id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17914v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17914v2
|
Extracting Lexical Features from Dialects via Interpretable Dialect Classifiers
| 2024-02-27T22:06:55 | 2024-03-23T20:21:04 |
Roy Xie, Orevaoghene Ahia, Yulia Tsvetkov, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Identifying linguistic differences between dialects of a language often
requires expert knowledge and meticulous human analysis. This is largely due to
the complexity and nuance involved in studying various dialects. We present a
novel approach to extract distinguishing lexical features of dialects by
utilizing interpretable dialect classifiers, even in the absence of human
experts. We explore both post-hoc and intrinsic approaches to interpretability,
conduct experiments on Mandarin, Italian, and Low Saxon, and experimentally
demonstrate that our method successfully identifies key language-specific
lexical features that contribute to dialectal variations.
|
[
-0.6002749801,
-0.4126055241,
0.585626483,
0.1161996201,
-0.0465453267,
-0.0373025015,
-0.4209748805,
-0.7777545452,
0.5027617216,
0.5971256495,
-0.2367973179,
-0.1619528532,
-0.4689466357,
0.065098308,
-0.2078129947,
0.6977297068,
0.5088017583,
-0.0604966991,
0.2694181204,
-0.3142946959,
-0.2105170786,
-0.5894140005,
-0.340464443,
-0.2008287609,
0.2921506763,
0.38858518,
0.9607756734,
0.4746674001,
0.2507734299,
0.31822595,
-0.5035789013,
0.2076502144,
-0.0262202919,
-0.1015159339,
-0.3394035399,
-0.5797811151,
-0.3380942047,
-0.2503822744,
0.5158413649,
1.0260083675,
0.0912575126,
-0.0903151035,
0.1042035222,
0.5761187673,
-0.5525326729,
0.4081990421,
-0.8689153194,
-0.0177490395,
-0.7155725956,
-0.0356211513,
-0.3040057123,
-0.3496144414,
0.3228118718,
-0.4893973172,
0.6514381766,
-0.2411200702,
0.8938880563,
-0.1825555265,
-0.2197107375,
-0.1553485841,
-0.4858598709,
0.5700079203,
-0.8059242964,
0.4113503397,
0.2130828649,
0.4395629764,
0.082402043,
-0.4988377988,
-0.4700978696,
-0.2840518355,
-0.3941274285,
0.0605172589,
0.2633750439,
-0.0112117277,
0.0706828386,
0.5322039723,
-0.2673015893,
0.0293444227,
-0.1851058453,
-0.2375860661,
0.6182927489,
0.0519236475,
0.2506322861,
-0.4725584388,
0.1302205473,
0.1808477193,
-0.5875312686,
0.3243477941,
0.2660323381,
0.6555275917,
0.0451975241,
0.1714190096,
-0.5049468279,
0.4631029665,
0.0091773476,
0.1621906012,
0.2378487736,
-0.0935334563,
0.2756800354,
-0.0160610955,
0.3768089414,
-0.2059056312,
0.3875556886,
-0.1690419763,
-0.4403766096,
-0.4799364805,
0.1034122258,
-0.3609244525,
-0.5398865938,
-0.1632818729,
-0.4930317104,
-0.5200083256,
0.3661872149,
-1.0473445654,
-0.5908809304,
0.02040907,
0.2707598209,
-0.2933437228,
-0.8280169964,
-0.011983267,
-0.5750747919,
0.5110058784,
0.2265839726,
-1.3264217377,
0.4592038393,
0.7380087376,
0.858702302,
-0.0685661286,
-0.2123344839,
-0.1974750161,
-0.1799633056,
-0.4880520105,
0.6872208714,
-0.8017089367,
-0.2873258293,
-0.1052915975,
0.0467819087,
-0.0435062759,
-0.8402925134,
0.1819365174,
-0.6067121625,
-0.2375717461,
-0.2170292139,
-0.309994787,
-0.4078407884,
-0.1099038422,
-0.9338106513,
0.9976974726,
0.6266207695,
-0.6901125908,
0.2332691699,
-0.4204098582,
-0.494620353,
0.2701131999,
-0.1249545589,
-0.0402290598,
0.7508113384,
0.1922784895,
0.1777304113,
-0.2216902077,
0.1847045124,
-0.1926178783,
-0.1899361014,
0.5154109001,
-0.4449954629,
0.9152484536,
0.2492271215,
-0.5575942397,
-0.030553123,
-1.1066257954,
0.3043285012,
0.1034115478,
0.0310528353,
-0.42335096,
0.2871429026,
0.2218622267,
-0.0297521856,
0.2390132993,
-0.313526392,
-0.0766443759,
-0.6259830594,
0.4625955522,
0.6252215505,
-0.2473842949,
0.4643044472,
-0.1563532054,
0.4684233069,
-0.0328972563,
-0.2345322073,
0.0554712638,
-0.3880455494,
-0.9396969676,
-0.3485844135,
0.4113556743,
0.5478743911,
-0.8049646616,
0.5367513895,
-0.2087377757,
-0.8104910254,
-0.2710803747,
0.163236782,
0.5025641322,
0.2655802667,
0.3225083649,
-0.4993653893,
-0.2454042584,
-0.7064651251,
-0.4135336578,
-0.3139584064,
-0.1453786641,
0.2763425708,
0.1265089661,
-0.0225122664,
1.0739188194,
-0.6074326634,
0.0239448603,
-0.7634168267,
0.2270336896,
0.1356987208,
0.1018379256,
0.7045086026,
-0.6757958531,
-0.3790234923,
0.6455023289,
-0.5551084876,
-0.7177212238,
-0.1652859002,
0.034014497,
0.016635403,
0.6170501113,
-0.1633781493,
0.3085560799,
0.1713821143,
-0.226142019,
0.7388183475,
0.0608118623,
-0.1168317422,
-0.5750265121,
-0.181444034,
-0.0915979519,
-0.3240860403,
-0.8081451058,
0.2238397002,
0.1826542914,
0.0541118681,
-0.3341741562,
0.7574647069,
-0.4436875284,
-0.0713388175,
0.0539400168,
0.081319131,
0.1874361783,
0.2943530977,
0.5618540049,
0.3996634483,
0.4520597756,
-0.3438888788,
0.1855395287,
0.0934119523,
-0.4702032506,
0.3312271535,
-0.4516347945,
0.0423624441,
0.00129989,
-0.3727914393,
-1.068428874,
-0.4096265435,
-0.0148294363,
-0.4926920533,
0.1562615335,
-0.2770924866,
0.140624553,
0.2370213419,
-0.0600039251,
0.2335584164,
0.3610112369,
-0.5326330066,
0.6278218031,
0.26065889,
-0.5259816647,
-0.2342115343,
-0.5223878026,
-0.0759628415,
-0.3718076944,
-0.3895618021,
-0.095404692,
0.6115870476,
-0.6303344965,
-0.0257062875,
-0.0912876949,
-0.5774235129,
0.3197885752,
0.1204841584,
0.0304759331,
-0.5905316472,
0.1359164268,
-0.0117142033,
-0.0757881105,
-0.0297764707,
-0.1971995234,
0.4316855967,
-0.2265381664,
-0.0950182751,
-0.4847014546,
0.3702000976,
0.4670346975,
-0.2931374311,
0.5601714253,
0.6304633617,
-0.1864788383,
-0.3458013833,
-0.5938555598,
-0.0793564692,
-0.5094346404,
0.5321516395,
-0.7156596184,
-0.5472867489,
0.705232203,
-0.165182814,
-0.2821023166,
0.4618079662,
0.2024215609,
0.0080799479,
0.7331305742,
0.6266264319,
-0.1620465666,
0.7448130846,
0.2682338357,
0.0481969602,
-0.382874608,
0.0645137057,
-0.7299683094,
0.0738537386,
-0.5991787314,
-0.1190285608,
0.4457278252,
0.0732506216,
0.0751976371,
0.2550995052,
-0.1125175655,
0.6567644477,
0.4572689235,
0.1561515033,
0.1340501755,
-0.2003735155,
-0.130671367,
-0.1267103106,
-0.2234270722,
-0.4673525691,
0.7144162655,
0.1548034549,
0.6729357839,
0.5386521816,
0.5990402102,
0.3582572639,
-0.0326533094,
-1.0089423656,
0.5065056682,
-0.2294154167,
-0.5295960903,
-0.445292443,
-0.5942863226,
-0.6434841752,
0.5403179526,
-0.3089343011,
-0.6009800434,
0.3464630842,
0.0761120096,
-0.2083011866,
0.1637623608,
-0.9429113269,
0.9415127635,
-0.3362311125,
0.0902755484,
0.0335555561,
-0.769266963,
-0.1000210494,
-0.2725327313,
0.5975852609,
0.0885705128,
0.0782414824,
0.4240912795,
-0.579970777,
0.8602019548,
-0.3283237517,
0.062281061,
0.1244799122,
0.3790421784,
0.0042183325,
-0.0647641271,
-0.3155558407,
0.5780800581,
0.3617170453,
-0.5278146267,
-0.7159504294,
0.0600979216,
-0.8424976468,
-0.7404282093,
-0.3695316613,
-0.3509926498,
-0.3900189996,
0.4284226596,
0.278072834,
0.7972175479,
-0.512632668,
-0.2489126623,
0.399869591,
-0.1242127493,
0.4061544836,
0.4720813334,
-0.1512273252,
-0.3002464771,
1.15729177,
0.120156303,
0.6439166665,
0.4196645021,
0.5495687723,
-0.1348545998,
-0.9943370223,
-0.5771616697,
0.109149754,
-0.6360337734,
0.4915616512,
-0.1387452781,
-0.3632662296,
-0.6080180407,
-0.3284976482,
-0.4459089637,
-0.826002717,
-0.2070643455,
0.0874743089,
-0.0428784937,
1.1873874664,
-0.1736805588,
0.5123118162,
-1.0827598572,
0.0370432287,
0.3593385816,
-0.1704671532,
-0.0074261376,
-0.6317867041,
-0.1341161281,
-0.1739634275,
-0.0209602788,
-1.102149725,
0.5516038537,
0.6424187422,
0.6680921912,
0.9752185345,
0.0861736834,
0.7337653637,
-0.3280938268,
0.83345294,
-0.0765529722,
-1.4564193487,
0.4782208502,
-0.1293266416,
0.067417793,
0.6214649677,
0.3027010262,
-0.6745544672,
-0.4351868033,
-0.3155718744,
-0.8218123317,
0.813472569,
0.0925823599,
0.0070129689,
-0.0604962669,
0.446054697,
0.3036936224,
0.0843340531,
-0.5305792093,
0.1312175095,
-0.2113208473,
-0.2067732662,
-0.3347700536,
-0.2938902378,
0.0205069669,
-0.2288067043,
0.1915665865,
-0.1669179499,
-0.0915794522,
0.0874296948,
-0.5989295244,
0.344856739,
0.4370768964,
0.169129312,
0.7854412794,
-0.1496113688,
0.6738315225,
0.2243439704,
-0.5386961699,
0.0072743837,
0.0011922271,
0.0407622382,
0.1938828528,
0.7939773798,
0.5137491822,
0.0604938939,
-0.6957292557,
0.533823967,
0.0087896539,
0.1855929494,
-0.4338711202,
0.16918464,
-0.1177237332,
0.3471736014,
0.080615513,
0.1880617887,
0.4467842579,
-0.7213901281,
0.1129394397,
0.2607775331,
-0.7021694779,
-0.5865707994,
0.247483328,
0.231056273,
-0.0939405113,
0.4570893943,
-0.475327462,
-0.7701575756,
0.8423570991,
0.3316667974,
0.6975795627,
-0.2853643894,
0.2767002285,
0.0309892427,
0.1080180407,
0.1165958643,
0.0386082269,
-0.3609416187,
-1.0049831867,
0.1779245883,
-0.5561976433,
-0.5737203956,
-0.3321432769,
-1.2784935236,
0.3093334436,
-0.2956044972,
0.2180294693,
0.5592538714,
-0.4240577519,
-0.3040117919,
0.004518169,
0.2559851408,
0.6742165089,
-1.1006275415,
0.7980250716,
0.6877070665,
-0.0302401464,
-0.7220432758,
0.2670998871,
0.3957207799,
-0.8449215293,
0.6831770539,
0.1648494005,
-0.3370580673,
-0.1728943288,
-0.1713900417,
-0.5165070891,
0.3124564588,
0.1192317307,
-0.2993804514,
0.0721850991,
0.5027189255,
0.6622990966,
-0.0384358279,
0.6574875116,
1.0440990925,
0.2765733004,
0.201190576,
-1.0409018993,
-0.1162056401,
-0.3501184285,
0.024533933,
0.2733947039,
-0.4882369339,
0.964640379,
-0.0471990854,
-0.1219494417,
0.1526162773,
0.4643787742,
-0.3133353293,
0.3538167775,
0.6932468414,
0.2773471177,
0.8573460579,
-0.2121466249,
0.4611433148,
-0.2023426294,
0.4442615807,
1.0491892099,
-0.246839419,
0.8985388279,
0.0960116982,
-0.3323165476,
0.3968451917,
0.7388292551,
0.400323391,
0.6237831712,
0.0336016938,
-0.6499444246,
-0.5251101851,
0.1077299193,
-0.3619323969,
0.8870657086,
0.69258219,
-0.1634448171,
-0.127875194,
-0.1325260997,
0.2223757356,
-0.0899739638,
-0.3696376681,
0.9514248967,
-0.1178685129,
-0.4855631888,
0.6647468209,
-0.3414613008,
0.5827067494,
-0.61244452,
-0.1002040282,
-0.2155352682,
0.2782896757,
-0.5161353946,
-0.7005285621,
0.5537048578,
-0.1043336242,
0.0479614325,
0.0940155387,
0.5150156617,
-0.1562401354,
-0.3608757257,
0.35155949,
0.7976035476,
0.3496640921,
-0.1766925156,
-0.1139094457,
-0.2644385397,
0.1020327285,
-0.108317174,
0.1115216687,
0.8105475903,
-0.0553120524,
0.253810674,
0.2190820277,
0.5167530775,
0.0729530752,
0.0278750416,
0.8015007377,
-1.077886343,
-0.450317204,
-0.7892382741,
0.1788603067,
0.0165523402,
-0.3834929466,
0.5715444088,
0.1302465349,
0.8723589182,
-0.1021902636,
0.9981613755,
-0.4747748077,
0.5868727565,
-0.5548270345,
0.7256859541,
-0.6022979021,
0.4081940055,
-0.190724194,
-0.620415628,
-0.233669728,
0.7620282769,
-0.2676045597,
-0.1043873802,
0.7053111196,
0.9488776326,
0.0325515978,
0.3826738596,
0.3174982965,
0.3403293192,
0.3225403428,
0.2037686855,
1.2026206255,
0.3608095646,
0.3009565771,
-0.4269764423,
-0.4759747684,
-0.0522887856,
-0.6331328154,
-0.986525774,
-0.4554989338,
0.0928740576,
-0.3685984612,
0.0329091772,
0.9209756851,
0.7468767762,
-1.2220864296,
-0.2804991305,
0.0908229724,
0.3569808006,
-0.6208156347,
-0.3303879797,
0.215539977,
-0.5018781424,
-0.7896440625,
0.2954015434,
0.0163322613,
-0.3345792294,
-0.1198546067,
0.3840840161,
0.3105850518,
0.25714311,
0.4968676567,
0.3787455261,
-0.6987475157,
-0.7447394133,
-0.2731190622,
0.1214995161,
0.1663951725,
0.9306444526,
-0.5051240921,
0.7554033399,
0.5904145837,
0.4503595233,
0.2359675765,
-0.0349443518,
0.3099068403,
-0.7300105095,
0.4741896093,
0.1689927131,
0.3858659863,
0.1119314283,
-0.2651003301,
0.5339557528,
0.4996347725,
-0.310048908,
-0.4089677334,
0.297698617,
-1.2296215296,
-0.2203980982,
1.0798422098,
-0.5977697968,
-0.0031609554,
-0.7461474538,
-0.2308665365,
-0.1500858665,
-0.0962489173,
0.7596734762,
0.7397560477,
-0.34547773,
-0.2294627577,
-0.4758737385,
0.4473739862,
0.2106225044,
-0.6969964504,
-0.0240829829,
0.375392884,
0.4389109015,
0.2582363784,
0.2853510976,
-0.183912158,
0.1194161177,
0.233179912,
-0.0849188566,
0.2224197239,
-0.3524810076,
-0.5763750076,
0.0986960679,
0.4970171452,
0.1018726304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17897v2
|
A Language Model based Framework for New Concept Placement in Ontologies
| 2024-02-27T21:27:35 | 2024-03-04T14:06:42 |
Hang Dong, Jiaoyan Chen, Yuan He, Yongsheng Gao, Ian Horrocks
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; I.2.4
|
We investigate the task of inserting new concepts extracted from texts into
an ontology using language models. We explore an approach with three steps:
edge search which is to find a set of candidate locations to insert (i.e.,
subsumptions between concepts), edge formation and enrichment which leverages
the ontological structure to produce and enhance the edge candidates, and edge
selection which eventually locates the edge to be placed into. In all steps, we
propose to leverage neural methods, where we apply embedding-based methods and
contrastive learning with Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) such as BERT for
edge search, and adapt a BERT fine-tuning-based multi-label Edge-Cross-encoder,
and Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT series, FLAN-T5, and Llama 2, for
edge selection. We evaluate the methods on recent datasets created using the
SNOMED CT ontology and the MedMentions entity linking benchmark. The best
settings in our framework use fine-tuned PLM for search and a multi-label
Cross-encoder for selection. Zero-shot prompting of LLMs is still not adequate
for the task, and we propose explainable instruction tuning of LLMs for
improved performance. Our study shows the advantages of PLMs and highlights the
encouraging performance of LLMs that motivates future studies.
|
[
-0.4216415286,
-0.882378459,
0.7288407087,
-0.2815363109,
0.0028273,
0.0474101417,
-0.0623279437,
-0.3388867378,
0.1338445246,
0.8573315144,
-0.5027768016,
-0.7922682762,
-0.470784694,
-0.0471203849,
-0.358645618,
0.8614473343,
0.0955636054,
0.0128456438,
-0.0770853162,
0.0846559331,
-0.2647691071,
-0.3477284312,
-0.6354172826,
-0.583171308,
0.3254207373,
0.3112007082,
0.7499256134,
1.0399935246,
0.6551442742,
0.2668835819,
-0.4780607224,
0.1996425539,
-0.2528109252,
0.0065243198,
-0.4905098379,
-0.4660004675,
-0.4423148632,
-0.0403909124,
0.5685527921,
0.6631804109,
-0.1399526447,
-0.2708514929,
-0.2220704108,
0.1552147716,
-0.4722460806,
-0.1295036376,
-0.812261939,
0.1184743717,
-0.1750756651,
-0.1861287504,
-0.202542007,
-0.3892789185,
0.7008501291,
-0.7234950662,
0.0951180384,
-0.1923111528,
0.8983787298,
0.0892810896,
-0.2742592096,
-0.6772739887,
-0.2901367545,
0.8449771404,
-0.7410861254,
0.4895559549,
0.0714724362,
0.066074498,
-0.114533186,
-0.9487275481,
-0.6238086224,
-0.1255122572,
0.2041777074,
-0.0744749829,
0.2105125487,
0.1747534126,
-0.1311608702,
0.2576686442,
-0.2437656969,
0.5510228276,
0.0940946341,
-0.0493239388,
0.5237293243,
0.1164281815,
0.4287448227,
-0.241957292,
-0.4408094287,
-0.2362723053,
-0.8917194605,
-0.2903932333,
0.2305055708,
0.7347974181,
0.086306341,
0.5309861302,
-0.0969611257,
0.697506845,
-0.1347866952,
-0.3984882534,
0.2812670767,
-0.5347038507,
0.1322306246,
0.0706450641,
0.4172350168,
0.3658840954,
0.0841770247,
-0.1107358783,
-0.3439100683,
0.1794657856,
0.1139741242,
-0.5379234552,
-0.186290279,
0.1528895199,
-0.4382365048,
-0.4509897828,
-0.2774170339,
-0.3972058594,
-0.4041130543,
-0.203752771,
0.4761364162,
-0.7649475932,
-0.3676685095,
0.1427965462,
-0.2494933754,
0.2539164424,
0.2882482409,
-0.877376616,
0.407194823,
0.810964942,
0.6829563975,
-0.1277368516,
-0.1442504227,
-0.0981458798,
0.239471823,
-0.3718294799,
1.0586901903,
-0.8138293624,
-0.3587595224,
0.4109005332,
-0.2727133036,
0.135319978,
-0.3603211939,
0.5738322139,
-0.6757234931,
0.1655337512,
-0.264965713,
-0.8935078979,
-0.3042627871,
0.3562000096,
-0.419731915,
1.0375115871,
0.0660100803,
-0.7082116008,
0.1377415359,
-1.0572208166,
-0.3803392053,
0.0857298821,
-0.2964877188,
-0.0597676672,
-0.0619777925,
-0.0623941869,
0.4282813072,
-0.3744944334,
-0.0773315504,
-0.0170639474,
-0.1469828933,
0.3356829882,
0.0399261601,
0.7734547257,
0.3447335362,
-0.0368187539,
-0.0667212754,
-0.5344874859,
0.2439906746,
0.0944298357,
-0.141131267,
-0.5661875606,
0.1209296435,
-0.0030270815,
0.3872624934,
0.3134386241,
-0.6850283146,
0.363122344,
-0.6065441966,
0.5702992678,
0.5238231421,
-0.1301791072,
0.5673328638,
-0.1702984124,
0.3126896024,
-0.0227173511,
0.0403622948,
-0.2572675943,
-0.2717506289,
-0.6867758632,
0.1713239104,
0.5613325238,
0.619592607,
-0.8529452682,
0.5845466256,
-0.3357534409,
-0.2397359163,
-0.5327330232,
0.2615384459,
0.4092475772,
0.541958034,
0.3734078407,
-0.2762206197,
-0.3222199976,
-0.6579880714,
0.3782098293,
0.0904559344,
0.1047306433,
0.1810890436,
0.2890093327,
-0.389759928,
1.1402152777,
-0.8553039432,
-0.5003612041,
-0.2406255156,
0.04771851,
-0.0124455318,
0.4037728906,
0.1921481043,
-1.0478241444,
-0.2026492953,
0.1159866974,
-0.678591013,
-0.1181147769,
0.3009646833,
-0.0350616947,
0.1269034147,
0.626896441,
-0.4337026477,
0.2050226629,
0.4804509878,
-0.0370653346,
0.2342080623,
-0.2351582646,
-0.3085848093,
-1.4759087563,
-0.2182563841,
-0.0312974714,
0.1451710612,
-0.6867569089,
0.2539601028,
-0.1508080363,
0.0193162411,
-0.6793827415,
0.6350780129,
-0.3981105983,
-0.105386056,
-0.4689599574,
0.8082473874,
0.1902331859,
0.0998997986,
0.3857873082,
0.2555061579,
0.5787349343,
-0.8982272148,
0.1997200847,
0.8360221386,
-0.393761903,
0.4749546945,
-0.4362266064,
0.0368694626,
0.0691417083,
0.199850902,
-0.7856062651,
0.2820963562,
0.0634674802,
-0.3191260695,
0.1803482175,
-0.1825743765,
-0.4767661393,
-0.0977458358,
-0.1498900056,
0.170051083,
0.4475753903,
-0.522308588,
0.4593432248,
0.6615852118,
-0.4176621139,
-0.5364175439,
-0.7564900517,
0.0205938406,
0.0832309574,
-0.7323083878,
0.9223899245,
0.206079334,
-0.2364496887,
0.3170641959,
0.1431557834,
-0.0434346385,
0.1383251101,
-0.0460756384,
0.0902888775,
-0.3261230886,
0.6609424353,
0.159589842,
-0.2597309649,
-0.1602623463,
-0.6311935782,
0.5748122334,
0.1381373405,
-0.1872944832,
-0.1413508654,
0.3355585635,
-0.1339934468,
-0.504291594,
0.4933893383,
0.3951661587,
-0.4048636556,
-0.3150700331,
-0.6123613715,
-0.3570850194,
-0.4684096277,
0.5090171099,
-0.4902106822,
-0.9537290335,
0.407314986,
-0.3979535401,
0.2751199007,
0.3703199625,
0.3284425735,
-0.1721548736,
1.0540351868,
0.9756597877,
0.4468422532,
0.5911974311,
-0.5371608734,
0.3185334504,
-0.9391420484,
-0.1586016417,
-0.4629457593,
-0.0475141816,
-0.9461199045,
-0.6240600944,
0.1630877703,
0.1076064035,
0.1368486732,
0.0898638591,
-0.4839773178,
0.2528495789,
0.3944406509,
-0.1156598628,
0.3801285923,
-0.0276982728,
-0.5145642161,
0.1159652472,
-0.8942371607,
-0.7083857059,
1.0807051659,
0.3916268051,
0.8273465037,
0.0651507303,
0.7437797189,
-0.1068392918,
0.2714094222,
-0.5803307295,
0.6015122533,
-0.6314130425,
-0.5520936847,
-0.6900598407,
-0.1828378886,
-0.9300746918,
0.0545349196,
-0.4380330443,
-0.7672997117,
0.0405182652,
-0.0114106368,
-0.536624372,
0.3957026601,
-0.3208868802,
0.6055172682,
-0.3797048032,
-0.200061962,
-0.1908863485,
-0.7393581271,
-0.0050595752,
0.0349668041,
0.0693659708,
-0.2634468973,
-0.210914731,
0.5201284885,
-0.384290427,
0.6533468962,
-0.0329094641,
-0.528958261,
0.3491685688,
-0.1785969883,
0.4112896621,
-0.1561743617,
-0.3886120021,
0.0537597351,
-0.1202235669,
-0.1284951717,
-0.7463753223,
0.7982983589,
-0.6334303617,
-0.6532306671,
-0.0581337363,
-0.5658141971,
-0.098356463,
0.1317455322,
0.3889620602,
0.4061603248,
-0.1858265251,
0.0021187461,
1.0183497667,
-0.3669634163,
0.3869533837,
0.5769066215,
-0.3898151517,
-0.1744202524,
1.0429083109,
0.4804589748,
0.2983256876,
0.7729682326,
0.3304343522,
-0.6733981371,
-0.6867079139,
-0.1818846613,
0.0910313353,
-0.8197824359,
-0.1636699885,
-1.0074951649,
-0.5227991939,
-0.6747375727,
-0.2725328505,
-0.5202069283,
-0.3774501085,
-0.0255820211,
-0.1589950621,
0.54514575,
0.7047032714,
-0.0528656691,
0.6467226744,
-0.8309746981,
-0.0577119514,
0.1835086793,
0.4283208251,
-0.0699090734,
-0.5190514326,
-0.3116971254,
0.0176139213,
-0.4025038183,
-0.468113035,
0.1986272484,
0.0739122927,
0.7346616387,
0.5264974236,
-0.0355122425,
0.2690453231,
-0.4410521388,
0.4734483361,
0.1120310053,
-0.9952359796,
0.7537598014,
-0.3393225968,
0.1548270881,
0.5063775778,
0.5321732163,
-0.645129025,
-0.1280795038,
-0.6358910203,
-0.68638134,
0.4589892626,
0.0377999432,
0.3041315377,
-0.0510068648,
0.475956738,
0.166218251,
0.1434734017,
-0.7508840561,
-0.2156905085,
-0.0557932407,
-0.2573365569,
0.1155744269,
-0.2291665375,
-0.0706238449,
0.1497036815,
0.6151606441,
-0.3217355311,
0.1472577155,
0.0835005194,
-0.146433562,
0.2384696454,
0.1351498216,
0.3433743417,
0.6948009133,
-0.0877596661,
0.0953142568,
0.2539406717,
-0.0509909913,
0.1694892645,
0.2863222361,
-0.3676480651,
-0.000376056,
0.2320913374,
0.7141284943,
0.246384576,
-0.6140118241,
0.3818182349,
0.2228683978,
-0.1756940782,
-0.2217177898,
0.0444871821,
0.2420826703,
0.2119793445,
0.1506756097,
-0.4683426023,
0.1753711998,
-0.4920819998,
0.3165104687,
0.3789573014,
-0.4043421447,
-0.1982579678,
0.1939462274,
0.453157872,
-0.4442625344,
0.7141082883,
-0.361880511,
-0.6748496294,
0.3291611671,
0.5485687256,
0.598356545,
-0.5402083397,
0.4635219872,
-0.0286067799,
0.1145383343,
-0.1089990214,
0.485627383,
0.2893662155,
-1.4074056149,
-0.4859758914,
-0.5584515333,
-0.4379380345,
-0.0318619274,
-0.3408765197,
0.4703507125,
-0.3125498593,
-0.3702646792,
0.0328534395,
0.1537666172,
-0.5671231151,
0.4073723257,
0.2905054092,
1.0259617567,
-0.9104112983,
0.8994697332,
0.8199759126,
-0.4821920395,
-0.5775775909,
-0.0168335345,
-0.1248814166,
-0.622004509,
0.6913794875,
-0.0064666811,
-0.1002436876,
0.2064256817,
-0.2809286416,
-1.190875411,
0.9948966503,
0.1090381145,
-0.2452487946,
-0.3131155372,
0.1162947342,
0.6531377435,
-0.7634508014,
0.3015687764,
0.3940723538,
0.3324765563,
0.1923425347,
-0.4227059782,
-0.0554071367,
-0.0488233939,
0.3967708349,
0.2509409189,
-0.5641174316,
1.1151515245,
-0.229880318,
-0.0928854942,
0.1587399989,
0.4610740244,
0.2698251307,
0.0025083809,
0.5054877996,
0.8290951848,
0.6335905194,
-0.0045895698,
0.9309405684,
-0.4153915346,
0.0485749431,
1.1165356636,
-0.6191238165,
0.9806770682,
0.4026010633,
0.0978645533,
0.7947337627,
0.7604079247,
0.0342906602,
0.7543576956,
0.4836355448,
-0.1180337295,
-0.1544098705,
-0.7774487138,
-0.4536983669,
0.6805830002,
0.7482807636,
-0.4405275583,
-0.1717267632,
0.1460570991,
-0.1381786019,
0.1648083031,
-0.1483745128,
0.8646876812,
0.2263295949,
-0.517852962,
0.1404160261,
0.256719768,
0.6489741802,
-0.6965976954,
-0.2194781452,
-0.1511916667,
0.0901234597,
-0.1774909943,
-0.7334982157,
0.0184674207,
-0.4096475542,
-0.0903973505,
-0.2527983189,
0.7812088132,
-0.4634414613,
-0.5709526539,
0.6510358453,
0.6563650966,
0.0515731424,
0.3455730379,
-0.6609550714,
0.0259955525,
-0.225319311,
-0.0793068558,
0.2183845192,
0.6372205615,
-0.2047587484,
0.7380626202,
0.6979004741,
0.1014193967,
-0.1844145656,
0.2037749141,
0.8461124897,
-0.7514386177,
-0.7883195877,
-0.5751081109,
0.3204115331,
-0.1042036638,
-0.5266245008,
0.4609064758,
0.3721113205,
0.9395615458,
0.4143419266,
0.8716442585,
0.0306633878,
0.6071487665,
-0.81919837,
0.4970210791,
-0.5257804394,
0.378520757,
-0.4210197926,
-0.9598151445,
-0.1247189045,
0.5989946723,
-0.2985795736,
-0.0038266031,
0.655192256,
1.0328142643,
0.1722949743,
0.0432073697,
0.283842206,
0.0457854979,
0.0751881301,
0.2835009396,
0.9122444391,
-0.3422311544,
0.559228301,
-0.1395756304,
-0.1522376835,
-0.3264911473,
-0.898628056,
-0.5427898765,
-0.4984567165,
-0.4247428775,
-0.0779501051,
0.2155212611,
1.0458374023,
0.7924536467,
-0.7544209957,
-0.3995442688,
-0.0460425243,
0.3919304013,
-0.1223665848,
-0.1619003564,
0.3181699812,
-0.4404664636,
-0.7577440143,
0.3986999094,
0.2823965549,
0.1981680095,
-0.3888143897,
-0.1058984473,
-0.6741397381,
-0.0408418477,
0.5965279937,
-0.0979718044,
-0.8208937049,
-0.3277471364,
0.0622691214,
-0.2664634585,
0.1050982848,
0.6627137661,
-0.5223886371,
0.335451901,
0.4945193529,
0.9426271319,
0.2626555264,
-0.1570062041,
0.8280553222,
-0.7116569877,
-0.019388482,
0.2175584435,
0.1689477414,
0.4923064709,
-0.0936569497,
0.6970003247,
-0.0129165892,
-0.090492107,
-0.7728847265,
0.2531619072,
-0.4729993045,
-0.5547417998,
1.0449947119,
-0.1055596769,
0.0415749364,
-0.2439535558,
0.0378660336,
0.373047471,
-0.0965535194,
0.5915994048,
0.585901618,
-0.3373202682,
-0.0456840433,
-0.2395563275,
0.5525947213,
0.5424660444,
-0.6845831275,
-0.2874460816,
0.0822617933,
0.2455231249,
0.7188746929,
0.4527291954,
-0.0997944251,
0.014012659,
0.0552779771,
0.6434952021,
0.0820505843,
-0.1492376477,
-0.2463168353,
0.0694758818,
0.0429255851,
-0.1400240362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17896v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17896v1
|
Researchy Questions: A Dataset of Multi-Perspective, Decompositional Questions for LLM Web Agents
| 2024-02-27T21:27:16 | 2024-02-27T21:27:16 |
Corby Rosset, Ho-Lam Chung, Guanghui Qin, Ethan C. Chau, Zhuo Feng, Ahmed Awadallah, Jennifer Neville, Nikhil Rao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing question answering (QA) datasets are no longer challenging to most
powerful Large Language Models (LLMs). Traditional QA benchmarks like TriviaQA,
NaturalQuestions, ELI5 and HotpotQA mainly study ``known unknowns'' with clear
indications of both what information is missing, and how to find it to answer
the question. Hence, good performance on these benchmarks provides a false
sense of security. A yet unmet need of the NLP community is a bank of
non-factoid, multi-perspective questions involving a great deal of unclear
information needs, i.e. ``unknown uknowns''. We claim we can find such
questions in search engine logs, which is surprising because most
question-intent queries are indeed factoid. We present Researchy Questions, a
dataset of search engine queries tediously filtered to be non-factoid,
``decompositional'' and multi-perspective. We show that users spend a lot of
``effort'' on these questions in terms of signals like clicks and session
length, and that they are also challenging for GPT-4. We also show that ``slow
thinking'' answering techniques, like decomposition into sub-questions shows
benefit over answering directly. We release $\sim$ 100k Researchy Questions,
along with the Clueweb22 URLs that were clicked.
|
[
-0.6637933254,
-0.8821631074,
0.7099368572,
-0.077202931,
-0.0704413131,
0.0916811898,
0.0836952254,
-0.5728253722,
0.3783357739,
0.3343998492,
-0.8790175915,
-0.2604208291,
-0.0775822178,
0.2173035741,
-0.3506013155,
0.9301525354,
0.0537965894,
-0.1731641591,
-0.3392109871,
-0.1233227253,
0.107868962,
-0.4496040046,
-0.7816723585,
0.0945227146,
0.9722357392,
0.061784476,
0.6104985476,
0.567684412,
0.6733027101,
0.2445507199,
-0.0855567977,
0.2250877172,
-0.5107751489,
0.2613877356,
-0.2292426229,
-0.7442131639,
-0.1396650374,
0.2748759091,
0.193474099,
0.7836386561,
-0.1949138641,
0.3148338795,
-0.1325285733,
0.5423947573,
-0.7592852116,
0.0007123844,
-0.5957143307,
-0.0668383762,
-0.0086092409,
-0.3077537417,
-0.1185936853,
-0.5098440647,
0.341371417,
-0.7284658551,
0.5506317616,
0.078468062,
0.8186862469,
0.2831943929,
-0.4992637932,
-0.4100246429,
-0.7105212808,
0.7882791758,
-0.5378352404,
0.2432189286,
0.4302294254,
0.1794284433,
-0.2501114309,
-0.5673706532,
-0.3532952368,
0.0965635851,
-0.0807774886,
0.0969599336,
-0.2317971587,
-0.054679323,
0.1874094903,
0.3571948111,
-0.823363483,
-0.1718037426,
-0.2468069345,
-0.2311547548,
0.6180477738,
0.2331972867,
0.3836947978,
-0.0446673147,
-0.2479614168,
-0.1728925705,
-0.528719306,
0.0677263811,
0.4101925492,
-0.0088853789,
0.2529690862,
0.4757494628,
-0.2157721221,
0.5960338712,
-0.0437059961,
-0.216368556,
0.1302236319,
-0.6265909076,
0.0566704981,
-0.4807916284,
0.5022104979,
0.3073738813,
0.0513541512,
-0.4377346337,
-0.0420399942,
-0.0781747699,
0.437954545,
-0.6504549384,
-0.2160397768,
0.6723051071,
-0.2656109929,
-0.0371142998,
-0.115698874,
-0.5511424541,
-0.2456926703,
-0.0238823295,
0.3405570984,
-0.3233564496,
-0.5190805197,
0.0615797713,
-0.5188159943,
0.7757738233,
0.4258270264,
-0.628467083,
0.2195906192,
0.5605012774,
0.506131053,
-0.2240093052,
-0.2405312508,
-0.1053687707,
-0.0199656747,
-0.45681113,
0.8090521097,
-0.445903182,
-0.1766135693,
0.1243670061,
0.0735508129,
-0.3214342892,
-0.6193018556,
0.4073200524,
-1.0433719158,
0.5427284241,
-0.5259814262,
-0.4446566701,
-0.1640160978,
0.747895956,
-0.785575211,
0.8837073445,
-0.0970306396,
-0.9835596681,
0.1082368046,
-0.6491303444,
-0.1230225936,
0.0112072388,
-0.0470177084,
0.1658962369,
0.0617071465,
0.332634747,
0.2959409654,
-0.3466447294,
0.1275389493,
-0.405634284,
0.0347339064,
0.6106321812,
-0.4366536736,
0.630605638,
0.2666572332,
-0.1250205487,
-0.246049881,
-0.8871102333,
0.3882752359,
0.1925548464,
-0.3460261524,
-0.5574177504,
-0.2328799069,
-0.1515934765,
0.1546031386,
0.4124021828,
-0.4905793071,
0.0723235309,
-0.4586431086,
0.3334507048,
0.5602505803,
0.2688836753,
0.1780125052,
-0.3363255858,
0.8933598399,
-0.1201995686,
0.3310817778,
0.1994254589,
-0.5511838198,
-0.7598642111,
0.0550280102,
0.1369718462,
0.3896757364,
-0.838660419,
-0.2551219463,
0.0839101896,
-0.4283596277,
-0.7404512763,
-0.0260427073,
0.306337446,
0.4449110627,
0.3375055194,
0.0780116022,
-0.19564493,
-1.1494811773,
-0.4649956524,
-0.1231414378,
-0.2834785283,
0.4056123495,
0.4635698795,
0.1391859353,
0.6858464479,
-0.5848959684,
0.1263950169,
-0.0595029034,
0.1702187806,
0.1508890092,
-0.0240966938,
0.1683042943,
-1.1562687159,
-0.2380640954,
-0.4275535941,
-0.785738349,
0.1699166745,
0.1249741316,
-0.0877148211,
-0.1453419626,
0.2994411886,
-1.0425462723,
0.1665072292,
0.3904058039,
-0.0603176579,
0.4224621952,
-0.1382413954,
0.0470256917,
-0.9284190536,
0.175408408,
-0.0307143945,
-0.0051139351,
-0.7329739928,
0.4336792827,
-0.0092016151,
-0.0395944342,
-0.5760110617,
0.4136242568,
-0.5857509375,
-0.0660214424,
-0.208531335,
0.3602474332,
0.0979975685,
0.5277140141,
-0.1217623055,
0.9592273235,
0.4867170453,
-0.7662511468,
0.2229903042,
0.1483277977,
0.0140888076,
0.2201209068,
-0.4625616372,
0.507271409,
-0.2046553344,
0.1004910618,
-1.0895118713,
-0.3005441725,
0.1518255621,
-0.504005909,
-0.0739787444,
-0.1878191978,
-0.4012453556,
-0.2475332916,
-0.6357399225,
0.6135933399,
0.2298662066,
-0.4220603406,
0.6245197654,
0.5412940979,
-0.1127494797,
-0.980954051,
-0.4071250558,
0.0725251287,
-0.2928577065,
-0.6590743065,
0.1309231669,
-0.2500267029,
-0.469034791,
0.3712526858,
-0.1613069326,
-0.2145175934,
0.1600161046,
0.0467295535,
0.1937659234,
-0.1794721335,
0.0062382319,
-0.443481952,
-0.0161658134,
0.4839420021,
-0.1676725894,
0.5250860453,
0.0194239113,
-0.2502810061,
-0.1438217461,
0.3839481473,
0.2933394909,
-0.221002534,
0.4069238603,
0.6014564037,
-0.273650825,
-0.3019137681,
-0.7137547731,
-0.1439192891,
-0.4196775258,
0.0236375649,
-0.4289204776,
-1.1297225952,
0.6737412214,
-0.0458183996,
0.181317091,
0.5324361324,
0.5323312283,
-0.3008466661,
0.9394982457,
0.4411146939,
0.0362630039,
0.0201474782,
-0.3209005892,
0.200436011,
-0.6673781872,
-0.3678118587,
-0.6048484445,
-0.2448811531,
-0.8366757631,
-0.6278992891,
0.438727051,
-0.2085506469,
0.3008365333,
-0.0785249099,
-0.3286567628,
0.4821546078,
0.8356519341,
0.0656517968,
0.1740642339,
-0.3065312803,
0.2065868378,
0.1514711976,
-0.573784709,
-0.366866827,
1.4001244307,
0.0838906839,
0.9322829843,
0.1545863152,
0.7441998124,
0.1042421833,
-0.1732178032,
-0.740926981,
0.5786058307,
0.4600836933,
-1.1289162636,
-0.4699599743,
-0.4452143013,
-1.1739073992,
0.4742736816,
0.1860365272,
-0.6505562067,
0.2114116102,
0.0335850306,
-0.4456886649,
0.232175529,
-0.6270244122,
0.4915233552,
-0.1376279742,
-0.5656203032,
-0.2320168167,
-0.7836942077,
0.3827664852,
0.1862249076,
0.2072132975,
-0.1932892501,
-0.1510525346,
0.9822983146,
-0.3849113584,
0.6163929701,
-0.2916377187,
-0.0706093535,
0.5346624851,
0.0129058771,
0.4461905658,
0.2541295588,
0.2827268541,
-0.2054604888,
0.318993032,
-0.5244101882,
-0.6221137643,
0.6449690461,
-0.8152987361,
-0.8902691007,
-0.5801236033,
-0.570007205,
-0.5437756777,
0.0334716178,
-0.0873989016,
0.1673664004,
-0.1902588159,
0.0650773719,
1.1956958771,
-0.1732017249,
0.365825206,
0.5069641471,
-0.1457390338,
-0.1434857547,
0.5991624594,
-0.0368831791,
0.0249106605,
0.5802361965,
0.0906390026,
-0.5507414341,
-0.7248954773,
-0.328597337,
0.4669340551,
-0.5988740921,
-0.0046094432,
-0.8577702045,
-0.1677384973,
-0.3645814061,
0.2787110806,
-0.3228234351,
-0.5262145996,
-0.2138835937,
-0.2778130472,
0.1277273446,
0.6831312776,
-0.1536977142,
-0.178340584,
-0.3717155457,
0.8443990946,
0.7143221498,
0.1049191356,
-0.1504009664,
-0.2383627146,
-0.0977560654,
-0.2333457768,
-0.0620526671,
-0.8470902443,
0.2113916427,
-0.1319628954,
0.5778080821,
0.2848035991,
0.2760270834,
0.5154369473,
-0.2095918953,
0.6446273923,
-0.1530663371,
-0.2649456263,
0.4531649649,
-0.428870976,
0.0962334201,
0.8208309412,
0.9511275291,
-0.4167231023,
-0.4067433476,
-0.611867249,
-0.8970692754,
0.8331151605,
0.1303783059,
0.108858414,
0.1942988634,
0.473154068,
0.1877093166,
0.2654893696,
-0.6407107711,
-0.5406153798,
-0.075521104,
0.2320271283,
0.1558293998,
-0.4981740117,
-0.4927756786,
-0.0684986115,
0.5333386064,
-0.1897011995,
0.2775063217,
0.2258412093,
-0.0734765008,
0.0079925349,
0.5354533195,
0.1434745342,
1.0718379021,
-0.7016475201,
0.2653111219,
-0.1355772614,
-0.3633759916,
0.2803360522,
0.1470500529,
-0.2800037563,
-0.1969397366,
0.2472663671,
0.3458656967,
-0.1566880196,
-0.6278815866,
0.497692585,
-0.5348036885,
-0.469978869,
-0.5286922455,
0.1526792496,
0.4603062272,
0.2377902418,
0.6280711293,
-0.3024007678,
0.3556828797,
-0.7145564556,
0.0520568378,
0.5733503103,
-0.2290560007,
-0.4254584908,
0.5755762458,
0.0505363047,
-0.2754663825,
0.5464360118,
-0.2495369911,
-0.29850927,
0.4692644179,
0.3388263881,
0.7475197911,
0.0324094705,
0.5788028836,
0.1551825404,
0.4796776772,
0.1881046891,
0.7672610879,
0.1082369313,
-0.7546502948,
-0.2796385586,
-0.5073959827,
-0.7337251306,
0.7009075284,
-0.7441051006,
-0.227861464,
-0.5479872823,
-0.0623218715,
0.2214028984,
0.1452199072,
-0.9370721579,
0.3528702259,
-0.0484058447,
0.8083911538,
-0.5555907488,
0.6238096952,
0.7445390224,
-0.5678805113,
-0.8129493594,
0.1136152893,
-0.0961665884,
-0.9230321646,
0.4156794548,
0.1135183573,
-0.1238202378,
-0.0626970083,
-0.7625578046,
-1.0467276573,
0.9203803539,
0.2113690674,
-0.2350071967,
-0.4452057779,
0.3444635868,
0.6506710649,
0.0154314851,
0.5041264296,
0.3534999192,
0.5689648986,
-0.0181869995,
-0.5903992057,
0.0824676007,
-0.4039678872,
-0.399174273,
0.0041800821,
-0.8135235906,
1.028642416,
-0.068919301,
-0.2798678577,
-0.29711169,
0.272698462,
0.0592356324,
0.5832848549,
0.4358079135,
0.5373268723,
0.7951385975,
0.0663580224,
1.0032746792,
-0.2763257325,
0.1346451491,
0.8625388741,
-0.1379620731,
0.6511701345,
0.7146237493,
-0.4546539187,
0.3511420786,
0.7792876363,
0.2344781905,
0.5227979422,
0.2774528563,
-0.1022188663,
-0.3957705796,
-0.2106728852,
-0.3323250413,
0.4317702353,
0.2599197924,
0.0591585003,
-0.3215230405,
-0.2866142392,
0.1184555963,
-0.1077673733,
0.1137634665,
0.9542011619,
0.0343250595,
-0.6902278662,
0.5048374534,
0.0106368707,
0.5838955045,
-0.8630949855,
0.151845172,
-0.7305486798,
-0.0413454436,
-0.0832075328,
-0.6216669083,
-0.0217004195,
-0.1714372635,
-0.2421031296,
-0.0571201332,
0.7647802234,
-0.1617234498,
-0.2497149259,
0.405736953,
1.1663782597,
0.4010583758,
-0.4126676023,
-0.860028863,
-0.3669707179,
-0.0747551695,
-0.5419511795,
0.5469529629,
0.6237270832,
0.0227709655,
0.9941688776,
0.6278991699,
0.0003913218,
0.3358797133,
-0.0428067558,
1.0322724581,
-0.821862638,
-0.2543381751,
-0.5082321167,
0.0585995391,
-0.0215211343,
-0.3783827424,
1.0434975624,
0.7031888962,
0.9740918875,
0.1771624386,
0.9535906315,
-0.0615250655,
0.7377003431,
-0.5073269606,
0.3841636777,
-0.7908958793,
0.0553335957,
0.0250023641,
-0.8127438426,
0.0134097682,
0.027429428,
-0.114377521,
-0.0560489483,
0.9071740508,
0.8569207788,
-0.0623775572,
0.1755265296,
0.3260543644,
-0.0313378759,
0.368139714,
0.5312629938,
1.2828942537,
-0.3511020839,
0.8697571158,
-0.3998075724,
0.0272315387,
-0.1435739547,
-0.3633989394,
-0.9010674953,
-0.5018051267,
-0.2569572926,
-0.1674620211,
0.0980177,
0.6308662295,
0.4893007576,
-0.7831500769,
-0.1769926548,
0.2951172888,
0.3095425367,
-0.1027078331,
-0.2174883932,
0.4784865975,
-0.405564934,
-0.5889197588,
0.5676553845,
0.1245071217,
-0.2329791188,
-0.5798329115,
0.2813707888,
-0.632681489,
0.1041502208,
0.2328118384,
0.2500599027,
-0.5867888331,
-0.1729528606,
0.3816144168,
0.0750098601,
0.155694738,
0.9614896178,
-0.5821552873,
0.2156246305,
0.4335172474,
0.8650923967,
0.750908196,
0.1959299594,
0.1862647533,
-0.6769934893,
-0.1286915392,
0.4347456694,
0.0220792387,
0.2137672901,
-0.3311548829,
0.6773135662,
0.300324738,
-0.4415926933,
-0.6440383196,
0.0799433365,
-0.8066242933,
-0.5181838274,
1.1002379656,
-0.1504958272,
-0.4386167228,
-0.4123046696,
0.1134760454,
-0.0828708857,
-0.4311449826,
0.8473927379,
0.7903604507,
-0.5078939199,
-0.1533949822,
-0.7909818292,
0.6733854413,
0.4027684629,
-0.9197428226,
0.1084859297,
0.6508997083,
0.3991309106,
0.3456913829,
0.8902974725,
-0.063451387,
0.0061389506,
0.1354876012,
-0.0643909127,
0.1241987646,
-0.2989791632,
-0.0129902186,
0.7815892696,
0.2607934773,
-0.3532391191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17887v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17887v4
|
JMLR: Joint Medical LLM and Retrieval Training for Enhancing Reasoning and Professional Question Answering Capability
| 2024-02-27T21:01:41 | 2024-06-28T13:23:31 |
Junda Wang, Zhichao Yang, Zonghai Yao, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated a remarkable potential in
medical knowledge acquisition and question-answering. However, LLMs can
potentially hallucinate and yield factually incorrect outcomes, even with
domain-specific pretraining. Previously, retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
has limited success in addressing hallucinations. Unlike previous methods in
RAG where the retrieval model was trained separately from the LLM, we introduce
JMLR (for Jointly trains LLM and information Retrieval) during the fine-tuning
phase. The synchronized training mechanism enhances JMLR's ability to retrieve
clinical guidelines and leverage medical knowledge to reason and answer
questions and reduces the demand for computational resources. We evaluated JMLR
on the important medical question-answering application. Our experimental
results demonstrate that JMLR-13B (70.5%) outperforms a previous
state-of-the-art open-source model using conventional pre-training and
fine-tuning Meditron-70B (68.9%) and Llama2-13B with RAG (67.7%) on a medical
question-answering dataset. Comprehensive evaluations reveal JMLR-13B enhances
reasoning quality and reduces hallucinations better than Claude3-Opus.
Additionally, JMLR-13B (148 GPU hours) also trains much faster than
Meditron-70B (42630 GPU hours). Through this work, we provide a new and
efficient knowledge enhancement method for healthcare, demonstrating the
potential of integrating retrieval and LLM training for medical
question-answering systems.
|
[
-0.3559748232,
-0.9117727876,
0.7797758579,
-0.1803755015,
-0.3624266684,
0.148085013,
-0.2178705037,
-0.5671246648,
0.0606615506,
0.6905236244,
-0.377887249,
-0.2835837007,
-0.6737134457,
0.1702121198,
-0.0820408612,
0.9505349398,
-0.0104877884,
0.7740013599,
-0.3867761791,
-0.1327110082,
-0.5828313231,
-0.6199570894,
-0.6862630248,
-0.4638702273,
0.6723306179,
-0.0066959905,
0.5875716209,
0.4520725012,
0.9966214895,
0.2604617178,
-0.0804704353,
0.5809116364,
-0.4419111311,
0.3208249509,
-0.1199730411,
-0.4406494796,
-0.3750876188,
-0.4485017657,
0.3484132886,
0.7349845767,
-0.3598843515,
0.138701275,
-0.153176561,
0.8278510571,
-0.7450416684,
-0.0762030184,
-0.6014183164,
0.2215784788,
0.0434271805,
-0.7760834098,
-0.4024968743,
-0.4821320474,
0.1321854442,
-0.6548014879,
0.0959829241,
0.2319390327,
0.744551599,
0.6130934954,
-0.1319966614,
-0.3489069939,
-0.6363860369,
0.4816890061,
-0.4577436447,
0.6247385144,
0.2849051058,
0.5487630963,
-0.0865894258,
-0.8178439736,
-0.6534998417,
-0.2023230195,
-0.2399620414,
0.2989721596,
0.3192770779,
0.199366346,
0.3157007992,
0.4193434715,
-0.6499346495,
-0.33555004,
-0.5478448868,
-0.0056373067,
0.4856216609,
0.4866121113,
0.2930732965,
-0.0440190025,
-0.310465306,
0.0453111678,
-0.6136271954,
-0.2571011186,
-0.3433984518,
0.092327863,
0.2837008238,
0.6215802431,
-0.0530161001,
0.7903216481,
0.1377868205,
-0.61477983,
0.1959534138,
-0.2849758565,
-0.2352155298,
0.0696281046,
0.4518466592,
0.3640654683,
0.0330033153,
-0.3891521692,
-0.1943946481,
-0.0451430902,
0.529851079,
-0.6835308671,
-0.2574599981,
0.1481513083,
-0.5546697974,
-0.0189023353,
0.0826668069,
-0.5636758208,
-0.6754069924,
-0.6101041436,
0.7595040798,
-0.416210413,
-0.2130043507,
0.3997734785,
-0.1642255336,
0.4619122744,
0.5580875874,
-0.58494699,
0.4237765074,
0.7855060697,
0.3447491527,
-0.4197431505,
-0.0488940887,
-0.4427018166,
0.1712847799,
-0.2906890213,
0.5860019326,
-0.4992025197,
-0.3767760992,
-0.1549083889,
-0.001926114,
-0.3508296013,
-1.0693821907,
0.3500761092,
-0.7049657702,
0.3706107736,
-0.2834765315,
-0.6274035573,
-0.0240486432,
0.3700389862,
-0.2739790678,
0.6807205081,
0.0263931379,
-0.8246097565,
0.3591192663,
-0.4550647736,
-0.3874729872,
0.2095791548,
-0.3545002639,
-0.3978861868,
-0.0763356611,
0.429217279,
0.3388292491,
-0.3904302418,
0.3729590178,
-0.028256109,
-0.5836575627,
0.3509259224,
-0.2845461071,
0.4707728028,
0.2622036934,
-0.0274218954,
-0.03993579,
-0.592689991,
0.104176484,
0.260676682,
-0.4543628395,
-0.3810882866,
-0.2983395755,
-0.247010231,
0.1180049479,
0.3043355942,
-0.3627278507,
-0.0830571949,
-0.5101616383,
-0.31747967,
0.2933281362,
0.4231626391,
0.2286319435,
-0.7014567852,
0.5544466972,
0.1231985912,
0.2749343812,
0.0365879498,
-0.2349693328,
-0.9514293075,
-0.0433629006,
0.0353471525,
0.7110994458,
-0.9760761857,
0.3549597561,
-0.0818421021,
-0.2975857258,
-1.1267895699,
-0.0103135305,
0.7281207442,
0.9122394919,
0.8540050387,
-0.1837887466,
-0.6981512308,
-0.6144963503,
-0.2621999681,
-0.0057085063,
-0.0044706156,
0.5085503459,
0.2433932126,
-0.0633724853,
0.4049982429,
-0.4325391054,
-0.380733192,
-0.4431950152,
-0.1822753996,
0.2628788054,
0.2658953071,
-0.0768818632,
-0.7362220883,
-0.4109596014,
-0.0306053795,
-0.9387567639,
0.003199477,
-0.247524485,
-0.1258646697,
0.3241981864,
0.4741450548,
-0.6195057631,
0.1835558265,
0.1488827765,
-0.1414782256,
0.3997673392,
-0.3090090454,
0.4610988796,
-1.3034389019,
0.2317851037,
-0.4715120196,
-0.1621156782,
-0.5526684523,
0.2632295489,
-0.0207295027,
0.2024024427,
-0.3286454976,
0.5587881804,
-0.4813529551,
0.0913564414,
-0.2920732498,
0.2947846651,
0.1058776602,
0.1420972794,
-0.1315975487,
0.9959959388,
0.3590391874,
-0.5196071863,
0.1112505794,
0.4752600491,
-0.3369465172,
0.5320906639,
-0.5971748233,
0.2391192764,
-0.4157812893,
-0.1086564064,
-0.4852373302,
-0.35026595,
0.2089940608,
-0.4191691875,
0.5943054557,
0.0679258406,
-0.3972043097,
-0.5181069374,
0.0253294613,
0.0534961,
0.7020183206,
-0.6255047321,
0.4860911369,
0.5025109649,
-0.05590358,
-0.8280241489,
-0.4725280106,
-0.184105292,
-0.0330450833,
-0.3129709661,
0.1737647504,
-0.0850754976,
-0.259716332,
-0.0784104466,
-0.4360464513,
-0.0582791865,
-0.0284592919,
0.1256490499,
0.4161469638,
-0.1935697347,
0.1532019526,
0.1796257943,
-0.1762158126,
0.2432393283,
0.1539166719,
0.6742995381,
0.1505180597,
-0.5252857208,
-0.4210321009,
0.1531271935,
0.2914538383,
-0.264949441,
0.8012896776,
0.5992075801,
-0.2151414454,
0.0686658919,
-0.9141729474,
-0.4906513989,
-0.4436214566,
0.420249939,
-0.330196172,
-1.1164220572,
0.1251734942,
-0.0409540273,
-0.2331863493,
0.2736146748,
0.7341579199,
-0.1197084114,
1.0613583326,
0.1363397986,
0.1661407948,
-0.0294467658,
0.0871277303,
0.0898845717,
-0.9412218928,
-0.5242548585,
-0.2078396082,
0.0165159162,
-0.2522484958,
-0.547200799,
0.7936961651,
0.2227161676,
-0.1359831393,
-0.2484586835,
-0.7288094163,
0.7543772459,
0.3555761278,
0.5193056464,
0.5065188408,
-0.1632619798,
-0.2569918633,
-0.0661608577,
-0.5810831785,
-0.2012666017,
1.0783787966,
0.1132105812,
0.7712156177,
-0.048133824,
0.7595450282,
-0.1244744062,
0.1702235043,
-0.4785380363,
0.689201057,
-0.0535909869,
-0.6410752535,
-0.0548667647,
-0.445464462,
-0.8456668854,
0.2318043858,
-0.5040075183,
-0.390281409,
-0.2685028017,
0.1443583816,
-0.3747801185,
0.274059087,
-0.4587976635,
0.4786640704,
-0.0924250484,
-0.2792609036,
-0.2656151056,
-0.9918391109,
0.3811278641,
-0.1525857151,
-0.2027880102,
0.0405124202,
0.0349346958,
0.4740245342,
-0.2331990004,
0.4431547523,
-0.4102552235,
0.2266527116,
0.0608725511,
-0.019300526,
0.4020027816,
0.1934369653,
0.0301297791,
-0.1443811655,
0.1497538984,
-0.0360630713,
-0.8015881777,
0.4439477324,
-0.7603634596,
-0.8901916742,
-0.3663562834,
-0.7545685172,
-0.4203054905,
0.0616301931,
0.0870739073,
0.1975130737,
-0.0505393669,
0.2558090389,
0.8996555209,
-0.369451344,
-0.0922450647,
0.5748027563,
-0.4608979225,
-0.6742056608,
0.6857430339,
-0.0575329401,
0.2817984819,
0.634126842,
0.117701076,
-0.3348821998,
-0.6974170208,
-0.2959311008,
0.5097557902,
-0.6224920154,
-0.3255904317,
-1.0326082706,
-0.7926237583,
-0.1865424961,
-0.0117225526,
-0.0904828459,
-0.3377239704,
-0.3253831565,
0.1632737666,
0.3981019855,
0.4731706679,
0.2124991119,
0.0274440497,
-0.8531054854,
0.5618902445,
0.1669719815,
0.2049206495,
-0.098008275,
-0.5549185872,
-0.210378319,
-0.1946268082,
-0.1262341589,
-0.5165027976,
0.3004380167,
-0.1085163951,
0.5342620611,
0.199677676,
0.1549558043,
1.0776661634,
-0.5397849083,
0.4741112888,
0.1103055626,
-0.4002177715,
0.5566436648,
-0.0715134889,
0.2604419589,
0.8582318425,
0.5986768007,
-0.411431551,
-0.5622675419,
-0.3140820861,
-0.5824607015,
0.3802566528,
-0.161112681,
-0.0760415345,
-0.1426692307,
0.6283017993,
0.2881684899,
0.1653683782,
-0.3157864511,
-0.2871872187,
0.2715917826,
-0.3232721686,
0.1290399581,
-0.2621612251,
-0.3592518866,
-0.6452808976,
0.6517139673,
-0.0413526446,
0.4353702962,
0.6161043048,
-0.1701871306,
-0.0696226954,
0.368276149,
0.4194163382,
0.6752424836,
-0.3589336872,
0.0892375335,
0.4810278714,
-0.6937350631,
0.0112436609,
0.3308983445,
-0.0501670986,
-0.0980682448,
0.1322166771,
0.7164844871,
-0.2928759158,
-0.8076987267,
0.4538145065,
-0.2080753595,
-0.3079269528,
-0.5235034227,
0.4578003585,
0.0567378663,
0.538742125,
0.1641651839,
0.0445606373,
0.3076374531,
0.0106489044,
0.3901234269,
0.4722522795,
-0.298658669,
0.1296232343,
0.9086114764,
-0.1987534016,
-0.0908861756,
0.4420006871,
-0.1055200621,
-0.129907459,
0.2651824951,
0.8806960583,
0.4651315212,
-0.0953518599,
-0.1100222468,
0.4071043134,
0.0708667561,
-0.1835840195,
0.7843547463,
0.0974865705,
-0.6431908011,
-0.4525037706,
-0.6999233961,
-0.6196614504,
0.1318165064,
-0.8229244947,
0.1792963892,
-0.5402079225,
-0.0499836765,
-0.1892543137,
-0.0272069611,
-0.3827938437,
0.1926722378,
-0.0326323397,
0.804464519,
-0.1780564189,
0.9314517975,
0.671672821,
-0.3798718452,
-0.847458601,
0.080275543,
-0.0789980516,
-0.9773288369,
0.4889357686,
0.0734815523,
-0.0552728884,
0.0875253603,
-0.2688555717,
-0.7230522037,
1.3374916315,
0.1059680209,
-0.5999017954,
-0.0772445798,
0.1964150071,
0.7216817141,
-0.2696259618,
0.1295195818,
0.5954099894,
0.1869710237,
0.2125807256,
-0.8876633644,
0.1781699806,
-0.2495051622,
-0.0934779793,
0.3746290505,
-0.3631964326,
0.4652960598,
-0.5674395561,
-0.1073392481,
0.2887718678,
0.2678132653,
0.7563921213,
0.4536391497,
0.311757803,
0.6261354685,
1.0167756081,
-0.1956391186,
1.1502740383,
-0.5429453254,
0.0375761464,
1.0981098413,
-0.3724409938,
0.8736274242,
0.7871948481,
-0.0496717691,
0.1991986334,
0.1846354306,
0.0189785678,
0.5921369195,
0.1042714268,
-0.5856093168,
-0.3428435326,
-0.3036194742,
-0.6224341393,
0.0819617957,
0.3966165781,
-0.4418611526,
0.1793486327,
0.1563843787,
0.1827501506,
0.065307349,
-0.197876066,
1.128937602,
0.2404660285,
-0.7122101188,
0.8101144433,
-0.4796391428,
0.3531026244,
-0.4958586693,
-0.0060745776,
-0.2248518467,
0.3922749162,
-0.0074703763,
-0.6409994364,
0.381955415,
-0.1841114312,
-0.1006573215,
0.0548745319,
0.9414975643,
-0.4622978568,
-0.3943715096,
0.2594431043,
0.8506819606,
0.0870689899,
0.2988763452,
-0.6887173653,
-0.1348769218,
-0.1462634057,
-0.0372065492,
0.355011642,
0.4153051078,
0.3797097504,
0.6954749823,
0.658714354,
0.3018793762,
0.030318208,
0.3754488528,
1.1044664383,
-0.6548129916,
0.0844888464,
-0.6382830143,
0.3264466524,
-0.1451545656,
-0.0686787143,
0.4695810378,
0.5588479042,
0.877773881,
-0.1930114627,
0.5492115617,
0.094689317,
0.9798073769,
-0.7367717028,
0.9759101272,
-0.8213433027,
0.3009863198,
-0.086927101,
-0.6657119989,
-0.7846979499,
0.5408768058,
-0.2642921209,
0.0456471965,
0.83443892,
1.0515128374,
0.0753271729,
-0.0431576744,
0.4654854238,
0.2702347338,
0.011881724,
0.5550883412,
0.9983315468,
-0.3415163159,
0.4696123302,
-0.3101442754,
0.120681718,
-0.1210345104,
-0.2377351224,
-1.1451659203,
-0.2168599665,
-0.1185822934,
-0.5644232035,
0.6131848097,
1.2813429832,
0.4580113292,
-0.7491694093,
0.0718887299,
-0.0447138138,
-0.1098159552,
-0.0483295918,
-0.2107534111,
0.3248360157,
-0.6801806092,
-0.2578612864,
0.4423680305,
0.356246531,
0.0609500185,
-0.0619317554,
-0.4284234345,
-0.1137870625,
-0.0973999947,
0.3760039508,
-0.0420008302,
-0.7773442864,
-0.1005152911,
0.3821103871,
-0.2963696122,
0.3737435639,
0.6836770773,
-0.7580891252,
0.5335552096,
0.3438473344,
1.0278425217,
0.430406481,
0.1565088034,
0.2849604785,
-0.4853684306,
0.0276592653,
0.3330189288,
0.2170871943,
0.2552275658,
-0.3875612915,
0.5065698028,
0.1964673996,
-0.8217700124,
-0.6329489946,
-0.1033876687,
-1.0161911249,
-0.3494825363,
0.9853212237,
0.1578669697,
-0.0241986662,
-0.3537871242,
-0.4513686299,
0.3895871341,
-0.0969542116,
1.0277705193,
0.2237564027,
-0.2946362793,
-0.4412715137,
-0.7520766258,
0.6004384756,
0.6163626909,
-1.0308845043,
-0.1362040341,
0.3027933538,
0.1803203821,
0.0195958801,
0.8245401382,
-0.5098699927,
0.4519562721,
-0.142946437,
0.0659597889,
-0.1443996578,
-0.4573386908,
-0.2148071378,
0.1390151381,
0.2678982019,
0.0138725061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17882v2
|
BlendSQL: A Scalable Dialect for Unifying Hybrid Question Answering in Relational Algebra
| 2024-02-27T20:48:24 | 2024-06-10T20:27:28 |
Parker Glenn, Parag Pravin Dakle, Liang Wang, Preethi Raghavan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many existing end-to-end systems for hybrid question answering tasks can
often be boiled down to a "prompt-and-pray" paradigm, where the user has
limited control and insight into the intermediate reasoning steps used to
achieve the final result. Additionally, due to the context size limitation of
many transformer-based LLMs, it is often not reasonable to expect that the full
structured and unstructured context will fit into a given prompt in a zero-shot
setting, let alone a few-shot setting. We introduce BlendSQL, a superset of
SQLite to act as a unified dialect for orchestrating reasoning across both
unstructured and structured data. For hybrid question answering tasks involving
multi-hop reasoning, we encode the full decomposed reasoning roadmap into a
single interpretable BlendSQL query. Notably, we show that BlendSQL can scale
to massive datasets and improve the performance of end-to-end systems while
using 35% fewer tokens. Our code is available and installable as a package at
https://github.com/parkervg/blendsql.
|
[
-0.3285569549,
-1.0764911175,
0.7718556523,
0.4072452486,
-0.2743725777,
0.6818563342,
0.0525651611,
-0.2184532732,
0.4609670043,
0.6639518142,
-0.7746617198,
-0.3315012455,
-0.1184986606,
0.148120448,
-0.4938231707,
0.9592554569,
0.1047017947,
-0.0068669003,
-0.6896742582,
-0.3838049471,
-0.3157999218,
-0.5458939672,
-0.4058922827,
-0.3073859811,
0.0713439435,
0.3020486832,
1.1063839197,
0.1823353767,
0.1662806123,
0.2065055072,
-0.1725824326,
0.2400519252,
-0.5560560226,
0.515666306,
-0.2305915952,
-0.5249300003,
-0.1334681511,
-0.4325067401,
0.5040533543,
1.0380856991,
-0.427752614,
0.0065620281,
-0.2651210427,
0.506562829,
-0.4964675009,
-0.1071431935,
-0.6445426941,
0.196443513,
-0.0603558645,
-0.0872612596,
-0.2233608514,
-0.2631778419,
-0.0093433168,
-0.8880067468,
-0.1905317754,
0.3165313601,
0.421377033,
0.0364043079,
-0.5961309075,
0.2821052969,
-0.7836581469,
0.8337749839,
-0.2367393374,
0.1793033332,
-0.1585301757,
0.6739843488,
-0.3800936937,
-0.6857589483,
-0.6870495081,
0.3204277456,
-0.1815971881,
0.1860391945,
-0.0132393409,
0.2199505419,
0.1145863384,
0.6849123836,
-0.7295495868,
-0.480496943,
-0.0934723467,
-0.1387082636,
0.4989054203,
0.4961200058,
0.3001920283,
0.0860909373,
-0.2205823064,
0.1905677468,
-0.717782557,
-0.1813717335,
-0.1115521118,
0.1929490566,
0.2279883027,
0.5836862326,
-0.5383443236,
0.9884500504,
0.012332988,
0.1998389214,
-0.2566687763,
-0.4774580896,
-0.2896660566,
-0.2367561013,
0.9378296137,
0.3345899284,
0.0886213183,
-0.3847590983,
-0.0931744799,
0.1178098246,
0.0348817855,
-0.562436223,
-0.132946074,
0.5547005534,
-0.1181054041,
0.1254207492,
-0.2467633188,
-0.8043919206,
-0.3629769087,
-0.395108223,
0.533888936,
-0.3775013089,
-0.1463168561,
0.2130917758,
-0.1021664515,
0.4064204991,
0.4427345395,
-0.8167740107,
0.7249917388,
0.5824413896,
0.6896657944,
-0.1061364412,
-0.0620538779,
-0.376180917,
0.1025647968,
-0.4929584861,
0.9080805779,
-0.6384841204,
-0.6284973025,
-0.1059841663,
-0.4411742687,
-0.2624287307,
-0.7481439114,
0.1934915036,
-0.701618731,
0.4039605856,
-0.1234992892,
-0.5219060183,
0.0003510924,
0.3068449795,
-0.2504555285,
1.3804498911,
0.5070274472,
-0.229677543,
0.1147605404,
-0.5485038161,
-0.6548066735,
0.4201345146,
-0.5093865395,
0.081231527,
0.0843820199,
0.3116101921,
0.0719577298,
-0.7717504501,
0.3504585922,
-0.2927597463,
-0.382737875,
0.2935576439,
0.1088634506,
0.8603584766,
0.3120832145,
0.1023547426,
0.1611962467,
-0.6249455214,
0.4104543626,
0.2152694762,
-0.2231881768,
-0.0648000389,
-0.1734161973,
0.0210283063,
0.2431332767,
0.1625383645,
-0.6791998744,
0.2710891366,
-0.208554253,
0.3947801888,
0.4929283857,
-0.0565641634,
0.4933126271,
-0.2065286785,
0.741002202,
-0.1027245894,
0.2420949787,
-0.2373840958,
-0.4191954732,
-0.6615523696,
-0.1464540958,
0.1276682913,
0.756000936,
-0.9660308957,
0.2375426888,
-0.2342738211,
-0.1279705018,
-0.4266774356,
0.1471316665,
0.2158800066,
0.5134599209,
0.583014369,
-0.0528784171,
-0.5485793352,
-1.0186886787,
-0.550735116,
0.061393138,
-0.1896958649,
0.5125360489,
0.4180274904,
0.0907211751,
1.161008358,
-0.6673368812,
-0.0207082704,
-0.4736540616,
-0.0633596256,
0.5620158911,
0.2459283918,
0.2042344213,
-0.7559614182,
-0.7806339264,
0.0893872976,
-1.0496001244,
0.1444711834,
-0.1601208299,
-0.5740702152,
-0.2481186092,
0.404715389,
-1.0286917686,
-0.0414544567,
0.2520036697,
-0.3279825449,
0.5563843846,
0.0682669207,
0.1678754985,
-1.1111267805,
-0.1396915019,
-0.3928679824,
-0.2141143829,
-0.5649420619,
0.3384046555,
-0.2028321475,
-0.258764863,
-0.2407588214,
0.2880944014,
-0.3295082748,
-0.201781109,
0.1790212244,
-0.0774159133,
0.1471827179,
0.3177602589,
0.1051006019,
0.9970031381,
0.8300905228,
-0.3073644638,
0.7083745599,
0.4433420897,
-0.0094295675,
0.953515172,
-0.6928229928,
0.0428482182,
-0.1415980607,
0.5510028601,
-0.8979127407,
-0.3265384436,
-0.0596321635,
-0.2172496915,
0.1125640422,
-0.27110219,
-0.4626922607,
-0.2300137579,
-0.2286388576,
0.3526886106,
0.4314542413,
-0.5581947565,
1.1195083857,
0.2523746192,
0.0535075665,
-0.3449356854,
-0.4618896544,
0.2591535151,
-0.1288877875,
-0.8701693416,
0.2910642028,
-0.2254242599,
-0.3098745346,
0.0854345486,
-0.3598052561,
-0.3304387033,
-0.0382004865,
0.0183351021,
0.4275380373,
-0.344825834,
0.0232808422,
0.3779887557,
-0.1483935863,
0.1034757271,
-0.5646399856,
0.3317358792,
-0.219341293,
-0.1099584699,
0.0073202583,
0.849645257,
0.7618755102,
-0.0856560916,
0.9209948778,
-0.2090910375,
-0.1866876036,
-0.304310739,
-0.1733080596,
-0.2668320537,
-0.4286962152,
0.0033145717,
-0.416957587,
-1.0776576996,
0.4141710401,
-0.3351234198,
0.1541674435,
0.4168946445,
0.3741577268,
-0.3505946994,
0.8225691915,
0.2001740187,
0.2067299634,
-0.0025448257,
-0.1813659519,
0.2529655695,
-0.6815598011,
-0.4010107219,
-0.3333329856,
-0.1934117526,
-0.1273767352,
-0.6990461946,
0.7736574411,
0.1475138664,
-0.1876707524,
0.1485461295,
-0.4185969532,
1.095569849,
0.5109725595,
-0.1211518049,
0.5770435929,
-0.0931250229,
-0.1926062107,
0.1626291275,
-0.7335616946,
-0.0307943523,
1.1700925827,
-0.4066150188,
0.7910861969,
0.2339460254,
0.6178812385,
0.0944814384,
-0.0250463299,
-0.5155605674,
0.636618793,
0.1589516252,
-0.9990703464,
-0.2268295884,
-0.5228099227,
-0.683799088,
0.6971229911,
-0.5036676526,
-0.7100493908,
-0.0995470881,
0.3407819569,
-0.6938480735,
0.1736235619,
-0.5774487257,
0.9087926745,
-0.1861222237,
-0.2893994749,
0.0231317915,
-0.853546679,
0.4394394159,
0.0745015293,
0.1215675622,
0.0653720647,
0.2406516522,
0.3814921081,
-0.6186504364,
0.2796770334,
0.2608987987,
0.381752491,
0.5578542948,
0.4844498932,
0.3031505942,
0.0967430621,
0.308316946,
0.0785168782,
0.3553785384,
-0.5118570924,
-1.039278388,
0.6934148669,
-0.4626027346,
-0.5217280388,
-0.5066705346,
-0.7881467342,
-0.6113532782,
-0.0469108149,
0.2706346512,
0.3496936262,
0.0528892688,
0.3876591921,
0.9621912837,
0.063650094,
0.0194319412,
0.2344246358,
-0.5404763222,
-0.1602908373,
0.8105406165,
-0.1034839898,
0.461350739,
0.6451182365,
-0.0244894587,
-0.6960413456,
-0.3096239865,
-0.9028567076,
0.1807113886,
-0.5193608999,
-0.2091343105,
-0.6120648384,
-0.1019609794,
-0.194717288,
-0.3161254227,
-0.4099121988,
-0.9527682662,
-0.0076370649,
0.034463115,
0.3843953311,
0.3931097984,
0.3029226363,
0.3060458004,
-0.7451176643,
0.3554535508,
0.5330032706,
0.375115186,
-0.3182614148,
-0.410944581,
0.0080195256,
-0.3370184898,
-0.1559301019,
-0.8112928867,
0.0247954167,
0.3220486641,
0.3761369288,
0.1556983292,
0.1962406933,
0.5782757998,
-0.330978632,
0.7106435895,
0.2465847284,
-0.7446948886,
0.5172541738,
-0.4485401213,
0.3105922937,
0.7165164948,
0.5046496987,
-0.7358558178,
-0.3033830822,
-0.3973036408,
-0.7979755402,
0.6364701986,
0.1955723166,
0.0166703593,
0.1169343516,
0.2230615616,
0.0507753231,
0.3059413433,
-0.5842149854,
-0.4826096892,
-0.2095610946,
-0.2897511125,
0.1536014825,
-0.0917822197,
-0.5193124413,
-0.2736115754,
0.4006917179,
-0.3271497488,
0.0665203556,
-0.1265300363,
-0.1159653887,
-0.2780944109,
0.5947431922,
-0.0022106117,
0.6893244386,
-0.2609053254,
0.100150764,
0.1004267037,
-0.0776379704,
0.0778283849,
0.2199357301,
-0.4875291884,
-0.2703003585,
0.1173277199,
0.3989127874,
0.0178572517,
-0.9848436117,
0.2071751207,
-0.0257980637,
-0.2322734147,
0.0418960154,
0.0885472447,
0.2600197494,
0.1773309708,
0.3949626386,
-0.247227028,
0.4170697629,
-0.6986255646,
-0.1452829689,
0.6782574654,
-0.0871450976,
-0.0583293512,
0.6888129711,
0.1640827358,
-0.0118219322,
0.8037182093,
-0.1650485843,
-0.4630732536,
0.2491084933,
0.6702049375,
0.5294601321,
-0.0967857018,
0.34448421,
0.0287337974,
0.2370400876,
0.1991465837,
0.5895692706,
-0.1769293547,
-0.7328203917,
-0.5764209628,
-0.857191205,
-0.6123735905,
-0.1034471542,
-0.4504108429,
-0.395655036,
-0.5918295383,
0.3126769364,
0.0891867578,
-0.3703180552,
-0.066674754,
0.1424307823,
-0.1707452089,
0.7194803357,
-0.9287571311,
0.3577938676,
0.871807456,
-0.2791770697,
-0.6802998781,
-0.5006011724,
0.2757903934,
-0.5569588542,
0.0774448812,
-0.247770384,
-0.0996606573,
-0.049921643,
-0.4484122992,
-0.7933285832,
0.9340521693,
0.4231386483,
-0.2649445236,
0.1442077607,
0.3731084168,
0.5261812806,
-0.3087626994,
0.3726974726,
0.8963045478,
0.1407517642,
0.7657927275,
-0.739120543,
-0.0808827877,
-0.0700918883,
-0.0644121915,
0.7214124799,
-0.3975787461,
0.9229343534,
-0.1589258611,
-0.2116777748,
-0.0923654884,
0.5339384675,
0.1737158895,
0.2778701186,
0.2638812661,
0.7837302089,
0.5270049572,
-0.3763896525,
1.3317164183,
-0.0806054994,
0.3453856707,
1.1380605698,
-0.3307102919,
0.4319078028,
0.4758342206,
-0.7243667245,
0.6645454764,
0.541562736,
0.5513622761,
0.2564902306,
-0.083378695,
-0.7344248891,
-0.7982137203,
-0.2548905313,
-0.2698073089,
0.1324341744,
0.4167927206,
0.1463889778,
-0.5291125774,
-0.4616256952,
-0.141358763,
0.2516325414,
-0.2181545198,
0.5516213775,
0.1602878273,
-0.664144218,
0.4302472174,
-0.346555829,
0.1333585978,
-0.6364071965,
-0.1599453837,
-0.5527399778,
-0.1461442262,
-0.243185252,
-1.0525488853,
0.4328436255,
-0.386787802,
-0.0444163345,
-0.1363382041,
0.4437862635,
-0.4601065814,
-0.3123865128,
0.0291084833,
0.6864594221,
0.0637418106,
-0.2839677334,
-0.8245655298,
-0.2057272792,
-0.223556906,
-0.0346954316,
0.5061364174,
0.5774444342,
-0.2281983048,
0.6913712025,
0.8894057274,
-0.2135438025,
0.1296147108,
-0.0120109841,
1.1198931932,
-0.5412390828,
-0.4224248528,
-0.482157886,
0.3268009722,
-0.2604081333,
-0.3105396926,
0.7669932246,
0.7852612138,
0.491204679,
0.0454832911,
0.4935156703,
-0.2091240585,
0.4902451634,
-0.3699046075,
0.1451238245,
-0.5531564355,
0.13188456,
0.0202863552,
-0.9513656497,
-0.6173874736,
0.4366877377,
-0.007001962,
0.0452648699,
0.723715961,
0.7756011486,
-0.1565585881,
0.2702662051,
0.4012698233,
0.1513751745,
0.0817965642,
0.6913813949,
1.0425448418,
-0.051436048,
0.6572775245,
-0.0187705103,
-0.1765430123,
-0.2067823112,
-0.4590945244,
-0.5105792284,
-0.1531200558,
-0.2042321563,
-0.568356514,
-0.0159793925,
0.8025451899,
0.593834877,
-0.866009295,
-0.3843185604,
-0.1991137862,
0.3134254515,
-0.3094108999,
-0.2582184672,
0.2237741798,
-0.1098133475,
-0.2831549644,
0.5550478697,
0.8179273009,
-0.2193601727,
-0.079576306,
0.0325068086,
-0.2883741856,
0.3558553755,
0.7738537192,
0.6793925166,
-0.5091900826,
0.0691161081,
0.3163639307,
0.1907402873,
0.1337868571,
0.8068660498,
-0.9481540322,
0.6901642084,
0.2792413235,
0.7563038468,
0.6576178074,
0.0738446191,
0.3895657361,
-0.6495584846,
-0.2914196253,
0.5304102302,
0.232097134,
0.1436688155,
-0.4139462709,
0.5460225344,
0.5214188099,
-0.4172555506,
-0.3994628787,
0.4235113859,
-1.1977752447,
-0.389860034,
0.828764081,
0.2839303911,
-0.231515348,
-0.4299540222,
-0.1570788771,
-0.4217845798,
-0.4277935624,
0.3259066641,
0.4383635521,
-0.7714574933,
-0.1916296482,
-0.3008381426,
0.145827055,
0.5817238092,
-1.0228456259,
0.0338171646,
0.9776440263,
0.2170174122,
0.117030561,
0.8880304098,
-0.0644242689,
0.450065732,
0.2128750086,
-0.217188254,
0.1736958921,
-0.4485509992,
-0.1056429893,
0.1947307736,
-0.1439586431,
0.0593685135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17879v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17879v2
|
Automated Statistical Model Discovery with Language Models
| 2024-02-27T20:33:22 | 2024-06-22T05:08:30 |
Michael Y. Li, Emily B. Fox, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Statistical model discovery is a challenging search over a vast space of
models subject to domain-specific constraints. Efficiently searching over this
space requires expertise in modeling and the problem domain. Motivated by the
domain knowledge and programming capabilities of large language models (LMs),
we introduce a method for language model driven automated statistical model
discovery. We cast our automated procedure within the principled framework of
Box's Loop: the LM iterates between proposing statistical models represented as
probabilistic programs, acting as a modeler, and critiquing those models,
acting as a domain expert. By leveraging LMs, we do not have to define a
domain-specific language of models or design a handcrafted search procedure,
which are key restrictions of previous systems. We evaluate our method in three
settings in probabilistic modeling: searching within a restricted space of
models, searching over an open-ended space, and improving expert models under
natural language constraints (e.g., this model should be interpretable to an
ecologist). Our method identifies models on par with human expert designed
models and extends classic models in interpretable ways. Our results highlight
the promise of LM-driven model discovery.
|
[
-0.2250249386,
-0.9903641939,
0.9753171802,
-0.1323584169,
0.0578311794,
0.0748448744,
-0.1718654335,
-0.0918833762,
0.0959364101,
0.9700652957,
-0.5989297628,
-0.7879042625,
-0.5007009506,
0.0655143261,
-0.4645877182,
0.4671387672,
-0.2716878653,
0.2172119021,
-0.0982458964,
0.1751723439,
-0.4454119802,
-0.4547318518,
-0.2363345623,
-0.3507315814,
0.2076353282,
0.2110566944,
0.8924739957,
0.8326236606,
0.6804199219,
0.3426922262,
0.1395951957,
0.3019032776,
-0.2589435279,
0.1753388345,
-0.275259316,
-0.7055920959,
-0.5112204552,
-0.1565035135,
0.4591054916,
0.9552756548,
-0.3098939359,
0.0764920041,
-0.1752558202,
0.4431968331,
-0.4340509176,
0.5748950839,
-0.8094137311,
-0.0016707288,
-0.3441325128,
-0.5818240047,
-0.5162952542,
-0.3573099375,
0.1986284554,
-0.5820636749,
0.7447193861,
0.1992275268,
0.4236050546,
0.1605364382,
-0.4666121602,
-0.4442285299,
-0.8546466827,
0.8708059788,
-0.593924582,
0.4086925089,
0.6824541092,
0.5201564431,
-0.5972294807,
-0.2031825185,
-0.3696857691,
-0.3312134743,
-0.0449448265,
-0.4001130164,
-0.1852755994,
-0.0980828181,
0.1078742221,
0.0728269219,
-0.7919956446,
-0.0836467966,
-0.3293204606,
-0.1920939535,
0.830091536,
0.2928362191,
0.2389163822,
0.0804790556,
0.1963752508,
-0.0499868654,
-0.5100371242,
-0.2680766582,
0.2609297037,
0.6288042068,
0.2798193395,
0.8444844484,
-0.2750736773,
0.7255125642,
-0.5208010674,
0.0281799883,
-0.1441185027,
0.012388275,
-0.0544526018,
-0.3383338451,
0.6330675483,
0.11439915,
0.440151155,
-0.0846813694,
-0.4687699676,
0.070556052,
0.106336385,
-0.3292447329,
-0.6227164865,
0.0852450058,
-0.4712190926,
-0.2140804976,
0.0799391046,
-0.7186473608,
-0.3931690753,
-0.3623235524,
0.5346406698,
-0.2902563214,
-0.417180717,
0.2594676316,
-0.1621909738,
-0.2771906257,
0.1859190911,
-0.5215983391,
0.417349726,
0.6963152289,
0.6890134215,
0.0082820039,
0.0275943894,
-0.4409623742,
0.1560088098,
-0.9928860664,
0.8863486648,
-0.9366644621,
-0.266369909,
0.0871233866,
0.2814131975,
0.0927700922,
-0.8491953611,
0.1110409275,
-0.8289157748,
-0.1762934327,
-0.1052005589,
-0.843806088,
-0.2883927822,
-0.4279591441,
-0.6521272659,
0.7759855986,
0.0238655843,
-0.3303743303,
0.4450783134,
-0.7249604464,
-0.1020298004,
0.2515795231,
-0.2381441295,
-0.5919943452,
0.1445718408,
0.1624175757,
0.6662391424,
-0.349948287,
0.6703671813,
-0.7568053007,
-0.171327889,
0.4541411996,
-0.1008558646,
0.7791486382,
0.3176990747,
-0.2392320335,
0.0635315478,
-0.9117555618,
0.0427860543,
0.375076741,
0.1162459627,
-0.4795807898,
0.405952245,
-0.0303653739,
-0.3993444741,
-0.0630809367,
-0.0942888185,
0.3766225576,
-0.1004918367,
0.3310183883,
0.6441563964,
-0.1337635517,
0.584125638,
-0.1484895051,
0.6898839474,
-0.1333522499,
-0.0721067339,
-0.3424489796,
-0.3952875435,
-0.6039040089,
-0.2421707362,
0.1704395264,
0.6718991399,
-0.373521775,
0.6615728736,
0.1211227253,
-0.4179655612,
-0.5311869979,
0.1922382414,
0.1056406051,
0.0009522716,
0.3693124056,
-0.34203583,
-0.4971851707,
-0.9754908681,
-0.1343429834,
0.045630347,
-0.2228744328,
0.2732512057,
0.6656087041,
-0.5995243192,
1.17771101,
-0.7868301272,
-0.3935849965,
-0.2474171817,
0.232773453,
0.3392501175,
0.296367377,
0.3349587023,
-0.4869536161,
-0.2118385136,
0.0013355304,
-0.9013826251,
-0.3506498039,
0.3173352182,
-0.069806926,
0.1069865376,
0.4650416672,
-0.4219592512,
0.6533471942,
0.1804813147,
-0.083820492,
0.4988552928,
-0.4072217941,
-0.0520057231,
-0.6980425715,
-0.018953111,
0.2076960653,
-0.1363512725,
-0.6268244982,
0.3864467442,
0.1626962274,
-0.3461185992,
0.2842132151,
0.6318754554,
-0.654763341,
-0.2248914987,
-0.3997254968,
-0.1410795301,
-0.2415650934,
0.1636845022,
0.4786082506,
0.5155010223,
0.8647527099,
-0.7168880701,
0.3338904381,
0.045828145,
-0.408704102,
0.2608461678,
-0.5122298598,
0.0698971823,
-0.2642753124,
0.3204778731,
-0.8543927073,
-0.3614403903,
0.032021381,
-0.1536526382,
0.0262806956,
-0.1017905101,
-0.4057579637,
-0.3694085181,
0.2110432982,
0.3923227787,
0.4783103466,
-0.4571301937,
0.3798759282,
0.6025838852,
-0.3430422544,
-0.1641830653,
-0.0568334348,
0.1476760954,
-0.1074366942,
-0.5117304325,
0.0269173123,
-0.1625504196,
-0.6346835494,
-0.1546866447,
-0.0745046958,
-0.3083191514,
0.200887993,
-0.0765987709,
0.060213428,
-0.3082400262,
0.2448403537,
-0.2708032727,
-0.2655799389,
0.0428821407,
-0.293004334,
0.5153908134,
-0.0186334997,
-0.4407934844,
-0.2514661849,
0.6143239737,
0.1632924378,
-0.3445134759,
0.321182549,
0.1381040066,
-0.748953104,
-0.7275435328,
-0.5291268229,
-0.3687369525,
-0.4393536747,
0.4605099559,
-0.5753272772,
-0.587813437,
0.5389258862,
0.0110712759,
-0.2988330126,
0.3451552391,
0.5088223219,
-0.0258852877,
1.5124291182,
1.1447511911,
0.0429315083,
0.165812254,
-0.2808109224,
0.5945954323,
-0.17247127,
-0.0998976231,
-0.6862592697,
0.1708219051,
-0.3854352832,
-0.7171022892,
0.4973324835,
0.1676287204,
-0.1544110775,
0.3793661296,
-0.5486890674,
0.5179103613,
0.7150102258,
0.2983910441,
0.3584991693,
-0.127413258,
-0.1267138124,
0.0533969998,
-0.8348247409,
-0.8218138814,
1.1591558456,
0.5094394684,
1.1281342506,
-0.1552135199,
0.7311573625,
0.3224239945,
0.3572751284,
-0.6123669744,
0.6787952781,
0.0226553045,
-0.6843423247,
-0.4214836359,
-0.5400043726,
-0.9945328236,
-0.1851056963,
0.0411729775,
-0.7782644033,
0.2335887253,
0.3503731191,
-0.2718234956,
0.1819063574,
-0.4499528706,
0.8249346614,
-0.2930926085,
-0.1713039577,
-0.3890823424,
-0.2645852864,
0.4023517072,
-0.2982987165,
0.6287559867,
-0.1436111629,
0.1482668072,
0.5700021982,
-0.5662146211,
0.8592281938,
-0.1144185811,
-0.2845832407,
0.1673231572,
0.6998534799,
0.6227570772,
-0.0610753074,
-0.0569412671,
-0.0723460838,
0.1514681131,
-0.3414413929,
-0.4835761189,
0.2430468053,
-0.4027647674,
-0.6774573326,
-0.3915908933,
-0.5815027952,
-0.1329368204,
0.1313579082,
-0.1630845815,
0.3663966358,
-0.1714444607,
0.0763102993,
0.8302174211,
-0.4329222739,
0.0373549089,
0.8083110452,
-0.5354212523,
0.0840768218,
0.7564231753,
0.1586276591,
-0.1170528755,
0.6030109525,
0.3351073265,
-0.3250212967,
-0.4526478052,
-0.227349177,
0.0936009362,
-0.6555714011,
-0.330676645,
-0.7513690591,
-0.1071929336,
-0.420060277,
-0.1461779624,
-0.264966011,
-0.0213516522,
-0.1936557144,
0.0190413799,
0.5943955779,
0.7509146929,
0.0363977179,
0.3023001254,
-0.61847651,
0.4773504734,
0.1853642613,
0.6223415136,
-0.1514256299,
-0.1874344051,
-0.3400052786,
0.004083646,
-0.1311564595,
-1.1807892323,
0.8400781751,
0.1290539652,
0.687903285,
0.4549112022,
0.1378716081,
0.6566159725,
-0.4918712676,
0.3545956314,
-0.2751860023,
-0.8575116396,
0.6791674495,
-0.523652792,
-0.0635670945,
-0.1471500546,
0.4945414066,
-0.1337314248,
-0.6396554112,
-0.5671133399,
-0.6726725698,
0.4370312989,
-0.0641610399,
-0.3767258823,
-0.0929742008,
0.1080241725,
0.405462563,
0.2681696713,
-0.5739881992,
0.0070172902,
0.2472018152,
-0.2526400983,
-0.4395238161,
-0.0683225393,
-0.2449040711,
-0.2058416605,
0.7829031944,
-0.3688083887,
0.2496851683,
0.1623391062,
-0.2620332539,
-0.5295701623,
0.0789169073,
0.3209975958,
0.9358157516,
-0.3682995737,
0.2403644919,
-0.032990586,
0.1963327229,
0.0276899114,
0.2390323132,
-0.1285017729,
0.2662169635,
0.4364986718,
0.7710918784,
0.2411754429,
-0.9757147431,
0.1062058806,
0.1841239482,
-0.1091441736,
-0.606058538,
0.2795989811,
-0.0550861843,
0.5499504209,
0.5969331264,
-0.1143862531,
0.2904461026,
-0.7992892861,
0.524541378,
0.7713015676,
0.1842601597,
-0.2807904482,
0.9460958242,
-0.2450821549,
-0.7414184213,
0.3224145472,
-0.2317540944,
-0.6234936118,
0.8612820506,
0.4892190397,
0.9138188362,
-0.2932290137,
0.3966616988,
0.1762511432,
0.182308495,
-0.4769755006,
0.3217897117,
-0.0129442913,
-0.7797700763,
-0.0367339775,
-0.5540214181,
-0.4609250128,
0.186358273,
-0.5499368906,
0.5025482774,
-0.0278757066,
-0.0439667962,
0.2369264662,
0.0694235861,
-0.9150207043,
0.1782433093,
-0.0760843158,
0.7646358013,
-1.0182142258,
0.7577124238,
0.426300168,
-0.0806485489,
-0.5200505853,
-0.2493626475,
0.0798016861,
-1.044706583,
0.7007318139,
-0.0384221151,
0.2234058231,
-0.0980712399,
-0.5513893366,
-0.9534152746,
0.8039431572,
0.0631310716,
-0.8869847059,
0.2646693289,
0.2062824965,
0.7023147941,
-0.7184728384,
0.4901818037,
0.6845670342,
0.299253583,
-0.3506469727,
-0.9581217766,
-0.0436993204,
-0.155385673,
0.1155045629,
0.1996963173,
-0.053160429,
0.7648189068,
-0.3930118382,
-0.0396174379,
0.2361621112,
0.5610121489,
0.4295349717,
0.7048044205,
0.4868689179,
0.3209739327,
0.8741196394,
0.1383028626,
0.8082472086,
-0.2662554383,
0.4787604213,
0.8086288571,
-0.6093586087,
0.9450564384,
0.0624784976,
-0.4489125609,
0.2056803852,
0.8774297237,
-0.1194175333,
0.40249753,
0.6099458933,
-0.1284400374,
-0.4842946529,
0.166093871,
-0.1090053245,
0.1064435169,
0.3793743849,
-0.4877190888,
-0.2217052132,
-0.0960412025,
-0.1816013753,
0.3499622941,
-0.2677065134,
0.6921892762,
-0.0663306564,
-0.6923152208,
0.4693470597,
0.1470529586,
0.2355407923,
-0.494214505,
-0.2050299942,
-0.1953023225,
0.3502586484,
0.0493346229,
-0.6106255054,
0.2302266657,
-0.0268100929,
-0.2736308873,
-0.2015026212,
0.7322736979,
-0.7199846506,
-0.9656774998,
0.3605954051,
0.688991785,
0.3551323116,
-0.0892473906,
-0.3722271919,
-0.0621460341,
-0.2057913393,
-0.2466930598,
0.0587098673,
0.5876177549,
-0.470364809,
1.0204656124,
0.4568279088,
0.1236659735,
0.0493862107,
0.0896553919,
0.3586340845,
-0.7964944243,
-0.4503898919,
-0.6875418425,
0.120967336,
0.148597613,
0.309293896,
0.4355219007,
0.7203456163,
0.7452162504,
-0.3880216479,
1.1578294039,
0.1567480266,
0.8258138299,
-0.5265002251,
0.3947838545,
-0.5143945217,
0.4709618688,
-0.2902845442,
-0.8418110013,
-0.3224168122,
0.8641363382,
-0.3379429281,
-0.0194354318,
0.565458715,
1.3496576548,
-0.2361825407,
-0.0035912539,
0.2254859507,
0.3046018481,
0.3797191381,
0.1994826496,
0.6650565267,
-0.0506255031,
0.2522633672,
-0.3086993098,
-0.6601063609,
-0.3249985278,
-0.9599426985,
-0.854729712,
-0.8946930766,
-0.4505586028,
-0.0305730384,
0.2588915229,
1.0886008739,
0.7840790749,
-0.9109399319,
-0.653241396,
-0.2676839828,
0.1975717396,
-0.4547476768,
-0.3149322867,
0.2599102855,
-0.3325901628,
-0.676097095,
0.5552861691,
0.1952517927,
-0.1621474177,
-0.4471647143,
0.0202931408,
0.2417047322,
0.2905734479,
0.3629325926,
0.2229772806,
-0.6834205389,
-0.1024380326,
0.1874744594,
0.271289289,
-0.2207404524,
1.0587186813,
-0.5690085292,
0.5316146612,
0.4174408317,
0.5407680273,
0.3118438125,
-0.3459373415,
1.0916554928,
-0.4597707689,
-0.113299191,
0.1823194027,
0.5062420964,
-0.0092704482,
-0.1991803348,
0.5843532681,
0.3343826234,
-0.7325642109,
-1.1838885546,
0.3056711555,
-0.7996341586,
-0.4741377234,
1.0267310143,
0.2387985885,
-0.0839937478,
-0.2158444524,
-0.2081044018,
0.1297999024,
-0.2658684254,
1.065207243,
0.5300431252,
-0.1188204288,
-0.2555201352,
-0.9763251543,
0.4498349428,
0.1537163705,
-0.4866381884,
0.2647224069,
0.255921483,
0.3261566758,
-0.0290300194,
0.5693824887,
0.1619615853,
0.0320820175,
-0.151611954,
0.2259598374,
0.25546965,
-0.5003839731,
-0.0520768836,
0.095823586,
-0.0223657358,
0.2861597538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00828v1
|
Deep Learning Detection Method for Large Language Models-Generated Scientific Content
| 2024-02-27T19:16:39 | 2024-02-27T19:16:39 |
Bushra Alhijawi, Rawan Jarrar, Aseel AbuAlRub, Arwa Bader
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-3 and BERT, reshape how textual
content is written and communicated. These models have the potential to
generate scientific content that is indistinguishable from that written by
humans. Hence, LLMs carry severe consequences for the scientific community,
which relies on the integrity and reliability of publications. This research
paper presents a novel ChatGPT-generated scientific text detection method,
AI-Catcher. AI-Catcher integrates two deep learning models, multilayer
perceptron (MLP) and convolutional neural networks (CNN). The MLP learns the
feature representations of the linguistic and statistical features. The CNN
extracts high-level representations of the sequential patterns from the textual
content. AI-Catcher is a multimodal model that fuses hidden patterns derived
from MLP and CNN. In addition, a new ChatGPT-Generated scientific text dataset
is collected to enhance AI-generated text detection tools, AIGTxt. AIGTxt
contains 3000 records collected from published academic articles across ten
domains and divided into three classes: Human-written, ChatGPT-generated, and
Mixed text. Several experiments are conducted to evaluate the performance of
AI-Catcher. The comparative results demonstrate the capability of AI-Catcher to
distinguish between human-written and ChatGPT-generated scientific text more
accurately than alternative methods. On average, AI-Catcher improved accuracy
by 37.4%.
|
[
-0.1498138011,
-1.0260906219,
0.4918849766,
0.1415614784,
-0.4188190103,
0.4032516181,
-0.3232809603,
-0.7016149759,
0.0738857761,
0.493810147,
-0.193625018,
-0.7687883973,
-0.7990259528,
0.487605989,
-0.6044963002,
0.9639511704,
0.2402548045,
-0.0581973083,
-0.2326164842,
0.4146209955,
-0.2466473877,
-0.2464676648,
-0.7395278811,
-0.3938807249,
0.4250486195,
0.2504909933,
0.4139287472,
0.5435190201,
0.7803077698,
0.3510439992,
-0.1500832736,
0.4338453412,
-0.2321271747,
0.2230737358,
0.0409169383,
-0.4038710892,
-0.0954746976,
-0.1223308146,
0.8592087626,
0.1527656913,
0.1385930479,
-0.0765987784,
0.1834067702,
0.3676666319,
-0.176924482,
0.3661797345,
-0.8745238781,
0.2868030667,
-0.4327926338,
-0.3084096014,
-0.6542182565,
-0.1502072066,
-0.0199458394,
-0.4444039464,
0.4559325278,
0.1544322968,
0.7252689004,
0.1844153255,
-0.4144424498,
-0.4647705853,
-0.4201980531,
0.8116337061,
-0.9137808681,
0.1682785004,
0.3070681691,
0.1334636956,
-0.4519393146,
-0.6748890877,
-1.1853806973,
-0.4527803659,
-0.1783220768,
0.2192437202,
-0.046810247,
-0.1987195462,
0.0084084617,
0.0252809245,
-0.9843305349,
0.3639148474,
-0.2544281185,
-0.1491613835,
0.6295890212,
-0.0496098511,
0.4441180825,
-0.3583293557,
-0.1667277813,
-0.3940838277,
-0.5920112133,
-0.2168437839,
0.2739554048,
0.1594836116,
0.068966575,
0.604729414,
0.1305977702,
0.2332985699,
-0.2187951356,
-0.1911368668,
0.2531055212,
-0.2090310156,
-0.0311496463,
0.3493651748,
1.2832343578,
0.1012281328,
0.2426574826,
0.1274761707,
0.0261078402,
-0.0538380109,
-0.1416242272,
-0.9336898923,
-0.3153579235,
-0.1038235947,
-0.6661750078,
-0.5339162946,
-0.0963976979,
-0.6295983791,
-0.7380567193,
0.0169603378,
-0.0481151789,
-0.493871063,
-0.3923173547,
0.1833877116,
0.0158927999,
0.2007762939,
0.2373782843,
-0.8062645793,
-0.0034330343,
0.8589575887,
1.1194894314,
-0.2882128656,
-0.1384423077,
-0.4269805551,
0.0939365402,
-0.0633508638,
1.0967005491,
-0.5724616051,
-0.2151290029,
-0.2854880989,
-0.1165230572,
0.0704768002,
-0.3040799797,
0.488933295,
-0.6695366502,
0.2303809226,
0.2489994913,
-0.7953725457,
-0.3558265567,
0.3835232854,
-0.6505173445,
0.8605943322,
-0.390915513,
-0.840680778,
0.5455961823,
-0.6584972739,
-0.5104920864,
0.4573281705,
-0.2559887171,
-0.929685235,
-0.3377665579,
0.4012857676,
0.6606231928,
-0.1795714945,
0.5787810087,
-0.4071611464,
-0.3582666814,
0.5469298959,
-0.9631909132,
0.6827571392,
0.3682008982,
-0.2636312246,
0.068384923,
-0.7566028833,
-0.1631101519,
0.2047084123,
-0.434314549,
-0.3729284704,
0.2992936075,
0.228225559,
-0.0994459093,
0.1202752218,
-0.9968873262,
0.2989515662,
-0.3045260906,
0.5070794821,
0.5220981836,
0.0462861992,
0.0136266723,
0.0670644864,
0.2386039943,
-0.0390543677,
-0.1204590127,
-0.3127835393,
-0.7095134854,
-0.3468025327,
-0.4816733599,
0.1935905516,
0.564206779,
-0.7132378221,
0.8011485934,
-0.016631918,
-0.5352143645,
-0.5421321988,
0.1051248237,
0.2973990142,
0.4211714268,
0.4351531863,
-0.1430190355,
-0.4344666898,
-0.6171839833,
-0.418926388,
-0.0743332356,
-0.1459537446,
0.1299697757,
0.7975786924,
-0.3168756366,
0.5950189829,
-0.3829663694,
-0.3424422145,
0.0333041884,
0.4380020797,
0.4467225373,
0.5929604769,
0.4076446593,
-0.9221006036,
-0.8794623613,
0.2752488554,
-1.0115753412,
0.0576045886,
-0.0789108425,
0.2353461385,
0.144941479,
0.6939925551,
-0.6830788255,
0.290001601,
0.3642210066,
-0.3958994746,
0.4923722744,
-0.1486264467,
0.2240083963,
-0.9418574572,
0.1626430452,
0.2017469555,
-0.2962966561,
-0.387597084,
-0.0630891025,
0.1482365131,
-0.0746714324,
-0.30675897,
0.5383639336,
-0.3012332022,
0.376342684,
-0.5890806317,
-0.0239160843,
0.0916165039,
-0.0194503963,
0.3442532122,
0.7465587854,
0.2210991681,
-0.3286082149,
0.3821161985,
0.3167229593,
-0.5855014324,
0.2129896283,
-0.6805295348,
0.182212308,
-0.311488986,
0.4891428649,
-1.0963432789,
-0.2057504356,
0.4059441984,
-0.6522158384,
0.3475951552,
-0.0162154902,
-0.8032363057,
-0.3775747716,
-0.2459728271,
0.382499963,
0.2915093899,
-0.4770243466,
0.3969664872,
0.0980459899,
-0.5002868176,
-0.6981934309,
-0.6846066117,
0.4423537552,
0.016750114,
-0.5243271589,
0.2391281426,
-0.0998700634,
-0.0704794601,
0.098498933,
0.0933054313,
0.0056564719,
0.1441585422,
0.0337398238,
0.2573891878,
-0.3370464444,
0.1617822796,
0.3160742223,
-0.0432266407,
-0.0237165093,
-0.2173425406,
0.7052620053,
-0.1525483429,
-0.3579658866,
-0.6267901063,
0.3549462855,
0.4802753031,
-0.232222721,
0.7390101552,
1.0938392878,
-0.1842385679,
0.0242713839,
-0.4890137613,
-0.3256073594,
-0.5183089972,
0.5726485848,
-0.0933944657,
-0.8867580295,
0.2340248376,
0.278485477,
-0.0283584222,
0.5554945469,
0.513497591,
-0.2384692132,
1.1841849089,
0.4218778312,
-0.1578001231,
0.4694930315,
-0.056916438,
0.4750483036,
-0.5996008515,
-0.3544294834,
-0.8095139861,
-0.1182771996,
-0.5212556124,
-0.1498942226,
0.2118365169,
-0.1728294492,
-0.3783070147,
0.2024376988,
-1.0143737793,
0.6987579465,
0.7852780223,
0.1999791265,
0.6735777855,
0.1672151983,
0.0854260027,
0.0265512802,
-0.327695787,
-0.6751924157,
1.1119369268,
0.3474881649,
0.6973060369,
-0.1074054018,
0.5691450834,
0.5146456957,
0.5402329564,
-0.6869009137,
0.4120595753,
-0.2398842573,
-0.4311786294,
-0.2819871902,
-0.4841533303,
-1.0725073814,
0.4540538788,
-0.4940606952,
-0.4594002366,
-0.1630594283,
-0.0823233426,
-0.085359171,
0.4440840483,
-0.6789884567,
0.5622798204,
-0.2892686427,
-0.0946512222,
-0.2576015592,
-0.4307441413,
0.3945421278,
-0.1919592768,
0.1448808312,
-0.2146980762,
0.2023701817,
0.8037393689,
0.1146242693,
0.9677534103,
-0.1102291346,
-0.1283868402,
0.3276369274,
0.1066429019,
0.6894786358,
0.4229803979,
-0.0167083032,
0.3239123523,
-0.1218134388,
-0.2143076509,
-0.0273988247,
0.6432254314,
-0.7381651998,
-0.5091196299,
-0.7184358835,
-0.6606380939,
0.2864031494,
0.6624619961,
0.2613031268,
-0.0937397927,
-0.03695371,
0.4705915153,
0.6794731617,
-0.5870145559,
0.6449227929,
0.7892864347,
0.0036477698,
-0.2167890221,
0.8439651728,
-0.3052652776,
-0.2185753286,
0.5334343314,
0.2692188621,
-0.176528886,
-0.9764547348,
-0.2264447659,
0.1555430442,
-0.3168590665,
-0.5563808084,
-0.9327318072,
-0.4318966866,
-0.5675595403,
-0.0133454269,
-0.1172716171,
0.0655359477,
-0.4837241173,
0.0485316589,
0.5101907849,
0.4435032308,
0.1970120817,
0.4451493025,
-0.9353334308,
0.2971592247,
-0.1255928725,
0.1102777198,
0.0594051257,
-0.2856877744,
-0.0131153343,
0.077210106,
-0.3755948246,
-0.4450427592,
0.7780063152,
0.2068217546,
0.2992734313,
0.5318171978,
-0.2602488101,
-0.0011203135,
-0.4880816042,
0.6349138021,
0.2864402533,
-0.6889472008,
0.4120050073,
-0.415446341,
0.3074260354,
0.2632098198,
0.2952160239,
-0.6217384934,
-0.6109907627,
-0.1844429672,
-0.6770122051,
0.3711275458,
0.030491313,
0.1757917702,
-0.15862149,
0.2213920206,
0.3738940954,
0.1911856979,
-1.0992991924,
0.2002059072,
-0.1780590862,
-0.472476691,
-0.085969463,
0.0064017843,
0.1928973943,
-0.1345489174,
0.7458595037,
-0.1839241385,
0.2542133033,
0.1449939162,
-0.1424859762,
0.093183808,
0.1357911676,
0.572999239,
0.1701704115,
-0.1793712825,
0.1745834351,
-0.2782191634,
-0.940058887,
-0.0479950793,
0.3188079894,
-0.4876891077,
-0.0610722899,
0.6851093173,
0.4309625626,
-0.2769140005,
-0.7168579102,
0.4203961194,
-0.1637074947,
-0.257476449,
-0.3211010396,
0.1666730642,
-0.0404813178,
0.5102093816,
0.6121063828,
0.2491325587,
0.3701625466,
-0.362698704,
0.1994383782,
0.6922573447,
-0.0476907566,
-0.1469718218,
0.6434246898,
-0.0450313762,
-0.2203410417,
0.7483201623,
0.0005223682,
-0.4955002666,
0.8268969655,
0.7234795094,
0.6695370674,
-0.0355244018,
0.3114854991,
0.1726972759,
0.2752331197,
0.0495436527,
0.0712700561,
-0.0575773828,
-0.8656620979,
-0.6619288325,
-0.7252480388,
-0.3010109067,
0.4535960257,
-0.143678382,
0.2076999396,
-0.3014470041,
0.069065392,
0.4456685185,
0.1546347439,
-0.606795311,
-0.1233540773,
0.2778585255,
0.6262581348,
-0.8225613832,
0.8229780197,
0.2507617176,
-0.3308912814,
-0.4046811759,
-0.1817402691,
0.0497982055,
-0.8721855283,
0.5796155334,
0.2834073603,
-0.0286833122,
0.0378684327,
-0.9316561222,
-0.8402714729,
0.8574610353,
0.1521062106,
-0.8204019666,
0.21056889,
0.0931964964,
0.6174736619,
-0.0848162398,
0.3455094993,
0.3116982579,
0.7479456663,
-0.0041584079,
-0.7511311769,
-0.0260938574,
-0.3958292007,
-0.4258413017,
0.1196261495,
-0.5783147812,
0.7614734769,
0.1147531345,
-0.0488146842,
0.2214244157,
0.7499725223,
0.528603971,
0.4215325415,
0.2181927562,
0.2434008867,
0.9929964542,
0.0144336764,
0.7563636303,
0.1504383087,
0.4558710456,
0.7987913489,
-0.4669138789,
0.6600485444,
0.3645949364,
-0.0396518968,
0.4756825566,
0.5568751693,
-0.7365096211,
0.5057688951,
0.2652208209,
-0.5379012823,
0.0440453626,
-0.1703491509,
-0.5016650558,
0.5712988973,
0.5716108084,
-0.5039391518,
-0.0757532045,
0.4230520427,
0.2507578731,
0.1054809764,
-0.1901946664,
0.7811725736,
0.1728280634,
-0.6507588029,
0.3420846462,
0.1343936771,
0.9969195724,
-0.3988769352,
-0.2335969508,
0.0042720526,
0.462020874,
-0.2505834401,
-1.0446822643,
0.0422324687,
0.1594758034,
-0.1376898438,
0.0474528596,
1.0667954683,
-0.5471513867,
-0.6199687719,
0.1151106581,
0.1783635467,
0.2869459391,
-0.1375820488,
-0.5741978288,
-0.0198712125,
-0.1493508816,
-0.4932135046,
0.1705724895,
0.4303864539,
-0.0428499244,
0.6020838618,
1.000343442,
0.0635569319,
0.0099024866,
0.0647500679,
0.6530207396,
-0.5044950843,
-0.3809221387,
-1.0477713346,
0.0098960754,
-0.3757554591,
-0.0202572383,
0.7949594855,
0.6851729155,
0.7014668584,
-0.2382266223,
1.0395427942,
-0.0418817215,
0.3568127155,
-0.5360347033,
1.1914168596,
-0.1457982957,
0.1812325418,
-0.3535623252,
-0.8263622522,
-0.880222261,
0.7043423057,
-0.1041331142,
-0.1799039692,
0.7324127555,
0.5888203979,
-0.1083118543,
0.1432268173,
-0.0062433453,
0.2299903333,
0.805134356,
0.3433717787,
0.7817913294,
-0.3174239397,
0.6275317073,
0.0968376696,
-0.1629293412,
-0.190648064,
-1.0462594032,
-1.1510632038,
-0.2782097161,
-0.3007175326,
-0.2666667104,
-0.0241062194,
0.5897429585,
0.5744946599,
-1.0038212538,
0.125280574,
-0.299071759,
0.086896427,
-0.1745499223,
-0.2923059762,
0.7964124084,
-0.2145824879,
-0.7118238211,
0.5501716137,
0.1892412454,
0.0048740939,
-0.2096738666,
0.1766792685,
-0.3967252672,
-0.0827761814,
0.6427329183,
0.2768622935,
-0.4711693227,
-0.2852811515,
0.0830134079,
-0.1703956276,
0.003487193,
0.5781516433,
-0.6029018164,
0.2487184554,
0.5392074585,
0.7276860476,
0.8717783689,
-0.3434981704,
0.1788153648,
-0.6920042634,
0.2345291376,
0.5520416498,
0.3147808611,
0.3094638884,
-0.7316316366,
0.3403536975,
0.2720218599,
-0.9032157063,
-0.8377322555,
-0.1445463598,
-0.9559500813,
-0.5361199379,
0.8204615712,
-0.0806826279,
-0.1794331968,
-0.0774680227,
-0.2559686899,
0.3666672111,
-0.5979578495,
1.1188040972,
0.5601472855,
0.0184662417,
-0.2470623851,
-0.5200155377,
0.2683696747,
0.2226807773,
-0.7290675044,
-0.2406701297,
0.322743237,
0.1445313096,
0.1902778298,
0.3318182528,
-0.161117062,
0.1652919799,
-0.063352406,
0.2761509418,
-0.3566616774,
-0.3017966747,
0.1031530946,
0.2334232181,
-0.211222589,
0.0843321681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00827v1
|
Self-Refinement of Language Models from External Proxy Metrics Feedback
| 2024-02-27T19:13:01 | 2024-02-27T19:13:01 |
Keshav Ramji, Young-Suk Lee, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo, Md Arafat Sultan, Tahira Naseem, Asim Munawar, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It is often desirable for Large Language Models (LLMs) to capture multiple
objectives when providing a response. In document-grounded response generation,
for example, agent responses are expected to be relevant to a user's query
while also being grounded in a given document. In this paper, we introduce
Proxy Metric-based Self-Refinement (ProMiSe), which enables an LLM to refine
its own initial response along key dimensions of quality guided by external
metrics feedback, yielding an overall better final response. ProMiSe leverages
feedback on response quality through principle-specific proxy metrics, and
iteratively refines its response one principle at a time. We apply ProMiSe to
open source language models Flan-T5-XXL and Llama-2-13B-Chat, to evaluate its
performance on document-grounded question answering datasets, MultiDoc2Dial and
QuAC, demonstrating that self-refinement improves response quality. We further
show that fine-tuning Llama-2-13B-Chat on the synthetic dialogue data generated
by ProMiSe yields significant performance improvements over the zero-shot
baseline as well as a supervised fine-tuned model on human annotated data.
|
[
-0.3151700795,
-0.5082937479,
0.6653921008,
-0.0136557538,
0.0042679631,
0.3425482213,
-0.1354489028,
-0.4951061606,
0.3895986378,
0.7380222678,
-0.7250870466,
-0.4851803184,
-0.217091009,
0.1549188495,
-0.4085842967,
0.9782802463,
0.0928827599,
0.1187168285,
-0.2084519118,
-0.2443888485,
-0.6311765313,
-0.2963843644,
-0.7363295555,
-0.2183726728,
0.4909098148,
0.6763097644,
0.7210102677,
0.7730365396,
0.4049288929,
0.3516779244,
0.2793014348,
0.1943525225,
-0.6500089169,
0.2007804662,
-0.4526084363,
-0.6279331446,
-0.4984069765,
0.1108355448,
0.5578640103,
0.4749477804,
-0.077693589,
0.487238735,
0.2543951869,
0.583206594,
-0.2285510749,
0.2401912361,
-0.7141200304,
-0.3061160743,
0.1117548421,
-0.0801553726,
-0.2470062524,
-0.2169958204,
0.0633618385,
-0.6755450964,
0.7402583957,
0.0492340103,
0.921849966,
0.3125950694,
-0.0475446954,
-0.300778836,
-0.6670824289,
0.511891067,
-0.9267356992,
0.4090730548,
0.3414956033,
0.4595449269,
-0.474781543,
-0.8574028611,
-0.4876372814,
-0.3561898768,
-0.2220152617,
0.1447883248,
0.1951315105,
0.0941615924,
-0.0440342166,
0.5026642084,
-0.3078113496,
0.339995563,
-0.5043262243,
-0.4250362515,
0.6594693065,
0.2050181776,
-0.1032085642,
-0.0011977645,
-0.1546546668,
-0.1638563126,
-0.6952400804,
0.2143568546,
0.4588983357,
0.761185348,
0.0591779836,
0.5076444149,
-0.7090165615,
0.2498322725,
0.1033943146,
-0.2633058727,
0.1797594726,
-0.3799810112,
0.090625748,
-0.2876994908,
0.7408461571,
0.3519481421,
0.1122651696,
-0.0782238394,
-0.3818234503,
0.0822586119,
0.4193424582,
-0.7364707589,
0.0778847933,
0.5574641824,
-0.5377575159,
-0.1067708358,
-0.0836597979,
-0.7237855196,
-0.2035634816,
-0.4875213504,
0.2971049845,
-0.202408731,
-0.3174237311,
0.0811419785,
0.2150277942,
0.1127486303,
0.5405747294,
-0.578494966,
0.5157994628,
0.7566996217,
0.8012070656,
0.1428161561,
-0.2869937718,
-0.8282683492,
-0.166937083,
-0.5562452078,
0.8065220714,
-0.3370772004,
-0.3616146445,
0.2743304968,
0.0144401882,
0.3242481053,
-0.3486976326,
0.6253156066,
-0.3773370683,
0.2674091756,
-0.2162592113,
-0.4973047078,
0.0045587411,
0.2943359911,
-0.5624318123,
1.0166213512,
0.0836494267,
-0.4500979185,
0.1004227996,
-0.5502532721,
-0.1529992372,
-0.0906276777,
-0.1821637899,
-0.1849870235,
0.4972677827,
0.1915617138,
0.2465634793,
-0.6497209072,
0.2671886683,
-0.5175236464,
-0.2196198255,
0.2273582816,
-0.2555844486,
-0.0297536571,
0.410469383,
-0.1675789654,
0.3370350897,
-1.0173273087,
0.3264141381,
0.1675761938,
-0.0897691846,
0.0368102901,
0.1249046177,
-0.3966775835,
0.2826604247,
0.324737817,
-0.789732337,
0.0630476624,
-0.7347798347,
0.3734899163,
0.7088897824,
-0.2769935131,
0.2168736607,
-0.4372546971,
0.4462695718,
-0.1644379199,
0.1221197918,
-0.6408842802,
-0.343826443,
-0.9826966524,
-0.1192539558,
0.224708125,
0.1255678535,
-0.4953521192,
0.0114132371,
-0.3143258095,
-0.4335286021,
-1.2496169806,
0.2815979123,
0.5715687871,
0.6704636812,
0.453684479,
-0.389670223,
-0.1973515451,
-1.0729759932,
-0.2580900788,
-0.6331327558,
-0.1017593667,
0.2192208916,
0.2062397003,
0.0735246018,
1.211602807,
-0.4959934652,
-0.5202972293,
0.0347816758,
0.1668032259,
0.150434047,
0.2925461829,
0.3785379529,
-0.4023861885,
-0.3830475509,
-0.1400630772,
-0.356623441,
-0.5388062596,
-0.0917015225,
0.0699423552,
0.2510660589,
0.5918201208,
-0.466989547,
0.3977282047,
0.5423917174,
-0.2707560658,
0.5446147919,
-0.3081795871,
0.173937425,
-1.0951468945,
-0.0481815599,
-0.1866391003,
-0.3736034036,
-0.5893864036,
0.3281227052,
0.0483690277,
-0.1224276945,
-0.4091275334,
0.9581256509,
-0.3508962691,
-0.1329279095,
-0.7087649107,
0.3929681778,
0.1286517233,
0.3143417835,
-0.0425356664,
0.7351781726,
0.4118199348,
-0.5799007416,
0.258687526,
0.2342956513,
0.0671573356,
0.4119505584,
-0.8985016942,
0.4208994806,
-0.2297619134,
0.3322787285,
-1.3638160229,
-0.1031970233,
0.1604069322,
-0.5345495343,
-0.0373872705,
-0.2134987712,
-0.5494414568,
-0.5311883092,
-0.2822599411,
0.1065971255,
0.3340377808,
-0.7221693993,
0.6055889726,
-0.0284054577,
-0.0363543443,
-0.4257702231,
-0.4140296876,
-0.026486095,
-0.0115760323,
-0.6117371321,
0.3522700369,
-0.3504990935,
-0.1728783399,
-0.0766484886,
-0.1793399155,
0.2042905539,
-0.0738702267,
0.3202951849,
-0.0833996534,
-0.1725823879,
0.291564554,
-0.0602013245,
-0.2713431716,
0.0316685401,
-0.4237012267,
0.6535906792,
-0.1469630301,
-0.471416533,
-0.4899425805,
0.2112167031,
0.6346853971,
-0.4583773017,
0.5778160691,
0.4342693985,
-0.0677463412,
-0.1371934861,
-0.969442606,
-0.5293753743,
-0.5358251929,
-0.0416124426,
-0.8854312897,
-1.1634092331,
0.9180087447,
-0.0837626904,
0.1769093126,
0.4705136716,
0.4097036123,
0.0454441868,
0.8606820703,
0.677087009,
-0.0832739174,
0.1871006042,
-0.0650066659,
0.0510639139,
-0.6541273594,
-0.0998874232,
-0.8527181745,
-0.0211806484,
-0.8281997442,
-0.2560426295,
-0.0034577155,
-0.0273300409,
-0.0196790304,
0.2664634585,
-0.2381018996,
0.2309747785,
0.5926361084,
-0.0638162643,
0.3101740181,
-0.0683051869,
-0.3486423194,
-0.0792746618,
-0.3764107823,
-0.6472793818,
1.0594455004,
0.8052591085,
0.8474522829,
0.0633703545,
0.7793265581,
0.0894390717,
0.3251647949,
-0.5225476623,
0.5892472267,
0.0465141684,
-0.455527544,
-0.1958700716,
-0.5285927653,
-0.7847590446,
0.3959537745,
-0.015325102,
-0.675355494,
-0.1589171588,
0.2449687421,
-0.252279073,
-0.1011272818,
-0.5618713498,
0.5806141496,
-0.1012903526,
-0.3945624232,
-0.471324265,
-0.4684411287,
0.0356858931,
-0.2328086495,
0.188072443,
-0.6514809132,
0.1373110712,
0.3074315786,
-0.6747617126,
1.0108221769,
-0.1315157712,
-0.4641526937,
0.5369440913,
0.3671619296,
0.5187034011,
0.296998024,
-0.1695204526,
0.1191712022,
0.120019339,
-0.2452618629,
-0.8970608115,
0.8295227289,
-0.6415455937,
-1.1349657774,
-0.076137118,
-0.318441689,
-0.341373384,
0.2644024193,
-0.0127626164,
0.4536653161,
-0.1397525817,
0.0149477618,
0.1002169251,
-0.2065005004,
0.418061763,
1.2703387737,
-0.5555366874,
-0.493076086,
0.5114399791,
0.0238229278,
0.5251402855,
0.1455609351,
0.3609369695,
-0.6514439583,
-0.3657121062,
-0.3103983104,
0.4308738112,
-0.674411118,
-0.4398118556,
-0.2956574261,
-0.2456974089,
-0.7302130461,
0.1791898161,
-0.8461681008,
-0.4607871473,
-0.2519907355,
-0.1265593618,
0.3346175551,
0.6301754713,
-0.1257614195,
0.5321478248,
-0.827447772,
0.4210883975,
-0.0114331041,
0.6275248528,
-0.2101463079,
-0.879917562,
-0.1051379219,
0.3088691533,
-0.2036440074,
-0.5234108567,
0.3970707953,
0.3205224276,
0.462472111,
0.2015829533,
0.1755750626,
0.743627131,
-0.7377114892,
0.7368914485,
-0.0350168534,
-0.8242393136,
0.7973233461,
-0.2680272162,
0.4317311347,
0.6192860603,
0.1612831354,
-0.4863869548,
-0.8257005215,
-0.5339833498,
-0.6149525642,
0.598821938,
0.2416320145,
0.5278409719,
-0.0571329929,
0.8904605508,
0.2659009397,
0.2748012245,
-0.5249434114,
-0.1714658886,
-0.2022139132,
-0.0973240733,
-0.1339149326,
-0.1938519776,
-0.1867401749,
0.1222676039,
0.6151077151,
-0.688781023,
0.1646048874,
0.3196524978,
0.2920369804,
-0.270170778,
0.3160425723,
0.3212555051,
0.6386423111,
-0.057616014,
-0.1156802997,
0.0250626206,
-0.0429558083,
0.2764464319,
0.0476965904,
-0.0627448484,
-0.1314548254,
0.2151129097,
0.5485069752,
-0.0961476415,
-0.5083603263,
0.2103780359,
-0.2985862792,
0.0041624261,
-0.2233966291,
0.1836227775,
-0.2899214625,
0.4011901617,
0.3305761516,
-0.390325278,
0.1388938427,
-0.5983025432,
0.2753080428,
0.4472816586,
-0.1670744866,
-0.3327921629,
0.7095219493,
0.1747477055,
-0.4080266953,
0.5368682742,
-0.090461053,
-0.2690110803,
0.2937508821,
0.91225034,
0.8492135406,
-0.3753559887,
0.5388493538,
0.5043637753,
0.1308541596,
-0.0900502875,
0.2332385778,
0.1593413204,
-0.8379073143,
-0.5603580475,
-0.7460520864,
-0.3113707602,
0.351464659,
-0.5748997331,
0.1538321376,
-0.5902402401,
-0.3753134012,
-0.2536806762,
0.0782660991,
-0.7307109833,
0.3854060173,
-0.1977289021,
0.8169475794,
-0.435135752,
0.6901225448,
0.4954585135,
-0.5668533444,
-0.8390079141,
0.1073605791,
0.0643320009,
-0.7874569893,
0.6680169702,
0.3593989909,
-0.4385993481,
0.0163603295,
-0.3963156343,
-1.2944129705,
0.8578112125,
0.5775779486,
-0.7066028118,
0.0755118132,
0.5280101895,
0.9359881282,
-0.5017294288,
0.4165621996,
0.4955994189,
0.0381463841,
0.1435298324,
-1.2414414883,
0.0669308305,
-0.1398900598,
0.176521942,
-0.03718853,
-1.0773872137,
0.4219523966,
-0.0457366444,
-0.2374197245,
0.3639723063,
1.0644299984,
0.0759124309,
0.0217707641,
0.3219861388,
0.630030334,
0.6520847082,
-0.1352867335,
0.9261705875,
-0.5892849565,
0.2543688416,
1.4005337954,
-0.3511592448,
0.9390273094,
0.2039514035,
0.1111316085,
0.4564678967,
0.5350822806,
0.223993808,
0.3591083288,
0.2808793187,
-0.0010770715,
0.1117447019,
-0.343003273,
-0.1597895175,
0.6367744207,
0.356630832,
-0.149809584,
-0.2084794641,
-0.1135342568,
-0.1349493414,
0.3403444886,
-0.326357156,
0.7327893972,
0.0243923943,
-1.0173965693,
0.5113262534,
0.255461812,
0.248240754,
-0.4994824827,
-0.0035467371,
-0.6702089906,
0.2770833969,
-0.0671262741,
-0.7052025199,
0.1818161905,
-0.0710200518,
-0.0658958778,
-0.1276939213,
0.6620517969,
-0.4825804532,
-0.2437387258,
0.6677034497,
0.4506733716,
0.0521769412,
-0.0464154966,
-0.8131656647,
0.1093276069,
-0.1784100682,
-0.1538804024,
0.1781634688,
0.3381001949,
0.1003918648,
1.1080867052,
0.7199302316,
0.0934032649,
0.0158280283,
0.3625905514,
0.9043648243,
-0.4101603031,
-0.5468927026,
-0.5519492626,
0.4851339757,
0.116608046,
-0.1871238649,
0.749430716,
0.3982043862,
0.9562468529,
0.0545480214,
0.4672430158,
0.2973593473,
0.9545701146,
-0.7003481388,
0.3847990036,
-0.594163239,
0.3482290208,
-0.090324007,
-0.9611275196,
0.0419047847,
0.3576034904,
-0.0976058692,
0.1341859102,
0.5169862509,
1.0504417419,
0.0985664204,
-0.2732146978,
0.367878437,
0.1703077555,
0.7083191872,
-0.125353843,
0.7520750761,
-0.3660790324,
0.5207567215,
-0.0945026726,
0.0226247031,
-0.0515365154,
-0.7078019381,
-0.7965903878,
-0.7470639944,
-0.4289619327,
-0.5794707537,
0.0588575229,
0.835185945,
0.769141078,
-0.7254112959,
-0.3148031533,
-0.0139278211,
-0.2937887013,
0.1893084943,
-0.2759881914,
0.2097266614,
-1.0479029417,
-0.6611152887,
0.7159716487,
0.1122024953,
0.0633802563,
-0.5173960328,
-0.1609565169,
0.2079767138,
0.3879167736,
0.3432285786,
0.438749373,
-1.044200182,
-0.5379990935,
-0.0424532667,
-0.1188575029,
0.2337149829,
0.8815086484,
-0.9522767663,
0.7002994418,
0.166917339,
0.7020950913,
0.4543809295,
0.2066510767,
0.8106877208,
-0.9686434269,
0.0533666573,
-0.1745026857,
0.2914867997,
0.3802307844,
-0.409896791,
0.6070965528,
-0.0705172047,
-0.5486397147,
-0.5361748934,
0.3231713176,
-0.4063482881,
-0.1759566963,
1.0613981485,
-0.3188247085,
-0.1232241541,
0.0850957856,
-0.3448612392,
0.1429964751,
-0.5955433846,
0.8384554386,
0.7359258533,
-0.0107434364,
-0.2892553806,
-0.5429549813,
0.4774238467,
0.5179776549,
-0.8700730205,
0.2234930992,
0.7222211957,
0.3606934845,
0.419957757,
0.9024094343,
-0.1287222952,
-0.0405942388,
-0.1793137491,
-0.0321204998,
0.0442316271,
-0.6506483555,
-0.3049538136,
0.1454063058,
0.3998731673,
-0.1035453677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17840v2
|
Follow My Instruction and Spill the Beans: Scalable Data Extraction from Retrieval-Augmented Generation Systems
| 2024-02-27T19:08:05 | 2024-06-20T21:32:35 |
Zhenting Qi, Hanlin Zhang, Eric Xing, Sham Kakade, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) improves pre-trained models by
incorporating external knowledge at test time to enable customized adaptation.
We study the risk of datastore leakage in Retrieval-In-Context RAG Language
Models (LMs). We show that an adversary can exploit LMs' instruction-following
capabilities to easily extract text data verbatim from the datastore of RAG
systems built with instruction-tuned LMs via prompt injection. The
vulnerability exists for a wide range of modern LMs that span Llama2,
Mistral/Mixtral, Vicuna, SOLAR, WizardLM, Qwen1.5, and Platypus2, and the
exploitability exacerbates as the model size scales up. Extending our study to
production RAG models GPTs, we design an attack that can cause datastore
leakage with a 100% success rate on 25 randomly selected customized GPTs with
at most 2 queries, and we extract text data verbatim at a rate of 41% from a
book of 77,000 words and 3% from a corpus of 1,569,000 words by prompting the
GPTs with only 100 queries generated by themselves.
|
[
-0.2150180489,
-0.8032983541,
0.5525836349,
-0.0659045205,
0.0660397932,
0.1342970729,
0.2038983703,
-0.4681027234,
-0.0846242607,
1.1227633953,
-0.4153802395,
-0.0354154781,
-0.7901588678,
-0.2361602485,
-0.6777675748,
1.3167549372,
0.0730557814,
-0.2149208486,
-0.1895241588,
0.2158927619,
-0.869494915,
-0.5163454413,
-0.4962739944,
0.3051714599,
0.2800204754,
0.3677933514,
0.7370297909,
0.6021757722,
0.5563536286,
0.295942992,
0.085239619,
0.1277868003,
-0.6582009196,
0.5752376318,
-0.409281373,
-0.5750235915,
-0.334405452,
-0.044321917,
0.3830506206,
0.2189696878,
-0.1434231699,
0.401017189,
0.0911413953,
0.7781915069,
-0.8609707355,
-0.1240372956,
-1.0242954493,
-0.1082296073,
-0.4007146358,
-0.3972076774,
-0.9730446339,
-0.1960912645,
0.0567286946,
-0.4748431146,
0.3038726449,
0.1235516891,
0.8281056881,
0.252030462,
-0.0572795458,
-0.5678258538,
-0.7408640385,
0.7312054038,
-0.2404019535,
0.2441825569,
0.4990757108,
0.5694897175,
-0.3511335552,
-0.9464846849,
-0.3211017549,
-0.1023120806,
-0.2228613049,
-0.0979239717,
-0.0764189363,
-0.2254180759,
0.5391128659,
0.4025877714,
-0.5989234447,
-0.2546272278,
-0.2824599445,
0.2693972886,
0.4651354253,
0.1783672422,
0.364466846,
-0.433862716,
-0.6615114212,
-0.2789932489,
-0.8113363385,
-0.4604976773,
0.3090254962,
0.4781520367,
0.1516013891,
0.4572505951,
0.3206318617,
0.7778854966,
0.0370469429,
0.1506610513,
-0.0800822303,
-0.2531403899,
-0.353518337,
-0.3574298918,
0.6574987173,
-0.17299667,
0.082197614,
-0.5583134294,
-0.5048720837,
-0.6082273722,
0.8271139264,
-0.8435506225,
-0.0708834976,
0.1874902397,
-0.1356660128,
-0.5755351186,
0.2255687267,
-1.2158213854,
-0.7098389268,
0.1611482352,
0.8475666046,
-0.4215043485,
-0.0817890391,
-0.0673263073,
-0.3321594298,
0.3337959945,
-0.0928508937,
-1.0805004835,
0.4429563582,
0.8399205804,
0.8576065302,
-0.2897967398,
0.0315969028,
-0.8870332241,
0.5146868229,
-0.3851261139,
0.561960876,
-0.5137369633,
-0.7664967775,
0.0188480858,
0.1992233992,
-0.1421319097,
-0.7356376052,
0.5032855868,
-1.018777132,
0.2078002095,
-0.4191716909,
-0.6830146313,
0.2864033282,
0.0127189923,
-0.7820140719,
0.7987734079,
0.2354475707,
-0.846362114,
0.2426320165,
-0.4566389024,
-0.2626837492,
0.1426389217,
-0.2215865552,
-0.1755494028,
0.0766316056,
0.2839342654,
0.4181680977,
-0.0915423557,
-0.1038499326,
-0.1156117991,
-0.419996798,
0.2665465176,
-0.6615869403,
0.8171721697,
0.1915060729,
-0.3084490299,
-0.4618207812,
-0.6010952592,
0.2199219763,
0.2307846546,
-0.129331246,
-0.5231738687,
-0.0905800015,
-0.1403123736,
-0.250104636,
0.2295487225,
-0.2086812258,
0.4354994595,
-0.2351817936,
-0.1683228463,
0.9663511515,
0.4975471795,
0.5755839348,
-0.3052206337,
0.7345948219,
-0.2385798097,
0.0798794106,
-0.3527149856,
-0.1740489304,
-0.4235813618,
-0.4084881842,
0.3476985097,
0.7004210949,
-1.0915571451,
0.0189266708,
-0.257724762,
-0.5143741369,
-0.2734973133,
0.0555044748,
0.4571305215,
0.75305897,
0.3373298943,
0.141115576,
-0.2221603394,
-0.6060174704,
-0.8114023209,
0.0643403456,
-0.3171592653,
0.5176582932,
0.3205238879,
-0.2146637738,
0.8380082846,
-0.7475086451,
-0.0884178802,
-0.0165796317,
-0.0596576035,
0.3663129508,
0.7178093791,
0.5440219045,
-0.7463588715,
-0.4602127373,
0.0440790951,
-0.7341814637,
-0.1437856704,
-0.2336562872,
-0.4257958531,
0.2007906437,
0.466368109,
-0.7324367166,
0.4191621244,
0.4008525908,
-0.3099155724,
0.7734664083,
-0.2777378559,
0.2005948275,
-1.2111631632,
-0.0482972972,
-0.3704806566,
-0.2638069987,
-0.6180826426,
0.4981614053,
0.2622283101,
-0.2605459988,
-0.2528078556,
0.4726746082,
-0.6515817642,
-0.3120799363,
-0.2823316455,
0.0283419359,
0.1861578375,
-0.0697385594,
-0.3056633174,
1.2114268541,
0.3903795183,
-0.8447915912,
0.0742794126,
0.2799747586,
-0.2643594146,
0.1836636364,
-0.5900366902,
0.5479839444,
-0.0142828133,
-0.0209382754,
-0.4928255677,
-0.3570850194,
0.1887878925,
-0.4678220153,
0.9925284386,
-0.4211919606,
-0.4153234959,
-0.0239570271,
-0.2531976998,
-0.1279131472,
0.5762247443,
-0.9328507185,
0.4449155331,
0.4532737732,
-0.2912777066,
-0.8117079735,
-0.8668789268,
0.1145084128,
-0.2657068968,
-0.4913608432,
0.1352678537,
0.0959235355,
-0.1822517514,
0.0232326798,
-0.0462971814,
-0.1350958794,
0.0279193558,
0.1763555557,
0.4195914567,
-0.0334927253,
0.2903404236,
0.1312066019,
-0.0223064944,
0.1089220494,
-0.1579846889,
0.411847055,
-0.0454534031,
-0.5240566134,
-0.005082326,
0.5167672038,
0.3256012797,
-0.0417403914,
0.9452682137,
0.3884224892,
-0.2933441997,
-0.307893604,
-0.3555842042,
-0.3419963419,
-0.613276124,
0.5270769,
-0.4610494673,
-0.2901261747,
0.2880530357,
-0.0131774172,
0.1518456489,
0.2550546825,
0.1250229776,
-0.0692406446,
0.8222393394,
0.7352214456,
-0.0505403914,
0.5876070857,
-0.3904178441,
-0.0866103321,
-0.7215015888,
-0.1045455039,
-0.5940644741,
-0.0278162863,
-0.8477292061,
-0.7434105873,
0.2084351182,
0.1211576685,
-0.2601085901,
0.4282913506,
-0.4444345534,
0.7988222241,
0.2390485555,
0.0725280792,
0.113427259,
0.2246331424,
0.248705104,
-0.1772293448,
-0.5538742542,
-0.6629367471,
1.2222853899,
0.2865917683,
1.0194556713,
0.3279818892,
0.9501380324,
0.5250635743,
0.2933618128,
-0.5716505051,
0.4321394861,
-0.2229077518,
-0.7685956359,
-0.1783657074,
-0.567576766,
-0.8847284317,
0.1576770991,
0.071280092,
-0.7927843332,
0.3854572475,
-0.0076364833,
0.0540986396,
0.3699833155,
-1.1026217937,
0.5998837948,
-0.1083814651,
-0.4820950031,
0.1810446829,
-0.4087622166,
0.4627723992,
-0.2796804011,
0.2537479103,
0.3426896632,
-0.3261429369,
0.5927122831,
-0.5134559274,
0.5758986473,
-0.4121494889,
0.0710069686,
0.3275976777,
0.3942065835,
0.9925045967,
0.1228090078,
-0.0463449284,
-0.2036085278,
-0.0150787896,
-0.5882086754,
-0.7882799506,
0.6637153625,
-0.4948573709,
-0.9078714252,
-0.4991274476,
-0.4926213622,
-0.4600873291,
0.1368494779,
0.459238261,
0.4253264666,
-0.0738518983,
0.1240036488,
1.0119184256,
-0.1859975606,
0.424025476,
0.4580440819,
-0.2696273327,
-0.2375309616,
1.2990769148,
0.1550078094,
0.7109885216,
0.1683500856,
0.2125352323,
-0.10170798,
-0.3985183835,
-0.7551491857,
0.0464216508,
-0.6444077492,
-0.4498955011,
-0.5821982622,
-0.2409783602,
-0.219285354,
-0.0955711529,
-0.395909816,
-0.3463743031,
-0.5185065269,
-0.1324148923,
0.570969224,
1.0507649183,
0.226129964,
0.3779636025,
-1.098098278,
0.2596667111,
0.3085492551,
0.088028945,
-0.1077210456,
-0.8803249598,
-0.0770287216,
-0.1102108881,
-0.3422254622,
-1.395652771,
0.5480703712,
0.0346530825,
0.3707755506,
0.3263204396,
0.0293900985,
0.721095562,
-0.6906047463,
0.7374907732,
-0.2567359507,
-0.77127105,
0.4926984012,
-0.4044368863,
0.1502287537,
0.4467924535,
0.636384964,
-0.1835158914,
-0.5298230648,
-0.6945230961,
-0.9479331374,
0.671197772,
-0.1104418933,
0.3371459246,
-0.1438374072,
0.5768823028,
0.3144139051,
0.0857781768,
-0.3866198361,
-0.1968631148,
0.0730662048,
-0.0225866511,
0.2825905681,
-0.4168405831,
-0.0594453812,
0.2206954658,
0.6365810037,
0.102824688,
0.1719080806,
0.0778200626,
-0.2530450821,
0.1184898466,
0.1919353455,
0.1500207037,
0.4393965304,
-0.0993360877,
0.1092492789,
0.151136294,
-0.9746459723,
0.0525573567,
0.1428376734,
-0.4321375489,
0.0761269554,
0.3625153303,
0.5832959414,
0.1054638177,
-0.6309348941,
0.3226776421,
-0.1714000553,
0.3154230714,
-0.2087958902,
0.0576777272,
-0.135189563,
0.2659722567,
0.5762405992,
0.0027420612,
0.3300939798,
-0.385835737,
0.5342486501,
0.4903190732,
-0.2409512252,
-0.0727427974,
0.4176312089,
-0.2065603882,
-0.0897881091,
0.2620832622,
-0.170367375,
-0.2006322145,
0.4582646489,
0.752766788,
0.9203225374,
-0.4265405536,
0.121809274,
0.2711471915,
0.4394542873,
0.0109180724,
0.0707966164,
0.184749797,
-0.2061326206,
-0.2479184866,
-0.6298539042,
-0.4209094644,
0.1333152503,
-0.8708423972,
0.2273305804,
-0.338347286,
-0.0296596959,
-0.2932023108,
-0.2413928807,
-0.5041393638,
-0.1525340825,
-0.2634523213,
0.7709831595,
-0.5649609566,
0.5204663277,
0.2788819671,
-0.3839761913,
-0.8227832317,
0.3059196174,
-0.2071024328,
-0.801928401,
0.5493125319,
-0.0818576962,
0.1338644475,
-0.1675902754,
-0.4897787273,
-1.0284734964,
1.0208078623,
0.5389376283,
-0.4364787638,
-0.13001059,
-0.0248502567,
0.1940165609,
-0.1528959274,
0.2300673723,
0.8156914115,
0.1501221061,
0.0225290973,
-0.431935519,
0.1052912846,
0.2293632478,
-0.0216680449,
0.3381197453,
-0.2369882911,
0.859605372,
-0.3470245302,
-0.4608578682,
0.0048023937,
0.5201537013,
0.218009606,
0.0429542176,
0.3654649556,
0.4246070385,
0.8922435045,
0.2292687744,
1.5061147213,
0.0883776024,
0.107024692,
1.3889838457,
-0.1018015817,
1.125549078,
0.5203784108,
-0.1198280081,
0.3507890403,
0.3171973228,
0.230322212,
0.603988111,
0.0010730819,
-0.4361955523,
0.4283639491,
0.1627674401,
-0.5260357261,
0.1888242066,
0.6091840863,
-0.5465968251,
0.017129872,
-0.0621567778,
0.2307147384,
-0.0853973478,
-0.1801395416,
0.8722659349,
0.0788363889,
-0.3817759454,
0.7150312066,
-0.4122406542,
0.1643360555,
-0.4738171101,
-0.0564084053,
-0.1841731071,
0.0684146658,
-0.2919110358,
-0.7445130348,
0.4613613784,
0.4018311799,
-0.2681376934,
-0.2031209767,
1.0373202562,
-0.2610073686,
-0.2892136574,
0.1565686613,
0.5292887092,
0.2284301072,
-0.1367109418,
-0.356895119,
0.1252676696,
-0.0948318467,
-0.818536818,
0.7102664113,
0.5712090135,
-0.0434533991,
0.6234497428,
0.605840683,
0.2288709134,
0.45727548,
-0.1132323369,
1.072861433,
-0.5961624384,
-0.0999854654,
-0.8058416843,
0.2441265583,
-0.2539461255,
0.2540314198,
0.9003160596,
0.4163552523,
0.5641152859,
-0.2808720171,
0.7682502866,
-0.074726738,
0.6613737345,
-0.525459826,
0.9744206667,
-0.339484483,
0.5443219543,
-0.1715276837,
-0.7624587417,
0.400932461,
-0.0035552238,
-0.3059450984,
0.1387417316,
0.6539573073,
0.7454417944,
0.0568857528,
-0.0242124125,
0.2399761975,
0.2876084745,
0.5459276438,
0.1334050596,
0.4862797856,
-0.4963243306,
0.7161146402,
-0.0585732646,
-0.4322352409,
0.054930076,
-0.8168827295,
-0.5106901526,
-0.3112849593,
0.022025086,
-0.3470302224,
0.261416465,
0.0825135335,
0.394592464,
-0.6445353627,
0.0055745761,
-0.2791585624,
0.2310619354,
0.0529775172,
-0.3362884521,
0.3475686312,
-0.8070207238,
-0.8442420363,
0.5782451034,
-0.0812624767,
0.1538922787,
-0.2214232087,
0.1571660191,
-0.054420609,
0.1520172805,
0.3752419353,
0.3824143708,
-0.1876942068,
-0.3774356246,
0.1212636009,
-0.1858844906,
-0.4409042299,
0.592228353,
-0.8005455732,
0.6195919514,
0.6178497076,
1.1746108532,
0.5640413165,
0.1215563491,
0.59104985,
-1.1524659395,
0.2887294888,
0.4782184958,
0.1041930243,
0.1705397815,
-0.7046338916,
0.4614499807,
0.1660758257,
-0.8467825651,
-1.1829568148,
0.3294982612,
-0.5626535416,
-0.2366545796,
1.1724579334,
-0.3035239279,
-0.4975902736,
0.0839287788,
-0.0247850157,
-0.0565439127,
-0.2125204653,
0.5564622283,
0.4533509612,
0.1164384857,
0.0431765988,
-1.340284586,
0.6525390148,
0.2413292676,
-0.9220073819,
0.2798464894,
0.2827109396,
0.2309390157,
0.1800888479,
0.3671709299,
-0.4399981797,
0.2064394951,
0.3539082706,
-0.1148105264,
0.0647860393,
-0.2936376929,
-0.2682998776,
0.1811521649,
0.0705326498,
-0.4921734631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17834v1
|
Stable LM 2 1.6B Technical Report
| 2024-02-27T19:00:07 | 2024-02-27T19:00:07 |
Marco Bellagente, Jonathan Tow, Dakota Mahan, Duy Phung, Maksym Zhuravinskyi, Reshinth Adithyan, James Baicoianu, Ben Brooks, Nathan Cooper, Ashish Datta, Meng Lee, Emad Mostaque, Michael Pieler, Nikhil Pinnaparju, Paulo Rocha, Harry Saini, Hannah Teufel, Niccolo Zanichelli, Carlos Riquelme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We introduce StableLM 2 1.6B, the first in a new generation of our language
model series. In this technical report, we present in detail the data and
training procedure leading to the base and instruction-tuned versions of
StableLM 2 1.6B. The weights for both models are available via Hugging Face for
anyone to download and use. The report contains thorough evaluations of these
models, including zero- and few-shot benchmarks, multilingual benchmarks, and
the MT benchmark focusing on multi-turn dialogues. At the time of publishing
this report, StableLM 2 1.6B was the state-of-the-art open model under 2B
parameters by a significant margin. Given its appealing small size, we also
provide throughput measurements on a number of edge devices. In addition, we
open source several quantized checkpoints and provide their performance metrics
compared to the original model.
|
[
-0.1904620081,
-0.9801200032,
0.1144537553,
0.1706020385,
-0.2573243678,
-0.0811740533,
-0.0702042133,
-0.7833393216,
-0.0259631053,
0.68486166,
-0.462882638,
-0.4041630626,
-0.4529463351,
-0.3692413867,
-0.2724064291,
0.8493743539,
0.0761768892,
0.3881855905,
-0.1666692048,
-0.562949121,
-0.4767037332,
-0.604475081,
-0.8324624896,
-0.4181991518,
0.7168086171,
0.3381687999,
0.9767853022,
0.5333408117,
0.5538941622,
0.1608916074,
-0.2875106633,
-0.3009067178,
-0.6696964502,
0.246303618,
0.0482978262,
-0.1878520697,
-0.8550900221,
-0.0366313308,
0.8803315163,
0.6035189629,
-0.2985535562,
0.2741580606,
-0.2355066091,
0.8533365726,
-0.2894554436,
0.0207607057,
-0.8482072353,
-0.1461703032,
-0.3980462849,
0.4142605066,
-0.8512918949,
-0.1885328293,
-0.0654748082,
-0.3142277002,
-0.2147926837,
-0.3710074127,
0.9112195969,
0.2510969043,
-0.3588964045,
-0.089195855,
-0.4166841805,
0.7381799817,
-0.7341353297,
0.6551792622,
0.4498588443,
0.5325644016,
0.027740879,
-0.9969638586,
-0.0646031648,
-0.3563355207,
0.1550613642,
-0.1098322645,
-0.2226698548,
0.0313490033,
0.1328837276,
0.1154417023,
-0.5384261608,
0.4854813814,
-0.6272710562,
-0.2631567121,
0.4939498007,
0.2492843717,
-0.004004729,
0.333517462,
-0.3195468783,
0.0648274943,
-0.8093297482,
0.1084884554,
0.079072997,
0.4720452428,
-0.3319390714,
0.3934242725,
-0.2907627821,
0.7072823644,
-0.2788897157,
-0.1445182115,
0.1748847365,
-0.4677604735,
-0.0725788474,
0.0745332837,
0.5588411689,
0.5904223323,
-0.0370696187,
-0.1314367354,
-0.4064047337,
-0.0534859523,
0.0755147785,
-1.0698318481,
-0.3142326474,
0.2738130987,
-0.6187821031,
-0.2276172787,
-0.2177737653,
-0.3588676155,
-0.3214412928,
-0.120047316,
0.4625415802,
-0.2678881586,
-0.6629700065,
-0.0335416459,
0.1513393223,
0.2586674988,
0.4235216379,
-0.8876521587,
0.5016173124,
0.6315007806,
0.8729079366,
-0.1631580591,
-0.05982586,
-0.7571949959,
-0.1341749281,
-0.2741878331,
0.5412968397,
-0.1693070978,
-0.2714835703,
0.2477034777,
-0.1241732091,
0.1698697507,
-0.5421380997,
0.4765915573,
-0.6381804943,
0.1698583812,
-0.198926881,
-0.3829436302,
-0.0361359641,
0.4075772762,
-0.7603567243,
1.2249867916,
0.4767653644,
-0.6250047088,
0.1181479245,
-0.4664716125,
-0.3227598071,
0.1326298118,
0.0419778787,
-0.558093667,
-0.0486661345,
-0.3469666243,
-0.0815546587,
-0.1961464882,
0.0106254583,
-0.452830404,
-0.1390606612,
0.1116374806,
-0.1080645844,
0.8044932485,
0.3521071076,
-0.0641183481,
0.2318184674,
-0.6436686516,
0.476187706,
0.0722482353,
-0.4377751648,
0.2008627951,
0.2860590219,
0.1782449484,
0.3644988835,
0.455224663,
-0.3750545979,
0.1298760027,
-0.1964349002,
0.4141786695,
0.3736056089,
-0.2592714131,
0.322760731,
-0.1746938527,
0.2796627879,
0.1328206658,
0.3048009574,
-0.409848243,
-0.4669553638,
-0.7840676904,
-0.1929940581,
0.4747874141,
0.6108670235,
-0.2925155163,
0.1008282155,
-0.1693418175,
-0.5009719133,
-0.6454246044,
0.2576871514,
0.5751509666,
0.3804302812,
0.2808403373,
-0.1092056409,
-0.5681364536,
-1.0277943611,
-0.0378375165,
-0.4076706469,
0.2095569968,
-0.2494848073,
0.0695938915,
-0.1530946195,
0.908628583,
-0.0283205863,
0.0848683938,
-0.4181217253,
0.128323555,
0.0268768854,
0.5171576738,
0.7052407861,
-0.3865635693,
-0.4951294065,
0.0165968463,
-0.7520247698,
-0.1070686057,
0.2434170544,
-0.1462520361,
0.7384589314,
0.5716482401,
-0.5658268929,
0.131379649,
0.7132908106,
-0.4286949635,
0.2644428611,
0.1662857085,
-0.3053229749,
-0.931140244,
-0.0913024619,
-0.1644878685,
-0.5903435349,
-0.7216687799,
0.1693080515,
0.3063432574,
-0.0218552221,
-0.8010474443,
0.6742079854,
-0.5855103135,
-0.1375626028,
-0.3042191565,
0.2420683056,
-0.1661536992,
0.1750124395,
-0.2262861133,
0.5549940467,
0.6306546926,
-0.4524116814,
-0.0013467361,
0.068560712,
-0.2611872554,
-0.0455296338,
-0.8758885264,
0.458212465,
-0.0158993993,
0.1348132193,
-0.8257561922,
0.0309216194,
0.2066240162,
-0.4907182157,
0.5138680339,
-0.3240399361,
-0.4637352526,
-0.2034135312,
-0.2804009616,
0.0297691282,
0.9345502257,
-0.1222649068,
0.2393079549,
0.8153059483,
-0.2854054868,
-0.21333386,
-0.6063126922,
-0.1172151715,
0.1653667986,
-0.8211274147,
-0.0158588383,
-0.0781219527,
-0.580055058,
-0.2584751844,
-0.0678688735,
-0.2306232601,
0.3163078427,
0.2700564563,
0.2105734348,
-0.4294998348,
-0.1062260121,
0.0474887155,
-0.261596173,
0.1327695251,
-0.1936834902,
0.4941553473,
-0.285690248,
0.0143038444,
-0.4046768248,
0.2326536924,
0.6946119666,
-0.3543223739,
1.0575414896,
0.5615785122,
-0.6113777161,
0.0683770776,
-0.3070050776,
-0.0849609971,
-0.4736555517,
0.5258256793,
-0.3183971643,
-0.7807994485,
0.6822273731,
0.1593146622,
0.4425648153,
0.4217548072,
0.7397542,
0.0073272265,
1.2061321735,
0.6264832616,
0.0667126253,
0.5307451487,
-0.0360729061,
-0.166355148,
-0.4251062572,
-0.4412561059,
-0.5897141099,
-0.2535128295,
-0.2215727419,
-0.3413511217,
0.2570354939,
0.8015486598,
-0.3271040022,
0.1423051655,
-0.1590498537,
0.3723201156,
0.4047420621,
0.1164164692,
0.0660269111,
0.0227515008,
-0.1512079984,
-0.1320416182,
-0.7395970821,
-0.7824583054,
0.9168767333,
0.8106306195,
0.6691830158,
0.280685991,
0.1949984282,
0.2424123585,
0.5392683148,
-0.6168087721,
0.6015931964,
-0.229598999,
-0.8062964678,
-0.2774038613,
-0.2467437834,
-0.6813710928,
0.1510471553,
0.0310557447,
-0.7442307472,
-0.5630908608,
0.317032665,
-0.0609130859,
0.2458522171,
-0.5598728657,
1.0225616693,
-0.3485768437,
-0.5421503186,
-0.323148191,
-1.0578258038,
0.4884604514,
0.1699305028,
-0.0654994622,
-0.4953671694,
0.084191218,
0.6632886529,
-0.4969832599,
0.5533815026,
-0.494336009,
-0.1017009318,
0.3500510752,
0.1797641069,
0.4797296226,
0.0916578025,
-0.6205664277,
0.4816990793,
0.0427036993,
-0.4524782002,
-0.2613314092,
0.5867002606,
-0.7447357774,
-0.2591433823,
-0.2400466353,
-0.489931345,
-0.0510227084,
0.3947792947,
0.1555847824,
0.7501142621,
-0.3245486915,
0.4060717523,
0.6843306422,
0.0414395928,
0.4741716385,
0.8328080177,
-0.7924678326,
-0.522591114,
0.504278481,
0.2230609208,
0.80609864,
0.2963806093,
-0.1638121903,
-0.4291422367,
-0.7866800427,
-0.7554881573,
0.0183443911,
-0.8123038411,
-0.2088540941,
-0.7520696521,
-0.3918083906,
-0.3999881148,
0.1507066637,
-0.7414210439,
-0.7056031823,
-0.1099032089,
-0.023089841,
0.3467016518,
0.808403194,
0.2027257383,
0.4316771328,
-0.8864164948,
0.2054027617,
-0.1731489003,
0.4417632222,
-0.3985944092,
-0.588969171,
-0.6597322226,
0.3326112628,
-0.4384115338,
-0.6958890557,
-0.0345422253,
0.2890247703,
0.7039064169,
0.4408655465,
0.075145036,
0.2593204975,
-0.4302440286,
0.9840448499,
0.2262758762,
-0.7975780368,
0.5980519056,
-0.4921807647,
0.4595003426,
0.8281454444,
0.0445089675,
-0.3535667062,
-0.3676211834,
-0.1205507591,
-0.6593232751,
0.76025635,
0.1230118945,
0.1587753296,
-0.044231683,
0.296328187,
0.3085899055,
0.099869065,
-0.6888099313,
-0.4723837078,
-0.2206611186,
-0.2291494906,
0.0327604301,
-0.4501137733,
-0.0493212454,
-0.3220728338,
0.6072062254,
0.0765489489,
0.1620539725,
-0.1239019334,
-0.2981499434,
-0.4108336568,
0.0734704062,
0.8692875504,
1.0243378878,
-0.4591708779,
0.1158266142,
0.1448572874,
-0.5175087452,
-0.0276711769,
0.0924428627,
-0.491812706,
0.3458544016,
0.0749536753,
1.0674302578,
0.3190097213,
-0.6413586736,
0.1085607633,
0.0488108471,
-0.2972394526,
-0.1550482512,
-0.0797989741,
0.1378795505,
0.1206295267,
0.1602611393,
-0.0891290754,
-0.2504761517,
-0.5936278105,
0.3236232996,
0.5554733872,
-0.636134088,
-0.4949270785,
0.8755851388,
0.3953119814,
-0.4523880482,
0.8494932652,
-0.4008447826,
-0.5164821148,
0.3018222153,
0.7746480703,
0.8861022592,
-0.1522358954,
0.2424076796,
0.4323682189,
0.5662436485,
-0.237512067,
0.5422090888,
0.3853885531,
-0.4847275615,
-0.0609375574,
-0.6387240887,
-0.5424557924,
-0.0216179397,
-0.801887393,
0.5425869823,
-0.5677750707,
-0.2674164176,
-0.3592642248,
0.081966795,
-0.1476483345,
-0.0673629418,
0.2787252367,
1.3328100443,
-0.4053115547,
1.2550698519,
0.8004801869,
-0.2263176292,
-0.6097702384,
-0.4711675942,
0.05005702,
-0.5687184334,
0.4697488844,
0.3446260095,
-0.1588283479,
0.0836104378,
-0.568292439,
-0.8002997041,
1.2379875183,
0.465405345,
-0.6392803788,
0.2309361696,
-0.0643026903,
0.3194262981,
-0.2798907161,
0.2042170018,
0.2788193524,
0.3818355501,
-0.0477471575,
-1.0878930092,
-0.0918859616,
-0.4557940662,
-0.0586672015,
0.6225806475,
-0.8283815384,
1.1747888327,
-0.1922049969,
-0.2154668719,
0.369562,
0.8005322218,
0.3785636425,
0.5683281422,
0.3796355426,
0.6999985576,
0.5683576465,
-0.1489340216,
0.8299648166,
-0.6137536764,
0.3888760805,
1.2580786943,
-0.667139709,
1.2103034258,
0.3548556268,
-0.0951854363,
0.5084834099,
0.692653358,
0.1540175676,
0.6346628666,
0.0568321645,
-0.1612475663,
-0.1710000783,
-0.0872263238,
-0.6228580475,
0.0006349134,
0.1688097417,
-0.1415626407,
-0.2234684229,
-0.1125484258,
0.1403232217,
-0.1772117466,
-0.5119577646,
0.7668108344,
0.0898306593,
-0.7186360359,
0.7943937182,
0.3008783758,
0.3669121563,
-0.9643677473,
0.1547218114,
-0.3354638517,
0.3958586156,
0.0481579937,
-0.747403264,
0.3219839036,
-0.0174140371,
-0.3097361922,
-0.364667207,
0.8569967747,
-0.4996775091,
-0.4720552564,
0.2748087943,
0.2728017569,
0.3481066525,
0.1230993196,
-0.6961764097,
0.5606721044,
-0.1441669911,
-0.2131957561,
0.3043468595,
0.0487960055,
-0.2120601386,
0.7052736282,
0.2401659042,
-0.2656441033,
0.4726094902,
0.3483254015,
0.7673989534,
-0.5885127187,
-0.2531196475,
-0.6090791821,
0.9711228609,
0.0241637956,
-0.390531987,
0.7187096477,
0.8162999749,
0.7104486823,
0.1788902283,
0.6176968813,
-0.1095260531,
0.5019810796,
-0.7560167313,
0.7601261735,
-0.4424887896,
0.1717796177,
0.234936446,
-0.696431756,
0.0026411496,
0.2965680361,
0.3179368973,
0.1050018966,
0.6349182725,
0.8012380004,
0.170788765,
-0.0127910301,
0.2891108394,
0.3933387697,
0.119662568,
0.4105033278,
0.742651403,
-0.7691081166,
0.5765633583,
-0.1395375878,
-0.1207484305,
-0.3375194371,
-0.7408956885,
-0.9584822655,
-0.2375295013,
-0.4257933199,
-0.7101700902,
0.1469012648,
0.7070984244,
0.8933330178,
-0.7499627471,
-0.2891255021,
-0.0554707386,
0.1143242642,
0.0200873427,
-0.1247995868,
-0.2589896917,
-0.3294257522,
-0.4992156029,
0.5486092567,
0.4462032318,
0.1168607101,
-0.4674644172,
-0.6908459067,
-0.1659197807,
-0.1040672809,
0.547719121,
0.2903755903,
-0.7673352361,
-0.0715435967,
0.1966576278,
-0.512406528,
0.0985886008,
0.6232601404,
-0.5278093219,
0.2530725002,
0.474930495,
0.3029285073,
0.5056331158,
-0.0304532945,
0.5032713413,
-0.5571639538,
0.3946725428,
0.0371805914,
0.2194816023,
0.2943258882,
0.1388107687,
0.5146372318,
-0.085545525,
-0.5746343136,
-1.2446005344,
0.4428136945,
-1.3389002085,
-0.033206284,
1.046251297,
-0.1418634951,
0.1968139559,
0.0217066053,
-0.0688329265,
0.2657133639,
-0.2295287251,
0.2035405189,
0.7099205852,
0.1397428811,
-0.5029549003,
-0.6941226125,
0.2133973092,
0.4429493845,
-0.7599022388,
-0.0185448639,
0.480918467,
0.2683457136,
-0.1089366376,
0.7775785327,
-0.3891503513,
0.3252317309,
0.2926881015,
0.0444021337,
-0.2078388035,
-0.3538053036,
-0.4048790038,
0.0645161942,
0.4216950238,
-0.0999838784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17826v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17826v2
|
Prediction-Powered Ranking of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T19:00:01 | 2024-05-23T16:50:21 |
Ivi Chatzi, Eleni Straitouri, Suhas Thejaswi, Manuel Gomez Rodriguez
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, stat.ML
|
Large language models are often ranked according to their level of alignment
with human preferences -- a model is better than other models if its outputs
are more frequently preferred by humans. One of the popular ways to elicit
human preferences utilizes pairwise comparisons between the outputs provided by
different models to the same inputs. However, since gathering pairwise
comparisons by humans is costly and time-consuming, it has become a common
practice to gather pairwise comparisons by a strong large language model -- a
model strongly aligned with human preferences. Surprisingly, practitioners
cannot currently measure the uncertainty that any mismatch between human and
model preferences may introduce in the constructed rankings. In this work, we
develop a statistical framework to bridge this gap. Given a (small) set of
pairwise comparisons by humans and a large set of pairwise comparisons by a
model, our framework provides a rank-set -- a set of possible ranking positions
-- for each of the models under comparison. Moreover, it guarantees that, with
a probability greater than or equal to a user-specified value, the rank-sets
cover the true ranking consistent with the distribution of human pairwise
preferences asymptotically. Using pairwise comparisons made by humans in the
LMSYS Chatbot Arena platform and pairwise comparisons made by three strong
large language models, we empirically demonstrate the effectivity of our
framework and show that the rank-sets constructed using only pairwise
comparisons by the strong large language models are often inconsistent with
(the distribution of) human pairwise preferences.
|
[
-0.2693311572,
-0.3592387438,
0.5965223908,
0.325902909,
0.0239124019,
0.0966361761,
-0.5964457989,
-0.5618857145,
0.2901127934,
0.3607625365,
-0.0117799528,
-0.4198082089,
-0.7418325543,
-0.104882516,
-0.2803565264,
0.7408117652,
0.4211161137,
0.0719767064,
-0.355678618,
-0.1879079491,
-0.3498456478,
-0.6368990541,
-0.4376699626,
-0.4447715878,
0.5860643983,
0.3828789294,
1.3865303993,
0.5200237036,
0.678180933,
0.2644309998,
-0.0328488126,
-0.0615194403,
-0.4641309381,
0.4346213043,
-0.1321339607,
-0.2664043605,
-0.6303628683,
0.052327022,
0.7868408561,
0.9121652246,
-0.0892946646,
0.1719173491,
0.123672314,
0.5103954673,
-0.6030686498,
0.172472164,
-0.8463472724,
-0.1994292587,
-0.4351155758,
-0.1043525785,
-0.527344048,
-0.3527807295,
0.1043233424,
-0.2512849867,
-0.0970192105,
0.4225474,
0.7949169278,
0.14618361,
-0.3185677826,
0.254109472,
-0.5665368438,
0.9454199076,
-0.8205234408,
0.5912367105,
0.7642867565,
0.3991144896,
-0.2732786834,
-0.1936443001,
-0.3741718829,
-0.3940963149,
-0.077484794,
-0.1309853494,
-0.0473759696,
0.1692142934,
0.1170323566,
0.1738394201,
-0.6936776638,
0.5483378172,
-0.0445174761,
-0.0251492728,
0.9444639087,
-0.0354631543,
0.1540805697,
-0.1897176355,
-0.0118282456,
-0.3843633831,
-0.7390071154,
0.0596097261,
0.6188772917,
0.7353037596,
0.1997184753,
0.6472716331,
-0.4392085969,
0.8952909112,
0.0248401519,
-0.0799264312,
0.2762721181,
-0.0469963886,
-0.0372096151,
0.1382049173,
1.0185921192,
0.7426723838,
0.2917992771,
-0.4202752411,
-0.375845015,
-0.0007243421,
-0.0348192416,
-0.7912644148,
-0.3370995522,
0.3192584515,
-0.4618892074,
-0.5442931652,
0.199578926,
-0.7631332278,
-0.7118088603,
-0.1628704965,
0.6303955317,
0.078608945,
-0.384583354,
0.084672153,
0.0749620646,
-0.2261314392,
0.078159757,
-1.0797157288,
0.3345769644,
0.8450331092,
0.7566699982,
-0.3229855001,
-0.3615943193,
-0.5048060417,
-0.152400583,
-0.4508627355,
0.7618561387,
-0.8474264145,
-0.2356873304,
-0.0748164281,
-0.4092888236,
0.146730274,
-0.6010364294,
0.5550299287,
-0.5509483814,
0.1889811754,
-0.2610337436,
-0.790758729,
0.3156104386,
0.0412614234,
-0.5844225883,
0.9548195004,
-0.2269513309,
-0.7515891194,
0.5782717466,
-0.2869539261,
-0.3350900114,
-0.0328139849,
-0.1219374016,
-0.540382266,
-0.1462119669,
0.0368269831,
0.73693645,
-0.4831767976,
0.5763063431,
-0.7579098344,
-0.3351419866,
0.4294056594,
-0.2464224398,
0.6826102138,
0.1513545364,
-0.3284071386,
0.3181734681,
-0.5042029023,
0.2564188838,
0.0468222089,
-0.1191495135,
-0.4791856706,
0.3340985775,
-0.0975497141,
0.2499456108,
0.3045674562,
-0.2561930418,
0.427739501,
-0.4015049636,
0.3083089888,
0.847253561,
-0.1738912612,
0.7134131193,
-0.2965830564,
0.3122735322,
-0.3255665898,
0.1756838858,
0.4677649736,
-0.7509838343,
-0.5680266023,
0.0262742005,
0.5498517752,
0.4309314191,
-0.1821729839,
0.6534999609,
-0.5639246106,
-0.6930555701,
-0.6131685972,
0.0959912762,
0.4361488223,
0.1170497462,
0.1834709048,
0.0332789868,
-0.382363379,
-1.0421169996,
-0.3347848952,
-0.4536032379,
-0.1297063082,
0.2155497521,
0.2213220894,
0.1119810268,
0.8599563837,
-0.6249165535,
0.0920623839,
-0.0238535404,
-0.036501471,
0.4833567739,
0.4244191647,
0.3892841935,
-0.7992862463,
-0.4341340363,
0.0070972056,
-0.4296520054,
-0.0792514607,
0.3862425983,
-0.2820732892,
0.190294221,
0.2606624067,
-0.414466083,
0.2761257589,
0.8160865903,
-0.3604222536,
0.4967040122,
-0.2550605834,
0.3976420164,
-1.2267463207,
0.1811246574,
-0.0049931551,
-0.190794751,
-0.3621415794,
-0.2341874689,
-0.0082048168,
-0.0005711855,
0.0741091743,
0.7727968693,
-0.0388837084,
-0.4032671154,
0.0237023309,
0.1067621261,
-0.1123097241,
0.2832775414,
0.3286904991,
0.5866003633,
0.5154037476,
-0.4571323693,
0.3660643995,
0.3533993363,
-0.460286051,
0.3577568531,
-0.7363818884,
0.0730039775,
0.2574500442,
0.1788437665,
-0.9810736775,
-0.3030366898,
-0.0734813213,
-0.5811988711,
0.18958354,
-0.208458066,
-0.6530092955,
-0.0934004933,
-0.2389066666,
0.5110288262,
0.4459652603,
-0.5385098457,
-0.036487557,
0.6147512794,
-0.3699220121,
-0.6993703842,
-0.2448747307,
0.1227465495,
-0.299710542,
-0.7746908665,
0.3894239068,
-0.2663633823,
-0.7083238959,
-0.1878093928,
0.0884379968,
0.1920182258,
0.1949148774,
0.4263429344,
0.3039912581,
0.0259045381,
0.3896584213,
-0.2188317329,
-0.2295416296,
-0.2347697765,
-0.3243569136,
0.6101474166,
-0.3414359689,
-0.4250668287,
0.0892306343,
0.1378512084,
0.709223628,
-0.2933199108,
0.7270743251,
0.1709048599,
-0.4195071757,
-0.0468717329,
-0.6194499731,
-0.3058854043,
-0.4186142683,
0.390963167,
-0.3349583745,
-0.6543294191,
0.5584224463,
0.5853645205,
0.1590970159,
0.371704042,
0.5065280199,
-0.0440151319,
1.6413276196,
0.2900787592,
-0.4406416118,
0.4575012922,
0.2375888377,
0.2814306319,
-0.326570183,
0.0184517298,
-0.7913781404,
-0.5470112562,
-0.9469492435,
-0.1296338439,
0.4429615736,
0.0687177479,
-0.359277606,
0.3310775161,
-0.3906182945,
0.5707625151,
0.7508646846,
-0.0545319654,
0.3124090731,
-0.0487995148,
-0.0833125636,
0.0084372004,
-0.7072538137,
-0.3587273955,
1.2264196873,
0.1794779748,
0.6762589812,
0.4611389935,
0.6899623871,
0.3375483155,
0.0500036553,
-0.70550102,
0.4573973119,
-0.1077108756,
-0.5942126513,
-0.7640158534,
-0.6576870084,
-1.1803482771,
0.277251333,
-0.6484165192,
-0.932076633,
-0.0966268703,
0.2807514966,
-0.4322407842,
0.3907253444,
-0.5634400845,
1.0140901804,
-0.3373629749,
-0.5470122099,
-0.2559272647,
-0.8123248219,
0.199133426,
0.0256743245,
0.213714838,
-0.1537268013,
0.3540702164,
0.8490689397,
-0.385170877,
0.4298281968,
0.083600238,
-0.0268512685,
-0.2890981734,
0.3152575195,
0.4246625304,
0.0893930942,
-0.4570881426,
0.1646406204,
0.0761593655,
-0.4568412006,
-0.5427672267,
0.9115418792,
-0.8648281097,
-0.56804353,
-0.3967768848,
-0.4758256972,
-0.4680416286,
0.2416362464,
0.3440157175,
0.5391337872,
-0.0063965591,
0.2432340235,
0.5469807982,
-0.1825941354,
0.1724208295,
0.1378348917,
-0.6697779894,
-0.2614249587,
1.0481965542,
0.2250554562,
0.4221375883,
0.5651912689,
0.4300268292,
-0.4852844477,
-0.4936615229,
-0.2400753647,
0.0851583928,
-0.4696961939,
-0.275329262,
-0.2504807413,
-0.1614767164,
-0.6187351346,
-0.1658291221,
-0.3429014385,
-0.5923647285,
0.2057115585,
-0.0242273603,
0.253587395,
0.799407661,
0.0566264279,
-0.050519634,
-0.5899745822,
0.0675090253,
0.4512889087,
0.7833377719,
0.0182401892,
-0.4534118176,
-0.1370899081,
0.0018250203,
-0.0137989158,
-0.6051137447,
0.3583917618,
0.0683022887,
0.689242959,
0.5285448432,
0.1656598747,
0.4614353776,
-0.2605368197,
0.5699199438,
0.1492140144,
-0.7157533169,
0.3893282712,
-0.5851373076,
0.0637415498,
0.6137595773,
0.0646323785,
-0.6767182946,
-0.4114091992,
-0.9002639055,
-0.7806582451,
0.6540632844,
0.329298377,
-0.2952622473,
0.0457044393,
-0.0409006998,
0.0939130038,
0.2916778624,
-0.5149658918,
-0.2162952125,
0.0680345371,
-0.2049679309,
-0.4739179015,
-0.0947041735,
0.0399498232,
-0.2832978368,
0.8695515394,
0.0259358007,
0.1063860878,
-0.4937148392,
0.0114014186,
-0.2608434558,
0.2658211291,
0.3979516625,
0.720151186,
-0.6715801954,
0.3732180595,
0.0440020077,
-0.1203508601,
-0.1019260213,
0.2183524072,
-0.0917043611,
-0.1563977301,
0.1552279443,
0.8078913093,
0.5756744146,
-0.7766377926,
0.6207172275,
-0.0550616644,
0.2022847086,
-0.3139862716,
-0.0646724254,
0.3181012869,
0.2085643411,
0.1288493425,
0.1949934214,
0.125199914,
-0.4308909178,
0.0595455393,
0.5761454701,
-0.2680616379,
-0.2578246593,
0.4972079396,
0.2790824175,
-0.5363197327,
0.5380802155,
-0.2453956604,
-0.7072809339,
0.4364467561,
0.2537698448,
0.4915092587,
-0.2796697021,
0.1290002465,
0.4346606135,
0.0708222538,
-0.584563911,
-0.0463610217,
0.0087190932,
-0.9248002172,
-0.1260114461,
-0.743095994,
-0.5620344281,
-0.0735753551,
-0.6931260824,
0.4747574627,
-0.1936149597,
-0.3228656054,
0.1948673576,
0.1951057166,
-0.5553373098,
-0.0394996069,
0.2955787182,
0.5416338444,
-0.8733922243,
0.7545213103,
0.5426992774,
-0.2676548064,
-0.6984162927,
0.0850770846,
-0.0783100575,
-0.7006798983,
0.4075987637,
0.0893029049,
-0.0962308049,
-0.129856497,
-0.421431154,
-1.1446284056,
0.9955981374,
0.419460535,
-0.5867940187,
0.1025641933,
-0.0497068949,
0.4144701064,
-0.1806804538,
0.3396147192,
0.4645931423,
0.5138242245,
-0.0539159179,
-1.3712887764,
-0.0617195554,
-0.2763392031,
-0.2581129074,
0.5452995896,
-0.6044709086,
0.6729623675,
-0.227113992,
0.0364424363,
0.0124288844,
0.5577812195,
0.5071170926,
0.2665798068,
0.801436305,
0.3102976978,
0.9989950657,
0.0046706307,
1.0065643787,
-0.4429245889,
0.4759775996,
1.1532020569,
-0.3965102434,
1.2673896551,
0.2145678848,
-0.4046208858,
0.1737824231,
0.7664164305,
0.1237028614,
0.2587915659,
0.1127976254,
0.0523532555,
-0.8545219302,
-0.0688018426,
-0.4129015803,
0.3973949254,
0.1534503251,
-0.3096711338,
0.1302788407,
-0.4733170569,
0.0173047651,
0.130360052,
-0.209566474,
0.6810024977,
0.0201902352,
-1.0101585388,
0.5940709114,
-0.0978591293,
0.7228322625,
-0.4737630785,
0.1045525447,
-0.0320878103,
0.0320855826,
-0.2432073057,
-1.0247597694,
-0.2836529613,
-0.1182384491,
-0.2912542522,
-0.2449632436,
0.6752017736,
-0.6862603426,
-0.5888900161,
0.320304215,
0.4191217422,
0.1706184745,
-0.2406552881,
-0.4034458995,
-0.0138598336,
-0.2150202394,
-0.2724265754,
0.6583324671,
-0.1402669847,
-0.3570960462,
0.6758638024,
0.5141658783,
0.1618786305,
-0.2301350832,
0.1984984279,
0.4825668931,
-0.318453908,
-0.6766783595,
-0.9385947585,
0.1185254306,
-0.3665948212,
-0.2485780567,
0.6142856479,
0.5596780181,
0.5712655783,
0.3673574328,
0.8650724888,
0.0990056023,
0.3918251693,
-0.3322014809,
0.9392431974,
-0.567784071,
0.2873027921,
-0.4479271472,
-1.1464909315,
-0.2988682389,
0.6184914112,
-0.5919110179,
-0.0069761681,
0.3054772913,
0.9625141621,
-0.1121010259,
-0.1179699004,
0.619594574,
0.2366000861,
0.1805927753,
0.3787941337,
0.6305008531,
-0.0152952066,
0.3477466702,
-0.264732182,
-0.3798729181,
-0.5099480748,
-0.9440799952,
-0.7913799882,
-0.7890725732,
0.0067947833,
-0.6627885103,
0.0224561933,
1.49769032,
0.8696905375,
-0.8993083835,
-0.4209033549,
0.4494691789,
0.3364730179,
-0.3667796254,
-0.1418007016,
0.4740273654,
0.108235471,
-0.8239537477,
0.3268240392,
0.0449469164,
-0.1664912254,
-0.3311844468,
-0.2798174024,
-0.0018157326,
-0.0149980951,
0.3695989549,
0.145524025,
-0.7424122095,
-0.524646163,
0.0366215259,
-0.2162193656,
-0.0269024521,
0.4944992959,
-0.5348860025,
0.4429662228,
0.7074720263,
0.3909044266,
0.1652892679,
-0.000189427,
0.7849547863,
-0.8883344531,
-0.0493962355,
0.0939544812,
0.4972855747,
0.4487131834,
-0.2092684507,
0.3422540724,
-0.0344711393,
-0.7790536284,
-0.9893916845,
0.2276083976,
-1.1286780834,
-0.2156298012,
1.4559569359,
0.1217140257,
0.1746321023,
0.1177085191,
-0.0260582734,
0.0523651503,
-0.7049570084,
1.0074154139,
0.785741806,
-0.094675079,
0.3200992048,
-0.4013038278,
0.5138195157,
0.3873212636,
-0.5843116641,
0.2951553166,
0.3475441933,
0.2838691771,
0.1439481825,
0.364728719,
0.201152727,
0.029517198,
-0.2001023889,
0.0272834748,
0.1308555901,
-0.2634220421,
-0.239633441,
0.2513491809,
0.5579860806,
0.1927673668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17764v1
|
The Era of 1-bit LLMs: All Large Language Models are in 1.58 Bits
| 2024-02-27T18:56:19 | 2024-02-27T18:56:19 |
Shuming Ma, Hongyu Wang, Lingxiao Ma, Lei Wang, Wenhui Wang, Shaohan Huang, Li Dong, Ruiping Wang, Jilong Xue, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent research, such as BitNet, is paving the way for a new era of 1-bit
Large Language Models (LLMs). In this work, we introduce a 1-bit LLM variant,
namely BitNet b1.58, in which every single parameter (or weight) of the LLM is
ternary {-1, 0, 1}. It matches the full-precision (i.e., FP16 or BF16)
Transformer LLM with the same model size and training tokens in terms of both
perplexity and end-task performance, while being significantly more
cost-effective in terms of latency, memory, throughput, and energy consumption.
More profoundly, the 1.58-bit LLM defines a new scaling law and recipe for
training new generations of LLMs that are both high-performance and
cost-effective. Furthermore, it enables a new computation paradigm and opens
the door for designing specific hardware optimized for 1-bit LLMs.
|
[
-0.3678826094,
-0.6067931056,
0.299123615,
0.5040371418,
-0.390481174,
-0.1622119546,
-0.2867824435,
-0.3795031011,
0.3877806962,
0.6921870708,
-0.4681684673,
-0.2111353576,
-0.6688394547,
-0.1362743527,
-0.4032221138,
0.4388727546,
0.2787843347,
0.0141400499,
0.1046705097,
-0.0186747834,
-0.0847093686,
-0.4460277557,
-0.8564321399,
-0.441488117,
0.7243406773,
0.4810830951,
0.7808610797,
0.7909301519,
0.7155302167,
0.2838293016,
-0.177910015,
-0.3621099889,
-0.3179156184,
-0.0259415749,
0.036553327,
-0.5761413574,
-0.8311812878,
-0.0262221694,
0.8818167448,
0.9391305447,
-0.0575469024,
0.3719721735,
-0.3493829966,
1.003674984,
-0.3077528775,
-0.1984163225,
-0.859388113,
0.1211685836,
-0.2613044083,
-0.2553044856,
-0.5593725443,
-0.2153774202,
-0.0612764843,
-0.4114075601,
0.1773548871,
0.1054401323,
0.7025544047,
0.3012740314,
-0.1660075486,
0.0817760527,
-0.6132772565,
0.6985033751,
-0.9300068617,
0.6257107854,
-0.043034818,
0.3351774216,
-0.0504240617,
-0.8043829203,
-0.3666992784,
0.11196661,
0.2462355345,
-0.5256560445,
-0.6230018735,
0.2561877668,
0.1326186806,
0.4550352097,
-0.4929164946,
0.3713024259,
-0.5286522508,
-0.0121249836,
0.3938384056,
0.2191707045,
-0.1299273819,
0.0869425014,
-0.4535191655,
0.2519082725,
-1.0349122286,
-0.182918787,
0.4427568913,
0.6808897853,
-0.2362769246,
0.1921585202,
-0.227841273,
0.5238131285,
0.2191139609,
-0.0794558302,
0.1102628782,
-0.1087345108,
-0.2878921926,
0.3092605472,
0.8386912942,
0.1293381006,
0.3921944797,
-0.2664173245,
-0.175801307,
-0.158696726,
0.4395766854,
-1.0820550919,
-0.1982380152,
0.0192925893,
-0.4341797531,
-0.5893734694,
-0.0750506148,
-0.3739815652,
-0.3469310701,
-0.1430137157,
0.6248809099,
-0.1799100041,
-0.4769225419,
0.539087832,
-0.0194459539,
0.4084930718,
0.3648736477,
-0.9929507971,
0.5314256549,
0.9286129475,
0.695292294,
-0.0000043064,
-0.0296940953,
-0.1507982165,
-0.290710777,
-0.5202395916,
0.2441142797,
-0.4991553426,
-0.1887122542,
-0.1381166577,
-0.0700591356,
0.4892812669,
-0.6362965703,
-0.0976165012,
-0.8009773493,
-0.100793846,
-0.1216607913,
-0.4387456477,
-0.0882601142,
0.3464880586,
-0.9100367427,
0.9244542122,
0.3029358983,
-0.7166757584,
0.2452828288,
-0.5453288555,
-0.6079040766,
0.2876089811,
-0.0834113285,
-0.363319844,
0.3408794105,
-0.3138039708,
0.3153354824,
-0.7481846809,
0.1480189711,
-0.278983593,
-0.7031543255,
0.2533931732,
-0.9555363655,
1.1144815683,
0.0054266136,
-0.4540686011,
-0.0954817012,
-0.7730278969,
0.0217187237,
0.131426245,
-0.6983819008,
0.2270644456,
-0.1513000131,
-0.1207247749,
0.2056998014,
0.6921408176,
-0.7254012227,
0.2108137608,
-0.4506077766,
0.4713428617,
0.9342089295,
-0.2961156666,
0.3324278891,
-0.3080324531,
0.5659741163,
0.0415066779,
0.3415522575,
-0.3132936358,
-0.2024613172,
-1.0139912367,
-0.172274068,
0.5601795912,
0.2680353522,
-0.4051358402,
0.5348450541,
-0.7372162342,
-0.5895198584,
-0.619137466,
0.0486219563,
0.2157350332,
0.0857674927,
0.278507024,
-0.1486309171,
-0.6688848138,
-1.0447627306,
0.1928874701,
-0.3067158759,
-0.0447333753,
0.2355269045,
0.1294464469,
-0.0057095126,
0.8577772379,
-0.1527537256,
0.2848207653,
-0.3814720809,
-0.1193054542,
0.4446864724,
0.6502443552,
0.2408302426,
-0.7525501847,
-0.3882898092,
-0.045802068,
-0.5102772117,
-0.095571436,
0.0021688377,
0.0751427636,
0.3730978966,
0.5865204334,
-0.3371927142,
0.3140651584,
0.6012127399,
-0.4019298553,
0.6013011932,
-0.1975402534,
-0.0740743205,
-0.9401341677,
0.0025202963,
-0.004956089,
-0.4045524895,
-0.6610184312,
-0.0081198364,
0.2260066867,
0.2016491294,
-0.8579137921,
0.5999172926,
-0.2193696797,
0.0810774565,
-0.2670172155,
-0.2499522567,
-0.1962659061,
0.4770963192,
-0.3430904746,
0.9979051948,
0.7486677766,
-0.5985674858,
0.379055053,
-0.1927327514,
0.0022425556,
0.3152289391,
-0.8353156447,
0.0982965231,
-0.2175266594,
0.0278071761,
-0.8045530915,
0.38921386,
-0.2260806113,
-0.5119231939,
0.5941688418,
-0.3146389425,
-0.6157965064,
-0.1203214824,
-0.460062176,
0.5116422772,
0.488168329,
-0.5576025844,
0.7112285495,
0.1983799934,
0.0017082999,
-0.4890780449,
-0.9424453378,
0.2894469798,
-0.1933139414,
-0.7245710492,
0.2336944044,
-0.0557984635,
-0.159135133,
-0.1782865375,
-0.2392928451,
0.0145695955,
0.3116504252,
0.1816084832,
0.4120621383,
-0.7187190056,
0.0672167987,
-0.1950539201,
-0.3814238012,
0.2754538655,
-0.6987751722,
0.7778683901,
-0.3127731979,
-0.0739417523,
0.0237136297,
0.2666109204,
0.56274575,
-0.0096504139,
0.6178104877,
0.308224678,
-0.4115189314,
-0.0616899282,
-0.7140302658,
-0.0182194859,
-0.6177978516,
0.4632615447,
-0.5256029367,
-1.1845365763,
0.2815381289,
-0.0053276517,
0.1399165541,
0.369856745,
0.4141385853,
0.0027288564,
0.303914994,
0.7126977444,
-0.242701754,
0.5990079641,
-0.2308600545,
0.2721732259,
-0.7619608641,
0.1160928532,
-0.4567944407,
-0.6761584878,
-1.0675262213,
-0.542263031,
0.5386151075,
-0.1659631282,
-0.7900176048,
0.5437322855,
-0.2918744981,
0.7443991303,
0.6523087025,
0.3911315203,
0.1689305305,
-0.0226278417,
0.1010091826,
0.1143029183,
-0.8065699339,
-0.6556711793,
1.3176909685,
0.5852291584,
0.9390102029,
0.2861050963,
0.5669552684,
0.2410077006,
0.0230038147,
-0.6602374315,
0.9254661798,
-0.7204306126,
-0.9832310081,
-0.5826749206,
-0.6104816198,
-1.052618742,
0.1115841642,
-0.0651406273,
-0.7391312718,
-0.1697683036,
0.1316299886,
-0.1589690298,
0.8215981722,
-0.4036039114,
0.9611566663,
-0.0594844297,
-0.3036893606,
-0.3542584479,
-0.8415439129,
-0.0181713868,
0.1036205143,
-0.2874076366,
-0.2625022233,
-0.2157743275,
0.5816954374,
-0.1221917048,
0.812030375,
-0.0394046046,
-0.0644152239,
0.190360561,
0.5420694351,
0.4897576869,
-0.2161640078,
-0.2293754518,
0.47544837,
-0.2455445975,
-0.5901173353,
-0.3548960984,
0.6303623915,
-0.5800511241,
-0.5960227847,
-0.0370145254,
-0.5058919191,
-0.0517473109,
0.0490301847,
0.1486773789,
0.7774054408,
-0.0568478219,
0.5513156056,
1.1613996029,
-0.0778307021,
0.6191152334,
0.6215581894,
-0.1000770479,
-0.2342302799,
0.9326323867,
0.1201273128,
0.5990464687,
0.9319807887,
0.2684147358,
-0.0414184518,
-0.6455155611,
-0.424877286,
0.1560402066,
-0.801525414,
-0.220117718,
-0.4439814687,
-0.3232986927,
-0.2457352132,
-0.2731229067,
-0.6697934866,
-0.7051010728,
-0.2970143557,
0.0120246252,
0.2650884688,
0.5431799889,
-0.0286220592,
0.5384632945,
-0.6182629466,
-0.1348855495,
0.5530025959,
0.8005229831,
-0.060052868,
-0.9039362073,
-0.3038684428,
-0.3604235649,
-0.1764775068,
-0.5757754445,
-0.2173254043,
-0.010056112,
0.2467101067,
0.3753428161,
-0.353446424,
0.1065364927,
-0.6680062413,
0.7722513676,
0.4008134604,
-0.896832943,
0.0524284728,
-0.2091796547,
0.4442132711,
0.5242490172,
0.3054884076,
-0.7122870684,
0.0185358692,
-0.7196793556,
-0.8016254306,
0.6118911505,
-0.135394901,
0.4176045656,
0.1487457454,
0.2365383208,
0.2991527021,
0.3811136484,
-0.7134293914,
-0.8516967297,
0.130286485,
-0.4129537046,
0.1274599582,
-0.3648779094,
0.3736518323,
-0.2114261985,
0.7989473343,
-0.1541478783,
0.4585142136,
-0.3265044093,
0.0377484336,
-0.2515634298,
0.4100919962,
0.3390189409,
0.7681404352,
-0.179481715,
0.6592529416,
0.3330575228,
-0.4092454016,
0.3676899672,
0.0511300974,
-0.2619574368,
0.0071207238,
0.2482233495,
0.9512844682,
0.4004442692,
-0.4568833411,
0.4900831878,
0.1641118973,
-0.2352104038,
-0.1397662163,
0.2091112584,
0.1484986097,
0.3174115717,
0.3214479685,
-0.3440932333,
0.0863326341,
-0.3038265705,
0.2298126668,
0.5501220822,
-0.3935227394,
-0.3995513618,
0.2957883477,
0.160322994,
-0.5549049973,
0.3925249279,
-0.5032664537,
-0.5810081363,
0.4960805476,
0.5902163982,
0.9763025045,
0.0582186803,
0.0617067479,
0.3270881474,
0.724968195,
0.2056581229,
0.3723100424,
0.1001997367,
-0.5696340203,
-0.4143697321,
-0.7413733006,
-0.4166442454,
-0.0696467161,
-0.1945361942,
0.3593897223,
-0.7155812979,
-0.0512405895,
0.132678166,
0.1639591306,
-0.638704896,
0.4236468375,
0.4439613223,
1.1355808973,
-0.4425563216,
0.7480498552,
0.5881307125,
0.0109032765,
-0.5768502355,
-0.5211536884,
-0.1397974342,
-0.8701491356,
0.4680904746,
-0.0029165025,
-0.0213954281,
0.0375281721,
-0.7218766809,
-0.8804864287,
0.9575328231,
0.5824702978,
-0.7995653749,
-0.1114514694,
0.5653776526,
0.1335441619,
-0.1526162028,
0.274245739,
0.686209321,
0.422231406,
0.1229425073,
-0.9967569709,
0.1683884859,
-0.1238910779,
0.1191743836,
0.885442853,
-0.7831436992,
1.0829882622,
0.0032766825,
-0.0267012417,
-0.2322497517,
0.6972341537,
0.0551403314,
-0.1112889573,
0.5878126621,
0.5257685781,
0.5042862892,
-0.2066203356,
0.6302047968,
-0.5211727023,
0.1907262951,
1.0879364014,
0.2071990222,
0.7409071326,
0.6987793446,
-0.6770645976,
0.2290756553,
0.2847303152,
0.2233362794,
-0.0125304498,
0.5342392921,
-0.4357711375,
-0.5786912441,
0.0912960842,
-0.0291287843,
0.1804426759,
0.0672719777,
-0.1596976668,
-0.1232700944,
-0.3816525042,
0.1859455705,
-0.2950252891,
-0.353289485,
0.7477756739,
-0.0016105206,
-0.0981268659,
0.4699693322,
0.1689351052,
1.0297480822,
-0.730915606,
0.17984429,
-0.3696783483,
-0.0525002629,
0.0258772727,
-0.8366151452,
0.0174346734,
0.0233041849,
-0.3582438231,
-0.0661672652,
0.6203268766,
-0.3447247446,
-0.8240368366,
-0.0148815131,
0.2372874469,
0.2092817277,
-0.2728125751,
-0.3926352561,
0.3760649264,
-0.116721943,
-0.2080101222,
0.1893164068,
0.7715262175,
0.3270648122,
0.7605922222,
0.1753343642,
0.3127299547,
0.4853146672,
-0.1004685238,
0.8564781547,
-0.9588992,
-0.4000778496,
-0.8948220611,
0.4044413865,
0.3181776404,
-0.4070463479,
0.2251181006,
0.6320841908,
0.6969755292,
0.3367299139,
0.6678513885,
-0.1233229265,
0.0814510286,
-0.3635273576,
0.3156949878,
-0.6479398608,
0.2502084672,
0.1415809393,
-0.6677451134,
-0.0633994341,
0.3653827608,
0.0893079042,
0.2388085574,
0.4888695478,
0.9262483716,
-0.0866364017,
0.1255812943,
0.4463535547,
0.0241443627,
0.4246444404,
0.6937475801,
0.2546612918,
-0.7583243847,
0.5626052022,
-0.3772666752,
-0.1373861581,
-0.253030777,
-1.063616991,
-0.6751335859,
-0.347489804,
-0.4150849879,
-0.2836148441,
-0.0371286944,
1.4516445398,
0.8666744232,
-0.5925666094,
-0.3716344833,
-0.0558610708,
0.0698677674,
0.0882606432,
-0.1551138014,
-0.1228891686,
-0.4177296162,
-0.3037830293,
0.2595435083,
0.5288416743,
0.3111224174,
-0.7559207678,
-0.2368783504,
-0.0579642989,
0.3913568258,
0.4734490216,
-0.0988799855,
-0.5605817437,
-0.1457753032,
0.109059833,
-0.2468165904,
0.6057644486,
0.8656541705,
-0.5767093897,
0.2949792445,
0.2299525738,
0.8335252404,
0.7019392252,
-0.4794384539,
0.230465427,
-0.878061533,
0.0737138316,
0.2532159388,
0.2619486451,
0.4593392909,
-0.0581782497,
0.4495433867,
0.0139276497,
-0.4430991411,
-0.6283154488,
0.1502648592,
-1.0070455074,
-0.1340810657,
1.158754468,
0.1240008697,
-0.3991617858,
0.3279586136,
0.0524331108,
0.0880946666,
-0.307307303,
0.5112572312,
0.5844913721,
0.459490329,
-0.1431194097,
-0.2548261583,
-0.0784669295,
0.4009906054,
-0.6327018142,
0.1996071339,
0.1416831464,
0.2579280734,
0.0340552889,
0.5751265287,
-0.0086271921,
0.2738736868,
0.2930443585,
0.2447648495,
-0.2171018422,
-0.6435859799,
-0.4871276915,
0.1631943882,
0.2369081825,
-0.2142259926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17762v1
|
Massive Activations in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T18:55:17 | 2024-02-27T18:55:17 |
Mingjie Sun, Xinlei Chen, J. Zico Kolter, Zhuang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We observe an empirical phenomenon in Large Language Models (LLMs) -- very
few activations exhibit significantly larger values than others (e.g., 100,000
times larger). We call them massive activations. First, we demonstrate the
widespread existence of massive activations across various LLMs and
characterize their locations. Second, we find their values largely stay
constant regardless of the input, and they function as indispensable bias terms
in LLMs. Third, these massive activations lead to the concentration of
attention probabilities to their corresponding tokens, and further, implicit
bias terms in the self-attention output. Last, we also study massive
activations in Vision Transformers.
|
[
-0.4534585178,
-0.8534534574,
0.84478724,
0.328335613,
0.1286669821,
-0.1834561378,
-0.4264082909,
-0.5371899009,
0.4168781936,
0.4209450781,
-0.3983363211,
-0.0844932795,
-0.8526118994,
-0.0616299883,
-0.740365088,
0.633448422,
0.1613936722,
0.1582295001,
-0.1034707502,
-0.4094562531,
-0.209331885,
-0.7372376323,
-0.5745515227,
-0.4139193594,
0.7761557698,
-0.0348328277,
0.4089294374,
0.2781980336,
0.4413170815,
0.3350850046,
-0.2138677537,
-0.2428407818,
-0.6134626865,
0.1483523101,
-0.0931723043,
-0.4906062782,
-0.2576006651,
-0.0982952043,
1.195294857,
1.1251462698,
0.1832335442,
0.1625640392,
0.0507269725,
0.6165063381,
-0.5680347681,
0.2256403416,
-0.6574146748,
-0.0068589901,
-0.1286489666,
-0.1180136874,
-0.5785522461,
-0.2608476877,
0.1613282859,
-0.0898541883,
0.0040787961,
-0.1312550157,
0.5596418381,
0.2308915704,
-0.4684610963,
-0.0690047964,
-0.7237045169,
0.9049009085,
-0.470089376,
0.3555985987,
0.0669936091,
-0.0367456526,
-0.2660139799,
-0.5078913569,
-0.5230058432,
-0.561098814,
-0.1221809238,
-0.1444894224,
-0.3434166908,
0.2797966003,
0.7896312475,
0.4337320924,
-0.1939848661,
0.4003727734,
-0.3022809327,
-0.0111574093,
0.4372825027,
0.3190643489,
0.3723440468,
0.1991347671,
-0.2276793718,
0.1899508685,
-0.978397429,
-0.2909134626,
0.3161523044,
0.017385995,
0.0018084749,
0.8641563654,
-0.1216144338,
0.7275778055,
0.3234303892,
0.0052510407,
0.2717112303,
-0.1922349334,
-0.3732522726,
-0.0074770674,
0.7060767412,
0.1101869941,
0.5030812621,
-0.189537555,
-0.2181316614,
-0.0183101837,
0.1210632101,
-0.7213744521,
0.2604474425,
0.3096286952,
-0.4040877521,
-0.2005729228,
-0.1481109262,
-0.3732888401,
-0.4503057301,
-0.2537060976,
0.5272282958,
0.0440230779,
-0.3726719022,
-0.0195775554,
-0.1492905915,
0.4066317379,
-0.0786277354,
-1.3105027676,
0.19583188,
0.4495514035,
0.6888125539,
-0.2301053405,
-0.4271692038,
-0.5239101052,
0.060184937,
-0.4630236328,
0.7174244523,
-0.5788253546,
-0.2187403589,
0.3942223191,
0.1459471136,
-0.05789271,
-0.7576075792,
0.1835439354,
-0.9037154317,
-0.1181886569,
-0.2949838638,
-0.5634330511,
-0.12510176,
0.0988600254,
-0.8101856709,
0.9896066189,
0.0564304031,
-0.4023110867,
0.5263162851,
-0.7665681839,
-0.3900010288,
0.2010495067,
-0.0730918422,
-0.1143766567,
0.6276198626,
-0.2720714211,
0.5477359295,
-0.2240471393,
0.237953186,
-0.4459325075,
-0.2619143724,
0.6530722976,
-0.5298518538,
0.692594707,
-0.1970985681,
-0.5312387347,
0.3463406265,
-0.4009354711,
-0.1995812804,
0.1575497985,
-0.3346748352,
-0.3027698696,
-0.0101859523,
-0.0275621228,
0.3234604001,
0.2740076184,
-0.3808600307,
0.4287620485,
-0.362246424,
0.4211044312,
0.6800894141,
0.2180719972,
0.6496143341,
0.2289411426,
0.465511471,
0.2347337604,
0.0039622211,
-0.2889606357,
-0.4304511547,
-0.9882054925,
-0.3946358562,
0.2078049034,
0.0724252462,
-0.2569647133,
0.5105280876,
-0.328425765,
-0.2024813741,
0.0129090929,
0.3054127693,
0.1074924618,
0.1247031689,
-0.0319126211,
-0.1224662662,
-0.235214889,
-1.2651264668,
-0.1679510176,
0.1952869147,
-0.2460364252,
0.1802838594,
0.5398811102,
-0.5490942001,
0.8525453806,
-0.4484091103,
-0.4243621528,
-0.4400719106,
0.2395488173,
0.3180138767,
0.1909087896,
0.4877204299,
-0.668307364,
-0.3301037848,
-0.1364021301,
-0.6786889434,
-0.3659736514,
-0.3946208358,
0.0462315865,
0.2960729599,
0.8516710401,
-0.6419643164,
0.2909620106,
0.6946864724,
-0.2843787074,
0.4763928354,
-0.2036362439,
-0.1592025012,
-0.7242447138,
0.107835874,
0.2944315076,
-0.1825323254,
-0.7806860805,
0.0031941033,
0.165290609,
0.2785101235,
-0.5782927275,
0.6580173969,
-0.6382163763,
-0.5128051639,
-0.4009130299,
0.1590397358,
-0.4025278687,
0.535977602,
0.0102244122,
0.5913618207,
0.7164701223,
-0.5906370282,
0.5306121707,
-0.0518632233,
-0.5737082958,
0.1620485634,
-0.7426906824,
-0.1815848798,
-0.2934148908,
0.3899002671,
-1.1853977442,
-0.4144470692,
-0.1082153842,
-0.0498696566,
0.3115861416,
-0.2264635414,
-0.8333334923,
-0.3963167071,
-0.2588454485,
0.5654700994,
0.442653656,
-0.5500239134,
0.5878893733,
0.5841372013,
-0.0882762671,
-0.4806609452,
-0.6656719446,
0.099470593,
-0.3009290397,
-0.4660738111,
-0.1762426943,
0.0149534754,
-0.4144848883,
-0.0113818329,
0.1334188133,
0.0925693884,
0.0130586866,
0.6052510738,
0.2651704848,
-0.155203864,
0.1926699579,
-0.0635967627,
-0.0744393989,
0.3520469666,
-0.4371973574,
0.952679038,
-0.0504224338,
-0.570407331,
-0.3787825108,
0.3259160221,
1.0391552448,
-0.2094952464,
0.8593351245,
0.4201597273,
-0.390166223,
-0.0203124806,
-0.783066988,
-0.3273897469,
-0.5028865337,
0.7060217261,
-0.2191904932,
-1.1593996286,
0.9199810028,
-0.0619394556,
0.0358832702,
0.6447055936,
1.1214141846,
0.2951858044,
1.4443762302,
0.3553022146,
-0.0891949087,
0.920001626,
-0.203824982,
0.1826694459,
-1.1832156181,
-0.2519010007,
-0.0895713568,
-0.4942694604,
-0.3559773862,
-0.371709913,
0.4641025364,
-0.1451556832,
-0.2395262867,
-0.1176917553,
-0.1496740729,
0.7234185338,
0.4830071926,
-0.1172527298,
-0.0741408914,
0.1528138071,
0.0547407009,
-0.0105223507,
-0.6174644828,
-0.1300395131,
1.2537099123,
0.5956897736,
0.7896293998,
0.0109073846,
0.2842743695,
0.2787226737,
0.7104460597,
-0.9923837185,
0.5868391991,
0.1451949626,
-0.9976722002,
-0.5200323462,
-0.1600889564,
-1.1280997992,
0.1481281221,
-0.3084723949,
-0.858966291,
0.1437582821,
-0.0491081923,
-0.252102375,
0.0913273841,
-0.6571727991,
0.802153945,
-0.2419665009,
-0.6322662234,
-0.4433631897,
-0.2087408006,
0.5004321933,
-0.2476262897,
0.0453201085,
-0.0309900828,
-0.101596795,
0.6653242111,
-0.0391710848,
0.9465087652,
-0.091002427,
-0.444896251,
0.2347985059,
-0.020367654,
0.6566282511,
-0.112032786,
0.3409254849,
0.2771282494,
-0.6569716334,
-0.5072372556,
-0.3626026213,
0.9558870196,
-0.6311163306,
-0.7080584764,
-0.2762840688,
-0.651619494,
-0.1611913741,
0.3448844254,
0.1971281469,
0.7065230012,
-0.0980282724,
0.3012257814,
0.9350277781,
-0.1966052204,
0.435156256,
0.3316862881,
-0.49559021,
-0.0739666224,
0.7676540017,
0.3631657064,
0.6886687875,
0.0674732849,
0.0054074726,
-0.3559811711,
-0.5422430634,
-0.2729869783,
0.4869325161,
-0.766382575,
0.255307138,
-0.9012746215,
-0.1911786348,
-0.0469373837,
-0.1726622283,
-0.2167813331,
-0.3556224704,
-0.1152145267,
-0.2187743634,
0.0287551507,
0.8856630325,
-0.0180024989,
0.3764102161,
-0.7248841524,
0.3789210916,
0.7248254418,
0.4874811769,
0.2175824493,
-0.6476502419,
-0.4938864708,
-0.1338169426,
0.0285982322,
-0.8147955537,
0.376999408,
-0.0192282461,
0.6934435964,
0.8952205181,
-0.5477672815,
0.3214134276,
-0.6841859221,
0.8803852201,
0.30512923,
-0.8213249445,
-0.0655254051,
-0.6650124192,
0.543022871,
0.1806751043,
0.3688209951,
-0.5677471161,
-0.5884968042,
-0.6840283871,
-0.9344077706,
0.6673621535,
-0.2361187935,
0.6545526385,
-0.0995133743,
0.367852062,
-0.1804573834,
0.1099554598,
-0.9134120941,
-0.4138264954,
0.4328483045,
-0.0197432898,
-0.0316773281,
-0.811566174,
-0.3154737055,
-0.1288326532,
0.3566732407,
-0.0707450137,
0.3417692184,
-0.1813893318,
-0.2591518164,
-0.3661751449,
0.12413311,
0.8149653673,
0.8322409391,
-0.0377756953,
0.2423180938,
0.5028512478,
-0.5314166546,
0.0343510695,
-0.4168206155,
0.0171822589,
-0.1585699767,
0.4047486186,
0.803124547,
0.4667975903,
-0.7750734687,
0.5791664124,
0.1143409759,
-0.2686827779,
-0.6507334709,
0.1393871307,
0.2826800942,
0.3014773428,
0.628117919,
-0.1736729443,
0.0455961116,
-0.6926143169,
0.068384029,
0.7940788865,
-0.5301032662,
-0.3706693947,
0.7398636341,
0.2711566091,
0.1186143756,
0.5212285519,
-0.1536934227,
-0.8753092289,
0.7108124495,
0.5847126245,
1.1422451735,
-0.0430763252,
-0.1252728552,
0.278254956,
0.4860615134,
-0.1991698146,
-0.0297591239,
0.1482675821,
-0.6652937531,
-0.9110090137,
-0.5514776707,
-0.159775883,
0.4108133316,
-0.3893860281,
0.1637049466,
-0.3915637136,
-0.0512946248,
0.3358496428,
-0.283991456,
-0.4788410068,
0.0960404947,
0.6869550347,
0.6816442609,
-1.196926713,
0.8819409013,
0.5892010331,
-0.1398682147,
-0.4365254343,
-0.0079893768,
-0.1622995585,
-0.8871818781,
1.2767802477,
0.2180739343,
0.1268539429,
0.0450366288,
-0.7536435723,
-1.1033335924,
0.7196480036,
0.242517218,
-0.567442894,
0.1284376979,
0.4154503942,
0.6671384573,
-0.4909266531,
0.2042950243,
0.5852987766,
0.6269649863,
0.0048981779,
-0.5786060095,
0.0318688974,
0.0686637983,
-0.0789660513,
0.4789691567,
-0.7647504807,
0.7143964171,
-0.0781994537,
-0.1210966483,
-0.2676792443,
0.4602575302,
0.0100936266,
-0.2074545324,
0.5405279398,
0.5879856348,
0.3377811313,
-0.1059336066,
1.2451494932,
-0.4665919542,
0.3593172133,
0.5764370561,
-0.1637039334,
0.5831838846,
0.4516703784,
-0.2226007581,
0.210185349,
0.2938787341,
-0.0098852944,
0.0864824653,
0.281802386,
-0.4232542813,
-0.6260425448,
-0.1432501972,
-0.2244228423,
0.0495117083,
0.6672987938,
-0.5629854202,
0.1177898124,
0.0235142857,
0.0795780569,
-0.5406933427,
-0.5291014314,
0.6687155366,
0.0604227707,
-0.5561349392,
0.5761594772,
-0.3634313941,
0.5022374392,
-0.7869884968,
0.2436971068,
-0.2212160677,
0.2000882775,
-0.3020822108,
-0.8763008714,
0.0457568243,
0.0303076785,
-0.4784366786,
-0.148462519,
0.6084893346,
-0.4026857913,
-0.3845685422,
0.4115288854,
0.100811623,
0.0377538651,
-0.3394795954,
-0.1984894276,
0.2405089885,
-0.0199785903,
-0.6950278878,
0.7274693847,
0.4100067019,
-0.0916701257,
0.6490443945,
0.815420866,
0.162535429,
0.5582156181,
0.1028054953,
0.9041979909,
-0.6914867163,
-0.2506907582,
-0.9746561646,
0.4178436697,
-0.1934598088,
-0.2248399556,
0.9187886715,
0.5952289104,
0.4604101181,
-0.1511893719,
0.6768270135,
0.1368754506,
-0.0539971218,
-0.2768516541,
0.5732603669,
-0.6065963507,
0.1289149523,
-0.1137308255,
-1.4840810299,
-0.4688918591,
0.1868791729,
-0.6634475589,
-0.1438892335,
0.6404851079,
0.5808048248,
0.1263789386,
-0.3291472793,
0.5514212847,
0.6246590018,
0.2177639455,
0.3525094986,
1.0087462664,
0.0037456811,
0.2571953833,
0.3209801614,
-0.3729143143,
-0.6096045971,
-0.7237372994,
-0.8604700565,
-0.4855073988,
-0.2699152827,
-0.3546999693,
-0.3830249906,
0.7877126336,
0.5758630633,
-0.8511375785,
-0.1073033139,
-0.0090890406,
0.1153270975,
-0.0102499938,
-0.1732747704,
0.2394464314,
-0.4765506983,
-1.0466587543,
0.1688209474,
0.5702210069,
0.0279270113,
-0.6677268147,
0.2628094852,
-0.0392839015,
0.4034623206,
0.9050483108,
0.3656148911,
-0.4555073082,
-0.3219339252,
-0.0904135406,
-0.3548300266,
-0.0175965913,
0.7310554981,
-0.7230687141,
0.2257786542,
0.5305175781,
0.4922276437,
0.566660881,
-0.2254584283,
0.3947361708,
-0.6259739399,
0.4869451821,
-0.0023870897,
0.5273321271,
0.0113153951,
-0.0019772609,
0.3423348963,
0.0763916746,
-0.6824675202,
-0.9777542949,
0.4530904591,
-1.1724267006,
-0.0445599742,
1.6871159077,
0.2087358683,
-0.2553444505,
0.0966496766,
-0.1840894073,
-0.1373834908,
-0.1126708984,
0.7537276149,
0.9170270562,
-0.1246287674,
0.0998579338,
-0.7598069906,
0.3035038412,
0.6729158759,
-0.6048011184,
0.3263766468,
0.7174050808,
0.2261295021,
0.48501423,
0.1390443891,
-0.1583566219,
0.1748554409,
0.0110743856,
-0.0502902269,
0.3150946796,
-0.1268047094,
-0.680292666,
0.4276954532,
0.2558150291,
0.1538043767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17759v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17759v2
|
Towards Optimal Learning of Language Models
| 2024-02-27T18:52:19 | 2024-03-03T15:07:50 |
Yuxian Gu, Li Dong, Yaru Hao, Qingxiu Dong, Minlie Huang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work studies the general principles of improving the learning of
language models (LMs), which aims at reducing the necessary training steps for
achieving superior performance. Specifically, we present a theory for the
optimal learning of LMs. We first propose an objective that optimizes LM
learning by maximizing the data compression ratio in an
"LM-training-as-lossless-compression" view. Then, we derive a theorem, named
Learning Law, to reveal the properties of the dynamics in the optimal learning
process under our objective. The theorem is then validated by experiments on a
linear classification and a real-world language modeling task. Finally, we
empirically verify that the optimal learning of LMs essentially stems from the
improvement of the coefficients in the scaling law of LMs, indicating great
promise and significance for designing practical learning acceleration methods.
Our code can be found at https://aka.ms/LearningLaw.
|
[
-0.1845266223,
-0.6644533277,
0.4667873085,
-0.1143077016,
-0.1343022734,
-0.1256507039,
-0.5527752638,
-0.1247201487,
-0.1016924158,
0.3459510505,
-0.4509568214,
-0.3275082707,
-0.4501823187,
-0.1714382768,
-0.475489527,
0.7609058022,
0.0996029004,
0.4141991138,
-0.2183334231,
0.038965825,
-0.1427816153,
-0.3779436946,
-0.7672075033,
-0.368059665,
0.4194932282,
0.3907190561,
0.4725914001,
1.1357066631,
0.2806703746,
0.2494949102,
-0.2385096252,
-0.0007435004,
-0.7613075972,
0.1846972555,
0.0505107529,
-0.774489522,
0.0073536271,
-0.0823781937,
0.6732319593,
0.7919890881,
-0.5392156839,
0.0628460944,
0.2628642917,
0.8407006264,
-0.5617668033,
0.2974123657,
-0.4600910246,
-0.034209922,
0.1765972227,
-0.4457004964,
-0.5240749717,
-0.543934226,
-0.0816509947,
-0.4367111623,
0.2526829541,
0.1032803506,
0.869487226,
0.0793957487,
-0.3247303367,
-0.3729287386,
-0.6249972582,
0.7750170231,
-0.3607375622,
0.6820305586,
0.333322674,
0.3814882636,
-0.0264992956,
-0.3665414155,
-0.1844055355,
-0.4019488394,
0.2126270533,
-0.2738030255,
-0.0962925553,
0.3319867551,
0.2493270934,
0.4305874705,
-0.6174801588,
0.3163378835,
-0.5502641201,
-0.182286188,
0.5686127543,
0.1716194153,
0.4358555973,
0.5102014542,
0.014877541,
-0.0659387857,
-0.8277246952,
0.1950452328,
0.4075299799,
0.5423744321,
-0.1457638144,
0.1118413806,
-0.1842465252,
0.6566090584,
-0.3003515005,
-0.4622127116,
0.2972384691,
-0.0390719585,
-0.1352684796,
-0.3206630051,
0.4018542767,
0.1851088107,
0.4644721746,
-0.3939375877,
-0.505677104,
-0.0219806451,
0.316693902,
-0.7559387088,
-0.0492465869,
-0.1125722006,
-0.4221041203,
-0.5368169546,
-0.2358419895,
-0.3891606331,
-0.2041131258,
-0.7142809033,
0.6979600787,
-0.2225707769,
-0.3354057372,
0.3243860602,
0.2055522054,
0.0036659071,
0.1600737423,
-1.1475000381,
0.5852113366,
0.5376313329,
0.6132967472,
0.1885276884,
-0.1207509264,
-0.5694560409,
-0.2827042937,
-0.5757749081,
0.4362512827,
-0.380022794,
-0.2425001115,
0.4290372431,
-0.2354692668,
0.0088867033,
-0.5794031024,
0.6918764114,
-0.6457547545,
0.0815356821,
-0.1727100313,
-0.9541378617,
-0.194161877,
-0.0781155452,
-0.4919361472,
0.8050906062,
-0.0027866764,
-0.1769911349,
0.3487870693,
-0.931407392,
-0.4089613855,
-0.0895838439,
0.0299278367,
-0.3606787622,
0.5019806623,
-0.2908747494,
0.5143399239,
-0.3502035439,
0.1448897123,
-0.1190096959,
-0.2039583325,
-0.0169335715,
-0.0341937281,
0.69283849,
0.613209486,
-0.0260001197,
-0.0414428376,
-0.7973243594,
0.0266063064,
0.5018009543,
-0.856559515,
-0.375107795,
0.2451294512,
-0.2122393101,
-0.1704093814,
-0.0716624036,
-0.3850379884,
0.2785351872,
-0.4909145534,
0.1556516588,
0.8530620933,
-0.1914707869,
0.7781815529,
-0.1903272718,
0.494722873,
-0.279668659,
0.2894036472,
-0.1665444672,
0.1174064353,
-0.9136930108,
-0.0677310079,
0.4792924225,
0.3153063655,
-0.353404969,
0.0468880646,
-0.1608225405,
-0.0711110681,
-0.3253148794,
0.5291008353,
0.3966480196,
0.2791139185,
0.3768793344,
-0.2867585421,
-0.6650491953,
-0.5416610241,
-0.4967024624,
-0.2261799723,
0.1560861021,
0.1021427438,
0.199532181,
-0.0469137803,
0.7195051312,
-0.3776424825,
0.1883937269,
-0.4803912938,
-0.1070015654,
0.2181930393,
0.3591559231,
0.6858919263,
-0.785795331,
-0.6190310717,
-0.16090931,
-0.5809398293,
-0.4951774478,
0.2386315465,
0.0573761426,
0.1555629522,
0.6836972833,
-0.2165163457,
0.187979877,
0.2444095612,
-0.0083221728,
0.5589029789,
-0.4074658751,
-0.3099146783,
-0.7654976249,
-0.4026702046,
0.2959076166,
-0.4554868042,
-1.1235809326,
0.3755721152,
0.1969966888,
0.1213459894,
-0.3660339117,
0.4729095101,
-0.6065118313,
0.1422524005,
-0.6644729376,
0.1248813272,
-0.4095700979,
0.6259883642,
-0.0665668771,
0.5235521793,
0.9334975481,
-1.0964763165,
0.1603721827,
-0.4645910561,
-0.4323652983,
0.1478928775,
-0.476619184,
-0.0443168283,
-0.4643351436,
-0.5297930241,
-0.6744812727,
0.0996251181,
0.0283234734,
-0.3038018942,
0.6196678281,
-0.1186643541,
-0.4253219962,
-0.1716994494,
0.0016738517,
0.0808708891,
0.9169024825,
-0.6212648153,
0.4814443886,
0.5773974657,
0.201127544,
-0.6396351457,
-0.284379214,
-0.4105125666,
-0.2910271883,
-0.0558843426,
0.068013683,
-0.2588194311,
-0.4340845942,
-0.1940914392,
-0.0477792472,
-0.1394802332,
0.257848531,
-0.0707291961,
0.0728175566,
-0.271181643,
0.4807917476,
-0.2146182954,
-0.0596572086,
0.165228352,
-0.5110017657,
0.6405333877,
-0.129061237,
-0.0390625782,
-0.2842659652,
-0.0967785418,
0.2056084126,
0.1264110357,
0.8112360835,
0.3052303791,
-0.2900335789,
-0.5061511993,
-0.4425596595,
-0.1305909902,
-0.4726581573,
0.6140317917,
-0.4785632789,
-0.7409151196,
0.1527924836,
-0.2669967413,
0.2268001437,
0.3966646791,
0.6076843143,
0.0060478621,
1.101047039,
1.2465401888,
-0.5091394186,
0.6857897043,
-0.3830933869,
0.0702122673,
-0.4356282949,
-0.0921923593,
-0.8067176938,
-0.0751555189,
-0.3282623589,
-0.3801499307,
0.1691244096,
0.5023901463,
-0.3717365563,
0.3937414885,
-0.1618553698,
0.8996042609,
0.3641704917,
0.155136168,
0.0494370759,
0.2192707509,
-0.6320278645,
0.0082095703,
-0.9560780525,
-0.4524397552,
1.0503915548,
0.621167779,
0.8866189718,
0.2591122985,
0.7636054158,
0.193408221,
0.2021028101,
-0.8725864887,
0.6018199921,
0.1678594649,
-0.45190835,
-0.332051307,
-0.7808148265,
-0.97279948,
0.2659114003,
-0.1338211745,
-0.7029954791,
-0.1015310511,
0.3187242746,
0.1001963317,
0.5380207896,
-0.5238271952,
0.6066971421,
-0.3851162195,
-0.3953760862,
-0.6186041832,
-0.5517336726,
-0.0459371358,
-0.1071712151,
0.5652281046,
-0.0357507281,
-0.2016004771,
0.5806271434,
-0.4499177337,
0.9044057131,
-0.4510350227,
-0.0697470456,
0.2909300923,
0.2613721788,
0.3407478034,
-0.4274323881,
0.1254997402,
-0.2663576305,
-0.3107367456,
-0.4777992368,
-0.6341153979,
0.1566115171,
-0.6988189816,
-0.3179591894,
-0.0492866971,
-0.4925567806,
-0.1114119142,
0.1412792355,
-0.0033950023,
0.5265990496,
-0.3065032065,
0.1695917547,
0.8569962382,
-0.1395998001,
0.4482242465,
0.858210206,
-0.6928326488,
-0.0204840768,
1.1152703762,
0.0704724714,
0.5122210979,
0.6931803823,
0.5326516032,
-0.3455978036,
-0.9722316265,
-0.0268629249,
0.3885751367,
-0.9839439988,
0.0645177141,
-0.2275375128,
-0.1308758259,
-0.2279230207,
0.2329373062,
-0.3570780754,
-0.3124126196,
-0.254685849,
-0.1381345838,
0.0841476843,
0.77536273,
-0.4684069753,
0.355599165,
-0.4906778932,
-0.0927421823,
0.2848615944,
0.2061383575,
-0.1035343781,
-0.8878288865,
-0.6007181406,
0.1357980072,
-0.4643293917,
-0.3986481726,
0.4121613801,
0.5740810037,
0.899502039,
0.5622742176,
-0.103339389,
0.4001383483,
-0.6617925167,
0.3580746651,
0.4250288904,
-0.7955653667,
0.5394641161,
-0.0669094175,
-0.092732355,
0.3015453815,
0.6970845461,
-0.5716891289,
-0.2518073916,
-0.5718916655,
-0.5516126752,
0.3831347227,
0.0178083163,
0.5024508834,
0.2312060148,
0.7603521347,
0.0808271617,
0.2252443731,
-0.919801116,
-0.4744504094,
0.3323379755,
-0.4305514097,
-0.267609179,
-0.2994976342,
0.1686276793,
-0.2786921263,
0.9027264714,
-0.2764948905,
0.244487837,
-0.1810438633,
-0.4402909577,
-0.2568960786,
0.0603652485,
0.8369064331,
0.8233537674,
0.018555101,
0.0795543417,
0.2616866827,
-0.36661309,
0.259244442,
-0.4773728549,
-0.2026716769,
-0.0886070505,
0.1831738651,
1.1575367451,
0.1585453749,
-0.6788367629,
0.4332947135,
-0.1682772189,
-0.2403541505,
-0.0449006036,
0.4148722589,
-0.0509097688,
0.3456473053,
0.4888693392,
-0.1050032973,
-0.0494318008,
-0.5229602456,
0.2768236995,
0.3207463026,
-0.2968747616,
-0.3561555445,
0.6050506234,
0.0335427336,
-0.6518222094,
0.1813225299,
-0.075619027,
-0.6376420856,
0.2842461467,
0.5439758897,
0.6388909817,
-0.4478022456,
0.1113443896,
0.4599419534,
0.291315794,
-0.3981404901,
0.1232701093,
-0.2111154795,
-0.834403038,
-0.2936358452,
-0.8415521383,
-0.3897978663,
-0.0466577001,
-0.587230742,
0.430424124,
-0.3653434515,
0.1045394167,
-0.1723775715,
-0.0184374377,
-0.4144756198,
0.3486425579,
0.1144168004,
0.9834927917,
-0.6090608835,
0.956974268,
0.2505144775,
-0.389964819,
-0.8621961474,
-0.2584759593,
0.1278974712,
-1.1834287643,
0.8645797968,
-0.0581814609,
-0.0928390473,
0.0674434751,
-0.8015122414,
-0.6082556844,
0.504075706,
0.73510921,
-0.6962485313,
-0.1112271696,
0.1387246996,
0.5170007348,
-0.6951242685,
0.0506728701,
0.3602828085,
-0.0945048854,
-0.0949766785,
-0.785574317,
-0.5191168785,
-0.2656041682,
-0.0580817424,
0.4476108253,
-0.3682707846,
0.662124455,
-0.4188038707,
-0.1753687114,
0.1315722317,
0.6342523694,
-0.1271013319,
0.0545031764,
0.55039078,
0.6322069764,
0.8008180857,
-0.1448339522,
1.1964834929,
-0.4144663513,
0.7960807681,
0.8400489092,
0.0926805437,
0.7607337236,
0.2839439213,
-0.3918963969,
0.4202561677,
0.7151442766,
0.2089233398,
0.6061335206,
0.6178769469,
-0.25035128,
-0.1555734575,
0.0547823645,
-0.1769261211,
0.1248123571,
0.2113357782,
-0.6254999042,
-0.0176605061,
0.117146045,
0.1310841143,
0.3008344471,
-0.5941184759,
0.7957259417,
0.003102429,
-0.2029743642,
1.011813879,
0.0698769987,
0.3971661925,
-0.5778894424,
0.2684583962,
-0.0744854212,
0.3301422298,
0.1300269514,
-0.2444926798,
0.0434866399,
-0.0617826022,
-0.1274467856,
-0.2235351801,
0.6007355452,
-0.7139178514,
-0.3159632981,
0.4722679257,
0.3611817658,
0.5330458879,
0.305143863,
-0.7783173323,
0.1116970628,
0.0331479274,
-0.2418885082,
0.4381824434,
0.053150069,
0.5181193948,
0.9499735832,
0.4615534246,
0.5040192604,
0.2339912355,
0.2431324869,
0.5726035237,
-0.4916999638,
-0.504645586,
-0.9851247072,
0.3108043373,
-0.0153778102,
0.0848356262,
0.5163913369,
0.5692893267,
1.0498691797,
0.0485748947,
0.678270936,
0.2381273806,
0.7115941048,
-0.7775804996,
0.4235622883,
-0.8263306618,
0.3043301404,
0.033795502,
-0.8855748773,
-0.4338157773,
0.8036051989,
-0.1251625568,
0.2636937797,
0.7108362913,
0.9870342612,
0.0448647328,
0.0676522106,
0.5567865968,
0.1693117619,
0.1192750633,
0.6307349205,
0.6784110665,
-0.5677752495,
0.4220219851,
-0.4485025108,
-0.0993446633,
-0.1566369534,
-0.7275946736,
-0.8746442199,
-0.6201541424,
-0.4506223202,
-0.3161658049,
0.157360971,
1.2635079622,
0.8280619383,
-0.5691157579,
-0.886195302,
-0.3473154306,
0.0967892259,
-0.1449934244,
-0.1199885681,
0.0782716349,
-0.9300760031,
-0.8296803236,
0.3789259195,
0.1587735265,
0.1950919032,
-0.1876823902,
-0.8033151627,
-0.0723820776,
0.1435055882,
0.5662167072,
0.5742840171,
-0.4043829441,
0.0091201598,
-0.2389896959,
-0.2001292557,
0.2507293224,
1.0827467442,
-0.379704684,
0.5346003771,
0.3871495724,
0.755043447,
0.3640152216,
-0.3998298645,
0.5012352467,
-0.6446139216,
0.1655366421,
-0.0652776137,
0.4796022177,
0.0676375851,
-0.0460532531,
0.7253011465,
0.4132658839,
-0.596680522,
-1.2486191988,
0.1528451741,
-0.3918211162,
-0.2861872613,
1.047467947,
-0.0277013518,
-0.4715966582,
0.0809882581,
-0.0167652778,
0.3163865805,
-0.1604471654,
0.5353838801,
0.4947122931,
-0.1623006612,
-0.4481334686,
-0.7960633039,
0.6817024946,
0.4301503897,
-0.5594416261,
0.0471370891,
0.1722742319,
0.4699258506,
0.0493865348,
0.3401407599,
0.067529276,
0.1667138636,
-0.2197805345,
0.0931792557,
0.0874742568,
-0.5097942948,
-0.7437634468,
0.2529528737,
0.4276587963,
-0.0753513053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17753v1
|
Evaluating Very Long-Term Conversational Memory of LLM Agents
| 2024-02-27T18:42:31 | 2024-02-27T18:42:31 |
Adyasha Maharana, Dong-Ho Lee, Sergey Tulyakov, Mohit Bansal, Francesco Barbieri, Yuwei Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Existing works on long-term open-domain dialogues focus on evaluating model
responses within contexts spanning no more than five chat sessions. Despite
advancements in long-context large language models (LLMs) and retrieval
augmented generation (RAG) techniques, their efficacy in very long-term
dialogues remains unexplored. To address this research gap, we introduce a
machine-human pipeline to generate high-quality, very long-term dialogues by
leveraging LLM-based agent architectures and grounding their dialogues on
personas and temporal event graphs. Moreover, we equip each agent with the
capability of sharing and reacting to images. The generated conversations are
verified and edited by human annotators for long-range consistency and
grounding to the event graphs. Using this pipeline, we collect LoCoMo, a
dataset of very long-term conversations, each encompassing 300 turns and 9K
tokens on avg., over up to 35 sessions. Based on LoCoMo, we present a
comprehensive evaluation benchmark to measure long-term memory in models,
encompassing question answering, event summarization, and multi-modal dialogue
generation tasks. Our experimental results indicate that LLMs exhibit
challenges in understanding lengthy conversations and comprehending long-range
temporal and causal dynamics within dialogues. Employing strategies like
long-context LLMs or RAG can offer improvements but these models still
substantially lag behind human performance.
|
[
-0.3132174313,
-0.8749809861,
0.685289681,
0.0889221355,
-0.2575213611,
0.2225993276,
-0.4559340179,
-0.6286724806,
0.1927991062,
0.7694326639,
-0.5492312908,
-0.4294071496,
-0.0291784871,
-0.0901876464,
-0.2074201107,
0.8590059876,
0.2234451324,
-0.1514542401,
-0.310282141,
-0.2588657141,
-0.5735507607,
-0.7754651904,
-0.8500602841,
-0.4401011467,
0.6775348783,
-0.074760139,
0.6323248744,
0.2980353832,
0.0762156695,
0.2736043334,
-0.2808472216,
0.5146478415,
-0.8582638502,
0.4722811282,
-0.1921650171,
-0.2838226259,
-0.7127130032,
-0.1112949178,
0.6377401948,
0.5035457015,
-0.0997759327,
-0.115058437,
-0.031704817,
0.4919255674,
-0.5644411445,
0.1469891816,
-0.7039390206,
0.0425643288,
0.0192804858,
-0.4227124751,
-0.7634937167,
0.1330940872,
0.1254533976,
-0.2780044377,
-0.1880464852,
-0.0435837284,
0.8252591491,
-0.016074812,
-0.43154037,
-0.4155586362,
-1.0302628279,
0.7914978266,
-0.573446393,
0.2605185807,
0.5068482161,
0.4469592571,
-0.4847280681,
-0.6129971743,
-0.2999213338,
-0.5964930058,
0.1807503998,
0.1231128499,
-0.1413148046,
0.0342488773,
0.2271815389,
-0.119823575,
-0.2742227912,
0.125359714,
-0.1275142878,
-0.2042971849,
0.5407164693,
0.6098272204,
-0.0226353314,
-0.0895206556,
-0.5201068521,
0.1277391016,
-0.5227177739,
-0.137923345,
0.2896915376,
0.1128761545,
0.078004472,
0.3990943134,
-0.0148675824,
0.4854772389,
-0.1119974703,
-0.2661444843,
-0.0069299163,
-0.2945564091,
-0.0860671923,
-0.3704842329,
0.961086452,
0.5917463303,
0.2970721126,
-0.5877462029,
-0.2460604459,
-0.1996429265,
0.2324908227,
-0.9006313682,
0.1531960368,
0.2336469442,
-0.2369465977,
-0.0709066615,
-0.3145234585,
-0.670648694,
-0.4284776151,
-0.045988556,
0.1633573174,
-0.2999655008,
0.0190843157,
0.0849308744,
-0.0450912006,
0.4105770886,
0.3077694178,
-0.462115109,
0.3243016005,
0.6067959666,
0.6267572045,
-0.3434661031,
-0.3751115501,
-0.7713679671,
0.345381856,
-0.3873603344,
0.7711387873,
-0.5253561735,
-0.516244173,
0.1401297003,
0.119275935,
0.0739067122,
-0.7225708961,
0.5708014369,
-0.6368216276,
0.143823728,
0.197372511,
-0.4716452956,
0.2116130143,
0.5078073144,
-0.3925790191,
0.855645597,
-0.0527465083,
-0.3694202602,
0.007631436,
-0.5669923425,
-0.2209034562,
0.0925702006,
-0.251154691,
-0.5076622963,
-0.0198426899,
0.066846855,
0.69915241,
-0.6148914695,
0.5915511847,
-0.1984987408,
-0.3469743431,
0.6507229209,
-0.7102242708,
0.2977228165,
0.0885088518,
-0.1881892085,
0.0170508586,
-0.6674110293,
-0.1410070956,
0.1426769495,
-0.2755714655,
-0.1774587035,
0.1492120028,
-0.1349856406,
0.2004071921,
0.1340749264,
-0.4178993702,
0.1114211753,
-0.2604519129,
0.7565318942,
0.8015857935,
0.0994504765,
0.2313821316,
-0.495950371,
0.3354797661,
0.2403326482,
0.0940739512,
-0.7898045182,
-0.2314734459,
-0.9765589833,
-0.1836271137,
-0.2531712949,
0.302336067,
-0.4983412027,
0.2648830116,
-0.5431801677,
-0.2562204599,
-0.0343111455,
0.1441185921,
0.4953552186,
0.35181427,
0.1949304491,
-0.5156971812,
-0.326474309,
-0.797011435,
0.0473257191,
-0.3036774993,
-0.0929993317,
0.9145346284,
0.4044454694,
-0.505068481,
1.0615580082,
-0.2953035533,
0.0535955392,
-0.069496356,
0.2056042105,
-0.0585248582,
0.0545904376,
0.2457033843,
-0.3788953424,
-0.1392039508,
-0.1791256219,
-0.6715767384,
0.2649657726,
-0.420738548,
-0.1804648042,
0.6627643108,
0.5091273189,
-1.0958127975,
0.2772920132,
0.3799249828,
-0.3613902926,
0.4744095206,
-0.1431312412,
0.0552266575,
-1.0478925705,
0.0982876122,
-0.2546150982,
-0.5361734629,
-0.4749819934,
-0.3010669649,
-0.1329387277,
-0.2948740423,
-0.696811974,
0.9076303244,
-0.670196116,
-0.2600473464,
-0.2415547967,
0.3977475464,
-0.0900090486,
0.8160883784,
0.0409092717,
0.7570312619,
0.1880530864,
-0.6457519531,
0.3999496102,
0.0691458732,
-0.3891078532,
0.4509050846,
-0.6138432622,
0.8730508089,
-0.1018045321,
0.7113010883,
-1.0553721189,
-0.1251806468,
0.1562552154,
-0.334518522,
0.2705964446,
-0.2863822281,
-0.405823499,
-0.2488777786,
-0.2306382507,
0.2096929848,
0.5535160303,
-0.3149402142,
0.6997115612,
0.3355100751,
-0.1322389245,
-0.5026968122,
-0.2332091182,
0.5764115453,
-0.4129739404,
-0.6957957149,
0.0712721944,
-0.152073577,
-0.2074953169,
-0.327268362,
0.0646876618,
0.1332428455,
-0.0201314781,
0.4919170737,
0.1660578847,
-0.074351117,
0.2004731447,
-0.3159429431,
-0.126880914,
0.2111127228,
-0.2158032954,
0.9211583138,
-0.0071641519,
-0.3619658947,
-0.2964420319,
0.2817755342,
0.8282176256,
-0.0356339999,
0.6590535045,
0.5290865302,
-0.0891940668,
-0.1452739835,
-0.8422771692,
-0.1008754522,
-0.4083617628,
0.4492221177,
-0.3532881439,
-0.892919302,
0.7156416774,
-0.2539980114,
0.1222522259,
0.0848163292,
0.7762797475,
-0.3053098023,
0.6841372848,
0.0749430805,
-0.3062806129,
0.4121198654,
-0.3596689105,
-0.0239590667,
-0.9377901554,
-0.2505965829,
-0.1843350977,
-0.1241749898,
-0.2909741402,
-0.9246702194,
0.1873400807,
-0.0162165947,
-0.351398468,
0.0594775565,
0.0168440584,
0.5716434121,
0.1386406124,
0.1086657122,
0.0971652269,
-0.1905687153,
0.2569016814,
0.0974853486,
-0.3671007454,
-0.7430661321,
1.1410003901,
0.5441885591,
0.7730390429,
-0.0962636769,
0.4642958939,
0.3041014075,
0.1024990529,
-0.799587965,
0.8772630692,
0.3397161067,
-0.4379006624,
-0.4446086884,
-0.2454228848,
-1.2576943636,
0.1076197699,
0.0075151208,
-0.7509316206,
-0.3224024773,
-0.0990153328,
-0.1938672215,
0.1484548748,
-0.3350498378,
0.5609642267,
-0.3255390823,
-0.7712655663,
-0.3144598007,
-0.8056282401,
0.1389250606,
0.1693027616,
-0.050959494,
-0.1966447979,
0.0219173338,
0.6378828883,
-0.1759269834,
0.9467248917,
-0.0392937735,
-0.1708217263,
0.6813981533,
-0.0259856191,
0.7780632377,
0.0484082811,
0.1176709086,
0.1722721756,
-0.3971259594,
-0.3551020622,
-0.5812686682,
0.6747198105,
-0.793556869,
-0.6294733286,
-0.1057165265,
-0.5090723634,
-0.3909837604,
-0.2132028043,
-0.2819404006,
0.4371607006,
-0.5450180769,
0.2880479991,
0.7046430111,
-0.4008684456,
0.5116731524,
0.5168796182,
-0.3240591586,
-0.3706271946,
0.7102729678,
-0.170733124,
0.4433524311,
0.3054918647,
0.0695998073,
-0.100972712,
-0.3299145699,
-0.4465018511,
0.2969323099,
-0.513360858,
-0.1907088012,
-0.8642662168,
-0.2717207968,
-0.1028194726,
0.1256670505,
-0.3729081452,
-0.2200274467,
-0.3524354994,
0.1127553657,
0.2265543789,
0.3905442357,
0.3289588392,
0.0290150139,
-0.8648130894,
0.4433820248,
0.4953393936,
-0.0370841995,
0.0783694535,
-0.4912098944,
-0.4077813625,
0.2445976585,
-0.5348985195,
-0.6538311839,
0.4522477984,
0.2074795812,
0.4091407061,
0.2929708362,
-0.2203998864,
0.9038396478,
-0.5627232194,
0.9918415546,
0.0663098097,
-0.5486665368,
0.3636655211,
-0.5895927548,
0.2249397188,
0.1232510731,
0.1438650042,
-0.5356318355,
-0.4733103514,
-0.4669309556,
-0.8731883764,
0.4887235463,
0.1415082216,
0.5246371031,
-0.3528241217,
0.3589904606,
-0.1482173055,
0.0712443441,
-0.3146979511,
0.0083931088,
0.1866569072,
0.3799122572,
-0.3090720773,
-0.5304849744,
-0.4062082767,
0.1607680619,
0.2707189322,
-0.204632625,
0.5082278252,
0.0105504636,
-0.0663546249,
-0.0460381433,
0.5662218928,
0.8020029068,
0.776587069,
-0.3353292644,
-0.1047768965,
0.3100768924,
-0.0724106207,
0.0174936596,
-0.1682116687,
0.3950172961,
0.0186025556,
0.2741647065,
0.980381012,
0.2483648509,
-1.0594625473,
0.4156215191,
-0.0778936222,
0.029288495,
-0.6838911772,
-0.0059730313,
0.5789760947,
0.4356220961,
0.4489571154,
-0.4138471782,
-0.1167430282,
-0.9845202565,
0.1241266802,
0.5446069837,
-0.3664744198,
-0.2563729882,
0.5238352418,
0.4310765266,
-0.4823942482,
0.8676507473,
-0.0932770297,
-0.2939018905,
0.4678778648,
0.6260644794,
0.9539077878,
0.0911125317,
0.0561434478,
0.1387428492,
-0.1940682083,
-0.0020569188,
-0.1655793935,
-0.3094893098,
-0.5334085822,
-0.5668947101,
-0.4667520225,
-0.4900595546,
0.3946045935,
-0.4298320711,
0.1734475046,
-0.161179319,
-0.4800599217,
-0.3435953557,
0.1411458552,
-0.5711699128,
-0.0770646483,
0.3065316975,
0.6196706891,
-0.57170403,
0.8559508324,
0.4638071954,
-0.0004711305,
-0.3227581382,
-0.248559624,
-0.2810370922,
-0.7841005325,
0.8151969314,
0.1927232891,
-0.4865931571,
-0.3395243883,
-0.6694720984,
-0.340720892,
1.4136174917,
0.3599919975,
-0.7100175023,
-0.359479636,
0.2168016583,
0.90426296,
-0.4666914642,
0.4703691006,
0.3507331312,
0.0397510231,
0.4327536821,
-1.0113757849,
-0.2922454178,
-0.078911826,
0.0066205896,
0.3015914261,
-0.9731144309,
0.5255950689,
-0.1409529001,
-0.3221135437,
0.2555882037,
0.7586787939,
0.4196812809,
0.5857890248,
0.3635091484,
0.5100153089,
0.5729622841,
0.2554912567,
0.8240652084,
-0.458599031,
0.1614065468,
1.4207085371,
-0.3450269401,
0.7736356854,
0.5163020492,
0.1007902622,
0.3545226455,
0.1636478007,
0.3383144736,
0.2028114647,
0.3707177639,
-0.3105671406,
-0.5199005604,
-0.279673785,
-0.1031567305,
0.3516166806,
0.4334479868,
-0.367277801,
0.0369737409,
0.0128577016,
0.1427107006,
-0.0546764508,
-0.0162850525,
0.8875924945,
0.1702717096,
-0.7952442169,
0.7549752593,
-0.2390022427,
0.5428248048,
-0.4138045311,
-0.1830400676,
-0.5174716711,
0.0857582688,
0.2417344451,
-0.7039755583,
-0.0337434895,
0.1606145054,
0.0688690692,
-0.2508017719,
0.6247941256,
-0.4588430524,
-0.0195191391,
0.4185477197,
0.5987218618,
0.5300711393,
0.1296363771,
-0.4662903845,
0.3095023334,
-0.2428666949,
-0.4788910449,
0.5439357758,
0.5276088119,
-0.2437344044,
1.1847983599,
0.4138217866,
-0.1274924129,
-0.0716207698,
0.1349526644,
0.9766559005,
-0.8405296803,
-0.0477617607,
-0.8699449301,
0.4860974848,
0.0058826092,
-0.240634203,
0.4815612733,
0.7831280231,
0.5261038542,
0.1192920208,
0.4495559037,
0.38844347,
0.3141512871,
-0.5593761206,
0.4934801459,
-0.265545845,
0.3174922764,
-0.1224977896,
-0.8677158952,
0.1499332041,
0.3080917895,
-0.1047582999,
-0.0450328849,
0.4107681811,
0.8667001724,
-0.0151328929,
-0.356729269,
0.6471837759,
0.3518033624,
0.5833628178,
0.9378672242,
1.4399614334,
-0.3447061181,
0.693485558,
0.1842588782,
0.2202934176,
-0.3164171576,
-0.7620721459,
-1.2261160612,
-0.6807413101,
-0.1163502038,
-0.4515813291,
0.5060489774,
0.9222941995,
0.6155499816,
-0.2023698986,
-0.5199310184,
0.2551160157,
-0.1373410225,
0.25776878,
-0.177289471,
0.2193703353,
-0.328124702,
-0.8667221069,
0.5174304843,
0.5282447934,
-0.0118700899,
-0.5154573917,
-0.4262727797,
0.0679795295,
0.2842568755,
0.8615322113,
0.3701960742,
-0.586569488,
-0.3975862265,
0.0936807469,
-0.3813524246,
0.2856062651,
0.7927035093,
-0.9544375539,
0.5208895206,
0.1641250551,
0.5416901708,
0.8069040179,
0.1161555126,
0.6029329896,
-0.3746187985,
0.2173788249,
0.4826261997,
0.0290619098,
0.2951672077,
0.0608119704,
0.4530114532,
-0.1336271465,
-0.9028363824,
-0.8867586851,
0.1387595683,
-1.1234571934,
-0.1062725931,
1.4085524082,
-0.3399006426,
-0.2422132343,
-0.1279641837,
-0.3731210828,
0.1865915358,
-0.5194091797,
0.7624732852,
0.7281564474,
-0.3056246042,
-0.132775262,
-0.5220628977,
0.2576396465,
0.1769064963,
-0.741594255,
0.292283684,
0.8150062561,
0.0507368632,
0.2037592977,
0.8935135007,
-0.0939725637,
0.0060390709,
-0.2051690966,
-0.1604544073,
0.0050441404,
-0.5036901236,
-0.0414639525,
0.0545646027,
0.0863268822,
0.0516184941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17733v1
|
Tower: An Open Multilingual Large Language Model for Translation-Related Tasks
| 2024-02-27T18:09:36 | 2024-02-27T18:09:36 |
Duarte M. Alves, José Pombal, Nuno M. Guerreiro, Pedro H. Martins, João Alves, Amin Farajian, Ben Peters, Ricardo Rei, Patrick Fernandes, Sweta Agrawal, Pierre Colombo, José G. C. de Souza, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While general-purpose large language models (LLMs) demonstrate proficiency on
multiple tasks within the domain of translation, approaches based on open LLMs
are competitive only when specializing on a single task. In this paper, we
propose a recipe for tailoring LLMs to multiple tasks present in translation
workflows. We perform continued pretraining on a multilingual mixture of
monolingual and parallel data, creating TowerBase, followed by finetuning on
instructions relevant for translation processes, creating TowerInstruct. Our
final model surpasses open alternatives on several tasks relevant to
translation workflows and is competitive with general-purpose closed LLMs. To
facilitate future research, we release the Tower models, our specialization
dataset, an evaluation framework for LLMs focusing on the translation
ecosystem, and a collection of model generations, including ours, on our
benchmark.
|
[
-0.110613957,
-0.5190883279,
0.2123649716,
0.3488442004,
-0.0602377243,
-0.0930566043,
-0.58318609,
-0.2102462351,
0.1887412369,
0.9661492109,
-0.4956613779,
-0.7041822672,
-0.5466837883,
0.1859663278,
-0.3905727565,
1.1476613283,
-0.3483217955,
0.0446533151,
-0.1070144847,
-0.2605832517,
-0.5443535447,
-0.7644295692,
-0.3395437002,
-0.3346760869,
0.5124700665,
0.6609423757,
0.8366723061,
0.63490659,
0.6247041821,
0.2797993124,
0.0899454951,
0.0100039821,
-0.7263873219,
0.1550067067,
-0.1429670155,
-0.3872003257,
-0.8050832748,
-0.0050859763,
0.6567490101,
0.8089740276,
-0.2504034936,
0.4066585898,
0.1762102544,
0.6882502437,
-0.4025224745,
0.1415354759,
-0.7790514827,
0.078598395,
-0.5246272683,
-0.0368154719,
-0.4090820551,
-0.0693651587,
-0.005893399,
-0.4934825003,
0.2966480851,
0.2257074416,
0.5609414577,
0.0533718802,
-0.4219290018,
-0.2156482339,
-0.5317859054,
0.9086364508,
-0.4063263834,
0.538416028,
0.0858703852,
0.4194888771,
0.0247263256,
-0.7524719834,
-0.1286088228,
-0.3922602534,
0.0842035413,
0.2440386266,
0.0001617219,
-0.0184436664,
-0.0333367847,
0.4512696564,
-0.6430326104,
0.2493235171,
-0.2603234053,
0.2407119125,
0.3781524301,
0.1758320183,
0.317168206,
0.0199519154,
-0.3297841549,
-0.026121391,
-0.934440732,
0.0491876714,
0.3718449175,
0.4636591971,
-0.1804743707,
0.605900526,
-0.2017174959,
0.6942493916,
-0.3366242945,
-0.2484772205,
0.3469357789,
-0.2099565417,
-0.3968843818,
-0.0700913891,
0.7193950415,
0.1156229451,
0.6490386128,
-0.4848952889,
-0.1508998722,
-0.2476754487,
0.4207948148,
-0.8218711615,
0.0658815131,
0.3269158304,
-0.4722185433,
-0.1658729017,
-0.1265048236,
-0.5138081908,
0.1217207983,
-0.3866984546,
0.0916702077,
-0.0240749437,
-0.3798648417,
0.3535690606,
0.1255310029,
-0.3530752063,
0.1687870771,
-0.8425050378,
0.3013584018,
0.56721735,
1.0332963467,
-0.5476236343,
-0.7394644022,
-0.7770556808,
0.4541738927,
-0.3810729086,
0.5121243596,
-0.485801369,
-0.3893535733,
0.4274523556,
0.0846484154,
-0.0903486386,
-0.6932330728,
0.8028504252,
-0.5731978416,
-0.1392199546,
0.0136713823,
-0.0659170225,
-0.0531943552,
0.4554622173,
-0.6749643683,
0.9941453934,
-0.0293438304,
-0.6212052107,
0.0146414246,
-0.6788472533,
-0.656040132,
0.0949950218,
-0.0054050703,
-0.2630389035,
0.292693615,
0.150732711,
0.6881239414,
-0.6231368184,
0.4428923428,
-0.3303450644,
-0.0212400351,
-0.1518127918,
0.0097935144,
0.6421574354,
0.3927137852,
0.1676682532,
0.4184696972,
-0.3359117806,
-0.0966830105,
-0.121131897,
-0.4154935777,
-0.0878188312,
0.1232036278,
0.1603124738,
0.3062331378,
0.3123689294,
-0.4279278219,
0.2968783081,
-0.1393081844,
0.5633866191,
0.3413556516,
-0.5537812114,
0.301042825,
-0.4678649008,
0.7106138468,
0.1792366058,
0.0169555433,
-0.0602558441,
-0.3967374265,
-0.651769042,
-0.4144645035,
0.008933492,
0.6950168014,
-0.5008824468,
0.1552202404,
-0.7425363064,
-0.5943490863,
-0.4483396113,
0.2567617893,
0.4413329959,
0.3121960759,
0.4903713763,
-0.1543983668,
-0.3424988687,
-0.9916337132,
-0.1664693952,
0.3552871943,
0.0907475501,
-0.1828892678,
0.6192176938,
-0.0101494305,
0.4276894629,
-0.3915955722,
-0.8023684621,
-0.441423595,
0.0657573193,
0.6168443561,
0.5040201545,
0.5824168324,
-0.648250699,
-0.7414401174,
0.4900110066,
-0.7916404605,
-0.1355148405,
0.1730816811,
-0.1919242442,
-0.3225064576,
0.8146477342,
-0.5622009635,
0.127303198,
0.8200643063,
0.334825635,
0.7103403211,
-0.2784744501,
0.2897702456,
-1.3792945147,
0.0685367361,
-0.0915389806,
-0.0555136614,
-0.8909464478,
0.3951677978,
0.0564277321,
-0.3017462492,
-0.5185120106,
0.5500043035,
-0.6845474839,
-0.1537758708,
-0.2461915314,
0.1402598917,
-0.1150637046,
0.363004446,
0.3973070681,
0.5831481814,
0.8492420316,
-0.4186342657,
0.2495241761,
0.3495437801,
-0.554264009,
0.5428111553,
-0.7358813286,
0.0480150841,
-0.1371009648,
0.1104341,
-0.7894678712,
-0.2421358526,
-0.2286823988,
-0.1452617794,
0.0210138559,
-0.4336107373,
-0.7006784081,
-0.4585547745,
-0.0296015032,
0.5240263343,
0.3163175285,
-0.4748149812,
0.6075776219,
0.1476210505,
-0.3257083297,
-0.7675603628,
-0.8809326887,
0.1432458311,
-0.2668299973,
-0.9188739061,
0.6935985684,
-0.1040442288,
-0.1418459266,
-0.1857469231,
0.2140728235,
-0.2801316082,
-0.0196835101,
0.2805973589,
-0.0118427854,
-0.4256363213,
0.1405429393,
-0.203009963,
0.0563702844,
-0.2518112659,
-0.5361643434,
0.3411388993,
-0.1034138948,
-0.4958114326,
-0.151338622,
0.6488290429,
0.8993119597,
-0.8346012831,
0.6867818236,
0.4567136168,
-0.4811226428,
-0.3064608872,
-0.6445652246,
0.2629861534,
-0.4202897549,
0.6364483237,
-0.9305190444,
-1.035389185,
0.5671451688,
-0.0463071354,
0.4258173704,
0.2607315779,
0.8796424866,
0.1698638946,
0.9000065923,
0.6550597548,
-0.1396006048,
0.2521080375,
-0.0156174134,
0.2850141525,
-0.7658038139,
-0.0906141177,
-0.8031785488,
-0.2579565048,
-0.2626571357,
-0.5263604522,
0.6803010702,
0.4587572515,
-0.2174949646,
0.3705835044,
-0.2815227807,
0.4243515432,
0.4148950279,
-0.2396394759,
0.597581625,
0.3015066087,
-0.2778186202,
-0.0362521783,
-0.8911383748,
-0.5441526771,
1.0913751125,
0.0991744399,
0.5016381741,
0.434502393,
0.5674878359,
-0.0776805356,
0.8300516009,
-0.5472456813,
0.2935767174,
-0.6434378624,
-0.7633721828,
-0.2041903734,
-0.3589518368,
-1.0797650814,
0.5000354052,
-0.0852919742,
-0.6522763968,
-0.457593441,
-0.0118911425,
-0.0659798905,
0.5131425858,
-0.5027204156,
1.291821599,
-0.44868806,
-0.2546705902,
-0.5022758245,
-0.2201546133,
0.498619765,
-0.392260313,
0.5412412286,
-0.2080440819,
0.1098296791,
0.3662945926,
-0.3661177754,
0.6127126813,
0.1541959941,
0.0763789341,
0.1894256771,
0.1399080157,
0.4521934986,
-0.0938630253,
-0.5316907763,
0.1610963643,
-0.0129003385,
-0.4631896615,
-0.1708185226,
0.8234363198,
-0.7987492681,
-0.6371459961,
-0.1032693908,
-0.7306476831,
-0.2304259688,
0.3066052794,
0.2479547411,
0.3297810555,
-0.5464676619,
0.2988033891,
0.3748557568,
-0.1244333461,
0.3718600571,
0.5008758903,
-0.4514963031,
-0.3189803958,
0.5408861041,
0.0198881142,
0.3535448313,
0.6874493361,
0.0570760444,
-0.1902476996,
-1.0967106819,
-0.4574312568,
0.0524795204,
-0.6059594154,
-0.0389721803,
-0.5827372074,
0.0358167142,
-0.3890232146,
-0.4240910411,
-0.426910162,
0.0108132465,
-0.0817918256,
0.0518868677,
0.0143026281,
0.8393290043,
0.109836705,
0.4491057992,
-1.0886766911,
0.4802630246,
0.1270919293,
0.3055170178,
0.0248341542,
-0.5842230916,
-0.5368236303,
-0.0535194241,
-0.1694073677,
-0.7470417023,
0.4152585864,
0.1856032312,
0.6785557866,
0.2028211802,
-0.2863809764,
0.5525955558,
-0.9318835139,
0.552093029,
0.5270318389,
-0.8121171594,
0.1961182952,
-0.5109747648,
0.5027644634,
0.5457329154,
0.6316413879,
-0.6915356517,
-0.184685275,
-0.0894017816,
-0.5277484059,
0.5077277422,
0.115544945,
0.183481425,
-0.0394738689,
0.2360525429,
0.1654514223,
0.3512862325,
-0.97142452,
0.0604761466,
-0.1078675538,
-0.126649186,
-0.3051180542,
0.0134002725,
-0.1257326454,
-0.1531766653,
0.5354861021,
-0.1893721819,
-0.2371364832,
-0.1807613671,
-0.3131109178,
-0.024696663,
0.2649546564,
0.4362368286,
0.6428806782,
0.0522012413,
0.0477480479,
0.1526274234,
-0.223165229,
0.0822385103,
-0.0187299326,
0.1071552932,
-0.1137872487,
0.5601345897,
0.6266123652,
0.0628017932,
-0.5299582481,
0.4264677465,
0.3504216075,
-0.3624376655,
-0.2563076019,
-0.2301279604,
0.341588527,
0.0827034488,
0.2290281355,
-0.0299527608,
-0.3505327702,
-0.5962387919,
0.1080503017,
0.4253059626,
-0.2506251335,
-0.4277591109,
0.8129422069,
0.3699663877,
-0.3025917709,
0.5245751739,
-0.063839376,
-0.5223161578,
0.4308488369,
0.282785356,
1.0324158669,
-0.3830180466,
0.0150809437,
0.4850497544,
0.547249198,
-0.4940641224,
0.2058759779,
0.3523697853,
-0.7197951078,
-0.6837912202,
-0.8065359592,
-0.0597961843,
0.1698437482,
-0.5897556543,
0.459528178,
-0.1175232455,
-0.0378509834,
-0.0796143934,
-0.4515173435,
-0.9114307761,
0.1101126969,
-0.003837063,
1.0845716,
-0.6920813322,
1.2417680025,
0.8386418819,
-0.3270480633,
-0.3348537385,
-0.145351395,
-0.1872042567,
-0.7784663439,
0.815479219,
0.2185503542,
-0.2188627869,
0.0447995886,
-0.027717106,
-0.8580399752,
0.7293717265,
0.3862446845,
-0.6270393729,
-0.1565433592,
0.587669909,
0.5574486852,
-0.7979823947,
0.1578693837,
0.2592844665,
0.4860680997,
-0.1894135028,
-1.2720445395,
-0.258759737,
-0.2403520942,
-0.0481169447,
0.1942125261,
-0.7943633795,
0.8975025415,
-0.1499969065,
0.0366694927,
0.2584705353,
0.6020576358,
0.0112949768,
-0.2720156908,
0.4124486744,
0.7322199345,
0.5144155025,
-0.0884090737,
1.0018624067,
-0.5504159331,
0.0879659727,
1.2525575161,
-0.446639657,
1.0988608599,
0.3202512264,
0.056418363,
0.425508976,
0.6206907034,
0.0825349316,
0.398858279,
0.6445800066,
-0.0016770163,
-0.3843296766,
-0.2550215721,
-0.4693286419,
0.3360550106,
0.2679365575,
-0.127989471,
-0.3452809453,
0.0991284028,
0.1554786265,
0.1505944282,
-0.4058373868,
0.233188048,
0.1306952834,
-1.2184163332,
0.7024849057,
0.3780806065,
0.5239662528,
-0.9280935526,
0.2690001428,
-0.1609138101,
0.1575347334,
-0.2217864394,
-0.633053422,
0.3530007899,
-0.005720709,
-0.2804457545,
-0.7263646722,
0.2509513795,
-0.6903111339,
-0.5492781997,
0.4339305162,
0.7786687613,
0.1929671615,
-0.4324758649,
-0.569840312,
0.1473466307,
-0.136417225,
-0.1704691499,
0.3086001277,
0.5363276005,
-0.1548414528,
0.6381607652,
0.5748394728,
0.084563151,
0.2124053985,
0.3701847792,
0.4563672841,
-0.4496499002,
-0.5208619833,
-0.5989615321,
0.4882017076,
0.1036484167,
-0.6604283452,
0.6141181588,
0.8165255189,
0.9565352798,
-0.3336679339,
0.8843508363,
0.1941312999,
0.2739844918,
-0.5661120415,
0.4621962309,
-0.7805612087,
0.0097064385,
-0.0302064978,
-1.1717762947,
-0.262695998,
0.038351953,
-0.2398578525,
-0.0649893731,
1.046654582,
0.6975321174,
-0.42510131,
-0.0426452793,
0.3657443523,
0.1318184584,
0.1265205145,
0.8741340637,
0.6641801,
0.0035067978,
0.8572657108,
0.1804757863,
-0.3672850728,
-0.1988724321,
-1.0450649261,
-1.3297035694,
-0.5413460732,
-0.2162855864,
0.052120842,
0.0173186641,
0.5849890113,
1.1005544662,
-0.8930370808,
-0.9476977587,
0.0116019621,
-0.1107813567,
-0.455476135,
-0.0678747073,
0.2684903443,
-0.4983943999,
-0.8202649951,
0.5994006991,
0.3740873635,
0.0141094569,
-0.2981321812,
-0.0593912117,
-0.0899323896,
-0.2128022015,
0.617988646,
-0.0106051983,
-0.7505312562,
-0.0624185018,
0.0768882781,
-0.1717572808,
0.3058131635,
1.0419156551,
-0.0891887322,
0.4071547091,
0.4254536927,
0.7446004748,
0.8533447981,
-0.3503475785,
0.6903395653,
-0.8404769301,
0.3685376346,
-0.0141413277,
0.4753717482,
0.2905538678,
0.0419468991,
0.6105404496,
0.0121212658,
-0.4118761122,
-0.5134155154,
0.5667493939,
-0.8541015983,
-0.3385258317,
1.0025336742,
-0.2031783015,
0.1916841865,
-0.0489094779,
0.241143629,
0.0280907396,
-0.0007313175,
0.423650533,
1.1649359465,
0.2076330334,
0.1516887546,
-1.1877276897,
0.4378923476,
0.708129406,
-0.9837763906,
0.1610029638,
0.298309356,
0.0593424104,
0.1062895656,
0.5783313513,
-0.1026777402,
0.0212944988,
-0.2782312632,
0.1277166903,
-0.1493953466,
-0.6801219583,
0.00940983,
0.6293647289,
0.2134228051,
0.0178495944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17717v1
|
AmbigNLG: Addressing Task Ambiguity in Instruction for NLG
| 2024-02-27T17:52:33 | 2024-02-27T17:52:33 |
Ayana Niwa, Hayate Iso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we introduce AmbigNLG, a new task designed to tackle the
challenge of task ambiguity in instructions for Natural Language Generation
(NLG) tasks. Despite the impressive capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) in understanding and executing a wide range of tasks through natural
language interaction, their performance is significantly hindered by the
ambiguity present in real-world instructions. To address this, AmbigNLG seeks
to identify and mitigate such ambiguities, aiming to refine instructions to
match user expectations better. We introduce a dataset, AmbigSNI-NLG,
consisting of 2,500 instances, and develop an ambiguity taxonomy for
categorizing and annotating instruction ambiguities. Our approach demonstrates
substantial improvements in text generation quality, highlighting the critical
role of clear and specific instructions in enhancing LLM performance in NLG
tasks.
|
[
-0.1367769688,
-1.3078354597,
0.1769394577,
0.4975961447,
-0.2976260185,
0.3073602021,
-0.2061270475,
-0.5567133427,
-0.0398160592,
0.5222914219,
-1.1510959864,
-0.8056685925,
-0.8803355098,
0.1496569365,
-0.163838774,
0.627076149,
-0.1381614655,
-0.1726980209,
-0.2562074363,
0.3160596788,
-0.8465253115,
-0.1573989391,
-0.8213458657,
-0.576282084,
0.3060112,
0.600455761,
1.0241525173,
0.8225476146,
0.4209009409,
0.2826577127,
0.0607675128,
0.6082100272,
-0.3369799256,
0.3743478954,
0.0093785506,
-0.3017041683,
-0.555535078,
-0.1494731307,
0.5768580437,
0.7572356462,
-0.1387642622,
0.3520931304,
-0.0406796038,
0.5949804187,
-0.6321083903,
0.1114854813,
-0.3602577448,
0.3188123405,
-0.3512180746,
-0.2282174975,
-0.4506325126,
-0.1345151663,
0.1328524202,
-0.8272615671,
0.4368101656,
0.3810966611,
0.8831593394,
0.5625568032,
-0.3409184813,
-0.6615941525,
-0.596370995,
0.7900099754,
-0.9809316397,
0.2138804942,
0.0093116937,
0.0077975579,
-0.5240362287,
-0.5763310194,
-0.5185241103,
0.1228287071,
-0.1130893379,
0.0713198557,
-0.456343323,
0.3282259703,
0.4831568599,
0.1309779435,
-0.8100314736,
0.3265612125,
-0.3032361269,
-0.198577255,
0.6530126333,
0.2135897726,
0.3449531794,
-0.5319353938,
-0.6367972493,
0.2401169688,
-0.7405844927,
-0.0285320263,
0.9036204219,
0.2337952405,
-0.0093293488,
0.7795526981,
-0.2260479033,
1.1095317602,
0.0912040472,
0.2250566334,
0.3145345449,
-0.2803443968,
-0.1956860423,
0.587195456,
0.7593721747,
0.4369548559,
-0.0105174053,
-0.169079259,
-0.0383690707,
-0.2849437594,
0.7149569392,
-0.3221496344,
-0.048276104,
-0.0139608895,
-0.2756477892,
-0.0373889431,
-0.0510505252,
-0.8778406382,
-0.3209649026,
-0.5224301815,
0.4469147921,
-0.2832885385,
0.0408512577,
0.2286659181,
0.0100885918,
0.2740986943,
0.4150049686,
-0.8995050192,
-0.0146383969,
0.8405766487,
0.4182634056,
-0.0835448951,
-0.0955280587,
-0.6844289899,
0.4863261878,
0.080601871,
0.4477383494,
-0.8139691353,
-0.4728595614,
-0.0866587684,
-0.122247465,
-0.1415283978,
-0.4361858368,
0.6604072452,
-0.253287226,
0.5197487473,
-0.1648254842,
-0.7027252913,
-0.3068252504,
0.273761332,
-0.5076848865,
1.1780563593,
0.1420266032,
-0.7670517564,
0.2182419449,
-0.8632996082,
-0.4911623299,
0.4696583152,
-0.2826381922,
-0.4386871457,
0.1935209185,
0.1566411853,
0.32661587,
-0.357421875,
0.2451994419,
0.1939678937,
-0.4987753928,
-0.0767627135,
-0.5668446422,
0.7132931352,
0.0271356124,
-0.4536834359,
0.2620209455,
-0.6066983342,
0.2436226755,
-0.083743766,
-0.5389558673,
-0.0786788911,
-0.034879826,
-0.2601045966,
-0.0469644517,
0.6131616831,
-0.4566813111,
0.3583280742,
-0.5429756641,
0.1485131979,
0.5153206587,
0.0868275538,
0.3869152367,
-0.1861385256,
0.8774572611,
-0.0870087519,
0.1251425892,
-0.0500305146,
-0.8724964857,
-0.9491332173,
0.3366090357,
0.4595572948,
0.8701406121,
-0.7881742716,
0.6562136412,
-0.1963871568,
-0.1350037009,
-0.9185308218,
0.3996779323,
0.6763419509,
0.4696155787,
0.4639861882,
-0.1653876454,
-0.6916114092,
-1.0381110907,
-0.3538402617,
-0.1296695918,
-0.1983249187,
0.2783634663,
0.1363113821,
-0.3802762032,
0.7850717306,
-0.465611279,
0.0116072148,
-0.0750988051,
0.9510059953,
-0.0838957354,
0.498157084,
0.0635984987,
-0.8001807332,
-0.288979888,
-0.1620713472,
-0.7453460693,
-0.5369200706,
-0.3496875465,
-0.3415962458,
0.2745580077,
0.7197916508,
-0.5608237982,
0.4559360445,
0.6137381792,
-0.1375771016,
0.5434666872,
-0.360344559,
0.1236860976,
-0.7986226082,
-0.2852635384,
-0.2125861496,
0.029481085,
-0.750783205,
-0.0637444779,
0.1072193459,
-0.0397741646,
-0.4622157216,
0.6290774345,
-0.6529826522,
0.2409439683,
-0.2883524299,
0.3758003116,
0.0971646607,
0.4229163229,
-0.2290866226,
0.5224225521,
0.4365197122,
-0.4884636104,
0.5999560356,
0.3441552222,
-0.0355506837,
0.3487682641,
-0.3695044219,
0.0535421669,
-0.1646596789,
-0.1446797848,
-0.898862958,
-0.393430829,
0.7694388628,
-0.3887976408,
0.6937782764,
-0.0265152138,
-0.5800793171,
-0.5454062819,
0.233296141,
0.4136636555,
0.2760049105,
-0.4296676219,
0.5368736982,
-0.0156827196,
-0.0284606535,
-0.9352760315,
-0.4766758978,
0.1770620942,
-0.2436511368,
-0.8080977798,
0.3414478004,
0.1138958037,
-0.1443427056,
0.1557285488,
-0.3153288662,
0.2522786856,
0.1390108168,
0.3559152186,
-0.0168609601,
-0.2273237258,
0.272696346,
0.1280079335,
-0.197517395,
0.3086233735,
-0.0314511582,
0.3202118874,
0.172988385,
-0.6241791248,
0.107486397,
0.4713973701,
-0.2041015625,
-0.3570532501,
0.4528784156,
1.0649255514,
-0.3669525385,
-0.5108854175,
-0.3255701959,
0.1882850081,
-0.5631045103,
0.2302937061,
-0.0052200211,
-0.7152196169,
0.2995390892,
-0.1633684188,
0.2236762941,
0.0760075152,
0.3008673489,
-0.1375904083,
0.9234349132,
0.4429603517,
0.5428631902,
0.2782969475,
0.2626667321,
0.672927916,
-0.8911514282,
-0.3567229211,
-0.0918185189,
-0.7287402153,
-0.519271791,
-0.731736958,
0.1830500066,
0.3788900673,
0.1934237033,
0.1669616252,
-0.767934978,
0.5377315879,
0.8064320683,
0.1342877299,
0.0310583264,
-0.2743007243,
0.1120538488,
0.0333938114,
-0.8116711974,
-0.8113369346,
0.9495894909,
0.0381760299,
0.7368680239,
0.3032821715,
0.8884965777,
0.4577294886,
0.0937312171,
-0.6540185809,
0.629180491,
-0.3089648187,
-0.6055095196,
-0.274962306,
-0.5605909228,
-1.3136140108,
0.1299780011,
-0.4399920106,
-0.7171539664,
-0.1812473536,
0.4028647244,
-0.4511694908,
0.1877597123,
-1.1144832373,
1.2835439444,
-0.4623565674,
-0.360988915,
0.2117351294,
-0.8033114672,
0.6225662231,
0.2565636635,
0.0848090202,
-0.3837220669,
-0.1118047088,
0.5968436599,
-0.0968515053,
0.8363721967,
-0.0893039107,
-0.2408772111,
0.4464018643,
-0.0227843113,
0.4473250508,
-0.1359241903,
-0.1795254201,
-0.0755174011,
-0.5564898849,
-0.4037760198,
-0.5482825637,
0.6513023973,
-0.3537063599,
-0.9975933433,
-0.1269545853,
-0.923114717,
-0.145587638,
0.1016590148,
0.443051368,
0.4752942324,
-0.054565873,
0.0187197551,
0.9147725105,
-0.5568883419,
0.3250735998,
0.2201274335,
0.056976933,
0.2144699544,
0.8518641591,
0.02708661,
0.2881032228,
0.5181131959,
0.0050283615,
-0.3405565619,
-0.6780789495,
-0.6387014389,
-0.0455828719,
-0.8261209726,
-0.3062655032,
-0.4639430046,
-0.2216743231,
-0.3155243993,
-0.2586312592,
0.0703863725,
-0.3084408641,
-0.64858073,
0.0175916534,
0.2619249523,
0.7961150408,
0.1735869646,
0.8525465131,
-0.7871487737,
0.3934983909,
0.1224543527,
0.2680430412,
-0.2364451885,
-0.3544766903,
-0.176025033,
0.2809695303,
-0.5313620567,
-1.1858432293,
0.2798224986,
0.1432208866,
0.7734304667,
0.1712138355,
0.1993371993,
0.707421422,
-0.7176477313,
0.7974510789,
0.2019708604,
-1.0399440527,
0.5610886216,
-0.3589137793,
0.7754110098,
0.0985033736,
0.2372020781,
-0.6097565889,
-0.7388130426,
-0.8135821819,
-1.4355553389,
0.8091878295,
0.2239322215,
-0.0297308024,
-0.1019041017,
0.5457085371,
0.0425006971,
0.4420841038,
-0.6105099916,
-0.4573417306,
-0.079481408,
-0.4348788261,
0.1905204356,
-0.3137488365,
-0.2551683784,
0.3303990364,
0.5595107675,
0.0402591079,
0.2436871827,
-0.1613380313,
-0.1886411011,
-0.3329997957,
0.502019465,
0.7300993204,
0.5545406938,
-0.0385640338,
0.342559278,
0.0889500231,
-0.2716239095,
0.0325586461,
0.1506773233,
-0.166275844,
0.1416489631,
0.4240914583,
0.9279549122,
0.6217485666,
-0.837015748,
0.3014010191,
0.0423503667,
-0.2849029601,
-0.1514651477,
0.4874326885,
0.0675437078,
0.1396544278,
0.2756833434,
0.0259685647,
0.1598867625,
-0.0556655414,
0.2555886209,
0.4551324546,
-0.1914589107,
0.1358522028,
0.7188723683,
0.4292640984,
-0.7773918509,
0.6177744865,
-0.8073377609,
-0.4568488598,
0.6291195154,
0.4205174446,
0.7027567625,
-0.020418724,
0.2249298543,
0.3092429042,
0.5304819345,
0.1485189646,
0.26908198,
0.22407718,
-0.4758419394,
-0.4973976612,
-0.5323591232,
-0.5699384212,
-0.1243523806,
-0.6807220578,
0.2796883583,
-0.3850113153,
-0.1287502199,
-0.0721623376,
-0.0965337679,
-0.5277611613,
0.1030162498,
0.5199663043,
0.5870645642,
-0.6377949715,
0.4458321631,
0.7307029963,
0.0135939391,
-0.6864705682,
-0.0586715117,
0.187010318,
-0.7286611795,
0.5909060836,
0.2939358354,
-0.1086817011,
0.0684608519,
-0.2988486886,
-0.5265349746,
1.0630884171,
0.3831357062,
-0.4626656473,
-0.3278845847,
0.3939242959,
0.4036321044,
-0.4073902071,
-0.0259875599,
0.3826868534,
0.7445055842,
0.1725313663,
-0.634406209,
0.1144408137,
-0.1667433828,
-0.1385130435,
0.6473298073,
-0.3305781484,
0.4861017466,
-0.234561041,
-0.4816756845,
-0.0495692044,
0.6476135254,
0.1882546097,
0.2188097835,
0.4554703236,
0.5180220604,
1.0720615387,
-0.6432032585,
0.7329627872,
-0.0568766855,
-0.1186110601,
1.4895991087,
-0.0014018703,
0.5426815748,
0.4819846153,
0.1803061366,
0.3385542929,
0.7704257369,
-0.2332643569,
-0.1102793366,
0.5578410625,
-0.4882307351,
-0.4472571313,
0.0567770749,
-0.1884049326,
0.458568573,
0.5608757734,
-0.2223598361,
-0.5673658252,
-0.0468121357,
-0.0264950171,
0.2775442898,
-0.2258956879,
0.4891869724,
-0.3541681767,
-0.6151829958,
0.4370313287,
0.2144562453,
0.6998550892,
-0.7065739036,
-0.2388199419,
0.2441611737,
-0.1100215986,
-0.3500152826,
-0.8929895759,
0.3289987147,
0.0160051044,
-0.1927424073,
-0.6114572287,
0.4772845209,
-0.7628545761,
-0.5300232768,
0.1720012128,
0.3859316111,
0.1292333752,
0.3356415629,
-1.0019240379,
0.1910675019,
0.372754246,
-0.1284601688,
-0.1196849793,
0.8757948875,
0.0760996416,
0.7101239562,
0.1287145168,
-0.2429046184,
0.9167630076,
-0.2194981724,
0.2880363762,
-0.5387448668,
-0.0188305322,
-0.7095186114,
0.6306236982,
0.0227822717,
-0.4250390828,
0.9629636407,
0.5282946229,
0.7691779733,
0.0474138856,
0.6061563492,
-0.3218694329,
0.3537974358,
-0.6839629412,
0.2085396349,
-0.444447428,
0.6338943839,
0.0768534839,
-0.6520217657,
-0.4030723274,
0.5689358115,
-0.5014774799,
-0.1109552905,
0.375249356,
0.8721387386,
-0.1664498746,
0.2727619708,
0.1012756079,
0.0141342292,
0.3317973912,
0.6582212448,
0.8173515797,
-0.4107137322,
0.6878409982,
-0.1351531297,
0.0686506033,
-0.2233667225,
-1.1215549707,
-0.823928535,
-0.1543441862,
-0.6734092832,
0.0096718939,
0.1307051033,
1.0355414152,
0.4994859099,
-0.4531657994,
-0.2165685892,
-0.174202323,
0.5482455492,
-0.2540339231,
-0.2364012003,
0.0571017116,
-0.622744143,
-0.8893613219,
0.4333978295,
0.0638749674,
0.147814855,
-0.123408027,
-0.1523044109,
-0.5106703043,
-0.0283331629,
0.2658946514,
0.2141091824,
-0.8136444092,
-0.3987187743,
-0.1164885312,
0.0204037018,
-0.033092767,
0.6856514812,
-0.3510212004,
0.7262414694,
0.3791396618,
0.6759291887,
0.1704610139,
0.2925116718,
0.8544187546,
-1.6457235813,
-0.0650427192,
0.158728987,
-0.0198116191,
0.4009226561,
-0.5554074049,
0.4188374877,
-0.1482662857,
-0.5161347389,
-0.7753666639,
0.4783406556,
-1.0129256248,
-0.3071958125,
1.1732782125,
-0.1194132417,
-0.1769260466,
-0.1892005503,
-0.2620559931,
0.4990922511,
-0.3083997965,
0.6285527349,
0.9109410048,
-0.4307159781,
-0.2747059762,
-0.8621088862,
0.5236380696,
0.4751015007,
-0.7849367261,
0.3822558224,
0.5455166698,
-0.3198898733,
0.2727134824,
-0.0425701961,
0.1656944305,
0.3573274314,
-0.120290719,
0.2407875061,
-0.2495283335,
-0.1093408316,
-0.1646698117,
0.2108819932,
-0.041931849,
-0.2384156138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17709v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17709v2
|
Case-Based or Rule-Based: How Do Transformers Do the Math?
| 2024-02-27T17:41:58 | 2024-06-26T09:25:07 |
Yi Hu, Xiaojuan Tang, Haotong Yang, Muhan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the impressive performance in a variety of complex tasks, modern
large language models (LLMs) still have trouble dealing with some math problems
that are simple and intuitive for humans, such as addition. While we can easily
learn basic rules of addition and apply them to new problems of any length,
LLMs struggle to do the same. Instead, they may rely on similar cases seen in
the training corpus for help. We define these two different reasoning
mechanisms as "rule-based reasoning" and "case-based reasoning". Since
rule-based reasoning is essential for acquiring systematic generalization
ability, we aim to explore exactly whether transformers use rule-based or
case-based reasoning for math problems. Through carefully designed intervention
experiments on five math tasks, we confirm that transformers are performing
case-based reasoning, no matter whether scratchpad is used, which aligns with
the previous observations that transformers use subgraph matching/shortcut
learning to reason. To mitigate such problems, we propose a Rule-Following
Fine-Tuning (RFFT) technique to teach transformers to perform rule-based
reasoning. Specifically, we provide explicit rules in the input and then
instruct transformers to recite and follow the rules step by step. Through
RFFT, we successfully enable LLMs fine-tuned on 1-5 digit addition to
generalize to up to 12-digit addition with over 95% accuracy, which is over 40%
higher than scratchpad. The significant improvement demonstrates that teaching
LLMs to use rules explicitly helps them learn rule-based reasoning and
generalize better in length.
|
[
-0.631652832,
-0.9678691626,
0.7236244678,
0.2374662906,
-0.2499282807,
0.1943300813,
-0.2113464326,
-0.0738142654,
-0.0458898284,
0.6913028359,
-0.8132808805,
-0.1684357375,
-0.5365902781,
0.0701081157,
-0.359937638,
1.063765645,
-0.0043566222,
0.109145999,
-0.4709888697,
-0.0655693933,
-0.7302715182,
-0.7391796112,
-0.4950587749,
-0.6775745749,
0.4102763832,
0.8189018369,
0.9250645638,
0.5666927695,
0.9844377041,
0.2560887635,
-0.0490455963,
0.119723022,
-0.1643991619,
-0.1904880852,
-0.269474864,
-0.8441230655,
-0.3155126274,
-0.1647349447,
-0.0301966872,
0.8687823415,
-0.448117286,
0.1022339538,
-0.5311715603,
0.757691741,
-0.2656953931,
0.1571729779,
-0.4867703617,
0.3824212551,
0.0264182873,
-0.4541835785,
-0.5349775553,
-0.3047939241,
0.0021184632,
-0.5292907357,
0.574821353,
-0.0184416398,
0.5717033148,
0.4920239151,
-0.3408894539,
-0.5072872639,
-1.0921121836,
0.8880751133,
-0.3549687266,
0.5283021927,
0.3521591723,
0.4323444664,
-0.1527673006,
-0.5311776996,
-0.5526192188,
-0.0123191513,
-0.3209254742,
0.0944418386,
-0.2169575095,
0.0719793662,
0.9628280997,
0.133185789,
-0.1370153278,
-0.1413965374,
-0.5695713758,
-0.0662746206,
0.4115814269,
0.0937450081,
0.178919524,
0.092665188,
-0.1403091252,
-0.2499421984,
-0.8115980625,
0.0704368278,
0.1074280217,
0.2565441728,
-0.0476698317,
0.7949198484,
-0.0177044068,
0.5935649276,
0.3389939666,
-0.175703451,
-0.1165354773,
-0.0918004438,
-0.2818717659,
0.062390089,
0.1338762641,
0.408865124,
1.0282598734,
-0.1463011503,
-0.2830376327,
0.2672054768,
0.3428342938,
-0.701920867,
0.024094969,
-0.1841943562,
-0.413233906,
-0.2324866056,
-0.0649224371,
-0.5524480939,
-0.2171936929,
-0.808590591,
0.7720196247,
-0.3857118189,
0.0967213213,
0.5436708927,
-0.3572796881,
0.4578565657,
0.585011065,
-1.0268259048,
0.5563312173,
0.9477970004,
0.3725297451,
0.1886842251,
-0.0762405321,
-0.746699512,
-0.013272603,
-0.3339565098,
1.1042356491,
-0.5267541409,
-0.4157960713,
-0.0176195167,
-0.2192345411,
-0.0940560177,
-0.8102807403,
0.8174509406,
-0.4574503601,
0.1871758103,
-0.2025791109,
-0.5119165778,
0.0274062641,
-0.0114914617,
-0.3678031564,
0.7241960168,
0.0963425413,
-0.2898063362,
0.523593843,
-0.6583034396,
-0.9856904745,
-0.0653528422,
-0.044378642,
-0.5190865993,
0.391187042,
0.3081330657,
0.4452592432,
-0.2839274108,
0.3072648346,
-0.1615146995,
-0.7325701118,
0.2129703611,
-0.4025895596,
0.4724213481,
0.1116951704,
-0.2709821165,
0.0122462288,
-0.4271894991,
-0.2069332749,
0.1084191203,
-0.1806681752,
-0.1439582556,
0.3213808239,
-0.4343708456,
0.167575717,
-0.1427958906,
-0.3757411242,
0.3820239007,
-0.1826588959,
0.350376606,
0.6750308275,
-0.1601324528,
0.5045839548,
-0.6785728931,
0.3501439989,
-0.0440263674,
0.2231550068,
-0.2207915783,
-0.4412144125,
-1.2692171335,
-0.0823537633,
0.3248223364,
0.7085650563,
-0.6483424306,
0.4483189583,
-0.1948398948,
-0.2803737819,
-0.1829064786,
-0.0042930101,
-0.0954746529,
0.5921681523,
0.8223144412,
-0.1185018346,
-0.5227741003,
-0.8895258307,
-0.2454237044,
0.0888098925,
-0.0853933245,
0.2304257005,
0.4658960998,
-0.2023262978,
0.9881283045,
-0.6756290197,
-0.4257851243,
-0.4467329085,
-0.0221824851,
0.4603171945,
0.1965398341,
0.4250820279,
-0.6225041747,
-0.407176435,
-0.196305871,
-0.5300889611,
-0.2542332411,
-0.5217232704,
0.0241936073,
0.101699248,
0.7556520104,
-0.6864686608,
0.5359097719,
-0.1679944247,
-0.4905840456,
0.4142203629,
-0.2053640634,
-0.1286397129,
-0.5229597688,
-0.5202666521,
0.2495936602,
-0.2783603072,
-0.6429607868,
0.038224522,
0.046137467,
0.0650037751,
-0.2523068488,
0.256165117,
-0.07915245,
-0.0413596407,
-0.2615202367,
-0.3029319644,
-0.0212201383,
0.6516731381,
0.0781361908,
0.8196595907,
0.3651631773,
-0.5559166074,
0.3493214846,
0.0298615303,
-0.2325217724,
0.7623514533,
-0.6350077391,
-0.0805387199,
-0.1771230251,
0.1333639026,
-0.5461294651,
0.2104157656,
0.0640885755,
-0.1488478035,
0.2386201769,
-0.3063405454,
-0.7451062202,
-0.4293216169,
-0.1102391779,
0.0770492405,
0.9451518655,
-0.7052686214,
1.0373066664,
-0.0427165367,
0.0066271853,
-0.3417916894,
-0.4510469735,
-0.1551096141,
-0.3538521528,
-0.5722677112,
0.4735455215,
-0.1852081716,
-0.5467603207,
-0.1527466923,
-0.3886193335,
-0.1681952477,
0.1970074326,
0.0410054252,
0.1279868633,
-0.1199253425,
0.0642760396,
0.3429155648,
-0.2068964243,
0.3137279153,
0.3305075467,
0.5454316139,
-0.1300029904,
-0.5853393674,
-0.0805569738,
0.3874408007,
0.6218915582,
-0.1987279952,
0.3533549309,
0.2010086924,
-0.2741760314,
-0.5399642587,
-0.6425772905,
-0.5644948483,
-0.5461614728,
0.0708977655,
-0.5637854934,
-0.7576779127,
0.39496544,
-0.3048319519,
0.1335536689,
0.5139242411,
0.598449409,
-0.4189136028,
1.0019022226,
0.6182800531,
0.298160404,
0.4709452391,
-0.1859891415,
0.2237757891,
-0.4798389673,
-0.169849813,
-0.4519035518,
-0.2734217644,
-0.2714693546,
-0.5284748673,
0.2061338425,
0.1327422261,
-0.2487022579,
0.4336282909,
-0.4704931676,
0.7313710451,
0.672108531,
0.108385399,
0.4096502662,
0.1937969029,
-0.3206597865,
-0.0235373676,
-0.6297162175,
-0.077079311,
0.9288651943,
0.2942049801,
0.9747179151,
0.1530906707,
0.586135149,
0.4648097157,
0.4351571798,
-1.2649331093,
0.6911629438,
-0.2098434716,
-0.4088384509,
-0.0906254053,
-0.516895771,
-0.7384706736,
0.1565003991,
-0.3245514333,
-0.1253581941,
0.0293352101,
-0.0797084868,
-0.2389494926,
0.180211246,
-1.055090189,
0.473362416,
-0.3471916914,
-0.0730059072,
-0.5139715075,
-0.3709543049,
0.1136696935,
-0.0783879012,
0.331263274,
-0.0238111634,
0.4101957381,
0.520205617,
-0.7855094075,
0.7711727619,
-0.0349222571,
-0.0978858396,
0.2907453477,
0.172325477,
0.363294214,
-0.146783188,
0.3075093329,
0.0607612617,
0.0267451294,
-0.0886354744,
-0.9778482318,
0.3278140426,
-0.6322292686,
-0.9224737287,
-0.5536572337,
-0.5333895683,
-0.3743385077,
0.0843615234,
-0.0530025475,
0.4158487916,
0.2666817307,
0.3044844568,
0.8687527776,
-0.0543161854,
0.3716678619,
0.7203266621,
-0.154870227,
-0.1568280309,
0.9602119923,
0.1574511975,
0.1264430285,
0.6303569674,
0.4521086812,
-0.2929638922,
-0.1461376101,
-0.4665728807,
0.3556402028,
-0.713434875,
-0.2185279429,
-0.2881295979,
-0.3573310673,
0.0510500707,
-0.4742884636,
0.021636283,
-0.5985864997,
0.0017363144,
-0.058811903,
0.5495769978,
0.4223000407,
0.0162569564,
0.2216261923,
-0.5837927461,
0.678832233,
0.6787281632,
0.5709114671,
-0.2397059649,
-0.5794139504,
-0.0869072229,
-0.0873482302,
-0.3522275984,
-0.44988662,
-0.1622470766,
0.0182843562,
0.4438669384,
0.1327926368,
-0.217410624,
0.7308580875,
-0.8608314395,
0.0421374813,
0.0344583876,
-0.9645389318,
0.3104580641,
-0.2565202117,
0.0624473579,
0.2479358166,
-0.0718599111,
-0.6853023767,
-0.0964423865,
-0.6237753034,
-0.3525814712,
0.6821196675,
0.1596773714,
0.3142540455,
0.0738083497,
0.496066004,
-0.0902737603,
0.1923031658,
-0.2490872443,
-0.3972298801,
-0.2776722312,
-0.3661683202,
0.1412647069,
-0.0545933768,
-0.1653586179,
-0.6861216426,
0.231436044,
-0.2696392536,
0.4868269563,
-0.0264417045,
-0.1716750264,
-0.2732871175,
0.355214864,
0.9564601183,
0.5084710121,
-0.2060461342,
-0.0417114645,
0.2802797854,
-0.3760815561,
0.0482214428,
0.1406162083,
-0.2022712976,
-0.1411449611,
0.4033994675,
0.5516956449,
0.1467521936,
-0.7654784918,
0.4445213974,
-0.2378395498,
-0.657483995,
-0.4034614265,
0.3618234396,
0.1698688716,
0.0803042203,
0.5317492485,
0.2959075868,
-0.0203294046,
-0.5745469332,
0.3818012476,
0.5067563057,
-0.1098769903,
-0.0789149106,
0.305840224,
0.1926109493,
-0.6374780536,
0.5540915728,
0.2688110471,
-0.593973279,
1.0793660879,
0.5683943033,
0.5928052664,
0.2598229647,
0.2335184962,
0.0597213618,
0.5066917539,
-0.2034536153,
0.331158489,
-0.1486960649,
-1.0823432207,
-0.825501442,
-0.3991491199,
-0.8964446187,
-0.1542609632,
-0.6226500869,
0.4543254375,
-0.7835579515,
0.0845734999,
0.1510425061,
-0.1525829136,
-0.72321558,
0.3565314412,
-0.0600283369,
0.9694344997,
-0.5906789899,
0.47164011,
0.5909882784,
-0.1624634713,
-0.8057150841,
-0.1020395905,
-0.2475225031,
-0.9377323985,
0.5275364518,
0.2545639575,
-0.096620515,
-0.0998832211,
-0.4833161831,
-0.5802502632,
0.7054153681,
0.2451344281,
-0.5684726834,
0.0969597027,
0.3772590756,
0.7864628434,
-0.1404997706,
0.3699435294,
0.6316946149,
0.504188776,
0.3715073466,
-0.744720161,
-0.2247369438,
-0.103853032,
-0.5116313696,
0.6783372164,
-0.6947355866,
0.5444771051,
-0.4703245163,
0.0180151481,
-0.3077902794,
0.408785373,
0.158049956,
0.3449184299,
0.5499269366,
0.8223437667,
0.4209811091,
-0.4399151504,
0.9868700504,
-0.1333513409,
0.3791197836,
0.8521156907,
-0.2066875845,
0.4629584253,
0.4840970933,
-0.2695429027,
0.7737606764,
0.2089366168,
-0.4062699378,
0.3184936941,
0.2660128474,
-0.0824111626,
-0.6742265821,
-0.0116706435,
-0.1475133896,
0.4195240438,
0.5556668639,
-0.22533153,
-0.32863307,
-0.1561852545,
0.0105429683,
0.091000855,
-0.40933007,
0.743088603,
0.1146018058,
-0.6891566515,
0.2893411219,
0.2521474957,
0.6122335196,
-0.4606330097,
-0.3813036084,
-0.3170075715,
0.3350039721,
-0.2132830471,
-0.8678642511,
0.5065495968,
-0.029403761,
-0.4154738784,
-0.4030217528,
0.6668542027,
-0.1293705106,
-0.8427765965,
0.0310643632,
0.6594617963,
-0.2461336702,
0.1845767796,
-0.6087735295,
-0.2536886632,
-0.0734492317,
0.1296966821,
0.311865449,
0.4392414093,
-0.4455153048,
0.8084753752,
0.8218513131,
-0.1338313073,
-0.1314587742,
0.5067449808,
0.7950572371,
-0.8106628656,
0.03004588,
-0.9458274245,
0.3279876113,
0.1727251858,
-0.1687513739,
0.4704352617,
0.4999005497,
0.8474888802,
-0.2195666283,
0.5720186234,
0.1966883093,
0.5448263884,
-0.5659059286,
0.2464348525,
-0.4337601066,
0.2109558135,
-0.1644478142,
-0.9386038184,
-0.6524640322,
1.0236481428,
-0.3657092154,
0.1691873074,
0.7579528689,
0.5665108562,
-0.2676930428,
0.1055469662,
0.2555615008,
-0.1474173963,
0.4351283312,
0.5169997811,
0.7799562216,
-0.1716477275,
0.6819944382,
-0.4320189357,
-0.0755792931,
-0.2196848392,
-0.6489978433,
-1.0700929165,
0.0001260151,
-0.2228556722,
-0.0778751224,
-0.3243028522,
0.886603713,
0.3939121068,
-0.7236189246,
-0.2858482599,
-0.3727321625,
0.563072443,
-0.3928821087,
-0.276686281,
0.1301762462,
-0.2191767544,
-0.5269287825,
0.3193981647,
0.2898183763,
0.1004605591,
0.1207790375,
0.161942035,
0.2109245062,
0.4922572374,
0.6863169074,
0.1460562944,
-0.5127511621,
-0.4928659201,
0.395290494,
0.0403374918,
0.2020040601,
1.1465281248,
-0.8060420156,
0.22041215,
0.3092875481,
0.4524765611,
0.5183992982,
0.1966336519,
0.4587624371,
-0.3705530465,
-0.0673685744,
0.0858358294,
0.5543238521,
0.2119921595,
-0.1693416089,
0.520901978,
0.4914893806,
-0.3855204582,
-0.6766456962,
0.476108253,
-0.8257335424,
-0.1973396987,
1.0173256397,
0.4953757524,
0.1442548782,
-0.1074944437,
-0.3919352591,
-0.0553473271,
-0.3537610471,
0.8375735879,
0.6958854198,
-0.322458446,
-0.3010199666,
-0.1731651425,
0.4852013886,
0.6824022532,
-0.6920458078,
-0.1765114814,
0.3425122797,
0.3424617052,
0.3338184655,
0.1947225332,
0.1104039252,
0.4550957382,
-0.3165584803,
-0.2079557478,
-0.1552627534,
-0.5217978954,
-0.1374310255,
0.0550035983,
-0.071884118,
0.437146008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17700v1
|
RAVEL: Evaluating Interpretability Methods on Disentangling Language Model Representations
| 2024-02-27T17:25:37 | 2024-02-27T17:25:37 |
Jing Huang, Zhengxuan Wu, Christopher Potts, Mor Geva, Atticus Geiger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Individual neurons participate in the representation of multiple high-level
concepts. To what extent can different interpretability methods successfully
disentangle these roles? To help address this question, we introduce RAVEL
(Resolving Attribute-Value Entanglements in Language Models), a dataset that
enables tightly controlled, quantitative comparisons between a variety of
existing interpretability methods. We use the resulting conceptual framework to
define the new method of Multi-task Distributed Alignment Search (MDAS), which
allows us to find distributed representations satisfying multiple causal
criteria. With Llama2-7B as the target language model, MDAS achieves
state-of-the-art results on RAVEL, demonstrating the importance of going beyond
neuron-level analyses to identify features distributed across activations. We
release our benchmark at https://github.com/explanare/ravel.
|
[
-0.1678411216,
-0.7552889585,
0.7335903049,
0.6002448201,
0.0604428202,
0.3513743877,
-0.1890969127,
-0.511611402,
0.0677223876,
0.099397406,
-0.3843795359,
-0.314270556,
-0.9997281432,
0.1480213404,
-0.6445127726,
0.6582322121,
-0.2340189964,
0.0569097362,
-0.4021629989,
-0.2319329232,
-0.3128312826,
-0.219186455,
-0.5235053301,
-0.6716023684,
0.7301898599,
0.1161259562,
0.5980281234,
0.6574094296,
0.9401996136,
0.2841443717,
-0.3166429102,
0.2926909328,
-0.3242515624,
0.3325274885,
-0.2874788046,
-0.5705692172,
-0.5884211063,
0.1955618858,
0.6388642192,
0.7080991864,
-0.5802186131,
0.2644301653,
0.0589942932,
0.7960512638,
-0.7846959829,
0.1992667019,
-0.6233382225,
-0.1318244338,
-0.470595032,
0.0037684392,
-0.6406502724,
-0.2718082964,
0.1760831326,
-0.4872043431,
-0.0023842407,
-0.0504852794,
0.7698943019,
0.3326537609,
-0.5474051237,
-0.491794765,
-0.6005433202,
0.8596173525,
-0.6859151721,
0.4315929413,
0.3494864702,
0.4189348221,
-0.0060077775,
-0.5957268476,
-0.6655405164,
-0.117526561,
-0.0674990118,
0.0943110138,
-0.3710477352,
-0.0794694945,
0.2409372926,
0.3220909238,
-0.4753639698,
0.0102553908,
-0.252386719,
0.0541278385,
0.683555007,
0.1635530293,
0.3058711886,
0.0580403358,
-0.2193469852,
-0.0788048059,
-0.4991995692,
-0.1303210706,
0.3481816649,
0.1174735427,
-0.1604854316,
0.6240602732,
-0.0054460121,
0.666680932,
0.3571187854,
0.1227598339,
0.3385481238,
-0.1193341389,
-0.024019789,
-0.0388460383,
0.5731002688,
0.0437628441,
0.048213087,
-0.2880693376,
-0.3023359179,
0.1076375619,
0.4020982683,
-0.4411872327,
-0.0622252226,
0.4408980906,
-0.6417047381,
-0.2993581891,
-0.1241772845,
-0.8203979731,
-0.9639526606,
-0.4271502793,
0.2224322259,
-0.2109868824,
-0.563839972,
0.2788780332,
-0.038231425,
0.2254243046,
0.1434960365,
-0.9275324941,
0.4870683253,
0.5457391739,
0.8794971704,
-0.5680612922,
-0.5204413533,
-0.2968918979,
0.0009092056,
-0.5821325779,
0.7934377789,
-0.6952982545,
0.1606482863,
-0.1798951328,
-0.3121123016,
-0.3276683688,
-0.6709274054,
0.3946929276,
-0.8905201554,
-0.2942352593,
-0.1609347165,
-0.4525511265,
-0.242815733,
0.237968266,
-0.8658900857,
0.882858932,
0.0011185597,
-0.7126148939,
0.2262838483,
-0.6733954549,
-0.343028456,
-0.4086945355,
-0.138090089,
-0.3110515177,
0.355114162,
0.2123157978,
0.4262001216,
-0.5390744209,
0.4017571807,
-0.2276816517,
-0.2456622124,
0.6188895106,
-0.4888105989,
0.5871189237,
0.4601043761,
-0.3717695475,
0.1939213723,
-0.770358026,
0.0220771786,
0.1540452987,
-0.1827021092,
-0.2661540806,
0.3994506001,
0.0102980714,
0.3352306783,
0.4864563048,
-0.3478071094,
0.1631160975,
-0.2383493483,
0.2771793008,
0.8179386854,
-0.2339471728,
0.4759453535,
0.038661778,
0.3818678558,
0.6227526069,
0.2189701498,
0.2641810179,
-0.4006448686,
-0.6993923783,
-0.3068635464,
-0.0236659572,
0.2563551366,
-0.4848397672,
0.1958356053,
-0.1673707962,
-0.5434779525,
-0.7373241782,
0.0815299973,
0.4098677337,
-0.0415060371,
0.3862127066,
-0.1706933379,
-0.5783166885,
-1.1351745129,
-0.4115232527,
0.0178287067,
0.235635832,
0.0264516957,
0.3487323523,
-0.5514953732,
0.8202031255,
-0.4995639026,
-0.1295002699,
-0.2806578577,
0.2970414758,
0.6191889644,
0.2086573541,
0.3017138839,
-0.7336438298,
-0.5381849408,
0.4583418667,
-0.9221323133,
-0.0903700441,
-0.2468873858,
-0.0094964905,
-0.1888227761,
0.254158169,
-0.5054496527,
0.3335213959,
0.8901126385,
-0.2603258491,
0.364418149,
-0.1089346856,
0.3099375069,
-0.9863350987,
0.0422377624,
0.0863402709,
0.0565382354,
-0.7343783379,
0.1165829897,
0.3047706783,
0.1567903459,
-0.158175379,
0.280218631,
-0.6541053057,
-0.2079805881,
-0.3518052399,
0.3070243299,
-0.11088337,
0.2181839049,
-0.1827349216,
0.8461127877,
0.9870223403,
-0.5692105889,
0.2862479687,
0.2146751583,
-0.2086155564,
0.7591670156,
-0.789481163,
0.2860575318,
-0.2398695499,
-0.0217773635,
-0.8279732466,
-0.0879059434,
0.122419551,
-0.2843815982,
0.2030938566,
-0.0423643552,
-0.2647712529,
0.0578308068,
0.0657463595,
0.5946983695,
0.2779147029,
-0.6666752696,
0.7937671542,
0.4460289478,
0.2517490685,
-0.8401854038,
-0.5954180956,
0.0493848547,
-0.2766804099,
-0.3548961282,
0.2210052907,
0.0689678639,
-0.5276351571,
-0.1990641057,
-0.3693885207,
-0.3152616024,
0.1481823027,
0.2509967983,
0.0601992942,
-0.0567126535,
0.0492427237,
-0.0110344859,
-0.1448377669,
0.049749814,
0.0447289236,
0.5565114617,
-0.2024616301,
-0.6313008666,
-0.3285836279,
0.3411776721,
0.641690135,
-0.5184458494,
0.9243940115,
0.4154446423,
-0.3548890054,
-0.4011134207,
-0.4037009478,
0.0553782135,
-0.5167788267,
0.3853527606,
-0.5928915739,
-0.4778338373,
0.7591385245,
-0.2351344228,
-0.0639390573,
0.4810026586,
0.6494211555,
-0.1577468812,
1.2175911665,
0.4928691387,
0.1036310047,
0.4306516647,
-0.1865955889,
0.3284259439,
-1.0659905672,
-0.3079872429,
-0.483643204,
-0.4069139063,
-0.4382389188,
-0.5983852148,
0.1643766165,
0.2479608208,
-0.0130117536,
0.4426444471,
-0.5532027483,
0.5528354645,
0.1543078274,
0.1188270599,
0.4184648097,
-0.1101983115,
0.0158589575,
-0.066107206,
-0.2900659144,
-0.5859734416,
1.0826997757,
0.4733786285,
1.056617856,
0.3436986804,
0.603407383,
0.2705205381,
0.3228065968,
-0.7253701091,
0.4228579104,
-0.0946377665,
-0.6949659586,
-0.0875704661,
-0.4117248654,
-0.9931724072,
0.4941457212,
0.0074745058,
-0.9303204417,
0.3988838494,
-0.0477373749,
0.2212005258,
0.1988399029,
-0.5628753901,
0.6037559509,
-0.2026147246,
-0.0927136466,
-0.6481483579,
-0.3055628538,
0.3457174897,
-0.0875942335,
0.1445778459,
-0.2934183776,
-0.0123084877,
0.7751776576,
0.4783519208,
0.7428239584,
0.0124663329,
-0.362845391,
-0.1103757322,
0.1180697978,
0.5667168498,
-0.0576095916,
-0.2657573223,
0.4562885463,
0.2425288707,
-0.3972924948,
-0.8130828142,
0.7542749643,
-0.8572046757,
-0.3265925348,
-0.7257897258,
-0.7758175731,
-0.2954970896,
0.1060560569,
-0.0877232552,
0.3620481789,
-0.1357970834,
-0.0330196247,
0.6557148099,
0.0619898289,
0.2922750115,
0.4655911922,
-0.2981310785,
-0.142692402,
1.016915679,
-0.0682054535,
0.2366172522,
0.3018208146,
-0.0910427421,
-0.2731844485,
-0.8802934885,
-0.1235534996,
0.2563025355,
-0.8989134431,
0.1538162231,
-0.4144553244,
-0.1927355826,
-0.0846984833,
0.1198461875,
-0.6161698699,
-0.2280772328,
-0.3727708757,
0.0144542987,
0.0693725944,
1.31146276,
-0.0601685271,
0.1965456903,
-0.5620647669,
0.442242384,
0.0462636799,
0.6360327601,
0.1979354024,
-0.3257298172,
-0.5450052619,
0.1253358871,
-0.322026819,
-1.1122640371,
0.1104567796,
0.1981371194,
0.9112534523,
0.3815055788,
-0.1032805219,
0.7683787942,
-0.4416392744,
0.4838740826,
0.3123028278,
-1.2154904604,
0.5118575096,
-0.0555226542,
0.0346802063,
0.2648067772,
0.4365847409,
-0.7298676372,
-0.3143129051,
-0.3313455582,
-0.6738913655,
0.5285879374,
0.2909560502,
-0.1061472148,
-0.1413141042,
0.282613188,
0.1243959069,
-0.1071529686,
-0.4853314459,
-0.4646549225,
0.2824423909,
-0.4751462638,
-0.2330933064,
-0.1780330986,
-0.3648360074,
-0.0812469199,
0.3802884221,
-0.2248603553,
0.3812874556,
0.0947611555,
-0.3693723381,
-0.0368469134,
0.3338165581,
0.2767854631,
1.107786417,
0.028656844,
0.4749821723,
0.0430669896,
-0.5703758001,
0.4413250387,
-0.0820023939,
0.0951665863,
-0.2040620446,
0.5863001347,
0.6960539818,
-0.0837088004,
-0.5888937116,
0.1765854508,
-0.0846250653,
0.0340226404,
0.1726513207,
-0.0311653428,
0.1045380831,
0.5340107679,
0.3561992645,
0.2863427103,
0.2744409144,
-0.3640808761,
0.3534168601,
0.3814146817,
-0.5237634778,
-0.4751213789,
0.5281231403,
-0.0088262409,
0.0081826746,
0.5885750651,
-0.0165830776,
-0.1616391093,
0.5170109868,
0.516977191,
0.9792950153,
-0.3022243381,
0.4273461103,
0.2164288908,
0.3200310767,
-0.1278452426,
0.3395860791,
0.1572783738,
-1.0202430487,
-0.4654931426,
-0.4325963259,
-0.3899044693,
-0.4644799531,
-1.1442722082,
-0.3321833014,
-0.0079990169,
-0.2218228877,
0.3076756895,
-0.1165261492,
-0.5006001592,
-0.1177275181,
-0.0449701548,
0.5938115716,
-0.9651149511,
0.8708276153,
0.7303543687,
-0.4372393489,
-0.5120487809,
0.1878913641,
0.079504095,
-0.7512181997,
0.8237526417,
-0.0551769175,
-0.3196250796,
-0.0072575929,
-0.5401675701,
-1.0076551437,
1.0305316448,
0.57115376,
-0.5705217123,
0.0981306508,
0.1854324192,
0.5469433069,
-0.2051458061,
0.3506468832,
0.9815707207,
0.4595567882,
-0.029951565,
-0.9476783276,
0.0442798175,
-0.2295387089,
-0.0685753822,
0.0465453863,
-0.297593385,
0.9058812857,
-0.1229825541,
-0.3526244462,
-0.295448333,
0.6490430236,
0.3795826435,
0.2766364515,
0.4470463991,
0.4787345231,
1.0444555283,
-0.1364853084,
0.9500827789,
-0.0286358558,
0.7406408191,
1.0007725954,
-0.3390040398,
0.8883823752,
0.7912355065,
-0.4955995679,
0.3946055174,
0.6604010463,
0.3844220936,
0.7174715996,
0.3183197379,
-0.1705820709,
-0.2841565311,
-0.0244850274,
-0.0349678397,
0.3112196624,
0.3100513816,
-0.2341388762,
-0.1971985996,
0.0706999525,
-0.3374413848,
0.1059808806,
-0.0477065742,
0.7680543661,
0.1902692318,
-0.3786954582,
0.5756589174,
-0.2347402126,
0.62858814,
-0.457125932,
-0.1417716444,
-0.2600402832,
0.557359457,
-0.3260694742,
-0.9872852564,
0.420030266,
-0.134687528,
-0.3577081859,
-0.215668276,
0.4546203911,
-0.4370348454,
-0.3200466037,
0.5451569557,
0.6760826707,
0.0666606277,
-0.0913317204,
-0.7637498379,
0.3087743521,
-0.2930938005,
-0.3961892128,
0.3684799671,
0.2899405658,
-0.0079450281,
1.1035039425,
0.3629254401,
0.1391793787,
0.2401721478,
0.064670071,
0.94386518,
-0.587217629,
-0.0326228887,
-0.9070672393,
0.450152874,
-0.1363311708,
-0.2544057667,
0.7799452543,
0.325032413,
0.4671569467,
0.0088646114,
0.5052853823,
-0.2937067747,
0.1341844797,
-0.509976387,
0.7972977161,
-0.5230962634,
0.3110837638,
-0.2350358218,
-0.9029486179,
-0.2168449014,
0.695392549,
-0.2059599906,
-0.1210166141,
1.0367631912,
0.8153383136,
-0.2147245407,
-0.0977635309,
0.3828504384,
0.2387547493,
0.4568712413,
0.3595206141,
1.1373257637,
-0.3840906024,
0.1794221103,
-0.0887914971,
-0.2411488593,
0.1679593623,
-0.7370028496,
-0.816942215,
-0.9848377109,
-0.3905055225,
-0.2568724453,
0.0824113488,
0.6851219535,
0.8114925027,
-1.0148460865,
-0.4719584286,
-0.0011406654,
0.3766491115,
-0.9070026278,
-0.1480034292,
0.439475745,
-0.4815927744,
-0.8139463663,
0.645165205,
0.2426774651,
-0.3823506236,
-0.4443638623,
-0.111088112,
-0.3523635566,
0.2226769328,
0.4014104605,
-0.2092096508,
-0.8372114301,
-0.1080842912,
0.0793840364,
-0.2396893054,
0.1010483876,
0.8400469422,
-0.2145537287,
0.6076145172,
0.4999884963,
0.6376375556,
0.4572330713,
-0.2041969746,
0.6826261282,
-0.5253005624,
-0.0820836574,
0.1867849529,
0.2934401631,
0.0653897822,
-0.2372754812,
0.5245649815,
-0.2149522454,
-0.5362275243,
-0.7428233027,
0.3158640265,
-1.2475510836,
-0.0632783026,
1.061083436,
-0.2287552208,
-0.1229960546,
-0.2033535689,
-0.1496859491,
0.1444000751,
-0.1275200993,
0.7141689062,
0.8190141916,
-0.2101421654,
-0.4045864344,
-0.4793099463,
0.3341499567,
0.0799496248,
-0.9104982615,
0.3179543316,
0.2697795331,
0.1118637249,
0.2943104804,
0.3361699283,
-0.1600466669,
0.1527391672,
0.0510035045,
0.2302926332,
0.1107280329,
-0.3464034498,
-0.4958028495,
-0.1170730814,
0.2521915138,
-0.2205902487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17682v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17682v2
|
NextLevelBERT: Masked Language Modeling with Higher-Level Representations for Long Documents
| 2024-02-27T16:56:30 | 2024-06-13T10:21:03 |
Tamara Czinczoll, Christoph Hönes, Maximilian Schall, Gerard de Melo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While (large) language models have significantly improved over the last
years, they still struggle to sensibly process long sequences found, e.g., in
books, due to the quadratic scaling of the underlying attention mechanism. To
address this, we propose NextLevelBERT, a Masked Language Model operating not
on tokens, but on higher-level semantic representations in the form of text
embeddings. We pretrain NextLevelBERT to predict the vector representation of
entire masked text chunks and evaluate the effectiveness of the resulting
document vectors on three types of tasks: 1) Semantic Textual Similarity via
zero-shot document embeddings, 2) Long document classification, 3)
Multiple-choice question answering. We find that next-level Masked Language
Modeling is an effective technique to tackle long-document use cases and can
outperfor much larger embedding models as long as the required level of detail
of semantic information is not too fine. Our models and code are publicly
available online.
|
[
-0.3198956251,
-0.4379346371,
0.5171813369,
0.2558793724,
0.0786983743,
0.3247382343,
-0.1129114702,
-0.5701688528,
0.1730325669,
0.9149629474,
-0.365511775,
-0.9520779848,
-0.847242415,
-0.0866529644,
-0.7608037591,
0.8560315967,
0.0171342921,
-0.1371965408,
-0.6796517968,
0.1646790653,
-0.4544127285,
-0.6760267615,
-0.5408425331,
-0.3722207248,
0.5874180794,
0.3914123476,
0.5780797601,
0.383138001,
0.3553535342,
0.24024342,
-0.1090745777,
-0.2815752327,
-0.5981263518,
0.3090106249,
0.0960668251,
-0.5308232307,
-0.3472688198,
0.1097230166,
0.9167543054,
0.5365008712,
0.1510645598,
0.0546638221,
-0.0635606572,
0.4325359762,
-0.6364207864,
0.3431281149,
-0.4585515857,
0.2128573358,
-0.0269210748,
-0.0926997438,
-0.5290049314,
-0.1408257186,
0.1834767014,
-0.5836686492,
0.1339805871,
0.1195206121,
0.5781724453,
0.0510973409,
-0.3035074472,
-0.3419003785,
-0.6360264421,
0.8174833655,
-0.5591461062,
0.601621151,
0.8104498982,
0.1523178518,
0.1102377996,
-0.8699848652,
-0.4979749918,
-0.6990441084,
-0.0602433719,
-0.0009637074,
-0.2278924137,
0.0537470914,
0.3228439391,
-0.0059624636,
-0.5696381927,
0.1570875794,
-0.305583179,
-0.221236974,
0.3398283422,
-0.0059451917,
0.1124444678,
-0.0985506177,
-0.4551982284,
-0.0324027129,
-0.6115675569,
-0.0399344265,
0.4498798847,
-0.0281756707,
0.2426440269,
0.6070786715,
-0.2866556346,
0.7629491687,
-0.0774186775,
0.0206074622,
0.3111004829,
0.1885091364,
-0.0829776749,
0.1217034981,
0.2819612026,
0.3414136767,
0.1865824312,
-0.0736789554,
-0.3821317554,
-0.3047789037,
0.2117217034,
-0.9039548039,
-0.385581553,
0.4587948918,
-0.3998512924,
-0.4044028521,
-0.3106708229,
-0.4633231759,
-0.6390753984,
-0.2759559751,
0.5237665176,
-0.3524665236,
-0.078460224,
0.3560828269,
-0.1022315621,
0.2717826962,
0.4023762643,
-0.6867645383,
0.3609390557,
0.8660371304,
0.9547463655,
-0.0162134171,
-0.1841012836,
-0.8772118092,
0.2739441693,
-0.3524744213,
0.6968489885,
-1.0485603809,
-0.227548182,
0.3915707767,
0.0478115529,
0.0923022181,
-0.2819031775,
0.7278192639,
-0.8058431745,
0.3707697093,
0.0372861139,
-0.7466534972,
-0.0596820489,
0.4112659693,
-0.6538908482,
1.2354375124,
0.1912705451,
-0.7628938556,
0.0275048707,
-0.4799399674,
-0.2291990519,
0.3668733537,
-0.1002032384,
-0.4096575379,
0.011932319,
0.3326802254,
0.842715919,
-0.2834727168,
-0.0156391077,
-0.1845111549,
-0.3010698557,
0.0142922094,
-0.0602369383,
0.6736546755,
-0.2701820135,
-0.140589267,
0.2237968147,
-0.7845213413,
-0.1340143234,
-0.0683266148,
-0.030960992,
-0.6332164407,
-0.1037454158,
0.0918181613,
0.5031418204,
0.6078321934,
-0.8240410686,
0.0165064018,
-0.1597313285,
0.4783330858,
0.5885545015,
-0.2581434846,
0.4807851315,
-0.1966335475,
0.7354699969,
-0.0965307951,
0.1375234574,
-0.4229386151,
-0.6343329549,
-0.7852712274,
-0.3062430918,
0.4614980817,
0.417235285,
-0.6822451353,
0.2738298476,
-0.3318408132,
-0.4326419532,
-0.2284658104,
-0.0240615048,
0.3905003667,
0.3669510484,
0.2707995772,
-0.3041778803,
-0.2709670961,
-0.8813078403,
-0.0289738327,
-0.0567552559,
-0.2166319042,
0.1067809165,
0.6647806764,
-0.3297641277,
0.7584244609,
-0.5770324469,
-0.5559299588,
-0.1852154583,
0.3518297374,
-0.0473784953,
0.3318521082,
0.4491373301,
-0.6643277407,
-0.3828561306,
-0.079174526,
-0.5429917574,
-0.033746995,
0.0063245753,
-0.1023590267,
0.2097039372,
1.2641915083,
-0.5629001856,
0.1107488796,
0.6341611147,
-0.0872780681,
0.1083571836,
-0.3262174129,
-0.3567380011,
-0.8981783986,
-0.2344238311,
0.0347243585,
-0.5277246833,
-0.7904421687,
0.0343737267,
0.5294786692,
-0.6180000305,
-0.4693392813,
0.5439442992,
-0.6394228935,
-0.2200668305,
-0.2839676142,
0.3557252288,
0.2525785565,
0.613750875,
0.1669697911,
0.3209462464,
0.7945538759,
-0.1604533941,
0.5188944936,
0.1118448526,
-0.493049413,
0.3985389769,
-0.7471675277,
0.1801508814,
-0.5573048592,
0.6288781166,
-0.8647605181,
-0.2399137318,
0.0869769007,
-0.5438443422,
0.5358338356,
-0.1923924237,
-0.5191605091,
-0.4008042514,
-0.5210180879,
0.45831424,
0.4775529206,
-0.3371450901,
0.663036406,
0.4968025088,
-0.4150961339,
-0.6724291444,
-0.4833628535,
0.2421364188,
0.0570002049,
-0.5527175665,
0.5334748626,
0.1502649486,
0.1590280831,
-0.0308111664,
0.011623092,
-0.038727656,
-0.2878744006,
0.2002485842,
-0.0015470169,
-0.14748694,
0.4295759499,
-0.0956955701,
-0.2099913657,
0.1308363676,
-0.9340663552,
0.7719148397,
-0.080784522,
-0.2861680388,
-0.0580958501,
0.8994626403,
0.5524318218,
-0.7387804985,
0.8658592105,
0.8466219902,
-0.8047766685,
-0.1985956728,
-0.5095244646,
0.2324910909,
-0.4338813126,
0.6901504397,
-0.1895962507,
-1.2490986586,
0.4168535471,
0.2604451478,
0.0081243822,
0.4281492829,
0.6427896023,
-0.1314297616,
0.9418598413,
0.9776025414,
0.0400264896,
0.6112964153,
-0.2930814624,
0.2707471848,
-0.7893825769,
-0.6981166005,
-0.6014541388,
0.1087987274,
-0.4778762162,
-0.828882277,
0.2408723384,
0.0767078772,
-0.329351455,
0.5574516058,
-0.4021587372,
0.6949693561,
0.6523968577,
-0.1141750515,
0.0628726706,
0.0490313917,
0.1153624952,
0.1937339306,
-0.6296967268,
-0.3975148201,
1.0009908676,
0.6910659671,
0.7658031583,
-0.1815151274,
0.9992671609,
0.4427409768,
0.1831371933,
-0.8199073076,
0.49676916,
-0.0590613112,
-0.4945045412,
-0.5861020088,
-0.0369181708,
-0.8643411398,
0.3071672022,
-0.2650405169,
-0.703954041,
0.3331262171,
-0.1130213514,
-0.2047500759,
0.1167587712,
-0.5529012084,
0.8700633049,
0.0373895802,
-0.1558093727,
-0.0551117584,
-0.6560710669,
0.1668841392,
-0.3281654418,
0.1187088341,
-0.2392347753,
-0.3843023181,
0.7885785103,
-0.1331819147,
0.80058676,
0.0709542558,
-0.46784091,
0.1369904131,
-0.0078836754,
0.6909887195,
0.1522302181,
-0.0449102409,
0.3064469397,
-0.0353263468,
-0.6903327107,
-0.7057699561,
0.8345476985,
-0.7774921656,
-0.6953931451,
-0.5861652493,
-0.4571068883,
-0.2116962075,
0.3044307828,
0.2536969185,
0.7651895285,
0.1404327154,
0.4814825654,
0.8287983537,
-0.3144362569,
0.362528652,
0.2594231069,
-0.3694457412,
-0.1291846484,
1.1261570454,
-0.0118044699,
0.1781451553,
0.9502892494,
-0.0538273305,
-0.429477632,
-0.6372849345,
-0.0353407003,
0.0205088891,
-1.0467400551,
-0.1463496089,
-1.1862472296,
-0.3656240404,
-0.5569885373,
-0.1635978073,
-0.1852172911,
-0.576302886,
-0.3102880418,
0.0566388816,
0.185956955,
0.8253647089,
0.0764431804,
0.1114856899,
-0.7513301373,
0.3689512014,
0.2971710861,
0.4190077782,
-0.1170060411,
-0.5050184131,
-0.5556746721,
-0.4025380909,
-0.1808689088,
-0.6500916481,
0.4387510419,
0.1068745926,
0.40275684,
-0.0857444331,
0.0988922566,
0.0193435587,
-0.5861470103,
0.6355573535,
0.2219076902,
-0.9185608029,
0.2473577708,
-0.4522349238,
0.3778022826,
0.2521871626,
0.7566697598,
-0.6710247397,
-0.6592898369,
-0.3736719191,
-0.9790226221,
0.5900915265,
0.4678995609,
0.4986061752,
0.1002865732,
0.1038495153,
-0.0615308657,
0.3354763985,
-0.8684148788,
0.1809163839,
-0.3434280455,
-0.0316377133,
-0.3228116035,
-0.5001271963,
0.0820027068,
-0.2064705193,
0.4830680192,
0.0409550741,
0.582190752,
0.0014539898,
-0.3046999872,
0.2496270835,
0.0933519155,
0.776196897,
0.6038270593,
-0.3499355614,
0.1924824119,
0.0566845015,
-0.5570649505,
-0.1201926842,
0.3362755477,
0.14404805,
0.1200714707,
0.7970098853,
0.6693281531,
0.1590879411,
-0.5561602116,
0.7982378602,
-0.0422382839,
-0.3242236674,
-0.6577831507,
-0.2348022461,
0.229775548,
0.3395346999,
0.2555680871,
-0.2798511088,
-0.0005670699,
-0.4930608571,
0.1928243488,
0.2363322526,
-0.6474356055,
0.2379125059,
0.6047737598,
0.192407459,
-0.4693947434,
0.469863534,
-0.004668266,
-0.6481423378,
0.4909602404,
0.3578946888,
0.8015452027,
-0.1522639692,
0.5290459991,
0.1624187529,
0.453800112,
0.0535888374,
-0.043061763,
-0.1456241161,
-0.3723956645,
-0.4558779597,
-0.7336904407,
-0.4462645054,
0.2047173828,
-0.3869632483,
0.2575232983,
-0.4158611298,
0.075710386,
-0.0108954255,
-0.0961468965,
-0.5553736687,
0.2090063542,
0.2749634087,
0.8901826739,
-0.5769730806,
1.0155975819,
0.3018250167,
-0.3985385895,
-0.2366090119,
0.2486491799,
-0.4854903221,
-0.775911212,
0.7558960915,
0.3706230521,
-0.1541982442,
0.0491600111,
-0.5081158876,
-1.1299579144,
0.8309333324,
0.2751431763,
-0.6397388577,
-0.3884037137,
0.2394435257,
0.6518313289,
-0.5384947062,
0.2752369642,
0.2706528008,
0.2109236866,
0.0454719029,
-0.3104870319,
-0.1237896606,
-0.2665137947,
0.3232803941,
0.1645558029,
-0.342287004,
1.1428478956,
0.1296704859,
0.0473719798,
-0.0499447621,
0.8273790479,
-0.2407033443,
0.0617362149,
0.3191312253,
0.3528805077,
0.7421726584,
0.1541434526,
1.2132297754,
-0.4469780028,
0.3577691913,
1.1716282368,
-0.318225503,
0.9200283885,
-0.0323189832,
0.3338160813,
0.7004498839,
0.5490375757,
0.0153704872,
0.455542326,
0.4958426654,
-0.4838731587,
-0.4829039276,
-0.1786660254,
-0.4230891764,
0.270783931,
0.362854898,
-0.4095151424,
-0.1902040243,
0.3195756376,
-0.1388408244,
0.0541792959,
-0.3986489773,
0.4464578032,
0.0767409056,
-0.5422455072,
0.8200154901,
0.3908741474,
0.4385973215,
-0.3176701069,
-0.1469067633,
-0.1461806893,
0.0122780008,
-0.1067777947,
-0.9010878801,
-0.0100758765,
-0.0683526173,
-0.1266449988,
-0.4944941998,
0.9775016904,
-0.6583527327,
-0.7675170302,
0.4813081324,
0.100322783,
0.088386327,
-0.2947272658,
-0.4514789879,
-0.0172312707,
-0.4695533812,
-0.1852198392,
0.2532453239,
0.4103787839,
-0.4389447868,
0.7259286642,
0.4409754574,
-0.3305659294,
0.3332886994,
0.2848826051,
0.8872766495,
-0.5836699605,
-0.524125576,
-0.4536853433,
0.2257442176,
-0.2306336462,
-0.1762005836,
0.6642531157,
0.5814707875,
1.0560905933,
-0.0236457102,
0.7358925343,
0.3277382553,
0.3734518588,
-0.5606954098,
0.602317512,
-0.5751883984,
-0.0157946758,
-0.3450632989,
-1.1603498459,
-0.4903727472,
0.5067080855,
-0.3328502774,
0.1190633029,
0.7565102577,
0.7500852942,
-0.073555246,
0.0251096506,
0.7196499109,
0.0930906087,
0.3175266981,
0.72746557,
0.9120754004,
-0.1966475397,
0.6080436707,
0.0136059588,
-0.2586656809,
-0.3041611612,
-0.9246872067,
-1.3620913029,
-0.8371160626,
-0.187553063,
-0.2580931187,
0.0797766075,
0.7284716964,
0.5862773657,
-0.4973719716,
0.0129371807,
-0.0832111686,
0.1542088985,
0.3206103146,
-0.0754183084,
0.5053193569,
-0.3233360946,
-0.7008517981,
0.0876198709,
0.4616150558,
-0.0448384359,
-0.5805251002,
0.0153431091,
-0.1117066965,
0.15247491,
1.0795949697,
0.1507446915,
-0.5636427999,
-0.4261357486,
0.0352007486,
-0.2932963371,
-0.0363891758,
0.9573203921,
-0.7256940007,
0.4189584255,
0.5796249509,
0.7220509052,
0.8873890042,
-0.4927771688,
0.5656019449,
-0.6963165402,
0.1670814902,
0.4893788099,
0.2367075086,
0.4143910408,
-0.1983025819,
0.0865911841,
-0.0787057504,
-0.2777252495,
-0.7056482434,
0.3631684184,
-0.701320529,
-0.2147299796,
1.2222737074,
-0.3383435905,
-0.14301759,
-0.2348592579,
-0.2851421237,
0.2054154426,
-0.294809252,
0.3781608939,
0.8471243382,
0.0914186835,
-0.5611840487,
-0.7885166407,
0.4481565058,
0.3203107417,
-0.681635499,
0.0605692603,
0.3432497978,
-0.0171270184,
0.2585044801,
0.6310260296,
-0.2059447169,
0.0788765326,
-0.0979578346,
-0.1406772286,
-0.1619350463,
-0.8388072848,
-0.3294785917,
0.4102694094,
-0.0616977513,
0.0004541462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17649v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17649v2
|
Beyond prompt brittleness: Evaluating the reliability and consistency of political worldviews in LLMs
| 2024-02-27T16:19:37 | 2024-06-03T22:25:08 |
Tanise Ceron, Neele Falk, Ana Barić, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Due to the widespread use of large language models (LLMs) in ubiquitous
systems, we need to understand whether they embed a specific worldview and what
these views reflect. Recent studies report that, prompted with political
questionnaires, LLMs show left-liberal leanings (Feng et al., 2023; Motoki et
al., 2024). However, it is as yet unclear whether these leanings are reliable
(robust to prompt variations) and whether the leaning is consistent across
policies and political leaning. We propose a series of tests which assess the
reliability and consistency of LLMs' stances on political statements based on a
dataset of voting-advice questionnaires collected from seven EU countries and
annotated for policy domains. We study LLMs ranging in size from 7B to 70B
parameters and find that their reliability increases with parameter count.
Larger models show overall stronger alignment with left-leaning parties but
differ among policy programs: They evince a (left-wing) positive stance towards
environment protection, social welfare state and liberal society but also
(right-wing) law and order, with no consistent preferences in foreign policy
and migration.
|
[
-0.1841832548,
-0.6794126034,
0.9350802302,
0.3755556345,
-0.1379829943,
-0.0569875687,
-0.2190732211,
-0.0396203808,
0.1773421615,
0.4047687054,
-0.5711790919,
-0.3990666866,
-0.6849118471,
0.3171176016,
-0.0716455653,
0.8195213079,
0.2370983809,
0.2579801083,
-0.2382576764,
-0.4168346822,
-0.3353299499,
-0.252332747,
-0.2400541902,
-0.6412574649,
0.423448503,
0.4842105508,
1.2970184088,
0.4637004435,
0.5229334235,
0.2166030258,
-0.4676195681,
-0.0190028995,
-0.3457585573,
0.2742567956,
-0.6119149923,
-0.5934903026,
-0.2692086101,
0.2589170933,
0.679097116,
0.6631253958,
-0.1450525075,
-0.2058242112,
0.3884047568,
0.4333183169,
-0.4284012616,
-0.054569535,
-0.931055665,
-0.093645148,
0.015563488,
-0.0718083009,
-0.5880900621,
-0.4204805791,
0.1604865938,
-0.1730351448,
-0.3171456754,
0.1592214257,
0.9869244695,
0.0369190872,
-0.744704783,
-0.3275482059,
-0.6042076945,
1.0726854801,
-0.738809526,
0.6530601382,
0.2918740511,
-0.0572028346,
-0.7078304291,
-0.2350905091,
-0.495105952,
-0.5429185629,
0.266351223,
0.0977470949,
0.0508603863,
0.065184392,
-0.0088690436,
0.0773960203,
-0.5577715635,
0.1593650877,
0.2632573247,
-0.2280180752,
0.455840677,
0.2540238798,
0.2910213768,
-0.5639595985,
-0.572599709,
0.1710688323,
-1.0997104645,
-0.0867913961,
0.5350233912,
0.5474283099,
-0.3057962954,
0.6966329813,
0.1305130273,
0.6658726931,
0.2095557451,
-0.4218628705,
-0.1909259856,
-0.3836596012,
0.0365309156,
-0.4055809081,
0.6911816597,
0.5666484237,
0.2882416844,
0.0399890505,
-0.2186723351,
0.0557399504,
-0.0316759609,
-0.447863251,
0.0372713767,
0.5187763572,
-0.5971003771,
-0.2688382268,
0.3122092485,
-0.5696175098,
-0.8129888773,
-0.4126792252,
-0.0995106027,
-0.2757219672,
-0.3957042694,
-0.1572749019,
0.0575386956,
0.4677895308,
0.2393773347,
-0.5003758669,
-0.0914595053,
0.9678609371,
0.927547276,
-0.5343203545,
-0.1975355893,
-0.6243472695,
-0.2159805596,
-0.498011142,
0.9805622697,
-0.838665843,
-0.4222354591,
0.3263665438,
0.3545042574,
0.1477310508,
-0.545958817,
0.6610376835,
-0.4210455418,
0.0393991396,
-0.7110282183,
-0.6421460509,
0.2027219832,
0.772513926,
-0.6953979731,
0.9825591445,
-0.2192122489,
-0.9420410395,
0.5976854563,
-0.2095782161,
0.0640046373,
-0.3387292922,
-0.4201085567,
-0.1040099487,
0.0930043831,
-0.3042998612,
0.5976138711,
-0.2194880396,
0.7191548944,
-1.0994244814,
-0.1412316114,
0.5534900427,
-0.7679392099,
0.9955642819,
-0.0738512874,
-0.4302251935,
0.2153199464,
-0.9459251165,
-0.2184388638,
-0.0435761921,
-0.4348292351,
-0.2974375188,
0.477835387,
0.0752091706,
0.4133001566,
0.3610232472,
-0.8136923313,
0.4339040518,
-0.2665238678,
0.4379284382,
1.1167861223,
0.0550925247,
0.3883048892,
-0.382209301,
0.3858601153,
0.0971874893,
0.2270420492,
0.1433460265,
-0.5097359419,
-0.5991620421,
0.1556830108,
0.0666302145,
0.9441402555,
-0.5688497424,
0.507815063,
-0.2900221944,
-0.3643402457,
0.2226105928,
0.1168877482,
0.1210817546,
0.1160664856,
-0.1470639706,
0.1400346011,
-0.4684160948,
-0.9699367881,
-0.5364408493,
-0.7640057802,
0.2135730386,
0.2549344003,
0.7964787483,
-0.2859203219,
0.9210201502,
0.1437189579,
0.4566062391,
-0.296114713,
-0.3122964203,
0.3334437907,
0.0868434384,
0.1429274082,
-0.6861426234,
-0.2700148821,
-0.1575541198,
-0.5429112911,
-0.0106794657,
-0.0530369319,
0.0925370157,
0.5392482281,
0.2236835808,
-0.6091024876,
0.1846802235,
0.8598936796,
-0.7676944137,
0.5494936705,
0.0475623719,
0.0636571869,
-1.1455715895,
-0.0851783454,
0.1028274745,
-0.3515123725,
-0.3665780127,
-0.1305311769,
-0.135489583,
0.3098597527,
-0.6027923822,
0.725518465,
-0.2441617548,
0.0157413911,
0.0085976748,
0.297861129,
-0.0718487278,
-0.2925084531,
-0.1977163702,
0.5643790364,
0.3567751348,
-0.320966959,
0.272577107,
0.0934412926,
-0.2977178693,
1.1041810513,
-0.6275439858,
0.1454781741,
-0.0313018896,
0.2536311746,
-1.1967948675,
-0.3870926201,
0.1123478636,
0.0384988412,
-0.0125795417,
-0.3384823203,
-0.6084205508,
-0.1122407168,
-0.3077255785,
-0.2264156938,
0.2754577696,
-0.538839817,
0.7169820666,
0.2499549389,
-0.2555635273,
-0.8570358157,
-0.5811538696,
0.1383447051,
-0.4274256825,
-0.6596385837,
0.001248061,
-0.1027409881,
-0.9295543432,
-0.09171433,
0.0146062961,
0.1957618296,
0.0669052228,
0.4853057265,
0.305224061,
0.0650297105,
0.1463127583,
-0.1963439435,
0.1031827331,
-0.0219406541,
-0.3136338294,
0.3528014421,
-0.3418625891,
-0.4818608165,
-0.4071704447,
0.4077637196,
1.0463593006,
0.1912005395,
0.7667781115,
0.0884910002,
-0.1718505919,
-0.0917050317,
-0.5527840257,
-0.0357964039,
-0.4540672302,
0.2111713141,
-0.2394058257,
-0.7820807099,
0.8219905496,
-0.0130556878,
0.3871080279,
0.4378588498,
0.5716702342,
-0.0708404854,
0.8929589391,
0.7225741744,
-0.1362704188,
0.1910850406,
0.1579304487,
-0.0906759053,
-0.3659391403,
-0.36409989,
-0.5477060676,
0.0034364448,
-0.7617515326,
-0.3019085526,
0.253102392,
-0.1765470654,
-0.5186038613,
-0.210025385,
-0.2743080556,
0.4615626037,
0.1307234764,
-0.0151456948,
0.2339726835,
-0.1024886444,
-0.3065812886,
-0.230913341,
-0.6687147021,
-1.0663248301,
0.9404524565,
0.455791831,
0.9935508966,
0.0851173401,
0.5143515468,
0.3868754208,
0.355761826,
-0.6723138094,
0.6942173243,
-0.0092376741,
-0.4772414267,
-0.2092192769,
-0.3344504833,
-0.758829236,
0.1044000834,
-0.34819749,
-0.5625920296,
0.3846898079,
0.1664927155,
-0.2079701126,
0.7390360832,
0.045966588,
0.5981611609,
-0.3884175122,
-0.518225193,
0.045967795,
-0.7038324475,
0.2039937675,
0.3237189651,
0.2511401176,
-0.3176726401,
-0.4689934552,
0.6025817394,
-0.1835519671,
1.0544518232,
-0.2522946298,
-0.6687145233,
0.2820703685,
0.1918783188,
0.7590202689,
0.1707015634,
-0.3745604455,
0.2165914476,
0.1718703955,
-0.4278510511,
-0.3549130857,
0.8289698362,
-0.776960969,
-0.6474383473,
-0.5028922558,
-0.6467268467,
-0.2383462042,
0.0935345069,
0.3253859878,
0.5375813842,
-0.6581534743,
0.3926880658,
0.9590989947,
-0.0599600635,
0.3626738787,
0.3202387393,
-0.283705771,
-0.486261487,
0.4407342076,
0.4760583043,
0.5566782951,
0.1059317663,
0.3352226913,
-0.4490349293,
-0.3246287704,
-0.4488402605,
0.1584859639,
-0.8292323947,
-0.0394376256,
-0.3129345179,
0.244550854,
0.1118145436,
-0.1621671617,
-0.5191299319,
-0.3254415393,
-0.1916380972,
-0.0321649499,
0.4087313712,
0.9895239472,
0.0243343133,
0.0147615438,
-0.6121688485,
-0.0971044376,
-0.0047104959,
0.3770486414,
-0.5020601153,
-0.621663034,
0.3167716861,
-0.0525623932,
-0.2297841907,
-1.3364073038,
-0.1489282101,
0.1824499369,
0.4090552926,
0.7152552009,
0.2318898886,
0.1754995137,
-0.6282568574,
1.2159899473,
-0.0118321339,
-0.7418236732,
0.42653355,
-0.5671972036,
0.0810789242,
0.5834673643,
0.5574012995,
-0.1947028339,
-0.7181604505,
-0.7795100212,
-0.5361596346,
0.0743869245,
-0.2852439582,
0.3845824599,
-0.1687500626,
0.53631109,
0.2292504162,
-0.1612848341,
-0.5959597826,
-0.2430605739,
-0.0129857305,
-0.1614912152,
0.0200538877,
-0.4443868697,
-0.4915241897,
0.2382117659,
0.5388884544,
-0.2741686106,
-0.018951416,
0.3576842248,
0.3579686284,
0.0838886425,
0.8125184774,
0.5800616145,
1.080611825,
-0.1109494492,
0.4399342239,
0.0664426014,
-0.2476693839,
0.6279824376,
-0.2539797425,
-0.2930023968,
0.2348754406,
0.3001126945,
0.3249213696,
-0.0096306521,
-0.4622030556,
0.598038137,
0.149572432,
-0.051948633,
-0.4029982686,
-0.0950921029,
0.2045412809,
0.2515114248,
0.1188948378,
0.0239886958,
-0.1923757941,
-1.0470237732,
0.2149332315,
0.8833965063,
-0.5368515849,
-0.4526109993,
0.4714543223,
0.2516438663,
-0.4137854278,
0.3715167046,
-0.2948866785,
-0.5457635522,
0.3762019277,
0.5417401791,
0.6603130102,
-0.1465398669,
0.2937262952,
-0.0355557911,
0.5957735181,
-0.1762384474,
0.7939302921,
0.4346403778,
-0.6433865428,
-0.3940695226,
-0.2256812453,
-0.8121972084,
0.0446262062,
-0.6527780294,
0.1513381898,
-0.612894237,
-0.6572936177,
-0.5615949631,
0.2749259174,
-0.2750745416,
0.0340525694,
-0.0059370999,
1.0897991657,
-1.281098485,
0.5543949008,
0.7364916205,
0.1175273061,
-0.7246639729,
0.2623419166,
0.4607032239,
-0.4637536705,
0.2762404382,
-0.0722268969,
-0.179286778,
-0.722489655,
-0.8904378414,
-0.8797649145,
0.8208451271,
0.6200350523,
-0.8365600705,
0.0299711321,
0.0706649348,
0.0591247417,
-0.2718676031,
0.0637426525,
0.5561066866,
0.6762137413,
-0.1447176188,
-0.8585637212,
0.158597663,
-0.0694825351,
-0.1592884064,
0.0575417988,
-0.9404655695,
0.726711154,
-0.2535177767,
-0.0718727037,
0.142566666,
0.7350361943,
0.7979714274,
0.2881349325,
0.7969429493,
0.3265306056,
0.9742753506,
-0.2522371709,
1.0438833237,
-0.7024219036,
0.2387264222,
0.8615490198,
-0.5754154921,
1.0189498663,
0.7360689044,
-0.0964453742,
0.8883225918,
0.6738907099,
0.0074710725,
0.0944069624,
-0.0278879907,
0.0162297934,
-0.4568088055,
-0.3014901876,
-0.0851978883,
0.2584963441,
0.2543101609,
-0.1068324745,
-0.0506653786,
-0.1682354659,
0.3576102853,
0.0846219435,
-0.1704676896,
0.4102969766,
0.3396994174,
-0.8025936484,
0.3893468082,
-0.2833196223,
0.7605670691,
-0.5306683779,
-0.0674997047,
-0.2465180904,
0.0478982255,
-0.4252443314,
-1.1554992199,
0.2816717625,
0.1029426455,
-0.2669563293,
-0.0072245141,
0.5745388865,
-0.0801908597,
-0.4412730634,
0.2736355662,
0.6636452079,
0.1467242986,
0.3239363432,
-0.899246037,
0.5239374042,
-0.041845087,
-0.5716007948,
0.1484616995,
0.5052828789,
-0.0228560288,
0.8790696263,
0.3491179347,
0.4023754001,
-0.1039945707,
-0.1908418089,
0.6057702899,
-0.4486833811,
-0.2201704979,
-0.9839376807,
0.5735898614,
-0.0759073049,
-0.3491608202,
0.9158143401,
0.3099288344,
0.4305628836,
0.4078059196,
0.6992384791,
-0.0963943601,
0.2432074249,
-0.6150379777,
0.5922725797,
-0.4927075505,
0.3501372337,
-0.086850509,
-1.034365654,
-0.246771872,
0.5351994634,
-0.4099985957,
-0.0140461437,
0.3452140987,
0.885473609,
-0.0753200799,
-0.2553983331,
0.2361678481,
0.3033592105,
0.2467505634,
0.3049786687,
1.2003949881,
0.1457101256,
0.4356232882,
0.0715592653,
-0.0352596268,
0.0134409266,
-1.155166626,
-0.8837339878,
-0.3030017316,
-0.3703893125,
-0.891320467,
0.1000149921,
1.103007555,
0.5890713334,
-0.6632124186,
-0.1846943945,
0.0252384041,
0.3486383259,
0.2699198425,
-0.2608111203,
0.4669103324,
-0.0241631605,
-0.5700985789,
0.2320006788,
0.4598003626,
-0.0211965851,
-0.7133209705,
-0.0863208994,
-0.0424114689,
0.6766426563,
0.4783782363,
0.2623194158,
-1.2272297144,
-0.7042251229,
0.1668054909,
-0.1892116368,
0.0968440697,
0.44489187,
-0.322773248,
0.1798479855,
0.4719197154,
0.2573866248,
-0.7415777445,
0.0531675294,
0.4770754874,
-0.2524521649,
0.1030974984,
0.2605338991,
0.5913582444,
0.6124272346,
-0.0169474371,
0.2619968057,
0.1580931991,
-0.8547641039,
-1.0898889303,
0.5380283594,
-0.9398204088,
0.0449519865,
1.5931318998,
-0.3494485021,
-0.1300813854,
-0.3250670731,
-0.0060206871,
-0.2192763239,
-0.2998768389,
0.3716504276,
0.8301947713,
-0.1668138504,
-0.0134699326,
-0.6034190655,
0.2379603386,
0.4016093314,
-0.4652442932,
0.1950935274,
0.4256146848,
0.5948919654,
0.250567466,
0.5211908221,
-0.1128617823,
-0.0684791952,
-0.0586102791,
-0.4482420683,
0.552325666,
-0.5072287321,
-0.5282421112,
0.2014538348,
0.3835383356,
0.3368692398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17645v1
|
SongComposer: A Large Language Model for Lyric and Melody Composition in Song Generation
| 2024-02-27T16:15:28 | 2024-02-27T16:15:28 |
Shuangrui Ding, Zihan Liu, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Rui Qian, Conghui He, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We present SongComposer, an innovative LLM designed for song composition. It
could understand and generate melodies and lyrics in symbolic song
representations, by leveraging the capability of LLM. Existing music-related
LLM treated the music as quantized audio signals, while such implicit encoding
leads to inefficient encoding and poor flexibility. In contrast, we resort to
symbolic song representation, the mature and efficient way humans designed for
music, and enable LLM to explicitly compose songs like humans. In practice, we
design a novel tuple design to format lyric and three note attributes (pitch,
duration, and rest duration) in the melody, which guarantees the correct LLM
understanding of musical symbols and realizes precise alignment between lyrics
and melody. To impart basic music understanding to LLM, we carefully collected
SongCompose-PT, a large-scale song pretraining dataset that includes lyrics,
melodies, and paired lyrics-melodies in either Chinese or English. After
adequate pre-training, 10K carefully crafted QA pairs are used to empower the
LLM with the instruction-following capability and solve diverse tasks. With
extensive experiments, SongComposer demonstrates superior performance in
lyric-to-melody generation, melody-to-lyric generation, song continuation, and
text-to-song creation, outperforming advanced LLMs like GPT-4.
|
[
-0.1506494284,
-0.3608772457,
0.3509665728,
0.9772499204,
-0.1996563822,
0.2627209127,
-0.2195134461,
-0.441190362,
0.262355119,
0.5951299667,
-0.6137478352,
-0.4918414652,
-0.2408587486,
-0.000014501,
-0.2560358047,
0.8862397075,
0.0081768129,
0.0586115457,
-0.3085547984,
0.1367992312,
-0.7655094266,
-0.3885990083,
-0.7619938254,
-0.3991604745,
0.6695293784,
0.380312413,
0.1495570242,
0.3540403247,
0.4455210865,
0.4016343057,
-0.0142766312,
-0.0204556677,
-0.6144836545,
0.2412580997,
0.2067774832,
-0.6540734172,
-0.6501472592,
0.4127723873,
0.6232510209,
0.5982171893,
-0.0633145571,
0.3697724938,
0.0548150688,
0.7685135007,
-0.1548045725,
0.1943935752,
-0.7110433578,
0.265907824,
-0.2782567143,
-0.2795262337,
-0.3193898201,
-0.6157928109,
0.1499103308,
-1.0297659636,
0.1233392581,
0.0700736493,
0.5023146868,
0.2266633511,
-0.1791196913,
-0.4370276034,
-0.8203597665,
0.7010983229,
-0.2476886213,
0.1703255177,
-0.0193105023,
0.5131595731,
-0.2490352988,
-0.9216877818,
-0.3080145717,
-0.2105300575,
0.1908302754,
0.4229457378,
0.1282496154,
0.0291104484,
0.3097683489,
0.6424819231,
-0.6713719368,
-0.330745697,
-0.2815733552,
-0.2619945705,
0.6849819422,
0.1426515728,
0.5138378143,
-0.1694852263,
-0.5723560452,
-0.0025339839,
-1.0274456739,
0.118896462,
0.4617700577,
0.15891473,
-0.1902476102,
0.5661548376,
0.3808907866,
0.7301528454,
0.3313922882,
-0.2731557488,
0.1148288324,
-0.1547065228,
-0.181404382,
0.3550632894,
1.0166656971,
0.1024640799,
0.1144790649,
-0.3343153298,
-0.4272143841,
0.0438088961,
0.1186709702,
-0.6584133506,
-0.4608787298,
0.0901961699,
-0.3940438032,
-0.0965093523,
0.1957368702,
-0.3719100654,
-0.3748966455,
-0.6277054548,
0.9342474341,
-0.6384485364,
-0.0927065313,
0.1660553366,
-0.3057631552,
0.0043993914,
-0.0781299099,
-0.9308954477,
0.1139909402,
0.7639586926,
0.9078160524,
-0.0861032382,
-0.3869570196,
-0.5019168258,
0.5897254348,
-0.3090626001,
0.672242105,
-0.1644541174,
-0.4327186644,
-0.2593014836,
-0.1106492728,
-0.2418477684,
-0.7320361137,
0.3519079387,
-0.3710863292,
0.4288463593,
-0.3111621141,
-0.7030681968,
-0.2219825983,
-0.1542725712,
-1.0507894754,
0.6058300734,
0.3689517677,
-0.5995310545,
0.2599311173,
-0.6520485282,
-0.6408399343,
0.1538808346,
-0.1354430169,
-0.483366698,
0.4885495901,
-0.0997341946,
0.3227009475,
-0.2720519304,
0.1566517055,
0.1054669023,
-0.7731269598,
0.4898208976,
-0.0886661857,
0.6747307181,
0.4346864223,
-0.0273302309,
0.1694229543,
-0.824441433,
-0.0519983061,
0.3597645462,
-0.560151875,
-0.2320938408,
-0.0117738042,
0.508952558,
0.2014030516,
0.5511800051,
-0.4724313319,
-0.0172451008,
-0.3742538393,
0.7521691918,
0.5298801064,
-0.1310766786,
0.5232386589,
-0.6990434527,
0.7983212471,
-0.3115281761,
-0.0519271791,
-0.2007800341,
-0.1259930581,
-0.4211155176,
-0.0833558217,
0.364469707,
0.2202712744,
-0.3532997966,
0.5479747057,
-0.3041469455,
-0.3385570347,
-0.4685698748,
0.3593595326,
0.3124334216,
0.2260098457,
0.1037954465,
-0.1620167494,
-0.9084767699,
-0.5351625085,
-0.2014673352,
-0.1633370072,
-0.2595731318,
-0.0589859113,
-0.0106308889,
0.2468741089,
0.8139638305,
-0.2897050977,
-0.7100690603,
-0.8056854606,
0.0435367338,
0.280218631,
0.6661427021,
0.6039769053,
-0.6978755593,
-0.4901964068,
-0.2605354488,
-0.4959326982,
-0.5115981102,
-0.3687656224,
-0.2708036602,
-0.1307466626,
0.3797318041,
-0.6027829051,
-0.6802082658,
0.7885785103,
-0.3397216499,
0.3888561726,
0.0838063806,
-0.034967415,
-1.2269227505,
0.1753254831,
-0.1740918458,
-0.0130398199,
-0.5754340291,
-0.1323425025,
-0.0099611972,
-0.1784459054,
-0.3725586832,
0.0467026867,
-0.4552168846,
-0.1787541658,
-0.3777426481,
0.2744431794,
0.2334723622,
0.1958494931,
0.1929444373,
0.7572157979,
0.2556364834,
-0.2112326473,
0.4482397139,
0.236498639,
-0.5570285916,
0.7850451469,
-0.8847440481,
0.1673777252,
-0.0240877941,
0.2004418969,
-0.9110456705,
-0.2642307281,
-0.0042555388,
-0.3988806605,
0.3927365839,
-0.1144427657,
-0.5294979811,
-0.4731911719,
0.0339943133,
0.3780118525,
0.3974395692,
-0.3973886967,
0.6834647655,
0.3634102643,
-0.1385205835,
0.1238797605,
-0.5887153149,
0.0842469186,
-0.6151103377,
-0.7941069007,
0.5630260706,
-0.0672658235,
-0.0146310003,
-0.1689588279,
-0.3295645714,
0.3589417934,
0.1255387813,
0.4577721059,
0.1805481166,
-0.2528096437,
0.3584676385,
-0.1559630632,
-0.343865335,
0.3672508597,
-0.4469735026,
0.9374704361,
0.1731911153,
-0.1896345019,
-0.2329627126,
0.5377560854,
0.3762590289,
-0.4044547081,
0.106912069,
0.4135175645,
-0.0018098515,
-0.2737122476,
-0.3896535635,
0.2726548612,
-0.5191994905,
0.3566033542,
-0.5241425037,
-0.8464736342,
0.4622887373,
-0.2012251765,
0.2440165281,
0.3532503545,
0.3768492937,
-0.4755960107,
0.9205667377,
0.6928313375,
-0.1649915874,
0.6963903308,
-0.547996521,
-0.3390099704,
-0.9166959524,
-0.3772013187,
-0.3312870264,
-0.8263503909,
-0.4734880924,
-0.2538987994,
0.4255723059,
0.0057252282,
-0.6395611763,
0.2423194796,
-0.6245595813,
0.4900636375,
0.62842381,
-0.0300191045,
0.109484829,
-0.2152117789,
0.0153694972,
-0.0686791167,
-0.4508551955,
-0.3297389746,
1.0739504099,
0.2145659775,
0.89893502,
0.0229731761,
0.9857017398,
-0.1744009852,
-0.0670282394,
-0.9573820233,
0.4454790652,
-0.4041178226,
-0.4271113873,
-0.0573098809,
-0.339243561,
-0.7094448209,
0.1101528481,
-0.0400251672,
-0.4326885939,
-0.3427650332,
0.0958802551,
-0.396153152,
0.0542440712,
-0.7081714869,
0.9303866029,
-0.6040704846,
0.0398448035,
0.0710640326,
-0.372338295,
0.4211804569,
-0.1852497458,
-0.0463424884,
-0.2265244871,
-0.1070276722,
0.8211526275,
-0.2477153987,
0.7165207863,
-0.2626847923,
-0.4053917229,
0.2069837451,
0.1453103274,
0.3169459701,
-0.0992558748,
0.0721900612,
-0.2847800851,
-0.2390048802,
-0.1820919961,
-0.5838297009,
0.8073966503,
-0.8600242138,
-0.6663678885,
-0.1165421605,
-0.8965956569,
-0.2731528878,
0.0272519346,
0.5112110376,
0.2204148471,
-0.1923280954,
0.331671685,
0.4760900438,
-0.0852841809,
0.3967487514,
0.2415061444,
-0.2987832725,
-0.7656825781,
0.9875484109,
-0.0248130616,
0.35216254,
0.6205356717,
0.3393526077,
-0.4668557644,
-0.5284752846,
-0.3626018763,
0.2467049509,
-0.3742601275,
0.0171461273,
-0.3757617474,
-0.286426127,
0.1140405908,
-0.0746065527,
-0.3232871294,
-0.460318923,
-0.1529808491,
0.1672489345,
0.5246166587,
0.5895726681,
-0.0847578496,
0.6165604591,
-0.8116931319,
0.5689122081,
0.4249094427,
0.3340010345,
-0.1923393607,
-0.4606795907,
-0.3654785156,
-0.1862119883,
-0.4938309789,
-0.8084310889,
0.1777796894,
0.3243261576,
0.3948936164,
0.5064135194,
-0.2974644005,
0.8146295547,
-0.5640119314,
0.7816897035,
0.4407871068,
-1.014351368,
0.6752387285,
-0.3629429638,
0.251763761,
0.3870920241,
0.0501520596,
-0.8320448399,
-0.4213456511,
-0.060418576,
-0.7710003853,
0.5562772155,
0.3000549376,
0.1553112715,
0.2789618373,
0.2863301039,
0.167568326,
0.1823802888,
-0.7616973519,
-0.2817393243,
-0.7336401343,
-0.4922835231,
-0.4389949441,
-0.0281622019,
-0.0615425631,
-0.0639980435,
0.47392115,
-0.0928571299,
0.2479428649,
-0.0166163296,
0.0527092516,
-0.363684386,
0.1449560374,
0.2800384462,
0.34880355,
0.014297192,
0.126213789,
-0.2956757843,
-0.6795540452,
0.3968897462,
0.2256737947,
-0.4363952577,
-0.2455736697,
0.3740464449,
0.7392237782,
0.4031768739,
-0.5348711014,
0.2431821227,
0.019007653,
-0.2035205662,
-0.627766192,
0.2974255979,
0.7320153117,
0.1771067828,
0.2947199643,
-0.2743682563,
0.0662537664,
-0.3550511897,
0.1064252481,
0.4221494496,
-0.5533720851,
-0.4471875727,
1.154545784,
-0.0305660386,
-0.1712161452,
0.2457839549,
0.1435133368,
-0.3324111402,
0.6407296062,
0.9910084009,
1.0693768263,
-0.2337575853,
0.2672155201,
0.1471210122,
-0.1118217781,
0.1729627103,
0.7742198706,
-0.0931341723,
-0.3959031999,
-0.6748560667,
-0.7618547082,
0.0163563602,
0.397259593,
-0.4202306569,
0.0270916559,
-0.4230404198,
0.0171504188,
0.1394812018,
0.3009791672,
-0.3748663068,
0.0536600314,
0.0367201976,
0.8697541356,
-0.7869952917,
0.683827281,
0.9423172474,
-0.6026900411,
-1.1850762367,
-0.0245379694,
0.1400535852,
-0.5668976307,
0.6760843992,
0.3258331418,
0.0335391909,
0.2479939014,
-0.5678957105,
-0.6755642295,
1.2542630434,
0.4088189304,
-0.7989732623,
0.030543793,
0.5948428512,
0.5554437041,
-0.4100020826,
-0.2841568887,
0.5642215014,
0.455257684,
0.647349894,
-0.5148938894,
-0.0967375562,
-0.4060265124,
0.1873787791,
0.2641311288,
-0.8467740417,
0.954144299,
0.0841224417,
-0.219663471,
0.6925037503,
0.6723455787,
0.6845299602,
0.1646311283,
0.4935947061,
0.5374653339,
0.4708503187,
-0.3950791657,
0.709677279,
-0.2901620567,
-0.1878528297,
1.1932146549,
-0.2400485724,
0.4420820475,
0.5104700923,
-0.1694615781,
0.1840192676,
0.6368676424,
-0.0661399961,
0.5094075799,
0.6524792314,
-0.4748910069,
-0.540602684,
-0.1100488529,
-0.2237209529,
0.7496334314,
0.190376848,
-0.4351328313,
0.0964223966,
-0.0898860842,
-0.2814590633,
0.2923508883,
-0.3487372696,
0.9968690276,
0.3189662695,
-0.5563650131,
0.1973209381,
-0.3789651394,
0.4712771475,
-0.6222424507,
0.032150846,
-0.2354241759,
0.0915826112,
-0.111679472,
-0.837256372,
-0.0910976455,
-0.2727466822,
-0.0530964322,
-0.1269685328,
0.4645383656,
-0.5858358145,
-0.5138770938,
0.1654138863,
0.443161875,
-0.1460341662,
-0.2585400045,
-0.5135961771,
0.0760605782,
-0.1912385821,
0.0428641401,
0.1609723568,
0.8258168697,
0.1142275035,
0.5554563999,
0.6195030212,
0.6334396005,
0.150319159,
0.5797497034,
0.663883388,
-0.8956118822,
-0.6388383508,
-0.4941613674,
0.3357287645,
0.0781823918,
0.0460007228,
0.5417422652,
0.9276453853,
0.8046662211,
-0.3584744334,
1.0494197607,
-0.0387322493,
0.4429836571,
-0.6664069295,
0.7921651006,
-0.5947886109,
0.3279607892,
-0.5000215769,
-1.1913170815,
-0.2438647598,
0.452082783,
0.1182382405,
-0.0011271804,
0.197471261,
0.4115328193,
-0.1353531331,
0.2440808713,
0.2003605813,
-0.018015692,
0.3842128515,
1.1920087337,
1.3748948574,
-0.3333751559,
0.6573372483,
-0.4471081495,
0.1147449017,
0.1609681398,
-0.685723424,
-0.8439526558,
-0.6175724864,
-0.1328406185,
0.2042354792,
-0.2685136795,
1.0313607454,
0.4894427061,
-0.7295339108,
-0.4970420599,
-0.1902303249,
0.0790790245,
-0.4492494762,
-0.2081074119,
0.445622772,
-0.3895693123,
-0.9219676852,
0.3577897847,
0.1606406718,
0.321031332,
-0.421659261,
-0.3559834957,
0.4880978465,
-0.1323955655,
0.6703388691,
0.034890309,
-0.6844995022,
-0.2201653719,
0.1832420826,
-0.0507804304,
0.129209429,
1.1898750067,
-0.4072920382,
0.3756720126,
0.650660634,
0.1173942611,
0.1820592135,
0.0099700466,
0.801554203,
-0.5671328306,
-0.1230505332,
0.0980285183,
0.4995242655,
0.2998212576,
-0.0482613146,
0.3093927801,
0.099593088,
-0.4392965436,
-0.1553954929,
0.2544412613,
-1.3519164324,
0.0390035473,
1.0072716475,
-0.2008292973,
-0.0227014665,
-0.0476047918,
-0.57698524,
0.4355698824,
-0.2849809527,
0.8238538504,
0.2927207649,
-0.0002590141,
-0.2255202234,
-0.3719326258,
0.5657250881,
-0.1156939119,
-0.527315259,
0.023317581,
0.7566204071,
0.3380875885,
0.1304656863,
0.453204751,
-0.4276837111,
0.5906005502,
-0.1460998058,
0.2654270232,
-0.3378981352,
-0.1915807575,
-0.0824741274,
0.496530354,
0.1863669306,
-0.4384934008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17644v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17644v2
|
Are LLMs Capable of Data-based Statistical and Causal Reasoning? Benchmarking Advanced Quantitative Reasoning with Data
| 2024-02-27T16:15:03 | 2024-06-09T13:54:09 |
Xiao Liu, Zirui Wu, Xueqing Wu, Pan Lu, Kai-Wei Chang, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Quantitative reasoning is a critical skill to analyze data, yet the
assessment of such ability remains limited. To address this gap, we introduce
the Quantitative Reasoning with Data (QRData) benchmark, aiming to evaluate
Large Language Models' capability in statistical and causal reasoning with
real-world data. The benchmark comprises a carefully constructed dataset of 411
questions accompanied by data sheets from textbooks, online learning materials,
and academic papers. To compare models' quantitative reasoning abilities on
data and text, we enrich the benchmark with an auxiliary set of 290 text-only
questions, namely QRText. We evaluate natural language reasoning, program-based
reasoning, and agent reasoning methods including Chain-of-Thought,
Program-of-Thoughts, ReAct, and code interpreter assistants on diverse models.
The strongest model GPT-4 achieves an accuracy of 58%, which has much room for
improvement. Among open-source models, Deepseek-coder-instruct, a code LLM
pretrained on 2T tokens, gets the highest accuracy of 37%. Analysis reveals
that models encounter difficulties in data analysis and causal reasoning, and
struggle in using causal knowledge and provided data simultaneously. Code and
data are in https://github.com/xxxiaol/QRData.
|
[
-0.0192987118,
-0.7457659245,
0.9093055725,
0.247117579,
-0.0417416766,
0.2215139121,
-0.0179183949,
-0.3412175775,
-0.4994089901,
0.3865202665,
-0.5036653876,
-0.6843633652,
-0.1696838737,
0.1627010405,
-0.4062941968,
0.6525418162,
-0.073761262,
0.4817667007,
-0.5009870529,
-0.1892528683,
-0.6158559918,
-0.5709836483,
-0.568127811,
-0.1656541526,
0.5643817782,
0.4255106747,
0.8138760328,
0.5619767308,
0.7625252604,
0.2266032249,
0.2152139544,
0.3371600509,
-0.5887743831,
0.3192537427,
-0.4591310024,
-0.7034917474,
-0.551774323,
0.1049255878,
0.7422266603,
0.5363968015,
-0.0306350421,
0.35341084,
-0.2659607232,
0.7023798227,
-0.5465239882,
0.2467913479,
-0.6723162532,
-0.215094775,
0.1104555652,
-0.1322397888,
-0.4206113517,
-1.0474541187,
-0.1204566285,
-0.63878268,
-0.0224034283,
0.2312268764,
0.7433238626,
0.6743097305,
-0.7355827689,
-0.075627327,
-0.7181402445,
0.7907884121,
-0.6347227693,
0.6654227972,
0.5518345237,
0.6787727475,
-0.2513557076,
-0.7860178947,
-0.4834856391,
-0.5182366371,
0.1934815049,
0.0940216631,
-0.4685026109,
-0.2121023387,
0.5948380232,
0.0038655514,
-0.9215189815,
0.0939237922,
-0.3389499187,
-0.0357693583,
0.6789764762,
0.5379632115,
0.0795465112,
0.1504568905,
-0.4465329349,
-0.1798687726,
-0.9076403975,
-0.1871871352,
0.2941133082,
0.0230716839,
-0.0980601162,
0.6424351335,
-0.4622952044,
0.460339427,
-0.4740277827,
0.2372160256,
-0.0374410152,
-0.3766821027,
-0.2791468799,
-0.3788084388,
0.6890000105,
0.276695013,
0.6567205191,
-0.2539966702,
-0.0623696893,
0.236090973,
0.1508431584,
-0.7248208523,
-0.3833982348,
0.3467229903,
-0.0918863788,
-0.0031371682,
-0.1964730769,
-0.6465235949,
-0.3871249855,
-0.4714117348,
0.4267189503,
-0.2638056874,
-0.0572667792,
0.3167823553,
-0.0670629889,
0.2804340124,
0.3983637989,
-0.3772372901,
0.4608244002,
0.7540352345,
0.5848594904,
-0.0963439941,
-0.2239101082,
-0.469519645,
0.1082717031,
-0.564195931,
1.2460889816,
-0.3090103567,
-0.0581943281,
-0.2400997579,
-0.288625747,
-0.0483987145,
-0.6847957373,
0.6550015807,
-0.6807307601,
-0.0073848651,
-0.4620550573,
-0.8227974176,
-0.203866303,
0.2063124329,
-0.6999912858,
1.1634502411,
0.1041510254,
-0.6738359332,
0.5617461205,
-0.0152392471,
-0.0036142529,
0.0041078008,
-0.4052723646,
-0.4597785175,
-0.3024798334,
0.0686449483,
0.4110893011,
-1.0377469063,
0.7737081051,
-0.7571314573,
-0.3927758634,
0.7135322094,
-0.5054956079,
0.6947699785,
0.1765480489,
-0.255486846,
0.1931938082,
-1.0701289177,
0.3481164873,
0.0994089395,
-0.211592108,
-0.104551971,
0.0982282981,
-0.1789696366,
0.1603583395,
-0.035570275,
-0.1527974904,
0.3703786135,
0.2289457917,
0.271694243,
0.6734659672,
-0.056258902,
0.1238924786,
-0.3172852099,
0.618690908,
-0.2116625905,
0.1109882146,
0.3826722503,
-0.4872026742,
-0.4671823382,
-0.3365717232,
0.3075037301,
0.8359988332,
-0.8280929923,
0.0919662118,
-0.2237005532,
-0.6391228437,
-0.369948566,
-0.0577542372,
0.5201719999,
0.6269159913,
0.4261654317,
0.1422086507,
-0.508261025,
-0.8672330379,
-0.4511213601,
-0.4589298368,
-0.0369969346,
0.0566298664,
0.6673475504,
-0.1343783885,
0.9557030201,
-0.6729341149,
0.2388608456,
-0.0950595737,
0.1181558222,
0.1706613004,
0.3039663434,
0.2693465948,
-0.6870071888,
-0.1740420461,
-0.1361997128,
-1.2525037527,
-0.528275311,
0.109399274,
-0.273599714,
-0.2172276378,
0.5985003114,
-0.5932451487,
0.3851239681,
0.2160629332,
-0.5185396075,
0.9617542624,
-0.2584659755,
0.2670333087,
-0.5896051526,
0.1186358854,
0.1113454625,
-0.0933532417,
-0.7219147086,
-0.0854745284,
0.3397597373,
-0.0099381115,
-0.3265117109,
0.8414306641,
-0.3197858334,
-0.3717954457,
-0.1129230708,
-0.1237354875,
0.1007189453,
0.3513942361,
-0.0286280792,
0.9821398854,
0.4587602317,
-0.594552815,
0.5099893212,
0.1994687319,
-0.5836883187,
0.522862792,
-0.8250114918,
0.0837615281,
0.1266405284,
0.1783193201,
-1.008182168,
-0.0776191726,
0.1386505216,
-0.4555769861,
-0.1267248392,
-0.0577334017,
-0.7837373614,
-0.2290536761,
-0.0683917552,
0.5743693709,
0.39393875,
-0.3480808437,
0.2458541542,
0.1378543079,
-0.0703758448,
-0.4275189936,
-0.6179889441,
0.0187106524,
-0.4512241781,
-0.5215842128,
-0.0723882169,
-0.1976048201,
-0.7391277552,
0.0908731297,
0.0359843113,
-0.5239983201,
0.0482037291,
-0.0354983583,
0.3050696552,
-0.2565833926,
0.4436597526,
0.0059516747,
-0.3342162669,
0.1801924556,
-0.1230263263,
0.1706564277,
-0.1571238786,
-0.4218367338,
-0.3941419721,
0.1177854091,
0.430311501,
-0.2098763436,
0.5953580737,
0.4958007038,
-0.2652426958,
-0.1047436744,
-0.6834890246,
-0.0689202994,
-0.3795146942,
0.2157040089,
-0.4621787369,
-0.9291526675,
0.6975006461,
-0.0027030187,
-0.2879755497,
0.2586370409,
0.6520245075,
0.022011295,
1.079588294,
0.1608862728,
-0.0397173353,
0.113828145,
-0.1605034769,
-0.0038633114,
-0.5285050273,
-0.1525037587,
-0.6653236151,
0.1733454913,
-0.5750138164,
-0.65936625,
0.3656308055,
0.1439026296,
-0.8588863015,
0.0814065114,
-0.1695091277,
0.2645044625,
0.6548309922,
0.2566037774,
0.4746437669,
-0.3715436459,
0.1195597127,
0.04435746,
-0.6644837856,
-0.719969213,
1.1683756113,
0.3737127781,
0.9660187364,
0.0863089114,
0.3622792065,
0.3888419569,
0.2358201146,
-0.4632978141,
0.7888929248,
0.180940792,
-0.5666223168,
-0.2329119146,
-0.8766707778,
-0.7326802611,
0.3599120378,
-0.0926117972,
-0.5137489438,
0.35620597,
0.0402561836,
-0.2929780185,
0.1375611722,
-0.7492141724,
0.865000844,
-0.3752425909,
-0.851680398,
-0.1967331022,
-0.3959906697,
0.5477612615,
-0.1150586084,
0.3149867058,
-0.5759869814,
-0.1112993434,
0.66681844,
-0.4611473978,
0.7774634957,
-0.114937596,
-0.1511926055,
0.4768734574,
0.1639790833,
0.505674243,
0.1138718501,
-0.3181038201,
0.1366423517,
0.2171907276,
-0.6287097335,
-0.757275939,
0.271653831,
-0.5623468161,
-0.5198251605,
-0.4447726011,
-0.4985872507,
-0.4961772263,
0.0078541525,
-0.2310059965,
0.4275282919,
-0.1850427538,
0.0146824503,
0.577530086,
-0.2082698643,
-0.1889714301,
0.7833939195,
-0.0310610197,
-0.5270938873,
0.7435120344,
-0.0024034155,
0.300715059,
0.4851061404,
0.360943526,
-0.4477653801,
-0.4853687286,
-0.428503722,
0.2198885381,
-0.7849686742,
-0.4676297903,
-0.4714560807,
0.0742867813,
-0.2517188489,
0.2531618476,
-0.1010961756,
-0.4827637374,
-0.0405978933,
-0.1706367433,
0.6191712618,
0.7403500676,
-0.1144822687,
0.1078521684,
-0.6771235466,
0.4621199369,
0.5676304698,
0.2000945657,
0.0082098171,
-0.3371386528,
-0.3425771594,
-0.0230415035,
0.0434901081,
-1.0156728029,
0.3488242328,
-0.1772551388,
0.5996325612,
0.225873217,
-0.083560057,
0.5210832953,
-0.4422447681,
0.4113394916,
-0.1866113245,
-0.773223877,
0.3822300732,
-0.5907796621,
0.1920565367,
0.5710052848,
0.4596948922,
-0.1023681685,
-0.425011754,
-0.2577756941,
-0.487151891,
0.3031054139,
0.2056575716,
-0.586275816,
-0.0451805182,
0.3932723999,
0.043471273,
0.2014088929,
-0.5172232985,
0.0737729222,
0.152580604,
-0.1863515526,
-0.042462945,
-0.2509019077,
0.0943930075,
-0.4671671391,
0.4059859216,
-0.2869165242,
0.1352182627,
0.003177024,
-0.0365248509,
0.0903786719,
0.2338085175,
0.4976001084,
0.9697020054,
-0.3097531497,
0.226845026,
0.2245507389,
-0.3717020154,
0.3980654776,
0.2083947808,
0.0456719734,
-0.433742404,
0.5594727397,
0.4894901514,
0.5974522829,
-1.0282533169,
0.2346933633,
-0.2648284137,
-0.1800070107,
-0.0400388315,
0.0526503175,
0.1420211047,
0.673283577,
0.4186468124,
-0.5725386739,
0.2342955172,
-0.6155162454,
0.2168385834,
0.296256572,
-0.0451818109,
-0.2579775751,
0.9220636487,
-0.2360733002,
0.214099735,
0.6280683279,
-0.1768880337,
-0.4405565858,
0.9394848347,
0.322938621,
0.7077892423,
-0.1623267829,
0.2035578787,
0.3756432831,
0.2870730758,
-0.2477313876,
0.6918804049,
-0.0000087895,
-0.8271148205,
-0.4839628041,
-0.282592088,
-0.9060134292,
-0.2342891693,
-0.780310452,
0.1123104393,
-0.2703671753,
-0.2031057477,
-0.0121446103,
0.1599456072,
-0.8076736927,
0.5509805083,
-0.3936847448,
0.7961812615,
-0.9970930815,
0.9997839332,
0.4664620757,
-0.5815734267,
-0.7516214848,
-0.2829948366,
-0.0405942202,
-0.9823725224,
0.8706432581,
-0.2622829974,
0.0024500983,
0.0233483724,
-0.5959021449,
-0.8698094487,
1.1033111811,
0.4426910579,
-0.5567496419,
0.260425806,
0.1667499393,
0.7001190782,
-0.0400017612,
0.5433914065,
0.8359131813,
0.5668674707,
-0.0846643597,
-0.7245877981,
0.1984128058,
-0.102394633,
-0.2317908406,
0.0909884796,
-0.6653545499,
0.95782727,
-0.1963587254,
-0.1199871451,
-0.0073538423,
0.7790592313,
0.6094297171,
0.704858005,
0.136047557,
0.6450431347,
1.0492683649,
-0.0403679051,
1.0263268948,
-0.0881422311,
0.1745670736,
1.2105953693,
-0.76689291,
0.9087083936,
0.1896325946,
-0.5576822758,
0.4625129402,
0.6938186288,
-0.1484092176,
0.4302729666,
0.355071187,
-0.2705997825,
-0.3410245776,
0.0293205511,
-0.399402827,
0.2490353435,
0.3001219034,
0.1034219712,
-0.0980082825,
-0.2357293069,
-0.0566243343,
0.1408101022,
-0.2381497175,
0.6324007511,
0.2535327971,
-0.3991296887,
0.6214780211,
-0.2175371349,
0.0491404496,
-0.5405822396,
-0.1123188138,
-0.4198377728,
0.1520060301,
-0.0830311924,
-0.9352834821,
0.2418358624,
0.2385001332,
-0.0379468016,
-0.0090570562,
0.750850141,
-0.2763830423,
-0.5091104507,
0.2162454873,
0.9832761288,
0.3601954281,
-0.1336124986,
-0.6304687858,
0.0588016324,
-0.266802907,
-0.1088851839,
0.2624410391,
0.6696873903,
-0.3895377219,
1.1147792339,
0.6417341232,
0.1803455353,
0.0764688402,
0.4595132768,
0.9606041312,
-1.0345336199,
-0.322568357,
-0.8793162107,
0.1238602176,
0.061306145,
-0.2634801567,
0.9249058366,
0.7053533196,
0.54957968,
0.1144317091,
0.6672880054,
0.4275610447,
0.7115696669,
-0.8150889874,
0.4903016388,
-0.3356852233,
0.2181083262,
-0.1576750427,
-0.783366859,
-0.3080893755,
0.4263698161,
-0.7331081629,
0.210600391,
0.7653136849,
0.7354071736,
0.1355955452,
0.0018660378,
0.486477375,
0.1854784936,
0.3322229087,
0.6277447939,
1.2287898064,
-0.271258831,
0.3700466454,
0.0368866138,
-0.2409920543,
-0.0261301789,
-0.8631131649,
-0.8739765882,
-0.3462472856,
-0.3673151731,
-0.1491800398,
0.4167244434,
0.5554727316,
0.4354495108,
-0.5895032287,
-0.3860583603,
-0.1976819783,
0.3504138291,
-0.190427348,
-0.2742643058,
0.517077446,
-0.1580185741,
-0.2892302573,
0.4838379622,
0.2250017971,
-0.0150131611,
-0.299256444,
0.0911752507,
-0.1319382042,
0.135724768,
0.524535656,
0.281768471,
-0.3108016551,
-0.1513036042,
-0.0077964868,
-0.2365661711,
-0.1283742785,
0.9823142886,
-0.8218058944,
0.1887848973,
0.6566308141,
0.5282078385,
0.4329022169,
0.1822396517,
0.6814968586,
-0.1440183222,
0.0083950981,
0.3300428092,
0.2576394081,
0.1982650906,
-0.2034372538,
0.8056002855,
0.0681701005,
-0.8680298924,
-1.0382730961,
0.0572965853,
-0.7819852829,
-0.3097841144,
1.1416479349,
-0.1194756776,
-0.1215284541,
-0.308234483,
-0.0347908847,
0.2913590968,
-0.1694455892,
0.5642825365,
0.4873872995,
-0.275262922,
-0.228990823,
-1.1006048918,
0.4440020025,
0.39172104,
-1.329657793,
0.1301550418,
0.6135940552,
0.1454875916,
-0.6765626669,
0.7891270518,
0.0796703622,
0.4626057446,
0.2252248526,
0.0273260679,
0.1294951737,
-0.3894344568,
-0.3071704209,
-0.103209652,
0.0672098249,
0.0696494505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17641v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17641v2
|
Variational Learning is Effective for Large Deep Networks
| 2024-02-27T16:11:05 | 2024-06-06T04:31:43 |
Yuesong Shen, Nico Daheim, Bai Cong, Peter Nickl, Gian Maria Marconi, Clement Bazan, Rio Yokota, Iryna Gurevych, Daniel Cremers, Mohammad Emtiyaz Khan, Thomas Möllenhoff
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML
|
We give extensive empirical evidence against the common belief that
variational learning is ineffective for large neural networks. We show that an
optimizer called Improved Variational Online Newton (IVON) consistently matches
or outperforms Adam for training large networks such as GPT-2 and ResNets from
scratch. IVON's computational costs are nearly identical to Adam but its
predictive uncertainty is better. We show several new use cases of IVON where
we improve finetuning and model merging in Large Language Models, accurately
predict generalization error, and faithfully estimate sensitivity to data. We
find overwhelming evidence that variational learning is effective.
|
[
-0.3663928211,
-0.433403194,
0.3766104877,
-0.0286847632,
-0.1893891245,
0.3557480872,
-0.5097125769,
-0.5737605691,
0.0881846622,
-0.1337985396,
-0.0727379471,
-0.1913830787,
-0.562562108,
0.1514273435,
-0.4012054503,
0.6629154682,
0.06292101,
0.4596166611,
-0.1454969794,
-0.1594255567,
0.2081378847,
0.002737222,
-1.1005028486,
-0.4842586517,
0.9339435101,
-0.1582055986,
0.6339558363,
0.5239482522,
0.6172260046,
0.3493447006,
-0.4611865878,
0.366882503,
-0.6008943915,
0.1579604298,
-0.1577530205,
-0.6467947364,
0.0408713706,
-0.5186813474,
0.8631595373,
0.9492925406,
-0.5079494715,
-0.5045132041,
0.1904949248,
0.8459336758,
-0.5588043332,
-0.2498727739,
-0.694329083,
0.343642205,
-0.1178719103,
0.4233936071,
-0.0204846021,
-0.4495188892,
0.3175404072,
-0.8114383817,
0.3063112497,
-0.0439951681,
0.8428179026,
0.247445032,
-0.4151803851,
-0.0172299445,
-0.9650272727,
0.8801235557,
-0.8142092228,
0.3339556158,
0.3927012086,
0.3539898694,
-0.3101892769,
-0.8514128923,
-0.3353405893,
-0.5910032988,
0.3958119452,
0.2639365494,
-0.0682011321,
0.4672181308,
0.3931374848,
0.8151966929,
-0.3977321386,
0.3983417749,
-0.4123089015,
0.0309714302,
0.5413171649,
-0.0612174459,
0.0839020982,
0.4462955296,
-0.2293730378,
-0.1378644854,
-0.7780689001,
0.1379885674,
0.7956497669,
0.2054320425,
0.0465128571,
0.358948797,
0.0913941115,
0.724650085,
0.1273243576,
0.0705129504,
0.1948709786,
0.1093723476,
-0.252938509,
-0.3924835622,
0.7320626378,
0.0844440982,
-0.1022391841,
-0.3721114695,
-0.3487023413,
-0.486451447,
0.2613671422,
-0.7851271033,
-0.2745088935,
0.1645226181,
-0.2619324923,
-0.2182884812,
0.1802280098,
-0.4718123078,
-0.566601932,
-0.4078708887,
0.1423284262,
-0.4794797897,
-0.1951446533,
-0.1364173889,
-0.0525562316,
0.1202192754,
0.545770824,
-0.9129654169,
0.3527601957,
0.7291295528,
1.0275988579,
-0.4085950255,
-0.2165585011,
-0.4431771338,
-0.4438059926,
-0.785433948,
0.4717175663,
-0.2651410401,
-0.0729955509,
0.0409985296,
-0.2512362897,
-0.0396338366,
-0.767421186,
0.3076183498,
-0.6045640111,
-0.0971543342,
-0.0551640391,
-0.9420319796,
-0.3309232295,
0.2838145792,
-0.8426306248,
0.6358702779,
0.2661021054,
-0.5369335413,
0.4224644899,
-0.5586276054,
-0.5292043686,
-0.0553290546,
-0.2938756347,
-0.7197877765,
0.3555601835,
-0.0403083079,
0.2475437969,
-0.5075702071,
0.3178199828,
-0.5254178643,
-0.3847242892,
0.3733576536,
-0.5456474423,
0.6876164675,
0.537766397,
-0.6287195683,
-0.0032584451,
-0.7060869932,
-0.2368415445,
0.0292437989,
-0.6300770044,
-0.0840019807,
0.2077718377,
-0.2522036433,
-0.2030101269,
-0.1654316336,
-0.6000722051,
0.090388976,
-0.8719578385,
0.4242836535,
0.6414544582,
-0.3260168731,
0.3633912504,
-0.3249846995,
0.6311670542,
-0.1805157363,
-0.1493721306,
0.2646295428,
-0.4989736974,
-0.6027002335,
-0.0179988593,
0.9211479425,
0.2787362933,
-0.6426456571,
0.5282883048,
-0.0629415289,
-0.3179430962,
-0.0884462148,
0.0358436629,
0.2966986895,
0.0963766128,
0.1624090374,
-0.4828286469,
-0.3520752192,
-0.7848622799,
-0.3250906765,
0.1468247026,
-0.2719841897,
0.6608474851,
0.1941458583,
-0.1578360051,
0.4476379156,
-0.0165795907,
0.2440821975,
-0.0115146125,
0.4864386618,
0.1689994931,
0.6038857102,
0.4762323499,
-0.947255075,
-0.6042527556,
0.4120342135,
-0.6362670064,
0.5072245598,
-0.1467071325,
0.4687876403,
0.0429850928,
0.3250850439,
-0.2654476464,
0.4567057192,
0.4664717317,
0.3100992143,
0.145787254,
-0.2656832933,
-0.0026009914,
-1.1001857519,
-0.0348509103,
0.0712328777,
-0.6619226933,
-0.2628960311,
0.114680551,
-0.1101594344,
-0.15518938,
-0.4881072044,
-0.0699163899,
-0.3582828939,
-0.127698943,
-0.2580372691,
-0.1172331944,
-0.2002563179,
0.080091238,
-0.3893913925,
1.0622496605,
0.6896106601,
-0.3928784728,
0.7234826684,
-0.0213401131,
-0.5597296953,
0.1104525104,
-0.7108615041,
0.2325652987,
-0.3073254526,
0.2243933082,
-0.9536736608,
-0.4197759926,
0.047620479,
-0.2612623572,
0.8109009862,
-0.1626802683,
0.2226812989,
-0.4193878174,
-0.3801201284,
0.4097262919,
0.43948102,
-0.7350728512,
0.906639576,
-0.0372750759,
0.1664343625,
-0.9622736573,
-0.889061749,
0.1154599786,
-0.1671149582,
-0.273136586,
0.2191514671,
-0.1592036933,
-0.0960656703,
0.0171557125,
-0.1582521945,
-0.2242816687,
0.3022216558,
0.0927170515,
-0.2090809047,
-0.565274775,
0.2250077426,
-0.129311949,
0.0481364802,
-0.1147076711,
-0.6275867224,
0.3952052891,
-0.2418996096,
-0.3380443156,
-0.4854843915,
0.246685639,
0.3876650929,
0.069794178,
0.9166473746,
0.6228685975,
-0.4723339975,
-0.2263798863,
-0.4125507772,
-0.1552219242,
-0.4379582107,
0.5777488947,
-0.3938015699,
-0.929064095,
0.6499128342,
-0.6168866158,
-0.2509583831,
0.790214479,
-0.0163616519,
-0.1271674633,
0.9335971475,
0.421035707,
0.054953821,
0.5778001547,
-0.6491712332,
0.0718666017,
-0.9882112145,
-0.0617437139,
-0.2474633157,
-0.4503934681,
-0.8107615709,
0.1031343564,
0.032026127,
0.3277372122,
-0.3478724957,
0.2502078116,
-0.3802699745,
0.9034254551,
0.5963146091,
0.3048545122,
-0.3721270561,
0.1015107483,
-0.1478901803,
0.1469294876,
-0.7265014648,
-0.0063286247,
1.3468247652,
0.3443317413,
0.9317679405,
0.2355123907,
0.563284874,
0.1321203709,
0.1948080808,
-0.7590146661,
-0.0016835405,
-0.4669151604,
-0.6880350709,
-0.5772539973,
-0.7556692958,
-1.2050205469,
0.145104751,
-0.3469111621,
-0.7700582743,
0.4824004769,
0.290812552,
-0.6920549273,
0.8424640298,
-0.584454298,
0.4963265359,
-0.2075792551,
-0.4660755396,
-0.246027559,
-0.8800984621,
0.1733857244,
-0.2076156437,
-0.2469567806,
0.0375398062,
-0.1066405997,
0.6219338775,
-0.4601229727,
0.8000097871,
-0.0641549826,
0.0743309185,
0.2580845654,
0.053592395,
0.6813136935,
0.1390541345,
-0.3213506043,
0.2362367958,
-0.6155906916,
-0.3580885828,
-0.6636513472,
0.6834661961,
-0.9685646892,
-0.3172523975,
-0.3902254701,
-0.3281173706,
0.0302346796,
0.0663961172,
0.7051379085,
0.7009670138,
-0.2200040817,
0.6936256289,
0.8586435914,
0.0369864553,
0.4563075602,
-0.1742058843,
-0.0211880784,
-0.8761110902,
0.9228164554,
0.2267327011,
0.37962538,
0.4668664634,
0.4659303129,
-0.0086382795,
-0.9127630591,
-0.4981116354,
-0.1655753106,
-0.7049740553,
-0.3181446195,
-0.3223410845,
-0.3711403608,
0.0895993337,
-0.1670770496,
-0.6525056958,
-0.4754848778,
-0.2813540995,
-0.0082502346,
0.0307211298,
1.059627533,
-0.373683691,
0.4391025007,
-0.3492780924,
-0.024810737,
0.6991488934,
0.426129669,
0.1149171069,
-0.473264128,
-0.2748599648,
0.1375153065,
-0.3312234581,
-0.3724760711,
-0.0940686762,
0.617030561,
0.5121585131,
0.7885069847,
-0.2970637083,
0.1806238741,
-0.5160116553,
0.8610022068,
0.5585293174,
-0.8263360858,
0.1820096374,
-0.4383148849,
0.0102132503,
0.5505030751,
0.6597803235,
-0.0560877696,
-0.0512878709,
-0.7066466808,
-1.0715939999,
0.5943447351,
0.3712691963,
0.1933288276,
0.3220270872,
0.6570863724,
0.2992341816,
0.3314719498,
-0.6584871411,
-0.4177533984,
-0.0574240163,
-0.1283919513,
-0.1425850391,
-0.1187438965,
-0.2910984457,
-0.5595581532,
0.6907155514,
-0.1519900858,
0.5022574663,
0.1534022987,
0.2161285281,
-0.2438398153,
-0.0938318446,
0.9417026639,
1.0793110132,
-0.1982851028,
0.2718819976,
0.7174617648,
-0.36849612,
0.2111575305,
0.3491145372,
-0.1934737563,
-0.2409346253,
0.3979096711,
1.0173666477,
-0.1275631189,
-0.2880982459,
0.764549911,
-0.2598625422,
-0.4862173498,
-0.5340610147,
0.2856937647,
0.005732696,
0.3345093131,
0.2141205519,
0.5571994781,
0.2806830108,
-0.2013947964,
0.1475701332,
0.3354539871,
-0.5628736615,
-0.1989516765,
0.7074727416,
0.093654111,
-0.5387097597,
0.3134314418,
-0.3414464593,
-0.549417913,
0.8932119608,
0.7694839239,
0.9842953086,
-0.3567801416,
0.0345405303,
0.2868083715,
0.0493046753,
-0.1205192283,
0.1076472849,
-0.0706564412,
-0.6597716808,
-0.7637700438,
-0.2611761093,
-0.6512218714,
0.286518991,
-0.3930878043,
-0.1612680554,
-0.7368766665,
-0.1890090704,
0.3587985635,
-0.2126846313,
-0.6498864293,
0.451469034,
0.006456648,
0.4359721541,
-0.3874689639,
0.4037976563,
0.7119832039,
-0.3006437123,
-0.9982373118,
0.1426329613,
-0.1982265413,
-0.5755724907,
0.4201823771,
0.2275913358,
-0.1785237938,
-0.1549762785,
-0.893456459,
-0.9715200663,
0.8518670201,
0.6528494954,
-1.0036892891,
0.4777616858,
-0.0982079506,
0.4278931022,
-0.3384988606,
0.4338804781,
0.0854087099,
0.1632529348,
0.3438080251,
-0.5436728597,
-0.3033735752,
-0.1286915541,
0.247055769,
0.4767530262,
-0.7747135162,
0.9499189258,
-0.0502082407,
0.0759902075,
0.1976059526,
0.6400845051,
-0.5557313561,
0.2011663467,
0.6571540833,
0.782787323,
1.1616503,
-0.1292859018,
1.2507271767,
0.009443203,
0.5434991121,
0.9143844247,
-0.1643767655,
0.5838944316,
0.0651999786,
-0.5980602503,
0.4567947984,
0.8375272751,
0.062799111,
0.5295484066,
0.6446585655,
-0.5484371781,
-0.4214788675,
0.1672571599,
-0.5047484636,
0.0965904221,
0.1748052388,
-0.3355323076,
0.0770547986,
0.3288193345,
-0.1415402442,
-0.0900840238,
-0.200832352,
0.8723719716,
0.125668034,
-0.2455202043,
0.7255074382,
-0.135000512,
0.5774616003,
-0.4276098311,
0.2709484398,
-0.2457531095,
0.3914136887,
-0.0952270329,
-0.3203380704,
0.0645177811,
-0.4541305304,
0.1037390679,
0.6052588224,
0.6777806878,
-0.3438822329,
-0.388854444,
0.1500540674,
0.0948991179,
0.3296088576,
0.0122818751,
-0.6245335937,
-0.4189333618,
-0.0220020991,
-0.3361864984,
0.1594011188,
0.278688103,
0.4338446558,
0.5945750475,
0.6436590552,
0.187113449,
-0.1668637842,
0.1207296103,
1.0224183798,
-0.366099894,
-0.3615650833,
-0.7073510289,
0.343695581,
-0.5046598315,
-0.5632257462,
0.2378180474,
0.7176762223,
0.821762681,
0.2768505216,
0.6714702845,
0.1720261425,
0.3421568871,
-0.5187419653,
0.562694788,
-0.8006055355,
0.1478401273,
0.2711868584,
-1.2339420319,
-0.7799821496,
0.8520180583,
-0.2381109893,
0.3841375411,
0.8500259519,
0.5012184381,
-0.4697902203,
0.2449185997,
0.523234725,
-0.010246939,
0.3366463184,
0.2915068567,
1.0098108053,
-0.4899579585,
0.2225533873,
-0.2791164815,
-0.2954110801,
-0.2280099243,
-0.9456053972,
-1.0861898661,
-0.3659490049,
-0.2708516419,
-0.502641499,
0.4239492416,
1.2910456657,
0.8429777026,
-1.1842294931,
0.105435811,
-0.7748972774,
0.0551328026,
-0.306230396,
-0.0677374974,
0.5053207874,
-0.406698972,
-0.5494259,
0.6254780889,
0.0023840487,
0.2632523775,
-0.0749202147,
-0.2381812483,
-0.1340055019,
0.0467992015,
0.2774603665,
0.5033647418,
-0.6591313481,
-0.3616496325,
-0.2083365768,
-0.0170181058,
0.3625786602,
0.7867093682,
-0.2330224812,
0.6509851813,
0.3363201916,
1.2796121836,
0.8399832249,
-0.0244166795,
0.6510646939,
-0.5198533535,
0.0717120841,
0.4087575376,
0.478859216,
0.5315231085,
-0.4188574553,
0.7283991575,
0.2948500216,
-0.88220191,
-0.4305345416,
0.2072912753,
-0.5599389672,
-0.156956017,
1.0571684837,
-0.5424850583,
-0.2880834639,
-0.0132713998,
-0.0421586148,
0.2274519354,
-0.4286484718,
0.7118673325,
0.5069895387,
-0.0797799528,
0.1419785172,
-0.4251000285,
0.5587588549,
0.7267478108,
-0.6238442063,
-0.3983424902,
0.1117201596,
0.1165171564,
0.2043740302,
-0.139432013,
0.4193434417,
0.1917484254,
0.124913305,
-0.0027683484,
-0.1298198998,
-0.4542281032,
-0.8074799776,
-0.0444280989,
0.3242610097,
-0.2606201172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17633v1
|
From Text Segmentation to Smart Chaptering: A Novel Benchmark for Structuring Video Transcriptions
| 2024-02-27T15:59:37 | 2024-02-27T15:59:37 |
Fabian Retkowski, Alexander Waibel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text segmentation is a fundamental task in natural language processing, where
documents are split into contiguous sections. However, prior research in this
area has been constrained by limited datasets, which are either small in scale,
synthesized, or only contain well-structured documents. In this paper, we
address these limitations by introducing a novel benchmark YTSeg focusing on
spoken content that is inherently more unstructured and both topically and
structurally diverse. As part of this work, we introduce an efficient
hierarchical segmentation model MiniSeg, that outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines. Lastly, we expand the notion of text segmentation to a more
practical "smart chaptering" task that involves the segmentation of
unstructured content, the generation of meaningful segment titles, and a
potential real-time application of the models.
|
[
-0.1916014552,
-0.8134216666,
0.343192488,
-0.019957481,
-0.7306782007,
0.1539613158,
-0.0815530643,
-0.3854205012,
0.1110366061,
0.5388256311,
-0.8315197229,
-0.7375747561,
-0.456145227,
0.1312300712,
-0.6765623689,
0.9326766133,
0.4484582245,
0.0457160473,
-0.1734466553,
-0.3730472624,
-0.4521448314,
-0.2245115042,
-0.2403456122,
0.0309210122,
0.1859977543,
0.4149357378,
0.5103033781,
1.4088096619,
0.4630057514,
0.348003298,
-0.2044866681,
0.2872786224,
0.0305576902,
0.4551754594,
0.042434901,
-0.3776626289,
-0.0655947626,
-0.2446488142,
0.9562567472,
0.801254034,
0.0473506153,
0.1474761516,
-0.1432421207,
0.7591031194,
-0.3626546562,
-0.0336780697,
-0.5329666734,
0.1954023987,
-0.2484115064,
-0.181952402,
-0.3247011006,
-0.4434217513,
0.3274490833,
-0.3656956255,
0.4896186888,
-0.125761494,
0.687707305,
0.4214691818,
-0.4482473135,
-0.089829877,
-0.6814523935,
0.7464533448,
-0.5457004309,
0.7499226928,
0.1301632077,
0.3423778415,
0.1231220588,
-1.034280777,
-0.224040702,
0.1076205745,
0.2264658809,
-0.2719377875,
-0.0672803372,
0.176423654,
0.1277468204,
0.5455282927,
-0.6177074909,
-0.0811831057,
-0.2202005088,
-0.2707446516,
0.2704331577,
0.1741201729,
0.6292333007,
-0.4532284141,
-0.291957885,
-0.2300189584,
-0.1217883229,
0.0506138727,
0.3638702631,
0.3850542903,
0.1621783823,
0.5596613884,
-0.1244274825,
0.6839874983,
-0.1100194082,
-0.612504065,
0.0124270981,
-0.4399077296,
-0.4728588164,
0.1510298103,
0.8792749643,
0.4714931846,
0.080149062,
-0.1324317753,
-0.0647300184,
-0.0640029237,
0.5103343725,
-1.0072308779,
-0.3996710777,
-0.1071131974,
-0.5780307055,
-0.0983797163,
0.0809135586,
-0.9519974589,
-0.2849369645,
-0.3211168647,
0.1520836651,
-0.558850646,
0.4635830522,
-0.0293688644,
-0.1288273633,
-0.0140718762,
0.2282231003,
-1.1109220982,
0.675086081,
0.7416636348,
1.1233503819,
-0.3892647624,
0.0553891361,
-0.6954929829,
0.0979913175,
-0.198260054,
1.0696353912,
-0.3644307256,
-0.3625251353,
0.0231526531,
-0.0798821896,
-0.0212945938,
-0.6171754599,
0.6123309135,
-0.4072653353,
0.2211156636,
-0.0855806768,
-0.5129163265,
-0.155338645,
0.3514204323,
-0.7941345572,
1.1264586449,
-0.0024636139,
-0.5705683231,
0.4352095127,
-0.2698736489,
-0.6374237537,
0.0381661542,
-0.4609793127,
-0.5890288949,
0.0774731934,
0.4091344178,
0.2123933285,
-0.5296701789,
0.2988343239,
0.0940290466,
-0.0503270887,
0.1755169928,
-0.5176045895,
0.2558037639,
0.0491051152,
-0.1920299977,
0.283662647,
-0.8990465999,
0.1928033531,
-0.169589445,
-0.0993728265,
-0.4964182079,
0.2170385718,
0.4232327044,
-0.1418671906,
0.0810612962,
-0.4944449365,
0.4166030884,
-0.2979022861,
0.5511305332,
0.4205377698,
0.2520754039,
0.6788671613,
-0.1603437662,
0.2397114635,
-0.272929281,
0.2081800252,
-0.4690362811,
-0.2394748777,
-0.5314840078,
-0.7330571413,
0.2504405677,
0.3163557053,
-0.5699596405,
0.3880062103,
-0.3169519007,
-0.6290686131,
-0.3068945706,
0.0314172693,
0.5007129908,
0.6035603285,
0.5648188591,
-0.5811892152,
-0.6449372768,
-1.1375837326,
-0.3681969941,
-0.1515742838,
-0.0641059056,
0.042112004,
0.206483826,
-0.3686754405,
1.0504977703,
-0.8351146579,
-0.5913972855,
-0.4319772422,
0.5426095128,
0.0236488953,
0.4408512115,
0.3016651571,
-1.0403069258,
-0.5366334915,
-0.061476998,
-0.5574354529,
-0.0495360494,
-0.2136727124,
0.3604544997,
-0.1955170929,
0.7824510932,
-0.3889025748,
0.2871938646,
0.2077768594,
-0.1051689312,
0.4408314228,
-0.4526879191,
0.2681428194,
-0.9266090989,
-0.24778229,
0.0134792784,
-0.3933388591,
-0.71307832,
-0.1468679011,
0.089356102,
-0.0987099037,
-0.3927175105,
0.1422865242,
-0.2833431065,
-0.420994848,
-0.2348448336,
0.0018164654,
-0.0783961266,
0.6231485605,
0.1526485234,
0.6686903238,
0.2910016775,
-0.5182088614,
0.0322708562,
0.5172289014,
-0.7873277664,
0.4208147824,
-0.6712012291,
0.0736889169,
-0.0208875183,
0.1918123215,
-0.9093061686,
-0.3319617212,
-0.1304795295,
-0.1906474233,
0.0899726003,
-0.2481365502,
-0.6610466242,
0.1482933462,
-0.4199611545,
0.889110446,
0.415884316,
-0.1773575246,
0.5021776557,
0.7558327913,
-0.4979486465,
-0.1576680839,
-0.7031584978,
0.0570411719,
-0.2281481028,
-0.6687453389,
0.8388457894,
-0.0650780201,
-0.2064750493,
-0.053625185,
-0.5554845929,
-0.6356178522,
-0.3134516478,
0.1897602826,
0.0744397193,
-0.2872691453,
0.0011694802,
0.2419224232,
-0.0723699778,
-0.3522417843,
-0.6138222814,
0.365259707,
-0.0188442543,
-0.2467750758,
-0.4609479308,
0.5449535847,
0.6943753362,
-0.2843794227,
0.338595897,
0.3097417653,
-0.4810302556,
-0.5711726546,
-0.3477964997,
-0.0265735593,
-0.4811162949,
0.5755255222,
0.0336218663,
-1.0528246164,
0.3196900785,
0.0970023125,
0.1463514715,
0.3554241657,
0.2966641784,
-0.0909323394,
0.9182576537,
0.8871093392,
-0.0053732172,
0.758592844,
-0.0508707389,
0.1206105873,
-0.4638957381,
-0.3190046549,
-0.8388428092,
-0.1798587441,
-0.8463854194,
-0.7551628351,
0.5643678308,
-0.0881430879,
0.1279347539,
0.6563112736,
-0.543004334,
0.6556940079,
0.4411794245,
-0.0954186991,
0.3895784616,
-0.0545029528,
-0.1043425277,
-0.3909106553,
-0.6582921147,
-0.566511333,
0.5842445493,
0.3233303428,
0.4134151042,
-0.0954576731,
0.5829855204,
0.8084855676,
0.0787621215,
-1.0690191984,
0.7101809382,
-0.6120781302,
-0.3210945427,
-0.5994808078,
-0.3734109402,
-0.7591070533,
0.5124689341,
0.0792696625,
-0.9201920033,
0.0458667539,
-0.0915836245,
-0.4248329103,
0.3817439079,
-0.5199819207,
0.9247102737,
-0.0835343376,
-0.1217653155,
0.0418447293,
-0.7021232247,
-0.0324028283,
0.0415654071,
0.5149441957,
-0.0292839538,
0.0195530169,
1.1506613493,
-0.8087051511,
0.4815522134,
-0.0070707402,
0.1546479464,
0.6689227223,
0.0159413312,
0.2225674242,
-0.0523858443,
0.1709917337,
-0.2603275776,
0.2829619348,
-0.0720917434,
-0.5919924974,
0.278458029,
-0.5067217946,
-0.116811499,
-0.3851095736,
-0.4066539109,
-0.5149388313,
0.474129349,
0.2642827332,
0.8124523759,
-0.5466137528,
0.5551280975,
0.9440363646,
-0.1049275771,
0.5096668601,
0.1829878986,
0.2104393095,
-0.7103622556,
0.8595249057,
0.0156675149,
-0.0839415714,
0.9101907015,
0.2313766032,
-0.5075272322,
-0.861315012,
-0.3991138637,
0.0452020168,
-0.7585485578,
-0.0989625379,
-0.7263460159,
-0.0408498421,
-0.4205228984,
-0.1058572754,
-0.8599029183,
-0.2876125276,
-0.0894844383,
-0.2700084746,
-0.2142525762,
0.6230238676,
0.252641499,
0.4753449559,
-1.2564119101,
0.7488585711,
0.6338280439,
0.2557666898,
-0.2851344645,
-0.4683816135,
-0.3961714506,
-0.4057781696,
-0.2362077981,
-0.8005426526,
0.3941119015,
0.2402483821,
0.4148487747,
0.3654016256,
0.1458859146,
0.6682870388,
-0.7490931749,
0.8394627571,
0.3021618426,
-0.9858233929,
0.3199932873,
-0.610992372,
0.4867352247,
1.0775897503,
0.018133074,
-0.7555914521,
-0.1357783079,
-0.4129620492,
-1.0850387812,
0.6621348262,
0.2985263765,
-0.2302729189,
-0.1025982201,
-0.0631423444,
0.2967967987,
0.187536642,
-0.7251676917,
-0.012656495,
-0.0335934311,
-0.2441786677,
0.094181478,
-0.2751274705,
0.1015857309,
-0.0968993679,
0.3789830208,
-0.1872546077,
0.1748232245,
0.3476135135,
-0.355214715,
0.078671217,
0.4671732187,
0.5495396852,
0.1190489456,
-0.2828220725,
0.253364414,
-0.2045797259,
-0.7788185477,
0.2041351497,
-0.0291375276,
-0.3389959633,
0.1613998562,
0.8691627383,
0.6522886157,
0.5250385404,
-0.835529089,
0.3701645732,
-0.1848649681,
-0.2823551297,
0.1054577827,
-0.1124222502,
-0.3116435707,
0.2019415945,
0.5102043152,
0.0457989536,
0.329538852,
-0.7349079251,
0.4900270104,
-0.0203069877,
-0.6884053946,
-0.2790103555,
0.5253633261,
0.3198282719,
-0.5037076473,
0.4316774607,
-0.0440689996,
-0.5203021765,
0.6779021621,
0.0701641291,
1.215788722,
0.1923809499,
0.3901362419,
0.2073531151,
0.3376993835,
-0.2624284625,
0.0244559869,
-0.5166804194,
-0.2390201986,
-0.3993757963,
-0.6839618087,
-0.4221655428,
-0.0755890906,
-0.8320066333,
-0.0976504385,
-0.3938525915,
-0.1291010827,
0.1268097907,
-0.2091617137,
-0.3614086807,
0.7252122164,
-0.0916732401,
0.9424017668,
-0.681083858,
0.946639955,
0.5173590183,
0.1372721046,
-0.5072162747,
0.3457629085,
0.0018338236,
-0.1129200011,
0.3289555609,
0.3845009208,
-0.2719171047,
-0.3845391572,
-0.188827008,
-0.3727135658,
0.990873754,
0.141477108,
-0.4203762412,
-0.2158312649,
0.4957855642,
0.749052763,
-0.2115032971,
-0.0951551497,
0.5875471234,
0.2280807495,
0.1136152148,
-0.5555269122,
-0.3741050363,
-0.2428216934,
-0.0749998838,
0.3221343458,
-0.4601070285,
0.7023736238,
0.1508148909,
-0.3046241701,
0.1601998955,
0.9259180427,
-0.1510796398,
0.5992405415,
0.706438303,
0.3480620682,
0.7334935665,
-0.0943366066,
0.7976905704,
0.0938874111,
0.0537420623,
1.3692466021,
-0.0117130121,
0.5097360015,
0.469979316,
-0.0835678428,
0.5287858248,
0.5025421381,
-0.027972905,
0.9714098573,
-0.0423385724,
-0.1244239435,
-0.3147496283,
-0.4127312601,
-0.1836230606,
0.5839662552,
0.0302762054,
-0.2000652552,
-0.1810753345,
-0.1537599117,
-0.3088511825,
0.5054593086,
-0.3132194877,
1.053052783,
0.0257273037,
-0.8326708674,
-0.1753957719,
0.4314947426,
0.3995781243,
-0.9138860106,
0.1719808877,
-0.2238733619,
0.0021550995,
-0.0040337136,
-0.5202180743,
0.4915111363,
0.3744021654,
-0.3226961195,
-0.57829988,
0.7804182172,
-0.371053189,
-0.2300582677,
0.0844638795,
0.3406115174,
-0.2447295487,
-0.1319282204,
-0.2713451684,
0.0646643639,
0.1052431911,
-0.1409157068,
0.4246084094,
0.7292060852,
-0.2498687953,
0.4935979545,
0.474547714,
-0.2089015245,
-0.0555011183,
0.1738059074,
0.7276415825,
-0.8745257854,
-1.0667967796,
-0.8973301053,
0.5632705688,
-0.0582657643,
-0.4397912621,
0.7619403005,
0.8904143572,
0.6775423288,
-0.1719851196,
0.7326704264,
0.0932308063,
0.2134038359,
-0.5274782777,
0.447238028,
-0.4891321957,
0.0441287532,
-0.6193253994,
-0.8586820364,
-0.2934453189,
0.330498606,
-0.1895615011,
-0.2933771014,
0.8064914942,
0.4261314571,
-0.093012251,
0.2398179173,
0.2982781231,
-0.2311954796,
0.4020877481,
-0.0214739535,
0.5838939548,
-0.4191355705,
0.7473497391,
-0.3105427325,
-0.1018740088,
-0.1349649131,
-0.8737384081,
-0.9854773283,
-0.7616688013,
-0.4136088192,
0.2702233195,
-0.0981106162,
0.9456503987,
0.9244582653,
-0.6988196373,
-0.3061636686,
-0.1822405756,
0.1585817188,
-0.3973546028,
-0.1338813305,
0.5033426285,
0.1293797791,
-0.6357557774,
0.7472140193,
0.6086757183,
0.0351616368,
0.2066853642,
0.0815889761,
-0.1843179464,
0.2605832517,
0.4764806032,
0.3994703591,
-0.0609878562,
-0.1266766489,
0.0614419803,
-0.258482933,
0.2290767431,
1.3219511509,
-0.3336208463,
0.4094279408,
0.6730428934,
0.8310588002,
0.8296233416,
0.2997893691,
0.3414750099,
-1.0918700695,
0.0808395594,
0.4048482776,
0.1773322374,
0.3848363459,
0.0526334643,
0.3746005893,
0.4447778761,
-0.2871337235,
-0.8386189342,
0.2063176483,
-1.3064825535,
-0.3863004744,
0.8356966972,
0.0334812403,
-0.260917455,
-0.0732231215,
-0.3090669513,
0.4841480255,
-0.4344103038,
0.632435143,
0.4994881451,
-0.1386204064,
-0.0800577998,
-0.325830698,
0.504529655,
0.4050273895,
-1.1446377039,
0.1085397005,
0.6184324622,
0.0508127064,
0.1550406367,
0.7027993202,
-0.0746338665,
0.2751408219,
0.1134473011,
-0.3340065181,
-0.2389816195,
-0.7757816315,
-0.0919437781,
0.6057941914,
-0.2141854912,
-0.3549550474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17630v1
|
Fine-Grained Natural Language Inference Based Faithfulness Evaluation for Diverse Summarisation Tasks
| 2024-02-27T15:57:11 | 2024-02-27T15:57:11 |
Huajian Zhang, Yumo Xu, Laura Perez-Beltrachini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study existing approaches to leverage off-the-shelf Natural Language
Inference (NLI) models for the evaluation of summary faithfulness and argue
that these are sub-optimal due to the granularity level considered for premises
and hypotheses. That is, the smaller content unit considered as hypothesis is a
sentence and premises are made up of a fixed number of document sentences. We
propose a novel approach, namely InFusE, that uses a variable premise size and
simplifies summary sentences into shorter hypotheses. Departing from previous
studies which focus on single short document summarisation, we analyse NLI
based faithfulness evaluation for diverse summarisation tasks. We introduce
DiverSumm, a new benchmark comprising long form summarisation (long documents
and summaries) and diverse summarisation tasks (e.g., meeting and
multi-document summarisation). In experiments, InFusE obtains superior
performance across the different summarisation tasks. Our code and data are
available at https://github.com/HJZnlp/infuse.
|
[
-0.3911168575,
-0.6857919097,
0.441772908,
0.4120355844,
-0.5020470023,
0.0336071253,
-0.2412106991,
-0.432320416,
0.3458387554,
0.5913825035,
-0.5713093281,
-0.4287756979,
-0.4611834884,
0.4245506525,
-0.3761045635,
1.0597959757,
-0.0024043096,
0.0343750939,
-0.7189803123,
-0.3770329952,
-0.2406912595,
-0.1280429661,
-0.2231419832,
-0.4303939641,
0.0008943303,
0.3639135361,
0.691942811,
0.2168860584,
0.724639535,
0.1954568624,
-0.284722805,
0.6965779066,
-0.5967773199,
-0.0111409547,
-0.2608183622,
-0.4975291193,
-0.2955073416,
-0.0496216714,
0.7107239366,
0.9087581038,
0.0049687796,
0.1644159853,
0.5050785542,
0.7194051147,
-0.9434012771,
-0.120202668,
-0.4682099819,
-0.1467160732,
-0.0266953632,
0.0313560367,
-0.4512363076,
-0.4817145467,
0.3488649726,
-0.5100002885,
0.3744028509,
-0.0164929833,
1.0078411102,
0.244241327,
-0.1362983733,
-0.4171693623,
-0.4887042642,
1.0111783743,
-1.3171334267,
0.1851155311,
0.4423215389,
0.1358052492,
-0.1665943712,
-0.8169935942,
-0.312699914,
-0.2286604643,
-0.2820513546,
0.3611539006,
-0.0129224686,
0.0151484925,
0.1169304624,
0.7963673472,
-0.5091844797,
-0.1729086488,
0.2586381137,
-0.0470449887,
0.7332558632,
0.1374790072,
0.2104001343,
-0.2160661072,
-0.2904869914,
0.1087820232,
-0.3604065478,
-0.123405017,
0.4692519307,
0.1963798255,
-0.2151163518,
0.6766117811,
-0.4248934686,
0.4447539151,
-0.0342482813,
-0.4703555107,
0.1371937245,
-0.9171701074,
-0.3870762289,
0.0751694664,
0.8025941849,
0.4733063281,
0.3177682161,
-0.4327884614,
0.0165182855,
0.0171970483,
0.106893003,
-1.1591458321,
-0.0027612539,
0.4803516269,
-0.5133370757,
-0.1287342459,
0.3303325176,
-0.738077879,
-0.2497636527,
-0.1566406041,
0.377677083,
-0.7697682977,
0.0981486216,
0.3404931426,
-0.6603925824,
0.1316644549,
0.3180311024,
-0.899469018,
0.7609558105,
0.8510255218,
0.8926765323,
-0.4252659976,
-0.5287578702,
-0.5156738162,
0.2493886203,
0.0263741948,
0.9121879339,
-0.4114340246,
-0.5961900353,
-0.2028860152,
-0.2967320979,
-0.1123162732,
-0.7139398456,
0.8212917447,
-0.1134640649,
0.4197442532,
-0.1802695692,
-0.9167875051,
-0.1523532569,
0.2823033035,
-0.6288570762,
0.8998253942,
0.2733715177,
-1.0522890091,
0.615960896,
-0.6112905145,
-0.5914269686,
-0.1943672001,
0.0320392214,
-0.6648929715,
0.2640393972,
0.4554620385,
0.1890765727,
-0.1021715999,
0.3052848279,
-0.6032831073,
-0.4801880419,
0.186332643,
-0.741511941,
0.6516692638,
0.0554071777,
-0.108530581,
0.0366203077,
-0.6109826565,
-0.1841111034,
-0.1687166095,
-0.217409417,
-0.4895718396,
0.1043360978,
0.1405093074,
-0.4028170407,
0.1284196526,
-0.5106423497,
0.1881936491,
-0.8103610277,
0.1567786485,
0.0388458334,
0.4440731108,
0.6906866431,
-0.4645026028,
0.1632811874,
-0.1970782131,
0.2524155676,
-0.3310419619,
-0.583814919,
-0.2608568966,
-0.7426204681,
0.5027578473,
0.4304862916,
-0.4859451652,
0.3341841102,
-0.5662525296,
-0.3263667822,
-0.4220826924,
0.2542403042,
0.3414264023,
0.3085719347,
0.255885005,
-0.373532325,
-0.2911032736,
-1.0106722116,
-0.7921076417,
-0.0278832223,
-0.3613004684,
0.0156835113,
0.8382053375,
-0.4401539266,
1.2818140984,
-0.3941117227,
-0.2637082338,
-0.5239180326,
0.468727082,
0.4162844121,
0.3222995996,
0.6160452962,
-0.7963175178,
-0.4833155274,
-0.0576965623,
-0.7535178065,
-0.0521113686,
-0.4128666818,
-0.0837788805,
0.0969157964,
0.2746379972,
-0.677834928,
0.5251733065,
0.3206588626,
-0.2291732728,
0.4449079633,
-0.1066669449,
0.161500901,
-1.1168168783,
-0.021695029,
-0.1285859644,
-0.5424958467,
-0.4990313053,
0.3358252645,
0.2198031247,
0.1556287706,
-0.344558835,
0.5306088924,
-0.4637277722,
0.0576667376,
-0.3686424792,
0.2364699692,
0.4958103299,
0.2838200927,
-0.1913348138,
0.7110207081,
0.2753930986,
-0.4187748134,
-0.166175589,
0.4400841296,
-0.2607980669,
0.3715844452,
-0.6915009022,
-0.2301085889,
-0.1334634423,
0.301964134,
-1.0164502859,
-0.4804384112,
-0.1122017354,
-0.3554579318,
0.311619848,
-0.1330498904,
-0.5400403142,
-0.0179091692,
-0.7898231745,
0.4637305737,
0.3333673775,
-0.4283559024,
1.0310353041,
0.0634218231,
0.025873458,
-0.4369727969,
-1.0049568415,
0.3293499649,
-0.3492218554,
-0.7314301133,
0.4907048345,
-0.0725586563,
-0.6398216486,
0.0280471984,
-0.2574582994,
-0.1673074514,
0.1294563115,
0.0953095034,
-0.0734847486,
-0.2622692585,
-0.3309136033,
0.2713457346,
0.0851922929,
-0.0120301228,
-0.2029768974,
0.2423689365,
-0.3467409015,
-0.4793182611,
-0.3787104189,
0.5673058629,
0.5317341089,
-0.3038013875,
0.5967381001,
0.3975977004,
-0.3965649903,
-0.3210078478,
-0.5432617664,
-0.0643909499,
-0.3889978528,
0.123053059,
-0.1281744838,
-0.4380656183,
0.7564345002,
-0.0920725241,
0.2779887319,
0.5818887353,
0.2199998051,
-0.0976227447,
0.4837391376,
0.3963004649,
-0.0580147803,
0.1888340563,
-0.4983589351,
0.0916672647,
-0.5939849615,
0.0798364133,
-0.3406385183,
0.0137786772,
-0.5101743937,
-0.3539850116,
0.2796226144,
0.3814516068,
0.3312755823,
0.1362440437,
-0.033526171,
0.6646230817,
0.4251859486,
0.0732791126,
0.5866861939,
-0.1455946714,
0.2050760835,
0.0287946686,
-0.6177887917,
-0.7331672311,
0.9656255841,
0.2377673984,
0.6725099683,
0.298948586,
0.9495907426,
0.1978385746,
0.4717726111,
-0.8984623551,
0.2471128702,
-0.2013673037,
-0.3612915576,
-0.4244116247,
-0.4312348664,
-0.7477216721,
0.4146468341,
-0.2490200698,
-0.600815475,
0.1503113359,
-0.0939729363,
-0.4099738598,
0.2127040625,
-0.7588533163,
0.6553211212,
0.1731073409,
-0.3760629892,
-0.1062103063,
-0.7092912793,
0.5718467832,
-0.1997497678,
0.1478281319,
-0.1079619452,
0.0059079323,
0.5330079198,
-0.6134086251,
0.7348173261,
0.2277861685,
-0.0773918703,
0.4256848693,
-0.0497940481,
0.4280263186,
0.7164661288,
-0.3972694576,
0.3168257177,
0.0121760871,
-0.548760891,
-0.8822929859,
0.4321486652,
-0.3345507383,
-0.3287778199,
-0.3058856428,
-0.5658906698,
-0.2794234157,
0.4133319259,
0.5457965136,
0.7995988727,
-0.5495828986,
0.2194125652,
0.8366048932,
0.060283158,
0.7367590666,
0.0568091944,
-0.0956827104,
-0.6235901713,
0.6340059638,
-0.0755228698,
0.6434510946,
0.5495357513,
0.4039567411,
-0.2781414688,
-0.9327795506,
-0.4919075966,
0.1710630804,
-0.5417850614,
-0.1311419904,
-0.6945906878,
-0.0263508875,
-0.3064499199,
-0.2004751116,
-0.4134738445,
-0.3182927966,
-0.3125737011,
0.209292978,
0.1343612075,
0.5226587653,
0.2950923145,
0.294515878,
-0.8501644731,
0.7878019214,
0.1768956482,
0.4977412522,
-0.3941580653,
-0.6006070375,
-0.1349824369,
0.2619766891,
-0.3712399006,
-0.7759105563,
0.2358827293,
0.5722234845,
0.5770005584,
0.644549191,
0.1664775461,
0.7994632125,
-0.3573950529,
0.8775933385,
-0.0183671732,
-0.871167779,
0.5104359388,
-0.3237421811,
0.5479565263,
1.2978426218,
0.1195072904,
-0.1618225873,
-0.8860034943,
-0.7114889026,
-0.9693818092,
0.1706297994,
0.6715506315,
-0.0371393822,
-0.0341393799,
0.1729443818,
0.5756834745,
0.2811406553,
-0.3622318208,
-0.2143825889,
-0.1967922002,
-0.3288456202,
-0.0571884476,
-0.2678956389,
0.0046651498,
-0.0422819257,
0.6080328226,
-0.3540119231,
-0.0403922349,
0.539249599,
-0.2870650887,
0.3743439317,
0.1709955186,
0.5781916976,
0.9003184438,
-0.6569507718,
-0.026154099,
0.6402777433,
-0.672565937,
-0.3434857726,
0.0786734968,
-0.2835151851,
0.5451934934,
0.924985826,
0.5011324286,
0.3630377352,
-0.6367006302,
0.7811967134,
-0.4349929988,
-0.3188458979,
-0.0765800774,
-0.0797579512,
-0.0916841701,
-0.0596105829,
0.3258267343,
0.3521444798,
0.6742849946,
-0.5980070233,
0.2723205984,
0.574760139,
-0.1982696503,
-0.0138523318,
0.5688117146,
-0.0446763709,
-0.2061583698,
0.3443502784,
-0.3325602412,
-0.0898019522,
0.4043751955,
0.3300344348,
1.1560199261,
0.2634765506,
0.0826354921,
0.2082373053,
0.3453086019,
-0.2430999279,
0.2818870842,
-0.0460996144,
-0.412817359,
-0.7786266208,
-0.7500624657,
-0.7545409203,
-0.1766151041,
-0.6738593578,
0.1096660718,
0.0230396483,
0.1241929382,
0.0591141656,
0.0380163267,
-0.2230066657,
0.1386912763,
0.0017922176,
1.2296128273,
-0.7646967173,
0.4705826938,
0.219154641,
-0.2868612111,
-0.3643081486,
0.3431007266,
-0.305582583,
-0.1374782473,
-0.2331515253,
0.1737885922,
-0.2425598353,
-0.4124487638,
-0.4884331822,
-0.6764366031,
0.8506688476,
0.6506148577,
-0.1486565918,
0.1435363442,
0.2191782147,
0.5026156902,
-0.1902659088,
0.3948534131,
0.7019897699,
0.4888745546,
-0.0830693692,
-0.7188867927,
-0.1954365075,
-0.2719739676,
-0.0614791773,
0.1671917886,
-0.4400959611,
0.4097796679,
-0.2500966787,
-0.2632369399,
0.2995401621,
1.0683224201,
0.2779487371,
0.5875387192,
0.3330673575,
0.6174531579,
0.851911664,
-0.0662593096,
1.523702383,
0.0024992917,
0.4208110571,
1.4326802492,
-0.0574935898,
0.6897381544,
0.6903933883,
-0.1688228995,
0.4095770121,
0.4469946623,
-0.0961548612,
0.6273391247,
0.085221,
-0.1988208145,
0.1016899422,
-0.124035351,
-0.1537400782,
0.3480407596,
0.1579772085,
-0.0977378115,
-0.4716872275,
-0.1609426439,
-0.112902388,
0.2497563809,
-0.208700031,
0.9850793481,
0.1892079562,
-0.7318042517,
0.5759813786,
-0.0636336803,
0.7216202617,
-0.7788717151,
-0.0208028574,
-0.5096262693,
0.1833022982,
-0.4764170647,
-0.76123631,
0.6540070772,
-0.2154020071,
-0.181399107,
-0.0859093964,
0.6580547094,
-0.3966844678,
-0.6186933517,
0.0000016313,
0.2739027441,
0.0681520849,
-0.3215343654,
-0.1718657464,
-0.4717877507,
-0.1337594837,
-0.3199769855,
0.1778048575,
0.5712343454,
-0.1314423978,
0.5196877718,
0.5139988661,
-0.0050492925,
-0.1452407241,
0.4724705815,
0.7224254012,
-0.209568873,
-0.5856595039,
-1.2478785515,
0.5364218354,
-0.4440661073,
-0.5742427111,
1.1997734308,
1.0683220625,
0.5904954672,
-0.1303243637,
0.6787205935,
0.4346941113,
0.1175000295,
-0.4756620228,
0.6177571416,
-0.4825118184,
-0.014964913,
-0.5574421883,
-0.9727172852,
-0.4090959132,
0.1348803043,
-0.1581567377,
-0.3100323975,
0.8622621894,
0.5451315641,
-0.4311034679,
0.4654621184,
0.0776128396,
-0.1848689765,
0.1622659713,
0.2409018576,
0.7348256111,
-0.5776910186,
0.2589826882,
-0.3016172647,
-0.1738718003,
-0.1228752211,
-1.0218700171,
-1.0533232689,
-0.0344137438,
-0.3402406573,
-0.2331364751,
-0.2494868785,
0.7166627049,
0.392095685,
-0.934678793,
-0.1465891153,
-0.284817338,
0.1227102578,
-0.4983150959,
-0.1982116103,
0.3831454217,
-0.3451965451,
-0.6988377571,
0.4425099194,
0.5516490936,
0.0723017007,
-0.0383638628,
0.0299077742,
-0.1717944443,
0.3350656927,
0.646317184,
-0.0577084459,
-0.6318182945,
0.0080073196,
-0.276083082,
-0.0454900824,
0.1778919101,
0.6951406002,
-0.4243123233,
0.2570131421,
0.6071776152,
0.8944213986,
0.7679418921,
0.2660325468,
0.4705423713,
-0.8505844474,
0.0251743831,
0.3456742167,
0.5783746839,
0.3903401792,
-0.3766476512,
0.6475640535,
0.002150744,
-0.2924355865,
-0.8821871877,
0.1073475406,
-1.1881929636,
-0.3778870106,
1.2223812342,
-0.1477030516,
-0.3539374769,
-0.2469677925,
-0.2845647931,
0.1516644657,
-0.2477286011,
0.6184082031,
0.5210556388,
-0.0287378989,
0.3968660235,
-0.4304380119,
0.5124966502,
0.4219449162,
-1.0343996286,
0.1669489145,
0.1460926086,
0.2024867535,
0.3010192811,
0.3741797209,
-0.0347258151,
0.1627722979,
0.0626543239,
-0.1850480735,
0.07681977,
-0.1796458811,
-0.2929269969,
0.3584766388,
-0.174107939,
-0.0928056315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17613v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17613v2
|
Neural Automated Writing Evaluation with Corrective Feedback
| 2024-02-27T15:42:33 | 2024-05-06T10:02:08 |
Izia Xiaoxiao Wang, Xihan Wu, Edith Coates, Min Zeng, Jiexin Kuang, Siliang Liu, Mengyang Qiu, Jungyeul Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The utilization of technology in second language learning and teaching has
become ubiquitous. For the assessment of writing specifically, automated
writing evaluation (AWE) and grammatical error correction (GEC) have become
immensely popular and effective methods for enhancing writing proficiency and
delivering instant and individualized feedback to learners. By leveraging the
power of natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning algorithms, AWE
and GEC systems have been developed separately to provide language learners
with automated corrective feedback and more accurate and unbiased scoring that
would otherwise be subject to examiners. In this paper, we propose an
integrated system for automated writing evaluation with corrective feedback as
a means of bridging the gap between AWE and GEC results for second language
learners. This system enables language learners to simulate the essay writing
tests: a student writes and submits an essay, and the system returns the
assessment of the writing along with suggested grammatical error corrections.
Given that automated scoring and grammatical correction are more efficient and
cost-effective than human grading, this integrated system would also alleviate
the burden of manually correcting innumerable essays.
|
[
-0.0006820614,
-0.977893889,
0.4420063496,
0.3967685699,
0.3900470436,
0.4950439334,
-0.4686994255,
-0.4382393062,
0.2183676809,
0.1363773644,
-0.3403586745,
-0.4688272476,
-0.3635780513,
0.2967535257,
-0.3117975295,
0.893872261,
-0.2636546791,
0.2917956412,
-0.4844960272,
0.0052956678,
-0.5021721721,
-0.4704551995,
-1.0166743994,
-0.3654356599,
0.454870224,
0.4619754255,
0.3414905667,
0.1159479767,
0.5855919719,
0.5166702867,
0.5210874677,
0.3398737609,
0.1622013003,
-0.0621737577,
-0.3139233887,
-0.407619983,
-0.5197014213,
0.0033651835,
0.616126895,
0.696312964,
-0.0439548194,
0.0762463734,
0.3341582716,
0.5789732337,
-0.573199749,
0.0073953047,
-0.1211401448,
0.2679191232,
0.2660003006,
-0.0767439529,
-0.6118654609,
-0.7988062501,
-0.0162991397,
-0.3974505961,
-0.062437471,
-0.2666797638,
0.6567541957,
0.2654734254,
-0.0493383184,
-0.506675601,
-0.766767621,
0.6031959057,
-0.7800661325,
-0.0773707926,
0.1963915825,
0.1809371859,
0.1045091301,
-0.5718953013,
-0.8658435345,
-0.661308229,
-0.1421448439,
0.5342730284,
-0.0393263288,
0.2931128144,
-0.0167458169,
0.327883333,
-0.4669734538,
0.2656829655,
-0.0586259514,
-0.2410248667,
0.7379145622,
0.0435890555,
0.6656805873,
0.0346956328,
-0.017056806,
-0.0233023725,
-0.0365977325,
0.062354628,
0.7368373275,
0.3129272759,
0.1314169317,
0.6414201856,
0.0901395977,
0.5997247696,
-0.0272607598,
0.0976911783,
0.1431494951,
-0.0542003363,
-0.1914419979,
-0.1713473946,
0.9004617929,
0.6184160113,
0.4103296399,
-0.1887554228,
-0.5067400932,
0.5817191005,
0.5033666492,
-0.220435366,
-0.0373143293,
0.0934146494,
-0.2177861929,
-0.4347375631,
0.2437951267,
-0.863650918,
-0.0630047321,
-0.6079573035,
0.9032124877,
-0.2018115968,
0.0186630692,
-0.0506684445,
-0.1934734434,
-0.1295214295,
0.3705891371,
-0.9103004336,
0.8382323384,
0.5297768712,
0.7900205851,
-0.1521763057,
-0.531506598,
-0.4339583814,
-0.4227544665,
-0.4069521129,
0.8846852183,
-0.3442152143,
-0.3060322106,
0.3422513604,
-0.0887141302,
-0.3340275288,
-0.3859591186,
0.3683812916,
-0.5131345391,
0.6278410554,
0.2059372962,
-0.6950973868,
-0.192917496,
0.1891203374,
-0.4983726144,
1.2431378365,
0.3251807094,
-0.392990917,
-0.0323264487,
-0.8093314171,
-0.6459827423,
0.0600681305,
0.0208954774,
-0.321416378,
-0.0101020867,
0.0925471857,
0.2906892598,
0.0499521308,
0.150849849,
0.0410402454,
-0.5940787792,
0.1008918136,
-0.234264791,
0.5212023258,
-0.1488582939,
-0.9197099805,
0.2678622305,
-0.9190392494,
0.50666821,
-0.1773244143,
-0.6859702468,
-0.0751703754,
-0.3097977936,
0.1804499775,
-0.0467006527,
0.2275007665,
-0.4928160608,
0.1982129067,
-0.4575776756,
0.0246990398,
0.870574832,
-0.1199235544,
0.5232572556,
-0.2506024539,
0.65478158,
-0.5903986692,
-0.1189388186,
0.1405403316,
-0.331259191,
-1.1690131426,
0.2404476702,
0.473765403,
1.1199293137,
-0.5197082162,
0.9082748294,
0.1324234903,
-0.3192299604,
-0.8279883862,
0.2603905797,
0.6736954451,
0.5888854861,
0.3181233704,
-0.2261544168,
-0.7225110531,
-0.4982415736,
-0.2869499326,
-0.4261653721,
-0.1147268936,
-0.0263576042,
0.4877855778,
-0.3221670985,
0.6339673996,
-0.3948225081,
-0.5383265018,
-0.4150393605,
0.3565374613,
-0.1440015137,
0.6527172327,
0.2184269279,
-0.0758725405,
-0.7906535268,
0.3100885153,
-0.7853163481,
-0.6004564166,
-0.3732237518,
-0.0245523397,
0.6070358753,
0.4322111309,
-0.1083656549,
0.4427161813,
0.4476168454,
-0.3805847764,
0.8302207589,
-0.5152855515,
0.4252080023,
-0.7451050878,
0.0956165642,
-0.0954687148,
-0.0455423407,
-0.2203286141,
0.0264652763,
0.0929986909,
0.095064275,
0.3114317954,
0.3792805672,
-0.1671490669,
0.0812848359,
-0.3950637877,
0.1689234972,
0.1030442715,
0.6253820062,
-0.1602208614,
0.6964734197,
0.2414523065,
-0.2979499996,
0.4869214594,
-0.048691012,
-0.1800603718,
0.5938952565,
-0.5053136945,
0.4296998978,
-0.1067941189,
0.0674483627,
-1.0188382864,
-0.2642526031,
-0.0104297493,
-0.7129993439,
0.3282896578,
0.3908284307,
-0.1711436957,
-0.4134991765,
-0.255915314,
-0.3214127719,
0.4968886971,
-0.4779185057,
0.7120853066,
0.0610180981,
-0.458522141,
-0.7552804947,
-0.7446161509,
0.3111817241,
0.4057357311,
-0.586566627,
0.1079467759,
-0.0715477318,
-0.4412302673,
0.255043298,
0.4498925209,
-0.0283454396,
-0.0904334038,
0.3460409641,
0.5438790321,
-0.2117169797,
0.3650553226,
0.253520757,
-0.2042924762,
0.0565813817,
-0.5731422901,
0.299664408,
-0.4600784779,
-0.5088928342,
-0.6969243288,
0.7249935865,
0.5556983352,
-0.0538229309,
0.3277026713,
0.4897577465,
-0.6462734342,
-0.4528474212,
-0.794267118,
-0.052807264,
-0.4067845643,
0.3629246354,
-0.1651505083,
-0.720328629,
0.3327353001,
0.1276119798,
0.0635074154,
0.6254458427,
0.5358113647,
-0.3275363743,
0.8944143057,
0.7546441555,
-0.0547299907,
0.2177539468,
-0.2029357851,
0.2944368124,
-0.4670999944,
-0.36768502,
-0.7082455754,
-0.3781935573,
-0.0099808387,
-0.0791001767,
-0.0189611427,
-0.0719362348,
-0.0736876279,
0.0729579031,
-0.6142042279,
0.6298108101,
0.7250162363,
-0.0860347301,
0.2430129796,
-0.0270159934,
-0.6721202731,
-0.3586144447,
-0.3361312747,
-0.8310515285,
0.9036605358,
0.1075891331,
0.5160983205,
-0.1317898035,
0.522500217,
0.6304501295,
0.626504302,
-0.9145802855,
0.5764057636,
-0.3377007246,
-0.0622296706,
-0.282805264,
-0.1823381186,
-0.219763875,
0.1039799079,
-0.1676162034,
-0.5390167236,
-0.0618133917,
0.0707310066,
-0.7239465117,
0.3122077286,
-1.1127697229,
0.7423687577,
-0.2687173784,
-0.4641246498,
-0.169765994,
-0.6367071271,
-0.2029819936,
0.15038912,
-0.0499566048,
0.3898537457,
0.1059312299,
0.8028337359,
-0.6892110705,
0.9133079648,
-0.2438126951,
0.0371106155,
0.5214318633,
-0.0618119054,
0.3329588175,
-0.114301309,
-0.2717871666,
-0.2201598436,
-0.4871360362,
0.1199807376,
-0.7737308145,
0.8155226111,
-0.8424280286,
-0.2365032732,
-0.4892258942,
-0.1551546752,
-0.2171063125,
0.0885805041,
0.1929664612,
0.3101929128,
-0.4178346992,
-0.3813354075,
0.2136772573,
0.0766438469,
0.5097081661,
0.6380162239,
-0.2449970096,
-0.7453409433,
0.8416221142,
0.1560558975,
0.0256501772,
0.3321845829,
0.1309996694,
-0.4478617907,
-0.3165617585,
-0.7658335567,
0.0724952444,
-0.9009124637,
0.0320994854,
-0.7901751399,
-0.1895924509,
-0.6291761994,
-0.7582399845,
-0.1444593072,
-0.4130414724,
-0.2893200815,
-0.3279342949,
-0.1136664376,
0.8491616249,
-0.4162211716,
0.3620527387,
-0.6728497148,
0.0783455223,
0.4165807962,
0.3937020898,
0.1483808905,
-0.4172148705,
-0.1520626396,
-0.3304024041,
-0.3483442664,
-0.5461242795,
0.2221261263,
0.3760287464,
0.1014170423,
0.1287449896,
-0.6341764331,
0.7269721627,
-0.6337299347,
0.7491315007,
0.2336278856,
-1.2663669586,
0.653888166,
-0.0108274603,
0.3345285654,
0.9603242278,
0.0275589228,
-0.9332261682,
-0.4995287657,
-0.2953238785,
-0.6615517735,
0.5361271501,
-0.1747394204,
0.0848979503,
-0.0028939224,
0.4000152946,
0.158366546,
0.0191415641,
-0.7291411757,
0.2836721539,
0.0314366631,
-0.6515161991,
0.0724537149,
-0.0852070302,
-0.0356022045,
-0.3323669434,
1.0803791285,
-0.2673334479,
0.1617628485,
0.408826679,
-0.0564139932,
-0.3960208893,
0.3528459072,
0.3537971079,
0.2845748067,
0.0749234334,
0.0083674984,
0.3456011415,
-0.6206632257,
0.248761043,
0.0343646184,
-0.2979736924,
0.2457844168,
0.5290742517,
0.367061168,
0.0263125338,
-0.7327587008,
0.5446326733,
-0.2185429335,
-0.2734860778,
-0.5272217393,
0.1691936553,
-0.027346082,
0.0508110039,
0.1646302044,
0.7565816045,
0.1527337432,
-0.3204234242,
0.2277200371,
0.2060837746,
-0.6126093268,
-0.293839246,
0.4150616825,
0.4997405708,
-0.7291168571,
0.6904860139,
-0.1696671844,
-0.7171671987,
0.6966766119,
0.6642913818,
1.1946566105,
-0.5769966245,
0.469829917,
0.5953491926,
0.4551241696,
-0.0135516832,
0.5114292502,
0.0519323796,
-0.3689025044,
-0.5767043233,
-0.7048182487,
-0.5341538787,
-0.0718909428,
-0.5291480422,
0.2861888409,
-0.7179141641,
-0.0342852883,
-0.1212716401,
0.0883413404,
-0.3355053961,
0.5853786469,
0.1248141229,
0.4532148242,
-0.8664144278,
0.4007711709,
1.0853441954,
-0.3741005957,
-0.867015481,
-0.1371537149,
0.1179605722,
-0.4958676696,
0.5103234649,
0.4846483171,
-0.640909791,
-0.1826126724,
-0.2122733593,
-0.2652409673,
0.5126199126,
0.1143832654,
-0.4846709669,
0.102670528,
0.3027606905,
1.0870974064,
-0.2993375957,
0.6193186641,
0.4816612601,
0.4988010824,
-0.2855315804,
-0.9031546712,
-0.1926215887,
-0.7241176367,
-0.0137167042,
-0.0287839696,
-0.449280709,
0.4211547971,
-0.4079170823,
-0.3278627694,
0.1539347023,
0.66552037,
-0.5073213577,
0.4281280339,
0.4207730293,
0.8326745033,
0.8730814457,
-0.1174148023,
0.7508829832,
0.0522381589,
0.2280111462,
1.0659019947,
-0.4050038755,
1.0339781046,
0.3747372031,
-0.2939141393,
0.8764134645,
0.2915840745,
0.0375791192,
0.1362891942,
0.3833912015,
-0.6638213992,
0.0682331324,
-0.0483959317,
-0.0298404936,
0.3402414024,
0.1436006129,
-0.280816853,
0.0428738482,
0.0816643387,
0.0905710608,
0.7132467628,
-0.1890346408,
1.0310858488,
-0.1338806599,
-1.2835960388,
0.0909046009,
0.2299769819,
0.7857015133,
-0.6451810598,
-0.2038808912,
-0.1736869514,
0.5433913469,
-0.6099079251,
-0.7006735802,
0.573069334,
0.3570513129,
-0.2489214242,
-0.192210868,
0.8593456745,
-0.6140629053,
-0.6080258489,
0.5435515642,
0.2502173781,
-0.2200377285,
0.2646475732,
-0.4032284319,
-0.1527090669,
-0.067722328,
-0.0159224831,
-0.1439087391,
0.0214833021,
0.2205006629,
0.3512608409,
0.6807107925,
0.2242610008,
-0.0707116947,
0.590606451,
0.3525006771,
-0.4382171035,
-0.6212643385,
-0.8133426905,
0.6643335819,
-0.2635937035,
-0.4926433861,
0.5992678404,
0.4628800452,
0.7808019519,
-0.3354711831,
1.2779210806,
-0.1054725125,
0.590010345,
-0.3776468635,
0.7812623382,
-0.4203212559,
-0.0709525794,
-0.4246712327,
-0.7582479715,
-0.6371223927,
0.709687233,
-0.0959296748,
-0.1019075066,
1.0480310917,
0.6759943366,
0.4347634315,
0.3429633677,
0.1555185765,
-0.1235385239,
0.0815517157,
0.4007693827,
0.9443845749,
-0.5997190475,
0.1341702044,
-0.3772464693,
-0.595698595,
-0.2316650003,
-0.4859011471,
-0.7331357002,
-0.4814072549,
-0.4499661922,
-0.5093390942,
0.2732470632,
0.9697285891,
0.0585929789,
-0.9503987432,
-0.3317531943,
-0.1927584708,
0.0171244964,
-0.3670721352,
-0.3384847045,
0.3848013878,
-0.718769908,
-1.0423812866,
0.2902956605,
0.757363379,
-0.0315010585,
-0.2793402672,
-0.0411192216,
-0.1154033095,
0.1558225602,
0.5195394754,
0.0703520998,
-0.4806139469,
-0.4533629715,
0.0837588608,
-0.3474366069,
-0.0734582022,
0.7685890198,
-0.573138833,
0.6367883682,
0.573707819,
1.0040440559,
-0.3275291622,
-0.1590008736,
0.7019677162,
-0.5548998713,
-0.2173714489,
0.541439116,
0.2482539713,
0.5061562657,
-0.6182462573,
0.5064117312,
0.2239895314,
-0.74244982,
-0.422711581,
-0.310195148,
-0.6633335352,
-0.013808771,
0.7200773954,
-0.3793982565,
0.015886195,
-0.0340548567,
-0.5285565853,
0.3139283955,
-0.1568470299,
1.0511511564,
1.0059595108,
-0.1742828935,
0.2650634944,
-0.3000157475,
0.3318641782,
0.9258689284,
-1.226069212,
-0.3181225955,
0.6079979539,
-0.0070081842,
0.4157930017,
0.6366623044,
-0.0025613797,
0.4777314961,
0.1454607993,
0.3194699883,
0.2621879578,
-0.556445241,
-0.6308899522,
0.3356251419,
-0.1847062111,
-0.142027542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17608v1
|
Linguistic Knowledge Can Enhance Encoder-Decoder Models (If You Let It)
| 2024-02-27T15:34:15 | 2024-02-27T15:34:15 |
Alessio Miaschi, Felice Dell'Orletta, Giulia Venturi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the impact of augmenting pre-trained
Encoder-Decoder models, specifically T5, with linguistic knowledge for the
prediction of a target task. In particular, we investigate whether fine-tuning
a T5 model on an intermediate task that predicts structural linguistic
properties of sentences modifies its performance in the target task of
predicting sentence-level complexity. Our study encompasses diverse experiments
conducted on Italian and English datasets, employing both monolingual and
multilingual T5 models at various sizes. Results obtained for both languages
and in cross-lingual configurations show that linguistically motivated
intermediate fine-tuning has generally a positive impact on target task
performance, especially when applied to smaller models and in scenarios with
limited data availability.
|
[
-0.2988586128,
-0.5797133446,
0.5106052756,
-0.0662013441,
-0.0868497938,
-0.1809036583,
-0.3603310883,
-0.7388599515,
-0.1878109574,
0.4494788647,
-0.4790483713,
-0.3966630697,
-0.9971256852,
0.3431199491,
-0.3777222037,
0.9232611656,
0.220373556,
0.2342019081,
-0.0713189468,
0.070873037,
-0.5952628851,
-0.3662664294,
-0.5891495347,
-0.4635687172,
0.5538657904,
0.3996120691,
0.6397938132,
0.7140719295,
0.5177903175,
0.303802073,
-0.2420023829,
0.1712024063,
-0.6212589741,
-0.0402392112,
-0.484983325,
-0.950912416,
-0.3383170962,
-0.3980030715,
0.3811044395,
0.9777766466,
0.2011366636,
0.0667309314,
0.2342212647,
0.4433712065,
-0.6029410958,
0.3114319444,
-0.7504713535,
-0.1252053827,
-0.1169966087,
-0.2768833935,
-0.4227512777,
0.046821855,
0.0684447214,
-0.5213560462,
0.3203395903,
-0.0461431779,
0.9769176841,
0.7782427073,
-0.3665851653,
-0.2957610786,
-0.7614328861,
0.5158758163,
-0.7294276953,
0.5492708087,
0.6385733485,
0.0534794554,
-0.0700126588,
-0.5277306437,
-0.3377553821,
-0.0611288249,
-0.4173913002,
-0.0295579582,
0.0591085739,
0.4942180514,
0.5931738019,
0.3056964874,
-0.1807355136,
0.1273269057,
-0.8435255289,
0.0348021425,
0.3471388519,
0.1585199982,
0.5746264458,
-0.0171262901,
0.370056808,
0.3201053739,
-0.645703733,
0.1647596359,
0.3099272251,
0.3858458996,
-0.0596182011,
0.7444035411,
-0.4649657905,
0.8974850774,
0.3858601153,
0.0454017073,
0.1915883124,
-0.5945618749,
-0.223517254,
0.1816922277,
0.387409091,
0.0277687572,
0.4726073444,
-0.3490552008,
-0.2077269107,
0.2770376801,
0.3397205472,
-0.7670964003,
-0.2867396772,
0.0385520533,
-0.1954417527,
-0.0620329082,
-0.0115779862,
-0.1783275008,
-0.1168873087,
-0.3473970294,
0.4560470283,
-0.7870993018,
0.0361135863,
0.6293517351,
-0.1919889301,
-0.0168299861,
0.1812654883,
-1.0471622944,
0.1700370759,
0.766255796,
0.6016692519,
0.4224005044,
-0.4544136524,
-0.5451692939,
0.2761741579,
-0.3817582726,
0.5340082049,
-1.1166309118,
-0.0863101557,
-0.1397051662,
0.1130950153,
-0.0890362784,
-0.3205211759,
0.5798960328,
-0.3963442743,
0.0837884396,
-0.3215461671,
-0.6093714237,
-0.1464035809,
0.2501897514,
-0.8877431154,
0.6873260736,
-0.0097078579,
-0.7515684962,
0.7032841444,
-0.6867927313,
-0.7865270972,
-0.0617473125,
0.0812811181,
-0.1787551194,
0.5276963115,
0.4960651696,
0.5545694232,
-0.082714051,
0.1223957613,
-0.2664963007,
-0.4324248135,
0.1178226173,
-0.1211791262,
0.3005737066,
0.02164107,
-0.2002162188,
-0.0254944302,
-0.7806742191,
-0.198095113,
-0.4045493901,
-0.468768537,
-0.2381883711,
0.0926069543,
-0.3303586841,
0.1149494201,
0.418964088,
-0.6067904234,
0.0228379685,
-0.7677353024,
0.5069486499,
0.4038385749,
0.0307442211,
0.5178125501,
-0.3228159249,
0.5132899284,
0.3278971314,
0.0441769734,
-0.403018415,
-0.2877993286,
-1.0086016655,
0.1324492842,
0.6285498738,
0.3431257904,
-1.0645413399,
0.2973670065,
-0.5055513978,
-0.4117239416,
-0.7592355609,
0.096218206,
0.5676085353,
0.1378587931,
0.4287372231,
-0.1257347316,
-0.7602283359,
-0.8436841369,
-0.6555995345,
0.0299109146,
-0.0514102392,
0.0632556155,
0.4453908801,
-0.1305978298,
0.651442945,
-0.271494478,
-0.4825869501,
-0.504709959,
-0.0034682902,
0.3284228146,
0.6102257371,
0.3482379019,
-0.6376721859,
-0.4723990262,
0.2281910032,
-0.6187024713,
-0.020513583,
0.0755220652,
0.1638804525,
0.0187651031,
0.5183979273,
-0.5920478702,
0.2512863576,
0.4190044105,
-0.515424192,
0.2448402792,
-0.6544885635,
0.2783874571,
-1.1697192192,
-0.2221705765,
0.1004224494,
0.0683833361,
-0.9185905457,
0.0131321298,
0.1167396829,
0.03136345,
-0.1906319112,
0.1753204167,
-0.5192742944,
-0.0356796533,
-0.0627107993,
-0.501742363,
-0.0740430281,
0.3129221797,
0.150620997,
0.8319336176,
0.4317031503,
-0.572107017,
-0.1903431118,
0.0432431698,
-0.7372769713,
0.1508063227,
-0.9272254705,
0.0774487406,
-0.3542504311,
-0.3469949663,
-0.7109414339,
-0.5433247685,
-0.2583710253,
-0.6906707883,
0.3101036549,
-0.227503255,
-0.4711835682,
-0.0625066459,
0.2761214375,
0.4044356048,
0.3608926833,
-0.2878863811,
0.777374208,
0.1778376698,
0.0470222533,
-0.4766490757,
-0.9194068909,
0.0131730679,
-0.1593161076,
-0.5708955526,
0.4115310013,
0.055865746,
-0.0274102502,
-0.0372746587,
0.1156670973,
-0.1182833314,
0.02854109,
0.2704724073,
-0.1450211108,
-0.108132422,
0.3703245521,
0.2673281729,
-0.0400535539,
0.0227383953,
-0.3471185863,
0.5082990527,
-0.1472363621,
-0.0438423194,
-0.1516126245,
0.0465954393,
0.5383806825,
-0.4377849698,
0.8662308455,
0.5194582343,
-0.4882256687,
-0.2147142291,
-0.5427706242,
-0.2559756339,
-0.5101404786,
0.6278184056,
-1.0487107038,
-0.9010759592,
0.3834952712,
0.2157130092,
-0.2365059406,
0.3258334994,
0.3652858734,
-0.1270343214,
1.0585805178,
0.9970362782,
-0.1496279091,
0.6328148842,
-0.218413949,
0.2491234988,
-0.5756335258,
-0.2696662843,
-0.5820505023,
-0.4273697436,
-0.585997045,
-0.3335778415,
0.4838791192,
0.0740238279,
-0.3609144986,
0.452581495,
-0.2447978109,
0.703950882,
0.337906599,
0.6688737273,
0.4345284998,
-0.0919670835,
0.1100611389,
-0.0258333534,
-1.052054286,
-0.246807009,
1.1646193266,
0.2642330229,
0.7252245545,
-0.0696756691,
0.461122334,
0.1000438854,
-0.3532157838,
-0.5492238998,
0.3186374605,
-0.5615840554,
-0.483153075,
-0.3913064301,
-0.3194841444,
-0.8609268069,
-0.1791062802,
-0.2310902178,
-0.4720471203,
0.3476383984,
0.1814949214,
-0.4576687813,
0.0310392436,
-0.8473885655,
0.8062135577,
-0.0914435238,
-0.3319038749,
-0.4543777108,
-0.3988197744,
-0.0942722037,
0.018273823,
0.2128269225,
-0.0450050198,
-0.3009292483,
0.5862564445,
-0.199190259,
0.9735462666,
-0.0802784488,
0.0657241493,
-0.2515962124,
0.0775277168,
0.4408054352,
-0.1246260181,
-0.3959496617,
0.091248177,
-0.1188465506,
-0.5066304803,
-0.7678264976,
0.4647112787,
-0.9137654305,
-0.6611691713,
0.2578439415,
-0.7318906188,
-0.3670209646,
0.3420271575,
0.5269425511,
0.5373179913,
0.0184864867,
0.4630407095,
0.7125421166,
0.1386077106,
0.2854737639,
0.4131345451,
0.431340307,
-0.1192452312,
0.6442576647,
0.4551469982,
0.3394613564,
0.6063544154,
-0.0661651716,
0.0925745443,
-0.7918024659,
-0.2134679705,
-0.0198128466,
-0.8310748935,
-0.0390406027,
-0.7691106796,
-0.0762719885,
-0.2108349055,
-0.0965638012,
-0.3688525259,
-0.3609128892,
-0.4341271818,
-0.4399095774,
0.3120107055,
0.9721081853,
0.1332596093,
0.2581292987,
-0.7459434271,
0.0880088508,
-0.1939758062,
0.5436098576,
-0.3441130519,
-0.7121701837,
-0.7458711267,
0.2586450875,
0.2412714064,
-0.5870184302,
0.4440328777,
0.5101987123,
0.4212613106,
0.2400811762,
-0.0699042529,
0.7378939986,
-0.4787779748,
0.7272853851,
0.0018919235,
-1.0627397299,
0.6426666379,
-0.4564609528,
0.7614243627,
0.5341504812,
0.5387648344,
-0.0637518913,
-0.4920448661,
-0.4954087734,
-0.4418097138,
0.6881083846,
0.1446074843,
0.1747262478,
0.1402289271,
0.4640755951,
0.1949252039,
0.130879879,
-0.6085457206,
0.3549560606,
-0.0953886881,
-0.455437988,
-0.4529826343,
-0.4456386566,
0.2482063472,
-0.497561276,
0.526039362,
-0.1344399899,
0.1818963736,
0.1302061826,
-0.2717577219,
-0.0680311248,
0.3231790364,
0.4836630523,
0.6253572702,
0.0146755734,
-0.0089976043,
0.5751868486,
-0.2553310096,
-0.0146742249,
-0.1384126693,
-0.2071899176,
-0.06404493,
0.7260487676,
1.1513328552,
0.4318686128,
-0.4603073895,
0.0200050753,
0.1216549054,
-0.2837741375,
-0.1140988097,
0.3374580145,
-0.050975211,
0.3787912428,
0.1090916991,
0.2139136493,
0.3044998646,
-0.7975355983,
0.1267732382,
0.0445404388,
-0.5209517479,
-0.524451077,
0.6145719886,
0.0847702101,
-0.1967109889,
0.3041863441,
0.1732180268,
-0.7489592433,
0.7352055311,
0.4855023921,
0.6494435072,
-0.2439309657,
-0.3282980025,
0.5420822501,
0.5308623314,
-0.1297867,
0.3411821723,
-0.0413276963,
-0.9950353503,
-0.6008127332,
-0.5687992573,
-0.0493068956,
-0.2659110129,
-0.5555987954,
0.4680474699,
-0.0717460364,
-0.0832206011,
0.132339716,
-0.0075941556,
-0.864715755,
0.5406590104,
-0.0715506449,
0.8026632667,
-0.5898914337,
1.1365853548,
0.794367075,
-0.4309702516,
-0.8951394558,
0.1128755882,
-0.6549698114,
-0.4169806242,
0.8806582689,
0.1033208296,
-0.1009384543,
0.1463983059,
-0.2357315719,
-0.9526236653,
0.810643971,
0.5932433605,
-0.6444219947,
-0.5028349161,
0.5706909895,
0.8430720568,
-0.5635520816,
0.4074561596,
0.8607226014,
0.4388002753,
0.0021881987,
-1.3315782547,
-0.1303177029,
-0.4513592124,
0.1371366531,
0.1996836513,
-0.2642436922,
0.7518575191,
-0.4116092622,
-0.2217062861,
-0.1061889306,
0.6891182065,
-0.4049220085,
-0.114693515,
0.4083354175,
0.5454737544,
0.5468940139,
-0.3160889149,
1.1195683479,
-0.7807773948,
0.0837930888,
1.0866615772,
0.234252274,
0.8852176666,
0.3233523369,
0.0428252071,
0.4960252047,
0.6555968523,
0.1035879925,
0.7086648941,
-0.2507508695,
-0.0051349951,
-0.4586328864,
-0.1462419331,
-0.2929155231,
0.5535770655,
0.7235761285,
-0.504647553,
0.1169542074,
0.3653111458,
-0.2391308099,
0.1760565639,
-0.6191680431,
1.0899032354,
-0.0487477258,
-0.8962562084,
0.710518539,
0.0614447072,
0.6495214701,
-0.3957416415,
0.1558808386,
-0.0403187796,
0.4669574797,
-0.4150336087,
-0.8288368583,
0.6371067762,
-0.2273537964,
-0.4414946735,
-0.0526632778,
1.0089424849,
-0.8663993478,
-0.5188993216,
0.3774424791,
0.3105689287,
-0.1853367537,
-0.1202737018,
-0.2615599334,
0.0974435732,
0.071233891,
-0.0420636795,
0.1676012725,
0.6155984402,
0.2791125476,
0.7928754091,
0.4813971519,
0.1666661054,
0.1392518431,
-0.0220334735,
0.9089361429,
-0.5815582275,
-0.5914395452,
-0.8799476624,
0.5860665441,
-0.0012044245,
-0.0938348472,
0.5801613927,
0.5341041684,
1.1854089499,
-0.3644589186,
0.9483975768,
-0.050942868,
0.44324705,
-0.7209166884,
0.614716351,
-0.6249682307,
0.3219566047,
0.0980288759,
-0.503998518,
-0.1421275884,
0.2131039351,
-0.7633872628,
0.060557764,
0.6389315724,
0.9538552761,
-0.0444108881,
0.1126524508,
0.6214778423,
0.4143562913,
0.0010668488,
0.8547036648,
0.5152260661,
-0.4516119659,
0.4746602178,
-0.4527485073,
0.1562579125,
0.1578903347,
-0.4621727467,
-1.3295023441,
-0.6908469796,
-0.0054897731,
-0.2038237751,
0.5953399539,
0.741440773,
0.6331409812,
-0.704924047,
-0.2435015142,
-0.3751829267,
-0.0586613677,
-0.047009483,
-0.092556946,
-0.0627573878,
-0.7352849841,
-0.9406250715,
0.3682313561,
0.1516323686,
-0.1623870283,
0.092271328,
-0.072752893,
-0.0180359595,
0.0714234486,
0.6993911862,
-0.2373314351,
-0.7134836912,
-0.3268525898,
0.0039457697,
0.0339295976,
0.020785721,
0.7208131552,
-0.6372906566,
0.470299691,
0.6883574128,
0.6098969579,
0.4990832508,
-0.0530912578,
1.2217823267,
-0.7390581965,
0.2154044658,
0.0979023874,
0.5985164642,
0.1344180554,
-0.6906909943,
0.639085412,
-0.0279281922,
-0.2248094827,
-0.4839990735,
0.1060825884,
-0.3898898363,
-0.3508544266,
1.0718557835,
-0.2196280807,
-0.2538796067,
-0.253651619,
-0.0723969042,
0.3222422004,
-0.1944638491,
0.730333209,
0.9314349294,
0.2593868673,
-0.648827672,
-0.4816463292,
0.7726565599,
0.6108743548,
-0.7375363111,
-0.235196352,
0.236223653,
0.1804491431,
-0.1189611107,
0.2480289936,
0.1597906947,
0.4340693355,
0.0239475891,
-0.1402773708,
-0.3135919273,
-0.5343949199,
-0.2591331899,
0.4318245351,
0.1569037437,
0.1863729507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17583v1
|
FaultProfIT: Hierarchical Fault Profiling of Incident Tickets in Large-scale Cloud Systems
| 2024-02-27T15:14:19 | 2024-02-27T15:14:19 |
Junjie Huang, Jinyang Liu, Zhuangbin Chen, Zhihan Jiang, Yichen LI, Jiazhen Gu, Cong Feng, Zengyin Yang, Yongqiang Yang, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Postmortem analysis is essential in the management of incidents within cloud
systems, which provides valuable insights to improve system's reliability and
robustness. At CloudA, fault pattern profiling is performed during the
postmortem phase, which involves the classification of incidents' faults into
unique categories, referred to as fault pattern. By aggregating and analyzing
these fault patterns, engineers can discern common faults, vulnerable
components and emerging fault trends. However, this process is currently
conducted by manual labeling, which has inherent drawbacks. On the one hand,
the sheer volume of incidents means only the most severe ones are analyzed,
causing a skewed overview of fault patterns. On the other hand, the complexity
of the task demands extensive domain knowledge, which leads to errors and
inconsistencies. To address these limitations, we propose an automated
approach, named FaultProfIT, for Fault pattern Profiling of Incident Tickets.
It leverages hierarchy-guided contrastive learning to train a hierarchy-aware
incident encoder and predicts fault patterns with enhanced incident
representations. We evaluate FaultProfIT using the production incidents from
CloudA. The results demonstrate that FaultProfIT outperforms state-of-the-art
methods. Our ablation study and analysis also verify the effectiveness of
hierarchy-guided contrastive learning. Additionally, we have deployed
FaultProfIT at CloudA for six months. To date, FaultProfIT has analyzed 10,000+
incidents from 30+ cloud services, successfully revealing several fault trends
that have informed system improvements.
|
[
-0.4873482883,
-0.6913560033,
0.3810067773,
0.4450888932,
-0.3210528791,
0.0638577044,
0.5727561712,
-0.4881353974,
0.1993278265,
0.4190889895,
-0.8803923726,
-0.2475953996,
-0.3133274615,
-0.2893395722,
-0.4603438973,
1.1710218191,
0.0142264878,
0.0494698696,
-0.4949054718,
0.0864957795,
-0.3574961424,
-1.0259394646,
-0.960013628,
-0.1812886596,
0.3307336271,
0.3668926358,
0.5588366985,
0.6111514568,
0.918222785,
0.424774766,
-0.034251377,
0.1000213847,
-0.0909699723,
0.0651144832,
-0.057183139,
-0.1748372763,
-0.3675628006,
-0.3752660155,
0.3561681509,
0.6344742775,
-0.3032699227,
-0.0060474863,
0.2315194905,
0.3740980923,
-0.853238225,
0.1409212202,
-0.5840272307,
0.1889827549,
-0.0821018964,
-0.2953344882,
0.0034914564,
-0.4217533767,
-0.1518958509,
-0.5320391655,
0.4773358405,
-0.0990391001,
0.7202013731,
0.4282718897,
-0.2090931684,
-0.1391172856,
-0.6571146846,
0.6113229394,
-0.3278746605,
0.1332233697,
0.3351067007,
0.4777665436,
-0.2329914868,
-0.6008108854,
-0.2563176453,
0.1367452145,
-0.1527580917,
0.126928851,
0.1960393339,
-0.0353587382,
0.1482005566,
0.466063261,
-0.7536177039,
0.4148457348,
-0.0061829323,
-0.4300343692,
0.6069098711,
0.4677310586,
-0.0494979806,
-0.0565109812,
-0.5323824286,
-0.1346808672,
-0.4484974146,
0.0025262143,
0.2499046773,
-0.1688019186,
0.0752613395,
-0.2476175129,
-0.2341814339,
0.4183570445,
0.1399849206,
-0.0854376033,
0.478158325,
-0.0355649628,
-0.505643189,
0.202511996,
0.7362854481,
0.0721458346,
-0.2504634857,
-0.2764739394,
-0.3361512721,
-0.0570098087,
0.7064266205,
-0.9302923083,
-0.551730454,
0.398976177,
-0.2879776955,
-0.5331344604,
0.3840774894,
-1.0908931494,
-0.9130965471,
-0.191448167,
0.4651417434,
-0.3795704246,
-0.3225677907,
-0.0271167811,
0.0459062755,
0.2085667551,
0.3095980287,
-0.3066533804,
0.0994359851,
0.8340450525,
0.7608311772,
0.0143210804,
-0.355877161,
-0.7846785188,
0.1454169601,
-0.5044047236,
1.0059144497,
-0.237735182,
-0.2148476988,
0.3943345249,
0.1301185787,
0.0444251858,
-0.846331656,
0.8402517438,
-0.5693349242,
-0.310749948,
-0.2082284242,
-0.1544346511,
-0.2715538144,
0.3829244971,
-0.4808098078,
0.8828822374,
0.1504374743,
-0.5407298803,
0.2955811322,
-0.4357427955,
-0.4400776327,
0.325537324,
-0.248423934,
-0.883594811,
0.0229837932,
0.1764209569,
0.5592766404,
-0.0047667213,
0.3598112166,
-0.1957149059,
-0.1703188121,
-0.2440970689,
0.2920312583,
0.6242627501,
0.2860819101,
-0.5146184564,
0.1068526134,
-0.990047276,
-0.1624872684,
0.1326284111,
-0.0455074199,
-0.4663496614,
0.2618334889,
0.1200792938,
0.2862073183,
0.148082152,
-0.5660598278,
-0.1362187117,
-0.1628000885,
0.0346743129,
0.699426055,
0.3162288666,
0.0315005332,
-0.4123626947,
0.4939820468,
0.6323641539,
0.7319982648,
-0.3260393739,
-0.0264968928,
-0.9138535261,
-0.0637516603,
-0.2956849933,
0.727517724,
-0.696688056,
0.6797863841,
0.0441137478,
-0.5954287648,
0.0069616777,
-0.0512897223,
0.4943395257,
0.7447382808,
0.5735868812,
-0.4596158862,
-1.1281793118,
-1.1979081631,
-0.013238146,
-0.3069332838,
-0.0698583499,
0.0408376753,
0.4949863553,
-0.477668345,
0.7710732818,
-0.5954754353,
-0.6176875234,
0.2793319523,
0.6029605269,
-0.0752712637,
0.7460526824,
0.5206875801,
-0.857593894,
0.1070525795,
0.185647741,
-0.762372613,
-0.1933193952,
-0.370587796,
-0.0264816508,
0.2617324591,
0.7180604339,
0.0033493,
0.0639041588,
0.5386759043,
-0.4865676761,
0.6033906341,
-0.0051179775,
0.4713477194,
-0.7789136171,
0.1605922431,
-0.1443337351,
-0.0734700859,
-0.6364348531,
0.0917301551,
0.2331908792,
-0.0885733142,
-0.3390959501,
-0.3724322021,
-0.3007833064,
-0.3990355432,
-0.288179934,
-0.435287416,
-0.2493644953,
0.5109881163,
-0.0376945324,
0.4237077236,
0.5432810783,
-0.5992158055,
0.1446762979,
0.198999837,
-0.4704756141,
0.694206357,
-0.3754134178,
0.2253336161,
-0.2359170914,
0.001347358,
-0.959169507,
-0.163549155,
-0.0549737327,
0.0104288459,
-0.0002185922,
-0.1724536717,
-0.5338853002,
-0.0588204972,
-0.0490149185,
0.1917716414,
0.3985797465,
-0.3264065683,
0.7597082257,
0.4295313358,
-0.3707898557,
-0.3665036559,
-0.3861290216,
0.100964725,
-0.2169592083,
-0.6868346334,
0.345302254,
-0.024805611,
-0.2531110644,
-0.2686724365,
-0.2457990199,
-0.4618677497,
0.5389645696,
0.7828122377,
-0.0363129377,
-0.3197852075,
-0.0547775328,
-0.0955948457,
-0.2086644918,
0.0955234915,
-0.0813489333,
0.7282916307,
-0.3064256608,
-0.1728620231,
-0.5021342635,
0.6077957153,
0.6796166301,
-0.1480621845,
0.5997305512,
0.3802761436,
-0.4891970456,
-0.2078261077,
-0.6811372638,
-0.0424940251,
-0.5043224096,
0.4741353095,
-0.2647796273,
-0.6469575167,
0.8207194209,
-0.3441513181,
0.1553275734,
0.6921787858,
0.1496105641,
-0.2159445137,
0.8089913726,
0.8287395239,
-0.165305689,
0.6002796888,
-0.1917794943,
-0.0360994786,
-0.3237376511,
-0.5023909807,
-0.8817946911,
-0.0979238376,
-0.1519614607,
-0.1060477421,
0.565733254,
0.3561843336,
-0.5949114561,
0.1156427264,
-0.1806377172,
0.5379061103,
0.0076544201,
0.0542252064,
0.3338314593,
-0.1235887334,
0.3318782151,
0.1760105789,
-0.4400387704,
-0.1830328107,
0.137003988,
0.1957417876,
0.1703985333,
-0.054619424,
0.6823685765,
0.3070661128,
0.4265865982,
-0.5417736769,
0.3615857661,
-0.2312279642,
-0.2316858619,
-0.2241960466,
-0.3918617666,
-0.7405199409,
0.0985778645,
0.028522525,
-0.2963977456,
0.7236158848,
0.2597241998,
-0.298619777,
0.1182503253,
-0.6462771297,
0.8548724651,
-0.1116066128,
0.1323847473,
-0.1428871006,
-0.4048600793,
0.2743917704,
-0.5618656278,
0.4624255002,
0.5617358685,
0.0088794315,
1.0284808874,
-0.840734005,
0.8882241249,
-0.3756354749,
-0.1923509091,
0.105095908,
0.2517774105,
0.8889292479,
-0.3148599863,
-0.0963984877,
0.2806954682,
-0.2155829817,
-0.3435276449,
-0.5241738558,
0.5772200227,
-0.7719722986,
-0.350915283,
-0.3238774836,
-0.2299645692,
-0.4313377142,
0.0309458598,
0.2046459317,
0.4034987986,
-0.0606913678,
0.2293194979,
0.6752058268,
-0.1915891767,
0.6864407659,
0.749651432,
0.2441641986,
-0.3948208094,
0.7838509083,
0.3100717962,
-0.2096024007,
0.1925492585,
0.1134506539,
0.1632520109,
-0.9690882564,
-0.1886122525,
-0.0797657296,
-0.5902426839,
-0.4598498642,
-0.8847358227,
-0.2609865665,
-0.2591632307,
-0.4892003238,
-0.4014379382,
-0.0756520554,
0.0137137687,
-0.2005145699,
0.2203322649,
0.4143789411,
0.0322500318,
0.7028596401,
-0.7655479908,
0.1995146573,
0.1184014827,
0.3341807723,
-0.1205338538,
-0.3068887591,
-0.2847022414,
-0.4014436603,
-0.5502915978,
-0.7918624878,
0.3353630602,
0.4268365502,
0.5357156992,
0.6896530986,
0.0701600909,
1.0961703062,
-0.4115762711,
0.8749943972,
0.269718796,
-1.0464528799,
0.8992696404,
-0.3876685202,
-0.0238141101,
0.6615968347,
0.6037251353,
-0.4725772738,
-0.5308581591,
-0.743042469,
-1.031078577,
0.771248579,
-0.0775039643,
-0.2403769195,
0.2451539338,
0.4513670504,
0.1344958693,
0.1294706166,
-0.2160876989,
-0.2962482572,
-0.4585181773,
-0.0191002339,
-0.3126748204,
-0.1816319823,
-0.0560858771,
-0.0337845609,
0.591827929,
-0.1726344824,
-0.0625546053,
0.3364470899,
-0.1877257675,
-0.4246887863,
-0.1310535967,
0.543612957,
0.6327222586,
-0.1892164946,
0.2036259472,
0.0748072192,
-0.7329342961,
-0.0657679588,
0.1522904634,
-0.0880120471,
-0.0624895543,
0.5554106832,
0.3794519305,
0.0419605896,
-0.6119072437,
0.5107867718,
0.3048080206,
-0.4553648531,
-0.5868225098,
0.0514667034,
-0.2194604427,
0.2558715641,
0.7014510036,
-0.1006249562,
0.492737174,
-0.6519747376,
0.5804969072,
0.2806141675,
-0.530467391,
-0.0553500541,
0.3452784717,
0.1741818637,
-0.314960897,
0.547286272,
0.1561693698,
-0.7053679228,
1.1386697292,
0.222140342,
1.0893491507,
-0.8365246058,
0.3313353062,
0.342941165,
0.39791134,
-0.0041711815,
0.1967846304,
-0.0245812628,
-0.6131705046,
-0.2788598239,
-0.9674010277,
-0.338101238,
0.6981663704,
-0.5555331707,
-0.0199817456,
-0.7503449321,
0.3029541671,
0.0064365948,
-0.0116266264,
-0.3495129049,
0.5121912956,
-0.1245743334,
0.6556231976,
-1.2307339907,
0.4367268085,
0.7914349437,
-0.2957503498,
-0.7011015415,
-0.0187454131,
0.0424311347,
-0.395655036,
0.5872357488,
0.1725736856,
0.2184568197,
-0.0388818905,
-0.3079524934,
-0.6150727272,
1.0945036411,
0.256392926,
-0.7317420244,
0.4188737273,
0.187823087,
0.6095551848,
-0.2848549485,
0.1241353601,
0.5633662343,
0.3795009255,
0.2285535038,
-0.5525810719,
0.1275613904,
-0.3005723357,
-0.2282349318,
0.4973967373,
-0.5736075044,
0.6774161458,
0.1893040836,
-0.1803122312,
-0.4189230502,
0.4417471588,
0.0133461673,
0.5923432708,
0.9379778504,
0.5339393616,
0.6503962278,
-0.0740472376,
0.94349581,
-0.023040643,
0.1692242175,
0.8008651733,
-0.1008581668,
0.6115412712,
0.5348511934,
0.0941693187,
0.775634408,
0.8783943653,
-0.2007943392,
0.5125472546,
0.0834235549,
-0.1018473506,
-0.5909905434,
-0.0328145958,
-0.2978268862,
0.0851263106,
0.1250925958,
-0.3573133349,
-0.3831734955,
0.089334622,
-0.0391609259,
-0.4162779748,
-0.6918455958,
1.1133009195,
-0.0857505649,
-0.5715628266,
0.5952188373,
-0.1444366276,
0.4716595709,
-0.6124043465,
0.0016916239,
-0.5886440873,
0.3114643693,
-0.667538166,
-0.4636377692,
0.7922350764,
-0.0415027551,
-0.1688444614,
-0.1630249321,
0.449862659,
0.0226424299,
-0.2197525799,
0.2260205001,
0.1665383577,
0.1324554235,
-0.5200949907,
-0.3487950265,
0.1149545833,
-0.2540577948,
-0.1305150539,
0.5432408452,
0.3018200397,
-0.4782907367,
0.4536755979,
0.5176646113,
-0.1794609129,
-0.1559993923,
0.0441978872,
0.9528862238,
-0.4782803357,
-0.7651816607,
-0.6794689894,
0.8771187067,
-0.1710097492,
-0.4113960266,
0.3899489343,
0.6134651899,
0.6014274359,
-0.1442615837,
0.5993970037,
0.0616714731,
0.016094923,
-0.4225659966,
0.4603066146,
-0.6380211115,
0.2521910667,
-0.321585685,
-0.6011541486,
-0.4157192111,
0.4148632288,
-0.0875084773,
-0.24870947,
0.7612103224,
0.9094263911,
0.0505144671,
0.2007703334,
0.1690622568,
0.3497907221,
0.3958365917,
0.5135579705,
0.9862391353,
-0.5245917439,
0.6870598793,
-0.3052786291,
-0.6298898458,
-0.4408399165,
-0.8726867437,
-0.392907083,
-0.7601213455,
-0.7961560488,
-0.0833353251,
0.1589972526,
0.212196663,
0.8264732361,
-1.0360803604,
0.0527755767,
-0.4704245925,
-0.0564717837,
-0.5382061005,
-0.2403042167,
0.515294373,
-0.5406573415,
-0.2441552877,
0.3603285849,
0.141676113,
-0.1059370413,
-0.0198753029,
0.07180015,
0.3220595717,
-0.1001715809,
0.656888485,
0.1251872182,
0.021842666,
-0.3056222498,
-0.4788793027,
-0.0388987325,
-0.1281620711,
1.1744451523,
-0.7285590768,
-0.3203318715,
0.6596090198,
0.7812524438,
0.3711898923,
0.1542660147,
0.3472872078,
-0.9015653729,
0.0676492751,
0.3795867562,
0.348993361,
0.159420535,
-0.8363136053,
0.4562451541,
0.4911656082,
-0.6448498368,
-1.0102225542,
0.3066456914,
-1.0838124752,
-0.5927515626,
0.9287894368,
-0.1012132764,
0.066909954,
-0.6745721698,
-0.0327772871,
0.1567110568,
0.1488862783,
1.0844012499,
0.3727092445,
-0.2877644897,
-0.5086501837,
-0.1854623258,
0.8326573968,
0.2985076904,
-1.317248702,
-0.0660570934,
0.6062842011,
0.109466143,
0.5435129404,
0.2757155597,
-0.3130934238,
0.4050537348,
0.0616849735,
0.1578390449,
-0.3231070638,
-0.5046893358,
-0.6713430285,
0.9092181921,
-0.352131784,
-0.2804977894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17574v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17574v3
|
Agent-Pro: Learning to Evolve via Policy-Level Reflection and Optimization
| 2024-02-27T15:09:20 | 2024-06-06T18:40:47 |
Wenqi Zhang, Ke Tang, Hai Wu, Mengna Wang, Yongliang Shen, Guiyang Hou, Zeqi Tan, Peng Li, Yueting Zhuang, Weiming Lu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit robust problem-solving capabilities for
diverse tasks. However, most LLM-based agents are designed as specific task
solvers with sophisticated prompt engineering, rather than agents capable of
learning and evolving through interactions. These task solvers necessitate
manually crafted prompts to inform task rules and regulate LLM behaviors,
inherently incapacitating to address complex dynamic scenarios e.g., large
interactive games. In light of this, we propose Agent-Pro: an LLM-based Agent
with Policy-level Reflection and Optimization that can learn a wealth of
expertise from interactive experiences and progressively elevate its behavioral
policy. Specifically, it involves a dynamic belief generation and reflection
process for policy evolution. Rather than action-level reflection, Agent-Pro
iteratively reflects on past trajectories and beliefs, fine-tuning its
irrational beliefs for a better policy. Moreover, a depth-first search is
employed for policy optimization, ensuring continual enhancement in policy
payoffs. Agent-Pro is evaluated across two games: Blackjack and Texas Hold'em,
outperforming vanilla LLM and specialized models. Our results show Agent-Pro
can learn and evolve in complex and dynamic scenes, which also benefits
numerous LLM-based applications.
|
[
-0.3661668301,
-0.8321251273,
0.7122513056,
0.2155389488,
0.0454677418,
0.6739730835,
-0.2439776808,
-0.2936483026,
0.043874938,
0.5503230095,
-0.7451245785,
-0.3363852203,
-0.2744039595,
0.081322439,
0.5902597308,
1.1126389503,
0.0343591645,
-0.1470659822,
-0.0155511536,
0.2698560655,
-0.6509357095,
0.0242176615,
-1.0707455873,
-0.5750823617,
0.3417666852,
0.343490988,
0.7807366252,
0.4072240293,
0.1416230947,
0.3308948874,
0.1247445717,
0.8548586369,
-0.6891847253,
0.378808856,
-0.4657820463,
-0.416767031,
-0.5855305791,
0.0120335566,
0.4636823237,
0.1007400826,
-0.2118780762,
-0.218898043,
0.0599098504,
0.2395124286,
-0.6115266681,
0.5708533525,
-0.6734473705,
0.0848338008,
0.4768746495,
-0.4420701563,
-0.4374946654,
-0.326734364,
0.234875977,
-0.9238941073,
-0.1730758697,
-0.094581075,
0.7005180717,
0.2422439754,
-0.3844495714,
-0.3338558376,
-1.0372899771,
0.5923306942,
-0.3080959916,
0.0866632462,
-0.0551469922,
0.5792886615,
-0.702606678,
-0.3918362856,
-0.596221447,
-0.6139597297,
0.3692705333,
0.2706804872,
0.0659606084,
0.4055009782,
-0.0062576928,
-0.0695748553,
-0.0867530257,
0.1451117247,
0.2923591435,
-0.0196836125,
0.7591048479,
0.3094356358,
0.114657782,
0.4681070447,
-0.1172355488,
-0.3003429174,
-0.7028864026,
0.3288051188,
0.4189222157,
0.3700655699,
0.2256124914,
0.0254717041,
-0.0725070834,
0.2975974977,
0.1499776244,
-0.4965984821,
0.1028197929,
0.1801998168,
0.2843790054,
-0.035536062,
0.448146373,
0.0250306875,
0.436298281,
-0.2360090166,
-0.5267478824,
-0.0788981766,
0.6195856929,
-0.4054160714,
0.0249159485,
0.2136688381,
-0.0748582557,
-0.4571596682,
-0.0087534348,
-0.8481068015,
-0.7677411437,
-0.3566192091,
0.7864844799,
-0.1771736294,
-0.3015019596,
0.3481612206,
-0.1215688959,
0.3304607868,
0.5944527984,
-0.5192959905,
0.3141985536,
0.9014988542,
0.5757626891,
-0.2078395486,
-0.3060660958,
-0.7739485502,
0.2223714888,
-0.525218308,
0.7485116124,
-0.8398250341,
-0.5518603921,
0.3672936261,
-0.034347754,
0.1230301112,
-0.6904532313,
0.2609714568,
-0.6106317043,
-0.2065008432,
-0.2241020799,
-0.304563731,
-0.0228072014,
0.5183776617,
-0.4564410448,
0.8492611051,
0.0848683268,
-0.0645014644,
0.6059377789,
-1.093809247,
-0.2476370782,
0.4587751627,
-0.3907662034,
-0.3568412364,
0.3856235147,
-0.0481470339,
0.015099708,
-0.1975615025,
0.2372186184,
-0.3423123658,
-0.3459314406,
0.1768103242,
-0.1710625291,
0.3165795505,
0.0885175988,
-0.5646767616,
0.2132855803,
-0.5013913512,
-0.2348398864,
0.2659290135,
-0.4304685295,
-0.0672203898,
0.6705000997,
-0.5679278374,
0.2658323348,
0.408446461,
-0.6016705036,
0.5362948775,
-0.3790876567,
0.1537027657,
0.8211259246,
0.2954526246,
0.342312634,
-0.4974702001,
0.7761383653,
-0.0844689012,
0.433131367,
0.0399245434,
-0.238342911,
-0.6044766307,
-0.2315898985,
-0.3204752207,
0.7118830681,
-0.9500015974,
0.1630458236,
-0.1508082151,
-0.3616873622,
-0.4003287554,
-0.0316143744,
0.3236116171,
0.2944616377,
0.3823325634,
-0.1839137971,
-0.1060758233,
-0.6603340507,
-0.4083409607,
-0.1332932115,
0.2966541648,
0.6578527093,
0.5231568813,
-0.1474421024,
0.9044044018,
-0.590683639,
-0.3932617903,
-0.323255688,
0.1115043312,
0.0723202527,
0.3272167444,
0.42354092,
-0.4907802045,
-0.6034610271,
0.2111365199,
-0.5853851438,
-0.0100745913,
-0.4881857634,
-0.1321492791,
0.0160187595,
0.1901335418,
-0.7122603655,
0.1177517772,
-0.0198349785,
-0.4775629938,
0.7563920021,
-0.5699548721,
-0.1385189742,
-0.5892455578,
-0.362487793,
-0.1471977085,
-0.4571827948,
-0.5312669873,
0.2848656774,
-0.4502741396,
0.0301309116,
-0.1986888349,
0.7455744147,
-0.5806474686,
-0.1629767269,
-0.6939569116,
0.136430487,
-0.0494500324,
0.4231840372,
0.3947736323,
0.9173759818,
0.6925532222,
-0.6128632426,
0.2914482057,
0.0725530013,
-0.1771447212,
0.3047046065,
-0.4433310926,
0.2018529773,
-0.27869609,
0.0571203977,
-0.53335917,
0.0747538805,
0.1466722935,
-0.0380429402,
0.3851079643,
0.166328311,
-0.4084535837,
-0.2370629609,
-0.3598228097,
-0.034101855,
0.6203607321,
-0.3478244841,
0.9335019588,
0.4193677604,
-0.0650054142,
-0.7407721281,
0.1236528605,
0.0752715319,
-0.034691073,
-0.1824765056,
0.3404594362,
-0.0246454403,
-0.3449821472,
-0.1520305872,
-0.1971230805,
0.4007916451,
0.1659331173,
-0.0736785382,
-0.0516504794,
-0.1038687006,
0.0213430542,
0.3217615783,
-0.1167617291,
0.1547062993,
-0.4012139142,
0.589816153,
-0.3509662151,
-0.0473522283,
-0.0217583161,
0.2115549743,
0.364911288,
-0.4810916483,
0.7161140442,
0.2336508483,
-0.0390725881,
-0.8666884899,
-0.4268797636,
-0.2868988514,
-0.6069657803,
0.5802038908,
-0.6686714888,
-0.8700896502,
0.6885807514,
-0.650131166,
0.4359957278,
0.0729826838,
0.4260920584,
-0.1913919747,
1.2175569534,
0.5890647173,
0.5761192441,
0.6043214202,
-0.2417420447,
-0.1144554168,
-0.4029032886,
-0.3990859389,
-0.0237596724,
-0.3647891879,
-0.6784618497,
-0.468942672,
0.5385300517,
-0.1735780984,
-0.6622020602,
-0.0091581605,
-0.3544491231,
0.7809021473,
0.2989063263,
0.3842443824,
0.0820433348,
-0.3226414621,
0.0195874292,
0.1319046021,
-0.3804165423,
-0.5411832333,
0.7693845034,
0.5134817958,
0.5936665535,
0.2233865559,
0.804268837,
0.6282927394,
0.2791013718,
-0.651230216,
0.6645693779,
-0.1157440096,
-0.4229300022,
-0.3848111331,
-0.1020624191,
-0.9095242023,
0.2868589759,
-0.5011861324,
-0.6448036432,
0.4537783563,
0.3296360672,
-0.3304255307,
0.0596413687,
-0.2156206667,
0.8212780356,
-0.4928072989,
-0.6237012744,
-0.4078149498,
-0.3488217294,
-0.0088509815,
-0.1048927158,
0.1843025833,
-0.0817173645,
-0.5483955145,
0.1916034073,
-0.3880696297,
0.7749408484,
-0.6792583466,
-0.3160590827,
0.476090312,
0.5851134062,
0.9710263014,
0.12166287,
-0.0390974171,
-0.4660581648,
-0.2164897621,
-0.308886081,
-0.7541661859,
0.3383453488,
-0.9860966206,
-0.9487399459,
-0.2939827442,
-0.5732895136,
-0.4515850544,
0.1223020107,
-0.3157788515,
0.2120552659,
-0.2442262918,
-0.0532391891,
0.7762729526,
-0.3605602682,
0.2963676155,
0.8787008524,
-0.3067879081,
-0.2133030295,
1.2112778425,
-0.0455647558,
0.1572812796,
0.2903798819,
0.4651829302,
-0.3089532554,
-0.6657937765,
0.0922260582,
0.286419034,
-0.5392936468,
-0.1630677581,
-0.2946683764,
0.013949709,
0.0546886139,
-0.2430026978,
-0.5315513015,
0.2135391086,
-0.2048353851,
-0.1734859347,
0.1844092458,
0.6316199303,
-0.0967370346,
0.6262540221,
-0.4354262054,
-0.0024313126,
0.2734682858,
0.2219040394,
-0.2016323656,
-0.3578993976,
-0.2075800598,
0.0049264538,
-0.5275624394,
-1.0505794287,
0.442135632,
0.8030133247,
0.7917515039,
0.6509310603,
0.2322696745,
0.2687076628,
-0.4679903388,
0.6334765553,
-0.2946469486,
-0.7534081936,
0.5376905799,
-0.5598846078,
0.0731538162,
0.6636836529,
0.2602883577,
-0.1072586477,
-0.576022923,
-0.2257645428,
-0.4317124188,
0.6912035346,
-0.3016425073,
0.4280073345,
-0.2047991902,
0.7096252441,
0.4624124765,
0.4800982177,
-0.6628921628,
-0.0415433049,
-0.2269221544,
0.0016167137,
-0.1560020298,
-0.0691050738,
-0.1570566744,
-0.1469271332,
0.4711308777,
-0.5894170403,
0.3806113899,
0.0482349992,
-0.0581252091,
0.1378312856,
0.0970783681,
0.7736994624,
0.5579028726,
-0.1042349711,
0.1572370976,
0.2130224705,
-0.4922347963,
0.3413698971,
-0.0949335173,
-0.1901628673,
-0.4303599894,
0.3439434469,
0.9765948057,
0.0374760628,
-0.9629818201,
0.4962314665,
0.2595728934,
-0.3793876767,
-0.4532283247,
0.6637144685,
-0.1758715063,
0.8362802863,
0.4054168165,
-0.3643187582,
0.0855317041,
-0.903937161,
0.2517646253,
0.5383746028,
-0.3848392665,
-0.3338535726,
0.6398983002,
0.2830998003,
-0.6627165079,
0.3280191123,
-0.6500303745,
-0.6043069363,
0.628380239,
0.7549797297,
0.9537012577,
-0.234841466,
0.8141812086,
0.0767062902,
0.1133294553,
-0.1213562191,
0.7331770658,
-0.1357355118,
-0.9359441996,
-0.485666424,
-0.6041680574,
-0.3798058331,
-0.0178097375,
-0.2618184984,
0.2180678546,
-0.674569428,
-0.4533284903,
-0.3780326247,
0.3761293292,
-0.621755302,
0.0545275025,
0.0600436516,
0.8092874289,
-0.6914907098,
0.6419017911,
0.8820516467,
-0.4273242652,
-0.4764057994,
-0.0583457164,
-0.1559935808,
-1.00311625,
0.6435695887,
-0.0348839872,
-0.3428213298,
0.1528987586,
-0.6883494258,
-0.5501830578,
1.0713460445,
0.615643084,
-0.5221699476,
-0.321698755,
0.1756384075,
0.8350092173,
-0.8303994536,
0.329382062,
0.5979455709,
0.3921235204,
0.0089229494,
-0.676074028,
-0.0632719621,
0.0570579693,
-0.1946700811,
0.1346029043,
-0.8982397318,
0.7052183747,
-0.3390028179,
0.1249123067,
-0.5148114562,
0.7291077375,
0.4811667204,
0.2469912022,
0.6620802283,
0.0879504904,
0.5249627233,
0.0773101673,
0.7034294009,
-0.3237270117,
0.1302761436,
1.0686143637,
-0.5227953792,
0.687707305,
0.1597987115,
0.0386835001,
0.8861731887,
0.5954591036,
-0.0416867472,
0.7424528003,
0.2875678241,
-0.5416893959,
-0.8181770444,
-0.2537461817,
0.2567484975,
0.7189419866,
0.4914107025,
-0.0642876327,
-0.2318380177,
0.1209465936,
0.0051382482,
0.2552652359,
-0.3571686149,
1.0942617655,
-0.0765410587,
-0.8334073424,
0.0291403979,
-0.2106252909,
0.4410273731,
-0.597171247,
-0.4416602254,
-0.2316856682,
0.3075885475,
0.15838705,
-0.7690945268,
-0.0413861349,
-0.3659314513,
0.2125933468,
-0.2540301979,
0.7191739678,
-0.3817006648,
0.0684429035,
0.4437319934,
0.5794574022,
0.1347963512,
-0.0320008248,
-0.8291751146,
-0.0354013145,
-0.3395723999,
-0.5507608056,
0.3579503298,
0.4245537221,
-0.0736445189,
0.9737510681,
0.2513570786,
0.2869157791,
-0.1675474942,
-0.2107695192,
0.7911388278,
-0.3100329638,
-0.7331494093,
-0.7270273566,
0.4445820451,
-0.2226337641,
-0.1248274669,
0.2128590792,
0.4185334444,
0.5260732174,
-0.1120399237,
0.7083560824,
0.2642959654,
0.1762303263,
-0.2810803652,
0.6143250465,
-0.8111701608,
0.2022295445,
-0.0569295771,
-1.2026182413,
0.0663118511,
0.6831650138,
-0.4248940349,
0.2424573153,
0.2925944924,
0.6836360693,
0.2573516369,
-0.3558299839,
0.3145788312,
0.1256456226,
0.6584009528,
0.4963746667,
0.9491570592,
0.197968483,
0.3820472658,
0.1810893714,
-0.3859069347,
-0.1814508736,
-0.7581999898,
-0.8204393983,
-0.3821172416,
-0.4960446954,
-0.2604984045,
0.3537303209,
1.2113906145,
0.4824414253,
-0.5121411085,
-0.2603207529,
-0.2789079845,
0.0292760823,
-0.5956557989,
-0.2363209128,
0.204630807,
-0.7108108401,
-0.6582555175,
0.6776422858,
0.2859069705,
-0.1273585856,
-0.4871807694,
-0.5375929475,
0.0539836958,
0.6576874852,
0.6802629232,
0.6192954779,
-0.4897829294,
-0.6194226146,
0.0509538278,
0.0995171443,
-0.0466046855,
0.7092924714,
-0.7566465139,
0.708691895,
0.2431610525,
0.6149238944,
0.3849015534,
-0.0449382365,
0.8642880917,
-0.457393527,
-0.1420879364,
0.4704214334,
-0.0817921013,
-0.2654694319,
-0.3119040728,
0.2804780602,
0.1115912125,
-0.6456076503,
-0.9831120968,
0.3914383054,
-0.7208034396,
-0.4375561774,
1.0645040274,
-0.2445032001,
-0.1165574864,
-0.2411334068,
-0.3916375935,
0.0901642367,
-0.6023360491,
0.7683578134,
0.3426581025,
-0.5008550286,
-0.5256057382,
-0.4432787299,
0.9970724583,
0.1422720551,
-0.7964480519,
0.035696201,
0.3632294834,
0.0908648893,
0.0647746399,
0.6099590659,
0.2519536912,
0.2273338288,
0.3749184012,
0.143950507,
-0.4689202011,
-0.8292374611,
0.0022264956,
0.3227242827,
0.4922550023,
-0.0874812678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17564v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17564v2
|
Unleashing the Potential of Large Language Models as Prompt Optimizers: An Analogical Analysis with Gradient-based Model Optimizers
| 2024-02-27T15:05:32 | 2024-04-17T03:17:58 |
Xinyu Tang, Xiaolei Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Siyuan Lu, Yaliang Li, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic prompt optimization is an important approach to improving the
performance of large language models (LLMs). Recent research demonstrates the
potential of using LLMs as prompt optimizers, which can generate improved task
prompts via iterative refinement. In this paper, we propose a novel perspective
to investigate the design of LLM-based prompt optimizers, by drawing an analogy
with gradient-based model optimizers. To connect these two approaches, we
identify two pivotal factors in model parameter learning: update direction and
update method. Focused on the two aspects, we borrow the theoretical framework
and learning methods from gradient-based optimization to design improved
strategies for LLM-based prompt optimizers. By systematically analyzing a rich
set of improvement strategies, we further develop a capable Gradient-inspired
LLM-based Prompt Optimizer called GPO. At each step, it first retrieves
relevant prompts from the optimization trajectory as the update direction.
Then, it utilizes the generation-based refinement strategy to perform the
update, while controlling the edit distance through a cosine-based decay
strategy. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of
GPO. In particular, GPO brings an additional improvement of up to 56.8% on
Big-Bench Hard and 55.3% on MMLU compared to baseline methods.
|
[
-0.2971071303,
-0.7566824555,
0.7931930423,
0.0158979557,
-0.381138593,
0.019584842,
-0.3530876637,
-0.0071163345,
-0.1065123752,
0.1521774381,
-0.9672020078,
-0.3460316956,
-0.1996256709,
0.2741932869,
0.198848322,
0.8813712597,
-0.0379842445,
0.2954831123,
-0.0904105753,
0.0583151989,
-0.6669071913,
-0.1639345288,
-1.3020232916,
-0.0984788686,
0.6701391935,
0.1387321651,
0.5993058681,
0.9021766782,
0.0834508836,
0.3228931427,
-0.2706869245,
0.0611346997,
-0.515057683,
0.3278064728,
-0.0197678283,
-0.4752667844,
-0.1817343384,
-0.0428931899,
0.7338052392,
0.7198530436,
-0.2947078049,
-0.0375152081,
0.1606652141,
0.7513561845,
-0.5895041227,
0.2481873184,
-0.6342673302,
-0.0066113197,
0.2045989782,
-0.4223339558,
-0.2437134236,
-0.4978179336,
-0.0990479439,
-0.7767087221,
0.166095823,
0.2896143198,
0.4676728547,
0.3002102673,
0.0952310562,
-0.4494548142,
-0.3899824321,
1.012619257,
-0.8368045092,
0.2405946553,
-0.1910106838,
0.4485284984,
-0.5426371098,
-0.4508972764,
-0.3707359731,
-0.6969804764,
0.0988460407,
-0.1511546224,
-0.0985160619,
0.2256070524,
0.4421417117,
0.1390664876,
-0.4918521643,
0.5741747022,
-0.0077936449,
-0.0659612492,
0.5010296702,
0.2842615843,
0.4238304794,
0.0510934442,
-0.3475912213,
0.0113303345,
-0.8027942181,
0.4690937996,
0.4473589659,
0.4185562134,
0.106578961,
0.0644685477,
-0.2116981596,
0.9421482086,
0.4251107275,
-0.2270038277,
0.1842845827,
-0.2290922254,
-0.0031361775,
-0.2225454599,
0.7493928671,
0.4165227115,
0.2456604987,
-0.1503786445,
-0.5797516704,
-0.3817932308,
0.089731358,
-0.7304713726,
0.178632468,
0.1740690172,
-0.4434525073,
-0.3238011599,
-0.2186914831,
-0.879420042,
-0.422914356,
-0.6965833306,
0.2656548619,
-0.1677726805,
0.123123467,
0.0754747838,
0.0094808396,
0.1175631657,
0.5990454555,
-1.0119737387,
-0.0034640324,
0.8028441072,
0.7526788116,
-0.0718615353,
-0.2980124056,
-0.9474070072,
-0.1001263335,
-0.4740606248,
0.40466097,
-0.8189748526,
-0.5890934467,
0.1498195529,
-0.1998521239,
-0.0331644155,
-0.4721624255,
0.4925256073,
-0.5987970829,
0.4420594573,
-0.4469476938,
-0.4002201855,
-0.0643662885,
0.1239429787,
-0.5468370914,
1.0607402325,
0.1112216711,
-0.375238806,
0.2054418623,
-0.5793933272,
-0.0350027382,
-0.0111230928,
-0.2182432711,
-0.2366939783,
0.3406351507,
0.4184500575,
0.294067204,
-0.755266726,
0.4400154352,
-0.1242138669,
-0.407661289,
0.157733947,
-0.2970615625,
0.8449167609,
0.0926085263,
-0.1306163073,
0.5017448068,
-0.758399725,
-0.1231357679,
-0.0051391707,
-0.3183278441,
-0.1475431025,
-0.0538519286,
-0.4661400914,
0.1929422319,
0.2312886715,
-0.3755738735,
0.3894935846,
-0.3341861367,
0.5002470016,
0.9477784634,
0.1940184832,
0.601806581,
-0.321354568,
0.9317618608,
-0.354988277,
0.3562188447,
-0.5653398633,
-0.302357018,
-0.5363587737,
-0.4482676685,
0.2688423395,
0.4901030958,
-0.7291284204,
0.3602600694,
0.0200949069,
-0.3261133432,
-0.5412082076,
0.1094253883,
0.3096189201,
0.9925817847,
0.3164736927,
0.0871560425,
-0.1580584198,
-0.7155238986,
-0.4365118146,
-0.2548088431,
-0.17055507,
0.3214270473,
0.0782845914,
-0.0428023785,
0.8756280541,
-0.4135919511,
0.2334963679,
-0.2609665394,
-0.0660792664,
0.5142040253,
0.4960207045,
0.7628369331,
-0.4777610004,
-0.5213785172,
-0.1710045338,
-0.6008672714,
-0.5469502807,
-0.4077742994,
-0.0635267422,
-0.0264089983,
0.8597715497,
-0.7328567505,
-0.020693792,
0.0794209987,
0.0068593612,
0.7627426982,
-0.326926738,
0.0553723201,
-0.8048174977,
-0.0482359529,
0.2340313643,
0.1273541749,
-0.7405346036,
0.4054942131,
-0.0358180366,
-0.4647406936,
-0.4832807779,
1.008466363,
-0.7596219778,
0.3543398678,
-0.2977823019,
0.1718171686,
-0.1026308015,
0.7322663069,
-0.4485312402,
0.8877122402,
0.8470694423,
-0.569975853,
0.5168364644,
-0.1849644184,
-0.0598522201,
0.4658662379,
-0.8017001152,
0.2793718278,
-0.6266611218,
0.201870665,
-1.209379673,
0.155183956,
0.4649993181,
-0.152014479,
0.5370228291,
-0.1528782696,
-0.3845846355,
-0.4432795346,
-0.7354886532,
0.3039186895,
0.6860927939,
-0.7608801723,
0.7786496878,
-0.1033749655,
-0.5115001202,
-0.6146614552,
-0.0076365126,
0.0815455839,
-0.4329354167,
-0.446564734,
0.131652832,
-0.1818003505,
-0.4044339359,
-0.4073805511,
-0.0080660013,
0.3644192517,
0.203718856,
-0.2222680002,
0.4629544318,
-0.0652004182,
0.292232424,
0.1588647962,
-0.2876182497,
0.1894084066,
-0.4305790365,
0.5854793191,
0.278675586,
-0.1215754449,
-0.5977908373,
0.3340894282,
0.3165794015,
-0.2211335599,
0.5082953572,
0.2812728584,
-0.0507393777,
-0.4904254973,
-0.5454763174,
-0.3501773477,
-0.6058578491,
0.4485917091,
-0.6063187122,
-0.5669497848,
0.6157112718,
-0.2004108429,
0.1106362939,
0.220922187,
0.4271271527,
0.0665059984,
0.8521156311,
0.4856106937,
-0.2080525011,
0.7495679259,
0.0628782958,
-0.0506165512,
-0.8676657081,
-0.1086389199,
-0.7147307992,
-0.2187921852,
-0.3589864969,
-0.4370755255,
0.2104329765,
0.4179449081,
-0.365708828,
0.1153078303,
-0.2724513412,
0.4255890846,
0.5803804994,
-0.0011304243,
0.0520275682,
0.0139123341,
-0.2812880576,
-0.085230872,
-0.7899721265,
-0.5346487761,
0.9518871307,
0.3174726069,
0.7395753264,
-0.1679390222,
0.4689932168,
0.1239969879,
0.1828577667,
-0.8461495638,
0.7563748956,
0.216909498,
-0.0286655203,
-0.2854900062,
-0.4339165986,
-0.7142166495,
0.4220879078,
0.0097346073,
-0.6303180456,
0.2194109559,
0.3457541168,
-0.2612305284,
0.0751673281,
-0.6241694093,
0.7719011307,
-0.1003823802,
-0.321108669,
-0.1045401096,
-0.5424590707,
-0.1482792348,
-0.2211871743,
0.1159469113,
0.1084264368,
-0.4216735959,
0.3353246748,
-0.5501565933,
0.7682430148,
-0.4957455099,
-0.3454518318,
0.3387045264,
0.0192871857,
0.9604039788,
0.0159776397,
-0.469699502,
-0.0881487206,
-0.663107872,
-0.382522434,
-1.0720157623,
0.7526156902,
-0.4323491156,
-1.0890338421,
-0.0401640423,
-0.5157946944,
-0.4296478331,
0.0486681722,
0.070312269,
0.7550599575,
-0.0843071267,
-0.2536077499,
0.4807672501,
-0.3198305368,
0.8786331415,
0.6084997058,
-0.013353223,
-0.3146422803,
0.7312059999,
-0.2670142055,
0.3303874433,
0.5704057813,
0.4147644937,
-0.3229743242,
-0.8769429326,
-0.690164268,
0.4416496754,
-0.711946249,
0.0258333813,
-0.3725429475,
0.2441937178,
-0.0661004707,
-0.4474377334,
0.1211314574,
-0.1686903089,
-0.6809587479,
0.0728119239,
0.1939406842,
0.2266736329,
0.0688602403,
0.3713063598,
-0.4464762807,
0.070330061,
0.2712902725,
-0.0165115036,
0.4066396654,
-0.5805760622,
-0.0515067428,
0.0935537815,
-0.2040967941,
-0.7734812498,
0.3848896325,
0.0570143238,
0.7643150687,
0.4909516871,
-0.1654894501,
0.4660718143,
-0.915538311,
0.759016633,
0.3167218268,
-0.8728038669,
0.5571926236,
-0.6244194508,
0.3456422985,
0.5482931137,
0.3299354613,
-0.5179069638,
-0.1801428199,
-0.2782979906,
-0.5882924199,
0.6010134816,
-0.1975167841,
0.279681623,
0.0245647524,
0.8851475716,
0.3104043007,
0.4870930612,
-0.3292099833,
-0.2497880161,
0.065601781,
-0.3054693937,
-0.1317489296,
-0.250662297,
-0.0024160359,
0.0191152766,
0.6687840223,
-0.345549345,
0.1578901857,
-0.0866030827,
0.1133758351,
-0.1706027091,
0.3135140538,
0.6436855197,
0.7825181484,
0.006838826,
-0.3794778585,
0.1318159103,
-0.2336486876,
0.1657859534,
0.1623297781,
-0.4523582458,
0.0582197942,
0.2634013295,
1.0660163164,
-0.0180175174,
-0.661670506,
0.3841862082,
0.2294893116,
0.1710753888,
0.1151972711,
0.3710895181,
-0.1006938517,
0.3255077899,
0.6745955944,
-0.0487680547,
0.1862513423,
-0.4867613316,
-0.1469198465,
0.6444928646,
-0.372325331,
-0.4363151491,
0.7719214559,
0.3321509361,
-0.7048197985,
0.2793147564,
-0.225067988,
-0.4592831731,
0.7397724986,
0.550265193,
1.0224429369,
-0.4360004365,
0.185392946,
0.4088329673,
0.1217242181,
-0.1284854859,
0.1766288728,
-0.0148060638,
-0.3602435291,
-0.5536216497,
-0.4828475416,
-0.2730136514,
0.0394751392,
-0.4874584675,
0.4661159217,
-0.6591973305,
0.0428424552,
-0.1914400607,
-0.0119343838,
-0.4564484358,
0.2038333714,
-0.134455353,
0.8642646074,
-0.521723628,
0.4421534538,
0.6185725331,
-0.1893528104,
-0.6826936603,
0.1685307622,
0.0216557626,
-1.0227856636,
0.7335045338,
0.0854986086,
-0.1467482746,
0.0827399716,
-0.3583135307,
-0.7847856283,
0.9589765668,
0.5097703934,
-1.0638897419,
-0.2902730703,
-0.1871543527,
0.6498422623,
-0.5610309243,
0.4131511152,
0.1597157419,
0.2748809159,
0.085025236,
-0.7603804469,
0.3214452565,
-0.0974664986,
0.4674752355,
0.3596020341,
-0.6351559758,
0.8880135417,
-0.4616956115,
-0.272199899,
0.3657726049,
0.5511746407,
0.3183459938,
-0.0280216429,
0.4356409013,
0.3506585956,
0.6937232018,
0.1334165335,
1.2598382235,
-0.3998086751,
0.2995468378,
1.0903166533,
-0.1422132701,
0.4434524775,
0.6060732603,
-0.0454356,
0.3887731433,
0.7277399302,
0.0061008707,
0.6954357028,
0.5119122267,
-0.3563050032,
0.0640021563,
-0.0978410542,
-0.2213522643,
-0.176731512,
0.0666148737,
-0.5529379249,
-0.3171233535,
0.0455612689,
0.1936628073,
0.0743066669,
-0.6969408393,
0.595494926,
-0.0205177385,
-0.6850515008,
0.7147128582,
0.0844035745,
0.4570589364,
-0.482796818,
0.0452829674,
-0.2699154019,
-0.1108510047,
0.2642049491,
-0.2718440294,
-0.4449363351,
-0.1237488836,
-0.1570687592,
-0.1972691268,
0.3524824083,
-0.5090073347,
-0.3865990937,
0.1779384464,
0.4447964728,
-0.2802631557,
0.0353555903,
-0.909581244,
0.069700852,
0.1739535332,
-0.3530570865,
0.0886075869,
0.444539398,
-0.0064836326,
0.8868344426,
0.7195662856,
0.2253003865,
-0.2027215511,
0.2152351737,
0.9509696364,
-0.6689334512,
-0.6919145584,
-1.0758234262,
0.4490631819,
0.0865766257,
-0.4645531774,
0.6870717406,
0.2445067316,
0.4933274388,
-0.2413568944,
0.5786083937,
0.4946140647,
0.4312957227,
-0.9106496572,
0.2114174515,
-0.5445519686,
0.4972651303,
-0.2229701132,
-1.3627896309,
-0.1652729064,
0.3702224195,
-0.4566986263,
0.2802654803,
0.6903361082,
1.0271956921,
0.1962595433,
0.0235227551,
0.0845625028,
0.1209761202,
0.3907699287,
0.4665215909,
0.8870267868,
-0.126659736,
0.1103420481,
0.1567439139,
-0.3736114502,
-0.1305774003,
-0.9457498193,
-1.1410386562,
-0.391611129,
-0.3763333857,
-0.0693278462,
0.3021802902,
1.0964077711,
0.3402162194,
-0.5354561806,
-0.1589369774,
-0.262085557,
-0.1344840527,
-0.069975391,
-0.2122510225,
0.4181715548,
-0.7505171895,
-0.9151262045,
0.5858490467,
0.2264638096,
0.0663174167,
-0.3611980677,
-0.0349377729,
0.1583073139,
0.1625756323,
0.4140139818,
0.3111141622,
-0.8587633371,
-0.1356625706,
-0.0092343967,
-0.07807789,
0.1408247203,
0.9425461888,
-0.8509781361,
0.5257268548,
0.4695538282,
0.8143749237,
0.1035612524,
0.1960948557,
0.8252035975,
-0.5805963874,
0.1850218922,
0.1666113734,
0.4456011355,
0.3865999281,
-0.4542197287,
0.2167613208,
0.0817864388,
-0.3760145903,
-0.7006900907,
0.2717849314,
-0.7043974996,
-0.3835870922,
1.326794982,
-0.0430490747,
-0.2993326485,
0.1880037785,
-0.5478268266,
-0.060224168,
-0.8806101084,
0.787124157,
0.5586479902,
0.0182640404,
-0.2531143725,
-0.436914295,
0.7535148263,
0.4304912984,
-0.6301766038,
0.1257462204,
0.6596549153,
0.1386665553,
-0.0777000859,
0.4600607157,
0.128754437,
0.1833487451,
-0.2360448539,
-0.2064685225,
-0.2630749941,
-0.1505941004,
-0.8817679882,
0.1878193766,
0.0101135643,
-0.0974911153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17812v1
|
DropBP: Accelerating Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models by Dropping Backward Propagation
| 2024-02-27T14:51:11 | 2024-02-27T14:51:11 |
Sunghyeon Woo, Baeseong Park, Byeongwook Kim, Minjung Jo, Sejung Kwon, Dongsuk Jeon, Dongsoo Lee
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Training deep neural networks typically involves substantial computational
costs during both forward and backward propagation. The conventional layer
dropping techniques drop certain layers during training for reducing the
computations burden. However, dropping layers during forward propagation
adversely affects the training process by degrading accuracy. In this paper, we
propose Dropping Backward Propagation (DropBP), a novel approach designed to
reduce computational costs while maintaining accuracy. DropBP randomly drops
layers during the backward propagation, which does not deviate forward
propagation. Moreover, DropBP calculates the sensitivity of each layer to
assign appropriate drop rate, thereby stabilizing the training process. DropBP
is designed to enhance the efficiency of the training process with
backpropagation, thereby enabling the acceleration of both full fine-tuning and
parameter-efficient fine-tuning using backpropagation. Specifically, utilizing
DropBP in QLoRA reduces training time by 44%, increases the convergence speed
to the identical loss level by 1.5$\times$, and enables training with a
6.2$\times$ larger sequence length on a single NVIDIA-A100 80GiB GPU in
LLaMA2-70B. The code is available at https://github.com/WooSunghyeon/dropbp.
|
[
-0.6260127425,
-0.7967638373,
0.1315127909,
0.4926336706,
-0.2658419609,
0.0288304836,
-0.5399699211,
-0.3583855033,
-0.2292865664,
0.3174007535,
-0.7293557525,
-0.495218426,
-0.5798802972,
-0.4045128524,
-0.2551978827,
0.8159447908,
0.2985743582,
0.0770600587,
0.1882629395,
0.1032734588,
-0.8707081079,
-0.0394557267,
-1.0426911116,
-0.7156316042,
0.7575812936,
0.4492521584,
0.7384251952,
0.6547526121,
0.4234345853,
0.2413742095,
-0.6134265065,
0.215693742,
-0.6273628473,
-0.0522341914,
-0.2393214703,
-0.5088157058,
-0.1365427822,
-0.114138931,
0.7643936872,
0.6656476855,
-0.4393089116,
0.141480878,
-0.0735902712,
0.7655691504,
-0.8989867568,
0.0767286718,
-0.5271618366,
0.2139359564,
-0.1451282948,
-0.3180317581,
-0.3372457623,
-0.3080949187,
0.00324936,
-0.3552776873,
0.2391612232,
-0.3255645931,
0.8581715226,
0.1315988302,
0.1440849751,
0.4167925119,
-0.8217156529,
0.4289065003,
-0.8034015894,
0.64977777,
0.1703686416,
0.1853694171,
-0.1820815057,
-0.6197672486,
-0.5964631438,
-0.1919423044,
0.3990501165,
-0.0253048688,
0.1259744912,
0.2400352508,
0.3441241086,
0.406136632,
-0.2804660797,
0.4346840978,
-0.4167224467,
-0.0537485853,
0.4676561356,
0.0775048956,
0.1160112321,
0.2367487699,
-0.0404787399,
-0.1230457947,
-0.982046783,
-0.0289820414,
0.3997704685,
0.4775488973,
-0.1391785294,
0.0605818555,
-0.3262034059,
0.3967222869,
0.18815732,
0.1194467992,
0.3366093338,
0.0878515765,
-0.3439078033,
0.0053854608,
0.3025490046,
0.3352176845,
0.0776930302,
-0.1448588073,
0.1535713822,
-0.0541474037,
0.0725423321,
-1.2204585075,
-0.7226467133,
0.1536322087,
-0.5902673006,
-0.4456553757,
-0.4759296477,
-0.5154970288,
-0.4759250283,
-0.1685808301,
0.2765547335,
-0.3319537938,
-0.3302367628,
0.2229778618,
-0.1085321084,
0.1891418099,
0.4550644755,
-0.9038400054,
0.2716240883,
0.7675050497,
0.8903884292,
-0.0803972557,
-0.2976456881,
-0.6947215199,
0.1601281464,
-0.5727886558,
0.3567713797,
-0.4193247259,
-0.3104452491,
-0.1172565445,
-0.2209960371,
0.0920173004,
-0.6079337597,
0.5531685352,
-0.6222922206,
-0.0376236066,
-0.0334509648,
-0.4730840325,
-0.5390833616,
-0.0807265118,
-0.3938453197,
0.7521386147,
-0.1648537815,
-0.4501289427,
0.3108394146,
-0.3207744956,
-0.7778482437,
0.2032419741,
-0.0660900548,
-0.4271858037,
0.3508165479,
0.3087633252,
0.5166286826,
-0.3402075768,
0.2018644661,
-0.3289581239,
-0.5463956594,
-0.3502211571,
-0.4997526705,
0.8631802201,
0.2328854501,
-0.5773296952,
-0.2737544775,
-1.0112761259,
0.3621655107,
-0.0975190848,
-0.6688166261,
-0.2161964029,
-0.0911054015,
0.3374201357,
0.4050787389,
-0.2405171543,
-0.5535572767,
0.432780385,
-0.7902815938,
0.4660672545,
0.6447812319,
-0.1171308756,
0.3772415817,
0.1037688851,
0.4265868664,
-0.0552324131,
0.1293210983,
0.0452090912,
-0.5473095775,
-0.5873638988,
-0.2792468965,
0.2575738132,
0.5895941854,
-0.5969868302,
0.3146510422,
-0.3053734004,
-0.713098228,
-0.5346717834,
0.1686403304,
0.8223640323,
0.7110595703,
0.4644519985,
-0.2004934251,
-0.435416609,
-0.8962293267,
-0.2922093272,
0.009612171,
0.0467673466,
0.228275761,
0.1068088859,
-0.1209789962,
0.5687584281,
-0.6906729937,
-0.4420531094,
-0.1687966138,
0.0996934101,
0.1494384408,
0.9846430421,
0.4261496663,
-0.5456833243,
-0.0441394411,
0.0345750265,
-0.2982946336,
-0.1437241733,
0.0543013476,
-0.2253217548,
0.4209029078,
0.3042168617,
-0.8592905998,
0.5319022536,
0.6160878539,
0.0755360052,
0.4084578454,
-0.137292996,
-0.1204209551,
-1.1254686117,
0.2279925197,
-0.1556374729,
-0.0068421373,
-0.5346564054,
0.2988271415,
0.1896599382,
-0.1780924499,
-0.5859251618,
0.4191756248,
-0.3865495622,
0.1142288372,
-0.3187661767,
0.0303574968,
0.317042917,
0.4708594978,
0.1206776351,
0.5382617116,
0.340103209,
-0.6743405461,
0.2579658031,
0.3259584308,
-0.1392182261,
0.1352955848,
-0.4812084138,
0.1943786293,
0.0186800845,
0.2852069139,
-0.733435452,
0.2915533185,
0.4004919231,
-0.2986212671,
0.5523696542,
-0.4640936852,
-0.4029757679,
-0.3617331386,
-0.326448828,
0.3407318294,
0.5180407763,
-0.7861397266,
0.3302385509,
0.1615290344,
-0.1001673266,
-0.8200557232,
-1.1058554649,
0.1821268499,
0.0750063658,
-0.4761262834,
0.505540967,
-0.1981640756,
0.2901472449,
-0.1972336173,
-0.2102787793,
-0.0318017974,
0.2180196047,
0.2964341342,
-0.1453149617,
-0.3060202599,
0.4408110082,
0.4713201821,
0.0009555888,
-0.0777163133,
-0.5845633149,
0.8580653667,
-0.0479116179,
0.0260063261,
-0.9514907002,
0.1790597588,
-0.0707030743,
-0.1859022975,
0.8704725504,
0.7774825096,
-0.3579610586,
-0.5145683289,
-0.4259390235,
-0.3105272055,
-0.5428884625,
0.7517235279,
-0.5633220077,
-0.6281751394,
0.4919742048,
-0.1440154761,
0.1107700765,
0.2084110677,
0.530061245,
0.0914835855,
0.7939369678,
0.7952870131,
-0.3260856867,
0.6769764423,
-0.7329746485,
0.1710605472,
-0.7062680721,
-0.2819955349,
-0.5155027509,
-0.4036587179,
-0.5265235901,
-0.3303013146,
-0.2921288013,
0.4926564097,
-0.224581778,
0.0615244061,
-0.4786036015,
0.643810451,
0.4647417068,
0.3663516343,
0.195440799,
-0.0679344311,
0.1332104206,
0.119617328,
-0.7484773397,
0.0182311218,
0.7430849671,
0.4824903309,
0.7728494406,
-0.0818395987,
0.6944007874,
0.170013994,
0.0752034858,
-0.6397749186,
0.5663483739,
-0.3218376338,
-0.3251629472,
-0.3561173975,
-0.6212646365,
-0.6131144762,
0.0584613904,
-0.2125923783,
-0.4293220937,
0.3443077207,
0.5963758826,
-0.3999211192,
0.4319982827,
-0.3610331714,
0.7179481387,
0.0808390453,
-0.3973265588,
-0.7055004239,
-0.6668435335,
0.1578494906,
0.3258842826,
-0.2568872571,
-0.2103626579,
0.0071367058,
0.3523828983,
-0.4979025126,
0.6313444376,
-0.5092706084,
-0.5039356351,
0.026269475,
0.4559304416,
0.5275462866,
0.3645063937,
-0.0853158385,
0.5227296948,
-0.4073511064,
-0.3870950937,
-0.8041304946,
0.7526701689,
-0.6987369657,
-0.3031408191,
0.0773722455,
-0.5163600445,
-0.0603244528,
0.2568410933,
0.2717031837,
0.6513506174,
0.2273217589,
0.0360324308,
0.4244320393,
-0.3561057746,
0.5650898814,
0.2750917673,
-0.120153673,
-0.5414924622,
0.9455642104,
0.1171946153,
0.3325049281,
0.4943908155,
0.3632050157,
-0.2463285029,
-1.260265708,
-0.4983170927,
0.0882754773,
-0.7700484991,
-0.3574244082,
-0.3203638792,
-0.3251072168,
-0.2967463136,
0.0691974238,
-0.6450685263,
-0.7743970752,
-0.1516342461,
-0.1528021693,
0.2989902198,
0.1865927875,
-0.0797912553,
0.7697220445,
-0.7125792503,
0.2129511386,
0.1009690017,
0.5939583182,
0.1531948298,
-0.7653472424,
-0.4822160304,
0.0725048706,
-0.2411904782,
-0.3505320549,
0.5218448639,
0.6598870158,
0.1946993172,
0.4048852921,
-0.2608243823,
1.042245388,
-0.5574609041,
0.5710721016,
0.1212668419,
-1.0898182392,
0.6797711253,
-0.4830678403,
0.4525499344,
0.5536794662,
0.0142455269,
-0.4682829976,
-0.23578915,
-0.4107193947,
-1.0639955997,
0.6818239689,
0.1273483336,
0.167585358,
0.2579337955,
0.7215840816,
0.118017897,
0.5391732454,
-0.2796437144,
-0.4290323555,
0.0779085606,
-0.0285152439,
-0.242641747,
-0.0009351601,
0.074866198,
-0.4377196431,
0.9145377874,
-0.147064507,
-0.1024333909,
-0.1090031788,
-0.2221536785,
-0.1440018266,
-0.1503488272,
0.6126081944,
0.7510852218,
-0.1540709138,
-0.076315023,
0.1645690948,
-0.7574996352,
-0.0304576047,
0.1475232691,
-0.6806073785,
-0.1681712717,
0.1287287027,
0.9369976521,
0.0849911422,
-0.4786513746,
0.2400532514,
-0.0527405366,
-0.0290930253,
0.0162578616,
-0.021676138,
0.1735326946,
0.4135537446,
0.302593112,
0.3906136155,
0.3126189411,
-0.2668217421,
0.2397246957,
0.1871472299,
-0.0495640859,
-0.2245743871,
0.6244253516,
0.4268413484,
-0.3354658186,
1.0439041853,
0.2136610895,
-0.3911632001,
0.6086350083,
0.5850048065,
1.1115560532,
-0.1392712146,
0.2422646284,
0.0023036173,
0.12864618,
-0.1142897382,
0.360951215,
0.0349207334,
-0.6375071406,
-0.7600802779,
-0.6620911956,
-0.306109488,
0.2874915302,
-0.4988234639,
0.0910834894,
-0.8379252553,
-0.0426872224,
0.1557617337,
0.2991295755,
-0.5039027333,
0.4245724976,
0.5632894635,
0.936799705,
-0.6132586598,
0.991399467,
0.3810108602,
-0.4254550934,
-1.0038057566,
0.096279256,
-0.4116511643,
-0.5152087808,
1.0278389454,
0.344493866,
-0.3517419994,
0.1398186386,
-0.5634987354,
-0.8085466623,
0.6930289865,
0.9697316289,
-0.8152247071,
-0.0013744126,
-0.2301209867,
0.5448496938,
-0.1421071887,
0.0922949314,
0.5660336018,
0.290050745,
-0.1139432788,
-0.7588587999,
0.144009769,
-0.2872162163,
0.5190133452,
0.2778133154,
-0.8157368302,
0.9728324413,
-0.3418226242,
-0.1381245106,
0.3011682332,
0.6823739409,
0.1119732931,
0.3054966927,
0.2447303385,
0.788084209,
0.6263749003,
0.0789558217,
0.7599183917,
-0.3240386844,
0.3610706627,
0.9963731766,
0.0438617542,
1.0456873178,
0.3975486457,
0.0268767793,
0.280944109,
0.7542562485,
-0.0313271433,
0.5841619968,
0.6016898155,
-0.0985147059,
-0.1876963377,
0.0692367554,
-0.4693399072,
0.280423522,
0.127040565,
-0.1499610245,
0.0745096132,
0.2344418019,
0.2941966057,
0.0835973993,
-0.730912149,
0.3453716636,
0.1369700134,
-0.5117553473,
1.0360205173,
0.0810291022,
0.5813506246,
-0.2516573668,
-0.1980295181,
-0.4667605162,
0.6499387026,
-0.5561171174,
-0.4527340233,
0.0096410932,
-0.5660777092,
-0.1559622139,
-0.0340209715,
0.5558985472,
-0.5018026233,
-0.3440848291,
0.5291936398,
0.2611678243,
0.1908425987,
-0.1548919082,
-0.5795574784,
0.1168885976,
-0.3743810058,
-0.4505223036,
0.2323465049,
0.1723085493,
-0.0059755961,
0.9181108475,
0.7213296294,
0.496080488,
0.3616047502,
0.567808032,
1.1675161123,
-0.5175787807,
-0.475782454,
-0.8714350462,
0.0051054675,
0.0606004074,
-0.336074084,
0.6156544089,
0.6126035452,
0.9441288114,
-0.1563933641,
0.647927165,
0.0366306901,
0.2950490415,
-0.6197652221,
0.9369840026,
-0.4927808642,
0.3215106428,
-0.4545063972,
-0.8700489998,
-0.437574774,
0.5897419453,
-0.018394934,
0.1702521145,
0.3031312227,
0.7310188413,
0.0530718826,
0.0277105756,
0.2338428944,
0.3274405599,
0.5017533302,
0.5823390484,
0.5835380554,
-0.5880873799,
0.6297944188,
-0.8025715351,
0.1299380511,
-0.2470459938,
-0.7856037617,
-0.8397768736,
-0.1158554554,
-0.4385027587,
-0.2714214325,
0.7663920522,
0.7988032699,
0.9992370605,
-0.7876237035,
-0.2664887905,
-0.4082006216,
0.0240230486,
-0.5303345323,
-0.1909178942,
0.5644053221,
-0.3239512444,
-0.7365181446,
0.4012711942,
0.14879857,
-0.2497341633,
-0.2826425135,
-0.0861130729,
-0.3073859513,
-0.3596893251,
0.5913795829,
0.4432431757,
-0.4843714237,
-0.3679475784,
-0.5052646399,
0.1089067683,
0.1907011122,
0.6205781698,
-1.0166636705,
0.1252024323,
0.7809742093,
0.9797031283,
0.5925506353,
0.1460742056,
0.6859301925,
-0.9666912556,
0.4472299814,
0.4025733769,
-0.2424908876,
0.2341181934,
-0.5150078535,
0.4670816958,
0.3107770979,
-0.4003491998,
-0.9996169209,
0.2350321263,
-0.788243413,
-0.2742041647,
0.9645130634,
-0.2218089849,
-0.2686135173,
0.2240950018,
-0.3092965484,
0.3694343269,
-0.6199942231,
0.800596118,
0.1158136576,
-0.0403608941,
-0.578207314,
-0.3906049132,
0.6265200377,
0.5992584229,
-0.6093088984,
0.2525468171,
0.490442574,
0.2456800789,
0.1270313561,
0.273614645,
0.2501169741,
0.4585815966,
-0.0712913722,
0.3970783949,
-0.408745259,
-0.605576098,
-0.7191712856,
0.3570397198,
-0.0621643066,
-0.4846742749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17553v2
|
OmniACT: A Dataset and Benchmark for Enabling Multimodal Generalist Autonomous Agents for Desktop and Web
| 2024-02-27T14:47:53 | 2024-02-28T17:27:39 |
Raghav Kapoor, Yash Parag Butala, Melisa Russak, Jing Yu Koh, Kiran Kamble, Waseem Alshikh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
For decades, human-computer interaction has fundamentally been manual. Even
today, almost all productive work done on the computer necessitates human input
at every step. Autonomous virtual agents represent an exciting step in
automating many of these menial tasks. Virtual agents would empower users with
limited technical proficiency to harness the full possibilities of computer
systems. They could also enable the efficient streamlining of numerous computer
tasks, ranging from calendar management to complex travel bookings, with
minimal human intervention. In this paper, we introduce OmniACT, the
first-of-a-kind dataset and benchmark for assessing an agent's capability to
generate executable programs to accomplish computer tasks. Our scope extends
beyond traditional web automation, covering a diverse range of desktop
applications. The dataset consists of fundamental tasks such as "Play the next
song", as well as longer horizon tasks such as "Send an email to John Doe
mentioning the time and place to meet". Specifically, given a pair of screen
image and a visually-grounded natural language task, the goal is to generate a
script capable of fully executing the task. We run several strong baseline
language model agents on our benchmark. The strongest baseline, GPT-4, performs
the best on our benchmark However, its performance level still reaches only 15%
of the human proficiency in generating executable scripts capable of completing
the task, demonstrating the challenge of our task for conventional web agents.
Our benchmark provides a platform to measure and evaluate the progress of
language model agents in automating computer tasks and motivates future work
towards building multimodal models that bridge large language models and the
visual grounding of computer screens.
|
[
-0.5905870795,
-0.6755299568,
0.5751301646,
0.0531669371,
0.2153623551,
-0.0739543289,
-0.3779397309,
-0.502286315,
0.0855395421,
0.3790438175,
-0.6723146439,
-0.554255724,
-0.155546993,
0.2219014615,
-0.5251758695,
0.6450719237,
0.0847423971,
-0.4517016411,
-0.41147542,
-0.2602960169,
-0.2892179489,
-0.4895314276,
-0.386056453,
0.0658962354,
0.4134610593,
0.2748157382,
0.7912704349,
0.662807107,
0.3436475694,
0.5496961474,
0.7986131907,
0.1829036474,
-0.3440665901,
0.1933754832,
-0.1917821318,
-0.21467942,
-0.3967539966,
0.1905546486,
0.4242961407,
0.493308723,
-0.0243074931,
0.1256972104,
0.0661519691,
0.368068248,
-0.8602070808,
0.2794613838,
-0.2558779418,
-0.0112469625,
-0.0535565354,
-0.0222892892,
-0.1837387532,
-0.7118365169,
0.0897533447,
-0.7867452502,
0.0855402723,
-0.2727192938,
0.6004920602,
0.4776213169,
-0.4415677488,
-0.0833870694,
-0.800196588,
0.6684812307,
-0.4472323656,
0.4338574708,
0.2393482029,
0.5817963481,
-0.0447606035,
-0.8442336321,
-0.7245975137,
-0.7495301366,
0.1878570318,
0.0147949075,
-0.2525515258,
-0.0601364411,
0.1116974503,
0.1530040205,
-0.8031187654,
-0.1691747159,
-0.067113325,
-0.184026584,
0.12381614,
0.3774933517,
0.3233936727,
0.1186151281,
-0.2426675409,
-0.4583227336,
-0.3126450479,
0.1751224399,
0.3530023396,
0.3258447647,
-0.1175693274,
0.6410104036,
-0.4351430535,
0.786018312,
-0.0775853619,
0.0048972731,
0.4289156497,
-0.5190475583,
-0.4151932299,
-0.3303494155,
0.849168539,
0.309248656,
0.2789907455,
-0.2113609463,
-0.1031268984,
0.4242244065,
0.5376060605,
-0.5643557906,
-0.3354516923,
0.2101076841,
-0.261652559,
-0.1901633739,
0.3003669381,
-0.6801245213,
-0.5906751752,
-0.7524389625,
0.5804510713,
-0.4762818813,
-0.2758885026,
-0.0336619765,
-0.0596776754,
0.3010775447,
0.4513979256,
-0.5161175132,
0.3988842964,
0.4682506323,
0.5913913846,
-0.1775571406,
-0.6682799459,
-0.6582941413,
-0.0069495281,
-0.2265520841,
0.8660299182,
-0.5061693192,
-0.0649430603,
0.276201576,
0.0588398241,
-0.2028862834,
-0.3406120539,
0.3006571233,
-0.1407572031,
0.0639085248,
-0.1049828008,
-0.139222756,
-0.1537723094,
0.4903696179,
-0.7789013982,
0.6315222383,
0.2884128392,
-0.0776361525,
0.4581867456,
-0.818285346,
-0.2980031073,
-0.0227881204,
-0.5151540041,
0.0539032966,
-0.0072051869,
0.0610057861,
0.3372287452,
-0.3714226782,
-0.2361674011,
-0.4456531107,
-0.1037597656,
0.2191057652,
-0.4126506448,
0.4309714139,
-0.0032564851,
-0.6386306882,
0.1911543161,
-0.8305491209,
0.4149050713,
0.0664202571,
-0.4584322274,
-0.1543395668,
-0.0333574824,
0.4116008282,
0.291254878,
0.4350274205,
-0.5739305019,
0.3405269384,
-0.0349987075,
0.2412071079,
0.7778570652,
-0.5146864653,
0.2032641023,
-0.1748735756,
0.4216666222,
-0.4904024601,
0.5256550312,
-0.1291063875,
-0.2435228676,
-0.6663637161,
-0.5372251868,
0.1798031777,
0.4799547493,
-0.8025593758,
0.4250018895,
-0.3753899634,
-0.5566602349,
-0.4533092678,
0.3214586079,
0.4703399241,
0.0809933618,
0.191284433,
-0.3982802331,
-0.4534232616,
-1.072838068,
-0.0315890126,
-0.0747187957,
-0.137606591,
0.2868155837,
0.4628154039,
-0.6319617033,
1.1433422565,
-0.2668645382,
-0.6169973016,
-0.1088293195,
0.4815607667,
0.0857984573,
0.3314961195,
0.5484548211,
-0.8019801974,
-0.5382621884,
0.2744831145,
-1.1664061546,
-0.1889781058,
-0.0337274596,
0.0304081291,
0.3029721677,
0.4657401145,
-0.4986727238,
0.3981809318,
0.6575960517,
-0.2773506343,
0.6707582474,
-0.549344182,
0.4813342094,
-0.4169810116,
0.4906581938,
-0.0866675675,
-0.5205329061,
-0.6037948132,
0.0824716315,
0.1234747395,
-0.0875724927,
-0.4634295106,
0.2733962238,
-0.5013037324,
-0.1830178797,
-0.3923490644,
0.017256422,
-0.2767795622,
0.6635815501,
-0.0909193829,
0.8450552225,
0.3650411069,
-0.7621971965,
0.5694897771,
0.1291331351,
-0.1352363974,
0.9673984051,
-0.5692757368,
0.2493004948,
0.1061905026,
-0.1045686677,
-0.9021564722,
-0.4262025654,
0.0897821411,
-0.4046874344,
-0.2110696584,
0.252063781,
-0.8567646742,
-0.3860623837,
-0.2507695556,
0.3165834546,
0.2600238919,
-0.4734247625,
0.9396757483,
0.3639142513,
0.0268540718,
-0.3031238019,
-0.3228146136,
0.373862505,
0.0963597745,
-0.6906659007,
0.1728016734,
-0.3047328889,
-0.231344074,
0.1047272608,
0.0128118964,
-0.1382374018,
-0.1034648642,
0.596323669,
0.2233910263,
-0.1368244439,
-0.1472528875,
-0.2692398429,
-0.2531038821,
-0.0858604237,
-0.3195845485,
0.5098860264,
-0.4888038337,
-0.621912539,
-0.4859139621,
0.3170566559,
0.8704819083,
-0.2469757646,
0.323843807,
0.5685243607,
-0.2812137008,
-0.0309082363,
-0.7659421563,
0.104687199,
-0.481215775,
0.0694598258,
-0.5456016064,
-0.4905770719,
0.236636281,
-0.0326448195,
0.2817603946,
0.3122088313,
0.6181260943,
0.2268451154,
1.1829793453,
0.964879632,
-0.2154503018,
0.4970332384,
-0.1328755915,
-0.3668220341,
-0.2658907473,
-0.0644763932,
-0.5849834681,
-0.0918167606,
-0.3439072073,
-0.29182899,
0.5951570868,
-0.5903767943,
-0.3315895498,
0.7175418139,
-0.5338027477,
0.3580624163,
0.8913277388,
0.0798875019,
0.2290155739,
-0.1613042057,
-0.1556637883,
0.2558412552,
-0.1033675224,
-0.5391077995,
1.204554677,
-0.1018084511,
0.8249543309,
0.2580424547,
0.2665451169,
0.9381510615,
0.1389869452,
-0.2634208202,
0.5702387094,
0.1548348516,
-0.5164347291,
-0.421336621,
-0.1840263158,
-1.0712994337,
0.415905565,
-0.1189063266,
-0.8140250444,
0.2120283395,
0.1022480726,
-0.3848761022,
-0.0356283225,
-0.6946541071,
1.2138701677,
-0.3621082306,
-0.6379223466,
-0.2483670563,
-0.6093223095,
0.1810445935,
-0.0710880756,
0.0697401986,
0.0118342321,
-0.2263632417,
0.3203180432,
-0.3785481155,
0.7953380346,
-0.1253873408,
0.1642292887,
0.0178943984,
0.2019614577,
0.4891776443,
-0.3747208118,
0.1002374366,
0.0024115343,
0.0274681207,
-0.2790646553,
-0.3777020276,
0.834400475,
-0.8841050863,
-0.1244178712,
-0.4611673355,
-0.2411636114,
-0.2634331584,
0.2638382316,
0.0181635097,
0.5066526532,
-0.5956686139,
0.1895846575,
0.2339940518,
-0.1371696591,
0.4307225943,
0.6754904985,
-0.1101872176,
-0.5126012564,
0.9341367483,
-0.2150065452,
0.2396498024,
0.3785571456,
-0.155884102,
-0.4948816001,
-0.232236743,
-0.5515588522,
0.0135839637,
-0.7230187654,
0.1548734009,
-0.7700816393,
0.2111308575,
-0.4458672702,
-0.2074324787,
-0.4508887827,
0.0323695391,
-0.0254303608,
0.2061433196,
-0.1609443277,
0.8429040313,
-0.3103798926,
0.0684329569,
-0.4526238739,
0.5744843483,
0.7343888283,
0.277220726,
-0.3060619235,
0.1381432116,
-0.2980692387,
-0.1029421836,
-0.5482000113,
-0.6417621374,
0.3038439453,
0.1966246665,
0.9312455058,
0.6851725578,
0.0068986532,
0.6842750907,
-0.3197616935,
0.6725007892,
0.2164585292,
-1.0163303614,
0.4440201819,
-0.4989649057,
0.3746814728,
0.8663519621,
0.0543009005,
-0.4280011952,
-0.4545208812,
-0.3655036986,
-0.6760858297,
0.5900113583,
0.480773598,
-0.2768741846,
0.0786270276,
-0.3258839548,
0.3318361044,
0.690715909,
-0.6976547837,
-0.1214999631,
-0.4170624018,
-0.0369507559,
-0.5809554458,
0.2810261548,
-0.0473195203,
-0.0254545789,
0.2666840255,
-0.4570235014,
0.4776227772,
0.2835282087,
-0.466789633,
-0.0168504771,
0.0605001152,
0.6902240515,
0.767013371,
-0.4022453725,
0.1991773099,
-0.2915663123,
-0.399641037,
0.1737104803,
0.2902504206,
0.239819631,
-0.109289594,
0.2069111317,
0.337564826,
0.0251241494,
-1.043913126,
0.65123564,
-0.2862294018,
-0.0963772535,
-0.821860075,
0.1397013068,
-0.3463086784,
0.3209524453,
0.3511322439,
0.1143612489,
0.3702526391,
-0.7383466363,
0.1888406873,
0.4079010487,
-0.5271418691,
-0.418822825,
0.9110696316,
0.3662491739,
-0.2201824635,
0.5063655972,
-0.2039452642,
-0.1700391918,
0.7244827151,
0.0431827195,
1.0846891403,
-0.1593146026,
0.2373861969,
0.1230385602,
0.6025575995,
0.0010394027,
0.1507855952,
-0.2857317924,
-0.3306672275,
-0.1415287405,
-0.3801245391,
-0.5327541828,
0.2042972594,
-0.3099822998,
0.01411747,
-0.4667863548,
-0.2665849626,
0.1319229454,
-0.2865922153,
-1.1360300779,
0.142065376,
0.2859839499,
0.7526488304,
-0.6642266512,
0.6052641273,
0.7290189862,
-0.5466870666,
-0.2489707619,
-0.196564436,
0.4416445494,
-0.4492216706,
0.3903649747,
0.5384068489,
-0.2848903835,
-0.1885906309,
-0.4661077559,
-0.5861887932,
0.9396155477,
0.2930010557,
-0.1833980083,
0.1390047669,
0.4386587441,
0.5840876102,
-0.5060248971,
0.6165745854,
0.575545013,
0.8324953318,
-0.2648826241,
-1.1881166697,
0.1564124078,
-0.611079812,
-0.1579445153,
0.0185304917,
-0.1498010606,
1.2160946131,
0.076646626,
-0.1905423403,
0.3775719702,
0.3744833767,
-0.1474255621,
0.2598409951,
0.8313300014,
0.3259979486,
0.4785394669,
0.0330199488,
1.0631980896,
-0.2280461937,
0.0073564881,
0.9344362617,
-0.5764844418,
0.6841298342,
0.2497060001,
-0.0540479496,
0.4462082684,
0.2318823189,
0.0065110745,
0.6621538401,
-0.0299959332,
-0.2774072886,
-0.4880633056,
-0.0219296627,
-0.227834031,
0.4927421212,
0.1037646607,
-0.0971950665,
-0.4048425257,
0.5273395181,
-0.2695324719,
0.1506880075,
-0.1524419636,
0.8781548738,
-0.4296675026,
-0.9165987968,
0.6004723907,
-0.0739909708,
0.5410491228,
-0.8739544153,
-0.0526763462,
0.119810313,
0.6354817748,
0.039930556,
-0.5151404738,
-0.1260289848,
-0.0043981057,
-0.034507297,
-0.1524643749,
0.491576612,
-0.0594007261,
-0.2133408487,
0.3876194358,
0.669197917,
0.1890780181,
-0.6525294185,
-0.590978086,
0.1390427202,
-0.0529490709,
-0.1356634498,
0.342553854,
0.3398484886,
0.1068311706,
0.9309729338,
0.8003544807,
-0.1529032737,
0.1266054362,
-0.1789424866,
0.8817608953,
-0.7065886855,
-0.6258523464,
-0.6552931666,
0.5478810668,
-0.2243994623,
-0.342284441,
0.7994181514,
0.8106164336,
0.5931661725,
-0.3409230411,
1.2006812096,
-0.4377815723,
0.3778980374,
-0.1457720548,
0.4440219104,
-0.7614158392,
-0.2941201031,
-0.3373897672,
-0.8129399419,
0.0912622958,
0.3504035771,
-0.1152803823,
0.0291687753,
0.7921266556,
0.8950757384,
-0.2556573451,
-0.1365689933,
0.6416504979,
-0.0151037229,
0.4267715812,
0.6320384145,
0.8526759744,
-0.0745161772,
0.8752804399,
-0.1523432285,
-0.5688399673,
-0.3867196739,
-0.6315351129,
-1.038120985,
-0.7377984524,
-0.1286497414,
-0.0781388432,
0.2294231057,
1.1406919956,
0.905705452,
-0.4958946407,
-0.4500075877,
-0.098869741,
-0.3327467442,
-0.6917321682,
-0.139647603,
0.1564781368,
-0.2386415899,
-0.8314725757,
0.5737634897,
0.2349593341,
-0.0725254864,
-0.535045445,
-0.0263633151,
0.0329257734,
0.0694243237,
0.6179761887,
0.6999288201,
-0.571886003,
-0.2207777053,
-0.0163071677,
-0.4844596386,
-0.0274977479,
0.7773824334,
-1.0348944664,
0.5669786334,
0.2518832386,
0.4365395308,
0.2146009058,
0.0553299636,
0.6004559398,
-0.490922153,
-0.0183664747,
0.1262059212,
0.1773724556,
0.0886604711,
0.0385176763,
0.5661303997,
0.1380994767,
-0.5704895854,
-0.5326441526,
-0.0188682731,
-1.2197031975,
-0.3405652344,
0.9588075876,
0.1341002285,
-0.3747564554,
-0.4281208515,
-0.2911995649,
-0.1664467752,
-0.6748329401,
0.7936758399,
0.229229331,
-0.0311808474,
0.0315755904,
-0.8738649487,
0.3782956004,
-0.0567767546,
-1.2454963923,
0.0577673689,
0.8815683722,
-0.0073136366,
0.3597024381,
0.6954757571,
0.1913704723,
0.5891910195,
0.1239392832,
0.6322957277,
-0.4257681668,
-0.5038555264,
-0.0214055013,
0.5827070475,
-0.2286851853,
-0.5735644698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17811v2
|
TruthX: Alleviating Hallucinations by Editing Large Language Models in Truthful Space
| 2024-02-27T14:45:04 | 2024-06-05T11:15:04 |
Shaolei Zhang, Tian Yu, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) sometimes suffer from producing hallucinations,
especially LLMs may generate untruthful responses despite knowing the correct
knowledge. Activating the truthfulness within LLM is the key to fully unlocking
LLM's knowledge potential. In this paper, we propose TruthX, an inference-time
intervention method to activate the truthfulness of LLM by identifying and
editing the features within LLM's internal representations that govern the
truthfulness. TruthX employs an auto-encoder to map LLM's representations into
semantic and truthful latent spaces respectively, and applies contrastive
learning to identify a truthful editing direction within the truthful space.
During inference, by editing LLM's internal representations in truthful space,
TruthX effectively enhances the truthfulness of LLM. Experiments show that
TruthX improves the truthfulness of 13 advanced LLMs by an average of 20% on
TruthfulQA benchmark. Further analyses suggest that TruthX can control LLM to
produce truthful or hallucinatory responses via editing only one vector in
LLM's internal representations.
|
[
-0.1434846371,
-0.7963480949,
0.9553682208,
0.2287702709,
-0.0765990764,
0.182547912,
-0.3994673789,
-0.3301121593,
0.1658643931,
0.5674719214,
-0.4699946046,
-0.6149410605,
-0.4899274111,
0.1275755167,
-0.3159623146,
0.6515630484,
-0.0062098061,
-0.0824559554,
-0.0105806096,
-0.163095355,
-0.4120078683,
-0.7602857947,
-0.3986386359,
-0.2310182154,
0.3631594777,
0.0576246902,
0.9996298552,
0.8027496934,
0.3004543185,
0.3879038692,
-0.162872985,
0.2056044936,
-0.5740977526,
0.1001137793,
-0.2679300904,
-0.6647331119,
-0.4785785675,
0.1087356359,
0.7901347876,
0.8224179745,
-0.2741404772,
-0.142803967,
0.0028863726,
0.4616523683,
-0.7180612087,
0.0438426398,
-0.6757288575,
0.3250779808,
0.2535363138,
-0.2002756596,
-0.3648656905,
-0.5864747167,
-0.2012162358,
-0.604398191,
0.0594459325,
0.0450736806,
0.4408680201,
0.7366920114,
-0.1892618388,
-0.2574936152,
-0.8502089381,
0.7369588614,
-0.9921887517,
0.7183148265,
0.0013997062,
0.0345595554,
-0.3150077164,
-0.4829483926,
-1.1019240618,
-0.1645623595,
-0.1972364038,
0.1156733111,
-0.2639003694,
0.1689657569,
0.5824459791,
0.1023580581,
-0.4608864784,
-0.0067889751,
-0.1089695767,
-0.2795999944,
0.4202592969,
0.2393898666,
0.1397975683,
0.0017279541,
-0.2132553905,
0.0290651713,
-0.4760426581,
-0.3096107543,
0.3800684512,
-0.0064764777,
0.1618534923,
0.7165182829,
-0.024745347,
0.543941617,
0.1873090118,
-0.4247043431,
0.3296451867,
0.048807174,
-0.2944565713,
0.4378633499,
0.5393912196,
0.5109664202,
-0.1148084924,
-0.2699222863,
-0.4316274524,
0.3583773077,
0.2705545127,
-0.9325953722,
0.0255114138,
0.4259049296,
-0.5029368997,
-0.3232698441,
-0.0419309698,
-0.7792087197,
-0.7182685137,
-0.5033742189,
0.5817329884,
-0.4332911074,
-0.448625505,
0.5679478049,
-0.0483880602,
0.164348647,
0.3930805624,
-0.3356798887,
0.3713598251,
0.4532626271,
0.75676018,
-0.1257496178,
-0.1261692941,
-0.5365499258,
0.1880909652,
-0.5671532154,
0.4662826359,
-0.9581227899,
-0.4670914114,
-0.0502993576,
-0.1394250244,
0.0942113027,
-0.7279521227,
0.5741330385,
-0.6918637753,
0.1041016504,
-0.2112293988,
-0.6650668383,
-0.245612517,
0.076231882,
-0.6409604549,
0.743083775,
0.0218161661,
-0.6249728203,
-0.012446966,
-0.8561785221,
-0.2293272614,
-0.3195665479,
-0.0518515967,
-0.3517207205,
0.408426553,
0.3504644632,
0.2436439097,
0.4462242723,
0.2759257853,
-0.2409454882,
-0.2937390804,
0.7854142189,
-0.4005191028,
0.4090310037,
0.1490352005,
-0.3867405057,
0.2115680277,
-0.8052033186,
-0.1671409309,
0.1350397617,
-0.1477803737,
-0.3885034621,
-0.1652931124,
-0.1611661464,
0.2575798631,
0.2054439932,
-0.6828343868,
0.2851025164,
-0.5494230986,
0.0996382087,
0.8740589619,
0.2374694794,
0.2933312953,
-0.2626497447,
0.3261150718,
0.2613303363,
0.2732585967,
0.0360197239,
-0.1230555549,
-0.9939269423,
-0.1186224297,
0.2464212626,
0.467776835,
-0.9785797596,
0.5960503221,
-0.1243449822,
-0.1431242526,
-0.7970842123,
0.2068235874,
0.3952824771,
0.6137405038,
0.5935888886,
-0.1947039813,
-0.4658662975,
-0.792514801,
-0.2531658411,
-0.1165498719,
0.0628028065,
0.1179926544,
0.465026021,
-0.5229055285,
0.9034542441,
-0.6646474004,
-0.2890999317,
-0.0268082246,
0.3234190643,
0.2184169143,
0.3296560645,
0.3671808243,
-0.7800167203,
-0.0568165332,
-0.3837573826,
-0.8244977593,
-0.4683235884,
-0.5281127095,
-0.0247762743,
0.2527634501,
0.4575143456,
-0.3601081073,
0.6418067813,
0.4826185405,
-0.3730177581,
0.6341944337,
-0.3482269347,
0.3225183189,
-0.8047207594,
-0.2230233848,
-0.4697469771,
-0.1320636868,
-0.4626767635,
-0.0931985453,
0.1362404972,
0.0638158321,
-0.3259856105,
0.5174284577,
-0.3959593177,
0.042996224,
-0.5220577121,
0.3592799306,
0.0346735194,
0.7886765003,
0.3404907584,
0.7619367242,
0.3794470131,
-0.4884797931,
0.2243551016,
0.4374273717,
-0.2563139796,
0.4183388054,
-0.3988534212,
0.5108480453,
-0.3210560977,
0.0975668579,
-0.7553116679,
-0.0020013421,
0.3111744225,
-0.3493179083,
0.0555228256,
0.1665012389,
-0.5177291036,
0.0839646459,
-0.2279602587,
0.1841522753,
0.4249731302,
-0.7835308909,
0.9005452991,
0.1475072801,
-0.0217318051,
-0.6071240902,
-0.7660450339,
0.4501298964,
-0.0190033708,
-0.2564381063,
0.2012537271,
-0.4507338703,
-0.6373535395,
0.1471032053,
-0.187133044,
0.19256185,
-0.1018670946,
0.4114998281,
0.2468469441,
-0.053525269,
0.1537729651,
0.3181844652,
-0.2789082527,
0.123047024,
-0.3504108191,
0.3323249221,
-0.0072433627,
-0.4126683772,
-0.4337711632,
0.4171496928,
0.452508837,
-0.3523518145,
0.7905574441,
0.3136949241,
-0.3692322969,
-0.3325698972,
-0.8529600501,
-0.4338099658,
-0.4953663349,
0.3106360435,
-0.45910272,
-1.0771771669,
0.3727440238,
-0.4245373905,
-0.1206823662,
-0.0573883913,
0.504429996,
0.1865166426,
0.8831357956,
0.6453600526,
-0.0087839933,
0.2145879865,
-0.2085124701,
0.3388014436,
-1.0097978115,
-0.0175759718,
-0.2998297215,
-0.2680571973,
-0.2785586715,
-0.8332797289,
0.5724218488,
-0.2821571231,
0.1295193583,
-0.1455877721,
-0.4470563829,
0.5597933531,
0.1959239542,
0.3587453663,
0.5169203281,
-0.2759259045,
-0.0710970908,
-0.4605198205,
-0.5226609707,
-0.4259629846,
1.0638055801,
0.2523459494,
1.0291434526,
0.183078602,
0.5219660997,
0.2148893774,
0.2094784975,
-0.7643930912,
0.6277390122,
0.1437234432,
-0.3517018259,
-0.2091343552,
-0.3629150987,
-0.4669068456,
0.0664565936,
-0.4540008307,
-0.443955034,
0.5859986544,
0.0391179323,
-0.5758244395,
0.5008828044,
-0.4283249676,
0.481485039,
-0.2309779823,
-0.5005294085,
-0.5520846248,
-0.6147572398,
0.3087890744,
-0.3832467198,
0.3437324166,
0.3017769456,
-0.2934076786,
0.5873035192,
-0.1239321902,
1.0463135242,
-0.1770436764,
-0.2884405255,
-0.1580444574,
0.5112134814,
0.6826843023,
0.0218504239,
-0.2243608236,
0.2803989053,
-0.3944742382,
-0.0190466568,
-1.1250462532,
0.6143333912,
-0.7659745216,
-0.7396550179,
-0.3319577277,
-0.6578018069,
-0.4070423543,
-0.0655676052,
-0.1505860835,
0.3682966828,
-0.1730898917,
0.1339523047,
1.201659441,
-0.4956308007,
0.4716606736,
0.6414068341,
-0.523748219,
-0.4277197719,
0.6909400821,
0.0644725487,
0.3165877163,
0.4184511304,
0.3497181535,
-0.4636814594,
-0.6158847809,
0.1511954367,
0.3927633166,
-0.8786016703,
0.0423149616,
-1.0059130192,
-0.2722994685,
-0.4534981847,
-0.250164032,
-0.4692897499,
-0.5007876158,
0.0404654145,
-0.2898890376,
0.1365376264,
0.6013618708,
-0.5243905783,
0.3962373137,
-0.6098105311,
0.6361236572,
0.6059013009,
0.2838671505,
-0.2505704463,
-0.6955610514,
-0.1744618416,
-0.1540675312,
-0.0111480411,
-0.8236915469,
0.4315159023,
0.0267693717,
0.4286152422,
0.5357319117,
0.184035942,
0.6615428925,
-0.4519976377,
0.7230852246,
0.0460857563,
-1.351769805,
0.5144360065,
0.1438860595,
0.2992200851,
0.1698320061,
0.209418416,
-0.7217588425,
-0.7050008774,
-0.4555387199,
-0.394973129,
0.4102987051,
0.2023267895,
0.2409535199,
0.3564685881,
0.5469920039,
0.3653395772,
0.4418115616,
-0.7194432616,
-0.1636230201,
-0.5330133438,
-0.0703099072,
0.2147767395,
-0.6199314594,
-0.4403713048,
-0.3023333251,
0.7390395403,
-0.3019412756,
0.2833639979,
0.4434094429,
-0.0691870078,
-0.2436240166,
0.4341310859,
0.5691619515,
0.768443346,
-0.1471293867,
0.392257452,
0.3019105494,
-0.4089746475,
0.0570180938,
-0.0721265152,
-0.1436285675,
0.0510125346,
0.5571550727,
1.0437290668,
0.0163176712,
-0.5005042553,
0.3901259601,
-0.2741128802,
-0.1782388091,
-0.1394686997,
0.4497962892,
-0.1550698429,
0.5821685195,
0.1023831069,
0.1267448813,
0.2669591904,
-0.3991015255,
0.1116430461,
0.3102389872,
-0.3878798485,
-0.1617191285,
0.8352578878,
-0.1991937906,
-0.2467394769,
0.5142902136,
0.01237805,
-0.6818675995,
0.085613817,
0.7056449652,
1.0132375956,
-0.5727899075,
0.0940785259,
0.3968463242,
0.4345288575,
0.3423176408,
0.1731900424,
0.0497739837,
-1.0791065693,
-0.5358618498,
-0.5729045868,
-0.5276814103,
0.3835598826,
-0.3899250627,
-0.070032604,
-0.4759351015,
0.0566732809,
-0.3072281182,
-0.1667499989,
-0.1656991988,
0.3769120574,
0.2258583307,
0.8424909711,
-0.6465927362,
0.9858753085,
0.3069781959,
-0.1059015244,
-0.8032261133,
0.3850671053,
0.0968572497,
-0.6880449653,
0.4489946961,
-0.1016807854,
-0.4490182996,
-0.0352945924,
-1.0813896656,
-0.5662001371,
0.7280476689,
0.545953691,
-0.7576162815,
0.2395401597,
0.3589906394,
0.4348432124,
-0.3781112432,
-0.0114215724,
0.6942317486,
0.7716271877,
0.4021887481,
-0.5981584787,
0.3508327305,
-0.2349789441,
0.0560040548,
-0.1347549409,
-0.4597243965,
0.5095943809,
-0.4400263727,
-0.096459724,
-0.1472043693,
0.8607809544,
0.2168942839,
-0.1276196837,
0.8380376697,
0.5582540035,
0.9094440937,
-0.0392112583,
0.6432917714,
-0.4820511043,
-0.0962827504,
1.2325809002,
-0.4120353758,
0.58726722,
0.6176825166,
0.1754863262,
0.5030092597,
0.2369540185,
0.0068284031,
0.5691890121,
0.0817949474,
-0.5826399326,
-0.5030223131,
-0.0934213772,
-0.4287308753,
0.2607594132,
0.5333763957,
-0.0136171682,
-0.068983838,
0.4234583974,
0.47305125,
0.3053023517,
-0.0547543168,
0.8623687029,
0.0452907421,
-0.397223413,
0.4983666837,
-0.0232379194,
0.4139232635,
-0.6737197638,
-0.4954136014,
-0.3060130179,
0.1807306707,
-0.2018214613,
-0.9195559621,
0.2798570693,
-0.106330283,
-0.0048488756,
-0.1637672335,
0.6520863771,
-0.5951404572,
-0.4120700359,
0.5645941496,
0.2364308238,
-0.0423232503,
-0.3763256967,
-0.5613155961,
0.4890877306,
0.0100463964,
-0.289771378,
-0.1061958,
0.6763501167,
0.2014557421,
0.6146128774,
0.7483147979,
0.3970887363,
-0.0638886094,
0.0628175586,
1.0557528734,
-0.7956403494,
-0.4779983759,
-0.8402818441,
0.5152885914,
-0.1404320151,
0.1207054928,
0.6537486911,
0.5551885366,
0.630566299,
-0.0927788615,
1.0417132378,
0.0843374953,
0.4252327979,
-0.8532282114,
0.7049846649,
-0.5828360319,
0.2604023516,
-0.1210502461,
-0.8328682184,
-0.3902207911,
0.5507976413,
-0.4351433814,
-0.341971904,
0.9236976504,
1.3285973072,
0.1477517188,
0.1083118916,
0.6625738144,
1.1028193235,
0.3222607672,
0.4311434627,
0.9647712111,
-0.1116816252,
0.3921246231,
-0.4402272999,
-0.5028907061,
0.0539966002,
-0.8186240792,
-1.0557672977,
-0.5535072088,
-0.4227308929,
-0.4325416088,
0.1678256392,
1.0745550394,
0.4521927238,
-0.8190737367,
-0.1418112516,
0.3050731719,
0.2971923351,
-0.2862609327,
-0.2147292495,
0.4992357492,
-0.3898970485,
-0.7454462051,
0.652443409,
0.5076889992,
-0.0568718761,
-0.4172631502,
-0.1578458101,
0.0857348442,
0.4030519426,
0.4482656717,
-0.2040465623,
-0.5846535563,
-0.4881155789,
-0.0053044958,
-0.0298706871,
0.3417062461,
0.8003243804,
-0.9014797211,
0.7776460648,
0.1148500517,
0.4824496806,
0.2950021923,
-0.1851686239,
0.4879902601,
-0.6446864605,
0.2292897403,
0.2458498627,
0.2793422639,
0.391448468,
-0.620211482,
0.4961298704,
0.4876143038,
-0.3330646455,
-0.6707113981,
0.0985575095,
-0.9444320798,
-0.5137830377,
1.183804512,
0.1826366931,
-0.4040101767,
-0.2023853213,
-0.6246881485,
0.3560611904,
-0.2791523933,
1.1168277264,
0.7017581463,
-0.0822672695,
-0.165088892,
-0.5851287246,
0.5752622485,
0.195283547,
-0.8705807328,
0.2925603986,
0.6870720387,
0.0181480292,
0.3333548009,
0.2929931581,
-0.1976969391,
0.0413169675,
0.0235605724,
0.4143287539,
-0.2129959166,
-0.3882178664,
-0.4215688407,
0.2007153183,
-0.2397560924,
0.010275132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17546v1
|
COCOA: CBT-based Conversational Counseling Agent using Memory Specialized in Cognitive Distortions and Dynamic Prompt
| 2024-02-27T14:38:47 | 2024-02-27T14:38:47 |
Suyeon Lee, Jieun Kang, Harim Kim, Kyoung-Mee Chung, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The demand for conversational agents that provide mental health care is
consistently increasing. In this work, we develop a psychological counseling
agent, referred to as CoCoA, that applies Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
techniques to identify and address cognitive distortions inherent in the
client's statements. Specifically, we construct a memory system to efficiently
manage information necessary for counseling while extracting high-level
insights about the client from their utterances. Additionally, to ensure that
the counseling agent generates appropriate responses, we introduce dynamic
prompting to flexibly apply CBT techniques and facilitate the appropriate
retrieval of information. We conducted dialogues between CoCoA and characters
from Character.ai, creating a dataset for evaluation. Then, we asked GPT to
evaluate the constructed counseling dataset, and our model demonstrated a
statistically significant difference from other models.
|
[
-0.3299694657,
-1.3518522978,
0.7089866996,
0.6405923367,
0.0901010633,
0.5155229568,
-0.0469386019,
-0.5380268693,
0.3648929596,
0.4959755242,
-0.7246658206,
-0.2459935546,
-0.515746057,
-0.2002973408,
-0.1411916763,
0.9350994825,
0.1738375872,
0.0659292713,
-0.1567180604,
0.1928927898,
-1.4409062862,
-0.4731131196,
-1.2735263109,
-0.4690741003,
0.2762594819,
0.4236392081,
1.0897616148,
0.0698716938,
0.0912580043,
0.3429041803,
-0.0421774648,
0.1435321271,
-0.3874028325,
0.4321165681,
-0.2188808471,
-0.3874702752,
-0.757461071,
-0.1036104858,
0.0970694274,
0.4134559929,
-0.5087694526,
-0.021159688,
-0.2142708451,
0.3257299066,
-0.4854387343,
0.5061203241,
-0.7691650391,
0.1613115668,
0.1890517175,
-0.2310216576,
-0.592043817,
-0.400193423,
0.1586845368,
-0.7217084169,
0.4458754957,
0.0607013553,
0.5970677137,
0.2181379646,
-0.5482279062,
-0.5248675942,
-0.8515663147,
0.534045577,
-0.3766204715,
0.1402863562,
1.0223191977,
0.6056407094,
-0.2520449758,
-0.611148715,
-0.1610712856,
-0.6142959595,
-0.0227094553,
0.3556939065,
0.0484395623,
0.1180860996,
0.2467512041,
0.2771916687,
-0.412198633,
-0.3021104038,
-0.0219574198,
-0.3860097528,
0.5793936849,
0.5865772367,
0.4222926497,
0.1588435918,
0.0740138143,
0.0485721864,
0.0272738785,
-0.1285975277,
0.1278721094,
0.0212255958,
0.204052195,
0.4026002586,
0.2260480076,
0.4743767679,
0.3974717855,
-0.1920043975,
-0.2645871341,
0.1207392514,
-0.3126274645,
0.6868342161,
0.604390502,
0.4534144104,
0.3454855084,
-0.1496018916,
0.0329623558,
0.2027909011,
0.7934499383,
-0.5564786196,
-0.443228811,
0.0712206587,
-0.2690144181,
-0.250715524,
-0.2023105472,
-0.6512343287,
-0.5604223013,
-0.2706159949,
-0.2588851452,
-0.9338695407,
-0.3574118912,
-0.0239049867,
-0.2808803022,
-0.0584337898,
0.5049711466,
-1.0677201748,
0.5850780606,
0.2577935159,
0.7049558759,
0.0138225714,
0.1854027361,
-0.1654422432,
0.412311703,
-0.3821095228,
0.7872692347,
-0.8013094664,
-0.7819604278,
-0.0577466562,
0.0254999809,
-0.0044026305,
-0.6190511584,
0.3113502562,
-0.4327783585,
-0.1889244765,
-0.6561214328,
-0.2478695363,
-0.0066352179,
0.7965545058,
-0.5960355401,
1.3278400898,
0.5444476008,
-0.5734146237,
0.1975814253,
-0.6876865029,
-0.4748820662,
0.2297275811,
-0.1758396924,
0.0412316695,
0.1950192153,
0.3903324008,
0.0619061664,
-0.4172371626,
0.2746278048,
-0.2434925437,
-0.2806737721,
0.8033058643,
-0.8726298809,
0.5078749657,
0.2707372606,
-0.0448167026,
-0.0362417698,
-0.8886675835,
0.1404981017,
0.3692198098,
-0.3712014556,
-0.3957135677,
-0.1659750193,
0.0611587726,
-0.0166772194,
0.0639444217,
-0.4371176958,
0.4618523717,
-0.0108319931,
0.4413568377,
0.6170068979,
0.378691256,
-0.0946274623,
-0.4760503769,
0.8077400923,
-0.0376895554,
0.2954563797,
-0.1603332162,
-0.7610604167,
-0.4592833519,
-0.4258364737,
-0.2810890973,
0.7171963453,
-0.799723506,
0.2971235216,
0.2089025974,
-0.3814555407,
-0.4125843048,
-0.2782980502,
0.3153464794,
0.6770086288,
0.4257349074,
-0.5009593964,
-0.2669745088,
-0.6229405999,
-0.1536754668,
-0.1346719116,
0.3331816494,
0.3340764344,
-0.0274634007,
-0.3841985762,
1.1523554325,
-0.6454598904,
-0.0299815014,
-0.1144609004,
0.4351608753,
-0.0361215845,
0.4086152911,
0.6059295535,
-0.4911089242,
-0.715407908,
-0.1005411297,
-0.7330759168,
-0.2431181669,
-0.408870399,
-0.2287684828,
-0.1782996058,
0.4389960766,
-0.6494886279,
0.6133622527,
0.1861989647,
-0.5072117448,
1.0125948191,
-0.4438256323,
0.2058700621,
-0.8324548602,
-0.1793080121,
-0.5087848306,
-0.4649108946,
-0.393971622,
-0.5987568498,
-0.1100312024,
-0.2999790609,
-0.3909404576,
0.5088660717,
-0.695862174,
0.0620670691,
-0.4144713581,
0.0407505594,
-0.0803012252,
0.501319766,
-0.0459624156,
0.7894417644,
0.5357451439,
-0.5717647076,
0.8193839192,
0.5377479196,
-0.0656296015,
1.0945910215,
-0.4189940095,
0.4293960929,
0.0620254315,
0.4503551126,
-0.680193007,
0.0486532375,
0.4903911352,
-0.0999666378,
0.3384011388,
0.0363330133,
-0.2894743085,
-0.4955960214,
0.1094553173,
0.6747370362,
0.1840492487,
-0.1474575698,
0.4268759191,
-0.0087238438,
-0.3585527539,
-0.5026055574,
-0.8829628825,
0.2315440476,
0.0661731288,
-0.4616973996,
0.2619938552,
-0.3853811026,
-0.0617199205,
0.1988569051,
-0.1529611796,
0.0478028841,
-0.0554528981,
0.3276930153,
0.0684315562,
-0.1345453709,
0.1825249493,
0.3375331461,
-0.3141628504,
0.1877950132,
-0.2002829462,
0.944924593,
-0.2713494301,
-0.5301662683,
-0.4775099456,
0.4768479168,
0.6278131604,
-0.2807380557,
0.8802837729,
0.4788400531,
-0.1845885217,
0.0706000701,
-0.6784197092,
-0.0059354831,
-0.5045799613,
0.2660495341,
-0.4848018289,
-0.4009122252,
0.835167408,
-0.0397932157,
-0.470462352,
-0.2058201134,
0.7472105026,
0.2346008867,
1.3083888292,
0.1404093355,
0.0992672294,
0.9534643888,
-0.2981627882,
0.1261902004,
-0.8673587441,
-0.0994075686,
0.0200502444,
-0.1995659322,
-0.109031409,
-0.236521706,
0.1028257534,
0.0529070459,
-0.5658914447,
0.1096708328,
-0.8219724298,
0.3412537575,
0.5245755315,
0.3903374672,
0.2323748022,
-0.3072431684,
-0.4032337368,
-0.0105401892,
-0.4201204181,
-0.4688245654,
0.7164230943,
0.2341078669,
0.7201981544,
0.1447650641,
0.1903055161,
0.4618733525,
0.5390719771,
-1.0405144691,
0.6021089554,
0.4968138933,
-0.9062308669,
-0.0261543989,
-0.2200524956,
-1.1324970722,
0.0015584662,
-0.0592646413,
-1.0499795675,
0.2160480171,
0.1190610901,
-0.2299965918,
-0.18814376,
-0.5248946548,
0.8177511096,
-0.5976759791,
-0.0407676101,
-0.3597925901,
-0.4958787262,
0.3066782057,
-0.144776836,
-0.113948524,
-0.2827242613,
0.3116368651,
0.4686584175,
-0.8294095993,
0.860014081,
-0.2548814714,
0.0650019869,
0.5221568942,
0.5331835151,
0.507664144,
0.4161764979,
-0.2064883262,
-0.2833735645,
0.5396812558,
-0.5795029998,
-1.0724978447,
0.426392138,
-0.7397458553,
-0.5136565566,
-0.5660629869,
-0.9624541998,
-0.5787441134,
0.2769967914,
0.0380050205,
0.359877646,
-0.8364189267,
-0.1047709361,
0.3360200524,
-0.5568631291,
0.1252711564,
0.7581234574,
-0.2626598477,
-0.4592798054,
0.7623825669,
0.0040646913,
0.3646313548,
-0.0686884597,
0.2779539526,
0.0553461164,
-0.3806703687,
0.0669880807,
0.3519747257,
-0.7245999575,
-0.1592100412,
-0.3895744383,
-0.1627694368,
-0.6173078418,
-0.4745165706,
-0.5439295769,
-0.1176023111,
-0.1110376716,
-0.2878337204,
0.4636828303,
0.5428040624,
0.2833222747,
0.7988455296,
-0.8395293951,
0.2829236686,
0.1798824072,
0.0989577398,
0.1738228649,
0.208300367,
-0.2109291255,
0.2596870959,
-0.8838537931,
-1.3320295811,
0.5890366435,
-0.0268572643,
0.5585666299,
0.6429610252,
0.2551910877,
0.9533887506,
-0.2014045268,
0.8900063038,
0.4249255657,
-0.9501261115,
0.7344188094,
-0.3792854249,
0.3366518021,
0.6118210554,
-0.0251278821,
-0.9308499694,
-0.6910369396,
-0.7631363869,
-0.6664484143,
0.9067823291,
0.1775841862,
0.1206152812,
-0.4942947924,
0.6542266607,
-0.108418189,
0.2690344751,
-0.2061740309,
-0.075849548,
-0.4367350936,
-0.4954004288,
0.2381670922,
-0.2162903696,
-0.3015711606,
-0.1656478494,
0.6626234055,
-0.2992635667,
0.7570126057,
0.2904236019,
-0.1071824804,
-0.1990269423,
0.1445030719,
0.349445492,
0.4639618695,
-0.3621087968,
-0.0240158476,
0.3206070662,
-0.934776783,
0.2704311609,
-0.0740629956,
0.0974573568,
-0.2692193091,
0.2947869301,
0.8827123046,
0.1580566615,
-0.6707687974,
0.2737755775,
-0.475736469,
0.078702502,
-0.5000311136,
0.1968351454,
-0.0140316188,
0.2682266533,
-0.1060528904,
-0.0498978272,
0.0277458355,
-1.093539238,
0.0042397836,
0.3739129901,
-0.729156673,
-0.1420786828,
0.5913698673,
-0.0946464092,
-0.7134889364,
1.2280256748,
0.0084849,
-0.4217013717,
0.7574061751,
1.1848376989,
0.7648642063,
-0.4562612176,
0.4863275886,
-0.1866688728,
0.0394992679,
-0.224860236,
0.2540544271,
-0.2464484274,
-0.8016542792,
0.0460702106,
-0.2206764817,
-0.5456969142,
-0.0470587276,
-1.0516273975,
0.070353277,
-0.7953450084,
-0.578563869,
-0.2893022299,
0.0038066993,
-0.6984705925,
0.2836123407,
-0.0265033133,
0.875918746,
-0.5747503042,
1.106313467,
0.7291461825,
-0.6759153008,
-0.9487412572,
-0.0600130633,
0.1587946713,
-1.0030469894,
0.3103170097,
0.0257092305,
-0.113111794,
-0.1395774633,
-0.3624038398,
-0.7418007255,
1.3402816057,
0.8203564882,
-0.2503611445,
-0.2080229521,
0.2619717717,
0.6318169832,
-0.326358676,
0.8138789535,
0.7963023186,
0.7179689407,
0.3610342145,
-0.7820684314,
0.3811987936,
-0.3144983351,
0.1316869855,
-0.0471376255,
-0.7205535769,
0.4234995246,
0.2169090509,
-0.0445054173,
0.1847237945,
0.4704542458,
0.2677182257,
0.4966846406,
0.3257627189,
0.0881392583,
1.337251544,
0.0577113293,
1.0338612795,
-0.2788023651,
0.2248929888,
1.3431156874,
-0.2478284687,
0.1286927313,
0.1621006429,
0.170128122,
0.5117385387,
0.83131814,
-0.0148492092,
0.3509651124,
0.0102075776,
-0.1990756094,
-0.0911203399,
-0.1724313647,
-0.2381843925,
0.0127022611,
0.8183829784,
-0.2500909269,
0.2096895576,
0.4365225434,
0.1292830557,
-0.1521248519,
-0.0774807483,
0.6824072003,
0.3221075833,
-0.7935137749,
0.6984231472,
-0.2176712602,
-0.0025748736,
-0.7898103595,
0.0820039809,
-0.2005761415,
0.3904210627,
-0.1341165453,
-0.4751515985,
0.5345929265,
-0.237638399,
-0.1827838868,
-0.3343292773,
0.7055392861,
-0.3016742468,
-0.42449224,
0.4227023125,
0.1751685441,
0.2207214534,
-0.3958674967,
-1.2161515951,
0.0651801527,
-0.4223673344,
-0.3437493443,
0.2054659873,
0.6339057684,
-0.3768069148,
0.787905395,
0.5085055828,
0.1135720238,
0.0048534842,
0.1828933358,
0.6872082949,
-0.8206066489,
-0.6341078281,
-0.5400192142,
0.2337291986,
-0.2104436159,
-0.1554803997,
0.70865345,
0.321274519,
0.0591986589,
0.0272853002,
0.7326586843,
-0.1419681907,
0.1584633142,
-0.3616701663,
0.4732896984,
-0.2547405362,
0.2363638431,
-0.3844739795,
-1.0236316919,
-0.1871806532,
0.7466465235,
-0.538914144,
0.2027627826,
1.0524133444,
0.8543185592,
-0.1457865238,
0.3587603569,
0.357401669,
0.4813843966,
0.9437520504,
0.4899452031,
1.0858211517,
-0.0787671804,
0.4196688533,
0.2127259076,
-0.3190614879,
-0.3819276094,
-0.7685127854,
-0.7792676091,
-0.2692988813,
-0.371931076,
-0.5541011691,
0.2130150497,
0.9737402797,
0.808898747,
-0.6259348392,
0.0370725654,
-0.3225083649,
-0.1720230132,
-0.8121516109,
-0.2979314923,
0.2655668557,
-0.3178598285,
-0.4049949348,
0.6334721446,
0.1233046278,
-0.0148015255,
-0.0672082007,
-0.2093472034,
-0.0494854115,
0.6671995521,
0.435433507,
0.295776546,
-0.5007876158,
-0.3644829392,
-0.3401060402,
-0.069114536,
0.2964959443,
1.2259699106,
-0.7065040469,
0.6535321474,
0.0781058371,
0.4424807131,
1.0151051283,
0.1768933535,
0.8715107441,
-0.5759087205,
0.3385062516,
0.3220237792,
0.1587396562,
0.2619003654,
-0.861081481,
0.2712409794,
0.2150665671,
-0.6621376872,
-0.543222487,
0.329575628,
-1.3912842274,
-0.4489321411,
0.9230834842,
-0.2185468376,
-0.1740170717,
-0.6065226197,
-1.2100504637,
0.5400056839,
-0.6924703121,
0.7479233146,
0.8321377039,
-0.579590559,
-0.1940114647,
-0.5131976604,
0.2820120454,
0.3120135665,
-0.6879284978,
0.0870482847,
0.4070776403,
0.3268494904,
0.1067172512,
1.102512002,
-0.0728150681,
0.0353012457,
0.2257898748,
-0.059404403,
-0.2486963868,
-0.0199107844,
0.1603571922,
0.0784914568,
0.0875791535,
0.0736608058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17532v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17532v3
|
Retrieval is Accurate Generation
| 2024-02-27T14:16:19 | 2024-03-16T04:31:47 |
Bowen Cao, Deng Cai, Leyang Cui, Xuxin Cheng, Wei Bi, Yuexian Zou, Shuming Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Standard language models generate text by selecting tokens from a fixed,
finite, and standalone vocabulary. We introduce a novel method that selects
context-aware phrases from a collection of supporting documents. One of the
most significant challenges for this paradigm shift is determining the training
oracles, because a string of text can be segmented in various ways and each
segment can be retrieved from numerous possible documents. To address this, we
propose to initialize the training oracles using linguistic heuristics and,
more importantly, bootstrap the oracles through iterative self-reinforcement.
Extensive experiments show that our model not only outperforms standard
language models on a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks but also demonstrates
improved generation quality in open-ended text generation. For instance,
compared to the standard language model counterpart, our model raises the
accuracy from 23.47% to 36.27% on OpenbookQA, and improves the MAUVE score from
42.61% to 81.58% in open-ended text generation. Remarkably, our model also
achieves the best performance and the lowest latency among several
retrieval-augmented baselines. In conclusion, we assert that retrieval is more
accurate generation and hope that our work will encourage further research on
this new paradigm shift.
|
[
-0.0701359212,
-0.6982882619,
0.5385596156,
0.0804395229,
-0.3861638904,
-0.0525240898,
-0.3209596276,
-0.2395180613,
0.1228705272,
0.6337075233,
-0.3692347407,
-0.4118755162,
-0.3036593199,
0.1504587829,
-0.6707206964,
0.9229769707,
0.1266224086,
-0.1128979847,
-0.1876559258,
-0.1796979159,
-0.4779102206,
-0.3570280671,
-0.4098062217,
-0.3011576831,
0.2475280762,
0.1836887747,
0.3541035056,
0.9872028828,
0.1921681166,
0.1782002747,
-0.1606133729,
0.0846267343,
-0.4083902836,
0.5160544515,
-0.2421078235,
-0.2641032636,
0.1076757088,
-0.0775706172,
0.7072680593,
0.6250534654,
-0.4379575849,
0.108653985,
0.0267378967,
0.7662619948,
-0.9211732745,
-0.0998018607,
-1.1847896576,
-0.1695582718,
-0.3693323135,
-0.3019937575,
-0.8213449717,
-0.1512545198,
0.2302328795,
-0.8650448322,
0.3707378507,
0.0523661338,
0.9065229893,
0.3393296599,
-0.3135888577,
-0.5253733397,
-0.4930372536,
0.9259502292,
-0.4719754457,
0.4080695808,
0.3185424209,
0.3958094418,
0.0036400331,
-1.0708328485,
-0.4714825749,
-0.3387610912,
-0.0957616121,
-0.0146646826,
0.0783076957,
-0.1910022497,
0.0102631999,
0.3310921788,
-0.2715320587,
-0.1444280297,
-0.4586536884,
-0.1412402838,
0.5392041206,
0.0195126776,
0.1656309962,
-0.6365993619,
-0.5823084712,
-0.1826903224,
-0.8319301605,
-0.221996665,
0.0803876743,
0.7452260852,
0.4680272341,
0.4989590943,
-0.3570916653,
0.91688025,
0.0608185567,
-0.0128842182,
0.2676035166,
-0.502317071,
-0.2423248291,
0.1164383963,
0.6258810759,
0.0450609587,
0.0249097198,
-0.1450763196,
-0.3881866336,
-0.2114724219,
0.6695384383,
-0.6533528566,
-0.0271237418,
0.0708307847,
-0.3368793726,
-0.3895095885,
-0.1549142152,
-0.6073219776,
-0.1921472698,
-0.3177453578,
0.4408442378,
-0.8852745295,
0.0330991298,
0.0398539454,
-0.0876214504,
0.2966108322,
0.2347016335,
-1.0409705639,
0.1093030199,
0.5130183101,
0.6844133735,
-0.1741640121,
-0.1447343081,
-0.7572672963,
0.1647351831,
-0.5683478713,
0.6471584439,
-0.5884401798,
-0.4384998679,
0.282502681,
-0.3834248781,
-0.1485618353,
-0.6697534919,
0.4966392517,
-0.5730037093,
0.4807183146,
-0.4089403152,
-0.641838491,
0.2334889919,
0.3091759682,
-0.6110066772,
1.5713785887,
0.1409303844,
-0.6891907454,
0.6323561668,
-0.4807040691,
-0.3655681014,
0.1458855718,
-0.3790565431,
-0.1320773661,
0.0764692053,
0.2064049691,
0.3079072833,
-0.4086381495,
0.2859997153,
0.3163022101,
-0.2811226547,
-0.1909564883,
-0.0388132036,
0.6968637109,
0.5257726312,
-0.4050880969,
-0.0594551973,
-0.9455639124,
0.3049733341,
0.0485952646,
-0.6451653838,
-0.8139872551,
0.0363358371,
0.01378207,
0.145118624,
0.178840369,
-0.6167033315,
0.2620967925,
-0.5981712937,
0.2279404253,
0.66428864,
0.0779524669,
0.6987737417,
0.0663235709,
0.1767317653,
-0.2031922042,
-0.1347022504,
-0.7021398544,
-0.1919202358,
-0.7346673012,
-0.2817589939,
0.3845023215,
0.2706442177,
-0.997091651,
0.5296633244,
-0.2343496084,
-0.3804656863,
-0.6169556379,
0.0398757868,
0.6594795585,
0.768273592,
0.6631509662,
-0.2731038332,
-0.4074961841,
-0.8512123823,
-0.3990986049,
-0.2511365116,
-0.0419762433,
0.2421794832,
0.4784183502,
0.1325761378,
1.1498572826,
-0.4479497671,
-0.0124380244,
-0.1100450754,
0.4015865326,
-0.1132595241,
0.5311172605,
0.4552129805,
-0.7051825523,
-0.6276147366,
-0.1475764513,
-0.7343284488,
-0.0309185963,
-0.2005438507,
-0.2362603694,
0.374222815,
0.7084575295,
-0.4290358424,
0.2751745582,
-0.040547315,
-0.3007274866,
0.4680188894,
-0.2036477923,
-0.1239781305,
-1.3102718592,
0.3905735612,
-0.2237336487,
-0.0801410601,
-0.5246350765,
0.4734131098,
0.2785274386,
0.1291935444,
-0.3773033619,
0.857822597,
-0.646684885,
-0.0052158907,
-0.2239920348,
0.2594973147,
-0.0094649065,
0.1061823368,
0.0807715729,
1.0032726526,
0.251273483,
-0.7490908504,
-0.1360180527,
0.4540543854,
-0.5820962191,
0.500711441,
-0.4432098866,
0.2036695927,
-0.2505915463,
0.0791492611,
-0.8132370114,
-0.0817288384,
-0.0977116227,
-0.2995514274,
0.3327279985,
0.2324341089,
-0.4844230115,
-0.1983208656,
-0.0191905182,
0.156405583,
0.6224066615,
-0.812451303,
0.5069789886,
0.1397899836,
0.0614076592,
-1.000774622,
-0.2947897613,
0.1285888404,
0.0042177252,
-0.4025581777,
0.4020992815,
0.0558090508,
-0.1949484646,
-0.1765740812,
-0.1995912045,
0.0096279047,
0.0867791176,
-0.3089607954,
0.0724610165,
-0.1653036475,
0.4717688262,
0.0991069376,
-0.0231892616,
-0.2073577791,
-0.5530315638,
0.6312696338,
0.0268539134,
-0.032053154,
0.0696785524,
0.2147388011,
0.1427402645,
-0.5661952496,
0.7723597288,
0.5190765262,
-0.2554215193,
-0.4117584229,
-0.5733163953,
-0.3490578532,
-0.4680508673,
0.3434405625,
-0.3619424701,
-0.7378606796,
0.1900287271,
0.0931779668,
0.1532123834,
0.3537098169,
0.4505870044,
0.1715369821,
0.7261986136,
0.9075497985,
0.2002670467,
0.574478209,
-0.0454242304,
-0.0490548424,
-0.8110322952,
-0.2566776276,
-0.6831248403,
0.1191977337,
-0.3625799716,
-0.4418430328,
0.2923802137,
0.213698253,
-0.2398103923,
0.4135733545,
-0.7334837317,
0.4628702998,
0.7390161753,
-0.0628234595,
0.311509341,
0.1160838902,
-0.7180461884,
-0.0769457221,
-0.6409474015,
-0.7193181515,
1.1608380079,
-0.0509495474,
0.4266223311,
-0.0317521356,
0.9917067885,
0.0611659326,
0.4350767434,
-0.4599915743,
0.6199682355,
-0.073669672,
-0.947170198,
-0.4304570258,
-0.3415712416,
-1.2178801298,
0.2597210109,
-0.1933317333,
-0.8913795948,
0.0188778099,
0.0913070068,
-0.3169459105,
-0.0361378975,
-0.291834712,
0.8417162299,
-0.0777739137,
-0.5544893146,
-0.0898992047,
-0.889003098,
0.3189660907,
-0.2063104063,
-0.0359760299,
0.0393299982,
-0.1394455433,
0.6378290653,
-0.4404663444,
0.5210520625,
-0.1285916716,
-0.0641105324,
0.5862336159,
0.1618746966,
0.2936797738,
-0.2192316502,
-0.4236583114,
-0.4457370341,
-0.0700741559,
-0.4955669343,
-0.5338224769,
0.4507329464,
-0.430955112,
-0.5193647146,
-0.3960067332,
-0.4139137864,
-0.1150714159,
0.5617675781,
0.4720965922,
0.3342581987,
-0.5435227156,
0.4386643171,
0.7082787156,
-0.3447584808,
0.4661335349,
0.59438169,
-0.3172326982,
-0.3194640875,
0.7749249935,
0.130718857,
0.3301856518,
0.5749849081,
0.1286733299,
-0.392462939,
-0.422806561,
-0.6994583011,
0.1597009301,
-0.8074343801,
-0.1783932298,
-0.6253068447,
-0.0918162167,
-0.244133532,
-0.0600234941,
-0.5291611552,
-0.4517979026,
-0.1784949899,
-0.1568101496,
0.0934966654,
0.6765788198,
0.1257632673,
0.4542857409,
-0.7966441512,
-0.1167033389,
0.2440370321,
0.1236022338,
-0.0807998255,
-0.4343238771,
-0.2887020707,
-0.2975991666,
-0.305775702,
-1.0573270321,
0.5234532356,
0.2921771109,
0.6467615366,
0.0688873902,
0.1431868821,
0.4178895056,
-0.7422297001,
0.9804680347,
0.0666162148,
-0.8805677295,
0.7208377719,
-0.5500787497,
0.2185823619,
0.941002667,
0.3072715402,
-0.4144598842,
-0.1478746086,
-0.7706178427,
-1.1159516573,
0.6430994868,
0.2969617844,
0.2990218997,
-0.5373046398,
0.7169513702,
0.1452344209,
0.6069197655,
-0.5512152314,
-0.1692456603,
-0.2191911787,
-0.2691797018,
0.0447877534,
-0.163579613,
-0.0747770965,
0.0731204376,
0.7708194852,
-0.3597087264,
0.1933435947,
0.2443608791,
-0.0992828086,
-0.1546296328,
0.3303564489,
0.2098855674,
0.6184670329,
-0.2042532563,
-0.0504651032,
-0.0878833309,
-0.2722791433,
0.0692350566,
0.1477859765,
-0.6798589826,
0.2593429089,
0.1207583547,
0.7060422301,
0.2931424379,
-0.8150517941,
0.5508755445,
0.1214871332,
-0.0729896501,
-0.3179236054,
0.096769236,
-0.1203171313,
-0.0252817925,
0.613846004,
-0.1161635146,
0.1644604951,
-0.5876631141,
0.5807234049,
0.6061047316,
-0.3255905807,
-0.0402333066,
0.8493788838,
0.1892484576,
-0.2535786033,
0.852060616,
-0.3018460274,
-0.2044897228,
0.3307284117,
0.7029600739,
0.7748841047,
-0.2841534615,
0.3723541498,
0.7200934887,
0.2426541001,
-0.4290415049,
0.1719678491,
-0.2064426392,
-0.7263922095,
-0.2951620519,
-0.9659194946,
-0.1736754775,
0.0094602853,
-0.8869065642,
0.200545758,
-0.3736182153,
-0.0581148565,
-0.140312776,
-0.0758352354,
-0.450214684,
0.366769731,
0.0182063617,
1.3197791576,
-0.5395935774,
0.9206883311,
0.6817814112,
-0.7120386362,
-0.8415160775,
0.1671968251,
-0.1443764567,
-0.7772249579,
0.6570032835,
0.1931868792,
0.1504985839,
0.1965609789,
-0.5829045773,
-1.0712307692,
1.2152719498,
0.216656372,
-0.3735781908,
-0.2948788702,
-0.2627682388,
0.6640943885,
-0.5359668136,
0.2250587642,
0.6648604274,
0.2548907101,
0.2424929142,
-0.8848685026,
0.1428774297,
-0.2520591617,
0.163525492,
0.2860663831,
-0.620921731,
0.9806958437,
0.0545015931,
-0.371247232,
0.5389972925,
0.7785215974,
0.4517107606,
0.1562504768,
0.4434266388,
0.4808845222,
0.9996479154,
0.0936020538,
1.2690087557,
-0.4713588059,
0.136110723,
1.1472221613,
-0.2876482606,
1.1515824795,
0.6826276779,
0.309574604,
0.7122544646,
0.4293043911,
0.3895740211,
0.7025321126,
0.0863040462,
-0.3079126477,
-0.3158076406,
-0.0900357217,
-0.3331966102,
0.4680355191,
0.2568662465,
-0.6380634308,
-0.3063443601,
-0.098442927,
0.0120999217,
0.6009131074,
-0.0090872655,
0.7741298676,
-0.0774392486,
-1.1790300608,
0.8572760224,
0.1375704706,
0.4560095668,
-0.5908609629,
0.0589757003,
-0.1671468467,
0.0841216445,
0.1376497895,
-0.3699029684,
0.2022195458,
-0.0756218135,
-0.0114627257,
-0.3403880894,
0.7208942771,
-0.5154520273,
-0.3071498573,
0.1903398782,
0.9156977534,
0.0868657306,
-0.0388898253,
-0.6325782537,
-0.1269270033,
0.1193986461,
-0.4445029497,
0.401858598,
0.3747117817,
-0.1128466874,
0.4161337018,
0.5309950113,
-0.1216399744,
0.2932332158,
-0.1040463224,
0.8850589991,
-0.6780617833,
-0.6011503339,
-0.5981978178,
0.5862370133,
-0.3129695952,
-0.5150925517,
0.6880984902,
0.5606781244,
0.8628490567,
0.0119004659,
0.8861598372,
-0.1909597069,
0.6929058433,
-0.6942939758,
0.5180082917,
-0.7552687526,
0.3861694336,
-0.2061738372,
-1.0370476246,
-0.0821202174,
0.8069750071,
-0.3193095326,
0.0015949449,
0.8316471577,
0.6709367633,
0.02312099,
-0.0123535143,
0.0718666688,
0.101420559,
0.2846678495,
0.1025006622,
0.6342527866,
-0.5800275803,
0.6139611602,
-0.1514889151,
-0.0663561001,
-0.1355162263,
-0.9397298098,
-0.7295389175,
-0.8051887155,
0.0396265313,
-0.4869437218,
0.3280250728,
1.0367313623,
0.7204310298,
-0.5032445788,
-0.2264953703,
-0.2923315763,
-0.1242468134,
-0.1539293677,
-0.21144858,
0.2438692898,
-1.0180978775,
-0.6864743233,
0.7499755025,
0.0510314852,
-0.3001436293,
-0.1549547911,
-0.1210548729,
-0.5275194645,
0.2882660925,
0.5106787086,
0.4002156556,
-0.638936162,
-0.4190762937,
0.2098349929,
-0.4496851563,
0.1296105981,
0.7923851609,
-1.1124670506,
0.677372992,
0.4419935644,
0.8506727815,
0.6591500044,
0.1986950934,
0.7415199876,
-1.3170830011,
0.1116395146,
0.3154698014,
0.2673641443,
0.5417789221,
-0.2331677526,
0.7362987995,
0.2258456498,
-0.4524163306,
-0.9579143524,
0.3520169556,
-0.5705604553,
-0.4309557378,
1.0638694763,
0.1293866336,
-0.4959356189,
0.0980157182,
-0.1851327717,
0.218010664,
-0.409878552,
0.9137552381,
0.4210723042,
0.0077396892,
0.0747723952,
-0.395293504,
0.6477926373,
0.7334061861,
-0.5396800041,
0.1331374645,
0.6075854301,
0.2431023568,
0.5441632867,
1.0907967091,
-0.0761881471,
0.19262968,
0.1098051891,
0.2262635678,
0.0876366496,
-0.4363580346,
-0.1275281012,
0.2986198664,
0.1336320788,
-0.0367339961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17531v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17531v2
|
Nissist: An Incident Mitigation Copilot based on Troubleshooting Guides
| 2024-02-27T14:14:23 | 2024-05-10T11:57:46 |
Kaikai An, Fangkai Yang, Junting Lu, Liqun Li, Zhixing Ren, Hao Huang, Lu Wang, Pu Zhao, Yu Kang, Hua Ding, Qingwei Lin, Saravan Rajmohan, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Effective incident management is pivotal for the smooth operation of
enterprises-level cloud services. In order to expedite incident mitigation,
service teams compile troubleshooting knowledge into Troubleshooting Guides
(TSGs) accessible to on-call engineers (OCEs). While automated pipelines are
enabled to resolve the most frequent and easy incidents, there still exist
complex incidents that require OCEs' intervention. However, TSGs are often
unstructured and incomplete, which requires manual interpretation by OCEs,
leading to on-call fatigue and decreased productivity, especially among
new-hire OCEs. In this work, we propose Nissist which leverages TSGs and
incident mitigation histories to provide proactive suggestions, reducing human
intervention. Leveraging Large Language Models (LLM), Nissist extracts insights
from unstructured TSGs and historical incident mitigation discussions, forming
a comprehensive knowledge base. Its multi-agent system design enhances
proficiency in precisely discerning user queries, retrieving relevant
information, and delivering systematic plans consecutively. Through our user
case and experiment, we demonstrate that Nissist significant reduce Time to
Mitigate (TTM) in incident mitigation, alleviating operational burdens on OCEs
and improving service reliability. Our demo is available at
https://aka.ms/nissist_demo.
|
[
-0.5288980007,
-0.679812789,
0.4721075594,
0.2016048878,
-0.4698073566,
0.3288873732,
0.2208541334,
-0.2661368847,
0.3667136133,
0.5101118684,
-1.2145680189,
-0.1203520373,
-0.0034225592,
-0.1823150963,
-0.3031881452,
1.2609001398,
0.0148113146,
-0.1596058309,
0.1022032574,
0.2398283631,
-0.4024366736,
-0.3843612075,
-1.2644758224,
0.175941512,
0.4241365194,
0.7144505978,
0.4631876349,
-0.0424297005,
0.4439179301,
0.1652627885,
-0.2104531378,
0.2306617498,
-0.1205105484,
0.2561589479,
0.0827149078,
-0.1739266962,
-0.5175151229,
-0.7647604942,
0.573190093,
0.4560754001,
-0.4759876728,
-0.2233452499,
0.2659652829,
0.417522788,
-0.7115827799,
-0.077731438,
-0.4593566656,
0.0616442077,
0.0463905409,
-0.3649129272,
-0.0985967293,
-0.1812705398,
0.321069777,
-0.7545188665,
0.3594887853,
-0.1065095514,
0.6851556301,
0.4239447713,
-0.3226850629,
0.0141332792,
-0.7554482818,
0.8299771547,
-0.6087355018,
-0.1149234325,
0.4018042386,
0.7053061128,
-0.2259139717,
-0.3694983423,
-0.1301238388,
0.0592345484,
-0.1534947455,
0.2516318858,
-0.0492022969,
0.0534957945,
0.2453057021,
-0.044583533,
-0.5128083229,
0.0151663562,
-0.1185448468,
-0.5459674597,
0.6110640764,
0.6744940877,
0.2605513632,
-0.0864290223,
-0.5968596339,
0.217637226,
-0.6164439321,
-0.0919554979,
0.373550117,
-0.0499107093,
0.0441557057,
-0.0675821602,
-0.2834962308,
0.6978616714,
0.0205306839,
-0.0986901,
-0.2337216288,
-0.3861785233,
-0.1221851856,
0.3610792756,
0.5387239456,
0.3886325657,
-0.2799048722,
-0.6262655854,
-0.0958537832,
-0.275380373,
0.7725393176,
-0.8892208934,
-0.1329110116,
0.1976292282,
0.071851179,
-0.3348121345,
0.0679135323,
-0.7954039574,
-0.5597404242,
-0.0870761052,
0.2500423193,
-0.6537767649,
-0.499489814,
0.1126311943,
-0.2857413888,
-0.0028678312,
0.5828592181,
-0.012964298,
0.1402442604,
0.6901118755,
0.9893069863,
0.511721909,
-0.1415752023,
-0.9085409641,
0.6419432759,
-0.3297784328,
0.9780564308,
0.0185360294,
-0.3449750841,
0.0082928156,
0.047751978,
0.0503357165,
-0.2441501468,
0.8610348105,
-0.2010207176,
0.0881948695,
-0.1128693894,
-0.4076853395,
-0.1688974649,
0.3143127859,
-0.5591989756,
0.6483721733,
-0.0257172696,
-0.866192162,
0.2813141644,
-1.0741388798,
-0.1673542112,
0.5839229226,
-0.2275419682,
-0.6528761983,
0.0906584486,
0.0875088274,
0.271060884,
-0.395193696,
0.3290750682,
-0.1784221679,
-0.1811289638,
-0.32888484,
0.1562514603,
0.9983554482,
0.0903832391,
-0.4530646801,
-0.0631697774,
-0.4275049269,
0.2743674219,
0.0102203535,
0.0375013016,
-0.4905472994,
0.0486225411,
-0.0089043351,
0.0771036595,
-0.1791759431,
-0.6077085733,
0.050308682,
-0.0812494233,
0.580886662,
0.5870143175,
0.6108501554,
0.3421546221,
-0.5757470727,
0.6727564335,
-0.0920571983,
0.5499815941,
0.0713505968,
-0.1443742216,
-0.7894502878,
-0.2767404914,
-0.3389450908,
0.5608762503,
-1.2252477407,
0.2707507312,
-0.1999651045,
-0.5946753621,
-0.175089702,
-0.0973284394,
0.5356743336,
0.5837414265,
0.2030211538,
-0.100743793,
-0.6906205416,
-1.0904426575,
-0.3059978783,
-0.1520245075,
-0.2282363772,
0.0828452185,
0.0969818681,
-0.17911762,
1.1095266342,
-0.506972909,
-0.4975384772,
-0.2721059918,
0.5946685076,
-0.1784442216,
0.1160981953,
0.9215513468,
-0.6941967607,
-0.3463669717,
-0.2760534585,
-0.4077214301,
-0.2824238539,
-0.1469169855,
-0.1496310532,
0.5010749698,
0.472383827,
-0.1604503393,
0.4827800691,
0.070144631,
-0.6163188219,
0.6853533387,
-0.1765303016,
0.1053352579,
-0.9578259587,
0.1529378444,
-0.2043347657,
-0.0650715753,
-0.9081096053,
-0.1183934286,
0.2764066458,
-0.1956318617,
-0.6523218155,
0.3300659657,
-0.3970199227,
0.0046150805,
-0.0240944959,
0.1282799542,
0.0636064708,
0.5304847956,
0.1483825892,
0.7812568545,
0.2714343369,
-0.8535883427,
-0.0009904929,
0.3149192631,
-0.4589166045,
1.074555397,
-0.4102652967,
0.2937550247,
-0.2849042118,
-0.073081769,
-0.7337684035,
-0.1340286285,
0.0630112588,
-0.1672439128,
-0.1395847499,
-0.5826609135,
-0.704918623,
-0.0763984248,
-0.360111922,
0.0062590656,
-0.0521468595,
-0.3178886473,
0.7687971592,
0.2799521983,
-0.5767632723,
-0.0599697083,
-0.6250287294,
0.264156729,
-0.3815693259,
-0.8862657547,
0.4416186512,
-0.3915367126,
-0.2458054125,
-0.0397056788,
-0.3002379537,
-0.7559669614,
0.5407515764,
0.3889712095,
0.3406258821,
-0.0396975018,
0.408835113,
-0.0843653604,
-0.3184733391,
0.0066327187,
-0.0193340443,
0.5835661888,
-0.2898065448,
-0.1714730859,
-0.2605178058,
0.7220923305,
0.5263948441,
0.0675596818,
0.802760303,
0.442792356,
-0.3748386204,
0.0623827539,
-0.6463989615,
-0.5387504101,
-0.4359198213,
0.2655930519,
-0.0142659312,
-0.6355163455,
0.3678536713,
-0.1294139922,
0.5922592282,
0.3695717156,
-0.1148064658,
-0.277235955,
0.7291383743,
0.6176770329,
-0.2281449437,
0.8110405207,
-0.4029292762,
0.5337891579,
-0.8114259839,
-0.2387585044,
-0.8291003704,
0.0168767497,
0.2045625597,
0.1085667163,
0.9639016986,
0.2102486789,
-0.3931844831,
0.3760857284,
-0.1104487032,
0.425136447,
0.127537936,
0.0324104987,
0.3961730897,
0.0357239284,
0.0583737344,
-0.0765088648,
-1.0388556719,
-0.4301038384,
0.2853549421,
-0.0603042915,
0.3598499,
0.5279254913,
0.7551460266,
0.3621024489,
0.0847979859,
-0.5179125667,
0.5424252748,
0.061323937,
-0.7182229161,
-0.2981701493,
-0.5089759231,
-0.7550242543,
-0.2005862296,
-0.0879407674,
-0.7212970853,
0.0375528634,
0.3597705066,
-0.7230594158,
0.3373829126,
-0.8326321244,
0.5825361609,
-0.3776047528,
-0.3278181255,
-0.2407075465,
-0.2612555027,
0.1877537966,
0.0239027794,
0.5191466212,
0.2150205523,
-0.1654342413,
0.8355225921,
-0.780346632,
0.8280186653,
-0.2887891233,
0.1304260492,
0.1658987403,
0.2075956464,
0.7198268771,
-0.0841153413,
-0.1601953357,
-0.0075417268,
-0.0733157173,
-0.4272529185,
-0.5738821626,
0.6210993528,
-0.4761507809,
-0.238813594,
-0.1237005293,
-0.4037918746,
-0.1029449925,
0.1094377339,
0.3159113824,
0.8148800731,
0.0162743907,
0.3470365703,
0.4915262163,
-0.0085520446,
0.7753727436,
1.019453764,
0.0400749892,
-0.5267108679,
0.6958141327,
0.5032559633,
0.42070508,
0.0171413049,
0.1192881837,
-0.0651614442,
-0.2475156188,
-0.4490143061,
0.0219776072,
-0.3984482288,
-0.4549664259,
-0.8054380417,
-0.2796256542,
-0.1773241162,
-0.3356850445,
-0.1562487483,
-0.6035257578,
0.024565693,
-0.2010172457,
0.6023766994,
0.3622075319,
0.200456202,
0.8098297119,
-0.8248452544,
0.127655834,
0.0830592588,
0.3457711339,
-0.1023740768,
-0.2858947814,
-0.4561161697,
-0.0859532356,
-0.4722606838,
-0.8612696528,
0.401363045,
0.3511635661,
0.7522517443,
0.3975098133,
0.5889600515,
0.830863595,
-0.0590022877,
0.6719533801,
0.2051452547,
-0.8787798882,
0.642934382,
-0.444763273,
0.1261702776,
0.5367366672,
0.2688871026,
-0.6463550329,
-0.5077636838,
-1.0103791952,
-1.0881745815,
0.9692066312,
0.2715872228,
-0.6347022653,
0.233352527,
0.1994611323,
-0.1954431534,
0.3533858359,
-0.0143605974,
-0.1572709531,
0.0326651521,
0.1594430208,
-0.1722750962,
-0.3919308186,
-0.2634658217,
0.2583583593,
0.9607830644,
-0.1150185317,
0.2426576167,
0.1766812354,
-0.2210833728,
-0.1108350754,
0.523722291,
0.6730508208,
0.3118987381,
-0.2615913153,
-0.1629793793,
0.2291687876,
-0.3848094046,
-0.2062115669,
-0.0474060476,
-0.4097551107,
0.1454687119,
0.28860569,
0.6369234324,
0.3188807964,
-0.6152425408,
0.2385524362,
-0.1526129991,
-0.3135800064,
-0.6352722049,
0.2644928396,
-0.0084430529,
0.0776931569,
0.5593506098,
-0.2950915694,
0.2575757205,
-0.4089943767,
-0.027098136,
0.4485921562,
-0.4399805963,
0.0755524561,
-0.0848305747,
0.3387751877,
-0.6546922922,
0.3061164916,
-0.1815823764,
-0.6413415074,
0.878461659,
0.1687393486,
1.0813632011,
-0.3881299198,
0.3152829409,
0.2794708312,
0.6556318402,
0.0051700096,
0.3102274537,
0.0240279455,
-0.2571155429,
-0.2601136267,
-0.0598996282,
-0.6138352752,
0.3439924419,
-0.7920877934,
0.3695157766,
-0.7828868032,
-0.1060620174,
-0.0906557664,
0.137746647,
-0.586432755,
-0.200431779,
-0.554731369,
1.0026909113,
-0.7903807759,
0.2260579169,
0.8829708099,
-0.3190916181,
-0.871976316,
0.1653105617,
0.1595915854,
-0.1249105036,
0.1088601947,
-0.0411418825,
-0.1002972424,
0.0122667905,
-0.3055431545,
-0.4211007953,
1.2713688612,
0.6716073751,
-0.6296344399,
0.2783359885,
-0.0965722501,
0.3858714402,
0.0250712968,
0.600235939,
0.3388622403,
0.4887522757,
-0.1099588796,
-0.9031499624,
-0.1957518607,
-0.2498859614,
-0.4276094437,
0.7740086317,
-0.5550869703,
0.5377846956,
0.0545394272,
-0.3371685147,
-0.1904350966,
-0.1707180887,
-0.0216735862,
0.5155425072,
0.8061462045,
0.4834482074,
0.6464048624,
0.0048148157,
1.1335991621,
0.0433394462,
0.0564089492,
1.2897424698,
0.1507673264,
0.4102979004,
0.7856749296,
0.1630006284,
0.6204915643,
0.3596121967,
0.58039397,
0.6984910965,
-0.3066629171,
-0.6293322444,
-0.6344270706,
-0.4566004872,
-0.2737610638,
-0.2386869639,
0.2759767473,
0.2421417236,
-0.8031889796,
0.1004594043,
0.393015027,
-0.3402730227,
-0.3915294111,
1.1342958212,
-0.1633018553,
-0.5138729215,
0.4724808037,
-0.1347065717,
0.2329159677,
-0.6856612563,
0.0578049161,
-0.3788179755,
0.2255812436,
-0.4211544693,
-0.6178016067,
0.7880901098,
0.2415596396,
-0.2415284067,
-0.1577124,
0.5910944343,
-0.1399069428,
-0.2644576132,
0.3684138358,
0.1034255624,
0.1394057721,
-0.5629884005,
-0.3324553967,
-0.1306485832,
0.0163194239,
0.2132812589,
0.3201891482,
0.485886395,
-0.4198589921,
0.913802743,
0.4232126176,
-0.0276307836,
0.052431941,
-0.059002988,
1.0178360939,
-0.3672496974,
-0.7866873145,
-0.5569328666,
0.8786254525,
-0.5905122757,
-0.0093583511,
0.3273844719,
0.509655714,
0.4233054817,
-0.0052841338,
0.9801462293,
-0.0198384896,
0.8274220228,
-0.431466341,
0.5792252421,
-0.6313995719,
0.4437581003,
-0.3851152956,
-0.3474664688,
-0.1313559711,
0.5811342597,
-0.3455688953,
-0.5522606969,
0.5951080918,
0.8647224307,
0.0058318251,
0.1355508119,
0.1454592794,
0.1146166399,
0.6477510333,
0.4953916371,
0.9208561778,
-0.3531178832,
0.8227031231,
-0.5079802275,
-0.3064605594,
-0.6366737485,
-1.3105921745,
-0.6434054971,
-0.4278668165,
-0.5706310272,
0.1306394041,
0.3563868701,
0.5938462615,
0.6307377219,
-0.4953665733,
0.0395363458,
-0.3991515636,
0.1717416197,
-0.2724493146,
-0.2510162294,
-0.0041217995,
-0.3063119948,
-0.011467088,
0.3523149192,
0.2501628399,
0.0229390226,
-0.1820604205,
-0.3306246996,
0.0272592884,
-0.1796134412,
0.2157775015,
0.0613101013,
-0.3037191331,
-0.336170435,
-0.1930399388,
0.0196764693,
-0.2729466558,
1.0611761808,
-0.5382524729,
-0.051110547,
0.2950466871,
0.5531084538,
0.3164102137,
-0.3749572039,
0.481372118,
-1.046636939,
0.2720479667,
0.4444355667,
0.4029807746,
0.1087625846,
-0.614251256,
0.7430124879,
0.0573029667,
-0.2689370811,
-0.960816741,
0.3101351857,
-0.7699581981,
-0.1164197102,
0.8388864398,
-0.3315927684,
0.0518671013,
-0.7505289316,
-0.634254992,
0.0960742235,
-0.5264024734,
0.9760237932,
0.533372283,
0.0322692804,
-0.4941953719,
-0.5696183443,
0.4660752714,
0.625382781,
-1.289167881,
-0.1680795848,
0.5216553211,
0.315838933,
0.4431832135,
0.4263668954,
0.2966064513,
0.5547884703,
-0.5080792904,
0.0449475981,
-0.2298743427,
-0.6840415001,
-0.2108356059,
0.0482552834,
-0.0530823432,
-0.2651171684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17527v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17527v2
|
Predict the Next Word: Humans exhibit uncertainty in this task and language models _____
| 2024-02-27T14:11:32 | 2024-03-18T16:21:24 |
Evgenia Ilia, Wilker Aziz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models (LMs) are statistical models trained to assign probability to
human-generated text. As such, it is reasonable to question whether they
approximate linguistic variability exhibited by humans well. This form of
statistical assessment is difficult to perform at the passage level, for it
requires acceptability judgements (i.e., human evaluation) or a robust
automated proxy (which is non-trivial). At the word level, however, given some
context, samples from an LM can be assessed via exact matching against a
prerecorded dataset of alternative single-word continuations of the available
context. We exploit this fact and evaluate the LM's ability to reproduce
variability that humans (in particular, a population of English speakers)
exhibit in the 'next word prediction' task. This can be seen as assessing a
form of calibration, which, in the context of text classification, Baan et al.
(2022) termed calibration to human uncertainty. We assess GPT2, BLOOM and
ChatGPT and find that they exhibit fairly low calibration to human uncertainty.
We also verify the failure of expected calibration error (ECE) to reflect this,
and as such, advise the community against relying on it in this setting.
|
[
-0.0876202732,
-0.5317454934,
0.6100167632,
-0.0294521637,
0.0159269199,
0.1051659361,
-0.171822533,
-0.5474838614,
-0.1906718016,
0.6076917052,
-0.7015889287,
-0.4363864958,
-0.5351073742,
0.1913525164,
-0.3229780793,
0.7196028233,
-0.0996075869,
0.1094361022,
-0.2499292344,
0.1285087317,
-0.7949400544,
-0.4706670344,
-0.6868982911,
-0.6025600433,
0.5784606934,
0.4846263528,
1.0132591724,
0.4441147745,
0.389379859,
0.2735236287,
-0.0036491733,
-0.2323525846,
-0.4722403884,
-0.0142889014,
-0.1710536033,
-0.7865590453,
-0.1786471456,
0.2805589437,
0.304281652,
0.8856589198,
-0.0315395296,
0.1333146393,
0.0263576787,
0.5128117204,
-0.4712823033,
0.0672293156,
-0.9102213979,
-0.0827438012,
-0.3243621588,
-0.1547833532,
-0.4360426068,
-0.358921051,
0.4152670503,
-0.3881773651,
0.2230582237,
0.1961393058,
0.7448179722,
0.3330002427,
-0.2003598809,
-0.2202451527,
-0.7212976217,
0.7218115926,
-0.7153387666,
0.4499016404,
1.056261301,
0.2107547522,
-0.354159981,
-0.6861243844,
-0.6988648176,
-0.3616238534,
0.1407944709,
0.1293390989,
0.1365164071,
0.0138728786,
-0.1401010305,
0.0578786097,
-0.765052855,
0.2170969397,
-0.4887356162,
-0.3936293423,
0.4791435301,
0.2098425329,
0.2363213152,
0.0790113062,
-0.2004909217,
-0.283827424,
-0.6608468294,
-0.0357155986,
0.4844971895,
0.404106468,
0.2354952395,
0.5674148798,
-0.0402285121,
0.6325692534,
-0.2692237198,
0.1148645282,
0.381736517,
-0.1953887641,
-0.1370956302,
-0.1220071614,
0.7094400525,
0.5443880558,
0.2465332448,
-0.0043730168,
-0.1711445153,
0.2339037508,
0.2849766314,
-0.4118749797,
-0.3892464638,
0.2709685266,
-0.0714465827,
-0.356285274,
-0.0178661961,
-0.8407455683,
-0.4192845225,
-0.0818518773,
0.7196843624,
-0.4195628762,
-0.0070417775,
0.128052175,
0.0108828386,
0.0980152041,
0.25330773,
-0.7656338215,
0.4007900655,
0.6423746943,
0.7155066133,
-0.0463420674,
-0.6161376238,
-0.1166561246,
-0.1967354864,
-0.6649743915,
0.8286908865,
-0.4685187042,
-0.6988893747,
-0.0198765118,
0.0502400473,
0.0652893111,
-0.2948208749,
0.869887948,
-0.5305401683,
0.6225310564,
-0.4296163619,
-0.8166143894,
-0.3943291605,
-0.0044666994,
-0.6001551747,
0.8215551972,
0.3668720424,
-0.9078102708,
0.5749459267,
-0.3715253174,
-0.1093437225,
0.3751726449,
-0.1614676416,
-0.3723013401,
0.0908209309,
-0.1152364016,
0.2689039707,
-0.1303897053,
-0.1463617235,
-0.4602360427,
-0.5001655817,
0.3426682949,
-0.6484858394,
0.3837161362,
0.065601103,
-0.2454434782,
-0.147064358,
-0.5561734438,
0.2157898247,
-0.0292582288,
-0.3237498701,
-0.3257617652,
0.5332187414,
0.1419758648,
0.101947993,
0.2236880809,
-0.4061086774,
-0.0854580104,
-0.6469497681,
0.1596665233,
0.8200951815,
-0.0683261529,
0.3137326241,
-0.656986475,
0.7347804904,
-0.3086393178,
-0.1456943899,
-0.1752449721,
-0.7835000157,
-0.3710312843,
0.285389334,
0.3786596954,
0.9165421724,
-0.4096326232,
0.3557914197,
-0.4831187427,
-0.6793980598,
-0.4207550883,
0.2727006972,
0.447866708,
0.3943648934,
0.1924680769,
-0.3566874564,
-0.7065005302,
-0.5886536241,
-0.5930368304,
-0.5384681821,
-0.1504333168,
0.2032228708,
0.3566497862,
-0.369862318,
1.0201673508,
-0.4026991725,
-0.2324438095,
-0.0822471008,
0.4863112867,
0.1479714215,
0.2080685794,
0.1005489975,
-0.7082959414,
-0.4102784395,
0.0239678994,
-0.2684887946,
-0.1673022062,
0.0947630927,
0.0998769999,
0.2357675433,
0.5506426692,
-0.2957250178,
0.5429651737,
0.6932704449,
-0.4528664649,
0.6917945743,
-0.4375795722,
0.0623729378,
-1.0315432549,
-0.2574244738,
-0.045672439,
-0.2783109844,
-0.5758892298,
-0.2387331873,
-0.0264705643,
0.1984556168,
-0.1344469339,
0.7258332372,
-0.3568505645,
-0.0185511224,
-0.4051250815,
0.0944982022,
-0.3052126467,
0.0394625925,
0.0746873319,
0.8576787114,
0.4037336111,
-0.4124486148,
0.2560426891,
0.0521162376,
-0.5119698644,
0.2101634592,
-0.5466345549,
0.1970190555,
-0.1682405919,
0.2361642718,
-1.2476944923,
-0.5210780501,
-0.1491800696,
-0.8260713816,
0.2039871514,
0.4251024425,
-0.3607735038,
-0.7350227833,
-0.2277631462,
0.3199949861,
0.6837261915,
-0.1356380433,
0.2075457722,
0.3258222342,
-0.3275901079,
-0.5356154442,
-1.0054528713,
0.1473118812,
-0.1788973063,
-0.3094127178,
0.094023332,
-0.2381059676,
-0.3932137489,
-0.0552945919,
0.1303065866,
-0.1337647587,
0.1066365987,
0.3616883159,
0.3279082179,
-0.0086108446,
0.2879162729,
-0.2716917098,
0.0171052944,
0.1281318218,
-0.1972121596,
0.5218192935,
0.0623026341,
-0.4726839364,
-0.4295234382,
0.1816638261,
0.4194319248,
0.1948357075,
0.5619416237,
0.5714164972,
-0.7047060132,
0.1030741483,
-0.6647871733,
-0.0990936831,
-0.4567683041,
0.9320750833,
-0.4801523685,
-0.5602706075,
0.3587174416,
0.2935000062,
-0.056058716,
0.5258216262,
0.68664819,
-0.1705287844,
1.08212924,
0.7425370216,
-0.2162770927,
0.2860076725,
0.2858960629,
-0.0026449685,
-0.429846704,
-0.060956236,
-0.5665348768,
0.0125932777,
-0.7583945394,
-0.5470416546,
0.0200065225,
0.1116974801,
-0.1774620265,
0.5503947139,
-0.1652450562,
0.598017633,
0.501868844,
0.2139279246,
0.0559035875,
-0.1115185916,
-0.0942005143,
-0.2557348311,
-0.4239057899,
-0.7543968558,
1.2830626965,
0.304469347,
0.7118416429,
-0.0074450723,
0.563290596,
0.3093505502,
0.5351808667,
-0.8050621748,
0.4347391725,
-0.1583955288,
-0.6842522025,
-0.5043947101,
-0.3547067642,
-0.9879171252,
0.0532769077,
-0.1436304301,
-1.3024201393,
-0.029589301,
0.0608758554,
-0.5504700541,
0.2135545164,
-0.8117702007,
0.6696814299,
-0.0501219071,
-0.1765770465,
-0.1141497567,
-0.6716716886,
0.2018840313,
-0.6446977854,
0.5980157852,
-0.2001258433,
-0.4450919032,
0.6293275356,
-0.2213761657,
0.7545205355,
0.2531104982,
-0.1071379483,
0.3209645748,
0.2795902789,
0.3371022642,
-0.2324111015,
-0.3385162055,
-0.1674917042,
0.2249720097,
-0.3055609167,
-0.3428007364,
0.3819806576,
-0.7282015681,
-0.5452795625,
-0.4495129287,
-0.4863206446,
-0.5809133053,
0.0540800355,
0.7279827595,
0.1899641603,
-0.4585088491,
-0.1414747834,
0.2318337858,
-0.1673615873,
0.3939893246,
0.3002554774,
-0.4555307329,
-0.3453528881,
0.8423281908,
0.073454082,
0.4485960007,
0.3940058351,
0.4158907533,
-0.6079736948,
-0.4471632242,
0.015246246,
0.0840137601,
-0.6602683067,
-0.0303589441,
-0.2949746847,
-0.0943907648,
-0.4618646204,
-0.0457509644,
-0.1461800784,
0.0133973788,
-0.5374191403,
-0.0970533788,
0.1893731952,
1.0544582605,
0.0202303994,
0.5640305877,
-0.826040864,
-0.15748173,
0.4359821081,
0.2340185195,
-0.4469165802,
-0.9749311805,
0.0347229131,
0.2252637893,
-0.2694174647,
-1.1945608854,
0.5285144448,
0.4480779469,
0.3947610855,
0.2686397731,
-0.2242156565,
0.5964838862,
-0.6995236278,
0.9396338463,
0.2017029375,
-0.9567785859,
0.4723781347,
-0.2147989273,
0.4322243333,
0.7966905832,
0.5553690791,
-0.7017741203,
-0.4428414106,
-0.6684752703,
-0.7870396376,
0.5706974864,
0.0792875811,
0.4111118615,
-0.0355885774,
0.4402222335,
0.1151873991,
0.0990053713,
-0.6670184135,
-0.0043866821,
0.1930957437,
-0.2503094077,
-0.645255208,
-0.4347887337,
0.3119098544,
-0.1401579827,
0.725667417,
-0.0837416798,
0.1963827908,
0.1431085616,
0.0498705022,
-0.3323825896,
0.1854853779,
0.6103183627,
0.7500967383,
-0.3379204571,
0.041140914,
0.4642192423,
-0.7350764871,
0.0240390208,
0.0306270346,
-0.1007650197,
0.2912229598,
0.4962123334,
0.7298737168,
0.1673936248,
-0.8147695065,
0.7626472712,
-0.14955163,
-0.2306212783,
-0.5580474734,
-0.1572597027,
0.1017948389,
0.0403092988,
0.3392524719,
0.2304371595,
0.1093916968,
-0.7176660299,
0.4337927103,
0.2878478765,
-0.7334339023,
-0.4954208434,
0.6794780493,
-0.1865245253,
-0.7171039581,
0.2864427269,
-0.4649560452,
-0.8785718679,
0.4600748718,
0.4185648263,
0.846935451,
-0.6475202441,
0.0302935336,
0.489862144,
0.4260480404,
-0.5169347525,
0.4765023291,
0.5322501063,
-0.9514403939,
-0.5388243794,
-0.7220970392,
-0.4881238043,
0.1981009692,
-0.5643756986,
0.4959714711,
-0.1575455517,
-0.4087858498,
-0.2042865306,
0.0320636518,
-0.7538508773,
0.4331579804,
0.4056299329,
0.9195226431,
-1.0115275383,
0.8190749884,
0.6887256503,
-0.1615012586,
-0.9310213923,
0.3020994067,
0.2099004537,
-0.784036994,
0.460704416,
0.2817958593,
0.0717320219,
-0.1627897918,
-0.3644673824,
-0.7720677257,
0.9771398306,
0.1782234013,
-0.646279335,
-0.1011159495,
0.1417507529,
0.7014135122,
-0.1215744466,
0.5090796947,
0.7354040146,
0.5010593534,
0.1385742724,
-1.1144446135,
-0.1585752666,
0.0423334986,
0.285402745,
-0.1057626605,
-0.1333871633,
0.8975481391,
-0.5339398384,
-0.204839617,
0.4883301556,
0.7588111758,
-0.0394543596,
0.1072875261,
0.7487816811,
0.3878445625,
1.0090427399,
-0.1598308533,
1.1571167707,
-0.1924173981,
0.4924527407,
1.5141147375,
-0.161826089,
1.3407585621,
0.3753503561,
-0.7220982313,
0.4733140767,
1.0411701202,
0.1802940369,
0.5145956278,
0.4258825779,
-0.391513139,
-0.1421722323,
0.1603783816,
-0.2410658896,
0.7396841049,
0.5081638694,
-0.3522616923,
-0.0154450601,
-0.1300476789,
-0.1274706721,
0.2428014576,
-0.3478295207,
0.6575400233,
-0.0039444841,
-0.7968746424,
0.279338479,
-0.132097587,
0.6748298407,
-0.4439862072,
0.1705039442,
0.0105597153,
0.2669621408,
-0.1006846949,
-0.8786281347,
0.3004387319,
-0.295710057,
0.1012786925,
0.2173818052,
0.5757827163,
-0.5434982181,
-0.6773436666,
0.3044716418,
0.5962664485,
0.4353544116,
-0.1132198721,
-0.6390743852,
-0.2333224714,
0.0554593466,
-0.3915210664,
0.1553016603,
0.2995938957,
0.0657088682,
0.8740339279,
0.3981814981,
0.3614380062,
0.2416398227,
-0.0267047174,
0.2450210452,
-0.5236389041,
-0.3472180367,
-0.9566521049,
0.1401814371,
0.1650330126,
-0.4643138945,
0.5127878189,
0.3801428378,
0.8246791363,
0.1215361208,
0.8709185123,
0.198046878,
0.7451469898,
-0.1985301673,
0.5272907019,
-0.5468254089,
0.2137307823,
-0.4212546349,
-0.7834202647,
-0.2783805132,
0.6257119775,
-0.3551129997,
0.1192566529,
0.8690976501,
0.8674303293,
0.2876676917,
0.2871654332,
0.6279790401,
0.2502491772,
-0.120409362,
0.6219347119,
0.5970057249,
-0.4273743033,
0.5328916907,
-0.154874742,
-0.3303551674,
0.0576544739,
-0.9296197891,
-0.5878522396,
-0.818046093,
-0.1675005108,
-0.5886403322,
-0.0277328845,
1.0172377825,
0.5045969486,
-0.9075360298,
-0.2905674577,
-0.4502117038,
-0.1316648424,
0.0040872567,
-0.2200238109,
0.1837795675,
-0.3583452702,
-0.9161766171,
0.1025344729,
-0.0194235332,
0.2567782104,
-0.3097412884,
-0.1112734005,
-0.0081055993,
0.240279302,
0.3449715674,
0.2350816578,
-0.8842677474,
-0.5492809415,
-0.1265379041,
-0.3334518969,
-0.1071944833,
0.3050863743,
-0.7063646913,
0.541377902,
0.4487000704,
0.7362686992,
0.1395996809,
-0.1406371891,
0.8796435595,
-0.4483691752,
-0.0566350855,
0.3464838862,
0.5396649241,
0.3987183869,
-0.2052523196,
0.4260552526,
0.2942909002,
-0.705091238,
-0.6341171265,
0.2755747736,
-0.7014740705,
-0.2054267824,
1.2466266155,
-0.2731616795,
-0.290668875,
-0.2340665907,
-0.2141656876,
0.1859523505,
-0.1749346405,
0.6769504547,
1.159435153,
0.1697780937,
-0.0690524951,
-0.804551959,
0.5296295285,
0.5525206327,
-0.6268568635,
0.0017913082,
0.2336972356,
0.4325237274,
0.2037723362,
0.6408483386,
0.0663871169,
0.1650839597,
0.1346899271,
-0.0245139766,
0.4908664823,
0.1517021954,
-0.4332285821,
-0.068480961,
0.2700662017,
-0.1445353478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17512v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17512v2
|
Latent Attention for Linear Time Transformers
| 2024-02-27T13:54:48 | 2024-03-04T12:21:52 |
Rares Dolga, Marius Cobzarenco, David Barber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
The time complexity of the standard attention mechanism in a transformer
scales quadratically with the length of the sequence. We introduce a method to
reduce this to linear scaling with time, based on defining attention via latent
vectors. The method is readily usable as a drop-in replacement for the standard
attention mechanism. Our "Latte Transformer" model can be implemented for both
bidirectional and unidirectional tasks, with the causal version allowing a
recurrent implementation which is memory and time-efficient during inference of
language generation tasks. Whilst next token prediction scales linearly with
the sequence length for a standard transformer, a Latte Transformer requires
constant time to compute the next token. The empirical performance of our
method is comparable to standard attention, yet allows scaling to context
windows much larger than practical in standard attention.
|
[
-0.1611800939,
-0.5958686471,
0.4445874095,
0.4554867148,
-0.041765891,
0.0609857365,
-0.1233780012,
-0.1866679043,
0.2605204284,
0.2595407665,
-0.7330633402,
0.2972212434,
-0.5027256608,
-0.1140971631,
-0.4528312981,
1.2303010225,
-0.2007954121,
-0.2863470316,
-0.0272989105,
0.0143494839,
-0.240486443,
-0.3588319421,
-0.9232949018,
-0.580997467,
1.1462718248,
0.1007600576,
0.8400421739,
0.4573577046,
0.7022534609,
0.2508345246,
-0.3290087581,
-0.2298481166,
-0.9087522626,
-0.1734150797,
-0.3177303076,
-0.7083480954,
-0.4725265205,
0.2011984289,
0.5796346664,
1.0235404968,
0.2044392228,
0.5484791398,
0.107333988,
0.5725672245,
-0.5736865997,
0.1681206971,
-0.4994812012,
0.4318133891,
-0.0454596952,
-0.4546420574,
-0.489452213,
-0.212375626,
0.2203186601,
-0.4222805202,
0.6271246076,
0.0024475681,
0.5708913803,
0.6576153636,
-0.3261606991,
0.2640161216,
-1.2528014183,
1.086805582,
-0.2355273217,
0.4072640538,
0.0785727799,
0.3559085727,
0.0432561859,
-1.1451265812,
-0.5551882982,
-0.1870145053,
-0.2500572503,
-0.0389791355,
-0.3517670631,
-0.0333267413,
0.5278570056,
0.398409903,
-0.3694316745,
-0.239323616,
-0.4333149493,
-0.087542288,
0.2327677906,
0.3665257692,
0.0552063957,
0.0691636056,
-0.3150509,
0.1995783597,
-0.702016294,
0.2534918785,
0.1643306762,
0.1461527348,
-0.0527376086,
0.4921787977,
0.0214521382,
0.4738328159,
0.5755861998,
0.0447277427,
0.1271980405,
-0.3188419938,
-0.0758941919,
-0.072293438,
0.4798848331,
0.4542127848,
0.1133044362,
-0.5011561513,
-0.1063265204,
0.2311653495,
0.5876947641,
-0.8530681133,
-0.1597311646,
0.1178219691,
-0.4960371852,
-0.3794375956,
-0.4693953395,
-0.6848380566,
0.1646807939,
-0.3580558896,
0.4819451571,
0.1163908541,
0.1191166192,
-0.1151467636,
0.172608003,
0.3233129084,
0.3435360789,
-0.9853501916,
0.3663514555,
0.5416400433,
0.9832077622,
-0.292278409,
0.1162933856,
-0.8211633563,
0.0497569889,
-0.3241147101,
0.6370638013,
-0.4803200364,
-0.2520729601,
-0.1102107018,
0.2032445669,
-0.2072231025,
-0.1692853272,
0.5896080136,
-0.6962128282,
0.4572389722,
-0.0832222998,
-0.2505541146,
-0.0453162044,
-0.1746724993,
-0.7426693439,
1.1533659697,
0.4645316899,
-0.8450408578,
0.0428661779,
-0.72546345,
-0.6378898025,
0.1024120003,
-0.0052150213,
-0.5235339403,
0.2234835029,
0.3187561035,
0.4346826375,
-0.3055047989,
0.0305570345,
-0.0435095914,
-0.479167968,
0.2099226117,
-0.5409598351,
0.6002341509,
0.2285853177,
-0.675127089,
0.1337876618,
-0.7493017316,
-0.135635674,
0.3673768044,
-0.1876598299,
0.0265523531,
0.1498246491,
0.3356227875,
0.250448525,
0.5065510273,
-0.536631763,
0.0376338065,
-0.7928063273,
0.7758694291,
0.7794251442,
0.0032908903,
0.7974049449,
-0.0538305566,
0.5525212884,
-0.0261371657,
0.417237103,
-0.193554312,
-0.2167487741,
-1.3342146873,
0.2390410006,
0.185961917,
0.3895514607,
-0.5701246262,
0.4048767984,
-0.4584470987,
-0.304187417,
-0.2932843864,
-0.0691561699,
0.3862553835,
0.5449927449,
0.2995935082,
-0.1474778503,
-0.2111247033,
-0.9461569786,
0.0169660971,
-0.0209980085,
-0.3905197382,
0.2575760484,
0.3000807166,
-0.0750727579,
0.9731960893,
-0.6847702861,
-0.0511222333,
-0.095606938,
0.2985219061,
0.3641555309,
0.1921439767,
0.5905756354,
-0.7616648078,
-0.4399558902,
0.0691993162,
-0.4139737785,
-0.0098411432,
-0.0628239959,
0.1926444173,
0.2083328962,
0.7780929208,
-0.4660966098,
0.6565256715,
0.4425910413,
-0.3598089218,
0.0433509052,
0.0069917995,
-0.066115953,
-1.0692877769,
0.224860847,
-0.1708759218,
-0.349999994,
-0.8521378636,
-0.2938074768,
0.20993644,
-0.3146726191,
-0.6389508247,
0.5225277543,
-0.2382068038,
-0.0678177997,
-0.1691131145,
0.0515729077,
-0.004275843,
0.9304568172,
-0.0716029331,
0.8053059578,
-0.1302614957,
-0.5352843404,
0.3103919029,
-0.1325524151,
0.0399710499,
0.5169349909,
-1.1975569725,
0.449701041,
-0.2136816233,
0.0201344453,
-1.2326308489,
0.0929001272,
0.1753308773,
-0.4624290764,
0.341614306,
0.0359076969,
-0.2858086228,
-0.6971052885,
-0.1354028881,
0.5733836293,
0.4105466008,
-0.5632722378,
0.5999262929,
-0.0830539465,
-0.3313270509,
-0.5773709416,
-0.5402821302,
-0.1199222356,
-0.230046317,
-0.4919938743,
0.5169460773,
-0.0705341399,
0.001846822,
0.0572923683,
-0.1911061108,
0.2212614566,
-0.1636523008,
0.0930547789,
0.063128382,
-0.2150444239,
0.2423240989,
-0.0757701471,
-0.3821783662,
0.0858149529,
-0.2829430997,
0.5800589919,
0.0327229463,
-0.0909218565,
-0.4901781678,
0.4179713428,
0.8152467608,
-0.4106315076,
0.653372407,
0.8120563626,
-0.3646213412,
-0.0463774614,
-0.5063980222,
-0.3674720228,
-0.4744529426,
0.370713532,
-0.3048452139,
-0.943066895,
0.5753478408,
0.1298051029,
0.174846068,
0.5212188959,
0.7364550829,
0.0035462885,
0.9904750586,
0.8837282658,
-0.1852899492,
0.642593801,
-0.2418677956,
0.7534455657,
-0.8390468359,
-0.1078683436,
-0.5377297997,
-0.6082565188,
-0.3038736284,
-0.6965283751,
0.3294644058,
-0.1573380828,
-0.2012539059,
0.3463778496,
-0.6230692863,
0.396963954,
0.334408164,
0.0971275121,
0.0773403496,
-0.0365082249,
0.2859981656,
-0.4174465835,
-0.5139569044,
-0.3505449593,
1.1466424465,
0.5846554637,
0.8008483052,
0.0597458631,
0.3361104429,
0.3421508968,
0.2105973661,
-0.9087300301,
0.3552035391,
-0.0047543999,
-0.4064113796,
-0.532194376,
-0.4114610553,
-1.2093367577,
-0.0658241883,
0.0403321646,
-0.8235204816,
0.0383643173,
0.197364077,
-0.6471373439,
0.1689824015,
-0.6411335468,
0.7760587335,
-0.0817180574,
-0.6112388372,
-0.2589612007,
-0.7395180464,
-0.1167871505,
-0.1454091221,
-0.1739050597,
-0.0714661181,
-0.2246906012,
0.8734582663,
-0.3909328878,
0.9965028167,
-0.0539306961,
-0.0993489325,
0.074532643,
-0.0450703315,
0.7669070959,
0.0534155071,
0.5737192035,
-0.0390284844,
-0.5124678016,
-0.5411860943,
-0.9272724986,
0.589027822,
-0.9075470567,
-0.5230403543,
-0.2760958374,
-0.7161912918,
-0.0260823518,
0.0999768153,
0.3104791045,
0.3452310562,
-0.2745418549,
0.2235051394,
0.9630897641,
0.1214333773,
0.8067013025,
0.3141725957,
-0.0582879595,
-0.0980998352,
0.6463752389,
0.265098542,
0.1952961683,
0.8359361887,
0.1088763922,
-0.4175441861,
-0.1350071579,
0.0041572084,
0.1985297799,
-0.4201973081,
0.0845437646,
-0.9779240489,
-0.4211286902,
-0.3951527178,
-0.2344580144,
-0.6398648024,
-0.7048994303,
-0.4592896402,
0.1585514247,
0.2492729723,
0.6853325367,
0.2973756492,
0.5640591383,
-0.437484473,
0.3935968876,
0.7689217329,
0.3174909949,
0.075661391,
-0.9631978869,
-0.2900000215,
-0.382268697,
-0.4345340729,
-0.5589741468,
0.2643096745,
0.0283010565,
0.50548774,
0.5811398029,
-0.1858907789,
0.2337507308,
-0.9196122289,
0.7771527171,
0.5037577748,
-0.9455157518,
0.575748086,
-0.383723557,
0.4518035948,
-0.0721589625,
0.4612582028,
-0.5749571919,
-0.1588780284,
-0.7133929729,
-0.8641607165,
0.6377990842,
0.6095255017,
0.2867443562,
0.1322564632,
0.4822653234,
-0.2582948208,
0.085156098,
-0.7574827671,
-0.3903973103,
-0.0481771752,
-0.047479596,
-0.7521497607,
-0.5091324449,
-0.0870405287,
-0.1933576912,
0.2572460175,
-0.001520235,
0.6274971962,
0.1742503345,
0.0311496761,
-0.3527486026,
0.2529225647,
0.7612812519,
0.6079282165,
-0.2592748404,
0.1739321053,
0.1491746008,
-0.4879160821,
0.3336854577,
0.0395287722,
-0.2476277053,
0.0987030193,
0.2635777593,
0.8449405432,
0.4919282794,
-0.1143946275,
0.4096333981,
-0.2373808771,
-0.1071170866,
-0.426487118,
-0.1371158063,
0.2206659317,
0.3448419571,
0.3557138443,
0.0727125779,
0.1968657225,
-0.0437879302,
0.2662499547,
-0.0535001494,
-0.8428003192,
-0.4171975255,
1.0434470177,
0.4533502758,
-0.6684325337,
0.3714018464,
0.0794467628,
-0.2324810177,
0.6186130643,
0.5522746444,
0.9802876115,
-0.6412444115,
0.0515809469,
0.3338904083,
0.4451526999,
0.1450797915,
-0.0390531197,
-0.0746655986,
-0.4220635891,
-0.5792717934,
-0.6766147017,
-0.1204056144,
0.40261814,
-0.6807276607,
0.1759831458,
-0.5844157338,
-0.5372175574,
0.4527130425,
-0.1804849058,
-0.7111865282,
0.0617106073,
-0.0471681915,
0.3710364103,
-0.840646863,
0.6059707403,
0.5266618133,
-0.3346585929,
-0.5127741098,
0.0579885505,
-0.1503962725,
-0.5862538218,
0.85748142,
0.1564050019,
-0.3178096414,
-0.0694320947,
-0.318364203,
-1.0877203941,
0.7803384662,
0.2670709193,
-0.8095377088,
-0.2118740678,
0.1950581372,
0.7057695389,
-0.3198521435,
0.0990664884,
0.625701189,
0.0656570792,
0.1403150856,
-0.901252985,
-0.1372487992,
-0.2823885977,
0.4746774435,
0.4119812846,
-0.8457196951,
1.1777393818,
-0.2988912165,
-0.135995537,
-0.2256329209,
0.9875797033,
-0.521417737,
0.1783773154,
0.548622489,
0.470433414,
0.4896455705,
-0.1191681698,
0.8087354898,
-0.3905014098,
0.5530047417,
1.1442240477,
-0.1486041993,
0.6934273243,
0.8558104634,
-0.5851020217,
0.3028922677,
0.5079559088,
0.2062581331,
0.4869475663,
0.2806991935,
-0.2858192623,
-0.0874229893,
-0.1687766463,
-0.2925256491,
0.3013518453,
0.3558687866,
-0.5089412332,
-0.161327228,
-0.0982710868,
0.1504969448,
0.1289612949,
-0.4541400075,
0.4540245235,
0.0357730575,
-0.7077962756,
0.6873621345,
-0.1956410557,
0.2822086215,
-0.2376780063,
-0.0808058456,
-0.246735841,
0.5440416336,
-0.0680723488,
-0.4988103211,
0.3860322833,
-0.2216105014,
-0.6208799481,
-0.1297609508,
0.4899032414,
-0.3221238256,
-0.7218402028,
0.4285370111,
0.145557493,
-0.0390511118,
0.0794091299,
-0.4635439515,
-0.1109065935,
0.0675331056,
-0.5167443156,
-0.0435750224,
0.2872152925,
-0.0476023145,
0.6175040603,
0.4278087616,
-0.2665945292,
0.2694284022,
0.366073519,
0.8456501961,
-0.5692510605,
-0.5938819647,
-0.5711537004,
0.2758460343,
-0.0394651107,
-0.0623259954,
0.4776796997,
0.5112137794,
0.614671886,
-0.1989359409,
0.6817457676,
0.0563221723,
0.6010126472,
-0.3658117056,
0.4782232046,
-0.6644538641,
0.0438437611,
-0.1172047704,
-1.2240341902,
-0.285749048,
0.5862661004,
-0.4503751397,
0.1155836657,
0.9768764973,
0.7049155235,
-0.1038294435,
-0.2050861865,
0.4249845147,
0.113617599,
0.238144353,
0.9390295148,
0.5618124008,
-0.4991414547,
0.716540575,
-0.286331147,
-0.394064784,
-0.3388624787,
-0.6630429029,
-1.3452810049,
-0.5733622909,
-0.2415712923,
-0.3366068006,
-0.0154965017,
0.5273101926,
0.6074009538,
-0.7790120244,
0.0281501412,
0.0528285578,
-0.0537056364,
-0.1666142642,
-0.2555035055,
0.602257967,
-0.7227311134,
-1.0543390512,
-0.1166905537,
0.5460619926,
0.0171270352,
-0.5796132684,
0.2296991795,
0.0407300182,
0.1160338446,
0.8467084765,
0.1776187122,
-0.7142722607,
-0.444408685,
0.2439596951,
-0.2016613781,
0.1548541188,
1.1122226715,
-0.4550707042,
0.3635641932,
0.4948878884,
0.4026275575,
0.834271729,
-0.3693575263,
0.6170405149,
-0.8737941384,
0.6996187568,
0.3510713279,
0.3060915768,
0.1145860404,
-0.6069502831,
0.512401104,
0.35164994,
-0.6653680205,
-0.3962368667,
0.3483056426,
-1.0655686855,
0.1015014872,
0.9441704154,
-0.1376178414,
-0.6325601935,
-0.3221978545,
-0.121237725,
0.3225643635,
-0.4221927226,
0.6613519192,
0.4102634788,
-0.0270290636,
-0.4138692617,
-0.4076581299,
0.4565165043,
0.5684207678,
-0.3990510106,
0.2055940628,
0.0874343216,
0.0755548403,
0.7050366402,
0.5975046754,
-0.2521648705,
0.298517108,
0.0238454789,
0.1150183678,
0.4965025485,
-0.5808800459,
-0.290125221,
0.185921967,
-0.1785899401,
-0.1765766591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17509v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17509v2
|
Extreme Miscalibration and the Illusion of Adversarial Robustness
| 2024-02-27T13:49:12 | 2024-05-31T00:09:56 |
Vyas Raina, Samson Tan, Volkan Cevher, Aditya Rawal, Sheng Zha, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep learning-based Natural Language Processing (NLP) models are vulnerable
to adversarial attacks, where small perturbations can cause a model to
misclassify. Adversarial Training (AT) is often used to increase model
robustness. However, we have discovered an intriguing phenomenon: deliberately
or accidentally miscalibrating models masks gradients in a way that interferes
with adversarial attack search methods, giving rise to an apparent increase in
robustness. We show that this observed gain in robustness is an illusion of
robustness (IOR), and demonstrate how an adversary can perform various forms of
test-time temperature calibration to nullify the aforementioned interference
and allow the adversarial attack to find adversarial examples. Hence, we urge
the NLP community to incorporate test-time temperature scaling into their
robustness evaluations to ensure that any observed gains are genuine. Finally,
we show how the temperature can be scaled during \textit{training} to improve
genuine robustness.
|
[
-0.3631174862,
-0.8767172694,
-0.0009485324,
-0.1935752034,
-0.0755407289,
0.07683523,
-0.0620171875,
-0.4203107655,
-0.1571482718,
0.3512667418,
-0.3671908677,
0.0117146866,
-0.7515745759,
-0.2543826997,
-0.4858466685,
1.099894166,
0.2857297361,
0.2936412692,
0.0732671469,
-0.2820313871,
-0.1490831375,
-0.7187542915,
-0.5961146951,
-0.5083915591,
0.1689176857,
-0.1721512973,
1.4252969027,
0.5939477086,
0.5796218514,
0.215676859,
-0.0507167205,
-0.0213955082,
-0.565226078,
0.2082063109,
0.0200477317,
-0.8968331814,
-0.3282974064,
0.081919305,
0.5601899028,
0.6507526636,
-0.0909336135,
-0.0772691369,
0.3075372875,
0.6750101447,
-0.933318615,
-0.3244519234,
-1.1170754433,
0.3195240498,
-0.0858563259,
-0.2398573905,
-0.2927381992,
-0.0824293643,
0.1111172289,
-0.394567579,
0.6198707819,
-0.1107491478,
0.917552352,
0.6553105116,
-0.1561634541,
-0.1291685551,
-0.9310227633,
0.876945734,
-0.819252491,
0.2035830915,
0.5189384818,
0.2568211257,
-0.2529362738,
-0.4450701773,
-0.5407883525,
-0.1626291573,
0.2035104185,
0.1176155806,
-0.6040915847,
0.0970990062,
0.5441764593,
0.3780583143,
-0.6750017405,
0.0778289363,
0.0338251628,
-0.2842124104,
0.3534768224,
0.1620498151,
0.4132383168,
0.192337811,
-0.3379364014,
-0.3802328706,
-0.4394878447,
-0.0373909101,
0.6840911508,
0.4210229218,
0.2015377581,
0.4306788146,
0.3369725645,
0.5986742973,
-0.09053123,
0.26608935,
-0.1143687889,
-0.1472455263,
-0.4267577529,
-0.0109950239,
0.6868963242,
0.3778315783,
0.1382964849,
-0.3602022529,
-0.2688666284,
0.4065650105,
0.5234177113,
-0.5972689986,
-0.4264535308,
-0.0078458432,
-0.0487297997,
-0.7862325311,
-0.1237085685,
-0.7294446826,
-0.5450416803,
0.0253889859,
0.4444569945,
-0.2164811641,
-0.1034141481,
0.1372537911,
-0.257684052,
0.0419913717,
0.092289649,
-0.8626810312,
0.2608227134,
0.5397140384,
0.5945999026,
0.3256424963,
-0.3887380064,
-0.3046914935,
-0.1255114824,
-0.5560244322,
0.4122903347,
-0.5693360567,
-0.3757432401,
-0.0538421348,
-0.2799176872,
-0.1701825857,
-0.5147792101,
0.5176430941,
-0.8119615316,
0.201866582,
-0.0921128988,
-0.1032798514,
-0.1581895351,
0.6314663291,
-0.6684237123,
1.1071174145,
-0.2435227036,
-0.9522551894,
0.4164613485,
-0.610429585,
-0.19336541,
-0.2853502631,
0.1000043303,
-0.5379721522,
0.1833280027,
0.3579186797,
0.2865539789,
-0.222657457,
-0.123325713,
-0.6584206223,
-0.209718883,
0.491294533,
-1.0972422361,
1.0346320868,
0.1957490593,
-0.4686480165,
-0.2156508863,
-0.8756101727,
0.2279939204,
0.2756494284,
-0.248548612,
-0.6232119799,
-0.0011770364,
-0.2519142032,
-0.0912566483,
0.1017784849,
-0.2008043379,
0.1377247721,
-0.888274014,
0.4177435935,
0.6877695918,
-0.0468148626,
0.6074322462,
-0.3840637207,
0.5758879185,
-0.0697419345,
0.1487211734,
0.1204917505,
-0.36937356,
-0.8315582275,
0.1408405602,
0.1769769341,
0.8718631268,
-0.6589552164,
0.1903998703,
-0.0311148912,
-0.6563485265,
-0.4590592086,
0.2444255501,
0.4020108283,
0.6988993883,
0.4045921862,
-0.0478665046,
-0.3458715677,
-0.7443103194,
-0.6956842542,
-0.166729793,
-0.28855142,
-0.0057610287,
0.4635540247,
-0.2197746485,
0.6474512815,
-0.3058964014,
-0.1242330596,
0.0862474293,
0.2623636425,
0.0091848141,
0.6212001443,
0.6366659403,
-0.9929602146,
-0.1908270121,
-0.195413202,
-0.6824237704,
0.2162630111,
-0.1953739971,
-0.0837885067,
0.0860379189,
0.5869070888,
-0.2130178511,
0.6201687455,
0.4447929561,
-0.1024180427,
0.4976264238,
-0.2755900323,
0.0435080267,
-0.9747192264,
0.0145035656,
0.0680140033,
-0.2927504778,
-0.8476749659,
0.4271002412,
0.0769703835,
-0.078310892,
-0.3549475968,
0.146028474,
-0.2480326593,
0.2507100403,
-0.2506107092,
-0.0440309495,
0.2051918954,
0.2150668502,
-0.4600905478,
0.6872144341,
0.7048761249,
-0.503470242,
0.4669279158,
-0.0624042824,
0.021852836,
0.5882177353,
-0.5323542953,
0.234940201,
-0.1223125309,
0.1520448625,
-0.7533661723,
-0.1513163149,
0.1745147407,
-0.6584969163,
0.5862784982,
-0.2105627358,
-0.4468002915,
-0.0954443961,
-0.47900334,
0.430287689,
0.2067562193,
-0.6108765602,
0.6641258001,
0.1438207179,
0.456990689,
-0.9652661681,
-1.1348682642,
0.2645092905,
-0.4452929199,
-0.4844333827,
0.2163962424,
-0.1620799899,
-0.4416190386,
-0.210982278,
-0.0292783752,
-0.1957985461,
0.4778120518,
0.1476861537,
0.2382086813,
-0.3099575341,
-0.2723511159,
-0.3991362453,
-0.0164875444,
0.4162304997,
-0.1613503098,
0.5022322536,
-0.4114308059,
-0.4662537873,
-0.4678018093,
0.2837442756,
0.6407732964,
0.086390689,
0.83933568,
0.7070545554,
-0.8548552394,
-0.1455213875,
-0.4799869657,
-0.312487036,
-0.5025883913,
0.4737764299,
-0.2619572282,
-0.2963919938,
0.7554392219,
0.2470957339,
0.1139385328,
0.6341460347,
0.1065954939,
-0.1140719727,
1.56127882,
0.6782638431,
-0.1731306762,
0.4086933136,
-0.4003197551,
0.1195819229,
-0.8944028616,
-0.0992558151,
-0.7178256512,
-0.3280961514,
-0.4943653643,
-0.1504343301,
0.2685410976,
0.1699020863,
-0.4114727974,
0.2317173332,
-0.4316070676,
0.7942130566,
0.7378540635,
0.3404254615,
-0.1263694912,
0.0320102498,
-0.1315751076,
-0.5488669872,
-0.8189618587,
-0.3912983835,
1.1500246525,
0.3727008402,
0.9964463115,
0.1884357929,
0.1806174368,
0.3290092051,
0.0958574787,
-0.7349765301,
0.2884333432,
-0.3033336401,
-0.7637181878,
-0.184490025,
-0.4045189321,
-0.8184962869,
0.1092311814,
-0.3014895022,
-0.7336478829,
0.2370957732,
0.3429636359,
-0.3905083835,
0.7077013254,
-0.7456053495,
0.8641476631,
-0.2218778133,
-0.2357197404,
0.0959738567,
-0.7278065085,
0.1592181176,
-0.0785860121,
0.206161499,
0.2657407224,
0.0625906065,
0.5919497013,
-0.249500677,
1.0154225826,
-0.2218445837,
0.0629627109,
-0.1558440626,
0.6291806698,
0.6249169707,
0.0686472282,
-0.1993501186,
0.0189967714,
-0.185630396,
-0.7122468352,
-0.7438623309,
0.6794612408,
-0.8180709481,
-0.7523952127,
-0.5760500431,
-0.6842845678,
-0.3882723749,
0.1605591625,
0.526755631,
0.4803683162,
-0.2399326116,
0.1679970622,
0.8120862842,
-0.0082897041,
0.41544047,
0.2100041658,
0.2153007388,
-0.2291809171,
0.915746212,
0.0653061047,
0.7440850735,
0.3350156248,
0.2352679372,
-0.0460421927,
-0.6863453984,
-0.422157079,
-0.2153359503,
-0.8730685711,
-0.2636599541,
-0.3428243697,
-0.3178943098,
-0.5663710237,
-0.4137859643,
-0.4962184429,
-0.3435565829,
-0.7411472201,
0.0409345478,
-0.0517684631,
0.4982422292,
-0.1983695179,
0.4019048512,
-0.5084186196,
0.1340826601,
0.3571208417,
-0.1325734854,
-0.1997908652,
-0.8645210862,
-0.1168463305,
0.412781924,
-0.4462415576,
-0.7098684311,
0.4247283936,
0.5097394586,
0.4298524559,
0.735213995,
0.3212863207,
0.7105550766,
-0.2267546058,
0.8739222288,
0.1859073937,
-0.7897658944,
0.5812312961,
-0.1864553392,
0.6335139871,
0.5265250802,
0.2949916422,
-0.1766481549,
-0.666436851,
-0.793730557,
-0.9507854581,
0.4849805236,
0.0424831137,
0.4860087037,
0.3786968291,
0.3402344286,
-0.0849151313,
-0.0781335831,
-0.8890438676,
-0.5918737054,
-0.5457993746,
0.1252682209,
-0.0370105654,
-0.3175159991,
-0.6191042066,
0.0808654279,
0.8276033998,
-0.2667235732,
0.139960885,
0.2476584613,
-0.0884372815,
-0.0906433612,
0.1548673064,
0.5733398199,
0.443806231,
-0.267539084,
0.4427078664,
0.452911973,
-0.5753610134,
-0.0747706592,
0.2776391804,
-0.1822018027,
-0.2238778919,
0.468967706,
0.7555897236,
-0.0399834812,
-0.2455651164,
0.487188518,
-0.4315576255,
-0.0586561151,
-0.2280154973,
0.2343459874,
-0.4008533359,
0.2458709925,
0.515250504,
1.059107542,
0.1513748765,
-0.4632919431,
0.0353442729,
0.9116746783,
-0.6984606981,
-0.3369191587,
1.0257270336,
-0.3804151416,
-0.2812617719,
0.4232397377,
-0.0170965716,
-1.0106977224,
0.5884513259,
0.6584919691,
0.7803500891,
-0.3786338568,
-0.0339969322,
0.1507004499,
0.9225512147,
0.0050669806,
-0.0457667597,
0.046320077,
-0.8181058764,
0.0846414417,
-0.3827504814,
-0.3537195921,
0.2698601782,
-0.9328522682,
0.0716063008,
-0.6443308592,
-0.261944741,
0.1455837339,
-0.2847259939,
-0.6303316355,
0.5093043447,
0.0639445037,
0.6719202995,
-0.8432407975,
0.5872750282,
0.5949106216,
0.0391974002,
-0.4145800471,
0.2978190184,
0.2861913145,
-0.9979321957,
0.2830633223,
0.0026924224,
-0.271147728,
-0.3611396551,
-0.5588442683,
-0.5744667053,
0.5948901176,
0.7997175455,
-0.1468549967,
-0.3046997786,
0.3226173818,
0.6667075753,
0.0691734701,
0.1153708696,
0.5225503445,
0.1852470338,
-0.1052657291,
-0.710732162,
-0.0102810459,
-0.3649724424,
-0.0890962258,
0.1628367454,
-0.3818652928,
0.6069129705,
-0.194504723,
-0.1926333457,
-0.1633455157,
0.5120356679,
-0.3927770853,
0.3589759171,
0.5816594958,
0.7994071841,
0.7714044452,
-0.1981300563,
1.0940275192,
-0.2538601458,
0.1309891045,
1.0708910227,
0.1156878993,
0.6678868532,
0.4425283372,
-0.0729222223,
-0.0943529904,
0.5294231176,
-0.1042329073,
0.5543509126,
0.0563231856,
-0.3579046726,
-0.2569154203,
-0.0521042049,
-0.5958890319,
0.2565882206,
0.5392481089,
-0.2926750779,
-0.1292055547,
0.2928835452,
0.3764139116,
0.2226924449,
-0.21880503,
0.5450778008,
-0.1147625819,
-0.3772160709,
0.8530086279,
-0.1401348561,
0.7724106312,
-0.5913794041,
0.3874972761,
0.0116964467,
0.495264858,
-0.2927486598,
-0.471452415,
0.4621309638,
-0.0868093148,
-0.2218195647,
-0.0588829219,
0.5459215045,
-0.0352511667,
-0.5305607319,
0.2853001952,
0.0393440574,
-0.0688288286,
-0.2028021216,
-0.9815194607,
-0.1712308675,
0.1212515831,
-0.4766668975,
0.4327958226,
0.2423600107,
0.4737110436,
0.7703683376,
0.709122777,
0.3355771005,
0.2159214318,
0.0027165413,
0.8919886947,
-0.2599335909,
-0.2082065493,
-1.094874382,
0.154300496,
0.0185604971,
-0.4434417188,
0.8197496533,
0.6129387021,
0.9955989122,
0.3561385274,
0.704767406,
0.2893748581,
0.2628765404,
-0.5585535169,
0.8831135035,
-0.6852847338,
0.5251626968,
-0.2195052952,
-0.7536202073,
-0.7945302129,
0.4148531556,
-0.2593219578,
0.0153589062,
0.5188457966,
1.0263236761,
-0.133013159,
0.1505226046,
0.42891559,
0.3850384951,
0.4941182733,
0.2857704461,
0.6169868708,
-0.7611500025,
0.8682706356,
-0.6553847194,
-0.2947382927,
0.0919648111,
-0.8351961374,
-0.998449266,
-0.5096710324,
-0.3867978454,
-0.7819055915,
0.1904619783,
0.6128091812,
0.6286477447,
-0.8177604079,
0.2086559385,
-0.1566423774,
-0.1222574338,
-0.179603979,
-0.2734153271,
0.2211382687,
-0.1920294911,
-0.755705297,
0.5754711032,
-0.0783136785,
0.3889498711,
-0.5081771612,
0.2847369909,
0.0187678915,
0.2685053349,
0.0149775911,
0.388971895,
-0.4543130398,
-0.0672097802,
-0.18992652,
-0.1655522585,
0.0745414197,
0.4634104073,
-0.575027585,
0.7740385532,
0.2361629903,
0.7527496815,
0.0666459799,
-0.2885772288,
0.629309535,
-0.7621694803,
0.1960974038,
0.5321105719,
0.3297734857,
0.4264197052,
-0.6198257208,
0.2725656629,
0.2134697288,
-0.6419023275,
-1.3514506817,
0.2486152351,
-0.5501826406,
-0.2602702975,
0.7989469171,
-0.2213015258,
-0.2903108299,
0.0267952494,
-0.0424910598,
0.1942252815,
-0.2579454482,
1.1003012657,
0.7458664775,
0.1092704982,
0.3750257194,
-0.8395109773,
0.5999580622,
0.6323856115,
-0.4342570007,
0.1106306389,
0.0672777295,
0.0177993122,
0.388251394,
-0.1433171332,
0.1359674931,
0.1891877204,
0.3196331561,
-0.5253870487,
-0.0435925461,
-0.1865146309,
-0.5430352092,
0.2721723616,
0.0332167409,
-0.1272508055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17505v1
|
BASES: Large-scale Web Search User Simulation with Large Language Model based Agents
| 2024-02-27T13:44:09 | 2024-02-27T13:44:09 |
Ruiyang Ren, Peng Qiu, Yingqi Qu, Jing Liu, Wayne Xin Zhao, Hua Wu, Ji-Rong Wen, Haifeng Wang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Due to the excellent capacities of large language models (LLMs), it becomes
feasible to develop LLM-based agents for reliable user simulation. Considering
the scarcity and limit (e.g., privacy issues) of real user data, in this paper,
we conduct large-scale user simulation for web search, to improve the analysis
and modeling of user search behavior. Specially, we propose BASES, a novel user
simulation framework with LLM-based agents, designed to facilitate
comprehensive simulations of web search user behaviors. Our simulation
framework can generate unique user profiles at scale, which subsequently leads
to diverse search behaviors. To demonstrate the effectiveness of BASES, we
conduct evaluation experiments based on two human benchmarks in both Chinese
and English, demonstrating that BASES can effectively simulate large-scale
human-like search behaviors. To further accommodate the research on web search,
we develop WARRIORS, a new large-scale dataset encompassing web search user
behaviors, including both Chinese and English versions, which can greatly
bolster research in the field of information retrieval. Our code and data will
be publicly released soon.
|
[
-0.4837206304,
-0.8016423583,
0.3321101665,
0.3345600665,
0.2249702662,
0.0931871235,
-0.2391252518,
-0.2244526148,
0.4697407186,
0.6337860823,
-0.4986790717,
-0.2434192151,
-0.1116095036,
0.0887715593,
-0.3604841828,
0.1329464912,
0.1532829106,
-0.0351304486,
-0.1252777278,
0.1583101004,
-0.1444312781,
-0.9338907599,
-0.4774295986,
-0.023460323,
0.4022644162,
0.4574294984,
0.9252468944,
0.5460202694,
0.4583293498,
0.3589426279,
-0.0018630348,
0.1464051306,
-0.887899816,
0.497033,
-0.5027391315,
-0.416321069,
-0.5000790954,
-0.0929867849,
0.7781587839,
0.614233315,
-0.3721696138,
-0.0442407429,
-0.328599453,
0.5847969055,
-0.6809934378,
0.0151767917,
-0.3148432374,
-0.0342901982,
-0.0978817567,
-0.3407601118,
-0.5577992797,
-0.2148841769,
0.1819412559,
-0.5398491621,
0.2154418081,
0.1082040742,
0.5595855713,
-0.1966165155,
-0.7801358104,
0.1606949121,
-0.4807058275,
0.7118493915,
-0.7665480375,
0.6328561306,
0.3672756553,
0.3970677853,
-0.7440468669,
-0.7244815826,
-0.5589026809,
-0.505871594,
0.2844189703,
-0.2902086079,
-0.0333373211,
-0.0481473915,
0.4311009943,
0.1884888709,
-0.7156108618,
0.1038694978,
-0.1604802758,
-0.0036782469,
0.8507124186,
0.3050175309,
0.5109307766,
0.1639915258,
-0.279471606,
-0.3802338243,
-0.794637084,
0.0668266565,
0.3618524969,
0.4598293006,
-0.0438339859,
0.6629522443,
-0.8567559719,
0.4555058181,
0.087780714,
-0.3335798681,
0.4787038267,
0.0936108828,
-0.0468617752,
-0.2984528542,
0.5358681679,
0.7563976049,
0.6141963005,
-0.4256442785,
-0.2500045896,
-0.1197282821,
0.1525902003,
-1.2411987782,
0.0396411605,
0.214028284,
-0.7973514199,
-0.1437514126,
0.0689639896,
-0.6985017061,
-0.737952888,
-0.2490088791,
0.2311052382,
-0.2079270333,
-0.6636561751,
0.1757501364,
-0.1501132995,
0.1468905061,
0.2326620221,
-0.8397281766,
0.7423655391,
0.3176693022,
0.4251094759,
-0.5090465546,
-0.6499488354,
-0.6818578243,
0.1081155837,
-0.1399109066,
0.3661387265,
-0.6108303666,
-0.6416730881,
0.200518474,
0.0175985415,
0.2169706374,
-0.6245422959,
-0.0715363547,
-1.0369881392,
-0.3084937334,
-0.4747918844,
-0.4268142283,
-0.1339873821,
0.4695547223,
-1.1243979931,
0.9305181503,
0.1226726472,
-0.3505135477,
-0.2044909149,
-0.6745441556,
-0.5130103827,
0.1319838166,
0.0007176754,
0.0733215511,
-0.027472483,
-0.0764057338,
0.5708850622,
-0.3840122521,
0.1381561458,
-0.4092600346,
-0.701330483,
0.3642754853,
-0.0892557502,
0.7833222151,
0.0696689412,
-0.3603812158,
-0.1564531177,
-0.5533640981,
0.1862885803,
0.3228720725,
-0.3967916071,
-0.129306972,
0.237899363,
0.3706636727,
0.2295009196,
0.5587974787,
-0.4489831924,
0.6183178425,
-0.3244806826,
0.0300763045,
0.5086200833,
0.0337188356,
0.4890370667,
0.033584334,
0.6810185313,
-0.3863051534,
0.0839221701,
0.0053815446,
-0.4319774806,
-0.201960817,
0.1131607518,
0.1919744611,
0.4694107771,
-0.4035043418,
0.2532578707,
-0.4099948406,
-0.4662329555,
0.2411542237,
0.2345425934,
0.2034686953,
-0.0111646317,
0.1934479773,
-0.4574757814,
-0.7251084447,
-0.7355479002,
-0.1668126136,
-0.3024073839,
-0.0233292431,
0.5294659734,
0.3889395297,
-0.7262732983,
1.0865273476,
-0.6007271409,
0.0584931001,
-0.3542809784,
-0.0934823081,
-0.155953005,
0.2336364537,
0.5653461814,
-1.3036812544,
-0.5355365872,
-0.1579219997,
-0.6980139017,
0.0688533485,
0.2582074404,
-0.2167135626,
0.0743820295,
0.5580470562,
-0.7229729295,
0.2816870511,
0.4941012859,
-0.2904331684,
0.6284886003,
0.0916609243,
0.1715424508,
-0.9829291105,
0.3060677946,
0.2036947757,
-0.2131682634,
-0.4789038002,
0.5993036032,
0.1776407063,
-0.133381173,
-0.3851228654,
0.9043954611,
-0.5297603011,
-0.1996654123,
-0.4631766379,
-0.2120285332,
-0.1984373033,
0.4148758948,
-0.0568219237,
1.1684259176,
0.3114818931,
-0.733563602,
0.5759457946,
0.0331546329,
0.0970828086,
0.090726763,
-0.3467946947,
0.0525940843,
0.0593638085,
0.5566578507,
-0.9016758204,
-0.6774308681,
-0.315762639,
-0.3871608973,
0.0891028419,
-0.1730421633,
-0.9676026702,
-0.5512549281,
-0.6188161373,
0.3219605386,
0.580137074,
-0.50222224,
0.6382365227,
0.6603270173,
-0.0143315755,
-0.7637215853,
-0.2226320654,
0.4155703187,
-0.0188928042,
-0.6826402545,
0.3137545884,
-0.486513555,
-0.4290285707,
-0.1850236654,
0.0661038533,
-0.3626959324,
0.5029426217,
0.1830208302,
0.1163006127,
-0.255412817,
-0.1844454408,
-0.3455953896,
0.2378677726,
0.0816116184,
-0.0414162092,
0.8525170088,
-0.2017601132,
-0.297647804,
-0.1563945562,
0.3874489069,
0.6995112896,
-0.1728956848,
0.57625705,
0.145719558,
-0.4662166536,
-0.2319790423,
-0.7009596825,
-0.1993196905,
-0.5334634781,
0.4097022414,
-0.374919802,
-0.9166307449,
0.5960708261,
-0.4025242329,
-0.063029401,
0.2903403044,
0.7356125116,
-0.0163136423,
1.2518687248,
0.8424186707,
-0.3054509461,
0.2359939516,
-0.1300548315,
-0.1219020337,
-0.5129874945,
-0.1031793132,
-0.2502996027,
-0.3631148338,
-0.5769524574,
-0.2861111164,
0.1490374953,
-0.0023038825,
-0.4157025218,
0.3133220971,
-0.2844457626,
0.6144635081,
0.5819521546,
0.0554775633,
0.0331141092,
0.3506963253,
-0.2526683211,
-0.0326495692,
-0.0213837605,
-0.1869946122,
1.0765295029,
-0.0755690858,
1.0387595892,
0.3486400247,
0.4061859548,
0.5558850765,
0.025523873,
-0.7263179421,
0.6601101756,
0.0081317192,
-0.9338154793,
-0.466078341,
-0.3936216235,
-1.0249558687,
0.3478303254,
0.19196482,
-0.8510459661,
0.0074594165,
0.0765153766,
0.0480920859,
0.3756700456,
-0.4956309199,
0.6232044101,
-0.4201982915,
-0.5207816362,
-0.1759120524,
-0.7633978724,
0.1977220774,
0.118173264,
0.040179193,
0.0974547192,
0.0104978457,
0.5249794126,
-0.3822055757,
0.8905159235,
-0.3500776291,
0.0921013355,
0.2233623415,
0.3534935117,
0.8316176534,
-0.1494602412,
-0.2304421663,
-0.184329018,
-0.4259583056,
-0.3676990271,
-0.3730620742,
0.7554696798,
-0.7806093693,
-0.6722922325,
-0.1931045204,
-0.3424392343,
-0.3807082772,
0.4961710274,
-0.0244224537,
0.0187895708,
-0.4756240249,
0.3876247108,
0.7436574101,
-0.0676654801,
0.0821876898,
0.9198867679,
-0.5344901681,
-0.0952380225,
0.8505720496,
0.0398684628,
-0.3254029751,
0.4742231071,
0.1522463858,
-0.2404332608,
-0.3955295086,
-0.5816360116,
0.3350748122,
-0.4858734906,
-0.1448045969,
-0.5073197484,
-0.3226647973,
-0.4435218871,
-0.1587759405,
-0.3644357324,
-0.0757803023,
0.0609960742,
-0.0104184598,
0.4179891348,
0.5570627451,
0.1563440263,
0.5744461417,
-0.4849616587,
0.5815857053,
0.2316313088,
0.5431962609,
0.2810961902,
-0.1348513961,
-0.5167785883,
-0.0474796705,
-0.2140491754,
-0.7875014544,
0.5337787271,
-0.3476341069,
0.6899961829,
0.425888449,
-0.0648826361,
0.5702190995,
-0.545854032,
0.8703124523,
-0.0000053599,
-0.6944511533,
0.1609228998,
-0.506002605,
-0.0216648541,
0.7089024782,
0.3290774226,
-0.6728019714,
0.2337878644,
-0.388551116,
-0.8001976609,
0.7545960546,
0.1764023453,
0.1396275014,
0.1589521319,
0.3419058025,
-0.0593432002,
0.1804008335,
-0.3715773523,
-0.5107807517,
0.1132339239,
0.1303630918,
0.1564163566,
-0.4459496737,
0.2445895523,
-0.0523772724,
0.6958663464,
-0.0985599756,
-0.0271152928,
-0.1424363703,
-0.2635368109,
-0.3268507421,
-0.0657186955,
0.2666008174,
0.6499428153,
-0.4704038203,
0.028634904,
0.2405040264,
-0.7334204912,
0.3464232683,
0.2080123872,
-0.0370583273,
-0.1593740582,
-0.2533285916,
0.1824926287,
0.1794553697,
-1.2175632715,
0.6822358966,
-0.340796262,
0.0027283099,
-0.6062723994,
0.1430578083,
0.5462899804,
0.1294135004,
0.5535140634,
-0.1396876276,
0.6403152347,
-0.462333262,
0.3131387234,
0.2753109634,
0.0849169046,
-0.2980682552,
0.5812948942,
0.342207253,
-0.4356795847,
0.6041690707,
-0.2244107872,
-0.5549049377,
0.8498126268,
0.6714182496,
0.6429840326,
-0.6470377445,
-0.207171455,
0.2174257636,
0.0618539937,
-0.7492652535,
0.4158754945,
0.0501619838,
-0.5600936413,
-0.3178510666,
-0.3563963771,
-0.8463805318,
0.4067332149,
-0.3486961126,
0.1664623767,
-0.3895796537,
-0.0981673896,
-0.1883706003,
0.4846795797,
-0.5791348219,
0.2741025984,
0.4209787846,
1.0510921478,
-0.361676693,
0.7590942383,
1.045214653,
-0.3510821462,
-0.6107734442,
0.1324718744,
0.1563497037,
-0.6486896276,
0.683136642,
0.3393302858,
-0.4596601129,
-0.0757649839,
-0.8201102018,
-1.1793825626,
0.9984803796,
0.4236128926,
-0.4549253285,
-0.3172905147,
0.0245477967,
0.4463234246,
-0.1761443168,
0.2815486193,
0.1899003685,
0.4330287278,
0.0309007652,
-0.9456437826,
0.1226695925,
-0.5500568748,
0.1364869773,
-0.1600150019,
-0.8989131451,
1.2254366875,
0.084294796,
-0.0700019151,
0.2579821348,
0.51669842,
0.6051781178,
0.2432836145,
0.5500721931,
0.3148960769,
0.7290980816,
0.7514362931,
1.0113825798,
-0.347348839,
0.3740445673,
0.6860531569,
-0.9746109247,
0.9821311235,
0.0589062944,
-0.1585437655,
0.4499680102,
0.2692002952,
-0.0427853838,
0.2001447678,
0.45863837,
-0.3605992794,
-0.345939666,
0.0759558007,
-0.3462476432,
0.4939915538,
0.4363455176,
-0.2523490191,
-0.2767183781,
-0.2306509763,
0.1607601941,
0.2144453228,
-0.1544462442,
0.4149001837,
-0.1844714433,
-0.5191689134,
0.5515455604,
0.5890492797,
0.8332543373,
-0.6105230451,
-0.047121428,
-0.2753806114,
0.1136495396,
-0.2022017092,
-0.6798073053,
-0.511364162,
0.1387215853,
-0.5243415833,
-0.0533976182,
0.9745112062,
0.0626216829,
-0.0869809091,
0.5587402582,
0.6914871335,
0.4199723303,
-0.5038998127,
-0.543664217,
0.1354880184,
0.0243826527,
-0.7262403369,
0.599186182,
0.3614545465,
-0.5047233105,
0.7149627209,
0.8457019329,
-0.0589763075,
0.1052397043,
-0.0081790173,
0.964188993,
-0.9812953472,
-0.6763221622,
-0.7116365433,
-0.0629849955,
-0.3228153288,
0.0409164466,
0.7977668047,
1.0182250738,
0.6288474798,
-0.2273310125,
1.0699671507,
0.0329519249,
0.5731498599,
-0.060993664,
0.9365720153,
-0.5716220737,
-0.153013438,
0.1067139134,
-0.877327621,
-0.1021713838,
0.410869211,
0.2347902656,
0.2725407183,
0.1901097745,
0.7646166682,
-0.4696393907,
-0.2188517153,
0.4153089225,
0.2366468459,
0.2771640718,
0.3300158978,
0.6468354464,
-0.2604728639,
0.4730536342,
-0.0684232861,
-0.0846047252,
-1.0187666416,
-0.3266619444,
-0.9494795799,
-0.327003926,
0.3746824861,
-0.4356457591,
0.0410629101,
1.097038269,
0.8717275858,
-0.5994953513,
-0.6998258829,
0.1841071546,
-0.16975981,
0.0700741932,
-0.1897819042,
0.1576597691,
-0.0861790255,
-0.7073429227,
0.5575687885,
-0.0864668339,
-0.0906951725,
-0.4213053584,
-0.4073410034,
-0.1922672689,
0.096505098,
0.6034501195,
0.7428152561,
-0.6284660697,
0.0696549788,
0.4036953449,
-0.6086425781,
0.0060321759,
0.7367534637,
-1.1845493317,
0.4945964515,
0.4769057631,
0.6868968606,
0.5021756291,
0.3432572186,
0.692745626,
-0.7597731948,
0.0015718343,
0.049430538,
0.3338871002,
0.2667708397,
-0.6066399813,
0.6353951693,
0.0783657953,
-0.246042043,
-0.7968613505,
0.0477732234,
-1.242733717,
-0.4767488241,
1.4554564953,
0.082409732,
-0.146162346,
0.0646801516,
-0.2309061736,
0.1609245837,
-0.7199602127,
0.6515878439,
0.6124581695,
-0.0240942463,
0.2296063006,
-0.6058059335,
0.1909193546,
0.0961892977,
-0.6179099083,
0.1622978002,
0.5213912725,
0.4315422475,
0.1646291763,
0.7038279176,
0.1485781074,
0.5878639817,
-0.0106378049,
0.3734545708,
-0.1134894937,
-0.1606663764,
0.070056431,
0.4061240852,
0.1537656039,
0.2418525517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17497v1
|
REAR: A Relevance-Aware Retrieval-Augmented Framework for Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-02-27T13:22:51 | 2024-02-27T13:22:51 |
Yuhao Wang, Ruiyang Ren, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jing Liu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Considering the limited internal parametric knowledge, retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) has been widely used to extend the knowledge scope of large
language models (LLMs). Despite the extensive efforts on RAG research, in
existing methods, LLMs cannot precisely assess the relevance of retrieved
documents, thus likely leading to misleading or even incorrect utilization of
external knowledge (i.e., retrieved documents). To address this issue, in this
paper, we propose REAR, a RElevance-Aware Retrieval-augmented approach for
open-domain question answering (QA). As the key motivation, we aim to enhance
the self-awareness of source relevance for LLMs, so as to adaptively utilize
external knowledge in RAG systems. Specially, we develop a new architecture for
LLM based RAG system, by incorporating a specially designed rank head that
precisely assesses the relevance of retrieved documents. Furthermore, we
propose an improved training method based on bi-granularity relevance fusion
and noise-resistant training. By combining the improvements in both
architecture and training, our proposed REAR can better utilize external
knowledge by effectively perceiving the relevance of retrieved documents.
Experiments on four open-domain QA tasks show that REAR significantly
outperforms previous a number of competitive RAG approaches. Our code and data
can be accessed at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/REAR.
|
[
-0.4543778896,
-0.4302635193,
0.4552028477,
0.0513835996,
0.0241289455,
0.1711253673,
-0.1878757328,
-0.3636138737,
0.2852307558,
0.4131616056,
-0.4057333469,
-0.3210166693,
-0.3365531862,
0.1243363097,
-0.23657839,
0.8432343006,
0.1558663398,
0.0051643727,
-0.4780267179,
-0.498524338,
-0.7322844863,
-0.4672051668,
-0.5820595026,
0.1286240071,
0.5232463479,
0.2554033995,
0.4191904962,
0.145314008,
0.489996314,
0.2136659473,
-0.023387434,
0.2153120935,
-0.7509945631,
0.4518830478,
-0.7395473719,
-0.3193417788,
-0.3756616414,
-0.1857380718,
0.7769008875,
0.342504859,
-0.0615491308,
0.4089000225,
-0.1896371394,
0.6520627141,
-1.0513615608,
-0.2189507633,
-0.8889412284,
-0.3654239476,
-0.1338913888,
-0.4986058176,
-0.3482068181,
-0.1626657546,
-0.162465319,
-0.7366256714,
0.0449138582,
0.3564538062,
0.8298247457,
0.3198560476,
-0.1003893837,
-0.1745137274,
-0.6322484612,
0.6100326777,
-0.5897129178,
0.9023413658,
0.3284902275,
0.5622790456,
-0.0797782317,
-0.7491761446,
-0.6813245416,
0.229949072,
-0.0166049358,
0.4473886192,
0.0914801285,
-0.3248178065,
-0.0942370743,
0.5795847178,
-0.6815111637,
-0.0627186894,
-0.1728682965,
0.0434469804,
0.3109364808,
-0.0707615241,
0.1988679469,
0.1426175535,
-0.3023783267,
-0.0068703429,
-0.8222460747,
-0.0192479193,
0.1047738642,
0.6117377877,
0.1913818568,
0.703522563,
-0.3901238143,
0.7170276642,
0.3396980762,
-0.1121782959,
0.1542207301,
-0.3401445746,
-0.1626214534,
-0.2502885461,
0.3826506734,
-0.062526688,
-0.1963353008,
-0.4209313393,
-0.3413749635,
-0.5901061296,
0.6586309075,
-0.6951230168,
0.2726299763,
0.2132672668,
-0.1864145845,
0.133253336,
0.0634392723,
-0.8572906852,
-0.2815103829,
-0.1648702919,
0.8433699608,
-0.391752094,
-0.206983909,
-0.1100743413,
0.0166042969,
0.4864040017,
0.3337215483,
-0.5738858581,
0.0970600918,
0.8278722763,
0.4112769663,
-0.0931527466,
-0.0868771374,
-0.8912126422,
0.2925610244,
-0.414091289,
0.9344967008,
-0.7352662683,
-0.3731950223,
0.1168751121,
-0.1500335187,
-0.0496217199,
-0.5974176526,
0.683010757,
-1.3963729143,
0.5342732668,
-0.2498091906,
-0.2623895109,
-0.1103854626,
0.5140873194,
-0.3069674671,
1.055791378,
0.4092400074,
-0.8741734028,
0.205546841,
-0.2091752142,
-0.2822901905,
0.1414346844,
-0.1210795864,
-0.3115444779,
0.0361316539,
0.2809911072,
0.1573963314,
-0.2877342999,
0.0290917736,
-0.0987278521,
-0.4774702191,
-0.0563833527,
-0.0212665144,
0.355474323,
0.2073110044,
0.2049555629,
0.0290906467,
-0.6028857827,
0.0750643089,
0.0981512219,
-0.4364593327,
-0.7988114357,
-0.4172286689,
-0.6130792499,
0.077786088,
0.4465851784,
-0.5377299786,
0.1583376229,
-0.7446836233,
-0.3432344198,
0.5827481747,
0.3464174271,
0.5991088748,
-0.3968908489,
0.5101534128,
-0.074477531,
-0.1603601277,
-0.0128856776,
-0.5072518587,
-0.4488849342,
-0.2349918336,
0.3205463588,
0.5503512025,
-0.8227816224,
0.1983554512,
-0.3379582763,
-0.1696905643,
-0.5648087859,
-0.0306883156,
0.6493648887,
0.7599155307,
0.6295502782,
-0.244546622,
-0.531547308,
-0.428669095,
-0.4429515004,
-0.070758827,
0.0634522438,
0.6024311781,
0.2671534717,
-0.1677612662,
1.0997252464,
-0.4891352654,
-0.4035946131,
0.0623522885,
-0.1491597146,
0.1115774736,
0.2401072085,
0.2878568172,
-1.0701783895,
-0.4467356801,
0.0330299847,
-0.6699074507,
-0.1714258492,
0.2357524633,
-0.5647230148,
0.1655676216,
0.3405725658,
-0.5533633232,
0.2572449744,
0.3046965599,
-0.1281749159,
0.6872091889,
-0.2238333374,
0.4442863464,
-1.328042984,
0.3923678994,
-0.2007526159,
-0.039095629,
-0.3528339565,
0.3837273121,
0.0570086837,
-0.2007904649,
-0.2797220349,
1.0564479828,
-0.4093674719,
-0.5298960805,
-0.3992329836,
0.5985703468,
0.1752929389,
0.5327188373,
-0.0645888522,
1.4186707735,
0.2195593864,
-0.7217662334,
-0.1063238755,
0.5671182871,
0.0326518565,
0.818313241,
-0.2081557214,
0.0789062455,
-0.2781697512,
-0.0218900144,
-0.982226789,
-0.199854821,
0.19629924,
-0.7308257818,
0.6442239285,
-0.2550190389,
-0.2457231879,
-0.3306766152,
-0.078972511,
0.5407873988,
0.4442991316,
-0.7080350518,
0.6928440332,
0.5161707997,
-0.3159937561,
-0.9755388498,
-0.2759663761,
-0.1901042014,
-0.0437063649,
-0.3788921237,
0.4509066343,
-0.0841999277,
-0.2963738739,
-0.0599298067,
-0.4767358005,
-0.2308928967,
-0.1138109565,
0.0339966156,
0.015627712,
-0.3225713372,
0.4432490766,
0.1225345358,
0.0031353354,
-0.2236399502,
-0.4485684931,
0.3385686874,
-0.0957497358,
-0.3323987722,
0.0409406461,
0.2439714223,
0.2339927703,
-0.783277452,
0.7259755731,
0.4936679602,
-0.3313828111,
-0.1408530027,
-0.6190271378,
-0.1795879304,
-0.4718701243,
0.1186819077,
-0.6214032769,
-1.013602972,
0.4795460403,
-0.1997955441,
0.0811691955,
0.4657212496,
0.6188527346,
-0.0973959938,
0.5198962092,
0.6130555868,
0.137592718,
0.3312434554,
-0.0452374518,
0.2729901671,
-1.3337882757,
-0.25132218,
-0.776325345,
0.1900276542,
-0.2947775126,
-0.6021370292,
0.5109223723,
0.4173462987,
-0.4688606262,
0.2416183949,
-0.5499818325,
0.2091139704,
0.5462734103,
0.0055007678,
0.5121743083,
-0.1933979839,
-0.0860661417,
0.2240195125,
-0.7107502222,
-0.1738314778,
0.8686953187,
-0.0585870259,
0.7234213948,
0.2283429354,
0.6731700897,
0.1602983773,
0.4289731085,
-0.4711521268,
0.5219641328,
-0.0858696178,
-0.5676555634,
-0.2823292613,
-0.4318799675,
-1.0731122494,
0.3739346862,
-0.1350156963,
-0.5564652085,
0.3314768672,
0.028068129,
-0.4499678314,
0.2040114403,
-0.3933341503,
0.7726098299,
-0.0517690107,
-0.5159543157,
-0.1041235849,
-0.6214210391,
0.3069747984,
-0.1650675237,
0.2638294101,
0.2079704404,
-0.2793501914,
0.619410634,
-0.1533865482,
0.4434524775,
-0.1366589069,
-0.4046545029,
0.5341647863,
0.1918000281,
0.4721961021,
0.3259491026,
-0.2882903218,
-0.1571329981,
-0.0219866745,
-0.144504562,
-0.7972887158,
0.8955313563,
-0.5891237855,
-0.9275354147,
-0.3066411912,
-0.653575778,
-0.7338914871,
0.4234780967,
-0.0579827018,
0.4823869169,
-0.0835858732,
0.0515568256,
0.8249408603,
-0.4154546559,
0.0377322584,
0.790351212,
-0.4797201753,
-0.4963593483,
1.097186327,
-0.0300366692,
0.0982874706,
0.9181120396,
0.219599098,
-0.4699735641,
-0.5449187756,
-0.4490199685,
0.2935522795,
-0.7170276046,
-0.5431461334,
-0.7043993473,
-0.1656819135,
-0.8322188854,
-0.0552020669,
-0.2213487923,
-0.3607687056,
-0.2099174559,
0.3557471931,
0.3832425177,
0.3966392577,
0.0533732995,
0.0945182666,
-0.8236387372,
0.568631053,
0.3656754792,
0.6974460483,
-0.1654521674,
-0.9729470611,
-0.3560147882,
0.1445729584,
-0.2688250244,
-0.5947717428,
0.4068600535,
0.1768193543,
0.7065860629,
-0.0404647328,
0.2718709409,
0.4600705504,
-0.4460334778,
0.5897562504,
-0.3251798451,
-0.47155267,
0.5263794661,
-0.4932086468,
0.2327659577,
0.7046198249,
0.5489825606,
-0.2666953802,
-0.4045403898,
-0.44140324,
-0.697055459,
0.4296580255,
-0.1142356247,
-0.1145270839,
-0.0421161577,
0.6720756292,
0.1703276038,
0.3897155225,
-0.2769425511,
0.0182002597,
-0.1933443397,
-0.2124115676,
0.2031208426,
-0.1726154387,
-0.1250277907,
0.0748740956,
1.0678058863,
-0.3457971811,
0.5010535717,
0.3665963709,
-0.0654330626,
-0.1947646737,
0.3267323077,
0.4398398399,
0.7845824361,
-0.2933109999,
-0.2182054818,
0.2000536174,
-0.4161203206,
-0.0119303754,
0.093697235,
-0.3149919212,
-0.234201014,
-0.0646370798,
0.3870608509,
0.2232322842,
-0.7603669167,
0.5704977512,
0.0707878023,
0.1819370389,
-0.2019803375,
-0.0695344806,
-0.0614998937,
0.4295963943,
0.5920816064,
0.0020525325,
0.1545325369,
-0.5301275253,
0.4101195037,
0.6410348415,
-0.2468805462,
-0.0916603282,
0.6827713251,
0.0550167039,
-0.4571577907,
0.2547994852,
-0.1507836133,
-0.4397023618,
0.2201169431,
0.6065486073,
0.6430116296,
-0.2897826433,
-0.0716228113,
0.3632293046,
-0.0383477584,
0.2076515704,
0.4122469127,
0.0847346559,
-0.6471366882,
-0.5817632675,
-0.9024171829,
-0.5243788362,
-0.1079817638,
-0.5964428186,
0.025375776,
-0.1788220704,
0.0097595239,
-0.4495461583,
0.0468948223,
-0.389447093,
0.4534360468,
-0.3878429234,
0.999525547,
0.0609841719,
0.6328795552,
0.8476610184,
-0.5909891725,
-0.5167050958,
0.4366829395,
-0.5600507855,
-0.8015229702,
0.7198289633,
-0.1237195358,
-0.3373014927,
0.2377712578,
-0.1995417178,
-1.0965572596,
1.0733631849,
0.203308776,
-0.0787072182,
-0.1075827926,
-0.2687711716,
0.6263837218,
-0.2636256218,
0.1836050749,
0.001546636,
0.2961220145,
0.3898290098,
-0.808781147,
-0.0265976992,
0.0402838774,
-0.0341411307,
0.3484369814,
-0.8533772826,
0.5193244219,
-0.3851796985,
-0.346160382,
0.3629850447,
1.0352621078,
0.2906166017,
0.5118676424,
0.1055503339,
0.7585562468,
0.6409702897,
0.0505917072,
0.9940927029,
-0.499193877,
0.1575705558,
1.3604339361,
-0.4412237704,
1.2441464663,
0.3628316522,
0.0095709991,
0.6172066927,
0.2748984993,
0.4362878501,
0.7022013664,
-0.038686689,
-0.3375767767,
-0.2337953746,
-0.0824218914,
-0.5139567852,
0.338365525,
0.3654688299,
-0.0831238702,
-0.325032413,
0.2612373829,
-0.4750974476,
0.4488984644,
-0.570088625,
0.9507858753,
0.0591384061,
-0.8672403693,
0.5940155983,
0.067278035,
0.5129957795,
-0.6225291491,
-0.1045596898,
-0.3262428939,
0.1334455907,
-0.0434305705,
-0.9308027029,
0.4926676154,
-0.2195584029,
-0.1879062504,
-0.056547191,
1.0529190302,
-0.4073926508,
-0.0298601873,
0.123750031,
0.7593628168,
0.032510303,
-0.3368282616,
-0.3630993068,
-0.1105476096,
-0.3370043039,
-0.1456022859,
0.6801608801,
0.5760561824,
-0.0932027698,
0.7958039641,
0.5129917264,
-0.2026855201,
0.0559043251,
-0.0597428903,
0.992241025,
-0.4409061074,
-0.4201355577,
-0.0414630994,
0.2336490303,
0.05135924,
-0.1484086961,
0.8517846465,
0.6906062365,
0.9393075109,
-0.0210160892,
0.5019418001,
-0.0869128481,
1.1610109806,
-0.3500254154,
0.5661581755,
-0.8877630234,
0.2691658735,
-0.0173059553,
-0.8033217788,
-0.1988260299,
0.3544371426,
-0.5478551984,
0.3523780406,
0.3800683022,
0.9156789184,
-0.0709220842,
0.0049056476,
0.4688367546,
0.2141264975,
-0.0490125045,
0.2864553332,
0.556353271,
-0.6050413847,
0.6504582763,
-0.0436735377,
-0.0659903884,
-0.2315859199,
-0.5315939784,
-0.5571223497,
-0.7411730886,
-0.0587238148,
-0.5410252213,
0.4624055624,
0.476434499,
0.4562823772,
-0.6994526982,
0.1590054333,
0.1293119937,
0.1783565581,
-0.2741116881,
-0.2698310018,
0.3985114396,
-0.6942548752,
-0.5511340499,
0.7224054933,
0.3236110508,
-0.2512719929,
-0.2263691872,
-0.0651034042,
-0.6387092471,
0.1982601732,
0.7293617129,
0.6733989716,
-0.3948406577,
-0.4145166278,
0.1145218983,
-0.2017435282,
0.2591564059,
0.7783825397,
-1.1846449375,
0.392383188,
0.7112708092,
1.18410182,
0.1861566156,
0.4906029701,
0.4722014666,
-0.9854658246,
-0.1951480061,
0.4450186193,
0.1554941982,
0.3121955395,
-0.6049209237,
0.6117686033,
0.3064681888,
-0.7055090666,
-0.7414681911,
0.156839937,
-0.9254142046,
-0.3340886831,
1.1822479963,
-0.1765144765,
-0.1918201447,
-0.1149538159,
-0.2628862262,
0.2782193422,
-0.2628658712,
0.6127074361,
0.0620463714,
0.0715642795,
-0.2183896452,
-0.3839940429,
0.2917231917,
0.3593278825,
-0.8730034232,
0.0989823043,
0.3889167905,
0.15140073,
0.355476439,
0.6169217825,
-0.323974669,
0.2989492416,
-0.1707574427,
-0.0812667161,
-0.1139031872,
-0.4741389155,
-0.1354560405,
0.4656769335,
0.0976489261,
-0.1113939881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17496v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17496v2
|
Emotional Voice Messages (EMOVOME) database: emotion recognition in spontaneous voice messages
| 2024-02-27T13:22:47 | 2024-06-13T13:09:48 |
Lucía Gómez Zaragozá, Rocío del Amor, Elena Parra Vargas, Valery Naranjo, Mariano Alcañiz Raya, Javier Marín-Morales
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS, I.5.1; I.5.4; I.2.7
|
Emotional Voice Messages (EMOVOME) is a spontaneous speech dataset containing
999 audio messages from real conversations on a messaging app from 100 Spanish
speakers, gender balanced. Voice messages were produced in-the-wild conditions
before participants were recruited, avoiding any conscious bias due to
laboratory environment. Audios were labeled in valence and arousal dimensions
by three non-experts and two experts, which were then combined to obtain a
final label per dimension. The experts also provided an extra label
corresponding to seven emotion categories. To set a baseline for future
investigations using EMOVOME, we implemented emotion recognition models using
both speech and audio transcriptions. For speech, we used the standard eGeMAPS
feature set and support vector machines, obtaining 49.27% and 44.71% unweighted
accuracy for valence and arousal respectively. For text, we fine-tuned a
multilingual BERT model and achieved 61.15% and 47.43% unweighted accuracy for
valence and arousal respectively. This database will significantly contribute
to research on emotion recognition in the wild, while also providing a unique
natural and freely accessible resource for Spanish.
|
[
-0.3622250557,
-0.7506250143,
0.4008832574,
0.7141970992,
-0.1883741915,
-0.0610985197,
-0.3735947013,
-0.4325856864,
0.5545141101,
0.3278381526,
-0.7824916244,
-0.8182965517,
-0.356608063,
0.2741892636,
-0.301494956,
0.6480004787,
0.2136326283,
0.3913017213,
0.1009495407,
-0.185212791,
-0.3439951539,
-0.5485032201,
-0.553763032,
0.0709294751,
0.4710643589,
0.6626810431,
0.007599161,
0.0638248101,
0.1204454303,
0.340737313,
-0.0609298982,
-0.0509349518,
-0.5171862245,
0.6102074385,
0.2188667357,
-0.5863729119,
-0.5972702503,
-0.1425047219,
0.4404830337,
0.0200198572,
-0.4644388855,
-0.0885572061,
-0.1278051734,
0.5566816926,
-0.5193167925,
0.0190729927,
-0.5120397806,
0.5825427175,
0.0437977463,
-0.3036082685,
-0.5035609007,
-0.6248204708,
0.2783554196,
-0.1548353583,
-0.0474089719,
0.1450967491,
0.506396234,
0.1782273352,
-0.6575684547,
-0.7075998783,
-0.8946470618,
0.6493625045,
-0.4179618955,
0.4364785254,
0.4299073815,
0.3403711021,
-0.1344676167,
-0.158017531,
-0.4752549529,
-0.1691716164,
0.3275207877,
0.4412079453,
-0.7292938828,
0.1522137672,
0.0892089605,
0.3908120096,
-0.4760400355,
0.3414461911,
-0.0740717649,
-0.1363050342,
0.4754710495,
0.4663330019,
0.4701437652,
-0.2170319855,
-0.2476941198,
-0.1671106964,
-0.5639535189,
-0.0237318408,
0.4733833075,
0.1845852584,
-0.2637880445,
0.6921421289,
0.0882503614,
0.4616554976,
-0.006892378,
-0.063800253,
0.243411988,
0.2270799279,
-0.5363650918,
0.5011496544,
0.9293829799,
0.2609736323,
-0.0354813412,
0.036801558,
-0.0945272967,
-0.1015734002,
0.1690518111,
-0.8289443254,
0.1384378076,
0.6401257515,
-0.3390200138,
-0.3172085583,
-0.2253993899,
-1.1705827713,
-0.5270310044,
-0.1680586934,
0.308434397,
-0.3764405847,
-0.2016201168,
-0.0840279981,
0.1032699198,
-0.0258774143,
0.5795717239,
-0.788274765,
0.2560390532,
0.4137201011,
0.9200211763,
0.3625816703,
0.1297499388,
-0.1216335446,
-0.2625854313,
-0.1554982811,
0.588943243,
-0.4664712548,
-0.5865984559,
0.0783258304,
0.3153218329,
-0.1714746803,
-0.4977085292,
0.8014592528,
0.0632032454,
0.2187985033,
-0.2586261928,
-0.7171558738,
-0.3582758605,
0.0809009001,
-0.587405324,
1.0663990974,
-0.2412661761,
-0.3572480083,
0.0817412883,
-0.3431315124,
-0.1788965911,
-0.1339128017,
-0.3105324805,
-0.3476470113,
0.3336171806,
-0.0303570125,
0.7266255617,
-0.4163172841,
-0.0524465293,
-0.1690045595,
0.0126480879,
0.5310443044,
-0.2794438899,
0.6102823615,
0.3821222782,
-0.5328553319,
-0.1195122004,
-0.9494845867,
0.0121237915,
-0.0256428197,
-0.246266529,
-0.3471855521,
-0.0650263429,
0.1225434914,
0.4901887178,
-0.0184053499,
-1.0356941223,
-0.0013264151,
-0.2200153619,
0.271240592,
0.5431937575,
-0.0523997024,
0.2720355392,
0.0475419983,
0.7625042796,
0.0921990052,
0.1162411422,
-0.3709418476,
-0.6563099027,
-0.646459043,
-0.3748761415,
-0.3600877225,
0.9818211198,
0.107724905,
0.607065618,
-0.0020439504,
-0.939740181,
-0.8061928153,
-0.1893145144,
0.4000399113,
0.5503575802,
0.082212463,
0.2072530538,
-0.7962434292,
-0.9057447314,
-0.0856788307,
-0.3555141687,
-0.1300643235,
1.1249126196,
0.2418242395,
-0.296949774,
0.6273354292,
-0.3127193153,
-0.3924883008,
0.0231036097,
0.5491817594,
0.0754367709,
0.3799870312,
0.6227298975,
-0.483078301,
-0.376788646,
0.1556056589,
-0.808965683,
-0.4963950217,
-0.0060456987,
-0.1156717464,
0.1031562984,
0.0814919025,
-0.4011098742,
0.3606796861,
0.6314395666,
-0.3791023195,
0.0676134005,
-0.0330493338,
0.7405328751,
-1.2272754908,
-0.2954240143,
0.1035110503,
-0.1219140366,
-0.7263048291,
-0.7547644377,
0.1076731607,
-0.2312853187,
-0.8010209203,
0.2336332947,
-0.4866221845,
-0.2041098475,
0.0026739007,
0.2517937124,
-0.1898321509,
0.3138851523,
-0.057173837,
0.3551465869,
0.6660186052,
-0.3517033756,
0.8648546338,
0.519915998,
-0.1783383936,
0.9968758225,
-0.5630020499,
0.4939386845,
-0.1928627938,
0.1488411427,
-1.0743535757,
-0.2640655935,
0.0553132892,
-0.5262668133,
0.2222410887,
-0.2454496026,
-0.1364278197,
-0.2127356976,
-0.1339484751,
0.0237450562,
0.527862668,
-0.5419999361,
0.8480311632,
0.6914752722,
-0.4298661351,
-0.2977232039,
-0.8331643939,
0.2367600501,
-0.315648824,
-0.7828093767,
0.02951915,
0.2254627645,
-0.1398710907,
-0.0848320201,
0.1610068977,
-0.1626613289,
-0.0317484178,
0.9261348248,
-0.0416429788,
-0.103143774,
0.363511622,
0.2274372131,
0.4061344564,
0.1499340534,
0.1098937094,
0.5645999908,
-0.4603037536,
0.0456829816,
-0.5170719028,
0.5435602665,
0.719401896,
0.2258541137,
0.9432764649,
0.6536445022,
-0.7690095901,
-0.2696919739,
-0.6180405021,
-0.0164918248,
-0.3830499053,
0.2427620292,
-0.3277821243,
-1.0200489759,
0.9810528159,
-0.1624292582,
-0.222285822,
0.2301588356,
0.8064591289,
-0.2625355422,
1.2081611156,
0.2431816459,
-0.0760145411,
0.4713169634,
0.1729324162,
0.0102457926,
-0.6773084998,
-1.0038733482,
-1.0816169977,
-0.3105753362,
-0.5283955336,
-0.1939668804,
0.2311347425,
-0.340741694,
-0.0327653103,
0.1935685873,
-0.4148427546,
0.2360608429,
0.1481530368,
0.1787051558,
-0.141184777,
0.0784686878,
0.0249296669,
-0.4826101959,
-0.3595109582,
-0.7211704254,
0.8719039559,
0.333683908,
0.9301828146,
0.3033775687,
0.5548644662,
0.3248133063,
0.2099902183,
-0.8665898442,
0.5862985253,
-0.0664846674,
-0.6793676019,
-0.0857673585,
-0.6061731577,
-0.9557688236,
0.0937312841,
-0.3623964787,
-1.0958430767,
0.426648736,
0.0284404811,
-0.2995221615,
0.1832440645,
-0.7413007021,
0.7136590481,
-0.443256706,
-0.1887771785,
-0.1473992765,
-0.532309413,
0.2437081933,
-0.059788473,
0.1655195504,
-0.5399579406,
-0.0445441082,
1.0025035143,
-0.6248056293,
0.8026763201,
-0.1257299185,
-0.2062239349,
0.3459233046,
0.1952023059,
0.3901748061,
-0.0162400194,
-0.0663865581,
0.1052112877,
-0.2568909526,
-0.1410436928,
-0.4940109253,
0.8772054315,
-0.9887461066,
-0.1695927083,
-0.3403658271,
0.0741682425,
-0.1364216954,
-0.0183859244,
0.4469124973,
0.4103293717,
-0.7579783201,
0.3469357789,
0.687510848,
-0.7745172977,
0.1278425455,
0.8368006945,
-0.1318467855,
-0.6438379288,
0.6350237131,
0.1141446158,
-0.068097733,
0.4220438302,
0.0986149311,
-0.3582512736,
0.1368929595,
-0.2683710754,
-0.0500088409,
-0.7122110724,
-0.1942070872,
-1.2199392319,
0.2872698307,
-0.4203787148,
-0.0578403473,
-0.6009680629,
-0.4652242959,
-0.4266247451,
-0.4121308923,
0.6934841275,
0.8317130208,
-0.0608168952,
0.3010938764,
-1.0850360394,
0.0450738296,
0.4180090725,
-0.0098656341,
-0.2291608006,
-0.4885613024,
-0.0742618144,
0.1825241297,
-0.0715904236,
-1.6397984028,
0.8299341202,
0.5814670324,
0.2324569225,
0.5866844654,
-0.0042950576,
0.5310217738,
-0.3131285906,
0.7737089396,
0.0960428864,
-1.2202965021,
1.0907205343,
-0.3588835299,
-0.1130876914,
0.3341977,
0.4895469546,
-0.7600917816,
-0.2922536433,
-0.6444919109,
-0.9385852814,
0.7775273323,
0.5331583619,
0.2188236713,
-0.0646579638,
0.1552059203,
-0.0074844002,
0.3615030944,
-0.2567231357,
-0.3769616187,
-0.1541291177,
-0.4856651723,
0.2266868651,
-0.314658314,
-0.0027039109,
-0.3594681919,
0.5979044437,
0.2923229933,
0.9543047547,
0.2642897367,
-0.1052782387,
-0.4274247885,
0.5033633709,
0.6773119569,
-0.231809631,
-0.6821250319,
0.2145782262,
0.3025059402,
-0.7685870528,
0.4592647254,
-0.1752809286,
0.3260561228,
0.2850432396,
-0.0036027844,
1.2740994692,
0.3251365125,
-0.861708343,
0.4798162282,
-0.4311929047,
0.0731358901,
-0.6338433027,
-0.1652005762,
-0.0316939019,
0.1303671896,
0.4039079249,
-0.0316127576,
0.3538625538,
-0.6253896356,
-0.0655232742,
-0.072912246,
-0.5892103314,
-0.6717802882,
0.6783807278,
0.4321573377,
-0.2847906053,
0.7303925753,
0.0555461831,
-0.7128150463,
0.9781979322,
0.4871721268,
1.2720726728,
-0.838398695,
0.3652276099,
0.5577729344,
0.4055410922,
0.0150438249,
0.7465073466,
0.1360722184,
-0.8415830731,
0.2238057405,
-0.4384795427,
-0.8452990651,
-0.0443020165,
-0.9357680678,
0.183247447,
-0.5548718572,
-0.4264422655,
0.0101226941,
-0.320589453,
-0.7946413755,
0.4579764307,
0.3584396541,
0.5465445518,
-1.2786105871,
0.4179712832,
0.9541005492,
-0.1096559316,
-0.8361734152,
-0.746589601,
0.3999876678,
-0.6045789123,
0.4804252684,
0.2598049939,
-0.2134235948,
0.017580945,
-0.5149071217,
-0.3898051679,
0.960306704,
0.4492760301,
-0.8435513973,
0.6881880164,
-0.0701118857,
0.8318501711,
-0.6308479905,
0.656514287,
0.3718261123,
0.3180240393,
0.0187319238,
-0.7703640461,
-0.0816203803,
-0.6686636209,
-0.4692413807,
0.1958718598,
-0.688318491,
0.7233297229,
0.0266692825,
-0.3550926149,
-0.2576506436,
0.3905631006,
0.0650808811,
0.5111864209,
0.4854316413,
0.6783630848,
1.1132807732,
-0.3713814914,
0.8421370983,
-0.0731796101,
0.2399880141,
0.834156394,
-0.4745535553,
0.9140065312,
0.0862449259,
-0.2737998068,
0.4146393538,
0.7808499932,
0.162507847,
0.1739308983,
-0.0725301579,
-0.6685937643,
-0.1216466427,
-0.386903137,
-0.3589478135,
0.4207006991,
0.6817460656,
-0.5273628831,
0.4308654666,
0.5150637031,
0.2901031375,
-0.3875855803,
-0.1597871333,
0.8697570562,
0.2267090976,
-0.2829786539,
0.403845191,
-0.2271366268,
0.4075398743,
-0.1441090554,
0.2374891788,
-0.2945136428,
0.0354094841,
-0.5461248755,
-0.6303287745,
0.0425115302,
0.5693545341,
0.0662475303,
-0.1732844263,
0.6154218912,
-0.7070114017,
-0.3607557714,
0.3616873622,
0.4394593537,
0.6193380356,
-0.0562457927,
-0.6011217237,
0.2055820674,
0.0389426835,
-0.3738173246,
-0.0064532273,
0.9902508259,
0.438274622,
0.6898897886,
0.3573500514,
0.2606974244,
0.4372486472,
0.3185321093,
0.6829103231,
-0.8834184408,
-0.7941061258,
-0.8249658346,
0.312641561,
-0.2082288414,
-0.4707036912,
0.9341704249,
0.548956573,
0.2266439646,
-0.2175179124,
0.6468945146,
-0.0203818418,
0.4113487899,
-0.3128701448,
0.4087502062,
-0.5914800167,
0.1585033387,
-0.7155543566,
-0.9022422433,
-0.1077740341,
0.7450072765,
0.011142185,
-0.1009702832,
0.3867123127,
0.8107296824,
0.319754988,
0.490252763,
0.3402232826,
0.5487679839,
0.0906205326,
0.7477419376,
1.1939429045,
-0.2852557302,
0.2231302112,
-0.2269355357,
-0.1966559887,
-0.5332346559,
-0.7783148885,
-0.7677410245,
-0.4684620202,
-0.5288583636,
-0.3700210452,
-0.0138279097,
1.3699873686,
0.4963497519,
-0.8954743147,
-0.1577159613,
0.0276263822,
-0.1255106926,
0.2218529582,
-0.1773136705,
-0.0119637139,
0.3349701762,
-0.8749644756,
0.5758273602,
0.5485628247,
0.4860138893,
-0.0048894309,
-0.3288830519,
0.1234123632,
0.4021016061,
0.4315051138,
0.4658259451,
-0.3275296092,
0.0606380776,
0.2200135589,
-0.3314570189,
0.0826633871,
0.781680882,
-0.3097087443,
0.6468805075,
0.7125188112,
0.2877168357,
0.5467715263,
-0.2144207358,
0.5660044551,
-0.8465957046,
0.5361410975,
0.5035853982,
0.5612485409,
0.4060110152,
-0.5816702843,
0.3762749135,
0.033122357,
-0.6130319238,
-1.083093524,
-0.0969125107,
-1.2268071175,
0.3008371294,
1.0036122799,
-0.4316489995,
-0.305929482,
-0.084438622,
-0.5613630414,
0.3925603926,
-0.8003973961,
0.5728417635,
0.7611351609,
-0.1464125365,
-0.4820260704,
-0.4986723959,
0.427479893,
0.574202776,
-0.9962380528,
-0.2529688776,
0.737431705,
-0.0846312046,
-0.0554413237,
0.5871824026,
-0.1074426025,
0.1566841602,
-0.0218443498,
0.4372798502,
0.3099388182,
-0.2878132761,
-0.6677117944,
0.1749190688,
-0.4325400293,
-0.1756474227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17493v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17493v4
|
Predicting postoperative risks using large language models
| 2024-02-27T13:18:00 | 2024-05-05T04:07:44 |
Bing Xue, Charles Alba, Joanna Abraham, Thomas Kannampallil, Chenyang Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, J.3; I.2.7
|
Predicting postoperative risk can inform effective care management &
planning. We explored large language models (LLMs) in predicting postoperative
risk through clinical texts using various tuning strategies. Records spanning
84,875 patients from Barnes Jewish Hospital (BJH) between 2018 & 2021, with a
mean duration of follow-up based on the length of postoperative ICU stay less
than 7 days, were utilized. Methods were replicated on the MIMIC-III dataset.
Outcomes included 30-day mortality, pulmonary embolism (PE) & pneumonia. Three
domain adaptation & finetuning strategies were implemented for three LLMs
(BioGPT, ClinicalBERT & BioClinicalBERT): self-supervised objectives;
incorporating labels with semi-supervised fine-tuning; & foundational modelling
through multi-task learning. Model performance was compared using the AUROC &
AUPRC for classification tasks & MSE & R2 for regression tasks. Cohort had a
mean age of 56.9 (sd: 16.8) years; 50.3% male; 74% White. Pre-trained LLMs
outperformed traditional word embeddings, with absolute maximal gains of 38.3%
for AUROC & 14% for AUPRC. Adapting models through self-supervised finetuning
further improved performance by 3.2% for AUROC & 1.5% for AUPRC Incorporating
labels into the finetuning procedure further boosted performances, with
semi-supervised finetuning improving by 1.8% for AUROC & 2% for AUPRC &
foundational modelling improving by 3.6% for AUROC & 2.6% for AUPRC compared to
self-supervised finetuning. Pre-trained clinical LLMs offer opportunities for
postoperative risk predictions with unseen data, & further improvements from
finetuning suggests benefits in adapting pre-trained models to note-specific
perioperative use cases. Incorporating labels can further boost performance.
The superior performance of foundational models suggests the potential of
task-agnostic learning towards the generalizable LLMs in perioperative care.
|
[
0.0492133088,
-0.4753502011,
0.6873394847,
-0.0733400211,
-0.3114999831,
0.0037782597,
-0.1043163165,
-0.6046094298,
0.0601518936,
0.9209849238,
-0.5264056325,
-0.7537966371,
-0.8911505938,
-0.1211429164,
-0.0539424159,
1.3189975023,
-0.1822464466,
0.3166012764,
-0.0120547833,
0.1493887603,
-0.5648433566,
-0.7801348567,
-0.4353218377,
-0.1662464887,
0.552020967,
0.3289088309,
0.6094741225,
0.5003042817,
0.7464460135,
0.2410704643,
0.1327161789,
-0.0119309034,
-0.362236321,
-0.2522758245,
0.0362547711,
-0.598182261,
-0.2021801621,
-0.2264570445,
0.3311510682,
0.8904739022,
-0.426851064,
0.0085594719,
-0.0794440955,
0.6676930189,
-0.5140026212,
0.1303799599,
-0.783151269,
0.3450085819,
-0.0891700611,
-0.4531407356,
-0.1689956188,
-0.3447939456,
0.3842737973,
-0.557513535,
-0.2472678572,
0.0884068236,
0.496032536,
0.3909792006,
-0.3923363686,
-0.3975052536,
-0.7332571745,
0.5437129736,
-0.5569859147,
0.570676446,
0.4520793557,
0.2988493741,
0.0289531257,
-0.656631887,
-0.0413992591,
-0.2909325063,
-0.0451528244,
0.1531805098,
-0.182534188,
0.3967324793,
0.3968462348,
0.3976075351,
-0.4540042877,
0.265904516,
-0.4763264358,
-0.2674692571,
0.5136228204,
0.2764062881,
0.1302617043,
0.0514862128,
-0.6365472674,
0.0087369028,
-0.7963751554,
0.0448435545,
0.270807296,
0.1363321096,
-0.1702162325,
0.5519675612,
-0.2032527626,
0.5449349284,
0.134251073,
-0.0538021289,
0.44011572,
-0.2552633584,
-0.2235558331,
0.0754509419,
0.682320714,
0.3506788909,
0.7049452066,
-0.1025778428,
-0.0764205232,
0.0661045313,
0.4912762344,
-0.6557964087,
-0.4241243005,
0.0012800723,
-0.4928086102,
-0.3804780543,
-0.1186723784,
-0.425494194,
-0.4516991973,
-0.3193060458,
0.4296371639,
-0.4769389927,
-0.0577632263,
0.3623140156,
0.4700747132,
0.0088060144,
0.4041499496,
-0.6236869097,
0.3540149629,
0.4141151011,
0.7423703074,
-0.1032124236,
-0.0994484946,
-0.4967629611,
0.1742276847,
-0.591750443,
0.6728649139,
-0.1591827124,
-0.5159586072,
0.3125576675,
0.1889329255,
-0.0841264948,
-0.4148916304,
0.6857182384,
-0.1550438851,
-0.1489287764,
0.1696528643,
-0.5542605519,
-0.1232480481,
-0.0160944816,
-0.664935112,
0.3380474448,
0.0538200997,
-0.5956116915,
0.3769541383,
-0.4251510799,
-0.8466421962,
-0.1200061813,
-0.1117554307,
-0.6977286935,
0.1346330196,
0.3389585018,
0.8534246683,
-0.0788677707,
0.2753526568,
-0.1033715829,
-0.0766731128,
0.270508945,
-0.1848261803,
0.2200179547,
0.2371245474,
0.0019859204,
0.2222300321,
-0.4467996955,
-0.174422279,
-0.1835070401,
-0.2154182196,
-0.0974557027,
-0.027807245,
-0.0802440718,
0.3491635919,
0.183783561,
-0.5553744435,
0.0652334616,
-0.4983865917,
0.3281346262,
0.3526186645,
0.3394290507,
0.3370122313,
-0.5440788865,
0.7279554605,
-0.1730896235,
0.3835735321,
0.1501098871,
-0.1413790286,
-0.2868035138,
0.1103085801,
0.2347312421,
0.8294347525,
-0.6060043573,
0.2689542472,
-0.2032952607,
-0.6821426749,
-0.3338557184,
0.0626408383,
0.6191166639,
0.5637264848,
0.3226602972,
-0.2819892168,
-0.7540584803,
-0.830781877,
-0.1020895913,
-0.2347055823,
-0.103526853,
0.5739303231,
0.1770598143,
-0.5486513972,
0.0166750588,
-0.9006573558,
-0.6863539815,
-0.2443093956,
0.155088678,
0.3298524022,
0.4997010827,
0.2327269614,
-0.4387523234,
-0.3828952014,
0.3129448891,
-0.5900945067,
-0.0407019518,
-0.1947778612,
-0.0633842424,
0.4612753689,
0.7594877481,
-0.3747966588,
0.4533470571,
0.733340323,
0.2246687412,
0.4786776006,
-0.3227187693,
0.1462513059,
-0.8610722423,
-0.0002170993,
0.1506715566,
-0.1212440208,
-0.6669422388,
-0.2986976206,
-0.0578582361,
-0.3217325509,
-0.5221303105,
0.2387069017,
-0.543176353,
0.3106298745,
-0.0198212378,
-0.4668363035,
-0.2027814239,
0.2058921158,
0.410612613,
0.3058751225,
0.6005235314,
-0.4994303882,
-0.1810834855,
0.1589455605,
-0.6382998824,
-0.0004638625,
-0.7947990298,
-0.1158294678,
0.2691456676,
0.2538740337,
-1.0304275751,
-0.1161844209,
-0.1289410293,
-0.2730699182,
0.7258454561,
-0.204624787,
-0.2026698887,
-0.4360288084,
-0.0572047047,
0.1622022837,
0.3291273713,
0.1452298164,
0.5916410685,
0.4768588841,
-0.6147023439,
-0.4120895863,
-0.6672361493,
-0.0712262765,
-0.1587796658,
-0.278401345,
0.2267860621,
-0.2111411393,
0.0871795416,
-0.162768364,
-0.1883505136,
0.0641495213,
0.1540844738,
0.4921759963,
0.4394157827,
0.0390075222,
0.4191604257,
0.0423107482,
-0.1563735902,
-0.1129859015,
-0.3076628149,
0.566105485,
-0.1392274052,
-0.0494862758,
-0.4848396778,
0.309799701,
0.4173199832,
-0.1941682994,
0.7551842928,
0.7783304453,
-0.6143294573,
0.2094617337,
-0.9577445388,
-0.2599420249,
-0.2650544345,
0.4876365364,
-0.2008107454,
-0.9999061227,
0.6084488034,
-0.2408953458,
-0.0870706588,
0.4446749687,
0.6662344337,
-0.331281364,
0.7384136915,
0.7051476836,
-0.0495517477,
0.5307693481,
-0.2929044366,
0.1708282679,
-0.7392725348,
-0.1837129891,
-0.2933903337,
0.0203686822,
-0.8545056581,
-0.6894598603,
0.6080535054,
0.0391923375,
-0.014507602,
0.2634081542,
-0.3920401931,
0.087882638,
0.0485252999,
0.2615335882,
0.0308835842,
0.075779818,
-0.0407863632,
0.1595361084,
-0.6410574317,
-0.1317711622,
1.6587107182,
0.6166992188,
0.9997672439,
-0.3592939973,
0.6915995479,
0.0691146925,
0.1996841431,
-0.7340298295,
0.0943611637,
-0.5099440813,
-0.3798327446,
-0.3350135386,
-0.3617345691,
-0.8798211217,
-0.2097951472,
-0.5798245668,
-0.5663167834,
-0.0390319303,
0.2447622865,
-0.7346820235,
0.1869767904,
-0.7109896541,
0.7427429557,
-0.4765707552,
-0.3311233521,
-0.2751508355,
-0.8922791481,
0.0254057981,
-0.3625959456,
0.3327849805,
0.0735506788,
-0.1789467037,
0.606087327,
-0.3395405412,
0.800056994,
0.1766924113,
-0.1561274529,
0.0558377318,
-0.0187168028,
0.5988856554,
0.0908533707,
-0.1651806533,
0.5906943083,
0.2463150322,
-0.0029242227,
-0.4337513745,
0.8768076301,
-0.9044075608,
-0.526427865,
-0.3884496689,
-0.5573391914,
-0.3774232864,
-0.0601968542,
0.4068757892,
0.5635727048,
-0.2798664868,
0.3482269645,
0.5905709863,
-0.5024128556,
-0.0491610207,
0.648249805,
0.1405671984,
-0.5126770139,
0.5500565171,
0.4075112939,
0.2062787265,
0.7935479879,
0.3765513897,
-0.5548161268,
-0.9321422577,
-0.0868686959,
0.1748204082,
-0.3656797409,
-0.3938395679,
-1.0032765865,
-0.3824844956,
-0.5315318108,
-0.4027473032,
-0.1200177446,
-0.0454955176,
-0.1895045191,
-0.3803963363,
0.3205492795,
0.4974350929,
0.008050425,
0.3774246573,
-0.8026146293,
0.0490998216,
0.0303349029,
0.4020103514,
-0.3857130706,
-0.3758080304,
-0.4836231768,
-0.2110243291,
-0.0810053349,
-0.7647942305,
0.4276373684,
0.2575446367,
0.6271372437,
0.4347300529,
0.0410552509,
0.5826534629,
-0.8063998222,
0.4442635179,
0.527989924,
-0.7377609611,
0.7293149233,
-0.4215033352,
0.2567696273,
0.7021427155,
0.6825208068,
-0.3937096,
0.0638974085,
-0.5513040423,
-0.8245568871,
0.5279069543,
-0.2527594864,
-0.0636334792,
-0.114144586,
0.4411874115,
0.1968229562,
0.5675296187,
-0.6847496033,
0.0523840487,
0.1087727696,
-0.095534265,
-0.5890427828,
-0.2830301523,
-0.2969713211,
-0.1791255772,
0.4194990695,
-0.3767739236,
0.1806635708,
0.2277267277,
-0.1265376955,
-0.4749647975,
0.2312642783,
0.5852621794,
0.6226685643,
-0.2157131881,
-0.1174597144,
0.4104693234,
-0.3838236332,
-0.2495967597,
0.2891183496,
0.3788763583,
-0.3590714037,
0.6956273317,
1.0766496658,
0.3745926321,
-0.6565049291,
0.4728722572,
0.0545430817,
-0.2269070446,
-0.5607491732,
-0.130123049,
-0.0616091825,
0.0723193884,
-0.0070414608,
0.2727205753,
0.3252385557,
-0.4813462198,
0.3492527604,
0.2884790301,
-0.669244647,
-0.1924535781,
0.462831676,
0.118695654,
0.0064784396,
0.0338038765,
0.3149759173,
-0.3130343854,
0.4958436787,
0.4530912936,
0.5530690551,
-0.5092919469,
0.2252305895,
0.4050597548,
0.3765780032,
-0.1442973912,
0.1459427625,
0.2161115557,
-0.4716814458,
-0.606559813,
-0.7033137083,
-0.1218012571,
0.1531369388,
-0.5779026747,
0.3148262799,
-0.6369056702,
-0.1462099552,
-0.2084257305,
0.23617962,
-0.887096405,
0.4132529795,
0.3412005603,
0.6563125253,
-0.9312224984,
0.711935997,
0.9108679891,
-0.2090879828,
-1.1398134232,
0.1583500206,
-0.0198212136,
-0.7530437112,
0.3157529831,
0.2107710093,
-0.0241789483,
-0.2103916258,
0.0002928504,
-0.9439634681,
0.9426335692,
0.1676257402,
-1.0037788153,
-0.0820584074,
0.0169439204,
0.9045458436,
-0.5691002011,
0.0920044333,
0.3623603284,
0.0219557229,
0.2182128727,
-1.0515525341,
-0.0586760826,
0.0930759758,
-0.0918132886,
0.3672677577,
-0.3430363536,
0.5504950285,
-0.6655955911,
-0.0007975899,
0.0128183486,
0.2730570734,
-0.0586297102,
0.3004348874,
0.6293165088,
0.7470889688,
0.3859272599,
-0.1470284611,
1.3616226912,
-0.4360002577,
0.0563391484,
0.8652139902,
-0.337207824,
0.9117927551,
0.3211094737,
-0.179039374,
0.4974249303,
0.428089112,
0.1797133237,
0.6845368147,
0.3604631722,
0.0532371067,
-0.36040622,
-0.2380197048,
-0.4545567334,
0.4791970253,
0.642165482,
-0.4281691015,
0.2759138048,
0.2913913727,
-0.0084609576,
0.0688006952,
-0.5012189746,
1.1283909082,
0.2723355591,
-0.8673579097,
0.6521316767,
-0.3760551512,
0.4354343116,
-0.7948506474,
-0.0514481664,
0.2085859776,
0.4156415164,
-0.3812957108,
-0.7998059392,
0.2657259107,
-0.4518632889,
-0.0562369227,
-0.1111311242,
0.7094967961,
-0.6020540595,
-0.8258361816,
0.4726976752,
0.3791215718,
-0.1259405613,
0.012922517,
-0.5994472504,
0.2361501902,
0.0937875658,
-0.0221532378,
0.3514201343,
0.3823367655,
-0.2181001008,
0.6869516373,
0.6720711589,
0.5776504874,
-0.3525586426,
0.2050999254,
0.8695375323,
-0.0672764331,
-0.4308044612,
-0.4376330972,
0.3168509305,
0.3970015943,
-0.3512156308,
0.3414868712,
0.1657705158,
0.8189886808,
-0.3548927009,
0.5773249865,
0.4202450216,
0.6296156049,
-0.7876190543,
0.6085848212,
-0.6883425117,
0.1058313772,
-0.7009944916,
-0.369917661,
-0.5379027128,
0.5730229616,
-1.0001633167,
-0.1697855145,
0.6750664115,
0.6359300613,
0.2409502119,
-0.4161011279,
0.5924479365,
0.2099571526,
0.0999711379,
0.7507968545,
0.5005546212,
-0.2501997948,
0.4491018951,
-0.2170082778,
-0.3321073949,
-0.5780357122,
-0.6923168302,
-0.7554718852,
-0.3046105802,
-0.4133273959,
-0.1025571153,
0.3446319997,
0.7500006557,
0.8648135066,
-0.6909685731,
-0.1003051549,
0.0819330066,
-0.3687152863,
-0.1971357912,
-0.0725078732,
0.5686486363,
-0.0974257812,
-0.2141612917,
0.0653809458,
0.2719896436,
0.0174742807,
0.1651584953,
0.0014610391,
-0.2747783661,
-0.2461916655,
0.6202346683,
0.0171775781,
-0.7607451677,
-0.334833771,
0.154409796,
-0.042546127,
-0.2177356631,
0.7711164355,
-0.3996963799,
0.3737058043,
0.1998572648,
0.7092443109,
0.4475285709,
0.0328679532,
0.5957416296,
-0.5377627015,
-0.0162356012,
0.4100759625,
0.639462471,
0.2615605295,
-0.8732180595,
0.4471006691,
0.0474019572,
-0.7471618652,
-0.4353911281,
0.2737536728,
-0.9706550241,
-0.0798938796,
1.0753414631,
-0.3200860918,
0.2230849564,
-0.0202882905,
-0.2635374367,
0.4297369421,
-0.3590549827,
0.5999361277,
0.5318592191,
-0.302508682,
-0.1866126209,
-0.7489289045,
0.7599086761,
0.5060630441,
-0.7938809991,
-0.2137149423,
0.4938554764,
0.5378217101,
0.2184700221,
0.6288026571,
-0.3227099776,
0.3821494281,
-0.5203440785,
0.2049900442,
-0.0539619438,
-0.5720901489,
-0.3592480123,
0.1208132505,
0.1495003849,
-0.0733759925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17478v1
|
Can GPT-4 Identify Propaganda? Annotation and Detection of Propaganda Spans in News Articles
| 2024-02-27T13:02:19 | 2024-02-27T13:02:19 |
Maram Hasanain, Fatema Ahmed, Firoj Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The use of propaganda has spiked on mainstream and social media, aiming to
manipulate or mislead users. While efforts to automatically detect propaganda
techniques in textual, visual, or multimodal content have increased, most of
them primarily focus on English content. The majority of the recent initiatives
targeting medium to low-resource languages produced relatively small annotated
datasets, with a skewed distribution, posing challenges for the development of
sophisticated propaganda detection models. To address this challenge, we
carefully develop the largest propaganda dataset to date, ArPro, comprised of
8K paragraphs from newspaper articles, labeled at the text span level following
a taxonomy of 23 propagandistic techniques. Furthermore, our work offers the
first attempt to understand the performance of large language models (LLMs),
using GPT-4, for fine-grained propaganda detection from text. Results showed
that GPT-4's performance degrades as the task moves from simply classifying a
paragraph as propagandistic or not, to the fine-grained task of detecting
propaganda techniques and their manifestation in text. Compared to models
fine-tuned on the dataset for propaganda detection at different classification
granularities, GPT-4 is still far behind. Finally, we evaluate GPT-4 on a
dataset consisting of six other languages for span detection, and results
suggest that the model struggles with the task across languages. Our dataset
and resources will be released to the community.
|
[
-0.5608250499,
-0.9434682727,
0.5559840202,
0.242074281,
-0.3189280927,
0.0185064543,
-0.305190891,
-0.5410177112,
0.0106094806,
0.4323414862,
-0.2469892353,
-0.4255654216,
-1.0068100691,
0.4651563764,
-0.5769423246,
1.2602701187,
-0.2029395998,
-0.2426229268,
0.2358938456,
-0.0178139526,
0.2415489256,
-0.4934690893,
-0.6648007631,
-0.2437347621,
0.6322914958,
0.2204492688,
0.6220838428,
0.8222730756,
0.4057790339,
0.2534927726,
0.0979350954,
0.2372578532,
-0.4505394101,
-0.3434161246,
-0.1045376137,
-0.3125676215,
-0.1384602636,
0.4638829827,
0.7876101136,
0.0736981481,
0.2357138097,
0.1887521446,
0.0184792802,
0.3868404329,
-0.3666489124,
0.1807370186,
-0.6646217704,
-0.1732607335,
-0.7087418437,
-0.1359969229,
-0.2618498802,
-0.1739952117,
0.0385330766,
-0.5648055673,
0.3312632442,
0.1841995567,
1.0672290325,
-0.009824479,
-0.5576443672,
-0.4566687644,
-0.6449987888,
0.7350135446,
-0.4469693899,
0.2489872724,
0.4287567139,
0.0196263343,
0.1170821264,
-0.780158937,
-0.6923464537,
-0.1461064816,
0.0113410549,
0.0267365314,
-0.5237125754,
-0.147686407,
0.241897136,
0.3328217268,
-0.7233730555,
0.1054815426,
-0.6602091193,
-0.6595072746,
0.3835864365,
-0.2193643749,
0.3713274598,
-0.4095328748,
-0.6125603914,
0.0893471986,
-0.6879813671,
-0.4737665057,
0.8784160614,
0.00996764,
-0.0948073119,
0.6937249303,
-0.1261211783,
0.7091080546,
0.0198365878,
-0.2850574851,
0.2438814193,
-0.3171773553,
-0.0881632194,
-0.075872235,
0.9792880416,
0.3864693046,
0.376087904,
0.1809687465,
-0.3091441095,
0.3903766572,
0.2097886652,
-0.5186957121,
-0.4633074999,
-0.2642200887,
-0.3016193807,
-0.4386311173,
-0.1499760002,
-0.8118847609,
-0.2901890576,
0.1072543189,
0.5230916739,
-0.5186959505,
-0.2217097282,
0.0129938452,
-0.1437071562,
0.2941372097,
0.0400910079,
-0.8122816086,
0.2285794169,
0.705416739,
1.1327739954,
-0.2696131766,
-0.3102326989,
-0.4702610373,
-0.0096540945,
-0.4966918528,
1.2181301117,
-0.6815335155,
-0.0046765646,
0.2529046834,
0.0288296677,
-0.0916732252,
-0.378382057,
0.8348863125,
-0.5493211746,
0.3400339484,
-0.3504781723,
-0.541218996,
-0.0397293344,
0.5767436028,
-1.0733252764,
0.804068327,
0.3661207855,
-0.9947990179,
0.3254621625,
-0.3966460526,
-0.4693548977,
-0.083246395,
-0.0963647366,
-0.7026872039,
-0.0340520032,
0.4075838327,
0.3595742583,
-0.0069615338,
-0.0638787076,
-0.0419575609,
-0.3881004155,
0.1698713154,
-0.8747038245,
0.1617392749,
0.3417619467,
-0.177156195,
-0.1295394152,
-0.4579842389,
-0.4336517155,
-0.0327265374,
-0.4971573353,
-0.3732077181,
-0.239777714,
0.0514695682,
0.3355732858,
0.3406746984,
-0.4008336365,
0.3194361031,
-0.1467977464,
0.3199031055,
0.6856782436,
0.2030917555,
0.366651535,
-0.261308521,
0.632676065,
0.0519142337,
0.1301624477,
-0.1963437796,
-0.6312942505,
-0.4985029101,
-0.2395837903,
0.1025664732,
0.4644304216,
-1.0262974501,
-0.2285220623,
-0.147109136,
-0.3321622312,
-0.1878372282,
0.0701794997,
0.4412630498,
0.556620419,
0.4577546418,
0.0769855306,
-0.6695161462,
-1.2181199789,
-0.6265156269,
-0.2652031183,
0.0342595205,
-0.366723299,
0.6553365588,
-0.0820694044,
0.5305446386,
-0.4369999468,
-0.4584639966,
-0.4664934576,
0.5421571136,
-0.0145366602,
-0.032320708,
0.4305404723,
-0.9654353261,
-0.4974883795,
-0.0372848138,
-0.5351804495,
-0.427347213,
-0.0465120897,
0.0311735515,
0.376198858,
0.3288477063,
-0.4956124425,
0.1260553747,
0.7707958817,
-0.3235416412,
0.8308560848,
0.0190880615,
0.25648278,
-0.7864894271,
-0.1467777193,
0.5303472877,
-0.1404343098,
-0.8705071211,
-0.4580191076,
0.264000833,
0.1906364113,
-0.3758285046,
0.4508830607,
-0.3130171895,
-0.0675360337,
-0.2913626432,
0.1297557503,
0.2035792768,
0.2661453187,
0.019384766,
0.9283974171,
0.291990906,
-0.25794819,
0.2523242533,
0.1428284347,
-0.5070014596,
0.6873462796,
-0.2394692898,
-0.2141613066,
0.0096034491,
0.4288781583,
-0.8291787505,
-0.5973870158,
0.6722710133,
-0.2427377552,
0.2243328542,
-0.3311156631,
-0.5458909273,
-0.3272066414,
-0.4038676322,
0.1886666715,
0.2814874351,
-0.3648532927,
0.3805992007,
0.3231938779,
-0.033743605,
-0.6611612439,
-0.5232363939,
0.155213818,
-0.5085780025,
-0.3735955358,
0.1610825807,
0.3662698269,
-0.1585852206,
-0.0125365844,
-0.3584161103,
-0.1995835453,
-0.314530313,
-0.2043508887,
0.172153905,
-0.0443727262,
0.1099174023,
-0.0788282827,
-0.0455215946,
0.1261780411,
-0.3086721599,
0.4660835266,
-0.2168229222,
-0.3453184068,
-0.4230204225,
0.2937218249,
0.5865081549,
-0.3469869196,
0.5193248391,
1.1054214239,
-0.1614851803,
-0.0213586297,
-0.7664321661,
0.0571595132,
-0.4186513424,
0.5204449892,
-0.2243857086,
-0.7202268839,
0.4227362871,
0.0088530593,
-0.1303679198,
0.7120973468,
0.4728512168,
0.2093610615,
1.1067556143,
0.5083764195,
-0.3700775206,
0.4650226533,
-0.2750730217,
0.0822983161,
-0.7066608071,
-0.1508041918,
-0.3551994562,
-0.1690156162,
-0.5287932158,
-0.3787598908,
0.4596611261,
-0.2111693472,
-0.2362806797,
0.0544763505,
-0.4620627165,
0.3503168821,
0.3352952003,
-0.1172741503,
0.4452623725,
0.1626336426,
0.3896203935,
0.0758960471,
-0.4638012648,
-0.7699214816,
0.9724827409,
0.5066354871,
0.6211941838,
-0.1604082286,
0.438988775,
0.4285409749,
0.716095984,
-0.6002644897,
0.4740765691,
-0.2108146101,
-0.6244626045,
0.007543717,
-0.375298202,
-0.8139361143,
0.2209935635,
0.0595394708,
-0.4785947502,
-0.0885793716,
0.2388012707,
-0.0496198572,
0.4078994691,
-0.7668563128,
0.944288671,
-0.17109707,
-0.1101063937,
0.0116753131,
-0.3146324158,
0.567525804,
-0.3351035416,
0.4448105395,
-0.2794321477,
-0.2747652531,
0.8635675907,
0.1112161577,
0.7246974111,
-0.1234956309,
-0.3457882404,
0.2148542702,
-0.1750407666,
0.6099783778,
-0.0609279722,
0.1313517839,
0.1878907233,
-0.1495208293,
-0.3665967584,
-0.2117311507,
0.7605367899,
-0.7538181543,
-0.583345592,
-0.5758935213,
-0.4644532502,
-0.0165496599,
0.2652439773,
0.6451019049,
0.4990549684,
-0.1062589511,
-0.0083595011,
0.562613368,
-0.1104837283,
0.2758553326,
0.4237319231,
-0.2309971899,
-0.3139694035,
0.9809831381,
0.4080095887,
0.2555956841,
0.111525625,
0.1058850214,
-0.4233056903,
-0.698848784,
-0.3808462322,
0.3979651928,
-0.653889358,
-0.1641054899,
-0.4288343489,
-0.0052558267,
-0.1442326307,
-0.0534452125,
-0.3813394904,
-0.0353508964,
-0.2433083206,
-0.1947791874,
0.2833270431,
0.9064235091,
-0.1215166077,
0.5210978389,
-0.4624736607,
0.4951072335,
0.0413292497,
0.3838431537,
-0.6607508063,
-0.5102485418,
-0.5082775354,
-0.0556663424,
-0.4027353227,
-1.1192169189,
0.5742103457,
0.0594702102,
0.3598573506,
0.6015045047,
-0.0507509001,
0.4230580926,
-0.5797442794,
0.965699017,
-0.1322815567,
-0.7157472968,
0.1743880361,
-0.627182126,
0.0789323747,
0.0614391007,
0.7147200704,
-0.4098360538,
-0.6390628815,
-0.5474056602,
-0.6352162957,
0.5540938377,
0.2609228194,
0.1475918591,
-0.4717682302,
0.18664217,
0.0699706748,
0.1143174022,
-0.886873126,
0.0214536022,
-0.4274662137,
-0.1900712252,
-0.0979322419,
-0.3772829771,
-0.2468326092,
0.1681091338,
0.7078716755,
-0.2044185251,
0.3576256037,
0.2840281427,
-0.1012786552,
-0.1129175276,
0.2316712737,
0.6480436325,
0.7342876196,
0.0955617949,
0.3513073921,
0.010886902,
-0.7351901531,
0.0022769654,
0.3381305933,
-0.0094594145,
0.1588383317,
0.6111775637,
0.6641174555,
0.1660442948,
-0.4188667238,
0.6837338805,
0.0990588889,
-0.4689375162,
-0.6178565621,
-0.1978426874,
-0.1706064641,
0.4343442619,
0.7189077139,
-0.0913429409,
0.1029357091,
-0.4461325109,
0.3214485049,
0.5678017735,
-0.0601867884,
-0.6364142895,
0.595757246,
-0.013925883,
-0.0164144207,
0.363676697,
-0.1197078303,
-0.7794812322,
0.377805829,
0.5257557034,
0.4061461985,
-0.3098224998,
0.5415149927,
0.0100111961,
0.6504152417,
-0.5423535109,
0.0749528557,
0.4223529398,
-0.8341041207,
-0.6834357381,
-0.5224593878,
-0.1948674172,
0.7903418541,
-0.5138238668,
0.1141803712,
-0.1021063998,
-0.0771934688,
0.1396148056,
0.1392387897,
-0.5007995367,
0.1671799868,
0.5182443261,
0.8604468703,
-1.4440594912,
0.8573399782,
0.4969645143,
-0.3626190424,
-0.6916097999,
0.2687006891,
0.2497313023,
-0.6472183466,
0.4020993114,
0.4557677805,
0.0408435464,
0.1518761516,
-0.7246391773,
-0.7443844676,
0.7483635545,
0.3410038352,
-0.1477614343,
-0.1799261719,
0.204055503,
0.512999475,
-0.3076972067,
-0.057879895,
0.8546836376,
0.8159484863,
-0.1804116666,
-0.8115029931,
-0.2184567302,
0.0236450937,
-0.1975229383,
0.3242712617,
-0.607878387,
1.0237588882,
0.4261057973,
-0.1462630332,
-0.0591236353,
0.5040006638,
0.0401795357,
0.3990982771,
0.5050406456,
0.4352436662,
0.4256716073,
-0.2925192714,
1.0614056587,
-0.1744835377,
0.3641396761,
0.5187982917,
-0.0345110446,
0.5762017369,
0.3964829743,
0.0835963488,
0.5035666823,
0.5675970912,
-0.2053598613,
0.4487290382,
-0.1794988662,
-0.4901542664,
-0.0570493527,
0.0894525126,
0.0136540001,
0.4753050506,
0.6899171472,
-0.5649470091,
-0.4136407673,
0.3766089976,
0.483592838,
0.0480317473,
-0.4779136777,
0.4579337537,
-0.1049905941,
-0.7392162681,
0.5631338954,
0.0950287282,
0.5728540421,
-0.7796820998,
-0.0265485253,
-0.1102407202,
0.1880129427,
-0.1239895225,
-0.8520597816,
0.4185875654,
0.0777770355,
0.0885586068,
-0.2112468183,
0.9638200402,
-0.5414602757,
-0.2761685252,
-0.0035228655,
0.5814779997,
0.2515613735,
-0.2746237516,
-0.4763152599,
0.4843118489,
0.0684458241,
-0.7002276182,
0.3966403604,
0.5445812345,
-0.2771978676,
0.5205854177,
0.621958077,
0.1350851059,
-0.0252194218,
-0.1582496911,
0.8950490952,
-0.2493087202,
-0.2552025318,
-0.9861930609,
0.0799906477,
-0.2994413376,
-0.1248866618,
1.0003105402,
0.6697831154,
0.9800835848,
-0.1610592306,
1.0440182686,
-0.0089431442,
0.4054480195,
-0.5064921379,
0.5287864804,
-0.2634106576,
0.1637915522,
-0.2807765007,
-0.769598484,
-0.4359386265,
0.6705939174,
-0.6984986663,
-0.1221061051,
0.7279849648,
0.7010129094,
-0.189802736,
-0.1111850888,
0.2915552855,
0.3164955378,
0.463560611,
0.2637465894,
0.8972696066,
-0.0012533896,
1.0211087465,
-0.1989502162,
-0.2374951541,
-0.0890474245,
-0.9366703033,
-0.9042318463,
-0.728890717,
-0.1075340435,
-0.1312095821,
0.1693855971,
0.5023971796,
0.3943772316,
-0.3082244694,
0.1973678321,
0.0182985738,
-0.0718011856,
-0.2712476552,
-0.2268498987,
0.5044003725,
-0.3045691252,
-0.938242197,
0.3048113883,
0.2777126431,
-0.0902076289,
-0.4763554633,
0.1761410683,
-0.308924526,
0.1895130426,
0.480298847,
0.36939767,
-0.7057529092,
-0.7166143656,
-0.1773845404,
0.0758357495,
-0.0327080786,
0.688100338,
-0.6530711651,
0.246801585,
0.1826674491,
0.3178065717,
0.3927604258,
0.3067971468,
0.3551915586,
-1.0607024431,
0.0940868258,
0.1031394154,
0.2966055572,
0.4831984937,
-0.3263352811,
0.3811866939,
0.3744805157,
-0.8424156308,
-0.676130414,
0.3193895519,
-0.6801026464,
-0.0689289719,
1.5136911869,
-0.2634169757,
-0.205952853,
-0.3879306912,
-0.3961209655,
0.3701358736,
-0.416983664,
0.6921465993,
0.8977590203,
-0.1593254656,
-0.3583270311,
-0.8937643766,
0.7383119464,
-0.1455212086,
-0.6279397607,
-0.014266965,
0.7946956754,
0.5328294635,
0.2137178034,
0.6417577863,
0.0012463433,
0.0358607806,
-0.1643829495,
-0.3704761863,
-0.1853513718,
-0.2947923243,
-0.1055421606,
0.3561288118,
-0.209771663,
-0.139650479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17463v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17463v2
|
Training-Free Long-Context Scaling of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T12:39:23 | 2024-05-29T05:44:58 |
Chenxin An, Fei Huang, Jun Zhang, Shansan Gong, Xipeng Qiu, Chang Zhou, Lingpeng Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to process and generate coherent
text is markedly weakened when the number of input tokens exceeds their
pretraining length. Given the expensive overhead of finetuning large-scale
models with longer sequences, we propose Dual Chunk Attention (DCA), which
enables Llama2 70B to support context windows of more than 100k tokens without
continual training. By decomposing the attention computation for long sequences
into chunk-based modules, DCA manages to effectively capture the relative
positional information of tokens within the same chunk (Intra-Chunk) and across
distinct chunks (Inter-Chunk), as well as integrates seamlessly with Flash
Attention. In addition to its impressive extrapolation capability, DCA achieves
performance on practical long-context tasks that is comparable to or even
better than that of finetuned models. When compared with proprietary models,
our training-free 70B model attains 94% of the performance of gpt-3.5-16k,
indicating it is a viable open-source alternative. All code and data used in
this work are released at \url{https://github.com/HKUNLP/ChunkLlama}.
|
[
-0.2771062255,
-0.6709013581,
0.6389857531,
0.5313895345,
-0.6759851575,
-0.1875681132,
-0.5150621533,
-0.6288865805,
0.1945520192,
0.4284986258,
-0.4461836517,
-0.1906032562,
-0.5884055495,
-0.0610104054,
-0.5386434197,
0.8116772771,
0.0007890136,
-0.0203671306,
-0.066101253,
-0.0627499223,
-0.5292506218,
-0.3568736017,
-0.8918383718,
-0.0288192555,
0.7185283303,
0.2742363214,
0.4068705142,
0.7714240551,
0.4319621623,
0.2605220377,
-0.3334397078,
0.0510587208,
-0.5530225635,
0.030615462,
-0.2245523185,
-0.3642654717,
-0.8190384507,
-0.1797111034,
0.8813990355,
0.4407886565,
0.008337548,
0.3264119923,
0.088599965,
0.8472751379,
-0.4534206986,
0.2748619616,
-0.8885458112,
-0.2397615761,
-0.3000662029,
-0.000565692,
-0.5210604072,
0.1776193082,
0.1487807333,
-0.4111309648,
0.1353455782,
-0.071507141,
0.5581506491,
0.4329999089,
-0.6590328813,
-0.1075651422,
-0.4292878807,
0.8356691599,
-0.6001747251,
0.2221631408,
0.272773087,
0.2073797137,
-0.0495073125,
-0.5761688948,
-0.410005033,
-0.0780279115,
0.2388384193,
-0.2143847644,
-0.0382107012,
0.1770365089,
0.135791555,
0.4746544361,
-0.4444454312,
0.1899424493,
-0.4720941484,
-0.0111996299,
0.5297238231,
0.0116093755,
0.1337421983,
0.1565428376,
-0.5189096928,
-0.0344664939,
-0.9163125157,
-0.1406628937,
0.1380616426,
0.4935805798,
-0.3717279136,
0.4414377511,
-0.2565573454,
0.74913311,
0.3389300704,
-0.0268162526,
0.0971996337,
-0.2807864547,
-0.4748197794,
0.1142624617,
0.6378341317,
0.1953778416,
0.1526012421,
-0.2610350847,
-0.1191622391,
-0.0115232859,
0.3545801044,
-0.8718797565,
0.1942918599,
0.5007281899,
-0.1214546561,
0.006806585,
-0.2615065575,
-0.7618662119,
-0.231311962,
-0.5751673579,
0.1951151192,
-0.0799396634,
-0.3340609074,
-0.0182922725,
0.1747238636,
0.2037727535,
0.4376028776,
-1.0860689878,
0.0151384966,
0.8042843938,
1.0757091045,
-0.3502494693,
-0.2350680083,
-0.6501323581,
0.3049370348,
-0.3328730464,
0.8001703024,
-0.363766849,
-0.0727536678,
-0.0174407884,
0.0763093457,
0.1365289092,
-0.6572918296,
0.0746832713,
-0.7630652189,
-0.2024209201,
-0.1885542125,
-0.3208506405,
-0.1895133704,
0.2129855305,
-0.7275488973,
0.9932342768,
0.2497998327,
-0.6923934817,
0.3856832683,
-0.414652884,
-0.5759401321,
0.039907109,
0.0060191052,
-0.0941567793,
0.2896858156,
0.1894340515,
0.571900785,
-0.3771242797,
0.5003504753,
-0.4270351529,
-0.3852311969,
-0.102536425,
-0.5145884156,
0.5019178987,
0.0481533855,
-0.6035258174,
0.4897077084,
-0.7981372476,
-0.1024151742,
0.1020182148,
-0.6720691919,
-0.3098795712,
-0.214424327,
0.275588423,
0.3862955868,
0.3726910651,
-0.3061541915,
0.156599462,
-0.4406430125,
0.5158501863,
0.9097943902,
-0.5384904146,
0.4253171086,
0.0277194437,
0.4518768191,
0.22507447,
-0.1476826668,
-0.2113718837,
-0.2459521741,
-0.8845562339,
-0.5455006361,
0.2128793001,
0.1700172871,
-0.4153295457,
0.5146789551,
-0.506767869,
-0.2192747295,
-0.4536184967,
0.2587747872,
0.3297971487,
0.2494306415,
0.4789305925,
-0.7020935416,
-0.4753703773,
-0.8501949906,
0.1023907885,
0.0262267925,
-0.1915530115,
0.1530757397,
0.3065634668,
-0.2069414109,
0.9285449982,
-0.2772630751,
-0.4198738635,
-0.4463261366,
-0.2099460661,
-0.0102955699,
0.282833606,
0.2655912042,
-0.6848902702,
-0.5679911971,
-0.0090508368,
-0.4102368653,
0.0306031685,
-0.0830727592,
-0.1784344912,
0.4643138945,
0.5551562309,
-0.6270552278,
0.2284150422,
0.9411799312,
-0.3536016941,
0.460786432,
-0.0978524759,
-0.234994188,
-1.4279146194,
0.3636915684,
0.0216791127,
-0.5404657125,
-0.5634449124,
0.2252083421,
0.4680897892,
0.1174260899,
-0.77568537,
0.8129582405,
-0.7005883455,
-0.1752466261,
-0.5942761302,
0.3141211271,
-0.10445638,
0.6290892363,
0.2408096194,
0.9090237617,
0.4336218536,
-0.5676316619,
0.2167707235,
-0.1620145738,
-0.492862314,
0.4195941389,
-0.7271806598,
0.3100224435,
-0.1013667583,
0.6269820333,
-0.9916688204,
-0.4187580645,
-0.0929978341,
0.0505612642,
0.6894809008,
-0.2050673962,
-0.4384284317,
-0.3865938783,
-0.3709791005,
0.7832732201,
0.3543553948,
-0.7218811512,
0.3466699123,
0.5125271082,
-0.201786682,
-0.6986427903,
-0.6822285056,
0.2174796313,
-0.320473969,
-0.5412766337,
0.1098922938,
-0.1328763217,
-0.085092403,
-0.30972296,
-0.1566920429,
-0.1480419487,
-0.0243005026,
0.2831369936,
0.168803677,
-0.1554138362,
0.1288197488,
0.183290273,
0.0290116984,
-0.1062022299,
-0.3562728763,
0.8994196057,
-0.011571913,
-0.083293438,
-0.5498303175,
0.382923156,
0.7850247025,
-0.2025150806,
0.8312748671,
0.4907437563,
-0.252766788,
-0.2883461416,
-0.6080969572,
0.0082848249,
-0.4878690243,
0.73149997,
-0.2568936944,
-1.1593809128,
0.3824542761,
0.1812354624,
-0.0027598734,
0.4354569316,
0.9107494354,
0.4370918572,
0.7641498446,
0.7862943411,
-0.485440135,
0.5693626404,
-0.0340864658,
-0.0435223542,
-1.1844013929,
-0.0272284877,
-0.1773339808,
-0.2878207564,
-0.0461210683,
-0.8993786573,
0.1547876894,
0.0467984565,
-0.1579584181,
0.3122348785,
-0.4581568539,
0.6510651112,
0.4078643322,
-0.118818894,
0.2437442392,
0.0138846505,
0.1536513269,
0.3874365389,
-0.4251428545,
-0.3780613244,
1.2207969427,
0.530619204,
0.7384971976,
0.0370338298,
0.4293109179,
-0.0457724743,
0.447898984,
-0.9735829234,
0.5404915214,
-0.1017259583,
-0.8521140218,
-0.3821992874,
-0.4267778993,
-0.7605570555,
0.4917688668,
0.4826617837,
-0.749476254,
-0.1942622811,
0.2474207729,
-0.3890083134,
0.369304508,
-0.6706770062,
0.7311083674,
0.0801301971,
-0.4132831693,
-0.5056203008,
-0.700160563,
0.5623402596,
-0.347753942,
0.1752039939,
-0.3302110136,
-0.0992993787,
0.7286815643,
-0.0935207456,
1.1292595863,
-0.0710183233,
-0.6121647358,
0.4877997935,
-0.1293696612,
0.5633111596,
0.1872764528,
0.2382270247,
0.1451555192,
0.0016296712,
-0.5165129304,
-0.0453060642,
0.8508141041,
-0.5676233172,
-0.6125355959,
-0.3936268985,
-0.9078950882,
-0.2498016953,
0.3069098294,
-0.0295721069,
0.4660228789,
-0.1179109886,
0.2753775418,
0.5746366978,
0.0721858293,
0.623395741,
0.3909513354,
-0.0399551839,
-0.3801749647,
0.5953462124,
0.0600235984,
0.4806711674,
0.4906158447,
-0.1157578602,
-0.3527164757,
-0.5729597211,
-0.681276381,
0.4630558193,
-0.5907844901,
-0.3121923506,
-0.6673246622,
0.0190242622,
-0.5127123594,
-0.028556589,
-0.5521937609,
-0.3569718301,
-0.4797767699,
0.000410961,
0.0369587317,
0.7324168086,
0.0832094997,
0.2843414545,
-0.6883473992,
0.2030194551,
0.5295954347,
0.3439385891,
0.4590235054,
-0.6791769266,
-0.5764406919,
-0.0686126575,
-0.2497248501,
-0.4851350784,
0.4104607701,
0.0223277416,
-0.054057274,
0.4774564207,
-0.2512436807,
0.7674285173,
-0.7967430353,
0.8532161713,
0.3259374797,
-0.9703940749,
0.1767908037,
-0.5014832616,
0.7491973042,
0.5489358306,
0.1532506794,
-0.6061741114,
-0.3925378025,
-0.1719105542,
-1.1047071218,
0.9444692731,
-0.3032022417,
0.3245323598,
-0.1845973283,
0.44475618,
0.1253789365,
0.1291362196,
-0.6617110968,
0.0235938132,
0.1101771072,
-0.3974704742,
-0.3179521263,
-0.6816664338,
-0.2296453416,
-0.0793639421,
0.6445785165,
-0.5142458677,
0.1947323829,
0.1201808155,
-0.256570816,
-0.1704624891,
0.3016356528,
0.82688272,
0.784268856,
-0.0745548457,
0.3453703523,
0.2434290498,
-0.6318682432,
0.2090789527,
0.0143296793,
0.0401083939,
-0.4143583179,
0.3425391912,
0.7179160118,
0.2909141481,
-0.8992731571,
0.384926945,
-0.0355951861,
0.0486807749,
-0.1579989642,
-0.1133742034,
0.4538218975,
0.330920577,
0.3725346029,
-0.4449036419,
-0.0312845856,
-0.5293611288,
0.1611938179,
0.4880808294,
-0.670745492,
-0.67822963,
0.8093960285,
0.2681084573,
0.1712877005,
0.5295801759,
0.0040598884,
-0.2443732619,
0.7937338948,
0.7975730896,
0.9281410575,
-0.1139496788,
-0.0291945525,
0.2650437951,
0.1650484204,
-0.3652540445,
-0.0171203222,
-0.1616639495,
-0.3181724548,
-0.7012443542,
-0.8422611356,
-0.2470885217,
0.3295315504,
-0.5775127411,
0.13784796,
-0.4594839513,
-0.1337748021,
-0.2786311209,
-0.0300562624,
-0.5097631812,
0.3449478149,
0.3920169771,
1.0369721651,
-0.5113638043,
1.2632106543,
0.5104429722,
-0.0876108706,
-0.7646021843,
0.1014539525,
-0.0220563132,
-0.7903857231,
0.4745693207,
0.7526746988,
-0.0234745909,
-0.0624563731,
-0.3357371688,
-1.0943660736,
1.203789115,
0.4483305216,
-0.9146694541,
-0.2830917537,
0.0036885322,
0.4085818529,
-0.2593680322,
-0.0043704864,
0.5368490219,
0.1125438288,
0.0107916314,
-1.0825029612,
0.2258320302,
0.129335314,
0.0496048331,
0.3070682585,
-1.2826081514,
0.7692941427,
-0.1941598952,
-0.2705681324,
0.0965991318,
0.9752395749,
0.1460242867,
0.0528062657,
0.5279104114,
0.671682179,
0.563252449,
0.1812984496,
1.0371354818,
-0.3420274258,
0.4444887042,
1.2804778814,
-0.3145395219,
1.0658797026,
0.7696075439,
-0.2548746765,
0.3211691082,
0.6363273263,
0.4761541784,
0.5889629722,
0.2728615403,
-0.3850926459,
-0.1636937708,
-0.0172193833,
-0.3828745782,
0.1914332658,
0.1056236476,
-0.3118183315,
-0.0199337956,
-0.2171551287,
0.1367310733,
-0.377127558,
-0.4662138522,
0.6316484809,
0.3907130063,
-0.7310907245,
0.6364663243,
0.1053046212,
0.8808039427,
-0.7685738802,
0.4267537594,
-0.3791690171,
0.2998084426,
0.0629446357,
-0.3633402586,
0.3113616407,
0.1508238912,
-0.2944333553,
-0.0201053303,
0.3278678954,
-0.7223411202,
-0.3716251552,
0.4049380422,
0.025352452,
0.055024229,
-0.4471289515,
-0.2777998745,
0.2102232575,
-0.0805730075,
-0.6052769423,
0.8564326167,
0.3253667355,
-0.1119690463,
0.6196940541,
0.4452730715,
0.0206866395,
0.2591204047,
-0.0071620671,
0.9323558211,
-0.6278048158,
-0.5524994731,
-0.8944420815,
0.3826446235,
0.1646537036,
-0.2392807454,
0.5728975534,
0.5850198865,
0.7442795634,
-0.0583985746,
0.576433301,
0.0756390244,
0.1416513026,
-0.562048912,
0.6430200338,
-0.7149317861,
-0.1124313697,
0.0187283382,
-1.071606636,
-0.3479236662,
0.1995836198,
-0.2038171738,
-0.0221564062,
0.7252312303,
0.5487923026,
-0.2930434942,
-0.3063880503,
0.3776489198,
0.120363906,
0.4469515681,
0.8725397587,
0.4545727372,
-0.1617687196,
0.5044218898,
-0.0792885125,
-0.312220186,
-0.3056368828,
-0.7800154686,
-1.077529192,
-0.4599207044,
-0.148058787,
-0.223193422,
-0.2236477882,
0.9031207561,
1.0124146938,
-0.795118928,
-0.2514193654,
0.055754222,
-0.1422264576,
-0.1088428423,
-0.2020966411,
0.6081783772,
-0.5529004931,
-1.0945812464,
0.7584050894,
0.528957665,
0.1349041909,
-0.5250675082,
0.0948000029,
-0.0200861506,
0.3342558742,
0.8241314888,
0.1263311654,
-0.7353399992,
-0.3295100033,
-0.3422659934,
-0.2473521978,
0.0993758813,
0.7300698757,
-0.6046028733,
0.3448344469,
0.323163569,
0.6809918284,
0.5359761715,
0.1012944952,
0.5106909275,
-0.7965219617,
0.6546294093,
-0.0569006093,
0.1856001019,
0.4396516681,
-0.3674018681,
0.4101861119,
-0.0299204513,
-0.5867885351,
-0.9289848208,
0.2004002482,
-1.3406569958,
-0.2496027052,
1.579579711,
-0.1795800328,
-0.4931532145,
0.0629799888,
-0.2599225938,
0.2011602521,
-0.5702063441,
0.832234323,
0.6926813722,
0.2795407176,
0.1310193986,
-0.4301956296,
0.4120476544,
0.4954310358,
-0.8167886734,
0.4658016562,
0.4471127391,
0.4159354568,
-0.0315253735,
0.8603858948,
-0.127888903,
0.0951493904,
-0.0941049904,
-0.00422714,
-0.0758709833,
-0.6571691036,
-0.6320299506,
0.4273984432,
0.1816421598,
0.0300766509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17456v1
|
A Piece of Theatre: Investigating How Teachers Design LLM Chatbots to Assist Adolescent Cyberbullying Education
| 2024-02-27T12:27:51 | 2024-02-27T12:27:51 |
Michael A. Hedderich, Natalie N. Bazarova, Wenting Zou, Ryun Shim, Xinda Ma, Qian Yang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Cyberbullying harms teenagers' mental health, and teaching them upstanding
intervention is crucial. Wizard-of-Oz studies show chatbots can scale up
personalized and interactive cyberbullying education, but implementing such
chatbots is a challenging and delicate task. We created a no-code chatbot
design tool for K-12 teachers. Using large language models and prompt chaining,
our tool allows teachers to prototype bespoke dialogue flows and chatbot
utterances. In offering this tool, we explore teachers' distinctive needs when
designing chatbots to assist their teaching, and how chatbot design tools might
better support them. Our findings reveal that teachers welcome the tool
enthusiastically. Moreover, they see themselves as playwrights guiding both the
students' and the chatbot's behaviors, while allowing for some improvisation.
Their goal is to enable students to rehearse both desirable and undesirable
reactions to cyberbullying in a safe environment. We discuss the design
opportunities LLM-Chains offer for empowering teachers and the research
opportunities this work opens up.
|
[
-0.2304043919,
-0.8879680037,
0.2584627271,
0.2383990586,
-0.1641499847,
0.718775332,
0.0885295048,
-0.1587379873,
0.4118389189,
0.5749253035,
-0.5834032893,
-0.2657932341,
-0.5494889617,
-0.0156007428,
-0.6994800568,
0.9159879088,
0.1413439959,
0.2159789056,
-0.2211933881,
0.5827093124,
-0.6409701109,
-0.0368548967,
-0.7735590339,
-0.1725501567,
0.7094583511,
0.8261329532,
0.6311813593,
0.0491863638,
0.5521993041,
0.4069160521,
0.1231506243,
0.0277680364,
-0.7742170691,
0.2663255036,
-0.3751001358,
-0.4708617032,
-0.2058448792,
-0.2238382995,
0.3194288611,
0.4252783358,
-0.0885630623,
-0.1214347705,
0.2891409695,
0.3117412627,
-0.2719678283,
-0.2932273746,
-0.4102136493,
0.4884292185,
0.1684670746,
-0.147533983,
-0.2643527985,
-0.691811502,
-0.1036961526,
-0.4991376102,
-0.3144573867,
0.0046350271,
0.400321275,
0.1787553132,
-0.502142787,
-0.3479154408,
-0.7944841981,
0.2868333757,
-0.379521668,
0.0203472711,
0.379552722,
0.5001453757,
-0.420637399,
-0.8385571837,
-0.3127110302,
0.0329050235,
0.1476552337,
0.1892792732,
-0.160034731,
0.3645465076,
0.0147698764,
0.4199607968,
-0.5837551951,
0.3926400542,
-0.767043829,
-0.2680386603,
0.5754756927,
0.4381946027,
0.4994334579,
-0.1664714813,
-0.4456087053,
-0.1043583676,
-0.5304268003,
0.1194001809,
0.4758675992,
0.201958701,
-0.4566507638,
0.46589908,
0.196758762,
0.4091442525,
0.0187320765,
-0.3088087738,
-0.4482403696,
-0.0288598854,
-0.0464607812,
0.2785142362,
0.9097049832,
0.6978126168,
0.5459463596,
-0.1357595772,
0.014012468,
0.3153322339,
0.6075801849,
-0.9795588255,
-0.5547932982,
0.1372915357,
-0.0660255775,
-0.7646644711,
-0.1986386478,
-0.8992113471,
-0.883792758,
-0.1188584641,
0.8186006546,
-0.2990270555,
-0.3645308912,
-0.2688348591,
-0.4706989825,
-0.3024861515,
0.1002843082,
-0.7646515965,
0.4717027545,
0.5723300576,
0.7716227174,
0.1650277972,
-0.0158700161,
-0.1610821933,
-0.2301774621,
-0.5540979505,
0.7681103945,
-0.8195531964,
-0.7853886485,
0.0794012845,
0.1550629586,
0.075285323,
-0.3454629481,
0.3163107336,
-0.0007274131,
0.2215331942,
0.5915785432,
-0.5080530047,
0.1768275946,
0.2003364265,
-0.2509269714,
0.4487924278,
-0.022910893,
-0.319888562,
-0.1000283882,
-0.4847024381,
-0.4528764784,
0.1784234345,
-0.250916034,
-0.0863699466,
0.1700419039,
0.1824254394,
0.3370135128,
-0.2850531638,
0.1274446398,
-0.3015008867,
-0.6585761905,
0.5887167454,
-0.3592916429,
0.5961775184,
0.1163802892,
-0.0166129898,
0.2740544677,
-0.558144629,
0.1995743811,
0.0835359618,
0.0405291952,
0.1385494918,
-0.0670583397,
0.130982846,
0.3839249611,
-0.0372305252,
-0.4673549533,
0.0282379389,
-0.2951306105,
0.4924501777,
1.0670138597,
0.0119555024,
0.2784701884,
-0.8257485628,
1.0647217035,
-0.2429570854,
0.3016494811,
-0.1710451096,
-0.397164464,
-0.5026260614,
-0.3058828413,
0.1096865833,
0.5557905436,
-0.8319051266,
0.0310537685,
0.1072477624,
-0.6846742034,
-0.8576868773,
0.0955969617,
0.3578532636,
0.3617251515,
-0.1913432926,
-0.5063458085,
-0.8355781436,
-0.642629087,
-0.1334169358,
-0.1524920315,
-0.2480303198,
0.2563937306,
0.1354765147,
0.1591798812,
0.836600244,
-0.3146742284,
-0.2871304154,
-0.1258351505,
-0.0308207851,
0.1836216599,
0.348739028,
0.2492425144,
-0.5296043158,
-0.7946358323,
-0.1781867892,
-0.5852047205,
-0.3714106381,
-0.1079750955,
-0.0110430177,
-0.3605808318,
0.3416992724,
-0.3409922421,
0.5761072636,
0.5604881048,
-0.2951312959,
0.5803033113,
0.0878372937,
0.1892630756,
-0.7920161486,
-0.1655141711,
-0.2364275903,
-0.308136493,
-0.9502742887,
-0.1699660867,
-0.4008228481,
-0.7231661081,
-0.7085961699,
0.4113225937,
0.0383748859,
0.2366006523,
-0.7254611254,
0.8192768097,
-0.1014875248,
0.3891749978,
-0.1600351334,
0.592348218,
0.6342142224,
-0.7221845984,
0.4953807592,
0.1901573241,
-0.3567007482,
1.2540079355,
-0.7187173367,
0.3643201888,
0.0873791352,
0.2474623024,
-1.1532655954,
-0.2313855439,
0.5996950269,
-0.7217706442,
0.0534584597,
-0.2891226411,
-0.5465687513,
-0.7218821049,
-0.2648897171,
-0.1361304969,
0.370079428,
-0.3761005402,
0.1806943417,
0.9690841436,
-0.2540135384,
-0.1920450181,
-0.6082298756,
0.2867254317,
-0.366651684,
-0.6485424638,
0.4843533337,
-0.4681348205,
-0.2475010455,
-0.1221712157,
-0.1582071334,
-0.3631383479,
0.3605697453,
0.5705117583,
0.0054989932,
0.051502943,
0.1351414025,
0.0150192995,
-0.081582658,
0.1657025218,
0.1208952963,
0.7255669236,
0.227681607,
-0.1446995288,
-0.6507707834,
0.1805848181,
0.2987036407,
0.4588336349,
0.223552987,
0.6040869355,
-0.336258322,
-0.1307763159,
-0.2425038368,
-0.4323069155,
-0.5664075613,
-0.0460379086,
-0.0417092405,
-1.1915813684,
0.1191704497,
-0.2292950898,
0.0852575451,
-0.3665438294,
0.5508800745,
-0.3022236228,
0.6540757418,
0.3707881272,
0.1381251365,
0.6451518536,
0.100199379,
0.3888610005,
-0.5467586517,
-0.0996772051,
-0.1525003761,
-0.7657576203,
-0.6348879933,
-0.1011699513,
0.4087507129,
-0.22298114,
-0.3057605624,
0.4146572649,
-0.7141599655,
0.5259594321,
0.4266315401,
0.3408903182,
-0.0691635162,
-0.1959804595,
-0.1153396145,
0.0287957024,
-0.5860825181,
-0.4743202627,
0.8343131542,
0.1500666589,
0.8962927461,
0.4614933729,
0.7254923582,
0.2518378794,
0.0644638687,
-0.5894029737,
0.6688443422,
0.1473456323,
-0.9569448829,
-0.3440686464,
-0.065436475,
-1.2212474346,
0.4528230727,
-0.3029615283,
-1.0949875116,
-0.2009127289,
0.0512740985,
-0.4567327499,
0.2870250046,
-0.7012168765,
0.7729766369,
0.0691174194,
-0.6943294406,
-0.4808916152,
-0.5773095489,
0.2661478221,
-0.0167592596,
0.4736883938,
0.0462301336,
0.3560660183,
0.5158804655,
-0.5495632887,
1.488484621,
0.1371453404,
-0.1208858937,
0.7449424863,
0.4621692896,
0.2229112685,
-0.2076389641,
0.1259244829,
-0.5646261573,
0.0794788375,
-0.2042818367,
-0.5778053403,
0.8963459134,
-0.6097254157,
-0.95507586,
-0.1594902575,
-0.4061833918,
-0.0373021923,
0.0410987325,
-0.3028409183,
0.2454768568,
-0.180043593,
0.4841325879,
0.3018283546,
-0.0699149743,
0.6636104584,
0.4045000672,
-0.5333607197,
-0.6532995105,
1.0940785408,
0.0760143474,
0.2132565826,
0.3479227722,
0.4656203985,
-0.1938823014,
0.1720747948,
-0.2306084335,
-0.1786313355,
-0.4856541455,
-0.1886614859,
-0.3449043036,
-0.4469097555,
-0.4773068726,
-0.5545496345,
-0.0086213173,
-0.5663670897,
-0.3272447586,
-0.3537485003,
0.6185774207,
0.9163500667,
-0.6036832333,
0.8561869264,
-0.5299580693,
0.0853993893,
0.6761533022,
0.2470019609,
0.1832007319,
-0.6633776426,
-0.1440800577,
-0.315404892,
-1.0957261324,
-0.8928323388,
0.4126390517,
-0.0061732675,
0.0961851031,
0.48490116,
0.2282431424,
0.627014339,
-0.5532316566,
0.8542548418,
0.431317687,
-0.6201886535,
0.4946195483,
-0.2725383639,
0.1631233245,
0.0897645801,
0.4557797015,
-1.0910331011,
-0.4622972608,
-0.8063089848,
-0.5202682018,
0.7287208438,
0.1700965911,
0.5473781824,
-0.0984494984,
-0.3891916871,
0.0313865095,
0.7355794907,
-0.5976709127,
-0.2992100418,
-0.2576161921,
-0.2126075476,
0.1171478108,
-0.3864277005,
-0.350451082,
0.2272100747,
0.3934565485,
0.1424769908,
0.2713931203,
-0.1788236201,
0.0121137733,
-0.1810668856,
0.3181431592,
0.3637633026,
0.5260485411,
0.1530002654,
0.3794720471,
0.149374947,
-0.3918171525,
0.2270444036,
-0.3253344893,
0.3902554512,
-0.2085247934,
0.0049371659,
0.7375099063,
0.6185434461,
-0.7017217875,
0.5257345438,
0.0465281457,
-0.176602453,
-0.4596394002,
0.4109382629,
0.1371697783,
0.5505722165,
-0.0189635679,
-0.5074024796,
0.0106097246,
-0.4793915451,
0.5162563324,
0.1495212018,
-0.494395107,
-0.3442274332,
0.5205271244,
0.3846909106,
-1.2602725029,
0.4695338011,
0.0669815391,
-0.3386934996,
0.5690985918,
0.8631469011,
0.7411778569,
-0.3553308249,
0.7954823971,
-0.0066758818,
0.1794834137,
0.5878366828,
0.2122649401,
0.0483656153,
-0.4176145792,
-0.0422753915,
0.0258703865,
-0.8669621944,
0.008029745,
0.0032882064,
0.4475723803,
-0.9912410975,
-0.2156658024,
-0.157867983,
-0.1396134943,
-0.4399484098,
0.251393646,
0.1961196512,
0.347707212,
-0.5026026964,
0.2879196405,
0.3800555468,
-0.2737649381,
-0.2438292652,
-0.3607188463,
0.5986830592,
-0.9236325622,
0.3305875659,
0.0777427107,
0.1504298002,
0.1068160236,
-0.5876043439,
-0.576752007,
0.8312762976,
0.0249583963,
-0.5876982808,
0.0781328604,
0.5252960324,
0.6797229648,
-0.3664221168,
0.7384011745,
0.0186860282,
0.1764856726,
0.3338870406,
-0.8065734506,
-0.1950499564,
-0.093197979,
-0.1674852371,
0.1257261634,
-0.7939901352,
0.2794688046,
0.0560493097,
-0.2545471787,
0.1422597915,
0.3335769773,
0.186486274,
0.2966339886,
0.3320513964,
0.3155903518,
0.8168359399,
0.0751734227,
0.6264610887,
-0.4715180099,
-0.1548976153,
0.9293599725,
0.2524430454,
0.5115451813,
0.3123190701,
-0.1998298019,
0.6219400764,
0.5849763155,
0.1493021399,
0.3310616314,
0.9639315009,
-0.573160708,
-0.2382317185,
-0.6759912968,
0.024197964,
0.1825479716,
0.5194944143,
0.0324038677,
-0.069050923,
0.2555138767,
0.4796649814,
0.1909838021,
-0.359965682,
0.4886386096,
0.5798732638,
-0.3841241598,
0.1925151199,
-0.4678069949,
0.3966679573,
-0.3685141802,
0.1414993107,
-0.0988392979,
0.1141543388,
-0.1772432923,
-1.0381044149,
-0.0284459461,
-0.0910936445,
0.4193137288,
-0.2138409019,
0.7450443506,
-0.2592245936,
-0.4753308594,
0.0269236639,
0.128181234,
0.5381118655,
0.3161040545,
-0.7375786901,
0.2510846853,
-0.2899300754,
0.3110375106,
0.4907223284,
0.6437358856,
0.2029775083,
0.8630285859,
0.395439595,
-0.2178610861,
-0.2685623169,
0.080539003,
0.9048079252,
-0.5609284639,
-0.2747221291,
-0.7538632751,
1.0211029053,
-0.2319452018,
-0.3539457619,
0.6233212948,
0.1957276314,
0.6857987642,
-0.0455269367,
0.437363565,
-0.1334036738,
0.5053557754,
-0.0910753757,
0.5673272014,
-0.3530115187,
-0.1466588676,
-0.5205392241,
-0.4858346283,
-0.2314604819,
0.5909369588,
-0.0654648021,
-0.1343125403,
0.5816155076,
0.9626861811,
0.3116974831,
0.2422840148,
0.7889355421,
0.1966542751,
0.5208286643,
0.5017948747,
1.1974531412,
-0.2806454897,
0.769461453,
-0.4018408656,
-0.1679163724,
-0.2736408412,
-0.4917917848,
-1.4172513485,
-0.39222911,
-0.3827899992,
-0.3576847017,
0.3754742444,
1.0570622683,
0.4694381058,
-0.3303731382,
-0.645419538,
0.0313491412,
0.6711418629,
0.1286932975,
-0.2398625165,
-0.2273490876,
-0.353724122,
-0.7823800445,
0.7515053153,
-0.0221587736,
0.0927159116,
-0.4347401857,
0.3343961537,
-0.1344091594,
0.3045706153,
0.7035710812,
0.1759626418,
-0.4553510547,
-0.4124335051,
-0.14659971,
0.0651864931,
-0.0613207258,
0.5146195292,
-0.5475977659,
0.5763231516,
0.3391425312,
0.5919567347,
0.2910642624,
-0.4177003205,
0.5936415195,
-0.6984380484,
-0.0827991739,
0.1159035191,
-0.0195031203,
0.2516036034,
-0.1085517108,
0.6607163548,
0.30326882,
-0.7261503935,
-0.9309942722,
0.0963324234,
-0.4105752409,
-0.2247577608,
0.7884050012,
0.0466698408,
-0.3329016864,
0.0782191083,
-0.6235927939,
0.0135465264,
-0.4176687002,
0.8199902773,
0.7708294392,
0.2014377713,
-0.6358567476,
-0.3367109299,
0.2870982587,
-0.0212405529,
-0.3638872802,
-0.4657877088,
0.1666542888,
0.0104903635,
-0.0478154011,
0.3407193422,
0.0649338141,
0.1409410089,
0.0746977627,
0.1241157949,
0.2616097927,
-0.5851988196,
-0.1225193739,
0.2260040343,
-0.0944054425,
-0.1837345511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17447v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17447v2
|
Deep Learning Based Named Entity Recognition Models for Recipes
| 2024-02-27T12:03:56 | 2024-06-06T07:41:21 |
Mansi Goel, Ayush Agarwal, Shubham Agrawal, Janak Kapuriya, Akhil Vamshi Konam, Rishabh Gupta, Shrey Rastogi, Niharika, Ganesh Bagler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Food touches our lives through various endeavors, including flavor,
nourishment, health, and sustainability. Recipes are cultural capsules
transmitted across generations via unstructured text. Automated protocols for
recognizing named entities, the building blocks of recipe text, are of immense
value for various applications ranging from information extraction to novel
recipe generation. Named entity recognition is a technique for extracting
information from unstructured or semi-structured data with known labels.
Starting with manually-annotated data of 6,611 ingredient phrases, we created
an augmented dataset of 26,445 phrases cumulatively. Simultaneously, we
systematically cleaned and analyzed ingredient phrases from RecipeDB, the
gold-standard recipe data repository, and annotated them using the Stanford
NER. Based on the analysis, we sampled a subset of 88,526 phrases using a
clustering-based approach while preserving the diversity to create the
machine-annotated dataset. A thorough investigation of NER approaches on these
three datasets involving statistical, fine-tuning of deep learning-based
language models and few-shot prompting on large language models (LLMs) provides
deep insights. We conclude that few-shot prompting on LLMs has abysmal
performance, whereas the fine-tuned spaCy-transformer emerges as the best model
with macro-F1 scores of 95.9%, 96.04%, and 95.71% for the manually-annotated,
augmented, and machine-annotated datasets, respectively.
|
[
-0.2265148014,
-0.9411355257,
0.4240558147,
-0.0150706237,
0.087836884,
0.0068889763,
-0.285333693,
-0.4890731275,
0.1447624266,
0.7727279663,
-0.596752882,
-0.6044080257,
-0.6948829293,
0.526267767,
-0.4553703666,
0.920373559,
-0.114931874,
0.2815194726,
0.051527191,
0.0423523076,
-0.5602593422,
-0.2840693295,
-0.7431056499,
-0.2905773222,
0.5885686278,
0.5433513522,
0.293509841,
0.7107847929,
0.5110161901,
0.2159116715,
-0.2861976624,
0.4785788655,
-0.1772842109,
0.4105499387,
0.0673410222,
-0.3071679771,
-0.211362198,
-0.1133864522,
0.3706003129,
0.831122458,
0.2230146676,
0.2093936652,
0.1139044985,
0.6840724349,
-0.4020448327,
0.1909344941,
-0.8817061782,
0.2735009491,
-0.1642577052,
-0.0788328573,
-0.3119348884,
-0.3388701379,
0.237659052,
-0.5359229445,
0.2315112054,
-0.0270730201,
0.7339689732,
0.2229180336,
-0.2971172631,
-0.5384198427,
-0.8664899468,
0.7979522347,
-0.7784506679,
0.3600239158,
0.3849801123,
0.224722445,
-0.7246047258,
-0.6796680689,
-0.7605522275,
-0.1672193408,
0.1277062744,
-0.184948191,
-0.0316822343,
-0.1815772802,
0.357534498,
0.3174106479,
-0.4040856063,
0.5188288689,
-0.0719026774,
0.1499516517,
0.5176099539,
0.3981616795,
0.3932991326,
-0.2827402949,
-0.4399162829,
0.0673026294,
-0.7871643901,
0.0494241677,
0.0072910702,
0.5508397818,
0.1537604928,
0.669146359,
-0.4110022783,
0.726010859,
0.238091886,
-0.1989598572,
0.0909098759,
-0.1012883261,
-0.4756736457,
0.211945489,
0.8098092675,
0.4818378091,
0.374591887,
-0.1526328921,
-0.1153412834,
-0.1661564857,
-0.1291898787,
-0.8173061609,
-0.4889041185,
-0.1295539141,
-0.1980552226,
-0.1620595008,
-0.0019985419,
-0.6901528835,
-0.7836059928,
-0.2556025386,
0.0757911056,
-0.3577732146,
-0.0010990164,
-0.2053139657,
-0.2426993698,
0.5449165702,
0.3290567398,
-1.0791912079,
0.4321898818,
0.7492331266,
0.6402335167,
-0.0029818793,
-0.2161202431,
-0.455935359,
0.1637412161,
-0.3870387375,
0.9033676982,
-0.7874096632,
-0.3210881352,
-0.3487624526,
0.3679075539,
-0.0615550503,
-0.8474596739,
0.4170292616,
-0.506059885,
-0.2166546881,
-0.6464967728,
-1.1500066519,
-0.2191721648,
0.2783432305,
-0.8998632431,
0.8590555787,
-0.2691911757,
-0.486681968,
0.9325965047,
-0.3228744566,
-0.6078475714,
0.4563022852,
-0.4306649268,
-0.3052161336,
0.2851050496,
0.4155301452,
0.6725113392,
-0.517796874,
0.3222005069,
-0.2262390256,
-0.2467846721,
0.4448596537,
-0.6041586399,
0.2495371848,
0.2485467792,
-0.2153594643,
-0.0898084342,
-0.821485579,
0.0230489504,
0.2915959358,
-0.3700049222,
-0.3687257469,
-0.0143719837,
0.0926401764,
-0.0828983709,
-0.2408890575,
-0.3534598947,
0.3239216506,
-0.5099964738,
0.4992034137,
0.5414415002,
0.2950594425,
0.4921918809,
-0.0339619294,
0.2079297155,
0.1801150292,
-0.2478003502,
-0.2988260984,
-0.6232875586,
-0.7917433381,
-0.2025944144,
0.607609868,
0.7550744414,
-0.5303030014,
0.5227180719,
-0.1894369423,
-0.4640749991,
-0.380974859,
0.2616659701,
0.1366520822,
0.6445320845,
0.3868952096,
-0.1140781641,
-0.6392903924,
-0.768684864,
-0.352465719,
0.3512176275,
-0.0218033139,
0.4073624015,
0.5904994011,
-0.1701281816,
0.6913376451,
-0.4697425067,
-0.3043056726,
-0.5394515991,
0.1648040414,
0.4310349822,
0.5076622367,
0.1557171047,
-0.6580929756,
-0.7777162194,
0.1604623646,
-0.7978124022,
0.2305275202,
-0.0874456689,
0.2925559282,
0.1432776898,
0.4455890954,
-0.6659786105,
0.3971239328,
0.1602516472,
0.0278615989,
0.1771774739,
0.2070278078,
0.1671068221,
-1.2228301764,
-0.2535942495,
0.1432853192,
0.1770576239,
-0.5596627593,
-0.2751142681,
0.0499685146,
-0.106766358,
-0.5804258585,
0.8013703823,
-0.6550364494,
0.0497394949,
-0.2401297837,
-0.3988155723,
0.1580992788,
0.2153772116,
0.3085550368,
0.5231822133,
0.4912545979,
-0.6754049063,
0.5362015367,
-0.0377318971,
-0.5509367585,
0.4852141738,
-0.5873129368,
0.1614611,
-0.1450035721,
0.2334942669,
-0.7782473564,
-0.4053415954,
0.5098930597,
-0.3349383175,
0.5393205285,
-0.3708384931,
-0.7826185226,
-0.2525274754,
0.0902746394,
0.2174032331,
0.1573220193,
-0.534363687,
0.5664697886,
0.3030274212,
-0.0411468148,
-0.3293576539,
-0.7124816775,
0.3192542493,
-0.2715685666,
-0.1668191254,
0.2167395949,
0.0552468114,
-0.017427776,
0.0902092233,
-0.1530561,
-0.2726196945,
0.0783708468,
0.4989339411,
0.0760005042,
-0.2722090781,
0.2625027299,
0.2005915195,
-0.14656201,
-0.1823125482,
-0.2606977522,
0.4027200341,
-0.1153952628,
0.1748326719,
-0.5792489052,
0.3369067013,
0.2392553538,
-0.1406159252,
0.9281342626,
0.6958690882,
-0.7706300616,
-0.1080426946,
-0.5547869802,
-0.2182413638,
-0.4279069006,
0.1005291045,
-0.5542222857,
-0.7614569664,
0.3901050091,
-0.25841102,
-0.1889332086,
0.438079834,
0.2670487165,
-0.2047238201,
0.5960300565,
0.3110344708,
-0.1376321018,
0.2236313224,
-0.1242532581,
0.1249201223,
-0.7502695322,
-0.4497030973,
-0.4819926918,
-0.324688822,
-0.6803019047,
-0.3650384545,
0.0538876392,
-0.0885067061,
-0.1545922309,
0.5084109306,
-0.6099112034,
0.8948795795,
0.4809119701,
-0.0943513885,
0.1756091863,
0.1083214954,
-0.3505406976,
-0.2645932138,
-0.4083853662,
-0.5536651015,
0.8563542366,
0.2662546039,
0.9222013354,
-0.1890063137,
0.9875301719,
0.2246371955,
-0.0324036069,
-1.0010510683,
0.656837225,
-0.2871801257,
-0.5842395425,
-0.3463512659,
-0.5530977249,
-0.8957610726,
-0.1156346202,
-0.4310008585,
-0.6420408487,
0.1422906667,
-0.002513834,
-0.4844412208,
0.3787456155,
-0.9706215858,
0.9026404619,
-0.5789616108,
-0.171869874,
0.6155102849,
-0.4854846895,
-0.0124243181,
0.143545717,
-0.0359234698,
-0.0891034901,
0.1789539456,
0.6965277791,
-0.056481503,
0.9781845808,
0.0289592743,
0.1367975324,
0.0417220332,
0.1331249923,
0.5532981157,
0.1934700608,
-0.0547323264,
0.2489490211,
-0.1228818595,
-0.0684187338,
-0.7528380752,
1.072958231,
-0.3947256207,
-0.2545771003,
-0.4410987198,
-0.1580456942,
0.132584393,
0.498966068,
0.4431562424,
0.1328656375,
-0.2142872065,
0.189857021,
0.7304869294,
-0.279846251,
0.3164537847,
0.436626941,
0.046346195,
-0.4345885217,
0.9347144961,
0.3239920735,
-0.2614274323,
0.7511069775,
-0.0216942858,
0.1063531786,
-0.3997279108,
-0.5107111335,
-0.0201988723,
-0.5720787644,
-0.4254801273,
-0.726287961,
-0.2754129171,
-0.3542513847,
-0.1272320896,
-0.3600692451,
-0.2259499282,
-0.7934085131,
-0.370492667,
0.3338270783,
0.7064902782,
0.3585427999,
-0.0144965509,
-0.8158608079,
0.3231245577,
0.1615587026,
0.3434309959,
0.1378644854,
-0.1729842126,
-0.1331236511,
-0.0582824498,
-0.1065555438,
-1.0626715422,
0.6871352196,
0.3469642103,
0.4386707246,
0.2487555593,
-0.0690776557,
0.6474793553,
-0.642724812,
0.7052707672,
0.0451332442,
-0.6911087036,
0.6896826029,
0.1456977576,
0.2652143836,
0.590639472,
0.5485069752,
-0.5069658756,
-0.023346629,
-0.2497696728,
-1.1109896898,
0.2607010305,
-0.0713497251,
0.1821810156,
-0.455249548,
0.4572618306,
0.464220494,
0.1332971752,
-0.734578371,
-0.2100497484,
0.0373612419,
-0.2061557174,
0.2439091206,
-0.1756227165,
0.2659902871,
-0.4322806299,
0.6308327317,
0.1178128347,
0.0704635829,
-0.019292634,
-0.162361607,
-0.1843373626,
0.5732230544,
0.3609381914,
0.1188116446,
-0.1916966587,
0.1784745455,
0.3865394592,
-0.1526274532,
0.0860478356,
0.2268792093,
-0.22161071,
-0.0347992033,
0.3308430314,
0.8539168835,
0.1805386841,
-0.45860672,
0.0834832415,
-0.3917378783,
0.0575037524,
-0.5854356289,
0.2390466481,
0.0127125839,
0.4121589661,
0.379835397,
-0.0856683925,
0.4609621465,
-0.3629712462,
0.1410727203,
0.4724529386,
-0.3738472164,
-0.2296225876,
0.3111162484,
0.1394918561,
-0.1293250322,
0.9470912814,
-0.1955434084,
-0.2363652885,
0.6871652603,
0.5892004967,
0.8518355489,
-0.0797356442,
0.224520728,
0.3599459231,
0.3126305044,
-0.0380453691,
0.0467825495,
-0.1100943983,
-0.7149565816,
-0.0084477626,
-0.788782239,
-0.2856098115,
0.5047376752,
-0.4977832735,
0.2755040228,
-0.4863957465,
-0.2491107285,
0.5641390085,
0.034571711,
-1.0758852959,
0.3385608792,
0.4885974526,
0.7391865253,
-1.0093601942,
0.5817847848,
0.8689188361,
-0.5019475222,
-0.8812467456,
0.0373283438,
0.0948329866,
-0.5810742974,
0.8207813501,
0.434325844,
0.2975484431,
-0.0946786702,
-0.565969348,
-0.8139954805,
0.8521903753,
0.2250865847,
-0.7103251219,
-0.2583920658,
0.234183982,
0.5030786395,
-0.5340764523,
0.0905224681,
0.4346581995,
0.5320878625,
0.3822708726,
-0.6531965137,
0.0331504941,
-0.3213064075,
0.1606777757,
0.2189581394,
-0.0786020085,
0.6100800633,
-0.3612932861,
-0.3723756075,
0.1940312982,
0.7170993686,
0.0705176294,
0.651779294,
-0.0367300399,
0.6325829029,
0.7048510313,
-0.1536758095,
0.8111517429,
0.1076014563,
0.2599992454,
1.4056791067,
-0.6191372871,
0.7320431471,
0.4521881938,
0.0515788272,
0.3428557813,
0.776815474,
-0.5172598958,
0.7122550607,
0.2164150476,
-0.0945513695,
-0.0385001376,
-0.3056664765,
-0.3500696421,
0.3720394373,
0.5576481223,
-0.8691479564,
-0.1561838686,
0.0877919346,
0.0767623633,
-0.1458104402,
-0.0734787583,
1.2055399418,
0.3779202104,
-0.4559301734,
0.4507457018,
0.030364072,
0.2761371434,
-0.1524420083,
-0.4430394769,
-0.2162578553,
-0.0355759822,
-0.3401570916,
-0.7716506124,
-0.0334130041,
0.0404380187,
-0.4272343516,
0.1925382912,
0.7407935262,
-0.4118143022,
-0.8110559583,
0.1077689976,
0.3357715905,
0.0847174004,
0.0248963032,
-0.5962976813,
0.0979542211,
-0.4216980636,
-0.0948547795,
0.1848428547,
0.5932933688,
0.2339241952,
0.3454014659,
0.555083096,
0.1045463905,
0.0899460763,
0.1464902908,
0.8951832652,
-0.9726971388,
-0.3407846987,
-1.0234179497,
0.3061138988,
0.0702255219,
-0.139322117,
0.7461451292,
0.4507327974,
1.0064747334,
-0.3446079195,
0.6757099032,
0.0951369628,
0.4620104432,
-0.8323616385,
0.4393675029,
-0.4089277983,
0.5847436786,
-0.3941933513,
-0.9279132485,
-0.44395715,
0.4585503042,
-0.4975783229,
0.1930007041,
0.3568303585,
0.7304287553,
-0.0616425462,
0.0359232314,
0.2800362408,
0.1361574233,
0.1323082596,
0.4984950125,
0.8458142281,
-0.4022610188,
-0.0754871517,
-0.1012279391,
0.0535681881,
-0.3291440606,
-0.9502144456,
-0.9020705223,
-0.3595466912,
-0.2963369489,
-0.0183333922,
0.3079828322,
1.2247931957,
0.683124423,
-0.9928506017,
0.0809824392,
-0.2681714296,
0.2193948328,
-0.4201655388,
-0.2718555033,
0.2198270261,
-0.0972211808,
-0.4984808564,
0.6248649359,
0.3020551205,
0.0751390755,
0.1735998392,
0.0373986624,
-0.0713604391,
0.0355503373,
0.5704871416,
0.5114569664,
-0.8966895938,
0.0599774942,
0.084973827,
0.0455827154,
-0.0196584947,
0.6253297329,
-0.6864300966,
0.4671786726,
0.2301332206,
0.8297070861,
0.2729209661,
-0.2644540966,
0.1994957477,
-0.8374388218,
-0.2955563366,
0.2065255493,
0.2965595126,
0.5666200519,
-0.633836031,
0.2747482657,
0.1006115675,
-0.5210582614,
-0.7051275969,
0.2548984587,
-0.8909286261,
-0.1204204857,
1.0794036388,
0.0010628903,
-0.4043601155,
0.1536666602,
0.1015971899,
0.3970407844,
-0.6275727749,
0.5144349337,
0.3690465093,
-0.2127902657,
-0.4917543232,
-0.4931536615,
0.3027871847,
-0.0044540125,
-0.746540904,
-0.2040165067,
0.6241525412,
0.4928023815,
-0.0405067801,
0.2375684232,
0.1063962355,
0.0619832575,
-0.2906472385,
-0.0957218483,
-0.084976472,
-0.6915208697,
-0.2353134453,
0.152385205,
0.2004963011,
-0.1059549227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17437v1
|
Exploiting Emotion-Semantic Correlations for Empathetic Response Generation
| 2024-02-27T11:50:05 | 2024-02-27T11:50:05 |
Zhou Yang, Zhaochun Ren, Yufeng Wang, Xiaofei Zhu, Zhihao Chen, Tiecheng Cai, Yunbing Wu, Yisong Su, Sibo Ju, Xiangwen Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Empathetic response generation aims to generate empathetic responses by
understanding the speaker's emotional feelings from the language of dialogue.
Recent methods capture emotional words in the language of communicators and
construct them as static vectors to perceive nuanced emotions. However,
linguistic research has shown that emotional words in language are dynamic and
have correlations with other grammar semantic roles, i.e., words with semantic
meanings, in grammar. Previous methods overlook these two characteristics,
which easily lead to misunderstandings of emotions and neglect of key
semantics. To address this issue, we propose a dynamical Emotion-Semantic
Correlation Model (ESCM) for empathetic dialogue generation tasks. ESCM
constructs dynamic emotion-semantic vectors through the interaction of context
and emotions. We introduce dependency trees to reflect the correlations between
emotions and semantics. Based on dynamic emotion-semantic vectors and
dependency trees, we propose a dynamic correlation graph convolutional network
to guide the model in learning context meanings in dialogue and generating
empathetic responses. Experimental results on the EMPATHETIC-DIALOGUES dataset
show that ESCM understands semantics and emotions more accurately and expresses
fluent and informative empathetic responses. Our analysis results also indicate
that the correlations between emotions and semantics are frequently used in
dialogues, which is of great significance for empathetic perception and
expression.
|
[
-0.3204505146,
-1.072779417,
0.6804970503,
0.3190302551,
-0.2699588239,
0.0116059277,
-0.0951595604,
-0.2871852517,
0.5716454983,
0.2016768456,
-0.9164382219,
-0.3662213087,
-0.5141599774,
0.2732181847,
-0.3030890524,
0.9121521115,
-0.0756081119,
-0.0761559382,
-0.3560959697,
-0.1736548841,
-0.1983746588,
-0.5260834694,
-0.4845308363,
-0.1977147013,
0.712253809,
0.4040027559,
0.2551366687,
0.2440848053,
0.4613508284,
0.4242508709,
-0.2382442951,
0.0531828329,
-0.2944132388,
0.9047517776,
0.1629943252,
-0.1609493643,
-0.5010902286,
-0.1860399693,
0.2684761584,
0.2087021768,
-0.1793014258,
-0.0288674682,
-0.1128507629,
0.4675717354,
-0.6124790907,
0.4884959459,
-0.5148062706,
0.4457638264,
0.2770288885,
-0.6658181548,
-0.3458867371,
-0.1623066664,
0.3450847268,
-0.4844811261,
-0.1678439975,
-0.0204049479,
0.6324977279,
0.3139971793,
-0.7534134984,
-0.6616538167,
-0.3979761302,
0.6104215384,
-0.3842867613,
0.0695333704,
0.0810803026,
0.1978078187,
-0.02406222,
-0.5293039083,
-0.484293431,
-0.2675217092,
-0.0977754891,
0.6138201356,
-0.0756435543,
0.1239557415,
0.348967135,
0.0467260517,
-0.2429109365,
-0.2405567765,
0.3009776473,
0.089593105,
0.3775013685,
0.7012601495,
0.4142200649,
-0.388874948,
-0.1980301291,
-0.1862575561,
-0.3096504807,
-0.1222873926,
0.2276078612,
0.3929026127,
-0.3016512692,
0.538760066,
-0.0137908077,
0.7053512931,
0.3636769354,
-0.2037315816,
0.1678913087,
-0.3575375676,
-0.2516900301,
0.3500985205,
0.7990533113,
0.5807827115,
0.2428115159,
-0.0090241982,
0.293835789,
0.4606783688,
0.2974345982,
-1.1032385826,
-0.0493930839,
0.4446029067,
-0.2940406799,
-0.7245510221,
-0.2796499729,
-1.1600137949,
-0.0724631101,
-0.2403167784,
0.0943700448,
-0.4163446724,
-0.3382433951,
-0.1376700848,
-0.2031047642,
0.237989977,
0.3231233358,
-0.8688105941,
0.3609803617,
0.4448661208,
0.5605151057,
0.33321473,
-0.1782848984,
-0.7189316154,
0.2148962766,
0.2654112577,
0.719396174,
-0.8262464404,
-0.4094361663,
0.1825139821,
0.0531032979,
-0.0807045922,
-0.0428329073,
0.4250456393,
-0.1535929292,
0.0411643051,
-0.1484430581,
-0.5258551836,
-0.0897362456,
0.3696696162,
-0.5522316694,
0.538880825,
0.0286637209,
-1.073150754,
0.0737293884,
-0.2403055429,
-0.4536100924,
-0.2153311521,
-0.2499518543,
-0.4504899085,
0.1795207113,
-0.2015919834,
0.5342888236,
-0.3578766286,
0.2824388742,
-0.4522737563,
0.2559031546,
0.468223691,
-0.1236237586,
0.298830092,
0.427677542,
-0.3511432409,
-0.2809053361,
-0.9757024646,
0.0432636254,
0.0973596498,
-0.0893458202,
-0.276743561,
0.314507544,
-0.1290457696,
0.5617564321,
-0.0436818562,
-0.7388207912,
-0.5148818493,
-0.29190889,
0.272849381,
0.4361033738,
0.2216445506,
0.3884424269,
0.0370003656,
0.4894032776,
0.3766599894,
-0.03720285,
-0.472160846,
-0.2441309541,
-0.7456349134,
0.0037290875,
-0.3898638189,
0.4466429949,
-0.265281558,
0.7132970691,
0.0252579339,
-0.5540058017,
-0.2997220159,
-0.3705201447,
0.5397721529,
0.875248611,
0.1553181559,
-0.2479254454,
-0.5539746284,
-0.5040014386,
-0.1736582816,
-0.3353954256,
0.2865272462,
0.6759077311,
0.1309824288,
-0.0986962244,
0.7903128862,
-0.6015264988,
0.0318734534,
-0.0488673635,
0.3763042688,
-0.2316412777,
0.2922051251,
0.4591666162,
-0.7589332461,
-0.4959661067,
0.0482376628,
-0.7468712926,
-0.4774733484,
-0.0501479432,
-0.431648016,
0.0900969803,
0.3713384271,
-0.5654537082,
0.2608689964,
0.7234396338,
-0.6066599488,
0.076452367,
0.1582514197,
0.1047426611,
-1.3172086477,
-0.0311731603,
-0.263695389,
0.0189277753,
-0.5167707205,
-0.1327813566,
-0.2264840454,
-0.0871140137,
-0.63105762,
0.3430214524,
-0.2665049732,
0.0892455876,
0.042605944,
0.4145354927,
0.164578855,
0.3478471637,
0.1141991466,
-0.1719739735,
0.6780676842,
-0.4429071248,
0.8661969304,
0.6731039882,
0.1126995981,
0.9825722575,
-0.392075479,
-0.154276371,
-0.2026483119,
0.4846908152,
-0.875472784,
-0.2708531618,
0.12540178,
-0.4581223726,
0.3037286997,
0.158320263,
-0.3576966524,
-0.2305855602,
-0.0468995832,
0.3940279782,
0.4712240398,
-0.3496156633,
1.0391397476,
0.2808273137,
-0.1021503061,
-0.1819616407,
-0.9556148648,
-0.3081888855,
-0.2730188966,
-0.8475241065,
-0.1016603038,
-0.0585261174,
-0.3037776649,
0.0259099528,
0.1470391601,
0.2189633101,
0.1917397976,
0.4854516089,
-0.1582112163,
0.0292394944,
0.2705637515,
0.1734407395,
-0.206926167,
0.3921417892,
0.319293797,
0.5744711161,
-0.1204116791,
-0.4061158299,
-0.2886911929,
0.5080213547,
0.6810283661,
-0.255137682,
0.6405994892,
0.6104614139,
0.0396341085,
0.1214217097,
-0.0763407722,
-0.3447242677,
-0.4070785344,
0.3672811389,
-0.4599199891,
-0.7378960848,
0.7119783759,
-0.2606206536,
-0.3220728934,
0.2393357009,
1.0088938475,
0.1605932862,
1.2436364889,
-0.0474643297,
0.3926392198,
0.6455013752,
0.1204765141,
0.5849502087,
-0.9449675679,
-0.32079494,
-0.4181394279,
-0.2513077259,
-0.9778574109,
0.0371380672,
0.1922599375,
-0.4924741089,
-0.4335481524,
0.1216711625,
-0.210676685,
-0.1547190398,
0.0935787261,
0.1101941392,
-0.0488937646,
-0.0049459245,
-0.29663378,
-0.0851107985,
-0.5226912498,
-0.2732962966,
0.5326930285,
0.2784439027,
0.9680685401,
0.2716233134,
0.8079577088,
-0.3604988754,
0.0777182356,
-0.9738739729,
0.5447148085,
0.0068204384,
-0.0834197253,
0.0707470402,
-0.3213419616,
-0.9658483863,
0.1266567111,
-0.3526136577,
-0.876793921,
-0.0206021033,
0.1466899216,
-0.4929777682,
-0.0306792948,
-0.7206622362,
0.6079162359,
-0.2202693373,
-0.4952201247,
-0.1139226779,
-0.9809374809,
0.1825795919,
-0.3020797074,
-0.0102837868,
-0.3791357875,
0.1938211173,
0.323970139,
-0.8047934771,
0.9385263324,
0.0559599735,
-0.0049708872,
0.4010947645,
0.521727562,
0.5327845812,
-0.132179603,
-0.1450759172,
-0.4960289896,
-0.0664608628,
-0.1045955047,
-0.7402462363,
0.905903995,
-0.6634124517,
-0.3171710968,
-0.3746141493,
-0.4851083755,
-0.2230037004,
-0.2169353515,
-0.0253350232,
0.5920555592,
-0.4916168153,
0.0236923154,
0.3009362221,
-0.4492393732,
0.1265903711,
0.6615033746,
-0.0553464964,
-0.2350762933,
0.6535130739,
-0.2089348435,
0.5256034136,
0.4601521194,
0.4156251848,
0.026220113,
0.5758354664,
-0.1091099009,
0.1654389054,
-0.533670783,
-0.3025642335,
-1.157158494,
-0.1140854433,
-0.2840127349,
-0.4112277031,
-0.2708159983,
-0.3449608088,
-0.1816433519,
-0.2921737731,
0.9690399766,
0.5787801147,
-0.0740546733,
0.2118979245,
-0.9871653914,
-0.0249413531,
0.4300629795,
0.058620438,
0.3570572138,
-0.2507086098,
-0.0745428428,
-0.0531968661,
-0.4677732289,
-1.0245708227,
0.8052456379,
0.1977691352,
0.1080660671,
0.4058977664,
0.0701161623,
0.5432636142,
-0.6759648919,
0.7790411115,
0.3506651521,
-0.9716128111,
0.7000197172,
-0.3334424496,
0.1484744102,
0.2051809877,
0.1197598577,
-0.7629169226,
-0.7921348214,
-1.049492836,
-1.0510052443,
0.7090343237,
0.2757413089,
0.3689816594,
-0.5459607244,
0.0789342597,
-0.2539601624,
0.1979542673,
-0.1157201603,
0.0091472585,
-0.0795040056,
-0.6253352761,
0.2019481659,
-0.3516858518,
-0.2821724415,
-0.0341385752,
0.1399727911,
-0.0909850597,
0.6793553233,
0.0528393574,
0.0799766853,
-0.6608160734,
-0.0745985731,
0.4002953768,
-0.2766087651,
-0.3703968227,
0.393640399,
0.1378405839,
-0.1137723625,
0.0616902076,
-0.1061726883,
0.367038101,
-0.0547081977,
0.2753757536,
0.9912403822,
0.557474792,
-0.6139695644,
0.7132682204,
-0.199517116,
0.2033033967,
-0.2801891565,
-0.1141854525,
0.3306329548,
0.2248068899,
-0.5693072081,
-0.145327419,
0.1553872377,
-0.6425833106,
0.43425107,
0.1694308668,
-0.3544541597,
-0.4783492684,
0.4226176739,
0.5137783885,
-0.2571758926,
0.5869853497,
0.2421118468,
-0.7483483553,
0.8241378069,
0.8063339591,
0.9715551734,
-0.5197258592,
0.2139427662,
0.5062763095,
-0.6023094654,
0.2894414663,
0.4851452112,
-0.2159774154,
-0.8248149157,
0.0496594682,
-0.7030884027,
-0.5967818499,
-0.5934180021,
-0.9039604664,
0.2544913888,
-0.2903015912,
-0.1093110517,
-0.0765192285,
-0.2740382254,
-0.7420398593,
0.3688958585,
0.1705466807,
0.6258071661,
-1.112614274,
0.4598244131,
0.5417771339,
-0.6899062395,
-0.9788152575,
-0.0843390599,
0.2146671116,
-0.8009849191,
0.9457631111,
0.1558883786,
-0.306647867,
0.0414363146,
-0.3126110435,
-0.7492646575,
1.1280199289,
-0.0375438668,
-0.3186535835,
0.2440223247,
0.0884640589,
0.9072018862,
-0.7639099956,
0.7726902962,
0.3862679005,
0.4307903051,
0.3783420324,
-0.4299584031,
0.2490143478,
-0.2979208529,
0.0654451847,
0.3902116716,
-1.0293334723,
0.8491969705,
0.1283546388,
-0.1684425473,
0.2751297355,
0.2190671712,
0.3130216002,
0.1016406938,
0.3357879817,
0.6302313805,
0.372178942,
-0.0862028375,
1.1764312983,
-0.8413274288,
0.3498054743,
0.9511532784,
-0.4725143909,
0.8641263247,
0.617721796,
0.1930066943,
0.7764379978,
0.5818581581,
0.1614289731,
0.499584198,
0.3461823761,
-0.680916369,
-0.2614415884,
-0.4867555201,
-0.020344831,
0.5432144403,
0.5843734741,
-0.7473377585,
-0.3700780571,
-0.1217579842,
0.2039208561,
-0.1214941442,
0.0867192969,
0.9533521533,
0.4401106238,
-0.6109563708,
0.1004441455,
-0.4622766674,
0.1115369126,
-0.6024194956,
-0.0418189578,
-0.1644227356,
0.0965862423,
-0.1741082519,
-0.9499672055,
0.3878494501,
0.2513985038,
0.0840782374,
-0.2256483585,
0.6591038704,
-0.7949099541,
-0.2486204952,
0.8595978022,
0.5889626741,
0.2403112203,
0.4267038107,
-0.4955173731,
0.1553919464,
-0.2838194966,
-0.3725596666,
0.3617273569,
1.0433039665,
0.4117303491,
0.4036738873,
0.269536972,
-0.1453120261,
-0.2080477625,
0.2698214948,
0.947996974,
-0.6933293343,
-0.3908032477,
-0.8465576172,
0.6016587019,
0.0022561925,
-0.0655649453,
0.4242004454,
0.0219479632,
0.326513797,
0.0263241958,
0.5785319209,
-0.3203670084,
0.2919660807,
-0.4150389433,
0.2659149766,
-0.6861342788,
-0.2975715995,
-0.6245869398,
-0.6442729831,
-0.4128328264,
0.6728391051,
-0.1788937896,
-0.0185984429,
0.8696862459,
0.8530344367,
0.1508428603,
0.1912024766,
0.4035823047,
0.5303795338,
0.2796169519,
0.8399700522,
1.0591309071,
-0.1427440792,
0.1489523202,
-0.0236107297,
-0.155787468,
-0.3112470806,
-1.1704199314,
-0.6372001171,
-0.4808645248,
-0.2172203511,
-0.6491651535,
-0.1100505888,
1.1261214018,
0.0907548815,
-0.6562362909,
-0.0879968926,
-0.3272713721,
-0.1514374614,
0.1889860034,
-0.2734903991,
0.1371332109,
-0.5364656448,
-0.8295075297,
-0.1780221164,
0.5599338412,
0.089864254,
-0.0380433872,
-0.2848750055,
-0.003023101,
0.375892669,
0.7715035081,
0.0445942245,
-0.4505467415,
-0.4079573154,
-0.1577996016,
-0.2597283125,
0.0034642685,
0.821777463,
-0.4930700064,
0.7142080665,
0.6976287961,
0.4099123776,
0.2413123995,
-0.1111988649,
0.8763453364,
-0.5149305463,
0.3031123281,
0.0294531714,
0.433065176,
0.3752548993,
-0.4120031893,
0.3364682198,
0.2385011464,
-0.5915244818,
-0.4460279047,
0.7216762304,
-1.2633862495,
0.2331170589,
1.4254078865,
-0.32699579,
-0.3918890059,
0.2797452807,
-0.3318754733,
0.6928585768,
-0.4997058213,
0.514203012,
0.6585206985,
-0.53694278,
-0.0029809077,
0.0992960632,
0.4227286279,
0.6278880239,
-0.7830697894,
0.1794175059,
0.4597726166,
-0.1648929119,
0.1361111701,
0.3008455932,
-0.0807830989,
0.0481885113,
0.170976758,
0.0518503636,
0.4330136776,
0.1365198791,
-0.1402833313,
-0.1739905924,
-0.1026209816,
-0.0626294985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17433v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17433v3
|
Enhancing EEG-to-Text Decoding through Transferable Representations from Pre-trained Contrastive EEG-Text Masked Autoencoder
| 2024-02-27T11:45:21 | 2024-06-10T09:51:50 |
Jiaqi Wang, Zhenxi Song, Zhengyu Ma, Xipeng Qiu, Min Zhang, Zhiguo Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reconstructing natural language from non-invasive electroencephalography
(EEG) holds great promise as a language decoding technology for brain-computer
interfaces (BCIs). However, EEG-based language decoding is still in its nascent
stages, facing several technical issues such as: 1) Absence of a hybrid
strategy that can effectively integrate cross-modality (between EEG and text)
self-learning with intra-modality self-reconstruction of EEG features or
textual sequences; 2) Under-utilization of large language models (LLMs) to
enhance EEG-based language decoding. To address above issues, we propose the
Contrastive EEG-Text Masked Autoencoder (CET-MAE), a novel model that
orchestrates compound self-supervised learning across and within EEG and text
through a dedicated multi-stream encoder. Furthermore, we develop a framework
called E2T-PTR (EEG-to-Text decoding using Pretrained Transferable
Representations), which leverages pre-trained modules alongside the EEG stream
from CET-MAE and further enables an LLM (specifically BART) to decode text from
EEG sequences. Comprehensive experiments conducted on the popular text-evoked
EEG database, ZuCo, demonstrate the superiority of E2T-PTR, which outperforms
the state-of-the-art in ROUGE-1 F1 and BLEU-4 scores by 8.34% and 32.21%,
respectively. These results indicate significant advancements in the field and
underscores the proposed framework's potential to enable more powerful and
widespread BCI applications.
|
[
-0.1987657547,
-0.6875083447,
0.5220987797,
0.5464106798,
-0.2220668793,
0.1174155176,
-0.2395178676,
-0.5954467654,
0.3932644129,
0.2369689047,
-0.2207839787,
-0.4133055508,
-0.7129914761,
0.3552149534,
-0.4398028851,
0.6981030107,
-0.2560848892,
-0.1176159084,
0.0314245,
0.0219985526,
-0.683499217,
-0.750315547,
-0.5425548553,
-0.2498259693,
0.2148151249,
0.0478701591,
-0.0117112417,
0.3335481286,
0.1630072445,
0.2433106601,
0.1787243932,
0.1718920022,
-0.2781537771,
-0.0922887996,
-0.1121816486,
-0.3850854933,
-0.6056066751,
-0.4320171177,
0.4113239646,
0.5914341807,
-0.1462086886,
-0.3722205162,
0.5386295319,
0.5832226872,
-0.8366764784,
0.2752349079,
-0.4039220214,
-0.1653076708,
0.1719606519,
-0.1488580257,
-0.704621613,
0.0542754047,
0.1226415709,
-0.4984682798,
0.0322163031,
-0.0213077143,
0.5691381097,
-0.0201704856,
-0.605790019,
-0.1976222545,
-0.5608500838,
0.5322214365,
-0.6161442995,
0.6057766676,
0.5262048841,
-0.0648483559,
0.0210304465,
-0.7211683989,
-0.5417182446,
-0.1379247755,
-0.2822591662,
0.4645675421,
-0.2517951131,
0.1256104559,
-0.1961797029,
0.3897195756,
-0.6829503179,
0.1758012176,
-0.1040614694,
-0.2648289502,
0.285531044,
0.0782280862,
0.3317348361,
-0.0900725201,
-0.2522540987,
-0.2151995152,
-0.4077145457,
-0.2486396283,
0.0179549456,
-0.1713090837,
-0.2980290055,
0.1875017732,
-0.0642722994,
0.3008963764,
0.4066117704,
0.237156108,
0.5562281609,
-0.3915718794,
-0.1190629974,
0.2035002559,
0.8153244257,
0.3683863282,
0.0052170097,
-0.3768640757,
-0.3350343108,
0.2239851058,
-0.0104644932,
-0.7600604296,
-0.5672934651,
0.1382038146,
-0.6961248517,
0.1151120365,
-0.0477307402,
-0.9136521816,
-0.1102084666,
-0.2567536831,
0.6702078581,
-0.5217136741,
-0.5047553778,
0.4093627036,
0.1986613274,
0.3567388058,
0.1676558852,
-0.9363405704,
0.4065649509,
0.1075220406,
0.6781371236,
-0.5322307348,
-0.1542098969,
-0.2947696447,
0.3557896316,
-0.1407903135,
0.6784256101,
-0.2702217996,
-0.5271212459,
0.0197030324,
0.2088699192,
-0.2970639765,
-0.3033665717,
0.4286805987,
-0.4304240644,
0.3008078337,
-0.1161030754,
-0.6576477885,
0.0873320103,
0.0137228332,
-0.7282336354,
0.7241959572,
-0.2859299779,
-0.5923775434,
-0.0800348446,
-0.6833775043,
-0.688829124,
-0.0794360116,
-0.2029788643,
-0.3268282413,
0.0819506869,
0.5969884992,
0.477819711,
-0.1172511652,
0.123101227,
-0.0817203522,
-0.3069197834,
0.2453707606,
-0.6062880158,
0.4978829622,
0.2714546323,
-0.4788970649,
-0.3343619108,
-0.9225885272,
-0.0448276214,
0.0997685045,
-0.1905196756,
-0.3284344077,
-0.1225453615,
0.3580395877,
0.1477395296,
0.2773714066,
-0.6043617129,
-0.3659531772,
-0.3972822428,
0.4685230851,
0.4798461795,
-0.0223210398,
0.5073602796,
-0.0489403047,
0.1816099435,
0.1301099509,
-0.183976844,
-0.7312475443,
-0.2356068492,
-0.9332963228,
-0.2574032545,
0.3072138727,
0.7025040984,
-0.9344642758,
0.8397458792,
-0.1940981895,
-0.0910373703,
-0.6324358582,
-0.2104349434,
0.3892362416,
0.6394168735,
0.718428731,
-0.2764620185,
-0.3887117803,
-0.9473597407,
-0.1633054614,
-0.1074108854,
-0.1472052634,
0.0248529073,
0.306740731,
-0.5947898626,
0.6690942049,
-0.1959089488,
-0.3381837308,
-0.1756171733,
0.540504992,
-0.0753680095,
0.7015452981,
0.3154539466,
-0.5386239886,
-0.5774965286,
0.25650841,
-0.7689480186,
-0.3673995733,
-0.2762009799,
0.0374611579,
0.3336373568,
0.7792884111,
-0.1395133138,
0.2556410432,
0.6154874563,
-0.3923894763,
0.2661756873,
-0.6165612936,
0.5138830543,
-0.9820168614,
0.1803292334,
-0.1044287235,
-0.2488511056,
-0.6172131896,
-0.3929815292,
0.4051430225,
0.0921596959,
-0.0454081036,
0.33951208,
-0.7100818753,
0.3099819422,
-0.6001349092,
0.0400813743,
0.1597559899,
0.4782519042,
0.3598198891,
0.8326845169,
0.5874978304,
-0.6292781234,
-0.1166774184,
0.2671896219,
0.1923912019,
0.6243857741,
-0.5731883049,
0.381913662,
-0.2624349296,
0.1619376391,
-0.7465937138,
0.0229612421,
-0.0424326621,
-0.293949455,
0.7308895588,
0.1423088163,
-0.3898646235,
0.0046970122,
-0.1502223313,
0.7726910114,
0.8167641759,
-0.7473524809,
0.8322744966,
0.388774544,
-0.2003525943,
-0.245420754,
-1.1369650364,
0.4246669412,
0.2127732038,
-0.421692729,
0.6675890684,
-0.061945904,
0.3182641864,
0.0110824872,
-0.1768919677,
-0.031801302,
-0.2735150754,
-0.1454297155,
0.181756258,
-0.0592713989,
0.0501430221,
0.2908369303,
-0.4091399014,
0.2736272812,
-0.4292992353,
0.3383456469,
-0.1394464672,
-0.3919044733,
-0.2786893845,
0.5228464603,
0.163123399,
-0.2528848648,
0.5378017426,
0.5400472879,
-0.4253282547,
-0.2122785896,
-0.7062008381,
-0.2381405681,
-0.4939928949,
0.6123979092,
-0.4815046191,
-0.9853717685,
0.2556589842,
-0.1916111112,
-0.3274519444,
0.3237872422,
0.5252258778,
-0.2475534528,
0.8229441047,
0.8008963466,
0.0533599034,
0.5017539263,
-0.0126237972,
0.1851521879,
-0.7437495589,
-0.3980948031,
-0.0104631027,
0.0856075883,
-0.5827142596,
-0.2097955942,
0.1666146517,
-0.1467827708,
0.21542418,
0.4162513018,
-0.4606839716,
0.5140179396,
0.1994724274,
0.3699529469,
0.3202387393,
0.1727577895,
-0.1573725045,
-0.2540093064,
-0.6300262809,
-0.3767226338,
1.1170847416,
0.3527105749,
0.7704234123,
-0.2886788845,
0.7616863251,
0.4011526108,
0.0321094282,
-0.2968122065,
0.4676458836,
-0.2825677693,
-0.1416064352,
0.2096167058,
-0.372808814,
-0.9272825122,
0.302760452,
-0.1808966696,
-0.6045020819,
0.5671821833,
0.1989568025,
-0.1126825586,
0.2345902324,
-0.9546779394,
0.6822226644,
-0.2795966864,
-0.5191230178,
-0.3005093336,
-0.6602740288,
0.1008769125,
-0.2332330346,
0.1146081984,
0.3834680915,
-0.1012040228,
0.7022858262,
-0.1129938588,
0.7367705107,
0.0519327037,
-0.2870946229,
0.2029902786,
0.1371012926,
0.405485332,
-0.1886234283,
0.0794837326,
0.2779745758,
0.0680372864,
-0.4792873263,
-0.5113771558,
0.8251455426,
-0.7604618669,
-0.2364665866,
-0.411316365,
-0.1096243411,
-0.3053614795,
0.0516724735,
0.4240365922,
0.4400017858,
-0.4583398998,
-0.0143763972,
0.9727720618,
-0.366155237,
0.6767525077,
0.3221421838,
-0.023549173,
-0.7187822461,
1.0988441706,
-0.1556584686,
0.1898570955,
0.6794753671,
-0.3643925786,
-0.3223347664,
-0.6042945981,
-0.0973749459,
0.3268917799,
-0.7187997103,
-0.0666206256,
-0.8518730402,
-0.2237730622,
-0.1654474884,
-0.3538909554,
-0.4867690206,
-0.0502832383,
-0.3554102182,
-0.1288399696,
0.0009233299,
0.4530310929,
-0.2949073613,
0.3223280609,
-0.7568357587,
0.5881556869,
0.3505787849,
0.4898007512,
-0.2638761699,
-0.4975160658,
-0.4102175236,
-0.0886530504,
0.0766830742,
-0.9986918569,
0.6146327257,
0.0217254926,
0.3629783392,
0.1438373923,
0.0794160366,
0.4117111564,
-0.4194657207,
0.5156155229,
0.600952208,
-1.0199325085,
0.4334535897,
-0.1024155766,
0.3361147046,
0.6204582453,
-0.0005773637,
-0.3118751347,
-0.1446751207,
-0.2126762569,
-0.8852586746,
0.6662810445,
0.677067697,
0.1861085743,
-0.1766578108,
0.2921043336,
0.3127677441,
-0.0249795765,
-1.0215824842,
-0.3540048897,
-0.5468719006,
-0.5526073575,
0.0964819714,
-0.4389303923,
0.2955280542,
-0.0521858148,
0.3932993114,
-0.0465603434,
0.8593712449,
0.4995846748,
-0.5036854148,
0.2057942152,
0.5285596251,
0.1099150032,
0.253916651,
-0.1686757654,
0.3609171808,
0.4156250656,
-0.691133678,
0.1551634669,
0.4661860168,
0.0214761589,
0.0217684619,
0.2114194334,
0.7065631747,
0.1045169234,
-0.5010308623,
0.5958960056,
-0.1027125865,
-0.1883683056,
-0.0424898118,
-0.2772685587,
-0.0989389718,
0.0521578304,
0.3159275651,
-0.1561236978,
0.3926936984,
-0.2156556696,
0.0725989863,
0.0879649743,
-0.1297869682,
-0.4957585037,
0.7140085697,
0.5648566484,
-0.1344145685,
0.228892222,
-0.177088365,
-0.3766315877,
0.4124378264,
0.948254168,
1.2030460835,
-0.2223533392,
-0.148240447,
0.3320099413,
0.3883290291,
-0.1584135443,
0.2899217904,
-0.1438874453,
-0.5855523944,
-0.5096150041,
-0.2778587937,
-0.1631911844,
0.2052506655,
-0.4548671246,
0.1394744068,
-0.0420347005,
0.0050712549,
-0.6206248999,
-0.3877946436,
-0.6523944736,
0.2753193378,
0.372798264,
0.6345438361,
-0.6282348037,
0.9577335715,
0.5006254911,
-0.2324847132,
-0.317198962,
0.2162862271,
-0.5988008976,
-0.4262843728,
0.3308407962,
0.2458337098,
-0.4613639116,
0.2522789538,
-0.268047899,
-0.4871774316,
1.0918617249,
0.4281431139,
-0.9305883646,
-0.0562893599,
0.1254692823,
0.5054180622,
-0.3108846843,
0.3629879057,
0.4768310785,
0.2599502802,
-0.3198161423,
-0.8922511339,
0.1365935504,
-0.4688963294,
0.0559066609,
0.1789052039,
-0.4717579186,
0.4626452625,
0.2594479024,
-0.3430249095,
-0.2312196046,
0.8788324594,
0.0140622547,
0.3666913211,
0.2162849009,
0.3037841618,
0.4013754129,
0.13399674,
0.794115603,
-0.5092738867,
0.1377886385,
0.8817528486,
-0.1176068261,
0.8164446354,
0.4641698003,
-0.0189664736,
0.5693868399,
0.2162397504,
0.1227359027,
0.8057801127,
-0.2798434794,
-0.3836374581,
-0.272803843,
0.4444451332,
-0.430668056,
0.1247778907,
0.35952124,
-0.374817729,
-0.1543516815,
0.2916926444,
-0.254360348,
0.3684622943,
-0.268969655,
0.7030786276,
0.3370201886,
-0.3352869153,
0.337310791,
0.1761074066,
1.0232112408,
-0.5346730947,
-0.2016654164,
-0.1707913429,
0.1865261942,
-0.0261285733,
-0.5507720113,
0.1112018824,
0.0090782382,
0.0366539881,
-0.3349375725,
0.9992665648,
-0.6453198195,
-0.2050800622,
0.7246710658,
0.7289486527,
-0.1788262427,
0.0390430391,
-0.455016762,
-0.1638002396,
-0.2222875357,
-0.0505065396,
0.4050878286,
0.4918240905,
0.25777632,
0.3498737812,
0.405760318,
-0.2001399547,
0.0803475678,
-0.0211372487,
0.7930720448,
-0.7869471908,
-0.8635894656,
-0.9410678148,
0.4417126179,
-0.0268092509,
0.1261917651,
0.5773682594,
0.4611659348,
0.6623877883,
-0.1918199062,
0.8316516876,
0.0510909073,
0.1347897053,
-0.7199804187,
0.6794564128,
-0.2826834023,
0.2240042537,
-0.1974957585,
-0.7255917788,
-0.1517679095,
0.6153030396,
-0.1263566166,
0.1802828759,
0.9992582202,
0.689657867,
-0.1465792954,
-0.052280549,
0.46040833,
0.1969781816,
0.0950608253,
0.822124958,
0.7127919793,
-0.5895944834,
0.7414697409,
0.0805430636,
-0.3354807794,
-0.1737332344,
-0.9060509205,
-0.9091288447,
-0.5270240307,
-0.5671107769,
-0.3628743589,
0.2818033993,
0.8791434765,
0.4385755062,
-0.9873319268,
-0.1656019688,
-0.5007314086,
-0.3561884165,
0.0147897815,
-0.1210188121,
0.5664824843,
-0.3961198032,
-0.5862953067,
0.5066187382,
0.4747991562,
0.2104670852,
-0.1298552901,
-0.2582131624,
-0.0161958765,
0.1461691409,
0.8439592719,
0.3560994267,
-0.3791411817,
0.060451787,
0.2208950967,
-0.3033004701,
0.2739160061,
0.6249539256,
-0.9630486965,
0.5499619842,
0.3726644516,
0.9771488309,
0.8594408631,
-0.4337058365,
0.7438227534,
-0.464286536,
-0.1817322224,
0.071130991,
0.4429778755,
0.3993852437,
-0.2810581625,
0.1907269657,
0.1817045659,
-0.4298963547,
-0.4382515848,
0.0856100172,
-1.0765644312,
-0.3326695561,
1.2168235779,
-0.0908374861,
-0.12721394,
-0.4213222563,
-0.4311854839,
0.1440973878,
-0.3728004396,
0.7896057367,
0.5723041296,
-0.1759597659,
-0.5083150268,
-0.1410175264,
0.2757710218,
0.6593514681,
-1.0322654247,
-0.0356130823,
0.5121805668,
0.1706161797,
-0.1187987402,
0.7777838111,
-0.2976630628,
0.3086420596,
0.092117779,
0.2326175719,
-0.1653172374,
-0.1213503554,
-0.6508852243,
0.1239514798,
-0.1188210547,
-0.3871015012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17411v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17411v2
|
Consistency Matters: Explore LLMs Consistency From a Black-Box Perspective
| 2024-02-27T11:02:12 | 2024-03-02T14:08:06 |
Fufangchen Zhao, Guoqiang Jin, Jiaheng Huang, Rui Zhao, Fei Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays both commercial and open-source academic LLM have become the
mainstream models of NLP. However, there is still a lack of research on LLM
consistency, meaning that throughout the various stages of LLM research and
deployment, its internal parameters and capabilities should remain unchanged.
This issue exists in both the industrial and academic sectors. The solution to
this problem is often time-consuming and labor-intensive, and there is also an
additional cost of secondary deployment, resulting in economic and time losses.
To fill this gap, we build an LLM consistency task dataset and design several
baselines. Additionally, we choose models of diverse scales for the main
experiments. Specifically, in the LightGBM experiment, we used traditional NLG
metrics (i.e., ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR) as the features needed for model training.
The final result exceeds the manual evaluation and GPT3.5 as well as other
models in the main experiment, achieving the best performance. In the end, we
use the best performing LightGBM model as the base model to build the
evaluation tool, which can effectively assist in the deployment of business
models. Our code and tool demo are available at
https://github.com/heavenhellchen/Consistency.git
|
[
-0.0753618479,
-0.6136142612,
0.569268465,
0.4411952496,
-0.1183882356,
-0.0189948641,
-0.4160818756,
-0.7967191339,
-0.0285502728,
0.4502174258,
-0.2551137209,
-0.5354098678,
-0.539799571,
0.1649229527,
-0.3167132735,
1.1770761013,
-0.2624612451,
0.0602648854,
-0.3347972333,
-0.4699718058,
-0.7024370432,
-0.1622194499,
-0.6822722554,
-0.7067497969,
0.4728449285,
0.1331697702,
1.0813928843,
0.7777658105,
0.5872267485,
0.1563102901,
-0.2941854298,
0.2201630324,
-0.6253387332,
0.0995621532,
-0.454341501,
-0.5340881348,
-0.4289556146,
-0.0079779755,
0.5391539335,
0.7443554401,
-0.5760487914,
0.1490206122,
0.313033998,
0.5249111652,
-0.4457621276,
0.1149505526,
-0.8202803135,
0.0005957228,
0.0813090727,
0.0972899422,
-0.3371328115,
-0.3249210417,
-0.2074588835,
-0.6959134936,
0.3707805574,
0.0482841507,
1.1003302336,
0.2808737755,
-0.3488760293,
0.0667887107,
-1.0189181566,
0.7642657161,
-0.8803212047,
0.4354897738,
0.1441067904,
0.0845025852,
-0.3043549061,
-0.6299524307,
-0.4099935293,
-0.2119110972,
0.034800522,
0.1814105809,
-0.1239759922,
-0.0603004172,
0.147133708,
0.2402845174,
-0.509531796,
0.4206264615,
-0.2000557333,
-0.0756113827,
0.6403830051,
0.2566439807,
-0.0316353478,
0.252599299,
-0.3945797682,
0.1770893633,
-0.8819254637,
-0.1443151981,
0.2879731655,
0.0398285575,
-0.0888643637,
0.7931901813,
-0.1212788895,
0.638266623,
0.1257048249,
-0.1264570355,
0.03847453,
-0.5777609348,
-0.3254211247,
-0.1725978255,
0.7307582498,
0.4378215373,
-0.0694131404,
-0.467908442,
-0.5000557303,
0.2561208308,
0.7289893031,
-0.480452925,
-0.1985841542,
0.265822798,
-0.3282999396,
-0.1158415005,
-0.342644304,
-0.2549744844,
-0.5157075524,
-0.6814591885,
0.7325598598,
-0.2256479412,
-0.3687336743,
0.2699334919,
0.1777091175,
0.2382017225,
0.5664846301,
-1.0165287256,
0.2529584169,
1.0699874163,
0.8822876811,
-0.3649117053,
-0.224843666,
0.0300925951,
0.1964243352,
-0.577473402,
0.3369652331,
0.0913152918,
-0.2635782659,
0.0351085439,
0.0659075156,
0.0761764348,
-0.8891226053,
0.4371507168,
-0.2377192974,
-0.1390047818,
-0.1518348902,
-0.8264496326,
-0.0017185176,
0.4754828513,
-0.2608697712,
1.0051287413,
0.0627783313,
-0.6361405253,
0.5167858005,
-0.3767306507,
0.0844029859,
0.3365885615,
-0.4410809278,
-0.7763366699,
0.3269368708,
-0.4727910757,
0.4479504824,
0.016028082,
0.5416676998,
-0.320661962,
-0.6273810267,
0.1449260563,
-0.2255206406,
0.8215517998,
0.0512634479,
-0.420983851,
0.0825175419,
-0.8545525074,
-0.0457707085,
0.1451341659,
-0.402290225,
-0.0192696378,
0.196260795,
0.1377851963,
-0.0141927637,
0.4959237874,
-0.6567846537,
0.324752599,
0.0106966924,
0.2835511863,
0.8050773144,
-0.1650960147,
0.3166594207,
-0.5643460155,
0.3970909417,
-0.0317796655,
0.1303383559,
0.1452369392,
-0.5901367664,
-0.768255651,
0.0429385789,
0.3219243884,
0.347895503,
-0.275595516,
0.495827347,
-0.2777872086,
-0.5886184573,
-0.7861795425,
0.3862687945,
0.1311479062,
0.6033024788,
0.2756426334,
-0.2334268689,
-0.4348524213,
-1.0758794546,
-0.0748186857,
-0.2776501477,
-0.1487125754,
0.0663514584,
0.4634511471,
-0.6910273433,
1.1198210716,
-0.3228991926,
-0.2110015303,
-0.1326830536,
0.0390628688,
0.3703153431,
0.6056502461,
0.3499562442,
-0.7142733932,
-0.4065298438,
0.141518116,
-0.9674949646,
-0.1853335649,
-0.1307455748,
-0.2427646667,
0.1662104279,
0.3550500274,
-0.5723534822,
0.3521764576,
0.7873290181,
-0.2456691712,
0.7503602505,
-0.4550561607,
-0.0720738843,
-0.8313776255,
0.0346046798,
0.2793314159,
-0.3766171038,
-0.6557460427,
-0.0154608423,
0.3762222528,
0.026065534,
-0.4127506912,
0.612134397,
-0.2506525218,
-0.0451809987,
-0.3637292683,
0.0399903804,
0.3265459239,
0.3654795289,
0.0416623317,
0.8880721331,
0.39079687,
-0.6283827424,
-0.0299402568,
0.2121376693,
-0.2582884431,
0.7592924833,
-1.0102711916,
0.1739893556,
0.202452451,
-0.0797788501,
-0.7745323181,
0.1590357274,
0.2992456257,
-0.0800280124,
0.3704690635,
-0.2746382654,
-0.9340783358,
0.1276313961,
0.0439007394,
0.0489419326,
0.6164508462,
-0.4199709594,
0.4568558931,
0.35705477,
0.0251081511,
-0.5532044172,
-0.8098905683,
0.1001987532,
-0.0007227729,
-0.7067394257,
0.4632217586,
-0.3911363482,
-0.3061456084,
-0.00539727,
-0.5582687855,
0.017360203,
0.36188519,
0.3002979755,
0.2492830008,
-0.2536050379,
-0.043698594,
-0.3589881957,
0.0678855032,
0.0289331209,
-0.4216146767,
0.0612218753,
-0.1755474657,
-0.5430442095,
-0.3888840079,
-0.0244479496,
0.212534681,
0.2666534483,
0.9538324475,
0.5603305697,
-0.3111022711,
-0.2918919325,
-0.5749749541,
0.0010065231,
-0.4988980889,
0.142644912,
-0.0055537373,
-0.6648743153,
0.5534660816,
0.1387996525,
0.5725645423,
0.1731211692,
0.4282858074,
-0.3344342709,
0.7366102338,
1.1263787746,
0.2384500951,
0.3377920687,
-0.1370343417,
0.2252032459,
-0.8763353229,
-0.4250408411,
-0.3875908256,
-0.3147341907,
-0.4983309507,
-0.2566947639,
0.3183981776,
0.4685225785,
-0.0671146885,
0.4000564814,
-0.5406497717,
0.4214157462,
0.2378967702,
0.1567687094,
0.4943772554,
-0.1093498021,
-0.0767672509,
-0.1529473811,
-0.7785724998,
-0.7975894809,
1.1320930719,
0.4280266166,
0.8743522167,
0.1122885793,
0.8079838157,
0.1668886095,
0.5180742145,
-0.6283691525,
0.5973362327,
0.0650467426,
-0.5887441635,
-0.1640903652,
-0.6312661171,
-1.3844685555,
0.3892904222,
-0.2399165928,
-0.6082411408,
0.1299578995,
0.3046970069,
0.0839692503,
0.3052455187,
-0.5616149902,
0.9223549962,
-0.400944531,
-0.7805836797,
-0.018197922,
-0.346014142,
0.1840328276,
-0.1116308868,
0.0519894287,
-0.3750953972,
-0.195255667,
0.6235871911,
-0.2068195194,
0.8506033421,
0.0746821314,
-0.3170555234,
-0.0330561809,
0.1305443943,
0.5630356073,
0.1193367168,
-0.0520768315,
0.7143440843,
-0.2505356073,
-0.5933824778,
-0.5269075632,
0.5637905002,
-0.793096602,
-0.6322469115,
-0.2652663589,
-0.6118433475,
-0.1737425029,
0.2535147369,
0.1196503714,
0.0135161439,
-0.3107202351,
0.4489355683,
1.074434638,
0.0132076414,
0.3587483764,
0.7433618903,
-0.3290572762,
-0.1178093925,
0.5548192859,
0.3575614989,
0.4315266311,
0.0961350054,
0.0174249765,
-0.2653989792,
-1.1291267872,
-0.2778723836,
0.2016115785,
-0.7064925432,
-0.1683464348,
-0.5826501846,
-0.2773474753,
-0.2157983482,
-0.3200227618,
-0.5181086659,
-0.1505069286,
-0.2948424816,
-0.0345516354,
0.1643719226,
0.9036172628,
0.0354509689,
0.2823285758,
-0.4798530638,
0.4588983059,
0.075179711,
0.6796109676,
-0.2811075449,
-0.6090827584,
-0.6929399371,
0.1215750724,
-0.5428097844,
-0.5433235168,
0.1043051556,
-0.0698924288,
0.8231397271,
0.1108890548,
-0.2092972398,
0.4975936115,
-0.44226107,
0.7154839039,
0.2049409002,
-0.8357294202,
0.3742918372,
-0.5985765457,
0.3891707361,
0.6934965849,
0.2414612621,
-0.6874323487,
-0.5917736888,
-0.9581501484,
-1.0055031776,
0.3889631927,
0.3753158748,
-0.2083566785,
0.3231646717,
0.4655256569,
0.2614878714,
0.4506480098,
-1.1103183031,
-0.3390001655,
-0.0235273633,
-0.3284606636,
-0.2584819496,
-0.1167303845,
-0.4059848487,
0.199867636,
0.6569579244,
0.0235275868,
-0.0897462517,
-0.0958636403,
-0.1894924194,
0.1103958786,
0.1819930971,
0.5644314885,
1.178455472,
-0.3246701658,
0.0895903483,
0.0251490604,
-0.4464147985,
0.4558071494,
-0.0725071803,
-0.6577709913,
0.2157332748,
0.1579905599,
0.5209792852,
0.4095714092,
-0.4555365145,
0.3092654645,
0.1102710813,
-0.3159569502,
-0.230670616,
0.3520571887,
0.2351689637,
0.1720957756,
0.2254509032,
0.2711353302,
-0.2323613614,
-0.4605695009,
0.1227416843,
0.3588708639,
-0.1183049828,
-0.0503644235,
0.9110381603,
-0.0510483347,
-0.4214328825,
0.4079767764,
-0.2111723572,
-0.0133168837,
0.7267994881,
0.4501735866,
0.7426365018,
0.1511264145,
0.2156495303,
-0.1066356152,
0.5908563137,
-0.7633937597,
0.2003546357,
0.2912808657,
-0.8035615087,
-0.314209044,
-0.5220943689,
-0.9211640358,
0.1748640537,
-0.5340362787,
0.3834354877,
-0.6429746747,
-0.1297555566,
-0.1089132652,
0.2842054069,
-0.7775879502,
0.141199857,
0.0852372125,
0.7291762233,
-0.7447493672,
0.7251794934,
0.4778102636,
-0.3093865514,
-0.6226763129,
-0.3591691256,
0.125317201,
-0.5277802348,
0.2371890247,
0.037277326,
0.003311018,
-0.2710609138,
-0.5309751034,
-0.7577251196,
1.2193015814,
0.6181312203,
-1.0108113289,
0.3353565037,
-0.0358661674,
0.7434763312,
-0.3242330551,
0.1018296853,
0.227533415,
0.4569541216,
-0.3143950105,
-0.9150280356,
-0.2400151342,
0.1094618216,
0.0950084031,
0.1488692462,
-0.6633050442,
0.5057843328,
-0.0037408788,
-0.1803737581,
-0.2003489286,
0.6350487471,
0.7294766903,
0.5821681619,
0.1722300798,
0.6795233488,
0.9323049784,
-0.172998175,
0.9001564384,
-0.2393962294,
0.3350523114,
1.334600091,
-0.5692449808,
0.7415470481,
0.3720319569,
-0.2070850879,
0.1428467482,
0.6493498087,
-0.5640120506,
0.1532106251,
0.2925428748,
0.0258140322,
0.2079077661,
-0.0615212806,
-0.2940477133,
0.0792813897,
-0.0172971878,
-0.0154377008,
-0.0433106944,
-0.2856177092,
0.1007124037,
0.1168736219,
-0.356174618,
0.6084048748,
0.1364363283,
-0.4215923846,
0.6334275007,
-0.0053518601,
0.83127141,
-0.8655235171,
0.183643505,
-0.3487921357,
0.2342565507,
-0.3528584838,
-0.8621385694,
0.4361988604,
-0.177673921,
-0.265563786,
-0.5504972339,
0.4078798592,
-0.7790544033,
-0.3906044066,
0.4330138564,
0.4463610649,
0.1666639447,
0.2435220033,
-0.7937276959,
0.3036848605,
-0.1963625103,
-0.0860926807,
0.6034395695,
0.5389000773,
0.2593288124,
0.7766942978,
0.4684431553,
0.4721547663,
0.2001619786,
0.0569543578,
0.2903568149,
-0.5166124701,
-0.1609822363,
-0.7057192326,
0.5657484531,
-0.0096915662,
-0.2783590853,
1.0168735981,
0.7092100382,
0.9154546261,
0.1316581517,
0.5583723187,
0.3166267872,
0.1565537155,
-0.5549401045,
0.5878458619,
-0.5593109727,
0.5669660568,
-0.1223624274,
-1.136839509,
-0.135227263,
0.478518188,
0.1110101268,
-0.0419397689,
0.4536876976,
0.8018177152,
-0.1600543857,
-0.2373328656,
0.546487093,
0.157856226,
0.3795390427,
0.2813001275,
0.662045002,
-0.3904488981,
0.3838467598,
-0.1791489869,
0.0727808699,
-0.2632179558,
-1.21098876,
-0.3987927735,
-0.2091956437,
-0.961345613,
-0.6185414195,
0.1149231046,
0.7348976135,
0.8871023655,
-0.5561819673,
-0.4933564067,
-0.2707719505,
0.3350559771,
-0.5024810433,
-0.2326531857,
-0.0629072636,
-0.4423716962,
-0.4917301834,
0.3034478128,
0.4883864522,
0.3405883014,
-0.341943562,
0.0512565784,
-0.1527649313,
0.0566594265,
0.2689778805,
0.1881156713,
-0.603725791,
-0.1571613252,
-0.2102296799,
-0.3681484759,
0.4293871224,
0.6779005527,
-0.3691051006,
0.2702085376,
0.2519853115,
0.9171308279,
0.5464832187,
-0.138378039,
0.7186341882,
-0.7526795864,
0.022460131,
0.2480549216,
0.5287681818,
0.5898136497,
-0.505623281,
0.8864323497,
0.2316869646,
-0.9541109204,
-0.8561034799,
0.2332702577,
-1.0633146763,
-0.2543000281,
1.1030416489,
-0.2937525213,
0.0558741577,
-0.3341032565,
0.083349742,
-0.0214303881,
-0.1926751435,
0.9374317527,
0.8740657568,
-0.1928203851,
-0.1858235449,
-0.7635546923,
0.3734512925,
0.5570599437,
-0.6163478494,
0.0985236466,
0.2908923924,
0.5738236308,
0.2207787931,
0.6466510892,
0.1395239979,
-0.0277330261,
0.0397660211,
0.246393472,
0.012750552,
-0.3832409084,
-0.6641107202,
0.1767011732,
0.1261481196,
0.0462053195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17407v1
|
A Neural Rewriting System to Solve Algorithmic Problems
| 2024-02-27T10:57:07 | 2024-02-27T10:57:07 |
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Modern neural network architectures still struggle to learn algorithmic
procedures that require to systematically apply compositional rules to solve
out-of-distribution problem instances. In this work, we propose an original
approach to learn algorithmic tasks inspired by rewriting systems, a classic
framework in symbolic artificial intelligence. We show that a rewriting system
can be implemented as a neural architecture composed by specialized modules:
the Selector identifies the target sub-expression to process, the Solver
simplifies the sub-expression by computing the corresponding result, and the
Combiner produces a new version of the original expression by replacing the
sub-expression with the solution provided. We evaluate our model on three types
of algorithmic tasks that require simplifying symbolic formulas involving
lists, arithmetic, and algebraic expressions. We test the extrapolation
capabilities of the proposed architecture using formulas involving a higher
number of operands and nesting levels than those seen during training, and we
benchmark its performance against the Neural Data Router, a recent model
specialized for systematic generalization, and a state-of-the-art large
language model (GPT-4) probed with advanced prompting strategies.
|
[
0.143938452,
-0.7310763597,
0.4609012604,
0.1808252186,
-0.1311327219,
0.0803157836,
-0.0685035363,
-0.1909049749,
0.5953061581,
0.3915130794,
-0.7913693786,
-0.2502758801,
-0.4366071224,
0.0948570296,
-0.3957554102,
0.8354573846,
-0.2922028899,
0.0579221919,
0.0082138637,
0.1147534698,
-0.5325564742,
-0.4505647123,
-0.817735076,
-0.6646870375,
0.6185894012,
0.0753189847,
0.4416501224,
0.8450892568,
0.4438393116,
0.4997292459,
0.0636312366,
0.1306984872,
-0.0513169207,
0.2902728915,
0.0397468917,
-0.744343996,
-0.3173069656,
-0.3251539171,
0.5694665909,
0.7879308462,
-0.4614063799,
0.100762412,
-0.3222206533,
0.6748631001,
-0.399525255,
0.5803790092,
-0.7002207041,
0.2578570247,
0.2480781376,
-0.2367432564,
-0.380122751,
-0.2950909138,
0.1102568209,
-0.7965828776,
0.2030138075,
-0.2339110821,
0.2156737596,
0.6089949608,
-0.0196272619,
-0.2934850156,
-0.5898671746,
0.6087137461,
-0.4535094798,
0.2286371589,
-0.0169951878,
0.5287162662,
-0.2398507148,
-0.8605113626,
-0.3361244798,
-0.2794517875,
-0.0035709068,
-0.1281256378,
-0.3823364675,
-0.0831366628,
0.1411103308,
0.0971281976,
-0.3561755121,
-0.3155010641,
-0.6447139978,
-0.1051455587,
0.6399059892,
0.3624995351,
0.1971992105,
0.0589528382,
-0.0646848753,
0.0401944928,
-0.7429071069,
-0.2298284471,
0.2722792029,
0.1151707098,
0.3867695332,
0.3421136141,
-0.2685967982,
0.4983405471,
-0.0265411325,
0.3379579186,
0.3128675222,
0.0471545979,
-0.3746930957,
-0.0884931609,
0.3641512394,
-0.1066127792,
0.4184158146,
-0.2535127997,
-0.6117278337,
0.0207319427,
0.6357370615,
-0.4147020578,
-0.4295860827,
-0.1277640164,
-0.5298687816,
-0.2228490114,
-0.4654078186,
-0.2450879514,
-0.1145382598,
-0.7112511396,
0.6495606303,
-0.4939531982,
0.1223071069,
0.2529733479,
-0.169088766,
0.0032452997,
0.3688775003,
-0.9103261828,
0.4475853443,
0.89441818,
0.7245448232,
0.1638268977,
-0.4887996018,
-0.1875633299,
-0.0368610285,
-0.364957273,
0.5790101886,
-0.5373438597,
0.0731402785,
-0.1207229272,
-0.2465136796,
-0.2647226453,
-0.4544948936,
0.2124876827,
-0.8273363709,
-0.2424488664,
0.0295574572,
-0.4304447472,
-0.2822933197,
0.2846135497,
-0.8323671818,
0.4593537748,
0.08866027,
-0.2476139218,
-0.1496413201,
-0.6932212114,
-0.6113996506,
-0.0245726611,
-0.2117987573,
-0.3505688012,
0.5936888456,
0.0192869771,
0.1022114828,
-0.2981721163,
0.3524973094,
0.2280058861,
-0.6215001941,
0.1282169968,
-0.5645647645,
0.5436334014,
0.1536250263,
-0.5237131715,
0.3671008348,
-0.6525974274,
0.2522682548,
0.0786321834,
-0.4957264662,
-0.0964275375,
0.1601836979,
-0.3906313777,
0.1366404742,
0.3893431723,
-0.5904304385,
0.3256570399,
-0.5567576885,
0.8395906687,
0.8800505996,
-0.3046004772,
0.3597477376,
-0.4318852723,
0.5019158125,
-0.2077247351,
-0.0352588147,
-0.2683111131,
-0.4835328758,
-0.8159640431,
0.0672113821,
0.1178166568,
0.4898948371,
-0.8793368936,
0.2066431195,
-0.2751128972,
-0.5456815958,
-0.5466477871,
0.0459584408,
0.6990622282,
0.3151136339,
0.3644844592,
0.0001887485,
-0.517968297,
-1.2348521948,
-0.3010554016,
-0.0182064977,
0.0437498912,
0.2117882371,
0.521504581,
0.0782793164,
0.2844948471,
-0.5702504516,
-0.0749704987,
-0.1709258109,
0.1115500331,
0.3164507449,
0.5759507418,
-0.1539658755,
-0.5931121111,
-0.2717711329,
0.0427790396,
-0.7384554148,
-0.0078019281,
-0.154128626,
0.0447748415,
0.0057408987,
0.7611247301,
-0.7777103186,
0.4680980742,
0.1467184424,
0.0036859012,
0.6104012728,
-0.5581272244,
-0.2123339027,
-0.9000771642,
-0.0489194915,
-0.2473680228,
0.2862948775,
-0.5706427693,
0.5775821805,
-0.1374726444,
-0.1463790387,
-0.3326508105,
0.1155902743,
-0.3405746222,
-0.0426165573,
-0.4230775535,
-0.3932666481,
-0.2710690498,
0.8254041672,
-0.0138377585,
0.43360883,
0.5757114291,
-0.3786679804,
0.6429299116,
0.1219507456,
-0.0582504049,
0.1343123466,
-0.9584316611,
0.1990061104,
-0.4534084499,
0.3977587223,
-0.7547209263,
-0.027617313,
0.280061096,
-0.1777980477,
-0.0599265173,
-0.0659405366,
-0.3146653771,
-0.0976917967,
-0.0506419502,
0.7393818498,
0.495036453,
-0.3080459535,
1.1287184954,
-0.0885397419,
0.0228055231,
-0.5997250676,
-0.7025577426,
0.1279661953,
0.0757121369,
-0.5766949654,
0.6343024373,
0.0449908525,
-0.0898634195,
0.0469068624,
0.0450371616,
-0.1189214736,
0.0346063189,
0.0905906633,
-0.1021926627,
-0.340539664,
0.1389315277,
0.1797910184,
-0.2667888105,
0.3012213409,
-0.5240908265,
0.763243854,
0.000581704,
-0.5939411521,
-0.7189569473,
0.7433990836,
0.6103992462,
-0.4051488638,
0.3583812416,
0.0146489041,
-0.553935349,
-0.6131566763,
-0.0529679023,
-0.2272581905,
-0.5065919757,
0.6045891643,
-0.7278625965,
-0.4455451369,
0.4546450675,
0.2210996896,
0.2806866169,
0.3263497651,
0.5519038439,
0.2021190524,
0.9064751267,
0.5147464275,
0.0158948191,
0.522225976,
-0.3430522382,
0.2666059434,
-0.5257363319,
-0.3789868355,
-0.2592278719,
-1.0080162287,
-0.4930706918,
-0.2094022781,
0.2082367241,
-0.2990028262,
-0.3197832108,
0.459117502,
-0.6104106903,
0.5707230568,
0.95633322,
0.3772540987,
0.0224429369,
0.2595970333,
-0.0187593196,
0.3050726056,
-0.6479175687,
-0.2214888334,
1.1001988649,
0.1098185554,
0.7377884388,
0.0610301942,
0.832529664,
0.1159126684,
0.4701240659,
-0.7338634729,
0.6259046793,
-0.4222526848,
-0.3904657662,
-0.2392591238,
-0.451261878,
-0.7793941498,
0.1923886538,
0.2807613313,
-0.4353100359,
0.1301363111,
0.2293361425,
-0.3596558869,
0.2464384437,
-0.8449521661,
0.5163812041,
-0.2317337543,
-0.0437010899,
-0.4583882391,
-0.5261467695,
0.1373114884,
-0.0089898556,
-0.2286596745,
0.3842219412,
-0.0993716866,
0.6102752686,
-0.5838051438,
1.0356904268,
-0.1348997205,
-0.0358666964,
0.1595199555,
0.2224840969,
0.4544202685,
-0.266523689,
-0.3518200517,
-0.1883376688,
-0.194666639,
-0.2747943401,
-1.0775212049,
0.6944873333,
-0.6955387592,
-0.7256130576,
-0.02755614,
-0.761652112,
0.1656628549,
0.2037713826,
-0.0138402432,
0.5248099566,
-0.0055417791,
-0.0421385951,
0.3423703015,
0.1438025385,
0.3891562819,
0.2225648612,
0.2950779796,
-0.406008929,
1.0351887941,
0.1131056398,
0.0754993111,
0.4443622828,
0.1762737781,
-0.1251386106,
-0.7675949335,
-0.5221306682,
-0.0413022228,
-0.8630588651,
-0.2139647305,
-0.5207834244,
-0.3230653405,
-0.1842019558,
-0.166813463,
-0.1896805465,
-0.4559969902,
-0.1328641027,
0.0477853641,
0.0722953081,
0.8693338633,
0.1421229541,
0.4356478155,
-0.5281842947,
0.1993253082,
0.2618769109,
0.3693813384,
0.246039778,
-0.2550411522,
-0.0829242319,
0.0331392251,
-0.3496782482,
-0.7420307398,
0.3771817684,
0.2477314323,
0.491618067,
0.0410183482,
-0.3512106836,
0.5274967551,
-1.0645731688,
0.2360202521,
-0.0857976526,
-0.8441669345,
0.1293635815,
-0.1236560792,
-0.0272529311,
0.4964518547,
0.0952196494,
-0.470805347,
0.0393549316,
-0.568585813,
-0.7013836503,
0.4376733899,
0.1877634674,
0.3664180934,
-0.0623804666,
0.9168325663,
-0.0831952095,
0.3485019803,
-0.5132543445,
-0.3088421524,
-0.250225395,
-0.5060870647,
-0.0861045942,
0.1252599508,
0.0140893059,
-0.2132053077,
0.5108344555,
-0.1130428389,
0.4026386142,
0.1014459804,
-0.0255295206,
0.1193594635,
0.1685218662,
0.6374417543,
0.5264942646,
0.2832882702,
0.2151928246,
-0.0819911659,
-0.1839416921,
0.3188180029,
0.1182536855,
-0.4988797605,
-0.1548301429,
0.3896347582,
0.6595198512,
0.2280777097,
-0.5547889471,
0.1487548053,
0.1112375334,
-0.4420090616,
-0.3551212847,
0.3400705457,
0.2762981653,
0.4014183283,
0.2360859066,
0.2660037279,
0.2512991726,
-0.4679151475,
0.3759597242,
0.4392972887,
-0.1981056333,
-0.5174172521,
0.411958158,
-0.0000221008,
-1.0514065027,
0.7224292159,
-0.0348791182,
-0.7287428975,
0.9464181662,
1.0018043518,
0.9069025517,
-0.1787489206,
0.1988759935,
-0.0595781952,
0.4421197176,
-0.0471833386,
0.5850030184,
-0.1246114448,
-0.5736807585,
-0.5419057608,
-0.6230089664,
-0.0888858214,
-0.1087820604,
-0.1531811208,
-0.1337078661,
-0.772172451,
0.3311578631,
0.2765855789,
-0.2816096246,
-0.4434705079,
0.1848612726,
-0.2391662002,
0.9259261489,
-0.7345237136,
0.4488523602,
0.8729783297,
-0.4052070081,
-1.1071116924,
-0.3418525159,
-0.2127368152,
-0.816646874,
0.9577609301,
0.0342011973,
-0.2207440287,
0.0602004193,
-0.284216851,
-0.8936917186,
0.8499901295,
0.6242392063,
-0.3488697708,
-0.4402669072,
0.0922060385,
0.8040623069,
-0.625462234,
0.1699761003,
0.452932328,
0.3486205041,
0.0764686093,
-0.7259161472,
0.1399430186,
-0.6993340254,
-0.2250616103,
0.2580552399,
-0.4400550723,
1.3765819073,
0.0443632938,
0.1376364231,
0.4455744922,
0.5081449747,
0.0848123059,
0.2245756239,
0.3442211449,
0.6248149872,
0.3854614794,
0.1081871688,
0.9871448874,
-0.1184481308,
-0.0848057419,
1.0219051838,
-0.0753142089,
0.8256809711,
0.5831058621,
0.1641167402,
0.6538482308,
0.1935706586,
0.0485363789,
0.4293760359,
1.0007176399,
-0.3362600803,
-0.235118404,
0.2094281912,
-0.018192973,
0.5648995638,
0.0895205215,
-0.6970439553,
-0.524744153,
-0.1993826479,
-0.407125175,
0.1390863657,
-0.384475857,
0.6470385194,
-0.0278266594,
-0.9112430215,
0.4783788621,
0.2783608735,
0.3970575631,
-0.493445009,
-0.3894700408,
-0.0023957829,
0.5511513948,
-0.1257074475,
-0.3338962495,
0.6259118319,
-0.3560755253,
-0.2411068678,
-0.2250667065,
0.3851912916,
-0.163108632,
-0.7765330672,
-0.0723183975,
0.4781966209,
0.1374270171,
-0.3230475485,
-0.6114008427,
-0.1108785421,
0.064762488,
-0.1347475201,
0.0036978221,
0.3963904977,
-0.3121772408,
0.9159579873,
0.740616858,
0.0875036344,
0.3538163006,
-0.0412896201,
1.0770816803,
-0.5691645741,
-0.5771884918,
-0.7612868547,
0.1211454272,
0.1943928301,
-0.3581437469,
0.3112359047,
0.2901732028,
0.6454963088,
-0.1724052727,
0.6136146188,
0.1615864038,
-0.1167984158,
-0.4688096046,
0.6388097405,
-0.4833790362,
0.3215302527,
0.0444542468,
-0.8249730468,
-0.5394798517,
0.6896702647,
-0.3393604159,
0.1004600003,
0.5332272649,
0.8767142296,
-0.1552296728,
0.1502822191,
0.1795326471,
-0.041285526,
0.4631379545,
0.9442713857,
0.8406536579,
-0.332092464,
0.4095663726,
-0.1688667536,
-0.1982850134,
0.1208855063,
-0.53089571,
-0.5722320676,
-0.4559070468,
-0.1038242728,
-0.0696417168,
0.3618561625,
0.9286006689,
0.5133107901,
-0.5542553663,
-0.0800841823,
-0.5596811771,
0.1435074657,
-0.4826940298,
-0.114467591,
0.5846694112,
-0.4743883312,
-0.5989847779,
0.6157559156,
0.0733346567,
-0.4237060547,
-0.3362389803,
0.053164389,
0.0677771345,
0.2075509727,
0.4556568265,
0.2418489456,
-0.555573523,
-0.1992410719,
0.3486766219,
0.155855611,
-0.1047820896,
1.2412493229,
-0.6957629919,
0.1085469574,
0.5454887748,
1.083545208,
0.1033063084,
-0.2691913545,
0.6482350826,
-0.5338218808,
-0.2730572522,
0.3332285583,
0.5665092468,
0.0295064636,
-0.2838504016,
-0.0591522641,
0.1750032753,
-0.2709460557,
-0.3858361244,
0.652762711,
-0.4348731637,
-0.3820109963,
0.6141523123,
-0.1659700423,
-0.7124117613,
-0.1101815552,
-0.2006431818,
0.157141462,
-0.2229825109,
0.9693921208,
0.2853403687,
-0.2822871208,
0.0080598583,
-0.0436392576,
0.1499522477,
0.696502924,
-0.628549099,
0.2292151153,
0.531267941,
0.3753596842,
0.4177769125,
0.61817801,
0.0596105233,
0.5356755257,
0.0178924706,
0.0086360034,
-0.5547421575,
-0.629756391,
-0.4513347745,
0.4718127549,
-0.4283998013,
-0.1723531932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17400v1
|
Investigating Continual Pretraining in Large Language Models: Insights and Implications
| 2024-02-27T10:47:24 | 2024-02-27T10:47:24 |
Çağatay Yıldız, Nishaanth Kanna Ravichandran, Prishruit Punia, Matthias Bethge, Beyza Ermis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper studies the evolving domain of Continual Learning (CL) in large
language models (LLMs), with a focus on developing strategies for efficient and
sustainable training. Our primary emphasis is on continual domain-adaptive
pretraining, a process designed to equip LLMs with the ability to integrate new
information from various domains while retaining previously learned knowledge
and enhancing cross-domain knowledge transfer without relying on
domain-specific identification. Unlike previous studies, which mostly
concentrate on a limited selection of tasks or domains and primarily aim to
address the issue of forgetting, our research evaluates the adaptability and
capabilities of LLMs to changing data landscapes in practical scenarios. To
this end, we introduce a new benchmark designed to measure the adaptability of
LLMs to these evolving data environments, offering a comprehensive framework
for evaluation. We examine the impact of model size on learning efficacy and
forgetting, as well as how the progression and similarity of emerging domains
affect the knowledge transfer within these models. Our findings uncover several
key insights: (i) when the sequence of domains shows semantic similarity,
continual pretraining enables LLMs to better specialize in the current domain
compared to stand-alone fine-tuning, (ii) training across a diverse range of
domains enhances both backward and forward knowledge transfer, and (iii)
smaller models are particularly sensitive to continual pretraining, showing the
most significant rates of both forgetting and learning. We posit that our
research marks a shift towards establishing a more realistic benchmark for
investigating CL in LLMs, and has the potential to play a key role in guiding
the direction of future research in the field.
|
[
-0.3069397211,
-0.5687798858,
0.6052703261,
0.0703576803,
-0.2198393941,
0.1406679749,
-0.5862367749,
-0.3480698168,
-0.2950303853,
0.3758769035,
-0.5809037089,
-0.2771010995,
-0.7023612857,
0.0433647633,
-0.285468787,
0.8775131702,
-0.264477849,
-0.0368850194,
-0.4178160727,
-0.2696431577,
-0.925176084,
-0.7046297789,
-0.821580708,
-0.3722419441,
0.6449767351,
0.211567387,
0.1923734546,
0.3709038198,
0.2935583293,
0.2143189609,
0.0907411799,
-0.0174339302,
-1.0849707127,
0.1522442251,
-0.4659756422,
-0.3992599547,
-0.4300269485,
-0.0746611953,
1.1905878782,
1.0508729219,
-0.1275939941,
0.2334936112,
0.4608809948,
0.7255026698,
-0.6924196482,
-0.0991415679,
-1.099719882,
-0.1695719808,
-0.2790026665,
-0.2205052078,
-0.4188550711,
-0.1370362937,
0.4338565171,
-0.7089942098,
0.023063425,
0.0314033665,
0.6680929065,
0.175628826,
-0.1428682655,
-0.3766300976,
-0.7645938396,
0.9755160213,
-0.5732324719,
0.6262922883,
0.0337120779,
0.1703706533,
-0.2446960956,
-0.9281468391,
-0.3961597681,
-0.2748762071,
0.2546234429,
-0.0124281384,
-0.0500812083,
-0.3337272108,
0.0950654298,
0.1047805399,
-0.6256344914,
0.2920549214,
-0.1251727194,
-0.0394114256,
0.3884036243,
0.1447645128,
0.2955863178,
0.8296412826,
-0.3555232584,
0.097125411,
-1.0996536016,
-0.1750976145,
-0.0635910034,
0.0765382871,
-0.0812816024,
-0.0868793279,
0.0704612583,
0.674258709,
-0.1193192229,
-0.0622006021,
0.1817542762,
-0.3392648995,
-0.0723903701,
-0.1119527742,
0.3998511434,
0.1133784652,
0.6890913844,
-0.3004004061,
-0.2769858539,
-0.2307143211,
0.5379574299,
-0.5941479802,
-0.3676436245,
-0.2036325186,
-0.2634458244,
0.2853671908,
-0.1987970024,
-0.5515437126,
-0.025900634,
-0.5796338916,
0.5587329268,
-0.5285912752,
-0.3846649826,
0.334708184,
0.245175004,
0.2044843733,
0.4130549133,
-0.8159638047,
0.4252415895,
0.6676171422,
0.9890589714,
-0.7106727362,
-0.7550595403,
-0.283324033,
0.1751442254,
-0.5434316397,
0.6996864676,
-0.4885412753,
-0.4313275814,
0.0444265269,
0.2586315572,
-0.6085324287,
-0.9069337249,
0.0075715329,
-0.7220664024,
-0.2142391056,
-0.2890990674,
-0.6709551215,
0.0698361024,
0.34420982,
-0.3576521873,
0.7735645771,
0.2024536133,
-0.3849368691,
0.5807936192,
-0.4302735031,
-0.212259829,
0.1002161577,
0.2189172655,
-0.6092607379,
0.167316556,
-0.3164462447,
0.3159751892,
-0.2203507125,
0.330697,
-0.5784512758,
-0.2425099909,
0.3369769454,
-0.2847931385,
0.4038384259,
-0.029442627,
-0.1469016075,
0.0117065897,
-0.6552062035,
-0.0596040972,
0.2938110232,
-0.1257251203,
-0.4248452783,
0.0484377295,
-0.2838869393,
0.3425180018,
0.3303976953,
-0.2735969722,
0.3129469454,
-0.1028872281,
0.2809556425,
0.8438190222,
0.3747921884,
0.4051635265,
-0.5720969439,
0.426156044,
0.1118578613,
0.1521584094,
-0.2234945595,
0.0564507358,
-0.8482753038,
0.0266812462,
0.3671626449,
0.2515837848,
-0.547355473,
0.2650617361,
-0.6789201498,
-0.4802799225,
-0.0037641986,
0.4815751612,
0.3010614514,
0.2538957,
0.4221982956,
-0.7104073167,
-0.478944391,
-0.3822407126,
-0.2114312351,
0.0890674442,
0.1968439221,
0.2235625535,
0.8563722968,
-0.3462009132,
0.7440690994,
-0.1733202934,
-0.1979527175,
-0.2102558613,
-0.1146372035,
-0.0156720262,
0.5975425243,
0.7138535976,
-0.4986405671,
-0.5997164249,
0.0305639524,
-0.7573345304,
0.1173899174,
-0.4051168263,
-0.146405369,
0.0446943268,
0.5635793209,
-0.447583735,
-0.0156109314,
0.5309391618,
-0.0294090863,
0.8768453598,
-0.1588077694,
-0.17043598,
-0.565189302,
0.2157569975,
-0.3248333037,
-0.1653686464,
-0.7946161628,
-0.1984914541,
0.0104302326,
0.1776138991,
-0.4226287603,
0.8386107087,
-0.6135671139,
-0.0847828016,
-0.2880686522,
0.2425289601,
-0.3177146018,
0.3314544261,
0.0873508006,
0.9123351574,
0.7849445939,
-1.1084840298,
-0.0608995892,
0.014003003,
-0.4504289031,
0.4507517815,
-0.5636069775,
0.3206070662,
0.1524218768,
0.2909357846,
-0.7082974911,
0.171264559,
-0.0424017422,
-0.3105881512,
0.4409570694,
-0.01987027,
-0.3577695489,
-0.3041720092,
0.0999915302,
0.4561053813,
0.5609807968,
-0.4464614391,
0.4485639334,
0.2692601383,
-0.5093790293,
-0.3509614468,
-0.2369649708,
0.0322949365,
-0.3441208303,
-0.3621229827,
0.3713712394,
-0.2803621888,
-0.0991543755,
-0.1429493278,
-0.3636384308,
0.022586314,
0.4817224741,
0.0588954873,
0.2012476772,
-0.4661482573,
0.2802772522,
-0.2705792785,
-0.0610315651,
0.2391656786,
-0.8763071299,
0.7227463722,
-0.005090761,
-0.2144519389,
-0.2454260141,
-0.0290407594,
0.5320987701,
-0.1543102562,
1.0650645494,
0.3296197653,
-0.2559069097,
-0.5828834176,
-0.5354046822,
-0.0671626776,
-0.4480276108,
0.4519659579,
-0.4840938449,
-1.1155422926,
0.4941990972,
-0.6690363884,
0.0978037715,
0.56953758,
0.578076303,
-0.1022665277,
0.365647316,
1.0291218758,
-0.1742092371,
0.5386975408,
-0.1708914191,
-0.0488682762,
-0.9083600044,
-0.1361059099,
-0.2757649124,
-0.0494592227,
-0.0745456293,
-0.27989012,
0.080411382,
0.3575024307,
-0.4589072168,
0.1216440648,
0.0426006317,
0.3778889775,
-0.0068069049,
-0.0870755687,
0.0812100768,
-0.2183783948,
0.0794614777,
0.0872480795,
-0.8652543426,
-0.3631320298,
1.2550419569,
0.3425312638,
0.5496620536,
0.0697624311,
0.5293021798,
0.2641951442,
0.5981729627,
-0.3606928885,
0.3906134665,
-0.0646552145,
-0.2650692463,
-0.387504071,
-0.345276773,
-1.1339780092,
0.0102528762,
-0.0385329612,
-0.6137224436,
0.0728522241,
0.2751867473,
-0.2216806263,
0.3308215141,
-0.3830066919,
0.9830560088,
-0.5502892733,
-0.4588537216,
-0.2913280427,
-0.4407379031,
0.1342801005,
-0.7681487203,
0.1025043726,
-0.0760903284,
0.0060919821,
0.8638628125,
-0.0199622512,
0.9096816778,
-0.2292103767,
-0.2034118921,
0.3063752651,
-0.0197146293,
0.3931031823,
-0.1466592997,
0.0630776212,
0.3523560166,
-0.0084209712,
-0.5777366161,
-0.4649119377,
0.6821805239,
-0.8043018579,
-0.579051435,
-0.2733479738,
-0.4221364558,
-0.6635371447,
0.3898612559,
0.0318532996,
0.2525441051,
-0.5049245358,
0.3532834351,
1.1478872299,
-0.2703498602,
0.1609719843,
0.6852231026,
-0.2226817161,
0.0501213409,
1.0983151197,
0.3165002763,
0.689596653,
0.1956761628,
-0.0115717817,
-0.180458799,
-0.970164001,
-0.1183321998,
0.4021708071,
-0.6338623762,
0.0148101123,
-0.6336007714,
-0.2662192881,
-0.3796369135,
-0.2544927597,
-0.504347086,
0.1415374428,
-0.3997873366,
0.1691264957,
0.0844820663,
0.7157257199,
0.1420256943,
0.4057549238,
-0.7778718472,
0.0129028447,
0.3260916471,
0.4551385343,
0.258143276,
-1.0877817869,
-0.5057955384,
-0.0779281482,
-0.2082220614,
-0.2389587462,
0.2804753184,
0.5694640875,
0.9109321833,
0.0880208015,
-0.1764526367,
0.6863186359,
-0.7435883284,
0.8587622046,
0.1910579652,
-0.8181270361,
0.3168552518,
-0.3258854151,
0.6060495973,
0.6681447625,
0.7488583922,
-0.5205039382,
-0.0483394638,
-0.4855378866,
-0.7372415066,
0.3884827793,
-0.2569307983,
0.211361438,
0.2340171337,
0.6181558967,
0.3523725569,
0.0750748962,
-0.5679849982,
-0.1346522123,
0.1082626283,
0.0575938001,
-0.3856586814,
-0.3442543149,
0.0545335822,
-0.2319925725,
0.7449537516,
-0.1166058555,
0.2652733624,
-0.2643029094,
-0.6249762774,
0.2098257393,
0.1211117357,
0.5916759968,
1.2375360727,
0.0015260072,
-0.0436219014,
0.7093418837,
-0.589804709,
0.1867780238,
-0.2384234369,
0.1095427796,
-0.1186368838,
0.6118118167,
0.8678857088,
0.4052405059,
-0.6757075787,
0.3580283225,
0.089956902,
-0.3025673032,
-0.6184945703,
0.2428349853,
0.0103939995,
-0.0286510084,
0.2944490314,
0.1115989015,
-0.4241280258,
-0.6251511574,
0.457891196,
0.2223920673,
-0.4617233574,
-0.4490545392,
0.3481240273,
-0.0507066771,
-0.0395303778,
0.6551090479,
-0.0030919716,
-0.4804495871,
0.3905039728,
0.7139134407,
0.6992454529,
-0.3323924839,
-0.1994086355,
0.3134535253,
0.2126416564,
-0.3908726871,
-0.2331727743,
-0.0808138028,
-0.8400509953,
-0.3435441554,
-0.804770112,
-0.33000049,
0.241078794,
-0.6534534693,
0.0186244585,
-0.4798292816,
-0.0666785464,
-0.1845470369,
-0.0861689746,
-0.8547511697,
0.3681176305,
0.2005852908,
0.9041801691,
-0.7442660928,
1.2541706562,
0.4044382274,
0.0066555743,
-0.4829142392,
0.083637394,
0.045347549,
-0.8112834096,
0.677128911,
0.1261599809,
-0.4050352871,
0.2300012261,
-0.5893548131,
-1.1048010588,
1.1887872219,
0.174773097,
-0.8650013208,
0.0233196337,
0.0091312826,
0.5476865768,
-0.6271106601,
-0.2393398732,
0.8328966498,
0.2001312524,
-0.041474428,
-0.859968245,
-0.1638890803,
-0.1713625342,
0.0563376993,
0.1618954092,
-0.6168443561,
0.7047986388,
-0.0473271981,
-0.3532423675,
0.2137170881,
0.6508966088,
0.2077880353,
0.2668867707,
0.4973244369,
0.4300626516,
0.7529577613,
-0.1203284189,
0.827591598,
-0.4399143457,
0.3301627934,
1.2687128782,
-0.6012396812,
0.8375021219,
0.2783657014,
-0.2566697598,
0.5620916486,
0.5970080495,
-0.0031014031,
0.481600672,
0.3984569609,
-0.2406257093,
-0.3476215303,
0.0779653564,
-0.5005103946,
0.0917256624,
0.640766561,
-0.1069135219,
0.0360356495,
0.3172417879,
-0.0628522709,
-0.0561080389,
-0.5023280382,
0.772762537,
0.3660999238,
-0.6826055646,
0.7412219048,
-0.3940953314,
0.6527981758,
-1.0277016163,
0.2331636697,
-0.2146611363,
0.3375356793,
0.19258596,
-0.517168045,
0.2443185896,
-0.07637804,
-0.1832640469,
-0.4328152239,
0.6046279669,
-0.3465903699,
-0.0588473491,
0.4838256836,
0.5111045241,
0.1884483546,
0.0632288456,
-0.7863071561,
0.434387207,
-0.1166345179,
-0.2343278378,
0.8204964995,
0.5751985908,
-0.0927396119,
0.8414379954,
0.6199108958,
0.2969175875,
0.1903294921,
0.1102240086,
0.8888173699,
-0.5945322514,
-0.2660423517,
-0.698209703,
0.2764613032,
0.1711477637,
-0.5875826478,
0.8161848187,
0.3539862633,
1.1712503433,
-0.1532961577,
0.7725894451,
0.3068044782,
0.3703439236,
-0.7998205423,
0.7085154653,
-0.5733020306,
0.3315648735,
-0.0037108404,
-1.0483227968,
-0.1873787194,
0.3109826148,
-0.6328992248,
0.2784712315,
0.839923501,
0.4659709334,
-0.0193839725,
-0.3139038086,
0.3958738744,
0.3424912691,
0.1625089496,
0.7035747766,
0.9227896333,
-0.0295540392,
0.1674710512,
0.2049703002,
0.0082819369,
0.0159288365,
-0.6768478155,
-0.8263761997,
-0.682585597,
-0.4088908136,
-0.1007673219,
0.5088564754,
0.6598103642,
0.6266302466,
-0.8508941531,
-0.2285800427,
-0.1014830992,
-0.2398119122,
-0.2842638195,
-0.1134515554,
0.3415307403,
-0.6841707826,
-0.2604255676,
0.2910874784,
0.3708522618,
0.0111112213,
-0.2094844282,
-0.2388283014,
-0.2932424843,
0.0195886828,
0.6614205241,
0.5713114142,
-0.3809675872,
-0.460046798,
-0.1104723588,
0.0565589555,
-0.032497827,
0.9250119328,
-0.7025739551,
0.3067193329,
-0.1700578332,
1.0459730625,
0.5227814913,
-0.2037976831,
0.5810863376,
-0.481100589,
-0.0385374799,
0.1766373515,
0.2435472757,
0.3509198725,
0.0256011374,
0.3125480413,
0.4602835178,
-0.8245539069,
-0.7590894103,
0.1736142784,
-0.7307733893,
-0.3902088404,
1.0998728275,
-0.5360668302,
-0.1304561943,
-0.4246513247,
0.2753151357,
-0.0025453079,
0.1937743127,
0.5952480435,
0.7285345793,
0.026762655,
-0.2496951818,
-0.6838572621,
0.4695504308,
0.4682396054,
-0.7718395591,
0.2097147852,
0.2786913514,
0.772854507,
-0.1224616468,
0.7730122209,
0.051146131,
0.2742113471,
0.124545075,
-0.131551072,
0.2485064119,
-0.7285822034,
-0.4677732587,
-0.0565869845,
0.3399525881,
0.2233674675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17396v1
|
Benchmarking GPT-4 on Algorithmic Problems: A Systematic Evaluation of Prompting Strategies
| 2024-02-27T10:44:52 | 2024-02-27T10:44:52 |
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of Natural
Language Processing thanks to their ability to reuse knowledge acquired on
massive text corpora on a wide variety of downstream tasks, with minimal (if
any) tuning steps. At the same time, it has been repeatedly shown that LLMs
lack systematic generalization, which allows to extrapolate the learned
statistical regularities outside the training distribution. In this work, we
offer a systematic benchmarking of GPT-4, one of the most advanced LLMs
available, on three algorithmic tasks characterized by the possibility to
control the problem difficulty with two parameters. We compare the performance
of GPT-4 with that of its predecessor (GPT-3.5) and with a variant of the
Transformer-Encoder architecture recently introduced to solve similar tasks,
the Neural Data Router. We find that the deployment of advanced prompting
techniques allows GPT-4 to reach superior accuracy on all tasks, demonstrating
that state-of-the-art LLMs constitute a very strong baseline also in
challenging tasks that require systematic generalization.
|
[
-0.3113214672,
-0.8831400871,
0.7934874296,
0.3686385155,
-0.0995356888,
0.0346607901,
-0.5549155474,
-0.1514705271,
-0.2626855969,
0.0792427137,
-0.5645021796,
-0.562063098,
-0.680455029,
0.6466438174,
-0.3551389575,
1.0057555437,
-0.3873452246,
0.2015474141,
-0.0396653377,
0.1083336845,
-0.6651294827,
-0.381346643,
-0.9097477794,
-0.4134190977,
0.5352314711,
0.1647815555,
0.5624756217,
0.52152282,
0.6195693612,
0.3319987655,
-0.0305037946,
-0.1402114928,
-0.3648394346,
0.3602266014,
-0.0024731464,
-0.4797226489,
-0.2748494446,
-0.0545557477,
0.696796298,
0.6588541865,
-0.2256071717,
-0.0012643539,
0.1184724197,
0.7305417657,
-0.2354777902,
0.3178676367,
-0.5311079025,
0.0501467027,
-0.2731273472,
-0.1499432325,
-0.1416425109,
-0.7090269923,
0.1970985085,
-0.7431022525,
0.5281918049,
-0.0186137483,
0.6095753908,
0.4825342596,
-0.1222534105,
-0.4869439304,
-0.7331651449,
0.6252819896,
-0.5156040788,
0.5610274673,
0.3730976582,
0.3214350641,
-0.1422829479,
-0.8820870519,
-0.4453245401,
-0.3401821554,
0.3721020818,
0.0459069647,
-0.4606359601,
0.0658219382,
0.6237703562,
0.2766029537,
-0.6486283541,
0.0826382414,
-0.3670337498,
-0.2071680129,
0.1888438314,
0.0732218698,
-0.0482884869,
0.1602514535,
-0.1782941371,
-0.1603350341,
-0.7694485188,
-0.0672009215,
0.4483035803,
0.0702787265,
0.1640446782,
0.2083310634,
-0.4822262824,
0.6941043735,
0.1775975227,
0.3053124547,
0.4358411133,
-0.3852390945,
0.0536931641,
-0.3603389561,
0.9087274075,
0.3230344951,
0.4418458045,
-0.1967257857,
-0.4342055619,
0.1205516085,
0.2746342719,
-0.6454365849,
-0.4217499495,
0.0100937961,
-0.2269903719,
0.057947278,
-0.3737217188,
-0.8830860853,
-0.243561551,
-0.2514729202,
0.3475959003,
-0.4141710699,
0.0159516223,
0.0864292458,
-0.0842490792,
0.4397250116,
0.2030694038,
-1.158188343,
0.6085829139,
0.8306955099,
1.0775752068,
-0.4287314415,
-0.2196849734,
-0.6309102178,
-0.1297691315,
-0.4413009286,
0.7558887601,
-0.6266654134,
-0.2448406816,
0.1272066981,
-0.2141077667,
-0.1345723867,
-0.6463744044,
1.0426453352,
-0.5933990479,
0.1384474784,
-0.6669744849,
-0.6191511154,
-0.0940702483,
0.5738357902,
-0.6981927752,
1.0527929068,
0.0575982183,
-0.6275804639,
0.2537398338,
-0.6578654051,
-0.2085908055,
0.22228764,
-0.3482506871,
-0.2672380805,
0.1334193498,
0.4260390699,
0.3332135677,
-0.5171887279,
0.2518333495,
0.0135129876,
-0.4965108931,
-0.1302094162,
-0.5816084146,
0.2400398403,
0.0301151536,
-0.6446140409,
0.1864110082,
-0.4308456481,
-0.0059994231,
0.1830862164,
-0.4583222866,
-0.0702695549,
-0.0358484685,
-0.4199383557,
0.106547676,
0.3038053513,
-0.3835919201,
0.3067442775,
-0.2193831652,
0.5194804072,
0.7320031524,
-0.0347169489,
0.1776255816,
-0.3407828212,
0.7126594782,
-0.299010545,
0.0843277276,
-0.1497896612,
-0.7657686472,
-0.6316072941,
-0.0179120768,
0.4365286827,
0.6026188731,
-0.9104511738,
0.0955014974,
-0.3584367633,
-0.3001301587,
-0.4178777039,
0.2904816866,
0.3552404344,
0.4446303546,
0.4971704483,
-0.2492273748,
-0.2231759727,
-0.8637849092,
-0.3704963028,
0.070057027,
-0.2896160483,
0.168610394,
0.2533894777,
-0.1084684134,
0.6837185025,
-0.2070051134,
-0.0645462275,
-0.2622207999,
0.3464503288,
0.3801867962,
0.2715616822,
0.0827730894,
-0.5806420445,
-0.4728860855,
-0.1701697558,
-0.7175165415,
-0.365588218,
0.1094608605,
0.3290132582,
0.1263656318,
0.6580830216,
-0.7289912105,
0.0806464553,
0.6097297072,
0.0898077488,
0.6158460975,
-0.422339648,
0.1205116063,
-0.5655378699,
0.0225580484,
0.092725426,
0.0547757298,
-0.9695903659,
-0.1989509314,
0.1974838972,
-0.0294791777,
-0.0433224067,
0.2612120211,
-0.5410949588,
-0.0590940751,
-0.1252136528,
0.1250616759,
-0.2905125022,
0.5253052711,
0.0325200371,
0.8078641295,
0.6260045767,
-0.570248127,
0.6403963566,
0.1256634891,
-0.0867691636,
0.3921479285,
-0.8989646435,
0.5738788843,
-0.0460892841,
0.2680095136,
-1.0588816404,
-0.0671714768,
0.2056318969,
-0.2727829814,
0.1989209056,
0.0184498187,
-0.6714937687,
-0.5494588017,
-0.3779510856,
0.4895567,
0.6807476878,
-0.4331281781,
0.4359225035,
-0.22488603,
-0.5405541062,
-0.2501327097,
-0.3041275144,
0.3032248318,
-0.2635189295,
-0.3288155496,
0.4006031752,
-0.1974627227,
-0.0167760663,
-0.2586746812,
-0.0419602282,
0.1144625023,
-0.1917054951,
-0.041091457,
0.0649280399,
-0.0717104599,
-0.0066737426,
-0.1711501777,
-0.3139957786,
0.3513397276,
-0.3077266812,
0.6654003263,
-0.2155382931,
-0.5894921422,
-0.3852464557,
0.1596703082,
0.1486870944,
-0.0920185372,
0.0628194436,
0.4379716218,
-0.2056530565,
-0.0656554177,
-0.7360030413,
-0.3415338099,
-0.4992012978,
0.2564888597,
-0.4922665358,
-0.8010920882,
0.4645335376,
-0.3443403542,
0.08888302,
0.1742789894,
0.4807701409,
0.2784474194,
1.1603940725,
0.3342003226,
-0.3512229919,
0.4065832198,
-0.0927783847,
0.1455790251,
-0.7133355141,
-0.1153428704,
-0.6249571443,
-0.3220680058,
-0.6943829656,
-0.3830285966,
0.4915586114,
-0.0070041083,
-0.2810904086,
0.1354409307,
-0.4701857865,
0.4209911823,
0.6937829256,
-0.1008826345,
0.3618442118,
-0.0938996077,
-0.2207294554,
-0.0083031263,
-0.7957887053,
-0.4214248061,
1.1435097456,
0.390391022,
0.6389909387,
0.0218383372,
0.6793122292,
-0.0970085263,
0.2877602577,
-0.6686723232,
0.5586332083,
0.1013572663,
-0.2512181401,
-0.280064702,
-0.5996515155,
-1.0915249586,
0.0734655187,
0.0934299901,
-0.5489817858,
-0.1220496967,
0.272705555,
-0.276643306,
0.0622179434,
-0.5832226276,
0.7064407468,
-0.1243077591,
-0.2996422052,
-0.0024537025,
-0.5367165804,
0.157574743,
-0.2494286448,
0.2470822632,
0.0552548878,
-0.2842483222,
0.7344502211,
0.0084252693,
0.6678430438,
-0.3336025178,
-0.0585526191,
-0.0338642411,
0.0192540623,
0.8923741579,
-0.2934702039,
-0.1369590759,
0.1719399095,
-0.3471193016,
-0.2718798816,
-0.6397388577,
0.7074346542,
-0.5404096246,
-0.5637130737,
-0.385483861,
-0.4326404631,
-0.5287672877,
0.2923926115,
0.5026009679,
0.5860828161,
-0.1530270875,
0.0713617057,
0.8015648127,
-0.0824283436,
0.6153352857,
0.2567903101,
0.0888209566,
-0.3650633097,
0.8508719802,
0.105945535,
0.26456967,
0.1501872987,
0.3085970879,
-0.5100761056,
-1.0617114305,
-0.5768333673,
0.0872980803,
-0.6484786868,
-0.172012046,
-0.4737405777,
-0.0085543692,
-0.1777621508,
0.0324145034,
-0.1967951804,
0.0156018045,
0.0006606042,
-0.0379657261,
0.3252762556,
1.1821415424,
0.1154544502,
0.1951062083,
-0.5884957314,
0.2901022136,
0.4740191698,
0.6672905684,
-0.1892779619,
-0.4720457494,
-0.0041100625,
-0.2970276475,
-0.4943026304,
-0.8793184161,
0.1509578526,
0.0544758551,
0.6920492649,
0.1521397084,
-0.1318227351,
0.2803087533,
-0.8871713281,
0.8009646535,
0.0297232661,
-0.858909905,
0.3809634745,
-0.6476998329,
0.6267677546,
0.5944799781,
0.5715731382,
-0.5195773244,
-0.3228541017,
-0.5329982638,
-0.8012781143,
0.4031936526,
0.3091745675,
0.0545610003,
-0.1566203833,
0.496250093,
-0.0103240116,
0.2306714058,
-0.5433271527,
0.0268347915,
-0.2395734638,
-0.3469940126,
-0.0610228069,
-0.05937979,
-0.0159273408,
-0.0210658256,
0.536256671,
-0.1790764183,
0.3082413077,
0.1465112567,
0.0473275445,
0.1091143414,
0.3036397696,
0.5988147855,
0.6774010658,
-0.0104747033,
0.1474842876,
0.5070143938,
-0.5082014203,
0.0922952965,
0.390622437,
-0.2097796947,
-0.0016376888,
0.3952867985,
0.7554661036,
0.3143935502,
-0.4609869123,
0.4655595124,
-0.2345825583,
-0.5388531685,
0.079741925,
0.0402265489,
0.0786512867,
0.1799824983,
0.5339452028,
-0.2699458003,
0.3852086961,
-0.1194046363,
0.0168332718,
0.4527243376,
-0.2758002877,
-0.483487308,
0.4838609993,
0.2622121274,
-0.5415264964,
0.5715287328,
-0.3582293391,
-0.6468958855,
0.3139270246,
0.5617253184,
0.915988028,
-0.3248984814,
-0.0597567037,
0.3472875059,
0.3804806769,
-0.5221089125,
0.3314241767,
-0.1003744602,
-0.5582211614,
-0.6576163769,
-0.3229876757,
-0.6785530448,
0.1827817857,
-0.5646323562,
0.0318351686,
-0.5266430974,
-0.1500244439,
-0.0747740492,
0.0582062341,
-0.7975998521,
-0.0963465497,
-0.0511966124,
0.964114666,
-0.6477521062,
0.5838013887,
0.4995064437,
-0.0151604954,
-0.8299967051,
0.1402871609,
0.126288861,
-0.6807742119,
0.4444330931,
0.2672132254,
-0.1233663112,
0.2134675831,
-0.4166406989,
-0.7318047881,
0.9569506049,
0.3438612521,
-0.857734859,
0.0321883,
0.004881979,
0.5894141197,
-0.0232628491,
0.34973526,
0.8662349582,
0.670350194,
0.044482585,
-1.0445456505,
0.1734791845,
-0.2149013579,
0.1625977606,
0.3005007803,
-0.4524501562,
0.7969622612,
0.087931864,
-0.0887868926,
0.0215950366,
0.4802255034,
0.372335881,
0.1832986027,
0.6367078424,
0.3310193419,
0.8751552105,
-0.2387290299,
0.983245194,
-0.2687969804,
0.1641175449,
0.8774987459,
-0.4122309983,
0.7362016439,
0.3012727499,
-0.2935383618,
0.3116510808,
0.5755285025,
0.0071687698,
0.4650273025,
0.5187501311,
-0.430721879,
0.1940156966,
0.2778890431,
-0.3615595102,
0.1204714626,
0.2300436348,
-0.0575500168,
-0.4014460444,
-0.0733519047,
-0.0331161581,
-0.020911321,
-0.3137317598,
1.0098798275,
-0.0759586394,
-0.9851120114,
0.617280066,
-0.1499917507,
0.747708261,
-0.7428973317,
-0.0665934831,
-0.3231643736,
0.0464001298,
0.0579108633,
-0.628880322,
0.1473995298,
0.1396208853,
-0.0930637494,
-0.2777679563,
0.5159291625,
-0.3461197913,
-0.2511804998,
0.2244647145,
0.4401883781,
0.2596838772,
-0.2275114506,
-0.7319268584,
0.3924619555,
-0.1401107609,
-0.4388659894,
0.2280654311,
0.4976553619,
-0.1782886237,
0.6975076199,
0.6099735498,
0.1647619009,
0.168682754,
0.4084743261,
0.9412855506,
-0.7329889536,
-0.2532528937,
-0.9030442834,
-0.1456989944,
-0.043102704,
-0.3429874778,
0.8241164684,
0.3659807742,
0.6255764961,
0.1957806647,
0.8168985248,
0.1665110588,
0.4879068434,
-0.6237504482,
0.0210224167,
0.0730874017,
0.3059530854,
-0.2377593517,
-1.1758571863,
-0.3321544528,
0.5289242268,
-0.5604154468,
0.4212795794,
0.7674788833,
0.7527751327,
0.0569139682,
0.2755686939,
0.1604648083,
0.0954167098,
0.4603570998,
0.630586803,
0.9253405333,
-0.1257541627,
0.6465395689,
0.0540970713,
-0.456197083,
0.0669745654,
-0.9989439249,
-0.7870857716,
-0.4259407222,
-0.0747667551,
-0.0173782185,
0.3182477653,
0.8006850481,
0.595749557,
-0.7749048471,
-0.1143805608,
-0.4159709215,
-0.0714381486,
-0.3280113935,
-0.1037641838,
0.2571365535,
-0.613907516,
-0.7522394061,
0.7071651816,
0.1411026418,
-0.1073949039,
-0.2861299515,
-0.1598517895,
0.0683425963,
-0.1438121945,
0.2710343003,
0.2304939181,
-0.5786579847,
-0.278806597,
0.0260780863,
0.1003897563,
0.0973800793,
0.9470560551,
-0.7140482664,
0.3475202322,
0.5218938589,
0.8416069746,
0.6342369914,
0.1574494243,
0.7977129817,
-0.6209232211,
-0.3790180385,
0.2872157991,
0.2652423084,
0.5976930857,
-0.1393945217,
0.5002788305,
0.0852849707,
-0.8807453513,
-0.6134111285,
0.1420154274,
-0.5258930922,
0.0385625325,
1.1764438152,
-0.0200193021,
0.1051724851,
-0.3645506203,
-0.1698616594,
-0.004629028,
-0.5688599348,
0.4652529061,
0.8135420084,
-0.3309093416,
-0.2559069693,
-1.1035783291,
0.7673974037,
0.579610467,
-0.7448454499,
0.1714922637,
0.3904412687,
0.451518327,
0.0024027016,
0.9009611011,
0.0388995074,
0.1642641872,
-0.1495722979,
-0.1290434301,
-0.037042208,
-0.3368295133,
-0.8733750582,
0.1438354403,
0.1383957565,
-0.0256009884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17392v1
|
Spot the bot: Coarse-Grained Partition of Semantic Paths for Bots and Humans
| 2024-02-27T10:38:37 | 2024-02-27T10:38:37 |
Vasilii A. Gromov, Alexandra S. Kogan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays, technology is rapidly advancing: bots are writing comments,
articles, and reviews. Due to this fact, it is crucial to know if the text was
written by a human or by a bot. This paper focuses on comparing structures of
the coarse-grained partitions of semantic paths for human-written and
bot-generated texts. We compare the clusterizations of datasets of n-grams from
literary texts and texts generated by several bots. The hypothesis is that the
structures and clusterizations are different. Our research supports the
hypothesis. As the semantic structure may be different for different languages,
we investigate Russian, English, German, and Vietnamese languages.
|
[
-0.1488197148,
-1.0887405872,
0.7739607096,
-0.0070077213,
0.0529385917,
0.156800434,
-0.1033156067,
-0.4131578505,
0.2702116668,
0.4788974822,
-0.5628476739,
-0.7136936784,
-0.481236279,
0.3218738437,
-0.4886444807,
0.9736308455,
0.2775763571,
0.0110767819,
-0.4356722236,
-0.1012928709,
-0.3547736406,
-0.3500868976,
-0.4259308577,
-0.0855247006,
0.8679905534,
0.1111946106,
0.7965527773,
0.6835368872,
0.6695408225,
0.4924410582,
-0.1370463073,
-0.1237860546,
-0.0152017232,
0.2858057916,
-0.2598201931,
-0.5866234899,
-0.0756246001,
-0.2391077131,
0.8833899498,
0.7332518101,
0.2860789597,
0.0435273834,
-0.1239309609,
0.8399053812,
-0.413813144,
-0.1352509707,
-0.4777546823,
-0.0158036761,
-0.5246214867,
-0.146121487,
-0.272205323,
-0.4844652414,
0.1131533831,
-0.5168104172,
0.7521178722,
0.0038386311,
0.9676936269,
0.3054305017,
-0.3958382607,
-0.4121319354,
-0.5448945761,
0.9408795834,
-0.5355189443,
0.1537558734,
0.327437222,
0.2813520133,
-0.4609405994,
-0.515548408,
-0.536144495,
-0.3563298881,
-0.2800535262,
-0.1763237417,
-0.0440670326,
-0.1806817502,
0.0932336226,
0.3094494939,
-0.6370765567,
-0.0180568155,
-0.3060874641,
-0.6046934724,
0.6521924138,
0.0848847702,
0.6369019151,
-0.4738764465,
-0.4733391702,
-0.3389826119,
-0.4965233803,
-0.0185506325,
0.5780037642,
0.3422288895,
-0.0286770649,
0.5424298048,
-0.3862460256,
0.9436076283,
-0.3460936248,
-0.4616797864,
0.3130816817,
-0.5795590281,
0.0910884142,
-0.0370873474,
1.0388021469,
0.4350063205,
0.343988657,
-0.4789611697,
-0.1029972583,
0.2557520568,
0.2744612992,
-0.3115671575,
-0.2310312837,
0.0745903701,
-0.5313693285,
-0.3858828247,
0.3202522695,
-0.6580708623,
-0.7695579529,
-0.014839313,
0.325409919,
-0.4476872385,
-0.1236353591,
-0.0380427651,
-0.565648973,
0.4891997576,
0.4112762809,
-0.551238358,
0.3631138802,
0.7196353078,
1.1175938845,
-0.1688573956,
-0.4497980773,
-0.2924832106,
0.0941859707,
-0.3162767887,
1.2385179996,
-0.4659077823,
-0.2311939895,
0.0267660357,
-0.0240683779,
0.103570275,
-0.4487763345,
0.689868331,
-0.3323538899,
0.2553648651,
-0.3706258833,
-0.6272754073,
-0.4511225224,
0.2996199429,
-0.5910121202,
1.1121662855,
0.2290198654,
-0.9018121958,
0.6322602034,
-0.5089356899,
-0.616959393,
0.1141146496,
-0.3798374236,
-0.1558985263,
-0.0309203751,
-0.0644856244,
0.3766545951,
-0.1383525878,
0.2453501821,
-0.1385928839,
-0.1695195436,
0.322619319,
-0.204118371,
0.6863819957,
0.1088139415,
-0.3603869975,
0.2987162769,
-1.0260523558,
-0.1035978869,
0.2044441551,
-0.3453809023,
-0.5112540126,
0.6282639503,
0.3233813345,
0.0661404729,
0.3266868293,
-0.8331000805,
0.256105125,
-0.2705717981,
0.4772212207,
0.8374629617,
-0.0390117504,
0.6356424689,
-0.5090374947,
0.3662291765,
0.0499423034,
-0.0577972122,
-0.3206997216,
-0.7310859561,
-0.6137852669,
-0.1557859778,
0.3785538375,
0.5080714226,
-0.4622935355,
0.5396885872,
-0.292886585,
-0.6091378331,
-0.4658474326,
-0.1234842315,
0.3591830134,
0.2976002991,
0.1554699689,
-0.3262224495,
-0.1609329432,
-0.6978898644,
-0.4752482474,
-0.2695276737,
-0.2490632534,
0.3261137009,
0.3923253715,
-0.0930216759,
1.1361632347,
-0.674733758,
-0.2890607119,
-0.1619300842,
0.0908675492,
-0.1470768005,
0.4948045313,
0.6503700614,
-0.6914004087,
-0.7057144642,
0.0829921439,
-0.4619598985,
-0.1894367635,
-0.0735381767,
-0.3271617889,
0.2722796202,
0.7391440868,
-0.4150419533,
0.5809580684,
0.2258710116,
-0.6551935673,
0.3480812907,
-0.2930498421,
0.0774632394,
-0.9354388714,
-0.0205256995,
-0.161288932,
-0.3890751004,
-0.6312510967,
-0.1210684329,
-0.3212364912,
0.2567715049,
-0.2239540219,
0.6554194689,
-0.2430916578,
-0.2579512894,
-0.3291436732,
0.4310069978,
-0.1746900678,
0.4058474898,
0.1530492008,
0.443947047,
0.5126312971,
-0.462079823,
0.0196446255,
0.0596506447,
-0.4562483728,
0.5114521384,
-0.7359700799,
0.2206245065,
-0.0582226515,
0.3578217924,
-1.3156172037,
-0.3757298887,
0.2514566481,
-0.5669488907,
-0.1703953892,
-0.0148233492,
-0.9541983008,
-0.0103993751,
-0.3687701821,
0.379268676,
0.2862552404,
0.1415452361,
0.4883750975,
0.5448531508,
-0.1146565825,
-0.2241507322,
-0.3690313399,
0.2324192524,
-0.1460470259,
-0.9658691883,
0.1783718467,
-0.0040733232,
-0.5155767202,
0.072299622,
0.1549526304,
-0.2629021406,
0.2599294186,
0.3479123712,
-0.0273546297,
-0.284432888,
0.1392596215,
-0.0966391936,
-0.1363098621,
-0.1323328614,
-0.0558454283,
0.7858449221,
0.0589345656,
-0.0586747639,
-0.4438033402,
0.4570572674,
0.4239585698,
0.1027532145,
0.7492924929,
0.7585226893,
-0.072374858,
0.0604769588,
-0.4754683077,
-0.0524704121,
-0.4788241386,
0.0749046579,
-0.1549000144,
-0.8943784833,
0.535351336,
0.1605442762,
-0.0079906909,
0.8145506382,
0.6160677075,
-0.0473909266,
0.8041857481,
0.8549714684,
-0.174118042,
0.5177232623,
0.1635843813,
0.1372798681,
-0.4804988205,
-0.0715658888,
-0.9214852452,
-0.4947497845,
-1.015758276,
-0.331923306,
0.1804807484,
-0.19382824,
-0.1182381883,
0.4331962764,
-0.6518207192,
0.5378001928,
0.9365776181,
-0.0935316682,
0.2750573754,
-0.1216914356,
-0.1091289893,
0.1658318192,
-0.6836520433,
-0.8325294256,
0.8962397575,
-0.0841680393,
0.2975854278,
-0.0067318473,
0.5469486117,
0.6277516484,
-0.106738545,
-0.7539436221,
0.643510282,
-0.1070314273,
-0.8946558237,
-0.4298085272,
-0.2319721878,
-1.2460808754,
0.2014876902,
-0.0388466641,
-0.8622645736,
0.0598625168,
-0.2192617357,
-0.0766974837,
0.2783111334,
-0.8914553523,
0.98063308,
0.1269152761,
0.0719252825,
-0.1136471629,
-1.0801385641,
-0.1230497137,
0.1091168001,
0.3344699144,
-0.374555558,
-0.1328198016,
0.995128274,
-0.6532693505,
0.9092524648,
-0.0641567037,
-0.1442679167,
0.7178928852,
0.1949457377,
0.2287378013,
-0.2406984419,
0.1119421795,
0.2948694527,
-0.0106202392,
-0.577399075,
-0.3040697575,
0.4133405387,
-0.7818590999,
-0.3622842133,
-0.4426138401,
-0.6715102196,
0.1180845276,
0.3680163026,
0.4504910111,
0.4247968197,
-0.2036443651,
-0.0020873726,
0.1244601682,
-0.3433502913,
0.6875756383,
0.3732243478,
-0.0030618946,
-0.1343243718,
0.7979383469,
0.1052731276,
0.2171323448,
0.5905532241,
0.4059975445,
-0.0333707295,
-0.347951591,
-0.3951436579,
0.2591843307,
-0.5365096927,
0.082813397,
-0.6730713844,
-0.1507350802,
-0.4125788212,
-0.7042267323,
-0.1777463406,
-0.3710175455,
-0.0450378582,
0.2287417203,
0.5702089071,
1.06425035,
0.0705921799,
0.5508378148,
-0.8067981005,
0.1010276973,
-0.0251981765,
0.1830520928,
0.1421597302,
-0.1932147592,
-0.1511243582,
-0.1191918477,
-0.3272111118,
-0.8377524018,
0.1031503007,
-0.018539967,
0.2100301981,
0.4668477476,
-0.0891609713,
0.509164989,
-0.8156821728,
0.9929457307,
0.0525095277,
-0.7774085402,
0.5634934902,
-0.6789293289,
0.3713615239,
0.5367256999,
0.1389139593,
-0.8074308038,
-0.7757192254,
-0.6959069371,
-0.9125932455,
0.7902553082,
0.3741627336,
-0.0142358467,
-0.0834161192,
0.0180814937,
0.4480989277,
0.0841045156,
-0.8176909089,
-0.2294917405,
0.1602241248,
-0.1551894844,
-0.1866087019,
-0.1202287897,
-0.0363615304,
-0.0712209493,
0.0859122574,
0.1743859053,
0.2458565682,
0.2833945453,
-0.2730819285,
0.1770577431,
-0.0180546902,
0.5229744315,
0.5542686582,
-0.0775237083,
0.2359535396,
-0.3336562514,
-0.7475073338,
0.0705049559,
-0.5154156685,
-0.5244694352,
0.3963921666,
0.6821098328,
0.6421018839,
0.1191851571,
-0.7080705166,
0.4529598951,
0.0986546874,
-0.2258761525,
-0.228989467,
0.2799454033,
-0.0174458884,
0.2301589102,
0.0863525867,
0.1690520048,
0.1986686736,
-0.6405359507,
0.1181934103,
0.2363577485,
-0.4224309921,
-0.5509763956,
0.3909035325,
0.1091469675,
-0.7460411191,
0.3849206567,
-0.4355251193,
-0.4879800677,
0.6163962483,
0.3440066576,
1.1010198593,
0.1956466436,
0.5368306041,
0.2491271347,
0.1878488511,
0.0687005073,
0.1445294321,
-0.3748722076,
-0.6408216953,
-0.333759129,
-0.7115198374,
-0.2079101205,
-0.4340286851,
-0.2762784362,
0.2385884225,
-0.2414265126,
-0.2167264968,
0.2720066011,
-0.0664945766,
-0.4121801257,
-0.0645736232,
-0.06740053,
0.5159796476,
-0.8379263282,
0.4516871274,
0.8785905242,
-0.2141938806,
-0.3952029347,
0.3125368357,
0.0282889847,
-0.5785273314,
0.5647398233,
0.0621381216,
-0.1090727076,
-0.039084658,
-0.6749350429,
-1.0682082176,
0.8954780698,
-0.1282627583,
-0.0869842991,
0.2007352114,
0.387643218,
0.7690998912,
-0.0378958397,
0.0961788893,
0.3570229113,
0.5205175877,
-0.0259342249,
-0.7183482647,
-0.1423696578,
-0.0234598052,
-0.1290954947,
0.5503586531,
-0.7403402925,
0.9522599578,
0.1514558494,
-0.3720144928,
0.2389199436,
0.4438283145,
0.0415509157,
0.3778819144,
0.618286252,
0.4322862923,
0.7043080926,
-0.2396044731,
1.1239535809,
-0.1550406367,
0.1474883854,
0.8348048925,
-0.1444678903,
0.7053192854,
0.245769158,
-0.5207013488,
0.9456274509,
0.5126326084,
-0.0108848121,
0.4394858479,
0.2901957333,
-0.1838923395,
-0.000539828,
-0.173674196,
-0.0441490971,
0.563914299,
0.0812183172,
0.032750994,
-0.4546781182,
-0.2155177742,
0.3445740938,
0.1151912138,
-0.2227445096,
1.0340089798,
-0.187847212,
-0.6349708438,
0.0794473812,
0.1675581336,
0.582447052,
-0.379234314,
0.3239983022,
-0.1266928315,
0.1140511706,
-0.2301107645,
-0.8308917284,
0.2859914899,
0.3041025698,
-0.4250148833,
0.0176036227,
0.8333129883,
-0.0418755524,
-0.6458075047,
0.1503877044,
0.5195225477,
0.4176646769,
-0.2404256761,
-0.4122130871,
-0.2334496528,
-0.2378931791,
-0.1440564692,
0.3037231565,
0.7340798974,
-0.3911712468,
0.5565340519,
0.7222210169,
-0.0756801292,
0.4778382182,
0.062309783,
0.5780476928,
-1.0129683018,
-0.6128816009,
-1.0827634335,
0.4483601749,
-0.1762368679,
-0.4921986163,
1.0789773464,
0.5981044173,
0.7162387967,
-0.0173513144,
0.6163849831,
-0.491219312,
0.6628357172,
-0.2385395467,
0.7837199569,
-0.5858207345,
-0.2734996378,
-0.6427662373,
-0.9443889856,
-0.4214445651,
0.525595963,
-0.0785347521,
-0.1607904434,
0.8451145887,
0.6981062293,
0.3343923092,
-0.4025457203,
0.1187523752,
0.0825795308,
0.1499618888,
0.1930937916,
0.881821692,
-0.3222182989,
0.4269660115,
0.0052777445,
-0.0758028105,
-0.2080876529,
-0.6777052283,
-0.8222013712,
-0.7910335064,
-0.3143153489,
-0.1701183468,
-0.3147311211,
0.1947100461,
0.3377089202,
-0.6591948867,
-0.3934556544,
-0.4361899793,
0.6252670884,
0.0385142863,
-0.2709495723,
0.548435688,
-0.6195766926,
-0.7349126339,
0.06524501,
0.5332409739,
-0.0750010237,
-0.3365570009,
0.1423507333,
-0.3183600903,
0.2529406548,
0.494353056,
-0.0255348906,
-0.7481595278,
-0.5406205654,
0.2750095129,
-0.3368734717,
0.3774581254,
0.8984210491,
-0.7786598206,
0.3758129478,
0.9668492079,
0.2329840362,
-0.0098175518,
0.0259262659,
0.4531038702,
-0.6547598839,
0.30430457,
0.0128465956,
0.1837557703,
0.3125055134,
-0.0647472739,
0.6339861751,
0.5174717903,
-0.8102055788,
-0.7020668387,
0.1327223033,
-1.1982021332,
-0.4936997592,
1.3007717133,
0.0050885817,
-0.4599090815,
-0.3030652702,
-0.4109868407,
0.3435869515,
-0.2175898552,
0.8285090327,
0.9624080062,
0.1019929498,
0.6727052927,
-0.4611309767,
0.57455194,
0.164145112,
-0.5748056769,
-0.2971992791,
0.5638959408,
0.1693277061,
0.3936527669,
0.844160676,
-0.069245331,
0.1185877174,
0.2644051313,
0.1004886106,
0.5839571953,
-0.3101217747,
0.0395451523,
0.2498549223,
-0.2480706573,
-0.3126625121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17389v1
|
FairBelief -- Assessing Harmful Beliefs in Language Models
| 2024-02-27T10:31:00 | 2024-02-27T10:31:00 |
Mattia Setzu, Marta Marchiori Manerba, Pasquale Minervini, Debora Nozza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language Models (LMs) have been shown to inherit undesired biases that might
hurt minorities and underrepresented groups if such systems were integrated
into real-world applications without careful fairness auditing. This paper
proposes FairBelief, an analytical approach to capture and assess beliefs,
i.e., propositions that an LM may embed with different degrees of confidence
and that covertly influence its predictions. With FairBelief, we leverage
prompting to study the behavior of several state-of-the-art LMs across
different previously neglected axes, such as model scale and likelihood,
assessing predictions on a fairness dataset specifically designed to quantify
LMs' outputs' hurtfulness. Finally, we conclude with an in-depth qualitative
assessment of the beliefs emitted by the models. We apply FairBelief to English
LMs, revealing that, although these architectures enable high performances on
diverse natural language processing tasks, they show hurtful beliefs about
specific genders. Interestingly, training procedure and dataset, model scale,
and architecture induce beliefs of different degrees of hurtfulness.
|
[
-0.425824523,
-0.8019247055,
0.4976233244,
0.3244284093,
0.2750748396,
-0.2645007372,
0.0652065426,
-0.5454158187,
-0.3095279634,
0.3154816031,
-0.318972975,
-0.3234361112,
-0.9152768254,
0.0621266179,
-0.3882845938,
0.8432742953,
0.0425471552,
0.3146511316,
-0.1161030754,
-0.4255494475,
-0.6969704032,
-0.3593228161,
-0.3205522001,
-0.3824670911,
0.3777556121,
0.1078290045,
1.0537416935,
0.1530482471,
0.3642841578,
0.1491441429,
-0.0869547799,
-0.3213892877,
-0.4704419971,
0.2189587951,
-0.4867383242,
-0.8253501654,
-0.2695671022,
0.3830484152,
0.5346168876,
0.9059698582,
-0.3059627414,
0.4343176782,
0.1082437113,
0.4009620249,
-0.8678959608,
-0.0158668105,
-0.7327700257,
0.2558148503,
-0.0659042969,
0.2775867581,
-0.5654254556,
-0.8347837925,
0.0651607066,
0.0722723752,
-0.0381795727,
0.171976611,
0.6910111904,
0.3356203139,
-0.6394102573,
-0.4803358614,
-0.4034670591,
1.1090837717,
-0.9559241533,
0.498296082,
0.425417006,
0.3910010755,
-0.2868112326,
-0.3367729187,
-0.6405726075,
-0.1589048505,
-0.2079198807,
-0.10413941,
-0.5004635453,
-0.0256158188,
0.4229628742,
0.2413217723,
-0.6311307549,
0.1791256815,
-0.144975096,
-0.139296785,
0.55853194,
0.1429665238,
0.4435386658,
-0.3481244445,
-0.1920185387,
0.1183330938,
-0.8892487884,
0.1854183823,
0.5581520796,
0.4988627136,
0.0002663548,
0.2585552633,
0.1289610714,
0.3758617938,
-0.0284217373,
-0.1390439123,
0.3046638072,
0.3275471032,
-0.4901203215,
0.1910032332,
0.6276960969,
0.5654194951,
0.4041991234,
-0.1276823878,
-0.4162926972,
0.5200170279,
0.1492459923,
-1.0060989857,
0.2031281739,
0.3700409234,
-0.6228733063,
-0.526663959,
-0.1825884432,
-0.7301331758,
-0.645599544,
0.0872923881,
0.375015825,
-0.3002739549,
-0.3691344559,
0.2972658873,
-0.1182077453,
0.0958404168,
0.1040900052,
-0.8004779816,
0.3837450147,
0.7451450229,
0.3331757784,
0.0136886658,
-0.0283565819,
-0.6363556981,
-0.0801641122,
-0.3993224204,
0.5084507465,
-0.6833197474,
-0.36630252,
0.2619311512,
0.1129640117,
0.2419367582,
-0.5622118711,
0.9509601593,
-0.3182159662,
0.40885818,
-0.4042630494,
-0.6622407436,
-0.405701071,
0.3197268546,
-0.5916998386,
0.7650136948,
0.0039451667,
-1.0749126673,
0.5951840878,
-0.494348228,
-0.2772957981,
-0.0668167174,
-0.4720183909,
-0.139330551,
0.4291875958,
-0.0568291172,
0.4286984205,
-0.2613616884,
0.6751533747,
-0.7358264327,
-0.1344307959,
0.3840829134,
-0.8306180239,
1.0699067116,
0.3104862571,
-0.534959197,
-0.2512915432,
-0.6546615362,
-0.1495402455,
0.2310841233,
-0.0451936573,
-0.6285211444,
0.2297267318,
-0.1823740005,
0.2772036493,
-0.1409227103,
-0.5702472329,
-0.1602334678,
-0.4536803663,
-0.188133046,
0.8232617974,
-0.1846342087,
0.5505574942,
-0.3888878524,
0.5916703343,
-0.1445671767,
0.3150754571,
0.3124075532,
-0.4335328937,
-0.5121275187,
0.1587466896,
0.2947331667,
0.3765109777,
-0.272924006,
-0.0731776878,
0.0676643848,
-0.2877178788,
-0.7458965778,
0.0272899233,
0.3570010066,
0.4805802405,
0.0720716715,
-0.2183740884,
-0.2786207795,
-1.1626206636,
-0.7713708282,
-0.3574181795,
0.1069695204,
0.3151151538,
0.5279626846,
-0.2153742164,
0.8705174923,
-0.3750108182,
-0.0304979887,
0.1069824472,
0.4172202349,
0.1966029108,
0.3913848996,
0.9438787103,
-0.7864078283,
-0.242831856,
-0.3306221068,
-0.7701853514,
-0.3888513148,
0.141659528,
0.0684622452,
0.1892816871,
0.0245081838,
-0.4387944639,
0.5993332267,
0.7067527771,
-0.7261856198,
0.5732558966,
0.3084016144,
0.3383772075,
-0.6013328433,
-0.2882199585,
-0.0403836407,
-0.3435668349,
-0.4771714211,
0.1552940458,
0.0291159246,
0.347631067,
-0.6143539548,
0.6851843596,
-0.2340530455,
0.1244207695,
-0.201316148,
0.0740269348,
-0.0234117005,
0.0966360271,
-0.1708360612,
0.3540414274,
0.3624410629,
-0.3723057806,
-0.1001702175,
-0.0068957089,
-0.2264304906,
0.5116109848,
-0.2588654459,
0.0122673353,
-0.4540999234,
-0.1786583364,
-0.745251596,
-0.0708397552,
0.2140133381,
-0.4910638034,
0.1040387154,
-0.2370304465,
-0.3204884231,
-0.0835877135,
-0.2033267766,
0.4078795314,
0.6312878728,
-0.5154693723,
0.6483229995,
0.5796479583,
-0.2154144347,
-0.7303232551,
-0.8825722933,
-0.0411677621,
-0.564889133,
-0.4516400695,
0.036984127,
-0.0641031787,
-1.0136151314,
-0.1330941319,
-0.0220179483,
0.0122751612,
0.369536221,
0.5428405404,
0.1120388284,
-0.0498440973,
0.345811516,
0.4426546991,
0.1822975278,
0.4065209925,
0.0570102856,
0.1626769453,
-0.3479540944,
-0.4251601398,
0.1099917516,
0.5019014478,
0.319049567,
0.08062879,
0.8246600032,
0.3636727631,
-0.8173359036,
-0.4865166545,
-0.6457642913,
-0.1216084808,
-0.4451581836,
0.3958550692,
-0.2274570763,
-1.0617381334,
0.4764153063,
-0.1147039607,
0.1560747176,
0.4010649025,
0.5470111966,
-0.1804809421,
1.296112299,
0.7277393341,
-0.0715528652,
0.0413989983,
0.2652227283,
0.2238398492,
-0.1361249089,
-0.0959433094,
-0.8742095828,
-0.0749641135,
-0.8135696054,
-0.4434094727,
-0.0940523222,
0.4121139646,
-0.5261975527,
-0.1164590046,
-0.1445665658,
0.4742369354,
-0.0782339424,
-0.4225817323,
0.2766329944,
-0.2372841239,
-0.0955055058,
-0.3586650193,
-0.6570048928,
-1.1231313944,
0.8689649105,
0.8220503926,
0.8348299861,
0.3962922394,
0.5809954405,
0.616260767,
0.9291725159,
-0.8435814977,
0.30831635,
-0.1151006296,
-1.1725145578,
-0.0363166146,
-0.4648885131,
-0.5959616303,
0.2385330498,
-0.0286445264,
-0.9699671865,
0.4834123552,
0.4046200514,
-0.1071847007,
0.3884906769,
-0.6500380039,
0.8644195199,
-0.3528727591,
-0.2640786767,
-0.2500736117,
-0.3201962709,
0.6597536802,
-0.1479834467,
0.7174444199,
-0.3213634193,
0.1760948151,
0.9241940379,
-0.068655923,
0.9218665957,
-0.5499465466,
-0.6039505005,
0.2819995284,
0.8139077425,
0.3367066979,
-0.0008873453,
-0.5538867712,
0.3060132861,
0.1503009796,
-0.3106456697,
-0.6014012098,
0.5825223327,
-0.429125607,
-0.5927550197,
-0.4180831909,
-0.4200592041,
-0.4433168173,
0.1112982482,
-0.0565236248,
0.3173781633,
-0.6536936164,
-0.0121303899,
0.5279821754,
-0.4549696743,
0.3456477523,
0.4784832597,
-0.6110306978,
0.1288705915,
0.7151315212,
-0.0424105264,
0.4213262796,
-0.0263859648,
0.1767456383,
-0.2757410705,
-0.6209103465,
-0.0504105277,
-0.1463521272,
-0.9718154669,
-0.3125214279,
-0.3082362413,
0.3470022976,
-0.4328252673,
0.0892818645,
-0.4648784697,
-0.1996206641,
-0.0528908893,
-0.2209784836,
0.0268723201,
0.8397305012,
-0.0165352486,
0.2740799785,
-0.8227457404,
0.1015537083,
0.2091325223,
0.4825740457,
-0.0810879394,
-0.5399872661,
0.0702503398,
0.2489698082,
-0.1747489572,
-1.0373663902,
0.4249186218,
-0.0599826574,
0.7438535094,
0.5516709685,
0.2359019965,
0.1758345664,
-0.5397562385,
0.6878917813,
0.5039377213,
-1.0220227242,
0.3361929655,
-0.0894969925,
-0.0630241409,
0.5907046199,
0.7015425563,
-0.7158830166,
-0.6802575588,
-0.4612022936,
-0.1310380995,
0.6124628186,
-0.06032487,
0.2818856537,
-0.1845360398,
0.1967839301,
0.6105551124,
0.1009321064,
-0.9852728248,
-0.2579403818,
-0.3877945244,
-0.5838025212,
0.2191605419,
-0.2382490486,
-0.0791414827,
-0.0786157772,
0.5480921268,
-0.2734079361,
0.1043648422,
-0.1517274976,
-0.5006818771,
-0.1230763271,
0.6372734904,
0.0782186612,
0.6143963933,
-0.3785740137,
0.3674955666,
0.3527712822,
-0.3152323663,
0.2609060109,
0.0386855453,
-0.2501608133,
0.0064315619,
0.3145261705,
0.6611897945,
-0.0942388922,
-0.8007546663,
0.8121062517,
-0.3245131671,
-0.0018906703,
0.0690954551,
0.0717540681,
0.2409456372,
0.4620701373,
0.1887359321,
0.041587878,
0.4048623741,
-0.6421009302,
0.0610869788,
0.4407576323,
-0.8075022101,
-0.4273912311,
0.3343035579,
0.14936167,
-0.3172003031,
0.1196524128,
-0.4724252522,
-0.6588012576,
0.3245370984,
0.4339882433,
0.8545359373,
-0.3870931566,
0.1562793851,
0.2264735997,
0.6106510162,
0.096148707,
0.2301431447,
0.3001062572,
-1.0160170794,
-0.3095209002,
-0.775799334,
-0.1102423891,
0.1327977479,
-0.6923496723,
0.0610604621,
-0.3280865848,
-0.372818619,
-0.1429967284,
-0.1705918014,
-0.8487808108,
0.3833982348,
0.5111095905,
0.958547771,
-1.0205181837,
0.3571934998,
0.2901953459,
-0.4154118299,
-0.7153702974,
0.281729728,
0.2412672937,
-0.8172220588,
0.8251468539,
0.0412689,
-0.226389125,
-0.5728562474,
-0.7948371172,
-0.3397770524,
0.5292570591,
0.7418937683,
-0.813467741,
-0.0099184299,
0.320064038,
0.2103733122,
-0.3885384202,
0.3952941298,
0.7363020182,
0.411488831,
-0.4631217122,
-0.8713677526,
0.2915940881,
-0.0402469859,
-0.2273718864,
0.0396292992,
-0.3211349249,
0.8059197068,
-0.1744752973,
-0.3199351728,
-0.2141714096,
0.6293141842,
0.1386378855,
0.2428717017,
0.7874593139,
0.3013493717,
0.9295615554,
-0.0379625633,
0.9286081195,
0.0845993236,
0.4599141181,
1.1175913811,
-0.3344821632,
0.7284875512,
0.4824225008,
-0.2783963978,
0.3969825804,
0.3856495023,
0.2271509469,
0.550245285,
0.437848419,
-0.1700827628,
-0.2275933623,
-0.354189992,
-0.2404246926,
0.5040094852,
0.3952952027,
-0.2459538728,
-0.4007076919,
0.1880033463,
0.178666696,
0.2596776783,
-0.2156610787,
0.4934512377,
0.5032570362,
-0.5320471525,
0.4755932391,
0.2677181363,
0.9603434205,
-0.2153874785,
-0.1843449026,
-0.3016941845,
-0.0042230058,
-0.1974173486,
-0.8932343721,
0.2897076905,
0.3086489141,
-0.1500361413,
-0.1580440849,
1.0158121586,
-0.2491995841,
-0.3749447465,
0.7359016538,
0.7087161541,
0.1019363478,
0.0201918669,
-0.731728375,
0.1567328125,
0.12987113,
-0.2774378657,
0.3672432303,
0.4398317635,
-0.1446558833,
0.5634854436,
0.1498466879,
0.178864792,
-0.061726436,
0.4836053848,
0.3988302052,
-0.7386472821,
-0.3042859137,
-0.8844320178,
0.4178649783,
0.2434609085,
-0.0952122435,
0.5644680262,
0.1729090661,
0.799441576,
0.4016573727,
0.8474045396,
0.0458313935,
0.5268320441,
-0.2834343314,
0.9522579312,
-0.6310324073,
0.1901664138,
-0.5720778108,
-0.7566927671,
-0.1937545836,
0.6940183043,
-0.4822184443,
0.224296093,
0.4345690906,
0.7247171998,
-0.0338787884,
0.6223974824,
0.3823855817,
0.5049098134,
0.5403926969,
0.359872967,
1.3250348568,
-0.3142244518,
0.4304376543,
-0.0415541679,
-0.3361773789,
-0.050014846,
-1.1401792765,
-0.8525308967,
-0.2289020568,
-0.3431470096,
-0.4193976223,
-0.1028222963,
0.886775136,
0.3735979199,
-0.9206182957,
-0.1571366787,
0.191598922,
0.2349576503,
0.259567529,
-0.2928708494,
0.221071586,
-0.2259215415,
-0.6826918125,
0.0718216524,
0.0018352717,
0.0378564447,
-0.3423135877,
-0.4498983324,
0.0522619598,
0.2956935763,
0.6009292603,
-0.1051770225,
-0.7186318636,
-0.6207286716,
-0.3578859866,
-0.186153397,
-0.2110848278,
0.4762164652,
-0.6711779237,
0.2446832359,
0.3235919774,
0.5128129721,
-0.0370970443,
-0.4023170471,
0.5779206753,
-0.5820362568,
0.0299700294,
0.6373487115,
0.6268830895,
0.3406846225,
-0.1843517274,
0.0349278115,
0.0134638557,
-0.1799680442,
-1.3120669127,
0.1293979138,
-0.4035311341,
-0.5714030862,
0.9433748722,
-0.1778364778,
-0.2359616905,
-0.0180816315,
-0.0889074877,
0.1817659438,
-0.4504004121,
0.6648672223,
0.8536117673,
0.1936745048,
0.2262705117,
-0.836399436,
0.637970984,
0.7680901885,
-0.7337914109,
0.2919298112,
0.580273211,
0.4721033275,
0.1322117448,
0.3976131976,
-0.3557240069,
0.2304343134,
0.1018375903,
0.1429217607,
0.2887881398,
-0.0884555206,
-0.5041997433,
0.4063978195,
0.3017169833,
0.2035466582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00826v1
|
LLMGuard: Guarding Against Unsafe LLM Behavior
| 2024-02-27T10:22:45 | 2024-02-27T10:22:45 |
Shubh Goyal, Medha Hira, Shubham Mishra, Sukriti Goyal, Arnav Goel, Niharika Dadu, Kirushikesh DB, Sameep Mehta, Nishtha Madaan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Although the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in enterprise settings
brings new opportunities and capabilities, it also brings challenges, such as
the risk of generating inappropriate, biased, or misleading content that
violates regulations and can have legal concerns. To alleviate this, we present
"LLMGuard", a tool that monitors user interactions with an LLM application and
flags content against specific behaviours or conversation topics. To do this
robustly, LLMGuard employs an ensemble of detectors.
|
[
-0.4496933818,
-1.0894157887,
0.3550646007,
0.0827955902,
-0.1635189205,
0.2106561214,
0.2300522327,
-0.4995275736,
0.261620611,
0.9442447424,
-0.5668591261,
-0.6621251106,
-0.6891294718,
-0.171756506,
-0.6662827134,
1.1237995625,
-0.0148417521,
-0.3327444494,
-0.2703516781,
0.1006320491,
-0.4960826337,
-0.864403367,
-1.0291323662,
-0.6849210858,
0.6075612307,
0.6072676778,
0.7522205114,
0.2515161335,
0.7133825421,
0.3724444211,
0.0369279757,
-0.0239704475,
-0.7143177986,
0.5512337089,
-0.1526956409,
-0.4120481908,
-0.9141016603,
-0.2716823816,
0.2702535093,
0.0744682103,
-0.4440145791,
0.1072151735,
0.1169139072,
0.2988457084,
-0.4749262929,
-0.0229568519,
-0.551471591,
-0.0239378791,
-0.6240429282,
-0.395537734,
-0.4348946512,
-0.2981894016,
-0.2129638195,
-0.1508049816,
-0.3577359319,
0.3690567017,
0.7850572467,
0.1337512732,
-0.6403755546,
-0.1508216858,
-0.3768196404,
0.6008197665,
-0.6057917476,
0.2945250571,
0.8471264839,
0.3408388793,
-0.5917553902,
-0.7005946636,
-0.5269250274,
-0.2953951657,
0.0582392514,
-0.1048862711,
-0.6874320507,
0.3421038091,
0.2238530517,
0.2461434752,
-0.5365312696,
0.6097409129,
-0.2336681634,
-0.5824000239,
0.7537350059,
0.3907366097,
0.7419444919,
-0.0100714043,
-0.3418757319,
-0.0671660528,
-1.1056770086,
-0.2276666313,
0.4921427369,
-0.1934002191,
-0.0389945805,
0.82845366,
-0.1170538217,
0.6611573696,
-0.0455867052,
-0.4187457561,
0.1639330983,
0.3632329106,
-0.3601375222,
0.2864044607,
0.8786055446,
0.6427822113,
0.3077308238,
0.0412441492,
-0.4662048221,
0.0542968512,
0.1989005059,
-0.7034640908,
-0.2563143373,
0.4650837183,
-0.1501173973,
-0.6055365205,
-0.0741942897,
-0.6205601096,
-0.7340452671,
-0.0138243018,
0.2453607917,
-0.3241226375,
-0.3613111079,
0.0101288427,
0.226305604,
0.1141333282,
0.2249614298,
-0.8895118237,
0.2892936766,
0.8768625259,
0.6927449703,
-0.5928782225,
-0.3627851903,
-0.842933476,
0.4705150127,
-0.2560108602,
1.0352877378,
-0.3921017051,
-0.8010228872,
0.1394096166,
0.1382022053,
0.3372690678,
-0.4738229513,
0.5118071437,
-0.7858398557,
-0.1275057197,
-0.1263805777,
-0.4957273304,
-0.2361835688,
0.6258977652,
-0.7650158405,
1.1350365877,
0.1518732905,
-0.8869268894,
0.3698356152,
-0.5911098123,
-0.5305720568,
0.1745512336,
-0.2551940978,
-0.5029532909,
-0.2114321589,
0.0242110696,
0.4542405605,
0.0091270953,
0.262109071,
-0.3575555682,
-0.1399638355,
0.6061666012,
-0.5044196844,
0.7701810598,
0.3292267323,
-0.125671342,
0.5305485129,
-0.4631533027,
-0.3470633924,
0.0243840404,
-0.7232800126,
-0.3447828591,
0.0933915377,
0.033375714,
0.0473478623,
0.4196444452,
-0.3477758765,
-0.0116703538,
-0.0019032839,
0.1588361859,
1.0412425995,
0.157451123,
0.1564605236,
-0.5632740855,
0.8619988561,
0.0633967593,
0.1469110399,
0.0477476865,
-0.7063781023,
-0.6261667013,
-0.2469381243,
-0.0246377029,
0.8268574476,
-0.8101255298,
0.5658189058,
-0.0667810366,
-0.3991627097,
-0.255353719,
0.5802976489,
0.3660708964,
0.4221749008,
-0.1324536353,
-0.2683808804,
-0.4991824329,
-0.7237608433,
0.032672964,
-0.5020865202,
-0.2497342825,
0.1968501806,
0.1870993525,
-0.5809454322,
0.6964601278,
-0.4263229966,
-0.2552934289,
-0.4442376196,
0.1645161808,
-0.007305963,
0.3124514818,
0.6900675893,
-0.5191547275,
-0.2329103053,
0.017231198,
-0.7650024891,
-0.6637740135,
-0.0241248589,
-0.476868093,
0.2621111274,
1.0143839121,
-0.5721751451,
0.2520674169,
0.8560920358,
-0.5601105094,
0.4645904303,
-0.0128142433,
0.012616381,
-1.0789781809,
-0.1648950875,
0.0105442917,
-0.6192427278,
-0.7017796636,
0.0936059952,
-0.1656907648,
0.0547814146,
-0.6781555414,
0.4682507813,
-0.2793664634,
-0.0940156356,
-0.3560187519,
0.2989358008,
-0.0252534486,
-0.186891064,
-0.0816441625,
1.0820803642,
0.6108214259,
-0.7256968617,
0.5857941508,
0.3678818345,
-0.5550496578,
0.8696858287,
-0.4690321386,
0.1388357133,
-0.0459569879,
0.0307274293,
-0.869097054,
-0.4387880266,
0.0467988141,
-0.3069970012,
0.3072871864,
-0.1891945302,
-0.5168113112,
-0.4092374146,
-0.3257457912,
-0.0789271817,
0.3899604678,
-0.4878071845,
0.7316403389,
0.9416742325,
-0.3898421526,
-0.4885911644,
-0.9949814677,
0.4374174178,
-0.6182509065,
-0.7924790978,
-0.1169244349,
-0.0399534591,
-0.7288367152,
-0.241077885,
0.0781167597,
-0.123417601,
0.5456810594,
0.4294963479,
0.5343398452,
-0.1732103974,
-0.0596305095,
-0.0515816286,
0.0416408479,
0.3948390484,
0.2435872406,
0.8271632791,
-0.0541637205,
-0.6561430693,
-0.0304899979,
0.3301754296,
0.5335832834,
0.0100440932,
0.6029824018,
0.6438522339,
-0.2234993428,
-0.1978329718,
-0.6566399932,
-0.2064646184,
-0.711995244,
0.3685247302,
-0.1186285242,
-1.1409026384,
0.4495047629,
-0.007408658,
0.0400807187,
0.0889030993,
0.7329035401,
-0.0611907095,
0.8661230206,
0.7782436013,
-0.4236679673,
0.6394389868,
0.3523107171,
0.2076284289,
-0.7677409053,
-0.4380107522,
-0.220852837,
-0.2298941463,
-0.5246859789,
-0.2007835209,
0.4005495608,
-0.0999718085,
-0.2521503866,
0.2704665959,
-0.2117521167,
0.6423124075,
0.6532167196,
0.0630020127,
0.5092138052,
0.0533089936,
-0.1261403561,
0.1256872118,
-0.4325945079,
-0.8217503428,
1.0040941238,
0.4135002792,
1.5200206041,
0.6064947844,
0.6953727007,
0.654902339,
0.7879036665,
-0.8882668018,
0.8751922846,
0.1114178225,
-0.811835289,
-0.1492164731,
-0.2932354212,
-1.1349009275,
0.0021401406,
-0.4335354865,
-1.3268151283,
-0.0547627024,
0.3778155744,
-0.2839459479,
0.5054422021,
-0.6097503304,
0.6441193819,
-0.5798483491,
-0.3966940939,
-0.0334870107,
-0.0227545686,
0.6668514013,
-0.2606815398,
0.1306650043,
-0.4565259218,
0.0152044306,
0.5392813683,
-0.2235453129,
1.0806149244,
0.2104996443,
-0.451860249,
0.5834493637,
0.7833017111,
0.6696166992,
-0.0208661743,
-0.0153911784,
0.2112385929,
-0.2796239555,
0.1238977015,
0.0782302618,
0.9020593166,
-0.4691586196,
-1.0103436708,
-0.5317325592,
-0.6033457518,
-0.0895790011,
0.3132983446,
0.149034366,
0.0129128806,
-0.4328428507,
0.2055526972,
0.8442233205,
-0.3761911988,
0.3910354376,
0.6932473779,
-0.7003315687,
-0.0472799502,
0.6346485615,
-0.2420946658,
0.3001731038,
0.2139491588,
0.0845224783,
-0.3182589114,
-0.6138673425,
-0.2189664543,
-0.1132052466,
-0.8364236355,
-0.4396225512,
-0.5708548427,
-0.2824547589,
-0.1716686636,
-0.2139305174,
0.243853882,
-0.3210915029,
-0.3084567189,
-0.5378109217,
0.7611116171,
0.7316814065,
-0.0406993441,
0.6426249743,
-0.7423971891,
0.1626132876,
0.550637424,
0.3250954747,
-0.3871242702,
-0.3693307638,
0.1110650599,
-0.4860662222,
-0.4340994358,
-0.7243942618,
0.4618855715,
-0.0286188796,
0.8113054037,
0.779594779,
0.0292200744,
0.1976702809,
-0.5172160268,
0.7652074099,
0.2394760549,
-0.7571015358,
0.6884718537,
-0.5874415636,
0.0950963721,
0.3259344101,
0.2831611037,
-0.5959086418,
-0.649929285,
-0.4129463136,
-0.8777023554,
0.3684458137,
-0.0360192657,
0.2270559072,
-0.3724762201,
-0.1612585336,
-0.3519493341,
0.2402740121,
-0.7756205201,
0.0769668072,
0.025364412,
-0.1325811297,
0.1536469758,
-0.5373562574,
-0.5272493362,
0.2697682381,
0.6187742949,
-0.0416308008,
0.0723978207,
-0.1610417962,
-0.3240807354,
-0.2080412656,
0.4397254288,
0.4283125103,
0.5253261328,
-0.1508589834,
0.4555006027,
0.4340097904,
-0.8744385242,
0.117983982,
-0.1414753199,
-0.2309790701,
-0.2539802492,
0.1685134023,
0.4196552634,
0.0573583394,
-0.8490764499,
0.582662642,
0.109266445,
-0.0690317303,
-0.5031630397,
0.4276801348,
0.1688862294,
0.1449073255,
-0.0230503045,
-0.3645960391,
0.2357583493,
-0.5461892486,
0.5298109055,
0.443035692,
-0.2980385721,
0.0878042653,
0.84756881,
0.3379350603,
-0.3756599724,
0.4852867424,
-0.0573941246,
-0.4247776866,
0.5053312182,
0.6941853166,
0.9650498033,
-0.6738538742,
-0.0179189648,
-0.0953906104,
0.6234149933,
-0.1370579749,
0.6073334813,
0.4556417763,
-0.9684307575,
-0.3673215806,
-0.4960305691,
-0.7189459205,
0.3431867659,
-0.5495880842,
0.3221178353,
-0.7241018414,
-0.7025274634,
-0.1447655112,
-0.5690288544,
-0.2206857055,
-0.0806386396,
0.5198802352,
1.0180659294,
-0.7285539508,
0.9881845713,
0.5400264859,
-0.1431386471,
-0.3820806742,
-0.2004931271,
0.7467381358,
-1.1359567642,
0.5242551565,
0.0064521153,
-0.5468927026,
-0.3628635108,
-0.406716615,
-0.7142193317,
1.1025687456,
0.3570356369,
-0.7509675622,
0.4921875596,
0.2824252248,
0.2337670177,
-0.1999243051,
-0.1921848059,
0.8356101513,
0.5825509429,
-0.0604351871,
-0.7361837626,
0.0898002014,
-0.258453995,
-0.213277638,
0.3972874582,
-0.576928854,
0.7623170614,
-0.0015646884,
-0.1963880658,
-0.1997061521,
0.5011801124,
0.4287597537,
0.2034034878,
0.4865480959,
0.5006011724,
0.9040744901,
-0.3262615502,
1.1852707863,
-0.3125191629,
-0.0915823579,
1.2112478018,
-0.5520498753,
0.8942575455,
0.4187663794,
0.0046947096,
0.6093285084,
0.4851099253,
-0.2205919921,
0.2262613475,
0.277330637,
-0.7275829315,
-0.3741791248,
-0.2314615548,
-0.0590060875,
0.4028387964,
0.9540129304,
-0.1413046718,
-0.1471501589,
-0.1883922666,
0.5649151206,
0.0868142024,
-0.5409730673,
0.8008405566,
0.2622426152,
-0.5292035937,
0.2203205079,
0.0489091203,
0.810326457,
-0.7418745756,
0.1321522295,
-0.22687307,
0.2528276145,
-0.4468129277,
-1.3143577576,
0.3492792249,
0.31699121,
0.4479945898,
-0.0975552797,
1.102987051,
-0.1963080615,
-0.4284899235,
0.4650306404,
0.4794427454,
0.0991736501,
0.1612074524,
-0.6221077442,
0.2993235588,
-0.1494252682,
-0.399279356,
0.4079327285,
0.3967877328,
-0.4321728051,
1.1171896458,
0.6637630463,
0.0450134538,
0.1292953193,
0.2942230403,
0.9618834257,
-0.4189903438,
-0.6287535429,
-1.0059734583,
0.2619925737,
-0.3334033787,
-0.1871331185,
1.0170289278,
0.5409537554,
0.6190247536,
0.3141745627,
0.8008612394,
0.0260635372,
0.2021856606,
-0.7088273168,
0.9688205123,
-0.1734213382,
0.6796244979,
-0.1410751492,
-0.7522552013,
-0.3758451343,
0.5842987299,
-0.2638092339,
-0.1434438825,
0.4047904611,
1.0811450481,
-0.2136003673,
-0.2838719189,
0.5547102094,
0.2699353099,
0.4326558709,
0.3339153528,
1.0738763809,
0.2179123312,
0.7591200471,
0.1403495967,
-0.1628256738,
-0.3575995862,
-1.1912142038,
-1.3146156073,
0.0940083191,
-0.3008803725,
-0.6427567601,
-0.0574909598,
0.6935309768,
0.5901945233,
-0.9163565636,
-0.6009995341,
0.1366462409,
0.1034580991,
0.2498784661,
-0.173644647,
-0.1180222332,
-0.1016775742,
-0.4438480735,
0.4927853644,
0.3503457904,
0.4729407728,
-0.4986130297,
-0.0824590623,
-0.0706895441,
0.2982089818,
0.7215877175,
0.4135936201,
-0.3820033669,
-0.2782872617,
-0.3896075189,
-0.2470882535,
0.0688026994,
0.5207253098,
-0.2449516356,
0.0966274962,
0.5148991942,
0.4443061352,
0.5579357147,
-0.0627200007,
0.7392907739,
-0.8566585779,
0.2941688597,
0.0055920682,
0.8132328391,
0.5701826215,
-0.6000655293,
0.504955709,
-0.3312852383,
-0.6405908465,
-0.7281398177,
0.5064995289,
-1.0088095665,
-0.1456339657,
1.3019787073,
-0.0852211118,
-0.4019376934,
-0.3704929054,
-0.321713686,
-0.3501864076,
-0.6751199961,
0.9200550318,
0.6953006387,
-0.0199758559,
-0.2033038586,
-1.0333125591,
0.5725194812,
-0.084886685,
-1.2302856445,
0.0147618167,
0.6447067261,
0.625579834,
0.0454704314,
0.6901091337,
-0.2436251789,
0.21774818,
-0.1029379666,
0.009456696,
-0.0675625503,
-0.1287897974,
-0.1303441226,
-0.1962604076,
0.467523545,
0.0584316961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17377v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17377v2
|
KoDialogBench: Evaluating Conversational Understanding of Language Models with Korean Dialogue Benchmark
| 2024-02-27T10:14:57 | 2024-06-17T05:12:56 |
Seongbo Jang, Seonghyeon Lee, Hwanjo Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As language models are often deployed as chatbot assistants, it becomes a
virtue for models to engage in conversations in a user's first language. While
these models are trained on a wide range of languages, a comprehensive
evaluation of their proficiency in low-resource languages such as Korean has
been lacking. In this work, we introduce KoDialogBench, a benchmark designed to
assess language models' conversational capabilities in Korean. To this end, we
collect native Korean dialogues on daily topics from public sources, or
translate dialogues from other languages. We then structure these conversations
into diverse test datasets, spanning from dialogue comprehension to response
selection tasks. Leveraging the proposed benchmark, we conduct extensive
evaluations and analyses of various language models to measure a foundational
understanding of Korean dialogues. Experimental results indicate that there
exists significant room for improvement in models' conversation skills.
Furthermore, our in-depth comparisons across different language models
highlight the effectiveness of recent training techniques in enhancing
conversational proficiency. We anticipate that KoDialogBench will promote the
progress towards conversation-aware Korean language models.
|
[
-0.3642243743,
-0.6963327527,
0.5710577965,
0.1471890658,
-0.2798566818,
0.3318742812,
-0.3214517236,
-0.3495463729,
-0.1785188317,
0.7675782442,
-0.4531520903,
-0.596437037,
-0.2933265269,
0.0662216023,
-0.0355789438,
0.5955563188,
0.0536136813,
0.3960343897,
-0.5940100551,
-0.4045056999,
-0.6649401188,
-0.3355426788,
-0.4985349774,
-0.6546987295,
0.0721784234,
0.3882651627,
0.8004111052,
0.3057219982,
0.1843517572,
0.3611352444,
-0.1956706345,
-0.1431282312,
-0.6540969014,
0.2917975485,
-0.0713151991,
-0.6415163875,
-0.3088524044,
0.003983459,
0.5306056738,
1.2394173145,
0.0107885897,
0.3203147352,
-0.092809543,
0.6914422512,
-0.4337421954,
0.595189333,
-0.5398375392,
0.0336577147,
0.2405910939,
0.242792666,
-0.429020077,
-0.4861013293,
0.3559767604,
-0.4335031509,
0.0734884813,
-0.1123267785,
0.6062526107,
0.0572398528,
-0.595536232,
-0.3207163513,
-0.553045392,
0.5854403377,
-0.808103621,
0.8282176256,
0.5289990306,
0.6190273166,
-0.0210377704,
-0.4818761349,
-0.4133909941,
-0.8891016245,
-0.0192950387,
0.3522430062,
-0.1715438068,
0.2365702093,
0.2569919229,
0.3907436132,
-0.6348134875,
-0.1772126257,
-0.2374841869,
-0.3023304343,
0.4867877364,
0.284006983,
0.2900379598,
-0.5498884916,
-0.0430049114,
-0.2016615719,
-0.2069625705,
0.1478686184,
0.5682277679,
0.3943944275,
-0.0747690648,
0.5207746625,
-0.6907882094,
0.7208027244,
-0.1117159873,
-0.2632505,
0.1978115737,
-0.6872246265,
-0.1077245921,
0.1014953405,
0.4487527311,
0.7143543363,
0.3527147472,
-0.3204568326,
0.2282521129,
0.3096120954,
0.1541740447,
-0.8986706138,
-0.6069601178,
0.1388481855,
-0.6846279502,
-0.3643366992,
-0.2916273177,
-0.8112794161,
-0.5282006264,
-0.2643024623,
0.0073322263,
0.0071232556,
-0.5786240697,
0.1906535327,
0.0319028832,
0.0238467045,
0.3351419568,
-0.3853212297,
0.4630151987,
0.5720921159,
0.6925171614,
0.021262154,
0.0008435051,
-0.4509571493,
-0.4513883591,
-0.5360535383,
0.6857452989,
-0.6069651246,
-0.7808458805,
0.0808681697,
0.0583978184,
-0.3797137737,
-0.9336141348,
0.5162058473,
-0.4113290608,
-0.0169903245,
0.0036540881,
-0.6443306804,
-0.2310897112,
0.3044553399,
-0.5534743071,
0.8847633004,
0.3536620736,
-0.3271015286,
-0.0571506433,
-0.5552221537,
-0.1850575358,
0.1954458207,
-0.0909312889,
-0.039244663,
0.1570064425,
0.0076956772,
0.277805686,
-0.2055557966,
0.2941257656,
-0.5239092112,
0.0628260449,
0.5056596398,
-0.3056549132,
0.6481435895,
0.3425231576,
0.1960399449,
0.0063792691,
-0.8318984509,
0.5931213498,
0.1528341323,
-0.1544508487,
-0.2690402567,
-0.3822891414,
0.0978340879,
0.2922831178,
0.2573382854,
-0.5498620272,
-0.0168527104,
-0.4947043061,
0.1745997369,
0.4194090068,
-0.0133364173,
0.6710786223,
-0.1211892143,
0.7066367865,
-0.2358276844,
-0.0857270882,
-0.6031986475,
-0.3590924144,
-0.6976386309,
0.0302265845,
0.5932165384,
0.6642404795,
-0.6788511872,
0.2284155786,
-0.3681303263,
-0.7088696361,
-0.6323748231,
0.3210088611,
0.7283779979,
0.6446481347,
-0.0297730677,
-0.433699578,
-0.3713939488,
-0.9172577858,
-0.4848472774,
-0.5096061826,
-0.2907837629,
0.8933230639,
0.2995378375,
0.0145058837,
0.8203137517,
-0.4302075207,
0.3461199999,
-0.6631145477,
0.1951040328,
0.0847029462,
0.2214839607,
0.3611060381,
-0.5909411311,
-0.8252010345,
0.3198474646,
-0.5583631396,
-0.4121076763,
0.1866571754,
-0.091201216,
0.1172863916,
0.6793198586,
-0.5849917531,
0.401153177,
0.7006825805,
-0.2490955144,
0.6590483785,
0.1410869807,
0.2555655837,
-1.0471255779,
0.1667148024,
-0.3618428707,
-0.4805142879,
-1.0080320835,
-0.1327914745,
-0.0427182429,
-0.5668984056,
-0.2828299999,
0.9259721041,
-0.0562229231,
-0.2790015638,
-0.4426646531,
0.4120553136,
-0.1623760015,
0.5073937774,
0.0953031629,
0.6876648664,
0.1672072858,
-0.5221405625,
0.2713140845,
0.4287129641,
-0.7153743505,
0.7267314196,
-0.7868872881,
0.4253903925,
0.1605608016,
0.3018798232,
-1.2532486916,
-0.4936160147,
0.2713270485,
-0.4961714447,
-0.1318944991,
-0.6650300622,
-0.3198899329,
-0.2411284298,
0.2224264294,
0.0584479123,
0.3445180357,
-0.3700475693,
0.6536754966,
0.4410013258,
-0.646073103,
-0.0151353776,
0.0083804522,
-0.0609083846,
-0.0112067563,
-0.7342478633,
-0.0417993143,
-0.2898466289,
-0.4375651479,
-0.1623243541,
-0.4810577631,
-0.2641445994,
0.1229240671,
0.2107322067,
0.3061035275,
-0.341568917,
0.1126605123,
-0.1796839386,
-0.313794136,
0.126847744,
-0.008555674,
0.9734537601,
-0.3281457722,
-0.5413587093,
-0.4830958545,
0.0420773849,
0.5800213218,
0.0119605744,
0.3217620254,
0.2742886245,
-0.0636299476,
0.3296045959,
-0.6604138017,
-0.1942456961,
-0.4336152673,
0.7097015977,
-0.4612700939,
-0.7532655597,
0.7114182711,
-0.6195555329,
-0.1759438664,
0.0202614274,
0.4304403663,
0.0714565367,
1.3825511932,
0.4215112627,
-0.2474126518,
0.5304522514,
0.1730165333,
0.3960733414,
-0.6443747282,
-0.0444776453,
-0.6540240645,
0.1618730724,
-0.546613276,
-0.484090209,
0.1201346368,
0.2444502711,
-0.0040601515,
0.48707816,
0.2346191555,
0.6561481357,
0.2739861906,
-0.0249717049,
0.3755534887,
-0.2943344712,
0.0293434504,
-0.0915029049,
-0.6598218083,
-0.7275110483,
0.9808239341,
0.3218958974,
0.5477877855,
-0.2705127895,
0.3532482386,
0.0271358564,
0.0100676147,
-0.7613741755,
0.7677077651,
0.2742872238,
-0.3538894951,
-0.1868038327,
-0.6325880885,
-0.8319642544,
0.4415960312,
0.237549141,
-0.9636178613,
-0.1515203714,
0.1158616915,
-0.2002255768,
-0.2118012607,
-0.8794432878,
1.3862719536,
-0.150648132,
-0.0204836987,
-0.3114649355,
-0.4615311027,
0.2022587955,
0.273075819,
-0.0891566798,
-0.4780633152,
0.3112219274,
0.4701389372,
-0.1629244834,
0.7285321951,
-0.2771724761,
0.0290148482,
0.2010801584,
0.2913683355,
0.4818170369,
0.3319804966,
0.0845214725,
0.1708046496,
0.1318370253,
-0.4798176289,
-0.7376835346,
0.4355230629,
-0.5085537434,
-0.308083266,
0.0686069801,
-0.6620948911,
-0.627116859,
0.1685483754,
-0.0823314264,
0.2834974825,
-0.5537186861,
0.3008871078,
0.496041894,
-0.1943736672,
-0.0504930429,
0.7592486143,
-0.606041491,
-0.4041359425,
0.7915681005,
-0.139917776,
0.799200058,
-0.2645277977,
0.0767206475,
-0.3470676243,
-0.2634281814,
-0.4906165302,
-0.095186159,
-0.8852699995,
0.03804975,
-0.7553043962,
-0.3125149012,
-0.2592996657,
-0.0031011193,
-0.7131224275,
-0.4206593037,
0.3405272067,
0.0200554207,
0.0668446496,
0.5436854959,
0.3025270104,
0.3576746881,
-0.8119391203,
0.2793450058,
0.3953450918,
0.4501680732,
-0.0021484185,
-0.4990876019,
-0.116723761,
0.1783307344,
-0.176952213,
-0.6713421345,
0.3147751391,
-0.1051906049,
0.7677938938,
0.2413200587,
-0.0220786519,
0.7089868188,
-0.3792301118,
0.6421711445,
-0.0190738495,
-0.9156034589,
0.5466845632,
-0.3612265587,
0.7065552473,
0.8995499611,
0.0278833006,
-1.083334446,
-0.4806718528,
-0.781511724,
-0.5681189299,
0.6982719302,
0.4448482096,
0.3651796281,
0.2129702717,
-0.0658870712,
0.1084325835,
0.4353034496,
-0.42784518,
0.0042503187,
-0.159935087,
-0.0890159011,
-0.1684800386,
-0.0480356179,
-0.0543202534,
-0.121657677,
0.4217925668,
-0.2342044115,
0.1722435802,
-0.1732614338,
-0.4294793606,
0.0575848483,
0.3214582503,
0.3816661835,
0.684754312,
-0.135358274,
-0.1665603667,
0.4094357491,
-0.4212107658,
-0.1322156787,
0.2465726137,
0.1154362932,
0.1895394474,
0.1942809522,
0.8225507736,
0.62005651,
-1.0451631546,
0.170153141,
-0.1514341235,
-0.0307335798,
-0.0235231835,
0.1003855616,
0.3142983913,
0.3419519365,
-0.1323598176,
0.0410792567,
0.1740428209,
-0.4808842242,
-0.0456300899,
0.2974513769,
-0.4504277408,
-0.3232700527,
0.237970382,
0.3662551045,
-0.5133089423,
0.7076509595,
-0.2894260585,
-0.7899343371,
0.7226606607,
0.4549824297,
0.8760130405,
-0.2348843366,
0.4193174243,
0.5644471645,
-0.0258586016,
-0.0648703575,
0.1552651823,
-0.3323400617,
-0.8225301504,
-0.1792221963,
-0.3449256122,
-0.8903989196,
0.255307734,
-0.7519674301,
-0.001560159,
-0.0433270112,
-0.0680018514,
0.0725439116,
0.160733521,
-0.6770358682,
-0.3905551136,
0.0420420468,
0.7254040837,
-0.8793788552,
0.5542512536,
0.604088366,
-0.1834400892,
-0.2992266119,
0.0270552579,
-0.0739760399,
-0.6732755303,
0.629453063,
0.4063114226,
-0.0833411142,
-0.0736025721,
-0.440785259,
-0.6612357497,
0.7008292079,
0.4144558907,
-0.3347580731,
0.4278444648,
0.3439092338,
0.6382626891,
-0.4930054545,
0.177586779,
0.7961063385,
0.2476768643,
-0.0928174853,
-1.2945108414,
-0.3746504486,
-0.5778400898,
0.1620642245,
0.0068857819,
-0.4969898462,
0.4911335707,
0.2439555526,
-0.1878735572,
0.4864156842,
0.4790678024,
0.2570756674,
0.6669251919,
0.7010707259,
0.3073761463,
0.8215130568,
0.009781044,
0.9301888347,
-0.5514103174,
0.221204713,
1.4473198652,
-0.5251537561,
0.7586666346,
0.0950495899,
-0.3201777637,
0.3385009468,
0.4037897885,
0.2398761213,
0.498611629,
0.1567407101,
-0.4259544611,
-0.543395102,
-0.4673540294,
-0.1958795786,
0.6122214198,
0.2163070887,
-0.1007474661,
-0.3279680014,
0.1914123893,
0.1495702565,
0.2842595279,
-0.2500621378,
0.8718603253,
-0.0972444117,
-0.8096040487,
0.3694430888,
-0.3686076701,
-0.0540217645,
-0.5122750998,
-0.050060004,
-0.3557418883,
0.3239488006,
0.3100996912,
-0.5289806128,
-0.0068346295,
0.0520361811,
-0.0766900256,
-0.0656198785,
0.9811785221,
-0.5779446959,
-0.3696359694,
0.1652966291,
0.7030831575,
0.3429103494,
-0.1853072494,
-0.7399684787,
0.1697051674,
-0.1088756546,
-0.0345829874,
0.4260615706,
0.1018467546,
0.0146239419,
0.673855722,
0.6503199935,
-0.2552096844,
0.0126138898,
0.4056717455,
0.7863351703,
-0.3022910357,
-0.5316395164,
-0.38664639,
0.3140157461,
-0.5676127672,
-0.3652373254,
0.9156340957,
0.6609307528,
1.1379683018,
-0.2334354222,
0.8652860522,
0.1409141421,
0.6344608068,
-0.4514561296,
0.6771354079,
-0.1029594317,
-0.1058748513,
-0.3724894226,
-0.8114572167,
0.2066792697,
0.994220078,
-0.4884092808,
0.0670032874,
0.4258382022,
0.9096401334,
-0.154933691,
0.3874929547,
0.462161988,
0.1245941371,
0.1312989444,
0.152846247,
1.1006503105,
-0.3233559132,
0.729993403,
-0.521050036,
0.0242557153,
-0.3889945447,
-0.7398379445,
-1.2873004675,
-0.5016958117,
-0.2470165938,
-0.3841091096,
0.1162818521,
1.0389937162,
0.7241301537,
-0.8243990541,
-0.5628095269,
-0.1922434717,
0.0773846805,
-0.113058731,
-0.2128130943,
0.0104526579,
-0.6221129894,
-0.8481677771,
0.6819764376,
0.1976908147,
0.0493277796,
-0.1331993639,
-0.2521878779,
0.2750712037,
0.1262615621,
0.5900473595,
0.4481389225,
-0.7174380422,
-0.0196322836,
0.3580063283,
-0.1134900451,
-0.065987505,
0.9049104452,
-0.753395319,
1.0044752359,
0.5232898593,
0.7312766314,
0.4612137973,
0.0485403724,
0.7446557283,
-0.4423167109,
0.2784255445,
0.1880396903,
0.0473793373,
0.3116441667,
0.0508924052,
0.6934282184,
0.0907655805,
-0.5906815529,
-1.1915737391,
0.2988393307,
-0.8234306574,
-0.0233429149,
0.8583855033,
-0.2501300871,
-0.0611157306,
-0.4334747493,
-0.5192648172,
0.0922981799,
-0.3416751921,
0.7607221603,
1.0722686052,
-0.0866786689,
-0.0136380251,
-1.2823227644,
0.3664224744,
0.4679675698,
-0.8798856139,
0.6007378101,
0.3720865846,
0.1435876936,
0.2337322831,
0.7181490064,
0.0243780073,
0.6274031401,
0.2473691255,
-0.1849511564,
0.2012102753,
-0.1880567819,
-0.2607791126,
-0.2264318019,
-0.067619659,
-0.1082236171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17371v1
|
A Dataset for Metaphor Detection in Early Medieval Hebrew Poetry
| 2024-02-27T10:09:40 | 2024-02-27T10:09:40 |
Michael Toker, Oren Mishali, Ophir Münz-Manor, Benny Kimelfeld, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
There is a large volume of late antique and medieval Hebrew texts. They
represent a crucial linguistic and cultural bridge between Biblical and modern
Hebrew. Poetry is prominent in these texts and one of its main haracteristics
is the frequent use of metaphor. Distinguishing figurative and literal language
use is a major task for scholars of the Humanities, especially in the fields of
literature, linguistics, and hermeneutics. This paper presents a new,
challenging dataset of late antique and medieval Hebrew poetry with expert
annotations of metaphor, as well as some baseline results, which we hope will
facilitate further research in this area.
|
[
-0.3815634549,
-0.440159291,
0.2616235018,
0.0339638516,
-0.5352411866,
-0.3552798629,
-0.0305812638,
-0.5618210435,
0.3505437076,
0.4982846081,
-0.2823450565,
-0.3622882962,
-0.6694529653,
0.14862068,
-0.4143367708,
0.706253767,
-0.0798167363,
-0.0690554306,
0.1780167967,
-0.3973037004,
-0.7383409142,
-0.3285655975,
-0.5001309514,
-0.317719698,
0.5602862835,
0.0609675013,
1.1549547911,
0.6327115297,
0.5204975009,
0.4389962256,
-0.0115943868,
0.1309299171,
-0.2206718773,
0.6151019931,
-0.0777008235,
-0.6902506948,
-0.0439353697,
0.4477464855,
0.8309442997,
0.472769022,
-0.1486057043,
0.2145764232,
-0.4087593555,
0.4517614841,
-0.8148061037,
0.3375557959,
-1.1974592209,
0.5297251344,
-1.1095837355,
-0.8219891787,
-0.4351674914,
-0.1817872971,
-0.0625226647,
-0.8085588813,
-0.0442654043,
0.7566612363,
0.7856195569,
0.3197623491,
-0.1674689353,
-0.2793811858,
-0.3063641191,
1.0407760143,
-0.3415414691,
0.2539453506,
0.6854109764,
0.8819233775,
-0.4785611331,
-1.0088828802,
-0.4609289169,
-0.3949322701,
-0.3225463331,
0.0560203195,
-0.8168839216,
-0.6490618587,
0.4116251767,
0.253176868,
-0.5768723488,
0.0770511329,
-0.3587357104,
-0.4655916691,
0.0918372497,
0.380124867,
0.6224477887,
-0.3204238117,
-0.3828772306,
-0.1691807508,
-0.6384442449,
-0.1015256047,
0.4136584103,
0.0688041821,
-0.1058796421,
0.5642781258,
0.2165331841,
0.8697630763,
-0.5702499747,
-0.1424874663,
0.4697734118,
0.0381155685,
-0.1148843914,
0.2308422327,
0.5351572037,
0.3651108742,
0.7415862679,
-0.1238693073,
0.002313514,
0.4413279891,
0.4670844972,
-0.4027559757,
-0.4444437027,
-0.614014864,
-0.7109802365,
-0.2767254114,
-0.0814894363,
-0.4043772221,
-0.5557847023,
-0.1516967714,
-0.2700386643,
-0.4252993166,
0.1191698089,
0.1729889959,
-0.7229251862,
0.0527008437,
0.3423902392,
-0.5926288962,
0.199312672,
0.5880380869,
0.6661806703,
0.0285614822,
-0.4680961668,
-0.7241692543,
0.3143410981,
-0.4648558199,
0.9687111974,
-0.9544637203,
0.1946132034,
-0.1102369651,
0.0754395947,
0.3253794312,
-0.7198570967,
1.0996083021,
-0.76056391,
0.2584303021,
0.0135099208,
-0.6146833897,
-0.3263821304,
0.1839851737,
-1.1011819839,
0.9860637784,
0.26562953,
-1.2756487131,
0.0349131636,
0.0560711995,
-0.0179800298,
0.4349182844,
-0.8653723598,
-0.0774052367,
0.4419710636,
-0.0335397124,
0.3253993988,
-0.9035657048,
-0.0913789123,
-0.0648896247,
-0.8111719489,
0.6039347053,
-0.5585134029,
0.9687136412,
0.4349873364,
-0.193327263,
-0.4193995297,
-0.7174324989,
0.0503824539,
0.3165343702,
0.220995307,
-0.907931149,
-0.0445683636,
0.4478056729,
0.0567577034,
-0.0917632654,
-0.4182522297,
-0.0555353016,
-0.4160499275,
0.1906822175,
0.4872301817,
-0.3685982227,
-0.1548987329,
-0.6576573253,
0.7059569359,
-0.0770500004,
-0.3542176187,
-0.2267911434,
-0.5721360445,
-0.1453533322,
-0.384428978,
0.4546093643,
0.390742898,
-0.9314104915,
0.4876107574,
-0.3434780836,
-0.5269392729,
-0.5920089483,
-0.1145633906,
0.0444328822,
0.572413981,
0.4288196564,
-0.3991115689,
-0.2540434301,
-1.1285939217,
-0.6153727174,
-0.2525652945,
-0.2299858183,
0.2421545982,
0.3381198943,
0.0976497307,
0.9022298455,
-0.4840532243,
-0.4031308293,
0.1951290816,
0.2859761715,
0.0132385725,
0.2557884157,
1.1099817753,
-0.9819646478,
-0.3812347353,
-0.026860008,
-0.6643355489,
-0.3502339721,
-0.0033033062,
-0.253251195,
-0.4547776282,
0.5383350253,
-0.18958956,
0.5584321022,
0.3875465989,
-0.5240374804,
0.4428494275,
0.0437565483,
0.1842897087,
-0.7905961871,
0.1407126486,
-0.1885572374,
-0.0237192158,
-0.5429508686,
-0.1656408459,
0.02089989,
0.197255224,
-0.5322474241,
0.8043422699,
-0.2154339701,
0.2832651138,
-0.457924664,
0.0881276578,
-0.1742599159,
-0.1186163276,
0.0999499932,
0.6392217875,
0.5490139127,
0.1720300317,
0.7585506439,
0.4504959285,
-0.3289217353,
0.8593946099,
-0.478010118,
0.0391145349,
-0.3361306787,
0.4351224899,
-0.8843812943,
-0.1929477602,
0.4487888813,
-0.3809467256,
-0.0023735175,
-0.0584847145,
-0.8409528136,
-0.1185440719,
-0.3576898277,
1.1744418144,
0.5820938349,
-0.2626060247,
0.3619429469,
0.1756298244,
-0.034751676,
-0.6617000699,
-0.7966710329,
0.256149739,
-0.5113571286,
-0.5972503424,
0.5300887227,
0.2738702297,
-0.4299657345,
0.1463276297,
-0.0126065174,
-0.3193073571,
0.0558880046,
0.0773769021,
0.2542656064,
-0.159561798,
0.0141941505,
-0.0638663247,
-0.4501498044,
-0.0422294699,
-0.0336067341,
0.5551773906,
-0.0903048664,
-0.4415258467,
-0.6951993108,
0.4397622943,
0.6930894256,
-0.1542291194,
0.569188714,
0.7243115902,
-0.6378821731,
0.1343765557,
-0.6426157951,
-0.0192150548,
-0.4375310838,
-0.0185258985,
-0.2430636436,
-0.5828788877,
0.4908394516,
-0.0798319131,
-0.3330528736,
0.5336031318,
0.5109394193,
-0.1466456354,
0.1879051179,
-0.0773871541,
-0.3374559879,
0.2077079564,
0.2587070465,
-0.0489244163,
-0.5777894258,
0.0768343583,
-0.8992389441,
-0.6389929652,
-0.8901267052,
-0.5216794014,
0.3568965197,
-0.2050071806,
-0.164603591,
0.1019795761,
-0.2423825264,
0.3480467498,
0.5467989445,
-0.4035723507,
0.26127702,
0.5928324461,
-0.164816007,
-0.5480310917,
-0.3322688341,
-0.6020407677,
0.7856038213,
0.4044261873,
0.4400122166,
-0.0236856434,
0.4812379777,
0.559237957,
0.0057334267,
-0.6498103142,
0.4232082367,
-0.3129470348,
-0.5872119665,
0.1432043314,
-0.4276275039,
-1.321752429,
0.3033894897,
-0.1255725026,
-0.7932021022,
-0.0770067051,
0.043578703,
-0.193426162,
0.1398818046,
0.0287488867,
0.7830656171,
0.217853412,
0.1655557901,
-0.1453073472,
-0.8229156733,
-0.0411417112,
0.0052681821,
0.300980866,
-0.2233754545,
-0.2234217972,
0.770642817,
-0.0714543387,
0.5894316435,
0.1405295432,
0.1589647532,
0.4114490151,
0.4456842542,
0.689119935,
-0.5334367156,
-0.0313897841,
0.0444498174,
0.2939703465,
-0.5853489637,
-0.5238783956,
0.4977350235,
-0.2769698501,
0.0624073409,
-0.8958576322,
-0.7768878937,
0.0704072118,
0.0419730581,
0.2788375914,
0.2960895002,
0.0753525123,
0.5303180218,
0.0604889058,
-0.1814845949,
0.1687728763,
0.2124978453,
0.0278351884,
-0.2994104326,
0.5609805584,
0.2008033991,
-0.3559926152,
0.0174445268,
0.3181999326,
-0.0391638055,
-0.4151460826,
-0.3477535844,
0.127694115,
-0.6777307391,
-0.226628527,
-0.0300011672,
-0.2103353143,
0.147132203,
-0.2244410217,
-0.2324337512,
-0.225715071,
-0.2212577015,
0.3290683031,
0.4984994233,
0.2953182161,
0.4187824726,
0.449765563,
-0.8799414635,
0.3057349622,
0.1074018553,
0.0045118369,
0.0543621145,
-0.2989815474,
0.2530175149,
-0.3352389634,
-0.0398375988,
-1.2136780024,
0.1318766624,
0.0309729967,
0.4739377499,
0.3955466747,
0.0699289292,
0.3441808224,
-1.0375744104,
0.6941282153,
0.4565646946,
-0.4655962586,
0.230019629,
-0.4815907776,
0.0453277826,
0.4806870818,
0.5004828572,
-0.9796866179,
-0.4457299411,
-0.6246989965,
-0.6136012077,
0.4698196352,
0.80667454,
0.3603904247,
-0.2611869872,
0.4580227435,
0.4086821973,
0.3472134173,
-0.5616856813,
-0.6012465358,
0.1064366102,
-0.4023476243,
0.1880092472,
-0.1009792909,
-0.2929647863,
-0.551974237,
0.0869712383,
0.1238429844,
0.140199542,
-0.4690959454,
-0.1492094547,
0.0538937561,
0.2459197342,
0.1322131455,
0.730843842,
0.2720039189,
0.7404999733,
0.1347935349,
-0.6340999603,
0.0247646142,
0.0852562487,
-0.3682517707,
0.1095814705,
0.7506438494,
0.7964462638,
0.1344542503,
-0.596868217,
0.3913827538,
0.2546892166,
0.2755703032,
-0.8296433687,
-0.0296008419,
-0.1324579567,
0.4759232998,
0.4951491654,
0.1107423529,
0.326031208,
-0.4644965529,
0.1335257888,
0.3788702488,
-0.2392973006,
-0.2467111647,
0.3747774065,
-0.5566135645,
-0.2072977424,
0.6775532365,
-0.3295717239,
-0.4662894309,
0.3928009272,
0.6791136265,
0.6016372442,
-0.1106316596,
0.2135926783,
-0.1718641073,
0.1425932646,
0.2006025612,
0.2962965071,
0.2747874558,
-0.747384131,
-0.0695504025,
-0.7322312593,
0.1321395189,
0.3006226718,
-0.6244130135,
0.2551640272,
0.0853061229,
-0.2497141212,
0.3746387959,
-0.3970359862,
-0.9639231563,
0.0467064641,
0.2592959702,
0.8367571831,
-1.1236314774,
0.6873295903,
0.840456605,
-0.130234167,
-0.4332657754,
0.0578969344,
0.2174569964,
-0.7782199979,
1.137382865,
-0.00294017,
-0.4131482542,
0.0605524704,
-0.3970698416,
-0.3396700621,
0.9377909303,
0.5563855171,
-0.191447705,
-0.0880740359,
-0.1022589579,
0.6925259233,
-0.3948041499,
0.3816688359,
0.7771379948,
0.7155334353,
0.1230813488,
-0.7901968956,
0.0405481122,
-0.3558018506,
0.2146042585,
0.2865487337,
-0.355149895,
0.9478075504,
0.7575005889,
-0.1532796472,
0.2771710157,
0.8161374331,
0.4935455322,
0.5123023987,
0.6491249204,
0.7314623594,
0.678422451,
0.0073943059,
0.8531911373,
-0.1356648207,
0.0280847903,
0.9683577418,
-0.1456347704,
0.7320137024,
0.5909235477,
-0.2310636193,
0.5135890841,
0.6032319069,
-0.3796864152,
0.4591027796,
0.7098932862,
-0.4701577723,
-0.2651604414,
-0.6170594096,
-0.7506241798,
0.7992199659,
0.2178088129,
-0.5072417855,
-0.4889092147,
-0.0122528477,
0.3270431459,
0.1948493719,
-0.1283000708,
0.2694862187,
0.1176045537,
-0.2698975205,
0.4504807889,
0.0951380581,
0.346578151,
-0.3471625447,
-0.239983052,
0.3169065714,
-0.1508752853,
0.0776141286,
-0.3981925249,
0.1953648776,
-0.004521091,
0.109365873,
0.2524769306,
0.8777243495,
-0.2497146279,
-0.5619837642,
0.3578094542,
0.7964324355,
0.5940603614,
0.0236817133,
-0.3664509952,
0.0932272896,
-0.427423805,
-0.1774664819,
-0.0422415026,
0.7882193923,
-0.395956099,
0.3752945662,
0.2237689942,
0.4418259263,
0.1570513546,
0.0981561616,
0.8823862672,
-0.648511529,
-0.4669641554,
-0.8166787624,
0.0866067111,
-0.1267538518,
-0.3616045117,
0.6410438418,
0.3523899615,
0.7039522529,
-0.1273310035,
0.5854307413,
-0.0101717617,
0.1325285435,
-0.48491624,
0.8957300782,
-0.755235672,
-0.1087453812,
-0.3079318702,
-0.825652957,
-0.3855837882,
1.0365701914,
-0.2777433395,
0.0978786126,
0.8799444437,
0.305567354,
-0.4648151994,
0.3961039484,
0.1158317253,
-0.0419285744,
-0.0879217759,
0.2247377038,
1.2069138288,
-0.3940842748,
0.0463303663,
-0.0045242151,
-0.0567623824,
-0.1545807272,
-1.0834776163,
-0.8709217906,
-0.7106833458,
-0.253811568,
-0.2103435546,
-0.1111992374,
1.2607083321,
0.1807981879,
-0.8024016023,
-0.0114675034,
0.2064679712,
-0.4467909336,
-0.2171425223,
-0.0699213371,
0.6429602504,
-0.3548532426,
-0.6693184376,
0.4189326763,
0.0542819872,
0.1626847982,
0.0264851004,
0.0401203036,
0.0221385788,
-0.0659237429,
0.2415051758,
-0.0734951645,
-0.9951024652,
-0.4856776595,
-0.2581562698,
-0.0438202098,
0.0966807902,
1.0325843096,
-0.5413241982,
0.5022303462,
0.6986282468,
0.7460231781,
0.1330025494,
-0.0697469264,
0.1493034959,
-0.9528207183,
0.6998000741,
0.5547660589,
0.5985590816,
0.0722072423,
-0.0115431305,
0.433945626,
0.6276284456,
-0.1289824992,
-0.8013572693,
0.3721146584,
-0.9394519925,
-0.1695153564,
0.6366987824,
-0.3544920683,
0.0787035152,
-0.2647168934,
-0.3328703344,
0.285061121,
-0.0764092579,
0.7593556643,
1.2924295664,
0.2096226364,
0.0064311088,
-1.1510386467,
0.4699070454,
0.6498245001,
-0.469463557,
-0.2121013403,
0.7895019054,
-0.0616132431,
0.3176749051,
0.4283261597,
-0.1953070015,
0.346896112,
-0.024924811,
-0.1977348328,
-0.0651633739,
-0.6573451161,
0.0488562584,
0.5119849443,
0.051283408,
-0.257211417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17358v1
|
SoFA: Shielded On-the-fly Alignment via Priority Rule Following
| 2024-02-27T09:52:27 | 2024-02-27T09:52:27 |
Xinyu Lu, Bowen Yu, Yaojie Lu, Hongyu Lin, Haiyang Yu, Le Sun, Xianpei Han, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignment problem in Large Language Models (LLMs) involves adapting them
to the broad spectrum of human values. This requirement challenges existing
alignment methods due to diversity of preferences and regulatory standards.
This paper introduces a novel alignment paradigm, priority rule following,
which defines rules as the primary control mechanism in each dialog,
prioritizing them over user instructions. Our preliminary analysis reveals that
even the advanced LLMs, such as GPT-4, exhibit shortcomings in understanding
and prioritizing the rules. Therefore, we present PriorityDistill, a
semi-automated approach for distilling priority following signals from LLM
simulations to ensure robust rule integration and adherence. Our experiments
show that this method not only effectively minimizes misalignments utilizing
only one general rule but also adapts smoothly to various unseen rules,
ensuring they are shielded from hijacking and that the model responds
appropriately.
|
[
-0.2142964453,
-0.7813099623,
0.5851757526,
0.2495558113,
-0.0343860164,
0.2161628157,
0.0198118668,
0.0211766325,
-0.0301371031,
0.8056377172,
-0.6724419594,
-0.3848429024,
-0.4734580517,
-0.0817951635,
-0.344510138,
0.8789643645,
-0.067097567,
-0.3159162998,
-0.1542124599,
0.0299573708,
-0.4785684049,
-0.5173093081,
-0.3075475693,
-0.096780479,
0.4823195338,
0.6046450138,
0.9852434993,
0.9256606102,
0.6254237294,
0.3082719445,
-0.1731563807,
0.0431883298,
-0.4149363339,
0.125501737,
-0.1579782367,
-0.4970060587,
-0.832077682,
-0.0619684234,
0.5930207968,
0.371545732,
-0.3427341878,
-0.0958600789,
0.3074774444,
0.6087937355,
-0.4734101295,
-0.2874770463,
-0.4919392765,
0.0563431866,
-0.4630067647,
-0.2653462887,
-0.402459383,
-0.4323571622,
-0.0295280814,
-0.5430044532,
-0.1826754957,
0.1101113483,
1.1259400845,
0.7047069073,
-0.5221885443,
0.0206617285,
-0.527476728,
0.7317857742,
-0.6636180282,
0.2413496077,
0.35217309,
0.2182319164,
-0.4542401433,
-0.363997221,
-0.5896764994,
0.0641411468,
-0.1410277486,
0.0379918441,
0.013476057,
0.2286572158,
0.3460631669,
0.0873540416,
-0.7116822004,
0.3418728113,
0.0800578818,
-0.2525111735,
0.4248272479,
0.1594546437,
0.3466190398,
0.029318165,
-0.4257645607,
0.0297467038,
-0.8317158222,
0.1863348335,
0.2615901828,
0.1849909872,
-0.1368977726,
0.6430758238,
-0.2193182856,
0.8647590876,
0.7392231226,
-0.2136909217,
0.162305966,
-0.445602566,
-0.3321716487,
0.2045836896,
0.578867197,
0.5994827747,
0.1012318581,
-0.1156096011,
-0.1252534389,
-0.1943057775,
0.4336394072,
-0.4403912127,
0.0600728393,
0.2922361195,
-0.1742756665,
-0.5708174109,
-0.2492636591,
-0.901945591,
-0.5549286008,
-0.4803840518,
0.2683249414,
0.121853061,
-0.1149918661,
0.1080386341,
0.3676920533,
0.5418083072,
0.1894322783,
-1.0937325954,
0.3522752523,
0.7991197705,
0.8360645771,
-0.289332509,
-0.042607829,
-0.7571703792,
0.6404489875,
-0.3469173908,
0.7617313266,
-0.4154003561,
-0.1341905296,
-0.0763300508,
0.2005276233,
-0.0140466793,
-0.065768525,
0.8261256218,
-0.673976779,
0.0806600004,
-0.1849627495,
-0.6120461822,
0.0846871212,
0.117779389,
-0.6739846468,
0.7249746323,
-0.1275684386,
-0.6651830673,
0.3666185141,
-0.5006558299,
-0.5869409442,
0.0134047335,
-0.2257518321,
-0.5521942973,
-0.0672350898,
0.2090134323,
0.3464200497,
0.0041199764,
0.3298486173,
-0.3622553647,
-0.1474197805,
0.1423270404,
-0.2918865085,
0.82050699,
0.1642613262,
-0.5530575514,
0.4255570173,
-0.3944997489,
0.0345965065,
-0.1128402948,
-0.2174741626,
-0.2092203349,
0.1881716996,
-0.1718789339,
0.4621018469,
0.2677743733,
-0.101179637,
0.4763560295,
-0.1913999766,
0.4130465984,
1.1939879656,
-0.1381953359,
0.9703642726,
-0.545422554,
0.6065042615,
-0.3671222031,
0.2564853132,
0.3015767634,
-0.2746120393,
-0.7409807444,
-0.4050900936,
0.4185142219,
0.7647641897,
-0.3139629364,
0.94621104,
-0.1695938855,
-0.2445044369,
-0.7618358135,
0.2910528779,
0.2871624231,
0.3234193921,
0.1573760808,
-0.0357004888,
-0.4074486494,
-0.9302063584,
0.0546734743,
0.033994671,
0.0531007238,
0.0495231673,
-0.2119670212,
-0.1353360415,
0.9665051699,
-0.4561090469,
-0.2992768884,
-0.2816137373,
-0.023221178,
0.1964839399,
0.606485188,
0.5354393125,
-0.90114218,
-0.5676805973,
-0.0601633266,
-0.5320925713,
-0.6966377497,
-0.3046284318,
-0.7116397023,
0.4509108961,
0.9356231689,
-0.5485447645,
0.4407420158,
0.6793398261,
-0.3539336622,
0.1894004792,
0.0540953763,
0.2202900797,
-1.1479926109,
0.0342572927,
-0.0930336416,
-0.4328618348,
-0.6884422898,
-0.1425329149,
0.2227363586,
0.248248741,
-0.2833996415,
0.4175064266,
-0.4839734435,
0.0893358663,
-0.3241120577,
-0.0719318762,
0.0998588353,
0.2532735467,
0.2269900143,
0.6945415139,
0.47310552,
-0.6196662784,
0.1202846766,
0.3762056828,
-0.2103523165,
0.6454838514,
-0.4561629295,
0.0722442195,
0.0224261824,
0.1874296218,
-1.0807087421,
-0.199802354,
0.2368559539,
-0.0032487691,
0.5908381939,
-0.4247536063,
-0.3641123474,
-0.2191573828,
-0.0302658379,
0.2599161267,
0.62361449,
-0.1235789955,
0.6057136655,
0.789108336,
-0.4656721652,
-0.6975899935,
-0.4015055299,
0.0620082244,
-0.5963112712,
-0.3365620077,
0.5497823358,
-0.3729932308,
-0.3518289924,
-0.2668987215,
-0.2040065825,
0.0948165432,
0.3312498629,
0.3538682163,
0.3587413728,
0.1222803593,
-0.1921625435,
0.1009507701,
-0.113649942,
-0.2827300131,
-0.3836792111,
0.4747312069,
0.1724387705,
-0.3323937654,
-0.7576684356,
0.3597340584,
0.858181417,
-0.1309307963,
0.2750173211,
0.1069731936,
-0.1671597064,
-0.1302787364,
-0.6536387205,
-0.1644552201,
-0.5266820192,
0.1329502165,
-0.3685144186,
-0.7308895588,
0.3378357291,
0.1559844911,
0.2810578346,
0.0872808024,
0.6665073037,
-0.3680978417,
0.999882102,
1.0938578844,
-0.378529489,
0.6755790114,
0.5652829409,
0.296652168,
-0.5205422044,
0.1128117889,
-0.5477291942,
-0.5568119884,
-0.5730864406,
-0.5531036258,
0.1503494829,
0.1912750155,
-0.1475454867,
0.6322841644,
-0.4997843206,
0.7303743362,
0.3911497891,
-0.1842038333,
0.2646508813,
-0.1001023278,
-0.267300427,
0.0760910287,
-0.6255609393,
-0.6322533488,
0.930383265,
0.289495945,
0.9412170053,
0.2752394378,
0.6612114906,
0.3811454773,
0.2836049795,
-0.5387341976,
0.6038455367,
0.0527786948,
-0.6157593131,
-0.4296250343,
-0.300289005,
-0.6576734185,
0.0767502263,
-0.0249600746,
-0.8106015325,
0.0620787852,
0.2491763979,
-0.7971017361,
0.0047203787,
-0.4771654904,
0.9379011393,
-0.5059761405,
-0.6330089569,
0.0871695131,
-0.8834501505,
0.2324336171,
-0.1587342024,
0.1418526173,
-0.2939501405,
-0.03570164,
0.5505369306,
-0.2438358665,
0.8240154386,
0.0055942107,
-0.2537777126,
0.0318386964,
0.2023703605,
0.4451438785,
-0.2197234631,
-0.0353502519,
-0.0599053577,
-0.0786864907,
-0.4513361752,
-0.260681808,
0.7709861994,
-0.5114566088,
-0.8497776985,
-0.4628025591,
-0.5705133677,
-0.2350839823,
0.3583617806,
0.2634304166,
-0.0537240542,
-0.1100827605,
-0.0056729582,
0.7011187077,
0.0429448485,
0.540215075,
0.6787124872,
-0.0792643279,
-0.2683996558,
0.5430734754,
0.186758101,
0.4487993717,
0.4904393852,
-0.0028140421,
-0.4868621528,
-0.538654387,
-0.4475474358,
-0.0351823606,
-0.4630642831,
-0.2614864707,
-0.6387147903,
-0.1029377654,
-0.5351561904,
-0.6968662143,
-0.1774841249,
-0.4220054746,
-0.1188667864,
-0.2568948865,
0.1529995203,
0.5377053618,
0.077831082,
0.3026234806,
-0.697049737,
0.2487607002,
0.2079667151,
0.3113509119,
-0.4733704627,
-0.5876925588,
0.1515855938,
-0.2813447714,
-0.4617949426,
-0.7274163365,
0.1854572147,
-0.2422573417,
0.8199667931,
0.5631877184,
0.2097044885,
0.8122412562,
-0.7111779451,
0.3588194847,
-0.0356103554,
-1.0226340294,
0.3353904784,
-0.3772693872,
0.2493065447,
0.7663679123,
0.2632922232,
-0.4462390244,
-0.6474798322,
-0.3937932551,
-0.85884583,
0.6533315778,
0.1305240095,
-0.136145547,
0.2602792978,
0.246476993,
-0.1118279099,
0.2002802938,
-0.6347540021,
0.3256530464,
0.1998026371,
-0.5819060206,
-0.0854546353,
-0.10754361,
-0.3386476636,
-0.0770113319,
0.592782259,
-0.1653888226,
-0.0524266027,
-0.0634238347,
-0.2639283538,
-0.2266107351,
0.2133468688,
0.8395701647,
0.4114367366,
-0.1378591508,
-0.0512636825,
-0.1407321095,
-0.2325548381,
0.3634446263,
0.094651714,
-0.3205914199,
-0.4964680374,
0.104955852,
0.3983308971,
0.2395814359,
-0.4130167961,
0.5239907503,
-0.0626683608,
-0.0917710587,
-0.0879607946,
0.0564070418,
0.0836412609,
0.1967746317,
0.0077473624,
-0.0392340943,
-0.0413996987,
-0.1889227629,
0.5951439738,
0.4289775789,
-0.3432562947,
-0.1337325275,
0.6702320576,
0.4250361919,
-0.0517365895,
0.4209636152,
0.0098939463,
-0.4446390569,
0.7203858495,
0.2642681599,
0.8740075231,
-0.3746839762,
-0.0218546521,
0.0125502264,
0.3991954029,
-0.2556019127,
0.125339523,
0.0256817359,
-0.7962206006,
-0.4389534295,
-0.7021375895,
-0.2976643145,
-0.0128977885,
-0.5737459064,
0.477787137,
-0.4409122765,
-0.2185326815,
0.0192719996,
-0.3854131699,
-0.2612647116,
-0.3315788209,
0.3132877052,
0.8586913347,
-0.9262325764,
0.962136209,
0.4622863233,
-0.1704517305,
-0.7113224864,
0.6375134587,
0.5903938413,
-0.5305719376,
0.2753207088,
0.1892109066,
-0.0313932784,
0.2258209139,
-0.4084944725,
-0.955316782,
0.9975540042,
0.168848455,
-0.8276934028,
-0.1334462762,
-0.1071465462,
0.2457037419,
-0.2407995015,
0.0611117743,
0.7236692905,
0.6477980614,
0.0990028158,
-1.1459430456,
0.1682407707,
-0.1162047312,
-0.2724962831,
0.3982815444,
-0.7534971237,
0.3694314063,
-0.1100248471,
-0.1922651082,
0.2282381952,
0.288857758,
0.0355457291,
0.0022460099,
0.6215281487,
0.6599391699,
0.6915583611,
-0.1731293201,
0.7353690267,
-0.3177521825,
0.070152238,
1.2372037172,
-0.9169129729,
0.6340847611,
0.6061502099,
0.0595580116,
0.1888153404,
0.7046538591,
0.1671967655,
0.8236989975,
0.2144009769,
-0.0766836181,
-0.4140304029,
-0.0349967964,
-0.0874731839,
0.4329457283,
0.1965747327,
-0.0402011983,
-0.0586499125,
-0.165693298,
0.0140552595,
0.108236827,
-0.3391299546,
1.226134181,
-0.226138562,
-1.0474582911,
0.6983362436,
-0.3031180799,
0.4018608034,
-0.5621094108,
0.0494507663,
-0.1869892031,
0.3096559346,
-0.2320678234,
-0.8817918897,
0.0878300294,
-0.0613123998,
-0.2427630126,
-0.5368228555,
0.3028627038,
-0.5985360146,
-0.27274701,
0.2283831388,
0.133793503,
-0.2519025505,
0.3242683113,
-0.6963502765,
0.2312880903,
0.1466369629,
-0.3464259207,
0.3960106075,
0.3318839669,
-0.5617584586,
0.5820948482,
0.5106694102,
-0.1214769781,
0.0588820949,
-0.0473546796,
0.8766924739,
-0.5386348963,
-0.7430387139,
-0.9787395597,
0.7470833063,
-0.3006562591,
0.0891850665,
0.582511723,
0.3498321176,
0.6273038983,
0.1926577389,
0.7888397574,
-0.0776026696,
0.2300126553,
-0.7210178375,
0.8602878451,
-0.471796453,
0.296361059,
-0.3936734498,
-0.8158524632,
-0.5507377386,
0.5843217373,
-0.2884814739,
-0.3437466323,
0.5695955157,
1.1098201275,
-0.0691682473,
-0.3005876541,
0.3621644378,
0.2382346839,
0.2978096902,
0.4635010064,
0.6249510646,
0.2283362597,
0.4078660905,
-0.0180454049,
-0.6269757748,
-0.5485793948,
-1.1794528961,
-0.7255494595,
-0.4597899318,
-0.327457279,
-0.3797745705,
0.1940029413,
0.9774883389,
0.9069726467,
-0.8297722936,
-0.3009809852,
-0.2508929968,
0.2471444458,
-0.3992524743,
-0.2012027651,
0.1892796159,
-0.3554463983,
-0.7271278501,
0.4614948332,
0.4453978837,
0.3668214381,
0.1736657023,
-0.0934783518,
-0.3761528134,
0.2356429398,
0.025023086,
0.3273530304,
-0.7528924942,
-0.261944592,
-0.0031333966,
-0.628354013,
0.0432985649,
0.8958435059,
-0.2813796997,
0.275583446,
0.5806351304,
0.6413161159,
-0.03282867,
0.4285194278,
0.8689570427,
-0.5095211864,
0.2451763898,
0.2762962878,
0.3736434877,
0.0638651028,
-0.5854822993,
0.3304255903,
0.0455747284,
-0.7560776472,
-0.8005111814,
0.4698268175,
-1.228777647,
-0.1261301786,
1.1765787601,
-0.0176010355,
-0.2344709188,
-0.2473435551,
-0.3635872602,
0.1624094844,
-0.4667264521,
0.8873638511,
0.904394865,
0.0305182766,
-0.1721757352,
-0.6733430028,
0.9334305525,
0.6745052338,
-0.7698898911,
0.4308879972,
0.5635396242,
0.3146342933,
-0.0119152805,
0.581420362,
-0.2004720122,
0.194319576,
-0.6062378287,
0.0921433866,
0.325190872,
-0.4271056056,
-0.5547556281,
0.1296919435,
0.1935364902,
-0.0953295529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17355v1
|
RECOST: External Knowledge Guided Data-efficient Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-27T09:47:36 | 2024-02-27T09:47:36 |
Qi Zhang, Yiming Zhang, Haobo Wang, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the current landscape of large language models (LLMs), the process of
instruction tuning serves as an essential step. Considering the high computing
power overhead, data-efficient instruction tuning was proposed to reduce the
training data size in this process, aiming at selecting high-quality
instructional data. Nevertheless, we argue that most current data-efficient
instruction-tuning methods are highly dependent on the quality of the original
instruction-tuning dataset. When it comes to datasets synthesized by LLMs, a
common scenario in this field, dirty samples will even be selected with a
higher probability than other samples. To address these challenges, we utilized
external knowledge (relevant examples or paragraphs) to evaluate those samples
synthesized by LLMs with an in-context-based relative predictive entropy. Based
on the new metric, we proposed a framework, dubbed as \textbf{RECOST}, which
integrates external-knowledge-base re-ranking and diversity-consistent sampling
into a single pipeline. Through extensive experiments on several synthetic
datasets (Alpaca and Alpaca-gpt4), we demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method and achieve even better results with only \textbf{1\%} of the full
dataset.
|
[
-0.2918823361,
-0.4770765007,
0.3764165342,
-0.0486102402,
-0.1049992517,
-0.0165661741,
-0.4064266086,
-0.3089359999,
0.0648870096,
0.4925562739,
-0.6796130538,
-0.6516558528,
-0.5124667883,
0.0057545207,
-0.4019020498,
0.8211665154,
-0.0433805361,
0.1118351817,
-0.3500036895,
0.0248950608,
-0.4638274014,
-0.1127848476,
-0.6873919964,
-0.2623469532,
0.368897438,
0.625908792,
0.2952281237,
0.9610090256,
0.4121542871,
0.3651888371,
0.1403860897,
0.5385702848,
-0.6592054963,
0.189968884,
-0.2471261919,
-0.616440773,
-0.1431599706,
-0.0283335317,
0.8291207552,
0.5538207889,
-0.3936589062,
0.3741595447,
0.1452106535,
0.8835330606,
-0.7216023207,
0.1129214317,
-1.1266264915,
-0.040978156,
-0.0648119524,
-0.4562712312,
-0.3608136475,
-0.7115107179,
-0.1277423948,
-0.6117126942,
0.5767387748,
0.1366030872,
0.4398328364,
0.5186870098,
-0.136415869,
-0.0808038786,
-0.4991787076,
0.894184947,
-0.4186048508,
0.7381844521,
0.438872993,
0.0720909238,
-0.3803673685,
-0.5490133762,
-0.3750339746,
0.2061379254,
0.1730660796,
-0.0911774263,
-0.1227606013,
-0.1187177896,
0.0700786859,
0.4976188838,
-0.3423316181,
0.1186300963,
-0.4066324532,
-0.0940510407,
0.3766841888,
0.2444779426,
-0.0231607221,
0.409403652,
-0.2128402144,
-0.1885343939,
-1.0773850679,
-0.0581179969,
0.3794589937,
0.3824156523,
0.0800512433,
0.2665891647,
-0.3050341904,
0.9004690051,
0.2779917717,
-0.1619158089,
0.3363402784,
-0.4968247712,
-0.3295305669,
0.0079203062,
0.451343596,
0.5008096695,
0.1185725108,
-0.2561495602,
-0.1671851277,
-0.3545699418,
0.3934808373,
-0.8283913732,
-0.3863353729,
-0.128236562,
-0.1833816767,
-0.269325614,
0.1782753468,
-0.9240729213,
-0.2833306193,
-0.64407444,
0.1386132091,
-0.4302768111,
0.0871595442,
-0.0461727269,
-0.0195429977,
0.2245871276,
0.3856446445,
-1.0686126947,
0.0506028458,
0.7365980148,
0.6695238352,
-0.1894704998,
-0.2194247991,
-0.6046048403,
0.1044328287,
-0.4403428733,
0.8098968267,
-0.747492969,
-0.2228552699,
-0.0722611248,
0.1535037309,
0.0771859959,
-0.6763410568,
0.2403062582,
-0.7217155695,
0.2126668096,
-0.5299914479,
-0.6629461646,
-0.1817924529,
0.1277432293,
-0.5630360842,
0.8546200395,
0.2339286655,
-0.5837627053,
0.6809663773,
-0.125304997,
-0.4522125721,
-0.3213321269,
-0.1258701533,
-0.401556462,
0.1337236762,
0.3359527588,
0.1337148249,
-0.4729580581,
0.0633947551,
-0.2301054001,
-0.5847179294,
-0.0642210692,
-0.5263386369,
0.515401125,
0.2175434977,
-0.2333933264,
-0.1254413575,
-0.8995797634,
0.3951898217,
-0.1512781084,
-0.7611482143,
-0.4131568372,
-0.1170618832,
-0.7093219757,
-0.150159657,
0.2687072754,
-0.6058437228,
0.2719593048,
-0.4383716881,
0.0619411245,
1.1078252792,
0.0259491894,
0.4483646154,
-0.4790947139,
0.5184982419,
-0.2676138878,
-0.0797932744,
-0.154042691,
-0.3651759624,
-0.6079081297,
-0.4070654213,
0.2094831169,
0.6619096398,
-0.7311640382,
0.5423637629,
-0.3211535513,
-0.4705368876,
-0.8480618596,
0.6259481907,
0.435495168,
0.517193675,
0.401172787,
-0.1301858127,
-0.6314277649,
-0.6998230219,
-0.228052929,
0.0475978069,
-0.1288588792,
0.2746404409,
0.1170334071,
-0.1715375632,
0.6372808218,
-0.5881797075,
-0.0118960021,
0.0262106862,
-0.0855963826,
0.3359417915,
0.5131845474,
0.2257712334,
-0.2977355123,
-0.3135116696,
-0.0656961724,
-0.6427306533,
-0.1948753893,
0.195442453,
-0.4790836573,
0.2198731303,
0.6074542403,
-0.357281208,
0.0238405187,
0.578132689,
0.008328571,
0.3836442232,
-0.2593248785,
0.4395911396,
-0.9815536141,
-0.1184475571,
-0.1334933192,
-0.0410057828,
-0.1961667836,
0.1298380643,
0.1269952059,
0.1065748706,
-0.1841942072,
0.2953436971,
-0.392713517,
0.0861428976,
-0.3522647619,
-0.2701669931,
0.0460979789,
0.4484187067,
0.0028653527,
0.8757945299,
0.4157145023,
-0.6747757792,
0.5390480757,
0.0636550263,
-0.8511501551,
0.3938186169,
-0.437961489,
0.2294670641,
-0.1626469791,
0.2073676437,
-0.8350904584,
-0.1034246311,
0.2079414278,
-0.1895096749,
0.6097086072,
-0.2544388473,
-0.582015276,
-0.0548504703,
-0.4480419457,
0.4181435406,
0.5144615769,
-0.9344998002,
0.0938141793,
0.3640712202,
-0.1305757463,
-0.7926826477,
-0.6428210735,
-0.3554169834,
-0.2565261126,
-0.5299094915,
0.4576390088,
-0.001608632,
-0.1575055271,
-0.0603638813,
-0.2162463218,
0.153828308,
-0.1821471006,
-0.0338873491,
0.0738267228,
-0.3158497214,
0.3212398589,
0.3001334965,
-0.0007931731,
0.0213697646,
-0.4631895125,
0.2776004076,
0.1173229218,
-0.4302299023,
-0.4187542498,
0.0764729902,
0.3001689911,
0.1642600596,
0.7986029983,
0.5097785592,
-0.2061596513,
-0.4449967444,
-0.4893689454,
-0.3597441018,
-0.5423567891,
0.3295563161,
-0.0333464742,
-0.5558088422,
0.1712401956,
0.0286808405,
0.5280748606,
-0.0018411889,
0.4173388779,
-0.2004990727,
0.6584260464,
0.54429245,
-0.2276702523,
0.8156195283,
-0.2063523233,
-0.0305547249,
-0.778390348,
-0.1737781316,
-0.3898309171,
-0.3990319669,
-0.8317224383,
-0.5220816731,
0.2358433902,
-0.2334220707,
-0.42772457,
0.2816256285,
-0.5553646684,
0.5896421075,
0.9487950802,
0.2587454319,
0.3553493619,
0.4919683933,
0.1334108561,
-0.0265642758,
-0.8696164489,
-0.1435002983,
1.3156349659,
0.0239230432,
1.0993232727,
-0.0231282432,
0.7857786417,
0.1320732385,
0.3826812506,
-0.3981202245,
0.4517459571,
-0.3083561957,
-0.4266766608,
-0.2955688238,
-0.8150351644,
-1.0710840225,
0.1791972816,
-0.06684874,
-0.4464153945,
0.121172227,
0.3200703859,
-0.1942258328,
0.5753682256,
-0.9037110209,
0.4711588025,
-0.0694919974,
-0.5198780298,
-0.2670072019,
-0.3591303229,
0.4319087565,
-0.1037785485,
0.1997276098,
0.0905653089,
-0.0119933812,
0.6598193049,
-0.4350521266,
0.876429677,
-0.1863039136,
-0.4952117801,
0.4354165196,
0.0366968997,
0.6136760116,
-0.0120538445,
-0.3258626759,
0.1565969139,
-0.105719462,
-0.1805372238,
-0.7273715138,
0.9600881934,
-0.7680999637,
-0.6951454878,
-0.0508324578,
-0.474999994,
-0.3427346051,
-0.0459713787,
0.4499886036,
0.4965417385,
0.0948706791,
0.3838683367,
0.8027154803,
-0.3915411532,
-0.0831044093,
0.5585446954,
0.1303275973,
-0.5046790838,
1.3069756031,
0.144349888,
0.3171161115,
0.7241964936,
0.0974067524,
-0.2009257525,
-0.5056647658,
-0.4194898605,
0.0780625641,
-0.7391209602,
-0.5862974524,
-0.1463402063,
-0.1118283644,
-0.3915148079,
-0.2098833025,
-0.4803308845,
-0.1753085554,
-0.3130348027,
-0.2057245523,
0.4815205038,
0.4451057911,
-0.1996997893,
0.1468439251,
-0.757797718,
0.2111087441,
0.2784726024,
0.6537317038,
-0.1318308413,
-0.7718886733,
-0.322039187,
0.2991394699,
-0.4071275592,
-0.381082803,
0.1325778514,
0.3798898458,
0.6652517319,
0.3304323256,
-0.0206450224,
0.6793033481,
-0.5005825162,
0.4891467988,
-0.0947415382,
-0.4700522721,
0.5258612037,
-0.0864017755,
0.342746079,
0.7727332115,
0.2174966633,
-0.1376812458,
-0.5522871017,
-0.4841658175,
-0.973472178,
0.6221631169,
-0.0721961856,
0.2061198652,
0.0084000602,
0.4009877145,
0.5889942646,
0.3607694507,
-0.4091913104,
-0.3932258189,
-0.0530573651,
-0.4194517136,
0.0744229928,
0.024671413,
-0.0597656704,
-0.3829122782,
0.8624793887,
0.0403843597,
0.3942030072,
-0.1833837926,
0.0985986143,
-0.2146325409,
0.0940344185,
0.4012116194,
0.6054236889,
-0.2856061459,
0.1442988515,
0.3076526523,
-0.4893147647,
0.1435164064,
-0.1765455604,
-0.2758745849,
-0.1171511859,
0.4658437967,
0.5401102304,
0.3207091093,
-0.5222549438,
0.0415548459,
0.017759189,
-0.0675762519,
-0.1690544635,
0.5730566382,
-0.1768993139,
0.2298086882,
0.1409466863,
0.0431110524,
-0.0891809613,
-0.4937002063,
0.3735828996,
0.4761004448,
-0.0224775858,
-0.2148195952,
0.2618964016,
0.2744689882,
-0.0663359687,
0.9098411202,
-0.1902170032,
0.0075469273,
0.5476858616,
0.5304811001,
0.5073058605,
-0.2612532377,
-0.080202058,
0.7005541921,
0.3734491765,
-0.1382880807,
0.2222463042,
-0.1534377187,
-0.899212718,
-0.3080655336,
-0.6675977707,
-0.2812150419,
0.3720878363,
-0.6421282887,
0.3026197255,
-0.4494140446,
0.0669631809,
-0.4475910068,
-0.1460578889,
-0.6933252811,
0.2474051863,
-0.1151077449,
0.9048746228,
-0.6037836075,
0.8560054898,
0.3683068156,
0.0925267637,
-0.38674891,
0.0920079201,
0.0027245774,
-1.1069978476,
0.4309183955,
-0.0128503665,
-0.4511689544,
0.02347151,
-0.5218061805,
-1.0846166611,
1.0961738825,
0.6819239259,
-0.6651111841,
0.0895007849,
-0.2267362028,
0.392168045,
-0.2644602358,
-0.119456619,
0.7098952532,
0.3844620585,
0.2469114363,
-0.4049120545,
0.0500271544,
-0.2041883618,
-0.2881505191,
0.2774524391,
-0.5526806712,
0.4349641204,
-0.4122319818,
-0.2428066134,
-0.0136873359,
0.7963920832,
0.4290775359,
0.2491743416,
0.4051347673,
0.5998166203,
1.015126586,
0.0170333888,
0.9527865052,
-0.4812237918,
-0.0070548123,
1.4042841196,
-0.0320352092,
0.7469457388,
0.4000581205,
-0.2814557552,
0.5881176591,
0.6475527883,
-0.165204078,
0.8530677557,
0.333176285,
-0.1928038001,
-0.1393264234,
0.1189563572,
-0.5861751437,
0.4418169558,
0.3108950257,
-0.5685036182,
-0.1446931362,
-0.402020514,
-0.1444858015,
-0.0148622496,
-0.3769997954,
0.8606569767,
0.0002452003,
-0.8483815789,
0.7786932588,
0.0828426704,
0.7850541472,
-0.6127837896,
-0.1101132184,
-0.3305075169,
0.1847916245,
-0.1143187582,
-0.9489938021,
0.3471051753,
0.0365672112,
-0.2810928822,
-0.2731654644,
0.4071588814,
-0.6226014495,
-0.6459999084,
-0.0773792565,
0.2764434218,
0.1120699495,
0.11431133,
-0.3564688861,
-0.1403596699,
0.1319807023,
-0.2771617472,
0.4966734648,
0.612990737,
0.2901425362,
0.7826989293,
0.7285071015,
0.2608718872,
-0.0170175098,
-0.0907122195,
0.6665257812,
-0.5502473712,
-0.3138619363,
-0.7912256122,
0.0460357293,
0.0692347959,
-0.2889540195,
0.6436274648,
0.5206072927,
1.0939377546,
0.0500830337,
0.8429068327,
0.1819533706,
0.3964163065,
-0.8654284477,
0.4796347022,
-0.5555891395,
0.4110612571,
-0.1385608613,
-0.7411285043,
0.0837237835,
0.6097912788,
-0.2152077556,
0.2869919538,
0.4464557171,
1.0559206009,
-0.1525848657,
0.1177096665,
0.1139955297,
-0.0556180477,
-0.0242601186,
0.661565125,
0.5177088976,
-0.2495076954,
0.5170782208,
-0.2544230223,
-0.1655548066,
-0.155169785,
-0.8745552897,
-0.5587784052,
-0.5825460553,
-0.2766543329,
-0.0720998198,
0.0050488766,
1.0169848204,
0.6474689841,
-0.8150775433,
0.0060224389,
-0.170098111,
0.4845268428,
-0.4183930159,
-0.2066299468,
0.285436511,
-0.3969249725,
-0.7032887936,
0.5769146085,
-0.092689313,
-0.0745032206,
-0.0098640444,
0.1203312203,
0.1951278001,
-0.008704491,
0.54759413,
0.227749899,
-0.3332801461,
-0.3356465995,
-0.0700162128,
-0.0628922284,
0.0191899892,
0.8510722518,
-0.6270191669,
0.3952511251,
0.6024334431,
0.8310915828,
0.2420160472,
0.1670620739,
0.8804734945,
-0.9945167303,
-0.1145170629,
-0.1903526634,
0.3195440173,
0.405811578,
-0.5228940248,
0.4031462371,
0.3125294447,
-0.4574859142,
-0.6978984475,
0.1064745784,
-0.4225889742,
-0.3116129637,
1.2804772854,
-0.1816874444,
-0.132270515,
0.1146794409,
0.0204697084,
0.256403774,
-0.5466204882,
1.2657285929,
0.5929319859,
-0.1334691346,
-0.0891880766,
-0.4302426279,
0.4942439497,
0.253798753,
-0.8401721716,
0.3440699577,
0.418194443,
0.5449716449,
-0.232758984,
0.3713096678,
0.0330306552,
0.2412805706,
0.0331315063,
0.0450345166,
-0.2656822503,
-0.3936680853,
-0.0586231016,
0.1272324771,
-0.0421653204,
-0.4212022722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17333v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17333v1
|
Unsupervised multiple choices question answering via universal corpus
| 2024-02-27T09:10:28 | 2024-02-27T09:10:28 |
Qin Zhang, Hao Ge, Xiaojun Chen, Meng Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised question answering is a promising yet challenging task, which
alleviates the burden of building large-scale annotated data in a new domain.
It motivates us to study the unsupervised multiple-choice question answering
(MCQA) problem. In this paper, we propose a novel framework designed to
generate synthetic MCQA data barely based on contexts from the universal domain
without relying on any form of manual annotation. Possible answers are
extracted and used to produce related questions, then we leverage both named
entities (NE) and knowledge graphs to discover plausible distractors to form
complete synthetic samples. Experiments on multiple MCQA datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.9396137595,
-0.8416283727,
0.8143721223,
-0.1956107765,
-0.0586319566,
0.2697347105,
0.0492120907,
-0.3438405395,
0.4053309858,
0.8716583252,
-0.9417231679,
-0.2458166927,
-0.1181810722,
0.2499587685,
-0.1813796908,
0.8529434204,
0.0261820946,
0.1548274904,
-0.470967859,
-0.2756757736,
-0.2402490973,
-0.729662776,
-0.5190955997,
0.0436182171,
0.5735507607,
0.5332981348,
0.4263907075,
0.1079583764,
0.004358293,
0.2155990601,
0.1112501547,
0.5770136714,
0.0296079125,
0.1116798595,
-0.3040923476,
-0.0739086866,
-0.0084039643,
-0.1056384817,
0.6130421162,
1.1878064871,
0.1518988758,
0.5420935154,
0.0597126596,
0.3619187772,
-0.6844497919,
-0.3214921951,
-0.8759770393,
-0.0878277794,
-0.1303123087,
-0.232500717,
-0.2915509641,
0.0403954126,
-0.0022617502,
-0.8609349132,
0.3017109334,
-0.053224504,
0.421156913,
0.3311980069,
-0.8466311693,
-0.182675302,
-0.6722871065,
0.6273123622,
0.008578389,
0.1544350833,
0.0694149658,
0.5009855628,
-0.2831120193,
-0.7579187751,
-0.6315106153,
0.1480896324,
0.0480373167,
0.2740488052,
-0.0365778543,
-0.2136459351,
0.0991768464,
-0.1223378032,
-0.344671756,
-0.3439429104,
-0.4383125305,
-0.4558190703,
0.5462222099,
0.0862729102,
0.4126213193,
-0.3831486702,
-0.4235087633,
0.0892946199,
-0.5776901245,
0.2805805504,
0.1172999218,
0.2101428658,
0.6184269786,
0.8368606567,
-0.5594169497,
0.6858966351,
-0.0806877762,
0.2078895122,
-0.0203600749,
-0.02304505,
-0.1998811811,
-0.053905528,
0.5221326947,
0.2903317213,
0.4917887151,
-0.3522262871,
0.2686780393,
0.0464291982,
0.3292299807,
-0.6417095065,
-0.2088522762,
0.5038725138,
0.1033629775,
-0.2492589206,
0.0564051531,
-0.8998882771,
-0.1255114973,
-0.4192022681,
0.3456497788,
-0.2607249618,
-0.1212731898,
-0.180052951,
-0.1988373846,
0.0367930196,
0.2192055583,
-0.5053256154,
0.1968902498,
0.039532464,
0.3108158708,
-0.3058464825,
-0.2170483023,
-0.6639613509,
0.35205248,
-0.2904715538,
1.0136168003,
-0.4883751571,
-0.3615322411,
-0.1341860294,
0.1068989411,
-0.2758258283,
-0.5744405985,
0.516119957,
-0.7890699506,
0.1886872798,
-0.4140608907,
-0.5654257536,
-0.3229508698,
0.1660407186,
-0.6986859441,
1.0999202728,
0.2230791003,
-0.8664963841,
0.1524022967,
-1.0940897465,
-0.0485799611,
-0.0025838919,
-0.260242939,
0.2443022579,
-0.1471810043,
0.770088315,
0.4731503427,
-0.1281442195,
0.6365227103,
-0.3600073457,
-0.1414855868,
0.7823299766,
-0.453350991,
1.0689580441,
0.1524648964,
-0.2098475993,
-0.0405360721,
-1.0011464357,
0.3167924285,
-0.0396213643,
-0.2174526602,
-0.3734898269,
-0.2599147856,
0.1042320281,
0.3839177489,
-0.2017076015,
-0.88915205,
-0.0636954308,
0.1189587563,
0.296621263,
0.5653502941,
0.4636749923,
0.3235152662,
-0.4287035465,
0.6323244572,
0.226903677,
-0.1320068389,
0.2564814687,
-0.6562736034,
-0.6223559976,
-0.4968287051,
0.5953871012,
0.4160386622,
-1.1413500309,
-0.0437707938,
-0.1072618067,
-0.1623785198,
-0.5712816119,
-0.0828514248,
0.1967386156,
0.7054995894,
0.7623330355,
0.0289087351,
-0.8406076431,
-0.9550270438,
-0.1794753969,
0.3646472096,
-0.4671837687,
0.4073623419,
0.4994870722,
-0.309261173,
1.3581181765,
-0.7454795837,
-0.1380836219,
0.0088628829,
-0.0706580877,
-0.2072064281,
0.3939395845,
0.3464853466,
-1.1069148779,
-0.1463521123,
-0.5382075906,
-0.6233636737,
-0.1124800891,
-0.2294358462,
-0.6278678775,
-0.1234024242,
0.6720814705,
-0.7245399356,
0.2125953734,
0.1249045208,
-0.0719749853,
0.9136074781,
0.1636678576,
0.1204966009,
-1.2283381224,
0.3734213412,
-0.3850043714,
-0.0529097952,
-0.6086246967,
0.23951675,
-0.0187437106,
-0.0717389658,
-0.9044042826,
0.9611912966,
-0.3758865297,
-0.0171751846,
0.171192199,
0.3323237002,
0.0658060461,
0.7041071653,
0.2067590356,
0.6902099252,
0.479431361,
-0.882596314,
0.1623313278,
0.5179394484,
-0.1508401036,
0.5053360462,
-0.445885241,
0.0225436836,
-0.3984781802,
0.3474242687,
-1.1364096403,
-0.7433260679,
0.1731032133,
-0.5926782489,
-0.1884545833,
-0.2349354625,
-0.2884851396,
-0.4669217765,
-0.168797493,
0.4630853236,
0.1692366898,
-0.8235177398,
0.5816739202,
0.5604451299,
0.0144016072,
-0.7242706418,
-0.6863766909,
-0.1268539727,
-0.2499331236,
-0.3546662331,
0.4044829607,
-0.5797775388,
-0.2140224129,
-0.0249107927,
-0.2520805299,
-0.4098794758,
0.0478021763,
0.4027097523,
0.3483421206,
-0.0571639054,
0.1798249781,
0.3466293514,
0.1417691708,
0.2351493537,
-0.3762492239,
0.3024831712,
0.2023769915,
-0.2456801534,
0.1179025248,
0.8586081266,
0.5720302463,
-0.3021612763,
0.4041481018,
0.6687899828,
-0.4448250532,
-0.2750158012,
-0.3847855926,
0.0469764546,
-0.4590313137,
0.0627214462,
-0.6584126353,
-1.2093425989,
0.5561181307,
-0.2297406346,
0.0905029103,
0.5545524359,
0.6398963928,
-0.1815824807,
0.9992308021,
0.151768297,
0.4644192457,
-0.141056031,
-0.0692921206,
-0.2155565917,
-1.1125091314,
-0.3322167099,
-0.2003599703,
-0.0902825966,
-0.3908402622,
-0.4499258399,
0.4892845154,
0.2834176421,
-0.4389860332,
0.0153238326,
-0.7689365745,
0.6467709541,
0.8901458979,
-0.0151038049,
0.3136644959,
0.0281423889,
-0.8239222765,
0.3278672099,
-0.5447728634,
-0.5312220454,
1.5626001358,
-0.3733204007,
0.1293732375,
0.2301038355,
0.6571545601,
0.0402126051,
0.5333535075,
-0.3140327632,
0.7039714456,
0.2846306562,
-1.104823947,
-0.4671784937,
-0.4370322526,
-1.0963321924,
0.6611506343,
-0.3610583544,
-0.9708727598,
0.0775238946,
-0.0071778656,
-0.7542028427,
0.347714752,
-0.4897723496,
0.7768052816,
0.1365002543,
0.1218266338,
0.6423924565,
-0.7085455656,
0.6112396717,
-0.2056144029,
0.2550120354,
-0.06090229,
0.0564861782,
0.9443292618,
-0.2176376432,
0.5985047817,
-0.0340562649,
0.2324365526,
0.8667495847,
0.0784157142,
-0.2267349511,
0.7147961855,
-0.0067845704,
-0.0290803146,
0.4229284525,
-0.5665225387,
-0.5790806413,
0.7466965914,
-0.6090055704,
-0.4793633819,
-0.2394446582,
-0.8464369178,
-0.7492538095,
0.4190229774,
0.5125857592,
0.4559875429,
-0.4086065888,
-0.0771960989,
0.5313215852,
0.0704437271,
0.6994949579,
0.359546721,
-0.2615081072,
-0.604968071,
0.4886859059,
0.0935308859,
-0.0756757557,
0.3666317761,
-0.0813562572,
-0.7346867323,
-0.083977662,
-0.9528805614,
-0.0228822138,
-0.7420996428,
-0.2072399557,
-1.026530385,
-0.3124401271,
-0.3287665546,
-0.1318049878,
-0.1068837568,
-0.7639055252,
-0.2738373876,
-0.1793522686,
0.1540862024,
0.2367657423,
-0.044110164,
-0.0568563156,
-0.7798311114,
0.6124360561,
0.9273092747,
0.0015582744,
-0.1828444302,
-0.0770123899,
0.3058777452,
0.5469990373,
-0.3382106125,
-0.9564896822,
0.1625622064,
0.0818477795,
0.5463253856,
0.0571839511,
0.6597402096,
0.6783810854,
-0.5950917602,
0.6812448502,
-0.0019609958,
-0.7404476404,
0.3661749661,
-0.3249588013,
0.3187471032,
0.7415095568,
0.7323403955,
-0.290789336,
-0.3290551901,
-0.9303074479,
-0.7267753482,
0.339158237,
0.4019863307,
-0.0160707124,
-0.2408936769,
0.3924300075,
0.0247948878,
0.2993893027,
-0.5672221184,
-0.3708853722,
-0.1392120719,
-0.0025378787,
-0.0596207976,
-0.044590082,
-0.3329842389,
-0.3451081812,
0.4923625886,
-0.3540571034,
0.3290994763,
0.5796188712,
-0.2774978876,
-0.0226277504,
0.4954349697,
0.3767249286,
0.609157443,
-0.2521898746,
0.3718283176,
0.2710215151,
-0.3447961211,
0.2601928711,
0.1297280192,
-0.4512251318,
0.1551424861,
-0.148617506,
0.0575175956,
-0.0229655579,
-1.0402975082,
0.2163478136,
-0.0387894176,
-0.4475088716,
-0.671903193,
0.0364031754,
0.439673543,
0.0274779946,
0.4805252254,
0.2627524734,
0.3368551433,
-0.5416315198,
0.6618824601,
0.5151848793,
-0.4717694819,
-0.052811563,
0.8099493384,
-0.0725389346,
0.0114546353,
0.5169731379,
-0.2229973525,
-0.436814934,
0.6784629822,
0.5215401649,
0.3275009692,
-0.2178646922,
0.5994588137,
0.2927829623,
-0.0008030052,
0.2563775778,
0.4438880384,
-0.1533096582,
-0.878528893,
-0.4053230286,
-0.706076026,
-0.4992626011,
0.382630676,
-0.8105773926,
-0.3275669217,
-0.2784097791,
-0.0773673207,
0.5271656513,
-0.116874814,
-0.7803316116,
0.6461745501,
0.0693412349,
0.57167238,
-0.4854452312,
0.8610705137,
0.983024776,
-0.4522247314,
-0.7186819911,
-0.0425232686,
0.0003612622,
-0.5044687986,
0.4143134952,
0.2801067233,
-0.0153939873,
0.2444555014,
-0.56276685,
-1.0659446716,
0.9815915227,
0.3342957497,
0.0560233481,
0.096814841,
0.3774264753,
0.2930392623,
-0.5561434031,
0.3321494162,
0.6335092783,
0.3947196603,
0.3180728853,
-0.3344987929,
0.1356048584,
-0.407330215,
-0.1904028207,
0.0918688402,
-0.3156959414,
0.7819768786,
-0.4150206745,
-0.1950926483,
0.0862399712,
0.5420311689,
0.4874769449,
0.3297179639,
0.5118097067,
0.3867651522,
0.9183676243,
0.1341812164,
0.6157349348,
-0.041866634,
0.2109389454,
1.2807188034,
-0.1079777926,
0.7474250793,
0.5531307459,
-0.0424575619,
0.4272100925,
0.835221529,
0.1978394836,
0.2677069306,
0.5238386989,
-0.3151713908,
-0.6446633935,
-0.1437893957,
-0.079108879,
0.5984041691,
0.1777828485,
0.1081088036,
-0.3307404518,
0.1655453295,
-0.0788314715,
-0.0623266995,
-0.3557117283,
0.4037863016,
-0.0479857735,
-1.0019534826,
0.6467776299,
-0.1169695109,
0.4436392188,
-0.2692968249,
0.0376513936,
-0.211002931,
-0.2003436387,
0.0186183117,
-0.763952136,
0.3808229566,
-0.0066331862,
-0.2162698656,
0.0859673321,
0.4791639149,
-0.5755308867,
-0.6742509007,
0.0441387855,
0.8958753943,
0.1236800402,
-0.501262784,
-0.547338903,
-0.7568943501,
0.0423493944,
-0.2777438462,
0.5036059022,
0.4377991259,
-0.2864411771,
0.745651722,
1.0436582565,
-0.3782068789,
0.153276518,
-0.1157981902,
0.7975473404,
-0.6100786924,
-0.4797394574,
-0.3609888852,
0.7000768185,
-0.2226509899,
-0.4580498636,
0.7040769458,
0.4315665364,
0.8992842436,
-0.2596870959,
0.8221662641,
-0.02626165,
0.8070093989,
-0.3616677225,
0.588794589,
-0.7194972038,
0.0155776497,
-0.2784484327,
-0.9744272232,
-0.4613164365,
-0.0071690879,
0.1350305527,
-0.1292752028,
0.7223446965,
0.7207104564,
-0.2571918666,
0.0748312175,
0.4058058858,
-0.230554536,
-0.0205990113,
0.6352761984,
0.8039707541,
-0.1903566569,
0.8617788553,
-0.361433357,
0.0157859232,
0.0630518273,
-0.5726805329,
-1.0520294905,
-0.8647749424,
-0.3481437862,
-0.225695461,
-0.2319462299,
0.7481170297,
0.6607014537,
-0.9975550771,
0.2925564647,
0.0825683624,
0.1355575472,
-0.1206241995,
-0.2555920482,
0.7523445487,
-0.1271128803,
-0.5871348381,
0.4097924829,
-0.0530358888,
0.0555018224,
0.0079920217,
0.371404618,
-0.3466055393,
0.4488741159,
0.6280670762,
0.396086365,
-0.714402914,
-0.4859339893,
0.1683789045,
0.2647195458,
-0.0491396487,
0.7447450161,
-0.9615644813,
0.2611219883,
-0.1432442367,
0.8112023473,
0.3735172153,
0.2195443809,
0.0887536108,
-1.0263305902,
-0.1505068839,
0.281994015,
0.322245717,
0.2457041442,
-0.3674194217,
0.4669783115,
0.1858960837,
-0.3805582225,
-0.5594840646,
0.5179636478,
-1.1786293983,
-0.7379145622,
1.2598414421,
0.1181177497,
-0.1881771535,
-0.5687813759,
-0.3480127752,
0.2414212078,
-0.1256882101,
0.4622260928,
0.4041991532,
-0.4196297526,
0.0884928554,
-0.6228395104,
0.6086555719,
0.4631002247,
-0.8925485015,
-0.1163512021,
0.6559146047,
0.6781098843,
0.3250108659,
0.8558160067,
-0.0474008918,
0.298488915,
0.0231696069,
0.0941585898,
-0.2103308141,
-0.4770745039,
0.1924331188,
0.626383543,
-0.5177637935,
-0.3870258927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17311v1
|
SKT5SciSumm -- A Hybrid Generative Approach for Multi-Document Scientific Summarization
| 2024-02-27T08:33:31 | 2024-02-27T08:33:31 |
Huy Quoc To, Hung-Nghiep Tran, Andr'e Greiner-Petter, Felix Beierle, Akiko Aizawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Summarization for scientific text has shown significant benefits both for the
research community and human society. Given the fact that the nature of
scientific text is distinctive and the input of the multi-document
summarization task is substantially long, the task requires sufficient
embedding generation and text truncation without losing important information.
To tackle these issues, in this paper, we propose SKT5SciSumm - a hybrid
framework for multi-document scientific summarization (MDSS). We leverage the
Sentence-Transformer version of Scientific Paper Embeddings using
Citation-Informed Transformers (SPECTER) to encode and represent textual
sentences, allowing for efficient extractive summarization using k-means
clustering. We employ the T5 family of models to generate abstractive summaries
using extracted sentences. SKT5SciSumm achieves state-of-the-art performance on
the Multi-XScience dataset. Through extensive experiments and evaluation, we
showcase the benefits of our model by using less complicated models to achieve
remarkable results, thereby highlighting its potential in advancing the field
of multi-document summarization for scientific text.
|
[
-0.1536804289,
0.0729989931,
0.6168159842,
0.1701826453,
-0.6387777328,
0.6681617498,
-0.1142682582,
-0.2077321112,
0.6286239624,
0.1132093146,
-0.3251847029,
-0.6297015548,
-0.7656730413,
0.5268085003,
-0.5032957792,
1.2972557545,
0.0712577626,
0.0230375044,
-0.5645366907,
-0.1150259525,
0.1664059162,
-0.3522320092,
0.277263999,
-0.252270788,
0.5788795948,
0.3994019032,
0.0833262205,
0.5055568814,
0.7705489397,
0.2634659111,
-0.1837507486,
0.2631564438,
-0.2903999388,
0.1985656321,
-0.1591536254,
-0.5015030503,
-0.4730115235,
-0.0418121144,
0.7567466497,
0.5878926516,
-0.0792763755,
0.2218044698,
-0.0706774965,
0.3260895014,
-0.2961059213,
0.3340689838,
-0.2767199874,
-0.0139163695,
-0.0063896081,
-0.2646576464,
-0.3855814934,
-0.458081156,
0.0997520164,
-0.5813322663,
0.6920401454,
-0.0584163032,
0.5780854821,
0.1834807396,
-0.5197440386,
-0.1506316662,
-0.7278130651,
0.6964517832,
-0.8182809949,
0.2672803104,
-0.4078265727,
0.3275766373,
0.1508904248,
-1.0030037165,
-0.5018712282,
-0.181354478,
-0.219001323,
0.752140224,
0.2359109074,
0.1263589561,
0.0329497866,
0.6482015848,
-0.6313338876,
-0.3839403987,
-1.0345773697,
0.0387553573,
0.4148305357,
0.2187368721,
-0.0110698659,
-0.3899524808,
-0.332126528,
-0.244011119,
-0.3631930649,
-0.5052644014,
-0.0300477222,
0.1356553137,
-0.2590862811,
0.9009717703,
0.0464541353,
-0.0232715663,
-0.0309118032,
-0.3972605765,
0.2607223988,
-0.7540092468,
0.1087816581,
0.1857702732,
0.7064833641,
0.4603580236,
-0.3190241754,
-0.3903804421,
0.2285262346,
0.665230453,
0.196973145,
-0.8168373704,
-0.1951930523,
0.4432905912,
-0.5630961657,
-0.537788868,
0.2664322555,
-0.8322771788,
-0.2091373652,
0.0287279952,
-0.0517157577,
-0.6439324617,
-0.2239925712,
-0.0974090919,
-0.6985965967,
-0.3067548871,
0.1506008655,
-0.6033837795,
0.3034508228,
0.2631658316,
1.1501377821,
-0.4232121408,
-0.3011204898,
0.0485060327,
0.7717657089,
0.0337816291,
0.8085508347,
-0.3179287612,
-0.7454521656,
-0.6933740377,
-0.2084778994,
-0.155257836,
-0.163809076,
0.4983899891,
-0.1689336151,
0.2483879924,
-0.0938122347,
-0.5580520034,
-0.2605200708,
-0.0175110232,
-0.5579063296,
1.055467248,
0.0622678176,
-0.803019166,
0.4879114926,
-1.1818330288,
-0.4788663387,
0.2729984522,
-0.1201411337,
-0.550513804,
0.3819186985,
0.1125367805,
0.5432661772,
0.0337654687,
0.393399328,
-0.3095211387,
0.0264561232,
0.047510881,
0.0926886573,
0.0442214496,
0.1947212517,
-0.0358899459,
0.3404989839,
-0.8076123595,
-0.2564174831,
0.0456957258,
-0.1985034943,
-0.4446829557,
0.1853670329,
0.1675571054,
0.4933456481,
0.0793572813,
-0.9814562798,
0.2475299388,
-0.2214510143,
0.7466672659,
0.3992133141,
0.124261111,
0.3921039701,
-0.4579490125,
0.4919449389,
0.2592747509,
-0.1945934892,
-0.8541460037,
-0.1535959542,
-0.3410808444,
-0.6933933496,
0.3558549285,
0.2107893527,
-0.671856463,
0.285877347,
-0.59901613,
-0.7553650737,
-0.5978850722,
-0.3313280642,
0.2023975253,
0.3289147019,
0.6597796679,
0.0125103099,
-0.679001689,
-0.8332353234,
-0.1382449716,
0.1915865242,
0.1094346642,
-0.185764119,
0.9248651266,
-0.0693371892,
1.0424594879,
-0.7487761378,
-0.2171042264,
-0.6761103272,
0.3867487907,
-0.0138802566,
0.3221328855,
0.4479038417,
-0.8368707299,
-0.3747551441,
-0.0663603619,
-0.8919624686,
0.1266995221,
-0.1311237514,
0.3642351329,
0.0135496166,
0.2748478353,
-0.813585043,
0.1893353462,
0.387768954,
0.0030608536,
0.7890207767,
-0.5313999057,
0.2661297023,
-1.5752043724,
0.2991057932,
0.1937203407,
-0.2657826841,
-0.4562706053,
0.2405383438,
0.2968740463,
-0.1595210731,
-0.2650967836,
-0.0959140509,
-0.6001109481,
-0.0702526495,
-0.2402677536,
0.0983333513,
0.0267159715,
0.1356812268,
0.2340117395,
0.6139038801,
0.0302040726,
-0.4144228101,
0.0631937608,
0.2828048766,
0.0643286109,
0.5180748105,
-0.7216078043,
-0.2483094484,
-0.3283073902,
0.822712779,
-0.8002782464,
-0.4095527232,
-0.1396302879,
-0.5004810691,
0.0189795606,
0.2701493204,
-0.6916134953,
-0.5553969741,
-0.6443258524,
0.2030627429,
0.268786788,
-0.4016832113,
0.8535564542,
0.0452161543,
-0.4751988351,
-0.0091097401,
-0.3400348127,
0.2570925355,
-0.3160511851,
-0.687423408,
0.7954443693,
-0.1820932925,
0.1119857281,
0.0908967257,
-0.2128618658,
0.5255271792,
-0.2646890283,
0.2472248375,
0.4242437184,
-0.0232184976,
-0.1888814121,
0.5853016376,
-0.381272912,
-0.0759550333,
-0.3315131068,
0.3346986473,
-0.0286779162,
-0.1552705616,
-0.2089469582,
0.8092086911,
0.9969702959,
-0.2197204828,
0.5403149724,
0.3333995342,
-0.2332213819,
0.0204802435,
-0.2230322361,
-0.399404943,
-0.3711607754,
0.5289497375,
-0.3013104498,
-0.8292566538,
0.465816766,
-0.2812294364,
0.3083198667,
0.6252905726,
0.34400177,
-0.411161989,
1.2037160397,
0.7383460402,
0.2302511781,
-0.0614111796,
-0.1978639513,
0.218562901,
-0.7546074986,
-0.5785152316,
-0.5654541254,
-0.0170782153,
-0.2660718262,
-0.2344451398,
0.8395783305,
-0.2864996195,
0.3788402975,
0.3389828503,
-0.5790485144,
0.2193264663,
0.2943326831,
-0.1410407275,
0.587780118,
-0.0576475598,
-0.4199950397,
-0.3166391253,
-0.9200691581,
-0.6229777336,
0.7825942039,
0.1500534415,
0.675599575,
0.0193127152,
0.8231508136,
0.3215025365,
0.2130907774,
-0.4033812881,
0.4615968764,
-0.2752496302,
-0.1700650454,
0.0880981907,
-0.4192844331,
-0.5770400763,
0.6897452474,
-0.1490952224,
-0.2409335673,
-0.1485282183,
0.0049700905,
-0.3703007102,
0.2432444245,
-0.75181216,
0.3192258775,
-0.0392111465,
0.2037108541,
-0.3497811854,
-0.9469320774,
0.6389850378,
-0.1103631258,
0.307818979,
0.1282539815,
-0.0006758412,
0.7816259861,
-0.3429801166,
0.7200951576,
0.0702156872,
0.3307357132,
-0.3220784068,
-0.2202140242,
0.3052105308,
-0.0105062798,
0.3815444112,
-0.0440632142,
0.4648514688,
-0.3333030045,
-0.4389024079,
0.670619607,
-0.5099623799,
-0.2107968777,
-0.9038562179,
-0.8170105219,
0.1258545667,
0.1623292118,
0.2701283991,
0.172386542,
-0.132529974,
0.2178757936,
0.60503304,
-0.0557441115,
0.4479361176,
0.4022192955,
-0.0354214609,
-0.6479253173,
0.9936404228,
0.1929209083,
0.4452886283,
0.1615054905,
0.0975614637,
-0.1991986632,
-0.4243249893,
-0.4052703083,
0.6379184723,
-0.4132530093,
-0.2535042763,
-1.0447673798,
-0.2374448031,
-0.7873309851,
-0.3981980979,
-0.2473522127,
-0.7215442061,
-0.2841974199,
-0.3607005775,
0.353243351,
0.8269512057,
-0.0733511671,
0.2688504457,
-1.016141057,
0.5522056818,
-0.5293660164,
0.0704480037,
-0.1369711161,
-0.0982503146,
-0.2531431019,
-0.1694007516,
-0.3747200072,
-0.8072613478,
0.5279300213,
0.2170748413,
0.5666020513,
0.3236084282,
0.0148089649,
0.4555912316,
-0.3193236887,
0.9050197601,
0.568114996,
-0.5927398801,
0.3739153445,
-0.4391121268,
0.5632327199,
0.3301673532,
0.2586013377,
-0.7096114159,
-0.8353278041,
-0.8325645328,
-0.9382292628,
0.6432316899,
0.2444144338,
-0.297000885,
0.0602608174,
0.0491422266,
0.5219059587,
0.3249864578,
-0.5034434199,
-0.1884349734,
-0.6558407545,
-0.4591234326,
-0.1596865505,
-0.0927532911,
-0.1569144428,
-0.1260977387,
0.7372140884,
-0.3408760726,
0.243665725,
0.1329187304,
-0.3468016386,
0.1828856319,
0.3942367136,
1.1012334824,
0.4318236113,
-0.2559068203,
0.3533948958,
0.0481627621,
-0.7189719677,
-0.0319610201,
0.3466652036,
-0.2587531805,
0.1868657917,
0.250251025,
0.3046244681,
0.2589527667,
-0.3393636644,
0.1792874634,
0.0305710882,
-0.5621095896,
-0.0367603078,
-0.0464199223,
0.3087351918,
0.0246267449,
0.8117185235,
0.3247721195,
0.2186424583,
-0.1581506878,
0.0924188346,
0.1153735146,
0.023704173,
-0.6020719409,
0.8328959942,
0.0640733242,
0.3404308856,
-0.079175204,
0.0956703946,
-0.6942293048,
0.5297006965,
0.7831359506,
0.5416368246,
-0.2355668098,
0.4497626424,
0.2372098863,
0.2620750964,
-0.060340602,
0.2901891768,
0.0086857397,
-0.132666871,
-0.4131241739,
-0.4107615352,
-0.392326653,
-0.1562259942,
-0.6459187865,
0.134875074,
-0.0944565237,
0.0900113806,
0.4542970657,
-0.1116240695,
0.0018716397,
0.1246267036,
-0.2540427744,
0.9263164401,
-0.9497618079,
0.5041610003,
0.5913786888,
-0.6574476361,
-0.2414345592,
-0.4841191471,
0.0198066011,
0.0302138422,
0.1212671623,
-0.0343138687,
-0.3116421402,
0.114448905,
-0.6482715011,
-0.7767875791,
1.4330707788,
0.1207128316,
-0.3055812418,
-0.1755914241,
0.1456526071,
0.5298627019,
-0.4366322458,
0.3509981632,
0.3752662539,
0.4612556994,
0.4438377619,
-0.589609623,
0.0516991839,
-0.4342235327,
-0.1092436984,
0.3849674761,
-0.8418361545,
0.550111413,
-0.3622511029,
-0.1790317595,
0.1231516376,
0.9796592593,
0.7021045089,
0.352109015,
0.0984111875,
0.4393233061,
0.6422662735,
-0.1184882745,
0.9752574563,
-0.2657593191,
0.2577269077,
1.0641812086,
-0.3984824419,
0.2318309695,
0.6893602014,
-0.1296711266,
0.3931183219,
0.5385383368,
-0.2189286202,
0.7166553736,
-0.1027867645,
-0.3352022767,
0.0756748095,
0.0376163647,
-0.6103956103,
0.144918412,
0.6017614603,
-0.5876866579,
-0.5498126149,
0.1848449111,
0.0858950093,
-0.0208030269,
-0.007315177,
0.6645330787,
0.3355907798,
-0.4414706528,
-0.0876265541,
0.4463100433,
0.7658441663,
-0.7457254529,
-0.0840337574,
-0.0327248946,
0.2002587169,
-0.3521366417,
-0.4206131995,
0.3560204506,
-0.0830559433,
-0.5952031612,
-0.2424096465,
0.6632147431,
-0.5199763179,
-0.603325963,
0.0320328698,
0.2963964641,
0.1909625679,
0.4045295119,
-0.2678504288,
-0.2998222709,
-0.3197778463,
0.149274677,
0.2754532099,
0.0212206598,
-0.34833166,
0.4566058815,
0.910119772,
0.1664112508,
0.1037474349,
0.067855455,
1.0242275,
-0.5929946899,
-0.9928119779,
-0.5866826177,
0.5366591215,
-0.3154985309,
-0.2359481603,
0.866342783,
1.0591695309,
0.208613351,
-0.2311453819,
1.3848900795,
-0.1311243176,
0.7121112943,
-0.132826969,
0.8335753083,
-0.2277435809,
-0.0712269396,
-0.4274893701,
-0.6663353443,
-0.482173115,
0.2325817645,
-0.0586516112,
0.0162799302,
1.0099899769,
0.5011405945,
-0.3286034167,
0.4964553714,
0.0431560799,
0.1568493396,
0.3831974268,
0.0460804291,
0.5602010489,
-0.1449540704,
0.5528190732,
-0.1377948821,
-0.1768104881,
-0.1866210252,
-0.8506290913,
-0.7679973841,
-0.7774561644,
-0.3016824126,
-0.2778918743,
0.110580489,
0.8795211911,
0.6022644639,
-0.7141142488,
0.0398975499,
0.1080948636,
-0.2952459455,
-0.2586811185,
-0.2055330575,
0.5132386088,
-0.1417676061,
-0.4043055773,
0.4991694391,
0.5815478563,
0.0839853287,
-0.4021725953,
-0.0501865745,
-0.2903388739,
0.0591622069,
0.6914921403,
0.0932290182,
-0.4915426672,
-0.0098810131,
0.2314674705,
-0.1263473034,
0.189661026,
0.933067441,
-0.6568239331,
0.2510603368,
0.3039067686,
0.2123864144,
1.0919693708,
-0.0241916776,
0.6661223769,
-0.6859003901,
-0.2706667185,
0.1755045503,
0.2032762617,
0.3572318852,
-0.411126405,
0.3415285349,
0.5007057786,
-0.1865671575,
-0.825081706,
-0.190362975,
-1.2077368498,
-0.1823300123,
0.9081457257,
0.0297871809,
-0.1572459191,
-0.2217483521,
-0.1965152621,
0.4189001918,
-0.6309457421,
0.9756206274,
0.6873639226,
-0.1002533659,
-0.3195869625,
-0.1190506518,
0.1552123427,
0.252302587,
-1.0847654343,
-0.2047661394,
0.4214929938,
0.3562696874,
0.4649626911,
0.189749375,
-0.4238128066,
0.4011288881,
-0.0362149812,
0.3519808948,
-0.433023572,
-0.3321203291,
-0.1092496589,
0.6146282554,
-0.6019730568,
0.0299009588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17304v2
|
Probing Multimodal Large Language Models for Global and Local Semantic Representations
| 2024-02-27T08:27:15 | 2024-03-27T02:59:57 |
Mingxu Tao, Quzhe Huang, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Yansong Feng, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has greatly
accelerated the development of applications in understanding integrated texts
and images. Recent works leverage image-caption datasets to train MLLMs,
achieving state-of-the-art performance on image-to-text tasks. However, there
are few studies exploring which layers of MLLMs make the most effort to the
global image information, which plays vital roles in multimodal comprehension
and generation. In this study, we find that the intermediate layers of models
can encode more global semantic information, whose representation vectors
perform better on visual-language entailment tasks, rather than the topmost
layers. We further probe models regarding local semantic representations
through object recognition tasks. We find that the topmost layers may
excessively focus on local information, leading to a diminished ability to
encode global information. Our code and data are released via
https://github.com/kobayashikanna01/probing_MLLM_rep.
|
[
-0.5165461302,
-0.6889331937,
0.6297281384,
-0.118618302,
-0.038701728,
-0.2742551267,
-0.3943765759,
-0.6570594907,
-0.2775965929,
0.6521903872,
-0.448346734,
-0.4666880667,
-0.6930387616,
0.0757912248,
-0.2992433608,
0.669136405,
-0.1336403787,
0.1557604074,
-0.7416457534,
-0.1754515916,
-0.2491734028,
-0.7237725854,
-0.5246413946,
-0.3150458634,
0.5970321298,
0.1916759312,
0.699462831,
0.379483968,
0.6177933216,
0.3562286794,
0.0157946888,
0.2099734545,
-0.3699094355,
0.1288975328,
-0.1620526016,
-0.4953681529,
-0.0669475719,
-0.1484372765,
0.9128527045,
0.5119842887,
0.2459848672,
0.1656951904,
-0.138918221,
0.4538965225,
-0.7149574161,
0.459218502,
-0.7316226363,
0.0997328311,
-0.0672550499,
-0.2353630215,
-0.6072479486,
0.3569375873,
0.2934724987,
-0.5291163921,
0.3135496676,
0.1301316172,
0.8829059601,
0.1352249384,
-0.8219047785,
-0.2056978047,
-0.6285519004,
0.8762346506,
-0.4673237503,
0.5162363648,
0.4891610444,
0.3282514215,
-0.0203584544,
-0.4698203802,
-0.5593415499,
-0.6051819324,
-0.3613871932,
0.0182983316,
-0.2158873528,
0.0120521244,
0.2633285522,
0.3119326532,
-0.5374347568,
-0.0070675784,
-0.3538977206,
-0.4095378518,
0.3431286216,
0.0745663792,
0.4352174699,
-0.2852829099,
-0.683195591,
-0.2185317278,
-0.7099526525,
0.1859716773,
0.097854197,
0.1285169125,
-0.2386619896,
0.8305245638,
-0.1551593393,
0.8355652094,
-0.4308096766,
-0.0698517263,
0.1521030813,
-0.6373557448,
-0.2269058228,
-0.071418196,
0.5340422392,
0.5436261296,
0.3462820053,
-0.2492429018,
-0.1997406781,
0.1825440675,
0.1295373738,
-0.7341628075,
0.1149175912,
0.2491254807,
-0.4442990124,
-0.1613412946,
0.0749096125,
-0.2782471478,
-0.5139788389,
-0.6864187717,
0.4343617857,
-0.3150431514,
-0.2177905589,
0.2860104442,
-0.1432010531,
0.5348324776,
0.2199083716,
-0.6357745528,
0.1287465543,
0.3357711136,
0.6510301232,
0.0200920459,
-0.544250071,
-0.5553326607,
0.4583634734,
-0.2630084753,
0.7927013636,
-0.8191426396,
0.0693520904,
0.0425155088,
0.2735287547,
-0.2339745462,
-0.541642487,
0.4305571914,
-0.510915637,
0.1060391963,
-0.2954118848,
-0.3290182352,
-0.3026089072,
0.4765084386,
-0.8187594414,
0.8933301568,
-0.1927475333,
-0.9825752974,
0.1909191757,
-0.4941652119,
-0.1739493161,
-0.3461706042,
-0.2785284221,
-0.2300263792,
0.2379817814,
0.6335939169,
0.9956722856,
-0.342135638,
0.0602384247,
-0.2048898637,
-0.2914753854,
0.4056719542,
-0.4433236718,
0.4207940102,
0.0103397071,
-0.0731010213,
0.2399989069,
-0.5907389522,
-0.3185887337,
0.4475167394,
-0.1786166131,
-0.4488239586,
-0.0284235589,
0.081849061,
0.3799485564,
0.3187316656,
-0.7268183827,
0.087251991,
-0.034913335,
0.374578923,
0.6196327806,
-0.0825518072,
0.6334502101,
-0.153978914,
0.1657548398,
0.5175383091,
0.1286345571,
-0.5785832405,
-0.5096153617,
-0.7877391577,
-0.0755779967,
0.0214643311,
0.3869541287,
-0.8320862651,
-0.1976178586,
-0.3203406632,
-0.2934454381,
-0.4485052228,
0.1910745651,
0.3856173158,
0.3252291083,
0.2789030969,
-0.1824331731,
-0.2408161312,
-1.2495186329,
0.0677386001,
0.157679975,
-0.037417762,
0.3168123364,
0.6021054387,
-0.3968777955,
0.8361282945,
-0.2991749942,
-0.4760536551,
-0.1890151799,
0.0771971196,
-0.0813035071,
0.3241157234,
0.6092973948,
-1.0298235416,
-0.388014257,
0.2238749862,
-0.6703622341,
0.3969667554,
-0.2112154067,
-0.3604969084,
0.2162959576,
0.509768188,
-0.9035316706,
0.25996387,
0.5865687132,
-0.3877793849,
0.3102185428,
-0.4786401093,
0.1154351234,
-0.6752849817,
0.1164844334,
0.1175754443,
-0.1814646721,
-0.6616227627,
0.3086277544,
0.350974232,
-0.1676900834,
-0.3139905334,
0.5015195012,
-0.9208268523,
-0.2798118293,
-0.0009181888,
0.3221503794,
0.1952407062,
0.635664165,
0.159144938,
0.6390394568,
0.9637394547,
-0.4260831475,
0.3491914868,
-0.0542548746,
-0.6512934566,
0.2120819241,
-0.547742486,
0.0869214237,
-0.6894680262,
0.2803295851,
-1.0536042452,
-0.52420187,
-0.0424166918,
-0.2983044982,
0.3986837864,
-0.0789701864,
-0.7601200342,
-0.193377614,
-0.2685393393,
0.4488886595,
0.3163656592,
-0.4020209312,
0.7424101233,
0.434528172,
0.0580305122,
-0.6030930877,
-0.7791839242,
-0.0511290319,
0.0161500145,
-0.715507865,
0.3332264721,
0.2570323646,
-0.0599115193,
-0.0402814373,
0.0040786709,
0.044711411,
-0.2362760603,
0.1238203719,
0.2030786425,
-0.2256554812,
0.2141980678,
-0.2670674622,
-0.0280282274,
0.1547183245,
-0.1341086626,
0.6916018128,
-0.2961118519,
-0.5543345213,
-0.2920522988,
0.5412709713,
0.8336066604,
-0.7405979633,
0.8224962354,
0.9123510122,
-0.4392259419,
0.021301996,
-0.5751248598,
-0.1497902125,
-0.431912899,
0.6230630279,
-0.3734560609,
-0.6871301532,
0.7519045472,
0.218178317,
-0.1863564253,
0.3523951769,
0.4537504315,
-0.0739871785,
1.1694279909,
0.4619669914,
-0.0171129052,
0.3477807343,
-0.5252401829,
-0.0879421383,
-0.9160791636,
-0.4087468386,
-0.2830881774,
-0.0400562994,
-0.3285869062,
-0.9636749625,
0.3396806121,
0.0199891869,
-0.1591508985,
0.0301934835,
-0.3395222127,
0.5950784087,
0.504250288,
0.1781726032,
0.2449276298,
0.2905291021,
-0.2084172815,
-0.0166823063,
-0.5963571072,
-0.3653439283,
0.8105624318,
0.5479319096,
0.7633464932,
-0.0643161833,
0.2767832279,
-0.019000886,
-0.0080724321,
-0.6025528312,
0.642737329,
-0.3363632858,
-0.5565757751,
-0.1400651783,
-0.2747661769,
-0.946814239,
0.5067584515,
-0.094448328,
-0.5109612942,
0.0857198015,
0.0507869683,
0.0673257336,
0.4236655831,
-0.7150294781,
1.1217792034,
-0.1571009308,
-0.1959680617,
-0.1154861599,
-0.6396648288,
0.2239241153,
0.22148256,
0.4107469916,
-0.2037972808,
-0.1977345347,
0.3883678019,
0.1007437184,
1.0067062378,
-0.2773297429,
-0.5360491872,
0.3054543436,
0.0185149908,
0.5050210357,
-0.2192573994,
0.2822810411,
0.2206680179,
-0.2304564267,
-0.4853817821,
-0.6206566095,
0.7058019638,
-0.6866722107,
-0.4311013222,
-0.1225209162,
-0.6689642072,
-0.245748207,
-0.0048809252,
0.1184866577,
0.9285848737,
0.3041339815,
0.4970251024,
0.684304893,
-0.3335848451,
0.3186463118,
0.0491524115,
-0.4347554147,
-0.0585030057,
1.003442049,
0.0649327785,
0.4781253934,
0.7157953382,
0.0458184853,
-0.3805216849,
-0.3797861636,
-0.5976933837,
0.292832464,
-1.1438022852,
-0.1625847071,
-0.5253190398,
-0.1155183092,
-0.2376385629,
-0.0039610332,
-0.2717326283,
-0.2444267422,
-0.0896903872,
0.0921575204,
0.2594002187,
0.7883230448,
0.3528364301,
0.0571035296,
-0.8395779133,
0.3674240708,
0.2159534544,
0.2424793094,
0.2519088387,
-0.2842377424,
-0.4020989537,
0.0601963252,
0.0976084918,
-0.6915841699,
0.0903112888,
0.3212762177,
0.8182556629,
0.3221500218,
-0.1142058894,
0.6850504279,
-0.5433178544,
0.822988987,
0.0666843727,
-0.6912638545,
0.4316970706,
-0.4365203977,
0.7151674032,
0.0304296091,
0.5077134371,
-0.4007113576,
-0.750434041,
-0.0659416839,
-0.7488164902,
0.6393217444,
0.1651503891,
0.5815091133,
0.1128728017,
0.0647319704,
0.0539664999,
-0.0732258409,
-0.9577471018,
0.0102409283,
-0.0665939897,
-0.1413512677,
0.048341006,
-0.2620168924,
-0.0347958617,
-0.1349574775,
0.1509044915,
-0.304662466,
0.6474814415,
0.4107547998,
-0.3446932733,
0.1645673513,
0.2345743328,
0.6165912747,
0.468814671,
-0.1151042804,
0.5380330086,
0.0499143861,
-0.4277365506,
-0.1699401438,
-0.0071412846,
-0.0038587651,
0.0462589785,
0.8494455814,
1.0544205904,
0.4361210167,
-0.8065761924,
0.5692585111,
-0.0107666506,
0.0502257831,
-0.191583097,
-0.0148454979,
0.0512140319,
0.248455137,
0.4365162551,
0.1806898564,
0.0744731948,
-0.7249994874,
0.0425840132,
0.5865315795,
-0.1982041746,
-0.1801895797,
0.382638067,
-0.1616881043,
0.3846899569,
0.4384066164,
0.0135437883,
-0.6108343005,
0.6060691476,
0.4974614084,
0.4411290288,
0.0611599572,
0.1922567934,
0.4082633257,
0.3085176647,
0.2124031931,
0.2777419388,
-0.307248652,
-0.7896777987,
-0.6983270645,
-0.555752039,
-0.1809654683,
-0.1228441373,
-0.5845458508,
0.0673140064,
-0.0984773785,
-0.0962624177,
-0.1391576976,
-0.4034703076,
-0.838914156,
0.0930914208,
0.5050599575,
0.6945418715,
-0.5084979534,
0.9420898557,
0.9306111932,
-0.4185881913,
-0.3805822432,
-0.0181102976,
-0.3827069402,
-0.7164812088,
1.0403417349,
0.5402815342,
-0.2205433398,
-0.1620755941,
-0.6164545417,
-1.0557023287,
1.0583090782,
0.4466478825,
-0.371743083,
-0.2682803869,
0.4302066565,
0.3737406433,
-0.5081242919,
0.2369835526,
0.0179043859,
0.3851546943,
0.086427696,
-0.9671434164,
0.0663839132,
-0.1966232955,
0.3029549718,
0.0136553477,
-0.4707733989,
1.0406894684,
-0.363766402,
-0.3513909578,
-0.0677132085,
0.4867372215,
0.0833934397,
0.0206154436,
0.4306719899,
0.3466278911,
0.4552271366,
-0.164397642,
1.4144115448,
-0.1502378434,
0.3296046853,
0.9547581673,
-0.0793766007,
1.1535189152,
0.4848670661,
0.0963345021,
0.39033705,
0.5383176208,
0.0191071238,
0.6046311855,
0.0447776802,
-0.1581403613,
-0.4204100966,
-0.2373229116,
-0.2511669099,
0.6079315543,
0.3109942079,
-0.3445628583,
-0.363022536,
0.5518629551,
-0.1090024561,
-0.1251580119,
-0.516108036,
0.715652287,
-0.1217198148,
-0.5298506021,
0.7695617676,
0.0233434029,
0.5701964498,
-0.6018791199,
-0.0901176333,
-0.1034869552,
0.2595880032,
-0.0265919324,
-0.9678954482,
0.1790648997,
-0.1872388273,
-0.1434876621,
-0.2428242564,
1.0353887081,
-0.7040523887,
-0.4692111611,
0.5855874419,
0.1992542595,
0.0000810569,
-0.2247137576,
-0.5524687171,
0.4290053546,
-0.2035471201,
-0.3308762312,
0.2759350538,
0.5040534735,
-0.1237020567,
0.6522043943,
0.5950209498,
-0.1777347922,
0.4527993798,
0.2429627329,
0.8548611999,
-0.5285143256,
-0.1533735842,
-0.78137815,
0.8395398259,
-0.1786754429,
-0.0589405559,
0.7567341924,
0.4739145041,
1.2061104774,
-0.4113382101,
0.424862057,
0.171197772,
-0.0231944639,
-0.9702509046,
0.5906045437,
-0.8143737316,
-0.1005814821,
-0.1136508584,
-0.8841258883,
-0.4314213395,
0.6137712598,
-0.280988574,
-0.1030334905,
0.5468280315,
0.7789344192,
-0.2896082401,
-0.0646015182,
0.4888796508,
0.2928263247,
0.1326966286,
0.5815129876,
1.143722415,
-0.4363801777,
0.5312120318,
-0.3733668327,
0.1862830967,
0.0241067614,
-0.7202338576,
-1.1419541836,
-0.8939877748,
-0.0797809064,
0.0818020999,
-0.3658028245,
0.6838872433,
0.6611725688,
-0.6969793439,
-0.113455385,
0.0763586983,
-0.1965437531,
0.1731456369,
-0.1664574593,
0.4417898357,
-0.4298694432,
-0.759806335,
0.1515673399,
0.27596277,
0.1125773787,
-0.6443344951,
-0.0492223538,
-0.1412070394,
-0.1409596205,
1.0390036106,
-0.3309811354,
-1.1014943123,
-0.2598118484,
0.1077862754,
-0.2385835648,
0.0955863297,
0.9297297597,
-0.5595377088,
0.5194682479,
0.4295454621,
0.6331008077,
0.5722681284,
-0.3487319648,
0.3832228184,
-0.9141091704,
0.3789986074,
-0.0375206284,
0.7311296463,
0.6195195317,
-0.2150835544,
0.2559674382,
-0.0048683397,
-0.3724481165,
-0.7513673306,
0.1843174398,
-0.9231293797,
-0.2900764048,
1.1850248575,
-0.1106827706,
-0.3745730221,
0.1179976463,
-0.6162362099,
-0.0487783626,
-0.0997244343,
0.0468515381,
0.8634006977,
-0.0775476024,
-0.5094752908,
-0.995139122,
0.1554718018,
0.1854349673,
-0.5757617354,
0.2493952364,
0.604203701,
0.0223401487,
0.4777904153,
0.43056795,
-0.2077706754,
0.1758323461,
0.0388108119,
-0.1543542743,
-0.0670493096,
-0.5109465122,
-0.1270690709,
0.3662249446,
-0.0960083902,
-0.1005770862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17302v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17302v2
|
Can LLM Generate Culturally Relevant Commonsense QA Data? Case Study in Indonesian and Sundanese
| 2024-02-27T08:24:32 | 2024-04-16T07:41:12 |
Rifki Afina Putri, Faiz Ghifari Haznitrama, Dea Adhista, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used to generate
synthetic data for training and evaluating models. However, it is unclear
whether they can generate a good quality of question answering (QA) dataset
that incorporates knowledge and cultural nuance embedded in a language,
especially for low-resource languages. In this study, we investigate the
effectiveness of using LLMs in generating culturally relevant commonsense QA
datasets for Indonesian and Sundanese languages. To do so, we create datasets
for these languages using various methods involving both LLMs and human
annotators, resulting in ~4.5K questions per language (~9K in total), making
our dataset the largest of its kind. Our experiments show that automatic data
adaptation from an existing English dataset is less effective for Sundanese.
Interestingly, using the direct generation method on the target language, GPT-4
Turbo can generate questions with adequate general knowledge in both languages,
albeit not as culturally 'deep' as humans. We also observe a higher occurrence
of fluency errors in the Sundanese dataset, highlighting the discrepancy
between medium- and lower-resource languages.
|
[
-0.4047355354,
-0.5875924826,
0.3683279455,
-0.0033362131,
-0.23444359,
-0.1228583455,
-0.4074379504,
-0.6333639622,
0.0555440672,
0.53285712,
-0.2783592045,
-0.4740854204,
-0.0665135905,
0.60311234,
-0.0408467427,
0.9178364873,
-0.0712221414,
0.0341963507,
-0.2325783223,
-0.4948132932,
-0.4006660581,
-0.4854384363,
-0.7675327063,
-0.0292338878,
0.5703142285,
0.5918057561,
0.5881246924,
0.4652371407,
0.2760224938,
0.2494547814,
-0.1662046313,
0.3447189629,
-0.5458982587,
0.1970710605,
-0.3072222173,
-0.759162426,
-0.0470273457,
-0.1408475488,
0.5048947334,
0.5583859682,
0.0762472972,
0.554161191,
-0.0773202926,
0.5952157378,
-0.508548677,
0.0605717339,
-0.711438179,
-0.0092363879,
-0.2321430594,
-0.1772758216,
0.078942515,
-0.7307755351,
0.0301058572,
-0.6436989903,
0.0662169307,
-0.1766880304,
0.7713243365,
0.4192547202,
-0.6262648106,
-0.3283805847,
-0.71688658,
0.7670944929,
-0.8648548126,
0.0906890258,
0.4873425663,
0.3913660944,
-0.053856235,
-0.3858120739,
-0.8992275,
-0.0498192608,
-0.0363218412,
0.1967798024,
-0.0104109291,
-0.2101805359,
0.4658323526,
0.3521351516,
-0.5829238892,
0.4214867949,
-0.5312283039,
-0.045819927,
0.8308237791,
0.2954617143,
0.3976595998,
-0.6131294966,
-0.1019598246,
-0.131995514,
-0.87630862,
0.1841830015,
0.5474306345,
0.1885315925,
0.0327493362,
0.5260326266,
-0.4163395762,
0.5973306298,
-0.1587412506,
-0.2922887206,
0.1359669119,
-0.5619550347,
-0.023971783,
-0.1994580626,
0.6452534199,
0.4162374735,
0.6539622545,
0.0933792293,
-0.1908698231,
-0.0933005512,
-0.1656767875,
-0.6235263944,
-0.0840184018,
0.3285865188,
-0.2054726183,
-0.2737174928,
-0.0251402538,
-0.6411278844,
-0.3208605349,
-0.3127996325,
0.1231007054,
-0.1624000818,
-0.7058945894,
-0.1283467114,
-0.0607719831,
0.7810640931,
0.1857608259,
-0.7194744945,
0.0272420757,
0.3667809367,
0.4787130654,
-0.113913089,
-0.0552593321,
-0.11805626,
0.1166691482,
-0.5799362063,
0.5987466574,
-0.4044162333,
-0.2921176553,
-0.0042172791,
-0.0978947878,
-0.0055973115,
-0.8680496216,
0.3445259631,
-0.6807345748,
0.3318900466,
-0.6639953852,
-0.2954443693,
-0.1216761842,
0.3778761625,
-0.7309740186,
1.1781288385,
0.1135192662,
-0.8039929867,
0.4386239052,
-0.4591992795,
-0.3965608478,
0.1769228131,
-0.3651553988,
-0.2350195795,
0.0430929475,
0.4992658198,
0.5895975232,
-0.3749577403,
0.3247365057,
-0.2239450067,
-0.5303419828,
0.7852883935,
-0.5835172534,
0.7810320258,
0.5166282654,
-0.3030771315,
-0.4086408615,
-0.6472057104,
-0.0412979908,
0.2947196364,
-0.3754124343,
-0.5347457528,
-0.3311813474,
0.0095384549,
0.3472950757,
0.2181238681,
-0.4396265745,
0.038801752,
-0.2698114216,
0.1854816526,
0.7431820035,
0.2714300752,
0.0386628769,
-0.440269053,
0.8117263913,
0.006504437,
-0.2456097305,
0.0415901653,
-0.4503252208,
-0.5824369788,
-0.0807491168,
0.0971848965,
0.7169081569,
-1.1918592453,
0.1078071892,
-0.3941348195,
-0.4271350801,
-0.4994954169,
0.3571263552,
0.3101909161,
0.5516435504,
0.0352678932,
-0.1340896785,
-0.3860555887,
-0.768497467,
-0.2257073075,
-0.3118263185,
-0.167084828,
0.7018566728,
0.3537423015,
0.0993023142,
0.9570871592,
-0.3339880109,
-0.0200463664,
-0.3872173727,
0.0122409174,
0.4213768244,
0.2577669322,
0.6802947521,
-0.7997524142,
-0.4042425156,
-0.0287295915,
-0.9250741005,
-0.2079476267,
-0.0508419052,
-0.0108202277,
0.3872747421,
0.3103676736,
-0.1626933664,
0.0058557666,
0.6630648375,
-0.0196095295,
0.5358963609,
-0.136433512,
0.4510999024,
-1.6252551079,
0.2234500945,
0.0152149647,
0.0217515957,
-0.6396994591,
-0.159129411,
-0.0718536824,
-0.2682776451,
-0.6168536544,
0.7257870436,
-0.3149570823,
-0.2386177778,
-0.091257669,
0.0346823707,
-0.249567613,
0.4977769554,
0.2557530105,
1.1746864319,
0.3268083036,
-0.5272565484,
0.4078643322,
0.1824532598,
-0.5539575815,
0.7424903512,
-0.6184591651,
0.2044065297,
-0.1804255992,
0.1438078135,
-0.9940106273,
-0.6176072359,
0.1190473661,
-0.2997544706,
-0.0970636681,
-0.270516187,
-0.6144958138,
-0.3471201956,
-0.1429242343,
0.7857545614,
0.7327948809,
-0.6195773482,
0.0342198089,
0.2562514544,
-0.5318814516,
-0.5784996152,
-0.8701651096,
0.0569377393,
-0.5189200044,
-0.645770371,
-0.3712483644,
0.1831671745,
-0.2768797278,
-0.0446742028,
0.0835362449,
-0.2185451835,
0.2011079043,
-0.1375413984,
0.1489704847,
-0.467058897,
0.2778489292,
0.0704672858,
0.1888222396,
0.1821699739,
-0.2316018492,
0.3226266205,
-0.0617621839,
-0.3486022353,
-0.4996779859,
0.1104227528,
0.4170682728,
-0.3614116609,
0.5852208734,
0.7430743575,
-0.286487788,
-0.1185814738,
-0.7132980227,
-0.2007685453,
-0.4616278708,
0.3460497856,
-0.4579123259,
-0.9815678596,
0.6913582683,
-0.0372773968,
-0.0131427515,
0.4525115788,
0.5177255869,
-0.3334658146,
0.6921311617,
0.3452873528,
-0.1601103544,
0.330041647,
-0.1797642261,
-0.0574051626,
-0.7106317878,
0.1197322533,
-0.5480970144,
-0.3228492141,
-1.0805541277,
-0.4527274966,
0.7284582257,
-0.1149803326,
-0.0708959177,
-0.0740048438,
-0.1953216195,
0.7211483717,
0.4344601631,
-0.0072554965,
0.3950919807,
0.1528978646,
0.2145406306,
0.0627710596,
-0.9289993048,
-0.6750742197,
1.4176080227,
0.0866531879,
0.677170217,
0.1984110624,
0.7822965384,
0.0024840201,
0.375457108,
-0.251229465,
0.4061034918,
-0.2575567067,
-0.682561636,
-0.4791690111,
-0.7606489658,
-0.9926428199,
0.1361400634,
-0.0682224184,
-0.3217760026,
0.2286925316,
0.1177178621,
-0.2634747624,
0.3078546524,
-0.6248269677,
0.6900938153,
-0.2886503935,
-0.295629859,
-0.0451701768,
-0.4424465895,
0.6544786692,
-0.1890041381,
0.1746811122,
-0.2991527021,
-0.0234975461,
0.9925773144,
-0.0173023138,
0.9446873069,
-0.2606403232,
-0.3978084922,
0.4662938714,
-0.1498006135,
0.3472743034,
0.3918222487,
-0.2816968262,
0.1286265403,
0.2348281145,
-0.691640079,
-0.5579451323,
0.5716903806,
-1.0213000774,
-0.6930042505,
-0.338496238,
-0.647911787,
-0.3463944495,
-0.0146158207,
0.006596324,
0.2875178456,
-0.1276173443,
-0.0260577761,
0.7466198206,
-0.649498105,
0.09285485,
0.4866455793,
0.1173521206,
-0.3955227137,
0.9706112146,
0.1762678325,
0.3658807576,
0.0071316394,
0.2056844234,
-0.3769482672,
-0.4558864236,
-0.6286805868,
0.4872738421,
-0.7504671216,
-0.1678288132,
-0.3448362052,
-0.0700534806,
-0.3445366323,
-0.0971924737,
-0.0607428476,
-0.4642440379,
-0.1139611974,
-0.0990130082,
0.6343806982,
0.7508717775,
-0.0135053964,
-0.1782448441,
-0.6929186583,
0.3197129667,
0.5765183568,
0.198132351,
-0.1739730388,
-0.4511019588,
-0.0960401222,
0.2340540737,
0.2687740922,
-0.7859353423,
0.1856278181,
0.1167734936,
0.4537368119,
0.1470521986,
0.2033852935,
0.6569697261,
0.1214644238,
0.962191999,
-0.2005861402,
-0.4320924878,
0.5721365809,
-0.4948900044,
0.5707893372,
0.6286955476,
0.4681696296,
-0.8828363419,
-0.6523581743,
-0.4138222635,
-0.6594934464,
0.6221215129,
0.0322762355,
0.4463348687,
-0.0566634052,
0.6066752076,
0.3418079317,
0.0981865376,
-0.6677670479,
0.0358874463,
-0.0992310196,
-0.3701302409,
0.0386378057,
-0.2575660348,
-0.1044863239,
-0.0223353598,
0.508474052,
-0.3953101635,
-0.0528060794,
0.164837271,
-0.2238021791,
-0.1071806699,
0.5257188082,
0.3868368268,
0.6917701364,
-0.068389751,
0.0032432692,
0.6747577786,
-0.3692934513,
0.2692620754,
0.0151219973,
-0.3328330815,
-0.2868756354,
0.3553572595,
0.4558016658,
-0.0637840256,
-0.8428143263,
0.2982873619,
-0.1213755533,
-0.038641531,
-0.4377609789,
0.1678828895,
0.0127406791,
0.2127108723,
0.3774593472,
-0.4938062131,
-0.2231569588,
-0.4294674397,
0.0629514083,
0.2737042308,
0.1542321146,
-0.2560621202,
0.5812226534,
0.4597783089,
0.4449847043,
0.8636772633,
-0.1105792895,
-0.4048817456,
0.6874268055,
0.3378735781,
0.6147604585,
-0.182141602,
0.3260077834,
0.5147075653,
0.2706592977,
0.1509502381,
0.576210022,
-0.1749402881,
-0.8499125838,
-0.6097851992,
-0.6072151065,
-0.5392513275,
0.1544344127,
-0.7128456235,
-0.0065480815,
-0.3046266437,
0.0555549785,
-0.5784131885,
0.2942503393,
-0.9478226304,
0.3099249899,
0.0859631523,
0.6330728531,
-1.2179156542,
0.7777020931,
0.8690133095,
-0.6063794494,
-0.880317688,
0.0146532543,
-0.2158367634,
-0.9246087074,
0.8053026199,
-0.0417995527,
0.1825368553,
-0.0661049783,
-0.4368810952,
-1.031159997,
1.3459771872,
0.2942045927,
-0.2620355189,
0.2166940719,
0.7369232178,
0.826100111,
-0.0910176188,
0.1836479157,
0.6175763011,
0.5261734128,
0.1512728631,
-0.9146664143,
0.1756860316,
-0.2186160833,
0.1672905385,
-0.1551205218,
-0.6453940868,
0.4569609165,
-0.2251311839,
-0.3324239254,
0.1459315866,
0.8474020362,
0.4533320069,
0.214766115,
0.4587648511,
0.4577908218,
0.8785567284,
-0.1630330384,
1.0516029596,
-0.1046949103,
-0.1705469191,
0.8010060191,
-0.3810631633,
0.7171055079,
0.4324739277,
-0.0984366983,
0.2054146379,
0.7176281214,
0.044488512,
0.0764635876,
0.2796663642,
-0.1071275994,
-0.1050409898,
-0.3236106932,
-0.3650073111,
0.5552566648,
0.2029717714,
-0.0468662754,
-0.0707930848,
0.0116707152,
0.231907934,
-0.0231718179,
-0.1951581538,
0.966047585,
-0.0887046605,
-0.7653928995,
0.8825395703,
-0.1293809116,
0.6461351514,
-0.4251462221,
0.0870751515,
-0.8990806341,
-0.2270783484,
-0.2427544743,
-0.8990264535,
0.2233719528,
0.4169383347,
0.1730336696,
-0.0759309158,
0.5127866268,
-0.6829899549,
-0.5207793117,
-0.4050596356,
0.7576173544,
0.3640820384,
0.2174227238,
-0.4687983692,
-0.1128639579,
-0.0522866808,
-0.1962723434,
0.1926343441,
0.5946602225,
-0.3488357961,
0.599691391,
0.8583254218,
0.3779399097,
0.1353981048,
0.0378806852,
0.6524859071,
-0.7414787412,
-0.4007439613,
-0.2914398909,
0.3173310757,
-0.0972615033,
-0.5000328422,
0.7138172984,
0.2867500782,
1.1433603764,
-0.0439010561,
1.0053019524,
0.060600061,
0.3938453197,
-0.6875211596,
0.6544857025,
-0.6223202944,
0.2785252333,
-0.1704253852,
-1.0536338091,
-0.174129799,
0.3227500916,
-0.4484537542,
0.1955450624,
0.4039441049,
0.9765071273,
0.0113124484,
0.0257645771,
0.3652428985,
0.2313016653,
0.4068033695,
0.7752153873,
0.9359937906,
-0.1821186095,
0.6359308362,
-0.2262595743,
-0.1684748232,
0.0736695156,
-0.6515543461,
-0.9696146846,
-0.6146069169,
-0.2122730315,
-0.0356264189,
0.0443533957,
0.8753951192,
0.2289901972,
-0.7815539837,
-0.3575847745,
0.3358154297,
0.0657659546,
-0.1829341501,
-0.2442409694,
0.5886561275,
-0.3259024918,
-0.8273184299,
0.1746310145,
-0.06196706,
0.1343816072,
-0.4255623519,
-0.0457735397,
0.0063633071,
0.0438470468,
0.3765264452,
0.5292454362,
-0.6391837001,
-0.3255718648,
0.0868034437,
-0.1080763787,
-0.1569058597,
0.7032757401,
-0.8230887651,
0.3457656801,
0.5168256164,
0.9424270391,
0.3085786104,
-0.0332886018,
0.6921511889,
-0.7974728942,
0.1063191593,
0.2408786863,
0.134124577,
0.5917799473,
-0.2734232247,
0.6256405115,
0.1503320336,
-0.3988990784,
-0.6241531968,
0.2474771291,
-0.6043331623,
-0.1113683656,
1.5619062185,
-0.029857114,
-0.2913987935,
-0.2147336006,
-0.1362233162,
0.1827288866,
-0.115882881,
0.9771049023,
0.5905898809,
-0.0356901251,
-0.1473077089,
-0.478825599,
0.5894119143,
0.614380002,
-1.1152575016,
0.0888592824,
0.5472735763,
0.5342788696,
-0.2145039141,
0.5794584155,
-0.1037115157,
0.5564801693,
-0.4137910008,
-0.1333515495,
-0.1568017453,
0.1903169453,
-0.2834278047,
-0.0117570171,
0.2571011186,
0.0865955576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18926v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18926v2
|
XMoE: Sparse Models with Fine-grained and Adaptive Expert Selection
| 2024-02-27T08:18:02 | 2024-05-24T10:14:55 |
Yuanhang Yang, Shiyi Qi, Wenchao Gu, Chaozheng Wang, Cuiyun Gao, Zenglin Xu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Sparse models, including sparse Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models, have emerged
as an effective approach for scaling Transformer models. However, they often
suffer from computational inefficiency since a significant number of parameters
are unnecessarily involved in computations via multiplying values by zero or
low activation values. To address this issue, we present \tool, a novel MoE
designed to enhance both the efficacy and efficiency of sparse MoE models.
\tool leverages small experts and a threshold-based router to enable tokens to
selectively engage only essential parameters. Our extensive experiments on
language modeling and machine translation tasks demonstrate that \tool can
enhance model performance while decreasing the computation load at MoE layers
by over 50\% without sacrificing performance. Furthermore, we present the
versatility of \tool by applying it to dense models, enabling sparse
computation during inference. We provide a comprehensive analysis and make our
code available at https://github.com/ysngki/XMoE.
|
[
-0.7040763497,
-0.6682839394,
0.3839142621,
0.1524748802,
-0.1311040819,
-0.1555063426,
-0.2350462526,
-0.2157395482,
0.3582694829,
0.3990763426,
-0.6494984627,
-0.0229118615,
-0.7360798717,
-0.1124651954,
-0.3884191811,
0.7218379378,
0.3227194846,
0.0526294373,
-0.1374917477,
-0.1375429481,
-0.5864885449,
0.2574307024,
-0.8276237845,
-0.3090282977,
0.4294815063,
0.5775426626,
1.0216500759,
0.6785554886,
0.4070755243,
0.4510080814,
0.0874275416,
0.1549217105,
-0.7158031464,
0.3128323257,
-0.262212038,
-0.635158658,
-0.7698355913,
-0.1264118105,
0.5875115395,
0.7723639607,
-0.1076774746,
0.0932881311,
0.1353828758,
0.2465244532,
-0.6515619159,
0.0320438445,
-1.1532838345,
-0.2412472516,
-0.0979835987,
-0.0733388215,
-0.5421808362,
0.1603736877,
0.1658547968,
-0.7488117218,
0.464055717,
0.1928648949,
0.7729748487,
0.6612280607,
-0.3367523849,
0.2074738294,
-0.453971535,
1.1074876785,
-0.5591179729,
0.4393584132,
0.3631424606,
0.3379002213,
-0.073833935,
-0.7361115217,
-0.288728267,
-0.1311494559,
-0.0425132141,
0.010474111,
-0.3238940537,
0.1957400292,
0.1794724613,
0.3534713089,
-0.2006224096,
0.1977117807,
-0.2352058142,
-0.0400739647,
0.6500191092,
0.4757271111,
-0.0196857583,
-0.3083201647,
-0.2520867884,
-0.0521524139,
-0.3782084882,
-0.1007337719,
0.1476544738,
0.1648373902,
0.0288399179,
0.2697781324,
-0.1477993131,
0.639197588,
0.2997834086,
-0.2014486194,
0.0893217921,
0.0190155227,
-0.252365917,
-0.3618091941,
0.9189606309,
0.2059320062,
-0.1587983519,
-0.344103843,
-0.3929057419,
-0.4087598324,
0.4081916809,
-0.9872137904,
-0.5124573708,
0.049247887,
-0.2898930311,
-0.4858689308,
-0.0554060265,
-0.9892514944,
-0.3183777034,
-0.0513313971,
0.7096447349,
-0.291120559,
-0.301659435,
0.1101275086,
-0.2746424079,
-0.4257662296,
0.4440980852,
-0.9866443872,
0.4735743701,
0.4621008039,
0.905952096,
-0.0782760084,
-0.0741973743,
-0.6417880654,
-0.0373688191,
-0.2795827389,
0.6598120928,
-0.8111802936,
-0.7705588341,
-0.5447778702,
-0.1918804049,
-0.2796350121,
-0.5248450041,
0.7199555039,
-0.5443405509,
-0.1465358585,
-0.0349453501,
-0.4177981913,
-0.3283383548,
-0.0912294611,
-0.8951274753,
1.3596779108,
0.5449948311,
-0.4783535302,
0.5676623583,
-0.799667418,
-0.2239744067,
0.0136013115,
-0.1028798223,
-0.4114934206,
0.4193881452,
0.2486663461,
0.6524230242,
-0.5088765025,
0.0388976075,
-0.5466318727,
-0.2412181348,
0.0363225602,
-0.7555500269,
0.6866668463,
0.0866165161,
-0.3307894468,
0.4380066097,
-1.0502203703,
0.0103935208,
-0.0092514278,
-0.1069373712,
-0.5018265247,
0.1143026575,
0.1393697262,
0.1502399296,
0.0432989001,
-0.5912226439,
0.3953442872,
-0.3840658069,
0.5811165571,
0.8551480174,
-0.1214236692,
0.7590650916,
-0.3732185662,
0.5236405134,
-0.2348876894,
0.0043421783,
-0.1168936566,
-0.6624010205,
-0.9365649223,
-0.8368419409,
0.5960990191,
0.4203487933,
-0.7358440161,
0.5117962956,
-0.5346212983,
-0.8024377823,
-0.9014828205,
0.4071028829,
0.0864969417,
0.4636219442,
0.3977109194,
-0.033884488,
-0.3565735817,
-0.7986090779,
0.0940791965,
0.1583101749,
-0.5184538364,
0.4975036681,
0.3146576285,
-0.2139813751,
1.2560306787,
-0.6546310782,
-0.3658493161,
-0.3180637956,
0.2741743028,
0.0247469787,
0.7334791422,
0.6899164319,
-0.7653034925,
-0.6466090083,
0.2925369143,
-0.3642425239,
-0.4109400511,
-0.2477184087,
-0.1529491097,
-0.3621792495,
0.3826037645,
-0.5772656202,
0.1589695364,
0.6201847196,
-0.1260384917,
0.1659510136,
-0.1408486515,
0.0360203981,
-1.0086050034,
-0.1123166531,
0.122242935,
-0.5643599629,
-0.3646450341,
0.2456427366,
0.2304540724,
-0.05422033,
-0.2284606695,
0.8681844473,
-0.3839567006,
0.3812299967,
-0.2755398452,
-0.0110033033,
0.0636699051,
0.5558266044,
-0.0571383238,
0.9202057123,
0.7258111835,
-0.2078386694,
0.0272135511,
0.0904275328,
-0.3165285587,
0.4036939442,
-0.7907538414,
0.0383664183,
0.26762712,
-0.25401932,
-0.8475228548,
-0.2929880619,
0.1745663136,
-0.3076770306,
0.4639043808,
-0.3558398783,
-0.5149832964,
-0.0852380916,
-0.4085187018,
0.4093904793,
0.6776607037,
-0.1868770719,
1.1552150249,
0.4210433662,
-0.3336641192,
-0.1485298127,
-0.4784140885,
0.0371566005,
-0.0317965448,
-0.9416185617,
0.267051518,
-0.2132784724,
-0.1605845392,
0.0880173743,
-0.0392007567,
-0.6360119581,
0.3044551015,
0.2774915993,
0.1687737256,
-0.4043769836,
-0.1998423785,
0.6845105886,
-0.42926085,
0.107200101,
-0.1166740209,
0.3437474966,
0.1240104437,
-0.4435012341,
-0.2846997976,
0.4757405221,
0.7476209402,
-0.0738370791,
0.5953518748,
0.5858501196,
-0.1920771152,
-0.4190558493,
-0.6926050186,
-0.2797445059,
-0.5792089701,
0.6441743374,
-0.503210485,
-0.7741137743,
0.3563692272,
-0.0463626981,
0.2916660011,
0.4636484981,
0.6837698221,
0.3427089453,
1.4277046919,
0.819011271,
-0.2127230167,
0.5466165543,
-0.3336457908,
0.1014950797,
-0.7060786486,
0.1191816106,
-0.4286710322,
-0.459857285,
-0.214356482,
-0.730427146,
0.701281786,
-0.0844150335,
0.3037386239,
0.2876329124,
-0.3785496354,
0.4625575542,
0.6007953286,
0.140124172,
0.2005801797,
-0.0551465452,
0.0256305672,
-0.0286948159,
-1.1998429298,
-0.3487505913,
0.9086028337,
0.2903756797,
1.0078078508,
-0.2744474411,
0.2722026408,
0.2414538264,
0.2712652087,
-0.8753698468,
0.6064890623,
-0.1361812055,
-0.8949899673,
-0.5144859552,
-0.4328460693,
-0.7823843956,
0.6308650374,
-0.3180087507,
-0.6518566608,
0.5537027717,
0.2081138194,
-0.7232451439,
0.5940339565,
-0.9101961255,
0.7629232407,
0.2691325247,
-0.4896228611,
-0.4559147358,
-0.4658865035,
0.2307970822,
-0.5704233646,
-0.0718924478,
-0.1633845568,
-0.3303131759,
0.5416662097,
-0.6545577049,
0.8566150069,
-0.1482811719,
0.104262121,
0.2662872076,
0.358306855,
0.5616775751,
0.3137874901,
-0.6202691793,
0.2951619625,
-0.1516382545,
-0.580080092,
-0.7402153611,
0.7435978055,
-0.7283040881,
-0.6220719814,
0.2473559529,
-1.1820211411,
-0.1422179043,
0.4477609992,
0.3013277054,
0.4776224494,
0.1119192019,
0.6212763786,
0.7450318933,
0.3551195562,
0.1319134235,
0.3695954978,
0.2112416923,
-0.3084796667,
1.0532934666,
0.5339024663,
0.3120793998,
0.382847935,
0.2342371643,
0.2254052609,
-0.5829214454,
-0.6300685406,
-0.1729378253,
-0.5967549682,
-0.4072462916,
-0.916246593,
-0.0393663496,
-0.0242008548,
-0.6592922807,
-0.4334594607,
-0.5824571252,
-0.3367806375,
0.0471171997,
0.2700243294,
0.5205435157,
0.0566251948,
0.7368253469,
-0.8967434168,
0.3419365585,
0.4099421501,
0.244516626,
0.2408078313,
-0.4966149032,
-0.3862701654,
0.0210376363,
-0.3642370105,
-0.443585515,
0.2140921801,
0.1946777105,
0.6304363012,
0.83656317,
0.2133023441,
0.7746329308,
-0.5038248301,
0.5492959619,
-0.0688786581,
-1.0731203556,
0.0935008302,
-0.3227052689,
-0.0157049168,
0.4608569443,
0.3162230849,
0.0482061766,
-0.6758096218,
-0.6273826957,
-0.8859906197,
0.7122497559,
0.3304169774,
0.3604105711,
0.0600336343,
0.1135506183,
0.4991948009,
0.0797146484,
-0.3389050066,
-0.1024471745,
-0.0734051913,
-0.1395747811,
0.3567725718,
-0.5129511952,
0.0192495324,
-0.3572611809,
0.8326537013,
-0.1679247022,
0.0422076173,
0.0142831979,
-0.2046352774,
-0.4607942104,
0.0304183699,
0.3191877604,
0.5237477422,
-0.1751182973,
-0.1234457046,
0.7247924209,
-0.5005850196,
-0.0182733033,
0.1516507119,
-0.3376850486,
0.1938068569,
0.3842637837,
0.8747004271,
0.7707082033,
-0.4985992908,
0.5531961918,
-0.0204036646,
-0.3414635062,
0.1362615228,
0.5764547586,
-0.2210029662,
0.1799318939,
0.4109886289,
0.8189764023,
0.2348639965,
0.3275423348,
0.1585113853,
0.4514592886,
-0.4950198829,
-0.4657949209,
0.9199700952,
0.6297181845,
-0.156747058,
0.3829208612,
-0.3239133954,
-0.0326761603,
0.3834531903,
0.1372559518,
0.8967818618,
-0.1452585757,
-0.2277251184,
0.0045147641,
0.4264655411,
0.1286550462,
-0.1273168176,
-0.1815635711,
-0.5683247447,
-0.5709168911,
-0.3136551976,
-0.2460583001,
-0.1624351144,
-0.6378548741,
0.6228342652,
-0.3670869768,
-0.2442295402,
0.0288228989,
-0.0863513798,
-0.5645915866,
0.0785054788,
-0.3062233627,
1.3712248802,
-0.8240241408,
0.9637040496,
0.5132358074,
-0.1535993218,
-0.6809737682,
-0.2485188842,
-0.0612243377,
-0.7883336544,
0.3785887063,
-0.1825181544,
-0.213221699,
0.3878118396,
-0.2936152816,
-0.7502722144,
1.0110090971,
0.5535691977,
-0.4732616842,
0.0153253051,
-0.1782956123,
0.1469829381,
-0.0765773579,
0.6466171145,
0.2909599841,
0.5679802299,
0.1035814285,
-0.9431411624,
-0.1343334019,
-0.3908191919,
-0.0324381739,
0.475643605,
-0.6039616466,
0.9810886979,
-0.0692096651,
0.1363510638,
0.371917516,
0.9326267838,
-0.1730364412,
0.0682966784,
0.9562063813,
0.4375013113,
0.6924080253,
0.1003832668,
0.9751824737,
-0.5608639121,
0.5312238932,
0.8175774217,
-0.1707856506,
0.674708426,
0.3313162923,
-0.1154863313,
0.3903833926,
0.3255798519,
-0.2330129147,
0.3446424305,
-0.3611867726,
-0.3033936024,
-0.6139221787,
0.0870571733,
-0.1214280725,
0.1437079012,
0.3433177769,
-0.215259552,
-0.4254493117,
0.1002749056,
0.1382460594,
-0.3069154322,
-0.4712093771,
0.5716887712,
-0.0279608853,
-0.3143885136,
0.4462455809,
0.0907569155,
0.7308239341,
-0.9400413036,
0.0117605841,
0.0932680592,
0.164540723,
-0.2927452922,
-0.5969736576,
0.1825775951,
-0.2933400273,
-0.5994457006,
-0.1269076318,
0.8989396691,
-0.2593761683,
-0.8940093517,
0.1053158268,
0.4419684708,
-0.1281200647,
-0.356906116,
-0.6517024636,
-0.1150048748,
-0.1233193576,
-0.5707995892,
0.3084527552,
0.8660695553,
-0.2389808595,
1.0114666224,
0.672260046,
0.1008560583,
0.3659293354,
-0.1374379098,
1.1287753582,
-0.1451222897,
-0.4832966626,
-0.6888397336,
0.9029297829,
-0.1346897483,
-0.2687777579,
0.919711113,
0.3697800636,
0.7838292718,
-0.1956793517,
0.6990807652,
-0.2935726345,
0.3353781104,
-0.3007436097,
0.7509356737,
-0.7090242505,
0.1537696421,
-0.2810203731,
-0.6885827184,
-0.3307532668,
0.493100822,
-0.3664284647,
0.1767491847,
0.4337094426,
1.068754673,
-0.5363725424,
-0.2010555118,
0.7458293438,
0.3417303562,
0.2021355778,
0.0828999281,
0.4001868665,
-0.3329987228,
0.7417351604,
-0.5088005662,
-0.3803145289,
-0.499275893,
-0.7682573199,
-1.0241526365,
-0.3974134326,
-0.2633413076,
0.1447408497,
-0.468867451,
1.2922309637,
1.4083000422,
-0.7334157228,
-0.0772276372,
0.0301774982,
0.2935228348,
-0.3859497309,
-0.2073286623,
-0.0075692232,
-0.5630598664,
-1.0461102724,
0.4558502436,
0.3485115767,
-0.4660815299,
-0.3386726677,
-0.0467576124,
0.3428202271,
0.2511841655,
0.6675867438,
-0.257763207,
-0.6266531348,
-0.1573699117,
-0.08212699,
0.0794320628,
0.125078693,
0.8883413076,
-0.7646303177,
0.5305635333,
0.7344821095,
0.7711012959,
0.037319839,
-0.2156084776,
0.5802507401,
-0.7492023706,
0.3453010619,
0.1373738199,
0.7204294801,
-0.0925785676,
-0.486762464,
0.4129261374,
0.3374451697,
-0.6450933814,
-0.9339392781,
-0.1130189076,
-1.1146068573,
-0.2433500141,
0.9036460519,
-0.0121733975,
-0.2024753243,
-0.2647455037,
-0.751321435,
-0.2094038278,
-0.7672858834,
0.7268298268,
0.5503211617,
0.2149344236,
-0.1473041326,
-0.7807354927,
0.0013404103,
0.6253480911,
-0.4124016762,
-0.0874428153,
0.1003753021,
0.3164184093,
0.1645736396,
0.2676193118,
0.2410066724,
0.2946935296,
0.2594861984,
-0.0087357285,
-0.3603615761,
-0.2168357521,
-0.096540235,
0.3201037943,
0.2580243647,
0.0057463478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00825v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00825v1
|
Comparing effectiveness of regularization methods on text classification: Simple and complex model in data shortage situation
| 2024-02-27T07:26:16 | 2024-02-27T07:26:16 |
Jongga Lee, Jaeseung Yim, Seohee Park, Changwon Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classification is the task of assigning a document to a predefined
class. However, it is expensive to acquire enough labeled documents or to label
them. In this paper, we study the regularization methods' effects on various
classification models when only a few labeled data are available. We compare a
simple word embedding-based model, which is simple but effective, with complex
models (CNN and BiLSTM). In supervised learning, adversarial training can
further regularize the model. When an unlabeled dataset is available, we can
regularize the model using semi-supervised learning methods such as the Pi
model and virtual adversarial training. We evaluate the regularization effects
on four text classification datasets (AG news, DBpedia, Yahoo! Answers, Yelp
Polarity), using only 0.1% to 0.5% of the original labeled training documents.
The simple model performs relatively well in fully supervised learning, but
with the help of adversarial training and semi-supervised learning, both simple
and complex models can be regularized, showing better results for complex
models. Although the simple model is robust to overfitting, a complex model
with well-designed prior beliefs can be also robust to overfitting.
|
[
-0.2009374797,
-1.0385313034,
0.3880618513,
0.1215058491,
-0.2339806557,
-0.0201615468,
-0.4100274146,
-0.4723891616,
-0.2162632644,
0.202109769,
0.1028066203,
-0.4107694626,
-0.7449108958,
0.1865667105,
-0.5283285975,
1.2004076242,
-0.0553009436,
0.3295828998,
-0.2852180302,
0.087776646,
-0.326882273,
-0.7060685754,
-0.5065283179,
-0.3820696771,
0.4139847457,
0.252365917,
0.7097167969,
0.6091880798,
0.7297602296,
0.3266572654,
-0.4221756756,
0.0542471632,
-0.5236204863,
-0.0102248443,
0.0232224911,
-0.6114667654,
-0.0825202614,
0.2924797535,
0.5649389029,
0.8639580011,
0.006326458,
-0.0857657045,
0.2699732184,
0.6011040211,
-0.7444400191,
-0.0552906133,
-0.3988951147,
0.0910921916,
-0.1645205021,
0.0939788148,
-0.2452584654,
-0.3341686726,
0.4232372046,
-0.4894818366,
0.6182905436,
0.2186017632,
1.0560519695,
0.3510482907,
-0.5813202262,
-0.5569640994,
-1.2310897112,
0.8031173944,
-0.6119761467,
0.353474617,
0.4143648744,
0.1289185733,
-0.1584637463,
-0.9041372538,
-0.5023311973,
-0.2547693551,
-0.0637646392,
0.4189043641,
-0.2426806539,
0.2162990272,
0.3782867491,
0.4952512681,
-0.4532007277,
0.136654377,
-0.6108407378,
-0.1419604868,
0.4270939529,
-0.1885775477,
0.2197979391,
-0.0458933376,
-0.5951768756,
-0.1693559736,
-0.3322421014,
0.1003781855,
0.4243793488,
0.3014715016,
0.1307146996,
0.7810944319,
-0.103051208,
0.9312207103,
-0.0650852621,
-0.2187421322,
-0.0799563751,
-0.5456647873,
-0.5334160924,
0.1307235062,
0.6545109749,
0.2100299895,
0.3230374455,
-0.1432855725,
-0.1958880126,
0.2985426784,
0.2145602852,
-0.7039058805,
-0.4202675819,
-0.0268998239,
-0.4935314655,
-0.3782530427,
0.3145730197,
-0.6252737641,
-0.4846405685,
-0.3245436549,
0.553360343,
-0.0627149493,
0.3196881413,
0.3840210438,
-0.3589918613,
-0.1138027832,
0.6355027556,
-0.6086592078,
0.2849495411,
0.3815093338,
0.8981630802,
-0.1306129098,
-0.0249855034,
-0.3160745502,
-0.0048452523,
-0.3253105283,
0.817663312,
-0.3927003443,
-0.2647455037,
0.0603624173,
-0.0901372284,
-0.1137632802,
-0.441224575,
0.9251001477,
-0.4223106205,
0.4567807317,
-0.0055541806,
-0.7477583289,
-0.2963190675,
0.4526920617,
-0.7589104772,
0.8784804344,
-0.2237746865,
-1.0975551605,
0.2590034306,
-0.3240805566,
-0.4279322624,
-0.193669349,
-0.0011363761,
-0.784296751,
-0.0106330225,
-0.0096222768,
0.7417713404,
-0.4428212643,
0.0773965418,
-0.4541452229,
-0.5058972836,
0.2848380804,
-0.5758924484,
0.6558074951,
0.1285057664,
-0.288646251,
-0.2648984194,
-0.6978369355,
-0.1185193956,
0.1569050401,
-0.7802832723,
-0.7132223845,
-0.0423762091,
0.3062823117,
0.010198121,
0.1595118195,
-0.6961832643,
0.4125987589,
-0.4801946282,
0.1983074844,
0.447576195,
0.1043130904,
0.5536216497,
-0.3449619412,
0.2472064197,
0.0669861436,
0.1028582454,
0.0674923882,
-0.5594473481,
-0.8893693686,
-0.4476483464,
0.9541383386,
0.6453611255,
-0.4569805562,
0.2225192487,
-0.0997916609,
-0.5886633992,
-0.3697334528,
0.035714265,
0.4272873104,
0.3193215728,
0.3337918818,
0.0142053338,
-0.1581274867,
-0.919750452,
-0.3074802756,
0.1077369004,
-0.1425769031,
-0.0054127951,
0.5043588281,
-0.3558757603,
0.9339820147,
-0.5847012997,
-0.5446660519,
-0.2003297955,
0.2490880936,
-0.2989714444,
0.4743097723,
0.6017718315,
-1.1019765139,
-0.5862273574,
0.0630605817,
-0.5403645635,
0.1245145351,
-0.2779885828,
0.2237115353,
0.246025458,
0.2302631885,
-0.4009129405,
0.820712924,
0.3666197658,
-0.1382361352,
0.1276724041,
-0.4418041706,
-0.0288147461,
-0.8966701031,
-0.0189670641,
0.2041794509,
-0.3106378317,
-0.9878858328,
-0.3140879571,
0.1534308791,
-0.2919845283,
-0.2031446695,
0.3327178359,
-0.538389802,
0.0737637058,
-0.3394863904,
0.2073763013,
0.2105628252,
0.3898950815,
0.0555540994,
0.3860056102,
0.4484170973,
-0.6379408836,
0.3216297328,
0.1222915277,
-0.1571306437,
0.0206580739,
-0.8070482016,
0.0196816195,
-0.3212387264,
0.2292306274,
-0.9992429018,
-0.0791617557,
0.3830337524,
-0.2572478056,
0.650290072,
-0.0432962812,
-0.6773802042,
-0.1452960223,
-0.4911991358,
0.0208882466,
0.2220764607,
-0.4058915377,
0.3864777684,
0.1831981689,
-0.1857156754,
-0.2223218977,
-0.6919642091,
-0.0047596712,
-0.0403289162,
-0.3301312923,
0.3991518319,
-0.2226867974,
0.0237966105,
0.1825859994,
-0.2541352808,
-0.3012093604,
0.3377076387,
0.0607680045,
0.2894823253,
0.0430968255,
0.3024613857,
0.2263678759,
-0.1272474229,
-0.2933416367,
-0.0041995286,
0.240375191,
-0.2903199494,
-0.3346541226,
-0.4404206574,
0.3226576447,
0.4695019424,
-0.289062649,
0.8568320274,
0.5354037881,
-0.7229830027,
0.002855215,
-0.5141741037,
-0.0746103674,
-0.3736975491,
0.2655658722,
-0.0310479365,
-0.6614707708,
0.1602175236,
-0.3532367349,
-0.0039008777,
0.550693512,
0.3994413614,
-0.242813617,
1.2414158583,
0.7843905091,
0.0071593043,
0.4970383346,
-0.4491262138,
0.3101298511,
-0.395824194,
-0.410310775,
-0.8341190219,
-0.2938224673,
-0.6499416232,
0.063815549,
0.1762560606,
0.4528924525,
0.102682963,
0.0643148124,
-0.6452885866,
0.2700923979,
0.7433003187,
0.2050579339,
0.3517277539,
0.2433083206,
0.2885569334,
-0.1079309359,
-1.0159920454,
-0.6789830923,
0.9219033718,
0.4013356566,
0.8363752365,
0.0204425864,
0.5393581986,
0.3278997838,
0.2878378332,
-0.9512878656,
0.0023817061,
-0.2312528491,
-0.5156875849,
-0.2805632651,
-0.5501281619,
-1.0866783857,
0.1292797327,
-0.8133148551,
-0.2466429919,
0.5506099463,
0.0331325792,
-0.3878077567,
0.2266189456,
-0.8598361611,
0.8509191275,
-0.2033642679,
0.0870227888,
-0.0037318959,
-0.5313091278,
0.1044991389,
-0.517459631,
0.2587457001,
0.3310184181,
-0.117105253,
1.0857627392,
-0.2934383154,
0.9120881557,
0.0587340482,
0.2779267728,
0.228937462,
-0.4139439166,
0.6042619944,
-0.2876274884,
0.1638153791,
0.059485279,
0.1103650779,
-0.5330290794,
-0.6533834338,
0.3955492675,
-0.8152863979,
-0.3793898523,
-0.6855803728,
-0.1247440502,
-0.0364495479,
0.4592814445,
0.7267647386,
0.5925489068,
-0.0400330648,
0.5862871408,
0.996445477,
-0.0870755613,
0.3060923815,
0.3409521282,
0.1534977704,
-0.2690609992,
0.8935500383,
0.5648291707,
0.1393152624,
0.1797271371,
0.5132161975,
0.0039410521,
-0.5966193676,
-0.1229808852,
0.1630921066,
-0.556266129,
-0.4504694939,
-0.7259400487,
-0.3212519288,
-0.4211827219,
-0.1378193796,
-0.3937507868,
-0.3545096219,
-0.5480525494,
0.0162219368,
0.0530105568,
0.8296939731,
0.2058154494,
0.391659379,
-0.8445237875,
0.2605028749,
0.3129054904,
0.1466389894,
-0.1167639866,
-0.4934028983,
-0.4967494011,
0.1759344786,
-0.3169777095,
-1.0090950727,
0.0406583697,
0.179137364,
0.4247751832,
0.5239769816,
0.4579975307,
0.4441206157,
-0.3532420993,
0.4449489415,
0.2417186499,
-0.6849918962,
0.4483353794,
-0.0413331091,
0.0656740144,
0.3996730447,
0.5761225224,
-0.3835588694,
-0.4643564522,
-0.6927986741,
-0.6334618926,
0.6759768128,
0.6120366454,
-0.0722022653,
0.1966184825,
0.3872314394,
-0.0583516248,
0.3063151538,
-0.6489696503,
-0.4460914731,
-0.1882958114,
-0.2611304224,
0.0481187403,
-0.4815488756,
-0.0175410435,
-0.1164882705,
0.671333015,
0.4120531678,
0.2187400758,
0.4060459733,
-0.0385131836,
0.157265678,
0.3185860515,
0.5917132497,
0.0852035284,
-0.1882126778,
0.193361029,
0.0947877169,
-0.6249685287,
0.009847085,
0.2092752904,
-0.5353149176,
0.25489676,
0.4925546944,
0.7201933265,
0.1404971629,
-0.3918959498,
0.7460811138,
-0.3013712168,
-0.1246496141,
-0.0795412585,
0.0090976283,
-0.1691862345,
0.2908646464,
0.2371128201,
0.4726141393,
0.4045903981,
-0.5008864999,
-0.1750340015,
0.2607625723,
-0.2618041933,
-0.0423060954,
0.4365358949,
0.0411563702,
-0.3330983818,
0.5143553019,
-0.1461010128,
-0.7543799281,
0.598837018,
0.6359393597,
0.5204263926,
-0.0803856552,
0.0901321918,
0.1920769513,
0.458666265,
-0.5748953223,
-0.1643267125,
0.0762490183,
-0.5434879065,
-0.0383372307,
-0.3173138797,
-0.4116360843,
-0.0344812572,
-0.6647815704,
0.2460836619,
-0.4895375669,
-0.2965885997,
0.1087972596,
0.4260980189,
-0.6248286366,
0.4202391505,
-0.053899467,
0.8078628182,
-1.0593152046,
0.6724762321,
1.0426014662,
-0.3792444468,
-0.5718796253,
0.2154865712,
-0.1625485718,
0.0316655748,
0.3751770556,
0.1812971085,
-0.0363975838,
0.0676335692,
-0.6802173853,
-0.7561721206,
0.8219062686,
0.1509470195,
-0.6287350655,
0.0985115394,
-0.0585412495,
0.8068968058,
0.0376582593,
-0.2643972039,
0.1371382326,
0.4259034395,
-0.0778400823,
-0.5821656585,
-0.2572921515,
-0.2058631778,
0.1131184697,
0.1083776131,
-0.5724611878,
0.6437661648,
-0.1321921051,
-0.5208244324,
0.026886493,
0.4815277755,
-0.1135602668,
0.7336855531,
0.4600833356,
0.334158361,
0.9198012948,
-0.1551195532,
1.1107207537,
0.0636822432,
0.7796145678,
0.8128914237,
0.080038242,
0.7316188812,
0.0926911607,
-0.0769554228,
-0.056569133,
0.8985286951,
-0.2528196871,
0.5482100844,
0.1053626165,
-0.0273844879,
-0.2673501074,
-0.1190389395,
-0.3078697026,
0.2209712565,
0.1958432496,
-0.0560264029,
-0.3035901189,
0.5074720383,
0.1835442334,
0.1196129322,
-0.1669706255,
0.7200756669,
0.0565289445,
-0.1608574539,
0.3365336061,
0.5169269443,
0.5351233482,
-0.3166542947,
0.2146099955,
-0.2538008392,
0.2289882153,
-0.2907509804,
-0.4794492126,
0.1836049259,
0.1857795119,
-0.5075934529,
0.0413158759,
1.0367275476,
-0.7912076116,
-0.6459352374,
0.1118457764,
0.2332268506,
0.1847905964,
-0.1382556707,
-0.6992855072,
-0.1581318825,
-0.0839870945,
-0.3893697262,
0.2373639941,
0.332500875,
-0.0870110244,
0.6356602311,
0.6950249672,
0.1070620194,
0.139536202,
-0.1291779131,
0.8269040585,
-0.3503758907,
-0.2962734103,
-0.7505553961,
0.1705990583,
-0.239686951,
-0.0972668976,
0.8797139525,
0.6743422151,
0.8854385018,
-0.0903699175,
0.6119860411,
0.1911001205,
0.5524291992,
-0.4864033461,
0.6652249098,
-0.7230139971,
0.2716513574,
-0.2593270242,
-0.9941707253,
-0.6588448882,
0.6375852823,
-0.2810668945,
-0.0466422439,
0.6515675187,
0.3527064621,
-0.2318642288,
-0.0005676096,
0.2190828472,
0.163673237,
0.0891445503,
0.0194309428,
0.7467412353,
-0.5510821939,
0.6299913526,
-0.4047082365,
-0.4466614425,
-0.3333582282,
-0.5565963984,
-1.0936794281,
-0.4515271783,
-0.5646777749,
-0.1912121624,
0.0595898405,
0.5870950222,
0.3531160951,
-0.5995665193,
0.3007367253,
0.0109851984,
0.2506297529,
-0.0356583856,
-0.203844294,
0.6483345628,
-0.2342156172,
-0.8853908181,
0.0568346754,
0.0336647592,
0.6045554876,
0.0003295849,
0.1825581342,
-0.2268904001,
0.0624013729,
0.5295493603,
0.1559191644,
-0.3565831184,
-0.1670977026,
0.0488899723,
-0.5101162791,
-0.1381657869,
0.6306326389,
-0.413190335,
0.6346199512,
0.6990010142,
0.8396269679,
0.4972037375,
0.2063162476,
0.2541126311,
-0.5541658998,
0.0055539669,
0.100201644,
0.3048947453,
0.3205652535,
-0.4909029603,
0.4934846163,
0.4126321673,
-0.553059876,
-0.9164990187,
0.0466104001,
-0.8411608338,
-0.5328273773,
0.9812780023,
-0.2832346261,
0.0812502354,
-0.1394841075,
-0.3902102709,
0.5643882155,
-0.1280752122,
0.9043736458,
0.7304768562,
0.1961873621,
0.2117822766,
-0.5805271864,
0.4345958233,
0.3015927672,
-0.6375055909,
-0.2299690247,
0.3563450575,
0.0988547951,
0.3175119758,
0.2039741129,
0.2808816731,
0.0209998339,
-0.1854779869,
-0.1086646244,
-0.1384667009,
-0.6029664874,
-0.5316059589,
0.081654571,
-0.1722946763,
-0.311501801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17263v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17263v2
|
MELoRA: Mini-Ensemble Low-Rank Adapters for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-27T07:14:12 | 2024-06-24T12:45:27 |
Pengjie Ren, Chengshun Shi, Shiguang Wu, Mengqi Zhang, Zhaochun Ren, Maarten de Rijke, Zhumin Chen, Jiahuan Pei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is a popular method for tailoring
pre-trained large language models (LLMs), especially as the models' scale and
the diversity of tasks increase. Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) is based on the
idea that the adaptation process is intrinsically low-dimensional, i.e.,
significant model changes can be represented with relatively few parameters.
However, decreasing the rank encounters challenges with generalization errors
for specific tasks when compared to full-parameter fine-tuning. We present
MELoRA, a mini-ensemble low-rank adapters that uses fewer trainable parameters
while maintaining a higher rank, thereby offering improved performance
potential. The core idea is to freeze original pretrained weights and train a
group of mini LoRAs with only a small number of parameters. This can capture a
significant degree of diversity among mini LoRAs, thus promoting better
generalization ability. We conduct a theoretical analysis and empirical studies
on various NLP tasks. Our experimental results show that, compared to LoRA,
MELoRA achieves better performance with 8 times fewer trainable parameters on
natural language understanding tasks and 36 times fewer trainable parameters on
instruction following tasks, which demonstrates the effectiveness of MELoRA.
|
[
-0.5657891631,
-0.725171566,
0.3276951909,
0.1319966316,
-0.3615418077,
0.0348440669,
-0.474039495,
-0.3861882985,
0.1764408052,
0.3628925681,
-0.3237023354,
-0.6154725552,
-0.695812583,
0.2049513012,
-0.2109606415,
1.1431162357,
0.2520324886,
-0.3782809973,
0.0756882876,
-0.2628814876,
-0.3957179189,
-0.1761299223,
-1.021079421,
-0.0636252686,
0.8970292211,
0.7459991574,
0.5908015966,
0.4667638242,
0.4527933896,
0.2721121311,
-0.1753327698,
0.1633083522,
-0.6045090556,
0.0970889255,
-0.1164858192,
-0.878303051,
-0.7692010999,
-0.1138285771,
0.6583008766,
0.6157925725,
-0.1798350513,
0.4730978608,
0.1626502573,
0.8240348697,
-0.8550860286,
-0.1441263855,
-0.9224760532,
0.0293146204,
-0.2677361667,
-0.0108137084,
-0.2465735525,
-0.2767671049,
0.0635296553,
-0.8154481053,
0.0675676391,
0.2185429782,
0.5079147816,
0.6087065935,
-0.0052727577,
-0.0028189812,
-0.8478221893,
0.9193623066,
-1.0090777874,
-0.0212018155,
0.4549654126,
0.3994417191,
0.0854918584,
-0.4298715591,
-0.3388170004,
0.0409720987,
-0.073405236,
0.0177060347,
-0.2914343476,
0.1912234575,
0.2037761211,
0.4061333835,
-0.4816756845,
0.4565669,
-0.2169397026,
0.153939575,
0.4553963542,
0.069417201,
0.1415625662,
0.086870037,
0.0247234572,
-0.0756055787,
-0.5760600567,
0.1718990207,
0.2660149038,
0.4629914761,
-0.2938060164,
0.3161878288,
-0.225968346,
0.9173043966,
0.3171180189,
-0.3719799519,
-0.0940158367,
-0.1557849497,
-0.5608564615,
-0.1195484996,
0.4754027128,
-0.0521926098,
0.1335987598,
-0.097875379,
-0.0939277411,
0.1173631325,
-0.03326004,
-0.9337206483,
-0.5947927833,
-0.1145293936,
-0.5720612407,
-0.4597129524,
-0.2942523956,
-1.1919560432,
-0.1832384318,
-0.2422087342,
0.7669816613,
-0.3169613779,
0.1514844596,
-0.0271450635,
-0.1035221368,
0.1682696193,
0.6177081466,
-1.2896746397,
0.7399024963,
0.2802514732,
0.6886658072,
-0.3427376151,
-0.2283329815,
-0.8558390141,
0.0341717452,
-0.1223837435,
0.8719459772,
-0.6549790502,
-0.2324336469,
-0.507527709,
0.0223495532,
-0.6845940351,
-0.8119207621,
0.4913319349,
-0.5056799054,
0.1575054973,
-0.0593661591,
-0.1981861591,
-0.0357373729,
0.0833940879,
-0.505872488,
0.924932003,
0.1525676548,
-0.474512428,
0.4336493611,
-1.0375066996,
-0.3834070861,
-0.201607123,
0.0280957259,
-0.3477732837,
0.328663826,
0.3988133967,
0.1811268479,
-0.2896132767,
-0.4711420834,
-0.3243687749,
-0.6284374595,
-0.1462856978,
-0.4278407395,
0.3980724216,
0.0545689985,
-0.354791671,
0.0423132665,
-0.9076836705,
-0.1523139775,
0.0046005542,
-0.668723464,
-0.7171255946,
-0.0374227539,
-0.1523255855,
-0.11383605,
0.2868688107,
-0.1829479337,
0.3347620666,
-0.7073709369,
0.3906986117,
0.8425113559,
-0.2109097838,
0.8523234129,
-0.4099909663,
0.6138154268,
-0.0891096443,
0.2208291292,
0.2240159214,
-0.616476953,
-1.043530941,
-0.5359064341,
0.6976501942,
0.5713711977,
-0.5437526703,
0.3635149002,
-0.1853996068,
-0.5507266521,
-0.6706422567,
0.639536202,
0.2169254571,
0.3810823262,
0.388882041,
0.073769398,
-0.4212086797,
-0.9264358878,
-0.1775554866,
-0.0450155549,
-0.0534267016,
0.1966464221,
0.4491513968,
-0.3684008121,
0.8966030478,
-0.3271498084,
-0.2606344223,
-0.145451501,
0.2568961978,
0.5015544295,
0.4464994371,
0.9816021323,
-0.5796046257,
-0.6861550212,
0.1672647744,
-0.2983464301,
-0.0572655611,
0.2955993116,
-0.284599483,
0.1004692465,
0.2083677351,
-0.2375127077,
0.1889538467,
1.1339837313,
-0.2319623232,
0.1003394276,
-0.3171036541,
0.1070889235,
-0.9798567891,
0.071265921,
-0.227239728,
-0.3275732696,
-0.5614907742,
-0.1711890697,
-0.2309136838,
-0.1255684197,
-0.311088711,
0.5768774748,
-0.1827615201,
-0.0683636442,
-0.3286256492,
0.0381320007,
0.0350740254,
0.6238619089,
-0.2755270898,
1.0337461233,
0.3779174387,
-0.8453105092,
0.0091162818,
0.2880897224,
-0.1458019763,
0.6197324395,
-0.3800290227,
0.3137822151,
-0.0887165442,
-0.2268588543,
-0.7169870138,
-0.146449104,
0.1512218118,
-0.0255241189,
0.0633523315,
-0.4147854447,
-0.3162686229,
-0.0601041652,
-0.4909152687,
0.5724759698,
0.759041369,
-0.6135824323,
0.7197339535,
0.2046404332,
-0.3781327009,
-0.3035170138,
-0.6242516637,
-0.2289661318,
-0.6311305165,
-0.4440892935,
0.6351602077,
-0.4585226178,
-0.3916454017,
-0.0915533006,
-0.0873353854,
-0.0111104334,
0.3028432727,
0.1358858943,
-0.0946655422,
-0.5641282201,
0.0310814735,
0.583204031,
-0.004873062,
-0.4931219816,
-0.0652887821,
0.4551014304,
-0.3105822504,
-0.1330346316,
-0.3462456167,
0.1662180275,
0.8235901594,
0.0846081749,
0.9397055507,
0.5947850347,
-0.3486859798,
-0.4515359104,
-0.2999267578,
-0.1760448366,
-0.4786361158,
0.0257012844,
-0.3991043568,
-0.893776238,
0.5306571722,
-0.1467576921,
0.1720678657,
0.6388484836,
0.3709414303,
-0.4240253866,
0.9112965465,
0.9599190354,
-0.3162699938,
0.5619199276,
-0.0692553446,
0.0362245366,
-0.7020167112,
0.2502824068,
-0.6851760149,
-0.7848960161,
-0.5896773338,
-0.4110635519,
0.4880191088,
0.3991259634,
-0.1437123269,
0.3918540776,
-0.3846945465,
0.3214000165,
0.6346247792,
0.0570422709,
0.5702694654,
0.0737968683,
0.1648633629,
-0.0011996689,
-0.9151098132,
-0.5041245818,
1.028319478,
0.1963419914,
0.8631762266,
0.3226736784,
0.7335151434,
0.5901091695,
0.37751019,
-0.8232806921,
0.4461092949,
-0.7400007248,
-0.3294677436,
-0.5079999566,
-0.2573797405,
-0.9721984863,
0.2949379683,
-0.4399677515,
-0.691139102,
0.4498546422,
0.5146887302,
-0.8744695783,
0.2181593776,
-0.7688596249,
0.8395154476,
-0.1321876645,
0.0338993408,
-0.3838186264,
-0.3783797026,
0.2699908316,
-0.4916437566,
0.3557194173,
-0.2636666,
-0.0861773267,
1.0362585783,
-0.1917883158,
0.8582634926,
-0.2582563758,
0.0725497752,
-0.0641621798,
-0.0668064654,
0.6125559807,
0.1988243312,
-0.4302656353,
-0.2095509917,
0.422850579,
-0.5114553571,
-0.6471892595,
0.7491759658,
-1.0245552063,
-0.5284257531,
-0.0334422253,
-0.5303319693,
-0.4189934134,
0.0268950928,
0.1713402718,
0.1130138114,
-0.2421214581,
0.2056915164,
0.8525632024,
-0.1203053594,
0.4714747667,
0.3327179849,
-0.2908689678,
-0.3434627652,
0.8095689416,
-0.0736343712,
0.2342947274,
0.6531860232,
0.2219031304,
0.3257601261,
-0.7427831888,
-0.4776419997,
0.1622331887,
-0.4683707654,
-0.1535206437,
-0.3403744996,
-0.1003502831,
-0.1649762392,
-0.1727650762,
-0.3407564461,
-0.4777222872,
-0.5738972425,
0.3233330548,
0.5533879995,
0.4833334088,
0.0212871097,
0.8307507634,
-0.6342055798,
0.4882723093,
0.8572425246,
0.0611818358,
-0.3457618356,
-0.9243545532,
-0.3129913509,
-0.1199474335,
0.0567328148,
-0.667435348,
0.2090446949,
0.6017920375,
0.5802653432,
0.4431220591,
0.0305921398,
0.7689655423,
-0.2747212648,
0.3371187449,
-0.1706905067,
-0.8216552734,
0.6843374372,
-0.4064871967,
0.2311587185,
0.9819354415,
-0.1396689117,
-0.0085980324,
-0.0980324373,
-0.2567324936,
-0.5112619996,
0.5555686355,
0.2119921893,
0.1367788464,
0.4075651169,
0.3741099238,
0.3490633667,
0.2948015034,
-0.6091016531,
-0.1266071051,
0.1681213677,
-0.4062350988,
-0.2644500136,
-0.2679168284,
-0.3627794683,
-0.5045176148,
0.612323463,
-0.4205306172,
0.3619247079,
-0.1315456182,
-0.3738642335,
-0.2137974501,
0.4319984317,
0.6938892007,
0.425552398,
-0.5024160147,
0.2281268239,
0.8021997213,
-0.344433099,
0.0296653714,
0.2384664267,
-0.2043870687,
-0.0625613108,
0.1137951314,
0.7479016781,
0.5457717776,
-0.503034234,
0.1996784508,
0.0013491218,
-0.118961595,
-0.0905015245,
0.4548870921,
-0.0221128426,
0.3395979702,
0.2157967389,
0.5901443958,
-0.0382016599,
-0.5618693829,
-0.1597822756,
0.305569768,
-0.1447452456,
-0.4353109002,
0.4988742173,
0.2864034474,
-0.3636306524,
0.103472881,
-0.0351831466,
-0.0005140367,
0.4826249182,
0.4258788526,
0.5061656237,
-0.2270551026,
0.1791596562,
-0.0091920346,
0.4647320807,
-0.0045176772,
0.0587686822,
-0.104473561,
-0.6274152398,
-0.3986341059,
-1.0767872334,
-0.4429785907,
0.1359992921,
-0.5978543162,
0.2878348827,
-0.7287416458,
-0.2641303837,
-0.0802699253,
-0.1612692624,
-0.6764914393,
0.1029481739,
0.1308934838,
1.09851408,
-0.9731732011,
1.0206180811,
0.7641742826,
-0.0338514,
-0.385356456,
0.0835351497,
-0.2541232109,
-0.8232189417,
0.2889818251,
-0.2558068335,
-0.2393576503,
0.2717200816,
-0.1953073293,
-0.9517105818,
1.280788064,
0.7139469981,
-0.6836280227,
-0.3662450016,
-0.0636196509,
0.5300459862,
-0.3523586392,
-0.1973674595,
0.8158584237,
0.6179922223,
-0.3193691969,
-0.9674504995,
-0.2853226364,
-0.1821390092,
0.062014237,
0.0887192711,
-0.6124989986,
0.8541277051,
0.1757299453,
0.1787354797,
0.4549365044,
0.3966261446,
0.3736329675,
0.3761459589,
0.7662872672,
0.5675731897,
0.8658964038,
0.0954237953,
0.6952992678,
-0.1606689692,
0.1510977149,
0.9926809072,
0.0756706297,
1.0526558161,
0.6087422371,
-0.3043714762,
0.7819584608,
0.5095958114,
0.1438954622,
0.8338335156,
-0.1275027245,
-0.283428371,
-0.3462173343,
0.2062749416,
-0.2269799411,
0.4098361433,
0.4504186213,
-0.4688820839,
-0.0256839264,
0.2368222922,
-0.1339306086,
0.0906827226,
-0.6972709894,
0.7568665743,
0.188009873,
-0.4601446688,
0.441383481,
0.0219156779,
0.9652154446,
-0.4227927625,
0.1403576583,
-0.2206538469,
0.2486244887,
-0.1922981739,
-0.1160338446,
0.2280338109,
-0.0362631865,
-0.5216008425,
0.0153176803,
0.8399559259,
-0.0983178169,
-0.5863994956,
0.4238344431,
0.6027340293,
-0.0054071099,
-0.0907892659,
-0.7039880157,
-0.0308671705,
-0.2929980159,
-0.2114583552,
0.6568598747,
0.0781176239,
0.1057401225,
0.3344958425,
0.5758679509,
0.1581255198,
0.148330465,
0.0573258102,
0.774605453,
-0.4418498278,
-0.2758184373,
-0.743588686,
0.3213078082,
0.0938175097,
-0.2432183176,
0.4415676892,
0.3158253431,
0.5242173672,
-0.170936957,
0.733648181,
0.0635577813,
0.5565545559,
-0.7255622149,
0.658842802,
-0.6799853444,
0.2808413804,
-0.1837527454,
-1.1495789289,
-0.3057863116,
0.5574349761,
-0.5539002419,
0.0255202111,
0.5565843582,
0.6549392343,
-0.3981221914,
-0.1905547827,
0.6392456889,
0.2022545338,
-0.0828646794,
0.5578046441,
0.607542038,
-0.3920492232,
0.7220515013,
-0.2354066074,
-0.2032911032,
-0.4710048139,
-0.6720997691,
-1.0696018934,
-0.1754005998,
-0.1633154899,
0.103292793,
0.2975685298,
0.8400204778,
0.9667483568,
-1.0225124359,
-0.0299748406,
-0.0956081823,
0.1786992699,
-0.2950885892,
-0.1580045968,
0.2181029618,
-0.1926832348,
-0.9404526949,
0.7443173528,
0.5390070677,
0.032034304,
0.018193515,
-0.1595954895,
0.0500719398,
0.229807809,
0.6674295068,
0.4782123268,
-0.6261879206,
-0.3022332191,
-0.0595212877,
0.0193934441,
0.1724698097,
0.4271132052,
-0.6816985011,
0.0430704951,
0.373983711,
0.5849233866,
0.7053857446,
-0.0492544584,
0.4497485459,
-0.5002499223,
0.1711805463,
0.1716745645,
0.3626189232,
0.0550322607,
-0.0773790106,
0.3425294757,
0.1584342867,
-0.509883225,
-0.7575593591,
0.1065265164,
-1.2559279203,
-0.1403794289,
0.8754295111,
0.0737745315,
-0.1842069626,
0.0283307359,
-0.2852202356,
0.0436943099,
-0.3069855273,
0.8820623159,
0.2198680192,
-0.241787672,
-0.4031822085,
-0.5662165284,
0.6670202613,
0.6819607019,
-1.1579214334,
-0.3892213702,
-0.0972336829,
0.4317843318,
0.1130759791,
0.678342104,
0.2566798329,
0.2161755562,
-0.3342289925,
-0.3881288767,
0.3204915524,
-0.3694007695,
-0.3912549019,
0.3429302871,
0.69514364,
-0.1842541695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17262v1
|
Speak Out of Turn: Safety Vulnerability of Large Language Models in Multi-turn Dialogue
| 2024-02-27T07:11:59 | 2024-02-27T07:11:59 |
Zhenhong Zhou, Jiuyang Xiang, Haopeng Chen, Quan Liu, Zherui Li, Sen Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to generate illegal or
unethical responses, particularly when subjected to "jailbreak." Research on
jailbreak has highlighted the safety issues of LLMs. However, prior studies
have predominantly focused on single-turn dialogue, ignoring the potential
complexities and risks presented by multi-turn dialogue, a crucial mode through
which humans derive information from LLMs. In this paper, we argue that humans
could exploit multi-turn dialogue to induce LLMs into generating harmful
information. LLMs may not intend to reject cautionary or borderline unsafe
queries, even if each turn is closely served for one malicious purpose in a
multi-turn dialogue. Therefore, by decomposing an unsafe query into several
sub-queries for multi-turn dialogue, we induced LLMs to answer harmful
sub-questions incrementally, culminating in an overall harmful response. Our
experiments, conducted across a wide range of LLMs, indicate current
inadequacies in the safety mechanisms of LLMs in multi-turn dialogue. Our
findings expose vulnerabilities of LLMs in complex scenarios involving
multi-turn dialogue, presenting new challenges for the safety of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2763804197,
-0.8950536847,
0.7855856419,
-0.0015468022,
-0.2642411292,
0.2417651713,
-0.1275501847,
-0.6547967792,
-0.0476297215,
1.1061782837,
-0.6582735777,
-0.2138437331,
-0.5284599662,
-0.2422486395,
-0.5842035413,
0.9773887396,
0.4582111537,
0.0235886071,
-0.1456100345,
-0.1442130208,
-0.3327246606,
-0.9233817458,
-0.599103272,
-0.1767334938,
0.4555084407,
0.6117584109,
0.7579832673,
-0.187613979,
0.4259726107,
0.3820936978,
0.1295700818,
-0.0469424501,
-0.7070159316,
0.5467115641,
-0.0607602112,
-0.6887875199,
-0.4357590973,
0.0279187784,
0.328561902,
0.5757939816,
-0.309417218,
-0.0394711457,
-0.0022792604,
0.7979332805,
-0.3148600459,
-0.1820114255,
-1.0422954559,
-0.2146448344,
-0.2972791493,
-0.1663888246,
-0.8326923847,
-0.4221083522,
0.1092409715,
-0.0833433568,
0.0371564776,
0.2086562812,
0.3146029413,
0.2363962531,
-0.2258470207,
-0.3715658188,
-0.9109060168,
0.4701294005,
-0.925665915,
0.1923495382,
0.3435676098,
0.2307978421,
-0.518376112,
-0.3621556461,
-0.8522231579,
-0.3782677352,
0.0001274591,
-0.1185586452,
-0.2473535985,
0.0387931392,
0.2323150933,
0.0567362793,
-0.4670301676,
0.2627644241,
-0.3059670925,
-0.0566843413,
0.7485896945,
0.4135027528,
0.5662429929,
-0.0734954923,
-0.3787496388,
-0.3156683445,
-1.2547399998,
0.0308243949,
0.7105621099,
0.5269327164,
-0.0756946579,
0.5705193877,
0.2881577015,
0.4757096469,
-0.047136765,
-0.2419640422,
0.0160884056,
-0.272765547,
-0.0897347257,
0.2060797513,
1.2354191542,
0.6270484328,
0.2842191756,
-0.2029380947,
0.1596496105,
-0.3231385648,
0.487588793,
-0.6437425613,
0.0821968317,
0.4512970746,
-0.2682602406,
-0.4773128033,
0.1186303645,
-1.0810011625,
-0.8343589902,
0.4306731224,
0.3812776804,
-0.3150916398,
-0.3709037304,
0.167434141,
0.1867111623,
0.3047066927,
-0.0471718609,
-0.7433879375,
0.3587704897,
0.4143643379,
0.6741907001,
-0.0866447315,
-0.2459645718,
-0.5551333427,
0.0695581213,
-0.2573823035,
0.4250202477,
-0.2347063571,
-0.9547247291,
0.0688574687,
0.1852591783,
0.1159024015,
-0.6223558187,
0.4670820832,
-0.4860552847,
-0.1188799292,
-0.1922605038,
0.1808677614,
-0.1011568904,
0.0109277731,
-0.5684473515,
0.6285327077,
-0.3865174949,
-0.8863902688,
0.093396619,
-0.6071202159,
-0.7526387572,
-0.2260177135,
-0.1376909167,
-0.5287747979,
0.1110341027,
0.084875159,
0.2069743425,
-0.2627548277,
0.2560905516,
-0.494117707,
0.106819503,
0.8420386314,
-0.7072615027,
0.9120208621,
0.0300694946,
-0.538333118,
0.1654554754,
-0.4232369065,
-0.1026731133,
0.2862353623,
-0.2719736993,
-0.5543245673,
0.1285311878,
-0.3240432441,
0.4316675961,
-0.1581299156,
-0.7941501141,
0.0544394851,
-0.6305764914,
0.4583383203,
0.6079370975,
0.1727649271,
0.4496852458,
-0.3062285185,
0.3080939949,
0.3073375225,
0.4434440136,
-0.3124492764,
-0.6976138353,
-0.7831537724,
0.0808970034,
-0.378562957,
0.6831759214,
-0.6121643186,
0.1114983857,
0.0427876189,
-0.5864627957,
-0.4066157043,
-0.1152384132,
0.5017959476,
0.3022627234,
0.3454385102,
-0.011061308,
-0.3910579681,
-0.7829527259,
-0.4811131656,
-0.4629863203,
0.2333554029,
0.3786038458,
0.2840624452,
-0.2733440697,
0.8114679456,
-0.4617661238,
-0.0077755027,
-0.5070621967,
0.2450862676,
0.0159528777,
0.426651299,
0.3344978988,
-0.680934608,
-0.227946803,
-0.2547076941,
-0.661449194,
0.050022874,
-0.3531963825,
-0.1344821304,
0.3221687675,
0.7776014209,
-0.8562583327,
0.5496179461,
0.564427793,
-0.1662845612,
0.4909058809,
-0.1264143288,
-0.0581586696,
-1.0886602402,
-0.4070085287,
-0.345100373,
-0.0356100872,
-0.8638392091,
-0.0714022368,
-0.106394738,
-0.2386184186,
-0.5359062552,
0.070814684,
-0.4881878793,
-0.0175051652,
-0.2073291242,
0.2573278844,
-0.0761568472,
0.1299568415,
-0.075089924,
0.6366032958,
0.5294355154,
-0.6077002287,
0.3981302083,
0.261903137,
-0.3793880641,
0.1811986566,
-0.6124283671,
0.5031952858,
-0.1423653215,
0.1865651459,
-1.0420249701,
-0.3375785351,
0.288600266,
-0.3696942329,
0.4261085987,
-0.1732281893,
-0.4175105989,
-0.2863860428,
-0.3840100765,
0.2500529289,
0.3571062684,
-0.4872455895,
0.4816856682,
0.839230001,
-0.6081047058,
-0.3305241466,
-0.8595442772,
0.3539406359,
-0.4516673684,
-0.7932059169,
-0.1238882616,
-0.0114366431,
-0.6475714445,
-0.4143278301,
0.0876521692,
0.1870134473,
0.0714703128,
0.6690899134,
0.2845906913,
0.2336429805,
0.0774694383,
0.0879142508,
0.0102195116,
0.5022357702,
0.0643181652,
0.6438343525,
-0.1727927029,
-0.8421985507,
-0.0598701909,
0.9606348872,
1.2282547951,
-0.160438627,
0.8459045887,
-0.0956687629,
-0.0546633862,
0.0171421971,
-0.5593983531,
-0.4550976753,
-0.5442607999,
0.4273510873,
0.0380134732,
-0.8410652876,
0.4390842021,
-0.1684759408,
0.157628864,
-0.048400484,
0.6843630075,
-0.1424182355,
1.122679472,
0.693857789,
-0.0841236487,
0.2004175037,
-0.0123088937,
0.5845281482,
-0.6735399365,
-0.6132000089,
-0.7387794256,
0.0105829714,
-0.8678803444,
-0.483435303,
0.8029276133,
-0.200414598,
-0.1662145853,
0.2463035434,
-0.2589022815,
0.2664765418,
0.4665301442,
0.157402575,
0.4680777788,
-0.2789232731,
-0.1365202367,
-0.0556513965,
-0.5828140378,
-0.48870489,
1.013047576,
0.368956387,
1.3977272511,
0.3415071964,
0.7671973109,
-0.2053761333,
0.34921211,
-0.7507194281,
0.6033679843,
0.2668378055,
-0.9315949082,
-0.6000715494,
-0.1566162109,
-0.8692403436,
0.3390099406,
-0.2645373344,
-0.9172102213,
0.1834996492,
0.0533252321,
-0.40516752,
0.4454023242,
-0.8747870922,
0.5927504301,
-0.6798284054,
-0.2050279826,
-0.1409374177,
-1.0044660568,
0.6470150948,
-0.1529915482,
0.7867892981,
0.0038727988,
0.4986338317,
0.5806965828,
-0.5053161979,
1.3577244282,
-0.1141938046,
-0.287594676,
0.5159099102,
0.2107150108,
0.7793099284,
0.3737388551,
0.0223605633,
0.0421134047,
-0.1844807565,
0.0391473435,
-0.3979986608,
0.7215328217,
-0.7431461811,
-0.948517561,
-0.4716050923,
-0.4160037339,
-0.5161756277,
0.0260497164,
0.5141332746,
0.2779401243,
-0.191392988,
-0.0444929861,
0.7122464776,
-0.5178205967,
0.721940577,
0.5662971735,
-0.3742284477,
-0.1912892759,
0.7136659622,
-0.1520309448,
0.679582417,
-0.1077995896,
0.2702016234,
-0.4379061759,
-0.6535822749,
-0.387406677,
0.1525612772,
-0.5630140901,
-0.2433640957,
-0.7052970529,
-0.1094603762,
-0.3141750097,
0.191588372,
-0.4774722159,
-0.0799389407,
-0.0023583509,
-0.3435863853,
0.3462072313,
0.7821074128,
-0.2177413553,
0.216271475,
-1.2856837511,
0.3093080223,
0.520273447,
0.0343570635,
-0.0951489806,
-0.429671675,
0.0133983213,
0.0935775563,
-0.3473458588,
-1.1156522036,
0.3421258032,
-0.0155386208,
0.6371728778,
0.4427636564,
0.5739902258,
0.3671784401,
-0.7492566109,
0.7026517987,
0.4467991292,
-0.7637141943,
0.5058338642,
-0.3428459167,
0.1505335718,
0.5267714858,
0.5257667303,
-0.6011827588,
-0.8943044543,
-0.4874678254,
-1.2133345604,
0.5553945303,
-0.002519029,
0.547883749,
-0.1826753616,
0.0305747185,
0.2903048098,
0.1829499751,
-0.8376142979,
-0.2821623981,
-0.2507398129,
0.4346852601,
0.0486658253,
-0.5965947509,
-0.48016873,
-0.0827964172,
0.4411940873,
0.0632545128,
0.1563869715,
0.1809822321,
-0.1278618872,
-0.3142983019,
0.6641321778,
0.7142528296,
0.2974078059,
-0.0351557471,
0.3156431615,
0.166030243,
-0.6157874465,
0.2158756703,
-0.3569138646,
-0.0429552384,
-0.2511276901,
0.4213385284,
0.7350137234,
0.2071717829,
-0.7015933394,
0.2978225946,
-0.1621975452,
0.0775766894,
-0.2639701068,
-0.026809115,
0.1907171905,
0.2267928421,
0.3663182259,
0.1314025074,
-0.0326428302,
-1.0725837946,
0.0972441211,
0.6544286609,
-0.3024392426,
-0.3206766546,
0.4185447991,
0.4007350206,
-0.4144971669,
0.6384064555,
0.0695784986,
-0.5808458924,
0.0429733954,
0.6340767741,
0.9823456407,
-0.3409025073,
0.2270997316,
0.1835493892,
0.7005787492,
0.1494110674,
0.2391318679,
0.3994549215,
-0.8936964869,
-0.5404671431,
-0.4301488698,
-0.6638829112,
0.3449507952,
-0.6996570826,
-0.2011225969,
-0.3418404758,
-0.4353646338,
-0.3077549636,
-0.7606183887,
-0.0543534718,
-0.1224098057,
0.2265115976,
0.5615146756,
-0.771995604,
0.705583334,
0.395830065,
-0.1502889246,
-0.566732645,
0.2935642004,
0.1280511171,
-0.5778070688,
0.512657702,
0.0905921012,
-0.6353979111,
-0.3687031269,
-0.8769689202,
-0.5729768872,
0.5507485867,
0.4711317718,
-0.723543644,
0.0844987631,
0.6009446383,
0.2387334704,
-0.2542316616,
-0.0732104182,
0.7785528898,
0.394601047,
0.0919844359,
-1.1243780851,
0.2280257195,
0.1059639826,
-0.2277797908,
0.2692195177,
-0.6533165574,
0.7969616652,
-0.869202733,
-0.1481797993,
-0.0879926905,
0.1895814091,
0.1532963812,
0.2005262226,
0.5741758943,
0.3763864934,
0.5776053667,
-0.1337435544,
1.0112577677,
0.0238644667,
-0.0374212302,
1.2182025909,
-0.4988002777,
0.7942214608,
0.6888210773,
-0.1183344722,
0.3468642235,
0.0567599051,
0.6324887872,
0.6490449309,
0.376191169,
-0.514387846,
-0.4788615108,
0.3998434246,
-0.2582190037,
0.6932810545,
0.6614390612,
-0.0245387759,
-0.1632547826,
0.2284515202,
0.3588172495,
0.0139576131,
0.0201754086,
0.9608786106,
0.3352833688,
-0.5749493837,
0.4086449146,
-0.0801521689,
0.5147883296,
-0.3636710048,
0.131940335,
-0.2487810403,
0.1146531552,
-0.1807125062,
-0.7526091933,
0.5344350338,
-0.0114362612,
0.0508796386,
0.0020173418,
0.6067479253,
-0.2893525064,
-0.2532958984,
0.475864172,
0.5036421418,
0.1553193927,
-0.2780173719,
-0.4492488801,
0.2554933429,
-0.0655965433,
-0.207013905,
0.6706078649,
0.385818094,
-0.1999587119,
0.9116027951,
0.8949545026,
-0.087780796,
0.4552174509,
0.1175860539,
1.2191272974,
-0.7743569613,
-0.1843026578,
-1.1240385771,
0.597933948,
-0.1786101907,
-0.0278114732,
0.6782102585,
0.2348320484,
0.6049146056,
0.0750012323,
1.1170341969,
0.0294767395,
0.4541043639,
-0.5598169565,
1.136977911,
-0.1289055198,
0.4082728326,
-0.4339275658,
-0.5448336005,
-0.0001862983,
0.2880424559,
-0.3407248855,
-0.1085841954,
0.7430750728,
0.8222492933,
0.510923624,
0.0604826584,
0.5016184449,
0.5107485652,
0.5399529338,
0.364194572,
1.1087340117,
-0.0674634352,
1.002892375,
-0.1152331829,
-0.2488449514,
-0.353369385,
-0.8309844732,
-1.1306605339,
-0.5589190125,
-0.0896792188,
-0.5061984658,
-0.0998434424,
0.5370973945,
0.5749948621,
-0.8403071761,
-0.3064479828,
0.0547179915,
0.2766014338,
0.2079278231,
-0.2057178915,
-0.0935156569,
-0.1903516501,
-0.5834384561,
0.8954487443,
0.5888158083,
0.174540922,
-0.4709236324,
0.0325069129,
-0.1531170458,
0.1699740738,
0.7140702605,
0.458463639,
-0.6520416141,
-0.4508345127,
-0.0209260248,
-0.0055565359,
-0.0635672212,
1.1225972176,
-0.4753324986,
0.4835665822,
0.2899143994,
0.2638424933,
0.5303785205,
-0.130476445,
0.7728001475,
-0.5919135809,
0.3466864228,
0.3027832806,
0.2508580983,
0.4309172034,
-0.4406736791,
-0.0060091484,
-0.0253252909,
-0.529407084,
-0.9699969292,
0.7139981389,
-0.8359029889,
-0.1000945419,
1.2273933887,
-0.1484348774,
-0.150958553,
-0.5799602866,
-0.4108152688,
0.0935192481,
-0.4285931587,
0.7638890743,
0.5064834952,
-0.4237985313,
-0.1268809587,
-0.6182079911,
0.564083159,
-0.003910094,
-0.9893051982,
0.5489119291,
0.1947413832,
0.2719429731,
0.3869563639,
0.6198083758,
-0.6075899005,
-0.0323356539,
0.0083051436,
-0.067663379,
0.04161264,
-0.3563726246,
0.0712713301,
0.2237295955,
0.4074642658,
-0.166614756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17256v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17256v2
|
Beyond the Known: Investigating LLMs Performance on Out-of-Domain Intent Detection
| 2024-02-27T07:02:10 | 2024-03-04T06:04:32 |
Pei Wang, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Xiaoshuai Song, Yutao Mou, Jingang Wang, Yunsen Xian, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Out-of-domain (OOD) intent detection aims to examine whether the user's query
falls outside the predefined domain of the system, which is crucial for the
proper functioning of task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems. Previous methods
address it by fine-tuning discriminative models. Recently, some studies have
been exploring the application of large language models (LLMs) represented by
ChatGPT to various downstream tasks, but it is still unclear for their ability
on OOD detection task.This paper conducts a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs
under various experimental settings, and then outline the strengths and
weaknesses of LLMs. We find that LLMs exhibit strong zero-shot and few-shot
capabilities, but is still at a disadvantage compared to models fine-tuned with
full resource. More deeply, through a series of additional analysis
experiments, we discuss and summarize the challenges faced by LLMs and provide
guidance for future work including injecting domain knowledge, strengthening
knowledge transfer from IND(In-domain) to OOD, and understanding long
instructions.
|
[
-0.5087978244,
-0.8650768399,
0.8899050355,
-0.3951196373,
-0.1644471139,
0.0352107137,
-0.2798453569,
-0.585131526,
-0.4109889865,
0.8433149457,
-0.6290115714,
-0.432795167,
-0.7331360579,
-0.1233258992,
-0.3612279594,
0.7896033525,
-0.1723368615,
-0.1892241091,
-0.22637932,
-0.0499245971,
-0.704850018,
-0.5503515601,
-0.7872437835,
-0.2401988357,
0.0404183269,
0.5198925734,
0.3219831884,
-0.0799886361,
0.6583377123,
0.2107912451,
-0.0961783305,
0.4286890626,
-0.9690220356,
0.2256372273,
-0.1347471476,
-0.6333128214,
-0.4889292717,
-0.117954284,
0.5886182189,
0.6338386536,
0.0471040569,
-0.0636704117,
0.0510721989,
0.5972561836,
-0.5400217175,
0.2059579343,
-0.8194923997,
-0.153025493,
-0.3389661312,
-0.3730035126,
-0.7018824816,
-0.1262505054,
0.4208016992,
-0.3294194639,
0.0912696347,
0.3198243082,
0.5730520487,
0.1503679305,
-0.5776739717,
-0.6688525677,
-0.7707923651,
0.9352273941,
-0.8026686907,
0.3897644579,
0.4915904701,
0.3616272211,
-0.8196287751,
-0.3890993595,
-0.5143072605,
-0.3544170558,
0.0304111689,
-0.0620520487,
-0.2996408343,
0.1989296079,
0.1631940156,
0.3902224004,
-0.5289697051,
0.1881290227,
-0.2479541153,
0.1618752331,
0.6141428947,
0.2003786266,
0.352434516,
0.1889639944,
-0.4005815089,
0.4149864912,
-0.9387257695,
0.0963704214,
0.2009694725,
0.2555424571,
0.1767933965,
0.8276436925,
-0.1512192637,
0.8324075937,
0.1118830815,
-0.113350369,
-0.2937656939,
-0.2323587388,
-0.2387580425,
-0.0376000106,
0.5937905312,
0.2560220659,
0.2194159925,
-0.2373285443,
-0.3841463327,
-0.27214095,
0.1401776224,
-0.7831920981,
0.1027528644,
0.4158656895,
-0.4998652041,
0.2626607418,
-0.3269351423,
-0.1841509789,
-0.572178483,
-0.1493794918,
0.4742385447,
-0.642472446,
-0.3486281931,
0.4155744612,
-0.1049258113,
0.1890007854,
0.3222868145,
-0.6720320582,
0.3022081852,
0.892395556,
0.8402118087,
-0.5315485001,
-0.0781472251,
-0.4824717939,
0.0156889725,
-0.3050787449,
0.7905700803,
-0.5643150806,
-0.5877590775,
-0.0009269872,
-0.0969556347,
-0.4264237285,
-0.7239845395,
0.5094101429,
-0.8299615383,
0.0643093064,
-0.1786931157,
-0.9996417761,
-0.3343318999,
0.2899520993,
-0.3870437443,
0.8915128708,
0.1607131213,
-0.4250271916,
0.4573557079,
-1.0312213898,
-0.2833135128,
0.1096874475,
-0.0949238688,
-0.0809083357,
0.4723166823,
-0.1565654278,
0.4826399088,
-0.3234760165,
0.1266285777,
-0.2507553697,
-0.4924375713,
0.3627043962,
-0.4275438786,
0.5814955831,
0.1071521863,
-0.3386417031,
-0.0046043359,
-0.5451577306,
-0.0914484039,
0.1422683448,
-0.2471624464,
-0.4232957959,
0.0931804627,
-0.5271047354,
0.1520281881,
0.0764896423,
-0.7749580145,
0.3251438141,
-0.4186913073,
0.6075051427,
0.4965347946,
-0.0494633131,
0.38466236,
-0.2761829197,
0.6065818071,
-0.0994084105,
0.3335534334,
-0.2646375,
-0.8395344019,
-0.7059423327,
-0.3630295992,
-0.0480070412,
0.2709775269,
-0.8194556832,
0.1862077415,
-0.1746679693,
-0.2155677974,
-0.1372930259,
0.1039808244,
0.4311894774,
0.25606215,
0.0735639036,
-0.5072919726,
-0.2062865496,
-0.3598892987,
-0.2053216398,
-0.2759420276,
0.2440727949,
0.5976312757,
0.5685833693,
-0.2588078976,
1.1441617012,
-0.5410458446,
-0.662732482,
-0.4991986454,
0.0664048642,
0.1934561878,
-0.0511106141,
0.3175496757,
-0.615147233,
-0.575296998,
0.2190177441,
-0.601162374,
-0.0343444385,
0.1816641688,
0.0608674772,
0.4317188263,
0.713521421,
-0.8935860395,
0.556786716,
0.5214409828,
-0.1745491475,
0.5239064693,
-0.1963727772,
0.0526522547,
-0.4909032881,
-0.1588988304,
-0.1216322705,
-0.1495364904,
-0.8611431718,
-0.0631802678,
-0.0329877809,
-0.171301946,
-0.7291263938,
0.6039178371,
-0.6014949679,
-0.2125584036,
-0.520203948,
0.3267438114,
0.066298537,
0.4442724288,
0.2239683419,
0.8667905331,
0.439787358,
-0.729793191,
0.3344610929,
0.1154044867,
-0.5793549418,
0.6220582128,
-0.4357841909,
0.2214304805,
-0.0815370679,
0.3663316369,
-1.4761046171,
-0.2166154683,
0.2132095397,
-0.4291029871,
0.2804830372,
-0.622475028,
-0.4884762466,
-0.2104092389,
-0.2742094696,
0.7162675858,
0.3893959224,
-0.6276266575,
0.5983623266,
0.4313536882,
-0.0954173282,
-0.2602656186,
-0.4886626899,
-0.0197518282,
-0.3938549161,
-0.7308017612,
0.2156281173,
0.1188437939,
-0.3133175969,
-0.2630565166,
0.0228259061,
-0.1931371093,
-0.0979558229,
0.3341260552,
0.0813577771,
-0.4098244011,
0.2022297829,
-0.1450458914,
0.1730843335,
0.1308478117,
-0.2896529734,
0.7029651403,
0.0762295648,
-0.7905026078,
-0.4983945191,
0.2345728725,
0.596971333,
-0.1185531318,
0.5621204376,
0.2708423138,
0.0296285301,
-0.3728762865,
-0.5071667433,
-0.1530414373,
-0.4808242023,
0.3579267859,
-0.2682431042,
-0.797532618,
0.3956566155,
-0.2945693135,
-0.0088313939,
0.0412290506,
0.4555162191,
0.0328175053,
1.0009967089,
0.6735215187,
0.1228545234,
0.5734081268,
-0.3530986309,
0.531088233,
-1.070345521,
-0.1729305834,
-0.2501562536,
0.0678519681,
-0.4048021734,
-0.5296846628,
0.4566142559,
0.0494835004,
0.1425465345,
0.2759611011,
-0.1295071691,
0.3992893398,
0.3570415974,
0.0223816372,
0.5435757637,
-0.2581318617,
0.2466528714,
0.3436865211,
-0.6903932095,
-0.5441846251,
1.3146823645,
0.4869420528,
0.8893660903,
0.2579586804,
0.3839892447,
0.2575235963,
0.073729977,
-1.1649650335,
0.6379936337,
-0.199779138,
-0.8801932931,
-0.5009158254,
-0.2364169806,
-0.9883167744,
0.2909010351,
0.3289087713,
-0.8775931597,
0.1864813417,
0.032373596,
-0.6639750004,
0.3924785256,
-0.9818058014,
0.6596042514,
-0.348580271,
-0.1061956212,
-0.0017933957,
-0.2621048391,
0.5046903491,
-0.0661122203,
0.0875294656,
-0.4241623878,
0.1429917812,
0.4682398438,
-0.1786728501,
1.0201569796,
-0.1285094023,
-0.5673707128,
0.5641930103,
0.0079149166,
0.6310037971,
-0.0850494355,
0.0433745943,
0.2217064649,
-0.061758399,
-0.0946012735,
-0.4350212812,
0.6394631267,
-0.3188334703,
-0.6496505141,
-0.1741150916,
-0.660400629,
-0.4589059353,
0.1900395453,
0.2795374393,
0.6593444347,
-0.3019793034,
0.1319425255,
1.0734747648,
-0.4227794111,
0.4056272805,
0.7479991913,
-0.455771327,
0.3749061525,
0.8762633204,
0.0505374335,
0.6385156512,
0.3612263799,
0.0610883236,
-0.5506162047,
-0.9921652675,
-0.6295236349,
0.0465833694,
-0.6775670052,
-0.0429436713,
-0.4706866145,
-0.1434098631,
-0.330634445,
0.2526359856,
-0.3936103284,
-0.1182311326,
-0.214034453,
0.3213710487,
0.3140078187,
0.8211151958,
0.4666432142,
0.6021074057,
-0.6471803188,
0.3949438035,
0.1079655886,
0.4102721214,
-0.0584940724,
-0.9001272917,
-0.0843086541,
0.0752397329,
-0.3799854815,
-0.3235776126,
0.3217330575,
0.3099690676,
0.6106743813,
0.6040067673,
0.2593875527,
0.4441729784,
-0.3343516886,
0.7424163818,
-0.0999021679,
-0.7447959781,
0.4835949242,
-0.3445010483,
0.1436123401,
0.2126991749,
0.5211161971,
-0.2847591043,
-0.3864349127,
-0.1201713011,
-0.6822273135,
1.026504755,
0.230008781,
0.107156828,
-0.0093777226,
0.2803824246,
0.3356684148,
0.0256503336,
-0.3259663284,
-0.0594794415,
0.4614667296,
0.205944851,
-0.1203335747,
-0.3032698035,
-0.0692623183,
0.113044247,
0.5097717643,
-0.0654762909,
0.3316809237,
0.0778170899,
-0.3383547664,
-0.1369216591,
0.3394235075,
0.7370811105,
0.7814077735,
-0.4644593,
-0.1084996536,
0.0377430357,
-0.4275535345,
-0.0268554445,
-0.1678076535,
0.063630186,
-0.0569582991,
0.2840928733,
0.823112607,
-0.1143163368,
-1.0396455526,
0.6875296831,
-0.2416182458,
0.0892917365,
-0.1705376208,
0.2257966101,
-0.3707461059,
0.2662799656,
0.3281671405,
-0.1234159693,
0.3492589295,
-0.9302928448,
-0.1099928617,
0.8997132778,
-0.6099065542,
-0.3312127888,
0.1365896761,
0.2949667275,
-0.1610355824,
0.3125860989,
-0.3000633717,
-0.4714603424,
0.5724609494,
0.5109055042,
0.6327679157,
-0.026413478,
-0.0008754667,
-0.4066284001,
0.1688908637,
-0.1168724298,
0.2308996022,
-0.1137718707,
-0.7634119987,
-0.5163695216,
-0.1513384134,
-0.5536159873,
0.3763563335,
-0.4699265063,
0.2440824658,
-0.1177920252,
-0.3665218949,
0.0456229188,
-0.0535208397,
-0.51255548,
-0.0338838734,
0.1065867841,
0.6634088755,
-0.3413957059,
0.916511476,
0.5973424911,
0.0021361322,
-0.282743752,
0.0315700769,
0.0964332223,
-1.0563493967,
0.9304542542,
0.0581812337,
-0.4828666151,
-0.1228926629,
-0.263073355,
-0.65797019,
0.8494418263,
0.2954402268,
-0.5706003904,
0.0416633599,
0.4459915459,
0.4233192205,
-0.3160489202,
0.4251163602,
0.8833974004,
0.222070992,
0.1440015435,
-1.2207026482,
-0.1401071101,
0.2846596539,
-0.1425217688,
0.4256209731,
-0.4982714355,
0.8410979509,
-0.2750476301,
-0.3478269577,
0.233853817,
0.1660061479,
0.0856422484,
0.5885785222,
0.2910479307,
0.31494537,
0.4365076125,
-0.0158293582,
1.0296125412,
-0.1165149882,
0.2466194034,
1.0641638041,
-0.5991095901,
0.842122972,
0.493563056,
-0.0878240839,
0.0722921491,
0.3731494546,
0.4488701224,
0.5945116282,
0.2132752836,
-0.4609194398,
-0.0606945194,
-0.2721153498,
-0.3686665595,
0.6520676613,
0.6737789512,
-0.2538015842,
-0.210174948,
0.1799152344,
-0.1832743883,
-0.2453725934,
-0.4912467003,
0.9171656966,
0.2171399444,
-0.7962851524,
0.7502083182,
-0.1325216293,
0.7623620629,
-0.4878091514,
-0.0093566682,
-0.2552158535,
0.5196726918,
-0.1154568121,
-0.8902538419,
0.1878568232,
-0.0880832076,
0.0434180237,
-0.0635346547,
0.9320537448,
-0.1850502342,
0.0526572689,
0.4780534506,
0.4722216725,
0.3352751732,
-0.5703362226,
-0.3653033972,
0.2933360636,
-0.1030136198,
-0.1493975371,
0.4327291846,
0.9109945893,
-0.1764793545,
0.8578357697,
0.5804932714,
-0.0455808528,
0.1520220935,
0.0555007458,
0.8214632869,
-0.5037670135,
-0.0680653229,
-0.96482867,
0.0641399324,
0.064749226,
-0.3987905979,
0.925694108,
0.4481140077,
1.0221997499,
0.0021833219,
0.7706132531,
0.1463990808,
0.4154565036,
-0.6587071419,
0.4954612851,
-0.4444982409,
0.5108499527,
0.0385918021,
-0.6303857565,
-0.0351867229,
0.1610037237,
-0.6747649312,
0.0781830922,
0.5021960139,
0.7767128944,
-0.1494596303,
-0.0092085591,
0.754335463,
0.105462648,
0.4926193058,
0.7242847085,
1.5713735819,
-0.2942896485,
0.6467547417,
0.0269638635,
-0.2657799125,
-0.7238951921,
-0.7870832682,
-1.3216347694,
-0.4140768349,
-0.1280119866,
0.1050777957,
0.1413958967,
0.6198419929,
0.960352838,
-0.8258327842,
-0.3791409433,
-0.1948625892,
0.1141881719,
0.0722173303,
-0.163607493,
0.1420225799,
-0.5240330696,
-0.5944361091,
0.5692398548,
0.5444018841,
-0.0660572872,
-0.187144801,
-0.0597838536,
-0.0164506044,
0.3708717525,
1.1140861511,
0.3026539385,
-0.7424775958,
-0.1298797578,
0.0139925405,
0.0235577561,
0.0248986501,
1.1209603548,
-0.4183320403,
0.3878495693,
0.3626886308,
0.4129856527,
0.317769289,
0.0371540785,
0.5443199277,
-0.6377298832,
-0.1323279291,
0.2799138725,
0.3199982047,
0.1386119127,
-0.4086605906,
0.3198207021,
-0.1765524298,
-0.8250275254,
-0.9344960451,
0.3683049381,
-0.9149748683,
-0.3760222495,
1.4802330732,
-0.3780445755,
-0.0696982369,
-0.784404099,
-0.6124105453,
-0.0808747634,
-0.6216355562,
0.6984767318,
0.5536108017,
-0.6566234827,
0.0598456226,
-0.8622315526,
0.7144119143,
0.2354757339,
-0.7463401556,
0.3451558352,
0.3431548476,
0.1326248646,
0.0334624238,
0.7980642915,
-0.1419721991,
0.1063437313,
-0.3804357946,
-0.2370028645,
-0.0043758475,
-0.2090430409,
-0.2411720753,
-0.0037280265,
0.4845396578,
-0.4149253368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17237v1
|
Image-Text Matching with Multi-View Attention
| 2024-02-27T06:11:54 | 2024-02-27T06:11:54 |
Rui Cheng, Wanqing Cui
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Existing two-stream models for image-text matching show good performance
while ensuring retrieval speed and have received extensive attention from
industry and academia. These methods use a single representation to encode
image and text separately and get a matching score with cosine similarity or
the inner product of vectors. However, the performance of the two-stream model
is often sub-optimal. On the one hand, a single representation is challenging
to cover complex content comprehensively. On the other hand, in this framework
of lack of interaction, it is challenging to match multiple meanings which
leads to information being ignored. To address the problems mentioned above and
facilitate the performance of the two-stream model, we propose a multi-view
attention approach for two-stream image-text matching MVAM
(\textbf{M}ulti-\textbf{V}iew \textbf{A}ttention \textbf{M}odel). It first
learns multiple image and text representations by diverse attention heads with
different view codes. And then concatenate these representations into one for
matching. A diversity objective is also used to promote diversity between
attention heads. With this method, models are able to encode images and text
from different views and attend to more key points. So we can get
representations that contain more information. When doing retrieval tasks, the
matching scores between images and texts can be calculated from different
aspects, leading to better matching performance. Experiment results on MSCOCO
and Flickr30K show that our proposed model brings improvements over existing
models. Further case studies show that different attention heads can focus on
different contents and finally obtain a more comprehensive representation.
|
[
-0.3739330471,
-0.2382393032,
0.7242159247,
0.3105455637,
-0.7276166081,
-0.2193614244,
0.2536077797,
-0.6870230436,
0.3176283538,
0.6769818664,
-0.4317952096,
-0.0124100177,
-0.7663229108,
-0.0182690993,
-0.3481455743,
0.6067501903,
-0.288266331,
-0.0772077441,
-0.4348609447,
-0.5743964911,
-0.7462592721,
-0.1324500442,
-0.4164639711,
0.0364553407,
0.6636099815,
0.222241044,
0.3345476985,
0.8477940559,
1.1177071333,
0.2926153839,
0.0509851985,
0.5312347412,
-0.6066707969,
0.2846701145,
-0.2581866682,
-0.1116377637,
-0.24005647,
0.1992506981,
0.6675382853,
0.1149067879,
0.1984193325,
0.3207021654,
0.1711457968,
0.8577118516,
-0.9354885817,
0.0927170143,
-0.6930878758,
0.061074771,
-0.0090924287,
-0.5777878165,
-0.4823400974,
-0.1517249942,
0.2659187913,
-0.4587601721,
0.0493971929,
0.2825598419,
1.0027561188,
0.3254994154,
-0.5716683269,
-0.1030792668,
-0.4379669726,
0.8149006367,
-0.173582986,
0.3022094667,
0.1543381512,
0.2240453809,
0.3983664215,
-0.2541744709,
-0.3793061376,
0.4136808217,
-0.1333681047,
0.5573251843,
-0.0265950803,
-0.2219553739,
-0.1195783392,
0.4170737863,
-0.4478826821,
-0.2335866988,
-0.2220086604,
0.026067812,
0.3185931444,
0.0404039398,
0.1465244889,
-0.0007676793,
-0.8270920515,
-0.2378723174,
-0.2040306777,
-0.2001357973,
0.2973865867,
0.0747758895,
-0.0502041616,
0.6118724346,
-0.10346926,
0.5964904428,
-0.007707655,
-0.1865542382,
0.2643556297,
-0.4213819504,
-0.1704747081,
-0.2054693401,
0.5289887786,
0.8612228632,
0.3287624121,
0.0140831508,
0.0179616809,
0.1506568491,
0.3790329099,
-0.9122005105,
-0.0167491045,
0.0361955985,
-0.919395864,
-0.129268527,
-0.0309943091,
-1.0182493925,
-0.4094287753,
-0.359425813,
0.7921752334,
-0.2685848176,
-0.2747223377,
-0.0098767113,
-0.2585816085,
0.3909024298,
0.4681851268,
-0.7718919516,
0.0367505774,
0.3646017313,
0.9700178504,
-0.2395453304,
-0.2473891973,
-0.6993642449,
0.2281625569,
-0.1051258519,
1.1326628923,
-0.7377364635,
0.0987531468,
-0.0056056264,
-0.4008699954,
-0.2050145715,
-0.3496956825,
0.3315770328,
-0.7131803632,
0.2358474135,
-0.2011095434,
-0.5134960413,
-0.3939958215,
0.4474892914,
-0.8676889539,
0.8647779226,
-0.0091471523,
-1.0291500092,
0.046311602,
-0.5508375764,
-0.3413335383,
-0.0410620347,
-0.144941926,
-0.5697277784,
0.0696430728,
0.386772722,
0.4084880948,
-0.2746713758,
-0.3603289127,
-0.5054636002,
-0.3986483514,
-0.02157313,
-0.3010091186,
0.1941817105,
-0.0853567794,
0.091022782,
-0.0266799256,
-0.4720629752,
0.0615708046,
0.1210514903,
-0.3784545064,
-0.5867902637,
0.1513442397,
0.6061403155,
0.4149840772,
0.306686312,
-0.2330161184,
-0.025928773,
-0.2635111809,
0.1091134995,
0.5736320615,
0.0438080616,
0.5521187186,
-0.2426499575,
0.3547731936,
0.3898833692,
0.0697077215,
-0.8447480798,
-0.5257598758,
-0.6052930355,
-0.2541579008,
0.1918366104,
0.5659211874,
-0.6629987359,
-0.0023948688,
-0.0936790109,
-0.1969620883,
-0.968542099,
0.0063663027,
0.6230421662,
0.3881836832,
0.6156083941,
-0.7135685682,
-0.3647283614,
-1.0557709932,
-0.5415706038,
0.340259999,
0.1115166098,
0.7311870456,
0.3494263291,
0.0099092806,
0.6217571497,
-0.6718896031,
-0.8407142758,
-0.1070299521,
-0.1230593994,
-0.0810163766,
0.2919277847,
0.7981370091,
-1.2257606983,
-0.6923946142,
0.1387906522,
-0.5976718664,
0.2904775739,
0.0043545724,
-0.4640673399,
0.0575896837,
0.0244499855,
-0.1139009297,
0.4703319669,
0.744776845,
-0.2124742717,
0.1254029423,
-0.1655780971,
0.6615123749,
-1.3702944517,
-0.1776694357,
0.3820618391,
-0.2705255151,
-0.4435408413,
0.3207551837,
0.3737469018,
0.0968747362,
-0.5900420547,
0.5027933121,
-0.6218899488,
-0.1233632192,
-0.5971572995,
0.4003432095,
0.3652200401,
0.7488136292,
0.2121356428,
0.500711143,
0.719681561,
-0.4282277822,
0.1800073385,
0.1914944649,
-0.079789713,
0.9183622003,
-0.5981203914,
0.3957048953,
-0.4976503551,
0.0485645756,
-1.3108838797,
-0.2752786875,
0.2441868186,
-0.4248878658,
0.3095358908,
-0.2475444525,
-0.4178466797,
-0.1808013916,
-0.5619706511,
0.7279213071,
0.1619924456,
-0.5566285849,
0.7966787219,
0.3654525876,
-0.011634713,
-0.630439043,
-0.5295163393,
0.1084826738,
0.0326069519,
-0.6302520037,
0.4546769559,
-0.0728926733,
0.3292093873,
0.1293870062,
-0.1531670541,
-0.2825354636,
-0.2097631097,
0.0151177263,
0.4070311785,
-0.0982979387,
-0.0773025751,
0.1850601137,
-0.1297537982,
-0.405344516,
-0.3837749958,
0.3398261666,
0.1243178919,
-0.3282781541,
-0.4515856802,
1.0425105095,
0.5717746019,
-0.6041859388,
0.7685933709,
0.5882205963,
-0.4737842381,
0.4070991874,
-0.6999437213,
0.0319834985,
-0.4204726517,
0.530716598,
-0.3898185492,
-0.7455209494,
0.3121790886,
0.2090592831,
0.1351580322,
0.2699372172,
0.5536228418,
-0.3270262778,
1.1253944635,
0.9080590606,
-0.0062331222,
0.5019071102,
0.0009149706,
0.1119148508,
-1.062417388,
-0.343850553,
-0.4516742229,
-0.6448343992,
-0.3254170418,
-0.5250681639,
0.211868912,
-0.2260014862,
0.2933256328,
0.5816458464,
-0.7537375689,
0.7421001792,
0.5928510427,
0.2331883013,
0.3469174504,
0.1767837703,
0.0554860346,
-0.3372711837,
-0.311946094,
-0.4407709837,
0.876788795,
0.1559060812,
0.7759596705,
0.1903992593,
0.4790268242,
-0.0838872641,
0.2130425423,
-0.724727869,
0.3149104118,
-0.4649332464,
-0.3702673614,
0.2677648365,
-0.4233194292,
-0.7773729563,
0.9141083956,
-0.246656239,
-0.6675754189,
0.2066445798,
0.3024290502,
0.0125219496,
0.1125813723,
-0.887657702,
0.8472622633,
0.0490570888,
-0.3589210808,
-0.3192406595,
-0.6977651119,
0.4459033608,
-0.067877464,
0.2459110469,
-0.1489275992,
-0.0851745233,
0.5380825996,
0.3175572753,
0.4341418147,
0.1123398542,
0.004718808,
-0.0548731983,
-0.1814433783,
0.252632916,
0.034848623,
0.2117040455,
-0.1879992634,
0.0556264035,
-0.4428454638,
-0.293698132,
0.5081962347,
-0.557100594,
-0.273026675,
-0.4508773685,
-0.5879133344,
0.1014098376,
0.3303886354,
0.3866589665,
0.477563411,
0.0761715323,
0.1601320803,
0.9059993029,
0.0620759465,
0.4809992015,
0.3597632945,
-0.1641528904,
-0.365003705,
0.6128436923,
-0.2987360954,
0.2293494493,
0.8869428039,
-0.1653710604,
-0.3563620448,
-0.2737479806,
-0.3561681211,
0.1482771486,
-0.7614971399,
-0.3808281124,
-0.8527472615,
-0.0635571182,
-0.2953185737,
0.0986096784,
-0.3520558178,
0.1944676191,
-0.5050923228,
0.5655452609,
0.2037483156,
0.2921127081,
0.3956965804,
0.1705476791,
-0.9131332636,
0.8230851293,
0.4569490254,
0.5746796727,
0.1827110499,
-0.6357527375,
-0.3272808492,
-0.210457474,
-0.5959388018,
-1.1073973179,
0.2261326462,
0.3091621399,
0.3957760632,
0.3368582428,
-0.1092757061,
0.6361904144,
-0.700699985,
0.1340813786,
0.425737977,
-0.7106851935,
0.6684681773,
-0.0636523589,
0.5246197581,
0.5203618407,
0.1652114689,
-0.7114907503,
-0.4877171516,
-0.2067613304,
-0.8432586193,
0.838244319,
0.4086104333,
0.284026742,
0.2911572158,
0.3054606318,
-0.0112725291,
0.0357607231,
-0.7199569345,
-0.2177768648,
-0.1280065179,
-0.4874494374,
0.2703327239,
-0.2498341501,
0.120471701,
0.0495708659,
0.4239645302,
-0.3054732978,
0.5106227994,
0.1329052299,
-0.250517875,
-0.1468064636,
-0.0030911679,
0.4038120508,
0.3560892344,
-0.0536702946,
0.1846973449,
-0.2975007296,
-0.8038992286,
0.0858581066,
0.198010996,
-0.0575398132,
-0.0939383656,
0.2685870826,
0.8656762242,
0.0909869671,
-0.580039978,
0.5313725471,
-0.2985549867,
-0.1619435102,
0.2098284364,
0.0382248834,
0.3655328453,
0.3895177245,
0.6176570058,
0.6482701302,
0.3851888776,
-0.456871897,
0.0978545472,
0.4304081202,
-0.4471750855,
0.0451372042,
0.8445146084,
0.2546706796,
-0.3398046792,
0.3543751538,
-0.1190460697,
-0.5535622835,
0.7565780282,
0.1826588959,
0.7779587507,
0.0027463026,
-0.1200264692,
0.2494622022,
0.175410375,
-0.2192330807,
0.3596380353,
0.0251007862,
-0.6828040481,
-0.5336713195,
-0.4165098667,
-0.3917401731,
-0.1136979088,
-0.7848951221,
0.192902416,
0.0622458942,
0.0979413167,
0.1887166351,
-0.1291709989,
-0.6809372306,
0.2356313169,
0.3422130048,
0.6206080317,
-0.6748809218,
0.7088876367,
0.8739435673,
-0.3290257752,
-0.5705230832,
0.2696451247,
-0.0464335941,
-0.5472034216,
-0.0216622371,
0.6730482578,
-0.2185569704,
0.0877304599,
-0.2852045596,
-0.9045212865,
0.9605436921,
0.2427193373,
-0.7632813454,
0.2107594609,
-0.4259386957,
0.2664963305,
-0.6060114503,
0.3623725772,
0.1703115106,
0.263415575,
0.3296325803,
-0.638656199,
-0.1721655577,
-0.2385440767,
0.2624623775,
0.3529944122,
-0.9247304201,
0.7389127612,
-0.352655381,
-0.2870776653,
0.0883975551,
0.7621055841,
0.337023288,
0.3473829925,
0.3685651422,
0.4419542253,
0.2694050074,
0.0685056373,
0.8493004441,
-0.0052338298,
0.7592428327,
0.9926165342,
-0.4106456339,
1.0487521887,
0.6141709685,
-0.0773728788,
0.0945606083,
0.6346803904,
-0.0669408217,
1.0178312063,
-0.3640672266,
0.10685049,
-0.3133615553,
0.0100773526,
-0.2730239928,
0.3339643478,
0.0021353171,
-0.5896030068,
-0.3980229199,
0.0571359619,
-0.4153911173,
0.4812834859,
-0.3336988986,
0.7383646369,
-0.0251056105,
-0.6941752434,
0.1089785621,
0.1994783878,
0.7817845345,
-0.1874973327,
-0.0881855786,
-0.1703434885,
0.403845638,
0.1758490205,
-0.9217870831,
0.2109842598,
-0.1276487261,
-0.6380233169,
-0.1977026761,
0.8645358682,
-0.7840742469,
-0.5331741571,
0.4053388238,
0.0761154518,
0.0513863303,
-0.3788933456,
-0.6582581997,
0.0757803321,
0.0070659905,
-0.1459206939,
0.3886437118,
0.2149374783,
0.0796743929,
0.336877197,
0.1126187518,
-0.4600136578,
0.1029051617,
0.1231263727,
0.6240519285,
-0.2905162573,
-0.6253018379,
-0.8633478284,
0.2951518595,
-0.1808366925,
-0.4400700629,
0.3109586537,
0.6867448688,
0.45168221,
-0.1820301265,
0.6949951053,
0.1758764535,
0.3743817806,
-0.4774930775,
0.5788843632,
-0.9974853396,
-0.3436497152,
-0.557559371,
-1.270611763,
-0.2630904317,
0.652345717,
0.3240340352,
0.0826644599,
0.8543142676,
0.5033494234,
-0.3652097285,
-0.1843916625,
0.1886290908,
-0.2942256927,
0.0677208602,
1.0600671768,
0.5778130889,
-0.9206319451,
0.901889801,
0.1274012178,
-0.2530026436,
-0.4860788286,
-0.8247595429,
-0.8827442527,
-0.7229447365,
-0.487443924,
-0.1311888397,
-0.0732280463,
0.403288275,
0.7559121251,
-0.4347921312,
0.2877989113,
0.4507746994,
0.0600499474,
-0.5175378323,
-0.1435773671,
0.437004149,
0.0451973267,
-0.9821439385,
-0.1629641354,
0.9600559473,
0.0864173248,
-0.1885983646,
0.0658169165,
-0.5413503647,
0.3606376946,
0.6986691952,
-0.161264196,
-0.6383978128,
-0.1951228976,
0.1923754215,
-0.3711874783,
0.3292945623,
0.6189342737,
-0.5392002463,
0.4902916849,
0.5352607965,
0.7774137855,
0.8482712507,
0.0125641814,
0.0377862267,
-0.9406181574,
0.1506339163,
0.1296195984,
0.364274621,
0.4735478461,
-0.4078695774,
0.226331681,
0.1677169204,
-0.3263064921,
-0.4328197241,
0.3902230263,
-1.3844635487,
-0.1406871229,
0.942019999,
-0.0544629544,
-0.1348064095,
0.1313621104,
-0.5030552149,
0.1926413178,
-0.3432011604,
0.7973932028,
0.8240481615,
0.1387026757,
-0.7026112676,
-0.4272430241,
-0.1785424352,
0.3890793622,
-0.7730944157,
-0.3189540803,
0.2120383829,
0.1354975849,
0.224230513,
0.5925747156,
-0.0363869667,
0.5017783046,
-0.27063936,
-0.0414504632,
0.1997747868,
-0.3386689425,
-0.0812665671,
0.3002063632,
-0.3736261725,
-0.7906517386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17231v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17231v3
|
MATHSENSEI: A Tool-Augmented Large Language Model for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-02-27T05:50:35 | 2024-04-03T15:22:35 |
Debrup Das, Debopriyo Banerjee, Somak Aditya, Ashish Kulkarni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tool-augmented Large Language Models (TALMs) are known to enhance the
skillset of large language models (LLMs), thereby, leading to their improved
reasoning abilities across many tasks. While, TALMs have been successfully
employed in different question-answering benchmarks, their efficacy on complex
mathematical reasoning benchmarks, and the potential complementary benefits
offered by tools for knowledge retrieval and mathematical equation solving are
open research questions. In this work, we present MathSensei, a tool-augmented
large language model for mathematical reasoning. We study the complementary
benefits of the tools - knowledge retriever (Bing Web Search), program
generator + executor (Python), and symbolic equation solver (Wolfram-Alpha API)
through evaluations on mathematical reasoning datasets. We perform exhaustive
ablations on MATH, a popular dataset for evaluating mathematical reasoning on
diverse mathematical disciplines. We also conduct experiments involving
well-known tool planners to study the impact of tool sequencing on the model
performance. MathSensei achieves 13.5% better accuracy over gpt-3.5-turbo with
Chain-of-Thought on the MATH dataset. We further observe that TALMs are not as
effective for simpler math word problems (in GSM-8K), and the benefit increases
as the complexity and required knowledge increases (progressively over AQuA,
MMLU-Math, and higher level complex questions in MATH). The code and data are
available at https://github.com/Debrup-61/MathSensei.
|
[
-0.3448880613,
-0.8281164765,
0.5107833147,
0.2381371409,
-0.2590841949,
0.1058962047,
-0.3084479272,
-0.2619226277,
-0.0949304104,
0.3623656332,
-0.3735521436,
-0.5126807094,
-0.6227040291,
0.0870427489,
-0.3652402461,
0.5935640931,
-0.1583912969,
0.3392894268,
-0.3433961272,
-0.0552267656,
-0.6112782359,
-0.5202864408,
-0.6505218744,
-0.6043277383,
0.4035923481,
0.087988846,
1.0060693026,
0.2392220497,
0.6193371415,
0.3404184878,
-0.1036446095,
0.0293590799,
-0.2223743349,
0.2102312446,
-0.219276756,
-0.9707334638,
-0.278850019,
-0.1458708495,
0.3995328844,
0.9397606254,
-0.1523545682,
0.0937921628,
-0.2085297108,
0.4733306468,
-0.772736907,
0.2322270721,
-0.5276150107,
-0.014413435,
-0.1852861047,
0.1551320851,
-0.2772365808,
-0.6268478036,
0.1071652621,
-0.7495362759,
0.023490781,
-0.1381000578,
0.3780293465,
0.4994836152,
-0.2364400625,
-0.3625810742,
-0.5399163365,
0.9863874316,
-0.7183750272,
0.56083709,
0.5483282208,
0.5241544247,
-0.2172123939,
-0.5203930736,
-0.3437861502,
0.0272814557,
0.0072540645,
0.1150067449,
-0.1188907996,
-0.3498675525,
0.7002316117,
0.250379771,
-0.5895152092,
0.0309406575,
-0.2001840025,
-0.2079014927,
0.4539964199,
0.3722634614,
0.318413496,
-0.1042533889,
0.1843088716,
-0.2715718448,
-0.8240574598,
-0.0445591249,
0.1402095854,
0.0412389338,
-0.0701698065,
0.8544504046,
-0.0268833414,
0.6726661325,
-0.5204266906,
-0.0654528067,
0.2590189278,
-0.0789589509,
-0.1651742309,
0.2508645058,
0.5203029513,
-0.1212242842,
0.3672601283,
-0.1002467796,
-0.1746223718,
0.3235086799,
0.0563099198,
-0.9869440198,
-0.1195508987,
0.1151523367,
-0.1667996794,
-0.0666681454,
-0.0175631791,
-0.5037406087,
-0.4529296756,
-0.5418866277,
0.4393592477,
-0.6355839372,
-0.2956044972,
0.5506948233,
-0.3570236266,
-0.090476498,
0.786839962,
-0.1957944036,
0.1088856533,
0.9017290473,
0.8297610879,
0.1135177016,
-0.0037052992,
-0.8011707664,
-0.0656148419,
-0.4813106656,
0.4725906849,
-0.9157672524,
-0.6197679043,
-0.1178435385,
-0.255836904,
-0.0045276736,
-0.5732322931,
0.5532383919,
-0.6512266397,
0.395650655,
-0.3289854228,
-0.5393049121,
-0.2534447312,
0.1398057193,
-0.8087928295,
0.9983994961,
-0.0921731144,
-0.6384788752,
-0.0156342387,
-0.8212072849,
-0.3720350266,
0.1100854799,
-0.1304522753,
-0.2868843377,
0.2657282948,
0.3175339103,
0.1041022092,
-0.8500921726,
0.4033031166,
-0.4558489621,
-0.3600171506,
0.4753810167,
-0.4900862277,
0.893129766,
0.3112441003,
-0.3493471146,
-0.2279241085,
-0.4649204016,
-0.0207596011,
0.4441736042,
0.0674527958,
-0.5283647776,
-0.1993580908,
-0.4491162896,
0.2103617638,
0.3763957322,
-0.68234694,
0.0492950901,
-0.4901324511,
-0.0085215615,
0.6588158607,
-0.2306549698,
0.2460424304,
-0.1560079008,
0.7494686842,
-0.0002339479,
-0.1034467444,
-0.2627882659,
-0.5614194274,
-0.5710966587,
-0.1483719349,
0.4920403361,
0.4435287416,
-0.9670373797,
0.1721721143,
-0.328271091,
-0.515389204,
-0.3186662793,
0.0229186006,
0.4729163945,
0.5062339306,
0.2476806641,
0.2041353136,
-0.1234639362,
-0.7498947978,
-0.4829308689,
0.2779068947,
-0.1980193406,
0.2460349351,
0.4471905828,
0.0100851953,
0.9058148265,
-0.9495648742,
-0.0079725869,
-0.1034821495,
0.3370012641,
0.5526572466,
-0.0129539371,
0.417886436,
-0.8769792914,
-0.4740643203,
0.0198232811,
-0.8074018955,
-0.4442670941,
0.2108962536,
-0.2069265246,
-0.0556808934,
0.1854649335,
-0.7220565677,
0.5856422782,
0.252068758,
-0.2392919809,
0.7304154634,
0.1095201671,
0.1002769917,
-1.0090842247,
0.3498167098,
0.2031565309,
-0.0518823341,
-0.4073065221,
0.0915774256,
0.0557728745,
-0.3673600554,
-0.2900647223,
0.8625767827,
-0.1030290052,
-0.0794034749,
-0.3279987574,
0.3446582556,
-0.0584296323,
0.3262778521,
-0.0272959787,
1.2421196699,
0.4748588204,
-0.4444519877,
0.3780829608,
0.2815130055,
-0.3239825964,
0.5008665919,
-0.8983398676,
0.0157158095,
-0.1112769619,
0.0065168589,
-0.7023021579,
-0.0434375219,
-0.0298109483,
-0.4486288428,
0.0397029631,
-0.1271361262,
-1.0420532227,
-0.3161127865,
-0.1180806905,
0.5146479607,
0.5501531363,
-0.621297121,
0.8615987301,
0.2760514319,
-0.5977500081,
-0.4963893592,
-0.2303803712,
-0.0478400774,
-0.0826499537,
-0.5012223721,
-0.0654013082,
-0.0258847587,
-0.4978175759,
0.1486240029,
-0.2555864155,
0.0473593622,
0.1459720433,
0.1533776224,
0.5319350958,
-0.0349882953,
0.482668221,
0.368791163,
-0.4304583967,
0.2164378017,
-0.0036017071,
0.9083173275,
-0.2701568604,
-0.6811212897,
0.0115520619,
0.0565351248,
0.4949221611,
-0.5525299907,
0.6200338006,
0.4496818185,
-0.5151561499,
0.1587395221,
-0.5961896777,
-0.2113877982,
-0.4288286269,
0.2265114486,
-0.6872382164,
-0.7911856771,
0.4957978129,
-0.4788186848,
0.3787444532,
0.5299726129,
0.5067334771,
0.2582063079,
1.5977079868,
-0.2240507156,
-0.098040469,
0.1361274421,
-0.2774182856,
0.1144978926,
-0.7430827022,
-0.1478764713,
-0.8098784685,
-0.2640840411,
0.112286374,
-0.2566351295,
0.5814904571,
0.1969160438,
-0.3275641799,
0.2684113383,
-0.288361609,
0.4567946792,
0.4871251285,
0.0192150995,
0.5146669149,
0.0995690748,
-0.4831662774,
-0.2125511616,
-0.6454278827,
-0.2921139896,
1.0092002153,
0.0676141381,
1.0175330639,
0.3218352795,
0.2410249263,
0.0028157383,
0.3689289093,
-0.7231580019,
0.655747056,
-0.1898477525,
-0.4536959529,
-0.1881919801,
-0.855533123,
-1.0603635311,
0.4159628153,
0.0119915316,
-0.6475278139,
-0.3297220469,
-0.1953844428,
-0.0415008068,
0.2198814154,
-0.7176853418,
0.558760047,
-0.4180709422,
-0.407871455,
-0.5965377092,
-0.3090267479,
0.3515328467,
-0.4386324883,
0.2958549261,
-0.1323365122,
-0.0120076621,
0.6514090896,
-0.5782198906,
0.6324897408,
-0.1998689324,
-0.457811296,
-0.0183828697,
0.4061234891,
0.5376318097,
0.0491374731,
-0.2791031599,
0.2657028139,
0.0523928143,
-0.0868109986,
-1.1162853241,
0.8608925343,
-0.6899811029,
-0.8292142153,
-0.3193089962,
-0.9099254012,
-0.2682011425,
0.5033562183,
-0.1672023386,
0.9159358144,
0.4147283435,
0.3655895293,
0.6602263451,
-0.3616655767,
0.1394046545,
0.3095987439,
-0.6066040397,
-0.6199265122,
0.5443558097,
0.1038438976,
0.0918451399,
0.3135388196,
0.351082921,
-0.6457920074,
0.0618891157,
-0.4665171206,
0.511205852,
-0.7195954919,
-0.3794687092,
-0.6333854198,
-0.2593843043,
-0.0486117862,
-0.0851121321,
-0.2606359124,
-0.7501058578,
0.0575354025,
0.3184337616,
0.5505593419,
0.248609513,
0.2081725448,
0.1751018912,
-0.830525279,
0.439211309,
0.0753974319,
0.4882863462,
0.1481048018,
-0.2838684916,
-0.2287031263,
0.5243622065,
-0.1452977508,
-0.5356619954,
0.1740164161,
-0.1924072653,
0.527082324,
0.2191415429,
0.0340452529,
0.7164095044,
-0.4338005185,
0.320674628,
0.3589878082,
-0.9099267125,
0.5504289269,
-0.1529637873,
0.8138229847,
0.1761174351,
0.3535096943,
-0.4441551566,
-0.3362965584,
-0.5304757953,
-0.198025465,
0.6713886857,
0.5340684652,
-0.1303887963,
0.0816048756,
0.2282376438,
0.1608361155,
0.3116335869,
-0.0078179361,
-0.1392336339,
-0.0627207011,
-0.3990720809,
-0.0039700638,
0.2347414494,
-0.2524476647,
-0.2629064023,
0.8048073649,
-0.0916487649,
0.1620734781,
-0.1901699454,
-0.3692056835,
-0.031783253,
0.2743136883,
0.4649194777,
0.7385818958,
0.1116327196,
0.2565280795,
0.1974071562,
-0.5883700252,
-0.012711308,
0.5819845796,
0.0146028558,
0.1879681945,
0.1240463257,
0.5976388454,
0.27719751,
-0.960085988,
0.3630470932,
-0.0982650965,
-0.2209759802,
-0.2279725522,
0.2650206685,
0.1313224733,
0.1814654022,
0.4496175945,
-0.1270702928,
0.0413531549,
-0.0749360025,
-0.1263954192,
0.5904396772,
0.03250058,
-0.1964928806,
0.6639057398,
-0.0882152244,
-0.3378952742,
0.6185156703,
0.073175624,
-0.7149031162,
0.6396109462,
0.6633970141,
0.5136756897,
-0.1430822164,
0.0843517482,
0.2823313773,
0.0700827315,
-0.029870132,
0.3847787678,
0.0376243778,
-0.5906950235,
-0.820171535,
-0.4668359458,
-0.3385252655,
-0.0235146675,
-0.4399093688,
0.4034517109,
-0.3130558431,
-0.3016113937,
-0.0554117486,
0.030840721,
-0.7845314741,
-0.0568413772,
-0.2840795815,
1.0988804102,
-0.4344665408,
0.3903109133,
0.8187317848,
-0.2181248516,
-0.7079008222,
-0.3749750853,
-0.0351744592,
-0.9026888609,
0.7337832451,
0.2603348494,
-0.2908169925,
0.2199492455,
-0.3736079335,
-0.907572031,
0.9801304936,
0.557559967,
-0.5477339029,
0.1752569079,
0.455162555,
0.399325192,
0.167305693,
0.3407658041,
0.1905747652,
0.4428086281,
0.522919476,
-1.0010691881,
0.0821678489,
-0.4985851943,
-0.1004325375,
1.0138349533,
-0.1798523664,
0.4586909413,
-0.0155931255,
-0.0738557205,
0.1428884268,
0.2417999804,
0.6109759808,
0.2366766334,
0.4162198007,
1.1455397606,
0.6244435906,
-0.1953221709,
1.023234129,
-0.289242357,
0.254367888,
1.0050927401,
-0.3481907547,
0.5609430075,
0.1534269303,
-0.2833290696,
0.4579369724,
0.1456973404,
0.0700005069,
0.2220257372,
-0.0134337731,
-0.3242252767,
-0.6325049996,
-0.3055703044,
-0.6122128367,
0.2314240485,
0.5685295463,
-0.0636573508,
-0.7056315541,
0.0944424346,
0.2251789719,
-0.0738166645,
-0.3210627735,
0.5019406676,
0.3193947673,
-0.5343257189,
0.4137505591,
0.0010069038,
0.0917873532,
-0.6147261858,
-0.2449051589,
0.0122363809,
0.2760554552,
0.0542918332,
-1.0117526054,
0.1133986935,
0.1252867281,
0.1486637741,
0.2031347156,
0.842094481,
-0.1485248953,
-0.8207347393,
-0.1938067675,
0.6955145001,
0.0053204885,
-0.2037389576,
-0.797555089,
0.026814051,
-0.4030588269,
0.1105537191,
0.2166695297,
0.4970971346,
-0.1687305421,
0.9015521407,
1.0682071447,
-0.0385547653,
-0.0098313997,
0.4870681167,
0.9950803518,
-0.417339623,
-0.3751112819,
-0.8095107675,
0.4033157825,
-0.3246375918,
-0.0502637811,
0.9530181885,
0.8079423308,
0.506334424,
0.0367548466,
0.6341863275,
0.2265798002,
0.6197031736,
-0.5316851735,
0.2557739317,
-0.6109216213,
0.315338999,
-0.3502842188,
-1.1720547676,
-0.566849947,
0.6016557217,
-0.8052410483,
0.1058813184,
0.6249266863,
0.5256952643,
-0.312712431,
0.3536042869,
0.1274993718,
-0.0286127925,
0.428558439,
0.4581773281,
0.9029358029,
-0.2481804341,
0.480938524,
-0.1544781476,
-0.2302015871,
0.0184464753,
-0.5621775389,
-1.0593911409,
-0.2515463531,
-0.1339501888,
-0.2039876729,
-0.2633491158,
0.9324477911,
0.1649252623,
-0.3220147789,
-0.0828975961,
-0.1602462828,
0.1447280198,
0.1057486236,
-0.2482708097,
0.34482342,
-0.4074284434,
-0.7096666098,
0.0630722269,
0.325653255,
-0.1861043721,
-0.1279779971,
-0.0503183752,
0.0593357086,
-0.0805101991,
0.7251824737,
0.0179369338,
-0.5026084185,
0.0906547457,
0.3870071471,
0.2055019885,
-0.2381676137,
0.9555179477,
-0.7871722579,
0.52172333,
0.4410614073,
1.0016281605,
0.4937994182,
-0.0821669251,
0.590067625,
-0.3278553784,
0.1021219045,
0.1445989162,
0.6822713017,
0.0759979188,
-0.1506599039,
0.6945402026,
0.1343700439,
-0.1957233548,
-0.738704145,
0.2874224484,
-0.4355450571,
-0.3983613849,
1.0722846985,
0.1748614311,
-0.0212673619,
-0.0236032493,
-0.365056783,
0.1450389624,
-0.2984879613,
0.7419628501,
0.8396819234,
0.1348032355,
-0.277636677,
-0.423222661,
-0.163198486,
0.6276195645,
-0.9416124821,
-0.0926807523,
0.5874677896,
-0.0149931377,
0.2997358739,
-0.0340033807,
-0.472902745,
0.4879196584,
-0.2884680033,
-0.1398322433,
-0.3352460563,
-0.2410369217,
-0.0906922519,
0.0817584321,
-0.094399862,
0.2444021553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17226v1
|
Reasoning in Conversation: Solving Subjective Tasks through Dialogue Simulation for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T05:37:10 | 2024-02-27T05:37:10 |
Xiaolong Wang, Yile Wang, Yuanchi Zhang, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in
objective tasks such as open-domain question answering and mathematical
reasoning, which can often be solved through recalling learned factual
knowledge or chain-of-thought style reasoning. However, we find that the
performance of LLMs in subjective tasks is still unsatisfactory, such as
metaphor recognition, dark humor detection, etc. Compared to objective tasks,
subjective tasks focus more on interpretation or emotional response rather than
a universally accepted reasoning pathway. Based on the characteristics of the
tasks and the strong dialogue-generation capabilities of LLMs, we propose RiC
(Reasoning in Conversation), a method that focuses on solving subjective tasks
through dialogue simulation. The motivation of RiC is to mine useful contextual
information by simulating dialogues instead of supplying chain-of-thought style
rationales, thereby offering potential useful knowledge behind dialogues for
giving the final answers. We evaluate both API-based and open-source LLMs
including GPT-4, ChatGPT, and OpenChat across twelve tasks. Experimental
results show that RiC can yield significant improvement compared with various
baselines.
|
[
-0.4668918848,
-0.9531945586,
0.8564975262,
0.2533873022,
-0.3079852462,
0.1055845991,
-0.5311989188,
-0.4103180468,
-0.0463133343,
0.5443236828,
-0.5450829268,
-0.6513975859,
-0.2050890625,
0.0427700169,
0.0774773955,
0.7318210006,
0.0389326885,
0.3165088296,
-0.6843102574,
0.1043899581,
-0.5174565911,
-0.7140650153,
-0.7345057726,
-0.409016639,
0.2868632376,
0.6474553943,
0.3631183207,
-0.1094832867,
0.637992382,
0.3718501925,
0.0512858965,
0.1856777668,
-0.5329468846,
0.3959567249,
-0.2807328105,
-0.7274160981,
-0.3310353756,
-0.131286785,
0.4699504673,
0.6831969023,
-0.195162788,
0.0066032917,
0.0281866882,
0.4297571778,
-0.3176074624,
0.4819095731,
-0.7041700482,
-0.0056604738,
0.0779855251,
-0.4036092162,
-0.4029226899,
-0.1879950762,
0.2212717831,
-0.4395947456,
-0.064433001,
0.2691738307,
0.4329828322,
0.1816683412,
-0.1016903222,
-0.4874402285,
-1.1141295433,
1.0295821428,
-1.0524939299,
0.205124557,
0.327257812,
0.2406266034,
-0.3364980221,
-0.2764889598,
-0.6346080303,
-0.5582862496,
0.2055661231,
0.2303880155,
-0.1379706115,
0.3091922104,
0.3708012104,
0.2954189479,
-0.3399870992,
-0.1014200896,
-0.1390405446,
0.0068068169,
0.4149235189,
0.3498205245,
0.234999612,
-0.0867612734,
-0.0749854445,
0.1213900298,
-0.6121776104,
0.06219,
0.1158762351,
0.3134343028,
-0.151478678,
0.5887532234,
-0.2350453436,
0.5542570949,
-0.1351839602,
-0.4911316931,
0.0191611815,
-0.1764492393,
-0.2559319735,
-0.0389783122,
0.7204166055,
0.3251847029,
0.2526041865,
-0.1472633034,
-0.0070756902,
0.0388036445,
0.1427953094,
-0.6302134395,
0.0215589628,
0.4149535298,
-0.3933723569,
-0.1024606377,
-0.4862390161,
-0.4509406984,
0.0223160349,
-0.7404441237,
0.2205541581,
-0.4488249123,
-0.2536906302,
0.2521609068,
0.0716651976,
0.171071887,
0.7418773174,
-0.4404319823,
0.3236593008,
0.7834818959,
0.8016932011,
0.0137610976,
0.145515576,
-0.4112693071,
0.1054252461,
-0.2246963084,
0.90578866,
-0.7430146337,
-0.6312314868,
-0.101654388,
-0.3898317814,
0.2839414775,
-0.641092658,
0.7031867504,
-0.2606759369,
0.2166627795,
-0.4693736732,
-0.6002724171,
0.0250921138,
0.7184012532,
-0.2384095937,
0.8766235113,
-0.1368098557,
-0.7391198277,
-0.0822127312,
-0.7356181145,
-0.2083034068,
0.1317195594,
-0.2452157587,
0.0159675069,
0.0734287873,
-0.0041679014,
0.4584600031,
-0.697070539,
0.4459838569,
-0.4770644903,
-0.4069578052,
0.5322540402,
-0.2689111531,
0.4565962255,
0.2933949828,
-0.3164594769,
-0.04153198,
-0.3141956031,
0.0601594113,
-0.0078986222,
-0.1374086291,
-0.2702890038,
0.2564391196,
-0.4283148646,
0.2234087437,
-0.0023297973,
-0.7560374141,
0.1631358117,
-0.4554686248,
0.3722151816,
0.527674377,
-0.0678316131,
0.4369524717,
-0.3036470711,
0.4906457663,
0.3041107357,
0.1579383016,
0.046875529,
-0.7396366596,
-0.9579011202,
-0.141664803,
0.1770276725,
0.6677744389,
-1.0215393305,
0.1534227282,
-0.2257303447,
-0.4258482754,
-0.2915117145,
0.0413636528,
0.4862071574,
0.5938611627,
0.0841523632,
-0.5132598281,
-0.4299537241,
-0.8083422184,
-0.1951131374,
-0.6103835106,
-0.0333936848,
0.6529530883,
0.3669263721,
-0.0461422205,
1.089995265,
-0.5104212165,
-0.1420455426,
-0.4079764485,
0.4041489065,
0.1995334923,
0.3034846187,
0.2812882662,
-0.4598576427,
-0.3157081902,
-0.0951690078,
-0.8822962642,
-0.2091984451,
-0.0756879672,
-0.2532822788,
0.1152741909,
0.5723542571,
-0.698685348,
0.1850515753,
0.4354066551,
0.1836102605,
0.7244440913,
-0.0604513623,
0.0764661655,
-0.8963328004,
0.0527208075,
0.2589945197,
-0.5274458528,
-0.5796554685,
-0.2795061767,
-0.5063310862,
-0.3744916022,
-0.5701209307,
0.6588023305,
-0.3761711419,
-0.3319904804,
-0.3644552231,
0.4558310211,
-0.1856270134,
0.7109248042,
0.2229891568,
0.7986612916,
0.4930385351,
-0.570684731,
0.5569384694,
0.1644387692,
-0.5381475091,
0.6372333169,
-0.6443747878,
0.3424924314,
-0.2954272032,
0.4382247925,
-0.8148921132,
-0.0295765772,
0.5090142488,
-0.4035209119,
0.1426211149,
-0.1650206447,
-0.4557379186,
-0.3585183322,
-0.0219501723,
0.3980261981,
0.5150703192,
-0.26392591,
0.6908729672,
0.347184062,
-0.440330416,
-0.5248686075,
-0.467656821,
0.2280371636,
-0.1699145883,
-0.4779185951,
0.1274623722,
-0.2988998592,
-0.6667107344,
-0.0375880525,
0.0372675993,
0.1063135788,
-0.0231165402,
0.132958442,
0.2179057747,
-0.0675960705,
0.1010215506,
-0.1488511264,
-0.0932051539,
0.3067696095,
-0.2088515311,
0.5873794556,
-0.3035994768,
-0.5515556931,
-0.5962114334,
0.4546431303,
0.4261066318,
-0.0111334082,
0.4882907569,
0.143224597,
-0.1607734561,
-0.3070640564,
-0.6507365704,
-0.1613656431,
-0.4694885314,
0.1678619832,
-0.5435522795,
-1.0126347542,
0.4627903998,
-0.4002604187,
0.1213241443,
-0.2165966779,
0.7260975838,
-0.3618984818,
1.0714058876,
0.1573684365,
-0.0275397785,
0.3944630325,
-0.0467713177,
0.6785642505,
-0.8251282573,
-0.2984345555,
-0.6146149039,
-0.1926833689,
-0.2835005522,
-0.8525367379,
0.6404826641,
0.0060552792,
-0.18042849,
-0.0478908308,
-0.3244966567,
0.5838382244,
0.7464715242,
0.1751796603,
0.4668693244,
-0.1191445664,
-0.0761147365,
0.0133842882,
-0.5153315663,
-0.7850874066,
0.8892188668,
0.2851169407,
0.8626368642,
0.015863711,
0.5674251914,
-0.0263002571,
0.6276202798,
-0.941547811,
0.9722931981,
0.140023917,
-0.6317043304,
-0.1299112886,
-0.7067480683,
-0.4009163976,
0.1455837488,
-0.0413271151,
-0.8034566045,
-0.1890102327,
0.2201072276,
-0.0390965827,
0.3123681545,
-0.5725826025,
0.5553523898,
-0.1837052703,
-0.3290167749,
-0.3490919769,
-0.5611661673,
0.5030006766,
0.3060911894,
0.2540605664,
-0.4279985726,
0.3266318738,
0.3932377994,
-0.3545005322,
1.0459256172,
-0.2507829964,
-0.2330280542,
0.6340610385,
0.3292056024,
0.4599529803,
0.2211748511,
-0.0174274649,
0.1434191167,
-0.1389442533,
-0.3343545794,
-0.981007576,
0.6357995272,
-0.6493121982,
-0.9150221348,
-0.2728276551,
-0.4993597269,
-0.5737667084,
-0.188139528,
-0.072511144,
0.5270141363,
-0.4709705412,
0.0670822039,
0.5668609738,
-0.3876159489,
0.1862396747,
0.5129478574,
-0.2065893859,
-0.2593119442,
0.7420849204,
-0.3687964678,
0.4074023962,
0.488930583,
0.066466257,
-0.2463077903,
-0.4270387292,
-0.332451731,
0.4068011642,
-0.7409403324,
-0.3106174767,
-0.7027514577,
-0.0219076537,
-0.1331693381,
-0.047685653,
-0.3053855002,
-0.32672894,
-0.1612317711,
0.138939321,
0.024380831,
0.4944734871,
-0.0751857609,
0.0422710553,
-0.6372936964,
0.1420059651,
0.4279735684,
0.1960739046,
0.0903803706,
-0.1691038311,
-0.1732373238,
0.4874937832,
-0.5447406769,
-0.5752795339,
0.2956531048,
-0.1278989017,
0.2733312547,
0.4612329006,
0.0564784594,
0.6413472891,
-0.5058354139,
0.837202251,
0.3304442763,
-1.1808017492,
0.5066707134,
-0.4738713205,
0.2353223413,
0.4817102253,
0.3550544083,
-0.6047450304,
-0.7217904925,
-0.4295197725,
-0.3109806478,
0.681692183,
0.3962130845,
0.2454529703,
-0.1439158022,
0.3902209103,
-0.1020278782,
0.3177770972,
-0.5123447776,
-0.0880745351,
-0.0534945354,
-0.1241758168,
-0.2139069587,
-0.2478244305,
-0.1062414125,
-0.4451344311,
0.6667664647,
-0.271907717,
0.7569852471,
0.3788913786,
0.17817913,
-0.0280457716,
0.3837094009,
0.6250380874,
0.4732887149,
-0.2927005589,
0.1177553609,
0.2323526293,
0.0157278329,
0.0354965925,
-0.3829564154,
0.2440284342,
0.1038737968,
0.0793762282,
0.8633335233,
0.482601583,
-1.026273489,
0.4804217219,
-0.2379845381,
-0.3016478717,
-0.4570270181,
0.1284120828,
0.3321839273,
0.3685462475,
0.0574022047,
-0.1671104729,
0.257202059,
-1.0603678226,
-0.2837659717,
0.7043641806,
-0.1892992407,
-0.2887886167,
0.4604375362,
0.5127305388,
-0.3667941391,
0.6771341562,
-0.1116266102,
-0.6700161099,
0.5584001541,
0.6218296289,
0.6958677173,
-0.0779119879,
0.3686206043,
0.2332616597,
-0.0431979559,
-0.1517021507,
0.3450406194,
-0.2925597131,
-1.0606716871,
-0.6919501424,
-0.4420410991,
-1.1716017723,
0.0514936075,
-0.3693263233,
0.22525765,
-0.3058962226,
-0.2181804627,
-0.1457089633,
-0.1072064787,
-0.5681831837,
0.1443665773,
0.303501904,
0.6392351389,
-0.4309460223,
0.6102596521,
0.6111021042,
-0.1575486362,
-0.6543890834,
-0.1020113677,
-0.1255496442,
-0.5841073394,
0.8055669069,
-0.0338954516,
-0.3955311179,
-0.1154355258,
-0.858430624,
-0.6614789963,
0.7215450406,
0.5635069609,
-0.6205803156,
-0.1836623549,
0.3784616292,
0.5911234617,
-0.3971387744,
0.6685841084,
0.3250961602,
0.3468275368,
0.3918741643,
-1.0268243551,
-0.2783972621,
-0.2996941209,
-0.0177131183,
0.0410679951,
-0.7481085062,
0.5198264718,
-0.0380026735,
-0.105067648,
0.0858491361,
0.6214289069,
0.3943667412,
0.3928658068,
0.4510321319,
0.5725761652,
0.5997694135,
-0.1608509868,
0.9946154356,
-0.3379353881,
0.30464378,
1.0958358049,
-0.7405844331,
0.7354374528,
0.2434547693,
0.0175059959,
0.7013224363,
0.3824648559,
0.4474988878,
0.3614924252,
0.2871192396,
-0.6734045744,
-0.5818766952,
-0.2007842213,
-0.1900706589,
0.6163852215,
0.433536768,
0.0714484155,
-0.1215683222,
0.1855732501,
0.1302444041,
-0.1100478843,
-0.233854562,
0.8540239334,
0.4083839953,
-0.8520541191,
0.4587517083,
0.0902183428,
0.510201633,
-0.2950738072,
-0.1038179323,
-0.1969842613,
0.1611063331,
0.0967194512,
-0.6376722455,
0.2293338329,
0.1882355362,
0.0286390875,
-0.4527940154,
0.7252369523,
-0.3338278234,
-0.3203011751,
0.1633702517,
0.6568501592,
0.4382146001,
-0.1152546182,
-0.7124313116,
0.1347925216,
-0.07490848,
-0.1197545156,
0.2549534738,
0.690320015,
0.1840467006,
0.9378969669,
0.6175895333,
0.0109101143,
-0.3924384117,
0.1880805641,
1.1967810392,
-0.7505816817,
-0.4338171482,
-0.6374189854,
0.2890828252,
-0.2202065438,
-0.0631571487,
0.6636129618,
0.5565481186,
0.806671679,
-0.0765988454,
0.8354450464,
0.1401109546,
0.6454435587,
-0.621620357,
0.1318859309,
-0.4151512086,
0.261734575,
-0.5273526907,
-1.0578199625,
-0.2213228792,
0.6995686889,
-0.6445372701,
0.0310901981,
0.8128823638,
0.8077161908,
-0.0392076485,
0.4639984965,
0.4229956269,
0.2736194432,
0.4433273971,
0.708073318,
1.2439172268,
0.0735223144,
0.315592289,
-0.108865194,
-0.2220300436,
-0.1471134424,
-0.7828397155,
-1.1667382717,
-0.4589143395,
-0.2778023481,
-0.2321750373,
0.0437378138,
1.0021343231,
0.6260362864,
-0.4924466312,
-0.4861060977,
-0.2535444498,
-0.0261406377,
0.1688339859,
-0.2598508,
-0.2956840396,
-0.6772773266,
-0.994040966,
0.5001202226,
0.3873631358,
-0.2155292481,
-0.281314373,
-0.1130712628,
0.1755870581,
0.3327377737,
0.6774755716,
0.2564719021,
-0.7340615392,
-0.2748778462,
-0.1453968436,
0.0588911697,
0.2550243139,
1.2878410816,
-0.8188627958,
0.3567280173,
0.4036143422,
0.3078234792,
0.5797205567,
0.256564945,
0.6952211857,
-0.4823843241,
0.2585327923,
0.6031450033,
0.3335457146,
0.3549311459,
-0.1153782904,
0.2776276171,
0.1319806427,
-0.6551387906,
-0.8608547449,
0.307952553,
-1.1147595644,
-0.3600791097,
1.2580730915,
-0.1408896148,
-0.2902109623,
-0.3837155998,
-0.4339392483,
0.1063211039,
-0.5449377298,
0.6258211136,
0.7844508886,
-0.3039508462,
-0.2209041268,
-0.5246818066,
0.483296454,
0.5792105794,
-0.9883891344,
0.0745708421,
0.4856164753,
0.1281969547,
0.123079136,
0.9915639162,
-0.1427742392,
-0.099446319,
-0.3292812705,
0.1713134199,
0.2191884965,
-0.2079453319,
0.0941473544,
-0.0057377773,
0.3046592474,
0.2044152617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17205v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17205v3
|
Measuring Vision-Language STEM Skills of Neural Models
| 2024-02-27T04:55:03 | 2024-05-22T05:11:56 |
Jianhao Shen, Ye Yuan, Srbuhi Mirzoyan, Ming Zhang, Chenguang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce a new challenge to test the STEM skills of neural models. The
problems in the real world often require solutions, combining knowledge from
STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math). Unlike existing datasets,
our dataset requires the understanding of multimodal vision-language
information of STEM. Our dataset features one of the largest and most
comprehensive datasets for the challenge. It includes 448 skills and 1,073,146
questions spanning all STEM subjects. Compared to existing datasets that often
focus on examining expert-level ability, our dataset includes fundamental
skills and questions designed based on the K-12 curriculum. We also add
state-of-the-art foundation models such as CLIP and GPT-3.5-Turbo to our
benchmark. Results show that the recent model advances only help master a very
limited number of lower grade-level skills (2.5% in the third grade) in our
dataset. In fact, these models are still well below (averaging 54.7%) the
performance of elementary students, not to mention near expert-level
performance. To understand and increase the performance on our dataset, we
teach the models on a training split of our dataset. Even though we observe
improved performance, the model performance remains relatively low compared to
average elementary students. To solve STEM problems, we will need novel
algorithmic innovations from the community.
|
[
-0.3095612228,
-0.6805120707,
0.3117845654,
0.1564626247,
-0.0228671785,
0.4470637143,
-0.1124038175,
-0.4101064503,
0.1139832214,
0.185741663,
-0.7316444516,
-0.4765812159,
-0.6750642657,
-0.194316715,
-0.4981922805,
0.489176333,
0.133627668,
0.4919736087,
-0.4420892596,
0.1575744003,
-0.7070690393,
-0.2586100399,
-0.5651068091,
-0.2140844613,
0.4172461033,
0.6855905652,
0.2451868504,
0.6107031107,
0.928168416,
0.1954528093,
-0.3076377213,
0.0511509627,
-0.1846487671,
-0.1487578005,
-0.107349664,
-0.5193110704,
-0.4082348645,
0.0979381055,
0.4213019013,
1.2923140526,
0.1867586076,
0.1486549824,
-0.108974956,
0.6932446957,
-0.3024760187,
0.2888143063,
-0.812454164,
0.1208114997,
-0.0657678023,
0.0329997391,
-0.2795186937,
-0.4714886844,
0.369012028,
-0.5163416266,
0.4851843417,
-0.147357285,
0.8588898182,
0.2958130538,
-0.3524996042,
0.06524802,
-0.4705324471,
0.7536625266,
-0.2974381745,
0.3896297216,
0.2068212479,
0.4550302327,
0.1375525892,
-0.4338045418,
-0.3477377295,
-0.3269152343,
0.5304009914,
0.2932669818,
-0.1359980404,
-0.0941974595,
0.1568897963,
0.2689313293,
-0.5970227122,
0.1636231393,
-0.8812355399,
-0.1908549815,
0.5285984874,
0.3018526137,
0.0944209769,
-0.1100533605,
-0.2854060829,
-0.5136927962,
-0.6715759039,
0.2478297651,
0.4078721404,
0.303060025,
0.2042264342,
0.7282567024,
-0.2778265774,
0.6783878803,
-0.1568213254,
-0.0229479466,
0.2992567718,
-0.6478307247,
0.1074433625,
-0.3524924815,
0.358854562,
0.5915167928,
0.6550559998,
-0.0014207608,
-0.0311016124,
0.243429929,
-0.0034568519,
-0.5975643992,
-0.4945379794,
-0.2752459645,
-0.3379265368,
-0.2730125785,
-0.2037156373,
-0.6508957744,
-0.4261232018,
-0.4762646258,
0.284958601,
-0.6415781379,
-0.4621298313,
0.2059265226,
-0.2834685445,
0.0768021569,
0.3828976452,
-0.9605513811,
0.3653738499,
0.6888599992,
0.8357775211,
-0.4970006049,
-0.6250245571,
0.0054718596,
-0.569453001,
-0.4481612146,
0.725022316,
-0.5053850412,
-0.1622210443,
-0.2592284381,
-0.2238729,
-0.3411331475,
-0.669516325,
0.1950107962,
-0.2475156188,
-0.2310553342,
-0.4200288951,
-0.5585757494,
-0.1397741288,
0.2002364993,
-0.4809806645,
1.0072169304,
0.2415409237,
-0.3692976832,
0.5371966958,
-0.7923172116,
-0.3658632338,
0.1397000998,
-0.151028201,
-0.1215406582,
0.3226423264,
0.2833672166,
0.4110181034,
-0.1500279605,
0.4432885349,
-0.280626893,
-0.1254357994,
0.1179083139,
-0.5251199603,
0.837680757,
-0.1058082283,
-0.0684457496,
0.1973916292,
-0.8433246017,
0.1651210487,
0.0447717868,
0.0141921444,
-0.1874860078,
0.0213673487,
0.2978086472,
0.2758002877,
0.2087436318,
-0.7515031695,
0.1353246421,
-0.4419180751,
0.6059649587,
0.8881076574,
-0.1771045774,
0.3190038502,
-0.1131865606,
0.5935964584,
0.12649104,
0.3090130985,
-0.2358408272,
-0.872061193,
-0.792783916,
-0.097428821,
0.2856816649,
0.4948894978,
-0.5962933898,
0.2551132441,
-0.2710585296,
-0.8030222654,
-0.6291567683,
-0.061281424,
0.363160789,
0.9111422896,
0.5660908818,
-0.4385901988,
-0.3805620074,
-1.0542523861,
0.0275887679,
-0.0837346762,
0.110855706,
0.3373993635,
0.9061644077,
0.3694328964,
1.1294225454,
-0.6975985169,
-0.1185556278,
-0.1103436276,
0.2298391908,
0.1872056872,
0.6298608184,
0.5562690496,
-0.8909000754,
-0.3034776449,
-0.041479487,
-0.768097043,
0.1575217396,
0.3223145008,
0.1491073519,
-0.1853750497,
0.3125109971,
-0.3991256058,
0.5047824979,
0.4165933728,
-0.5118399262,
0.6334336996,
0.00340013,
0.0723802447,
-0.8328592777,
-0.0112709692,
0.02444176,
0.27747491,
-0.5862693787,
0.0343644805,
0.2278444171,
-0.4123330116,
-0.6608369946,
0.4032177031,
-0.3019984663,
-0.3463855088,
-0.1659498364,
-0.1091906726,
-0.1751666367,
0.4413430989,
0.1122989878,
0.8624626398,
0.9008587599,
-0.422290802,
0.5939098001,
0.0998048261,
-0.6300597191,
0.6470951438,
-0.931317687,
-0.0188130308,
-0.0316253938,
-0.2018979341,
-0.9728868008,
-0.2820697129,
-0.2799851894,
-0.6237723231,
-0.1067992076,
-0.1274967343,
-0.3924644589,
-0.5932027698,
0.0460356437,
0.2203000039,
0.4415557086,
-0.3581445515,
0.5917767286,
0.2720952034,
-0.2291065007,
-0.6865031719,
-0.7050801516,
0.0688939244,
0.1279147416,
-0.9893811941,
0.3383840024,
-0.2604997158,
0.0018439927,
0.2745976746,
-0.130869776,
-0.5716019273,
0.4058206975,
0.1141094118,
0.5234110355,
-0.4487929046,
0.1465751082,
-0.0018669988,
-0.2314426154,
0.149460122,
-0.3135996461,
0.48993209,
-0.3643014431,
-0.6760328412,
-0.3699240088,
0.2034833133,
0.7980496883,
-0.5396901369,
0.4009897113,
0.2333816439,
-0.5120392442,
-0.0125429137,
-0.4652731419,
-0.5065132976,
-0.413867265,
0.884804666,
-0.4957262576,
-0.8331703544,
0.4828296006,
0.1480550021,
-0.0290997382,
0.2368697673,
0.3141992092,
-0.1529365331,
1.0616185665,
0.7537667155,
0.0052374396,
0.2418702543,
-0.4895373881,
0.1952195019,
-0.614372015,
-0.5882555842,
-0.278506875,
-0.4438414872,
0.0072852001,
-0.354885906,
0.2773030102,
0.0353803076,
0.08613123,
0.3745951653,
-0.600217998,
0.671731174,
0.7911294699,
0.1785744876,
0.2427526414,
0.0563026629,
-0.1339630485,
-0.3399061859,
-0.6668345928,
-0.0803074539,
1.2275022268,
0.3836322427,
0.559828043,
-0.3448878825,
0.2856658697,
-0.2093877345,
0.0870246217,
-1.0326867104,
0.6781300902,
-0.2811261714,
-0.7803710699,
-0.2278145999,
-0.3492230475,
-0.5505113602,
0.1637987792,
-0.1360025406,
-0.26961568,
0.2840802372,
0.2385998368,
-0.3395294249,
0.3961395621,
-0.9425965548,
0.985571146,
-0.2748295069,
-0.178399384,
-0.1731236577,
-0.5272952318,
0.1865565181,
-0.0567874908,
-0.0525379889,
-0.347016722,
0.058889851,
0.8308534622,
-0.1358713955,
0.9321268797,
-0.2902208269,
0.3323462307,
0.2883435786,
-0.2306630611,
-0.1210858151,
-0.2478803396,
0.1149618104,
0.1073640734,
-0.184768185,
-0.4495558441,
-0.4776610434,
0.602971971,
-0.767408967,
-0.4310409725,
-0.4477217495,
-0.8429219127,
-0.3356419206,
0.2111845464,
0.2107030898,
0.3843687475,
-0.0085823964,
0.603428781,
0.8532334566,
0.1919294745,
0.3945032954,
0.4869761765,
-0.215097338,
-0.3189870715,
1.2185553312,
0.4828034341,
0.3313697875,
0.0422045439,
0.2974749207,
-0.1171839535,
-0.8762737513,
-0.3298752904,
0.0142836189,
-0.7787042856,
-0.1522841603,
-0.5053287745,
-0.3768146038,
-0.3937466443,
-0.0493123606,
-0.558106184,
-0.5217800736,
-0.2778626382,
-0.3220887482,
0.4108380079,
0.7284060121,
-0.0002535923,
0.1847781837,
-0.4989875853,
0.1059746891,
0.4591167271,
0.3220541179,
0.040046487,
-0.393466264,
-0.1319026649,
-0.0341358781,
-0.268497467,
-0.8031075597,
0.2685486078,
0.2517331839,
0.4506505132,
0.1167656481,
-0.4635197222,
0.6914703846,
-0.5943650007,
0.7711083889,
0.318937093,
-0.842905581,
0.6823183298,
-0.2526918054,
0.0772661194,
0.6995206475,
0.4079948366,
-0.3523735702,
-0.2160525322,
-0.5497890711,
-0.6727617383,
0.6250743866,
0.0465915203,
0.144836247,
0.1267288476,
0.267203182,
-0.0750266537,
0.2377237678,
-0.4549740255,
-0.2765941024,
-0.4687935114,
-0.363824755,
0.166973874,
0.1451436579,
0.1017355099,
-0.6891680956,
0.3188172281,
-0.2592359483,
-0.0637661964,
-0.0788155124,
0.1738832146,
0.1209666431,
-0.0570318252,
0.6318201423,
0.9700753093,
-0.1134597957,
0.0142832445,
0.1437989622,
-0.8926773667,
-0.0144693702,
-0.0068841591,
-0.2650289834,
-0.1838366985,
0.423763901,
0.6506522894,
0.2154052258,
-0.7872726917,
0.6911565065,
0.036729183,
-0.5614067316,
-0.3531785309,
0.1551521868,
0.2681759,
-0.0501488,
0.7341266274,
0.7562254667,
-0.0638865978,
-0.2362205386,
0.3710642159,
0.2242027372,
-0.5507043004,
-0.393263191,
0.4053600132,
0.2786852717,
-0.1890091598,
0.7173640728,
0.0477472059,
-0.5517783761,
1.2345097065,
0.4201005101,
0.4956166744,
-0.2003411502,
0.234187454,
0.5223651528,
0.5645753741,
-0.1936558485,
0.5639519691,
0.3275410533,
-0.8481447101,
-0.6353380084,
-0.2563042939,
-0.5063835979,
0.1600554734,
-0.6798636913,
0.113843143,
-0.4418725967,
-0.0831063315,
0.0623443536,
-0.2022357881,
-0.6534730792,
0.4796270132,
-0.223564744,
1.2019408941,
-1.1829731464,
0.8204721808,
0.6945360899,
-0.5236980915,
-0.6487045884,
-0.5242902637,
-0.0365015604,
-1.0034366846,
1.1711120605,
0.1725841165,
-0.0118641565,
0.2104508132,
-0.6552743912,
-0.9125729203,
1.0094412565,
0.4084987044,
-0.4851250947,
-0.3133239746,
0.01351301,
0.5609560609,
-0.5884281993,
0.2142731845,
0.3590076566,
0.2933460474,
0.2635116279,
-0.8547754288,
-0.6149249077,
-0.3998599052,
-0.0277968068,
-0.1302594244,
-0.3399430215,
1.0243828297,
-0.275555402,
0.0854049698,
-0.0329753608,
0.8552929163,
0.3143196106,
0.4239487648,
0.5116379261,
0.6417627931,
0.7746320963,
-0.4781807065,
0.7039818764,
-0.2575833499,
0.2998768091,
0.9869197011,
-0.0683898926,
1.028131485,
0.6402247548,
-0.0369420759,
0.0696510896,
0.6759751439,
-0.4050547779,
0.4491635859,
0.3504810929,
0.0107519003,
-0.5286591649,
-0.3527990878,
-0.441390723,
0.4811009467,
0.2878321409,
-0.0946760327,
-0.0200287141,
0.4376232624,
-0.2386775464,
0.376381129,
-0.4314665496,
0.1534411311,
-0.1138085425,
-0.6307886839,
0.3647561371,
-0.2592392266,
0.797091186,
-0.5135777593,
-0.2306083888,
-0.1717657745,
0.2513524592,
-0.0296525899,
-1.087567091,
0.3130147457,
-0.006846528,
-0.3885691762,
-0.2218634933,
0.5799506307,
-0.3125605583,
-0.8370342851,
0.3182190657,
0.4930692315,
0.1270350814,
-0.0832872838,
-0.5894895792,
-0.0799737722,
-0.0932327658,
0.1811106056,
0.0315998942,
0.0952699557,
0.0906767249,
0.871171236,
0.6429451108,
0.2508234382,
0.5588797331,
0.0192968976,
0.8698319197,
-0.389384836,
-0.140898481,
-0.5337033272,
0.5610550046,
-0.2925809026,
-0.9115633368,
0.5979946256,
0.6310997009,
1.0523226261,
-0.2222223729,
0.6908600926,
0.0308653638,
0.5905307531,
-0.402698189,
0.6540783048,
-0.5429611802,
-0.1463385969,
-0.1060508192,
-0.7277026176,
-0.273798883,
0.6444278955,
-0.3493979871,
0.1056850851,
0.8993666172,
0.7242343426,
-0.1183940247,
0.1339630038,
0.4710916877,
-0.0684034675,
0.1569902897,
0.8988559246,
0.9565497637,
-0.4238147736,
0.5644506812,
-0.5995080471,
-0.472863704,
-0.0222068615,
-0.6888369918,
-1.1505428553,
-0.6198793054,
-0.4012621939,
0.0691708922,
0.1105223,
0.6127908826,
1.0285304785,
-0.7885233164,
-0.2539654672,
-0.4220967293,
-0.0188884921,
-0.549051106,
-0.1947800815,
0.4065042734,
-0.2220186889,
-0.7118977904,
0.9154681563,
0.0120506547,
0.093545571,
-0.4691989124,
0.2788247466,
-0.1361144334,
-0.3662081659,
0.4661305845,
0.1589915752,
-0.7041597962,
-0.2820841074,
0.7921826839,
0.0335988775,
0.0866446197,
0.6937218308,
-0.6222960353,
0.4483289123,
0.6385239363,
0.8404377699,
0.2853392065,
-0.309615314,
0.2909908891,
-0.6187122464,
-0.0795715377,
0.5459349751,
0.4330306649,
0.3633645475,
-0.0257515032,
0.5824646354,
0.6703411937,
-0.2242109478,
-0.7487429976,
0.3700496852,
-0.8431992531,
-0.1650416106,
0.5839928985,
-0.2645121217,
-0.17703031,
-0.1574523151,
-0.0518606119,
-0.1411662996,
-0.2213764638,
0.4992507398,
0.9811902642,
-0.1264806092,
-0.2490394115,
-0.6557780504,
0.1726466417,
0.686775744,
-0.7187632322,
-0.0870004594,
0.3411587179,
0.2507300079,
0.4669574201,
0.3286332488,
-0.1047930494,
0.5872547626,
0.097572349,
0.2130159736,
-0.4805830717,
-1.0018459558,
-0.3091150224,
0.4716149569,
-0.0788078979,
-0.3057767451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17193v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17193v1
|
When Scaling Meets LLM Finetuning: The Effect of Data, Model and Finetuning Method
| 2024-02-27T04:18:49 | 2024-02-27T04:18:49 |
Biao Zhang, Zhongtao Liu, Colin Cherry, Orhan Firat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) often adopt finetuning to unlock their
capabilities for downstream applications, our understanding on the inductive
biases (especially the scaling properties) of different finetuning methods is
still limited. To fill this gap, we conduct systematic experiments studying
whether and how different scaling factors, including LLM model size,
pretraining data size, new finetuning parameter size and finetuning data size,
affect the finetuning performance. We consider two types of finetuning --
full-model tuning (FMT) and parameter efficient tuning (PET, including prompt
tuning and LoRA), and explore their scaling behaviors in the data-limited
regime where the LLM model size substantially outweighs the finetuning data
size. Based on two sets of pretrained bilingual LLMs from 1B to 16B and
experiments on bilingual machine translation and multilingual summarization
benchmarks, we find that 1) LLM finetuning follows a powerbased multiplicative
joint scaling law between finetuning data size and each other scaling factor;
2) LLM finetuning benefits more from LLM model scaling than pretraining data
scaling, and PET parameter scaling is generally ineffective; and 3) the optimal
finetuning method is highly task- and finetuning data-dependent. We hope our
findings could shed light on understanding, selecting and developing LLM
finetuning methods.
|
[
-0.7606683373,
-0.8323109746,
0.3468855917,
0.3938019872,
-0.3645961285,
-0.4005851448,
-0.7278556824,
-0.3590478003,
-0.0793308616,
0.5292539001,
-0.5023916364,
0.0616136044,
-0.5700987577,
0.341638267,
-0.1339553446,
1.2023197412,
0.0164691545,
0.5282478333,
-0.0865581408,
-0.2372263074,
-0.2576746345,
-0.3938499987,
-0.652682066,
-0.6661030054,
0.5914332867,
0.7366821766,
0.8847170472,
1.0588293076,
0.7736941576,
0.2522102296,
-0.2158994973,
0.0222013853,
-0.7018676996,
-0.1515396535,
-0.0216381513,
-0.9040510654,
-0.5257810354,
0.1370920241,
0.7025657296,
0.8643596768,
-0.0114521058,
0.2622250915,
0.3928748071,
0.7206380963,
-0.4214066863,
0.1261358708,
-0.5782400966,
-0.2195965201,
-0.3144136071,
-0.1609245539,
-0.1974863559,
-0.270804584,
-0.1059597656,
-0.4028499722,
0.3737568557,
-0.0433724374,
0.8099671602,
0.4859314561,
-0.5671861768,
-0.1713427007,
-0.7180370092,
0.8619981408,
-0.9723951817,
0.3721732497,
0.3213378787,
0.1326235086,
0.0677853972,
-0.472045809,
-0.3848296404,
-0.2591195703,
-0.195474878,
-0.2761647105,
0.1523351669,
0.2620820403,
0.6276922822,
0.9083518386,
-0.2418133169,
0.6611596346,
-0.3343398869,
-0.0426038615,
0.5387250185,
0.2304860204,
0.0744323879,
0.0030460556,
-0.2169453353,
-0.066787146,
-0.9202420115,
-0.0624552928,
0.2715215385,
0.7970499396,
-0.2785069346,
0.6219744086,
-0.2669357359,
0.6183365583,
0.3328685462,
-0.1750989407,
0.0088665215,
-0.7123212218,
-0.3619389236,
-0.086040549,
0.7947584987,
0.721588552,
0.4620084465,
-0.1467117965,
-0.2432367057,
-0.3023784161,
-0.1606730819,
-1.1484223604,
0.1305841357,
-0.1053960919,
-0.4210489392,
-0.2096356452,
-0.1622955948,
-0.4383195043,
-0.4802250862,
-0.8059383035,
0.6656350493,
-0.220023036,
-0.304823041,
-0.0369151123,
0.2106096745,
0.5003429651,
0.1852908134,
-1.3137335777,
0.3488613665,
0.6881082058,
0.8789258599,
-0.2158845514,
-0.2914908826,
-0.5844307542,
-0.3733622134,
-0.307195425,
0.4566963911,
-0.0085212244,
-0.100939244,
-0.1776377857,
0.1817857027,
-0.0909480229,
-0.7691006064,
0.531850338,
-0.3523041308,
-0.2981911004,
-0.4336221814,
-0.4723034501,
0.0114605362,
0.0856247842,
-0.9207128286,
0.4995832443,
-0.1035477817,
-0.7299706936,
0.6577521563,
-0.2717837989,
-0.546428144,
-0.3439188898,
0.0058581894,
-0.3652706146,
0.3148144782,
0.1675711274,
0.7497697473,
-0.6579672694,
0.0383765101,
-0.3103482723,
-0.2599562109,
0.1757728159,
-0.6325894594,
0.6646983027,
0.1527213156,
-0.1045936272,
0.0618092678,
-0.839347899,
0.0160254762,
0.107908532,
-0.621460855,
-0.2777896821,
-0.1005913913,
0.2469666153,
0.0954097137,
0.303869307,
-0.6128293276,
0.1869137436,
-0.4809688926,
0.6101005077,
0.5446189642,
-0.0521597639,
0.6585124731,
-0.4991765022,
0.3913722038,
-0.256795764,
-0.0283860583,
-0.0665940419,
0.035429813,
-0.8790736198,
-0.1231518537,
0.5375899673,
0.3440035582,
-0.2688240111,
-0.0326467194,
-0.2122971863,
-0.441917479,
-0.4861622751,
0.222743094,
0.2822955251,
0.1751615852,
0.3127238154,
-0.1346765608,
-0.3766950965,
-1.0727661848,
-0.267151475,
0.3810563385,
-0.2862346172,
0.1297752261,
0.1487243325,
-0.0032233577,
0.6665445566,
-0.1446046233,
-0.2852615714,
-0.4207644165,
0.115689151,
0.2594185174,
0.5110374689,
0.6026605368,
-0.4998166859,
-0.6134821177,
0.1512839496,
-0.2698380351,
-0.2353902161,
-0.1652432829,
0.2845441401,
0.2282360643,
0.6971890926,
-0.4363280833,
0.0037537441,
0.6362912059,
-0.0655356944,
0.4828774631,
-0.3013688624,
0.0637091473,
-0.7724927068,
-0.3342610598,
0.086720258,
-0.2398170233,
-0.7147472501,
0.2227346599,
0.2420327067,
0.2761587501,
-0.3800752461,
0.1598828733,
-0.4502882659,
-0.1095226035,
-0.2263838649,
-0.0475656874,
-0.1242694035,
0.3224095106,
-0.2269419283,
0.9048373699,
0.3613405526,
-0.6277080178,
-0.0136112347,
-0.1796899587,
-0.4167115092,
0.4160729647,
-0.602073729,
-0.1581151932,
0.0115919607,
-0.0949243307,
-0.8671219945,
-0.1035550386,
-0.4003660381,
-0.1159586906,
0.5467472672,
-0.1426873952,
-0.833473742,
0.0209029224,
-0.3494291902,
0.3810396791,
0.1188142225,
-0.6357057095,
0.4220843911,
-0.0608047806,
-0.2000762224,
-0.0739546642,
-0.8657454252,
-0.2984522879,
-0.5820814967,
-0.6139699221,
0.226691708,
-0.196191445,
-0.4096985757,
-0.6017867327,
-0.1745054871,
-0.0849739835,
0.1188662574,
0.1353656203,
0.1330099255,
-0.4879562557,
-0.0227395818,
0.0239529256,
-0.0066818842,
0.1257773042,
0.131434679,
0.6689081788,
-0.3489589393,
0.0744343996,
-0.386757344,
0.0815408751,
0.8696069121,
-0.3696014881,
0.7359523177,
0.6401667595,
0.0073921997,
0.0031863223,
-0.6164836287,
-0.3486631215,
-0.4861523211,
0.3336444497,
-0.3716922998,
-0.7952648401,
0.7112874389,
-0.2141222656,
0.3092773557,
0.6525704861,
0.8002038598,
-0.0045996024,
1.0279729366,
0.8818690777,
0.0427300781,
0.5838571191,
-0.2506694794,
-0.0670636743,
-0.9166986942,
0.3224746287,
-0.5108206868,
-0.5852096677,
-1.1010199785,
-0.3088797927,
0.17172499,
0.3308320642,
-0.3506072164,
0.1097082496,
-0.1081528962,
0.6813336015,
0.3945535421,
-0.028613003,
0.5894165635,
0.02022985,
-0.0921407193,
-0.1241421774,
-0.6299495101,
-0.2623201609,
1.4679762125,
0.3520153761,
0.9879062772,
0.0516554788,
0.3838023841,
-0.189424336,
0.2799246013,
-1.0300801992,
0.2658847272,
-0.3633285165,
-0.5354572535,
-0.57582587,
-0.3232843578,
-0.8426043987,
0.415945828,
-0.2951186299,
-0.3829391599,
0.0888645649,
0.0135568436,
-0.4356611669,
0.2587149739,
-0.8367748857,
0.5729743242,
-0.2875307798,
-0.4346857667,
-0.3055799305,
-0.6123466492,
0.1597316265,
-0.2671765387,
0.3371789157,
-0.1147653759,
0.0262155328,
0.6873193979,
-0.4440443218,
0.7338347435,
0.0225217808,
-0.3849820495,
-0.0047050989,
0.1005929261,
0.4906344116,
0.0185093507,
-0.0739566982,
0.1798232049,
0.0719709545,
-0.1991038024,
-0.3616629541,
0.8807983398,
-0.870438695,
-0.5445144773,
0.1495003849,
-0.7830670476,
-0.4165750444,
0.3195820153,
0.4777614474,
0.3008319736,
-0.022998387,
0.607347846,
0.6614133716,
0.1479395032,
0.5105439425,
0.7400853634,
-0.2394412607,
-0.1032722518,
0.8199832439,
0.5751425624,
0.8833658695,
0.3525882363,
0.3163641691,
0.0833671689,
-0.6487641335,
-0.3653054535,
0.4331851602,
-0.3683952689,
-0.1303166151,
-0.1689476967,
-0.1959325373,
-0.0682312399,
-0.0510915406,
-0.6778600216,
-0.5602932572,
-0.2568938136,
-0.1805850416,
0.4406110346,
0.4594815969,
-0.1338549703,
0.473305732,
-0.3982897997,
0.2864628136,
0.3171262741,
0.496324569,
-0.0199060291,
-0.4872942269,
-0.5114957094,
0.1344441324,
-0.226983726,
-0.3359736502,
-0.0501363911,
0.3371266723,
0.2549171746,
0.5753038526,
-0.1310855001,
0.5256951451,
-0.6292394996,
0.5095239282,
-0.0394250154,
-0.5239138603,
0.2390707284,
-0.5691587925,
0.4816750586,
0.5104346871,
0.3314851224,
-0.2810219824,
-0.3898534179,
-0.2724514008,
-0.8526360393,
0.5451684594,
0.0302231293,
0.1767131239,
0.2715167999,
0.5167326331,
0.4205507338,
-0.0584228113,
-0.7813789248,
-0.395186156,
0.1050082073,
0.2063719332,
-0.5121979117,
-0.252653867,
-0.0115641654,
-0.3748047352,
0.318516165,
-0.1302599013,
0.0981217325,
-0.0269619152,
-0.0845292732,
-0.2787146866,
0.4685377479,
0.5635344386,
0.533056736,
-0.2720707357,
-0.037785355,
0.3005169034,
-0.3790927827,
-0.0449489057,
0.1354204714,
-0.1771349013,
-0.2328636944,
0.4419464767,
0.8089669347,
0.174483031,
-0.4366113544,
0.1654773653,
-0.1132737771,
-0.4150641859,
0.1552910209,
0.2240230292,
0.1756443232,
0.3142257035,
0.0949846357,
-0.1582162529,
-0.0388211794,
-0.4183733463,
-0.0369787291,
0.4532425106,
-0.2267136276,
-0.1543583572,
0.6448105574,
0.0051532756,
0.0073557585,
0.4705142975,
0.2168322802,
-0.0098486906,
0.7111207843,
0.5765553117,
0.3203034699,
-0.2501885593,
-0.2364673465,
0.4218273163,
0.4596956968,
-0.1416117251,
-0.0705575794,
-0.1146520898,
-0.6128278375,
-0.6085090637,
-0.6617109776,
-0.2616579235,
0.4081207216,
-0.9510896802,
0.3323478997,
-0.4771323204,
-0.273762852,
0.2370551974,
0.2238058597,
-0.769259274,
0.225387007,
0.0625307187,
0.7562072873,
-0.8127102256,
0.7076943517,
0.5007241368,
-0.3562610745,
-0.8761755824,
0.0877086148,
0.1619694531,
-0.6740715504,
0.4204281271,
0.1300716549,
-0.0160734504,
0.1714443117,
-0.388948828,
-1.1161991358,
1.0956749916,
0.4928094745,
-0.7835814953,
-0.0127937123,
0.4896374345,
0.5051365495,
-0.1721643806,
0.011700023,
0.9864674211,
0.3080193698,
-0.089988701,
-1.4715731144,
0.0118216751,
0.0546462722,
-0.1579537839,
0.263179332,
-0.9816768169,
1.0873726606,
-0.1979380101,
0.0169868432,
0.0536692664,
0.4486955702,
-0.0967059284,
-0.0428721532,
0.4469736814,
0.4669813514,
0.5800064802,
-0.0565270111,
0.8773813248,
-0.2205595821,
0.5302670002,
1.1560435295,
0.0533960685,
0.7543957829,
0.6775682569,
-0.3685496747,
0.0060279416,
0.6805160046,
-0.0147017129,
0.3906219304,
0.3421422839,
0.0943726078,
-0.0945549607,
-0.1954131573,
-0.4856320024,
0.348656565,
0.3574477732,
-0.3941310346,
-0.320468545,
0.4768857956,
0.248028338,
-0.1071996167,
-0.7347513437,
0.6999198198,
0.1580692679,
-0.4660506546,
0.9509067535,
0.2083721459,
0.830947876,
-0.3974198997,
0.4662941992,
-0.5959793329,
0.2876296937,
-0.2291874439,
-0.6114895344,
0.2152131647,
0.0750428364,
-0.4062339664,
-0.3279166222,
0.3124417961,
-0.3644353747,
-0.3745959699,
0.1214999557,
0.3252895176,
-0.0048724301,
-0.10523168,
-0.2023424655,
0.0474072807,
0.0148104876,
-0.3845942914,
0.6182394028,
0.5652573705,
-0.0590751506,
0.6491850615,
0.3642156124,
0.2949353456,
0.1340406239,
0.3150553107,
0.6862660646,
-0.3767447472,
-0.205936864,
-0.972222805,
0.2406735718,
0.3309171498,
-0.0570855066,
0.9088671207,
0.6509481072,
0.9397421479,
0.015431365,
0.3283005655,
0.068544805,
0.3259629309,
-0.6592847109,
0.6707137823,
-0.5703648925,
0.1110076904,
-0.0336471386,
-1.0218687057,
-0.334007591,
0.3282374442,
-0.429045558,
0.028772695,
0.5930507779,
0.7231565714,
-0.1679226011,
0.0073289596,
0.2911528945,
0.5060994625,
0.1095448881,
0.3412454724,
0.3405309021,
-0.248395741,
0.4473588765,
-0.3749668002,
-0.2151135504,
-0.2159783393,
-0.6121351123,
-0.9861302376,
-0.4525328279,
-0.1696698964,
-0.0445451476,
-0.3965931237,
0.8054388165,
0.5810310841,
-0.5824759007,
-0.3735054731,
-0.2156467289,
0.0060842074,
-0.1746867448,
-0.2439699769,
0.2108948827,
-0.4114318192,
-0.7046881318,
0.0664904639,
-0.0245809928,
0.2263822556,
-0.284779489,
0.0386244617,
0.0422873981,
0.1539286226,
0.6137641072,
0.1340229213,
-0.6638599634,
0.0038702986,
-0.2667345703,
-0.2115069777,
0.1936506331,
0.8331776261,
-0.3866547048,
0.3100456595,
0.2956907153,
0.4721615613,
0.6831931472,
-0.1312422156,
0.5993279219,
-0.5825557113,
0.1628742218,
-0.243768394,
0.1109025031,
0.2089705318,
-0.3135386109,
0.4290454686,
-0.2676988244,
-0.7675845623,
-0.6962329149,
0.0658308268,
-0.7425625324,
-0.0337694511,
1.2029658556,
0.2113651335,
0.1292404681,
0.4312162399,
-0.2643979788,
0.2442854643,
0.0034219278,
0.3863120675,
0.9042800665,
-0.2995764017,
-0.161445573,
-1.0890730619,
0.6499245167,
0.5040196776,
-0.4277497232,
0.5425889492,
0.3767885864,
0.3818980455,
-0.0870353207,
0.3085293472,
0.0487210415,
0.0909382179,
-0.2366989553,
-0.3326709569,
0.0252590626,
-0.1112992615,
-0.5394194722,
-0.0246677659,
0.4070915282,
0.1910688132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14657v1
|
A Synergistic Approach to Wildfire Prevention and Management Using AI, ML, and 5G Technology in the United States
| 2024-02-27T04:09:30 | 2024-02-27T04:09:30 |
Stanley Chinedu Okoro, Alexander Lopez, Austine Unuriode
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Over the past few years, wildfires have become a worldwide environmental
emergency, resulting in substantial harm to natural habitats and playing a part
in the acceleration of climate change. Wildfire management methods involve
prevention, response, and recovery efforts. Despite improvements in detection
techniques, the rising occurrence of wildfires demands creative solutions for
prompt identification and effective control. This research investigates
proactive methods for detecting and handling wildfires in the United States,
utilizing Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning (ML), and 5G
technology. The specific objective of this research covers proactive detection
and prevention of wildfires using advanced technology; Active monitoring and
mapping with remote sensing and signaling leveraging on 5G technology; and
Advanced response mechanisms to wildfire using drones and IOT devices. This
study was based on secondary data collected from government databases and
analyzed using descriptive statistics. In addition, past publications were
reviewed through content analysis, and narrative synthesis was used to present
the observations from various studies. The results showed that developing new
technology presents an opportunity to detect and manage wildfires proactively.
Utilizing advanced technology could save lives and prevent significant economic
losses caused by wildfires. Various methods, such as AI-enabled remote sensing
and 5G-based active monitoring, can enhance proactive wildfire detection and
management. In addition, super intelligent drones and IOT devices can be used
for safer responses to wildfires. This forms the core of the recommendation to
the fire Management Agencies and the government.
|
[
-0.1795989871,
-0.9206528664,
-0.0346041545,
0.2166973799,
-0.2569429576,
0.2205772698,
0.1204516664,
-0.4317533672,
0.0168188177,
0.5262872577,
-0.7363357544,
-0.2559106946,
-0.070368804,
-0.1455285698,
-0.4815312624,
0.6784788966,
-0.0008652366,
-0.3449548185,
0.1789226532,
-0.0923636407,
-0.7541106939,
-0.3748919964,
-0.3885092437,
-0.2525690794,
0.7268389463,
0.4264343977,
0.9157342911,
0.0461596958,
1.2311600447,
0.3576889336,
0.2463753074,
-0.1462844014,
0.0236007161,
-0.0074115396,
0.372089386,
-0.4487126768,
-0.2128895372,
0.414008975,
0.1183444262,
0.0257183444,
-0.3858910799,
-0.095798783,
-0.5022674203,
0.6213308573,
-0.6423280239,
-0.1228296608,
-0.7543489337,
0.2080792785,
-0.110809207,
-0.648493588,
0.1653180271,
-0.4568941593,
0.2154328227,
-0.682071507,
0.3424224854,
0.02498734,
0.3290694356,
0.5022851825,
-0.6008980274,
-0.4285840988,
-1.3456622362,
0.4865254462,
-0.5253388882,
-0.1412109733,
0.2409147918,
0.7549538016,
-0.4937159419,
-0.7471283674,
-0.9378405213,
-0.0168482736,
0.1767870933,
0.5066710114,
-0.1804860532,
-0.1134157255,
0.0425238758,
0.3001368642,
-0.836324811,
0.1046092808,
-0.4067527652,
-0.381391257,
1.1774786711,
0.0315872505,
0.0995772555,
0.104381904,
-0.5659404993,
-0.0525518805,
-0.9247252345,
0.3320473433,
0.7953411341,
-0.1746393442,
0.1409511119,
0.2668225467,
-0.0840123147,
0.645299077,
-0.372284919,
-0.2688064873,
-0.0447918065,
-0.7827222347,
-0.6868100762,
0.0441264398,
0.3550814092,
0.5019224882,
-0.0459923483,
-0.1922736168,
-0.1436705589,
0.42045632,
0.4797303379,
-0.4522352815,
-0.3998456001,
0.3869695961,
-0.6735602617,
-0.6341072917,
0.0824434832,
-0.4487119913,
-0.3881511688,
-0.2366044223,
0.6889829636,
0.1812454909,
-0.7014884949,
-0.0975995883,
-0.188994512,
-0.2215890437,
0.1587718129,
-0.8635525703,
-0.0426195785,
0.3161743581,
0.6007646322,
0.3678122759,
-0.0492219664,
-0.0446059294,
0.0231237672,
-0.0353118442,
0.5122179389,
-0.4723745584,
-0.5350192785,
-0.0865089893,
0.0202689935,
0.0855080634,
-0.6807492375,
0.6946416497,
-0.7566992044,
0.060977269,
-0.1898474842,
-0.070965372,
-0.7559702992,
0.2870094478,
-0.7305497527,
0.9581224918,
-0.3577356637,
-0.4839610755,
0.5358453393,
-0.4863355756,
-0.4209680259,
-0.0412855782,
0.22807163,
-0.9162709713,
0.1723729819,
0.0322074071,
0.4027435184,
-0.0357112847,
0.2334211618,
0.0409490168,
-0.2902002633,
-0.0052692797,
-0.5139984488,
0.7077674866,
0.6408080459,
-0.4439985454,
0.4659509361,
-0.4909925461,
0.1107692868,
0.0651416928,
-0.0535512604,
-0.2659952641,
0.2748113573,
0.0596471056,
0.2037900686,
-0.2266162187,
-0.5547369123,
-0.0605263226,
0.2150876075,
0.339787662,
0.424528569,
0.0739055723,
0.1540670693,
-0.6941765547,
0.1190280393,
0.0344582312,
0.403817147,
-0.4802312553,
-0.2952165008,
-0.2982978225,
-0.1039916053,
-0.2612888217,
1.1889890432,
-0.4482434094,
0.7334322333,
0.3753767014,
-0.8203424215,
0.1348574907,
0.0322222076,
-0.2364421189,
0.2684703171,
0.3988854587,
-0.089029856,
-0.449895978,
-0.1555255949,
-0.3674906194,
0.2095790356,
0.4282743633,
-0.078710869,
0.338631779,
0.1090747938,
1.0482423306,
-0.1551413089,
-0.4315612316,
-0.0774219409,
0.0933302417,
0.1095633209,
0.474378407,
0.7459822297,
-1.5890344381,
-0.270028621,
0.0858072415,
-1.0338298082,
0.1464077979,
-0.4327088296,
0.4053584337,
-0.6185165048,
0.426304996,
-0.4336165786,
0.6839051843,
0.3307757378,
-0.4246277511,
0.3416942656,
-0.3422687948,
0.0820811167,
-0.4943874776,
-0.037398193,
-0.065927051,
0.3728269339,
-0.9622984529,
0.0211051013,
-0.2109830379,
-0.1309994608,
-0.4356726408,
0.3212658167,
-0.2142598778,
-0.09719906,
-0.4823245108,
-0.4827547967,
-0.2428282201,
0.0090925209,
0.0661360994,
0.6807065606,
0.5287704468,
-0.3468921185,
0.9857484102,
0.0418424904,
-0.0077091288,
0.2274105698,
-0.5131630301,
-0.2380209714,
-0.1078623012,
0.6514745951,
-0.646820426,
-0.2481507361,
-0.0142998239,
-0.2589524388,
-0.1430630684,
0.3379474878,
-0.3490535319,
-0.7439923882,
-0.0987754241,
-0.3639307618,
0.4493221939,
-0.219693765,
0.7708153725,
-0.0342444889,
-0.1837374419,
-0.3403073549,
-0.6373921037,
0.2701427639,
-0.6797208786,
-0.5048933029,
0.3219752014,
-0.0385606773,
-0.3301551044,
-0.0460825898,
-0.4861164391,
0.021857731,
0.6412059665,
0.3279304504,
-0.2415557802,
0.2830531895,
0.0861481503,
-0.5980888009,
-0.4549610019,
0.2219792604,
-0.3306294382,
-0.1991921067,
0.5184254646,
-0.2073612213,
-0.8343437314,
0.6513149142,
0.7034853101,
-0.4501270056,
0.5151581168,
1.0696997643,
-0.4545337558,
0.2156857848,
-0.6391025186,
-0.4782876372,
-0.5011156797,
-0.3143756688,
-0.0591663644,
-0.5003513098,
0.469073534,
-0.8523591757,
0.4466844499,
0.1181679145,
0.4670206606,
-0.2496575564,
0.748811245,
0.7660728097,
-0.0147459144,
0.9004834294,
-0.3241703212,
0.6975368857,
-0.2407993376,
-0.6790165901,
-0.4558289945,
-0.5998305082,
-0.4929832518,
0.0277753714,
0.5402782559,
0.3294613063,
-0.2536896765,
0.3309850991,
-0.7117205858,
0.2725823522,
0.6041387916,
0.2607232332,
0.4322688878,
0.1659640074,
0.1942622662,
0.1622872353,
-0.5037056804,
-0.3941001594,
0.9971444607,
0.0502562709,
0.7033939362,
0.4197652936,
0.6828743219,
0.4874202907,
0.4127498567,
-0.4324695468,
0.2397473305,
0.0970687121,
-0.8180639148,
-0.3314815164,
-0.2760733366,
-0.8812733889,
0.1396210641,
-0.5496271849,
-0.1812210977,
0.0411332212,
0.1156489402,
-0.4621828198,
0.0539481491,
-1.0486403704,
0.7091435194,
-0.754970789,
-0.229900986,
-0.6165485382,
-0.7271132469,
0.0814033374,
-0.162414521,
0.304867506,
-0.360429883,
0.2473299205,
0.3604115546,
-0.3808346987,
0.6296508312,
-0.459369123,
0.1981872022,
0.8787462711,
-0.2908213437,
0.9874684215,
-0.1132859439,
-0.1742840409,
-0.1744283587,
-0.3368782699,
-0.5761145949,
-0.2967363894,
0.5648679137,
-0.6678231955,
-0.1526168585,
-0.4337889254,
-0.5105967522,
0.0427057482,
0.3086228371,
0.2226307243,
0.3520553112,
-0.2684051692,
0.0943749174,
0.4509933889,
-0.0576525182,
0.8873370886,
0.1478807032,
0.2486090213,
-0.2193683386,
0.804841876,
0.2854070961,
-0.0289240684,
0.0222560223,
0.4417333305,
-0.1975522786,
-0.8054639101,
-0.0834859535,
-0.5882149935,
-0.2250773609,
-0.3825892806,
-0.6349301934,
-0.1742900461,
-0.1082896516,
-0.3180874884,
0.4774670005,
0.103875421,
0.1282269061,
-0.1955158114,
0.6176581383,
0.5258534551,
-0.0819659978,
0.9530231953,
-0.7257230282,
0.492949903,
0.658151865,
-0.1571736634,
-0.109091714,
0.4824821949,
-0.0342711136,
-0.0636505336,
-0.6828660965,
-0.3519800603,
0.6744021773,
0.3668120205,
0.6529349685,
0.3297652602,
0.3046328425,
0.2831377983,
-0.0387281962,
0.6626064181,
0.3898499906,
-0.324254185,
0.4880155623,
-0.5290233493,
0.2911460996,
0.1246144176,
0.2670356333,
-0.0663331822,
0.083540678,
-0.6235657334,
-0.4194575846,
0.2967547774,
0.3164810836,
0.2062275261,
0.3637169302,
-0.2435534745,
-0.1097072214,
0.4721368849,
-0.4783409834,
0.353305459,
-0.5493332744,
-0.134659037,
0.0953701511,
0.3858368397,
-0.483042717,
-0.1214157566,
0.1546125561,
-0.1269540936,
0.258826226,
-0.0956280008,
0.0798477307,
-0.0431713462,
0.3289507329,
0.7399645448,
0.2823449075,
-0.3091739714,
0.2489456236,
0.0937825888,
-0.7050839067,
0.1554644555,
0.0555480644,
-0.2347668856,
-0.2428775132,
0.3834506571,
0.3556688726,
-0.456056267,
-0.3034672439,
0.3156065643,
0.0594384745,
-0.3069102168,
-0.2704604566,
0.0744624287,
0.006997494,
0.53822577,
1.0288749933,
0.5599780679,
0.3731696904,
-0.7265952826,
-0.1008021384,
0.5515784025,
0.2061467618,
-0.2631025314,
0.8241460919,
0.8227591515,
-0.245880127,
0.0518860035,
0.0348498859,
-0.516156137,
1.1772067547,
0.6531319618,
0.66075176,
-0.299626708,
-0.1335048974,
0.1357156336,
0.5273647308,
0.0332445651,
0.775282979,
-0.3549577892,
-0.6334856153,
0.0228056926,
-0.1774211377,
-0.0271313787,
0.0638633296,
-0.1059561148,
0.028161943,
-0.6945769191,
-0.3240379691,
0.0505853295,
0.2948091626,
-0.7562481761,
0.5173255205,
0.016216429,
0.9223866463,
-1.0690866709,
0.3559262156,
0.4777638018,
0.1129281223,
-0.7204037309,
0.2361367941,
0.4114046097,
-0.4571124315,
0.3359189034,
0.4110826254,
0.1361979544,
0.4488719404,
-0.3835062385,
-0.5580736399,
1.422696352,
-0.2477828711,
-0.4816058874,
0.4025973082,
-0.3035306036,
0.456112057,
0.1770966649,
0.4080773592,
0.4145689309,
0.8197291493,
0.4452830851,
-0.6881504655,
-0.3048990667,
0.0253237784,
-0.1896840781,
0.4178141654,
-0.7855191827,
0.1212961748,
-0.4707431495,
-0.139659375,
-0.0843863711,
0.5760860443,
-0.3403638899,
1.1235487461,
0.3257352412,
0.6283863783,
0.4956851304,
-0.2472895384,
0.2216438949,
0.0193798505,
0.2446610183,
0.2768482268,
-0.3932663202,
0.426223129,
0.2618566155,
-0.074848339,
0.1604655832,
0.6599759459,
0.0327453613,
1.0809460878,
-0.1138735637,
-1.0771005154,
-0.1546792537,
-0.4013624787,
-0.3517286777,
0.5489795804,
0.6697153449,
-0.0282149799,
-0.4528516233,
0.5127254128,
-0.0816163346,
0.0037218633,
-0.216870293,
0.897713542,
-0.1727713943,
-0.623570025,
0.1652736068,
0.1726886332,
0.7397414446,
-0.4312618673,
-0.0830340907,
-0.159755826,
0.3938255012,
-0.7890618443,
-0.7967856526,
0.9887846708,
0.0225842092,
-0.0158644412,
-0.2777453363,
0.7526198626,
-0.0857716873,
-0.3007312119,
0.0624861792,
0.1284631491,
-0.1025351658,
0.1384292245,
-0.3810954988,
0.1037694514,
-0.3409530818,
-0.0734746605,
0.0107515287,
0.138050586,
-0.5453708172,
0.5587545037,
1.1900088787,
-0.0319238305,
0.1888521314,
-0.4042258561,
0.8804665208,
-0.6001233459,
-0.4467695355,
-0.4976784885,
0.290312022,
-0.2700886726,
-0.3056723773,
0.7815864086,
-0.0221108906,
0.5377823114,
0.1956638843,
1.0979646444,
-0.5479882956,
0.1452922225,
-0.260268271,
0.0997580513,
-0.0635655224,
0.1748541594,
0.2363403887,
-1.041952014,
-0.6381133199,
0.5026397109,
-0.1476536691,
0.0319462642,
0.002937868,
0.7811020017,
0.0313227512,
0.1678404361,
0.3390896618,
-0.2544597089,
0.6196478009,
0.2313620597,
0.5110698938,
-0.4583804905,
0.4509357214,
-0.0381361507,
-0.6114729047,
-0.6730214357,
-0.9064956903,
-0.5647599101,
0.0410538167,
0.0503382273,
0.1556382626,
0.0945655704,
0.5967895985,
0.9183627367,
-0.7974959016,
0.2904426455,
-0.4014199376,
0.2332112193,
-0.7301864028,
-0.1689236611,
0.0743480921,
0.0761800408,
-0.1033169851,
0.6589552164,
0.5803679228,
-0.0189523734,
-0.4260674119,
-0.0721587688,
-0.2934272289,
0.0850614011,
0.4560738504,
0.6287556291,
-0.6682292819,
-0.1727185994,
0.2067406178,
-0.1327036917,
-0.6743657589,
0.6724513173,
-0.9549036026,
0.5313982368,
0.7780100107,
0.5955966711,
0.1063565314,
0.0974589437,
0.2507971525,
-0.4880902469,
0.4471922219,
0.3402003944,
-0.232011795,
0.2651707232,
-0.7081543803,
0.7139981985,
0.6127917171,
-0.9048629403,
-0.4277703464,
0.2545834184,
-0.7104599476,
-0.0291925166,
0.4150353074,
-0.2603340745,
0.4931329191,
-0.4276228547,
-0.3626967669,
0.0394962728,
0.0766585097,
0.7106654644,
0.2876590192,
-0.2465943843,
-0.4288545847,
-0.5225681663,
0.2208871394,
0.2655893862,
-0.8695028424,
-0.198393181,
0.3217564225,
-0.0817550346,
0.3303888738,
0.2867657542,
0.3484177589,
0.4542941153,
0.2177652121,
-0.1291308105,
-0.2537893653,
-0.8076441884,
-0.2221286148,
-0.0889793858,
-0.3339292407,
-0.3357367516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17189v1
|
An Effective Mixture-Of-Experts Approach For Code-Switching Speech Recognition Leveraging Encoder Disentanglement
| 2024-02-27T04:08:59 | 2024-02-27T04:08:59 |
Tzu-Ting Yang, Hsin-Wei Wang, Yi-Cheng Wang, Chi-Han Lin, Berlin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
With the massive developments of end-to-end (E2E) neural networks, recent
years have witnessed unprecedented breakthroughs in automatic speech
recognition (ASR). However, the codeswitching phenomenon remains a major
obstacle that hinders ASR from perfection, as the lack of labeled data and the
variations between languages often lead to degradation of ASR performance. In
this paper, we focus exclusively on improving the acoustic encoder of E2E ASR
to tackle the challenge caused by the codeswitching phenomenon. Our main
contributions are threefold: First, we introduce a novel disentanglement loss
to enable the lower-layer of the encoder to capture inter-lingual acoustic
information while mitigating linguistic confusion at the higher-layer of the
encoder. Second, through comprehensive experiments, we verify that our proposed
method outperforms the prior-art methods using pretrained dual-encoders,
meanwhile having access only to the codeswitching corpus and consuming half of
the parameterization. Third, the apparent differentiation of the encoders'
output features also corroborates the complementarity between the
disentanglement loss and the mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture.
|
[
-0.4491368532,
-0.2503559589,
-0.02185986,
0.0123544708,
-0.240900591,
0.6910763979,
-0.0823720768,
-0.4085496664,
0.1500785053,
0.102986455,
-0.2134819925,
0.0074392743,
-1.1238172054,
0.1761327386,
-0.6535617113,
0.562970221,
-0.0081537236,
-0.0043269452,
0.0139533058,
-0.0665869564,
-0.3213124871,
-0.3041531444,
-0.787027657,
-0.5352940559,
0.1385718584,
0.1094079539,
0.5119418502,
0.403187722,
0.0347222202,
0.3193296492,
-0.4144114256,
0.3508850932,
-0.3522132337,
-0.232517004,
-0.0143489772,
-0.554466486,
-0.1804912239,
-0.2963222861,
0.3768309653,
0.3925617635,
-0.5031318069,
-0.1659227461,
0.2516570091,
0.6324340105,
-0.5654583573,
0.0329865068,
-0.8966016173,
0.2898189723,
-0.4314005077,
-0.488727212,
-0.3255318999,
0.0767649859,
0.0163490288,
-0.3552604616,
0.0792014226,
-0.1485715955,
0.5294680595,
0.8443097472,
-0.4143582582,
-0.3087383807,
-0.7806191444,
0.470388025,
-0.7806583643,
0.7511286139,
0.3997859955,
0.2412397414,
0.0642258972,
-0.3752743602,
-0.5970822573,
0.1328123659,
0.1149972826,
0.39947474,
-0.3424073458,
-0.1155407652,
0.0136145512,
0.3425072432,
-0.5150796771,
0.2739338279,
-0.3941404819,
-0.4792829752,
0.6941542029,
-0.2736153603,
0.2343911082,
0.4553380609,
-0.2031317353,
0.0265261214,
-0.4809600115,
0.0986433476,
0.4879204333,
-0.087376602,
-0.004806425,
0.0694962889,
0.048424609,
0.724542141,
0.6950848699,
-0.0700007528,
0.5238808393,
-0.0353454538,
0.0935960636,
0.6090583801,
0.6196416616,
0.2498137802,
-0.0185298752,
-0.453288883,
-0.2972637117,
0.0054728519,
-0.0758370906,
-0.4923621118,
-0.4864532948,
0.2932191491,
-0.1929536015,
-0.1335469335,
0.105695501,
-0.5479863882,
-0.2530320287,
-0.2743736804,
0.4740557671,
-0.2531111836,
-0.7783792615,
0.3663824499,
-0.290828824,
0.146462664,
0.0225651525,
-0.998021543,
0.4044467211,
0.4843504727,
0.6998860836,
-0.0401617549,
-0.2338273674,
-0.5195997357,
0.2413915098,
-0.2782842517,
0.469532758,
-0.4597028196,
-0.4487290382,
-0.3265833259,
-0.4733272493,
-0.2377539724,
-0.8406711221,
0.0706861764,
-0.6492727399,
-0.0656935945,
0.0338053703,
-0.5666031241,
0.0072656781,
-0.1240575388,
-0.6016976833,
0.8481734991,
-0.4293059409,
-0.6406723261,
0.3335288167,
-0.347476989,
-0.4715886712,
0.0249424335,
-0.5920868516,
-0.564792335,
0.0566090122,
0.3085138202,
0.1161414981,
-0.0431036502,
0.1466858983,
0.2195729166,
-0.4864224195,
0.4813819528,
-0.5158585906,
0.9180223346,
0.2659936547,
-0.6314421892,
-0.4095802903,
-0.7042324543,
0.0331955105,
-0.025010692,
-0.4965802133,
-0.3134019971,
0.1669711769,
0.0429543033,
0.3451722562,
0.3319194913,
-0.4605733156,
-0.2646540105,
-0.2769905031,
0.6242402196,
0.4735396206,
-0.1507933289,
0.5034441948,
-0.2265145481,
0.2445808202,
0.4992688894,
-0.046211049,
0.1381626129,
-0.5883241296,
-0.6837521791,
-0.1499776393,
0.4836160839,
0.7706184983,
-0.8893744349,
0.9803691506,
0.0138534838,
-0.3263006508,
-0.9698594213,
0.1157555729,
0.7838372588,
0.4085656404,
0.4253637791,
-0.5140079856,
-0.5699393749,
-0.6543123126,
-0.5255542397,
-0.0210335981,
-0.2141380906,
0.1159663126,
0.1702863574,
-0.3029977381,
1.1544438601,
-0.2979438901,
-0.2041638345,
-0.046986714,
0.1511651576,
0.1008669883,
0.6332142949,
0.2945050299,
-1.0341278315,
-0.5105888247,
0.1272246987,
-0.4094142914,
-0.0263251234,
-0.2863424122,
0.1204360947,
0.1223177165,
0.6523795724,
-0.2323161066,
0.3615546525,
0.4698852003,
-0.0246731285,
0.2646546066,
-0.2246838212,
0.2082430273,
-0.9930152297,
-0.2593022883,
-0.0804873183,
-0.0635114089,
-0.7980790734,
-0.2201991528,
0.118742615,
0.1073749289,
-0.2223252952,
0.0058438471,
-0.6311911941,
-0.0050969552,
-0.0187324136,
-0.1059471294,
0.0124189798,
0.4863319695,
-0.0689565539,
0.75758183,
0.7826179266,
-0.4821772277,
0.3115732074,
0.3875690401,
-0.0478496552,
0.3278339803,
-0.5111864209,
0.6857360005,
-0.1628731042,
0.2434132099,
-0.8740468025,
0.0947675183,
-0.0113426782,
-0.869466424,
0.7615195513,
-0.4234128594,
-0.4249105752,
-0.2464641482,
-0.0570517704,
0.5034307241,
0.8232808709,
-0.6816273928,
0.6358355284,
0.6843135953,
-0.1796364933,
-0.4279814959,
-1.001185894,
0.3939791322,
-0.1534654051,
-0.4977566898,
0.6017471552,
-0.120248735,
-0.0380661152,
-0.2301309854,
-0.6069844365,
-0.4654895365,
-0.1478603035,
-0.2774149776,
-0.0496512465,
-0.1033104435,
-0.1112084463,
0.5255781412,
-0.5033115149,
0.0567522645,
-0.330810219,
0.3859263062,
0.0165180117,
-0.5550175309,
-0.3884838521,
0.4096828997,
0.354196161,
-0.7239922285,
0.1896200329,
0.6229404807,
-0.4911116064,
-0.2907949984,
-0.6318554282,
-0.186520651,
-0.528873682,
0.7354474068,
-0.3819710612,
-0.697525382,
0.5206362605,
-0.215345934,
0.0059223543,
-0.0221164059,
0.438482672,
-0.0757123083,
0.8534961939,
0.3158122897,
-0.4062747359,
0.2293740064,
-0.2186879963,
0.5269297957,
-0.708172977,
-0.3668137193,
-0.3158663511,
-0.2473109812,
-0.3073744774,
-0.5021547079,
0.5940963626,
0.1506438851,
0.0756633878,
0.2846906781,
-0.7436797619,
0.6609376073,
0.3121237159,
0.4776599109,
0.2602242529,
0.0573734194,
0.1921290308,
0.0014560908,
-0.7683349252,
-0.0705918372,
0.8427824974,
0.3455670476,
0.874630928,
0.2170265615,
1.0972081423,
0.2153984904,
-0.7064874172,
-0.4592038393,
0.396790266,
-0.312120229,
-0.2629714608,
-0.3892939687,
-0.4612310529,
-0.6303625107,
0.2606401145,
0.0923857316,
-0.2237949371,
0.5169953108,
0.5105802417,
-0.4776289761,
0.3874922097,
-0.5867754221,
0.2662963271,
-0.3818241358,
-0.1070658043,
-0.2244377583,
-0.8170086741,
-0.0906549841,
-0.2435169369,
0.1506259292,
0.3460131586,
-0.0373158418,
0.841463387,
-0.3762931228,
0.8152607679,
-0.4271541536,
-0.2321257293,
0.2034543008,
-0.1305578649,
0.3386125565,
-0.1278457344,
0.1302322149,
0.4539659917,
-0.5123689771,
-0.2071878612,
-0.4768130183,
0.4037916362,
-0.895481348,
-0.147923395,
-0.1274680942,
-0.264036715,
-0.4752527773,
-0.0619472116,
0.6098317504,
0.8737552762,
0.1608387381,
-0.0461264737,
1.1848369837,
-0.1259674877,
0.384007901,
0.6209105253,
0.2353036106,
-0.3796114028,
1.2165033817,
0.3586762547,
0.3258550465,
0.4909098446,
0.0712896287,
-0.2973499596,
-0.7627479434,
-0.6437708735,
-0.251611352,
-0.4290122092,
-0.2000924647,
-0.5287800431,
-0.5429335833,
-0.3657599986,
-0.3121114671,
-0.67459023,
-0.1373242289,
-0.344832778,
-0.1546255797,
0.3501182497,
0.4040935338,
-0.1617503017,
-0.1061733216,
-0.7304306626,
0.3446952701,
0.5768713355,
0.282323122,
-0.0064705769,
-0.8744125366,
-0.4264454842,
0.2417356372,
0.0920589566,
-0.9038687348,
0.0959974527,
0.5002328157,
0.7355614305,
0.4930729568,
0.1544501781,
0.7420250177,
-0.588630259,
0.4290219545,
0.4550339878,
-1.139798522,
0.2622028887,
-0.1672676504,
0.3681082428,
0.5540944338,
0.0540648326,
-0.3520283699,
-0.5284623504,
-0.3393534422,
-1.1066982746,
0.6075995564,
0.2941028476,
-0.0499194339,
0.2564142644,
-0.0112995207,
0.2142920047,
0.2535540164,
-0.3120589256,
-0.403433919,
-0.573543787,
-0.3361434937,
-0.0048953188,
-0.1065267846,
-0.0696453378,
-0.4761433005,
0.4290652871,
0.1716271639,
0.3028577566,
0.0515652932,
-0.4447765648,
0.0535157435,
0.3983169496,
0.5072163939,
0.4499579966,
-0.0998030975,
0.1782745123,
0.4269178808,
-0.5207080245,
0.2561628819,
0.3197953999,
-0.0344983488,
0.2412918806,
0.1116939709,
0.8432061672,
0.4698013663,
-0.3929588199,
0.5626434684,
0.2415143996,
-0.2980520427,
-0.4762417972,
0.0348254852,
0.2837913036,
0.1669314206,
0.7371174097,
0.6309694648,
0.4581796527,
-0.1839259118,
0.4203323722,
-0.1377153695,
-0.2245620489,
-0.2271867245,
0.6263263226,
0.6449317336,
-0.4936331809,
0.579503715,
-0.326954037,
-0.549847424,
0.9249811769,
0.6339067221,
0.9757065773,
-0.8612986803,
-0.1096295044,
0.1248550713,
0.3416012228,
-0.0782196894,
0.1550357193,
-0.2878710926,
-0.8612118959,
-0.1019897982,
-0.1085809097,
-0.3926440179,
-0.2620508373,
-1.1260416508,
0.2204709798,
-0.0310703442,
0.1630223691,
-0.3150670528,
-0.6118898988,
-0.4384860992,
0.133155331,
0.3876345158,
0.6525899768,
-0.6372675896,
0.8200047612,
0.5718992949,
-0.1939778775,
-0.52432096,
0.2083010375,
0.2242193371,
-0.7612469196,
0.1260703057,
0.0968550369,
-0.428088963,
0.2065256089,
-0.2175242156,
-0.6723672748,
1.2203210592,
0.305087477,
-1.2251662016,
0.0102610411,
0.2101722956,
0.3492334783,
-0.0361716263,
0.3152648211,
0.8037010431,
0.2541370988,
-0.0372187085,
-1.3192081451,
-0.3202150464,
-0.6252236366,
-0.0185564887,
0.2308071852,
-0.6188464761,
0.7140190005,
-0.2172710598,
-0.0525741242,
-0.4905113578,
0.4395709634,
0.3053867221,
0.4150336087,
0.9297564626,
0.3736503124,
0.6674634218,
0.0740208924,
0.2863722146,
-0.4150529504,
0.22557275,
1.0140259266,
-0.2966552079,
1.0399118662,
0.4028120339,
-0.4440326393,
0.0300650373,
0.3690869808,
0.0755777061,
0.9591799378,
0.0932178721,
-0.3904590309,
-0.2133437693,
0.5978636742,
-0.7614286542,
0.5450842977,
0.3343179226,
-0.0174842719,
-0.0904288068,
0.2165794075,
0.0673541129,
0.0280934796,
-0.2197449803,
1.1334718466,
0.1637329012,
-0.0862675309,
0.7080292702,
-0.2878077626,
1.197648406,
-0.6123068929,
-0.0119387638,
0.0388086848,
0.0477137566,
-0.5735094547,
-0.5284576416,
0.3780068755,
-0.0724902228,
-0.2458512038,
-0.3076608777,
0.6188679934,
-0.9651643634,
-0.3056052625,
0.5703753829,
0.2161733806,
0.2260254771,
-0.0956967399,
-0.6240050793,
0.1993156224,
0.1000276953,
0.1676297784,
0.5199918747,
0.3172350228,
0.5242458582,
0.1821346283,
0.4906649292,
-0.0423349254,
0.3961094022,
0.2334680408,
1.0592063665,
-0.2524004579,
-0.8935080767,
-0.6755574942,
0.6860916615,
-0.139286831,
-0.1963207573,
0.485540837,
0.7152155042,
0.9161513448,
-0.210084796,
1.020714283,
-0.0103208423,
0.5249238014,
-0.5509917736,
1.1994137764,
-0.3446739614,
0.3485156596,
-0.2718195319,
-0.3348125219,
-0.0030946597,
0.7156689763,
0.0446456671,
0.1348814666,
0.3304241598,
1.00892663,
-0.1335839182,
-0.0580132827,
0.462965548,
0.35639745,
0.3357269168,
0.6424316764,
0.7053197026,
-0.6133323312,
0.6149884462,
-0.0530165248,
-0.6078509092,
-0.176895678,
-0.4685981274,
-0.6711726189,
-0.8258482218,
-0.6238661408,
0.021570392,
0.3570058048,
0.7348840833,
0.6678762436,
-0.8819476962,
-0.2471531034,
-0.1678590775,
-0.2568701506,
-0.4119153321,
-0.1629677266,
0.0182894841,
0.0001132669,
-0.5147063732,
0.7427771688,
0.3721107543,
-0.1873531491,
-0.0675278679,
-0.5756245255,
0.1785219759,
0.0924794599,
0.4195724726,
0.2899853587,
-0.668646872,
-0.007004803,
-0.3149763942,
0.1919195801,
0.0600493401,
0.6863886714,
-0.4909659624,
0.7567961812,
0.3890891671,
0.9073601961,
0.3402043283,
-0.269656986,
0.460046947,
-0.7186208963,
0.1027560607,
0.3579683602,
0.465236634,
0.2374720126,
-0.3395169675,
0.0635319576,
0.1122122556,
-0.545439899,
-0.7659348845,
0.1731960624,
-0.9372369051,
-0.0591299199,
0.8880978823,
-0.0877909735,
0.1839647591,
-0.6124019623,
-0.258818686,
0.2107221335,
-0.5429298878,
0.9475154877,
0.3195745945,
-0.2333927602,
-0.2963804007,
-0.1317637563,
0.3259693384,
0.4344648719,
-0.6715155244,
-0.1911324263,
0.1605425328,
0.3956184685,
0.1810585558,
0.8722603917,
-0.1469285488,
0.4524509013,
0.2079672813,
0.2113092989,
-0.4971890748,
-0.2923575044,
-0.5670393109,
-0.3075294495,
0.0356828384,
-0.6417979598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17184v1
|
Extreme Encoder Output Frame Rate Reduction: Improving Computational Latencies of Large End-to-End Models
| 2024-02-27T03:40:44 | 2024-02-27T03:40:44 |
Rohit Prabhavalkar, Zhong Meng, Weiran Wang, Adam Stooke, Xingyu Cai, Yanzhang He, Arun Narayanan, Dongseong Hwang, Tara N. Sainath, Pedro J. Moreno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The accuracy of end-to-end (E2E) automatic speech recognition (ASR) models
continues to improve as they are scaled to larger sizes, with some now reaching
billions of parameters. Widespread deployment and adoption of these models,
however, requires computationally efficient strategies for decoding. In the
present work, we study one such strategy: applying multiple frame reduction
layers in the encoder to compress encoder outputs into a small number of output
frames. While similar techniques have been investigated in previous work, we
achieve dramatically more reduction than has previously been demonstrated
through the use of multiple funnel reduction layers. Through ablations, we
study the impact of various architectural choices in the encoder to identify
the most effective strategies. We demonstrate that we can generate one encoder
output frame for every 2.56 sec of input speech, without significantly
affecting word error rate on a large-scale voice search task, while improving
encoder and decoder latencies by 48% and 92% respectively, relative to a strong
but computationally expensive baseline.
|
[
-0.7697004676,
-0.7445406914,
0.0434102602,
-0.0436764732,
-0.2987246811,
-0.0288019888,
-0.1642242372,
-0.4379136562,
-0.0042696632,
0.4433508813,
-0.4072157741,
-0.0699717402,
-0.5622005463,
0.157574892,
-0.7531657219,
0.452205956,
0.1151633039,
0.0642116293,
0.1130922809,
0.1614243537,
-0.0737034604,
-0.7556954026,
-1.0305511951,
-0.4683164954,
0.0157757122,
0.2563450038,
0.4628078341,
0.8893991709,
0.510140419,
0.234909445,
-0.3666840196,
-0.0096152266,
-0.3836528659,
0.2374669611,
0.2883486152,
-0.2279123962,
-0.2748507261,
-0.4401032925,
0.8309478164,
0.5207108855,
-0.3235263228,
0.2502274513,
-0.0033323956,
0.6992611885,
-0.6932511926,
0.0010191863,
-0.3348053396,
0.2132748365,
-0.2585413754,
-0.3718224764,
-0.5663977861,
0.1518730223,
-0.2583080232,
-0.2233801931,
0.2860009968,
0.0427954309,
0.5375900865,
0.5074231029,
-0.1492314488,
-0.1180039197,
-1.0227268934,
0.1640360951,
-0.6845627427,
0.7597944736,
0.2299282402,
0.2738625705,
0.0714526102,
-0.4983051121,
-0.6411414146,
0.3232291043,
0.3117924333,
0.069669269,
-0.6442801952,
0.2099559307,
0.4641813934,
0.2698403895,
-0.7047905326,
0.2482275069,
-0.3433141708,
-0.3249836862,
0.4128961563,
0.0020430391,
0.0141929789,
0.1443955302,
0.1609173566,
-0.3345737755,
-0.7237740159,
0.3129656315,
0.397341013,
0.0589843169,
0.0582363866,
0.5993430018,
-0.1886618137,
0.5855463743,
0.1525664181,
0.09396635,
0.1822948456,
-0.1299834698,
-0.2382820398,
0.3388534784,
0.4024834931,
0.4206263423,
-0.1465589106,
0.0074813627,
-0.387422353,
0.469209373,
0.2535311282,
-1.0953327417,
-0.0494799502,
0.3508025706,
-0.5641595125,
0.0161422845,
-0.246998474,
-0.6492456794,
-0.0880353451,
-0.0568867661,
0.3110812306,
-0.1817855537,
-0.0731332228,
0.1599620581,
-0.3764779866,
0.5413123965,
0.227893129,
-0.6693307757,
0.7207815051,
0.3818152845,
0.9045318365,
0.0368452631,
0.2880989611,
-1.0011047125,
0.1920695156,
-0.5515545011,
0.7428511977,
-0.6098994017,
-0.5029242039,
-0.1610523015,
-0.3354203403,
0.1551174521,
-0.7113927007,
0.6456954479,
-0.7119653821,
-0.2027386874,
0.055770997,
-0.600038588,
-0.3599034548,
-0.2446590811,
-0.7003293633,
0.6355504394,
-0.1881427318,
-0.1426769197,
-0.096443668,
-0.9107781649,
-0.6189991832,
-0.2194103003,
0.0567343347,
-0.603143692,
0.5517500043,
0.4982121289,
0.4036663473,
-0.4711976945,
-0.2827334702,
0.1135415137,
-0.4201630354,
0.1865455508,
-0.5746452212,
0.4204569161,
0.4425660968,
-0.5842548013,
-0.1183147579,
-0.9445112944,
0.0854403526,
0.0719478354,
-0.4405588806,
-0.0029655886,
-0.1244253665,
0.1894242167,
0.1925279051,
-0.3259708285,
-0.6745737791,
-0.339542985,
-0.5008174777,
0.7336975932,
0.4842846394,
-0.1501119286,
0.4508716762,
-0.1982538402,
0.3741088212,
-0.0993178785,
-0.0548691191,
-0.459512949,
-0.3553294837,
-0.9839379191,
-0.198574543,
0.1342415661,
0.3716786504,
-0.5501511693,
0.494897306,
-0.2118678987,
-0.4178337753,
-0.636279583,
-0.1582929492,
0.7487587333,
0.3146063089,
0.3798758388,
-0.6402541995,
-0.587697506,
-0.818587482,
-0.1654691994,
-0.1272862703,
-0.2968092263,
0.2770531178,
0.3159878552,
-0.0664389879,
0.6849402189,
-0.3819026649,
-0.193048507,
-0.0832971632,
-0.0758436322,
0.0891976729,
0.5367803574,
0.1836675406,
-0.667945385,
-0.3177960813,
-0.0118075069,
-0.3171907663,
-0.1006782949,
-0.0528425723,
0.1808589548,
0.4227764904,
0.3775701225,
-0.4749858081,
0.515601933,
0.5325930119,
-0.1317604184,
0.2641953826,
-0.2481528521,
0.1602073461,
-0.5195842385,
-0.1150511205,
-0.0966942012,
-0.1472416669,
-1.1398925781,
0.0275008529,
0.0033312545,
-0.333601743,
-0.3476296961,
0.1096804291,
-0.6835074425,
-0.3426814079,
-0.2479962558,
-0.2519955039,
0.0561740138,
0.5394917727,
0.1160123125,
0.9290844798,
0.4729075134,
-0.5821409822,
0.3364684582,
0.4533141255,
0.1332748383,
0.2280553281,
-0.8799071908,
0.6933271885,
-0.3753250837,
0.5323165655,
-1.0607771873,
-0.1245669052,
-0.0414237753,
-0.8280704021,
0.4428884089,
-0.1675854623,
-0.3541129231,
-0.2684479952,
-0.3486312628,
0.2466473281,
0.9408956766,
-0.6604633927,
0.6210904717,
0.6029354334,
-0.1786426157,
-0.2485982478,
-1.104195714,
0.1388152689,
-0.0426924191,
-0.6464284658,
0.5873253345,
-0.0948267728,
0.0348149464,
-0.051150918,
-0.2563314438,
-0.0790290087,
-0.253501296,
0.1931177825,
-0.1275279373,
-0.2288464457,
-0.3219990432,
0.1876894236,
-0.2955562472,
0.0371269956,
-0.4295446277,
0.6734659672,
0.1895137876,
-0.4300117493,
-0.5463495255,
0.8471614122,
0.6450644135,
-0.3636833727,
0.658931613,
0.7059445977,
-0.7798320651,
-0.2862653434,
-0.7581407428,
-0.1260774285,
-0.4525406659,
0.5098184943,
-0.5439293981,
-0.7879074216,
0.7197089195,
0.0364258103,
0.138361603,
0.1805233657,
0.4971309304,
0.318831116,
1.0846501589,
0.4043068886,
0.1395770311,
0.4302756488,
-0.4729011655,
0.3755802214,
-1.1902537346,
-0.3236954808,
-0.64340204,
-0.1773749888,
-0.008687404,
-0.7704722881,
0.5888180137,
-0.015660271,
-0.2341880053,
0.3013987839,
-0.669644773,
0.4773108959,
0.5373764634,
0.2046555579,
0.0702943057,
0.380839169,
0.2170026302,
0.1021953374,
-0.8801714182,
-0.437027365,
1.0386668444,
0.3403430283,
0.5804920197,
0.3518167734,
0.5318647027,
0.2973480225,
-0.3430947661,
-0.6108544469,
0.4808550775,
-0.513474226,
-0.2077447921,
-0.5131905675,
-0.3825303912,
-0.5013412833,
0.2314270884,
-0.1659428924,
-0.2556650043,
0.1437757164,
0.3335905373,
-0.6126476526,
0.3332678676,
-0.5497570038,
0.3807224929,
0.0602985471,
-0.5112064481,
-0.3146390915,
-0.7180022001,
-0.2202281207,
-0.0993565023,
0.243388623,
0.2144075185,
-0.2008325607,
0.8024915457,
-0.3229515553,
0.4672880471,
-0.4320071042,
0.077935949,
0.2187769562,
-0.120600678,
0.7731283903,
-0.3286099732,
-0.2156401277,
0.1561933756,
-0.4631309807,
-0.0646717623,
-0.5917454958,
0.2597354352,
-0.8651834726,
-0.2626426816,
0.1275795996,
-0.1997791827,
-0.0432473496,
-0.1661121249,
0.472574383,
1.2537608147,
-0.0811171681,
0.2901539505,
0.7890433073,
-0.3326132298,
0.4870787263,
0.2609340549,
0.2066764385,
-0.4852631688,
0.7217012048,
0.3808881044,
0.3267511427,
0.462189585,
-0.0411047712,
-0.6079434752,
-0.8716223836,
-0.51315099,
-0.1144709215,
-0.718018949,
-0.242506966,
-0.7691265941,
-0.414570123,
-0.6850834489,
-0.3740092814,
-0.7211213708,
-0.5154553652,
-0.297108233,
0.1502016634,
0.1907061785,
0.4119395614,
-0.1634100527,
0.6410502195,
-0.8026313186,
0.3899056017,
0.074286215,
0.1586660594,
0.0759381875,
-0.8312872648,
-0.1897669882,
-0.0362895988,
0.0127510214,
-0.7095660567,
0.7365768552,
0.7212225795,
0.626658082,
0.3324697912,
0.3251883388,
0.9436828494,
-0.7576838136,
0.7059369087,
0.5047790408,
-1.0933274031,
0.3957239985,
0.1857944131,
0.398804158,
-0.0121870786,
-0.0318042934,
-0.4817430079,
-0.0737008005,
-0.3612158,
-1.1415734291,
0.6408073306,
0.4511465132,
0.0446134061,
0.2157246917,
0.2027026862,
-0.0192694888,
-0.0259265974,
0.000463631,
-0.3693130314,
-0.1190726161,
-0.0242805202,
-0.0762600601,
-0.3569246531,
-0.0978577659,
-0.1880883873,
0.6836268902,
-0.1089902669,
0.6579908133,
0.4593208432,
-0.2597883642,
-0.154892996,
0.4883739054,
0.4863361716,
0.0636245832,
0.0689720735,
0.3226896226,
0.3456664383,
-0.3350566924,
0.2589567304,
0.1261173338,
-0.141774565,
0.1870994866,
0.0290058404,
1.1541401148,
0.0397327021,
-0.5646189451,
0.4240532815,
-0.040067032,
-0.097828187,
-0.50906533,
-0.0391275175,
-0.0981934518,
0.3286725283,
0.545422256,
0.4298734069,
0.5875845551,
-0.2496574074,
0.2591466904,
0.3286540806,
-0.0639862865,
-0.363560468,
1.0137928724,
0.5663207173,
-0.6150359511,
0.7639311552,
-0.0004108959,
-0.6095895171,
0.5782266259,
0.7529550791,
1.0365896225,
-0.3734953105,
-0.27286461,
0.3737659156,
0.2847331464,
-0.1907644123,
-0.0135073699,
-0.1993040591,
-0.6494083405,
-0.5176579952,
-0.6559135318,
-0.5020588636,
-0.1769248843,
-0.7639689445,
0.2254276425,
-0.1466024965,
-0.2252269983,
0.0542732738,
-0.3048402369,
-0.4932559431,
0.0009382062,
0.5393832326,
0.7166019082,
-0.4936729968,
0.5623333454,
0.5266190171,
-0.0426585078,
-0.7135477662,
-0.3477111757,
0.2909716666,
-0.5237120986,
0.2422443628,
0.3257342279,
-0.4503583014,
0.2548944354,
-0.2161427438,
-0.6994510889,
0.8601026535,
0.4214823842,
-0.9251483083,
-0.1062491611,
0.1771371812,
0.3448688984,
-0.5369576812,
0.5168763995,
0.7550444007,
0.2684258521,
0.2913194895,
-1.1339144707,
-0.0931421816,
-0.6439768672,
0.3393647373,
0.1295473427,
-0.4723388255,
0.579202652,
-0.3513349891,
-0.3363954127,
-0.2900314331,
0.439799875,
0.1169258878,
0.2939613461,
0.5638209581,
0.4293471873,
0.3778651357,
0.028825786,
0.7255242467,
-0.5265990496,
0.1012721658,
0.553041935,
-0.234015435,
1.0803320408,
0.4464389682,
-0.1198369563,
-0.1468980908,
0.3899375498,
0.121082589,
0.5838934779,
0.2432074249,
-0.2090131491,
-0.1719509065,
-0.0858787596,
-0.336227417,
0.4933750033,
0.3810355067,
-0.3045848012,
0.1481875777,
0.3799075484,
0.1716402471,
0.0205888003,
-0.4175332189,
0.8260505795,
-0.1336772442,
-0.3224409819,
0.7780038714,
-0.0964470357,
0.9066373706,
-0.5889322162,
-0.2008298934,
-0.015401816,
0.4288059473,
-0.4519634545,
-0.4376530945,
0.5660389066,
0.3976348042,
-0.2084635943,
-0.3621092439,
0.6534569263,
-0.45030424,
-0.2898859084,
0.3378337324,
0.4356675446,
0.4293762445,
-0.2503498495,
-0.1882728487,
0.6067069769,
0.0619401261,
-0.5008721352,
0.1783406585,
-0.0059342165,
0.3841239214,
0.4241185486,
0.9495921135,
0.2934691608,
0.3976437151,
0.0415471047,
1.072860837,
-0.4340917766,
-0.631203413,
-0.6056759357,
0.4751485586,
-0.034257628,
-0.0462756343,
0.405423075,
0.8750188351,
0.8187772632,
0.0752904639,
0.8491962552,
-0.1329050809,
0.3909487426,
-0.503315866,
0.5358531475,
-0.4573940039,
0.5039548874,
-0.1485000551,
-0.6938043833,
-0.4206112027,
0.7959140539,
0.4041151702,
-0.1916920245,
0.4736528993,
1.0012661219,
0.341116935,
0.1589541435,
0.5329241157,
0.1961535066,
0.6164362431,
0.5853604078,
0.5014685988,
-0.6471838951,
0.8245079517,
-0.4050042331,
-0.4377555549,
-0.0178549215,
-0.4380971193,
-0.5504000187,
-0.5485014319,
-0.4310525656,
-0.1930536926,
0.4257192016,
0.9412847757,
0.7628375888,
-0.6648417115,
-0.353438884,
0.0762168318,
-0.5979413986,
-0.4639351368,
-0.0961893052,
0.2955603302,
0.0460448265,
-0.7851333022,
0.5237933993,
0.4755689502,
-0.2432086021,
-0.0162395891,
-0.2896947563,
0.3699803054,
0.1545347422,
0.7374871969,
0.1263257563,
-0.6894364357,
-0.4283009768,
0.2971852422,
0.274622947,
0.122695908,
0.8333594203,
-0.6739584804,
0.5974593163,
0.6450161934,
0.7516091466,
0.7275918722,
0.0360495597,
0.5660224557,
-0.3668675721,
-0.0244526602,
0.3158788383,
0.2409948111,
0.2960883975,
-0.3092053235,
0.5733219981,
0.0520306751,
-0.62600106,
-0.8946728706,
0.0291422475,
-0.7983387113,
-0.0714947283,
1.1582713127,
-0.1431409866,
-0.3083325028,
-0.3170662224,
-0.1394873857,
0.490536958,
-0.6675922871,
0.2124703974,
0.3382197022,
-0.7868559957,
-0.4675227702,
-0.4843182862,
0.0424344987,
0.1720351428,
-0.54355371,
0.3353002965,
0.773593545,
0.0929833427,
0.1660921723,
0.7188645005,
-0.2047508359,
0.4120609164,
0.5476156473,
0.1596952528,
-0.4740386903,
-0.2595351338,
-0.8040806055,
0.4048916996,
-0.2554993927,
-0.3224630654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17168v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17168v1
|
Benchmarking Data Science Agents
| 2024-02-27T03:03:06 | 2024-02-27T03:03:06 |
Yuge Zhang, Qiyang Jiang, Xingyu Han, Nan Chen, Yuqing Yang, Kan Ren
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the era of data-driven decision-making, the complexity of data analysis
necessitates advanced expertise and tools of data science, presenting
significant challenges even for specialists. Large Language Models (LLMs) have
emerged as promising aids as data science agents, assisting humans in data
analysis and processing. Yet their practical efficacy remains constrained by
the varied demands of real-world applications and complicated analytical
process. In this paper, we introduce DSEval -- a novel evaluation paradigm, as
well as a series of innovative benchmarks tailored for assessing the
performance of these agents throughout the entire data science lifecycle.
Incorporating a novel bootstrapped annotation method, we streamline dataset
preparation, improve the evaluation coverage, and expand benchmarking
comprehensiveness. Our findings uncover prevalent obstacles and provide
critical insights to inform future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.2031414509,
-0.5622907281,
0.6252872944,
0.1724716127,
-0.0423528887,
0.6950228214,
-0.3122195303,
-0.4787887633,
0.0280680526,
0.2756069005,
-0.6541274786,
-0.6935961246,
-0.533036232,
0.28066957,
-0.5036835074,
0.9685246944,
0.0520570427,
0.0741255432,
-0.5989685655,
-0.1428618878,
-0.0909944028,
-0.3894300759,
-0.3848263621,
-0.2746309936,
0.4265150428,
0.2706512511,
0.8948957324,
0.9390060902,
0.6156353951,
0.3806410134,
0.121090062,
0.1361479908,
-0.3976248503,
0.6344301701,
-0.1750267744,
-0.4305241704,
-0.6436570883,
0.1930060536,
0.7800528407,
1.1402028799,
-0.1691398621,
0.3637055457,
-0.1720250398,
0.9088481069,
-0.7739385962,
0.5636250973,
-0.7384770513,
-0.0779969394,
-0.255194366,
0.0448665842,
-0.2587952018,
-0.5271862745,
0.0957165211,
-0.5495052934,
-0.0749943182,
-0.0872676447,
0.3661224544,
0.5916636586,
-0.2488311231,
-0.1739189774,
-0.6324019432,
0.9407387972,
-0.4845945835,
0.268956542,
0.2635529041,
0.85250175,
-0.3389258683,
-0.7217652798,
-0.3217907548,
-0.5040471554,
0.1737106144,
-0.355917871,
-0.0930624828,
-0.2088454962,
0.2443716377,
0.109057337,
-0.2064968944,
0.2725659609,
-0.3790784478,
-0.1277558059,
1.1380921602,
0.5862461925,
-0.0722928271,
0.2104459852,
-0.2538156211,
-0.1475621462,
-0.572663784,
-0.3357712626,
0.1294641048,
0.7695806623,
0.1673788726,
0.3158767521,
-0.5511523485,
0.5314131975,
-0.342717737,
0.0383154526,
0.6110476851,
-0.2168807089,
-0.175556317,
-0.1594441682,
0.6196519136,
0.3462622166,
0.149546504,
-0.4325711429,
-0.3748829663,
0.1939671636,
0.1903213412,
-0.8866984844,
-0.0837862492,
0.530908823,
-0.0361366682,
-0.6835800409,
-0.3096917272,
-1.0507500172,
-1.154969573,
-0.3851118386,
0.3249530792,
-0.1097252294,
-0.2985078394,
-0.1352654397,
0.1048222408,
0.0766542852,
0.3253721595,
-0.53795892,
0.6821175814,
0.8326361179,
0.7160443068,
-0.3876341879,
-0.4621498585,
-0.5668978691,
-0.1759834737,
-0.7106708288,
0.9076769948,
-0.8941004276,
-0.2445131391,
-0.0609213449,
-0.0666832477,
-0.043669194,
-0.4766042233,
0.5406977534,
-0.5587955117,
-0.5260160565,
-0.5281670094,
-0.5876022577,
0.0436097905,
0.1828955561,
-0.6928457022,
1.2811777592,
0.2129988372,
-0.4851959348,
0.8154665232,
-0.5747770071,
-0.2607884407,
0.5447171926,
-0.4639112949,
-0.4350758493,
-0.093274802,
0.0864855573,
0.6840535402,
-0.8417267799,
0.3864537179,
-0.4090656638,
-0.2970336676,
0.4408953786,
-0.1739880741,
0.431867063,
0.3286561668,
-0.3015344143,
0.2451867461,
-1.1617883444,
0.1971729696,
0.1999948621,
-0.06229911,
-0.2110181004,
0.3199016452,
0.1546353698,
0.1895107776,
-0.011493382,
-0.4539268911,
0.3052107692,
0.1667933613,
0.5087298751,
0.8524954319,
-0.2503711581,
0.0178016704,
-0.2068719864,
0.6833781004,
-0.1273085326,
0.0143232821,
-0.0161664449,
0.0471992455,
-0.4763828814,
-0.6446025372,
0.4629070759,
0.2242948264,
-0.7691400647,
0.3709088564,
-0.5584072471,
-1.0503491163,
-0.8532409668,
0.0180106144,
0.1991718262,
0.5082066059,
0.3771359622,
-0.0397840403,
-0.3971681297,
-0.9858573079,
-0.2059334666,
-0.0494849235,
0.0902539045,
0.1092347056,
0.7079924941,
-0.3617142737,
0.9124322534,
-0.4323472977,
0.102003552,
-0.3829618394,
0.0070484937,
0.0743121952,
0.1952216923,
0.3546591699,
-0.6037442088,
-0.4131757915,
-0.0578733794,
-0.8731542826,
-0.4532828331,
0.0057444479,
0.2337359488,
0.2294566333,
0.5590292811,
-0.3369844854,
0.290523082,
0.2358238846,
-0.2424725145,
0.599620223,
-0.1642794758,
0.2634370625,
-0.5165307522,
0.2996388972,
0.0103443032,
-0.187858969,
-0.7632306218,
-0.183161065,
0.2468670905,
-0.0115830461,
-0.1924609393,
0.4340768456,
-0.5202997327,
-0.4435103536,
-0.1452258825,
0.2517851591,
-0.1660668701,
0.0105203269,
0.0045122514,
0.9419591427,
0.8491311669,
-0.5480541587,
0.6166093946,
0.1292352676,
-0.4311207235,
0.6860010624,
-0.7547080517,
0.0990630761,
-0.1977742314,
0.3455630243,
-0.9948393703,
-0.067299515,
-0.1413570791,
-0.0292966571,
0.2704973221,
-0.0773930401,
-0.744152844,
-0.4081768394,
-0.6482366323,
0.2654367089,
0.264811337,
-0.5188397169,
0.3269684613,
0.498326391,
-0.2348764241,
-0.5625032783,
-0.4416872263,
0.3644216657,
-0.3811627924,
-0.5148388147,
0.1569996029,
-0.0711037442,
-0.5235472918,
-0.1492761821,
-0.1522189528,
0.0261150971,
0.2394165397,
0.1943666041,
0.4280909896,
-0.0297064539,
0.3298052251,
-0.1387776434,
-0.4080033898,
0.0334708504,
0.1064162478,
0.2348460555,
-0.2862043083,
-0.3784514666,
-0.1995037794,
0.0452522896,
0.9150264263,
-0.3711027801,
0.7053945661,
0.1967241019,
-0.280305326,
-0.3993910849,
-0.7460482121,
-0.0487478301,
-0.4722798169,
0.7602058053,
-0.4072485566,
-0.1265124083,
0.4250606,
-0.3324508369,
-0.0449239202,
0.4024912715,
0.428121388,
0.3313949704,
0.8240356445,
0.3533222079,
-0.246073395,
0.0091720996,
-0.1852285713,
-0.1252589524,
-0.7473739386,
-0.1580877751,
-0.6558416486,
-0.0225011259,
-0.63679111,
-0.4353564382,
0.3592877984,
-0.2971989214,
-0.3243100643,
0.2950780392,
-0.4519320428,
0.4787055552,
0.0286992732,
-0.2451974005,
0.4261267781,
-0.1911428869,
0.2725425363,
-0.0373629816,
-0.3853625953,
-0.8408033252,
1.5526884794,
0.5338934064,
0.8504929543,
-0.3171036839,
0.5251626372,
0.7064638734,
0.2904182374,
-0.6221846938,
0.8017320633,
0.1126026139,
-0.4651627243,
-0.3627032936,
-0.3415982127,
-0.9447897673,
0.4886270761,
-0.2551344037,
-0.89204669,
0.0378894284,
-0.3190831244,
-0.0651676208,
0.0361199155,
-0.4405035079,
0.664152205,
-0.3204641342,
-0.7597877979,
-0.2106698751,
-0.6581306458,
-0.1740446091,
-0.2384984046,
0.4030052423,
-0.5123734474,
-0.3926466703,
0.7592401505,
-0.5438562036,
0.5768383741,
-0.3675343692,
-0.0532552339,
0.0833254457,
-0.1042174622,
0.6026533842,
-0.1489630938,
-0.6416072845,
0.1156306267,
0.2546547651,
-0.4675971866,
-0.4192759693,
0.7082472444,
-0.4796351492,
-0.3419035077,
-0.6835583448,
-0.6635659337,
-0.6267362833,
0.0331144296,
-0.3521495759,
0.22895585,
-0.3086087406,
0.1573107988,
0.295011729,
0.0502658188,
0.3423000574,
0.8304704428,
-0.0744217485,
-0.2356863767,
0.8004701734,
0.3103718758,
0.2886174917,
-0.0834707692,
-0.0154057238,
-0.3804750144,
-0.8657448292,
-0.4824531674,
0.1558023691,
-0.8148170114,
-0.2212818563,
-0.492444098,
0.0209065285,
-0.0835898221,
-0.0649460629,
-0.7498074174,
-0.4391870797,
0.2297925949,
-0.1156847626,
0.4497883618,
1.0102595091,
0.0113278618,
-0.2279637903,
-0.3851416409,
0.1082545891,
0.0801220387,
0.5262461305,
0.1214233488,
0.069817543,
-0.3210427165,
-0.1241756603,
0.0129129179,
-0.6242287755,
0.1472520828,
0.0300438311,
0.8556728363,
-0.0042774836,
0.0767045543,
0.4797482491,
-0.458964169,
0.5261380672,
-0.3735352755,
-0.7606047988,
0.4051271677,
-0.2783180177,
-0.1209724918,
0.9307315946,
0.4027372301,
-0.3885368109,
-0.0428236201,
-0.2495791316,
-1.0781341791,
0.7383016944,
0.2591547966,
-0.3193481266,
0.109932065,
0.1717410237,
0.427888155,
0.5347696543,
-0.2296723723,
-0.2872546911,
0.1970178634,
-0.1020609587,
-0.1494836807,
0.0671085417,
-0.1434498876,
-0.1738535613,
0.7619454861,
-0.2496824712,
-0.2426835001,
-0.0326293856,
-0.286588639,
-0.0240852255,
0.436101377,
0.194099322,
0.9475563169,
-0.1806377172,
-0.0986032933,
0.1829266697,
-0.5222212076,
0.1322810352,
0.6740974784,
0.0254842509,
-0.3668780327,
0.4913733304,
0.3404220939,
-0.0511583313,
-0.8944484591,
0.4404019713,
-0.0217488334,
0.1405186951,
-0.0651628375,
0.0373432338,
0.0001506952,
0.4153845906,
0.8018780351,
-0.3209656477,
0.1849453449,
-0.3981390595,
0.1060627326,
0.4817416668,
-0.2650562823,
-0.2564268112,
0.4913643897,
0.2274317592,
-0.0313898996,
0.4453500807,
-0.2448692918,
-0.3667768836,
0.8143138289,
0.2049988508,
0.9003899693,
-0.2232407779,
0.2516735494,
0.0529334173,
0.289167434,
-0.0211795494,
0.2147179693,
-0.161297217,
-0.3273040056,
-0.1283690333,
-0.6020747423,
-0.649924159,
0.0551805906,
-0.7375924587,
0.3237008154,
-0.2458966225,
0.0427251607,
0.464643091,
0.4712764323,
-0.9588766098,
0.2644316256,
0.0965577215,
0.9201158285,
-1.0584231615,
0.679959476,
0.6036764383,
-0.4083147943,
-0.1329111457,
-0.1432104111,
0.1938958615,
-0.81111449,
0.6521331668,
0.1872310489,
-0.1457448602,
-0.4203336835,
-0.4738363326,
-0.7522571683,
1.3604005575,
0.2908323705,
-0.5322782993,
0.3999084532,
0.3576519787,
0.9717258811,
-0.7106627822,
0.5548196435,
1.1537966728,
0.6158566475,
-0.0056756129,
-0.8129674792,
0.3770983815,
-0.3619863093,
0.1158344895,
0.1212120801,
-0.6490863562,
0.7115807533,
-0.1202714592,
-0.1087647229,
0.0316190012,
0.3985206187,
0.3724463284,
0.575873673,
0.411932081,
0.020572843,
0.9414218664,
0.0798299983,
0.9834301472,
-0.2409326136,
0.2173823714,
1.0695979595,
-0.8819248676,
0.7464845181,
0.360185504,
-0.7641020417,
0.4569337666,
0.5901524425,
-0.2749187946,
0.388757199,
0.5500064492,
-0.1339735985,
-0.2081044018,
-0.3383566141,
-0.4032024145,
0.4020338953,
0.6595707536,
-0.1828633696,
-0.2565143108,
-0.2066770196,
-0.0933557749,
0.3789003789,
-0.3092888594,
0.5609632134,
-0.3582890332,
-0.2800376117,
0.5786253214,
-0.4094078541,
0.3325277269,
-0.577989459,
-0.0387047455,
-0.1238253713,
0.0866533443,
-0.3099563718,
-0.6545416713,
0.0686528161,
0.0389588885,
0.2287291586,
0.164762184,
0.4722773433,
-0.1922494918,
-0.6255784035,
0.3906283975,
0.5377938747,
0.2811210752,
0.0254085213,
-0.7104523778,
0.4140620232,
-0.4330663383,
-0.4173131287,
0.2476913631,
0.348547399,
-0.2748120129,
1.027579546,
0.28523615,
0.3319378495,
-0.380833447,
0.2441355735,
1.2255526781,
-0.7569078803,
-0.2708547413,
-0.8803992271,
0.5699093938,
-0.3435755372,
0.089613378,
0.6438171268,
0.6610195041,
0.2693032622,
0.189997375,
1.0206468105,
-0.036668513,
0.7853627205,
-0.1298712343,
0.7703799605,
-0.3508689404,
0.7236207128,
-0.6303262711,
-0.9272078872,
-0.1658022404,
0.119738467,
-0.6349470019,
0.2846163213,
0.5996084213,
0.759753406,
0.1870614588,
0.0873302966,
0.2734175026,
0.2536520064,
0.4443438947,
0.2710972726,
0.8871396184,
-0.3591446579,
0.3588943183,
-0.1342484653,
-0.410762012,
-0.0838381723,
-1.073133707,
-1.1068210602,
-0.7195293307,
-0.5047613978,
-0.161305666,
0.337418586,
1.120444417,
0.6529170871,
-0.6671591997,
-0.1841563284,
0.01214513,
0.0004105595,
-0.2791161239,
-0.1455008388,
0.6410241723,
-0.3982153833,
-0.6543710232,
0.6004145145,
0.3316627741,
-0.1148931906,
-0.5642922521,
0.1589342207,
-0.0305247121,
0.1267783046,
0.374244988,
0.1403417289,
-0.3540899158,
-0.0147890402,
-0.3171452284,
-0.1275003254,
-0.0503290482,
0.59362185,
-0.9923664331,
0.5275135636,
0.1633474231,
0.9345434308,
0.5166453123,
-0.0106104743,
0.4517839253,
-0.5162866712,
-0.0128855435,
0.306458801,
0.0471538603,
0.7311327457,
-0.2022811919,
0.9141612053,
-0.125648886,
-0.648041904,
-1.1926724911,
-0.0637098774,
-0.5920274854,
-0.2036415786,
1.1269705296,
-0.0552490987,
-0.1261867583,
-0.1683232188,
0.0503529273,
-0.1270075887,
-0.5178797245,
0.9807950854,
0.658429265,
-0.1781658679,
0.2748034298,
-0.6557379365,
0.6273258328,
0.2965190411,
-1.1534655094,
0.6072717905,
0.4677353203,
0.1867734343,
-0.092679821,
0.4887000918,
-0.1336069256,
0.1181348786,
0.2905226052,
-0.1544387043,
-0.2744966745,
-0.3402338624,
-0.48786062,
-0.0221071634,
0.3434557915,
-0.1077272221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17151v2
|
Clustering Document Parts: Detecting and Characterizing Influence Campaigns from Documents
| 2024-02-27T02:36:43 | 2024-04-26T20:01:28 |
Zhengxiang Wang, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a novel clustering pipeline to detect and characterize influence
campaigns from documents. This approach clusters parts of document, detects
clusters that likely reflect an influence campaign, and then identifies
documents linked to an influence campaign via their association with the
high-influence clusters. Our approach outperforms both the direct
document-level classification and the direct document-level clustering approach
in predicting if a document is part of an influence campaign. We propose
various novel techniques to enhance our pipeline, including using an existing
event factuality prediction system to obtain document parts, and aggregating
multiple clustering experiments to improve the performance of both cluster and
document classification. Classifying documents after clustering not only
accurately extracts the parts of the documents that are relevant to influence
campaigns, but also captures influence campaigns as a coordinated and holistic
phenomenon. Our approach makes possible more fine-grained and interpretable
characterizations of influence campaigns from documents.
|
[
-0.291240871,
-0.7563673258,
0.8372088671,
0.0810047686,
-0.2077370137,
0.129364863,
-0.0889112875,
-0.2627270222,
0.740170598,
0.5843220949,
-0.6396628022,
-0.9058027864,
-1.1254665852,
-0.3396704197,
-0.9082570672,
1.1148798466,
0.2800943851,
0.038111683,
-0.3977545798,
-0.0927702114,
-0.1553186774,
-0.2502362728,
-0.6290635467,
-0.1868495494,
0.8701483011,
0.4412993491,
0.0421557091,
0.6660833955,
0.3843538761,
0.2626597583,
-0.1591643095,
-0.1567243934,
-0.7855498791,
0.1182842478,
-0.434106946,
-0.6549691558,
-0.0575802214,
0.3145552874,
0.787588954,
0.1497702748,
-0.1575817615,
0.1005069539,
-0.1463475078,
0.3679148555,
-0.6133062243,
0.4076770842,
-0.9721549153,
-0.2841282189,
-0.6317647696,
-0.0678943545,
-0.5995081663,
-0.2710726857,
-0.2331816852,
-0.5423917174,
0.9073116779,
0.2438963652,
0.4971308112,
0.013960178,
-0.6199600697,
-0.691026926,
-0.7961000204,
0.7583000064,
-0.5506436825,
0.1776225269,
0.2021154463,
-0.0124374917,
-0.1302521378,
-1.0680123568,
-0.6161729693,
0.2934495807,
-0.2307847142,
0.1717594564,
-0.2129092366,
-0.1216660142,
0.0245975349,
0.273794204,
-0.2292399406,
0.1132676303,
-0.3390827477,
-0.2620142996,
0.5205292702,
-0.1351177543,
0.2378939241,
-0.3721852899,
-0.3103095591,
-0.3239594698,
-0.7349418402,
-0.0465572327,
0.5006779432,
0.2355431914,
0.0320456363,
0.3410009444,
-0.3245445192,
0.278174907,
0.5879724026,
-0.0051507163,
-0.1722043604,
-0.6025627851,
-0.0388898216,
0.4874183536,
0.6748561859,
0.1427882016,
-0.5936625004,
0.0084044887,
0.2140457481,
0.1827219725,
0.2493454516,
-1.1483662128,
-0.1595256627,
0.018275626,
-0.7082896233,
-0.5737463236,
0.7242910862,
-0.8528740406,
-1.023062706,
-0.2253272682,
0.2509310544,
-0.1151131168,
-0.3074775636,
-0.3154335916,
-0.7201145887,
0.1281506568,
0.4575022459,
-0.7775788903,
-0.0062132846,
1.3430095911,
0.8270456791,
-0.3479122221,
-0.1067944914,
-0.6408706903,
0.1240933016,
-0.4433703125,
1.1867213249,
-0.8704612851,
-0.6076215506,
0.2468273342,
0.4928969145,
-0.0701996833,
-0.4103162289,
0.8138313293,
-0.5831583738,
0.2976961434,
-0.5256080627,
-0.8446633816,
-0.1410863101,
0.1274663955,
-0.9011998177,
0.8293495178,
0.177712217,
-0.8772941828,
0.7782531977,
-0.5124089122,
-0.4857271612,
-0.0737732127,
-0.2347493619,
-0.3577878177,
0.1607640088,
-0.0435445122,
0.5778028369,
-0.1973253638,
0.2219727635,
-0.3168261051,
-0.1151416078,
-0.1338751018,
-0.0585645065,
0.6099247932,
-0.2211016417,
-0.3786339462,
0.4458183348,
-0.7637674809,
-0.6235855818,
-0.2333296239,
-0.1380248517,
-0.7275082469,
0.290969491,
-0.1273823231,
0.0151671991,
0.2997259796,
-0.759313941,
0.3104792535,
-0.0243979264,
0.0303683709,
0.7456767559,
0.7002263665,
0.9195384383,
-0.092183724,
0.3824897408,
0.0732401013,
0.1501018703,
-0.2339318842,
-0.6099150777,
-0.9627696872,
-0.0468733087,
0.2054544389,
0.1480772048,
-0.4469674826,
0.5575879812,
-0.105589807,
-0.867413342,
-0.1150063872,
-0.0341720618,
0.0234679952,
0.4514447749,
0.1688838154,
-0.2945529819,
-0.3409072161,
-0.6543802023,
-0.3294655085,
-0.3450686634,
-0.0518942773,
-0.0643367842,
0.5361843705,
-0.1102961227,
0.7998250723,
-0.593310535,
-0.6144559979,
0.2739921808,
0.586026907,
0.2276135236,
0.2339139134,
0.6517379284,
-0.8717822433,
-0.5630989671,
0.2906548679,
-0.2287987322,
-0.0995282903,
-0.1874621958,
-0.2602683902,
-0.1835727245,
0.9989759326,
-0.250582397,
0.4109060764,
0.2692571282,
-0.787201941,
0.4021360278,
0.0102266548,
0.4412811995,
-1.0206130743,
-0.3300963342,
0.2169691324,
0.1980415583,
-0.6138074994,
-0.2594884038,
0.0343830436,
0.0342855528,
-0.2162213922,
0.3961782455,
-0.1944004446,
0.2423959523,
-0.4217303097,
-0.0256706756,
0.3292409778,
0.101455614,
-0.0106479144,
0.2091730684,
0.5693763494,
-0.178483054,
0.4864878058,
0.094015196,
-0.5997285843,
0.9743388295,
-0.497480303,
0.0840791687,
-0.2826687098,
0.7064311504,
-1.0711967945,
-0.2056741714,
0.2151450664,
-0.1375737786,
0.4443445504,
-0.6504946947,
-0.487146467,
0.0146791292,
-0.2262926549,
-0.2533547878,
0.2045891881,
-0.4150960445,
0.847086668,
0.50613451,
-0.10216894,
-0.2208151817,
-0.1764262021,
-0.1345610768,
-0.4783095419,
-0.4855628908,
0.5430906415,
0.2251562476,
-0.1016338542,
0.2742724121,
-0.0870530233,
-0.3069986701,
-0.325406462,
0.7542116046,
-0.0868482515,
-0.13656874,
0.1985669881,
0.329277277,
0.0000725096,
0.2030287236,
-0.6585710049,
0.2338681668,
0.2381755263,
-0.4698862433,
-0.1354901493,
0.5564271212,
0.7945611477,
-0.236565724,
0.8378654718,
1.2714245319,
-0.186921522,
-0.3809306622,
-0.7480496168,
-0.4445969462,
-0.4089232683,
0.2172265649,
0.1307342649,
-0.7471991181,
0.5619487166,
-0.3745738864,
0.00074341,
0.8616902232,
0.6184411049,
-0.0429775231,
0.849252522,
0.7966749668,
-0.4762619138,
0.9338933825,
-0.5887443423,
0.1166056842,
-0.5672464967,
-0.4468924701,
-0.8924934268,
-0.2637735307,
-0.5593931079,
-0.8822210431,
0.3903639615,
-0.0116983028,
0.3920081258,
0.226815477,
-0.4306123257,
0.3856597841,
0.7591879368,
-0.0416570157,
0.2489243746,
0.0840636417,
0.2140517384,
0.2804122269,
-0.7284405231,
-0.2036291063,
0.8694409132,
-0.0695821792,
0.6631044745,
-0.050994128,
0.7180259824,
0.7929217815,
0.5509034395,
-0.8727802038,
0.2708179355,
-0.18222709,
-0.7444136143,
-0.2714371085,
-0.0441255234,
-1.1719688177,
0.1081167758,
-0.4289064109,
-0.6157469749,
0.7269647121,
-0.2872433364,
0.182816714,
0.3776798546,
-0.6731594205,
0.8598482013,
0.2226184011,
-0.2300263792,
-0.7654069662,
-0.2791140079,
0.0088483961,
-0.1978702098,
0.2923828363,
-0.1035643369,
0.0596926399,
1.0922454596,
-0.1666663587,
0.9979386926,
-0.2625620663,
-0.0831842795,
0.4931671023,
-0.0620392039,
0.6627488732,
-0.103731744,
-0.3506275117,
0.0915931985,
0.1579155773,
-0.3897121549,
-0.8445283771,
0.9022561908,
-0.3584834933,
-0.5362766385,
-0.1985529661,
-0.3640090227,
0.1480868757,
0.6365153193,
0.3563033938,
0.6739019752,
-0.7177712917,
0.4929888248,
0.4873048663,
0.5627049804,
0.3960410357,
0.5283147693,
0.111761421,
-0.1888352931,
1.2085300684,
0.1312651783,
-0.0920050219,
0.4664447308,
0.5548829436,
-0.4792674184,
-0.7490002513,
-0.2255533189,
0.3293822408,
-0.771158576,
0.0355751999,
-0.486309737,
0.297943145,
-0.7766496539,
-0.1274004728,
-0.2325390875,
-0.2345839739,
-0.3898491561,
-0.0979315639,
0.1411367804,
1.3490322828,
-0.0639872551,
0.6543157697,
-0.7652241588,
-0.164524436,
0.3380330801,
0.1473129392,
-0.1748117656,
-0.2993266582,
-0.7322227359,
-0.4342348576,
-0.3755711317,
-1.1134996414,
-0.023878308,
0.1134899408,
0.5214146972,
1.1091601849,
0.343203187,
-0.1295332015,
-0.3365992308,
0.8301944137,
0.1656623334,
-0.7728449106,
0.5726236105,
-0.6440622807,
0.0725632459,
0.6888097525,
0.6436368823,
-0.295588851,
-0.3478881121,
-1.22059834,
-0.500371933,
0.5824118257,
0.2206042856,
-0.1784805804,
0.0520694628,
0.1417943984,
-0.1347899288,
0.3540089726,
-0.2464159727,
0.0926855728,
0.0573011488,
0.0349431299,
0.0853664204,
-0.2599901259,
-0.4036763012,
0.0642726868,
0.8966340423,
-0.1898428202,
-0.3428012133,
0.2281781733,
0.387201339,
-0.2096451372,
-0.0235963482,
0.1482093781,
0.8188140988,
-0.2685791254,
0.0352241248,
-0.2276850194,
-0.457913667,
-0.0449745655,
0.0353954993,
-0.3221989572,
0.4023573995,
0.6552680731,
0.7133193016,
0.04734971,
0.09221863,
0.6000820398,
-0.0677990094,
-0.2336478829,
-0.0533632226,
0.0578063428,
0.1981747746,
0.276311636,
0.2774642408,
0.0681820363,
0.3967637122,
-0.8932529688,
0.3232781291,
0.4777148366,
-1.0484058857,
-0.4367102385,
0.275111407,
0.5437465906,
-0.1417992562,
0.0404086486,
-0.1993902177,
-0.6242164373,
1.0017124414,
0.2232526392,
0.6725454926,
-0.3240592182,
0.404605031,
0.3777014911,
0.2351996601,
-0.028123416,
-0.7061083317,
-0.2150177807,
-0.7034819126,
-0.2512375712,
-0.4061395526,
-0.4931619763,
-0.0598701015,
-0.6520764232,
0.4461618662,
-0.3277332187,
-0.1466780156,
0.3733392954,
0.201924324,
-0.248885721,
0.0744519979,
-0.1302980185,
0.7757468224,
-1.1592929363,
0.9102967978,
0.5328379869,
0.0486429967,
-0.6179497242,
0.2393035889,
0.2795232832,
-0.3804050684,
0.2277612686,
0.0036872793,
-0.1674012691,
0.0806610361,
-0.4334347248,
-0.6435716152,
1.108566165,
-0.218400687,
-0.3124266863,
0.014602649,
-0.2986848056,
0.1669295877,
-0.5369664431,
-0.0597019717,
0.7066664696,
0.691770196,
0.2242450565,
-0.100055933,
0.06953419,
0.0364216231,
-0.4571875334,
0.5698007345,
-0.6238872409,
0.5714355111,
0.2879188061,
-0.4128588736,
-0.2080088407,
0.7454323769,
-0.136467427,
0.8675765991,
0.9324005246,
0.4389556944,
1.013455987,
-0.0803535879,
1.1814351082,
-0.3119825125,
0.4185236394,
0.9305493236,
-0.0263646021,
0.5703254938,
0.3851761222,
-0.0318377092,
0.9228538275,
0.399587065,
0.023344608,
0.3875569999,
0.0840728581,
-0.5913362503,
-0.1061298549,
-0.5203030109,
-0.2758117914,
0.4589004517,
0.6724250913,
-0.4249490499,
-0.1549593955,
-0.1406015754,
0.1878613234,
0.1173267365,
-0.1293964982,
0.8164192438,
-0.0927800685,
-0.8206393719,
-0.3469901979,
0.0085435081,
0.5198686719,
-0.8205877542,
-0.1396659017,
0.0445914455,
0.1186344922,
-0.3003334701,
-0.6688085794,
0.2568156123,
-0.2606714666,
-0.6581919789,
-0.1037142053,
1.2618393898,
-0.5495636463,
-0.6656832695,
0.2740128934,
0.3772982657,
-0.0699638724,
-0.3939373493,
-0.4106529355,
0.0135607412,
0.0061613424,
-0.0369855203,
0.3626700938,
0.7452409267,
0.0170242116,
-0.0073836935,
1.0895867348,
0.2969035208,
-0.0864685178,
0.2108253241,
0.7763609886,
-0.3094106019,
-0.5972815752,
-0.5704945326,
0.1583969295,
-0.6995915174,
-0.150770545,
0.967979908,
0.5745028853,
0.5752800107,
0.0124974288,
0.6778347492,
-0.2863688171,
0.4553890228,
-0.2898384035,
0.9238066673,
-0.3440617025,
-0.0507055968,
-0.2617377937,
-0.7831609845,
0.0253243931,
0.0417205952,
-0.2878398597,
-0.5570660233,
0.8223791718,
1.020182848,
-0.2389416099,
0.1062312722,
0.0622650087,
0.2396662533,
0.6519815326,
-0.2233867198,
0.7176968455,
-0.0891752914,
0.6049481034,
-0.249111861,
-0.3937611282,
-0.1620795131,
-1.1304017305,
-0.7645351291,
-1.00525105,
-0.4692674577,
-0.5117921233,
-0.3509453833,
0.1550801843,
1.2796149254,
-0.814326942,
-0.15871571,
-0.2630523741,
0.7876706123,
-0.0021178976,
-0.32530725,
0.5680558681,
-0.1053964049,
-1.0281108618,
0.5995636582,
0.2687487602,
-0.3055100441,
-0.4639338553,
0.300619483,
-0.333122015,
0.2574796081,
0.6648741364,
0.0838885307,
-0.3663799763,
-0.1466630846,
-0.1774677336,
0.2147700489,
-0.188202098,
1.4761279821,
-0.4747354984,
0.4963418841,
0.9132641554,
0.4199392796,
0.9641128778,
0.2917312086,
0.2636485398,
-0.8348555565,
0.2658866048,
0.0522034541,
0.1968980432,
0.2416854054,
-0.5353481174,
0.516672194,
0.6740772724,
-0.5973594785,
-0.3300142586,
0.1297011524,
-1.2101950645,
-0.2894600928,
1.2208869457,
-0.1183924079,
-0.3662961721,
-0.2061116993,
-0.2907405794,
0.1541069001,
-0.745978415,
0.5915846229,
0.6747758389,
-0.2034253925,
0.2438120693,
-0.0846098736,
0.2762531936,
0.0825935379,
-0.948022902,
-0.2694179118,
0.7520220876,
0.1494138539,
0.7458411455,
0.6968638897,
0.0040578153,
-0.2559095621,
0.1314263344,
-0.3740510046,
0.3882217109,
-0.4570170641,
0.1712488979,
0.4197742343,
-0.2176304758,
-0.1225434765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07910v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07910v2
|
MAGPIE: Multi-Task Media-Bias Analysis Generalization for Pre-Trained Identification of Expressions
| 2024-02-27T02:00:28 | 2024-03-15T09:30:29 |
Tomáš Horych, Martin Wessel, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Jerome Waßmuth, André Greiner-Petter, Akiko Aizawa, Bela Gipp, Timo Spinde
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Media bias detection poses a complex, multifaceted problem traditionally
tackled using single-task models and small in-domain datasets, consequently
lacking generalizability. To address this, we introduce MAGPIE, the first
large-scale multi-task pre-training approach explicitly tailored for media bias
detection. To enable pre-training at scale, we present Large Bias Mixture
(LBM), a compilation of 59 bias-related tasks. MAGPIE outperforms previous
approaches in media bias detection on the Bias Annotation By Experts (BABE)
dataset, with a relative improvement of 3.3% F1-score. MAGPIE also performs
better than previous models on 5 out of 8 tasks in the Media Bias
Identification Benchmark (MBIB). Using a RoBERTa encoder, MAGPIE needs only 15%
of finetuning steps compared to single-task approaches. Our evaluation shows,
for instance, that tasks like sentiment and emotionality boost all learning,
all tasks enhance fake news detection, and scaling tasks leads to the best
results. MAGPIE confirms that MTL is a promising approach for addressing media
bias detection, enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of existing models.
Furthermore, LBM is the first available resource collection focused on media
bias MTL.
|
[
-0.8065952063,
-0.680470109,
0.0827067047,
0.5617401004,
-0.0802476779,
-0.0435861051,
-0.3763603568,
-0.1181711406,
0.2903551757,
0.2458211482,
-0.8166630268,
-0.0817967653,
-1.0868560076,
-0.0330602117,
-0.3904151917,
1.1010806561,
0.3097169101,
0.3889219463,
-0.0401982889,
-0.1733386517,
-0.32957533,
-0.3334687948,
-0.2052672207,
-0.2135163546,
0.3707103133,
0.3022527993,
0.5033227801,
-0.0706866756,
0.3560869098,
0.2190371752,
0.0366076343,
0.727393806,
-0.5260284543,
-0.4045099616,
-0.2143176049,
-0.2405837178,
-0.4001699388,
0.7867516875,
0.5240513086,
0.2474125028,
0.2065504342,
0.7363731265,
-0.0544308089,
0.9234752059,
-1.0900117159,
-0.2992939651,
-0.5672056079,
0.5249438882,
-0.3906320035,
-0.4407982826,
-0.6852737665,
-0.0877932906,
-0.2856990695,
-0.6347619891,
0.3712135553,
0.0487072133,
0.9348495007,
0.2725247145,
-0.6866170764,
-0.4368611872,
-0.820674479,
0.8562254906,
-0.324260205,
0.4196228087,
0.2759710848,
0.2225088179,
-0.1417066604,
-0.4939461946,
-0.7501873374,
0.1349000186,
-0.0691594332,
0.2455306202,
-0.255567342,
-0.3526315391,
0.3491698802,
0.4015552998,
-0.4829396605,
-0.1265044957,
-0.4612305164,
-0.3716471791,
0.4414191842,
-0.1972611099,
0.1770633459,
-0.1831153929,
-0.2590691447,
0.1669640243,
-0.5943965316,
-0.1334076077,
0.4171929061,
0.1580175906,
0.0845009387,
0.340328604,
-0.2214352638,
0.7547787428,
0.5257901549,
-0.278242141,
0.5923120379,
-0.2165986151,
-0.4519886971,
-0.0993263423,
1.1589636803,
0.3593068123,
0.1142223254,
0.2202364504,
-0.0005431336,
-0.0034480833,
0.4977189004,
-1.009051919,
-0.0983022004,
0.0333392099,
-0.7262888551,
-0.437656343,
0.2002289444,
-1.0721478462,
-0.8294832706,
-0.1135187075,
0.6374707818,
-0.0627237335,
-0.5359002948,
-0.0423776321,
0.0474241488,
0.090273425,
0.1235274449,
-0.4790233672,
0.1165393591,
0.3306288421,
0.720774591,
-0.069355607,
-0.1190793365,
-1.0963379145,
-0.097589463,
-0.3989698589,
0.7748360634,
-0.663869381,
0.0336457789,
0.0215665512,
0.0383215621,
-0.039976839,
-0.6799325943,
0.7825775146,
-0.7059940696,
0.6230205894,
-0.4384433925,
-0.2886847556,
0.0079477988,
0.4767276347,
-0.8648893237,
0.9363468885,
0.3064335585,
-1.1048641205,
0.8014798164,
-0.9887264967,
-0.3671862781,
-0.4309628308,
0.0836201832,
-0.5080750585,
0.054779239,
0.6915347576,
0.459851265,
-0.3910591602,
0.0669151172,
-0.3523840904,
-0.4524478316,
0.0903760493,
-0.4109979272,
0.8881465197,
0.4917710125,
-0.4092267454,
0.1598866731,
-0.4961298108,
-0.144108355,
0.0370066799,
-0.1530461758,
-0.1139442176,
-0.1266001761,
0.1991908997,
0.5855945945,
0.0437979065,
-0.5017730594,
0.1868278235,
0.3740048409,
0.2431750149,
0.6463827491,
-0.33011657,
0.4775475562,
-0.0089836121,
0.4469338357,
0.5156054497,
0.4481311142,
-0.2263465673,
-0.1005457714,
-0.4719244838,
-0.5627057552,
0.4771240354,
0.4720689356,
-0.6398182511,
0.3162220418,
-0.2191496491,
-0.5119967461,
-0.5498186946,
0.4987168312,
0.3515942991,
0.3680108786,
0.4582525194,
-0.3295562267,
-0.5083740354,
-0.9654960632,
-0.5889977813,
0.4012066722,
-0.118946895,
0.0430769287,
0.2065747082,
-0.3669168651,
0.891037941,
-0.3005978763,
-1.0136421919,
-0.0856684148,
0.3496725261,
0.3014745116,
0.2861697078,
0.6397231221,
-1.1996018887,
-0.4275785089,
-0.2846396863,
-0.6941276193,
-0.4012769759,
-0.1993555129,
-0.0141925756,
-0.0505921505,
0.4780446589,
-0.7541508675,
0.0511039272,
0.6877029538,
-0.3404071927,
0.4860278368,
0.1367300749,
0.3622938097,
-0.8976598978,
-0.1806112975,
0.4089500308,
-0.3170236349,
-0.6680920124,
-0.1698348373,
0.2314785123,
0.0990325436,
-0.6131692529,
0.1713568866,
-0.523573041,
-0.2666879594,
-0.512229979,
0.0146493567,
0.1737425327,
0.2775484324,
-0.1421120316,
1.0816414356,
0.4622625411,
-0.3808351457,
0.2003323585,
0.0249238517,
-0.2191922367,
0.7148138285,
-0.2583994865,
0.2344554514,
-0.4074559808,
0.4247105122,
-0.7990407944,
-0.1453220397,
0.4295551777,
-0.6263853908,
0.2781499028,
-0.1571039706,
-0.6679077148,
-0.537516892,
-0.3134415448,
0.2707933486,
0.2653850317,
-0.5645145178,
0.9925530553,
0.5462120771,
0.3073180616,
-0.9273396134,
-0.206578359,
-0.1421434581,
-0.3648198545,
-0.2340963483,
0.1098569855,
-0.0909263194,
0.0680982545,
-0.2720997632,
-0.2490737587,
-0.2225238383,
-0.2075030953,
0.276194334,
0.0729000717,
-0.0363208242,
0.2117550671,
0.0443449132,
0.1783426702,
0.0849845931,
-0.1395787895,
0.681135118,
-0.2833507061,
-0.1351759881,
-0.2814894915,
0.2415749282,
0.7200688124,
-0.5576835275,
0.4796769619,
1.5390487909,
-0.1897930801,
-0.0650892779,
-0.9188333154,
-0.0081911404,
-0.452546984,
0.3835262954,
-0.1660297811,
-0.551602006,
0.1429517418,
-0.2281406671,
-0.0098575,
0.3113934398,
0.744787991,
0.1823441535,
0.9875841141,
0.7115439773,
-0.547388494,
0.6380006671,
-0.102279447,
-0.023090316,
-0.7302480936,
0.0217758808,
-0.0168166049,
-0.4215382934,
-0.0947840512,
-0.5073312521,
0.2090384513,
-0.0123304613,
-0.2278183699,
-0.0277612116,
-0.702115953,
0.6670181751,
0.6703432202,
0.2638046443,
0.1735381782,
-0.2022421807,
0.3569759727,
0.0268517155,
-0.4065052271,
-0.3811802268,
1.379099369,
0.1933235377,
0.450101763,
-0.1700256616,
0.4044843316,
0.8407354355,
1.0455168486,
-0.5817382932,
0.3644164503,
-0.0346879438,
-1.0611723661,
-0.0348137803,
-0.3327275217,
-0.5360702276,
0.6870955229,
-0.6316876411,
-0.2600244582,
-0.0753635913,
0.3218655884,
-0.2774296105,
0.2465029657,
-0.931314826,
0.9520017505,
-0.1547556072,
-0.5234838724,
-0.1444294155,
-0.4863570929,
0.7146939635,
-0.457859844,
0.6952313185,
-0.2058306634,
0.1566972435,
0.7838302255,
0.027369773,
0.675534308,
-0.5138404965,
0.3335345387,
0.1488289237,
-0.103825435,
0.2177819461,
-0.0796326026,
0.0712429658,
0.0531940795,
-0.0725284517,
-0.5058413148,
-0.407291472,
0.4702396989,
-0.8393015265,
-0.4514453113,
-0.3642059267,
-0.825283289,
-0.2841053307,
0.5498533845,
0.3146841228,
0.1628227681,
0.0002819378,
0.0886327401,
0.6932671666,
-0.2204575092,
0.2739503086,
0.6112591028,
-0.3915977478,
-0.3459029198,
0.7169156075,
-0.0381074362,
-0.0921800062,
-0.0161958486,
0.1822954267,
0.2589113414,
-0.2059093118,
-0.5010002851,
0.0457961559,
-0.5523067713,
-0.3239181936,
-0.6254037023,
0.1082835793,
-0.2235448658,
0.1536494195,
-0.6620172858,
0.2118925005,
-0.2363037616,
0.1387127191,
-0.2123306394,
0.520921886,
-0.1997629106,
0.6367063522,
-0.8585762978,
0.724181056,
0.2667329907,
0.0724659264,
-0.2818550467,
-0.496124059,
-0.3569568098,
0.0892506614,
-0.8423041105,
-1.0940806866,
0.6128512025,
0.2756994665,
0.3035999238,
0.8426830769,
0.1571332067,
0.5963983536,
-0.633084178,
0.5930619836,
0.3161260486,
-0.9736888409,
0.479521811,
-0.225475058,
0.0245960131,
0.4676303864,
0.8229837418,
-0.0619463287,
-0.2548622191,
-0.3885941505,
-0.3614447713,
0.5145418048,
-0.1395069957,
0.214062199,
-0.0690510869,
-0.0437883995,
0.1806977987,
0.4789951444,
-1.0687572956,
-0.214550823,
-0.4197449982,
-0.0716199279,
-0.0286198389,
-0.2184724957,
-0.5034512877,
-0.4809855521,
0.545574069,
-0.1768867671,
0.4484399259,
0.167262271,
-0.6847257018,
-0.3168124259,
0.2030038983,
0.7968252301,
0.7646337748,
-0.162207827,
0.0823652446,
-0.0651174709,
-0.654394567,
0.0945717171,
0.1201070771,
0.0997886807,
0.2185478359,
0.1424768865,
0.3693187833,
-0.1751285046,
-0.6900830269,
1.1602894068,
0.160464555,
-0.2416618168,
-0.6264535785,
-0.2026860714,
0.0080156494,
0.560192585,
0.8015726209,
0.1473720968,
0.4017892778,
-0.5566303134,
0.220973894,
0.6847234368,
-0.6227462292,
-0.3083203137,
0.7612099648,
0.1247474775,
0.1331651211,
0.4524212778,
-0.4350545704,
-0.6622565389,
0.400363028,
0.4943729043,
0.5042056441,
-0.1639683545,
0.3828463554,
0.0881186873,
0.5410267115,
-0.068497628,
-0.0560525469,
0.0762608871,
-1.0573480129,
-0.5998252034,
-0.4732345343,
-0.1472811848,
0.3508895636,
-0.8436742425,
0.246263817,
-0.4413433671,
-0.5068988204,
0.287314862,
0.0458445363,
-0.7636858225,
0.3467383385,
0.4169549942,
0.8282476068,
-1.4433420897,
0.8807272315,
0.6830078363,
-0.3451635838,
-0.5851511359,
-0.0195916742,
0.3204296231,
-0.5639659762,
1.1394994259,
0.6396430135,
0.1235140264,
-0.2848796248,
-0.5301926732,
-0.4162433147,
0.8710998893,
0.3402641118,
-0.3371468484,
0.0159909222,
-0.1885372251,
0.1600410789,
-0.6997903585,
0.5552436709,
0.5164484382,
0.4821946025,
-0.071499452,
-0.8528395295,
-0.0501703881,
-0.3854841292,
-0.4400214851,
0.3111201525,
-0.7723029852,
1.0066808462,
-0.025435783,
0.1582060903,
-0.6077051759,
0.7354505062,
-0.0183979515,
0.5735070705,
0.7805299759,
0.4179601073,
0.8037834167,
-0.0374606177,
0.7534052134,
-0.3291575015,
0.4400962889,
0.9431849122,
-0.2121629715,
0.4746747911,
0.5141378045,
-0.1092255563,
0.3935803771,
0.6332719326,
-0.254360944,
0.5880938768,
0.0336553343,
-0.2788385451,
-0.2828312516,
0.0606287532,
-0.2724365294,
0.2644149959,
0.4792325795,
-0.6273614168,
-0.046950344,
0.5963895917,
0.2838934958,
-0.1033195183,
-0.7571434975,
0.3384718001,
-0.2804315984,
-0.3322471082,
0.4229030609,
-0.3672725558,
1.1957612038,
-0.4877880216,
0.2411340922,
-0.0210946575,
0.2254952937,
-0.5211081505,
-0.2974614203,
0.1877351403,
-0.2364721745,
-0.5115695,
-0.0840933695,
0.9339907169,
-0.4117224514,
-0.5047367811,
0.0795326829,
0.4878735244,
-0.0552309416,
-0.5677369237,
-0.5924959779,
0.2970304191,
-0.1201056167,
-0.6085929871,
0.4733262062,
0.2768500447,
0.1264669746,
0.6305105686,
0.6385459304,
0.1471733153,
0.3002853096,
-0.14539285,
1.0910781622,
-0.2668845654,
-0.1207850799,
-0.6931485534,
0.1857865304,
-0.5004723072,
-0.2109173536,
0.7869588733,
0.4959284067,
0.8206778765,
-0.471807152,
0.6750837564,
-0.2217295766,
0.5767298341,
-0.3054992259,
0.7555282116,
-0.6136428714,
-0.205479905,
-0.5400654674,
-1.0602208376,
-0.2794090509,
0.6970648766,
-0.5064738393,
0.0636604205,
0.6512594223,
0.8252000213,
-0.3584791422,
-0.0448393226,
0.1859361082,
-0.0378561206,
0.2515228987,
0.4476892948,
0.696721375,
-0.3867482245,
0.6135730147,
-0.1337352991,
-0.4293346405,
-0.2695513368,
-0.8827544451,
-1.1171706915,
-0.2843729854,
-0.1113381386,
-0.3637512624,
-0.1368678957,
1.1968803406,
1.1121908426,
-0.6192392707,
0.0630308613,
0.5392617583,
0.0291281622,
-0.475918293,
-0.2721185088,
0.2434055358,
-0.4455321133,
-0.9090726972,
0.2486632764,
0.0118467342,
-0.6342993975,
-0.1662450284,
0.0096953157,
-0.1738535762,
0.0717302933,
0.8716185689,
0.2927312255,
-0.3677317798,
-0.2545382679,
-0.1348504573,
0.1005679891,
0.1544425786,
1.0539638996,
-0.7186251283,
0.4388382733,
0.0625777617,
0.7030747533,
0.5518454909,
0.1182965115,
0.2923467159,
-0.7838160396,
0.4631362855,
0.0268559158,
0.3578708172,
0.2785056829,
-0.2552142441,
0.377214849,
0.2047967911,
-0.6392454505,
-0.9849370718,
0.3138409555,
-1.0469673872,
-0.2180516124,
1.0375412703,
-0.0497075021,
-0.0358361714,
0.1803270578,
-0.3390411437,
0.163963601,
-0.2083095163,
0.8103045225,
0.7234592438,
0.1100685224,
-0.5000540018,
-0.7938042879,
0.2839942575,
0.2742150724,
-0.7206424475,
-0.1820015162,
0.640000701,
0.4770415723,
0.461817801,
0.835357666,
-0.3177622259,
0.3115613759,
-0.2865688205,
0.2263245136,
-0.5939119458,
-0.3835017085,
0.0970999822,
0.4088508785,
-0.2125573158,
-0.2828588486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17128v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17128v4
|
OSCaR: Object State Captioning and State Change Representation
| 2024-02-27T01:48:19 | 2024-04-02T23:14:42 |
Nguyen Nguyen, Jing Bi, Ali Vosoughi, Yapeng Tian, Pooyan Fazli, Chenliang Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The capability of intelligent models to extrapolate and comprehend changes in
object states is a crucial yet demanding aspect of AI research, particularly
through the lens of human interaction in real-world settings. This task
involves describing complex visual environments, identifying active objects,
and interpreting their changes as conveyed through language. Traditional
methods, which isolate object captioning and state change detection, offer a
limited view of dynamic environments. Moreover, relying on a small set of
symbolic words to represent changes has restricted the expressiveness of the
language. To address these challenges, in this paper, we introduce the Object
State Captioning and State Change Representation (OSCaR) dataset and benchmark.
OSCaR consists of 14,084 annotated video segments with nearly 1,000 unique
objects from various egocentric video collections. It sets a new testbed for
evaluating multimodal large language models (MLLMs). Our experiments
demonstrate that while MLLMs show some skill, they lack a full understanding of
object state changes. The benchmark includes a fine-tuned model that, despite
initial capabilities, requires significant improvements in accuracy and
generalization ability for effective understanding of these changes. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/nguyennm1024/OSCaR.
|
[
-0.399110347,
-0.4540231526,
0.3213707507,
-0.1602219939,
-0.2402807623,
0.0598092787,
-0.0920541286,
-0.5919519067,
-0.011828701,
0.0911677182,
-0.3441256583,
-0.2255726606,
-0.7138182521,
0.1953659058,
-0.6103004813,
0.6185765862,
-0.344841212,
0.2273267061,
-0.1692595482,
-0.3231235445,
-0.3764533103,
-0.2382300347,
-0.2115501612,
-0.076154843,
0.1812878847,
0.2632730603,
0.6594164371,
0.8051579595,
0.6220368147,
0.328646034,
0.1334729791,
0.1756045371,
-0.2386489511,
0.0036590958,
-0.2581856847,
-0.5255396962,
-0.1635386646,
0.0850166157,
0.8882961869,
0.2723888755,
-0.0840585902,
0.5021136403,
-0.3087226152,
0.6565544605,
-0.7933664918,
0.9704778194,
-1.0293962955,
0.2847056091,
-0.0819063857,
0.1699620038,
-0.0597445965,
0.3730215132,
0.0461726785,
-0.7088615298,
0.245667845,
0.3733186722,
1.1922445297,
0.5194502473,
-0.0903538018,
0.1316645741,
-0.8390218019,
0.8004929423,
-0.5577545762,
0.7162351608,
0.1375015825,
0.6723057032,
0.0572277009,
-0.5755798817,
-0.8755794764,
-0.6137343645,
0.0985157564,
-0.1646778136,
-0.2600646019,
-0.1354416609,
0.2781911194,
0.2252356857,
0.0192130003,
0.0590930544,
-0.5405540466,
-0.2127463669,
0.6485418677,
0.2585189044,
0.0998017117,
-0.2107852995,
-0.3522962034,
-0.6743398905,
-0.5171020627,
0.2206149846,
0.033856418,
0.1695153266,
0.0518950373,
0.7181632519,
-0.2701255381,
0.6780000329,
-0.1809687763,
0.0145252189,
0.317119956,
-0.1570126861,
-0.4502741992,
-0.1009087637,
0.5650779605,
0.5303000212,
0.1808828712,
0.0937791318,
-0.3270151019,
0.2593845427,
0.2944025993,
-0.602157712,
-0.0771379322,
0.3079070747,
-0.4100284278,
0.058668863,
0.3365420699,
-0.5477360487,
-0.7740929127,
-0.650981009,
0.4291451871,
-0.2192308158,
-0.1050447002,
0.1982619315,
-0.0077117104,
0.487940073,
0.612929821,
-0.577278018,
0.2089339197,
0.7506269813,
0.7635110021,
-0.1766316742,
-0.5244716406,
-0.5572001338,
0.1612285823,
-0.6870139241,
0.8220641017,
-0.6400822997,
0.2326819897,
0.0029373169,
0.048426602,
0.085155353,
-0.7391158938,
0.058536768,
-0.3645632267,
-0.3383581042,
0.0622376502,
-0.4905801713,
-0.2898285687,
0.4153843522,
-0.868663311,
0.65382725,
-0.1414505839,
-0.1996960938,
0.5574349761,
-0.8680286407,
-0.0741308406,
-0.2118615508,
-0.2612108886,
-0.5710112453,
0.2466521561,
0.380461812,
0.822863102,
-0.1508906782,
0.3680969775,
-0.2600180507,
-0.2763483524,
0.3599426746,
-0.1272399276,
-0.145620048,
0.2887967825,
-0.2144833952,
0.3841887116,
-0.6737575531,
-0.3731898069,
0.0056783389,
-0.1439834237,
0.1101366729,
0.3758884966,
0.0933836773,
0.1315401495,
0.2574938536,
-0.6010609269,
0.0791099221,
0.1254251748,
0.4877161086,
0.7450374961,
-0.4069289863,
0.2295679897,
-0.1848362684,
0.47196275,
0.4118307829,
0.2083474398,
-0.4382556379,
-0.3822552264,
-0.6673545837,
-0.1613162756,
0.0617648438,
0.3798801899,
-0.5858476162,
-0.161446631,
-0.2122063339,
-0.2642638087,
-0.9163755774,
0.1081983373,
0.1677594483,
0.3242151737,
0.5530004501,
-0.2103771865,
-0.5455120802,
-1.1781901121,
-0.2242909819,
-0.1974791884,
0.0609213263,
0.2058718652,
0.7027518153,
-0.0692424625,
0.7658197284,
-0.4267624021,
-0.6226899624,
0.0069526923,
0.161781162,
-0.0374343842,
0.4554855227,
0.2453250885,
-0.9561453462,
-0.1494357288,
0.0476760603,
-0.6524931788,
0.3295820355,
-0.3883855045,
0.1362574548,
0.1003065556,
0.9113132358,
-0.3152889013,
0.4118028879,
0.504191041,
-0.1780801266,
0.6793780327,
-0.1518808007,
0.367215395,
-0.5818399191,
0.2072133422,
-0.0090701301,
-0.2686466277,
-0.4003687799,
0.3157732785,
0.0771560967,
-0.4215491116,
-0.8516148925,
0.5986320972,
-0.6326718926,
-0.464006424,
-0.1515825242,
0.0540847927,
-0.2229567021,
0.6444219947,
0.1821604073,
0.681748569,
0.8383738995,
-0.4259451628,
0.6417409182,
0.1991056651,
-0.6641337276,
0.464330852,
-0.5785921812,
-0.0792331845,
-0.5640736818,
0.2525852323,
-0.7742024064,
-0.1703975052,
0.3373993337,
-0.2180458754,
0.0558394901,
-0.1147922501,
-0.6279412508,
-0.0442029387,
-0.3302061558,
0.1572888047,
0.2168149203,
-0.253603816,
0.6656372547,
0.4431494474,
0.148160845,
-0.5649170876,
-0.4802031815,
0.3176996112,
-0.0494059026,
-0.1200441197,
0.1345737278,
-0.0251211077,
-0.2685054243,
0.2192609161,
-0.0812834576,
-0.1412746161,
0.0209695213,
0.229144901,
0.2367200553,
-0.1380606443,
0.3465065658,
-0.1210341156,
0.0205537155,
-0.0149928257,
0.0908802971,
0.4735939801,
-0.5210261941,
-0.3697368503,
-0.776812017,
0.2271212637,
0.8575145602,
-0.7159425616,
0.7255923152,
0.6800268888,
-0.4725117385,
0.0750181228,
-0.3582470715,
-0.0883878693,
-0.4129627347,
0.8717321754,
-0.461702615,
-0.713262558,
0.5630569458,
-0.0598381199,
0.2862790823,
0.2937845886,
0.5104788542,
-0.1466106176,
1.1414390802,
0.3145561814,
-0.1819856614,
0.7746186852,
-0.4147402942,
-0.1958677173,
-1.1855021715,
-0.3298006058,
-0.3088178039,
-0.6525415778,
-0.3779703975,
-0.8289638758,
0.3152193725,
0.0409634598,
-0.3447770774,
0.2369025797,
-0.236654982,
0.4531294107,
0.2553720176,
0.1171200871,
0.2138825655,
0.0595154427,
0.2455610633,
0.0315089487,
-0.3960085809,
-0.4152894318,
1.1297841072,
0.4233297408,
0.8930588961,
0.1521749496,
0.2285315394,
0.6731845737,
0.3462537229,
-0.8959841728,
0.7879295945,
-0.1919324696,
-0.4167389572,
-0.4340825975,
-0.1713565141,
-1.071177721,
0.5299040675,
-0.3889263272,
-0.6525560617,
0.0803331435,
0.4572623074,
-0.0255869739,
0.4693163037,
-0.399592191,
0.8434005976,
-0.1175948158,
-0.1797245294,
-0.4890506864,
-0.4145389199,
-0.0033786008,
0.106479466,
0.0735682026,
-0.4368405938,
-0.2959779203,
0.5940985084,
-0.1667872071,
0.6691511869,
-0.1698126048,
-0.0094442125,
0.2540453076,
0.326392889,
0.6834767461,
-0.0327675305,
-0.0560208224,
0.1661610007,
-0.0658626705,
-0.3654719889,
-0.6082851887,
0.4162010849,
-0.6434904337,
-0.6460549831,
-0.3862160444,
-0.6468273401,
-0.1693233252,
0.0039690724,
-0.4106026292,
0.4565654695,
-0.0800912231,
0.2308267802,
0.3553880751,
-0.211697191,
0.1967873573,
0.6593046188,
-0.4540342987,
0.115454644,
0.9240458012,
-0.1186304241,
0.1083617881,
0.465557605,
0.2073077857,
-0.4484879375,
-0.4208960831,
-0.848770678,
0.1621439308,
-0.7556908131,
-0.0547544248,
-0.1780298799,
0.205386579,
-0.3668153882,
0.0710937828,
-0.5940918922,
-0.2179823816,
-0.3201818168,
-0.0502838232,
0.3143400848,
0.7589460015,
-0.0053341775,
-0.2416195869,
-0.6950353384,
0.4531739652,
0.3912421763,
0.4099081755,
0.0836339593,
-0.3862637877,
-0.3265485168,
-0.0345558152,
0.0318434425,
-0.6960577965,
0.1766651571,
0.6644170284,
0.6859384179,
0.4566892087,
-0.0494739264,
0.8531595469,
-0.6151490211,
0.820664227,
0.0589112937,
-1.0165710449,
0.6051588655,
-0.0731917545,
0.5250146389,
0.2693851292,
0.1735042632,
-0.7617322206,
-0.4873183668,
-0.3410254419,
-0.5159581304,
0.7380641103,
-0.0736691728,
0.2039951086,
0.3508082628,
-0.0237221718,
-0.0622315556,
0.5445437431,
-0.4704165161,
-0.0916743577,
-0.3352633119,
-0.0883676857,
-0.1634667367,
0.2543933094,
-0.1487770081,
-0.3279674649,
0.4222447872,
-0.1959071308,
0.3915357888,
0.1638973653,
-0.3755481839,
-0.0399441086,
0.2256886065,
0.8177477717,
0.7337226868,
-0.1758214086,
0.154611364,
0.0602147169,
-0.278185457,
0.1308616698,
0.2504802048,
0.0507739298,
-0.0276552904,
0.4037694335,
1.1044354439,
0.1946283579,
-1.1989141703,
0.3179457188,
0.1612253487,
0.144397825,
-0.3057378829,
0.1216851994,
-0.2650901675,
0.2594240308,
0.3678300381,
0.3042920232,
0.1917040646,
-0.8845427036,
0.1542178541,
0.2694531381,
-0.5816459656,
-0.3867058754,
0.8254976273,
0.0851492584,
-0.069133997,
0.4722736478,
-0.2801539898,
-0.5008587837,
0.7535902858,
0.2159236223,
0.5924533606,
0.0000520719,
0.4498671889,
0.334007442,
0.2361014038,
-0.2349566072,
0.0219445303,
-0.1946522444,
-1.0586878061,
-0.1844197214,
-0.472528398,
-0.5024671555,
0.2213144898,
-0.6962880492,
0.0950033069,
-0.4704520404,
0.0895705074,
-0.0750301704,
-0.360755831,
-0.8429800272,
0.1022067741,
0.4049155712,
0.6092311144,
-0.8304328918,
0.6309521198,
1.2858111858,
-0.1979101151,
-0.5956091881,
-0.2843536437,
0.1029702201,
-0.8621561527,
0.7014678717,
0.1920958459,
-0.1518681496,
-0.2587649822,
-0.7568153143,
-0.8381572366,
0.9822092652,
0.3936761022,
-0.6293969154,
0.4218544662,
0.2717831433,
0.6332922578,
-0.4237248302,
-0.0634928495,
0.5057429075,
0.4831335843,
-0.1251940429,
-0.9054752588,
-0.166867733,
-0.1902822256,
0.1507404,
0.1998935938,
-0.6890230775,
1.0976690054,
-0.2618252039,
-0.2458228767,
-0.0672163144,
0.8621669412,
0.3621296585,
0.1743294001,
0.7742038369,
0.5332794189,
0.4782288373,
-0.0048078191,
0.9406785369,
-0.1034057438,
0.4002972543,
1.0446059704,
-0.3669728637,
1.1333925724,
0.4741306305,
-0.1775010824,
0.4305067062,
0.2813084126,
-0.3631795049,
0.2899332643,
0.4195845425,
-0.0212373026,
-0.3406012058,
-0.1980423033,
-0.135773614,
0.7897515893,
0.1579551548,
-0.2524420619,
-0.1686351299,
0.4614267945,
0.0973795429,
-0.0383026525,
-0.5718404055,
0.5276186466,
-0.3231223822,
-0.684863627,
0.4030405581,
-0.1059679836,
0.4379246235,
-0.6042993665,
-0.5664479136,
-0.1228061542,
0.3084605038,
0.1047160476,
-0.8351253867,
-0.0000810124,
0.1119075492,
-0.0426085629,
-0.1567468345,
0.2817418575,
-0.4578870237,
-0.6962386966,
0.0563356392,
0.0933867916,
0.4568681717,
-0.1392586678,
-0.9708635807,
0.5735155344,
-0.1179341152,
-0.1148337945,
0.1685933173,
0.0542959124,
-0.337997824,
1.0169904232,
0.4774549007,
0.341556102,
0.0906706005,
-0.0168905053,
0.5832017064,
-0.4260205925,
-0.3621143103,
-0.498894304,
0.4348218739,
-0.0104249036,
-0.4082850218,
0.367839843,
0.468272388,
1.0783247948,
-0.5186715126,
0.4408797026,
-0.3413411379,
0.2159909606,
-0.696674943,
0.5849660039,
-0.83810848,
0.2169778496,
-0.2693414688,
-0.8120558858,
-0.2219832838,
0.5993628502,
-0.0115510998,
-0.2884269059,
0.459726274,
0.9069753289,
-0.0378806144,
-0.4023605883,
0.5064515471,
0.398170352,
0.5244216919,
0.2567835152,
0.8447218537,
-0.5065622926,
0.5189626217,
-0.1338487864,
0.058568731,
-0.2125139236,
-0.8900120258,
-0.4589329362,
-1.0619975328,
-0.54261446,
0.1465601623,
0.0837234929,
0.9735197425,
0.8923207521,
-0.983736515,
-0.3779048622,
0.2632256746,
-0.0929012448,
-0.7241152525,
-0.1983833164,
0.4803649783,
-0.0332799852,
-1.0667905807,
0.4242460132,
0.1362014711,
-0.1835058779,
-0.6766554713,
-0.1164365485,
-0.228296712,
0.0101351514,
0.6657338142,
0.4390485883,
-0.9022060037,
-0.5794844031,
-0.329999119,
0.2875702381,
0.1481504142,
0.8275312781,
-1.0137318373,
0.8670176864,
0.3215106428,
0.5310940742,
0.4552060962,
0.0625928566,
0.376123786,
-0.6107013822,
0.2977495193,
0.0045347027,
0.5130403638,
0.4708330631,
0.0294361468,
0.3492175341,
0.1120550111,
-0.2502275407,
-0.7876766324,
0.2664866149,
-0.9595797062,
-0.3487816155,
0.7650687099,
-0.2309709191,
-0.318270117,
0.0910193101,
-0.3442728519,
0.0846989602,
-0.668094039,
0.9742670655,
0.638530314,
-0.3301540315,
-0.6310997009,
-0.5260314941,
0.3697711825,
0.3014754057,
-0.955696106,
-0.0166286584,
0.599386096,
0.0644586235,
0.2474886626,
0.1633888334,
-0.149368003,
0.2810953856,
-0.0663548782,
0.1089565903,
-0.5220839381,
-0.5293551087,
-0.2818576694,
0.0017684005,
-0.0851081014,
-0.6132280827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17124v1
|
Fact-and-Reflection (FaR) Improves Confidence Calibration of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T01:37:23 | 2024-02-27T01:37:23 |
Xinran Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Wenlin Yao, Dong Yu, Tongshuang Wu, Jianshu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For a LLM to be trustworthy, its confidence level should be well-calibrated
with its actual performance. While it is now common sense that LLM performances
are greatly impacted by prompts, the confidence calibration in prompting LLMs
has yet to be thoroughly explored. In this paper, we explore how different
prompting strategies influence LLM confidence calibration and how it could be
improved. We conduct extensive experiments on six prompting methods in the
question-answering context and we observe that, while these methods help
improve the expected LLM calibration, they also trigger LLMs to be
over-confident when responding to some instances. Inspired by human cognition,
we propose Fact-and-Reflection (FaR) prompting, which improves the LLM
calibration in two steps. First, FaR elicits the known "facts" that are
relevant to the input prompt from the LLM. And then it asks the model to
"reflect" over them to generate the final answer. Experiments show that FaR
prompting achieves significantly better calibration; it lowers the Expected
Calibration Error by 23.5% on our multi-purpose QA tasks. Notably, FaR
prompting even elicits the capability of verbally expressing concerns in less
confident scenarios, which helps trigger retrieval augmentation for solving
these harder instances.
|
[
-0.359757334,
-0.7936736345,
1.1866527796,
0.2917751074,
-0.2246310711,
-0.0516744256,
-0.1930405945,
-0.1390504688,
-0.0330492556,
0.3513485193,
-0.4919484556,
-0.2981359363,
-0.3133459985,
0.2124761045,
-0.0670926943,
0.9171956182,
0.2288681716,
0.4853905737,
-0.4812193513,
0.1584388167,
-0.6287720799,
-0.3778682053,
-0.5247796774,
-0.4041796029,
0.8607962728,
0.5447660685,
0.5576220155,
0.0645147189,
-0.0121599454,
0.2109766006,
0.0726002678,
0.5786126256,
-0.6308262944,
0.1928224564,
-0.0129423188,
-0.8883814812,
-0.0982345194,
0.3712642491,
0.6019756198,
0.428984493,
-0.394323647,
0.2607018948,
0.3879876733,
0.7288323641,
-0.8085691929,
0.2597050071,
-0.3488069475,
-0.3841938078,
0.2348782718,
-0.6898005605,
-0.7177140117,
-0.7083486915,
0.1157900468,
-0.4842063487,
0.1267703772,
0.2288345993,
0.5317998528,
0.3547030985,
-0.4251381457,
-0.3397710323,
-0.6162725091,
0.8570872545,
-0.5374878049,
0.4758425057,
0.1906728595,
0.222338751,
-0.3241981268,
-0.1906913668,
-0.4643434584,
-0.2897230387,
-0.0073634232,
0.3361683488,
0.2329379618,
0.0488994867,
0.3891680837,
0.1137302667,
-0.1746576279,
-0.1832417399,
-0.2261219025,
-0.3444955051,
0.4535586238,
-0.008362541,
-0.0573576018,
0.023779273,
-0.3971135616,
-0.4134639502,
-1.2261440754,
0.3931233883,
0.2700732648,
0.5069553256,
0.1899553239,
0.2021709532,
-0.177488789,
0.8331061602,
0.2111584991,
-0.2912819386,
-0.0323964544,
-0.2148971558,
0.0711963326,
0.2121318132,
0.2918389142,
0.6834171414,
0.2199813426,
0.1259368807,
-0.1569737792,
-0.1716127694,
0.096088469,
-0.9324440956,
0.0015452806,
0.2441899031,
0.0127013708,
-0.1444535702,
0.3197627664,
-0.8362404704,
-0.7715262175,
-0.4771699905,
0.8897663355,
-0.1454467624,
0.0320432447,
0.3086402714,
0.0153294876,
0.6058164239,
0.8803119063,
-0.5062971115,
0.0651778877,
0.828199625,
0.6274267435,
0.0870976225,
-0.1324083805,
-1.0321948528,
-0.1565505266,
-0.5655103922,
0.7526428699,
-0.1918054968,
-0.3225161433,
0.1255795062,
-0.1677440107,
-0.0540462695,
-0.426310122,
0.543833673,
-0.6036164165,
0.5621153116,
-1.0645316839,
-0.3100865185,
-0.4094364345,
0.501983285,
-0.7206710577,
1.0063245296,
-0.2041762173,
-0.4192228317,
0.3514240682,
-0.3719453514,
-0.2298009545,
-0.1713632792,
-0.2955284119,
-0.0379685201,
0.143926695,
0.5577908754,
0.7238179445,
-0.4928068817,
0.2077987939,
-0.0073721493,
-0.7619105577,
0.3936609328,
-0.6678618789,
0.4766676128,
-0.0343317986,
-0.1729611456,
-0.3376704752,
-0.4930320084,
0.2061249167,
-0.2254912704,
-0.3983606696,
-0.2910303473,
0.0012372711,
-0.6266093254,
0.2692531347,
0.0531147458,
-0.8615136743,
-0.0821674988,
-0.5604801774,
0.1063892096,
0.8031817675,
0.2848672867,
0.1510389447,
-0.8290835023,
0.5579521656,
0.0010710909,
0.0306446925,
-0.2682388425,
-0.7617669106,
-0.6983010173,
-0.202315703,
0.1732758582,
0.6220956445,
-0.8262280226,
-0.0528411679,
-0.213245675,
-0.3724318445,
-0.7742126584,
0.1828747988,
0.6039102077,
0.8890589476,
0.3284264505,
-0.0672534332,
-0.309564501,
-0.4599216878,
-0.2803047895,
-0.3199518919,
0.0347815119,
0.4228175879,
0.1259921342,
0.6281937361,
1.052485466,
-0.6691554189,
-0.1332868934,
0.1168396696,
0.1576282084,
0.3120006025,
0.0471189134,
0.2917857766,
-0.8016396761,
-0.4783450663,
-0.592949748,
-0.3221105933,
-0.1196120754,
-0.0983700007,
0.0061559994,
0.1398234367,
0.4020323455,
-0.4109392464,
0.3095548451,
0.4893452227,
-0.043157991,
0.6863455176,
-0.0853233337,
0.6695992351,
-0.8788998127,
-0.1837958843,
-0.0338092558,
-0.3130793571,
-0.4918718934,
0.0490428433,
0.0835000202,
0.3562652767,
-0.7310823798,
0.5735747814,
-0.4801698625,
0.2116442472,
-0.0736832693,
0.2923116088,
0.6426351666,
0.2065131664,
0.0204144306,
1.2927709818,
0.4879543781,
-0.9383274913,
0.2817390263,
0.200530231,
-0.450440526,
0.6323517561,
-0.4655104578,
0.2299458086,
-0.2903233767,
0.4063071609,
-1.5240863562,
-0.003976413,
0.1178300455,
-0.3796822131,
0.3168133497,
-0.0088788904,
-0.4529298842,
-0.3816086054,
-0.8622005582,
0.2108918428,
0.6151127219,
-0.8674995303,
0.6871656775,
-0.4424580038,
-0.0214523207,
-0.7319170833,
-0.7339061499,
-0.0122561073,
-0.0210086163,
-0.5337054729,
0.0425249077,
-0.3949868381,
-0.2947429717,
-0.6683961153,
-0.1332615912,
0.2938936949,
-0.0037667186,
0.3970528245,
0.4791976511,
-0.2379455268,
0.1936019212,
-0.1020096466,
0.0534914024,
0.4057235122,
0.0501461402,
0.3970417976,
-0.2259325534,
-0.5684780478,
-0.4749598503,
0.0138729941,
0.2002205849,
-0.0708232,
0.7709553242,
0.293364346,
0.2154831886,
-0.1758985668,
-1.1781257391,
-0.8819618225,
-0.536170423,
-0.0031421948,
-0.292109549,
-0.9041973352,
0.3487232625,
-0.1681722254,
0.1685096025,
-0.0396447107,
0.5012177229,
-0.2278466821,
1.1632726192,
0.3446736634,
0.0565239377,
0.2333513647,
0.0620647594,
0.2743852735,
-0.8708709478,
-0.2388000786,
-0.5981969237,
-0.0111539885,
-0.2880323529,
-0.698533237,
0.407941699,
-0.2343258262,
0.1937445998,
-0.2457563281,
-0.5212954283,
0.5966678858,
0.4224182963,
0.4968491793,
0.4110097885,
-0.0420049466,
-0.1800676733,
-0.1462800354,
-0.5627586842,
-0.5652131438,
0.8696471453,
0.2140454054,
0.9352414608,
-0.0157901607,
0.8367714882,
-0.0668890029,
0.469084084,
-0.9420591593,
0.6846199632,
0.2986038029,
-0.8296871185,
-0.1646674275,
-0.3860223293,
-0.5204750299,
0.1215889528,
-0.0095517691,
-0.4374924898,
0.369451642,
0.2830344439,
-0.9593212605,
0.0145977763,
-0.7461532354,
0.0885489061,
-0.072996296,
-0.3988722861,
-0.0930009261,
-0.6662121415,
0.2838587463,
0.0423465408,
0.3363778889,
0.0221110247,
-0.1250858456,
0.5473867655,
-0.0437572151,
1.1554188728,
-0.40240255,
-0.5214380026,
0.5658846498,
0.2105576843,
0.680554986,
0.0716253966,
-0.3981908262,
-0.4115429223,
0.0400003158,
-0.1201403141,
-0.9690309167,
0.4612722397,
-0.2802528143,
-1.1228632927,
-0.3122221231,
-0.5068898201,
-0.5602763891,
-0.1815612316,
0.1942216754,
0.511808157,
-0.1200929731,
0.0743515715,
1.2447084188,
-0.110504441,
0.2117967308,
0.8823215365,
-0.3274018168,
-0.21284163,
0.9528082609,
0.1686317623,
0.5928399563,
0.3697039187,
0.4060918391,
-0.5568069816,
-0.1591983438,
-0.3146368563,
0.3323301077,
-0.8829616308,
-0.2883811295,
-0.2311704457,
-0.0035683119,
-0.347592622,
-0.0154081006,
-0.1148288995,
-0.4166897833,
-0.3422261178,
-0.321315825,
0.584627986,
0.6615760326,
0.0271830447,
0.0842897072,
-0.7149171233,
0.0547635034,
0.7301428318,
0.111028634,
0.0566200688,
-0.6316777468,
0.0582992621,
0.3772574365,
-0.1440503746,
-0.7995203733,
-0.1967292875,
0.2569595873,
0.2957381904,
0.4141703546,
0.3496692479,
0.7846212983,
-0.4291136265,
1.0306706429,
-0.0603355169,
-0.6116802096,
0.3201459348,
-0.0474126935,
0.1611160338,
0.850485146,
0.2431780398,
-0.476218611,
-0.4749414623,
-0.1680270135,
-0.3481878042,
0.6068664193,
-0.3466219008,
0.5015295744,
-0.0304014888,
0.5899728537,
0.1063060462,
0.3220861554,
-0.4889248908,
-0.2926667035,
-0.1665305644,
0.012462493,
-0.1436765045,
-0.5091775656,
-0.3979898691,
-0.1750648916,
0.8538854122,
-0.4173290431,
0.2390697151,
0.5972689986,
0.0763356537,
-0.2536950707,
0.5383300781,
0.7581633329,
0.5747987628,
-0.1962907165,
0.2306108624,
0.2844887376,
-0.4377066195,
0.2304808646,
-0.0987994745,
-0.4299769104,
-0.1023100838,
0.1200671867,
0.4422610104,
0.1086586714,
-0.4118191004,
0.7654246688,
-0.0787059143,
-0.3283486664,
0.223823607,
0.3974227607,
0.181049183,
0.1813505292,
0.6122788191,
-0.3002219498,
0.0895839259,
-0.5216670632,
0.0689390898,
0.5319117904,
-0.3384817243,
-0.1539772153,
0.3856503665,
0.1267617494,
-0.102151379,
0.4743828177,
-0.1074376479,
-0.8773939013,
0.3240864873,
0.5525978208,
0.331836462,
-0.434369117,
0.4941106439,
0.4081840515,
0.0898708776,
-0.421597302,
0.8630424142,
-0.0668280497,
-0.6788141727,
-0.861656487,
-0.4139621556,
-0.6808992624,
-0.1999305487,
-0.6372271776,
0.1089154929,
-0.5000885129,
-0.111100845,
-0.3349534273,
0.3323452473,
-0.4621117413,
0.4192872941,
0.0688049346,
1.0876113176,
-0.8663623929,
0.5138093829,
0.5585873127,
-0.3090237081,
-1.444205761,
-0.0234175082,
0.2437161654,
-1.0612728596,
0.4061164558,
0.4293606877,
-0.6880605817,
0.2479726076,
-0.9708121419,
-0.6453978419,
1.1033861637,
0.6235536337,
-0.5058143735,
0.0429451242,
0.1031929925,
0.4593279362,
-0.242359519,
0.3545027971,
0.3536171317,
0.7559380531,
0.4206992686,
-0.6668902636,
0.4781692028,
0.1445221901,
-0.2859557271,
-0.0190107804,
-0.8392688632,
0.6499804854,
-0.4539341927,
-0.1103918031,
0.2573481202,
0.556227386,
0.6199534535,
0.3724128902,
0.6334073544,
0.1657548398,
0.8309283853,
-0.2920255363,
0.8693872094,
-0.2052051127,
-0.0603072532,
1.1034749746,
-0.4936451018,
0.9220727682,
0.8464016318,
-0.1054140776,
0.8072844744,
0.403282851,
0.0474390909,
0.3184568882,
0.0063595367,
-0.3525997698,
-0.4400095046,
-0.3881618381,
-0.3027150333,
0.1569226831,
0.3153081536,
-0.1170776039,
-0.2970712781,
0.0310386606,
0.1459970176,
0.1560195982,
-0.2380708158,
0.5273609757,
0.3632267714,
-1.242936492,
0.5588274598,
-0.3731295764,
0.5748682618,
-0.4136499166,
-0.2810074687,
-0.0975172445,
-0.162755087,
-0.387131691,
-0.8582129478,
-0.2994430363,
-0.3928251565,
-0.159233585,
-0.4846121669,
0.5623617172,
-0.5599505901,
-0.0400169268,
0.0811375305,
0.621316433,
0.2067238837,
-0.4358836412,
-0.5774082541,
-0.2624432147,
-0.0156825669,
-0.4522777498,
0.1287966967,
0.3837463856,
0.0791781172,
0.625921607,
0.7759751081,
0.0219965242,
-0.0329387859,
0.3861655891,
0.852489531,
-0.3845157027,
-0.2609210908,
-0.8858671784,
0.4354058206,
0.1418768913,
0.2001683861,
1.0859290361,
0.4073314071,
0.293854326,
0.1060041413,
0.2322466671,
0.2462795079,
0.7613989115,
-0.6371043324,
0.5715559125,
-0.5392698646,
0.4286845624,
-0.1288493127,
-0.8269281387,
-0.1872501969,
0.4392845929,
-0.5106002092,
0.2075625658,
0.6346703172,
1.3188005686,
0.38847211,
0.2235785276,
0.4331611097,
0.1787225008,
0.2620668411,
0.418176502,
1.1211274862,
-0.2694113851,
0.4914822876,
-0.1952800453,
-0.221420154,
-0.2735175192,
-1.2097728252,
-0.8182103038,
-0.4301558733,
-0.2723876834,
-0.5589267612,
0.0886326954,
0.8905919194,
0.7373688817,
-0.8196451664,
0.0325386748,
0.1547019929,
0.1646326631,
-0.2212803811,
-0.2019565403,
0.1659454703,
-0.2002946287,
-0.4356604815,
0.4805210531,
0.0573946722,
0.0610421598,
-0.4285345972,
-0.2368191928,
-0.2664323747,
0.4224971831,
0.3723214865,
0.156261459,
-0.6713815928,
-0.5483756065,
0.2274621874,
-0.2342397422,
0.3658139408,
0.5750601292,
-1.1139442921,
0.4994182587,
0.4441313446,
0.3794582784,
0.170698747,
0.4734940529,
0.7168061137,
-0.9943398833,
-0.2332085222,
0.2585681081,
-0.0319743454,
0.4923643172,
-0.7434931993,
0.3801161051,
-0.1391215622,
-0.6228875518,
-0.8197273016,
0.11901398,
-0.5724214315,
-0.0683039129,
1.1067664623,
-0.1367053688,
-0.3456347883,
-0.1651552469,
-0.5551627874,
0.0267102644,
-0.6857740283,
0.8762816191,
1.1504541636,
-0.0850663856,
-0.1882020384,
-0.5485076308,
0.674929142,
0.8544436097,
-0.4520929754,
0.2964905798,
0.5067052841,
0.3585510254,
0.4132263064,
0.6177091599,
0.0237461608,
0.7343796492,
-0.4968575835,
-0.3108337224,
-0.138561666,
-0.5118265152,
-0.5098726153,
-0.0101440214,
0.433147043,
0.2430481017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17119v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17119v1
|
Creating Suspenseful Stories: Iterative Planning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T01:25:52 | 2024-02-27T01:25:52 |
Kaige Xie, Mark Riedl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated story generation has been one of the long-standing challenges in
NLP. Among all dimensions of stories, suspense is very common in human-written
stories but relatively under-explored in AI-generated stories. While recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) have greatly promoted language
generation in general, state-of-the-art LLMs are still unreliable when it comes
to suspenseful story generation. We propose a novel iterative-prompting-based
planning method that is grounded in two theoretical foundations of story
suspense from cognitive psychology and narratology. This theory-grounded method
works in a fully zero-shot manner and does not rely on any supervised story
corpora. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first attempt at
suspenseful story generation with LLMs. Extensive human evaluations of the
generated suspenseful stories demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.3175839782,
-0.8915201426,
0.8892580271,
0.6601048112,
-0.1643432826,
0.0998054519,
-0.4759299755,
-0.3068177998,
0.4432198703,
0.2501654923,
-0.8189923763,
-0.7366585135,
-0.134244591,
0.1339435577,
-0.5157914162,
0.7983899713,
-0.0838921964,
-0.3666985035,
-0.003644784,
0.3035476208,
-0.4273876846,
-0.6215655804,
-0.3932186365,
-0.1801328957,
0.5515418649,
0.3654138744,
0.7116920352,
0.7363886833,
-0.0484260842,
0.1324737221,
0.0650755465,
0.2816804647,
-0.2658745944,
0.5181174278,
0.1022960246,
-0.0731949359,
0.0409299061,
-0.3147512972,
0.4845119417,
0.6200195551,
-0.476378113,
-0.1485361308,
-0.3431268036,
0.6105270386,
-0.635227859,
-0.1910915524,
-0.5759313107,
0.374483943,
-0.0907531604,
-0.6575211883,
-0.5195995569,
-0.2730541825,
0.2213916183,
-0.4241471887,
0.2916838527,
0.1407281905,
0.498853296,
0.1445540786,
-0.16826047,
-0.6547963023,
-0.9763380885,
0.5965027213,
-0.5881122947,
-0.1006249487,
0.4930894673,
0.0633674562,
-0.2140141726,
-0.3883858025,
-0.572763443,
-0.7488585711,
0.3456492424,
-0.0423770398,
-0.0745227784,
-0.3758814037,
0.4024662971,
0.1311013103,
-0.7273455858,
0.3518974185,
-0.2840015888,
0.1219291389,
0.8555204868,
0.5469583869,
-0.0627440289,
-0.1714259833,
-0.2991007268,
-0.1082024798,
-0.6321944594,
0.0504768454,
0.4381344318,
0.2364808768,
-0.1012229323,
0.6284537315,
-0.3135613203,
0.5019849539,
0.0755431801,
-0.3701585531,
-0.0004403177,
-0.018253196,
0.1175900623,
0.4250845611,
0.8993012309,
0.6469426751,
0.4162485898,
-0.1318343282,
-0.1296252459,
0.4547545314,
0.5068429112,
-0.4776070118,
-0.006791376,
0.6177352071,
0.074197948,
-0.8777368665,
-0.4748182595,
-0.6411928535,
-0.3557821214,
0.191895932,
-0.0110041127,
-0.8367245197,
-0.2518334687,
0.3019458652,
0.0017025395,
0.3933061659,
0.0795702264,
-1.1081464291,
0.1972457021,
0.4587318897,
0.7334057689,
-0.3734588623,
-0.4661103785,
-0.3065744042,
0.333617717,
-0.9243499041,
0.7506228685,
-0.1318722963,
-0.4516744912,
0.435549289,
-0.6311604381,
0.3618595004,
-0.1695293188,
0.618643105,
-0.3966423869,
0.1665681899,
0.0880809799,
-0.4394234121,
0.2035372704,
0.6086515188,
-0.1973936558,
0.9479252696,
-0.1190351397,
-0.4975121021,
0.3787338138,
-0.5218054652,
-0.7360716462,
0.0546085089,
-0.2335182577,
-0.3354881704,
0.2234217972,
0.5277263522,
0.3102083802,
-0.2279478312,
0.9787481427,
0.2673324645,
-0.0744391084,
0.2819837928,
-0.3638173044,
0.5416261554,
0.2426812798,
-0.267847389,
0.1057784259,
-0.8189265728,
0.2657386065,
0.5925627947,
-0.1595213115,
0.1386087984,
0.0443553738,
-0.047394,
0.0752540082,
0.0338310711,
-0.3269400001,
0.4853241742,
-0.4745749533,
0.2071074694,
0.6101942658,
0.2742466629,
0.5367245078,
-0.5021042824,
0.8078938723,
-0.2108540982,
-0.0993534103,
-0.8904598951,
-0.3483509123,
-0.6132490635,
-0.0354630202,
0.0249974746,
0.4717144668,
-0.9407247305,
0.3198049366,
0.137876913,
-0.5339154005,
0.0756251663,
-0.1934886277,
0.2837866545,
0.4196831882,
0.2247807086,
-0.0606125966,
-0.601834178,
-0.4781723022,
-0.0445903242,
-0.2198230326,
-0.1216295063,
-0.1171392724,
0.1327251047,
0.1730040908,
0.9236111045,
-0.6010054946,
-0.2032078207,
-0.4410222173,
0.4136908948,
0.1937472671,
0.4859288931,
0.5557239056,
-0.4342980683,
-0.3831894696,
-0.5495206714,
-0.9065058827,
-0.105391331,
-0.4894128144,
0.1478019506,
0.5343003869,
0.3915422857,
-0.865043819,
0.5990141034,
0.2619168758,
-0.1084142774,
0.8841309547,
-0.1166229919,
-0.2955772281,
-1.0509998798,
-0.1863553971,
-0.021945456,
-0.0121663231,
-0.7274367213,
0.2617013752,
-0.1816456616,
-0.3179880083,
-0.18626526,
0.5611662269,
-0.6590240598,
0.0665924177,
-0.1710435003,
0.1024402454,
-0.2522120774,
0.6365730762,
0.4530125558,
0.2660444081,
0.7248925567,
-0.8690831065,
0.0869514793,
0.421905905,
-0.3942805231,
0.3102178574,
-0.3561730087,
0.2172715366,
-0.0115686031,
0.1908807606,
-0.5951208472,
-0.5612872243,
0.0505300015,
-0.5050219297,
0.3539298475,
0.0222879965,
-0.652387619,
-0.5664458275,
-0.3143202662,
0.0403423868,
0.6626273394,
-0.3324922919,
0.4667410553,
-0.0839293748,
-0.5163490772,
-0.3282822967,
-0.3932646215,
0.59684515,
-0.252147764,
-0.619263947,
0.2353493571,
-0.2844748199,
-0.4453077316,
-0.2883813977,
-0.007710767,
-0.0540402867,
-0.0052798926,
0.2381039411,
0.1684433818,
-0.2329177856,
-0.0746387169,
0.1383608729,
-0.3201280236,
0.1602005213,
-0.3991294801,
0.7515130043,
0.1314443648,
-0.2740307748,
-0.2939259112,
0.7655304074,
0.2016634494,
-0.0192144662,
0.4525955915,
0.3789680898,
-0.1994533092,
-0.3898735344,
-0.5440586209,
-0.2705836594,
-0.4318526089,
0.0276804268,
-0.2339031547,
-0.846508801,
0.16771999,
-0.1447548121,
0.2652225792,
0.1345955878,
0.7083793283,
-0.0118282642,
1.0243400335,
0.9356948137,
0.2106561959,
0.2434844226,
0.131891042,
0.2157525718,
-0.2023322731,
0.021654807,
-0.3103586137,
-0.0312055685,
-0.1277441829,
-0.1304406971,
0.467734009,
0.1655389816,
-0.0365783684,
0.0801099464,
-0.4405421317,
0.5286979079,
0.6337051988,
-0.417078644,
0.4423058033,
0.2521920502,
-0.3981342912,
-0.1487936974,
-0.8492174745,
-0.6402218342,
1.0129976273,
0.0994704515,
0.5535376072,
0.0711628124,
0.8211280704,
0.0698338449,
0.0234232936,
-0.7458745241,
0.5848730803,
0.3776071668,
-0.4726669192,
-0.4582998157,
-0.0235852599,
-0.8520310521,
-0.1223499179,
-0.3660440445,
-1.2710622549,
0.0638085231,
0.1064462662,
-0.7188544273,
0.0220491979,
-0.3623360991,
0.1742749661,
-0.5259173512,
-0.4371863008,
-0.0692345947,
-0.7270528674,
0.5135973692,
-0.1059673727,
-0.0671674907,
-0.0436752364,
0.2401795387,
0.376734972,
-0.5022703409,
0.6074912548,
-0.0618398227,
-0.3105958998,
0.5041331053,
0.721565783,
0.5423533916,
0.1777956933,
-0.2566528618,
-0.139979288,
-0.4843274653,
-0.3254731894,
-0.3596468568,
0.5364493728,
-0.2358505428,
-0.7794253826,
-0.543484211,
-1.0474052429,
-0.4528120756,
0.1669669449,
0.5197429657,
0.3333314657,
-0.4210788608,
-0.1886084676,
0.552190423,
-0.2745365202,
0.9842095375,
0.540088594,
-0.5367068648,
-0.251104027,
0.5259566903,
-0.019599339,
0.0901781619,
0.1681094468,
0.2892585397,
-0.0794100538,
-0.8728122711,
-0.4616871178,
-0.1468015015,
-0.2677627504,
-0.0763334259,
-1.0315675735,
-0.2839792669,
-0.2497438788,
-0.947060287,
-0.308073312,
-0.444655478,
0.0400111787,
-0.5206819177,
0.6055975556,
0.7554724216,
-0.3664236665,
0.3683907688,
-0.5526854396,
0.3866717815,
-0.0925445184,
-0.1652997732,
0.1031361595,
-0.2063290626,
-0.1185490787,
-0.3943484724,
-0.416896224,
-0.6566082835,
0.9968277812,
-0.2775629461,
0.232716009,
0.457003355,
0.5153369308,
0.4853267074,
-0.6268311143,
0.9769132733,
0.2917051017,
-0.562959075,
0.6641339064,
-0.7722207904,
0.4069814682,
0.3813407421,
0.4115501046,
-0.205578357,
-0.4358133674,
-0.7729986906,
-1.2830593586,
0.5462730527,
0.3411439657,
0.3388794363,
-0.2482848763,
0.2508017421,
0.2509662509,
0.4589359462,
-0.7444614768,
-0.1211127937,
-0.0546019487,
0.1865207106,
-0.1758013219,
-0.6016011238,
-0.4505658746,
0.0737560242,
0.5182832479,
-0.3099800348,
0.1796288341,
0.2617492974,
0.0235354323,
-0.3992798626,
0.3142909706,
0.9250795245,
0.7711258531,
-0.2907800376,
-0.1545323879,
0.0299341604,
-0.0732504874,
0.2134070098,
-0.0368721485,
-0.5523844957,
0.1192510128,
0.4092603922,
0.8339811563,
0.0850004479,
-0.7153917551,
0.3902179003,
-0.0629676357,
-0.5241365433,
-0.8754370213,
-0.0872752964,
0.1454123557,
0.2681784034,
0.6949902773,
-0.1543252021,
-0.2806657553,
-0.5431417823,
0.1093158424,
0.1692943573,
-0.0950089023,
-0.0691338107,
0.5245773196,
-0.0687421933,
-0.5993332863,
0.6190487146,
-0.4907681942,
-0.3307713568,
0.5547364354,
1.0047969818,
1.045805335,
-0.0409898013,
0.6052489877,
0.4637362957,
0.5229362249,
-0.1524235606,
0.393021673,
-0.0648643672,
-0.7487199306,
-0.4575920403,
-0.5505817533,
-0.5898345113,
0.1608574688,
-0.6378402114,
0.2058472931,
-0.6588578224,
0.0982444659,
-0.2800628543,
-0.134535566,
-0.1342215091,
-0.0274533927,
0.2812765241,
0.9934609532,
-0.4118138254,
0.3759360611,
0.3828004599,
-0.2137024254,
-0.9341549277,
0.458901763,
0.1358342022,
-0.6738324761,
0.1827686876,
0.1461026073,
0.0442093462,
0.0387505889,
-0.942137897,
-0.6634728909,
0.9675896764,
0.1407602429,
-0.5997498631,
-0.381965667,
-0.0645788312,
0.5732391477,
-0.6371769905,
-0.3365185261,
0.2502662539,
0.4594998956,
0.4789634347,
-0.5291568041,
0.0239620861,
-0.0970118493,
0.0060601528,
-0.0550081842,
-0.3539646864,
0.6659088135,
-0.8397869468,
-0.2122879773,
0.6086716652,
0.5483786464,
0.7006835938,
0.6058564186,
0.3197602928,
0.5204424262,
0.6880033612,
0.0929082185,
1.2859165668,
-0.2772010863,
-0.2142322809,
1.4047129154,
-0.8554061055,
0.6529322863,
0.3714499176,
0.2526036203,
0.5173280835,
0.5504034162,
0.1228431612,
0.4636962116,
0.3898500204,
-0.2084495127,
-0.2489452809,
-0.1649796069,
-0.1730010957,
0.4832773209,
0.3634256124,
-0.1726188511,
-0.348208189,
0.0508763604,
0.2313026041,
0.2984364629,
-0.2214650363,
0.8562729955,
0.2240682542,
-0.9308705926,
0.5672549009,
0.0387693271,
0.406899631,
-0.7337422967,
0.1864192784,
-0.1956399977,
-0.3017542362,
0.1461305469,
-0.6039889455,
0.1079009175,
0.4278549254,
-0.2399639487,
-0.4461136758,
0.5916290283,
-0.3578880429,
-0.3219838738,
0.0922016054,
0.6950574517,
-0.0510107949,
-0.1866588145,
-0.2594084144,
-0.038808465,
-0.0870615393,
-0.4036961496,
0.3011516333,
0.6247515678,
-0.4501320422,
0.7022987604,
0.9369500279,
-0.0889971256,
-0.1407013088,
0.0353844203,
0.8840113878,
-1.0444908142,
-0.9347789288,
-0.91600734,
0.6202300191,
0.0325282291,
-0.3767161369,
0.5225994587,
0.3544465601,
0.2376116663,
-0.062295869,
0.7293530703,
-0.0248997435,
0.2618849874,
-0.7841549516,
0.3765571117,
-0.0108891726,
0.2989623547,
-0.4305014312,
-0.9944806695,
-0.3805395961,
0.3995868862,
-0.0974259526,
-0.2970634401,
1.0040575266,
0.6857526898,
0.617344439,
-0.0577852204,
0.6606293321,
0.3250991404,
0.0315428674,
0.4718547165,
1.2110340595,
0.1243254617,
0.4038019776,
-0.2835418284,
-0.1318322271,
-0.1951769441,
-1.2968444824,
-0.9977641702,
-0.5387376547,
-0.150518164,
-0.3800329566,
0.0388379432,
0.8731172085,
0.4922718108,
-0.4189187288,
-0.2382106185,
-0.2976229489,
-0.093354404,
-0.2191385329,
-0.2476949245,
0.0182677638,
-0.233876124,
-0.3824700713,
0.9723478556,
0.4165104926,
0.1336745769,
-0.5390636921,
-0.0534121655,
-0.3349979818,
0.3518228233,
0.4900149703,
0.6078265309,
-0.5595101714,
0.0766892061,
-0.088128224,
-0.03552619,
0.0127870236,
1.0211795568,
-0.8819771409,
0.2434450686,
-0.1091313809,
0.3711307645,
0.7692454457,
-0.1328356713,
1.0522825718,
-1.1763159037,
0.3780290186,
0.5325680375,
0.1594310999,
0.2867226303,
-0.6267209649,
0.7731354833,
-0.212142542,
-0.3324009478,
-1.0137466192,
0.4531386495,
-1.0044955015,
-0.1343670338,
1.2278760672,
0.2345701754,
-0.0905460045,
0.0084070545,
-0.3528262377,
-0.1657392532,
-0.5941511989,
0.9302892685,
0.7287160754,
-0.1979634464,
-0.3304341435,
-0.408100903,
0.5560614467,
0.4508653283,
-0.5966687799,
0.1692572087,
0.4921373725,
-0.2450816929,
0.6804280877,
0.9846949577,
0.1083261818,
0.2896877229,
0.2551571429,
0.1932383478,
-0.3048619628,
-0.5688533187,
-0.2025119513,
0.4679558277,
0.0505683757,
0.4746247232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17110v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17110v1
|
Sinkhorn Distance Minimization for Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-02-27T01:13:58 | 2024-02-27T01:13:58 |
Xiao Cui, Yulei Qin, Yuting Gao, Enwei Zhang, Zihan Xu, Tong Wu, Ke Li, Xing Sun, Wengang Zhou, Houqiang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Knowledge distillation (KD) has been widely adopted to compress large
language models (LLMs). Existing KD methods investigate various divergence
measures including the Kullback-Leibler (KL), reverse Kullback-Leibler (RKL),
and Jensen-Shannon (JS) divergences. However, due to limitations inherent in
their assumptions and definitions, these measures fail to deliver effective
supervision when few distribution overlap exists between the teacher and the
student. In this paper, we show that the aforementioned KL, RKL, and JS
divergences respectively suffer from issues of mode-averaging, mode-collapsing,
and mode-underestimation, which deteriorates logits-based KD for diverse NLP
tasks. We propose the Sinkhorn Knowledge Distillation (SinKD) that exploits the
Sinkhorn distance to ensure a nuanced and precise assessment of the disparity
between teacher and student distributions. Besides, profit by properties of the
Sinkhorn metric, we can get rid of sample-wise KD that restricts the perception
of divergence in each teacher-student sample pair. Instead, we propose a
batch-wise reformulation to capture geometric intricacies of distributions
across samples in the high-dimensional space. Comprehensive evaluation on GLUE
and SuperGLUE, in terms of comparability, validity, and generalizability,
highlights our superiority over state-of-the-art methods on all kinds of LLMs
with encoder-only, encoder-decoder, and decoder-only architectures.
|
[
-0.4839301705,
-0.6895697117,
0.4524563849,
0.0839801207,
-0.3280416429,
0.322816968,
-0.5203956962,
-0.0881767645,
0.2780284286,
-0.0304708332,
-0.2242226601,
-0.6505451202,
-1.1169936657,
-0.0941714346,
-0.3536502123,
0.9709370136,
0.10437271,
-0.0857364833,
-0.4423770607,
-0.0856224149,
-0.3264344931,
-0.0899976864,
-0.4947527349,
-0.3499262631,
0.2523802221,
0.1280329227,
0.5397149324,
0.5080441833,
0.4611230195,
0.2708450854,
-0.6402009726,
0.2444194108,
-0.525695622,
0.2952462733,
-0.0453447327,
-0.5811679959,
-0.1123720855,
-0.0903189406,
0.2887211144,
1.0339386463,
-0.4693136811,
0.0632569343,
0.3069730103,
0.8242971897,
-0.8888287544,
0.2855041027,
-0.5093898177,
0.2029206157,
-0.1361774504,
0.2124687582,
-0.2648836374,
-0.6805457473,
0.4891503751,
-0.4681645036,
0.2913331389,
-0.3439313471,
0.5325490832,
0.54994452,
-0.3653775454,
-0.5879198313,
-0.7629969716,
1.0483145714,
-0.8416565061,
0.5970191956,
0.3631719649,
0.4334126115,
-0.1197563261,
-0.5308758616,
-0.266994983,
0.105319716,
-0.1157445535,
0.1768643558,
-0.0561369732,
-0.0537275709,
0.142915234,
0.3369261324,
-0.1930901408,
0.1009235978,
-0.5324974656,
-0.0891176388,
0.4069649279,
0.0115245068,
-0.0703999549,
0.0138634611,
-0.5476503968,
-0.3762588799,
-0.5067529082,
0.0943875611,
0.2534034848,
0.0539300181,
-0.0754984543,
0.2047543526,
-0.1737149656,
0.3516479433,
-0.126231268,
-0.62849015,
0.000455282,
0.0470710322,
-0.2492669076,
0.2557046413,
0.7256197929,
0.3767199218,
0.2643738389,
-0.0999143049,
-0.040847905,
0.0321074612,
-0.1925507933,
-0.843849659,
-0.5076642036,
0.1647044718,
-0.3366523087,
-0.3652262986,
-0.143435806,
-1.0269231796,
-0.5419303179,
-0.313016057,
0.2688319087,
-0.2951746583,
-0.5019605756,
0.2628924549,
-0.3210207224,
-0.1771181673,
0.1968781352,
-0.8900724649,
0.3946560025,
0.638768971,
0.8161914349,
-0.2953190506,
-0.2786098123,
-0.1289552748,
0.1392098367,
-0.3604232669,
0.4708018005,
-0.4016448855,
-0.4681859612,
-0.1630393118,
-0.4197024107,
0.0990828797,
-0.8929353356,
0.3752238154,
-0.6007738113,
0.0851373523,
-0.1592380255,
-0.9055461287,
-0.3235248923,
0.0864996836,
-0.5452894568,
0.8355848193,
0.1440815479,
-0.8626856208,
0.653090179,
-0.2272128165,
-0.3479093611,
-0.071157217,
-0.3234922886,
-0.4835078418,
0.2881980538,
0.444357574,
0.549541235,
-0.278055191,
0.4460099936,
-0.3772545755,
-0.2902547419,
-0.0119449869,
-0.6507348418,
0.9123356342,
0.0539962091,
-0.2761673331,
-0.3750263155,
-0.5090253949,
-0.1594481021,
-0.2074568123,
-0.6110144854,
-0.7983692884,
-0.0184146091,
-0.2896384597,
-0.3073054552,
0.0884409547,
-0.3193820417,
0.4023155272,
-0.3962309062,
0.2766769528,
0.7957706451,
-0.1068664119,
0.5027835369,
-0.0558357239,
0.4709776342,
0.433929354,
0.0833374783,
0.002468277,
-0.2617299557,
-0.5185425878,
-0.5540397167,
0.5096703768,
0.3951910436,
-0.7718265057,
0.2596800029,
-0.4489890635,
-0.6577281356,
-0.500331223,
0.3091513813,
0.2979336381,
0.5371417999,
0.5542456508,
-0.0172681902,
-0.2881501019,
-0.5704818964,
-0.2976120412,
0.0312049557,
-0.1863085479,
-0.0626162365,
0.2334887832,
-0.1699231714,
1.1935853958,
-1.0375571251,
-0.5582956672,
-0.0313710421,
-0.0909314975,
0.4374544919,
0.2473352253,
0.5411468744,
-0.5172595978,
-0.7489438653,
-0.0745636672,
-0.7798486948,
-0.0543991216,
0.182470724,
0.1954813302,
0.286893338,
0.6882958412,
-0.8945225477,
0.4418114722,
0.4489296377,
-0.1883050352,
0.6227023005,
-0.0972082615,
0.0014098259,
-1.0768996477,
-0.3917068541,
0.0083228191,
-0.2011842132,
-0.515122354,
-0.063615486,
-0.0720928237,
0.3778429031,
-0.3621685207,
0.3353176117,
-0.3801796436,
0.2105511427,
-0.0681365803,
0.3546988964,
-0.0379745066,
0.1489664167,
0.0326538347,
0.3856701255,
0.8066913486,
-0.5798020363,
0.5359648466,
0.1089697033,
-0.4453726411,
0.6255936027,
-0.6162225604,
-0.136142388,
-0.1821558774,
0.2235053182,
-0.9075837135,
0.1142257154,
-0.1035028249,
-0.2278608233,
0.5068398118,
-0.2819290161,
-0.1069040895,
-0.1520582736,
-0.6347789764,
0.4849381447,
0.9457650781,
-0.7948838472,
0.5011719465,
0.1016343981,
-0.1435346752,
-0.9121538997,
-0.7861885428,
-0.1335797012,
-0.6668689251,
-0.5180170536,
0.0657123327,
0.0329445377,
-0.4778643548,
0.0069012656,
-0.5246414542,
-0.1523606181,
-0.2422951907,
-0.0192303173,
0.1198024079,
-0.1877640188,
0.2270917594,
0.5876703262,
0.0637131408,
0.1052650884,
-0.3707326651,
0.3427039385,
0.1468327492,
-0.381429255,
-0.100238204,
0.0455922447,
0.5385326743,
0.2833512127,
0.7109007835,
0.6953603625,
-0.1075576022,
-0.7219184637,
-0.6565028429,
-0.4843403101,
-0.5204343796,
0.2465806007,
-0.2502357662,
-0.8149529099,
0.4189405441,
-0.3999881148,
-0.0111432262,
-0.0106027564,
0.3750054836,
-0.0945731252,
0.3336615562,
0.3821418285,
-0.2359978557,
-0.1175515577,
-0.4817944169,
0.353570044,
-0.6844664812,
-0.1524240375,
-0.2574915588,
-0.4436851144,
-0.3882039785,
-0.3793702126,
0.5006774664,
0.6168153882,
0.2499822229,
0.200397402,
-0.4515983462,
0.8036093116,
0.4842483401,
-0.1423442215,
0.4080145359,
0.1826977134,
-0.2902854383,
-0.3986231983,
-0.7473717928,
-0.2068842649,
1.0885740519,
0.3330461383,
1.2074315548,
0.1958839148,
1.1558153629,
0.2652673125,
-0.0535073467,
-0.8689700961,
0.4696150422,
-0.2524895966,
-0.1483215392,
-0.5646023154,
-0.5422311425,
-0.8737453818,
0.5097792149,
0.2826312184,
-0.5548773408,
0.1595250815,
-0.017366061,
-0.189620927,
0.4670414627,
-0.7724314928,
0.387863487,
0.3896766603,
0.0434099548,
0.0122832134,
-0.4706997275,
0.5232424736,
-0.2284420729,
0.4128661156,
-0.0636742786,
0.0298560429,
0.6099568009,
-0.5640363693,
0.7990658283,
-0.411760211,
-0.4873744249,
0.3518773317,
0.5002120137,
0.3146890402,
0.2868289649,
0.2897029221,
0.3487903774,
0.2740562558,
-0.1099402457,
-0.7204782963,
0.8325873017,
-0.6595982909,
-0.6391757131,
-0.0554124117,
-0.5809079409,
-0.113368161,
0.0440642647,
0.1890508831,
0.4606126547,
0.2905074954,
0.3111411333,
0.8639957309,
0.0482904315,
0.9037955999,
0.3211184442,
-0.256765306,
-0.3156552017,
0.9183180928,
0.2734018266,
0.3472547233,
0.1900210828,
0.5005403161,
-0.6199851632,
-0.4341900945,
-0.2672716379,
0.0259212218,
-0.9859697223,
-0.2926847637,
-0.3933926821,
-0.0165018812,
-0.6154414415,
-0.3008123636,
-0.6277090907,
-0.4659824967,
-0.3202534914,
0.0623139031,
0.3736823201,
0.6491767764,
-0.1491302103,
0.0435521789,
-0.6678509116,
0.1999689043,
0.5061596036,
0.3105097711,
0.225155592,
-0.5547591448,
-0.0188364051,
-0.0099529605,
-0.1576146781,
-0.6709033251,
0.2564960122,
0.3977227509,
0.3409437835,
0.6989645362,
0.4071609974,
0.6563029289,
-0.3729246557,
0.6886783242,
0.3082541525,
-0.8071079254,
0.437563628,
-0.0999248475,
0.3468742967,
0.4660684466,
0.6926062107,
-0.3656600118,
-0.668045342,
-0.228701517,
-0.9382326007,
0.3628477752,
0.0845317021,
0.0337999389,
0.0044820434,
0.1484737545,
0.2716575265,
0.1151502952,
-0.5752724409,
-0.3826570511,
0.1206789464,
-0.3481353223,
0.051830858,
-0.0894792452,
-0.2385437042,
-0.3263574839,
0.5419365168,
0.0003214784,
-0.4345887899,
0.177712813,
-0.1095897928,
0.3355052471,
0.3055335283,
0.4104038775,
0.6128903627,
-0.0614801012,
0.5681024194,
0.5334898233,
-0.9627583027,
0.3781835735,
-0.085618645,
-0.136113286,
0.2097744942,
0.5806713104,
0.3088842332,
-0.0169974007,
-0.3617516458,
0.5840051174,
-0.0451442339,
-0.3178060949,
-0.0964420438,
0.0462931544,
0.4841893911,
0.5008056164,
0.287466377,
0.0161726531,
0.1144891754,
0.0441468731,
0.0744888559,
0.2312957346,
-0.377315253,
-0.055887647,
0.4332738221,
0.0222050808,
-0.0457816198,
0.538870275,
-0.3608704507,
-0.2327207029,
0.4781538248,
0.340978682,
0.7947116494,
-0.3795492649,
0.1599283814,
0.2111872286,
0.2528971434,
-0.2226274759,
-0.0060083009,
-0.2242640555,
-0.5549800396,
-0.4203148484,
-0.8775437474,
-0.0046272334,
-0.0192640871,
-0.7086181641,
0.3927704394,
-0.309815675,
-0.0089564342,
-0.1006183773,
-0.2267570496,
-0.2528870404,
0.0025680247,
-0.1797988266,
0.7678749561,
-0.8499253988,
0.6677207351,
0.481546998,
-0.0162588619,
-0.8137434721,
0.0433765687,
0.0620470606,
-0.3409609497,
0.8437143564,
-0.0469415933,
-0.2258461416,
-0.0904315859,
-0.1535709351,
-0.6214795709,
1.341889143,
0.4202615321,
-0.8282875419,
0.0639935136,
0.369104147,
0.4491218925,
-0.0199492034,
0.1953394711,
0.8103847504,
0.1671998799,
0.1625282168,
-0.9223008752,
-0.0105020804,
0.3313517869,
0.1972344816,
0.3415437639,
-0.4441061616,
0.8003843427,
-0.1533860564,
-0.1974360049,
-0.5741829872,
0.3809432387,
0.2398581505,
0.1868574023,
0.6076735854,
1.0167902708,
0.558168292,
-0.2338100225,
0.4683949053,
-0.1058411002,
0.8554163575,
1.1266825199,
0.0523750708,
0.6434605122,
0.7666195035,
-0.7023703456,
0.2579112351,
0.2345621735,
0.0886801556,
0.6285659075,
0.3466461599,
-0.4632413089,
0.0319573022,
0.0477012917,
-0.5204575062,
0.4269197285,
0.2245304137,
-0.0127735753,
-0.5257619619,
0.0580262132,
0.2807483077,
0.1907830238,
-0.1478724033,
0.7881893516,
0.3194614947,
-0.3626848459,
0.8934120536,
-0.3419329822,
0.9724754691,
-0.3764009774,
0.1072301865,
-0.546874404,
0.3146807253,
-0.2802111804,
-0.7233626842,
0.401107192,
-0.3678855598,
-0.0500968657,
0.0500259846,
0.8428131938,
-0.7616195679,
-0.2986829877,
0.403062135,
0.4152437449,
0.1809205711,
0.1814683527,
-0.2957340777,
0.2180463076,
-0.1384734809,
-0.3740297556,
0.1687731892,
0.3962327838,
0.3082530797,
0.7355021238,
0.2795262635,
0.3077224791,
0.3096115887,
0.2769795954,
0.8552025557,
-0.2043221444,
-0.3347853124,
-1.3301018476,
0.2973435819,
-0.063173838,
-0.0937755927,
0.8562602401,
0.5181975365,
0.9451103806,
-0.3538911939,
0.6286473274,
0.0406607576,
0.495972842,
-0.526853025,
0.8770933151,
-0.447809726,
0.4259870052,
-0.4605492055,
-1.1761575937,
-0.1469254345,
0.4241196215,
-0.078562133,
-0.0092358598,
0.7394869328,
0.5923878551,
-0.3121729493,
-0.1476335973,
0.4087395072,
0.0782060698,
0.4262960851,
0.5940023661,
0.948212564,
-0.3429047763,
0.6820296049,
-0.3054094017,
-0.1846492141,
-0.0195918735,
-0.8890937567,
-1.1300028563,
-0.4535291791,
-0.6205605268,
-0.0343251601,
-0.2110005617,
0.5888438225,
0.8086308837,
-0.6305215359,
-0.2094194293,
-0.1910750866,
0.3311322033,
-0.1442142427,
-0.3032492995,
0.5191033483,
-0.5338150263,
-0.7985473871,
0.2089227736,
0.2547645569,
0.1490680873,
-0.6086666584,
0.0159070604,
0.1084772199,
-0.0214597136,
0.6673858762,
-0.2966777086,
-0.7648380995,
-0.1441568583,
-0.2401572913,
0.1071699485,
-0.2335627228,
0.3481452465,
-0.6351902485,
0.5153377056,
0.4991306961,
0.6611546278,
0.4410796165,
-0.2159900665,
0.1032452732,
-1.0436322689,
0.2122466564,
0.1169313565,
0.0143614421,
0.1579352766,
-0.2239282727,
0.5498280525,
0.2969367504,
-0.5878089666,
-0.8556293249,
0.2622922659,
-0.6045019031,
-0.4619752765,
1.1459188461,
-0.4642128944,
0.031712722,
-0.0629638582,
-0.1145662963,
0.0852349102,
-0.3019531071,
1.0849244595,
0.8332002759,
0.0249501672,
0.022377992,
-0.4805500805,
0.8594227433,
0.3425560594,
-0.63102144,
0.1296459585,
0.2568943202,
0.6006159782,
0.2540444136,
0.3123726547,
-0.0006217402,
-0.1541100889,
0.2484554052,
-0.1263975799,
0.0070435805,
-0.3526119292,
-0.3150303662,
0.2098112702,
-0.0790985301,
-0.1055718511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00824v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00824v2
|
Information Flow Routes: Automatically Interpreting Language Models at Scale
| 2024-02-27T00:24:42 | 2024-04-16T23:32:38 |
Javier Ferrando, Elena Voita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Information flows by routes inside the network via mechanisms implemented in
the model. These routes can be represented as graphs where nodes correspond to
token representations and edges to operations inside the network. We
automatically build these graphs in a top-down manner, for each prediction
leaving only the most important nodes and edges. In contrast to the existing
workflows relying on activation patching, we do this through attribution: this
allows us to efficiently uncover existing circuits with just a single forward
pass. Additionally, the applicability of our method is far beyond patching: we
do not need a human to carefully design prediction templates, and we can
extract information flow routes for any prediction (not just the ones among the
allowed templates). As a result, we can talk about model behavior in general,
for specific types of predictions, or different domains. We experiment with
Llama 2 and show that the role of some attention heads is overall important,
e.g. previous token heads and subword merging heads. Next, we find similarities
in Llama 2 behavior when handling tokens of the same part of speech. Finally,
we show that some model components can be specialized on domains such as coding
or multilingual texts.
|
[
-0.1594226956,
-0.6818093061,
0.4817856848,
0.2708640695,
-0.2128204405,
-0.0379379466,
-0.0049853683,
-0.5269823074,
0.3617418706,
0.7170782089,
-0.5701276064,
-0.2554710507,
-0.7014654279,
-0.159697175,
-0.7482796907,
0.8179302216,
-0.0669406503,
-0.0407653078,
-0.1028739512,
0.0016120734,
-0.1692149192,
-0.4831212461,
-1.1326519251,
-0.6369083524,
0.8527488112,
0.3347193301,
0.5853326917,
1.2065821886,
0.6394134164,
0.2945674062,
-0.203881532,
-0.1172809824,
-0.315636307,
0.0945850238,
-0.400223434,
-0.5853452086,
-0.4511297345,
-0.1797143072,
0.6913322806,
0.8351379633,
-0.2912453711,
0.1811513603,
-0.009716427,
0.7317700386,
-0.3054943979,
0.260886699,
-0.6237732172,
-0.1309698075,
-0.5059819221,
-0.2325494587,
-0.4408148527,
-0.2004535794,
-0.0997179225,
-0.4680274725,
-0.2339571118,
0.2364218086,
0.6497921944,
0.374232173,
-0.5801486969,
-0.5099653602,
-0.6012198329,
0.5958755612,
-0.6767846942,
0.2223106325,
0.3942221403,
0.446126014,
-0.2898658514,
-1.0618569851,
-0.4626046717,
0.178408578,
-0.1579730213,
-0.3303874135,
-0.6356490254,
0.1512996405,
0.2411153167,
0.2570492625,
-0.35022524,
0.2863533199,
-0.6264185905,
-0.165649116,
0.3967894018,
0.082017228,
0.3211106956,
-0.0035231574,
-0.1560833454,
0.0536129735,
-0.9064537883,
0.0714240372,
0.4728067517,
0.4290311337,
-0.129397288,
0.6149807572,
-0.2427516878,
1.045235157,
-0.0037041099,
-0.1359438598,
0.240303576,
-0.2246957868,
-0.2025535107,
-0.0687026829,
0.7387562394,
0.0105518019,
0.5261546373,
-0.269133985,
-0.051663734,
-0.400439918,
0.32197088,
-0.6227200627,
-0.2464570552,
0.1235308424,
-0.5756755471,
-0.472402066,
-0.2835826278,
-0.587379992,
-0.6368460655,
-0.4821221232,
0.1924676299,
-0.1560535431,
-0.672819376,
-0.1323010623,
-0.0391316302,
0.1715701222,
0.3281096816,
-0.9106448293,
0.4257355332,
0.7641399503,
1.0569102764,
-0.4066887498,
-0.342990905,
-0.5389607549,
0.1061325818,
-0.269303441,
1.0164196491,
-0.7160358429,
0.074517101,
-0.144400835,
-0.0475007892,
-0.1901774108,
-0.4826670587,
0.2091722041,
-0.693225503,
-0.2059900165,
-0.162485376,
-0.5309519172,
-0.2939539552,
0.0874475986,
-0.9145336151,
0.7539861798,
0.0925757214,
-0.9510230422,
-0.0226011202,
-1.0109574795,
-0.5624103546,
-0.2834835947,
0.0382802412,
0.1202643365,
0.0121656461,
-0.0417900719,
0.2471682727,
-0.4880889654,
0.1004781052,
-0.1721616834,
-0.0771765709,
0.105486773,
-0.3007413447,
1.0482634306,
0.2881183922,
-0.309455663,
0.1963666826,
-0.7870764136,
-0.0529330522,
0.0478229634,
-0.3365280926,
-0.249320358,
0.2841884792,
-0.0651505142,
0.2390679717,
0.0333400443,
-0.3500027359,
0.3583191633,
-0.414563477,
0.8170983195,
0.9116826057,
0.0570454709,
0.5716842413,
-0.0100233844,
0.6230877638,
0.265778482,
0.2316082567,
-0.306802392,
-0.8438815475,
-0.7689657211,
-0.0441255756,
0.3310649991,
0.5146303773,
-0.6032848954,
-0.0190683845,
-0.3352416456,
-0.6963614821,
-0.5105606914,
0.1897871047,
0.2405937612,
0.5099644065,
-0.0113966381,
-0.1972052604,
-0.5234549642,
-0.8711515665,
-0.3069104254,
-0.6109390855,
0.0963264778,
0.1429859847,
0.2035165727,
-0.1102034152,
0.8634633422,
-0.420905143,
0.0284020938,
-0.4729279876,
0.2692218721,
0.2795202136,
0.4418838024,
0.390455246,
-0.8756706715,
-0.3822751343,
0.0364562683,
-0.5455588102,
-0.2146932334,
0.1221807748,
-0.2242383659,
-0.2698121071,
0.7616354823,
-0.4301728308,
0.382692039,
0.6988406777,
-0.4760026336,
0.1421267837,
0.0100588249,
-0.1142981723,
-0.9575231671,
0.0019190209,
-0.0775673389,
-0.3340019286,
-0.9690847993,
0.0868684724,
-0.0871595964,
0.0115739359,
-0.4044612646,
0.8166728616,
-0.2870717049,
-0.3334651589,
-0.3642706275,
0.0269955192,
0.0564117804,
0.545219779,
-0.0379212573,
0.769443512,
0.7500113249,
-0.6135060787,
0.4656288922,
-0.2096114308,
-0.2844100595,
0.3630152643,
-0.6561761498,
0.2489079535,
-0.1982788295,
0.1970296204,
-1.1871327162,
-0.3199883401,
0.2446206957,
-0.4201191068,
0.2943390608,
-0.2726013064,
-0.8333474398,
-0.1688766778,
0.068529956,
0.502363801,
0.4233147204,
-0.4884258807,
0.6324601769,
0.8898750544,
-0.1719740331,
-0.334836185,
-0.8704839349,
0.1548297703,
-0.3325107396,
-0.6319425702,
0.0907093883,
-0.0241460353,
-0.4077231586,
-0.0618110187,
0.3289918303,
-0.579862833,
0.3087417185,
0.404648751,
-0.1400451213,
-0.3161663115,
0.2062668353,
0.0374975093,
-0.0356194004,
0.0795770511,
-0.5658434033,
0.5252097845,
-0.0812393352,
-0.4982406199,
-0.4983388186,
0.4362545311,
0.917121172,
-0.1581890136,
0.6886274815,
0.5042849183,
-0.5696572661,
0.1725251526,
-0.3802751005,
-0.1060845926,
-0.47196576,
0.1391143203,
-0.3159148693,
-0.6653114557,
0.6417809725,
-0.2915070951,
0.0931485966,
0.5057314038,
0.5985386968,
-0.010622574,
1.0154988766,
1.0514583588,
-0.219786346,
0.5308911204,
-0.097014904,
0.4456344843,
-0.9043563604,
-0.2056587189,
-0.4921475053,
-0.3328770399,
-0.5679647923,
-0.4805005789,
0.2387744188,
0.3310491741,
-0.109848693,
0.5164313316,
-0.2416550517,
0.4896517396,
0.6430489421,
-0.3103552759,
0.3717460334,
0.2290867865,
-0.1923776567,
0.1848758012,
-0.8765550852,
-0.5173213482,
1.0526130199,
0.5729088783,
0.7644424438,
0.0520314984,
0.3885101676,
0.3736773431,
0.5626739264,
-0.8349024653,
0.3489334285,
-0.0058541317,
-0.5896484852,
-0.4742010832,
-0.2839927673,
-0.8820345998,
0.023019569,
0.2595375478,
-1.1013321877,
0.1467810571,
0.3546414077,
-0.0758957863,
0.6294478774,
-0.707663238,
0.732765615,
0.1089918241,
-0.0633358359,
-0.2262855321,
-0.6110118032,
0.1681361943,
-0.1130275056,
0.4868195057,
0.0592946224,
-0.0350013562,
0.8858812451,
-0.2934684753,
0.9524739385,
0.0073674559,
-0.1438591182,
0.5252324343,
0.1475010067,
0.6440002322,
-0.4320490062,
-0.3932289779,
0.4083883464,
-0.3094541132,
-0.2023484409,
-0.5967992544,
0.5592246652,
-0.6370712519,
-0.3840400875,
-0.0230828803,
-0.4422443509,
-0.0498412475,
0.3247814178,
0.2731715739,
0.6433560252,
0.2575449944,
-0.0435479172,
0.4493216574,
0.118305251,
0.3811610639,
0.3020987213,
-0.2601288259,
-0.0915882513,
0.8396478295,
0.0647767782,
0.4473071992,
0.4390053451,
0.3140137196,
-0.3460333347,
-0.6077294946,
-0.6262277961,
0.3567516804,
-1.067412138,
-0.0955807939,
-0.6866357923,
-0.2884480059,
-0.3720020354,
0.1246208921,
-0.4466894865,
-0.7781201601,
-0.225873217,
-0.2290704101,
0.3823029399,
1.1544787884,
-0.2069396079,
0.5931448936,
-0.4690713882,
-0.0661819279,
0.1999478787,
0.3231021166,
0.2659968138,
-0.5898826718,
-0.3598639667,
-0.2448520362,
-0.2633687258,
-0.9754820466,
0.1362986267,
0.1604047269,
0.5167388916,
0.5012798309,
-0.2433661371,
0.6827589869,
-0.7627799511,
0.8553586006,
0.2422093451,
-0.9431079626,
0.6580553651,
-0.1609287262,
0.0951003134,
0.2134393603,
0.2752595544,
-0.6402568221,
-0.6048949361,
-0.5251286626,
-0.7922798991,
0.6393684149,
0.2377149761,
0.0128812203,
-0.0098973913,
0.4789599478,
-0.0693347529,
0.318194747,
-0.6813859344,
-0.3867849112,
-0.0980600268,
-0.2409915924,
0.2152040154,
-0.1572865397,
-0.0983252451,
-0.0743282065,
0.3109446764,
-0.1346276999,
0.503865242,
-0.1102335155,
0.0360471159,
-0.2679087222,
-0.0271793362,
0.6230839491,
1.0718513727,
0.2104719579,
0.3326161802,
-0.1739837676,
-0.3452467918,
0.0770213977,
-0.3611370921,
-0.0592410974,
0.0908518955,
0.7403293848,
1.0551114082,
-0.0059751868,
-0.5574059486,
0.4761970341,
0.0641119406,
0.1474679112,
-0.1553827375,
0.1365758926,
0.1956676394,
0.45693174,
0.1739214361,
0.0604740456,
0.4172989726,
-0.6480190754,
0.1356500387,
0.0680254996,
-0.6233842373,
-0.5331993699,
0.5879609585,
-0.0196669009,
-0.6056957841,
0.5276942849,
-0.0953604877,
-0.5272044539,
0.7187497616,
0.5562781096,
0.8775904775,
-0.2436996847,
0.1253936142,
0.4091612101,
0.403490603,
0.020059051,
0.0678437725,
-0.057330396,
-0.462410748,
-0.5063460469,
-0.5616297126,
-0.4001525044,
0.0548703745,
-0.6686164141,
0.1113667339,
-0.3840366602,
-0.2133322358,
0.1031049564,
-0.4898451865,
-0.7284215689,
0.1363127828,
0.2340055257,
1.3034861088,
-0.9454832673,
1.0220890045,
0.9550485611,
-0.2521092594,
-0.8524810672,
0.0266529452,
0.0794869587,
-0.9418643713,
1.0360506773,
-0.0138674295,
-0.2341638058,
0.1836924553,
-0.2875830233,
-1.3409928083,
1.0933866501,
0.3038654923,
-0.3223616183,
-0.3471352458,
0.0991517007,
0.3560201228,
-0.6177646518,
0.3808327019,
0.4224476814,
0.406838268,
0.3183261156,
-1.0959068537,
0.0526459664,
-0.2261519134,
-0.0505265556,
0.1049455404,
-0.4864057899,
1.1033760309,
-0.2005140185,
-0.1901947111,
-0.2145164907,
0.4879142046,
-0.0747637004,
0.0447041094,
0.7849184275,
0.3035192192,
0.9606878757,
0.089092806,
1.1623735428,
-0.3611697853,
0.10111963,
0.9947260618,
0.0983807445,
0.8677739501,
0.6766638756,
-0.1066933423,
0.7413039207,
0.7211837173,
0.6191270947,
0.819570303,
0.4335331619,
0.1651884466,
-0.0995650068,
-0.2089163363,
-0.0646196455,
0.4736806452,
0.4949780107,
-0.3061335683,
-0.3716529906,
0.0255922657,
0.1424693912,
-0.3624809682,
-0.5327188373,
0.7486800551,
0.1666156799,
-0.720207572,
0.3154594004,
0.2205844671,
0.1488038599,
-0.6149324775,
-0.1402158886,
-0.195670858,
-0.0207340885,
-0.14529109,
-0.8751219511,
0.5667984486,
0.1641225517,
-0.2155342847,
-0.2730179131,
0.7023336291,
-0.1935933679,
-0.3123003542,
0.4184036553,
0.2880159914,
0.4938868582,
-0.1105322763,
-0.7153853774,
0.2639003694,
0.0036585797,
-0.5223939419,
0.2443165779,
0.765596211,
-0.2007028759,
0.9797770381,
0.4948186576,
0.4564609528,
0.3456524909,
0.2227123827,
0.9846622348,
-0.5354323387,
-0.598461926,
-0.9170454741,
0.5596186519,
-0.2365515679,
-0.1628767252,
0.4073536694,
0.2527735233,
0.5401834249,
0.2959248722,
0.7481877804,
0.0958486348,
0.4981411695,
-0.6791092157,
0.447732836,
-0.6331907511,
0.364977628,
-0.0026690599,
-0.6675252914,
-0.1426013857,
0.5983043313,
-0.0847681835,
-0.2910858691,
0.6879405379,
0.6635057926,
-0.2492072582,
-0.1512729675,
0.0538002327,
0.1495898068,
0.4089927375,
0.4368106127,
0.5754469633,
-0.3131392598,
0.498496443,
-0.0955081955,
-0.4174945951,
-0.2648792863,
-1.128182292,
-0.8352185488,
-0.697486937,
-0.4140948355,
-0.2675115764,
-0.2092753053,
0.6400842071,
0.9319502711,
-0.6975356936,
-0.4756935835,
-0.3613175452,
0.4607656002,
-0.2029982507,
-0.1742773801,
0.3061176836,
-0.3785592616,
-0.4935173392,
0.2703569233,
0.5473099351,
-0.074270919,
-0.5721497536,
0.1129521728,
-0.017700579,
0.2722457051,
0.5245766044,
0.3217552006,
-0.6834654808,
-0.1598428786,
-0.0860590786,
-0.1018071547,
0.1033458114,
1.1207436323,
-0.5462658405,
0.4208495021,
0.5995610356,
0.667634964,
0.4034106731,
-0.0938127637,
0.7836574912,
-0.5324766636,
0.153901577,
0.0010351698,
0.3345463574,
0.4159066677,
-0.2947051525,
0.5692233443,
0.1553849429,
-0.3227115273,
-0.912093997,
0.5655851364,
-0.6964722872,
-0.1152221262,
1.3686772585,
-0.3972739279,
-0.4965091944,
-0.1416344196,
0.076516293,
0.1713181436,
-0.0439420305,
0.5066399574,
0.8243118525,
-0.2456918508,
-0.1977918893,
-0.8346635699,
0.5325784087,
-0.1535176933,
-0.7174962759,
0.1951286197,
0.0223006979,
0.3163334131,
0.3808011115,
1.000087142,
-0.0484747477,
-0.1595297158,
-0.0910800993,
-0.2271071225,
-0.0277214795,
-0.5811011195,
-0.1225571483,
-0.0227451809,
0.2354213446,
-0.1605294794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17097v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17097v2
|
Re-Ex: Revising after Explanation Reduces the Factual Errors in LLM Responses
| 2024-02-27T00:22:18 | 2024-04-12T11:37:44 |
Juyeon Kim, Jeongeun Lee, Yoonho Chang, Chanyeol Choi, Junseong Kim, Jy-yong Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mitigating hallucination issues is a key challenge that must be overcome to
reliably deploy large language models (LLMs) in real-world scenarios. Recently,
various methods have been proposed to detect and revise factual errors in
LLM-generated texts, in order to reduce hallucination. In this paper, we
propose Re-Ex, a method for post-editing LLM-generated responses. Re-Ex
introduces a novel reasoning step dubbed as the factual error explanation step.
Re-Ex revises the initial response of LLMs using 3-steps : first, external
tools are used to retrieve the evidences of the factual errors in the initial
LLM response; next, LLM is instructed to explain the problematic parts of the
response based on the gathered evidence; finally, LLM revises the initial
response using the explanations provided in the previous step. In addition to
the explanation step, Re-Ex also incorporates new prompting techniques to
reduce the token count and inference time required for the response revision
process. Compared with existing methods including FacTool, CoVE, and RARR,
Re-Ex provides better detection and revision performance with less inference
time and fewer tokens in multiple benchmarks.
|
[
-0.2789078951,
-1.0070669651,
0.700363338,
-0.0782270059,
-0.3973317444,
0.0339836515,
-0.1939544082,
-0.2933160663,
0.3096102774,
0.7212221622,
-0.9199961424,
-0.4019576013,
-0.3394298255,
0.4122794867,
-0.4184776545,
0.9876096249,
-0.3431030512,
-0.1934786439,
-0.2448600978,
0.0531914569,
-0.5626751781,
-0.3793827891,
-0.8884446621,
-0.1566326916,
0.6880948544,
0.5001704693,
0.5074759722,
0.4139228761,
0.3258970976,
0.3322323263,
-0.0780703202,
0.3421907425,
-0.5643142462,
0.2721025646,
-0.2512219846,
-0.6774153113,
-0.5935353041,
-0.1414655298,
0.6553695798,
0.6424703002,
-0.1010782272,
0.1157027632,
-0.1293991208,
0.6722477674,
-0.5180717707,
-0.1139272526,
-0.7096764445,
0.0683628172,
0.3594706655,
-0.6204820871,
-0.7993806005,
-0.5260029435,
-0.128944695,
-0.6431686282,
0.7223178148,
0.052434098,
0.6855942011,
0.4987668991,
-0.0777486339,
-0.1271737516,
-0.8657238483,
0.566285789,
-0.8728643656,
0.6014697552,
-0.0731841177,
0.122207813,
-0.4577538669,
-0.8674104214,
-0.9383750558,
-0.1087063998,
-0.2027718872,
-0.0602626577,
0.0512460396,
-0.161873132,
0.4031994045,
0.318184346,
-0.4823263586,
-0.1553468704,
-0.2369451374,
-0.4978962839,
0.519528687,
0.1810576916,
0.0773677453,
0.0434167571,
-0.2348755598,
-0.0961713493,
-0.9834520817,
-0.1426870525,
0.1145710275,
0.0923173428,
0.3514416516,
0.6206462383,
-0.1832409501,
0.3660499454,
0.1876284033,
-0.1416584402,
0.3398976326,
-0.5610894561,
-0.4774270356,
0.1727537811,
0.3064325452,
0.4084814787,
-0.0496113859,
-0.0319939628,
-0.4501480758,
0.0300511774,
0.3214705288,
-0.6665170193,
-0.0089149727,
0.4136221707,
-0.5330671072,
-0.2215805352,
-0.2717511952,
-0.8714600801,
-0.5104169846,
-0.5676687956,
0.3329470754,
-0.2758862674,
-0.2739860117,
0.4286525249,
0.088011086,
0.2179877311,
0.9620479345,
-0.5098768473,
0.1975201964,
0.8296285272,
0.5493537188,
0.1366979927,
-0.2947836816,
-0.7370031476,
0.0276461877,
-0.4257599711,
1.0966334343,
-0.3928104341,
-0.3845547736,
0.0372717269,
0.2249096036,
0.076764904,
-0.5087023377,
0.8404592276,
-0.6930194497,
0.4252871275,
-0.5005014539,
-0.4096325338,
-0.4695872664,
0.3956285417,
-0.5521386266,
0.9061955214,
-0.0838626549,
-0.8292541504,
0.5109531283,
-0.3398633301,
-0.4388154745,
-0.4218145907,
0.0596892983,
-0.4317997098,
0.4471828043,
0.4130877852,
0.1143131852,
-0.0836677998,
0.0890910774,
-0.004785398,
-0.6347696781,
0.2617340088,
-0.4145347178,
0.6175905466,
0.021382777,
-0.4090379179,
0.4306240082,
-0.7853094339,
-0.0977732018,
0.1065860167,
-0.4268527627,
-0.0110472385,
0.0731034875,
-0.4342291057,
0.1460770369,
0.183153674,
-0.6526366472,
0.1527813524,
-0.4801259637,
0.0357837304,
0.8361292481,
0.1431539357,
0.0634230971,
-0.3480699956,
0.4655866325,
-0.1176536307,
0.1307834089,
-0.4764505923,
-0.438221246,
-0.9247885346,
-0.044397451,
0.0422644131,
0.5665941238,
-0.8816817403,
0.2533768117,
-0.4280340672,
-0.2354407161,
-0.7226816416,
-0.0129263075,
0.4215609729,
0.6356790662,
0.5032669306,
0.1362743974,
-0.9204261899,
-0.6979518533,
-0.5346848965,
-0.5109390616,
0.0860092118,
0.0266419072,
0.5589244962,
-0.4215735197,
0.8371706605,
-0.4629304409,
0.1446640193,
-0.2789899111,
0.3804976642,
-0.0574887097,
0.2303695381,
0.0693276227,
-0.6344437003,
-0.1241150796,
-0.1068425402,
-0.6893146634,
-0.5010907054,
-0.6350448728,
0.0581832267,
0.6923466921,
0.7480081916,
-0.6780155897,
0.6712881327,
0.1200778559,
-0.2384005189,
0.9459841251,
-0.3257848322,
0.5475893021,
-0.7162371278,
-0.1284495592,
-0.4200218916,
-0.2510507405,
-0.4111477435,
0.1870691031,
-0.1599997133,
0.0505172834,
-0.2977074981,
0.2831785977,
-0.5461392999,
-0.0403812118,
-0.441878885,
0.4339337349,
0.1430018544,
0.4417451322,
0.0396279097,
0.5548660755,
0.1387680173,
-0.4432367682,
0.4520184696,
0.3402929902,
-0.0342533998,
0.3207069933,
-0.5818472505,
0.3213098347,
-0.46650213,
0.455291748,
-1.4956623316,
-0.0937808752,
0.611349225,
-0.6425780654,
0.2573164701,
-0.0413737334,
-0.4788822234,
-0.3012496233,
-0.5783886313,
0.2189366221,
0.2293911576,
-0.7438184619,
0.7957327366,
-0.2059100866,
-0.1747465432,
-0.5967450142,
-0.6120346785,
0.3478503525,
-0.077818118,
-0.7167628407,
0.3740053177,
-0.0961232111,
-0.3929907978,
0.0840228871,
-0.2680121064,
0.2556636631,
0.0528717414,
-0.0942073986,
0.2003841996,
-0.2841818035,
0.0283828788,
0.155441016,
-0.3461587727,
0.4650264382,
0.267437607,
0.4484689832,
0.2181625664,
-0.3891960382,
-0.7321190238,
0.3567384183,
0.7649371028,
-0.0449167006,
0.8186053634,
0.4395405948,
-0.4684349298,
-0.0642154813,
-0.8292723894,
-0.5226553082,
-0.4267224967,
0.3426337838,
-0.4755870402,
-0.5931553245,
0.3857314289,
-0.1109575406,
0.4586352706,
0.1678043008,
0.4884355068,
0.0560616255,
0.7821896076,
0.358215481,
0.3715784848,
0.2236838043,
0.2488472015,
0.7143345475,
-0.9010811448,
-0.3683697283,
-0.4122880399,
-0.1718078852,
-0.2788211703,
-0.5370280743,
-0.0396510288,
-0.1919693947,
0.1146671772,
0.1815683693,
-0.246858418,
0.2756964564,
0.1488885432,
0.1804399043,
0.4177187383,
0.1163352877,
0.2048666924,
-0.1539438963,
-0.3835020065,
-0.5717722178,
0.8335072994,
0.3165412545,
0.8361546993,
0.2550065219,
0.7992928028,
0.122123763,
0.6665079594,
-0.7604974508,
0.8429866433,
0.3624503911,
-0.3665289283,
-0.2821054757,
-0.4542124569,
-0.6458799839,
0.4982811809,
-0.4313704669,
-0.4985853136,
0.1035906449,
0.1918105185,
-0.5063793659,
0.4239071608,
-0.7394204736,
0.5425174236,
0.0241101813,
-0.4517590106,
-0.4159727693,
-0.4823978841,
0.5966348052,
-0.2701802552,
0.2875021994,
0.4103479087,
-0.1079371199,
0.7158035636,
-0.5348218083,
0.861926496,
-0.3247166276,
-0.3697341979,
0.3191719055,
0.4089394212,
0.897315681,
0.0821986571,
-0.0173240136,
-0.365180403,
-0.1702737361,
0.1243485808,
-1.0197435617,
0.6223265529,
-0.2611588836,
-1.1819435358,
-0.2378768623,
-0.3744490743,
0.0147979409,
-0.1299644113,
0.1708051115,
0.4228792787,
-0.0449011028,
0.176312238,
0.7835683823,
-0.6554880738,
0.1960120946,
0.6795759797,
-0.6219094396,
-0.3243207037,
0.4908762872,
0.0657918975,
0.1989916265,
0.3349423409,
0.0815842971,
-0.49237293,
-0.7380639911,
-0.1383753121,
0.4775031209,
-0.8613917828,
-0.0411549248,
-0.9406152368,
0.1243465617,
-0.7125916481,
-0.1945402622,
-0.2970274985,
-0.3502026498,
-0.1192182973,
-0.3612246215,
0.2896924615,
0.5493510365,
-0.3259816468,
0.2785653174,
-0.6683564186,
0.6482699513,
-0.0130696008,
0.1206612885,
0.1005921811,
-1.059863925,
-0.1324167699,
0.1717798561,
0.0521759093,
-0.9637538791,
0.3061361611,
-0.0792067945,
0.4710852802,
0.2387734503,
-0.0564450957,
0.905023396,
-0.6104804277,
0.7813652754,
-0.0760434642,
-0.955076158,
0.6162534952,
0.1197744533,
-0.1584961414,
0.332360208,
0.134900853,
-0.73514992,
-0.2682803273,
-0.5287014842,
-0.859634459,
0.4944681227,
0.0902265236,
0.0532661602,
-0.1375356764,
0.8010809422,
0.2456220686,
0.0858539119,
-0.6288282871,
-0.2315025181,
-0.0472922549,
0.256400317,
0.10227184,
-0.7767796516,
-0.1252469569,
-0.3395453095,
0.9726216793,
0.0626382679,
0.3560737669,
0.6799228787,
-0.3689135015,
-0.2324795723,
0.319562912,
0.9093607068,
0.6841161847,
-0.2665550709,
0.3442265689,
0.3478285968,
-0.3035895824,
0.1788526624,
-0.2764910758,
-0.0147420317,
0.293282181,
0.5809736848,
0.4786628485,
0.2362280786,
-0.6090342999,
0.2548546791,
-0.1711958051,
-0.084697403,
-0.2178256363,
-0.0999024436,
-0.015049289,
0.0551511012,
0.2282595038,
0.078227818,
0.0364962667,
-0.6657773256,
0.4638994038,
0.0594861545,
0.0343600661,
-0.4212072492,
0.6299383044,
0.0302553251,
-0.4219503999,
0.5547828674,
-0.2719584107,
-0.6085630655,
0.3822564483,
0.7511150241,
0.9467207193,
-0.4050734341,
0.3431164324,
0.5971556902,
0.5343614817,
0.0972719267,
0.3931684792,
0.2674650252,
-0.9472819567,
-0.8154969215,
-0.1032343581,
-0.3215487301,
0.1252435446,
-0.6190518737,
0.148124814,
-0.6964869499,
0.1324365586,
-0.2554856241,
-0.3297581077,
-0.2612923682,
0.3677439988,
0.0367181189,
0.9591645002,
-0.8017788529,
0.3707307279,
0.5072214007,
-0.3490093946,
-0.5282296538,
0.1789980829,
0.2759730816,
-0.7750038505,
0.6356102228,
0.1064602584,
-0.4492743015,
-0.2249674052,
-0.529581964,
-0.6385641098,
0.8093384504,
0.3098865151,
-0.5920801759,
0.3188169897,
-0.02527293,
0.6047176123,
-0.1392602473,
0.1889123619,
0.8077169061,
0.5408203006,
0.1954341829,
-0.4500636458,
0.5374627113,
-0.0704666004,
-0.2747998834,
0.025950361,
-0.1992268264,
0.7594072819,
-0.6211317778,
-0.3546289206,
0.1193705201,
0.9064106345,
0.3982255757,
0.2627026737,
0.7327471375,
0.6917160153,
1.0338908434,
-0.1161252186,
0.9498140216,
-0.0331664905,
0.24247545,
1.3784285784,
-0.5021988153,
0.7709416151,
0.7868909836,
-0.065741241,
0.7665989995,
0.7674423456,
0.2302150726,
0.3322336972,
0.2754810452,
-0.4778078794,
-0.2728255093,
-0.0057191001,
-0.4483415186,
0.139513582,
0.2681245804,
-0.1366314143,
-0.2784575224,
-0.0370016135,
0.354863584,
0.0319537893,
-0.222318545,
0.5205795765,
-0.2082229853,
-0.72500211,
0.6947711706,
-0.0124311475,
0.4065435529,
-0.1578337103,
-0.3145499527,
-0.6173691154,
0.205481723,
-0.4156634212,
-0.7762654424,
0.6723763943,
0.1539755613,
-0.2869088948,
-0.259019047,
0.5919566154,
-0.3475218713,
-0.3265963793,
0.2696047425,
0.3070359528,
0.3554420173,
-0.3181559741,
-0.6247033477,
0.3295238316,
0.390116781,
-0.4196098149,
-0.2595132291,
0.8361256123,
0.0315811336,
0.7755134106,
0.7857058644,
-0.1088630036,
0.0519069023,
0.1811437607,
0.90470016,
-0.7513067126,
-0.1671978384,
-0.8610196114,
0.6453501582,
-0.005697492,
0.0629713908,
0.5589334369,
0.4907926917,
0.6561540961,
-0.1836493164,
0.7217222452,
0.1322319508,
0.6596489549,
-0.7538523078,
0.3241878748,
-0.5904861093,
0.6317127347,
-0.2097356319,
-0.8541643023,
-0.4791330993,
0.5810995698,
-0.3295637071,
-0.0617985278,
1.1520110369,
1.2133989334,
0.321695745,
0.1177455634,
0.2357540578,
0.6694685817,
0.5065977573,
0.3063221872,
0.8840328455,
-0.6074228883,
0.5233071446,
-0.0390673913,
-0.1769048572,
-0.2532585263,
-0.8756354451,
-0.6768374443,
-0.2725169063,
-0.698703289,
-0.5867051482,
0.0007595771,
0.9159521461,
-0.0140203824,
-0.8058515787,
0.271812737,
-0.0082252966,
0.4353731275,
-0.2801717222,
-0.243492648,
0.390021354,
-0.3794961572,
-0.4974693656,
0.522729516,
0.2619248629,
-0.1415842026,
-0.1147645041,
0.0400691479,
-0.2389526665,
0.19898808,
0.7149301171,
0.1437619478,
-0.9396613836,
-0.8211067319,
0.0482981987,
0.2150308788,
0.178395927,
1.0074820518,
-0.9447470307,
0.4828420877,
0.6698810458,
0.6779463291,
0.1879715472,
-0.085758388,
0.5380747318,
-0.5132061243,
-0.0346550085,
-0.1037072912,
0.6337711811,
0.5054297447,
-0.5296164751,
0.5638265014,
0.6284814477,
-0.3404161334,
-1.0826092958,
0.1507873535,
-0.8404855728,
-0.3097224534,
1.0702323914,
-0.2163850963,
-0.313334316,
-0.2986371815,
-0.6926115155,
0.446749121,
-0.0454999506,
1.0504814386,
0.7033657432,
-0.0225072261,
-0.5399145484,
-0.2642787695,
0.3937926888,
0.5039454103,
-0.9276090264,
0.5785319805,
0.5489208698,
0.3134775162,
0.1001569852,
0.5207489133,
-0.2719530463,
0.3883020878,
0.1186906323,
0.1802461147,
-0.0404847153,
-0.4581368566,
-0.2387336493,
-0.2340428978,
-0.2016295195,
-0.2124495506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00823v1
|
Adapting to Teammates in a Cooperative Language Game
| 2024-02-26T23:15:07 | 2024-02-26T23:15:07 |
Christopher Archibald, Spencer Brosnahan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The game of Codenames has recently emerged as a domain of interest for
intelligent agent design. The game is unique due to the way that language and
coordination between teammates play important roles. Previous approaches to
designing agents for this game have utilized a single internal language model
to determine action choices. This often leads to good performance with some
teammates and inferior performance with other teammates, as the agent cannot
adapt to any specific teammate. In this paper we present the first adaptive
agent for playing Codenames. We adopt an ensemble approach with the goal of
determining, during the course of interacting with a specific teammate, which
of our internal expert agents, each potentially with its own language model, is
the best match. One difficulty faced in this approach is the lack of a single
numerical metric that accurately captures the performance of a Codenames team.
Prior Codenames research has utilized a handful of different metrics to
evaluate agent teams. We propose a novel single metric to evaluate the
performance of a Codenames team, whether playing a single team (solitaire)
game, or a competitive game against another team. We then present and analyze
an ensemble agent which selects an internal expert on each turn in order to
maximize this proposed metric. Experimental analysis shows that this ensemble
approach adapts to individual teammates and often performs nearly as well as
the best internal expert with a teammate. Crucially, this success does not
depend on any previous knowledge about the teammates, the ensemble agents, or
their compatibility. This research represents an important step to making
language-based agents for cooperative language settings like Codenames more
adaptable to individual teammates.
|
[
-0.3495410085,
-0.2316800803,
0.2316192538,
0.5723329186,
0.0333396383,
0.9318287969,
-0.4928097129,
-0.4871246517,
0.4509146214,
0.2714927495,
-0.2660712302,
-0.4062988162,
-0.4423578084,
0.2598000169,
0.0961805284,
1.1499613523,
-0.0349736512,
-0.1372389644,
-0.1645056307,
-0.6221725941,
-0.7531262636,
-0.2460837066,
-1.0152333975,
-0.2225654274,
0.2404815555,
0.6528692842,
0.7169357538,
0.3350236118,
0.5858213902,
0.5557181835,
0.3997278214,
0.05465018,
-0.5191652775,
0.3621726334,
-0.2908177078,
-0.6769762635,
-0.51962322,
-0.2762633562,
0.6732628345,
0.179503873,
0.0151133938,
0.230174005,
-0.072736226,
0.6645025015,
-0.314163655,
0.3775144815,
-0.7328166962,
0.1140933409,
0.0940184519,
-0.4198936522,
-0.3876286745,
-0.3681812584,
0.1166751012,
-0.9880384207,
0.0281446408,
-0.0395483524,
0.268527627,
0.3247919083,
0.1949504316,
-0.4225462079,
-0.5025222898,
0.5251792073,
-0.4906356633,
-0.1364896446,
0.0256808326,
0.6115390062,
-0.2135995626,
-0.2945167124,
-0.0750748143,
-0.1654705554,
0.0012328104,
0.3834022582,
-0.3557575643,
-0.0490351357,
-0.2101050615,
-0.0296301059,
-0.7018561959,
0.2071214169,
-0.2131706625,
-0.3431760371,
1.0770756006,
0.2852197587,
0.4571945369,
0.7047913074,
-0.7042964101,
0.0626940876,
0.2160640806,
0.3528275788,
0.3805186749,
0.403290242,
-0.2561641932,
-0.1928104311,
-0.0637394413,
0.4672425091,
0.3918959498,
-0.1697474718,
0.1373576522,
0.0153326467,
-0.0767769217,
0.480247587,
0.72978127,
0.3915263116,
0.4529232383,
-0.7943381667,
-0.2921983302,
0.3404556811,
0.2024015337,
-0.4900191426,
-0.6873564124,
0.1074435711,
-0.2826769352,
-0.5845696926,
-0.048645623,
-0.6996523142,
-0.3947033286,
0.1381117851,
0.6291594505,
-0.2993088961,
-0.3512589931,
-0.1146339849,
-0.4855892658,
0.1697991937,
0.2909710109,
-0.8184129596,
0.755505681,
0.4632396102,
0.703099072,
-0.4373998642,
-0.7414907217,
-0.5924440622,
-0.1084489599,
-0.6928687096,
1.1821615696,
-0.494515419,
-0.465495646,
-0.3560661376,
-0.1175473556,
-0.2475168407,
-0.4299945235,
-0.0038753767,
-0.5861173868,
-0.0802539885,
-0.0180888642,
-0.5754451752,
0.1102800965,
0.1265942901,
-0.4155937135,
0.5911322236,
0.2846647203,
-0.4774304926,
0.4034201503,
-0.8582497239,
-0.3203551471,
0.7034850717,
-0.1659093201,
-0.0654691309,
0.0384090617,
-0.0485766605,
0.0992968082,
-0.0218726546,
-0.2082880735,
-0.2633187175,
-0.5609291196,
0.4235051274,
0.1556399912,
0.5219402313,
0.10812556,
0.0228073504,
0.3711266518,
-0.4158298671,
0.5964308977,
-0.0409189723,
-0.1937679201,
-0.3573835492,
0.2682273686,
-0.1655922681,
-0.047279615,
0.016924873,
-0.1540036947,
0.2959950864,
-0.2180756778,
0.1365618557,
1.1268155575,
-0.0637417659,
0.9974127412,
-0.7983731031,
0.8615685701,
-0.3450549543,
0.0775669739,
0.0243579969,
-0.4086067379,
-0.3583922982,
-0.514442265,
0.3955467045,
0.5179954171,
-1.0516574383,
0.3568201959,
-0.276501298,
-0.8217397332,
-0.4226104021,
0.0093393968,
0.4668812454,
-0.1527082622,
0.0250800997,
-0.8089612722,
-0.455337882,
-0.6288858056,
-0.6425509453,
-0.6502718925,
0.1380383521,
0.4044442177,
0.2841691673,
0.0645112321,
0.9121766686,
-0.2928619981,
-0.3444425762,
-0.1772653759,
-0.0762243271,
0.0467592739,
0.4120663106,
1.0276222229,
-0.5338645577,
-0.9600653648,
0.1896620393,
-0.6495000124,
-0.142428413,
-0.1629098505,
-0.3254125714,
0.145831123,
0.0784442648,
-0.006733086,
0.1113817021,
1.0530949831,
-0.801361084,
0.5500594974,
-0.3466002345,
0.2526853979,
-0.9836910963,
-0.0323282704,
-0.1408485025,
-0.2562022209,
-0.6222597361,
0.4569985271,
-0.3411384821,
0.3304760158,
-0.0417253412,
0.7299196124,
-0.5818155408,
-0.2613115311,
-0.3093509674,
0.3629272282,
-0.4020730853,
0.4782774448,
0.0003575575,
0.8675664067,
0.9451107383,
-0.7223435044,
0.5354501605,
0.1761704236,
-0.3767978847,
0.8440417647,
-0.5476682782,
0.4650612473,
0.1222047955,
0.2400063276,
-0.952206552,
-0.0802168325,
0.1647467315,
-0.8752769828,
0.0006012873,
-0.121599175,
-0.2571095824,
-0.1262623817,
-0.0482076854,
0.7133798003,
0.47431463,
-0.4490478337,
0.5984352231,
0.5969116688,
-0.0852840394,
-0.1690719277,
-0.402661413,
0.3654641211,
-0.3377026916,
-0.6695668101,
0.494923979,
-0.7698656321,
-0.5946973562,
-0.0757902041,
-0.1433643997,
-0.6331755519,
0.3569990695,
0.0777984858,
0.0377512798,
-0.4735918045,
0.4132215977,
-0.3587458432,
-0.3181473017,
-0.1344662905,
-0.1572850496,
0.2713267803,
-0.3643059433,
0.5175833702,
-0.1698432267,
0.3315776885,
0.6120066643,
-0.3767445087,
0.702249527,
0.2671615779,
-0.0725733414,
-0.709202528,
-0.2599321306,
0.0601226836,
-0.4701350927,
0.4794546962,
-0.534275949,
-0.5698449016,
0.9430893064,
0.0526621938,
-0.0997076035,
0.1442977488,
0.497274369,
0.1218245625,
0.7592073083,
0.7758864164,
-0.4334875047,
0.2593631446,
0.2463024259,
-0.1036231294,
-0.5026909709,
0.0359335169,
-0.676579535,
-0.5252128243,
-0.6993306279,
-0.4186766148,
0.344045192,
-0.1760647297,
-0.2411393821,
0.6080690026,
-0.680393815,
0.7845464349,
0.1262800097,
0.2212170511,
0.230001837,
-0.306930095,
0.2294544578,
0.2040892392,
-0.7185348868,
-0.2891276181,
0.5877990723,
0.1331175715,
0.7061833739,
0.5697074533,
0.8836390376,
0.6072519422,
0.2580796778,
-0.619423449,
0.4313648641,
0.0367545374,
-0.4240060747,
-0.4218541384,
-0.4511632323,
-0.8177812099,
0.1580726504,
-0.239154309,
-0.7726604939,
-0.0942364186,
-0.1102180034,
-0.6650716662,
0.1231363565,
-0.7295250297,
0.7446824908,
-0.2874902785,
-0.3422335386,
-0.0982250869,
-0.4705347121,
0.1183155477,
-0.2092857063,
0.4492414594,
-0.0507660955,
-0.3083010614,
0.5820330977,
-0.0053145317,
0.4692098796,
-0.1286267638,
0.098443456,
0.3638063967,
0.6182495356,
0.4105740786,
0.0915110037,
-0.3462349176,
-0.0062391199,
0.1896110624,
-0.6865695715,
-0.6144516468,
0.7663840652,
-0.7958256602,
-0.2828785479,
-0.308681488,
-0.6886745691,
-0.1724347472,
0.1419305205,
0.0833788887,
0.2364736348,
-0.5418990254,
-0.0512190796,
0.2534185648,
-0.2616039515,
0.7082649469,
0.9388915896,
-0.1710395068,
-0.2558979392,
0.8687122464,
-0.1311980039,
0.3721600175,
0.2667376697,
0.3158079982,
0.1989405602,
-0.4562205076,
-0.4884985387,
-0.3971950114,
-0.4675557613,
-0.3596718907,
-0.1852169782,
0.062428318,
-0.2175437212,
-0.4376737177,
-0.2328072488,
-0.0262987185,
-0.025346173,
0.2816399634,
0.3590551615,
0.7355733514,
-0.0453625955,
0.2090458274,
-0.8080016971,
-0.0079267472,
0.3018904626,
0.7396464944,
-0.3136797547,
-0.4997757673,
-0.1542425454,
-0.2121915072,
0.2616482377,
-1.0219961405,
0.1530698985,
0.3489375412,
0.9182854891,
-0.0352187864,
0.3177925944,
0.5426415801,
-0.2824698687,
0.6571070552,
0.0764975697,
-0.918454349,
0.1161217839,
-0.4491858482,
0.3825396895,
0.732339263,
-0.1897223443,
-0.492982626,
-0.4851611555,
-0.5104976296,
-0.2703612149,
0.8960112333,
0.3740385473,
0.1603399813,
0.0569226705,
0.2012087107,
0.1686239541,
-0.1001769006,
-0.4440068305,
-0.1416612715,
0.3214816749,
-0.2940895855,
-0.3139870763,
0.4794139564,
-0.0438920967,
-0.077986218,
0.5661556125,
-0.5436350703,
0.5769748092,
0.1798298806,
-0.1197770014,
-0.485435307,
-0.0778502598,
0.569175601,
0.5456334949,
0.2192035317,
-0.1888223737,
0.5444642305,
-0.0973361582,
0.0405344516,
-0.1518827528,
0.350820899,
0.0299030393,
0.5937886834,
0.4228459597,
0.4616421759,
-0.564183414,
0.5694183707,
-0.3253958225,
-0.286577791,
-0.2568742633,
0.3353536129,
-0.1132956147,
0.6387076974,
0.269757688,
0.8071084023,
-0.1721715331,
-0.8378831148,
0.4282157719,
0.2935563624,
-0.6488369107,
-0.3453814387,
0.2492273152,
0.4237134159,
-1.0907635689,
-0.0396233052,
-0.4466455281,
-0.8266510367,
1.2735351324,
0.4897907674,
1.0593901873,
-0.6329478621,
0.4386030436,
0.3019910455,
0.2465243787,
-0.0175871197,
-0.1373880506,
-0.0321957245,
-0.8340979815,
0.0324238054,
-0.3362952471,
-0.110491991,
-0.8431703448,
-0.3938222826,
0.106912151,
-0.4694676101,
-0.0228590574,
-0.0355150849,
0.0078890212,
-0.8058912158,
-0.0420661606,
0.0671882853,
0.9683469534,
-0.7357464433,
0.7851376534,
0.7742028236,
-0.2799827754,
-0.7860632539,
0.0657526478,
-0.1514753997,
-0.9776852131,
0.1738761067,
-0.2698944509,
-0.0882811174,
0.2586386204,
-0.5441234708,
-0.6844341159,
1.1167423725,
0.0382849611,
-0.4601282179,
-0.0151857557,
-0.3722766638,
0.9320660233,
-0.6564881802,
0.5576450825,
0.4031295776,
0.5317668915,
-0.1190514639,
-1.0369653702,
0.0143789267,
-0.2957407832,
-0.2500264347,
0.2432238758,
-1.2251154184,
0.6651628613,
-0.3803831935,
-0.20420672,
0.6295422316,
0.4214252234,
-0.0585943349,
0.4166103601,
0.7251672149,
0.0946387574,
0.7115918994,
0.1007086262,
0.7632974982,
-0.4585371017,
0.4602099955,
1.1020965576,
-0.2679660618,
0.5340955853,
0.1084415019,
-0.2697592676,
0.6105676293,
0.1861112267,
-0.0262135733,
0.6202489734,
0.4971341491,
-0.2930924892,
-0.4412238896,
0.2380423993,
-0.2009654939,
0.8400229812,
0.119753778,
-0.2820109427,
-0.1187023371,
-0.290083468,
-0.2572188377,
0.5421252847,
-0.3598328233,
1.1803818941,
-0.3570322096,
-1.00202775,
0.0011708988,
-0.2073868215,
0.5859835744,
-0.5779291987,
-0.1010335013,
-0.3302248418,
0.3904523849,
-0.3082337976,
-0.6367016435,
-0.0436553806,
-0.1781421304,
-0.0720424801,
0.1565466076,
0.5920944214,
-0.4382510483,
-0.4769192338,
0.5816073418,
0.3786379397,
0.2121357769,
0.0266470741,
-0.6429133415,
0.1259533316,
-0.1247914061,
0.4118191302,
0.4384339154,
0.3307895362,
0.1963299215,
0.5105873942,
0.1912548989,
-0.1114826873,
-0.0404181033,
-0.3874767721,
0.6588169932,
-0.3081148565,
-0.5737743378,
-0.5980923772,
0.4549621344,
0.0120532224,
-0.4416714013,
0.6893453002,
0.4097581506,
0.5813384652,
0.011278471,
0.8623429537,
-0.0556185842,
0.0675948709,
-0.107465975,
0.8533659577,
-0.2809777856,
0.112591356,
-0.6910662651,
-0.9050689936,
-0.2556499243,
0.5618089437,
0.2687659562,
0.0596383549,
0.5878309011,
0.7387068868,
0.3530601561,
0.1550143659,
0.5468886495,
0.248452723,
0.2390180826,
1.032089591,
0.6979217529,
-0.5143068433,
0.5372055769,
0.0466509014,
-0.6762088537,
-0.0533354543,
-0.7116142511,
-0.9750295281,
-0.3576696515,
-0.4198615253,
-0.0866208971,
0.5781885386,
1.0202867985,
0.6061863899,
-0.6531735063,
-0.3411017358,
0.0417146944,
0.1311312467,
-0.70251894,
-0.2449930012,
-0.0062256306,
-0.4374450445,
-0.4962173402,
0.6323418617,
0.0781433061,
-0.4583880305,
0.0249054655,
-0.691334486,
0.1696393639,
0.231249541,
0.296081543,
0.4101401567,
-0.3867475986,
-0.6665561199,
0.0681674778,
-0.1531244367,
0.0140036959,
0.7294567823,
-0.8315781951,
0.8855212331,
0.2460169494,
0.5509966612,
-0.1817314923,
-0.001845739,
0.7200037837,
-0.5326616168,
-0.0296947174,
0.3649953008,
-0.0320334621,
-0.1386136711,
-0.3323515356,
0.4856846929,
0.1134678721,
-0.9287518263,
-0.4911086261,
-0.0494845733,
-0.9430009723,
-0.2433060855,
0.9803766608,
-0.2287698239,
0.0300028287,
-0.1388187706,
-0.3738143742,
0.063740775,
-0.6481394768,
0.8833402991,
0.6890205741,
-0.0229530688,
0.1519040465,
-0.1170444041,
0.3971685767,
0.1554893702,
-0.6641923189,
-0.1583743542,
0.1181797609,
0.3031045794,
0.0723458454,
0.8719792962,
0.2312160134,
0.6760600209,
0.4127664268,
0.0754861012,
0.2491491884,
-0.2859678566,
-0.312410295,
-0.0193813555,
0.281738162,
-0.336933583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17019v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17019v4
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Learning Complex Legal Concepts through Storytelling
| 2024-02-26T20:56:06 | 2024-07-02T17:50:42 |
Hang Jiang, Xiajie Zhang, Robert Mahari, Daniel Kessler, Eric Ma, Tal August, Irene Li, Alex 'Sandy' Pentland, Yoon Kim, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Making legal knowledge accessible to non-experts is crucial for enhancing
general legal literacy and encouraging civic participation in democracy.
However, legal documents are often challenging to understand for people without
legal backgrounds. In this paper, we present a novel application of large
language models (LLMs) in legal education to help non-experts learn intricate
legal concepts through storytelling, an effective pedagogical tool in conveying
complex and abstract concepts. We also introduce a new dataset LegalStories,
which consists of 294 complex legal doctrines, each accompanied by a story and
a set of multiple-choice questions generated by LLMs. To construct the dataset,
we experiment with various LLMs to generate legal stories explaining these
concepts. Furthermore, we use an expert-in-the-loop approach to iteratively
design multiple-choice questions. Then, we evaluate the effectiveness of
storytelling with LLMs through randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with legal
novices on 10 samples from the dataset. We find that LLM-generated stories
enhance comprehension of legal concepts and interest in law among non-native
speakers compared to only definitions. Moreover, stories consistently help
participants relate legal concepts to their lives. Finally, we find that
learning with stories shows a higher retention rate for non-native speakers in
the follow-up assessment. Our work has strong implications for using LLMs in
promoting teaching and learning in the legal field and beyond.
|
[
-0.0446242951,
-0.6993175745,
0.8077763915,
-0.2237499952,
-0.6285470128,
0.2720486522,
-0.4562221766,
-0.3075638711,
0.300745815,
0.6734824181,
0.0166231468,
-0.627697289,
-0.4153849185,
-0.283964932,
-0.3389346004,
0.9273333549,
-0.110537596,
0.1868453324,
0.0019274304,
-0.1683228612,
-0.627918601,
-0.2560872436,
-0.3631028235,
-0.2545115054,
0.4780305922,
0.4449422359,
0.5659214854,
0.6267552972,
-0.0397273153,
0.1755160391,
-0.0405104086,
0.0679164231,
-0.660000205,
0.1250292808,
-0.3221760392,
-0.9765098095,
0.1344641149,
-0.1554495543,
0.4371778071,
0.6857718229,
-0.5094882846,
0.0153204696,
-0.4392181933,
0.5739950538,
-0.4363065362,
0.2707198262,
-0.5738947988,
0.4332458377,
-0.1134221256,
-0.2197087556,
-0.2986321747,
-0.4166959524,
0.2297672033,
-0.6704272628,
0.1083536223,
0.2491078973,
0.4426205754,
0.0125001715,
-0.6469553709,
-0.7503548265,
-0.5786875486,
0.2664920688,
-0.7721999288,
0.3484582901,
0.230912894,
0.4012476206,
-0.0800649598,
-0.4266129434,
-0.8316693306,
-0.6081391573,
0.1312968433,
0.0997382924,
-0.0108882375,
-0.0370964035,
0.323931545,
0.1762529165,
-0.5981901288,
0.6428537369,
-0.3738906682,
-0.0878174677,
0.6430515051,
0.3970182836,
0.3086209595,
-0.2244805992,
0.0282351375,
0.1403422058,
-0.9000485539,
0.3528486192,
0.5694368482,
0.3963935971,
-0.391218096,
0.7640571594,
0.2487666607,
0.5355692506,
0.0255579744,
-0.7016425729,
0.2034434676,
0.1426758319,
0.0142032551,
0.3375210166,
0.6950219274,
0.2245179564,
0.5453511477,
-0.1719662398,
-0.2125139982,
-0.5544844866,
-0.0655732453,
-0.6857589483,
0.0520977192,
0.0899917558,
-0.4601042271,
-0.3751910031,
0.0140725179,
-0.7874265909,
-0.8556589484,
-0.5206816792,
0.2693450749,
-0.336863935,
-0.1800634712,
0.436283499,
-0.0328411758,
0.2129970938,
0.3700577617,
-1.0306683779,
0.0653228983,
0.6580466628,
0.6612061262,
0.2770020068,
0.1041896939,
-0.7562621236,
0.4221615195,
-0.6328997612,
0.439812392,
-0.6292892694,
-0.3356755078,
0.3594707549,
-0.2270730287,
0.2256198525,
-0.4875620306,
0.4777465165,
-0.4535706341,
-0.1175866202,
0.0494118817,
-0.6996692419,
-0.2744293213,
0.3751755655,
-0.5855149031,
0.2613478303,
-0.2202452868,
-0.4125022292,
0.4905610383,
-0.5577216148,
-0.7870172858,
0.3394931555,
-0.6402614117,
-0.3209829926,
0.4233389795,
0.2651213109,
0.4959944487,
-0.3176348805,
0.7951463461,
0.1484865397,
-0.1508890986,
0.2096864283,
-0.347625792,
0.6104853153,
0.1639427096,
-0.294153899,
0.004179372,
-0.4507255256,
-0.2773924768,
0.3508063555,
-0.4655145109,
-0.2688238621,
-0.0504900813,
-0.1639405787,
0.1884267777,
-0.0830960646,
-0.4721390009,
0.4330444932,
-0.42542243,
0.4526704848,
0.4731225371,
0.1436116695,
0.3085364997,
-0.3889858723,
0.7492957115,
-0.0426484197,
-0.2363654226,
-0.5579892397,
-0.3341849446,
-0.5464807153,
-0.0442496166,
0.2492620796,
0.4277225137,
-0.7887154818,
-0.0553869456,
-0.2513459325,
-0.4995966852,
-0.422463119,
0.3251437247,
0.1946490109,
0.3576950133,
0.1160918102,
0.1507496685,
-0.3050382435,
-0.7341656685,
-0.4586035609,
-0.4377652109,
-0.0304403491,
0.4621342719,
0.7464300394,
0.1830371916,
0.7743989825,
-0.3122712374,
-0.2744994164,
-0.6599696279,
0.3342524171,
0.2259460837,
-0.0015176994,
0.4733932018,
-0.8111142516,
-0.4667675793,
0.2725471854,
-0.7932901382,
0.1071276441,
-0.606335938,
0.461687088,
0.0615585037,
0.2366065085,
-0.7558925152,
0.1954947859,
-0.131799221,
-0.429137826,
0.8622510433,
-0.5349037647,
0.054872591,
-1.0120488405,
-0.2247941196,
0.0522931628,
-0.2288707942,
-0.3664066792,
0.2552554607,
0.0311478693,
-0.2484799773,
-0.7599528432,
0.5364001393,
-0.546664238,
-0.1498917043,
-0.0647468492,
0.2652841806,
-0.1382805854,
0.2428493053,
0.1225556508,
0.5452024937,
0.4385830164,
-0.3161705434,
0.481826365,
0.2791164815,
-0.7577402592,
0.6292358637,
-0.1633414775,
-0.1098623946,
-0.370293051,
0.3029795289,
-0.2109176964,
-0.3708279431,
0.0122745531,
-0.1416003108,
0.3278746307,
-0.4603573978,
-0.9713975191,
-0.356561929,
0.0517457053,
-0.2419119626,
0.429002285,
-0.3524115086,
0.7703149319,
0.5758404136,
-0.2139720917,
-0.5139839649,
-0.5627059937,
0.5504931211,
-0.5882932544,
-0.393247962,
-0.2109054774,
0.0824787095,
-0.4450003803,
-0.029192742,
0.1673320681,
-0.1670812517,
-0.0260290932,
0.2714962959,
0.0100014433,
-0.2944892645,
0.634396255,
0.3452889919,
0.1761398315,
0.3387395144,
-0.3702434301,
0.3490841687,
-0.0389978178,
-0.459237963,
-0.2839486599,
0.2794205844,
0.64408499,
-0.2808720171,
0.6503035426,
0.2040599287,
-0.1915995926,
-0.3002530038,
-0.7275165319,
-0.119786866,
-0.3816612959,
0.6202144623,
-0.3695282042,
-1.1916599274,
0.3706468642,
-0.1478687078,
0.3473194242,
0.1257021874,
0.776363194,
-0.2416206598,
0.2575163245,
0.456237793,
-0.0068170279,
0.0656335205,
-0.0817951113,
0.5130177736,
-0.2614909708,
-0.4370719194,
-0.2139920443,
-0.1274563521,
-0.142518118,
-0.5903477073,
0.2369450778,
0.1385748535,
-0.1959748417,
0.0621354766,
0.2080483288,
0.8306714892,
0.2373778522,
-0.0474191904,
0.6801955104,
0.0960661247,
-0.3682943285,
-0.0870325863,
-0.6125259995,
-0.774107635,
1.2152564526,
0.5287184715,
0.874366343,
0.1537870914,
0.7782717943,
0.2587106526,
0.0688276291,
-0.9984052777,
0.4414792955,
-0.1228911951,
-0.4759740233,
-0.403912127,
-0.3837982714,
-0.7698128819,
0.2988199294,
-0.5333153009,
-0.4616281986,
0.0541603193,
-0.1330277622,
-0.6365207434,
0.7383968234,
-0.3330157101,
0.4936949313,
-0.6834284663,
-0.3012546003,
-0.2837985754,
-0.6625968218,
0.2800285816,
-0.4529455006,
0.4884612858,
0.1043409705,
0.0568649396,
0.7207201719,
-0.3009047508,
0.9476271868,
-0.0590330511,
-0.2061178684,
0.6572208405,
0.2035880685,
0.5082475543,
0.2359207124,
0.0668218583,
-0.2098734975,
-0.2239877433,
-0.0196634792,
-0.6518662572,
0.4822657406,
-0.5734980702,
-0.8463847041,
-0.1616353989,
-0.9584035873,
-0.1232788935,
0.1662534922,
-0.2829158306,
0.1684069037,
0.0220129378,
0.4109050035,
0.7618592381,
-0.4238557816,
0.3003738225,
1.1383632421,
-0.1210673302,
-0.0431115627,
0.8368130326,
0.4310387075,
0.0962062702,
0.4035849571,
0.5278070569,
-0.5473670363,
-0.8795364499,
-0.3787976503,
0.3750580251,
-0.9171433449,
-0.0834476426,
-0.9285771251,
-0.0189744011,
-0.0418161564,
-0.2444433123,
-0.0173992962,
-0.2931061387,
0.003012442,
-0.6082838774,
0.3180207312,
0.7679989934,
-0.1526804268,
0.1643505692,
-0.6813979149,
0.2701261342,
0.4011767209,
0.0140605466,
0.0521098897,
-0.7021762133,
-0.0839962736,
-0.0572184697,
-0.1174466908,
-0.6720590591,
0.3054472506,
-0.012193731,
0.7519897819,
0.5199348927,
0.0063580656,
0.6080979109,
-0.7193614841,
0.5058515668,
0.2769874036,
-0.6742814779,
0.4142246544,
-0.6847908497,
-0.0969353095,
0.459562242,
0.3145669103,
-0.6222730279,
-0.5485631227,
-0.2893391848,
-0.8643807173,
0.3894265294,
0.0186257474,
0.7077074647,
0.2172907591,
0.5708396435,
0.4121135771,
0.4055049419,
-0.8697118163,
0.0768410712,
0.0050378568,
-0.2235157788,
-0.1164769903,
-0.2191630155,
-0.1237182841,
-0.2130350173,
0.3628892601,
-0.0601533465,
-0.2463918626,
-0.2152181417,
-0.4666617513,
-0.1315440983,
0.6214627624,
0.7310492992,
0.7997092009,
0.0959882811,
0.1226161644,
0.2692799568,
-0.3585389555,
0.166885376,
-0.2909418344,
0.0582850613,
-0.0490952246,
0.6038771272,
1.0029575825,
0.2551164329,
-1.128010273,
0.6007454991,
0.0315046012,
-0.4565974772,
-0.3554812968,
-0.0844816566,
0.7141516805,
0.5640774965,
0.4558370113,
-0.3352959156,
-0.1619949639,
-0.7800285816,
0.2435883731,
0.1187313348,
-0.1658694744,
0.1215336695,
0.5512592196,
0.1514064521,
-0.3104689419,
0.4017928839,
-0.0477070734,
-0.3027914762,
0.7976228595,
0.6614169478,
0.3926328421,
0.1998652667,
0.4385186434,
0.3224178255,
0.3679284453,
-0.3895501494,
-0.150093317,
0.0020714381,
-0.4167686105,
-0.5100973248,
-0.5145468116,
-0.4332365692,
0.2808338404,
-0.3968510628,
0.3098278344,
-0.4455694854,
0.393599242,
-0.2175236493,
-0.1305482388,
-0.5050139427,
-0.0168242306,
0.271148324,
0.8816341162,
-1.0720944405,
0.6992223263,
0.3985503018,
-0.5838823318,
-0.9663179517,
0.1013159603,
0.0381421745,
-0.6179497242,
0.7416561842,
-0.045023296,
0.348341912,
-0.0675658807,
-0.4695924222,
-0.2063570768,
1.06696105,
0.5544061661,
-1.148170352,
-0.1730234623,
0.4606770277,
0.7106026411,
-0.6750605702,
0.1943305135,
0.3160881698,
0.4308679998,
0.4622600377,
-0.7307821512,
-0.1158175841,
0.1185785383,
-0.3501750827,
-0.0916301608,
-0.1272647083,
0.6995884776,
-0.7352619171,
0.1323836595,
-0.1557106078,
0.5794830322,
0.4861633182,
0.2933388948,
0.2917933166,
0.491232425,
1.0176490545,
0.1371930689,
0.9230099916,
-0.0125746615,
0.3267555237,
1.3988406658,
-0.2070880979,
0.6728696823,
0.3901083469,
0.1088195965,
0.4456530213,
0.4946780205,
-0.274530977,
0.1549877822,
0.5611959696,
-0.1967440546,
-0.4603404999,
-0.2182554007,
-0.1473221034,
0.374139607,
0.3689029515,
-0.3644668758,
-0.4973965585,
0.4343270063,
0.1566013843,
0.4789529443,
-0.6043390036,
0.675542891,
0.2668482661,
-0.3030164242,
0.1519205272,
-0.0403073393,
0.3948529065,
-0.3411374688,
-0.1062028706,
-0.114763923,
-0.2584760785,
-0.1596128941,
-1.224938035,
-0.1364513934,
0.3634183109,
-0.0374644101,
-0.0342938378,
0.215549767,
-0.6108439565,
-0.5314427614,
0.167233482,
0.4884685576,
0.3814736307,
0.1680824012,
-0.6370013952,
-0.1775936037,
-0.2357910872,
0.0405995287,
0.2884179056,
0.6246317029,
-0.4348668158,
0.8110126853,
0.5675951838,
0.1001680419,
0.1559221447,
0.3430301249,
0.8134871721,
-0.5822313428,
-0.8043161035,
-0.7425687313,
0.735343039,
0.0968887955,
0.0220253579,
0.5326134562,
0.7262983918,
0.6669339538,
-0.2309096307,
0.8088828921,
0.070904009,
0.2672383189,
-0.7268298864,
0.8319897652,
-0.2703077495,
0.2816819251,
0.0016193113,
-0.7842601538,
-0.2160566896,
0.4724788964,
-0.4608299732,
-0.1739917397,
0.5975722075,
0.4017258584,
-0.0507112257,
-0.1736689806,
0.7742036581,
0.3114109337,
0.5924192667,
0.5071986318,
0.8358714581,
0.0788128302,
0.5809796453,
0.1917583793,
0.1128502786,
-0.1950576752,
-0.623809278,
-1.4539015293,
-0.2888296247,
-0.0952257961,
-0.0311818235,
0.1697336137,
0.9689449072,
0.3709631562,
-0.5094249249,
-0.3510601819,
-0.0397351123,
0.0162212551,
0.3914137781,
-0.155883655,
0.2312107831,
-0.3767775297,
-0.5066313744,
0.3625617623,
0.2311189175,
0.0105367322,
-0.2266352177,
-0.3056304157,
-0.2977204323,
0.176619485,
0.561594069,
0.2923074663,
-0.926086247,
-0.1335366517,
-0.4095561802,
0.0911869332,
0.0311008282,
1.1172422171,
-0.5401624441,
0.6937552094,
0.2397480458,
0.7413380146,
0.6609649658,
-0.2314602435,
0.4316698015,
-0.4649364948,
0.2263554335,
0.4285826385,
0.4769099951,
0.1057904661,
-0.3414111435,
0.2591995597,
-0.0853569582,
-0.009298726,
-0.6818739772,
0.147932604,
-0.5652400255,
-0.5247303247,
1.0885206461,
-0.3793182373,
-0.0299487673,
-0.4213130474,
-0.3297600448,
0.0335884243,
-0.4325572252,
0.8260646462,
0.8236324191,
0.3287922442,
-0.4718456864,
-1.0005625486,
0.1164144799,
0.0460059531,
-0.8694310188,
0.0158486702,
0.3874525726,
0.6382358074,
-0.0989997983,
0.3008211553,
-0.3108357191,
0.2154993713,
-0.2326998264,
0.0049407058,
-0.6216799021,
-0.2683904767,
-0.3309854269,
0.3113847673,
0.0144609623,
0.4039038122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17016v1
|
Multi-Task Contrastive Learning for 8192-Token Bilingual Text Embeddings
| 2024-02-26T20:53:12 | 2024-02-26T20:53:12 |
Isabelle Mohr, Markus Krimmel, Saba Sturua, Mohammad Kalim Akram, Andreas Koukounas, Michael Günther, Georgios Mastrapas, Vinit Ravishankar, Joan Fontanals Martínez, Feng Wang, Qi Liu, Ziniu Yu, Jie Fu, Saahil Ognawala, Susana Guzman, Bo Wang, Maximilian Werk, Nan Wang, Han Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We introduce a novel suite of state-of-the-art bilingual text embedding
models that are designed to support English and another target language. These
models are capable of processing lengthy text inputs with up to 8192 tokens,
making them highly versatile for a range of natural language processing tasks
such as text retrieval, clustering, and semantic textual similarity (STS)
calculations.
By focusing on bilingual models and introducing a unique multi-task learning
objective, we have significantly improved the model performance on STS tasks,
which outperforms the capabilities of existing multilingual models in both
target language understanding and cross-lingual evaluation tasks. Moreover, our
bilingual models are more efficient, requiring fewer parameters and less memory
due to their smaller vocabulary needs. Furthermore, we have expanded the
Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) to include benchmarks for German and
Spanish embedding models. This integration aims to stimulate further research
and advancement in text embedding technologies for these languages.
|
[
-0.1968179494,
-0.5911810398,
0.4613289535,
0.5224530101,
-0.3323001564,
0.1283490211,
-0.1047041491,
-0.5203746557,
0.1933957487,
0.4872383177,
-0.3013425767,
-0.5626807213,
-0.8050324917,
0.3250837624,
-0.0261044521,
0.8774484396,
-0.1952571869,
0.4747602344,
-0.194427982,
-0.3924361467,
-0.5592813492,
-0.4988726079,
-0.680452466,
-0.1787920892,
0.5855542421,
0.4721715152,
0.3026908934,
0.5240194201,
0.3820691407,
0.3599881232,
-0.0228606872,
0.2431162,
-0.3854107857,
0.1016199961,
-0.3164531291,
-0.4917264879,
-0.4875028431,
-0.2255580425,
0.7530382872,
0.7434980869,
0.1220840663,
-0.0203161016,
0.3142236173,
0.415581584,
-0.609058857,
0.3587239087,
-0.555320859,
0.131150201,
-0.2263623029,
0.047882732,
-0.7355158925,
0.224413231,
0.0730251297,
-0.4700941145,
0.1240879372,
0.1963308901,
0.376470536,
-0.1049822271,
-0.9169613719,
-0.1996943057,
-0.1066785753,
1.1820309162,
-0.4788799584,
0.7020484209,
0.4368378818,
-0.0989475921,
0.3567659855,
-0.5875204206,
-0.4229492843,
-0.0764965788,
-0.0465240963,
0.1705131978,
-0.1302929074,
-0.1640211642,
-0.0199844204,
0.2771627605,
-0.7177301645,
0.2759663761,
-0.3696473241,
-0.1924616098,
0.1233264208,
0.3076229393,
0.0827543661,
-0.2769775689,
-0.5918624997,
-0.0766611993,
-0.4898777008,
-0.1305139512,
0.3925011456,
0.4958320558,
-0.4295428991,
0.260343641,
0.05857981,
0.3584611118,
-0.0506376587,
-0.0134152835,
0.7229219079,
-0.4833943248,
-0.1710910797,
-0.3250404,
0.7868071795,
0.3491658866,
-0.2373091131,
-0.3593582809,
-0.211350143,
-0.2207024097,
0.20364061,
-0.8146070242,
0.1660647988,
0.0584124811,
-0.5481488705,
-0.2033680379,
0.0401003361,
-0.7916172147,
-0.3449254036,
-0.2545620203,
0.4151334465,
-0.3663044274,
-0.241467014,
0.2013451904,
-0.2863738537,
-0.0031401634,
0.2148979604,
-0.7572233677,
0.3911563456,
0.6913444996,
0.8746266961,
-0.6279389858,
-0.6188759804,
-0.5757027864,
0.2180774659,
-0.2193411738,
0.5253283978,
-0.5692391992,
-0.5709869862,
0.1662988514,
0.2739364505,
-0.2892029285,
-0.5964480042,
0.7714092135,
-0.5015795827,
0.3176040649,
-0.2526082695,
-0.2452903986,
-0.41051054,
0.4232461452,
-1.1031472683,
1.4311351776,
-0.099483192,
-0.9312739968,
0.0225383751,
-0.6592198014,
-0.5825704336,
-0.0732810944,
0.1004055515,
-0.3430260718,
0.0654781833,
0.1362952292,
0.5952859521,
-0.5076858997,
0.246047169,
-0.1331421435,
-0.2422024161,
-0.236586079,
-0.3777305484,
0.8622713685,
0.0644860491,
-0.441188544,
0.2696185708,
-0.5244650841,
-0.3056271672,
0.0815059394,
-0.3444475234,
-0.5466141701,
-0.1473453343,
0.6155839562,
0.3898042738,
0.4840032458,
-0.7083349228,
-0.2989479899,
-0.3078634143,
0.3055939376,
0.7196370959,
-0.4045507908,
0.4208440483,
-0.311160326,
0.4456161559,
0.401044935,
-0.1046721563,
-0.5986171365,
-0.5680413842,
-0.6872025728,
-0.4309477508,
0.4009988606,
0.771668613,
-0.7507100701,
0.5673151016,
-0.2019217461,
-0.4146326184,
-0.5130130649,
0.2469412088,
0.6861343384,
0.5381902456,
0.6327272058,
-0.3462198675,
-0.5680365562,
-1.0378072262,
-0.209728688,
0.264269799,
0.1668617576,
0.2283956558,
0.8043212295,
-0.2654170096,
0.2632977664,
-0.2290505171,
-0.4093388021,
-0.4428410828,
0.2791108489,
0.0352491103,
0.72191149,
0.6204410791,
-1.0497515202,
-0.8757202625,
0.3124475777,
-0.6193238497,
0.3206479847,
0.2528607249,
-0.0781808347,
0.163652733,
0.6550077796,
-0.3119901419,
0.2410268635,
0.8060624599,
-0.3801307678,
0.3035573363,
-0.4314565063,
0.4260165691,
-1.5111646652,
0.0799643397,
0.1018710211,
-0.4626537263,
-0.6226667762,
0.267198205,
0.5491648912,
0.0106966235,
-0.5931714177,
0.7491304278,
-0.3878097534,
0.2908049226,
-0.2909611166,
0.1228944957,
0.1777157485,
0.4838700593,
0.0470851585,
0.6378606558,
0.6444770098,
-0.3016716242,
0.1428532749,
0.0957204998,
-0.1847274452,
0.7660823464,
-0.6902635694,
0.0187047347,
-0.2069089264,
0.3376087248,
-1.1116997004,
0.1459507346,
0.0274344143,
-0.1424244195,
0.2282166928,
0.0963562727,
-0.701967895,
-0.1721803844,
-0.6735810041,
0.7671274543,
0.2470133305,
-0.572473824,
0.858112514,
0.4942904413,
-0.5266559124,
-0.6602762341,
-0.8849170804,
0.05280485,
-0.179065153,
-0.2727521062,
0.8950849771,
-0.0502445586,
0.1451791078,
0.0680360198,
0.1190695539,
-0.2367212325,
-0.0857614428,
0.2357077003,
0.3638772368,
-0.1538037062,
0.2467442304,
0.3190555274,
-0.1865026653,
-0.2514685094,
-0.2381835133,
0.5011153221,
-0.0120248729,
-0.4021796584,
-0.3313816488,
0.9355140924,
0.5110046268,
-0.5988416076,
0.9682282805,
0.7946904898,
-0.6944108605,
-0.0641141906,
-0.6129942536,
0.0504942276,
-0.4292949438,
0.7820959091,
-0.6343608499,
-1.0423388481,
0.641671896,
0.0814395025,
0.1919627637,
0.6027632356,
0.6792727113,
0.1642915606,
1.1067973375,
0.7586603761,
-0.0944876745,
0.4434717,
-0.0555763319,
-0.0382786393,
-0.7036257386,
-0.3969266713,
-0.7002771497,
-0.212360993,
-0.623255372,
-0.902581811,
0.0784972683,
-0.2805389464,
-0.2122437209,
0.4184556007,
-0.1297950298,
0.5459577441,
0.6313617826,
0.2046923488,
0.1607720256,
-0.0638622269,
-0.7005907893,
-0.2323811948,
-0.5280142426,
-0.390591979,
1.2343345881,
0.296020031,
0.3633295298,
0.0986102596,
0.7160096765,
0.3140222728,
0.2632448077,
-0.5486060977,
0.3718477488,
-0.5430700183,
-0.560652554,
0.0063292966,
-0.3279101849,
-0.9182818532,
0.6965895295,
-0.2080800086,
-0.6436832547,
-0.0127203157,
-0.0179989543,
0.1283826828,
0.4260917306,
-0.8693583608,
1.2075498104,
-0.067841731,
-0.4623972178,
-0.6388942599,
-0.4157058597,
0.0172057431,
-0.1905000657,
0.4161748588,
0.0719383731,
-0.495002538,
0.9523844123,
0.2182451487,
1.0685909986,
-0.064258419,
-0.0520150699,
-0.1123306304,
-0.022767799,
0.5003880858,
-0.1800999939,
-0.3511381745,
0.167787686,
-0.0874912664,
-0.652978301,
-0.087948896,
1.1096429825,
-0.5106143355,
-0.3411621153,
-0.361391753,
-0.6724162698,
-0.2628603578,
0.4083532989,
-0.0670278296,
0.4579596817,
-0.3429285884,
0.3249646723,
0.5078422427,
-0.2059778273,
0.5919145346,
0.4317896962,
0.0028788215,
-0.6688138247,
1.0213403702,
-0.1704587489,
0.074847877,
0.7852455974,
-0.0352316014,
-0.5432530642,
-0.3985875845,
-0.1961911768,
0.4876985848,
-0.8215181231,
-0.1130402461,
-0.8130457997,
0.3279999495,
-0.4273182154,
-0.2135343105,
-0.3748633564,
-0.2229586095,
-0.2748576999,
-0.2566697299,
-0.1279696226,
0.8928316236,
0.1252045184,
0.0767751485,
-0.9206366539,
0.4391165376,
0.0728770345,
0.4175513387,
0.1801955551,
-0.5005761981,
-0.564252317,
-0.2133218199,
-0.55750072,
-0.9741934538,
0.347289592,
0.0070917276,
0.7591972947,
0.245213151,
-0.1210259348,
0.4985454082,
-0.8911084533,
0.6721516252,
0.3709910512,
-1.1736408472,
0.0746823996,
-0.1465391517,
0.3317967057,
0.4311235547,
0.732640028,
-0.4226129949,
-0.3358753324,
-0.5440340042,
-0.7765251994,
0.6262797713,
-0.0910670608,
0.3513296247,
-0.1000114009,
-0.2349639386,
0.5015166998,
0.2292181551,
-0.9811476469,
-0.3458918929,
-0.0592182912,
-0.4911274612,
-0.2701939344,
-0.2825312912,
-0.0125579555,
-0.2268184274,
0.5548592806,
-0.260981679,
0.2305647433,
-0.21816881,
-0.3269095123,
0.2109556645,
0.3421039283,
0.5396931171,
0.4496333301,
0.1098443121,
0.3474072218,
0.520952642,
-0.330383122,
-0.1008075029,
0.4896530807,
0.1235291213,
0.1472072303,
0.3171056509,
0.7902601957,
0.697645545,
-0.8458570242,
0.5840888023,
0.1125112027,
-0.2997118831,
0.128012538,
-0.5693330765,
0.3556480706,
0.3516283631,
0.4729825556,
0.0068811276,
0.1896238774,
-0.4573042393,
0.1949652731,
0.533929646,
-0.4806689322,
-0.469098568,
0.6836550832,
0.4981566072,
-0.2961072028,
0.1574832201,
-0.2387948185,
-0.7322285771,
0.5542556643,
0.7441517711,
0.7851126194,
-0.2663903832,
0.1750419736,
0.4388330579,
0.1648076475,
-0.0735806897,
0.381721735,
-0.1680062264,
-0.5901158452,
-0.4167819023,
-0.3306032419,
-0.4806336462,
-0.2042195797,
-0.7115784883,
0.2753005326,
-0.0481614619,
-0.1302464157,
0.0263411105,
-0.1230964884,
-0.8861752152,
0.0748649687,
0.0321466923,
0.787469089,
-0.912889123,
0.8315146565,
0.8723152876,
-0.1141003296,
-0.2363356501,
-0.1668768376,
-0.0637779459,
-0.7113733292,
0.661015451,
0.5476578474,
-0.0072935983,
-0.012275002,
0.1207083538,
-0.3831126094,
0.9815071225,
0.4505833983,
-0.2952449322,
-0.2349788547,
0.1869155169,
0.3744813502,
-0.4891796112,
0.4219795167,
0.1549876183,
0.3205178678,
-0.3984582424,
-1.1904882193,
0.0383911133,
-0.3407167494,
-0.2040273696,
0.2480491996,
-0.5847893357,
0.954199791,
-0.0604814366,
0.0054772235,
0.0085535655,
0.5210270286,
0.1487993747,
0.2103673369,
0.5283390284,
0.7000806928,
0.554743588,
-0.0573848821,
0.8690294027,
-0.4514836669,
0.3263262212,
0.9739658833,
-0.3097359538,
1.2099057436,
0.6727221608,
-0.0680852309,
0.5359236002,
0.3184726834,
0.2079621553,
0.5103725195,
-0.2530055046,
-0.3135536611,
-0.3462235332,
-0.3055000901,
-0.2501175404,
0.1915203333,
0.2385311425,
-0.4698603451,
-0.3449377716,
0.3338712454,
0.0007968437,
0.1981756389,
-0.1910597235,
0.5959857106,
-0.0037816151,
-0.6116525531,
0.2018102258,
0.4903154671,
1.0244395733,
-0.5557246208,
-0.0452127121,
-0.0989317447,
0.237610057,
0.1030209661,
-0.6366782188,
0.1271318644,
-0.0275424607,
-0.2338455766,
-0.6277846098,
0.3065011203,
-0.6744402051,
-0.5094406605,
0.6909644604,
0.6868216991,
-0.33073017,
0.0052029034,
-0.8510522246,
0.0595586114,
-0.0294550676,
-0.0340172015,
0.5202412009,
0.458484292,
0.0392939933,
0.4128220379,
0.3755063117,
-0.1355196387,
0.1866632998,
0.0369576551,
0.7053400278,
-0.7846899033,
-0.8516520262,
-0.7431353331,
0.7882117629,
-0.08518859,
-0.3389210701,
0.7601043582,
0.9694219232,
0.9151788354,
-0.3491532207,
0.7603338957,
0.188271746,
0.6805285215,
-0.3266262412,
0.2424868047,
-0.7992758751,
-0.0889983699,
-0.1530063301,
-0.6808946133,
-0.295661062,
0.2884627283,
-0.0507498756,
-0.0222799089,
1.0074002743,
0.7024220824,
-0.2262060642,
-0.0832088664,
0.3518722653,
-0.2685171366,
0.1386630833,
0.8110138178,
0.4728268087,
-0.6532019973,
0.660676837,
-0.3052164316,
-0.1381694525,
-0.0264246874,
-0.8700342178,
-1.0817742348,
-0.8965633512,
-0.2370633185,
0.027001407,
-0.0102790939,
0.8622438312,
0.7038962841,
-0.9751982093,
-0.3731950223,
0.061691355,
0.1971213967,
-0.1802948564,
-0.1799056828,
0.4528121948,
-0.3943625689,
-1.2899676561,
0.3916500509,
0.369999975,
-0.0477769487,
-0.124073483,
-0.2148296684,
-0.3509017229,
0.0346956067,
0.6978038549,
0.0446965247,
-0.6838517785,
0.0612596087,
0.1268303543,
-0.4333939254,
0.0507160798,
0.7754029632,
-0.5527035594,
0.4654889107,
0.5938397646,
0.9803205132,
0.4587289691,
-0.3316722512,
0.3893335164,
-0.7747680545,
0.5465059876,
0.1264944524,
0.6634626985,
0.3695106804,
0.0665999129,
0.1205253378,
0.2249767184,
-0.191868484,
-0.8352456689,
0.0078283129,
-0.9944645166,
-0.1755501777,
0.7856917381,
-0.3215077519,
0.1994434148,
-0.2223276496,
-0.3444716632,
0.041937165,
-0.3210873306,
0.3802635074,
0.7359588742,
0.1810703278,
-0.2634260952,
-0.4178667367,
0.1143799275,
0.6605796814,
-0.8533986807,
-0.2278213054,
0.1549820155,
0.0521444976,
0.2197831571,
0.382510066,
-0.191305235,
0.4640447795,
0.1170663089,
-0.0619209521,
-0.0380842164,
-0.2669374943,
-0.2871775925,
0.5604630113,
0.0002126152,
-0.2827483714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17014v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17014v2
|
Z-AGI Labs at ClimateActivism 2024: Stance and Hate Event Detection on Social Media
| 2024-02-26T20:43:48 | 2024-04-14T13:43:39 |
Nikhil Narayan, Mrutyunjay Biswal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the digital realm, rich data serves as a crucial source of insights into
the complexities of social, political, and economic landscapes. Addressing the
growing need for high-quality information on events and the imperative to
combat hate speech, this research led to the establishment of the Shared Task
on Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Detection at CASE 2024. Focused on
climate activists contending with hate speech on social media, our study
contributes to hate speech identification from tweets. Analyzing three
sub-tasks - Hate Speech Detection (Sub-task A), Targets of Hate Speech
Identification (Sub-task B), and Stance Detection (Sub-task C) - Team Z-AGI
Labs evaluated various models, including LSTM, Xgboost, and LGBM based on
Tf-Idf. Results unveiled intriguing variations, with Catboost excelling in
Subtask-B (F1: 0.5604) and Subtask-C (F1: 0.7081), while LGBM emerged as the
top-performing model for Subtask-A (F1: 0.8684). This research provides
valuable insights into the suitability of classical machine learning models for
climate hate speech and stance detection, aiding informed model selection for
robust mechanisms.
|
[
-0.4047385156,
-0.8493573666,
0.4388714731,
-0.1227776557,
-0.3581263721,
0.4500056505,
-0.0452441312,
-0.6198880672,
0.2705254555,
0.1465110779,
-0.8686701059,
-0.6218294501,
-0.8543655276,
-0.3911185861,
-0.543684721,
1.0826046467,
0.2585632503,
0.059321221,
0.0782545581,
-0.1672972739,
-0.0928430855,
-0.4256957173,
-0.7250180244,
-0.4157081246,
0.7379260659,
0.2697510421,
0.7868338823,
0.5031737685,
0.1734406203,
0.2504967153,
-0.1191946119,
-0.3904075325,
-0.4487517178,
-0.0013924149,
-0.1821367294,
-0.030186113,
-0.3449512124,
0.2579546273,
0.4898074567,
0.0484044775,
-0.0894954503,
0.2068180591,
-0.2834406793,
0.1739307493,
-0.4982677996,
-0.0675925985,
-0.9996148944,
0.0770302638,
-0.2880325913,
0.1503970474,
-0.1978998035,
-0.0708736777,
-0.2040733844,
-0.3356074393,
0.7113823295,
0.1134135798,
0.8963100314,
0.2271807492,
-0.221384719,
-0.2962709963,
-0.4854196906,
0.9997981787,
-0.6658467054,
0.533115685,
0.12253052,
0.0955049321,
-0.0460463762,
-0.3588662744,
-0.9523723722,
0.0228754617,
0.2602564991,
0.1496257782,
-0.4525111616,
-0.0977504179,
-0.056166485,
0.1909366995,
-0.5321707129,
0.5057317615,
-0.2823841572,
-0.2734892666,
0.8116116524,
0.2263388783,
0.3060685992,
-0.4426012933,
-0.4245041311,
-0.0255638696,
-0.2471424192,
-0.0286844652,
0.6830891371,
0.6119292378,
-0.104010269,
0.3337239623,
-0.1531641483,
0.3916601837,
0.0942036808,
0.0696438104,
0.0445951112,
-0.363270551,
-0.2440150082,
0.1696115881,
0.8803974986,
0.3249709308,
0.0412342735,
-0.1759729087,
-0.0662887916,
0.2093174309,
0.396471262,
-0.7967412472,
-0.2752141654,
0.2936408222,
-0.3914279044,
-0.5675243139,
-0.118102707,
-0.9381443262,
-0.9912461638,
-0.3768704534,
0.2406923771,
-0.0767339095,
-0.3985359669,
-0.2527270019,
-0.4298470318,
0.3687105477,
0.4167120159,
-0.5077441335,
0.0629821718,
0.8822706938,
0.8827822804,
-0.609910965,
0.0243388843,
-0.5093166828,
-0.0893243179,
-0.1323373765,
0.6019912362,
-0.8023526073,
-0.3046797812,
-0.1802435666,
-0.0556155331,
-0.0303884484,
-0.2689433992,
0.6426863074,
-0.6365210414,
-0.136664018,
-0.1944474578,
-0.4970163107,
-0.2472229749,
0.2076301873,
-0.5175739527,
0.8714263439,
-0.0304036904,
-0.7672931552,
0.6656783819,
-0.7521777153,
-0.1704239994,
0.2649319172,
-0.100995779,
-0.8999401927,
-0.0082232906,
-0.2240303457,
0.6336765289,
-0.0523961447,
0.3976239264,
-0.6899965405,
0.1169620007,
-0.0588203743,
-0.1410342753,
0.9514972568,
0.201167807,
-0.6531527042,
0.6633330584,
-0.6531550884,
-0.2695440352,
0.3710545897,
-0.03234322,
-0.1746290028,
0.2236391753,
0.265492171,
0.2670362294,
0.1035658494,
-0.9221081734,
-0.1382602304,
0.2657848299,
0.5889075994,
1.0404009819,
-0.1003886238,
0.165445298,
-0.0688508153,
0.7033448815,
0.045218803,
0.2098197639,
0.6358641982,
-0.6084801555,
-0.5054095387,
-0.158428669,
-0.236427784,
0.6711453795,
-0.4031744897,
-0.0713720098,
-0.0988837779,
-0.9021690488,
-0.07322032,
0.1687411517,
0.2540159523,
0.4343445599,
0.3674755394,
0.0933045968,
-0.7295333147,
-0.790776372,
-0.503282249,
-0.3483936787,
0.4336227179,
0.1817630529,
0.7197744846,
-0.2885650396,
0.864772141,
-0.2072679549,
0.100328818,
-0.4887991846,
0.3959821463,
-0.1262542307,
0.1535249352,
0.9380124807,
-1.3633856773,
-0.5761876106,
-0.0861794427,
-0.0736281052,
-0.1099845693,
0.2591715455,
-0.1080267653,
0.2760083675,
0.4010227919,
-0.2895670533,
0.5220468044,
0.5811457038,
-0.6216825843,
0.4115077853,
0.6773734689,
0.3281698227,
-1.0571795702,
-0.1966670603,
0.35606125,
-0.3374682963,
-1.1564689875,
-0.1025247201,
-0.3220344186,
-0.0549475849,
-0.7274354696,
0.4525772929,
0.0027533455,
0.041692771,
-0.403186202,
-0.0266114902,
-0.4963592291,
0.2570713758,
0.3145295084,
0.5746891499,
0.3480684459,
-0.5064269304,
0.3526660502,
0.1912601143,
-0.3046606779,
0.2354846448,
-0.3193775117,
0.3465865254,
-0.1236832589,
0.160880506,
-1.11346066,
-0.2100623846,
0.5687516928,
-0.5682414174,
-0.1210536659,
-0.1395879388,
-0.5413038135,
-0.3955591619,
-0.2604736984,
0.3141077459,
0.2684808671,
-0.4117304385,
0.8209040165,
0.8549385667,
-0.1667711437,
-0.4120265841,
-0.4614442587,
0.0672154203,
-0.639000535,
-0.3411441445,
0.3375624418,
-0.1188673601,
-0.4970628917,
-0.1264572889,
-0.0970071852,
-0.2279007584,
0.2581930161,
0.5955652595,
-0.0239031017,
0.0580743328,
-0.2230561823,
-0.2228843272,
0.2771995366,
0.1167435199,
0.0156027814,
0.6218933463,
-0.1843006313,
0.0731642246,
-0.4778260291,
0.4359025955,
0.7523807883,
0.1395010054,
0.8502565622,
1.0253295898,
-0.5900890827,
0.004543771,
-0.3816294968,
0.172431618,
-0.4341357648,
0.1488904059,
0.237889573,
-1.1143577099,
0.65725559,
0.3135541379,
0.2375980467,
0.483690083,
0.676756382,
0.1099759191,
1.0558792353,
0.6395713091,
-0.4084122479,
0.7973447442,
-0.0468119048,
0.3708880842,
-0.3279469311,
-0.1837419271,
-0.7208477855,
-0.1572571099,
-0.4289452732,
-0.4509335458,
0.1475766003,
-0.3100554645,
-0.1994168907,
0.4989187121,
-0.3729110956,
0.1512993872,
0.3376592994,
-0.0416989848,
-0.0225332659,
-0.0373165607,
0.4514127374,
-0.0135357929,
-0.4455704093,
-0.3814889491,
0.546323061,
0.2993604243,
0.0293398108,
0.1289698333,
0.4858573079,
0.8437382579,
0.5221819878,
-0.9302499294,
0.8517088294,
-0.194608286,
-0.7347548604,
-0.3988752365,
-0.1656240821,
-0.6656640768,
0.2497710139,
-0.131788224,
-0.7307471633,
0.1913926303,
0.2469254136,
-0.2121012509,
0.5689318776,
-0.375667572,
0.9534502625,
0.00828024,
-0.327490747,
-0.4554476738,
-0.3884420395,
0.084746927,
-0.1286363751,
0.6119890213,
-0.4178497195,
0.0021608633,
0.8981580138,
-0.1211788803,
1.1275839806,
-0.5115351081,
-0.1672375053,
0.3942061961,
-0.2540286779,
0.4933623075,
-0.2580547333,
-0.4603072703,
0.3646606207,
-0.3092501462,
-0.3355490565,
-0.09490446,
0.5568085909,
-0.5962942243,
-0.6529946923,
-0.3305401206,
-0.3997114599,
-0.0476911254,
0.190524891,
0.1831878126,
0.0876084566,
-0.5634779334,
0.1749642938,
0.4399814308,
-0.0574347079,
0.5058690906,
0.5182840228,
-0.00407456,
-0.3363086581,
1.0497788191,
0.1594099998,
0.1900501847,
0.1312046647,
0.4998035133,
-0.0651438832,
-0.861584425,
-0.2724771202,
-0.1682242602,
-0.6555293798,
-0.1615339518,
-0.876742959,
-0.0733809397,
-0.6498078704,
-0.1744685769,
-0.2275920957,
-0.3049151599,
-0.4104279578,
-0.3945457637,
0.5005466342,
0.5875431299,
-0.2563851774,
0.4581234455,
-0.4194867909,
0.4630487561,
0.1197935268,
-0.1452002078,
-0.1788219064,
-0.4297082424,
-0.1581319869,
0.1330235153,
-0.4288363755,
-0.954384923,
0.54021734,
0.1831353456,
0.4723135829,
0.4622997344,
0.2033102214,
0.5906903148,
-0.4282489419,
1.0902841091,
0.1365671456,
-1.0750193596,
0.6773064733,
-0.7195559144,
-0.2379224598,
0.3280614913,
0.6307498813,
-0.2377482206,
-0.7643380761,
-0.8811722398,
-0.771415472,
0.7487146258,
0.2468423992,
0.17378591,
-0.0780322552,
0.2406995595,
0.1859745532,
0.4539709985,
-0.8609883785,
-0.2048052251,
-0.5174478889,
-0.0220218226,
-0.2225957066,
-0.12847884,
-0.0918465033,
-0.389862448,
0.8061162233,
-0.0991412252,
0.0607270598,
-0.145993486,
0.2790288329,
-0.2632501125,
0.4076556563,
0.7328169942,
0.446316272,
-0.0714811459,
-0.039981585,
0.0900486186,
-0.4901351333,
-0.0329629146,
-0.0028324614,
-0.2028028667,
0.1285146922,
0.2134846896,
0.9725176096,
-0.2020869255,
-0.4583178163,
0.4098958075,
0.0848715082,
-0.3358747661,
-0.6294980049,
0.2518408298,
-0.0624123104,
0.3517941236,
0.352969259,
-0.0858015269,
0.3962374628,
-0.7264238596,
-0.0072879558,
0.7371660471,
-0.630663991,
-0.57494241,
0.7072541714,
-0.0403991379,
-0.3073506355,
0.2283778638,
-0.1844311208,
-1.0518038273,
0.8690732718,
0.1989069134,
0.8247007728,
-0.3401792943,
0.5197921395,
0.3806802034,
0.1382653415,
0.3201844692,
0.2727595568,
-0.1860615164,
-1.0681279898,
0.046633888,
-0.6336604357,
-0.524951756,
0.4749863446,
-0.6911612749,
0.166783303,
-0.607863307,
-0.3132617474,
0.3311037421,
0.0460295528,
-0.4712524414,
0.2756420076,
0.2920076251,
0.5265635252,
-1.1636381149,
0.542165637,
0.7204173803,
0.0488374792,
-0.5147855878,
0.0803073868,
0.4844410717,
-0.6232118011,
0.4861177206,
0.1579115689,
-0.4490126669,
0.0478578731,
-1.0340921879,
-0.4321754575,
0.9490403533,
0.1829048991,
-0.4172841907,
0.3211434186,
0.1398788095,
0.6184239388,
-0.3720966876,
-0.3877496719,
0.484708339,
0.6334620118,
0.1477381587,
-0.6636347175,
0.040520411,
-0.2166461796,
-0.2982011735,
0.3281498849,
-0.9918122888,
0.6698540449,
0.0189944487,
-0.42145136,
-0.2305979133,
0.8073951602,
0.2547041178,
0.8174624443,
0.9115322232,
0.4504551291,
0.6115841866,
-0.0069911885,
0.8305097222,
0.0088959355,
0.1865759492,
0.7932127714,
-0.1574197114,
0.7181952,
0.3839945197,
0.1310355514,
0.4413141012,
0.7742060423,
-0.1491941512,
0.4798371196,
0.2687981427,
-0.4482867718,
-0.7270717025,
-0.5719106793,
0.0890852734,
0.3614470959,
0.6351235509,
-0.0644560233,
-0.1736913174,
0.2049161643,
0.1900177747,
0.111264132,
-0.6633657813,
0.6216195226,
-0.0851853043,
-0.4740507603,
0.0608077534,
0.041332271,
0.6167055368,
-0.2630142868,
0.0963267311,
0.3945333064,
0.0450713187,
-0.3066385686,
-0.7586596012,
0.6174271107,
0.1938466132,
-0.3772516847,
-0.4969543219,
0.6590388417,
-0.1980752051,
-0.2446665764,
0.607535243,
0.0191565696,
0.0977747068,
-0.0765090883,
-0.9240825772,
0.4071123004,
0.0330010988,
-0.3148010075,
0.3840462863,
0.1120757088,
-0.2108010054,
0.5343866944,
0.6114365458,
-0.198441118,
0.2145321667,
0.2135597765,
0.7676584125,
-0.4626075327,
-0.4334930778,
-0.8600310683,
0.2096839398,
-0.1449832618,
-0.1774318963,
0.8236840367,
0.5583527088,
0.6914469004,
0.0356728323,
0.8871549368,
-0.2829648554,
0.6968253851,
-0.3593628705,
0.5275105834,
-0.7501144409,
-0.3333393633,
-0.4208404124,
-0.4284773171,
-0.2385687232,
0.2974931598,
-0.429356277,
-0.0508105643,
0.1507102698,
0.7048368454,
0.0314869285,
0.2033923268,
0.1134427562,
0.1676286757,
0.634521246,
0.1342940181,
0.7044048905,
-0.0930484012,
0.5272820592,
-0.1889450252,
0.0881429762,
-0.2157113552,
-1.0356013775,
-0.8591215014,
-0.7173212767,
-0.8175737858,
-0.3609609306,
0.0343442298,
0.7376278639,
0.6297405362,
-1.0029383898,
-0.0020151122,
-0.2908897102,
0.2515649796,
-0.0933865532,
-0.2774182856,
0.1985702813,
0.2400684059,
-0.8692833185,
0.5557186007,
0.0580393709,
0.0325264111,
0.0700027198,
0.0166678075,
-0.365781635,
0.3174690008,
0.4589987099,
0.4800669849,
-0.841732204,
-0.5424317718,
-0.2121214718,
0.115642935,
-0.0492028818,
0.8647968769,
-0.4151973426,
-0.1156574041,
0.6324523091,
0.5137478709,
0.2332359701,
0.2060570717,
0.2539106905,
-0.4275000691,
0.0900704414,
0.3176936805,
0.2409331053,
0.3431301415,
-0.5395751595,
0.4323096573,
0.4370974004,
-0.4220768511,
-0.9827972054,
0.2700715363,
-1.1465250254,
-0.2176139504,
1.2347990274,
0.0993007943,
-0.1929980516,
-0.3350092471,
0.0803985149,
0.3179700673,
-0.5956465006,
0.6128236055,
0.9960917234,
-0.287511915,
-0.362449646,
-0.5705397129,
0.4825934768,
0.2764194608,
-0.5508803129,
0.1105377153,
0.5969632864,
0.2066983134,
0.4224901199,
0.5590139031,
0.2118002325,
0.2040508986,
-0.3595961332,
0.026502341,
-0.0254813358,
-0.3791548014,
-0.1545631588,
0.4046576619,
-0.4086376727,
-0.104726024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17013v1
|
Towards Explainability and Fairness in Swiss Judgement Prediction: Benchmarking on a Multilingual Dataset
| 2024-02-26T20:42:40 | 2024-02-26T20:42:40 |
Santosh T. Y. S. S, Nina Baumgartner, Matthias Stürmer, Matthias Grabmair, Joel Niklaus
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2
|
The assessment of explainability in Legal Judgement Prediction (LJP) systems
is of paramount importance in building trustworthy and transparent systems,
particularly considering the reliance of these systems on factors that may lack
legal relevance or involve sensitive attributes. This study delves into the
realm of explainability and fairness in LJP models, utilizing Swiss Judgement
Prediction (SJP), the only available multilingual LJP dataset. We curate a
comprehensive collection of rationales that `support' and `oppose' judgement
from legal experts for 108 cases in German, French, and Italian. By employing
an occlusion-based explainability approach, we evaluate the explainability
performance of state-of-the-art monolingual and multilingual BERT-based LJP
models, as well as models developed with techniques such as data augmentation
and cross-lingual transfer, which demonstrated prediction performance
improvement. Notably, our findings reveal that improved prediction performance
does not necessarily correspond to enhanced explainability performance,
underscoring the significance of evaluating models from an explainability
perspective. Additionally, we introduce a novel evaluation framework, Lower
Court Insertion (LCI), which allows us to quantify the influence of lower court
information on model predictions, exposing current models' biases.
|
[
-0.5442165732,
-0.3317250609,
0.7760269642,
0.1233623773,
-0.1889168769,
-0.2031457722,
-0.1955282837,
-0.8505453467,
-0.0879679546,
0.342128098,
-0.4038825333,
-0.2828690112,
-0.7509483099,
-0.2166317999,
-0.2894052863,
1.1006524563,
-0.0514093675,
0.6792430282,
-0.3266326785,
-0.5591443777,
-0.2787513137,
-0.5380499959,
-0.305632174,
-0.5084946156,
0.4378505051,
0.1629866809,
0.8586668372,
0.4903891385,
0.1921017915,
0.2326297015,
-0.2200608552,
-0.4110673666,
-0.2268469632,
-0.1208781227,
-0.4997982085,
-0.6278914213,
-0.3778779209,
-0.3543384075,
0.5388085842,
1.0037901402,
-0.51810956,
-0.0279421341,
-0.187059164,
1.0810266733,
-0.7892506719,
0.1764675379,
-0.553258419,
0.525273025,
-0.0715761259,
0.2168973535,
-0.4514963925,
-0.3799834847,
0.0740075335,
-0.5238785744,
0.3060031533,
0.2267334163,
0.6022905707,
-0.0622079037,
-0.1959461421,
-0.2903647423,
-0.3639508784,
0.4912548661,
-0.8756966591,
0.5564417839,
0.0807709694,
0.9052445292,
0.0086665442,
-0.4669411182,
-0.4929077625,
-0.177116856,
-0.1954150647,
0.450219214,
-0.3456455171,
-0.1461656243,
0.4864735603,
-0.011520152,
-0.5999550819,
0.4026685357,
-0.215778321,
-0.2315355539,
0.5994494557,
-0.3036668003,
0.0976569951,
-0.071065478,
-0.2626141012,
0.2077802271,
-0.6076253653,
0.4641940594,
0.7648116946,
0.4920682609,
-0.0469308235,
0.4464612603,
-0.3334494531,
0.5643370748,
0.1145752221,
-0.0724069849,
0.1790920496,
-0.1174012348,
-0.1050002426,
0.6290155649,
0.5087548494,
0.4854131341,
0.3802325726,
-0.1685377657,
-0.060097497,
-0.2101644725,
-0.0237399749,
-0.9006373286,
0.1809352636,
0.2402900159,
-0.8039842844,
-0.1557195187,
0.2348789722,
-0.6188828349,
-0.7469283938,
-0.2335063666,
-0.0592408739,
-0.4296246171,
-0.3180092871,
0.4850833416,
-0.1791069508,
0.1462768763,
0.4320758879,
-0.7389332056,
0.3299413323,
0.5380243659,
0.2714559138,
0.029713979,
-0.2097843438,
-0.495110333,
0.1590918154,
-0.092090264,
0.7830858231,
-0.3052558899,
-0.2834817767,
0.3344156444,
0.1945655942,
0.0912318677,
-0.5159398317,
0.8803592324,
-0.5542942286,
0.1802835017,
-0.3335010409,
-0.3784761727,
-0.4868062735,
-0.0239355806,
-0.741119504,
0.4221734703,
0.031620007,
-0.9627755284,
0.9121736288,
-0.7035676241,
-0.6844596267,
0.1072743759,
-0.1339771897,
-0.3972008824,
0.3157245517,
0.3649843931,
0.3688075542,
-0.1511139721,
0.7727095485,
-0.822183907,
-0.4228447378,
0.2620337903,
-0.4951187074,
1.0225301981,
0.2936454713,
-0.3014425635,
-0.1000989228,
-0.7286564112,
0.0445729308,
0.0996883288,
-0.0031276233,
-0.0329325721,
0.2475242019,
-0.0164020155,
0.3891804814,
0.0499578938,
-0.4930776358,
-0.2762285173,
-0.5453691483,
0.3521163762,
0.8936144114,
-0.444553256,
0.3964755535,
-0.2053802758,
0.7224623561,
0.0923377424,
0.2855136693,
-0.1236751154,
-0.4402883351,
-0.446736604,
0.0896512046,
0.6528153419,
0.6288870573,
-0.60394907,
0.0485211983,
-0.6455737352,
-0.2693423033,
-0.5607658625,
-0.0961766839,
0.4244396091,
0.5277642608,
0.0406008288,
-0.3202198148,
-0.3781405985,
-1.4682397842,
-0.7989243269,
-0.3336876333,
0.1302410811,
0.3885416985,
0.6364499331,
0.2914732695,
0.7571943998,
0.0964256972,
0.1948616654,
-0.4758461118,
-0.0201364923,
0.6198565364,
0.2563982904,
0.8268322945,
-1.0123474598,
-0.387273401,
0.2581409812,
-0.8252239823,
-0.0612369329,
0.0638266131,
0.0529054552,
0.2311018854,
0.1743754447,
-0.0070199072,
0.6062915325,
0.0033232833,
-0.4883087277,
0.6528838277,
-0.3325538635,
0.2867875099,
-0.448464632,
-0.128403917,
0.0033258437,
-0.3691692352,
-0.4602118433,
0.2089453042,
0.2114943862,
0.0114803491,
-0.8284835219,
0.433777988,
-0.1698074341,
-0.5076208115,
0.0015801797,
0.2271708697,
0.1118505895,
0.344071418,
-0.0510131232,
0.3373281956,
0.5513017774,
-0.364065975,
0.0362344533,
-0.0712036267,
-0.7235199809,
1.0172257423,
-0.4881572127,
-0.4623878598,
-0.3349199295,
0.1946248263,
-0.5612422228,
-0.2029072791,
0.1025588289,
-0.4164558947,
0.3293094039,
-0.493230015,
-0.6944878101,
-0.281390816,
-0.1048529074,
0.3371520042,
0.2995101511,
-0.6380033493,
0.8251826167,
0.3279349208,
-0.3130068779,
-0.8923665881,
-0.8676397204,
0.094763428,
-0.5334142447,
-0.7006189823,
0.3764176071,
-0.201655522,
-0.4876687229,
-0.0225433838,
-0.0042450121,
-0.2709644735,
0.3581977487,
0.3777831197,
0.0379781723,
-0.1836436093,
0.1096750349,
0.3275997043,
-0.0740619004,
0.367734462,
0.0252188649,
0.0571540967,
-0.3106541634,
-0.7277035713,
-0.5976921916,
0.4682207406,
0.1637496054,
0.1096283793,
0.4798881412,
0.3557131886,
-0.39409554,
-0.0485821441,
-0.3957797885,
0.246636495,
-0.3363581002,
0.2255498618,
-0.7478919625,
-0.699960351,
0.8500273228,
0.1149344295,
-0.1343554854,
0.7309615612,
0.415890187,
0.0855681673,
1.3059160709,
0.4782325625,
-0.0154484101,
0.2306053489,
0.2587078512,
0.3964040875,
-0.1726044863,
-0.1889148355,
-0.6443991661,
0.0655720457,
-0.8993356824,
0.026495466,
0.1067116484,
0.3983827233,
-0.1560969055,
0.0518969931,
-0.2711417377,
0.5895978808,
0.4567054212,
0.0135465711,
0.4568144679,
0.0572723337,
-0.4821271598,
-0.06580282,
-0.9312663674,
-0.41517061,
0.9927322268,
0.4494549334,
0.4246331751,
0.2058727741,
0.5917155743,
0.360997498,
0.280841589,
-0.5579748154,
0.2812477946,
-0.2998083532,
-0.6517555714,
-0.0519026369,
-0.2409700155,
-0.4540342987,
0.4562733769,
-0.4209246635,
-0.8016005158,
0.4111706614,
-0.061814934,
-0.5576746464,
0.2193178236,
-0.7025261521,
0.7640979886,
-0.4417570829,
-0.6002368927,
-0.3048316538,
-0.6539773941,
0.466707617,
-0.1740083396,
1.0024036169,
-0.2486662716,
0.2962111235,
0.5993664265,
-0.3857370019,
0.4775221646,
-0.4111884832,
-0.2553341985,
-0.0354334302,
0.121081233,
0.2080075741,
0.2144202441,
-0.5713492036,
0.3005771041,
0.311390996,
-0.3892307878,
-0.885985136,
0.8325443864,
-0.3227151632,
-0.5392805934,
-0.4949684143,
-0.3816257417,
-0.0838043764,
0.1771765798,
-0.0027798226,
0.1634727269,
-0.2775580585,
-0.0444554351,
0.4642295241,
-0.4357309043,
0.3414720595,
0.9134976268,
-0.3532150686,
-0.2392605394,
0.8954262137,
0.3328921199,
-0.0410244167,
0.1033082306,
0.1989610344,
-0.5048106313,
-0.7895398736,
-0.6168801188,
0.029519422,
-1.068947196,
0.1505276561,
-0.3137412965,
0.0043758834,
-0.3372645974,
-0.3175444603,
-0.1282554567,
-0.9152873158,
0.3310828507,
-0.2851912975,
-0.0538513176,
0.6269356608,
-0.3572060466,
0.1618482918,
-0.3380182981,
0.2227416784,
0.0324355103,
0.7402986884,
-0.1815913022,
-0.7695779204,
-0.307069689,
-0.0308075976,
0.0716149956,
-0.4417382777,
0.105069533,
-0.0459596515,
0.7451232672,
0.6485482454,
0.1596826017,
0.7067826986,
-0.7402791381,
0.6350961328,
0.4101906419,
-0.9710375071,
0.6613060832,
-0.2187703848,
-0.03766305,
0.6890762448,
0.1641431004,
-0.1263628006,
-0.387427479,
-0.7376796603,
-0.7712802291,
1.0095462799,
-0.0591311269,
-0.1060663611,
0.4547023177,
0.4054536521,
0.7264304161,
0.2636915743,
-1.0180435181,
-0.057419043,
-0.2391297221,
0.1785878241,
-0.1313158274,
-0.2356472313,
-0.2154933065,
-0.1663713306,
0.7127154469,
-0.0377280861,
0.1293476373,
-0.1110956445,
-0.2608043551,
0.0822274089,
0.5736325383,
0.4977192581,
1.1400651932,
-0.3851685524,
-0.1165813729,
0.1928491145,
0.1532070935,
-0.1443294287,
0.5564702749,
-0.1311567873,
0.1300666332,
0.5676341653,
0.7163271904,
0.0210512485,
-0.7928490043,
0.6331875324,
-0.2473369539,
-0.576130867,
-0.5543883443,
0.0481437631,
-0.1458210796,
0.4527586699,
0.1541159749,
0.0868506953,
0.599432826,
-0.5133056641,
0.0631421506,
0.2754909098,
-0.7806966901,
0.0453591757,
0.8642689586,
-0.1725939512,
0.0563310273,
0.044048097,
-0.0700970814,
-0.343146503,
0.6100429296,
0.0757843629,
0.4821826816,
0.0284424983,
0.2490594089,
0.2745875716,
0.1205800027,
-0.1507256329,
0.2521463931,
-0.0630293339,
-0.7248882055,
-0.4048061669,
-0.3362456262,
-0.2866156995,
-0.2033611387,
-1.1934803724,
-0.0040074596,
-0.2187934369,
-0.060580112,
0.406709224,
-0.2107223719,
-0.8018267155,
0.2176538259,
0.0834285021,
1.1180436611,
-0.8066891432,
0.716819346,
0.2556472421,
-0.3718518317,
-0.0953027457,
-0.1546062529,
-0.1055077091,
-1.0693064928,
0.6454247832,
0.3741901517,
-0.1329068989,
-0.6877228022,
-0.3226230145,
-0.1888514608,
0.7676582336,
0.8069037199,
-0.6801457405,
0.1147622243,
0.1850560606,
0.5443575978,
-0.3165685534,
0.3095566928,
0.6147369742,
0.8907225728,
-0.0518090166,
-0.7316917181,
0.0427896567,
-0.2423952967,
0.010407947,
-0.1377401948,
-0.2241569757,
0.2717296183,
-0.5230531693,
-0.1868707687,
0.0073506851,
0.4442785978,
0.1700917333,
0.6036438346,
0.6747561693,
0.6234084964,
0.6794764996,
-0.3866002858,
1.4784353971,
-0.3912246823,
0.0927434936,
1.3182150126,
-0.4543361664,
0.7131379247,
0.6350045204,
-0.3259494901,
0.7299947143,
0.7427712679,
-0.0429680049,
0.5865744948,
0.4341192245,
0.0374557152,
-0.409735918,
-0.3606693745,
-0.4069634974,
0.330068469,
0.0409096591,
-0.5410573483,
-0.1892311722,
0.0426295698,
-0.0284064263,
0.4046368897,
-0.4463254511,
0.6244747639,
-0.171539247,
-0.7001894712,
0.224488914,
0.1684094816,
0.1740777642,
-0.4493523538,
-0.0196603704,
-0.0994610116,
0.2039063871,
-0.2221640795,
-0.9729629755,
0.1231315583,
-0.2382815778,
-0.5096919537,
-0.4844774604,
0.4364145994,
-0.010091451,
-0.6994600296,
0.7056471109,
0.6535342336,
0.2218031585,
0.1795724779,
-1.1779308319,
-0.2384005189,
0.0121973688,
-0.0565726832,
0.6361885071,
0.6934422255,
-0.0872398764,
0.7350504398,
0.3566553891,
0.0833604112,
-0.2843202055,
0.5505101085,
0.7856162786,
-0.6078976989,
-0.538400352,
-0.7898673415,
0.6960783601,
-0.1019102409,
0.146985054,
0.4959279597,
0.5937249064,
0.7744105458,
0.1425815821,
0.9930535555,
0.0564247258,
0.7708129287,
-0.7847829461,
0.6981622577,
-0.6241201162,
0.3700762093,
-0.0769662708,
-0.462457329,
-0.2605627477,
0.5923358202,
-0.3581388593,
0.2448091805,
0.4956822097,
0.4481442273,
-0.1168596968,
0.2467985451,
0.4123978615,
0.1916377246,
0.0361108221,
0.573462069,
0.7236737609,
-0.1453983337,
0.5598319769,
-0.2418827564,
-0.1373103559,
-0.2737360895,
-1.1813212633,
-0.7441860437,
-0.0705228001,
-0.0409087464,
-0.3936593235,
0.2488185316,
0.0780729726,
0.619759798,
-1.1651735306,
-0.2764475048,
-0.0346026346,
0.4496639669,
-0.2487596273,
-0.2222254723,
0.356474191,
-0.2376308441,
-0.4805638492,
0.3726093173,
0.1674435735,
-0.0383430086,
-0.11119169,
-0.2899765968,
0.0221736226,
-0.1376242191,
0.4793686867,
0.1912825406,
-1.0199801922,
-0.148074314,
-0.694273293,
0.5088618994,
0.1294911355,
0.6825482249,
-0.5837248564,
0.9648400545,
0.1691243798,
0.2359773368,
0.4461159706,
-0.231901139,
0.9999151826,
-0.2307879031,
0.2710436285,
0.0094110677,
0.9969322085,
0.1383352578,
-0.1490563005,
0.6774579883,
-0.058953844,
-0.1818838865,
-0.8667179942,
0.2873859406,
-0.6664635539,
-0.6288941503,
0.4795394838,
-0.5786116719,
-0.0265701208,
-0.2737270296,
0.0319344178,
-0.1558278501,
-0.5071586967,
0.6037731171,
1.0562949181,
-0.0917317644,
-0.0455343239,
-1.0965595245,
0.401468426,
0.3456951082,
-0.4860140085,
0.1262613088,
0.5726043582,
0.1587816775,
0.0783152208,
0.2712877095,
-0.2866091132,
0.4940459132,
-0.2948119938,
0.0267025661,
-0.0211365726,
-0.0796030611,
-0.6666138768,
0.4261207581,
-0.0054662097,
0.4712258577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17011v1
|
DiffuCOMET: Contextual Commonsense Knowledge Diffusion
| 2024-02-26T20:35:34 | 2024-02-26T20:35:34 |
Silin Gao, Mete Ismayilzada, Mengjie Zhao, Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inferring contextually-relevant and diverse commonsense to understand
narratives remains challenging for knowledge models. In this work, we develop a
series of knowledge models, DiffuCOMET, that leverage diffusion to learn to
reconstruct the implicit semantic connections between narrative contexts and
relevant commonsense knowledge. Across multiple diffusion steps, our method
progressively refines a representation of commonsense facts that is anchored to
a narrative, producing contextually-relevant and diverse commonsense inferences
for an input context. To evaluate DiffuCOMET, we introduce new metrics for
commonsense inference that more closely measure knowledge diversity and
contextual relevance. Our results on two different benchmarks, ComFact and
WebNLG+, show that knowledge generated by DiffuCOMET achieves a better
trade-off between commonsense diversity, contextual relevance and alignment to
known gold references, compared to baseline knowledge models.
|
[
-0.1564112902,
-0.5556231141,
0.7259684801,
-0.1511144042,
-0.1161640659,
0.0013358175,
0.230454728,
-0.2841586173,
-0.2206113935,
0.0334455818,
-0.6906169653,
-0.3193215728,
-0.8374921679,
-0.1166966334,
-0.5450602174,
1.1739405394,
0.1240242049,
-0.1082784981,
-0.4303229451,
-0.3643004,
-0.2916116118,
0.0161787029,
-0.1668644696,
-0.4629561603,
0.5971775055,
0.1701962948,
0.6656503677,
0.3350058496,
0.0961483717,
0.2894916832,
-0.4616781771,
0.1703250706,
-0.7880099416,
0.1727667749,
-0.6139830947,
-0.129552722,
0.0990265384,
0.0704573318,
0.3167232275,
1.1481294632,
-0.330290854,
0.2334973812,
0.1943707317,
0.7016645074,
-0.634326756,
-0.2236077487,
-0.4732462764,
-0.1261294335,
-0.0198749453,
0.2906515598,
-0.1384920627,
-0.5798499584,
0.646081686,
-1.0457917452,
0.4888772964,
-0.099524267,
0.4871167839,
0.4505352974,
-0.8346596956,
-0.5255816579,
-0.5040803552,
0.6751385331,
-0.5536375046,
0.2947727442,
0.2232952863,
0.3039392531,
0.0957667157,
-1.129852891,
-0.6933808327,
-0.217504859,
-0.4228382409,
0.2305499613,
-0.4107071161,
-0.4463473856,
0.1128652319,
0.333678335,
-0.491607368,
-0.2514733374,
-0.3497210741,
-0.0224474501,
0.4198064208,
0.1052373499,
0.3203759789,
-0.0844175592,
-0.7667521238,
0.0108356746,
-0.4221304357,
-0.367323041,
0.3962384462,
-0.2613447607,
-0.1273713857,
0.1687355936,
-0.3295970857,
0.6941225529,
0.1806280017,
-0.390489012,
0.4377309382,
-0.3636366129,
0.0342741236,
0.1662573963,
0.3274912834,
0.5291350484,
-0.1725288481,
-0.1497345716,
0.0576304421,
-0.1617686599,
0.134475112,
-0.5207052231,
-0.2476571053,
0.0071543804,
-0.3882369697,
-0.1161945388,
-0.006700465,
-0.7919756174,
-0.5671186447,
-0.3381933272,
0.4796005487,
-0.5408653021,
-0.624581337,
0.2393783778,
-0.9503920674,
-0.0379940271,
0.7685797811,
-0.7019125223,
0.1714213341,
0.5357512832,
0.9763302803,
-0.5238813758,
-0.2877141237,
-0.1804858595,
0.3079709411,
-0.0268826559,
0.7789689302,
-0.3296935856,
-0.192369774,
0.0003353569,
-0.1539065689,
-0.159539029,
-0.559391737,
0.3960522413,
-0.6265286803,
0.2000892311,
-0.6206901073,
-0.9185746312,
-0.4702121317,
0.293718487,
-0.8350820541,
0.6471152306,
0.3462481499,
-0.8851454854,
0.696280241,
-0.8732916117,
-0.493067354,
0.1282309741,
0.4120931625,
0.0753757209,
0.0591808036,
-0.0160888508,
0.3723353744,
0.15502204,
0.3410363793,
-0.3278589249,
-0.1488599181,
0.1552015841,
-0.646353364,
0.8428179622,
0.3879152834,
-0.1197506562,
-0.4238995314,
-0.4874137342,
-0.9279760122,
0.0205596928,
-0.0501893796,
-0.7126905322,
-0.1723380834,
-0.0183603372,
-0.1371341348,
0.0635306537,
-0.3579834998,
0.184880659,
0.1377966851,
0.4870541096,
0.4208752513,
0.2079049945,
0.736497879,
-0.5671329498,
0.1984477341,
0.371538192,
0.1024978757,
0.0537077971,
-0.5882994533,
-0.1966878474,
-0.1877972782,
0.0760628581,
0.4225070775,
-0.7650268078,
-0.2200917602,
-0.1213973686,
-0.4339807332,
-0.144935742,
0.1121524274,
-0.0162806865,
1.0375287533,
0.5096970797,
0.0566673875,
-0.061292395,
-0.6177529097,
-0.3016476333,
-0.0670678988,
-0.0036120845,
0.1298497468,
0.6970978379,
-0.2685888708,
1.0241143703,
-0.8465889692,
-0.066834718,
-0.2078978419,
0.4669868052,
0.1539498717,
0.3065805435,
0.6777415276,
-1.2541482449,
-0.3269371688,
-0.1038216054,
-0.5799561143,
-0.1544597447,
-0.1463397145,
-0.1564265341,
-0.3719057441,
0.5125992894,
-0.5295655131,
0.35376665,
0.5107327104,
-0.5964707732,
0.4922807515,
0.0105369445,
0.5114923716,
-1.0224114656,
0.0906750709,
-0.1921316683,
-0.2736491561,
-0.5566421747,
-0.1810969412,
-0.0230390728,
0.392059207,
-0.808701098,
0.9470232129,
-0.3091394305,
-0.0502546877,
0.2319337428,
0.6034091115,
0.2709328532,
0.1331529766,
0.1085734293,
0.5047386289,
0.2718789577,
-0.6820918918,
0.3666256666,
0.4132398367,
-0.5104219317,
0.955257833,
-0.3096932471,
-0.3459916413,
-0.1159718186,
0.298186779,
-1.3796960115,
-0.2032855004,
-0.0419782847,
-0.2853729725,
-0.1355869323,
-0.6008549333,
-0.511251092,
-0.0464865938,
-0.0695672706,
0.7183374763,
0.5959008932,
-0.8154630065,
0.4478678107,
0.0474309884,
-0.142853111,
-0.5692591071,
-0.7677888274,
-0.3370288908,
-0.6008785367,
-0.6104229093,
0.3922259212,
-0.1409484893,
-0.5282582641,
0.2107239366,
-0.1600124836,
-0.3726101816,
0.185637027,
-0.0285359994,
-0.1001241431,
-0.1426811218,
0.5072003603,
0.6013576984,
0.0444284715,
-0.2021813542,
-0.4000808001,
0.0980186686,
0.244630903,
-0.5687084198,
-0.0869040787,
0.2354381233,
0.4648259282,
0.100150153,
0.7083413601,
0.9025653601,
-0.0396149531,
-0.119142592,
-0.5501409173,
-0.1232676357,
-0.3910726607,
0.1894736886,
-0.0756003559,
-0.9513291121,
0.6180826426,
-0.6593065858,
0.324872911,
0.4761364162,
0.3197912574,
-0.2453521043,
0.2085572034,
0.1735866219,
0.3518561423,
0.3051565289,
-0.2767173648,
-0.1577898264,
-0.824201107,
-0.0856820494,
0.009895524,
-0.3515573442,
-0.2382760644,
-0.5007176399,
0.1635119468,
0.3819720149,
-0.2778943181,
0.0930680633,
-0.252671212,
0.5913240314,
0.444591701,
0.2090211809,
0.9059764147,
-0.1749049574,
-0.1055694073,
0.2372989953,
-0.7705539465,
-0.4096518457,
0.7887676358,
0.1295176446,
0.5690133572,
0.7918434143,
0.8245756626,
0.6037698388,
0.4629097879,
-0.340490967,
0.0144295162,
-0.2661311924,
-0.6857428551,
-0.271075964,
-0.4303888977,
-0.9269101024,
0.3441461623,
-0.0788885504,
-0.619259119,
0.1843364686,
0.1548208594,
-0.533385098,
0.3500644267,
-0.9217710495,
0.8576047421,
0.2428693473,
-0.5500307679,
-0.2130997628,
-0.6047924161,
0.7041678429,
0.0714505762,
0.4155655205,
-0.1225441396,
-0.1067210361,
0.6305423975,
-0.2548723817,
0.9454975128,
-0.1049590632,
-0.0865512788,
0.3547460437,
0.4159309268,
0.105016835,
0.5172327757,
-0.0132037168,
0.2669912875,
0.1154437214,
-0.4564021528,
-0.6219422817,
0.5598708391,
-0.561101675,
-0.452404052,
-0.367506355,
-0.596843183,
0.0121506481,
0.1140330732,
0.3241507709,
0.3526885509,
-0.4133313894,
0.0014546238,
0.8833454847,
-0.1940694749,
0.4861132503,
0.5254036188,
0.1305113435,
-0.1837123334,
0.4365803003,
-0.0387621559,
0.6116499305,
0.3855862021,
0.4422203004,
-0.6518051028,
-0.367133975,
-0.4997116327,
0.0756736398,
-0.9159387946,
-0.3209232092,
-0.6818601489,
0.0592862032,
-0.289174974,
-0.4247042239,
-0.2395009845,
-0.5140430331,
-0.2781767547,
-0.3487081826,
0.8071386814,
0.9873595238,
-0.5644314885,
0.2346572429,
-0.6652134061,
0.4171548486,
0.5953361988,
0.1447540671,
0.1901215315,
-0.6048523784,
-0.0813682899,
0.0334858336,
-0.2981389165,
-1.0847017765,
0.1042093933,
0.0745614544,
0.8137615323,
0.4161149859,
0.3182548285,
0.5541936159,
-0.3132516146,
0.9900794625,
0.2872335315,
-0.8055220246,
0.4595506489,
-0.4681413472,
0.5307150483,
0.6529659033,
0.6278492808,
-0.5155737996,
-0.2305957824,
-0.7240511775,
-0.8501816988,
0.2924407423,
0.3197985291,
0.2483882159,
-0.210083127,
0.2315918356,
0.6663652658,
0.2070951462,
-0.6128129959,
-0.2546731532,
-0.398686409,
-0.3234913945,
0.1740075499,
-0.118581973,
-0.2829627097,
-0.2590684295,
0.2597463727,
0.0266806856,
-0.2480628937,
0.2949461937,
-0.6155599356,
0.5521780849,
0.0763229504,
0.6276267767,
0.8610299826,
-0.0676912814,
0.2978051305,
0.4377799332,
-0.7394443154,
0.0934242904,
0.1569964886,
-0.2070859075,
0.08843752,
0.7338351607,
0.4362344444,
0.4622916579,
-0.4832570851,
0.6565065384,
-0.1226095408,
-0.4336612821,
0.0349496044,
0.1475436836,
0.5731860995,
0.62765944,
0.4130859375,
0.1426744312,
0.6161448956,
-0.2624365389,
0.6076830029,
0.0219470467,
-0.1902036965,
0.192060709,
0.3504957855,
0.4255309105,
0.2774502635,
0.5840196013,
-0.441429019,
-0.3547616601,
0.4652661085,
0.1579164714,
0.5245060921,
-0.1305555701,
0.5443630815,
0.5950545669,
0.0096720411,
-0.370428592,
-0.4394694567,
-0.4957690537,
-0.7819961905,
-0.1241335422,
-0.5064716339,
-0.1858270317,
-0.2278351039,
-0.6442108154,
-0.1833457947,
-0.0294949058,
-0.0226293895,
-0.122877568,
-0.2114983946,
-0.6979396343,
-0.0254833475,
-0.0560040548,
0.8251954913,
-1.0422145128,
0.5489549041,
0.2660847902,
-0.4680534005,
-0.3559790254,
0.146827817,
0.3248812258,
-0.5548784137,
0.9022929668,
-0.0996602625,
-0.0290857796,
-0.0252506472,
-0.1573771685,
-0.8638010025,
1.5977374315,
0.2989769578,
-0.6386693716,
0.2882864773,
-0.1015997157,
0.2250056565,
-0.2808855176,
0.4218782187,
0.555457592,
0.4747064412,
0.6649292111,
-0.6127568483,
0.0196993239,
0.1609232128,
-0.101377584,
-0.0564836599,
-0.3283012509,
0.6281943321,
-0.3667408228,
-0.3351941109,
-0.0632168502,
0.5006548762,
0.3582921922,
0.6782692671,
0.5694298744,
0.7810093164,
0.9082421064,
-0.0259898137,
0.6358291507,
0.1775300205,
0.3856199682,
1.4243110418,
-0.1607367098,
0.6022439599,
0.4887010455,
-0.0798380896,
0.8619096875,
0.5885082483,
-0.0190245192,
0.7614588737,
0.0340307802,
-0.4442201853,
-0.0583136417,
0.0476701409,
-0.3582824171,
0.1834742427,
0.1146340519,
-0.2184043527,
-0.6496551633,
-0.0255541652,
0.0068894722,
0.1449908167,
-0.1096792668,
0.9715369344,
-0.0240427423,
-0.6461662054,
0.1940324455,
-0.6174305677,
0.662645936,
-0.549811244,
-0.4074847996,
-0.7663481236,
-0.0427317172,
-0.1642150879,
-1.0595222712,
0.392254442,
-0.3292179704,
-0.2503291667,
-0.2305541188,
0.4944219887,
-0.5984914303,
-0.2344412804,
0.2851002514,
0.6597789526,
-0.0084956111,
0.054382354,
-0.6763039827,
-0.2856432199,
-0.0365549773,
-0.18868801,
0.2852210701,
0.888674438,
0.275028199,
0.4986024797,
0.6523323059,
-0.3154916167,
0.0766939521,
0.1490420401,
0.6620016098,
-0.3264603913,
-0.5103474259,
-0.9237151742,
0.9082167745,
-0.4125777185,
-0.4925929904,
0.6199272871,
0.3064019978,
0.7458754778,
-0.1784493923,
0.6476877332,
-0.0623359494,
0.4554678798,
-0.5672640204,
1.0019601583,
-0.7456905246,
0.3492563367,
-0.4393190444,
-0.617845118,
0.0610987321,
0.5473483205,
-0.1568939388,
0.0733761638,
0.5782281756,
0.5448866487,
-0.4395943284,
-0.0083806505,
0.4098654687,
0.1098226979,
0.0187364724,
0.4835733473,
1.095847249,
-0.3294468522,
0.2726230025,
-0.0015993578,
-0.4116008878,
-0.1276603788,
-1.1023622751,
-0.5891911983,
-0.8782995939,
-0.5270153284,
-0.0348700099,
0.1178096086,
0.2236132175,
0.7412742972,
-0.2868198156,
0.0426655971,
-0.1473018527,
0.5856371522,
-0.3455889821,
-0.3001476228,
0.2707463801,
-0.2059627473,
-0.3398587108,
-0.0268607289,
0.062293686,
0.1646755636,
-0.1241838709,
-0.1819375455,
-0.4377908707,
0.1719633192,
0.7750076056,
-0.1789536476,
-0.6949558854,
0.0020337177,
-0.2433713377,
0.171017915,
-0.2283830345,
0.7245498896,
-0.8598956466,
0.2246102691,
0.580036819,
0.389341563,
0.7322679162,
-0.0112851104,
0.4644619823,
-0.6817504764,
0.0804909095,
0.1353499442,
0.3690069616,
0.4164877832,
-0.4192614853,
0.5732390881,
0.4808406532,
-0.2844776511,
-0.4637698531,
0.5125468969,
-0.9757388234,
-0.7973518968,
1.3320817947,
-0.2532206476,
0.0052000736,
-0.5537070036,
-0.012475729,
0.1547312587,
-0.5343205333,
0.6198214889,
0.5809707046,
-0.0845404714,
-0.3572471738,
-0.4841400683,
0.7788023949,
-0.0682841688,
-0.737942636,
0.301417619,
0.6367955804,
0.7431969047,
0.2369790971,
0.465873152,
-0.0617770851,
0.3360953033,
0.383666575,
-0.4445848167,
-0.0666133687,
0.060510993,
0.0998070538,
0.1348181218,
-0.1656672806,
0.2031915933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17010v1
|
Can Large Language Models Recall Reference Location Like Humans?
| 2024-02-26T20:35:32 | 2024-02-26T20:35:32 |
Ye Wang, Xinrun Xu, Rui Xie, Wenxin Hu, Wei Ye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When completing knowledge-intensive tasks, humans sometimes need not just an
answer but also a corresponding reference passage for auxiliary reading.
Previous methods required obtaining pre-segmented article chunks through
additional retrieval models. This paper explores leveraging the parameterized
knowledge stored during the pre-training phase of large language models (LLMs)
to independently recall reference passage from any starting position. We
propose a two-stage framework that simulates the scenario of humans recalling
easily forgotten references. Initially, the LLM is prompted to recall document
title identifiers to obtain a coarse-grained document set. Then, based on the
acquired coarse-grained document set, it recalls fine-grained passage. In the
two-stage recall process, we use constrained decoding to ensure that content
outside of the stored documents is not generated. To increase speed, we only
recall a short prefix in the second stage, then locate its position to retrieve
a complete passage. Experiments on KILT knowledge-sensitive tasks have verified
that LLMs can independently recall reference passage location in various task
forms, and the obtained reference significantly assist downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.0655475184,
-0.4294850528,
0.8397945166,
-0.0877787471,
-0.3066726625,
-0.3069075942,
-0.2393087447,
-0.5055689216,
0.0087597473,
0.7154256701,
-0.4519601762,
-0.2685835361,
-0.4894943237,
0.075747557,
-0.4732270241,
0.7074658275,
-0.0310925413,
-0.2175375074,
-0.2850754261,
0.1602374166,
-0.1624592841,
-0.6762204766,
-0.8108202219,
-0.4989976287,
0.8467532396,
0.3891230226,
0.3549712002,
0.8074250817,
0.2358067185,
0.2483802587,
0.0323017463,
0.1485314965,
-0.3776431084,
0.2254115641,
-0.4752038121,
-0.6568390131,
-0.0982825607,
-0.036052499,
0.876103878,
0.5936747789,
-0.2097969055,
-0.1146100909,
0.1005823165,
0.5256640315,
-0.5836893916,
0.1533895284,
-0.9269914031,
-0.1678194553,
-0.1113694683,
-0.3557827175,
-0.5610111356,
-0.1136121005,
0.1755853444,
-0.5174697638,
0.4897240996,
0.1429958642,
0.8710954189,
0.1676557809,
-0.5074816942,
-0.3576534688,
-0.7419718504,
0.5705464482,
-0.5176032186,
0.6027056575,
0.9527271986,
-0.0584337972,
-0.0384308174,
-0.6793430448,
-0.5314395428,
-0.2388980091,
-0.3417774737,
-0.3153352737,
0.433074683,
-0.1680447161,
0.2003515363,
-0.28636989,
-0.173793003,
-0.0648789704,
-0.5160678029,
-0.2505807579,
0.3902540505,
-0.0663046762,
-0.0168477856,
-0.2408860624,
-0.269955337,
-0.3259227276,
-0.8601785898,
0.0510718711,
0.1612069607,
0.3693802357,
0.1016845405,
0.16972664,
-0.1747523993,
0.547385931,
0.2822695374,
-0.2774325013,
0.1826992184,
-0.3124530315,
0.1127437055,
-0.073164314,
0.6212610602,
-0.2374506891,
0.3167166114,
-0.43900913,
-0.2906264365,
-0.7779368758,
0.6102759242,
-0.5981303453,
-0.2589437068,
-0.2331363112,
-0.1997237504,
0.2768650651,
0.010723019,
-0.2979217172,
-0.4772964418,
-0.4307707548,
0.3028580248,
-0.5464069247,
0.0242395382,
-0.0159960445,
0.069895491,
0.2437926084,
0.3340599537,
-1.1297249794,
0.1059526876,
0.6187852025,
0.5301734805,
-0.0663981289,
-0.6458901763,
-0.5540751815,
0.6923259497,
-0.2449279577,
0.7082184553,
-0.7253639698,
-0.3558955491,
-0.0477502756,
0.0424140655,
-0.1939634681,
-0.5264089108,
0.5022625923,
-1.0162882805,
-0.1695478112,
-0.5625754595,
-0.4146841466,
-0.2445785254,
0.4256699979,
-0.6159712076,
0.935308814,
-0.0967062041,
-0.7856794,
0.1600779295,
0.0849030092,
-0.4713520706,
-0.3668300807,
-0.3518481255,
-0.1750914752,
0.0484672152,
0.1518057734,
0.4276384115,
-0.2750264406,
0.1758498549,
-0.095177941,
-0.3080568314,
0.0831020921,
-0.287863791,
0.3236857355,
-0.1369049549,
-0.0292124078,
-0.199868843,
-0.7227557302,
-0.0369279049,
-0.0242249742,
-0.7021124363,
-0.919493258,
0.2104511708,
-0.4677217305,
0.4020097554,
0.3535985947,
-0.3990678191,
0.1058763191,
0.0588369966,
0.1293586344,
0.5265210271,
0.2533135712,
0.5917339325,
-0.212574333,
0.2139329612,
0.1607231349,
-0.273201406,
-0.3357886374,
0.1286512613,
-1.0851593018,
0.1114527732,
0.1524602473,
0.4865650237,
-0.8754279613,
0.2615152001,
-0.3480892479,
-0.2201447785,
-0.104800649,
0.4282362759,
0.5270323157,
0.5567836761,
0.232575044,
-0.0259003397,
-0.4440670907,
-0.8202433586,
0.1655668318,
-0.4307597876,
-0.2738514245,
0.2786967754,
0.4446828365,
0.1450942308,
0.7818937302,
-0.532900095,
-0.2345039994,
-0.0765722394,
0.2347536385,
0.0754953846,
0.5609276891,
0.1509048492,
-0.8251197338,
-0.1128335744,
-0.2571475804,
-0.697267592,
-0.0478163622,
-0.3109353185,
-0.3481568098,
-0.0690447241,
1.0405378342,
-0.706510067,
-0.0330446847,
0.1574845463,
-0.3594921231,
0.5329746008,
-0.6439698339,
-0.0493191853,
-1.0177367926,
0.3625245392,
-0.2764903009,
-0.2434402257,
-0.4145389199,
0.0234852061,
0.5107316375,
0.2256524265,
-0.1442450136,
0.5885042548,
-0.7946129441,
-0.0229960587,
-0.3655921519,
0.211103946,
0.1683182418,
0.5415565372,
0.5499304533,
0.726054132,
0.1075771153,
-0.8107139468,
-0.2760825455,
0.2666279078,
-0.3368244469,
0.4729901254,
-0.3810678422,
0.5120446682,
-0.4548647106,
0.4655783474,
-0.702069521,
-0.1081468984,
-0.1267444044,
-0.14583157,
0.539337337,
-0.0960387811,
-0.6341562271,
-0.2728307247,
0.1074089259,
0.4995296597,
0.3258322477,
-0.131513834,
0.4994138777,
0.3303780556,
-0.5850088,
-0.5779868364,
-0.2492609769,
-0.1656503528,
-0.0242034793,
-0.1575770229,
0.0544776358,
0.1797386855,
0.1264724135,
-0.1838822216,
-0.113686651,
-0.3789867759,
-0.0480132215,
0.2155741453,
0.2019703537,
0.1630765498,
0.4136419594,
-0.2517746091,
-0.0854410455,
0.063712053,
-0.537740767,
0.5184401274,
0.3183930218,
-0.4564443827,
-0.0789132863,
0.4599023461,
0.5234827399,
-0.3459788263,
0.6006089449,
0.5677976012,
-0.4576729536,
0.0067606503,
-0.9121900797,
-0.4281400442,
-0.4329403341,
0.6540163755,
-0.4190576077,
-0.7311934829,
0.4283026755,
0.2123244256,
-0.0172494743,
0.0822976977,
0.2595562041,
-0.2034225166,
0.4938593209,
0.683050096,
-0.2923271656,
0.4660170674,
-0.0315457955,
0.0165509749,
-0.9734708071,
-0.5187952518,
-0.7603442669,
-0.3744832277,
0.2276578993,
-0.7423997521,
0.4583852589,
0.6219390631,
-0.2785964608,
0.3684657216,
0.1456158459,
0.6601904035,
0.9134231806,
0.3171439469,
0.4197785258,
-0.0110474266,
-0.5871853232,
0.0649572536,
-0.6307318211,
-0.3284831941,
0.8629460931,
0.145593673,
0.7172842622,
-0.319904089,
0.8451973796,
-0.1777950078,
0.2405223548,
-0.4462704659,
0.6125076413,
-0.0266280007,
-0.7640070319,
-0.5077181458,
-0.2370281368,
-0.855343461,
0.2357830405,
0.0149778081,
-0.9310430288,
0.1530350745,
0.1410074532,
-0.5460463166,
0.3389680088,
-0.4345821738,
0.4011012614,
-0.0408532247,
-0.5643627048,
-0.2729652524,
-0.8279513121,
0.216629535,
-0.3459526598,
0.2510909438,
-0.017608894,
-0.0167133994,
0.6722382307,
-0.1744542271,
0.9877200723,
-0.2877624333,
-0.1262610555,
0.4092642069,
0.1580867618,
0.8027807474,
-0.0692951903,
-0.3154710233,
-0.2154392004,
-0.0711597577,
-0.3014362156,
-0.4951606393,
0.6273924708,
-0.6731669307,
-0.6755206585,
-0.0948689803,
-0.6897714734,
-0.4510400891,
0.3817991018,
0.096977666,
0.3338488042,
0.0075288815,
0.213700965,
0.7986052632,
0.0685398877,
0.5966974497,
0.9510007501,
0.122143425,
-0.088614814,
0.6755273342,
0.0419593155,
0.2137089521,
0.7800810933,
-0.0305046849,
-0.506847918,
-0.6726751924,
-0.2551480532,
0.4195233881,
-0.699667275,
-0.1475913674,
-0.7530450821,
-0.2170087844,
-0.2229075134,
-0.187527582,
-0.4551461041,
-0.0517390966,
-0.1964704394,
-0.1137603372,
0.0019545178,
0.6348477602,
-0.087789163,
0.1653499454,
-1.1179177761,
0.2098088115,
0.4110039473,
0.2303554863,
0.3616177142,
-0.467582047,
-0.3619447351,
0.0202389192,
-0.2052982152,
-0.3739353418,
0.3084265888,
0.1711056381,
0.5450785756,
0.4524351656,
0.0466326438,
0.6008726358,
-0.7659007907,
0.4762631357,
0.0952767506,
-0.4342462718,
0.2547314167,
-0.4162264168,
0.6564204693,
0.8736192584,
0.5132871866,
-0.6245106459,
-0.1965473443,
-0.2202516496,
-0.8546190858,
0.7940849066,
-0.0003365533,
0.0025550788,
-0.256690681,
0.7545983195,
0.1213706136,
0.0290583707,
-0.6800636053,
0.2026098073,
0.3526729345,
-0.0171572436,
-0.2631136477,
-0.4251620173,
-0.0684695914,
-0.175755918,
0.6473956108,
0.0076554194,
0.1117308214,
0.4524990022,
-0.2873702943,
0.0695930123,
0.3067674339,
0.3034093082,
0.6664733887,
-0.2104703784,
0.5346179008,
0.179267928,
-0.5917429924,
0.3713324666,
0.1352564991,
-0.4782450199,
-0.0793437958,
0.4555018246,
0.668129921,
0.6754244566,
-0.6065324545,
0.3664191067,
0.27696684,
0.0651272982,
-0.4937384725,
-0.0169217419,
0.489551127,
0.5135041475,
0.5901587605,
-0.2132049203,
-0.1638157517,
-0.5164797902,
0.4105225503,
0.236995399,
-0.4442571104,
-0.3728310764,
0.7609502077,
0.1387417167,
-0.222524628,
0.865922153,
-0.2449106425,
-0.3593028486,
0.4072141945,
0.7065069675,
0.5884939432,
-0.2565182447,
0.0608380735,
0.5031684637,
0.0235213898,
-0.4320800006,
0.1616308689,
-0.2149194777,
-0.7455637455,
-0.26896438,
-0.9080988169,
0.0818526372,
-0.0646370649,
-0.5722255707,
0.139691323,
-0.2906945348,
0.0203671865,
-0.3524485528,
-0.203336671,
-0.850196898,
0.224489972,
0.4275603294,
0.9461218715,
-0.5396717191,
1.3802889585,
0.5323563814,
-0.2174086869,
-1.1030372381,
0.2156447172,
-0.1367888153,
-0.90896523,
0.6881687641,
-0.0090628499,
-0.3631979823,
0.0765530691,
-0.2790026963,
-1.1205222607,
1.2814577818,
0.1666809767,
-0.6481246352,
-0.7993270755,
0.042100057,
0.421716243,
-0.1769263148,
0.2715710402,
0.6706447005,
0.2230918854,
0.4570465684,
-0.9907624125,
0.1977050453,
-0.0658832043,
0.0576606654,
0.230047971,
-0.6116551161,
0.9182502031,
-0.3657229245,
-0.0050300453,
0.1455015987,
0.466321826,
0.3307366371,
-0.0081744362,
0.6121755838,
0.4514288604,
0.7755007148,
0.373711288,
1.1334154606,
-0.1895733327,
0.1457543373,
1.5407831669,
-0.1573899239,
1.2618485689,
0.6087949276,
-0.0025340177,
0.4755236506,
0.2598322332,
0.5468113422,
0.9047054648,
-0.0292502381,
-0.3593097925,
-0.5475001931,
-0.0240587126,
-0.1671834439,
0.485450089,
0.3781609237,
-0.639539659,
-0.3856166601,
0.0112511367,
0.2014426589,
-0.0852519125,
-0.3706849515,
0.8076791167,
0.3253289759,
-1.025377512,
0.6435257196,
-0.0633920208,
0.3470428288,
-1.0759612322,
0.109632805,
-0.1917680651,
0.2617558837,
0.2787922919,
-0.4805295467,
0.1473559588,
-0.3666536808,
-0.5377765298,
-0.3239158988,
0.6047152281,
-0.9235596061,
-0.4656777978,
0.1810521632,
0.3881927431,
0.1424533129,
-0.2595922351,
-0.1896569729,
-0.2018089145,
0.0655709356,
-0.3639593422,
0.5125027299,
0.486741513,
-0.3064745963,
0.7289262414,
0.3639884293,
-0.0647915155,
0.1401649266,
0.028056154,
0.7597095966,
-0.7646437883,
-0.6688606143,
-0.5966817737,
0.0810585618,
-0.0331043676,
-0.081487596,
0.427018702,
0.402536273,
0.8713175654,
-0.2543289065,
0.6598000526,
-0.024922464,
0.5777967572,
-0.7740129232,
0.7294747233,
-0.3635187447,
0.1855071783,
-0.0951433405,
-0.8586204052,
-0.0353975222,
0.522295475,
-0.4202179909,
-0.1438292414,
0.9349313974,
0.8020119667,
-0.2224349678,
-0.2420721501,
0.2326058596,
0.2363720685,
0.0913265198,
0.9647095799,
0.6805294752,
-0.0909219757,
0.8311716914,
-0.1389278322,
0.1395148933,
-0.1308826357,
-0.7519057989,
-0.8038827181,
-0.8298899531,
0.0482464321,
-0.1728885919,
0.1271458715,
0.8728721738,
0.913313508,
-0.64553231,
-0.1270936877,
0.1041211188,
-0.0720852464,
-0.0151183438,
-0.1231641024,
0.3491111398,
-0.4118614197,
-0.7492593527,
0.4513372481,
0.1973825544,
0.1065278277,
-0.1201725602,
-0.1145409793,
-0.4647039771,
-0.0986900032,
0.2927925289,
0.4112419784,
-0.6328793764,
-0.7499498129,
-0.0746492967,
-0.4370678067,
-0.0331149362,
1.1815321445,
-0.9038141966,
0.2568802238,
0.4442590475,
0.6127139926,
0.7740872502,
0.1688189656,
0.7081526518,
-1.0396571159,
0.4758362472,
0.1241905019,
0.4031322598,
0.2600452602,
-0.2879399061,
0.2820126116,
0.0078533599,
-0.3779619634,
-0.1468409896,
0.1950211227,
-0.7715913057,
-0.3499996364,
1.33017838,
-0.5085053444,
-0.0469414555,
-0.1825803667,
-0.2538723648,
0.2336610556,
-0.2452019453,
0.9618898034,
0.8611931205,
0.2134030014,
-0.2421598136,
-0.4718037248,
0.4024225175,
0.3172782362,
-0.6153107285,
0.0846213624,
0.6492387652,
0.6676308513,
0.1795386225,
0.9634678364,
-0.1343069822,
-0.0441939607,
0.0587659739,
-0.1353347003,
-0.1897502095,
-0.5889553428,
0.1209663302,
0.3930442929,
0.2370350808,
-0.0510719344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17008v1
|
Benchmarking LLMs on the Semantic Overlap Summarization Task
| 2024-02-26T20:33:50 | 2024-02-26T20:33:50 |
John Salvador, Naman Bansal, Mousumi Akter, Souvika Sarkar, Anupam Das, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Overlap Summarization (SOS) is a constrained multi-document
summarization task, where the constraint is to capture the common/overlapping
information between two alternative narratives. While recent advancements in
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved superior performance in numerous
summarization tasks, a benchmarking study of the SOS task using LLMs is yet to
be performed. As LLMs' responses are sensitive to slight variations in prompt
design, a major challenge in conducting such a benchmarking study is to
systematically explore a variety of prompts before drawing a reliable
conclusion. Fortunately, very recently, the TELeR taxonomy has been proposed
which can be used to design and explore various prompts for LLMs. Using this
TELeR taxonomy and 15 popular LLMs, this paper comprehensively evaluates LLMs
on the SOS Task, assessing their ability to summarize overlapping information
from multiple alternative narratives. For evaluation, we report
well-established metrics like ROUGE, BERTscore, and SEM-F1$ on two different
datasets of alternative narratives. We conclude the paper by analyzing the
strengths and limitations of various LLMs in terms of their capabilities in
capturing overlapping information The code and datasets used to conduct this
study are available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/llm_eval-E16D.
|
[
-0.4934343398,
-0.4098758101,
0.539057076,
0.1889758557,
-0.1592485905,
0.1510870308,
0.0194762908,
-0.5510968566,
0.2722074687,
0.2943660915,
-0.844438076,
-0.5665872693,
-0.8499859571,
0.5879437327,
-0.2870468199,
0.9567691684,
-0.424182415,
0.0332995206,
-0.4820489883,
-0.3694159389,
-0.3121094108,
-0.2115993947,
-0.0711419284,
-0.0228463057,
0.4539548457,
0.3534371853,
0.5197039247,
0.5345240235,
0.7257577181,
0.260991931,
-0.2525716126,
0.4280562401,
-0.6502879262,
0.2320420146,
-0.1499092132,
-0.3461920917,
-0.4145555794,
-0.131460458,
0.8848977089,
0.7254217267,
0.2887222767,
0.4138531089,
0.1691955775,
0.4134866893,
-0.7930509448,
-0.0864679217,
-0.2536941469,
0.1240906864,
-0.2469237149,
-0.0904981717,
0.0600685142,
-0.6706198454,
0.403598398,
-0.5505312085,
0.1674494743,
0.0047207759,
0.8746160865,
0.2997870445,
-0.4339068532,
-0.2100593895,
-0.5182833672,
0.7957018018,
-0.8660534024,
0.2564378679,
0.0031747166,
0.285977453,
-0.088692382,
-0.6430616379,
-0.4884286821,
-0.0952301845,
-0.120332025,
0.4611085653,
-0.4491342306,
-0.0885033831,
0.2751286328,
0.3568526506,
-0.618601799,
0.5243791938,
-0.35442397,
-0.1988871247,
0.4696571529,
0.9627501965,
0.0992705598,
-0.3678829968,
-0.7801468968,
0.0058063339,
-0.7340663075,
0.1950362772,
0.4068147242,
0.0239209253,
-0.0944773331,
0.6911224127,
-0.4994076788,
0.7318453789,
-0.5498731136,
-0.1249792725,
0.3782284558,
-0.5798410773,
-0.1012028903,
-0.0225699414,
0.9330969453,
0.9317214489,
0.0274450518,
-0.0317459218,
-0.0989355892,
0.0677870438,
-0.0144033274,
-0.4854758084,
0.5923339128,
0.1219458207,
-0.4803812206,
0.1681864709,
0.0415101983,
-0.804739356,
-0.4571255147,
-0.265481174,
0.2199936658,
-0.4356899858,
0.0250763316,
0.1825711429,
-0.6076887846,
0.2468135655,
0.2547889054,
-0.5345010161,
0.6870170236,
0.7011320591,
0.9393777251,
-0.5983781219,
-0.6405146718,
-0.5459617972,
0.1512011439,
-0.2887239158,
0.9515390396,
-0.4816302955,
-0.427282244,
0.0121121192,
-0.1893467009,
-0.2953232229,
-0.510828793,
0.5513483286,
-0.4657323956,
0.179547742,
-0.4121522903,
-1.0024436712,
-0.1165079996,
0.3165875971,
-0.6459389329,
1.2496488094,
0.1091938838,
-0.7451053262,
0.1941319257,
-0.2284040749,
-0.13852714,
-0.0487414673,
-0.426754266,
-0.1642298102,
0.1949759573,
-0.1136579663,
0.3891222775,
-0.6396764517,
0.2054869682,
-0.0444961786,
-0.4933597744,
0.1563356668,
-0.0347921103,
0.2289324254,
0.1389408559,
-0.1149250567,
0.3475021124,
-0.7629146576,
-0.0787105635,
-0.0060091261,
-0.0529462993,
-0.3686132729,
-0.3064422011,
-0.0338114537,
0.0487874374,
0.2898970842,
-0.4408425987,
0.0222622566,
-0.255753547,
0.0732129216,
0.5512408614,
-0.0402111784,
0.1145617738,
-0.7927168012,
0.7392169833,
-0.2923463285,
-0.1264234483,
-0.4495265186,
-0.2864024639,
-0.4579467177,
-0.3692848682,
0.3654500842,
0.5452316999,
-0.3810999095,
0.4536055624,
-0.5859556198,
-0.7191740274,
-0.3478389084,
-0.1200685203,
0.4356563389,
0.3044211864,
0.2614654303,
-0.4181835651,
-0.6122285724,
-0.8574975729,
-0.641902864,
0.2720791101,
-0.3867504597,
0.2580470145,
0.4774696827,
0.1747531295,
1.3150280714,
-0.5292046666,
-0.4931176007,
-0.372530371,
0.1946205646,
0.2984102368,
0.0378445722,
0.2252633125,
-0.4590236545,
-0.3781204522,
-0.4942862391,
-0.992299974,
-0.4119502306,
-0.0240685679,
0.4580133259,
0.0231504962,
0.7973322272,
-0.6526983976,
0.4624528587,
0.4317130148,
-0.1783058345,
0.8172385097,
-0.218588084,
0.1932013482,
-0.8573875427,
-0.0573763661,
-0.1239411011,
0.0197792314,
-0.6856219172,
-0.1245882958,
0.0710617676,
0.196786046,
-0.5394054651,
0.6096663475,
-0.6233834624,
-0.4379118383,
-0.1015011817,
0.6149426103,
-0.1063856035,
0.2133515924,
0.0523138046,
0.5298282504,
0.4302392006,
-0.4761675894,
0.4455354512,
0.3513724208,
-0.5122010708,
0.5412454009,
-0.7589431405,
-0.1564545035,
-0.2512387335,
0.5387172103,
-1.1574163437,
0.0426846445,
0.0540910549,
-0.1285798103,
-0.1893995702,
0.1778856367,
-0.572840929,
-0.1112814471,
-0.7542729974,
0.4219756126,
0.2232010663,
-0.3778781891,
0.9038150311,
0.0822765902,
-0.3970533311,
-0.5140959024,
-0.3615815938,
0.2721634805,
-0.4873870611,
-0.7471531034,
0.6941662431,
0.1534818113,
-0.3573310077,
0.1116468534,
-0.3925659359,
0.4067142606,
-0.3150565028,
0.2089133561,
0.4317436516,
-0.3508538902,
0.0545666814,
-0.2095492035,
-0.4068424404,
-0.04216877,
0.11220631,
0.5944488645,
-0.1766332984,
-0.4395733774,
-0.3199137151,
0.2279315144,
0.3547922671,
-0.0941805318,
0.4829507172,
0.2539051175,
-0.1835985184,
0.2897203863,
-0.7639975548,
0.0812761635,
-0.3694998622,
0.2681668103,
-0.5371940732,
-1.0681239367,
0.8311372399,
-0.2813554108,
0.1816070527,
0.6594834328,
0.3336815238,
0.1524218768,
0.3365631998,
0.312554419,
-0.0356829837,
0.3191261292,
-0.1866566688,
-0.2123394758,
-0.8588491082,
-0.2231310457,
-0.4239538014,
-0.4145469368,
-0.4440136254,
-0.4143784046,
0.5413235426,
-0.0077706557,
0.0904054344,
0.4074067771,
0.0867218599,
0.6653404832,
0.5511644483,
-0.1309565455,
0.6530824304,
-0.4391302466,
-0.0869322121,
-0.041392751,
-0.832780838,
-0.6349377036,
1.0093958378,
0.2688269615,
0.7717319727,
0.1846345216,
0.7459889054,
0.25181216,
-0.2480020076,
-0.4002844989,
0.7394017577,
-0.1097632647,
-0.2947885692,
-0.5377774239,
-0.2965053022,
-1.1590539217,
0.4673986733,
-0.2781458199,
-1.0507876873,
0.0969710276,
-0.4523514509,
-0.6151957512,
0.1175878495,
-0.5185756683,
0.769974649,
0.0072011347,
-0.3215972185,
-0.1779766381,
-1.0958622694,
0.1439480782,
0.0155696329,
0.1363650709,
-0.3977331519,
-0.4435477853,
0.8078120351,
-0.348046124,
0.9926418066,
0.4327596128,
0.0442481562,
0.1730478704,
-0.0770319104,
0.4879491031,
-0.3042649925,
0.1154626086,
0.3988204598,
0.1298018694,
-0.1880420148,
-0.3876030743,
0.5478290915,
-0.5098788738,
-0.5397980213,
-0.593370378,
-0.6876595616,
-0.3623357117,
0.2964070439,
0.4420641065,
0.6854166985,
-0.5152667165,
-0.0653452948,
0.4708433747,
-0.0922663435,
0.5742334127,
0.7984431386,
0.0388713107,
-0.2708518505,
0.6082795858,
0.2485686094,
0.3205986619,
0.4426658154,
0.2263468504,
-0.4075044096,
-0.5868561268,
-0.5606026649,
0.0856932327,
-0.743403852,
-0.2755829394,
-0.8923475146,
-0.4109005332,
-0.315733701,
-0.1206287444,
-0.1912485659,
-0.5524567962,
-0.0801165551,
-0.0863932967,
0.443547368,
0.9579836726,
0.0259087086,
0.3546546698,
-1.0953454971,
0.3752838373,
-0.0922951549,
0.4444274306,
0.0139539074,
-0.4274394512,
0.0683249682,
-0.5483598709,
-0.1317125112,
-0.8836871982,
-0.0063024298,
-0.1399621516,
0.9150666595,
0.3024891615,
0.3457856774,
0.546156764,
-0.4173611999,
0.8165587187,
0.4165074527,
-0.8683119416,
0.2280480713,
-0.3733910918,
0.6135829091,
0.5402487516,
0.5811926723,
-0.6636077762,
-0.7308697701,
-0.6260569692,
-0.9903706312,
0.7994886041,
0.3850241005,
-0.0570052788,
0.1098515019,
-0.129451707,
0.4096058011,
-0.0050087785,
-0.2556390464,
-0.2776407897,
0.3187823892,
-0.3541674614,
-0.1557814777,
-0.4755680859,
-0.194538936,
0.3030056953,
0.2859661877,
0.1011904404,
-0.314345181,
0.2040348798,
-0.0787629411,
0.1115243956,
0.352096796,
0.5977585316,
0.6848329902,
-0.1817344129,
0.3762432039,
0.6991325021,
-0.2400528789,
-0.110184446,
0.4009580016,
0.0173520595,
0.2147153467,
0.7625417709,
0.6847549677,
0.2980160713,
-1.0340557098,
0.5335187912,
-0.175607428,
-0.2489190698,
-0.0180485919,
0.1523251086,
0.0824017227,
0.4700600803,
0.3233407736,
-0.0476331562,
0.2391126007,
-0.3733619452,
0.0724229068,
0.2759701014,
-0.1962184757,
0.0991028175,
0.370871067,
0.1034778655,
-0.3278995156,
0.1463395655,
-0.0463852622,
-0.4393272996,
0.6722376943,
0.3164795637,
0.5860902071,
-0.0610897876,
-0.2484140247,
0.1704493612,
0.2147201896,
-0.0422062911,
0.0732662901,
0.0500923991,
-0.5878365636,
-0.3665100634,
-0.1522571445,
-0.6352035999,
-0.0053041121,
-0.7271860838,
0.5474063754,
-0.0086933421,
-0.1405234933,
0.1444162577,
-0.226611197,
-0.5212664008,
-0.0084994808,
-0.1165113449,
1.2555396557,
-0.8146543503,
0.018950196,
0.6226981282,
-0.1986719072,
-0.3248268664,
0.0992145315,
0.4522344172,
-0.8829841614,
0.4025411904,
0.2037220448,
-0.4244611561,
-0.134682864,
0.2411004752,
-0.9168253541,
1.1363344193,
0.098342821,
-0.5206241608,
0.0041771042,
0.3673205376,
0.5769942999,
-0.4635098875,
0.5732627511,
0.7837913036,
0.2618215382,
0.3000526428,
-1.0180923939,
0.2539073825,
-0.1473193318,
0.0030765811,
0.166585505,
-0.7612507939,
0.368773222,
-0.2881771922,
-0.2586173117,
0.4358630776,
0.4928095043,
0.4628544748,
0.7403616309,
0.6497195959,
0.4292356372,
0.5542926192,
-0.0981123894,
0.8483736515,
-0.1198842451,
0.1621969938,
1.4183951616,
-0.3585348725,
0.6271075606,
0.3088294268,
-0.3243123591,
0.2288294435,
0.7678017616,
-0.1538273692,
0.2565076053,
0.4407927692,
-0.0713543445,
-0.011166322,
-0.4193966985,
-0.6886816621,
0.5354812145,
0.1518973857,
-0.2111191005,
-0.6259041429,
-0.278786689,
-0.1129499599,
0.0739318132,
-0.1215032786,
0.9650794268,
0.0124842692,
-0.7385270596,
0.2815341949,
-0.1374090165,
0.5509693623,
-0.8951278329,
0.2092574239,
-0.266386658,
-0.0669277534,
-0.1800558418,
-0.8847465515,
0.2766757309,
0.097039625,
-0.0848074257,
-0.2208202928,
0.7398270965,
-0.2205058485,
-0.2645782828,
0.3364508748,
0.7280356288,
0.310685128,
0.2890904248,
-0.1671614647,
0.327380538,
-0.3639487624,
-0.1761304438,
0.3155963123,
0.439340055,
-0.0643088445,
0.5551677346,
0.3417179883,
0.0239856616,
0.0497332923,
0.3866935968,
1.0075385571,
-0.8365097046,
-0.7849192023,
-1.0331596136,
0.1549629569,
-0.2333322018,
-0.5802976489,
1.1312247515,
1.0406607389,
0.686562717,
0.1193396822,
0.6005791426,
0.1646627188,
0.6694189906,
-0.6705402732,
0.0747631937,
-0.503780961,
0.4828974009,
-0.4651855826,
-0.8753693104,
-0.1743655354,
0.1084564552,
-0.4488466978,
-0.0680502206,
0.8070759773,
0.695990026,
0.1586446613,
0.618360579,
0.1067765132,
-0.0372174866,
-0.1434927136,
0.5033771992,
1.5604118109,
-0.1365807056,
0.6502652764,
0.2799035907,
-0.3985054791,
-0.2930835187,
-1.0632449389,
-0.7828658819,
-0.3877019882,
-0.0903907195,
-0.2228059024,
0.0857407898,
0.6930261254,
0.4358682036,
-0.5566776395,
-0.3458509743,
0.1171554849,
0.227892831,
-0.3856358528,
-0.1691659987,
0.4137360454,
-0.2711660266,
-0.6289008856,
0.1708928496,
0.4175060391,
0.1011677682,
0.0910178944,
-0.0204765033,
0.0916045532,
0.0202446803,
0.3018895686,
0.0078267362,
-0.7648659348,
0.0469031744,
0.2655638158,
-0.068383038,
-0.0860373452,
1.0870330334,
-0.6297804713,
0.3659242392,
0.5430734158,
0.7212733626,
0.5943405032,
0.0189255122,
0.5083140731,
-0.737211287,
-0.3615752757,
0.03756072,
0.3528699279,
0.0260919966,
-0.127715677,
0.7204298973,
0.1877339929,
-0.2514152527,
-0.6582151055,
0.0997249559,
-1.066049695,
-0.3572537005,
1.3143202066,
-0.0774474144,
0.1862565577,
-0.2014752179,
-0.11045371,
0.0863138437,
-0.2856119871,
0.7217649817,
0.7142503858,
-0.5128242373,
0.1369752288,
-0.3897204697,
0.1967368573,
0.5560817122,
-0.7610759735,
0.1617279351,
0.4612486064,
0.1888300329,
0.2089799345,
0.7960788608,
-0.0026129365,
0.1841795295,
0.1552498788,
-0.2783742249,
-0.1247558072,
-0.1197967008,
-0.3460288644,
0.1023940369,
-0.4555514157,
-0.2005531192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16998v1
|
What Do Language Models Hear? Probing for Auditory Representations in Language Models
| 2024-02-26T20:13:58 | 2024-02-26T20:13:58 |
Jerry Ngo, Yoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This work explores whether language models encode meaningfully grounded
representations of sounds of objects. We learn a linear probe that retrieves
the correct text representation of an object given a snippet of audio related
to that object, where the sound representation is given by a pretrained audio
model. This probe is trained via a contrastive loss that pushes the language
representations and sound representations of an object to be close to one
another. After training, the probe is tested on its ability to generalize to
objects that were not seen during training. Across different language models
and audio models, we find that the probe generalization is above chance in many
cases, indicating that despite being trained only on raw text, language models
encode grounded knowledge of sounds for some objects.
|
[
-0.3670122027,
-0.5151258707,
0.8078942299,
-0.1675788462,
-0.0821126327,
-0.1122848392,
-0.2405572981,
-0.7007322907,
0.0470928028,
0.4423065782,
-0.5207023621,
-0.4423472583,
-0.4783006907,
-0.2845472097,
-0.7195308208,
0.689232111,
0.4106364846,
0.3833025694,
-0.1739721745,
-0.1835913062,
-0.4828488529,
-0.6309643984,
-0.4469167292,
-0.5514370799,
0.2088481933,
0.1721064597,
0.5217741132,
0.684553802,
0.3045940399,
0.2937067449,
-0.5519945025,
-0.4665918052,
-0.4305520058,
0.0492070355,
-0.2042082995,
-0.8907614946,
0.0168291014,
0.4583628774,
0.440664053,
1.1573710442,
-0.1533800662,
0.1271778494,
-0.059996143,
0.2921630442,
-0.4272122085,
0.1806030571,
-0.5989003778,
0.2349148542,
0.1415878385,
-0.2911365628,
-0.6721056104,
0.0406527705,
0.3509566486,
-0.4065454304,
0.3727518022,
0.1667155474,
1.0303090811,
0.1082164496,
-0.6367800832,
-0.5394963026,
-0.8275578022,
0.9394610524,
-0.6921381354,
0.9795567989,
0.6827282906,
0.4232241213,
0.2673494518,
-0.6466798782,
-0.4001237452,
-0.4967451394,
-0.1752356589,
0.2210664153,
0.1332923621,
0.1365711391,
0.2405747324,
0.7627633214,
-0.3096185625,
-0.1637797505,
-0.2810366154,
-0.0551931597,
0.3396086991,
-0.1824417859,
0.4085509777,
0.023576891,
-0.1048086509,
-0.3328820169,
-0.5539880395,
0.0192135014,
0.5262242556,
0.1790003926,
-0.2142584324,
0.5261130333,
0.0983598903,
0.6583324075,
0.0091496604,
-0.0488556214,
0.1709934324,
-0.2540464103,
-0.0171026122,
0.1905847341,
0.4119570255,
0.328696698,
0.4367135465,
-0.3238262236,
-0.5618312359,
0.1670329273,
0.1275690794,
-0.5058278441,
-0.2039651275,
-0.0608559065,
-0.7846410871,
-0.3522604704,
0.0716847777,
-0.1093047708,
-0.2730094194,
-0.5876480341,
0.4600086212,
-0.4141821563,
-0.5537623763,
0.7188464403,
-0.3097788692,
0.2977803349,
0.1017351896,
-1.2870665789,
0.6692617536,
0.6662514806,
0.482639432,
0.4438610375,
-0.1282120049,
-0.6544707417,
-0.0191994626,
-0.571229279,
0.8824849129,
-0.6238119006,
-0.6163615584,
0.0372654796,
0.0292448401,
0.0284364726,
-0.6905992031,
0.4315025508,
-0.3438718915,
0.2775199413,
-0.5063804388,
-0.6629299521,
-0.3958441019,
0.1333291233,
-0.6574177742,
0.9069548249,
0.0902847126,
-0.7803826332,
0.5351510644,
-0.2455171198,
-0.0109519074,
-0.3148087859,
-0.655441165,
-0.1016792059,
0.5366963148,
0.2342398614,
0.3113273978,
-0.330093056,
0.064076528,
-0.2012675107,
-0.6901131868,
0.4130336344,
-0.0466595702,
0.4116379023,
0.0431088135,
-0.3145672977,
0.0255662035,
-0.7093694806,
-0.2555836141,
0.2767392099,
-0.4178489745,
-0.5568597317,
0.3099002838,
0.3087701797,
-0.1249127388,
-0.1168247238,
-0.8581361771,
-0.0505011193,
-0.74306494,
0.3203354478,
0.4555393755,
-0.1150375381,
0.5926041007,
-0.344347477,
0.1797761023,
0.1728451699,
-0.2010073215,
-0.6733113527,
-0.2790045738,
-0.8410996199,
0.1979328096,
0.2518399358,
0.1825835109,
-0.0158600155,
0.0801602751,
0.0840313137,
-0.3193355501,
-0.7599125504,
-0.0761231035,
0.2941893637,
0.6629161835,
0.1055993885,
-0.1508619785,
-0.694240272,
-0.8914361,
-0.3641714752,
-0.5210053921,
-0.2884290218,
0.4600197375,
0.329826951,
-0.4327153265,
0.845385313,
-0.4652453065,
-0.2380130291,
-0.1233843267,
0.3850954175,
0.4644777179,
0.5186625719,
0.8887605071,
-0.8830330968,
0.0402806699,
0.3215776682,
-0.8434596062,
-0.0540447459,
0.0606806278,
0.3538856804,
-0.4455109537,
0.9891655445,
-0.3329572976,
0.3115715981,
0.5998163223,
-0.4682604373,
0.3916112483,
0.0246272516,
0.0766331404,
-0.8629263639,
-0.0588174053,
-0.3640727401,
-0.2910797596,
-0.5492902398,
-0.1851946861,
0.1175141037,
-0.3447313011,
-0.3955072165,
0.5105156898,
-0.6711243987,
-0.4549513161,
-0.4180803001,
0.0838044211,
0.1469410211,
0.0622466765,
0.3063842654,
0.8497599363,
0.8673051596,
-0.7140548825,
0.2424887866,
0.08129289,
-0.4104320109,
0.4227044582,
-0.8961910009,
0.4200178981,
-0.361987114,
-0.1909850538,
-0.954613626,
-0.0091530681,
-0.183000803,
-0.6187996864,
0.0836549476,
-0.270457387,
-0.3713153303,
-0.0169694088,
0.1148158982,
0.802067399,
0.5392353535,
-0.6531393528,
0.70877105,
0.6403023005,
0.0673197135,
-0.1910379678,
-0.9355362654,
-0.3929730356,
-0.0154076451,
-0.4006970823,
-0.0574131683,
-0.0364375524,
-0.5309525132,
0.014688056,
-0.3156486452,
-0.1384390593,
0.222789377,
0.4077600241,
-0.2533785105,
-0.8731017113,
0.3703639805,
-0.3127050698,
0.0091485754,
0.5205812454,
-0.2376054376,
0.7029616833,
-0.3989353776,
-0.9441899061,
-0.1734881401,
0.2805681825,
0.3479026854,
-0.2299405783,
0.3530151844,
0.488715589,
-0.5474648476,
-0.0737181231,
-0.6938043237,
-0.6077826023,
-0.5834119916,
0.4042569399,
-0.6131619215,
-0.6999026537,
0.836034894,
-0.2186074555,
-0.2459887266,
0.2395936698,
0.1481966078,
-0.3443889022,
1.1589105129,
0.6865513325,
-0.142931208,
0.326672256,
-0.3025289178,
0.0416170098,
-0.7123304605,
-0.5458564758,
-0.8770107031,
-0.0182426404,
-0.324336648,
-0.2612200975,
-0.166056335,
0.2597840726,
0.0008616162,
0.1931161284,
-0.2329702824,
0.7632763982,
0.7180398107,
0.1301046312,
0.2341954857,
-0.2807330787,
-0.2668823898,
-0.30260095,
-0.3619441688,
-0.48053509,
0.9543190002,
0.6957756281,
0.8074898124,
-0.0802412853,
0.6372184753,
0.0436874032,
0.0175421964,
-1.1058883667,
0.2903981805,
0.2149465233,
-0.616243422,
-0.124964729,
-0.0874606743,
-0.9277996421,
0.2707689106,
-0.0340686478,
-0.6104911566,
0.4399929941,
0.0120286802,
0.1597668678,
0.3261452019,
-0.4188534915,
0.5263937116,
-0.2828833759,
0.1752071083,
-0.1761939675,
-0.1680690199,
0.1163132861,
0.1525177062,
0.3636772633,
-0.0708371326,
0.2248311937,
0.9179188609,
0.0661856458,
0.6610088348,
-0.1014429107,
-0.3047334254,
0.2097689956,
0.3889240623,
0.1973593682,
0.1499524117,
-0.0723650381,
-0.072245568,
-0.1653137207,
-0.5026646256,
-0.5483115911,
0.342895329,
-0.6002526283,
-0.5670105815,
-0.2917015254,
-0.5362793803,
-0.3868314028,
0.3133821189,
0.2856263816,
0.3827224672,
-0.4500322938,
0.3785951436,
0.8303080201,
-0.3244750798,
0.230391264,
0.7015373111,
-0.5422705412,
0.1922270209,
0.6163284183,
-0.3167957664,
0.1241521016,
0.419077754,
0.2342915386,
-0.3440011144,
-0.5728471279,
-0.1572090238,
0.3393418491,
-1.0470227003,
0.3559055626,
-0.4922990203,
-0.3120488524,
-0.3461463153,
0.0497192219,
-0.6089658737,
0.1037893891,
-0.4893276989,
-0.6355914474,
0.2196347862,
1.2201257944,
-0.0951364189,
0.4078054726,
-0.7737397552,
0.3679236472,
0.5785194039,
0.4232015014,
-0.1661143005,
-0.6539174318,
-0.356444627,
0.2027141303,
0.1904873401,
-1.0790594816,
0.365583539,
0.1716677099,
0.6434502602,
0.5929508209,
-0.2040858418,
0.3880110085,
-0.6448298097,
0.6554706097,
0.0333288647,
-1.2314966917,
0.7576572895,
-0.7790745497,
0.387283057,
0.4454333782,
0.1287888438,
-0.8085466027,
-0.431556344,
-0.4671427906,
-0.4982579947,
0.6662669778,
-0.0167123601,
0.4523733854,
-0.0301202293,
0.1426746249,
0.0656373277,
0.2591977119,
-0.8392971754,
-0.102850318,
-0.3634447455,
0.0852466151,
-0.1814896315,
-0.5457983017,
-0.2209014446,
-0.1073395759,
-0.1318185031,
0.1176957935,
0.5363426208,
0.1358823329,
-0.2079948187,
-0.1637293249,
0.0449313559,
0.5417667031,
0.3250391185,
-0.5751773119,
0.5524801612,
0.1881927252,
-0.5474166274,
0.2625858188,
-0.364067018,
0.1907133758,
0.4547548592,
0.7906128764,
1.0822671652,
0.6582806706,
-0.7963488698,
0.5242112279,
-0.0852680728,
-0.408846736,
-0.3452084959,
0.0029412315,
0.37255916,
0.1526082158,
0.485583812,
0.0635262728,
0.5453540087,
-0.8117907643,
0.2855513394,
0.0335648172,
-0.7687425613,
-0.6050271392,
0.8012676835,
-0.0535461791,
-0.1482329518,
0.6936610937,
0.2955036461,
-0.5422497392,
0.7318093181,
0.669941783,
0.8245992064,
-0.357468158,
-0.0264283232,
0.2478531897,
0.358094722,
-0.1193678528,
0.4816406965,
-0.1000073403,
-0.8537716269,
-0.2679418623,
-0.5113756061,
-0.6172004938,
0.3170320094,
-1.0304170847,
0.0641636774,
-0.3392640054,
0.0448410884,
-0.1761076748,
-0.472506851,
-0.7437106371,
0.5467574,
0.2407893986,
0.8310672045,
-1.1831417084,
0.6949502826,
0.7533519268,
-0.4085364342,
-0.89364779,
-0.0053418651,
-0.2047695667,
-0.6496264338,
1.174757123,
0.3279109001,
-0.2759192288,
-0.1927717328,
-0.5476182699,
-1.0721852779,
0.6440272331,
0.671836555,
-0.5897772908,
0.1104222834,
0.2278475314,
0.5729956627,
-0.3746945858,
0.5207446218,
0.3218352199,
0.3956735432,
-0.3133114278,
-1.0980693102,
-0.1471017897,
-0.4524062872,
-0.1198756993,
-0.2876648009,
-0.26528579,
1.2819712162,
0.0542508997,
-0.3007398248,
-0.2062800676,
0.7579166889,
0.3812613785,
0.4269219935,
0.5688260794,
0.4034997523,
0.6584358811,
-0.3293990493,
1.1929162741,
-0.133865431,
0.2700564563,
1.0079727173,
-0.1635296345,
0.781596303,
0.5050295591,
-0.011382659,
0.2234446853,
0.6509621143,
0.234780252,
0.6597921252,
0.4530942142,
-0.1609055698,
-0.2366303951,
-0.2803996801,
-0.6353476048,
0.6034690142,
0.2538486123,
-0.4542855918,
0.023767909,
0.3664868772,
-0.3753502965,
0.4825595319,
-0.1613270491,
0.9108684063,
0.2392348498,
-0.2219946831,
0.6193993688,
-0.252745986,
0.4344765544,
-0.3625356853,
-0.1619103402,
-0.2998868823,
0.16584903,
0.0317123644,
-0.623382926,
0.2766976058,
-0.5016881824,
-0.3797112703,
-0.2802062035,
0.6217468381,
-0.4506106675,
-0.2202892601,
0.8575617671,
0.3346437812,
0.3281044066,
-0.2619746327,
-0.206047833,
0.4292965233,
-0.0659776926,
-0.3566876352,
0.1154637113,
0.5184860229,
0.2367201298,
0.8117747903,
0.5310834646,
0.4201910496,
0.2532492876,
0.5330052376,
0.8447738886,
-0.8858459592,
-0.4816972315,
-0.4231313467,
0.3619180918,
0.0555895343,
-0.0135617657,
0.5117175579,
0.6641480327,
1.0591917038,
-0.5514838696,
0.5227146745,
0.5953029394,
0.7605765462,
-0.7983003855,
0.8300944567,
-0.5226623416,
0.2606299818,
-0.2408786267,
-0.9430673718,
0.0125510246,
1.0589182377,
-0.2261761874,
-0.0427727997,
0.7728976607,
0.6628930569,
-0.5963014364,
0.1543499082,
0.6763375401,
0.2242584229,
0.1485161185,
0.0944355354,
1.1913564205,
-0.6483145356,
0.313790679,
-0.0982211456,
0.4010733366,
-0.1683098525,
-0.426045537,
-1.0808960199,
-0.7444966435,
-0.0784881115,
-0.0254436508,
0.1110923216,
0.3712971509,
1.1401942968,
-1.0438328981,
-0.7763348222,
-0.3315030336,
-0.3098058999,
-0.0452545807,
-0.2098139226,
0.2422601432,
-0.3343283832,
-0.9420309663,
0.9976468682,
-0.0035689883,
0.338622719,
-0.0983256698,
-0.2263673842,
-0.0721994042,
0.0778429955,
0.207198143,
0.2091891319,
-0.6979137063,
-0.4113817811,
0.1844708771,
-0.1697407514,
-0.0477638394,
0.8756155372,
-0.8437710404,
0.5533845425,
0.6407062411,
0.6999434829,
0.748208046,
-0.31972453,
0.9851182699,
-0.8545966148,
0.9086944461,
0.5447639227,
0.6976599097,
0.3521565795,
-0.167556718,
0.4141504467,
0.0425980836,
-0.24136585,
-1.0963453054,
0.4209477007,
-0.9044450521,
-0.3318977952,
1.0885493755,
-0.0888943225,
-0.1682277769,
-0.0856712162,
-0.6158859134,
0.2737930715,
-0.1465727538,
0.5079144835,
0.7730520964,
0.3012608588,
-0.6319549084,
-0.5537974834,
0.5273401141,
0.8376300335,
-0.2369656414,
-0.2870391309,
0.2054591775,
0.2413042784,
0.2786172926,
0.4930828214,
-0.0376680493,
0.4175938666,
0.3247674406,
0.140414089,
0.1185919046,
-0.188832745,
-0.2459232956,
-0.0087995883,
0.4256929457,
-0.3848325014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16986v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16986v1
|
Long Dialog Summarization: An Analysis
| 2024-02-26T19:35:45 | 2024-02-26T19:35:45 |
Ankan Mullick, Ayan Kumar Bhowmick, Raghav R, Ravi Kokku, Prasenjit Dey, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dialog summarization has become increasingly important in managing and
comprehending large-scale conversations across various domains. This task
presents unique challenges in capturing the key points, context, and nuances of
multi-turn long conversations for summarization. It is worth noting that the
summarization techniques may vary based on specific requirements such as in a
shopping-chatbot scenario, the dialog summary helps to learn user preferences,
whereas in the case of a customer call center, the summary may involve the
problem attributes that a user specified, and the final resolution provided.
This work emphasizes the significance of creating coherent and contextually
rich summaries for effective communication in various applications. We explore
current state-of-the-art approaches for long dialog summarization in different
domains and benchmark metrics based evaluations show that one single model does
not perform well across various areas for distinct summarization tasks.
|
[
-0.5922531486,
-1.016125679,
0.3612613082,
0.3383663893,
-0.2713434994,
0.2169183791,
-0.2483049184,
-0.849588275,
0.3021354675,
0.5905091166,
-0.3566920459,
-0.3011305928,
-0.3036836982,
0.1084378138,
-0.2475976199,
1.2410632372,
0.1061416715,
-0.1938802302,
-0.3027658761,
-0.2629626095,
-0.6895704269,
-0.8614767194,
-0.6503307819,
-0.2433654368,
0.2076641172,
0.4644925594,
0.6364557743,
-0.1514434218,
0.382694602,
0.3664939702,
-0.2699740827,
0.3314841986,
-0.786619544,
0.3583427668,
0.2185675055,
-0.3032556474,
-0.9221544862,
-0.1976895034,
0.5923012495,
1.0291128159,
0.0848076418,
0.1989643574,
0.224627763,
0.8058459163,
-0.2306479365,
0.2635289729,
-0.3096894026,
0.101032339,
0.022063667,
-0.4028335512,
-0.1559548676,
-0.2678132951,
0.630392015,
-0.4041210711,
0.1202946976,
-0.015222461,
0.5526316762,
-0.144304499,
-0.777327776,
-0.66969347,
-1.0594574213,
0.9112337828,
-0.7870950699,
-0.1356099099,
0.2073374838,
0.607694447,
0.0389592089,
-0.4386113882,
-0.1128002554,
0.1097536534,
-0.1101387739,
0.467464745,
-0.2702155113,
0.0301420949,
0.1717679948,
0.4457474649,
-0.2339665145,
0.0445739999,
-0.6248164773,
-0.1784901619,
0.6288104057,
0.6826388836,
-0.1579982489,
-0.1789329499,
-0.2891238928,
0.3582672179,
-0.3133687377,
0.1416556984,
0.2251289785,
0.1890170723,
-0.2279927433,
0.3624804318,
-0.6003846526,
0.5362991095,
-0.0963114128,
-0.5531020761,
0.0961461961,
-0.6601278186,
-0.073674798,
-0.0448559821,
0.6600642204,
1.122674942,
0.389249742,
-0.0236896463,
-0.0320604853,
-0.5579841137,
0.0746274441,
-0.8942470551,
0.3903155625,
0.6007019877,
-0.7086619735,
0.0004889861,
-0.0511262752,
-1.0928725004,
-0.0919688269,
-0.6599941254,
-0.1605953276,
-0.0773028061,
-0.1163858101,
0.0915465206,
-0.1972116679,
0.309879452,
0.8176391721,
-0.5466164351,
0.359090507,
0.7990632057,
0.840123415,
-0.2328725904,
-0.1568559557,
-0.0502312407,
0.0588566512,
-0.1742312759,
0.6737565398,
-0.2791923285,
-0.7122615576,
0.311453253,
0.0225583557,
-0.0834101811,
-0.6455511451,
0.1472599953,
-0.3796803653,
0.4581389725,
-0.1353107095,
-0.5427176356,
-0.2581496239,
0.4124367237,
-0.3332244158,
0.5211762786,
0.0914210007,
-0.5721758604,
0.0394135304,
-0.7293606997,
-0.6720746756,
-0.0774071664,
0.1343190521,
-0.4706321061,
0.3445949554,
0.0847229809,
0.6660448909,
-0.0136794345,
0.0678386092,
0.0510320924,
-0.3285703361,
0.6152201295,
-0.3357079923,
0.5727441907,
0.255033046,
-0.1381361187,
0.1385676712,
-0.3407716751,
-0.0375673957,
0.0525770932,
-0.0434346385,
0.0029328689,
-0.1401541084,
0.0413603522,
0.0773947462,
0.3439560235,
-0.170737803,
0.2541417181,
0.0929122344,
0.4851245582,
0.2837137282,
0.2493416071,
0.2738293409,
-0.4128554761,
0.6833187938,
-0.0017081536,
0.2314173728,
-0.692912817,
-0.4344533384,
-0.5648673773,
-0.3110807538,
0.1539383978,
0.6151129603,
-0.3407013416,
0.3676226437,
-0.3905059099,
-0.2511495352,
-0.0672400594,
0.0284648407,
0.3925545812,
0.3598764241,
0.1420206726,
-0.5020501614,
-0.1954919249,
-0.8542367816,
-0.0380516015,
-0.0551384911,
0.0829629079,
0.4813392162,
0.4913780093,
-0.0818510726,
1.0602647066,
-0.8627415299,
-0.4825058877,
-0.7944103479,
0.0868577883,
0.0640652105,
0.0796583071,
0.6770459414,
-0.6868563294,
-0.5488811135,
-0.1148045883,
-0.723952055,
0.1806496978,
-0.4769906998,
-0.0743887424,
0.1393221468,
0.4746581316,
-0.9289343953,
0.6872509122,
0.2237499952,
-0.0436646156,
0.8411425352,
-0.2856166661,
0.37346524,
-1.1052174568,
0.0545545742,
-0.0826982334,
-0.4789016247,
-0.9495443702,
-0.2558585405,
-0.2871796191,
-0.4047959447,
-0.2482101619,
0.2652121484,
-0.2989480495,
-0.1720557213,
-0.4982014894,
0.2920747697,
0.1319704503,
0.6430563331,
0.0550377518,
0.6903933883,
0.2831323445,
-0.6330074668,
0.4668111205,
0.465629369,
-0.1749218255,
0.6177675128,
-0.9350186586,
-0.162755087,
-0.1367000043,
0.7983555198,
-0.9005253911,
-0.3840046823,
0.1494053751,
-0.5262713432,
0.1505523622,
-0.0343982354,
-0.2340374887,
-0.2596904933,
-0.3409704864,
0.4854848683,
0.5329304338,
-0.1919667125,
0.5216130614,
0.4079190791,
-0.6052404642,
-0.2449603975,
-0.4817795157,
0.3843050003,
-0.5813288093,
-0.5350244045,
0.0449402817,
-0.1204010993,
-0.3597304225,
-0.6616475582,
-0.111706242,
-0.1002060324,
0.1216247827,
0.2616969049,
0.0247852746,
-0.036650341,
0.0994070321,
-0.1803418696,
-0.3384386003,
0.2599089146,
0.1725002378,
0.5045316219,
-0.1804176569,
-0.3921296299,
-0.6678785086,
1.2207729816,
0.9033132792,
-0.1072570831,
0.4749570489,
0.2700836957,
-0.1380254179,
-0.0247869026,
-0.5678218007,
-0.0698032379,
-0.3685758114,
0.4793349504,
-0.1996804327,
-0.7848935127,
0.7652802467,
-0.4225272238,
0.2359265834,
0.162213102,
0.4416875243,
-0.3591003418,
0.9398548007,
0.6804546118,
-0.2130266875,
0.4021222591,
-0.1632576585,
0.692759335,
-0.7634720206,
-0.1775324941,
-0.5327040553,
0.0517544076,
-0.3041253686,
-0.0884442553,
0.4337075353,
0.0034699244,
0.4330306947,
0.2210166603,
-0.1012686193,
0.3518949151,
0.3390091062,
-0.2036149055,
0.4104306698,
-0.210831672,
0.639928937,
0.142179206,
-0.4547109604,
-0.7501325607,
0.6470811367,
0.4251917899,
0.4847286046,
0.2754011154,
0.6488645673,
0.1888338476,
-0.1515990794,
-1.0694240332,
0.5570771694,
0.2637592554,
-0.417802006,
-0.4675377905,
-0.3813215196,
-1.1424661875,
0.3713921905,
0.0742557272,
-0.6799653769,
-0.3254848719,
0.312151134,
-0.4199948907,
-0.123457171,
-0.7948776484,
0.8142322898,
-0.2310477942,
0.1017608643,
-0.3316680491,
-0.8398323059,
0.1918342263,
0.0317467004,
0.1218322963,
-0.1853459477,
0.3548909426,
0.5772146583,
-0.3392317593,
1.0234125853,
0.0178716686,
-0.2219454646,
0.4957458079,
-0.265473932,
0.2117306441,
0.1406071335,
0.3915637732,
0.0442738011,
0.0282354206,
-0.6650033593,
-0.5970264673,
0.2936926484,
-0.4598128498,
-0.6069514155,
-0.2130197436,
-0.4555676877,
-0.297772646,
0.0119327102,
0.1155497506,
0.9171122313,
-0.4417169392,
0.12968871,
0.5899350643,
-0.2326279879,
0.5332119465,
0.223160103,
-0.2797750831,
-0.2415724546,
0.6868331432,
0.0841169283,
0.547256887,
0.1376755089,
-0.0366944112,
-0.0359956101,
-0.5680279732,
-0.210801661,
0.1907953322,
-0.8522052765,
-0.2545193434,
-0.6837688088,
-0.1493170857,
-0.3722562492,
-0.3535884321,
-0.184770599,
-0.550876677,
-0.1292946637,
0.1278313398,
0.0863024816,
0.7931444049,
0.4928237498,
0.477627486,
-0.9215175509,
0.4842737317,
0.4652430713,
0.0520902351,
0.323040843,
-0.1411515623,
-0.4308819175,
0.1430649757,
-0.3815375268,
-0.5105583072,
0.3330560029,
0.147683695,
0.4229498804,
0.4291657209,
-0.0148980515,
0.8844146729,
-0.2741584778,
1.1495697498,
0.404309541,
-0.8827852011,
0.4385746121,
-0.3625673652,
0.8401916623,
0.5837218761,
0.3092767894,
-0.8575428724,
-0.3791851401,
-0.4689231813,
-1.0899841785,
0.3445350528,
0.1885908842,
0.4077354968,
0.0905664414,
0.075459078,
0.3273514211,
0.2623538673,
-0.1090572625,
-0.1507364959,
-0.1804784685,
-0.0009222086,
-0.2031308264,
-0.33419016,
-0.3920972347,
0.0076871058,
0.366463989,
-0.1167332307,
0.3081587851,
0.0418716967,
-0.2476764768,
0.4300576746,
0.5937098861,
0.9666433334,
1.2342914343,
-0.1216701716,
-0.3034736216,
0.2246809304,
-0.2657471597,
-0.532866776,
-0.2130913436,
0.1825437844,
0.166340664,
0.5603954196,
0.6553248167,
0.0880753174,
-0.6123048067,
0.6619285941,
-0.3135680258,
-0.1642495245,
-0.4423803091,
-0.2774828374,
-0.0281866118,
0.1897215098,
0.5045549273,
-0.1102473438,
0.3821505904,
-0.7857083678,
-0.2151767612,
0.4343828559,
-0.2392724305,
-0.4091911018,
0.0144955795,
0.683801055,
-0.1226246208,
0.5485230684,
0.1048999876,
-0.6537787318,
0.5374117494,
0.5059692264,
0.855835259,
0.1815670282,
0.078411065,
0.0636003315,
-0.367199719,
0.2441842258,
-0.1824578047,
-0.5616590381,
-0.2744344771,
-0.4670749903,
0.0262223016,
-0.8795870543,
-0.1704779565,
-0.7581971884,
-0.2569360137,
0.0203734431,
-0.493016392,
0.0988954008,
-0.0710975826,
-0.5225155354,
-0.0680014417,
-0.1594912708,
0.6336557269,
-0.4946677983,
-0.0148640256,
0.2409154624,
0.0362903513,
-0.149588868,
-0.0923918337,
-0.0102232667,
-0.378431201,
0.2865757346,
0.3161815405,
-0.3557499945,
-0.6617939472,
-0.3830043972,
-0.3451289237,
1.0975371599,
-0.3358983696,
-0.4040533602,
-0.1771571189,
0.3679344654,
0.7273374796,
-0.5948004127,
0.4130668342,
0.593272984,
0.1758384109,
0.0637639388,
-1.3697971106,
-0.2531304061,
-0.1216534823,
-0.090760082,
0.3083043993,
-1.0848923922,
0.3677484095,
-0.1386856139,
-0.2002266496,
0.173681289,
0.6485310793,
-0.093870759,
0.6046882272,
0.3315860331,
-0.0210491493,
0.4354368448,
-0.1002592072,
0.7411696911,
-0.2762807906,
0.3024716377,
1.259267211,
-0.2497259229,
0.5306651592,
0.428602159,
0.0408690199,
-0.0780306458,
0.3174135983,
0.3080466688,
0.0843789503,
0.2549674511,
-0.207072407,
-0.1062325612,
-0.1255639493,
-0.4963867962,
0.5875359774,
0.5612955093,
-0.0594190657,
-0.3618417978,
0.0069801072,
0.233683899,
-0.2485052645,
-0.1367108226,
1.1161237955,
0.179419294,
-0.9020314813,
0.349948734,
-0.4146379232,
0.5048273206,
-0.4909894168,
-0.0684012994,
-0.2239131033,
0.1399292499,
-0.210874334,
-0.5675470829,
0.2292673588,
0.1099098697,
-0.1145244762,
-0.4093745947,
0.3911042511,
-0.3311034441,
0.038535554,
0.0485805459,
0.7066968679,
0.4839347899,
-0.0389916599,
-0.4402655959,
0.2431037724,
0.0309245568,
-0.2785819471,
0.2327149957,
0.4755817056,
-0.1578992605,
0.7120304704,
0.3558067977,
-0.1995461881,
-0.0782803074,
0.3501298428,
0.7021511197,
-0.869078517,
-0.4867327511,
-0.4257902503,
0.8375340104,
-0.4548994303,
-0.6836240888,
0.9541786909,
0.6339223981,
0.4224832654,
-0.0362006947,
0.870040834,
0.1939030141,
0.6515567899,
-0.4419127703,
0.4110089839,
-0.0412758589,
0.1845943183,
-0.0694402084,
-1.0609651804,
-0.1651495844,
0.2883397937,
-0.080152519,
0.0508360527,
0.5989868045,
0.2455012202,
0.11408858,
0.1714931428,
0.247031495,
-0.018754391,
0.5828980803,
0.4701944888,
1.0502243042,
-0.2947117686,
0.5151197314,
-0.047400333,
-0.3330237865,
-0.6796876788,
-0.8030279875,
-1.1302118301,
-0.5647468567,
-0.5287969112,
-0.1611484289,
-0.0629077777,
0.6593416929,
0.7735771537,
-0.7167470455,
-0.4574466944,
0.6566990614,
0.0283534583,
-0.1987166256,
-0.2602684498,
0.1659147441,
-0.4597226679,
-0.7985990047,
0.0228993837,
0.4497339427,
0.5771143436,
-0.121942915,
0.2019595653,
0.4124572873,
0.1837967634,
1.0006643534,
0.3749932647,
-0.6042917967,
-0.1963650882,
-0.0831078142,
-0.0349176936,
0.1721669585,
1.0802565813,
-0.450055331,
0.406735301,
0.278621912,
0.3434833586,
0.7246546745,
0.2977475226,
0.7463040948,
-0.6108401418,
-0.0685456172,
0.152912885,
0.2484212071,
0.2324705869,
-0.2544974387,
0.1703613549,
-0.3855060935,
-0.7309729457,
-0.6471912861,
0.3681924343,
-1.4628825188,
-0.3210249245,
0.9957438707,
-0.1913995147,
0.0067858449,
-0.4085480273,
-0.5877373219,
0.0357288308,
-0.5452808738,
0.7974649072,
0.6838110685,
-0.4391373396,
0.1971774399,
-0.5350494981,
0.4716852307,
0.2158620209,
-1.1004585028,
0.4712328911,
0.7758231759,
0.0564416796,
0.3850304484,
0.5814134479,
-0.0918712839,
0.1196295992,
-0.2868563235,
-0.5212426782,
0.1098134071,
-0.4100829959,
-0.2804710865,
0.4891269803,
-0.1777429879,
-0.0269125123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16977v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16977v2
|
Dealing with Data for RE: Mitigating Challenges while using NLP and Generative AI
| 2024-02-26T19:19:47 | 2024-02-28T11:12:07 |
Smita Ghaisas, Anmol Singhal
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Across the dynamic business landscape today, enterprises face an
ever-increasing range of challenges. These include the constantly evolving
regulatory environment, the growing demand for personalization within software
applications, and the heightened emphasis on governance. In response to these
multifaceted demands, large enterprises have been adopting automation that
spans from the optimization of core business processes to the enhancement of
customer experiences. Indeed, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has emerged as a
pivotal element of modern software systems. In this context, data plays an
indispensable role. AI-centric software systems based on supervised learning
and operating at an industrial scale require large volumes of training data to
perform effectively. Moreover, the incorporation of generative AI has led to a
growing demand for adequate evaluation benchmarks. Our experience in this field
has revealed that the requirement for large datasets for training and
evaluation introduces a host of intricate challenges. This book chapter
explores the evolving landscape of Software Engineering (SE) in general, and
Requirements Engineering (RE) in particular, in this era marked by AI
integration. We discuss challenges that arise while integrating Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and generative AI into enterprise-critical software
systems. The chapter provides practical insights, solutions, and examples to
equip readers with the knowledge and tools necessary for effectively building
solutions with NLP at their cores. We also reflect on how these text
data-centric tasks sit together with the traditional RE process. We also
highlight new RE tasks that may be necessary for handling the increasingly
important text data-centricity involved in developing software systems.
|
[
-0.4660699368,
-0.6596326232,
0.3209856749,
0.4425845146,
0.4315495789,
0.2257689983,
0.0509147644,
-0.6084553599,
-0.1063230485,
0.8090362549,
-0.8828611374,
-0.1948632747,
-0.3880655766,
0.2506115735,
-0.6375709772,
1.0995897055,
-0.3177846968,
-0.414701134,
-0.5941718817,
-0.1756150872,
-0.7880505919,
-0.8018726707,
-0.6867172122,
-0.5267465115,
0.1542191356,
0.4986976683,
0.718190372,
0.4140805006,
0.7563413382,
0.307571739,
0.198992148,
0.0691799,
-0.1827687025,
0.5532382727,
-0.0191943794,
-0.6281195283,
-0.3422930539,
-0.1102795824,
0.4456616342,
0.7510393858,
-0.1932229996,
0.259870559,
0.1472397596,
1.0651513338,
-0.5005145073,
0.3987620473,
-0.5624466538,
0.4738076925,
-0.0459563136,
-0.2950267494,
-0.3286827803,
-0.0515838563,
0.3012304008,
-0.8039748073,
0.1929319054,
0.3244482577,
1.0316296816,
0.7454100251,
-0.2725380659,
-0.4877941608,
-1.0769252777,
1.0754030943,
-0.2296070606,
0.3664537966,
0.3078166544,
0.1310310662,
-0.2893450558,
-0.7835942507,
-0.2848514915,
-0.0642453507,
0.1513794363,
0.0344852582,
-0.2010537535,
-0.0110395681,
0.4507322013,
0.5136790872,
-0.6170879006,
0.1549660414,
-0.3616971374,
0.1066515446,
0.9117566943,
0.4071950018,
0.4579719007,
0.1879068017,
-0.1512483209,
-0.075366877,
-0.5256788731,
-0.3445783854,
0.3334794044,
0.2078405619,
0.2377874404,
0.6405293941,
-0.0331180282,
0.6478196383,
-0.1793884039,
0.4555641115,
0.4932574332,
-0.3906632066,
-0.4334684014,
-0.1572948396,
0.3373151422,
0.0018670516,
0.3458323777,
-0.2916933894,
-0.447424382,
0.0736067295,
0.979830265,
-0.1311355084,
-0.098290287,
0.6237037182,
-0.3365381062,
-0.1906601191,
-0.255027622,
-0.8327365518,
-0.5267012119,
-0.7236465812,
0.1143411547,
-0.3316660821,
-0.0432384312,
0.0883436725,
-0.410618037,
0.7571213841,
0.1653761715,
-1.0483725071,
0.2110273391,
0.9588849545,
0.6189943552,
0.0757473335,
-0.2579570413,
-0.2740007639,
0.3269245625,
-0.4807547033,
0.498565048,
-0.2948479056,
-0.3604816198,
0.0399861559,
-0.1375225931,
0.0839510784,
-0.8446180224,
0.7216954827,
-0.4618428946,
-0.0089845732,
0.1813846976,
-0.5844442248,
-0.1788901389,
0.3724812865,
-0.8806419373,
0.9554153085,
0.2889925539,
-0.5070924759,
0.4635160565,
-0.8679789305,
-0.5074304938,
0.151942268,
-0.2927371264,
-0.5103993416,
0.1465092301,
0.1221309453,
0.3775038719,
-0.4168662727,
-0.1193570569,
-0.1768718809,
0.0787249282,
-0.310359776,
-0.2035163343,
0.7412807941,
0.2891200483,
-0.3583102226,
-0.0132330162,
-0.6744003892,
0.3687766492,
0.0726690963,
-0.2454200983,
-0.3595156074,
0.2806971669,
0.1989517212,
-0.3082682788,
0.228257373,
-0.0892417431,
-0.0472525358,
-0.3487149179,
0.420817256,
0.5577452183,
-0.0460570343,
0.4138635099,
-0.3865658343,
0.5415357947,
-0.1081604436,
0.3452422619,
0.0606524423,
-0.2929991782,
-0.6997226477,
0.0819824487,
0.1911863536,
1.0215717554,
-0.7797412872,
0.6807779074,
-0.1163845658,
-0.597617209,
-0.8291114569,
0.3559758663,
-0.1842453778,
0.1523893923,
0.4157221913,
-0.2836919427,
-0.8626146317,
-0.9347304106,
-0.119495824,
-0.1460671723,
-0.3185877204,
0.3611041307,
0.3236800432,
-0.5513623357,
1.043022275,
-0.4973845482,
-0.5758247972,
-0.6074261069,
0.4122831225,
0.2091094553,
0.6468307972,
0.2805351317,
-1.2678776979,
-0.1725330949,
0.1451952606,
-1.0195641518,
-0.1087996215,
-0.7156713605,
-0.0590327159,
0.2312492728,
0.4608239233,
-0.4205045402,
0.3862830997,
0.2530158162,
-0.0047975574,
0.3139947653,
-0.1653285325,
0.0267762113,
-0.8597674966,
0.2928075194,
0.259052515,
-0.0557678342,
-0.5915132761,
0.1878549308,
-0.3179829419,
-0.3687334359,
0.0775969923,
0.1738666594,
-0.4576432407,
-0.1111266315,
-0.1697998494,
0.0028979934,
-0.0104893055,
0.1298406869,
-0.0823836848,
0.7271139026,
0.4143411219,
-0.7686282396,
0.8658094406,
0.593331635,
-0.4148600698,
0.676012814,
-0.6759982705,
-0.001142998,
-0.2209661752,
-0.0765726268,
-0.2168756425,
-0.0382800251,
0.0465174019,
-0.3738459349,
0.3488941193,
0.0814883783,
-0.488139987,
-0.4303114712,
-0.1811808497,
0.1111924276,
0.4048339128,
-0.3191275597,
0.8460677862,
0.4636461139,
-0.2892331481,
-0.7022377849,
-0.8710343838,
0.4484654963,
-0.3228652477,
-0.5984417796,
0.5506213307,
0.1980820596,
-0.278370738,
0.1730023623,
-0.1902886182,
-0.3859088421,
0.4411956966,
0.2113604993,
0.172817871,
-0.0192689039,
0.0335001238,
-0.1349529326,
-0.4974938631,
0.2856539786,
-0.1339862645,
0.0851314366,
0.0234273486,
-0.3547464609,
-0.4974312186,
0.6838248968,
0.6077281237,
-0.0800958499,
0.6153615713,
0.5076810718,
-0.5212779641,
-0.4282840192,
-0.2548978031,
-0.1306427717,
-0.4159468114,
0.6044190526,
-0.4083454311,
-0.3804135323,
0.2896792591,
-0.280202955,
0.6228976846,
0.3574513495,
0.3482093215,
-0.3796313405,
0.6864690781,
1.091557622,
-0.5378745198,
0.5282312632,
-0.3054016829,
0.6463832259,
-0.755651772,
-0.1325006634,
-0.7623093128,
-0.385699898,
-0.4281971157,
0.0584673509,
0.2038912028,
-0.1516719908,
-0.2528445721,
0.3796245754,
-0.4460944831,
0.3384715617,
0.5352191925,
-0.209751606,
0.1822898239,
-0.0668510273,
0.5866658092,
-0.1123135164,
-0.6690077186,
-0.4790231287,
0.9172666669,
0.4698906243,
1.0338971615,
-0.0769859552,
0.5228534341,
0.8448501229,
0.0441473424,
-0.6515294909,
0.3139333427,
-0.2409553826,
-0.7476539612,
-0.4109930098,
-0.4282947481,
-0.9411284924,
-0.1533101946,
-0.2878378332,
-0.2946868539,
0.0865057185,
0.0970460325,
-0.2911123335,
0.1228110865,
-0.8620861173,
0.895544529,
-0.364297837,
0.019660065,
-0.310459286,
-0.6379132271,
-0.0328054726,
-0.1074176505,
-0.0157951843,
0.0638454631,
-0.0946776569,
0.5917460918,
-0.0937867835,
0.7112296224,
0.0186213981,
0.0893009529,
0.1921318918,
-0.3391484618,
0.4143057168,
-0.2774263918,
-0.1575265825,
0.0137799717,
0.2934863269,
-0.5110396147,
-0.797531426,
0.3498345912,
-0.6024600267,
-0.5647438765,
-0.4418256283,
-0.4676651061,
-0.3804448843,
-0.0884986147,
0.0936141536,
0.1322734952,
-0.1843067855,
0.4578156471,
0.853998065,
-0.4279361069,
0.0617603585,
-0.0299232397,
0.0767812505,
-0.1428575069,
0.8878609538,
0.1206917912,
0.1236808449,
0.3166345358,
-0.3910378218,
-0.1697820127,
-0.3474314213,
-0.4125826359,
-0.2065702826,
-0.5336769819,
-0.1553301364,
-0.329015404,
-0.4883725345,
-0.1674802452,
-0.5004440546,
-0.3252173662,
-0.1224182025,
-0.482383877,
-0.0933736712,
0.2467436641,
0.6968314052,
0.2429195493,
-0.1864771694,
-0.7709434628,
0.3769283295,
0.0203772038,
0.3136126697,
0.0543838888,
-0.0927132592,
-0.3366635144,
-0.1312471777,
-0.3229829371,
-0.5500353575,
0.3162780106,
0.0540364534,
0.7678354383,
-0.1575154215,
0.2021818608,
0.4411017001,
-0.3555679321,
0.6279361844,
-0.283978045,
-0.8836840987,
0.692073226,
0.0769923627,
-0.3254080713,
0.7596510649,
0.5279786587,
-0.8289846778,
-0.2362122387,
-0.5435547233,
-1.5388873816,
0.451164186,
0.2264352888,
0.3119308949,
0.4331309497,
0.6216756105,
-0.0512776747,
0.3576698899,
-0.638818562,
-0.2876342833,
0.0838064104,
-0.562471509,
0.1761368811,
0.0060233413,
-0.0659347326,
-0.0013103689,
0.8412674665,
0.0821619853,
0.138188526,
-0.0455878377,
-0.1542633921,
0.4507514238,
0.2668436468,
0.2178484499,
0.4086783826,
0.0631456748,
-0.3562450409,
0.0624824353,
-0.4584611058,
0.1030955985,
-0.1138006225,
-0.2865026891,
-0.1141036227,
0.3216328919,
0.5773743987,
-0.1511338353,
-0.6861634851,
0.0207985844,
0.1759489328,
-0.1859361678,
-0.5787188411,
0.2478437424,
-0.2298838943,
0.1708160937,
0.4559197724,
-0.1657093465,
0.1568854302,
-0.5051805377,
0.3437834084,
0.309671998,
-0.1900195628,
0.254111886,
0.4963186979,
0.4008693993,
-0.1736575812,
1.155933857,
0.0832982883,
-0.2461480051,
1.0032624006,
0.372474581,
1.1246327162,
-0.1264776886,
-0.0330652148,
-0.0803790092,
0.6490741372,
0.2118353248,
0.3268556595,
0.2011055201,
-0.668294847,
-0.1457689404,
-0.3296711147,
-0.7409903407,
0.1893534213,
-0.6927942038,
0.140103966,
-0.5044547915,
-0.094943963,
0.0620168485,
0.2155981958,
-0.6079841256,
0.3315566778,
-0.0849260017,
0.8603593111,
-0.9562681317,
0.2860301435,
0.7424907684,
-0.5905255675,
-0.4083639383,
-0.0883926898,
-0.0088343099,
-0.632402122,
0.4709920883,
-0.0525940657,
0.2023018003,
-0.0113385916,
-0.3618226051,
-0.4190662801,
0.8337432742,
0.1369521022,
-0.28346017,
0.0434974805,
0.3103447556,
0.5279861093,
-0.2994552553,
-0.193085283,
0.8085100651,
0.5884894133,
-0.2769140899,
-0.3469587862,
-0.3604514301,
-0.2903975546,
0.1383703053,
0.2783638835,
-0.3441112339,
0.3108634055,
0.075717546,
-0.2636955082,
-0.0696071386,
0.6978655457,
0.1110331267,
0.6157802343,
0.4464926422,
0.5688202977,
0.7104818225,
-0.1928402632,
0.9281808138,
-0.3231040537,
0.1252934337,
1.0064406395,
-0.577906251,
0.8190854788,
0.5888893604,
-0.47669819,
0.4222227633,
0.8334902525,
-0.4761138856,
0.0537739582,
0.446331054,
-0.2909837961,
0.1243077368,
-0.0295395534,
-0.2748984396,
0.2386017293,
0.4706912339,
-0.0870195031,
-0.0346930437,
0.2016847879,
-0.3849096298,
0.0692568868,
-0.1749696285,
0.8607289195,
0.133276552,
-0.4117028713,
-0.0607335456,
0.0599905401,
0.387026161,
-0.61526227,
-0.0804193094,
-0.1959644407,
0.2150771618,
-0.5047926307,
-1.0590217113,
1.0400463343,
0.2451435775,
-0.6480451226,
-0.5565658808,
0.3415355682,
-0.0153997187,
-0.2594128549,
0.2135533243,
0.2224452347,
0.0573236831,
-0.084307462,
-0.9001533389,
0.0074654063,
0.120623216,
-0.3207882345,
0.1517756432,
0.5580693483,
0.0051805614,
1.1157752275,
0.210239619,
-0.0335877426,
-0.0322401896,
0.0814793035,
0.4980019331,
-0.8417539597,
-0.2414726615,
-0.6190968752,
0.3462684155,
-0.1267367899,
-0.0683637336,
0.4315010011,
0.6644448042,
0.6249972582,
0.0340417288,
1.0178103447,
-0.4508229792,
0.4498743713,
-0.59139961,
0.7013677955,
-0.6420209408,
0.3895494044,
-0.1352012157,
-0.9325813651,
-0.2371503413,
0.5136255622,
-0.189575702,
0.2323084325,
0.4968779385,
0.5688832998,
0.2851423025,
0.1817638129,
0.0808710083,
-0.0755919069,
0.419690609,
0.6413639188,
0.5730219483,
-0.6119727492,
0.4403570592,
0.0554093011,
-0.1560172886,
0.0073680519,
-0.6519995928,
-0.1313354075,
-0.96111238,
-0.5662988424,
-0.2330628783,
-0.1364653856,
0.7258639932,
0.5732193589,
-0.8579204082,
-0.2248602808,
-0.3148595691,
0.4297105372,
-0.4509262741,
-0.2900489867,
-0.0126040028,
-0.8404475451,
-0.7372216582,
0.2322559506,
0.3952945471,
0.1776975095,
-0.284421891,
0.161185056,
-0.0191027224,
-0.077251263,
0.4254870713,
0.6361550689,
-0.1826272309,
-0.1788127273,
-0.287558198,
-0.0370407179,
-0.0432223752,
0.8504575491,
-0.7002246976,
0.1559267491,
0.4006702602,
1.4817318916,
0.3314647079,
-0.0489025787,
0.9750172496,
-0.8347582817,
-0.1319907904,
0.4457487464,
0.0544444844,
0.3295374513,
-0.683609128,
0.8817047477,
0.2887475789,
-0.7871724963,
-0.8510578871,
0.3385526836,
-0.8279520273,
-0.1659018397,
0.5433073044,
0.0513286926,
-0.0299302656,
-0.610283494,
0.0540272817,
-0.0438697934,
0.1642557681,
0.8788740039,
0.9649673104,
-0.3552771509,
-0.0976566523,
-0.9577895999,
0.5865979195,
0.7220167518,
-1.3367792368,
0.4279519618,
0.3512558043,
-0.1425068229,
0.1521807909,
0.3194983006,
0.0328563079,
-0.0126716644,
0.2563201189,
0.1812544912,
0.2918000519,
-0.5849507451,
-0.3676239848,
0.1609560847,
0.0234002676,
-0.4070648849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16973v1
|
Successfully Guiding Humans with Imperfect Instructions by Highlighting Potential Errors and Suggesting Corrections
| 2024-02-26T19:16:04 | 2024-02-26T19:16:04 |
Lingjun Zhao, Khanh Nguyen, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This paper addresses the challenge of leveraging imperfect language models to
guide human decision-making in the context of a grounded navigation task. We
show that an imperfect instruction generation model can be complemented with an
effective communication mechanism to become more successful at guiding humans.
The communication mechanism we build comprises models that can detect potential
hallucinations in instructions and suggest practical alternatives, and an
intuitive interface to present that information to users. We show that this
approach reduces the human navigation error by up to 29% with no additional
cognitive burden. This result underscores the potential of integrating diverse
communication channels into AI systems to compensate for their imperfections
and enhance their utility for humans.
|
[
-0.1829251796,
-0.7323777676,
1.1399352551,
0.1693575233,
-0.270568043,
-0.0890077204,
-0.2488607466,
-0.10515102,
0.0766708627,
0.4544779658,
-0.860337317,
-0.508652091,
-0.3198444247,
-0.143403545,
-0.1587800533,
0.4493375123,
0.0612752102,
0.1554948241,
-0.2046281248,
-0.0189625192,
-1.1097838879,
-0.361127764,
-0.6238673329,
-0.6089727283,
0.245683521,
0.8449687958,
1.0734616518,
0.5151899457,
0.1623104662,
0.2978591025,
-0.0179418232,
0.5492733717,
-0.4961349964,
0.1077155396,
-0.5115914941,
-0.8173211813,
-0.4090792239,
0.0440379493,
0.316862613,
1.1467559338,
-0.4531794488,
-0.3825753629,
0.0862651244,
0.7527204156,
-0.3417329192,
0.1312756985,
-0.3143708706,
0.0173221044,
0.0914077759,
-0.5210677385,
-0.6601697803,
-0.3060824275,
0.2000398487,
-0.8422991037,
0.148008734,
0.3848159313,
0.7581527233,
0.6581833363,
-0.1957951039,
-0.5679289103,
-0.9613637328,
0.577252984,
-0.5970755816,
0.4884184897,
0.8584797382,
0.296225369,
-0.6601487398,
-0.6160449386,
-0.4118920267,
-0.4257206917,
0.0444529727,
0.0963817686,
-0.0399368107,
0.5367008448,
0.1378154755,
-0.1898826957,
-0.1882689744,
0.1215548888,
-0.543258667,
-0.0849082321,
0.4533030093,
0.185009867,
0.5371891856,
-0.0508535169,
0.1417211443,
-0.2843975723,
-0.6380706429,
-0.178844735,
0.4937919378,
0.4515489042,
-0.2493831515,
0.4074393213,
-0.2381011546,
1.0896937847,
0.3800012767,
0.1574376673,
-0.0211916752,
-0.1228756905,
-0.1324067265,
0.3233195245,
0.1486963034,
0.6806727052,
0.1105505303,
-0.4250250459,
-0.2212291956,
0.1905136406,
1.1489554644,
-0.2787539959,
-0.4920987189,
0.1303606778,
-0.4578391016,
-0.2006908655,
0.1813115627,
-0.7309120297,
-0.5456007123,
-0.4891656339,
0.328096211,
-0.4784110785,
-0.0650446638,
0.3086910844,
-0.1545397341,
0.4335009158,
0.7010908127,
-0.8002467752,
0.2592657506,
0.5928211808,
0.8207253814,
0.3301148713,
-0.3192075789,
-0.3866040111,
-0.071024932,
-0.6457691193,
0.7379573584,
-0.452129364,
-0.758644104,
-0.2352935225,
-0.1108515039,
-0.0613213293,
-0.3696779907,
1.1159178019,
-0.0567734949,
0.3103718758,
-0.5103757977,
-0.3116224408,
-0.7663078904,
0.0363390781,
-0.4231494069,
0.3498668969,
0.1820331216,
-0.1969711035,
0.0658377856,
-0.7217794657,
-0.6213438511,
0.1012024283,
-0.2534857094,
-0.2530846596,
0.2836003304,
0.1840515882,
0.2713835835,
-0.1250958443,
0.3462805748,
0.0158137027,
-0.740704298,
-0.0099816564,
-0.6673112512,
0.7265073657,
0.0409210101,
-1.0745735168,
0.0723633394,
-0.6495017409,
0.0082996907,
0.0341379382,
-0.4346676767,
-0.3981354833,
0.5662221313,
-0.2397918701,
0.0391524471,
-0.1543117762,
0.0541287549,
0.3204787672,
-0.523504436,
0.3191730082,
0.8816484809,
0.0120736584,
0.7112062573,
-0.4126422703,
0.3648348451,
0.0281401873,
0.3903465271,
-0.3169252872,
-0.8221420646,
-1.3461011648,
0.3855487406,
-0.033842165,
0.6986029148,
-0.8550286889,
0.5304883122,
-0.1649741381,
-0.448748827,
-0.9036804438,
-0.1421889961,
0.5262514949,
0.605316937,
0.4843716025,
-0.0423011407,
-0.5604169965,
-0.5760645866,
-0.1818411201,
-0.5354463458,
0.0451764576,
0.5632941723,
0.0810885578,
-0.5694032907,
0.6044214964,
-0.2051358372,
-0.1436871737,
0.0478637293,
0.1917793006,
-0.0877128467,
0.6849219799,
0.2483410686,
-1.0147166252,
0.0339184403,
0.1550618708,
-1.0748178959,
-0.0189088155,
-0.701441884,
-0.2875050902,
0.064829044,
0.5046738386,
-0.4800896943,
0.6705763936,
0.1246875152,
-0.6472021341,
0.1448214948,
-0.5510309935,
0.497998625,
-0.6817109585,
-0.3294527233,
-0.0582118817,
-0.223042205,
-0.7728103399,
0.1046111211,
-0.0776803792,
0.0435255282,
-0.2254773974,
0.3264357448,
-0.6959555149,
0.2366039753,
-0.2135060281,
0.3558278978,
-0.1360525191,
0.5430659652,
-0.1131831259,
0.5585625768,
0.596204102,
-0.58157897,
0.3108258247,
0.3926746845,
0.0961097777,
0.9652295709,
-0.4933257103,
0.3207297623,
-0.4460036159,
0.0442358516,
-0.8909967542,
-0.5796869397,
0.7566644549,
-0.557295382,
0.3574124277,
-0.1703020185,
0.0143606272,
-0.2870217264,
-0.0044086552,
0.0287668519,
0.6668885946,
-0.5782650709,
0.9794406295,
0.0532233827,
0.301844418,
-0.0859069601,
-0.7139931917,
0.4438021481,
-0.1576216668,
-0.7128821015,
0.2940645814,
-0.1738191843,
-0.3330162466,
-0.0518451557,
-0.2153461426,
0.0329762101,
0.3619086444,
0.8677597046,
0.2100428194,
-0.215495795,
-0.2234217674,
0.1330424398,
0.0378715619,
0.1757263392,
-0.5891607404,
0.3219511509,
-0.4015580416,
-0.7826479077,
-0.8640908599,
0.2768868506,
0.8907247186,
0.3238755167,
0.7628691196,
0.1143087298,
-0.438401103,
-0.074425593,
-0.6591689587,
-0.4281436801,
-0.5358020067,
0.0395542867,
-0.1858604252,
-0.2774384618,
0.2709338665,
-0.3154012859,
-0.0232262295,
-0.02481791,
0.1008300632,
-0.21456635,
1.2507491112,
0.9000437856,
0.3038525581,
0.228303805,
0.0125731891,
0.5029745102,
-0.4815593958,
-0.6617105007,
-0.4240911603,
-0.2411717623,
-0.4319831729,
-0.576444447,
0.4166663885,
0.3934042156,
-0.0182529073,
0.0929462314,
-0.808993876,
0.3095806837,
0.9926694632,
0.4358197749,
0.0013060487,
0.0246094111,
-0.3539040685,
-0.07320261,
-1.1685482264,
-0.9581650496,
0.6317471266,
0.2496767044,
0.898984313,
-0.1474789083,
0.7400830984,
0.4449951649,
0.2376493216,
-0.5436283946,
0.432056576,
0.4941982031,
-0.169017151,
-0.252563864,
-0.3444072008,
-0.7048147321,
0.095462583,
-0.3651961684,
-0.6355943084,
0.3229997158,
0.3451881111,
-0.5624322295,
0.1941138655,
-1.1976553202,
0.8475968242,
-0.4883860946,
-0.3122008443,
-0.0808617994,
-0.8159784675,
0.3118390739,
0.0824531466,
0.2363598496,
0.35627985,
0.1070978418,
0.6239153147,
-0.3324244618,
1.0533305407,
-0.3185048997,
0.1544173807,
0.2793488801,
0.0893875435,
0.5436291099,
-0.2445922494,
-0.0401662029,
0.0905519947,
-0.68256706,
-0.3969923854,
-0.673566401,
0.426382035,
-0.7199419141,
-0.8053101301,
-0.2211560905,
-0.199521929,
-0.0098962719,
0.1229028329,
0.4348104894,
0.2615903616,
-0.1503727734,
-0.1974352449,
0.584471643,
-0.3427132964,
0.2401933223,
0.4797264338,
0.2615384758,
-0.0885068178,
0.9006391168,
-0.1563870311,
0.1350802034,
-0.1613072604,
-0.1067678407,
-0.2187593579,
-0.6180702448,
-0.6895004511,
0.2162016481,
-0.9385056496,
-0.0380335301,
-0.4514934421,
-0.050311055,
0.0892762765,
-0.7221696377,
-0.4870350957,
-0.0939600393,
-0.8106624484,
-0.2740615308,
-0.0786304399,
1.0161446333,
-0.2088931352,
0.5898580551,
-0.6193425655,
0.1556341052,
0.1355869919,
0.084448263,
0.2850844264,
-0.3482759893,
-0.0287309308,
0.7815276384,
-0.4637833536,
-1.0497359037,
0.091090031,
-0.0619994514,
0.8604229093,
0.5688456297,
0.1837768108,
0.9221535921,
-0.723420918,
0.8957579136,
0.2190711051,
-1.0874636173,
0.9679486156,
-0.2817238569,
0.2462990284,
0.4552733004,
0.3016698062,
-0.7067705393,
-0.5450994372,
-0.6854430437,
-0.8339784145,
0.8005354404,
0.4899506569,
0.0583919697,
-0.0176490843,
0.5762793422,
-0.3382602334,
-0.1390825808,
-0.5643016696,
-0.4042529166,
-0.3044358194,
-0.0569824539,
0.1831225455,
-0.0738206804,
-0.1861023754,
-0.1488025486,
0.7025376558,
-0.0105878413,
0.3891375661,
0.4526103139,
0.07687819,
-0.3104147017,
0.0396925695,
1.1796386242,
0.8289169073,
-0.0223472603,
0.1494971365,
0.0743349344,
-0.4342333376,
0.3547101915,
-0.130115509,
-0.3327868581,
0.0098773595,
0.3441686928,
1.0020568371,
0.2999303937,
-0.6742218733,
0.2725490034,
-0.3498058319,
-0.0721096247,
0.0144426469,
0.4767815769,
0.0960978046,
0.3370556533,
0.457275182,
0.6889689565,
0.0066929837,
-0.4696776867,
0.300444901,
0.1716653705,
-0.7033680081,
-0.3617557287,
0.8968450427,
0.6228210926,
-1.0240391493,
0.8878118396,
-0.509416163,
-0.7645022273,
0.39312011,
0.212904945,
0.7919978499,
-0.4845802784,
0.4544750452,
0.1083515286,
0.8877369761,
-0.6562081575,
0.0263528135,
-0.2288136929,
-0.4963572323,
-0.1256560236,
-0.1744239032,
-0.4742873013,
-0.343795985,
-0.499930203,
0.1998326629,
-0.3707939386,
-0.0337421075,
-0.3277789652,
-0.6274452209,
-0.4737705588,
0.2075492442,
0.3640464842,
0.4969373047,
-0.6802007556,
0.3783490062,
0.8292853832,
-0.4868029058,
-0.9381276965,
0.2877892554,
0.0603063554,
-0.4364897311,
0.4026759267,
0.129762277,
-0.476302892,
-0.0481745675,
-0.6356785893,
-0.4620637596,
0.7331179976,
0.3212473691,
-0.4634628296,
-0.3684804142,
-0.0427652895,
0.3873896599,
-0.2278072983,
0.1440565586,
0.5334507227,
0.7542707324,
0.0651933104,
-0.8025667667,
0.1243951395,
-0.1607624292,
-0.0701848119,
-0.0809593871,
-0.3584879041,
0.5256974101,
-0.5798667073,
-0.5564943552,
0.0681829154,
0.5802456737,
0.1022644043,
0.4071213007,
0.3932967186,
0.2722339034,
1.1865906715,
-0.2091785818,
0.9953165054,
-0.0450194553,
-0.0726649463,
0.9117441177,
-0.0204393193,
0.4608316123,
0.5418340564,
0.3308639526,
0.605901897,
0.5708574057,
0.3083428442,
0.6851044893,
0.070924297,
-0.1377902478,
-0.3522165418,
0.1161690801,
-0.2449636161,
0.4626354575,
0.5708470941,
-0.113601014,
-0.2540650368,
0.2751030326,
-0.0178254303,
0.406121552,
-0.2489367872,
0.5813325644,
0.0187233649,
-1.2712138891,
1.0876598358,
0.325735569,
0.5823454857,
-0.1542261392,
-0.5391828418,
-0.3435789645,
0.1358180195,
-0.2401428968,
-0.4277148247,
0.2207304537,
-0.2331138104,
-0.105662182,
-0.237011373,
0.6069552898,
-0.304947257,
-0.2820456326,
0.1785361767,
0.4134970009,
0.1675440222,
-0.1064166278,
-0.6507928967,
0.2596205771,
0.4346892834,
0.1743395627,
-0.2723712921,
0.3545278013,
-0.1065169126,
1.0167919397,
0.5270053744,
0.0260051936,
0.2756616771,
-0.1618803293,
0.7639437318,
-0.7920355201,
-0.6920479536,
-0.8153544068,
0.7398814559,
-0.2396738231,
-0.1598032117,
0.752892375,
0.1550817788,
0.7686476111,
-0.0571487732,
0.6802381277,
0.2120123059,
-0.0140775526,
-0.6117035151,
0.7125692368,
-0.4052694738,
0.6030740142,
-0.1402214468,
-0.848982513,
-0.2256791145,
1.2205393314,
-0.0825794339,
0.1479634196,
0.628510952,
0.9193232656,
-0.2376978099,
0.2528729439,
0.3869403899,
0.1871894896,
0.2189357281,
0.5887471437,
1.1109592915,
-0.4730460644,
0.1460280269,
-0.1084944382,
-0.364708364,
-0.5615771413,
-0.6065946817,
-1.1462874413,
-0.5940515399,
-0.2845474184,
-0.4547052085,
0.6489591599,
0.8513306975,
1.1630586386,
-0.3380672336,
-0.1168929935,
-0.6463003159,
0.5380578041,
-0.256036669,
-0.1623846591,
-0.0759823769,
-0.4328673184,
-0.5981942415,
0.7713153958,
0.435806185,
0.329764843,
-0.4320558608,
-0.6118143201,
-0.060648635,
0.1671275795,
0.2907991111,
0.2897094488,
-1.0837292671,
-0.3870635629,
-0.0632307455,
-0.0971359313,
0.0304795019,
0.8440333605,
-0.6289842129,
0.5898593664,
-0.1205431446,
0.5766587257,
0.177506417,
0.1339245439,
0.9153859019,
-0.5966118574,
0.3440445364,
0.391644448,
0.0978619829,
0.7554315925,
-0.7781702876,
0.513325572,
0.1788320988,
-0.4661497176,
-0.7615677118,
-0.1557979137,
-0.892490685,
-0.483279556,
1.1037976742,
0.0021414664,
-0.4283356965,
-0.4232945442,
-0.6149249673,
0.1343402117,
-0.3524600267,
0.9679822922,
0.7709111571,
-0.027120851,
0.0289473124,
-0.7339502573,
0.6264549494,
0.4655202925,
-0.8122304082,
-0.1178338602,
0.7834402323,
-0.1444453448,
0.336379379,
0.5114771128,
0.437472254,
0.5795277357,
0.3129829764,
-0.2140466571,
0.0004991414,
-0.6417611241,
-0.2805351913,
-0.1236910447,
0.2006289214,
-0.339846313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16846v2
|
GROUNDHOG: Grounding Large Language Models to Holistic Segmentation
| 2024-02-26T18:59:33 | 2024-04-16T17:59:53 |
Yichi Zhang, Ziqiao Ma, Xiaofeng Gao, Suhaila Shakiah, Qiaozi Gao, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Most multimodal large language models (MLLMs) learn language-to-object
grounding through causal language modeling where grounded objects are captured
by bounding boxes as sequences of location tokens. This paradigm lacks
pixel-level representations that are important for fine-grained visual
understanding and diagnosis. In this work, we introduce GROUNDHOG, an MLLM
developed by grounding Large Language Models to holistic segmentation.
GROUNDHOG incorporates a masked feature extractor and converts extracted
features into visual entity tokens for the MLLM backbone, which then connects
groundable phrases to unified grounding masks by retrieving and merging the
entity masks. To train GROUNDHOG, we carefully curated M3G2, a grounded visual
instruction tuning dataset with Multi-Modal Multi-Grained Grounding, by
harvesting a collection of segmentation-grounded datasets with rich
annotations. Our experimental results show that GROUNDHOG achieves superior
performance on various language grounding tasks without task-specific
fine-tuning, and significantly reduces object hallucination. GROUNDHOG also
demonstrates better grounding towards complex forms of visual input and
provides easy-to-understand diagnosis in failure cases.
|
[
-0.3767817318,
-1.1992812157,
0.3142578602,
0.1864517927,
-0.5686362386,
-0.0490593687,
-0.2683629692,
-0.3340007961,
-0.2430619895,
0.6769322753,
-0.2915945649,
-0.9263427854,
-0.5822114348,
-0.4123157859,
-0.0579215363,
0.7767099142,
0.267854929,
0.037745852,
-0.2737896442,
-0.3012447655,
-0.8817629218,
-0.4343794882,
-0.5502046943,
-0.3626230061,
0.4466813803,
0.4507911503,
0.7271262407,
0.9568796158,
0.2759623528,
0.2584070563,
-0.0024570255,
0.313813597,
-0.3576913774,
-0.0282804985,
-0.2011857182,
-0.2151999325,
-0.2165963054,
-0.0510603301,
0.5225413442,
0.7376875877,
-0.1181541756,
0.1415454596,
-0.1909542829,
0.6440006495,
-0.7335932851,
0.2904601693,
-0.6817513704,
0.1007043347,
-0.18199718,
-0.2202015668,
-0.5336141586,
0.2321724296,
-0.172862336,
-0.7612041831,
0.1138288155,
0.182443127,
0.9724138975,
0.3727096021,
-0.260086298,
0.0886778012,
-0.3092716336,
0.7274891734,
-0.4521211386,
0.4911647439,
0.4087902308,
0.4776283205,
-0.0344609059,
-0.4366925657,
-0.0488379709,
-0.2778619528,
0.0723835602,
0.0249130558,
-0.0015014306,
0.1695883274,
0.4520340562,
0.2223918289,
-0.4343951941,
0.0871230513,
-0.069887802,
-0.3558757305,
0.1119483188,
0.117537789,
0.3839665055,
-0.0321237594,
-0.144736737,
-0.0082076658,
-0.604890883,
0.15896146,
0.0499906167,
0.2338258624,
0.1446831375,
0.5474085808,
-0.2720153928,
1.290699482,
0.1878359318,
-0.4971958399,
0.0092404019,
0.2883221209,
-0.4684382975,
0.1831882596,
0.3136247396,
0.7241544724,
0.1838231236,
-0.1818839461,
-0.0855485722,
0.207331121,
0.0871794075,
-0.7882586122,
-0.3486045599,
-0.0273373872,
-0.483122021,
-0.1851131469,
0.1407122761,
-0.6838721037,
-0.4938915968,
-0.5740814209,
0.1527174115,
-0.5356500745,
-0.299375087,
0.4241118133,
-0.2484549284,
0.4660484791,
0.5406777263,
-0.8437893391,
0.0941669866,
0.8461515307,
0.8498277664,
0.1378994584,
-0.4813090861,
-1.0522050858,
0.538076818,
-0.5103759766,
0.9403704405,
-0.7703130245,
-0.0441605337,
-0.1761808544,
0.2992964685,
0.0485693254,
-0.6354660392,
0.1629575342,
-0.3828395307,
-0.0491373725,
-0.3685392439,
-0.0949987844,
-0.5455262065,
0.5729061365,
-0.4074969292,
1.0076524019,
0.1260115206,
-0.9567992091,
0.5390598178,
-0.2403216511,
-0.5066576004,
0.0613562278,
-0.1424196661,
-0.369469583,
0.198746115,
0.2784143984,
0.6796378493,
-0.2256903052,
0.7336109877,
-0.43658638,
-0.3952334225,
-0.4295875728,
-0.3023732305,
0.5102996826,
-0.1463585943,
-0.5508373976,
0.3754531145,
-0.9063345194,
-0.112570554,
0.1704171002,
-0.2421969026,
-0.5251733661,
0.1487937719,
0.327552855,
0.445661366,
-0.0096114706,
-0.1471183598,
-0.0087731881,
-0.3331872821,
0.3679916263,
0.4102347195,
-0.1713862568,
0.201994881,
-0.2272272855,
0.0878312737,
0.2658845782,
-0.0551064312,
-0.6544000506,
-0.6125463843,
-0.883955121,
-0.4414061308,
-0.1303184479,
0.5474203229,
-0.4292508066,
0.7819533348,
-0.0782383233,
-0.3754836917,
-0.2169548869,
-0.0612166487,
0.3912143111,
0.7597801685,
0.4777058065,
-0.0568439066,
-0.5201647282,
-0.9845011234,
0.0486534275,
-0.0891040489,
0.0700263083,
0.289986372,
0.2143150568,
-0.550183475,
0.9485379457,
-0.3559980989,
-0.3130474985,
-0.0037881155,
0.0948896185,
-0.1603586376,
0.5715661645,
0.2565324605,
-0.5336786509,
-0.209799394,
0.4641780555,
-0.9940792918,
-0.0498769619,
-0.0490066074,
-0.2031297386,
-0.0666451007,
0.5817278624,
-0.7512108088,
0.3751915097,
0.4855032861,
-0.4269375801,
0.4303101301,
-0.1683420688,
0.0003048333,
-0.7670522928,
0.2299430817,
-0.110130474,
-0.5458081961,
-0.3151353002,
0.1007472575,
-0.0497761518,
-0.4123912752,
-0.2983519435,
0.4716640413,
-0.6378446221,
-0.4225155711,
-0.3505840898,
-0.0169595797,
0.3507834971,
0.3996607959,
0.1785580814,
0.719052732,
0.9856582284,
-0.5118899941,
0.2903556824,
0.1451379359,
-0.0759624615,
0.5386177897,
-0.5901572704,
0.083254464,
-0.2852308154,
0.1082878634,
-0.7202095389,
-0.3988396227,
0.3799494207,
-0.0355661735,
0.4049482644,
-0.3360309005,
-0.4211029708,
-0.1381162256,
-0.0612711571,
0.2420527339,
0.4228637218,
-0.5143657327,
0.6176487803,
0.539255321,
0.3565736115,
-0.3586328924,
-0.4152494967,
0.2483393103,
-0.5068646073,
-0.7423866987,
-0.0539994314,
0.2086464912,
-0.2836742699,
-0.3231195509,
-0.0623476394,
0.055346854,
0.4219854176,
0.474889487,
-0.1951665133,
-0.5497201681,
0.2494610548,
-0.0765652731,
-0.5260292888,
0.0510497168,
-0.553034842,
0.6723067164,
-0.327249676,
-0.5815551877,
-0.132434845,
0.4546595514,
0.7759671807,
-0.5542969108,
0.3358670473,
0.8926121593,
-0.5235785842,
0.0967550054,
-0.6504700184,
-0.0378774181,
-0.4124648869,
0.4088745713,
-0.48290658,
-0.7481012344,
0.3103219271,
-0.3591445982,
-0.0126297213,
0.449798286,
0.5442572832,
0.2127959281,
1.2481534481,
0.6204336882,
-0.036826171,
0.4481333792,
-0.0950300992,
-0.1770782769,
-0.8582397103,
-0.4093010724,
-0.1719695479,
0.16989097,
-0.0149795003,
-0.7892386317,
0.018904319,
0.6684837341,
-0.1625098586,
-0.1877036393,
-0.6224397421,
0.6225923896,
0.3764768839,
0.2632642984,
0.0823241398,
0.2517952621,
-0.1640501618,
-0.0629783794,
-0.5225002766,
-0.7134703398,
0.5463563204,
0.5192568302,
0.6531453133,
-0.4759698808,
0.1894904524,
0.0074000205,
0.3275168836,
-1.0476824045,
0.3643256426,
-0.0599204563,
-0.3472720087,
-0.3281848133,
0.0693109408,
-0.6715868115,
0.5587956309,
0.0363522545,
-0.7488977313,
-0.1070887521,
0.2618738711,
-0.1100273877,
0.2605034411,
-0.5587649345,
1.1872458458,
-0.2951208055,
-0.4904818833,
-0.0815533102,
-0.8198478818,
0.4761464298,
0.1441020519,
0.2497315854,
-0.5008537769,
0.2093460411,
0.7821419835,
-0.0692768991,
0.9106877446,
-0.4214691222,
-0.2211304754,
0.1829320937,
0.0513296872,
0.3956673145,
0.4347015917,
0.2504879832,
0.4596510231,
-0.3616014421,
-0.4794539809,
-0.411383599,
0.435095042,
-0.6367214322,
-0.7061849833,
-0.2036007494,
-0.286958158,
-0.2796987593,
0.4640775323,
0.2144109309,
0.6670026183,
-0.1961358786,
0.3815094531,
0.7632600069,
-0.2627136409,
0.2548839152,
0.3674907386,
-0.4368733168,
-0.5183623433,
1.0021224022,
-0.1586297899,
-0.0716807768,
0.3990775943,
0.3612115979,
0.0552262738,
-0.5298774242,
-0.8217127919,
0.1873070598,
-0.8788208961,
-0.222880289,
-1.0420576334,
0.0155446511,
-0.0161140952,
-0.3496411145,
-0.4645619094,
0.2627452016,
-0.598803997,
-0.0865164176,
0.2629238367,
0.4854862988,
0.0414453074,
0.5011543632,
-0.7652233839,
0.578986764,
0.4866437018,
0.2388419509,
-0.1637014896,
-0.3606633246,
-0.4408740103,
0.1119658574,
-0.15705432,
-0.7836329341,
0.2387981713,
0.2147767693,
0.5459520817,
0.6582354307,
-0.3845369816,
1.2924282551,
-0.7731107473,
0.5505109429,
0.4492282569,
-1.0339791775,
0.6934684515,
-0.6749637723,
0.3638727069,
0.4569278955,
-0.2365692109,
-0.6247606277,
-0.3382182419,
-0.2414155453,
-0.7138708234,
0.6494191289,
-0.2540723681,
-0.07667505,
-0.073649846,
0.0451696105,
0.2533543408,
0.2160759568,
-0.5357248187,
-0.0866161063,
-0.6070542336,
-0.0029441894,
-0.3619595468,
-0.3973250687,
-0.3418310285,
-0.5252931118,
0.2208681405,
-0.4864999652,
0.0572586656,
-0.0177079644,
-0.4477246702,
-0.3223454356,
-0.136937812,
0.6975907683,
0.7874136567,
-0.2534851432,
0.428584516,
-0.0500778109,
-0.344524771,
0.1568043828,
-0.1019320264,
0.0499755554,
0.2046809047,
0.5453137755,
1.069475174,
0.4320032597,
-0.7118186355,
0.4843769968,
0.2117107064,
0.042458225,
0.0262532644,
-0.0927651227,
0.0375771448,
0.1560104638,
0.2039230317,
0.1186710596,
0.2297342569,
-0.2597274184,
0.4992887676,
0.5747854114,
-0.4593245983,
-0.4598913789,
0.4461372495,
0.0398791581,
-0.2360613048,
0.3459783792,
0.1056129783,
-0.5629815459,
0.5963749886,
0.8596497774,
0.8409504294,
-0.0788398087,
0.3223367035,
0.1957609355,
0.4834620655,
-0.2270774245,
-0.1230349019,
-0.0983735174,
-0.4089272022,
-0.3733645976,
-0.5729933977,
-0.1282990277,
0.2164172679,
-0.6320968866,
0.5261363387,
-0.6369208097,
0.1363287717,
-0.1749784499,
-0.2514970005,
-0.4670234025,
0.4351508319,
0.3111419976,
0.6653672457,
-0.9985601306,
0.7318643332,
0.983510077,
-0.0194067117,
-0.683121264,
0.0316971615,
-0.3158149421,
-0.9077100158,
0.6633607745,
1.0692546368,
-0.14045991,
0.2945703864,
-0.4958640337,
-0.7915197015,
0.874609828,
0.4932288229,
-0.4201932549,
0.0624135882,
-0.2229239345,
0.2423588634,
-0.476208657,
0.2102000564,
0.4057902098,
0.6699098945,
0.1976951361,
-0.5448884964,
-0.03863905,
0.0385510512,
-0.0490471944,
0.2359381318,
-0.7036877871,
1.0157527924,
0.0406947657,
-0.2854782641,
-0.5008884668,
0.3969866335,
0.459100306,
0.6289405227,
0.4893494248,
0.8822571039,
0.6696026921,
0.0456658974,
0.5806977749,
-0.2820525169,
0.3465054333,
0.8096217513,
-0.2554077208,
0.519457221,
0.4247632027,
0.3038173318,
0.3864692152,
0.8285207152,
0.0774921179,
0.5801416636,
0.1024954915,
0.1436891407,
-0.7983009815,
-0.1593399346,
-0.6007656455,
0.6921476126,
0.4233113825,
-0.0922225192,
-0.7269304991,
0.3409282863,
-0.1278333515,
-0.1588090509,
-0.3101131916,
0.9628783464,
-0.0309215579,
-0.4037922323,
0.8480228782,
0.2076787949,
0.3008369505,
-0.3500140309,
-0.4223409295,
-0.1682183594,
-0.0370213725,
-0.1445352584,
-0.3480938375,
0.3810539544,
-0.2809882462,
-0.2939789891,
-0.0657354072,
0.8899107575,
-0.3552918732,
-0.4187210798,
0.3782866299,
0.3278042972,
0.1589956135,
-0.4959388077,
-0.6871417761,
0.2989994884,
-0.2038043737,
-0.2356493473,
0.2326414883,
0.8365866542,
-0.3798114061,
0.691014111,
0.7980123162,
-0.2409273386,
0.1464928836,
-0.0538261347,
1.151645422,
-0.8800862432,
-0.5539354682,
-1.0896090269,
0.7526401281,
-0.0362134129,
-0.2083306909,
0.7851899266,
0.6505376101,
0.4467997551,
-0.2489865273,
0.5684427023,
0.2889325023,
0.0032670563,
-0.8442772031,
0.4076254368,
-0.5512320995,
-0.127479583,
-0.0532862134,
-0.9167859554,
-0.4948747456,
0.9050790668,
-0.1260925382,
-0.3202792108,
0.6360834241,
0.5524958968,
-0.3012200594,
-0.5787473321,
0.8688724041,
-0.0846633837,
0.3318372965,
0.4156281054,
1.097232461,
-0.1638010889,
0.0117263608,
-0.0213924963,
-0.2674925327,
-0.5740302205,
-0.7226296067,
-1.331815958,
-0.1815762967,
-0.2578667998,
-0.1643282026,
0.0878361911,
0.7249678373,
1.1854381561,
-0.7148727179,
-0.0453392565,
-0.4218644202,
0.239182204,
-0.0049256105,
-0.1991101354,
0.1838117987,
-0.352196604,
-0.3076852262,
0.3769143522,
0.8630669117,
-0.1112029999,
-0.3434089124,
-0.0203951597,
0.037619926,
-0.3682613671,
0.759966135,
0.0883826017,
-1.2035881281,
-0.2981810272,
-0.1637499928,
-0.1539185345,
0.3122539818,
0.9587417245,
-0.8195050955,
0.4734292924,
-0.1341992617,
0.6950503588,
0.1612050533,
0.2970409095,
0.325104475,
-0.6620755792,
0.7996920347,
0.1554430425,
0.3071523607,
0.5985856056,
-0.4596958458,
0.0788769424,
0.5156001449,
-0.252445817,
-0.7534677982,
0.2627990842,
-0.9494227767,
-0.2540796995,
1.4972525835,
-0.1292385906,
-0.3443772495,
-0.3896713555,
-0.8074047565,
0.3392680585,
-0.2304704934,
0.4364951551,
0.5821551085,
0.5040472746,
-0.4015987813,
-0.5367072821,
0.2496334016,
0.1494527757,
-0.9803074598,
0.2798092663,
0.859537065,
0.2403066754,
0.1652973443,
0.3983598053,
0.2451025844,
0.1968864202,
0.1025807038,
0.0685589239,
-0.4287926257,
-0.6714243889,
-0.4074873626,
0.3310865462,
0.3040759265,
-0.2983552217
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.