9595722556,
-0.2633498311,
-0.4007774293,
-0.9754257202,
-0.2749547958,
0.0829151943,
0.3579641581,
0.3059780002,
-0.1408032328,
0.1788196862,
0.2771085203,
0.1275160015,
0.7265963554,
0.6379273534,
-0.0159379281,
-0.8971226811,
0.5205746293,
0.052718401,
0.561116159,
0.559784472,
0.0390358232,
-0.2073772103,
-0.6573844552,
-0.3646969199,
-0.0141035151,
-0.674590528,
-0.233655706,
-1.0967725515,
-0.2798159122,
-0.4004231989,
-0.4482305348,
-0.3517937958,
-0.1800068319,
-0.5179466009,
0.1169369519,
0.1067040488,
0.5847269893,
-0.5024852157,
0.1308584809,
-0.8116107583,
0.1458932012,
0.4270896912,
0.0322844386,
0.5571009517,
-0.4689565301,
-0.3649859428,
0.1024333164,
-0.297878623,
-0.6878396273,
0.8496081829,
0.0137028117,
0.7834707499,
-0.049974069,
0.128428787,
0.6760459542,
-0.4056375325,
0.5908896923,
0.3468358517,
-0.8746505976,
0.2274550349,
-0.4088406563,
0.4402509928,
0.7956491709,
0.5466744304,
-0.5979652405,
-0.1532214731,
-0.5488395691,
-0.9034104943,
0.390103668,
0.1996123642,
0.0157200228,
-0.110157378,
0.2487099916,
0.2773506045,
0.3308306932,
-0.6476873755,
-0.3456598222,
-0.3048748076,
-0.317756027,
-0.3648221791,
0.2334824055,
0.0667734742,
-0.3140665293,
0.3345282972,
-0.045163095,
-0.161327973,
0.6340611577,
-0.3378872573,
-0.0869947448,
0.0240315404,
0.2221219987,
0.4597228467,
-0.1448948085,
0.1070080772,
0.2839795053,
-0.1821736991,
0.2104403675,
0.0934559479,
0.0048427358,
0.0786436275,
0.2794326842,
0.5308554173,
0.1847925335,
-0.0972880349,
0.6112237573,
-0.1834627837,
-0.3844903409,
-0.0816036686,
-0.0831162557,
0.2374734581,
0.4497685432,
0.324829638,
0.6355572939,
0.2789770663,
-0.3666810393,
0.6090273857,
0.2592627108,
-0.7601317167,
-0.3666339815,
0.8052054048,
0.2428344041,
-0.1648725569,
0.5591410398,
-0.2557322383,
-0.5435759425,
0.7083670497,
0.7128387094,
0.975658536,
-0.2662139237,
0.1839817911,
0.4652096629,
0.0387951992,
-0.0031204147,
-0.2569154203,
-0.5072760582,
-0.4326911867,
-0.3458471894,
-0.4568725526,
-0.6183274984,
-0.0533815585,
-0.8937761188,
-0.0111518539,
-0.3347480893,
0.0182812922,
-0.322255969,
0.0725741908,
-0.699227035,
0.2054418623,
-0.0300057847,
0.4879035354,
-0.7899492383,
1.0164459944,
0.5943580866,
-0.5606496334,
-0.7329525352,
0.1695345193,
0.0936191529,
-0.5050848722,
0.9147051573,
0.0574804209,
-0.1045689732,
0.2403041869,
-0.2367842495,
-0.914552331,
1.3342418671,
0.1056330279,
-0.7208103538,
-0.0816477984,
0.0531450547,
0.5572451353,
-0.8139085174,
0.0964524969,
-0.142947495,
-0.0852665082,
0.3607070744,
-0.7718826532,
0.1083014905,
-0.2431204617,
0.2068953812,
0.0081839412,
-0.78549546,
1.1615831852,
-0.1665575504,
-0.0312553942,
0.255728662,
0.5937250853,
0.3755451739,
0.2591862082,
0.590760529,
0.4245363474,
0.54464674,
0.3834446669,
0.7073281407,
-0.2610363364,
0.486694634,
1.4541927576,
-0.0782263801,
0.8044221997,
0.4556681216,
0.1783825755,
0.5668809414,
0.4930822849,
-0.1979449987,
0.8541183472,
0.0708345175,
-0.5421928763,
-0.3379536569,
-0.1086300835,
-0.3410614431,
0.2492485046,
0.137426585,
-0.662325561,
-0.3570619226,
0.1338443458,
-0.2362065911,
0.3173490167,
-0.0641525015,
0.8788698912,
0.4141928256,
-0.7908539176,
0.6247178912,
-0.0610742271,
0.8095371723,
-0.1246138811,
-0.1627455056,
-0.3903907835,
0.2001112849,
0.1292898059,
-0.1303748488,
0.4003381729,
-0.1516962796,
-0.3982789516,
-0.077209793,
0.3522276878,
-0.7061290145,
-0.3474678993,
0.6796246767,
0.657998085,
-0.2657358646,
0.0933775529,
-0.9586267471,
-0.3074989319,
-0.2121315449,
0.2514862716,
0.4171774387,
0.3033644259,
0.2538029253,
0.4859874547,
0.6916958094,
0.0334044732,
0.0303277504,
-0.0126823289,
0.9343130589,
-0.4271864295,
-0.4045845568,
-0.8500151038,
0.563621521,
-0.0454932675,
-0.1854088157,
0.7696141005,
0.5212729573,
0.8361674547,
0.0401926637,
0.8135886788,
0.1649528444,
0.5126713514,
-0.3972319067,
0.9112669826,
-0.5195332766,
0.2666040659,
-0.1702869684,
-0.7829008698,
-0.4389047027,
0.4222114682,
-0.2661949098,
0.1406191438,
0.7247534394,
0.4457779527,
-0.2952092886,
-0.2153185606,
0.5490887761,
-0.098844476,
0.1216013357,
0.6020867229,
0.6954340935,
-0.5633906722,
0.6889221668,
-0.5512481928,
-0.1950000823,
-0.1810749322,
-0.7668124437,
-1.2195911407,
-0.6235611439,
-0.3383878767,
-0.1687812209,
0.2714913785,
1.0128567219,
1.0356900692,
-0.7901394963,
-0.2384791225,
-0.5896068215,
0.0990629345,
-0.2026650608,
-0.2207392603,
0.3440952897,
-0.6095666885,
-0.6354978085,
0.4706042707,
0.0032581943,
0.1791412085,
-0.0956533104,
-0.2184952945,
-0.4972201586,
-0.1592669189,
0.3605775833,
-0.0966998115,
-0.6227016449,
0.1785170287,
0.1152476519,
-0.277072072,
0.2705160677,
0.5864226222,
-0.6759556532,
0.544308722,
0.4784261286,
0.7044844627,
0.5194184184,
0.049631577,
0.8400593996,
-0.776915729,
0.1060261875,
0.2498553842,
0.2330498397,
0.5385699868,
-0.2699227035,
0.3417823911,
0.2886992097,
-0.7402099371,
-0.4650598168,
0.0928744748,
-0.7882035375,
-0.2982645631,
0.9219366908,
-0.4980244637,
-0.143100813,
-0.2119718194,
0.1165746674,
0.7437880039,
-0.3524220884,
0.683596611,
0.3786223829,
0.1225675568,
-0.3336416781,
-0.4673376381,
0.1412123889,
0.5407908559,
-0.4405680001,
-0.2294135988,
0.2784897387,
0.360478282,
-0.1252781749,
0.2213623077,
-0.2486763,
0.1916837394,
0.1456786692,
0.052819252,
-0.2638767064,
-0.202629447,
-0.5938914418,
0.0061555319,
0.0387045145,
-0.2146039158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18424v1
|
Emotion Classification in Low and Moderate Resource Languages
| 2024-02-28T15:46:09 | 2024-02-28T15:46:09 |
Shabnam Tafreshi, Shubham Vatsal, Mona Diab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It is important to be able to analyze the emotional state of people around
the globe. There are 7100+ active languages spoken around the world and
building emotion classification for each language is labor intensive.
Particularly for low-resource and endangered languages, building emotion
classification can be quite challenging. We present a cross-lingual emotion
classifier, where we train an emotion classifier with resource-rich languages
(i.e. \textit{English} in our work) and transfer the learning to low and
moderate resource languages. We compare and contrast two approaches of transfer
learning from a high-resource language to a low or moderate-resource language.
One approach projects the annotation from a high-resource language to low and
moderate-resource language in parallel corpora and the other one uses direct
transfer from high-resource language to the other languages. We show the
efficacy of our approaches on 6 languages: Farsi, Arabic, Spanish, Ilocano,
Odia, and Azerbaijani. Our results indicate that our approaches outperform
random baselines and transfer emotions across languages successfully. For all
languages, the direct cross-lingual transfer of emotion yields better results.
We also create annotated emotion-labeled resources for four languages: Farsi,
Azerbaijani, Ilocano and Odia.
|
[
-0.3921550512,
-0.2072735578,
0.0121127842,
0.3666015267,
-0.0783123598,
0.3467673361,
-0.6435940266,
-0.8533515334,
0.1073113605,
0.0639289245,
-0.222819671,
-0.2786553204,
-0.5112410784,
0.2384222895,
0.1640867442,
1.10503304,
-0.4710639417,
0.0880513936,
0.3228294253,
-0.5770308375,
-0.2228966802,
-0.6607989073,
-0.6673071384,
-0.2643326819,
0.8166286349,
0.6513597369,
0.4588924646,
0.0022012074,
0.3412491977,
0.3497900963,
0.0607147627,
-0.0690556169,
-0.5322354436,
-0.1706068814,
-0.2682136595,
-0.3750414252,
-0.1747060269,
-0.0170852821,
0.2407482713,
0.5193085074,
0.0811324343,
0.227662161,
-0.1715624481,
0.6749513745,
-0.9358834028,
0.386736989,
-0.0982123613,
0.5470964909,
-0.2779207826,
0.0051642326,
-0.3644438684,
-0.2371526062,
0.2012696117,
-0.3168241978,
-0.1135090888,
0.349483639,
0.6132196784,
0.1205435768,
-0.4825060666,
-0.3326557875,
-0.7269029021,
0.9283046126,
0.0099844057,
0.5046948791,
0.1914520264,
0.2164572328,
0.7887441516,
-0.2535547614,
-0.6374167204,
-0.0572911464,
-0.0775004402,
0.2176098377,
-0.4221039116,
-0.0046504335,
0.2203751057,
0.454411447,
-0.3952529132,
0.4423619211,
-0.4664325118,
-0.2994823456,
0.6426619291,
0.0319811702,
0.5378661752,
-0.3623484969,
-0.4314545691,
-0.2976778746,
-0.5886951089,
0.2023384869,
0.3657317162,
0.4596808255,
-0.4281672537,
0.1695990711,
-0.096416913,
0.3643527925,
-0.0039329981,
-0.0690479353,
0.4363818169,
-0.1519776583,
-0.0945147499,
0.2108802646,
0.8693503141,
0.278088063,
0.2382359505,
-0.0868500844,
-0.1871350855,
0.170789212,
-0.1694148481,
-0.6861665845,
-0.0535610728,
-0.1215891987,
-0.4690234363,
-0.0895100012,
-0.5043259859,
-1.2263609171,
-0.4054161012,
-0.1059302464,
0.2457018644,
-0.2849187553,
-0.3072934449,
-0.0185279101,
0.5132269859,
-0.0068884455,
0.4207633138,
-0.9201056361,
0.1718869209,
0.2315904796,
0.748026669,
-0.2438037992,
-0.1817354113,
-0.3140497804,
-0.1996456087,
-0.2638524175,
0.6962477565,
-0.5307007432,
-0.2115036547,
0.372828722,
0.1639769673,
-0.1319545358,
-0.4207623303,
0.6948409081,
-0.3370310664,
0.5022747517,
-0.3321989179,
0.0390720442,
-0.5198860765,
0.1680804491,
-0.7553147078,
0.9401327372,
0.4664291441,
-0.7148899436,
-0.016858872,
-0.6919203401,
-0.7414952517,
0.0867089108,
0.2552333474,
0.0857549906,
-0.0061516715,
-0.1722393036,
0.5302983522,
-0.5569466352,
-0.3712936342,
-0.2034802288,
-0.309103936,
0.1296804547,
-0.1858885437,
0.558465302,
0.6571561694,
-0.3824905455,
-0.1602055877,
-0.6387102008,
-0.1437119544,
-0.0815495923,
-0.4391859174,
-0.466183871,
-0.4445593953,
0.5078672767,
0.5322697163,
0.3335949779,
-0.5801155567,
-0.0678535923,
-0.0031482254,
0.0402390324,
0.6268504262,
-0.2648620903,
0.7489270568,
0.0161957964,
0.9098443389,
0.168731302,
-0.0623976663,
0.3850846589,
-0.0563864857,
-0.8955990076,
-0.2378241569,
0.2552962005,
0.9146499634,
-0.804363668,
0.2220328748,
-0.10185121,
-0.389123559,
-0.76504004,
0.1807121933,
0.6516452432,
0.5779787302,
0.3962295651,
-0.2567799389,
-0.4206267595,
-0.5820816159,
0.0528939515,
-0.3182558715,
0.2912510335,
0.5533666015,
-0.1147598997,
-0.2677628994,
0.0367851071,
-0.2047477216,
-0.1810321659,
-0.4246350527,
0.3548772037,
-0.1499054432,
0.3311370313,
0.8608175516,
-0.7192214131,
-1.003862381,
0.6686019301,
-0.5692693591,
-0.2921782732,
-0.0543743372,
-0.4346229136,
0.74779737,
0.0978064835,
-0.3451069593,
0.0836888552,
0.7362316251,
-0.0966716185,
0.0992850587,
0.1521716863,
0.4690110981,
-1.0581531525,
0.0651490912,
0.0295824874,
0.0440078825,
-0.4901884198,
-0.5050803423,
0.0255251434,
-0.2413850129,
-0.7817669511,
0.7880677581,
-0.5443632007,
0.0488240272,
-0.1014754921,
-0.1251361966,
-0.2849382162,
0.7081415653,
0.3133799136,
0.4708553553,
0.6153637171,
-0.2953789532,
0.7190644741,
0.2775585949,
-0.2671907544,
0.8809634447,
0.0923066437,
0.0693032667,
-0.0775033236,
0.0581481904,
-0.5427039862,
-0.0046743061,
0.3783662915,
-0.008559037,
0.5963905454,
-0.2828583419,
-0.1656356305,
-0.045498386,
-0.1441656947,
0.4905350506,
0.8745257854,
-0.5811414123,
0.5982707739,
0.1675441563,
-0.5039306283,
-0.6120128036,
-0.7968283892,
-0.0905213282,
-0.5310475826,
-0.3209665418,
-0.0402810425,
-0.0130239883,
-0.2878200114,
0.2564283013,
0.0942796841,
-0.2970432937,
-0.1615037769,
0.2925916314,
0.1875034124,
-0.1314693391,
0.2673297524,
-0.0313378982,
-0.0408473574,
-0.1305437982,
0.2201061547,
0.2296442688,
-0.4355451167,
-0.2684780657,
-0.2565659881,
0.5718316436,
0.5003036857,
-0.2825252712,
0.608336091,
1.0704698563,
-0.3861390948,
-0.377137363,
-0.4729324877,
0.2747891843,
-0.3286493123,
0.4809740484,
-0.4483562112,
-0.8919259906,
0.6156731248,
-0.2776740193,
-0.2854704857,
0.4448930919,
0.6926369071,
0.0476284437,
0.8764723539,
0.9704552889,
-0.6502399445,
0.8605045676,
-0.1455117911,
0.3145609498,
-0.5456855893,
-0.0276269354,
-0.6357130408,
-0.5511364341,
-0.8230284452,
-0.318837285,
-0.0155060021,
-0.0491061322,
-0.0718883723,
0.3118627369,
-0.1374403238,
0.3736718893,
0.1434193701,
-0.0630678982,
-0.0159346424,
0.2610542476,
0.1998615861,
-0.2784341574,
-0.7520596981,
-0.3806658983,
0.4865342677,
0.2392214388,
1.022102356,
0.2519335747,
0.827994287,
0.2183195055,
0.7591128349,
-1.019878149,
0.2759857178,
-0.4436464906,
-0.3325514495,
-0.1396706402,
-0.566160202,
-0.695581615,
0.11218106,
-0.276314348,
-0.7256667614,
0.4881066382,
-0.1288327575,
-0.2631999254,
0.4232983887,
-0.9800878763,
1.0914173126,
-0.5098654032,
-0.5276494622,
-0.4311857224,
-0.5650593042,
0.3527158201,
-0.2882577181,
0.4838041663,
-0.2422676831,
0.090831697,
0.6779574752,
-0.1878251135,
0.7819725275,
-0.1482865959,
-0.0006039591,
0.2516314983,
0.3033717871,
0.2355959713,
-0.3255002201,
-0.1766680032,
0.1322294325,
-0.1948942989,
-0.3531667888,
-0.4531433284,
0.6425901651,
-0.9265578985,
-0.2430177778,
-0.5358942151,
-0.524029851,
-0.1866846681,
-0.0096466728,
0.1373382509,
-0.1252993792,
-0.1595392227,
-0.1131175458,
0.4925302863,
-0.4738392234,
0.3030437231,
0.7073611021,
0.2628242373,
-0.2155551463,
1.2160128355,
0.1746685058,
0.1960119903,
0.4064873159,
0.2209059149,
-0.1656703353,
-0.1616277844,
-0.4013306201,
0.1667395234,
-0.9058508277,
-0.3432302475,
-0.3828518391,
-0.0113853384,
-0.1335735023,
-0.4811894596,
-0.4454331994,
-0.2130064964,
-0.1451105922,
-0.1030906886,
0.4862035811,
0.5417721272,
-0.4831888676,
-0.0947813913,
-1.1149699688,
-0.0347989835,
0.405477047,
0.244911164,
-0.0261249971,
-0.5235757828,
-0.4095300138,
-0.2318835407,
-0.0166049115,
-0.9383299947,
0.5982003808,
0.4589311481,
0.2713758349,
0.4746184945,
0.5468999147,
0.6426817179,
-0.3237030804,
0.423592627,
0.4185463786,
-1.1316041946,
0.2589688599,
0.1818754226,
-0.1745434552,
0.4951228201,
1.0278366804,
-1.015201807,
0.0912748501,
-0.4160012901,
-0.7328242064,
1.1126025915,
-0.2641493678,
0.1636744738,
0.0032670023,
-0.0610719509,
0.1177629381,
-0.0973202363,
-0.7257164717,
0.1024982929,
-0.0150121534,
-0.5083340406,
-0.1238075048,
-0.134022668,
-0.1113487631,
-0.0851797089,
0.4257142544,
-0.1741920859,
0.1614856124,
-0.0128120165,
-0.480175972,
-0.6001524329,
0.3952714801,
0.0896696225,
-0.1565568596,
-0.2188575566,
0.4038270116,
0.6745358706,
-0.2492342442,
0.3685164154,
0.1747816652,
0.1780073941,
-0.0949543342,
0.3839300573,
1.1453680992,
0.4366731644,
-0.691378057,
0.5179355741,
-0.0050187781,
0.2071173936,
0.1052923054,
-0.4183122814,
0.0497082993,
0.5951512456,
-0.1879100502,
0.0065867081,
0.2156670094,
-0.8925040364,
-0.2839948833,
0.0539848842,
-0.4398167431,
-0.6807361841,
0.0619845502,
0.5689301491,
-0.0349498987,
0.5121921897,
-0.5170626044,
-1.0047569275,
0.2724334598,
0.407160908,
0.9787050486,
-0.3969498575,
0.1830174029,
0.3392002285,
0.0857957676,
-0.0944657102,
0.5318817496,
-0.289899379,
-0.7018760443,
-0.546292305,
-0.7645632625,
-0.8009806871,
-0.3332202733,
-0.6753870249,
0.1255061924,
-0.2739026248,
0.2080509067,
-0.0952914208,
0.2696103156,
-0.977699399,
0.0392193161,
0.7764959335,
0.6481186152,
-1.4631155729,
0.6936804056,
1.089152813,
-0.5190317035,
-0.6301842928,
-0.3595766723,
-0.0978580192,
-0.7017238736,
1.1434113979,
0.1360576898,
-0.3132570088,
-0.3002135754,
-0.227597028,
-0.6884027123,
0.7076733708,
0.3090776503,
-0.4052658975,
0.3482875526,
-0.0974360257,
0.9566260576,
-0.2955739498,
0.1762237996,
0.0797343403,
0.4489128292,
0.1001666114,
-1.0032057762,
0.1331350207,
-0.242639944,
-0.1198598742,
0.2213842422,
-0.9931027889,
0.7489196062,
-0.1706566364,
-0.5369086862,
-0.1759832799,
0.6392947435,
-0.2002312988,
0.3186862767,
0.6409800053,
0.4511696398,
0.7059040666,
-0.2004389465,
0.7164601088,
-0.5038195252,
0.2959415317,
0.3643401265,
-0.7640671134,
0.971103549,
0.244433865,
-0.4339355826,
0.5253016949,
0.7932875752,
0.2372183502,
0.4020073712,
0.3131290376,
-0.5292614102,
-0.1991818994,
-0.6767123342,
-0.2157944739,
0.3840982318,
0.3732809424,
0.1083492115,
-0.139867425,
0.3913110197,
0.3007764518,
-0.1794040352,
-0.3713642955,
0.5412880778,
0.0016371086,
-0.5120649338,
0.6817133427,
-0.1865118295,
0.8736273646,
-0.3355126083,
0.101857014,
-0.490316242,
0.181667611,
-0.470713824,
-0.7038360238,
0.2672353387,
0.4757920802,
-0.0303513613,
-0.4762881696,
0.6585888267,
-0.832367003,
-0.2594988942,
0.6152309179,
0.5528662205,
0.4619092345,
0.2857117355,
-0.5734006763,
0.0721697956,
-0.0517403372,
-0.305575788,
0.5990896821,
0.8788782954,
-0.3607228994,
0.3115344048,
0.3946577013,
0.1637071222,
-0.0138958702,
0.0970028415,
0.6672786474,
-0.703637898,
-0.3284235895,
-0.3197925091,
0.1859488934,
0.2189308256,
-0.3132496476,
0.4937761128,
0.2092478573,
0.9379917979,
-0.245061636,
0.8145645261,
-0.4349903762,
0.2699762285,
-0.3702054322,
0.4399573505,
-0.6556148529,
-0.3183064163,
-0.3638921678,
-0.8509348035,
-0.1355373412,
0.7317774892,
-0.2551245987,
-0.1667957306,
0.8415808678,
0.2512103915,
0.0711347312,
-0.3107060492,
0.3161385953,
0.1043139398,
-0.164546445,
1.1207518578,
1.0004343987,
-0.0952321738,
0.6798544526,
-0.7749627233,
-0.4214372337,
-0.2767630517,
-0.8045373559,
-0.6307276487,
-0.3470326066,
-0.5302141309,
-0.4105655849,
-0.0559102483,
1.0882622004,
0.5667085648,
-0.8997597694,
-0.3671811521,
0.520057261,
0.2646287382,
-0.0529479757,
-0.1936870813,
0.3228746951,
-0.3774423599,
-1.0499192476,
0.1703308225,
0.2683035135,
0.1450140178,
-0.2428788245,
-0.3538465202,
-0.0630666837,
-0.2565971315,
0.672457993,
0.7541729212,
-0.3376905024,
-0.3762265444,
-0.0504346676,
-0.426135987,
-0.0682476684,
0.4727039337,
-0.3002887964,
0.3647826314,
0.8257011175,
0.7524735928,
0.5269444585,
-0.2966977358,
0.25144732,
-0.718983531,
0.4484086037,
0.1783910096,
0.5773476362,
0.5262207985,
-0.3581993282,
0.681419909,
0.3568256497,
-0.4221512973,
-0.8109050989,
0.2447095364,
-1.0793429613,
0.1060689539,
1.0953807831,
-0.4419283569,
-0.2239388078,
0.2247756124,
-0.3441221118,
0.5548806787,
-0.3416927457,
0.8274739981,
0.7440466881,
-0.3068356216,
-0.3415381014,
-0.3218473196,
0.5055920482,
0.6173950434,
-0.9625403881,
0.0307490639,
0.5471020937,
0.0087658502,
0.6059992313,
0.3767843843,
0.0039801607,
0.2284148186,
-0.0225271154,
0.7325362563,
0.3962238729,
-0.1021599993,
-0.6535027623,
-0.0123440679,
-0.0121907238,
-0.102749601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18419v1
|
Can GPT Improve the State of Prior Authorization via Guideline Based Automated Question Answering?
| 2024-02-28T15:39:53 | 2024-02-28T15:39:53 |
Shubham Vatsal, Ayush Singh, Shabnam Tafreshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Health insurance companies have a defined process called prior authorization
(PA) which is a health plan cost-control process that requires doctors and
other healthcare professionals to get clearance in advance from a health plan
before performing a particular procedure on a patient in order to be eligible
for payment coverage. For health insurance companies, approving PA requests for
patients in the medical domain is a time-consuming and challenging task. One of
those key challenges is validating if a request matches up to certain criteria
such as age, gender, etc. In this work, we evaluate whether GPT can validate
numerous key factors, in turn helping health plans reach a decision drastically
faster. We frame it as a question answering task, prompting GPT to answer a
question from patient electronic health record. We experiment with different
conventional prompting techniques as well as introduce our own novel prompting
technique. Moreover, we report qualitative assessment by humans on the natural
language generation outputs from our approach. Results show that our method
achieves superior performance with the mean weighted F1 score of 0.61 as
compared to its standard counterparts.
|
[
-0.2697432041,
-0.980992794,
1.0819472075,
0.085125491,
-0.3570381999,
-0.1194634363,
0.2501503229,
-0.5086864829,
-0.1675652713,
0.3736949265,
-0.5474817753,
-0.0946336314,
-0.1964311004,
0.3201544583,
0.1495721191,
0.8772907853,
-0.2986115217,
0.0805326998,
-0.2837581038,
0.3004291952,
-0.6115705371,
-0.4120000303,
-1.0662248135,
-0.3940753043,
0.2252406776,
0.1394262165,
0.4557513297,
0.1270795017,
0.5219016671,
0.3077119887,
-0.1739696711,
0.2621841431,
0.0541566871,
0.0010469193,
-0.1370909065,
-0.3618840277,
-0.7914879322,
0.1010444462,
0.446226716,
0.5364702344,
-0.3905905187,
0.1692397147,
0.0559441298,
0.6978678703,
-0.5038294196,
-0.0262244865,
-0.543487072,
-0.0902404636,
0.0990892276,
-0.4560507834,
-0.2648904324,
-0.5999277234,
0.6896018386,
-0.8358231187,
0.2842124104,
-0.0059735421,
0.9911664724,
0.4894829392,
-0.2157520652,
-0.2859227657,
-0.7801973224,
-0.0457456782,
-0.526088357,
0.3554622531,
0.5671487451,
0.4734264016,
-0.0248593017,
-0.8155982494,
-0.9305371046,
-0.312685281,
-0.3097231686,
0.2435400188,
-0.2331469655,
0.2177134454,
0.5623053312,
0.3409410417,
-0.7540314198,
-0.2283195406,
-0.3872076869,
-0.3143229783,
0.5683637857,
-0.0031027347,
0.3328389227,
-0.2166666985,
-0.3614546061,
0.1000389233,
-0.5652381778,
0.2330919355,
0.2194605023,
-0.2169869244,
-0.0786485747,
0.3743728995,
-0.5330283642,
0.4872187078,
0.4918444157,
0.1555656642,
0.3761718869,
-0.2132967412,
-0.611083746,
0.095995456,
0.3603889048,
0.4407240152,
0.5185840726,
0.0229471326,
-0.0155788325,
-0.2521094084,
0.2556781769,
-0.742438674,
-0.3103092611,
0.5424475074,
-0.4646668136,
0.2194446027,
0.3932852745,
-0.5534166098,
-0.4104768038,
-0.4560276866,
0.4027654231,
-0.4244008064,
-0.3142913282,
0.0649822429,
-0.0337666571,
0.6557043195,
0.6365180612,
-0.4615373611,
0.2742699683,
0.5356087685,
0.6028795838,
0.1613084674,
0.0161365382,
-0.5664995313,
-0.0649729446,
-0.3978793025,
0.7636721134,
-0.3110405505,
-0.5995436907,
-0.180571124,
0.0374419913,
-0.4792816043,
-0.4595555365,
0.4716660976,
-0.8716944456,
0.4724384844,
-0.4209260345,
-0.3514394462,
-0.0958946869,
0.4400998354,
-0.3077669144,
0.4306387603,
0.1542618126,
-0.6225430965,
0.9170311689,
-0.7230681777,
-0.3280656636,
0.3346455693,
-0.2485328317,
-0.5477207303,
-0.055968605,
0.6227356791,
0.2189451754,
-0.1757767648,
0.2026139051,
0.083832033,
-0.2230363488,
0.243331328,
-0.423376143,
0.6681059003,
0.4004158974,
-0.3031317592,
0.3426322043,
-0.5345878601,
0.4589779377,
0.1262295991,
-0.2499498874,
-0.3424130082,
-0.2372835726,
-0.4368064702,
0.1144242659,
-0.032790944,
-0.1787621975,
0.3513729572,
-0.4125192165,
0.2412132174,
0.843623817,
0.7285019755,
0.5567007661,
-0.354580611,
0.7798554897,
-0.3953371048,
0.3192556798,
-0.2136955857,
-0.7409777045,
-0.1194179282,
-0.1670729667,
0.3370013237,
0.729791522,
-0.7824734449,
0.3596443236,
-0.1489803791,
-0.1480751485,
-0.4862203598,
-0.1339907348,
0.2044679821,
1.0587726831,
0.3517168462,
-0.2645143569,
-0.0667861849,
-0.5013306141,
0.0826564804,
-0.6442195177,
-0.3852128983,
0.3023810983,
0.3635831177,
-0.1808500737,
0.9764314294,
-0.6188928485,
-0.3303427696,
-0.1120946705,
0.2570486069,
0.0954605192,
0.430899322,
0.3415889144,
-1.0732830763,
-0.5432550907,
-0.0415121429,
-0.4860179722,
-0.2998583913,
-0.2714770436,
-0.0244127605,
0.0426921211,
0.3894038796,
-0.5122436881,
0.4695442319,
0.1195091084,
-0.4478507936,
0.3950701058,
-0.6701660156,
0.537674427,
-0.6882663369,
0.4476551414,
-0.1652941406,
-0.1130725443,
-0.5933212042,
-0.0728395507,
0.2074676603,
-0.2784705758,
-0.4292525351,
0.4661185443,
-0.5038555264,
0.4900989234,
-0.2639867067,
-0.4726490378,
-0.140783146,
0.2215497792,
-0.0035443641,
0.935251832,
0.5085598826,
-0.9265328646,
0.0305918436,
0.3548856378,
-0.1580215245,
0.9886395335,
-0.9788297415,
0.4323399067,
-0.5369957089,
0.5014273524,
-0.9957234859,
-0.3749315441,
0.5838060975,
-0.3330470026,
0.1413270682,
-0.2869227529,
-0.0000673188,
-0.5851825476,
0.0719467476,
0.1328939348,
0.5627199411,
-0.0071173827,
0.6531510949,
0.0053299707,
-0.4662476778,
-0.3070862591,
-0.3314539492,
-0.1239253655,
-0.1026820242,
-0.4805704355,
0.3239732683,
-0.0548400059,
-0.3270410299,
0.0319780782,
-0.2557540536,
-0.3452581763,
-0.0710694343,
0.3071084619,
0.1518017203,
-0.1075866669,
0.2137601525,
0.1553467065,
-0.3964081407,
0.0691129714,
-0.4748153687,
0.4712906182,
0.0831613913,
-0.4157864749,
-0.8998657465,
0.5875436068,
0.5368557572,
-0.5794886947,
0.0818168968,
0.4135673344,
-0.4792122245,
0.3147262633,
-0.7839984298,
-0.2335148156,
-0.4703663588,
-0.0510816686,
-0.3953425288,
-0.3743540645,
0.3683388531,
-0.0026718301,
0.1256049573,
0.40851143,
0.4411482215,
0.0343773402,
0.962690711,
0.5045530796,
0.1080711856,
0.3473549783,
-0.0352473482,
-0.1882240325,
-0.5930359364,
-0.1704141796,
-0.5372036695,
0.0816711038,
-0.4043622017,
-0.3509145081,
0.5596779585,
0.0108187851,
0.1500638872,
-0.1258916259,
-0.5636705756,
0.3182589412,
0.4371267259,
0.5417634845,
0.3856035173,
-0.2538169622,
-0.1150010601,
0.114051424,
-0.1875962615,
-0.4922823012,
1.0151292086,
0.3072690368,
0.3678149283,
-0.0488955788,
0.6342540979,
0.4012698531,
0.6233679056,
-0.4501388669,
0.476936698,
0.3584007621,
-0.7181898952,
-0.4646016359,
-0.4756152332,
-0.9752742648,
0.0061603035,
-0.1748598069,
-0.6079984903,
0.304564923,
0.6539987326,
-0.8314990401,
-0.1881177574,
-1.0936033726,
0.7948247194,
-0.3219505847,
-0.052757442,
0.0214739516,
-0.6636283994,
-0.0577113442,
-0.0814822987,
-0.1843184084,
-0.0757069141,
-0.0355719514,
0.5391995907,
-0.6002593637,
0.4011839628,
-0.7224954367,
-0.0411904119,
0.4888222516,
-0.2699456811,
0.6554967761,
0.2514044046,
-0.0567964762,
-0.2773982286,
0.0834956467,
-0.3018864989,
-0.7486606836,
0.3736024201,
-0.3093114197,
-0.77150172,
-0.3964212239,
-0.1371506006,
-0.6195799112,
0.4630038142,
0.2685650587,
-0.0202502999,
-0.0474333428,
-0.3232999146,
0.5433667302,
-0.1036759838,
0.2193912566,
0.7393217683,
0.09651272,
-0.2438682616,
0.3352718353,
0.2460165769,
0.2110079676,
0.4417881668,
0.6202557087,
-0.5570490956,
-0.8844436407,
-0.5986616611,
0.083564885,
-0.4131060541,
0.0781221092,
-0.7585625648,
0.1631985903,
-0.5765770078,
0.1029722318,
0.4192883968,
0.0855256096,
0.2132662833,
-0.2373612076,
0.0651754662,
0.5125278831,
0.2020265609,
0.3602149189,
-0.4959008694,
0.5581102371,
0.7207769752,
0.2732336223,
-0.3200864196,
-0.0156188086,
0.4103055596,
-0.1590021402,
-0.1204586923,
-1.2458257675,
-0.0929020643,
-0.0033423484,
0.8695824146,
0.3787893355,
0.2198250592,
0.8561014533,
-0.8496001363,
0.6625068784,
-0.0028138626,
-0.9405398965,
0.8242017627,
-0.1933485866,
0.4088024199,
0.9502561688,
0.6498095989,
-0.4038805366,
-0.2587363124,
-0.6783787608,
-0.9482815862,
0.1729731262,
0.0507160947,
0.1348339766,
0.1226984859,
0.5261707902,
-0.091852732,
0.217884019,
-0.319665134,
-0.1978895217,
-0.0045216936,
0.0241705645,
0.1924730539,
-0.2055836767,
0.0528066605,
0.010727535,
0.3246721625,
-0.1641502678,
0.2642515004,
0.9933380485,
0.0355125256,
-0.2349034399,
0.638504982,
0.7881036997,
1.1948436499,
-0.207670629,
-0.2285847813,
0.2768794596,
-0.7802776694,
0.1566163749,
0.4547980726,
-0.510676384,
-0.0473671928,
-0.0096504511,
0.3233683407,
-0.2817978859,
-0.3025589883,
0.4646883011,
-0.3060901761,
-0.5814829469,
-0.10792806,
-0.0135276271,
-0.5768409967,
0.0658012405,
0.7089223266,
-0.1429060847,
0.1665819138,
-0.2899498343,
0.6797366142,
0.2742978334,
-0.5235732198,
-0.0742200613,
0.7283772826,
0.2547389269,
-0.2571819127,
0.5415624976,
-0.1265275776,
-0.3739279807,
0.3673877418,
0.3004981875,
0.7382119298,
-0.4602355361,
0.3101170659,
0.4075550437,
0.4524103105,
0.1276652217,
0.5266641378,
-0.1985656321,
-0.2217382938,
-0.7708984613,
-0.1978495866,
-0.6552106738,
0.1455719173,
-0.4412042797,
-0.0805282295,
-0.6723700166,
-0.1355269849,
-0.0510837473,
-0.0456944332,
-0.9136541486,
0.544647336,
-0.0944114476,
0.8225255013,
-0.7042005658,
0.4453617036,
0.970746994,
-0.4881550968,
-1.3261235952,
0.406886518,
0.1260856688,
-0.7472397685,
0.4016236961,
0.0147571545,
0.0841929689,
-0.0640730634,
-0.3209679723,
-0.3037844002,
0.9828643203,
0.1630563736,
-0.363327086,
-0.4003270566,
-0.1398741305,
0.5076633692,
0.1144319773,
0.4103743434,
0.3846673667,
0.7456151247,
0.1083004102,
-1.1289337873,
0.3291363716,
-0.2287057787,
-0.5228148103,
0.1169696674,
0.0092063528,
0.7012813687,
-0.3586515784,
-0.4461784959,
-0.075871706,
0.618263185,
0.0444392338,
0.7330750227,
0.9997495413,
0.1703781337,
1.2657176256,
-0.137431711,
1.393134594,
0.1376351118,
0.0785878003,
0.8828567863,
-0.5062396526,
0.5756884217,
0.5863313675,
-0.3420549631,
0.3159862757,
0.6313183904,
0.3487346768,
0.4210612774,
0.2433824837,
-0.2317376286,
-0.1815902889,
0.0278469082,
-0.7168360353,
0.1990931779,
0.008988684,
-0.2663091123,
-0.1083074883,
0.0577618405,
-0.0230463929,
0.050830476,
-0.3455533385,
1.125885129,
-0.0320495702,
-0.9463051558,
0.2085368633,
-0.3609263003,
0.3364884853,
-1.0021702051,
-0.1805273145,
0.108347334,
0.0577174015,
-0.2056435943,
-0.4552027285,
0.2260381728,
0.0280089807,
-0.1831828654,
-0.4493020475,
0.6227360368,
-0.1947247535,
-0.1724764556,
-0.3171825707,
0.6471969485,
-0.0596832074,
-0.4816679657,
-0.9094964266,
-0.4639606774,
-0.3060352802,
-0.1426206529,
-0.1730001271,
0.4002701044,
-0.2075905651,
0.4790097475,
1.0664675236,
0.6277714968,
-0.0903322324,
0.1159275919,
0.4378897846,
-0.2183173597,
-1.0881153345,
-0.7853921652,
0.6910267472,
-0.3199149966,
-0.4609290957,
0.5077477694,
0.1637580395,
0.7752645016,
-0.0034588694,
0.6408587098,
-0.220626995,
0.6899976134,
-0.849778831,
0.6874622107,
-0.4009097517,
0.0298339892,
-0.5983929634,
-0.4376687706,
-0.4841420949,
0.5269804001,
-0.9668171406,
0.036636062,
0.6030147672,
0.5475849509,
0.2201799303,
-0.0023805983,
0.0633210763,
-0.2780458033,
0.709091723,
0.3941966295,
0.8044119477,
-0.1202944592,
0.5675869584,
-0.1306239963,
-0.4636647403,
-0.0074109873,
-0.916972518,
-0.5631002188,
-0.2981618047,
-0.4193611443,
-0.364685446,
0.2432146072,
0.9711412191,
0.7145966887,
-0.6021113992,
0.4385320246,
-0.2178726643,
0.1242210418,
-0.6653363109,
-0.2371399105,
0.4696422219,
-0.1302164793,
-0.5675640702,
0.0890658274,
0.1125146747,
0.3802426457,
0.2135613561,
-0.0784478262,
0.1880582273,
-0.2250573635,
0.2308866084,
0.4257961214,
-0.3693026304,
-0.253638953,
0.2093113065,
-0.0269344915,
-0.0155654335,
1.3457204103,
-0.5964832306,
0.6382420063,
0.586402297,
0.852460444,
0.1309708655,
0.487293452,
0.6552995443,
-0.2751421928,
-0.0192534272,
0.3762523234,
0.3430833519,
-0.0469222143,
-0.5948243737,
0.1945119649,
-0.0595325418,
-0.6543184519,
-0.3747907579,
0.1802681834,
-0.9532908797,
0.027336726,
0.8657476306,
-0.1223475859,
-0.0830500796,
-0.603669405,
-0.7420484424,
-0.0225928482,
-0.5165792704,
0.6796286702,
0.4698480368,
-0.279432267,
-0.1707890332,
-0.385730952,
0.6753150821,
0.3939188719,
-1.1189061403,
0.0307004843,
0.4479491413,
0.4202007353,
0.2348865867,
1.4634865522,
-0.1853694469,
0.7906472087,
-0.3978911638,
-0.5082995296,
-0.3551124334,
-0.2539405823,
-0.3352893293,
0.3407700658,
0.0895898044,
-0.4582033157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18409v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18409v3
|
A Cognitive Evaluation Benchmark of Image Reasoning and Description for Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-28T15:28:36 | 2024-06-14T09:35:57 |
Xiujie Song, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu, Chunhao Zhang, Yanyi Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs), despite their recent success, are
hardly comprehensively tested for their cognitive abilities. Inspired by the
prevalent use of the "Cookie Theft" task in human cognition test, we propose a
novel evaluation benchmark to evaluate high-level cognitive ability of LVLMs
using images with rich semantics. It defines eight reasoning capabilities and
consists of an image description task and a visual question answering task. Our
evaluation on well-known LVLMs shows that there is still a large gap in
cognitive ability between LVLMs and humans.
|
[
-0.4772588611,
-0.7379179597,
0.6352202296,
-0.1843904704,
-0.2540538907,
0.1051201895,
-0.3184962869,
-0.8686238527,
-0.3115375042,
0.7124419212,
-0.4344747663,
-0.2719907761,
-0.4913623035,
-0.0519056208,
-0.527859211,
0.5078940392,
-0.108888261,
0.1753643304,
-0.5823837519,
-0.0769835338,
-0.7530095577,
-0.099020645,
-0.5256687999,
-0.0494822338,
0.4140377045,
0.0407097824,
0.6479638815,
0.4807753861,
0.8796401024,
0.2943021655,
0.0689320788,
0.0475155301,
-0.2985661924,
-0.114559263,
-0.3657486141,
-0.3915243149,
-0.1745616347,
-0.1613499522,
0.6160774231,
0.6399587393,
-0.0116708735,
0.4706248045,
-0.2280956209,
0.6261258125,
-1.0644737482,
0.1822712719,
-0.8402600884,
-0.0799972713,
-0.0957204401,
0.1890640259,
-0.41442433,
-0.1934477836,
0.1570832431,
-0.731798172,
0.1765328199,
0.3732721806,
1.0448007584,
0.2167454362,
-0.2295274436,
-0.1678371131,
-0.5342245698,
0.9535040259,
-0.4061452746,
0.349209547,
0.6943792701,
0.8017109036,
0.0425843559,
-0.8160319924,
-0.630546689,
-0.3172671795,
0.1109833717,
0.0926890746,
-0.2172905356,
-0.3109443784,
0.3759810925,
0.2876529396,
-0.4788496494,
0.1578909755,
-0.5735586882,
-0.2081423402,
0.6309658289,
0.4436444342,
0.3270462155,
-0.1263079643,
-0.525750339,
-0.17182827,
-0.2832437456,
0.3675721288,
-0.2323705405,
-0.1847964525,
0.2819362581,
0.6992654204,
-0.3845895529,
0.9040811062,
-0.4933415055,
-0.2427278459,
0.2713413835,
-0.2156665325,
-0.4804793,
-0.2715957165,
0.4548996091,
0.8610724211,
0.3766655624,
-0.0625546575,
-0.4093043804,
0.4200341105,
0.1659882218,
-0.5191435814,
0.0819344446,
0.0439090505,
-0.7697049975,
-0.00614283,
-0.049279809,
-0.8037514687,
-0.4468258321,
-0.0266291648,
0.3486189842,
-0.3999355137,
-0.1971973181,
0.4961747527,
-0.4773723483,
0.7066236138,
0.5463319421,
-0.474799335,
0.4944434464,
0.7429384589,
0.3885785639,
-0.3270554245,
-0.4235265851,
-0.5173974037,
0.0772078484,
-0.3860697746,
0.8498701453,
-0.6685025692,
-0.2410105318,
-0.0290168636,
0.1563261002,
0.1076474786,
-0.7482576966,
0.6371857524,
-0.7607851624,
-0.1329755485,
-0.4576933384,
-0.5800881982,
-0.1704002321,
0.467640698,
-0.6827667356,
0.9215129614,
0.124095045,
-0.4569735229,
0.5632227659,
-0.2297682166,
-0.404494822,
0.6046870351,
-0.4450683296,
-0.3365342021,
0.0184472036,
0.2469725907,
0.4678356946,
-0.7905438542,
0.0862439722,
-0.4512873292,
-0.5665478706,
0.599781394,
-0.2827195823,
0.8204971552,
0.2604039907,
-0.4190171063,
-0.0112776989,
-0.63367486,
0.3690614998,
0.5801921487,
-0.2769795954,
-0.4448825121,
0.0137636857,
-0.0984211415,
0.122631073,
0.4644057751,
-0.5585119128,
0.0404271521,
0.1040350795,
0.3448140025,
0.6633222103,
-0.1298794299,
0.1358259171,
-0.2016937286,
0.3628564775,
-0.1439694166,
0.4687996805,
-0.1474761367,
-0.5363914371,
-0.6944090724,
-0.5143122673,
0.0054393373,
0.6865417361,
-1.0036700964,
0.3797611892,
-0.3802026808,
-0.5663142204,
-0.4210297167,
0.1756676137,
0.8153740168,
0.1979067475,
0.3488087058,
-0.57648772,
-0.0060010813,
-1.2702614069,
-0.4101358354,
0.0249664243,
0.0032188972,
0.4668414593,
0.8273951411,
0.0392661542,
0.3798179328,
-0.4583056271,
-0.2970649302,
0.006459726,
-0.1125616208,
-0.0562817156,
0.234547168,
0.4346596301,
-0.7662286758,
-0.1519775093,
-0.1306199133,
-0.8168587685,
0.3925887346,
0.0175205395,
-0.1212661862,
0.0990730971,
0.5965536237,
-0.7815832496,
0.9140717983,
0.1776192784,
-0.5637659431,
0.7265839577,
-0.1615222096,
0.4328535497,
-0.3237470686,
-0.0178388767,
-0.0143381674,
-0.0182679612,
-0.0830501467,
0.2557601333,
0.1998390555,
-0.0406733342,
-0.6204006076,
0.6399818063,
-0.7281008959,
-0.6256756783,
0.1289005876,
0.1765043288,
0.005769657,
0.2830420732,
0.2071126103,
0.2986843884,
1.0137832165,
-0.3473555148,
0.7165326476,
0.1151831448,
-1.0931645632,
0.8433778286,
-0.4919578433,
0.0882816166,
-0.170468837,
0.1042029262,
-0.9341613054,
-0.2467205077,
-0.1744107753,
-0.2263438255,
-0.0889698863,
0.197889477,
-0.5835298896,
-0.711356461,
-0.1240896359,
0.5465854406,
0.7928299904,
-0.4377069473,
0.5976226926,
0.1509949863,
0.3270823359,
-0.6019120216,
-0.7329028845,
0.2781462371,
-0.1651595533,
-0.5850241184,
0.0091061126,
0.0150392437,
-0.457393676,
0.3184323609,
0.0474705957,
-0.1072056293,
0.0724042282,
0.1014506444,
0.3637266457,
-0.168062076,
0.1736537963,
-0.7390042543,
0.177517131,
0.186591208,
-0.1100551486,
0.3320223987,
-0.504216671,
-0.6060519218,
-0.2945157886,
0.3496232331,
0.7110698223,
-0.6883954406,
0.4895945787,
0.5153329372,
-0.4722099304,
-0.1453780085,
-0.7206216455,
0.1242736951,
-0.3914031684,
0.5499160886,
-0.6701463461,
-0.6485344172,
0.3485264778,
0.1970946491,
-0.0462044254,
0.3784812987,
0.4751461148,
-0.1199618205,
0.8868193626,
0.0297598597,
0.3598053753,
0.2751077116,
-0.1539979875,
-0.0223959573,
-0.828330934,
-0.573076725,
-0.4196797609,
-0.2064408362,
-0.1468284279,
-0.6724299192,
0.0712821931,
0.1189344376,
-0.3998425603,
0.1611364037,
-0.6649881601,
0.6314380765,
0.6243469715,
0.1612001657,
0.1818140298,
-0.0125781037,
-0.0181995146,
-0.023830438,
-0.2424023896,
-0.4299336374,
0.7673860192,
0.1425038725,
0.754774034,
-0.0643216446,
0.207836017,
0.2940660417,
0.0287565179,
-0.693044126,
1.0223317146,
-0.2264657319,
-0.7361578941,
-0.3604146838,
-0.3125407398,
-1.0827723742,
0.2176107466,
-0.4658414125,
-1.1241008043,
-0.0788637474,
-0.08404921,
-0.0608399957,
0.4093518853,
-0.5458217859,
1.0608838797,
-0.7725576758,
-0.291428864,
-0.5630760193,
-0.4646317363,
0.5274312496,
0.14112252,
0.2994977832,
-0.3788483441,
-0.1155856848,
0.7610760927,
-0.0746923238,
0.5767273903,
-0.1750280112,
0.3000033498,
0.494725734,
0.3338291049,
0.3998062611,
-0.3478643894,
0.2502353787,
0.0479199775,
0.3290030062,
-0.6811623573,
-0.7178215981,
0.4158150256,
-0.4747388959,
-0.5625296235,
-0.2690881193,
-0.3226051927,
-0.2900323868,
0.2430307716,
0.1723611504,
0.3725006878,
-0.248017177,
0.4074564874,
0.4628941715,
-0.5517919064,
0.3651049733,
0.3511614203,
-0.4127112329,
-0.2901139557,
0.8715817928,
-0.2374063879,
0.3933202028,
0.266951561,
0.0711655766,
-0.05814768,
-0.7296896577,
-0.3617764711,
0.0214632861,
-1.1896393299,
-0.0230503473,
-0.3181481659,
-0.0610304847,
-0.0422359407,
-0.2602352798,
-0.4272243381,
-0.2991918623,
0.1927731484,
0.2652667463,
0.0390520319,
0.6729895473,
0.5725207329,
-0.235975489,
-0.5804269314,
0.5889968872,
0.6585520506,
0.4264066219,
0.2319124341,
-0.2066084892,
-0.2432533205,
-0.2202299982,
0.0545693785,
-0.5412848592,
-0.0248754285,
-0.2476115525,
0.8726645112,
0.2212362587,
-0.1240525544,
0.6827359796,
-0.2767980695,
1.0082172155,
0.5791593194,
-0.806842804,
0.4445393085,
-0.0400364101,
0.5770163536,
0.3174285889,
-0.0915452987,
-0.1903302372,
-0.2099646628,
-0.6848357916,
-0.6854767799,
0.1228786334,
0.1774581671,
-0.1430997998,
-0.1216189265,
0.2144784629,
-0.1094201505,
0.0215105508,
-0.6170601845,
0.0849512443,
-0.1012313217,
-0.0201481171,
-0.0138218189,
-0.0919692516,
-0.1860185266,
-0.431537956,
0.3688139617,
-0.1173314899,
0.2136288881,
0.2220227718,
-0.1781600714,
0.0490986109,
0.2442569733,
0.2848771513,
0.7539539337,
-0.0527767539,
0.3640663624,
0.3075270355,
-0.3196228445,
-0.1749903411,
-0.1967587322,
0.0313567556,
-0.5348151326,
0.8813133836,
0.8039695621,
0.0460568368,
-1.2443854809,
0.8086298704,
-0.3879668415,
-0.202911824,
-0.4375009835,
0.0743776113,
0.2561385632,
0.3265009522,
0.2706448734,
0.1281587481,
0.1641192138,
-0.7655804157,
0.1188154221,
0.7706651688,
-0.3414227664,
0.1182583645,
0.4818314314,
-0.1590309441,
-0.1743881851,
0.8102039099,
-0.2329003811,
-0.4217945039,
0.9471278191,
0.3424616754,
0.6720299721,
0.1775177717,
0.0378638804,
0.3378317058,
0.4687462747,
-0.1066432297,
0.3591856062,
-0.1170707345,
-0.7793211937,
-0.3074204922,
-0.4973904192,
-0.080674842,
0.011842587,
-0.9156728387,
0.1502249986,
-0.4995296001,
-0.1755408198,
0.3708338737,
-0.2728773057,
-1.1704876423,
0.5855775476,
0.3247973323,
0.9467980862,
-0.3928075731,
0.6930071115,
0.546446979,
-0.3458979428,
-0.5027032495,
-0.3596948683,
-0.3049367964,
-1.2585479021,
1.0947278738,
0.1373467445,
-0.2045967877,
-0.552369535,
-0.8358041048,
-0.664495945,
1.1603560448,
0.2405240089,
-0.4895937443,
0.0443107039,
-0.0970761776,
0.4757818878,
-0.6004761457,
0.0788211748,
0.7338784337,
0.5779078007,
0.1840666234,
-0.9992778897,
0.2049168348,
-0.2368064225,
0.1797428429,
-0.0248157177,
-0.5521791577,
0.875616312,
-0.386888206,
-0.3608867824,
0.3499544263,
0.2910850644,
0.2164866924,
0.1867566705,
0.8625282049,
0.7227061987,
0.7028737664,
-0.1203748882,
1.423197031,
0.2359593958,
0.1893925965,
1.1595486403,
-0.421618402,
1.1721132994,
0.3002721369,
-0.0573803522,
0.4275127053,
0.3844451904,
-0.295627147,
0.5947030187,
0.4958794415,
-0.1404978037,
-0.7290856838,
-0.2082603425,
-0.1269923896,
0.6745915413,
0.4487959146,
-0.3607301712,
0.0169112291,
-0.0564619303,
-0.3332630694,
0.1189038306,
-0.6383382082,
0.7028025389,
-0.0261519887,
-0.9946380854,
0.7904951572,
-0.2823707163,
0.1668340713,
-0.3021811247,
-0.0246945228,
0.3882809281,
0.4739359617,
-0.0864974633,
-1.27475667,
0.0147796134,
-0.0117264055,
0.0623522513,
0.0742402747,
0.8644652963,
-0.0605041273,
-0.5570908785,
0.6724633574,
0.4589807391,
0.2731019855,
0.0275121182,
-0.8886405826,
0.2363179773,
-0.1756603271,
-0.2799062133,
0.16314511,
0.1241647899,
-0.3902072906,
0.8647270203,
0.5103220344,
0.0382277183,
0.1509128958,
0.1345676482,
0.6093841791,
-1.016305089,
-0.2816570997,
-0.7442086935,
0.3763681352,
-0.3318397403,
-0.3337617517,
0.6721485853,
0.6279179454,
0.8318504095,
-0.2145727277,
0.9414807558,
-0.1310599893,
0.2333219349,
-0.7371448278,
0.1243236884,
-0.6625304222,
0.0707965046,
-0.2897578478,
-0.8503289223,
-0.1875101179,
0.5047562718,
-0.3274903595,
0.0358001068,
0.9972870946,
0.5401065946,
-0.0333976187,
-0.0103798155,
0.7297719121,
0.1157009229,
0.112750195,
1.0391997099,
1.3588716984,
-0.275461942,
0.6954020262,
-0.1643390954,
-0.3149578869,
0.0584106594,
-0.9187481999,
-1.1058894396,
-0.6280849576,
-0.3197443783,
-0.4762694538,
-0.0624148771,
0.4266338944,
0.7278045416,
-0.4409494996,
-0.101336062,
0.1696922332,
-0.1200267002,
-0.6038601398,
-0.1860146374,
0.41801548,
0.0967911631,
-0.2913264036,
0.0807589516,
0.4286036193,
-0.0328777619,
-0.5430551767,
-0.1301407367,
0.0424976572,
-0.0621078312,
0.5681928992,
0.1505711526,
-1.2296408415,
-0.3976463377,
-0.0273953229,
-0.1111408696,
-0.0674662814,
0.7928221226,
-0.6665433645,
0.6658201814,
0.3602896333,
0.6847268939,
0.88568151,
-0.2263630629,
0.1299607009,
-0.1459130794,
0.1861076802,
0.2145159245,
0.7740112543,
0.4912171066,
-0.1919018477,
0.4353070855,
0.1828556806,
-0.4694078267,
-0.6545102596,
0.4833962917,
-1.3262659311,
-0.6783386469,
1.0537250042,
-0.3189408779,
-0.5333432555,
-0.0134671479,
-0.1629548967,
-0.2076882869,
-0.070962511,
0.4841796756,
0.8242061734,
0.0197846964,
-0.4484826922,
-0.8260836601,
0.2476911247,
0.1820532978,
-0.9010803103,
0.1545575112,
0.6486400962,
0.2821811438,
0.2421573997,
0.5006027222,
-0.3419436812,
0.6584333777,
0.2576605976,
0.2707186937,
0.0369423851,
-0.0968675986,
-0.0202128254,
0.0865091085,
0.2487650514,
-0.230861187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18397v1
|
Decomposed Prompting: Unveiling Multilingual Linguistic Structure Knowledge in English-Centric Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T15:15:39 | 2024-02-28T15:15:39 |
Ercong Nie, Shuzhou Yuan, Bolei Ma, Helmut Schmid, Michael Färber, Frauke Kreuter, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the predominance of English in their training data, English-centric
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3 and LLaMA display a remarkable ability
to perform multilingual tasks, raising questions about the depth and nature of
their cross-lingual capabilities. This paper introduces the decomposed
prompting approach to probe the linguistic structure understanding of these
LLMs in sequence labeling tasks. Diverging from the single text-to-text prompt,
our method generates for each token of the input sentence an individual prompt
which asks for its linguistic label. We assess our method on the Universal
Dependencies part-of-speech tagging dataset for 38 languages, utilizing both
English-centric and multilingual LLMs. Our findings show that decomposed
prompting surpasses the iterative prompting baseline in efficacy and efficiency
under zero- and few-shot settings. Further analysis reveals the influence of
evaluation methods and the use of instructions in prompts. Our multilingual
investigation shows that English-centric language models perform better on
average than multilingual models. Our study offers insights into the
multilingual transferability of English-centric LLMs, contributing to the
understanding of their multilingual linguistic knowledge.
|
[
-0.2890362144,
-0.6753673553,
0.5161620378,
0.3421965837,
-0.1875507236,
-0.0215231422,
-0.3749503195,
-0.3377218843,
0.0309420228,
0.1512553692,
-0.6809914112,
-0.5800229907,
-0.4255432487,
0.5763422847,
-0.0664074719,
0.9103990197,
0.1132149771,
0.1707054973,
-0.2546875179,
-0.1367515475,
-0.7075323462,
-0.4349849224,
-0.6919041276,
-0.5646185279,
0.787528038,
0.4594489336,
0.3371309042,
0.5748218894,
-0.2504330873,
0.3314533532,
-0.5098267198,
0.0346073546,
-0.2291214615,
0.2905169725,
-0.1784102172,
-0.6656615734,
-0.2069910914,
-0.1611134559,
0.6916075945,
0.9120404124,
0.0392781645,
0.0898931995,
0.2461737245,
0.4126124084,
-0.3659567237,
0.3974099755,
-0.629832387,
-0.0410940126,
-0.0702569187,
-0.2682023942,
-0.7721540928,
0.0887800455,
0.0436991453,
-0.4698134959,
0.1392297745,
-0.1645525694,
0.4826649129,
0.2050739378,
-0.4505468607,
-0.2260401696,
-0.3579390645,
0.6908636093,
-0.4367806613,
0.5322088003,
0.4770345092,
-0.1480676979,
-0.026413355,
-0.4591915905,
-0.3362809718,
-0.2503500581,
-0.1715629399,
-0.0544798225,
-0.1491180658,
-0.0079490617,
0.1561195552,
0.1570550054,
-0.8800828457,
0.4600781798,
-0.4074712098,
-0.1730168909,
0.2877013981,
-0.0251708645,
0.683845818,
-0.2781461775,
-0.3900746107,
0.0089577707,
-0.9624533653,
0.2931596637,
0.2027081102,
0.6923817992,
-0.3330800235,
0.540997088,
-0.0357074514,
0.6673406363,
-0.0656187087,
-0.3144716024,
0.2285294086,
-0.3048940599,
-0.0130738607,
0.333853513,
0.6717050076,
0.2757531703,
0.4258972406,
0.0030087277,
0.001247386,
-0.0190748852,
-0.2482102662,
-0.6363506317,
-0.2512373924,
0.4366936684,
-0.2062440962,
0.1125036627,
-0.3584475815,
-0.4545207918,
-0.2904672027,
-0.2118895799,
0.3379504383,
-0.3981601,
-0.2666314244,
0.2240842283,
0.0391018912,
0.3534170985,
0.1740249097,
-0.9998879433,
-0.3741617799,
0.7513447404,
0.6511104703,
-0.0990883783,
-0.7875240445,
-0.5652931333,
0.1373753548,
-0.1417959183,
0.8990155458,
-0.6286679506,
-0.5036277771,
0.0891149864,
0.2875448763,
-0.1682799459,
-0.3277118206,
0.3151551485,
-0.4744077921,
0.4621483386,
-0.4691013992,
-0.3883084059,
-0.3206844926,
0.6682649255,
-0.7436856627,
1.0203033686,
-0.2945483625,
-0.6554912925,
0.268014282,
-0.5100302696,
-0.565679729,
0.294657588,
-0.1425905973,
0.1695990413,
-0.0292252414,
0.6849611402,
0.6171745658,
-0.1858996153,
0.3382415175,
0.0889696479,
-0.2156032026,
0.074136354,
-0.567945838,
0.9445556998,
-0.0283765905,
-0.1452150047,
0.2417875379,
-0.8040297031,
-0.0664888918,
0.226961121,
-0.6302479506,
-0.3172089159,
-0.1607443839,
-0.4506366551,
-0.0618664473,
0.1552662849,
-0.3155275285,
0.3871877193,
-0.5093082786,
0.4466346204,
0.6387241483,
0.0808063,
0.5427954197,
0.0992809013,
0.782877028,
-0.0059015248,
-0.1259421408,
-1.0933070183,
-0.6325669885,
-0.4662870169,
-0.4114796519,
0.1028382182,
0.7534814477,
-0.8593344092,
0.0237971768,
-0.1804117262,
-0.14996773,
-0.537091434,
-0.0089224856,
0.5325139165,
0.6888512373,
0.4017613232,
0.2944956422,
-0.3578608036,
-0.7986242771,
-0.204669252,
-0.4072359204,
-0.0311757382,
-0.2731960416,
0.2486733198,
-0.1466191113,
0.4291378558,
-0.2411758006,
0.1418099105,
-0.5276156664,
0.2168293148,
0.291693747,
0.1196439713,
0.2589948475,
-0.5454967022,
-0.3376330733,
0.0665771887,
-0.3666019142,
-0.3032388091,
0.0407855473,
0.1624552161,
0.3052526414,
0.4654275477,
-0.5763939619,
0.0600058548,
0.6313639283,
-0.2193416953,
0.7551439404,
-0.1368281543,
0.2243415117,
-1.2116578817,
0.1306670904,
-0.1660847664,
-0.0292767845,
-0.7509890795,
0.041228842,
0.1954231262,
-0.1317351013,
-0.6112921238,
0.7037162781,
-0.8580031395,
-0.0145878103,
-0.0700682551,
0.0848773196,
0.3714519739,
0.4488087296,
0.0419500992,
0.8160216808,
0.6449180245,
-0.7278616428,
0.0991394147,
0.3550480604,
-0.3445067108,
0.5265236497,
-0.7431493402,
0.139417395,
-0.4702551663,
0.212596789,
-1.3381285667,
-0.2783571184,
0.1169451401,
-0.4013003111,
0.4304128289,
-0.4907575846,
-0.3747574091,
-0.1582749039,
-0.398111254,
0.6811437607,
0.2391826808,
-0.7141430974,
0.334161967,
0.1125779375,
-0.4775030911,
-0.7428718209,
-0.7138414979,
0.0430768616,
-0.2922236919,
-0.4892770946,
0.303760618,
-0.1951053441,
-0.2085166723,
-0.2952056229,
0.1532230228,
0.1107680202,
0.082171239,
0.1250406206,
0.2993297577,
-0.2943127453,
0.1613169312,
0.0996065363,
-0.2211668491,
0.295237869,
-0.0913534015,
0.7048115134,
0.0310009308,
-0.3247652948,
-0.3234431744,
0.5534118414,
0.4119695425,
-0.5488874912,
0.6252732277,
0.4500384331,
-0.1951985508,
-0.2848178446,
-0.3386084437,
-0.1414945871,
-0.4704539776,
0.2875202894,
-0.673543334,
-1.0429245234,
0.6721276641,
0.1653791815,
0.1426540017,
0.2692260444,
0.733319819,
0.222240597,
1.1033155918,
0.5703024864,
-0.0728473961,
0.2758615315,
-0.0313319005,
0.0935363173,
-0.4868630767,
-0.5612385273,
-0.6903297901,
-0.1355281025,
-0.2776614428,
-0.377779156,
0.4150655568,
0.1476537436,
-0.0749965161,
0.0881982297,
-0.5568326712,
0.8134875894,
0.3573311567,
-0.2279328555,
0.3812258542,
0.0706856325,
-0.3101082742,
0.0943995342,
-0.6646260619,
-0.3307566345,
0.5094141364,
0.3156415224,
0.6231820583,
0.0052656461,
0.5700650215,
-0.0876834914,
-0.0021520306,
-1.1660445929,
0.5047829151,
0.1452821344,
-0.378770411,
-0.11141105,
-0.239258036,
-1.3541636467,
0.3275068998,
0.2522596419,
-0.8226288557,
0.0745823979,
0.0879032239,
-0.214292258,
0.0100751081,
-0.819018662,
0.6567012072,
-0.1422959268,
0.0563120171,
0.1334461421,
-0.654995203,
0.3370150924,
0.2118705213,
0.3863176703,
-0.1850140989,
-0.1550234705,
0.6138045192,
-0.1036714464,
1.0287362337,
-0.1165534928,
-0.8080260158,
0.1806401014,
0.323829025,
0.4872905314,
0.0725266263,
-0.0418947674,
0.135415405,
-0.0138160484,
-0.2287520021,
-0.5208328366,
0.7417369485,
-0.4745157659,
-0.5754763484,
-0.0545631349,
-0.5877342224,
-0.3389000893,
0.2270334065,
0.5180924535,
0.6392825842,
0.1001515985,
-0.2769733369,
0.6856455803,
-0.3839766085,
0.6863604784,
0.60268116,
-0.3019306064,
-0.4771496952,
0.5588895679,
-0.0235625114,
0.089334175,
0.6017416716,
0.2626005411,
-0.6451306939,
-0.4030983746,
-0.6009118557,
0.5270527005,
-1.0088875294,
-0.1740401387,
-0.6362187266,
0.2602652609,
-0.4424471855,
-0.137119621,
-0.2112235278,
-0.2843561769,
-0.2655308247,
-0.3941198587,
0.2516156435,
0.9301373959,
0.1073566526,
0.1162331998,
-1.0327297449,
0.0678399801,
0.2241088599,
0.1365411878,
0.0851739421,
-0.5167779922,
-0.1789500713,
-0.0698536709,
0.2215543091,
-1.2224087715,
0.2325943708,
0.2509777546,
0.6175642014,
0.1576315314,
-0.0288925096,
0.63525635,
-0.7332490683,
1.1487873793,
0.039072264,
-0.949598968,
0.6029753089,
-0.389228642,
0.7882086635,
0.3584309518,
0.6923149824,
-0.5911402106,
-0.1248920634,
-0.1609714031,
-1.1073858738,
0.7913772464,
-0.4887210727,
0.1732481271,
-0.2962292731,
0.2631645501,
0.2489004135,
-0.0744778812,
-0.8204521537,
-0.2782593966,
0.1753353477,
-0.0436097533,
-0.1069496423,
-0.5772138238,
-0.1616072804,
-0.0954309329,
0.5085117817,
-0.3094130158,
0.070341669,
0.2267974168,
-0.3703617454,
0.3009056151,
0.6891956329,
0.7740271091,
0.7571356297,
0.2987930179,
0.5523446798,
0.1537008286,
-0.2680658996,
0.473583132,
0.0375208817,
0.014877121,
0.0121891908,
0.5991435051,
0.7712812424,
0.2088862807,
-0.5145207047,
0.1524200439,
0.0450298227,
-0.1297917813,
0.258430481,
-0.370449543,
0.1834606677,
0.1903497726,
0.3415138125,
-0.5908234119,
0.0735954717,
-0.4680675864,
0.0829772428,
0.2353471965,
-0.1054516286,
-0.7380512357,
0.4482367337,
0.1266518682,
-0.17217049,
0.4078240395,
-0.2344625443,
-0.7513383031,
0.3018736541,
0.8102351427,
0.829230547,
-0.6360154748,
0.3589371741,
0.5105759501,
0.4520964921,
-0.1303509474,
0.4397328198,
-0.2537200451,
-0.6674863696,
-1.0011432171,
-0.3572463095,
-0.2813943028,
0.2870918214,
-0.7079401016,
0.0990240797,
-0.1575565934,
0.2038273513,
0.024249116,
-0.3219029605,
-0.4249546528,
-0.041464828,
0.4909480214,
0.7493317127,
-0.8510893583,
0.6071492434,
1.1367659569,
-0.098426722,
-1.2748315334,
-0.1769863814,
0.2550435066,
-1.0061935186,
0.7294247746,
0.55755651,
-0.2768989205,
0.1317133307,
-0.4479490519,
-0.6951898932,
0.6950734854,
0.6109589338,
-0.2443050742,
0.11455369,
0.1847459227,
0.3515605927,
-0.1436924934,
0.3072229326,
0.534412086,
0.5478479862,
0.1519644558,
-0.9746066928,
0.2083781511,
-0.4146736264,
-0.0953886136,
0.2659724951,
-0.2955967188,
0.7817783952,
-0.3573032916,
-0.4925475419,
-0.1848309338,
0.4645861387,
0.3713539839,
0.1220346466,
0.4407027066,
0.3033404052,
0.9408488274,
0.0404712372,
0.8522964716,
-0.2712235749,
0.0493941754,
1.0390536785,
-0.3421097994,
0.8692356348,
0.4374714196,
-0.1306810528,
0.528100431,
0.6593081355,
0.2429168075,
0.1598058343,
-0.0456254631,
-0.3701800406,
-0.0085951546,
-0.3050988019,
-0.4273379147,
0.5301410556,
0.4051755965,
-0.098958157,
-0.4542155862,
0.27971071,
0.5150869489,
-0.205755055,
-0.4365837574,
0.902969718,
0.0024945401,
-1.0065015554,
1.0329458714,
-0.063109979,
0.6337157488,
-0.7655305862,
-0.0636918545,
-0.4676819444,
-0.2257426232,
-0.3163239956,
-1.0205975771,
0.0701753944,
0.1081453413,
-0.3686856925,
-0.457187742,
0.5019350648,
-0.818197608,
-0.0912777707,
0.2550810575,
0.5542926788,
0.3108050227,
-0.1648400575,
-0.6171037555,
0.1970006078,
0.2105230689,
-0.3571581841,
0.1900000721,
0.5675623417,
-0.071194075,
0.6057235003,
0.5031294823,
-0.1133898869,
-0.0117675308,
0.4318853319,
0.6938068867,
-0.6545289755,
-0.5400826931,
-1.1110970974,
0.8886713386,
0.4995769858,
-0.079511933,
1.0163289309,
0.4013629556,
0.8488692045,
-0.089173615,
0.5563412309,
0.1628666222,
0.2264213115,
-0.7370006442,
0.4880018532,
-0.5023775697,
0.4174151123,
0.0054955701,
-0.8876345754,
-0.3796659708,
0.1621525437,
-0.1210638732,
-0.0201627742,
0.7069888115,
0.9247763157,
0.3068423867,
-0.0018939041,
0.3408062756,
0.1011053622,
0.3245975375,
0.4493886828,
0.9375125766,
-0.0145316347,
0.6261314154,
-0.1013140082,
-0.1432862729,
0.118058145,
-0.9256328344,
-0.9625008106,
-0.675889194,
-0.366633147,
-0.2304311544,
-0.3224435747,
0.9832648039,
0.3300184906,
-0.6359207034,
-0.1364857405,
0.338881731,
0.1999156773,
-0.0500658639,
-0.220650509,
0.3502885699,
-0.5806729794,
-0.8307301402,
0.9684218764,
0.3236462474,
0.1443186849,
-0.2679885924,
0.1878801882,
-0.13256073,
-0.2095442712,
0.860869348,
0.3214661479,
-0.8109583259,
-0.0685195923,
0.1028263867,
0.1525941789,
0.0649694055,
0.7939414978,
-0.774936974,
0.4197976589,
0.7370547652,
0.5765778422,
0.0167293251,
-0.0111971069,
0.6180589199,
-1.1962326765,
0.2887260318,
-0.0032383255,
0.393206358,
0.5172740817,
-0.3681498766,
0.285803169,
-0.0081674689,
-0.5306861997,
-0.8772070408,
0.3566455543,
-0.7807020545,
-0.4331489205,
1.4004938602,
-0.2668782771,
-0.323587805,
-0.1219120473,
-0.4085663259,
0.0901062489,
-0.2693764567,
0.1939694434,
0.677976191,
0.0310475975,
-0.5235157013,
-0.1589407772,
0.4235818684,
0.581404686,
-0.6742379069,
0.2375646383,
0.5689492226,
0.3092557788,
0.1766685396,
0.6090667248,
-0.0547695421,
0.0620473884,
-0.1989246607,
0.1005399078,
-0.202188313,
-0.47673437,
-0.9107688069,
0.175238505,
0.1874078661,
-0.1260850728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18385v1
|
The First Place Solution of WSDM Cup 2024: Leveraging Large Language Models for Conversational Multi-Doc QA
| 2024-02-28T15:05:43 | 2024-02-28T15:05:43 |
Yiming Li, Zhao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Conversational multi-doc question answering aims to answer specific questions
based on the retrieved documents as well as the contextual conversations. In
this paper, we introduce our winning approach for the "Conversational Multi-Doc
QA" challenge in WSDM Cup 2024, which exploits the superior natural language
understanding and generation capability of Large Language Models (LLMs). We
first adapt LLMs to the task, then devise a hybrid training strategy to make
the most of in-domain unlabeled data. Moreover, an advanced text embedding
model is adopted to filter out potentially irrelevant documents and several
approaches are designed and compared for the model ensemble. Equipped with all
these techniques, our solution finally ranked 1st place in WSDM Cup 2024,
surpassing its rivals to a large extent. The source codes have been released at
https://github.com/zhangzhao219/WSDM-Cup-2024.
|
[
-0.5635018349,
-0.7229294777,
0.9699943662,
-0.1300680488,
-0.386508882,
0.5925704837,
-0.0469389744,
-0.4295238256,
0.0087473914,
0.5980517268,
-0.7759832144,
-0.6569789648,
-0.6574528813,
0.2409759164,
-0.1739021242,
0.7194536924,
-0.1114080101,
0.2517909706,
-0.8170938492,
-0.1880058944,
-0.2616509497,
-0.5812216401,
-0.5831742883,
-0.2819039822,
0.3390731215,
0.3640962839,
0.3003651798,
0.2297914475,
0.547968924,
0.4299987853,
-0.1605802327,
0.6434108615,
-0.428493917,
0.1066026837,
-0.0186664835,
-0.5053294301,
-0.3515022993,
0.1391188353,
0.5128863454,
0.591575563,
-0.3183165193,
-0.0271305498,
-0.1001480296,
0.0555323586,
-0.0569216125,
0.2668752968,
-0.9690790176,
-0.0505982824,
0.1548027247,
-0.5989108086,
-0.5413527489,
-0.2124522924,
0.0586843491,
-0.7006008029,
0.3056795895,
0.0816929936,
1.0043632984,
0.1371362656,
-0.6148227453,
-0.3296509385,
-0.6696239114,
0.7047402263,
-0.8528563976,
0.1453613639,
0.1403234452,
0.3863408267,
-0.2004051656,
-0.5753602386,
-0.8123475313,
0.1939474046,
0.2424822748,
0.452462554,
0.181856975,
0.1498944014,
0.0006565224,
-0.0014504276,
-0.6007783413,
0.2665587366,
-0.3466432989,
-0.0916188508,
0.7083209157,
0.293476373,
0.0329551697,
0.2849341035,
-0.4230671823,
-0.0287069995,
-0.2599034011,
0.0830789879,
0.0287373122,
0.1258783489,
-0.0175684392,
0.5410404801,
-0.165931344,
0.5001365542,
0.0872984529,
-0.4870018363,
0.2347625047,
-0.4992874861,
-0.0807189271,
-0.0966541097,
0.7166051269,
0.3202175498,
0.1187642366,
-0.2867330611,
-0.0814051703,
-0.0454468243,
0.0878472179,
-0.6804248691,
0.0894861743,
0.6515579224,
-0.117724888,
-0.4004141986,
-0.0489095077,
-0.7909623384,
-0.3875823617,
-0.2258038223,
0.1396543384,
-0.2435580641,
-0.2393175513,
0.0939086378,
-0.2633874416,
0.6616549492,
0.4221364856,
-0.6765122414,
0.0529640019,
0.8125009537,
0.7036087513,
-0.1695614904,
-0.3350995779,
-0.6518468857,
0.3463817239,
-0.421153754,
1.0512850285,
-0.6259131432,
-0.5305861831,
0.1968851984,
-0.0038184556,
-0.3456852734,
-0.464345336,
0.6654859781,
-0.7292548418,
0.3392344117,
-0.1163196191,
-0.7628965974,
0.0968121439,
0.5243885517,
-0.3951479793,
0.8724220991,
0.0018681065,
-0.7399868965,
0.0684312657,
-0.5634695888,
-0.1614292264,
0.3488746285,
-0.0226456486,
-0.4656590521,
-0.1286521256,
0.1991304904,
0.4192485213,
-0.224822998,
0.342045337,
-0.6315094233,
-0.2783233523,
0.291395545,
-0.1483566314,
0.5628489256,
0.0651145726,
0.1779479831,
0.2966499627,
-0.7589722276,
0.2169217616,
0.6211596131,
-0.395575583,
-0.0537349023,
-0.2618242204,
-0.1351630837,
0.5484654903,
0.1236515567,
-0.7545230985,
0.1598537117,
-0.2096152008,
0.6448210478,
0.7349309921,
0.2671148479,
0.5303478837,
-0.4046238959,
0.7601265907,
0.0528663881,
0.1614294797,
-0.1178587899,
-0.5762808919,
-0.4385206699,
-0.3602644503,
0.2144087851,
0.5876715779,
-1.0328053236,
0.2631678581,
-0.2004838437,
-0.7818734646,
-0.5674705505,
0.0305717606,
0.1847665608,
0.5277038813,
0.0780700669,
0.0717048571,
-0.4139531255,
-0.5692622662,
0.2453891784,
-0.3157687783,
0.2305715978,
0.3498975933,
0.5084788203,
-0.1893434525,
0.8820848465,
-0.7002220154,
-0.3394357264,
-0.4975793958,
0.032977283,
0.0694432557,
0.3092610538,
0.3326931596,
-0.9544757009,
-0.3188334107,
-0.2476858944,
-0.8428047895,
0.0413079076,
0.1169965118,
-0.218029961,
0.2274245471,
0.6612745523,
-0.8908845186,
-0.232454583,
0.6747155786,
-0.2151954323,
0.7241256833,
-0.4664669037,
0.2541418672,
-1.147682786,
-0.1119399145,
-0.018242402,
-0.1721032858,
-0.671448648,
0.2736415863,
-0.0068384684,
-0.4919323921,
-0.4987675548,
0.5288502574,
-0.3055268824,
0.209798947,
-0.1469733268,
0.5445734859,
0.2694214582,
0.7458325028,
0.2530412972,
0.6394481063,
0.3007761836,
-0.4768491983,
0.4507393241,
0.5899215937,
-0.1935387701,
0.5389863849,
-0.5948582888,
0.2965395749,
-0.3057346642,
0.5867895484,
-1.2495301962,
0.0289663319,
-0.1143013313,
-0.5755568147,
0.3379909098,
-0.0787369832,
-0.5089302659,
-0.7018108964,
-0.2610863447,
0.1540537626,
0.2378938794,
-0.4423449636,
0.5611518621,
0.6421225667,
-0.3438153267,
-0.1231003478,
-0.1896056831,
0.2334863544,
-0.3983049989,
-0.795638144,
0.4125082791,
-0.5534744859,
-0.0519411452,
-0.3918969035,
0.0407745913,
-0.2513948679,
0.2347291559,
-0.2344984114,
0.4528421164,
-0.2082913518,
-0.0151155833,
-0.0696573108,
-0.3125889599,
0.0600920245,
-0.3695746362,
0.7163683176,
0.0069208872,
-0.2940219045,
-0.2430328727,
0.6401239634,
0.6442234516,
-0.639734149,
0.7318386436,
0.6071500778,
-0.3055300713,
-0.2224112451,
-0.4856263697,
-0.1718202084,
-0.4665609896,
0.6275660396,
-0.5885589719,
-0.9251184464,
0.3686394095,
-0.2663524151,
0.258708477,
0.1581661254,
0.4916801453,
-0.4405650198,
1.3757494688,
0.5420888662,
-0.0024023945,
0.1280955523,
-0.1820605993,
0.3332386911,
-0.7791827321,
-0.5133518577,
-0.8160511851,
0.2291460931,
-0.4214443266,
-0.4832767844,
0.5754708052,
0.0535445213,
0.0501648746,
0.1104830205,
-0.3846687675,
0.2709037662,
0.439954102,
0.0262326673,
0.4538581073,
-0.4847743213,
-0.2872066796,
0.0481657125,
-0.8223869801,
-0.5477829576,
0.8422708511,
0.3086128235,
0.3040348887,
0.1422632784,
0.8209635019,
0.040442545,
-0.0036708945,
-0.5960544944,
0.6301572919,
0.1509326547,
-0.243806392,
-0.6157266498,
-0.3770599365,
-0.9002352357,
0.7602187395,
-0.2952442467,
-0.4355456233,
-0.2853056192,
-0.292067796,
-0.2108419836,
0.2177866399,
-0.5905189514,
0.8578267694,
-0.0765584931,
-0.118844986,
0.1776594967,
-0.4448032379,
0.4380995333,
-0.1025529653,
0.612883985,
-0.1308796108,
-0.047914315,
0.7260249853,
-0.3935391903,
0.4820753634,
-0.2485805899,
-0.3577544391,
0.226309523,
-0.1593022794,
0.79480654,
0.1727325022,
-0.0543945804,
-0.2209368199,
0.4315832555,
-0.613571167,
-0.4984621108,
0.5149769783,
-0.6165670753,
-0.863902986,
-0.5647279024,
-0.4745802581,
-0.6998167634,
0.2038308978,
0.1317301542,
0.5182284117,
-0.4385855496,
-0.1778007001,
1.0722374916,
-0.2331408709,
0.5172829628,
0.7505362034,
-0.0017029416,
-0.2083006203,
0.8470370173,
-0.2220982313,
0.3971476555,
0.4751779139,
0.1978258342,
-0.6276130676,
-1.0467580557,
-0.727796793,
0.4377704561,
-0.7584702373,
-0.1298335195,
-1.0113589764,
-0.3029149771,
-0.7043848634,
-0.1278851479,
-0.2497559339,
0.0294246059,
-0.066621922,
-0.2193560451,
-0.0058396091,
0.5223270655,
0.318303287,
0.0227996875,
-0.9480911493,
0.1591932774,
0.3708795011,
0.0506844223,
-0.1461236477,
-0.4627740979,
0.0221712422,
-0.0879798532,
-0.2114768922,
-0.6950750351,
0.4249880016,
0.0746412501,
0.864504993,
0.2300564498,
0.1877875477,
0.5038574934,
-0.5293979049,
0.8253648877,
0.2139957249,
-0.6253610849,
0.3505945504,
-0.5483124256,
0.4706810713,
0.694691062,
0.223433733,
-0.677385807,
-0.7188187838,
-0.6134566069,
-0.7099015117,
0.6791309118,
-0.0969301388,
0.1140842587,
0.0608811639,
0.0234991051,
-0.017922584,
0.3022888303,
-0.39777565,
-0.0695974678,
0.1076162606,
-0.2668046355,
-0.2121954709,
-0.1481475085,
-0.1151324362,
0.0016049867,
0.9150448442,
-0.393265754,
0.2326176316,
0.0958492458,
-0.1194755211,
0.2560478449,
0.2461938411,
0.6868386269,
0.7511432767,
-0.2200776935,
-0.0137309097,
0.285064131,
-0.2052806467,
0.1308037043,
0.1206505448,
-0.1003758311,
0.026827544,
0.4276377857,
0.4877147973,
0.3182783425,
-0.8752014041,
0.5796723962,
-0.2505978644,
-0.4295414388,
-0.3927226365,
-0.1777795255,
0.4334254861,
0.1264051497,
0.4393368661,
-0.3070454001,
-0.0377612449,
-0.5850551724,
0.2142568529,
0.6137270331,
-0.4215831161,
0.0363686569,
0.6830396652,
0.3313888609,
-0.1385874003,
0.1821860522,
-0.4800807834,
-1.027982831,
0.7834275961,
0.7367233038,
0.2280412018,
-0.0670579672,
0.7184281349,
0.3099460006,
-0.0126757687,
0.1200327426,
0.1825130582,
0.1231404319,
-0.8610892296,
-0.1939954609,
-0.5849695206,
-0.7221306562,
0.0668745413,
-0.3447293937,
0.2501106858,
-0.2010366619,
0.3202008605,
0.1785315126,
0.2898645997,
-0.6973602176,
0.1374842376,
0.1622373015,
0.9273158908,
-0.6072823405,
0.93468678,
0.6248871088,
-0.381526351,
-0.5582124591,
-0.3003766537,
0.0067388425,
-0.8043660522,
-0.0456740968,
-0.0744529516,
-0.0096736839,
0.2633226514,
-0.552826345,
-0.7811342478,
1.2364332676,
0.0611000508,
-0.3362986147,
-0.1969032288,
0.2079551369,
0.2779819071,
-0.3899574876,
0.4178121388,
0.5584425926,
0.3959891498,
0.5831333399,
-0.8008059263,
-0.1465221643,
-0.19160375,
-0.2036166638,
-0.0144061893,
-0.8824593425,
0.4791172147,
-0.382430315,
-0.153559342,
0.3126236796,
0.6830567718,
0.6135262251,
0.4287126064,
0.5116748214,
0.4341701269,
1.1318057775,
-0.1733125299,
0.9687492251,
0.0012269665,
0.3204523921,
1.0836185217,
-0.719892025,
0.6141366363,
0.3243586123,
-0.2451692224,
0.1068297625,
0.7879477143,
0.0673712268,
0.6219712496,
0.2302424014,
-0.3003901541,
-0.4957692921,
-0.213936165,
-0.381760031,
0.720381856,
0.0545768477,
0.2013838291,
-0.2514915168,
0.1905010939,
0.1069606096,
0.29867962,
-0.1724635363,
1.1922566891,
0.1052837968,
-0.8543180823,
0.3965597749,
0.3189593852,
0.8088959455,
-0.8261122108,
0.0783454254,
-0.2742831707,
0.0940882489,
0.0671700686,
-0.7135537863,
0.0536333621,
-0.2354538441,
-0.1347780526,
-0.1224409416,
0.531490922,
-0.764421165,
-0.5107916594,
0.3092926443,
0.6476067901,
0.0218492784,
-0.1827622205,
-0.5916394591,
-0.0309741441,
-0.2095875144,
0.1951575726,
0.5782952905,
0.5611314774,
-0.0110555775,
0.6785219908,
0.7800880671,
-0.0580655001,
-0.0029753011,
0.301191926,
0.6946570873,
-0.3513008356,
-0.7418506742,
-0.4338898659,
0.1220590249,
-0.2746838927,
-0.3588784635,
0.516787529,
0.6876488924,
0.6601499319,
0.0218367539,
0.8395587802,
0.2807377279,
0.5220547318,
-0.4625144899,
0.6147695184,
-0.4515441954,
-0.0234842207,
-0.3703971207,
-0.5355513096,
0.0847959295,
0.1514724046,
0.1356876343,
-0.1728483737,
0.7601761818,
0.6526548862,
0.2276455313,
0.3574475646,
0.5120235682,
0.0010066704,
0.6491627097,
0.9882875085,
0.7447275519,
-0.3473365307,
0.883009851,
-0.1259771138,
-0.3739778697,
-0.0479459316,
-0.6945653558,
-0.795339644,
-0.9892213941,
-0.4208570719,
-0.4633978307,
-0.1745258272,
0.7920439243,
0.7234943509,
-0.7344546318,
0.1757509857,
0.283567518,
0.2827722132,
-0.2184392363,
-0.1842338592,
0.2569364607,
-0.4006444514,
-1.0403577089,
0.5155702233,
0.0684332177,
0.0207794867,
-0.1418292671,
-0.2869328856,
-0.5020994544,
0.3671723008,
0.7707810998,
-0.0423670188,
-0.4135324359,
-0.2187219113,
0.093991138,
-0.2536792755,
0.0746178627,
0.7029905915,
-0.4915964603,
0.1778667271,
0.3428560495,
0.8595967889,
0.6809973717,
0.0084932894,
0.4420224726,
-0.4190451801,
0.0130538549,
0.3183724284,
0.3786675632,
0.2039124817,
-0.3102519214,
0.4659667015,
0.4102005661,
-0.3699252605,
-0.8056619763,
-0.0006737167,
-1.3166640997,
-0.4937423766,
1.2412242889,
-0.126763016,
-0.0798741058,
-0.5551792979,
-0.2858259678,
0.2381161451,
-0.2988446057,
0.8982763886,
0.9632692933,
0.0915690884,
-0.2071313709,
-0.4869630635,
0.3456593454,
0.1613459885,
-1.2587954998,
-0.089320533,
0.2318010181,
0.2328430116,
-0.0319535546,
0.973015368,
-0.3567101359,
0.1373823881,
-0.1575728953,
-0.2532346249,
-0.3383517265,
-0.1631627232,
-0.0814914703,
0.4991454482,
0.0053701703,
-0.243663162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18376v1
|
Tokenization Is More Than Compression
| 2024-02-28T14:52:15 | 2024-02-28T14:52:15 |
Craig W. Schmidt, Varshini Reddy, Haoran Zhang, Alec Alameddine, Omri Uzan, Yuval Pinter, Chris Tanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Tokenization is a foundational step in Natural Language Processing (NLP)
tasks, bridging raw text and language models. Existing tokenization approaches
like Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) originate from the field of data compression, and
it has been suggested that the effectiveness of BPE stems from its ability to
condense text into a relatively small number of tokens. We test the hypothesis
that fewer tokens lead to better downstream performance by introducing
PathPiece, a new tokenizer that segments a document's text into the minimum
number of tokens for a given vocabulary. Through extensive experimentation we
find this hypothesis not to be the case, casting doubt on the understanding of
the reasons for effective tokenization. To examine which other factors play a
role, we evaluate design decisions across all three phases of tokenization:
pre-tokenization, vocabulary construction, and segmentation, offering new
insights into the design of effective tokenizers. Specifically, we illustrate
the importance of pre-tokenization and the benefits of using BPE to initialize
vocabulary construction. We train 64 language models with varying tokenization,
ranging in size from 350M to 2.4B parameters, all of which are made publicly
available.
|
[
-0.5303148031,
-0.4255093634,
0.1668713987,
0.2618366182,
-0.8014239669,
-0.0254573505,
-0.065598689,
-0.5721157193,
0.256149292,
0.2905311286,
-0.0740637034,
-0.3319385946,
-0.7328568101,
0.2085613608,
-0.419362694,
1.111905694,
0.2094921768,
0.1298639029,
0.02662329,
0.1287503839,
-0.8750978708,
-0.7076770663,
-0.9122954011,
-0.2222242951,
0.5903362632,
-0.0952483714,
0.6138890386,
1.0038738251,
0.6037871242,
0.2169157267,
-0.3171271086,
-0.1454101503,
-0.2168046981,
0.0242870003,
-0.0633813366,
-0.5501713753,
-0.1541881859,
0.2096661627,
0.6226017475,
1.0660642385,
0.2090629041,
0.2736596763,
0.0234735217,
0.632026732,
-0.4756552875,
-0.0918480009,
-0.5414920449,
-0.0069538248,
-0.5466469526,
-0.1506355256,
-0.6163085699,
-0.0291874539,
0.0262427088,
-0.3578938544,
0.1983933151,
0.3523156643,
0.8856737018,
0.2380665094,
-0.3412390351,
-0.3166890442,
-0.5836562514,
0.4679765403,
-0.6566764116,
0.6102692485,
0.2824839652,
-0.1565789133,
-0.1579244584,
-0.8974401355,
-0.463327229,
0.3259906769,
-0.248307988,
-0.2658473253,
-0.1264870614,
0.4499304891,
0.1562006027,
0.44904387,
-0.4194606543,
0.2612726688,
-0.6292244196,
-0.4588643312,
0.147273764,
-0.0864935666,
0.4372485578,
-0.6851693392,
-0.5256275535,
-0.0361148007,
-0.5291395187,
0.1174270958,
0.3773628473,
0.5819101334,
0.2656284571,
0.5699453354,
0.0907998011,
0.8472884297,
0.0154795395,
-0.0497252382,
-0.0820012465,
-0.743440032,
-0.3089469373,
0.2460581809,
0.5594282746,
0.236992836,
-0.0994696319,
-0.6007528305,
-0.2211600989,
0.2637030184,
0.5458753109,
-1.1481127739,
-0.0076896972,
0.578967452,
-0.7370226383,
-0.3951300979,
0.1853113621,
-0.3492297232,
-0.3007903397,
-0.3332411349,
0.4075452089,
-0.6022728086,
0.0195064396,
0.412055105,
-0.6332094669,
0.4152657092,
-0.0737690553,
-1.1332660913,
0.4831038713,
1.1323541403,
1.2929558754,
-0.3988351226,
-0.1956651509,
-0.6988016963,
-0.0260604918,
-0.4724560976,
0.9357591867,
-0.511528492,
-0.4930693805,
-0.1745355278,
-0.187841028,
-0.0172065552,
-0.4102559984,
0.7634996772,
-0.5989515781,
0.0855998695,
-0.2866652906,
-0.7739692926,
0.0451408401,
0.0183211099,
-0.7023442984,
0.9089995027,
-0.1163101047,
-0.8905969262,
1.0370428562,
-0.8570013046,
-0.6178644896,
0.3465870917,
0.0053078528,
0.0184598174,
0.5896049738,
0.1883150339,
0.4530233145,
0.0109688574,
0.0237119347,
0.2889989614,
-0.7166054845,
-0.1049153656,
-0.217678085,
0.5118119121,
0.0387912579,
-0.2432875633,
0.0651863813,
-0.5690405965,
-0.1271679252,
-0.2346967757,
-0.6822887659,
-0.3728582859,
0.0923433974,
0.1314338893,
0.1351076216,
0.0855283886,
-0.6199144125,
0.1362213939,
-1.0321494341,
0.4960492849,
0.8519005179,
0.0433963761,
0.7063570023,
-0.2796714008,
0.3273184001,
0.1196975112,
0.2384374887,
-0.2380738854,
-0.5011107922,
-0.8559754491,
-0.2758936286,
0.8127764463,
0.037900079,
-0.4538086951,
0.3544559777,
-0.4743001759,
-0.2520408928,
-0.4437174499,
-0.0808518529,
0.1203815714,
0.1874542087,
0.1878121048,
-0.6760480404,
-0.7200878263,
-0.6771093011,
-0.3200894892,
-0.2954800129,
-0.1466685683,
-0.092075862,
0.4344073832,
0.0844731405,
1.1910098791,
-0.1402914077,
-0.2128532827,
-0.2572613955,
0.3375806212,
0.3332358301,
0.6683245301,
0.4780050218,
-0.7036504745,
-0.2792872787,
-0.2748022377,
-0.0725525916,
0.0808186606,
-0.0979481414,
-0.3265063167,
0.1293705553,
0.4312475026,
-0.5434246659,
0.4698459804,
0.543340385,
-0.4543893635,
0.3812911212,
-0.0404614322,
-0.1662327051,
-1.0936120749,
0.2112465948,
-0.4168640375,
-0.0636652634,
-0.9883219004,
0.0712765232,
-0.1888324618,
-0.2931703925,
-0.4878771305,
0.5456236601,
-0.4501193464,
-0.0823876783,
-0.5171076059,
0.1857522875,
0.1063762009,
0.4676683247,
0.0657950789,
0.7881121635,
0.2727158368,
-0.7434438467,
-0.0638422444,
0.2946870029,
-0.3100907207,
0.4519061744,
-0.8983766437,
0.4572971463,
-0.3914267123,
0.2827708423,
-0.8221135139,
-0.0866742581,
0.1093169078,
-0.4761156738,
0.2088514268,
-0.4423305988,
-0.5792905688,
-0.2535195053,
-0.4956654012,
0.4134692848,
0.3821374774,
-0.4491841197,
0.5251665115,
0.365652591,
0.1768816113,
-0.3510134816,
-0.7101337314,
0.4128386676,
-0.2338088751,
-0.7349157333,
0.7415530682,
-0.1588512659,
0.0328598022,
-0.1055609211,
-0.3476896286,
-0.0253702272,
0.18370381,
0.3014492989,
0.2226160318,
-0.0077128001,
0.461191535,
-0.1759569049,
-0.2939894199,
0.0170173943,
-0.8330845237,
1.0606482029,
0.1999954879,
-0.1714003682,
-0.2100364268,
0.2157186717,
0.1482406259,
-0.3506476581,
0.9248121977,
0.7868890762,
-0.4864680469,
-0.0457404405,
-0.4643399119,
-0.188210994,
-0.4770601988,
0.0974097028,
-0.4934884906,
-0.9063538313,
0.3559026718,
-0.0565414429,
0.2681970894,
0.2431605011,
0.1958357096,
0.2144735307,
0.7809922099,
0.6154067516,
-0.11132285,
0.5568907261,
-0.0471486039,
0.4209801555,
-0.9670677781,
-0.1067063063,
-0.6249732375,
-0.3351799846,
-0.6219435334,
-0.6764854789,
0.165763855,
0.301648885,
0.1943672746,
0.4011271596,
-0.5945320129,
0.7165068388,
0.6024159193,
-0.0780152529,
-0.0059030969,
-0.1244876385,
-0.146389097,
0.1201714203,
-0.8090788722,
-0.7846316099,
0.9322661757,
0.3099790812,
0.0338082761,
0.1171140149,
1.0771481991,
0.1520165056,
-0.0703285038,
-1.1701426506,
0.398837626,
-0.1510587782,
-0.7406070828,
-0.3212932646,
-0.1079040021,
-1.341412425,
0.351327002,
-0.3211328089,
-0.754077673,
0.1465236098,
0.0922640488,
-0.5039249063,
0.2978825569,
-0.7269983888,
0.8933711052,
0.0450815782,
-0.1777057946,
-0.098823227,
-0.616550386,
-0.0391043015,
-0.0875484645,
0.2864224017,
0.1178839058,
-0.2921102047,
1.1639443636,
-0.6072291136,
0.7665192485,
-0.2279625386,
0.176277563,
0.2084501684,
0.040272329,
0.5808355808,
-0.0896099582,
0.050584238,
0.1762009561,
0.1937729716,
-0.6838638783,
-0.6212311983,
0.1365346462,
-0.3954226375,
-0.5369334221,
-0.1700372249,
0.0176496468,
-0.16270639,
0.5290625095,
0.2180253565,
0.8295211196,
-0.1463124603,
0.3040953279,
0.3915925324,
-0.0343654156,
0.6803441644,
0.019241238,
-0.1207253039,
-0.3648438454,
0.8787465096,
0.0388433002,
0.154206872,
0.4312956929,
0.4500239491,
-0.1541996598,
-1.0874816179,
-0.2922641039,
0.1870171428,
-0.7303353548,
-0.0053717452,
-0.5669566393,
-0.0264886059,
-0.4211376011,
-0.2300565094,
-0.3066767454,
-0.2983858287,
-0.1420083195,
-0.1938601434,
-0.0650003254,
0.905505836,
-0.1259064972,
0.4162575901,
-0.8458446264,
-0.0099305194,
0.2709575593,
0.5129879713,
-0.0443094485,
-0.3665628135,
-0.4002862573,
-0.3626919091,
0.211900264,
-0.6931857467,
0.0377522446,
0.0498334318,
0.2994057536,
0.2964864969,
-0.2179854512,
0.7061672211,
-0.7817893624,
1.1259692907,
0.1615427583,
-1.141726613,
0.4116607606,
-0.0695239604,
0.2772065997,
0.6658133268,
0.2311181128,
-1.0178571939,
-0.0239675026,
-0.5373923779,
-1.0054106712,
0.5842014551,
0.4281842709,
0.3931403458,
-0.3488188386,
0.4255799055,
0.2425465286,
0.3484897912,
-0.6174049377,
-0.1470887363,
-0.1641445309,
-0.0272090305,
0.0582758114,
-0.4958902895,
0.1567578763,
-0.025282044,
0.3912262917,
-0.0580797233,
0.4579774737,
0.0478488132,
-0.1776781529,
0.3538131416,
0.1809341311,
0.4717039764,
0.3778284788,
-0.1363143921,
0.3864556849,
0.0235559735,
-0.6410681605,
-0.0005033691,
-0.2113456875,
-0.0092110848,
0.2145875096,
0.5640117526,
1.0360114574,
0.2068452835,
-0.3068315685,
0.6309607625,
-0.0541118905,
-0.0548684411,
0.1679966748,
-0.1387203634,
-0.0733412504,
-0.0995172113,
0.1784967333,
0.1476199925,
0.2736545205,
-0.3953012228,
0.2136848122,
0.47834602,
-0.3114160299,
-0.4515720606,
0.5813526511,
0.4732816219,
-0.5007507801,
0.3999250829,
-0.2765787542,
-0.4571583569,
0.1844119728,
0.4005506039,
0.8084306717,
0.3003819883,
0.1968862861,
0.3421070874,
0.5047523379,
0.087974079,
-0.2212709188,
-0.3034401834,
-0.7340745926,
-0.7033111453,
-1.0135322809,
-0.106157057,
-0.1118801832,
-0.3451598883,
0.3282877505,
-0.509021759,
-0.3886440992,
0.0353605673,
0.0804492831,
-0.6790090799,
0.2529724836,
0.0465947092,
1.0484935045,
-0.6248390079,
0.4632851779,
0.4501114786,
-0.5405383706,
-0.8816354275,
0.1055551469,
-0.2710129321,
-0.6909422278,
0.8703579307,
0.3534011841,
0.1495348811,
0.07364586,
-0.1749736965,
-0.93038553,
0.7894463539,
-0.0214617755,
-0.1910040379,
-0.3417313397,
0.2904041708,
0.3689912558,
-0.0224818382,
0.094136335,
0.6575453281,
0.5002809763,
0.1089750975,
-0.8510836959,
0.0653134733,
-0.2018529326,
0.4210199118,
0.5963243246,
-0.4544746876,
0.6893123984,
0.2717434764,
-0.6779049635,
-0.1408741623,
0.491114229,
-0.1606898457,
-0.2710366547,
0.7272891402,
0.2683681548,
0.7654327154,
-0.1109142229,
1.0570931435,
-0.5524459481,
-0.2800469995,
0.7968456745,
0.2731898129,
0.8533771634,
0.859392941,
-0.1980592608,
0.463085711,
0.6618243456,
0.2164775431,
0.1816924512,
0.3955004811,
-0.1522671282,
0.0000537848,
-0.3445479572,
0.0333011858,
0.6419427395,
-0.1219328642,
-0.2484432906,
0.049023062,
-0.0409420393,
0.184041515,
-0.2022692859,
-0.2087506354,
0.8234000206,
-0.111779958,
-0.5783213377,
0.3197416067,
0.2464328855,
0.9568815231,
-0.5560621619,
0.3021492958,
-0.2217603326,
-0.3867819905,
-0.1979231834,
-0.2767707407,
0.4977623224,
-0.0272396933,
-0.0629950389,
-0.342633009,
0.9129241109,
0.010773425,
-0.261329025,
-0.0902124941,
0.3255025744,
0.3786357343,
-0.125830248,
-0.2843150198,
0.2994797528,
-0.38933447,
-0.2171031237,
0.2116423547,
0.3634240031,
0.1599353254,
0.2586483359,
0.8782950044,
0.4888968766,
0.2689108253,
0.1933279037,
0.7843316793,
-0.6584103703,
-0.5621386766,
-1.0027438402,
0.637216568,
-0.2685698867,
-0.2811985016,
0.7257943153,
0.6442415714,
0.8223466873,
0.1929747611,
0.4964675605,
-0.1269025356,
0.077690348,
-0.7025812268,
0.3663053215,
-0.3331579268,
0.0758822933,
-0.3268805146,
-0.7044668198,
-0.407956183,
0.461817652,
-0.0782753974,
-0.0877932832,
0.859085083,
0.5003313422,
0.2174188644,
-0.0189465601,
0.1885024011,
-0.4349809587,
0.4751960337,
0.1981151253,
0.5400862098,
-0.5885914564,
0.6325359941,
-0.2285933793,
-0.0279910751,
0.0718222409,
-0.9531107545,
-1.1330525875,
-0.6240752339,
-0.0858315676,
-0.1033153906,
-0.1575574428,
1.0803699493,
1.0445016623,
-0.5130642056,
-0.2729890645,
-0.4823060036,
-0.0147614982,
-0.0584511347,
-0.1556222439,
0.3224963248,
-0.820815146,
-0.8433246613,
0.3075341284,
0.3979460299,
0.1846325397,
-0.2793684304,
0.068638891,
-0.0596689843,
0.392035991,
0.6813097596,
-0.2306289077,
-0.427396208,
-0.5102698803,
-0.152486369,
0.1181315556,
0.2293854058,
1.1125388145,
-0.6976088285,
0.5195059776,
0.617248714,
0.7064921856,
0.4518615603,
0.0298911817,
0.6948676109,
-1.0050731897,
0.4129159153,
0.1301507056,
0.2872615457,
0.2695907056,
-0.2562195659,
0.5320410132,
0.3494353592,
-0.2922219336,
-0.9739095569,
0.3230992854,
-0.6369116902,
-0.4488545358,
0.9214779139,
0.2165857106,
-0.3828613758,
-0.1357361674,
-0.3880011141,
0.2609760463,
-0.2461573631,
0.4631248713,
0.96438694,
-0.0639615655,
0.1846451163,
-0.2035102099,
0.7818129063,
0.4221725464,
-0.6295585632,
-0.0760659799,
0.2337308824,
0.0220553,
0.3788045049,
0.7974513769,
0.0486235358,
-0.1071925759,
0.3268012106,
-0.0733064413,
0.014026545,
-0.1179535463,
-0.2768322229,
0.418433696,
0.4203430116,
-0.3749640584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18374v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18374v2
|
VerifiNER: Verification-augmented NER via Knowledge-grounded Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T14:49:05 | 2024-06-08T13:01:36 |
Seoyeon Kim, Kwangwook Seo, Hyungjoo Chae, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent approaches in domain-specific named entity recognition (NER), such as
biomedical NER, have shown remarkable advances. However, they still lack of
faithfulness, producing erroneous predictions. We assume that knowledge of
entities can be useful in verifying the correctness of the predictions. Despite
the usefulness of knowledge, resolving such errors with knowledge is
nontrivial, since the knowledge itself does not directly indicate the
ground-truth label. To this end, we propose VerifiNER, a post-hoc verification
framework that identifies errors from existing NER methods using knowledge and
revises them into more faithful predictions. Our framework leverages the
reasoning abilities of large language models to adequately ground on knowledge
and the contextual information in the verification process. We validate
effectiveness of VerifiNER through extensive experiments on biomedical
datasets. The results suggest that VerifiNER can successfully verify errors
from existing models as a model-agnostic approach. Further analyses on
out-of-domain and low-resource settings show the usefulness of VerifiNER on
real-world applications.
|
[
-0.0086039379,
-0.863758266,
0.8950368762,
-0.2286307216,
-0.0146810282,
0.0197244529,
-0.2310445309,
-0.4986664057,
0.1243332922,
0.5425537825,
-0.0251755752,
-0.4754393399,
-0.6476137042,
0.2947842777,
-0.5089190006,
0.9040287733,
-0.2865525186,
0.1537149101,
-0.6418203712,
-0.1852504015,
-0.3202835023,
-0.7394185662,
-0.4947447777,
-0.5968977213,
0.2772095203,
0.217057541,
0.4364233315,
0.7733446956,
0.594765842,
0.2660684586,
-0.1622819006,
0.4398727715,
-0.3858538866,
0.0271625724,
-0.5902850032,
-0.188886568,
-0.5093922615,
-0.4120735228,
0.6684600115,
0.703953445,
-0.1013064161,
0.0173405707,
-0.1740023494,
0.2381366789,
-0.7397136688,
-0.1710729301,
-0.6917017102,
-0.1601731926,
-0.0940271392,
-0.0725194961,
-0.3833066821,
-0.381496489,
0.1876324415,
-0.6035853028,
0.3400640786,
0.0455176495,
1.3300198317,
0.4590968788,
-0.5016504526,
-0.0558528416,
-1.1169769764,
0.6201289892,
-0.5468068719,
0.6287838221,
0.5204644799,
0.715436399,
-0.3252592981,
-1.0106458664,
-0.6694594026,
-0.2550887465,
-0.1258156598,
-0.13688986,
-0.1821747571,
-0.0699445531,
0.5214681625,
0.389837265,
-0.2590800524,
-0.2662160099,
-0.3441603184,
-0.4878109992,
0.3524978459,
-0.1348672807,
0.3946135044,
0.2283192426,
-0.3617617786,
0.1501691192,
-1.0278174877,
-0.0071404409,
-0.1519125253,
-0.1880203635,
0.1599938124,
0.6850899458,
-0.3433230817,
0.8069320917,
0.4098925889,
-0.0518761389,
0.2670729458,
-0.2848311067,
-0.2656193972,
0.2809918523,
0.4026657641,
0.2762873769,
-0.1742754579,
-0.2535281777,
-0.2710357308,
0.1953314692,
0.1601415426,
-0.8304044008,
-0.31139943,
0.2883094251,
-0.2308787107,
-0.0296880156,
-0.356136173,
-0.4877844155,
-0.6081064939,
-0.3375051618,
0.6692014337,
-0.6183558106,
-0.2230894864,
0.2755105793,
-0.0639998093,
0.3274728954,
0.6542908549,
-0.2573626041,
0.2582323253,
0.7366248369,
0.4623535573,
0.3169754744,
-0.4191133976,
-0.6208618879,
0.2006589323,
-0.2474878579,
0.8834408522,
-0.4923051894,
-0.1744152158,
-0.2915700972,
0.1468465328,
0.0984144062,
-0.4094418585,
0.6391370296,
-0.5942975879,
-0.18373321,
-0.6827300787,
-0.9002361298,
-0.2203734964,
0.622467339,
-0.5025761127,
0.7940369844,
0.044560831,
-0.8432982564,
0.7262100577,
-0.2170158923,
-0.3495634794,
0.263983041,
-0.4621351361,
-0.378433913,
0.066049099,
0.0598819591,
0.2781336308,
-0.5015853047,
0.6470728517,
-0.3414594233,
-0.1136095747,
0.3756379783,
-0.0650829822,
0.3704709709,
-0.1323461086,
-0.3412511349,
0.0613413788,
-1.1007900238,
0.1648087353,
0.0218897872,
-0.137254402,
-0.5506833196,
0.1588977575,
-0.1895826906,
0.1622380614,
0.1961979866,
-0.8846585155,
-0.0693975762,
-0.3006894588,
0.5513407588,
0.3408800364,
-0.0770571232,
0.308955133,
-0.427806288,
0.0769147649,
0.0007747593,
-0.121579729,
0.0960185379,
-0.3728087842,
-0.7657074928,
-0.3531638086,
0.4137462378,
0.4403831065,
-0.6318879128,
0.4900208116,
-0.5040815473,
-0.6387619972,
-0.2485036403,
-0.1558826715,
0.3832657635,
1.1189467907,
0.6650872231,
0.2570254803,
-0.863688767,
-0.7545980811,
-0.2515617311,
-0.21329467,
-0.0866456553,
0.4057839513,
0.8524782658,
-0.752722919,
1.1711550951,
-0.2051080763,
0.0047501447,
0.0774518177,
-0.1991372705,
0.1958004683,
0.642667532,
0.2534922659,
-0.7401200533,
-0.0285740141,
0.4645374417,
-0.9611860514,
-0.0227734335,
0.180252701,
-0.1148857176,
-0.1271394789,
0.4937592149,
-0.392375052,
0.4964036942,
0.4556374848,
-0.431879729,
0.6259031296,
-0.5822977424,
0.2822094262,
-0.7188896537,
0.3787980676,
-0.11152073,
-0.5287008286,
-0.6208975911,
-0.2800736725,
0.1964576542,
-0.0236304384,
-0.0763089657,
0.8902307749,
-0.310883522,
0.2409009635,
-0.3881957233,
-0.1561014205,
0.3633332253,
-0.1752141714,
0.4841317832,
0.6227766275,
0.5769810081,
-0.8075233698,
0.3182229102,
0.4524329007,
-0.1491592824,
1.0236206055,
-1.1380831003,
0.1017369851,
-0.3372018039,
0.2156579942,
-0.6657854319,
-0.6253407001,
0.2600758374,
-0.4181637466,
0.2349838018,
-0.3146375716,
-0.2258330137,
-0.3138558269,
0.2813018858,
0.5737872124,
0.4139161408,
-0.7424682379,
1.0354254246,
0.5052785277,
0.2681335509,
-0.6340260506,
-0.582663238,
-0.0742954835,
0.0083922641,
-0.7039996982,
0.5453223586,
0.1493920833,
-0.2941743135,
0.1648846865,
-0.337335676,
-0.4030718803,
-0.0016193684,
0.4469255805,
0.1860587299,
-0.1997477114,
0.182467714,
0.0580425337,
-0.3607188165,
-0.0060052145,
-0.3837533593,
-0.0119969929,
-0.3695537448,
-0.5799674988,
-0.2111897916,
0.0880663842,
0.5758084655,
-0.3168269098,
0.6305227876,
0.362555325,
-1.020596385,
-0.006181777,
-0.8032317758,
-0.2751556933,
-0.3766255379,
0.2542302608,
-0.510088563,
-0.9489999413,
0.6964908838,
-0.4524742067,
-0.2609325349,
0.3621485829,
0.3302190304,
0.1942431778,
0.7707027793,
0.6001136303,
0.3184555173,
-0.2722456753,
0.0452544354,
0.320720613,
-0.8699187636,
-0.3058202267,
-0.6473992467,
-0.0224142037,
-0.1037460938,
-0.5496428609,
0.315284878,
0.213805005,
-0.3713790178,
0.4495679736,
-0.4198825061,
0.6246429682,
0.3993029594,
0.2830066085,
0.122853063,
-0.2456500232,
-0.1155367047,
-0.0197649356,
-0.3939309418,
-0.8087493181,
0.8165056109,
0.2524797618,
0.441562295,
-0.0819588974,
0.5030053854,
0.0115248049,
0.5493955612,
-0.6200887561,
0.3157756031,
0.1663160026,
-0.8740154505,
-0.1512911171,
-0.4037258923,
-0.555973649,
0.0642552897,
-0.2751830816,
-0.8004598618,
0.5419037342,
0.503829658,
-0.3963963389,
0.3158291876,
-0.1399429739,
0.9973702431,
-0.2102259696,
-0.4312852323,
0.1151334345,
-0.587392509,
0.3451983333,
-0.2355484664,
0.1510486007,
-0.0895213038,
0.1831561178,
0.4594987929,
-0.9302537441,
0.5679725409,
-0.2306708843,
-0.0796823129,
0.0972863063,
0.0535693467,
0.8546845317,
0.2923978567,
-0.2436214983,
0.3794620037,
0.1927906573,
-0.1860911697,
-0.4631836712,
0.5820812583,
-0.6380120516,
-0.4189244509,
-0.32457605,
0.0099078622,
-0.2687352896,
0.5953689218,
0.6341573596,
0.3829165399,
-0.2462954968,
0.2321856916,
0.9292661548,
-0.1906263381,
-0.3362089694,
0.4776288569,
-0.1952878535,
-0.8317840099,
0.7736337781,
0.019283168,
-0.023620056,
0.3734446764,
0.1852990389,
-0.2356731892,
-0.7026284337,
-0.5305012465,
0.2892814577,
-0.8030972481,
-0.379340291,
-0.889721036,
-0.1592539251,
-0.1557814628,
-0.2987973988,
-0.5696468353,
-0.0121900877,
0.0243242718,
-0.1324310005,
0.5232877731,
0.3014900088,
-0.1655125171,
0.2509239316,
-0.8517597914,
0.2763288617,
0.1797614843,
0.2996853292,
-0.6143445969,
-0.5282232165,
-0.1172987521,
0.2385421097,
0.3723498583,
-0.8268270493,
0.0254153535,
0.2498614341,
0.6071689725,
0.3600929976,
0.0172653273,
0.6723710895,
-0.8395454288,
0.5205288529,
-0.0055712592,
-1.2233153582,
0.6203496456,
-0.1686041802,
-0.1961018145,
0.776799202,
0.1215953305,
-0.4113351703,
-0.1753437817,
-0.7313426733,
-0.8185945749,
0.2910163105,
0.0093469881,
-0.1437330693,
-0.0800320357,
0.5663300157,
0.0925218984,
0.1139002815,
-0.3576720357,
-0.2654384375,
-0.3087426424,
0.0740229785,
0.1226832941,
-0.4851915538,
-0.2089919746,
-0.0572773516,
0.8784449697,
-0.1551285386,
0.0918871984,
0.6726998687,
-0.3114340901,
-0.0482039005,
0.1479229778,
0.5139575601,
0.7977485061,
-0.1505015492,
0.3889796436,
0.3924946785,
-0.3530315757,
0.371720612,
0.2274758071,
-0.4337662458,
0.2164832205,
0.2018821985,
0.5639664531,
0.1901861727,
-0.6085275412,
0.7485173941,
-0.1391272098,
-0.1318872869,
-0.4375126958,
-0.2693163753,
-0.0952391401,
0.1431550384,
0.0994482636,
0.3969120979,
0.3213854432,
0.2682259977,
0.4617832899,
0.2852464914,
-0.5474382639,
-0.4485966563,
0.8875457644,
-0.0312581994,
0.0881629586,
0.3546648324,
-0.2462796271,
-0.3652597964,
0.5222069025,
0.6291518807,
0.657736063,
-0.3471357524,
0.0324789323,
0.5960936546,
0.2225266099,
-0.4103595614,
0.3415291309,
0.0854979753,
-1.0569369793,
-0.7165181637,
-0.5295818448,
-0.6090483665,
0.0859664008,
-0.4979815781,
0.4320747554,
-0.7675445676,
-0.4820187092,
0.2781341076,
-0.4896765649,
-0.6370607018,
0.3091973364,
0.122024335,
0.7692647576,
-0.7166355848,
0.6978383064,
1.2315126657,
-0.2433189154,
-0.8660674095,
-0.3088212609,
0.1159951985,
-0.4384625256,
0.8713976145,
0.1541602015,
-0.275708735,
0.0661092699,
-0.4208744764,
-1.033095479,
0.9329120517,
0.5019722581,
-0.5350777507,
0.2166776955,
-0.1678446382,
0.458075434,
0.0003734832,
0.2169062644,
0.1886997968,
0.5021107197,
0.4058843851,
-0.9244432449,
0.3125748634,
-0.2766183317,
-0.0271530692,
0.1785806119,
0.0484934822,
0.8331131935,
-0.2379632145,
-0.2737163305,
-0.0725314766,
0.8399903178,
0.5947757959,
0.4776106477,
0.2493912429,
0.6236066818,
1.3598358631,
-0.1504730284,
0.8770563006,
-0.3570825458,
0.4276849627,
1.1512855291,
-0.8960919976,
0.5192139745,
0.4916107953,
-0.0585765913,
0.4657817185,
0.1434405446,
0.0434079841,
0.2808762491,
0.3299760818,
-0.3858398497,
-0.5929118395,
-0.3168665767,
-0.6014276743,
0.3209202886,
0.4551748931,
-0.2694829404,
-0.364067167,
0.1400963366,
0.1882894486,
0.1022521928,
-0.2692221701,
0.5656298995,
-0.1352148056,
-0.2983023524,
0.6601757407,
0.0722338185,
0.4190662503,
-0.3833300173,
-0.2678413689,
0.1948950738,
0.6968218684,
-0.2062532455,
-0.3219165206,
0.4957058728,
-0.0770777389,
-0.4225681126,
-0.0137571171,
1.3332762718,
-0.2860035896,
-0.484100163,
0.1295350492,
0.512227118,
0.0222811289,
-0.1929721385,
-0.2932802737,
-0.0754512101,
-0.367575258,
0.0901666805,
-0.1710985899,
0.7655111551,
-0.0667920411,
0.5745301843,
0.7347022891,
0.1764118224,
-0.3165612817,
-0.2936393619,
0.7352811098,
-0.5790510774,
-0.2339485884,
-0.9084484577,
0.4824696779,
-0.2831575274,
-0.1009532362,
0.7670269012,
0.5243157744,
0.8134767413,
-0.1198698655,
0.9378009439,
-0.1663120389,
0.7387991548,
-0.4101547301,
0.7046084404,
-0.2949593663,
0.2016605884,
-0.0491501167,
-0.4340005815,
-0.6392974257,
0.8188617826,
-0.651476562,
-0.1251037717,
0.6676802635,
0.7170790434,
-0.1340888739,
0.0076097841,
0.3698552847,
0.207995981,
0.326056987,
0.6047033668,
1.1880091429,
-0.5519166589,
0.0072505064,
-0.1292937994,
-0.3127474189,
-0.3052167296,
-1.1458506584,
-0.8053132892,
-0.2969729006,
-0.7318701744,
-0.8246452212,
0.3092174232,
0.8684988022,
0.7390549779,
-0.898383379,
0.3707166016,
-0.2995688915,
0.2090012282,
-0.3283846378,
-0.0728450641,
0.3371789157,
-0.0927903578,
-0.3038664162,
0.4294590652,
0.2192530036,
0.1133613586,
0.1710407287,
-0.1311231107,
0.1097322926,
-0.0586391725,
0.3816731572,
0.6461026073,
-0.6864370108,
-0.4636790156,
0.1213738248,
-0.2235379666,
-0.0427213386,
0.7493211627,
-0.9896305799,
0.2145691812,
0.5902089477,
0.9578131437,
-0.0185762569,
-0.0010806189,
0.6161944866,
-0.4108291268,
-0.2918742597,
0.2201597989,
0.7509999275,
0.4645971656,
-0.5861648321,
0.3434225917,
0.3081216812,
-0.7579221725,
-0.950991869,
0.1333134621,
-0.6952849627,
0.1639694273,
1.2712304592,
-0.4670129418,
-0.4479032159,
-0.2599154413,
-0.089027755,
0.2109834701,
-0.0121429255,
0.4022155404,
0.5908050537,
0.1511097103,
0.0873499587,
-0.3041151464,
0.5967679024,
0.2357853353,
-0.8898926973,
0.1359070688,
0.8161401153,
0.571516633,
0.3525001109,
0.76767838,
-0.1738016009,
0.3467968702,
-0.0578060783,
0.1617841125,
-0.2163714617,
-0.3279946744,
-0.2748484612,
-0.0639617369,
0.239976421,
0.065723218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18344v2
|
Focus on Your Question! Interpreting and Mitigating Toxic CoT Problems in Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-02-28T14:09:02 | 2024-06-27T06:54:58 |
Jiachun Li, Pengfei Cao, Chenhao Wang, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Daojian Zeng, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models exhibit high-level commonsense reasoning abilities,
especially with enhancement methods like Chain-of-Thought (CoT). However, we
find these CoT-like methods lead to a considerable number of originally correct
answers turning wrong, which we define as the Toxic CoT problem. To interpret
and mitigate this problem, we first utilize attribution tracing and causal
tracing methods to probe the internal working mechanism of the LLM during CoT
reasoning. Through comparisons, we prove that the model exhibits information
loss from the question over the shallow attention layers when generating
rationales or answers. Based on the probing findings, we design a novel method
called RIDERS (Residual decodIng and sERial-position Swap), which compensates
for the information deficit in the model from both decoding and serial-position
perspectives. Through extensive experiments on multiple commonsense reasoning
benchmarks, we validate that this method not only significantly eliminates
Toxic CoT problems (decreased by 23.6%), but also effectively improves the
model's overall commonsense reasoning performance (increased by 5.5%).
|
[
-0.2250577956,
-0.7924253941,
0.9166316986,
-0.0791814998,
-0.3728754818,
-0.015119642,
0.01148983,
-0.5189487934,
-0.1403746605,
0.9477485418,
-0.4270716012,
-0.4217768312,
-0.6198216677,
-0.0068755969,
-0.3856956661,
0.9903085232,
0.0753065646,
-0.2151211947,
-0.2171525657,
-0.1621878743,
-0.6554826498,
-0.6690775156,
-1.0117824078,
-0.1065791845,
0.9226856232,
0.478976965,
0.7951270342,
0.3563210964,
0.3769051731,
0.2899537086,
-0.7310066223,
0.2760256529,
-0.9739319086,
-0.0538487732,
-0.4459908605,
-0.6013046503,
-0.2956012487,
-0.3132195473,
0.3938993514,
0.4570838511,
-0.0445481129,
0.10315115,
0.0327694118,
0.6709461212,
-1.0958929062,
-0.1612822711,
-0.7030525208,
-0.1388302743,
-0.1698735505,
-0.5415162444,
-0.9585772753,
-0.1706729978,
-0.2223347872,
-0.6328511238,
0.1201835722,
0.1072462872,
0.6006049514,
0.2914852798,
-0.9051271081,
-0.2062900811,
-0.6188149452,
1.00707376,
-0.9023423195,
0.0067483769,
0.4643637836,
0.102488175,
-0.1210047752,
-0.490079999,
-0.6247084141,
-0.265763402,
-0.2606408,
0.0831711814,
0.0177109651,
0.0232177265,
0.2709882259,
-0.141128242,
-0.3659304082,
0.0517266206,
-0.5165885687,
-0.4254644513,
0.7308881879,
0.4997551441,
0.370883435,
-0.078141965,
-0.7987682223,
0.0111077242,
-0.9170714617,
-0.1249383464,
0.2808284163,
0.1605525613,
-0.0113208722,
0.3895173371,
0.0050793649,
0.7651589513,
-0.3249468207,
0.2033433765,
-0.0070385989,
-0.352386415,
-0.0924857408,
-0.0243736822,
0.4597480893,
0.5329139829,
0.2345205843,
-0.1632374823,
-0.2446192354,
0.0164467264,
0.2980149686,
-0.3992708623,
-0.1057857424,
0.3634694219,
-0.4044622183,
-0.7260943651,
-0.3431301713,
-0.9210232496,
-0.5733551383,
-0.3775357604,
0.3680816591,
-0.2363592237,
-0.6270976663,
0.1780264974,
-0.3317158818,
0.281424731,
0.3774515986,
-0.7190189362,
0.2607608438,
0.5887573361,
0.7562868595,
-0.2483242005,
-0.1201875582,
-0.6159524918,
0.5654006004,
-0.3975680172,
1.1815298796,
-0.5171456337,
-0.3472765982,
-0.1859956831,
-0.0897616446,
-0.1085396931,
-0.6420919299,
0.555675447,
-0.5224611759,
-0.2056424171,
-0.8117370009,
-0.2659842372,
-0.0665708482,
0.3380382061,
-0.6608945131,
0.6912136674,
-0.2267283052,
-1.0363184214,
0.0827179104,
-0.5486367345,
-0.2686573863,
-0.2803891301,
0.3080153763,
-0.1147465482,
0.0276124347,
0.1566903442,
0.0249089003,
-0.2849269211,
0.2164086699,
-0.4048136473,
-0.451497823,
0.5776907206,
-0.6750387549,
1.0513839722,
0.4393605292,
-0.1615326107,
0.1871354133,
-0.5114326477,
-0.1213175431,
-0.0648468286,
0.1704407781,
-0.4788674116,
0.115647465,
0.1036725417,
0.2549835443,
-0.1352601647,
-0.4128156304,
-0.2759890258,
-0.242532447,
0.5109764338,
1.1964908838,
0.4640858471,
0.3205246329,
-0.5429310799,
0.3919639885,
0.3085588217,
0.4719550014,
0.3506218493,
-0.5104562044,
-0.6310468316,
-0.0385999717,
-0.2228213549,
0.3029612005,
-0.7767249346,
-0.0670998693,
0.0019447808,
-0.2438935637,
-0.0775536299,
-0.2055998743,
0.5466556549,
0.8806378245,
0.5572420359,
-0.120952256,
0.0261665434,
-0.6682639718,
-0.4854026735,
-0.1465097666,
0.2980844975,
0.1621244848,
0.383549273,
-0.1744321436,
0.72903198,
-0.6939103007,
-0.1080270186,
-0.1026834995,
0.3070820868,
-0.1175197512,
0.5134929419,
0.3156692386,
-0.79307127,
-0.2411004454,
-0.1147326306,
-0.4462069273,
-0.2671409249,
-0.2422567904,
-0.6359440088,
0.2138277143,
0.6601052284,
-0.4512413442,
0.4254136682,
0.1638939679,
-0.5663294792,
0.7784666419,
-0.0593415499,
0.1659771502,
-0.5020131469,
0.2768243253,
-0.3595932424,
-0.1078431308,
-0.588182807,
0.1308802366,
-0.0287936255,
-0.0228633676,
-0.8284753561,
0.7027884126,
-0.4018918574,
0.1328119338,
-0.3571007848,
0.6055102348,
0.2371150851,
0.5830545425,
-0.1722899675,
0.6689846516,
0.3028842211,
-0.6334806681,
0.2728459239,
0.2943663299,
0.1195927486,
0.4670624435,
-0.4204234779,
0.210472241,
-0.4209348559,
0.2594326437,
-1.211155057,
0.0986748263,
0.2253848165,
-0.3362213671,
0.0678810328,
-0.1615632474,
-0.5806033611,
-0.2998825908,
-0.2784087062,
0.592906177,
0.3003476262,
-0.4954049587,
0.4440903664,
0.2552245855,
0.0334767252,
-0.7496845722,
-0.8777025342,
-0.1191143915,
-0.3624931574,
-0.5149469376,
-0.0905569419,
0.0277539697,
-0.3872002363,
0.2315880507,
-0.3844634891,
-0.2725225985,
0.1079256237,
-0.2625150383,
0.4242116213,
-0.0290098712,
0.4346982241,
0.216782555,
-0.5811795592,
0.3217329979,
0.1790924519,
0.5403299332,
0.0027951603,
-0.3146519661,
-0.3800534606,
0.3856655955,
0.8146890998,
-0.3916658461,
0.8367618918,
0.3401092589,
-0.0387390219,
-0.2637502551,
-0.481692493,
-0.2617340982,
-0.5355394483,
0.2078044713,
-0.1591376513,
-0.39774248,
0.7147401571,
0.0110046407,
-0.2203280479,
0.5453529358,
0.5306099653,
-0.0544808246,
0.872659266,
0.236818701,
0.0143557116,
0.2278436273,
-0.409481734,
0.2816868424,
-1.0318713188,
-0.2096285522,
-0.3249085844,
-0.2443453968,
-0.3496192098,
-0.5038834214,
0.5959841609,
-0.1553850174,
-0.6763589978,
0.1522449404,
-0.5942009091,
0.860534668,
0.1913223118,
0.6732911468,
0.5158081055,
-0.4706681371,
-0.0845583826,
0.4339780211,
-0.6540568471,
-0.5598415732,
1.0658519268,
0.2196733207,
0.8224189878,
0.1998409778,
0.574182272,
0.0912201405,
0.6294183135,
-0.4030296803,
0.7027385831,
-0.2028574497,
-1.0214922428,
-0.2624974251,
-0.6240075827,
-0.6185668707,
0.3705992103,
-0.0724864453,
-0.7351054549,
0.301102072,
0.3551002145,
-0.3392834663,
0.6080467701,
-0.9762730598,
0.9280467629,
-0.2093373984,
-0.8502012491,
-0.5456617475,
-0.7119893432,
0.7321896553,
0.056977272,
0.4427630305,
-0.1024975702,
-0.1143920571,
0.6809027195,
-0.4000586569,
1.0614881516,
-0.2329219729,
-0.2997142076,
0.5946561098,
0.0937021449,
0.61384058,
0.0003526953,
-0.0684947595,
-0.0705870464,
0.2572028935,
-0.6839122772,
-0.5527225733,
0.7042229772,
-0.6671074033,
-0.6139975786,
-0.5101761222,
-0.6544080377,
-0.3122033775,
0.0799385384,
0.2692327797,
0.6238263249,
0.2255583405,
-0.1324536204,
0.6391680241,
-0.5684175491,
0.2828938663,
0.4429775178,
-0.0446803421,
-0.2627539039,
0.8263264298,
-0.0872873366,
1.005533576,
0.2602556944,
0.3666326702,
-0.4239384234,
-0.521823287,
-0.113541536,
0.5152358413,
-1.1207865477,
-0.4332289398,
-0.5218675137,
-0.0472497493,
-0.0961320624,
-0.2613728642,
-0.3777657449,
-0.2529065609,
-0.2570913136,
-0.1525723934,
0.3787232041,
0.5909974575,
-0.0090415627,
0.253264606,
-0.7463766932,
0.4948200583,
0.2446024865,
0.4779908657,
0.5037887096,
-0.5139226913,
-0.0040870113,
0.2572028041,
-0.5423610806,
-1.1083416939,
0.2926257849,
-0.5199177265,
0.5984506607,
0.3267151415,
0.469558835,
0.8885980844,
-0.1627166867,
0.7433770895,
0.1821030378,
-1.0676021576,
0.4390042424,
-0.3243128955,
-0.0500784852,
0.3814443946,
0.2537485063,
-0.471596092,
-0.8659175634,
-0.5728856921,
-0.9740964174,
0.5779156685,
0.3001230359,
0.0785217583,
-0.292325139,
0.2306822091,
-0.0717546418,
-0.2254527062,
-0.7292194963,
-0.0221037436,
0.1292040199,
-0.0612312667,
0.0860576034,
-0.4559794962,
-0.2448600233,
-0.0958033577,
0.6359258294,
0.1253820658,
0.2426125705,
0.423873961,
-0.2423692048,
-0.3383588493,
0.286424607,
0.7942596674,
0.7615497708,
-0.1341423094,
0.3835844994,
0.3913455904,
-0.297657162,
0.1301393062,
-0.4491543472,
-0.0253161974,
-0.3564661741,
0.582875073,
0.4734888673,
0.3193525672,
-0.8495151997,
0.5297156572,
0.3092853725,
0.0958484262,
-0.1478236318,
0.0962208062,
0.1974147707,
0.0861764103,
0.1515173018,
0.2911719084,
0.2505784631,
-0.673959434,
0.2232949734,
0.3560251296,
-0.2545684278,
-0.0392972045,
0.735458076,
0.4239242971,
0.0314147435,
0.6294164062,
0.1070729047,
-0.5776526928,
0.9512529373,
0.6465750933,
0.7132255435,
0.0373066105,
0.2627999783,
0.4173243642,
0.3131158054,
0.0033172811,
0.0967993587,
-0.0001013218,
-0.7245115042,
-0.6465532184,
-0.0628690794,
-0.5035350323,
-0.0616816282,
-0.8381180167,
0.340957433,
-0.2638716698,
-0.025047211,
-0.2424939424,
-0.2900173366,
-0.2500540316,
0.0991301462,
0.1615592539,
0.8738951087,
-1.1541426182,
0.5748339891,
0.0970988199,
-0.7421381474,
-0.7164500952,
0.2458009422,
-0.0521295927,
-0.8469059467,
0.7389618158,
0.017119376,
-0.4533757865,
0.0002423401,
-0.8532425165,
-0.7827865481,
0.9431949854,
0.2784633636,
-0.454878509,
0.2040041834,
0.0928099081,
0.5112900734,
0.1563444436,
0.32328704,
0.5217345357,
0.4868361354,
0.2449124455,
-0.7836976647,
0.3299740553,
-0.0005791248,
-0.0517417975,
0.3035798371,
-0.7754741311,
0.6764134765,
-0.4379643798,
-0.2845142782,
0.0627054274,
0.0630345494,
0.4253101051,
0.6482018828,
0.6319311857,
0.3806787431,
0.7512149215,
0.2178775221,
1.0808191299,
0.0438771024,
0.4627007544,
1.0993021727,
-0.3274697065,
0.8382868767,
0.618316412,
0.0270674247,
0.4845888615,
0.2147249281,
0.403668344,
0.7453567982,
0.3842560351,
-0.461078018,
-0.2204154432,
0.0999235809,
-0.3242844641,
0.1349963993,
0.2768369317,
-0.1613123864,
-0.2869695723,
0.2416887581,
0.1252350658,
0.1797873527,
-0.3764854968,
0.6889163852,
0.0205799509,
-0.5768555999,
0.951559782,
-0.3521834314,
0.3907106817,
-0.3203805983,
-0.0209210068,
-0.4384809732,
0.2244438082,
-0.0883565024,
-0.9700913429,
0.6910327077,
-0.0956089348,
0.2022969276,
-0.3604758382,
0.7027495503,
-0.3065359592,
-0.3336188197,
0.3523239493,
0.1676167846,
0.1712409258,
-0.0510717034,
-0.4644236863,
0.2321799845,
-0.0537599027,
-0.0287688542,
0.0186019335,
0.7054949999,
-0.1715052575,
0.9223966599,
0.675237298,
0.0625861734,
0.1010478884,
-0.0296017714,
1.295812726,
-0.8709754348,
-0.3939888179,
-0.7368500233,
0.7952526808,
-0.2065875083,
-0.228844732,
0.2547373474,
0.3917917013,
0.5543220043,
-0.2462738156,
0.4477168918,
0.2349361628,
0.5153845549,
-0.7611620426,
0.8563765883,
-0.3755806983,
0.6600654721,
-0.2517208457,
-0.4838859141,
-0.3934445977,
0.3960959613,
-0.6080744863,
-0.1208699942,
1.1193566322,
1.0195577145,
-0.0030290836,
0.0465114936,
0.2632666528,
0.6495510936,
0.4837126732,
0.8251728415,
1.099113822,
-0.2637915313,
0.7506113052,
-0.2703889608,
-0.2901715338,
-0.0473542549,
-0.8457218409,
-0.7339166999,
-0.3296613395,
-0.2598651052,
-0.3469829261,
0.2792546153,
0.2819512784,
0.2840746939,
-0.7643947005,
0.0472680405,
-0.496004045,
0.5169590116,
-0.3635349274,
-0.3093250692,
0.486092627,
-0.7019680738,
-0.2558944821,
-0.1914326549,
0.0209363922,
-0.2769432366,
0.0918205604,
0.0302949138,
-0.3243750632,
0.1405249834,
0.7509733438,
0.028483877,
-0.7621831298,
-0.6631294489,
-0.0713259354,
-0.0849753246,
-0.1154754981,
0.9583352208,
-0.7506340146,
0.4386351109,
0.4435638785,
0.0952659249,
0.5400786996,
0.0996513888,
0.4625910223,
-0.2865975201,
0.317586869,
0.5250493884,
0.0953190103,
0.0161492024,
-0.5728738904,
0.418567121,
0.2947063148,
-0.5735475421,
-1.0027462244,
0.3626362979,
-1.2625888586,
-0.5044584274,
1.456484437,
0.083991386,
-0.2436894178,
-0.3946475983,
-0.5675809383,
0.3494440317,
-0.0434089638,
0.8872340918,
0.5700052977,
-0.1681568772,
-0.2196241021,
-0.5780149698,
0.3297591209,
0.4246335328,
-0.8206162453,
0.6157372594,
0.5172277689,
0.479642868,
0.044713527,
0.8406693339,
-0.4721800983,
0.2861592174,
0.1428693086,
-0.3861171007,
-0.0059726927,
-0.1341760159,
0.0747158676,
-0.0823331326,
0.0482182354,
-0.2362987101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18334v2
|
Learning to Generate Instruction Tuning Datasets for Zero-Shot Task Adaptation
| 2024-02-28T13:54:57 | 2024-06-06T13:50:26 |
Nihal V. Nayak, Yiyang Nan, Avi Trost, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Bonito, an open-source model for conditional task generation
that converts unannotated text into task-specific training datasets for
instruction tuning. We aim to enable zero-shot task adaptation of large
language models on users' specialized, private data. We train Bonito by
fine-tuning a pretrained large language model on a new large-scale dataset with
1.65M examples created by remixing existing instruction tuning datasets into
meta-templates. The meta-templates for a dataset produce training examples
where the input is the unannotated text and the task attribute and the output
consists of the instruction and the response. We use Bonito to generate
synthetic tasks for seven datasets from specialized domains with unannotated
text across three task types -- yes-no question answering, extractive question
answering, and natural language inference -- and adapt language models. We show
that Bonito significantly improves the average performance of pretrained and
instruction tuned models over the de facto self supervised baseline. For
example, adapting Mistral-Instruct-v2 and instruction tuned variants of Mistral
and Llama2 with Bonito improves the strong zero-shot performance by 22.1 F1
points whereas the next word prediction objective undoes some of the benefits
of instruction tuning and reduces the average performance by 0.8 F1 points. We
conduct additional experiments with Bonito to understand the effects of the
domain, the size of the training set, and the choice of alternative synthetic
task generators. Overall, we show that learning with synthetic instruction
tuning datasets is an effective way to adapt language models to new domains.
The model, dataset, and code are available at
https://github.com/BatsResearch/bonito.
|
[
-0.0247027948,
-0.6596550345,
0.3374202251,
0.0260361675,
-0.2549836636,
-0.2087281942,
-0.5745054483,
-0.3626891971,
-0.177654326,
0.8005777597,
-0.6120367646,
-0.761251688,
-0.5817104578,
0.1330866963,
-0.0982380584,
1.5242226124,
0.1026125625,
-0.0293358229,
-0.0792858228,
0.1142157316,
-0.9089748859,
-0.1565088034,
-0.6951733232,
-0.0975743681,
0.3850262761,
0.6698114872,
0.2359659672,
0.6819352508,
0.0460631624,
0.280461967,
0.7265738845,
0.2954038382,
-0.6878775954,
0.2459312081,
-0.44096753,
-0.9266012311,
-0.4748837948,
-0.2142652571,
0.4031426013,
0.4644197226,
0.2023784369,
0.1823583096,
0.0072257705,
0.4733412564,
-0.8858786225,
0.3020228446,
-1.1833443642,
-0.1300225556,
-0.2337226123,
-0.7742092609,
-0.5559754372,
-0.0912008062,
-0.2236070782,
-0.8519611359,
0.7484518886,
-0.1366406828,
0.6741377115,
0.5955216885,
-0.3627359569,
-0.2205771953,
-0.7840625048,
0.9617457986,
-0.6835042834,
0.3092234433,
0.4669101238,
0.21955055,
-0.3617951572,
-0.4371990263,
-0.3545822799,
-0.1310949624,
0.1787313372,
0.3347386718,
0.0256694928,
0.1858324558,
0.14006643,
0.1612132043,
-0.529990077,
0.1410802305,
-0.4133909643,
0.0241869558,
0.6844658256,
0.1088452414,
0.2746810615,
0.1258396506,
-0.2023958266,
-0.1268867254,
-0.7926267385,
0.1761136502,
0.4467491508,
0.4625253081,
0.0162418336,
0.4063584208,
-0.317394644,
1.1540209055,
0.154760614,
-0.1296698004,
-0.0137755377,
-0.2115208209,
-0.3691221178,
0.3759913743,
0.6441007257,
0.3134520948,
0.447426796,
-0.4587694407,
-0.153818801,
0.125824526,
0.6915251017,
-0.8133357763,
-0.4966600537,
0.0447990969,
0.2523234189,
-0.1299007088,
-0.1426363438,
-0.6406034231,
-0.1386012584,
-0.4366548955,
0.640149951,
-0.4716094136,
0.2440548092,
0.5286338925,
-0.207343325,
0.1213083342,
0.302657336,
-1.1579859257,
0.356310308,
0.6018574834,
0.689715445,
-0.0390255563,
-0.325484544,
-0.7683563232,
0.3574403822,
-0.5012643933,
0.9581654072,
-0.6504507661,
-0.3506882489,
-0.0876655579,
0.480386883,
-0.4312590659,
-0.3827795684,
0.5610200763,
-0.3034565747,
0.1661078036,
-0.0217321049,
-0.6240170002,
-0.1385677606,
-0.0251774117,
-0.3811762333,
0.6906086206,
0.1520852745,
-0.3508791924,
0.3962996602,
-0.815279603,
-0.7801973224,
0.1859919876,
-0.1914906502,
-0.1922480315,
0.3155556023,
0.2187223732,
0.5666594505,
-0.306766957,
-0.1031395346,
-0.0517394803,
-0.5542783141,
-0.0346282572,
-0.2190841734,
0.6494314671,
-0.168264553,
-0.5572169423,
0.0610576831,
-0.687084496,
0.1668091565,
0.129952386,
-0.2028305084,
-0.3736285567,
-0.0237456579,
-0.4402982593,
-0.2111059427,
0.2646538317,
-0.6402336359,
0.3763822019,
-0.5685690641,
0.2482544333,
0.6223970056,
0.3381105959,
0.3172568381,
-0.2982016802,
0.638646841,
-0.0425343178,
0.1082742363,
-0.4145864844,
-0.5275151134,
-0.8977277279,
-0.1894961745,
0.4418455958,
0.5855432749,
-0.9446029067,
0.3922022283,
-0.3954758942,
-0.3404282033,
-0.6902926564,
0.3263909519,
0.626885891,
0.6976829171,
0.4348900616,
-0.2761463225,
-0.4976539314,
-0.7889362574,
-0.2840976417,
0.317109704,
-0.1530911475,
0.2049303502,
0.31120646,
0.1205791086,
0.6214650869,
-0.5818778276,
-0.5072176456,
0.0083378218,
0.3194450438,
0.0568642281,
0.5047037005,
0.6721029878,
-0.4587813914,
-0.5825692415,
0.286057651,
-0.4352485538,
0.004787568,
-0.2833677232,
-0.282916218,
0.2649611533,
0.1721967161,
-0.3371141255,
0.2659696937,
0.633433938,
-0.118747212,
0.3725228608,
-0.3708914816,
0.3458266854,
-1.1655737162,
0.0068381787,
0.0499191098,
-0.3386766613,
-0.7477803826,
-0.1229262128,
0.0526413321,
-0.2342290729,
-0.3530694246,
0.4950121343,
-0.3659152389,
-0.0389515646,
-0.5337936282,
0.0454271957,
0.117598556,
0.8338041902,
0.1201221049,
1.0092082024,
0.7554181814,
-0.8300603032,
0.0716004595,
0.2850154042,
-0.5141898394,
0.2568739653,
-0.7595047951,
0.3728473783,
-0.0369305909,
0.0308666527,
-0.7464378476,
-0.3253047764,
0.2896195352,
-0.4822141826,
0.5296487212,
-0.4595417082,
-0.2980159521,
0.017065078,
-0.1305173784,
0.0733469799,
0.5558555722,
-0.4008923471,
-0.0635193363,
0.2882448137,
-0.1192938983,
-0.5642881989,
-0.4895415604,
0.0010444754,
0.1354613304,
-0.0078400942,
0.567224443,
-0.1833190918,
0.4203443825,
0.0643910691,
-0.1966487616,
-0.225025624,
0.2412674725,
0.3561517894,
0.201014474,
-0.2364320457,
0.0730521828,
0.5934728384,
0.0044340058,
-0.1610188335,
-0.4775930345,
0.3749457598,
0.2101304233,
-0.0155517105,
-0.4539812505,
-0.0015793135,
0.3295480311,
-0.3950413764,
0.7077818513,
0.4492077529,
-0.3024156392,
-0.7319634557,
-0.0432336219,
-0.2100226134,
-0.464278698,
0.3289382458,
-0.4496033788,
-0.7193515301,
-0.1020302847,
-0.0170715861,
0.5422255397,
0.1709902883,
0.6540291309,
0.0618866682,
0.8820604086,
0.7339645624,
0.1669026613,
0.5600587726,
-0.319527626,
0.2766825557,
-0.6984183788,
-0.078600429,
-0.4800713062,
-0.3584248126,
-0.6001689434,
-0.4794784486,
0.2482284904,
0.1345033497,
0.1033447459,
0.6919605732,
-0.5860450268,
0.6332648993,
0.5714634657,
0.1805181652,
0.1162479967,
-0.0151384231,
0.413777709,
0.1343168318,
-0.8187416196,
-0.4495043755,
1.4283410311,
-0.1814180017,
0.4816524386,
-0.1961447597,
0.7394044399,
0.3671582937,
0.2315469235,
-0.8854826093,
0.4061296284,
-0.5348687172,
-0.6802254319,
-0.2895783782,
-0.3929932117,
-1.0397672653,
-0.1268843263,
-0.2191396207,
-0.6518747807,
0.2230108231,
0.4460839629,
-0.355994463,
0.1459724456,
-0.8469762802,
1.0291153193,
-0.3088023961,
-0.4214262366,
-0.1216419116,
-0.2232705206,
0.4320008159,
-0.153397873,
-0.2545030713,
-0.2212364227,
-0.0685753897,
0.6296213865,
0.0643351153,
1.0780851841,
-0.2888113856,
-0.2388244271,
0.2280939221,
0.1788051426,
0.3320999146,
0.1476683766,
-0.2277272344,
0.2892526388,
0.186430037,
-0.5838772655,
-0.8832113147,
1.0224035978,
-0.7748716474,
-0.702314198,
-0.0198199693,
-0.8033412695,
-0.5024390817,
0.2422537953,
0.500151515,
0.5179079771,
-0.0715670958,
0.286106497,
0.4916185141,
0.0001434863,
0.1894993782,
0.6959621906,
0.4251227677,
-0.2138470262,
1.1303050518,
0.0383357368,
0.0492742844,
0.6739899516,
-0.1876704544,
-0.1065154821,
-0.5149186254,
-0.7970999479,
0.0105686914,
-0.3775836229,
-0.4093232751,
-0.4222821295,
-0.0371330753,
-0.4398574531,
-0.1532004923,
-0.4018792808,
-0.3942931294,
-0.4357084632,
0.0532284938,
0.4439195693,
0.4218653738,
0.2786701918,
0.2681150436,
-0.6395183802,
0.3138975799,
0.1027633473,
0.2712308168,
-0.3361726403,
-0.714692831,
-0.4414818883,
0.3792319894,
-0.3666254282,
-0.7970335484,
0.3099376559,
0.7338407636,
0.3526874781,
0.21326904,
0.2975860238,
0.71026057,
-0.9190718532,
0.614914,
-0.0358292013,
-0.898694396,
0.7370491624,
-0.3701384664,
0.3238495588,
0.6914733648,
0.8140345812,
-0.1252084821,
-0.3439979851,
-0.3071142137,
-0.3084580004,
0.9139530659,
0.1337595731,
0.4671888649,
-0.1135899499,
0.6294932961,
0.5611288548,
0.3403888941,
-0.4970550537,
-0.0729911625,
-0.5117473602,
-0.4222529233,
-0.4787191153,
0.1693746001,
-0.2137076557,
-0.206431061,
0.903706789,
-0.4736081064,
0.3221438229,
-0.0572708994,
-0.2055644393,
-0.3251393139,
0.2839027047,
0.6800137758,
0.5484414101,
-0.2027442604,
-0.0857988372,
-0.0003663189,
-0.1899635345,
0.0833156705,
-0.0188552663,
-0.1829739958,
0.0577677712,
0.3431231976,
1.2668286562,
0.6227105856,
-0.7520797849,
0.3736847043,
-0.0479924902,
-0.5245637298,
-0.0032082193,
0.9595302939,
-0.2825959921,
-0.0585567467,
-0.0365932398,
0.0464415289,
0.0815851092,
-0.55402565,
0.2068747282,
0.3470658064,
-0.3025528789,
-0.7157250643,
0.656393528,
0.185241431,
-0.4409140348,
0.1926333755,
-0.2406260371,
-0.009515102,
0.5173601508,
0.9559265375,
0.8204093575,
-0.3050968349,
0.5436034799,
0.3922217786,
0.1997012645,
0.209805578,
0.1870891005,
-0.4389593899,
-0.5952939987,
-0.4331397712,
-0.696251452,
-0.3036108017,
0.4066569209,
-0.7838276625,
0.2709388435,
-0.67644912,
0.0174193215,
0.1234742627,
0.0527227707,
-0.7552374005,
0.2950213253,
-0.146703437,
0.5164366961,
-0.8957484961,
1.0729905367,
0.9910616279,
-0.2226291001,
-0.3106964231,
0.2356783748,
-0.4841870666,
-0.8420320153,
0.2971839607,
0.0202543456,
-0.0897075087,
0.4183518291,
-0.2996835113,
-0.544582963,
0.9411979914,
0.7069142461,
-0.7170838714,
-0.0029789798,
0.093680732,
0.6570678949,
-0.2887714207,
-0.1341702044,
0.4458512962,
0.1115800291,
-0.1811782569,
-0.5476928949,
-0.0444837883,
-0.0719707087,
-0.1117658913,
0.4447881281,
-0.5138403773,
0.6282021999,
-0.0606660023,
-0.2893968523,
-0.0250499379,
0.4788754582,
-0.1013104469,
0.1784675866,
0.340872556,
0.3767560422,
0.6007698774,
0.056499131,
1.0358421803,
-0.6837322116,
0.185242027,
1.4078099728,
-0.3136081696,
0.7348123789,
0.0278971065,
0.2865087092,
0.6856250763,
0.3869606555,
-0.0417155847,
0.6983155608,
-0.1431974918,
-0.3726781607,
-0.3285111785,
-0.2262369245,
-0.0256611444,
0.6566749215,
0.3561315536,
-0.2292493284,
-0.3600795567,
0.0844162256,
-0.1247465909,
0.114619188,
-0.2989998162,
0.710844636,
-0.1110665947,
-0.8786831498,
1.018073678,
0.2313721031,
0.3125230968,
-0.7315188646,
-0.18728742,
-0.1860965937,
0.1665821075,
-0.0621123798,
-0.4896269441,
0.1056811512,
0.2911538482,
-0.2275082767,
-0.1451045722,
0.6142519712,
-0.5261109471,
-0.5544843078,
-0.0207424592,
0.1393341571,
0.0978342444,
0.0700468794,
-0.789411366,
-0.169198513,
0.1584383249,
-0.0997252613,
0.4603001177,
0.4552552402,
-0.0895711705,
0.2846918106,
0.6683858633,
0.128137663,
0.2176329345,
-0.0497430041,
0.5621326566,
-0.4332527518,
-0.2779682875,
-0.388848424,
0.3277148604,
0.1127422154,
-0.5030898452,
0.8224230409,
0.4828636646,
1.2150295973,
-0.4988715649,
0.8672143817,
0.0461118184,
0.1505671591,
-0.7166303396,
0.4824911952,
-0.7365107536,
-0.2140664011,
0.1933865547,
-0.837359786,
-0.0566162206,
0.3588160574,
-0.5200040936,
-0.0128646074,
0.4882551432,
0.9601738453,
-0.3822649121,
-0.1514726579,
0.5791386366,
0.0983570367,
0.1192534789,
0.7501319647,
0.1802132279,
-0.6069640517,
0.2949087322,
-0.510294497,
-0.3130262196,
-0.1463238597,
-0.7221703529,
-1.1396694183,
-0.7436605096,
-0.4689303041,
0.2798381448,
0.4991866648,
0.6306335926,
0.8514114618,
-1.0075194836,
-0.1837464571,
-0.3681180775,
-0.1671940982,
-0.2579492629,
-0.2408503145,
0.1151013449,
-0.8497709632,
-1.1715583801,
0.8809645772,
0.3551763296,
-0.074053362,
0.1756926626,
0.1497231126,
-0.0160448309,
0.3232310712,
0.5252829194,
0.6196889281,
-0.4122486413,
-0.3170279562,
-0.0779240057,
0.2598075569,
0.0229019821,
0.9106394053,
-0.6909147501,
0.5979953408,
0.1785104424,
0.8467230797,
0.474996388,
-0.0366338342,
0.5697492361,
-1.0697005987,
0.3034616709,
0.1078408584,
0.0581700169,
0.2180618644,
-0.578364253,
0.2843771279,
0.0015682249,
-0.4489121139,
-0.7778333426,
0.1800873876,
-0.7700563073,
-0.3355540335,
0.8420994878,
-0.2407111377,
-0.5253659487,
0.0499402136,
-0.1053481251,
0.4817646146,
-0.2232683897,
1.075360775,
0.2515177131,
-0.1416240633,
-0.1146019474,
-0.7695823312,
0.6135244966,
0.4952183366,
-1.0358407497,
0.1402561367,
0.348960638,
0.4585107863,
-0.1777761579,
0.3359675705,
0.2032488734,
0.4764601886,
-0.1317036748,
0.24627617,
-0.3540784419,
-0.732532084,
-0.1970247626,
-0.1625618041,
0.005580843,
-0.6437013745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18312v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18312v2
|
How to think step-by-step: A mechanistic understanding of chain-of-thought reasoning
| 2024-02-28T13:14:20 | 2024-05-06T09:16:15 |
Subhabrata Dutta, Joykirat Singh, Soumen Chakrabarti, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite superior reasoning prowess demonstrated by Large Language Models
(LLMs) with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting, a lack of understanding prevails
around the internal mechanisms of the models that facilitate CoT generation.
This work investigates the neural sub-structures within LLMs that manifest CoT
reasoning from a mechanistic point of view. From an analysis of Llama-2 7B
applied to multistep reasoning over fictional ontologies, we demonstrate that
LLMs deploy multiple parallel pathways of answer generation for step-by-step
reasoning. These parallel pathways provide sequential answers from the input
question context as well as the generated CoT. We observe a functional rift in
the middle layers of the LLM. Token representations in the initial half remain
strongly biased towards the pretraining prior, with the in-context prior taking
over in the later half. This internal phase shift manifests in different
functional components: attention heads that write the answer token appear in
the later half, attention heads that move information along ontological
relationships appear in the initial half, and so on. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first attempt towards mechanistic investigation of CoT
reasoning in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3710530102,
-0.9320427775,
0.9868857861,
-0.0307021514,
-0.1358876824,
0.3812123537,
0.2012947351,
-0.1943797767,
0.0679780394,
0.5762534738,
-1.089537859,
-0.220364064,
-0.3276024461,
0.1409979314,
-0.2785103917,
0.9824068546,
-0.2170566022,
0.0241605733,
-0.1392837018,
0.0812663585,
-0.366186887,
-0.6940341592,
-0.4826744199,
-0.6812984347,
0.7210356593,
0.3344215453,
0.5299024582,
0.3878223598,
0.2737426758,
0.236736536,
-0.2585326135,
0.038558621,
-0.3825114369,
0.2357393354,
-0.4874998033,
-0.9882312417,
-0.3995521665,
-0.2456014454,
0.3793491423,
0.671630621,
-0.0857525542,
0.3414028287,
0.04507282,
0.7263604999,
-0.566142261,
-0.0030029041,
-0.7857682109,
0.1236093193,
-0.0866131485,
-0.3283948004,
-0.3884472251,
0.164871797,
0.1039558277,
-0.3483038843,
0.1777540594,
0.1571062952,
0.1065342128,
0.2880902588,
-0.3495360017,
-0.5716472268,
-0.4664317667,
0.52118361,
-0.4899360538,
0.3161383569,
0.2273945957,
0.0469923839,
-0.4764022231,
-0.620069921,
-0.7963491678,
-0.2051143944,
-0.0001483303,
-0.1519543976,
0.315122366,
0.0602409616,
0.3741824925,
0.1921866536,
-0.4964872003,
-0.1420394331,
-0.4217852056,
-0.131528616,
0.1717220247,
0.2687336504,
0.1628343314,
-0.2046643943,
-0.6469562054,
-0.0918918028,
-0.8330451846,
0.1228691712,
0.0929917544,
0.269916743,
-0.0152248489,
0.5545537472,
-0.0420316532,
0.7535911798,
0.1336107552,
-0.3260529637,
0.1191991121,
-0.6443213224,
-0.3817534745,
0.2949682474,
0.5971259475,
-0.1197640076,
0.3537301719,
-0.0625520498,
-0.1182274446,
0.022580782,
0.7285447121,
-0.2200023681,
0.1404572129,
0.4432351291,
-0.3521764874,
-0.3514526486,
-0.3141231239,
-0.4417769313,
-0.3772096336,
-0.4092698097,
0.2859458327,
-0.265512228,
-0.2764584124,
0.1883967817,
0.1784723997,
0.342900902,
0.3378799558,
-0.749475956,
0.2839413583,
0.7899289727,
0.6596090198,
-0.0089899749,
-0.5825355053,
-0.0732215568,
0.2204667032,
-0.4925426841,
0.8751471639,
-0.4841703773,
-0.0726795346,
-0.0044860719,
-0.0889423564,
-0.2113464177,
-0.3544507027,
0.1965323538,
-0.6426222324,
-0.1570790708,
-0.7614654303,
-0.1939133406,
-0.2519237697,
0.5715529323,
-0.3693320751,
0.9251352549,
-0.2916149497,
-0.8919118047,
0.2842636108,
-0.5090577006,
-0.359121263,
-0.3573641777,
-0.533241868,
0.3638218343,
0.1492332518,
0.0422505029,
0.3690060079,
-0.6759207845,
0.0591226146,
-0.1643548161,
0.0322900154,
0.5392561555,
-0.339756906,
0.6800094843,
0.0580088533,
-0.5250023603,
0.1348896772,
-0.7216887474,
-0.1976611167,
0.0014479958,
-0.1476828903,
-0.3052434027,
0.005172357,
-0.6295704842,
0.7863233089,
0.1629120708,
-0.3513837159,
0.3491614163,
-0.0957952663,
0.3864566684,
0.8933851719,
0.0477861688,
0.5151838064,
-0.2291187942,
0.4513996243,
0.3983155489,
0.2410660386,
-0.2601011693,
-0.4459601641,
-1.0708007812,
0.3286444545,
-0.1099014133,
0.5199414492,
-0.9491587877,
0.1112136021,
0.1146916226,
-0.2527990937,
-0.5267004371,
0.1826991141,
0.6139128804,
0.5945077538,
0.5206506848,
-0.3174409866,
-0.1303881258,
-0.6965312958,
-0.006852638,
-0.3801286519,
0.1544456631,
0.016690867,
0.5823394656,
-0.0597195961,
0.4835880697,
-0.4151301086,
-0.0766690299,
-0.2814137936,
0.231359452,
0.0696440637,
0.303773582,
0.0742911175,
-0.403123349,
0.2479914129,
-0.0680892393,
-0.9220674038,
-0.0100648552,
-0.6113564968,
-0.6045701504,
0.068254821,
0.8042604327,
-0.758687079,
0.4506858885,
0.0833998397,
-0.4818138182,
0.580796659,
-0.2358949184,
0.0493939407,
-1.0550912619,
-0.2040751725,
-0.4510494769,
-0.0261630025,
-0.4796616137,
0.2304947972,
-0.2190474272,
0.4720869064,
-0.399435997,
0.2262911499,
-0.5685138702,
-0.3748188913,
-0.3517065644,
0.2987841666,
-0.0765671954,
0.8128702044,
-0.268391639,
0.6507891417,
0.5375301838,
-0.7442622185,
0.0963107198,
0.3591188788,
-0.2426449358,
0.3139441907,
-0.4332163334,
0.5221267939,
-0.1949101388,
0.4432348609,
-1.0905667543,
0.1251602322,
0.3668056726,
-0.1759574413,
0.2189185172,
0.1364722401,
-0.6956239939,
-0.380302459,
-0.1525551826,
0.7089951038,
0.2536657453,
-0.3602035344,
0.7197434902,
0.302094996,
-0.1194087416,
-0.6626659036,
-0.8699967861,
-0.1614739001,
0.1402038187,
-0.5151077509,
0.0130220428,
0.1108700037,
-0.4085686803,
-0.280261755,
-0.4704018831,
0.0485066213,
-0.2110804021,
0.0537781641,
0.1507712156,
-0.2368558645,
0.2291802615,
0.3117323816,
-0.061325442,
0.4702061117,
-0.5366917253,
0.7914587259,
-0.019885689,
-0.4422302842,
-0.1856104583,
0.1558128893,
0.8238583207,
-0.0629144832,
0.6960502863,
0.0691522658,
-0.1225964352,
-0.4406984746,
-0.3934904933,
-0.135849297,
-0.4126804173,
0.1190159768,
-0.7342705727,
-0.7071470618,
0.7260096073,
-0.0234991442,
0.0190304499,
0.3198956251,
0.8973407745,
-0.1039505005,
0.5379651785,
0.2924167216,
0.3695302308,
0.0657856688,
-0.447381109,
0.2324737608,
-1.1192350388,
-0.6724853516,
-0.1970983595,
-0.3650892377,
-0.5131856799,
-0.9989138246,
0.3849277496,
0.1515736431,
-0.4058995843,
0.2626526356,
-0.219506979,
0.402510643,
0.3241015375,
0.1907216012,
0.2445347756,
-0.2578218579,
-0.8495848179,
0.4875442088,
-0.8259112835,
-0.5708072186,
0.9684135914,
0.3303319514,
1.0045130253,
-0.0904162452,
0.5161983967,
0.0668778345,
0.02633789,
-0.549302578,
0.7742798924,
0.1298654079,
-0.6999381185,
-0.2503358722,
0.0810884982,
-0.6966901422,
0.4140136838,
-0.1207240596,
-0.7272369266,
0.1655229181,
0.1333431751,
-0.3058762252,
0.4039419591,
-0.3551211953,
0.5125021338,
-0.3992537856,
-0.5765865445,
-0.5843266249,
-1.0377354622,
0.47666502,
-0.1293063462,
0.2334569395,
0.0760873184,
-0.0277746636,
0.5326424241,
-0.5207997561,
0.9576010704,
0.1311733872,
-0.4021355212,
0.6905624866,
0.4014061689,
0.3496802747,
-0.1630054116,
0.1884717643,
0.1794436872,
-0.252589643,
-0.2920063734,
-0.658911407,
0.6622514129,
-0.5121623278,
-0.8366088271,
-0.5222819448,
-0.6642096639,
-0.3208472133,
-0.0256516896,
0.1847214401,
0.3944870532,
0.2413794249,
-0.2237152755,
0.6529237032,
-0.1056361422,
0.3480084836,
0.1074097753,
-0.3984865546,
-0.0914169922,
0.3990844488,
0.1920390874,
0.6106230617,
0.5373230577,
0.0165778529,
-0.4990716875,
-0.3378801942,
-0.4873490632,
0.3277847767,
-1.0698632002,
0.0651605427,
-0.6242707372,
-0.1814969033,
-0.1098134071,
-0.1120227277,
-0.2663966715,
-0.5018558502,
-0.0124386996,
-0.386118561,
0.0040640994,
1.2661231756,
0.2105643898,
0.005860344,
-0.6074021459,
0.3268306553,
0.2678754628,
0.1722388268,
0.691727519,
-0.4075263441,
-0.0523230471,
0.0648512617,
-0.5314608216,
-0.7719017863,
-0.213250041,
-0.3463657796,
0.5160198212,
0.2609682381,
-0.1680779457,
0.7649759054,
-0.8430247307,
0.7854834795,
0.2830549479,
-0.8709852695,
0.5088964105,
-0.1492884606,
0.3352265954,
0.4327589273,
0.531222403,
-0.0899153873,
-0.5438349247,
-0.5504130125,
-0.7818844914,
0.5321375132,
0.2834605873,
-0.0455530249,
-0.1169648096,
0.4906223714,
0.3901654482,
0.2335188836,
-0.7071759701,
-0.2057048678,
-0.0627391636,
0.2233754396,
0.0966984704,
-0.1823580265,
-0.0886721537,
-0.1984662265,
0.3352817297,
-0.1800680012,
0.2876286507,
0.5162591934,
-0.2435157001,
-0.0965937674,
0.2740290165,
0.757620573,
0.9828637838,
0.1116100252,
0.3750345111,
0.1846709102,
-0.159157455,
0.2518557608,
-0.571934104,
-0.0716523528,
-0.3520522416,
0.6797243357,
0.9140615463,
0.2147636116,
-0.3604282737,
0.0631111562,
0.1528342366,
-0.080246143,
-0.1660357863,
0.2327912897,
0.073353529,
0.6048538685,
0.1914700419,
0.1129293442,
0.2414040565,
-0.9490809441,
0.0575625561,
0.2228446603,
-0.3001086116,
-0.5803323984,
0.682059586,
0.0070309248,
-0.3755631745,
0.4347382784,
0.0339402333,
-0.568834722,
0.5083321333,
0.6020437479,
1.0924091339,
-0.0547143593,
0.2290235311,
0.2069001049,
0.4177237153,
0.0178107657,
0.4643189609,
-0.4613488913,
-0.7102281451,
-0.5646719337,
-0.7867673039,
-0.3005640805,
-0.0386224017,
-0.5267225504,
0.1535250545,
-0.5795897245,
-0.1616356224,
-0.0359721743,
-0.645480454,
-0.5786467791,
0.3652401268,
0.546820879,
0.9890042543,
-0.6818392277,
0.7308663726,
0.5965811014,
-0.6392303705,
-0.901470542,
0.6786478162,
-0.1127380133,
-1.0199737549,
0.5915868282,
0.1282424629,
-0.5054809451,
-0.1806003898,
-0.5313846469,
-0.8578438163,
1.1388342381,
0.1765137911,
-0.481593132,
-0.3111391068,
0.3606354892,
0.6075777411,
-0.5639838576,
0.1986943483,
0.6267591119,
0.0447658263,
0.4040255547,
-0.9494901299,
0.3746717572,
0.1091620848,
-0.0257830136,
0.280618161,
-0.69441998,
1.1012405157,
-0.5018382072,
0.1541576982,
-0.2024321556,
0.3007624745,
0.5249331594,
0.1870019585,
0.4949775636,
0.4816148281,
0.6197763681,
0.2200506926,
1.1930302382,
-0.2897327244,
0.0629489496,
1.0489661694,
-0.2840958834,
0.8922564983,
0.7860785723,
-0.1985663772,
1.0836037397,
0.5875720978,
0.5925046206,
0.610763967,
0.5613893867,
-0.1242889389,
-0.3114837408,
0.1201183796,
-0.2085507959,
0.489154011,
0.3643942475,
-0.3340666592,
-0.1195128784,
-0.1163534895,
-0.0255368408,
-0.3813805878,
-0.6354407668,
0.8887004256,
0.398093313,
-1.044929862,
0.7264050245,
-0.5127413273,
0.1449872851,
-0.5457556844,
-0.0916795284,
-0.0183700658,
0.1148899645,
-0.0668684021,
-1.0671836138,
0.2793557346,
-0.0219038352,
-0.3039727807,
-0.2753307223,
0.6307820678,
-0.2827512622,
-0.432492137,
0.665649116,
0.6731087565,
0.25372082,
0.159012109,
-0.7222208977,
-0.0388127044,
-0.0613998137,
-0.422359705,
0.3626525104,
0.7493646145,
-0.4186107218,
0.7348524332,
0.6779804826,
-0.1382751018,
0.4266003668,
0.2857288718,
0.9998201728,
-0.8780358434,
-0.5250895619,
-1.0444364548,
0.6635532379,
0.274089992,
-0.3664928377,
0.209996447,
0.0880731568,
0.8625521064,
-0.0696408823,
0.7028834224,
-0.0793518052,
0.0709748715,
-0.9197604656,
0.4944221973,
-0.5336588025,
0.3902758658,
-0.2988689542,
-0.7518497705,
0.0482863933,
0.5851365328,
-0.247414276,
-0.1502382904,
1.3110480309,
0.6547173262,
0.1984180808,
0.0774828717,
0.2470503002,
0.5368356705,
0.0896459296,
0.6746368408,
0.8579824567,
-0.208761245,
0.2675791681,
0.0120404204,
-0.1939608604,
0.26098454,
-0.746912539,
-1.0039966106,
-0.6022964716,
0.0092494739,
-0.5356967449,
-0.0919726565,
1.0340287685,
0.2893892825,
-0.8016570807,
-0.4950282276,
-0.6421136856,
0.2618421614,
0.0667751431,
-0.12312565,
0.1655147225,
-0.7782482505,
-0.0706579834,
0.3298984468,
0.5294555426,
-0.1924431771,
-0.6201078892,
0.1823598295,
-0.7075692415,
0.3981778026,
0.7014923692,
-0.0981395692,
-1.0980576277,
-0.1208437607,
0.1221317798,
-0.0139591973,
0.1019389555,
1.1173924208,
-0.8296185136,
0.4756538272,
0.6159402728,
0.4648023248,
0.4391283393,
-0.149633348,
0.7180492878,
-0.4313481748,
0.1798288524,
0.0341695473,
0.3963779211,
0.1652101725,
-0.281527251,
0.4984161258,
0.1631121635,
-0.5595023632,
-0.5947825313,
0.4436611831,
-0.9350335002,
-0.2908848226,
1.2252774239,
0.0141517781,
-0.4944633543,
-0.2136588991,
-0.2777829468,
0.3266294003,
0.1061750427,
0.7939947248,
1.0195702314,
-0.6927797794,
0.053734608,
-0.3435406685,
0.4326217175,
0.3736147285,
-0.7368949652,
0.1469054669,
0.1145069376,
0.1141149849,
0.56726861,
0.8872067928,
-0.0188747495,
0.1012706459,
0.2156947851,
-0.151295349,
0.3502746522,
-0.6485146284,
0.0504508391,
0.1161040366,
-0.007693476,
-0.2545656562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18284v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18284v2
|
Is Crowdsourcing Breaking Your Bank? Cost-Effective Fine-Tuning of Pre-trained Language Models with Proximal Policy Optimization
| 2024-02-28T12:24:07 | 2024-03-02T23:19:27 |
Shuo Yang, Gjergji Kasneci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Wide usage of ChatGPT has highlighted the potential of reinforcement learning
from human feedback. However, its training pipeline relies on manual ranking, a
resource-intensive process. To reduce labor costs, we propose a self-supervised
text ranking approach for applying Proximal-Policy-Optimization to fine-tune
language models while eliminating the need for human annotators. Our method
begins with probabilistic sampling to encourage a language model to generate
diverse responses for each input. We then employ TextRank and ISODATA
algorithms to rank and cluster these responses based on their semantics.
Subsequently, we construct a reward model to learn the rank and optimize our
generative policy. Our experimental results, conducted using two language
models on three tasks, demonstrate that the models trained by our method
considerably outperform baselines regarding BLEU, GLEU, and METEOR scores.
Furthermore, our manual evaluation shows that our ranking results exhibit a
remarkably high consistency with that of humans. This research significantly
reduces training costs of proximal policy-guided models and demonstrates the
potential for self-correction of language models.
|
[
-0.2918943465,
-0.3708053529,
0.3310941756,
0.1942774057,
-0.0680894107,
0.1203674674,
-0.5506238341,
-0.2027272284,
-0.106960535,
0.8313786983,
-0.5870027542,
-0.3317714334,
-0.5076620579,
0.0800213367,
-0.0207802393,
1.3795334101,
0.3798889816,
-0.1700470746,
-0.1754119545,
0.0479906537,
0.0344793089,
-0.506893456,
-0.8979833722,
-0.1603544503,
0.5998960733,
0.6479848623,
0.9309619665,
0.790753901,
0.3976823986,
0.4575972855,
0.1497551948,
0.3279342651,
-0.652227819,
-0.0751094595,
-0.338285774,
-0.3526774943,
-0.1277787238,
0.5150082111,
0.3748627305,
0.3518676162,
-0.2836555243,
0.1989965141,
0.3070689142,
0.588609457,
-0.5795263052,
0.3040482402,
-0.6487526894,
-0.437179625,
-0.3111518621,
-0.2054058462,
-0.3552196026,
-0.834022522,
0.0101009998,
-0.6579921842,
0.3525181413,
0.032385055,
0.8791809082,
0.5218526721,
0.1261693239,
-0.162146762,
-0.4064974487,
0.9070123434,
-0.5752242208,
-0.0007343864,
0.8522206545,
0.0683573559,
-0.0357893519,
-0.5617227554,
-0.4396754205,
-0.6363757253,
-0.1829663217,
0.0610861629,
-0.1698683351,
0.2461601645,
-0.1468569934,
0.1122761816,
-0.6044432521,
0.3949539065,
-0.3865385056,
-0.3300765455,
0.8090914488,
-0.1732826382,
0.1319034696,
-0.2371448725,
-0.0326028205,
-0.4201570451,
-0.4353286624,
0.0967324376,
0.7784340978,
0.4889219701,
0.2067618817,
0.3466145992,
-0.507701993,
0.5928096771,
0.1119651496,
0.038049262,
0.0712936521,
-0.1436406225,
0.1079941839,
-0.1699516922,
1.0449067354,
0.1453286111,
0.5589896441,
-0.5055980086,
-0.1688744426,
-0.1529214233,
0.3782330453,
-0.7107305527,
-0.632247448,
0.0319320522,
-0.3061610162,
-0.7136128545,
-0.2196437269,
-0.550997436,
-0.2514261901,
-0.4754098058,
0.4851890802,
-0.178092435,
-0.2559256554,
-0.1194860265,
0.1620999724,
-0.3419494033,
0.1722142398,
-1.1912821531,
0.1990988851,
0.6519340873,
0.7366246581,
0.1272637844,
-0.4172175825,
-0.5930953622,
-0.1532382816,
-0.3632819951,
0.9795854688,
-0.6607192159,
-0.4400536418,
-0.0229568854,
-0.1111947894,
0.0237338822,
-0.8327491879,
0.3677128851,
-0.3735117316,
0.4035225511,
0.0288896598,
-0.4235354662,
0.2327013314,
0.1181016415,
-0.6193630099,
1.0717163086,
0.1365678012,
-0.5269477963,
0.421398133,
-0.6842609048,
-0.222342059,
0.161039263,
-0.0127541712,
-0.5629922748,
-0.1281452775,
0.4200843573,
0.344976753,
-0.1160398722,
0.6274487972,
-0.1810433716,
-0.1701781601,
0.0880324319,
-0.3737834692,
0.497249037,
0.3801423907,
-0.4706895053,
0.262186259,
-0.712354362,
0.1425285041,
-0.1357696205,
-0.5149758458,
-0.4496806562,
0.1949627548,
0.1299417466,
0.1779202819,
0.2797065079,
-0.3774826229,
0.4725885689,
-0.5252756476,
0.4886484742,
1.0482821465,
-0.1857365966,
0.6873907447,
-0.1427136213,
0.4522548318,
-0.5049339533,
0.2982668877,
0.1135929227,
-0.1362650692,
-0.6707431674,
-0.1937621087,
0.5446435809,
0.3305662274,
-0.5058711767,
0.3922371864,
-0.1479275525,
-0.6855384707,
-0.9672160745,
0.2520230711,
0.5064489245,
0.4064494073,
0.4079756439,
-0.0770495161,
-0.2274963111,
-0.8875702024,
-0.5832237601,
-0.3565892279,
-0.1707659811,
0.238931179,
0.1748067588,
0.0717685297,
1.122620821,
-0.4359276593,
-0.4946363568,
0.0133146653,
0.5971490145,
0.0662355646,
0.6862330437,
0.2316586077,
-0.5993885994,
-0.2714922726,
-0.1663144827,
-0.236120522,
-0.3045404553,
-0.0452588648,
-0.0171384886,
0.1550382823,
0.5231804848,
-0.2358902693,
0.0371555164,
0.7182760835,
-0.2392802685,
0.3826758564,
-0.6089015603,
0.1077092588,
-0.7519715428,
-0.0226587784,
0.1081960425,
-0.4270775616,
-0.0920984372,
-0.0255411658,
-0.0810695663,
-0.3384469748,
-0.005972377,
0.5818471909,
-0.1577465385,
0.3062039316,
-0.3638296425,
0.107647799,
-0.2657700777,
0.6734718084,
0.3143343627,
1.0470767021,
0.1432223618,
-0.5755578279,
0.0868130401,
-0.0056304256,
-0.4393211603,
0.2735536993,
-0.7488823533,
0.1562592536,
-0.1168936342,
0.0635284334,
-0.8387855291,
-0.0844512656,
0.1760765463,
-0.3205667138,
0.0857914686,
-0.18828848,
-0.4965415895,
-0.0538659282,
-0.0464528091,
0.1508485973,
0.4923657775,
-0.6478222013,
-0.0452010818,
0.6844316125,
-0.4632408321,
-0.4090673029,
-0.2376869619,
-0.005795368,
-0.0515928566,
-0.134610787,
0.4062685072,
0.1531115174,
-0.103282623,
0.0369603448,
0.0800870806,
-0.0494100153,
0.0482503548,
0.0662357733,
-0.1079968661,
0.2362918705,
0.3739948869,
-0.1212396026,
-0.4854541719,
-0.1368379295,
-0.5262610316,
0.4852060676,
-0.1594787538,
-0.1550104022,
-0.3580850959,
-0.0904603526,
0.1919616759,
-0.6674463153,
0.5728920698,
0.5709840059,
-0.0882151499,
-0.01642083,
-0.6795630455,
-0.2383878231,
-0.5489432216,
0.4851647019,
-0.1174092591,
-1.1321310997,
0.0097172642,
-0.3951764703,
0.1364562213,
0.3287937045,
0.6203436852,
-0.2001604289,
1.1546120644,
0.6575968266,
-0.5214527845,
0.585806787,
-0.2466969788,
0.0773449391,
-0.0765822306,
-0.1938943267,
-0.7978453636,
-0.105729945,
-1.1216868162,
-0.4483892322,
0.3783882558,
0.1526837796,
-0.2744441628,
0.3335596621,
-0.7813375592,
0.8229265213,
0.9286993742,
0.1615139842,
0.2278259695,
-0.0587233827,
0.2028622478,
-0.1563188136,
-0.7003773451,
-0.5825698376,
0.9760141373,
0.1698670983,
0.7921521068,
-0.1351778656,
1.0282278061,
0.4759241939,
0.4687025249,
-0.2674951851,
0.3545183539,
-0.1090465263,
-0.4778248966,
-0.9456402659,
-0.5980038047,
-1.1253831387,
0.2950099409,
-0.187000528,
-0.7708979249,
0.0895683318,
0.4075370431,
-0.2999188304,
0.0608810671,
-0.6742827892,
1.1328626871,
-0.1902124286,
-0.4755861163,
-0.6897636652,
-0.3093491197,
0.1038228124,
0.1290255934,
0.4441237152,
-0.3598353863,
0.1467547119,
0.6800638437,
-0.7990145087,
0.7766403556,
-0.2893727422,
-0.0120732673,
0.2080641091,
0.0194439702,
0.6480864882,
0.2806967199,
-0.0315912291,
0.0298705287,
-0.0563630983,
-0.703592658,
-0.4608958364,
0.7698312998,
-0.9990595579,
-0.5192026496,
-0.2117135376,
-0.2719962895,
-0.2875308692,
0.0166833624,
0.3120346069,
0.3041837215,
-0.2514823675,
0.027011456,
0.4918632805,
-0.1450657398,
0.4162910879,
0.4221680164,
-0.017881738,
-0.3712970614,
1.3374483585,
0.1391150802,
0.0760599598,
0.4103992879,
0.4097799659,
-0.539906621,
-0.2349443734,
-0.1984137744,
0.1169780865,
-0.1232170463,
-0.1495827436,
-0.4998480082,
0.049568519,
-0.5684728026,
-0.0161786415,
-0.6310539842,
-0.3599080741,
-0.1105246171,
-0.0753464028,
0.3713842034,
0.3939685524,
-0.3985029161,
0.4560942948,
-0.6350702047,
0.0820221528,
0.6159747243,
0.5142483115,
-0.182900995,
-0.333517462,
-0.4108290076,
0.028518213,
-0.2341941595,
-0.5331209302,
0.5046260953,
0.2312882692,
0.4749019742,
0.3907913864,
0.207288906,
0.7097585201,
-0.4971598387,
0.3839712739,
-0.0458486937,
-0.9111378193,
0.5981776118,
-0.416398555,
0.3049911559,
0.928638339,
0.2844944894,
-0.518578887,
-0.6941947341,
-0.8055605292,
-0.7716404796,
0.8428425789,
0.2661016285,
0.3056174517,
-0.1063911915,
0.1908447146,
-0.0828716829,
0.1601415426,
-0.7061030269,
0.0608336255,
-0.2429318875,
-0.1604287028,
-0.3466728032,
-0.2095154524,
0.0063460111,
-0.246762231,
0.7494515181,
-0.1818100959,
-0.3081761003,
0.0675069764,
-0.1418173909,
0.0289760977,
0.2373728305,
0.288490206,
0.5053501725,
-0.1294247806,
-0.0099640656,
-0.0451205447,
-0.1610136479,
0.1429300159,
0.2710985839,
-0.217738241,
0.0250975452,
0.0528062582,
0.5924133062,
0.5060135126,
-0.7784987688,
0.3895252943,
0.0622360595,
-0.2370736748,
-0.1454479545,
0.1789563894,
0.0857122019,
0.3150126636,
0.1530304253,
0.0267788935,
0.2705761194,
-0.116192095,
0.153047204,
0.3938030601,
-0.3357463479,
-0.0198984873,
0.7208303213,
0.4981826544,
-0.3901612461,
0.7067661285,
-0.2772909403,
-0.2494014949,
0.451194793,
0.2260253578,
0.6067366004,
-0.3746826053,
0.76231879,
0.4464877248,
0.4609449506,
-0.4281538725,
-0.1960159093,
-0.2663325965,
-0.548352778,
-0.5576446652,
-0.6085063815,
-0.5891551375,
0.1058266908,
-0.5272698998,
0.1504802108,
-0.3587967157,
-0.1770974696,
-0.0970725268,
0.1769671142,
-0.662658155,
0.3001931012,
-0.0412872583,
0.4397322536,
-0.728987813,
0.7783125043,
0.4221763313,
-0.5987952948,
-0.8039248586,
0.0214116778,
-0.353464365,
-0.7322286367,
0.6311770082,
0.051554732,
-0.0909123644,
0.5068516135,
-0.801409781,
-0.8821260333,
0.5288798809,
0.508510232,
-0.7279435396,
-0.1006449163,
0.0356525555,
0.4923580885,
0.1392424256,
0.5045059919,
0.5352073908,
0.5041586161,
-0.4570078254,
-1.0243781805,
-0.2692156732,
-0.0015427013,
0.0615695491,
0.2157301903,
-0.8449902534,
0.5030652285,
-0.2328033298,
-0.0743044093,
-0.0757559836,
0.7104066014,
0.2760175765,
0.0200251956,
0.5359497666,
0.4129379988,
0.8743071556,
-0.0381673798,
1.0578117371,
-0.3729281425,
0.5785323977,
0.9350922108,
0.1009763777,
0.7653019428,
0.3159357607,
-0.3557844758,
0.4826897085,
0.8275622725,
-0.0524070933,
0.7938949466,
0.5237517357,
-0.0974796787,
-0.6158311963,
-0.164681375,
-0.0957891047,
0.5331092477,
-0.0889204741,
-0.1297223121,
-0.4520328343,
-0.012638201,
0.2540011704,
0.5440406203,
-0.2780309021,
0.8722592592,
-0.1800360084,
-0.8691733479,
0.485673964,
0.213503778,
0.7313119769,
-0.510536015,
0.0675719827,
-0.3338557184,
0.2348864675,
-0.0222395193,
-0.2588100731,
0.0828216225,
0.164792642,
-0.0658214539,
-0.542391479,
0.4795147777,
-0.7090346217,
-0.6030106544,
-0.0709293783,
0.4606620967,
0.2873146236,
-0.512906611,
-0.7730364799,
-0.4344584942,
-0.2482773066,
-0.4155533016,
0.5874801278,
0.3290714622,
-0.2421754301,
0.7581568956,
0.85247159,
0.1211674437,
-0.3106050491,
0.2219112068,
0.7934715748,
-0.4090729654,
-0.7968711257,
-0.8969144821,
0.3229160607,
-0.2714001238,
-0.4629585445,
0.3614751995,
0.6151464581,
1.2211450338,
-0.0040998505,
0.9081438184,
0.2415540367,
0.5955210924,
-0.4196469188,
0.9025326967,
-0.4065909386,
-0.0500680171,
-0.2860562801,
-0.7234873176,
-0.066582568,
0.7400665283,
-0.5872322917,
-0.0787337944,
0.1670230329,
1.0044350624,
0.2500302494,
-0.2626397908,
0.1253044009,
-0.2107123733,
0.1763988733,
0.1299176365,
0.7053642869,
0.0416163802,
0.8802022338,
-0.3409127295,
-0.3804273009,
-0.1805679947,
-0.7396808863,
-0.705417335,
-0.5507149696,
-0.420622915,
-0.1541917175,
0.4049448371,
1.0530723333,
1.048111558,
-0.7833920717,
-0.3597426713,
-0.2101363391,
0.1227878258,
-0.4106360376,
-0.282171011,
0.455617547,
-0.9884133339,
-1.0100381374,
0.2810192406,
0.2138943225,
-0.4024534822,
-0.3627413809,
-0.136842519,
0.0508654043,
-0.1926879734,
0.278868407,
0.3839980662,
-0.635052979,
-0.1206703782,
-0.0762763396,
-0.3590500355,
-0.1897811294,
0.9959162474,
-0.9888268113,
0.4687310457,
0.2989016771,
0.625887394,
0.4120581746,
0.3304764032,
0.6143458486,
-0.7535888553,
0.1730299741,
0.3479614556,
-0.1710911393,
0.2010216862,
-0.2944137752,
0.5480095148,
0.0824399441,
-0.8966346979,
-0.6736397743,
0.0459322818,
-0.3774084747,
-0.4021174908,
0.995968163,
-0.0270293839,
-0.0125143658,
-0.0478037186,
-0.4268311262,
0.2104049623,
-0.537648499,
1.2119152546,
0.5039063096,
-0.0909967646,
-0.3697260916,
-0.3228583038,
0.960282743,
0.4361615777,
-0.7647926211,
0.2148236185,
0.3519053459,
0.1853533685,
-0.0617694259,
0.9794332981,
0.0174760316,
-0.0088701136,
-0.2105118781,
0.4544406831,
-0.1267807037,
-0.1457276493,
-0.1588020921,
0.0733458325,
0.4001219273,
-0.3699951172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18281v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18281v2
|
Towards Better Understanding of Contrastive Sentence Representation Learning: A Unified Paradigm for Gradient
| 2024-02-28T12:17:40 | 2024-06-05T14:07:50 |
Mingxin Li, Richong Zhang, Zhijie Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentence Representation Learning (SRL) is a crucial task in Natural Language
Processing (NLP), where contrastive Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) is currently
a mainstream approach. However, the reasons behind its remarkable effectiveness
remain unclear. Specifically, many studies have investigated the similarities
between contrastive and non-contrastive SSL from a theoretical perspective.
Such similarities can be verified in classification tasks, where the two
approaches achieve comparable performance. But in ranking tasks (i.e., Semantic
Textual Similarity (STS) in SRL), contrastive SSL significantly outperforms
non-contrastive SSL. Therefore, two questions arise: First, *what commonalities
enable various contrastive losses to achieve superior performance in STS?*
Second, *how can we make non-contrastive SSL also effective in STS?* To address
these questions, we start from the perspective of gradients and discover that
four effective contrastive losses can be integrated into a unified paradigm,
which depends on three components: the **Gradient Dissipation**, the
**Weight**, and the **Ratio**. Then, we conduct an in-depth analysis of the
roles these components play in optimization and experimentally demonstrate
their significance for model performance. Finally, by adjusting these
components, we enable non-contrastive SSL to achieve outstanding performance in
STS.
|
[
-0.3477560282,
-0.3709415197,
0.4026072025,
0.2874381542,
-0.436347127,
0.0806195587,
-0.2232638299,
-0.2809094489,
0.0836656392,
0.4150218368,
-0.4760430753,
-0.4638399184,
-0.6096662283,
0.1323155165,
-0.4622603357,
1.342208147,
0.0811256543,
0.3106615245,
-0.364210099,
-0.6211367846,
-0.2786044776,
-0.4904519022,
-0.5318464637,
-0.6746808887,
0.4821140766,
-0.0702310577,
0.5764887929,
0.6623559594,
0.7252945304,
0.3504858911,
-0.0972864851,
-0.1977518201,
-0.6419721246,
0.1980055124,
-0.2302426994,
-0.6754472852,
0.1929823607,
0.095946312,
0.7415819168,
1.0355379581,
-0.2559387982,
-0.1533245742,
0.6667651534,
1.1297395229,
-0.6324116588,
-0.0841364041,
-0.5132442117,
0.4793598354,
-0.155625686,
-0.2759444714,
-0.4074553549,
0.0296743698,
0.0177315995,
-0.6894376278,
0.5471199751,
0.2070312053,
0.8016516566,
0.4508307278,
-0.6854023337,
-0.1711936444,
-0.5760543346,
0.9284679294,
-0.4206065536,
0.3435522914,
-0.1019646227,
0.0331464224,
-0.0334059,
-0.8350197673,
-0.3931695819,
-0.3944034278,
-0.2957169116,
0.5025759339,
-0.2850364149,
0.3023878932,
0.0598269776,
0.5970903635,
-0.7482737303,
0.1511209458,
-0.3078899384,
-0.2462771684,
0.4160993695,
0.2276922464,
0.1972934008,
-0.2611546516,
-0.8140299916,
0.000750975,
-0.5789219737,
0.0976121798,
0.1832570732,
0.4018836915,
-0.0899590254,
0.2679035962,
-0.0418349393,
0.4802042544,
0.1392389834,
0.4088891447,
0.2291972041,
-0.4958863854,
-0.305885464,
-0.2067121416,
0.8601731062,
0.442577213,
0.1119649261,
-0.1668916792,
-0.211786598,
0.1357170641,
0.5858812928,
-0.5996192098,
-0.3661919236,
-0.1119581163,
-0.8541395068,
-0.3172669113,
0.0465223975,
-0.6651313901,
-0.3029152155,
-0.5959549546,
0.2991445661,
-0.4176742136,
-0.0394022986,
-0.0186044816,
-0.2184810489,
0.0950958207,
0.2834354937,
-1.0445188284,
0.6450342536,
0.5501351953,
0.8711705804,
-0.2647835016,
-0.3829621077,
-0.4451325834,
-0.0241148751,
-0.4889363647,
0.5783697367,
-0.391572237,
-0.3566824198,
0.1328145266,
-0.3621995449,
-0.2653844655,
-0.5295000672,
0.5359159708,
-0.4925154746,
0.3808441758,
-0.3288537264,
-0.7171530724,
-0.1316415071,
0.0278836638,
-0.8319987059,
1.0079498291,
-0.0002758676,
-0.9871068001,
0.1848229319,
-0.5550003052,
-0.3954357803,
0.0117911054,
-0.3036473393,
-0.2234746218,
0.4463253319,
-0.0806933194,
0.5963039994,
-0.2622775137,
0.0211246703,
-0.0794647858,
-0.5213710666,
0.0695171133,
-0.1212136745,
0.7109524608,
0.32583794,
-0.2298489958,
0.1381704211,
-0.6413766742,
-0.2469849735,
0.0276868101,
-0.2243864238,
-0.5478661656,
-0.15687491,
0.1478755474,
0.1470744908,
0.1151052639,
-0.4650409222,
-0.1591784805,
-0.3450229466,
0.4599294066,
0.8616683483,
-0.1905045658,
0.8231979012,
-0.11250671,
0.4141400754,
0.1882267743,
0.0261966363,
-0.0259117261,
-0.174767673,
-0.9469830394,
-0.077022329,
0.4946498573,
0.3076592088,
-0.7410282493,
0.1686679572,
0.0232160129,
-0.375557512,
-0.5918578506,
0.2524511218,
0.7112812996,
0.9120993018,
0.6602655053,
-0.3321188092,
-0.4857137799,
-1.1002407074,
-0.4510475397,
-0.2138002217,
-0.0410085395,
-0.0639960542,
0.5298586488,
0.0189530533,
0.648275435,
-0.4237808585,
-0.4987354279,
-0.3830936849,
0.4814836383,
0.0376576558,
0.6126632094,
0.6013989449,
-0.9928141832,
-0.5449069142,
-0.0926462412,
-0.8241630197,
-0.0424680933,
-0.2429932058,
0.105473116,
0.2717401683,
0.8471007943,
-0.3888319731,
0.2900759876,
0.495573163,
-0.1391757131,
0.350128293,
-0.5471394062,
0.0095247431,
-0.8555067778,
0.0220319983,
0.5488947034,
-0.0094592469,
-0.7412665486,
0.2099657804,
0.2594944537,
0.0693987608,
-0.1414966881,
0.2194011956,
-0.2950302362,
-0.0613453425,
-0.1345439851,
0.3175414205,
0.174149707,
0.6454973221,
-0.1221565753,
0.7996384501,
0.4728649855,
-0.6961579323,
0.0856958106,
-0.0338169634,
-0.1021040305,
0.8424350023,
-0.7187644243,
-0.3229210079,
-0.5639117956,
0.4664197862,
-1.1397224665,
0.3277736902,
0.1211913675,
-0.3255910575,
0.3630383909,
0.0975008532,
-0.1295309067,
-0.0344006717,
-0.4881244898,
0.3602913022,
0.550871551,
-0.5823142529,
0.4885745645,
0.1157459393,
0.0632096455,
-0.8719675541,
-0.9236254692,
-0.0676820576,
-0.3395158052,
-0.3307938874,
0.8255836964,
-0.019498691,
-0.2135965675,
0.1081759557,
-0.1516245008,
0.0191075336,
0.1101562157,
0.0726522729,
0.2549686134,
-0.1864247918,
0.5622973442,
-0.1324683726,
-0.4256460965,
0.05421336,
-0.2471656203,
0.3666068316,
-0.30497545,
-0.2349357754,
-0.6984727979,
0.4568010867,
0.0028422072,
-0.1904389411,
0.6767738461,
0.7001678944,
-0.0402939543,
-0.2512993217,
-0.3957216442,
-0.0449225977,
-0.4519801736,
0.3512531519,
-0.3849477172,
-0.9453961253,
0.6619512439,
-0.0927868113,
-0.0556594506,
0.8192782402,
0.3151095212,
-0.5566608906,
0.6209221482,
0.8369099498,
-0.0140133481,
0.5458962917,
-0.2524885833,
0.0275020283,
-1.0777089596,
-0.373583436,
-0.7254207134,
-0.3155916929,
-0.9053913951,
-0.3269323409,
0.0275991093,
0.1025247052,
-0.2184839994,
0.1914097369,
-0.432005614,
0.4333178699,
0.5818055868,
-0.0804738998,
0.2163983434,
-0.0619575046,
-0.362949729,
-0.2848197222,
-0.6540900469,
-0.4707449973,
0.9101340771,
0.2052779347,
0.8072898388,
-0.0984272286,
0.9986165166,
0.4838583469,
0.0100668492,
-0.4358983934,
0.4661118686,
-0.457940191,
-0.2223259956,
-0.237374872,
-0.5314632058,
-1.1821299791,
0.7785654068,
-0.18813245,
-0.3650435805,
0.0192680713,
0.3047799766,
-0.2545812726,
0.1152537689,
-0.5624933839,
0.9904201627,
0.0219757613,
-0.4073296487,
-0.3733659685,
-1.1230914593,
0.0620152131,
0.3406622708,
0.1997473836,
0.3049479127,
-0.3009597361,
0.6709443927,
-0.0975233689,
0.7251092196,
-0.1577313691,
0.0112049356,
-0.0065918458,
-0.0128626805,
0.163864404,
-0.303733021,
-0.0213905368,
0.2450172156,
-0.2141441852,
-0.6020665765,
-0.9139097929,
0.7828967571,
-0.721660912,
-0.494186759,
-0.472043395,
-0.2724865377,
-0.0212282762,
-0.02793549,
0.3201503158,
0.5154290199,
-0.4358430207,
0.3187275827,
0.86194098,
-0.0356709287,
0.5282600522,
0.2231496722,
-0.0243313238,
-0.1423364282,
0.8964317441,
0.1611005962,
0.2330850363,
0.7992298007,
0.1262247115,
-0.5048366785,
-0.8521826267,
-0.1952906847,
0.1780179143,
-1.0238332748,
0.0542854555,
-0.5691072345,
-0.1845427155,
-0.2276374251,
-0.2705544531,
-0.1782345176,
-0.400110811,
-0.6209251881,
-0.2147787958,
-0.1858109236,
0.8854070902,
-0.179892078,
0.1689276695,
-0.5640275478,
0.3307754993,
0.2450717241,
0.2497814,
0.0557734184,
-0.529346168,
-0.2237462252,
-0.267451942,
-0.3053610921,
-0.612839222,
0.2313469499,
0.298014164,
0.7053209543,
0.2978998423,
0.1129019484,
0.6479707956,
-0.5762447715,
0.9111809134,
0.4406947494,
-0.9600260854,
0.4224662781,
-0.1811124235,
0.1008948088,
0.7958007455,
0.4006440341,
-0.6135883331,
-0.421192199,
-0.6827139258,
-0.765940845,
0.5014960766,
0.4119362831,
0.3784111142,
0.1098273471,
0.3542295098,
0.1598979086,
0.1929670423,
-1.0614107847,
-0.4342908263,
-0.554546833,
-0.446110487,
-0.232817784,
-0.1917748302,
-0.1094204709,
0.0755807683,
0.4488495588,
-0.1529105157,
0.1793261915,
0.3146013319,
-0.215401262,
0.0742260292,
0.2951360047,
0.4705227017,
0.3941496015,
-0.0365751386,
0.4164757729,
0.0293698478,
-0.1445882618,
-0.1037067249,
-0.0344183072,
0.0378758535,
-0.0298886634,
0.7628470659,
0.7307537794,
0.2979599535,
-0.3970794678,
0.6207618713,
-0.2074815333,
-0.2387352139,
-0.0163525511,
0.0377060287,
-0.0549581833,
0.1841008067,
0.4263997078,
0.2633799016,
0.4467211962,
-0.4926895499,
0.181624338,
0.5490258336,
-0.5816226006,
-0.0335204899,
0.4792533815,
0.5457828641,
-0.2102367729,
0.6726541519,
-0.1029092148,
-0.5992891192,
0.6727483273,
0.5480866432,
0.6524623036,
-0.2051173002,
0.4307951629,
0.38924101,
0.1925848871,
0.0143348714,
-0.0272748284,
-0.3196985126,
-0.6172184944,
-0.2248715758,
-0.4305275977,
-0.2252185941,
-0.2179887891,
-0.9713751078,
-0.1948613673,
-0.4161837101,
0.2156906873,
0.125246793,
0.0574033856,
-0.5675031543,
0.306953162,
-0.0246130489,
0.6007018685,
-1.0170736313,
0.5611801147,
0.5167659521,
-0.5916644335,
-0.429017812,
0.2146936804,
-0.0649285242,
-0.8073357344,
0.9693990946,
0.3495386839,
-0.2562655807,
-0.0934032574,
-0.3897454739,
-0.5588569045,
1.1383042336,
0.3003922403,
-0.5893737078,
0.088213101,
0.0870899633,
0.949092865,
-0.5457363725,
0.0981249437,
0.2050866485,
0.1415650398,
0.103315793,
-0.6327309608,
0.0695283636,
-0.3140386641,
0.5372822881,
0.2377259731,
-0.7592134476,
0.9145091772,
-0.0645238161,
-0.384013027,
-0.0018753628,
0.8640948534,
0.0301511139,
0.3678204119,
0.3197234273,
0.646312952,
0.801486671,
-0.113414675,
1.3804306984,
-0.2603458464,
0.5086761117,
0.9820067286,
-0.2261906862,
0.7303085327,
0.7490193248,
-0.1892611533,
0.7315087914,
0.5958643556,
-0.0320108086,
0.7084282637,
0.4202728868,
-0.0937998518,
-0.3207923472,
-0.2166100144,
-0.3665614724,
0.3142940104,
0.0405952744,
-0.4776342213,
-0.2905218303,
-0.013471663,
-0.3006905615,
0.6374348402,
-0.3393201828,
0.8335343003,
0.1438303441,
-0.6089330316,
0.41324687,
-0.0963380188,
0.681610167,
-0.6441956758,
-0.1106143519,
-0.2594576776,
0.0939664394,
-0.1378946006,
-0.7008097768,
0.2881515026,
-0.338852644,
-0.262615025,
-0.3400406241,
0.6776024699,
-0.4120586216,
-0.2406329215,
0.6189292073,
0.4261628091,
-0.0672127083,
0.2141652405,
-0.9591698647,
0.0151506355,
-0.0393049791,
-0.0458880067,
0.6021100879,
0.4205308259,
0.3845381439,
0.7987911701,
0.4044728875,
-0.0565270185,
-0.1820447296,
0.2890385091,
0.8119718432,
-0.8298076987,
-0.593208313,
-0.947260797,
0.5852738619,
-0.3209979236,
-0.3188903034,
0.7719776034,
0.3934657574,
0.9781656265,
-0.0011847405,
0.6072242856,
0.2367669791,
0.3107072711,
-0.8534222245,
0.4062822759,
-0.7704740763,
0.1993062943,
-0.2531230152,
-0.7873964906,
-0.6175147891,
0.8777164817,
0.0113169076,
0.1655075699,
1.1218130589,
0.5895742774,
0.1895529032,
0.1718739271,
0.3238203824,
-0.0432983451,
0.1630595773,
0.4371859729,
0.947835505,
-0.4508081377,
0.5976313949,
-0.1738839447,
-0.0071785948,
-0.1148026362,
-0.9466311336,
-0.9198092818,
-0.7728809714,
-0.3686751425,
-0.0991167873,
0.1307747811,
0.7814068198,
0.6130928397,
-0.5819984078,
-0.1551794857,
-0.5257557631,
0.149529174,
-0.2246566713,
-0.2038118988,
0.4638276696,
-0.7901936173,
-0.5129401684,
0.1379996091,
0.483723253,
0.0159349889,
-0.2772621214,
-0.1561396718,
-0.1038122699,
-0.0324134491,
0.5453321934,
0.0513288751,
-0.8663439155,
-0.0835844129,
-0.4623576403,
-0.4033554196,
0.2246574908,
1.0700531006,
-0.789916873,
0.3498953879,
0.4053509831,
0.7664928436,
0.4009698331,
0.007554112,
0.4426821172,
-0.8634995222,
-0.0938978642,
0.3227882385,
0.5126901865,
0.4707120657,
-0.2143291533,
0.7353264093,
0.2791179717,
-0.5581533909,
-0.5634742975,
0.4480723739,
-1.0327179432,
-0.4434815049,
0.8067219257,
-0.2658395469,
0.054788582,
-0.0935176685,
-0.1809332967,
0.1732755154,
-0.5258638263,
0.8383921981,
0.7059480548,
-0.4379718304,
-0.2219300419,
-0.2227267325,
0.6254829168,
0.7642205954,
-0.5341635942,
0.0910411105,
0.4543870091,
0.146195069,
0.3601817489,
0.6067298055,
-0.0078304717,
0.0777864158,
-0.0757358074,
-0.1774891764,
0.1510387361,
-0.2695898116,
-0.8364149332,
0.4668099284,
-0.1070912778,
-0.2047727108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18275v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18275v3
|
Exploration of Adapter for Noise Robust Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-02-28T12:06:08 | 2024-06-04T08:20:02 |
Hao Shi, Tatsuya Kawahara
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Adapting an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system to unseen noise
environments is crucial. Integrating adapters into neural networks has emerged
as a potent technique for transfer learning. This study thoroughly investigates
adapter-based ASR adaptation in noisy environments. We conducted experiments
using the CHiME--4 dataset. The results show that inserting the adapter in the
shallow layer yields superior effectiveness, and there is no significant
difference between adapting solely within the shallow layer and adapting across
all layers. The simulated data helps the system to improve its performance
under real noise conditions. Nonetheless, when the amount of data is the same,
the real data is more effective than the simulated data. Multi-condition
training is still useful for adapter training. Furthermore, integrating
adapters into speech enhancement-based ASR systems yields substantial
improvements.
|
[
-0.2143234611,
-0.3430318534,
0.2387378663,
0.2401749492,
-0.1983884871,
-0.0687484741,
-0.1913059354,
-0.8195718527,
-0.3645506203,
-0.0040320163,
-0.0922017843,
0.0667318255,
-0.6080033779,
0.0730305836,
-0.535692811,
0.5024704933,
0.2927503586,
0.0888842046,
0.2393651605,
-0.2921021283,
-0.6380197406,
-0.3003214896,
-0.9447631836,
-0.225491181,
0.0262472816,
0.0749097988,
0.421307832,
0.58118397,
0.4927251935,
0.4753971994,
-0.0675146803,
-0.1970470548,
-0.2500185668,
0.1998793483,
-0.1571346521,
-0.4050135911,
-0.1312517971,
-0.3233567476,
0.8287572861,
0.4240714014,
-0.1361177564,
-0.0901283324,
0.3895270526,
0.4462703764,
-0.4822594821,
0.2731095552,
-0.8251153827,
0.111288242,
-0.0043746312,
-0.0848790482,
0.0598863587,
-0.1745623797,
0.4625904858,
-0.5578127503,
0.2277481407,
-0.153754428,
0.419821173,
0.6497693658,
-0.0705700219,
-0.3686082065,
-1.0745420456,
0.6245351434,
-0.6779174805,
0.784604311,
0.1408558488,
0.4676015079,
-0.0427122265,
-0.6085830927,
-0.3125912547,
0.16720061,
0.2091436386,
0.2933591902,
-0.5070478916,
-0.109537296,
0.121784091,
0.4349044859,
-0.1623892635,
0.0984224007,
-0.636146605,
-0.468574971,
0.4442202747,
-0.278215766,
0.0616767369,
0.2564397156,
0.0759796575,
-0.233683452,
0.0402253568,
0.3489051163,
0.0931383371,
0.4673530757,
-0.3542158306,
-0.1645122766,
0.0423253104,
0.8088281751,
0.3340944052,
-0.1988099515,
0.4024407268,
-0.4260201752,
0.0001269518,
0.5156414509,
0.5319804549,
-0.0433988236,
0.2951751947,
-0.1659917682,
-0.5507187247,
0.0591754317,
0.4739828408,
-0.7759467959,
-0.6800328493,
-0.2135543227,
-0.5215820074,
-0.4460711181,
-0.0022509559,
-0.6237543225,
-0.3749051392,
-0.306512624,
0.9108342528,
-0.4445503354,
-0.1243100464,
0.0844358131,
-0.2861146629,
0.3423820436,
0.4889095426,
-0.6184061766,
0.6261413097,
0.1070444062,
1.0039997101,
-0.0219304599,
-0.1376174986,
-0.8440216184,
0.0249553919,
-0.354735285,
1.0291813612,
-0.3781974912,
-0.3519297242,
-0.2949274778,
0.1239185333,
-0.386518836,
-0.8788359165,
0.9069683552,
-0.2789117992,
-0.0882594064,
0.0201283637,
-0.046853736,
-0.1425099224,
-0.0799411833,
-0.4581427574,
0.6345680952,
0.1266990006,
-0.2924486697,
0.2800146341,
-0.9980971813,
-0.598442018,
-0.2567007244,
0.0431176238,
-0.6259205937,
0.2265227288,
0.2318135202,
0.078784354,
0.196870029,
-0.4329758584,
-0.1516320109,
-0.6141761541,
0.5868937969,
-0.4750339389,
0.6610433459,
0.3967832625,
-0.3882368207,
0.0490978956,
-1.0208369493,
-0.0828446448,
-0.0947496891,
-0.6753234267,
-0.3993334472,
-0.0608504377,
0.0810775906,
0.1382785439,
-0.4114078283,
-0.4878887832,
-0.3755602837,
-0.3647508323,
0.7021298409,
0.6640608311,
0.0514664426,
0.5620729923,
-0.510053277,
0.3229604959,
0.3210804164,
0.0418823212,
0.0823534057,
-0.3603132963,
-0.8143598437,
-0.2166831344,
0.4617803693,
0.5380687118,
-0.3592373431,
0.4970964193,
-0.0752136186,
-0.1468569189,
-0.7686219811,
0.0876128599,
0.0437108763,
0.6606388092,
0.5185169578,
-0.2775825262,
-0.6215829849,
-0.562531054,
-0.2702166736,
-0.1732542366,
-0.2312332541,
0.4376399219,
0.0674374774,
-0.3755549192,
0.4081244469,
0.1065798253,
-0.4782750309,
0.0640886351,
-0.2966964841,
0.1879135519,
0.677929461,
0.7458173633,
-0.4584360123,
-0.3629722297,
-0.0238324087,
-0.3391770422,
-0.1601849943,
-0.1684428155,
0.028382035,
-0.1358179152,
0.3789540231,
0.153075397,
0.6226556897,
0.7306033969,
0.0097900741,
0.2244146764,
-0.0368063711,
0.003688368,
-0.9528672695,
0.0020212317,
-0.0734322816,
-0.3224253953,
-0.9491674304,
-0.4690703154,
-0.0946245641,
-0.277990073,
0.037764255,
0.0916296169,
-0.4117612839,
-0.2716499567,
-0.4811488986,
-0.0035403864,
-0.102437824,
-0.034792494,
0.0059962529,
0.9022951126,
1.1214963198,
-0.9182418585,
0.1126860082,
0.335395366,
-0.2026303411,
0.4939594269,
-0.7395174503,
0.4410004914,
-0.034859892,
0.0989594758,
-0.8893373013,
-0.1097633839,
0.3886756897,
-0.3360530734,
0.3109885454,
-0.2882503867,
0.2459736764,
-0.0898276567,
-0.3435225487,
0.5056748986,
0.6439475417,
-0.7720907331,
0.704277575,
0.4662074149,
-0.1245668605,
-0.1607275605,
-0.9135673642,
0.0867535993,
-0.4269085824,
-0.199605003,
0.2289601266,
-0.2414569855,
-0.1285581142,
-0.1422474235,
-0.4287137985,
-0.3225616515,
0.1552099138,
0.3466224372,
0.0083490787,
-0.4864075482,
-0.18821612,
-0.196310848,
0.0262514763,
0.083333306,
-0.3473004103,
0.1948677152,
-0.3573076129,
-0.2502742112,
-0.8927029967,
-0.0779854059,
0.3700201809,
0.1807365566,
0.1782241017,
0.807700336,
-0.5179705024,
-0.3281327486,
-0.4687813818,
-0.4440104365,
-0.5533988476,
0.4117366076,
-0.5673148632,
-0.422670722,
0.5184556246,
-0.0791563988,
0.1499036402,
0.1146145314,
0.0111881671,
-0.1742184311,
0.4758514166,
0.5057100654,
-0.4245990813,
0.7432560325,
0.1128918454,
0.223477751,
-1.0132485628,
0.0106245968,
-0.8219910264,
-0.6312191486,
-0.3529393375,
-0.3927713633,
0.3382190466,
0.0137414876,
-0.1646478325,
0.1832980961,
-0.5653608441,
0.1941404343,
0.4512451291,
0.3791218698,
0.1377523839,
0.216730684,
0.3080771863,
-0.0216503497,
-0.8647766709,
0.1499059349,
0.7809961438,
0.4399273694,
0.947492063,
0.2978648543,
0.5314765573,
0.1419384629,
-0.1305441111,
-0.8908676505,
0.0479590297,
-0.2130429596,
-0.0468158498,
-0.4635936916,
-0.3276663721,
-1.0006769896,
-0.0247034058,
-0.3329495192,
-0.541924417,
0.9774355292,
0.3948151469,
-0.631572485,
-0.0000817884,
-0.6565495133,
0.1496002674,
-0.2229992747,
-0.0736883953,
-0.1042131707,
-0.6997566819,
-0.0835013092,
-0.4143090248,
0.4698485434,
0.29899773,
0.2071727663,
0.9567911625,
0.0765075907,
0.6842503548,
-0.4138639569,
0.1226752698,
0.3755063117,
0.0968713835,
0.5204220414,
-0.2011035085,
-0.4060325921,
0.2038374394,
-0.0986507684,
-0.1804845482,
-0.4747186005,
0.6223952174,
-1.2380307913,
-0.2170872241,
-0.3276992142,
-0.8745755553,
-0.2962425947,
0.1345369369,
0.1152918115,
0.6542931199,
0.0319410264,
0.5403960943,
0.6490219235,
-0.1461577863,
0.4538859427,
0.5746018887,
0.0689001158,
-0.4811601639,
1.0738030672,
0.2154453695,
0.148450613,
-0.2195272446,
0.6046622992,
-0.2412786931,
-0.840811491,
-0.3422068655,
-0.1823380589,
-0.587423563,
-0.2125150114,
-0.7315746546,
-1.0010020733,
-0.4500260055,
-0.1229714826,
-0.3551084697,
-0.3659810722,
-0.4094032049,
0.2267097533,
0.4104183316,
0.6650744081,
-0.5068622231,
0.3288785219,
-0.5573060513,
0.4059765637,
0.5804784298,
0.3719039261,
-0.1252343953,
-1.2828224897,
-0.151562795,
-0.0766102001,
-0.0460797437,
-0.5580787063,
0.0887054652,
1.0613355637,
0.77889961,
0.6066203713,
0.2771434486,
0.9806547761,
-0.2137864679,
0.2658282816,
-0.2366785556,
-0.8564817309,
0.5982150435,
-0.2256947905,
0.5982263088,
0.652009964,
-0.0934126154,
-0.1300735921,
-0.1955303252,
-0.3513836563,
-0.423392266,
0.8471677899,
0.3037112355,
0.1665475518,
0.7352241278,
0.6665009856,
-0.0342018455,
-0.0888327286,
-0.6112385392,
-0.0136689954,
-0.7578239441,
-0.1820200533,
-0.0341901705,
0.13625817,
-0.1549053341,
-0.5489290953,
0.530138433,
-0.1830180585,
0.5147004724,
0.2064123005,
-0.127103135,
-0.4102016389,
0.2431113124,
0.3727574348,
0.278593719,
-0.248597756,
0.3113664389,
0.6333408952,
-0.7292537689,
0.1010724828,
0.3925395012,
-0.0722093359,
-0.0252468716,
0.372058183,
0.7652256489,
0.1174344122,
-0.2569550872,
0.4121567011,
-0.2901307344,
-0.4442991912,
-0.2304706424,
0.5838827491,
-0.0855909362,
0.4071297944,
0.2260455638,
0.8433858752,
0.5913103223,
-0.5591400862,
0.2871032953,
0.3704158068,
-0.7809606194,
-0.6273024082,
0.6117550135,
0.2227550447,
-0.674607873,
0.4658863842,
0.3071810603,
-0.5339304209,
0.2473620921,
1.0817805529,
0.7534113526,
-0.8546748757,
-0.4536266029,
0.3714567423,
0.3561460674,
0.0484285206,
0.2354863286,
-0.368421644,
-0.9043277502,
-0.1291398555,
-0.6026144624,
-0.3286776245,
0.2914042771,
-0.7622722387,
0.3058318496,
-0.4689041376,
-0.0075184065,
-0.0590404831,
-0.5008782744,
-0.6680942774,
0.1645627171,
0.1022269279,
0.6281304955,
-0.9538570642,
0.9052202106,
0.9054597616,
0.3061570525,
-0.7208965421,
0.31587708,
0.25239411,
-0.9817146659,
-0.0170776919,
0.032396853,
-0.5397614837,
0.0904423892,
-0.1333995014,
-0.9163714051,
0.9262657762,
0.3776226044,
-0.6671636701,
0.5191552043,
0.0058169486,
0.6340590119,
-0.192806378,
-0.059647385,
0.6009250283,
0.3612222672,
0.1976189166,
-1.0714850426,
-0.0208625793,
-0.4225056469,
-0.0269758869,
-0.224054426,
-0.5876664519,
0.4669475555,
-0.1334008574,
-0.0106369322,
-0.0472865738,
0.4832493961,
0.1388627738,
0.3435854614,
1.1822081804,
0.0867563784,
0.7434307337,
0.1779517084,
0.3300229013,
-0.3077605963,
-0.2417406142,
1.0576080084,
-0.0724264681,
0.6600801945,
0.2790409029,
-0.1158430055,
0.327570945,
0.2808769941,
0.1207514703,
0.6702711582,
0.1144905314,
-0.3799574077,
-0.0597472154,
-0.0847057402,
-0.5943810344,
0.6734148264,
0.3523866236,
-0.2007129788,
-0.0309030581,
0.1636425108,
-0.4931197166,
-0.1813202798,
-0.2164935172,
1.2734165192,
0.1367524415,
0.031477496,
0.4429204166,
-0.4613951445,
0.6340606213,
-0.4329872131,
-0.0207431037,
0.0266371947,
0.370454222,
-0.4282197952,
-0.4508497417,
0.6882087588,
-0.1882938445,
-0.0729528964,
0.114215523,
1.2509214878,
-0.1970470548,
-0.5317210555,
0.2849676907,
0.3216264546,
0.3380793333,
-0.0085806465,
-0.6096468568,
0.2845672667,
0.0489657559,
0.0827965066,
0.4755996764,
0.6278579235,
0.2825619876,
0.4936897457,
0.8439409137,
0.2811294496,
0.2366161793,
0.1518768221,
1.1590931416,
-0.372348994,
-0.6087175012,
-0.431432128,
0.3646944165,
0.0600596927,
-0.0170450583,
0.6406490207,
0.5877762437,
0.3464548588,
0.1383458227,
0.9348891973,
0.2510786355,
0.5093691349,
-0.330057323,
0.7587047815,
-0.2161392123,
0.47926566,
-0.47319749,
-0.8852370977,
-0.4265817404,
1.1560927629,
0.0545416921,
0.100107722,
0.282723546,
0.8709308505,
-0.5350878835,
0.1982139647,
0.4448388815,
0.447932452,
0.2308338732,
0.0815212578,
0.9638792276,
-0.8630367517,
0.8933445215,
-0.5276334286,
-0.3783502579,
0.0948127806,
-0.4213681221,
-0.7353746295,
-0.4407782257,
-0.4429026544,
-0.4557261765,
0.4083768725,
0.7098719478,
0.9250192046,
-1.1979663372,
-0.316562742,
-0.1782250255,
-0.4158610106,
-0.4913590252,
-0.1884336025,
0.2152055353,
-0.310204953,
-0.5434493423,
0.9680842757,
0.0510724671,
0.3060926497,
0.3768042624,
-0.2126182467,
0.1828566492,
-0.0275581107,
0.2645105124,
0.3481408358,
-0.234191373,
-0.6268680096,
-0.219579801,
0.4926456213,
0.3153503239,
0.6223029494,
-0.8484890461,
0.6595831513,
0.1767916679,
0.7686290145,
0.3353817165,
0.1743670106,
0.548635006,
-0.4754831195,
0.3746232986,
0.1679984331,
0.2778728306,
0.2575549185,
-0.406862855,
0.2597644627,
0.1094808355,
-0.9179467559,
-0.8464243412,
-0.3691648245,
-0.9822380543,
0.0014448789,
1.0407096148,
0.0635193288,
0.1132351905,
-0.8039065003,
-0.2174168527,
0.2670512795,
-0.5952559114,
1.0812587738,
0.176434204,
-0.5311242938,
-0.5132964849,
-0.3462814987,
0.5453340411,
0.1242818311,
-0.6601724029,
-0.245268479,
0.2703198195,
0.6038585901,
0.2595940828,
0.461861968,
0.0075534503,
0.3551867008,
0.2509692907,
-0.2729892731,
-0.0473722667,
-0.2278914452,
-1.0917181969,
-0.0245512947,
0.3789230287,
-0.5539326668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18272v1
|
Rethinking the Bounds of LLM Reasoning: Are Multi-Agent Discussions the Key?
| 2024-02-28T12:04:05 | 2024-02-28T12:04:05 |
Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Hanghang Tong, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent progress in LLMs discussion suggests that multi-agent discussion
improves the reasoning abilities of LLMs. In this work, we reevaluate this
claim through systematic experiments, where we propose a novel group discussion
framework to enrich the set of discussion mechanisms. Interestingly, our
results show that a single-agent LLM with strong prompts can achieve almost the
same performance as the best existing discussion approach on a wide range of
reasoning tasks and backbone LLMs. We observe that the multi-agent discussion
performs better than a single agent only when there is no demonstration in the
prompt. Further study reveals the common interaction mechanisms of LLMs during
the discussion.
|
[
-0.8273751736,
-0.6820107698,
1.0782626867,
-0.0779084638,
-0.2583111823,
0.1712804437,
-0.2237492055,
-0.5536723137,
0.3250586092,
0.4150832891,
-0.5837134719,
-0.3263130486,
-0.5498009324,
0.3229225874,
-0.0519954152,
0.5695136786,
0.1420915425,
0.2263910174,
-0.4975271225,
-0.5168446302,
-0.410463959,
-0.6127560139,
-0.6945188046,
-0.636934042,
1.0011451244,
0.5385644436,
0.783330977,
0.4126033485,
0.4472513497,
0.4293826222,
-0.2506158948,
0.5730645657,
-0.2942764759,
0.6299923062,
-0.2372227162,
-0.5498057008,
-0.6150149703,
0.0309674628,
0.5742239356,
0.7476747632,
-0.0771523938,
-0.2315105796,
0.1117894202,
0.4436944723,
-0.3049811721,
-0.1870981604,
-0.6510557532,
0.0823645517,
0.0401599482,
-0.3761143982,
-0.5928682089,
-0.0381661952,
0.1169374511,
-0.3578901589,
0.2163405269,
0.0053602494,
0.5285467505,
0.5452209711,
-0.7456346154,
-0.0652769282,
-0.5351821184,
0.6249960661,
-0.5233204365,
0.1135394499,
0.0620915517,
0.4979126453,
-0.4594319761,
-0.6299235821,
-0.4216083586,
-0.1891330034,
-0.0571076497,
-0.0885453671,
-0.1623730212,
0.3142164648,
0.2086996138,
0.2703381777,
-0.1400924176,
-0.0033552865,
-0.209479332,
-0.3405667841,
0.9147179127,
0.4055230916,
-0.1455236375,
0.2593765259,
-0.3559400141,
0.3514561951,
-0.6965361238,
-0.095335789,
0.1523933858,
0.2469961941,
0.2696667314,
0.427921921,
-0.2335929573,
0.5116807818,
0.1386899501,
-0.0932606459,
0.00056302,
-0.6115762591,
0.0809554905,
-0.3744702935,
0.5640463829,
0.692717433,
0.1068645045,
-0.2925195694,
0.0699426755,
0.0577946007,
0.1700402349,
-0.6642276645,
0.1966837347,
0.1432109028,
-0.4376363456,
0.0758449435,
0.0610343218,
-0.7043748498,
-0.6532432437,
-0.2632141709,
0.0321625657,
0.1925104707,
-0.2418714762,
0.1672178656,
-0.4268096685,
0.3123500943,
1.0709218979,
-0.3498671949,
0.5128019452,
0.6848739982,
0.5694358349,
-0.0626663938,
-0.6195371747,
-0.5283899307,
0.23461321,
-0.3259091377,
1.3954997063,
-0.4557072818,
-0.5274153948,
-0.1881906539,
-0.1696089804,
0.0061820163,
-0.5197635293,
0.4511576593,
-0.3952867985,
0.1405237615,
-0.7242932916,
-0.6693832278,
0.0744064525,
0.6364753842,
-0.6592402458,
0.3336577415,
-0.4901068211,
-0.4643793106,
0.3752394021,
-0.753785491,
-0.2771459818,
0.0744710043,
-0.4323075116,
0.0111021064,
0.0193347409,
0.1583560854,
0.2884644568,
-0.5992097259,
0.0520343892,
-0.5027600527,
-0.4674132168,
0.755902648,
-0.5110473037,
0.3856890202,
0.2677162886,
-0.1266371757,
0.3920473456,
-0.1569157988,
0.3016464412,
-0.0311078876,
-0.2751537561,
0.1936999559,
-0.0313123874,
-0.7395783663,
0.1108513102,
0.1020273641,
-0.3403159678,
0.6579339504,
-0.136568442,
0.493804723,
0.9362052679,
0.2005425245,
0.6455016136,
-0.8502047658,
0.5215982199,
-0.3157818913,
0.4550762177,
-0.1747547537,
-0.6661067009,
-0.7926706076,
-0.1118063852,
-0.0969415978,
0.1559955329,
-0.6484048963,
-0.1423817128,
0.0446805283,
-0.3564639986,
-0.4793228507,
0.0451642573,
0.3123067617,
-0.0199187044,
0.2991274297,
-0.0294657256,
-0.3140954971,
-0.8005667329,
-0.2409159541,
-0.4953658283,
0.1816714406,
0.3026329875,
0.1489874125,
-0.2091020197,
0.9593294263,
-0.2548503578,
0.1081976146,
-0.6134553552,
0.0710641667,
-0.0648648664,
0.0702863112,
0.3043369055,
-0.5003550053,
-0.4321776628,
-0.3981537223,
-0.7394477725,
-0.1089841202,
-0.0972903967,
-0.2138934433,
0.3147912025,
0.5182574987,
-0.9759778976,
0.6116914153,
0.2267303765,
-0.5224075317,
0.5263727903,
-0.1044464037,
0.2888196707,
-0.8529557586,
-0.705329597,
-0.2435754985,
-0.1563684493,
-0.6483587027,
0.0963324532,
-0.3586516976,
0.2050722092,
-0.3667831421,
0.6771345735,
-0.7285889387,
0.1195835546,
-0.8771818876,
0.3865641654,
0.0815818384,
0.4712015688,
-0.1394397467,
0.7261024714,
0.6939968467,
-0.8650995493,
0.4829441011,
0.2434836477,
0.2111525685,
0.6900841594,
-0.680772841,
0.4923791885,
-0.1489554942,
0.7773408294,
-1.0270020962,
-0.0365017019,
0.2418922037,
-0.5112178922,
-0.0566442721,
-0.1351697594,
-0.3940470219,
-0.2828727663,
-0.5812259316,
0.450204581,
0.1755793989,
-0.4677794278,
0.8432438374,
0.3141149282,
0.0012371283,
-0.7186782956,
-0.4762041569,
0.4831757843,
-0.3425996006,
-1.1300332546,
0.1640976071,
-0.3111543357,
-0.833137989,
-0.0321061052,
-0.1051084474,
0.0764734969,
0.0558781102,
0.2296151072,
-0.0123950839,
-0.038209144,
0.6662173867,
-0.1362295896,
-0.211389035,
0.0742330253,
0.1640653908,
0.5188219547,
-0.4872484505,
-0.6129555106,
-0.1073263586,
0.6254649162,
0.5008997321,
-0.0964306071,
0.6781696081,
-0.0185794886,
-0.1294781268,
-0.3298866749,
-0.8267872334,
-0.5436761379,
-0.5232630968,
0.024096122,
-0.582696557,
-1.2273182869,
0.7110854983,
-0.416652739,
0.1045152545,
0.3906253874,
0.433662504,
-0.0528067984,
0.898866117,
0.6436674595,
0.3801192641,
0.1075046733,
-0.0847641677,
0.0773356482,
-0.8870357871,
-0.1376917213,
-0.5436236858,
-0.335635066,
-0.3135169744,
-0.7866285443,
0.4157257676,
0.0465422608,
-0.057851553,
-0.1090813056,
-0.3293003738,
0.8099393845,
0.2900299728,
-0.0168328788,
0.4420531988,
-0.3639580607,
-0.1741530746,
0.2485601157,
-0.8022164702,
-0.8543112874,
0.9721220732,
0.2572063506,
0.6396760941,
0.4979738295,
0.531040132,
0.3391610682,
0.5565183759,
-0.6296034455,
1.036534071,
0.4761182964,
-0.765720129,
-0.6561890841,
-0.4972323775,
-1.1868271828,
0.7334300876,
-0.0421879888,
-0.6210826039,
-0.0342548415,
-0.0616677776,
-0.1441089362,
0.488093257,
-0.5375019908,
0.7102845907,
-0.1926000416,
-0.5905105472,
-0.3459011316,
-0.7597883344,
0.1964669526,
0.3963058591,
0.2196925581,
-0.2404816598,
-0.0227821115,
0.5148246884,
-0.8034655452,
0.7870756984,
-0.1677901596,
-0.443392694,
0.7766544223,
-0.3939315677,
0.4324743748,
0.1409191489,
0.0608504601,
-0.0397609137,
-0.5312879086,
-0.4311428666,
-0.9903140664,
0.3630880117,
-0.5773433447,
-1.3652603626,
-0.3617358208,
-0.5057557821,
-0.2236156911,
-0.1830816865,
0.0978694558,
0.1731100678,
-0.3240061104,
0.0306240283,
0.5793150067,
0.1860956252,
0.3781553805,
0.6762397289,
-0.2844234407,
-0.5149983168,
0.4596696794,
0.0836008713,
0.5869496465,
0.0317523628,
0.2709988654,
-0.2982102036,
-0.5030260086,
-0.2944883108,
0.3900531828,
-1.1606812477,
-0.1484207958,
-0.6432977319,
0.0698972419,
-0.4668976068,
-0.1389395148,
-0.3684489429,
-0.623960793,
0.0158543866,
-0.3122039437,
0.2676751018,
0.8923686743,
-0.152549535,
0.2223753035,
-0.6735854149,
-0.0341219492,
0.8264058232,
0.0529161468,
0.1266313642,
-0.3805960417,
-0.1520553231,
-0.1316570193,
-0.5189290643,
-1.1254012585,
-0.2603711784,
-0.288287133,
1.0846655369,
0.456908673,
0.196599111,
0.5318061113,
-0.3875201344,
0.9718168378,
0.1489368081,
-0.8116770387,
0.4495922327,
-0.1018972993,
0.1882875413,
0.3939238787,
-0.065014869,
-0.490054369,
-0.7867014408,
-0.6704541445,
-0.6300277114,
0.3877731562,
0.1714472175,
-0.1663936079,
0.0450455435,
0.4341961145,
0.0630891472,
0.1428328604,
-0.5328010321,
-0.4197521806,
0.1702572256,
0.3927638829,
-0.0791138634,
-0.3230641186,
-0.513323009,
-0.2011771202,
0.3257036507,
-0.3393056989,
0.463837564,
0.2895800471,
0.1737691164,
-0.3298160434,
0.7059198022,
0.8381172419,
0.9301384091,
0.2309683561,
0.7304633856,
0.5051547885,
0.087410897,
0.5939614177,
0.0946008712,
0.2211434394,
-0.1342399716,
0.5704410076,
0.746912837,
-0.3008725643,
-0.4465865493,
0.3961681426,
-0.5572871566,
-0.5523982048,
-0.0416225493,
0.2820259631,
0.285720557,
0.809915781,
0.4308261275,
0.0266919881,
0.0253497325,
-0.7164450288,
0.3304936886,
0.623791337,
0.0538031943,
0.0690885931,
0.4762035608,
0.4556042552,
-0.5913395882,
0.1843962073,
-0.4623219073,
-0.7284050584,
0.8194475174,
0.278157562,
0.7718761563,
-0.1987701058,
0.3361123204,
-0.1177915037,
0.6367031932,
-0.0539225414,
0.2423092723,
-0.2091869265,
-1.0148658752,
-0.5735494494,
0.1966878325,
-1.0246294737,
-0.3420056999,
-0.209963575,
0.0213370025,
-0.2904025912,
-0.452885747,
-0.1996165216,
0.2776710689,
-0.2288178653,
-0.3723523915,
0.0944640115,
0.6720820665,
-0.4518372715,
0.5110332966,
0.7441242933,
-0.313382864,
-0.6347020864,
0.0250631385,
-0.0806103423,
-0.4736894667,
0.3046563864,
0.32439816,
-0.628079474,
-0.4940039814,
-0.9205455184,
-0.8230860233,
1.1959527731,
0.6572508216,
-0.244031027,
0.2448286116,
0.0996605083,
0.5801523328,
-0.4323240817,
0.3379307091,
0.0370041579,
0.7528973818,
0.6000775099,
-1.1019347906,
0.1429111958,
-0.4962875247,
-0.5062347651,
0.0698304176,
-1.1812921762,
0.9786779881,
-0.5854616761,
-0.2594852448,
0.0466792546,
0.9311411977,
0.5800492764,
0.8453151584,
0.6660118699,
0.3880762756,
1.1058744192,
-0.0713815466,
0.95118016,
-0.0458957627,
0.2225869298,
1.1989741325,
-0.7497754693,
0.1962566823,
0.5587545633,
-0.1671817005,
0.3189591169,
0.415545702,
0.3495538533,
-0.0248471554,
0.6083009839,
-0.5791879892,
-0.7272294164,
-0.3315631151,
-0.5518235564,
0.1167168841,
0.0942664072,
0.1460872889,
-0.1128342599,
-0.0507385023,
-0.0253323521,
0.1497792453,
-0.2802790701,
0.8097470999,
0.0489831716,
-0.7807873487,
0.3675315678,
0.0361907594,
0.5725600123,
-0.3096997142,
-0.1986938715,
-0.4422502816,
0.0968605131,
-0.0864221156,
-0.6316497922,
0.1592004597,
-0.1638433933,
-0.1193259135,
-0.4388969243,
1.1076979637,
-0.4839101434,
0.0636075437,
0.4347335696,
0.9801368713,
0.3978505433,
-0.0323149227,
-0.3680393696,
0.1148132756,
-0.2621568143,
-0.282867074,
0.2857888639,
1.0061227083,
0.0560870953,
0.9037355781,
0.4153847098,
-0.3005732,
0.1926744431,
0.224956587,
1.2391985655,
-0.679123342,
-0.2542932928,
-0.8948757052,
0.3871979415,
-0.3468231559,
0.028400749,
0.8987904191,
0.2795491219,
0.5200422406,
0.348279953,
0.6416655779,
0.4468183815,
0.3789971769,
-0.4707150459,
0.3817762136,
-0.4985127747,
0.5024622083,
-0.1188043803,
-0.6626390219,
-0.2384934276,
0.6166861653,
-0.1799904257,
0.3043055534,
1.0400207043,
0.6546878219,
0.5149886012,
0.3521834314,
0.4022527337,
0.0203502886,
0.6480011344,
0.7648895979,
1.6788547039,
-0.1198538244,
0.6036319137,
0.0503808856,
-0.1847087443,
-0.0209289752,
-0.7757233381,
-1.1889753342,
-0.1330514252,
-0.4125306904,
-0.3247906268,
0.0468460619,
0.9881323576,
0.4829086959,
-0.0795927495,
-0.352184236,
-0.1446047276,
0.780787468,
-0.2156276256,
-0.1973459125,
0.0271714125,
-0.3106858432,
-0.4858622253,
0.6399123669,
0.2769034803,
-0.0264587533,
-0.3518611491,
-0.6698439121,
-0.1767427474,
0.4342351258,
0.4441206753,
0.1693776846,
-0.7413531542,
-0.4820626974,
0.0143973036,
-0.0650274083,
0.1298469901,
1.0775289536,
-0.6228867173,
0.1250077039,
0.2380786538,
0.6098290682,
0.296738416,
-0.0296702441,
0.4993309081,
-0.4524611831,
0.0916297808,
0.154165104,
0.3949217796,
-0.0063309972,
-0.211670965,
0.6365562081,
0.421810776,
-0.9418016076,
-0.8597435951,
0.5824434161,
-0.9305300117,
-0.3627176583,
1.2596781254,
0.0052385698,
0.0410090238,
-0.1985756457,
-0.4939174354,
0.2180150151,
-0.5390111208,
0.5796122551,
0.9307240248,
-0.6461682916,
-0.4469484389,
-0.0658175647,
0.1233995259,
0.4748915136,
-1.0486439466,
0.1348104477,
0.6632653475,
-0.2297941744,
0.3459584117,
1.1974618435,
0.2405866235,
0.2659801841,
0.099177219,
-0.1675725877,
-0.2399483025,
-0.8039422035,
-0.1305280626,
0.5882139802,
0.3815490007,
0.0422977395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18267v2
|
A Survey on Neural Question Generation: Methods, Applications, and Prospects
| 2024-02-28T11:57:12 | 2024-05-07T15:08:56 |
Shasha Guo, Lizi Liao, Cuiping Li, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this survey, we present a detailed examination of the advancements in
Neural Question Generation (NQG), a field leveraging neural network techniques
to generate relevant questions from diverse inputs like knowledge bases, texts,
and images. The survey begins with an overview of NQG's background,
encompassing the task's problem formulation, prevalent benchmark datasets,
established evaluation metrics, and notable applications. It then methodically
classifies NQG approaches into three predominant categories: structured NQG,
which utilizes organized data sources, unstructured NQG, focusing on more
loosely structured inputs like texts or visual content, and hybrid NQG, drawing
on diverse input modalities. This classification is followed by an in-depth
analysis of the distinct neural network models tailored for each category,
discussing their inherent strengths and potential limitations. The survey
culminates with a forward-looking perspective on the trajectory of NQG,
identifying emergent research trends and prospective developmental paths.
Accompanying this survey is a curated collection of related research papers,
datasets and codes, systematically organized on Github, providing an extensive
reference for those delving into NQG.
|
[
-0.6663668752,
-0.8428441286,
0.3539916277,
0.0155291911,
0.0306121297,
0.0403810404,
0.0384017117,
-0.1812679023,
0.0843430609,
0.3116469383,
-0.6545708179,
-0.3678870201,
-0.2223747522,
0.2118144929,
-0.636597693,
0.8138828278,
0.3017363846,
0.2722489238,
-0.8477724791,
0.1018428132,
-0.1908107102,
-0.3192579746,
-0.8378818631,
-0.1938557178,
0.727778554,
0.2500576973,
0.3685136437,
0.0848215744,
0.197315231,
0.1982037872,
-0.294370532,
0.3426699638,
0.0391411595,
0.4063064754,
0.2153931558,
-0.4302089214,
-0.117327325,
0.0658318177,
0.6005933881,
0.8657717705,
0.0299853757,
0.4557350874,
-0.0229494665,
0.4969977736,
-0.6318923235,
-0.1401625127,
-0.5102927089,
0.300046891,
0.1275624335,
-0.2112438977,
-0.0078113982,
-0.922960639,
0.1995363086,
-0.4478496611,
0.4803028703,
-0.1551791877,
0.4043272138,
0.0974669531,
-0.6911975145,
-0.2443022132,
-0.4227483869,
0.4600918591,
-0.7707694769,
0.1886629313,
0.339949131,
0.5022497177,
-0.1955938935,
-1.1410489082,
-0.5232796669,
-0.2670964301,
0.2597279847,
0.380341053,
-0.1703455895,
-0.1967613101,
0.3185465038,
0.4746814072,
-0.6965466142,
0.0457527377,
-0.2881162167,
-0.0783751085,
0.7305781841,
0.3471015394,
0.2922878563,
-0.4940201938,
-0.3334740102,
0.1331695616,
-0.5832925439,
0.1349622309,
0.5285859108,
0.0038559698,
0.3202882707,
0.3391648531,
-0.6135817766,
1.0625818968,
0.1098244116,
0.3870354295,
-0.156334579,
-0.8321533799,
0.1703159064,
-0.2151137739,
0.9627536535,
0.7411441803,
-0.1652213931,
-0.2165584415,
-0.1084106416,
-0.5398277044,
0.3687576056,
-0.6183552742,
-0.1990608424,
0.3059747815,
-0.4761109054,
-0.5818677545,
-0.3177295029,
-0.8845638037,
-0.6262735724,
-0.1311553568,
0.1421772093,
-0.2012894899,
-0.5520923138,
-0.0834923834,
-0.4319084585,
0.5292321444,
0.195500493,
-0.7638080716,
0.0072990251,
0.265725404,
0.427501291,
-0.0380460769,
0.0322059914,
0.0550425574,
-0.5174784064,
-0.1810131222,
0.8643035293,
-0.0795168281,
-0.1035771817,
0.2263173461,
-0.346550703,
-0.0153354043,
-0.6963122487,
0.0675861984,
-0.8328407407,
0.5689015388,
-0.2458487302,
-0.4347308576,
-0.225099355,
0.9426225424,
-0.7005947232,
0.9751474261,
0.2066118419,
-0.7467407584,
0.3193167746,
-0.5038443804,
-0.110485971,
0.3242621422,
-0.3288164437,
-0.2142399848,
0.1041171253,
0.3079364896,
0.3909379244,
-0.726000607,
0.3448695838,
0.0073641897,
-0.1472711414,
0.4582773149,
-0.1426397711,
1.0044721365,
0.246316433,
-0.1415711641,
0.0817576572,
-0.7490805984,
0.5857194662,
0.2260013968,
-0.3730744123,
0.0544811785,
0.0099572213,
-0.1273151487,
0.2098854184,
0.3369436264,
-0.6539513469,
0.0857988521,
-0.1115435511,
0.7732033134,
0.3312304914,
0.4865688086,
0.4444803894,
-0.2949998677,
1.0147082806,
-0.1664917022,
0.4090417325,
0.0093963062,
-0.60923177,
-0.5352407694,
0.8655250669,
0.8371731639,
0.389395088,
-1.2525798082,
0.1372884065,
0.2526951134,
-0.6153150201,
-0.0449391827,
-0.1083755791,
0.1580438018,
0.7865068316,
0.1709825099,
0.1040741578,
-0.51670748,
-0.8618391156,
-0.0222589951,
-0.4937767088,
-0.0153839663,
0.4835442007,
0.2644765675,
0.4392762184,
0.6216056347,
-0.4750435352,
0.4666941166,
-0.2834082544,
0.2729412615,
0.0820965096,
0.4133699536,
0.5134985447,
-0.9728171229,
-0.0642747059,
-0.1970341057,
-0.8471235037,
0.141085133,
-0.1286588609,
-0.3044131398,
-0.2634650469,
0.6094408035,
-0.4826031029,
0.1630043238,
0.4499823451,
-0.0559777766,
0.72939533,
0.3140920997,
0.0910203382,
-1.2770172358,
-0.0252866782,
-0.1455373019,
0.3544733822,
-0.7447903156,
0.3045780659,
0.2176364064,
-0.1541628391,
-0.5352905393,
0.2646361291,
-0.3776830137,
0.1347568929,
-0.1024282947,
0.0289345607,
0.2114332765,
0.3021236658,
-0.2924402058,
0.4871005714,
0.3750236928,
-0.7785749435,
0.6899409294,
0.4019515812,
-0.2762658,
0.154036805,
-0.8136169314,
0.4447545111,
-0.2583515346,
0.0372573212,
-1.0802963972,
-0.0817708001,
0.3402073979,
-0.8819663525,
0.0482885279,
-0.1233823597,
-0.5276732445,
-0.3671351373,
-0.0290032662,
0.7941077352,
0.5971302986,
-0.2408207655,
0.3497453332,
0.0431670584,
-0.1554476619,
-0.4512947202,
-0.6657973528,
0.121637851,
-0.0364676304,
-0.7891312242,
0.3004253805,
0.0041800495,
-0.1436926872,
-0.0570898913,
-0.0538119562,
-0.3037513196,
0.0280422382,
-0.138266474,
0.1078069732,
-0.5395877361,
0.3594072163,
-0.0616274811,
0.3660654426,
0.5507196188,
-0.4540167749,
0.4381425977,
0.1859869063,
-0.1503525376,
0.3025170565,
0.4818255305,
0.0549466722,
-0.5770900249,
0.1881521493,
0.4272405207,
-0.3814297616,
-0.4383948445,
-0.3025909066,
-0.2577658892,
-0.3736819327,
0.3427935541,
0.2682602108,
-0.8798758984,
0.5149332881,
-0.1777744889,
0.2363717705,
0.2801119983,
0.3935839534,
-0.2587819397,
0.9097247124,
0.2416313142,
0.4438777566,
0.5499111414,
-0.5044841766,
0.0552477762,
-0.8554881215,
-0.6425474882,
-0.4345031679,
-0.7384388447,
-0.4029937685,
-0.3721084893,
0.2814171314,
0.1667214781,
0.1212566271,
0.0984444916,
-0.5719854236,
0.3670820594,
0.7270261049,
0.0149578378,
-0.092205286,
-0.273159802,
-0.1473798156,
0.2201424241,
-1.1307178736,
-0.1968716532,
1.355440855,
-0.0735126138,
0.1156958044,
-0.2170155197,
0.9058019519,
-0.1434977204,
0.0872022286,
-0.9008041024,
0.721398592,
0.1940698922,
-0.9774737358,
-0.3375745118,
-0.545054853,
-1.1671618223,
0.043246109,
-0.2493050247,
-0.128903389,
0.299795121,
0.0346066803,
-0.9759055972,
0.371488899,
-0.4723315835,
0.6032308936,
-0.5185875893,
-0.3773575127,
0.5250508189,
-0.5874972343,
0.6670405269,
0.3367889524,
-0.5178673863,
0.0687526315,
0.0864783227,
0.7560510039,
0.0342845395,
0.3807989359,
-0.4134221673,
0.1412513256,
0.8386597633,
-0.2590149641,
-0.2573727667,
0.3042369187,
-0.1847475469,
-0.01410677,
-0.1383925676,
-0.3022615314,
-0.8026646972,
0.4212825596,
-0.4875817299,
-0.3372276127,
-0.2117908448,
-0.8114271164,
-0.5569112301,
0.257330209,
0.3661054969,
0.5094434023,
-0.1650731415,
0.2762497365,
0.72710675,
-0.5440398455,
0.5468696952,
0.044656083,
-0.2988635898,
-0.5869867206,
0.7613337636,
0.1608729213,
0.2853124738,
0.0850538462,
-0.0001505482,
-0.59694767,
-1.0431064367,
-0.5690460801,
-0.1686014384,
-0.3615830839,
-0.5947129726,
-0.3376508653,
-0.5845245719,
-0.543045342,
0.4991427064,
0.0221999325,
-0.6508609653,
-0.220199585,
-0.0705496371,
0.2471105754,
0.7534388304,
0.4764795303,
0.1910845637,
-0.5502107739,
0.4935450554,
0.7244696021,
0.2699111998,
0.0530033037,
0.0574355647,
-0.110522449,
0.134510085,
-0.5982500315,
-0.9248549938,
0.030853482,
0.0030477056,
0.6270478964,
0.1809205562,
0.1095372662,
0.3051563203,
-0.1449354589,
1.1613949537,
0.3494253755,
-0.1599165648,
0.6008574963,
-0.4944441617,
0.4740934968,
0.6764308214,
0.4292846024,
-0.5138507485,
0.0120264813,
-0.6268494725,
-0.9240621924,
0.3491954505,
0.1476996988,
0.2449399382,
-0.1704154462,
0.679504931,
-0.0404967889,
0.4857121706,
-0.3477154374,
-0.1552569866,
-0.421435833,
0.1906628609,
0.2548917234,
0.1867058426,
-0.1584711373,
-0.2469467223,
0.1776653379,
-0.2998343706,
0.4723112583,
0.211106956,
0.1719367057,
0.2744393051,
0.1618962437,
0.5207349658,
0.4929664731,
-0.0075351382,
0.0294129066,
-0.0486599505,
-0.1922007203,
0.1818870008,
0.114188008,
-0.6695363522,
-0.0953417346,
0.0633208379,
0.4639245868,
-0.2118988484,
-0.3601842225,
0.3049819767,
-0.3720381558,
-1.0595263243,
-0.3785037994,
0.1253225654,
0.3594156504,
0.2680498958,
0.2677666545,
0.1549352258,
0.3860853612,
-0.3202838302,
0.0641798526,
0.3635455072,
-0.3440513313,
-0.1235959083,
0.6576863527,
-0.0603699237,
-0.4047912359,
1.0536884069,
-0.3383018672,
-0.2626120448,
1.1035149097,
0.3897288442,
0.9282966852,
0.2546469867,
0.6149474978,
0.5474296212,
0.2096421719,
0.1284718663,
0.8140357137,
-0.2387229502,
-0.8671174645,
-0.283971101,
-0.4188198447,
-0.2577183843,
0.5562074184,
-0.5908472538,
-0.2849740982,
-0.930300951,
-0.6814141273,
-0.0615313202,
-0.3090065122,
-0.5617172718,
0.3282881081,
0.3714008331,
0.9636179805,
-0.3391326964,
0.162614882,
1.1260095835,
-0.5651580095,
-0.8152396083,
0.225578472,
-0.3374476433,
-0.476195693,
0.5142343044,
-0.1073869169,
0.2813010216,
0.1150212884,
-0.8612164259,
-0.7412426472,
1.295196414,
0.2511273921,
0.2479430884,
-0.4502976537,
0.2879619598,
0.5023587942,
-0.3109849393,
0.4085634351,
0.390391618,
0.3868713081,
0.0541419834,
-0.1836948097,
-0.1042994335,
-0.9844969511,
-0.0107728532,
0.1731725633,
-0.7702351809,
0.8815542459,
0.0701152906,
-0.061748419,
0.3339990377,
0.5734651089,
0.334515661,
0.4728859961,
0.4541526139,
0.314222157,
0.3901872635,
-0.3256784976,
0.7843512893,
-0.2832725942,
-0.3075430989,
0.6965632439,
0.0723600164,
0.4415213466,
0.5775057673,
-0.0163364802,
0.3151860535,
0.8021202087,
-0.2730358541,
0.2047474831,
0.6880710125,
-0.1833865941,
-0.2237716466,
-0.3830847144,
-0.5134657621,
0.6215116382,
0.0059089409,
-0.4556314051,
-0.2831448317,
-0.2481857836,
-0.6681233644,
-0.0369768478,
-0.3787054121,
0.7693645358,
-0.0772554129,
-0.908026576,
0.5604457259,
-0.1351356655,
0.5060184598,
-0.5821492672,
-0.2816256583,
-0.5287475586,
-0.4942956269,
-0.2462904155,
-0.7171218991,
0.0182971172,
-0.2611239552,
-0.1069630533,
-0.6504197717,
0.867133379,
-0.1459976882,
-0.3691496551,
-0.1888237745,
0.966716826,
-0.0822095722,
-0.2064186186,
-0.5709750056,
-0.6921311617,
-0.0176656004,
-0.1708918214,
0.2080620527,
0.4388108253,
0.07465294,
0.3602513671,
0.554761827,
0.040359389,
0.7441768646,
0.0892113298,
0.7361412644,
-0.7326149344,
-0.2316470146,
-0.206695348,
0.8845529556,
-0.1977493018,
-0.9784604907,
0.7373817563,
0.4933564961,
0.7522647381,
-0.0250061508,
0.7635510564,
-0.1826268286,
0.1369879842,
-0.375705421,
0.9300564528,
-0.5348371267,
-0.1906937957,
-0.1036118716,
-0.8366781473,
-0.2645312548,
0.178856656,
-0.2071855217,
0.2015757561,
0.5066598654,
0.5674204826,
0.3535751104,
0.4733998477,
0.234372288,
-0.589631319,
-0.0425897427,
0.5830568671,
1.6846688986,
-0.6329108477,
0.5310397148,
-0.3614172041,
0.1753066033,
0.1779901236,
-0.5157662034,
-0.7538097501,
-0.5509648323,
-0.3409634233,
-0.1162608936,
-0.417852968,
0.4541890621,
0.6724650264,
-0.536473155,
-0.1494140923,
-0.4195235968,
-0.0110073891,
-0.1001378149,
-0.240753144,
-0.0891626254,
-0.2947123349,
-0.3410186172,
0.3452609777,
-0.2779565454,
-0.0270031411,
-0.3070531487,
0.2029226273,
-0.4294912219,
-0.2200570256,
0.4352020919,
0.2729312778,
-0.2137778848,
0.1320863217,
0.7124650478,
0.1774757951,
-0.1076499298,
0.9741895199,
-0.7720310092,
0.1763279587,
1.0056254864,
0.9855414033,
0.2631379962,
0.0106902216,
0.5573675632,
-0.7576771379,
-0.4961091876,
0.8311754465,
0.0044392198,
0.1257036477,
-0.3690856695,
0.1704368591,
-0.0078351647,
-0.5324406624,
-0.6558907032,
0.3948257864,
-0.6688171029,
-0.1329116523,
0.984806478,
0.1387243271,
-0.1701532751,
-0.0233709589,
0.0257663503,
0.3805850744,
0.0249814466,
0.6092598438,
0.5897801518,
-0.5686091185,
-0.3439587057,
-0.7394596934,
0.3977278471,
0.6188252568,
-0.9363715649,
-0.2839298546,
0.6351692677,
0.0360859372,
0.3004532754,
0.3377953768,
-0.3856417239,
0.5722593665,
0.1078180671,
0.3246543407,
-0.3605718911,
-0.1771621555,
-0.433345437,
0.7190092206,
0.0887767896,
-0.3193410337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18264v1
|
Retrieval-based Full-length Wikipedia Generation for Emergent Events
| 2024-02-28T11:51:56 | 2024-02-28T11:51:56 |
Jiebin Zhang, Eugene J. Yu, Qinyu Chen, Chenhao Xiong, Dawei Zhu, Han Qian, Mingbo Song, Xiaoguang Li, Qun Liu, Sujian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's fast-paced world, the growing demand to quickly generate
comprehensive and accurate Wikipedia documents for emerging events is both
crucial and challenging. However, previous efforts in Wikipedia generation have
often fallen short of meeting real-world requirements. Some approaches focus
solely on generating segments of a complete Wikipedia document, while others
overlook the importance of faithfulness in generation or fail to consider the
influence of the pre-training corpus. In this paper, we simulate a real-world
scenario where structured full-length Wikipedia documents are generated for
emergent events using input retrieved from web sources. To ensure that Large
Language Models (LLMs) are not trained on corpora related to recently occurred
events, we select events that have taken place recently and introduce a new
benchmark Wiki-GenBen, which consists of 309 events paired with their
corresponding retrieved web pages for generating evidence. Additionally, we
design a comprehensive set of systematic evaluation metrics and baseline
methods, to evaluate the capability of LLMs in generating factual full-length
Wikipedia documents. The data and code are open-sourced at WikiGenBench.
|
[
-0.4731716216,
-0.854326427,
0.6351472735,
0.2088491917,
-0.5743624568,
-0.1583566964,
-0.5893836021,
-0.6747054458,
0.4315217435,
0.1083644181,
-0.678805232,
-0.3031699061,
-0.0622447021,
0.2927557826,
-0.9836261272,
1.0658400059,
-0.065461643,
-0.2637761533,
-0.2294535488,
0.4297090173,
0.2727474868,
-0.1457467675,
-0.5654438734,
-0.1730951518,
0.6639044881,
0.5502887964,
0.3346742094,
0.4975306392,
0.2693967819,
0.0954548866,
-0.0525681861,
0.2663342655,
-0.7879955769,
0.3731726408,
-0.1729881018,
0.0987276062,
0.007240382,
0.0663668513,
0.9227494001,
0.5109026432,
-0.1721806377,
0.5494974256,
-0.0629137903,
0.1932952404,
-0.7610505223,
-0.1877161264,
-0.8665981889,
0.1575518548,
-0.5711440444,
-0.1277639121,
-0.4153746068,
-0.227290839,
0.0593849681,
-0.5396375656,
0.6252403855,
-0.1384640932,
1.068888545,
-0.255369693,
-0.1525026262,
-0.2202982605,
-0.8182983398,
0.2862755656,
-0.4976699054,
0.4223602712,
0.0022192327,
0.08877974,
-0.3793780208,
-1.0211855173,
-0.9413128495,
-0.4843487442,
0.3690637946,
0.1324197054,
-0.0120014129,
-0.2942183316,
0.3848432899,
0.1740721613,
-0.4678233862,
0.2679553628,
-0.3410379887,
0.0510542206,
0.5341970921,
0.1042885557,
0.2683059573,
-0.7094897032,
-0.2656511068,
-0.1612838656,
-0.9803457856,
-0.3395603001,
0.5358865261,
0.0946840569,
-0.0512550697,
0.7825995684,
-0.3942342401,
0.3708886802,
0.1722693443,
-0.0940582082,
0.1951377094,
-0.5338877439,
0.2353799939,
0.004152488,
0.9989511967,
0.3782012761,
0.5242048502,
-0.5259774923,
0.071231164,
-0.2404557467,
0.3424182832,
-0.9574565887,
-0.0882693678,
0.124324128,
-0.1927141249,
-0.5317713618,
0.135406509,
-0.9858993292,
-0.1790669858,
-0.097762607,
0.2423927039,
-0.4785647988,
-0.2368333042,
-0.5764921904,
-0.3221923113,
0.3165952265,
0.1524997652,
-0.5476329327,
-0.3301809728,
0.4724742174,
0.8214372396,
-0.3555501699,
-0.3878520131,
-0.6620433927,
0.4393025041,
-0.5782940388,
0.8177319169,
-0.1787434071,
-0.4698657691,
0.1962885112,
-0.1582830846,
0.3896335363,
-0.4567094445,
0.7890889645,
-0.7315468788,
-0.1437447667,
-0.0876215547,
-0.520721674,
0.5705804825,
0.185938254,
-0.6542674303,
0.9736938477,
-0.1837492287,
-1.0864797831,
0.6530202031,
-0.2734205723,
-0.7307500839,
0.1477581263,
-0.3417984545,
-0.4433348179,
0.1128385738,
-0.0615170486,
0.2182174027,
-0.1973132342,
0.5108728409,
-0.4087566733,
-0.2377282828,
0.2384357303,
-0.5945693851,
0.4551973343,
-0.0002937928,
-0.5183353424,
-0.1045133248,
-1.1746011972,
-0.0040107444,
0.2517784536,
-0.580370307,
-0.1362095624,
0.357596308,
0.1503691375,
0.2670090199,
0.3380921483,
-0.9024164677,
-0.0101412367,
-0.3521572053,
-0.2219821215,
0.6971856952,
0.3886821866,
0.2883653045,
0.0257176179,
0.1747108549,
0.1001975015,
0.2311444283,
-0.1202321276,
-0.3268743157,
-0.8398041129,
-0.0771406963,
0.4151107967,
0.3102328777,
-0.9710604548,
0.448862195,
-0.7753038406,
-0.653568089,
-0.116251111,
0.3253399432,
0.1469548494,
0.5558638573,
0.1043538526,
-0.1350203305,
-0.8276288509,
-0.7584565282,
0.0118151503,
-0.2334372401,
-0.4466665983,
-0.0214052945,
0.4629570544,
-0.1377120316,
0.8175773025,
-0.3907959163,
0.2768451273,
0.010950828,
0.2618810236,
-0.0621152706,
0.077252984,
0.3505620658,
-0.6914260983,
-0.4442077279,
-0.1517699957,
-0.7247125506,
0.0077189654,
-0.0225198772,
-0.3463175893,
0.2139697224,
0.3595799208,
-0.7759072185,
0.4325788319,
0.1901425719,
-0.0611460581,
0.7866329551,
-0.1481286287,
-0.0300322268,
-1.1061012745,
0.339702338,
-0.3173997402,
-0.0104621425,
-0.5123972893,
0.1628703922,
0.3162706196,
-0.1775249839,
-0.3710124791,
0.5241268873,
-0.4167999625,
-0.0677735507,
-0.2579979599,
0.4224177897,
-0.1634655446,
0.0589282364,
0.110660553,
0.5702432394,
0.1302194297,
-0.7045365572,
0.4821722806,
0.2135661542,
-0.6018692851,
0.2583007514,
-0.211212948,
-0.1140687913,
-0.2233090252,
0.3532197475,
-0.4471472502,
-0.59144032,
0.0320952833,
-0.5029705763,
0.4090983868,
0.0426634364,
-0.8031527996,
-0.5702638626,
-0.4775635898,
-0.1066465527,
0.4778838158,
-0.6901473999,
0.3007606566,
0.0942981392,
-0.3364711702,
-0.5840144753,
-0.2265397161,
0.2613060772,
-0.0067889937,
-0.6913917661,
0.33531636,
-0.1032657921,
-0.1879332811,
0.1110965237,
-0.2265536785,
0.1201902926,
0.0056745345,
0.1875554472,
0.2807454169,
-0.1284667701,
-0.0472818762,
-0.0192471929,
0.2534048855,
0.05789949,
-0.28047207,
0.4289894998,
0.4711130261,
-0.3839282393,
-0.1741717607,
0.4740308821,
0.4338816404,
-0.2288225889,
0.8898984194,
0.8107168078,
-0.276293695,
-0.3222350478,
-0.8596614003,
-0.0555732399,
-0.3607285917,
0.3592340946,
-0.1277090907,
-0.5620443821,
0.4229272604,
0.0178907309,
0.3053653538,
0.5630351901,
0.6297984719,
-0.2735683024,
0.6701779962,
0.073273994,
0.2027009279,
0.7050015926,
0.0302515253,
-0.0046505486,
-0.7348306775,
-0.410272181,
-0.5567995906,
0.0397541486,
-0.3656335175,
-0.5083198547,
0.3695575595,
0.2161988467,
-0.1809606105,
0.0947020128,
0.0731941909,
0.3938689828,
0.6105633974,
0.0535900779,
0.3147076964,
0.475541085,
-0.328781575,
0.1182483286,
-0.616219461,
-0.3683179319,
1.2610818148,
-0.361131072,
0.5271676779,
0.1686775982,
0.7305193543,
0.2018114775,
0.5829867125,
-0.2660154998,
0.4991631806,
-0.0571488775,
-0.8020378351,
-0.5100251436,
-0.7992355227,
-1.0958935022,
-0.0186744072,
-0.3392279148,
-0.479244113,
-0.0054318518,
-0.2427993566,
-0.0092249606,
0.3624667227,
-0.3123752773,
0.5187039375,
-0.2891593575,
-0.3644413054,
-0.2239158899,
-0.438205868,
0.5172900558,
-0.4879893661,
0.3296185136,
-0.2345733941,
0.0816923976,
0.6187466383,
-0.2379411161,
0.5848872662,
-0.0232643429,
-0.0889097303,
0.554438889,
0.1052710712,
0.5768198967,
0.2633634806,
-0.1501204222,
-0.1361690611,
-0.2819463015,
-0.3135459423,
-0.2165049762,
0.8142040372,
-0.827814579,
-0.4454763234,
0.0896510258,
0.003858713,
-0.2971693277,
0.2756613195,
0.6596002579,
0.4142170548,
-0.7498592734,
0.1654292196,
0.7850676775,
-0.1995744258,
0.5072247386,
0.6759346128,
-0.1861379445,
-0.449387908,
0.8571271896,
0.267424196,
0.0954492018,
0.3820432425,
-0.2069354206,
-0.2061223686,
-0.4846210182,
-0.7509471178,
0.2118845433,
-0.6680150032,
-0.3630653918,
-0.5201615095,
-0.394077003,
-0.4844641685,
0.0273698531,
-0.1144844592,
-0.4067608714,
-0.3170313835,
-0.3693302274,
0.1074379086,
0.5159699321,
-0.3711314201,
-0.1113533452,
-0.8997652531,
0.5820293427,
0.239441216,
0.44813779,
0.335205853,
-0.3398139775,
-0.3173171282,
-0.1163816974,
-0.392228663,
-0.9796883464,
-0.0226451866,
0.3743962049,
0.7387059927,
0.6340384483,
0.2353349924,
0.5716267228,
-0.9992377758,
0.6959371567,
0.3506851196,
-0.4184344709,
0.7078692913,
-0.3371876776,
0.1858871281,
0.4464939535,
0.5006884336,
-0.3477138281,
-0.4710821807,
-0.8873496652,
-1.0404976606,
0.430839479,
0.4157381654,
0.2912098467,
-0.4854289591,
0.5926536918,
0.0416180007,
0.1025710776,
-0.513590157,
-0.0351556689,
0.0206486583,
-0.0962552279,
-0.0305543598,
-0.413754195,
-0.050950475,
0.0350261703,
0.782836616,
0.0871345326,
-0.1321365386,
0.2254884243,
-0.2567816675,
-0.2825124264,
0.2258743495,
0.4014017284,
0.8357970119,
-0.2019504905,
0.009638126,
0.2332781255,
-0.5448336005,
0.1262798011,
0.4007563591,
-0.6209260225,
0.4853655398,
0.4240022302,
0.5636337399,
0.4770492017,
-1.0136806965,
0.6514604092,
0.0196144953,
0.0327050872,
-0.7238305211,
-0.0077633951,
0.270598948,
0.154351905,
0.7619417906,
-0.6927676797,
-0.0555407256,
-0.504491508,
0.36542207,
0.3865945339,
0.0458471738,
-0.2440922707,
0.5925945044,
0.3836877644,
0.0331211053,
0.9585610628,
-0.3605750501,
-0.0968731791,
0.5039514303,
0.3601402342,
0.4559292197,
0.0199610144,
0.1759963781,
0.5778761506,
0.3133480549,
0.2222163528,
0.0456228592,
-0.1432347149,
-0.6219110489,
-0.5865379572,
-1.2808759212,
-0.3760928214,
0.2771974802,
-0.554377377,
0.2633849084,
-0.1225267872,
-0.3523618877,
-0.0419508778,
0.0480706617,
-0.5683005452,
0.0412053727,
0.4566258788,
1.3217452765,
-0.6185880899,
0.6242769957,
0.4790951312,
-0.5641522408,
-0.4625042379,
0.2543667257,
-0.2688821554,
-0.2020794898,
0.3585542738,
-0.2176721841,
0.3109182119,
-0.1177959591,
-0.4804448485,
-0.7573361993,
0.9050351381,
0.382386297,
-0.5456228256,
-0.6360781789,
0.0394068621,
0.4747467041,
0.0774769038,
-0.1141002327,
0.1671473384,
0.43678689,
0.2571544349,
-0.8576512337,
-0.1765734404,
-0.0771905631,
-0.0585356243,
0.2456859946,
-0.522946775,
0.4913981259,
-0.074789837,
-0.4634930193,
0.299089551,
0.9865299463,
0.4998703897,
0.1004395634,
0.3828184605,
0.5072767735,
0.8066369891,
0.0761289671,
1.0046311617,
-0.250402987,
0.1471398026,
1.1079093218,
-0.3089535236,
1.093113184,
0.3853852749,
-0.0545562208,
0.5298386216,
0.5517737269,
-0.11288964,
0.3924653828,
0.3018917441,
-0.6004844308,
-0.3406429589,
0.0184664689,
-0.4194696844,
0.348210007,
0.225155741,
-0.3092619479,
-0.6027296185,
-0.0761963949,
0.054635901,
-0.2186496705,
-0.3211638927,
0.7685867548,
0.0213228427,
-0.815934062,
0.166959554,
0.1380689293,
0.5868153572,
-0.7995347381,
0.1374501735,
-0.3092153072,
-0.0630907714,
-0.0513969176,
-0.6323387623,
0.0150853163,
0.64443928,
-0.3746884465,
0.2434244454,
0.7026886344,
-0.2885628641,
-0.6359268427,
0.1192526966,
0.5723823905,
0.2450047284,
0.0620778166,
-0.0572231002,
0.0455907285,
-0.0707548708,
-0.5620743036,
0.5088331699,
0.6990157366,
-0.1077526137,
0.3014834225,
0.9087691903,
0.2417961061,
0.4263306856,
0.0598655641,
0.7698353529,
-0.459889859,
-0.3067652285,
-0.706664443,
0.1478686184,
-0.6054811478,
-0.1632359624,
0.7225833535,
0.8801863194,
0.8741565943,
-0.0023940424,
0.7860680819,
-0.2817344069,
0.3959294558,
-0.3557213545,
0.765658021,
-0.4193302989,
-0.2645082176,
-0.0986510888,
-0.8373039365,
0.1291646212,
0.1255302876,
0.2473319918,
-0.2713452578,
0.3402792215,
0.3019604087,
-0.1121269614,
0.0164819714,
0.1842317879,
0.2652531266,
0.2673349679,
0.2128841579,
0.9874032736,
0.1482396573,
1.0845353603,
-0.0288734511,
-0.0868557394,
-0.376090318,
-0.8582308292,
-0.6203881502,
-0.6334232688,
-0.013577316,
-0.4399015009,
0.0903865546,
0.6468614936,
0.4061742425,
-0.6295695305,
0.0635562688,
0.132558167,
-0.1789833754,
0.3914165795,
-0.2333823889,
0.370732069,
-0.4579544663,
-0.5506324172,
0.5139958858,
-0.0409956425,
0.0377178453,
-0.3367651999,
0.1002847105,
-0.2798763216,
0.115748167,
0.5328413248,
0.3429545164,
-0.4168870747,
-0.4378891289,
-0.1771261692,
-0.2191359103,
-0.2111920118,
0.5159902573,
-0.7000218034,
0.1706629843,
0.4623501897,
0.5844447017,
1.0279717445,
-0.2035192996,
0.5216774344,
-0.9824924469,
-0.0642657429,
0.0170313902,
0.3389958441,
0.3483423293,
-0.1442772448,
0.4774750173,
0.3474033773,
-0.2063693702,
-0.8680925965,
0.2901840806,
-0.5302449465,
-0.3222102225,
1.1595263481,
-0.0631237552,
-0.1635778844,
0.1433849186,
0.3728329837,
0.6846659184,
-0.01742924,
0.8856258392,
0.7858766913,
-0.0087610129,
0.1796489656,
-0.5139449239,
0.2661658823,
-0.3214731812,
-0.6990656257,
0.0774526298,
0.8165178299,
0.6257245541,
0.4288100302,
0.4920179546,
0.029148601,
0.5008000731,
0.2532830238,
0.203259334,
0.0297975596,
-0.4378694594,
0.3052742779,
0.4264023602,
-0.0042872764,
0.3110770285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18262v1
|
Hierarchical Multimodal Pre-training for Visually Rich Webpage Understanding
| 2024-02-28T11:50:36 | 2024-02-28T11:50:36 |
Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Zihan Zhao, Da Ma, Ruisheng Cao, Zichen Zhu, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The growing prevalence of visually rich documents, such as webpages and
scanned/digital-born documents (images, PDFs, etc.), has led to increased
interest in automatic document understanding and information extraction across
academia and industry. Although various document modalities, including image,
text, layout, and structure, facilitate human information retrieval, the
interconnected nature of these modalities presents challenges for neural
networks. In this paper, we introduce WebLM, a multimodal pre-training network
designed to address the limitations of solely modeling text and structure
modalities of HTML in webpages. Instead of processing document images as
unified natural images, WebLM integrates the hierarchical structure of document
images to enhance the understanding of markup-language-based documents.
Additionally, we propose several pre-training tasks to model the interaction
among text, structure, and image modalities effectively. Empirical results
demonstrate that the pre-trained WebLM significantly surpasses previous
state-of-the-art pre-trained models across several webpage understanding tasks.
The pre-trained models and code are available at
https://github.com/X-LANCE/weblm.
|
[
-0.45179829,
-0.5383064151,
0.3258190751,
0.2852535546,
-0.5212808847,
-0.0100399712,
-0.0534491763,
-0.4626241028,
-0.1639664173,
0.1517245471,
-0.5864343643,
-0.4583472013,
-0.5794820189,
-0.1034543365,
-0.2890045643,
0.8294510841,
0.2216824889,
0.2656449676,
-0.5930202007,
0.0529062599,
0.1306606233,
-0.4173440635,
-0.3167981505,
-0.2384578884,
0.990965426,
-0.066907391,
0.6242364645,
0.392608583,
0.5973380804,
0.4008558095,
0.1777733117,
0.202093035,
-0.302932322,
-0.0655781925,
-0.0226574037,
-0.3390319347,
-0.576551795,
0.04081681,
0.5538603067,
0.8754713535,
0.0911006033,
0.0552759655,
0.2697890997,
0.4190027714,
-0.8756067753,
0.3009043336,
-0.6266576648,
0.1748222709,
-0.2315105796,
-0.4064567089,
-0.4813354015,
0.1127429008,
0.1508056819,
-1.1769689322,
0.4585391283,
0.014726501,
1.1341667175,
0.136561349,
-0.5912110209,
-0.0395656899,
-0.3832729459,
0.6447582245,
-0.3276807368,
0.9387353659,
0.8555939198,
0.0111511638,
0.1354759932,
-0.9655439854,
-0.7719806433,
-0.0145063624,
-0.1672275364,
0.3845733702,
-0.1780438125,
0.1248880625,
-0.0184072182,
0.1231794655,
-0.8734181523,
0.2325181067,
-0.1850180626,
-0.2556654811,
0.17901057,
-0.0472028181,
0.3885362148,
-0.3336623013,
-0.5366795063,
-0.2533680201,
-0.1244768351,
-0.1833061874,
0.1287338138,
0.0975169912,
-0.080236651,
0.1275611073,
0.062894538,
0.7988985777,
-0.1742567867,
-0.2270682901,
0.3099747002,
-0.5591996908,
-0.2782045007,
-0.3797696233,
0.6493079662,
0.1931343824,
0.1803183854,
-0.1924612075,
-0.3047499061,
0.0608280897,
0.5294173956,
-0.7566490173,
-0.4131974578,
-0.1225490943,
-0.8506336212,
-0.1623028517,
0.1938606948,
-0.685923934,
-0.3667037487,
-0.5988030434,
0.5668441653,
-0.4157999456,
-0.304689765,
-0.1679439247,
-0.3258680105,
0.2304068804,
0.7641742229,
-0.7873319983,
0.2033536136,
0.1887755245,
0.5410925746,
-0.0968147218,
-0.6365032196,
-0.5002522469,
0.3552926779,
-0.1798755825,
0.778750062,
-0.460134685,
-0.3084315062,
0.0390841886,
-0.2440454662,
-0.2322214842,
-0.3306747079,
0.3470923305,
-0.8239777088,
0.2941384315,
0.2882501781,
-0.145429939,
-0.1601973474,
0.6894057989,
-0.7024267912,
0.519661963,
-0.0761597231,
-0.8549364805,
0.2800861001,
-0.5661183596,
-0.6784485579,
0.0163188074,
-0.1390471309,
-0.4523155689,
0.0934482217,
0.3399990797,
0.430847019,
-0.0269025154,
-0.1369235516,
-0.3639208674,
-0.1047012061,
0.1284994185,
-0.664853096,
0.5367840528,
0.2530599833,
0.0007704608,
0.4962276816,
-1.0222324133,
0.1553499699,
0.2843741179,
-0.6594039202,
-0.451452136,
-0.2545833886,
0.7694414854,
0.3200760484,
0.3153716922,
-0.1920655668,
0.0936450586,
0.1536213309,
0.1369086355,
0.7135214806,
-0.2606268823,
0.51655972,
-0.0956754982,
0.3935928643,
0.0755247027,
0.4540352821,
-0.4722105265,
-0.154892236,
-0.7260608673,
-0.3818261325,
0.2403777838,
0.3843043447,
-0.8888708353,
0.2956556678,
-0.2762784362,
-0.1288599074,
-0.0962489769,
0.325049758,
0.6640919447,
0.6096273661,
0.5457190275,
-0.4734970927,
-0.562061429,
-0.6970793009,
-0.0598513708,
0.0086487606,
0.0105332118,
0.1852518618,
0.4791689515,
-0.6172899008,
0.9042865634,
-0.3093283474,
-0.4938477576,
-0.2404675335,
0.6911675334,
-0.1634453237,
0.5949978828,
0.1618774533,
-1.4959744215,
-0.4453414381,
0.0384359434,
-0.7688875198,
0.175486356,
-0.2659524083,
0.0570718944,
-0.2050421536,
0.3332771063,
-0.5969400406,
0.5046820641,
0.4417131841,
-0.1530811489,
0.4634090066,
-0.4227294326,
-0.049657058,
-1.0631177425,
0.0586318672,
0.3718571663,
-0.3298579454,
-0.6339173317,
0.1640035063,
0.563034296,
-0.3238143921,
-0.4597959518,
0.4983923435,
-0.8525692821,
-0.5017807484,
-0.0108106714,
0.139010936,
0.5736064315,
0.6379116774,
0.0476349927,
0.5178591609,
0.283919543,
-0.5744432807,
-0.01348799,
0.4201483428,
-0.1255901754,
0.5856556296,
-0.2868767381,
0.0863460526,
-0.2644981146,
0.4347197711,
-0.903596282,
-0.2498776019,
-0.0856163204,
-0.3791439235,
0.4813723266,
-0.1108096167,
-0.5076982379,
-0.3838478327,
-0.2472049743,
0.3375334442,
0.1266745329,
-0.4787255824,
0.9171802998,
0.0557519756,
-0.006077148,
-0.5879727602,
-0.5266960263,
0.0857867748,
0.2736935616,
-0.646391511,
0.5804048777,
-0.0920563489,
-0.1410237551,
0.0954551995,
-0.1011995524,
-0.6458091736,
0.4167712331,
0.3337650895,
0.3138487339,
-0.1725472212,
0.1990917027,
-0.1920795143,
-0.0337734111,
-0.24655509,
-0.4567413926,
0.6822333336,
-0.2353368402,
-0.6309543252,
-0.8023350239,
0.2854293287,
0.6562640667,
-0.79986763,
0.4392444789,
0.9768535495,
-0.4031325877,
0.1042710692,
-0.338055253,
0.0282632783,
-0.4590347707,
0.5342552662,
-0.4108650386,
-0.4100358784,
0.2764269114,
-0.1291279346,
-0.0562586114,
0.3931713104,
0.257163763,
-0.7205973864,
1.0340301991,
0.7540895939,
0.2338276654,
0.8123720288,
-0.3965345025,
-0.2060020566,
-0.710534513,
-0.56271559,
-0.3443854153,
-0.3585655093,
-0.004785561,
-0.5808666348,
0.3287250102,
0.4977852404,
0.0407096259,
-0.019251626,
-0.0785854757,
0.3129910827,
0.5778160095,
0.2885192931,
0.3420110643,
0.0618159808,
-0.3343282938,
0.3246299028,
-0.6220750809,
-0.1667856723,
0.7596043944,
0.1855920255,
1.0714039803,
0.0104599409,
0.5613626242,
0.2694494426,
0.3113390505,
-0.6149071455,
0.3794046044,
-0.1939953864,
-0.3430184722,
-0.2953878641,
-0.3440957367,
-1.325712204,
0.6161941886,
-0.6446722746,
-0.340988785,
0.300722599,
0.2083450556,
-0.1146042719,
0.1229151338,
-0.7326235771,
1.0491017103,
-0.7396062016,
-0.4865127802,
-0.3550973535,
-0.7871602178,
-0.077412352,
0.0088697523,
0.3628336191,
0.2920769453,
-0.052203998,
0.4509775937,
-0.2249350548,
0.8826099634,
-0.0256953761,
0.0501270145,
-0.1693438739,
-0.0396753438,
0.3119818866,
-0.2175484598,
0.1791327596,
0.1321423054,
-0.2350972742,
-0.6141624451,
-0.6898077726,
0.2202993631,
-0.9387905598,
-0.3844804168,
-0.3251034617,
-0.6006461382,
-0.2900105715,
0.6258354783,
0.3432728052,
0.9931333065,
-0.2099344134,
0.3666468859,
0.6505566239,
-0.1316689998,
0.6921073198,
0.2622270882,
-0.3744825721,
-0.3693729639,
0.8907191157,
-0.1190027967,
0.0063941926,
0.6485008001,
0.1411341876,
-0.4876190722,
-0.7761873603,
-0.5058152676,
-0.1157016978,
-0.9441481829,
-0.0368121266,
-0.8107676506,
-0.216630131,
-0.4561278224,
-0.1117708385,
-0.0212739669,
-0.1716690063,
-0.7192710638,
0.1532940418,
-0.259952426,
0.9181206822,
0.146985516,
0.2564419508,
-1.164812088,
0.583088398,
0.6343877912,
0.3347373605,
0.2695376575,
-0.2404693812,
-0.3793037534,
-0.1587647647,
-0.3335629404,
-0.7287563086,
0.3902688026,
0.3857282996,
0.9606000185,
0.6612381339,
-0.2736450434,
0.8201233149,
-0.3945201635,
0.4800502956,
0.7298035622,
-0.6744663715,
0.5153236985,
-0.624114573,
0.591416657,
0.4283520579,
0.7975558043,
-0.2710911036,
0.2557646632,
-0.3434163332,
-0.5351434946,
0.4118411839,
0.1159000993,
0.1309196353,
0.2227921188,
-0.0260993689,
0.1108888835,
0.2311537266,
-0.9231410027,
0.1753334105,
-0.7736794949,
-0.3627867103,
-0.0244928561,
-0.0335390233,
-0.0597412996,
-0.3202250302,
0.1439639032,
-0.4066432118,
-0.0506397262,
0.1578639746,
-1.0509109497,
0.153522253,
0.2286040038,
0.6209942102,
0.9984859228,
-0.0386470035,
0.6259689331,
-0.2292775959,
-0.6431765556,
-0.0271344148,
0.2737164497,
0.1834466457,
-0.3012019098,
0.8502037525,
0.8888350725,
0.3621285856,
-0.4347678423,
0.6078334451,
-0.3874208331,
-0.2793028355,
-0.0864482671,
-0.2736660838,
-0.0671772361,
0.1875420213,
0.6857543588,
0.1978047192,
0.0978338569,
-0.740873456,
0.390014112,
0.4695610404,
-0.4276126325,
-0.3588895202,
0.5402947068,
0.5083112717,
-0.4477721453,
0.7019104362,
-0.1054040343,
-0.7647268772,
0.3811907768,
0.8293317556,
0.5175312161,
0.105101645,
0.2483233362,
-0.0472191423,
0.0254037939,
0.4052514434,
0.1355973929,
-0.4551253617,
-0.7016791701,
-0.1029441431,
-0.8265031576,
-0.1469351947,
-0.058584597,
-0.4633845091,
-0.1415550411,
-0.5828853846,
-0.2209894657,
-0.0373699069,
-0.1036040634,
-0.8520880938,
0.5337969661,
0.4289442301,
0.7454560995,
-0.4925332367,
1.0168085098,
0.7225748301,
-0.6467608213,
-0.4475369751,
0.3018666804,
0.0435120128,
-0.4913529754,
1.0221889019,
0.2856123447,
-0.155071646,
0.2233499885,
-0.1128070056,
-0.704369247,
0.978921771,
0.0893251151,
-0.4329602122,
-0.3091186583,
-0.1993325651,
0.4202362895,
-0.0647145063,
0.352922976,
-0.3678950667,
0.4866166711,
-0.137934953,
-0.8446466923,
-0.3729154468,
-0.6452774405,
0.1746326983,
-0.1070610434,
-0.3538268209,
1.1953371763,
-0.0006547729,
-0.0817351565,
-0.1161906272,
0.6171943545,
-0.0906989276,
0.1805219948,
0.9635418653,
0.6175429225,
0.9181959033,
0.192273885,
1.1582844257,
0.0533712506,
0.0952058733,
1.1326036453,
-0.1140778288,
0.7883894444,
0.3046002984,
0.055652298,
0.7164005041,
0.7136492729,
0.0865936801,
0.507668376,
-0.0438340418,
-0.2230856121,
-0.5758242607,
-0.1731200516,
-0.3553202748,
0.6134232283,
0.3141630292,
-0.2781246305,
-0.4367854595,
0.2927308083,
-0.4965109527,
0.0930470377,
-0.5049035549,
0.847971499,
-0.0297368113,
-0.2838436365,
0.4887111485,
-0.1268595904,
0.6973081827,
-0.9010264874,
-0.0152726769,
0.0050676716,
0.0890235156,
-0.4176485837,
-0.6127138138,
-0.091656819,
-0.2072016001,
-0.3972327113,
-0.4881571233,
1.1921231747,
-0.2632501423,
-0.3060244918,
0.55869174,
0.6506446004,
-0.2117064297,
-0.2043070197,
-0.8258190155,
0.0921347737,
-0.3019291759,
-0.3352690339,
0.6939208508,
0.3297409117,
-0.1448299736,
0.5448325872,
1.0475305319,
-0.328602016,
0.3918283582,
0.5263316631,
0.9625832438,
-0.3208796978,
-0.6804430485,
-0.7368353605,
0.473695904,
-0.3093812466,
-0.1806028485,
0.6311736107,
0.566042304,
0.7889516354,
-0.1273448765,
0.6376134157,
0.2999990582,
-0.3470095694,
-0.548412323,
1.1814519167,
-1.0286514759,
-0.4948584735,
-0.334243536,
-1.0556646585,
-0.5060750246,
0.7877932787,
0.0007581864,
-0.0559584387,
0.6716622114,
0.4119186401,
-0.3319696188,
-0.1163402051,
0.5010967255,
-0.0174370222,
0.1809502542,
0.0650542304,
0.9170675874,
0.0397235602,
0.7838606834,
-0.1967190206,
-0.1963051558,
-0.2471835762,
-0.8779379129,
-0.9062157869,
-0.803794682,
0.1854664683,
-0.0643845946,
-0.0691538453,
0.7942547798,
1.2758296728,
-0.3122279048,
0.0043312591,
-0.0234100483,
0.1096896976,
-0.0562050603,
-0.0900752023,
0.2239595056,
-0.4346092343,
-0.4417357445,
0.3802117407,
0.434173584,
0.3223818243,
-0.3403433263,
-0.0586927608,
-0.7469061017,
-0.1680448353,
0.7376292348,
0.0695558488,
-0.5637214184,
-0.0205196813,
-0.1039629281,
-0.4612235427,
0.3811289668,
0.8024358153,
-0.5247974992,
0.5420798063,
0.569435358,
0.9351117015,
0.715667665,
0.1020880938,
0.25189358,
-0.9347172976,
0.334482193,
0.1992536336,
0.6384000778,
0.3942097425,
-0.2157047987,
0.2782318592,
0.379201889,
-0.0584703125,
-0.3745369017,
0.2513967156,
-1.1126990318,
-0.7908002138,
0.6676384807,
-0.3378287554,
-0.2336642742,
-0.201529488,
-0.1359245926,
0.4715887904,
0.000947901,
0.3485813737,
0.2285039127,
-0.0291318148,
-0.5616670847,
-0.1663797945,
0.1958791614,
0.3058992922,
-1.1400911808,
-0.3610373735,
0.5591167212,
-0.1301854402,
0.5362905264,
0.7324927449,
0.1629872918,
0.3284188509,
0.0615845621,
0.2063921988,
-0.3405465484,
-0.7232960463,
-0.1806468666,
0.3962991238,
-0.0867096409,
-0.2150607407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18258v1
|
A BiRGAT Model for Multi-intent Spoken Language Understanding with Hierarchical Semantic Frames
| 2024-02-28T11:39:26 | 2024-02-28T11:39:26 |
Hongshen Xu, Ruisheng Cao, Su Zhu, Sheng Jiang, Hanchong Zhang, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work on spoken language understanding (SLU) mainly focuses on
single-intent settings, where each input utterance merely contains one user
intent. This configuration significantly limits the surface form of user
utterances and the capacity of output semantics. In this work, we first propose
a Multi-Intent dataset which is collected from a realistic in-Vehicle dialogue
System, called MIVS. The target semantic frame is organized in a 3-layer
hierarchical structure to tackle the alignment and assignment problems in
multi-intent cases. Accordingly, we devise a BiRGAT model to encode the
hierarchy of ontology items, the backbone of which is a dual relational graph
attention network. Coupled with the 3-way pointer-generator decoder, our method
outperforms traditional sequence labeling and classification-based schemes by a
large margin.
|
[
-0.068118684,
-0.6912642717,
0.5084058642,
0.2013318837,
-0.0873144567,
-0.2003305405,
-0.1308110207,
-0.2293815464,
-0.170737654,
0.6841681004,
-0.7402490377,
-0.4263366461,
-0.4116935432,
-0.2163825482,
-0.121325776,
1.1582666636,
0.2758461237,
0.0832435712,
0.0669120103,
-0.2794386744,
-0.5519731641,
-0.2430250198,
-0.4464455545,
-0.2533854842,
0.5285277367,
0.6595788598,
0.8521006703,
0.3609509468,
0.5434247851,
0.21428141,
-0.0019858477,
0.2016876787,
-0.6299268603,
0.0517353155,
-0.3132933974,
-0.0340867676,
-0.6079742908,
-0.1920927763,
0.8979513645,
0.8474559784,
-0.2968568206,
0.0346404687,
0.0479124188,
0.3008849919,
-0.5542920232,
0.4620934129,
-0.4530839026,
-0.3149005175,
-0.0208936576,
-0.210953474,
-0.7639295459,
0.1114107966,
0.3872877359,
-0.8752272129,
-0.0836784542,
0.1865066737,
0.9313153625,
0.4308218062,
-0.3632070422,
-0.3916020691,
-0.8924211264,
0.6117386222,
-0.5195782781,
0.6162186265,
0.4382788539,
0.2116313577,
-0.0418141112,
-0.7037059069,
-0.6205695868,
0.0561097264,
-0.304353267,
0.224727124,
-0.3011636734,
0.259577781,
-0.0363931283,
0.1391622871,
-0.9397377968,
-0.0983243659,
-0.1844092607,
0.0927784219,
0.2472527921,
0.2632451952,
0.3868589103,
-0.3774072528,
-0.8471137881,
-0.0168600492,
-0.6535726786,
0.094005838,
-0.0086655021,
0.5260204077,
-0.058141917,
0.7085838318,
-0.1522225738,
0.9550027251,
-0.026438823,
-0.1656272411,
0.0879514515,
-0.8776535392,
-0.4470826983,
0.2341297716,
0.7650372386,
0.1986198276,
0.0531355552,
-0.2569975853,
0.143538326,
-0.1826544851,
0.290045321,
-0.5595320463,
0.0081218183,
0.110173218,
-0.3542129099,
0.0321303681,
-0.0444025137,
-0.4171620309,
-0.0182796177,
-0.2498565018,
0.3776447177,
-0.6364825368,
-0.1926004142,
0.6104364991,
0.1575881094,
0.5971307755,
0.1230225489,
-1.1251062155,
0.2927967012,
0.5296056271,
0.606104672,
0.2896927595,
-0.4832510054,
-0.5551776886,
0.7372923493,
-0.0892179534,
0.8117325306,
-0.532158196,
-0.1829073578,
-0.2905581295,
-0.2613777816,
-0.3470378816,
0.1703611314,
0.489046365,
-0.6685813665,
0.3087009788,
0.1000655368,
-0.2888935804,
-0.5186907649,
0.2598402798,
-0.189695105,
0.856560111,
0.2210597843,
-0.7902992964,
0.1595074385,
-0.8676786423,
-0.4561189711,
0.3401528299,
-0.1728006005,
-0.1811984479,
-0.0277314242,
0.0581967346,
0.414041698,
-0.2313772738,
0.395955056,
-0.2038009465,
-0.2108510584,
0.1116221696,
-0.4556488991,
0.7364044785,
-0.0373503566,
-0.1554206014,
0.2788462043,
-0.5318086743,
0.002190246,
-0.0569956414,
-0.3537677824,
-0.5391833782,
-0.009637651,
0.0276092775,
0.3628765941,
0.1093634516,
-0.670350492,
0.1545145959,
-0.5592961311,
0.2322505265,
0.5337635875,
-0.0413195193,
0.4673479497,
0.0542878024,
0.2309190482,
0.0304526109,
0.2249357551,
-0.1443600059,
-0.6681727767,
-0.7216190696,
-0.1168376952,
-0.0623445734,
0.6711365581,
-0.6124309897,
0.3643169701,
-0.7420479059,
-0.0242576469,
-0.512239635,
-0.1453834921,
0.7116987705,
0.402969569,
0.2611211836,
-0.1783377677,
-0.1991976202,
-1.033059001,
-0.07399261,
-0.4887935519,
0.1368048489,
0.4827765822,
0.269043684,
-0.3977811933,
1.0025751591,
-0.4830318093,
-0.3866325319,
-0.3900070488,
0.0690650865,
0.0482422449,
0.0961038023,
0.2232523859,
-0.8545398712,
-0.396900773,
0.4814134538,
-0.6793284416,
0.2338973135,
-0.0422056839,
-0.3129446507,
-0.2865378261,
0.1978706867,
-0.6784130931,
0.6115678549,
0.5132057071,
-0.4828386903,
0.2157921493,
-0.2431460321,
-0.0308424141,
-1.1008002758,
-0.1341473907,
-0.3025071323,
-0.2263148129,
-1.1095210314,
-0.391025573,
0.0666246191,
-0.0704788491,
-0.5091648698,
0.3050260246,
-0.4125292301,
-0.383923769,
-0.1366776079,
0.4460986555,
0.3694925904,
0.870726943,
0.161565125,
0.6291324496,
0.4799625874,
-0.4772731662,
0.1713463366,
0.8171733618,
-0.4565806687,
0.4585447013,
-0.5550193191,
0.2379508913,
-0.3689037263,
0.2139115632,
-1.3174664974,
-0.342764914,
0.3917745054,
-0.4671339989,
0.3539316952,
-0.346776545,
-0.2617264092,
0.0722292364,
0.1296341121,
0.3756125271,
-0.0130169271,
-0.4422125816,
0.7563331723,
0.6014718413,
-0.4228126109,
-0.7740121484,
-0.6416716576,
0.033013843,
-0.0228673723,
-1.0334243774,
0.2556993067,
0.186261788,
-0.0651256815,
0.0797409117,
0.0639513433,
0.0205714274,
-0.1330583543,
0.3172151744,
0.4073583782,
-0.4541267455,
0.2871971428,
0.0554163978,
-0.2938632369,
-0.1444991231,
-0.549233973,
0.4900070727,
-0.4994657636,
-0.4261399508,
-0.7049750686,
0.734823525,
0.6779036522,
-0.4229675531,
0.7637870908,
0.5038287044,
-0.2065310627,
0.0421683155,
-0.0240064263,
0.1391317397,
-0.3790619373,
0.464579016,
-0.5724095106,
-0.8819433451,
0.0822816789,
0.1478316784,
0.2850260437,
0.1683481038,
0.936509788,
-0.1672758609,
1.0801471472,
0.4841991365,
0.2452583462,
0.2925167084,
-0.2673233449,
0.7612799406,
-1.0199998617,
-0.4736759067,
-0.4753768444,
0.0175405089,
-0.2382253706,
-0.4437164664,
0.5146970749,
-0.0295847673,
-0.0843063071,
0.4211131334,
-0.3567496538,
0.2701546848,
0.2729749978,
-0.0971922353,
0.4384328723,
0.0153151974,
0.1107211486,
0.2902238071,
-0.9057934284,
-0.6010754108,
0.6039326787,
0.3408989906,
0.8752721548,
0.6625475883,
0.1564878821,
-0.1146417186,
0.2425910681,
-0.8355349898,
0.2604793608,
-0.1175560877,
-0.7610852122,
-0.5827190876,
-0.389580071,
-0.9843856692,
0.6834312081,
0.2649846971,
-0.9951813817,
0.4433557093,
0.0341812074,
-0.6587536335,
0.1108623147,
-0.9584925771,
1.1691734791,
-0.2727797031,
-0.2924406826,
-0.0985385701,
-1.0304449797,
0.4568715692,
0.3575576246,
0.4555439055,
-0.4157381356,
0.2019154876,
0.6493353844,
-0.043395482,
0.7587685585,
-0.0779725909,
-0.0271235872,
0.1413426995,
-0.0901835486,
0.3702576756,
0.1963939518,
0.0543147326,
0.0074349316,
-0.0562616475,
-0.4125105739,
-0.5757769942,
0.531862855,
-0.7277833819,
-0.2896479964,
-0.2665488124,
-0.8831826448,
-0.3899757564,
0.2691226006,
0.3703108728,
0.9410561919,
-0.3621997833,
0.1347290277,
0.6843696237,
-0.0116524249,
0.2389326245,
0.4249942005,
-0.1867966354,
0.0325614698,
0.9127154946,
-0.1985262632,
0.4979423881,
0.5528091788,
0.2276655287,
-0.5893316269,
-0.4956268072,
-0.7914882898,
0.1828231961,
-0.8670978546,
-0.1284594536,
-0.8721154928,
-0.1699196696,
-0.6302216649,
-0.0050723702,
-0.3766452074,
-0.424518019,
-0.0330814719,
-0.0427085124,
0.2153539956,
1.1459556818,
0.077806212,
0.7232655883,
-0.7030425072,
0.4526957572,
0.3079371154,
0.4036117196,
-0.2808012068,
-0.6387322545,
-0.3587799072,
0.0681450963,
-0.070069775,
-0.8080320954,
0.2343898565,
0.2813719511,
0.5950706601,
0.6290103197,
-0.0448591635,
0.6804032922,
-0.4525425434,
0.4740859866,
0.2616509795,
-0.7489523292,
0.4919735491,
-0.5376842618,
0.3689213395,
0.6951600313,
0.1592547297,
-0.8033719063,
-0.1695303768,
-0.4205697477,
-0.6388218403,
1.3147395849,
0.4651505947,
0.026424095,
0.0865015984,
0.1308215559,
0.0017163279,
-0.1393266469,
-0.5934414864,
-0.3373687267,
-0.3287394643,
-0.2201023549,
-0.0932137296,
-0.2311890423,
-0.0183217712,
-0.0662453622,
0.6646388769,
0.0439986549,
0.2851475179,
0.154765889,
-0.340320766,
0.1496680975,
0.6080719233,
0.5753002167,
0.5156339407,
-0.2608269155,
0.403693825,
-0.1520071179,
-0.593449831,
0.2214400023,
0.0356467515,
-0.1395070255,
-0.1087654009,
0.1459374875,
1.2283582687,
0.4814368486,
-0.3735635579,
0.5439962745,
-0.3474348783,
0.0751456767,
-0.0769118294,
-0.1008213311,
0.1607216448,
-0.1354621202,
-0.2469817549,
0.1271630824,
0.362644583,
-0.5030322671,
0.1780620664,
0.243738398,
-0.7709220648,
-0.3237661123,
0.3209090531,
0.1818047613,
-0.3621997833,
0.6790522337,
-0.3285858631,
-0.4500062168,
0.0819398016,
0.423817873,
0.6442995667,
-0.3310475647,
0.2266766131,
0.1892181635,
0.2734070122,
0.3146030903,
0.1806871593,
-0.2012965679,
-1.1377900839,
-0.4640541971,
-0.6884109974,
-0.3784361482,
-0.0417648256,
-0.7828777432,
-0.032786034,
-0.1298228353,
-0.0113197453,
0.4157150686,
-0.4173439741,
-0.5049801469,
-0.1702553481,
0.0514272153,
0.3697348535,
-0.6386131644,
1.1791517735,
0.6236246824,
-0.2483826876,
-0.870785892,
-0.166294992,
0.1022303253,
-0.7186847329,
0.4731343687,
0.1372725666,
-0.8025845289,
0.2886723876,
-0.1168273762,
-0.9165839553,
0.7048479319,
-0.0560637042,
-0.2677825093,
-0.2616060972,
0.0292355977,
0.1163183749,
-0.5845612884,
0.1738266498,
0.8972556591,
0.5745755434,
0.1225589514,
-0.7084168792,
-0.3847583234,
-0.3259832263,
0.0246625617,
0.2929720283,
-0.4081799984,
0.6326377392,
-0.3203427196,
-0.3588886857,
-0.2085417658,
0.5130991936,
0.1537982672,
0.1799390614,
0.5658665299,
0.4383651614,
0.5287682414,
-0.0169949159,
1.1599469185,
0.0092011467,
0.5377711058,
1.3880341053,
-0.4632849693,
0.6383855939,
0.4683433473,
0.0706615373,
0.633979857,
0.4102725983,
0.5375626683,
0.7263062,
-0.1889470369,
-0.3978354931,
-0.3684788346,
-0.2710689604,
-0.0208393708,
0.8539603949,
0.8949750066,
0.1367895454,
-0.4225434661,
0.2062927037,
-0.1294674277,
-0.2917813659,
-0.0542095266,
1.1514763832,
-0.1755840927,
-0.6867861152,
0.4164290428,
-0.0001924025,
0.0772993863,
-0.6577179432,
0.036912255,
0.1858655959,
0.2675832808,
-0.1608617157,
-1.0532704592,
0.338006109,
-0.1912279874,
-0.2370084971,
-0.3401557207,
0.7330938578,
-0.7070354819,
-0.2681170106,
0.4276219904,
0.3982283473,
0.4403097928,
0.1307858974,
-0.5365128517,
-0.0491631106,
0.0268770438,
-0.3516594768,
-0.0139710633,
0.3562973142,
-0.0410295166,
0.5045562387,
0.5103189349,
-0.3296254873,
0.3407571614,
0.3540911973,
0.7446245551,
-0.3818480372,
-0.5789543986,
-0.5892461538,
0.5721350312,
0.0271867383,
-0.301034987,
0.6721504927,
0.523367703,
0.6806767583,
0.3342318535,
0.8428062201,
-0.0696540922,
0.326220572,
-0.4057180285,
0.4180823863,
-0.4320952296,
0.202819109,
0.0301621072,
-0.4602309167,
-0.3264197409,
0.8280391097,
-0.3413084149,
-0.1852403879,
0.5865472555,
0.9015299678,
-0.361574471,
0.3647762239,
0.4730076492,
0.1911328435,
0.1867010742,
0.7303654552,
1.0359443426,
-0.3880969882,
0.63428545,
-0.1814107001,
-0.4556853175,
-0.3221482635,
-0.2250990123,
-0.6547106504,
-0.6571143866,
0.0514275692,
-0.2456351072,
0.0033825759,
0.5854599476,
0.8705887794,
-0.5685642362,
-0.3167169988,
0.2155199945,
0.2562474012,
-0.0681136921,
-0.1066013277,
0.5147736073,
-0.3279027939,
-0.4831668437,
0.6422401667,
1.0074173212,
-0.1822382659,
-0.2367703319,
-0.390971452,
-0.5731387734,
0.0423380286,
0.796984911,
-0.0803334564,
-0.9002168775,
-0.52623564,
0.1444574594,
-0.2702734768,
0.2761146128,
1.0395667553,
-0.307865411,
0.5208019018,
0.5083527565,
0.4069026709,
0.6711073518,
0.1255854219,
0.3665562272,
-0.7044997811,
0.1877553612,
0.2133639008,
0.3584681451,
0.1910476089,
-0.375774622,
0.2357779741,
-0.1201782748,
-0.4955005348,
-0.5081846714,
0.4757309854,
-1.4062776566,
-0.3287838399,
1.1422659159,
-0.2119667977,
-0.3598461747,
-0.9483107328,
-0.1831514984,
0.3650518656,
-0.3141180873,
0.0281842761,
0.4879979193,
-0.4878811836,
-0.176472649,
-0.6325721145,
0.2211079895,
0.3328361213,
-0.7477101088,
0.6179969907,
0.3930550516,
0.067531772,
0.2151308358,
0.8420092463,
-0.169334501,
0.4461302161,
-0.0399068519,
0.107304804,
0.1782404184,
-0.6990762353,
-0.2441711873,
0.0821269751,
-0.0415417813,
-0.358967334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18252v1
|
Towards Generalist Prompting for Large Language Models by Mental Models
| 2024-02-28T11:29:09 | 2024-02-28T11:29:09 |
Haoxiang Guan, Jiyan He, Shuxin Zheng, En-Hong Chen, Weiming Zhang, Nenghai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on many
tasks. However, to achieve optimal performance, specially designed prompting
methods are still needed. These methods either rely on task-specific few-shot
examples that require a certain level of domain knowledge, or are designed to
be simple but only perform well on a few types of tasks. In this work, we
attempt to introduce the concept of generalist prompting, which operates on the
design principle of achieving optimal or near-optimal performance on a wide
range of tasks while eliminating the need for manual selection and
customization of prompts tailored to specific problems. Furthermore, we propose
MeMo (Mental Models), an innovative prompting method that is simple-designed
yet effectively fulfills the criteria of generalist prompting. MeMo distills
the cores of various prompting methods into individual mental models and allows
LLMs to autonomously select the most suitable mental models for the problem,
achieving or being near to the state-of-the-art results on diverse tasks such
as STEM, logical reasoning, and commonsense reasoning in zero-shot settings. We
hope that the insights presented herein will stimulate further exploration of
generalist prompting methods for LLMs.
|
[
-0.5628916621,
-1.0595668554,
1.0177284479,
0.2097586095,
-0.4033040702,
-0.3805836141,
-0.4477141798,
0.1638533771,
0.1428254843,
0.385124594,
-0.9393285513,
-0.5509146452,
-0.1039855629,
-0.0003043124,
-0.4299659133,
0.9765387774,
0.0631262213,
-0.0850090384,
-0.1824250668,
0.2045657486,
-0.6961999536,
-0.44823578,
-0.7886510491,
-0.3418261707,
0.7829414606,
0.352165699,
0.3041530252,
0.539439857,
-0.0165455006,
0.2136309743,
-0.1340353936,
0.1499905586,
-0.2966802716,
0.3306460083,
-0.2617697418,
-0.7251046896,
-0.3333366811,
-0.0545197837,
0.4553896189,
0.5218842626,
-0.3330968022,
0.2259474397,
0.1486196667,
0.6482806206,
-0.6338339448,
-0.0143491719,
-0.7555778623,
-0.0349827968,
0.022898769,
-0.2545752525,
-0.5448648334,
-0.3226816952,
0.0375483595,
-0.7019475698,
0.3981388807,
0.1729495823,
0.5108038783,
0.1280878931,
-0.0512395166,
-0.4052911401,
-0.8244202137,
0.7265065908,
-0.5302082896,
0.0952309072,
0.4241257012,
0.3644137383,
-0.2014573216,
-0.2728544772,
-0.5514549017,
-0.4451012015,
0.1518214196,
0.0221928786,
-0.4546578228,
0.25540483,
0.5277460814,
0.0547262914,
-0.6631042957,
0.0762041435,
-0.1194997877,
0.0352322459,
0.2837584615,
0.4218400419,
0.3459989429,
0.2221194357,
0.0543250218,
0.1274783164,
-0.8134490848,
0.1137522459,
0.3814968467,
0.3725462556,
-0.1066678241,
0.4651181102,
-0.3460827768,
0.9198718071,
0.322642833,
0.1029196829,
-0.4261699021,
-0.2350032479,
-0.2400939763,
-0.3691853881,
0.7141768336,
0.27046597,
0.9545400143,
-0.1466380507,
-0.4633632302,
0.2579320669,
0.1186427772,
-0.6790370345,
-0.4423759878,
0.1840561628,
-0.1052874848,
-0.0225417148,
-0.333689183,
-0.8228758574,
-0.2420649081,
-0.6764732003,
0.48456195,
-0.3511492908,
-0.0556302108,
0.3325586319,
-0.1443997473,
-0.0545682199,
0.5429435968,
-1.5320591927,
0.2887789905,
0.5968515873,
0.7289799452,
0.0546736903,
-0.0485364348,
-0.6469320059,
0.6019864678,
-0.501912415,
0.99611938,
-0.7189490199,
-0.7449551225,
0.137600109,
-0.5207169652,
-0.1283562481,
-0.5636677146,
0.3316999376,
-0.2985411882,
0.4346862435,
-0.5844947696,
-0.4235055149,
-0.1928075105,
0.3266052306,
-0.3564938903,
0.6659974456,
-0.0874600932,
-0.4159053564,
0.2210779041,
-0.8957772255,
-0.192599833,
0.1189369783,
-0.3780049682,
0.2591099739,
0.5622412562,
0.6105946302,
0.5586555004,
-0.7382862568,
0.5013307929,
-0.2305482328,
-0.4402144253,
0.0286757462,
-0.4679870605,
0.5574737787,
0.1747361124,
-0.153121978,
0.2481284291,
-0.3937162459,
0.2649685144,
0.3158134818,
-0.4482980669,
-0.4162423313,
-0.1030199155,
-0.3474824727,
0.0344178677,
0.0154278679,
-0.0532666557,
0.5513224006,
-0.2739041746,
0.3643719852,
0.950091362,
0.0333279446,
0.5528910756,
-0.54842031,
0.711342454,
-0.1300803274,
0.1906765401,
-0.4132063687,
-0.3865875602,
-0.6737516522,
-0.587829113,
-0.0470041819,
0.729452908,
-0.2953325212,
0.2122339755,
-0.2099251896,
-0.0785425752,
-0.4496076405,
0.5557923317,
0.3052997291,
0.3934423029,
0.325695008,
-0.1002417579,
-0.4075997174,
-0.9452570677,
-0.347042948,
-0.2591234446,
-0.4258792102,
0.3808348477,
0.2496823668,
-0.117583558,
1.1448603868,
-0.5409330726,
-0.1469522268,
-0.4494576156,
0.1323324591,
0.4987629354,
0.1469300389,
0.4300934672,
-0.407006681,
-0.4509634674,
-0.2442156374,
-0.6870915294,
-0.4483876228,
-0.0500913411,
-0.0347636342,
0.1122940034,
0.6290061474,
-0.9902610183,
0.1095759645,
0.1479277313,
0.0273327362,
0.7822937965,
-0.2633431256,
-0.1514306515,
-0.9278050065,
0.3285113275,
0.0757398531,
0.1520327777,
-0.8664519191,
-0.010530916,
0.0553435273,
-0.0898652524,
-0.3844855428,
0.951002121,
-0.4759958684,
0.445445478,
-0.1824953556,
0.0976511165,
-0.0106887454,
0.5435675383,
-0.2495981604,
0.7284128666,
0.5237522721,
-1.0010954142,
0.3477905989,
-0.0518124327,
-0.1864631325,
0.8376148939,
-0.9033391476,
0.3553959131,
-0.5095773935,
0.2510804534,
-1.023940444,
-0.3955127001,
0.3674038053,
-0.1089848056,
0.3528835773,
-0.1443387121,
-0.4111717045,
-0.7734501362,
-0.2148285061,
0.1176846251,
0.606351018,
-0.3599013984,
0.5331640244,
-0.0900074914,
-0.4183999002,
-0.3855446279,
-0.376332581,
0.0201405343,
-0.3738613129,
-0.3765805364,
0.0638773665,
-0.6338909864,
-0.3241620362,
-0.1574527025,
-0.0029185379,
0.083062157,
0.138237834,
0.2228094786,
0.6866074204,
-0.279004693,
0.1158113182,
0.0608622916,
-0.1701149791,
0.1380122006,
-0.5161390305,
0.6939795613,
-0.0032630409,
-0.4365682304,
-0.590996623,
0.5580804944,
0.3509976864,
-0.1520778388,
0.3142630756,
0.2268366516,
-0.2887960076,
-0.4435948431,
-0.9567317963,
-0.49034217,
-0.4982940257,
0.0928026736,
-0.5366629362,
-0.9884973764,
0.3422391713,
-0.1310650706,
0.2067530453,
0.0175721608,
0.744335413,
0.0230942946,
1.3590732813,
0.609143734,
-0.241074875,
0.5833688974,
-0.1571016014,
0.1438207179,
-0.7235418558,
-0.0358951837,
-0.571128428,
-0.1769841164,
0.2641480863,
-0.3189814985,
0.114896439,
0.2299523056,
-0.4191215336,
-0.1362071782,
-0.58856076,
0.8472104073,
0.5941694975,
-0.2859163582,
0.1187367812,
0.2904036641,
-0.7506981492,
0.1137614623,
-0.6622415185,
-0.5909953713,
0.8162260056,
0.1211144924,
0.9812575579,
-0.0112071289,
0.8104133606,
0.0320582651,
0.3023164272,
-0.9792483449,
0.8874797225,
0.1735860258,
-0.8792930245,
-0.2820519209,
-0.2777905166,
-0.9532144666,
0.1752584428,
0.2058682591,
-1.1075086594,
0.0220800564,
0.4507064819,
-0.7014205456,
0.0828235671,
-0.6012576818,
0.6330853105,
-0.0495023914,
-0.0720386878,
-0.3169544637,
-0.307503581,
0.4513249397,
0.0025191582,
0.3270581961,
-0.2136949003,
-0.2437520176,
0.4497638643,
0.0947098508,
1.0424369574,
-0.4070978165,
-0.0601187833,
0.3104021251,
0.3459472656,
0.7704534531,
-0.3366865814,
0.0559609681,
-0.5187325478,
-0.2926471531,
-0.2118322998,
-0.7608478665,
0.6168526411,
-0.4096850455,
-1.166872263,
0.1330226511,
-0.8187127113,
-0.3755005896,
0.3079419732,
0.4060527384,
0.4371083081,
-0.2243350148,
-0.1561898142,
0.9797903299,
-0.0456179269,
0.5583914518,
0.6363242865,
-0.3784677386,
-0.441534847,
0.8574160337,
0.1140753031,
0.3079863787,
0.3232837021,
0.402415663,
-0.4329564869,
-0.6580258608,
-0.4901279807,
0.4995164573,
-0.8039891124,
0.0473999567,
-0.7363533974,
0.1633944809,
-0.3921580911,
-0.3827781081,
0.1026126519,
-0.2189059854,
-0.4668180943,
0.0603702366,
0.1613771617,
0.8027901649,
-0.0200117547,
0.2408106178,
-0.6710362434,
0.4259188771,
0.8016420007,
0.0518931411,
0.4015949368,
-0.6074830294,
-0.0825108364,
-0.0219391324,
-0.4443119168,
-0.6756532788,
0.2343085259,
0.1433479041,
0.9519753456,
0.6546381116,
0.1139666066,
0.6310395598,
-0.7230806351,
0.6014176607,
0.4158218205,
-0.9462165236,
0.8655610681,
-0.743421495,
0.5690796375,
0.4528441429,
0.3899568915,
-0.8399466276,
-0.462677896,
-0.427947402,
-0.7955238223,
0.4289913177,
-0.4758497775,
0.4792051911,
-0.3065027595,
0.4291003048,
-0.0696693137,
0.3010793328,
-0.4570620656,
-0.046453163,
0.1223834679,
-0.353405118,
0.0767079443,
-0.227983579,
-0.4101736248,
-0.1015708596,
0.5368073583,
-0.4646404386,
0.375472039,
0.1301831603,
-0.0558729433,
-0.3319271505,
0.5278892517,
0.9383596182,
0.7717261314,
-0.0461587869,
0.0107320957,
0.3622269034,
-0.1072345749,
0.4833268225,
-0.2892253697,
-0.4386522472,
-0.137777254,
-0.0693304241,
0.8076414466,
0.125309661,
-0.3829687834,
0.2769230008,
-0.0367921107,
-0.3909735084,
0.0011532606,
0.5029159188,
0.4096539319,
0.2506922483,
0.5305077434,
-0.3031148016,
-0.1448419392,
-0.3866491914,
-0.1389131844,
0.6580912471,
-0.2141945213,
-0.4493218362,
0.8160763383,
-0.0113304602,
-0.5508199334,
0.6012913585,
-0.1386016607,
-0.2495054901,
0.2506453991,
0.847546339,
1.0119650364,
-0.4332676828,
0.3948983252,
0.3404605985,
0.1409009993,
-0.4685961902,
0.2379075885,
-0.130732134,
-0.4655683339,
-0.4574941695,
-0.4197063148,
-0.5629068613,
0.2944445908,
-0.657490015,
0.1246169955,
-0.8842893243,
-0.1274073124,
-0.0408442207,
-0.0972130299,
-0.6656968594,
0.103755936,
0.2862221599,
1.1686513424,
-0.685880363,
0.896563828,
0.6049998999,
-0.1876799315,
-0.8942233324,
-0.1203279942,
0.3037874699,
-0.9638615847,
0.4705121219,
0.2341103405,
-0.0215238146,
0.1483633816,
-0.6785948873,
-0.466760695,
0.8462255597,
0.7992584109,
-0.7210767269,
-0.4028036892,
-0.1085808203,
0.3880339265,
-0.46565786,
0.1161845252,
0.3604359329,
0.6121224165,
0.2228156328,
-0.5432980657,
0.2841210663,
-0.2524350882,
0.2552510202,
0.1435623765,
-0.4217277169,
0.7642654777,
-0.4783894122,
-0.2828020155,
0.3031472862,
0.4628176093,
0.4208457768,
0.1212366819,
0.5322713256,
0.3878988326,
1.1550126076,
0.1867664158,
1.1583955288,
-0.1428275257,
-0.0960685015,
0.9625018835,
-0.2822553813,
0.7506723404,
0.513194561,
-0.1065665409,
0.3417398036,
0.4305149913,
-0.0128162969,
0.5048696399,
0.4252139926,
-0.6396529078,
-0.428136766,
-0.2189620584,
-0.1915146708,
-0.1298857033,
0.6159616113,
-0.1387090534,
-0.2290770411,
-0.0726881102,
0.1011489779,
-0.1641059071,
-0.3596383035,
0.7485178709,
0.2642904818,
-1.0276433229,
0.7539175749,
-0.2326893508,
0.6306633949,
-0.7399109602,
0.3441295922,
-0.3379784524,
0.0313861221,
0.2137949765,
-0.5751317143,
0.0142680025,
-0.0529548042,
-0.6084866524,
-0.205207333,
0.5346986055,
-0.436858952,
-0.1435579807,
0.1893214732,
0.6209764481,
0.043957565,
-0.2965826392,
-0.7187729478,
-0.11379949,
-0.0051200427,
-0.2887500823,
0.428308785,
0.5646012425,
-0.1590115726,
0.9108373523,
0.8882633448,
0.1871032715,
-0.2796438038,
0.2860431671,
0.8132423759,
-0.9758867621,
-0.485663116,
-1.2344657183,
0.4057793021,
0.1678871661,
-0.1878949553,
0.5676093102,
0.1051940024,
0.4614218175,
-0.2534525096,
0.9134365916,
0.4080874622,
0.4438018203,
-0.5025848746,
0.3992036283,
-0.34270823,
0.2156913728,
-0.1782788187,
-0.9761860967,
-0.4427586198,
0.5063964128,
-0.4913576543,
0.0525097474,
0.5770087838,
1.1692037582,
0.0358212702,
0.1505832374,
0.5861930251,
-0.0164711811,
0.4952331185,
0.7017947435,
1.0574616194,
0.4349083602,
0.545507431,
0.2051866353,
-0.1669257134,
-0.4045105577,
-0.8572967649,
-1.1845700741,
-0.3170215487,
0.0057397196,
0.0396605246,
0.167309761,
1.1630216837,
0.5412709117,
-0.6948081851,
-0.3177637458,
-0.1396550238,
0.0661078021,
0.0205686372,
-0.1195478812,
-0.0479889214,
-0.5142161846,
-0.7266846895,
0.4523934424,
0.4009037614,
0.4474321604,
-0.2248983532,
-0.0838732049,
0.0224906243,
0.5308064222,
0.3377844989,
0.4851373732,
-0.9562348127,
-0.104341045,
0.0345892347,
-0.2753107548,
-0.1197822765,
1.0689220428,
-0.7556419969,
0.2851838171,
0.41820243,
0.3878483772,
0.219713062,
-0.1459204108,
0.660944581,
-0.5415773392,
0.020733906,
0.297919184,
0.1711770743,
0.2630418539,
-0.1471477747,
0.3016187847,
0.1407583505,
-0.4580276906,
-0.8180183172,
0.345769465,
-0.6070252657,
-0.2198193669,
1.1535270214,
-0.1331291646,
-0.3205993176,
-0.121438913,
-0.5008131266,
-0.094613716,
-0.5844433904,
0.6962144375,
0.8487536907,
-0.0056062741,
-0.2234110534,
-0.8478595614,
0.3907593489,
0.6471693516,
-0.6131784916,
0.3199534714,
0.4650624394,
0.3495562077,
-0.0049805581,
0.8182324767,
0.292386502,
0.3611708283,
-0.1965938359,
-0.1409376115,
-0.1919929832,
-0.5519155264,
-0.4797086716,
0.195785895,
0.2030406296,
0.1772319973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18243v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18243v2
|
Learning or Self-aligning? Rethinking Instruction Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-28T11:16:00 | 2024-03-02T08:28:14 |
Mengjie Ren, Boxi Cao, Hongyu Lin, Cao Liu, Xianpei Han, Ke Zeng, Guanglu Wan, Xunliang Cai, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction Fine-tuning~(IFT) is a critical phase in building large language
models~(LLMs). Previous works mainly focus on the IFT's role in the transfer of
behavioral norms and the learning of additional world knowledge. However, the
understanding of the underlying mechanisms of IFT remains significantly
limited. In this paper, we design a knowledge intervention framework to
decouple the potential underlying factors of IFT, thereby enabling individual
analysis of different factors. Surprisingly, our experiments reveal that
attempting to learn additional world knowledge through IFT often struggles to
yield positive impacts and can even lead to markedly negative effects. Further,
we discover that maintaining internal knowledge consistency before and after
IFT is a critical factor for achieving successful IFT. Our findings reveal the
underlying mechanisms of IFT and provide robust support for some very recent
and potential future works.
|
[
-0.2961839736,
-0.7119712234,
0.4407208264,
-0.1381741315,
0.0164285619,
0.1223239526,
-0.2948767543,
-0.2458102256,
-0.3788677752,
0.334010154,
-0.7016934156,
-0.2741823494,
-0.6148294806,
-0.0885528177,
-0.3700707555,
1.1122332811,
-0.2491536289,
-0.2104457915,
-0.0495180562,
0.095272094,
-0.7999287248,
-0.1426088065,
-0.7985534668,
-0.4990169406,
0.3455524445,
0.915088892,
0.367231071,
0.7602056861,
0.4990308285,
0.2374563068,
0.2692783177,
0.2285985351,
-0.7489331961,
-0.0832433775,
-0.3037596345,
-0.4602373838,
-0.1432595998,
0.0289418753,
0.8781257868,
0.5758558512,
-0.103024818,
0.1765282452,
0.613942802,
0.6804468036,
-0.3878673911,
0.2819314897,
-0.481253475,
-0.1513961256,
-0.0622768104,
-0.2274959981,
-0.0766195357,
-0.3016577065,
0.1574246585,
-0.404889375,
0.1588638872,
-0.1723441631,
0.7059634328,
0.6125099659,
-0.4242838621,
-0.2795523703,
-0.6343529224,
0.6581229568,
-0.7836644053,
0.6567178965,
0.3302451074,
-0.1433134526,
-0.4105437398,
-0.383298099,
-0.4071418345,
-0.1936040372,
-0.0332676806,
-0.1163309589,
0.0706199706,
0.1824373752,
0.1063007563,
0.4431301355,
0.0570867062,
0.3454265893,
-0.5602372289,
-0.1857608706,
0.5020909309,
0.1276415288,
0.2207164168,
0.1074172482,
-0.4944544733,
0.1261155158,
-0.9776221514,
0.5096490979,
0.3148891628,
0.4577406347,
-0.1482410282,
0.4333655238,
-0.2412219793,
0.6773456335,
0.543851912,
-0.2806214988,
-0.2949544489,
-0.382386595,
-0.0686770305,
0.1955479532,
0.4711814523,
0.4087559283,
0.1854052395,
-0.1254385114,
-0.4814215004,
-0.1789384335,
0.3279026151,
-0.8314765692,
-0.2993482351,
-0.1183252633,
-0.1776821613,
-0.2261898816,
0.0978428796,
-0.332901448,
-0.1321964562,
-0.8574886918,
0.5731685162,
-0.7138442993,
-0.2400595844,
0.2038445622,
0.2059456408,
0.4633285105,
0.1744174212,
-1.1199973822,
0.2728441954,
0.8743458986,
0.4483606815,
-0.1063656509,
-0.5159111619,
-0.2309543341,
0.133403331,
-0.4317492545,
0.7982655168,
-0.4956749082,
-0.3369886875,
-0.0010646804,
0.1657726169,
-0.0128782559,
-0.4218150675,
0.3093935847,
-0.4028683007,
0.2179105282,
-0.5914262533,
-1.0631753206,
-0.147630766,
0.3599398136,
-0.3029551506,
0.7550753951,
0.0756551176,
-0.5019762516,
0.5331841111,
-0.7253265381,
-0.5339733958,
-0.1718663573,
-0.3212005794,
-0.207667172,
0.2751043737,
-0.0936664715,
0.4451053441,
-0.3737397194,
0.2164168656,
-0.1027063206,
-0.4738694727,
0.2027088255,
-0.445712626,
0.5371686816,
0.0143804187,
-0.5842058063,
0.0500128716,
-0.6472316384,
0.1257290542,
-0.1078802571,
-0.5790815353,
-0.3053101599,
-0.034279041,
-0.7866609693,
0.0603589006,
0.3211022615,
-0.4286491275,
0.4826950729,
-0.2705749869,
0.3748221695,
1.0356436968,
0.2082113326,
0.551566124,
-0.3085929751,
0.4968014956,
-0.014402912,
0.0664275587,
-0.1815367788,
-0.1847140789,
-0.8422061205,
0.0290765353,
0.2438970059,
0.2986450493,
-0.6383168697,
0.0808662027,
-0.0961164236,
-0.1684692502,
-0.7105142474,
0.4048932791,
0.7741474509,
0.4992317557,
0.3223896027,
-0.037834581,
-0.4122928083,
-1.0092998743,
-0.4751286507,
0.0898159742,
0.2336319089,
-0.2859302163,
0.262311399,
-0.2687236071,
0.8769732714,
-0.3268568218,
-0.3092876375,
-0.0484083965,
0.0887106359,
-0.0682716146,
0.7463209033,
0.2102423757,
-0.2706146538,
-0.6213878989,
0.0447678268,
-0.5214177966,
0.0066586458,
-0.1509573162,
-0.0418480709,
0.0070215627,
1.0474044085,
-0.0423450992,
0.473819375,
0.3455138505,
-0.1014538407,
0.5303381681,
-0.3323063254,
0.3130464256,
-0.7949560285,
-0.4776509404,
0.0697660148,
0.096289821,
-0.5897604227,
0.123404108,
0.4160256088,
0.2062914819,
-0.1828130931,
0.4860156476,
-0.5186983347,
0.3165586293,
-0.3912523985,
-0.0210819785,
-0.1129460633,
0.4261963069,
-0.4746005237,
1.058036685,
0.3071927428,
-0.7190133929,
-0.3045827746,
0.036114227,
-0.4437991083,
0.6378360391,
-0.4235269725,
0.1185965464,
0.0079540163,
-0.2079117149,
-1.1050940752,
-0.2260799855,
0.0406931564,
-0.0715827048,
0.7390919328,
-0.1859778166,
-0.4286758006,
-0.158735469,
-0.1946200877,
0.1669038832,
0.329670608,
-0.5767831802,
0.3664476871,
0.3496742547,
0.1712914109,
-0.4259328246,
-0.3887271583,
-0.1848887205,
-0.2262355685,
-0.7037887573,
0.4432920814,
-0.0996443778,
-0.3220295906,
0.0091849836,
-0.3633725643,
0.0320195407,
0.3167468905,
-0.0323321,
-0.1501720995,
-0.4535191655,
0.3615935445,
0.4982248247,
-0.4243392944,
0.0770352408,
-0.5099948049,
0.1909210086,
-0.4115654528,
-0.4624768198,
-0.8534572721,
0.2656609118,
0.4322819114,
-0.2408736795,
0.6270920634,
0.4861247241,
-0.0956833139,
-0.2687645257,
-0.5867161751,
-0.5452839732,
-0.5234871507,
0.3385938108,
-0.4252264202,
-1.0048241615,
0.2906500697,
-0.4267527759,
0.3084953725,
0.1812206358,
0.4335111678,
-0.284371078,
0.8696286082,
1.1137681007,
0.086754106,
0.8727766871,
-0.3341958523,
0.5306175947,
-0.9862975478,
-0.0286048017,
-0.0956643075,
-0.4357872009,
-0.4563450217,
-0.2276975811,
0.2042177916,
0.2699098885,
-0.5190884471,
0.0763725117,
-0.4059646428,
0.7717027068,
0.5894744396,
0.1436297446,
0.3562544286,
-0.1277060211,
-0.0971598923,
-0.0153998798,
-0.8483026624,
-0.338809371,
0.9017804861,
0.1598898023,
1.0433750153,
0.1635148078,
0.8970758915,
0.0990490168,
0.457075268,
-0.5907230377,
0.3237359822,
-0.2346631736,
-0.4719697535,
-0.3707316816,
-0.0588264652,
-0.9730796218,
-0.0323054902,
-0.0435013957,
-0.6837143302,
0.2247246951,
0.4374538064,
-0.5592706203,
0.2427271307,
-1.2236965895,
1.0156069994,
-0.3993195593,
-0.4411621392,
-0.2426408827,
-0.4597595632,
0.4356377423,
0.0709618628,
0.2453569472,
-0.0581972711,
0.0420859046,
0.3687219918,
-0.210857287,
1.2428876162,
-0.0565621667,
-0.510238409,
0.1589933336,
0.297072798,
0.4724989831,
-0.0208031982,
0.0065961871,
0.0225958452,
0.0609668009,
-0.3691161275,
-0.6301271915,
0.8450476527,
-0.9286109209,
-1.1008480787,
0.1042293385,
-0.6761806607,
-0.3613550663,
0.2705370188,
0.1319587529,
0.4926382005,
-0.1273660511,
0.2791893184,
0.9703916311,
0.2129276544,
0.0094386721,
0.6688922048,
-0.186021924,
-0.006958473,
1.1087273359,
0.4004453421,
0.7184984684,
0.3235703409,
0.4999643564,
-0.0728773996,
-0.6015145183,
-0.1338196546,
0.1695397943,
-0.8296993375,
-0.3240389824,
-0.2214802653,
-0.1620654613,
-0.3739646077,
-0.2415457368,
-0.4055128694,
0.0548483059,
-0.4060288966,
-0.2231041789,
0.3072251379,
0.901948154,
-0.2782235146,
0.3939266503,
-0.7402904034,
-0.1044556648,
0.4360484779,
0.531947732,
0.2014250308,
-0.6816818714,
-0.6459172368,
0.2003823072,
-0.3810144663,
-0.5882911086,
-0.1572390497,
0.2763079107,
0.6712036729,
0.4829945564,
-0.0167292692,
0.9421718121,
-0.50635463,
0.4716016948,
-0.0988686457,
-0.9358255863,
0.300955832,
-0.3136267066,
0.5387458205,
0.6403640509,
0.3197363317,
-0.5276235938,
-0.391769439,
-0.6387123466,
-0.7312452197,
0.6837007403,
-0.1550946981,
0.177586779,
-0.0781318694,
0.7017037272,
0.2393824458,
0.1121128276,
-0.4465333521,
-0.032077387,
-0.0461974181,
-0.3625865281,
0.1426663548,
-0.437599659,
-0.3311381936,
-0.3871840239,
0.8188127279,
-0.3291905224,
-0.0015177854,
0.1101547331,
-0.2290447503,
-0.2768458426,
0.1388241798,
0.586928606,
0.5024210215,
0.1752167493,
-0.0100768488,
0.1833882034,
-0.083909519,
0.0109762205,
-0.199010551,
-0.1759087145,
-0.8910134435,
0.3663190603,
0.7532304525,
0.7943305373,
-0.255143255,
0.1630331427,
-0.0701591223,
-0.1556680501,
-0.1119413152,
0.3949249089,
-0.0496247932,
0.4933665395,
-0.0218185205,
-0.0596279651,
-0.178637892,
-0.6216772199,
0.4106506705,
0.4482631981,
-0.543962419,
-0.3480184376,
0.3619880378,
0.1961673647,
-0.5428910851,
0.5580356717,
-0.2680501938,
-0.5726771355,
0.4223579168,
0.6799187064,
0.5663012266,
-0.467582047,
0.0411329232,
0.363319546,
0.5346816182,
-0.0099837212,
0.1982813627,
-0.1097477749,
-0.8911244869,
-0.4597142935,
-0.3484659493,
-0.1327436417,
-0.1369550228,
-0.6059002876,
0.2824920118,
-0.5374799967,
0.2422144413,
-0.2498748004,
-0.0117397541,
-0.7038374543,
-0.1025246829,
0.0338175744,
0.5665362477,
-0.6213493347,
0.9540501833,
0.423014611,
-0.5011812449,
-1.2043447495,
0.4655795097,
0.2590242028,
-1.0751738548,
0.5633785725,
-0.02105253,
-0.2199264318,
0.3613357544,
-0.5426179767,
-1.2594507933,
0.95212394,
0.3114279211,
-0.5987032056,
-0.0635119006,
-0.0540655106,
0.3345632553,
-0.3017656505,
-0.3509456217,
0.9110175371,
0.5830867887,
-0.1984694451,
-0.727748394,
0.1699153334,
0.1690891832,
-0.1760137826,
0.5228422284,
-0.7913419008,
0.8052219748,
-0.4714745879,
-0.3372761011,
-0.096127145,
0.6797837615,
-0.2386346906,
-0.1225806028,
0.4160095453,
0.4785560369,
0.8720117211,
0.0173052084,
1.0187109709,
-0.5770190358,
0.2656651437,
1.2195390463,
0.1325179189,
0.4601140916,
0.4862502515,
-0.0975537598,
0.4283016026,
0.6297207475,
0.2945737243,
0.5096895695,
0.0463769957,
-0.141469568,
-0.4168919921,
0.250366807,
-0.3033120036,
0.4316143394,
0.6313367486,
-0.0131308269,
-0.3241042197,
0.0341506004,
0.1001701131,
0.0645666644,
-0.2664350569,
0.9398310184,
0.0973824412,
-0.9042314291,
0.7013298273,
-0.2362029552,
0.5419519544,
-0.5672162771,
-0.1816092134,
-0.2269320041,
0.4876467884,
-0.2665424049,
-0.8942005634,
0.2757783532,
-0.336930424,
-0.3588177264,
-0.2508170903,
0.6476269364,
-0.7778040171,
-0.2252403051,
0.227445811,
0.4597840309,
-0.1980848461,
0.1902314276,
-0.7587775588,
0.0778624788,
0.4529940784,
0.0432394706,
0.5932626724,
0.9802683592,
-0.0464334451,
0.5476530194,
0.6256767511,
-0.4693726897,
0.1106125787,
-0.1468370557,
0.855660975,
-0.555098176,
-0.2439888716,
-0.7275679708,
0.7103884816,
0.2271545827,
-0.3957686424,
0.956358552,
0.0811200663,
1.0164166689,
0.1962772459,
0.5347149372,
0.0689731538,
0.2748511732,
-0.5610871315,
0.5281524062,
-0.7623997331,
0.4296226501,
-0.0733023211,
-0.419731617,
-0.1427447796,
0.5558418036,
-0.58394593,
-0.22332111,
0.6749187112,
0.7591637373,
-0.022810692,
0.2073821425,
0.512321949,
0.4516417682,
0.6641287208,
0.0853472576,
0.7762905955,
-0.1896160543,
0.2766796052,
-0.4632785618,
-0.323694557,
-0.214558661,
-0.9520748854,
-0.6945014596,
-0.7150780559,
-0.1638362855,
-0.0957964435,
0.1995694041,
1.0758070946,
0.3869876564,
-0.5777431726,
-0.3344860077,
-0.2144522965,
0.4297186136,
-0.3243272305,
-0.1581832767,
0.3532199562,
-0.8628262281,
-0.4512481391,
0.4089891613,
0.2959555686,
-0.0247212034,
-0.3457585573,
0.0874050334,
-0.1342619061,
0.0177461375,
0.6722301841,
0.471352607,
-0.6391745806,
-0.664943099,
-0.0922018215,
0.239894703,
0.1585372984,
1.0361454487,
-0.5467934608,
0.47545892,
0.1059747115,
0.8421329856,
0.0595768653,
-0.3093623221,
0.806453526,
-0.6576989889,
-0.0891442224,
-0.0170515906,
0.3614340425,
0.2437245846,
-0.4868997335,
0.251288265,
-0.0026732159,
-0.8018565178,
-0.7297430038,
0.3998637795,
-0.3298359215,
-0.1676439494,
0.9651969075,
-0.00989372,
-0.2092129588,
-0.1242174581,
-0.2482268512,
0.1702467352,
-0.3568162322,
1.1461344957,
0.7342444658,
-0.2568812668,
-0.1564793289,
-0.3482955694,
0.6568289995,
0.3380310535,
-0.6289715767,
0.2569565177,
0.2262788266,
0.6350099444,
-0.0237380248,
0.5767256021,
0.1017087176,
0.2186495662,
-0.1901597828,
0.0069361664,
0.0662199408,
-0.5458171964,
-0.2159831226,
-0.2385392636,
0.3036811948,
0.1427057385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18240v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18240v2
|
Prospect Personalized Recommendation on Large Language Model-based Agent Platform
| 2024-02-28T11:12:17 | 2024-03-05T12:14:52 |
Jizhi Zhang, Keqin Bao, Wenjie Wang, Yang Zhang, Wentao Shi, Wanhong Xu, Fuli Feng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The new kind of Agent-oriented information system, exemplified by GPTs, urges
us to inspect the information system infrastructure to support Agent-level
information processing and to adapt to the characteristics of Large Language
Model (LLM)-based Agents, such as interactivity. In this work, we envisage the
prospect of the recommender system on LLM-based Agent platforms and introduce a
novel recommendation paradigm called Rec4Agentverse, comprised of Agent Items
and Agent Recommender. Rec4Agentverse emphasizes the collaboration between
Agent Items and Agent Recommender, thereby promoting personalized information
services and enhancing the exchange of information beyond the traditional
user-recommender feedback loop. Additionally, we prospect the evolution of
Rec4Agentverse and conceptualize it into three stages based on the enhancement
of the interaction and information exchange among Agent Items, Agent
Recommender, and the user. A preliminary study involving several cases of
Rec4Agentverse validates its significant potential for application. Lastly, we
discuss potential issues and promising directions for future research.
|
[
-0.5251146555,
-0.5693907142,
0.701068759,
0.1537763625,
-0.0020355524,
0.2393810004,
-0.0199113786,
-0.6109682918,
0.4651263058,
0.8968147039,
-0.6917830706,
-0.5534390807,
-0.1919097602,
0.1174078509,
-0.0981652662,
1.3292614222,
0.0861861184,
-0.0646483228,
-0.1435108036,
0.0114676757,
-0.9301128387,
-0.6658285856,
-0.9281327128,
-0.8311286569,
0.678348124,
0.3622751236,
0.6899160743,
0.3803233504,
0.467559278,
0.4605798125,
0.3078539371,
-0.039871905,
-0.4617502093,
0.5260182619,
-0.552592814,
-0.3151087165,
-0.8539767861,
-0.0574025251,
0.4530307353,
0.2558405101,
-0.2458387166,
-0.1667825133,
-0.0844861269,
0.6697200537,
-0.2320477813,
0.342672497,
-0.357042253,
0.1038130149,
-0.1461834013,
-0.5458692312,
-0.2518332899,
-0.2057956904,
0.4306343496,
-0.7307924032,
0.2002772242,
0.1166951209,
0.3667203486,
-0.237434268,
-0.3750263155,
-0.045026321,
-1.0969525576,
0.6122700572,
-0.4004795253,
0.4552488029,
0.40033409,
0.7181199193,
-0.3883526027,
-0.9162552953,
-0.5028038621,
-0.396846503,
0.2570411265,
-0.2201583385,
-0.3340305984,
-0.001696543,
-0.11820025,
0.1915412992,
-0.4886761606,
0.0184172969,
0.1684611887,
-0.2096650302,
0.443143785,
0.2449584901,
0.1619087905,
0.4922403693,
-0.4779056907,
0.1692350358,
-0.6923390627,
-0.0960468426,
0.4353868067,
0.3511046469,
0.0458714925,
0.4612272084,
-0.5617013574,
0.5973578691,
0.3225801289,
0.1154780313,
0.610223949,
-0.5497959852,
0.0474879034,
-0.1571312994,
0.4319191873,
0.5488493443,
0.210609749,
-0.3304995894,
-0.333090812,
-0.2790514529,
0.200115487,
-0.8610471487,
-0.1325082928,
0.1257055253,
-0.4072270393,
-0.3880753517,
0.0382227413,
-0.6612585187,
-0.737221837,
-0.4034398496,
0.2066950351,
-0.2588872313,
-0.3761993051,
0.2100024521,
-0.0795046687,
0.0090197008,
0.6057397127,
-0.8176575899,
0.3775528967,
0.7113204598,
0.7201462984,
-0.282311976,
-0.4869444072,
-0.4452150762,
0.3115820289,
0.1462861747,
1.1893092394,
-0.9082249403,
-0.2526557744,
0.0830637738,
0.3548678756,
0.4449670017,
-0.2677412331,
0.2991221547,
-0.7880213857,
0.0637642071,
-0.4729691148,
-0.3972720504,
-0.2970506847,
0.6973777413,
-0.6422457099,
0.3728044331,
0.2174234241,
-0.5729803443,
0.3137175739,
-0.8788291216,
-0.102724202,
0.4949930608,
-0.1286243945,
-0.0963857919,
-0.4634471536,
-0.0356863625,
0.4303880036,
-0.3924132884,
0.34601143,
-0.5459198952,
-0.464087218,
0.2103764862,
-0.1731094271,
0.0737148002,
0.2517774105,
-0.4620353878,
0.4120760858,
-0.4554100931,
-0.1757286936,
0.1100565866,
-0.1737269312,
-0.2853353918,
-0.1121068001,
0.2550980151,
0.0928306952,
0.8505384326,
-0.5975917578,
0.4515207112,
-0.4362094104,
0.492233336,
0.9734210372,
0.0931536332,
0.5152628422,
-0.5253385901,
0.7103136778,
-0.0858958811,
0.0936852768,
-0.3047394156,
-0.477966845,
-0.2886398137,
0.024706807,
-0.0347431116,
0.3881639838,
-0.893865943,
0.3975940347,
-0.0584519394,
-0.2575564981,
-0.0243998226,
-0.0770107135,
0.1952514648,
0.0551964119,
0.1463342011,
-0.3428443372,
-0.6153521538,
-0.9378324151,
-0.0961107761,
-0.1434263289,
0.1707352847,
0.4404818118,
0.1833299845,
-0.8642801642,
1.1010144949,
-0.3998288214,
-0.4057354629,
-0.3487488329,
-0.399084568,
0.3994209468,
0.2323484868,
0.6008810997,
-0.7874908447,
-0.4177680314,
0.3749811351,
-0.4252934456,
0.0422628932,
0.4453513026,
-0.1832673997,
-0.0095393788,
0.1340186894,
-0.4746959805,
0.1562270969,
0.4068695605,
-0.7332084775,
0.4311125576,
-0.5096180439,
0.1293072402,
-1.1589622498,
-0.0296917092,
-0.0263281763,
-0.5295766592,
-0.7298078537,
-0.1324754208,
-0.5301700234,
-0.0799254924,
-0.0832915828,
0.9342904687,
-0.2246609032,
-0.2204779685,
-0.7591260672,
0.3050059676,
-0.0265477933,
0.3306600451,
-0.0491187572,
0.5320964456,
0.32380867,
-0.3109673858,
0.736759305,
0.2915410995,
0.2190650254,
0.7047199607,
-0.5457330346,
0.3679015338,
-0.069664456,
0.6629118323,
-0.8686119318,
0.1098679751,
0.3596007526,
-0.154197216,
-0.0101142209,
0.115415521,
-0.4264370501,
-0.3383315206,
-0.5227379799,
0.3872475624,
-0.0412343144,
-0.5263080597,
0.5685603023,
0.4926816523,
-0.4293203354,
-0.7297566533,
-0.3249806762,
0.3710033596,
-0.0781268328,
-0.6730356812,
0.360401094,
-0.4868482947,
-0.1270207316,
0.1023442596,
0.3494785428,
0.2504170537,
-0.1037550718,
0.389298439,
0.1549563706,
-0.1070671305,
0.2403260171,
-0.2285418808,
-0.3619594574,
-0.2271832675,
-0.7556598783,
0.731363833,
-0.6627022624,
-0.1711695939,
-0.4000628293,
0.3195754588,
0.3884948194,
-0.2363695055,
0.5186055899,
0.7781546712,
-0.2790400684,
-0.0623864941,
-0.770542264,
-0.3213524818,
-0.5671967864,
0.6371709108,
-0.4392926991,
-1.1891288757,
0.4081070721,
-0.1323790401,
0.0250322912,
0.1948653162,
0.8861874938,
0.2791897953,
1.1057678461,
0.9942944646,
-0.2806831896,
0.7249267697,
-0.3675412536,
0.1880594641,
-0.6981010437,
-0.2347179949,
-0.201723367,
-0.2110478431,
-0.8580762148,
-0.1811657995,
-0.0036128659,
-0.5209990144,
-0.5839239955,
0.2074566185,
-0.5675895214,
0.4125083387,
0.4619924724,
0.029510865,
0.5195078254,
0.0241259504,
-0.1022061035,
0.1113605127,
-0.2181230932,
-0.5632846951,
0.919886291,
0.5766254067,
0.6731463671,
0.3731072247,
0.5060094595,
0.9192082286,
0.4217087626,
-0.6762189865,
0.550976038,
0.0041319462,
-0.4852571487,
-0.3399331272,
-0.069895573,
-1.3406808376,
0.1554540545,
-0.1804162115,
-0.8645341992,
0.4577358067,
-0.0550350323,
-0.118652992,
0.1536176652,
-0.4527266026,
0.6577111483,
-0.0143214036,
-0.4278384745,
-0.3118233979,
-0.4174203873,
0.0850353613,
-0.1046904922,
0.2096209228,
-0.0464284122,
-0.1593177021,
0.5028607249,
-0.2977109551,
0.7754746675,
-0.3825937808,
-0.1299928874,
0.1309494227,
0.1184353828,
0.933614552,
0.1120866537,
-0.2202912569,
0.0807057768,
0.0716145858,
-0.0303097963,
-0.433721602,
1.0528818369,
-0.9488530755,
-0.7215203047,
-0.3961065114,
-0.515776217,
-0.3273420632,
0.6325281858,
-0.0696078166,
0.2187820524,
-0.3030800223,
0.1218810454,
0.1363211125,
-0.1507625878,
0.2505641878,
1.0321376324,
-0.4416597486,
-0.6864907146,
1.1346771717,
-0.2381213754,
-0.2709017694,
0.4735482037,
0.2585611641,
-0.3517562747,
-0.6883702278,
-0.1136744395,
0.4656476378,
-0.63548702,
-0.1707529724,
-0.6968945265,
0.0339116938,
-0.3993265331,
-0.1123623773,
-0.2680710256,
0.1261216998,
-0.019484546,
-0.0708734617,
0.3881247342,
1.1408256292,
0.2288005054,
0.3657109439,
-0.57390517,
0.0437491909,
0.1680562794,
0.7333003879,
-0.0380405858,
-0.257273227,
-0.6023334861,
-0.0189105235,
-0.5119726062,
-0.5585340261,
0.3621553779,
-0.1351524889,
0.7663386464,
0.7377339602,
-0.0688467175,
0.0103518041,
-0.5829668045,
0.5420204997,
0.051672332,
-0.5567846894,
0.1936929524,
-0.7615938187,
0.1127646789,
0.3720565438,
-0.016747376,
-0.6151615381,
-0.2535141408,
-0.4594961107,
-0.6851688623,
0.7127404213,
0.1494544446,
0.0432394445,
0.200247243,
0.5689168572,
0.3394077122,
0.585087359,
-0.7580087781,
-0.1168422326,
-0.1690105647,
0.0614598319,
-0.5084909797,
-0.2697915435,
0.02141032,
0.277345866,
0.6322017908,
-0.1812890619,
0.4892842472,
0.0477940328,
0.3782971203,
-0.238962844,
0.2845694125,
0.6464811563,
0.6247196198,
-0.4694201946,
-0.1769386977,
-0.1456395239,
-0.5097895861,
0.4107604623,
0.2997693717,
-0.055409424,
-0.3666712642,
-0.0253203698,
0.8651984334,
-0.1635668576,
-0.5226920843,
0.5878786445,
-0.3523392081,
-0.0061447448,
-0.9368697405,
-0.098647818,
0.1175027713,
0.7282752991,
0.1865338236,
0.0999853238,
0.4708195627,
-0.5770010352,
0.1333130449,
0.5556053519,
-0.4888679683,
-0.5888611674,
0.4006320536,
0.5823335648,
-0.6296446919,
0.071845524,
-0.058021307,
-0.2755000591,
0.249708131,
0.6513699293,
1.1677815914,
-0.4086337984,
0.240877077,
-0.1296795309,
0.0994014144,
-0.1778322309,
0.0841723159,
-0.0603373908,
-1.0665544271,
-0.2079260349,
-0.3417128921,
-0.5045377016,
0.1629358381,
-0.1230903491,
0.4971194863,
-0.5537526011,
-0.5439266562,
-0.0057679554,
0.1678312719,
-0.7056981921,
-0.0758948252,
0.0465604924,
0.5622774363,
-0.3892425001,
0.9243318439,
0.9675776362,
-0.2822818458,
-0.3909310699,
-0.0458572805,
-0.1541045904,
-0.5905060768,
0.6751294732,
0.1592657715,
-0.4998381436,
0.0412734225,
-0.1680617332,
-0.9265815616,
1.3070656061,
0.4447403848,
-0.5903320312,
-0.1207395643,
-0.1429994851,
0.7400451303,
-0.8625327945,
0.5693197846,
0.3531715274,
0.7008875608,
0.1715857238,
-0.7324714065,
0.1768422425,
-0.5380220413,
0.1526496112,
0.1813936979,
-0.766083777,
0.7875967026,
-0.2243225425,
0.1965905577,
0.2785232365,
0.4312691987,
0.2359240949,
0.6792693138,
0.6082429886,
0.1795502752,
0.5173493624,
0.3618960977,
1.1454107761,
-0.3243069947,
0.302172333,
1.1532262564,
-0.7704886198,
0.6099320054,
0.1633693725,
-0.2624029517,
0.8382875323,
0.5972629786,
-0.1112904176,
0.440072149,
0.0984726995,
-0.4289817214,
-0.0006417116,
-0.2848789394,
-0.5327792168,
0.294836551,
0.2115541995,
-0.2470360696,
-0.0808817521,
0.3656055629,
-0.2059265226,
-0.0936943144,
-0.0945402011,
0.9031204581,
-0.2065971345,
-0.4896163344,
0.2318029851,
0.2939961851,
0.6419168115,
-0.5604190826,
-0.366597116,
-0.1438285559,
0.3799050152,
-0.1951626688,
-0.7065514326,
-0.2792462409,
-0.3681015372,
-0.3552096486,
-0.1438903809,
1.0081173182,
-0.3529493809,
-0.0731546134,
0.536531508,
0.3578545153,
0.1083072275,
-0.1782015711,
-0.6457492113,
-0.1964166462,
0.0089389384,
-0.235274896,
0.5269191861,
0.5378318429,
-0.0903153419,
0.9784370065,
0.7556409836,
0.1748745441,
-0.7134050131,
0.0437429324,
0.9317461848,
-0.9457300901,
-0.9134720564,
-0.7333604097,
0.0770872161,
0.0324131735,
0.1264374405,
0.7902875543,
0.3354770243,
0.5027886033,
0.0035081182,
1.0005400181,
0.3111129105,
0.5964685678,
-0.0556927994,
0.491984427,
-0.2713857591,
0.728076458,
-0.3814418614,
-1.2828016281,
0.1151107624,
0.127093643,
-0.4047368467,
0.6510238647,
0.5310797095,
0.7001556754,
0.1860791743,
0.0755332559,
0.4653624594,
0.2939707935,
0.6910313964,
0.3793710172,
0.7675409317,
0.0581580214,
0.27188465,
0.0705752447,
-0.3083786964,
-0.6951932311,
-0.7362728119,
-0.8247329593,
-0.7582187057,
-0.01590918,
-0.4816649258,
0.2615155578,
1.1697788239,
0.5224952102,
-0.6045130491,
-0.3131505549,
-0.2214546353,
0.1112245247,
-0.0289411414,
-0.2412459552,
0.1779806614,
0.1010712534,
-0.6331939697,
0.3804282546,
0.5040642619,
0.0780035779,
-0.6212640405,
-0.3097910285,
0.0541304015,
-0.0941012576,
0.6754218936,
0.1903984249,
-0.6552659273,
-0.2695010304,
-0.2261531651,
0.0070137158,
-0.149169758,
1.0806981325,
-0.9356054664,
0.6427235007,
0.2149727046,
0.5108937025,
0.4595875144,
0.0820739269,
0.9748552442,
-0.2861207426,
0.2292257696,
0.1391710937,
0.3208974302,
0.3782404363,
-0.7392042875,
0.2977012992,
0.3048740923,
-0.8505985141,
-0.6628683805,
0.2220316082,
-1.0144861937,
0.0243283007,
1.1835907698,
-0.1679163277,
0.0064200419,
-0.4637613297,
-0.5356471539,
-0.0935499147,
-0.9670855403,
0.4760315716,
0.5071143508,
-0.2450727224,
-0.0792297497,
-0.5041931272,
0.296272248,
-0.0276575331,
-0.6599769592,
-0.0016571538,
0.3528086245,
0.4910945296,
0.2010193318,
0.9277387261,
0.1686598063,
0.1815574914,
-0.3775925636,
0.4320144057,
-0.3742380142,
-0.1092992797,
-0.2833759487,
0.0778941065,
0.5024873614,
0.0131688323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18225v1
|
CogBench: a large language model walks into a psychology lab
| 2024-02-28T10:43:54 | 2024-02-28T10:43:54 |
Julian Coda-Forno, Marcel Binz, Jane X. Wang, Eric Schulz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of
artificial intelligence. Yet, evaluating them comprehensively remains
challenging. We argue that this is partly due to the predominant focus on
performance metrics in most benchmarks. This paper introduces CogBench, a
benchmark that includes ten behavioral metrics derived from seven cognitive
psychology experiments. This novel approach offers a toolkit for phenotyping
LLMs' behavior. We apply CogBench to 35 LLMs, yielding a rich and diverse
dataset. We analyze this data using statistical multilevel modeling techniques,
accounting for the nested dependencies among fine-tuned versions of specific
LLMs. Our study highlights the crucial role of model size and reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) in improving performance and aligning with
human behavior. Interestingly, we find that open-source models are less
risk-prone than proprietary models and that fine-tuning on code does not
necessarily enhance LLMs' behavior. Finally, we explore the effects of
prompt-engineering techniques. We discover that chain-of-thought prompting
improves probabilistic reasoning, while take-a-step-back prompting fosters
model-based behaviors.
|
[
-0.5373725295,
-1.0262104273,
0.5730376244,
0.4665320218,
0.167291671,
0.0278480481,
-0.520821929,
-0.4945254326,
-0.2300460488,
0.2534397542,
-0.8353931904,
-0.452416271,
-0.3894839883,
-0.1601998806,
-0.239790082,
0.8393553495,
0.1951221526,
0.1554085612,
-0.3019608259,
0.0186344776,
-0.4157952666,
-0.5826947689,
-0.8076663613,
-0.6487174034,
0.5915731788,
0.2523146272,
0.6527064443,
0.235976696,
0.5346123576,
0.2253782898,
0.0256113503,
-0.0327917896,
-0.6036213636,
0.0272290744,
-0.2574798763,
-0.3958628476,
-0.5936281681,
0.3044179082,
0.2675745487,
0.9742057323,
-0.5695370436,
0.1460110396,
-0.0889636129,
0.4167950451,
-0.4262260199,
0.3693207502,
-0.3819177747,
-0.0620931275,
0.160892114,
0.047550194,
-0.675737977,
-0.1452622563,
0.0718687028,
-0.4023060799,
0.1692710817,
0.4001433849,
0.38093701,
0.252052784,
-0.1340231448,
-0.3211051524,
-0.5377682447,
1.0131368637,
-0.7081181407,
0.465315491,
0.3248595893,
0.189664036,
-0.4370979965,
-0.3067151308,
-0.3749820888,
-0.8343666792,
-0.1299500316,
-0.0362741165,
-0.0450800098,
0.120376505,
0.4589666426,
0.2041153908,
-0.5395191908,
0.4132028222,
-0.2581857145,
-0.2438938916,
0.8140392303,
0.3652321696,
0.3045052886,
0.1333555579,
0.026374178,
-0.3319426477,
-0.4885003567,
0.2217116207,
0.3334628046,
0.2766214907,
-0.1563878506,
0.3191855848,
-0.1249960959,
0.6001275778,
0.1989970654,
0.075048767,
0.0718002915,
-0.129419595,
0.0957233906,
-0.0316691697,
0.8577492237,
0.0552043021,
0.4697609544,
-0.410260886,
-0.113417834,
0.2329438776,
0.3451971114,
-0.7923730612,
-0.5720810294,
0.3335166872,
-0.2680928111,
0.0274578165,
-0.1007903293,
-0.8271920085,
-0.5293124914,
-0.4003234208,
0.1151770204,
-0.4009000361,
-0.1962975413,
0.1356901079,
-0.0404606052,
0.2053550482,
0.4020512998,
-0.9956834316,
0.5071303248,
1.0091153383,
0.708468616,
-0.4935067296,
-0.4800087214,
-0.6497536302,
-0.032052055,
-0.7366310954,
0.5015414357,
-0.5818337202,
-0.2993372381,
-0.1350282878,
-0.1902970076,
0.222302407,
-0.7899996042,
0.2182185352,
-0.4521245956,
0.0819182992,
-0.249725759,
-0.6242842674,
-0.0792647451,
0.3286253512,
-0.6359926462,
1.0379219055,
0.1376786679,
-0.3139643669,
0.3134981692,
-0.7928329706,
-0.4727829099,
0.054207664,
-0.20555529,
-0.2867301404,
0.3408598006,
0.1686725616,
0.4772617519,
-0.3420484662,
0.6602468491,
-0.5796840787,
-0.3490891159,
0.2689873874,
-0.1833664775,
0.7497900724,
-0.0231527034,
-0.1425269246,
0.2404921204,
-0.9753909707,
0.1998002678,
-0.008096572,
-0.3977897465,
-0.1385830492,
0.048181165,
-0.1882892549,
0.20767349,
0.1678948849,
-0.4677503109,
-0.1232992634,
-0.1961053908,
0.4912977815,
0.681450367,
-0.1350009143,
0.4959000349,
-0.2077773809,
0.3740493059,
-0.1735038757,
0.2167844325,
0.0917380154,
-0.2156811655,
-0.5262769461,
-0.6147854328,
-0.1690345556,
0.392811358,
-0.142655924,
0.5904694796,
0.0387607664,
-0.7116296887,
-0.3674464226,
0.2063521892,
0.2434708029,
0.2719760537,
0.3333251774,
-0.3883465528,
-0.3976157308,
-0.7326318622,
-0.5166375041,
-0.2598167956,
-0.0853964165,
0.3037621081,
0.6201636791,
-0.1101828963,
0.6319587231,
-0.342394501,
0.1870090514,
-0.2466562092,
0.4739580154,
0.3356725872,
0.4296527207,
0.3713830411,
-0.2495214045,
-0.1003989726,
-0.3247792423,
-0.7321482897,
-0.190663293,
0.0204891711,
-0.1451106519,
-0.0038705221,
0.8029322624,
-0.6352856159,
0.0832201466,
0.6096739769,
-0.2975231707,
0.7624167204,
-0.3458671272,
-0.1282622218,
-0.3382486701,
-0.0021672689,
0.032587301,
-0.0323009044,
-0.5508196354,
0.2638620138,
-0.1001965478,
-0.1705098152,
-0.2096879929,
0.6770669818,
-0.267269969,
-0.3014563918,
-0.0738268793,
-0.0995819122,
-0.2238499969,
0.8529717922,
0.0729268417,
0.7509325147,
0.269289881,
-0.6906903982,
0.6674475074,
0.2065452635,
-0.6848248839,
0.6522350311,
-0.7340585589,
0.2649584115,
-0.0327423178,
0.2988595366,
-0.9564920068,
-0.1593503654,
-0.0694846585,
-0.1654737592,
0.0500348099,
0.439344883,
-0.6704492569,
-0.3846313953,
-0.2041794956,
0.1454404294,
0.579380095,
-0.6160159111,
0.4178552628,
0.185287714,
-0.370824486,
0.0988217741,
-0.606783092,
0.108723022,
0.0543249808,
-0.5291229486,
0.1077031493,
-0.3902436495,
-0.4040564001,
-0.341411829,
0.0626477152,
0.0887140259,
0.3458064795,
0.0157374926,
0.3234934211,
-0.1890378445,
0.2127885222,
-0.3710468113,
-0.0006507396,
0.3591758609,
-0.1098971739,
0.8080267906,
-0.4237070978,
-0.3046001792,
-0.2693632245,
0.2181904912,
0.3566274047,
-0.2923385501,
0.8782898188,
0.5705410242,
-0.1581477821,
-0.3729464412,
-0.3144513071,
-0.4982215762,
-0.4321649969,
0.7724625468,
-0.1707601249,
-0.8656229973,
0.3056305349,
-0.1092318892,
-0.0374966785,
-0.0606013834,
0.7296985388,
-0.2780233026,
1.2309508324,
0.6672933102,
0.0604911894,
0.7901540399,
-0.0173211619,
0.4307658076,
-0.752541244,
-0.2353128046,
-0.359983623,
-0.3681775033,
-0.6652030349,
-0.2536832988,
0.3755750358,
-0.0060806912,
-0.7594004869,
0.0403061062,
-0.1123600826,
0.2095030248,
0.5496092439,
0.1068482473,
0.2519790232,
-0.0324527994,
-0.1187937036,
0.0966535583,
-0.7989471555,
-0.373251915,
0.7105005383,
0.3258410096,
1.0491498709,
0.0169986058,
0.4835649431,
0.1163377613,
0.4977340698,
-0.7333277464,
0.836702764,
-0.0622386262,
-0.6741472483,
-0.5623152256,
-0.4315790236,
-0.8030919433,
0.2439684421,
-0.1111139581,
-1.0247863531,
-0.0203796644,
0.2423608303,
-0.3557911813,
-0.0755545646,
-0.6300603747,
0.8987869024,
-0.5517674685,
-0.5688883662,
-0.6079948545,
-0.3348980844,
0.384947747,
0.0601665042,
0.2626123428,
-0.2781088054,
-0.0136389406,
0.6558430195,
-0.2360647172,
0.8088518977,
-0.012845641,
-0.2850055397,
0.1062536761,
0.2792916596,
0.7254753709,
-0.2109778523,
-0.0728697404,
0.1398834586,
0.0378373116,
-0.4880791605,
-0.6591759324,
0.570735991,
-0.7784125805,
-0.620143652,
-0.1424595714,
-0.8410086632,
-0.7032536864,
-0.0228272751,
-0.0798215419,
0.2508102953,
-0.4755051732,
0.2438041419,
0.7429684997,
-0.6152720451,
0.301071018,
0.5437909365,
-0.3400253356,
-0.1306488067,
0.8174604774,
-0.1571046412,
0.2970670164,
0.2613102794,
0.3441857696,
-0.265009433,
-0.323238492,
-0.057847362,
0.2843351066,
-0.6422402263,
0.3838474452,
-0.5159521699,
-0.0259865951,
-0.2746223509,
-0.0983512253,
-0.3290857077,
-0.0062625776,
0.0611166172,
-0.227343902,
0.353849262,
0.6749299765,
-0.0547522642,
0.4088604748,
-0.5315334797,
0.2801847756,
0.3197582364,
0.6029506326,
0.4927517176,
-0.1916319281,
-0.2347942144,
-0.1660243571,
-0.1663170755,
-0.5161915421,
0.2265895456,
0.0488064624,
0.6320163608,
0.0014457097,
-0.2017102689,
0.4633761346,
-0.390854001,
0.695124805,
0.359118551,
-0.7594847083,
0.4266828001,
-0.5097638965,
0.3440105319,
0.3103537261,
0.2115733922,
-0.6887860894,
-0.32613042,
-0.5659014583,
-0.605263412,
0.6839168072,
-0.2988238037,
-0.0730840415,
-0.0561182201,
0.1593283713,
0.135983631,
0.4234859943,
-0.4859454036,
0.1659462005,
0.0441054925,
-0.4534286559,
-0.455635041,
0.0267715845,
-0.0980511904,
-0.3392995298,
0.6091504693,
-0.1499127448,
0.130903855,
-0.1150283366,
-0.306461066,
-0.0464054197,
0.3157583773,
0.3963707685,
0.6054795384,
-0.1728181392,
0.0534014218,
0.0926010162,
-0.2679864168,
0.2508868873,
-0.2209549099,
0.0158857889,
-0.5188167691,
0.5202066302,
0.7950707078,
0.2641801834,
-0.9298385978,
0.1834639907,
0.0076958858,
-0.0090748286,
-0.0574859083,
0.4338978827,
0.2454578727,
0.3296888471,
-0.0833646506,
-0.0509755351,
-0.0578740202,
-0.9763314724,
0.0822716802,
0.4105071127,
-0.4172356129,
-0.4002151489,
0.4198836088,
0.2454593331,
-0.4833244979,
0.8723349571,
-0.1901309639,
-0.3155964315,
0.6613998413,
0.3292418122,
0.5783993006,
-0.06024101,
0.2630510032,
0.4205995202,
0.2993284762,
-0.4554341137,
0.237996906,
0.0395313948,
-0.6695193052,
-0.4219947457,
-0.4133079946,
-0.4285897613,
0.247362107,
-0.6519759893,
0.0204802584,
-0.7666954398,
-0.10609667,
-0.1239928007,
0.1320560426,
-0.8800461888,
0.2145496607,
0.287014544,
0.9333675504,
-0.6908336282,
0.4223672748,
0.5885688663,
-0.2545304298,
-0.7123951912,
-0.1734065115,
-0.195848152,
-0.9741065502,
0.55830127,
0.0521610193,
0.0330010988,
-0.0426738076,
-0.8679605126,
-0.7229175568,
0.7319623828,
0.427139461,
-0.8501570225,
0.052304402,
0.013977713,
0.8678088784,
-0.3221493661,
0.2586483359,
1.0341018438,
0.4932276309,
-0.1437894106,
-0.726701498,
0.0952748284,
-0.0248393901,
-0.0677062869,
0.1285005957,
-0.8312196136,
0.8538529873,
-0.4804850817,
0.0830415264,
0.1538387537,
0.6111861467,
0.5465523601,
0.067377843,
0.3275562823,
0.4762657285,
1.0921006203,
0.0049594115,
1.1779308319,
-0.1614103317,
0.1892825663,
1.3551343679,
-0.3816364706,
0.9560388327,
0.4632490277,
-0.3400730491,
0.6398601532,
0.6475400329,
-0.1669620275,
0.4833445847,
0.6187308431,
0.1465915442,
-0.5074729919,
-0.0968911946,
0.0854307041,
0.2864599824,
0.4968098104,
0.0367900319,
-0.1235532314,
-0.1150038913,
-0.0617426448,
0.0710084066,
-0.4359550476,
0.6281705499,
0.2937847674,
-1.0875309706,
0.368403703,
-0.1868264526,
0.6650545001,
-0.4754342139,
0.1846467555,
-0.2323525399,
0.5026093721,
0.0533655956,
-0.5738204122,
0.0210499708,
-0.0861623958,
-0.2040208429,
-0.1466801614,
0.3630980849,
-0.4507079422,
-0.4721648395,
0.5629258156,
0.6919759512,
0.1504181772,
-0.0700778663,
-0.7088745236,
0.021192845,
-0.5257403851,
-0.3013236821,
0.4055279791,
0.3479903042,
-0.2510711551,
0.8252962232,
0.5708918571,
0.2604902089,
0.1403072327,
0.3002316654,
0.3156026006,
-0.8784621954,
-0.586535573,
-1.0154061317,
-0.0371128954,
0.0317883119,
-0.130815044,
0.5096145868,
0.1886534989,
0.8282405138,
-0.0543146841,
0.9102416039,
0.1359512061,
0.4265360832,
-0.3626065552,
0.3963922858,
-0.3365088999,
0.0918454677,
-0.0567823201,
-0.6827159524,
-0.0064008082,
0.5979758501,
-0.7027398944,
0.266653806,
0.7454586625,
0.9643173814,
0.1849128306,
0.0792047381,
0.5088413954,
0.5114031434,
0.5551601648,
0.7101334333,
1.1794769764,
-0.0654525012,
0.2882067263,
0.097210601,
-0.2083784789,
-0.3525268435,
-0.9682635665,
-1.0820481777,
-0.1344095469,
-0.3255968094,
-0.1633874774,
-0.0142052351,
1.0011848211,
0.8167324066,
-0.8618867993,
-0.5661988258,
-0.2932156622,
-0.0557044037,
-0.4348061383,
-0.180220589,
0.0118716061,
-0.4706439376,
-0.3913078606,
0.252063483,
0.3390263021,
-0.0808884725,
-0.5932124257,
-0.3210377693,
-0.0696802512,
0.2550103962,
0.5996791124,
0.0111903083,
-0.7226176262,
-0.2538710833,
0.1111176386,
-0.1415181607,
0.0694602653,
0.8357601166,
-0.5783252716,
0.0920198411,
0.5638316274,
0.4714919925,
0.3291690946,
-0.2570952773,
0.7727296352,
-0.5552738905,
0.043058306,
0.2109339535,
0.2901241779,
0.4034720957,
-0.2378204912,
0.4861955941,
0.0392312519,
-0.4642514884,
-0.7506198883,
0.2731676996,
-0.646430254,
-0.3632921875,
1.0426260233,
-0.0815924555,
-0.408046037,
0.0110164778,
-0.1437015831,
0.0270162616,
-0.5368822217,
0.9525523186,
1.2503941059,
-0.4122118354,
-0.4062682092,
-0.6522889137,
0.3609072566,
0.4990251958,
-0.938370347,
0.1998167485,
0.3764758706,
0.2922818065,
0.0793817192,
0.571315825,
0.1203109398,
0.3045435846,
0.0941906646,
0.1085845083,
0.1228728071,
-0.3622911274,
-0.2485602796,
0.0171380341,
0.2097001821,
0.3155002296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18223v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18223v2
|
Improving Open-Ended Text Generation via Adaptive Decoding
| 2024-02-28T10:38:21 | 2024-06-03T03:02:44 |
Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Zhiwei He, Yiming Ai, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current language models decode text token by token according to probabilistic
distribution, and determining the appropriate candidates for the next token is
crucial to ensure generation quality. This study introduces adaptive decoding,
a mechanism that dynamically empowers language models to ascertain a sensible
candidate set during generation. Specifically, we introduce an entropy-based
metric called confidence and conceptualize determining the optimal candidate
set as a confidence-increasing process. The rationality of including a token in
the candidate set is assessed by leveraging the increment of confidence.
Experimental results reveal that our method balances diversity and coherence
well. The human evaluation shows that our method can generate human-preferred
text. Additionally, our method can potentially improve the reasoning ability of
language models.
|
[
-0.0950693488,
-0.3352998495,
0.4184454381,
0.1789173186,
-0.4953450263,
0.1984751076,
-0.3199617267,
-0.3929941952,
-0.1773596406,
0.1749426872,
-0.2293707132,
-0.4890533686,
-0.4866072536,
0.334831655,
-0.3113952577,
0.8189432621,
-0.1479495466,
-0.1703344584,
-0.2438873798,
-0.021241596,
-0.447124809,
-0.2592995763,
-0.8082125783,
-0.3505842388,
0.188260749,
0.4027187824,
0.8368699551,
0.7801366448,
0.3782147467,
0.2740207911,
-0.065219827,
0.2585701048,
-0.4572556317,
0.5414684415,
-0.278478384,
-0.5930944085,
-0.3446324766,
-0.1931129843,
0.7037576437,
0.5010111928,
-0.1798915416,
0.0434623994,
0.1478567719,
0.4499387741,
-0.8817147613,
-0.1026564091,
-1.0962888002,
-0.1107238829,
-0.1584881246,
-0.8539889455,
-0.6883562803,
-0.5130352974,
0.0754388794,
-0.5570270419,
0.4243755043,
0.1216471568,
0.5969858766,
0.0612888969,
-0.0365938097,
-0.7197394967,
-0.6558491588,
0.7876778245,
-0.7054527998,
0.4625590742,
0.3987572491,
-0.0632885993,
-0.3356369734,
-0.7770221829,
-0.5530197024,
-0.0674919933,
0.3039569557,
0.3310202062,
-0.120503895,
0.0194533952,
-0.3228562474,
0.5160476565,
-0.2588490248,
-0.0294126347,
-0.1690292656,
-0.1952556521,
0.3849521875,
0.0418895707,
0.4576316774,
0.0313844495,
0.0389726944,
-0.3941724002,
-0.1531127244,
0.0643452927,
0.7860326171,
0.4815979898,
0.0911554992,
0.4817330241,
-0.248426646,
0.7422735095,
0.110945113,
0.0034535592,
0.2583047748,
-0.4763499796,
-0.160242632,
0.3146999776,
0.6740289927,
0.3337677717,
0.3351649642,
-0.1486779153,
-0.2351326793,
-0.0377038494,
0.3236745298,
-0.7225592732,
-0.2082211077,
0.422526449,
-0.6167317629,
-0.6427557468,
0.3189854324,
-0.6494953036,
-0.118902564,
0.1419509798,
0.1023701951,
-0.7084558606,
-0.3364449143,
0.5634616017,
-0.5983114839,
-0.0570572019,
0.1440346092,
-1.1929862499,
-0.0071241315,
0.5441893339,
0.9374683499,
-0.0441371761,
-0.0937749743,
-0.471006006,
0.1042343751,
-0.656914711,
0.6977148652,
-0.6666260958,
-0.2590719163,
0.0297854897,
-0.4069040716,
0.0768380985,
-0.3734889328,
0.6786538363,
-0.5853870511,
0.4185917079,
-0.0159988869,
-0.3802259564,
0.2172265053,
-0.0116664888,
-0.5679951906,
0.9057895541,
0.2666848302,
-0.9517902136,
0.6336886883,
-0.5710806847,
-0.398026973,
0.0740153641,
-0.0616274923,
-0.5136749744,
0.538126111,
0.2526224554,
0.3317883909,
-0.2228669524,
0.1131299734,
-0.1471235007,
-0.215995416,
0.4216074049,
-0.6482955217,
0.671882987,
0.5651055574,
-0.0552047715,
0.1064944342,
-0.9955263138,
0.2872145474,
0.0326777473,
-0.6831329465,
-0.4910298884,
0.2557326257,
-0.2093985528,
-0.2460525185,
0.1878454089,
-0.5159366131,
-0.1313067973,
-0.7958523631,
0.3088436723,
0.9318459034,
0.1632178277,
0.598105073,
-0.2674928308,
0.3295916021,
0.1507391185,
-0.1996788532,
-0.5250512362,
-0.5533187389,
-0.6624863148,
-0.1104887426,
0.5172905922,
0.4916688502,
-0.8553264737,
0.6974560618,
-0.2871910036,
-0.3052130938,
-0.7929543853,
0.0256624054,
0.2327852994,
0.2585843205,
0.1173579171,
-0.528989017,
-0.6222429872,
-0.3682231605,
-0.5888749361,
-0.476895839,
-0.188903138,
-0.0034750972,
0.1296066791,
0.1100520417,
1.1239613295,
-0.4474442303,
0.4219704568,
-0.0969506353,
0.3572074175,
0.0814957321,
0.5946593881,
0.3651322722,
-0.7904514074,
-0.3629990816,
0.2852535844,
-0.8084847331,
-0.0346475691,
-0.3900583088,
-0.3162938654,
0.2991320491,
0.4704645872,
-0.2859182656,
0.328744024,
0.4892882407,
-0.5476872921,
0.4134978354,
-0.4770737588,
0.2325129211,
-1.3812189102,
0.0251738187,
-0.3169641793,
-0.2064791769,
-0.6839657426,
0.2379651815,
-0.1197439805,
0.0579004996,
-0.1397654563,
0.4459607303,
-0.6165727377,
0.0295993369,
-0.5097227693,
0.0287009086,
-0.0894804969,
-0.0269525535,
0.0350657217,
0.7918741703,
0.4552986026,
-0.6279351711,
0.3335145116,
0.1404515058,
-0.5758631229,
0.6150022745,
-0.3667144179,
0.1453121156,
-0.396730274,
0.0263535921,
-0.8950186968,
-0.3923634887,
0.1386650652,
-0.8777199388,
0.1684798449,
0.2827169597,
-0.3746725917,
-0.2494813353,
-0.12378636,
0.4579543173,
0.6894002557,
-0.5922828913,
0.2600339949,
-0.0045209923,
-0.2242718041,
-0.4817230403,
-0.6276553869,
0.20970577,
-0.0288989376,
-0.5988895297,
0.2949963212,
-0.1499982327,
-0.3825185001,
0.0387071818,
-0.0612506457,
0.0164399594,
0.1748256385,
-0.2037052065,
-0.0260777678,
-0.245961383,
0.2918771505,
0.239527002,
-0.2188427895,
-0.2354500592,
-0.8352406621,
0.5411427021,
0.1526573002,
-0.1196959764,
-0.3206057847,
0.3544916213,
0.4888853133,
-0.358533293,
1.034276247,
0.5727451444,
-0.4453771114,
-0.3097556531,
-0.0483119451,
-0.0830825567,
-0.544901371,
0.4339657426,
-0.5820125937,
-0.7864898443,
0.4868962467,
0.1635311842,
0.3110643327,
0.2631978989,
0.8377788663,
0.1332835406,
1.0901366472,
0.8396885991,
0.2811769247,
0.6016212106,
0.4120074809,
0.2115661502,
-0.4800545573,
-0.1136952341,
-0.6567903757,
0.0383670591,
-0.5639739633,
-0.4565516114,
0.0917571411,
0.4036559463,
-0.0712284222,
0.1428888589,
-0.8000289798,
0.3606617451,
0.7357353568,
0.2096178979,
0.3798554242,
0.308459878,
-0.2538679242,
0.2022345662,
-0.8113849163,
-0.5507343411,
1.0900450945,
0.445489645,
0.6853944063,
0.0868377313,
0.7729249597,
0.2755434811,
0.2860268652,
-0.465964824,
0.2623957992,
-0.1112039611,
-0.4121745527,
-0.4115594923,
-0.6158755422,
-0.9966813326,
-0.0124011654,
-0.4366167486,
-0.6850732565,
0.3289567232,
0.3585017025,
-0.235060811,
0.3858911991,
-0.4522265196,
0.4639544189,
0.0910441652,
-0.2365699857,
-0.0968874246,
-0.3568186164,
0.2518333197,
-0.3433884382,
0.0440428965,
0.0638817921,
-0.1758051962,
0.6292651892,
-0.1928148568,
0.4827324152,
-0.0856793448,
-0.3721760213,
0.5706766248,
0.0178028699,
0.5693076253,
-0.0868360773,
-0.738289535,
-0.3018911481,
-0.3556923568,
-0.6219727993,
-0.5011103749,
0.3969697952,
-0.647218287,
-0.296828568,
-0.184999004,
-0.6845005155,
-0.1004873067,
0.340600282,
0.8286182284,
0.2213281095,
-0.3296395838,
0.3937176168,
0.6090776324,
-0.4669199586,
0.4808347821,
0.0202469938,
0.102016218,
-0.6169828176,
0.976026237,
-0.1366637945,
0.5926472545,
0.4121408165,
0.301273495,
-0.2067894936,
-0.8750071526,
-0.4228726923,
-0.2883543968,
-0.8076276779,
-0.3030813932,
-0.6671177745,
-0.1200093776,
-0.4658762813,
-0.4349869788,
-0.1416498423,
-0.270278573,
-0.5040124655,
-0.232989803,
0.2811373174,
0.3974123001,
-0.0228022151,
0.4996226728,
-0.7061047554,
0.2544334531,
0.1672895998,
0.6799464226,
0.0709287822,
-0.5265885592,
-0.3448277116,
0.2043640018,
-0.2320281863,
-0.9710717201,
0.2634579837,
0.4127859175,
0.4962079227,
0.2795552313,
0.3061019182,
0.3223561347,
-0.4721315205,
0.6834468842,
0.4416200221,
-1.10711658,
0.5836682916,
-0.4369350672,
0.4360137284,
0.5240152478,
0.0224458948,
-0.4158304632,
-0.7993527055,
-0.6584393382,
-0.7750615478,
0.5858899951,
0.5581485629,
0.3988249302,
-0.3446416557,
0.5532182455,
0.1763143241,
0.1156560406,
-0.6540639997,
0.2623316646,
-0.498390764,
-0.8790993094,
0.031352777,
-0.1519426703,
0.1114748269,
0.2276201546,
0.6654344797,
-0.3920606077,
0.4370613694,
0.2415821552,
0.20758757,
-0.4916541874,
0.4675462246,
0.5658290386,
0.4943312705,
-0.2617349625,
0.2214816958,
0.1498904824,
-0.6180187464,
0.2941088378,
-0.2566087842,
-0.2926592231,
0.1416994035,
0.4663055241,
1.002435565,
-0.2009911388,
-0.5846021175,
0.3233160377,
-0.1932660341,
-0.3401964009,
0.142051816,
0.3526378572,
0.016967589,
0.0145034045,
0.4779214859,
0.2995056212,
-0.050630983,
-0.7115190625,
0.4010922611,
0.4343555868,
-0.4075829387,
-0.2677037716,
0.6940402985,
0.2951951623,
-0.6497952342,
0.5891772509,
-0.2362814099,
-0.1252858937,
0.446377486,
1.0842264891,
1.0635819435,
-0.3947882056,
0.1431060731,
0.4747017622,
0.4095335901,
-0.3128648996,
0.4912354946,
0.0707021654,
-1.1157351732,
-0.1894006431,
-0.9838290215,
-0.189550072,
-0.2889123857,
-0.6643079519,
0.1645104736,
-0.3806100488,
-0.2487770021,
-0.2804968655,
-0.4125960469,
-0.3347172141,
0.4414389133,
-0.1269987226,
1.1000339985,
-0.6994224787,
0.7285534143,
0.468408227,
-0.0769597813,
-0.4341129065,
0.4609668255,
-0.5044276714,
-0.6641081572,
0.0506157167,
0.0701187402,
-0.2376152426,
0.2013190389,
-0.5607961416,
-0.7850109935,
1.0227843523,
0.4545887411,
-0.2875774503,
-0.0382430032,
-0.0576870888,
0.5751880407,
-0.6135427356,
0.0296312924,
0.507548511,
0.3678687215,
0.1139101461,
-0.6558583975,
0.1127403229,
-0.3247050941,
0.1252394021,
0.2687405944,
-0.248164326,
0.7784920931,
-0.3505586982,
-0.5828229785,
0.5162565708,
1.0783360004,
0.354046613,
0.2859604955,
0.6354631186,
0.3098121881,
1.0000561476,
0.0403639115,
0.916079402,
-0.4220537245,
0.1067389548,
0.9964866042,
0.0538426153,
0.99764961,
0.3477415442,
0.0664154068,
0.703148365,
0.5761695504,
0.2937773168,
0.5796924233,
0.2453633547,
-0.5662605762,
-0.2775247097,
0.0116015505,
-0.2150398791,
0.4165040851,
0.3451346457,
-0.6556437612,
-0.0272685643,
0.0820117295,
-0.22970815,
0.4142707884,
-0.2418069243,
0.8090624809,
-0.1194560304,
-1.0327841043,
0.5371118784,
0.4816068113,
0.6325691342,
-0.4486293495,
0.1935088784,
0.036258515,
0.2032606751,
-0.2321101278,
-0.8834187984,
0.2591633499,
0.1240836903,
-0.2932296693,
-0.1365967691,
0.8840918541,
-0.4890732765,
-0.5715301037,
-0.0335573927,
0.3334386945,
-0.0275450852,
0.1986971051,
-0.3928438723,
0.0699223056,
0.1683450937,
-0.1259808242,
0.0449240096,
0.6438603401,
0.0483818166,
0.4459634423,
0.8428874016,
0.2127276063,
0.0655677393,
-0.0817190185,
0.5727117062,
-0.5031478405,
-0.8507573605,
-0.9078735709,
0.5280345082,
-0.1415886879,
-0.3304364383,
0.5389419794,
0.3439425528,
0.7534863353,
-0.0044193529,
1.143804431,
0.0728506446,
0.2188802063,
-0.7100738883,
0.5789424777,
-0.4264029562,
0.2009058297,
-0.3026897907,
-0.8541798592,
-0.393215239,
0.6664847732,
0.0983804464,
0.048488427,
0.5426030159,
0.6808713675,
-0.1041696519,
0.1739457995,
0.1715013236,
-0.0994486511,
0.3504648805,
0.5078023672,
0.6654195189,
-0.4386372268,
0.6423959136,
0.3131383657,
-0.5842782259,
-0.0083099231,
-1.0728789568,
-0.6992350817,
-0.5425987244,
-0.0203668103,
-0.5645884871,
0.269800663,
0.8050248623,
0.5185108185,
-0.6609501243,
-0.1704284549,
-0.6401600838,
0.0514054932,
-0.2445271462,
-0.1908762902,
0.1516521424,
-0.6654598117,
-0.7794620395,
0.219634369,
0.3780216277,
0.1539659202,
-0.0985068232,
-0.3481897116,
0.03183515,
0.6979748607,
0.4178390503,
0.1063635498,
-0.4058071375,
-0.4452931583,
-0.0096854633,
-0.1171124205,
0.1148605198,
0.9369732738,
-0.5218412876,
0.7645359039,
0.7984125614,
0.6750664115,
-0.1267347634,
0.1295736879,
1.0937609673,
-1.03512609,
0.1712578982,
0.1169103384,
0.0309297927,
0.4475376308,
-0.5171306729,
0.1776088625,
0.2177582979,
-0.2968752086,
-1.0722011328,
0.4412907958,
-0.5921764374,
-0.5417938232,
0.9473264813,
-0.1157566458,
-0.1883251071,
-0.1791042387,
-0.0805173293,
0.4901072979,
-0.3684189916,
0.6782715917,
0.724327445,
0.1376320869,
-0.248233065,
-0.0378019623,
0.558798492,
0.3782047629,
-0.8775439858,
0.2421727926,
0.199777633,
0.0842275769,
0.3195824623,
0.9864479899,
-0.0609494001,
0.4419620037,
0.5171841979,
-0.049661126,
0.1888564229,
-0.3490915895,
-0.22596775,
0.4501586258,
0.3170965314,
-0.2008135021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18216v1
|
LLM Task Interference: An Initial Study on the Impact of Task-Switch in Conversational History
| 2024-02-28T10:19:05 | 2024-02-28T10:19:05 |
Akash Gupta, Ivaxi Sheth, Vyas Raina, Mark Gales, Mario Fritz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the recent emergence of powerful instruction-tuned large language models
(LLMs), various helpful conversational Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems
have been deployed across many applications. When prompted by users, these AI
systems successfully perform a wide range of tasks as part of a conversation.
To provide some sort of memory and context, such approaches typically condition
their output on the entire conversational history. Although this sensitivity to
the conversational history can often lead to improved performance on subsequent
tasks, we find that performance can in fact also be negatively impacted, if
there is a task-switch. To the best of our knowledge, our work makes the first
attempt to formalize the study of such vulnerabilities and interference of
tasks in conversational LLMs caused by task-switches in the conversational
history. Our experiments across 5 datasets with 15 task switches using popular
LLMs reveal that many of the task-switches can lead to significant performance
degradation.
|
[
-0.0651646852,
-1.2068263292,
0.4539175928,
-0.0457910895,
-0.0560012199,
0.0096746618,
-0.0001754201,
-0.7737638354,
0.1509779692,
0.9660351872,
-0.5243099928,
-0.0894561708,
-0.8010872006,
-0.3602018654,
-0.72094661,
0.9638364315,
0.0807743669,
-0.1441924423,
-0.4686944485,
0.2952431738,
-0.6469653249,
-0.7073468566,
-0.7010335922,
-0.4102950394,
0.255536288,
0.2523538768,
0.5757725835,
0.40125525,
0.7032675147,
0.3279758096,
-0.0685790107,
0.0864688605,
-0.8245803118,
0.3945191801,
-0.0727374703,
-0.8625745177,
-0.4821053445,
-0.1311644316,
0.3510170877,
0.7250155807,
0.0833822861,
-0.0825977251,
0.3389047682,
0.3465856016,
-0.5385234356,
0.1899810284,
-0.8253545761,
0.0410114676,
-0.5732243061,
-0.3469318449,
-0.5533742905,
0.2420336753,
0.0151739586,
-0.2789615691,
0.0086449822,
-0.1137337685,
0.5501089096,
0.554913342,
-0.5088974833,
-0.0307042766,
-1.0659580231,
0.9012644887,
-0.6660728455,
0.2765321732,
0.4868969023,
-0.181765914,
-0.2652691305,
-0.6190374494,
-0.2909366786,
-0.6005410552,
-0.0817687586,
0.0428393856,
-0.5376020074,
0.1871452481,
0.365257889,
0.0819102526,
-0.0893318057,
0.2560982108,
-0.3044278026,
-0.1244452521,
0.5649725199,
0.6345167756,
0.3172723949,
0.0350278467,
-0.2122057825,
0.3319708407,
-0.840362072,
0.0592732094,
0.4974570572,
0.2316368371,
0.1336483508,
0.6201209426,
-0.267495364,
0.7074314356,
0.0973857418,
-0.0162214935,
-0.2105137557,
-0.5674032569,
-0.1718428731,
-0.3669669628,
0.7664705515,
0.276245743,
0.1150857806,
-0.4964842498,
0.178691417,
0.0483920574,
0.5867844224,
-0.4661558568,
-0.0884087905,
0.0291908551,
-0.2219988704,
-0.1226653755,
-0.2042126656,
-0.2737616003,
-0.3220721483,
-0.1877580136,
0.190375194,
-0.2324668914,
0.1062122658,
-0.2082922012,
0.1956395805,
0.0576281212,
0.4668773711,
-0.6086916327,
0.6112997532,
0.799292028,
0.6524267197,
-0.7118917704,
-0.5574886799,
-0.4953921437,
0.0490321554,
-0.0971238539,
0.4218456447,
-0.5568224788,
-0.7958420515,
0.0943282694,
-0.0939020813,
-0.127475813,
-0.6250473857,
0.395632267,
-0.7330860496,
-0.0211879555,
-0.1189217567,
-0.4933249056,
0.0457946733,
0.0223057512,
-0.6381722689,
0.8962248564,
-0.3974136114,
-0.4142359197,
0.1641493142,
-0.2995530367,
-1.0617864132,
0.0029412201,
-0.0336607955,
-0.1298402548,
-0.2004425973,
-0.2482632399,
0.3950988948,
-0.1851835698,
0.0653550029,
0.0129711255,
-0.4496927857,
0.4056425989,
-0.5643382072,
0.6754069328,
-0.0704806298,
-0.6560691595,
-0.0820768997,
-0.2361991704,
-0.1173774749,
-0.2438899726,
-0.2381681353,
-0.3174664974,
0.2983813286,
0.0269426852,
0.134002164,
0.4136963487,
-0.2769385874,
0.1430557072,
-0.1428682208,
0.2462192625,
0.5290584564,
0.0980240628,
0.1356288642,
-0.5568196177,
0.5331405997,
0.2802390456,
0.258569032,
-0.2604266107,
-0.7095402479,
-0.766233325,
0.1977820545,
0.0327405706,
0.845795989,
-0.3998184204,
0.2004067302,
0.1361283511,
-0.2422362417,
-0.1848808527,
0.3683206141,
0.6086804867,
0.2304444164,
0.1087109521,
-0.3273040652,
-0.4523144662,
-0.8929761648,
-0.4650644958,
-0.2342617214,
0.2760877907,
0.8032330871,
0.4017533362,
-0.2377969623,
0.9598858953,
-0.4022521973,
-0.187966153,
-0.1040741801,
0.0607734732,
0.0876128152,
0.5505587459,
0.1236721128,
-0.3921282291,
-0.2632555366,
-0.0557787381,
-0.3653854132,
-0.2186103314,
-0.4455378354,
-0.3724434078,
0.3129594624,
0.8425705433,
-0.7659938335,
0.4142538905,
0.5068261027,
-0.2563294768,
0.5497514606,
0.0043792194,
0.3544452488,
-0.8514075875,
0.0860103294,
-0.084586218,
-0.1398258507,
-0.9063646793,
-0.2960640192,
-0.1287019551,
0.2392002642,
-0.5741476417,
0.3664126694,
-0.2330821902,
0.0752470493,
-0.2313905656,
0.0698510185,
-0.3354925215,
0.4397259355,
-0.1403759271,
0.637950182,
0.2034605443,
-0.6394850016,
0.1179723516,
0.3564000726,
-0.1837407649,
0.4749652445,
-0.435084641,
0.4460519254,
0.4383043349,
0.0377745032,
-0.8999243379,
-0.0359425843,
0.3778245151,
-0.2166454643,
0.3636833429,
-0.0990455225,
-0.21638228,
0.0751910731,
-0.0496798269,
0.5295683146,
0.2714565992,
-0.1976633668,
0.2078686059,
0.6072722673,
-0.2259675562,
-0.4866025448,
-0.6742138863,
0.553638041,
-0.0175622534,
-0.5376982689,
0.5527099371,
-0.2103092074,
-0.3638578951,
-0.065755941,
-0.1003301963,
-0.1833939552,
0.2875705957,
0.659286797,
0.4338888824,
0.0915518552,
-0.1130850017,
-0.1101661399,
0.1354289353,
0.2084797174,
0.2675309479,
0.6241385937,
0.0708664209,
-0.7895708084,
-0.5525730848,
0.3486162424,
0.570039928,
-0.0265655741,
0.4990791976,
-0.029874105,
-0.2222140729,
0.0349852405,
-0.6525774598,
-0.1965199709,
-0.425861448,
0.6795554757,
-0.1774916798,
-1.0140464306,
0.5042466521,
-0.2181190401,
0.1505283862,
0.1538295448,
0.6307249665,
-0.3353338838,
0.7998759747,
0.458116591,
-0.4177551568,
0.9778885245,
-0.0061378251,
0.2631745636,
-0.6304740906,
-0.2658936679,
-0.4312557876,
-0.4450439215,
-0.5822917223,
-0.4756463468,
0.1971917897,
-0.071983844,
-0.0869407728,
0.1116499305,
-0.0100801094,
0.4823566079,
0.6607146263,
0.3706526458,
0.3747017086,
-0.4308106005,
0.6686428189,
0.0146585023,
-0.5536710024,
-0.3493086398,
1.1649763584,
0.0171274543,
0.9925295711,
-0.0608562343,
0.7849096656,
0.6840435863,
-0.27700302,
-0.6597704887,
0.782556355,
-0.1859800518,
-0.4877005517,
-0.4500880539,
-0.132709071,
-1.4390968084,
0.0346797965,
-0.0740050897,
-1.0630933046,
-0.2731190622,
0.2604759634,
-0.1429874003,
0.1067984775,
-0.6768989563,
0.7127816677,
-0.4516364336,
-0.623043716,
-0.3737099767,
-0.6186121106,
0.6039897203,
0.1243055463,
-0.0901210308,
-0.0466802977,
-0.0161032975,
0.6435713768,
0.0470829234,
1.4720112085,
0.0988997146,
0.0871569216,
0.0551094748,
0.2415516227,
0.7322362661,
-0.2183019966,
0.2992108166,
0.4150939286,
-0.1121407375,
-0.1726867706,
-0.4042565227,
0.7147490382,
-0.7485786676,
-1.2419323921,
-0.2058626562,
-0.9105353951,
-0.3181591928,
0.1760938168,
0.0138333486,
0.2554528415,
-0.5596356392,
0.0864762738,
0.6991308928,
0.2634761035,
0.3179035783,
0.3908308744,
-0.0431330316,
0.3066113293,
0.6539896131,
0.0723257214,
0.4174875915,
0.2917784452,
-0.2419245988,
0.2451486886,
-0.699837327,
-0.169806689,
-0.0631300434,
-0.3961156309,
-0.0264620222,
-0.5135181546,
-0.2547641098,
-0.131779924,
-0.0117972642,
-0.3317351937,
-0.309143573,
-0.6695957184,
0.2414193749,
0.1482743472,
0.9662672281,
0.3038745522,
0.2281427681,
-0.7288679481,
0.1677442938,
0.2872384191,
0.1591460258,
-0.1760151982,
-0.3867170811,
-0.4028214812,
0.0103456192,
-0.3994493783,
-1.0468678474,
-0.0549281947,
0.1227376014,
0.9577108622,
0.4424417615,
-0.0359704532,
0.4273167253,
-0.4608996809,
1.0016332865,
0.1288218051,
-0.9312168956,
0.4381819069,
-0.363668859,
0.4595199525,
0.2932100594,
0.032372918,
-0.8479944468,
-0.8042191863,
-0.5730096102,
-0.9900537133,
1.0148466825,
0.3249869645,
0.2795392573,
-0.0324027538,
0.1603173018,
0.2469805181,
0.1820905805,
-0.3713531494,
-0.5515178442,
0.1838041842,
0.2136092484,
-0.0931147933,
-0.3021355867,
-0.4239837825,
-0.0142005971,
0.5271483064,
0.098550193,
0.2773789465,
-0.3018074632,
-0.5228813887,
-0.1114043295,
0.2420514375,
0.7659761906,
0.6505564451,
0.2464640588,
0.1424844861,
0.4183656871,
-0.4849908352,
-0.0870525315,
-0.0706942156,
-0.195364058,
-0.1185865551,
0.3605110347,
0.9540587664,
0.7511571646,
-0.6469538808,
0.1830647588,
0.0996083841,
0.0392106324,
-0.0507011376,
0.4583684206,
0.1462359875,
0.611136198,
0.146197632,
0.1628471613,
0.1172876731,
-0.6344587803,
0.3207368255,
0.9047184587,
-0.080504559,
-0.0460623689,
0.4002797604,
0.447981298,
-0.7897410989,
0.5272283554,
0.2460535169,
-0.5337420106,
0.7622076273,
0.6067257524,
0.8989648223,
-0.3053477407,
-0.0564098768,
-0.1149372458,
0.4397337139,
0.1438738406,
-0.0425633453,
-0.1830128282,
-0.6699550748,
-0.366799891,
-0.0082908031,
-0.8417232633,
0.0490096398,
-0.7610805631,
-0.104701601,
0.0392628647,
-0.453779608,
-0.2394154519,
-0.144293353,
-0.7308660746,
-0.1052989885,
0.3559159636,
0.4226955771,
-0.5556029677,
0.7391015887,
0.4883328378,
0.1888326108,
0.0168185048,
0.2792336941,
0.0009201274,
-0.92141819,
0.8184341788,
-0.274651438,
-0.383774668,
-0.2103185803,
-0.2304392606,
-0.8900301456,
0.9443151355,
0.3703387678,
-0.7333838344,
0.100924328,
0.6571190357,
0.3641217053,
-0.1344732195,
0.2963830233,
1.0012998581,
0.2456421852,
-0.097351484,
-1.0770560503,
0.0352589786,
-0.2139206082,
-0.1447073072,
0.5064134002,
-0.7592176199,
0.6827656031,
-0.0981469974,
-0.1423533708,
0.0073470194,
0.3943135142,
-0.0609049462,
0.3699949384,
0.4817380607,
0.3187806606,
0.6789284945,
-0.1263305098,
0.8548913002,
-0.5634123683,
0.0328099318,
1.1482949257,
-0.3673223555,
0.8733433485,
0.7777075171,
-0.5360850096,
0.0240385905,
0.3847322166,
0.1906754971,
0.2775227427,
0.118515864,
-0.2646474242,
-0.3109342456,
-0.0104284538,
-0.2983869016,
0.4756359458,
0.3340723217,
-0.1919368654,
0.0575476289,
-0.1304233074,
0.4315358102,
-0.4364720881,
-0.1216548234,
0.6977078915,
-0.054490611,
-0.8460671902,
0.1902128458,
-0.34895432,
0.8763949275,
-0.6185829043,
-0.0028925519,
-0.2116779834,
-0.0077378522,
-0.211060077,
-0.6518347859,
0.2058012187,
-0.1459944099,
-0.2804379463,
-0.330556035,
0.8003461361,
-0.4311464131,
-0.1653978229,
0.2612403631,
0.7229550481,
0.0892307833,
0.0204295702,
-0.4484563172,
0.2884532213,
0.0154479574,
-0.4839123189,
0.7557311058,
-0.1877726018,
-0.0979095399,
0.484272033,
0.5508082509,
-0.2235447466,
0.2869430184,
-0.2547034621,
0.7686985731,
-0.7144488096,
-0.3117464483,
-0.9973726869,
0.3085644543,
0.0016096684,
-0.3623883724,
0.7510444522,
0.4864594638,
0.7668096423,
0.2113454789,
0.8454173803,
-0.0238136854,
0.1585093141,
-0.5331534743,
0.7293612957,
-0.3084808588,
0.4837431014,
-0.1529952139,
-0.4008310437,
0.0902449265,
-0.0314522013,
-0.3607516885,
0.1149177551,
0.7218258381,
0.7612806559,
0.2365654707,
0.0220450424,
0.5936233997,
0.2920750082,
0.3669084013,
0.5144962668,
0.9632827044,
-0.0603202879,
0.6664143801,
-0.2412768304,
-0.1445559114,
-0.5742278099,
-0.5979309082,
-0.7395234108,
-0.6629220843,
-0.5079995394,
-0.2352805138,
0.5382911563,
0.2655538321,
0.4058051407,
-0.5686795712,
-0.6779153943,
0.0448452719,
0.2580053508,
-0.3791549206,
-0.1954116523,
0.0494331717,
-0.402069658,
-0.9370468855,
0.5213502049,
0.1986605674,
-0.3149728775,
-0.192893222,
-0.0903537646,
-0.1954921037,
0.1486171931,
0.6392924786,
0.4690545201,
-0.8801237941,
-0.2188768387,
0.0068832142,
-0.3092569411,
0.0622134097,
1.1623575687,
-0.6480828524,
0.304407686,
0.284108758,
0.7715004086,
0.7355339527,
-0.2031142861,
0.5145205259,
-0.5942313671,
-0.0953451619,
0.3472779393,
0.3461222053,
-0.2440166324,
-0.6224782467,
0.1223262846,
0.1561286896,
-0.7381649017,
-0.7370616794,
0.230546236,
-1.1410551071,
-0.2440600395,
1.2034758329,
-0.0796270147,
0.104076311,
-0.3406024873,
-0.4133202434,
0.2363657653,
-0.360897541,
0.9177418351,
0.8579460382,
-0.8247752786,
-0.0130164586,
-0.8055746555,
0.3477067351,
0.7457304597,
-1.1710247993,
0.0840053558,
0.5566224456,
-0.0575807802,
-0.0449770875,
0.514536202,
0.2788133323,
0.4423999488,
-0.0146340216,
-0.0501954965,
-0.1029987931,
-0.1254831702,
-0.0056251138,
0.1498334408,
0.0910717174,
-0.4080357254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18209v1
|
DANSK and DaCy 2.6.0: Domain Generalization of Danish Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-28T10:01:00 | 2024-02-28T10:01:00 |
Kenneth Enevoldsen, Emil Trenckner Jessen, Rebekah Baglini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named entity recognition is one of the cornerstones of Danish NLP, essential
for language technology applications within both industry and research.
However, Danish NER is inhibited by a lack of available datasets. As a
consequence, no current models are capable of fine-grained named entity
recognition, nor have they been evaluated for potential generalizability issues
across datasets and domains. To alleviate these limitations, this paper
introduces: 1) DANSK: a named entity dataset providing for high-granularity
tagging as well as within-domain evaluation of models across a diverse set of
domains; 2) DaCy 2.6.0 that includes three generalizable models with
fine-grained annotation; and 3) an evaluation of current state-of-the-art
models' ability to generalize across domains. The evaluation of existing and
new models revealed notable performance discrepancies across domains, which
should be addressed within the field. Shortcomings of the annotation quality of
the dataset and its impact on model training and evaluation are also discussed.
Despite these limitations, we advocate for the use of the new dataset DANSK
alongside further work on the generalizability within Danish NER.
|
[
-0.6729508042,
-0.5653966665,
0.4408693016,
0.1340429783,
-0.2922869921,
-0.1592203379,
-0.3644925356,
-0.9171888828,
0.1663342118,
0.4855024517,
-0.1514386833,
-0.658649981,
-0.7809839845,
0.423061043,
-0.3848567307,
0.8686580658,
-0.1596469879,
-0.0088661481,
-0.3023181558,
-0.1472133994,
-0.6975977421,
-0.6500973701,
-0.864156723,
-0.2954271436,
0.4273065329,
0.249257192,
0.5134030581,
0.4786270559,
0.7600883842,
0.1824606955,
-0.3756747544,
0.1237424761,
-0.4217386842,
0.1770748049,
-0.4126567245,
-0.0644145012,
-0.8723987937,
-0.158878848,
0.8944086432,
0.9560745358,
-0.0603711754,
0.0214538518,
0.061340671,
0.7700522542,
-0.6860336065,
0.3739443719,
-0.6382058859,
-0.19019714,
-0.1050770432,
0.3435018659,
-0.1290247142,
0.070051834,
0.400490284,
-1.1232732534,
0.4327654839,
-0.1236882061,
1.0120658875,
0.2992787659,
-0.4318477809,
-0.5194077492,
-0.9363186955,
0.7983375192,
-0.5445527434,
0.6255968213,
0.5198764205,
0.5313649774,
-0.2060941905,
-0.704857409,
-0.4939451218,
-0.2018453479,
-0.0433512628,
-0.1169735715,
-0.0420165807,
0.1932056099,
0.3236276507,
0.4635400772,
-0.2633029222,
0.1904518008,
-0.2778448761,
0.0977677926,
0.8326471448,
0.2236363888,
0.0128557952,
-0.1186929792,
-0.3497867286,
-0.0032407772,
-0.5110914111,
-0.1115126386,
0.4621174634,
0.3381377459,
-0.1686920673,
0.2708097398,
-0.3579622805,
0.7043397427,
0.3348065317,
0.1392881125,
0.1850991845,
-0.0826368406,
-0.1967116147,
0.0585911162,
0.3508494496,
0.4044321477,
0.2772418261,
-0.2079444081,
-0.4630000293,
0.0153042665,
0.2079690695,
-0.4474647343,
-0.5386937857,
0.2014472336,
-0.4295515418,
-0.2466689348,
0.314153254,
-0.654925406,
-0.4212530553,
-0.6279003024,
0.2238945216,
0.0830306113,
-0.7080413699,
0.2889437377,
-0.2177302837,
0.0585815795,
0.6177217364,
-1.0493407249,
0.8407374024,
0.856957078,
0.476911366,
-0.4779370427,
0.0300380588,
-0.0525609143,
0.1625134498,
-0.5142146349,
0.6681429148,
-0.6800687313,
-0.5556365848,
-0.1921416521,
0.2181832641,
-0.0804773346,
-0.8703351021,
0.4601415098,
-0.624951005,
-0.3164700866,
-0.4047227502,
-0.7501499057,
-0.2247206122,
0.2659151554,
-1.052472353,
1.0659463406,
0.2691588998,
-1.0246165991,
0.6280614138,
-0.597073257,
-0.0969980732,
0.1824622452,
-0.4127830267,
-0.1041932181,
0.4128424227,
-0.0178379994,
0.7065902948,
-0.4035467207,
0.5385472775,
-0.4021519721,
-0.2629400194,
-0.030637037,
-0.2469579875,
0.4491407871,
0.0599497706,
-0.0105991988,
-0.4975965321,
-0.9717912674,
-0.2304068953,
0.1896301508,
-0.6388819218,
-0.7684835196,
-0.0822533742,
0.3201465011,
0.2381795049,
0.1356943101,
-0.5526355505,
0.2924223244,
-0.4654869139,
0.0398473553,
0.6394140124,
0.0831802636,
0.562286377,
0.0071775187,
0.3212276995,
0.0633892044,
-0.0090892222,
0.3278431296,
-0.5273085833,
-0.7071816921,
-0.315071553,
1.0515027046,
0.3470319808,
-0.7636744976,
0.1896483004,
-0.5986035466,
-0.227602765,
-0.1915646046,
-0.2489746809,
0.1930562556,
0.3295930624,
0.3751700521,
-0.5002041459,
-0.7060734034,
-1.1679748297,
-0.2904980183,
-0.0452853329,
0.1191206053,
0.6338027716,
0.6056080461,
-0.3432345986,
0.9463384151,
-0.3019321561,
-0.0457013249,
-0.1771504581,
0.0712512955,
0.3527035415,
0.5077208877,
0.4913279414,
-1.2234172821,
-0.7058110833,
0.1067201793,
-0.5695971251,
-0.0128292525,
0.0555042736,
0.1639734358,
0.1552326232,
0.3749870956,
-0.550840795,
0.6130645275,
0.3661435544,
-0.1754881591,
0.6953661442,
-0.0000346793,
0.0734185427,
-0.945949316,
0.1226199791,
-0.0809772238,
-0.4004485011,
-0.7625121474,
-0.2174888998,
0.0649184212,
0.0831028447,
-0.4297874272,
1.204714179,
-0.5567111969,
0.0314054415,
-0.3392103016,
-0.0745509416,
-0.0400821306,
0.0561433546,
0.2027442455,
0.5153442621,
0.6365360618,
-1.072396636,
0.4785524607,
0.3650342226,
-0.2420761287,
0.8745835423,
-0.5767030716,
-0.0352862179,
0.0292310398,
0.2280948311,
-0.4469218254,
-0.5256206989,
0.317266494,
-0.3873303533,
0.9156030416,
-0.489109844,
-0.4871629775,
-0.3444216847,
-0.0025957853,
0.5215826631,
0.3674449623,
-0.7483748198,
0.6390798092,
0.5736196041,
-0.2389951497,
-0.7291821837,
-0.5370966792,
0.3099771142,
-0.1655920446,
-0.4423069656,
0.4976872504,
0.1076859087,
-0.3430381417,
0.2434362769,
-0.5833709836,
-0.4551549852,
0.1463767141,
0.3167159855,
0.0036426855,
-0.0987805277,
0.3614942133,
0.0966517627,
-0.3978174329,
0.0550422892,
-0.3293118477,
0.0927436352,
0.0448775478,
0.0122629432,
-0.3923967779,
0.4158495367,
-0.0249541085,
0.0680749193,
0.546443522,
0.3416288495,
-0.8200833201,
-0.337046206,
-0.5407045484,
0.1152460724,
-0.426799655,
0.3188076913,
-0.7133775353,
-0.9305793643,
0.3742612898,
-0.4785406291,
-0.1798882782,
0.9760251045,
0.5188068151,
-0.0911851004,
0.6283169985,
0.9747419357,
0.1897892058,
0.0902819335,
-0.4288165569,
0.2572475374,
-0.9735220075,
-0.1276969314,
-0.4378071725,
-0.2307730019,
-0.7056183219,
-0.24091883,
-0.1014240682,
0.2824841738,
0.2507736087,
0.3771356046,
-0.5132719874,
0.5681981444,
0.2214110792,
-0.4824371338,
0.2169307917,
0.0646683201,
-0.3810286224,
0.0974474996,
-0.5398074985,
-0.8085476756,
1.0918118954,
0.3085263669,
0.8470557928,
-0.200556159,
0.839928329,
0.478213042,
0.0421532914,
-0.5604628921,
0.4582565427,
-0.4411902428,
-0.999484241,
-0.0718694553,
-0.3732143641,
-0.9853468537,
-0.0488285944,
-0.076537028,
-0.7752239108,
0.865073204,
0.2323090136,
-0.1876718402,
0.4098726511,
-0.4379013479,
0.7006253004,
0.2481675893,
0.1018446237,
-0.0820706636,
-0.6290912628,
0.067705065,
-0.3220707178,
0.0436980203,
-0.4585435092,
-0.0455978364,
0.979960978,
0.0504822545,
0.7141587734,
-0.3874617517,
-0.2147301584,
0.3520181775,
-0.0588140897,
0.4068379998,
0.3376591504,
0.0678881258,
0.6744550467,
0.2286321521,
-0.1810784489,
-0.3619461954,
0.9625800252,
-0.4496697187,
-0.3731011748,
-0.4805072546,
-0.3208872676,
-0.1850453913,
0.1231785193,
0.1527942717,
0.3207676411,
-0.606652081,
-0.0285069868,
0.7682734132,
-0.1037390009,
0.3141553104,
0.4567433894,
-0.025450943,
-0.5312174559,
0.891729176,
0.358091414,
0.0209790263,
0.2204187214,
-0.4389529526,
-0.1680438966,
-0.5326453447,
-0.2538436353,
0.2999632657,
-0.8665763736,
-0.2520780563,
-1.0069769621,
-0.1388802975,
-0.3636566401,
-0.082006529,
-0.534131825,
-1.037681818,
-0.3987616301,
-0.1034643427,
0.0456269756,
1.2215001583,
-0.2960666716,
0.2027656287,
-0.5394406319,
0.655379951,
0.2347456962,
0.7247276306,
-0.0563319921,
-0.2492162883,
-0.5069736838,
-0.1063494384,
-0.1234400123,
-0.7429842949,
-0.087965399,
0.2144420147,
0.4914018214,
0.1795500964,
-0.1084731668,
0.2318745852,
-0.6947582364,
0.639318049,
0.0211681481,
-0.7829139233,
0.3278520703,
-0.3277793825,
-0.2198475003,
0.5306566358,
0.4464235902,
-0.7207773924,
0.1715178341,
-0.9575672746,
-0.9998291731,
0.6787210703,
0.2367375791,
0.1664645672,
-0.1576959044,
0.7596496344,
0.5363604426,
0.3212737739,
-0.2657934725,
-0.3068546057,
0.1765404195,
-0.1056858748,
0.0113615198,
-0.6037355661,
0.1587522775,
-0.2446644306,
0.9255095124,
0.1565033793,
0.364323765,
0.2518660724,
-0.1551926881,
0.0240538046,
0.3180045485,
0.0447381772,
0.6931828856,
-0.2173126787,
0.0628449395,
0.2939459383,
-0.6353642344,
0.1948630959,
0.4200540781,
-0.1012041867,
0.4238533974,
0.1699066758,
0.6397348046,
0.0216109883,
-0.1704598814,
0.4214578271,
-0.1645099521,
-0.2139572501,
-0.2632395327,
0.1544827968,
-0.0044671581,
0.2713451684,
0.0568796583,
-0.0932806656,
0.3696753085,
0.2444122136,
0.1365741342,
0.1887939721,
-0.3474136889,
-0.5456402302,
0.6046540141,
0.2693661749,
0.0408602469,
0.4934676588,
-0.4737032056,
-0.2466691285,
0.7831929922,
0.2906271219,
1.0378336906,
-0.3103914857,
0.0243312996,
0.4745459855,
0.2495334595,
-0.1970671117,
0.5266159773,
0.0141542628,
-0.5766275525,
-0.1963315159,
-0.6684492826,
-0.3651721478,
0.1531070322,
-0.7601032257,
0.4511380792,
-0.4341430664,
-0.6380804181,
0.2319399863,
0.1590195745,
-1.1854255199,
0.5031833649,
0.3568048179,
0.961943686,
-0.7471511364,
0.6797323227,
1.1007483006,
-0.051344797,
-0.3755815923,
-0.2075108439,
-0.1788578928,
-0.2709065676,
0.8710258007,
0.2686228752,
0.2912210226,
0.0546034351,
-0.604650259,
-0.9899975657,
1.0275518894,
0.0663989261,
-0.5721784234,
-0.1453533173,
0.188098222,
0.4614587724,
-0.533315897,
-0.2881726921,
0.5914398432,
0.6714698076,
-0.3581683338,
-1.1745280027,
-0.1950478405,
-0.2061986476,
0.3205535114,
0.3486352861,
-0.2381969541,
0.7567868829,
0.0479036011,
-0.4974091649,
-0.0025686522,
0.5016736388,
-0.1808326691,
0.4136266112,
0.3641920388,
0.9876663685,
0.7189128995,
-0.1677821279,
1.1265587807,
0.0322682858,
0.6356887817,
1.3671090603,
-0.2663152814,
0.6179544926,
0.4001845717,
-0.184598133,
0.2032479197,
0.7538107634,
-0.1690625995,
0.5277543068,
0.3459676206,
-0.2400622815,
-0.2219597548,
-0.3963344395,
-0.4557013214,
0.2301234752,
0.5978893638,
-0.1192263812,
-0.3241998851,
-0.1217941046,
-0.1220780835,
-0.374868691,
-0.2594723701,
0.9395407438,
0.3248185813,
0.1241781935,
0.6824579239,
0.3570609987,
0.4292367995,
-0.3179872632,
-0.3466409445,
0.065005742,
-0.0087944996,
-0.1944481134,
-0.4177585542,
0.2159475833,
0.0221275017,
-0.435729295,
0.223790288,
1.0715157986,
-0.2590743005,
-0.3871456385,
0.4220403135,
0.4053899348,
0.3073557615,
-0.2115927339,
-0.7876541615,
-0.2005195171,
-0.4732877612,
-0.3254478574,
0.1134929582,
0.6099068522,
-0.2375926375,
0.3192109466,
0.3474405408,
0.1019484103,
0.0653398633,
0.0312859155,
0.9975709915,
-0.5719915032,
-0.3701330125,
-0.5081349015,
0.4270147085,
-0.0874640644,
-0.2331440151,
0.5564392805,
0.5879603028,
1.247721076,
-0.1239201576,
0.8166559935,
-0.1496703625,
0.5590206981,
-0.3309352398,
0.4526464641,
-0.5262778997,
0.2119263858,
-0.1429358125,
-1.290251255,
-0.3901623487,
0.341724813,
-0.4210777879,
0.2632302046,
0.6482969522,
0.3413667381,
-0.5024811625,
-0.0614150763,
0.4312908351,
0.4191420376,
0.1395867765,
0.2797273993,
0.882101655,
-0.4975421429,
-0.1426740736,
-0.2874527872,
-0.0024220231,
-0.3094661534,
-0.8422784209,
-0.9742359519,
-0.5908716917,
-0.4017204046,
-0.1087619439,
0.3471772373,
0.8704441786,
0.6875851154,
-1.0689945221,
0.0624178015,
0.0917428508,
-0.1057861969,
-0.0423996858,
-0.180698961,
0.5550673604,
-0.3016848266,
-0.6454519629,
0.209528625,
0.3155357242,
0.2484498471,
0.2024452239,
-0.087551862,
-0.1333788186,
0.1598582864,
0.2118708342,
0.1500102282,
-0.7177942395,
-0.0624379441,
-0.266508311,
0.0399435274,
0.177497074,
0.7679573894,
-0.7217153907,
0.6209078431,
0.3389114439,
0.7833759189,
0.2330899686,
-0.0818717927,
0.2775098383,
-0.7367035747,
-0.0853212327,
0.3221068382,
0.2718426287,
0.4772601128,
-0.475980401,
0.7840870023,
0.237387687,
-0.5061735511,
-0.6191577315,
0.158619076,
-0.7902150154,
-0.0369266719,
1.1768832207,
-0.144176349,
-0.0170068163,
-0.383995533,
-0.0650766119,
0.135551855,
-0.3847017288,
0.4480195045,
1.1077827215,
0.0768056661,
0.4885708988,
-0.9478626847,
0.6859405041,
0.0321820751,
-0.5929813385,
0.2854242027,
0.461871773,
0.3241728544,
-0.0716623738,
0.6283504963,
-0.132646367,
0.3103510439,
0.0739227384,
0.2894662917,
-0.0404438712,
-0.7889844775,
-0.6966289878,
-0.3044389784,
0.0920931697,
0.0679458603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18191v1
|
Clustering and Ranking: Diversity-preserved Instruction Selection through Expert-aligned Quality Estimation
| 2024-02-28T09:27:29 | 2024-02-28T09:27:29 |
Yuan Ge, Yilun Liu, Chi Hu, Weibin Meng, Shimin Tao, Xiaofeng Zhao, Hongxia Ma, Li Zhang, Hao Yang, Tong Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With contributions from the open-source community, a vast amount of
instruction tuning (IT) data has emerged. Given the significant resource
allocation required by training and evaluating models, it is advantageous to
have an efficient method for selecting high-quality IT data. However, existing
methods for instruction data selection have limitations such as relying on
fragile external APIs, being affected by biases in GPT models, or reducing the
diversity of the selected instruction dataset. In this paper, we propose an
industrial-friendly, expert-aligned and diversity-preserved instruction data
selection method: Clustering and Ranking (CaR). CaR consists of two steps. The
first step involves ranking instruction pairs using a scoring model that is
well aligned with expert preferences (achieving an accuracy of 84.25%). The
second step involves preserving dataset diversity through a clustering
process.In our experiment, CaR selected a subset containing only 1.96% of
Alpaca's IT data, yet the underlying AlpaCaR model trained on this subset
outperforms Alpaca by an average of 32.1% in GPT-4 evaluations. Furthermore,
our method utilizes small models (355M parameters) and requires only 11.2% of
the monetary cost compared to existing methods, making it easily deployable in
industrial scenarios.
|
[
-0.5587067604,
-0.3532781303,
0.2811133862,
0.0197126213,
-0.3679493666,
0.1950073242,
-0.299004972,
-0.3960902989,
-0.1077205241,
0.0689474195,
-0.3241070807,
-0.9717183709,
-0.6533918977,
-0.4080438614,
-0.4306263626,
1.0056570768,
0.2651204467,
0.1449826062,
-0.1078733057,
-0.2398987114,
-0.7654304504,
-0.0968736187,
-0.712788403,
0.0358507894,
0.4135629535,
0.6970719695,
0.6629103422,
1.3066796064,
0.5349519849,
0.2904898226,
-0.1191953644,
0.1523370743,
-0.4321993589,
-0.242374137,
-0.2053298801,
-0.4113512933,
-0.38058424,
0.1495721638,
0.438692838,
0.7350413203,
-0.4254027605,
0.3176573217,
0.0933337361,
0.7136510611,
-0.7921612263,
0.0345633067,
-0.7814931273,
0.0748490468,
-0.0943244845,
-0.0202752687,
-0.266138941,
-0.9432480931,
-0.0826788619,
-0.4055315852,
0.5177956223,
0.1786860675,
0.5980063677,
0.4876362979,
-0.2002662122,
-0.2335956097,
-0.6401965618,
1.1641433239,
-0.5181258321,
0.2423220575,
0.504383862,
0.5943645835,
-0.079785347,
-0.1719625145,
-0.2132030725,
0.0970492736,
0.1160022467,
0.4231229424,
0.2675926387,
-0.1185278445,
-0.1731258482,
0.6115916967,
-0.5041572452,
0.6536032557,
-0.5764826536,
0.0278749876,
0.5237672925,
0.0268432796,
-0.0093922252,
0.4231216908,
-0.3358326256,
-0.3817610145,
-0.5804237127,
0.0723899677,
0.3226638734,
0.2882601321,
0.301700592,
0.2935017347,
-0.1734532267,
0.8326371908,
0.0108659845,
-0.3240121305,
0.0656927228,
0.0342414565,
-0.0454901718,
0.0460236147,
0.4985686839,
0.5087214708,
-0.2623079121,
-0.2695478499,
-0.1544884592,
0.1731955111,
0.3793799281,
-0.5081032515,
-0.1080031544,
-0.1847595125,
-0.4802464545,
-0.1213750169,
0.3911890984,
-1.0281231403,
0.0373244025,
-0.2032555044,
0.2773835361,
-0.2875161469,
0.0864020586,
-0.1633513272,
-0.1317410469,
0.3205613792,
0.198830992,
-1.2780787945,
0.0687758848,
0.9067372084,
0.6932914257,
-0.3621011674,
-0.3470990658,
-0.3554474115,
0.2879941761,
-0.4212224185,
1.0099701881,
-0.8993285298,
-0.78496629,
-0.3194200099,
-0.0157335196,
-0.2011602223,
-0.7922121882,
0.580075264,
-0.6195175648,
0.0570278689,
-0.2527769506,
-0.5381813645,
-0.3044959605,
-0.0225736834,
-0.5404326916,
1.0917686224,
0.3023154438,
-0.4231126606,
0.7536380291,
-0.2471027374,
-0.4137800634,
-0.1332114935,
-0.361455977,
-0.7772650719,
-0.0597527288,
0.3298070729,
0.0131219542,
-0.1256601661,
0.0199436378,
-0.3519013524,
-0.6359017491,
-0.3932361007,
-0.343770653,
0.421772778,
0.231308043,
-0.6226072311,
-0.0455863699,
-0.6716509461,
0.1819695979,
-0.3111067712,
-0.5669648647,
-0.3388661444,
0.1116359308,
-0.6346659064,
0.0350471139,
0.3133950531,
-0.5853009224,
0.3066584766,
-0.1770377308,
0.0174952336,
1.0216560364,
-0.223384887,
0.4920682311,
-0.4267789125,
0.5177434087,
-0.0463304073,
0.6067249179,
0.4008306563,
-0.793361783,
-0.9170385599,
-0.3164987564,
0.3933912516,
0.5405524969,
-0.3753532767,
0.8488449454,
-0.0701111108,
-0.8485384583,
-0.7929996252,
-0.0128688226,
0.2862635553,
0.5106746554,
0.640499413,
-0.3506493866,
-0.0313877799,
-0.8810485005,
0.0067357393,
0.0572140962,
-0.095561482,
0.2286685407,
-0.023536697,
-0.2440221161,
0.9914302826,
-0.6105225086,
-0.1774053872,
0.2528166771,
0.3782667518,
0.3048898578,
0.8557240367,
0.6675368547,
-0.2939893603,
-0.523360908,
0.2204313576,
-0.4947032034,
0.0955305099,
0.3886758685,
-0.6627578139,
-0.0629000664,
0.0787955299,
-0.1816054881,
0.6918507218,
0.5373466611,
0.0711330622,
0.1864497811,
-0.1605896056,
0.5014380813,
-0.8315885663,
-0.221469596,
-0.0609714389,
-0.0078336243,
-0.0314224362,
-0.097069487,
0.0239099283,
0.0544698425,
-0.0392341949,
0.121026881,
-0.4169706702,
-0.3587343097,
-0.4319005311,
-0.3084510863,
-0.055405613,
0.4299275577,
0.0497598834,
0.9772646427,
0.5993649364,
-0.5532510281,
-0.00727478,
0.386063844,
-0.5430427194,
0.4844650328,
-0.4353623688,
0.3485256135,
0.0161630921,
-0.1048114002,
-0.4985938072,
0.1400763839,
0.0769409686,
-0.1050103605,
0.3565148711,
-0.3547570407,
-0.0897047594,
-0.2759088576,
-0.2489878982,
0.4013065696,
0.7353138328,
-0.9452210665,
0.2490044534,
0.4174090028,
-0.4131943583,
-0.7221676707,
-0.309464395,
-0.3442006409,
-0.2461374998,
-0.3620028198,
0.3864479065,
-0.2829737663,
0.2409229577,
0.031852331,
-0.4690367877,
-0.3439246416,
0.0796969905,
0.0556144528,
0.4918156862,
-0.1927593946,
0.0286794733,
0.780664444,
-0.2599179447,
-0.4032487571,
-0.2741976976,
0.2418924272,
-0.1082880273,
-0.6492703557,
-0.2041858435,
0.5634726882,
0.3230398595,
-0.3509962559,
0.8754080534,
0.7713487148,
-0.0105041955,
-0.4246098697,
-0.6106191874,
-0.1574906111,
-0.5770158172,
0.1407308429,
0.1190975979,
-0.9052411914,
0.1238722354,
-0.0324647576,
0.4111361504,
0.4346737862,
0.2709318101,
-0.164319858,
1.3137111664,
0.6052592993,
-0.3733410835,
0.6327246428,
-0.2584318519,
0.3227677643,
-0.5111369491,
-0.338536948,
-0.8183756471,
-0.4811086357,
-0.532982409,
-0.2830600739,
0.8372757435,
-0.0369228795,
-0.2347953916,
0.1395303905,
-1.0309128761,
0.7794856429,
0.9680677056,
0.2394886613,
0.1728504002,
0.2362874746,
0.3583927751,
0.2073633373,
-0.7244689465,
-0.5149866343,
0.7765955925,
0.1067544818,
0.8290916085,
-0.0364459753,
0.7658143044,
0.3797052205,
0.4021971524,
-0.6892810464,
0.4206926823,
-0.6424710155,
-0.3451209664,
-0.3545739949,
-0.5535423756,
-1.0211899281,
0.0102448445,
-0.0742983893,
-0.5283139348,
0.4337186813,
0.1282317936,
-0.5274742842,
0.2665269673,
-0.7197414041,
0.7345714569,
-0.2781648338,
-0.1314589679,
-0.5258741975,
-0.448156774,
0.1411846578,
0.0702060536,
0.1291724294,
-0.1902880073,
0.1167539433,
0.8536436558,
-0.6731349826,
0.5297858119,
-0.2873882055,
0.087681137,
0.2114121169,
-0.2571126521,
0.1502985805,
-0.1896538883,
-0.4530590177,
0.3057109714,
-0.148456499,
-0.5330132246,
-0.6611967087,
0.9387717247,
-1.0231025219,
-0.5356404781,
-0.072991319,
-0.4191089571,
-0.283513844,
0.0806286559,
0.4081478715,
0.4449178576,
0.1081388742,
0.2994259596,
0.6259276867,
-0.1374824792,
0.4794967175,
0.4720704257,
0.4572051764,
-0.4933231175,
1.3725178242,
0.3486025631,
0.1130335629,
0.1993869692,
0.2668665051,
-0.0764571354,
-0.7736808658,
-0.5909324884,
-0.0863260105,
-0.7734974027,
-0.405990988,
-0.3639253676,
-0.2468085438,
-0.1232241318,
-0.359656781,
-0.4701029062,
-0.527574718,
-0.3611539006,
-0.1929814368,
0.2695977092,
0.7309555411,
0.0497187451,
0.5444492102,
-0.840188086,
-0.0171003137,
0.6965509057,
0.7179073691,
-0.0341457352,
-0.3008794785,
-0.6594329476,
-0.1102622822,
-0.3342685103,
-0.685523808,
0.1333547533,
0.3057319522,
0.8720474243,
0.5431417227,
-0.0422402918,
0.6918690801,
-0.3560452759,
0.5717595816,
-0.12384893,
-0.7020613551,
0.5604487658,
-0.222620368,
-0.0400584824,
1.081397891,
0.3691274524,
0.1149999276,
-0.4615111947,
-0.4219056964,
-1.0304671526,
0.6800681353,
-0.0877305716,
-0.3112831414,
-0.035781607,
0.240537554,
0.752512157,
0.3939270675,
-0.3265766501,
-0.1288054287,
-0.4512031376,
-0.5411188006,
0.3002294004,
0.1384067982,
-0.1133746728,
-0.4892350733,
0.9533284903,
-0.0107810032,
0.226532653,
-0.378126204,
0.1275868565,
-0.0487560034,
0.1924323589,
0.3017228842,
0.7144512534,
-0.1905246973,
-0.2620534897,
0.0155431489,
-0.5124195814,
0.2275265008,
0.0689454377,
-0.3419495821,
-0.1100599095,
-0.1499003619,
0.6569313407,
0.0866091773,
-0.2185795903,
0.3121289015,
-0.0686259419,
0.1738509983,
-0.053581953,
0.7212147117,
-0.2536362708,
0.1681306809,
0.3278958499,
0.1831628978,
0.3722318411,
-0.2413976043,
0.0140440091,
0.4593010843,
-0.1034242511,
0.0692751035,
0.4307974279,
0.2865840495,
-0.1632080376,
0.74931252,
-0.3221452832,
-0.2166713029,
1.0097888708,
0.3147622049,
0.7767045498,
-0.5708578229,
0.2695652246,
0.5648694634,
0.3142211437,
-0.2946041226,
-0.0434360653,
-0.0605356321,
-0.405366987,
-0.0084827961,
-0.6030138731,
-0.7011569142,
-0.1886646897,
-1.031506896,
0.1780003905,
-0.5945538282,
-0.1874098033,
-0.4448126256,
-0.237391606,
-0.6175205112,
0.5235843062,
-0.1071835533,
0.8007634282,
-0.8538876176,
0.7665268779,
0.5323053002,
-0.1402327269,
-0.8782458901,
-0.0983942151,
-0.339138329,
-0.7257229686,
0.0184648391,
0.2743483484,
-0.1783608347,
0.1863593906,
-0.4587450922,
-0.9821369648,
1.2742472887,
0.3298746347,
-0.670653522,
0.1022296697,
-0.0272658318,
0.1762455851,
-0.2782931924,
0.4345054626,
0.9541540742,
0.4740158319,
0.1313513219,
-0.5123588443,
-0.3638792634,
-0.3470383286,
-0.0407445505,
0.2238788903,
-1.0399519205,
0.8089065552,
0.0933646783,
-0.0999709219,
0.0570211597,
0.7311282158,
0.392003268,
0.4354188442,
0.7128641009,
0.6004984379,
0.9205179811,
-0.1420192868,
0.6615390182,
-0.3739885092,
0.1915698349,
0.887763381,
-0.0096913222,
0.6943743825,
0.0013701911,
-0.1924217939,
0.7508170605,
1.0011581182,
-0.3620564938,
0.7976349592,
-0.3254277408,
-0.3795915842,
-0.1701463908,
0.0289203078,
-0.7370526195,
0.5509966612,
0.2243524194,
-0.1539960057,
-0.1129271835,
-0.2857782543,
-0.2298983485,
-0.1758859009,
-0.418672204,
0.9494917989,
-0.2277904749,
-0.8543182015,
0.4288390577,
0.0202739872,
0.5369254351,
-0.4861340225,
-0.1091602594,
-0.4363927543,
-0.0838162825,
-0.2759835124,
-0.4431515336,
0.1391463876,
-0.0296944864,
-0.4146241248,
0.1931135058,
0.3377054036,
-0.6344688535,
-0.7151733637,
0.0178225487,
0.176602006,
0.0803108737,
0.3322353363,
-0.3946674466,
0.0118366368,
-0.1271127015,
0.0623412132,
0.6053977013,
-0.0183720943,
-0.1224529669,
0.3509271145,
0.306286335,
-0.0581120998,
0.1563808173,
0.0272794794,
0.914375782,
-0.4757353961,
-0.7620366216,
-0.3756695092,
0.4515176117,
-0.1887197942,
-0.1133855283,
0.4888009131,
0.530669868,
0.8599272966,
0.0056548933,
0.9361147285,
0.2374808937,
0.5907860398,
-0.5325800776,
0.6478666663,
-0.2356243283,
0.3773619831,
-0.1729891598,
-1.0986367464,
0.2261685431,
0.7715145946,
-0.5314108729,
0.3882989287,
0.4066489637,
0.7817007899,
-0.3053636253,
0.311242342,
0.1137322858,
-0.2117045671,
0.1435442865,
0.3395040035,
0.696824789,
0.059039522,
0.4222406447,
-0.5339740515,
-0.7563969493,
-0.1870877296,
-0.8284007311,
-0.6923683286,
-0.0343196057,
-0.3695307076,
0.2707167268,
-0.003244499,
0.8849503994,
0.9555366635,
-0.8945015669,
-0.2674121261,
0.1758086979,
0.2374716997,
-0.6907948852,
-0.1788908839,
0.5378688574,
-0.2350666672,
-0.7297016978,
0.8738948703,
0.1407591105,
-0.0893641785,
0.0145747606,
0.1166952699,
0.2785868347,
-0.0585438684,
0.309320271,
0.2071912587,
-0.2041390836,
-0.4033450186,
-0.2473690659,
0.1479296088,
0.2571333349,
0.5344302654,
-0.4884654284,
0.3468121588,
0.1808764935,
0.8008609414,
0.3070599735,
0.3510631919,
0.4628045857,
-0.6875633001,
0.0549471043,
0.2471690923,
0.2232879698,
0.3404699564,
-0.5290592909,
0.5195120573,
0.1329464614,
-0.9419442415,
-0.3827768564,
0.0541919097,
-0.859142065,
-0.0969209373,
0.5965165496,
-0.1752098203,
-0.2938923538,
0.0550714247,
-0.1378027648,
0.5062066317,
-0.5433272123,
1.4445749521,
0.2498562336,
-0.1551455408,
0.0959043205,
-0.383295238,
0.226217106,
0.4549276829,
-0.9626042247,
-0.4659268558,
0.5118873715,
0.1363335401,
-0.1046934649,
0.1010224298,
0.0491177775,
0.4188442826,
-0.1300126314,
0.1524668783,
-0.0963034779,
-0.5173048973,
-0.0806348622,
0.297483772,
0.1926542521,
-0.6144917011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18179v1
|
Challenges in Pre-Training Graph Neural Networks for Context-Based Fake News Detection: An Evaluation of Current Strategies and Resource Limitations
| 2024-02-28T09:10:25 | 2024-02-28T09:10:25 |
Gregor Donabauer, Udo Kruschwitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-training of neural networks has recently revolutionized the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP) and has before demonstrated its effectiveness
in computer vision. At the same time, advances around the detection of fake
news were mainly driven by the context-based paradigm, where different types of
signals (e.g. from social media) form graph-like structures that hold
contextual information apart from the news article to classify. We propose to
merge these two developments by applying pre-training of Graph Neural Networks
(GNNs) in the domain of context-based fake news detection. Our experiments
provide an evaluation of different pre-training strategies for graph-based
misinformation detection and demonstrate that transfer learning does currently
not lead to significant improvements over training a model from scratch in the
domain. We argue that a major current issue is the lack of suitable large-scale
resources that can be used for pre-training.
|
[
-0.4341241419,
-0.9886112809,
0.4822487235,
0.0486926138,
-0.4892802536,
0.2080515325,
-0.0043128035,
-0.5892056823,
0.4508405328,
0.3538782299,
-0.5297469497,
-0.2094724327,
-0.9634020329,
0.1168658361,
-0.6029887795,
0.8798432946,
-0.1350798458,
-0.0002168712,
-0.1985115707,
-0.0988477916,
-0.3319886923,
-0.758610189,
-0.7962167859,
0.0050875391,
0.6619073749,
0.0250886455,
0.5461338162,
0.216273427,
0.1808248609,
0.2881417871,
0.1609642953,
0.3872191906,
-0.4430425763,
-0.487426281,
-0.005513126,
-0.0431502163,
-0.1306780428,
0.3856478035,
0.7283445597,
0.5740590096,
0.2746852636,
0.0904006064,
-0.002275438,
0.4219002724,
-0.6781351566,
0.0045870286,
-0.7123250961,
0.15086326,
-0.1288744956,
-0.4342347383,
-0.3625890017,
-0.3713048697,
0.322373271,
-0.7544769049,
0.3037180305,
0.1156408414,
1.1260929108,
-0.1444836706,
-0.6795945168,
-0.3729585111,
-0.6457460523,
0.2741963267,
-0.6475161314,
0.3367682993,
0.2336374223,
0.2874320149,
-0.1138690487,
-1.0807459354,
-0.731058538,
-0.1196550801,
-0.2094845772,
-0.0841699243,
-0.3832036257,
-0.089745149,
0.1980361789,
-0.123984918,
-0.6909670234,
0.1325235963,
-0.4449602664,
-0.6147379279,
0.3232368827,
-0.404191941,
0.4328401983,
-0.3362673819,
-0.3427071571,
0.0583006255,
-0.5378645658,
-0.1368629336,
0.5503697991,
0.4474878609,
-0.0114104114,
0.0847905278,
-0.2508249581,
0.8741487265,
0.0032112575,
0.013072893,
0.4087683856,
-0.5082310438,
-0.3379521668,
0.1461335719,
0.8205472827,
0.1717614383,
0.340526551,
-0.1778216362,
-0.0081665451,
0.2100161761,
0.5379058719,
-0.6661165953,
-0.0646170229,
-0.3166489005,
-0.5013988018,
-0.4825554192,
0.0164898261,
-0.4686985314,
-0.1947398484,
-0.4348956943,
0.5516031384,
-0.2008387297,
-0.2971124053,
-0.0356810465,
-0.2247401625,
-0.2010625601,
0.4582223296,
-0.4461789727,
0.1582572609,
0.2611583769,
0.9118807316,
0.0431303754,
-0.2882684469,
-0.5593772531,
-0.1770755053,
-0.3775083125,
0.886634469,
-0.3926940858,
-0.0871752948,
0.0717336461,
0.1341845691,
-0.1938817948,
-0.4771939814,
0.3328099549,
-0.7681841254,
0.2432715595,
-0.4157477021,
-0.2516121268,
-0.1756827533,
0.5013711452,
-0.7809195518,
0.6894146204,
0.5319532752,
-0.8874257207,
0.4212021828,
-0.5324265957,
-0.8719658256,
0.0025524974,
-0.1008551642,
-0.3566938937,
0.0423016213,
0.3553179204,
0.2694457769,
0.294296205,
0.1942173839,
-0.3828861117,
-0.428062439,
0.0388513356,
-0.5986118913,
0.9045765996,
0.2834300995,
-0.3854240775,
0.1758592725,
-0.5760143399,
0.0461490192,
0.1143660918,
-0.2496043742,
-0.2357938886,
-0.2319238931,
-0.2261179239,
0.3983486593,
-0.0817691609,
-0.3307000995,
-0.0255637709,
-0.10328269,
0.5602797866,
0.6709766388,
-0.1284370422,
0.4953403175,
-0.111583218,
0.2741540074,
0.2909940183,
0.2434780598,
-0.0171765275,
-0.3660995364,
-0.5391500592,
0.1942276061,
0.4269106686,
0.6491815448,
-1.1966462135,
0.4608907104,
-0.3195773959,
-0.0888272673,
-0.067838788,
0.0123037249,
0.2115667909,
0.9513179064,
0.5289891362,
-0.3962743878,
-0.7883546352,
-0.8282687068,
-0.5817231536,
0.0393844247,
0.1472491622,
0.2334329188,
0.6272270083,
-0.1500594616,
1.0344918966,
-0.0831772238,
-0.4050906301,
-0.2300613075,
0.1167057157,
-0.0371754095,
0.3352942467,
0.7618202567,
-1.133366704,
-0.5343194604,
-0.1149864867,
-0.7933773994,
0.1424271315,
0.0224100072,
0.1561965644,
0.4197717309,
0.7737801671,
-0.6212047935,
0.8715401888,
0.5659094453,
-0.1448481828,
0.7839761376,
-0.0224328414,
0.2837898731,
-0.9274613261,
-0.0844846293,
0.1245359406,
-0.5917345881,
-0.9025898576,
-0.4846934676,
-0.1051491126,
-0.2756005526,
-0.6577889323,
0.5202766061,
-0.4253241718,
-0.3035112917,
-0.4562144578,
0.3067900538,
0.0696235448,
0.2562809289,
-0.0545611419,
0.5068802238,
0.2961434722,
-0.6523208022,
0.5702518821,
-0.0759079456,
-0.4882010221,
0.3937187493,
-0.2813006341,
0.1841088682,
-0.1780050248,
0.9188929796,
-0.6991984248,
-0.1990734935,
0.7471756935,
-0.6001804471,
0.3584528565,
-0.2600669861,
-0.5901777148,
-0.890876472,
0.072950989,
0.4021540582,
0.2757202089,
-0.5047867298,
0.5924814343,
0.0921061933,
0.2077845931,
-0.8113526702,
-0.5736237764,
0.2426367849,
-0.0675147921,
-0.6501934528,
0.3602464199,
0.347543031,
0.0732241571,
0.563282609,
-0.3760972619,
-0.1241975352,
0.194534719,
-0.0879988074,
0.1010372192,
-0.3338549435,
0.0583710633,
-0.2741483152,
-0.0557611547,
0.059589643,
-0.7319074273,
0.533649087,
-0.1819231659,
-0.2844084501,
-0.8014757633,
0.2130574435,
0.1974612623,
-0.0581118539,
0.8005554676,
0.6819182038,
-0.5543527007,
-0.2598509192,
-0.5632194281,
-0.2253114283,
-0.4151298404,
0.6271141171,
0.253107965,
-0.8609554768,
0.2969351411,
-0.3674815595,
-0.5918709636,
0.454185307,
0.0219078604,
-0.1188127771,
0.7974580526,
0.5066890121,
-0.2566431463,
0.6962068081,
-0.2858660519,
0.5116074085,
-0.4191499949,
-0.0084077651,
-0.2395437807,
-0.4736936986,
-0.1551558226,
-0.2057998627,
0.0373777486,
0.2854510248,
-0.2522779107,
0.1845006347,
-0.4433707893,
0.5533403158,
0.6148124933,
0.1775547713,
0.1413232386,
0.3842402101,
0.1858185232,
0.3193171918,
-1.0141167641,
-0.2753501236,
1.107498765,
0.0466735736,
0.1374366283,
-0.4564214945,
0.2358570993,
0.564440608,
0.7366466522,
-0.4507328868,
0.3885852993,
-0.2742262781,
-0.5363080502,
-0.357276082,
-0.7621834874,
-0.7857509851,
0.2938729525,
-0.3763257563,
-0.6708705425,
-0.0529533289,
0.2505252659,
-0.2600774467,
0.7624829412,
-0.8109624386,
1.0423805714,
-0.3678604364,
0.1929438114,
0.0276151653,
-0.7109577656,
0.2210906446,
-0.149874866,
0.3772867024,
0.1004485935,
0.5160983205,
0.6879609823,
-0.3764179349,
0.9663449526,
-0.5710722208,
0.3811795115,
0.6176679134,
-0.2847101986,
0.604224205,
-0.0102603137,
0.4040276706,
0.3172873855,
-0.3829556406,
-0.3761481047,
-0.5689971447,
0.484154582,
-0.6158322096,
-0.6115094423,
-0.4217114151,
-0.4064928293,
-0.2450714707,
0.5804207921,
0.8209754825,
0.4075773656,
-0.2651196122,
0.2415685058,
0.3116814792,
-0.1282809973,
0.4193748832,
0.1275909543,
-0.2584071159,
-0.2552992404,
0.873614192,
0.6947419047,
-0.0334427953,
-0.1972701102,
0.0869986936,
-0.2265171558,
-0.8224987388,
-0.35293293,
0.0430895351,
-0.6717842221,
-0.1905495375,
-0.4281284213,
-0.5943342447,
-0.6708254814,
-0.16905348,
-0.2224767655,
-0.0030830982,
-0.5739394426,
-0.0437683575,
-0.1728951931,
0.6252706051,
-0.0752980635,
0.6384392381,
-0.7050350904,
0.4431830943,
0.2148126513,
0.3477706313,
-0.0157482065,
-0.472558856,
-0.3555597961,
0.3936854303,
-0.2678334415,
-0.8580880165,
0.4479746222,
-0.1205169559,
0.5487495661,
0.4661472738,
0.0416454189,
0.492705524,
-0.4053671658,
0.6136263609,
0.4137431085,
-0.8073213696,
0.5885561705,
-0.256092906,
-0.0929518864,
0.425306201,
0.8848847747,
-0.4353635609,
0.073557198,
-0.7676365376,
-0.4471921027,
0.7469376326,
0.1743014902,
0.2788208127,
0.0873444155,
0.5361835361,
-0.1615811288,
0.367832303,
-1.038017869,
-0.1375449598,
-0.6771674752,
0.125674516,
-0.2120090723,
-0.0603352897,
-0.2205003798,
-0.4118717015,
0.541163981,
-0.2654525638,
0.087076351,
0.2672579587,
-0.3619965315,
0.1759776771,
-0.1824680865,
0.6660553217,
0.8630902767,
0.041348245,
0.0202116333,
0.2245143205,
-0.529174149,
0.1301010251,
0.1335220635,
-0.2858760953,
0.2354481965,
0.5817267895,
1.1730166674,
0.0806465149,
-0.080351539,
0.9733521938,
0.0765652061,
-0.7160108089,
-0.4237494469,
-0.2338441014,
0.0152371926,
0.1685864776,
0.6333709955,
0.5461697578,
-0.1478429586,
-0.5934087634,
0.1671429425,
0.4229882061,
-0.4730835259,
-0.4952372313,
0.3419514298,
0.1356694102,
-0.3583788276,
0.8486781716,
-0.3248404264,
-0.7822114229,
0.7532388568,
0.7470363975,
0.5271311998,
-0.1025429294,
0.5495413542,
0.0405709222,
0.451366365,
-0.2139385343,
-0.145147711,
0.214731738,
-1.173922658,
-0.3986768425,
-0.3225865066,
0.0902643055,
0.6670905948,
-0.1539528966,
0.187958777,
-0.6462879181,
-0.4854862988,
-0.0713305101,
-0.061786864,
-0.7064195871,
0.3709818423,
0.2405137867,
0.8387719393,
-0.8491873741,
0.7349807024,
0.3829168379,
-0.1587479711,
-0.6464545727,
-0.0715365112,
0.1568974406,
-0.4962650836,
0.9227622151,
0.5247430205,
-0.0157959238,
0.0166135225,
-0.7789136767,
-0.8608233929,
0.83182621,
0.7389599681,
-0.3698886037,
-0.5884454846,
0.09409713,
0.3949446082,
-0.6194941998,
-0.2518843412,
0.1187915802,
0.5072538257,
0.0321245454,
-0.6751761436,
-0.0334970318,
-0.1007591635,
-0.1772544086,
-0.0951450318,
-0.4766709208,
1.0281155109,
0.0878703967,
-0.566403985,
-0.5384859443,
0.714871645,
-0.2047336251,
0.6220437288,
0.7355400324,
0.6134886146,
0.7674384713,
-0.1498668194,
1.1441119909,
-0.074479565,
0.2943852842,
1.0260396004,
-0.1680998653,
0.4920859635,
0.1373116225,
0.0831538513,
0.7761839628,
0.8423530459,
-0.0346892662,
0.3653284013,
0.370837301,
-0.2079697251,
-0.1984052807,
0.0169903338,
-0.5695065856,
0.2864054441,
0.3364894092,
-0.3604764938,
-0.3456381559,
0.2572958767,
0.0690365657,
-0.1061872393,
-0.6388516426,
0.2812379003,
0.0801928565,
-0.3147303164,
0.3798429072,
-0.2375926375,
0.6893521547,
-0.7911865115,
0.2905634642,
0.0977660343,
-0.1066714674,
-0.3589166105,
-0.2917672396,
0.5240439773,
-0.3354293108,
-0.0735029653,
-0.1331964284,
1.3211625814,
-0.1015145704,
-0.2546019554,
0.5547096729,
0.5870592594,
-0.159914434,
-0.5369194746,
-0.4922549427,
-0.1165057942,
-0.1421064287,
-0.3957929313,
0.4187513888,
0.3640892506,
-0.2090894133,
0.3907006979,
1.1380112171,
0.1630699486,
0.1486778855,
0.07333038,
1.0751850605,
-0.3548162282,
-0.800688386,
-0.7529007792,
0.0224315729,
-0.3894147873,
-0.2222916037,
0.7641371489,
0.3023501039,
1.2216796875,
-0.0948477089,
0.9158481359,
0.2238265574,
0.2440894693,
-0.585203886,
0.9109646678,
-0.5480694175,
-0.1558342725,
-0.2829841375,
-1.0544912815,
-0.4064304531,
0.5213859081,
-0.3944993615,
0.3062890768,
0.8667165041,
0.2628772259,
-0.2187771797,
0.0448985323,
0.1705775708,
0.0627976209,
0.1470133513,
0.4051249325,
0.8441977501,
-0.3114257753,
0.6820764542,
0.0664289594,
-0.0491560102,
-0.4489506185,
-1.0402969122,
-0.7609431744,
-0.4582421482,
-0.1277647167,
-0.6159214377,
0.0641274303,
0.4141764045,
1.0980637074,
-0.5577811599,
0.3788638115,
-0.1790388376,
0.1874298751,
0.0267873723,
-0.1879128963,
0.3795625567,
-0.4089501798,
-0.2095498592,
0.4392339885,
0.0820328519,
0.3117115498,
-0.0438254848,
-0.0083212508,
-0.422162652,
0.0998762026,
0.6919612288,
0.6183220148,
-0.4071895778,
-0.768181622,
-0.2238680273,
-0.0797450989,
0.162091285,
0.9447588325,
-1.1260739565,
0.1990127712,
0.3014416695,
0.8146292567,
0.5799224973,
0.2211538702,
0.2653732896,
-0.9227688313,
0.3372579813,
0.1241303384,
0.2389623374,
0.3140799403,
-0.4744409025,
0.2898644507,
0.8604726195,
-0.2615196705,
-0.8708541989,
0.3113960326,
-0.6544354558,
-0.6622300744,
0.871047318,
-0.069394432,
-0.3823447526,
-0.2966061831,
0.0056012059,
0.4452654123,
0.0182660744,
0.4959466755,
0.7940258384,
-0.0044263811,
0.1627500951,
-0.5870052576,
0.7922517061,
-0.049579557,
-0.9118896723,
-0.4475086033,
0.4514475465,
0.3205760121,
0.5241905451,
1.0336441994,
0.1017455906,
0.2617887259,
0.1486124545,
-0.3154331744,
-0.4884259999,
-0.7825095654,
-0.1765161008,
0.2548296154,
-0.7340903282,
-0.0201161094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18169v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18169v2
|
MIKO: Multimodal Intention Knowledge Distillation from Large Language Models for Social-Media Commonsense Discovery
| 2024-02-28T08:57:42 | 2024-02-29T06:45:56 |
Feihong Lu, Weiqi Wang, Yangyifei Luo, Ziqin Zhu, Qingyun Sun, Baixuan Xu, Haochen Shi, Shiqi Gao, Qian Li, Yangqiu Song, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media has become a ubiquitous tool for connecting with others, staying
updated with news, expressing opinions, and finding entertainment. However,
understanding the intention behind social media posts remains challenging due
to the implicitness of intentions in social media posts, the need for
cross-modality understanding of both text and images, and the presence of noisy
information such as hashtags, misspelled words, and complicated abbreviations.
To address these challenges, we present MIKO, a Multimodal Intention Kowledge
DistillatiOn framework that collaboratively leverages a Large Language Model
(LLM) and a Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) to uncover users'
intentions. Specifically, we use an MLLM to interpret the image and an LLM to
extract key information from the text and finally instruct the LLM again to
generate intentions. By applying MIKO to publicly available social media
datasets, we construct an intention knowledge base featuring 1,372K intentions
rooted in 137,287 posts. We conduct a two-stage annotation to verify the
quality of the generated knowledge and benchmark the performance of widely used
LLMs for intention generation. We further apply MIKO to a sarcasm detection
dataset and distill a student model to demonstrate the downstream benefits of
applying intention knowledge.
|
[
-0.3396021724,
-0.7358297706,
1.0320036411,
0.4227900803,
-0.5717470646,
-0.1693010479,
-0.3616182506,
-0.2291402519,
0.3799563646,
0.3368849158,
-0.82733953,
-0.6252781153,
-0.8448365331,
-0.0906481296,
-0.2553424239,
0.9649458528,
-0.033690162,
-0.0004708476,
-0.1222373322,
-0.1105172336,
-0.3714024425,
-0.0862510204,
-0.5985408425,
-0.2916960716,
0.9661448598,
0.6730155945,
0.5695277452,
-0.18227458,
0.2899920642,
0.2020388246,
0.1956730634,
0.595256865,
-0.8622110486,
0.1108910963,
-0.2545338869,
-0.2177031338,
-0.159617275,
0.0224376842,
0.5878147483,
0.2822920084,
0.2077481896,
0.2213123143,
0.0100150052,
0.5923340917,
-0.7508214116,
0.0532866418,
-0.628754437,
-0.2422941476,
0.04382414,
-0.2896550298,
-0.4642239213,
-0.2472156733,
-0.2451306581,
-0.7253060937,
-0.0203842968,
-0.1488786787,
0.5564637184,
0.2073236108,
-0.5653900504,
-0.5916004777,
-0.4763822258,
0.9834651947,
-0.5801222324,
0.6264374256,
0.6566615105,
0.4640397727,
-0.3121597469,
-0.6410449743,
-0.8025755286,
0.1341385543,
-0.2104165554,
0.0147813121,
-0.17206949,
0.0981194898,
0.2257743329,
0.0251803882,
-0.397952646,
-0.4328725934,
-0.3977193832,
-0.1997253001,
0.9202355742,
-0.0715123489,
0.4640080929,
-0.3220185339,
-0.4319166243,
0.2291317135,
-0.4940485358,
-0.0142563162,
0.5043720007,
-0.0408610813,
-0.1409695297,
0.7254837751,
-0.396740526,
0.3409471512,
-0.0871613324,
-0.2674567997,
0.182974115,
-0.4757855237,
0.1559720188,
0.0756857842,
1.0374723673,
0.9372557402,
0.3637253642,
0.0944868252,
-0.1472435594,
0.122846067,
0.1892821193,
-0.8555556536,
-0.1947687566,
0.1974322647,
-0.6969379187,
-0.3003208041,
0.0302716438,
-0.6524738669,
-0.6211135387,
-0.3941456079,
0.4933660924,
-0.5511730909,
-0.6028825641,
0.1396333724,
-0.4904500246,
-0.0065520005,
0.4398278296,
-0.6820043325,
-0.3359828591,
0.7442041039,
0.7506575584,
0.4685769379,
-0.3870452344,
-0.5358923674,
0.1761861145,
-0.2480269372,
0.4559867978,
-0.6110689044,
-0.3282924294,
0.0042855581,
-0.051005505,
0.1992107481,
0.0770414695,
0.6938694715,
-0.4165900946,
-0.3238847554,
-0.4554539621,
-0.269271791,
-0.3620321155,
0.2575367689,
-0.6280975938,
0.7466261983,
-0.1199982539,
-0.4940643311,
0.597714901,
-0.7318112254,
-0.4560907483,
0.0797477588,
-0.1464430988,
-0.0286416505,
0.5510881543,
0.2336995155,
0.8461540937,
0.0475322045,
0.567612946,
-0.6067328453,
-0.3678152859,
0.5951939225,
-0.6608185172,
0.5001882315,
0.4499423504,
0.1145107001,
-0.056938298,
-0.5198665261,
-0.1954462081,
0.1356616914,
-0.3207758069,
-0.8157098889,
0.1277150214,
0.0785970017,
0.4337976873,
0.3067552447,
-0.5603313446,
0.1097857952,
0.2925029099,
0.5726292729,
0.7110184431,
0.2510596216,
0.383407712,
-0.0995398164,
0.2037926465,
0.0140316291,
0.6102084517,
-0.3265320659,
-0.7716547251,
-0.3530822098,
-0.1312433481,
-0.270083487,
-0.3410773873,
-0.9638831615,
-0.0007050486,
-0.3833199739,
-0.3256875873,
-0.8214328885,
0.5529969931,
0.1654247195,
-0.0543807074,
0.2042363733,
0.0265327804,
-0.4682455659,
-0.9632355571,
-0.469512254,
-0.0367716141,
0.1525288522,
0.3627026677,
0.3220481873,
-0.6481251121,
0.8415127397,
-0.4874734282,
-0.0351521708,
-0.4673282206,
0.4693256915,
0.1012488976,
-0.0076058004,
0.5763574243,
-1.2075058222,
-0.8385387063,
0.0706314594,
-0.7307439446,
-0.0338564627,
-0.0791546777,
-0.2500032485,
0.0077433684,
0.3498047292,
-0.5500079393,
0.2967570722,
0.8060097098,
-0.1427546144,
0.3830514848,
0.1545836776,
0.5986553431,
-1.3549866676,
-0.0654337555,
0.1165013313,
-0.0643019453,
-0.680990994,
-0.226974383,
0.199037984,
0.0986376852,
-0.5212064981,
0.7477612495,
-0.5291682482,
0.1324515194,
-0.2325905412,
0.1267359853,
0.246602878,
0.2797853053,
0.007448948,
0.2272461653,
0.3535733223,
-0.5360249877,
0.1583522111,
-0.0810240284,
-0.4087099731,
0.5781379342,
-0.2529105246,
0.1838285625,
-0.3436955512,
-0.0524957031,
-1.3720363379,
-0.7519661784,
0.3480153382,
-0.8048417568,
-0.0240599196,
-0.5395733714,
-0.5717913508,
-0.2193091065,
-0.3674555123,
0.5752176046,
0.1712504327,
-0.7198471427,
0.8346706629,
0.2094179988,
-0.2722041309,
-0.8323593736,
-0.6748645306,
0.07072182,
-0.1999874115,
-0.736240387,
-0.1501947343,
-0.031706281,
-0.2251194268,
0.0219237581,
0.2317216694,
-0.0705610365,
-0.0589112863,
0.4165323675,
0.0717970207,
0.2320502102,
0.4201265574,
0.430159688,
0.0222084895,
0.0464891493,
0.0434671193,
0.7529481649,
0.1786804497,
-0.3572381437,
-0.5730606914,
0.4945667684,
0.8028583527,
0.1278111786,
0.6858223677,
1.0158179998,
-0.4073651731,
-0.1011969522,
-0.6690554619,
-0.3244771957,
-0.4812238216,
0.0729816779,
-0.3411263525,
-0.823869586,
0.2112507522,
-0.2087581903,
0.1352278739,
0.100131996,
0.2418384403,
-0.1987810731,
1.1814227104,
0.3378916383,
-0.1041826755,
0.5527686477,
-0.0513624549,
0.5311961174,
-0.5853720307,
-0.0007347279,
0.1104822755,
-0.6396806836,
-0.3193528056,
-0.4477855265,
0.3984016478,
0.2369230092,
0.5152216554,
0.1878384799,
-0.0880884752,
0.542837739,
0.4566469491,
0.241710335,
0.5820606947,
0.1317735463,
0.2405883372,
0.0037816805,
-0.4850971997,
-0.4967027307,
1.2088282108,
0.2921352088,
0.7571977377,
0.2346265316,
1.0202074051,
0.3168921769,
0.5732904673,
-0.8883895874,
0.4964631498,
-0.0080567691,
-0.8856832385,
-0.2030046135,
-0.508066535,
-0.7780508399,
0.1271010935,
-0.5076106191,
-0.5910518765,
-0.0137317041,
0.4702690244,
-0.176553756,
-0.0031242939,
-0.9616573453,
0.7920528054,
-0.4863598645,
-0.5423606038,
-0.5602712631,
-0.5490633249,
0.8047107458,
-0.0971086398,
0.6675149798,
-0.281649977,
0.1859922856,
0.5000955462,
0.0956430361,
0.9300416112,
-0.2577108741,
0.0139727276,
0.5021901131,
-0.0479624905,
0.5851692557,
0.1612520516,
0.2331219167,
0.4341675937,
-0.2556537688,
0.0495856702,
-0.5370398164,
0.8805972934,
-0.398345083,
0.0736371353,
0.1623060852,
-0.7061799765,
0.073793523,
0.3764202595,
0.1724043638,
0.3338296711,
-0.4188631773,
0.4509610236,
0.4196528494,
-0.1056061536,
0.3547481,
0.3040974438,
-0.5212167501,
-0.4312114716,
1.0454007387,
0.1241258085,
0.2630772293,
0.155463621,
0.4357178211,
-0.5629578829,
-0.3356136084,
-0.2602632344,
0.3829311132,
-0.8963803649,
0.1820673645,
-0.764408946,
0.2421895713,
-0.4768763483,
-0.441385895,
-0.265211761,
-0.220519349,
-0.0243359543,
0.0269161705,
0.4851441681,
0.7518510818,
-0.2005811185,
0.5152641535,
-0.9296249747,
0.4555838406,
0.113879852,
0.3197546899,
-0.1646852344,
0.0029766059,
-0.2096482664,
0.5140225887,
0.0447152071,
-0.8622166514,
0.282759726,
0.0275151823,
0.5249496698,
0.9684938192,
0.2085404545,
0.5115630031,
-0.0640177876,
0.3751645386,
0.5715529323,
-0.5070983171,
0.6406002045,
-0.5237617493,
0.132204473,
0.7749436498,
0.8835718036,
-0.9584665298,
-0.1713647991,
-0.5678781867,
-0.7328967452,
0.496899873,
0.1424238831,
0.3010956645,
-0.160977751,
0.2257530689,
0.2152829766,
0.3535622656,
-0.8317828774,
0.0255440641,
-0.043784827,
-0.5743564367,
-0.2907201648,
-0.4501645267,
-0.2255448699,
-0.0867181048,
0.691110909,
-0.2044704705,
-0.0065164701,
-0.2349400073,
-0.4299348593,
-0.040260002,
0.3558914661,
0.4707244039,
0.5274382234,
-0.0837294087,
0.3334201872,
-0.2973926365,
-0.5234749317,
-0.0812215209,
-0.1423440278,
-0.2246014476,
0.1672382653,
0.0013629597,
0.5222374201,
0.3970846236,
-0.7364339232,
0.6019239426,
-0.2831437588,
-0.3842544556,
-0.2071905881,
-0.0000137959,
0.5039361119,
0.2249711156,
0.150205493,
-0.1542238295,
0.3889351487,
-0.6656051874,
-0.1124036312,
0.5229541063,
-0.3044126928,
-0.3264641762,
0.1536795646,
0.2369909286,
-0.1547646821,
0.3205456734,
-0.4099402428,
-0.3737490177,
0.1272131056,
0.064621143,
0.9021651149,
-0.288644135,
0.3344744146,
0.5261287093,
0.3744925261,
0.0072732489,
0.4680691361,
-0.4253695309,
-0.981066525,
-0.1525721848,
-0.6710745692,
0.0923201591,
0.2496044189,
-0.4040018618,
0.4450855851,
-0.307738781,
-0.3374025524,
0.3326370418,
-0.4317771196,
-0.5797617435,
-0.176950708,
-0.1387127042,
0.2584190369,
-1.1078777313,
0.6163289547,
0.7434190512,
-0.2905723751,
-0.7028210163,
-0.0217964649,
0.310877949,
-0.7331560254,
0.5240727067,
0.4241383672,
-0.2039453685,
-0.0656961352,
-0.7406843901,
-0.4988648891,
1.060661912,
0.0663591549,
-0.7169196606,
0.3799729943,
0.347704947,
0.1162409633,
-0.2677607238,
0.0691766739,
0.2883042693,
0.565018177,
0.4788829088,
-0.4127573073,
-0.1262925118,
-0.2325977534,
-0.2297776341,
0.4348339736,
-0.4171636105,
0.5582602024,
-0.3375781775,
-0.3879022896,
-0.5982398987,
0.2450830489,
0.3201277852,
0.853939712,
0.4911834896,
0.4803064764,
0.501822412,
-0.0232573152,
0.6585122347,
-0.2680685818,
0.2585007846,
1.0795316696,
-0.1778707355,
0.8153796792,
0.9133520722,
0.2361719757,
0.2196272612,
0.365020901,
0.4388618469,
0.4724791646,
-0.315354526,
-0.684610188,
-0.4115302563,
-0.2023658901,
-0.1190913394,
0.4089735746,
0.7151678801,
-0.7888408899,
-0.300241977,
0.047563877,
0.1590680629,
-0.0551794134,
-0.5087878108,
0.8150888085,
0.1024621129,
-0.7572544813,
0.1033576801,
-0.2276688367,
0.7023557425,
-0.5803282261,
-0.2028144002,
0.1372613311,
0.2544471025,
-0.399156481,
-0.9608695507,
0.1537365913,
-0.1364521533,
-0.218288511,
-0.1997034997,
1.2832388878,
-0.6997490525,
-0.5143930912,
0.3623023629,
0.1279306263,
0.3120475411,
-0.4585283101,
-0.4443110824,
0.2562715113,
-0.1057432592,
-0.0069002807,
0.1375572383,
0.5980497599,
0.0422342569,
0.538269341,
0.9230512381,
-0.3575282693,
0.1678241938,
0.2464356422,
0.851218462,
-0.1037283465,
-0.3012500703,
-0.9542459846,
0.6761725545,
-0.3544821441,
-0.1447729468,
0.7517701387,
0.3496868312,
0.8852149844,
-0.0133958776,
1.1487985849,
-0.0851152539,
0.1379388124,
-0.5486957431,
0.8610255122,
-0.8307530284,
-0.1028257236,
-0.4450088739,
-0.7983591557,
0.1579860747,
0.6465483904,
-0.4014858007,
0.0263207331,
0.3394661546,
0.8979697227,
-0.2161567509,
0.1922991127,
0.5546352863,
-0.0113958502,
0.1894423217,
0.4584052861,
1.2450072765,
-0.242876485,
0.372127831,
-0.3701599836,
-0.4345998764,
-0.6424354315,
-0.8854569197,
-0.9600353837,
-0.7878547907,
-0.0186761227,
-0.1046045646,
-0.0291939005,
1.0941256285,
0.478938818,
-0.2965225875,
0.0151472343,
-0.070068866,
0.243487075,
0.0093463706,
-0.2514073849,
-0.1849749833,
-0.2704668939,
-0.5911770463,
0.2616923749,
0.2061523199,
-0.003723074,
-0.1799997091,
-0.530619204,
-0.5257204771,
0.074173905,
0.9000523686,
-0.081431821,
-0.6634008288,
-0.282886982,
0.0108630601,
0.0704829767,
-0.3452811837,
0.8571972847,
0.0247092322,
0.8599225879,
0.6544000506,
0.2381945848,
0.484416306,
-0.0966529697,
0.3468052447,
-0.9885668755,
-0.1923495382,
0.0501872934,
0.6395683885,
0.1847794205,
-0.4707244933,
0.2344643176,
0.1631723046,
-0.4221832454,
-0.5959550738,
0.2712836266,
-0.970780015,
-0.4969316125,
1.5105469227,
0.0788932219,
-0.1045705453,
-0.198840782,
-0.4497360587,
0.161287576,
-0.6917388439,
0.6943721175,
1.0099186897,
0.2069748342,
-0.440977186,
-0.7527217865,
0.4822279215,
-0.2294412851,
-0.425270021,
0.2015711814,
0.8928488493,
0.2831518054,
0.3657991588,
0.8888936043,
0.0546724834,
0.3014863729,
-0.1391651481,
0.4386881292,
-0.1341266334,
-0.6391749978,
-0.0363122821,
0.0207768455,
-0.0213864148,
-0.0951673239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18158v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18158v2
|
Evaluating Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T08:43:05 | 2024-06-06T07:30:44 |
Shiyao Li, Xuefei Ning, Luning Wang, Tengxuan Liu, Xiangsheng Shi, Shengen Yan, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Post-training quantization (PTQ) has emerged as a promising technique to
reduce the cost of large language models (LLMs). Specifically, PTQ can
effectively mitigate memory consumption and reduce computational overhead in
LLMs. To meet the requirements of both high efficiency and performance across
diverse scenarios, a comprehensive evaluation of quantized LLMs is essential to
guide the selection of quantization methods. This paper presents a thorough
evaluation of these factors by evaluating the effect of PTQ on Weight,
Activation, and KV Cache on 11 model families, including OPT, LLaMA2, Falcon,
Bloomz, Mistral, ChatGLM, Vicuna, LongChat, StableLM, Gemma, and Mamba, with
parameters ranging from 125M to 180B. The evaluation encompasses five types of
tasks: basic NLP, emergent ability, trustworthiness, dialogue, and long-context
tasks. Moreover, we also evaluate the state-of-the-art (SOTA) quantization
methods to demonstrate their applicability. Based on the extensive experiments,
we systematically summarize the effect of quantization, provide recommendations
to apply quantization techniques, and point out future directions. The code can
be found in https://github.com/thu-nics/qllm-eval.
|
[
-0.224933818,
-0.5913195014,
0.6187846661,
0.4378408194,
-0.5142484903,
0.07709153,
-0.4010809064,
0.0939459279,
-0.3358047307,
0.3669811189,
-0.0737887546,
-0.5410563946,
-0.5447698236,
0.0463148206,
-0.5601930022,
0.7966102958,
-0.0596979298,
0.1285860389,
-0.1487385184,
-0.0812740326,
-0.2287841737,
-0.7865193486,
-0.849154532,
-0.2309167236,
0.2088358104,
-0.1035649702,
0.7685551047,
0.3508048058,
0.3494636714,
0.2670698762,
-0.2247107476,
-0.1810263395,
-0.6761817336,
-0.0338139236,
0.2652528882,
-0.6285949349,
-0.6040666699,
-0.1151304469,
1.0587786436,
0.5152227283,
-0.1422049403,
0.2505840659,
-0.0104214102,
0.6203129292,
-0.9909834862,
0.1318638921,
-0.4102602601,
0.1681703627,
-0.1456295252,
-0.1861846149,
-0.4627038538,
-0.4897787869,
0.3659862876,
-0.6425693631,
-0.5054162145,
-0.1926445365,
0.6435123682,
0.2355644852,
-0.668289721,
0.0964667052,
-0.7988443375,
1.1213431358,
-0.828281939,
0.5692529082,
0.4284249246,
0.1521240622,
0.0160841998,
-0.8765845299,
-0.3593234718,
-0.2699231207,
0.1760706306,
0.153494671,
-0.3846514523,
0.3201412261,
0.4093261063,
0.7034725547,
-0.6140223145,
0.0145276943,
-0.0909569114,
-0.04518402,
0.2080599964,
0.1345011443,
0.1442521513,
0.0693781674,
-0.1953145415,
-0.2097305804,
-0.7143200636,
0.0961713195,
0.3430683315,
-0.178839013,
0.0456672013,
0.5370973349,
-0.6156854033,
0.6564944386,
0.1004681438,
-0.191738531,
0.1236517876,
-0.5825113058,
-0.5036750436,
-0.1732939184,
0.8993755579,
0.1464543641,
0.3224925399,
-0.2774753571,
-0.3413352668,
-0.1425265074,
0.0914670825,
-1.0718506575,
-0.0304263774,
0.2220715731,
-0.5291052461,
-0.1614809185,
-0.2769269049,
-0.1996301711,
-0.1364274472,
-0.2183070183,
0.7360801697,
-0.6361913085,
-0.3073428869,
0.4034959078,
0.0217501763,
0.4039130211,
0.2139609009,
-0.5254525542,
0.2490722984,
0.7229733467,
0.6793347001,
0.0693357289,
-0.0084290942,
-0.639677763,
-0.0634155422,
-0.3638083935,
0.5174282193,
-0.4038676322,
-0.3041123748,
0.0461420231,
-0.2442066967,
-0.0170470588,
-0.4917501807,
0.689838469,
-0.7741953731,
-0.0073038279,
-0.2365136147,
-0.2624958754,
-0.1615041643,
0.1742047817,
-0.8243567348,
1.1261441708,
0.3738211989,
-0.6974492073,
0.4388109446,
-0.2680419087,
-0.3509161174,
0.1624798626,
0.4253115952,
-0.4946032465,
0.3604543507,
0.151007086,
0.4370590746,
-0.5279792547,
0.4374497831,
-0.1736463755,
-0.7298562527,
0.4463478327,
-0.3084350526,
0.7753341794,
0.1705834866,
-0.3721633852,
0.2752824128,
-0.6839164495,
0.3088888526,
-0.1755958945,
-0.5366569757,
-0.4565784037,
-0.0241636317,
-0.2192256302,
0.136218816,
0.1731705219,
-0.0764788538,
0.0399788879,
-0.67332232,
0.7904977202,
0.3090633452,
0.0051096333,
0.3791162372,
-0.0238955822,
0.6876452565,
-0.2014816701,
0.4357245266,
-0.1391241401,
-0.0898375213,
-1.0306198597,
-0.4141272306,
0.7137960792,
0.1626212597,
-1.0079021454,
0.2785348594,
-0.3205427229,
-0.3585948646,
-0.4469743967,
-0.2307862937,
0.725825429,
-0.2468165159,
0.0840472504,
-0.335067153,
-0.5532810688,
-0.8301686049,
-0.199556306,
-0.1363591701,
-0.2204910219,
-0.0788769647,
0.3876041174,
-0.0520163029,
0.883037746,
0.0486540236,
0.2635740042,
-0.0419233814,
0.3344126344,
-0.1085644439,
0.2378779203,
0.3563145995,
-0.4166940153,
-0.4478351176,
-0.0153975794,
-0.2967167795,
-0.1606877446,
-0.0172956958,
-0.1057343781,
0.2631832659,
0.3836033642,
-0.8578974009,
0.3799678385,
0.6379728913,
-0.0704328418,
0.7164233327,
0.0086779315,
0.4062253833,
-0.6368447542,
0.3899959624,
-0.0232218839,
-0.3734814227,
-0.6221761703,
0.2623805702,
0.1769818515,
-0.1342110634,
-0.6569299102,
0.5245082974,
-0.4547215402,
-0.420048207,
-0.1693568081,
0.0250413399,
0.0514000095,
0.4256314337,
-0.0664109439,
0.850771606,
0.4009972215,
-0.4958904088,
0.2107124031,
-0.2390663773,
-0.5750631094,
0.243825838,
-0.879874289,
0.2170602381,
0.0887159556,
0.2316335589,
-0.8968249559,
0.3520928621,
0.0513722263,
-0.2653084695,
0.0191205479,
-0.100414291,
-1.1468697786,
-0.2147207558,
-0.5206491947,
0.5610762835,
0.4216454029,
-0.1998209655,
0.4200258851,
0.0804793909,
0.1638779193,
-0.2948383391,
-0.2591588497,
0.0897332877,
-0.5299490094,
-0.3231817484,
0.2298737168,
-0.0389345847,
-0.2705054581,
-0.2059196234,
-0.1954961121,
-0.1495337784,
0.3832146227,
0.1189698055,
-0.1652833074,
-0.1788613349,
0.2401810735,
0.2040896565,
-0.1997122616,
0.0534844957,
-0.4760906696,
0.9082656503,
-0.5149089098,
0.0651057586,
-0.4597613811,
-0.0970830992,
0.5644416809,
-0.6124600768,
0.8266817927,
0.9148040414,
-0.295591563,
0.0013563058,
-0.4824685156,
-0.0002234891,
-0.41203776,
0.5310288072,
-0.3057431281,
-1.141890645,
0.3603241742,
-0.270837456,
-0.1820550263,
0.3877609372,
0.8407796621,
0.2290827483,
1.1791390181,
0.4177166522,
0.1085703447,
0.518432498,
-0.2840125859,
0.3491038978,
-0.8340357542,
0.1829819828,
-0.4344552159,
-0.100823015,
-0.3218765855,
-0.7454934716,
0.3691020906,
0.4936926961,
-0.3329463899,
0.3494769037,
-0.1598358452,
0.2580556273,
0.4586422443,
-0.0701342374,
0.4521850646,
-0.099028714,
0.0574861765,
0.1454660445,
-0.6077994704,
-0.6228012443,
1.4639099836,
0.4644853175,
0.4650014341,
-0.0827156752,
0.3552297056,
0.0965878069,
0.2133542746,
-1.1025072336,
0.6024034619,
-0.1710976064,
-0.2723981142,
-0.528192997,
-0.4963108301,
-0.9744420648,
0.3338464499,
-0.2779382467,
-0.5554744601,
-0.201482445,
-0.1060423777,
-0.7482581139,
-0.1953304559,
-0.6324900389,
0.8623689413,
-0.288970083,
-0.1366104037,
-0.5813876987,
-0.3479225338,
0.7333449721,
-0.490147382,
-0.2463373542,
0.0482033752,
-0.1858983785,
0.9811292887,
-0.3328215182,
0.54676193,
0.0365609713,
-0.1649137437,
0.2998974621,
-0.0924286097,
0.4016356766,
0.0629775673,
-0.1547049582,
0.2464478463,
0.5225602984,
-0.1877593398,
-0.6942859292,
0.4959999323,
-0.6867796183,
-0.4213298857,
-0.1826547384,
-0.5366683006,
-0.4199224114,
0.1611037999,
-0.0816438049,
0.3653377891,
-0.0957470462,
0.6112319231,
0.7298620343,
-0.6327433586,
0.4118519127,
0.6088485122,
-0.2928523123,
-0.6219146848,
0.5967449546,
0.0708191618,
0.4614132345,
0.5232509375,
0.3550931215,
-0.1998573393,
-0.724270463,
-0.1544436812,
0.227824837,
-0.3436240852,
-0.3095312417,
-0.7079303265,
-0.1411233246,
-0.2809403241,
0.3151529133,
-0.4689787626,
-0.6543731093,
-0.3019497991,
0.051035542,
0.1705060601,
0.0566308908,
0.4982949197,
0.9707607031,
-0.7810566425,
0.1510775983,
0.4341500998,
0.275334388,
0.1491884887,
-0.462703079,
-0.6903065443,
0.0388448797,
-0.2907919884,
-0.5338706374,
0.3963354528,
0.2340914607,
0.3840897679,
0.6045863032,
0.1306210756,
0.8727176785,
-0.2745207548,
0.64769274,
0.087349996,
-1.3793510199,
0.2896982431,
-0.2440253496,
0.458011657,
0.452355653,
0.4727456868,
-0.3616394103,
-0.3384867907,
-0.4676474631,
-0.8003755808,
0.4869714379,
0.3098919988,
0.0601669885,
0.162917763,
0.4619626105,
-0.1468633562,
0.5850414634,
-0.8223802447,
-0.0727638751,
0.1077156439,
0.0724828839,
0.2282095253,
-0.7223771811,
0.0885244906,
-0.0838236883,
0.4999832213,
0.0910994932,
0.1273723841,
-0.2606726289,
-0.2262798697,
-0.1496357769,
0.3615897298,
0.4953948855,
0.7183965445,
-0.1948398501,
0.0818715915,
0.1401819885,
-0.1882363111,
-0.0539052077,
-0.0611187555,
-0.0739297941,
-0.1856982112,
0.3336253464,
0.9795435071,
0.4898023605,
-0.8961379528,
0.607627809,
-0.2309161574,
-0.1087889001,
-0.1375948638,
0.0351590551,
-0.1162994877,
0.416124016,
0.146168381,
-0.4832397997,
0.3355229497,
-0.6253373027,
-0.0004600752,
0.6272544265,
-0.1790491194,
-0.5765556693,
0.3564941585,
0.0011812939,
-0.0589067861,
0.4795719981,
-0.306456387,
-0.6962250471,
0.3658739328,
0.3850164711,
0.8643780351,
-0.455740571,
0.1812358499,
0.3398737311,
0.394633621,
-0.1848715693,
0.243409127,
-0.2192047089,
-0.4186611176,
-1.0131344795,
-0.8677559495,
-0.084335424,
0.2888789773,
-0.6171845794,
0.2080586702,
-0.3480930626,
-0.5240184665,
-0.4767880142,
0.3537358046,
-0.5721391439,
0.2304100692,
0.1294007748,
0.506200552,
-0.6430703998,
1.0879898071,
0.5194307566,
0.0130410213,
-0.7258986831,
0.0597066395,
-0.4689051211,
-0.7579775453,
0.930113256,
-0.1081972122,
0.1473521143,
0.3738618493,
-0.1911997646,
-1.0680316687,
1.0263668299,
0.4033246636,
-0.6106035113,
0.0323412791,
0.2724584937,
0.807118535,
0.1228666231,
0.6559517384,
0.9291840792,
0.4653427899,
0.0377656147,
-1.215364337,
0.0233698115,
-0.0427751057,
0.3818820417,
0.3439665139,
-0.6151590943,
0.8636881113,
0.2104365379,
-0.4820441902,
0.3051184714,
0.4597814083,
0.5164456367,
-0.0445129536,
0.5248425603,
0.7571976185,
0.3405921757,
-0.0453775898,
0.9122777581,
-0.508368969,
0.4254395068,
0.6906806827,
-0.2413377762,
0.8294103146,
0.4467568994,
-0.6382752061,
-0.0371047109,
0.6327583194,
0.2199529856,
0.5319375992,
0.7221395969,
-0.1772787273,
-0.2015951425,
-0.1867310107,
-0.3215443492,
0.4523318112,
0.2253418267,
-0.1031290293,
0.033912383,
0.1427325606,
0.2018652558,
-0.5282066464,
-0.4034796059,
0.5307615399,
0.2514138818,
-0.5870243907,
0.9368607402,
0.2777968347,
0.3884728849,
-0.5708069205,
0.1313284189,
-0.101621978,
-0.0629501194,
-0.033072751,
-0.3616458178,
0.1571568996,
-0.0027317172,
0.0807247385,
-0.4026708007,
0.5154150724,
-0.2816608548,
-0.3133393526,
0.1028844938,
0.404486537,
0.0716145411,
-0.6601271629,
-0.4533648789,
0.3606750667,
-0.2018472701,
-0.4304927588,
0.5261441469,
0.5794662833,
-0.171560064,
0.6420964599,
0.5512487888,
0.0368911065,
0.0563412532,
0.1339312792,
0.78906703,
-0.4855322242,
-0.295529753,
-0.7822726965,
0.5582906008,
0.4115897417,
-0.2109650075,
0.9237949848,
0.6119627953,
0.6244254112,
-0.004091742,
0.5200561881,
0.2872984707,
0.083760187,
-0.745010674,
0.6451089382,
-0.4351078868,
0.3357552886,
-0.3329052627,
-1.1809033155,
-0.323623538,
0.5351361632,
-0.6160085797,
0.1300246865,
0.9211004972,
0.3690753281,
0.4137831926,
-0.2695903182,
0.5532110929,
0.1051801741,
0.0683690012,
0.7964097261,
1.2695022821,
-0.5713555217,
0.6770192385,
-0.2349257171,
-0.1468797177,
-0.2507821023,
-0.7880690694,
-0.9563525319,
-0.5476016998,
-0.612148881,
-0.1681574881,
0.0659626946,
0.4105864465,
0.9102566838,
-0.4965437651,
-0.311997205,
0.0668404102,
-0.1287156492,
-0.2100058794,
-0.2331953049,
0.5813165903,
-0.1564199775,
-0.8747109175,
0.1581369787,
0.5191731453,
-0.1287608296,
-0.4081711769,
-0.1164109111,
0.1811174154,
-0.0540103987,
1.0646011829,
-0.1081830189,
-0.8058264256,
-0.0244714264,
0.0907892212,
-0.1202107668,
-0.0980906114,
0.9514319301,
-0.9999160171,
0.2961564958,
0.455352664,
0.5242177248,
0.5194083452,
0.0712289065,
0.5979539752,
-0.4222405255,
0.0631977394,
0.3817715049,
0.147712484,
-0.0120584071,
-0.1005992293,
0.4632141292,
-0.101763688,
-0.6160222292,
-1.0262299776,
-0.1562293321,
-0.9619846344,
-0.0681528822,
1.2194868326,
-0.2684684396,
-0.106135495,
0.1709923297,
-0.0151762813,
0.4493584633,
-0.2341760397,
0.6311578155,
0.7690426707,
0.2463096678,
-0.5478839278,
-0.6600537896,
0.4725092947,
0.6207161546,
-0.8400864005,
-0.1138417423,
0.339471221,
-0.0656275526,
-0.2500573099,
0.5752660036,
-0.2035947144,
0.1968162656,
-0.3715845346,
0.2658197284,
0.1754896343,
0.0158728361,
-0.5527909398,
-0.0517344922,
0.3445747793,
0.0703795925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18157v1
|
From Summary to Action: Enhancing Large Language Models for Complex Tasks with Open World APIs
| 2024-02-28T08:42:23 | 2024-02-28T08:42:23 |
Yulong Liu, Yunlong Yuan, Chunwei Wang, Jianhua Han, Yongqiang Ma, Li Zhang, Nanning Zheng, Hang Xu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The distinction between humans and animals lies in the unique ability of
humans to use and create tools. Tools empower humans to overcome physiological
limitations, fostering the creation of magnificent civilizations. Similarly,
enabling foundational models like Large Language Models (LLMs) with the
capacity to learn external tool usage may serve as a pivotal step toward
realizing artificial general intelligence. Previous studies in this field have
predominantly pursued two distinct approaches to augment the tool invocation
capabilities of LLMs. The first approach emphasizes the construction of
relevant datasets for model fine-tuning. The second approach, in contrast, aims
to fully exploit the inherent reasoning abilities of LLMs through in-context
learning strategies. In this work, we introduce a novel tool invocation
pipeline designed to control massive real-world APIs. This pipeline mirrors the
human task-solving process, addressing complicated real-life user queries. At
each step, we guide LLMs to summarize the achieved results and determine the
next course of action. We term this pipeline `from Summary to action', Sum2Act
for short. Empirical evaluations of our Sum2Act pipeline on the ToolBench
benchmark show significant performance improvements, outperforming established
methods like ReAct and DFSDT. This highlights Sum2Act's effectiveness in
enhancing LLMs for complex real-world tasks.
|
[
-0.2136518508,
-0.7162739635,
0.4297134876,
0.0148652354,
-0.1853417456,
0.2986399829,
-0.2754997313,
-0.3738021553,
0.0355991833,
0.725834012,
-0.5364640951,
-0.2548245788,
-0.4953644574,
-0.0812308192,
-0.5335515738,
0.8808178902,
0.0455458015,
-0.0555624776,
-0.352367878,
-0.1049925759,
-0.5710187554,
-0.3700906932,
-0.6067986488,
-0.4916176498,
0.3854674995,
0.4759530425,
0.6707739234,
0.4237940311,
0.3825258613,
0.3614996672,
0.0444731712,
0.4194825888,
-0.6176838875,
0.0958412886,
-0.3446117938,
-0.6922163963,
-0.3886042535,
-0.075529635,
0.4359348416,
0.812024951,
-0.107026875,
0.4120710194,
0.1986799389,
0.3999810517,
-0.5810211897,
0.1447169632,
-0.5364567041,
-0.1937098503,
0.1123182848,
0.0179364588,
-0.3889731765,
-0.0461619534,
0.1309492886,
-0.4899503291,
-0.0653635561,
-0.0092394641,
0.3405649066,
0.5234920979,
-0.2582760155,
-0.450211674,
-0.6790362597,
0.7996445894,
-0.9501016736,
0.169419229,
0.2811556756,
0.2307619601,
-0.5346095562,
-1.0281971693,
-0.4476758838,
0.110814631,
-0.3510801792,
0.0544257723,
-0.1530470848,
0.0072043859,
0.5162736773,
0.1567723453,
-0.5314118862,
0.210696429,
-0.3786380291,
-0.215561837,
0.5309286714,
0.2700686157,
0.3666454256,
0.1240917295,
-0.1052463502,
0.0581628941,
-0.7851811647,
0.2463164032,
0.2595787048,
0.3742094636,
-0.2570838928,
0.6572813392,
-0.1094670296,
0.6799510121,
-0.3450152576,
-0.1179456189,
-0.116359435,
-0.0779339895,
-0.4098584652,
-0.2091555446,
0.517701447,
0.1811525524,
0.1384695172,
-0.3236234784,
-0.1856895089,
-0.0843184814,
0.3690699935,
-0.891974926,
0.0657837763,
0.6368247867,
-0.2039322853,
-0.1537874788,
-0.1054535806,
-0.5234355927,
-0.5111296177,
-0.6385082006,
0.3944815099,
-0.1725837141,
-0.3640418649,
0.0147007871,
-0.2408988923,
0.295165509,
0.3212543726,
-0.7530629039,
0.5609371662,
1.0077520609,
1.007240057,
-0.0037159631,
-0.2232005447,
-0.8106169105,
0.2499704361,
-0.4842234552,
0.7682987452,
-0.5105660558,
-0.4028002024,
0.0443212204,
-0.1405276358,
0.3033796549,
-0.8201616406,
0.3693876266,
-0.4990984499,
0.2628779411,
-0.3071854115,
-0.4378989935,
-0.3269761503,
0.2131175995,
-0.5082504153,
1.1246554852,
0.3282286823,
-0.4388663769,
0.2228318006,
-1.1398186684,
-0.5346575379,
0.0203448422,
-0.0487980805,
-0.1243978292,
0.2119238824,
0.2167464793,
0.5187774897,
-0.4954382479,
0.1526623964,
-0.2273525745,
-0.4598217607,
0.0275440849,
-0.0198704191,
0.8663029075,
-0.0292701069,
-0.2692689896,
0.445381552,
-0.4436852932,
-0.0122957351,
0.00628309,
-0.1323639601,
-0.3678296506,
0.081290856,
-0.281485945,
0.3351735175,
-0.0306795239,
-0.4133764505,
0.1893040538,
-0.8231906295,
0.7412389517,
0.5929533839,
-0.005733592,
0.6335826516,
-0.0797364861,
0.3490479589,
-0.3573724031,
-0.037617851,
-0.3120746613,
-0.2910542488,
-0.5535803437,
-0.4436666667,
0.1243944243,
0.6715407968,
-0.5936442614,
0.474394232,
-0.265416503,
-0.5641527772,
-0.3137519658,
0.2950878739,
0.4391111732,
0.5505461693,
0.2751801312,
-0.3844932318,
-0.4708508551,
-0.664498806,
-0.2843718827,
-0.1270651072,
-0.6243056655,
0.417937547,
0.5367743969,
-0.1633985043,
1.0420633554,
-0.4531674087,
-0.1939094514,
-0.3870460093,
0.2873344421,
0.2205247581,
0.2702524364,
0.5184718966,
-0.6384034753,
-0.1445686817,
-0.2077602595,
-0.9411047697,
-0.1155510992,
-0.031552095,
-0.3878035545,
-0.0732250959,
0.7612807155,
-0.5953653455,
0.2493415475,
0.2621153295,
-0.395891726,
0.4873917997,
-0.0913071632,
-0.2350316495,
-0.9399730563,
0.1135465875,
-0.2533156574,
-0.26244542,
-0.5071464777,
0.3678997159,
0.0875622407,
-0.3201560974,
-0.6441187859,
0.8237791657,
-0.4601412416,
-0.3796794713,
-0.3892972767,
0.0769211277,
-0.1750108153,
0.6277891397,
-0.2956317365,
0.8257855177,
0.5975783467,
-0.7565723062,
0.4370184243,
0.267030865,
-0.251475662,
0.3485601842,
-0.7834768295,
0.0072415709,
-0.1057807133,
0.3715013564,
-1.137768507,
-0.574739635,
0.0760150328,
-0.404640317,
0.2405150235,
-0.1005959064,
-0.8472429514,
-0.2074766606,
-0.2703058422,
0.0781566203,
0.5134221315,
-0.5548686981,
1.0541622639,
0.4777697921,
-0.3430416882,
-0.3592935801,
-0.6876836419,
0.2543287575,
-0.2647601664,
-0.4031065404,
0.0983943343,
-0.1131125838,
-0.4822802544,
-0.2111626267,
0.0056617493,
0.089889355,
0.1649760157,
0.3058069348,
0.089976944,
0.0843627304,
0.3082853556,
0.2885772884,
-0.0851194412,
0.3002163172,
-0.1479327679,
0.636294663,
0.0922372937,
-0.4130241871,
-0.2071332335,
0.4838950634,
0.807094872,
-0.5154988766,
0.2199109644,
0.4329941571,
-0.3545664847,
-0.2984898388,
-0.3487777412,
-0.5817861557,
-0.4901762903,
0.4972524047,
-0.1139567569,
-0.7263144255,
0.5780553222,
-0.7322852612,
0.6698045731,
0.1156484857,
0.7357903123,
-0.1708167791,
1.0419164896,
0.4805460572,
-0.1085120589,
0.5356054306,
-0.6611814499,
0.1858318001,
-1.0591826439,
0.0688199699,
-0.2095847726,
-0.6284708381,
-0.0653075874,
-0.5967488289,
0.4816164374,
0.1769997329,
-0.4362792373,
0.1488340199,
-0.3068501353,
0.6548330784,
0.4380140603,
0.013939498,
0.0776662454,
0.0643438846,
-0.0999907404,
0.1931992024,
-0.551828444,
-0.6034104228,
1.2497156858,
0.2519824207,
0.5157773495,
0.34278813,
0.3802955449,
0.3525277078,
0.4713784158,
-1.0132955313,
0.6211726069,
0.0923630819,
-0.4644033015,
-0.4698316753,
0.1136581823,
-0.6901956201,
0.4321711361,
-0.0885916948,
-0.7570804954,
-0.1478736848,
0.050317347,
-0.3401539624,
0.2241755575,
-0.885383606,
0.6188606024,
-0.3056427836,
-0.5889650583,
-0.487226665,
-0.7993240356,
0.325189501,
0.2333801687,
0.458894819,
-0.0290838368,
-0.3950086236,
0.3865445554,
-0.3886321187,
1.1702800989,
-0.249928087,
-0.3451446891,
0.3512324095,
0.1264507771,
0.8847626448,
0.0228771325,
-0.1337764114,
0.0336604677,
-0.4632880986,
-0.4867708981,
-0.8600804806,
0.5934754014,
-0.5022950768,
-0.3730911613,
-0.0951946899,
-0.744310081,
-0.4671577513,
0.2887595892,
-0.0424217284,
0.7933372259,
-0.0789535716,
0.1086398289,
0.5321971178,
-0.085494794,
0.7534908056,
0.5658065677,
-0.2395824939,
-0.3644963503,
0.7096207142,
-0.0172780827,
0.4050325751,
0.2978312969,
0.1917761862,
-0.4027965367,
-0.4423630834,
-0.7082349658,
0.2807292044,
-0.6603879929,
-0.1513509452,
-0.5712221265,
0.2300325781,
-0.304795742,
-0.2241036892,
-0.171729669,
-0.2153480351,
-0.2595555782,
-0.1231003329,
0.1914801598,
0.635661006,
0.1046208739,
0.3311547339,
-0.6896631122,
0.4292069972,
0.4389466643,
0.3527933359,
0.1675349176,
-0.4710631967,
-0.2962600291,
0.1085982695,
-0.2337371707,
-0.5850166082,
0.2476221174,
0.3086038232,
0.5411619544,
0.3934109807,
0.1242885143,
0.7516279221,
-0.4273538589,
0.8867795467,
-0.1369460672,
-0.8060306907,
0.4804310501,
-0.2771743834,
0.3935083747,
0.0725950524,
0.2929515839,
-0.3088699877,
-0.5809928775,
-0.4033932984,
-1.1293209791,
0.6086096764,
0.0715655237,
0.3138419688,
0.2964856923,
0.3324317336,
0.0057031987,
0.1311020702,
-0.1402536631,
0.0222372562,
0.0148964766,
-0.0451890342,
0.0858145207,
-0.1046849564,
-0.3560898304,
-0.3597682416,
0.5593926907,
-0.4929399788,
0.0293163378,
0.0331158713,
-0.3387521505,
-0.0424566492,
0.2884596586,
0.5113328695,
0.9336568713,
0.0057722786,
-0.0411515273,
0.3157632053,
-0.3306002319,
-0.1759024411,
-0.1156718358,
-0.0332052074,
-0.4152470231,
0.6357502341,
0.6554131508,
0.3950873315,
-1.2975819111,
0.2637842298,
-0.0554966703,
-0.0859828666,
-0.3153124154,
0.1973054856,
0.2976937592,
0.4935596287,
0.3973675072,
-0.0133099211,
0.3317917883,
-0.7034651637,
0.0468555354,
0.375418961,
-0.3824050128,
-0.2500155568,
0.4770424366,
0.2943462729,
-0.2825101018,
0.5466454029,
-0.2490033805,
-0.3915641904,
0.4738643765,
0.6128216982,
0.771510303,
0.1143847033,
-0.0393573157,
0.4536391497,
0.1699567288,
0.0250469055,
0.3835504949,
-0.1675888896,
-0.4842480123,
-0.7890677452,
-0.5063676238,
-0.4816789925,
-0.0167733654,
-0.4613827467,
0.2398045957,
-0.4501208663,
0.2779614925,
-0.0677801445,
-0.1425798982,
-0.3464654982,
0.0872249603,
-0.1221386045,
0.8048670292,
-0.7883039117,
0.5855826735,
0.7667008638,
-0.3697969615,
-0.8538065553,
-0.041893553,
0.2464774847,
-0.5539643764,
0.4993858039,
0.0016153556,
-0.2661057711,
0.1317419112,
-0.8039464951,
-0.8055998683,
1.085906148,
0.5321748257,
-0.3417152464,
0.061154969,
-0.0303797219,
0.6188428402,
-0.3490187228,
0.3763390779,
0.747792244,
0.3471597433,
0.303766489,
-0.8951343298,
0.0656267479,
-0.2439246327,
-0.2177308798,
0.3689916134,
-0.4110644758,
0.66278404,
-0.4946862459,
-0.2257113606,
-0.0418370925,
0.5589808822,
0.2564623654,
0.105583325,
0.5185521841,
0.6698604226,
0.6837480664,
-0.0044883224,
1.1055014133,
-0.0346479937,
0.0505358651,
1.2851701975,
-0.3133710325,
1.0452529192,
0.3063431084,
-0.3444013,
0.5310249925,
0.4827791154,
0.2572764456,
0.3650836349,
0.2432322055,
-0.2950482368,
-0.1337671578,
-0.247312203,
0.0361830629,
0.5779982209,
0.6860644221,
-0.1047218591,
-0.4187557995,
0.0937952846,
0.1785750091,
0.1392446607,
-0.4282084107,
1.1997340918,
-0.101268433,
-0.7450226545,
0.4573767781,
-0.1377745867,
0.5649569035,
-0.7147957683,
-0.3448494971,
-0.0479477532,
0.1738123745,
-0.252412945,
-0.7777225375,
0.4991910756,
0.0692680404,
-0.1490030885,
-0.1967790872,
0.6358315945,
-0.2744558156,
-0.3761539161,
0.3284539878,
0.3582392037,
0.2424853593,
-0.3523628116,
-0.4805906117,
-0.1649155319,
-0.1775098741,
-0.0652841181,
0.3956685364,
0.400318563,
-0.3588601649,
0.7524327636,
0.8772380352,
0.1791083813,
-0.1609304994,
0.0987894163,
1.0417124033,
-0.4610346556,
-0.564961493,
-0.802780807,
0.7621541619,
-0.232536599,
-0.0940961167,
0.4641289711,
0.7919748425,
0.8489115834,
-0.0109540001,
1.023324728,
-0.2184185833,
0.9278653264,
-0.305337429,
0.5514205098,
-0.5871926546,
0.2786416709,
-0.120451428,
-0.5895822644,
-0.4494399726,
0.2138492167,
-0.1601057798,
-0.3469230831,
0.4122724235,
0.8514567018,
-0.168127358,
-0.1723498255,
0.2070789486,
0.2605772316,
0.7288252115,
0.2039511353,
0.4742067754,
-0.2107618898,
0.5010949373,
-0.0241662525,
-0.484580487,
-0.132825762,
-0.8899133801,
-0.901643455,
-0.2846788764,
0.120064795,
-0.0336577334,
-0.2610760927,
1.1161834002,
0.678537786,
-0.7666667104,
-0.4333281517,
-0.1690369248,
0.0920918211,
-0.5014330745,
-0.161567077,
0.3372115195,
-0.4908568561,
-0.7759283185,
0.3971123695,
0.4842680395,
-0.1931829154,
-0.5233969688,
-0.1391309053,
-0.0575987361,
0.0639197677,
1.1008940935,
0.4567238986,
-0.9243839979,
-0.0854882002,
-0.110090591,
0.2724600732,
-0.2577249706,
1.1708037853,
-0.9678379297,
0.5385451913,
0.6292652488,
0.6111024022,
0.2627078891,
0.0462312885,
0.6878118515,
-0.8928218484,
0.3259872496,
0.3565951586,
0.303868264,
0.2218510658,
-0.1927968264,
0.7222483158,
-0.1104725227,
-0.3614380658,
-0.8685017824,
0.4051668942,
-0.7798079252,
-0.4303725362,
0.9850461483,
-0.1113074273,
-0.0267508607,
-0.2390200049,
-0.5646383166,
0.2656015456,
-0.388936311,
0.6721542478,
0.500968039,
-0.3443869054,
-0.0231447741,
-0.7115057111,
0.2800068855,
0.0329959057,
-1.0454246998,
0.4767052233,
0.5782814026,
0.2206550986,
0.1460949779,
0.3825122714,
-0.210300982,
0.0767661333,
-0.2176952958,
-0.0381470732,
-0.2205717415,
-0.3183030486,
0.0086845625,
0.1975691915,
-0.0074692513,
0.0221967045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18154v1
|
Cutting Off the Head Ends the Conflict: A Mechanism for Interpreting and Mitigating Knowledge Conflicts in Language Models
| 2024-02-28T08:34:41 | 2024-02-28T08:34:41 |
Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Hongbang Yuan, Yubo Chen, Jiexin Xu, Huaijun Li, Xiaojian Jiang, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recently, retrieval augmentation and tool augmentation have demonstrated a
remarkable capability to expand the internal memory boundaries of language
models (LMs) by providing external context. However, internal memory and
external context inevitably clash, leading to knowledge conflicts within LMs.
In this paper, we aim to interpret the mechanism of knowledge conflicts through
the lens of information flow, and then mitigate conflicts by precise
interventions at the pivotal point. We find there are some attention heads with
opposite effects in the later layers, where memory heads can recall knowledge
from internal memory, and context heads can retrieve knowledge from external
context. Moreover, we reveal that the pivotal point at which knowledge
conflicts emerge in LMs is the integration of inconsistent information flows by
memory heads and context heads. Inspired by the insights, we propose a novel
method called Pruning Head via PatH PatcHing (PH3), which can efficiently
mitigate knowledge conflicts by pruning conflicting attention heads without
updating model parameters. PH3 can flexibly control eight LMs to use internal
memory ($\uparrow$ 44.0%) or external context ($\uparrow$ 38.5%). Moreover, PH3
can also improve the performance of LMs on open-domain QA tasks. We also
conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate the cross-model, cross-relation,
and cross-format generalization of our method.
|
[
-0.4554038048,
-0.923820138,
0.6994248629,
-0.0845505372,
-0.3178862929,
0.0454803966,
-0.2148441076,
-0.4778378308,
-0.0187498461,
0.7428184152,
-0.6885078549,
0.0307441112,
-0.6072791815,
-0.2982974052,
-0.195751816,
0.9002421498,
-0.1704651564,
-0.2731766105,
-0.1776681095,
-0.2143361121,
-0.7828735113,
-0.423101604,
-0.8127416372,
-0.3074551523,
0.6404983997,
0.2055924535,
0.6888394952,
1.0561829805,
0.8196878433,
0.2495756298,
-0.3782479167,
0.2131984085,
-0.631203711,
0.3756880462,
-0.4989444315,
-0.4092709124,
-0.1379627734,
-0.1688386947,
0.6203417182,
0.6436071992,
0.0780598819,
-0.1106075495,
0.2297162116,
0.9286745191,
-0.7834154963,
-0.0294835921,
-0.7820760012,
-0.1052917391,
-0.4504884183,
-0.4372658134,
-0.132014811,
-0.2274161726,
0.4043238461,
-0.389098376,
-0.278486073,
-0.2859401703,
1.0303683281,
0.4051814079,
-0.2624874413,
-0.1211482808,
-0.7609905601,
0.7446248531,
-0.7969551682,
0.1995332092,
0.3258498013,
0.3297781646,
-0.0739066675,
-0.5242962837,
-0.5183359981,
0.4601950347,
0.1147259548,
-0.0840739831,
-0.4314824343,
-0.0803092942,
0.3275281787,
0.1052424833,
-0.1539720148,
-0.2809990644,
-0.6944459081,
0.0836884081,
0.2905237973,
-0.0089559294,
0.4242633879,
0.1483392864,
-0.3666577339,
-0.0057989615,
-1.0456182957,
0.1429230869,
0.2757307589,
0.2286514491,
0.2969051301,
0.4222300053,
-0.0113238553,
1.051617384,
0.2267497629,
-0.3703318238,
-0.0766259283,
-0.2821384668,
-0.3198077679,
-0.2153707743,
0.6537883282,
0.6479117274,
0.254470557,
-0.1227732301,
-0.0948756486,
-0.0893162489,
0.468203634,
-0.611641407,
-0.0516818576,
0.2738546729,
-0.1038338467,
-0.0901913717,
-0.1696348041,
-0.6711162925,
-0.3844131827,
-0.2531535625,
0.5264819264,
-0.6440542936,
-0.5137367249,
-0.0796805173,
-0.1077363566,
0.1266817451,
0.3619113266,
-0.3275819719,
0.1087252349,
0.6692973971,
1.0235188007,
-0.202443257,
-0.2058898956,
-0.2672290504,
0.5929053426,
-0.3220933676,
0.6188477278,
-0.4721872211,
-0.1895198822,
-0.0887658522,
-0.10969273,
-0.309643209,
-0.8471015096,
0.2244159132,
-0.6210975051,
0.0921668634,
-0.533808291,
-0.51609689,
-0.5009530187,
0.3409588039,
-0.7446754575,
0.6446210742,
0.1329684705,
-0.84654212,
0.092367582,
-0.4217440188,
-0.357344538,
-0.0206623487,
-0.2333859801,
-0.3284637928,
-0.241585657,
0.0175170954,
0.1011775658,
-0.4433747828,
0.2890845239,
-0.1545266509,
-0.2372673601,
-0.0335315615,
0.1807677448,
0.8334695697,
0.138448149,
-0.4234055281,
0.3000909388,
-0.3967529535,
-0.179309085,
0.2062833756,
-0.0976198018,
-0.7548931241,
-0.0401979424,
-0.4548379481,
0.6692795753,
0.0069743334,
-0.3733508587,
0.1401103288,
-0.2888287008,
0.469170332,
0.7581841946,
0.553347826,
0.4133096635,
-0.7777662873,
0.5217814445,
0.5129025578,
0.1805199087,
-0.1457312107,
-0.7011348605,
-0.7598511577,
0.0900463387,
-0.1713129431,
0.4495207667,
-0.7728942633,
0.2960553169,
-0.1085208431,
-0.3601811826,
-0.5224911571,
0.1091473699,
0.4159201682,
0.7308610678,
0.2083579153,
-0.3849565387,
-0.5025119781,
-0.8346691132,
-0.6513474584,
-0.1985040307,
0.0885277689,
0.2592305243,
0.0009371261,
0.0057067098,
1.3409444094,
-0.3361025453,
-0.5407890677,
-0.2352176309,
0.0251975786,
-0.0336605087,
0.6938818693,
0.3662077487,
-0.7807023525,
-0.4137434065,
0.0821373016,
-0.5754535794,
-0.1378220171,
-0.2930372953,
-0.4486952126,
-0.0377514511,
0.4302981496,
-0.7961146235,
0.4619916975,
0.2016865164,
-0.360104531,
0.3838184774,
0.2946741879,
0.1560012251,
-0.5498968363,
0.141300261,
0.0101159131,
-0.1629151106,
-0.87089324,
0.3274540901,
0.157846421,
0.2187370956,
-0.6654586792,
0.6204561591,
-0.4896755517,
0.2320026904,
-0.3957459033,
0.384139359,
0.2419587225,
0.7307153344,
0.1893894076,
0.5036143064,
0.3708091378,
-0.8257170916,
0.0022483028,
0.1908313334,
-0.1023010686,
0.7167277336,
-0.2119607925,
0.34628883,
-0.1997141689,
-0.1407122612,
-0.5753747225,
0.1791052967,
0.551358223,
-0.1916206777,
0.2260508984,
-0.2648583651,
-0.083155863,
-0.0364139415,
-0.4594420493,
0.6456307769,
0.4797932506,
-0.205761224,
0.5390315652,
0.7692584991,
-0.263289541,
-0.4575728476,
-0.6263777614,
-0.0696449131,
-0.4649964273,
-0.7019867301,
0.3219113648,
-0.1985429376,
-0.473595649,
0.105651103,
-0.3629824817,
-0.4430007637,
-0.1772621274,
-0.0443002433,
0.0632960275,
-0.1326669455,
0.0164247211,
0.0645802468,
0.2299170345,
0.1290898919,
-0.3135631979,
0.2979149818,
0.2326669693,
-0.4105218053,
-0.1178992093,
0.2850984037,
0.7555008531,
-0.2470909804,
0.8374587297,
0.2967669964,
-0.5742247701,
0.1338290572,
-0.8724437356,
-0.284974426,
-0.4359565079,
0.329752624,
-0.4374488294,
-0.7355732918,
0.5090824366,
-0.1771780103,
0.263974309,
0.3329882622,
0.4364986122,
0.2565947473,
0.7405644655,
0.5948247313,
0.0554666221,
0.5495276451,
-0.0470818058,
0.4710942507,
-1.2888457775,
-0.1534616202,
-0.1779668927,
-0.3044835925,
0.0343418494,
-0.7049645185,
0.4384393394,
0.6693512201,
-0.0286767874,
0.5097910166,
-0.5195109844,
0.359875083,
0.4369808137,
0.0509298965,
0.4217746854,
-0.3074859083,
-0.2037189454,
-0.210702464,
-0.8004585505,
-0.2377147675,
0.7960973382,
0.4823034108,
0.3895179629,
0.1212171242,
0.3009530902,
-0.1418483108,
0.1117694676,
-0.5988880396,
0.4784475863,
0.4593629539,
-0.3970163167,
-0.3369269967,
-0.5270431638,
-0.8127906322,
0.5816498995,
0.2585654259,
-0.9912785888,
0.402454257,
0.1563951075,
-0.4694392979,
0.8052945733,
-0.6248779297,
0.9761122465,
0.0657910109,
-0.5754161477,
-0.2548225224,
-0.5903745294,
0.6675143838,
-0.1655252129,
0.4931295514,
-0.0107975956,
0.0862642154,
1.1196397543,
-0.3962951005,
0.5359909534,
-0.1687492728,
-0.2195249498,
0.5623964667,
0.3866757154,
0.6771675348,
-0.3015470207,
0.3347260952,
0.0729631558,
0.0150178848,
-0.2485124469,
-0.5369874835,
0.5477133989,
-0.4146444798,
-0.8271456361,
-0.2240034789,
-0.8794238567,
-0.4126875997,
0.2817837894,
0.0379102416,
0.156666711,
0.2566601038,
-0.1460657567,
0.7077014446,
-0.1579476446,
0.4057885706,
0.5843362808,
-0.2765581608,
-0.0634334832,
1.0166454315,
0.2762145698,
0.5694262981,
0.2038588226,
0.228070572,
0.1031840742,
-0.4537302554,
-0.2135562301,
0.3227861226,
-0.7475964427,
-0.4068173766,
-0.7940139771,
-0.3746805489,
-0.3504381478,
0.1832156181,
-0.4393472672,
-0.2843917012,
0.1216790378,
0.2096435577,
0.3435904384,
0.8795177937,
-0.213224262,
0.4628928304,
-0.8695642948,
0.1120241657,
0.2203454226,
0.1452051252,
0.2215767056,
-0.4810087681,
-0.5434473157,
-0.0563334599,
-0.5656635165,
-1.3307557106,
0.547544837,
-0.1402031332,
0.2727642059,
0.670466423,
0.0532035194,
0.8655134439,
-0.4420419037,
0.4316002131,
0.1642692983,
-1.0017664433,
0.4457525611,
-0.4391708672,
0.6385928988,
0.1943847239,
0.1684399396,
-0.9660651684,
-0.8922532201,
-0.4872983694,
-1.1564565897,
0.7927138805,
0.2044439316,
-0.6211207509,
0.0249431208,
0.223415941,
-0.1319936216,
0.3007763326,
-0.5017680526,
-0.1262784749,
0.2345446944,
0.0237669405,
0.6530764103,
-0.2604361475,
-0.4374800324,
-0.1343440115,
0.8035240173,
0.0961732417,
0.1855221838,
0.2079937756,
-0.3140976429,
-0.6210641265,
0.1314439178,
0.5811130404,
1.1285853386,
-0.1162046567,
0.0903406143,
-0.1040268764,
-0.4661743045,
-0.1151160076,
-0.3449583948,
-0.5155017972,
-0.047926113,
0.2956144512,
0.8224560618,
0.234183684,
-0.6796910167,
0.4219113588,
0.1556194574,
0.0665042326,
0.1488509625,
-0.2622576058,
0.203154847,
0.2401970029,
0.4579516351,
0.3726519942,
0.0112039298,
-0.2849366367,
0.445605129,
0.527238965,
-0.549634397,
-0.0879183561,
0.1874693334,
0.0270356908,
-0.2769334018,
0.2348811924,
0.0158912539,
-0.7153231502,
0.3582417965,
0.253786087,
0.641140461,
-0.4002540708,
-0.1251246631,
0.3005978465,
0.5535051227,
0.0487017334,
0.0675540194,
0.0493005998,
-0.6792767644,
-0.6569758058,
-0.215090394,
-0.4210394323,
0.4486623406,
-0.7792275548,
-0.0831696838,
-0.423155874,
-0.1154510528,
-0.4935426712,
-0.2311408669,
-0.6230514646,
0.0638410449,
-0.0540726893,
0.8214307427,
-0.5116603971,
0.9127423167,
0.5054497123,
-0.3817749619,
-0.6979427338,
0.3321392238,
0.1636733562,
-0.5791457891,
0.5025340319,
0.1167198271,
-0.1061331183,
-0.1531182677,
-0.0306106731,
-1.0639415979,
0.6739650369,
0.4778250158,
-0.6570604444,
-0.2379720211,
-0.1256759763,
0.0067441752,
-0.1041029021,
0.2578721642,
0.7125994563,
0.6710029244,
0.0196080822,
-1.0935716629,
0.2983550429,
-0.1607721299,
-0.1218428463,
0.3410390019,
-0.521636188,
0.958266139,
-0.076451771,
-0.622081399,
-0.3314106464,
0.4557843208,
0.2005316168,
-0.0929942057,
0.6605995893,
0.5082120299,
0.5022469759,
-0.1081987694,
0.7188874483,
-0.5938233733,
0.1348459572,
0.9151774645,
-0.2378223091,
0.6416084766,
0.9767463803,
-0.2587330937,
0.3574993312,
0.4740946293,
0.612134099,
0.7132619619,
0.1284697801,
-0.1116078645,
-0.0327377692,
-0.1357112527,
-0.4180986881,
0.1052269861,
0.299203068,
0.0401158743,
-0.375284493,
0.047709208,
0.2771070004,
-0.0776855722,
-0.2175092101,
0.829285264,
0.1940637231,
-1.0206073523,
0.4688247442,
0.0773995221,
0.5063673854,
-0.7477809191,
-0.160870567,
0.0103540123,
0.3946794271,
-0.0191982463,
-0.7087984681,
0.7087362409,
-0.3785969317,
-0.1428707391,
-0.1508786827,
0.7356325984,
-0.8688522577,
-0.0059527927,
0.6827096939,
0.7052274346,
-0.0016666682,
-0.4486061931,
-0.6593390703,
0.3876821697,
0.0065882509,
-0.3611328006,
0.5908838511,
0.482432276,
-0.1459196508,
0.496709615,
0.5496198535,
0.378575474,
0.1051975191,
-0.1038329452,
1.0570474863,
-0.6305935383,
-0.7321273088,
-1.0466406345,
0.4473959506,
-0.1462274343,
-0.0804542303,
0.6852114797,
0.2110760808,
0.7824183702,
0.0990409628,
0.810007453,
-0.0197724998,
0.790255785,
-0.3389920592,
0.6766173244,
-0.3371713459,
0.3022692204,
-0.3174260259,
-0.5704633594,
-0.0719865412,
0.6820693016,
-0.2500436306,
0.0016154618,
0.9743674397,
0.5020759106,
0.0981890336,
-0.2298931628,
0.3215857148,
0.3105923533,
0.1184688136,
1.0217915773,
0.5139824748,
-0.3120590448,
0.7084179521,
-0.5763584971,
-0.3737150729,
0.1134623066,
-0.6942216158,
-0.7799677849,
-0.6376029849,
-0.4872253537,
-0.3535188735,
0.3207239807,
0.5944632292,
0.7857982516,
-0.6412959099,
-0.4354326129,
-0.1181882396,
0.5088897943,
-0.6811759472,
-0.2983110547,
0.2699069679,
-0.3254203498,
-0.5035442114,
0.3886324763,
0.4967781305,
-0.3359743953,
-0.4556480944,
-0.1365200728,
-0.4611983597,
0.1766328514,
0.3597580791,
0.4524405003,
-0.8927012086,
-0.1963312328,
-0.3280943334,
0.0204598717,
0.2765311897,
1.1954118013,
-0.9539012313,
0.3214435577,
0.310587436,
0.7970286608,
0.2168067992,
-0.0778322965,
1.1214331388,
-0.758590579,
0.0964338705,
0.135698393,
0.2531020343,
0.4376413822,
-0.5251514316,
0.4120292962,
0.2983725667,
-0.3248254061,
-0.9568053484,
0.3949130774,
-0.6553854942,
-0.4509495497,
1.0799690485,
-0.395267874,
-0.3122210801,
-0.1488214731,
-0.1897136867,
0.5036931038,
-0.1681917608,
0.7440906763,
0.68072927,
-0.0514403805,
-0.4409278631,
-0.5962280035,
0.8680413961,
0.476783663,
-0.7012470365,
0.1738916337,
0.1341595799,
0.0665986463,
0.340203166,
0.6387038231,
-0.1156898513,
0.2820907831,
-0.3785749972,
0.0246465709,
-0.0277904756,
-0.3787799478,
-0.2329512835,
0.2522238791,
-0.040207725,
-0.0733532682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00830v1
|
MedAide: Leveraging Large Language Models for On-Premise Medical Assistance on Edge Devices
| 2024-02-28T08:30:49 | 2024-02-28T08:30:49 |
Abdul Basit, Khizar Hussain, Muhammad Abdullah Hanif, Muhammad Shafique
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are revolutionizing various domains with their
remarkable natural language processing (NLP) abilities. However, deploying LLMs
in resource-constrained edge computing and embedded systems presents
significant challenges. Another challenge lies in delivering medical assistance
in remote areas with limited healthcare facilities and infrastructure. To
address this, we introduce MedAide, an on-premise healthcare chatbot. It
leverages tiny-LLMs integrated with LangChain, providing efficient edge-based
preliminary medical diagnostics and support. MedAide employs model
optimizations for minimal memory footprint and latency on embedded edge devices
without server infrastructure. The training process is optimized using low-rank
adaptation (LoRA). Additionally, the model is trained on diverse medical
datasets, employing reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) to
enhance its domain-specific capabilities. The system is implemented on various
consumer GPUs and Nvidia Jetson development board. MedAide achieves 77\%
accuracy in medical consultations and scores 56 in USMLE benchmark, enabling an
energy-efficient healthcare assistance platform that alleviates privacy
concerns due to edge-based deployment, thereby empowering the community.
|
[
-0.1935358644,
-0.7471519113,
0.6948503256,
-0.0388859138,
-0.3631533086,
0.1802347898,
-0.2464235872,
-0.5375421643,
0.4364093244,
0.5230479836,
-0.548899591,
-0.5196692348,
-0.4877717793,
-0.0950225741,
0.1601781547,
1.0020744801,
0.1777784675,
0.2438208014,
-0.1890249252,
-0.2378067523,
-0.2229519039,
-0.221437782,
-1.2808610201,
-0.4071609676,
0.3079428375,
0.4198156297,
1.0428788662,
0.5757975578,
0.5908041596,
0.2305030078,
0.2133095115,
0.3603325784,
-0.3331921995,
-0.0774105191,
-0.0746015683,
-0.4236980081,
-0.8095077872,
-0.3865466118,
0.1071737334,
0.5963197351,
-0.4764815569,
-0.0073773139,
-0.2568501532,
0.4789026082,
-0.3859876096,
-0.0282328129,
-0.6105986834,
-0.0919362456,
0.0118929734,
0.2020044327,
-0.2523642182,
-0.3166478872,
0.2584327757,
-0.5616577864,
-0.155542627,
0.0508163348,
0.8192396164,
0.4625783265,
-0.2134800255,
-0.2247031629,
-0.5226598382,
0.6366863847,
-0.8844192028,
0.4280301034,
0.5164007545,
0.4730302691,
-0.3501660526,
-1.0856693983,
-0.2864299715,
-0.2019514292,
0.2718413472,
-0.0112009728,
-0.4139485955,
0.3694264293,
-0.0296720676,
0.2400112003,
-0.2377199531,
0.5975245237,
0.0252508,
-0.0985506698,
0.3863744438,
0.095092766,
0.5463777781,
-0.2412129343,
-0.3021000624,
0.1764034182,
-0.7849503756,
-0.0422497801,
-0.5003765225,
0.3423230648,
-0.381470263,
0.389303863,
-0.0122762648,
0.5040842295,
-0.0995257348,
-0.6035122871,
0.1433679461,
0.0608730987,
-0.404687047,
0.1757711619,
0.6672281623,
0.3716596663,
-0.1350495815,
-0.1428927332,
-0.3404132128,
-0.0546533503,
0.210047245,
-0.7937324047,
-0.2236716598,
0.4917299747,
-0.6047552824,
-0.1686339825,
-0.7350875735,
-0.612823844,
-0.885116756,
0.0251500942,
0.1902566999,
-0.3991066813,
-0.0756665245,
0.1122493669,
0.1070238128,
0.0355828814,
0.3358059227,
-0.8054815531,
0.7144313455,
0.580301702,
1.1249555349,
-0.0780311227,
0.2168131471,
-0.6716019511,
-0.0408409387,
-0.0678517818,
0.7378743291,
-0.3046584427,
-0.4813865423,
0.028785944,
0.0661558881,
-0.1770220697,
-0.6622312069,
0.6926033497,
-0.2094430029,
-0.0672370419,
0.3405473828,
-0.4437484443,
0.0545319617,
0.1048601344,
-0.4837604761,
0.6390187144,
0.175885722,
-0.516024828,
0.091411449,
-0.950412333,
-0.458806783,
0.379832536,
-0.3059561849,
-0.5976036191,
0.2627709806,
0.5071620941,
0.4765767753,
-0.617323935,
0.1026736796,
-0.2164958715,
0.038510628,
0.0616457537,
-0.2600013316,
0.5681773424,
0.2105523497,
-0.2191660851,
0.251067251,
-0.6623136997,
0.1189012378,
0.2947702408,
-0.0166323595,
-0.4692389965,
0.2020253539,
0.3030989468,
0.0532133766,
0.245785445,
-0.7019532919,
0.2659313977,
-0.7053366303,
0.5189407468,
0.5155552626,
0.0308752023,
0.2697132826,
-0.5151604414,
0.5656363368,
-0.3377246559,
0.4117727876,
0.1699322611,
-0.6954581141,
-0.3253727853,
-0.7277252078,
0.3421477973,
0.8506141305,
-0.8740385771,
0.1358717829,
-0.5803296566,
-0.435561955,
-0.9625390768,
0.0616887882,
0.06742917,
0.402666688,
0.2687050104,
0.089117825,
-0.3397787809,
-0.9992991686,
0.1317226887,
0.0115458807,
-0.3816176057,
0.7035672069,
0.1484875679,
-0.7254437804,
0.8710811138,
-0.4737456441,
-0.5310178995,
-0.4382227063,
-0.275606215,
0.2753115296,
0.4176167548,
0.3472132981,
-0.6652989388,
-0.2383476943,
0.4915800989,
-0.564700067,
-0.2206563056,
0.0769607201,
0.2998270392,
0.2012585849,
0.3381500244,
-0.5704512596,
0.2148941159,
0.9438440204,
-0.0036438219,
-0.0017756491,
-0.5530650616,
-0.05896556,
-1.4556486607,
0.0080767041,
-0.1163486317,
-0.5654335022,
-0.5567561984,
-0.1222646311,
-0.1744328439,
-0.5870650411,
-0.3732541203,
0.6971969008,
-0.150281325,
0.0492851995,
-0.5651763678,
0.3135950267,
-0.1157853901,
0.1631617099,
0.099660933,
0.6454452872,
0.3994318545,
-0.3796347082,
0.2529481649,
0.1328246295,
-0.0711405054,
0.6133438945,
-0.8580590487,
0.1288700402,
0.1768456995,
0.1829477102,
-0.5575904846,
-0.2889513969,
0.0289537907,
-0.2127394527,
0.0495327041,
-0.2961783409,
-0.3671607077,
-0.2052297592,
-0.1480727494,
0.3128439784,
0.8888122439,
-0.5654415488,
0.776374042,
0.7787150741,
-0.4686771929,
-0.2156566828,
-0.4213719666,
0.1395027488,
-0.0541468002,
-0.6769580245,
0.2842002809,
0.3006347418,
-0.3878518343,
-0.1423934102,
0.1295795739,
-0.1330930442,
0.2145172209,
0.7013795972,
0.3351462483,
-0.2099742591,
0.4301812053,
0.2680883408,
-0.1025536433,
-0.0241388567,
-0.4751895666,
0.4795814157,
-0.1531869918,
-0.388217926,
-0.526473105,
0.2886847854,
0.7127009034,
-0.0245450605,
0.7093676329,
0.3096663952,
-0.7625688314,
-0.1884419769,
-0.4090395868,
-0.3526331782,
-0.4943676591,
0.4837919176,
-0.1362530738,
-0.713604629,
0.5828714967,
-0.6425754428,
0.2723435163,
0.3801025152,
0.481256336,
-0.0785221905,
1.0250507593,
0.6680515409,
-0.187784031,
0.2808934152,
-0.0188881978,
0.2154775709,
-0.6549875736,
-0.1821309477,
-0.4028845429,
-0.1302658021,
-0.751055479,
-0.4830178022,
0.8403592706,
-0.1553998291,
-0.0591003597,
-0.0666600764,
-0.355437547,
0.1208802313,
0.0687525868,
0.4491799474,
0.1707226485,
0.0956846476,
-0.1362766474,
-0.0414603651,
-0.9829486609,
-0.4166257381,
0.9020069838,
0.6600952148,
0.9672124982,
-0.0173887387,
0.5124553442,
0.431535095,
0.5201017857,
-0.9340892434,
0.3134307563,
-0.4069485366,
-0.1727708429,
-0.1007188782,
-0.3351138234,
-1.1001909971,
0.0399934389,
-0.3124714196,
-0.7156896591,
-0.1208409891,
0.0372340046,
-0.5839783549,
0.4598235786,
-0.6759915948,
0.7189036608,
-0.1168285832,
-0.103314966,
-0.4361777604,
-0.5206554532,
-0.05062861,
0.0463542417,
0.4885517955,
-0.1828045547,
-0.1644884944,
0.6696686149,
-0.775393784,
0.9287234545,
-0.2488834113,
-0.1570360959,
0.0112510622,
-0.068255581,
0.5853242278,
0.2683136761,
0.1448111832,
0.1701670885,
-0.1758295149,
-0.6437274814,
-0.5763081312,
0.860453546,
-0.8205997944,
-0.3887070417,
-0.232528016,
-0.3398860097,
-0.6146690249,
0.1919451207,
0.1413324773,
0.8361153603,
-0.2207245529,
-0.1339102685,
0.7170978189,
-0.4164065421,
0.2713853419,
0.4388633668,
-0.4911936522,
-0.400912255,
0.7625954151,
-0.1636362225,
0.4436843395,
0.2473759502,
0.3359704316,
-0.2240236849,
-0.553416431,
-0.8077457547,
0.371119231,
-0.6902797818,
-0.4211505353,
-0.6436288953,
-0.3670702279,
0.0219628513,
-0.4676655829,
-0.771572113,
-0.2297371924,
-0.084691219,
-0.0013142973,
0.8588017821,
0.7397177219,
0.0550933667,
0.6937590837,
-0.8435313106,
0.2720629871,
0.2064408809,
0.3826276958,
-0.2085630149,
-0.2803611457,
-0.3408757746,
0.2217522711,
0.1467077583,
-0.4756264985,
0.0853764489,
0.268022269,
0.3996734917,
0.3734650612,
0.0924882218,
0.3596112728,
-0.6272230148,
0.7173138857,
0.2725886703,
-0.7783400416,
0.6082777977,
-0.2345240712,
0.3008748591,
0.5959243774,
0.2460943609,
-0.6889570951,
-0.3318474293,
-0.5123749375,
-0.6575897932,
0.1149300411,
-0.1783576459,
0.1099973246,
-0.0385348015,
0.320379287,
-0.0759793967,
-0.0451747961,
-0.3224342167,
-0.1985896081,
0.2081396431,
-0.3943567276,
0.2719516456,
0.1027973369,
-0.2973387539,
-0.0527075939,
0.5765447021,
-0.3691369295,
0.3054865599,
0.3956946433,
0.005878788,
-0.0395700671,
0.165108785,
0.5756705403,
0.5917823315,
-0.0491698608,
-0.0757655799,
0.5332619548,
-0.7578583956,
-0.1316559762,
0.2719122171,
0.1679383516,
0.226445049,
0.2716599405,
0.8072416186,
0.2835281789,
-0.9608009458,
0.6050158739,
-0.1215035021,
0.3293188512,
-0.2010800093,
-0.1585303396,
0.1127681285,
0.1234405562,
0.2844359577,
0.1578650028,
0.0376594886,
-0.176017791,
0.2385664731,
0.5391981006,
-0.7490308881,
-0.1354992837,
0.5796044469,
0.5011353493,
-0.4687949717,
0.6091009974,
0.0258188657,
-0.2074238658,
0.4707588851,
0.5925624967,
0.778708756,
-0.325976193,
0.1159851328,
-0.1157822236,
0.3080193102,
0.1303452104,
0.3909916878,
0.3661428988,
-0.5192590952,
-0.6218065619,
-0.3680079877,
-0.5315577388,
0.0475388765,
-0.2356090248,
0.2472669333,
-0.7227703333,
-0.4479568601,
-0.1168417409,
-0.0416408218,
-0.5548921824,
0.1246088967,
0.2989777923,
0.9079632163,
-0.6499252319,
0.8820573092,
0.7315968275,
0.0918776169,
-0.7787818313,
-0.2549884021,
-0.1361974031,
-1.1427634954,
0.3158123791,
-0.1570166945,
-0.4073349535,
0.0005027604,
-0.3947634101,
-0.4997909069,
1.0121450424,
0.2145002186,
-0.4605315924,
0.1316467673,
-0.0982888192,
0.6156334281,
-0.4697257578,
0.3861026466,
0.248438552,
0.0919133201,
-0.2000956535,
-1.4750199318,
0.0931555778,
-0.0509875081,
0.0530328713,
0.3332083225,
-0.4191977382,
0.4081874788,
-0.3854471147,
-0.1091225296,
-0.0060280701,
0.3270275295,
0.1043221951,
0.3163918257,
0.4293121696,
0.4223574698,
0.9394494295,
0.2923939228,
1.3252900839,
-0.3531790674,
0.0872440562,
0.6342403293,
-0.4478621781,
0.9259759784,
0.4179620445,
-0.1799372435,
0.57445544,
0.4234283268,
0.4927948415,
0.4928569198,
0.1647479534,
-0.6394971013,
-0.0522369593,
-0.6940668821,
-0.3979893327,
0.3692292273,
0.6481474638,
-0.28504318,
-0.4049652815,
0.4835071564,
0.2887845933,
-0.003737693,
-0.640183568,
0.8837112188,
0.4527712166,
-0.1863063425,
0.7106486559,
0.2205757499,
0.5137505531,
-0.9365798831,
-0.0760614648,
-0.1252708882,
0.3732103705,
-0.2524787486,
-0.1357171237,
0.1272008121,
-0.2035630643,
-0.0529015809,
-0.0518526062,
0.9647914767,
-0.001580043,
-0.4129157662,
0.2611498237,
0.6384617686,
0.1763576567,
0.1252809316,
-0.7222364545,
0.0609305054,
-0.1007699594,
0.0715863183,
0.5593969226,
0.2693479657,
-0.0788445696,
1.0320237875,
0.7106459141,
0.2878061831,
-0.1881998032,
0.0470775701,
0.8842777014,
-0.273163408,
-0.6320384741,
-0.8309257627,
0.1902283579,
-0.1526608318,
-0.2974282503,
0.3840732276,
0.4772273898,
0.0341429338,
0.0372017696,
0.7242504954,
-0.0157913882,
0.5474113226,
-0.4737314284,
0.7700437903,
-0.5563221574,
0.2007407695,
0.1104638353,
-0.2238417715,
-0.3057442307,
0.4759691656,
-0.2927601039,
-0.2878132463,
0.5338560939,
0.6486909389,
-0.0824386477,
0.0332270563,
0.2788942158,
0.0192853417,
0.3338671625,
0.5758281946,
0.319096595,
-0.2817226052,
0.1220001951,
-0.0567176864,
-0.4151503444,
-0.3664950132,
-0.6977618933,
-0.7598080635,
-0.2378673255,
-0.285416007,
-0.3935275972,
0.1613723934,
1.5321297646,
0.8229604959,
-0.7536814213,
-0.1961980313,
0.1860937774,
0.1998408437,
-0.3051104546,
-0.1251967549,
0.5150678158,
-0.1590886861,
-0.5275469422,
0.6087396145,
0.4480364025,
-0.0470169075,
-0.1988582313,
0.0433347486,
0.0243450068,
-0.0187282171,
0.5710197091,
0.3854369819,
-0.6273713708,
-0.2251463681,
0.0728387311,
-0.4365785718,
0.1813036948,
0.7793779373,
-0.7646039724,
0.327973783,
0.0246238094,
1.2359919548,
0.0763146579,
0.022023445,
0.5481501222,
-0.4683143795,
0.2583523989,
0.4882501662,
0.3136131465,
0.323777914,
-0.3723112345,
0.1943211108,
0.1081797481,
-0.6324355006,
-0.6693490148,
0.2473843098,
-0.8332450986,
-0.2266112715,
1.0149312019,
-0.1541647315,
-0.3254942894,
-0.3447109461,
-0.3013831377,
-0.0088468054,
-0.3951867223,
0.5192086101,
0.1268409491,
-0.2960449159,
-0.0783228725,
-0.9125094414,
0.6645567417,
0.4560930431,
-1.0658047199,
-0.2614094019,
0.160543561,
0.2862615287,
0.0262561813,
0.8866383433,
0.1906073093,
0.2367416471,
-0.0498674139,
0.2644502521,
0.0823998228,
0.1074950323,
-0.3719346821,
-0.0321738683,
0.3530733883,
-0.4787359536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18603v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18603v4
|
MMSR: Symbolic Regression is a Multimodal Task
| 2024-02-28T08:29:42 | 2024-03-14T12:10:43 |
Yanjie Li, Jingyi Liu, Weijun Li, Lina Yu, Min Wu, Wenqiang Li, Meilan Hao, Su Wei, Yusong Deng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Mathematical formulas are the crystallization of human wisdom in exploring
the laws of nature for thousands of years. Describing the complex laws of
nature with a concise mathematical formula is a constant pursuit of scientists
and a great challenge for artificial intelligence. This field is called
symbolic regression. Symbolic regression was originally formulated as a
combinatorial optimization problem, and GP and reinforcement learning
algorithms were used to solve it. However, GP is sensitive to hyperparameters,
and these two types of algorithms are inefficient. To solve this problem,
researchers treat the mapping from data to expressions as a translation
problem. And the corresponding large-scale pre-trained model is introduced.
However, the data and expression skeletons do not have very clear word
correspondences as the two languages do. Instead, they are more like two
modalities (e.g., image and text). Therefore, in this paper, we proposed MMSR.
The SR problem is solved as a pure multimodal problem, and contrastive learning
is also introduced in the training process for modal alignment to facilitate
later modal feature fusion. It is worth noting that in order to better promote
the modal feature fusion, we adopt the strategy of training contrastive
learning loss and other losses at the same time, which only needs one-step
training, instead of training contrastive learning loss first and then training
other losses. Because our experiments prove training together can make the
feature extraction module and feature fusion module running-in better.
Experimental results show that compared with multiple large-scale pre-training
baselines, MMSR achieves the most advanced results on multiple mainstream
datasets including SRBench.
|
[
-0.2117869109,
-0.6757175922,
0.4622217715,
0.1104340032,
-0.5055008531,
0.0293935724,
-0.1054426059,
-0.1292918622,
0.2311421484,
0.1877699643,
-0.8341243267,
0.0776332319,
-0.7594178319,
0.2047850043,
-0.0931649804,
0.9900877476,
-0.1547793299,
0.4937377274,
-0.1274743527,
-0.2389745563,
-0.4598156214,
-0.4216660261,
-0.4643303752,
-0.1601362526,
0.541384995,
-0.1309758574,
0.5294028521,
0.5566031933,
0.9298884869,
0.4090634882,
0.298561126,
0.4286356866,
-0.4732702076,
0.164174512,
0.1141622066,
-0.3644910753,
-0.0346709266,
0.1410877854,
0.6358813047,
0.2330944836,
-0.1301484108,
0.1936123669,
0.0372444391,
0.8048343658,
-0.6952409148,
0.5163097382,
-0.4570055604,
0.0582748279,
-0.0840973109,
-0.2691203952,
-0.3168396056,
-0.3730940521,
-0.0951131061,
-0.6365553141,
0.0724581107,
-0.0470240079,
0.9919461608,
0.5777809024,
-0.5042327642,
0.0166019164,
-0.8308340311,
1.1267764568,
-0.3582471311,
0.5093280673,
0.1792365611,
0.8663443923,
-0.0529993214,
-0.5817676187,
-0.6335719824,
-0.5240520835,
-0.2390109152,
0.1901623756,
-0.1979966164,
-0.104776822,
0.1532884985,
-0.0651251227,
-0.5604841113,
-0.3314834237,
-0.5453969836,
-0.4433775246,
0.4720283449,
0.394304812,
0.027922323,
-0.2668178082,
-0.43929106,
-0.2820849717,
-0.4002116323,
-0.0219129827,
-0.1628635973,
0.6365126371,
-0.3302633166,
0.6209480166,
0.0522618182,
0.6661213636,
-0.2911089659,
-0.6720209718,
0.4075032473,
-0.5458909869,
-0.1759102345,
-0.0503899381,
0.7006100416,
-0.0032232834,
0.250390023,
0.1358286142,
-0.1790103316,
0.606108129,
0.1622420549,
-0.7178325653,
0.0353029408,
-0.3179672062,
-0.4404749274,
-0.0974000543,
0.1175650582,
-0.4510101974,
-0.0711430237,
-0.9784575701,
0.719594717,
-0.6169116497,
-0.1102736443,
-0.0916612148,
-0.0938033387,
-0.0251401979,
0.5688601732,
-0.4143353999,
0.0733095333,
0.6397951245,
0.9239900112,
0.1708896905,
-0.3732987344,
-0.4045264721,
0.2985300422,
-0.1775971949,
0.3411894143,
-0.6038755178,
-0.2189148664,
-0.2993754148,
-0.1978421211,
-0.2510580719,
-0.1887099147,
0.1032358333,
-0.3012052774,
0.3613829315,
-0.2163684815,
0.1003251821,
-0.2178392112,
0.2965996861,
-0.5394313335,
0.8595387936,
0.3053797185,
-0.6249110103,
0.3469506502,
-0.6716820002,
-0.2201780379,
-0.172491923,
-0.3751108944,
-0.3884292543,
0.0789730325,
0.0420224257,
0.3314046562,
-0.5768955946,
0.4344368279,
-0.1704298705,
-0.1656387895,
0.3369574249,
-0.3467639089,
0.3621492386,
0.4035206437,
-0.3038556576,
0.2042874694,
-0.5501189828,
-0.0863907859,
0.0486277975,
-0.1855977327,
-0.4733654261,
-0.018290475,
0.0116514377,
0.6226545572,
0.0241336282,
-0.4821528196,
0.0455460288,
0.0014752629,
0.4510982931,
0.9805476665,
-0.3315770924,
0.2728966773,
-0.2996482253,
0.3898774981,
0.2001209408,
0.2883992195,
-0.0270848107,
-0.2002521455,
-0.6021657586,
-0.7745556235,
0.2966327369,
0.3261286914,
-1.0862709284,
0.122381784,
-0.3377991021,
-0.4063362777,
-0.7079157233,
-0.0526143871,
0.8194293976,
0.7202230692,
0.5728553534,
-0.1398494542,
-0.8303735852,
-1.1041307449,
0.1494547278,
-0.1486338526,
0.0366950855,
0.2287046909,
0.5954539776,
-0.3759513497,
0.8031768799,
-0.6390941739,
-0.7060062289,
-0.1802259684,
0.214088127,
-0.1058298498,
0.5574342608,
0.4278474152,
-1.0372335911,
-0.3465513885,
-0.1009571031,
-0.8376678824,
0.0560352169,
-0.0863215253,
-0.1124545112,
0.3184303939,
0.3495820165,
-0.6156949401,
0.1220356077,
0.5277216434,
0.01229164,
0.5897348523,
-0.1013561636,
0.2661158741,
-1.2015587091,
0.0882032141,
0.493786782,
0.0220156666,
-0.4342067242,
0.1030878276,
0.0544394962,
-0.1615062207,
-0.4407829344,
0.4050422013,
-0.4010036886,
0.087351501,
-0.046119377,
-0.1163393855,
-0.3053840101,
0.5518430471,
-0.1079446226,
0.7900104523,
0.4699445665,
-0.5823200345,
0.2871754467,
0.1757473946,
0.1813250184,
0.5605872273,
-0.3559188247,
-0.3047863245,
-0.43022874,
0.3078097999,
-0.9964354038,
0.0467880629,
0.3241030276,
-0.373781234,
0.3369387388,
0.2598674893,
-0.3415083289,
-0.3621283472,
-0.2661754191,
0.3755873442,
0.6113475561,
-0.1756290346,
0.8966097832,
0.3006234765,
0.032265,
-0.6666336656,
-0.4603954554,
-0.1787436604,
-0.1731794327,
-0.5423696041,
0.1962727308,
0.0334940851,
-0.1871358901,
-0.0791266933,
-0.2919949889,
-0.0383564532,
-0.3661091328,
0.2058462352,
0.5283741355,
-0.397164613,
0.1230026856,
-0.1855071336,
-0.5855013728,
-0.0682899207,
0.2192210257,
0.6300571561,
-0.1238108799,
-0.3417662382,
-0.7285398245,
0.2047628462,
0.6194076538,
-0.2733696103,
0.5281301737,
0.6883662343,
-0.1698830426,
0.1655496657,
-0.6518668532,
-0.2385372669,
-0.4973117709,
0.5556726456,
-0.6253573298,
-0.8436570168,
0.1207963377,
-0.1324475408,
-0.1186669022,
0.4694777727,
0.4824109674,
0.0238242615,
1.4832479954,
0.8386461735,
-0.0977249369,
0.4308808446,
-0.1571992636,
0.0648576617,
-0.5894303322,
-0.6936579943,
-0.7190233469,
-0.5372887254,
-0.516518414,
-0.4256659448,
0.5702471137,
-0.2348243743,
-0.58284688,
0.3376121819,
-0.5581266284,
0.1629358828,
0.4728730321,
0.4291282296,
0.0241514072,
0.1126614362,
-0.1789486408,
-0.6230327487,
-0.345538497,
-0.2067588568,
0.652949512,
0.0717600435,
1.0200353861,
0.2758444548,
0.5377544761,
0.0988729596,
0.3249481022,
-0.8279259205,
0.7674183249,
-0.2847368419,
-0.2246936113,
-0.2574641407,
-0.8165072799,
-0.7346758246,
0.5255147815,
-0.3967779875,
-0.2091774791,
-0.1198038757,
0.1193280146,
0.055858776,
0.0379621908,
-0.5889390111,
0.6344761252,
-0.3185141683,
-0.1045190841,
-0.2711155415,
-1.0444157124,
0.4287002385,
-0.3657608926,
0.3341550827,
0.0179362241,
-0.0730066076,
0.745423317,
-0.4445384145,
0.8240121603,
-0.3040454388,
0.3540736437,
-0.1167661846,
0.2480698526,
0.4041444659,
-0.3955236077,
0.2728514075,
-0.2198330164,
-0.0336618125,
-0.3335333169,
-0.7856878638,
0.4558160603,
-0.8003705144,
-0.5334250927,
-0.6687679887,
-0.731136024,
-0.1188065559,
0.0648700595,
-0.2029055506,
0.2201609164,
0.0036910593,
0.1408916563,
0.4200294614,
0.1947697848,
0.4696600139,
0.6265574098,
-0.037365783,
-0.5692827106,
1.0387057066,
0.1042806879,
0.1832722574,
0.4121566713,
0.4873306453,
-0.2611091733,
-0.244813323,
-0.3237620294,
0.6088309884,
-0.4235901535,
-0.4179675579,
-0.6362888217,
-0.2270145267,
-0.2828032076,
-0.3021269143,
-0.1725031286,
-0.3483665586,
-0.1886700392,
0.2309329212,
0.2731851935,
0.2614484429,
-0.1741460711,
0.3160683215,
-0.9426375031,
0.5083587766,
0.222951293,
-0.1272353977,
-0.1359829605,
-0.3990511,
-0.087634556,
0.2224445492,
-0.2517676651,
-0.62618047,
0.6257576942,
0.236030966,
0.6179865003,
0.408200711,
-0.1440909207,
1.2466036081,
-0.4802179039,
0.4435878098,
0.7420096397,
-0.8397495747,
0.4669612944,
-0.0506428257,
0.116698131,
0.4875117242,
0.6667428613,
-0.4557246864,
-0.285700798,
-0.4584503472,
-0.5070315003,
0.7526643276,
0.185541749,
0.2695885599,
0.2878547013,
0.129823789,
0.0843884349,
0.4511486888,
-0.6695868969,
-0.19133614,
-0.3237709701,
-0.3591143191,
-0.3462243974,
-0.0602603778,
-0.2638376355,
-0.5134510398,
0.6834695935,
-0.0933406353,
0.2256526798,
-0.1058221683,
-0.1848949492,
-0.2041839659,
0.061022494,
0.7810531855,
0.5801414251,
-0.1032613367,
0.218341127,
-0.1238317788,
-0.5721470118,
0.33742401,
0.158302024,
-0.0002752173,
-0.012330031,
0.1475079209,
0.5751869082,
0.1804707497,
-0.5636942983,
0.3765432537,
0.2371596694,
-0.3328512609,
-0.2050632983,
-0.087787725,
-0.1909710616,
0.2868235409,
0.4188929498,
0.4231501222,
-0.079803139,
-0.4438314736,
0.328053385,
0.7012896538,
-0.6217306852,
-0.2893032134,
0.5850265026,
-0.0941128433,
-0.1416871548,
0.6214900613,
0.1369217038,
-0.5982701182,
0.6005020142,
0.8285297155,
0.6174454093,
-0.4284713268,
0.4442936778,
0.3628242612,
0.3159109652,
-0.2327800244,
0.3809408545,
0.1351058781,
-0.4516812563,
-0.5866402984,
-0.7908316255,
-0.1540976763,
-0.1799755096,
-0.4394878149,
0.3450972438,
-0.2318657786,
-0.049296122,
0.2442633957,
-0.1664081067,
-0.3199910223,
0.2595742643,
-0.0634307563,
0.6017063856,
-1.1452894211,
0.7294437885,
0.5587291718,
-0.8545574546,
-0.8747493029,
-0.4520775676,
0.3525142074,
-1.0439602137,
1.2360050678,
0.1328888088,
-0.2430726588,
-0.0776331648,
-0.5157900453,
-1.016759038,
1.0430283546,
0.4839016795,
-0.1839959174,
-0.0980406776,
0.2335361987,
0.5653029084,
-0.4628987908,
0.0048250966,
0.1752503067,
0.6465109587,
0.5509105921,
-0.9284117222,
0.2539301813,
-0.1432922632,
0.2011467665,
0.8132119775,
-0.6329362392,
1.1954987049,
-0.1153195053,
-0.0478176139,
-0.0490060002,
0.5154141188,
0.4683399796,
0.2975880504,
0.276232481,
0.5940833688,
0.1051665321,
-0.2713721693,
0.7759497762,
0.1362094432,
0.364309907,
0.6823735833,
-0.2402285039,
0.6763626337,
0.6987802982,
-0.3908785284,
0.4182769954,
0.4167898893,
-0.1151321679,
0.7634305358,
0.2609652281,
-0.1982725263,
-0.2804443538,
-0.1636257172,
-0.5566977262,
0.5171512961,
0.2102828473,
-0.4110969007,
-0.6003102064,
0.2906915843,
0.0543466657,
-0.0068017682,
-0.3804119527,
0.7157509327,
0.0834001154,
-0.2139556855,
0.534311235,
-0.0534523018,
0.6648569107,
-1.1672421694,
-0.3180725574,
-0.0128927063,
0.240425542,
-0.0972978249,
-0.1986679882,
0.2534000874,
-0.4313665032,
-0.1104425788,
-0.1504932046,
0.5516123176,
-0.3306911588,
-0.6605167389,
0.0071384432,
0.7849792838,
0.0953232348,
0.0547232851,
-0.9253848791,
-0.0570985302,
0.0080666579,
-0.0557821468,
0.6453120112,
0.3871208131,
-0.2259504795,
0.7725186348,
0.9116223454,
-0.0178617388,
-0.1654487699,
-0.162056163,
1.1762135029,
-0.685044229,
-0.5091528296,
-1.0052289963,
0.5607947707,
0.1373550147,
-0.0248509552,
0.7266420126,
0.6375571489,
0.5731983185,
-0.1367628127,
0.5272234082,
-0.0652276278,
0.3067873418,
-0.5086712837,
0.4270736873,
-0.6794320345,
-0.0845163837,
-0.3783127367,
-1.0559700727,
-0.6251423955,
0.5828764439,
-0.1101569235,
0.1396160126,
0.9041074514,
1.0017492771,
-0.1534534544,
-0.1538466513,
0.3075923324,
-0.1020829529,
0.2370498478,
0.3488320708,
0.7437791228,
-0.2312977612,
0.6279730797,
-0.2926158309,
-0.3676031232,
-0.2149198949,
-0.656454742,
-0.4158514738,
-0.8524212837,
-0.1825720966,
-0.5511824489,
0.0918398425,
1.0325872898,
0.5814906359,
-0.5118970275,
-0.2532944977,
0.2242917418,
-0.1821136624,
-0.5715957284,
-0.2103476524,
0.5833384991,
-0.4943299592,
-0.4737170041,
0.0337530896,
0.2277563214,
0.2458291054,
-0.3606998026,
-0.2766933739,
-0.231619522,
-0.0983203128,
0.7820659876,
0.2106585056,
-0.7109100223,
-0.1547993571,
-0.0006370942,
-0.4159025848,
0.0926233828,
1.0966719389,
-0.9717348218,
0.4566524923,
0.4105645418,
0.5805630088,
0.5589209199,
-0.01292942,
0.4024581909,
-0.5320027471,
0.2733459771,
0.2681613266,
0.3376993239,
0.0112554105,
-0.0501810201,
0.6192193627,
0.341886282,
-0.2702503502,
-0.902648747,
0.3484077454,
-1.1669532061,
-0.368439585,
0.9174224138,
0.2535758913,
-0.2384324074,
-0.0764520168,
-0.4131044447,
0.3779757321,
-0.4563367069,
1.0158997774,
0.2596331537,
-0.3115836978,
-0.2719751,
-0.4327691495,
0.4241732955,
0.4475996494,
-0.6004046798,
-0.2903769314,
0.9007498026,
-0.0705880895,
0.4447914958,
0.5463778377,
-0.2714859545,
0.1709230542,
0.0624592341,
0.0164554939,
-0.45639503,
-0.41201967,
-0.2064799666,
0.3043292761,
-0.252974093,
-0.2832167745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18150v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18150v2
|
Unsupervised Information Refinement Training of Large Language Models for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-02-28T08:24:38 | 2024-06-12T03:21:15 |
Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Mo Yu, Fandong Meng, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enhances large language models (LLMs) by
incorporating additional information from retrieval. However, studies have
shown that LLMs still face challenges in effectively using the retrieved
information, even ignoring it or being misled by it. The key reason is that the
training of LLMs does not clearly make LLMs learn how to utilize input
retrieved texts with varied quality. In this paper, we propose a novel
perspective that considers the role of LLMs in RAG as ``Information Refiner'',
which means that regardless of correctness, completeness, or usefulness of
retrieved texts, LLMs can consistently integrate knowledge within the retrieved
texts and model parameters to generate the texts that are more concise,
accurate, and complete than the retrieved texts. To this end, we propose an
information refinement training method named InFO-RAG that optimizes LLMs for
RAG in an unsupervised manner. InFO-RAG is low-cost and general across various
tasks. Extensive experiments on zero-shot prediction of 11 datasets in diverse
tasks including Question Answering, Slot-Filling, Language Modeling, Dialogue,
and Code Generation show that InFO-RAG improves the performance of LLaMA2 by an
average of 9.39\% relative points. InFO-RAG also shows advantages in in-context
learning and robustness of RAG.
|
[
-0.3212100565,
-0.4765001833,
0.4131000638,
-0.2779790163,
-0.3516680002,
0.3896511495,
-0.3825684488,
-0.3753316104,
0.1697437614,
0.6689604521,
-0.4333302379,
-0.1631878465,
-0.4532281458,
0.0441956632,
-0.3422975242,
1.2402693033,
0.0517261475,
0.0146861896,
-0.293715775,
0.066613093,
-0.2340646684,
-0.3344984651,
-0.6167626381,
-0.50713557,
0.5448487997,
0.6892794967,
0.2092415839,
0.5718411803,
0.3996281326,
0.2166879177,
-0.0590292178,
0.5330866575,
-0.8939225674,
0.4680451155,
-0.3758592904,
-0.6816731095,
0.0632297397,
-0.1273503453,
0.6790398359,
0.6161648631,
-0.2495281398,
0.5183092356,
0.2276329398,
0.950776875,
-0.8908318281,
-0.1110114008,
-1.0245828629,
-0.1945236325,
-0.4049217701,
-0.5373443365,
-0.5304822922,
-0.1634235382,
-0.0489248149,
-0.7026787996,
0.4816460013,
0.1270002276,
0.9243748784,
0.492279321,
-0.3429923058,
-0.1688245535,
-1.0022879839,
0.8619378209,
-0.504370451,
0.3674238622,
0.3401475847,
0.2615590394,
-0.4919978976,
-0.6912519932,
-0.6086958647,
0.014629731,
-0.0718371421,
0.1577372104,
-0.0488524958,
-0.0805945918,
0.4378956556,
0.4007629752,
-0.3565457463,
0.0276758149,
-0.4705282748,
0.096424371,
0.3920580745,
-0.135707885,
-0.3266600966,
-0.1153183654,
-0.625777185,
-0.0326914713,
-0.9116337895,
0.0634550974,
0.3562018871,
0.2415748835,
0.2760535181,
0.5918428302,
-0.3022325337,
0.6632810831,
0.2614609599,
-0.4561619163,
0.2857848704,
-0.1261409819,
-0.0844056979,
-0.0890337452,
0.4547423422,
0.1461015195,
0.1582438052,
-0.1544668674,
-0.3445395529,
-0.2975584865,
0.5080727935,
-0.8719964027,
0.0560463518,
-0.0087592574,
-0.2412160337,
-0.412974,
0.1554261595,
-0.7657237649,
-0.6128419638,
-0.575506866,
0.2143340409,
-0.1957226545,
-0.430948168,
-0.1608407348,
-0.1344905347,
0.1706820577,
0.3689331412,
-0.6869459748,
0.0651616901,
0.4404887259,
0.3340751529,
-0.1902017593,
-0.0748126656,
-0.6445681453,
0.4103312492,
-0.4462976754,
1.1190479994,
-0.6012022495,
-0.111466527,
-0.1438457072,
-0.1955143511,
0.1168699488,
-0.6688765287,
0.4813361168,
-0.7760166526,
0.213222459,
-0.1041356847,
-0.5252828002,
-0.3445620239,
0.324403286,
-0.5859071016,
1.2621921301,
0.1740884185,
-1.042036891,
0.402944386,
-0.3426487446,
-0.2176876813,
0.0253760722,
-0.2634421587,
-0.3888758421,
0.3773285151,
0.0827907696,
0.2360885441,
-0.642991364,
0.3353807032,
-0.1027622595,
-0.4933143854,
0.289966166,
-0.3550507724,
0.1795230359,
0.3464156091,
-0.0932310298,
-0.1528495103,
-0.9760222435,
0.1873933226,
0.1489622742,
-0.7758303285,
-0.3033043146,
-0.2646805644,
-0.1120137647,
-0.0690201446,
0.3496078849,
-0.6444447637,
0.2739774585,
-0.5229441524,
-0.1462014318,
0.6595093012,
0.1077754721,
0.5219151378,
-0.3498491943,
0.4071515203,
-0.0825536847,
-0.0009785262,
-0.3245433569,
-0.1628456861,
-1.015220046,
-0.2076183408,
0.6197792292,
0.4479935765,
-1.0451146364,
0.1276495159,
-0.035364043,
-0.4765330255,
-0.6584131122,
0.3025355339,
0.5590266585,
0.6436417103,
0.2020403445,
-0.2564566433,
-0.8303765059,
-0.7692739964,
-0.5099598765,
-0.1286369562,
0.0298502184,
0.1195553169,
0.1959598064,
-0.311578393,
0.9127409458,
-0.3315310478,
-0.2667084932,
-0.2944377065,
0.3305670917,
0.2409287989,
0.2713478804,
0.0344806723,
-0.8519388437,
-0.4445262551,
0.0088576162,
-0.4421124756,
-0.2889994085,
0.0336428992,
0.0040702126,
0.3353836536,
0.5814094543,
-0.3487718403,
0.5923349261,
0.5083436966,
0.0588337146,
0.5532326698,
-0.418150723,
0.0528809987,
-1.2454179525,
0.3749747276,
-0.3128707409,
-0.2921886444,
-0.7657578588,
-0.0244795121,
-0.0107452003,
0.0703505725,
-0.1842283756,
0.8007020354,
-0.6525149941,
-0.2498203516,
-0.765414536,
0.2620762587,
0.2060652077,
0.4909025729,
-0.1707298756,
0.7735132575,
0.246616289,
-0.6565610766,
0.2405345291,
0.0029313879,
-0.5404814482,
0.5133085847,
-0.2288171649,
0.3166997433,
-0.5796898603,
0.154626891,
-1.1165754795,
-0.3096765578,
-0.2603949606,
-0.6063939929,
0.7764219046,
-0.21026586,
-0.5647819638,
-0.0412956849,
-0.2245644778,
0.3721234202,
0.3966460526,
-0.7474039197,
0.5927959085,
0.4786774814,
-0.1297472864,
-0.9680131674,
-0.5242620707,
-0.1455109119,
-0.0968762636,
-0.3394603729,
0.3082936704,
-0.0105034336,
-0.1895272285,
-0.0161165129,
-0.1828684509,
-0.0771859661,
0.0184866507,
0.2273808569,
0.21585536,
0.111260891,
0.5014452934,
-0.1024927422,
-0.303413868,
-0.4104571939,
-0.1112292632,
0.5701139569,
0.1368130893,
-0.3352060318,
-0.0513624065,
0.2042654455,
0.2245907634,
-0.403026104,
0.7057077289,
0.6342695355,
-0.1802253723,
-0.3183831871,
-0.898165226,
-0.2897907197,
-0.4566150308,
0.338498801,
-0.2128453404,
-0.8972994685,
0.1761345416,
-0.5171291232,
0.2048586458,
0.3289367259,
0.4371193945,
-0.2434240878,
0.877497077,
0.8927432895,
0.1001902297,
0.5650457144,
-0.2547926009,
0.1452514529,
-1.1933387518,
-0.4073625505,
-0.5213799477,
-0.2651132345,
-0.472366035,
-0.6011657715,
0.2699652314,
0.4797920585,
-0.4335870445,
-0.0873820037,
-0.3839461207,
0.6224210858,
0.6074334979,
-0.1028345078,
0.4416820407,
0.48501423,
-0.0919372663,
-0.0410952829,
-0.740743041,
-0.4560710192,
1.2246828079,
0.1417518258,
1.0689897537,
-0.0832577273,
0.632719636,
0.0179256983,
0.3960743845,
-0.6179949641,
0.2856779397,
-0.1938539445,
-0.5042080283,
0.03954418,
-0.6066080928,
-1.0609792471,
0.0930067599,
-0.3914999366,
-0.4368344843,
0.1009436175,
0.0778042674,
-0.1087390035,
0.3837093115,
-0.5694392323,
0.249855563,
-0.1807764918,
-0.2278087139,
-0.1308580041,
-0.4492632747,
0.1737738103,
-0.4141991138,
0.3029816151,
0.0184677765,
-0.113775149,
0.7237467766,
-0.1605000198,
0.7027288079,
-0.2185523361,
0.0319654047,
0.2873887718,
0.0988911316,
0.6675235629,
-0.1634827703,
-0.0767572224,
-0.0981566235,
-0.2786666453,
-0.233358711,
-0.666057229,
0.6220533848,
-0.6176786423,
-0.6456906199,
-0.3534213006,
-0.5730525851,
-0.4295437932,
0.3109794855,
0.4092190862,
0.366707325,
0.0717529282,
0.3121187389,
0.9183291793,
-0.1629391462,
0.0390648246,
0.9080503583,
-0.4852004647,
-0.4349208474,
0.758825779,
-0.0462898239,
0.3490846455,
0.4943404794,
0.0938957334,
-0.3142568171,
-0.4095142484,
-0.3008852303,
0.5208101273,
-0.789260745,
-0.4740997553,
-0.3510804176,
-0.2820126414,
-0.1584925801,
0.2183630615,
-0.4452520907,
-0.4589447379,
-0.2241400927,
-0.041756656,
0.4623938799,
0.9747118354,
-0.0449923873,
0.3467628658,
-0.576743722,
0.2992070317,
0.1484166682,
0.3928554356,
-0.0883060694,
-0.963845253,
-0.3748489618,
0.1364514083,
-0.2743847072,
-0.5218743086,
0.1504679471,
0.1442230046,
0.5776232481,
0.3423493207,
-0.0216913987,
0.7436981201,
-0.5594965219,
0.4682136178,
0.1412237436,
-0.3981071115,
0.4949499071,
0.0240881052,
0.3574774861,
0.7521390319,
0.1707737595,
-0.4427673817,
-0.3760479093,
-0.6394685507,
-0.7902786732,
0.829908967,
-0.0677649453,
-0.03480573,
0.2249649167,
0.5989898443,
0.1304603517,
0.4136345387,
-0.4694061279,
-0.1865340769,
0.2050836682,
-0.1325933337,
0.0356957465,
-0.6870099902,
-0.025638856,
0.0843115449,
0.9357924461,
-0.0362577811,
0.1383823603,
0.0568315275,
0.0787099004,
-0.3690397739,
0.3057159185,
0.3918178976,
0.5801404119,
-0.0602127723,
0.1917283833,
0.1545013487,
-0.4735226035,
0.1337462664,
-0.0403099097,
-0.2894364297,
0.0573960841,
0.236839965,
0.8639158607,
0.0325000212,
-0.6780258417,
0.4827965498,
-0.1089279726,
0.0605826713,
-0.4025266469,
0.0527824759,
-0.1282968372,
0.4578556418,
0.4607275426,
0.2612668574,
-0.0331323855,
-0.4681118727,
0.1608623117,
0.4248293936,
-0.2474051863,
-0.0613265112,
0.3275768161,
-0.0798589513,
-0.0681473613,
0.3768075705,
-0.2141716033,
-0.4073096514,
0.23899661,
0.687504828,
0.6590921283,
-0.4763447046,
-0.008679959,
0.5522049069,
0.2042312175,
-0.193754524,
0.3205362856,
-0.0327695757,
-0.6361290812,
-0.6394987106,
-0.883898735,
-0.3553882539,
0.3239599168,
-0.6113467216,
0.2742400169,
-0.3791275918,
-0.1667027026,
-0.348602742,
0.082930252,
-0.6098269224,
0.228137508,
0.0432280265,
0.7985098362,
-0.269279778,
0.87552315,
0.77947855,
-0.23219724,
-0.9201639295,
0.1512032598,
-0.2432387024,
-0.805601716,
0.8111585975,
0.2228967845,
-0.3088229299,
-0.0077068508,
-0.5073129535,
-1.2125339508,
1.0638581514,
0.5757083893,
-0.5860797763,
-0.0943160877,
0.1321914792,
0.5480186939,
-0.3770869374,
0.2541076541,
0.3734955192,
0.2752521038,
0.4906382561,
-0.845333159,
-0.3054819703,
-0.2949012816,
0.2281625122,
0.3245484233,
-0.5095311999,
0.8037521839,
-0.3135954738,
-0.4815637767,
0.1574327946,
0.4343560338,
0.3344684243,
0.1047525406,
0.462428391,
0.7239049077,
1.0401060581,
-0.0133285504,
1.0427372456,
-0.1927106082,
0.2081055641,
1.377820611,
-0.1526761949,
0.986640811,
0.4534654319,
0.1307202131,
0.6032012105,
0.3265919387,
0.1902958751,
0.623865366,
0.2087426484,
-0.3289479315,
-0.0200603697,
-0.3628884256,
-0.2376884222,
0.5003458858,
0.3800209761,
-0.3562493622,
-0.4193109274,
0.0991984829,
0.0043318793,
0.1074920893,
-0.37112993,
1.0932142735,
-0.0619557239,
-0.7698628902,
0.9484190941,
-0.0057945051,
0.5192595124,
-0.6336294413,
-0.1769782901,
-0.2756451368,
0.3608150184,
-0.3799197376,
-0.7620931864,
0.1724511981,
0.431211859,
-0.378757,
-0.0720683411,
0.9933255315,
-0.687546134,
-0.3775838912,
0.1709733158,
0.2762889862,
0.3748658895,
-0.2172646075,
-0.5153500438,
0.0518717133,
0.2620938122,
-0.2853650153,
0.3692824244,
0.6932528615,
0.0999287888,
0.6017055511,
0.7347840071,
0.2667715251,
-0.0351577327,
0.0962258801,
1.0133373737,
-0.5621473789,
-0.1632848829,
-0.5495874882,
0.4182284474,
-0.155059427,
-0.0341528542,
0.7142395973,
0.664914906,
1.0607645512,
0.1457419395,
0.8462250233,
0.2293682396,
1.3007196188,
-0.5407857299,
0.5436182022,
-0.7021552324,
0.4701911211,
0.0607488416,
-1.1416568756,
-0.0145621961,
0.4283522069,
-0.1444847286,
0.0405341089,
0.4282115102,
0.8463697433,
0.1225717291,
-0.1919770539,
0.1864733249,
0.1450936496,
0.2078469247,
0.3836014867,
0.9217923284,
-0.2867922485,
0.6716755629,
-0.2119125724,
-0.3807325065,
-0.1905482709,
-0.6930327415,
-0.8946831226,
-0.6317642927,
0.1348282397,
-0.2553524971,
-0.2749406099,
0.6826030612,
0.4890099466,
-0.4925808311,
-0.2641122043,
0.0297747944,
-0.1001854241,
0.3331308663,
-0.1996280551,
0.0993524343,
-0.6446808577,
-0.5581589341,
0.4747958779,
0.3018634021,
-0.0595789999,
-0.3302896619,
0.0976241156,
-0.2159875184,
0.14783445,
0.4507656991,
0.2795530856,
-0.5561994314,
0.041493725,
-0.1622872502,
-0.1258623302,
0.1686471701,
0.8181740046,
-0.9696105719,
0.826384902,
0.3649974465,
0.810784936,
0.8667863607,
0.2286484241,
0.3644595444,
-1.2097156048,
0.3680701256,
0.112807557,
0.1832235456,
0.63089782,
-0.416661948,
0.5536954999,
0.0158370323,
-0.7141075134,
-0.852971077,
0.4242922664,
-0.5106977224,
-0.254224509,
1.3407125473,
0.0025465779,
-0.2787800729,
-0.1082350761,
-0.496011883,
0.4047442675,
-0.289162755,
0.7837824225,
0.3995556831,
0.1220631227,
-0.1525240988,
-0.6313968301,
0.7289835215,
0.3043028414,
-0.7690506577,
0.3153187633,
0.2905986309,
0.3062064052,
0.463298887,
0.6059219837,
-0.1337695718,
0.1067001075,
-0.3106456697,
0.2572180033,
-0.2236052901,
-0.4623780251,
-0.2309951335,
-0.135319382,
0.402295202,
0.1410108209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18145v1
|
Learning Intrinsic Dimension via Information Bottleneck for Explainable Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-28T08:11:05 | 2024-02-28T08:11:05 |
Zhenxiao Cheng, Jie Zhou, Wen Wu, Qin Chen, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Gradient-based explanation methods are increasingly used to interpret neural
models in natural language processing (NLP) due to their high fidelity. Such
methods determine word-level importance using dimension-level gradient values
through a norm function, often presuming equal significance for all gradient
dimensions. However, in the context of Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA),
our preliminary research suggests that only specific dimensions are pertinent.
To address this, we propose the Information Bottleneck-based Gradient
(\texttt{IBG}) explanation framework for ABSA. This framework leverages an
information bottleneck to refine word embeddings into a concise intrinsic
dimension, maintaining essential features and omitting unrelated information.
Comprehensive tests show that our \texttt{IBG} approach considerably improves
both the models' performance and interpretability by identifying
sentiment-aware features.
|
[
-0.7493894696,
-0.8827429414,
0.3595201075,
0.4134895504,
-0.4328930974,
-0.0492409468,
-0.0651960745,
-0.5392736793,
0.1410280168,
0.2875583172,
-0.7424129844,
-0.4645377696,
-0.3297693431,
-0.228444472,
-0.302636683,
1.2001928091,
0.0445601456,
0.0136000952,
-0.5051679015,
-0.5312191844,
-0.4593878984,
-0.4524779618,
-0.6461010575,
-0.5140860081,
0.5106585622,
0.3541117907,
0.3184757829,
0.8578062654,
0.5942854881,
0.1388039887,
-0.3263355494,
-0.206033051,
-0.295761615,
0.0825438946,
-0.4608948827,
-0.6000201702,
-0.4461265802,
-0.0750823542,
0.4276514351,
0.9594942927,
-0.0951505676,
0.3192964494,
0.3095541,
1.0246685743,
-0.5538372397,
0.4588793814,
-0.637134552,
0.1899444461,
0.0648847669,
-0.0827938616,
0.0210430529,
-0.2268090844,
0.2778184414,
-0.3885994554,
0.5514551997,
0.1065231115,
0.9831847548,
0.3447520733,
0.0613278858,
-0.3596074283,
-0.6526911259,
0.6328524947,
-0.3353036642,
0.1455488503,
0.0418886654,
-0.1826643348,
0.4051663578,
-0.2971890867,
-0.6875803471,
0.0723570213,
0.0918641537,
0.0869051889,
-0.2862876654,
0.2596173286,
0.2128456533,
0.857009232,
-0.3248938024,
0.133841753,
-0.1444752514,
-0.0137865627,
0.4460925162,
-0.0483725667,
-0.0957624987,
-0.3039879203,
-0.5658249855,
0.1539942026,
-0.8559333682,
0.5396375656,
0.2687981427,
0.353695333,
-0.1225323752,
0.4416027665,
-0.0833679885,
0.445227623,
0.2999160588,
0.2342292964,
0.3264906406,
-0.1361434758,
-0.0148670552,
0.1875358969,
0.5103965998,
0.2415811419,
-0.1104142517,
-0.0672302619,
-0.215749234,
-0.2713899612,
0.4637200236,
-0.9124152064,
-0.017885467,
0.5843738317,
-0.6270961761,
-0.2834240198,
0.0732724667,
-1.0073955059,
-0.5078095198,
-0.3793727756,
0.3218400776,
-0.5401209593,
-0.4237152636,
-0.1795897484,
-0.1564247757,
0.1021256149,
0.1141531467,
-0.6647319794,
-0.159869656,
0.7640293241,
1.1341412067,
-0.014146938,
0.1303833723,
-0.3849180639,
-0.258000195,
-0.2220166624,
0.7280026674,
-0.7700955868,
-0.2348096222,
-0.0552369952,
-0.4092333019,
0.2684580386,
-0.6817301512,
0.639939487,
-0.2505978048,
-0.027437117,
-0.6324470639,
-0.3346332312,
-0.6908293366,
0.162763536,
-0.4609765112,
1.0331560373,
0.3209359646,
-0.8879016042,
0.4622810781,
-1.0282877684,
-0.4501394928,
0.0119268242,
0.0828441679,
-0.476352036,
0.6601383686,
0.4591180682,
0.5499218702,
-0.4338157177,
0.0303338207,
-0.2859297097,
-0.0433913618,
0.2982540131,
-0.2945385575,
0.4242731631,
0.094212912,
-0.1597283185,
-0.0235185027,
-0.7513560057,
-0.1385661364,
-0.1737061143,
-0.1928120404,
-0.428706944,
0.0357512794,
-0.4334118366,
0.1302874833,
0.4609808922,
-0.6339684725,
0.027296124,
-0.303876847,
0.4650885761,
0.8141985536,
0.1832746565,
0.500921309,
-0.1534748375,
0.7420578599,
0.4757145047,
0.1954793632,
-0.2108726352,
-0.2626565695,
-0.8314791918,
-0.4591899216,
0.2589039207,
0.4753441811,
-0.7707144618,
0.5695824623,
-0.2973929346,
-0.3227525949,
-0.7244784236,
0.2017580122,
0.4384530783,
0.8872327805,
0.4369000196,
-0.6598488092,
-0.1601560414,
-1.0769693851,
-0.4124664962,
-0.4381203949,
-0.2686315477,
0.4398570061,
0.2333315164,
0.1496417373,
1.0781399012,
-0.331050247,
-0.3449635804,
-0.4665821791,
0.7346101403,
0.4643415511,
0.2969053686,
0.5156659484,
-0.7476069927,
-0.2651363313,
0.0604117811,
-0.7195719481,
-0.4940649569,
-0.3991128802,
-0.0213701259,
-0.1929596812,
0.2831271589,
-0.4793987274,
0.4241813421,
0.1849438995,
-0.1299160123,
0.4029883444,
-0.0286405254,
-0.348279655,
-0.6246060133,
-0.030651113,
0.5237478614,
-0.0040233964,
-0.58567065,
0.0303000938,
-0.0370595306,
0.0255935006,
-0.038947925,
0.444417119,
-0.4793383777,
-0.118385531,
-0.372523576,
0.3359193504,
0.2059079707,
0.8508033752,
-0.148087725,
0.4475853443,
0.6659425497,
-0.6862265468,
0.0633370206,
-0.0889916122,
-0.1515952945,
1.2364579439,
-0.6320616603,
-0.0267285015,
-0.5843566656,
-0.1018539518,
-0.7329746485,
0.1765650958,
0.1374740452,
-0.5808388591,
0.4454076886,
-0.2544700503,
-0.0708255842,
-0.2654058933,
-0.4737018049,
0.2055693567,
0.3171927929,
-0.7617069483,
0.9121561646,
0.4205637574,
-0.3266669512,
-0.8694387078,
-0.511838913,
-0.168941915,
-0.4005031586,
-0.3221098781,
0.3375062943,
0.1932807118,
-0.2972765565,
0.2029713243,
-0.3298570812,
-0.0760428682,
0.1425453722,
0.4828161001,
0.0075167017,
-0.3053401411,
0.5218154192,
0.0641155317,
-0.0105110351,
0.2584991455,
-0.3752337694,
0.5287254453,
-0.4684447348,
0.0237582289,
-0.5822591186,
0.3663718402,
0.4284256101,
-0.2792097628,
0.9643523693,
0.8132355809,
-0.2397606373,
-0.4908461571,
-0.3298439085,
-0.1039948612,
-0.4335368276,
0.6516824961,
-0.3041657209,
-0.7225498557,
0.8079535365,
-0.046575021,
-0.0044992664,
0.6138033867,
0.3125596046,
-0.2239790261,
0.7369993329,
0.7917805314,
-0.2678243518,
0.7957094312,
-0.3336744606,
0.6636841893,
-1.3914221525,
-0.2858780921,
-0.5067513585,
-0.536692977,
-0.2817664146,
-0.3541243076,
0.5411924124,
0.7906081676,
-0.2509687841,
-0.1401507407,
-0.5264227986,
0.3968248963,
0.5449205041,
0.0917521492,
0.0578496158,
0.0998306647,
0.0153546827,
0.0767325535,
-0.7226750851,
-0.2374322712,
0.8719719052,
0.5661839247,
0.6170740724,
-0.0682235807,
0.1281702369,
0.1660443246,
0.5775196552,
-0.9222046733,
0.2740555704,
-0.2299800068,
-0.3805264235,
-0.2287238091,
-0.6139550209,
-0.5403523445,
0.3266495764,
-0.1770020723,
-0.9055074453,
0.412789315,
0.3643450141,
-0.2606912255,
0.3937091827,
-0.5673809052,
0.5060411096,
-0.0593841933,
-0.3218121231,
-0.2992593348,
-0.3251302838,
0.3343849778,
0.0483145751,
0.2891701758,
-0.1515853107,
0.0106079681,
0.5357904434,
-0.4851362109,
0.7571869493,
-0.4675688148,
0.0229097176,
0.3408714235,
0.1104869172,
0.3671748042,
0.279168725,
-0.1392332315,
0.6869779825,
-0.5541602969,
-0.2642378807,
-0.8757243752,
0.6570937037,
-0.6381645799,
-0.6596528292,
-0.1137721986,
-0.5186821222,
-0.2215053588,
-0.3029127121,
0.3319682479,
0.5119464993,
0.0715080947,
0.4156453013,
0.7601351738,
-0.2643448412,
0.4796008468,
0.3700805008,
0.0471450314,
0.0841236189,
1.136636734,
0.1127551794,
0.0433470085,
0.6728205085,
0.4294445813,
-0.3359405696,
-0.7252345681,
-0.2603555024,
0.1644831151,
-0.5860572457,
-0.1921302974,
-0.6445133686,
-0.2465454638,
0.167752564,
-0.1158879921,
-0.5227478147,
-0.4798334837,
-0.4672535658,
-0.2394463271,
0.3389858603,
0.6753665805,
-0.3375088274,
0.4549355805,
-0.6530819535,
0.2170308977,
0.0663400367,
0.4296616912,
0.3987515569,
-0.5894691348,
-0.4611336589,
0.0822395459,
-0.5648127198,
-0.6484011412,
0.3900465965,
0.4152897596,
0.5237417221,
0.9584010839,
-0.1088147759,
0.3284457922,
-0.0807181671,
1.0300841331,
0.2866992056,
-1.3458807468,
0.5217260718,
-0.0387955643,
0.2694138885,
0.3920277357,
0.4098525047,
-0.5912519693,
-0.2719715238,
-0.5008075237,
-1.2444010973,
0.5581080317,
0.0947302654,
0.0958129987,
0.1186219454,
0.8100745678,
0.3150637448,
0.4583672285,
-0.8832034469,
-0.2412445843,
-0.3702828288,
-0.3297272921,
0.2852379382,
-0.3738260567,
-0.0612727366,
-0.0468105003,
0.6697736979,
-0.3320346475,
0.500331521,
0.2730142176,
-0.0785745233,
0.0930634364,
0.2154233605,
0.2526809871,
0.742220521,
-0.1471907645,
0.1228591129,
-0.0321750827,
-0.480409652,
-0.1498497725,
-0.1794570982,
-0.0865479335,
-0.0505869873,
0.6292881966,
0.9778568745,
-0.4485511184,
-0.4344183505,
0.7543328404,
0.0665360242,
0.0514028817,
-0.1149713099,
0.0401092581,
-0.2090798616,
0.2971819043,
0.4952718318,
0.0156744998,
0.0109144989,
-0.5882734656,
-0.0454416834,
0.5689093471,
-0.9765227437,
-0.5260850191,
0.459885031,
0.2343225777,
-0.1060220376,
0.551345408,
-0.2730954289,
-0.6874560714,
0.6817619205,
-0.0972142667,
1.0869876146,
-0.2177003473,
0.54203403,
0.3388100266,
0.4080943465,
0.2005918473,
0.4225737453,
-0.1772220135,
-0.853625834,
-0.307169646,
-0.845744133,
-0.2550953627,
0.2384267151,
-1.0082159042,
-0.276140362,
-0.7379689813,
0.0990593657,
0.0416302755,
-0.3495424092,
-0.7429480553,
0.1692003459,
-0.2458345443,
0.5399689078,
-0.6891998053,
0.4074031115,
0.3609157503,
-0.4390209913,
-0.4552734196,
0.2677755058,
-0.0874714926,
-0.8109862208,
0.6728814244,
0.2528169155,
-0.1507445872,
-0.5443425179,
-0.544334352,
-0.68948102,
0.7957986593,
0.0969518572,
-0.5380618572,
0.2359964252,
0.1202284992,
0.8278000355,
-0.6896609664,
0.1517773122,
0.4446662664,
0.2509661913,
0.094595857,
-0.2975194156,
0.0653495118,
-0.1378806233,
0.1205600277,
0.1602070779,
-0.5786460042,
0.9209251404,
-0.1369562149,
-0.1923526078,
-0.4041281641,
0.8943225145,
-0.3466599882,
0.1322075874,
0.710196197,
0.668840766,
0.9260689616,
-0.247358188,
1.1241264343,
-0.5134931803,
0.4459295571,
1.0025237799,
0.0974971503,
0.7566053867,
0.4331943393,
-0.0864275396,
0.7567496896,
0.6173564792,
0.2034835368,
0.4478704333,
0.3165052235,
-0.3559196293,
-0.0548259839,
-0.4107473195,
-0.089189671,
0.5458474159,
0.7807703614,
-0.5811733603,
-0.1497165263,
0.1754532307,
-0.0520079732,
-0.2169393003,
-0.727224648,
0.7277541161,
0.04135672,
-0.4838450849,
0.2700514197,
0.0138569437,
0.6443402171,
-0.4681973755,
0.0776585713,
-0.4911549687,
0.2459379584,
-0.141990006,
-0.8326148987,
0.420430541,
-0.0780533925,
-0.3856493831,
-0.182015419,
0.2954785526,
-0.3585494161,
-0.4373214841,
0.0498630032,
0.2800622284,
-0.0172890648,
-0.5961027145,
-0.7157745361,
-0.3266622424,
0.0755872354,
-0.2717807293,
0.1988948733,
0.8818346858,
0.0881777182,
0.8523346186,
0.4023126364,
0.2250934988,
-0.4127160609,
-0.167341277,
0.8612151742,
-0.7118725777,
-0.5985455513,
-0.8724616766,
0.406144619,
-0.2097514272,
-0.5426656604,
0.3764483929,
0.3674075305,
0.6047953963,
0.1205146834,
0.9097466469,
-0.0403711237,
0.5378882885,
-0.7230631113,
0.4844093621,
-0.6135870814,
0.6707521677,
-0.0121578155,
-1.0922394991,
-0.0703765899,
0.6685865521,
-0.060215354,
-0.023258891,
0.8663243055,
0.6478216648,
0.1017628536,
0.2525904477,
-0.0589145422,
0.6575240493,
0.4071320891,
0.4822082222,
0.5852247477,
0.1348318905,
0.2109163851,
-0.41736871,
-0.4402066469,
-0.1343411803,
-1.1036303043,
-0.9288219213,
-0.6389940381,
-0.5152518153,
-0.2648715079,
-0.4346608818,
0.6227568388,
0.6043952703,
-0.6518520713,
0.2306471318,
-0.1324085742,
0.4605635107,
-0.5232100487,
-0.3623240888,
0.4376793206,
-0.2974648774,
-0.4758172631,
0.0324013457,
0.6936005354,
-0.2166826278,
-0.6049742103,
0.4932329357,
0.1632588804,
0.3956545889,
0.5436834097,
0.3062428832,
-0.5916629434,
-0.6002936363,
-0.5436939597,
0.3520458341,
0.4653682411,
1.1438738108,
-0.5712246299,
0.5137133598,
0.5187273026,
0.6254739165,
0.3897533417,
0.3343756497,
0.6485136151,
-1.2499006987,
0.1571590304,
0.2631511986,
0.2944767475,
0.5706526041,
-0.7098587751,
0.4132453203,
0.2088455111,
-0.1792363375,
-0.6038123965,
0.2611207664,
-0.9944878817,
-0.4524413645,
0.9692600965,
-0.5350385904,
-0.3192908764,
-0.1768462807,
0.1419378668,
-0.0836499557,
-0.4284334183,
1.0254702568,
0.8488718271,
-0.320392698,
-0.2750654519,
-0.2307345867,
0.5340667963,
0.1731948406,
-0.8276170492,
0.2554005682,
0.2274432033,
-0.054727681,
0.3746037483,
0.1933189332,
-0.057328932,
-0.1782606393,
-0.0417521894,
0.3011361063,
-0.1244305596,
-0.4489341974,
-0.5443825722,
0.5025522113,
-0.2089886218,
-0.1595558971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18139v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18139v2
|
Cause and Effect: Can Large Language Models Truly Understand Causality?
| 2024-02-28T08:02:14 | 2024-04-15T22:42:11 |
Swagata Ashwani, Kshiteesh Hegde, Nishith Reddy Mannuru, Mayank Jindal, Dushyant Singh Sengar, Krishna Chaitanya Rao Kathala, Dishant Banga, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rise of Large Language Models(LLMs), it has become crucial to
understand their capabilities and limitations in deciphering and explaining the
complex web of causal relationships that language entails. Current methods use
either explicit or implicit causal reasoning, yet there is a strong need for a
unified approach combining both to tackle a wide array of causal relationships
more effectively. This research proposes a novel architecture called Context
Aware Reasoning Enhancement with Counterfactual Analysis(CARE CA) framework to
enhance causal reasoning and explainability. The proposed framework
incorporates an explicit causal detection module with ConceptNet and
counterfactual statements, as well as implicit causal detection through LLMs.
Our framework goes one step further with a layer of counterfactual explanations
to accentuate LLMs understanding of causality. The knowledge from ConceptNet
enhances the performance of multiple causal reasoning tasks such as causal
discovery, causal identification and counterfactual reasoning. The
counterfactual sentences add explicit knowledge of the not caused by scenarios.
By combining these powerful modules, our model aims to provide a deeper
understanding of causal relationships, enabling enhanced interpretability.
Evaluation of benchmark datasets shows improved performance across all metrics,
such as accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 scores. We also introduce
CausalNet, a new dataset accompanied by our code, to facilitate further
research in this domain.
|
[
-0.1379824579,
-1.1098892689,
0.8984727859,
0.3020474613,
-0.20717372,
-0.4985979795,
0.0567095913,
-0.7082182169,
0.1009554118,
0.4251241684,
-0.6156723499,
-0.1233539507,
-0.562233448,
-0.1417440921,
-0.4122204185,
0.5952345133,
0.0952717438,
0.1422778517,
-0.2819437385,
-0.0911563486,
-0.6993646622,
-0.2821894884,
-1.1007038355,
-0.6023068428,
0.6592389941,
0.2929291725,
0.4992660582,
0.4309948981,
0.4227607548,
0.358143419,
0.0357577838,
0.134350419,
-0.5846249461,
-0.0499955192,
-0.6728403568,
-0.5020214319,
-0.5315395594,
-0.4681658447,
0.3784594238,
0.558067739,
0.0132431155,
-0.1971939057,
-0.1751147807,
0.5325934291,
-0.6018624902,
0.2462118566,
-0.5824931264,
-0.1633770615,
0.0942429379,
-0.4914690256,
-0.2845135629,
0.0465458483,
0.1528402567,
-0.775663197,
0.1656832099,
0.0767461285,
0.5159354806,
0.4624988735,
-0.6708173156,
-0.1561584771,
-0.6147287488,
0.548304677,
-0.8006119728,
0.3369527161,
0.0841349736,
0.1405763775,
-0.4628840685,
-0.8146906495,
-0.8502110839,
-0.0344250277,
-0.2237942666,
0.2170765102,
-0.4372057319,
-0.0934127346,
0.3023943305,
0.1158781201,
-0.7014555335,
0.3884578943,
-0.156005621,
-0.1129400954,
0.6227842569,
0.2982899845,
0.7329126596,
-0.0477659442,
-0.4292398095,
0.2436403334,
-1.1088703871,
-0.0730860159,
-0.0983737931,
0.2388279289,
-0.3294325173,
0.1974612027,
-0.1776233464,
0.5814063549,
-0.2432761043,
0.1893034726,
-0.2441350222,
-0.3041141033,
-0.5799188018,
0.3449005783,
0.4356800616,
0.3023968935,
0.2271437794,
-0.1806623936,
0.3311053216,
0.2939156294,
0.3038281798,
-0.8972193599,
0.0734655261,
0.4217618406,
-0.3716720939,
-0.1245776415,
-0.0378581807,
-0.3003425896,
-0.5508753657,
-0.7343634963,
0.4217141867,
-0.0857262388,
-0.5730338693,
0.5580070615,
-0.095351845,
0.220997259,
0.4167357385,
-0.3558098376,
0.2012685388,
0.774353683,
0.6580372453,
-0.0708634481,
-0.1986328512,
-0.568257153,
0.3872916698,
-0.458819747,
0.7929173112,
-0.3288009167,
-0.2574856579,
-0.0437995046,
0.1857908219,
-0.1850414872,
-0.2859967351,
0.4653458595,
-0.684081912,
0.0318443403,
-0.4861719906,
-0.5030885935,
-0.3587230444,
0.045772247,
-0.7049722075,
0.5165293217,
-0.3904103339,
-0.772172451,
0.4664297104,
-0.7747070789,
-0.7325858474,
-0.035280589,
-0.1885845661,
-0.163435936,
0.2333673984,
0.0169557724,
0.5575814843,
-0.5398144126,
1.1377704144,
-0.5006421208,
-0.3463600874,
0.2270787358,
-0.5818053484,
0.8769670725,
0.0624922104,
-0.6036114693,
0.3912228942,
-0.6808305979,
-0.3520922661,
0.0711789876,
0.1665017456,
-0.5439876318,
0.1513226032,
0.059547212,
0.6869484782,
-0.0264592357,
-0.3748210669,
-0.161384508,
-0.4461353719,
0.2444590032,
0.6852976084,
0.0928542465,
0.2121606171,
-0.0635210723,
0.2635734081,
0.3980945349,
0.1941685677,
-0.0593391731,
-0.2717418373,
-0.6069799066,
-0.1734223664,
-0.5243886709,
0.4676942825,
-0.8618558645,
0.1990044713,
-0.2635303736,
-0.1790760309,
0.1872174144,
-0.0722339451,
0.6120867133,
0.984140873,
0.5919849873,
-0.0240309369,
-0.6947963238,
-0.8528828621,
-0.3605326712,
-0.3039748371,
0.1478465199,
0.3443838954,
0.6211915016,
-0.3429125845,
0.8877413273,
-0.6143390536,
-0.0442431308,
-0.1978303641,
0.0175070688,
0.2480195761,
0.5462980866,
0.3307577074,
-1.0436960459,
0.1740160435,
-0.1686968356,
-0.92116642,
-0.3452068567,
-0.2500811517,
-0.2094626725,
0.0868725777,
0.9560028315,
-0.4099919796,
0.5185346007,
0.2909722924,
-0.8236051202,
0.6320303082,
-0.2425352335,
0.0700556189,
-1.1006968021,
0.4153954387,
0.1220988333,
0.0118378699,
-0.792406261,
-0.0753262043,
-0.1078984067,
0.0803084821,
-0.60178262,
0.8793512583,
0.0674262643,
0.0382723697,
-0.313580215,
0.1911712289,
0.2740616798,
0.3057863116,
0.2763103247,
0.4843569398,
0.4442460835,
-0.710527122,
0.1610274762,
0.076151453,
-0.3025335371,
0.7283543944,
-1.0534676313,
-0.5131782889,
-0.3225005269,
0.4560274482,
-1.0390233994,
-0.2450806499,
0.1355571747,
-0.2209516317,
0.1722130626,
0.2152350694,
-0.4057935476,
-0.1086836085,
0.1359428465,
0.2589890063,
-0.0467293821,
-0.7259038091,
0.5776299834,
0.0892422572,
0.1477661431,
-0.600853622,
-0.8138893843,
0.2072356045,
-0.3793051839,
-0.564801991,
0.2972390652,
-0.1928852499,
-0.4873022735,
-0.0592108332,
-0.2219545543,
-0.2171556503,
0.4610986412,
0.4029910266,
0.2905136645,
-0.3927468657,
0.6707865,
0.1632216126,
-0.293743521,
0.4372485876,
-0.2675980031,
0.1810182482,
0.0539284758,
-0.22479029,
-0.4030147195,
0.4168348908,
0.7165380716,
-0.1445918381,
1.0389324427,
0.5543110371,
-0.3540076613,
-0.1582100987,
-0.3842284381,
-0.3181335032,
-0.4187195599,
0.4253537357,
-0.4414204061,
-1.064422369,
0.6150784492,
-0.2319627851,
-0.2949252129,
0.5757187009,
0.4539255202,
0.2814763784,
0.8428649306,
0.4165898561,
-0.2011769712,
0.3023204505,
0.0140228141,
0.4718625844,
-0.7200331688,
-0.457528919,
-0.366120398,
0.2664000392,
-0.4556364119,
-0.2293527126,
0.2746545672,
0.1794058681,
-0.6864194274,
0.0988365412,
-0.051220946,
0.2212724835,
0.0649588183,
0.2816225886,
0.4612050354,
-0.2291115671,
-0.0605058782,
0.2652327716,
-0.7526584864,
-0.3731331527,
0.5439195633,
0.2442453802,
0.5071451664,
0.511852026,
0.0814230815,
0.1770103276,
0.3975283802,
-0.5130276084,
0.4415165484,
-0.1164521053,
-0.7831639051,
-0.3422076404,
-0.5057244301,
-0.8516677022,
0.4109469354,
-0.2557263374,
-0.8627141118,
0.4072833061,
0.3101364672,
-0.1500952393,
0.0487960316,
-0.6719603539,
0.9059641361,
-0.153577581,
-0.8581517339,
-0.4464987218,
-0.5324026942,
0.6626281738,
-0.0391880237,
0.3979139626,
0.107518144,
0.2555809319,
0.522277236,
-0.3394277096,
1.1638680696,
-0.127755627,
-0.4766316116,
0.057970807,
-0.0003423155,
0.3252861202,
0.2842491865,
-0.1005932391,
0.2114850581,
-0.2215303779,
-0.2971443236,
-0.8390746117,
1.0907806158,
-0.4143230617,
-0.7785378098,
0.0263674688,
-0.6142253876,
-0.2205057442,
0.2383291721,
-0.1255699247,
0.9136294723,
-0.3057107329,
0.0751123503,
0.7620244622,
-0.5270200372,
0.4600773156,
0.8764558434,
-0.0288239084,
0.0581301786,
0.6431815624,
-0.1368055195,
0.178921625,
0.6850705743,
0.529302001,
-0.4381219447,
-0.1342535019,
-0.2114576399,
0.1563183963,
-0.68385607,
-0.0081370221,
-0.7756970525,
0.2235577554,
-0.4088723063,
-0.1941245645,
-0.1182503775,
-0.2414194643,
-0.3182494342,
-0.1887989342,
0.3140546679,
0.5566158891,
-0.1739581972,
0.3925177753,
-0.4080779254,
0.5176687241,
0.3583832979,
0.315128684,
0.4748441279,
-0.3028974235,
-0.2349004,
-0.1420022249,
0.2146371156,
-0.5981297493,
0.1890324801,
-0.1294898838,
0.4538598061,
0.7352361679,
0.0264890362,
0.9323533773,
-0.5331126451,
0.602180481,
0.3562346995,
-1.0483849049,
0.5997011065,
-0.3413032591,
0.4190385938,
0.1295960397,
0.3273378909,
-0.4549422264,
-0.2113655359,
-0.6405162215,
-0.8508034348,
0.5978395939,
0.0043674288,
-0.2060788423,
-0.0591798015,
0.4401816428,
-0.1416920573,
-0.1549701691,
-0.5676606894,
-0.2012461722,
-0.0761310086,
-0.1241978705,
-0.4113547802,
-0.333322823,
-0.10849379,
-0.1329877675,
0.7252888083,
-0.1672787219,
0.0275016017,
0.5106402636,
-0.1890764087,
-0.1097151488,
0.394076556,
0.8968147039,
0.9647290707,
0.0947501659,
0.3291694224,
0.0534674637,
-0.1456440538,
-0.1331352443,
0.1347297281,
0.081172511,
-0.3434416652,
1.0462146997,
0.7379555702,
0.485060215,
-0.6497696042,
0.3774926364,
-0.1084045693,
0.2646983862,
-0.1452480704,
0.2923201025,
0.3668379188,
0.3630260527,
0.1961379647,
-0.2205904275,
0.3400378823,
-0.5486076474,
0.2790994644,
0.3993784785,
-0.4899095595,
-0.2998565733,
0.690392375,
0.0253460594,
0.1108138263,
0.2315600365,
0.3660696149,
-0.4834798574,
1.0381630659,
0.7754663825,
0.5237821937,
-0.295925051,
0.203254357,
0.483299762,
0.3418626189,
-0.0422861166,
0.3220896721,
-0.0185489096,
-1.0529130697,
-0.736954093,
-0.2591365576,
-0.1938116699,
0.3260144293,
-0.5977996588,
-0.2165530026,
-0.0543449707,
0.2729822993,
0.1104469299,
-0.0974792391,
-0.5855848789,
0.6742307544,
-0.3235200047,
0.727548182,
-1.2405030727,
0.6437662244,
0.4803252816,
-0.4823103547,
-0.9244942069,
-0.154995665,
0.0407953411,
-0.7766472697,
1.1029685736,
0.2177259475,
-0.4794028401,
-0.2773039341,
-0.5143651962,
-0.5392543674,
1.0236531496,
0.35851717,
-0.7127544284,
0.4431368709,
0.0868280306,
0.6428874135,
-0.3981120586,
0.2819122076,
0.5600830913,
0.5431801677,
0.0774780884,
-0.5720313787,
0.5940281749,
-0.1380009949,
-0.0987862423,
-0.0040064072,
-0.3448573947,
0.3748504221,
-0.1870391518,
-0.0410598107,
-0.3758506179,
0.4310258925,
0.3821560442,
0.6923637986,
0.3613942862,
0.5393960476,
0.5853033066,
0.0964724943,
1.3554956913,
-0.1808610111,
0.0071211951,
1.3075520992,
-0.3199927807,
0.4842518866,
0.6233490109,
0.1543785036,
0.6891111732,
0.2783203423,
0.6276136637,
0.2768646777,
0.2819644809,
-0.3626801074,
-0.5425376892,
-0.6241686344,
-0.1913242787,
0.474403888,
0.4745750427,
-0.381088227,
-0.0994150862,
-0.1404028088,
0.2512004375,
0.0152262533,
-0.4431248903,
0.5797021985,
0.3802274168,
-0.5504236817,
0.1327291429,
-0.1566656232,
0.201537326,
-0.5364125371,
-0.2139984965,
-0.2269364148,
0.3202108741,
-0.2918890715,
-0.423214972,
0.4598290324,
-0.3446774483,
-0.3833935559,
-0.0019153212,
0.9504464269,
-0.3496393263,
-0.3415183127,
0.6127122045,
0.668682158,
-0.1191400811,
0.0623488389,
-0.475284934,
0.0308633503,
-0.4130393863,
-0.1396513879,
0.0942303911,
0.5516893268,
-0.3859367967,
0.6312891841,
0.7946865559,
0.0633881614,
-0.5510640144,
0.4724653363,
0.8653252721,
-0.6243778467,
-0.5825771093,
-1.1028724909,
0.5195215344,
-0.2169688791,
-0.1997120231,
0.5292328596,
0.1840098947,
0.400197655,
0.0061071776,
0.4350644946,
0.190499112,
0.1737178862,
-0.698427856,
0.6588410139,
-0.8545206785,
0.386056453,
-0.3539430201,
-0.491137594,
-0.601254046,
0.3135776818,
-0.6360681057,
-0.1490853578,
0.7762596607,
0.8931719065,
-0.0604490973,
0.1708914936,
0.4419452548,
0.5243673921,
0.5895473361,
0.5863918066,
0.6887205839,
-0.1447971165,
0.0524215885,
0.3756806254,
-0.246538341,
-0.0612523444,
-1.0683839321,
-0.9086149335,
-0.4127719998,
-0.3590186238,
-0.0137761766,
0.1860080659,
0.4155307412,
0.6211864352,
-0.7984321713,
0.1476143897,
-0.6124848127,
0.5196808577,
-0.0872127935,
-0.3469192386,
0.7117517591,
-0.2118489593,
-0.1980425566,
0.5441257358,
0.5137904286,
-0.4235405326,
-0.2246519327,
-0.0902406201,
-0.3525694311,
0.3411563337,
0.9507027268,
0.2678460181,
-0.7238361835,
-0.3453400731,
-0.3572492898,
0.2084051818,
-0.4878620207,
1.1644507647,
-0.6766206622,
0.4905715585,
0.4308996797,
0.5934123993,
0.1364182234,
-0.2703379691,
0.6857576966,
-0.333509028,
0.1433406621,
-0.3125143051,
0.5790897608,
0.1700887382,
-0.7324048281,
0.529425323,
0.2137431353,
-0.1932022274,
-0.457614243,
0.5036224127,
-0.8328633308,
-0.7886237502,
1.025462389,
-0.2247836888,
-0.0053672795,
-0.4347830713,
-0.0126252286,
0.4525383115,
-0.1132248342,
0.7078679204,
0.3712540865,
-0.3039075136,
-0.0551347658,
-0.4670633078,
0.2520228624,
0.5913310051,
-1.1741347313,
-0.062390998,
0.7533580661,
0.1656787097,
-0.0867404044,
0.529527247,
-0.1744730771,
0.3450817466,
-0.281869173,
-0.16256091,
-0.2162484825,
-0.4007134736,
-0.4105253816,
0.0862633064,
-0.404032588,
0.2784817815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18137v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18137v2
|
DecisionNCE: Embodied Multimodal Representations via Implicit Preference Learning
| 2024-02-28T07:58:24 | 2024-05-24T03:31:50 |
Jianxiong Li, Jinliang Zheng, Yinan Zheng, Liyuan Mao, Xiao Hu, Sijie Cheng, Haoyi Niu, Jihao Liu, Yu Liu, Jingjing Liu, Ya-Qin Zhang, Xianyuan Zhan
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Multimodal pretraining is an effective strategy for the trinity of goals of
representation learning in autonomous robots: 1) extracting both local and
global task progressions; 2) enforcing temporal consistency of visual
representation; 3) capturing trajectory-level language grounding. Most existing
methods approach these via separate objectives, which often reach sub-optimal
solutions. In this paper, we propose a universal unified objective that can
simultaneously extract meaningful task progression information from image
sequences and seamlessly align them with language instructions. We discover
that via implicit preferences, where a visual trajectory inherently aligns
better with its corresponding language instruction than mismatched pairs, the
popular Bradley-Terry model can transform into representation learning through
proper reward reparameterizations. The resulted framework, DecisionNCE, mirrors
an InfoNCE-style objective but is distinctively tailored for decision-making
tasks, providing an embodied representation learning framework that elegantly
extracts both local and global task progression features, with temporal
consistency enforced through implicit time contrastive learning, while ensuring
trajectory-level instruction grounding via multimodal joint encoding.
Evaluation on both simulated and real robots demonstrates that DecisionNCE
effectively facilitates diverse downstream policy learning tasks, offering a
versatile solution for unified representation and reward learning. Project
Page: https://2toinf.github.io/DecisionNCE/
|
[
-0.0602392331,
-0.1760860234,
0.9332800508,
0.0419656225,
0.0144755598,
0.1550527513,
-0.1504306197,
0.0258587152,
0.2514029443,
0.53232795,
-0.7657210231,
-0.5692595243,
-0.7027682662,
-0.1993050426,
0.079439342,
0.9823163748,
-0.2940814495,
0.056239754,
-0.1720204502,
-0.3467361927,
-0.5870748162,
-0.4232449234,
-0.5795947313,
-0.4421067834,
0.8032981753,
0.454844296,
0.6374519467,
0.4587222636,
0.3417284489,
0.4184707701,
0.6088703871,
0.2262779921,
-0.3926210701,
0.0583386831,
-0.1950557977,
-0.4483547211,
-0.0844102874,
0.1217950806,
0.5622519255,
0.5017821193,
-0.0940614417,
-0.1081654131,
0.0463018827,
0.8888147473,
-0.8478068113,
0.3743772805,
-0.1005279273,
0.3102200627,
0.2503620386,
-0.2869049609,
-0.4060362279,
-0.3674426675,
-0.0411678776,
-0.9069011211,
-0.0827379525,
-0.173265487,
0.7374516129,
0.5573677421,
-0.555986166,
-0.2322952747,
-0.7322064042,
0.8398841023,
0.0486299321,
0.554443121,
0.0562508292,
0.4099036157,
0.0664457679,
-0.5968751311,
-0.4914748669,
-0.511736393,
-0.1371079236,
0.6354495883,
-0.0802723914,
0.4764179885,
0.2826908827,
-0.0400198884,
-0.5172840357,
-0.1965038329,
-0.2163305283,
-0.3631238043,
0.3617217541,
-0.0526503138,
0.2965840995,
-0.234484598,
-0.7437167168,
-0.6830711365,
-0.3443873525,
0.5086787343,
0.4504915774,
0.2849834263,
-0.18776986,
0.570017457,
-0.217008844,
0.4573839605,
0.1288360059,
-0.0835381001,
0.3881773353,
-0.0572505146,
0.1252664626,
0.0041143196,
0.6983252764,
0.2837266624,
0.110232532,
-0.2668454945,
-0.0818256214,
0.2133156508,
0.5546914935,
-0.5806306005,
-0.3283064067,
0.0554858223,
-0.3349901438,
0.0090731215,
0.4546285868,
-0.614061594,
-0.2121839523,
-0.7990092635,
0.6206105351,
-0.3714372218,
-0.270126164,
0.288610369,
-0.177286014,
0.1378637105,
0.5144084692,
-0.8069837093,
0.0556253865,
0.1351785362,
0.7030874491,
-0.2000176609,
-0.2320364267,
-0.4314132333,
0.3717508316,
-0.4159863591,
0.6604718566,
-0.5875937343,
-0.334877342,
-0.2273015082,
0.1753751338,
-0.0850096047,
-0.200694412,
0.4810786247,
-0.3437113762,
0.0706667379,
-0.2095252424,
-0.0580429956,
-0.4858848453,
0.2989627719,
-0.7903099656,
0.7675879598,
0.2082090229,
-0.2678000927,
0.6820819378,
-0.8409284353,
-0.2544153929,
-0.269816637,
-0.4430290461,
-0.1238356829,
-0.1584559828,
0.1283280849,
0.4362045825,
0.1169135645,
0.3596971929,
-0.1905801892,
-0.0870283097,
-0.375808388,
-0.3735993505,
0.4190561473,
0.0278475732,
-0.4594933689,
0.5678569674,
-0.5010165572,
-0.0183381326,
0.1724500656,
-0.2559028566,
-0.2375386357,
0.181870237,
-0.3818802834,
0.2877359092,
0.4817422032,
-0.3835048378,
0.2295006961,
-0.007157783,
-0.0886013061,
1.2029540539,
-0.4650282264,
0.8611936569,
-0.3005805612,
0.4677999318,
0.0943837315,
0.3069804609,
-0.2650176585,
-0.0859193131,
-0.9936414361,
-0.2563381493,
-0.1147290915,
0.496824652,
-0.7885804176,
0.2863098085,
-0.2076986879,
-0.1905532777,
-0.1755809784,
0.0891281515,
0.5477144718,
0.4051868021,
0.53791219,
-0.2770925164,
-0.4600974917,
-0.9547492862,
0.1869339198,
-0.3678242266,
0.0896355212,
0.2968214154,
0.402567476,
-0.3695401251,
0.8620125651,
-0.4387429059,
-0.242039904,
-0.09395051,
0.5730485916,
0.3175496757,
0.600373745,
0.6179587841,
-1.1205848455,
0.0171162207,
0.0448033661,
-0.8367469311,
0.2887032628,
-0.2115957141,
-0.4289769232,
-0.04442719,
0.377401799,
-0.4004165828,
0.3248716891,
0.4660612941,
0.0258948784,
0.3674278259,
-0.4629353583,
0.6501463652,
-0.8706027269,
-0.076248318,
-0.1703503132,
-0.3057422936,
-0.0937339589,
-0.0854663029,
0.0734620392,
0.0097951125,
-0.3876004219,
0.4195243418,
-0.3381018043,
-0.0769641995,
-0.0948876143,
-0.0687721223,
-0.0289201029,
0.8218199611,
0.4241173267,
0.6316148043,
0.6025385857,
-0.9055938721,
0.4915257096,
0.1541706324,
0.0591186248,
0.5543487668,
-0.5028316379,
0.2364567369,
-0.5060319304,
0.2488725185,
-1.0693124533,
-0.2965591848,
0.3517311513,
-0.4155521989,
0.1364860088,
-0.1459458917,
-0.1134607643,
-0.4034335017,
-0.2198963165,
0.3676012456,
0.3725772202,
-0.6719859242,
1.0038042068,
0.1593139172,
0.287281692,
-0.9290106893,
-0.4161017835,
-0.3379271328,
0.0196643695,
-0.4538823366,
0.3508901298,
-0.2508663535,
-0.0068119764,
-0.1084287912,
-0.3478502631,
0.2857193947,
-0.2098729014,
0.4099089801,
0.3084347844,
-0.0043936446,
0.1886354238,
0.1174469516,
-0.5790656209,
-0.1052357107,
-0.541120708,
0.4570740759,
-0.0947642103,
-0.6224867105,
-0.0542516299,
0.339119494,
0.4401734769,
-0.0923386961,
0.2585349381,
0.7471364737,
-0.1203583702,
-0.1476337761,
-0.2461360395,
-0.2591640055,
-0.4924956262,
0.3052992225,
-0.273791939,
-0.6965658069,
0.1084046215,
-0.5060281754,
0.0954611674,
0.2499424517,
0.2741396427,
-0.3652050197,
1.2646776438,
0.95058465,
0.113652572,
0.6082671285,
-0.4384985268,
-0.1438732892,
-0.5561124682,
-0.5540983677,
-0.1896984577,
-0.4538362324,
-0.357619375,
-0.4820918441,
0.5445527434,
0.1228288412,
-0.6386075616,
0.3855996132,
-0.4742397368,
0.4330113232,
0.6529893875,
0.5446356535,
0.0421676897,
0.0592834353,
-0.3963602483,
-0.1629295647,
-0.3424172401,
-0.7401135564,
0.9683719277,
-0.4275100529,
0.8977842927,
0.0222045965,
0.701891005,
0.6374100447,
-0.0078790514,
-0.6350977421,
0.6120906472,
-0.2956691682,
-0.2724084556,
-0.0335160196,
-0.3001859486,
-1.0415248871,
0.0811051205,
-0.3675657213,
-0.6544989347,
0.2025501877,
0.3627569675,
-0.3212729096,
0.2878208756,
-0.5443271995,
1.1853508949,
-0.665700078,
-0.5442377925,
-0.3503355384,
-1.0202970505,
0.0716988891,
0.3471722305,
0.0056901658,
-0.2998544872,
-0.0749887228,
0.572609067,
0.0833454877,
0.7062557936,
-0.2437649816,
0.1437831968,
-0.0047247815,
0.1247554794,
0.3275671899,
-0.0109251719,
0.1258208305,
0.0234667882,
-0.4000604451,
-0.4018431306,
-0.7092753053,
0.2948272526,
-0.8935412765,
-0.480109036,
-0.4864529073,
-0.4916373789,
-0.1645324677,
0.2086895257,
0.1086683422,
0.4595030248,
-0.3731808662,
0.0079664011,
0.6048251987,
-0.1096118689,
0.4296864271,
0.3677275181,
-0.3111373484,
-0.1882078946,
0.9830880165,
-0.3896756172,
0.3561951518,
0.9132372141,
0.1027306542,
-0.531334579,
-0.0991101265,
-0.4112099707,
-0.0330277085,
-0.9945142269,
0.0605114512,
-0.6975780129,
0.0736077353,
-0.0578774661,
-0.5630753636,
-0.5324112773,
-0.2088948041,
-0.2676921785,
-0.2086617053,
0.1634726673,
0.9413562417,
-0.5022130609,
0.2666009665,
-0.5647850037,
0.6992652416,
0.754196465,
-0.1156731993,
-0.4620119929,
-0.1492339522,
0.1086158752,
0.3196094334,
-0.5388284922,
-0.5699084401,
0.0886169672,
0.0346231833,
0.7197657228,
0.476142168,
0.0090163974,
0.7355914116,
-0.3538461626,
0.6243365407,
0.5821333528,
-0.7905265689,
0.8776284456,
-0.3686080873,
0.1307949573,
0.660068512,
0.7156205177,
-0.4062651992,
-0.062268924,
-0.4805304408,
-0.8033900857,
0.8381455541,
0.0842361525,
0.2541624308,
0.142534405,
-0.0168882906,
0.222094655,
0.2036037147,
-1.0046306849,
-0.2096160054,
-0.4123245776,
-0.3005341589,
-0.1793333888,
0.2179708481,
-0.2467080802,
-0.2259088755,
0.2989954352,
-0.4754347801,
0.5200456977,
0.103781648,
-0.317070812,
0.1462103724,
0.0652416348,
0.4040481448,
0.4890038073,
-0.065163739,
0.1096793562,
-0.181837976,
-0.236513406,
0.6042075157,
-0.0696054921,
0.0260916073,
-0.1634222567,
0.2331984639,
0.9782407284,
0.2967124879,
-0.6370065808,
0.5847817659,
0.0235566292,
-0.0214750953,
-0.3178666234,
0.2990731895,
-0.2899666429,
0.4775224924,
0.3449505866,
0.6189233065,
0.2254565656,
-0.5421109796,
0.2832968533,
0.4080914855,
-0.6915106773,
-0.2808241248,
0.8132072687,
0.0789010599,
0.2237624079,
0.3991428912,
-0.2515738606,
-0.3745158613,
0.749458313,
0.1983217448,
0.8561093211,
-0.3129679859,
0.7040255666,
0.7369383574,
0.2767775059,
-0.3341016471,
0.2895018458,
-0.5321383476,
-0.9510976672,
-0.2697728872,
-0.4783326387,
-0.4388203323,
-0.6338942647,
-0.525295496,
0.3343342841,
-0.4302799404,
-0.0795190632,
-0.4964824021,
-0.6773197055,
-0.6751939654,
0.2921306193,
0.2760062814,
-0.153439343,
-0.6232157946,
0.4675906599,
0.7683532834,
-0.7668713331,
-0.784563303,
-0.1947793663,
0.1479842812,
-1.0093410015,
1.0829486847,
0.4923152328,
-0.809607327,
-0.0365456939,
-0.7702631354,
-0.8551113605,
1.1256456375,
0.8599085212,
-0.4094214737,
-0.0712759718,
-0.0849083662,
-0.0529476441,
-0.3433705568,
0.519318819,
0.2511490285,
0.7531756163,
0.3696522713,
-0.4266831577,
-0.2135554105,
-0.2829008996,
-0.1975908577,
0.2880334556,
-0.712847054,
0.8899948597,
-0.474419564,
-0.3250174224,
-0.0029653013,
0.5414559245,
0.3152071238,
-0.0908166319,
0.6785875559,
0.5353546143,
0.711812675,
-0.4339647591,
1.0152595043,
0.0367429294,
0.1570817679,
0.7695164084,
-0.1448403448,
0.3249208033,
0.1718118191,
-0.0407030545,
0.857499063,
0.484375447,
0.4954950511,
0.7850154638,
-0.1584298611,
-0.1713140458,
-0.7082937956,
-0.0994570032,
-0.315656215,
0.5791928172,
0.2008551806,
-0.0860636607,
-0.2989377081,
0.3970644176,
-0.0172415078,
0.1756006181,
-0.4316531122,
0.7467626929,
-0.2968298793,
-0.7209997773,
0.2235479355,
-0.510506928,
0.7418794632,
-1.1283566952,
-0.5324836373,
0.0871262252,
0.3030936122,
-0.0462949052,
-0.7535523176,
-0.1842315942,
-0.468420893,
-0.1870458573,
-0.640751183,
0.4247600436,
-0.4933520257,
-0.4278486371,
0.7463465929,
0.1911631972,
0.0091566918,
0.0569001734,
-0.8899713755,
-0.0999124646,
-0.0074628922,
-0.0742738843,
-0.0657121837,
0.282242626,
0.0965696722,
0.6877701283,
0.5298139453,
-0.2363032699,
-0.0782348514,
0.0357562639,
0.7348661423,
-0.601359427,
-0.4332670271,
-0.6840564013,
0.8141995668,
-0.0698576495,
-0.2655890286,
0.456779331,
0.3319376707,
1.0065499544,
-0.10743393,
0.676887691,
-0.2656502426,
-0.1236578822,
-1.0365352631,
0.3012782931,
-0.8710641861,
-0.4263962805,
-0.4468573034,
-0.9458598495,
-0.1034149379,
0.8517512679,
-0.2330349237,
0.4595974088,
0.8515546322,
0.690672338,
-0.0920181796,
-0.1894784719,
0.3421902955,
-0.3044210672,
0.1131190434,
0.7641398907,
0.9715147614,
-0.1121112108,
0.5085313916,
-0.2058012038,
-0.2399396598,
0.1511214226,
-0.8765913844,
-0.5967856646,
-0.8530913591,
-0.1712825,
0.0336504392,
0.3210292757,
1.1496698856,
1.1063503027,
-0.7032777667,
-0.3214506507,
-0.1640018821,
0.1577864736,
-0.2809183598,
-0.1441025883,
0.2073706985,
-0.6129527688,
-0.8860011697,
0.4424548149,
0.6169416308,
0.0548094623,
-0.1168659106,
-0.492022872,
-0.1677629948,
-0.387501061,
0.6994251609,
0.3855909407,
-0.5170629621,
-0.4430950582,
-0.0389427803,
-0.083504051,
0.3496572971,
1.0648781061,
-0.8511732817,
0.8244047165,
0.1642637849,
0.5016342998,
0.6373062134,
-0.0783991143,
0.6742889285,
-0.6114554405,
0.5164405704,
0.2375579327,
0.5844865441,
0.2670722604,
-0.0965499505,
0.6463131309,
0.259645313,
-0.3781711161,
0.0326909833,
0.4876246452,
-1.1864613295,
-0.1659177244,
0.9435849786,
0.0063542938,
-0.1766037792,
-0.0802636668,
-0.6417653561,
0.371534586,
-0.5468919277,
0.2965576649,
0.4547177553,
-0.1388866901,
-0.1415010244,
-0.4769470096,
0.2726658881,
0.2905551791,
-0.7348181605,
-0.2767623961,
0.8776275516,
-0.229380846,
0.4470098913,
0.7093260884,
-0.0198422577,
0.3651651144,
-0.2121635973,
0.6512334347,
0.1062681898,
-0.8423576355,
0.0759539977,
-0.0375917032,
-0.2479603142,
-0.4732375145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18121v1
|
Saving the legacy of Hero Ibash: Evaluating Four Language Models for Aminoacian
| 2024-02-28T07:22:13 | 2024-02-28T07:22:13 |
Yunze Xiao, Yiyang Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study assesses four cutting-edge language models in the underexplored
Aminoacian language. Through evaluation, it scrutinizes their adaptability,
effectiveness, and limitations in text generation, semantic coherence, and
contextual understanding. Uncovering insights into these models' performance in
a low-resourced language, this research pioneers pathways to bridge linguistic
gaps. By offering benchmarks and understanding challenges, it lays groundwork
for future advancements in natural language processing, aiming to elevate the
applicability of language models in similar linguistic landscapes, marking a
significant step toward inclusivity and progress in language technology.
|
[
-0.5164142847,
-0.3965427876,
0.4270500243,
-0.2084530741,
0.0684496462,
0.3237652481,
-0.1958833039,
-0.603759706,
-0.1413529515,
0.7460541725,
-0.4026136398,
-0.1758224666,
-0.3820482492,
0.4781543016,
-0.0875711814,
1.1057658195,
-0.0865951478,
0.0047299848,
-0.2433651835,
-0.700540483,
-0.8302794099,
-0.3511233032,
-0.8267450929,
-0.5513890386,
0.4799669683,
0.7158328891,
1.1062703133,
0.6742947698,
0.5788130164,
0.2144469619,
-0.0383698605,
-0.095583871,
-0.4334249198,
0.164388299,
-0.6513212323,
-0.4140531123,
-0.7478253841,
-0.1606104523,
0.7988854051,
0.7917155623,
0.2854157984,
0.0399257392,
-0.1681439131,
0.6590644121,
-0.6542643309,
0.0831620097,
-0.5484296679,
-0.3798415959,
-0.5072704554,
0.0023931889,
-0.3457805514,
-0.5285381675,
-0.0128245847,
-0.0449916683,
0.0860891268,
0.1340139657,
0.6384581327,
-0.2807543576,
-0.2486595064,
-0.2652562857,
-0.7094204426,
0.837644279,
-1.0186901093,
0.1877643913,
0.6655413508,
0.5853636861,
-0.1236398891,
-1.1681321859,
-0.846709609,
-0.1754463911,
0.0217403881,
-0.0373067409,
-0.3784818649,
0.1035298556,
0.0113034276,
0.7057988048,
-0.4058288038,
0.3409896791,
-0.573158443,
-0.0161994398,
0.7842859626,
0.2973719537,
0.6979541183,
-0.2762459517,
-0.2240361869,
-0.2854435742,
-0.9363593459,
0.3021137714,
0.4406163096,
0.5648741722,
-0.1330779791,
0.2605523169,
-0.1647506058,
0.4672454,
-0.4726192057,
-0.2054888457,
-0.0013119103,
-0.2370870709,
0.0131532494,
0.0051307352,
0.7445386052,
0.339774251,
0.2334211171,
-0.0539641865,
-0.1659067571,
0.17998299,
0.3878823221,
-0.7774304748,
-0.2999420464,
0.2345957309,
-0.468469739,
-0.0874986053,
-0.4964160025,
-0.7842289805,
-0.3323260546,
0.0836936012,
0.3836509585,
-0.8593072295,
-0.1484294087,
-0.2090555578,
-0.1577077061,
0.0295873247,
0.3777114451,
-1.2512844801,
0.3593710661,
0.5558891892,
0.9264888763,
0.0245258249,
-0.3085878193,
-0.158767879,
0.0890273005,
-0.2535643876,
1.0595760345,
-0.824559927,
-0.302705586,
-0.1574399024,
-0.2365757227,
-0.1245396957,
-0.2896131575,
0.9491599202,
-0.3305868506,
-0.1524800956,
-0.3450246751,
-0.6214004755,
-0.6493864655,
0.2645832002,
-1.0611505508,
0.5899588466,
0.6462616324,
-0.5360893011,
0.0756282806,
-0.8392597437,
-0.2063800246,
0.5066739917,
-0.1934938282,
-0.2119230479,
0.228806451,
0.0688688383,
0.1394530833,
-0.7247318029,
0.0563127548,
-0.1798949242,
-0.1395368129,
0.1752825826,
-0.5415964723,
0.8021600246,
0.2557911575,
-0.2428018004,
-0.1395701766,
-0.6612910032,
0.0789666325,
-0.0700520501,
-0.0984092653,
-0.3612374067,
-0.0276655853,
0.3410436809,
0.1597909927,
0.1155171692,
-0.524777174,
0.3432711661,
-0.3803191483,
0.5852748752,
0.6476245522,
-0.0932099372,
0.1650831252,
-0.3843994737,
0.7249157429,
-0.3811168373,
0.1171864197,
-0.4648374319,
-0.481600821,
-0.6856062412,
-0.1531758159,
0.5482977033,
0.2808349133,
-0.8203151226,
-0.168721959,
-0.3739251494,
-0.4640783072,
-0.7308204174,
0.0282525178,
0.3531396687,
0.4931362569,
0.5022517443,
-0.6986370087,
-0.3496720195,
-1.3400458097,
-0.4252860546,
-0.398845166,
0.2148366868,
0.1470814198,
0.6243928671,
-0.6154470444,
1.0754257441,
0.1748528183,
0.1854032725,
-0.9721115232,
0.4204295874,
0.2034292221,
0.6739695072,
0.7757528424,
-0.6335710883,
-0.5678753257,
0.3684522808,
-0.628919065,
-0.1231149808,
0.0329157524,
0.1005634516,
-0.061514914,
0.121783331,
-0.414588362,
0.7648741603,
0.5073263049,
-0.2472456545,
0.4398087561,
-0.0073871352,
0.4024450481,
-0.8918218017,
0.4515755475,
-0.5670853853,
-0.276594013,
-1.0081367493,
0.2829945683,
0.0709589124,
-0.1372607946,
-0.2555726767,
0.9780211449,
-0.497000128,
-0.1103262976,
-0.5546554327,
0.07235118,
0.0853109062,
0.2446215153,
0.0342677645,
0.7138876319,
0.3091761768,
-0.4913702607,
0.2501205206,
0.4146555662,
-0.3260464966,
0.8178739548,
-0.5853368044,
0.0664806142,
-0.0680865571,
-0.0596827306,
-0.9204360843,
-0.2146739364,
0.1063422114,
-0.5437253714,
0.4602943957,
-0.251205653,
-0.4149749577,
-0.3003046513,
-0.2583863139,
0.7644398808,
0.4406643808,
-0.2764856219,
0.5562364459,
0.3963033855,
-0.5730925202,
-0.373439312,
-0.5449256301,
0.3956026435,
-0.0764782205,
-0.4921782613,
0.0369619951,
-0.2584818304,
-0.5250422955,
-0.3298836648,
0.0469351709,
-0.1705376953,
0.2780382037,
-0.1556055993,
0.1550228596,
-0.3773447275,
-0.1064397991,
0.2084163278,
-0.0374470577,
-0.3635988832,
0.1860390157,
0.6585168839,
-0.3346245587,
-0.0340674333,
-0.3905547559,
0.4662408531,
0.6682247519,
-0.3496824205,
1.0095077753,
0.3623626828,
-0.5388638377,
-0.0279153604,
-0.3345599473,
0.0141111556,
-0.4611644149,
0.3224394023,
-0.2952836454,
-0.5318109989,
0.6205834746,
-0.1100086793,
0.1615110189,
0.6548233628,
0.4201706946,
0.0227333419,
0.6779415607,
0.6742240787,
-0.0161412861,
0.1630189717,
-0.3939297199,
0.3554387391,
-1.1681643724,
0.0087916879,
-0.4979681373,
-0.3561559021,
-0.5848252773,
-0.048000481,
0.3753021657,
0.3227070272,
-0.040325027,
0.7160302401,
0.1418317705,
0.2987747788,
0.2498054057,
-0.1940822154,
0.3127517104,
-0.1542371958,
-0.1131171957,
-0.121824041,
-0.8523178101,
-0.9434209466,
1.1947079897,
0.4751408994,
0.5090528131,
0.3050355315,
0.3450428545,
0.7068831325,
0.6061467528,
-0.4396283329,
0.3861558139,
-0.0991511196,
-0.7007184029,
-0.2856268585,
-0.3014222682,
-1.0075775385,
0.3002814949,
-0.1517677158,
-1.1527007818,
0.4266350865,
0.1441559941,
-0.3478780091,
0.5488888621,
-0.3581361175,
1.2512372732,
-0.1598779857,
-0.6124210358,
-0.3843578398,
-0.6412089467,
0.4130624533,
0.2052938044,
0.4415825009,
-0.1430351883,
0.1725920141,
0.3612789512,
-0.3293297589,
0.45896703,
0.4520108104,
0.1185837537,
0.3184865713,
0.3430079222,
0.1728433371,
0.0587469079,
-0.2610028386,
0.3591641188,
-0.1807035357,
-0.4708887637,
-0.5324493051,
0.6849957108,
-0.5720664263,
-0.219595775,
-0.5025195479,
-0.7395106554,
-0.2543955743,
0.3830811381,
0.2502084374,
0.9959540367,
-0.5736004114,
0.2243599892,
0.4788852632,
-0.2029812336,
0.8024886847,
0.4318968654,
0.0074946927,
-0.6565491557,
0.6970070601,
-0.0138875125,
0.4475862682,
0.3766210079,
0.019635139,
-0.2067429125,
-0.8188230395,
-0.691675663,
0.2423343211,
-0.7899859548,
-0.3839735389,
-0.6782163382,
-0.1866693646,
-0.4050291479,
-0.2880997062,
-0.6743195653,
-0.612232089,
-0.0110461423,
0.0496758297,
0.2338620126,
1.0567982197,
-0.1045660675,
0.5305178761,
-0.9407969117,
0.1760656685,
0.1109375358,
0.3935159147,
0.2003895938,
-0.4665403962,
-0.6523082852,
0.1169044226,
-0.4975727201,
-0.8806376457,
0.5117757916,
0.3759430349,
0.7937991023,
0.3166436851,
0.169659391,
0.3628742993,
-0.6129559278,
0.7104493976,
0.1831534058,
-1.1302134991,
0.5247913003,
-0.4719487429,
0.5377958417,
0.8712184429,
0.40414837,
-0.700935185,
-0.4056877196,
-0.7314998507,
-1.0628923178,
0.7167362571,
0.6949363351,
-0.1476596445,
-0.0912999362,
0.086823687,
0.4806299508,
0.2854532897,
-0.8120738864,
-0.1748112589,
-0.2574174702,
-0.2752981782,
-0.1170753539,
-0.3064300716,
0.1005576253,
-0.2212306112,
0.56673491,
-0.1558921188,
0.2033595294,
-0.0720260739,
-0.4555238485,
0.0780437514,
0.5096213222,
0.6358147264,
1.0351732969,
-0.1240831763,
-0.0682116151,
0.1089242697,
-0.7292689085,
-0.0979981944,
-0.0788424164,
-0.1374460012,
-0.1074390635,
0.8607569933,
1.0605661869,
0.3708802164,
-0.7311264277,
0.1511654556,
-0.1994766444,
0.5920240879,
-0.1973261386,
0.1122797206,
-0.1395040751,
0.2581082582,
0.3974767029,
0.3511022329,
0.3311861455,
-1.1466536522,
0.0521836393,
0.2382517159,
-0.0694656149,
-0.5862856507,
0.5942425728,
0.1414504051,
-0.4556015432,
0.5933744311,
0.1732405275,
-0.6598103642,
0.4145821631,
0.6533381939,
1.0050110817,
-0.460300535,
0.1158573031,
0.5289933681,
0.462675333,
-0.0935367867,
-0.012297783,
-0.1046134979,
-0.727977097,
0.2250280529,
-0.689956665,
-0.5896487832,
0.1434762478,
-0.7709099054,
0.0698651224,
-0.5321638584,
-0.3677627742,
-0.0127452184,
-0.021650847,
-0.6724796295,
0.2291420102,
0.1372770518,
0.8971105814,
-0.7614933848,
0.7370795012,
0.540086627,
-0.7027545571,
-0.3590749204,
0.0116719501,
-0.3533544838,
-0.5171768069,
0.4724688828,
0.1726022512,
-0.0694684684,
-0.1025276557,
-0.4344378114,
-0.9003213048,
1.1240688562,
0.486250937,
-0.2961404324,
0.1053526476,
0.0747549683,
0.6743763089,
-0.4444046617,
0.8504585028,
0.9207211733,
0.4794001281,
-0.2565047741,
-1.209217906,
-0.2643198669,
-0.5310689807,
0.4324384928,
0.0002777268,
-0.6986246705,
1.2364652157,
-0.1094450429,
-0.4830879271,
0.5177218914,
0.8389335275,
0.1776932925,
0.2474363744,
-0.0887315869,
0.5215455294,
0.4945534468,
0.1262715906,
1.3956756592,
-0.2242224067,
0.1322313845,
0.9459398985,
-0.2350807935,
0.9361506104,
0.0747429207,
-0.1863860041,
1.0115827322,
0.274389416,
0.483091712,
0.3895375729,
-0.2136342525,
-0.3859659731,
-0.0781458393,
-0.1515682936,
-0.4001069665,
0.6825090051,
0.4719947278,
-0.2376438081,
-0.2612590194,
0.0399959087,
0.2792648375,
0.3543230295,
-0.791795373,
0.410220623,
0.0999886021,
-0.5586923361,
0.6873174906,
0.1705268323,
0.2440402806,
-0.7519590855,
-0.3293953836,
-0.6307657361,
0.3596563041,
0.0184719339,
-0.6076264381,
0.2139614671,
0.1149000674,
-0.2364863902,
-0.13755849,
0.6872617602,
-0.3051346838,
-0.4876838624,
0.2261493653,
0.1028127745,
0.1781686097,
0.4737637043,
-0.342053324,
0.3184551895,
-0.1598401517,
0.1048916802,
0.2729852498,
0.2305685282,
-0.2955596149,
0.8958929181,
0.2354802191,
0.0198693704,
-0.2863054872,
-0.1851612478,
0.6281905174,
-0.787078023,
-0.6601772308,
-0.9087196589,
0.5727242231,
-0.081365861,
-0.5427579284,
0.9913068414,
0.5168557763,
0.7124730349,
-0.196451813,
0.8736290932,
-0.0851642042,
0.4880030155,
-0.540222466,
1.1771684885,
-0.3258527517,
0.2586471736,
-0.4955672622,
-0.7258934379,
-0.0064898715,
0.6398741603,
-0.131817624,
0.0682909712,
0.8160247207,
0.1873073429,
-0.005750386,
0.2115320712,
0.4349239767,
0.2356707454,
0.1597162187,
0.6043659449,
0.6848234534,
-0.73205024,
-0.0636123866,
0.100254491,
-0.1856389791,
-0.2394077033,
-0.8238574862,
-1.052947998,
-0.5143882632,
-0.0100762052,
-0.0572310388,
0.2748040855,
0.7799005508,
0.2926924229,
-1.1175075769,
-0.6182150245,
0.0173004624,
0.3189678788,
-0.1511280537,
-0.2036829889,
0.1052759811,
-0.1125248,
-0.7927430868,
0.6632460952,
0.4119304717,
-0.0622004829,
-0.3316086531,
-0.1685813367,
-0.3774950802,
0.343729943,
0.6402789354,
0.8334174156,
-0.6053590775,
-0.3110850751,
-0.4147387147,
0.0514305085,
0.1944157928,
0.9003804326,
-0.8437470794,
0.5488618016,
0.5788792372,
0.515871346,
0.2410691977,
-0.1664835811,
1.1452103853,
-0.3771569431,
0.0570827909,
0.5406828523,
0.5919288397,
0.655275166,
-0.0439196192,
0.4751709998,
0.3031898141,
-0.5396154523,
-1.1192142963,
0.445559442,
-0.6199164391,
-0.1844764948,
0.7163461447,
-0.1732506305,
-0.1066907346,
-0.3275117278,
0.075960286,
0.0922397673,
-0.2009885609,
0.4890392125,
0.6228970885,
-0.1732395142,
-0.5776275396,
-0.6828762889,
0.5792198777,
-0.0249178465,
-0.7534426451,
-0.071115762,
0.4407411516,
0.1214039996,
0.1077189744,
0.7556338906,
-0.0969734862,
0.5880442262,
0.2305502594,
0.3413442373,
0.1211342067,
-0.6279799342,
-0.3734490275,
-0.0615184791,
0.2528448403,
0.3606070578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18120v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18120v2
|
Exploring Multilingual Concepts of Human Value in Large Language Models: Is Value Alignment Consistent, Transferable and Controllable across Languages?
| 2024-02-28T07:18:39 | 2024-04-16T07:29:36 |
Shaoyang Xu, Weilong Dong, Zishan Guo, Xinwei Wu, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior research in representation engineering has revealed that LLMs encode
concepts within their representation spaces, predominantly centered around
English. In this study, we extend this philosophy to a multilingual scenario,
delving into multilingual human value concepts in LLMs. Through our
comprehensive exploration covering 7 types of human values, 16 languages and 3
LLM series with distinct multilinguality, we empirically substantiate the
existence of multilingual human values in LLMs. Further cross-lingual analysis
on these concepts discloses 3 traits arising from language resource
disparities: cross-lingual inconsistency, distorted linguistic relationships,
and unidirectional cross-lingual transfer between high- and low-resource
languages, all in terms of human value concepts. Additionally, we validate the
feasibility of cross-lingual control over value alignment capabilities of LLMs,
leveraging the dominant language as a source language. Drawing from our
findings on multilingual value alignment, we prudently provide suggestions on
the composition of multilingual data for LLMs pre-training: including a limited
number of dominant languages for cross-lingual alignment transfer while
avoiding their excessive prevalence, and keeping a balanced distribution of
non-dominant languages. We aspire that our findings would contribute to
enhancing the safety and utility of multilingual AI.
|
[
-0.2831164002,
-0.1445101202,
0.2879785299,
0.3343726695,
0.0954364985,
0.5255654454,
-0.1487578303,
-0.8851388097,
0.4276990891,
0.1624358743,
-0.2996641099,
-0.0217136946,
-0.6154311895,
0.0290672984,
0.1669611186,
0.5168604851,
-0.4215984643,
0.4591615498,
-0.1322665215,
-0.6343827844,
-0.4690357149,
-1.1212580204,
-0.223838836,
-0.3789255619,
0.7150692344,
0.2630125582,
0.8635649085,
0.4470108747,
0.5127752423,
0.2052135617,
-0.1321266592,
0.0316378586,
-0.3016563952,
-0.1768398583,
-0.3750506341,
-0.3218561709,
-0.746905148,
0.2458463609,
0.7596301436,
0.9117738605,
-0.0538372025,
0.0945171192,
0.0953415036,
0.6765701175,
-0.5720131993,
0.2051074207,
-0.3610343933,
0.1340198517,
-0.2878016531,
-0.1047421694,
-0.2444154322,
-0.3280544281,
-0.1247012466,
-0.5180931091,
-0.3104605675,
0.0242063478,
1.1080788374,
0.2407923341,
-0.6413320899,
-0.140422374,
-0.404622376,
0.9458910227,
-0.4308550358,
0.7251954675,
0.2229191512,
0.2610431015,
0.3031877279,
-0.0578313991,
-0.4639793336,
-0.0692567825,
-0.2371576577,
0.1281340271,
0.2927512527,
0.0916904137,
0.0160369631,
0.1995569766,
-0.3639916778,
0.4941722453,
-0.2103435695,
-0.4052691758,
0.9318423867,
0.1438378692,
0.4404112399,
0.0636058077,
-0.3151739836,
-0.3023276031,
-1.0109834671,
0.2158838809,
0.5316759944,
0.4021030962,
-0.14356713,
0.5886870027,
0.3129586577,
0.4187356532,
-0.3341416717,
-0.4849750102,
0.406262368,
-0.5940807462,
0.1145890355,
0.1874310374,
0.5496057868,
0.2665262222,
0.6484925151,
-0.2611284554,
-0.0519967489,
-0.0807871148,
0.1715067625,
-0.6715758443,
0.2847470641,
-0.1684752852,
-0.5829903483,
-0.0837179571,
-0.1341775805,
-0.4793086648,
-0.3443593085,
-0.5787923932,
0.0353890546,
-0.2397258133,
-0.597647965,
0.1541350037,
0.1198887229,
0.3989801705,
0.2104943544,
-1.2232052088,
0.0303495638,
0.3619455099,
0.6044135094,
-0.5094448924,
-0.7961078882,
-0.0162369702,
0.2517077625,
-0.3378916979,
0.5799241066,
-0.4795096219,
-0.4776518047,
-0.0523256846,
0.0888677984,
-0.0296082757,
-0.5126712918,
0.1243598387,
-0.6877931356,
0.0640690029,
-0.4421446025,
-0.3065283895,
-0.0591755547,
0.2516025007,
-0.7963522673,
0.8486189246,
0.120313324,
-0.5320933461,
0.5231199265,
-0.67184937,
-0.5744402409,
-0.1011878178,
-0.5300419927,
-0.1057524979,
0.0171951763,
-0.1915988177,
0.3223084211,
-0.3316866457,
0.2989320755,
-0.3106901348,
-0.073834762,
0.4027681053,
-0.6161741614,
0.773786962,
0.1269340962,
-0.2389519811,
0.004342868,
-0.6022311449,
0.1560121924,
0.0955631211,
-0.4715259373,
-0.2379507273,
-0.1870577484,
0.2172321379,
0.5393410325,
0.4598528445,
-0.4533819258,
0.2758581042,
-0.0966232941,
0.1873262525,
0.8535758257,
-0.3023369908,
0.6940677762,
-0.2364204377,
0.7486876249,
0.1199440956,
-0.0426242799,
0.1367501318,
-0.3274808824,
-0.5026812553,
-0.2809510231,
0.0738306642,
0.7988996506,
-0.4283511043,
0.1843964607,
-0.2249674201,
-0.0472076274,
-0.8794937134,
0.2370395809,
0.3500444889,
0.2116655409,
0.3742268085,
0.0882159993,
-0.5445557833,
-1.2241829634,
-0.2654713094,
-0.248817578,
0.0901847929,
0.0983473212,
0.2527766824,
-0.340819478,
0.8007722497,
-0.295828402,
-0.0232090689,
-0.1286464036,
0.1253964007,
0.0678934082,
0.3775719404,
0.5463238955,
-0.9165396094,
-0.4841439426,
0.3979716599,
-0.8954032063,
-0.1182258949,
-0.146904543,
-0.1785402298,
0.4490224719,
0.3723559976,
-0.2818152308,
0.1929180771,
0.6493350863,
-0.1753326356,
0.4115608335,
-0.2182719558,
0.3653302789,
-1.2435604334,
0.1979530901,
-0.1038744822,
-0.0320191495,
-0.3284681439,
0.0717839599,
0.3255248666,
0.1073688343,
-0.6631919146,
0.7974278331,
-0.687931478,
-0.2875691354,
-0.2214176208,
-0.0456293859,
0.1136200354,
0.2645494938,
0.2864861786,
1.0001901388,
0.1690570414,
-0.4626801312,
0.4890041351,
0.1879711151,
-0.1166311651,
1.0679703951,
-0.4274616838,
-0.0462256297,
-0.1160204038,
-0.2462200522,
-0.668397963,
0.0199474934,
-0.0437305644,
-0.396096319,
0.560426116,
-0.1143017411,
-0.5119304657,
0.2371477336,
-0.0412080027,
0.699203372,
0.276533246,
-0.2467683852,
0.3517507911,
0.8590323329,
-0.358502835,
-0.8382126093,
-0.84978652,
0.1784071028,
-0.3776865602,
-0.7343589664,
0.3534384966,
-0.1714614183,
-0.4352255762,
-0.0489041992,
0.1561301798,
-0.2361541688,
0.2174604088,
-0.0091313133,
0.5166070461,
-0.1733188629,
0.3438667953,
-0.0744497329,
-0.3243766129,
0.009352332,
-0.3261830211,
0.1020783186,
-0.2670069933,
-0.7320438027,
-0.1016389281,
0.4850983918,
0.741522789,
-0.20819287,
0.6936006546,
0.5907185078,
-0.5073055625,
0.3009772897,
-0.4917759597,
0.0887138546,
-0.4142628908,
0.5148236752,
-0.5049641132,
-0.9724222422,
0.6836643219,
0.0449767634,
0.1274223179,
0.4261487424,
0.6244883537,
-0.2474126667,
1.0670711994,
0.7888833284,
-0.4437099695,
0.2499964535,
-0.041746214,
0.1758238077,
-0.7216051817,
-0.3868120611,
-0.4338864684,
-0.559248507,
-0.6637071371,
-0.3743516207,
0.4386553168,
0.2291930467,
-0.4321727455,
0.076591,
-0.2809633911,
0.4249182045,
0.2347334474,
-0.4133945704,
0.2946996093,
-0.1210292205,
-0.1177511662,
-0.4737355709,
-0.5936865211,
-0.7483488321,
0.79380548,
0.4946769178,
1.0728176832,
0.3396981955,
0.5264610648,
0.0893404409,
0.3986892104,
-0.8823700547,
0.1062371656,
0.1160047427,
-0.6940187216,
-0.5228418708,
-0.3411212564,
-0.9093213081,
0.3797725141,
-0.0943780839,
-0.5954195857,
0.1756310165,
0.0398192182,
-0.1688995808,
0.50997895,
-0.6450667381,
1.0137467384,
-1.0109268427,
-0.3123086393,
-0.2688325942,
-0.7569485903,
0.2070911229,
-0.1883604676,
0.5109431744,
-0.1629852355,
-0.1225761995,
0.5131440759,
-0.0563814677,
0.7967164516,
0.0478643849,
-0.581115365,
0.00009799,
-0.0256292392,
0.1611972004,
0.0691403076,
-0.1287151277,
0.3900761306,
0.118474476,
-0.694150269,
-0.3475899398,
0.5852960944,
-1.136493206,
-0.4708577991,
-0.4809417129,
-0.7498704195,
-0.2823039293,
0.3215634227,
0.1315406412,
-0.0443597883,
-0.3346176445,
-0.1438244581,
0.6997662783,
-0.3414583504,
0.3182259798,
0.2873974442,
-0.1430805176,
-0.4012365043,
1.0307426453,
0.2383558899,
0.666927278,
0.7629901171,
0.0176347569,
-0.6061849594,
-0.2788477242,
-0.6834165454,
0.302477926,
-0.8978439569,
-0.0707356781,
-0.3265008926,
-0.2136663944,
-0.3597203195,
-0.4805541039,
-0.5493998528,
-0.2994376123,
-0.3152583539,
-0.2453733981,
0.1896359175,
0.7325436473,
0.0201417729,
-0.0930388272,
-1.1339352131,
0.182738021,
0.2206310928,
0.5041539669,
-0.3012651205,
-0.4711704254,
-0.5618219972,
0.4201835692,
-0.2506641746,
-0.6961976886,
0.4340145588,
-0.0748496354,
1.0911916494,
0.2040802091,
-0.1911366731,
0.6709681153,
-0.3980869651,
0.6975155473,
0.3404824138,
-1.0046015978,
0.1030316651,
0.0292362273,
0.0335387178,
0.5462736487,
0.4935578406,
-0.9202101231,
0.0829791427,
-0.429417491,
-0.5896517038,
0.5198013186,
-0.2103467733,
0.178778559,
0.2116451263,
0.1384071112,
0.0908892527,
0.208923623,
-0.9251218438,
-0.1935962141,
-0.409481585,
-0.2083168179,
-0.2238742113,
-0.095640175,
-0.2322312444,
-0.1046969071,
0.3769882619,
-0.2936504781,
0.0278817546,
-0.2112861872,
-0.5098318458,
-0.0980740264,
0.5597023964,
0.9382860661,
0.8496223688,
-0.0987261087,
0.4116745591,
0.4035909474,
-0.1806153506,
0.7750533819,
-0.1558278501,
0.3399496078,
-0.2510072887,
0.3518975973,
0.7397574186,
0.1481750906,
-0.569862783,
0.4270702302,
0.250290364,
-0.0261907298,
-0.2274755388,
-0.4549415708,
0.4339081049,
0.0772450566,
0.1692517102,
-0.0642389879,
-0.2533729672,
-0.565001905,
-0.0609760359,
0.3943029046,
-0.3685083091,
-0.6079022288,
0.5872088671,
0.328070879,
-0.0824314356,
0.6107028723,
-0.277682513,
-0.5311513543,
0.3977950811,
0.2794022262,
0.7309622169,
-0.2194081247,
-0.0523778535,
0.0668560639,
0.5189383626,
0.0243812185,
0.3279646039,
0.3657615781,
-1.2404828072,
-0.6261199117,
-0.5157065988,
-0.4856153131,
-0.1983437538,
-0.5682702065,
0.3085905612,
-0.0033078399,
0.0307837576,
-0.11823906,
-0.2848425508,
-0.5865551829,
-0.0788144693,
0.4196153879,
0.6703785658,
-0.9307732582,
1.0054690838,
0.9482491612,
-0.5676627159,
-0.85224545,
-0.3804838955,
0.1743641198,
-1.070483923,
1.2415094376,
-0.0653978512,
-0.4037559628,
-0.2260812968,
-0.0271251146,
-0.841447711,
1.2093176842,
0.7518908978,
-0.2722541392,
-0.2689346075,
0.6855049133,
0.4315319359,
-0.3120744526,
0.1892380267,
0.5017185211,
0.6312234998,
0.0191177782,
-1.2869955301,
-0.2229757905,
-0.2521600425,
0.1748015136,
0.3149723411,
-0.6937098503,
0.7373079658,
-0.1588017792,
-0.1751137972,
-0.3785477579,
0.3819760084,
0.346599251,
0.0445200577,
0.1667031646,
0.5093966126,
0.8399122953,
0.1822032928,
0.8907673359,
-0.5992087126,
0.2308308482,
0.6370961666,
-0.587236464,
0.4790685773,
0.7238889933,
-0.4320609868,
0.2122472525,
0.7461640239,
0.461217016,
0.2535782754,
0.2038114965,
-0.1243632883,
-0.2673008442,
-0.3129040003,
-0.5010105968,
0.4486756325,
0.2750252187,
-0.0889539346,
0.0141873118,
0.0736636668,
0.1226739958,
0.1063464731,
-0.1191079393,
0.6756193638,
0.2065588087,
-0.4398559332,
0.8959597945,
-0.1178097874,
0.8175073266,
-0.62286973,
-0.0296704937,
-0.1330435127,
0.130918026,
-0.1296235472,
-1.0438073874,
0.4559096396,
-0.3492339253,
-0.2970713973,
-1.0252250433,
0.4062023461,
-0.6041388512,
-0.3816290498,
0.4412615597,
0.7285397649,
0.1459823251,
0.0419318192,
-0.5327369571,
-0.0680372268,
-0.0706829205,
0.1010855138,
0.6698625088,
0.5196244717,
-0.3901311755,
0.6613360047,
0.3107717633,
0.4728173912,
0.065975152,
0.1368941218,
0.6217737794,
-0.7870870829,
-0.3980150819,
-0.8445221782,
0.5748383999,
0.0861617699,
-0.3863587677,
0.4977890551,
0.509711504,
1.2101355791,
0.0659178123,
0.9777907133,
0.1882902682,
0.240917623,
-0.6543444395,
0.7955728173,
-0.5314832926,
0.1314861774,
-0.3060946465,
-0.7456246018,
-0.247959584,
0.7311742306,
-0.0006547552,
-0.0942725018,
0.6070293784,
0.5039690137,
0.0913504884,
-0.3242420554,
0.5081298351,
-0.3841265738,
0.5414195657,
0.4990470707,
1.1753066778,
-0.1245452389,
0.269854188,
-0.0104278419,
-0.2048269063,
-0.245321691,
-0.9733091593,
-0.4664906859,
-0.5290699601,
-0.1189494431,
-0.1853370667,
-0.332074672,
1.1383920908,
0.7490170002,
-0.7959192991,
-0.8672986031,
0.3797501326,
0.2422250658,
-0.0915927961,
-0.1637961119,
0.1671843231,
-0.3851757348,
-0.6892032027,
0.2139894664,
0.48828125,
0.4334875941,
-0.5875070691,
-0.5975388885,
-0.2730573714,
-0.2207549065,
0.7214258909,
0.3842642605,
-0.7279578447,
-0.5416519046,
0.3726870418,
-0.5330286622,
0.289442867,
0.9673561454,
-0.2297321707,
0.3662776053,
0.4574822783,
1.0678870678,
0.2157381624,
-0.2262473106,
0.5941257477,
-0.7762352824,
0.4297666848,
0.3951489031,
0.6943918467,
0.4042203426,
-0.4401736856,
0.384368211,
0.4358818531,
-0.4367451072,
-0.598087132,
0.5384252667,
-0.8046948314,
-0.1587368846,
1.0241934061,
-0.0852944776,
0.3457036316,
0.0021850418,
-0.1863334328,
0.258128643,
-0.1013574526,
0.6178407669,
0.9609920382,
-0.3419515789,
-0.3418509066,
-0.525138557,
0.3160440922,
0.4344337583,
-1.0629671812,
0.0321350358,
0.5090007782,
0.1422547251,
0.3757800162,
0.533290863,
-0.3089275062,
0.0386443101,
-0.3333323896,
0.6998903751,
0.0851592794,
-0.1848136485,
-0.3133512437,
-0.1165688857,
0.5586435199,
-0.2176173031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18115v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18115v2
|
UniVS: Unified and Universal Video Segmentation with Prompts as Queries
| 2024-02-28T07:05:27 | 2024-06-10T10:52:54 |
Minghan Li, Shuai Li, Xindong Zhang, Lei Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite the recent advances in unified image segmentation (IS), developing a
unified video segmentation (VS) model remains a challenge. This is mainly
because generic category-specified VS tasks need to detect all objects and
track them across consecutive frames, while prompt-guided VS tasks require
re-identifying the target with visual/text prompts throughout the entire video,
making it hard to handle the different tasks with the same architecture. We
make an attempt to address these issues and present a novel unified VS
architecture, namely UniVS, by using prompts as queries. UniVS averages the
prompt features of the target from previous frames as its initial query to
explicitly decode masks, and introduces a target-wise prompt cross-attention
layer in the mask decoder to integrate prompt features in the memory pool. By
taking the predicted masks of entities from previous frames as their visual
prompts, UniVS converts different VS tasks into prompt-guided target
segmentation, eliminating the heuristic inter-frame matching process. Our
framework not only unifies the different VS tasks but also naturally achieves
universal training and testing, ensuring robust performance across different
scenarios. UniVS shows a commendable balance between performance and
universality on 10 challenging VS benchmarks, covering video instance,
semantic, panoptic, object, and referring segmentation tasks. Code can be found
at \url{https://github.com/MinghanLi/UniVS}.
|
[
-0.2938175499,
-0.4104182422,
0.4375640154,
0.2636584044,
-0.6302556396,
0.1394850016,
0.0892883614,
-0.0897845477,
-0.0539764799,
0.578666985,
-0.8286870122,
-0.5200850964,
-0.1150477529,
0.0889873356,
-0.2480431497,
0.5784075856,
0.1604876965,
0.3001247942,
-0.4444210529,
-0.4647698998,
-0.769892931,
-0.4437250495,
-0.3987763524,
-0.0437639989,
0.0689279214,
0.5018855929,
0.1105853766,
0.537297368,
0.1580930799,
0.3636279106,
-0.0031069121,
0.3148074746,
0.0272446517,
0.4452865422,
-0.0791733712,
-0.0716275945,
0.5710544586,
-0.329749614,
0.7680106759,
0.6443142295,
0.1250102222,
0.2518672645,
0.1694434285,
0.6320642829,
-0.7804008126,
-0.3108552396,
-0.4524629116,
0.256133616,
-0.0980824977,
-0.222563982,
-0.297524929,
0.3358211815,
0.0937575251,
-0.6629239917,
0.4284190834,
-0.0585389361,
0.6505632401,
0.4732073545,
-0.3940253556,
0.4744401872,
-0.60483706,
0.5195035934,
0.2513001859,
0.6345279217,
-0.4433756471,
0.4701751769,
-0.1776811182,
-0.860522449,
-0.0217437018,
-0.1860689968,
0.2117576301,
-0.1141731888,
-0.6220098734,
0.2149356604,
0.1698871851,
0.1495165825,
-0.7589964867,
0.21596919,
-0.2512595356,
-0.3506611586,
0.3568030298,
0.3785186112,
0.4557491839,
-0.3374162018,
-0.9707348943,
-0.0408227257,
-0.3694056571,
0.7722001672,
0.0233642124,
-0.000288564,
0.3123753667,
0.3566598594,
-0.6550887823,
0.5843120813,
0.0467745066,
0.2196181118,
-0.1077831164,
-0.0365319736,
-0.4549488425,
-0.1260899156,
0.9391835928,
0.5782259703,
0.296689719,
-0.2115392536,
-0.0510903969,
0.304687202,
0.3116080463,
-0.8127720356,
-0.3097132146,
-0.0383283235,
-0.141582191,
0.0470688045,
0.302619338,
-0.8118734956,
-0.2414265871,
-0.3594279289,
0.2381975502,
-0.2390614152,
0.1738591939,
0.0447592698,
-0.2632741332,
0.2671138048,
0.4976841211,
-0.6640250683,
0.2842350006,
0.2849424779,
0.4426693022,
-0.4640493393,
-0.0926190466,
-0.9566381574,
-0.0954055265,
-0.0465376154,
1.2724305391,
-0.6977174878,
-0.4657613039,
0.0477028079,
0.2050853223,
-0.1813731194,
-0.3260589838,
0.4521579742,
-0.3333655894,
0.1625674963,
-0.486299634,
-0.3107611835,
-0.1874025315,
0.2443009317,
-0.3347136676,
1.1514896154,
-0.0383471549,
-0.431842804,
0.1992060095,
-0.8064225316,
-0.0490058362,
0.4275587797,
-0.5466132164,
-0.0582118407,
0.1770753264,
0.6192412972,
0.3761416078,
-0.4537444115,
0.3568601012,
-0.0888283923,
-0.3932240605,
0.176997155,
-0.7135096192,
0.7637289762,
0.293754369,
-0.3148802519,
0.6969640255,
-0.8401928544,
0.1351531893,
-0.0400085896,
0.149391368,
-0.178860575,
-0.3613115847,
0.142273739,
-0.2017337829,
-0.1206181273,
-0.7278340459,
0.3637001812,
0.4977554083,
0.1778894663,
0.6956386566,
0.1665046513,
0.5639747381,
0.5191437602,
0.6500596404,
-0.0623938516,
0.4937610328,
-0.4673122168,
-0.644606173,
-0.2578092813,
-0.3903340101,
0.1151026785,
0.4890904427,
-0.537312746,
0.1576994359,
0.1550448388,
-0.0532205999,
-0.1415182203,
0.1113144532,
0.4758370519,
0.6893934011,
0.27028054,
-0.4454833865,
-0.8301767111,
-0.5922438502,
0.0549625084,
-0.1103083268,
-0.5184529424,
0.0792768151,
0.1804989874,
-0.2332658321,
0.9573872685,
-0.7229240537,
-0.3698598146,
-0.1814034134,
0.0273601785,
-0.3008671105,
0.4102539718,
0.3358337581,
-0.93534863,
-0.340834558,
-0.2530598044,
-1.0018905401,
-0.0381131172,
-0.1624801606,
-0.0420993753,
-0.1810018569,
0.8131765723,
-0.606369257,
0.5608949661,
-0.1861671358,
-0.6375555396,
0.5475745797,
-0.3594383001,
0.3699742854,
-0.9145349264,
0.0227303002,
0.2729281783,
-0.0567526408,
-0.3823848665,
0.1831894368,
-0.1196262613,
-0.2903463244,
-0.5830308199,
0.3961778581,
-0.6802887917,
-0.3884011507,
0.0744674429,
-0.1220492423,
0.2964416146,
0.5400505066,
-0.1697595567,
0.6753931046,
0.9739899039,
-0.699717164,
0.7250103951,
0.2253966779,
-0.2450639457,
1.0595653057,
-0.7363101244,
-0.0490871333,
-0.1862460673,
0.1447726637,
-1.2837656736,
-0.3838849664,
0.2585920095,
-0.5015067458,
0.1157607213,
-0.233207196,
-0.162262395,
-0.5244141817,
-0.3297013938,
0.4311040044,
0.5518013239,
-0.8689795732,
0.4842481017,
0.284160316,
0.471380204,
-0.5932590365,
-0.1877096891,
0.1197100729,
-0.3103231788,
-0.6939195991,
0.2820526361,
-0.3029312491,
-0.0657422245,
0.1683500707,
-0.3661829233,
-0.3259109259,
0.1341292858,
0.5841680765,
0.3583529592,
-0.3006921411,
-0.1975506395,
-0.0297934469,
-0.2275493592,
-0.0013094407,
-0.5223223567,
0.2174582034,
-0.083079569,
-0.2786378562,
-0.6334832311,
0.7059012055,
0.6028133631,
-0.5616340637,
-0.1282695532,
0.8166621327,
-0.3144105375,
-0.0774713606,
-0.5883862376,
0.0498814471,
-0.4782645106,
0.3175517321,
-0.3855306506,
-0.9600135684,
0.5589657426,
-0.1447343081,
-0.1288663894,
0.3224628568,
-0.0064970595,
-0.2614130378,
1.1884580851,
0.6380967498,
0.0508779362,
0.5617473722,
-0.3295243979,
-0.4297614694,
-1.0672175884,
-0.7517910004,
-0.4352052212,
-0.1711619794,
-0.082590431,
-0.414921701,
0.465978235,
0.2954087555,
-0.2025518864,
0.1810935885,
-0.9775221348,
0.9619510174,
0.579774797,
-0.1796710789,
0.1399013102,
0.282941401,
-0.2537734807,
-0.0523058064,
-0.3829512298,
-0.2328287065,
0.8095043898,
-0.1273591518,
0.7718946934,
-0.3633986413,
0.3955897987,
0.60650599,
-0.1426687092,
-0.4067019522,
0.9088536501,
-0.134154886,
-0.2915050685,
-0.4346780479,
-0.1464290917,
-1.3029493093,
0.4648472071,
0.0248214379,
-1.3673098087,
0.180580318,
-0.0080945008,
-0.7635000348,
0.6067370176,
-0.4601419866,
1.2143335342,
-0.1674197018,
-0.1329009533,
0.3516525924,
-0.9553812742,
0.1357150227,
0.6007636189,
-0.3651086092,
-0.0864867046,
0.1057837903,
0.7660090327,
-0.1485558599,
0.694542706,
-0.2248277664,
0.4318898618,
0.7403539419,
-0.1348422319,
0.0068386099,
0.3355539739,
0.5582991242,
-0.0348879322,
0.0016945921,
-0.2286184132,
-0.5722910166,
0.4254906476,
-0.4880278111,
-0.5822514892,
-0.3787266016,
-0.3353449106,
-0.0352928415,
0.1635827571,
0.5321151018,
0.8117955923,
-0.6336274743,
0.1428471357,
1.0332098007,
0.1309111416,
0.7673921585,
0.429379642,
-0.0547662377,
-0.4703858197,
0.7218393087,
-0.3955601752,
-0.2362094671,
0.5414792895,
-0.0945584103,
-0.6837226152,
-0.4158708453,
-1.0366636515,
-0.3563740551,
-0.5833218098,
-0.489787966,
-0.5915926695,
0.1471152604,
-0.5134861469,
-0.0599232987,
-0.3576647937,
0.0467996672,
-0.6640633941,
-0.1328570396,
0.2634143531,
0.6762286425,
-0.2136939466,
0.3228870034,
-0.8753672838,
0.61508286,
0.7617327571,
0.2045207173,
-0.6260820031,
-0.5847997665,
0.2952626348,
-0.3126470149,
-0.4264244735,
-0.8675500751,
0.1171490178,
-0.0952108726,
0.6922021508,
0.6648942828,
0.1013661325,
0.7164462805,
-0.4552012086,
0.8440476656,
0.5068782568,
-0.6406531334,
0.3338936269,
-0.1442019343,
0.3524535298,
0.8170421124,
0.2967957854,
-0.5388692021,
0.2443749458,
-0.4240835309,
-0.6494820118,
0.6790466309,
-0.0794043541,
0.0760905221,
0.1866772324,
0.0971350297,
-0.1101921126,
-0.1222196296,
-0.304215759,
-0.4435500503,
-0.101520963,
0.0384315215,
0.1739498079,
-0.3190197051,
-0.0160073414,
-0.3375723064,
0.1038683131,
-0.1893358529,
0.1391415745,
0.3855653405,
-0.2445297241,
-0.2954562306,
0.4228187203,
0.2366129905,
0.160772711,
-0.2824632525,
0.0253422856,
-0.0968886241,
-0.3323341012,
0.5534439087,
0.3164935112,
-0.4323080182,
0.2289966643,
-0.1351480782,
0.8957667947,
0.457662195,
-0.6586126685,
0.5125733018,
-0.3037444949,
-0.1603111178,
-0.1168304011,
0.0581957214,
-0.4029321373,
0.4935854375,
0.6828371882,
0.3274039328,
0.4078892469,
-0.480651468,
0.5438911915,
0.5379667282,
-0.589432478,
-0.4072403312,
0.9175991416,
0.466843456,
-0.4437965751,
0.6722708344,
-0.5193526149,
-0.6521024704,
0.5331627131,
0.302318871,
1.1282317638,
-0.5128790736,
0.8134927154,
0.2914273441,
0.0913842693,
-0.0950425118,
0.3046958745,
-0.4509779513,
-0.3240547478,
-0.2135635465,
-0.4616454244,
-0.3951355219,
0.0888789892,
-0.8889770508,
-0.0507152677,
-0.2049185783,
0.2244232595,
-0.1339179724,
-0.319327414,
-0.7506273985,
0.461854279,
0.2893936932,
0.6432371736,
-0.6992684603,
0.4456248879,
0.9612345695,
-0.4150212407,
-0.6653941274,
-0.3942079246,
0.0402552299,
-0.6627078652,
0.3560914993,
0.6407318711,
0.1944054663,
-0.1204664335,
-0.4994859099,
-0.720025897,
0.8990688324,
0.4232956469,
-0.2486563623,
-0.2137659639,
0.1812832952,
0.1571384519,
-0.5325281024,
0.1904275268,
0.5460372567,
0.1558888406,
0.4673517644,
-0.2844795585,
-0.0293190237,
-0.2587891519,
-0.1148139983,
0.2156163156,
-0.3700267375,
0.7888926864,
-0.5483582616,
-0.3129958808,
0.2739778459,
0.887614727,
0.0549059063,
0.6780384779,
0.6936158538,
0.6491456628,
0.6754049063,
-0.0618645698,
0.7314826846,
0.1581745297,
-0.1367413998,
0.7907597423,
0.0069270651,
0.2396059483,
0.3394306898,
-0.1442736387,
0.525144577,
0.672866106,
-0.2232476771,
0.5513957143,
0.1377326399,
-0.3355824351,
-0.6998817921,
-0.5307894349,
-0.2999845743,
0.638348341,
-0.0521047339,
0.1911741048,
-0.4453808665,
0.3614756167,
-0.404782176,
0.0432642438,
-0.5369083285,
0.6622804999,
-0.1931895614,
-0.8344668746,
0.3321749568,
-0.3064893782,
0.5192427039,
-0.6918171644,
-0.1297292858,
-0.4023689926,
-0.086224027,
0.0381460674,
-0.741363287,
-0.172807157,
0.3877438903,
0.0571777523,
-0.0142246485,
0.5709879398,
-0.2383438796,
-0.3317970634,
0.0927031338,
0.2429146469,
0.2679477036,
-0.6593852639,
-0.6751892567,
0.1668464094,
0.4424350262,
-0.1978388578,
0.4430102408,
0.7144667506,
-0.2889312506,
0.4937433302,
0.6161144972,
-0.5883029699,
-0.0310462713,
0.202740401,
0.9324134588,
-0.71344769,
-0.4813804328,
-0.6276929379,
0.9092389941,
-0.1615972668,
-0.5685178638,
0.7015784383,
0.454233259,
0.7454981208,
-0.0606585592,
0.290368557,
0.2604039311,
-0.2502838373,
-0.339907974,
0.0211065728,
-0.6060273051,
0.1038504019,
-0.3730356991,
-0.8913733959,
-0.3860032856,
0.1862682402,
0.3525651097,
-0.3776176274,
0.5523881912,
0.4435578883,
-0.0391786806,
-0.0879013687,
0.5721037388,
-0.4844110012,
0.2558750212,
0.3492206931,
0.9342659116,
-0.2155244201,
0.8984979391,
-0.253886342,
-0.1665836871,
-0.1213028729,
-0.5651926994,
-0.8433040977,
-0.5484362841,
-0.4172923565,
0.0388390832,
0.0758593231,
0.7853789926,
0.7009646297,
-0.6725715399,
-0.1202210411,
-0.1261043996,
0.1937370449,
-0.0326683708,
-0.1621657163,
0.3167640269,
-0.2368467748,
-0.5996505618,
0.7744061947,
0.630982399,
0.0097453874,
-0.226970017,
0.0631623939,
0.1434946656,
-0.0887375921,
0.4157361984,
0.9211508632,
-0.5883534551,
-0.2072972506,
0.2642839253,
0.1581300795,
0.2024800181,
1.0967383385,
-1.0131107569,
0.5948650241,
0.2920766771,
0.7040796876,
0.3002223372,
0.2336013466,
0.171690017,
-0.8737308979,
0.1832114607,
0.0096714906,
0.7264208198,
0.5745021701,
-0.3347347975,
0.5675079226,
0.5219575167,
-0.4123126566,
-0.9831261039,
0.2949690819,
-1.2920974493,
-0.3710790277,
0.9241831899,
-0.0223517139,
-0.4131260812,
-0.1011193246,
-0.5272120237,
0.2044641674,
-0.5523216724,
0.3223814368,
-0.1941824853,
-0.3221330643,
-0.0413625911,
0.0349240564,
0.3533125222,
0.455347389,
-0.6081594229,
-0.0286731385,
0.6394064426,
0.3677661717,
-0.0382628627,
0.7276204824,
0.1487728506,
0.5635164976,
-0.0697105452,
0.1364957094,
-0.3175285757,
-0.8076190948,
-0.4281820357,
0.3903534114,
-0.5071787834,
-1.0783907175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18113v1
|
Small But Funny: A Feedback-Driven Approach to Humor Distillation
| 2024-02-28T07:02:38 | 2024-02-28T07:02:38 |
Sahithya Ravi, Patrick Huber, Akshat Shrivastava, Aditya Sagar, Ahmed Aly, Vered Shwartz, Arash Einolghozati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought to light promising
language generation capabilities, particularly in performing tasks like complex
reasoning and creative writing. Consequently, distillation through imitation of
teacher responses has emerged as a popular technique to transfer knowledge from
LLMs to more accessible, Small Language Models (SLMs). While this works well
for simpler tasks, there is a substantial performance gap on tasks requiring
intricate language comprehension and creativity, such as humor generation. We
hypothesize that this gap may stem from the fact that creative tasks might be
hard to learn by imitation alone and explore whether an approach, involving
supplementary guidance from the teacher, could yield higher performance. To
address this, we study the effect of assigning a dual role to the LLM - as a
"teacher" generating data, as well as a "critic" evaluating the student's
performance. Our experiments on humor generation reveal that the incorporation
of feedback significantly narrows the performance gap between SLMs and their
larger counterparts compared to merely relying on imitation. As a result, our
research highlights the potential of using feedback as an additional dimension
to data when transferring complex language abilities via distillation.
|
[
-0.1994434595,
-0.851627171,
0.713866353,
0.3815593123,
-0.3028473258,
0.1532369256,
-0.4394295514,
-0.048575528,
0.3410066962,
0.2774567604,
-0.3884658515,
0.0812272578,
-0.6029775143,
0.164740175,
-0.3215755522,
1.3714543581,
0.4752884507,
0.3068849742,
-0.2270013243,
0.2628704011,
-0.5156771541,
-0.3142392337,
-0.834482491,
-0.5836276412,
1.0282384157,
0.7849863172,
0.4437353611,
0.3490073085,
0.2189320773,
0.3565796018,
-0.1234196872,
0.0552301332,
-0.571557343,
0.0793368742,
-0.4855330884,
-0.9445860982,
-0.0998043418,
0.0801146999,
0.6184043288,
0.884011507,
-0.4402398467,
0.1121223271,
0.2990957797,
0.8308349848,
-0.2412881851,
0.0442260541,
-0.466042757,
0.1719049364,
-0.202698499,
-0.1571279913,
-0.558133781,
-0.7057909369,
0.153866291,
-0.1328709573,
0.0449441634,
-0.0926384032,
0.0952104181,
0.3088623881,
-0.2159886062,
-0.8391000032,
-1.03084445,
0.6569143534,
-0.8198248148,
-0.3895085752,
-0.1775650531,
0.5056196451,
-0.3672775626,
-0.8387451172,
-1.0679693222,
-0.2685647607,
0.0781081319,
0.0684083179,
-0.0431829989,
-0.3342804909,
0.3358342052,
0.3688865006,
0.0448336303,
-0.0084463721,
-0.5034151673,
0.3310575783,
0.6609788537,
0.1929045022,
0.1871081591,
-0.263273865,
-0.0937742293,
-0.1117658764,
-0.5528774858,
0.3178086579,
0.7208864093,
0.3611602187,
0.2036139816,
0.4917480052,
-0.0261080656,
0.2572579086,
0.0759844854,
-0.3974737525,
-0.0414599217,
-0.0663568079,
0.0842311233,
0.274117142,
0.7280548811,
0.1966586411,
0.3660191298,
0.0519730411,
-0.3020189106,
-0.0095866602,
0.1917526126,
-0.7568275928,
-0.7228680253,
-0.3433000147,
-0.1374625862,
-0.7486817241,
0.2509099245,
-1.0745267868,
-0.6561089754,
-0.3453200161,
0.5900530815,
-0.1139300391,
-0.2952171564,
0.0014452968,
-0.4299115241,
-0.4063505232,
0.3901057243,
-0.655703187,
0.3287629187,
0.43525967,
0.6918002963,
-0.0628143623,
-0.3781818748,
-0.8843715787,
0.0430815592,
-0.2230264097,
0.4961308539,
-0.5498645902,
-0.3744649291,
-0.35845083,
-0.0167923886,
0.178840965,
-0.8139731884,
0.2561587691,
-0.127864033,
0.2797391415,
-0.35206604,
-0.1813587695,
-0.106329903,
-0.037133202,
-0.6695720553,
1.0129637718,
0.0782879516,
-0.8325088024,
0.1602176428,
-0.3932519555,
-0.5764836669,
0.0040772678,
-0.3193657696,
-0.1933673769,
0.5883739591,
-0.0538138039,
0.178608194,
-0.3273527026,
0.2251808792,
-0.4408062398,
-0.6200433969,
0.7008441091,
-0.5118464231,
0.5464051962,
0.2183601111,
-0.7416715026,
-0.2911123335,
-0.8309623599,
-0.0136144096,
0.344530195,
-0.6180502176,
-0.4027281106,
0.0760260522,
-0.4024314582,
0.3465096653,
-0.1043696553,
-0.466252178,
0.2935765684,
-0.4496005774,
0.4579622447,
0.8077807426,
0.0252397545,
0.2165649086,
-0.4782803655,
0.6077934504,
0.2699601054,
-0.0816182345,
-0.0615957528,
-0.4365526736,
-0.9185492396,
-0.0683753341,
0.2099012285,
0.3493801355,
-1.1459599733,
-0.1636658609,
-0.2516846657,
-0.4948647618,
-0.6825844646,
0.6043713093,
0.3473037779,
0.482422322,
-0.0922459289,
-0.4498814344,
-0.5090844631,
-0.5811907649,
-0.3108533621,
-0.2150377035,
0.0453123525,
0.3499694169,
0.2523844838,
0.1835510433,
0.8360245228,
-0.6133748293,
-0.1095604077,
-0.6314843893,
0.2771035433,
0.463336885,
0.3223585188,
0.7191256881,
-0.3811080158,
-0.6188776493,
-0.2757325768,
-0.3632684946,
-0.4407137334,
0.1077334881,
0.0974318534,
-0.0150939366,
0.2266610712,
-0.4582528472,
0.3467590809,
0.2821947038,
-0.0596994348,
0.7709201574,
-0.1884568781,
0.0643573925,
-0.8648709059,
-0.06425374,
-0.3907998502,
-0.1940336972,
-0.511768043,
-0.2050175816,
-0.5547277331,
-0.005751492,
-0.5173093081,
0.2380951643,
-0.3530070484,
0.1314276904,
-0.5731723905,
0.2841174304,
0.0018139256,
0.3280507028,
-0.3777709603,
0.3824325204,
0.5250579715,
-0.6018474102,
0.6473925114,
-0.4353001714,
-0.281110853,
0.6412431598,
-0.6218083501,
0.3951359093,
-0.1337108165,
0.1012149379,
-1.2604048252,
-0.1905249506,
0.0137984911,
-0.2669661939,
0.3708087802,
-0.125853166,
-0.8207291961,
-0.7269186378,
-0.4729436338,
0.0755668208,
0.7810774446,
-0.6154596806,
0.1369296163,
0.0991853848,
-0.5548209548,
-0.407905072,
-0.9582851529,
-0.0223341398,
-0.4390764832,
-0.4719361365,
-0.2246972024,
-0.1844149232,
-0.4455453455,
0.032019183,
0.0727925524,
0.2973433733,
0.0476256795,
0.1297585815,
-0.0727868527,
-0.2923166454,
0.0555901565,
0.0806322321,
0.3023740053,
0.206997335,
-0.0320525877,
0.3720897734,
0.0134584671,
-0.2359413803,
-0.2975243926,
0.250918895,
0.4761331677,
0.4806687236,
0.6724276543,
0.3629819453,
0.1268484592,
-0.7623285651,
-0.4854112566,
-0.5043917894,
-0.542381525,
0.0780738741,
-0.2530886233,
-0.6908953786,
0.2909594476,
-0.2154949605,
-0.2093143612,
0.0357341692,
0.5982570052,
-0.2855713069,
1.0187045336,
0.6526925564,
0.1519258916,
0.4464790523,
-0.0849042311,
0.4496465027,
-0.4951104522,
-0.1720891893,
-0.4112468958,
-0.8008233905,
-0.3274381757,
-0.4065228403,
0.1814280599,
0.3867307603,
0.2024267167,
-0.1197448596,
-0.4108915031,
0.6389015317,
0.5978618264,
-0.1546286345,
0.4481628835,
-0.0137345688,
-0.3317766488,
-0.2151153982,
-0.8820685148,
-0.5500636697,
0.8382363319,
0.3281814754,
1.1726572514,
0.455683738,
0.9354632497,
0.0354851596,
0.4949890971,
-0.7927058935,
0.6354709268,
-0.4531003237,
-0.0843615383,
-0.1063210368,
-0.5925768614,
-0.558293283,
0.1252510548,
0.2196374983,
-0.5965142846,
-0.1662852317,
0.3717914522,
-0.3606286049,
0.2623333335,
-1.1389062405,
0.4191493988,
-0.0723460615,
-0.5614578724,
-0.1294250786,
-0.5190503001,
0.4977350533,
0.0274306629,
0.4899424016,
0.1963384598,
0.3794544637,
0.5825089812,
-0.5623464584,
1.0963345766,
-0.5448349714,
-0.1174572557,
0.562918365,
0.4717861414,
0.4717730284,
0.411477685,
0.0330872163,
-0.5341850519,
0.0146598052,
-0.0545839593,
-1.0138084888,
1.0143140554,
-0.5070968866,
-1.1318225861,
-0.2670976818,
-0.4709831476,
-0.0734840706,
0.0083189243,
0.0690087676,
-0.0296087041,
0.2634012401,
0.3488415182,
0.3866606951,
-0.0370989367,
0.6958566904,
0.5440295935,
-0.3251653314,
-0.1701519787,
0.945933938,
0.1298013479,
0.3971294463,
-0.0831691697,
0.6219052076,
-0.2328871191,
-0.1695296168,
-0.4633316696,
0.2898355424,
-0.7102129459,
-0.0235992875,
-0.528567493,
-0.0476647727,
-0.4157170653,
0.0739091188,
-0.5089836121,
-0.6367014647,
-0.4343492687,
0.0044146068,
0.1654850841,
1.2580564022,
-0.1971193999,
0.2560860813,
-0.5044460893,
-0.2509562373,
0.6931892633,
0.2109195143,
0.5789262652,
-0.6017661691,
-0.1548957974,
0.0439474061,
-0.6645795703,
-0.9589627385,
0.1745955348,
0.3921729326,
0.3854502738,
0.3075030148,
0.0058451514,
0.662273407,
-0.6731189489,
1.065138936,
0.3239148557,
-0.8011920452,
0.718678236,
0.1730433106,
0.3422132432,
0.3080500364,
0.016352959,
-0.3768276274,
-0.8584740758,
-0.5654496551,
-0.575578928,
0.9455798864,
0.1017098054,
0.5228920579,
-0.1566117257,
0.3511207104,
0.2530472577,
0.6552174091,
-0.88026613,
-0.0913009048,
-0.2214480639,
-0.1044902876,
0.0107939932,
-0.1772052646,
-0.3210594654,
-0.2608069181,
0.4132969975,
-0.1738106459,
-0.0329417586,
0.178099677,
0.1032842547,
-0.1663687378,
0.4995743334,
0.7070559263,
0.4745334089,
0.1690938622,
0.8373451829,
0.0904815197,
-0.5335126519,
0.1991012096,
-0.4002353549,
0.0978757739,
0.218378976,
0.2043043077,
0.646402359,
0.1653354913,
-0.6937182546,
0.5225098133,
0.0529724993,
0.0479511507,
-0.0388693474,
0.6070699096,
0.2813658714,
0.5909880996,
0.3878593147,
-0.1170739979,
0.1030161306,
-1.0596722364,
0.3691472411,
-0.0533042662,
-0.1886485964,
-0.7466252446,
0.5318367481,
0.0261256956,
-0.4002450407,
0.3892062306,
-0.3372114599,
-0.5097839832,
0.7322995663,
0.7873815894,
0.6019454598,
-0.2646935284,
0.3916333616,
0.202439934,
0.0576032102,
-0.2463544607,
0.5170432925,
-0.0665329099,
-0.1789179295,
-0.3132060766,
-0.6627136469,
-0.1199358776,
0.0682336241,
-0.7006029487,
0.4280397594,
-0.535307765,
-0.1114511266,
0.1345791072,
-0.1399221122,
-0.5322591066,
0.0701174736,
0.0058579538,
0.5799029469,
-0.6908349991,
1.019675374,
0.8384702206,
-0.453905046,
-1.0813705921,
0.1578122675,
-0.0248015858,
-0.494256705,
0.9242508411,
0.0545740873,
-0.178502351,
-0.1489681154,
-0.389031142,
-0.3086274564,
0.8653783798,
0.53309834,
-0.8251565099,
-0.1169585139,
0.2362016588,
0.9695276618,
-0.6109237075,
0.1874984801,
0.5260611773,
0.1141643524,
0.5407098532,
-0.8793879747,
0.1352485269,
-0.1880337,
0.3147580624,
-0.1151633784,
-0.7980199456,
0.9891573191,
-0.6601148844,
-0.1041153595,
-0.0792086199,
0.3156234324,
0.3954591155,
0.5556840301,
0.7011529803,
0.5533950329,
0.5055656433,
0.0333551206,
0.9163398147,
0.1374284923,
0.3179271519,
1.5092927217,
-0.2956758738,
0.8139615059,
1.0368056297,
-0.1483695656,
0.6768909097,
0.1089373752,
0.1012282521,
0.849363029,
0.6365660429,
-0.137203306,
0.2397656441,
-0.0251486637,
-0.1326831281,
0.1214917675,
0.1419525295,
-0.5064432621,
-0.1416272223,
0.2545622289,
0.0589615591,
0.249300018,
-0.1839046031,
0.8377708793,
0.367169559,
-0.9142784476,
0.2799490988,
-0.2126109749,
0.6383666396,
-0.2165677249,
-0.2232780457,
-0.3691797256,
0.2394315302,
-0.3096549809,
-1.0379599333,
0.3895460665,
0.151876539,
-0.1492037177,
0.0039118221,
0.306566447,
-0.6500410438,
-0.2548613846,
0.199545607,
0.2449367642,
0.321578145,
0.379337877,
-0.2682551742,
-0.0332294218,
0.1350651234,
-0.303301394,
0.2543359101,
0.9577333927,
0.2508227229,
0.3844563663,
0.4567744136,
0.467826575,
0.3582412004,
0.3636004031,
1.0446926355,
-0.5929392576,
-0.6264500618,
-1.0183116198,
0.634455502,
-0.134108901,
-0.1973270625,
0.7880724669,
0.2906656265,
0.795348525,
-0.3440156579,
0.7044357657,
-0.2653578222,
0.5825129747,
-0.3866826892,
0.6454008222,
-0.8344506621,
0.6613043547,
-0.4186688066,
-0.9746089578,
0.295368433,
0.3171766698,
-0.1876237988,
0.0628963932,
0.8484882116,
0.7346602082,
-0.1128310263,
-0.0002578174,
0.3276386559,
0.4456469715,
0.5318338275,
0.6277502775,
1.132196188,
0.0075465054,
0.6252219081,
-0.5727968216,
-0.2687830329,
-0.3172180653,
-0.8315581679,
-0.9917952418,
-0.3941221535,
-0.3013829589,
-0.447747767,
-0.3245142102,
0.6147466302,
0.3602569401,
-0.5469036102,
-0.1848585159,
0.0051792967,
0.234263733,
-0.1307427436,
-0.3575184047,
-0.0033739742,
-0.3489794731,
-1.0148400068,
0.2586043775,
0.2826277316,
0.0414336696,
-0.5907930732,
0.0149520217,
0.1980154365,
0.4162137806,
0.5431435108,
0.0430193432,
-0.8008951545,
-0.3383680284,
-0.1788036823,
-0.1111026034,
-0.1977324188,
1.0177404881,
-0.5412428975,
0.6511905789,
0.5892187953,
0.4228888154,
0.3698493242,
-0.3393319547,
0.3649398983,
-1.1750757694,
0.3879214227,
0.3646944761,
-0.02279469,
0.4066188931,
-0.5238443017,
0.2746466994,
0.5239823461,
-0.3813042045,
-1.3614339828,
0.1417721361,
-0.7161076069,
-0.1897616088,
1.0459487438,
-0.3245478272,
-0.3437513113,
0.385350734,
-0.4069423079,
0.1878102869,
-0.3336784542,
1.1841564178,
0.9565464258,
-0.2525342107,
-0.3304377496,
-0.5364336371,
0.452354461,
0.6233147383,
-0.5597171783,
-0.1487878263,
0.1764264852,
0.64544034,
0.3362472951,
0.5294830203,
-0.1195046008,
0.3794522285,
0.0605006851,
-0.2357200831,
0.0482484326,
-0.5187532306,
-0.2153681815,
0.3311436176,
0.4021028876,
0.0746935755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08822v1
|
LoRA-SP: Streamlined Partial Parameter Adaptation for Resource-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T06:50:10 | 2024-02-28T06:50:10 |
Yichao Wu, Yafei Xiang, Shuning Huo, Yulu Gong, Penghao Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In addressing the computational and memory demands of fine-tuning Large
Language Models(LLMs), we propose LoRA-SP(Streamlined Partial Parameter
Adaptation), a novel approach utilizing randomized half-selective parameter
freezing within the Low-Rank Adaptation(LoRA)framework. This method efficiently
balances pre-trained knowledge retention and adaptability for task-specific
optimizations. Through a randomized mechanism, LoRA-SP determines which
parameters to update or freeze, significantly reducing computational and memory
requirements without compromising model performance. We evaluated LoRA-SP
across several benchmark NLP tasks, demonstrating its ability to achieve
competitive performance with substantially lower resource consumption compared
to traditional full-parameter fine-tuning and other parameter-efficient
techniques. LoRA-SP innovative approach not only facilitates the deployment of
advanced NLP models in resource-limited settings but also opens new research
avenues into effective and efficient model adaptation strategies.
|
[
-0.3371462226,
-0.9203746319,
0.3653877079,
0.1256065965,
-0.4795119464,
-0.0731227547,
-0.4963275492,
-0.2271751612,
0.3643226027,
0.5765872002,
-0.6072103977,
-0.2583607137,
-0.3748402596,
-0.0499573834,
-0.3746017218,
1.0917665958,
-0.0188389514,
-0.0218930226,
-0.0221844502,
-0.1832786351,
-0.2209893912,
-0.3813860714,
-1.1597722769,
-0.2949534357,
0.8956432939,
0.5271106362,
0.5898070335,
0.6555972695,
0.5315040946,
0.2234871984,
-0.0964104831,
0.1274928898,
-0.7842339277,
0.2670752704,
-0.324462831,
-0.6340153217,
-0.6361243129,
-0.2906606793,
0.8084528446,
0.825070858,
-0.4500770271,
0.4572722018,
0.1103411764,
0.9574934244,
-0.8796619177,
-0.0169472527,
-0.9826034904,
0.16592893,
-0.1992368698,
-0.559905231,
-0.4741921127,
-0.1570335627,
0.1297559142,
-0.824549973,
0.0689357817,
0.1800094992,
0.7934610248,
0.7655228972,
0.1110689268,
-0.0399564728,
-0.8778324723,
0.8424979448,
-0.8579332829,
0.2357108295,
0.3360857069,
0.2510087192,
-0.2324816883,
-0.6537595391,
-0.2008342445,
0.000803552,
0.4765635729,
-0.0114795649,
-0.1773457527,
0.0726673603,
0.3464213908,
0.1107245907,
-0.2663380206,
0.5016671419,
-0.4526280165,
0.0025780969,
0.5174021125,
-0.0065451199,
0.0497410744,
0.2988915741,
-0.1453780532,
0.1503622234,
-0.6900719404,
-0.1360320896,
0.2516067624,
0.8067196012,
-0.1772955507,
0.5195582509,
-0.3776470423,
0.8878322244,
0.1372282654,
-0.3214157522,
0.0424521007,
-0.0063306554,
-0.3985056877,
0.0646372065,
0.6244611144,
0.0341290869,
0.2334923595,
-0.1202133,
-0.1158651337,
-0.2604737282,
-0.0137115987,
-0.6419813037,
-0.1937054545,
0.0054320744,
-0.2725813985,
-0.0215878095,
-0.6299850345,
-0.8353019953,
-0.6085816622,
-0.2365044057,
0.5018677711,
-0.2125446051,
0.0754038766,
0.4911449552,
-0.0873054415,
0.1253907979,
0.5293440819,
-0.9139102101,
0.5523356795,
0.397704035,
0.7809238434,
-0.4982282221,
-0.4498650134,
-0.780441165,
0.3318706155,
-0.084520638,
0.8352137208,
-0.5036275983,
0.032779932,
-0.133703053,
-0.260286957,
-0.2107979804,
-0.5359639525,
0.6162698865,
-0.5650216341,
0.1492849141,
-0.334161669,
-0.247786805,
0.0599393509,
-0.0256904792,
-0.7573813796,
1.2617026567,
0.009553412,
-0.8372915387,
0.2789043486,
-0.7658487558,
-0.3087297976,
-0.1056066528,
0.1044199467,
-0.3403935432,
0.3693427742,
0.1455601901,
0.3118513525,
-0.6957654953,
-0.1801583022,
-0.4237037599,
-0.3640740812,
0.0729290545,
-0.2835876048,
0.5161728263,
0.3180352151,
0.1137214676,
0.2265756875,
-0.7387494445,
0.0261637587,
0.3047356606,
-0.5278447866,
-0.4381766617,
0.3164808452,
-0.2139796615,
0.0558056533,
0.5774409771,
-0.1628602892,
0.3487281501,
-0.4839996994,
0.4664286971,
0.8056455851,
-0.0984598696,
0.5921400785,
-0.2770397961,
0.5356063247,
-0.0554643199,
0.2394606471,
0.1168027148,
-0.3704560697,
-1.3049662113,
-0.5063762665,
0.5674704313,
0.4538156688,
-0.681781888,
0.4202591777,
-0.1910264939,
-0.4732461274,
-0.4565477073,
0.3048168719,
0.1370558888,
0.3532777727,
0.363104701,
-0.2518767715,
-0.5644171238,
-0.8156004548,
-0.4123384058,
-0.0951633528,
-0.0419046171,
0.0778483227,
0.4284318984,
0.218451485,
0.9385738969,
-0.6462711692,
-0.2992678583,
-0.3735823035,
-0.0588149577,
0.3902032673,
0.3171142936,
0.5727617145,
-0.4294420183,
-0.5726838708,
-0.1107334048,
-0.3394060731,
-0.1217351407,
0.0349873528,
-0.1668296605,
0.2331775129,
0.5455224514,
-0.5454528332,
0.1537387818,
0.7370550632,
-0.2060968727,
0.3693946004,
-0.5312883854,
-0.2827511728,
-1.0076655149,
0.1781453639,
-0.0287572574,
-0.2728767991,
-0.6430542469,
0.1510367543,
-0.2348817587,
-0.2101059258,
-0.4642872214,
0.6915683746,
-0.5387411118,
-0.1916635036,
-0.2594225705,
0.2669513226,
-0.18946518,
0.5912951827,
0.0326117836,
0.6347093582,
0.6011726856,
-0.6778966188,
0.1361805052,
-0.1752313972,
-0.2580343783,
0.2805327177,
-0.4201769531,
0.3474102616,
-0.1024560332,
0.1952609867,
-0.5311250091,
-0.1583025903,
0.1732174754,
0.050362628,
0.1014764532,
-0.4223223925,
-0.6081855297,
-0.0398423411,
-0.2482030392,
0.3947397768,
0.6956648827,
-0.2142927051,
0.8339913487,
0.4361271858,
-0.4395226538,
-0.4031931758,
-0.4845204353,
-0.1383501142,
-0.3604223728,
-0.2445988208,
0.2123327851,
-0.2610283494,
-0.0505563691,
-0.1806732863,
-0.2017377913,
-0.2015616,
0.2517384887,
-0.1145029217,
0.0110757528,
-0.3707587123,
-0.245802477,
0.2701144218,
-0.0697954446,
-0.2975951433,
-0.1791311055,
0.7218455076,
0.2119532377,
-0.3542906344,
-0.4135101736,
0.2364099324,
0.5338335037,
-0.0790078491,
0.9567578435,
0.3826107979,
-0.4216733575,
-0.750942409,
-0.5547408462,
-0.1391789615,
-0.4956077337,
0.6240682006,
-0.4132728875,
-0.8665631413,
0.7541473508,
-0.349709183,
0.0323871672,
0.2389132231,
0.5982351899,
-0.0431153961,
0.7505613565,
0.9784342051,
-0.339915216,
0.646365881,
0.0816668049,
0.287181288,
-0.5453665257,
0.0961167961,
-0.8505446315,
-0.5615948439,
-0.3689523339,
-0.7000460029,
0.2978946865,
0.4083833396,
-0.4469488263,
0.0533080883,
-0.4229795635,
0.635499835,
0.3926196694,
0.0577783845,
0.3791176677,
0.2152484804,
0.098283343,
0.0277774688,
-0.9703087807,
-0.1443318576,
0.8759900928,
0.4433684647,
0.9013773203,
0.0087700197,
0.5294472575,
0.3017826378,
-0.1715588123,
-0.9635371566,
0.7773288488,
-0.4749355912,
-0.43505615,
-0.5778282285,
-0.3653805554,
-0.6787606478,
0.2001086324,
-0.1698690057,
-0.8742474914,
0.0735785589,
0.2943116426,
-0.6184674501,
0.42974177,
-0.6979385018,
0.4703353643,
-0.0221598502,
-0.1897692382,
-0.3243320286,
-0.2957277,
-0.0009062302,
-0.5719071627,
0.0410200544,
-0.4162250161,
-0.4237341285,
1.0759438276,
-0.1568246782,
0.9279788136,
-0.5078662634,
-0.1644682586,
-0.0193517655,
0.1021960899,
0.8370008469,
-0.2198112309,
-0.4376622736,
0.0215568803,
0.0451182127,
-0.5542084575,
-0.7326370478,
0.742331028,
-0.8373702168,
-0.6013457179,
-0.3887403607,
-0.6739082336,
-0.5704949498,
0.3315753043,
0.0029484131,
-0.07252004,
-0.0275918953,
0.1470701844,
0.8453344107,
-0.352604866,
0.370100379,
0.7809410095,
-0.3226506412,
-0.1832578182,
0.7604926825,
0.154743135,
0.3682992756,
0.3984894454,
0.2839340866,
0.1305568218,
-0.9996107221,
-0.1522510648,
0.4347705245,
-0.6361877918,
-0.1938280463,
-0.2402740121,
-0.4300256371,
0.1055093333,
-0.2560897171,
-0.8105663657,
-0.5997228026,
-0.4990220964,
0.2715898752,
0.5522186756,
0.3458842933,
0.1818163842,
0.4283052087,
-0.3482367396,
0.4262920022,
0.1060448587,
0.5035551786,
-0.2068398446,
-1.0898755789,
-0.3665918112,
-0.0085117826,
0.171001792,
-0.4474315345,
0.3123414814,
0.562097013,
0.4347797632,
0.1623260379,
0.2604918778,
0.8585602045,
-0.6737722754,
0.6810449958,
0.1677073389,
-0.8629134297,
0.4715777636,
-0.4766900539,
0.5043578148,
0.5999196172,
0.1666782051,
-0.1789915264,
-0.2134145945,
-0.0427133963,
-0.9396409392,
0.9320631027,
-0.0473253168,
0.1246703342,
0.6002337933,
0.5953733921,
0.1714806557,
-0.1074885428,
-0.5780562758,
-0.2871637642,
0.1553771943,
-0.191012904,
-0.0984701216,
-0.4786266088,
-0.3452862203,
-0.3559117019,
0.8211942315,
-0.4810029864,
0.2703968585,
-0.1740473658,
0.0353600644,
-0.1937317848,
0.2845632136,
0.731558919,
0.7614443302,
-0.3301494718,
-0.0522322692,
0.6574498415,
-0.4427039027,
-0.1028060168,
0.0193470623,
-0.2190043181,
-0.1550837606,
0.0682606399,
1.0063182116,
0.4183816314,
-0.6128529906,
0.1322962344,
-0.0186750349,
-0.1945206076,
-0.2531990707,
0.2123223245,
0.1334742308,
0.1527545154,
0.516297996,
0.154217273,
-0.133431077,
-0.4299793243,
-0.144437477,
0.2805819809,
-0.3060562909,
-0.4246562719,
0.3990444243,
0.1424255222,
-0.2075605839,
0.1811783016,
0.1414363831,
0.1074182466,
0.188157931,
0.666990459,
0.7938768268,
-0.2049262077,
0.1391765326,
0.173235178,
0.1579311043,
-0.4535716474,
0.5050031543,
0.1131093651,
-0.6984935999,
-0.6365668774,
-0.9877213836,
-0.4294342697,
0.1446362138,
-0.8603779078,
0.4823795855,
-0.8075433969,
-0.2285931706,
0.0048176078,
-0.020814579,
-0.4753762186,
0.0072230478,
0.1058358848,
1.2504862547,
-0.777528584,
1.2462261915,
0.5986195803,
-0.1417493969,
-0.5626511574,
0.0112978751,
-0.0900609866,
-0.8444686532,
0.4301842153,
-0.6057862639,
-0.4292249084,
0.0902474746,
-0.5069522858,
-1.2779392004,
1.0173681974,
1.1108950377,
-0.6347202659,
-0.3864312768,
0.203310445,
0.6852717996,
-0.2039292455,
-0.1189899072,
0.6235792637,
0.2810974717,
0.1195498034,
-1.3089205027,
0.0239334553,
-0.0193901192,
0.0459713154,
0.1813508123,
-0.7921133041,
0.63205266,
-0.0610848479,
-0.0697163492,
0.3414306045,
0.7451887727,
0.4907409251,
0.0457442366,
0.5484017134,
0.4196481407,
0.7947750092,
0.0778768435,
0.6426269412,
-0.4112368226,
0.3243681788,
1.3785094023,
-0.5495662689,
1.3247686625,
0.7978029847,
-0.137133956,
0.2969200015,
0.397839874,
0.2923531234,
0.699988842,
0.3143594861,
-0.1543695182,
-0.1984330863,
-0.1918672472,
-0.2829828858,
0.5220264792,
0.2846480608,
-0.1353847235,
-0.1225735843,
-0.0529851504,
0.1721546799,
-0.1602513641,
-0.5120421648,
0.7742099166,
0.2209391147,
-0.5165829659,
0.815495491,
0.0735194311,
0.6224490404,
-0.9393888116,
0.285817802,
-0.2111578435,
0.3055207431,
-0.1664947867,
-0.2513845265,
0.0169084296,
0.1619528681,
-0.428085953,
-0.2413865775,
0.6057288647,
-0.2682954073,
-0.4888546467,
0.3933928311,
0.4931617677,
0.0791658759,
0.0740979165,
-0.9150417447,
0.4351651967,
0.0371479914,
-0.3816845715,
0.7305292487,
0.4369729459,
0.0852449387,
0.9897230864,
0.5447447896,
0.4890353978,
0.1472268999,
0.3104116619,
1.0298467875,
-0.6190597415,
-0.5152557492,
-0.5529766679,
0.3057449758,
0.0792426541,
-0.1740579754,
0.7241985202,
0.5811808705,
0.6228660941,
-0.0831382871,
0.7834696174,
0.0233904812,
0.6232917905,
-0.9186930656,
0.7555671334,
-0.634254694,
0.4516629577,
-0.2422187179,
-1.0112662315,
-0.2952268124,
0.2820968032,
-0.2608178556,
0.1300126761,
0.8586332798,
0.6837774515,
-0.249677971,
-0.2557201385,
0.4291229844,
0.3968439102,
-0.0753258392,
0.4314312339,
0.5275494456,
-0.2958211303,
0.3871518672,
-0.1052002311,
-0.2096251696,
-0.1463226825,
-1.0134724379,
-0.8982673287,
-0.6646926403,
-0.5864195824,
-0.0942364112,
0.3481556177,
0.8121508956,
0.7992789149,
-0.853335619,
-0.3750268817,
0.2529504895,
-0.1703604609,
-0.1595456004,
-0.1284864694,
0.4467329681,
-0.3293897808,
-0.5697159171,
0.5886628628,
0.3737881482,
-0.3335775733,
-0.3756500483,
-0.1157411635,
-0.2193070799,
0.426499635,
0.5321012735,
0.5997387171,
-0.7971076965,
-0.1230289191,
-0.2253290266,
0.1370906979,
0.0049428381,
0.7258951068,
-0.5630164742,
0.2231279761,
0.5345341563,
0.5420920253,
0.6255003214,
-0.2174512893,
0.5384815931,
-0.6190572381,
0.5053673983,
0.1446467936,
0.3617269993,
0.1094900742,
-0.1298252642,
0.3404437602,
-0.0224617533,
-0.4628078043,
-1.1383464336,
0.1875932813,
-1.3209822178,
-0.3060495555,
1.264870882,
0.0174429659,
-0.2984052002,
-0.0224282295,
-0.1863341331,
0.034488596,
-0.5378469229,
0.7269030809,
0.3956661224,
-0.1299502999,
-0.258831799,
-0.6702952385,
0.6937927008,
0.4821846485,
-0.8116959929,
0.1701132357,
0.1780526191,
0.3838517666,
-0.1294496357,
0.737311244,
0.2313878834,
-0.0125367707,
-0.1621573865,
-0.0281437617,
0.1115411818,
-0.3185375631,
-0.3792313635,
0.3415057063,
0.501685679,
0.1943678856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18101v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18101v2
|
Assessing the Efficacy of Grammar Error Correction: A Human Evaluation Approach in the Japanese Context
| 2024-02-28T06:43:43 | 2024-02-29T10:53:40 |
Qiao Wang, Zheng Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we evaluated the performance of the state-of-the-art sequence
tagging grammar error detection and correction model (SeqTagger) using Japanese
university students' writing samples. With an automatic annotation toolkit,
ERRANT, we first evaluated SeqTagger's performance on error correction with
human expert correction as the benchmark. Then a human-annotated approach was
adopted to evaluate Seqtagger's performance in error detection using a subset
of the writing dataset. Results indicated a precision of 63.66% and a recall of
20.19% for error correction in the full dataset. For the subset, after manual
exclusion of irrelevant errors such as semantic and mechanical ones, the model
shows an adjusted precision of 97.98% and an adjusted recall of 42.98% for
error detection, indicating the model's high accuracy but also its
conservativeness. Thematic analysis on errors undetected by the model revealed
that determiners and articles, especially the latter, were predominant.
Specifically, in terms of context-independent errors, the model occasionally
overlooked basic ones and faced challenges with overly erroneous or complex
structures. Meanwhile, context-dependent errors, notably those related to tense
and noun number, as well as those possibly influenced by the students' first
language (L1), remained particularly challenging.
|
[
0.0515498407,
-1.1023827791,
0.4265744388,
0.2050791532,
-0.0100449258,
0.055657018,
-0.1337214559,
-0.1427650899,
-0.0645075291,
0.112647891,
-0.3872040212,
-0.5497497916,
-0.3134678304,
0.6327238679,
-0.155516848,
0.4736948907,
-0.2315154076,
0.1488351673,
-0.2768528163,
0.0776607171,
-0.9370942116,
-0.5889556408,
-0.6706501245,
-0.1948808581,
0.2268646061,
0.6890810728,
0.5617684722,
0.6359887123,
0.5298560858,
0.3108869493,
0.0523322821,
0.0152718639,
-0.2477320582,
-0.3538056016,
-0.2638935745,
-0.5750783682,
-0.5671417117,
-0.0970948935,
0.8684698343,
0.7961811423,
-0.3239948452,
0.1215727851,
-0.0649329796,
0.6482483745,
-0.4528136253,
-0.0894217566,
-0.0645566955,
0.0406265706,
-0.4773465395,
0.1401138008,
-0.6455764771,
-0.2070130557,
-0.1332952976,
-0.6315633655,
0.1648278385,
-0.0286283176,
0.8178062439,
0.3089590669,
-0.2490542382,
-0.1568272859,
-0.4629451036,
0.3598118424,
-0.9639696479,
-0.0406669602,
0.5850669146,
0.2237575352,
-0.4759207964,
-0.52994138,
-0.4496813118,
0.3323778212,
-0.2541002929,
0.3784657717,
-0.1979915351,
0.1311140954,
0.6177229881,
0.0406664349,
-0.4859527349,
0.1400303245,
-0.2531700134,
-0.3252128363,
0.6341690421,
0.2194703072,
0.7387483716,
-0.677434206,
-0.1584659368,
-0.1044386029,
-0.1589083821,
0.2802151144,
0.6141629815,
0.3539031148,
0.2261016965,
0.3299969435,
-0.3891643286,
0.62923491,
-0.1627132148,
-0.2433935106,
0.1056523994,
-0.2652331293,
-0.3823441565,
0.0160343219,
0.8215252161,
0.3985745311,
0.1803910583,
-0.0922842175,
-0.2388687879,
0.5121609569,
0.3700888455,
-0.3679405451,
-0.2613164485,
-0.1365650743,
-0.2004321665,
-0.0903875306,
0.3221423924,
-0.8360952139,
-0.1614091098,
-0.0384632312,
0.7909059525,
-0.3479330838,
-0.0856614709,
0.2945095301,
-0.111685805,
0.020237444,
0.3015239239,
-0.6386260986,
0.3432986438,
0.509850502,
0.638425231,
0.05559282,
-0.5163873434,
-0.064314194,
-0.1040049121,
-0.2730269134,
0.8954762816,
-0.3582239747,
-0.7404844761,
-0.1730706245,
0.1711603701,
-0.5253258348,
-0.2785819173,
1.2375096083,
0.047560256,
0.2347654849,
-0.3904729187,
-0.9366566539,
-0.1770531386,
-0.1354272068,
-0.6830083728,
1.2745350599,
0.3788570762,
-0.5939668417,
0.2583673,
-0.4145867825,
-0.5095000267,
0.2137303352,
0.0001392991,
-0.6987707615,
0.1143294051,
0.2709083557,
0.4581010342,
0.1243399382,
0.6428343654,
0.1210619807,
-0.7635703087,
0.4095739722,
-0.2130861431,
0.7396484017,
-0.2674496472,
-0.4718579054,
-0.0240359232,
-1.0175483227,
0.0392669886,
0.3979449868,
-0.6353009343,
-0.551363647,
-0.2431996316,
-0.2863925695,
0.0072158407,
-0.3000870943,
-0.4990984797,
0.3716557622,
-0.148975119,
0.2805462182,
0.5691103935,
0.1105648875,
0.2780475914,
-0.467289418,
0.7149302959,
-0.2522405982,
0.0254334081,
-0.7327588201,
-0.298453927,
-1.0477784872,
0.1237692311,
0.6744480729,
0.4806903899,
-0.5451356173,
0.5012001991,
-0.1849157512,
-0.4717676044,
-0.7872384191,
-0.0128651541,
0.7488529682,
0.7675853968,
0.1572070867,
-0.4540717602,
-0.8595926166,
-0.5495929122,
-0.6357527375,
-0.4083185196,
0.3932344019,
-0.0738521144,
0.6216183305,
-0.5355371237,
0.7601540089,
-0.1489332765,
-0.0695521384,
-0.0315764025,
0.3468182981,
0.0553446487,
0.68079561,
0.1414384395,
-0.363244772,
-0.3025399148,
-0.328813076,
-0.5620594025,
-0.5014361739,
-0.2035968304,
-0.3828542233,
0.7132002711,
0.2943441868,
-0.2138898969,
0.6884871721,
0.1130996272,
-0.7061274648,
0.5742560029,
-0.1155288741,
0.2529882789,
-0.8740769625,
0.2805213332,
-0.0377329923,
-0.4618909359,
-0.7877028584,
0.049685657,
0.4814165533,
0.1625116765,
-0.0641916096,
0.3031869829,
-0.1565448344,
0.0009158276,
-0.113972716,
-0.0402768515,
0.2955439389,
0.4256063104,
-0.3118606508,
0.5474281907,
-0.1157538518,
-0.2916039526,
-0.0542715937,
0.0749685466,
-0.1055519953,
0.647087872,
-0.5447332263,
0.3187279701,
-0.2084012032,
-0.012388478,
-1.5277721882,
-0.6822339892,
0.3993272483,
-0.6818491817,
0.3066005111,
-0.0519121587,
-0.4571894705,
-0.5139019489,
-0.0880503729,
0.0242790207,
0.3726013005,
-0.3593970835,
0.6839075685,
0.1296231598,
-0.2332697064,
-0.5335333347,
-0.4154739976,
0.0697092563,
-0.0851170272,
-0.3729518652,
-0.0435925387,
0.2076926678,
-0.1912967861,
-0.0452416278,
-0.1703711301,
0.132341966,
0.6804121137,
0.4544484913,
0.4564930797,
-0.0463954248,
0.291174531,
0.0632523447,
-0.0869791955,
0.2532510757,
0.28999874,
0.3430177867,
-0.2484095395,
-0.3318110704,
-0.6412644386,
-0.1541117579,
0.1245257631,
0.1654038429,
0.3248574436,
0.3947010338,
-0.5551006794,
-0.1454905123,
-0.6882981658,
0.1196373329,
-0.3441134989,
0.39166677,
-0.2510633171,
-0.4698237479,
0.492461592,
-0.0112926876,
-0.28776443,
0.6261643171,
-0.0282108132,
-0.2841184437,
0.7476952076,
0.4467912912,
-0.0470886268,
0.1029633433,
-0.0203192104,
-0.0362777412,
-0.7412900925,
-0.2118096501,
-0.6932727098,
-0.2866515219,
-0.2902322114,
-0.3070462048,
0.0788288042,
0.5090985298,
-0.1478464156,
0.2061059624,
-0.079336606,
0.6903328896,
0.5445200205,
0.0485832952,
0.466656208,
-0.0525705032,
-0.1657477468,
-0.3235599399,
-0.8236811757,
-0.7906699777,
0.9380990863,
0.4551289976,
0.6762907505,
0.1504894048,
0.729493618,
0.2732353806,
0.3901409507,
-0.8552553058,
0.4200407565,
-0.1101944149,
-0.4868189096,
-0.4494630396,
-0.2687246799,
-0.5787565708,
0.3232028186,
-0.1898323596,
-0.4360741079,
0.0131780878,
0.020520227,
-0.5249688029,
0.0168683119,
-0.8521213531,
1.19227314,
-0.2240537107,
-0.3830236197,
0.4415647089,
-0.8833174706,
0.1827542186,
-0.1243375167,
0.3151322603,
-0.1664724648,
0.1232999489,
0.9957467914,
-0.2757115364,
1.0864460468,
-0.2649632096,
0.2347156703,
0.3223826587,
0.1368682981,
0.2791263759,
-0.1203447059,
-0.0409670509,
0.0286273211,
-0.0326062441,
-0.2349196523,
-0.4968289435,
0.0190304741,
-0.9592088461,
-0.4664230645,
-0.6351426244,
-0.3514504731,
-0.0072871768,
0.5257033706,
0.2617925704,
0.5277625322,
-0.4929551184,
-0.147731483,
0.1515532136,
-0.0942818671,
0.4777002037,
0.8239637613,
-0.4089625776,
-0.4992325306,
0.5433841348,
0.1794369966,
0.1524282396,
-0.0711001381,
0.3632911444,
-0.2048998773,
-0.1371838301,
-0.7652813792,
0.3677530587,
-0.9670262337,
-0.2699829638,
-0.7517904043,
0.1699156463,
-0.6156738997,
-0.1064162925,
-0.215031743,
-0.415520519,
-0.3945949972,
-0.1247702837,
-0.2258432806,
0.7375241518,
0.188008666,
0.7030256987,
-0.7936954498,
-0.1171420366,
-0.1557806283,
0.2616253197,
-0.0992795676,
-0.710444212,
-0.0944963023,
-0.0661434755,
-0.176535964,
-0.8398686051,
0.3277727365,
0.2577361763,
0.5136935115,
-0.0266784988,
-0.1689411998,
1.0738928318,
-0.1621283293,
0.4720736146,
-0.1550215036,
-1.3875182867,
0.7987245917,
-0.3995577991,
0.6108310819,
0.8493038416,
0.2921330333,
-0.9350104928,
-0.3105864525,
-0.8452503681,
-0.6654788256,
0.9664480686,
-0.1790266335,
-0.1634137481,
-0.0189738441,
0.9565213323,
-0.0563212596,
-0.0946854874,
-0.717255652,
0.0035830354,
-0.0294918604,
-0.4298452139,
-0.2078572959,
-0.5343456268,
0.237246573,
-0.2166286856,
0.9189355373,
-0.2048435211,
-0.0565169528,
0.6126670241,
-0.325455606,
-0.5439234376,
0.6388071775,
0.4416036904,
0.8575026989,
-0.1464271694,
0.0712223127,
0.1354127675,
-0.397295326,
0.2883481681,
0.0788840875,
-0.4506572485,
0.3006437719,
0.4641631842,
0.5979312062,
0.5247887373,
-0.7724087834,
0.6649897099,
-0.3167436719,
0.2320803255,
-0.3673747778,
0.0242968891,
-0.0140160322,
-0.0811457187,
0.1733764261,
0.1683332771,
0.3154067099,
-0.4928674698,
-0.0784089044,
-0.1442207992,
-0.0909393057,
-0.3913398385,
0.4490166903,
0.1875743717,
-0.244988665,
0.5177474022,
-0.3743939698,
-0.8388840556,
0.8332870603,
0.8977206945,
0.5033657551,
-0.7494735718,
0.3500311673,
0.8380841017,
0.3980044425,
-0.6214510202,
0.3671177626,
0.3645310998,
-0.8543844223,
-0.319176048,
-0.5639705658,
-0.4037677646,
-0.3838760853,
-1.0075348616,
0.3625292778,
-0.5634839535,
-0.3727891147,
-0.0726170912,
0.07699617,
-0.4302571416,
0.3109858334,
0.0443734191,
0.6506192088,
-1.1027946472,
0.4901740551,
1.2845796347,
-0.2162824571,
-1.1863737106,
-0.2350343764,
0.2113886774,
-0.5163109303,
0.4825536907,
0.4689574838,
0.1019465849,
0.1612171829,
-0.1078938842,
-0.6328727007,
0.9830092192,
-0.1133580357,
-0.9107557535,
0.0597177781,
0.1866468787,
0.7176399231,
-0.0261437949,
0.3233443499,
0.9846172929,
0.1801596135,
-0.0483517125,
-0.9499601126,
0.0079142787,
-0.4300953746,
0.3972947896,
0.4432663023,
-0.5659219027,
0.8225148916,
-0.1041646227,
-0.6756705046,
0.2035066038,
0.314727515,
-0.0979368314,
0.468758136,
0.1927438974,
0.9256264567,
1.1852866411,
-0.3956799805,
1.0128984451,
0.2825983465,
0.4236152172,
1.2095019817,
-0.136333555,
0.9226101041,
0.2819188237,
-0.433155477,
0.4501029849,
0.4440702498,
0.0009901564,
0.0165641401,
-0.0458659418,
0.1067720652,
-0.1313063502,
-0.1106108427,
-0.0651282892,
0.4783678949,
0.3300676048,
-0.421284914,
0.1650718451,
-0.0029667828,
0.5466008782,
0.4623351693,
-0.5101396441,
0.9504524469,
-0.2756055892,
-1.0209738016,
0.283877641,
0.3378816545,
0.6006816626,
-0.0631034151,
0.0737070367,
-0.3729379773,
0.3119173348,
-0.3858538568,
-0.4839401543,
0.191986531,
0.1284377277,
0.0117874118,
0.2410800904,
1.1498601437,
-0.3089229763,
-0.7068037987,
-0.1367302835,
0.525863111,
-0.0782831311,
0.3730175197,
-0.2394170612,
0.3923068643,
-0.0421355329,
0.2197714001,
-0.2085825354,
0.0627965033,
0.0351972617,
0.2084092796,
0.2373135388,
-0.1219193414,
0.1649526209,
0.2785315216,
0.4817159176,
-0.7895416021,
-0.5502459407,
-1.0471289158,
0.5910789371,
0.0110563748,
-0.4035301208,
1.0417276621,
0.310544461,
1.346446991,
-0.0287708174,
0.9208347201,
0.0719377398,
0.7544551492,
-0.4763768911,
0.214901343,
-0.0785901025,
0.1624515802,
-0.6369112134,
-0.6863299012,
-0.700678885,
0.9805782437,
-0.4412673116,
-0.058159668,
0.6456152201,
0.4866206348,
0.3859600723,
0.4140259027,
0.2838311493,
0.2077825516,
0.1129219383,
0.6124112606,
1.2717232704,
-0.8677823544,
-0.2647809386,
-0.6230795383,
-0.2622362375,
-0.3892459273,
-0.5865850449,
-1.0424433947,
-0.2757579088,
-0.4504480958,
-0.3892971277,
0.3320795298,
1.1472271681,
0.0238962732,
-0.5963585377,
-0.2099911273,
0.0427206233,
-0.2342198342,
0.0716501251,
-0.2232487649,
0.1365261078,
-0.4156075418,
-0.6534673572,
0.0217982642,
0.0464697555,
0.1949172616,
0.1612080634,
0.0342136063,
-0.1893311888,
-0.2203522474,
0.2902368009,
0.0911887065,
-0.7708858848,
-0.2116432786,
-0.0254629124,
-0.3573183417,
0.1778447181,
0.6870201826,
-0.5079149604,
0.9678041339,
0.5405252576,
0.7353910208,
-0.2444635034,
0.713794291,
0.2459958941,
-0.696878016,
-0.1105854437,
0.0851033404,
0.6447809339,
0.6177563071,
-0.4002055526,
0.7984167337,
0.6350672841,
-0.7789459825,
-0.7420293689,
-0.4775967002,
-0.6546261907,
-0.245308578,
1.0243389606,
-0.5009454489,
-0.5612274408,
-0.0666152909,
-0.6062698364,
0.4932507575,
-0.2192031592,
0.7775342464,
1.1317881346,
0.0521417335,
0.0089157578,
-0.4632728696,
0.277931124,
0.6832570434,
-0.9840957522,
-0.1797155142,
0.7883790135,
0.307002753,
0.1556620747,
0.7100929618,
-0.2135654688,
0.6557580829,
-0.0412008576,
0.1993270069,
-0.037381161,
-0.2736725807,
-0.9886295199,
-0.2374104112,
0.2981800735,
0.273468852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18099v2
|
Editing Factual Knowledge and Explanatory Ability of Medical Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T06:40:57 | 2024-06-04T14:38:34 |
Derong Xu, Ziheng Zhang, Zhihong Zhu, Zhenxi Lin, Qidong Liu, Xian Wu, Tong Xu, Wanyu Wang, Yuyang Ye, Xiangyu Zhao, Yefeng Zheng, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Model editing aims to precisely alter the behaviors of large language models
(LLMs) in relation to specific knowledge, while leaving unrelated knowledge
intact. This approach has proven effective in addressing issues of
hallucination and outdated information in LLMs. However, the potential of using
model editing to modify knowledge in the medical field remains largely
unexplored, even though resolving hallucination is a pressing need in this
area. Our observations indicate that current methods face significant
challenges in dealing with specialized and complex knowledge in medical domain.
Therefore, we propose MedLaSA, a novel Layer-wise Scalable Adapter strategy for
medical model editing. MedLaSA harnesses the strengths of both adding extra
parameters and locate-then-edit methods for medical model editing. We utilize
causal tracing to identify the association of knowledge in neurons across
different layers, and generate a corresponding scale set from the association
value for each piece of knowledge. Subsequently, we incorporate scalable
adapters into the dense layers of LLMs. These adapters are assigned scaling
values based on the corresponding specific knowledge, which allows for the
adjustment of the adapter's weight and rank. The more similar the content, the
more consistent the scale between them. This ensures precise editing of
semantically identical knowledge while avoiding impact on unrelated knowledge.
To evaluate the editing impact on the behaviours of LLMs, we propose two model
editing studies for medical domain: (1) editing factual knowledge for medical
specialization and (2) editing the explanatory ability for complex knowledge.
We build two novel medical benchmarking datasets and introduce a series of
challenging and comprehensive metrics. Extensive experiments on medical LLMs
demonstrate the editing efficiency of MedLaSA, without affecting unrelated
knowledge.
|
[
0.1023029014,
-0.9639599323,
0.8696141243,
-0.049077142,
0.0187873896,
-0.0622322969,
-0.2175381631,
-0.5934202075,
0.4917244017,
0.5625591278,
-0.1419046968,
-0.4369744658,
-0.5320544839,
-0.1560053825,
0.0222604629,
1.0273196697,
-0.080374606,
0.4346661568,
-0.2302131057,
-0.6080794334,
-0.6736059189,
-0.4789637923,
-0.7807723284,
-0.031135276,
0.7108379602,
-0.04641461,
0.8957031965,
0.910758853,
0.5730986595,
0.3966560364,
-0.7018193603,
0.6034753323,
-0.2695532441,
0.1997841299,
-0.6038963795,
-0.7123068571,
-1.0582746267,
-0.1594985873,
0.6169462204,
0.7759634852,
-0.1337782592,
0.2019370794,
-0.2940369248,
0.8428122997,
-0.3727027774,
0.141374737,
-0.7772398591,
-0.0305210929,
-0.0633969828,
-0.4136412144,
-0.4180164933,
-0.2744268775,
0.0717267841,
-0.6217827201,
0.1010924429,
-0.0933842808,
0.4988877177,
0.664298892,
-0.1707636118,
-0.2947276235,
-0.7934978604,
0.2062714994,
-0.9206013083,
0.078332141,
0.0442791991,
0.2413114905,
-0.1703824103,
-0.7634289265,
-0.4118303359,
-0.0139120193,
-0.0150446165,
-0.129480496,
-0.2093513012,
0.1497485638,
0.4408106208,
0.195726797,
-0.2273517102,
0.1947070658,
-0.6168959737,
0.0316948071,
0.4270219505,
0.2667150497,
0.6435668468,
-0.0594616868,
0.1157314628,
0.1722222716,
-0.8206781149,
-0.011736352,
-0.0865506232,
0.1344154328,
0.1002838314,
0.8681340218,
0.0486988053,
0.8704226017,
0.1389258653,
-0.2962470055,
0.358566463,
0.0100984927,
-0.4784109592,
-0.0678442717,
0.3406977355,
0.445365876,
-0.1587127447,
-0.0808926523,
-0.1173107475,
-0.1230193824,
0.4541020691,
-0.719404459,
-0.2197574377,
0.2645199001,
-0.6427369118,
-0.4824006855,
-0.5535902381,
-0.557272315,
-0.9009530544,
-0.4007465839,
0.6872913241,
-0.4161812961,
0.057121478,
0.4040201008,
0.0400835723,
-0.3631964624,
0.5910848975,
-0.8402586579,
0.1604265124,
0.4979113936,
0.9245426655,
0.0954077318,
-0.2225798666,
-0.3690131605,
0.3146317601,
-0.4589706659,
0.7317462564,
-0.6852906346,
0.0621061027,
-0.2911735177,
0.0131148165,
-0.2577082515,
-0.6957931519,
0.4997880459,
-0.6895148158,
0.0362474807,
-0.3246768117,
-0.8459995389,
-0.4804247022,
-0.0060864007,
-0.6346327066,
0.4325617552,
0.089992933,
-0.6980767846,
0.2126851082,
-0.8213749528,
-0.2751033604,
-0.2216120064,
-0.1199472472,
-0.3672154844,
0.4602532387,
0.2382864207,
0.4939955175,
-0.1300704181,
0.6333869696,
-0.2693533897,
0.0403450802,
0.3883096874,
-0.1052597389,
0.5418159962,
-0.0716778114,
-0.0350326672,
0.4827991128,
-0.9986736774,
-0.1406113803,
0.0200325996,
-0.2171869576,
-0.5120978355,
0.0887054279,
-0.0847377703,
0.4642920792,
0.0674856454,
-0.4477534294,
0.5500748754,
-0.4831042886,
0.6293136477,
0.8251619935,
0.2027598768,
0.2665719986,
-0.5156538486,
0.3893554509,
-0.0510869734,
0.2582240105,
-0.027549481,
-0.5575113297,
-0.5918607116,
-0.4433891773,
0.3856579959,
0.3437593579,
-0.703536272,
0.1184929907,
-0.145912841,
-0.6688584685,
-0.9340216517,
0.0324550979,
0.2763734162,
0.8377279639,
0.6361056566,
0.0954976454,
-0.4576313794,
-0.9476652741,
-0.5512066483,
-0.0015552444,
0.0653268471,
0.330548197,
0.4339102805,
-0.3220726848,
0.4968612194,
-0.7094795704,
-0.4408044815,
0.0121009899,
-0.2136837393,
0.2417295426,
0.5980982184,
0.6662549973,
-0.5534819961,
-0.2180767804,
0.1903270632,
-0.8410787582,
-0.1885894686,
-0.3615967333,
-0.0033464301,
-0.0094985645,
0.6044397354,
-0.6710592508,
0.2455791533,
0.5294736624,
-0.5140576959,
0.5279566646,
-0.7883808613,
0.1961602867,
-1.056932807,
0.1020109728,
-0.3225720823,
-0.0674648359,
-0.9329325557,
0.247060284,
0.3371351659,
0.1860119104,
-0.2544046342,
0.5637489557,
-0.2677125037,
0.144910872,
-0.2829205096,
0.0211024582,
0.0046023135,
0.4167240858,
-0.1216602772,
0.4832587838,
0.4103929102,
-0.3090882599,
0.0671589747,
0.3127854764,
-0.4098696411,
0.459931314,
-0.7919307351,
0.0750724152,
-0.1868477166,
0.1665202379,
-0.6330348253,
-0.0848842934,
0.0555732027,
-0.1412496418,
0.258136034,
-0.1381762028,
-0.4499584138,
0.0153314341,
-0.1088814512,
0.4443511069,
0.2192236036,
-0.4591703713,
0.7711085677,
0.5817760825,
-0.3972433209,
-0.3277127445,
-0.5782891512,
0.2741955817,
-0.1905003488,
-0.7279663682,
0.5186319351,
-0.3612200916,
-0.2498369813,
-0.0535472408,
-0.0082193166,
-0.0932051614,
-0.1123571172,
0.2295506597,
0.6719985604,
-0.2677818835,
0.369808495,
0.6441890001,
-0.0931054354,
0.0570961609,
0.0675453246,
0.1060589254,
0.215106681,
-0.3327306211,
-0.4745695293,
0.0508582331,
1.1010286808,
-0.2404565066,
0.7556963563,
0.149134174,
-0.6154230833,
-0.0243869964,
-0.7822447419,
-0.0162849687,
-0.3927247822,
0.7044299245,
-0.4703368247,
-0.7860924006,
0.6683601141,
-0.28465119,
0.0836547017,
0.4633996785,
0.6084160209,
0.1228908226,
1.0741269588,
0.5552318692,
0.1769709736,
-0.0102906041,
-0.0014593621,
0.1809143871,
-1.144592762,
-0.2033614069,
-0.4198235571,
-0.4553419352,
-0.4236359298,
-0.7907570004,
0.5668263435,
-0.1431731284,
0.1140963733,
-0.0561160147,
-0.4706190526,
0.5214512348,
-0.0280748643,
0.4915946722,
0.4245027006,
-0.291922003,
-0.0871000364,
-0.2188656777,
-0.7707599401,
-0.313560158,
1.2627938986,
0.4592093825,
0.5998896956,
0.0609003082,
0.1148046479,
0.1385983825,
0.3419162929,
-0.6034894586,
0.2523957193,
-0.2736523449,
-0.5805399418,
-0.2053156495,
-0.2100878358,
-0.3467531502,
0.4425414503,
-0.3855838776,
-0.4814655185,
0.4295655191,
0.3212472498,
-0.6012424827,
0.874578476,
-0.6635637283,
0.5871326327,
0.095915027,
-0.286629945,
-0.3808817267,
-0.6117245555,
0.2369031906,
-0.431340903,
0.4935429394,
0.2630071342,
-0.2748580277,
0.7591976523,
-0.5018063188,
0.8590627909,
-0.2348540276,
-0.1340090781,
-0.2806047499,
0.2939795852,
0.6992892623,
0.0217882916,
-0.1872313917,
-0.0437971354,
0.1221766397,
-0.2572776973,
-0.8002662063,
0.7399148941,
-0.5747523308,
-0.5574525595,
-0.1110178605,
-1.1193757057,
-0.4112551212,
0.0330294743,
-0.0801663324,
0.4956119061,
-0.1162167415,
0.0753956661,
0.8038383722,
-0.4975311756,
-0.074482277,
0.6800948381,
-0.3972940147,
-0.2857129276,
0.8260188699,
0.4760458767,
0.3867349029,
0.2580188215,
0.3138997555,
0.1641935855,
-0.8268969655,
-0.5688937902,
0.4541873932,
-0.7519440651,
-0.0987170637,
-1.0343106985,
-0.3322186768,
-0.0987415984,
-0.4380555451,
-0.5534302592,
-0.6173703671,
-0.0395907126,
-0.0637817457,
0.3563686311,
0.9609793425,
-0.1231903955,
-0.0080359923,
-0.5687555075,
0.5271018744,
0.2264297158,
0.2952404916,
0.0663290918,
-0.7676713467,
-0.2512492537,
-0.0952508375,
0.217441991,
-0.7263619304,
0.3029231131,
-0.0562858582,
0.2694291174,
0.4130810499,
-0.3864764571,
0.9344556332,
-0.6971457601,
0.4613063037,
-0.0594442077,
-0.9049387574,
0.4598446786,
-0.175359115,
0.2228361815,
0.3508922458,
0.0553572141,
-0.5893247128,
-0.4556632638,
-0.4785937369,
-0.4811239541,
0.5413376093,
-0.0923295841,
0.03144072,
0.3227282763,
0.7386247516,
0.2857705951,
0.0884790942,
-0.3884940743,
-0.2413118184,
0.3183335662,
0.0737843812,
0.0442538559,
-0.4901117682,
-0.2753749788,
-0.7719230652,
0.7059016824,
0.0538446419,
-0.2769971788,
0.3273826241,
-0.1388287991,
-0.2319921851,
0.1932438761,
0.9736015201,
1.0560725927,
-0.2803591788,
0.0409892946,
0.3799441755,
-0.6091154814,
0.0080622435,
-0.2483446598,
-0.4702745378,
0.0582445264,
0.4150546193,
0.8164906502,
0.28390944,
-0.6430786848,
0.2364296466,
0.03269732,
-0.1585592479,
0.2532843947,
0.0170695614,
0.3170529902,
0.4230179489,
-0.0810936242,
0.8137675524,
0.087751098,
-0.2931522429,
-0.0526287183,
0.1376674324,
-0.34387514,
-0.3813015819,
0.7896110415,
-0.1158754826,
-0.2399157286,
0.0515812635,
0.2777045965,
-0.1809250116,
0.5612347126,
0.6325427294,
0.5705623031,
-0.5406630635,
0.1464495659,
0.362698108,
0.3982052207,
0.051478114,
0.1011472866,
0.4644592106,
-0.5861470103,
-0.5133528113,
-0.2955436707,
-0.2810125351,
0.2592746019,
-0.5783156753,
0.2019217908,
-0.5723679662,
-0.0476589575,
0.5960244536,
-0.5170741081,
-0.4543012381,
0.2702601552,
-0.2957404554,
0.8002131581,
-0.7556747794,
0.9561316967,
0.7352138758,
-0.2052192539,
-0.6776012182,
-0.4218627214,
0.1879557073,
-0.8045820594,
0.3375355601,
-0.2146258652,
0.0385168232,
-0.2511567771,
-0.4644775391,
-0.6898201108,
1.0153264999,
0.4352066517,
-0.6193570495,
-0.3168189228,
-0.1426098049,
0.7961429358,
-0.5005566478,
0.0577224642,
0.4970709085,
0.3691685498,
0.0184956118,
-0.7242562771,
0.3110520542,
-0.3730567992,
-0.0336951055,
-0.1020669118,
-0.4624197483,
0.8715972304,
-0.5306990743,
0.2817463279,
0.1371334046,
0.2719899416,
0.047196988,
0.167053476,
0.3651647568,
0.5893609524,
1.0359152555,
0.3928641379,
0.8186241984,
-0.3576803803,
0.1086877659,
1.4088025093,
-0.2876089513,
0.7138608098,
0.5927488208,
-0.0238665268,
0.3816589713,
0.2210632563,
0.0543570593,
0.196322903,
0.1235799864,
-0.2500187755,
-0.0717579797,
0.0263197925,
-0.6127263308,
0.3880158663,
0.3847151697,
-0.7607038617,
0.059256088,
0.2086952627,
0.5523314476,
0.0731180906,
-0.3079777658,
0.7429043651,
-0.190942511,
-0.4551251233,
0.3999484479,
0.1574950367,
0.2705381513,
-0.5790569782,
-0.1870518178,
-0.0349948481,
0.1575301588,
-0.3355511129,
-0.5497556329,
0.3886007965,
0.0656297356,
-0.5178689957,
0.0831191242,
0.657271564,
-0.3175666928,
-0.6525962353,
0.2509972751,
0.5839888453,
0.0587865114,
-0.1516585499,
-0.5863111019,
0.1342329979,
0.1040515304,
-0.1934847683,
0.3814927638,
0.5662677288,
0.1000172347,
0.7414552569,
0.7640763521,
0.7295545936,
-0.1176418141,
0.1293975115,
1.0867863894,
-0.5870143771,
-0.2684671283,
-0.7794789672,
0.418197751,
-0.0890979096,
-0.2717245519,
0.3801710904,
0.498305887,
0.4288648665,
-0.2969570458,
0.5911605954,
-0.0107151316,
0.4528595507,
-0.6349900365,
1.1180101633,
-0.5098719001,
0.3653006554,
-0.4185729623,
-0.7123821378,
-0.5816577077,
0.2574976683,
-0.3281242549,
-0.2159071565,
0.8892094493,
0.9745835662,
-0.0111390697,
-0.023539383,
0.5115402341,
0.9808056355,
0.3519866467,
0.3887282312,
0.3479517102,
-0.3318852186,
-0.0667038411,
-0.3525261283,
-0.4717830122,
-0.0400665887,
-0.5609171391,
-0.997647047,
-0.5389854312,
-0.3331310451,
-0.2355045229,
0.2524117827,
0.895986855,
0.5703469515,
-0.6933876872,
0.1095256656,
0.2812606394,
0.1590861678,
-0.446877718,
-0.1068638116,
0.9056885839,
-0.2336552292,
-0.5564704537,
0.5458048582,
0.6954849362,
-0.2708179951,
-0.077137731,
0.1209948584,
-0.3544980586,
0.3139582574,
0.7929463983,
0.1286535561,
-0.6948208213,
-0.2655230165,
-0.2026141882,
-0.0103961779,
0.1183377504,
0.88078475,
-0.5711764693,
0.9907601476,
0.3701562285,
0.7451915145,
0.1376609355,
-0.3186112046,
0.3267168105,
-0.0687750801,
0.0043403893,
0.0854012594,
0.4595461786,
0.2224710882,
-0.440880388,
0.3720255494,
0.1806559563,
-0.7014272213,
-0.8235823512,
-0.2439475954,
-1.0432481766,
-0.4242936969,
0.847386539,
-0.1470119655,
-0.1479818225,
-0.0478170104,
-0.716696322,
0.2226960361,
0.1854339838,
1.1320296526,
0.5393033624,
-0.1509499401,
0.215076223,
-0.8520132899,
0.582960546,
0.5506621003,
-0.9841228127,
0.1227442101,
0.5627021194,
0.3649205863,
-0.0282737222,
0.4380588233,
-0.4172515571,
0.3497478664,
-0.1912076324,
0.0436637327,
-0.2376676202,
-0.3228703439,
-0.4498654306,
0.283634305,
-0.0115766805,
0.1880344301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18091v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18091v1
|
Polos: Multimodal Metric Learning from Human Feedback for Image Captioning
| 2024-02-28T06:24:39 | 2024-02-28T06:24:39 |
Yuiga Wada, Kanta Kaneda, Daichi Saito, Komei Sugiura
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Establishing an automatic evaluation metric that closely aligns with human
judgments is essential for effectively developing image captioning models.
Recent data-driven metrics have demonstrated a stronger correlation with human
judgments than classic metrics such as CIDEr; however they lack sufficient
capabilities to handle hallucinations and generalize across diverse images and
texts partially because they compute scalar similarities merely using
embeddings learned from tasks unrelated to image captioning evaluation. In this
study, we propose Polos, a supervised automatic evaluation metric for image
captioning models. Polos computes scores from multimodal inputs, using a
parallel feature extraction mechanism that leverages embeddings trained through
large-scale contrastive learning. To train Polos, we introduce Multimodal
Metric Learning from Human Feedback (M$^2$LHF), a framework for developing
metrics based on human feedback. We constructed the Polaris dataset, which
comprises 131K human judgments from 550 evaluators, which is approximately ten
times larger than standard datasets. Our approach achieved state-of-the-art
performance on Composite, Flickr8K-Expert, Flickr8K-CF, PASCAL-50S, FOIL, and
the Polaris dataset, thereby demonstrating its effectiveness and robustness.
|
[
-0.4903333485,
-0.120414041,
0.3300895691,
0.4100691378,
-0.5569214821,
0.3084996045,
-0.3835148513,
-0.1751113385,
0.2059548646,
0.336887151,
-0.4860101938,
-0.6077524424,
-0.5066608787,
0.2945801914,
-0.0538280644,
1.1981698275,
0.0224577095,
0.659381628,
-0.6203763485,
-0.3815151751,
-0.3581293523,
-0.1366180927,
-0.3828916848,
0.1158850566,
0.7560046315,
0.4885359704,
0.5107595921,
0.213106215,
0.7328400016,
0.28730762,
0.4673697352,
0.7190763354,
-0.1297118664,
-0.0972555354,
-0.119541347,
-0.3299108744,
-0.2079540044,
0.3187889755,
0.5157749653,
0.395380348,
0.0184246004,
0.2287161648,
-0.0911362097,
0.7960795164,
-0.8005678058,
0.5885867476,
-0.3712851405,
0.4905596077,
0.1423763484,
-0.3756146133,
-0.5983451009,
-0.0946603194,
0.2312368453,
-0.826618731,
0.3604386449,
0.5966189504,
0.8488928676,
0.1018986553,
-0.3034077883,
-0.2085447311,
-0.4910841882,
1.1579376459,
-0.2098971158,
0.4036142528,
0.2978675365,
0.4579119682,
0.3324807584,
-0.3424459696,
-0.7014455795,
-0.5688908696,
-0.452815026,
0.3914392889,
0.1270200759,
-0.2378396988,
0.1579288244,
0.2250797749,
-0.4265313148,
-0.0311693046,
-0.6698594093,
-0.3842226267,
0.6672555208,
0.3308488131,
-0.0568879806,
-0.5643422008,
-0.7530068755,
-0.3769825995,
-0.2881178558,
0.213995114,
0.1823791564,
0.0292942282,
-0.2636983693,
0.2463982701,
-0.2748754621,
0.4424802959,
-0.1160857305,
-0.2352888882,
0.5945555568,
-0.1851594597,
0.1721628457,
-0.6403647065,
1.173838973,
0.8470785022,
0.076752685,
-0.3853332102,
-0.3481118381,
-0.0274176523,
0.3475443423,
-0.5174766779,
-0.3575751185,
-0.0886347592,
-0.4285850227,
-0.5431411862,
0.8201367259,
-1.0269840956,
-0.6056736112,
-0.5836583972,
0.6241005063,
-0.4378647804,
0.2770370841,
-0.1982435435,
-0.3046379685,
0.3860901594,
0.3951745033,
-0.4989189208,
0.4412699938,
0.3879892528,
0.9217150211,
-0.444562912,
-0.5886847377,
-0.9258177876,
0.0206794925,
-0.3503817916,
0.8250340819,
-0.3684228063,
-0.0790852755,
-0.1607800126,
0.2470265478,
0.1481144428,
-0.5332563519,
0.3143398762,
-0.5168156624,
0.3969822526,
0.0018007202,
-0.0830627382,
-0.1908638775,
0.2151211053,
-0.7694570422,
0.3995454311,
-0.0244200584,
-0.7571659684,
0.5491964817,
-0.8189899921,
-0.524766326,
-0.0789175853,
-0.0957629904,
-0.9790437818,
0.0471667908,
0.6656762362,
0.5554503798,
-0.4355152845,
0.0603537895,
-0.4772294164,
-0.3275545239,
0.6039136648,
-0.1621499956,
0.4189324379,
0.2060732096,
-0.1814843863,
0.5248517394,
-0.5688816905,
-0.0800066292,
0.0314755775,
0.0320773311,
-0.0401063785,
0.0157388076,
0.0845867097,
0.0973137468,
-0.1393646896,
-0.6512702703,
-0.2772962749,
0.1665770411,
0.614400506,
0.6853494644,
-0.0984133556,
0.4431762695,
-0.4410687089,
0.5033862591,
0.2263601422,
0.4233444631,
-0.4706271589,
-0.199303925,
-0.7582113147,
-0.7413695455,
0.2520621121,
0.4693532586,
-0.6801434159,
0.5206964016,
-0.3897541165,
-0.4271864891,
-0.6306951046,
0.4540598691,
0.5413190126,
0.3217521608,
0.4057879746,
-0.7564666867,
-0.2623751462,
-1.2206761837,
0.2087803632,
0.0755561665,
-0.2836320996,
0.4851486087,
0.4678825438,
0.0120780775,
0.7230806351,
-0.6481449008,
-0.8715535998,
0.0589535795,
0.6157596707,
-0.3191293478,
0.3926121294,
0.3501877785,
-0.6852064729,
-0.5126103163,
-0.2111501098,
-0.6872633696,
0.041867353,
-0.2599806786,
-0.1180057004,
0.0552921593,
0.4891267419,
-0.4251160622,
-0.0644586235,
0.4210319221,
0.05197246,
0.6623461246,
-0.2920570076,
0.3541443348,
-0.7510935664,
-0.0251257923,
0.1948966682,
-0.24789913,
0.201471433,
-0.0142388344,
0.1756985784,
-0.0959995985,
-0.4227017164,
0.2060404718,
-0.6508093476,
-0.2748608291,
0.0821774378,
0.5055914521,
0.4646318853,
0.702660203,
0.0789832771,
0.5112134814,
0.6707149744,
-0.1021911278,
0.963956356,
0.1101182699,
-0.4801650345,
0.9564570785,
-0.4157401919,
0.2383770049,
-0.3747288883,
0.2971065938,
-1.1958138943,
-0.2564232349,
0.1866771281,
-0.4567393064,
0.221406281,
0.2486812621,
-0.4726558626,
-0.5781879425,
-0.7773320079,
0.1477638036,
0.3023533523,
-0.6002351046,
0.496501267,
0.2748458385,
-0.0627350435,
-0.635484159,
-0.4012560844,
-0.0044574584,
-0.2114971131,
-0.3602284491,
0.0606958792,
-0.0001299143,
0.0800976753,
-0.075605765,
0.4204092622,
-0.0110431863,
-0.2212475389,
0.4574263394,
0.5410991311,
0.0706949234,
0.3613448441,
-0.1537171751,
-0.148825407,
0.1478834301,
-0.0664370134,
0.2350964099,
-0.5755472183,
-0.395029217,
-0.8045814037,
0.2214404196,
0.8266353011,
-0.6005957723,
0.4084396362,
1.1037230492,
0.06921684,
-0.0298176352,
-0.5189406872,
-0.3480969965,
-0.3563243151,
0.6511369944,
-0.2400049418,
-0.5743367672,
0.4022302926,
0.098920621,
-0.1627605259,
0.3104776144,
0.2499064803,
-0.5214864612,
1.1115591526,
0.4292648733,
-0.1071908697,
0.4546556771,
-0.3602020442,
-0.1057777703,
-0.920856595,
-0.3389941156,
-0.1163143441,
-0.5130036473,
-0.5120954514,
-0.6087521315,
0.4380154312,
-0.2610571682,
0.0048697963,
0.0781506523,
-0.3078734279,
0.6566367149,
0.5743605494,
0.6056509614,
0.2197457701,
0.1003098488,
0.0754035786,
-0.2669472694,
-0.4278458357,
-0.3058328927,
1.1068322659,
0.2242932767,
0.8184612393,
-0.1461962312,
0.3891755044,
0.5116428733,
0.8275927305,
-0.8047009706,
0.3876230717,
-0.322130084,
-0.3678397536,
-0.2612639666,
-0.4717836678,
-0.7261691093,
0.3904225528,
-0.6645650864,
-0.1779050678,
-0.1962545365,
0.0987251848,
-0.5065102577,
0.1962717921,
-0.6902748346,
0.8726069331,
-0.542981565,
-0.5085073113,
-0.4578666687,
-0.9879045486,
0.2895777524,
0.1343176067,
0.4961347282,
0.0111676306,
-0.1733798683,
0.8641537428,
0.0245689545,
0.984500587,
-0.1628283858,
0.4084702432,
0.1998697519,
0.0403887816,
0.0270122793,
0.1668803394,
0.4817013741,
0.2273292542,
-0.0831221193,
-0.411115855,
-0.7295249701,
0.5902116299,
-1.0064976215,
-0.3401248455,
-0.2379801571,
-0.5647010207,
-0.2793412209,
-0.0955941528,
0.1110844612,
0.4382424355,
-0.1004510894,
0.2329290062,
0.2632440031,
-0.3563094139,
0.2670178711,
0.5017584562,
-0.0992805734,
-1.1893863678,
1.1683920622,
-0.3213664889,
0.0553544536,
0.4576489627,
0.2667579651,
-0.1799255311,
-0.1117845178,
-0.6638882756,
0.5597041249,
-0.625400424,
-0.5345321894,
-0.300532043,
0.1307813674,
-0.121413365,
-0.3121090233,
-0.3438202739,
-0.2255238742,
-0.1763678193,
-0.0264812335,
0.0099880314,
0.7727511525,
-0.0609489083,
0.2076924443,
-0.9012169838,
0.2572827637,
0.4758331776,
0.4606888294,
-0.0209119488,
-0.371756196,
-0.3351245522,
-0.3147073388,
-0.5688993335,
-0.8502263427,
0.4337247014,
0.3669116199,
0.3692966402,
0.7232737541,
0.0378717631,
0.5175969601,
-0.3008284867,
0.7351942062,
0.5100536942,
-0.9412845969,
0.4459364116,
-0.0833840743,
0.0034870943,
0.4201118648,
0.4648775458,
-0.3911725581,
-0.393538326,
-0.3922098577,
-0.4290830195,
0.6375794411,
-0.2537882626,
0.2028663605,
0.2025029212,
0.131840378,
0.3772067726,
0.4477643669,
-0.9563962817,
0.3096414506,
-0.2159314156,
-0.2615711093,
-0.2998872399,
0.1221758872,
-0.3715568483,
-0.4490022361,
0.3163131475,
-0.3358166218,
0.1022222564,
0.0979446247,
-0.3893033266,
-0.1680521816,
0.1222848892,
0.595215261,
0.4440701604,
-0.1544122398,
0.2749111056,
0.1695613265,
-0.1131697893,
-0.0645769313,
-0.1530963182,
0.0820737183,
-0.1385477036,
0.5198777914,
0.8660803437,
0.0630529597,
-0.7771103978,
0.9994980097,
-0.0282800645,
-0.1405507624,
-0.3299777508,
-0.3011091948,
-0.3365595937,
0.1354122758,
0.0767358541,
0.3458993733,
0.0939454585,
-0.4412957132,
0.2828796804,
0.6462429762,
-0.7557998896,
-0.4994062185,
0.5117864013,
0.4262905121,
0.0285638385,
0.6258007884,
-0.4601092339,
-0.6666479111,
0.4108609855,
0.0743666068,
0.9348717928,
0.1302983314,
0.5031359196,
0.6141707301,
0.3226263225,
0.291665554,
-0.0954328552,
-0.3421913385,
-0.487167567,
-0.3021035194,
-0.5858269334,
-0.5571030974,
-0.1887440532,
-0.7467160821,
0.5033887029,
-0.5787192583,
-0.140786469,
0.0272932872,
-0.2477282882,
-0.6544148326,
0.0706931502,
0.3552378118,
0.2254145443,
-1.1573005915,
0.2675086558,
0.8448203802,
-0.7700901628,
-0.247228682,
-0.1836351901,
-0.0481486805,
-0.4516537786,
0.896987915,
0.3651053309,
-0.2003653049,
-0.5431076884,
-0.7756317258,
-0.4753706157,
1.1497483253,
0.0925366133,
-0.2931189835,
0.3242559135,
-0.0664404929,
0.5859087706,
-0.7614964843,
0.3989526331,
0.107404761,
0.2978378534,
-0.1076884121,
-0.6743015051,
-0.0584202819,
-0.205020383,
-0.081296511,
-0.198186785,
-1.025638938,
0.6550167799,
-0.7313668132,
0.0625689998,
0.0957285464,
0.7090118527,
0.0457614921,
0.2856710255,
0.8486463428,
0.4492926598,
0.4057169855,
-0.1037676781,
0.8737940192,
0.0012776528,
0.364934653,
0.8544103503,
-0.041849371,
0.9905046821,
0.4905712008,
-0.337375164,
0.8642111421,
0.4112930894,
-0.4007536173,
0.6917974353,
0.2692539692,
0.0199842416,
-0.4819523394,
0.162395671,
0.2559552491,
0.6041742563,
0.2185581923,
-0.5523386002,
0.1313170791,
0.3639909327,
-0.3023465276,
0.0648323596,
0.0489195734,
0.9095317125,
-0.0936541557,
-0.7212050557,
0.1951434761,
-0.0631188899,
0.7399348617,
-0.2968606055,
-0.1039218679,
-0.0863742009,
0.2265926152,
-0.2015821785,
-0.7642886043,
0.0993108526,
-0.2009072453,
-0.3379794359,
0.0246988796,
0.075089179,
-0.4910113811,
-0.4547139406,
0.2062434554,
0.1748735458,
0.0987983122,
0.1179702505,
-0.5282096863,
-0.0935254991,
-0.1919642836,
0.0854659453,
0.0839309618,
0.2451943308,
-0.166516006,
0.5676437616,
0.5533243418,
0.0417759009,
-0.0970063061,
0.2400531769,
0.7009953856,
-0.5657276511,
-0.5432122946,
-0.5299448371,
0.4587623477,
-0.3489364684,
-0.2001488805,
0.4941287339,
0.586766839,
0.7708823085,
-0.5605125427,
0.6726729274,
0.1882503033,
0.4948435128,
-0.322173357,
0.6631497145,
-0.6173255444,
0.0760963708,
-0.3284006715,
-0.9368144274,
-0.5277269483,
0.6576614976,
-0.3893640339,
-0.1905449629,
0.7634687424,
0.9071004391,
0.08126726,
-0.1019585207,
0.17965509,
-0.0355487466,
0.187896803,
0.3306161463,
1.0630451441,
-0.3416815996,
0.7712348104,
-0.534212172,
-0.5004752278,
-0.094017826,
-0.6887139678,
-0.8189123273,
-0.7288885117,
-0.4946859181,
-0.0257159453,
-0.0817969739,
0.8176527023,
0.8367743492,
-1.0688991547,
-0.2669990063,
0.4745970666,
-0.0121638337,
-0.4385769367,
-0.2587532699,
0.4490072429,
-0.6865098476,
-0.8260543942,
-0.2218479216,
0.449706167,
-0.277418524,
-0.6480128765,
-0.2561310232,
0.2069748044,
-0.1358485818,
0.6982061267,
-0.0844100118,
-0.793191731,
-0.2188118398,
0.063809976,
-0.1979961693,
0.113243714,
0.8148340583,
-0.5796682239,
0.8643818498,
0.3968900144,
0.2811951041,
0.3557785451,
0.073730126,
0.3691287637,
-0.8269962072,
0.1993505061,
-0.0177677292,
0.4641573131,
0.8072602153,
0.1236843914,
0.2450958192,
0.6065855026,
-0.3979283869,
-0.4467922747,
-0.0483430997,
-1.1440206766,
-0.0072464822,
0.8493267894,
-0.3267628849,
-0.2512232661,
0.3246824145,
-0.5947656035,
-0.0288706981,
-0.3423720002,
1.1642102003,
0.6694434285,
-0.1251901388,
-0.3683502376,
-0.1045924202,
0.2459193915,
0.5535828471,
-0.682875216,
-0.0542995334,
0.7995157242,
0.3422246575,
0.5432271957,
0.1463951766,
-0.4855586886,
0.4325319529,
-0.0581471175,
0.3145864606,
-0.0871477276,
-0.4595851302,
-0.2647104561,
0.2931394279,
-0.0451683663,
-0.5191501975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18061v2
|
On the use of Silver Standard Data for Zero-shot Classification Tasks in Information Extraction
| 2024-02-28T05:45:37 | 2024-03-06T08:42:24 |
Jianwei Wang, Tianyin Wang, Ziqian Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The superior performance of supervised classification methods in the
information extraction (IE) area heavily relies on a large amount of gold
standard data. Recent zero-shot classification methods converted the task to
other NLP tasks (e.g., textual entailment) and used off-the-shelf models of
these NLP tasks to directly perform inference on the test data without using a
large amount of IE annotation data. A potentially valuable by-product of these
methods is the large-scale silver standard data, i.e., pseudo-labeled data by
the off-the-shelf models of other NLP tasks. However, there is no further
investigation into the use of these data. In this paper, we propose a new
framework, Clean-LaVe, which aims to utilize silver standard data to enhance
the zero-shot performance. Clean-LaVe includes four phases: (1) Obtaining
silver data; (2) Identifying relatively clean data from silver data; (3)
Finetuning the off-the-shelf model using clean data; (4) Inference on the test
data. The experimental results show that Clean-LaVe can outperform the baseline
by 5% and 6% on TACRED and Wiki80 dataset in the zero-shot relation
classification task, and by 3%-7% on Smile (Korean and Polish) in the zero-shot
cross-lingual relation classification task, and by 8% on ACE05-E+ in the
zero-shot event argument classification task. The code is share in
https://github.com/wjw136/Clean_LaVe.git.
|
[
-0.1075235158,
-0.5841168165,
0.2634227276,
-0.7194001675,
-0.1370591223,
-0.2692199945,
0.0783888102,
-0.496170938,
-0.0379528403,
0.5233194232,
-0.1647876352,
-0.8280477524,
-0.4339918792,
-0.0279611852,
-0.4453885257,
1.3113856316,
-0.0334941819,
-0.3289811909,
-0.0212487448,
-0.079931125,
-0.3841071427,
-0.3885651827,
-0.3904211521,
-0.2014570832,
0.3930492997,
0.6015583277,
0.5183601379,
0.7752963305,
0.2794991732,
0.1874811053,
0.0199345555,
0.204277873,
-0.7511096001,
0.0451701954,
-0.3562487066,
-0.7259726524,
-0.4783699512,
0.3593976498,
0.407094419,
0.5994091034,
-0.0855018198,
0.5265595913,
-0.1856750101,
0.3633256555,
-1.3287557364,
0.369579196,
-0.6691044569,
0.297510922,
-0.4548933208,
-0.2912015617,
-0.5220935941,
0.0138528915,
-0.274609983,
-0.7399743199,
0.1926272511,
-0.3010295033,
1.3952572346,
0.1612727791,
-0.2083913833,
0.0514605083,
-0.8436806798,
0.9296180606,
-0.8072798848,
0.3062618375,
0.523301363,
0.224710837,
0.0730497837,
-0.8948966861,
-0.5507009029,
0.1087450534,
0.0506688394,
0.3874345422,
-0.4458542466,
-0.1325987279,
0.4198803604,
0.172940895,
-0.6144365668,
0.1079705209,
-0.789958775,
0.0127781322,
0.6846633554,
-0.1563350409,
0.0528899319,
-0.0344918296,
-0.2720979452,
-0.0729381144,
-0.6064876914,
0.1678045094,
0.1314722449,
0.5136813521,
0.1757332981,
0.5660818219,
-0.587320745,
0.7973901033,
0.1816134453,
-0.4385411143,
0.6816480756,
-0.166189,
-0.6534104347,
0.1978502274,
0.6556462049,
0.4026788473,
0.4051924944,
-0.4579540789,
-0.1593099236,
0.1223418266,
0.033306282,
-0.7749131322,
-0.0817171857,
0.1176686361,
-0.35269925,
-0.1523732096,
0.2497796714,
-0.5821117759,
-0.2738635838,
-0.3395441771,
0.5828176141,
-0.1461380124,
-0.1606425643,
0.4229876101,
-0.2900908589,
0.2809017301,
0.6077831984,
-0.499645412,
0.2916411757,
0.5936123133,
0.8008621335,
0.0049810237,
0.2010993809,
-0.9220921397,
0.248578757,
-0.4209081829,
0.7991902232,
-0.3310577571,
-0.242985189,
-0.2509838045,
0.0084042363,
-0.0885582939,
-0.6803303361,
0.7226473689,
-0.3927523792,
0.3122412562,
-0.0087813968,
-0.5183875561,
-0.3338374496,
0.4169768393,
-0.5592343211,
0.8647978902,
0.1552440226,
-0.9182008505,
0.4480214715,
-0.6014620662,
-0.1096493825,
0.4352115989,
-0.1623751074,
-0.1667144746,
0.0292405952,
-0.0144664021,
0.4796277583,
0.0250878483,
0.0087815505,
-0.4475194812,
-0.744771421,
-0.1815795898,
-0.2173645943,
0.8730067015,
0.4398056567,
-0.4295528531,
-0.4344112277,
-0.902290225,
0.1173976213,
0.0423089825,
-0.0645982251,
-0.5246071815,
-0.3187775314,
-0.2700885534,
0.3376919329,
0.2066715211,
-0.7637158036,
0.062811695,
-0.4527342021,
-0.2185098976,
0.4802094698,
0.0411303155,
0.631926477,
-0.2163651586,
0.5578765869,
0.0237033907,
0.120141007,
-0.2707946599,
-0.2925609648,
-0.7613702416,
-0.4886189103,
0.7574711442,
1.0181792974,
-0.6122459769,
0.4938206077,
-0.1676160097,
-0.5974876881,
-0.9023945332,
0.2237998247,
0.3413990438,
0.9039676189,
0.3776274323,
-0.3162984252,
-0.2863437533,
-0.9888453484,
-0.0439103134,
-0.0477391109,
-0.0700249374,
0.013448379,
0.5153048038,
0.0121248346,
1.0906406641,
-0.5978468657,
-0.4443847835,
0.0608126633,
0.4755578935,
0.2171572298,
0.1787657738,
0.3422831893,
-0.687097609,
-0.4233618677,
0.2675814927,
-1.0869739056,
-0.3227883875,
-0.1319342852,
-0.0147175547,
0.0244399775,
0.506911695,
-0.389174819,
0.778239429,
0.0566827841,
-0.1827980876,
0.3219025433,
-0.0435578637,
0.1549837291,
-0.6966855526,
0.49021402,
0.2836956382,
-0.4710358381,
-1.0852590799,
0.2237653583,
0.0949523896,
0.1315198988,
-0.9629521966,
0.7212336063,
-0.2680139542,
0.0904576927,
-0.2374685556,
0.2480400205,
0.2800658941,
0.1204138696,
-0.0096670724,
0.5189145803,
0.2921645343,
-0.3205460012,
0.0322815664,
0.1294569522,
-0.0512282364,
0.5901377201,
-0.4960466027,
0.0800634846,
-0.4310389459,
0.0274640806,
-0.5437141657,
0.0877368003,
0.2292884737,
-0.4341292679,
0.5883723497,
-0.1365338564,
-0.8062959313,
0.1412420571,
-0.4922352135,
0.0069611385,
0.6647995114,
-0.2019905448,
0.2341919392,
0.4653797746,
-0.1150647998,
-0.7346488237,
-0.5548668504,
0.1127066389,
-0.3674274981,
-0.4881362319,
0.1917124093,
0.2180248499,
-0.4167276919,
-0.0033239836,
-0.2874767482,
-0.0774797425,
0.2191953063,
0.2648233771,
0.4285155237,
0.1472837478,
0.0293979049,
-0.2314558327,
-0.2767722011,
-0.4667991102,
0.2249843031,
0.2909981906,
-0.1426909268,
-0.1821777225,
-0.7025415301,
0.1965037286,
0.1390209198,
-0.3167414665,
0.6586910486,
0.7075409293,
-0.4166409671,
-0.2114543319,
-0.3182185888,
0.0756121725,
-0.387339741,
0.1412994415,
-0.1693736017,
-0.6523191333,
0.4366137087,
-0.1303426921,
0.5100404024,
0.6140013337,
0.1246447936,
-0.372510463,
0.9928557873,
0.4547775984,
0.0644659549,
0.3009968698,
-0.5640522242,
0.252987802,
-0.5185168982,
-0.2657094002,
-0.6506339312,
-0.2325474769,
-0.2689719796,
-0.0999490023,
0.0764294639,
0.5576331019,
-0.205411464,
0.1327310055,
-0.3224239051,
0.3964971602,
0.5207073092,
-0.2180828899,
0.2796759903,
-0.0188231543,
0.3349116147,
0.0316420905,
-0.4813511074,
-0.6683258414,
1.0706874132,
0.2048956156,
0.6819203496,
-0.2832778692,
1.2747604847,
0.2954551578,
0.0570821166,
-0.7750526071,
0.5494738817,
-0.5949145555,
-0.5682369471,
0.1509658545,
-0.3515565693,
-1.0718847513,
0.1206149161,
-0.3975004256,
-0.9432964325,
0.1712189764,
-0.0710930601,
-0.4718596339,
0.1889470816,
-0.9027571678,
0.6743154526,
-0.0883261338,
-0.2480302006,
0.4771450758,
-0.6509584188,
0.4092194438,
-0.3126283884,
0.5233673453,
-0.1026886404,
0.04456947,
0.9411718249,
-0.0635539219,
0.7099807858,
-0.4118260741,
0.0269768331,
0.3524959087,
0.06601917,
0.4639463425,
-0.2856484354,
-0.1308865398,
0.2502951026,
0.2792099714,
-0.1725478023,
-0.5765762329,
0.5160027146,
-0.6314364076,
-0.2640434504,
-0.6771339774,
-0.6626589894,
0.0136972331,
0.417833358,
0.0623848327,
0.183022514,
0.2429515123,
0.3957832456,
0.5956577063,
0.0926660597,
0.4795486927,
0.5567111373,
0.0385666899,
-0.1542020142,
0.8970208764,
0.5618320704,
0.2379730344,
0.1079561114,
-0.0781442374,
-0.2258552462,
-0.6955006719,
-0.0928579569,
0.2428223193,
-0.8219804764,
-0.4586105943,
-0.4961287677,
-0.3556713462,
-0.4093549252,
-0.2198464572,
-0.2929316163,
-0.6861335039,
-0.7568337917,
-0.1687910408,
-0.0613822602,
0.3616636395,
-0.1451607645,
0.3031557202,
-1.0828689337,
0.4693697095,
-0.2167831063,
-0.0244138855,
-0.4678037465,
-0.4798781574,
-0.2393756956,
0.0476915389,
-0.3244040608,
-0.7765333056,
0.4432220757,
0.2911599278,
0.7672460079,
0.695682466,
0.3870075047,
0.922329843,
-0.258266896,
0.8748632073,
0.2465978414,
-0.6130102873,
0.4692327976,
-0.2474787086,
0.4178095758,
0.9970045686,
0.3798020184,
-0.4142327905,
-0.405146271,
-1.062656641,
-0.8684858084,
0.73225528,
0.1845123917,
-0.2599880397,
0.0365750119,
0.6104103327,
0.266811043,
0.2622363567,
-0.6442300081,
-0.196807757,
0.0503302664,
-0.2888991833,
-0.0972101763,
0.1777907312,
-0.2108353525,
0.0563356988,
0.7024719119,
-0.0854806677,
-0.1666617543,
0.0777263343,
-0.195954904,
0.0683641434,
0.3922045529,
0.1813643873,
0.6382058859,
-0.4688930213,
0.1732948422,
0.1565526575,
-0.3604742289,
-0.1170595512,
0.2382148355,
-0.8460831642,
0.08115457,
0.33920753,
0.4351893067,
-0.1273857206,
-0.7214329839,
0.5251147151,
0.0351654962,
-0.5344808698,
0.0084958039,
0.4620135725,
-0.2340396941,
0.2132021338,
0.2465068102,
0.0132238027,
0.4550098181,
-0.6221661568,
0.3612237871,
0.5198523998,
-0.379280895,
-0.2608675063,
0.3506815135,
-0.1766090989,
-0.0466751941,
0.4528082907,
-0.6190484762,
0.0669320673,
0.291518271,
0.5392326117,
0.53519243,
0.0379655547,
0.4676519632,
0.4169226885,
-0.0654458776,
-0.2374222279,
0.4951799214,
0.0001730097,
-0.4467876852,
-0.6191019416,
-0.788664937,
-0.0484956466,
0.4210828245,
-0.8376338482,
0.5156139135,
-0.3540436327,
-0.3155069053,
0.1954896003,
0.2524021268,
-0.5974819064,
0.4190230966,
0.4616973996,
1.0447969437,
-0.9262703657,
0.6081545353,
0.4520779848,
-0.3322995305,
-0.6035273075,
-0.5538814664,
0.2831041217,
-0.5843588114,
0.8221392035,
0.2010274678,
-0.0451141447,
-0.1495819092,
-0.5369933844,
-0.6655960083,
1.2212405205,
0.4214725494,
-0.4467989802,
-0.2853819728,
-0.1188927367,
0.3818637133,
-0.303979218,
0.0972608328,
0.6137322783,
0.3321157992,
0.5308976173,
-1.097291708,
-0.2845926285,
-0.4094871283,
-0.4235505164,
0.4013777077,
-0.2274806947,
0.7384985685,
-0.0063754809,
-0.5492758155,
-0.1946054846,
0.2797222733,
0.3348006904,
0.5308803916,
0.4843931198,
0.9734745622,
0.952494204,
-0.0203710143,
0.5723177791,
0.1965723932,
0.4644816518,
1.2799705267,
-0.638864398,
1.1211497784,
0.3401434124,
0.0226282421,
0.3169303536,
0.4738036096,
-0.3172261715,
0.7514992356,
-0.0007412948,
-0.2297869772,
0.0024225879,
-0.3160814643,
-0.1795398295,
1.0252789259,
0.2606461346,
-0.1221010685,
-0.8254963756,
-0.1220304593,
0.4684805572,
-0.2424704432,
-0.7043696642,
0.9238818288,
-0.2169252336,
-0.4396030605,
0.4819463193,
0.0012192472,
0.6441341639,
-0.6166887283,
-0.2764581442,
0.1143402606,
0.2923152745,
-0.5318880677,
-0.7239687443,
0.3149298728,
0.221182555,
0.1450193375,
-0.2398114949,
1.0086956024,
-0.3157231212,
-0.3772183061,
-0.0587406866,
0.5202844739,
0.4959612191,
0.1056919917,
-0.6595931649,
-0.3677720428,
0.0721621886,
-0.1063426062,
0.5673629045,
0.1701165736,
-0.1501446664,
0.2060092986,
0.8104501367,
0.495644033,
0.078073889,
0.0176836643,
0.5583411455,
-0.5212411284,
-0.3833520412,
-0.635227561,
0.8639746904,
-0.3496996164,
0.1028814763,
0.8363178372,
0.7251137495,
0.8737097383,
0.362013191,
0.7691299915,
-0.0129665714,
0.5580624938,
-0.2685077488,
0.5880661011,
-0.6315757036,
-0.1550710797,
0.0562881194,
-0.734505713,
-0.5584025979,
0.6189624667,
-0.1752737761,
-0.0228025988,
0.4492224157,
0.548596859,
-0.1150238812,
0.0257599875,
0.3961749375,
-0.0561049655,
0.5495353937,
0.3108885884,
0.2648625672,
-0.5229723454,
0.4241317511,
-0.2624915242,
-0.5271246433,
-0.0186025016,
-0.9189437628,
-0.5797103047,
-0.3262264431,
-0.4373562932,
-0.2361992002,
-0.1374616623,
0.557112813,
0.713668406,
-0.6262720823,
0.0104269786,
0.242378369,
-0.5059726834,
-0.0556738488,
-0.2573952973,
0.3518202305,
-0.4676859081,
-0.619784534,
0.2884911597,
0.4101253152,
0.0871352851,
0.2560272217,
0.194207266,
-0.5139396787,
-0.0844709575,
0.4576665163,
0.6064707637,
-0.4146237373,
-0.260340333,
0.2174219936,
0.2011340559,
0.059236221,
0.2196504176,
-0.9556782842,
0.7507488132,
0.4517914951,
0.3289500773,
0.8285867572,
0.137449801,
0.2337183654,
-0.8456155658,
0.0999883413,
0.285813421,
0.3672684431,
0.1485659927,
-0.2476189882,
0.5859826207,
-0.007621971,
-0.4634065926,
-0.9720067382,
-0.0595198013,
-1.1610610485,
-0.3122079372,
1.3068743944,
-0.3798668385,
-0.326841265,
-0.248861894,
-0.1590569913,
0.4569874704,
-0.343908608,
0.5088892579,
0.4729665518,
-0.3775099516,
-0.2728244066,
-0.9647387862,
0.22932145,
-0.2315431237,
-1.0200529099,
-0.0082543585,
0.4639730453,
0.3189262152,
0.5787353516,
0.7611967921,
-0.3119027317,
0.2838796377,
-0.1575023681,
0.0676804557,
-0.4214689434,
-0.4020234048,
-0.2962142527,
0.5635964274,
-0.2460015118,
-0.3161512017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18060v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18060v4
|
Benchmarking Large Language Models on Answering and Explaining Challenging Medical Questions
| 2024-02-28T05:44:41 | 2024-06-25T21:17:09 |
Hanjie Chen, Zhouxiang Fang, Yash Singla, Mark Dredze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have demonstrated impressive performance in answering medical questions,
such as achieving passing scores on medical licensing examinations. However,
medical board exam or general clinical questions do not capture the complexity
of realistic clinical cases. Moreover, the lack of reference explanations means
we cannot easily evaluate the reasoning of model decisions, a crucial component
of supporting doctors in making complex medical decisions. To address these
challenges, we construct two new datasets: JAMA Clinical Challenge and
Medbullets. JAMA Clinical Challenge consists of questions based on challenging
clinical cases, while Medbullets comprises simulated clinical questions. Both
datasets are structured as multiple-choice question-answering tasks,
accompanied by expert-written explanations. We evaluate seven LLMs on the two
datasets using various prompts. Experiments demonstrate that our datasets are
harder than previous benchmarks. Human and automatic evaluations of
model-generated explanations provide insights into the promise and deficiency
of LLMs for explainable medical QA.
|
[
-0.0910912082,
-0.7473162413,
1.1320863962,
-0.0880469978,
-0.0973681659,
0.0189382173,
-0.2137796879,
-0.2860438824,
-0.2100112885,
0.5326471329,
-0.8030121922,
-0.4636594951,
-0.579177618,
0.4437901378,
0.0801003948,
0.8819463849,
-0.2909864187,
0.5218343735,
-0.7188557982,
-0.280035466,
-0.791339159,
-0.3960694671,
-0.6192270517,
-0.4840884209,
0.5992844105,
0.1865492165,
0.780808568,
0.5462161899,
0.844486177,
0.2809304595,
-0.0997770429,
0.2005951107,
-0.4080788791,
0.2011989504,
-0.3171887398,
-0.7357347012,
-0.0781304538,
-0.1480847597,
0.3389236033,
1.1788368225,
-0.1598659605,
0.1557504982,
-0.4286854565,
0.5630539656,
-0.3804496527,
0.0511334389,
-0.5986388326,
-0.0627066121,
-0.0233993195,
-0.2499975711,
-0.3816803992,
-0.4877436757,
-0.0116686234,
-0.5156847239,
0.2273482531,
0.0113879964,
0.8979575634,
0.2927576303,
-0.715764761,
-0.5481356382,
-0.6175980568,
0.5768603683,
-0.4910719395,
0.2553291023,
0.2123725563,
0.6657153964,
-0.3466804028,
-0.6782209277,
-0.2422380447,
-0.2197253257,
-0.0966951996,
0.1300353259,
-0.2035041898,
0.0428799391,
0.370184809,
0.2817659676,
-0.866689682,
0.2438329607,
-0.606420815,
-0.0775503218,
0.5954489112,
0.6750692725,
0.1602515131,
-0.0663645789,
-0.1921848804,
-0.0632372275,
-0.9515275955,
0.1606678665,
-0.2794881463,
-0.0603565834,
0.0249509402,
0.5442117453,
0.0004219167,
0.763101995,
-0.2238242775,
-0.2263461649,
0.2014682144,
-0.1700254381,
-0.2669375539,
-0.3371733427,
0.7247775197,
0.5820899606,
0.196838811,
-0.0806319267,
0.0667812601,
0.0970810652,
0.2660833001,
-0.6882645488,
-0.0106603364,
0.6528226137,
-0.5879396796,
-0.1463544518,
-0.2550831735,
-0.6497205496,
-0.6203218699,
-0.0598466955,
0.494343549,
-0.1408520639,
0.1615227908,
0.4137328863,
-0.1186604351,
0.198648572,
0.509167552,
-0.51864326,
0.4058037996,
0.5182788968,
0.5117456317,
-0.2114575505,
0.1103355438,
-0.266220212,
-0.045076225,
-0.4833279252,
0.9501090646,
-0.5671847463,
-0.3822372258,
-0.0875678882,
0.1690495014,
-0.0947621167,
-1.1544585228,
0.461720109,
-0.2156829089,
0.3071898818,
-0.5047571063,
-0.7149925828,
-0.2860300243,
0.2692842484,
-0.2751308382,
0.7076839805,
0.160617739,
-0.3238157332,
0.2147943974,
-0.4249664545,
-0.1284793317,
0.0991944373,
-0.5825111866,
-0.3903542459,
0.3327179551,
0.4454083145,
0.6219571829,
-0.8850295544,
0.5533367991,
-0.4262554049,
-0.2373352647,
0.5634742379,
-0.310548842,
0.7169899344,
0.3424657881,
0.0967251733,
-0.1173005328,
-0.6756095886,
0.049140323,
0.5037996769,
-0.1751683354,
-0.0635573566,
0.0410752185,
-0.4093073606,
0.1946520209,
-0.037561357,
-0.3418921828,
0.1999631375,
0.0027605945,
0.3420551121,
0.4657844901,
0.2216872871,
-0.3544892669,
-0.7636325359,
0.8909549117,
0.0146561004,
0.2453071922,
-0.4221920073,
-0.6265618205,
-0.3386503458,
-0.1480472386,
0.1063075513,
0.5099766254,
-0.4721207321,
-0.2448135912,
-0.3457768261,
-0.505638063,
-0.8400132656,
0.0601028688,
0.4489164054,
0.7612999082,
0.4315807819,
-0.2223117501,
-0.3246619701,
-1.0500310659,
-0.4234395027,
-0.1988018453,
-0.3740839958,
0.7079465389,
0.5472658277,
-0.1008309275,
0.4940221608,
-0.4972037971,
0.0835032314,
-0.1277444214,
-0.0018382423,
0.4337125719,
0.1265574098,
0.3827704489,
-0.6496326327,
-0.0905852988,
-0.1446084827,
-0.9437323213,
-0.5137026906,
-0.299025625,
0.2709113657,
-0.3930430114,
0.606551826,
-0.5155653954,
0.1539032161,
0.4470064342,
-0.2817161083,
0.7402381301,
-0.2319566309,
0.1934986413,
-0.7102043629,
0.0414165929,
-0.2675776482,
-0.3478941023,
-0.5270493627,
0.1370348036,
0.0159641746,
-0.2022150755,
-0.4848147929,
0.5675785542,
-0.4482325613,
-0.0675746426,
-0.0172208119,
0.1917023212,
0.2277789861,
0.1710737497,
-0.2461494356,
0.6788765192,
0.3833427131,
-0.4032144547,
0.4770543277,
0.2828750312,
-0.3437285125,
0.5327404141,
-0.9254819751,
0.0330485068,
-0.289609313,
0.2723916769,
-1.0947496891,
-0.2964968085,
-0.1022360399,
-0.3309510946,
0.0928961933,
-0.1382863671,
-0.3556086123,
-0.7314478159,
-0.0215174686,
0.380528152,
0.6172409654,
-0.2700659335,
0.4205646515,
0.1955694556,
-0.3522237539,
-0.2912738025,
-0.4839757979,
0.0337781236,
-0.2123139054,
-0.3631858528,
0.2057532966,
-0.2912582457,
-0.4473679662,
-0.0940302536,
-0.1337248385,
-0.1244287193,
0.1855286211,
0.4870174825,
0.3148615956,
-0.344671756,
0.3779849112,
-0.0930399969,
-0.0476466008,
0.4573378861,
0.3790597022,
0.2514977455,
0.0032740543,
-0.6167730093,
-0.4205785096,
0.4317854047,
0.6457311511,
0.0479593687,
0.5184599757,
0.0693024099,
-0.3848719001,
0.0989730805,
-0.8016281724,
-0.1940695047,
-0.3941447139,
0.3720071018,
-0.5245652199,
-0.7852942944,
0.6290256977,
-0.2055636197,
0.1632229388,
0.4004281461,
1.0525599718,
-0.2002921551,
1.2874512672,
-0.1533840448,
0.3112188876,
-0.3734639585,
0.1885773838,
-0.1086316928,
-0.4260050952,
-0.3885597587,
-0.5912510157,
-0.1220318824,
-0.387860626,
-0.6543393731,
0.6544042826,
0.0155618312,
-0.0358852372,
-0.1783291847,
-0.323089391,
0.6458699703,
0.2057483345,
0.2260266542,
0.3613696396,
-0.3940501213,
-0.3302051723,
-0.0265169106,
-0.7647941113,
-0.5383360982,
1.3123488426,
0.5708193183,
0.7914469242,
-0.0130746253,
0.4423337579,
-0.0768616647,
0.4290914237,
-0.5406894684,
0.4075912833,
-0.1216618493,
-1.004123807,
0.0527749732,
-0.4624313414,
-1.0569069386,
0.4240981936,
-0.2875272334,
-0.4800355136,
-0.1954799145,
0.0919652805,
-0.6243628263,
-0.0286527295,
-0.6510338783,
0.7848338485,
-0.170591414,
-0.2284624726,
0.0238245316,
-0.7498630285,
0.4363082349,
-0.018334223,
0.4974190891,
-0.3368360996,
-0.0841365755,
0.5924316049,
-0.5058147907,
0.6585048437,
0.0118174255,
0.0320210829,
0.1240001693,
0.1679056734,
0.2156872451,
0.2099372596,
-0.1483149529,
-0.0927213207,
0.334504813,
-0.5665460229,
-0.774331212,
0.4819479585,
-0.505992651,
-0.79885602,
-0.1741992831,
-0.6857588291,
-0.5920283794,
-0.068921946,
0.0676592365,
0.5433223248,
-0.0532670841,
0.1617290825,
0.561991632,
-0.5205006003,
-0.1745473295,
0.7397924662,
-0.3208046854,
-0.1757877022,
0.3900865316,
-0.0415145159,
0.3250846565,
0.2930609584,
0.3614351749,
-0.2967166901,
-0.9266924262,
-0.5240869522,
0.5673447251,
-0.8472375274,
-0.1323387772,
-0.5257481337,
-0.0036184855,
-0.1405116469,
-0.1295084059,
-0.1348165125,
-0.1057772487,
-0.0681128055,
-0.0199857429,
0.1766489744,
0.9049772024,
0.270979017,
-0.0280818846,
-0.8470318913,
0.5464954376,
0.3987973034,
0.2455946207,
-0.2339441627,
-0.5109657645,
0.0164697114,
-0.1275296211,
-0.2081437707,
-1.1261628866,
0.0364435166,
0.0216277651,
0.518501699,
0.3606848717,
-0.1155569032,
0.9472440481,
-0.6841632724,
0.7504422665,
-0.0387193337,
-0.5412676334,
0.5349957943,
-0.2467045337,
0.4182592928,
0.6393221021,
0.7135772109,
-0.4964276254,
-0.4829395115,
-0.4329286218,
-0.4368704855,
0.3345630169,
0.060313303,
-0.0900303721,
-0.0969395265,
0.8220223784,
0.4171492159,
-0.0223499537,
-0.5261459947,
-0.219523564,
0.4499738216,
-0.3732522428,
-0.2379815727,
-0.2701633275,
-0.4123830497,
-0.192020148,
0.3190499544,
-0.0134065421,
0.2020145506,
0.3340759277,
-0.1703176498,
-0.0863788351,
0.2886378169,
0.7634074688,
0.9095022082,
-0.3044557571,
0.2221283168,
0.3677782416,
-0.2761179209,
0.208922714,
-0.0134493681,
0.2537955046,
0.1342167258,
0.7381430268,
0.6904486418,
0.068815276,
-1.2272160053,
0.5482729673,
-0.2124619633,
-0.5808489323,
-0.0493566133,
0.0453529805,
0.3096525669,
0.2487695366,
0.2050533742,
-0.4823825955,
0.0909319595,
-0.5808851123,
0.1423741579,
0.4055101275,
-0.3867906928,
-0.199387759,
0.72767663,
-0.0719992816,
-0.1313495636,
0.3733329177,
0.1963608414,
-0.2608317733,
0.785618782,
0.6202430725,
0.2122110724,
-0.0938970074,
0.1162343174,
0.315171957,
0.2329665869,
0.1105889082,
0.4994492233,
0.321737498,
-0.4062891006,
-0.5149943233,
-0.2061944753,
-0.9311744571,
0.5082482696,
-0.849691391,
0.1916783899,
-0.4910802543,
-0.0743177533,
0.4371656775,
-0.1215158999,
-0.8220016956,
0.4651755393,
0.0245490801,
0.8649627566,
-0.9180095196,
0.3936822414,
0.7642716169,
-0.2476061732,
-0.747056067,
-0.4357447922,
0.1573069543,
-1.2422988415,
0.4209111035,
0.1567888111,
0.4492297471,
-0.3945260048,
-0.478548795,
-0.4370642304,
0.8274615407,
0.3477623463,
-0.6355800033,
-0.031509608,
0.1824536473,
0.681681335,
-0.4696512222,
0.6502227187,
0.5280615687,
0.3695406914,
-0.0598402172,
-0.930649817,
0.2799327672,
-0.1463096738,
-0.1591666341,
-0.0046357634,
-0.3671995103,
0.7648374438,
-0.5781644583,
0.0330241658,
0.0078267846,
0.0700048581,
0.4797293842,
0.5029512644,
0.4779005349,
0.4282509387,
0.7691478133,
-0.2541751266,
1.2521352768,
0.1092303321,
0.2283696234,
0.9954220057,
-0.4607928693,
0.7563149929,
0.5501607656,
-0.6123568416,
0.6528551579,
0.7593399882,
-0.0741798729,
0.1502882689,
0.6243588328,
-0.1695091575,
-0.6373760104,
-0.1420404911,
-0.4359494746,
0.4202052951,
0.5160999894,
-0.3241051733,
-0.3674806654,
0.279161185,
0.0170449857,
0.0923580304,
-0.2232777923,
0.8384674191,
0.1102689505,
-0.6943212748,
0.946906507,
-0.2063914984,
0.0421012715,
-0.5640663505,
0.0162037984,
-0.3102878332,
0.2040091902,
0.0359950997,
-0.7638901472,
0.1726534516,
0.0957772657,
-0.1796672195,
-0.0315508954,
0.3325897455,
-0.3334636986,
-0.4408339262,
0.0052502342,
0.6041378975,
0.6275467277,
0.1552448124,
-0.9091562629,
0.1608770341,
-0.2138656676,
-0.2325960994,
0.21920757,
0.3994246125,
-0.089645952,
1.144530654,
0.5096467137,
0.1940271854,
-0.0453731306,
0.1014125496,
0.7491315007,
-0.7084987164,
-0.0391392112,
-0.8116051555,
0.1425903589,
0.1091209128,
-0.232380867,
0.3652573228,
0.412226826,
0.3871585131,
-0.1139274687,
0.55410254,
0.4131419063,
1.0428642035,
-0.687150836,
0.4210869372,
-0.8347353339,
0.3036439717,
0.0933031216,
-0.3551249504,
-0.5093289614,
0.3038942814,
-0.1552954912,
0.1397917718,
0.9385656714,
0.8085480332,
0.1251303703,
-0.132477507,
0.4396773875,
0.5511718392,
0.3576664627,
1.0840853453,
0.6979500055,
-0.4929899275,
0.5765155554,
-0.1249331236,
-0.0856415555,
-0.3872252107,
-0.8811590672,
-1.1081229448,
-0.3066429496,
-0.3469490707,
-0.3477900326,
0.2233025432,
0.9361525178,
0.6296287179,
-0.9620200992,
-0.062693499,
0.2215678841,
0.1757811457,
-0.2566981316,
-0.1631111652,
0.3956029117,
-0.2472802401,
-0.502568543,
0.5764171481,
0.2445343584,
0.0954740718,
-0.097561568,
0.1511729211,
0.1024532765,
0.2198536247,
0.2943596542,
0.1537437439,
-0.8891812563,
-0.0913459733,
0.0452645011,
-0.1597931981,
0.1606602222,
0.8788806796,
-0.8962090015,
0.551143527,
0.2181967497,
0.8332569599,
0.2301567197,
-0.0091865864,
0.5783724785,
-0.298543781,
-0.269972086,
0.331761688,
0.3650167882,
0.2116459906,
-0.1038366109,
0.4179886281,
0.1413556635,
-0.583635509,
-1.0950909853,
0.031417165,
-0.9632161856,
-0.5383819938,
0.9840942025,
-0.2644099593,
-0.1141789183,
-0.392003715,
-0.215272963,
-0.0950825736,
0.0770107657,
0.7279477715,
0.8379129171,
-0.2841432393,
-0.2221724838,
-1.1117372513,
0.4605941474,
0.8911397457,
-1.0394295454,
0.1542412937,
0.506839931,
0.5457592607,
-0.2978242338,
0.7339155078,
-0.3885947466,
0.6393471956,
-0.1828343719,
-0.2274332643,
-0.2102761865,
-0.1317762583,
-0.5352387428,
0.2564046979,
0.0941240788,
-0.0042288089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18059v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18059v3
|
Token-Specific Watermarking with Enhanced Detectability and Semantic Coherence for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T05:43:22 | 2024-06-06T04:49:37 |
Mingjia Huo, Sai Ashish Somayajula, Youwei Liang, Ruisi Zhang, Farinaz Koushanfar, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models generate high-quality responses with potential
misinformation, underscoring the need for regulation by distinguishing
AI-generated and human-written texts. Watermarking is pivotal in this context,
which involves embedding hidden markers in texts during the LLM inference
phase, which is imperceptible to humans. Achieving both the detectability of
inserted watermarks and the semantic quality of generated texts is challenging.
While current watermarking algorithms have made promising progress in this
direction, there remains significant scope for improvement. To address these
challenges, we introduce a novel multi-objective optimization (MOO) approach
for watermarking that utilizes lightweight networks to generate token-specific
watermarking logits and splitting ratios. By leveraging MOO to optimize for
both detection and semantic objective functions, our method simultaneously
achieves detectability and semantic integrity. Experimental results show that
our method outperforms current watermarking techniques in enhancing the
detectability of texts generated by LLMs while maintaining their semantic
coherence. Our code is available at https://github.com/mignonjia/TS_watermark.
|
[
-0.2040659487,
-0.6735125184,
0.4189635515,
-0.0183538068,
-0.7181219459,
0.1623572111,
-0.0547613241,
-0.5874335766,
0.2552417517,
0.6423931122,
-0.420098871,
-0.5634199977,
-0.7943633199,
0.0275833048,
-0.430911541,
0.8173937201,
0.0676457956,
-0.2167535871,
-0.1883723885,
-0.4807555974,
-0.380150944,
-0.5155080557,
-0.703034997,
-0.2498144954,
0.3626342416,
0.2595846653,
0.4390628636,
0.962997973,
0.5092157722,
0.3141283691,
-0.3319484293,
0.4186903536,
-0.3466956615,
0.2803125381,
0.0289891306,
-0.355430007,
-0.3175072074,
-0.1537884027,
0.5560685396,
0.2330602258,
0.2425396144,
0.1035671383,
0.053619206,
0.3217739165,
-1.0654160976,
0.1673778147,
-0.8965377212,
0.0403100587,
-0.3347394764,
-0.2168778032,
-0.3545119166,
0.0716674477,
-0.077910237,
-0.8215922117,
0.0497774146,
0.3501144648,
1.126511693,
0.1637908667,
-0.2416525185,
-0.3475681841,
-0.2360421866,
1.1669588089,
-0.8288090229,
0.366427511,
0.3633313775,
-0.0941435248,
-0.0156529304,
-0.619472146,
-0.4858413935,
-0.057128109,
0.1674133837,
0.1711595803,
-0.1206859425,
0.014838024,
-0.0116752451,
0.1803087145,
-0.2804621458,
-0.0663478374,
0.147190541,
-0.6699778438,
0.4006822109,
0.0116077745,
0.5652140379,
-0.1220341101,
-0.54598701,
0.0764200538,
-0.4899927974,
-0.0608408228,
0.5650191903,
0.4824880958,
0.0517984629,
0.4399963915,
-0.2476295084,
0.3848210573,
-0.2584937215,
-0.5496736169,
0.1384162903,
-0.5701010227,
0.1112409532,
0.0968502536,
0.7600374222,
0.1034512669,
0.0617989451,
-0.2630378902,
-0.4666425884,
0.0815747008,
-0.114656955,
-0.8923966289,
0.2443417162,
0.0743239,
-0.4631481171,
-0.468210727,
0.073501192,
-0.4353452623,
-0.3770112395,
-0.3687611818,
0.6029241681,
-0.3304743767,
-0.2983904779,
0.3108904064,
-0.4522327483,
-0.0362845138,
0.1365125179,
-0.737598598,
0.0920213014,
0.9056890011,
0.8924041986,
-0.3126968741,
-0.0469243117,
-0.845913589,
0.6474691033,
-0.1927506328,
0.6454545259,
-0.5915612578,
-0.2271119058,
-0.2023814917,
-0.3823854327,
0.0600073524,
-0.5920643806,
0.701462388,
-0.6179391742,
-0.0783705041,
-0.1080647781,
-0.645288229,
0.0717314705,
0.3763014972,
-0.7175658941,
0.9387276769,
-0.1988071501,
-0.8160966039,
0.5455158353,
-0.7251849174,
-0.4262956977,
0.1235181615,
0.0687754899,
-0.7022719383,
0.1317422241,
0.2186024636,
0.4539223015,
-0.3352835178,
0.4892835915,
-0.3122249842,
-0.2217307091,
0.1660286337,
-0.5246534348,
0.5311015844,
0.0794766024,
-0.4335897863,
0.3938656747,
-0.9001432657,
0.1455916464,
0.1573695242,
-0.425905019,
-0.6524448991,
0.0698571205,
0.0557299405,
-0.1226070449,
0.5296495557,
-0.7073461413,
-0.2315800637,
-0.1340780556,
0.6267101765,
0.8606787324,
-0.042605672,
0.3282926679,
-0.07673309,
0.2492861599,
0.2216852456,
0.4282717705,
-0.1115486622,
-0.4939442277,
-0.8593338728,
-0.72928828,
0.2307299078,
0.2917922735,
-0.775798142,
0.6548751593,
-0.3329881728,
-0.3021986485,
-0.2793431282,
0.3486801684,
0.4837881029,
0.4931771159,
0.456791997,
-0.2536539435,
-0.2298519611,
-0.9764554501,
-0.5492737889,
-0.2296328992,
0.2860816419,
0.341645658,
0.6655650735,
-0.2804448605,
0.9014027715,
-0.4060554802,
-0.2302170396,
-0.3541155159,
0.0864455998,
-0.2060428709,
0.5856646299,
0.409920305,
-0.9659486413,
-0.307800889,
-0.0336330906,
-0.4693332016,
-0.3892922699,
0.0698630959,
-0.2754346132,
-0.0312482715,
0.5607827902,
-0.376447916,
0.413967371,
0.6953040361,
-0.4335677326,
0.3356667161,
-0.0605389774,
-0.0285807513,
-1.0772149563,
0.0945613012,
-0.2858581841,
-0.3925922513,
-0.4074175656,
0.2363904417,
0.0565537401,
-0.1694817096,
-0.2277839333,
0.7767531872,
-0.3871933222,
0.1895811856,
-0.3922916651,
0.0552431718,
0.3504262865,
0.3252051473,
-0.2198922485,
0.6655948758,
0.4486813247,
-0.3644713163,
0.1144497469,
-0.0418467224,
-0.3259149194,
0.5831083655,
-0.7861905098,
0.1664862782,
-0.0722351596,
0.0050413162,
-0.905090332,
0.03335201,
0.2635899186,
-0.1427167207,
0.1763437241,
-0.1559599638,
-0.6255866885,
0.2660456002,
-0.444786042,
0.5424671769,
0.0363801345,
-0.467315644,
0.8256616592,
0.3233527541,
0.103278771,
-0.589173913,
-0.6700429916,
0.3657088876,
-0.1540186256,
-0.6192718744,
0.5072112679,
0.0226973891,
-0.0450804383,
0.1568300128,
-0.3144190311,
-0.2700336277,
0.3268427849,
0.2771782875,
0.1517877281,
-0.1908326447,
-0.0952648222,
0.2622700036,
-0.6132751107,
-0.4048372209,
-0.4126320183,
0.5888369083,
0.0908946097,
-0.5554294586,
-0.9238482118,
0.4441216588,
0.60514009,
-0.5057715178,
0.7967358232,
0.7775697112,
-0.3834374249,
-0.2078202218,
-0.522049129,
-0.0655286163,
-0.5112944841,
0.3453487158,
-0.3345492482,
-1.0930826664,
0.4953291416,
0.0092136944,
-0.0727058873,
0.399078548,
0.2058636546,
0.3267351985,
0.7416317463,
0.3932898343,
-0.3178323507,
0.8603907228,
-0.1489287317,
0.3551381826,
-0.732679069,
-0.0980347693,
-0.6023507118,
-0.1292276233,
-0.2068665028,
-0.471126914,
0.0077098613,
0.2715036571,
-0.2514636517,
0.3137021363,
-0.4169168472,
0.6388595104,
0.7726759911,
0.0857202932,
0.5346089602,
0.0163635686,
-0.2366705984,
0.0329201035,
-0.560692668,
-0.5705022812,
0.8063700795,
0.0724222809,
0.5104906559,
-0.0400765948,
0.9904646873,
0.232812956,
0.2894250453,
-0.6178206801,
0.711084187,
-0.1372286975,
-0.6721445322,
-0.3484552503,
-0.6129484177,
-0.8754429221,
0.4462839663,
-0.198326245,
-0.6893612742,
-0.0596788079,
-0.1353862286,
0.1589002609,
0.3638287485,
-0.655759573,
0.8671374321,
-0.2572605312,
-0.4685855508,
-0.271240592,
-0.3806107938,
-0.0428947657,
-0.1982088238,
0.3388936222,
-0.6948981881,
-0.604316771,
0.6813465953,
-0.6130862832,
0.7058591247,
-0.2702762783,
-0.0755051672,
0.3983844817,
-0.1063546091,
0.6652712822,
0.1587162763,
-0.1958738416,
0.2091746032,
-0.1028906554,
-0.5011078715,
-0.2897449434,
0.5339711308,
-0.5999845862,
-0.4437885284,
-0.2193303108,
-0.5118605494,
-0.0993914306,
0.590329349,
0.1449960321,
0.5093393326,
0.1075687036,
0.4112616479,
0.2901198566,
-0.226898402,
0.702249229,
0.275326252,
0.1959023476,
-0.6909545064,
1.0934946537,
0.001700428,
0.3025231063,
0.5881360769,
0.5227857232,
-0.2969813347,
-0.9644976258,
-0.2830026746,
0.071495004,
-0.7480278611,
-0.2981418669,
-0.4512859285,
0.0761354789,
-0.001050145,
-0.0648622587,
-0.5433760285,
-0.2000699788,
-0.4581670165,
0.1044483259,
0.1265519708,
0.321739763,
0.1495982111,
0.2897375226,
-0.8169152737,
0.4738872945,
0.1970801204,
0.4107743502,
0.079354614,
-0.278470397,
-0.2012998164,
0.1496907026,
-0.1254195422,
-0.2564465702,
0.0841533616,
0.3470275998,
0.4140293002,
0.560680747,
0.2518226504,
0.8499859571,
-0.4226403236,
0.5737346411,
0.3949536383,
-1.4578870535,
0.3664640486,
-0.1889499873,
0.1391269565,
0.5710076094,
-0.2697895765,
-0.3050042391,
-0.6480437517,
-0.3298015594,
-1.1922911406,
0.4188165963,
0.3869326711,
0.5232668519,
0.0611093864,
0.456040144,
0.123325631,
0.2049866021,
-0.7588940263,
-0.0422421284,
-0.0388368666,
-0.4180832207,
0.279024601,
-0.3998574018,
-0.2284354419,
0.0549909547,
0.6386915445,
-0.3419992924,
-0.0150193265,
0.0981054902,
-0.183546111,
0.1912781,
0.1485466957,
0.4958752692,
0.5189278722,
0.2479025424,
0.2576399446,
-0.0366136208,
-0.6252216697,
0.278803736,
-0.2179080844,
-0.3683363497,
0.0591440238,
0.755345881,
0.7924768329,
0.1064515412,
-0.7651242614,
0.6738978028,
-0.0434530489,
0.0111926654,
0.1227350011,
0.3419705927,
0.1521242857,
0.3514568806,
0.5087493062,
0.0277018044,
-0.0456557162,
-0.2718616426,
-0.0045220675,
0.6838507056,
-0.1312700361,
-0.3030667603,
0.83396101,
0.3094963133,
-0.257653445,
0.1542709023,
-0.0807607248,
-0.5820840001,
0.5752242804,
0.4961105287,
1.0612299442,
0.2860927284,
-0.0621266253,
0.0831118152,
0.2346001118,
-0.1168310493,
0.1855024993,
-0.262083739,
-1.0639631748,
-0.2751292586,
-0.6769245267,
-0.4559122026,
-0.0524771027,
-0.5831446052,
0.1994924098,
-0.464331001,
-0.4027846456,
0.0962698683,
-0.097535938,
-0.3304281831,
0.2613250613,
0.0140352882,
0.5209137201,
-0.5646651387,
0.598972857,
0.3066552579,
-0.0753333792,
-0.5375542641,
0.147263974,
-0.1930594593,
-0.9733380079,
0.4906724393,
0.3919862807,
-0.3889169097,
0.0039375033,
-0.5813154578,
-0.8813390136,
1.0800790787,
0.8198366165,
-0.4049705267,
0.4312414229,
0.3141219914,
0.380169332,
-0.2046495825,
-0.1662581265,
0.0688751414,
0.4841105342,
-0.05566727,
-0.5854359269,
0.2657342553,
-0.1226745695,
0.2056409419,
0.2732910216,
-0.840505898,
0.5110278726,
0.060214866,
-0.2289685905,
0.2025532871,
0.4352244735,
0.3699721992,
0.3411723375,
0.5734736323,
0.7106617093,
0.7191064358,
-0.1884735972,
0.9892992973,
-0.5798856616,
0.4183963239,
0.7131481171,
-0.2158198208,
0.8698368073,
0.7402772307,
0.1791470051,
0.2402799129,
0.4488743842,
0.0820190161,
0.5272985697,
0.1894527525,
-0.5330529213,
-0.4235087037,
-0.61716187,
-0.170105949,
0.3715032339,
0.0164667964,
-0.3746177554,
0.1163715124,
-0.1617071331,
0.0350807048,
-0.2228005528,
-0.2198330164,
0.7106737494,
-0.0256420132,
-0.2123566717,
0.2232000828,
0.2664617896,
0.9243580699,
-0.6604620814,
0.3062043488,
-0.1671972275,
0.3079038858,
-0.1777983159,
-0.3495962322,
0.2140593827,
0.0003435939,
-0.1319137365,
-0.4145495296,
0.9898059368,
-0.4007858038,
-0.4164903164,
0.550660491,
0.4440109432,
-0.106049709,
-0.1291268021,
-0.6331045628,
0.3417724669,
-0.1925939769,
-0.4416231215,
0.2296877503,
0.5723511577,
-0.0623321086,
0.8673276305,
0.9200146198,
0.0939519033,
0.086056456,
0.2645954192,
0.7065760493,
-0.4365573823,
-0.5756491423,
-1.2066930532,
0.3018528223,
-0.2334612161,
-0.4301767945,
0.5545881391,
0.7504038811,
0.5861786604,
0.0397588611,
0.779093504,
0.177104786,
-0.122631371,
-0.444614917,
0.6936815381,
-0.8644108772,
0.1292874217,
-0.4748463631,
-0.830088973,
-0.5650347471,
0.3656051457,
0.0890591294,
-0.0586773604,
0.4524770379,
0.774507761,
-0.0943491757,
-0.0490146913,
0.360350877,
-0.4378862679,
0.5889918208,
0.3978910148,
0.7500144243,
-0.4236526787,
0.8492683768,
-0.0702397004,
0.081691958,
-0.1281368732,
-1.0994416475,
-0.854804039,
-0.4805288911,
-0.5487552881,
-0.1957935542,
0.0294904746,
0.7024782896,
0.8642353415,
-0.9726573229,
0.069637008,
-0.3262099922,
0.3520423174,
-0.0114421686,
-0.2211561054,
0.4912104309,
-0.201368615,
-0.8336367607,
0.0634107068,
0.8132963181,
0.3293210864,
0.0229466408,
-0.1731470823,
-0.0086646266,
0.2498069704,
0.5192179084,
-0.1655291021,
-0.668943584,
-0.5017978549,
-0.1891293228,
-0.3413853645,
-0.0352763683,
0.8214938045,
-0.1392949969,
0.4704227149,
0.6536853909,
0.9673615098,
0.3459457159,
-0.1056740358,
0.2024274021,
-0.8239523172,
0.4000803232,
0.3300632536,
0.5759855509,
0.4166345,
-0.0609668419,
0.44257918,
0.7256686091,
-0.0971095189,
-0.9807010293,
0.0670001507,
-0.8472269773,
-0.2170877308,
1.1374497414,
-0.3673129082,
-0.1399473101,
-0.20432432,
-0.2513608038,
0.2137993574,
-0.504899919,
0.6024153829,
0.9684272408,
0.145097062,
0.0249618795,
-0.2677194178,
0.1482539326,
0.5048308969,
-0.9045622945,
-0.0707679763,
0.083274968,
0.2933650911,
0.1949934512,
0.4133762121,
-0.1436493695,
-0.1142274067,
0.0831708536,
-0.042321939,
-0.2632266879,
-0.1357168406,
0.1534339041,
0.2686717808,
-0.0401359722,
-0.4598501027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18054v1
|
Contextualizing Generated Citation Texts
| 2024-02-28T05:24:21 | 2024-02-28T05:24:21 |
Biswadip Mandal, Xiangci Li, Jessica Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstractive citation text generation is usually framed as an infilling task,
where a sequence-to-sequence model is trained to generate a citation given a
reference paper and the context window around the target; the generated
citation should be a brief discussion of the reference paper as it relates to
the citing context. However, examining a recent LED-based citation generation
system, we find that many of the generated citations are generic summaries of
the reference papers main contribution, ignoring the citation contexts focus on
a different topic. To address this problem, we propose a simple modification to
the citation text generation task: the generation target is not only the
citation itself, but the entire context window, including the target citation.
This approach can be easily applied to any abstractive citation generation
system, and our experimental results show that training in this way is
preferred by human readers and allows the generation model to make use of
contextual clues about what topic to discuss and what stance to take.
|
[
-0.3125812411,
-0.4161201715,
0.806894362,
0.0292618815,
-0.545588553,
-0.2292425931,
-0.1418589354,
-0.4160606861,
0.1436812878,
0.2659335136,
-0.4168431461,
-0.2473743856,
-0.3252412379,
0.5077918768,
-0.5295085907,
1.3660600185,
0.0998111367,
-0.2379074842,
-0.4189341664,
0.0863322616,
-0.4657470882,
-0.454000771,
-0.293413341,
-0.5035789609,
0.8368659616,
0.46528247,
0.2632036805,
0.6130337119,
0.3930496275,
0.1158913225,
-0.2025188953,
0.084138833,
-0.4106413126,
0.46723333,
-0.6117509007,
-0.0399506055,
-0.0721763596,
-0.0003964889,
0.6630232334,
0.8663102984,
0.5297171474,
0.3736425638,
0.2374069244,
0.7106619477,
-0.7168759108,
-0.0533276461,
-0.920214057,
-0.1823868304,
-0.3360078335,
-0.6813054085,
-0.72706002,
-0.2729206085,
0.1993637085,
-0.3191316426,
0.5409421921,
0.0504752062,
0.6173233986,
-0.0441038385,
-0.780064106,
-0.4165665209,
-0.7697197795,
0.6913861632,
-0.3181396425,
-0.3472023904,
0.0378213227,
0.0513514243,
0.0363266096,
-0.7859988809,
-0.2336311489,
0.1741361916,
-0.2739186287,
0.0268269833,
-0.0396716855,
-0.1802323163,
0.3623563647,
0.048654642,
-0.5134533048,
-0.6206624508,
-0.3415495753,
0.1332960576,
0.6449136138,
-0.1278735399,
-0.0480716713,
-0.4873531163,
-0.2638819516,
-0.0074781356,
-1.0049747229,
-0.2566072345,
0.1073287576,
0.6505072713,
0.358981967,
0.5451024175,
-0.0756478533,
0.7689675093,
0.3104948997,
0.1164835021,
0.1287299395,
-0.4842554331,
-0.2175263166,
0.2544423342,
0.2782624066,
0.3481846452,
0.3378829956,
-0.4097026885,
-0.0749832764,
-0.4231676161,
0.4554546773,
-0.9571411014,
-0.0295859985,
0.1495566368,
-0.4495771527,
-0.3206853569,
0.3426321447,
-0.3220791519,
0.0324746259,
-0.4916443825,
0.057873141,
-0.2393732965,
-0.031640362,
-0.6922335625,
-0.2886722386,
0.0397536978,
0.3521696925,
-0.8012231588,
-0.3669413924,
0.4246195555,
0.9074426293,
-0.1677090526,
-0.1368442923,
-0.6842078567,
0.7686316371,
-0.1291594505,
1.0285555124,
-0.650544405,
-0.7135246396,
0.2967743874,
-0.1706947833,
-0.1001844332,
-0.478303045,
0.3147412539,
-0.7549179196,
0.1123077571,
-0.5921308398,
-0.5418605208,
0.012705029,
0.0456283502,
-0.3932285011,
0.757491529,
-0.0004423196,
-0.9847558737,
0.6440294385,
-0.7617364526,
-0.7002716064,
0.1240710989,
-0.3265179992,
-0.3188227415,
0.1153700352,
-0.0136132501,
0.2676123679,
-0.1096871719,
0.5777378082,
0.2054927498,
-0.3610877693,
0.1343398243,
0.0870753974,
0.6481800079,
0.6084389687,
-0.4272734821,
0.337451756,
-0.8748189211,
0.0625170097,
-0.0732384324,
-0.5752843022,
-0.5475494862,
0.0103126718,
0.5716854334,
0.0408995971,
0.1764126718,
-0.5226612091,
0.0600208566,
-0.2410544157,
0.2713050544,
0.5938383341,
0.4661465287,
0.542579174,
-0.2938135266,
0.278721869,
-0.0641925856,
-0.4341012537,
-0.6994059086,
-0.5515674353,
-0.3173001707,
-0.0826772526,
0.1867660135,
0.2093276232,
-0.5760750175,
0.3267610073,
-0.3199292123,
-0.0342979878,
0.3113790751,
0.1168594137,
0.3991308808,
0.6595267653,
0.2748660445,
0.2293326557,
-0.7667270899,
-0.6672033072,
-0.5198730826,
-0.3585756421,
-0.1574164182,
0.2088570595,
0.7110081911,
-0.011760884,
1.440824151,
-0.604250133,
0.1401516795,
-0.1653594524,
0.4503585398,
-0.0395133942,
0.8008419275,
0.7078620791,
-1.0712201595,
-0.804268837,
-0.1174883693,
-0.9400364161,
-0.1477034688,
-0.4318117201,
-0.3007110357,
-0.1763165146,
0.8860312104,
-0.295047909,
0.3048891723,
-0.1979477704,
-0.4895683527,
0.3674088717,
-0.0592447445,
-0.017714696,
-1.3513427973,
0.7147239447,
-0.2153041959,
-0.1922979057,
-0.5818754435,
0.182120055,
0.1348119229,
-0.4830359221,
-0.2072804123,
0.4756264389,
-0.5571225286,
0.0036282078,
-0.7481281757,
-0.0269573703,
0.0884173587,
0.0919687599,
0.2222755402,
0.7068442106,
0.0138220862,
-0.5932588577,
-0.1996922046,
0.3191665709,
-0.1027595997,
0.7037492394,
-0.6226714253,
0.2287645191,
-0.4586569965,
0.4254601002,
-0.8983842731,
-0.3354496062,
-0.0756784007,
-0.3365235031,
0.3171411157,
-0.1367145032,
-0.3282192051,
-0.0229458865,
-0.3097569346,
0.704351306,
0.2535061538,
-0.6999205947,
0.2291069776,
-0.0622268952,
-0.2523644269,
-0.3801361024,
-0.479423672,
0.2411187738,
-0.3162806332,
-0.6752440333,
0.8370755911,
-0.2889941335,
-0.4001027346,
-0.0526441708,
0.1870884299,
0.1017989293,
-0.0819468722,
0.4446651042,
0.0686409771,
-0.1910277456,
0.4873184264,
0.2210212052,
-0.1009788513,
-0.0966691598,
-0.3134054244,
0.1106013805,
0.1942464411,
-0.1708320081,
0.0181307849,
1.0636205673,
0.3287020326,
-0.0616248958,
0.5374076366,
0.2032477111,
-0.1125443354,
-0.0671435073,
-0.1132524237,
-0.2326819748,
-0.4108970463,
0.1880856305,
-0.4771791101,
-0.5811351538,
0.212741062,
-0.1511859745,
0.4494534433,
0.4196579158,
0.5602788925,
-0.1350366026,
0.7218492627,
0.6513728499,
0.2630428672,
0.7853566408,
0.00092435,
0.057475578,
-0.8497601748,
-0.1605832279,
-0.6711330414,
-0.2800520062,
-0.1861147732,
-0.1660644114,
0.2724345326,
0.1401827037,
-0.371065259,
0.2298588753,
-0.740945816,
0.4015442729,
0.7085908055,
-0.1198062673,
0.4771878719,
0.3124328554,
0.0787867084,
-0.0040886886,
-0.3844018281,
-0.8847751617,
1.3101569414,
-0.176890552,
0.2967841327,
0.0100994594,
1.0990407467,
0.4128851593,
0.6602165103,
-0.4074609578,
0.3869391084,
0.3457077444,
-0.8145503402,
-0.1325085312,
-0.2013915479,
-1.1206784248,
0.4381618202,
0.0417060964,
-0.4647287726,
0.3915431798,
0.3131106496,
-0.2583853006,
0.0005698588,
-0.6509782672,
0.5007078052,
0.3445877135,
-0.2956634462,
-0.117012836,
-0.5947517157,
0.1509985626,
-0.0029752939,
0.0754540414,
0.2619469464,
0.2322097123,
0.7107710242,
-0.5425236225,
0.7166308165,
-0.220071137,
0.0301637184,
0.6320651174,
-0.2465608567,
0.6800211072,
0.2691940963,
-0.0634641945,
-0.4390829206,
-0.5566580892,
-0.5566559434,
-0.3235800266,
0.6190817952,
-0.3226030469,
-0.7546628714,
-0.5630282164,
-0.7099696994,
-0.1469607502,
0.0866617039,
0.6550474167,
0.3913773298,
-0.4548027813,
0.0806697831,
0.6218440533,
0.1448015422,
0.7300291657,
0.2520356774,
0.0462513342,
-0.3117012978,
0.6376977563,
-0.1482879966,
0.1424970329,
0.4434874952,
-0.1497784555,
-0.0776215792,
-0.650498867,
-0.467549324,
0.1824568957,
-0.8558512926,
-0.2028356045,
-0.546780467,
-0.0768312216,
-0.5979230404,
-0.5746532083,
0.0599910468,
-0.4335310459,
-0.7059986591,
-0.1912069023,
0.3473312557,
0.6705414653,
-0.07469289,
0.2575421929,
-0.5608057976,
-0.0699802563,
0.5316002965,
-0.2661605775,
0.1866423041,
-0.4644271433,
-0.4159500301,
-0.2269494534,
-0.6491159797,
-0.918192029,
0.1682516485,
0.4308958054,
0.3224411905,
0.4386720955,
0.1381006539,
0.4952215552,
-0.8850479722,
0.8230755329,
0.3406980932,
-0.729444325,
1.0781302452,
-0.5675381422,
0.5061436296,
0.6642552018,
0.1511707306,
-0.0969137549,
-0.4003951848,
-0.5253632665,
-0.9464338422,
0.4515224397,
0.4152714908,
0.2931019068,
-0.2161168456,
0.5436748266,
0.1298009604,
0.1958094686,
-0.9355949759,
-0.2687883973,
-0.354378283,
-0.1043963507,
0.0134306233,
-0.3782576621,
-0.3353022933,
0.0488835983,
0.5131358504,
-0.2478308976,
0.2370039672,
0.4786296785,
-0.2446806133,
-0.257940948,
0.3712822795,
0.9245142937,
0.9925905466,
-0.5875185728,
0.2016217262,
-0.4864885807,
-0.4274316132,
0.1699529737,
-0.0930300578,
-0.8988106847,
0.5030500293,
0.4165789187,
0.4294800758,
0.2355750799,
-0.5207543373,
0.261903435,
0.3567525148,
-0.3078494966,
-0.2439028323,
-0.0929370522,
0.0415648185,
0.2168670893,
0.9133386016,
0.2328023314,
0.1711045653,
-0.7184904218,
0.3111523688,
0.4115238786,
-0.3013216555,
-0.3656517267,
0.8353924155,
0.572756052,
-0.0853625387,
0.1275205165,
-0.1750896871,
-0.2568864524,
0.3604175746,
0.8752838969,
1.0572832823,
0.2759245038,
0.1368403137,
0.7554628253,
-0.0352314934,
0.2568002343,
0.0836796463,
-0.4724753797,
-0.321395874,
-0.3141089082,
-0.4214917421,
-0.2184903771,
-0.0837280601,
-0.7509364486,
-0.0116949473,
-0.2564589381,
-0.3135644794,
0.082629174,
-0.2318571508,
-0.1511536092,
0.2533076704,
0.1186861023,
0.7982864976,
-0.7810914516,
0.9367548823,
0.9142233729,
-0.628397584,
-0.1162979752,
0.3840371966,
-0.3178134561,
-0.1965983957,
1.1127597094,
-0.0186803807,
-0.1030235663,
-0.0321195498,
-0.5633047819,
-0.8507122397,
1.121243,
0.2374276221,
-0.2752088606,
-0.1506397724,
-0.176582396,
0.1869559586,
-0.890753746,
-0.0665303618,
0.1222326607,
0.4088018537,
0.3378585279,
-0.460919559,
0.3431045115,
-0.4880390763,
0.4045324028,
-0.0041461498,
-0.355610311,
0.9843611717,
-0.3195870519,
-0.3199816048,
0.2185689211,
1.0217077732,
0.5714232326,
0.5294035077,
0.2228144258,
0.0200071335,
0.7355946302,
0.1633169651,
1.02908957,
-0.0854302123,
0.0845133737,
1.2958263159,
-0.2147672176,
0.7103602886,
0.9923796654,
0.0992079079,
0.6805902123,
0.5333647132,
0.0270883963,
0.979807198,
0.062623851,
-0.3707488775,
-0.1369928569,
0.0233407356,
-0.7799659967,
-0.1647202522,
0.0628384352,
-0.872860074,
-0.4279208779,
0.1447340995,
-0.0851353407,
0.5197430849,
-0.3183143437,
0.5165239573,
0.0616627857,
-0.8492028117,
0.5909268856,
-0.0083322972,
0.6390593648,
-0.2873560786,
-0.0206140429,
-0.0462134555,
-0.0920181274,
-0.275803417,
-0.2960726321,
0.371142745,
0.4174667597,
-0.9434529543,
-0.4802025855,
0.5999225378,
-0.3129490912,
-0.3200806081,
-0.145521313,
0.4110561013,
0.1434438974,
-0.2152338624,
-0.1926069707,
-0.3598884642,
0.3970702291,
-0.3290200233,
0.5545514822,
0.2927777171,
0.0535756089,
0.0273645278,
0.6202296019,
-0.2002776861,
-0.0168040954,
0.0236629043,
0.7842981219,
-0.8937003016,
-0.6435526609,
-0.7145197392,
0.5125262737,
-0.3908551633,
-0.5894114375,
0.8908686638,
0.6241458654,
0.4552159011,
-0.2307125628,
1.0143252611,
-0.1792855561,
0.6664759517,
-0.3148569465,
0.5860376358,
-0.466001004,
0.276496917,
-0.4036288559,
-1.0646908283,
-0.145863995,
0.5970138907,
-0.1993152201,
0.0738647729,
0.709749043,
0.3331920803,
0.0518250614,
0.0819995701,
0.112739034,
-0.2712450325,
0.3922907114,
0.3837824762,
0.7353783846,
-0.3637976348,
0.715862751,
0.1548739076,
-0.1022998616,
-0.4216474891,
-0.9734578133,
-0.8505601287,
-0.6436160803,
-0.4719553292,
-0.4289159477,
-0.025484113,
0.6511894464,
0.611733675,
-0.8955385089,
-0.2507532835,
-0.3887637258,
0.1051402241,
-0.0527379997,
-0.2394649833,
0.5352771282,
-0.6423581839,
-0.8782603145,
0.4778768718,
0.0661512688,
0.0641279817,
0.0623083226,
0.0203511268,
-0.3896673322,
0.0909541696,
0.6754439473,
0.341940105,
-0.491966784,
-0.4006379247,
-0.1502293646,
-0.2541589141,
0.1969784647,
1.4122389555,
-0.8775151968,
0.269934386,
0.4012174606,
0.2848005295,
0.7481417656,
0.2372545749,
0.8745623231,
-1.0316082239,
0.2104091048,
0.1486477852,
0.2928444743,
0.4119918346,
-0.400641799,
0.5278000832,
0.3020641804,
-0.4897748828,
-0.9811454415,
0.3276609182,
-0.8292541504,
-0.7533704042,
0.9963268638,
-0.1111599728,
0.0452306941,
-0.3395827711,
-0.2171100974,
0.1941449344,
-0.3734063506,
0.646630764,
0.4767005444,
-0.2554413378,
0.4106984735,
-0.0698581934,
0.5433649421,
0.3877331614,
-0.6177473068,
0.1111817211,
0.5580599308,
0.1831210107,
0.619841516,
0.5205534101,
0.016842166,
0.4811745584,
0.100309819,
-0.0863340497,
-0.0544879213,
-0.1809653789,
0.0316364393,
0.5624160171,
0.0891813338,
0.0010882416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18050v1
|
MEGAnno+: A Human-LLM Collaborative Annotation System
| 2024-02-28T04:58:07 | 2024-02-28T04:58:07 |
Hannah Kim, Kushan Mitra, Rafael Li Chen, Sajjadur Rahman, Dan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Large language models (LLMs) can label data faster and cheaper than humans
for various NLP tasks. Despite their prowess, LLMs may fall short in
understanding of complex, sociocultural, or domain-specific context,
potentially leading to incorrect annotations. Therefore, we advocate a
collaborative approach where humans and LLMs work together to produce reliable
and high-quality labels. We present MEGAnno+, a human-LLM collaborative
annotation system that offers effective LLM agent and annotation management,
convenient and robust LLM annotation, and exploratory verification of LLM
labels by humans.
|
[
-0.3499632776,
-0.562232554,
0.6852280498,
0.3475598991,
-0.2770413756,
0.6269465685,
-0.348421514,
-1.0097532272,
0.4861069918,
0.674723506,
-0.5824907422,
-0.8599663377,
-0.5321455598,
0.5533528924,
-0.1283060312,
0.7033876181,
0.2240576446,
0.1320872307,
-0.4256818891,
-0.0878033116,
-0.4519292712,
-1.0335862637,
-1.128913641,
-0.8029216528,
1.1099361181,
0.1917311996,
0.8400658965,
0.851140976,
0.4394985437,
0.4354020357,
-0.4131202698,
0.5960540771,
-0.2385800928,
0.1810052991,
-0.2351531237,
-0.4929456115,
-0.9487910867,
0.0989874974,
0.4162304699,
0.8813599944,
0.128256321,
0.1857906729,
-0.0751740485,
0.3853226006,
-0.3095722497,
-0.0627413765,
-0.4982220232,
-0.0129497712,
-0.1436038464,
0.008609253,
-0.4486204088,
-0.6500815749,
0.1608457118,
-0.978133738,
-0.0982427076,
0.2127653807,
0.6517868042,
0.4141669571,
-0.2957267463,
-0.0511928126,
-0.7762030959,
0.7499409914,
-0.2991582751,
0.2945791483,
0.4737364054,
0.2985862792,
-0.2931232154,
-0.4973082244,
-0.5742792487,
-0.4333941638,
-0.2441266626,
-0.0005207599,
0.3200149536,
0.00341167,
0.0897917971,
-0.10782931,
-0.3592877984,
0.399933964,
-0.2617423236,
-0.5186840892,
1.0184388161,
0.3226646781,
0.3719864488,
-0.1041764468,
-0.6346235275,
0.0196219012,
-0.7613447905,
-0.5623540878,
0.4896941483,
0.5564957857,
-0.0598902218,
0.4680992961,
-0.2544025481,
0.7549364567,
-0.4549083412,
-0.041132763,
0.3504943252,
-0.430760026,
-0.0380959548,
0.2607591748,
1.0784817934,
0.3912976682,
0.4246551692,
-0.4186345637,
0.1020981148,
0.0596086867,
-0.1163467094,
-0.4083174169,
-0.2177106291,
0.3734474778,
-0.0148539543,
-0.4823004603,
-0.0537236258,
-0.6598172188,
-0.8241381645,
-0.6259899139,
0.6521490216,
-0.0094472133,
-0.3139688969,
0.0147746075,
-0.2316014171,
-0.267575264,
0.7769091725,
-0.6198264956,
0.3090164661,
0.7994347215,
0.8989303112,
-0.4312004447,
-0.6280035973,
-0.25070858,
0.262391001,
-0.352296263,
0.9939571023,
-0.2165684402,
-0.4048508406,
-0.2032622248,
0.0481781699,
0.0638076738,
-0.7494667172,
0.5138739944,
-0.3152624965,
0.1204214916,
-0.2379366308,
-0.5639103651,
-0.2404229045,
0.4755746424,
-0.8364604115,
1.192596674,
0.3436238468,
-0.6684625745,
0.3576433361,
-0.5409348011,
-0.0138213402,
0.5195826292,
-0.0705087259,
-0.2415307313,
-0.5173428059,
-0.1830793619,
0.6974468231,
-0.3852448761,
0.503326416,
-0.3299569786,
-0.5878092647,
0.6859372854,
-0.0709623843,
0.9466168284,
0.0741088092,
-0.0435509011,
0.5070903301,
-0.9014956951,
-0.242998153,
0.3200802803,
-0.7600758672,
-0.3839727342,
0.0137823522,
0.06648691,
0.237121582,
0.6634870768,
-0.5666431785,
0.370390147,
-0.194329679,
0.3437816501,
0.7376483679,
-0.3679001033,
0.3127546608,
-0.5220766664,
0.2852528393,
-0.3660620153,
0.1016453579,
-0.0499673747,
-0.6494421959,
-0.7574870586,
-0.5775715709,
0.4606526196,
0.8884881139,
-0.6731909513,
0.7558182478,
-0.2992064953,
-0.512245059,
-0.4856599569,
0.377663523,
0.3720298409,
0.3797244132,
0.2731601596,
-0.1079432368,
-0.7661939859,
-0.9526788592,
0.1164538711,
-0.2963090539,
-0.2425738126,
0.1817511022,
0.4532093108,
-0.4993782043,
0.8812198043,
-0.3079719543,
-0.3462049961,
-0.4757427275,
0.0250977427,
0.2151821703,
0.3384561241,
0.2819984555,
-0.6904815435,
-0.448944211,
0.3527909815,
-0.5826096535,
-0.3541624248,
0.0161678996,
-0.2150176018,
0.3141746819,
0.4138217866,
-0.4731086493,
0.1444193572,
0.7247765064,
-0.5168988109,
0.3873654902,
-0.3254513144,
0.0321208574,
-1.3077569008,
-0.0672438741,
-0.154199928,
-0.7136167884,
-0.4339161217,
-0.208551228,
-0.2374768257,
0.1796719879,
-0.5396918654,
0.6041517854,
-0.0149342977,
0.1149193943,
-0.1117992625,
0.3179513812,
0.1456884295,
0.4155946672,
0.39028427,
0.6990765929,
0.1818767041,
-0.455532819,
0.8699778914,
0.2353681922,
0.1347001046,
0.7466316819,
-0.677026391,
0.2805006206,
0.1841543168,
0.2028636336,
-0.9209123254,
-0.6133820415,
0.4756885469,
-0.456487745,
-0.0209683776,
-0.2235563546,
-0.9993531108,
-0.2257083058,
-0.4306949079,
0.2065474093,
0.0993463174,
-0.6910075545,
0.5750418305,
0.3621868193,
-0.1564105004,
-0.1179679036,
-0.6592440009,
0.3720307052,
-0.3841086328,
-0.7103188038,
0.2392065078,
0.0379377827,
-0.4607707262,
-0.0947252065,
0.6543123722,
-0.2709661126,
0.2840889394,
0.4534469247,
0.3905926049,
0.0912864879,
0.2180029899,
-0.299947232,
-0.4317435026,
-0.0442275405,
-0.0335038155,
0.6170413494,
0.0533782914,
-0.1206984967,
-0.7176963091,
0.3951174915,
0.4058288932,
0.1716413051,
0.8519061208,
0.5372236967,
-0.5712608099,
0.0220894795,
-0.6670910716,
0.0697105974,
-0.4723228216,
0.2451081872,
0.038306918,
-1.1046969891,
0.6598540545,
-0.3498080075,
-0.3003519177,
0.4765230715,
0.6228840947,
-0.311352551,
0.7206112146,
0.6476802826,
-0.059783943,
0.2471660525,
-0.0333505608,
-0.3532963991,
-0.8114400506,
-0.6765933633,
-0.5972076058,
-0.3206475973,
-0.5433760285,
-0.457890898,
0.1664361209,
-0.0779687017,
-0.2727641463,
0.7115628123,
-0.8611959219,
0.6294608116,
0.7700318098,
0.2230780274,
0.666620791,
-0.33128649,
0.0135693178,
0.0114778858,
-0.5183199048,
-0.7784621119,
0.9248720407,
0.2302296609,
0.5179108381,
0.0952938125,
0.8351088762,
0.4411382079,
0.5678936243,
-0.7620294094,
0.6395804286,
-0.0409023464,
-0.852869451,
-0.331076622,
-0.4083283544,
-0.9978448749,
0.1971132308,
-0.6425993443,
-1.1603736877,
-0.0439617448,
0.1200619787,
-0.5716374516,
0.272169292,
-0.8610414267,
0.8557344675,
-0.2896141708,
-0.3760437667,
-0.0159652438,
-0.5903556943,
0.1621596366,
-0.4599221945,
0.3601197898,
-0.5540822744,
-0.3091584742,
0.8716699481,
-0.5007626414,
1.0581309795,
0.2006519139,
-0.091428645,
0.4386712611,
0.1641129702,
0.3867868781,
-0.0069261338,
-0.1126235127,
0.3628123105,
-0.0264620483,
-0.0238504987,
-0.2624012232,
0.5942132473,
-0.8888387084,
-0.2213377357,
-0.3112062812,
-0.5615323782,
0.0716292411,
0.0172107387,
0.0567527004,
0.0281828996,
0.0748446807,
-0.0797637179,
0.4916734397,
-0.2725520432,
0.3446103632,
0.1164114773,
-0.5227640271,
-0.9803607464,
1.0120364428,
0.2277889252,
0.1940833479,
0.3109970093,
0.3416320384,
-0.1911096871,
-0.4904721677,
-0.446120739,
0.3469710648,
-0.6069330573,
-0.1747796983,
-0.5148339272,
-0.0489233658,
0.0442449339,
-0.3825400472,
-0.4828849137,
-0.5812857151,
-0.2937783301,
-0.0298519637,
0.8303396106,
1.0943523645,
-0.0590881705,
0.6175767183,
-0.850702405,
0.1055124924,
0.473987788,
0.1706427485,
-0.3690879345,
-0.0883224085,
-0.2455069572,
-0.042233225,
-0.0989546254,
-0.8532211185,
0.200142473,
-0.1944349557,
0.2951206267,
0.1100593731,
-0.2500757575,
0.41463992,
-0.2660697401,
0.7202829719,
0.1199668273,
-0.9488847852,
0.43543607,
-0.8414117694,
0.0076762708,
0.6097983718,
0.3812476397,
-0.6938029528,
-0.3451345861,
-0.3997166455,
-0.9645112753,
0.687286675,
0.2706966698,
0.0613407604,
0.0367253609,
0.5192041993,
0.1547794044,
-0.0041701407,
-0.7572073936,
-0.1488714665,
0.3604087532,
-0.2475212216,
-0.0776045844,
-0.271980077,
-0.0751134753,
-0.3828673363,
0.5956024528,
-0.0380373374,
0.1343642622,
0.3293720186,
0.0018217606,
0.0494212992,
0.0312887654,
0.6689949632,
0.572366178,
-0.3715670109,
0.2154824138,
0.5515604615,
-0.3199545145,
0.2204181403,
0.0440686159,
-0.1048189923,
-0.0259455182,
0.6580546498,
0.4040387571,
-0.0164628401,
-0.6097359061,
0.347533524,
-0.1406683028,
-0.312104404,
-0.5584954023,
0.1646122932,
0.7496477365,
0.3348367512,
0.2679669857,
-0.0900800005,
-0.0588781051,
-0.2272735983,
0.0525882281,
0.2064401805,
-0.3814940751,
-0.440510571,
0.7247867584,
0.5167222619,
-0.8005201817,
0.2937458456,
-0.2816150486,
-0.7223032117,
0.755589664,
0.3321394622,
0.7530972362,
-0.2195995152,
0.2847120762,
0.3599564135,
0.3434426188,
-0.2019958198,
0.2234577388,
0.0108442353,
-0.8292921782,
-0.825094223,
-0.4920338988,
-0.9829320908,
-0.1621922255,
-0.341381669,
0.3913750648,
-0.5478678942,
-0.4258019328,
0.0465799123,
0.0914003327,
-0.5695160031,
0.2946706414,
0.3760044575,
0.5928015113,
-0.7712051868,
0.8500124216,
0.7320196033,
-0.3570446074,
-0.6453233957,
-0.6950771809,
0.053426031,
-0.6694687009,
0.949246347,
0.2969095409,
-0.3730381727,
-0.0197328888,
-0.6434084177,
-0.7664437294,
1.2838048935,
0.4626460969,
-0.6648945808,
0.3397456706,
0.5235897899,
0.7433245182,
-0.410267204,
-0.0639533103,
0.4439635873,
0.6638884544,
0.1902218759,
-1.0504776239,
0.1305082887,
0.1855673045,
-0.1522651464,
0.1845818162,
-0.7147698998,
0.6673226357,
-0.0781424493,
0.0319768153,
0.3252154291,
0.3644664288,
0.1859196723,
0.3724641502,
0.4582241774,
0.5649704933,
0.9777584672,
-0.2361730635,
1.0372000933,
0.1326748729,
0.2330409288,
1.3368958235,
-0.304982692,
0.9062996507,
0.3720137179,
-0.3637959957,
0.2510273159,
0.8359040022,
0.104099758,
-0.1956840456,
0.3678403497,
-0.5612006783,
-0.7025662065,
-0.6848163009,
-0.0728228837,
0.2937115431,
0.3770538867,
-0.1939941496,
0.068586275,
-0.4193209708,
0.2494540662,
0.2569402456,
-0.196052283,
0.9675401449,
0.0279200282,
-0.2564376593,
0.3057434857,
-0.1044697985,
0.9400135875,
-0.3193405569,
-0.0206378922,
-0.0055817869,
0.0250361077,
-0.4879606664,
-0.7661075592,
0.4735627472,
-0.0729687139,
0.0576031022,
-0.0835501105,
0.7306673527,
-0.5437120199,
-0.6709649563,
0.7155333161,
0.5889884233,
0.2436449826,
-0.1670994759,
-0.3720664084,
0.3628709018,
-0.218676284,
-0.0568719581,
0.0169620942,
0.205149129,
-0.2887113988,
0.9271264672,
0.8373443484,
0.2752787471,
-0.0512147844,
0.1699026823,
0.7363770604,
-0.7481686473,
0.0914877653,
-1.3011444807,
0.4987769425,
-0.3643329442,
-0.2312822491,
0.5995950699,
0.4226879179,
0.9399579763,
0.2539017498,
0.7215256095,
0.4067706764,
0.6131355762,
-0.2603826523,
1.0182939768,
-0.3763447702,
0.0883163139,
-0.2232026011,
-1.2009361982,
-0.993801713,
0.605486989,
0.0089706667,
-0.1122825071,
0.4593276978,
0.5776740313,
0.4708064497,
-0.2893108428,
0.5030260682,
-0.1878496855,
0.1739416271,
0.5684387088,
1.3524621725,
-0.0686989203,
0.4898478985,
-0.4486460686,
0.059057612,
-0.113350451,
-1.0262640715,
-1.2836356163,
-0.4038464129,
-0.5783808231,
-0.2039636225,
-0.040632125,
1.4617197514,
0.8454904556,
-0.5575998425,
-0.2196274251,
0.2339668274,
0.5220322013,
0.2228010446,
-0.1834254563,
0.2415133268,
0.1688953936,
-0.8488017917,
0.215070188,
0.3923577368,
0.2616362274,
-0.4608006477,
-0.2683175206,
-0.1557312906,
0.0366935767,
0.5773553252,
-0.0914111435,
-0.6001815796,
-0.4426573813,
-0.265693903,
-0.2027058005,
0.2052172273,
0.451143682,
-0.8104416132,
0.4110813737,
0.5447688699,
0.622451663,
0.0722462609,
0.0513025634,
0.4777350724,
-0.6333682537,
0.2588931918,
0.1678328067,
0.321030885,
0.6641413569,
-0.5590969324,
0.7114454508,
0.4332575798,
-0.6373610497,
-0.5814231634,
0.0948801264,
-1.1614381075,
-0.0477737859,
1.1726920605,
-0.2067312002,
-0.3861614168,
-0.3750856519,
-0.6861454844,
0.1823359281,
-0.4049278498,
0.6177482009,
0.8157860637,
-0.0351416543,
0.1923602521,
-0.4117195904,
0.2211657465,
-0.0646999255,
-1.0558029413,
-0.1069105417,
0.3880747855,
0.2407897562,
0.5518254638,
0.6242639422,
0.1783509552,
0.0346872993,
-0.2087172866,
0.5108525157,
-0.3910665512,
-0.3482502699,
-0.1057357863,
-0.0625056401,
0.3599972129,
-0.1290590763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18048v1
|
Characterizing Truthfulness in Large Language Model Generations with Local Intrinsic Dimension
| 2024-02-28T04:56:21 | 2024-02-28T04:56:21 |
Fan Yin, Jayanth Srinivasa, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study how to characterize and predict the truthfulness of texts generated
from large language models (LLMs), which serves as a crucial step in building
trust between humans and LLMs. Although several approaches based on entropy or
verbalized uncertainty have been proposed to calibrate model predictions, these
methods are often intractable, sensitive to hyperparameters, and less reliable
when applied in generative tasks with LLMs. In this paper, we suggest
investigating internal activations and quantifying LLM's truthfulness using the
local intrinsic dimension (LID) of model activations. Through experiments on
four question answering (QA) datasets, we demonstrate the effectiveness
ohttps://info.arxiv.org/help/prep#abstractsf our proposed method. Additionally,
we study intrinsic dimensions in LLMs and their relations with model layers,
autoregressive language modeling, and the training of LLMs, revealing that
intrinsic dimensions can be a powerful approach to understanding LLMs.
|
[
-0.1178127304,
-0.8588175178,
0.9337861538,
-0.0461388268,
-0.083876051,
0.1302516162,
-0.2976471186,
-0.6483508945,
-0.1984762549,
0.3054091632,
-0.2745887935,
-0.3927692473,
-0.4068287313,
0.0853790939,
-0.2110202163,
0.6128122807,
-0.1594304591,
0.1358722001,
-0.7525064349,
-0.2555738986,
-0.0312539488,
-0.8110446334,
-0.4909652472,
-0.579623282,
0.4053990841,
0.1993135065,
0.5413756371,
0.5803146958,
0.5431304574,
0.2729888558,
-0.3008595109,
0.0452816486,
-0.3590980768,
0.3279109001,
-0.0711816177,
-0.7587220669,
-0.3134261966,
0.1891886443,
1.0410333872,
0.6803051829,
-0.0116684418,
0.5010176897,
0.1689439267,
0.4434334338,
-0.4631192982,
0.3125938773,
-0.8888432384,
-0.0092415987,
0.0681805685,
-0.1440206319,
-0.330401659,
-0.6758854389,
0.2271654308,
-0.289966464,
0.2289224863,
-0.0337499008,
0.8008327484,
0.2930076122,
-0.6396694183,
-0.2703974247,
-1.0047034025,
0.9495432377,
-1.0593826771,
0.3182359338,
0.6152306199,
0.0252021346,
0.2178839743,
-0.4894730151,
-0.7461180091,
-0.5283929706,
-0.0449523032,
-0.1212105528,
0.0500658527,
-0.0972127095,
0.2892469764,
0.7720006108,
-0.5201438665,
0.300796926,
0.1022623405,
-0.2517416775,
0.3698691726,
0.2088130116,
0.0967608839,
-0.0986509025,
-0.4609455466,
-0.0041208612,
-0.8431637883,
0.2723867297,
0.5871964693,
0.0600660965,
-0.1275123209,
0.6237584352,
-0.2850644588,
0.3855903447,
0.1520675421,
-0.4977882206,
0.3482825458,
-0.4128513932,
-0.0431121662,
-0.0247168373,
0.6189778447,
0.0010185083,
-0.0638269112,
-0.2115503252,
-0.2329034209,
-0.12680085,
0.1259199828,
-1.0447028875,
0.4147387147,
0.3403829932,
-0.4682176709,
-0.517893672,
-0.0492845476,
-0.1305868775,
-0.3725828826,
-0.4647467434,
0.528829813,
-0.6295728087,
-0.4008396864,
-0.0024026956,
0.1868436188,
0.481711477,
0.1069138646,
-0.6160924435,
0.0552648567,
0.6488799453,
0.6027242541,
0.0314628705,
-0.3531722128,
-0.3894343376,
0.0539369024,
-0.4328222573,
0.496591568,
-0.5379750729,
-0.0316118076,
0.0323333926,
-0.3710002899,
0.0276028868,
-0.7014480233,
0.7990290523,
-0.6612543464,
0.1350920051,
-0.5407678485,
-0.7572060227,
-0.2781614959,
0.5396066308,
-0.3571178019,
1.0654232502,
0.0288146269,
-0.8714054823,
0.273522079,
-0.4192781746,
-0.1488070786,
0.1337768435,
-0.1657217443,
-0.3271123171,
0.5791143179,
0.0337915123,
0.5360651612,
-0.3309466541,
0.4722135961,
-0.398019582,
0.0216941778,
0.7616603374,
-0.8568887711,
0.709416151,
0.0112820948,
-0.2043993026,
-0.0458820164,
-0.7521182895,
0.2244315892,
0.1149772853,
-0.273296088,
-0.31490466,
-0.0297139473,
-0.5505420566,
0.1849427819,
0.6327280998,
-0.8179255724,
-0.0126924915,
-0.5216725469,
0.340444535,
0.7658525705,
0.2916001081,
0.2698111534,
-0.207812652,
0.4517388046,
0.2249132395,
0.1639548987,
-0.0335252844,
-0.3382475972,
-0.7472836375,
-0.12183211,
0.3471217752,
0.2148756683,
-0.7812241912,
0.8009929657,
-0.5511002541,
-0.5607463717,
-0.3543529809,
0.1489068568,
0.336422205,
0.71568501,
0.0553581268,
-0.3088637888,
0.0874320418,
-1.1406264305,
-0.1264619827,
-0.673206985,
-0.2768599689,
0.3274371028,
0.6333385706,
-0.0883333683,
1.1515936852,
-0.2452824563,
0.0759257004,
0.1037159637,
0.6121942401,
0.0864753649,
0.2813103497,
0.4216685295,
-0.686778605,
-0.4721374214,
-0.0515969396,
-0.9750375748,
-0.0752762556,
-0.0956022367,
0.2151005566,
0.1332576126,
0.1135763898,
-0.5474172235,
0.338673532,
0.6849176288,
-0.1858022809,
0.7074855566,
-0.2340606749,
0.1006681025,
-0.8365429044,
0.025451988,
0.0412313789,
-0.1745292842,
-0.5896679759,
0.2330401093,
0.0975607708,
0.2245958298,
-0.3079866767,
0.5335139036,
-0.6051753163,
-0.2040761411,
-0.2083176672,
-0.0381951295,
0.0536918677,
0.43728742,
0.0980234593,
0.8434473276,
0.6782012582,
-0.5053992271,
0.5371098518,
0.041729793,
-0.6545266509,
0.7660508752,
-0.7996421456,
0.3588176668,
-0.215802744,
0.1114402637,
-0.739285171,
-0.1291680634,
-0.2321633101,
-0.7580330968,
0.2472259402,
-0.0091858869,
-0.9381783009,
-0.1083642542,
-0.3467912078,
0.4935681522,
0.4008048475,
-0.520699501,
0.7955086231,
0.2219387889,
-0.1906623691,
-0.2623568773,
-0.6391512752,
0.0951900259,
-0.3013763726,
-0.8199210167,
0.0820832774,
-0.2790533006,
-0.4944700897,
-0.1523077041,
-0.1265922636,
-0.0427558869,
0.127810806,
0.3607985079,
0.1205365956,
-0.3787761927,
0.2077025026,
-0.1089241952,
0.0394979157,
0.3665214181,
-0.2201603949,
0.5068185925,
-0.6364190578,
-0.3893164098,
-0.4735229313,
0.0656474903,
0.6443659663,
-0.4156063199,
1.2051464319,
0.6413547397,
-0.3926700354,
-0.0544189773,
-0.7391952872,
-0.3942032754,
-0.5048012137,
0.1790918559,
-0.3634839654,
-0.9271705747,
0.828481257,
0.1233022511,
-0.1745581627,
0.3376246691,
0.8123002648,
-0.0380161218,
1.001021266,
0.5234821439,
-0.0125698661,
0.1663224548,
-0.0936216861,
0.334623307,
-1.1225038767,
-0.1702988893,
-0.6570348144,
-0.1183736622,
-0.4826830029,
-0.5468147397,
0.7559353113,
0.216600582,
-0.3770832717,
-0.2109387666,
-0.0901248157,
0.3789212108,
0.7053598166,
0.1686047912,
0.4282572269,
-0.0028040966,
-0.1350426078,
-0.1415095031,
-0.3690036535,
-0.7440833449,
0.9831733704,
0.8367299438,
0.7715429664,
0.1063511521,
0.433121413,
-0.1612158865,
0.3035314083,
-0.801891923,
0.5308784246,
0.2718513906,
-0.7544692159,
-0.5003777146,
-0.8269903064,
-0.5823813081,
-0.0565310679,
-0.1414797008,
-0.8902438879,
0.2127509415,
0.0103198094,
-0.2902737558,
0.523534596,
-0.6021618843,
0.5086088777,
-0.3494840562,
-0.2881850898,
-0.1735182256,
-0.6719482541,
0.3483502269,
-0.1523814499,
-0.0972801745,
-0.1682307571,
-0.0853672698,
0.5415370464,
-0.1132439822,
1.0575799942,
0.0983859971,
-0.6320517659,
0.3128478527,
0.2475147694,
0.6988199353,
0.0996605903,
-0.3597093225,
0.453015089,
-0.1159317046,
-0.2644201815,
-0.6440306902,
0.8705407977,
-0.8944186568,
-0.4941678345,
-0.3954204619,
-0.6752594113,
-0.6718042493,
0.07491301,
0.2653896213,
0.5205691457,
-0.1580007076,
0.6931889653,
1.0644190311,
-0.2712737322,
0.2950141728,
0.6365552545,
-0.0637225062,
-0.0562881529,
0.9015824795,
0.2113702893,
0.5816643238,
0.7202689648,
0.4900766313,
-0.5293218493,
-0.5901944041,
0.028870929,
0.268337667,
-0.6808183789,
-0.2268027365,
-0.4691576362,
-0.4680186212,
-0.426846385,
0.2144461125,
-0.366504997,
-0.2976818383,
-0.3012517095,
-0.4187519252,
0.136265099,
0.5622174144,
-0.0829814523,
0.0003581651,
-0.9009201527,
0.3171057999,
0.6646178961,
0.3872821033,
0.0935768336,
-0.8832982183,
-0.306491226,
0.3487250507,
-0.231793642,
-0.6654441357,
0.2230078578,
0.1311555356,
0.6945701838,
0.6512761712,
0.2920851111,
0.0502379388,
-0.1634911895,
0.9894397259,
-0.0231538955,
-1.1184911728,
0.3905550838,
-0.3940588534,
0.2883274853,
0.4528177381,
0.4362000823,
-0.36423105,
-0.6773946881,
-0.7070319653,
-0.454264313,
0.264845103,
0.2922830284,
0.4283501506,
0.2739607096,
0.5969421864,
0.2094362974,
0.4005127549,
-0.9138808846,
-0.353793323,
0.0337831527,
-0.1416803002,
0.0115423221,
-0.6391142011,
-0.06698668,
-0.1015388295,
0.7242640853,
-0.3596056998,
0.2165991962,
0.1318466365,
0.0851034895,
-0.3256187737,
0.3395610154,
0.3820792437,
0.9216732383,
-0.3267954886,
0.4824484587,
0.1649511307,
-0.3900733292,
0.1742845476,
-0.3862326145,
-0.3478015959,
-0.2639427781,
0.5894560218,
0.8734850883,
-0.4024469256,
-0.3756747246,
0.5023859739,
-0.037934728,
-0.0264771916,
-0.2761342227,
0.0369142555,
-0.0504483245,
0.0947144479,
0.3332003057,
-0.0663493499,
-0.1489097774,
-0.8087282777,
-0.1647727638,
0.5733274817,
-0.485357374,
-0.6039516926,
0.3720293939,
0.1656170189,
-0.0073718131,
0.6683551669,
-0.30880481,
-0.7560123801,
0.4099370241,
0.3144443631,
1.0735845566,
-0.2855554521,
0.3503271639,
0.3899435401,
0.6217742562,
0.1938576698,
-0.0132808797,
0.0617935807,
-1.2561218739,
-0.6227454543,
-0.747720778,
-0.4774247706,
0.3429253101,
-0.8611851931,
-0.4275092781,
-0.2049631774,
-0.096472092,
-0.3464165628,
0.1921137124,
-0.5237499475,
0.3127563,
0.2745418251,
0.6453749537,
-0.7949244976,
0.9871475697,
0.4697333276,
-0.2455295175,
-0.7335492969,
0.4077486098,
0.0136956787,
-0.9722725153,
0.8763402104,
0.0182339009,
-0.2320486158,
-0.1590648293,
-0.8664122224,
-0.8025281429,
1.0208672285,
0.4922282994,
-0.2665072381,
-0.011368542,
0.4561730325,
0.7990909219,
-0.2510781288,
0.111648269,
0.4240615368,
0.4687486291,
0.1413927972,
-0.8573535085,
0.0313253216,
0.0122419605,
0.214739874,
-0.1026455685,
-0.5951533914,
0.7688192725,
-0.1877107769,
-0.241098091,
0.1482693404,
0.9639761448,
0.1518076658,
-0.0828123912,
0.4922381043,
0.7312865853,
0.9199086428,
-0.0377495959,
1.1470103264,
-0.479806006,
0.5014621615,
1.1060386896,
-0.4017890692,
0.9081583619,
0.3914633691,
-0.0766179413,
0.3982648253,
0.307941556,
0.2248412669,
0.1634121537,
0.160471037,
-0.5153523684,
-0.4269880354,
-0.398234576,
-0.2468567938,
0.3519625664,
0.3108967245,
-0.1567200869,
0.0319799669,
0.0246624965,
-0.1258120239,
-0.036366608,
-0.2083596438,
0.7397412062,
0.068398051,
-0.3413900733,
0.4246985018,
0.0440414324,
0.5895140171,
-0.6299162507,
0.1433150619,
-0.3426808417,
0.0488626696,
0.1010252759,
-1.1130142212,
0.0629488602,
-0.0240723323,
-0.2929592133,
-0.2014020979,
0.5451883078,
-0.3435918093,
-0.589286685,
0.0169697218,
0.485542506,
-0.1266168505,
-0.4263012111,
-0.4430350065,
0.0274903569,
-0.0345733128,
-0.3193971813,
0.3334773481,
0.8307827711,
0.3320337832,
0.9851434827,
0.5976740122,
0.2586310804,
0.1075480878,
-0.1665991694,
0.5067452192,
-0.4986076951,
-0.2008129209,
-0.6226123571,
0.272251159,
0.0241710059,
-0.3719909787,
1.0249809027,
0.5354687572,
0.8117517233,
0.1480002999,
0.592266798,
0.1980549842,
0.6904217005,
-0.7321374416,
0.4514962435,
-0.4126652181,
0.4308783412,
0.1899899095,
-1.0281682014,
0.0819644481,
0.4519616663,
-0.4694120586,
0.0387988612,
0.7633574009,
0.8074640632,
0.2233851105,
-0.0471262783,
0.5065406561,
0.7669295669,
0.3071587086,
0.2807789743,
1.2137384415,
-0.1859783679,
0.1180450097,
-0.4769768417,
-0.2546468675,
-0.0368492231,
-0.9632219076,
-0.7913159728,
-0.7129089236,
-0.486187607,
-0.3719944656,
-0.6092556715,
0.6235013008,
0.6381998062,
-0.6142767072,
-0.0459314846,
0.1403962076,
0.1462177187,
-0.0797006264,
-0.2871791422,
0.281340301,
-0.3123005331,
-0.6216694117,
0.2451550514,
0.2776463628,
0.1914613843,
-0.7237630486,
0.0458702706,
0.1684631705,
0.3752882481,
0.6595851779,
0.0020258881,
-0.674929738,
-0.5627070665,
-0.0194594488,
-0.3835060596,
0.1966696978,
0.7628091574,
-0.5792928338,
0.260340631,
0.6652521491,
0.3698126972,
0.3489342034,
0.1236763522,
0.5743445158,
-1.0051814318,
-0.1914291829,
0.4759210646,
0.3069176972,
0.454156667,
-0.3755397201,
0.3079202771,
-0.0045653577,
-0.7076631188,
-0.9281685948,
0.2889136672,
-0.8229004145,
-0.1432984322,
1.3215347528,
-0.1826250553,
-0.0974440575,
0.0532963648,
0.1894219518,
-0.2014304996,
-0.185686633,
0.7720555067,
0.9268422127,
0.0241137892,
-0.0605692901,
-0.445994854,
0.3027121425,
0.202124238,
-0.9498456717,
0.2718142867,
0.5020481348,
0.1606107354,
0.5090449452,
0.2911483943,
-0.1531274319,
-0.2506630123,
0.0174084958,
0.0258196108,
0.0702052265,
-0.2649115026,
-0.3117751777,
0.1557203233,
0.4442205727,
0.1408160478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18045v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18045v2
|
Multi-FAct: Assessing Multilingual LLMs' Multi-Regional Knowledge using FActScore
| 2024-02-28T04:43:46 | 2024-03-01T12:35:55 |
Sheikh Shafayat, Eunsu Kim, Juhyun Oh, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are prone to factuality hallucination,
generating text that contradicts established knowledge. While extensive
research has addressed this in English, little is known about multilingual
LLMs. This paper systematically evaluates multilingual LLMs' factual accuracy
across languages and geographic regions. We introduce a novel pipeline for
multilingual factuality evaluation, adapting FActScore(Min et al., 2023) for
diverse languages. Our analysis across nine languages reveals that English
consistently outperforms others in factual accuracy and quantity of generated
facts. Furthermore, multilingual models demonstrate a bias towards factual
information from Western continents. These findings highlight the need for
improved multilingual factuality assessment and underscore geographical biases
in LLMs' fact generation.
|
[
-0.2838590145,
-0.6870520711,
0.8194871545,
0.2584170699,
-0.0750949383,
0.2160086036,
-0.5208443403,
-0.4667728841,
0.218432948,
0.3836383522,
-0.4698981941,
-0.7885226011,
-0.7625988722,
0.3124087751,
-0.1080757752,
0.9185892344,
0.1745039672,
0.1951755732,
-0.4362183809,
-0.6937906742,
-0.2943990827,
-0.8391201496,
-0.0519472025,
-0.2744131684,
0.4949408472,
0.6052250266,
0.6392147541,
0.3492808342,
0.6004199982,
0.3737111092,
0.0512176678,
0.7071415186,
-0.417042762,
0.0413400941,
-0.2239841074,
-0.6770234704,
-0.3788295984,
-0.0119772945,
0.6972621083,
0.6291151643,
-0.1933270842,
0.3469314277,
-0.1556330174,
0.5002136827,
-0.5593805909,
0.2325678617,
-0.8244405985,
0.0000434009,
-0.2026323676,
-0.2215107232,
-0.4576202631,
-0.6981304288,
0.1950127184,
-0.2125881016,
0.6172289848,
0.2194374204,
0.6520670652,
0.2384013981,
-0.9197756052,
-0.6087905169,
-0.6902467608,
0.7952327132,
-0.5384540558,
0.7538874745,
0.0585780628,
0.2070052475,
0.109075062,
-0.4878075421,
-0.4893351495,
-0.2450626194,
-0.2455138266,
0.1824902147,
0.0356290489,
-0.3857316375,
0.233275041,
0.2093809247,
-0.5349504948,
0.0060840282,
-0.4376208782,
-0.4539029896,
0.6920116544,
0.055642236,
0.2825259864,
-0.3395534754,
-0.5764889717,
0.3047955036,
-0.9064224958,
-0.0372291319,
0.3985037506,
0.5968842506,
-0.3598545492,
0.6638145447,
0.0151090678,
0.4204490185,
-0.3057030141,
-0.8964165449,
0.3390659094,
-0.6256216764,
0.1087621525,
0.2945118845,
0.6108695269,
0.5950103998,
-0.0247329026,
-0.1609473228,
0.0955762938,
0.0521489494,
-0.18517299,
-0.5923077464,
-0.0857036263,
0.2708549201,
-0.052015204,
0.2257947326,
-0.017550366,
-0.78575176,
-0.4935152233,
-0.3005340993,
-0.0071345093,
-0.3972569108,
-0.2234014273,
0.1175843701,
-0.0404673442,
0.018272927,
0.3712521791,
-0.399141252,
-0.0198903736,
0.4966904819,
0.8155961633,
-0.1922244579,
-0.8101451993,
-0.3700065315,
0.0198797882,
-0.3193477988,
1.2680209875,
-0.3113071918,
-0.0160383265,
0.0496536531,
0.1282022744,
-0.0883742049,
-0.4252624214,
0.6683091521,
-0.4700506032,
0.3447568119,
-0.784786582,
-0.2456799597,
-0.5825980306,
0.6157308817,
-0.6911577582,
1.0466896296,
-0.3194946945,
-0.7455567122,
0.7422035933,
-0.4292833209,
-0.5087606907,
-0.2037125677,
-0.0905466825,
-0.1913414001,
0.0640145838,
0.2642712295,
0.264705807,
-0.4140695333,
0.6784505248,
-0.249743104,
-0.0490445644,
0.3568246067,
-0.7280504704,
0.6110092402,
0.0825693607,
-0.2018434703,
-0.0447059982,
-0.872289598,
-0.3134230971,
-0.021669209,
-0.5145519972,
-0.2160415649,
0.1341133714,
-0.2892383039,
0.4035635591,
0.2220087796,
-0.6963794231,
-0.0692526326,
-0.0182151683,
0.0306252223,
0.4104090631,
-0.0156262405,
0.1043699458,
-0.4088439941,
0.224176392,
0.1917687953,
-0.105628483,
0.0290483218,
-0.5376115441,
-0.6695830822,
-0.4572410583,
0.2566107512,
0.7190019488,
-0.7344354391,
0.1863609105,
-0.5051022172,
-0.6154924631,
-0.3925716877,
0.1282931715,
0.0971266702,
0.494549185,
0.1568815261,
-0.148058176,
-0.5818496943,
-0.8591380715,
-0.3812362552,
-0.1527496129,
0.4345346987,
0.1795609444,
0.5124831796,
-0.1573380083,
0.6667867899,
-0.3547864258,
-0.0111767137,
-0.1882879436,
0.0930565819,
0.105833441,
-0.068164207,
0.6591239572,
-0.6476448178,
-0.2369904667,
-0.0937006697,
-0.93050915,
0.1966558248,
-0.0460669696,
0.0993315578,
0.4508599341,
0.0107469624,
-0.6838886142,
0.0525003076,
0.8042088151,
-0.3498214781,
0.7209842801,
-0.2962233424,
0.6498072743,
-0.8389700651,
-0.112256743,
0.0619300716,
-0.2668287754,
-0.3689117432,
0.1626714319,
0.1119582579,
0.0457278416,
-0.6543259025,
0.3485626578,
-0.6191070676,
-0.2921300232,
0.1235782951,
0.5080535412,
0.0843368471,
0.1491254121,
-0.037628334,
0.7703275084,
0.3765956461,
-0.6970931888,
0.7122528553,
0.12854819,
-0.7634247541,
0.5431806445,
-0.1402777284,
-0.0702600703,
-0.2922653556,
0.1129556075,
-0.9781237245,
-0.152938813,
-0.3330224752,
-0.2609179318,
0.0370745175,
-0.1694687158,
-0.4857265949,
-0.2878702283,
-0.3365700245,
0.224815309,
0.1561668664,
-0.6882553697,
0.5902845263,
0.5314977169,
-0.3094690144,
-0.8496925831,
-0.7473458052,
0.3090093732,
-0.2894017398,
-0.8480715752,
-0.2296830565,
-0.2039722204,
-0.5611519814,
0.0155305462,
0.0490804352,
-0.1029282063,
0.117254138,
-0.1766800135,
0.1604419947,
-0.3738200068,
0.0764547363,
-0.1190264001,
0.2024940252,
0.2706877887,
-0.0823425874,
0.347627759,
-0.0804627165,
-0.608617723,
-0.0000919197,
0.2332462072,
0.7351428866,
-0.2312523425,
0.8287854195,
0.565102458,
-0.396269083,
-0.2343111783,
-0.7885264754,
-0.0561495349,
-0.340005815,
0.64180094,
-0.4412668943,
-0.7697354555,
0.7142499685,
-0.1365485936,
0.2370985001,
0.6175689697,
0.7868463993,
0.1697978973,
0.6023845077,
0.3979061842,
0.1619049013,
-0.3517395258,
-0.0098763909,
0.5069959164,
-0.317592442,
-0.5026990771,
-0.5846125484,
-0.0180497039,
-0.7877064347,
-0.6018120646,
0.6194938421,
-0.2818170786,
0.0118863424,
-0.0727682337,
0.2336850166,
0.5242342353,
0.3744815886,
-0.0029700741,
0.5350270867,
0.2396250516,
-0.3551111221,
-0.3204056919,
-0.9926086664,
-0.6555066705,
1.1446057558,
0.3125755191,
0.5505144596,
0.6231722236,
0.2562762797,
0.4026431739,
0.4607383311,
-0.7966551185,
0.2133280784,
-0.3078612387,
-0.8804559708,
-0.1220924929,
-0.3931562304,
-0.3906565905,
0.4103551209,
-0.4552367926,
-0.3589981496,
-0.0478880107,
0.0209969115,
-0.4880100191,
0.6228220463,
-0.701628089,
0.3483004272,
-0.4981631935,
-0.3431921005,
-0.20396173,
-0.388762176,
0.8447032571,
-0.209340468,
0.9543302059,
-0.3756740987,
0.0564956814,
0.4550603926,
-0.0258295666,
0.9104886055,
-0.0127604892,
-0.4785726368,
0.3656171262,
0.1796106249,
0.2816728652,
0.3310372829,
-0.2669039965,
0.538261652,
-0.0549886785,
-0.4702495635,
-0.5518352985,
0.8277083635,
-0.8238736391,
-0.6299405694,
-0.6965709329,
-0.7214025259,
-0.3574380577,
0.0478872135,
0.2042793036,
0.8350141048,
-0.4365093708,
-0.1260762811,
0.6360036731,
-0.3278431892,
0.270599395,
0.8398629427,
-0.1449996233,
-0.3978466094,
0.9486770034,
0.4058217108,
0.1348522156,
0.29095608,
0.2451725155,
-0.7033811212,
-0.5205097795,
-0.5785558224,
0.386105299,
-1.0563979149,
-0.1088658646,
-0.6428176165,
-0.0709456578,
-0.5096316338,
0.1445861757,
-0.515503943,
-0.3643726408,
0.3734790087,
-0.3700198829,
0.2042687237,
1.0665330887,
-0.3507558703,
-0.0530960113,
-1.057308197,
0.2372384667,
0.3584639132,
0.1226009503,
-0.2686734498,
-0.661057353,
-0.2858987451,
0.0684994906,
-0.0561452396,
-0.7192384601,
0.1382060498,
0.2224198729,
0.69838202,
0.2377166599,
0.0626819357,
0.5263773203,
-0.7383341193,
1.0433564186,
0.1622189581,
-0.7218688726,
0.1036278456,
0.077882573,
0.1482781321,
0.3165119886,
0.7057200074,
-0.6400790215,
-0.3125951886,
-0.4559004605,
-0.5273661613,
0.3651188314,
-0.2888302207,
0.1046878919,
-0.0212188028,
0.1269747317,
0.4680501521,
0.2582609653,
-0.7368155718,
-0.5324091315,
0.0252456926,
-0.0679395124,
-0.392724812,
-0.6614301801,
-0.5279405713,
-0.0944233462,
0.6559324265,
-0.3065401912,
0.1596996039,
0.3659935296,
-0.4198339283,
0.0381199196,
0.5293434262,
0.9878612161,
1.2350895405,
-0.1951779574,
0.6280214787,
0.6618841887,
-0.4049954414,
0.2496254742,
-0.0732168853,
-0.1971461028,
0.2856464684,
0.848105371,
0.7361837626,
0.2603587508,
-0.4556064308,
0.4091053605,
-0.2816595435,
-0.1764462441,
-0.1812827438,
-0.2721817791,
0.2209267318,
0.1276640892,
0.2771117687,
0.3878635168,
-0.0017250944,
-0.7524744868,
0.2581957877,
0.2812737823,
-0.1796194315,
-0.5560287237,
0.2869235575,
0.4085145593,
0.2076221257,
0.3206678629,
-0.3737438023,
-0.9461798668,
0.4166282117,
0.6190166473,
0.4255440235,
-0.1596675515,
0.2124854028,
0.6096967459,
0.8077320457,
0.1219278201,
0.5523706675,
0.4238474667,
-1.0831514597,
-0.7623001337,
-0.4752798975,
-0.404555589,
-0.0233856514,
-0.3101889491,
0.2994606495,
-0.2297902554,
-0.092852667,
-0.2250870764,
0.1406143904,
-0.8175422549,
0.3088894188,
0.2778903246,
0.8961721659,
-1.1611918211,
0.5543510914,
0.8991451263,
0.0848570094,
-0.5976083875,
-0.049560912,
0.4022856355,
-0.9429297447,
0.5681353211,
-0.0362116471,
-0.3982717991,
-0.3665365577,
-0.3980065584,
-1.0120100975,
0.917650044,
0.5658621788,
-0.501976192,
0.3129436076,
0.3218899071,
0.2429508418,
-0.3767944872,
0.4162904024,
0.736196816,
0.5569673777,
-0.0728729516,
-0.8535359502,
-0.0893115923,
0.200306043,
-0.4466026425,
-0.1142367646,
-0.9708834887,
0.7640595436,
-0.5554195642,
-0.2830105126,
-0.4653234482,
0.6770807505,
0.4785037935,
0.3084403574,
0.4631721377,
0.5410443544,
1.332093358,
-0.2423801571,
1.0580735207,
-0.6319928169,
0.4074065089,
1.1294658184,
-0.6022719145,
0.4976222515,
0.1586962789,
-0.3568322659,
0.6772811413,
0.5229478478,
0.2177321017,
0.2812180519,
-0.2159630805,
-0.349399209,
-0.3044375777,
-0.3418222964,
-0.2244748771,
0.7942731977,
0.2630364895,
0.2620542645,
-0.4160725772,
-0.2599798739,
0.3934182525,
0.2166033536,
-0.1340598464,
0.4703787863,
-0.0956815258,
-0.7114188671,
0.4244567454,
0.2359920889,
0.6816473007,
-0.5401936769,
0.1181197986,
-0.434951216,
-0.0165016502,
-0.3549197018,
-0.807733953,
0.3834169805,
0.28532359,
-0.3902849853,
0.3070482314,
0.4986310005,
-0.613009274,
-0.7486742139,
0.2962252498,
0.9087279439,
0.157507956,
0.1733365804,
-0.5817044973,
0.034960933,
0.1478687674,
0.0762863681,
0.010781276,
0.8093338013,
0.0991066694,
0.5997502208,
0.6237883568,
0.365136385,
0.3545375466,
0.2034333497,
0.3665765822,
-0.6256963611,
-0.2339274436,
-0.9424455762,
0.4327868223,
-0.0206014514,
-0.3507471383,
1.2190008163,
0.7397803664,
0.8705618978,
-0.0213589258,
0.9839308858,
-0.0123571372,
0.5631130338,
-0.808452487,
0.6093250513,
-0.408531785,
0.1326920688,
0.0911916792,
-0.8669865727,
-0.2444855571,
0.0772489458,
-0.3462197781,
-0.150675118,
1.1609275341,
0.6601142287,
-0.1420848221,
0.1458707601,
0.4556458294,
0.4059561491,
0.1090836227,
0.194891125,
1.0703915358,
-0.3795859516,
0.2432873547,
-0.4530971348,
-0.1859001368,
0.2145789862,
-1.1747200489,
-0.7941679955,
-0.4228503108,
-0.4011407793,
-0.2862306535,
-0.1926513463,
0.9242478013,
0.7442911267,
-0.9659755826,
-0.4146762788,
0.7499004006,
0.5207218528,
0.1184260845,
-0.1934293956,
0.3424747586,
-0.4278648496,
-0.6169312596,
0.6432737112,
0.2921927273,
-0.2060141116,
-0.3523981571,
-0.0298483931,
-0.4797679484,
0.1001657173,
0.9772982597,
-0.2113902271,
-0.6879885197,
-0.4949091673,
-0.0059750876,
-0.1514465213,
0.2126311809,
0.8755657673,
-0.2887332439,
0.3139710724,
0.343778044,
0.4524066448,
0.038286794,
0.0300731473,
0.3487070799,
-0.9128754139,
0.3114689291,
-0.1328348368,
0.6442170739,
0.8559836149,
-0.3236922324,
0.3371752501,
0.7074735165,
-0.4831969142,
-0.6466300488,
0.1436244696,
-0.4621680677,
-0.2533004284,
1.1728699207,
-0.2716323137,
-0.2771660388,
-0.2631428242,
0.0996982604,
0.0622019246,
-0.0977684706,
0.6581524611,
1.0339301825,
0.0767824873,
0.0621953905,
-0.7090535164,
0.4054673314,
0.1590788066,
-0.7392504215,
0.0654628724,
0.7200213075,
0.565810442,
0.3883164525,
0.4303544164,
0.0010819522,
0.0532899052,
0.0148494458,
0.2013887614,
0.1959602684,
-0.7636914849,
-0.1641412526,
0.2354917228,
0.3575406969,
0.2702045143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18043v1
|
Crisis talk: analysis of the public debate around the energy crisis and cost of living
| 2024-02-28T04:42:59 | 2024-02-28T04:42:59 |
Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Geri Popova, Tony Russell-Rose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A prominent media topic in the UK in the early 2020s is the energy crisis
affecting the UK and most of Europe. It brings into a single public debate
issues of energy dependency and sustainability, fair distribution of economic
burdens and cost of living, as well as climate change, risk, and
sustainability. In this paper, we investigate the public discourse around the
energy crisis and cost of living to identify how these pivotal and
contradictory issues are reconciled in this debate and to identify which social
actors are involved and the role they play. We analyse a document corpus
retrieved from UK newspapers from January 2014 to March 2023. We apply a
variety of natural language processing and data visualisation techniques to
identify key topics, novel trends, critical social actors, and the role they
play in the debate, along with the sentiment associated with those actors and
topics. We combine automated techniques with manual discourse analysis to
explore and validate the insights revealed in this study. The findings verify
the utility of these techniques by providing a flexible and scalable pipeline
for discourse analysis and providing critical insights for cost of living -
energy crisis nexus research.
|
[
-0.4745079279,
-0.4003335834,
0.3396089375,
-0.1205054596,
0.117526494,
0.4910381138,
-0.0638855919,
-0.2877629399,
0.628881216,
0.4606886804,
-0.3861514032,
-0.082535319,
-0.4463047385,
0.0653067008,
-0.3344718218,
0.4718175232,
0.1930635571,
-0.0615728684,
-0.1338362098,
0.007988153,
-0.4898103774,
0.0181791726,
-0.6442046762,
0.2000110596,
0.5626723766,
0.5148470402,
0.9234523773,
0.0564767085,
0.3940954208,
0.3995566964,
-0.3018605411,
-0.0217275359,
-0.8271757364,
0.1025725827,
-0.1847504526,
-0.1648367047,
-0.3166454732,
0.1679536402,
0.6031474471,
0.5373558402,
-0.0306111537,
0.2610974312,
0.259403944,
0.6200643778,
-0.666885674,
0.0732836202,
-0.9507533312,
-0.0305917598,
-0.1313167661,
-0.1975860596,
-0.0566673204,
-0.2731894851,
-0.1441560686,
-0.1626867205,
0.2291992307,
0.1699191183,
1.034766078,
0.5100930929,
-0.4314964712,
-0.291698426,
-0.8334338665,
0.5577733517,
-0.313547045,
0.0696481168,
-0.2120592892,
0.3154432178,
-0.0126721989,
-0.5919617414,
-0.7672470212,
0.3005376756,
-0.5381537676,
0.2502651513,
-0.4486448467,
-0.0364925228,
-0.0554715171,
0.3169187903,
-0.2274416983,
-0.2114505917,
-0.7269667387,
-0.1438599229,
0.582960546,
-0.0074679335,
0.0551970638,
-1.0033653975,
-0.5035392642,
0.0364569724,
-0.5571591258,
-0.1485087276,
0.8113409877,
0.3260369599,
-0.2679776549,
0.1245652661,
0.1353789419,
0.0150025263,
-0.3330872357,
0.0228620302,
-0.1891895384,
-0.2163720429,
0.1531092376,
0.5652341843,
0.5674605966,
0.9278903008,
-0.1671901345,
0.3172204196,
0.2771798372,
-0.4576649964,
0.3788568079,
-0.52364254,
-0.0383572504,
0.3873259723,
-0.3107058108,
-0.3509214222,
-0.0319378339,
-1.2274724245,
-0.6248840094,
0.2332115024,
0.1266136318,
0.5173869133,
-0.4967360497,
0.2500031292,
-0.2145196944,
-0.0543682799,
0.1850935817,
-0.2061835378,
0.0455505177,
0.4354400933,
0.6925514936,
0.4509750307,
0.2402226627,
-0.1478606462,
0.3169253767,
-0.102643095,
1.1855700016,
-0.5768330097,
-0.7647330165,
0.0536124483,
0.2808934152,
0.0421075113,
-0.3144842684,
0.7751147151,
-0.0155568859,
0.4306400716,
-0.7289373279,
-0.1974116415,
0.0442413427,
-0.0265747011,
-0.6991706491,
0.706545949,
-0.1868506074,
-1.0740613937,
0.1744538695,
-1.1401433945,
-0.1535622776,
0.3499447405,
-0.3197582364,
-0.2162563056,
-0.0362119786,
-0.0668698773,
0.4098932445,
-0.6041970849,
0.2563457191,
-0.1335387528,
0.1808990687,
0.1001984552,
-0.7112891674,
0.4870700538,
0.2712412775,
-0.1101576909,
-0.1359183043,
-0.7864227295,
-0.4768083692,
-0.041043859,
0.1163599491,
0.0380366333,
0.5823484659,
-0.0340225026,
0.2871360183,
0.0187364463,
-0.5568339229,
0.089123629,
0.0220945105,
0.7625930905,
0.3927262127,
0.4422667623,
-0.0368759185,
-0.2975472808,
0.501141727,
-0.0731623545,
0.2188901901,
-0.1332338303,
-0.4359832406,
-0.6438812017,
0.0059589115,
-0.0115125701,
0.7012922168,
-0.2291852534,
-0.0607993528,
0.0519758053,
-0.3043012917,
-0.7156251669,
-0.5354754329,
0.0619410798,
0.7721261978,
0.2378175855,
0.2487767488,
-0.5694830418,
-0.8977923989,
-0.5844633579,
-0.2590021193,
-0.0240415409,
0.5065649748,
0.1070336252,
0.3756495416,
0.8274643421,
-0.7543591857,
0.2237921953,
0.0286678616,
0.874001205,
0.0376752354,
0.4382126927,
0.1916752309,
-0.8897628188,
-0.4425525963,
-0.1001452655,
-0.1509330124,
-0.2584426701,
-0.4239313602,
-0.0533758067,
-0.0280413758,
0.6515760422,
-0.0972789824,
0.1312187463,
0.2431475967,
-0.3067380786,
0.4043590724,
-0.0276782066,
0.5470868945,
-1.0306267738,
0.3185361624,
0.0458438173,
0.0893318877,
-0.7210807204,
-0.4358067811,
-0.4169997871,
-0.6572226286,
-0.7193216085,
0.3240459263,
-0.5055857301,
0.1033020467,
-0.0058983359,
0.1141581833,
0.2576575577,
-0.1015385538,
0.0430590659,
0.6062928438,
0.3366347551,
0.1451719403,
0.0762491599,
0.2107707411,
-0.2862584591,
0.4576635063,
-0.2748798728,
0.2798892856,
-0.1673279107,
0.3563315868,
-1.4361817837,
-0.3522006273,
-0.0957150981,
-0.1959975511,
0.1680446416,
-0.2156459242,
-0.2219143808,
-0.6292074323,
-0.1395005435,
-0.2198488861,
0.347949177,
0.17604357,
0.7485602498,
0.7283247709,
-0.5668047667,
-0.4456213117,
-0.1218293086,
0.3624998927,
-0.4251285195,
-0.7129551172,
0.2936364412,
0.1826788783,
-0.6150574088,
0.0072258511,
-0.1831560433,
0.060845945,
0.1295613199,
0.5153483152,
0.1809168905,
-0.0113547174,
0.3005230725,
-0.1355663538,
-0.5283039808,
0.3323609531,
0.1819891781,
0.2772450149,
-0.1667027026,
0.0666940436,
-0.3442316949,
0.8453659415,
0.8555554748,
0.0731607825,
0.7049229145,
0.0979130641,
-0.3355726898,
0.490346998,
-0.6107250452,
0.2766767144,
-0.432908833,
-0.0344354995,
0.1401788592,
-0.6019546986,
0.3513678908,
-0.4768688679,
0.2804748714,
0.6928287148,
0.4101601541,
-0.3093002439,
0.6171988845,
0.3765029013,
-0.0661738589,
0.0285938103,
-0.1549607217,
0.5705711842,
-0.289236486,
-0.3418597281,
-0.9472751021,
-0.5902130008,
-0.4009517133,
-0.4503003061,
0.6045575738,
-0.1899232715,
0.0064828638,
0.1364205778,
-0.5392971635,
0.8622876406,
-0.2456489801,
-0.2390062362,
0.129489392,
-0.4437014461,
0.4143436253,
0.1457778811,
-0.329023093,
-0.8682270646,
0.1284692585,
0.3701595664,
0.4098063409,
0.0143988756,
0.307240963,
0.3014148474,
0.2778166533,
-0.6655472517,
0.6361199021,
0.1709319204,
-0.7861083746,
-0.4018629491,
-0.3142753541,
-1.0544500351,
0.1855392605,
-0.4614526629,
-0.6164832115,
0.6523886919,
-0.1685234457,
-0.8196992278,
0.6400024295,
-0.5254788399,
0.8353336453,
0.0250962172,
-0.374091953,
-0.5608987212,
-0.5549504757,
0.1568595171,
0.2567034364,
0.6503109336,
-0.4694704711,
0.300168395,
0.8158989549,
-0.3616093695,
0.7161515951,
-0.1529984027,
-0.3583161533,
0.4495245814,
-0.3978495896,
0.3346633911,
-0.0234891511,
0.0840421319,
-0.1102014408,
0.1670891345,
-0.6396952271,
-0.2607220411,
0.582518518,
-0.6418474913,
-0.8919945955,
-0.2239319831,
-0.1576851606,
-0.2260176539,
-0.3257321715,
0.2322642505,
0.5487029552,
-0.4591297805,
-0.1163190752,
0.4029991627,
-0.0122591788,
0.754078269,
0.4507609606,
0.0362280905,
-0.4991669059,
0.853304565,
0.5632010102,
0.2786825597,
0.3765851259,
0.6431820989,
-0.0596668608,
-0.150537923,
0.2224258035,
0.1193771884,
-0.5318974257,
-0.3472777903,
-0.7152599096,
-0.023481369,
-0.3822564185,
-0.5167400241,
-0.648719728,
-0.0761824548,
-0.2430931032,
-0.3254482746,
0.2302091569,
0.5993968844,
-0.572283864,
0.0336158648,
-0.7636809349,
0.0476516113,
0.5991238952,
-0.1983872503,
-0.1558452845,
0.180894047,
-0.3135520816,
-0.4056156576,
-0.7805914283,
-1.3144118786,
0.3736892045,
0.0207665209,
0.1501839757,
0.7100545168,
0.4871818423,
0.537184,
-0.5104424953,
1.2236591578,
0.5699580312,
-0.8741110563,
0.368955344,
-0.260425508,
-0.1038312241,
0.659037292,
0.9160430431,
-0.6321764588,
-0.0829672441,
-1.1042538881,
-1.0893422365,
0.3414839208,
0.1831797808,
0.0779442862,
-0.1961274743,
-0.0542125851,
-0.0353458412,
0.2316228747,
-0.053100355,
-0.4855045378,
-0.2502650619,
0.7194842696,
0.1414416581,
-0.3429563642,
-0.5794779658,
-0.4195764065,
0.3712687492,
-0.0133099118,
0.1562754065,
0.0548870377,
0.5701696873,
-0.4853674471,
0.6294600368,
0.4805799127,
0.3518404663,
-0.3341296911,
-0.0050070444,
0.2346825451,
-0.3367867768,
0.2327377796,
-0.0897232741,
0.1158754975,
0.3113198876,
0.1452014148,
0.7600780129,
0.7646153569,
-0.4744228721,
0.3184604943,
-0.218598336,
-0.6052671075,
-0.1192351878,
-0.1564743519,
0.3382829726,
0.4196823537,
0.5166220665,
-0.0062109507,
0.3621995747,
-0.9959866405,
-0.1748711169,
0.118375279,
-0.5006747246,
-0.3665200472,
0.4390874505,
0.9873979688,
-0.4076656699,
0.0591764115,
0.0707426891,
-0.6072440147,
0.3982202113,
0.1305969208,
0.9425869584,
-0.173259303,
0.4665754437,
0.1712922603,
0.0357284136,
0.3649095893,
0.6070126295,
0.1473059654,
-0.3989836872,
-0.3656260371,
-0.3322773278,
-0.5993717313,
0.3017080426,
-0.8186704516,
0.2191503942,
-0.1828403622,
-0.1050757691,
0.1138814166,
0.4853617847,
-0.3454158604,
-0.1716485322,
0.6257828474,
1.0288999081,
-0.9819002748,
0.2646359205,
0.2950083911,
0.0671042725,
-0.8668353558,
0.315792799,
0.3182733953,
-0.2391548008,
0.3785569668,
0.0279189646,
-0.257094413,
-0.1392500848,
-0.7704076767,
-0.9091740847,
1.0152288675,
0.8332386613,
-0.7256507874,
0.018693639,
0.0419756845,
0.1342881322,
-0.186501205,
0.4002585709,
0.6815674305,
1.0462917089,
0.6178384423,
-0.8752342463,
-0.1000345945,
-0.2556132972,
-0.4379797876,
0.5330504179,
-1.2124478817,
0.5056301355,
0.1181377396,
-0.8440356255,
-0.5584687591,
0.6352394819,
-0.6275143623,
0.4785670936,
0.5186766982,
0.1792319268,
1.1868926287,
0.0598852336,
0.8521233797,
-0.6384162307,
0.5695918798,
0.6474663019,
-0.5534647703,
0.9030906558,
0.1591775417,
-0.5589589477,
0.4316901863,
0.3348721862,
0.3927120566,
0.4282136559,
0.4258540571,
-0.4761406779,
-0.2835384309,
-0.2983117402,
-0.4128692448,
0.5027575493,
0.60545367,
0.1621933132,
-0.7080398798,
-0.1690200716,
0.2997461855,
0.0528070666,
-0.1089025363,
0.7633730769,
-0.035383489,
-0.2400146127,
0.2584392726,
-0.4055865407,
-0.0020655135,
-0.3160273433,
0.2473320216,
-0.2002375275,
-0.575101316,
-0.2430041581,
-0.5890942216,
0.7689864039,
0.0371473916,
-0.0498052798,
-0.4462572634,
0.6584219337,
-0.1953411549,
-0.3434098959,
-0.0149217835,
0.2713401616,
0.4030040801,
0.0895959511,
-0.9537795186,
0.2055102736,
-0.0913070962,
0.0844474882,
0.4112069905,
0.5173872709,
0.676758945,
0.1093723178,
0.1451715082,
-0.0977542251,
-0.2922602594,
-0.1630267054,
1.0340220928,
-0.7758131027,
-0.2366779745,
-0.4452021718,
0.6251462102,
-0.4994116127,
-0.6985176206,
0.3742081523,
0.2994297445,
0.2339154482,
0.210049659,
0.5787960887,
-0.1960349828,
0.6224453449,
-0.4546920061,
1.0036771297,
-0.3625967801,
0.1351127774,
-0.1908945739,
-0.3923085332,
0.1529858261,
0.3648767471,
-0.6792181134,
-0.5651638508,
0.8300217986,
0.8501853943,
0.3121458292,
0.3663554192,
0.4824841321,
0.415931493,
0.311076194,
0.1762913913,
0.8533212543,
-0.0856837854,
0.4307435751,
0.099589102,
0.0458544418,
-0.3963106573,
-1.2263646126,
-0.2559016943,
-0.7709715962,
-0.7302880883,
-0.4025203288,
0.1529139429,
0.8838946819,
0.5587444901,
-0.6186074615,
-0.1727529913,
0.0750080273,
0.4061327577,
0.0162880253,
-0.2101458609,
0.5008999109,
-0.0964759216,
-0.6904640198,
0.3518951535,
0.5883554816,
-0.2446448207,
-0.5833395123,
0.4806838334,
-0.2942950428,
0.8307403326,
0.4016988873,
0.54982692,
-0.3968093395,
-0.4192717373,
-0.718024075,
0.0682456046,
0.3436177969,
1.0612331629,
-0.6877565384,
-0.0696194991,
0.2950054705,
0.3894289136,
-0.0133450367,
-0.2635503709,
0.3200992942,
-0.6371468306,
-0.0330823846,
0.1484856904,
0.464276731,
0.4747210443,
-0.6577265859,
0.2843340039,
0.3905165195,
-0.7593502998,
-1.0010147095,
0.0663376153,
-0.8475225568,
-0.4487018585,
0.8244150281,
-0.0941961631,
-0.2760265172,
-0.2603545785,
-0.295848608,
0.027660029,
-0.6452984214,
1.0192958117,
0.7974885702,
0.0509179421,
-0.2821307778,
-0.3719814718,
0.3727858365,
-0.0168781783,
-0.7694398165,
0.3693758845,
0.3195798099,
-0.3553227782,
0.6584054828,
0.4138607085,
0.2482946068,
-0.4612131119,
0.3938385248,
-0.1876255572,
0.4360047579,
-0.5998136997,
0.0785886645,
0.6940985918,
-0.6059008837,
-0.0605978146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18041v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18041v1
|
Datasets for Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2024-02-28T04:35:51 | 2024-02-28T04:35:51 |
Yang Liu, Jiahuan Cao, Chongyu Liu, Kai Ding, Lianwen Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper embarks on an exploration into the Large Language Model (LLM)
datasets, which play a crucial role in the remarkable advancements of LLMs. The
datasets serve as the foundational infrastructure analogous to a root system
that sustains and nurtures the development of LLMs. Consequently, examination
of these datasets emerges as a critical topic in research. In order to address
the current lack of a comprehensive overview and thorough analysis of LLM
datasets, and to gain insights into their current status and future trends,
this survey consolidates and categorizes the fundamental aspects of LLM
datasets from five perspectives: (1) Pre-training Corpora; (2) Instruction
Fine-tuning Datasets; (3) Preference Datasets; (4) Evaluation Datasets; (5)
Traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP) Datasets. The survey sheds light
on the prevailing challenges and points out potential avenues for future
investigation. Additionally, a comprehensive review of the existing available
dataset resources is also provided, including statistics from 444 datasets,
covering 8 language categories and spanning 32 domains. Information from 20
dimensions is incorporated into the dataset statistics. The total data size
surveyed surpasses 774.5 TB for pre-training corpora and 700M instances for
other datasets. We aim to present the entire landscape of LLM text datasets,
serving as a comprehensive reference for researchers in this field and
contributing to future studies. Related resources are available at:
https://github.com/lmmlzn/Awesome-LLMs-Datasets.
|
[
-0.4116533995,
-0.6503835917,
0.4733382761,
0.028041888,
0.0743554384,
0.2275239974,
-0.5739198327,
-0.1388105303,
0.0477338843,
0.8163196445,
-0.4463007152,
-0.7505075336,
-0.6741961837,
0.109477073,
-0.5933046341,
0.9304847717,
-0.0224478785,
0.2089553028,
-0.225783959,
-0.1134512126,
-0.3640295863,
-0.6307167411,
-0.2811269164,
-0.216568172,
0.4761764109,
0.3720315695,
0.3863525391,
0.6403217316,
0.5756354332,
0.1993387341,
-0.1701482236,
0.1381158531,
-0.7288686633,
0.2827596962,
-0.0081147235,
-0.334883064,
-0.3084111214,
-0.0185257234,
1.0603680611,
1.1562981606,
-0.0814924389,
0.3997682333,
0.0074354378,
0.6382975578,
-0.4262872636,
0.1799042374,
-0.5322896838,
-0.0508176647,
-0.6284011602,
-0.0864274353,
-0.2700460553,
-0.4406356514,
0.0967957601,
-0.0550895892,
0.1114972457,
0.1291175783,
0.3384971321,
0.0594404936,
-0.6791189313,
-0.3973333836,
-0.8442684412,
0.926317811,
-0.6428648829,
0.4681277573,
0.136712268,
0.1158633232,
-0.1676775962,
-0.5815222859,
-0.2906232476,
-0.1068954244,
0.2344691306,
-0.0902974606,
-0.1333505213,
-0.041013144,
0.2584312558,
0.6930443645,
-0.7654196024,
0.4446798265,
-0.2640963197,
0.0054283594,
0.6398384571,
0.504488349,
0.2159090787,
0.1189464331,
-0.046710141,
-0.0000940415,
-1.0929034948,
-0.2463745624,
0.3962090313,
0.2842106521,
-0.1610307097,
0.5656804442,
-0.1845455915,
1.0231533051,
-0.4426229298,
-0.1080410257,
0.264546454,
-0.543947041,
-0.2007452846,
-0.1008278131,
0.8738338947,
0.1581433713,
0.4329262972,
-0.0911204219,
-0.2344077379,
-0.2061116248,
-0.0468304381,
-0.595127821,
0.0109027112,
0.2844478488,
-0.2679558098,
-0.2021677792,
-0.0383036584,
-0.658608973,
-0.4019290507,
-0.6689081788,
-0.2532235682,
-0.0996444821,
-0.2653562129,
0.2712936699,
0.354349941,
0.4885494411,
0.1350306273,
-0.849303484,
0.4894337654,
0.8263321519,
0.7089468241,
-0.340241909,
-0.2952773273,
0.0096492646,
0.0028592709,
-0.5748252869,
0.7639748454,
-0.5807064176,
-0.3969714046,
0.403773725,
-0.0079127261,
0.1133073196,
-0.6859486699,
0.5361747742,
-0.655929327,
0.2322607785,
-0.3335026503,
-0.756747067,
-0.0148994625,
0.6109194756,
-0.8671319485,
0.9903065562,
-0.1103187799,
-0.7435219884,
0.1254784614,
-0.4725227058,
-0.4075532854,
-0.0391369201,
-0.3406395018,
-0.1752453297,
0.1630674899,
0.1246099621,
0.7146623135,
-0.7840775847,
0.5598697066,
-0.3918693364,
-0.1847543567,
0.3527129591,
-0.4406138361,
0.7884655595,
0.0706573948,
0.0683945492,
0.0837089866,
-0.8711295128,
0.0210475046,
0.1487125009,
-0.1406623721,
-0.2147194594,
-0.047915671,
0.1869430095,
0.134760499,
0.4920889139,
-0.4560291469,
0.4216166139,
-0.2067854553,
0.2578086555,
0.6442009807,
-0.0279342383,
0.4344615936,
0.0049940282,
0.6310661435,
-0.1256078184,
0.167518273,
-0.2678411901,
-0.1369883567,
-0.6989073753,
-0.0161708854,
0.4658921063,
0.3905447721,
-0.3960533738,
0.5565191507,
-0.4967719913,
-0.425239116,
-0.2613682449,
0.162273407,
0.2370027751,
0.1658384055,
0.050521411,
-0.0748637915,
-0.6762650609,
-0.9896544814,
0.1101422757,
-0.0197891556,
-0.0278457813,
0.3468063772,
0.495046258,
-0.1516562104,
0.9281483889,
-0.6491705179,
-0.1563192904,
-0.5046582222,
-0.2758367956,
0.5129010677,
0.1797625721,
0.4535721242,
-0.5209492445,
-0.3312254846,
-0.1710985303,
-0.6685757637,
-0.1923586577,
0.1621577293,
0.0405986682,
0.0118941413,
0.4385157228,
-0.391146034,
-0.1539574713,
0.8040528297,
-0.0771569684,
0.6309971213,
-0.0589713566,
-0.1255158782,
-1.1198009253,
0.2570638955,
0.0027135778,
0.0092868619,
-0.7095820904,
0.0493413992,
-0.1345171481,
0.12497022,
-0.1804182678,
0.5834537745,
-0.5470909476,
-0.381759733,
-0.1159418598,
-0.0169760641,
-0.2627029717,
0.0786644593,
0.0203166436,
0.6722248197,
0.7380230427,
-0.4072085023,
0.5162414312,
0.3671177328,
-0.5210878849,
0.2575283945,
-0.5761807561,
0.1866651475,
-0.1041050926,
0.4058834314,
-0.7076675296,
-0.2296611518,
0.0685542226,
-0.1584048718,
0.2636440396,
-0.0233956911,
-0.7022224665,
-0.1828307509,
-0.2710856199,
0.2207034677,
0.2989268899,
-0.2128049433,
0.1181941852,
0.7335504889,
-0.4017328024,
-0.6915782094,
-0.389085263,
0.3650048971,
-0.200953126,
-0.2974127531,
0.00846045,
-0.1606134921,
-0.4458103776,
-0.2249234617,
0.2279774696,
-0.0134876156,
-0.0754536092,
0.0037351297,
0.3525851071,
-0.2582376301,
0.1470741034,
-0.3418979645,
-0.0256032664,
0.1665219069,
-0.3014534116,
0.8751899004,
-0.2115445882,
-0.2976957262,
-0.0148506667,
0.2244917899,
0.3938218355,
-0.1860275269,
0.58917588,
0.2677152455,
-0.2897915542,
-0.2307897061,
-0.5071102381,
0.0447798334,
-0.3625089526,
0.4151611626,
-0.1745459288,
-1.1480629444,
0.5166192651,
-0.0535779037,
0.3450390995,
0.3359127939,
0.8183003664,
0.0720147491,
0.6799107194,
0.7324501276,
-0.6188054681,
0.3016872406,
-0.4371361434,
0.1378016472,
-0.8308656812,
-0.1779052913,
-0.7044728398,
-0.1289591938,
-0.6398459077,
-0.4027840793,
0.0782597661,
-0.3214629591,
-0.3216927052,
-0.01196172,
-0.0320433266,
0.4383037388,
0.1696087867,
-0.3584246635,
0.3428374231,
0.0266298968,
-0.0302464217,
-0.0163650978,
-0.6349742413,
-0.8449770808,
1.3983632326,
0.4779682159,
0.7577810884,
0.0336470306,
0.5051549077,
-0.0434964821,
0.1777148694,
-0.8412250876,
0.5616153479,
-0.3025992215,
-0.8493507504,
-0.4277269542,
-0.4366760254,
-0.9159834385,
0.0435082503,
0.084314011,
-0.3561924994,
0.1033486798,
-0.0084635112,
-0.1967332959,
0.2888480425,
-0.2823071778,
0.6410297751,
-0.4121887088,
-0.2291780561,
-0.0565578192,
-0.7037726045,
0.5361612439,
-0.2977929115,
0.2700062394,
-0.1394242346,
-0.1003996804,
0.820260942,
0.0340388827,
0.8146051764,
0.0373910889,
-0.5309630632,
0.2581323981,
-0.2597985864,
0.3040519357,
-0.1237588078,
-0.1240371615,
0.2513621449,
0.0076224585,
-0.2513653934,
-0.4153250158,
0.6842509508,
-0.665517807,
-0.2683739066,
-0.4544990659,
-0.5140893459,
-0.6076288223,
0.1704357266,
-0.0559665561,
0.5823206306,
-0.5115613937,
0.5232530236,
0.9630104899,
-0.4702506065,
0.1459001005,
0.5727155805,
-0.5026836991,
-0.2527025044,
0.9098173976,
0.2804431021,
0.2229263932,
0.4444237351,
-0.0433956571,
-0.4432432652,
-0.8793457747,
-0.1505643427,
0.3469765186,
-0.5540331006,
-0.0763544142,
-0.4970484376,
-0.2487558275,
-0.4206466377,
0.2798802853,
-0.4006822109,
-0.1537722647,
-0.3002454937,
-0.095176585,
0.2854859829,
1.048994422,
0.2218809277,
0.3907362521,
-0.6647432446,
0.1672741622,
0.0577796102,
0.5600139499,
-0.007582888,
-0.3931090832,
-0.2586979568,
-0.0128995907,
-0.0213458836,
-0.4485486746,
0.3624837697,
0.1173664182,
0.5678973794,
0.5996289253,
-0.1458016485,
0.4241446257,
-0.6333414316,
0.8577873707,
0.032790713,
-0.4723562598,
0.1561030149,
-0.6044492722,
0.239365533,
0.5390831828,
0.5714437366,
-0.9156816602,
-0.0678736418,
-0.5330891013,
-0.8839740157,
0.6311922073,
0.0342509225,
0.2708060443,
0.2235143781,
0.203205049,
0.2303112745,
0.3632448316,
-0.3621596992,
-0.339512527,
0.2686783075,
-0.3790696561,
-0.4475164413,
-0.328918308,
-0.0303964447,
-0.0170331113,
0.5252130032,
-0.0689190999,
0.0341484323,
-0.4821709394,
-0.1554991901,
0.341432184,
0.4437168241,
0.4738821387,
0.9010832906,
-0.2465977669,
0.1685387492,
0.2030187696,
-0.612557292,
0.1782311201,
-0.0832549259,
-0.0519774668,
-0.0645070672,
0.468782872,
0.7243788838,
0.1575225741,
-0.7716882229,
0.3714506626,
-0.051480867,
-0.0961994529,
-0.4858911932,
-0.2387841791,
0.2605173588,
-0.0978350043,
0.3006165326,
-0.4958307743,
0.0209383238,
-0.5512021184,
0.0710549802,
0.3456555009,
-0.3519923091,
-0.4252636135,
0.1157224029,
0.0356684327,
0.1030117795,
0.7270777822,
0.2280942202,
-0.2870664001,
0.5254559517,
0.2723836601,
0.6373109818,
-0.0770267844,
0.0929965749,
0.1696236581,
0.2991868258,
-0.1902737468,
0.2032369077,
0.2303273678,
-0.9052320123,
-0.5672592521,
-0.839449048,
-0.640403986,
0.6861560941,
-0.5044965744,
0.3035250604,
-0.3969468772,
0.1390147209,
-0.2416763157,
0.2571439445,
-0.6463387609,
0.2951594889,
0.2818872631,
0.9186204076,
-0.8777959347,
0.8298210502,
0.6527615786,
-0.1871295422,
-0.4046041369,
-0.1098021269,
0.0561640002,
-0.8132891059,
0.563757956,
-0.1052553579,
0.0070993695,
0.0801698864,
-0.7566165328,
-0.8876574636,
0.731064558,
0.3102974892,
-0.8387613297,
-0.0883992538,
0.57668221,
0.5680260658,
-0.4040004909,
0.2496745139,
1.0001943111,
0.4201362431,
-0.0655754432,
-0.6273075938,
-0.2961938679,
-0.2173455805,
0.1067318916,
0.0683498085,
-0.5839529634,
0.5813384652,
0.2213306129,
0.0875030458,
0.0664673969,
0.4687082767,
0.3605714738,
-0.1118434668,
0.3226010203,
0.4084349573,
0.5246443152,
-0.1155417114,
0.8733175397,
-0.4671691358,
0.3500062227,
1.123832345,
-0.524189949,
0.750669539,
0.3532088995,
-0.455685854,
-0.001479657,
0.8059298992,
-0.1095994562,
0.1209692135,
0.5106371045,
-0.2265837789,
-0.2345776856,
-0.288033843,
-0.4732608497,
0.544511199,
0.5159884095,
-0.2400735021,
-0.3796815574,
-0.1220407188,
-0.0021952565,
-0.1528036445,
-0.2482283264,
0.7016275525,
0.1627477258,
-0.1654605567,
0.2298501134,
-0.0170643665,
0.6682792306,
-0.8285735846,
0.1119299755,
-0.3908103704,
0.036823567,
-0.1245782375,
-1.0877739191,
0.0820286721,
0.215402171,
-0.1658589244,
-0.5740143657,
0.586086452,
-0.3796398044,
-0.5026386976,
0.091493614,
0.6245432496,
0.4024923146,
0.1105195954,
-0.4335016012,
0.3835791945,
-0.1675518304,
-0.3939649165,
0.3392098546,
0.4750252068,
-0.0624508485,
0.5781260729,
0.4478072226,
0.3636391461,
0.0866359398,
0.3916809559,
0.919531405,
-0.8570018411,
-0.0824698135,
-0.670814693,
0.3062953055,
-0.022322759,
-0.3982793391,
0.8236185908,
0.9455458522,
0.8579659462,
-0.0311869178,
1.0605906248,
0.003131998,
0.7989549041,
-0.5135782957,
0.6652715802,
-0.2213896364,
0.3021579981,
-0.2007789761,
-1.0421401262,
-0.4243633151,
0.2821909785,
-0.4907805026,
0.1263780445,
0.4253974557,
0.6090208888,
-0.0014283848,
0.0451438166,
0.334379524,
0.3518273234,
0.344532609,
0.2190121263,
1.0516052246,
-0.1955167502,
0.1874433905,
0.000964538,
-0.0208923072,
-0.1422058791,
-0.7629978657,
-0.6990283728,
-0.6232991219,
-0.1227863654,
0.124860011,
-0.099416256,
0.8383342028,
0.3248355687,
-0.9305369258,
-0.6531661749,
0.1056871265,
-0.0494012348,
0.3015224636,
-0.14043051,
0.3281749487,
-0.3729933798,
-0.7828100324,
0.3321112394,
0.1601050645,
-0.0721558705,
-0.7752079368,
0.1143135428,
-0.1918371618,
-0.0858077481,
0.8141419291,
0.1928652227,
-0.4544800818,
0.0198879782,
0.2565575242,
-0.1423347741,
0.0157128349,
0.8456471562,
-0.4584970474,
0.1287541687,
0.4714480639,
0.6964907646,
0.2976771891,
-0.5012457371,
0.6295868754,
-0.6329923272,
-0.050715927,
0.2421926409,
0.3655413091,
0.4411116242,
-0.0054587717,
0.4947183132,
0.0076877996,
-0.4962111115,
-0.9586746693,
0.1611099839,
-0.9076149464,
-0.1498768181,
1.2409793139,
0.0132289603,
-0.0618480034,
-0.173850134,
-0.1625736505,
0.0814677849,
-0.1252704263,
0.4942067266,
1.028345108,
0.0280054398,
-0.2281799316,
-0.7600144744,
0.2682458162,
0.0486980453,
-0.9822376966,
0.4575442076,
0.8276527524,
0.3512662947,
-0.1445896327,
0.4992754161,
-0.2106724381,
-0.398709029,
-0.3175828755,
0.1850923449,
0.1928945929,
-0.4419901967,
-0.7182359099,
0.250769496,
0.1296350807,
0.215168938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18039v1
|
ResLoRA: Identity Residual Mapping in Low-Rank Adaption
| 2024-02-28T04:33:20 | 2024-02-28T04:33:20 |
Shuhua Shi, Shaohan Huang, Minghui Song, Zhoujun Li, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As one of the most popular parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods,
low-rank adaptation (LoRA) is commonly applied to fine-tune large language
models (LLMs). However, updating the weights of LoRA blocks effectively and
expeditiously is challenging due to the long calculation path in the original
model. To address this, we propose ResLoRA, an improved framework of LoRA. By
adding residual paths during training and using merging approaches to eliminate
these extra paths during inference, our method can achieve better results in
fewer training steps without any extra trainable parameters or inference cost
compared to LoRA. The experiments on NLG, NLU, and text-to-image tasks
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. To the best of our knowledge,
ResLoRA is the first work that combines the residual path with LoRA. The code
of our method is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps/tree/main/reslora .
|
[
-0.2958008051,
-0.5860072374,
0.4592786133,
-0.1433716416,
-0.3145474792,
0.0986762568,
-0.4075975716,
-0.5688132644,
0.2880556881,
0.6014962792,
-0.5296596289,
-0.4529218674,
-0.4872917831,
-0.0800302625,
-0.2389860302,
0.8706851602,
0.0893855393,
-0.2252828032,
0.2155809551,
-0.6460453868,
-0.7172253728,
-0.1978881955,
-0.8602936864,
-0.3139299452,
1.2947304249,
0.6371238828,
0.6948927641,
0.3926493526,
0.3566557169,
0.2441305965,
-0.1234169155,
0.4107069373,
-0.9067854881,
0.2096645534,
-0.5933820605,
-0.50112468,
-0.6454417109,
-0.0499463119,
0.9350840449,
0.7371067405,
0.0079028681,
0.5779696703,
0.0434869081,
1.033531785,
-0.7800931931,
-0.3910183012,
-0.8734972477,
-0.1675196737,
-0.13738662,
-0.4432891607,
-0.4648177028,
-0.4426481724,
-0.1268654764,
-0.4335871041,
-0.1367338896,
-0.0726299882,
0.9570096135,
0.5373566151,
-0.2799122334,
0.2911007404,
-0.8998196721,
0.7460266948,
-0.818864584,
0.4288722873,
0.0149654606,
0.5176321864,
-0.2741848528,
-0.6360825896,
-0.1854203641,
0.0081866821,
0.1631958783,
-0.1233298331,
-0.3260058165,
-0.0630518496,
-0.0070824153,
0.181222409,
-0.1729021072,
0.5448358059,
-0.586564362,
0.1535635442,
0.5197018981,
-0.2457928061,
0.097420074,
0.5315602422,
-0.1699298173,
-0.0172411483,
-1.2173902988,
-0.3026404977,
0.3000200689,
0.7489121556,
-0.0491872877,
0.3668536842,
-0.1456754357,
1.2017745972,
0.0610871762,
-0.3461703658,
0.1999310702,
-0.1023848802,
-0.2808783352,
0.2195273042,
0.1785375774,
0.221189782,
0.225181818,
-0.2656053901,
0.0486973226,
-0.0950048268,
0.0223276298,
-0.7445162535,
-0.1180473343,
0.0919261947,
-0.4435471892,
-0.1714421064,
-0.1909727454,
-0.818933785,
-0.5868267417,
-0.5327813029,
0.2744643092,
-0.3060355484,
0.0229967907,
-0.0183475129,
0.2878883183,
0.5057894588,
0.787186265,
-0.5421580672,
0.2000995874,
0.6804689169,
0.6641961336,
-0.4199124873,
-0.425575912,
-0.9417179227,
0.0821983591,
-0.3566263318,
1.0375238657,
-0.4200725555,
0.195604533,
-0.1693636924,
0.1425572634,
-0.1351524442,
-0.5811648369,
0.4908761382,
-0.6493409276,
0.2427707165,
-0.1931307018,
-0.274952203,
-0.4627635479,
0.0721937418,
-0.6250010729,
1.0615478754,
0.5982475877,
-0.4269849956,
0.1062576547,
-0.6200765967,
-0.1309832186,
-0.1331298053,
0.152232632,
-0.3599155545,
0.1893739402,
-0.0243836623,
-0.0261465423,
-0.3712633848,
0.0551773012,
-0.3407555521,
-0.6880773902,
-0.0476177633,
-0.5053908825,
0.5970592499,
0.1159625724,
-0.2916963995,
0.2594301999,
-0.8542271256,
0.0752865076,
-0.0758250654,
-0.6104578972,
-0.4018398225,
-0.0788753182,
0.0789803937,
0.2425630391,
0.3428622186,
-0.2726312578,
0.473254621,
-0.4629046619,
0.1179178208,
0.9684889317,
0.0639521256,
0.4665527046,
-0.3131277859,
0.5441940427,
-0.1502795666,
-0.0657696202,
0.118034184,
-0.62228477,
-1.0776683092,
-0.2521986365,
0.6776164174,
0.469550997,
-0.5936275721,
0.5310078263,
-0.6248435974,
-0.8186635971,
-0.6045921445,
0.3757767677,
0.3164450526,
0.5056921244,
0.4278288782,
-0.1825046688,
-0.5369364619,
-0.7870624065,
-0.4616522193,
-0.0155466124,
0.0541967712,
0.213137567,
0.2364788353,
-0.3337562382,
1.1928005219,
-0.4476130307,
-0.6655778885,
-0.086940825,
-0.1882813871,
0.4435771108,
0.5289573669,
0.8363075256,
-0.4179471135,
-0.7114059329,
0.243027404,
-0.312209934,
-0.3355077207,
-0.1881045252,
-0.2453788072,
0.2433123887,
0.458835274,
-0.0096264537,
0.4099647701,
0.8835258484,
-0.6088442802,
0.1102968752,
-0.3881054819,
0.087722145,
-0.9331184626,
0.2712881565,
-0.1909001768,
-0.632153213,
-0.5880034566,
0.1468605101,
-0.2765420675,
-0.1512368768,
-0.5680583119,
0.6239100695,
-0.5267272592,
-0.4546901882,
-0.4363161922,
0.3787836432,
-0.1059923247,
0.7217139602,
-0.3117458224,
0.9046224356,
0.2230540067,
-0.3997689188,
0.2313725352,
-0.1651251018,
0.0378091894,
0.6128342748,
-0.3211557567,
0.3144074082,
-0.0791996047,
0.2467768937,
-0.9396185875,
0.2309007645,
0.3417016566,
-0.0634261742,
0.1314613223,
-0.333414942,
-0.2631713152,
0.1089227125,
-0.2728327513,
0.4659812152,
0.8076500893,
-0.8149327636,
0.9171984196,
0.1679124087,
0.0202452019,
-0.306529969,
-0.4434945881,
0.2581936419,
-0.6055821776,
-0.2900711894,
0.6356101036,
-0.0697030053,
-0.1115666404,
-0.1294161677,
0.1604673713,
-0.0997051671,
0.4084129035,
0.2382496446,
0.0289059319,
-0.4193653762,
0.0060645225,
0.103562735,
-0.2643485367,
-0.5891759396,
0.051255092,
0.5104241371,
-0.0982019603,
-0.4875018895,
-0.6160125136,
0.17179811,
0.6927282214,
-0.0305551775,
0.909460485,
0.6149190664,
-0.4219256341,
-0.1774141639,
-0.5001242161,
-0.0534241982,
-0.4884358346,
0.2659436762,
-0.207080543,
-0.7328888774,
0.6854553223,
-0.5129640698,
0.1607151181,
0.3862443566,
0.2824048698,
0.0757081807,
0.3852835298,
0.8106684089,
-0.3278146386,
0.6447355747,
-0.1189488545,
0.2975866497,
-0.959826529,
0.2233460099,
-0.5465142131,
-0.7430168986,
-0.39825207,
-0.6061881185,
0.3104381263,
0.3400315642,
-0.288955152,
0.391956538,
-0.5677452683,
0.4096418917,
0.4646083415,
0.1604549289,
0.6329761744,
0.183239609,
0.5499081016,
-0.2021417022,
-0.7925652862,
-0.3336479366,
0.8663575053,
0.5110551715,
0.7509434223,
0.3935010433,
0.8579740524,
0.3550690114,
0.7676003575,
-0.7401974201,
0.4820267856,
-0.3756898642,
-0.0478456505,
-0.3663378656,
-0.0822828636,
-1.0337189436,
0.4389988482,
-0.2176206261,
-0.8958630562,
0.5980158448,
0.3671326935,
-0.5642235875,
0.3641724885,
-0.6476230621,
0.6415331364,
-0.1136687249,
-0.4313649833,
-0.1698868126,
-0.2384962738,
0.3281829655,
-0.4438989758,
0.0277903564,
-0.1229556277,
-0.1548288316,
0.9366336465,
-0.3873212934,
1.0759646893,
-0.2460400015,
-0.5990476012,
0.2235886902,
-0.0232956894,
0.7937871218,
-0.2847428918,
-0.1260277927,
0.0211377926,
0.0166525599,
-0.2779015601,
-0.7354052067,
0.9630662203,
-0.6124263406,
-0.4323310256,
-0.4216664135,
-0.4319448769,
-0.4569951296,
0.1937337965,
-0.0933720171,
0.0740058795,
-0.0511498563,
0.2999655604,
0.4907507002,
-0.2733618617,
0.2273404896,
0.6448239684,
-0.3482846022,
-0.4089101553,
0.9635291696,
0.1286811531,
0.2228907943,
0.157369405,
0.1519658417,
0.01171837,
-0.6447918415,
-0.1011818722,
0.5004969239,
-0.7261227965,
-0.417064935,
-0.011878428,
-0.1796152443,
-0.247760728,
-0.2792378664,
-0.6885235906,
-0.3835599124,
-0.5634916425,
0.2513726354,
0.6163800359,
0.4422383606,
0.0952535197,
0.5519724488,
-0.6260719299,
0.3985027373,
0.2305106968,
0.2892473042,
0.0799150169,
-0.9894521832,
-0.2359964997,
0.0058816965,
-0.0984638557,
-0.8180762529,
0.3896767795,
0.6122507453,
0.3128850758,
0.2874853611,
0.0515227504,
1.1363401413,
-0.5947492719,
0.5989397764,
0.0402128324,
-0.6018347144,
0.3787586689,
-0.2317517102,
0.1691476852,
0.8863602281,
-0.2818941474,
-0.4843171239,
-0.0089889737,
-0.3930774927,
-0.7167621255,
0.4201152325,
-0.0516430847,
-0.1343513429,
0.5796486735,
0.5517359972,
-0.078782171,
-0.127361089,
-0.7217235565,
-0.3637527227,
0.3159883916,
-0.1966808289,
-0.1565199047,
-0.4363593459,
-0.42899701,
-0.4453268945,
0.7942348123,
-0.4684993327,
-0.0497073308,
0.1636523604,
-0.1133073345,
-0.0753388107,
0.1366943419,
0.7284319997,
0.9010494351,
-0.3848595619,
0.048045136,
0.4224154949,
-0.2196612954,
0.2266521007,
-0.1234413385,
-0.0878400058,
0.0377935097,
0.5541374087,
0.6826516986,
0.4913401902,
-0.6096544266,
0.2142981738,
0.221232444,
-0.0466713421,
-0.380274415,
0.0632454529,
0.0817919225,
0.2539484799,
0.4038258493,
0.1399643868,
-0.2426424474,
-0.5081796646,
0.1597544253,
0.1840524077,
-0.590336144,
-0.2193692774,
0.2373894155,
0.1506462544,
-0.4644372463,
0.2938468456,
0.0657872036,
-0.3000115454,
0.3458233476,
0.5760809779,
0.8949195743,
-0.2568793595,
0.087768808,
0.1343975812,
0.3248183727,
0.0198575817,
0.2309384495,
0.3024046719,
-0.5669134855,
-0.3600755334,
-0.5555754304,
-0.1395480186,
0.0565758124,
-0.4149851203,
0.3779866099,
-0.3441411555,
-0.0562893637,
-0.3581438065,
-0.128737554,
-0.3611288667,
-0.2140945792,
0.0342388153,
1.1049282551,
-1.028252244,
1.0519464016,
0.3847826719,
-0.139378503,
-0.6231865883,
-0.1323624551,
-0.3194229603,
-0.6071169972,
0.7623028159,
-0.2419997454,
-0.4152560532,
0.1845957339,
-0.2944894731,
-1.2609126568,
1.3369858265,
0.8490743041,
-0.493447572,
-0.1014657542,
-0.1146931574,
0.6749879122,
-0.5775761008,
-0.2885203958,
0.7511780262,
0.712179184,
0.0609893203,
-0.8330030441,
0.1207491755,
0.2265540212,
0.1367319971,
-0.1209738702,
-0.6626116037,
0.7699292898,
-0.0307747908,
-0.2494812012,
0.4456393123,
0.724034965,
0.5186402202,
0.1056600586,
0.577642858,
0.6725366712,
0.8108311296,
-0.0424244255,
0.6979244351,
-0.3564819992,
0.5288368464,
1.6506958008,
-0.3993695378,
0.9973131418,
0.7508509159,
-0.2530859113,
0.7855044603,
0.7454829812,
0.0673331246,
0.5544703603,
0.2083902955,
-0.0082641589,
-0.253870368,
-0.1380330324,
-0.5059403777,
0.4215024114,
0.1400971711,
-0.418420583,
-0.5472325683,
-0.025423374,
0.0709832311,
0.242878899,
-0.3379645944,
0.5249218941,
-0.0137217399,
-0.5860831738,
1.0471946001,
0.1020790935,
0.6497440338,
-0.4771083295,
-0.415181309,
-0.4322496355,
0.3054719865,
-0.3115230501,
-0.2392384112,
0.1700679511,
-0.1879998893,
0.049108386,
0.0076438077,
0.7032008767,
-0.4916130006,
-0.51885432,
0.4017238915,
0.4192517102,
0.0427343771,
-0.1087150127,
-0.6964425445,
0.2501681447,
0.048357293,
-0.1162058935,
0.4747714102,
0.1418244392,
-0.1895528436,
0.7426168919,
0.6982408762,
0.2893972993,
0.0698676929,
0.1246243119,
0.9847015738,
-0.6000429392,
-0.4462164938,
-0.603112042,
0.3040878773,
0.0442927033,
-0.069066979,
0.5936194062,
0.5922736526,
0.159342289,
-0.0645431578,
0.3461318016,
0.2038668692,
0.5501941442,
-0.6868544817,
0.7482314706,
-0.6542260647,
0.4634006321,
-0.1876949966,
-1.4166904688,
-0.3217935562,
0.397962898,
-0.0965564176,
-0.0198238175,
0.7025328279,
0.8121861815,
-0.2786303759,
-0.8006648421,
0.4099613726,
0.151995495,
0.3735552132,
0.78496629,
0.2635273933,
-0.8257884979,
0.2262229621,
0.0257937722,
-0.2735360861,
-0.4173436761,
-1.1301480532,
-0.6076130271,
-0.4073411822,
-0.4791402221,
-0.4711310267,
0.1428497732,
0.603377223,
0.735334456,
-0.7815095782,
-0.0965435654,
0.0642090291,
0.4479840994,
-0.4806979299,
-0.2045826018,
0.5983044505,
-0.0155167412,
-0.845136404,
0.5428745747,
0.3195254803,
-0.0022543916,
-0.5181932449,
-0.196121335,
-0.437092036,
-0.0165823605,
0.5109691024,
0.7730286717,
-0.8036069274,
-0.6119536161,
-0.5354143381,
0.1532416195,
0.2049247622,
0.6326842308,
-1.059437871,
0.1558742821,
0.5425485969,
0.7271963954,
0.1598966867,
0.3061696589,
0.5984583497,
-0.5482704639,
0.325812161,
-0.0558501184,
0.4337062836,
0.3045319021,
-0.3405506611,
0.7346938848,
0.2075137347,
-0.300560683,
-1.1484754086,
0.2402873039,
-1.343334794,
-0.2788010538,
1.2619639635,
-0.1675695181,
-0.5603724718,
-0.0147508588,
-0.3908394575,
0.1114249751,
-0.1896776855,
0.6057146788,
0.1185208857,
-0.0382039994,
-0.3206689358,
-0.1900762916,
0.5735048056,
0.2885199189,
-0.9102490544,
0.2548896968,
0.2914388478,
0.3473383784,
0.3467197716,
0.6469166875,
0.0420295149,
0.1933021396,
-0.5133571625,
-0.1351442337,
-0.0936875418,
-0.387345612,
-0.6881653666,
0.1610962003,
0.5111079216,
-0.086541079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18031v1
|
Corpus-Steered Query Expansion with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T03:58:58 | 2024-02-28T03:58:58 |
Yibin Lei, Yu Cao, Tianyi Zhou, Tao Shen, Andrew Yates
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Recent studies demonstrate that query expansions generated by large language
models (LLMs) can considerably enhance information retrieval systems by
generating hypothetical documents that answer the queries as expansions.
However, challenges arise from misalignments between the expansions and the
retrieval corpus, resulting in issues like hallucinations and outdated
information due to the limited intrinsic knowledge of LLMs. Inspired by Pseudo
Relevance Feedback (PRF), we introduce Corpus-Steered Query Expansion (CSQE) to
promote the incorporation of knowledge embedded within the corpus. CSQE
utilizes the relevance assessing capability of LLMs to systematically identify
pivotal sentences in the initially-retrieved documents. These corpus-originated
texts are subsequently used to expand the query together with LLM-knowledge
empowered expansions, improving the relevance prediction between the query and
the target documents. Extensive experiments reveal that CSQE exhibits strong
performance without necessitating any training, especially with queries for
which LLMs lack knowledge.
|
[
-0.2389265597,
-0.7828765512,
0.9691503644,
0.0494848713,
-0.2736676931,
0.1639444828,
-0.3390850723,
-0.2860105634,
0.3768316209,
0.7577552795,
-0.7022049427,
-0.6006016731,
-0.5756884217,
-0.0807842314,
-0.7884662151,
0.73458004,
0.428165555,
0.1618251204,
-0.1975524724,
0.0503136739,
-0.3835439682,
-0.7777912617,
-0.2788058519,
0.25203228,
0.4873356521,
0.2537847757,
0.8714522719,
0.3632025421,
0.420789361,
0.1869976074,
-0.1648480594,
0.4626881182,
-0.8004169464,
0.2695255578,
-0.2952847779,
-0.7213402987,
-0.182389468,
-0.3106188178,
0.9517034292,
0.7158156037,
-0.2260502726,
-0.1727528274,
0.0528018177,
0.6813034415,
-0.8207894564,
-0.1156713441,
-0.6622652411,
-0.2086246312,
-0.2539232671,
-0.4891664386,
-0.4262501895,
-0.6388428211,
0.3653367162,
-0.5374349356,
0.0521581285,
0.3041034639,
0.6216458082,
0.0783123448,
-0.4660953879,
-0.5167807937,
-0.6794353724,
0.8023261428,
-0.5465022326,
0.6576751471,
0.1808076501,
0.2398420125,
-0.5003790259,
-0.8052867055,
-0.4630544782,
-0.427683264,
-0.1252610087,
0.0896288007,
-0.0007883633,
0.1557810754,
0.18916291,
0.2568857372,
-0.5535745621,
-0.0705393776,
-0.3060738444,
-0.247798413,
0.3996582925,
0.0893470347,
0.2765977085,
-0.1093077809,
-0.1853529513,
-0.0532856099,
-0.9227576852,
-0.1890748292,
0.2613318264,
0.2672375441,
0.3801934421,
0.6885539889,
-0.197001636,
0.9531209469,
0.374432981,
0.0564258471,
0.051794827,
-0.3787133098,
0.084328562,
0.0576855429,
0.6076547503,
0.1231843755,
-0.1171960682,
-0.3985597193,
-0.1484327316,
-0.4446606338,
0.4703897238,
-0.8233677745,
0.1075220332,
0.1454432309,
-0.3657119572,
-0.0503541902,
0.2728748918,
-0.7026251554,
-0.482486397,
-0.2983951569,
0.325474292,
-0.6609772444,
-0.3683053255,
-0.109047778,
-0.1790083349,
0.4564330876,
0.213550508,
-0.6020748019,
0.1340507865,
0.7382663488,
0.4513180256,
-0.2249624878,
0.0780166611,
-0.8966190815,
0.0784750879,
-0.5388048887,
0.8155997396,
-0.8962927461,
-0.8018606305,
0.3183761239,
0.0732349232,
-0.0129028307,
-0.6230481267,
0.7648748159,
-1.2602128983,
0.1633158922,
-0.5106550455,
-0.7506377697,
-0.0933960229,
0.21179986,
-0.4422070682,
1.3108640909,
0.1620398313,
-0.6945418715,
0.1424962282,
-0.5300361514,
-0.3536937833,
0.1248844117,
-0.2423996329,
0.0237109903,
0.1809123158,
0.0934307277,
0.1805769056,
-0.4943775833,
0.5126077533,
-0.33608073,
-0.4052425027,
0.1274954826,
-0.1298696846,
0.6212062836,
0.0994817242,
0.0156331137,
0.2788122892,
-0.6297946572,
0.2048122287,
-0.1441539526,
-0.1895045042,
-0.5783889294,
0.0710540339,
-0.2510976195,
-0.0532000922,
0.5330210328,
-0.2435189635,
0.2421031445,
-0.7349620461,
0.114864409,
0.3111311793,
0.2347974926,
0.835997045,
-0.1784428954,
0.7999864221,
-0.0182876065,
-0.004695612,
-0.153788045,
-0.3449210525,
-0.5602662563,
-0.1090373173,
0.5046312213,
0.5915369391,
-0.8871881366,
0.4301121831,
-0.3842845261,
-0.5099332929,
-0.4421168864,
0.2262815982,
0.0993023887,
0.4485992193,
0.4462372065,
0.0052345661,
-0.502473712,
-0.8497498035,
-0.3083558083,
-0.3428137898,
-0.1645154506,
0.4748765826,
0.1389416605,
0.0217192844,
1.0706138611,
-0.6056523323,
-0.0855762213,
-0.1932900697,
0.0757691786,
0.3376636505,
0.1428283602,
0.3932928443,
-1.1072795391,
-0.3308459818,
-0.2336010933,
-0.5845056772,
-0.3004707992,
-0.0490025952,
-0.461275965,
-0.1355474591,
0.7250289321,
-0.5498167276,
0.1557500809,
0.2035384923,
-0.0719801411,
0.7808785439,
-0.2451539934,
0.2587928474,
-1.0308827162,
-0.0344627723,
-0.1121208742,
-0.1522114575,
-0.372679621,
0.2173710316,
0.5715663433,
0.0244640838,
-0.3401145637,
0.5113770366,
-0.6562258005,
-0.1773316264,
-0.5130659342,
0.465120554,
-0.1947092116,
0.1068591103,
0.3250828683,
0.8900995255,
0.6484345198,
-0.8964751959,
0.0882857963,
0.0823511705,
-0.0969553143,
0.4419943392,
-0.3053915799,
0.0112587512,
-0.2465870678,
0.1280880868,
-1.0232366323,
-0.0072915098,
-0.2080846727,
-0.4405187368,
0.3782269061,
-0.185186848,
-0.6844702363,
-0.5237573385,
-0.3478243947,
0.2107346207,
0.4229311645,
-0.7204039097,
0.8259956837,
0.3482087851,
-0.1805774719,
-0.809014082,
-0.169300288,
0.1285355091,
-0.1943590194,
-0.6913388968,
0.6676876545,
-0.0576336049,
-0.2480736226,
0.0927463472,
0.1007899493,
-0.1172362641,
-0.0977996662,
0.1077613607,
0.3293077946,
-0.3822757602,
0.3315796256,
0.4729854167,
0.3740282357,
0.0093091568,
-0.5308745503,
0.6287033558,
0.056472864,
-0.2041057497,
0.0116663249,
0.3104947209,
0.5443452001,
-0.3609595001,
0.7730466127,
0.4788351953,
-0.1495692581,
-0.1044312641,
-0.7777295113,
-0.5325624347,
-0.4683679342,
0.5354547501,
-0.4857366383,
-1.1728206873,
0.4053537846,
-0.4261125028,
-0.1206519976,
0.5565267205,
0.4738468826,
-0.1597411782,
0.8905212879,
0.7797073126,
0.0453200601,
0.5213796496,
-0.042626638,
0.1096391007,
-0.9637846351,
-0.0374786519,
-0.4787814021,
-0.0469096601,
-0.7333567739,
-0.5856446624,
0.4124312997,
0.4964196086,
0.0932242274,
0.4032155275,
-0.3766870499,
0.4313420355,
0.5288590193,
0.0477141812,
0.2744119167,
-0.2688930929,
-0.4673092067,
-0.1130321175,
-0.8611588478,
-0.2691545486,
1.4037222862,
-0.1116246507,
0.4793310165,
0.3094211817,
0.7115310431,
0.3660589755,
0.4029389322,
-0.8407123089,
0.6020359397,
-0.0002731972,
-0.6380176544,
-0.1603097469,
-0.3530633748,
-0.9176985025,
0.3252060115,
-0.3420221806,
-0.5746689439,
0.297167182,
-0.1259268373,
-0.6028234363,
-0.0758530498,
-0.6268250942,
0.427685529,
-0.4222881198,
-0.7341415286,
-0.4603723884,
-0.6058695316,
0.3615384102,
-0.3056289256,
0.1730492711,
0.3418924212,
-0.1708582789,
0.7796474695,
-0.4919855297,
0.6703791618,
-0.1876850724,
-0.0669314489,
0.6209460497,
0.1434948742,
0.6837903857,
0.2236960232,
-0.3025419414,
-0.1402576715,
0.1528209001,
-0.2879939377,
-0.7289016247,
0.9268740416,
-0.4183654785,
-1.1817797422,
-0.289659977,
-0.3863527775,
-0.5583718419,
0.4469439983,
-0.0699354857,
0.1891980171,
-0.3117960393,
0.3761928082,
0.7433707714,
-0.3547333181,
0.3047395647,
1.1382980347,
-0.4900800586,
-0.1683600694,
0.4983802438,
0.2276031673,
0.1057792231,
0.6442847848,
0.0970385671,
-0.7990034223,
-0.6852998137,
-0.4088803828,
0.4469502568,
-0.4208029509,
-0.1816659868,
-0.6991245151,
-0.1687285155,
-0.5678914785,
0.0174879674,
-0.221845746,
-0.3214510083,
-0.3781687617,
-0.0925948024,
0.3428681493,
0.429110527,
-0.0327855758,
0.489762336,
-0.9791805744,
0.0499855429,
0.0689271167,
0.1259012222,
-0.1223745421,
-0.7666295171,
-0.147520408,
-0.1779570431,
-0.4488252401,
-1.20274508,
0.5660441518,
-0.102385968,
0.6088764071,
0.4625877142,
0.2381064743,
0.6318653226,
-0.4784285426,
0.7438138127,
0.105606325,
-0.5721576214,
0.5780074596,
-0.5454967022,
0.2973796427,
0.5874813199,
0.623351872,
-0.1914713383,
-0.4453025162,
-0.5518713593,
-0.8143376708,
0.5237722993,
0.0673326775,
0.1846348494,
-0.2999299765,
0.7768183351,
-0.1791042686,
0.2075323462,
-0.2172498703,
-0.0510053635,
0.1944490373,
-0.0459577963,
0.3302171528,
-0.5518019199,
0.2344757169,
-0.1271409988,
0.8044987321,
-0.1439187974,
0.264015764,
0.4404031634,
-0.2625383139,
0.0151347574,
0.2864892781,
0.3595921695,
0.6651554108,
-0.3321276009,
-0.1699137241,
0.1698188782,
-0.2672639489,
-0.2075414807,
0.1283372939,
-0.0389525145,
-0.0966820195,
0.0270809233,
0.3856474161,
0.3365175724,
-0.8691066504,
0.5476189852,
0.0066457991,
-0.0706242695,
-0.473241806,
0.0854469016,
0.373283267,
0.2760597467,
0.7841958404,
-0.2436563969,
0.4339274168,
-0.5598919988,
0.430000484,
0.6264532208,
-0.5567453504,
-0.090078108,
0.6731368303,
0.1561294198,
-0.163404271,
0.5804684162,
-0.1820222139,
-0.6186561584,
0.4571869075,
0.5716790557,
0.5128685236,
-0.1502345204,
-0.0256355722,
0.6030101776,
0.3276616037,
-0.1917957813,
0.2269560546,
-0.2149004936,
-0.7129211426,
-0.7705201507,
-0.6416836977,
-0.3346648216,
0.0948947296,
-0.6733968258,
0.5694131255,
-0.3642215133,
-0.3976868391,
-0.2962005734,
0.0360336825,
-0.3538351655,
0.2145267725,
-0.0019436822,
1.007971406,
-0.2964735329,
1.172886014,
0.5102010369,
-0.386270225,
-0.6019411683,
0.245972693,
-0.1771857291,
-0.760353446,
0.7608546615,
-0.1551817954,
-0.2964485884,
0.1818304956,
-0.2898453176,
-1.0809038877,
1.0326138735,
0.2194360495,
-0.8397219777,
-0.1503681839,
-0.0046970486,
0.6544920802,
-0.404428035,
0.5704805255,
0.4567535222,
0.4692085385,
0.1587169617,
-0.8571373224,
-0.0383481197,
0.0203978624,
-0.0710158423,
0.3287958503,
-0.5642112494,
0.2688375115,
-0.1754477024,
-0.1265187413,
0.2146419287,
1.1436601877,
0.1025789008,
0.0224479437,
0.469301939,
0.2154005319,
0.9993301034,
0.0663886592,
1.2688499689,
-0.6667450666,
0.0050727171,
1.3495306969,
-0.4229594171,
1.1452488899,
0.4833041728,
-0.0551525541,
0.5360049605,
0.5758353472,
0.2829561234,
0.4947548807,
0.2152483761,
-0.2063077688,
-0.4528452158,
-0.2149313241,
-0.4173986018,
0.3250543773,
0.6860699058,
-0.6517926455,
-0.1318100989,
-0.1603592336,
-0.1571123004,
0.2953918576,
-0.3166681528,
0.7471579313,
-0.0392096192,
-0.8542739153,
0.5383136868,
0.1049916297,
0.7602633834,
-0.7048461437,
0.049411606,
-0.1987968832,
-0.1332312375,
-0.0744392872,
-0.706340611,
0.4578376412,
-0.1299135685,
-0.2832666337,
0.0458076224,
1.0337022543,
-0.3918479979,
-0.3965278566,
0.5998911858,
0.6896529794,
-0.0511155576,
-0.3302109838,
-0.5210439563,
-0.2104430944,
0.1619720012,
-0.1577400118,
0.5712240934,
0.4653550386,
-0.2350996435,
0.5228618979,
0.7553163767,
-0.0288304016,
0.2059087902,
-0.0290541388,
0.985175848,
-0.6865656972,
-0.4694822729,
-0.6865921617,
0.0531505719,
-0.3317883015,
0.0855343789,
0.7330055237,
0.7909228206,
0.3573545218,
0.0734085292,
0.8050251603,
0.0624740757,
0.8105350137,
-0.4988735616,
0.629863739,
-0.6667745113,
0.5078164935,
-0.0289503429,
-1.147161603,
-0.251455307,
0.2901952267,
-0.881621182,
-0.0386280306,
0.7704508305,
1.0875095129,
0.0881907493,
0.1292233467,
0.4434183836,
0.4111759663,
0.0232444536,
0.3125319779,
0.9262930751,
-0.1414564699,
0.7012127638,
0.1350492239,
-0.2847135365,
-0.3117375374,
-0.7606678009,
-0.6753130555,
-0.5095745921,
-0.2863099575,
-0.3758113384,
0.108584851,
0.6827456355,
0.763674438,
-0.6937153339,
-0.1109013855,
-0.0610963888,
0.1461327672,
0.0794357061,
-0.3380230367,
0.4930188358,
-0.4800003469,
-0.7678945065,
0.7465633154,
0.2548031509,
-0.3771967292,
-0.2462363243,
0.0171840359,
-0.382337898,
0.2821561098,
0.5751153231,
0.2449927181,
-0.4918534458,
0.1173636317,
0.2951665223,
0.023433568,
-0.0861011595,
0.8751612902,
-0.9982445836,
0.3498834074,
0.4551021159,
0.8003646731,
0.6682952642,
0.1256948858,
0.7283288836,
-0.6488985419,
-0.0611067526,
0.329310447,
0.2365590334,
0.1134205163,
-0.6529608369,
0.3965511322,
0.114361912,
-0.2938953638,
-0.6362563372,
0.0734526515,
-0.9186165333,
-0.350304544,
1.3033790588,
0.1040537208,
-0.4106389582,
0.0409383029,
-0.3052297235,
0.0602973886,
-0.5091817975,
0.5840072036,
0.6936648488,
-0.1627073288,
-0.0482536107,
-0.4436661005,
0.3256872296,
0.760604322,
-0.4035913646,
-0.0164539441,
0.6514987946,
0.219144702,
0.21123074,
0.608751893,
-0.5255898833,
0.2967509627,
-0.3281382918,
-0.2580823004,
0.2646628022,
-0.1073582396,
0.0351413451,
0.6621941924,
0.3326660395,
0.1874610484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18025v1
|
Hire a Linguist!: Learning Endangered Languages with In-Context Linguistic Descriptions
| 2024-02-28T03:44:01 | 2024-02-28T03:44:01 |
Kexun Zhang, Yee Man Choi, Zhenqiao Song, Taiqi He, William Yang Wang, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How can large language models (LLMs) process and translate endangered
languages? Many languages lack a large corpus to train a decent LLM; therefore
existing LLMs rarely perform well in unseen, endangered languages. On the
contrary, we observe that 2000 endangered languages, though without a large
corpus, have a grammar book or a dictionary. We propose LINGOLLM, a
training-free approach to enable an LLM to process unseen languages that hardly
occur in its pre-training. Our key insight is to demonstrate linguistic
knowledge of an unseen language in an LLM's prompt, including a dictionary, a
grammar book, and morphologically analyzed input text. We implement LINGOLLM on
top of two models, GPT-4 and Mixtral, and evaluate their performance on 5 tasks
across 8 endangered or low-resource languages. Our results show that LINGOLLM
elevates translation capability from GPT-4's 0 to 10.5 BLEU for 10 language
directions. Our findings demonstrate the tremendous value of linguistic
knowledge in the age of LLMs for endangered languages. Our data, code, and
model generations can be found at https://github.com/LLiLab/llm4endangeredlang.
|
[
-0.146754086,
-0.3752982914,
0.2658394277,
0.3169279993,
-0.2943776548,
0.0758153051,
-0.5110818148,
-0.6274866462,
0.1088049188,
0.8151607513,
-0.5507547259,
-0.3501989543,
-0.5484663844,
0.286128521,
-0.4608591795,
0.6520799398,
0.1819791347,
-0.140202418,
-0.1083416566,
-0.1469588727,
-0.2949533761,
-0.4663783014,
-0.4311693311,
-0.0394332036,
0.3708715439,
0.6513524055,
0.7789043784,
0.9128674865,
0.1829903722,
0.3337008655,
-0.4237076342,
0.1338986158,
-0.8358833194,
0.1886422336,
-0.1825768948,
-0.6430116296,
-0.2477829605,
-0.0744889081,
0.7108175159,
0.9020721316,
0.1938588768,
-0.0417215228,
-0.1030062139,
0.4487392306,
-0.4913392365,
0.1269359887,
-0.9950969815,
0.1156753078,
-0.3433992565,
-0.2613061368,
-0.5298838019,
-0.3573114276,
0.2189686745,
-0.75082165,
-0.1357475072,
-0.0993476287,
0.5974683166,
0.3392733037,
-0.3801760375,
-0.298020035,
-0.4239438474,
0.9587141275,
-0.5588856936,
0.2290170789,
0.6894872785,
-0.1116978899,
-0.2546173632,
-0.483759284,
-0.2977026403,
-0.1019689739,
-0.1184167117,
0.1173264086,
-0.128865242,
0.035055127,
0.1504531652,
0.2770585716,
-0.5004917383,
0.4347616136,
-0.3057195544,
-0.0821659043,
0.3511897027,
-0.0452790596,
0.3636116982,
-0.1614019871,
-0.4136311412,
0.0247683991,
-0.8274213672,
-0.2534879744,
0.2935319543,
0.4118507504,
-0.029687522,
0.3921734989,
-0.1638799012,
0.6919403076,
-0.1655075997,
0.1004681513,
0.2752515078,
0.2474839836,
0.047587052,
0.0008145539,
0.3864412308,
0.2357717603,
0.2687191665,
-0.2633762956,
-0.2632679343,
-0.3907515705,
0.2117194533,
-0.8018211126,
-0.0407903008,
-0.1228785589,
-0.2951282859,
-0.3297461569,
-0.727017343,
-0.7574031949,
-0.348831296,
0.048225861,
0.2527545393,
-0.5798201561,
-0.3680874109,
-0.023066882,
0.110200882,
0.2275250107,
0.2060964406,
-1.0961456299,
0.0240283702,
0.5132007599,
0.8892810941,
-0.1105070114,
-0.4097517729,
-0.7155663967,
0.1819161475,
-0.5422798991,
0.5072519779,
-0.6878027916,
-0.4300271273,
0.3289007545,
0.2062397301,
-0.1859223396,
-0.6155807972,
0.7185714245,
-0.729074955,
0.0014970262,
0.0902236477,
-0.4401013553,
-0.5838168263,
0.0869744271,
-0.5277130604,
0.9381884336,
0.2490933537,
-0.5542986393,
0.1950054616,
-0.5885512829,
-0.3512268662,
0.7515274882,
0.2398501039,
-0.0817480162,
0.2486675382,
0.1147996932,
0.3751125336,
0.0507991835,
0.1520818323,
-0.1857884973,
-0.2101091892,
0.3706255555,
-0.3658291698,
1.0931748152,
0.2925572991,
-0.275663197,
0.017942844,
-0.3606176972,
0.1383591145,
-0.0778312758,
-0.7153442502,
-0.4629971385,
-0.0556122065,
0.2195053846,
0.1781916022,
0.2246307284,
-0.3099497259,
0.0321633667,
-0.804576695,
0.3623997569,
0.6609435678,
-0.3584832847,
0.4915956557,
-0.1240531951,
0.7134222984,
-0.324474901,
-0.0640490279,
0.0219010804,
-0.2269502878,
-1.0865844488,
-0.2130357623,
0.1327283829,
0.6369188428,
-0.7755025029,
0.173807025,
-0.3572959006,
-0.2717056274,
-0.5179338455,
0.3772018254,
0.3020332158,
0.2685623169,
0.3366536796,
-0.2365412265,
-0.571400702,
-0.7063809037,
-0.4172941148,
-0.3536477983,
0.0971326903,
0.2644949257,
0.2226228267,
-0.598387897,
0.638348937,
-0.0151602859,
-0.2209338099,
-0.3610205054,
-0.049741324,
0.1559134573,
0.3961187899,
0.4220229685,
-0.7948210835,
-0.4371227622,
0.1434933394,
-0.808360219,
-0.2258649766,
0.1622385085,
-0.2602858543,
0.4969778955,
0.6841135621,
-0.5116696954,
-0.0037180798,
0.6771677136,
0.0777975619,
0.197640866,
-0.1891601086,
-0.3146372139,
-0.8257398605,
0.2253288478,
-0.3873963952,
-0.335952431,
-0.8259310126,
0.275960803,
0.1696639657,
-0.2941878736,
-0.704470396,
0.8564700484,
-0.6451564431,
0.0120571265,
-0.2258971483,
0.1523552239,
-0.7461454272,
0.3717216253,
0.4397067428,
0.4687093198,
0.710919559,
-0.5114533305,
0.0437114909,
0.529306829,
-0.4494612813,
0.1937470138,
-0.0179136433,
0.0701561049,
0.0059186071,
-0.275028199,
-0.5091320276,
-0.47862342,
0.156100437,
-0.2328217924,
0.6080711484,
-0.4619717598,
-0.1092457846,
-0.2753641009,
-0.0472051762,
0.4446160197,
0.4885607064,
-0.6190216541,
0.3738016784,
0.7442902327,
-0.6473582387,
-0.6996635795,
-0.6762422323,
0.4548538625,
-0.4823691249,
-0.3482015729,
-0.0997992828,
-0.2868739665,
-0.0625949949,
0.139132455,
-0.0504644513,
-0.3149820268,
0.5292524099,
0.3012832999,
0.1384913474,
-0.125785172,
0.1850250512,
-0.1499806643,
-0.1123669818,
-0.0162800532,
-0.4793239832,
0.3501548469,
-0.3254711628,
0.049209632,
0.2063654363,
0.2176364511,
0.4496782422,
-0.2007318884,
0.5172501206,
0.4212573767,
-0.3415443897,
-0.3179289997,
-0.4024692178,
0.2776536942,
-0.4771550894,
0.6265441179,
-0.1827882975,
-1.0291531086,
0.2354280651,
-0.3609219193,
0.1413823664,
0.3927723169,
0.5892692804,
0.2967574,
0.6280586123,
0.9283729792,
-0.2834848166,
0.6002576947,
-0.1413589418,
0.1054892913,
-0.4527267814,
-0.1301562637,
-0.1833999902,
0.0017832946,
-0.5018132329,
-0.6148119569,
0.4164201915,
0.3790258765,
0.0744150132,
0.4869693518,
-0.3153298199,
0.7985574603,
0.5242379308,
-0.0761305243,
0.2601841986,
0.1873322129,
-0.1983169466,
0.0325174704,
-0.9400451779,
-0.7461215258,
0.9757419825,
0.2253075093,
0.5773062706,
0.0923831686,
0.7069224119,
0.1039351448,
0.552280128,
-1.0768820047,
0.6906741858,
-0.2532815635,
-0.6548817754,
-0.7120590806,
-0.5236076713,
-0.7919235229,
0.4176521003,
0.0255380329,
-0.4340622723,
0.1303319931,
0.0193627533,
-0.0872918889,
0.2174829245,
-0.4390886724,
0.9648916125,
-0.8471512794,
-0.3938015401,
-0.3571662903,
-0.6978757381,
0.292162478,
-0.4862125218,
0.6102560759,
-0.2470948547,
-0.2402382344,
0.6279323101,
-0.2125583738,
0.9468200803,
-0.0999552608,
0.0451182947,
0.0483494624,
0.5430303812,
0.2897615135,
-0.1021404937,
-0.3214794397,
0.1581783891,
-0.2286388427,
-0.3513429761,
0.1237325743,
0.713144958,
-0.6265784502,
-0.6188833117,
-0.419983834,
-1.0446770191,
-0.2487060875,
0.6252275109,
0.2381408811,
0.0811319724,
-0.4598799646,
0.0573813692,
0.5114998817,
-0.5869728923,
0.5518115163,
0.7094662786,
0.082603924,
-0.1972801536,
0.8827173114,
0.1099364907,
0.3039111793,
0.4800033271,
0.1186531559,
-0.3558214903,
-0.6514267325,
-0.6038156748,
0.2259094268,
-0.9764765501,
-0.1267128289,
-0.8500371575,
-0.0943786427,
-0.0957459882,
-0.326359868,
-0.1206790209,
-0.4479760528,
-0.34897995,
-0.1465497017,
0.377466172,
0.8007069826,
-0.4508131444,
0.197501421,
-0.6623210311,
-0.1094555855,
0.2704800367,
0.2064383328,
-0.087126039,
-0.7877586484,
-0.4474562705,
0.2068798095,
-0.161410585,
-0.4183706045,
0.9033951759,
0.6340563893,
0.7457482219,
0.3189686835,
0.2037738711,
0.6517989635,
-0.531809628,
0.4038229585,
-0.0099177631,
-0.8814353347,
0.2612482905,
-0.4365375638,
0.1644691229,
0.3012506068,
0.7604929209,
-0.8595481515,
-0.7307322025,
-0.329626888,
-1.0999794006,
1.033352375,
-0.0247350484,
0.4305787981,
-0.2842904329,
-0.0219997708,
0.0709608272,
0.1564716846,
-1.0895186663,
0.2883211672,
-0.1777171195,
-0.0042379894,
-0.310508281,
-0.6794092059,
-0.1394704729,
-0.0353545062,
0.6996278167,
-0.1472239643,
-0.0514982641,
-0.1295925081,
-0.8273984194,
-0.3548238575,
0.3448987603,
0.4467379451,
0.512427628,
-0.2240349203,
0.3966672421,
0.370577246,
-0.1062505618,
0.0069767544,
-0.0259157512,
-0.1800951958,
0.0312778093,
0.5340019464,
0.7129437923,
0.665815413,
-0.9447663426,
0.4645502865,
0.2248526514,
-0.194980979,
-0.4732468426,
-0.1510094553,
0.4604697526,
0.1335516423,
0.122311756,
-0.096315749,
-0.0583945215,
-0.5079123974,
0.0414733738,
0.3482478857,
-0.3142346442,
-0.1040385365,
0.7647770643,
0.3137081563,
-0.1256675571,
0.7415457368,
-0.2892933488,
-0.823112011,
0.29464674,
0.6476749182,
0.8000584245,
-0.2952857316,
0.2888967097,
0.1798242927,
0.4428795576,
-0.2822460532,
-0.0142413666,
0.1091598719,
-0.7013049126,
-0.2969401479,
-0.8677193522,
-0.4677023888,
0.1819574982,
-0.4128480256,
0.1424694508,
-0.0811172053,
0.2340043485,
-0.2266778052,
-0.3080806732,
-0.5734608173,
-0.2665280402,
0.101885967,
0.855014503,
-0.8927056789,
0.6372355819,
0.5696792006,
-0.2544257939,
-0.6059195399,
-0.1470461488,
0.0505695641,
-1.0258711576,
0.8810821176,
0.1188279688,
0.0054962966,
0.2613257766,
-0.3101127744,
-0.8838788867,
0.5022794604,
0.7650775313,
-0.3787046075,
0.1698587835,
0.0626555607,
0.5227867961,
-0.1861629635,
0.1794317961,
0.3945713043,
0.2895433009,
0.0438946411,
-0.8800699115,
-0.1453892887,
-0.1950840503,
0.026756281,
0.1214517578,
-0.4225170612,
0.6531621218,
-0.2494477928,
-0.4837941825,
0.4514152706,
0.1673475057,
-0.2184585184,
-0.2116259784,
0.4984593093,
0.2634455562,
0.8650104403,
0.2002551705,
1.0063962936,
-0.3627780676,
0.1598035991,
0.9292441607,
-0.225522697,
0.9662648439,
0.3256675899,
0.257258445,
0.1605919898,
0.7787466645,
0.2971709669,
0.4942644238,
0.2705569565,
-0.5394515991,
-0.58846277,
-0.3801341653,
-0.139641121,
0.3708423078,
0.5698119402,
-0.1755699962,
-0.3509770036,
0.1273328215,
-0.0895912349,
0.1455126703,
-0.5212467909,
0.6012122631,
0.2505871952,
-0.425832063,
1.2025485039,
-0.1335590631,
0.5923387408,
-0.449436903,
0.1077748016,
-0.4721999764,
0.3223760128,
-0.3317579627,
-0.5845239758,
0.2490530461,
0.1225999445,
-0.0241507702,
-0.5903866887,
0.6642310023,
-0.8592061996,
-0.5283309221,
0.5819135308,
0.5818560719,
0.8463688493,
0.0915312245,
-0.3791708946,
-0.1430112422,
0.0798962265,
-0.0782989338,
0.3044016957,
0.7433682084,
-0.4237867594,
1.0237634182,
0.4084230363,
0.439326793,
0.4167164564,
-0.1258780062,
0.8652297258,
-0.3272484541,
-0.3821424842,
-0.590425849,
0.2153088003,
0.0946978033,
-0.1233993396,
0.786118865,
0.6790754199,
1.1817359924,
-0.4710031748,
0.6966314912,
0.0067455117,
0.6972170472,
-0.3860590756,
0.830085218,
-0.5556307435,
0.1215450987,
-0.2797394991,
-0.713680923,
-0.4728165269,
0.7507691979,
-0.3730048537,
-0.3614484668,
0.5309069753,
0.9930253029,
-0.1730033457,
-0.3538188636,
0.6506379843,
0.4372982383,
-0.1034780368,
0.5798006058,
1.2114163637,
0.113445133,
0.8868114352,
-0.0261539929,
-0.3058232665,
-0.320945859,
-0.9128909707,
-0.8822777867,
-0.3122267425,
-0.0567259341,
0.1901741773,
0.0919397771,
0.7168859243,
0.747717917,
-0.7429594398,
-0.7890166044,
-0.0008216547,
0.0728691518,
-0.0223308876,
-0.1325491071,
0.1033412963,
-0.574328959,
-0.7968484759,
0.8442778587,
0.2815560997,
0.0261830501,
0.1745329201,
-0.36108917,
-0.214816168,
-0.3432355523,
0.6705638766,
0.4520222545,
-0.7570680976,
-0.219381243,
-0.087150149,
0.0156216742,
-0.3171781898,
0.5853503942,
-0.5023428798,
0.6193867922,
0.1288906485,
0.9204246998,
0.5928350687,
-0.3250867724,
0.6396393776,
-0.6523607969,
0.610902071,
0.5070753694,
0.2941383421,
0.3860473633,
-0.2615838349,
0.7059112191,
0.2259317487,
-0.5722694993,
-0.9359017015,
0.2124507576,
-0.6831312776,
-0.2345084101,
1.1969085932,
-0.287689805,
-0.082908161,
-0.2340597957,
-0.1019600108,
0.1669029742,
-0.1557413191,
0.5656031966,
0.5798850656,
0.2425187379,
-0.2936106622,
-0.795112431,
0.6396896839,
0.583497107,
-0.5258310437,
0.4308542013,
0.573628366,
0.3780617416,
-0.0713341683,
0.6439535022,
-0.0960148051,
0.177633822,
-0.162681669,
0.1756769866,
0.0256891679,
-0.1655315608,
-0.6035892963,
-0.1601665914,
0.647320807,
-0.0084736133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00829v1
|
TroubleLLM: Align to Red Team Expert
| 2024-02-28T03:40:46 | 2024-02-28T03:40:46 |
Zhuoer Xu, Jianping Zhang, Shiwen Cui, Changhua Meng, Weiqiang Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) become the start-of-the-art solutions for a
variety of natural language tasks and are integrated into real-world
applications. However, LLMs can be potentially harmful in manifesting
undesirable safety issues like social biases and toxic content. It is
imperative to assess its safety issues before deployment. However, the quality
and diversity of test prompts generated by existing methods are still far from
satisfactory. Not only are these methods labor-intensive and require large
budget costs, but the controllability of test prompt generation is lacking for
the specific testing domain of LLM applications. With the idea of LLM for LLM
testing, we propose the first LLM, called TroubleLLM, to generate controllable
test prompts on LLM safety issues. Extensive experiments and human evaluation
illustrate the superiority of TroubleLLM on generation quality and generation
controllability.
|
[
-0.2354108691,
-0.8343549967,
0.3122770488,
0.5553161502,
-0.0474629067,
0.1751988828,
-0.1162856296,
-0.3721476197,
-0.1399660856,
0.481377542,
-0.7189276814,
-0.4227544963,
-0.4993186295,
0.3160969913,
-0.3761278093,
0.8408324122,
-0.2944469154,
-0.2910811603,
-0.0675385892,
0.0346128419,
-0.7549527287,
-0.4685691297,
-0.8560687304,
-0.1193757728,
0.5396793485,
0.6636530161,
0.7734478712,
0.4360025525,
0.6858178973,
0.3117919266,
-0.1168645844,
0.3219475746,
-0.4825146794,
0.3754718304,
-0.0770895556,
-0.3666776717,
-0.3627573252,
-0.0455972888,
0.3982216716,
0.4653463066,
-0.2528050244,
-0.0872572511,
0.0390068628,
0.4372590482,
-0.3550355136,
0.0202097874,
-0.689101398,
0.0006860194,
0.055350244,
-0.2234122306,
-0.592782259,
-0.747688055,
-0.1878534704,
-0.4320686162,
-0.0833460838,
0.6255474091,
0.8687591553,
0.594861269,
-0.3038598299,
-0.2315357476,
-0.5817961693,
1.0928372145,
-0.6992819905,
0.1453237981,
0.1823871881,
0.5198144913,
-0.5548919439,
-0.1890817583,
-0.6903845668,
-0.2551133335,
0.0027702132,
-0.0370336287,
-0.3582101762,
-0.0594990626,
0.1088264585,
-0.0891415477,
-0.8516156673,
0.5186213851,
-0.0817920417,
-0.308185041,
0.9588032961,
0.626106441,
0.5899769068,
-0.0082879234,
-0.6376840472,
-0.0032207228,
-0.8921028376,
-0.4344214499,
0.2389701009,
0.440310061,
-0.2211373746,
0.6483701468,
0.0177907869,
0.8227450848,
-0.1525876671,
-0.2264826447,
-0.0870973244,
-0.3689712882,
-0.3751402795,
0.1447092593,
0.8219453692,
0.6159183979,
0.5145465732,
-0.0321781524,
-0.2186184376,
0.0020169658,
0.3353955746,
-0.5934419036,
-0.1723245978,
0.3837949336,
-0.019423563,
-0.4560010731,
-0.1978681535,
-0.8092250824,
-0.5712166429,
-0.1724810004,
0.3042364419,
-0.4792942107,
-0.4303196669,
0.0472338162,
0.3159564435,
0.2798356414,
0.2150128484,
-0.6124378443,
-0.0750179961,
0.5396858454,
0.4735806286,
-0.7273069024,
-0.3053665757,
-0.4494152367,
0.1126181409,
-0.3835024536,
0.5787750483,
0.0311431345,
-0.50160712,
0.1285208315,
-0.0285373572,
-0.1056532487,
-0.6615414023,
0.2897829413,
-0.6430158615,
0.2990738451,
0.0343592502,
-0.5002070069,
0.1915774345,
0.559028089,
-0.2854166031,
0.896248877,
0.0315723568,
-0.7486674786,
0.2013383806,
-0.5677003264,
-0.3070685863,
0.2942604125,
-0.2240470052,
-0.4377070069,
-0.3515885472,
-0.2928674817,
0.4121542573,
-0.2730450034,
0.4608015418,
0.0849583,
-0.1626617163,
0.4312434196,
-0.2851348221,
0.8164156675,
0.3545897305,
-0.4366866946,
0.3758369088,
-0.4128219783,
0.2553241849,
0.295922786,
-0.5554209948,
-0.2957333326,
-0.1787131578,
-0.0792988837,
0.1764309257,
0.1925518215,
-0.3301346302,
-0.1428470761,
-0.2470221519,
0.0418626443,
0.863389492,
0.0079899728,
0.1615100354,
-0.5674728155,
0.8541708589,
-0.0424040519,
0.2685293555,
0.0431695245,
-0.4262545109,
-0.8498247266,
-0.1164333075,
0.1864486039,
0.8450856805,
-0.4119830132,
0.6148410439,
0.0891028792,
-0.4521362185,
-0.1425407976,
0.2815915048,
0.6405979395,
0.3571457267,
0.2414525151,
0.4174350798,
-0.4719799161,
-0.9347897768,
-0.084555164,
-0.3559550643,
0.0927736312,
0.2554373741,
0.1701329201,
-0.544036746,
1.067133069,
-0.5890640616,
-0.0043167723,
-0.473973155,
0.105969958,
-0.0418148227,
0.4819417596,
0.3233466148,
-0.6679832935,
-0.4688919783,
-0.2593841553,
-0.5494989753,
-0.5352123976,
0.0228792224,
-0.2484951615,
0.6226570606,
0.619639039,
-0.6403867006,
-0.2018799782,
0.8041601777,
-0.5359656215,
0.7318080664,
-0.14318268,
-0.0432602651,
-1.1979695559,
-0.0298635419,
0.028827861,
-0.239544645,
-0.454061687,
0.1182077229,
0.142403245,
-0.2978896797,
-0.8052520156,
0.6626257896,
-0.3503274024,
0.4329351187,
-0.2287282199,
0.2219448239,
-0.0512297899,
0.1088190749,
-0.3356128633,
1.0575883389,
0.2478688657,
-0.9018020034,
0.2335302979,
0.2518005967,
-0.0969100073,
0.5146679282,
-0.6040824652,
-0.0279728733,
-0.1075084731,
-0.3453509212,
-1.0672873259,
-0.4416513443,
0.1170989648,
-0.1306362599,
0.5198313594,
0.4634570777,
-0.5702456236,
-0.419582963,
-0.0108227283,
0.3223800957,
0.9074107409,
-0.4274142981,
0.1316486001,
0.5580658317,
-0.4615857303,
-0.3949096501,
-0.5453600287,
0.0486878939,
-0.601901412,
-0.7320811749,
0.0296733528,
-0.4381693304,
-0.5618467331,
-0.4271045029,
0.0702427179,
-0.1602491587,
0.3911965787,
0.4221362174,
0.3505017757,
-0.0304135866,
0.3151437342,
-0.0455455445,
-0.2816475332,
0.2101515979,
0.3243222237,
0.4079445004,
0.0083715376,
-0.2553999424,
-0.3408250213,
0.5155287385,
0.4969213307,
-0.1487121433,
0.3914255798,
0.0703556389,
-0.2876062393,
-0.5713213086,
-0.5950095057,
-0.1014300883,
-0.5200021267,
0.3207974434,
0.1898600459,
-0.9535987377,
0.1137933433,
-0.268448323,
0.1455260068,
0.2041039169,
0.5178645253,
-0.2762253284,
0.9643256068,
0.7309367657,
0.0077844476,
0.081236437,
0.2578799725,
0.2031364441,
-0.1692061722,
-0.2950113416,
-0.6589294672,
-0.1161923558,
-0.281678021,
-0.29528597,
0.3631840348,
0.1534002572,
-0.6514748931,
0.2059014142,
-0.4749576449,
0.5766370296,
0.2350338548,
-0.1883335263,
0.3945742249,
-0.1201363802,
-0.2555231154,
-0.3011929989,
-0.7411453128,
-0.8014442921,
0.5106163621,
0.4854612947,
1.1248619556,
0.3182205856,
0.7046491504,
0.1815749109,
0.5316482782,
-0.6531113386,
0.780246377,
0.0771906152,
-0.5425946116,
-0.340852797,
-0.3060619235,
-1.0199161768,
-0.2289699316,
-0.1026936248,
-0.4125020802,
-0.4361052811,
0.2808664739,
-0.5524455309,
0.0251266249,
-0.8378994465,
0.8250365853,
-0.4556849897,
-0.1178798974,
0.2915403545,
-0.5138645768,
0.7561491132,
-0.4206182659,
0.3003155887,
-0.2082138509,
-0.0532617383,
0.7367710471,
-0.4403241873,
0.9803473353,
-0.0241248533,
-0.5544974208,
0.3317570984,
0.493480444,
0.659386754,
-0.0521187112,
-0.0950087905,
-0.0654174611,
-0.4703806043,
-0.0370047018,
-0.2395075709,
0.8411971927,
-0.5086880326,
-0.8662067056,
-0.3158283234,
-0.743863225,
-0.2937427461,
0.3302794397,
0.0967102349,
-0.0234015994,
0.0272186715,
-0.2808040679,
0.9388850331,
-0.6037508249,
0.6169915795,
0.6914687157,
-0.3336734474,
-0.0791510046,
0.8154636621,
-0.3819870949,
0.5276277661,
0.0225750655,
0.1746481657,
-0.3348770142,
-0.7677056789,
-0.287899673,
0.2906595469,
-0.4014149606,
-0.58749789,
-0.5835863352,
-0.2445901334,
0.0171114914,
-0.266898632,
-0.3918540478,
-0.0527524948,
-0.470071137,
-0.2079622597,
0.5549585819,
0.5513202548,
0.1282025129,
0.3979723752,
-0.9540401101,
0.1748318374,
0.3995620012,
0.137563169,
-0.467081666,
-0.2443452626,
0.0559017472,
-0.1909447163,
-0.3863622844,
-0.8033496141,
0.3676236272,
-0.1700541079,
0.5086069107,
0.2241091132,
0.4919942915,
0.264634192,
-0.4287874699,
0.914034009,
0.4198625982,
-0.7156810164,
0.6801683307,
-0.4135106802,
0.0334783681,
0.5477523208,
0.472643435,
-0.3439408541,
-0.7006387711,
-0.3732994795,
-0.7183606029,
0.504468143,
0.1483300179,
0.2237109095,
-0.3048368692,
0.0771984681,
0.183408618,
0.0104699451,
-0.5365475416,
-0.3740586042,
0.1374486983,
-0.3852694929,
0.0068290983,
-0.496155858,
-0.4372827709,
0.265455097,
0.4691828191,
-0.0618152767,
0.1745303571,
0.0645953864,
-0.0144333951,
-0.4910546541,
0.5903744102,
0.9021216035,
0.5840195417,
-0.0967921913,
0.3407489061,
0.2243073434,
-0.163102448,
0.4776555896,
-0.0518167913,
-0.2186277062,
-0.0410923176,
0.1826134473,
0.5119479299,
0.1810387075,
-0.9541082978,
0.431981653,
-0.032340724,
-0.3156309128,
-0.2904627025,
0.6247856021,
0.2216954529,
0.2135698348,
0.2242295444,
-0.2782114744,
-0.4992174506,
-0.1988955289,
0.3382195532,
0.5330498815,
-0.3413582146,
0.0728674009,
0.8579130173,
0.5335193276,
-0.6692742705,
0.4510993659,
-0.4452213347,
-0.5328977108,
0.8030489087,
0.8299905658,
0.6843805909,
-0.4783470035,
0.2944361269,
0.3050780594,
0.4893212914,
-0.0478879586,
0.615606904,
0.6819100976,
-0.791211307,
-0.496995002,
-0.5704030991,
-0.5490819216,
0.2230810523,
-0.2716782093,
0.2615663409,
-0.3660505712,
-0.0826362893,
-0.5092126727,
-0.2579114139,
-0.3375025988,
0.3007445633,
0.0295045096,
1.1603349447,
-0.6819083095,
0.5524197221,
0.6156546474,
-0.0074373963,
-1.1728223562,
-0.0591578446,
-0.0190290045,
-0.74506253,
0.9266704917,
0.2169499397,
0.1770337224,
0.2207844257,
-0.4823615551,
-0.547816813,
1.1997244358,
0.5250580907,
-0.9142268896,
0.0882070065,
0.2829192281,
0.2035276741,
-0.242498219,
-0.0872232094,
0.4552212656,
0.8922809958,
-0.0627364814,
-0.9466193914,
0.4611865282,
0.0220131874,
-0.055085279,
0.403357923,
-0.6386477351,
0.7799483538,
-0.6004166007,
-0.5017063022,
-0.030738702,
0.2761515677,
0.8447799087,
0.184637785,
0.5466715097,
0.3411312997,
0.8124278188,
-0.184169054,
1.1431194544,
-0.1724999845,
0.1682914644,
1.0447018147,
-0.4516034424,
0.4700419307,
0.6248183846,
-0.3061729968,
0.1404149681,
0.6277358532,
0.1439348459,
0.3642969728,
0.5822782516,
-0.2726412714,
-0.4042551517,
-0.2160806805,
-0.4361996651,
0.1711715162,
0.1269613802,
-0.2801772058,
-0.3789767623,
-0.1897234917,
0.1689298153,
0.1361994743,
-0.1541607976,
0.6344692707,
0.1333352178,
-0.604113996,
0.7711411119,
-0.0916182995,
0.9114950895,
-0.6462929845,
0.0954765603,
-0.4538171887,
0.0139220916,
-0.0947471708,
-0.7525379062,
0.5310717821,
0.0606950298,
-0.0516848117,
-0.233070612,
0.6720226407,
-0.5248823166,
-0.3214170039,
0.3466145992,
0.594786942,
0.1273902953,
0.0564819127,
-0.6096792221,
0.1244898513,
-0.0351321883,
-0.1176045612,
0.2508143485,
0.1950264722,
-0.1285870224,
0.8129178286,
0.326772809,
0.0552105308,
0.3344236016,
-0.1607257873,
0.6416581869,
-0.7947365642,
-0.3024750948,
-0.9056830406,
0.7060545087,
0.1563958079,
-0.2379469126,
0.7765951157,
0.1982338876,
0.4476440251,
-0.172101438,
0.832936883,
0.1778003722,
0.398515135,
-0.632301569,
1.015319705,
-0.5113917589,
0.2665275335,
-0.1638827771,
-0.7443706989,
-0.5833624005,
0.2394681722,
0.1911709607,
-0.0624248758,
0.8710339665,
1.1159499884,
0.1990723163,
-0.072100848,
0.3852573931,
0.197559312,
0.4418184757,
0.7425297499,
1.0869833231,
-0.1533908248,
0.7073565722,
0.0290781967,
-0.2756830156,
-0.2956378162,
-1.2768673897,
-0.8776583076,
-0.0402979106,
-0.6282719374,
-0.3314190507,
-0.0371075608,
0.8524814844,
0.4499647319,
-0.8172025681,
-0.0098942593,
-0.4243932366,
0.3864136934,
0.1890982538,
-0.2994086742,
0.0938072279,
-0.4671430588,
-0.6807531714,
0.5646621585,
0.0976554453,
0.5831819177,
-0.388936311,
-0.4930550456,
0.0619076267,
-0.0711013973,
0.3755665421,
0.2846569717,
-0.5196595192,
-0.3851363659,
0.0314997882,
-0.4645051956,
-0.1953646541,
0.6216309667,
-0.1840408593,
0.0737539008,
0.3357007504,
0.8447580338,
-0.3908009827,
0.0467659086,
0.809966743,
-0.7874233723,
-0.077574648,
0.2373796105,
0.2304473966,
0.3033393919,
-0.5222488642,
0.4469101131,
-0.1426413953,
-0.7569937706,
-1.0142111778,
0.3418502808,
-1.0409295559,
-0.1022753492,
1.6245443821,
-0.1892727911,
-0.026370855,
-0.358907491,
-0.3359301984,
0.2692727745,
-0.2619906962,
0.7894337177,
0.5011307001,
-0.1966946721,
-0.1127346307,
-0.3678064346,
0.5743437409,
0.6868775487,
-1.2803151608,
0.2433515191,
0.4302572608,
0.4054863453,
0.2006371468,
0.4717622995,
-0.0489500761,
0.1112001538,
-0.4546180069,
0.2066088766,
-0.4443908334,
-0.3485367,
-0.3623632193,
0.2071721405,
0.3882859945,
-0.1594813019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18023v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18023v2
|
Do Large Language Models Mirror Cognitive Language Processing?
| 2024-02-28T03:38:20 | 2024-05-28T05:51:15 |
Yuqi Ren, Renren Jin, Tongxuan Zhang, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in text
comprehension and logical reasoning, indicating that the text representations
learned by LLMs can facilitate their language processing capabilities. In
cognitive science, brain cognitive processing signals are typically utilized to
study human language processing. Therefore, it is natural to ask how well the
text embeddings from LLMs align with the brain cognitive processing signals,
and how training strategies affect the LLM-brain alignment? In this paper, we
employ Representational Similarity Analysis (RSA) to measure the alignment
between 23 mainstream LLMs and fMRI signals of the brain to evaluate how
effectively LLMs simulate cognitive language processing. We empirically
investigate the impact of various factors (e.g., pre-training data size, model
scaling, alignment training, and prompts) on such LLM-brain alignment.
Experimental results indicate that pre-training data size and model scaling are
positively correlated with LLM-brain similarity, and alignment training can
significantly improve LLM-brain similarity. Explicit prompts contribute to the
consistency of LLMs with brain cognitive language processing, while nonsensical
noisy prompts may attenuate such alignment. Additionally, the performance of a
wide range of LLM evaluations (e.g., MMLU, Chatbot Arena) is highly correlated
with the LLM-brain similarity.
|
[
-0.2441225946,
-0.7481626272,
0.9232708216,
0.1636709124,
-0.2436050624,
-0.070968762,
-0.7188677788,
-0.4149274528,
0.24836725,
0.4272964001,
-0.6357916594,
-0.3948737979,
-0.6340105534,
0.1121264249,
-0.1920728087,
0.4918352067,
0.1027683169,
0.582970798,
-0.5728801489,
-0.1159106717,
-0.6527177691,
-0.606981039,
-0.622508049,
-0.537863493,
0.4554403424,
-0.1353346705,
0.7956418395,
0.6731193066,
0.4712556899,
0.3275455534,
0.0812903047,
-0.0451950692,
-0.3327929974,
0.2045647204,
-0.2362328023,
-0.673340857,
-0.4362403154,
-0.0000060948,
0.8527085185,
0.7497563362,
-0.1621327549,
0.0938290134,
0.291410923,
0.518332541,
-0.3819091022,
0.1782122999,
-0.8408730626,
-0.227934286,
-0.1184041053,
-0.1926614046,
-0.4842664599,
-0.2860032916,
0.0239306241,
-0.4574888945,
-0.1301419586,
0.2168519348,
0.7768000364,
0.3030120134,
-0.3069808781,
-0.2644562721,
-0.3486353755,
0.9015317559,
-0.8222677708,
0.5831776261,
0.239324078,
0.0653809607,
-0.3167445362,
-0.1897367835,
-0.88817662,
-0.132805571,
-0.1691229492,
-0.0909413621,
0.0557114705,
0.0237642843,
0.4677345157,
-0.0615233481,
-0.786632359,
0.3761374056,
-0.1001392156,
-0.1916881353,
0.475132823,
0.39644292,
0.4562755227,
0.0144740297,
-0.1667596847,
-0.59345752,
-0.6116835475,
-0.0522683673,
0.2996109128,
0.2842230499,
-0.0884165242,
0.6331530213,
0.181340903,
0.9209524393,
0.0212063231,
-0.2551417053,
0.3745217025,
-0.1042445302,
-0.3128898442,
0.1062223613,
1.0454107523,
0.4225325286,
0.6243678927,
-0.1565801054,
-0.2381115109,
0.2904399335,
0.3485199213,
-0.5327201486,
0.0606302582,
0.0468674451,
-0.5093858242,
-0.0311614461,
-0.1047366709,
-0.294321835,
-0.4870596826,
-0.7409263849,
0.4040400088,
-0.613945961,
-0.1634402275,
0.1911767572,
0.1245500147,
0.6172844172,
0.2064338326,
-1.0816686153,
0.3205495775,
1.0102795362,
0.5808643103,
-0.3317280114,
-0.3162117004,
-0.1226737872,
0.1044374034,
-0.3006130755,
0.7452207804,
-0.7919660807,
0.1082619205,
0.0946419463,
-0.0291090813,
-0.342373848,
-0.5109321475,
0.3006219864,
-0.9217720032,
0.0638821051,
-0.4522524178,
-0.5236755013,
-0.1356022656,
0.3546948731,
-0.6888871789,
0.6493681669,
-0.372389257,
-0.7071733475,
0.255128175,
-0.095624797,
-0.3822423816,
-0.2840676606,
-0.6896747351,
-0.3260239661,
0.0430328883,
0.3415265381,
0.6664397717,
-0.4181081355,
0.1531826258,
-0.4964745641,
-0.4348956645,
0.7445193529,
-0.4020506442,
0.7387309074,
-0.1195467189,
-0.1637225449,
0.0942114815,
-0.3261437714,
0.2182906121,
0.0598978251,
0.024160618,
-0.4965516329,
0.0510455482,
-0.0975840539,
0.3172961771,
0.4290883243,
-0.4526078105,
0.2903059423,
-0.4016912878,
0.4965375364,
0.5221944451,
-0.1432897598,
0.4687388837,
-0.3128792644,
0.3266970813,
0.0009385453,
-0.1794353724,
-0.1794163138,
-0.3925479352,
-0.3687382936,
-0.3648774326,
0.2588887513,
0.4111858904,
-0.2459053844,
0.4310373366,
-0.7467218637,
-0.3022366166,
-0.5448317528,
0.075408332,
0.3195953965,
0.2142992616,
0.2042278051,
-0.2839404941,
-0.6267997026,
-1.0352373123,
-0.3357744515,
0.0420566201,
-0.1303735226,
-0.0638750941,
0.2031016201,
-0.1309179813,
0.7528937459,
-0.3331765234,
-0.3755048811,
0.1020026654,
-0.0022168513,
0.2427522093,
0.2714083493,
0.4065269232,
-0.344764024,
-0.279533565,
-0.0662335455,
-0.9104226232,
-0.0543997735,
-0.1441499442,
0.0707839578,
0.3301734924,
0.7375621796,
-0.7597668171,
0.06733834,
0.7117254138,
-0.0906593651,
0.0685651228,
-0.2134329826,
0.3251881003,
-0.9752047658,
-0.0473199114,
-0.1195932552,
-0.1160435602,
-0.1994096935,
-0.1294437349,
0.2580766082,
0.0705828592,
0.0893101543,
0.275632143,
-0.7201426029,
-0.4202160835,
-0.4046441615,
0.5933246017,
-0.207249105,
0.4678239524,
0.3520334661,
0.8209975958,
0.5489653945,
-0.3010864854,
-0.1174297407,
0.0571019612,
-0.4082484841,
0.5390987396,
-0.568567276,
0.3052217066,
-0.1286242604,
0.2717684805,
-1.3292541504,
0.1621303111,
-0.0797642246,
-0.4748298526,
0.391511023,
0.339712292,
-0.5869244337,
0.0067435321,
-0.2254620492,
0.4410130084,
0.6404732466,
-0.2806857526,
0.8240545988,
0.3382158577,
0.0498618186,
-0.7288409472,
-0.8033457398,
-0.0313138999,
-0.0594422854,
-0.5454201698,
0.3879708052,
0.1685608625,
-0.0938921273,
-0.0679606274,
0.0863481909,
0.3236825764,
-0.1242351979,
0.5862913132,
0.3580096066,
-0.3704197705,
0.021497963,
-0.1747702956,
0.0863470733,
0.4172013998,
-0.0944359004,
0.8668237925,
-0.024148142,
-0.4330098331,
-0.5250623226,
-0.1211680621,
0.593369782,
-0.2461426556,
1.0706167221,
0.3630844355,
-0.4402205944,
0.0433210805,
-0.6713053584,
-0.4196674824,
-0.4308228493,
0.4680161774,
-0.4075437486,
-0.9077333808,
0.4300394356,
0.139485836,
-0.0504246242,
0.1985941678,
0.8054925799,
-0.3799360096,
1.0727149248,
0.3550533354,
-0.2783399224,
0.4988919795,
0.1544179916,
0.1747108847,
-1.1371406317,
-0.219821617,
-0.3950307369,
-0.4847034216,
-0.2811749578,
-0.4821355045,
-0.057621751,
0.0326057635,
-0.366458267,
0.4368705451,
-0.3322716057,
0.5228486061,
0.0528107211,
0.0795640573,
0.2926134169,
0.2126549631,
-0.2744134665,
-0.3186062574,
-0.4654261768,
-0.729903996,
1.1166536808,
0.361055702,
0.8105129004,
-0.1671043336,
0.3895001113,
-0.0329542123,
0.4679152966,
-0.5648214221,
0.7229314446,
0.0071793944,
-0.3578219414,
-0.3471597433,
-0.1635996699,
-0.9413409233,
0.3202077746,
-0.6896104217,
-0.7068293691,
-0.1569694281,
-0.0997147858,
-0.1371612996,
0.1513166875,
-0.4353114069,
0.6023109555,
-0.1775171906,
-0.1211582646,
-0.7162214518,
-0.4026969671,
0.4080724716,
-0.2126285285,
0.2750292718,
0.0523117334,
-0.2001922727,
0.742685914,
0.1221935451,
0.9004734755,
0.1227916554,
-0.322983712,
0.0155484369,
0.0975702554,
0.2021480054,
-0.0764993727,
-0.0264482256,
0.4010893404,
0.1359383762,
-0.2468105853,
-0.8636243939,
1.0431214571,
-1.0267738104,
-0.6818660498,
-0.4793378711,
-0.5806146264,
-0.3465139866,
0.0226525478,
0.0671186894,
0.0801219046,
-0.2571587861,
0.0815354288,
0.7638342977,
-0.1161837056,
0.2587077916,
0.4747023284,
-0.3476626575,
-0.4865200222,
0.4713901877,
0.1337727457,
0.2427020073,
0.6518049836,
-0.2583494186,
-0.2998475134,
-0.6218819618,
-0.2521743476,
0.5114543438,
-0.6109072566,
-0.2071077377,
-0.5761622787,
-0.1332351565,
-0.369854182,
0.0214973781,
-0.2328125983,
-0.0561169051,
0.033344578,
0.0303445384,
0.1835064441,
0.573763907,
0.3843001425,
0.4451079667,
-0.5703676343,
0.1059367731,
0.216982767,
0.3037847877,
0.2875671387,
-0.558594048,
-0.2259182483,
0.3289863169,
-0.1382285506,
-0.7793086767,
0.0194170289,
-0.0613358021,
0.5231616497,
0.4216599166,
-0.3215167522,
0.6796190739,
-0.6464825273,
0.7361066937,
0.3183415532,
-0.8041703105,
0.0257376377,
-0.2757685483,
0.3180094957,
0.42529127,
0.490028739,
-0.4413684607,
-0.2897828817,
-0.2145578563,
-0.1987027824,
0.595118463,
0.071336247,
0.2527149022,
-0.1863737553,
0.5080116987,
-0.2226238847,
-0.1049393862,
-0.6517884135,
-0.0702710748,
0.1479564756,
-0.5410272479,
-0.0638716295,
-0.0505541489,
-0.1606167406,
-0.0642932802,
0.49218449,
-0.1212973744,
0.4285617173,
-0.0469460152,
-0.0896763951,
-0.2105029672,
-0.0084623806,
0.6372887492,
0.566172421,
-0.0365874022,
0.1045232415,
0.3460826576,
-0.4937574863,
0.0257753804,
-0.3862749934,
0.1965695769,
-0.3539855778,
0.6465104818,
0.5824598074,
0.303540498,
-0.8493841887,
0.6383351684,
-0.3160483539,
-0.1331040412,
-0.4190493524,
0.1608415544,
0.6154087186,
0.4682165384,
0.1908444315,
-0.0850653201,
-0.2823227644,
-0.4939058125,
-0.0924566686,
0.9452905059,
-0.1789553165,
-0.3374246061,
0.5231557488,
-0.3506485522,
-0.3899894059,
0.9402567148,
0.3685692847,
-0.4085557461,
0.4498510063,
0.7385930419,
0.6493409872,
-0.1700298041,
-0.3062704206,
0.483497709,
0.336868912,
-0.187169835,
0.1580165327,
0.1287623495,
-1.0983862877,
-0.7487185001,
-0.522064507,
-0.123797819,
0.1369908154,
-0.6021183729,
0.5109561086,
-0.5276166797,
-0.3382592499,
0.0549249463,
-0.0687903017,
-0.7596901655,
0.2946968675,
0.6089738607,
0.6716529131,
-0.8576555848,
1.2260463238,
0.8137099147,
-0.2764551938,
-0.8339362741,
0.0054358635,
-0.2001687288,
-0.9575933814,
0.6926038861,
0.1251857132,
-0.2564207613,
-0.2742786705,
-0.5910595059,
-1.0429745913,
1.1248826981,
0.6764520407,
-0.9438433647,
0.0475485027,
0.4057228863,
0.7916871905,
-0.5920656919,
0.5004659295,
0.4798873961,
0.2666290998,
-0.1932755411,
-0.8727273345,
0.4283821583,
0.0035490829,
0.1910965741,
0.2322773188,
-0.6194905639,
0.5449576378,
-0.0117197335,
-0.1541485488,
-0.0771990791,
0.8544229865,
0.6099389791,
-0.0786122009,
0.5191831589,
0.6503093839,
0.6617567539,
-0.0007655966,
0.7204990983,
-0.5178179741,
0.0978957564,
1.070322752,
-0.4740566015,
1.2309001684,
0.7726841569,
-0.1802871227,
0.6773657799,
0.4138150215,
0.0987531468,
0.3936040998,
0.2096022516,
0.2718601227,
-0.4040469527,
0.3406243622,
-0.2329326868,
0.2223811001,
0.4547855556,
-0.4761703014,
0.0832463577,
0.1653484106,
-0.0604541712,
0.51732862,
-0.112724036,
0.7362724543,
0.3355961442,
-0.7135617137,
0.6849238276,
-0.0039955215,
0.8491540551,
-0.6375011206,
0.1522905231,
0.0468215942,
0.0783992484,
-0.2597178519,
-0.8880307674,
0.3593186736,
-0.2535162568,
-0.35269171,
-0.2293705493,
0.4309255183,
-0.4042237699,
0.0472161509,
0.4917604625,
0.2588298321,
0.1468463987,
-0.1304921806,
-0.6054692864,
0.5080382824,
-0.1701951176,
-0.3192378581,
0.7516233325,
0.3716614842,
-0.3158583939,
0.5074875951,
0.5415256023,
0.0284398142,
0.0758210048,
0.0710834712,
0.6821169257,
-0.8307967186,
-0.1950140744,
-1.0761801004,
-0.054994531,
-0.0531317219,
-0.0999931768,
0.5955963135,
0.4483088553,
0.7584373951,
-0.2046195865,
0.3756511211,
0.1284420341,
0.0869216248,
-0.7324864864,
0.6009792089,
-0.1836328954,
0.25741449,
-0.1138309687,
-1.3977581263,
-0.2080242336,
0.8021381497,
-0.7290223241,
0.0331048854,
0.7854248881,
0.9910545945,
-0.105793789,
0.2750459909,
0.3569014668,
0.1945879012,
0.0905964151,
0.6652266383,
0.7948653102,
-0.4455248713,
0.2605535388,
0.153392002,
-0.0529668741,
0.1476500034,
-0.8729803562,
-1.1357135773,
-0.6920549273,
-0.2992589176,
-0.3146949112,
-0.0078856396,
1.1463114023,
0.6075950861,
-0.6755259037,
-0.4100239277,
0.1113055721,
-0.1983187497,
-0.3613956869,
-0.1697738767,
0.4707409739,
-0.4966337979,
-0.6987378597,
0.1528251618,
0.1207237095,
-0.2460926771,
-0.4988901913,
-0.0990550369,
-0.1016306654,
0.1464805752,
0.4634374678,
-0.1391402781,
-0.863630116,
-0.3907001913,
0.2099602371,
-0.6847681403,
0.0341572836,
0.8141301274,
-0.9553854465,
0.0747381449,
0.5326917768,
0.8496357799,
0.3781668544,
-0.1789013147,
0.6479836702,
-0.3839850128,
0.1089442819,
0.0182612799,
0.3852446377,
0.3791159987,
-0.3639243543,
0.1600355208,
-0.305459708,
-0.6436316371,
-0.6005716324,
-0.0213727374,
-1.2191751003,
-0.2703239918,
1.1454128027,
0.1666926146,
-0.5652920604,
0.2295863032,
-0.2695658207,
0.3219816983,
-0.1504021436,
0.703035593,
1.0387896299,
-0.1744724512,
-0.1930708885,
-0.4773693681,
0.3481360376,
0.6604167819,
-0.3090720475,
0.1630847454,
0.2552662194,
0.5548607707,
0.2191059738,
0.5001021028,
-0.3207492232,
-0.0574183799,
-0.2617914677,
0.2317268252,
0.1414966583,
0.1305821985,
-0.5725818872,
0.0238143168,
0.1519999355,
-0.0105968174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07921v1
|
Merino: Entropy-driven Design for Generative Language Models on IoT Devices
| 2024-02-28T03:20:27 | 2024-02-28T03:20:27 |
Youpeng Zhao, Ming Lin, Huadong Tang, Qiang Wu, Jun Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) stand as a revolutionary advancement
in the modern era of artificial intelligence (AI). However, directly deploying
LLMs in resource-constrained hardware, such as Internet-of-Things (IoT)
devices, is difficult due to their high computational cost. In this paper, we
propose a novel information-entropy framework for designing mobile-friendly
generative language models. Our key design paradigm is to maximize the entropy
of transformer decoders within the given computational budgets. The whole
design procedure involves solving a mathematical programming (MP) problem,
which can be done on the CPU within minutes, making it nearly zero-cost. We
evaluate our designed models, termed MeRino, across nine NLP downstream tasks,
showing their competitive performance against the state-of-the-art
autoregressive transformer models under the mobile setting. Notably, MeRino
achieves similar or better zero performance compared to the 350M parameter OPT
while being 4.9x faster on NVIDIA Jetson Nano with 5.5x reduction in model
size. Code will be made available soon.
|
[
-0.233273074,
-0.160395667,
0.3294396698,
0.3461572528,
-0.2955271006,
-0.2123582214,
-0.1713003218,
-0.5143129826,
0.1439037323,
0.4206670523,
-0.5159597993,
-0.4001274407,
-0.5345010757,
0.071487613,
-0.312305063,
0.6069276929,
0.1092474982,
-0.3579657078,
-0.2038068622,
0.2075551152,
-0.0934299752,
-0.1044589877,
-0.4370706081,
-0.2728275955,
0.3845286667,
0.3462472856,
0.5662310123,
0.6300545335,
0.6130778193,
0.2865628004,
-0.0162976254,
0.0890215263,
-0.1271600872,
0.37713328,
0.1505846083,
-0.6400305033,
-0.3215959966,
-0.2518928051,
0.0464024916,
0.0943623558,
-0.4321383238,
0.3112585545,
-0.08664947,
0.8217303157,
-0.8370460868,
0.1930919141,
-0.994148016,
0.0882465318,
-0.099149704,
-0.2284888923,
-0.5088148713,
-0.137589246,
-0.2030440122,
-0.4415791333,
0.1985622346,
-0.0103086522,
0.6020807028,
0.7668053508,
-0.1238595545,
-0.3438163698,
-1.0903900862,
0.6707065701,
-0.811334312,
0.6687859893,
0.5942624211,
-0.0491979085,
0.0944155455,
-0.4311850369,
-0.5591439605,
-0.357249409,
0.2795760334,
0.1857828796,
-0.5214858651,
-0.2793318331,
-0.0477516614,
0.3896142244,
-0.766579926,
0.2266524881,
-0.1883400828,
0.1222142652,
0.6345906854,
0.2554079592,
0.0121051343,
-0.0315249227,
-0.2973709404,
0.0401178151,
-0.8024743795,
-0.2868825495,
0.2080008537,
0.2281148136,
-0.3945307136,
0.3272060454,
-0.4032853544,
0.8998339772,
0.008985295,
-0.465777874,
0.053561341,
0.1151219383,
-0.282458812,
-0.0104562351,
1.0161221027,
0.2119638622,
-0.2239864767,
-0.4061754048,
-0.3340869844,
-0.2745476663,
0.4856978357,
-0.8111487031,
-0.1018351465,
0.3916860521,
-0.5409326553,
-0.5576133728,
-0.2603776455,
-0.7049313188,
-0.4571305811,
-0.0746665522,
0.1744730622,
-0.0722867772,
-0.1578881145,
0.1621973366,
-0.0439177603,
0.0792779624,
0.0506910421,
-1.2491402626,
-0.2402988523,
0.5071169734,
0.8987463117,
-0.0259057116,
-0.0295902472,
0.0699090809,
0.3548351526,
-0.0829001442,
0.5118028522,
-0.2357784361,
-0.5082113743,
-0.2576249242,
-0.4118255675,
-0.1671600193,
-0.5791866779,
0.8360040784,
-0.8212170005,
-0.0251762904,
0.4513387978,
-0.2288452536,
-0.0458674543,
0.1468662471,
-0.7731567025,
0.5460588932,
0.0412899554,
-0.8149216175,
-0.0525777973,
-0.8672354221,
-0.7211886048,
0.1746150851,
0.2210035324,
-0.4949163198,
0.3841643929,
-0.0656337291,
0.4994748533,
-1.0303000212,
0.3374049664,
-0.2332912385,
-0.0726110265,
0.2438502908,
-0.9357322454,
0.7656179667,
0.8735727072,
-0.5645756721,
0.064912267,
-1.0302910805,
0.1106639355,
0.0809296072,
-0.4954974353,
-0.2694374919,
0.2846102417,
0.0538448915,
0.1703240722,
0.314078033,
-0.6497011781,
-0.0120155197,
-0.1309816241,
0.7921419144,
0.6248643994,
-0.6396231651,
0.5128622055,
-0.1065660417,
0.4855757654,
-0.4509797692,
0.4135902524,
-0.0194403455,
-0.525467515,
-0.8000025153,
-0.4821095765,
0.1238313243,
0.8594770432,
-0.6702191234,
0.7248376608,
-0.4545018077,
-0.741697371,
-0.5248206258,
0.2200510949,
-0.0066321716,
0.3391535282,
0.1216992885,
0.3232083023,
-0.4811180532,
-0.807082057,
0.0473951474,
-0.2672636211,
-0.4920416474,
0.3778296411,
0.2682038248,
-0.6893391609,
0.940718472,
-0.5352215171,
-0.034114711,
-0.1652808934,
0.329320848,
0.2375775874,
0.5136576891,
0.2522592247,
-0.9006999731,
-0.2272156775,
0.4260783792,
-0.7573847771,
-0.2994167209,
-0.0723973364,
0.0555454269,
0.2454968393,
0.2911907136,
-0.9304639697,
0.5284009576,
0.863034606,
-0.0170234963,
0.36159271,
-0.1156619713,
-0.2476079017,
-1.3808289766,
0.1345146745,
-0.0383772925,
-0.0543443523,
-0.5384861231,
0.1177656427,
0.0256136525,
-0.4292657971,
-0.375777483,
0.4154497981,
-0.0613744855,
0.493652463,
-0.4948102534,
-0.6021027565,
-0.035205856,
0.4577997625,
0.1014155298,
0.8026261926,
0.5624458194,
-0.7573139071,
0.3949838877,
-0.4214078486,
-0.3098140061,
0.3579470813,
-0.8543596268,
-0.0505696982,
-0.1318101734,
0.0543240421,
-0.5108479261,
-0.2169022858,
0.034037035,
-0.3710298836,
0.030920092,
-0.0665205941,
-0.5894136429,
-0.5413597226,
-0.0988002717,
0.6419768333,
0.4850534499,
-0.6146426797,
0.8705046773,
0.4529268742,
0.0528851897,
-0.1327728331,
-0.5880118012,
0.2447937131,
-0.6194269657,
-0.6322067976,
0.6565072536,
-0.0578837879,
-0.1622497439,
-0.1105570868,
0.0055920845,
-0.1707499176,
0.2440945953,
0.3828405142,
0.0636578053,
-0.0647896007,
0.160631597,
-0.2491388619,
-0.3578184843,
-0.054902371,
-0.7979551554,
0.7562320828,
-0.2652016878,
-0.2392320782,
-0.9463102221,
0.4842544198,
0.9663596153,
-0.2450750321,
0.6868650913,
0.7316197157,
-0.3056710958,
-0.2111168206,
-0.502050221,
0.0787691921,
-0.5653797388,
0.1124405861,
-0.56799227,
-0.997646153,
0.5886086226,
-0.1466085762,
-0.1164214015,
0.5712772012,
0.807410121,
-0.3971873522,
0.7963137031,
0.9401366711,
-0.3777632117,
0.6184279919,
-0.2625660896,
0.601539135,
-0.7032622099,
-0.2645862103,
-0.5518952608,
-0.1600039452,
-0.8469013572,
-0.4414512217,
0.670781076,
0.064403221,
-0.3448794484,
0.416256696,
-0.5107194781,
0.3546456695,
0.9178236723,
0.1007293612,
0.1181324869,
0.1653701067,
0.2187311947,
0.4533325434,
-0.9943937659,
-0.3498567045,
0.9505855441,
0.2262764126,
1.2644838095,
0.3012383878,
0.5297199488,
0.2552526593,
0.3202920556,
-0.6988447905,
0.3099182546,
-0.2272120118,
-0.4587150812,
-0.2744688988,
-0.6721265316,
-0.864443779,
0.1272688657,
0.2064531744,
-0.6409063935,
0.2964362502,
0.0777481943,
-0.3231970966,
0.5477471352,
-0.6678062677,
0.6047823429,
-0.4196566641,
-0.2927771807,
-0.2205408514,
-0.4858720899,
0.3010641038,
-0.0306887627,
0.0881270766,
-0.0259024333,
0.1201297566,
0.5332359076,
-0.7776367068,
0.786218226,
0.2085841149,
-0.4208108485,
0.6193104982,
0.0695483536,
0.4916768372,
-0.0047571221,
-0.2499661297,
0.2236396819,
-0.4361959398,
-0.2140490115,
-0.5362017751,
0.6059086323,
-0.5494628549,
-0.4713487327,
0.0008430266,
-0.6887580752,
0.0110826548,
0.1017872989,
0.6933410168,
0.2461676449,
0.0775288269,
0.356133014,
0.7175958157,
-0.1388531178,
0.7822620869,
0.352393955,
0.3238747418,
-0.4603362679,
1.1220175028,
-0.3163190186,
0.1491958946,
0.7274335623,
0.2370377034,
-0.1182289273,
-0.199027732,
-0.6837881804,
-0.1678119749,
-0.1671424955,
-0.6602078676,
-0.5122753382,
-0.2747633457,
-0.3592405617,
-0.1872672439,
-0.7027343512,
-0.3014444113,
-0.4851126075,
0.1990938336,
0.6011086106,
0.4510524571,
-0.261367619,
0.5680229068,
-0.6991345882,
0.2972024679,
0.4850983918,
0.4949664474,
0.2790856063,
-0.4658853114,
-0.3939863741,
0.0488982759,
-0.4455710351,
-0.5667618513,
0.4600058198,
0.0239800587,
0.1831142604,
0.6985770464,
0.129545182,
0.512401104,
-0.4685997367,
0.3741790056,
0.4787176251,
-0.9131630063,
0.5716663599,
-0.3402764499,
0.4490365386,
0.2259310782,
0.1806592643,
-0.3818118572,
-0.1793417782,
-0.4190176427,
-0.8735026121,
0.3562909961,
0.2964518368,
0.3975881338,
0.1595270187,
0.0392109528,
-0.0522150993,
0.2497141212,
-0.684109807,
-0.109540619,
-0.1833441108,
-0.3358356953,
0.288800776,
-0.381246686,
0.036500182,
-0.3019521534,
0.5406332612,
0.1160378605,
0.5810796022,
0.0093831951,
-0.0368988775,
0.1622569263,
0.3329196274,
0.9863657951,
0.1892189384,
-0.1515240818,
0.3500317335,
-0.2104974538,
-0.4675274193,
0.1133958176,
-0.006256504,
-0.4219330847,
0.0412355922,
0.2700275481,
1.0517421961,
-0.2715112269,
-0.6186178327,
0.0917088836,
-0.0441678949,
0.1230984703,
-0.1029772684,
0.0543391556,
-0.0220972598,
0.3399868309,
0.4700558186,
0.1384826452,
0.1524494886,
-0.284171164,
0.0440369807,
0.5208743215,
-0.0622879937,
-0.3889650106,
0.934799552,
0.2897396982,
-0.5630070567,
0.5294346809,
-0.4781705737,
-0.6420342922,
0.5754984617,
0.8862442374,
1.2306313515,
-0.3304468989,
0.2577352822,
0.1837068498,
0.5533376336,
0.2163619101,
0.2381631732,
-0.5785740018,
-0.6674465537,
-0.0732006952,
-0.8401059508,
-0.0253152922,
0.0454907566,
-0.4520206153,
-0.0899857804,
-0.1929705292,
-0.3254210055,
-0.402880758,
-0.5862975121,
-0.5731212497,
0.3252652287,
0.3240731061,
0.5574634075,
-0.5894961357,
0.7595422864,
0.2457421124,
0.0413352735,
-0.5776863694,
-0.003688476,
-0.2837756276,
-0.7712278366,
0.7294425964,
-0.1625447124,
-0.5424553156,
0.039552696,
-0.4605769217,
-0.9795132279,
0.9819382429,
0.2815496027,
-0.4394954741,
0.2296869904,
0.4499755502,
0.4511249959,
-0.2833716571,
0.0735663772,
0.1564913839,
0.2640130818,
0.146581471,
-0.9966701865,
-0.3175856173,
-0.4822615385,
0.261325568,
0.0988023728,
-0.7142664194,
0.6285654306,
-0.4101420939,
-0.0954697877,
0.1298491359,
0.5656051636,
0.0975457653,
0.3158421218,
0.2533456683,
0.8914912343,
0.8500529528,
0.1868944168,
1.0934072733,
-0.7112606764,
0.3631090224,
0.8926135302,
-0.0874776393,
0.9274725914,
0.4136286378,
-0.1500793993,
0.2995078266,
0.4357550442,
0.2091929317,
0.9138676524,
0.2989779711,
-0.6807541251,
-0.0916278437,
-0.272692591,
-0.3153157234,
0.5813139677,
0.3083362281,
-0.3591068387,
-0.1134448126,
0.3257976472,
0.0472416133,
-0.4824614525,
-0.3701418042,
0.6507803202,
0.0746975243,
-0.2121949345,
0.925978601,
0.5323728919,
0.8168082833,
-0.1585453898,
0.4467681646,
-0.3312092125,
0.1106749177,
-0.2297065109,
-0.3179460466,
0.4416466951,
0.4210389256,
-0.6106772423,
-0.3660616875,
0.5822020769,
-0.1924237162,
-0.8634271026,
-0.1898156703,
0.058219675,
-0.0757044107,
-0.212000981,
-0.4443040192,
0.453430295,
-0.0245627835,
0.0140892807,
-0.1012014896,
0.458229512,
0.0552857779,
1.0593554974,
0.5969674587,
-0.2240530103,
0.3184945583,
-0.0454708077,
0.7216669321,
-0.513173759,
-0.4756726027,
-1.0595092773,
0.4675543606,
0.1749450117,
-0.2334828824,
0.540317893,
0.6714025736,
0.5828638077,
-0.2992950678,
0.7551273108,
-0.3299249113,
-0.0517393313,
-0.5614005327,
0.829613626,
-0.6037333012,
0.4254442453,
0.1206511706,
-0.7941551208,
-0.4607994258,
0.6271348596,
-0.0569459945,
-0.142582342,
0.3021743596,
0.7983843088,
-0.0520950183,
0.1649763584,
0.1802107394,
-0.037667606,
0.2429111302,
0.7882050872,
0.6239385605,
-0.5403758883,
0.2475386411,
-0.4077114761,
-0.1531454027,
-0.3764541745,
-0.828042388,
-0.5211476088,
-0.750408113,
-0.1468818188,
-0.0176907387,
-0.1104776412,
0.7252752781,
0.9767324924,
-0.5594249964,
-0.3892377019,
-0.4371542335,
0.436301887,
0.1066762507,
-0.163486734,
0.2585731745,
-0.1990449429,
-0.5317565203,
0.3825060725,
0.4790329635,
-0.059994407,
-0.0668987185,
-0.048989851,
0.2754642665,
-0.0035804755,
0.9790116549,
0.2719539702,
-0.6896237135,
0.2465402931,
0.0452714488,
-0.1473943293,
0.0836871862,
0.9318503737,
-0.6492731571,
0.3503426611,
0.5529851317,
0.7007184625,
0.3069139123,
-0.0389317051,
0.4118027687,
-0.285533607,
0.2769898474,
0.2766203582,
0.0073367325,
0.0867872462,
-0.3327375352,
0.3574001193,
0.2335963398,
-0.397538662,
-0.8294664025,
0.3098978698,
-0.7312790751,
-0.1236003488,
1.0652848482,
0.2623793483,
-0.2834575176,
0.3299418092,
0.348600775,
-0.044233337,
-0.1055696532,
1.1162847281,
0.3176748753,
-0.0922445133,
-0.2269198149,
-0.3936837316,
0.1812389493,
0.2838740051,
-0.8075562716,
0.1226496324,
0.0741901696,
-0.1385199726,
0.3049319088,
0.3456609845,
0.119429931,
0.0299778748,
-0.0263880901,
0.4029122889,
0.0962357298,
-0.5908754468,
-0.1912891567,
0.0940208957,
-0.1013660729,
-0.3261919916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18013v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in LLM-Based Multi-turn Dialogue Systems
| 2024-02-28T03:16:44 | 2024-02-28T03:16:44 |
Zihao Yi, Jiarui Ouyang, Yuwen Liu, Tianhao Liao, Zhe Xu, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This survey provides a comprehensive review of research on multi-turn
dialogue systems, with a particular focus on multi-turn dialogue systems based
on large language models (LLMs). This paper aims to (a) give a summary of
existing LLMs and approaches for adapting LLMs to downstream tasks; (b)
elaborate recent advances in multi-turn dialogue systems, covering both
LLM-based open-domain dialogue (ODD) and task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems,
along with datasets and evaluation metrics; (c) discuss some future emphasis
and recent research problems arising from the development of LLMs and the
increasing demands on multi-turn dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.5843197703,
-0.6840927601,
0.9442103505,
0.2831770778,
0.0836228356,
0.486218214,
-0.2761723995,
-0.4488782287,
0.3486835957,
0.9165165424,
-0.7547088265,
-0.2863417566,
-0.6133738756,
0.1453486979,
-0.3001208007,
0.6435005069,
0.1312837005,
0.5445137024,
0.0139611596,
-0.3309133649,
-0.3621649444,
-0.6529588103,
-0.6997417808,
-0.1650937945,
0.4341855347,
0.4169810414,
0.4553151429,
-0.4789832234,
0.3898727894,
0.412650615,
-0.0647882298,
0.3580821753,
-0.3359666765,
0.4618133605,
0.0027595232,
-0.392980963,
-0.7746790051,
-0.1868271083,
0.9196419716,
0.7149963975,
-0.1092300788,
-0.0960807502,
-0.008472926,
0.4173297882,
-0.5752689242,
0.1530026942,
-0.4622884095,
-0.1765208393,
-0.1675855964,
-0.1580215693,
-0.5672106743,
-0.3528039455,
0.3165007532,
-0.200075835,
-0.2184633762,
0.1501159221,
0.0446011126,
-0.1116971746,
-0.3410758674,
-0.5058997869,
-1.0611554384,
1.196133852,
-1.0875043869,
0.4055330455,
-0.1795876622,
0.4294996262,
-0.438252598,
-0.5037599802,
-0.4829955995,
-0.247262001,
0.2938237488,
0.1674841791,
-0.0170635432,
0.0779135227,
-0.0764001086,
0.4775824845,
-0.1700041443,
0.2858059108,
-0.0505365841,
0.0619553402,
0.5592192411,
0.6314193606,
0.117939733,
0.0789689198,
-0.24054721,
0.2074806839,
-0.8772011995,
-0.1423413604,
0.1554035693,
0.358774066,
-0.0475620404,
0.6542412043,
-0.391623795,
1.0144277811,
-0.0083077578,
-0.4180287421,
-0.1436508447,
-0.6708124876,
-0.3236747384,
-0.2093786448,
0.9375724792,
0.5905956626,
0.1203340366,
-0.004979725,
-0.1826911271,
-0.4115947187,
0.0703942329,
-0.3704919815,
0.1690827459,
0.2993713021,
-0.5286563039,
0.0065209223,
-0.2191051245,
-0.8484452963,
-0.579192102,
-0.4506678283,
0.1924321353,
-0.1251462698,
-0.4530986845,
0.1522040963,
-0.0854011327,
0.4247481823,
0.7935547233,
-0.5616852641,
0.401479125,
0.8058157563,
1.099598527,
-0.5197656751,
-0.2058041692,
-0.4828781188,
-0.0404606648,
-0.1340389699,
0.8763728738,
-0.5938519239,
-0.5269217491,
0.4609025717,
0.319400996,
-0.1525087059,
-0.5927065015,
0.3086607456,
-0.6003519893,
0.2176030874,
-0.0289830025,
-0.1864352971,
0.0145016909,
0.4267192185,
-0.4159414768,
0.6184472442,
-0.001458339,
-0.6119968295,
-0.0951891094,
-0.6708812714,
-0.3265297413,
-0.2933360338,
0.0411507562,
-0.1683452427,
0.2186855525,
0.1251343042,
0.459161967,
-0.6069628596,
0.3426244557,
-0.4821323156,
-0.1835079342,
0.5679909587,
-0.5190653801,
0.7860038877,
0.2899965346,
-0.0455989465,
0.4062390625,
-0.6649545431,
0.0105842184,
-0.1527065933,
-0.2963456511,
0.0089974627,
0.3469121456,
-0.0104735866,
0.261254251,
0.25848037,
-0.7382042408,
0.6106933951,
-0.0241902303,
0.4812076092,
0.5124160051,
-0.0513441116,
0.4837036729,
-0.3672281504,
0.5470074415,
-0.0355303735,
0.2578279674,
-0.3154237568,
-0.6431274414,
-1.1393932104,
-0.1077901423,
-0.0119008198,
0.6065606475,
-0.8970756531,
0.0835984051,
-0.1782170087,
-0.2918654382,
-0.2005544007,
-0.0685534477,
0.05376314,
-0.3124361336,
0.2401881516,
-0.5038044453,
-0.4155236185,
-0.7216262221,
-0.1482218504,
-0.2119852901,
-0.1650722474,
0.3249643445,
0.0010707095,
-0.2108417302,
0.7113441825,
-0.4941036701,
-0.0402334668,
-0.550552547,
0.0691135526,
0.1354366392,
0.0916834474,
0.2966158092,
-0.3106785417,
-0.4722880423,
-0.0005819029,
-0.3133484721,
-0.1017153859,
-0.0794459283,
0.0952563062,
0.2963234782,
0.4467814565,
-0.7728315592,
0.2683092356,
0.695753932,
-0.0266912617,
0.5514853597,
0.1149209812,
0.1621359289,
-0.9629221559,
-0.3299907148,
-0.0145075414,
-0.2729377449,
-0.8771458864,
-0.4117779434,
-0.2887948155,
0.1823823005,
-0.4394950271,
0.4777959585,
-0.6557583809,
-0.5537465215,
-0.4941470027,
0.1521892846,
-0.2760947943,
0.4809243679,
0.2875975668,
0.4836750627,
0.5343092084,
-0.7770263553,
0.6761897206,
0.1715471447,
-0.4143335521,
0.7559297681,
-0.1578537375,
0.1896687448,
0.2103744149,
0.484298557,
-1.0381379128,
-0.0795654878,
0.3573144376,
-0.2550987005,
0.2143059224,
-0.2961018085,
-0.2567151189,
-0.4720263183,
-0.3166491389,
0.3110209405,
0.290051043,
-0.3342320919,
0.7012038231,
0.4753232896,
-0.9673717022,
-0.3476902843,
-0.4217728972,
0.3218393624,
-0.1170328259,
-0.5329004526,
0.068252787,
-0.0726510882,
-0.5220307708,
-0.4592245519,
0.2006901503,
-0.1030640453,
-0.2975384593,
0.0262948032,
0.1417210847,
-0.2122586221,
-0.2272517085,
-0.1113298535,
0.1361066848,
0.204348594,
-0.5207984447,
0.6723022461,
-0.0093590254,
-0.6039125919,
-0.2431962341,
0.5793204308,
0.9045078754,
0.0095520765,
0.4151958525,
0.4008371234,
0.1032581627,
-0.1183152422,
-0.7885221839,
-0.1558927745,
-0.4457729757,
0.4301137328,
-0.1639403701,
-1.1038314104,
0.2781006992,
-0.4938848317,
0.4510262012,
0.3013986647,
1.0263515711,
-0.1563969254,
1.0950140953,
0.7675483823,
-0.0323411748,
0.6289181113,
0.0371601917,
0.4354398251,
-1.1594591141,
-0.324223429,
-0.7105643749,
-0.1232067123,
-0.6562927365,
-0.5972850919,
0.264852196,
-0.2021342665,
-0.1144748852,
0.1581940204,
-0.2263855636,
-0.2451372594,
0.5318134427,
-0.4458528757,
0.6946076155,
-0.2399047017,
-0.0200599339,
0.2910617888,
-0.8035569191,
-0.577471137,
1.0339536667,
0.4767019451,
1.0593760014,
0.3479704559,
0.2532755733,
0.1452173293,
0.5150563717,
-0.918002367,
0.5504157543,
-0.0034632024,
-0.5596755147,
-0.6493112445,
-0.2065042257,
-0.7355136871,
0.2382556498,
0.2053355128,
-0.8204023838,
0.0637287945,
-0.2135140747,
-0.186149165,
0.5807737708,
-0.4572675526,
0.1787887216,
-0.4803438187,
0.0027745287,
-0.1386586577,
-0.4770330191,
0.4476280212,
0.0795721561,
0.313751936,
-0.1255631,
0.259686321,
0.6978347898,
-0.481682539,
0.8696427345,
-0.4917457104,
-0.6045095325,
0.6327121854,
-0.2870274186,
0.478594929,
0.0676872581,
0.045950707,
-0.0384032577,
0.2013985217,
-0.1349973232,
-0.5073199272,
0.8314349055,
-0.4800436497,
-0.7286586761,
-0.4682364166,
-0.5787379742,
-0.8284800053,
-0.0083798999,
-0.0978851467,
0.3559482098,
-0.2551923692,
0.0269883312,
0.5522018075,
-0.3361440003,
0.6628111005,
0.6374312043,
-0.7035061121,
-0.5290593505,
0.6833739281,
0.0890493169,
0.6064651608,
0.3484947383,
-0.1940211058,
-0.4859585464,
-0.8833144307,
-0.5913358927,
0.1185835302,
-0.442356199,
-0.1906646937,
-0.5960422754,
-0.1905354261,
-0.4856427908,
0.1545497179,
-0.4394320548,
-0.539675355,
0.039149899,
0.2802886963,
0.3871500492,
1.3890333176,
0.252459228,
0.4189706147,
-0.8137819171,
0.3391572833,
0.3600057065,
0.5503839254,
0.1012372896,
-0.4552277625,
-0.2208677083,
0.1511241049,
-0.5120683908,
-0.5838857293,
0.2098193616,
-0.2290839106,
0.6290466189,
0.3201660812,
0.0768313184,
0.2771820128,
-0.5951267481,
1.1497392654,
0.4364896119,
-0.5989196897,
0.1173898205,
-0.4033063948,
0.5844790339,
0.192074582,
0.2265886515,
-0.7632811666,
-0.4072515368,
-0.155318141,
-0.4727559388,
0.8783382773,
-0.1632402539,
0.0803242475,
0.3021931946,
-0.0758735836,
0.0745354071,
0.2145638764,
-0.4169312418,
-0.2276583165,
0.0146352462,
-0.1561671197,
-0.1797752529,
-0.2416243255,
-0.0418230556,
0.0243579093,
0.5347570777,
-0.326870203,
0.6379110813,
0.0455228165,
-0.0387740284,
0.24051781,
0.7445976138,
0.8446376324,
0.5828373432,
-0.1776697785,
-0.1953512579,
0.3933060467,
-0.3414405882,
0.2949753702,
-0.1267002821,
-0.0522403382,
0.1408818662,
0.0898442864,
0.9127109647,
0.2135946155,
-0.507828474,
0.3184646666,
-0.0727834404,
-0.1101636887,
-0.3105840683,
-0.1531371772,
0.2577316761,
0.3821071684,
0.4527157843,
-0.0664023608,
0.0791725442,
-0.7280091643,
-0.4401798844,
0.7423906922,
-0.5660691261,
-0.3678120673,
-0.0390405133,
0.5060606003,
-0.4523961842,
0.3364995718,
0.1181216389,
-0.4186584651,
0.1766016036,
0.3245291412,
1.0426599979,
-0.2809448242,
0.0551443659,
0.0033587045,
0.0619845465,
0.0124209756,
0.3788174689,
-0.1223768592,
-0.6071152687,
-0.7807846069,
-0.6250936985,
-0.9859830141,
0.3747662604,
-0.4542118013,
0.2049250603,
-0.3629130125,
-0.509978652,
-0.1694098264,
-0.2435670644,
-0.425994575,
-0.0153939659,
0.1868903041,
0.7645914555,
-0.350389123,
0.6849730015,
0.7531084418,
0.2600838244,
-0.0902519003,
-0.0627827123,
0.0093690092,
-0.5439356565,
0.3295056224,
-0.3641110361,
-0.673556149,
-0.2434360534,
-0.3968734741,
-0.8645935059,
0.8900905252,
-0.1554492861,
-0.8582351804,
-0.2586780488,
0.5127410889,
0.3884883821,
-0.5393454432,
0.470672816,
0.6903249621,
0.609390378,
-0.0292794164,
-1.2684211731,
-0.4453527033,
0.0431216955,
0.0365972146,
0.2953542471,
-1.048414588,
0.6285789013,
0.0388697535,
0.0761981681,
0.6140603423,
0.4195511639,
0.303366065,
0.4510812163,
0.4154190123,
0.1881483942,
0.228872776,
-0.3434903026,
0.8756551147,
-0.0672169253,
0.2585760951,
1.2024825811,
-0.5524154305,
0.8086352348,
0.6270587444,
-0.5447748303,
0.4463936687,
0.2594186962,
0.2767055631,
0.3567986488,
0.3927913904,
-0.4442476332,
-0.245510906,
-0.1763088107,
-0.2647299469,
0.3314980268,
0.7905879617,
-0.0645780414,
-0.1909382194,
0.0783509836,
-0.3001056015,
-0.4592606425,
-0.365100503,
1.1544446945,
0.2945145965,
-0.9671452045,
0.2981414497,
0.1688985527,
0.9774470329,
-0.6507216096,
0.1183815226,
-0.0161023382,
0.0821956843,
-0.12406151,
-0.8838085532,
0.1401972324,
0.1163633242,
-0.1436792463,
-0.3107509613,
0.7576877475,
-0.3571887314,
-0.3916085958,
0.3070245087,
0.8051105738,
0.0235795826,
0.0002928259,
-0.4990883768,
0.5034348369,
0.1216911748,
-0.1608131528,
0.2464922071,
0.438046664,
-0.1737608463,
0.7438153028,
0.3476657867,
0.0974003375,
0.422922045,
0.3554179668,
0.7837173343,
-0.9872556925,
-0.0788570046,
-0.3125396669,
0.4311368465,
-0.0452348925,
-0.0953624249,
0.7363473773,
0.3389700949,
0.6693453789,
-0.0954717547,
1.1777728796,
0.0815840513,
0.9628663063,
-0.6908164024,
0.3649119139,
-0.2675014734,
0.208497569,
-0.407558918,
-1.1625907421,
0.1080179065,
0.1471193433,
-0.4271402955,
0.2620403767,
0.5842726827,
0.6422352791,
0.0760244206,
0.302872479,
0.2835015655,
0.252045691,
0.5086151958,
0.4712242186,
1.6190311909,
-0.1284157932,
0.3936325014,
0.1616837531,
-0.0984316468,
-0.5700617433,
-0.7122529149,
-0.6692183614,
-0.5927746296,
-0.340608567,
-0.0203844775,
-0.0961073413,
0.4444566965,
0.7158358693,
-1.0668281317,
-0.5615891814,
0.1296698898,
0.0524896793,
0.1147576123,
-0.1608507484,
-0.1345227808,
-0.3802278638,
-1.1813485622,
0.6164269447,
0.7127559781,
0.0144361947,
-0.6228830218,
-0.3681225181,
-0.3232960701,
0.2046697885,
0.9476521015,
0.2482235581,
-1.0633212328,
-0.1411471069,
0.145537734,
0.0566499308,
0.1826863587,
1.204123497,
-0.4249756038,
0.2810664177,
0.465084672,
0.4241945446,
0.6613025665,
-0.1685988754,
0.8314636946,
-0.2215186357,
-0.1210692078,
0.3415672183,
0.3646480143,
0.5040135384,
0.1601839662,
0.1354925036,
-0.1087973714,
-0.5452535748,
-0.5937696695,
0.4466743469,
-1.0599629879,
-0.1495244354,
1.0857162476,
-0.0737077966,
0.2127641588,
-0.6056061983,
-0.3998869658,
0.1125501469,
-0.2450046986,
0.1822208613,
1.1167654991,
-0.59490484,
-0.205762893,
-0.4059576988,
0.4070119858,
0.3550976813,
-0.8236380816,
0.0735694394,
0.6004141569,
0.0984218046,
0.3525437415,
0.6899968386,
-0.3780066371,
-0.0982093811,
-0.460267514,
-0.2128068954,
0.4575655162,
-0.502084136,
-0.3229396343,
0.0216476563,
0.4773319066,
0.1822652519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18005v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18005v2
|
A Sentiment Consolidation Framework for Meta-Review Generation
| 2024-02-28T02:40:09 | 2024-06-04T16:10:13 |
Miao Li, Jey Han Lau, Eduard Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Modern natural language generation systems with Large Language Models (LLMs)
exhibit the capability to generate a plausible summary of multiple documents;
however, it is uncertain if they truly possess the capability of information
consolidation to generate summaries, especially on documents with opinionated
information. We focus on meta-review generation, a form of sentiment
summarisation for the scientific domain. To make scientific sentiment
summarization more grounded, we hypothesize that human meta-reviewers follow a
three-layer framework of sentiment consolidation to write meta-reviews. Based
on the framework, we propose novel prompting methods for LLMs to generate
meta-reviews and evaluation metrics to assess the quality of generated
meta-reviews. Our framework is validated empirically as we find that prompting
LLMs based on the framework -- compared with prompting them with simple
instructions -- generates better meta-reviews.
|
[
-0.7839891315,
-0.2541745901,
0.5843569636,
0.3637797534,
-0.4444240928,
0.0411950536,
-0.1258058697,
-0.0199583061,
0.5264076591,
0.4329592586,
-0.6723666191,
-0.6758707762,
-0.3719751537,
0.7374222279,
-0.2777400613,
1.3394440413,
0.163806349,
0.1969691366,
-0.5400172472,
0.1491166353,
-0.0503135659,
-0.1191705614,
-0.2570248842,
-0.549955368,
0.7569810748,
0.3832710087,
0.4101304412,
0.0344062448,
0.609692812,
0.1964635104,
-0.1820124388,
0.6304194927,
-0.3134937882,
0.2551599443,
-0.1162384301,
-0.1847194582,
-0.8014339805,
0.0732933432,
0.5298386216,
0.7768093944,
-0.1209090203,
0.4012692273,
0.4621833563,
0.8099027872,
-0.5800092816,
-0.0008386779,
-0.1962137073,
0.2830168605,
0.3699686229,
-0.4549261928,
-0.3884905875,
-0.7248672843,
0.0435963906,
-0.2712038457,
0.483073324,
-0.1005103216,
0.3863250911,
0.1202809587,
-0.4255001843,
-0.3109666407,
-0.5705369115,
0.6479626298,
-0.8811151981,
-0.1937164217,
-0.0187712889,
0.0407592095,
0.0208242629,
-0.4900033772,
-0.7595746517,
-0.0104323979,
-0.3003414571,
0.5041239858,
0.1014120802,
0.1052542552,
-0.0121052675,
0.4160730839,
-0.3228042424,
-0.3990923166,
-0.5416082144,
0.014651862,
0.5292237401,
0.2460000515,
-0.0635091215,
-0.6017467976,
-0.2388513386,
-0.221157968,
-0.8998296261,
-0.0869463682,
0.2441878617,
0.2526013255,
0.2187187076,
0.696741879,
-0.1910799295,
0.6008611917,
0.2394750863,
-0.2479918003,
0.2942500114,
-0.5195184946,
-0.4290314913,
0.0943588093,
1.0916947126,
1.0873705149,
-0.079550989,
0.1862378865,
-0.2396499813,
0.1924461573,
0.3738526702,
-0.8584679365,
0.143714726,
0.4701067209,
-0.6537830234,
-1.0501397848,
0.3301699758,
-0.9002614021,
-0.2988361716,
-0.2243790329,
0.1444731802,
-0.0340746939,
-0.4242456853,
0.285145849,
-0.3368427455,
0.1297442615,
0.1344823986,
-0.7233583331,
0.1714161187,
0.6151519418,
0.7157828212,
-0.0247869957,
-0.25711146,
-0.2520933747,
0.2528381348,
-0.4112131596,
0.914303422,
-0.2604816854,
-0.9329295754,
0.071370177,
-0.2581005394,
0.3049708307,
-0.4235831797,
0.3837862611,
-0.25637725,
0.7953732014,
-0.5789980888,
-0.064761281,
-0.328060776,
0.6273413301,
-0.6092720032,
1.0486437082,
0.0922051817,
-0.9073289633,
0.5663380027,
-0.7731620073,
-0.4807318747,
0.0285417214,
0.1184796393,
-0.3463501632,
0.484713465,
0.4613320231,
0.7345361114,
-0.408611387,
0.5762324333,
-0.275439322,
-0.0082451887,
0.120529294,
-0.0804889724,
0.2996233106,
0.3642705083,
-0.3944315016,
-0.0839695781,
-0.3653506935,
0.0531228967,
-0.3474515975,
-0.3988748491,
-0.0986957848,
-0.0681877136,
-0.2498127967,
0.2496520579,
0.0050660092,
-0.3817633092,
0.3674841821,
-0.3964622915,
0.4994908869,
0.3700993359,
0.5662114024,
0.6562511921,
-0.434062928,
0.6460626721,
0.1528268903,
0.0882076696,
-0.5115320683,
-0.2794770002,
-0.5366309881,
0.0043475502,
0.3282664418,
0.2173781097,
-0.4815825522,
0.6677143574,
-0.4757657647,
-0.3647095561,
-0.5152733922,
0.3343530297,
0.3541939557,
0.6246951222,
0.3381879926,
-0.0566373132,
-0.5243518353,
-0.7308417559,
-0.2347733676,
-0.380492121,
-0.1010745615,
0.2152036726,
0.4628772736,
-0.643196702,
1.0407418013,
-0.2275781035,
-0.1353467852,
-0.29339692,
0.544555068,
0.1942722201,
0.1124649346,
0.2181984335,
-0.487575084,
-0.3647977114,
-0.1384486705,
-0.9300849438,
-0.299300611,
0.0915305987,
0.0512318239,
0.0792729855,
0.5092689991,
-0.8170769811,
-0.0941098183,
0.5250489116,
-0.0187359769,
0.5247119069,
0.0735574961,
0.460018158,
-1.3757692575,
0.3481791914,
-0.297799021,
-0.1696045995,
-0.3587785363,
-0.0721279904,
-0.1174336001,
-0.151824668,
-0.2899471521,
0.3032130897,
-0.5151354074,
0.0522081815,
-0.3800091147,
0.3134913445,
0.4164820015,
0.0127474302,
-0.0131005971,
0.289629817,
0.439943552,
-0.8091973662,
0.1918758005,
0.1469498426,
-0.1155086905,
0.6140092015,
-0.6968599558,
-0.3333157003,
-0.4691358805,
0.6969488263,
-0.9975092411,
-0.6511513591,
0.0226329379,
-0.4675096571,
0.1322983801,
0.275192678,
-0.3541680276,
-0.7062743306,
-0.7258893251,
0.0610843226,
0.5113558769,
-0.5255112648,
0.8377857804,
-0.0497850515,
-0.5281552076,
-0.7475556135,
-0.6653843522,
0.2574718297,
-0.2085047811,
-0.6665434241,
0.3648800254,
0.004832251,
-0.3809905052,
0.2972157001,
0.1058808118,
0.7157425284,
-0.2360980064,
0.1919933856,
0.0890388563,
-0.1726577878,
0.0731306002,
0.3883074522,
0.034602806,
0.358425945,
-0.3797349036,
0.3228096366,
-0.139541775,
-0.112453796,
-0.1388026774,
0.5303251743,
0.8547020555,
0.0303532798,
0.3199716806,
0.5054835081,
-0.1323432922,
-0.3562054634,
-0.5976755023,
-0.5128137469,
-0.3914764822,
-0.1034847647,
0.0228169169,
-0.7834812999,
0.2445638776,
-0.2351135761,
0.3196842372,
0.6278889179,
0.717965126,
-0.4570458233,
1.2826057673,
0.4134979546,
-0.1003661677,
0.0090703191,
-0.4000816345,
0.1286775768,
-0.8438980579,
-0.3404060304,
-0.3341626525,
-0.4121523201,
-0.2855956852,
-0.3460257649,
0.5737586021,
0.1518053561,
0.226489976,
-0.169481039,
-0.6917946935,
0.5997336507,
0.3341244757,
0.0128509505,
0.0718650892,
0.058483582,
-0.2448865175,
0.3289895058,
-0.6554883718,
-0.8393067718,
0.9079621434,
0.0685618669,
0.5046455264,
-0.109106265,
1.1643071175,
0.3575718701,
0.6368205547,
-0.6089839339,
0.6169873476,
0.1425277442,
-0.370113492,
-0.0519016944,
-0.5109681487,
-0.5818816423,
0.2133823931,
-0.4032130837,
0.2653056681,
0.0548916161,
0.2790834904,
-0.6328750849,
0.0107054459,
-0.4195839167,
0.3211063743,
0.0409437902,
-0.2848221958,
-0.2929523289,
-0.6586892009,
0.8649184108,
0.0948462188,
0.3926712871,
0.2159676999,
0.004320289,
0.4605270922,
-0.4878643453,
1.0833574533,
-0.3879885077,
-0.2136009634,
0.5512136221,
0.3589020669,
0.3105728328,
0.3259916306,
0.0232489742,
-0.346090883,
-0.2914704978,
-0.0959575921,
-0.6495908499,
0.619582653,
-0.4477953911,
-0.4906945229,
-0.2065738142,
-0.0988718197,
-0.1886792481,
0.1444523931,
0.6842700243,
0.2705698311,
-0.2734264731,
0.2375697345,
0.7554314137,
-0.0169181451,
0.3571635187,
0.2081772983,
-0.4495246708,
-0.9552239776,
0.6617517471,
-0.2695909142,
0.1159918755,
0.1572394073,
0.4132243693,
-0.2153167725,
-0.1723511815,
-0.2913421094,
0.2748984098,
-0.6388891339,
-0.648676157,
-0.7468342781,
0.0364007652,
-0.6018789411,
-0.3130978942,
0.0793141276,
-0.3883966208,
-0.3716719747,
-0.464684993,
0.0747314394,
1.2156103849,
-0.1678659916,
0.3663902283,
-1.120986104,
0.2499620169,
0.5462754965,
0.0425133631,
-0.0202112105,
-0.1229857579,
-0.0607779324,
-0.0608649813,
-0.4896520674,
-0.8784251809,
0.4195671976,
0.2928161025,
0.2610321343,
0.6168822646,
-0.1962983161,
0.3901152909,
-0.3724027872,
1.3831511736,
0.5046018362,
-0.9186138511,
0.6547971368,
-0.5641753674,
0.3897446096,
0.6953685284,
0.3552058637,
-0.3569856286,
-0.6072122455,
-0.7637302876,
-0.7773426175,
0.3268432617,
-0.194969058,
0.1572660357,
-0.2596694529,
0.4234924316,
0.1544978023,
0.4817516506,
-0.8111587167,
0.2953431904,
-0.5509960055,
-0.303114742,
-0.1934189945,
-0.4831196666,
-0.5423273444,
0.2755832374,
0.615277648,
-0.388435334,
0.1782921106,
0.2973159552,
-0.0379205309,
-0.3975346386,
0.3470039666,
0.8646390438,
0.193144843,
-0.0975650698,
0.3035943806,
0.1345676035,
-0.1469745189,
0.0674650893,
-0.5632460713,
-0.2966690063,
0.0800223425,
0.4316516519,
0.3993346095,
0.2220803946,
-0.1295142174,
0.5962443948,
-0.0689597875,
-0.9004835486,
0.1788124293,
0.0514832847,
0.1951743215,
-0.0446300246,
0.3349428773,
0.235600397,
0.3286416829,
-0.39575243,
-0.0056054313,
0.6226580739,
-0.0515774302,
-0.50368011,
0.3411117792,
0.6131793261,
-0.0265639406,
0.2473440021,
-0.1921512336,
-0.7218301892,
0.2496452779,
0.3338718414,
1.0798498392,
-0.0755054578,
0.5665498376,
0.7004752755,
0.2593571544,
-0.4483089745,
0.4608068764,
-0.397867173,
-0.4053904414,
-0.6113604307,
-0.8021767139,
-0.6583312154,
-0.2736749947,
-0.7198275328,
0.4035685956,
-0.3174815178,
-0.563390553,
-0.321392715,
-0.2097726911,
-0.2836458087,
0.2654710412,
0.2010492384,
0.8071268201,
-0.9417639971,
0.0596299283,
0.569239676,
-0.350215584,
-0.6833010912,
-0.094802998,
-0.0763947815,
-0.1843799651,
0.6033952832,
0.2819693089,
-0.5906335711,
-0.1781449765,
-0.6883064508,
-0.4606178403,
1.2686979771,
0.0538875498,
-0.3162063062,
-0.1334159076,
0.0352651961,
0.7646795511,
-0.6526542902,
0.1812923551,
0.3443682194,
0.7337929606,
0.0430160277,
-0.3612519503,
-0.0174474847,
-0.4115325511,
-0.2124370784,
0.0138166165,
-0.5898003578,
0.6770421863,
-0.3165415525,
-0.1837015748,
-0.2382063419,
0.5181900859,
0.4301730096,
0.3421834707,
0.4516474903,
0.4530418217,
0.7448126674,
-0.0830734819,
0.9370446801,
-0.6287361979,
0.138410911,
0.7451494336,
-0.3516086936,
0.6933441758,
0.6391912699,
0.119704999,
0.9103375673,
0.5174244642,
-0.0768077224,
0.3758815229,
-0.0182096679,
-0.3333474398,
-0.1512109488,
0.0492164008,
-0.4556189179,
0.0594411902,
0.3678756058,
-0.6361330748,
-0.1305869222,
-0.0543506108,
-0.138808161,
-0.0752697513,
-0.4148820043,
1.1307010651,
0.182284534,
-1.2867697477,
0.364199698,
-0.0861094892,
0.5821714401,
-0.568107307,
0.1558595449,
-0.3276535869,
-0.2354048043,
-0.7207037807,
-0.7718582749,
0.1728553772,
0.2191321999,
-0.5609103441,
-0.6448364258,
0.4063116908,
-0.4556229711,
-0.4429481626,
0.0712699965,
0.4595690072,
-0.018642325,
0.3765664995,
-0.2886495292,
-0.2602050006,
-0.0818147659,
-0.4670727551,
0.1206337214,
0.449668318,
0.142521739,
0.3203370571,
0.8457071185,
0.3536267281,
-0.172282517,
0.3051066995,
0.7913230062,
-0.6298915744,
-0.4719386101,
-0.9498932362,
0.7031925321,
-0.1092157736,
-0.0861881152,
0.7551186681,
0.4792766273,
0.1823315322,
-0.3039210141,
1.1280795336,
0.0282321945,
0.4784450233,
-0.5061540604,
0.6644220352,
-0.5909222364,
0.1802477092,
-0.3649540246,
-1.1525087357,
-0.5613629222,
0.2912793159,
0.0600938499,
0.1369036138,
0.7508295178,
0.8182076812,
0.1129894331,
0.0846955925,
0.0244867075,
-0.0584377423,
0.2760743797,
0.1634099185,
0.9578659534,
-0.0873715356,
0.4914464653,
0.2194777131,
-0.162131086,
-0.4253576696,
-1.3673341274,
-0.8675493002,
-0.2593961954,
-0.0057612355,
-0.6024683118,
-0.4801575541,
0.8864431381,
0.4814644158,
-0.6807542443,
-0.0408771858,
-0.3430640101,
-0.0876135901,
-0.1015772596,
-0.2452069521,
0.028434433,
-0.712952137,
-0.5486499071,
0.3979808688,
0.3638531566,
0.0780111849,
-0.7734797001,
-0.2324358821,
0.5445433855,
0.2916180491,
0.6983143687,
-0.0386293083,
-0.6562084556,
0.1353035271,
0.223916173,
-0.2061936408,
-0.2125476748,
1.2281184196,
-0.7253992558,
0.3657300472,
0.7858855724,
0.1937125772,
0.1867745221,
0.3222230375,
0.8263739944,
-0.7949955463,
-0.4883538485,
0.3418199122,
0.2907165587,
0.5359472632,
-0.2142864764,
0.382466346,
0.0309932288,
-0.5048188567,
-1.1291834116,
0.1299794614,
-0.7924200892,
0.0426686779,
1.2508032322,
0.2964243889,
-0.2520931661,
0.3826173842,
-0.2728973925,
-0.0823341459,
-0.2674234807,
0.8160873652,
0.6838434339,
-0.1430396289,
0.144848913,
0.1033462957,
0.6821380854,
0.3659585118,
-0.8814055324,
0.3804553449,
0.5456312299,
0.2482162565,
0.5891979933,
0.5364913344,
-0.35461393,
0.5323764086,
-0.2353135943,
0.2360981703,
-0.1326945275,
-0.4755983949,
-0.5709120035,
0.4242402017,
-0.1020762548,
0.6219486594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17985v1
|
FlattenQuant: Breaking Through the Inference Compute-bound for Large Language Models with Per-tensor Quantization
| 2024-02-28T02:00:34 | 2024-02-28T02:00:34 |
Yi Zhang, Fei Yang, Shuang Peng, Fangyu Wang, Aimin Pan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance
across various tasks. However, the latency of inference and the large GPU
memory consumption of LLMs restrict their deployment performance. Recently,
there have been some efficient attempts to quantize LLMs, yet inference with
large batch size or long sequence still has the issue of being compute-bound.
Fine-grained quantization methods have showcased their proficiency in achieving
low-bit quantization for LLMs, while requiring FP16 data type for linear layer
computations, which is time-consuming when dealing with large batch size or
long sequence. In this paper, we introduce a method called FlattenQuant, which
significantly reduces the maximum value of the tensor by flattening the large
channels in the tensor, to achieve low bit per-tensor quantization with minimal
accuracy loss. Our experiments show that FlattenQuant can directly use 4 bits
to achieve 48.29% of the linear layer calculation in LLMs, with the remaining
layers using 8 bits. The 4-bit matrix multiplication introduced in the
FlattenQuant method can effectively address the compute-bound caused by large
matrix calculation. Our work achieves up to 2$\times$ speedup and 2.3$\times$
memory reduction for LLMs with negligible loss in accuracy.
|
[
-0.3863967657,
-0.8998445272,
0.6989634633,
0.2038338184,
-0.27026546,
0.146529749,
-0.6058533192,
-0.0926955938,
-0.0499932617,
0.5748308301,
-0.3876360655,
-0.640905261,
-0.3392948806,
-0.3086011112,
-0.3179291785,
0.7048565745,
-0.0120514249,
-0.098771818,
-0.2031558156,
0.1630686671,
-0.0024520773,
-0.6013967395,
-0.5939098597,
-0.4038820267,
0.2863815129,
0.4691832364,
0.779080689,
0.678925097,
0.4375930727,
0.3395412862,
-0.2448675185,
-0.0516787246,
-0.5693449378,
0.0831231996,
0.1945181936,
-0.8151304126,
-0.6309751868,
-0.1481390446,
0.8668502569,
0.7805474401,
-0.3275580406,
0.2287991494,
-0.0877726078,
0.5851076841,
-0.9636609554,
0.0367640071,
-0.4372642636,
0.3792367578,
-0.3419493735,
-0.1006674021,
-0.341664046,
-0.1801204085,
-0.2772093117,
-0.4953051507,
0.4419522285,
-0.3120511174,
0.706582427,
0.4147469401,
-0.1157268137,
0.423499018,
-0.7654153109,
0.9872157574,
-0.9901143312,
0.4904279113,
0.2978921533,
0.0723755658,
-0.1017363891,
-0.8503098488,
-0.5056414008,
0.0048278952,
0.1917269081,
-0.2155849487,
-0.230225116,
0.428668797,
0.3903779685,
0.7510928512,
-0.4144126773,
0.1030094475,
-0.2132259309,
-0.1628321856,
0.439702034,
0.0579069071,
-0.1068283543,
-0.172282517,
-0.3483972847,
-0.0209486187,
-0.8072308898,
-0.1002726257,
0.180679664,
0.0726955235,
-0.0665878206,
0.5325750113,
-0.2440609038,
0.4077374935,
0.0064432789,
-0.1999146938,
0.0289068054,
0.0741815642,
-0.6268650293,
0.0655640289,
0.8718785048,
0.0435254574,
0.2296958715,
-0.1834406108,
-0.3857917786,
0.0723909512,
0.0455444902,
-1.1811304092,
-0.3262597919,
0.3646582663,
-0.2094404101,
-0.0147370053,
-0.326954931,
-0.5593947768,
-0.3161736429,
-0.2151529789,
0.3170093894,
-0.4799830019,
0.0611008182,
0.2003879547,
0.2805780172,
0.0438925028,
0.4080779552,
-0.7502833605,
0.4253895879,
0.8995050788,
0.9080307484,
0.0070821457,
-0.049851831,
-0.6400797367,
0.1337051392,
-0.2175254375,
0.5034908056,
-0.2504029572,
-0.0838250294,
-0.1841456592,
-0.3908931613,
0.2815976441,
-0.4038990736,
0.5042281747,
-0.5782699585,
-0.0776299462,
0.1426541209,
-0.5515883565,
-0.0806552693,
0.2438494861,
-0.6959037185,
0.702893734,
-0.1997656822,
-0.5395599008,
-0.0930948257,
-0.450424999,
-0.4348294437,
0.1677114069,
-0.1391661167,
-0.5561420918,
0.3602962196,
0.4165320992,
0.7082782984,
-0.5038682222,
0.0766263083,
-0.5616260171,
-0.611476779,
0.1272945404,
-0.7967614532,
0.7007887959,
0.3722366989,
-0.3880899251,
-0.0846303329,
-0.6531486511,
0.2437849045,
0.0166427158,
-0.4339245856,
-0.348310709,
-0.2820447683,
0.1548131406,
-0.1802562177,
0.2041654438,
-0.6270416379,
0.3400381207,
-0.1901282668,
0.673489809,
0.8393142223,
-0.4710091054,
0.451068759,
0.060288813,
0.6682632565,
-0.1722904295,
0.2410625517,
0.0204642881,
-0.1364864707,
-0.7981684208,
-0.7751737833,
0.5339254141,
0.3362635672,
-0.6715183258,
0.1924230456,
-0.439593643,
-0.3885468841,
-0.5612891316,
0.0463699289,
0.6022210121,
0.1006070226,
0.4533213973,
-0.2408723086,
-0.3749091923,
-0.7253531218,
-0.1393592507,
0.1470118612,
-0.330558151,
-0.1061677188,
0.1930535436,
-0.1389572471,
0.5753487349,
-0.7627137899,
-0.2047789544,
0.1570573747,
0.0835804194,
0.2204292715,
0.6159982085,
0.0531558618,
-0.6585512757,
-0.1177682951,
-0.1908235699,
-0.4568442404,
-0.0248769503,
0.1216830015,
0.0665198565,
0.4655845463,
0.5451610088,
-0.7659771442,
0.6009287238,
0.9408456683,
-0.3450886607,
0.3499246836,
-0.2279095799,
0.0389344469,
-0.8780776858,
-0.0367516875,
0.0692724362,
-0.6050348878,
-0.4480679631,
0.0834118202,
0.1719032377,
0.0487971455,
-0.3224119246,
0.3374452889,
-0.5232521296,
-0.1541445851,
0.1321100891,
-0.1022181436,
0.332596302,
0.4015237689,
-0.0955067351,
0.7378997207,
0.2013195902,
-0.4384489954,
0.351973176,
0.1171645895,
-0.4237786829,
0.5401442647,
-0.5057805777,
0.2257133871,
0.1253617555,
0.5022845268,
-0.8364970088,
0.1355290264,
-0.2761556506,
-0.1588169187,
0.4203065038,
-0.3294292986,
-0.5227895379,
0.0476126038,
-0.4857117832,
0.7133207321,
0.4610898793,
-0.6391179562,
0.6449745893,
0.2028810829,
-0.0697390139,
-0.7880483866,
-1.1398830414,
0.1924283057,
-0.1988018155,
-0.7329218984,
0.6606117487,
-0.1131042242,
-0.1246943548,
-0.0606221184,
-0.2579575479,
-0.0702501461,
-0.027338421,
0.1722794771,
0.1770426631,
-0.4612423182,
-0.1029770598,
0.0765933841,
-0.021398548,
0.0426528379,
-0.3653678596,
0.8107708097,
-0.6119693518,
-0.2792811692,
-0.4403502047,
0.2785750329,
0.5244796872,
-0.2380815744,
0.6721581221,
0.704230845,
-0.2812700868,
-0.3431300819,
-0.842738688,
-0.1759060323,
-0.4604617953,
0.3717398047,
-0.7529289722,
-1.2163968086,
0.5408648252,
-0.0002946965,
-0.2265668809,
0.1811498106,
0.5755776167,
0.1252314746,
0.8023295403,
0.4480331242,
-0.0258127861,
0.3678441346,
-0.6258102655,
0.1787454486,
-0.9066095948,
-0.115960218,
-0.432682991,
-0.312371701,
-0.69599998,
-0.7393557429,
0.3542055786,
0.2504690289,
-0.5085875988,
-0.0226422176,
-0.3513267934,
0.5057018995,
0.4960027039,
0.1597967297,
0.6456946731,
0.2000062317,
-0.057810083,
0.2310366184,
-0.7210562825,
-0.2311791778,
0.9367004633,
0.4694201052,
1.1323426962,
0.355635643,
0.6902267337,
0.0796282217,
0.1980466098,
-0.8806412816,
0.6270961165,
-0.4654162824,
-0.3139989972,
-0.389971137,
-0.9336422086,
-0.8367173076,
0.2467065901,
-0.0085705388,
-0.6329276562,
-0.0179110151,
0.1039105207,
-0.4492737651,
0.6659280062,
-0.7139000297,
0.6523543,
0.1206718758,
-0.4251383841,
-0.2224158645,
-0.4186204672,
0.5493048429,
0.010934568,
0.1306921095,
-0.1602803469,
-0.1755673289,
0.5836589336,
-0.8178318143,
0.6640677452,
-0.0021137407,
-0.3588055968,
-0.1595059335,
0.1796366721,
0.3612181842,
0.2866331041,
0.0038481962,
0.5308283567,
0.3180817366,
-0.745274663,
-0.5463152528,
0.9222826958,
-0.7684379816,
-0.4506683946,
-0.2625030577,
-0.7571246028,
-0.2701412439,
0.1163104996,
0.1709420383,
0.4052728415,
0.014910955,
0.2218174785,
0.8353412151,
-0.0973429903,
0.5297043324,
0.1401563883,
-0.1841945052,
-0.5351063609,
0.6150873899,
-0.020663267,
0.460827291,
0.5560433269,
0.3090602458,
-0.2713747323,
-0.5912100673,
-0.1973053813,
0.2751977444,
-0.5906944275,
-0.4502432644,
-0.2784192264,
-0.2318816036,
-0.435593456,
-0.177980125,
-0.7623050809,
-0.6872346401,
-0.0945432708,
0.2467841506,
0.4345873594,
0.2675384283,
-0.0846991464,
0.4069653153,
-0.7538073659,
0.3434800804,
0.2426094711,
0.6469478011,
-0.0123333074,
-0.4907664657,
-0.2261432856,
-0.1160440817,
-0.0912409425,
-0.2588557005,
0.3038716316,
0.0963107497,
-0.019905122,
0.4159345627,
0.086976923,
0.9802529812,
-0.3950731158,
0.5442531109,
0.230426982,
-1.3313744068,
-0.0852505788,
-0.137505129,
0.5529380441,
0.4034239352,
0.1755553633,
-0.395180583,
-0.3037771583,
-0.6417033672,
-0.9637222886,
0.4851453304,
0.225530535,
0.1124056578,
0.3713805377,
0.4032122195,
-0.285056591,
0.2417545766,
-0.3730150759,
-0.3392987847,
0.0582536198,
-0.1501984596,
-0.1270933002,
-0.3524840176,
0.0101346308,
-0.3650046587,
0.6381726861,
-0.1870903373,
0.2791473866,
0.1327459514,
-0.0199337546,
-0.0914851725,
0.4283064902,
0.4986062348,
0.6261311769,
-0.4346592426,
0.5922774673,
0.1574186683,
-0.8387573361,
0.0863517672,
0.4507693648,
-0.2227322608,
-0.2015492171,
0.1988627613,
0.7639675736,
0.0934118256,
-0.4631409943,
0.3907673955,
-0.2135252059,
0.012137644,
-0.3395134211,
-0.1339804381,
0.084975943,
0.4742189348,
0.2732007205,
-0.1812113374,
-0.0431055538,
-0.3043020964,
0.138514325,
0.521132946,
-0.1693565995,
-0.1332929283,
0.5779157281,
0.0462550148,
-0.0404950529,
0.6816646457,
0.1062966436,
-0.4386534691,
0.2491110414,
0.3773379028,
0.8150556684,
-0.3885321021,
-0.1551859677,
-0.0334922783,
0.0644034445,
-0.078234829,
0.2062809765,
-0.0015991835,
-0.7320067883,
-1.2392940521,
-0.7685866356,
-0.4232036471,
0.5635111332,
-0.6713662148,
0.0627513155,
-0.6456142664,
-0.2384007573,
0.149581477,
0.2839829028,
-0.5358262062,
0.2383494824,
0.4360473156,
0.7525451183,
-0.3506368399,
0.9396885633,
0.5503775477,
-0.2485576421,
-0.8951935172,
-0.056413237,
-0.138610214,
-0.6573314667,
0.448797375,
-0.0092732674,
-0.216983676,
0.2067351192,
-0.621845603,
-0.6391713023,
0.9494714141,
0.8844754696,
-0.6379797459,
-0.0821392313,
0.2572749555,
0.122678943,
0.0201813933,
0.3435893059,
0.7907683253,
0.4352258742,
0.2801273465,
-0.8650587797,
0.3148275316,
0.0261833183,
0.1998261362,
0.5150463581,
-0.6027316451,
1.0978125334,
-0.1643274575,
0.0690878183,
0.0935039893,
0.7082967758,
0.3764009774,
0.0143115651,
0.5278090239,
0.8467108607,
0.7543752193,
-0.0374531038,
1.0982084274,
-0.0470337681,
0.7169082761,
0.8639287353,
0.0046814019,
0.922316432,
0.7636330724,
-0.3487475812,
0.4411840141,
0.3196292222,
0.2135022432,
0.1499827057,
0.6137701273,
-0.5184703469,
-0.4026743472,
0.0818353519,
-0.0478824489,
0.4009017944,
0.2512196004,
0.0202584863,
-0.105726555,
-0.2224969268,
0.6546462178,
-0.0765263066,
-0.4866025746,
0.2203159332,
0.3024399579,
-0.5112495422,
1.2059634924,
0.2461249828,
0.8479961753,
-0.3862326443,
-0.0716586336,
-0.4015495181,
0.6591818929,
-0.4550141394,
-0.577039063,
0.0859061107,
0.051518444,
-0.0955144912,
-0.2049934119,
0.4341677427,
-0.4954078794,
-0.4988484383,
0.0159078334,
0.1341637671,
0.1172042415,
-0.550188005,
-0.4481418133,
0.2899326682,
0.0388144068,
-0.6570190787,
0.4585336149,
0.535318017,
-0.1045073271,
0.5905163288,
0.7359052896,
0.3320331872,
0.1083168238,
0.0552480631,
0.8278291225,
-0.6915693879,
-0.1651842296,
-0.8584040403,
0.3665658534,
0.1150110587,
-0.0726277456,
0.5197319984,
0.6580588222,
0.7368406057,
0.0323397741,
0.5289222598,
0.1439236403,
0.0186963789,
-0.8266905546,
0.711782217,
-0.5277642012,
0.5662456751,
-0.1015413851,
-0.9637700319,
-0.5509624481,
0.6412753463,
-0.3810684383,
0.0465996377,
0.8059971929,
0.6272988915,
-0.237982139,
-0.1371171176,
0.4857956767,
0.4336265028,
0.4664878547,
0.69580549,
0.5771616697,
-0.417860806,
0.582677722,
-0.633887589,
-0.2214915901,
-0.1240933686,
-1.0251626968,
-0.7835518718,
-0.2887821496,
-0.3956209123,
-0.5717692375,
-0.0644019023,
0.7087901235,
0.8415768743,
-0.6260251999,
-0.2770894468,
-0.1301467866,
0.1483778358,
-0.0152593311,
-0.2621052861,
0.6917017698,
-0.2740055621,
-0.8863306642,
0.2413064986,
0.1504794061,
-0.254643172,
-0.5776889324,
-0.0135253547,
-0.1524925679,
0.0652115494,
0.6754496694,
0.1808945239,
-0.6205753684,
-0.2014357597,
-0.2994014323,
-0.1153033823,
0.1475502104,
0.7746551633,
-0.8539057374,
0.1235933006,
0.4358760715,
0.7144314051,
1.1460666656,
0.0180213489,
0.4595490098,
-0.9306715727,
0.3578203917,
0.4079514742,
0.265278548,
0.4821657836,
-0.364233464,
0.4825774133,
0.1783391833,
-0.5326212049,
-0.9254701734,
0.1219352633,
-1.0385975838,
-0.2605624795,
1.3307436705,
-0.2194915712,
-0.5618826747,
0.253554523,
0.2350831628,
0.2564460635,
-0.4787706733,
0.5609498024,
0.2295453101,
-0.0421011485,
-0.377881825,
-0.6264691949,
0.4030889869,
0.657058239,
-0.6564612389,
0.0867081806,
0.4431109726,
0.3490142524,
0.1619094461,
0.3464028239,
-0.0409234241,
-0.1189898849,
-0.238124758,
0.6201994419,
-0.1887548715,
-0.0140886763,
-0.4411229193,
0.2677386105,
0.143984586,
-0.1029833779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17983v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17983v2
|
M3-VRD: Multimodal Multi-task Multi-teacher Visually-Rich Form Document Understanding
| 2024-02-28T01:56:00 | 2024-05-20T01:49:47 |
Yihao Ding, Lorenzo Vaiani, Caren Han, Jean Lee, Paolo Garza, Josiah Poon, Luca Cagliero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper presents a groundbreaking multimodal, multi-task, multi-teacher
joint-grained knowledge distillation model for visually-rich form document
understanding. The model is designed to leverage insights from both
fine-grained and coarse-grained levels by facilitating a nuanced correlation
between token and entity representations, addressing the complexities inherent
in form documents. Additionally, we introduce new inter-grained and
cross-grained loss functions to further refine diverse multi-teacher knowledge
distillation transfer process, presenting distribution gaps and a harmonised
understanding of form documents. Through a comprehensive evaluation across
publicly available form document understanding datasets, our proposed model
consistently outperforms existing baselines, showcasing its efficacy in
handling the intricate structures and content of visually complex form
documents.
|
[
-0.4179859459,
-0.8216092587,
0.6872330308,
0.163461417,
-0.2682014406,
0.0651815683,
0.0299699455,
-0.2240785658,
-0.3748734295,
0.3230982423,
-0.6180828214,
-0.4497693181,
-1.1433079243,
-0.2148807645,
-0.410174042,
0.7658823133,
-0.3492827117,
0.3760845661,
-0.7004366517,
0.0797196478,
-0.5353915095,
-0.4249866605,
-0.3069207072,
-0.3435030282,
0.5032012463,
0.4540578425,
0.382769078,
0.2835605145,
0.6502408981,
0.2842755318,
-0.2182203233,
0.2386553884,
-0.572524786,
0.1402707696,
-0.2498142421,
-0.6353542805,
-0.4868122637,
-0.0653950423,
0.5367835164,
0.7155244946,
-0.0935658589,
0.2283546478,
0.3545264602,
0.5621486902,
-0.9006814957,
0.5905644298,
-0.4238298833,
0.2552424669,
-0.1710156649,
-0.1819981039,
-0.4657125175,
0.3306207657,
0.1239121184,
-0.970477879,
0.4424368143,
-0.3937473893,
0.7622837424,
0.2522542477,
-0.6538088918,
-0.0604631193,
-0.7920122743,
0.3257584572,
-0.1614926755,
0.5647505522,
0.5023645759,
0.6447247863,
0.136303708,
-1.0236923695,
-0.9769990444,
0.2071613669,
0.3230681121,
0.4828004837,
-0.0929623395,
0.1785917282,
0.017455684,
0.6274645329,
-0.3535205424,
-0.0140589587,
-0.6717765927,
-0.1089083031,
0.1697208285,
0.1410063207,
0.3315438032,
-0.2513126731,
-0.7891150117,
-0.3914344609,
0.0316269659,
0.0787536129,
0.0525099449,
0.0766312107,
-0.3717476726,
0.7675241828,
-0.1069838777,
0.8615753055,
-0.1024680585,
-0.4855844378,
-0.0893187001,
-0.4761361778,
-0.5363649726,
-0.1457609236,
0.4468444586,
0.5466488004,
0.0100953411,
0.0175032429,
-0.0945523828,
-0.0072228778,
0.23064439,
-0.8842434287,
-0.2255283594,
-0.1386507452,
-0.5866841674,
-0.420982033,
0.2498050779,
-0.6518409252,
-0.6251282096,
-0.8351995349,
0.8106591702,
-0.6896317601,
-0.2487437576,
0.3077850044,
-0.8389394283,
-0.0816351846,
1.012658,
-0.9545178413,
0.1993120164,
0.5440399051,
0.9235337377,
-0.0288345199,
-0.5057733059,
-0.3662838638,
0.6148639321,
0.087524876,
0.808714211,
-0.6161342859,
-0.5799358487,
-0.3887898624,
0.0299175344,
-0.0323111974,
-0.3626542985,
0.3586091995,
-0.1976277828,
0.2679446638,
-0.1217328683,
-0.3088172674,
-0.6037614346,
0.3300246,
-0.8561269641,
0.8489248157,
0.4488772452,
-0.7412160635,
0.6819270253,
-0.1999980211,
-0.1196719855,
-0.0526735783,
-0.3013598323,
-0.3315373957,
0.2749705911,
0.2589054704,
0.7018168569,
-0.2737226784,
0.3114024997,
-0.509232223,
0.0338898972,
-0.1434493363,
-0.9804862142,
0.6172817945,
0.2477095127,
-0.0365379862,
0.2199447453,
-1.1335631609,
-0.478018105,
-0.1464225948,
-0.3127467334,
-0.3678146601,
-0.5059220195,
0.4210061729,
0.4446508884,
0.1565539986,
-0.2229643315,
0.2892692387,
0.4048769474,
0.3773261607,
0.7548627257,
-0.0593526959,
0.5598392487,
-0.3732618392,
0.6699914336,
0.5415314436,
0.2952935994,
-0.3822083771,
-0.4727790058,
-0.4394801557,
-0.6573104262,
0.0129883224,
0.2084433585,
-0.7564308047,
-0.0602311343,
-0.1953819841,
-0.5129483938,
-0.5895932913,
0.1747240126,
0.2465580851,
0.7435174584,
0.2827213407,
-0.4677295089,
-0.2282896042,
-0.7775185704,
0.3424244821,
-0.0253138095,
0.2173783481,
0.1252516061,
0.417924732,
-0.4432707727,
0.8097989559,
-0.5572234392,
-0.6270704865,
-0.2716700435,
0.5159068108,
-0.3602199554,
0.3821573853,
0.6085290909,
-1.0190176964,
-0.3138970733,
-0.005389174,
-0.6741377711,
0.1259195656,
-0.2491246462,
-0.2579101324,
-0.1915246993,
0.5907547474,
-0.6738466024,
0.6322871447,
0.56189394,
-0.5954563618,
0.4207586646,
-0.5071948171,
0.2567988336,
-1.2608219385,
-0.1167536378,
-0.0142161911,
-0.1778720766,
-0.2444793582,
0.0042263167,
0.3167971671,
-0.3916205168,
-0.4952173531,
0.474799484,
-0.6871047616,
-0.117770724,
0.0444321856,
0.1468418539,
0.7119588852,
0.3440285921,
0.0319284536,
0.5600808263,
0.7337101102,
-0.4555095136,
0.4109431207,
0.2253966331,
-0.3215453029,
0.9852735996,
-0.3261224329,
-0.4277655184,
-0.7514902949,
0.2373763174,
-1.2730787992,
-0.1303140223,
-0.0727817714,
-0.3275294602,
0.5543570518,
-0.3100092411,
-0.392984122,
-0.2346531153,
-0.3325107992,
0.2606110573,
-0.0358443819,
-0.3370162845,
0.9968950748,
0.2741725445,
-0.0652964786,
-0.4345342219,
-0.6835477352,
0.0188716203,
-0.0392532125,
-0.9234549999,
0.6217830181,
0.0313145891,
-0.2278021872,
0.213023439,
-0.2681751251,
-0.4158836007,
0.2438090146,
0.4838481843,
0.2336034179,
-0.2786114514,
0.1355197281,
0.2393358797,
-0.0151459472,
-0.1426637769,
0.0195404142,
0.3444990814,
0.2486702502,
-0.5640985966,
-0.6772625446,
0.3972249627,
1.2267192602,
-0.30590716,
0.9092304111,
1.2236722708,
-0.4194292128,
-0.179628104,
-0.447550565,
0.0563540272,
-0.385063678,
0.4476372302,
-0.8895859122,
-0.6609035134,
0.5569237471,
-0.1374952048,
-0.1930954605,
0.7114495635,
0.5969656706,
-0.1357167661,
0.572416842,
0.9623491764,
0.3638685942,
0.6055864692,
-0.6045328975,
-0.1966529489,
-0.8202978373,
-0.9309889078,
-0.2800080776,
-0.2076749504,
0.0889480785,
-0.8899406195,
0.3439381123,
0.6807365417,
0.2886452973,
-0.1045985743,
-0.5223121047,
0.2059191912,
0.5898875594,
0.1710230559,
0.4627038836,
-0.1002787203,
-0.1970546097,
0.1486937106,
-0.4792256355,
-0.4540854692,
0.9875498414,
0.2466662973,
0.9560050368,
0.368344605,
0.5426930785,
0.2988871932,
0.0013305153,
-0.7430803776,
0.2253295779,
-0.1342671067,
-0.3783332407,
-0.2822325528,
-0.0751099214,
-0.8134743571,
0.6765069366,
-0.4519200921,
-0.4016883671,
0.2535564601,
-0.0707378313,
-0.3522180021,
0.3847263455,
-1.4049171209,
1.3017743826,
-0.0339251831,
-0.3301603198,
-0.232509762,
-0.4014234245,
0.6760708094,
-0.0227800254,
0.3524167836,
-0.1512448788,
0.1338747293,
0.6315261722,
-0.602185607,
0.6613114476,
-0.2769374549,
-0.185626626,
0.3004972041,
0.0918606743,
0.1220019981,
0.1198728234,
0.1199783385,
-0.1992113888,
0.2415913343,
-0.3112208247,
-0.8226338625,
0.5484164953,
-0.8349555135,
-0.4575647116,
-0.2410771102,
-0.4692710042,
0.1165951118,
0.2952643037,
0.0745214075,
0.8135420084,
-0.2548265755,
0.2629716694,
0.7327887416,
-0.0389710218,
0.3293591142,
0.3952575922,
-0.1445028484,
-0.105501309,
0.8353765607,
0.2477156967,
0.357460767,
0.5564286113,
0.0880570933,
-0.4324801862,
-0.53636235,
-0.7013217807,
-0.1361585855,
-0.9775252342,
-0.1249891594,
-0.9056319594,
-0.0599203855,
-0.7430124879,
-0.1834213138,
-0.2075830102,
-0.5280156136,
-0.8148835897,
-0.3069737554,
0.3658367991,
1.0517909527,
-0.144111082,
0.2892567217,
-0.8727806211,
0.9281626344,
0.6291334629,
0.4756829143,
0.2453091443,
-0.6164259315,
-0.0869211927,
-0.1475691646,
-0.6513683796,
-0.8389776945,
0.3586280346,
0.2702155113,
0.6891261339,
0.5807977915,
-0.1563922018,
1.0700006485,
-0.3567945063,
0.6911711097,
0.3446742892,
-0.8029213548,
0.509447217,
-0.2473648489,
0.3998834491,
0.5565282702,
0.4714539349,
-0.5103605986,
-0.1166760027,
-0.5523892045,
-0.9572207332,
0.8272104263,
-0.1030648053,
-0.0776671842,
0.3387989104,
-0.0252153184,
0.5789903402,
0.0328885615,
-0.4558052421,
-0.1491172761,
-0.5101877451,
-0.4034407437,
-0.0450217016,
-0.4244692922,
-0.0594116636,
-0.3982449472,
0.2898702919,
0.1365744621,
0.0495217256,
0.1697009057,
-0.4188527167,
0.28838709,
0.2604357004,
0.8257118464,
0.8166283965,
-0.3633221686,
0.740054369,
-0.217917636,
-0.8721613884,
0.09684515,
0.3755809367,
0.3404093087,
-0.0221822597,
0.4117124677,
1.0402251482,
0.262521565,
-0.4138008356,
0.7776302099,
-0.3424282968,
-0.3791603446,
-0.0457517132,
-0.0085051227,
0.1806235164,
0.2192765921,
0.320672214,
0.3542030156,
0.2175574899,
-0.7845514417,
0.3207936883,
0.1458498538,
-0.4934431911,
-0.2801989019,
0.9621553421,
0.2858092189,
0.1225120574,
0.2950056493,
-0.0807197616,
-0.147534892,
0.5215838552,
0.4316538274,
0.6705210209,
0.1370797455,
0.4837453365,
0.123119168,
0.011755133,
-0.069638297,
0.3100954294,
-0.5767413378,
-0.4171267748,
-0.1209940836,
-0.7008299232,
-0.2685234845,
0.0545584485,
-0.7603358626,
0.382902652,
-0.4253461659,
-0.164248541,
0.4844211042,
-0.3362744153,
-0.8325459957,
0.3284319043,
0.4666214287,
0.6301477551,
-0.7856612206,
0.7209843397,
0.4539287388,
-0.8823711872,
-0.7459825277,
-0.3920461833,
0.2901875079,
-0.8401302099,
0.9951880574,
0.0952046216,
-0.1834118664,
-0.066158317,
-0.083339341,
-0.8188198209,
1.4449807405,
0.4284046292,
-0.5042371154,
-0.1822414696,
-0.01643374,
0.1585952789,
0.0557614416,
0.550462544,
0.002102836,
0.4451080263,
0.395391047,
-0.8991168141,
-0.2636065781,
-0.2333391756,
0.1390029937,
-0.0513666384,
-0.5697751045,
1.0077275038,
-0.1215342432,
-0.3098104298,
-0.5394767523,
0.623765111,
0.0100884717,
0.4171192348,
0.2129767835,
0.9015228152,
0.7810596228,
-0.0040579275,
0.9311312437,
-0.1299108714,
0.1956200302,
1.1846454144,
0.0292656496,
0.5990060568,
0.6028501987,
-0.1260348409,
0.3649363518,
0.3810817599,
0.15342246,
0.5400301814,
0.1216619387,
-0.435647279,
-0.2353493124,
-0.1253584176,
-0.4319766462,
0.7013974786,
0.3013572991,
-0.2873561382,
-0.6287472248,
0.5286672115,
-0.2892601788,
0.0877169743,
-0.4441853166,
0.8517354727,
0.0232465863,
-0.425331831,
0.3726117909,
0.196491763,
0.599893868,
-0.4799133539,
-0.2028111368,
0.0925236717,
0.1133287847,
-0.2968058884,
-1.2230081558,
0.1676874459,
-0.2696171403,
-0.5243003964,
-0.5800434947,
0.7167749405,
-0.6103707552,
-0.5268721581,
0.1822697371,
0.502258122,
0.0499573387,
-0.2714063525,
-0.4858405292,
0.2409498543,
-0.1696930826,
-0.0239668656,
0.2946302593,
1.2519594431,
-0.0494518541,
0.6755537391,
0.4728861153,
-0.1640541553,
0.3535208702,
0.5955511332,
0.8919701576,
-0.4353397489,
-0.4280913174,
-0.8374021649,
0.7622514367,
0.026780922,
-0.4303658903,
0.605840385,
0.6776794791,
1.0326652527,
-0.3673618436,
0.6935228109,
0.2611269057,
-0.1431422234,
-0.629538238,
0.9560390115,
-0.6261084676,
-0.2763971984,
-0.4605096579,
-0.7690657377,
-0.2201628536,
0.4543306828,
0.0946493447,
-0.2811763883,
0.4319219291,
0.4657926261,
-0.3533307612,
-0.2143489122,
0.5018518567,
-0.1345836371,
0.4445406795,
0.3304434419,
0.7757383585,
-0.4162674844,
0.5238977671,
-0.2491989136,
-0.1769027263,
-0.2618044019,
-0.4780780077,
-0.9095298648,
-1.08855474,
-0.2678904533,
0.0813004598,
-0.286550045,
0.4647548199,
0.856110394,
-0.09102083,
0.1333036721,
-0.0240757875,
0.138450101,
0.0059040734,
-0.3018042147,
0.3816585541,
-0.1177527383,
-0.6399248242,
-0.0293070227,
0.5737040639,
0.6551454067,
-0.4082345665,
0.1257260442,
-0.1919075996,
-0.1863448918,
1.1018667221,
-0.2844844759,
-0.6532889605,
0.1524825692,
-0.3606547117,
-0.3690285981,
0.037777219,
0.5554448962,
-0.7147218585,
0.9652469754,
0.6866939664,
0.5179044604,
1.0018663406,
-0.0306001045,
0.4016849995,
-0.5143452883,
0.3861869276,
-0.0645118356,
0.4379507601,
0.2302016765,
-0.297324717,
0.1505990773,
0.5216311216,
-0.0232727639,
-0.6728479266,
-0.050721731,
-1.6405036449,
-0.6165877581,
0.8957114816,
-0.0492727645,
-0.370734781,
-0.0470673516,
-0.6828767061,
0.5149356723,
-0.3264961839,
0.6267806292,
0.8883633018,
0.1589310318,
-0.4638839364,
-0.475628078,
0.3272214532,
-0.0256161988,
-0.8466443419,
0.1020465344,
0.6936472058,
0.0945499688,
-0.0768057257,
0.8458844423,
-0.2370686233,
0.2007571757,
0.368696183,
0.1583922058,
-0.5701009631,
-0.562227726,
-0.05795113,
0.5094653964,
0.0228967723,
-0.2798415124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17982v1
|
Collaborative decoding of critical tokens for boosting factuality of large language models
| 2024-02-28T01:53:37 | 2024-02-28T01:53:37 |
Lifeng Jin, Baolin Peng, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Ye Tian, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The most common training pipeline for large language models includes
pretraining, finetuning and aligning phases, with their respective resulting
models, such as the pretrained model and the finetuned model. Finetuned and
aligned models show improved abilities of instruction following and safe
generation, however their abilities to stay factual about the world are
impacted by the finetuning process. Furthermore, the common practice of using
sampling during generation also increases chances of hallucination. In this
work, we introduce a collaborative decoding framework to harness the high
factuality within pretrained models through the concept of critical tokens. We
first design a critical token classifier to decide which model to use for the
next token, and subsequently generates the next token using different decoding
strategies. Experiments with different models and datasets show that our
decoding framework is able to reduce model hallucination significantly,
showcasing the importance of the collaborative decoding framework.
|
[
-0.3311341405,
-0.5425444245,
0.4493463933,
-0.0390711464,
-0.3348212242,
0.2054201216,
-0.3381965458,
-0.3423572779,
0.0810060874,
0.7282685637,
-0.2782422304,
-0.4972017705,
-0.4932726324,
0.0755721256,
-0.4424991608,
1.2387274504,
0.1231390685,
0.328440845,
-0.2227689922,
-0.1843883097,
-0.5863915086,
-0.9563248158,
-0.5057742596,
-0.2991503179,
0.2843815684,
0.5541203618,
0.6458438039,
0.5323171616,
0.5092418194,
0.3010863066,
0.0131099336,
0.3253337443,
-0.9111248851,
0.0676101893,
-0.2561298609,
-0.6569470763,
-0.3599756062,
0.029670598,
0.3911411464,
1.0450052023,
-0.1545115262,
0.3047121763,
0.236269325,
0.4280534983,
-0.6332968473,
0.4609827995,
-0.7735482454,
0.0182648115,
0.0248851553,
-0.2144616544,
-0.7308496237,
-0.6254565716,
0.1178760678,
-0.6020051837,
0.7400550842,
0.2407872379,
0.5969097614,
0.1936419755,
-0.0759323686,
-0.2618245482,
-0.7710235119,
0.626948595,
-0.6388236284,
0.4776527584,
0.3743731678,
0.0357751884,
-0.0835272074,
-0.887347281,
-0.7308293581,
-0.1993047595,
-0.1660888046,
-0.0803286955,
0.2430326045,
0.3276013732,
0.0826337412,
0.5480957627,
-0.3418059945,
0.0105412621,
-0.2780096233,
-0.6472750902,
0.3852300048,
0.1908549219,
0.2380494326,
-0.1220257431,
-0.3061732948,
-0.268933028,
-0.5442952514,
-0.2102311999,
0.0875664279,
0.5634148717,
-0.0337789319,
0.4515139461,
-0.193925038,
0.3763177991,
0.2447877228,
-0.0105492324,
0.3648243546,
-0.6925660372,
-0.1314725578,
0.2322455496,
0.5771521926,
0.520018518,
0.1716146171,
-0.4905256927,
-0.3211923838,
0.2334088534,
0.0630754605,
-0.9004907012,
-0.3085509539,
0.1298727095,
-0.5780661106,
-0.5634769797,
0.1459440142,
-0.4764158428,
-0.3526070416,
-0.5484832525,
0.5237044096,
-0.3034621179,
-0.5417448878,
0.4656501114,
-0.1036046296,
-0.0224156156,
0.0712035745,
-1.0954297781,
0.3846980631,
0.9065551162,
0.7554190755,
-0.0215688329,
-0.3967173994,
-0.9696866274,
0.1123911515,
-0.4614275098,
0.6333612204,
-0.3776426017,
-0.2453565747,
0.1921028346,
0.0353566967,
0.0292037725,
-0.5688386559,
0.514021039,
-0.6128190756,
0.0938234329,
-0.6093080044,
-0.686616838,
-0.3093602061,
0.4088048339,
-0.7937007546,
0.672203958,
-0.0547989793,
-0.8981826305,
0.5297484994,
-0.3844816089,
-0.2790430784,
0.2382111549,
-0.330116272,
-0.2356352508,
0.2805575132,
0.2196156383,
0.7360112071,
-0.3542944789,
0.6846093535,
-0.2555419207,
-0.4427671432,
0.1454103142,
-0.4799836278,
0.6816087961,
0.2263023257,
-0.5366618633,
0.2050545514,
-0.8688220382,
-0.1353543401,
-0.0916200578,
-0.2606793344,
-0.2262564749,
-0.1957233846,
0.2203315198,
0.0894364566,
0.1389939636,
-0.2753288746,
-0.084497571,
-0.3743298352,
0.2789925635,
0.6913216114,
0.1656718999,
0.3401258588,
-0.312518537,
0.3440792263,
0.1777977943,
-0.0686795712,
-0.1942185313,
-0.1612331718,
-1.0421681404,
-0.2647758424,
0.4983601868,
0.3919226229,
-0.7497830987,
0.7327016592,
-0.3038098514,
-0.2124792933,
-0.6073276997,
0.0866649151,
0.4790023565,
0.5066440105,
0.1765030175,
-0.4359425306,
-0.6324873567,
-0.6303363442,
0.056210693,
-0.2651216388,
0.1122422963,
0.0148881031,
0.3746198118,
-0.3244813085,
0.9032185078,
-0.3698503077,
-0.1356488615,
-0.3590862453,
0.3821105957,
0.1287697405,
0.7511188984,
0.4427887797,
-0.6308413148,
-0.2104073316,
-0.1128889173,
-0.7875365019,
0.2158798128,
-0.3594724834,
-0.214632988,
0.0961282104,
0.739374578,
-0.5112705827,
0.0540427044,
0.5360463262,
-0.4184692204,
0.6362191439,
-0.1676139235,
0.1897045225,
-1.2377668619,
0.1504396051,
-0.6034949422,
-0.4693237543,
-0.4395532012,
0.3640411794,
-0.4253307879,
-0.0895873979,
-0.2171999812,
0.0558261052,
-0.4488911331,
0.1697258353,
-0.132202059,
0.075471431,
-0.0018412075,
0.3890005946,
0.1783535182,
0.735317111,
0.5596929193,
-0.4048473537,
0.3293468058,
0.242076382,
-0.5121299028,
0.2231287211,
-0.5466525555,
0.4178898036,
-0.0953319594,
0.2767009437,
-0.7856705189,
-0.3011470437,
0.1132366806,
-0.22373344,
0.1830895692,
-0.0725416765,
-0.7661335468,
-0.2175185084,
-0.104495272,
0.6365677714,
0.3723292947,
-0.7844334245,
0.4887657762,
0.5574634075,
0.1675590426,
-0.5266211033,
-0.5564628839,
0.086051099,
-0.0192993805,
-0.660831809,
0.0977982357,
-0.1120199263,
-0.0788087994,
0.0118392855,
0.1015398055,
0.0213344656,
0.1120574027,
0.3197576702,
0.3807741404,
-0.3736515045,
-0.0306498185,
-0.2383340895,
-0.3359983861,
0.1599380672,
-0.5631335378,
0.9326953888,
-0.2942759097,
-0.248696059,
-0.5707828403,
0.3826450706,
0.7946021557,
-0.5003772974,
1.200532198,
0.8897166848,
-0.5712046027,
-0.0962209329,
-0.8037281632,
-0.4416240454,
-0.4945084751,
0.3989237547,
-0.298976481,
-1.0202276707,
0.7405574322,
-0.1113655567,
-0.1437543929,
0.1461060941,
0.7877185345,
0.4111112952,
1.0720168352,
0.927963376,
-0.2921032608,
0.2508450747,
-0.4420569837,
0.3160358667,
-0.4354573786,
-0.287561357,
-0.4339262843,
0.1272168458,
-0.4058482349,
-0.5304085016,
0.1215235069,
0.3084356189,
0.0286551639,
0.0378150269,
-0.4988220036,
0.7971528769,
0.5253401995,
0.2430276722,
0.2201909274,
0.2057943046,
-0.5270404816,
0.0893767253,
-0.7891372442,
-0.5286859274,
1.0670716763,
0.2478651702,
0.5028620958,
-0.1596043706,
0.8287504911,
0.0511215851,
0.1740566939,
-0.7833471894,
0.4833632112,
0.0251764618,
-0.8816056848,
-0.182037428,
-0.4777603149,
-0.6113752723,
-0.0443227962,
-0.6459885836,
-0.5058777928,
0.1987424195,
0.2983643413,
-0.639446497,
0.2570928037,
-0.7725042105,
0.9758274555,
0.1954814792,
-0.312210232,
-0.6036691666,
-0.6145379543,
0.4177405238,
-0.1819843501,
0.3386678696,
0.2541139424,
0.6014277935,
0.7400407195,
-0.4886645079,
1.0894120932,
-0.1631816775,
0.0774417669,
0.3579497337,
0.211966902,
0.5230783224,
0.1890986562,
-0.2257284373,
0.0480416752,
0.0646411628,
-0.3578870595,
-0.338059783,
0.4494818151,
-0.7762286663,
-0.4566355348,
-0.2234779745,
-0.522272408,
-0.2283491492,
0.4567281604,
0.426369518,
0.8065373302,
-0.4287260473,
0.3466186523,
0.6030092835,
0.1347412467,
0.1815768778,
0.2157621533,
-0.1396722198,
-0.5413299203,
1.2345428467,
-0.0176958125,
0.2698252499,
0.1710996628,
0.1911902279,
-0.2146291137,
-0.9275624156,
-0.0595713668,
0.2590266466,
-0.8742881417,
-0.1911123693,
-0.5861513615,
-0.268353343,
-0.5831092596,
-0.2783821225,
-0.478398025,
-0.2852487266,
-0.280669868,
-0.3608538806,
0.0340200812,
0.8536186814,
-0.3703552783,
0.1713068634,
-1.2436388731,
0.308129102,
0.3134437799,
0.3145586848,
0.2025884241,
-0.2480867803,
-0.4924602211,
0.0050967978,
0.1595191807,
-0.5429912806,
0.1016373262,
-0.129830882,
0.5426311493,
0.5553863049,
0.3721469641,
0.7572930455,
-0.6079936624,
0.8100295663,
0.3156197965,
-1.2314097881,
0.0439570881,
-0.1502661407,
-0.0398002304,
1.0760886669,
0.2093527168,
-0.6372792125,
-0.4160763323,
-0.5726681948,
-0.7230536938,
0.7775313258,
0.1754053235,
0.2636278272,
-0.1700161397,
0.3966815174,
0.4593810737,
0.222017616,
-0.6692940593,
0.0502176099,
-0.2988124192,
-0.5216538906,
-0.0590552017,
-0.4321532547,
-0.416683346,
-0.3282370865,
0.4789239466,
-0.1878888905,
0.0271063745,
0.031453006,
-0.2427601069,
-0.1141850427,
-0.1310434639,
0.2859301269,
0.4326626062,
-0.1852270812,
0.2912979722,
0.1628711075,
-0.5868434906,
0.059767969,
-0.0976464227,
-0.0911433324,
-0.0177367851,
0.6315200329,
0.8598976135,
0.0970428735,
-0.467174083,
0.6622998714,
-0.2815586627,
-0.1506682187,
-0.181093365,
0.135949403,
-0.0533320159,
0.3187766373,
0.073941201,
0.4819062054,
0.2005445063,
-0.5089526772,
0.3653102219,
0.311083436,
-0.1684528142,
-0.5660346746,
0.5203530788,
0.635966897,
-0.2131254375,
0.6777684093,
-0.4280115366,
-0.8715497255,
0.3969337642,
0.8118409514,
0.9335675836,
0.1080497354,
0.3309582174,
0.4488021433,
0.242359668,
-0.4788118005,
-0.0226630252,
-0.3106380105,
-0.985603869,
-0.5016127825,
-0.6158869863,
-0.3901396394,
0.245473966,
-0.8653779626,
0.3644465208,
-0.5694707036,
-0.0692345351,
-0.3359422982,
-0.0260510482,
-0.7611000538,
0.3200393021,
0.4164324403,
0.5292075872,
-0.9479389191,
0.7021784186,
0.3720578849,
-0.4107149541,
-1.2399840355,
0.2875621319,
-0.1166258156,
-0.5382048488,
0.643371582,
0.5000908375,
-0.3732197881,
0.1685829908,
-0.565109849,
-0.8762393594,
0.7508515716,
0.5155573487,
-0.727175951,
-0.2815850377,
0.2335624695,
0.4332507849,
-0.4946452379,
-0.0843104646,
0.5950327516,
0.1452160776,
0.1454323083,
-0.7891644239,
0.4102042615,
-0.0690798461,
-0.2517625988,
-0.2716074884,
-0.4969604909,
0.7724558115,
-0.2050690353,
-0.3167153001,
0.0546804406,
0.7163349986,
0.2343374044,
0.135599643,
0.7378568649,
0.4803441167,
1.1500139236,
0.2382932454,
0.7226468325,
-0.6222257018,
0.4545158148,
0.9960642457,
-0.0668737441,
0.7834870219,
0.2588838339,
0.2663074732,
0.3443119228,
0.3940283358,
0.125513956,
0.5769186616,
-0.0673599616,
-0.2839914858,
-0.6611392498,
-0.1662822515,
-0.5552307367,
0.4185264707,
0.3371655345,
-0.2464060485,
-0.1087097377,
0.0385188535,
0.0744787157,
0.1074821129,
-0.0810898021,
0.6661607027,
-0.0323430821,
-0.6638306379,
0.9276857972,
-0.2203706801,
0.5396803617,
-0.1152390391,
0.0148041546,
-0.1739514768,
0.3807533383,
-0.2859528661,
-0.3533734679,
0.2076766342,
-0.1171305925,
-0.3398189843,
-0.1506029963,
0.3547802567,
-0.5253835917,
-0.451600492,
0.1511645317,
0.2852931321,
0.0365598574,
0.0790310353,
-0.4194974303,
0.3518022299,
0.0612001233,
0.1571199,
-0.1485703588,
0.5971720219,
0.1960484087,
0.2551656067,
0.9259002209,
0.1276872158,
0.0399098843,
0.4275365472,
1.1000195742,
-0.4770644307,
-0.6482154131,
-0.7932602763,
0.4939670563,
-0.0734385327,
-0.2301224172,
0.6425641179,
0.540012002,
0.9988591075,
-0.1103666201,
0.6589227915,
0.3316845596,
0.3009321988,
-0.7546113729,
1.0876473188,
-0.1566785276,
0.2292137891,
-0.2679160833,
-0.9369596243,
-0.4955756366,
0.7218002677,
0.0282295048,
-0.3552429378,
0.7437737584,
0.8520718813,
-0.0822886899,
0.155963093,
0.1578639597,
0.357595861,
0.5509669781,
0.254593581,
0.7949647903,
-0.2307754457,
0.5066283941,
-0.196262911,
-0.3273951709,
-0.3143876493,
-0.7325658798,
-1.3424975872,
-0.6765627265,
-0.2227970213,
-0.5754985213,
-0.0370490104,
1.3116555214,
0.9306536317,
-1.0411337614,
-0.1140071154,
-0.5256879926,
0.0128679825,
0.0552340373,
-0.2016958445,
0.2386574447,
-0.7200956941,
-0.5867806673,
0.1692372411,
0.0139867943,
0.0515145026,
-0.3383998275,
-0.0235913489,
0.1647207737,
0.1130608991,
0.5375034809,
-0.0341675356,
-0.3858813047,
-0.5376845002,
0.0412457958,
-0.2107775807,
-0.1352192014,
1.0209453106,
-0.8376086354,
0.466011554,
0.6519711018,
0.8938382268,
0.4309056401,
-0.1551297009,
0.8721144795,
-0.5841535926,
0.4831689,
0.3232512176,
0.2986080945,
0.5447499752,
-0.3807351291,
0.2087710053,
0.5845481157,
-0.5520197153,
-1.2801678181,
0.1031892225,
-0.8096621633,
-0.1306817383,
0.9602426291,
-0.1973065287,
-0.2967492342,
-0.1892276108,
-0.3648751974,
0.568941474,
-0.1699951589,
0.9635277987,
0.9266607761,
0.373372823,
0.2949557006,
-0.0269201379,
0.6355372667,
0.5886371136,
-0.5625653863,
0.3645165563,
0.5249192715,
0.2598159611,
0.4165566266,
0.5317983031,
0.0325276107,
0.1913533062,
0.3169497848,
-0.0404984877,
-0.036923524,
-0.5231164694,
-0.2146979719,
0.2046398073,
0.2390561998,
-0.3047279716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17971v2
|
All in an Aggregated Image for In-Image Learning
| 2024-02-28T01:32:59 | 2024-04-02T09:32:51 |
Lei Wang, Wanyu Xu, Zhiqiang Hu, Yihuai Lan, Shan Dong, Hao Wang, Roy Ka-Wei Lee, Ee-Peng Lim
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a new in-context learning (ICL) mechanism called
In-Image Learning (I$^2$L) that combines demonstration examples, visual cues,
and chain-of-thought reasoning into an aggregated image to enhance the
capabilities of Large Multimodal Models (e.g., GPT-4V) in multimodal reasoning
tasks. Unlike previous approaches that rely on converting images to text or
incorporating visual input into language models, I$^2$L consolidates all
information into an aggregated image and leverages image processing,
understanding, and reasoning abilities. This has several advantages: it reduces
inaccurate textual descriptions of complex images, provides flexibility in
positioning demonstration examples, and avoids multiple input images and
lengthy prompts. We also introduce I$^2$L-Hybrid, a method that combines the
strengths of I$^2$L with other ICL methods. Specifically, it uses an automatic
strategy to select the most suitable method (I$^2$L or another certain ICL
method) for a specific task instance. We conduct extensive experiments to
assess the effectiveness of I$^2$L and I$^2$L-Hybrid on MathVista, which covers
a variety of complex multimodal reasoning tasks. Additionally, we investigate
the influence of image resolution, the number of demonstration examples in a
single image, and the positions of these demonstrations in the aggregated image
on the effectiveness of I$^2$L. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/AGI-Edgerunners/IIL.
|
[
-0.4941492975,
-0.9182278514,
0.465218097,
0.0977618694,
-0.6066513658,
0.3647508025,
-0.0221931767,
-0.4602324963,
-0.1258689463,
-0.0254983567,
-0.2246447057,
-0.2827469707,
-0.4292655289,
-0.1245659813,
-0.2993558347,
0.8805072308,
-0.1295062602,
0.3723709881,
-0.829575181,
-0.3767436743,
-0.3542425036,
-0.2718317807,
-0.5150892735,
-0.5241933465,
0.260047704,
0.6089677215,
0.4863232672,
0.4929575622,
0.4755238593,
0.2679849863,
0.245623827,
0.5554977655,
-0.2597106695,
-0.1561442614,
-0.2254175991,
-0.3426994383,
-0.1378104091,
0.031163685,
0.8034930825,
0.444019109,
0.1494106799,
0.092905812,
0.0918603987,
0.3873184025,
-0.7815229297,
0.2479994744,
-0.6914071441,
0.0571807586,
-0.185513854,
-0.1752159148,
-0.3783126473,
-0.2387973964,
-0.0396277048,
-0.5917476416,
-0.2170340419,
-0.1100291386,
0.5367655158,
0.1715794504,
-0.8467122912,
-0.326657325,
-0.5183146596,
0.7133547664,
-0.3093543351,
0.3136154115,
0.1942820549,
0.3883702159,
0.193010971,
-0.8354741335,
-0.887037158,
-0.1902575195,
-0.1301616132,
0.4292896092,
-0.1897293329,
-0.0426884852,
0.243008703,
0.3706176877,
-0.3946786523,
0.1515954584,
-0.4643447101,
-0.065425694,
0.3579589128,
-0.0036974172,
0.3587574959,
0.2938606739,
-0.7223079801,
-0.2606205344,
-0.7443392873,
0.3085792959,
-0.0769894496,
-0.3062895834,
-0.2216364741,
0.5205844641,
0.2409937531,
0.660346806,
0.1297832876,
-0.3402646482,
0.1918418854,
-0.2843681872,
-0.0411959141,
-0.1286613047,
0.6011827588,
0.533239603,
-0.1477250308,
0.0258322861,
-0.2864712477,
0.4063108563,
-0.0953892544,
-0.6719706059,
-0.0180682205,
-0.1424358636,
-0.4952736497,
-0.1636853963,
-0.0404805429,
-0.7422801256,
0.0338903293,
-0.4816424549,
0.8751299977,
-0.8421641588,
-0.2089715898,
-0.2755863369,
-0.1798176765,
0.351752311,
0.5120722651,
-0.5970214009,
0.625020504,
0.3283908665,
0.8916343451,
-0.1809384674,
-0.3862574697,
-0.8449075222,
0.1850453168,
-0.4211795628,
0.996340692,
-0.566268146,
-0.3276745677,
-0.0405740216,
-0.3550562263,
-0.1989900917,
-0.6586344838,
0.2682897449,
-0.4698436856,
0.4263933003,
0.1222323775,
-0.646704495,
-0.563670516,
0.4471947253,
-0.435025543,
0.8711043,
0.0990593508,
-0.5213448405,
0.3380809724,
-0.8990083933,
-0.5682476759,
0.2892998159,
-0.5735788941,
-0.4947434068,
-0.2351171672,
0.1876679361,
0.4376745522,
-0.1631551236,
0.1681486815,
-0.3776440918,
-0.4201011658,
0.4677844346,
-0.4181024432,
0.6313153505,
0.3043029606,
-0.5476646423,
0.1505378783,
-0.3546707034,
0.0236802287,
0.1945700198,
-0.2225132883,
-0.3412671387,
-0.1336529106,
0.1238004193,
0.3597461581,
0.1888041496,
-0.4357598722,
0.3459365964,
-0.0011490724,
0.2647798359,
0.6812244654,
-0.0968303308,
0.6213660836,
-0.2470371872,
0.3434529603,
0.2959823608,
0.3447084725,
-0.5381401181,
-0.5321794152,
-0.6247028112,
-0.4859551489,
0.0462421775,
0.4913226664,
-1.2506791353,
0.1062766239,
-0.0712343678,
-0.278495729,
-0.0968642905,
0.0718865767,
0.8024622202,
0.6766277552,
0.5276973248,
-0.2485456467,
-0.1318122,
-0.9650072455,
0.0687707439,
-0.0149079775,
0.279584229,
0.3646951318,
0.8024097681,
-0.2725028396,
0.7967388034,
-0.167523697,
-0.2538104653,
-0.2607684135,
0.2162401527,
0.0201191101,
0.5143404007,
0.7705679536,
-1.0899107456,
-0.6542083621,
0.1162760034,
-1.0144178867,
0.2520494163,
-0.1457896978,
-0.0565780476,
-0.0061582942,
0.498247534,
-0.5522075891,
0.4750730395,
0.3031013608,
-0.4395390451,
0.4428480566,
-0.4772228003,
0.3104003072,
-0.9907339811,
-0.550417006,
0.5033988953,
-0.1468717605,
-0.5245632529,
0.4273681045,
0.5945439339,
-0.0652568638,
-0.4449988604,
0.4662668705,
-0.4256692529,
-0.22337915,
-0.1966895014,
-0.1135283709,
-0.0985113606,
0.5259979367,
-0.2508546412,
0.9661996961,
0.9450817108,
-0.6612761617,
0.3121419549,
0.1479851156,
-0.4527891576,
0.7548502088,
-0.2652333677,
0.2282563448,
-0.3750644326,
0.54819417,
-1.0614930391,
-0.248296082,
0.1461206973,
-0.2923854589,
0.4686029553,
0.1134384274,
-0.4714097977,
-0.1371856779,
-0.1492079049,
0.7882179022,
0.5707473159,
-1.0493556261,
0.8399688005,
0.3671372831,
0.2588694096,
-0.3022402525,
-0.5843965411,
0.1563824415,
-0.4207388163,
-0.6609187126,
0.5452190638,
-0.2835591435,
-0.5361169577,
0.1100996584,
0.2686223686,
-0.1574534774,
-0.1001744419,
0.1138629168,
0.5091796517,
-0.1311562508,
0.3226857781,
0.2772026956,
-0.0440092981,
-0.1482296437,
-0.4878930748,
0.281909436,
-0.5124023557,
-0.600466609,
-0.4883882105,
0.6292539835,
0.6392285824,
-0.4186196029,
0.2330177128,
0.545065701,
-0.3550704122,
-0.0766597092,
-0.4475256503,
-0.166750282,
-0.4219050705,
0.2701316774,
-0.3800714016,
-0.678425312,
0.2733810544,
-0.4501113296,
0.1149453446,
0.3194124103,
0.4743933976,
-0.5227875113,
1.1382687092,
0.3915370107,
0.1168367267,
0.5340180993,
-0.7318592668,
-0.0165398214,
-0.8013303876,
-0.4504885972,
0.0862735584,
-0.6216856241,
-0.103056103,
-0.7265111208,
0.978599906,
0.0206162669,
-0.21042189,
-0.2386926115,
-0.2240427732,
0.8340938687,
0.6256889701,
0.6812651753,
0.1767933965,
0.2446779907,
-0.2491378039,
0.0553618111,
-0.6305601597,
-0.1347650588,
0.8921200633,
0.0782013759,
0.8120061159,
0.2931582928,
0.343944937,
0.3320682347,
0.3805792332,
-0.775773108,
0.6324142218,
-0.3472236395,
-0.2222253829,
-0.0432215929,
-0.1885883361,
-0.5747618675,
0.6322383881,
-0.4427925348,
-0.5059144497,
0.1305084229,
0.3241692781,
-0.1565051526,
0.5813389421,
-0.8486386538,
0.6604476571,
-0.6718782187,
-0.6198843122,
-0.7112230659,
-0.6388661265,
0.5528031588,
0.1560092419,
0.4066692889,
0.3424284458,
-0.0233885758,
0.3349598944,
-0.2217690349,
0.8416453004,
-0.2301091552,
0.2685046494,
0.2869791687,
0.0659842491,
0.6024540663,
-0.120058164,
0.2902493179,
0.0446307249,
-0.4088454247,
-0.3376562595,
-0.7679791451,
0.6143528819,
-0.6928380728,
-0.203584075,
-0.2664255202,
-0.5429226756,
-0.1741165072,
-0.0949033201,
0.350435406,
1.0946741104,
0.1818103641,
0.4349012375,
0.8759887815,
-0.018327076,
0.6205579638,
0.0669813901,
-0.1350454837,
-0.6006624699,
0.9554994106,
0.0879602209,
0.4574732482,
0.4171852767,
0.3272204101,
-0.4150672853,
-0.3668916821,
-0.6597043276,
0.0086673386,
-1.2267781496,
-0.1979798675,
-0.6559883952,
0.0211687051,
-0.0091085443,
-0.2998637557,
-0.1273424029,
-0.30910936,
-0.2137035728,
-0.0553365052,
0.0964857116,
0.642088294,
0.0070099421,
0.2523471117,
-0.4106264412,
0.2851994336,
0.6963031292,
0.1717151254,
0.1357751638,
-0.4051738679,
-0.4013965726,
0.0798048601,
-0.5196881294,
-0.6873703599,
0.0724346787,
0.5061277151,
0.7980746627,
0.5749288201,
-0.3661655784,
0.8433817029,
-0.2274336964,
0.6730448008,
0.6525477171,
-0.9199188948,
0.4160573184,
-0.2323190868,
0.2117543668,
0.1924339682,
0.3772374094,
-0.1091644615,
-0.1875602454,
-0.6860266328,
-0.665550828,
0.3048054278,
0.0980762243,
-0.0932208002,
0.0828152969,
0.23534742,
0.2102239877,
-0.2183681875,
-0.8944140673,
-0.2604549229,
-0.2552645206,
-0.2727534473,
0.1623069793,
-0.2290239334,
-0.3568110168,
-0.7114310265,
0.6703988314,
-0.6546750665,
0.1726075411,
0.0621298663,
-0.3858553767,
-0.0142729552,
-0.0879748389,
0.5550314784,
0.7580749989,
0.2489715368,
0.4395222068,
0.3533158302,
-0.2145165652,
0.2383457571,
-0.129517138,
-0.2065422535,
-0.2158655673,
0.4857854843,
0.8377888203,
0.2300872803,
-0.5845997334,
0.7557172179,
-0.1951250732,
-0.6787471175,
-0.4074984193,
-0.1825786382,
-0.3335898519,
0.6492424011,
0.4801125228,
0.3674301207,
0.2289741486,
-0.6862099767,
0.3937227726,
0.6733350754,
-0.3178862631,
-0.2186840177,
0.6636514068,
-0.0142832985,
-0.0479121134,
0.6449460983,
-0.325031966,
-0.4595731199,
0.6943432093,
0.9548995495,
0.6803004742,
0.1341385692,
0.3139714301,
0.3272228539,
0.1176781803,
0.1141382158,
0.1823007613,
-0.3208704889,
-0.8669458628,
-0.5553911328,
0.0567941703,
-0.39441365,
-0.1166342571,
-0.3009363115,
0.1680645496,
-0.3775960505,
0.100149788,
-0.0992178693,
-0.5644422174,
-0.6121131182,
0.2297857702,
0.3782494366,
0.642349124,
-0.9251832962,
0.9334484339,
0.9540731311,
-0.4842226505,
-0.6606319547,
0.0407810137,
-0.0340482481,
-0.91004318,
0.8948495984,
0.2570800781,
-0.2316368371,
-0.1045017764,
-1.0595884323,
-0.719355762,
1.3002766371,
0.2958925068,
-0.1215912774,
0.3502836525,
-0.2334381193,
0.127048701,
-0.6789553761,
0.4586003423,
0.0907729864,
0.3108033836,
0.4458915293,
-0.6699275374,
-0.173464939,
-0.5030276179,
-0.0306025315,
0.0692100897,
-0.8594630361,
1.0840734243,
-0.423391968,
-0.074040167,
-0.2308264971,
0.6398313046,
0.4137629867,
0.6361811161,
1.0501289368,
0.697522521,
0.590144515,
-0.0625606179,
1.0454323292,
0.1088599786,
0.1653448641,
0.9303664565,
-0.1999712884,
0.4364543855,
0.5628857613,
-0.0188483559,
0.6713124514,
0.6306931973,
0.1457578242,
0.821619451,
-0.2735726833,
-0.5927360058,
-0.4832578301,
-0.1207938641,
-0.1817143261,
0.4616037011,
0.6895660758,
-0.0982616246,
-0.4547969401,
0.5399938822,
-0.366692096,
0.1130627692,
-0.4458213449,
0.9229118824,
-0.043351423,
-0.5636022091,
0.3687772155,
-0.4306204915,
0.6697684526,
-0.4879474342,
-0.4954513907,
-0.1381482035,
0.4786060154,
-0.1392581612,
-0.8996677399,
-0.0285461079,
-0.2231439203,
0.0237421691,
-0.2234364748,
0.744563818,
-0.4997375011,
-0.5066330433,
0.2234444469,
0.2878168523,
0.1223524287,
0.0177738126,
-0.662935257,
-0.3283513486,
-0.0850305259,
0.1488012969,
0.5948595405,
0.4742614329,
-0.4982245266,
0.7233826518,
0.7111966014,
-0.369299233,
-0.0390884541,
0.0113529591,
1.1121073961,
-0.2904942036,
-0.5680669546,
-0.857440412,
0.7002395391,
-0.2353280038,
-0.1409517378,
0.548045218,
0.8064857721,
0.9843878746,
-0.0133873085,
0.9679941535,
-0.0775793716,
0.0931031555,
-0.7513533831,
0.1399543285,
-0.9427830577,
-0.1521845609,
-0.0756161958,
-0.5931513309,
-0.3129685819,
0.6116907597,
-0.1007516906,
-0.1786710024,
0.8160877228,
0.4993033111,
-0.4524147213,
-0.0421453416,
0.3689817488,
-0.1593446136,
0.4870431423,
0.4441250563,
1.1274870634,
-0.1949981004,
0.4894625247,
-0.4840810001,
-0.5275138617,
-0.0042605866,
-0.7131118774,
-0.6880893707,
-0.7931857109,
-0.3042469323,
-0.2059822232,
-0.2223280966,
1.0584700108,
0.8535360694,
-0.4120875001,
-0.345664382,
0.0487808958,
0.0544875599,
-0.5748534203,
-0.1881644428,
0.2369626909,
-0.2430548668,
-0.5371161103,
0.4968213141,
0.559347868,
0.118037425,
-0.1978460252,
-0.2425402701,
-0.3574309349,
-0.3565063477,
0.8589324355,
0.0038923493,
-0.6456304193,
0.0115863094,
-0.2293724567,
0.1098346785,
0.1758205295,
0.8552654982,
-0.753359437,
0.6359708309,
0.2520873845,
0.5112502575,
0.7991163135,
-0.0967468917,
0.2420151532,
-0.577414453,
0.468269676,
0.2072964609,
0.6879570484,
0.1842022091,
-0.365986377,
0.5038030148,
0.3378882706,
-0.4636310041,
-0.3519764543,
0.213108927,
-0.9105067849,
-0.3894581199,
0.9913179874,
0.0300247427,
-0.2105274945,
0.1297084093,
-0.3390310705,
0.0658931136,
-0.309694767,
0.6351887584,
0.309004128,
-0.3668316305,
-0.4734741151,
-0.4226242602,
-0.0257148631,
0.0846522003,
-0.9019181132,
-0.6038098335,
0.7054439783,
-0.0124058118,
0.0795687065,
0.6310065389,
-0.2217271775,
0.5092147589,
-0.1314128488,
0.1091720238,
-0.0706077144,
-0.3625603616,
-0.2325058877,
0.122841306,
-0.2094206512,
-0.3657933772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07920v1
|
ProtLLM: An Interleaved Protein-Language LLM with Protein-as-Word Pre-Training
| 2024-02-28T01:29:55 | 2024-02-28T01:29:55 |
Le Zhuo, Zewen Chi, Minghao Xu, Heyan Huang, Heqi Zheng, Conghui He, Xian-Ling Mao, Wentao Zhang
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose ProtLLM, a versatile cross-modal large language model (LLM) for
both protein-centric and protein-language tasks. ProtLLM features a unique
dynamic protein mounting mechanism, enabling it to handle complex inputs where
the natural language text is interspersed with an arbitrary number of proteins.
Besides, we propose the protein-as-word language modeling approach to train
ProtLLM. By developing a specialized protein vocabulary, we equip the model
with the capability to predict not just natural language but also proteins from
a vast pool of candidates. Additionally, we construct a large-scale interleaved
protein-text dataset, named InterPT, for pre-training. This dataset
comprehensively encompasses both (1) structured data sources like protein
annotations and (2) unstructured data sources like biological research papers,
thereby endowing ProtLLM with crucial knowledge for understanding proteins. We
evaluate ProtLLM on classic supervised protein-centric tasks and explore its
novel protein-language applications. Experimental results demonstrate that
ProtLLM not only achieves superior performance against protein-specialized
baselines on protein-centric tasks but also induces zero-shot and in-context
learning capabilities on protein-language tasks.
|
[
-0.248029232,
-0.9225845337,
0.2400894761,
0.0506430417,
-0.5622518063,
0.304530412,
-0.0423667915,
-0.471442312,
0.2296040654,
0.3389563859,
-0.5891572833,
-0.4042616487,
-0.7831415534,
0.2331231982,
-0.57174474,
1.0650805235,
0.1653086245,
0.5803102851,
-0.3630312383,
-0.068115361,
0.0177692547,
-0.7138141394,
-0.1332832426,
-0.7105504274,
0.8000636697,
0.2259630561,
0.4740155637,
0.2602855265,
0.5704764724,
0.150822252,
0.1234183535,
0.1957236081,
-0.5047162771,
0.0619321652,
-0.2473446727,
-0.3556280732,
-0.6290844083,
0.1816484183,
0.5535077453,
0.8595480919,
0.3432992697,
0.1576321721,
0.1489514112,
0.6356269717,
-0.5098640323,
0.2021424472,
-0.6342175007,
0.0593907796,
-0.6932390928,
-0.354893744,
-0.4783336222,
0.0249569416,
0.3094930649,
-0.2756735682,
-0.116050683,
0.267809391,
0.4756196737,
-0.0480417646,
-0.5696513057,
-0.3352803588,
-0.3138116598,
0.618873477,
-0.7899404168,
0.7199028134,
0.6313803792,
0.1718619913,
-0.5285507441,
-1.1238183975,
-0.6325992346,
-0.5121626258,
-0.1070151776,
0.1312829852,
0.1580470353,
0.2860099673,
-0.0868531764,
0.2800641656,
-0.9584589005,
0.0145045361,
-0.1715683788,
0.0239299592,
0.5237193704,
-0.0916734412,
0.4380393922,
0.3450604975,
-0.0404041149,
0.1511671841,
-0.9253122807,
-0.0129397064,
0.2550717592,
0.560760498,
0.2741281986,
0.7248523235,
-0.2046687156,
0.9027590752,
-0.2737748027,
0.1723940074,
0.1661562324,
-0.0974624157,
-0.441346705,
0.2481098026,
0.7357120514,
-0.0686512887,
0.1779071093,
-0.4710375965,
-0.0428793393,
-0.3287193775,
0.2241001725,
-0.9222618341,
-0.405407548,
0.5548811555,
-0.3284329474,
-0.1065447778,
-0.0037744599,
-0.1691083014,
-0.0902700126,
-0.1583670825,
0.8642198443,
-0.7458652854,
-0.0481393151,
0.2231973857,
0.0787296221,
0.1451380998,
0.0412452221,
-0.6215974689,
0.1739089936,
0.5249930024,
0.7320900559,
-0.235828802,
-0.5301547647,
-1.0867807865,
0.4024149179,
0.0423638076,
0.7155823708,
-0.7836402655,
-0.1686556935,
-0.0366424248,
0.2426243126,
0.0492110886,
-0.507712543,
0.2993950844,
-0.8359363675,
0.2615566254,
-0.2458529323,
-0.9283463955,
-0.2957793772,
0.2478752583,
-0.3946754634,
0.4378086627,
0.0982224867,
-1.0254589319,
0.2332019806,
-0.7635396719,
-0.7075411081,
0.5618389845,
-0.1655463576,
-0.2411763072,
0.238583684,
-0.2043649107,
0.3560840487,
-0.4726503193,
0.3936760128,
-0.2838722169,
-0.2690548599,
0.5248791575,
0.0591525696,
0.6185468435,
0.0895752236,
-0.0278081615,
0.2638123631,
-0.4515549541,
0.3846810758,
-0.1343308389,
-0.5435931087,
-0.2304364741,
0.1309571117,
0.0870568454,
0.0407964475,
0.2806138396,
-0.7749586105,
0.3297828734,
-0.3171281815,
0.4457126558,
0.2657942772,
-0.292473495,
0.2009730339,
-0.1185876355,
0.2059870958,
0.0587272719,
0.2497785538,
0.0162599254,
-0.3052538037,
-0.605245769,
-0.3719056845,
0.4383053184,
0.2466205955,
-0.7364507318,
0.374861002,
0.0302604195,
-0.308570832,
-0.5079852939,
-0.0416425876,
0.4298503399,
0.5444426537,
0.7936276793,
-0.2371265739,
-0.5101638436,
-0.8811234832,
-0.4707185626,
-0.0486125015,
-0.0880228058,
-0.1156040132,
0.4449694157,
-0.3467151225,
0.9010792375,
-0.2457750887,
-0.492312789,
-0.5489966273,
0.2810679674,
0.3135062456,
0.4777669013,
0.1788354218,
-0.8561360836,
-0.6608626842,
0.0387484096,
-0.7874628305,
-0.3275361359,
0.1928910464,
0.1894192249,
-0.1843422353,
0.5527589917,
-0.5460453629,
0.2608471811,
0.7395798564,
-0.5271862149,
0.7581057549,
-0.4756414294,
-0.1546144634,
-0.5607227683,
0.2296307385,
-0.3477680981,
-0.3938984275,
-1.0094884634,
0.0671928152,
0.1528376788,
0.1177874506,
-0.7922054529,
0.7012314796,
-0.5700270534,
-0.268728137,
-0.6195200086,
-0.2645486295,
0.1216701418,
0.2047702968,
0.1591451168,
0.7378584146,
0.5730792284,
-0.5077722669,
0.0789190084,
0.2212556154,
-0.3427290916,
0.0107444655,
-0.7358850241,
0.0249559935,
-0.1635447443,
0.2231921405,
-0.446080476,
-0.1949084103,
0.1958615631,
-0.2353141159,
0.303902775,
0.3426076472,
-0.6424100399,
-0.3504613638,
-0.2663504779,
0.4223469198,
0.2617843747,
-0.1346472651,
0.6274391413,
0.2661737204,
-0.0779567808,
-0.3183145225,
-0.7705178261,
0.0294586774,
0.1625213027,
-0.1249588132,
0.5186283588,
-0.2447855473,
-0.0455801152,
0.0512330607,
-0.0240290295,
-0.0299688261,
-0.139099434,
0.1435982138,
-0.2106410563,
0.0703973249,
0.3114695549,
-0.0557795316,
-0.1112840623,
-0.3911963999,
-0.7062911987,
0.9123356342,
-0.2360622287,
-0.5006552935,
-0.1518700719,
0.5500673652,
0.5408027768,
-0.4745073915,
0.8906214833,
0.7606253624,
-0.1218649819,
0.0357455797,
-0.1975107342,
-0.3975587487,
-0.4232966304,
0.7327584624,
-0.3847355545,
-0.7984887362,
0.2077649981,
-0.1126724631,
0.0943361446,
-0.0797160044,
0.5973784924,
-0.4489280581,
0.8034924269,
0.8157466054,
0.4880092144,
0.4002753198,
-0.1740322113,
0.4411998093,
-0.8548058867,
-0.4165855646,
-0.1204161867,
-0.6730784178,
-0.0724060386,
-0.7077580094,
0.3171877265,
0.5035991073,
-0.4377757013,
0.3377475142,
-0.0191848259,
0.2632844746,
0.7159879208,
0.1747796834,
0.3667816818,
-0.0695383549,
-0.2524498999,
-0.1005034372,
-0.8768815398,
-0.3124415874,
0.7890644073,
0.1921698451,
0.6849085689,
-0.0084021632,
0.4572861493,
0.3841876984,
0.4520154893,
-0.7751637697,
0.563867569,
-0.7455031276,
-0.3323884308,
-0.1987280846,
-0.0248164572,
-0.7262592912,
0.1684170812,
-0.1272847354,
-0.5602875948,
-0.0177659877,
0.045292832,
-0.0103090219,
0.1072229594,
-0.4521079361,
0.7726943493,
-0.6419152021,
-0.3759461641,
-0.0556009114,
-0.7179536819,
0.1277520359,
-0.4786917865,
0.1508280337,
-0.2288646698,
-0.1378218234,
0.5542430282,
-0.7483784556,
0.7325954437,
-0.0796764269,
0.0196247511,
0.2182732671,
0.318685472,
0.4704672396,
0.0074934256,
-0.199304089,
0.0885199085,
-0.1276276708,
-0.4709164202,
-0.3486607373,
0.4363387525,
-0.607647717,
-0.5530546308,
-0.3506812155,
-0.811468184,
-0.3605700135,
0.3260549307,
0.5639887452,
0.5384697914,
0.2401732504,
0.462941736,
0.4973353148,
-0.4323621094,
0.3710848689,
0.9072975516,
-0.4927035272,
-0.2630370557,
0.7941783667,
0.3227427602,
0.214259401,
0.7296675444,
0.086604327,
-0.5378188491,
-0.8865686655,
0.0571311936,
0.3099258244,
-0.4023116827,
-0.320315659,
-1.0766899586,
-0.3719769716,
-0.2648388147,
-0.2763241231,
-0.3300534785,
-0.0228570625,
-0.1744254231,
0.0724793002,
0.2881025374,
0.3500092626,
0.053048566,
0.3730474412,
-1.0146267414,
0.2487540543,
0.3680712879,
0.3047624528,
-0.3202861845,
-0.6503059268,
-0.2850620747,
0.143502593,
0.0682400987,
-0.8798624873,
0.7130286098,
0.900591135,
0.6984810829,
0.0268199258,
0.237488687,
0.3119983077,
-0.4342680275,
0.7082081437,
0.226199314,
-0.7557314038,
0.5737146735,
-0.1853782386,
0.7822068334,
0.4378728569,
0.7609853148,
-0.3746002614,
-0.6603878736,
-0.2640010715,
-0.8526579142,
0.5710535645,
0.0000101705,
-0.1123112813,
-0.2425318509,
0.0522781983,
0.4496060908,
0.3776758909,
-0.9909666777,
0.1958551854,
-0.0306224227,
-0.2656096518,
-0.0091941766,
-0.4327322245,
-0.2090931684,
-0.3054914773,
0.6753849983,
-0.4792756736,
0.1260216236,
0.1573311538,
-0.5646093488,
0.0978586674,
0.1290622354,
0.3578453064,
0.478087157,
-0.3724135756,
0.5309967399,
-0.001354553,
-0.6249302626,
0.0762260482,
-0.0139416019,
-0.1722054482,
-0.1529907435,
0.8220867515,
0.6713887453,
-0.0428581648,
-1.0819447041,
0.4133617878,
-0.0207392089,
-0.3380112648,
0.2269786447,
-0.2770773172,
0.3853920102,
0.5610637665,
0.5873479843,
-0.4052820802,
0.0765185282,
-0.7637785077,
0.53015697,
0.4044601023,
-0.5070315003,
-0.6404959559,
0.6865045428,
0.0059695132,
-0.3545106649,
0.5169657469,
-0.1785674244,
-0.5750874877,
0.2216099352,
0.9414892793,
0.8492290974,
-0.0495888367,
0.3536359072,
-0.0358377174,
-0.1149464995,
0.0898345187,
0.5433441401,
0.1431625038,
-0.5805519223,
-0.4517597258,
-1.3369089365,
0.0373730808,
0.2407020479,
-0.1414437592,
0.2959694564,
-0.3721538186,
-0.1720140278,
-0.123424083,
0.179678604,
-0.5539618134,
0.1016126871,
0.0563026816,
1.1515865326,
-0.7478168011,
1.6044347286,
0.9987320304,
-0.4020493925,
-0.3749738038,
0.1527246088,
-0.2456326038,
-0.5736447573,
1.4187347889,
0.2126389444,
-0.0438488424,
0.3407594562,
-0.2837689817,
-0.6675595641,
0.9307997823,
0.4777545631,
-0.8044495583,
0.0130796395,
0.3231160045,
0.6807693839,
-0.5679578781,
0.1403288394,
0.4086874127,
0.4046133757,
-0.0475756265,
-0.8659586906,
-0.2382041216,
-0.1545201242,
-0.2662090957,
-0.088899672,
-0.756218493,
1.2001844645,
0.0180965811,
0.0764664635,
-0.2558938265,
0.6479163766,
0.2606476843,
0.0200994797,
0.1788171083,
0.1594997793,
0.5567964315,
0.1918342412,
0.82797575,
-0.3177444935,
0.1458082199,
1.2938482761,
-0.5748274326,
0.8929273486,
0.6264042258,
-0.238321498,
0.1610765904,
0.4306557477,
0.4216269255,
0.8661266565,
0.3009179235,
-0.5322059393,
-0.3394892514,
-0.5110971928,
-0.4433456659,
0.6755048633,
0.4127352834,
-0.1870478392,
-0.3714750707,
0.5728157163,
-0.3044773638,
-0.0196991377,
-0.1969199181,
0.6367913485,
0.2550102472,
-0.1256611496,
0.539577961,
-0.233000204,
0.5655086637,
-0.9569385052,
0.207220763,
-0.3257544637,
0.2686278224,
-0.0546026491,
-0.7903442383,
0.3875063956,
-0.0642479435,
-0.1937359571,
-0.1993915886,
0.7792103291,
-0.9344727397,
-0.4131321907,
0.5925422907,
0.5437218547,
0.0890408084,
-0.1896599531,
-0.7098968029,
0.2568335831,
-0.1026515737,
-0.3947315514,
0.7477855682,
0.2802565694,
-0.0428721011,
0.765755415,
0.4500972331,
0.2649674416,
-0.0912937075,
0.1277144104,
1.0432201624,
-0.512336731,
-0.3467310667,
-0.9398678541,
0.3887377977,
0.0182340387,
0.2324798405,
0.5422222018,
0.5732396245,
0.6863084435,
-0.351108104,
0.7267243266,
-0.2426407635,
0.3802551329,
-0.4426989257,
0.7502108216,
-0.6939331889,
-0.0782539323,
0.2467226833,
-0.87819767,
-0.6724591851,
0.3792924881,
-0.3259799182,
-0.3268163204,
0.8176586628,
0.7433355451,
0.0156716239,
-0.0139832217,
0.5032368898,
0.3210636377,
0.6727340221,
0.5288873911,
0.7239688039,
-0.381386131,
0.2685659528,
0.22314924,
-0.2010126859,
-0.5516960621,
-1.1376742125,
-0.8008409739,
-0.6637141705,
-0.2098320872,
0.0392906331,
0.3525834978,
1.1015539169,
0.7672834992,
-0.899246037,
-0.2636418045,
-0.2617764175,
-0.4600740075,
-0.1279494464,
-0.1336540431,
0.2139701843,
-0.5643623471,
-0.6728544235,
0.7161154747,
0.6456831098,
0.2237477005,
-0.110954091,
-0.23205778,
-0.8311776519,
-0.099683702,
1.0096651316,
0.4245733917,
-0.6007378101,
-0.2912302613,
-0.0653860644,
0.011438217,
-0.2885960937,
0.889211297,
-0.8401012421,
0.474398315,
0.7226990461,
0.6988557577,
0.3369688988,
-0.2131473273,
0.9616401792,
-0.8274588585,
0.4539114833,
0.3693066537,
0.1385703087,
0.1621281356,
-0.2543106377,
0.3653083146,
0.1934870481,
-0.4063203633,
-0.8451948762,
0.2870329022,
-0.7483446002,
-0.7088475227,
0.9103357196,
-0.347556293,
-0.1080736071,
-0.2619099915,
-0.0997008458,
0.4287856817,
0.173355341,
0.5326763391,
0.473251909,
-0.2906935811,
-0.1317150295,
-0.5943589211,
0.7390122414,
0.4063256979,
-0.7238106132,
0.2985534072,
0.1324010342,
-0.0177398585,
-0.2518425286,
0.9366397262,
-0.1990349293,
-0.0356858522,
-0.1362483203,
-0.0771230683,
-0.438805759,
-0.5820531845,
0.1364669204,
0.3197576702,
0.2171176523,
0.0514372513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17959v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17959v2
|
An Iterative Associative Memory Model for Empathetic Response Generation
| 2024-02-28T00:49:06 | 2024-06-02T10:46:13 |
Zhou Yang, Zhaochun Ren, Yufeng Wang, Chao Chen, Haizhou Sun, Xiaofei Zhu, Xiangwen Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Empathetic response generation aims to comprehend the cognitive and emotional
states in dialogue utterances and generate proper responses. Psychological
theories posit that comprehending emotional and cognitive states necessitates
iteratively capturing and understanding associated words across dialogue
utterances. However, existing approaches regard dialogue utterances as either a
long sequence or independent utterances for comprehension, which are prone to
overlook the associated words between them. To address this issue, we propose
an Iterative Associative Memory Model (IAMM) for empathetic response
generation. Specifically, we employ a novel second-order interaction attention
mechanism to iteratively capture vital associated words between dialogue
utterances and situations, dialogue history, and a memory module (for storing
associated words), thereby accurately and nuancedly comprehending the
utterances. We conduct experiments on the Empathetic-Dialogue dataset. Both
automatic and human evaluations validate the efficacy of the model. Variant
experiments on LLMs also demonstrate that attending to associated words
improves empathetic comprehension and expression.
|
[
-0.3183757067,
-0.8494019508,
0.6439443827,
0.2565709949,
-0.2664095163,
-0.1698888689,
-0.0428483523,
-0.0769578367,
0.2628809214,
0.43586725,
-0.6689703465,
-0.1325960904,
-0.4498923719,
0.0935720578,
-0.3430706859,
0.7928380966,
-0.2167216241,
0.0288749076,
-0.254920572,
-0.4108638167,
-0.291000694,
-0.5681061745,
-0.9974864721,
-0.4854783118,
0.4335720837,
0.2725532055,
-0.0085668797,
0.4529784322,
0.4575170875,
0.3243436813,
0.0114080803,
0.1788557321,
-0.3612064123,
0.3375550807,
0.0858024806,
-0.2626045346,
-0.3661590517,
-0.003549502,
0.29018718,
0.288205415,
-0.5100740194,
0.1100156009,
-0.0894641355,
0.3945282102,
-0.5671386719,
0.1424273551,
-0.7148357034,
0.2383845448,
0.5030197501,
-0.6896622777,
-0.5914168358,
-0.2217929065,
0.3270368874,
-0.326215297,
0.0790438503,
0.2014859021,
0.0784514919,
0.2744357884,
-0.1951727718,
-0.6169717312,
-0.5821533203,
0.5054853559,
-0.6738251448,
-0.0262988824,
0.55985111,
0.0160961654,
0.1484811306,
-0.3848535717,
-0.5802649856,
-0.426916033,
0.0534695834,
0.4940001965,
-0.2480546683,
0.2279984504,
0.1779165566,
0.3257347941,
-0.2964001596,
-0.2814573348,
-0.17935206,
-0.0239947885,
0.380728811,
0.7887624502,
0.1829347908,
-0.130065158,
-0.2843111753,
0.1069901511,
-0.1933339387,
0.0291941315,
0.0180846862,
0.213675797,
-0.1419608295,
0.6706887484,
0.2339948118,
0.4702094793,
0.4564421773,
-0.2351549566,
-0.1642509997,
-0.2752477229,
-0.0365207456,
0.2830709517,
0.6616591811,
0.5845754147,
0.267649442,
-0.1854834408,
0.1559346914,
0.447088927,
0.5270965695,
-0.8378174305,
-0.367208451,
0.547005415,
-0.369422704,
-0.0961453989,
-0.4605540931,
-0.7167937756,
-0.086005643,
-0.118222408,
0.4531144202,
-0.7280167937,
-0.144829914,
-0.183372125,
-0.0996704623,
0.1903923154,
0.1824491322,
-0.7860729098,
0.420060426,
0.2734537423,
0.896697998,
0.0383019224,
-0.2034796923,
-0.6544815898,
0.3522201777,
0.1059971005,
0.8108205795,
-0.7765066028,
-0.6061533689,
-0.083644107,
-0.2377768308,
-0.1676584482,
-0.3105709255,
0.0678052753,
-0.2721598446,
0.0844617486,
-0.0469396077,
-0.6884006858,
-0.3235367537,
0.4770407975,
-0.5485014915,
0.575864017,
0.1495140195,
-0.756267488,
-0.1666473597,
-0.4060234129,
-0.3804606199,
-0.3716847003,
-0.1466931403,
-0.4356286526,
0.4150412977,
0.0098668626,
0.2418216318,
-0.4494241476,
0.0128005696,
-0.3481437266,
-0.079278782,
0.4551596642,
-0.2798359394,
0.3175835013,
0.0950752646,
-0.1188592464,
-0.19120498,
-0.7152658701,
0.1129403561,
0.1209735349,
-0.3297956884,
-0.2345683724,
-0.2663944662,
-0.2363443673,
0.3427930772,
-0.037851423,
-0.6835425496,
-0.1447966248,
-0.256457746,
0.5670688748,
0.6887170076,
0.4736399949,
0.6530467272,
-0.3870898783,
0.4932877421,
0.537905395,
-0.035151463,
-0.8536096215,
-0.0952979401,
-0.7914769053,
-0.0425836481,
-0.2031411827,
0.4360867441,
-0.3894640505,
0.1596399397,
0.2112999111,
-0.2795355618,
-0.9001995921,
-0.1112769693,
0.7896547318,
0.7507186532,
0.4150380492,
-0.7386391163,
-0.4085332155,
-0.5511104465,
-0.0371261239,
-0.4306911826,
0.2053761035,
0.6662573218,
0.224525243,
-0.2026863396,
0.5684229136,
-0.3525439203,
-0.2487667054,
0.0130463466,
0.5353959203,
-0.4543726444,
0.1364157796,
0.0775687397,
-0.4480693638,
-0.1280890256,
-0.1358834356,
-0.5066475868,
-0.018097369,
-0.1827424914,
-0.1405486166,
0.21069552,
0.2711113989,
-0.6339997053,
0.4617874026,
0.3004784286,
-0.2917586863,
-0.0539353117,
-0.1882573962,
0.3022562265,
-1.2064756155,
0.2173165083,
-0.0686545596,
0.113911733,
-0.5085200667,
-0.1625294983,
-0.0972525477,
-0.0313364714,
-0.2838539779,
0.7841952443,
-0.4830627441,
-0.1891073138,
-0.316719383,
0.2729406357,
-0.0547256805,
0.6421896815,
0.0537160113,
0.4080354869,
0.3792752326,
-0.7736957073,
0.3484219015,
0.729724586,
0.1630030572,
0.899913609,
-0.4056279659,
0.4069270492,
-0.397438705,
0.2990310192,
-1.1189391613,
-0.1413598806,
0.2887915969,
-0.5704305172,
0.2580725849,
0.3178145885,
-0.278639704,
-0.4759465754,
-0.1479210407,
0.5715157986,
0.466496706,
-0.4680095315,
1.0007326603,
0.2619149983,
-0.3116989136,
-0.0451779664,
-0.5764402151,
-0.2112803906,
-0.2681457698,
-0.4756628275,
-0.0449866392,
-0.3579185307,
-0.4237058461,
-0.1476486623,
0.0844792053,
0.0431808382,
-0.1052739099,
0.2547984123,
-0.1267319769,
0.0894530639,
0.1586623937,
-0.0373654887,
-0.2146140933,
0.1773413718,
0.4801414013,
0.7544104457,
0.2534463704,
-0.2589614987,
-0.5778834224,
0.8230832815,
0.5699310303,
-0.3072373867,
0.4405922294,
0.5077455044,
-0.2209298164,
0.1504381895,
-0.4879817069,
-0.4755085409,
-0.3956192732,
0.1830088049,
-0.4973458946,
-0.5311467648,
0.8797744513,
-0.149704501,
0.1349939555,
-0.0069291908,
0.7908785939,
-0.141339466,
1.4092693329,
0.3313949406,
-0.1928161681,
0.4155100286,
-0.0446565747,
0.4980438054,
-1.280878067,
-0.0827184618,
-0.1521962583,
-0.2321456671,
-0.147806257,
-0.2150299847,
0.4046880603,
-0.3504798114,
-0.4993157983,
-0.0843524411,
-0.1976930499,
0.0090608364,
0.339437902,
0.4161527455,
0.4977059066,
-0.0624064468,
-0.0542605072,
-0.0924745575,
-0.4798891246,
-0.2476821095,
0.7831475139,
0.2987431884,
1.0007978678,
0.0656632856,
0.8742333055,
-0.0527482592,
0.4338767827,
-0.9546719193,
0.4813958704,
0.0254833382,
-0.257057488,
0.1415103823,
-0.1508823782,
-0.6560101509,
-0.0489026383,
0.3013086319,
-1.1679766178,
-0.1487575322,
0.3718805909,
-0.7424984574,
-0.0424077958,
-0.5453415513,
0.0612002276,
-0.1185287461,
-0.4729395807,
-0.3320477009,
-0.8449095488,
0.4050374329,
-0.0269715209,
-0.1726591289,
0.117032513,
0.1981792897,
0.5478781462,
-0.3928683698,
0.7566768527,
-0.0568278395,
-0.15258874,
0.3997045755,
0.3591596782,
0.5396797657,
-0.0852201059,
-0.3152009547,
-0.3331413865,
-0.3563027382,
-0.110680975,
-0.4935819209,
0.6744060516,
-0.5269617438,
-0.5692683458,
-0.2314503044,
-0.7482296824,
-0.2510000169,
-0.3703727424,
0.3596088886,
0.4367630482,
-0.4307223856,
-0.2021018863,
0.6861456633,
-0.1463745087,
0.4368694723,
0.7387496829,
0.0306597054,
-0.3569092751,
0.5569885969,
-0.1955090761,
0.4760391116,
0.1406900734,
-0.0701921955,
0.0189363342,
0.0989627913,
-0.2088234276,
0.2318694592,
-0.4873029888,
-0.4155380428,
-1.2340708971,
-0.2197883129,
-0.1710454226,
-0.1907797307,
-0.3946456313,
-0.1210426167,
-0.29722628,
-0.1777228564,
0.8940307498,
0.5146002173,
-0.2093837857,
0.3683497906,
-0.8264166117,
0.6066296101,
0.2449312508,
0.0834214389,
0.5229536295,
-0.653429985,
0.022512123,
0.0829891413,
-0.5915682912,
-0.8281357884,
0.6867042184,
0.2058847845,
0.2643846571,
0.3772774637,
-0.1155273393,
0.8203935027,
-0.5704447031,
0.6100808978,
0.3703501821,
-0.7982010245,
0.6269094348,
-0.1628754139,
0.5008812547,
0.5717281103,
0.1971966624,
-0.5958593488,
-0.6290800571,
-0.7561153769,
-1.0878335238,
0.7427744865,
0.1881636232,
0.3319348991,
-0.3689379394,
0.4545351565,
0.0463295244,
0.1988765299,
-0.3040560186,
-0.2459103763,
0.1499539912,
-0.4083142877,
-0.095828481,
-0.2697642744,
-0.5521197319,
-0.0018640008,
0.3941673636,
-0.1662251651,
1.0485887527,
0.2262695134,
-0.0276554879,
-0.7484899759,
-0.0756197199,
0.2838711441,
-0.0205048732,
-0.236076057,
0.0423126258,
0.1483980566,
-0.1693805307,
0.1803531349,
-0.0384234637,
0.2764388919,
-0.2163883597,
0.0840692297,
0.7058593631,
0.2845983207,
-0.6722682118,
0.3302118182,
-0.3475901783,
0.1323468685,
-0.3756555319,
0.0656205937,
0.3322610557,
0.5339391828,
0.0096808001,
-0.2192854136,
0.3850371838,
-0.9400649667,
0.4618935585,
0.3039304316,
-0.2635286152,
-0.2254668027,
0.5983117223,
0.0937723741,
-0.6108063459,
0.5952795148,
0.223321557,
-0.6803230643,
0.6937157512,
0.8974379897,
1.0068203211,
-0.654612422,
0.1709624827,
0.710119307,
-0.2789795995,
-0.0144382054,
0.5602270961,
-0.4920049906,
-0.6411061883,
0.3429165184,
-0.5766540766,
-0.6460748315,
-0.2389354557,
-1.1197715998,
-0.2771535516,
-0.5810607076,
-0.1263750196,
-0.20878537,
-0.2493962944,
-0.7606902122,
0.375500232,
0.1057728827,
0.7068517804,
-0.7586024404,
0.3692176342,
0.325548768,
-0.4517714381,
-0.7996715307,
0.2282801718,
0.0806772038,
-1.16291821,
0.2658465505,
0.3827120662,
-0.2234060466,
0.3009262383,
-0.3359556496,
-0.7366804481,
1.328953743,
-0.2509625852,
-0.5504369736,
-0.0149470251,
-0.1193520054,
0.7058643103,
-0.8744968772,
0.6056423783,
0.8842278123,
0.2390605062,
0.3082593381,
-0.6203902364,
0.1511234045,
-0.3840129077,
0.1894367486,
0.1481769979,
-1.169190526,
0.7006361485,
-0.5931941867,
-0.07772284,
0.7071377039,
0.2699838579,
0.6089238524,
0.5748996139,
0.1341021359,
0.789945066,
0.4233411551,
0.1030527204,
1.0758923292,
-0.4145756662,
0.0574062653,
1.3469855785,
-0.3951100707,
0.9324885011,
0.7228053808,
0.2970225811,
0.2503250837,
0.5596808195,
0.2701694369,
0.8196855187,
0.06751398,
-0.5834559798,
-0.0762624294,
-0.4093001485,
-0.1034902185,
0.6496702433,
0.4925059676,
-0.8365681171,
-0.1095494404,
0.1474601775,
-0.0384198762,
-0.0911323801,
-0.4171562493,
1.3235856295,
0.4882271588,
-0.9418269992,
0.2188026309,
-0.2890972793,
0.1981060356,
-0.3256372213,
-0.20504345,
-0.4591976404,
0.2204343677,
0.1852536201,
-0.7227660418,
0.1628163457,
0.119757846,
-0.1588698477,
0.0353066437,
0.5864616036,
-0.7530360818,
-0.1585666239,
0.6688277125,
0.319535166,
-0.150223285,
0.3407536745,
-0.583589673,
0.0758826807,
-0.0606178865,
-0.5481866002,
0.1844407171,
0.4750063717,
0.419836849,
0.7551115155,
0.1498368382,
-0.3174298108,
-0.0483651608,
-0.0012201852,
0.939724803,
-0.8831839561,
-0.5495995283,
-0.7510799766,
0.6842340827,
0.0688064024,
-0.2129541188,
0.2847823501,
-0.028686339,
0.2993146181,
0.0664311945,
0.7816364765,
0.0553874522,
0.4144358039,
-0.5666113496,
0.1655985266,
-0.5229272842,
-0.0251998696,
-0.1913631558,
-0.772211194,
-0.032308273,
0.841704905,
-0.2435746342,
0.1555334181,
0.6675289273,
0.7994529009,
0.0819766298,
0.2729125321,
0.2750899792,
0.6042812467,
-0.0137107214,
1.065112114,
0.7442574501,
-0.4777524769,
0.1584191769,
-0.003176227,
-0.0849741548,
-0.2827511728,
-0.5078395605,
-0.8501007557,
-0.4973810315,
-0.1091368794,
-0.5657253265,
0.0144301411,
0.9983686805,
0.0765064135,
-0.4824935198,
-0.0268397965,
-0.3031921387,
-0.5065312386,
0.1690943241,
-0.2669472396,
-0.1038901806,
-0.0971997008,
-0.6437593699,
-0.0992464498,
0.7207975984,
0.1100281924,
-0.2081218511,
-0.3056126833,
-0.1212885007,
0.5444126129,
0.4304376245,
0.3866595924,
-0.5960971117,
-0.2151859552,
-0.1409812868,
-0.1008929163,
0.2763611078,
0.9850234389,
-0.5422083139,
0.7724349499,
0.073310785,
0.5118154883,
0.4643905461,
0.140339613,
0.9008421302,
-0.4878806472,
0.034871392,
0.3241093755,
0.3496444225,
0.4656834602,
-0.5210075974,
0.372307539,
-0.3106721938,
-0.4957951903,
-0.5707192421,
0.4750953615,
-1.198879838,
0.1765265465,
1.2888883352,
-0.324790895,
-0.2618186176,
0.251637727,
-0.5195659399,
0.6067754626,
-0.6065637469,
1.1141653061,
0.5981515646,
-0.5788784623,
-0.4823372662,
0.019911183,
0.2183360308,
0.5500515103,
-0.7808601856,
0.2523302734,
0.4788620174,
-0.0349593684,
0.1985328496,
1.0007770061,
-0.0311922729,
0.5649012327,
0.102699779,
-0.1468642205,
0.5357003212,
-0.1909359694,
-0.3978491724,
-0.0484121703,
-0.1224774942,
-0.0412431993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17954v2
|
Twists, Humps, and Pebbles: Multilingual Speech Recognition Models Exhibit Gender Performance Gaps
| 2024-02-28T00:24:29 | 2024-06-19T13:42:48 |
Giuseppe Attanasio, Beatrice Savoldi, Dennis Fucci, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current automatic speech recognition (ASR) models are designed to be used
across many languages and tasks without substantial changes. However, this
broad language coverage hides performance gaps within languages, for example,
across genders. Our study systematically evaluates the performance of two
widely used multilingual ASR models on three datasets, encompassing 19
languages from eight language families and two speaking conditions. Our
findings reveal clear gender disparities, with the advantaged group varying
across languages and models. Surprisingly, those gaps are not explained by
acoustic or lexical properties. However, probing internal model states reveals
a correlation with gendered performance gap. I.e., the easier it is to
distinguish speaker gender in a language using probes, the more the gap
reduces, favoring female speakers. Our results show that gender disparities
persist even in state-of-the-art models. Our findings have implications for the
improvement of multilingual ASR systems, underscoring the importance of
accessibility to training data and nuanced evaluation to predict and mitigate
gender gaps. We release all code and artifacts at
https://github.com/g8a9/multilingual-asr-gender-gap.
|
[
-0.2123960108,
-0.2515502274,
0.1423315555,
0.2088838369,
0.2352396697,
0.5134171247,
-0.0755050406,
-0.7176033854,
-0.4978505969,
0.0749640539,
-0.5343109369,
-0.0072654379,
-0.9884262085,
0.2876208127,
-0.5541377068,
0.5200651288,
0.2032574713,
0.5599333644,
-0.1304086745,
-0.1289629936,
-0.7212189436,
-0.4942735732,
-0.3162195683,
-0.5925497413,
0.2388486266,
0.1895491928,
0.7406680584,
0.6914455891,
0.4318175018,
0.3125865757,
-0.4842122495,
0.1154728532,
-0.0628220439,
0.0854662806,
0.2148159295,
-0.0675913319,
-0.2711865604,
-0.0475791432,
0.9981718659,
1.0485197306,
-0.2453053147,
0.0336372778,
0.4078190029,
0.6665782332,
-0.500097394,
0.1390179545,
-0.4730378687,
0.1311855316,
-0.5102266669,
-0.0329508856,
-0.091646269,
-0.1779966205,
0.3432454467,
-0.212987572,
0.5318715572,
-0.1349263638,
0.7188909054,
0.2111165822,
-0.5389582515,
-0.5471335053,
-0.9398393631,
0.6157937646,
-0.505012691,
1.0926588774,
0.4669625759,
0.4688291252,
-0.0879522339,
-0.1369478852,
-0.3163978755,
-0.2642471194,
0.1090345159,
-0.4129746854,
-0.2920652628,
-0.313739717,
0.400570482,
0.4420256019,
-0.7663357258,
0.1596010327,
-0.7041540742,
-0.081575118,
0.5700232983,
-0.0943334252,
0.3792678118,
0.2098575383,
-0.0386377089,
-0.0961020291,
-0.7158011794,
0.4795928299,
0.7609533072,
0.9960456491,
-0.4040143788,
0.5473953485,
0.1819586605,
0.61908108,
0.057004299,
-0.328217566,
0.4557187557,
-0.0255106222,
0.1921888739,
0.3246543705,
0.6271532774,
-0.2135272622,
0.2887999117,
-0.175524205,
-0.1698086262,
0.0356677733,
-0.0555979274,
-0.458578974,
-0.3055115342,
-0.219384402,
-0.1884181947,
0.2979466915,
-0.0417331904,
-0.5238358378,
-0.7292760611,
-0.2775416076,
0.1900643855,
-0.2470056415,
-0.4505076706,
0.2128180116,
-0.4011867344,
0.0544202588,
0.100660108,
-0.9738668799,
0.6415391564,
0.5869681835,
0.7553385496,
0.3619346023,
-0.5326060653,
-0.4500219226,
0.0856645778,
-0.2105978876,
0.6438111067,
-0.7663893104,
-0.7173822522,
-0.1351096034,
-0.1214007437,
-0.3830288947,
-0.6576992273,
0.1023564264,
-0.0544007234,
0.1424024254,
-0.432025224,
-0.3197288215,
-0.0885481164,
-0.0949275419,
-0.7142198086,
0.9491073489,
-0.477843225,
-0.5773752928,
0.4826546609,
-0.5401795506,
-0.3104035258,
-0.0472532958,
-0.5466372371,
-0.476177007,
0.03020305,
0.1354783326,
-0.0282807499,
-0.3438394666,
0.2337735295,
-0.0625246912,
-0.3710285723,
0.3836992085,
-0.5918123126,
0.662297368,
0.0242709816,
-0.4313470125,
0.0557399727,
-0.5892986059,
-0.3503472805,
-0.0705641285,
-0.4305965602,
-0.125080049,
0.2896243334,
0.1755375266,
0.323330164,
-0.1419233382,
-0.4833368361,
-0.1142993942,
-0.2039150894,
0.4666928053,
0.4878824651,
-0.795383811,
0.3485418558,
-0.1908872575,
0.4023573697,
0.0351655073,
-0.0690414011,
-0.1448255181,
-0.7246886492,
-0.5572980642,
-0.368824631,
0.5793731809,
0.3250999451,
-0.3636846244,
0.0149750067,
-0.3242793381,
-0.2681332827,
-0.7043498158,
0.0118943807,
0.8024895787,
0.3236326873,
0.1711829305,
-0.2786640227,
-0.3419758976,
-0.8837061524,
-0.6434848905,
-0.2397462577,
-0.1037661955,
0.3576098979,
0.3827314973,
-0.1245390847,
0.6590980291,
-0.1206339747,
-0.2057829797,
-0.3565606773,
0.3430904746,
0.1308996528,
0.5377801061,
0.3812014759,
-0.9723131657,
-0.1816134602,
-0.123349756,
-0.4059254229,
0.0442927107,
0.2802686095,
0.361537993,
0.3482908607,
0.2382059544,
-0.256731987,
0.476077795,
0.6836618185,
-0.7021080256,
0.4689479172,
-0.1948672831,
0.3457439244,
-0.3383852541,
0.0063371435,
0.0382585526,
-0.3233041763,
-0.8130748272,
-0.0718531162,
0.1992754042,
-0.2642154098,
-0.2128555179,
0.5023115277,
-0.7451020479,
-0.5892832875,
-0.1290434301,
-0.0877298564,
-0.189861998,
-0.0435622111,
0.0405841582,
0.9929571152,
0.5312511325,
-0.8369709849,
-0.2927966714,
0.4702475965,
-0.121319823,
0.2275723517,
-0.5765755177,
0.2158756256,
-0.0844522491,
0.00114167,
-1.125361681,
-0.2463323325,
0.1179938838,
-0.7497317195,
0.8463024497,
-0.2973200083,
-0.2391907573,
-0.5144199133,
-0.1427970678,
0.7036322355,
0.2922303379,
-0.4674242437,
0.6420269012,
0.7196524739,
-0.2845953703,
-0.6936299205,
-0.7865350842,
0.1386394054,
-0.1567137837,
-0.6006332636,
0.0835858509,
-0.0568822287,
-0.167147696,
-0.4933918715,
-0.2115416974,
-0.3728549182,
0.2025035322,
0.4134878218,
-0.143639937,
-0.1119490042,
0.2818858922,
-0.2575897574,
-0.1351119727,
-0.164518103,
0.1609291434,
0.7362380624,
-0.3944079876,
-0.5335832834,
-0.3733331263,
0.4566304386,
0.5136917233,
-0.3453031182,
0.4710451066,
0.558475554,
-0.6278541088,
0.1998524219,
-0.5992953777,
-0.1173360571,
-0.4527544379,
0.1596894711,
-0.7864518166,
-0.9164105058,
0.69765836,
0.2777210176,
-0.0955100134,
0.3234041333,
0.2347180098,
-0.1609567702,
1.0960450172,
0.7688179016,
-0.0866190195,
0.3296067417,
0.0307014771,
0.2352816463,
-0.7331760526,
-0.4183764756,
-1.0311837196,
-0.1698268205,
-0.9025825858,
-0.3312293887,
0.3455579579,
-0.0161537286,
-0.3142451346,
-0.0644578785,
-0.2290954292,
0.3046748936,
0.5577219725,
-0.2162230611,
0.3245353401,
-0.0397859961,
0.2360082269,
-0.3603161573,
-0.7345089912,
-0.5289595723,
0.7934629321,
0.6408699751,
0.5821102262,
0.3699056208,
0.3080196679,
0.4741623402,
-0.3903353512,
-0.3994483054,
0.1190747991,
-0.5246317387,
-0.7476683259,
-0.371117264,
-0.5636945963,
-1.0485781431,
0.3247953057,
0.0472869799,
-0.6010478139,
0.4435712397,
0.2788060308,
-0.1659258306,
0.3296405077,
-0.3196790218,
0.6180945635,
-0.2406533062,
-0.1263147444,
0.027468564,
-0.6861776114,
0.3152691722,
0.0432823934,
0.4441733062,
-0.4282647967,
0.3479320705,
0.7204654217,
-0.0345456935,
0.5122536421,
-0.301569432,
-0.111391753,
-0.2640461922,
0.0449402705,
-0.0238051154,
-0.2311662585,
0.0087869391,
0.7677314878,
-0.2124297917,
-0.2933820486,
-0.0024682155,
0.4541379213,
-0.7867658734,
-0.300191313,
-0.6646653414,
-0.5707770586,
-0.2336630523,
0.0434881784,
0.2324525416,
0.7953218222,
-0.020606786,
-0.0713777244,
0.6387633681,
-0.4675938189,
0.4679349959,
0.5647215247,
-0.180878371,
-0.0731906965,
0.6852883697,
0.3502381742,
0.1197446957,
0.1238471642,
0.2213840038,
-0.658228755,
-0.4839537144,
-0.867993772,
0.2379589379,
-0.3984639347,
-0.0036649066,
-0.7592462301,
-0.2183408439,
-0.6584993601,
0.0897708982,
-0.623806417,
-0.5624860525,
-0.0415263921,
0.1834230274,
0.3116123378,
0.9037078619,
-0.0847818181,
0.2025248557,
-0.6778441072,
0.5252529979,
0.23410891,
0.4021557271,
-0.0356824324,
-0.7336078882,
0.022678325,
0.2857673466,
-0.2480062097,
-0.7916628718,
0.5390980244,
0.6200264096,
0.4816100895,
0.0932325497,
-0.327067256,
0.9838169217,
-0.8542782068,
0.7463681698,
0.2239340544,
-1.2309288979,
0.3239815831,
-0.5890391469,
0.4150402546,
0.3195673823,
0.1819602102,
-0.6520389318,
-0.4363644421,
-0.2188916057,
-1.0420261621,
0.9223187566,
0.3542220891,
-0.000741207,
0.3185801506,
0.0648917034,
0.3501760662,
0.6038290858,
-0.6734068394,
-0.3866744936,
-0.1160411313,
0.0247784164,
-0.1577331871,
-0.3049726486,
-0.0003500738,
-0.2393064797,
0.605701983,
0.0483121611,
0.4729906321,
-0.1976397187,
-0.3482158184,
-0.1945072412,
0.3710542023,
0.7286732793,
0.7436189055,
-0.1264261603,
0.2004035115,
0.0950921699,
-0.5185803771,
0.2732417881,
0.4220881164,
0.1429717243,
0.2597347796,
0.3706279695,
0.7520058751,
0.4497644007,
-0.6179197431,
0.2313791811,
-0.3828234375,
0.0002532697,
-0.3588882685,
-0.1786161363,
0.0016811402,
0.4546040595,
0.4463067353,
0.1701449603,
0.6121596098,
-0.5513033867,
0.0452655517,
0.3391070366,
-0.4703130424,
-0.2436175197,
0.7292228341,
0.1714285612,
-0.4650443494,
0.737793684,
-0.025386354,
-0.6394450068,
0.5137620568,
0.4570548832,
0.772187531,
-0.8580799103,
0.0975914747,
0.2833743393,
0.4452759027,
-0.2154910117,
0.4564278424,
0.0805806294,
-0.5224250555,
-0.0574265644,
-0.4801356792,
-0.2938227654,
-0.0863813162,
-0.7859464288,
0.3070615828,
-0.158147648,
-0.1869278252,
0.171094507,
-0.2096654326,
-0.6360731125,
0.0692559555,
0.6732180715,
0.6331940293,
-0.916041851,
0.4467933476,
0.6397128701,
-0.0677219257,
-0.6201375723,
0.0617464483,
0.3606235385,
-0.4545550048,
0.5634033084,
0.5389543772,
-0.6254894137,
-0.4658616185,
0.1577984542,
-1.0071116686,
0.6862411499,
0.5562694669,
-0.7625451088,
0.0346646681,
0.6767483354,
0.4075845778,
-0.13265571,
0.3374774158,
0.487814188,
0.3903979659,
-0.0553599708,
-1.5920151472,
-0.4432141483,
-0.3632843196,
0.2024898231,
0.3056299388,
-0.3965358138,
1.1482203007,
-0.200065434,
-0.3067780137,
0.0828594565,
0.3067292273,
0.5954142809,
0.6011402607,
0.5642505288,
0.1745744944,
0.8941245079,
-0.4638042152,
1.1466584206,
-0.0443867184,
0.0571849719,
1.1297920942,
-0.3876179159,
0.7728226185,
0.1261315048,
-0.3923283815,
0.1177120954,
0.5774619579,
0.2786686122,
0.35078004,
0.0349485427,
-0.1205186546,
-0.3115172684,
-0.1619479656,
-0.7263585329,
0.7509060502,
0.3312503099,
-0.2307890356,
-0.0896013975,
0.1355706751,
0.0354346372,
0.1130140051,
-0.2794450819,
0.6432440281,
0.087240994,
-0.0302925892,
0.5447992086,
0.0354278013,
0.6097763777,
-0.6814129353,
-0.0193795599,
0.0895670205,
0.3067610562,
-0.1902201474,
-0.5401323438,
0.235529989,
0.3296844363,
-0.4852411747,
-0.1774689406,
0.6679211855,
-0.6715997458,
-0.6925461292,
0.5331190825,
0.5959496498,
0.2719743848,
0.0479501598,
-0.6952429414,
0.116964519,
-0.1315183789,
0.1582851708,
0.316105336,
0.1562319547,
-0.2540770173,
0.8601168394,
0.4809913933,
0.0802473873,
0.4855899215,
0.4139730036,
0.6149148941,
-0.5436315536,
-0.6323455572,
-0.8403659463,
0.6116891503,
0.1849580556,
-0.3426359594,
0.7820498943,
0.7814542055,
0.8548462391,
0.0472257696,
0.4993629754,
0.2992511392,
0.8559165597,
-0.3833442032,
0.903457582,
-0.5531080365,
0.3932434916,
-0.5694547892,
-0.6458752751,
-0.3801190555,
0.7702370286,
-0.2555197179,
0.4270711243,
0.1917352527,
0.5453551412,
-0.273900032,
0.1401970685,
0.3061604798,
0.0506322496,
0.3649667501,
0.1297444105,
1.2255328894,
-0.5840627551,
0.17429474,
-0.025487151,
0.032270506,
-0.1257619113,
-0.6636464,
-0.6420363188,
-0.6093913317,
-0.4206922352,
0.0779871866,
0.4129837155,
0.7242509723,
0.8261913657,
-0.7243068814,
-0.8191540241,
0.1445930004,
0.0517343991,
-0.2051854432,
-0.0916025937,
0.1049007699,
-0.1125891656,
-0.7359419465,
0.5231932402,
0.0193916727,
0.0758443475,
0.0502612256,
-0.3782161176,
-0.1548438668,
-0.1998898238,
0.1952420175,
0.3496675789,
-0.8865658641,
0.0506047606,
-0.1935092509,
0.2811749279,
0.1562732905,
0.8683516979,
-0.5962387323,
0.4906582236,
0.2497308403,
0.3762103915,
0.2898004949,
-0.1899954975,
0.7241624594,
-0.9764297605,
0.1907690167,
0.1781767905,
0.4096156359,
0.8253020644,
-0.1681215912,
0.3101752698,
0.0060075331,
-0.4084633887,
-1.2320202589,
0.1543304622,
-0.486756444,
-0.3311676383,
0.9983603358,
0.011373762,
0.2845803499,
-0.3083302081,
0.0458333045,
0.292653352,
-0.5632505417,
0.7528911233,
0.6101918221,
-0.2390777469,
-0.1651922464,
-0.6917731166,
0.595502317,
0.1669725925,
-0.3421050012,
0.2567538917,
0.6093147993,
0.3186808825,
0.2225022763,
0.4476510882,
-0.2465086281,
0.4463307858,
0.017240135,
0.2515171468,
-0.0786948204,
-0.8466123939,
-1.0565220118,
-0.0629557818,
0.3048345745,
-0.225852862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14659v1
|
Social Intelligence Data Infrastructure: Structuring the Present and Navigating the Future
| 2024-02-28T00:22:42 | 2024-02-28T00:22:42 |
Minzhi Li, Weiyan Shi, Caleb Ziems, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems become increasingly integrated
into human social life, these technologies will need to increasingly rely on
social intelligence. Although there are many valuable datasets that benchmark
isolated dimensions of social intelligence, there does not yet exist any body
of work to join these threads into a cohesive subfield in which researchers can
quickly identify research gaps and future directions. Towards this goal, we
build a Social AI Data Infrastructure, which consists of a comprehensive social
AI taxonomy and a data library of 480 NLP datasets. Our infrastructure allows
us to analyze existing dataset efforts, and also evaluate language models'
performance in different social intelligence aspects. Our analyses demonstrate
its utility in enabling a thorough understanding of current data landscape and
providing a holistic perspective on potential directions for future dataset
development. We show there is a need for multifaceted datasets, increased
diversity in language and culture, more long-tailed social situations, and more
interactive data in future social intelligence data efforts.
|
[
-0.3448362947,
-0.6964111328,
0.1722991318,
0.2266970426,
0.1129470542,
0.5765060782,
-0.030561164,
-0.8062533736,
0.4128323495,
0.3961052299,
-0.6884584427,
-0.545343101,
-0.5440322161,
-0.0679445043,
-0.5569965839,
0.8599840403,
0.575319171,
-0.1081826016,
-0.6991177201,
-0.3669761121,
-0.4081475139,
-0.642664969,
-0.7418567538,
-0.4192271233,
0.6451516151,
0.6654279828,
1.0178047419,
0.6573807001,
0.5076184273,
0.307618767,
-0.1020381004,
0.1891896129,
-0.5408917665,
0.0627394691,
-0.1787318885,
-0.1221423969,
-0.692129612,
-0.1512850374,
0.5232510567,
1.0333014727,
0.0957495868,
0.6098075509,
0.127161786,
0.9925165176,
-0.3929851651,
0.4524233639,
-0.427316457,
-0.1380431801,
-0.5549317598,
0.0587206073,
0.0104128541,
-0.2953309417,
0.2144035846,
-0.3225648105,
-0.2297563553,
0.2103310227,
0.524952352,
0.2040846348,
-0.3143955171,
-0.051645942,
-0.8514883518,
0.6505493522,
-0.3574615121,
0.3521614969,
0.3339579999,
0.3801150024,
-0.0985740572,
-0.8243584037,
-0.3191435337,
0.1239259243,
0.1397077739,
-0.1714303344,
0.0069333147,
-0.3316333294,
-0.1250752807,
0.1539697796,
-0.5159260035,
0.1170820072,
-0.6764335036,
0.0581586398,
1.0564126968,
0.3869802356,
0.4058426023,
-0.103725642,
-0.0236466471,
0.1020141169,
-0.6903605461,
0.0026354517,
0.3375556171,
0.4611509144,
-0.3009974658,
0.5591979623,
-0.4375361204,
0.233425051,
-0.3922657669,
0.3373920321,
0.5446003079,
-0.5955175161,
0.0459268056,
0.0343146324,
0.6936429739,
0.4711468518,
0.5142968297,
-0.4521324933,
-0.0156927649,
0.2017911971,
0.308062911,
-0.3180855513,
-0.2361200452,
0.4504042268,
-0.4757245183,
-0.2619502246,
-0.3074827194,
-0.8578163981,
-0.6588740945,
-0.6230345368,
-0.1587163806,
-0.401766628,
-0.4044244587,
-0.0197888594,
-0.3944316804,
0.3030378819,
-0.0328764468,
-0.705833137,
0.5294957757,
1.0612684488,
0.9822494984,
-0.0633276775,
-0.4969415963,
-0.265067935,
0.1622282416,
-0.2413419783,
0.8963817358,
-0.6408955455,
-0.1970416158,
0.3181318939,
0.0087132128,
0.2269502431,
-0.2345050275,
0.2676999867,
-0.4342445135,
-0.2323523611,
-0.3473113477,
-0.4221643507,
0.0843656734,
0.2730906308,
-0.9111081958,
0.9702349901,
0.0117889047,
-0.8062111735,
0.4130304158,
-1.0350806713,
-0.6791052222,
0.4536110461,
-0.1691370606,
-0.1771677732,
-0.0291124582,
0.1137072071,
0.4829500914,
-0.3800867498,
0.5779262781,
-0.8859997988,
-0.3835921884,
0.0893330351,
-0.2692086995,
1.1655939817,
0.0028051019,
-0.1502564549,
-0.0091257431,
-0.8138294816,
-0.2911447883,
0.154181987,
0.0635105148,
-0.3363270462,
0.5963431597,
0.0728907883,
0.0436845459,
0.534322679,
-0.4908911288,
0.0034221292,
-0.4030220211,
0.6132729053,
0.989592731,
-0.248021543,
0.6318076253,
-0.4336121082,
0.3371489346,
-0.2753829062,
0.4955543876,
0.4298472703,
-0.8274437785,
-0.563957274,
0.3014488518,
0.0751743987,
0.6945246458,
-0.7891175151,
0.4043318629,
-0.8134744763,
-0.7443203926,
-0.4171867073,
0.0366379768,
-0.1374276876,
0.1105121896,
0.211329937,
-0.0564494804,
-0.6245926619,
-0.8964092731,
-0.1910363138,
-0.3687636256,
0.0340565071,
0.2160052806,
0.5771916509,
-0.2666766942,
1.100818634,
-0.1099418253,
-0.0464135408,
-0.5750290155,
0.0114376433,
0.1394723654,
0.3154331744,
0.331462115,
-1.0098019838,
-0.1889920235,
0.0755074546,
-0.9452844858,
0.1406766176,
0.2040098459,
-0.2872977555,
-0.1624532938,
0.4352832139,
-0.5229451656,
0.458262682,
0.3918688297,
-0.4488832057,
0.1598056108,
0.148048088,
-0.0956504866,
-1.0177584887,
0.2892373204,
-0.1257597059,
0.1065804958,
-0.8867842555,
-0.1526575238,
-0.2610836327,
-0.2704793811,
-0.2515192032,
0.8015221953,
-0.2344983965,
-0.348177731,
0.3061155677,
0.1153721213,
-0.2164372802,
0.3221260905,
-0.2890838981,
0.4725193381,
0.5911439061,
-0.4924310148,
0.589692235,
0.4261437058,
-0.426507622,
0.5255106688,
-0.8866798878,
0.2670932114,
-0.3003949821,
0.0616455302,
-0.5856724381,
-0.454616189,
0.1783797592,
-0.5921143889,
-0.0601209439,
0.1713501066,
-0.6207764745,
-0.3584893644,
-0.42099455,
0.3183376491,
0.1624110043,
-0.2791776359,
0.8232117295,
1.1435592175,
-0.5150715709,
-0.633225143,
-0.6599612832,
0.506024003,
-0.1700877994,
-0.8605713248,
0.3453732729,
-0.0593768507,
-0.6104435325,
0.198840335,
0.3889108002,
-0.0445581451,
0.390889436,
0.4661291838,
0.3195945323,
-0.0438569263,
0.3025427461,
-0.0310578328,
-0.2049190849,
0.3384800851,
-0.0566814058,
0.5898343921,
-0.1338933259,
-0.3133317828,
-0.0745267719,
0.6803433895,
0.7361136079,
-0.5034743547,
0.7717112303,
0.5349932313,
-0.6781997085,
0.0414993688,
-0.2885502279,
0.2245056629,
-0.4452367723,
0.3861040473,
0.107597746,
-0.8403192163,
0.7406995893,
0.0957547203,
0.5264925957,
0.2520964444,
0.3844333887,
-0.1596840918,
1.0794360638,
0.6644038558,
-0.6502440572,
0.4284153283,
-0.1517931968,
0.5740023255,
-0.482234776,
-0.3291256428,
-0.5732065439,
-0.4990308881,
-0.5722277164,
0.0813190714,
0.070867084,
-0.5503043532,
-0.3181042671,
-0.0244934335,
-0.4287906587,
0.2716726065,
0.6086171269,
-0.0091792308,
0.0099720769,
-0.122923471,
0.6099247336,
0.3143775165,
-0.6167111397,
-0.6330925226,
1.1095827818,
0.3512098789,
0.4044308662,
0.1426526755,
0.4943780005,
0.6900103688,
0.3931016624,
-0.4667983949,
0.7640493512,
-0.29604581,
-0.6021214724,
-0.47012797,
-0.1684265137,
-0.9652503133,
-0.4446328282,
-0.3599164188,
-0.5272353292,
0.2793456018,
-0.1690007001,
-0.2368024439,
0.1044560298,
-0.7041866779,
0.7911598682,
-0.0981741697,
-0.2818883061,
-0.1502598822,
-0.7846961021,
0.092873998,
0.2335629165,
0.4958107173,
-0.4219191074,
0.16926606,
0.6264994144,
-0.1295621097,
0.9622072577,
-0.1170627847,
0.2961582541,
0.0953071341,
-0.5077325106,
0.2078114748,
0.1569369882,
-0.3673545718,
0.439463228,
0.0093851592,
-0.5548753142,
-0.3816771507,
0.623622179,
-0.7663777471,
-0.2581459284,
-0.2191708386,
-0.45679456,
-0.2597430944,
-0.0505761951,
-0.0900408402,
0.5785694122,
-0.3801595569,
0.6040735841,
0.4040419459,
0.0348579995,
0.3200796843,
-0.091985099,
0.0768057406,
-0.2587585747,
0.8536030054,
0.5792577863,
-0.0628060102,
0.163097322,
-0.1785633713,
-0.2894794345,
-0.582290113,
-0.180533126,
-0.0257972013,
-0.7076191902,
-0.1403701007,
-0.4990719557,
-0.364600569,
-0.7121710777,
-0.2414900512,
-0.2067911327,
-0.1533414721,
-0.1009165347,
-0.073713012,
0.6250507236,
0.9770230055,
-0.086551398,
-0.0983756408,
-0.7856963873,
0.2162013948,
0.1996875554,
0.6416342854,
0.1606283635,
0.2471203208,
-0.5013071895,
0.1292623281,
0.2733902633,
-0.8206761479,
0.2684598565,
0.3845255375,
0.5202595592,
0.0079043889,
0.1286451221,
0.6047717333,
-0.5454699397,
0.8666988015,
-0.4189269543,
-0.6325154305,
0.6415319443,
-0.3151599765,
0.2674583793,
0.7600653768,
0.2240921408,
-0.8186489344,
-0.4528677166,
-0.6555665135,
-1.0714946985,
0.3726980686,
0.1148466766,
0.2508431375,
-0.1240629852,
0.4018362463,
-0.0872516707,
0.0386653543,
-0.519852519,
-0.3624183834,
-0.1308939159,
-0.3853827417,
-0.1070682034,
-0.0278722029,
0.0244784225,
-0.2560607195,
0.5257711411,
-0.2178694308,
0.240819335,
-0.3013573587,
0.1860498935,
0.2773691118,
-0.0059420117,
-0.1577742696,
0.8580107689,
-0.1298330277,
-0.1082741842,
0.1360865533,
-0.3931773603,
-0.141873166,
0.0703414753,
-0.1019647941,
-0.1330500096,
0.3976983428,
0.3968824148,
0.1054253131,
-0.6491372585,
0.417617321,
-0.3309244514,
-0.1885324121,
-0.7776309252,
0.1919685751,
0.4248865545,
0.4130788445,
0.4172916114,
-0.0626066327,
0.1946588755,
-0.6805945039,
0.2210319489,
0.4359593391,
-0.3774669766,
-0.2058912069,
0.452593863,
0.2156173736,
-0.6983431578,
0.9208047986,
-0.1990585476,
-0.2049304843,
0.5984719396,
0.0138948821,
0.7940834761,
0.0069112387,
0.2803148031,
0.0848389789,
0.3605556488,
0.2283836901,
0.3636667728,
0.0683690459,
-0.7995208502,
-0.4755709469,
-0.4822632968,
-0.4392456114,
0.0272301286,
-0.5619561076,
0.2631261051,
-0.4342745841,
-0.1154108644,
0.1793987155,
0.1691628098,
-0.957542479,
0.2123492509,
0.2603965104,
0.9054377079,
-1.0835015774,
0.782436192,
0.6994541287,
-0.1842751652,
-0.2788154781,
-0.3813211024,
0.1339030266,
-0.7375462055,
0.3623338938,
0.2316862792,
-0.2788748443,
-0.165318802,
-0.9180406332,
-0.9497169256,
1.1841235161,
0.0895221755,
-0.0599284135,
-0.2844471335,
0.3648104668,
0.6142766476,
-0.4857344031,
-0.1511349976,
0.632610023,
0.4727323949,
-0.1909149885,
-0.2617994249,
-0.1825577915,
-1.0041358471,
0.081409812,
0.1379729062,
-0.4922215939,
0.6030907631,
0.3253730536,
-0.5453906059,
-0.147792235,
0.9162994623,
0.0574216507,
0.5772424936,
0.4025018215,
0.2168311179,
0.7754691243,
-0.0872951671,
0.774538219,
-0.4987477362,
-0.079122372,
1.0280257463,
-0.4192845523,
0.8804192543,
0.3215287328,
-0.1559067816,
0.5549021959,
0.7925171256,
0.0507226102,
0.2268848568,
-0.1454430223,
-0.0988915637,
-0.0835382268,
-0.5271465182,
-0.1368396729,
0.6425017118,
0.6977869272,
0.0720505267,
0.1194650978,
-0.1810396761,
-0.3105004728,
0.0259284563,
-0.2135343105,
0.7370712757,
-0.1987429708,
-0.4634564519,
-0.1214120388,
-0.4379019141,
0.5026211739,
-0.4852021933,
-0.0795116499,
-0.3413693607,
-0.1694319546,
-0.1343296766,
-1.0112497807,
0.769546032,
-0.1253989786,
0.0221331287,
-0.2193574756,
0.9372287393,
-0.058372207,
-0.458958745,
0.5388526917,
0.6730322242,
0.034963239,
0.1461124122,
-0.787294805,
-0.1048749909,
-0.2061072588,
0.0299439095,
0.3517135978,
0.6694889069,
0.0234108511,
1.0224941969,
0.7883937359,
0.1030322909,
-0.1460191458,
0.2967656553,
0.9503467679,
-0.6194269657,
-0.3887883425,
-0.9108676314,
0.6794508696,
-0.6372444034,
-0.5651707053,
0.4963991344,
0.3081761897,
0.5290382504,
0.5072752833,
0.7878572941,
-0.2744402289,
0.5396629572,
-0.1519487649,
0.7605996728,
-0.5571706891,
0.2613265812,
-0.10520529,
-0.5792589188,
-0.345015645,
0.2018892169,
-0.2268970162,
-0.1769284159,
0.1181892678,
0.7449864745,
0.241686821,
0.3897213042,
-0.0841279477,
-0.1185988933,
0.4344426692,
0.2557971776,
0.7930970788,
-0.1195381731,
0.3711477518,
-0.1699474603,
-0.2224954814,
-0.1196120605,
-0.6661233306,
-0.8048583269,
-0.8165007234,
-0.1298019439,
-0.0968175381,
0.239373371,
0.7641052604,
0.5794829726,
-0.5505577922,
-0.2594941854,
-0.0074164588,
0.4225612879,
-0.2065695822,
-0.2443989515,
0.1307560056,
-0.2917460203,
-0.5147624016,
0.2356660366,
0.7597506046,
-0.2985614836,
-0.6971560717,
0.0045060078,
-0.4694515765,
0.0479669981,
0.652066946,
0.2122034431,
-0.3167396188,
-0.5121545792,
0.372422576,
0.0620763861,
0.0114588076,
0.2689770162,
-0.6316761971,
0.178069517,
0.5592045188,
0.9298552871,
-0.079237245,
-0.3611595035,
0.8086161613,
-0.6214128733,
-0.1278139204,
0.2624211907,
0.2836497426,
0.4503139555,
-0.3942694366,
0.7039197087,
0.0779791698,
-0.7588172555,
-0.6993327141,
0.1185572371,
-0.5506879091,
-0.2383376658,
0.8622534275,
0.2238628119,
-0.6003171206,
-0.8389899731,
0.2205813229,
0.1971597821,
-0.4461934268,
0.8740599751,
0.9075887799,
0.0050110775,
-0.1922232807,
-0.6477584243,
0.4210396111,
0.1042682678,
-1.0513857603,
0.3263120353,
0.4304867387,
-0.3763436675,
0.4650457501,
0.8839536905,
0.0370950289,
0.0920043066,
0.1089614108,
-0.1767055541,
0.3956752121,
-0.4821392596,
-0.0251338854,
0.2707296014,
-0.1550804079,
0.0117598651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17946v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17946v3
|
SparseLLM: Towards Global Pruning for Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-02-28T00:09:07 | 2024-05-23T20:19:07 |
Guangji Bai, Yijiang Li, Chen Ling, Kibaek Kim, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The transformative impact of large language models (LLMs) like LLaMA and GPT
on natural language processing is countered by their prohibitive computational
demands. Pruning has emerged as a pivotal compression strategy, introducing
sparsity to enhance both memory and computational efficiency. Yet, traditional
global pruning is impractical for LLMs due to scalability issues, while local
pruning, despite its efficiency, leads to suboptimal solutions. Addressing
these challenges, we propose SparseLLM, a novel framework that redefines the
global pruning process into manageable, coordinated subproblems, allowing for
resource-efficient optimization with global optimality. SparseLLM's approach,
which conceptualizes LLMs as a chain of modular functions and leverages
auxiliary variables for problem decomposition, not only facilitates a pragmatic
application on LLMs but also demonstrates significant performance improvements,
particularly in high-sparsity regimes where it surpasses current
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.4018630385,
-0.9910580516,
0.460870266,
0.4528261125,
-0.3970496953,
0.1855062544,
-0.6769558191,
-0.2232786417,
0.3904643059,
0.3709079027,
-0.8977321982,
-0.4227257669,
-0.5953518748,
0.1659839451,
-0.4582261443,
0.9477508664,
-0.0036337704,
-0.2004414499,
-0.3677544892,
-0.2356311381,
-0.5078018904,
-0.8059634566,
-0.4661718905,
-0.1124647036,
0.5444421172,
0.2726746202,
0.9102358222,
0.6057193279,
0.2001107484,
0.3891534805,
-0.272865057,
0.367541641,
-0.8144437671,
0.2332663834,
0.1319402009,
-0.2914579213,
-0.359633714,
-0.1763349771,
1.0656985044,
0.9881169796,
-0.2692164481,
0.0466695912,
0.350605309,
0.3933387995,
-0.4307865202,
0.0941124856,
-0.8165817857,
-0.1252258122,
-0.0229414944,
-0.1969192773,
-0.0763770342,
-0.4361518621,
-0.0602409355,
-0.543882072,
0.4045259058,
-0.0242276564,
0.8285831809,
0.4431377649,
0.0019661274,
0.1154185086,
-0.7664282322,
0.9463271499,
-0.4238209128,
0.3220881522,
0.1933763474,
-0.1201357543,
-0.3401639163,
-0.5206951499,
-0.2559813857,
-0.1690606177,
-0.0720092356,
-0.2776225805,
-0.0986015052,
0.2583707273,
-0.0669934675,
0.4861345291,
-0.7345289588,
0.1280514002,
-0.2988065779,
-0.1806741953,
0.4180828035,
0.126365304,
0.3731380105,
0.355977416,
-0.1979863346,
0.3714316487,
-1.0644087791,
-0.4673848748,
0.3075285852,
0.4028609097,
0.224009335,
0.2778477371,
0.0850032493,
0.7673324943,
-0.4212836325,
-0.3144623935,
-0.066848889,
-0.4176873267,
-0.3546088338,
-0.1997601986,
0.6622021794,
-0.1046872512,
0.4518653452,
-0.4240390062,
-0.1465200484,
-0.0518798456,
0.1410311908,
-0.842238009,
-0.2349201292,
0.1220760867,
-0.2410413027,
-0.1691124737,
-0.1111993194,
-0.5463256836,
-0.0174037199,
-0.4497641027,
0.1879093945,
-0.1925927252,
-0.4213617146,
0.149894163,
0.4933339655,
-0.0999947116,
0.2584592402,
-1.015417695,
0.6886774302,
1.0044822693,
1.0945001841,
-0.193502754,
-0.2720732987,
-0.4935538173,
0.2235020548,
-0.2368135154,
0.6547724605,
-0.4877343476,
-0.4816863835,
-0.0193338301,
0.0588189885,
-0.3451311886,
-0.7848833799,
0.4933122098,
-0.2504277229,
-0.1880363673,
-0.0075095859,
-0.2388506383,
-0.0648074597,
0.3907391429,
-0.7211082578,
1.121776104,
0.1204246283,
-0.4317293167,
0.1476923078,
-0.1636366695,
-0.5830823779,
0.1910666078,
-0.1214575022,
-0.5152669549,
0.4313975573,
0.288723141,
0.6262916923,
-0.5488590598,
0.728510201,
-0.2391548604,
-0.5592228174,
-0.0156801846,
-0.3882567286,
0.4866078794,
0.0968804136,
0.163723886,
0.3470555246,
-0.6059775352,
0.0389447436,
0.1976357847,
-0.4466809928,
-0.268571794,
0.1011080816,
0.0775106251,
-0.0261450503,
0.1598389447,
-0.2982103527,
0.4502116144,
-0.7142724991,
0.7552310228,
0.852502346,
-0.1435194314,
0.5752746463,
-0.4463874102,
0.486491859,
-0.4752516747,
0.2114460915,
-0.1203335151,
-0.2175068259,
-0.9125563502,
-0.6109909415,
0.152093783,
0.4511528313,
-0.2103732824,
0.4862107635,
-0.386798799,
-0.2379796207,
-0.3027819395,
0.495265305,
0.1363243759,
0.0389682092,
0.3709155321,
-0.1769270748,
-0.685221076,
-0.8154239058,
-0.1066122651,
-0.0681032687,
-0.0001219565,
0.0831259489,
0.2120687664,
-0.2934718132,
1.0385403633,
-0.4481973648,
-0.5338259339,
-0.6404549479,
0.1586603373,
0.3340901434,
0.6479088068,
0.1248877123,
-0.7699556351,
-0.2888073921,
-0.1665696651,
-0.284817338,
-0.2202156633,
-0.2694192231,
0.1260834783,
0.091914922,
0.4436998665,
-0.9952859879,
0.1223479062,
0.4432747066,
0.161551863,
0.6378987432,
-0.2529338896,
-0.2789583504,
-0.8233644366,
-0.0481702685,
-0.0287196785,
-0.291798681,
-0.5554273725,
0.0975519791,
-0.2443103343,
-0.2464735359,
-0.2657163143,
0.5061917901,
-0.8835484982,
-0.1423659623,
-0.1635440439,
-0.0656335056,
-0.1315757036,
0.5956065059,
0.1757064313,
0.8217671514,
0.4579654634,
-0.5561232567,
0.1692940295,
-0.0477941073,
-0.2752135396,
-0.0322845131,
-0.6522770524,
-0.0446319208,
-0.2182692438,
0.1018210351,
-0.8367319107,
-0.0755309984,
0.1250513494,
-0.1175648123,
0.6299396157,
-0.2626691461,
-0.7013959289,
-0.1152275875,
-0.331605643,
0.5132855177,
0.5695545673,
-0.3740939498,
0.5441188216,
0.5036910772,
-0.5499710441,
-0.4509043396,
-0.4338950217,
0.2083537132,
-0.354475081,
-0.768895328,
0.4986128211,
-0.1217254102,
-0.2289033681,
-0.0930891484,
-0.3085823953,
-0.2320418656,
0.3670441508,
0.1082827076,
0.2691734731,
-0.1435720921,
0.0574271157,
-0.2247345001,
-0.2214392573,
-0.0454005301,
-0.4287621677,
0.6913145781,
-0.1145725623,
-0.2834777534,
-0.0337400809,
0.4298193157,
0.2432704121,
-0.1808259487,
0.6887760758,
0.5750267506,
-0.4311366379,
-0.5848245621,
-0.7105267644,
-0.0994184315,
-0.5018647909,
0.6227169037,
-0.1461289227,
-1.3958624601,
0.1385777593,
-0.4367308617,
0.0565375388,
-0.0229458977,
0.6559148431,
0.3206663132,
1.0174738169,
0.920674026,
-0.3555581272,
0.3811748028,
-0.2957652211,
0.3748260438,
-0.522852838,
-0.0152636375,
-0.5733708143,
-0.0791266263,
-0.1130713969,
-0.8502265811,
0.1115209013,
0.402931571,
0.0239898916,
0.2015800923,
-0.5611173511,
0.8223839402,
0.1756784618,
-0.3624415398,
0.1946290731,
0.1850202531,
-0.1539530605,
-0.2200544775,
-1.0356363058,
-0.4536897242,
0.6074461937,
0.2955777943,
0.7890296578,
-0.1287847757,
0.6428291798,
-0.0648454949,
0.6378783584,
-0.8694552779,
0.8361071348,
0.0195699465,
-0.2250526398,
-0.2790999413,
-0.5405224562,
-1.109365344,
0.5092583299,
-0.0961742923,
-0.9342800975,
-0.1940988004,
0.1280891895,
-0.2910316885,
0.4056054056,
-0.6057010889,
0.760535121,
-0.1855214983,
-0.5259434581,
-0.3540616035,
-0.3317667544,
0.5349056721,
-0.2615629435,
0.5066224337,
-0.4182354212,
-0.2030480504,
0.664336741,
-0.7555491328,
0.9582984447,
-0.0012040508,
-0.021277938,
0.2906012535,
0.2958514988,
0.4942172766,
0.2496020347,
0.2693617642,
0.2561541498,
-0.1187790036,
-0.277287811,
-0.4074270129,
0.9715096951,
-0.5627595782,
-0.804816246,
-0.4571752846,
-0.755982399,
-0.4397073388,
0.0700634271,
-0.1069157571,
0.4094755948,
-0.4363048971,
0.0346974954,
0.702832222,
-0.2480159104,
0.3412053287,
0.3634418547,
-0.0704391226,
-0.4331419766,
1.2434027195,
0.3014722466,
-0.0020606266,
0.3573057055,
0.0589924231,
-0.2079576999,
-0.9593996406,
0.0004180841,
0.4589401186,
-0.5403465629,
-0.2938426137,
-0.4516888261,
-0.2968514264,
-0.3554424942,
-0.2406867743,
-0.1502932161,
-0.3743932247,
-0.3614033163,
-0.1314003766,
0.0440546758,
0.735514164,
-0.1530597508,
0.3575409353,
-0.9398064613,
0.2448117137,
0.2332385778,
0.2900744677,
-0.0657820329,
-0.2190003544,
-0.3449727893,
-0.3106539547,
-0.1064170152,
-0.5208970904,
0.7584041357,
0.5047811866,
0.6162316799,
0.0569628365,
-0.1701634824,
0.9617349505,
-0.6539334059,
0.4766426384,
0.1991659403,
-0.7060889602,
0.2231778204,
-0.2081977427,
0.3615814745,
0.4189534783,
0.4486712813,
-0.5890259743,
-0.500957191,
-0.4758297801,
-1.2101100683,
0.6298152208,
0.089358829,
0.2894693017,
-0.1799334288,
0.2933603227,
0.055839479,
0.0926083401,
-0.8122227788,
0.0805759877,
0.2203761786,
-0.2649656534,
-0.1166364327,
-0.6683277488,
-0.1178297624,
-0.2477822453,
0.7001447082,
-0.1788203567,
0.0754692182,
0.1191988066,
-0.5149794817,
-0.0492087863,
0.3564384282,
0.3015515804,
0.6429869533,
-0.0251927208,
0.17683056,
0.2920292914,
-0.4381702244,
0.279953301,
-0.0126760909,
-0.2262846977,
-0.0985044241,
0.5541552901,
0.4105150104,
0.5682163239,
-0.7473880649,
0.3497985303,
-0.2176246643,
-0.3121154308,
-0.1873230785,
0.030570088,
0.1993523985,
-0.0580618456,
0.4938883185,
0.0852509066,
-0.221032396,
-0.1634329259,
0.0908882543,
0.5369731188,
-0.1770590246,
-0.4230432212,
0.5335134864,
0.1090469733,
-0.1893545985,
0.3709912598,
0.073646605,
-0.5696169734,
0.4595745802,
0.6444782615,
0.8597922921,
-0.1501181126,
0.0631510615,
0.4281501472,
0.5986917615,
-0.3296694458,
-0.0119158188,
-0.3621235192,
-0.658460319,
-1.015349865,
-0.9812822938,
-0.1604787409,
0.3124851882,
-0.2201515436,
0.0838498473,
-0.7889326215,
0.1040154546,
-0.4716884792,
0.0561114401,
-0.3761171997,
-0.008314156,
0.1056367308,
0.7856453061,
-0.6906132102,
1.1079041958,
0.4861510396,
-0.1249840483,
-0.6868262887,
-0.0386208817,
0.0141297327,
-0.7006397247,
0.5391548276,
0.4512586892,
-0.1577413678,
0.0554102063,
-0.4735226631,
-1.0802334547,
0.7570718527,
0.7752648592,
-0.6425383687,
-0.0003493542,
0.212909773,
0.2264157534,
-0.0794928446,
-0.1068907157,
0.667683959,
0.3697018623,
0.1548686177,
-0.8750184178,
0.0534451641,
-0.2549118996,
0.1839797944,
0.5116049051,
-0.5891546011,
0.8704422712,
-0.0577938817,
-0.6351161599,
0.297665447,
0.7369433045,
0.2090288699,
-0.4077327251,
0.4980213642,
0.6291481853,
0.7803559303,
-0.2642816305,
0.7603312731,
-0.354378432,
0.2629691064,
0.8790889382,
-0.3554517031,
0.567453444,
0.5905257463,
-0.3050115407,
0.0347734317,
0.5854258537,
0.286796689,
0.3124882579,
0.5445380807,
-0.5638412833,
-0.4326608479,
-0.2009069026,
-0.1894323379,
-0.0997254103,
0.631875813,
0.284016937,
-0.4144054055,
-0.0734715685,
0.1841290444,
0.2432221323,
-0.4755190015,
0.6718167067,
0.2254078537,
-0.5647155046,
0.9037469625,
0.2351822853,
0.9040319324,
-0.8496313691,
0.1012787148,
-0.3436686099,
0.2332869917,
-0.287416935,
-0.2446910441,
0.7361781001,
-0.0283515751,
0.0140161999,
-0.692692399,
1.0998704433,
-0.5795166492,
-0.4392870665,
0.3815838099,
0.5272619128,
0.0200035404,
-0.1128236204,
-0.7218810916,
0.3929867446,
-0.2099094689,
-0.2726243138,
0.662942946,
0.3875117004,
-0.2085175365,
0.879352212,
0.7702896595,
0.4071332216,
0.0741992891,
0.0578985102,
1.1676621437,
-0.417688787,
-0.3908179998,
-0.9749262333,
0.1806825697,
0.1146692187,
-0.1000502706,
0.784614563,
0.5343825221,
0.7903878093,
0.2049036473,
0.5937365294,
0.1305039674,
0.3841510117,
-0.5146225095,
0.4208446145,
-0.3485138118,
0.4576502144,
-0.0361708514,
-1.11292243,
-0.7182069421,
0.8030071259,
-0.2639773488,
-0.1189140454,
0.5627282858,
1.0226322412,
-0.0719855577,
-0.1489637345,
0.4094259441,
0.28213498,
0.1166864857,
0.5304613709,
0.8696315289,
0.2030909359,
0.7559124231,
-0.1024556011,
-0.053448014,
0.0642904788,
-0.8050832152,
-0.8570308089,
-0.3970044255,
-0.2031074017,
0.1417307854,
0.0420746803,
1.0383731127,
0.9629085064,
-0.7002611756,
-0.5130622387,
-0.3493924439,
0.2878977656,
-0.0368540958,
-0.1813916117,
0.1536287814,
-0.6077283621,
-0.6616268754,
0.747053802,
0.6018573642,
-0.0808113292,
-0.4852476716,
-0.2339459211,
-0.2429970056,
-0.0753614753,
0.5064430833,
0.4108235836,
-0.6371612549,
0.0372756422,
-0.3357527554,
0.1348314434,
0.0581457093,
1.1435239315,
-0.9118139744,
-0.0889574662,
0.3394311368,
0.743960917,
0.5162884593,
-0.0231987983,
0.7836829424,
-1.2210097313,
0.6665056944,
0.5122890472,
0.517070353,
0.3444558978,
-0.1442350149,
0.4795638025,
0.4984617531,
-0.5734357238,
-1.1437849998,
0.1835869998,
-0.6434067488,
-0.5615827441,
1.1709960699,
-0.1723772287,
-0.4605026245,
-0.2630199492,
-0.2779347301,
0.0020627836,
-0.0854700357,
0.3644328117,
0.629370451,
0.2708890438,
-0.2652998269,
-0.4099325836,
0.5593868494,
0.6597599983,
-0.7046411037,
0.3941850662,
0.5819693208,
0.2492770255,
-0.2142451108,
1.0320256948,
0.035972558,
-0.1932845563,
-0.2810371816,
-0.1103221625,
-0.2282043099,
-0.6224553585,
-0.5252930522,
0.4467554986,
0.2862353027,
0.3715337813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17944v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17944v4
|
Large Language Models(LLMs) on Tabular Data: Prediction, Generation, and Understanding -- A Survey
| 2024-02-27T23:59:01 | 2024-06-21T19:59:54 |
Xi Fang, Weijie Xu, Fiona Anting Tan, Jiani Zhang, Ziqing Hu, Yanjun Qi, Scott Nickleach, Diego Socolinsky, Srinivasan Sengamedu, Christos Faloutsos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recent breakthroughs in large language modeling have facilitated rigorous
exploration of their application in diverse tasks related to tabular data
modeling, such as prediction, tabular data synthesis, question answering, and
table understanding. Each task presents unique challenges and opportunities.
However, there is currently a lack of comprehensive review that summarizes and
compares the key techniques, metrics, datasets, models, and optimization
approaches in this research domain. This survey aims to address this gap by
consolidating recent progress in these areas, offering a thorough survey and
taxonomy of the datasets, metrics, and methodologies utilized. It identifies
strengths, limitations, unexplored territories, and gaps in the existing
literature, while providing some insights for future research directions in
this vital and rapidly evolving field. It also provides relevant code and
datasets references. Through this comprehensive review, we hope to provide
interested readers with pertinent references and insightful perspectives,
empowering them with the necessary tools and knowledge to effectively navigate
and address the prevailing challenges in the field.
|
[
-0.3535392284,
-0.9611163139,
0.6579419374,
0.0223705545,
0.1751513332,
0.3290947676,
-0.3271707296,
-0.1390431672,
-0.0772880912,
0.7581091523,
-0.5933012366,
-0.8072172999,
-0.3840469718,
-0.0076178531,
-0.6641800404,
0.9277694225,
-0.215601325,
0.1613502353,
-0.3695010841,
0.2550165653,
-0.4349161685,
-0.5119639039,
-0.2525027096,
-0.2251287997,
0.6449344158,
0.5851553679,
0.559514761,
0.7321509719,
0.7205351591,
0.2882991731,
-0.1941384077,
0.1944236755,
-0.6777311563,
0.4628147781,
0.1450768113,
-0.3927806318,
-0.6231725812,
-0.1651294529,
1.0560711622,
1.0854233503,
-0.4406073689,
0.3623622954,
-0.0463372916,
0.6200851202,
-0.2269600481,
0.2856722474,
-0.9788255095,
0.3072394729,
-0.4689556062,
-0.1682167202,
-0.3637104332,
-0.3361758888,
0.097522229,
-0.233736977,
0.222975105,
0.2756734192,
0.4439129531,
-0.0520489514,
-0.6163327098,
-0.3377270401,
-1.023504138,
0.929736495,
-0.744717598,
0.5209259391,
0.2139186561,
0.5936890841,
-0.4623607695,
-0.8087172508,
-0.3741118312,
-0.4000927508,
0.2430309057,
-0.0875467062,
-0.0854643956,
-0.1261604726,
0.2313957661,
0.4302101433,
-0.7382066846,
0.4581282735,
-0.4200529456,
0.0007283256,
0.6721308827,
0.7303448915,
0.266433984,
-0.0767116174,
-0.0440632477,
0.1990217865,
-1.0433071852,
-0.1108532548,
0.2263254672,
0.4166745245,
-0.2068164945,
0.6726921201,
-0.2915547192,
0.9585594535,
-0.5945701599,
-0.3059794009,
0.2159546465,
-0.5162294507,
-0.339040339,
-0.3401826322,
0.772105217,
0.2276738584,
0.0563481599,
-0.1765578091,
-0.2765337527,
-0.1349722445,
0.0503611192,
-0.5609048009,
0.0260977186,
0.2672808766,
-0.3141774833,
-0.265963316,
-0.0075513911,
-1.1061856747,
-0.5349460244,
-0.5600344539,
-0.2991936505,
0.1476971954,
-0.1833502203,
-0.0425614007,
0.4448580146,
0.2723164558,
0.3807256222,
-0.8124796152,
0.3325413167,
0.8103002906,
0.7890601754,
-0.5026604533,
-0.1900992841,
-0.2346210629,
0.1331560016,
-0.6469569206,
0.832531929,
-0.4890108407,
-0.4911221564,
0.4312199056,
-0.1113875285,
0.1338782459,
-0.7491071224,
0.5886954665,
-0.4453087747,
-0.1052512154,
-0.3516429365,
-0.5220108628,
-0.0548233241,
0.4342026114,
-0.772798717,
0.9089471102,
0.1523676068,
-0.6019935012,
0.3170299232,
-0.3766704202,
-0.1554710269,
0.0838435739,
-0.3115818799,
-0.5466858745,
0.1253498793,
0.1445901692,
0.8023458123,
-0.7552765608,
0.5914877653,
-0.3248946667,
0.0112835998,
0.449748069,
-0.1567741483,
0.3675281107,
0.418811053,
0.1060256585,
0.21684663,
-0.6794148088,
0.0465984978,
0.1752579957,
-0.3523368835,
0.2325384617,
0.325547874,
0.2726934254,
0.1838326752,
0.1509368122,
-0.3162024319,
0.3500631154,
-0.0881132558,
0.4117029607,
0.4265701771,
0.0108759077,
0.3804144561,
-0.1552079767,
0.8265126944,
-0.0165058468,
0.1111954525,
-0.0704235658,
-0.171008423,
-0.4771527648,
0.1239987239,
0.3140901923,
0.5846287608,
-0.6384684443,
0.2234809697,
-0.466632396,
-0.8696889877,
-0.2415052503,
0.3673600256,
0.287127614,
0.4273664057,
0.1105377153,
0.0160621591,
-0.7456213832,
-1.0052495003,
-0.035998933,
0.0475087799,
0.173767671,
0.4754584432,
0.5132260323,
-0.360573709,
0.8543080688,
-0.5424535275,
-0.1957141757,
-0.8753119111,
-0.1045590043,
0.4558797181,
0.2424565703,
0.3657165468,
-0.7026883364,
-0.5726184249,
0.2914997637,
-0.7340945005,
-0.0665898919,
0.0632702038,
0.1480053663,
0.1784259081,
0.5721321106,
-0.4145694673,
0.1571387202,
0.6811380982,
-0.110169813,
0.6664845347,
0.1773247868,
0.0906799883,
-1.0741465092,
0.0771870837,
0.074423641,
-0.0222894102,
-1.0359402895,
-0.0471717715,
-0.0886098593,
-0.0453490466,
-0.3536611795,
0.5133346915,
-0.7780787349,
-0.4274887443,
-0.0928849205,
0.2787413001,
-0.3540817201,
0.0242753327,
-0.1370593756,
0.7886273861,
0.6987246871,
-0.4525909424,
0.5631298423,
0.4134254456,
-0.8754789829,
0.1837382168,
-0.5291534066,
-0.1139295995,
-0.1414975077,
0.2669938207,
-0.9998247623,
-0.3048702478,
0.0708313286,
-0.4557149708,
0.4596990049,
-0.1461869329,
-0.6638042927,
-0.5814819336,
-0.1585606486,
0.2571057975,
0.3965304494,
-0.1067535654,
0.3463597894,
0.7995223999,
-0.5691823363,
-0.700688839,
-0.8334433436,
0.2852678895,
-0.3624584675,
-0.3786235154,
0.0769234523,
0.0366274714,
-0.5987557769,
-0.2908867598,
0.0270628892,
-0.048244331,
-0.073094517,
-0.0028536203,
0.3173455596,
-0.1702371687,
0.1198703125,
-0.3074443042,
0.1336143166,
0.1489006281,
0.1191582456,
0.7638869286,
-0.0002934488,
-0.1416255236,
-0.0826225132,
0.2478031516,
0.4194128513,
-0.2194340974,
0.7420201898,
0.4142775536,
-0.3066993356,
-0.4007358253,
-0.6631384492,
0.0891636312,
-0.4194706678,
0.8164096475,
-0.2979593575,
-0.9689315557,
0.7651329637,
-0.0924252272,
0.159708634,
0.2104747295,
0.9434965253,
0.0484867431,
0.7530570626,
0.5170148611,
-0.3243976533,
0.3804940283,
-0.3181354105,
0.2413901687,
-0.8860501647,
-0.4385758638,
-0.9468929768,
-0.0995213166,
-0.7099657059,
-0.4495935738,
0.3929317296,
-0.4033238888,
-0.1200870201,
-0.0561918877,
-0.2080545872,
0.1989411563,
0.0789992362,
-0.2412023395,
0.2806794047,
0.2210537642,
0.0904590338,
-0.075226754,
-0.5905334949,
-0.5496999025,
1.325319171,
0.4070366323,
1.0383753777,
0.0667853653,
0.4689042568,
0.1289124936,
0.2999480367,
-0.6949779987,
0.6629374027,
-0.0310503505,
-0.7540023923,
-0.4878272712,
-0.8263831735,
-1.1600474119,
0.2313874513,
-0.1458472908,
-0.8996428251,
-0.2815615535,
0.1438421756,
0.0813511163,
0.4812774062,
-0.3732025027,
0.8037725091,
-0.2685577869,
-0.3604357541,
-0.0190660544,
-0.4748577774,
0.5305768251,
-0.2180026621,
0.4739475548,
-0.2235083431,
-0.1231967881,
0.8408645391,
-0.0681467429,
0.5408667326,
-0.1636648774,
-0.4043051004,
0.5207685828,
0.1692478508,
0.4566891193,
-0.1182639077,
-0.1096557975,
-0.0107113998,
0.0384153165,
-0.1100319251,
-0.3823759556,
0.7974446416,
-0.5083070397,
-0.4936822057,
-0.2993882298,
-0.8422463536,
-0.6319405437,
0.0453581177,
-0.0467573628,
0.4956132174,
-0.2138929814,
0.4383531213,
0.5846582055,
-0.3122508824,
0.4037247896,
0.3869624436,
-0.6713859439,
-0.4498038292,
0.7888547182,
0.3492303491,
0.082484439,
0.4729693234,
-0.0493893921,
-0.4486038685,
-0.9864591956,
-0.2528745234,
0.3922454715,
-0.5184266567,
-0.3193331063,
-0.3931096494,
-0.1563218534,
-0.4749746919,
0.1573616117,
-0.2235991657,
-0.1636936963,
-0.2363066226,
-0.2005428672,
0.2710787356,
1.1232507229,
0.4449469447,
0.4672923088,
-0.7909950614,
0.2100406885,
-0.0045331456,
0.3745892048,
0.2529590726,
-0.4476661086,
-0.4705116749,
-0.1652087569,
-0.1634818614,
-0.9424325824,
0.5995786786,
-0.1104999334,
0.7864919901,
0.1588929743,
-0.3492019475,
0.56838274,
-0.5970901251,
0.8280625939,
0.1165577844,
-0.661552012,
0.2973197699,
-0.6736292839,
0.2416423261,
0.5450906754,
0.4291092753,
-0.6550368071,
-0.0530107319,
-0.1593946815,
-0.990657568,
0.5032164454,
-0.0621716678,
0.0303028729,
0.4481367767,
0.2692437768,
0.1931065023,
0.5590471029,
-0.8842368722,
-0.2399881929,
0.550981462,
-0.2837436497,
-0.2635754943,
-0.3407959044,
0.0838924125,
-0.2867218256,
0.6343742609,
0.0279492997,
0.1366749108,
-0.3200005889,
-0.1226416379,
-0.1447937489,
0.4988659024,
0.5369516015,
1.1316171885,
-0.0579266399,
-0.2340339869,
0.2402685583,
-0.5028418899,
0.0539567918,
0.0831768215,
-0.1912564784,
-0.1637223363,
0.2080229968,
0.8000090718,
-0.068991296,
-0.8147793412,
0.2091192454,
0.0688847378,
-0.2842173576,
-0.3880192637,
-0.2529543936,
0.2544257641,
0.1302695423,
0.3385426104,
-0.6518704891,
0.2314437181,
-0.6533996463,
-0.0317532048,
0.6143388152,
-0.1200702488,
-0.1380787194,
0.3232657313,
-0.1551387608,
-0.012598671,
0.5406637788,
0.1676162034,
-0.2670078874,
0.6059262753,
0.4952684045,
0.5377913117,
-0.2813654244,
0.1532719135,
0.1447675526,
0.1875744909,
0.0164149366,
0.45842278,
0.1105064005,
-0.6335291862,
-0.4143106639,
-0.8204283714,
-0.5601915717,
0.483881861,
-0.5493711233,
0.126236558,
-0.1749893427,
-0.257977128,
-0.0768827349,
0.1970086545,
-0.6962022781,
0.1633072048,
0.2688905001,
0.8566365838,
-0.8240288496,
0.6669233441,
0.7029739022,
-0.1731110066,
-0.742040813,
-0.2263466716,
0.0132127516,
-0.5501848459,
0.3918478787,
-0.2210287005,
0.1241968125,
-0.1214354262,
-0.477135241,
-1.0470474958,
0.9984140396,
0.1294885427,
-0.7777354121,
-0.1644981503,
0.4974201024,
0.5361381769,
-0.3892324269,
0.1213654131,
0.9194536805,
0.6159710288,
0.0007936985,
-0.8948489428,
-0.2115591615,
-0.1362485737,
0.247791931,
0.2156127095,
-0.5243400931,
0.8119087815,
-0.0429957211,
-0.0573461354,
0.2551074028,
0.696049273,
0.2932247519,
0.3214442134,
0.1577569991,
0.5097985268,
0.451494962,
-0.2620045841,
0.7418709397,
-0.1016599387,
0.4197730422,
1.0166047812,
-0.5748636723,
0.8901495337,
0.4455028474,
-0.7309542894,
0.2117034793,
0.7313594222,
-0.3252565861,
0.1168486252,
0.6212634444,
-0.0759585798,
-0.0927788466,
-0.1817463636,
-0.430167526,
0.5412862897,
0.8033480048,
-0.4543462396,
-0.3300049305,
-0.2335639149,
0.0009753421,
0.0988667756,
-0.573500514,
0.8586286306,
0.1017977446,
-0.63982445,
0.4141063988,
-0.0710119829,
0.3659648597,
-0.6189820766,
0.037098933,
-0.261226207,
-0.0042326795,
-0.2567825019,
-1.0417771339,
0.0308182612,
0.1511053443,
-0.0540412329,
-0.3332409859,
0.5381411314,
-0.4867480993,
-0.5371896625,
0.027235318,
0.9696679711,
0.2154270411,
0.3304806054,
-0.5805979967,
0.468824476,
0.0932804346,
-0.4069715738,
0.2350507826,
0.3453708589,
0.0493805856,
0.9754157662,
0.3035723567,
0.4408639669,
0.2686640918,
0.2474601269,
0.8889091611,
-0.8106998801,
-0.3108837008,
-0.8152665496,
0.4278565645,
0.0870364383,
-0.1678922921,
0.7803106904,
0.9092386961,
0.6140651107,
-0.3246025443,
0.9743754268,
0.0408488624,
0.9510553479,
-0.6739104986,
0.7473323345,
-0.5341686606,
0.2261655927,
-0.4260214865,
-1.1136105061,
-0.4611519277,
0.1168208867,
-0.4296011925,
0.2121303082,
0.5644984841,
0.8507304788,
0.1909297407,
-0.1627976745,
0.3620812595,
0.4059630036,
0.3262086213,
0.4026646912,
0.9914962649,
-0.0137969824,
0.4871739447,
0.1350370944,
0.0534302257,
-0.1947100759,
-0.6827316284,
-0.7454941869,
-0.7848729491,
-0.0444888584,
-0.0339185335,
-0.1269081384,
0.702029109,
0.5241622329,
-0.8556895852,
-0.7381834388,
-0.0841701627,
0.1001112312,
0.3536013663,
-0.1907591373,
0.3663921058,
-0.2656872869,
-0.7197957635,
0.2206289619,
0.062878795,
0.059380047,
-0.5338672996,
0.1076674834,
-0.1326614767,
-0.1073315218,
0.6316856742,
0.2978443801,
-0.6937597394,
0.2835631967,
-0.039459575,
-0.1456749737,
0.0563469827,
0.8774508238,
-0.4641623199,
0.0946155936,
0.551282227,
0.7536508441,
0.5688862205,
-0.1285173893,
0.4019451439,
-0.4952133298,
-0.1776463687,
0.2899132669,
0.5472414494,
0.572771132,
-0.1732048094,
0.5160553455,
-0.1057437658,
-0.8026314378,
-1.177107811,
0.3419013023,
-1.1722055674,
-0.0606970862,
1.3404054642,
0.1076529846,
-0.2226093858,
0.167901054,
-0.1225016266,
0.1457402557,
-0.2691168785,
0.630164206,
0.652669847,
-0.1240108386,
-0.277274698,
-0.9670163393,
0.3750602305,
0.072580345,
-1.3224838972,
0.3700716794,
0.804738462,
0.1143951192,
-0.1697463393,
0.3200032413,
-0.299108088,
-0.0814810768,
-0.2595381737,
-0.0213080216,
0.1516333222,
-0.5319896936,
-0.290712148,
0.2309255451,
0.4090670943,
0.3199582398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17938v1
|
EmMark: Robust Watermarks for IP Protection of Embedded Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T23:30:17 | 2024-02-27T23:30:17 |
Ruisi Zhang, Farinaz Koushanfar
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces EmMark,a novel watermarking framework for protecting
the intellectual property (IP) of embedded large language models deployed on
resource-constrained edge devices. To address the IP theft risks posed by
malicious end-users, EmMark enables proprietors to authenticate ownership by
querying the watermarked model weights and matching the inserted signatures.
EmMark's novelty lies in its strategic watermark weight parameters selection,
nsuring robustness and maintaining model quality. Extensive proof-of-concept
evaluations of models from OPT and LLaMA-2 families demonstrate EmMark's
fidelity, achieving 100% success in watermark extraction with model performance
preservation. EmMark also showcased its resilience against watermark removal
and forging attacks.
|
[
0.0226102918,
-1.1021074057,
0.4470178485,
-0.0132500753,
-0.5573678017,
0.4666644931,
0.2060806155,
-0.5479233861,
0.1104452461,
0.631860435,
-0.1767966002,
-0.5026583076,
-0.7827795744,
-0.4408686459,
-0.6535384655,
0.6430857778,
-0.0125720128,
-0.1555954218,
-0.1143305153,
-0.3359201849,
-0.0661094412,
-0.4232514799,
-0.8138144612,
-0.0322460905,
0.2685619891,
0.0365278199,
0.8972184062,
0.8001235127,
0.5086715817,
0.2246551812,
-0.3566017151,
-0.0679802522,
-0.1275302768,
0.5290518999,
-0.1251254976,
-0.4155181646,
-0.7243591547,
-0.1826669425,
0.7475184798,
0.1607392877,
-0.0302242264,
0.1848465055,
0.2012274861,
0.4828121662,
-1.0254204273,
-0.0399697833,
-0.8697360754,
0.048165746,
-0.7237588763,
-0.0588164777,
-0.5999667048,
-0.0576493815,
-0.2838250995,
-0.6838182211,
-0.33972013,
0.4674634337,
1.2340352535,
0.305080235,
-0.4176982343,
0.0437699147,
-0.9312674403,
1.0118021965,
-0.8031552434,
0.2436174154,
0.8399304152,
0.4705007076,
0.2202573568,
-0.8417252898,
-0.5172131658,
0.1276795715,
0.3891058564,
0.0623419061,
-0.5364163518,
-0.243472144,
0.3599337935,
0.413754642,
-0.4201762378,
0.148138836,
-0.0573114939,
-0.1376194209,
0.6587020159,
0.1380115449,
0.3489266932,
0.0885113999,
-0.514503777,
-0.0524793454,
-1.3716987371,
-0.0111522544,
0.7056270838,
0.3110768497,
-0.1756568253,
0.4556692243,
-0.1130578667,
0.5200189948,
-0.2697610259,
-0.265953511,
-0.1724060625,
0.3458622396,
-0.1308848709,
0.0648557097,
0.8643333912,
-0.0734134316,
0.2129154652,
0.198339209,
-0.3993638456,
-0.3766707778,
-0.0012697222,
-0.8512127399,
-0.128600806,
0.4222101867,
-0.5021791458,
-0.2634996772,
-0.177743569,
-0.7413439155,
-0.481228143,
0.0481632724,
0.761726737,
-0.4549043775,
-0.6564419866,
-0.027501557,
0.1834937185,
0.2518925965,
0.239647463,
-0.8533964753,
0.3105840087,
0.9143891335,
0.6471085548,
-0.0252136849,
0.1934846491,
-0.4980723858,
0.4434951544,
-0.2912660241,
0.9161456823,
-0.5706070662,
-0.3895891309,
0.0453425944,
-0.0495933816,
0.0377270319,
-0.5960162282,
0.3738393188,
-1.0784915686,
-0.1147807091,
-0.0979057699,
-0.6852703094,
-0.008881961,
0.2787301242,
-1.042840004,
1.0367513895,
0.2518563569,
-1.010160923,
0.1952349395,
-0.4489943981,
-0.4714768827,
0.5199245811,
0.1903123558,
-0.8284448981,
-0.2123012841,
0.1247713938,
0.4535667896,
-0.3774604201,
-0.0594376884,
-0.5409939289,
0.0272621624,
0.3520846665,
-0.3771316111,
1.0392397642,
0.4231036901,
-0.2875846326,
0.0217191949,
-0.9545658827,
0.1692326963,
0.474711746,
-0.189080596,
-0.94056499,
0.0946730897,
0.2175228447,
-0.2579064667,
0.3484872282,
-0.6978219151,
-0.1397975981,
0.2355502248,
0.6483794451,
0.8536570668,
-0.0346645676,
0.1751850694,
-0.1939550638,
0.8352052569,
-0.1731221974,
0.1982846558,
-0.3347314596,
-0.6705965996,
-0.5320959687,
-0.7717286944,
0.9001047015,
0.4922197461,
-0.7362680435,
0.2851980925,
-0.3908755481,
-0.3905537128,
-0.7266017795,
0.1434917301,
0.4778066278,
0.3136183321,
0.2856447101,
-0.048274301,
-0.0558097139,
-1.1632268429,
-0.1481889933,
-0.258362323,
-0.1054035798,
0.2000389993,
0.4509920478,
0.0344715975,
0.8995415568,
-0.2804993987,
-0.1223868877,
-0.341507107,
0.1128225327,
-0.0750223473,
0.6760538816,
0.4632461071,
-0.9510346651,
-0.8490687013,
0.2635616958,
-0.6816770434,
-0.111664854,
0.030999314,
-0.00379555,
0.0491681285,
0.4528914988,
-0.7118674517,
0.4437759817,
0.7924916148,
-0.3259722292,
0.549859941,
0.2343706787,
-0.0643377751,
-1.2344425917,
0.1954194903,
-0.272179544,
-0.6283037663,
-0.2449625582,
0.525342226,
0.1493648589,
-0.0416727029,
-0.5327547193,
0.8649680614,
-0.1911052465,
0.0835975781,
-0.1835397929,
-0.3507575989,
0.2772786319,
-0.0458797514,
-0.1632165164,
0.8332519531,
0.5289075971,
-0.2373015136,
0.2714225948,
0.1717926264,
-0.4471870959,
1.2247526646,
-1.015052557,
0.2328345031,
0.362727493,
-0.2151281983,
-0.7610711455,
-0.0389828496,
-0.1763547063,
-0.2056605518,
0.5883784294,
-0.6247799397,
-0.5950225592,
-0.0224009063,
-0.2831188738,
0.2976793945,
0.6822026372,
-0.5433880091,
0.9700558782,
0.5393294096,
-0.3888226449,
-0.4611447155,
-0.630302906,
0.1523212045,
-0.6370990276,
-0.7267634273,
0.623041451,
-0.0372699201,
-0.4793333411,
0.2370455563,
0.1860166341,
-0.4530188143,
0.4239414632,
0.3344510794,
-0.0531666949,
-0.3293923736,
-0.3143598139,
0.4438199401,
-0.3959029019,
-0.1299815029,
-0.0403293036,
0.416688323,
-0.0555213764,
-0.5576518178,
-0.5185988545,
0.6583836079,
0.5239757895,
-0.2709585726,
0.7739805579,
0.4881325662,
-0.7035832405,
-0.385211587,
-0.3653362095,
-0.0970548764,
-0.5452180505,
0.116155602,
-0.4610953033,
-1.1539949179,
0.7337086797,
-0.0341915786,
0.0731761679,
0.5694051385,
0.259102881,
-0.3735305965,
0.7417837977,
0.715080142,
-0.0580559,
0.4142867923,
-0.1160785705,
0.3771747947,
-1.1106914282,
0.1608464122,
-0.4176718295,
-0.2194172591,
-0.2368967682,
0.0635879636,
0.0825332925,
0.2829360366,
-0.2997738719,
0.6048687696,
-0.4160177708,
0.5016306043,
0.9425017834,
-0.0265492648,
0.3038194776,
-0.0286071021,
-0.4316245615,
-0.2398459166,
-0.341863215,
-0.695110321,
1.1482366323,
0.4687939584,
0.881314218,
0.1213605776,
0.4221708179,
0.6647108793,
0.2204632461,
-0.374666363,
0.5876649022,
0.2216144353,
-0.9804683924,
-0.2190663517,
-0.3116332889,
-1.0391966105,
-0.0147963138,
-0.1139926314,
-1.0281791687,
0.059830837,
0.1261088103,
-0.7002293468,
0.6628836393,
-0.3556834459,
0.6325613856,
-0.1156290844,
-0.9764513969,
-0.3873741925,
-0.3262287974,
0.2826267481,
-0.5025359392,
0.2158853412,
-0.3685936034,
0.3160134256,
0.7890110016,
-0.3793108463,
0.7087445259,
-0.1992650777,
-0.2232628763,
0.4948801398,
0.658693254,
0.7313553095,
0.089050971,
-0.0846592039,
0.2330886275,
0.0889724866,
-0.3407200277,
-0.2375763953,
0.4141642153,
-0.32469064,
-0.6707154512,
-0.2033977062,
-0.314960748,
0.0736289918,
0.3531441092,
0.2058433741,
0.2511025071,
-0.0333775133,
0.5375832319,
0.7211198807,
-0.5076781511,
0.7496074438,
0.4783840179,
-0.0356705859,
-0.651866436,
0.8809849024,
0.0956065878,
0.3676374257,
0.517279923,
0.1344253868,
-0.041547671,
-0.6669430733,
-0.3937250674,
-0.1563157141,
-0.7280935645,
-0.4993880987,
-0.7185103893,
-0.5536929369,
0.0121772047,
-0.2369595915,
-1.1059539318,
-0.8231253624,
0.0206668545,
-0.0918982923,
0.6886951923,
0.5775001049,
-0.1024673358,
0.8116628528,
-0.7384373546,
0.0585141927,
0.6619013548,
0.3406934142,
-0.1229624152,
-0.5115166306,
-0.4430308938,
-0.0660243705,
-0.5684877038,
-0.5056883693,
0.4190366864,
0.2143050581,
0.3610851169,
0.8827469349,
0.3523628712,
0.266908884,
-0.4966498911,
0.754471302,
-0.1365893632,
-1.1889436245,
0.4536211491,
-0.6614584923,
0.0704909414,
0.2306796908,
0.2057937682,
-0.0798157156,
-0.2572914362,
-0.6886461973,
-1.2696626186,
0.0742066056,
0.381449163,
0.3286214471,
0.3870209754,
0.0051346924,
-0.0639269575,
0.2273057252,
-0.9593580961,
0.131600067,
0.032839302,
-0.1992152035,
0.8125281334,
-0.6726439595,
-0.3461762071,
-0.1398389637,
0.8000800014,
-0.0539114922,
0.487118125,
-0.2253440619,
-0.1282922328,
-0.1871331632,
0.135041371,
0.3750305176,
0.4029393494,
-0.0954201594,
0.3683874905,
0.0353656784,
-0.4832481146,
0.070791617,
0.1939570159,
-0.2933028042,
-0.269990772,
0.8431149721,
0.4589281976,
0.0464785658,
-0.4245256186,
0.4413302839,
-0.0453984812,
0.1125419736,
-0.3675885797,
-0.013863842,
0.2631089687,
0.2699198127,
0.5946563482,
-0.5024672151,
-0.0818426013,
-0.0281965137,
0.1794346869,
0.7699175477,
-0.3047395945,
-0.7073814273,
1.1010217667,
-0.01348262,
-0.2692413926,
0.4630862772,
-0.0145157175,
-0.5778141618,
0.5850989819,
0.5661184192,
1.1795164347,
-0.6948954463,
-0.1812213808,
0.2743461132,
0.5787830353,
0.1549574286,
0.3322663009,
-0.1241833046,
-0.8220701814,
-0.1181583852,
-0.6650394797,
-0.7307219505,
0.0893271863,
-0.6385325193,
0.1746658981,
-0.884459734,
-0.4305226505,
0.0267806109,
-0.4114861786,
-0.2246226817,
-0.046126835,
0.1898613423,
0.5291912556,
-0.7350869775,
1.0294981003,
0.3613960743,
0.0467393622,
-0.480836004,
-0.2736494839,
0.1598806381,
-0.8041879535,
0.3740417361,
-0.0130682588,
0.068954289,
0.1221411601,
-0.7457993627,
-1.0971763134,
0.9903355837,
0.4207518101,
-0.3762074709,
0.5181112885,
0.284555763,
0.298255682,
-0.2644127309,
-0.081335187,
0.1488235444,
0.3576159179,
-0.1332356185,
-0.6786618233,
0.2036213428,
-0.5650225878,
-0.08022324,
0.0381085537,
-0.8243671656,
0.9264435768,
0.0734537244,
-0.3154614866,
0.1490021646,
0.3941621184,
0.3633996844,
0.0474861339,
0.2955254614,
0.7894937396,
0.6031759381,
-0.2535536289,
1.1965155602,
-0.3846262991,
0.2167740762,
0.9908159971,
-0.7019138336,
1.3072907925,
0.3825716376,
-0.3710601628,
0.5155483484,
0.5407495499,
-0.0767884329,
0.7364420295,
-0.0906151608,
-0.5456261635,
-0.3084078729,
-0.1693038195,
-0.4309259653,
0.3412106931,
0.6072522402,
-0.3361926675,
0.2374126613,
-0.1663062423,
0.4239807129,
0.0209455229,
0.0865751952,
0.5110942125,
0.4150746167,
0.0998085588,
0.5210855603,
0.1489523649,
0.4658710361,
-0.705160439,
0.1440621614,
-0.2196821421,
0.3649798334,
-0.0095409071,
-0.698261559,
0.3992016613,
-0.0619993024,
0.124042578,
-0.3360767663,
0.6922543645,
-0.0739758387,
-0.4969191849,
0.4932060838,
0.1587083489,
-0.3146488667,
-0.1834613234,
-0.6945152283,
0.3410396278,
-0.2406521589,
-0.5791759491,
0.3171265125,
0.3362691104,
-0.150623396,
0.9405876994,
0.7400530577,
-0.0160975829,
0.0022060031,
-0.430249542,
0.6259325147,
-0.4850782752,
-0.5151507854,
-1.055803895,
0.6925426722,
-0.2637099624,
-0.0815855265,
0.9823712111,
0.5164755583,
0.3973160684,
0.1148575246,
0.6819577813,
0.0063804351,
0.3499094248,
-0.5698510408,
1.2375720739,
-0.5079917908,
0.4113736749,
-0.5867323875,
-1.1521742344,
-0.5005040169,
0.5253555179,
0.0500980318,
-0.0722111091,
0.623214066,
0.7102814913,
-0.254499495,
-0.0293491688,
0.5916961432,
0.0131339515,
0.524430871,
0.3530605435,
0.9864266515,
-0.5464442372,
0.2061638087,
-0.1538644731,
-0.1803486943,
0.0405567437,
-1.1583752632,
-0.8237448335,
-0.6090228558,
-0.8113734722,
-0.422503978,
0.1890695244,
0.5486567616,
1.1224353313,
-1.1226991415,
0.0817819983,
0.3092077672,
0.2997288108,
-0.1709775925,
-0.2258544862,
0.6585213542,
0.3767609894,
-0.7223836184,
0.3464467525,
0.4963651001,
0.4650583267,
-0.1895566732,
0.1682873219,
-0.0070816888,
0.3327449858,
0.4649976194,
0.3280264139,
-0.2548283637,
-0.0019663344,
-0.3072412312,
-0.0989864692,
-0.055127088,
0.3953539133,
-0.3119319677,
0.1441082656,
0.2033072859,
0.801815927,
0.5405602455,
-0.2688053548,
0.4926836789,
-0.7616028786,
0.4861651957,
0.2326103449,
0.7156764865,
0.6404501796,
-0.3614042997,
0.4928875864,
0.2959074378,
-0.3370760381,
-1.1005895138,
0.0473719984,
-0.8441367149,
-0.102643691,
1.2291096449,
-0.532550633,
-0.3368146718,
-0.1005213857,
0.2273758948,
-0.3605680466,
-0.241025269,
0.7376870513,
0.7481153607,
0.6908940077,
-0.413297385,
-0.8387610912,
0.2952318788,
0.281055361,
-0.8363416791,
0.0450778306,
-0.0162417572,
0.3098368645,
0.1352104247,
0.3018845618,
-0.557033658,
-0.0560828745,
0.229575038,
0.3973069787,
0.0154100256,
-0.2691000104,
0.0575062037,
0.2304617167,
0.3017194867,
-0.0568727702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17936v1
|
Acquiring Linguistic Knowledge from Multimodal Input
| 2024-02-27T23:29:10 | 2024-02-27T23:29:10 |
Theodor Amariucai, Alex Warstadt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In contrast to children, language models (LMs) exhibit considerably inferior
data efficiency when acquiring language. In this submission to the BabyLM
Challenge (Warstadt et al., 2023), we test the hypothesis that this data
efficiency gap is partly caused by a lack of multimodal input and grounding in
the learning environment of typical language models. Although previous work
looking into this question found that multimodal training can even harm
language-only performance, we speculate that these findings can be attributed
to catastrophic forgetting of complex language due to fine-tuning on captions
data. To test our hypothesis, we perform an ablation study on FLAVA (Singh et
al., 2022), a multimodal vision-and-language model, independently varying the
volume of text and vision input to quantify how much text data (if any) can be
offset by vision at different data scales. We aim to limit catastrophic
forgetting through a multitask pretraining regime that includes unimodal
text-only tasks and data sampled from WiT, the relatively diverse
Wikipedia-based dataset (Srinivasan et al., 2021). Our results are largely
negative: Multimodal pretraining does not harm our models' language performance
but does not consistently help either. That said, our conclusions are limited
by our having been able to conduct only a small number of runs. While we must
leave open the possibility that multimodal input explains some of the gap in
data efficiency between LMs and humans, positive evidence for this hypothesis
will require better architectures and techniques for multimodal training.
|
[
-0.3744028509,
-0.6969547272,
0.2806170285,
-0.154068172,
-0.325486064,
0.1388025135,
-0.2582511008,
-0.4072898626,
-0.2969985604,
0.3215757608,
-0.5477307439,
-0.0769152269,
-0.7015343308,
-0.1033329517,
-0.1993327141,
0.9646793008,
-0.0214276649,
0.0823074207,
-0.6467207074,
-0.272023797,
-0.5810910463,
-0.5354887843,
-0.4761018157,
-0.3321140409,
0.8926661015,
0.536080122,
0.4809194207,
0.5261552334,
0.3827084601,
0.2957550585,
0.1829717308,
0.3855555356,
-0.536565423,
0.1965677589,
-0.1805687994,
-0.6854308844,
-0.1777705103,
-0.0491531193,
0.7078393698,
0.8240655065,
-0.1266037673,
0.0300528966,
-0.0713043213,
0.9364882708,
-0.8394351006,
0.2170842439,
-0.6660400629,
-0.0400821008,
-0.3430066407,
-0.3173907399,
-0.566778183,
0.0482589155,
0.1394566596,
-0.4260828793,
0.3476205468,
0.1004427448,
0.8835099339,
0.3580846786,
-0.4490971267,
-0.4256142676,
-0.862229526,
0.9216634631,
-0.42626068,
0.7350965738,
0.5786911845,
-0.0134778703,
0.116289176,
-0.2246244699,
-0.82796067,
-0.2584990859,
-0.1037361026,
0.0605608001,
-0.0772105306,
0.2304650992,
0.5669660568,
0.1799715161,
-0.6786273718,
-0.1263850629,
-0.6520659328,
-0.2725665867,
0.3891186118,
0.0629213154,
0.4381176531,
-0.0897707939,
-0.2224843502,
-0.3142192662,
-0.6564894915,
0.1303150505,
0.3231146932,
0.3112885356,
-0.1859687567,
0.6690101624,
-0.1196902841,
0.7844331264,
-0.2711059749,
-0.4238131046,
0.4979190528,
-0.3949998915,
0.0104633868,
-0.2427238375,
0.6839284897,
0.2271986157,
0.49644503,
-0.1670722812,
-0.2284633368,
0.4067287147,
0.3934707046,
-0.5388656855,
-0.4018212259,
0.1301684082,
-0.150965929,
0.1988374889,
-0.0240142234,
-0.7325034738,
-0.4064039588,
-0.262460649,
0.5480498672,
-0.7434278727,
-0.2816932201,
-0.1355914176,
-0.1066830084,
-0.0062891371,
0.1511377096,
-1.0775036812,
-0.1421339959,
0.3104773164,
0.7230828404,
-0.0134672523,
-0.6225845814,
-0.3340079486,
-0.098410286,
-0.3889746964,
0.8530766368,
-0.4537353516,
-0.1236437336,
-0.0183175281,
-0.0947130471,
-0.5829048753,
-0.5875721574,
0.0639967471,
-0.6078558564,
0.0285107456,
-0.257132262,
-0.3237095177,
-0.2891730368,
0.1657354981,
-0.7426126599,
0.5986480117,
-0.0160461068,
-0.5961537957,
0.7578600645,
-0.6355806589,
-0.6198477149,
-0.2790324092,
-0.0413534865,
-0.4943121672,
0.2861773372,
0.0316053592,
0.3896352351,
-0.0373371989,
0.3102019727,
-0.2734875381,
-0.1990296394,
0.3994289041,
-0.7099454999,
0.4751781523,
0.30790627,
-0.2648707926,
-0.080083169,
-0.9640433788,
-0.3014678359,
0.1346546561,
-0.5663791299,
-0.4474880993,
0.1079416648,
-0.1440452188,
0.4371173382,
0.0174717344,
-0.6711706519,
0.0462735742,
-0.2096193433,
0.1329384148,
0.6416822672,
-0.2945582271,
0.4848294854,
-0.5940811634,
0.5186696649,
0.3583984971,
0.105034478,
-0.6619669199,
-0.142697528,
-1.1657562256,
-0.1422637999,
0.1650295258,
0.2721569538,
-1.2043133974,
-0.2765151262,
-0.2421811223,
-0.3395872712,
-0.5376651287,
0.4291779995,
0.6544809341,
0.4263091683,
0.3105116785,
-0.5445509553,
-0.54567343,
-0.9841356874,
-0.1257182509,
-0.200206086,
0.1752694696,
0.2712077796,
0.4673003256,
-0.1888319552,
0.7196312547,
-0.1793792993,
-0.263643086,
-0.3269123137,
0.2255786061,
-0.1167335138,
0.609043777,
0.4410333037,
-0.8333291411,
-0.265784502,
-0.2070944756,
-0.8579065204,
0.1182978377,
-0.185389474,
0.1991688013,
0.5399521589,
0.2122482955,
-0.8313905001,
0.2876108587,
0.7682281137,
-0.3848142624,
0.4205296636,
-0.3583995402,
0.1948744655,
-0.5514549017,
0.0950416252,
-0.201489538,
0.0049542361,
-0.8636989594,
-0.0550996251,
0.3002859056,
0.0547658429,
-0.5842400193,
0.5072340369,
-0.4982048273,
0.1076600924,
-0.2225454748,
-0.0777230039,
0.0885907859,
0.6759807467,
0.0223699063,
0.7682462335,
0.4111852944,
-0.7707726359,
0.171856761,
0.0694795176,
-0.4222607017,
0.5574563742,
-0.2825136781,
0.1669938713,
-0.5664642453,
-0.0326827243,
-1.2078106403,
-0.4039530158,
0.0359183885,
-0.5637801886,
0.5720764399,
0.2986979783,
-0.4973109365,
-0.1924594641,
-0.1207132787,
0.5424921513,
0.4108906388,
-0.4191934466,
0.6608267426,
0.2561422288,
-0.0796132609,
-0.7217032909,
-0.7547442317,
-0.0295771137,
-0.1263885945,
-0.4455292523,
-0.1687674522,
-0.1703774333,
-0.1890473515,
-0.1407228559,
-0.0559800155,
-0.1316036582,
0.1304157972,
0.2886909246,
0.1993189156,
-0.1764502376,
0.5564624667,
-0.119351171,
-0.2005074173,
-0.0229468755,
-0.0360104702,
0.6649952531,
0.0456439108,
-0.4529074728,
-0.3678724468,
0.2870227098,
0.8137591481,
-0.2625149786,
0.9450964332,
0.5909975171,
-0.2895549536,
-0.0166037623,
-0.7835448384,
-0.0984809995,
-0.4276286662,
0.480366677,
-0.3249637485,
-0.6063505411,
0.2733208835,
0.0637466535,
0.1505821794,
0.4002562165,
0.4606463909,
-0.4766208827,
0.8587865233,
0.817561388,
0.3084394336,
0.6376245022,
-0.40887779,
-0.0288038105,
-0.7742851377,
-0.5050781965,
-0.3070664108,
-0.2293175608,
-0.180146724,
-0.2730914354,
0.1510993093,
0.0418933965,
-0.1607690603,
0.086721465,
-0.0305122659,
0.3481216431,
0.6189370155,
0.2838109136,
0.3496075869,
0.0846581087,
-0.2181886882,
-0.1765538156,
-1.1022168398,
-0.2768802047,
1.2180079222,
0.1790893078,
0.7925004959,
0.0761111453,
0.3379730284,
0.132442832,
0.3966249526,
-0.4848908782,
0.2315972447,
-0.1906880587,
-0.9269499183,
-0.1628552526,
-0.4092694521,
-1.0142171383,
0.3288252056,
-0.2231978625,
-0.4935864806,
0.2036014348,
0.5392603874,
-0.4103527069,
0.3105780184,
-0.9633840322,
0.9184318781,
-0.3953916132,
-0.5583506823,
-0.1973714083,
-0.6462674737,
0.3899530768,
-0.3821315467,
0.6578446627,
-0.0300254878,
0.0931429937,
0.9134953022,
-0.1514671892,
0.982843101,
-0.41027385,
0.0244678948,
0.280395329,
-0.0595246144,
0.0902173147,
-0.2784628272,
0.2309861332,
0.1064230651,
-0.1751239598,
-0.6242111921,
-0.4589715302,
0.4313659668,
-0.8593094349,
-0.2756014168,
-0.4900850654,
-0.7322769165,
-0.3380362391,
0.1347638667,
0.3250072896,
0.6094807386,
0.1648166329,
0.3595466614,
0.8305729628,
-0.2448448092,
0.5597347021,
0.4575783908,
-0.1120921373,
-0.2280769646,
1.1292408705,
0.3723640144,
0.7557848692,
0.2781546712,
0.0514066219,
-0.3666059673,
-0.6610367298,
-0.530749321,
0.3069911897,
-0.8050245643,
-0.0764981806,
-0.7610758543,
0.1243534163,
-0.0984962657,
-0.0416694395,
-0.6869914532,
-0.0969390199,
-0.2338079363,
0.0571209677,
0.1210647002,
0.7346844673,
-0.1756391823,
0.3976272941,
-0.9001976848,
0.3898435235,
0.3442069888,
0.3045979142,
0.2358840257,
-0.4865541458,
-0.476218164,
0.3117724657,
-0.2279417962,
-0.5023762584,
0.2641243637,
0.4726857543,
0.5342091322,
0.4820488691,
-0.1033543572,
0.8729419112,
-0.3773051202,
0.8104855418,
0.4335683882,
-0.5884106159,
0.3848687112,
-0.2382894754,
0.767051518,
0.6894557476,
0.3987142444,
-0.5680932999,
-0.3114666045,
-0.55361408,
-0.8002012968,
0.8052765131,
-0.1432929933,
0.2581712306,
0.105413273,
0.1918946505,
0.3175950348,
0.4200434983,
-0.8071638942,
-0.1914455295,
-0.1300309747,
-0.1106328145,
-0.5485620499,
-0.4649124742,
0.0874701515,
-0.3736380339,
0.4891160727,
-0.0763008818,
0.2180860192,
0.0922959372,
-0.6542125344,
-0.2967651486,
0.1349776089,
0.8501381278,
0.8173689842,
0.060954228,
0.3515133858,
0.1861258745,
-0.5207394958,
0.2207927853,
-0.237231493,
-0.1114826947,
-0.0422481671,
0.8914692998,
1.0607671738,
0.396330148,
-0.9397343397,
0.4089204371,
-0.0887846798,
-0.2572332919,
-0.2717218697,
0.1209734753,
0.167339161,
0.1170715913,
0.4253958762,
0.4988262057,
-0.3938615918,
-0.6705376506,
0.3244451582,
0.3994085491,
-0.39846766,
-0.4016138017,
0.7220691442,
-0.018227417,
-0.3527786732,
0.7207716703,
0.0166626107,
-0.4321467578,
0.5047248006,
0.3097313643,
0.4879870415,
-0.3441601098,
-0.0019619311,
0.402294606,
0.446986407,
0.0218855124,
0.1871504784,
-0.1373883337,
-0.8424541354,
-0.4213350713,
-0.7210689187,
-0.0277139321,
0.1992249638,
-0.4073776603,
0.0903132632,
-0.3012058437,
0.0492308997,
-0.009366069,
-0.2892889678,
-0.8932934403,
0.2641197443,
0.2710998952,
0.4187275767,
-0.9070242643,
0.8392995596,
0.5972998738,
-0.4848392308,
-0.6223025918,
-0.2727852464,
0.0210084505,
-0.7294686437,
0.6748504043,
0.2470559627,
-0.0939289108,
-0.1283683926,
-0.3914327621,
-0.8307624459,
0.8046166301,
0.3033624589,
-0.6132419109,
-0.1521963477,
0.3284758329,
0.4499486089,
-0.2223967761,
0.32072559,
0.4989304245,
0.3768174946,
0.1448095739,
-1.0613350868,
-0.3109251559,
-0.1980070174,
-0.0561095066,
0.0890476853,
-0.6263090968,
1.145757556,
-0.4410246313,
-0.3757983744,
-0.1723998636,
0.3388668895,
-0.0420314148,
0.4620386064,
0.6549152136,
0.5336571336,
0.4426513612,
-0.0361625552,
1.1384553909,
-0.0725376308,
0.3679742217,
0.856179595,
0.1297479272,
0.7347698808,
0.6823319793,
-0.1622169763,
0.2361002415,
0.46308285,
0.3483521044,
0.6996250749,
-0.1264502108,
-0.1127720028,
-0.3428363204,
-0.0844228864,
-0.1600538641,
0.6464619637,
0.4153143466,
-0.2531934083,
-0.247284919,
0.6081713438,
0.0689140558,
0.0846493244,
-0.0462247394,
0.8291659951,
0.0646612495,
-0.8006617427,
0.9709489942,
-0.3525714576,
0.8893817067,
-0.7568410635,
0.0056909863,
-0.2066806555,
0.2411533147,
-0.1057362556,
-0.2857961059,
0.3879650831,
-0.1508602798,
-0.1887415349,
-0.1900441349,
0.5898374915,
-0.7621058226,
-0.3620196581,
0.2341641337,
0.7136244178,
0.0981175005,
0.0572455227,
-0.5251646042,
0.3085974455,
0.0657167137,
-0.3845564127,
0.4496632218,
0.1255468726,
0.1871356815,
0.8145543337,
0.7515615225,
0.0610652938,
0.4098240137,
-0.0647617355,
0.8188057542,
-0.5870252848,
-0.180153057,
-1.0156798363,
0.6628913283,
0.1815781295,
-0.3548707366,
0.5629866123,
0.5159987807,
1.1027829647,
-0.1873750091,
0.7720122933,
-0.1634148955,
0.3738484979,
-0.6468732953,
0.7912227511,
-0.9269387126,
0.0338075943,
-0.3246198595,
-0.7660944462,
-0.359074533,
0.5944145322,
-0.2090056986,
0.0633783787,
1.0033310652,
0.669297874,
0.0240648277,
-0.1715414971,
0.5948050618,
0.1224906594,
0.2813903689,
0.7448396087,
1.0094296932,
-0.259441942,
0.5147870183,
-0.5897022486,
-0.2502908111,
-0.1381486356,
-0.507735908,
-1.0407152176,
-0.8888862133,
-0.1499049664,
-0.0765259266,
0.2013042867,
0.7741132379,
0.5998392105,
-0.6822889447,
-0.1484859884,
0.0880712792,
-0.0037231923,
-0.0858422145,
-0.1386828572,
0.1755223572,
-0.5202647448,
-0.7225995064,
0.3024758399,
0.1425410062,
-0.0093908487,
-0.3824706078,
-0.0596483387,
-0.5458120704,
-0.1881081462,
0.7779289484,
0.3370828331,
-0.7285491228,
-0.4289413691,
-0.0221187342,
-0.0324920826,
0.1836361885,
0.8206131458,
-0.6897094846,
0.8987733722,
0.2748086154,
0.5721285939,
0.4122987688,
-0.2029159367,
0.3633081317,
-0.6862522364,
0.4318687916,
0.1135324761,
0.3049248159,
0.4352699518,
-0.0747344866,
0.1410704851,
0.4890528321,
-0.3420586288,
-0.8023317456,
0.1240427271,
-0.6293855906,
-0.3165823221,
1.0851349831,
-0.1237279996,
-0.3852225542,
-0.3345604539,
-0.2090242356,
0.3769052625,
-0.3473960161,
0.8498757482,
0.9014880061,
-0.2005586773,
-0.3937697709,
-0.7418163419,
0.3834097385,
0.5513404608,
-0.4699065387,
0.1365761012,
0.5066596866,
0.255120337,
0.4346551299,
0.704416573,
0.032762792,
0.3821878433,
0.3349777758,
0.2457591444,
-0.2467537522,
-0.7013360262,
-0.4032568038,
0.3666655719,
0.2129050642,
-0.2201142907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17934v1
|
Multitask Multilingual Model Adaptation with Featurized Low-Rank Mixtures
| 2024-02-27T23:12:45 | 2024-02-27T23:12:45 |
Chu-Cheng Lin, Xinyi Wang, Jonathan H. Clark, Han Lu, Yun Zhu, Chenxi Whitehouse, Hongkun Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Adapting pretrained large language models (LLMs) to various downstream tasks
in tens or hundreds of human languages is computationally expensive.
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) significantly reduces the adaptation
cost, by tuning only a small amount of parameters. However, directly applying
PEFT methods such as LoRA (Hu et al., 2022) on diverse dataset mixtures could
lead to suboptimal performance due to limited parameter capacity and negative
interference among different datasets. In this work, we propose Featurized
Low-rank Mixtures (FLix), a novel PEFT method designed for effective multitask
multilingual tuning. FLix associates each unique dataset feature, such as the
dataset's language or task, with its own low-rank weight update parameters. By
composing feature-specific parameters for each dataset, FLix can accommodate
diverse dataset mixtures and generalize better to unseen datasets. Our
experiments show that FLix leads to significant improvements over a variety of
tasks for both supervised learning and zero-shot settings using different
training data mixtures.
|
[
-0.3092763722,
-0.5308271646,
0.4132236242,
0.3407140076,
-0.1748771071,
0.3423788548,
-0.4887193739,
-0.2866009474,
0.1159831956,
0.5535436869,
-0.5177839398,
-0.2933286726,
-0.4873181283,
0.1208711937,
-0.139248088,
1.0365363359,
-0.1828878373,
-0.1725855917,
-0.240110144,
-0.2681644261,
-0.4033722579,
-0.5022951365,
-0.4506876469,
-0.1475274861,
0.7212488055,
0.8430302739,
0.3100244701,
0.1703165025,
0.021043051,
0.2923975587,
0.3189657032,
0.4907621741,
-0.8391393423,
0.174344033,
-0.1975866854,
-0.6066721678,
-0.4491134286,
-0.1676127166,
0.6033819318,
0.9362921715,
-0.0255307332,
0.09051653,
0.3963893652,
0.6034308672,
-0.81335181,
-0.0829748809,
-0.7179451585,
-0.0886351466,
-0.299205482,
-0.1601499617,
-0.1459111869,
0.1908434927,
-0.2469953597,
-0.746021986,
0.1741018295,
0.2630557716,
0.4087718725,
0.4079461694,
-0.1053031236,
0.2466239035,
-0.7455515265,
1.0685821772,
-0.7450089455,
0.5907427669,
0.482503444,
0.1180920973,
-0.1203315631,
-0.2042626292,
-0.3634291291,
-0.2093426287,
0.1232411414,
0.0925809667,
0.1244492531,
-0.0729534999,
0.1454074234,
0.156922698,
-0.595939517,
0.2519991994,
-0.1942272186,
-0.2131267488,
0.568180263,
-0.0653697625,
0.1034237519,
0.1235101074,
-0.2889811993,
-0.2207830399,
-0.562574625,
0.2164841592,
0.4517390132,
0.6268960834,
-0.3647243679,
0.254640758,
-0.4936284423,
0.7583918571,
0.2038469166,
-0.5566089749,
0.4944802523,
-0.3339517713,
-0.2607721686,
0.0526382327,
0.5077360272,
-0.0189605001,
0.2085752934,
-0.4179865122,
-0.2566629052,
-0.323441714,
0.1901499629,
-0.6764737964,
-0.3674991727,
0.4621379972,
-0.2359508872,
-0.2058447897,
-0.1603785008,
-0.7139603496,
-0.413830936,
-0.4231226444,
0.6177909374,
-0.5256631374,
-0.2273302227,
0.0445570946,
0.0700310245,
-0.1501847208,
0.5628275275,
-0.8646146655,
0.2991525233,
0.495128423,
0.7572672367,
-0.3523229957,
-0.8015245795,
-1.0626544952,
0.0465099998,
-0.2700504959,
0.9385880232,
-0.4657794535,
-0.2227018476,
-0.3835494816,
0.1252308935,
-0.5846748352,
-0.637830019,
0.4624862075,
-0.0762934834,
-0.1175506338,
-0.1857708097,
-0.2063315213,
-0.1090058684,
0.1437005848,
-0.5416600704,
1.4205377102,
0.445446074,
-0.5401569009,
0.4937118292,
-0.6618999243,
-0.8471400142,
0.0506643765,
0.0308790505,
-0.2158490717,
0.3749706149,
0.3855651617,
0.6406790018,
-0.0422960967,
0.0856877938,
-0.6118349433,
-0.4993596375,
0.1326338202,
-0.288269043,
0.366286099,
0.1574809998,
-0.2606727481,
0.2902671993,
-0.8259966373,
-0.0936835706,
0.014101984,
-0.3469947577,
-0.4329135418,
0.0828477815,
0.2530400455,
0.2613628209,
0.230898425,
-0.3897355199,
0.0970664322,
-0.4267216325,
0.3637082875,
0.5479438305,
-0.1396269649,
0.4207639396,
-0.5551792979,
0.4770574868,
0.2856490016,
-0.0926105008,
0.0062443819,
-0.2233732641,
-0.8321940303,
-0.4666564465,
0.44088462,
0.7364600301,
-1.1055983305,
0.2516804039,
-0.527207315,
-0.5720103383,
-0.4355696142,
0.7279860973,
0.0564144216,
0.4437458217,
0.3330782056,
-0.0471994951,
-0.1156053692,
-0.8537583947,
-0.2758026719,
0.1898450404,
-0.2030824572,
0.356533289,
0.4103346169,
0.0904473141,
0.6193398833,
-0.2568674386,
-0.1956192404,
-0.4448806047,
0.2590961158,
0.1888287365,
0.4719385803,
0.8350741267,
-0.6702465415,
-0.5734059215,
0.0509269424,
-0.1923984587,
-0.0622871444,
-0.2290222794,
-0.2543496192,
0.0404723175,
0.2009237856,
-0.0307479687,
-0.0422866903,
0.7258399725,
-0.0851790756,
0.3215377033,
-0.4088529944,
0.490759939,
-1.052362442,
0.0524921566,
0.0581533685,
-0.5151129961,
-0.849948585,
-0.0290166084,
0.2047243416,
-0.2171496898,
-0.8727806211,
0.5385403037,
-0.147910133,
0.1685935855,
-0.3024357557,
-0.2132004499,
0.0110222157,
0.7090209126,
0.183345139,
0.9007833004,
0.7752293944,
-0.7377671599,
-0.0048688091,
0.0524299406,
-0.2112080604,
0.8275498748,
-0.2710014582,
0.2299476415,
-0.1399430186,
-0.0779360831,
-0.9417691827,
-0.3328768015,
0.1190462634,
0.0375217907,
0.2371210456,
-0.2196203023,
-0.6906890869,
-0.0359527543,
-0.4921416044,
0.4584333003,
0.147674799,
-0.4903452396,
0.5168857574,
0.2593180239,
-0.3767631054,
-0.2422656864,
-0.6558154821,
-0.0116912639,
-0.3795513511,
-0.5195266604,
0.5440620184,
-0.2041453719,
0.1084905341,
-0.460968405,
-0.2128904462,
-0.1159147248,
0.3388052583,
0.1184719279,
-0.0185066089,
-0.2564440966,
-0.0072668274,
0.4499862492,
0.0719745234,
-0.6071939468,
-0.1114717722,
0.4114361703,
0.0130796945,
-0.2056340426,
-0.0729188621,
0.5237399936,
0.6278325319,
-0.2295714468,
0.8097242713,
1.0142964125,
-0.4706046879,
-0.4558589458,
-0.471235007,
-0.2711115777,
-0.4709679782,
0.5161574483,
-0.5667784214,
-1.0735913515,
0.4276181161,
-0.2489452362,
-0.0047854218,
0.1746420413,
0.5515385866,
-0.2238168567,
0.7743252516,
0.5897377133,
-0.2356669903,
0.3985363841,
0.1811348349,
0.2647479177,
-0.6769526601,
0.276629895,
-0.5194144249,
-0.722690165,
-0.4492098689,
-0.4721484482,
0.6215535402,
0.297640264,
-0.0889960304,
0.3758271337,
-0.1540940106,
0.2686896324,
0.7080293298,
0.2517802715,
0.1416182667,
0.3474858105,
-0.0529525355,
-0.167703405,
-0.9754045606,
-0.0485822596,
1.1053470373,
0.1018081233,
0.7038945556,
0.1011565626,
0.8542742133,
0.2329286933,
0.1255913973,
-0.450391978,
0.2563990355,
-0.6606277823,
-0.2384333313,
-0.1998312026,
-0.377938509,
-0.7204203606,
0.4450009465,
-0.4759238064,
-1.0360484123,
0.3287143409,
0.2561765015,
-0.7541981339,
0.1221282333,
-0.8944362998,
1.0299651623,
-0.5664551258,
-0.5613595843,
-0.1130048409,
-0.3453543782,
0.2457531542,
-0.473346889,
0.5612086058,
-0.2888920307,
-0.0970320329,
0.8123161197,
-0.1424413025,
0.9497819543,
-0.2867821753,
-0.1402187943,
-0.1002520919,
0.0484047867,
0.5265609026,
0.0601795502,
-0.1811820418,
0.2823715806,
0.4265111089,
-0.5122445822,
-0.466670543,
0.8877586126,
-0.7324576378,
-0.2604820132,
-0.2430928349,
-0.8176038265,
-0.7625570297,
0.1311304569,
0.108878158,
0.3703789115,
0.1004542187,
0.1866207719,
0.4157624543,
-0.2703270614,
0.3804430366,
0.4557714164,
0.0783665404,
-0.4259159863,
1.4288350344,
0.0271160472,
0.1866740137,
0.5374287367,
0.129475221,
-0.1846645176,
-0.7395958304,
-0.5772249699,
0.1354212463,
-0.4351363778,
-0.0959914997,
-0.5396510959,
0.1933229417,
-0.4890940785,
-0.1171973422,
-0.4652157426,
-0.341580987,
-0.4708081186,
0.357879132,
0.383004874,
0.1554856598,
0.1473170072,
0.4477270842,
-0.9195788503,
0.6276625991,
0.1053468511,
0.3975268304,
-0.213161543,
-0.6030044556,
-0.437849313,
0.0874829367,
-0.1707520038,
-0.7279614806,
0.2762567997,
0.7546674609,
0.6964119077,
0.1776186973,
0.1333313286,
0.918792963,
-0.4353420138,
0.650254488,
0.0103065828,
-0.8172630072,
0.423475951,
-0.4053409696,
0.404663533,
0.8835429549,
0.2094612271,
-0.4522983134,
-0.266640991,
-0.2241678387,
-0.8009536266,
0.893207252,
0.0991020426,
0.1030254588,
0.4575030208,
0.2827574611,
0.5245476365,
0.4252135456,
-0.5425255299,
-0.2003348917,
-0.2909734845,
-0.4968714416,
-0.4232120812,
-0.0029851198,
-0.1421729028,
-0.5096243024,
0.6015286446,
-0.5766220689,
0.0767348707,
-0.1229510084,
-0.5247275829,
-0.1003518254,
0.5113806129,
0.886113286,
0.5448192954,
-0.0135209234,
0.1913365126,
0.3508384824,
-0.3327279091,
0.1345884949,
0.4933935702,
0.1317475736,
-0.4747808576,
0.3352291584,
0.9322422743,
0.8885473609,
-0.8317654729,
0.2169249803,
0.2611455321,
-0.533573091,
0.1870323867,
0.5015348196,
0.122639209,
0.2561770678,
0.5482954383,
0.3006263375,
-0.0424377061,
-0.2117056102,
0.1373860091,
0.193477273,
-0.1022525206,
-0.2952113152,
0.6736152768,
0.2034020275,
0.0336736478,
0.0629452541,
-0.2129195184,
-0.2786303759,
0.2792167068,
0.363850534,
0.5580375195,
-0.2216295451,
0.3624996543,
0.0657438785,
0.2581340969,
-0.1359387934,
0.3565238714,
-0.1234842688,
-0.7568818331,
-0.5339170098,
-0.9330085516,
-0.2744811773,
0.447491169,
-0.2483043075,
0.112061888,
-0.2263284177,
0.2205356807,
0.0503548868,
0.0154673709,
-0.7831959724,
0.0664401278,
0.209675923,
0.6601350904,
-0.9310526848,
1.0248322487,
0.8838023543,
-0.0141435228,
-0.4482592642,
0.0302201044,
-0.142904833,
-0.5874039531,
0.1701393723,
-0.05550519,
0.0346781164,
0.2028814256,
-0.2016650289,
-0.8818712831,
0.8477683067,
0.7418147922,
-0.6413576603,
0.274345696,
0.4526090026,
0.3556050062,
-0.3876612186,
-0.0935036317,
0.5454822779,
0.6153218746,
-0.112638481,
-1.1466724873,
-0.0945385322,
-0.112858586,
-0.0636017099,
0.076069288,
-0.5430979729,
0.8114894629,
-0.0038248634,
0.1442534178,
-0.0557857193,
0.4357555509,
0.2763643563,
0.2084953338,
0.8481155038,
0.4125652015,
0.7590306997,
0.0575084053,
0.7681777477,
-0.4511435628,
0.2040342093,
1.1529425383,
-0.5751439333,
0.9310087562,
0.5141863227,
-0.3201230168,
0.2483992279,
0.8153203726,
0.0578116365,
0.6412774324,
-0.2490428239,
-0.0934646055,
-0.6862596869,
0.1936492324,
-0.1415341198,
0.5072895288,
0.4053330421,
0.0167383179,
-0.4304233789,
0.4730683565,
-0.276832819,
-0.0820372254,
-0.3812571168,
0.5631036758,
-0.0384438001,
-0.6468935013,
0.8555710316,
0.1602745205,
0.9287867546,
-0.4844099879,
0.1271585077,
-0.0362351164,
0.0811057761,
-0.2242963761,
-0.3221399188,
0.0596364625,
-0.1749432683,
-0.1322263777,
-0.1847914755,
0.8303021789,
-0.7492093444,
-0.8703715801,
0.0439864285,
0.6880610585,
-0.1269249618,
-0.5541510582,
-0.9564862847,
0.1369820386,
-0.0627271906,
-0.0118861757,
0.7622051835,
-0.0587892607,
-0.0246519987,
0.4609024227,
0.6764541268,
0.1495039016,
0.0272400659,
0.1549596041,
0.6925991774,
-0.3762751818,
-0.7194722891,
-0.4099142849,
0.5436279774,
0.2364429981,
-0.1748375446,
0.4858806133,
0.5523816347,
0.7506664395,
-0.3140004873,
1.0008842945,
0.1321331263,
0.5753644705,
-0.6134466529,
0.7232626081,
-1.0452370644,
-0.0164246056,
-0.2209044993,
-0.919846952,
-0.1424965411,
0.4233093262,
-0.3046319187,
0.2218967825,
0.6144390702,
0.7093356848,
-0.658816576,
-0.0744355246,
0.5831321478,
0.0835576579,
-0.032612402,
0.5691617131,
0.3059504032,
-0.2001262754,
0.2714572549,
-0.6961559057,
-0.2972626686,
-0.3512689173,
-0.8148087263,
-0.8933498263,
-0.6032282114,
-0.5018820167,
0.1336594671,
0.0641309172,
0.8602195382,
1.0857561827,
-1.1676917076,
-0.1925245076,
0.1758895069,
0.0085242642,
-0.6815449595,
-0.2260054052,
0.2069371194,
-0.4596569836,
-0.8899575472,
0.8296243548,
0.3285686374,
-0.200134635,
-0.1376701295,
-0.0532299578,
-0.1334875524,
-0.2686173916,
0.695258081,
0.1831135154,
-0.5997508168,
-0.4320784509,
-0.0438506305,
0.3656685054,
0.2306693345,
0.8458588123,
-0.6695560217,
0.2274395972,
0.3157966733,
0.5820996761,
0.5018795133,
-0.0437863953,
0.4121739268,
-1.104604125,
0.4128312767,
-0.0004649524,
0.3395152986,
0.3634502888,
-0.3782503903,
0.1242158189,
0.3676059246,
-0.2070570439,
-0.8490538001,
-0.0691991746,
-1.1863539219,
-0.3423780799,
1.041855216,
0.131391868,
-0.2410837412,
-0.2571379244,
-0.1827334017,
-0.1210363507,
-0.4709875882,
0.5034313798,
0.6110406518,
-0.367975831,
-0.4641733766,
-0.6329017282,
0.3890143633,
0.4072196782,
-0.9718793631,
-0.0174139999,
0.1507195085,
0.5753307939,
-0.0687722936,
0.4111104906,
0.3863063753,
0.1673598439,
-0.2151425481,
-0.1905466318,
-0.1607123017,
-0.3639699817,
-0.1205024719,
0.3772878349,
0.1847223788,
-0.0798703805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17930v1
|
Pragmatic Instruction Following and Goal Assistance via Cooperative Language-Guided Inverse Planning
| 2024-02-27T23:06:53 | 2024-02-27T23:06:53 |
Tan Zhi-Xuan, Lance Ying, Vikash Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
People often give instructions whose meaning is ambiguous without further
context, expecting that their actions or goals will disambiguate their
intentions. How can we build assistive agents that follow such instructions in
a flexible, context-sensitive manner? This paper introduces cooperative
language-guided inverse plan search (CLIPS), a Bayesian agent architecture for
pragmatic instruction following and goal assistance. Our agent assists a human
by modeling them as a cooperative planner who communicates joint plans to the
assistant, then performs multimodal Bayesian inference over the human's goal
from actions and language, using large language models (LLMs) to evaluate the
likelihood of an instruction given a hypothesized plan. Given this posterior,
our assistant acts to minimize expected goal achievement cost, enabling it to
pragmatically follow ambiguous instructions and provide effective assistance
even when uncertain about the goal. We evaluate these capabilities in two
cooperative planning domains (Doors, Keys & Gems and VirtualHome), finding that
CLIPS significantly outperforms GPT-4V, LLM-based literal instruction following
and unimodal inverse planning in both accuracy and helpfulness, while closely
matching the inferences and assistive judgments provided by human raters.
|
[
-0.2020168453,
-0.8527577519,
0.7550248504,
0.3624062836,
0.1121654138,
0.208744958,
-0.2276692539,
0.1179608703,
0.1970492452,
0.3865476549,
-1.0818008184,
-0.6947529912,
-0.4598395526,
-0.1665546894,
0.3275362253,
0.5263827443,
-0.3044326305,
0.083077766,
0.0941611454,
0.2143330425,
-0.734716177,
-0.3241449893,
-0.5674417615,
-0.2857656777,
0.3654545844,
0.7668533921,
1.1064301729,
0.3826847374,
0.2743091285,
0.3455485106,
0.3021385968,
0.2875301838,
-0.2618139088,
0.0796360523,
-0.3290571272,
-0.3207341135,
-0.7067446113,
-0.0461474657,
0.4841161668,
0.6668208838,
-0.3838705122,
-0.2263171226,
0.0319117978,
0.5137345791,
-0.6703285575,
0.4826316237,
-0.3681390584,
-0.0460937805,
0.5137204528,
-0.008065003,
-0.060449101,
-0.2595376968,
0.2387562096,
-0.8267817497,
0.2153440565,
-0.1339973956,
0.421649456,
0.1295318753,
0.0441647209,
-0.3746000826,
-0.5247257352,
0.6642332673,
-0.3926985562,
0.2809601426,
0.7711189985,
0.3600113392,
-0.6793932319,
-0.4561927021,
-0.5664272308,
-0.2001398504,
-0.1066320017,
0.2542325854,
-0.3491334319,
0.5334684849,
0.14426893,
-0.3471633196,
-0.6911648512,
-0.1368373185,
-0.0892091244,
-0.2293886244,
0.6212821603,
0.0082451077,
0.2208800763,
0.0995044634,
-0.5259497166,
-0.3296334743,
-0.4691580236,
0.2078133821,
0.3348651528,
0.1603829861,
0.0387809016,
0.6139255762,
-0.4874428213,
0.8571550846,
-0.0185135342,
-0.0185730215,
-0.0874858424,
-0.3069874048,
-0.1122363433,
0.0601190403,
0.323192507,
0.4475255311,
0.2031706572,
-0.4168869853,
-0.2697495818,
0.1164620146,
0.239726454,
-0.3916943073,
-0.4199714363,
0.0173648875,
-0.1930746883,
0.4162480533,
0.1259711981,
-0.5438427925,
-0.0591151156,
-0.5828146338,
0.7869989276,
-0.6362092495,
0.0058955555,
0.4013004601,
-0.3263275623,
0.3956851065,
0.4173644185,
-0.5646058321,
0.4765127897,
0.8766441345,
0.7141565084,
0.2901357412,
-0.5870831013,
-0.8877637386,
0.4724836349,
-0.12618348,
0.8403263688,
-0.8355931044,
-0.5668504834,
-0.029731689,
0.1120500118,
-0.2375970334,
-0.093403019,
0.4911496639,
-0.3017893136,
0.1268764585,
-0.4022398889,
-0.2959388793,
-0.564632237,
0.287760675,
-0.2891224325,
0.4068252146,
0.1380595714,
-0.2589634359,
0.2059792131,
-0.3176953793,
-0.3066183627,
0.1250361949,
-0.4143297374,
-0.307880491,
-0.1864195913,
0.3075177372,
0.467710495,
-0.1449851692,
0.3150437176,
-0.2173319459,
-0.629992485,
-0.0514966734,
-0.4238068461,
0.4820495844,
-0.3946799636,
-0.5068123341,
0.4156651795,
-0.5994678736,
0.0432233848,
-0.0044825291,
0.0177488793,
-0.5147529244,
0.2274715006,
-0.4699324071,
0.0624206588,
0.3915754855,
-0.3144651055,
0.4119481444,
-0.1303904355,
-0.0596393757,
0.8443461061,
0.1113130301,
0.7372564077,
-0.5371815562,
0.818520546,
-0.4578839839,
0.2951801419,
-0.0771722272,
-0.865151763,
-0.1227668524,
-0.4590654969,
-0.3020268977,
0.5698168874,
-0.6578025222,
0.4807542861,
0.0899122804,
-0.3522467315,
-0.5232726336,
0.0243665297,
0.6238937378,
0.5882813334,
0.345290333,
-0.235175997,
-0.3318322599,
-0.9411221743,
-0.2247888595,
-0.2904858887,
-0.1855886132,
0.1045918986,
0.2258167118,
-0.1585355997,
1.0199153423,
-0.7082589269,
-0.4089458883,
-0.1163007095,
0.2966183126,
0.1545008421,
0.3770311773,
0.2833128572,
-1.0765883923,
-0.5670542121,
-0.079545781,
-0.1857223213,
-0.2782633901,
-0.2023217976,
-0.2936449647,
-0.2381077111,
-0.075560607,
-0.5415902138,
0.708769381,
0.4319657683,
-0.3559999764,
0.7216569781,
-0.5236181617,
0.1239130571,
-0.7392531633,
-0.0557924993,
-0.1313418746,
-0.1475274861,
-0.5306872129,
-0.138339147,
-0.0516045392,
0.1012684405,
-0.0287261643,
0.4550502896,
-0.7326821685,
-0.2741039693,
-0.4164462388,
0.3372134566,
0.0239157118,
0.8879887462,
0.606043458,
1.0214880705,
0.6568494439,
-0.4502957463,
0.3115633726,
0.4848267734,
0.128032133,
0.5302439928,
-0.5940797329,
0.0569641776,
-0.2605561912,
0.3122026026,
-0.9775476456,
-0.2629825175,
0.7112091184,
-0.4718395174,
0.1856241822,
-0.3353036642,
-0.2088435292,
-0.1541281641,
-0.4549293518,
0.0122117437,
0.3765365481,
-0.4064730108,
0.5622464418,
0.2889119387,
-0.2008818239,
-0.8584548235,
-0.4909803867,
-0.3039044738,
0.0964229405,
-0.5450848937,
0.6555760503,
-0.04625066,
-0.2402779162,
0.1689881831,
-0.27878353,
-0.2098005265,
-0.0234223977,
0.573438406,
0.3428111672,
-0.0006017721,
-0.0330941491,
0.2409678102,
0.0631428063,
0.1288837641,
-0.1276585907,
0.439819634,
-0.1147105098,
-0.5265215039,
-0.2898771465,
0.6261253357,
0.0133633502,
-0.1376546174,
0.673235178,
0.4488845766,
-0.0761745498,
-0.2119468153,
-0.3522414565,
-0.1346255094,
-0.4711860716,
0.2306671441,
-0.4863973856,
-0.5437153578,
0.4911351204,
-0.036298953,
0.0887540281,
-0.284732908,
0.3080649972,
0.0450334139,
1.1981867552,
0.6738566756,
0.2160321027,
0.6403588653,
-0.3213108182,
0.0193818454,
-0.8240397573,
-0.3251746297,
-0.2996608019,
-0.3523891866,
-0.4169179201,
-0.6485020518,
0.4882017672,
0.371132046,
-0.0204070602,
0.8414710164,
-0.6621191502,
0.281919986,
0.6727624536,
0.3107210994,
0.1271834224,
-0.195816949,
-0.0933354422,
0.1775241047,
-0.9263619184,
-0.6528156996,
0.6446018815,
0.1526389718,
0.8668425083,
0.1623619497,
0.6800070405,
0.0411897674,
0.2982593775,
-0.9617134333,
0.6469404697,
0.290892154,
-0.2463253587,
-0.2923139334,
-0.2084008306,
-0.9533191323,
0.417414546,
-0.0526868589,
-0.8527340889,
0.4162458181,
0.2759082019,
-0.2610270083,
0.0073364414,
-0.9412391782,
0.9320166707,
-0.2371280789,
-0.7070026994,
-0.4231698513,
-0.8239175081,
0.0065229079,
0.1548565179,
0.1345484406,
-0.2027913928,
-0.4939789772,
0.4062184393,
-0.2250083387,
0.9201490879,
-0.4205683768,
0.1330208182,
0.4272345006,
0.2669841349,
0.7218958139,
0.0438908972,
-0.0137300417,
-0.2790353596,
-0.1538686156,
-0.4850548506,
-0.8080539107,
0.6771985292,
-0.5196859241,
-1.0283325911,
-0.201691106,
-0.607583642,
-0.3548098803,
0.1940168589,
-0.0551934466,
0.3193767965,
-0.3072188795,
-0.3407752514,
0.3433884382,
-0.1141711175,
0.4773683548,
0.8254475594,
0.1300531179,
-0.1513774842,
0.7130013704,
-0.1174204871,
0.1133379936,
0.6799021363,
0.2813060582,
-0.4129959047,
-0.4034644067,
-0.2484149188,
0.2687202394,
-0.5539027452,
-0.2337809801,
-0.3550546467,
0.0838953257,
-0.4223439991,
-0.5820968151,
-0.0238071885,
-0.3203251958,
-0.1784697622,
0.0737323388,
0.0656813383,
0.3963412344,
-0.3349341452,
0.582876265,
-0.8700039387,
0.2189718336,
0.4504614472,
0.0595025346,
-0.1974206716,
-0.1491467208,
0.1961886883,
0.3815887272,
-0.4432412684,
-1.2539986372,
0.3716004789,
0.0622213818,
0.8930256963,
0.2557534873,
0.2896488607,
0.827783525,
-0.5007094741,
0.4709071815,
0.1497674286,
-0.6116694212,
0.5628256798,
-0.2435375005,
0.316167742,
0.4025355875,
0.6940829754,
-0.1833349317,
-0.1841095388,
-0.5487819314,
-0.5214143991,
0.7976229787,
0.2297588736,
-0.1289072335,
0.0079191485,
0.179790765,
0.1284526736,
0.2310746908,
-0.3463979661,
0.1509694457,
-0.0470720455,
-0.1686671525,
0.1766621917,
0.080978699,
-0.2302870899,
0.0719581842,
0.483458519,
-0.3342728317,
0.4834067822,
0.5158743858,
0.0766649842,
-0.0849822313,
0.2849155664,
0.7090167999,
0.7194023728,
-0.2490378022,
0.0241519567,
-0.0056692325,
-0.3393266201,
-0.0022253464,
0.3667219579,
0.1342030317,
-0.0394744314,
0.3084240556,
0.6627580523,
0.4642731547,
-0.9903427362,
0.7325686216,
-0.1043824032,
0.0355068333,
-0.5230360627,
0.2986005247,
-0.055387143,
0.4511781335,
0.2842965126,
0.1474617869,
0.2209015489,
-0.6523291469,
0.3207327425,
0.7106695771,
-0.3304073215,
-0.6040025353,
0.2857710719,
-0.037460357,
-0.7071923614,
0.2693922818,
-0.366909802,
-0.7360448241,
0.5208858252,
0.5147294402,
0.8008748889,
-0.2824395597,
0.6844028234,
0.1113295332,
0.1701003909,
-0.1469347775,
0.42091313,
-0.7193927169,
-0.5940572023,
-0.3719080985,
-0.1671252847,
-0.6150112152,
-0.6183462143,
-0.4703636467,
0.2876318395,
-0.2293700874,
-0.0094485171,
-0.2166399211,
-0.0332067944,
-0.5957747102,
-0.1458244175,
-0.2722202241,
0.7778931856,
-0.5001369119,
0.8976228237,
1.0641332865,
-0.4559198916,
-0.8994663954,
0.2236020565,
0.0451782048,
-1.0862125158,
0.5000001788,
-0.0053040665,
-0.6539194584,
-0.0909226537,
-0.5256134868,
-0.5293368101,
1.2078166008,
0.2371719331,
-0.6476646662,
-0.6895173192,
-0.3131435215,
0.4246020019,
-0.2851748168,
0.1823469698,
0.3447937965,
0.4694641531,
0.4560606182,
-0.6687445045,
0.0015802637,
0.3280565739,
-0.2890632451,
0.3083669245,
-0.6557210684,
0.4918787181,
-0.4250079691,
-0.2479490787,
0.245686546,
0.4321982265,
0.3768184185,
0.5526993871,
0.3311411142,
0.0044450779,
0.4472942352,
0.3164139092,
0.895235002,
-0.1322980225,
-0.0269325059,
1.3566361666,
-0.2188107967,
0.8124232888,
0.4552388191,
0.0730611011,
0.5557720065,
0.1471999139,
0.2297354937,
0.7150607705,
-0.0603683479,
-0.3713421524,
-0.1286733299,
-0.0339506716,
0.1167007908,
0.3464200497,
0.6368947029,
-0.1388717443,
-0.3246131539,
-0.1376795769,
-0.1208680794,
0.4700756073,
-0.3123228848,
0.7039290071,
-0.0886089504,
-1.0262910128,
0.2439411879,
0.1040906236,
0.3652970791,
-0.8211564422,
-0.5123211145,
0.0304037016,
0.1264480203,
-0.0779966488,
-1.0012651682,
0.3143909872,
-0.2082037181,
0.1485192776,
-0.2228291482,
0.8603004813,
-0.5588730574,
0.1221577749,
0.3530364037,
0.3688315749,
-0.0584319755,
-0.1849554926,
-0.8803810477,
-0.1011038572,
-0.132047236,
-0.0795123056,
0.2471964657,
0.3213897347,
-0.2010858804,
0.6528978348,
0.361828953,
0.1779266745,
-0.005122351,
-0.3916540742,
0.9368280172,
-0.4227422476,
-0.4317945242,
-0.4361784756,
0.3555909991,
-0.1262703836,
-0.0861310512,
0.6093988419,
0.2437999994,
0.8982308507,
-0.0483151078,
0.3478850722,
-0.0574672185,
0.2204093933,
-0.4388941228,
0.1886913776,
-0.2137632668,
0.2952676117,
-0.1651233584,
-1.0704246759,
-0.1724841595,
1.0418208838,
-0.7362733483,
-0.1382089257,
0.3249917328,
1.0551862717,
-0.1470379233,
-0.0515303724,
0.440322578,
-0.2942449749,
0.2360906601,
0.8457016349,
0.8417260647,
0.006259222,
0.4880301952,
-0.3826334476,
-0.6115222573,
-0.0175531637,
-0.4980666041,
-0.8251122236,
-0.6395153403,
-0.2561601698,
0.0876439437,
0.3039295077,
1.2775018215,
0.6786959767,
-0.3931950033,
-0.3474516869,
-0.5150497556,
0.4433125854,
-0.6389141679,
-0.2332400829,
0.3693418801,
-0.1630367935,
-0.6356104016,
0.7077535987,
0.2253888845,
-0.0757431313,
-0.226897642,
-0.2964405715,
-0.3397344649,
-0.0030104108,
0.3117801249,
0.5222116113,
-0.7465589046,
-0.3814365268,
0.0611984134,
-0.0708285719,
-0.0764759406,
0.9300881028,
-0.8109580278,
0.6971035004,
0.4998428822,
0.5189211369,
0.2543701828,
0.3174716532,
0.9108530879,
-0.7331739068,
0.1651228666,
0.4526283741,
-0.0148250414,
0.1084553525,
-0.3895712197,
0.4302556217,
-0.0408469886,
-0.5905679464,
-0.3889306486,
0.3245540559,
-0.9842309952,
-0.4450111091,
1.0616930723,
-0.5837711096,
-0.3941234946,
-0.0915193334,
-0.9294823408,
0.3173832595,
-0.6649819613,
0.6121091843,
0.3658232093,
-0.6351289749,
-0.3037897944,
-0.141621545,
0.5016571879,
0.3785744011,
-0.3626262248,
-0.0172326025,
0.788505733,
-0.0370275415,
0.0479352772,
0.6490359902,
0.2614665926,
0.5148249865,
0.0660528764,
-0.1957601905,
-0.1922495365,
-0.4221611917,
-0.2577241957,
0.0906644017,
0.0079380451,
-0.6063495278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17916v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17916v3
|
Adversarial Math Word Problem Generation
| 2024-02-27T22:07:52 | 2024-06-15T22:36:20 |
Roy Xie, Chengxuan Huang, Junlin Wang, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly transformed the educational
landscape. As current plagiarism detection tools struggle to keep pace with
LLMs' rapid advancements, the educational community faces the challenge of
assessing students' true problem-solving abilities in the presence of LLMs. In
this work, we explore a new paradigm for ensuring fair evaluation -- generating
adversarial examples which preserve the structure and difficulty of the
original questions aimed for assessment, but are unsolvable by LLMs. Focusing
on the domain of math word problems, we leverage abstract syntax trees to
structurally generate adversarial examples that cause LLMs to produce incorrect
answers by simply editing the numeric values in the problems. We conduct
experiments on various open- and closed-source LLMs, quantitatively and
qualitatively demonstrating that our method significantly degrades their math
problem-solving ability. We identify shared vulnerabilities among LLMs and
propose a cost-effective approach to attack high-cost models. Additionally, we
conduct automatic analysis to investigate the cause of failure, providing
further insights into the limitations of LLMs.
|
[
-0.1347813457,
-1.2264066935,
0.6808789968,
0.1330015659,
0.060793303,
0.2589197159,
-0.0656385124,
-0.0110316239,
-0.2313789427,
0.5889261365,
-0.4923778474,
-0.2882947326,
-0.8171923161,
0.0166264772,
-0.6144406199,
1.0085958242,
-0.2891058624,
0.0922426879,
-0.621168077,
-0.192263335,
-0.3333173394,
-0.758597672,
-0.6630401015,
-0.2952730954,
0.2047269493,
0.1464095414,
1.1015849113,
0.4683710337,
0.758628428,
0.4004893601,
-0.2105955034,
0.0075703897,
-0.634091258,
0.1905148774,
-0.0316715837,
-0.6207889915,
-0.3381263912,
0.1785763353,
0.4383770227,
0.8673056364,
-0.3147638142,
0.149588868,
-0.0387164094,
0.6483411193,
-0.598569572,
0.0718943477,
-1.1623924971,
0.2272176594,
-0.2735668719,
-0.088820599,
-0.3943040371,
-0.5684190989,
-0.1039726883,
-0.5763911605,
0.2045790851,
-0.4141793847,
0.6961685419,
0.2909505665,
-0.067902863,
-0.6945517063,
-0.4288097024,
0.6924910545,
-0.4586615264,
-0.2036713362,
0.1553243399,
0.4385641515,
-0.6403975487,
-0.5298716426,
-0.6158048511,
-0.1254255623,
0.2800934911,
0.0286222622,
-0.5569778681,
-0.1862362772,
0.2910094559,
0.3787136078,
-0.5487675071,
0.0312537886,
-0.4083201289,
-0.1132418215,
0.6242456436,
0.4333370924,
0.4953936636,
-0.1489127576,
-0.0867297575,
-0.1819855273,
-0.926168859,
-0.1965157986,
0.6739317775,
0.0954730436,
0.2729869485,
0.7865330577,
0.4050273597,
0.4441354275,
-0.4022569656,
0.088254109,
0.0501922444,
0.064823091,
-0.3046108186,
-0.184616968,
0.7399157882,
0.1328258216,
0.471680671,
-0.1559415162,
-0.4299259186,
0.5245856643,
0.1453538537,
-0.6382744908,
-0.1733805239,
0.0842823461,
-0.1038910598,
-0.7644988298,
-0.3010964394,
-0.7083389759,
-0.6348565221,
-0.1221318617,
0.7977784276,
-0.2975691259,
-0.0378920175,
0.2273109257,
-0.16500552,
-0.2589025199,
0.2779854834,
-0.2588754296,
0.2802862823,
0.6944998503,
0.6028851271,
0.0258906297,
-0.3211597204,
-0.5865493417,
-0.2448819727,
-0.4024254382,
0.2800994217,
-0.3806298375,
-0.6038198471,
-0.0519407615,
-0.2941557765,
0.1853592694,
-0.7475858927,
0.3518742621,
-0.6091695428,
0.4000351131,
-0.0591392629,
-0.4334723949,
0.044738479,
0.4499303401,
-0.5607581735,
0.7059144974,
0.2360219359,
-0.7615718842,
-0.2676452398,
-0.6953810453,
-0.2197009176,
0.2039273977,
-0.3240494132,
-0.7438303828,
0.2492329478,
0.1667220145,
0.1732566059,
-0.3284634948,
0.4721339047,
-0.3840649724,
-0.2334801257,
0.5140733719,
-0.8046984076,
1.1042881012,
0.1676109135,
-0.3667798638,
0.0673092529,
-0.6692708731,
0.04460885,
0.999522388,
-0.2226165384,
-0.369418174,
-0.0451342128,
-0.3899787366,
0.1316805631,
0.2666683495,
-0.3786123097,
-0.0218077693,
-0.5282257795,
0.3301062286,
1.1443083286,
-0.1420882642,
0.0102357715,
-0.4476537704,
0.8476979733,
-0.0865150765,
0.1992629319,
-0.0298483744,
-0.402351439,
-0.6585905552,
-0.0025508478,
0.2235461622,
0.5177150369,
-1.0228321552,
0.0589707382,
-0.2990572155,
-0.4971073866,
-0.5718472004,
0.3684001863,
0.6884807348,
0.4625076354,
0.2751107812,
-0.0030545581,
-0.1955738813,
-0.7196225524,
-0.4955368638,
0.0158786252,
-0.1116637066,
0.4607325196,
0.7044076324,
-0.0677856654,
0.7331948876,
-0.711194396,
-0.2265854478,
-0.1100026369,
0.1359030455,
-0.0589538179,
0.1725211293,
0.4948337674,
-0.7070043087,
-0.1779630482,
-0.546687305,
-0.7676989436,
-0.3472135365,
0.0493388735,
-0.0312769264,
0.1198662743,
0.3796774447,
-0.4872359931,
0.4068134129,
0.5523873568,
-0.4127494693,
0.6535628438,
-0.1573566496,
-0.1993971616,
-0.9445525408,
-0.1784656793,
-0.0763824061,
0.06502413,
-0.1670808494,
0.6944568157,
-0.1884162128,
-0.5718970895,
-0.4781440198,
0.3216030002,
-0.2807174921,
-0.0633515865,
-0.1712901294,
0.4605119228,
0.1258230209,
0.3710018098,
-0.6214718819,
0.7495409846,
0.3472555876,
-0.2754273713,
0.6364561915,
0.1237229034,
-0.1666447371,
0.4740076959,
-0.8012370467,
0.2069801539,
-0.2883187234,
0.1351868212,
-0.7317965031,
0.1028307676,
0.0776620358,
-0.6271626353,
0.0647724792,
-0.0519440025,
-0.6137191653,
-0.3430983722,
-0.5599887967,
0.3919489384,
0.5235682726,
-0.7309899926,
0.3795657754,
0.4060643315,
-0.2085908949,
-0.579983592,
-0.625939548,
0.2615394294,
-0.1901684254,
-0.7594498396,
0.1132260561,
-0.2307395637,
-0.6339294314,
0.3043279052,
-0.0295196157,
0.0483006015,
0.591283977,
0.1304630637,
0.4253256917,
-0.1313239634,
0.0208472349,
-0.2344162464,
0.1166215688,
0.4843907058,
-0.0574138239,
0.4181054831,
-0.2681392729,
-0.6431607008,
0.1611524522,
0.4353784621,
0.8245106936,
-0.3921111822,
0.4378428459,
0.1121319532,
-0.6681591868,
-0.508900106,
-0.2823983729,
0.0679194257,
-0.5399070978,
0.6667438745,
-0.3487144709,
-0.7114158273,
0.3547471762,
0.0207798108,
0.1843294203,
0.3686621785,
0.5340316892,
0.3206489682,
1.0294005871,
0.1387600899,
0.1520819664,
0.0050283433,
-0.3599054813,
0.1690140367,
-0.5358473659,
-0.2995319068,
-0.5016047955,
-0.1806964278,
-0.3151737154,
-0.5919985771,
0.6036128402,
0.1677330136,
-0.1543019414,
0.1767292768,
-0.5312405825,
0.7375053167,
0.3698785007,
0.011033182,
0.2296074778,
0.2229404896,
-0.2958495021,
-0.1168880984,
-0.4849813282,
-0.5239328146,
1.3172284365,
0.3526099324,
0.6984269023,
0.3556191325,
0.5735858679,
0.204512462,
0.5810104609,
-0.7628749609,
0.7405458093,
-0.3460499942,
-0.6368530393,
-0.3424165845,
-0.8864172697,
-1.0311145782,
0.447778523,
-0.1636819094,
-0.3868620992,
-0.4651915729,
-0.0677270964,
-0.0696204305,
0.4786207378,
-0.5999245048,
0.8117123842,
-0.3920260668,
-0.3302122056,
-0.0644384921,
-0.0832755715,
0.52931422,
-0.342069,
0.4832149744,
-0.0037331115,
0.2604648471,
0.6939353347,
-0.6368581653,
0.6200793982,
-0.1921849847,
-0.3294782341,
0.4922858775,
0.6493621469,
0.5663262606,
0.0493072346,
-0.0694782808,
0.0101507772,
-0.2127045989,
-0.4388960302,
-0.8618593812,
0.9289102554,
-0.7707711458,
-0.9613419175,
-0.5171318054,
-0.6766763926,
-0.2880171835,
0.039589718,
0.0019082348,
0.5092616677,
-0.1654553562,
0.0492286608,
0.5717970729,
-0.4288163483,
0.2793041766,
0.4813540876,
-0.3015037477,
-0.4506992698,
1.2294578552,
0.128774628,
0.3261471391,
-0.193887949,
0.4175606966,
-0.1976922601,
-0.6952733994,
-0.3109999597,
0.0278830994,
-0.909039855,
-0.3619701862,
-0.2943355441,
-0.3616751134,
-0.2647019625,
-0.2425999492,
-0.227571547,
-0.5035008788,
-0.2898834646,
0.0011252169,
0.1752108932,
0.7722510695,
0.1140109375,
0.124777399,
-0.6192529798,
0.3051376045,
0.5900625587,
0.1384731233,
0.0346592218,
-0.4603516161,
0.2472387105,
0.0775501281,
-0.7451732159,
-0.7324749231,
0.300534457,
-0.1755950004,
0.3354257643,
-0.0233283732,
0.0014789389,
0.5240392089,
-0.5721439719,
0.6843720675,
0.3594078124,
-1.0991499424,
0.4219136536,
-0.1691148132,
0.1016654894,
0.234028846,
0.2187961489,
-0.26517573,
-0.7100993991,
-0.8102991581,
-0.8292071223,
0.4151590466,
0.4734178782,
0.2869550884,
-0.1213016137,
0.4266782403,
-0.1594412029,
0.0973046124,
-0.8064938784,
-0.2479447871,
-0.1580306292,
-0.3973545432,
0.0217035599,
-0.1817338169,
-0.4364408255,
-0.0074869543,
0.5572945476,
0.0091646165,
-0.2126056552,
0.0655288771,
-0.1347721517,
-0.267032057,
0.4616877735,
0.503855288,
0.6289179325,
0.1472813636,
0.2709827423,
0.2342192531,
-0.2463757545,
0.1914364398,
0.175456509,
-0.2125915885,
-0.083132267,
0.3474593759,
0.455683291,
-0.0813986361,
-0.887345612,
0.8795813918,
-0.1656838208,
-0.4427422583,
-0.5692059398,
0.030818237,
0.1075065807,
-0.0072209793,
0.3300518095,
0.0881983414,
-0.0422675237,
-0.5524947047,
0.1748816371,
0.8481579423,
-0.0872288793,
-0.2074114233,
0.5699428916,
0.1455297321,
-0.6111604571,
0.539969027,
-0.2752286494,
-0.9753604531,
0.8532448411,
0.6657696366,
0.684052825,
-0.1803992093,
0.1582119912,
-0.0266380943,
0.411986798,
0.1231342256,
0.226473093,
0.4274215996,
-0.6126143932,
-0.1918506026,
-0.5393173099,
-0.4833637774,
0.5688514113,
-0.3985804915,
0.2149436474,
-0.6766986251,
0.0227511339,
0.0665240437,
-0.0303575844,
-0.3347214758,
0.195851028,
0.237478897,
0.5614647269,
-0.6645227671,
0.2596566081,
0.6422011852,
-0.1984672397,
-0.6382020116,
-0.2035186142,
0.1207187101,
-1.0080634356,
0.691141665,
-0.0745647699,
-0.1192094088,
-0.1865913272,
-0.5675407648,
-0.4395781755,
0.8363013864,
0.75608778,
-0.4473464191,
-0.2397380024,
0.3595888913,
0.4457387328,
0.0705283135,
0.0000604751,
0.3462695479,
0.278766185,
0.0822943151,
-0.7100684047,
0.1957866848,
-0.2527589798,
-0.0952554345,
0.3653174937,
-0.353223294,
1.1114382744,
-0.299577415,
-0.2113663703,
-0.0251468699,
0.2251855582,
0.4746598899,
0.3100245595,
0.541402638,
0.9323166609,
0.6854670048,
-0.0955178589,
0.9648045301,
-0.0315342806,
0.2998487055,
1.0635316372,
-0.0809183791,
0.5599544644,
0.4453396201,
-0.3142277598,
0.1512206942,
0.1563380957,
-0.2681017518,
0.0814041272,
1.099119544,
-0.3388152421,
-0.2808123231,
0.0362413824,
-0.4532696605,
0.5001183152,
0.4656427801,
-0.1981771886,
-0.5383861065,
-0.055301901,
0.2968375385,
0.5915976167,
-0.3669552505,
0.3331437409,
0.1734323353,
-0.4765108824,
0.6045415401,
0.3302581012,
0.5338460803,
-0.5297584534,
-0.1065061912,
-0.1546127498,
0.387481004,
-0.0816031843,
-0.6591285467,
0.3681462407,
0.3046990335,
0.1439018846,
-0.0049776006,
0.4327804744,
-0.3146314323,
-0.8593204618,
0.2613639235,
0.5380589962,
0.051517494,
-0.0725730807,
-0.8431666493,
0.1516972631,
-0.251313746,
-0.1499960721,
0.4786961973,
0.5886337757,
-0.0011078223,
0.8005369902,
0.7717812657,
0.1973948926,
0.0416119695,
-0.0398786254,
0.8909383416,
-0.3584124744,
-0.2626366913,
-1.098064065,
0.0564729236,
-0.0208744705,
-0.2904658616,
0.8349589109,
0.4143751562,
0.8225328326,
0.2399777025,
0.7397681475,
0.4503149986,
0.2056183368,
-0.3664365113,
0.8050857186,
-0.6837342978,
0.5808641315,
-0.424579829,
-0.5658124089,
-0.3651352525,
0.3192166686,
-0.1877603382,
-0.1270823628,
0.6915363073,
0.5714459419,
0.2061633468,
-0.0474782325,
0.3902748227,
0.2194606215,
0.5806934237,
0.9558675289,
0.9955117106,
-0.5154787302,
1.0778907537,
-0.1598351449,
-0.2684724331,
0.0619587377,
-0.6706385612,
-0.9955846667,
-0.1626509279,
-0.4946420193,
-0.7567789555,
0.1305659264,
0.6232519746,
-0.0698025823,
-0.5932146907,
-0.0364584327,
-0.2175569832,
0.420956552,
0.3142065406,
-0.3056549728,
0.4926437736,
-0.297352761,
-0.6199510694,
0.4359947145,
0.0446555912,
0.2797164619,
-0.543177247,
0.1961853206,
0.4328935146,
0.3649142683,
0.4275163412,
-0.0935018137,
-0.6313663721,
-0.184604615,
-0.0927965716,
-0.228326261,
-0.2562386096,
0.8174293041,
-0.5693898797,
0.3412999511,
0.2446292192,
0.9965143204,
-0.1707143635,
-0.1042859331,
0.4382066429,
-0.5737450719,
-0.1820026785,
0.4620868862,
0.4547408819,
0.4092065096,
-0.2785224319,
0.2235084325,
0.5372616649,
-0.2676425874,
-1.1896466017,
0.303982079,
-0.3734934926,
-0.6504436135,
1.0487799644,
-0.3859170079,
-0.2719755769,
0.0789223686,
-0.0335645489,
-0.0283714868,
0.0778242052,
1.0012931824,
0.8709520698,
0.3686396778,
0.4332068861,
-0.2856394351,
0.2505837679,
0.6442878246,
-0.7643762231,
0.1996632218,
0.4341593087,
0.389960289,
0.3021305501,
0.2671968937,
-0.5590008497,
0.2480085641,
0.0732457936,
-0.1946494877,
-0.5406587124,
-0.1805717647,
-0.5707485676,
0.667789042,
0.1791845113,
-0.0164396223
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.