id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16107v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16107v6
|
Knowledge Fusion of Chat LLMs: A Preliminary Technical Report
| 2024-02-25T15:11:58 | 2024-05-29T03:58:10 |
Fanqi Wan, Ziyi Yang, Longguang Zhong, Xiaojun Quan, Xinting Huang, Wei Bi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, FuseLLM introduced the concept of knowledge fusion to transfer the
collective knowledge of multiple structurally varied LLMs into a target LLM
through lightweight continual training. In this report, we extend the
scalability and flexibility of the FuseLLM framework to realize the fusion of
chat LLMs, resulting in FusionChat. FusionChat comprises two main stages.
Firstly, we undertake knowledge fusion for structurally and scale-varied source
LLMs to derive multiple target LLMs of identical structure and size via
lightweight fine-tuning. Then, these target LLMs are merged within the
parameter space, wherein we propose a novel method for determining the merging
weights based on the variation ratio of parameter matrices before and after
fine-tuning. We validate our approach using three prominent chat LLMs with
diverse architectures and scales, namely NH2-Mixtral-8x7B, NH2-Solar-10.7B, and
OpenChat-3.5-7B. Experimental results spanning various chat domains demonstrate
the superiority of FusionChat-7B across a broad spectrum of chat LLMs at 7B and
34B scales, even surpassing GPT-3.5 (March) and approaching
Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct.
|
[
-0.403500706,
-0.5768507123,
0.2666669786,
0.3494500518,
-0.1845986694,
0.3797723651,
-0.2493310869,
-0.6770245433,
0.2998043001,
0.3903799057,
-0.5129210949,
-0.3191576004,
-0.4348301888,
-0.2586124241,
-0.4871174395,
0.7832802534,
-0.1094517112,
0.2826046646,
-0.4021118879,
-0.2639709711,
-0.699285984,
-0.2026059926,
-0.5080766082,
-0.4568014443,
0.6077377796,
0.5903152823,
0.5172008872,
0.4341700375,
0.7454212904,
0.3461672664,
-0.2102942169,
0.3419123888,
-0.9037517905,
0.1071161702,
-0.0984504148,
-0.6325287819,
-0.3965198696,
-0.0237287264,
0.6754541397,
0.7640813589,
-0.1509693116,
0.1619109511,
0.2935398519,
0.6753459573,
-0.3505995274,
0.0453367159,
-0.8535618782,
-0.0654194579,
-0.1137794182,
0.0761670694,
-0.3518999219,
-0.2163193375,
0.013145878,
-0.3185343444,
-0.0731386095,
0.525372684,
0.5997112989,
0.3536677659,
-0.4130756557,
0.1033716723,
-0.92049402,
0.7932994366,
-0.5133649111,
0.5006705523,
0.0071600629,
0.7120625377,
-0.1525181681,
-0.5769848228,
-0.2745869756,
-0.1358835548,
-0.1738610715,
0.1183966175,
-0.0348703079,
0.0544994324,
-0.1672863364,
0.5028320551,
-0.6291538477,
0.4714105427,
-0.6062424183,
-0.3887928426,
0.6181136966,
0.2662406564,
0.2317731231,
0.014705129,
-0.7476442456,
0.0609090067,
-0.77708745,
-0.4763377011,
0.1660119742,
0.3163101673,
-0.4759674072,
0.659517467,
-0.3015923798,
0.8803039193,
0.1793683618,
-0.2851464152,
0.0598367974,
-0.6562038064,
-0.1401099116,
0.1494280696,
0.7393811345,
0.4377788603,
-0.5108004212,
-0.1528639346,
0.1133432984,
-0.049667336,
0.1101393774,
-0.4210422039,
-0.0152935516,
0.1140486225,
-0.4655774534,
-0.2239245325,
-0.2763897479,
-0.5197604299,
-0.6350963712,
-0.156771332,
0.5033121109,
-0.5735664964,
-0.3778752089,
0.091178447,
-0.2855728567,
0.5597041249,
0.637550354,
-0.8160998821,
0.3414808214,
0.658007443,
0.7925727367,
-0.5638329983,
-0.1683981568,
0.0407215059,
0.1749309599,
-0.0205060747,
0.8519563079,
-0.251169771,
-0.5427623987,
-0.3334213495,
-0.5756720304,
-0.1563925147,
-0.5285024643,
0.181648165,
-0.5043069124,
0.4092237353,
-0.115261063,
-0.8747141957,
-0.0987490565,
0.543892622,
-0.440510273,
0.7738173008,
0.3494208455,
-0.6862867475,
0.2800096273,
-0.375885129,
-0.2740190625,
0.3429237306,
-0.184690699,
-0.0651728809,
-0.2061579973,
-0.0556262843,
0.4249156117,
-0.5006586909,
-0.2736097276,
-0.5853614807,
-0.3047910333,
0.0436984524,
-0.2141653746,
0.3397499025,
0.2771398127,
-0.0072203185,
0.2213193774,
-0.5430452824,
-0.0165481344,
-0.1886896491,
-0.3627896905,
-0.0237726402,
-0.0396883972,
-0.107632488,
0.066191189,
0.6448802352,
-0.4171803594,
0.2518264055,
-0.4082842767,
0.3191967607,
0.4555957615,
0.1019665524,
0.7851231694,
-0.6993336678,
0.185423851,
0.0005231425,
0.212730661,
0.1262722611,
-0.4808056355,
-0.8681883812,
-0.3263406754,
0.163167268,
0.520021677,
-0.7382529378,
0.6509168148,
-0.2599214911,
-0.9637576938,
-0.2914003432,
0.3378865421,
0.3019942045,
0.3833233416,
0.2798218429,
-0.2272012532,
-0.7207552195,
-0.8503689766,
-0.1969816536,
-0.4095518589,
-0.1392670572,
0.3779318035,
0.1476832032,
-0.1403344572,
0.7708262205,
-0.4829818606,
-0.3763283491,
-0.4573354423,
-0.024954658,
-0.0871464908,
0.569873631,
0.4318364263,
-0.8205490112,
-0.5272225142,
0.1823093891,
-0.7588831782,
0.2130324095,
-0.1186711267,
-0.1934936792,
-0.1146831661,
0.5048321486,
-0.626838088,
-0.0350405052,
0.610129416,
-0.0689106658,
0.390619576,
0.0966523215,
0.3201512396,
-1.5321941376,
-0.4079628289,
-0.2822420001,
-0.1512786895,
-0.5167634487,
-0.1735435128,
0.0416160002,
0.0689610615,
-0.7517761588,
0.6448411942,
-0.4605657756,
-0.1183899269,
-0.2738650441,
0.3290598392,
-0.4061057568,
0.4535178244,
-0.3576887548,
0.4162206948,
0.5666962266,
-0.62661165,
0.8222966194,
0.1912557483,
-0.1629105061,
0.7624167204,
-0.4666888416,
-0.0480464809,
0.1966523826,
0.2794306278,
-1.3088794947,
-0.3206945956,
0.2043503672,
-0.360722512,
0.2804532945,
-0.0823820531,
-0.3633723855,
-0.3694171906,
-0.2766092122,
0.3357980549,
0.6305500269,
-0.3774483204,
0.7236788869,
0.4274675548,
0.0661195666,
-0.1830002964,
-0.5355612636,
-0.0413321629,
-0.4162552655,
-0.9249244928,
0.4818841517,
-0.2550311387,
-0.234963268,
0.0622146614,
-0.3092496991,
-0.0862141475,
-0.1733573824,
0.4554653168,
0.337988615,
-0.180654943,
0.1382091343,
0.1256244481,
0.0820073411,
-0.2858089209,
-0.3832055628,
0.6681980491,
-0.2684223652,
-0.7765681148,
-0.1614789814,
0.0659913421,
0.5259724855,
0.1992025226,
0.8873231411,
0.6840407848,
-0.1802161485,
0.0048537315,
-0.9502449036,
-0.2341147214,
-0.5122058988,
0.2320816815,
-0.1302547455,
-1.4224135876,
0.8279824257,
-0.3263640106,
0.2118408829,
0.5463598967,
0.6571823359,
-0.2177674174,
0.6725820899,
0.7168953419,
-0.2665101886,
0.4693082273,
0.0519287065,
-0.1207960919,
-0.6977317929,
-0.4526548982,
-0.4451607466,
-0.6660347581,
-0.5273920298,
-0.5169970393,
0.5238040686,
-0.0183839146,
-0.0335867591,
0.4947601855,
-0.2926531136,
0.4744928181,
0.2705246806,
0.3221059442,
0.2585985065,
-0.1350819468,
0.043596305,
0.0974198058,
-0.8661176562,
-0.0902492702,
0.9927658439,
0.2136736363,
0.9769547582,
0.1523116827,
0.852865994,
0.1315671802,
0.2564691603,
-0.6795805097,
0.7034086585,
0.1719869673,
-0.4844238162,
-0.369785428,
-0.6381915808,
-0.6867662668,
0.364625752,
-0.3550923169,
-0.6852087975,
-0.1529202759,
0.0968117341,
0.0054088519,
0.3830588162,
-0.8361452222,
0.4576112926,
-0.1102735326,
0.0812374055,
-0.5716792345,
-0.799973011,
0.9162883162,
-0.1622591317,
0.0780884922,
-0.3575231731,
-0.0414340347,
0.8028872013,
-0.2257569283,
0.941580832,
0.2095903307,
-0.026525842,
0.2312010825,
0.0526757911,
0.2093297988,
0.0020075357,
0.1239165813,
0.1854977012,
-0.2138343155,
-0.2796753347,
-0.6115630865,
0.7780357599,
-1.025184989,
-0.5390350819,
0.1343665123,
-0.8314787149,
-0.54982692,
0.2648466229,
0.2637064159,
0.1888100654,
-0.2269801348,
0.6507663727,
0.7640732527,
0.1786671281,
0.1677824557,
0.6176807284,
-0.1952314526,
-0.3737791479,
0.8266795278,
-0.1061356366,
0.5385293961,
0.7404662371,
0.0115437582,
-0.1496361345,
-0.525270164,
-0.0756607205,
0.1804992408,
-0.4985835254,
-0.5192664862,
-0.3543861508,
-0.6606543064,
-0.3901679218,
-0.1159592569,
-0.6377319098,
-0.4521027803,
-0.2424956411,
0.0198057238,
0.3940706849,
0.6537018418,
-0.0405832753,
0.5555582047,
-1.117426157,
0.2851784825,
0.525229156,
0.4454399049,
-0.2627205551,
-0.5389249325,
-0.2883792818,
0.2442427725,
-0.2034933567,
-0.6902547479,
-0.0370173156,
0.1909262091,
0.8808433414,
0.3900785148,
-0.0000623635,
0.4780490994,
-0.139758423,
0.897762835,
0.5686842799,
-0.5740355253,
0.6356277466,
-0.4189514816,
0.3098903,
0.4879363477,
0.4196545184,
-0.4425502419,
-0.6902089119,
-0.6799485087,
-0.6004151702,
0.5854454041,
0.2667281032,
-0.0703192502,
0.4930652976,
0.4043844044,
0.1033058539,
-0.0241856873,
-0.2256897539,
-0.3399402499,
0.1418906897,
-0.3538063765,
0.0591160282,
-0.2131273001,
-0.4517202973,
-0.2344871163,
0.3575467169,
-0.0429628976,
0.1698462665,
-0.3048729599,
-0.0872653872,
-0.0375857726,
0.1267831773,
0.565109551,
0.6030511856,
-0.1746408492,
0.0754092783,
0.6105101109,
-0.4378435314,
0.0121988552,
-0.039285399,
0.1164779365,
-0.4236989617,
0.4162683487,
0.8368597031,
0.7302979827,
-0.3430766761,
0.0324461684,
-0.2400894016,
-0.624319315,
0.3067229092,
0.624891758,
0.3110184073,
0.519533813,
0.1826488227,
0.0968690589,
-0.1532139331,
-0.2266099751,
0.2788020372,
0.5648903847,
-0.3048608601,
-0.1629603803,
0.4278413355,
0.423963666,
0.0571474954,
0.440205127,
0.0271548722,
-0.2766962647,
0.2514116466,
0.4151802063,
0.5242627263,
-0.2015586048,
0.0198161341,
0.1685918868,
0.1934574544,
-0.0532719567,
0.0778185502,
-0.1902512759,
-1.0355886221,
-0.2967050374,
-0.6444459558,
-0.8370628357,
-0.2934745848,
-0.4039258957,
0.2769950628,
-0.3233802021,
0.0531072021,
-0.1658214331,
0.1876059771,
-0.3234453797,
-0.1281546503,
0.158955127,
0.8830553293,
-0.6114906073,
0.559556067,
0.8143628836,
-0.1142531186,
-1.0678812265,
-0.5269316435,
0.3771992922,
-1.0642405748,
0.2733791173,
-0.2947534919,
-0.0156039596,
0.0521054603,
-0.6822636724,
-0.9674425721,
1.4322328568,
0.4447315633,
-0.4022258222,
0.0638151467,
0.2503547668,
0.2652047873,
-0.3518715501,
0.0759237707,
0.3976388574,
0.3920829594,
1.0415885448,
-1.3213484287,
-0.0901425779,
-0.0152542461,
-0.0818321705,
0.1362070888,
-0.8627722263,
0.6875500083,
-0.0157002602,
-0.1650881618,
-0.1134214327,
1.0216156244,
0.2841644883,
-0.174258247,
0.6503551602,
0.472979933,
0.7210315466,
-0.2039239407,
0.4015433788,
-0.5377383828,
0.2922346592,
0.9940559864,
-0.3383173048,
0.6767659187,
0.3289693296,
-0.2277748138,
0.2532212138,
0.6025297642,
0.0313016213,
0.2940091193,
-0.0682883933,
-0.2825761139,
-0.2176730931,
-0.0397006497,
-0.6269952655,
0.5903778672,
0.4499431551,
0.2204461396,
-0.5398225784,
0.0608644299,
-0.2461288124,
-0.3677280545,
-0.274320662,
1.1528806686,
0.1863995194,
-0.4248171151,
0.5182520747,
-0.1549821049,
0.7442890406,
-0.8717968464,
0.1611408889,
-0.2460021973,
0.1854073107,
-0.2015563101,
-0.8829844594,
0.3527123332,
-0.4435630143,
0.0072981347,
-0.292024821,
1.3302949667,
-0.672996819,
-0.0400634557,
-0.0034346005,
0.6011761427,
0.0288106557,
-0.0374550149,
-0.5184540153,
0.2627659738,
-0.0231333673,
0.0247337464,
0.7392545938,
0.1917974502,
0.3330913782,
0.7460303903,
0.4800671339,
0.1086750552,
0.1069434956,
-0.1192267016,
1.1733062267,
-0.3940829039,
-0.431299299,
-0.6507590413,
0.3462416232,
-0.0658566132,
-0.0752776489,
1.0714002848,
0.4259647131,
0.6122670174,
0.173663795,
0.4998597205,
-0.1897175312,
0.3187939823,
-0.5181334019,
0.7936248183,
-0.4538504779,
0.2755569518,
0.1560074985,
-0.9083527327,
-0.0681716502,
-0.0058009457,
0.0313788056,
-0.0377418213,
0.5008863807,
0.7037047148,
0.179682076,
0.2593401968,
0.3464312255,
0.0791658238,
0.3707734346,
0.6259931922,
0.7888489366,
-0.243694976,
0.8049484491,
-0.0448285677,
-0.2416517138,
-0.4810993373,
-0.5744715333,
-0.7430954576,
-0.6541702151,
-0.2910753489,
-0.2186205536,
-0.3419729471,
0.6046404839,
0.892174542,
-0.4208825827,
-0.3090624809,
0.128328234,
0.6299934983,
-0.1189157143,
-0.2355600893,
-0.0457520708,
-0.5246309042,
-0.2860277295,
0.5666957498,
0.408865869,
0.2270747125,
-0.4943917394,
-0.1803141236,
-0.0239264872,
-0.0273610093,
0.57686764,
0.3035949767,
-0.4019781053,
-0.3489748836,
-0.1418969631,
-0.3495078087,
-0.0883534402,
0.6485475898,
-0.6749113202,
0.063758418,
0.6436738968,
0.5534716249,
0.5653122067,
-0.2658960819,
0.6307486892,
-1.0213104486,
0.1610420048,
0.1415577978,
0.3523469269,
0.1673313826,
-0.1691742241,
0.3318638206,
0.3031382561,
-0.4352048635,
-0.677210331,
0.1839569807,
-1.522713542,
-0.1114244685,
1.23549366,
0.2126377672,
-0.1192821711,
0.0055120164,
-0.3074184656,
0.2389284223,
-0.0937976316,
0.524905324,
0.5656601787,
-0.3859108984,
-0.2969382703,
0.0971261486,
0.4571070075,
0.2077565044,
-1.0963337421,
-0.1643255353,
0.4281231761,
0.208458975,
0.26287359,
0.6268135905,
-0.0044004289,
0.1911807954,
0.2884992361,
-0.1056199819,
0.010063312,
-0.2179623395,
0.1115548834,
0.3606318533,
0.0596022606,
-0.1586699039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16102v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16102v1
|
Interpreting Predictive Probabilities: Model Confidence or Human Label Variation?
| 2024-02-25T15:00:13 | 2024-02-25T15:00:13 |
Joris Baan, Raquel Fernández, Barbara Plank, Wilker Aziz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rise of increasingly powerful and user-facing NLP systems, there is
growing interest in assessing whether they have a good representation of
uncertainty by evaluating the quality of their predictive distribution over
outcomes. We identify two main perspectives that drive starkly different
evaluation protocols. The first treats predictive probability as an indication
of model confidence; the second as an indication of human label variation. We
discuss their merits and limitations, and take the position that both are
crucial for trustworthy and fair NLP systems, but that exploiting a single
predictive distribution is limiting. We recommend tools and highlight exciting
directions towards models with disentangled representations of uncertainty
about predictions and uncertainty about human labels.
|
[
-0.30412516,
-0.045152802,
0.645273447,
0.3462925255,
0.0394530408,
0.3506682217,
0.1644098163,
-0.8783226013,
0.0188143514,
0.1453139633,
-0.4840107858,
-0.2345231175,
-1.0872550011,
-0.178041786,
-0.3696225286,
0.8927648067,
0.2476654798,
0.3613182604,
-0.5076892376,
0.1783118695,
-0.292730689,
-0.7175374031,
-0.4363150597,
-0.6768173575,
0.3583958447,
-0.2208353728,
1.3081943989,
0.3200928867,
0.8624861836,
0.1890269518,
-0.3065467775,
-0.4149513841,
-0.041552525,
-0.0143580092,
-0.3588706553,
-0.6036172509,
-0.4132330716,
0.3747739494,
0.5076175332,
1.199005127,
-0.1997218281,
0.0300987996,
0.1683054417,
0.48825562,
-0.9196621776,
0.0841215178,
-0.3323636651,
0.1458127648,
0.0443025157,
0.0993513614,
-0.6002833843,
-0.1480314434,
0.5301049948,
-0.3780008554,
0.041210942,
0.1411077678,
0.5689795017,
0.3456716537,
-0.3705200255,
-0.23110798,
-0.966337502,
0.9775159359,
-0.6875833869,
0.3550666273,
0.6024355292,
0.5536510944,
-0.3863969743,
-0.8851408958,
-0.4065564275,
-0.2405408472,
0.0842009708,
0.2202043235,
-0.3553040326,
0.0556581169,
-0.1241146922,
0.389977932,
-0.3401709795,
0.3170314729,
0.0107884817,
-0.2607345581,
0.9045768976,
-0.11735861,
0.0132514825,
-0.0298898891,
-0.4142223597,
-0.2638314068,
-0.2562476695,
0.000271159,
0.7773649096,
0.2284106612,
0.006107179,
0.3684528768,
-0.1418704838,
0.8711750507,
-0.1790015996,
-0.2239184678,
0.2513484955,
-0.0945425108,
-0.2011064887,
-0.1525219083,
0.9426199794,
0.4005461633,
-0.0858061835,
-0.0880767703,
-0.1970800012,
0.2202619612,
0.2362074554,
-0.2134605348,
-0.4727898836,
0.4161442518,
-0.5346509814,
-0.6918632388,
0.5370788574,
-0.6428260207,
-0.840593636,
0.0318364166,
0.3365972042,
-0.2066652924,
-0.3937778175,
0.6442935467,
-0.3520125449,
-0.2827700675,
0.3513904512,
-1.0377635956,
0.2875969708,
0.8813204169,
0.3087147176,
-0.3807245791,
-0.0418895297,
0.0127061782,
-0.1318939328,
-0.4414080381,
0.4146568775,
-0.5235084295,
-0.2687570453,
-0.0096989367,
-0.15968889,
0.084482424,
-0.5414391756,
0.7038881183,
-0.5092154145,
0.0467780121,
-0.0765696615,
-0.6962935328,
-0.1955690831,
-0.0479742959,
-0.8922092915,
0.6930262446,
0.2107069492,
-1.0228010416,
0.758274734,
-0.1653063893,
0.0833057389,
0.2097808719,
0.0723452047,
-0.116601333,
0.2786197066,
-0.1134876162,
0.3785176575,
-0.1980222911,
0.5245062113,
-0.7289373875,
-0.1245970652,
1.0204130411,
-0.8332008719,
0.7391075492,
0.3048126698,
-0.0350162536,
-0.3751498461,
-0.812749505,
0.0869049728,
-0.223810032,
-0.1527077109,
-0.1893341392,
0.4788905084,
0.219426915,
0.2457430959,
0.323215425,
-0.3425746858,
-0.0437492654,
-0.4280037582,
0.4123259783,
0.558815062,
0.0674716234,
0.5558086634,
-0.1852466762,
0.7942448258,
0.2648306489,
0.4286716878,
0.3173583746,
-0.9341242909,
-0.1801037937,
0.0206654575,
0.7138230801,
0.5018963814,
-0.4353692532,
0.3841763437,
0.1576105952,
-0.6502099037,
-0.731359601,
-0.2964655459,
0.301867336,
0.2627135217,
0.1687065363,
-0.4165455997,
-0.4241841733,
-0.9768466353,
-0.4934986532,
-0.6202027202,
-0.2985774577,
-0.1130978316,
0.6068265438,
-0.3680157065,
0.9609231353,
-0.5270050764,
0.0567932986,
-0.100453943,
0.4116874039,
0.2903704047,
0.6722263694,
0.2995622456,
-1.1385592222,
-0.2482757121,
-0.2168138325,
-0.4739653766,
0.3086644113,
-0.1292373389,
0.084473066,
0.108852908,
-0.0279115792,
-0.338898629,
0.6865481734,
0.6578429937,
-0.3164355457,
0.8774068952,
-0.2112522572,
0.0171214454,
-0.690991044,
-0.3635309041,
0.1456108689,
-0.3071088493,
-0.6873185635,
0.0137998462,
-0.2236528844,
0.3364666104,
-0.2466297001,
0.3630342782,
-0.2822126448,
-0.2868582606,
0.0706176162,
-0.1014720872,
0.3159818947,
-0.2420951724,
0.1845394373,
0.3933774531,
0.5669232607,
-0.3640556037,
0.172318235,
0.1954695433,
-0.6503888965,
0.3109486997,
-0.6057316661,
-0.0466108248,
-0.061231751,
0.2890305221,
-0.9930509925,
-0.6239446402,
0.3764438629,
-0.7548363209,
0.5186769366,
0.1368876249,
-0.4292415977,
-0.5956972837,
-0.1747583598,
0.0298558157,
0.5708609223,
-0.2408346087,
0.15148063,
0.4250975549,
0.0519785769,
-1.1682090759,
-0.9946321249,
-0.1137128845,
-0.0639845878,
-0.4078736901,
0.2945381999,
0.1362118274,
-0.7550999522,
-0.0127823744,
-0.3611412942,
-0.3000126183,
0.5154461861,
0.4179035723,
0.1477564126,
-0.001103892,
0.3199685812,
-0.0150353955,
-0.1444436908,
0.1492019147,
-0.5323656797,
0.0894302279,
-0.113028504,
-0.5423055291,
-0.6222257018,
0.3669426143,
0.039281588,
0.0300052688,
0.8233144283,
0.4641905129,
-0.5273054242,
0.3028351963,
-0.2562404871,
-0.1677516252,
-0.3682414591,
0.4262911677,
-0.2942425311,
-0.4650213122,
0.5346707702,
-0.0167831033,
-0.3007602096,
0.6361248493,
0.4744012952,
-0.7551124692,
1.1891863346,
0.9218016267,
0.1666614413,
0.1984119266,
0.0138307549,
0.2107060999,
-0.3521016836,
-0.2140752971,
-0.5348313451,
-0.1308555305,
-0.757702291,
-0.5682457089,
-0.1409035176,
0.5580456257,
0.0704643875,
0.004124295,
-0.6904917955,
0.3156585097,
0.7027865648,
0.107949622,
0.4507236779,
-0.2556976974,
0.295383662,
-0.4032973647,
-0.674970448,
-0.9769340754,
1.2981748581,
0.8040580153,
0.7349589467,
-0.0120419739,
0.7129117846,
0.3997209072,
0.4096169472,
-0.4866722524,
0.0470019095,
-0.2146206349,
-1.1158114672,
-0.3669249713,
-0.1035001948,
-0.8121666908,
0.1953683197,
-0.6773793101,
-1.1079188585,
0.6844269037,
0.3296685815,
-0.4022079706,
0.4414926767,
-0.6275424957,
0.8769910336,
-0.1011918783,
0.0249406062,
0.2210872322,
-1.0232950449,
0.3938341439,
-0.1300815344,
0.2143761367,
-0.2000879347,
-0.0699357167,
0.6819816232,
-0.0765031651,
0.7742105126,
-0.0970624983,
-0.0589986518,
0.4531800449,
0.0895995349,
0.2046542019,
0.1679094583,
-0.410199523,
0.062449012,
0.456682086,
-0.2661388516,
-0.6946333051,
0.0179102737,
-0.8573164344,
-0.4209394753,
-0.5919792056,
-0.5837255716,
-0.3067864478,
-0.2071302682,
0.6363307834,
0.2098368257,
-0.3157457411,
0.1522205621,
0.4611657262,
-0.3313722312,
0.0514790229,
-0.2622478604,
-0.300858289,
-0.0654332414,
0.6249092221,
-0.0041281977,
0.5250012875,
0.5427245498,
0.2114694566,
-0.6667042375,
-0.5916873813,
0.0923583731,
-0.0475352667,
-0.9610332251,
0.0524447337,
-0.462535888,
0.0503645241,
-0.5035566688,
-0.1303275228,
-0.4103907049,
-0.7248539925,
-0.6081421971,
-0.2913568914,
0.1036498621,
0.8763420582,
-0.2870553732,
0.6418519616,
-0.3668230176,
0.0651527122,
0.2208908498,
0.3779685199,
-0.3267808259,
-0.4244820476,
0.0808027461,
0.3238414228,
-0.266618669,
-1.4064211845,
0.4608328938,
-0.0282683782,
0.4750183821,
0.5707083344,
0.2432189137,
0.0785644501,
-0.0162789524,
0.7941870689,
0.5033611655,
-0.8512042761,
0.3008636236,
-0.2131463885,
-0.1784831285,
0.68340832,
0.911834538,
-0.4675470591,
-0.4873414934,
-0.9793745875,
-0.6361936927,
0.5901203752,
-0.0413943194,
-0.1785833538,
0.1167820171,
0.3720386624,
0.4614849091,
0.3553676009,
-0.827275157,
-0.4260344803,
-0.4164459705,
-0.1442257017,
-0.5481830239,
-0.5894560218,
-0.2454971075,
0.0565424263,
0.2921087742,
0.0662117004,
0.4469542801,
0.0249214601,
0.2637459934,
0.2471926361,
0.382181108,
0.2600456774,
0.8361457586,
-0.7144554257,
0.2462620884,
-0.2458004355,
-0.5173730254,
0.3677146435,
0.1093436256,
-0.272585541,
0.3608218431,
0.5852066875,
0.8122779131,
-0.0282545928,
-0.4271633029,
0.5260568261,
0.1384338588,
-0.2737888396,
-0.3977030218,
-0.1588390321,
0.3109137118,
0.1430037022,
0.4473700821,
0.4306687415,
0.6051268578,
-0.5939833522,
0.1304392219,
0.1192075908,
-0.7093738317,
-0.367955476,
0.941175282,
-0.0279077236,
-0.4218363166,
0.4643919766,
-0.355410248,
-0.4182768464,
0.7385607958,
0.2950900197,
0.6980860829,
-0.1574811488,
0.6245348454,
0.1795994937,
0.3940832615,
-0.3029920757,
0.2278716713,
0.356198132,
-0.88921839,
-0.449829042,
-0.6060592532,
-0.8543634415,
-0.1669859886,
-1.2577950954,
0.0160057936,
-0.021467939,
-0.6945776343,
0.2476083785,
-0.1424461305,
-0.5464843512,
0.4653218985,
0.2578274608,
0.9469478726,
-1.1361805201,
0.6862463355,
0.7796801925,
-0.1506569982,
-0.6778687239,
0.0449909754,
-0.0418214537,
-0.2778474987,
0.6622554064,
0.0193492062,
0.2364993691,
-0.3354367018,
-0.5821095109,
-0.7902744412,
0.7936112285,
0.2355107069,
-0.6439446807,
0.1185789406,
0.2332060039,
0.6708771586,
-0.2368175089,
0.2419397384,
0.738021791,
0.4630617201,
-0.1199868172,
-0.7114560008,
-0.3040483296,
0.3375115097,
0.2983304262,
-0.1985557824,
0.1462905556,
0.7381572127,
-0.3832330704,
-0.3578269482,
-0.1181441173,
0.6448504925,
0.4216410816,
0.555568099,
0.4541710615,
0.1185397133,
0.9907673597,
-0.36017555,
1.586368084,
-0.0427987948,
0.557903707,
1.3140859604,
-0.2169820815,
1.0340073109,
0.6977420449,
-0.9164804816,
0.3761986494,
1.1733111143,
0.2551408112,
0.5899158716,
0.3359242678,
-0.1764237434,
-0.4408695102,
-0.0070926659,
-0.4161826968,
0.4876871407,
0.5470848083,
-0.2789185941,
0.1230034903,
-0.0570859835,
-0.3355540931,
0.1092056856,
0.0308019817,
0.36860618,
0.2166775912,
-0.5843378901,
0.1325125992,
0.0065930365,
0.6728143692,
-0.3168833256,
0.1772124171,
0.2098962367,
0.0878145322,
-0.2572481334,
-1.1733386517,
0.1737604886,
-0.5941851139,
-0.2558797598,
-0.2086046189,
0.7530235052,
-0.0938668549,
-0.5378284454,
0.3604380488,
0.4859314561,
0.373021394,
-0.1337002367,
-0.9204939008,
-0.1687687188,
-0.0029090869,
-0.4775467515,
0.2286787331,
0.1949569881,
0.0695923418,
1.024610877,
0.2848113179,
0.07795991,
0.2154533565,
-0.0367958657,
0.3192997873,
-0.1981867701,
-0.266861707,
-0.693825841,
0.5233783722,
0.0834752247,
-0.3173820078,
0.4215485752,
0.0526264161,
0.586976707,
-0.3024095595,
0.7188454866,
0.0659204498,
0.431769371,
-0.1095397323,
0.5507442355,
-0.3675607443,
0.0931437165,
-0.4128457904,
-0.704852581,
-0.4446512759,
0.6684587002,
-0.3006145358,
0.0570084937,
0.4425231814,
0.1777248234,
0.3221557736,
0.0891725272,
0.377274245,
-0.1618822217,
-0.0478364229,
0.6137182117,
1.2362165451,
-0.4780170619,
0.2511898279,
-0.5602447987,
-0.2909739316,
-0.3616679609,
-1.143445015,
-0.1562755555,
-0.7367417812,
-0.558452189,
-0.4437534213,
-0.1971221864,
0.5447882414,
0.7910915613,
-0.7346881628,
-0.0189582631,
0.0012727719,
0.2944754958,
-0.585534513,
-0.1671719998,
0.1461764574,
-0.0529828779,
-0.7622947693,
-0.0790831372,
0.1698648036,
0.6002625823,
-0.3557214737,
-0.1395511776,
0.1352318972,
0.0475648791,
0.2510634065,
0.1234052107,
-0.9341929555,
-0.244842872,
-0.1274621189,
-0.1754623652,
-0.1673946977,
0.0707619637,
-0.5203795433,
0.7328636646,
0.4842143357,
0.3509854674,
0.3610365093,
0.029532956,
0.8077973127,
-0.4857774079,
0.2716434598,
0.5647559166,
0.3577077985,
0.2455416918,
-0.4523150325,
0.6629666686,
-0.0671151131,
-0.4935800433,
-1.2060699463,
0.6029371619,
-0.9654377699,
-0.3730311096,
0.809137404,
-0.4132024646,
0.1387213171,
-0.2121288329,
0.3491745889,
-0.1060544923,
0.0407918617,
0.5305966735,
1.0156034231,
-0.1715810001,
0.2128077298,
-1.0550282001,
0.6901147962,
0.4119466543,
-0.423158586,
-0.108872436,
0.1134517044,
-0.0440709218,
0.6277886033,
0.5506914854,
-0.0817394778,
0.2370984256,
0.3983644843,
0.3657316864,
0.4785364568,
-0.366766572,
-0.576241076,
0.0611800961,
0.3661321104,
-0.1515665799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00813v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00813v3
|
UrbanGPT: Spatio-Temporal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-25T12:37:29 | 2024-05-19T01:58:03 |
Zhonghang Li, Lianghao Xia, Jiabin Tang, Yong Xu, Lei Shi, Long Xia, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Spatio-temporal prediction aims to forecast and gain insights into the
ever-changing dynamics of urban environments across both time and space. Its
purpose is to anticipate future patterns, trends, and events in diverse facets
of urban life, including transportation, population movement, and crime rates.
Although numerous efforts have been dedicated to developing neural network
techniques for accurate predictions on spatio-temporal data, it is important to
note that many of these methods heavily depend on having sufficient labeled
data to generate precise spatio-temporal representations. Unfortunately, the
issue of data scarcity is pervasive in practical urban sensing scenarios.
Consequently, it becomes necessary to build a spatio-temporal model with strong
generalization capabilities across diverse spatio-temporal learning scenarios.
Taking inspiration from the remarkable achievements of large language models
(LLMs), our objective is to create a spatio-temporal LLM that can exhibit
exceptional generalization capabilities across a wide range of downstream urban
tasks. To achieve this objective, we present the UrbanGPT, which seamlessly
integrates a spatio-temporal dependency encoder with the instruction-tuning
paradigm. This integration enables LLMs to comprehend the complex
inter-dependencies across time and space, facilitating more comprehensive and
accurate predictions under data scarcity. To validate the effectiveness of our
approach, we conduct extensive experiments on various public datasets, covering
different spatio-temporal prediction tasks. The results consistently
demonstrate that our UrbanGPT, with its carefully designed architecture,
consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines. These findings highlight
the potential of building large language models for spatio-temporal learning,
particularly in zero-shot scenarios where labeled data is scarce.
|
[
-0.4536192119,
-0.6929232478,
0.8059862256,
0.1847148389,
0.0289022736,
0.0968235806,
-0.3471576273,
-0.5241208673,
-0.1404641271,
0.1367092878,
-0.186851263,
-0.4999430776,
-0.4786833525,
-0.4141535759,
-0.3246119618,
0.8013380766,
-0.0784299523,
0.0496235788,
0.1747160554,
0.1821532696,
-0.4525004923,
-0.3510784209,
-0.7850461602,
-0.4253703356,
0.5476158857,
0.4050157964,
0.70127666,
1.0400993824,
0.2352578044,
0.2014436126,
0.1710295975,
0.0483758003,
-0.3135736287,
-0.2752380073,
0.0105048036,
0.3341610134,
-0.2928237915,
-0.4036993086,
0.6606100798,
0.924212873,
-0.3519574404,
-0.0856422186,
0.0050087725,
0.3305309713,
-0.3916173875,
0.4346826375,
-0.5540041327,
0.0519774556,
-0.0942029729,
-0.1547529101,
-0.0362318493,
-0.1390571445,
0.2449224144,
-0.5306486487,
0.3515598178,
-0.038030412,
0.5285685062,
0.3739018738,
-0.4694339633,
0.0570048168,
-1.2254129648,
0.6008753777,
-0.3698132932,
0.5277856588,
0.4556730986,
0.5621885657,
-0.0976051763,
-0.5087099075,
-0.3607551754,
-0.1973019987,
0.1254766583,
0.3561395705,
0.1896858066,
0.074366197,
0.0024428098,
-0.1812753081,
-0.9663828015,
0.2457989007,
-0.3210853636,
0.3470425606,
0.3543952703,
0.3550724089,
-0.0361870304,
-0.1396689266,
-0.5348343849,
0.0634764284,
-0.5757424235,
-0.1356022954,
0.0785113946,
0.4048119187,
-0.1214394867,
0.1430660784,
-0.2750709951,
0.4796776772,
-0.305072695,
0.2561745644,
-0.0657452047,
-0.2129280865,
-0.2019886672,
-0.0796690211,
0.9557768703,
0.2085184306,
0.3181099892,
-0.4183117151,
-0.0136142997,
-0.4359947145,
0.1423380822,
-0.7083454728,
-0.5632875562,
0.3950787783,
0.096397616,
-0.0833669826,
0.0221912153,
-1.1648079157,
-0.2239141762,
-0.4059291482,
-0.178625226,
-0.5092932582,
-0.1793069988,
0.351567179,
0.2388066351,
0.0744018108,
0.4916187227,
-1.1778240204,
-0.0513448864,
0.5208580494,
0.7913835645,
-0.0108553646,
-0.7391512394,
0.0275616851,
0.7414150834,
-0.2704194784,
0.9211272001,
-0.7045584917,
-0.1147237271,
-0.0274768174,
-0.246622771,
-0.1536930352,
-0.314973563,
0.4270068109,
-0.3224345446,
-0.3716382682,
0.0963921398,
-0.1821342111,
-0.2067209929,
0.2040697783,
-0.4096348882,
1.3062591553,
0.0603317879,
-0.4406134486,
0.5251554251,
-0.6917927265,
-0.4484561384,
0.4452202618,
-0.0661606863,
-0.5071922541,
-0.0384414829,
0.5128244758,
0.6259602904,
-0.1194920465,
0.6621527076,
-0.4142777026,
-0.4316554964,
-0.0254434105,
-0.6033104062,
0.2720733583,
0.1525895596,
-0.4905614853,
-0.0546614714,
-0.7748361826,
-0.3114410043,
0.2095830142,
-0.6660636067,
-0.1060173362,
0.3508248925,
0.399857223,
-0.0134253222,
0.2536837757,
-0.7484865785,
0.4002222121,
-0.2270490527,
0.4322647452,
0.8260535598,
-0.2338384241,
0.4402228892,
-0.2160344422,
0.3573593795,
-0.1180495024,
0.1659584343,
-0.0866089538,
-0.5461483002,
-0.4793651998,
-0.2467691302,
0.0465120412,
0.7300893068,
-0.6774505973,
0.4263353944,
-0.926777482,
-0.5078761578,
-0.0884481892,
-0.1952220798,
-0.1650830209,
0.2815252244,
0.4392470121,
0.265550077,
-0.8218839169,
-0.1655169725,
0.2696932554,
0.0604475103,
-0.1768133938,
0.4854295552,
0.4902084172,
-0.4403261244,
0.759506762,
-0.402187407,
-0.0026639637,
-0.2486360669,
0.1269022822,
-0.04225282,
0.4439938366,
0.5747607946,
-0.6377293468,
-0.406037569,
0.2259082347,
-0.43214643,
0.0555538684,
-0.0943820998,
-0.1021440029,
-0.2689146996,
0.2503787577,
-0.6540104747,
0.6022760272,
0.4858654141,
-0.2833411694,
0.5385203362,
-0.3254090846,
0.0855424553,
-0.9530271888,
-0.1950891316,
-0.1036830842,
-0.1770725399,
-0.6330932379,
-0.0196231436,
-0.2438459694,
-0.5074601173,
-0.3645652235,
0.592526257,
-0.1259243786,
-0.2144157737,
-0.0905845463,
-0.1668306589,
-0.286521852,
0.5528163314,
0.3610540628,
0.6517857313,
0.6196931601,
-0.5629957318,
0.4439812601,
0.0617319867,
-0.5510120392,
-0.1289187372,
-0.5701673031,
0.2403414845,
-0.1799483597,
0.2393881381,
-0.9464637041,
-0.4478719532,
0.0666744038,
-0.2433407158,
0.0019463201,
-0.5671267509,
-0.9082781672,
-0.4468496144,
0.1885205805,
0.5180219412,
0.2392972857,
-0.6905421615,
0.6877260804,
0.1757549644,
-0.0150355902,
-0.2663415074,
-0.7341513038,
0.0414551757,
-0.1482005119,
-0.2315507084,
-0.1481160671,
-0.1029500887,
0.2090582103,
-0.0330539048,
0.3522672355,
-0.350489974,
0.0757560581,
0.2996632159,
0.1223720387,
0.0394414067,
0.2301457524,
-0.239174217,
-0.2694389224,
-0.1300418973,
-0.7291879654,
0.8512626886,
0.0078397924,
-0.4026455581,
0.171726957,
0.3635685742,
0.7498241663,
-0.3468540311,
0.5457094908,
0.9137735367,
-0.4128452539,
-0.1383477896,
-0.2452384233,
0.1124848425,
-0.4450470209,
0.6308506727,
-0.2975103557,
-0.9500354528,
0.4758788347,
-0.2228426486,
-0.0959040001,
-0.048135601,
0.5978031754,
-0.401129514,
1.0183309317,
0.3258445263,
-0.0778157935,
0.6237409711,
-0.2315087616,
0.3254476786,
-0.7144044638,
-0.2460374534,
-0.3165168464,
-0.3220416903,
-0.5622178316,
-0.5967105031,
0.4368689656,
-0.2466208637,
-0.6281712651,
0.2337775528,
-0.5644830465,
0.5606322885,
0.5129951835,
0.0599645935,
-0.0850533247,
0.2786896527,
0.0227470752,
0.1581851542,
-0.7960765958,
-0.3481184542,
1.1028271914,
0.3777469993,
0.4880931973,
0.0771580786,
0.3717104197,
0.0721971765,
0.0955551937,
-0.6288768649,
0.5221569538,
-0.512227118,
-0.4224268496,
-0.408546567,
-0.5225932002,
-1.2696400881,
-0.0240829233,
-0.0317912661,
-0.926250875,
0.1792212576,
0.0107801771,
-0.6673790216,
0.7486282587,
-0.5319554806,
0.8283010721,
-0.4890706837,
-0.2248662114,
-0.0112639591,
-0.2846137583,
-0.1198105142,
-0.0270465985,
0.2979025841,
-0.4562264383,
0.080450505,
0.3216695786,
0.0115403058,
1.0389130116,
-0.2033956796,
0.1972593218,
0.1178742722,
0.1151034981,
0.4239497781,
0.1876899004,
0.061082758,
0.4894941449,
-0.1199755818,
-0.534630537,
-0.4848012924,
0.6190271974,
-0.9928106666,
0.1521854848,
-0.1872155517,
-1.0039075613,
-0.1025410816,
0.0669058114,
0.2754046023,
0.7713099718,
-0.2211109847,
-0.1576919854,
0.6927816868,
-0.2016565651,
0.5619020462,
0.5250068307,
-0.3538120091,
-0.4602565467,
1.0872799158,
0.1416328847,
-0.1699058712,
0.7287656069,
0.3797886968,
-0.1919825375,
-0.7969917059,
-0.5560562611,
-0.0794465169,
-0.4073047936,
-0.0699347481,
-0.5092086792,
-0.0901276842,
-0.5205302238,
-0.5415965319,
-0.5435002446,
-0.1411139816,
-0.1567890644,
-0.1826156229,
0.3530306518,
1.1593123674,
-0.1435695887,
0.3381339312,
-0.7912985086,
0.1048438028,
0.2802150249,
0.5162006617,
0.1137612835,
-0.2819903791,
-0.5417476296,
0.0879095346,
-0.0353572629,
-0.4537965655,
0.4142730534,
-0.0007921982,
0.1907971352,
0.3535215557,
-0.198166579,
0.702021718,
-0.8321659565,
0.6283065677,
-0.1308517605,
-0.3660472333,
0.6247649789,
-0.9399681687,
0.7116929889,
0.2469517887,
0.3366067708,
-0.3842979074,
-0.2791874707,
-0.3746438026,
-1.0879843235,
0.3946511745,
-0.1109967828,
0.0323253497,
-0.1121528149,
0.3089589179,
0.1426915377,
0.2119560838,
-0.6518396735,
0.0453477055,
-0.4957453907,
-0.2560280859,
-0.233829096,
-0.3500377238,
0.2337518632,
-0.5412672162,
0.2009711117,
-0.1622233093,
0.5814474225,
0.0810650736,
0.3128992617,
-0.0804869458,
0.4950202107,
0.6941387653,
0.5718612671,
-0.4984939396,
0.2055163085,
0.3179443181,
-0.623236835,
0.1279668361,
0.4748180509,
-0.4495534301,
-0.2010820806,
0.3116247654,
0.9852983952,
0.4048386812,
-0.6040738225,
0.2290408313,
0.266197145,
-0.0184303652,
-0.5917393565,
-0.3601419032,
-0.1015072316,
0.2720226347,
0.4946633577,
0.1609250009,
0.1261468381,
-0.4219075739,
0.1834785193,
0.0353495143,
-0.3823701143,
-0.3552676141,
0.8280104399,
0.0452177972,
0.0114224749,
0.7046628594,
-0.4279401302,
-0.6895344853,
0.7121881247,
0.3072824478,
1.0326147079,
-0.1696451902,
0.0379566289,
0.4920271635,
0.3827973604,
0.0792341977,
0.2148714513,
0.0200001337,
-0.8733392358,
-0.6754278541,
-0.802374661,
-0.2260607183,
0.2921836376,
-0.3618783951,
-0.1323503107,
-0.6626728177,
-0.125558421,
-0.5640969276,
0.0161156002,
-0.6878097057,
0.1977069825,
0.3543418944,
0.7724347711,
-0.8169229031,
0.9151819348,
1.0019490719,
-0.0819389373,
-1.0197353363,
0.1658487916,
-0.2680689394,
-0.7167593837,
0.5708443522,
0.0535290912,
-0.0823544487,
0.0189766958,
-0.6823825836,
-0.8702821732,
1.1182150841,
0.3421038091,
-0.8221415281,
-0.2344124019,
0.6409330964,
0.6195141077,
-0.3410818577,
0.3006468415,
0.655262351,
0.5281562209,
0.2779627442,
-0.9245373011,
-0.1902364343,
0.146429643,
0.1070530266,
0.3813485205,
-0.5972917676,
0.7645720243,
-0.3092422783,
-0.0207434185,
-0.0134356627,
0.4659516215,
0.0336547233,
0.2996671498,
0.204608649,
0.8603947163,
0.468511641,
-0.5010595918,
1.1898037195,
-0.2660432756,
0.3118746579,
1.258672595,
-0.0990784168,
0.8483620286,
-0.074313134,
-0.0728707761,
0.2916043103,
0.686011076,
-0.1915096045,
0.7425011396,
-0.1108884737,
-0.3247902393,
-0.3384050727,
-0.1826757044,
-0.0489668958,
0.6760612726,
0.4949993789,
0.1554984748,
-0.3734144568,
0.1445636451,
-0.0364498608,
-0.2202803195,
-0.4958542287,
0.6789374948,
-0.3134185672,
-0.3423840106,
0.2161254883,
-0.2298873365,
0.403838098,
-0.6003752351,
-0.1394766122,
-0.1114229709,
0.1877949983,
0.0110371569,
-1.1226660013,
0.2519594431,
-0.2996277511,
-0.1384064555,
-0.3098314106,
0.4932469428,
-0.7369912863,
-0.380109936,
0.5865967274,
0.2105690241,
0.1600488424,
0.0197053496,
-0.5745022297,
0.0334965959,
-0.0436815731,
-0.0856941715,
0.3639899492,
0.7029982805,
0.2092975825,
0.938722074,
0.696385026,
0.4283602834,
0.3558477461,
0.2037177384,
0.6282359958,
-0.3757671416,
-0.4028631449,
-0.630874157,
0.4547941387,
0.3173276484,
-0.1322562546,
0.4268766642,
0.6375441551,
0.8491430879,
-0.0489662141,
0.9347667694,
0.0601744466,
0.5002837777,
-0.5119245648,
0.539121151,
-0.2873581946,
0.2989013791,
0.1090334654,
-0.7850076556,
-0.2128389478,
0.5637251735,
-0.5646293759,
0.2505476773,
0.4282598495,
0.4964127839,
-0.2800540328,
-0.2331886441,
0.4582600594,
0.0894709229,
0.3959645629,
1.1008399725,
0.9369146228,
-0.2771916389,
0.867049098,
-0.4233592451,
-0.1012391374,
-0.0200864449,
-0.7296605706,
-0.85472399,
-0.6365636587,
-0.1274454445,
0.2094193548,
0.242152065,
0.7524191737,
0.935451746,
-0.8156881928,
-0.246393621,
-0.2817843854,
-0.29327178,
-0.0844114721,
-0.3033841252,
0.4279265106,
0.1164058149,
-0.8264818192,
0.6131952405,
0.5327785015,
0.4390814304,
-0.0784219056,
0.0171970557,
-0.066161491,
-0.1219078526,
0.4790997207,
0.3423852921,
-0.3507111073,
-0.5656289458,
-0.2687539458,
-0.0444552042,
0.2028291374,
0.7745053768,
-0.5944634676,
0.3808816969,
0.2290659249,
0.6219120622,
0.5853355527,
-0.096603781,
0.5647458434,
-0.9782535434,
0.2676514685,
0.2219769508,
0.5181105733,
0.4761665463,
-0.4416264594,
0.6174638867,
0.1053365916,
-0.9285345078,
-0.3859700859,
0.4204598963,
-0.8429300189,
-0.2296311408,
1.232708931,
0.0392996073,
0.0397847816,
-0.5695608258,
0.0910453871,
0.254519403,
-0.627643466,
0.8593399525,
0.4368309081,
-0.0244213231,
-0.4562499225,
-1.0007115602,
0.135896042,
-0.0197715648,
-0.7230829597,
0.3505233526,
0.4075717032,
0.150066942,
0.0415504389,
0.5639656782,
0.3569228947,
0.1941598058,
-0.0329219662,
0.2090877444,
-0.2360188067,
-0.6554750204,
-0.1506647766,
0.1520331502,
-0.1711774021,
-0.1541594416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16065v1
|
Training a Bilingual Language Model by Mapping Tokens onto a Shared Character Space
| 2024-02-25T11:26:39 | 2024-02-25T11:26:39 |
Aviad Rom, Kfir Bar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We train a bilingual Arabic-Hebrew language model using a transliterated
version of Arabic texts in Hebrew, to ensure both languages are represented in
the same script. Given the morphological, structural similarities, and the
extensive number of cognates shared among Arabic and Hebrew, we assess the
performance of a language model that employs a unified script for both
languages, on machine translation which requires cross-lingual knowledge. The
results are promising: our model outperforms a contrasting model which keeps
the Arabic texts in the Arabic script, demonstrating the efficacy of the
transliteration step. Despite being trained on a dataset approximately 60%
smaller than that of other existing language models, our model appears to
deliver comparable performance in machine translation across both translation
directions.
|
[
-0.0540068522,
-0.1409496069,
0.2009254843,
0.2548597455,
-0.3764348626,
0.4241398573,
0.0511765219,
-0.5746512413,
0.2395845652,
0.5218417645,
-0.4525018632,
-0.7725836039,
-0.7089552879,
0.1525296569,
-0.4690578878,
0.9296496511,
-0.2357772589,
0.6837544441,
0.0807078481,
-0.5615634322,
-0.5711806417,
-0.5860629678,
-0.4915878177,
-0.5298247933,
0.5614517331,
0.3591403663,
1.0790934563,
0.7988924384,
0.5889369249,
0.2755708396,
0.2183791995,
-0.0298856832,
-0.2532112598,
-0.1421163827,
-0.1370026767,
-0.5544144511,
-0.2092489749,
-0.3017140627,
0.8106142879,
1.1010587215,
-0.0063710832,
0.0199681465,
-0.3626497388,
0.3774752617,
-0.298543632,
0.2606799006,
-0.6323335767,
0.2544307709,
-0.1680604368,
-0.0337787531,
-0.3810917139,
-0.3457295001,
0.1053266674,
-0.4413983524,
0.2351105511,
0.405636847,
0.7354754806,
-0.0880733132,
-0.761098206,
-0.2851310968,
-0.6157183051,
0.8440383077,
-0.4316563606,
0.4577193558,
0.3964335322,
0.2562405765,
0.2490431666,
-0.5091078281,
-0.4192071557,
-0.3178668916,
-0.2966528237,
0.0053846515,
-0.1262321472,
-0.0747020617,
0.0075192614,
0.1871802658,
-0.730396688,
0.3297141194,
-0.4540063441,
-0.4492584765,
0.5081264973,
0.1534305662,
1.124599576,
0.0356315821,
-0.6351206303,
-0.2784546912,
-0.8218250871,
0.0935814753,
0.499648124,
0.4606721997,
-0.1646065265,
0.717998147,
0.189166829,
0.4076037705,
-0.1787576377,
0.0265299622,
0.3692384362,
-0.4810186327,
-0.0913582519,
0.4182911515,
0.6771031618,
0.300884217,
0.3177900314,
-0.532877326,
-0.3614398539,
-0.051843971,
0.3095114827,
-0.7682703137,
0.2988794148,
-0.2064158171,
-0.3692235947,
0.1476745605,
0.1246840954,
-0.3250357807,
-0.0407518409,
-0.3602485061,
0.3926975131,
-0.6173737049,
-0.1977955103,
0.1347602904,
-0.2049691677,
0.2226531804,
0.1269259751,
-1.3237338066,
0.4929101765,
0.8579322696,
0.8544819951,
-0.285183996,
-0.7390109301,
-0.5031863451,
0.2125865668,
-0.4825790524,
0.487098217,
-0.5984913707,
-0.4497517347,
0.4161990583,
-0.1576002836,
-0.4351188838,
-0.6427493691,
0.2920173705,
-0.9340823889,
-0.0485051796,
-0.2579852939,
-0.4768138528,
-0.2779842913,
-0.0164680332,
-1.0074783564,
0.9891226292,
0.3927739263,
-0.8981192112,
0.4504708946,
-0.4152392149,
-0.5326922536,
0.0177753661,
-0.1408027112,
-0.381043762,
0.134004727,
0.2149034292,
0.0946208909,
-0.2676225305,
0.1769518703,
-0.1135950014,
-0.5536667705,
0.2084976584,
-0.0556882918,
0.960208714,
0.0686117262,
-0.191726476,
0.1589441299,
-0.6449537277,
-0.0378467515,
-0.0445153788,
-0.4202505052,
-0.4102005363,
-0.4116641879,
0.4604241252,
0.2718245685,
0.4811713099,
-0.5595071316,
0.2808603048,
-0.5511850119,
-0.0937063098,
0.363914609,
-0.4346843362,
0.7821909189,
-0.3405830562,
0.6671691537,
0.2909371853,
-0.344609797,
-0.2378049046,
-0.4689249098,
-0.8763878942,
-0.3340188563,
0.4321856797,
0.5771097541,
-0.5801867247,
0.4414375126,
-0.329163909,
-0.379355669,
-0.7750707269,
0.2016417086,
0.6242288947,
0.2477951944,
0.3995499015,
-0.883222878,
-0.6631163359,
-1.0119364262,
-0.5261269808,
-0.2119566053,
0.1953808367,
-0.0518583581,
0.7074618936,
-0.3560587466,
0.76552701,
0.1633558571,
-0.1016291976,
-0.5966924429,
0.5764594674,
0.0088420985,
0.5126021504,
0.5151798129,
-0.6649272442,
-1.0553995371,
0.5462357402,
-0.6693156362,
-0.1178156883,
-0.0188818593,
-0.086810939,
0.1951116025,
0.5822460651,
-0.4050245285,
0.7157238722,
0.6969097853,
-0.4952431917,
0.3078089952,
-0.3887742162,
0.2706286013,
-1.1657311916,
0.2272173166,
-0.3914150298,
-0.382047534,
-0.7649337649,
0.1964497417,
0.150690496,
-0.1636398584,
-0.4638664424,
0.762830615,
-0.4948555529,
-0.3585287929,
-0.2746777534,
-0.3347715735,
-0.2368161231,
0.5777651668,
0.2446810007,
1.01220119,
0.6323804259,
-0.034642797,
0.2016927302,
0.2592587471,
-0.5575858951,
0.2847933769,
-0.6863661408,
0.2060318887,
-0.1247835457,
0.1579366326,
-0.9888812304,
-0.1345141381,
0.1068692952,
-0.1774143875,
0.5682509542,
-0.139791593,
-0.7234503627,
-0.1145064905,
0.0873370841,
0.9043923616,
0.5394217968,
-0.4220212102,
0.6006108522,
0.1895159334,
-0.3523841798,
-0.7239967585,
-0.7544380426,
0.0323876254,
-0.1606025398,
-0.7278467417,
0.5236490369,
0.2499096692,
-0.1091697589,
0.0019418799,
0.0330349654,
-0.4184535146,
-0.0430966802,
0.3510207832,
0.2259580493,
-0.3656493425,
0.1706858277,
0.1852510124,
-0.2551631927,
-0.2264565378,
-0.3815686107,
0.8581804037,
-0.0491806902,
-0.8935855627,
-0.7073462009,
0.8324180841,
0.8202672005,
-0.3467814624,
1.3186078072,
0.6662541628,
-0.3510578275,
0.0605776496,
-0.3459743559,
0.0458672531,
-0.3652962446,
0.5822367072,
-0.3949431479,
-0.7244956493,
0.8424193859,
-0.1119928509,
-0.10818284,
0.4791554511,
0.7693037987,
0.0765456036,
1.1989959478,
0.878804028,
-0.4521999359,
0.3637779951,
0.0279715564,
0.2480578721,
-0.2445764393,
-0.3615112007,
-0.7673745751,
-0.3403384387,
-0.4854723215,
-0.6217568517,
0.2325988561,
0.1107808203,
-0.2880289257,
0.6313037872,
0.174847886,
0.5312094688,
0.8343500495,
-0.3164635301,
0.4043754041,
0.5230251551,
-0.7441539168,
-0.2303425819,
-0.6951636672,
-0.515583992,
1.1300578117,
0.2925447822,
0.524012208,
0.1132435575,
0.9439160824,
0.1479415894,
0.2242540419,
-0.4515151381,
0.2271204591,
0.029840583,
-0.7736087441,
-0.1957169622,
-0.3484015763,
-1.0737704039,
0.2612689137,
0.1680907756,
-0.6472737193,
-0.3193193078,
-0.2781183422,
-0.0124217747,
0.2340364009,
-0.6109504104,
0.9124449492,
-0.2234596312,
0.0293568578,
-0.5583875179,
-0.814442277,
-0.0658475608,
-0.2907804847,
0.0403917395,
0.1663445234,
0.1408851892,
0.8136999011,
-0.6332297325,
0.811134398,
0.182656914,
0.0991306305,
0.2789033055,
0.1916787028,
0.1912863404,
-0.2581009269,
-0.1154630333,
0.5769372582,
0.0712863058,
-0.7209250927,
-0.5286636949,
0.4077534676,
-1.2910504341,
-0.3554633856,
-0.6006768346,
-1.0016977787,
-0.1103750467,
0.3154619932,
0.0994942635,
0.271253258,
-0.4995682538,
-0.0621264279,
0.2582376301,
-0.3003458083,
0.3573886752,
0.5468431115,
-0.5712009072,
-0.3785603046,
0.7312370539,
-0.0143120233,
0.2745191455,
0.567574203,
-0.1028291211,
-0.3013842106,
-0.3640753031,
-0.7933254838,
0.4365516603,
-0.7762547731,
0.0748037472,
-0.4385489821,
-0.3838047683,
-0.3435238898,
-0.2116605639,
-0.458039552,
-0.414270401,
-0.1050440073,
0.0544452332,
-0.0386313125,
0.9075410962,
-0.0583255924,
0.3988967538,
-1.0307397842,
0.0854173377,
0.2228664756,
-0.0060701584,
-0.0929657146,
-0.6822377443,
-0.549886167,
0.1488266289,
-0.1819685251,
-0.8603940606,
0.5702082515,
-0.0265407003,
0.4443727136,
0.2841656208,
-0.5439984798,
0.6700262427,
-0.9107836485,
0.5323377252,
0.6610683799,
-0.9478928447,
0.0352642946,
-0.3290672004,
0.3824101686,
0.5400189161,
0.7652451992,
-0.9381845593,
-0.2800720632,
-0.3448561728,
-0.5425354838,
0.8078696728,
0.1845492572,
0.3090862334,
0.1729248315,
-0.0362353362,
0.5202938318,
0.2627335191,
-0.7767608166,
-0.2679340243,
0.0816624016,
-0.5164497495,
-0.1323287636,
-0.1166789085,
-0.21706222,
-0.4091599882,
0.36524719,
0.0094303368,
0.3673185706,
-0.289475143,
-0.3910753131,
-0.30910182,
0.1149260402,
0.4026290774,
0.6502253413,
0.0348568261,
0.2030410469,
0.1041426957,
-0.3857061565,
0.2317374796,
0.0534730516,
-0.2672525346,
0.2120856792,
0.6491826773,
0.8478683829,
0.2437869757,
-0.6514376998,
0.4966278672,
0.0585076399,
-0.0287245978,
0.0585974492,
-0.1947788149,
0.4468509555,
0.190301165,
0.2417663336,
0.2435128391,
-0.1618193388,
-0.8756682277,
0.1680276692,
0.4547386467,
-0.429562211,
-0.6117731333,
0.3316244483,
0.017727498,
-0.6019114852,
0.7182978392,
-0.0601232164,
-1.0066940784,
0.7119506598,
0.9464401603,
0.7422386408,
-0.3418085575,
0.3004213274,
0.406799376,
0.1924260408,
-0.008777298,
0.1807945967,
-0.110780187,
-0.6797943115,
-0.0805087015,
-0.7428047061,
-0.2907427549,
-0.3614226878,
-0.691360116,
0.2859900296,
-0.2777884901,
0.0700092092,
-0.2470692396,
-0.0016449229,
-0.9894090891,
0.0564252883,
0.2563130856,
0.8217785358,
-1.0628848076,
1.0455390215,
0.5695634484,
-0.6946761012,
-0.8585210443,
-0.0933257937,
-0.2882220149,
-1.3025001287,
1.2587746382,
0.4061383307,
-0.2459727079,
-0.1323262602,
-0.143161729,
-1.0348231792,
1.0565848351,
0.3801560998,
-0.4755554199,
-0.2149094939,
0.8190511465,
0.6974503994,
-0.5711518526,
0.2615360618,
0.330195725,
0.1537860483,
0.1317549348,
-1.2527548075,
-0.2599863112,
-0.1883524209,
0.0680558905,
0.0571596362,
-0.5320695043,
0.8043839335,
-0.0484308973,
-0.4133267999,
0.3059083819,
0.7824863791,
-0.0714655444,
0.4265188277,
0.238167882,
0.7768162489,
0.734238863,
0.2741913497,
0.9487922788,
-0.656763196,
0.3047975898,
0.962521255,
-0.5417097211,
0.8653899431,
0.659009397,
-0.0404407121,
0.7720708251,
0.3355507851,
0.3010360301,
0.6626638174,
0.1394699067,
-0.3715084195,
-0.2659741342,
-0.307087332,
-0.4877869785,
0.5322933793,
-0.0446300358,
-0.6538797617,
-0.3804982603,
-0.0614678375,
0.1084278226,
0.191815719,
-0.1524510086,
0.5984759927,
-0.0017700593,
-1.0167831182,
0.4821678102,
0.5083543062,
0.2012385726,
-0.6361387968,
0.1210121214,
-0.2742532194,
0.1395036727,
0.2638041973,
-0.2617440224,
0.4061665535,
0.0676373616,
-0.1026439816,
-0.4852159619,
0.4580776095,
-0.7248215675,
-0.8519646525,
0.4989022911,
0.6428210735,
0.1597789973,
0.3774312139,
-0.6285560727,
0.0870632678,
-0.0508481897,
0.2517139018,
0.4939017296,
0.3734298944,
-0.1073748246,
0.4726884067,
0.5996149182,
0.1200183332,
0.4584256113,
0.3187637627,
0.6981322169,
-0.6109525561,
-0.5166912675,
-0.8577565551,
0.3382549882,
0.0299552903,
-0.2868005037,
0.8899785876,
0.6869166493,
0.9955608249,
-0.1998392642,
0.6898076534,
0.3595563769,
0.3300314248,
-0.3507721126,
0.7386896014,
-0.6109892726,
-0.1419176012,
0.1360124648,
-0.7798486948,
-0.4283876121,
0.6850936413,
-0.2381169796,
0.153842032,
0.901479125,
0.9704432487,
-0.2741492391,
0.0107453289,
0.4544066489,
-0.2179280072,
-0.0431547239,
0.7816534042,
0.8760147691,
-0.5957661271,
0.2789779902,
0.1140604764,
0.064788878,
-0.3073695302,
-0.5110217929,
-1.2630982399,
-0.6373425722,
-0.1165207028,
-0.294057548,
0.0056122737,
0.9978645444,
0.6991609931,
-0.8349261284,
-0.672329843,
-0.1847500652,
-0.09581168,
-0.1480090767,
-0.0249364004,
0.3581083715,
-0.4012364149,
-0.922367394,
0.2893758714,
0.4375782609,
0.0526044182,
-0.3597131073,
-0.3604873121,
-0.3493295312,
0.2231332511,
0.0619255379,
0.2083258629,
-0.6638823152,
-0.1931320727,
0.1256777942,
-0.742955029,
0.1702357829,
1.0436617136,
-0.4356081784,
0.5438461304,
0.4898108244,
0.9217499495,
0.6196539998,
-0.1805009246,
0.7158993483,
-0.6980079412,
0.2906236649,
0.1465009749,
0.4323194623,
0.4060257077,
-0.0314575136,
0.0861803442,
0.1571845561,
-0.3436493874,
-0.5373975039,
0.4144566059,
-0.8836457133,
0.0520365834,
1.0530480146,
-0.4628596902,
-0.1829098016,
-0.1195466593,
-0.3416453004,
0.5716456771,
-0.1657567918,
0.801071465,
0.9091499448,
0.5001807809,
0.3212231696,
-0.163945511,
0.276999712,
0.916141808,
-0.3404847383,
-0.2525871992,
0.1126032397,
0.2734338343,
0.2129365355,
0.5454580784,
0.0254318416,
0.4427511692,
0.3223870993,
0.1561691463,
0.1891959012,
-0.563793242,
-0.4538528323,
0.1714264303,
0.1558918357,
-0.0289119743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16063v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16063v3
|
Citation-Enhanced Generation for LLM-based Chatbots
| 2024-02-25T11:24:41 | 2024-03-04T01:53:35 |
Weitao Li, Junkai Li, Weizhi Ma, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit powerful general intelligence across
diverse scenarios, including their integration into chatbots. However, a vital
challenge of LLM-based chatbots is that they may produce hallucinated content
in responses, which significantly limits their applicability. Various efforts
have been made to alleviate hallucination, such as retrieval augmented
generation and reinforcement learning with human feedback, but most of them
require additional training and data annotation. In this paper, we propose a
novel post-hoc Citation-Enhanced Generation (CEG) approach combined with
retrieval argumentation. Unlike previous studies that focus on preventing
hallucinations during generation, our method addresses this issue in a post-hoc
way. It incorporates a retrieval module to search for supporting documents
relevant to the generated content, and employs a natural language
inference-based citation generation module. Once the statements in the
generated content lack of reference, our model can regenerate responses until
all statements are supported by citations. Note that our method is a
training-free plug-and-play plugin that is capable of various LLMs. Experiments
on various hallucination-related datasets show our framework outperforms
state-of-the-art methods in both hallucination detection and response
regeneration on three benchmarks. Our codes and dataset will be publicly
available.
|
[
-0.4080865681,
-0.9443264008,
0.5298404694,
-0.0351738483,
-0.3801964223,
-0.0441070125,
-0.3310211003,
-0.3373895288,
0.4180110097,
0.6047729254,
-0.5271400809,
-0.4158334434,
-0.2614956498,
0.273883462,
-0.1533066779,
0.8620733023,
0.4864316285,
0.0814743638,
-0.5586640239,
0.1342466325,
-0.5402430296,
-0.6712573171,
-0.4278014302,
-0.3442299068,
0.6631863117,
0.3593911827,
0.6624547839,
0.0890770182,
0.373816967,
0.2436067313,
0.0285900664,
0.7602646351,
-0.5229974389,
0.4521144032,
-0.3844224513,
0.0309096426,
-0.3755011559,
-0.3392477632,
0.3612110019,
0.5190224051,
-0.0753599852,
-0.1842954159,
0.2015554756,
0.4804739356,
-0.6259135008,
-0.0810490325,
-1.3648099899,
-0.2515205145,
0.1548776031,
-0.7946176529,
-0.7918068171,
-0.6167898178,
0.0271771085,
-0.5619573593,
0.2324792594,
0.0303411204,
0.8627821207,
0.2481757402,
-0.134233132,
-0.5373402238,
-0.5908100009,
0.7861721516,
-0.6013188958,
0.2286862582,
0.4582106173,
0.1741394103,
-0.5136675239,
-0.7128691077,
-0.5360776782,
-0.4025630057,
-0.0948453322,
-0.0423451774,
-0.1572421491,
-0.1435812712,
0.2046264559,
0.0150656868,
-0.5473735332,
-0.1937773377,
-0.2054907233,
-0.3025920391,
0.6248093843,
-0.1901475042,
0.0306474734,
-0.4763962626,
-0.3752858937,
-0.0917665437,
-0.7719898224,
-0.7724164128,
0.4212401509,
0.5260759592,
0.4028665125,
0.4638775885,
-0.078574121,
0.2072815001,
0.1207241565,
0.2124912143,
0.5265437365,
-0.082276091,
-0.118954137,
0.1639381498,
0.8100025654,
0.2061558217,
0.2599973083,
-0.4391689301,
-0.0138891982,
-0.1087836102,
0.4735215604,
-0.8883681893,
-0.3643048406,
0.2022794038,
-0.2494641542,
-0.4535672367,
0.1022094712,
-0.7701624632,
-0.6096780896,
-0.225581944,
0.3461018205,
-0.5503005981,
-0.4104230106,
-0.0282356273,
0.05394952,
0.4422036111,
0.3343503177,
-0.7006524801,
-0.0910764411,
0.500395596,
0.7691105008,
-0.2870835066,
0.0223097242,
-0.8956548572,
0.2099038512,
-0.2394446284,
1.1297683716,
-0.814201653,
-0.6268039942,
0.3695354164,
0.151932165,
0.0387471803,
-0.8185001612,
0.7568650246,
-0.6900703311,
0.1842951775,
-0.2307067811,
-0.4939678013,
0.0134667959,
0.2695250511,
-0.5095394254,
1.1621278524,
-0.1353023648,
-0.8065713644,
0.1803949475,
-0.5140275359,
-0.4023106694,
0.3037607074,
-0.3820503652,
-0.6225869656,
0.1419869512,
0.2899909616,
0.4033956528,
-0.2542765439,
0.6651640534,
-0.510835886,
-0.229764685,
0.2443798929,
-0.3264006972,
0.4894502163,
0.2390942127,
-0.1683758795,
0.4733796418,
-0.8881092668,
0.1480924487,
0.210769549,
-0.1641199738,
-0.238630414,
0.2120464295,
0.0432708375,
0.1617839932,
0.1644328237,
-0.4469939172,
-0.0523276143,
-0.2407296896,
0.1886249483,
0.6710131764,
0.4016554356,
0.243527621,
-0.3355197906,
0.312035203,
-0.1721929461,
-0.1615859717,
-0.2587866485,
-0.3145426214,
-0.6545556188,
-0.1478267461,
-0.1379110366,
0.3655220568,
-1.0107221603,
0.8560703993,
-0.4086719155,
-0.3920404911,
-0.2866258621,
0.1464526355,
0.1864523441,
0.5094953775,
0.6475323439,
0.1558734477,
-0.9331751466,
-0.7172872424,
-0.033079721,
-0.2688995004,
-0.3930264115,
0.6628379226,
0.380209744,
-0.4188576341,
0.7388654947,
-0.2235527635,
-0.0322329476,
-0.3447534442,
0.1377681941,
-0.2136177868,
0.5478324294,
0.1350092888,
-0.5509735346,
-0.1463141739,
-0.0157838557,
-0.9582129121,
-0.401080668,
-0.472320348,
-0.668951571,
0.2911037803,
0.6617293954,
-0.6265622973,
0.2736698389,
0.0838947669,
-0.1173586622,
0.6295317411,
-0.0485345423,
0.0470547229,
-1.062086463,
0.2734354436,
-0.3260315657,
-0.184138,
-0.4227951169,
-0.1024262831,
-0.1690209806,
-0.1783797741,
-0.4038244784,
0.4919498563,
-0.3084231913,
0.1209150925,
-0.7301870584,
0.4845710993,
-0.0753418654,
0.4133788645,
0.5460714698,
0.4376964867,
0.403716892,
-0.5790303349,
0.1017082259,
0.4047535062,
0.0379818827,
0.4551878572,
-0.7313995361,
0.567696631,
-0.0406000242,
0.3341723084,
-0.8950914145,
-0.3031839132,
0.2268288732,
-0.6196228266,
0.0273689032,
0.0623932146,
-0.6355978251,
-0.1841528118,
-0.3960438967,
-0.0017721078,
0.4036306143,
-0.9047772288,
0.5762161613,
0.2019999772,
-0.0784570798,
-0.1751660854,
-0.2289519906,
0.2223411947,
-0.2533394992,
-0.6742203236,
0.4132798612,
-0.3178360164,
-0.0751094818,
-0.3891042173,
0.0169588141,
0.3684656322,
0.0666068643,
0.2040338665,
0.4232540131,
-0.1141541377,
0.3904842734,
0.1782417297,
-0.0474113114,
0.0568597056,
-0.0635507032,
0.9636471868,
-0.0264675412,
-0.3195288777,
-0.4174668789,
0.3926438689,
0.1190664396,
-0.0178564675,
0.5811131001,
0.6888400912,
-0.2811162174,
-0.2539218962,
-0.6961224079,
-0.5871848464,
-0.5439978838,
0.2625264227,
-0.1815263331,
-0.7334389687,
0.2896895111,
-0.2233707607,
0.2203629166,
0.2580095232,
0.764044106,
0.0483446047,
0.6796555519,
0.0216950607,
0.3834271729,
0.4910639822,
0.1550607979,
0.1151988655,
-0.7238237262,
-0.3580023646,
-0.5547617674,
-0.0543185323,
-0.4657822847,
-0.569869101,
-0.1304744184,
0.1650544852,
-0.1656566411,
0.2252508998,
-0.698771596,
0.3776362836,
0.4726656079,
0.262093395,
0.2988449633,
0.2493056655,
0.0420278683,
0.0153712006,
-0.3942991197,
-0.8883291483,
1.0502203703,
-0.019334266,
0.5597132444,
0.0017962033,
0.8599171638,
0.4253675044,
0.4195310771,
-0.6482229233,
0.8469346762,
0.5488824248,
-0.4146376252,
-0.2986913919,
-0.4639007449,
-1.0877963305,
0.3809407949,
-0.3228207231,
-0.7397450209,
0.0338121317,
0.0794236213,
-0.1181592047,
0.0729610696,
-0.4436085522,
0.4607275426,
-0.0343028419,
-0.6757066846,
-0.1825742573,
-0.4538720846,
0.2885796428,
-0.086668767,
-0.0145435743,
-0.0780977681,
0.2894927859,
0.6305283308,
-0.428358376,
0.7584545016,
-0.3405166268,
-0.1163010448,
0.590415895,
0.1128999442,
0.7779177427,
0.3518728316,
-0.2388976067,
-0.1128010005,
-0.327953577,
-0.3209484518,
-0.4791748822,
0.8540463448,
-0.416320622,
-0.8733209372,
-0.1751163006,
-0.518021524,
-0.3964045346,
-0.0467923023,
0.0666256025,
0.0150486324,
-0.3065233827,
0.5179249644,
0.6295763254,
-0.5684681535,
0.4355631471,
0.2505062521,
-0.2712337077,
-0.6406607628,
0.9366736412,
-0.3390757143,
0.0281305555,
0.0942687541,
0.2460189164,
-0.3900442123,
-0.515243113,
-0.1468048245,
0.3448552489,
-0.4852061272,
-0.3544689119,
-0.8329415321,
-0.3185665011,
-0.5186500549,
-0.2420836687,
-0.1680231392,
-0.172030434,
-0.4210037291,
-0.2446630001,
0.5347361565,
0.2635995448,
-0.041222062,
0.1663808078,
-0.6407137513,
0.1602469534,
0.1795083731,
0.002712429,
0.2329559624,
-0.6256974936,
-0.0653172061,
-0.1443008333,
-0.6420978308,
-0.7802734375,
0.3972685337,
0.2279247195,
0.636094749,
0.4028468132,
0.4017851055,
0.7661353946,
-0.4851730168,
0.8115542531,
0.18930839,
-0.6602541208,
0.7920506001,
-0.3808355629,
0.0653211921,
0.4317722321,
0.2239500284,
-0.1263757497,
-0.4910834432,
-0.6896588206,
-0.982493937,
0.3139215708,
0.4391214252,
0.4922123849,
-0.6337703466,
0.2469353676,
0.3305086792,
0.06719888,
-0.7670721412,
0.0735865235,
-0.2977551818,
0.0809200332,
0.4054277539,
-0.2493279874,
0.0197981969,
-0.1160207838,
0.825517416,
-0.1567437202,
0.25707376,
0.256302774,
-0.3148205876,
0.121592626,
0.203916505,
0.4847759008,
0.423417151,
-0.1753177196,
0.1055726781,
0.0932752788,
-0.2121307552,
-0.2491542399,
0.1191516891,
-0.0607318729,
0.314286679,
0.1476000249,
0.5548942089,
0.1584580094,
-0.9253026843,
0.3249942362,
0.0972596481,
-0.334975332,
-0.5115697384,
0.117481716,
0.119363904,
0.3558889031,
0.5649522543,
-0.2207919657,
0.0352056026,
-0.3430273831,
0.5677136183,
0.5830810666,
-0.2453349233,
-0.2968581319,
0.7465204597,
0.4196693599,
-0.504345119,
0.4602304995,
-0.3500857055,
-0.1300139129,
0.1393108219,
0.6894437671,
1.0652142763,
-0.0962943733,
0.3754144311,
0.7599051595,
-0.1284280568,
0.2018817067,
0.3649392128,
-0.4239337742,
-0.6648147106,
-0.1046469957,
-0.5664976239,
-0.2781486809,
0.3752881885,
-0.5892794132,
0.3874073923,
-0.3035092652,
-0.2750178874,
-0.2715543509,
-0.0829756036,
-0.5016860366,
-0.1516242027,
0.3361615241,
0.4674279988,
-0.4682842195,
0.906946063,
0.3110285401,
-0.4575143456,
-0.2295876294,
0.1008322015,
-0.289306581,
-0.5803390741,
0.4707656801,
0.1749905199,
-0.2838436067,
-0.0871130079,
-0.6577904224,
-0.6209114194,
1.0410331488,
0.442900449,
-0.5230270624,
-0.0705440938,
-0.0433826782,
0.4848339558,
-0.5042582154,
0.280998379,
0.365830332,
0.2271529138,
0.5700504184,
-0.5573379993,
0.3145359159,
-0.419875443,
0.0740460604,
-0.2766175568,
-0.3556645811,
0.2548639774,
-0.3140750527,
-0.2965909839,
0.3035966754,
0.9359007478,
0.9132958651,
0.2900513113,
0.4348067641,
0.0630226135,
1.1012231112,
0.1509900242,
0.6629793644,
-0.300467521,
0.0921119675,
1.5065559149,
-0.4994108677,
1.0602555275,
0.6591861844,
0.2233158201,
0.6829293966,
0.5207859278,
-0.2186612636,
0.5102035999,
0.4276616871,
-0.3266655803,
-0.5108252168,
-0.3625276089,
-0.501249969,
0.1866953522,
0.3370195627,
-0.7058409452,
-0.0916505083,
0.0124461204,
0.1871220171,
0.3029766679,
0.0126171373,
0.9121002555,
-0.0662046522,
-0.6571170688,
0.8520932198,
-0.5134111643,
0.619438231,
-0.3602865636,
-0.1885176301,
-0.2490539253,
-0.0371939689,
-0.1680239588,
-0.3176331818,
0.3677129149,
0.140455693,
0.0435932241,
-0.0669198707,
0.8289231062,
-0.3203493953,
-0.3948480189,
0.405957371,
0.6270548701,
0.44947505,
-0.1706461012,
-0.3621836007,
0.1426909119,
0.0977602378,
-0.4380641282,
0.2258837521,
0.4619705379,
0.0378376022,
0.4673471749,
0.7693818808,
-0.1114378348,
-0.0005605331,
0.4985240698,
0.970082581,
-0.577147007,
-0.193885088,
-0.8617908955,
0.4499389529,
-0.5691435337,
-0.1384758055,
0.6756106615,
0.7084795237,
0.5683574677,
-0.0732745752,
0.939519763,
0.0381732956,
0.472251296,
-0.4237236977,
0.6370700598,
-0.4024053812,
0.5504204035,
-0.4300507307,
-0.883458972,
-0.3357665539,
0.7229393721,
-0.3065519929,
0.073570691,
0.5992668271,
1.1009885073,
0.2516523004,
0.0914619863,
0.5045210123,
0.013212204,
0.5443738699,
0.3976461887,
0.9127926826,
-0.229254216,
1.0439435244,
0.2013577372,
0.1043914557,
-0.4156917334,
-0.7838454843,
-1.150444746,
-0.4818897545,
-0.5125347972,
-0.6949594617,
0.0696220025,
1.0895318985,
0.5270023346,
-0.7236865759,
0.1521084756,
-0.2069524229,
-0.0576390736,
0.1590878069,
-0.2530346811,
0.505702436,
-0.7904874086,
-0.7080308795,
0.5169566274,
0.0464834236,
-0.1654944718,
-0.2384586185,
-0.3124649227,
-0.2337310761,
0.3951926827,
0.7767100334,
0.1734584719,
-0.8193262815,
-0.5016273856,
0.1242856234,
-0.0432659797,
0.198893249,
0.7011181116,
-1.0403100252,
0.3895772696,
0.3402456343,
0.6829251647,
0.4094035327,
0.1212785617,
0.4351966679,
-0.7651815414,
0.1108312458,
0.3916212022,
0.3573569059,
0.5506262779,
-0.2534271479,
0.466496557,
0.244621411,
-0.6352325082,
-1.0411396027,
0.1346850097,
-0.9641225934,
-0.230723381,
1.5092135668,
0.0639646202,
-0.0144522898,
-0.1389100254,
-0.4027761221,
0.3124122322,
-0.6169042587,
1.1956498623,
0.5488478541,
-0.0890085772,
-0.1390980631,
-0.3201810122,
0.4217202067,
0.2645971477,
-1.0703239441,
0.5120399594,
0.6909739971,
-0.1510241181,
0.2522805333,
0.3905854523,
-0.2636828423,
0.2567708492,
0.0879691392,
0.2595436275,
0.025360886,
-0.2831012011,
0.0574072152,
0.2695348561,
-0.0409404114,
-0.2387977242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12077v1
|
Evaluating Robustness of Generative Search Engine on Adversarial Factual Questions
| 2024-02-25T11:22:19 | 2024-02-25T11:22:19 |
Xuming Hu, Xiaochuan Li, Junzhe Chen, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Xiaoguang Li, Yasheng Wang, Qun Liu, Lijie Wen, Philip S. Yu, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Generative search engines have the potential to transform how people seek
information online, but generated responses from existing large language models
(LLMs)-backed generative search engines may not always be accurate.
Nonetheless, retrieval-augmented generation exacerbates safety concerns, since
adversaries may successfully evade the entire system by subtly manipulating the
most vulnerable part of a claim. To this end, we propose evaluating the
robustness of generative search engines in the realistic and high-risk setting,
where adversaries have only black-box system access and seek to deceive the
model into returning incorrect responses. Through a comprehensive human
evaluation of various generative search engines, such as Bing Chat,
PerplexityAI, and YouChat across diverse queries, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of adversarial factual questions in inducing incorrect responses.
Moreover, retrieval-augmented generation exhibits a higher susceptibility to
factual errors compared to LLMs without retrieval. These findings highlight the
potential security risks of these systems and emphasize the need for rigorous
evaluation before deployment.
|
[
-0.3898376822,
-1.0495069027,
0.5609638691,
0.0096703032,
0.059487734,
0.2768744528,
-0.1146836281,
-0.4410949349,
-0.1314787269,
0.2841607034,
-0.3617964089,
-0.3484401703,
-0.5181720853,
0.0877251253,
-0.6783570647,
0.761030376,
0.3377573192,
-0.3949079216,
-0.2754606605,
-0.0317721516,
-0.2994392216,
-0.6788451076,
-0.5879268646,
0.1652059108,
0.3895636797,
-0.150843963,
1.2121635675,
0.0812615305,
0.5617556572,
0.3642706275,
-0.2013884783,
0.2477156669,
-0.6964796185,
0.4021880329,
-0.3088964522,
-0.7280339599,
-0.100054577,
-0.1655219793,
0.2668646276,
0.4717759788,
-0.3022580743,
0.0039506718,
0.14045766,
0.3668885231,
-1.0320883989,
-0.1578125209,
-1.0940362215,
0.0511258543,
-0.1174300388,
-0.2883953154,
-0.4977569878,
-0.5524295568,
0.1874586344,
-0.636674881,
0.5187866092,
0.0676353052,
1.0427396297,
0.3416489065,
-0.4471734762,
-0.3671928644,
-0.9447495341,
0.3758900166,
-0.4475178421,
0.1428057849,
0.4816814363,
0.4720850885,
-0.4814075232,
-0.7241056561,
-0.5105633736,
-0.404071331,
0.0183074009,
0.1219053119,
-0.5022567511,
0.0931081623,
0.4008263946,
0.378064692,
-0.901517272,
0.0363471843,
-0.2014291584,
-0.4379351437,
0.6015840173,
0.021321347,
0.5527771115,
-0.1798923016,
-0.3984209001,
-0.4191645384,
-0.7778245807,
-0.2556245923,
0.6119194031,
0.187695384,
0.1541231126,
0.717911303,
0.0306517389,
0.5696631074,
0.1598637849,
0.1574527621,
-0.1046527103,
-0.5186215043,
-0.165915072,
0.0323097333,
0.7909117937,
0.2861966491,
0.0431876965,
-0.464817971,
-0.3437886536,
0.3246303499,
0.9496781826,
-0.6678720713,
0.0496275127,
0.2196437716,
-0.2336577475,
-0.6573781371,
0.1565530449,
-0.8939276934,
-0.6247916222,
0.4403843582,
0.6518373489,
-0.3417608142,
0.0096704429,
0.0230762493,
-0.1334162354,
0.1883468479,
0.2846393883,
-0.657509625,
0.012162379,
0.5860093236,
0.7604741454,
0.0753595456,
-0.1033778638,
-0.6741832495,
-0.1047216952,
-0.4135672748,
0.6423788667,
-0.1230033636,
-0.8106364012,
0.3176366389,
-0.1679145545,
-0.1137474775,
-0.5508767962,
0.881508708,
-1.1513600349,
0.070348151,
-0.3123323619,
-0.26885131,
0.0362240411,
0.6480462551,
-0.7404744029,
0.6857628822,
-0.1548255682,
-0.9593268633,
0.2729208469,
-0.3999275565,
-0.5899057388,
0.1343445629,
-0.2455352992,
-0.5602652431,
0.0675831288,
0.3306074142,
0.1590108871,
-0.3224606514,
0.2488873303,
-0.6481701136,
-0.3906699419,
0.6280542612,
-0.9945194721,
1.0583782196,
0.3570350707,
-0.5073968768,
-0.065267235,
-0.5921421051,
0.0168038644,
0.3662019074,
-0.3963916898,
-0.4150457382,
0.0179229099,
-0.1262586862,
0.0101450179,
0.2764863372,
-0.4392151833,
-0.0805370137,
-0.5567441583,
0.1081228703,
0.8628690243,
0.1075554788,
0.0525097959,
-0.2662750185,
0.750394702,
-0.2058615088,
0.173725605,
0.1184814051,
-0.4645549953,
-0.5015898347,
0.0143182455,
0.3991992474,
0.6728915572,
-1.0533887148,
0.5597798228,
-0.278188318,
-0.4044877291,
-0.3932974935,
0.0092791095,
0.3533557951,
0.4459430277,
0.0623249821,
-0.0109869847,
-0.3593339026,
-0.689607203,
-0.2240075469,
-0.5472580194,
-0.1676297933,
0.4719872475,
0.5181828141,
-0.3765417337,
0.6380997896,
-0.5671137571,
0.3932910562,
0.1388055086,
0.1969468296,
-0.342015028,
0.08850234,
0.5864217877,
-1.1781266928,
-0.1778810322,
-0.0895570293,
-1.0629603863,
0.2247867137,
-0.1537884325,
-0.1751485914,
0.102990523,
0.1011962742,
-0.9434293509,
0.5347986817,
0.5041140914,
-0.261885792,
0.7002224922,
-0.2740430534,
0.2685407996,
-0.9270806313,
0.3361523151,
-0.1192572713,
-0.1820397824,
-0.4882270098,
0.4973141849,
-0.0202445593,
-0.3829356432,
-0.2849408388,
0.1096821427,
-0.1473827064,
-0.1578914225,
-0.1977489889,
0.2007276118,
0.1124820933,
-0.0625215396,
-0.519220531,
1.283752203,
0.4415150583,
-0.5777486563,
0.5264407396,
0.3097896874,
-0.5996656418,
0.4871365726,
-0.6988115311,
0.252310425,
-0.1120143384,
0.1480218619,
-0.8759680986,
-0.385202527,
0.1013412774,
-0.6682545543,
0.3319332302,
0.0115065817,
-0.6242161393,
-0.244334057,
-0.4830876589,
0.1953888237,
0.3413661122,
-0.6705527306,
0.3487164974,
0.2666891217,
-0.191262126,
-0.8388699889,
-0.5167800784,
0.5637831092,
-0.2573678792,
-0.8703297973,
0.3074051738,
-0.0332712382,
-0.2971796095,
0.1694160998,
-0.143220365,
0.1042700708,
0.6566456556,
0.1061902791,
0.3821773529,
-0.1182150021,
-0.1245008409,
-0.2286301255,
0.0985754505,
0.2004966587,
-0.0470447503,
0.4028545618,
-0.2261621952,
-0.6929097176,
-0.1114083752,
0.1952731609,
0.7052819729,
-0.2686457932,
0.8485689163,
0.5630273819,
-0.5418353081,
0.0407109223,
-0.5717221498,
-0.1345976293,
-0.5101917982,
0.354706645,
-0.174028784,
-0.696805656,
0.5764165521,
0.1538009346,
-0.2100906074,
0.4804292619,
0.5041025877,
-0.0379023179,
1.3589792252,
0.2671222389,
0.0225975178,
0.0904435068,
-0.078210786,
0.1868958473,
-0.5188080668,
-0.2874411941,
-0.669479847,
0.0920267552,
-1.0055189133,
-0.128376022,
0.6249259114,
-0.095997341,
-0.1384155303,
0.3052353561,
-0.2445519567,
0.1138219982,
0.6112154126,
0.3232676387,
0.1158589348,
0.2554244697,
-0.1640069336,
0.0496366061,
-0.597636044,
-0.5931392908,
1.2272369862,
0.1705527455,
0.9921378493,
0.4394392073,
0.367818445,
0.5099298954,
0.1865323335,
-0.5967434645,
0.4301755726,
-0.0692221895,
-1.0064281225,
-0.2512558103,
-0.6432392597,
-0.9788169265,
0.3107617497,
-0.4103184342,
-0.499917239,
0.2095515877,
0.0610383004,
-0.5342397094,
0.3251467943,
-0.5796965361,
0.609726429,
-0.5296256542,
-0.341827333,
-0.0887467712,
-0.6999213099,
0.3852785826,
-0.1795187891,
-0.067820102,
0.3769507706,
0.2052977085,
0.3126361966,
-0.3006426692,
0.7699851394,
0.0477020964,
-0.1171616614,
0.3698994517,
0.2719177604,
0.690421164,
0.1772388816,
-0.1227737144,
-0.151308611,
-0.2469716668,
-0.4803421795,
-0.8521933556,
0.8465260267,
-0.6836129427,
-0.9945389032,
-0.6029613614,
-0.2614920139,
-0.3507991135,
0.2464221269,
0.5286418796,
0.1663320959,
-0.48338902,
0.3668325543,
0.8898901343,
-0.4186743796,
-0.0589230768,
0.2245402485,
0.1885806471,
-0.4124798477,
0.9204300046,
-0.1119255722,
0.290228039,
0.2333492488,
0.0838550106,
-0.5643745065,
-0.5862190723,
-0.6788388491,
-0.1286533326,
-0.6832055449,
-0.2485477775,
-0.4095001817,
-0.2589657903,
-0.3241377473,
-0.0020620709,
-0.2011210322,
-0.1181950867,
-0.2820102274,
-0.23114492,
-0.1452642381,
0.4586847723,
0.2261344194,
-0.1643597633,
-0.6733494401,
0.324796319,
0.7157340646,
0.0726969019,
-0.2303854227,
-0.3870982528,
0.0329681113,
0.2370833755,
-0.6013154387,
-0.9108905196,
0.0897780806,
-0.0060147,
0.5477378368,
0.4952140152,
0.338860333,
0.5171555877,
-0.3037859797,
0.7879488468,
-0.0505962372,
-0.5063470006,
0.6041383147,
-0.292476207,
-0.0273928791,
0.5848223567,
0.4238088131,
-0.1251734495,
-0.1424978375,
-0.7329661846,
-0.6762443185,
0.321457386,
0.6466697454,
0.2088075727,
0.0527027287,
0.4157139659,
-0.2195655257,
0.2218971848,
-0.419428736,
-0.3405236602,
-0.4589439332,
-0.015305399,
0.0944758505,
-0.3496333063,
-0.4120777249,
0.3706720471,
0.5784834623,
-0.0301272236,
0.2588744462,
0.1178275049,
-0.1045020297,
-0.0705880746,
0.4621038735,
0.5670149922,
0.4431035817,
-0.3037283719,
0.4430161715,
0.197474286,
-0.4016488791,
0.3149104118,
0.4347273707,
-0.5419685245,
-0.2740601003,
0.4092561007,
0.7215061784,
0.0041113649,
-0.8855364919,
0.6780057549,
-0.3497689068,
0.0972591788,
-0.1724851727,
0.112323381,
-0.1122920737,
-0.0579292588,
0.3607880771,
0.368653357,
0.3610534072,
-0.6663010716,
0.0775053874,
0.8026423454,
-0.2080517858,
-0.3500398993,
0.8482350111,
0.1092073545,
-0.1862586141,
0.5764483809,
-0.2483766079,
-0.7615641356,
0.525757432,
0.657702744,
1.1153352261,
-0.167375356,
0.2237674743,
0.103934668,
0.6852101088,
-0.0591230765,
-0.0725092813,
0.0035671578,
-0.6703916192,
-0.1913572252,
-0.4796380997,
-0.3890477419,
0.3599936664,
-0.6906911731,
-0.0593332462,
-0.3909532726,
-0.4280866981,
-0.1068979874,
-0.151417464,
-0.4961700439,
0.2939385772,
0.0841269717,
0.716050446,
-0.5432882905,
0.0446285084,
0.9993095994,
-0.3852151632,
-0.1560364962,
0.4600131214,
-0.0145414555,
-0.7922902107,
0.4313951433,
-0.0769598335,
-0.4829941094,
-0.3859751821,
-0.6138489842,
-0.6293229461,
1.0115146637,
0.7132155299,
-0.2599292994,
-0.1465242803,
0.1221601814,
0.5933519602,
0.2642443776,
0.0797622204,
0.2477529198,
0.2100526839,
0.1395675987,
-0.702162683,
0.2328996658,
-0.1752477586,
0.2976726294,
-0.1822511256,
-0.493511945,
0.3532742262,
-0.2359078974,
-0.68113482,
0.1324945241,
0.4964386523,
0.1746028811,
0.2743239999,
0.5530133247,
0.7122682929,
0.786329329,
-0.0734683722,
1.3186901808,
-0.2349065691,
0.3820614219,
0.6046630144,
-0.2883284092,
0.7478803992,
0.1475754976,
-0.2500852644,
0.1407644302,
0.3761794567,
0.1101536974,
0.4712443054,
0.0257244315,
-0.6584698558,
-0.3902865052,
0.0115828281,
-0.3511602283,
0.3912833035,
0.4523358643,
-0.1315492988,
-0.2879239321,
-0.0840181857,
0.0164501481,
0.2957710028,
0.1842927039,
0.6700496674,
-0.140829742,
-0.6624599099,
0.825853765,
0.0958225802,
0.487372607,
-0.4091251791,
0.1924420148,
-0.1287425309,
0.0813955367,
-0.1798372269,
-0.7093448043,
0.2431908101,
0.2893404365,
0.0714228824,
0.2853753269,
0.9039277434,
0.035494484,
-0.5250602365,
0.1232590601,
0.1744111627,
-0.2778083086,
-0.2395148724,
-0.777579248,
0.1312848926,
-0.0762129948,
-0.205605492,
0.3997472823,
0.0974121764,
0.1673058718,
0.9528051615,
0.7730606198,
0.1128725708,
0.1241990849,
-0.1420997679,
0.9179722667,
-0.3670009375,
-0.3237672746,
-0.7267680764,
0.2100200802,
-0.1653594673,
0.0088315159,
1.0031616688,
0.4455257952,
0.7898705006,
0.1370157748,
1.1777095795,
-0.1133523285,
0.1182052195,
-0.4518407881,
0.8663211465,
-0.5192062259,
0.4547851384,
-0.0649666563,
-0.7660133839,
-0.285797298,
0.3940664232,
-0.2016076446,
0.0681147724,
0.2544060946,
0.9762127995,
-0.1172163486,
0.0183849055,
0.517432332,
0.3017560244,
0.5722157955,
0.2096014619,
0.9994267225,
-0.6025289297,
0.9899597168,
-0.1426281631,
-0.2038512528,
-0.4406085908,
-0.615224123,
-0.680408299,
-0.2890745699,
-0.1643242389,
-0.8077710271,
0.4936942756,
0.5570322871,
0.3622063398,
-0.7579620481,
0.2024136633,
-0.0798078999,
0.1839937419,
0.103760764,
-0.2337472737,
0.3984934986,
-0.2900624573,
-0.5929866433,
0.6377829909,
0.1690418124,
0.1906508356,
-0.567690134,
0.1151909009,
-0.0278859511,
0.0531701185,
0.5209798813,
0.4260690212,
-0.6245812774,
-0.4551392198,
0.1724331379,
-0.3649539053,
-0.2267077863,
0.4925433695,
-0.4944859743,
0.9018411636,
0.5289694071,
1.0715045929,
0.300254643,
0.4232412279,
0.5750994086,
-0.6364301443,
-0.0948506817,
0.2775800526,
0.2274008542,
0.6159283519,
-0.6297959089,
0.1392776668,
0.3034829199,
-0.5416679978,
-1.0088249445,
0.3161683679,
-0.5480515957,
-0.0800028071,
1.0315315723,
-0.2740877569,
0.0213282071,
-0.1007981971,
-0.0566804372,
0.0876703411,
-0.1590064913,
1.243679285,
0.699414134,
0.1595874131,
0.3297871947,
-0.5617980957,
0.289321959,
0.391238451,
-0.6341708899,
-0.1215758994,
0.3552958369,
0.2290511876,
0.4338026345,
0.0957454816,
-0.2003690898,
0.417313993,
0.2347345799,
-0.3674809933,
0.1539392024,
-0.1636360139,
-0.3793031871,
0.4116244912,
0.3357311785,
-0.2666721046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16061v2
|
How Large Language Models Encode Context Knowledge? A Layer-Wise Probing Study
| 2024-02-25T11:15:42 | 2024-03-04T13:37:48 |
Tianjie Ju, Weiwei Sun, Wei Du, Xinwei Yuan, Zhaochun Ren, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has showcased the intriguing capability of large language
models (LLMs) in retrieving facts and processing context knowledge. However,
only limited research exists on the layer-wise capability of LLMs to encode
knowledge, which challenges our understanding of their internal mechanisms. In
this paper, we devote the first attempt to investigate the layer-wise
capability of LLMs through probing tasks. We leverage the powerful generative
capability of ChatGPT to construct probing datasets, providing diverse and
coherent evidence corresponding to various facts. We employ $\mathcal V$-usable
information as the validation metric to better reflect the capability in
encoding context knowledge across different layers. Our experiments on
conflicting and newly acquired knowledge show that LLMs: (1) prefer to encode
more context knowledge in the upper layers; (2) primarily encode context
knowledge within knowledge-related entity tokens at lower layers while
progressively expanding more knowledge within other tokens at upper layers; and
(3) gradually forget the earlier context knowledge retained within the
intermediate layers when provided with irrelevant evidence. Code is publicly
available at https://github.com/Jometeorie/probing_llama.
|
[
-0.332891345,
-0.944237113,
0.7266637087,
-0.0017984966,
-0.2169274241,
-0.1002385467,
-0.3628461361,
-0.4241043031,
-0.0512553416,
0.6520431638,
-0.3173004687,
-0.4188720286,
-0.606505096,
-0.1271583736,
-0.6528374553,
0.8092886806,
0.0792344958,
-0.0263790376,
-0.4318609834,
-0.0281319208,
-0.2923994958,
-0.8088724613,
-0.5581807494,
-0.4395370781,
0.5970318913,
0.3853530884,
0.3304355145,
0.4805285037,
0.3028883934,
0.2939890623,
-0.359493643,
0.3344813585,
-0.6880626678,
0.2430443466,
0.0237403549,
-0.6485300064,
-0.2995567918,
-0.1488785148,
0.7682154775,
0.7095738649,
-0.1407163143,
0.254135251,
0.2153541297,
0.4208465219,
-0.5739295483,
0.210419029,
-0.9650967717,
-0.0478880554,
-0.3150457144,
-0.4772711396,
-0.6282255054,
0.2072643638,
0.263925612,
-0.3537256122,
0.0077444836,
0.0393289551,
0.6901531219,
0.1354275048,
-0.8406840563,
-0.1878893226,
-0.7247658968,
0.6877763271,
-0.5396639705,
0.4699358344,
0.4360101819,
0.3561910987,
-0.1977024227,
-0.7951557636,
-0.5617787838,
-0.2988801599,
-0.197161302,
-0.0654619858,
-0.0978249609,
-0.1355629861,
0.3450035751,
0.4335702658,
-0.196359545,
0.0522124059,
-0.2190455943,
-0.3728185892,
0.2803375721,
0.0379429385,
0.289745748,
-0.282071501,
-0.5733520389,
-0.0390309729,
-0.9081943631,
0.172511667,
0.0971472859,
0.138342917,
-0.2168705761,
0.7096133232,
-0.1620741487,
0.4713642299,
-0.2331236899,
-0.0149303405,
0.1345376074,
-0.2548206449,
-0.3481634259,
0.063784197,
0.64544034,
0.0704722181,
0.0850061998,
-0.2549664378,
-0.2880333662,
-0.3062300086,
0.2240583599,
-0.6971607208,
0.0784814954,
0.1849730611,
-0.2050213367,
-0.0555197448,
-0.1650497019,
-0.3354196548,
-0.3937702775,
-0.2741748095,
0.4394990206,
-0.5905707479,
-0.2915887833,
0.3842493892,
-0.0327924453,
0.6934732199,
0.4222777486,
-0.6997430325,
0.1294685304,
0.9138967991,
0.670533061,
0.0364249013,
-0.3468263745,
-0.4660630822,
0.268853426,
-0.2394080013,
0.6332808733,
-0.5717054605,
-0.1231023446,
0.0906635597,
-0.0680162162,
-0.0788521022,
-0.4787852168,
0.5980777144,
-0.946603179,
0.0950202793,
-0.6665232778,
-0.6672781706,
-0.3114303946,
0.5734123588,
-0.5648236871,
0.9049822688,
-0.0659958646,
-0.9535116553,
0.304243952,
-0.3701832294,
-0.2759892941,
0.0865484104,
-0.3835381269,
-0.0935287476,
0.1997041404,
0.3637205064,
0.6269572377,
-0.3705020547,
0.2160040736,
-0.2399280071,
-0.3131012917,
0.6144195199,
-0.4869801402,
0.7309855223,
0.0693132728,
-0.1566607207,
-0.1141041219,
-0.537375927,
-0.1336909533,
0.3313027322,
-0.6131612062,
-0.330601573,
0.052827917,
-0.3613911271,
-0.1043912396,
0.2308111787,
-0.5869191289,
0.301672101,
-0.0491872653,
0.6619354486,
0.5871449709,
0.0839940459,
0.364693284,
-0.1332018524,
0.2713579834,
0.4177334905,
-0.1364435256,
-0.1723317206,
-0.3593466878,
-0.9069567919,
-0.0003576661,
0.2359020114,
0.3791000247,
-0.8315346837,
0.050460659,
-0.4323330522,
-0.212423265,
-0.2438955009,
0.0344839618,
0.281419605,
0.6076101065,
0.2420539558,
-0.3229423165,
-0.5459657311,
-0.8817323446,
-0.0798032284,
-0.2285168171,
-0.1343211532,
0.6412804723,
0.5891380906,
-0.4238211513,
0.8571668863,
-0.3189322054,
-0.108324632,
-0.2276782691,
-0.1005066633,
0.0853192955,
0.2782488465,
0.512747407,
-0.7068629861,
-0.05654829,
0.1793939173,
-0.8106284142,
-0.0129028503,
-0.0023021796,
-0.2959516048,
-0.1561038792,
0.6318876147,
-0.7254593372,
-0.0087012798,
0.6826916933,
-0.1286104918,
0.4395334125,
-0.1066200733,
0.0907309353,
-0.8823702335,
-0.0141533436,
-0.1491568983,
-0.3244622946,
-0.7952854633,
0.2174313068,
0.3734247088,
0.26370278,
-0.3210788071,
0.4569608569,
-0.6584482789,
-0.2005922645,
-0.1675939709,
0.2475804538,
-0.0130791981,
0.5000727177,
-0.0329066105,
0.7340484858,
0.7589091659,
-0.6550096869,
0.184225589,
0.03049987,
-0.7373725176,
0.2320455462,
-0.4373689592,
0.4033586681,
-0.1537344754,
0.3320025504,
-0.7924768925,
-0.4158743024,
0.0638603568,
-0.3822892308,
0.2263846099,
-0.3765769601,
-0.6143438816,
0.0485118665,
0.0482269898,
0.6900190115,
0.5623931289,
-0.5790094733,
0.6002521515,
0.6984989643,
0.1615371555,
-0.6736397147,
-0.8160238266,
0.160017401,
-0.3612796068,
-0.5822305679,
0.2791361809,
0.1437333226,
-0.2263009846,
-0.1677910835,
-0.1933120191,
-0.0082938774,
0.0382809862,
0.1238236129,
-0.0908068791,
-0.4936291873,
0.0614966527,
-0.0528656878,
0.2000765055,
0.4607252479,
-0.3947800398,
0.8412524462,
-0.2878012657,
-0.6718499064,
0.0209505409,
0.0851024985,
0.4763403535,
-0.2788846195,
0.8896200657,
0.5860518217,
-0.4110646248,
-0.4222954214,
-0.775059104,
-0.1455268562,
-0.5051547289,
0.3368570209,
-0.5126600266,
-1.33400774,
0.9462739229,
-0.1683900803,
-0.1430760771,
0.3066926301,
0.430226922,
0.0546114892,
0.7441140413,
0.4775873125,
-0.134820044,
0.3109102547,
-0.2927035093,
0.1283316463,
-1.220749855,
-0.3787589073,
-0.3448624313,
-0.097645998,
-0.4313926399,
-0.6601651907,
0.5184162855,
0.2902113795,
-0.1857504398,
0.0893885121,
-0.0600217804,
0.713280499,
0.3679791689,
0.3552780747,
0.3373091221,
-0.0624565929,
-0.144603461,
0.3190352023,
-0.7987676263,
-0.4034768045,
1.015443325,
0.6399700642,
0.6117702723,
0.2000987828,
0.5214750171,
-0.0258336794,
0.0934337005,
-0.8161657453,
0.7821922302,
-0.0031528673,
-0.5008738637,
-0.2132385671,
-0.6239205599,
-0.7889238,
0.3411130011,
0.1494372487,
-0.6768001318,
0.1605525613,
0.1439905912,
-0.0401051417,
0.437238574,
-0.6564739347,
0.5155923963,
-0.2914617658,
-0.2958980501,
-0.0921004191,
-0.4595606625,
0.4890207052,
0.0154779423,
0.1868398041,
0.0953257531,
-0.0246656872,
0.5165742636,
-0.0037317448,
1.0218390226,
-0.0983587652,
-0.618216157,
0.2674784362,
0.3282285035,
0.4211560488,
0.2410190254,
0.0024269847,
0.3200286627,
-0.1249404997,
-0.4818032384,
-0.4338313937,
0.5753179789,
-0.6867338419,
-0.8193833232,
-0.1791262031,
-0.4780141711,
-0.3291943371,
0.1715779006,
0.1353094131,
0.516430974,
-0.1326645911,
0.56947577,
0.8938269019,
-0.2085864842,
0.065577507,
0.3988464773,
-0.2446844727,
0.1898168027,
0.6217270494,
-0.0000988934,
0.3560573459,
0.7468566895,
0.2374289781,
-0.1641954482,
-0.7511554956,
-0.4216151536,
0.017719727,
-0.9325085878,
-0.0789689124,
-0.6163300276,
-0.5986650586,
-0.2275724262,
0.2383499146,
-0.3494896293,
-0.0670403391,
-0.0355164558,
-0.1141278669,
0.1590743363,
0.6087357998,
0.1571335196,
0.1110178679,
-0.6204117537,
0.0065883598,
0.4756443799,
0.2318791747,
0.1566191912,
-0.6678828001,
-0.3262999952,
0.2521519363,
0.0785842836,
-0.8194826245,
0.1675259769,
0.0431662165,
0.6857936382,
0.4233772159,
-0.0446260422,
0.5291345119,
-0.4852027595,
0.8597605228,
-0.4295344055,
-0.9172244668,
0.3885501623,
-0.5498378277,
0.3955144584,
0.1379209459,
0.2474761307,
-0.5641946793,
-0.3144870102,
-0.2606174052,
-0.8062645197,
0.6591572165,
0.171859026,
0.5559689999,
0.0645170286,
0.5872408152,
0.1404495388,
0.1533189714,
-0.7989346385,
-0.0115206707,
-0.0332138091,
0.2737663686,
0.0504591353,
-0.6036616564,
-0.4915739298,
-0.1594467461,
0.255535543,
-0.2134932876,
0.4558224678,
0.2147737145,
-0.3947489858,
0.2200483382,
0.4351533651,
0.5705409646,
0.6172513366,
-0.1679694653,
0.6559355259,
0.4000748396,
-0.524618268,
-0.1680501103,
-0.2087419033,
-0.083817482,
-0.3659414351,
0.7275438905,
1.0471417904,
0.339220643,
-0.5717736483,
0.4057418704,
-0.1970916092,
-0.2123901397,
-0.3030192256,
0.2435988635,
0.1755190045,
0.3655483723,
0.3678847551,
-0.2919929624,
0.0536008663,
-0.6661582589,
0.0212687012,
0.5276434422,
-0.0375927165,
-0.3052943647,
0.3031278551,
-0.0158994198,
0.0152000729,
0.5945837498,
-0.130142495,
-0.6588609219,
0.4833818376,
0.6593969464,
0.6239928007,
0.0503392257,
0.072821334,
0.2056754827,
0.324994266,
-0.0192719717,
0.0657622069,
-0.3416633606,
-1.1127022505,
-0.5186680555,
-0.5786147714,
-0.4552422762,
0.4815198779,
-0.6113994122,
-0.0963415578,
-0.2835168839,
0.1004547328,
-0.2717052102,
-0.220824033,
-0.8993796706,
-0.0015717689,
0.2236995846,
0.9027750492,
-0.5718147755,
0.987695694,
0.6113708615,
-0.0842586011,
-0.707875967,
0.2826994956,
0.0578813069,
-1.159776926,
0.7025636435,
0.2466163933,
-0.2943021953,
-0.0689391792,
-0.7216029763,
-1.0154205561,
1.1936957836,
0.554099679,
-0.4559257627,
0.0699675828,
0.3724284172,
0.5319839716,
-0.4693939388,
0.333681494,
0.5235930681,
0.2956423163,
0.1260725856,
-0.8805445433,
0.1196580529,
-0.3320361376,
-0.1326682568,
-0.0127737597,
-0.5964391232,
0.8644007444,
-0.1026409268,
-0.4124228358,
-0.2439865619,
0.6245024204,
0.1077741235,
0.1018926501,
0.5904698968,
0.4057703614,
0.648955822,
-0.104648754,
1.1343433857,
-0.3104541898,
0.1504533589,
0.9377774,
-0.1983897686,
0.8604984879,
0.5184535384,
0.0576186851,
0.5782544613,
0.5880507231,
0.3048185706,
0.4193996787,
0.1590058357,
-0.2849119306,
-0.3573048711,
-0.173102349,
-0.3909236789,
0.7140968442,
0.4753902256,
-0.2521893382,
-0.053522788,
-0.1858820915,
0.0201764889,
-0.2915426493,
-0.2266796976,
0.9022655487,
0.1871631444,
-0.6159155369,
0.5546666384,
0.0761459321,
0.4702774286,
-0.6690527797,
0.1239589527,
-0.3812929392,
0.0214909632,
-0.0681847706,
-0.9747589827,
-0.0091143725,
-0.0315910392,
0.0390737206,
-0.3311803937,
0.8507452607,
-0.4169320464,
-0.0853078067,
0.4115747809,
0.6898103952,
0.0456251651,
-0.1011939049,
-0.2283776104,
0.2741831541,
-0.0999909714,
-0.597715795,
0.4780910909,
0.8822749257,
0.0178817082,
0.7274299264,
0.5657474995,
0.0994875804,
0.1762904823,
0.3536306918,
1.0595649481,
-0.5661642551,
-0.209313333,
-0.9354255199,
0.5673452616,
-0.0141037488,
-0.1631563902,
0.8431959152,
0.4297748804,
1.1966422796,
0.1276287287,
0.580671072,
0.0653343648,
0.1074129716,
-0.933681488,
0.6520997286,
-0.5195468664,
0.6630216837,
0.0370028168,
-0.7088543177,
0.0132177547,
0.429246366,
-0.347728014,
0.0920561552,
0.5079253316,
0.7395028472,
-0.4432159066,
0.1226014048,
0.1708820015,
0.506236434,
0.3911989927,
0.6962541342,
1.0854581594,
-0.1881779432,
0.3235394359,
-0.2653141916,
-0.1839565486,
-0.1569932699,
-0.9416422844,
-1.0365309715,
-0.7657136321,
0.0469077192,
-0.1808285713,
-0.2309659719,
0.4300306439,
0.7324364185,
-0.4710416198,
-0.2512755394,
0.0264797956,
0.0058445316,
-0.0103341686,
-0.199838385,
0.3186874986,
-0.1989829242,
-0.4524919987,
0.573804915,
0.0747764111,
-0.1110543981,
-0.47241956,
0.0171089098,
0.0359069854,
0.0692609102,
0.7638527155,
0.0630993545,
-0.6457009315,
-0.5378851295,
0.0626965463,
-0.1995191872,
-0.0096234083,
1.0116915703,
-0.7054413557,
0.2147375345,
0.6711261868,
0.8717318773,
0.6197189689,
-0.295340538,
0.5315212011,
-1.0136562586,
0.0204742253,
0.0478776097,
0.6242535114,
0.4489103556,
-0.4275635779,
0.3670681715,
-0.0861789584,
-0.6546956301,
-0.9530470371,
0.4584188759,
-1.1085903645,
-0.1459417492,
1.3587899208,
-0.1220717877,
-0.2698150873,
0.2384402454,
-0.1780237705,
0.2317292988,
-0.1216183528,
0.8436100483,
0.7784504294,
-0.1069377363,
-0.4180189371,
-0.8194131255,
0.3711396456,
0.4108039439,
-0.7047861814,
0.1721469015,
0.3552630544,
0.3211005926,
0.0797622874,
0.6105668545,
-0.0049422542,
-0.0130156334,
0.0013253335,
-0.4301898479,
-0.1713055372,
-0.3234531581,
-0.1630679369,
0.294059515,
0.0253351852,
-0.0038123438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16058v1
|
Say More with Less: Understanding Prompt Learning Behaviors through Gist Compression
| 2024-02-25T11:07:08 | 2024-02-25T11:07:08 |
Xinze Li, Zhenghao Liu, Chenyan Xiong, Shi Yu, Yukun Yan, Shuo Wang, Ge Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) require lengthy prompts as the input context to
produce output aligned with user intentions, a process that incurs extra costs
during inference. In this paper, we propose the Gist COnditioned deCOding
(Gist-COCO) model, introducing a novel method for compressing prompts which
also can assist the prompt interpretation and engineering. Gist-COCO employs an
encoder-decoder based language model and then incorporates an additional
encoder as a plugin module to compress prompts with inputs using gist tokens.
It finetunes the compression plugin module and uses the representations of gist
tokens to emulate the raw prompts in the vanilla language model. By verbalizing
the representations of gist tokens into gist prompts, the compression ability
of Gist-COCO can be generalized to different LLMs with high compression rates.
Our experiments demonstrate that Gist-COCO outperforms previous prompt
compression models in both passage and instruction compression tasks. Further
analysis on gist verbalization results suggests that our gist prompts serve
different functions in aiding language models. They may directly provide
potential answers, generate the chain-of-thought, or simply repeat the inputs.
All data and codes are available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/Gist-COCO .
|
[
-0.4018181562,
-0.9941661954,
0.5777711272,
-0.0004979392,
-0.3259832263,
0.258197844,
-0.656650722,
-0.1138280183,
0.2534002662,
0.1444409341,
-0.956391871,
-0.515142858,
-0.6665152311,
0.3694418967,
-0.1316687465,
1.1343265772,
0.2031230927,
0.1975981444,
-0.461002171,
0.1803645492,
-0.8663606048,
-0.6127624512,
-0.8013741374,
-0.1363259703,
0.4728015959,
0.7200875878,
0.6264785528,
0.2527779341,
0.156855911,
0.2241361141,
-0.350574702,
-0.1277783811,
-0.5830551386,
0.1723288894,
0.2307038903,
-0.4107902646,
-0.0178154949,
0.0113635529,
0.144187659,
0.7141885757,
-0.1667467207,
0.1265749037,
0.2849656641,
0.4553255439,
-0.5012086034,
0.5680910349,
-0.2682956457,
0.0203304272,
0.516356945,
-0.1066514626,
-0.7411831617,
-0.3905998766,
-0.0189220365,
-0.7557039261,
0.1149599031,
0.0270481668,
0.7524647713,
0.2876148224,
-0.2349230498,
-0.456033349,
-0.2616871297,
0.4053323567,
-0.4734622836,
0.3864177763,
0.4907340705,
0.3716472387,
-0.0349533632,
-0.5950582623,
-0.5164526701,
-0.468993187,
-0.2593114078,
-0.0160252471,
-0.0459541678,
0.2875982821,
0.6665756106,
0.2049319148,
-0.7252069116,
-0.1835200936,
-0.4586289823,
-0.2196748853,
0.1107463613,
-0.0292526428,
0.4482932389,
-0.2787907422,
-0.4012959301,
-0.4665005207,
-0.6461322904,
0.4761732221,
0.2438000143,
0.247327894,
-0.4040941298,
0.5793135762,
-0.2310452014,
0.7459334135,
0.1309143603,
0.0272354521,
-0.0074726734,
0.0263925791,
-0.3865661025,
0.0836142451,
0.6774561405,
0.2861090899,
0.616554141,
0.0942787826,
-0.1670400053,
0.301664263,
-0.0659689307,
-0.8459834456,
-0.312757045,
-0.1807534993,
-0.2035225034,
-0.1440146267,
0.1392506063,
-0.7251836061,
-0.6036000848,
-0.4120949209,
0.1013387144,
-0.4777856767,
0.0900613219,
0.41588521,
-0.3665975928,
0.1385836154,
0.3004358411,
-0.9256809354,
0.4626247883,
0.6561880112,
1.1405272484,
0.0273498297,
0.0470577478,
-0.7557296753,
-0.3376271129,
-0.1692341715,
0.6740756035,
-0.719168365,
-0.6085763574,
0.0055373358,
0.1492948979,
-0.1877197176,
0.001593982,
0.7851864696,
-0.529740572,
0.1327818781,
-0.3378951252,
-0.3786946237,
-0.4023992717,
0.4869134426,
-0.7427669764,
0.6702268124,
0.2884660959,
-0.7220606804,
0.0234126169,
-0.5194914937,
-0.3836356103,
0.1561863571,
-0.181468606,
0.0118734278,
0.3509917855,
0.6538136601,
0.5068352222,
-0.3397479653,
0.4132217765,
-0.2067723721,
-0.4968060553,
0.3868392408,
-0.6505140662,
0.6312785149,
0.278095305,
0.0897988379,
0.1046967283,
-0.3479253948,
-0.2127818614,
0.259411931,
-0.4771097004,
-0.1759122163,
-0.388928175,
-0.4206135869,
0.1688984632,
0.1427722871,
-0.4105134606,
0.6704986691,
-0.3091525733,
0.7328688502,
0.5317007303,
0.1492702365,
0.5878888369,
-0.2785315216,
1.0256237984,
-0.2155783176,
0.2577321529,
-0.6788813472,
-0.4901854396,
-0.7863763571,
-0.2801098228,
0.2888328731,
0.4099909365,
-1.0731765032,
0.0871438757,
-0.7162783146,
-0.1155930758,
-0.4965717494,
-0.0509306565,
0.049080044,
0.7575682402,
0.2960280478,
0.0282258298,
-0.5444620252,
-0.4477864206,
0.1399538964,
-0.2201973349,
-0.2148988247,
0.3224714398,
0.3561221957,
0.087473236,
0.9561399221,
-0.7273195386,
0.0946645364,
-0.426550746,
0.1457003951,
0.5332733989,
0.3561060727,
0.2295343727,
-0.4157184362,
-0.4747564197,
-0.2297119945,
-0.4606087804,
-0.069099322,
-0.1436862051,
0.1198466495,
-0.1905705631,
0.5663432479,
-0.9147655368,
0.3450665474,
0.6469408274,
-0.376778692,
0.6239643097,
-0.2224192321,
0.2975857258,
-0.6853533387,
-0.1337655932,
-0.333088398,
-0.511870563,
-0.3563956916,
0.1861073822,
0.1453407407,
-0.7331193686,
-0.4920183718,
0.5052936673,
-0.7876882553,
0.0158388149,
-0.1675252914,
0.1150424778,
0.4322134256,
0.8957833052,
0.1500931531,
1.0698570013,
0.7887418866,
-0.7558712363,
0.4218803644,
0.288644284,
-0.4502833784,
0.2856927514,
-1.0170681477,
0.3530272245,
-0.2632554471,
0.5931021571,
-0.9783979654,
-0.3207697272,
0.5608345866,
-0.7441571951,
0.3340708613,
-0.5828831792,
-0.5369753242,
-0.5087711811,
-0.638759613,
0.3615334034,
0.8963236809,
-0.7162245512,
0.4317554235,
-0.0862092823,
-0.4469825625,
-0.3082469702,
-0.7836557031,
0.0426940545,
-0.2719411254,
-0.6130708456,
-0.1182723269,
-0.6229054332,
0.2588148713,
-0.2518433034,
-0.0314767472,
0.1642016619,
0.3535816967,
0.4124950171,
0.3566169739,
-0.274096787,
0.2431255132,
0.2044350654,
-0.0528429523,
0.1419541985,
-0.5419322848,
0.789986074,
0.1204856709,
-0.2046539634,
-0.2856108844,
0.4039894044,
0.4758001268,
0.0464778021,
0.8580244184,
0.209123373,
-0.1395758986,
-0.0460402668,
-0.1056253016,
-0.2802571654,
-0.5637497306,
-0.2433475703,
-0.3502095044,
-1.0185400248,
0.4230733216,
-0.2266085446,
-0.3060619533,
-0.0091212047,
0.2990855575,
0.0912685618,
1.1427599192,
0.6065143943,
0.004030244,
0.7422217131,
-0.4226954877,
0.1272287369,
-0.8734456897,
-0.2558403015,
-0.5822990537,
-0.1329283267,
-0.1165912822,
-0.657879591,
0.3797870576,
0.4685561359,
-0.2552224994,
0.3974145949,
-0.761649251,
0.7515230179,
0.3331091702,
0.1923781186,
0.0633211881,
0.0392904356,
-0.3962287903,
0.308444798,
-0.8039326668,
-0.4505195916,
0.4113273323,
0.2062665969,
1.0492339134,
0.05015577,
0.3737733066,
0.4242228568,
0.004226292,
-1.2182133198,
0.4396722317,
0.3658435643,
-0.1146400645,
-0.04827746,
-0.2543805838,
-1.0501083136,
-0.1637750864,
0.0102937166,
-0.880536139,
0.1484113187,
0.1573619246,
-0.4667571187,
-0.2580364943,
-0.9836483598,
0.6331176758,
-0.0300576109,
0.0400148816,
0.0096987328,
-0.5707426071,
0.4035260081,
0.376147151,
0.3621329367,
-0.0209490936,
0.0042269859,
0.6970754266,
-0.3495787382,
1.0997296572,
-0.1985847801,
-0.0745012462,
0.4552149773,
0.1950254738,
0.9089771509,
0.4114734828,
-0.1794943511,
0.0122416066,
-0.3088567257,
-0.2897258103,
-1.0440872908,
0.809009254,
-0.5976143479,
-0.6888943315,
-0.310005039,
-0.1571111977,
-0.0589483045,
-0.1586479992,
0.5623685122,
0.5750048161,
-0.0202556383,
-0.1785541326,
0.7309142351,
-0.3022363782,
0.5219320059,
0.3236752748,
-0.0618131645,
-0.5140508413,
0.7941409349,
-0.1548200101,
0.21853064,
0.3540880084,
0.4313720167,
-0.3277842402,
-0.1830702573,
-0.4783711731,
0.0926016793,
-1.1077404022,
-0.5657899976,
-0.723839283,
0.0359745733,
-0.7168525457,
-0.4544460177,
0.2923733294,
-0.4947371483,
-0.6438506246,
-0.4418105781,
0.6679527164,
0.6222750545,
0.0901149213,
0.816408217,
-0.8545487523,
0.2185385227,
0.1776354909,
0.0900613442,
0.1164515913,
-0.6647387147,
-0.3825840652,
0.1613150239,
-0.1013527811,
-1.132776022,
0.4272871614,
0.1344249845,
0.2195652276,
0.4791990519,
0.5042677522,
0.5861763358,
-0.4430708885,
1.082255125,
0.4571805596,
-1.153542757,
0.6271700263,
0.0264581703,
0.5038464665,
0.512765348,
0.3768346608,
-0.8409718871,
-0.1205864102,
-0.4868378341,
-0.7946075201,
0.675314784,
-0.1764259785,
0.5332112908,
-0.379838258,
0.199691847,
0.3051375151,
0.121048294,
-0.7405411601,
0.0369219892,
-0.2843749821,
-0.2712479532,
-0.0836395174,
-0.5154020786,
0.0359139703,
-0.246653676,
0.4083093703,
-0.5202073455,
0.5082768202,
0.1421841234,
-0.6160897017,
0.3758571744,
0.4215937555,
0.6553931236,
-0.0355701596,
0.2689296603,
0.3102241457,
0.2977229953,
-0.0867763609,
0.2970704436,
-0.2128951848,
-0.0026811992,
-0.0288371965,
0.6163808703,
1.2953190804,
0.3175381422,
-0.651943326,
0.7897402048,
-0.5170526505,
0.1287620366,
-0.1596076638,
0.3165458441,
0.0715341717,
-0.0728605911,
-0.0054631941,
-0.096438624,
0.1799613684,
-0.3701036274,
-0.0790686235,
0.1735993922,
-0.4599173367,
-0.5114810467,
0.4542580545,
0.3535892367,
-0.3759866655,
0.7657972574,
-0.305767864,
-0.7109460831,
0.4666329324,
0.3774724007,
0.7820129395,
0.1716154665,
0.332796663,
0.6262857318,
0.0172278862,
-0.1289097816,
0.1027758121,
-0.7991873026,
-0.2840878665,
-0.6167424917,
-0.4860272706,
-0.2962706089,
-0.2065277696,
-0.7524482608,
0.609293282,
-0.5913835764,
-0.1245053858,
-0.4811928272,
-0.1063823402,
-0.8171672821,
-0.0542345122,
0.1727134883,
1.1129739285,
-0.7818769217,
0.6597796082,
0.5050458312,
-0.5445942879,
-0.9801969528,
-0.134217754,
0.0365744866,
-0.8245632648,
0.460180372,
0.4820895195,
-0.124530673,
0.0723121986,
-0.9317393303,
-0.737365067,
0.8314262033,
0.8377650976,
-0.7581769228,
-0.3034587502,
-0.2129331082,
0.2572848499,
-0.3337270021,
0.5223261714,
0.4843619168,
0.5014562607,
0.3685521781,
-0.4018733799,
0.1895379126,
-0.0949206501,
-0.1862561405,
-0.165379554,
-0.2809531093,
0.7754453421,
-0.5315560102,
-0.6482339501,
0.2134047896,
0.5231872201,
0.0613184609,
0.0176990442,
0.4068080783,
0.0496699587,
0.974529326,
0.0783972517,
1.3601624966,
-0.4336828887,
0.4351760149,
1.1344876289,
0.1006366536,
0.3074244261,
0.2994849384,
0.2200499177,
0.6867799759,
0.9038106203,
0.1293841898,
0.5635719895,
0.5264077187,
-0.3395844698,
-0.2509718537,
-0.4819038808,
-0.1963713467,
-0.0028100344,
0.3689082265,
-0.1010572687,
0.0246305,
0.5064693093,
0.2072657347,
-0.030189652,
-0.2371064276,
0.9364178181,
0.2945379317,
-0.7727026939,
0.9073978662,
-0.1410066485,
0.7589843273,
-0.6474254727,
-0.0692888945,
-0.3532348275,
-0.4433968663,
0.0019656627,
-0.603733182,
-0.0357307121,
0.3008181155,
-0.2630769312,
-0.3254974484,
0.5473530293,
-0.396247983,
-0.3820302784,
0.3311363161,
0.2416139543,
0.2808834612,
-0.0961052701,
-0.5233873129,
0.3267890513,
-0.1700885892,
-0.2899435461,
0.1052434891,
0.615586102,
0.0308859237,
0.802110672,
0.6764917374,
0.0473169982,
-0.0783612207,
0.3057753742,
1.0826752186,
-0.6325593591,
-0.632358849,
-0.9214176536,
0.4109134376,
0.0761225373,
-0.1107901633,
0.4321708381,
0.1929722279,
0.6669178605,
-0.2757790983,
0.5795841217,
-0.0218282398,
-0.0865463093,
-0.7977084517,
0.3798275888,
-0.2115089893,
0.3426221311,
-0.014578186,
-0.3774029613,
0.0556868799,
0.6032427549,
-0.1300059408,
-0.0440674759,
0.7447559834,
0.6071520448,
0.0888334513,
-0.1127180979,
0.6256702542,
-0.1636541188,
0.3271018565,
0.7272804976,
1.1188243628,
-0.1575041711,
0.6856763959,
-0.0502549149,
0.1135307476,
-0.1673959196,
-0.8036745787,
-0.9806438088,
-0.4203288555,
-0.3317689896,
-0.2280553579,
-0.0230735093,
1.2085256577,
0.9401989579,
-0.5158007145,
0.1643804759,
-0.2548889518,
0.5679854751,
-0.2019783258,
-0.2840623558,
0.1576604098,
-0.3769133985,
-0.7686101198,
0.5933158994,
-0.0635884851,
0.2696976662,
-0.0052508004,
-0.4032566547,
0.106811367,
0.2194080502,
0.5661472678,
0.0666477755,
-0.3745465279,
-0.4680272937,
0.0729139596,
-0.0825561881,
0.2470166683,
1.198092103,
-1.3186023235,
0.214849934,
0.7035292387,
0.502219975,
0.366486609,
0.2503308356,
0.6099601984,
-1.0829318762,
0.1677169055,
0.12696217,
0.570245266,
0.5961674452,
-0.7719594836,
0.4751803279,
0.0746375844,
-0.3001661599,
-0.5328000188,
0.3391714692,
-0.9944679737,
-0.4286850691,
1.3216724396,
-0.5577694774,
-0.3772740066,
0.1371961832,
-0.6271348596,
0.5363976359,
-0.9149547815,
0.2908853292,
0.749543786,
0.0551714115,
-0.5860379934,
-0.2374629229,
0.410060972,
0.0920630097,
-0.6663036346,
0.3606311977,
0.5853621364,
0.2250311375,
-0.1032736376,
0.3772496879,
0.4115409851,
0.2413417697,
0.0256759096,
-0.0503956042,
-0.4688718617,
-0.4210475981,
-0.945499599,
0.0998710021,
0.2744895518,
-0.1701717228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16050v1
|
LSTP: Language-guided Spatial-Temporal Prompt Learning for Long-form Video-Text Understanding
| 2024-02-25T10:27:46 | 2024-02-25T10:27:46 |
Yuxuan Wang, Yueqian Wang, Pengfei Wu, Jianxin Liang, Dongyan Zhao, Zilong Zheng
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite progress in video-language modeling, the computational challenge of
interpreting long-form videos in response to task-specific linguistic queries
persists, largely due to the complexity of high-dimensional video data and the
misalignment between language and visual cues over space and time. To tackle
this issue, we introduce a novel approach called Language-guided
Spatial-Temporal Prompt Learning (LSTP). This approach features two key
components: a Temporal Prompt Sampler (TPS) with optical flow prior that
leverages temporal information to efficiently extract relevant video content,
and a Spatial Prompt Solver (SPS) that adeptly captures the intricate spatial
relationships between visual and textual elements. By harmonizing TPS and SPS
with a cohesive training strategy, our framework significantly enhances
computational efficiency, temporal understanding, and spatial-temporal
alignment. Empirical evaluations across two challenging tasks--video question
answering and temporal question grounding in videos--using a variety of
video-language pretrainings (VLPs) and large language models (LLMs) demonstrate
the superior performance, speed, and versatility of our proposed LSTP paradigm.
|
[
-0.1561218947,
-1.0969272852,
0.8890330791,
0.5121249557,
-0.3248259127,
0.2407858074,
-0.4375731647,
-0.2685709596,
-0.0794585124,
0.2829802036,
-0.9539127946,
-0.5034964681,
-0.4907608628,
0.0486293994,
-0.2061585188,
0.6603258252,
-0.1793412566,
0.1152480021,
0.1291766018,
-0.1208306849,
-0.7274514437,
-0.2721781731,
-0.8381854892,
-0.1233002469,
0.7233178616,
0.2504503429,
0.5354256034,
0.5299227238,
0.2550528347,
0.3031737506,
-0.1799179167,
0.1304443181,
-0.2639118731,
0.2222249657,
-0.2645112276,
-0.0655967072,
0.0276384838,
-0.4145486951,
0.838660419,
0.9148580432,
-0.0404556133,
0.0028974428,
0.0566289499,
0.7157995105,
-0.4924796224,
0.1139075235,
-0.2430750281,
0.5464713573,
-0.1056401134,
-0.6439742446,
-0.3366924822,
-0.2640945315,
0.3702713847,
-0.7335620522,
0.4527715147,
-0.0390072688,
0.585083127,
0.5816784501,
-0.3584638238,
-0.0267834589,
-0.8001260161,
0.4935292304,
-0.186424315,
0.8158590794,
0.2907573283,
0.7520692348,
-0.0118873836,
-0.5028496385,
-0.4546499252,
-0.0769756064,
0.2238420546,
0.0997092426,
0.0913220495,
0.0772540197,
0.3441874683,
-0.201033622,
-1.0594124794,
0.3208423555,
-0.263831377,
0.0350339711,
0.17614685,
0.1141217276,
0.4458656013,
-0.2205034494,
-0.5130569339,
-0.0635368899,
-0.4288327098,
0.2819531858,
-0.2717646956,
0.4770421684,
-0.254090488,
0.6116449833,
-0.0909626484,
0.7812331915,
0.1106434315,
-0.0719103292,
-0.0162657946,
-0.2361050546,
-0.3098177016,
0.0652588159,
0.5912997127,
0.24596636,
0.2295937687,
0.0333045572,
0.0974409804,
-0.2088790834,
-0.2559567392,
-0.7386037111,
0.007882948,
0.14443627,
-0.2419898659,
0.0706675053,
-0.1518439949,
-0.9355244637,
-0.4351891279,
-0.5170739889,
0.2537866831,
-0.4746679366,
-0.0811430439,
0.2537738085,
-0.160621345,
0.3412651122,
0.6169329286,
-0.9527013302,
0.0049011558,
0.5970560908,
0.9242516756,
-0.2366668582,
-0.6072898507,
-0.9473975897,
0.3479988873,
-0.1577483416,
0.8593212962,
-0.5439130068,
-0.1996061206,
0.1991984695,
-0.0797455236,
-0.0041811131,
-0.2874922752,
0.2444103509,
-0.6250448227,
0.4865674675,
-0.3215167522,
-0.2878633738,
0.0731728449,
0.4484639168,
-0.6219372153,
1.1641175747,
-0.0048593534,
-0.4269558191,
0.5130932331,
-0.5018795133,
-0.0282881372,
0.1673574299,
-0.4654839933,
-0.1545701772,
-0.0369612984,
0.5657788515,
0.4596908987,
0.1584574878,
0.6536784768,
-0.1372269541,
-0.1444041282,
0.0026604829,
-0.5612370968,
0.4058853388,
0.2947295606,
-0.184680149,
0.1629666984,
-0.5645111203,
-0.0453480259,
0.1660680026,
-0.1434595585,
-0.1619858295,
0.108208783,
-0.0096672513,
0.2710548341,
0.2059463412,
-0.3087933958,
0.1775171757,
-0.2915234864,
0.3874502778,
0.7778152227,
-0.0278525092,
0.8297163844,
0.1547274441,
0.5818955898,
-0.0995844305,
0.0706440508,
-0.5478246212,
-0.0899194852,
-0.2299935073,
-0.0269361492,
-0.3938307166,
0.6938520074,
-1.0640311241,
0.244201839,
-0.3496730626,
-0.2726095021,
0.1881349236,
0.0754948482,
0.2731457949,
0.6919057965,
0.4471371472,
0.1913930029,
-0.4836289585,
-0.2932485044,
-0.300131619,
-0.1604421586,
-0.093775779,
0.3613436222,
0.4204008877,
0.0942617729,
0.9783334732,
-0.707043767,
-0.1900672019,
-0.5348826647,
0.1649838388,
0.3582253754,
0.1526262909,
0.5242822766,
-0.7267665863,
-0.4822593629,
-0.1775059402,
-0.779714644,
-0.3093907535,
-0.3364735544,
0.0792088062,
0.1724973917,
0.7549464703,
-0.6177781224,
0.3230988979,
0.4059659839,
-0.7756311297,
0.6001207232,
-0.2923797965,
0.2419739962,
-0.9037321806,
-0.2201386243,
0.0114934035,
-0.2164492309,
-0.5128372908,
0.0448354855,
-0.2233601958,
-0.8570069671,
-0.7678105831,
0.7943081856,
-0.4259569943,
-0.2303848863,
-0.0677228421,
0.3055946231,
-0.0173170995,
0.7222499251,
0.6400381923,
0.7424169779,
0.3914756477,
-0.6527023315,
0.3459711671,
0.1812965721,
-0.2915863395,
0.534942627,
-0.6421817541,
-0.013405906,
-0.5024999976,
0.3945120871,
-0.8349201083,
-0.1732628644,
0.0648420975,
-0.4412233233,
0.1267152429,
-0.2016899586,
-0.4385505617,
-0.1137308031,
-0.0191796832,
0.823723495,
0.2655194104,
-0.7606550455,
0.7309145927,
-0.1577780396,
-0.4549612403,
-0.652189672,
-0.6121762395,
0.0585058965,
-0.1633471847,
-0.6459883451,
0.2726549208,
-0.1173913181,
-0.0641495436,
-0.1815035194,
-0.1267031282,
-0.3751675487,
-0.1164325401,
-0.0498174652,
-0.0156599898,
-0.1463436782,
0.2351991236,
-0.0213181023,
-0.2817349136,
0.0224822871,
-0.4197783768,
0.7456332445,
0.126441747,
-0.511393249,
-0.4194016457,
0.7579381466,
0.1104475111,
-0.273594439,
0.4234511554,
0.7689750791,
-0.3823327422,
-0.3876631856,
-0.277520895,
-0.0953520313,
-0.4785042107,
0.6970191002,
-0.1279230863,
-1.0459315777,
0.2177930027,
-0.027770238,
0.0415613689,
-0.0391216092,
0.2234190255,
-0.455811739,
0.9069181681,
0.7532458901,
-0.0236658826,
1.0992031097,
-0.0665384755,
0.0085109593,
0.0151635045,
-0.4788598418,
-0.5587863326,
-0.2547007799,
-0.0507907122,
-0.6231231689,
0.5111416578,
0.0622755699,
-0.7232608199,
-0.1179757342,
-0.1460801661,
0.8743319511,
0.3370813727,
0.2685897648,
0.0770132095,
0.3526767492,
0.0418143608,
-0.6057992578,
-0.6172431111,
-0.0354491472,
0.287371397,
0.4133325517,
0.566136837,
0.2056224793,
0.5048809052,
0.2472572625,
-0.5774068832,
-0.808603704,
0.8078018427,
-0.2021749318,
0.0256043803,
-0.3714457154,
-0.2762485147,
-0.8508179188,
-0.049109377,
-0.0867479742,
-0.60131675,
-0.1122743711,
0.232884258,
-0.4713630378,
0.3294487894,
-0.5557202697,
0.8894224167,
-0.6365227103,
-0.4927766919,
-0.1981529444,
-0.7342470288,
-0.175818339,
0.3538908958,
0.2287191153,
0.1680042297,
-0.1378214061,
0.4715921283,
-0.3852851987,
1.0698415041,
-0.592189014,
-0.0625576675,
0.140281111,
0.1710514724,
0.3522669971,
0.0959417149,
0.5534258485,
-0.1325746626,
-0.2518553138,
-0.3394219577,
-1.028973937,
0.2316704839,
-0.6553085446,
-0.3397583961,
-0.4884116948,
-0.4727605879,
-0.0738447681,
0.3286064267,
0.1399558336,
0.6542983055,
-0.1970023513,
-0.1444018185,
1.1491373777,
-0.5584070683,
0.7400342226,
0.4359837472,
-0.4055158496,
-0.6328513622,
0.6610918641,
-0.3577183485,
0.1339785457,
0.9542147517,
0.1752473116,
-0.4342873693,
-0.4697950482,
-0.3256154358,
0.3188442588,
-0.6946539283,
0.0252168272,
-0.2895662189,
-0.1197436973,
-0.1519967318,
-0.4565425813,
-0.2112679332,
-0.2801165283,
-0.3736984432,
-0.1425040513,
0.2313589752,
0.2975949347,
0.1776278764,
0.4882519245,
-0.9986675978,
0.5418103933,
0.381632179,
0.3466309011,
-0.3820312917,
-0.5475740433,
-0.1132028773,
-0.2746383846,
-0.133796066,
-0.934845686,
0.5131127834,
0.3936825097,
0.2038747817,
0.3780796826,
-0.3711329699,
1.0108993053,
-0.9974426627,
1.1792553663,
0.2059997171,
-0.8339380622,
1.0245161057,
-0.5548578501,
0.6572750807,
0.3732307851,
0.2450223863,
-0.725286305,
-0.0261967741,
-0.2197075188,
-0.7476918101,
0.3470654786,
-0.1555211842,
-0.1467553973,
0.0537353419,
0.3443339169,
-0.0344741493,
-0.0166340601,
-0.8266906738,
0.0506936014,
-0.2441139519,
-0.2410251796,
-0.389852494,
-0.2354559004,
0.0129485922,
-0.0950089991,
0.1586645246,
-0.3128985465,
0.3173471987,
0.5808346868,
-0.4197642207,
0.0409707502,
0.5258436203,
0.7266726494,
0.4513895214,
-0.093203716,
0.1086359248,
0.1653943956,
-0.4735206664,
0.0895772204,
0.1582900584,
-0.0842291489,
0.1805647463,
0.5990033746,
0.7628833652,
0.3089279532,
-0.8653478026,
0.5404605269,
-0.0175277703,
-0.1761004627,
-0.5977146626,
-0.3201355934,
-0.4008821249,
0.6063972712,
0.5210191011,
-0.0868058577,
-0.0608657226,
-0.266400069,
0.0641338676,
0.2354539931,
-0.3232773244,
-0.4606752694,
0.7217573524,
0.0773627087,
-0.4336072206,
0.5984794497,
-0.0036048561,
-0.5759138465,
0.4868815839,
0.5411539078,
0.9724815488,
0.0099210786,
0.3402849734,
0.3833323717,
0.0999216735,
-0.153055802,
0.5764166117,
-0.5291804075,
-0.4941416383,
-0.917699635,
-0.2308477461,
-0.3322176039,
-0.0806941465,
-0.4253789485,
0.3241831958,
-0.5482370257,
0.1133014187,
-0.4362663627,
0.0433411784,
-0.5389007926,
0.132881701,
0.5327593684,
1.2078487873,
-0.9621172547,
0.6111433506,
0.6918550134,
-0.2060864866,
-0.7492794991,
-0.2201970071,
-0.009909627,
-0.7321358323,
1.0957336426,
0.1938421577,
-0.0990160853,
-0.185799852,
-0.63646698,
-0.7085437775,
1.1485295296,
0.4770701826,
-0.6224750876,
-0.5025063753,
0.420822084,
0.5482458472,
0.0007110416,
0.1235603839,
0.3042377234,
0.1644781828,
0.182085067,
-0.8430274725,
-0.2651910782,
-0.158838734,
-0.1735624224,
0.4216992855,
-0.2809622288,
0.3938513994,
-0.3190439641,
-0.246362254,
-0.0225147884,
1.0262658596,
0.7422683835,
0.774451077,
0.5546018481,
0.5185238123,
0.6164750457,
-0.1139258891,
0.5902380347,
0.0487840325,
0.138316974,
1.2086243629,
-0.0653069466,
0.8567802906,
0.7888260484,
-0.0526909754,
0.4495006502,
0.6977545619,
0.3312295973,
0.6392912269,
-0.1206412464,
-0.3663151264,
-0.281802386,
-0.2736273408,
-0.3206216693,
0.2507393658,
0.3718040586,
-0.1343932003,
-0.5686406493,
0.082774803,
-0.2491123825,
0.3780782521,
-0.6491366029,
0.651837945,
-0.0144704869,
-0.6248780489,
0.2379658818,
-0.5203092098,
0.5607115626,
-0.8969228268,
-0.2308827788,
-0.1498794854,
0.0092019094,
-0.0681555867,
-1.0705935955,
0.2216752023,
0.2156761289,
-0.2033457458,
-0.7896190286,
0.4573669732,
-0.7011248469,
-0.1404756457,
0.1576837897,
0.5268608332,
-0.0245151334,
0.0388583578,
-0.7690910697,
-0.0053401161,
-0.226046592,
-0.0095594469,
0.1597925425,
0.7298917174,
-0.0412909128,
0.8003329039,
0.3713656366,
0.1747741699,
-0.1465315074,
0.5008599758,
0.6525157094,
-1.0295422077,
-0.8511016369,
-0.8808348775,
0.5176420808,
0.1516811401,
-0.2451924086,
0.4733868837,
0.3349345028,
0.7987827063,
-0.0320587307,
0.3745164573,
0.1649191976,
0.338267386,
-1.1345229149,
0.2072145045,
-0.4167733788,
0.2979372144,
-0.328767091,
-0.6993251443,
-0.5991672873,
0.3471229672,
-0.2874016464,
0.0017290321,
0.8576523066,
0.4435492754,
0.0716603175,
-0.1617868692,
0.0632241368,
-0.0027434665,
0.6088336706,
0.8936302662,
1.0821471214,
0.0052483953,
0.5535745621,
-0.2223254144,
-0.1219744012,
0.1632351875,
-1.228826046,
-0.9492047429,
-0.6949750185,
-0.0162779689,
-0.0532936044,
0.1470089257,
1.1842817068,
0.4510078132,
-0.3053947985,
-0.217426762,
-0.2040025592,
-0.0712712184,
-0.2076594085,
-0.2105265111,
0.5006712079,
-0.3999842107,
-0.6657930613,
0.6720628142,
0.2705864012,
0.2706519067,
-0.081568189,
-0.1003714725,
0.0815883279,
-0.5655540824,
0.8327768445,
0.6391564608,
-0.5209442973,
-0.2676203251,
0.3502079546,
0.104195565,
-0.0598649234,
1.0851621628,
-0.9427957535,
0.3396371007,
0.7155930996,
0.799113512,
0.4850958288,
0.0306044333,
0.6818723679,
-1.0908942223,
0.5185747147,
0.3121814132,
0.4581063092,
0.2294412404,
-0.4237116575,
0.2702920139,
0.2217585593,
-0.5729115605,
-0.6907119751,
0.5606774688,
-1.3634529114,
-0.3731518984,
1.0604319572,
0.2464415729,
-0.2950648665,
0.0411390923,
-0.324010253,
0.1358436197,
-0.5047966838,
0.4760370255,
0.3204522431,
0.0270388704,
-0.5981785655,
-0.5289775729,
0.4457903206,
0.5863240957,
-0.648165226,
0.0026290361,
0.7755172849,
0.1258809268,
-0.1297844648,
0.6345575452,
0.1987577677,
0.5665860176,
-0.4125547409,
-0.3019903302,
-0.2276490033,
-0.7591207623,
-0.8133084774,
0.2175381929,
-0.087593548,
-0.0573844723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16048v1
|
LLMs with Chain-of-Thought Are Non-Causal Reasoners
| 2024-02-25T10:13:04 | 2024-02-25T10:13:04 |
Guangsheng Bao, Hongbo Zhang, Linyi Yang, Cunxiang Wang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the role of the Chain of Thought (CoT) in Large Language
Models (LLMs) reasoning. Despite its potential to improve task performance, our
analysis reveals a surprising frequency of correct answers following incorrect
CoTs and vice versa. We employ causal analysis to assess the cause-effect
relationship between CoTs/instructions and answers in LLMs, uncovering the
Structural Causal Model (SCM) that LLMs approximate. By comparing the implied
SCM with that of human reasoning, we highlight discrepancies between LLM and
human reasoning processes. We further examine the factors influencing the
causal structure of the implied SCM, revealing that in-context learning,
supervised fine-tuning, and reinforcement learning on human feedback
significantly impact the causal relations. We release the code and results at
https://github.com/StevenZHB/CoT_Causal_Analysis.
|
[
-0.2102868706,
-1.0576905012,
0.9886155128,
0.1365267187,
-0.197318092,
0.0485879183,
-0.1660904884,
-0.5787336826,
0.1189642623,
0.628426075,
-0.4948341846,
-0.1754663736,
-0.661436975,
0.1226362437,
-0.4408885539,
0.837647438,
-0.2515981197,
0.0446617641,
-0.3094024956,
0.0663830861,
-0.5601490736,
-0.5820403695,
-0.9131689668,
-0.4857446849,
1.0019016266,
0.1504986137,
0.5405410528,
0.457804203,
0.2970529497,
0.2719444931,
-0.2072783858,
0.3273283839,
-0.5660172105,
0.1592696756,
-0.7398289442,
-0.8046195507,
-0.492364794,
-0.1019008383,
0.5365051031,
0.7675520182,
0.0652375147,
0.2745628059,
0.0520573109,
0.9728794694,
-0.7853564024,
-0.0406881012,
-0.6704754233,
-0.2481317818,
0.0585437752,
-0.5326420665,
-0.7231596112,
-0.252479583,
0.0990943834,
-0.2033728361,
0.1491121054,
0.3877683282,
0.5240017772,
0.3459852934,
-0.8001167774,
-0.4017571509,
-0.8098259568,
0.6313481331,
-0.5833188891,
0.3643232584,
0.36624524,
-0.0946261436,
-0.7753943801,
-0.4439374506,
-0.6077031493,
-0.2652673423,
-0.0381148383,
-0.0256404728,
0.0289982446,
0.3038353622,
0.367703557,
0.2111007273,
-0.3000795543,
0.2243646085,
-0.4400202036,
0.0044837655,
0.6402036548,
0.2856959701,
0.329380244,
0.0258607045,
-0.6446883082,
0.2143176198,
-1.1112017632,
-0.0236755852,
0.2603913844,
0.1668882519,
-0.1933968067,
0.5822327137,
0.0541568547,
0.9652288556,
0.0602578335,
-0.160684824,
-0.2707907259,
-0.1401558667,
-0.5092798471,
0.3579808176,
0.6882073283,
0.168294847,
0.2987743318,
-0.2886178195,
-0.1465251893,
0.2810321748,
0.394349277,
-0.3087528944,
-0.0004510929,
0.1990496814,
-0.3215363622,
-0.2284044921,
0.1301347762,
-0.3838706613,
-0.2928941548,
-0.5643952489,
0.2271879166,
0.0551082864,
-0.1254013479,
0.1292620748,
-0.1242490038,
0.1786065698,
0.3163223565,
-0.5147240758,
0.5325723886,
0.610684216,
0.6383702159,
-0.141854912,
-0.3157703578,
-0.5234040618,
0.3947818875,
-0.7568722963,
0.8922992349,
-0.2558563054,
-0.1517758518,
-0.1935577244,
0.0944223478,
-0.2199732065,
-0.3149978518,
0.3753089607,
-0.646697104,
0.0647530556,
-0.7300891876,
-0.6937012076,
-0.1673199832,
0.2134650052,
-0.7119702101,
0.9050430059,
-0.2366286665,
-0.8765150309,
0.3223187327,
-0.4036536515,
-0.4922347665,
-0.1991028488,
-0.4611595273,
-0.048127234,
0.3653685451,
-0.0773663223,
0.3102798462,
-0.8335155845,
0.731675446,
-0.4727676511,
-0.4633428752,
0.6605828404,
-0.4860033691,
0.6633458734,
0.0989496484,
-0.6085935831,
0.4105886221,
-0.576159358,
-0.1508006454,
0.0159571022,
-0.2352872193,
-0.3605427742,
0.418417573,
-0.3856008351,
0.7462534308,
-0.0101285521,
-0.3021174073,
0.1313809305,
-0.2577572465,
0.3225572407,
1.1001932621,
0.2983963788,
0.3073563278,
-0.3639249504,
0.3461632133,
0.0818453059,
0.1541847289,
0.3136377037,
-0.4330437183,
-0.9084951878,
-0.0068060979,
-0.1426229328,
0.2970805466,
-0.7882882357,
0.2175095975,
0.0676180273,
-0.200371936,
-0.0148583446,
0.1482462138,
0.6868035793,
0.4811790287,
0.2343299687,
-0.1625636071,
-0.6117962599,
-0.7659979463,
-0.3936120272,
-0.5477798581,
0.2667135298,
0.0733909979,
0.6251620054,
-0.2354538739,
0.7652059197,
-0.529871881,
0.0536058061,
-0.2688977122,
-0.0201712791,
0.2091400474,
0.1642330438,
0.1461529434,
-0.4309127629,
0.0617494173,
-0.2402418703,
-0.8451088071,
-0.0864642859,
-0.2635975778,
-0.4176626205,
0.3845146298,
0.7937933803,
-0.5615357757,
0.4235075414,
0.307992667,
-0.4951105714,
0.8580175042,
-0.3569966853,
0.0063375421,
-0.8352134824,
0.016776884,
-0.0288834665,
-0.0395344943,
-0.4079372287,
-0.0459560603,
-0.1572528332,
0.2822123766,
-0.5022717714,
0.3823058903,
-0.4834931493,
-0.3031265438,
-0.4135651588,
0.5201263428,
-0.069178924,
0.6556196213,
-0.0535109527,
0.7252787352,
0.4581134319,
-0.88977772,
0.1194807887,
-0.0306740254,
-0.2756516933,
0.4152250886,
-0.7125472426,
0.1472061425,
-0.161317274,
0.4425271451,
-1.1070572138,
-0.0105218785,
0.1110930964,
-0.096373342,
0.0171042141,
0.1691098511,
-0.7880061865,
-0.5621886253,
-0.1573691666,
0.3473191261,
0.0633785501,
-0.6410574913,
0.2872652411,
0.3769568205,
0.3014844656,
-0.4390948713,
-0.6347277164,
-0.1051694304,
-0.1029928997,
-0.4359880388,
0.134141773,
0.1403185874,
-0.5553874969,
-0.0119619817,
-0.5298565626,
-0.0441856198,
0.1859247983,
0.3260430694,
0.4683968425,
-0.1242090687,
0.5683016181,
-0.0190247633,
-0.0006932134,
0.6265053153,
-0.3531791866,
0.4405822754,
-0.1743988693,
-0.2579136193,
-0.2939265072,
-0.0100792218,
0.7157565355,
0.0640915334,
0.9816438556,
-0.0436566845,
-0.1374981552,
-0.253253907,
-0.6146692634,
-0.0355876684,
-0.42076689,
0.0528242551,
-0.3233981133,
-1.0112475157,
0.4858201742,
-0.2232262939,
-0.3804156184,
0.542634666,
0.6346123815,
-0.2249158323,
0.8496576548,
0.3920810223,
-0.2163609415,
0.3191364408,
-0.2387306988,
0.4534937739,
-1.1526143551,
-0.3345020711,
-0.2813304961,
-0.2832793891,
-0.8290525079,
-0.4859459996,
0.2787394226,
0.4426291883,
-0.5827947259,
0.2935144901,
-0.2116972357,
0.54313761,
0.2229063064,
0.3338398933,
0.2427347302,
-0.4910461903,
-0.3638785481,
0.6979005337,
-0.9490777254,
-0.6405548453,
0.8755279779,
0.2058220655,
1.0320376158,
0.1104905829,
0.511756897,
0.1353451014,
0.1150731519,
-0.4587585628,
0.6532586217,
0.2086198777,
-0.7038648129,
-0.2261152118,
-0.4699368775,
-0.9995461702,
0.3023471534,
-0.1727180481,
-1.0011976957,
0.2740484774,
0.1497489363,
-0.063259609,
0.5275969505,
-0.6008514762,
0.5731893182,
-0.3563550711,
-0.7923258543,
-0.4482366145,
-0.7598903775,
0.6560272574,
0.0960507542,
0.2398390174,
0.0601585917,
0.1739906073,
0.9069629312,
-0.5165472627,
1.121776104,
0.2077960521,
-0.3783856928,
0.6620420218,
0.0540574901,
0.6582249999,
-0.0402067676,
0.1112275645,
0.0933204442,
-0.0892816037,
-0.3977246284,
-0.661350131,
0.943138659,
-0.7386879921,
-0.9563161135,
-0.5273328424,
-0.5100081563,
-0.2392226756,
-0.0775159895,
0.0282492302,
0.4449058473,
-0.0131289233,
-0.1618997157,
0.6815776825,
-0.2879260778,
0.375500381,
0.3697679639,
-0.2734334767,
-0.2081988156,
0.3705742061,
0.0486024134,
0.63799119,
0.4848201871,
0.2878834009,
-0.2424524575,
-0.1319746673,
-0.1507554054,
0.4539143741,
-0.8972845674,
-0.1465534717,
-0.4993259013,
-0.0765094459,
0.0017714187,
-0.2600621283,
-0.1994074732,
-0.2152462006,
-0.0895662233,
-0.4511034787,
0.2834900618,
1.0993262529,
0.225997299,
0.1474132687,
-0.3787881434,
0.2946351171,
0.3288350701,
0.3476308584,
0.5129945874,
-0.0259621311,
-0.3065163791,
-0.0055075465,
-0.5449082255,
-0.9220478535,
-0.1213267818,
-0.4164705575,
0.5974341035,
0.4861676693,
0.0691320747,
0.9855161309,
-0.4808342159,
0.7919045091,
0.419841975,
-1.1147348881,
0.6455125213,
-0.1599979848,
0.3348810971,
0.2099139988,
0.2789366543,
-0.4648198485,
-0.7481546998,
-0.6117982268,
-0.7955046892,
0.6166962385,
0.163519606,
-0.4552236199,
-0.6379575729,
0.4221448302,
-0.1884997189,
-0.0789361969,
-0.6875575781,
-0.2405157238,
0.5046074986,
0.234788537,
-0.0582422875,
-0.5068792105,
0.0276398901,
-0.3016830683,
0.6997009516,
0.0044901897,
0.3602791131,
0.5857539773,
-0.3257281184,
-0.6041520238,
0.3574880362,
0.892812252,
1.1313307285,
-0.0246115346,
0.5639554858,
0.4390550852,
0.0778052136,
0.2014943212,
-0.7131937742,
0.2546314299,
-0.3508615792,
0.8239499331,
0.9603123665,
0.5874785781,
-0.5823266506,
0.3580944836,
0.0682847053,
-0.0906782225,
-0.279689908,
0.2530014515,
0.1485402733,
0.334110707,
0.1757597625,
0.1596084237,
0.0544816889,
-0.7961831689,
0.1378082037,
0.3590983748,
-0.5013337135,
-0.3654530644,
0.7206562757,
0.0159691926,
-0.298805654,
0.4669179916,
0.0928873494,
-0.6867815852,
0.7640771866,
0.8488577604,
0.8005410433,
-0.1078651473,
0.1637539268,
0.3012117147,
0.485797137,
-0.201675728,
0.3456904292,
-0.1156328842,
-0.5964634418,
-0.8578560352,
-0.3450775445,
-0.2475527674,
-0.0925967023,
-0.7143738866,
0.309395045,
-0.4281825423,
-0.1666515917,
-0.2958047092,
-0.1638023853,
-0.5779974461,
0.3325857222,
0.0958975255,
0.7131669521,
-0.8825126886,
0.9738734961,
0.2887489498,
-0.5707826614,
-0.9835426807,
0.1592117548,
-0.1743296534,
-0.6042962074,
1.1172944307,
0.051782921,
-0.7017391324,
-0.2912278771,
-0.4692946076,
-0.9942296743,
1.0714396238,
0.3518179655,
-0.8104285598,
0.0045476495,
0.0622528791,
0.7163960338,
-0.3143002689,
0.2164732218,
0.4067547321,
0.1435108185,
0.1041302606,
-0.8337491155,
0.440118134,
0.1998609304,
0.2038610727,
0.5956314802,
-0.5503198504,
0.7193760276,
-0.5526303053,
-0.2041670382,
-0.2065754533,
0.4283063412,
0.4752207994,
0.2791399062,
0.4505985677,
0.4748749137,
0.8915429115,
0.2028450072,
1.3895673752,
-0.2252771854,
0.2889743149,
1.3678746223,
-0.365108937,
0.8085031509,
0.8859701157,
-0.3038417399,
0.9619076848,
0.5272590518,
0.5062855482,
0.5122602582,
0.6120517254,
-0.1236738712,
-0.2733253241,
0.1599983275,
-0.1366620064,
0.246351108,
0.2958874404,
-0.4935094714,
-0.0132391155,
-0.2687920332,
-0.0678945556,
-0.0192720443,
-0.5002530217,
0.8299958706,
0.3649472892,
-0.747774899,
0.6675367355,
-0.1907381713,
0.235821262,
-0.3419338465,
0.0995807424,
0.1324110329,
0.2442516834,
-0.2549179494,
-0.6401953697,
0.5216836333,
-0.0997482315,
-0.4041364491,
-0.0756480992,
0.7682784796,
-0.2294926792,
-0.3947655261,
0.7610845566,
0.511046648,
0.0152444495,
0.1686055809,
-0.3830811679,
0.0017858283,
-0.3443925977,
-0.1768599302,
0.271597445,
0.5380128026,
-0.5845060945,
0.7491351366,
0.7177271843,
0.1012459919,
0.0447824672,
0.1277041435,
1.0161970854,
-0.9288275242,
-0.4105763435,
-1.3909076452,
0.2954677045,
-0.0178499073,
-0.2144377381,
0.6997031569,
0.4066119492,
0.7969397306,
-0.0634569004,
0.4015582502,
0.1407470852,
0.009372321,
-0.7339274883,
0.5194782615,
-0.3323077261,
0.5405526161,
-0.5097203851,
-0.7963867188,
-0.2436496466,
0.3737795353,
-0.8597838283,
-0.2438528091,
1.4126055241,
0.5707139373,
0.3120263815,
0.2459476441,
0.2969938517,
0.4546264112,
0.3171865344,
0.6808973551,
1.0538492203,
-0.3418647945,
-0.0062443349,
0.1658407003,
-0.1617952287,
0.0165741034,
-0.8502642512,
-1.1883308887,
-0.5769402981,
-0.3362854719,
-0.2846540809,
0.2181845605,
1.0161041021,
0.3624401987,
-0.7140556574,
-0.5969243646,
-0.7813282013,
0.7974348664,
-0.356687218,
-0.2104593813,
0.4591676295,
-0.6386992335,
0.053583689,
0.221897006,
0.3964380622,
-0.4600897729,
-0.1396358311,
-0.1253574193,
-0.7045632601,
0.394330442,
1.0691843033,
-0.1294160485,
-1.127189517,
-0.4044572413,
-0.1703235656,
-0.0363187157,
-0.1039879769,
1.1439096928,
-0.7957556248,
0.3005864918,
0.3524601758,
0.3065700233,
0.4751060009,
-0.3207287192,
0.6887045503,
-0.5597199202,
0.0499415733,
-0.2020399868,
0.5965366364,
-0.0355909541,
-0.6559245586,
0.4463377595,
0.1668072492,
-0.7152261138,
-0.7063313723,
0.3898403645,
-0.8773325682,
-0.5603737831,
1.2355883121,
-0.0002372296,
-0.6027826667,
-0.1109782532,
-0.2689894736,
0.3966110945,
-0.0460583642,
0.8811395168,
0.7593893409,
-0.4014668167,
0.0224332958,
-0.2736495435,
0.2511382401,
0.1080140173,
-0.8585630059,
0.0912305862,
0.4175873995,
0.2805762291,
-0.0194123238,
0.7258135676,
-0.0445101038,
0.1680357307,
-0.1507825702,
-0.0554843694,
0.2914993167,
-0.507807374,
-0.0407338254,
-0.0395187736,
0.2143636048,
-0.0326481834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16041v2
|
Detecting Machine-Generated Texts by Multi-Population Aware Optimization for Maximum Mean Discrepancy
| 2024-02-25T09:44:56 | 2024-02-29T14:46:44 |
Shuhai Zhang, Yiliao Song, Jiahao Yang, Yuanqing Li, Bo Han, Mingkui Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have exhibited remarkable
performance in generating human-like texts. However, machine-generated texts
(MGTs) may carry critical risks, such as plagiarism issues, misleading
information, or hallucination issues. Therefore, it is very urgent and
important to detect MGTs in many situations. Unfortunately, it is challenging
to distinguish MGTs and human-written texts because the distributional
discrepancy between them is often very subtle due to the remarkable performance
of LLMs. In this paper, we seek to exploit \textit{maximum mean discrepancy}
(MMD) to address this issue in the sense that MMD can well identify
distributional discrepancies. However, directly training a detector with MMD
using diverse MGTs will incur a significantly increased variance of MMD since
MGTs may contain \textit{multiple text populations} due to various LLMs. This
will severely impair MMD's ability to measure the difference between two
samples. To tackle this, we propose a novel \textit{multi-population} aware
optimization method for MMD called MMD-MP, which can \textit{avoid variance
increases} and thus improve the stability to measure the distributional
discrepancy. Relying on MMD-MP, we develop two methods for paragraph-based and
sentence-based detection, respectively. Extensive experiments on various LLMs,
\eg, GPT2 and ChatGPT, show superior detection performance of our MMD-MP. The
source code is available at \url{https://github.com/ZSHsh98/MMD-MP}.
|
[
-0.5986981392,
-0.8040545583,
0.3748244047,
0.3260511458,
-0.2655656934,
0.1673642099,
-0.2062142491,
-0.0825453699,
0.1477836967,
0.4348126352,
-0.7134740949,
-0.5483262539,
-0.6842859387,
0.3548400104,
-0.1479211897,
0.7729789019,
-0.0881568193,
-0.2364268899,
-0.1539588869,
-0.2454241812,
-0.4158988893,
-0.6464975476,
-0.527975738,
-0.137167111,
0.2952040732,
0.3601826429,
0.417283088,
0.7532625794,
0.4399368763,
0.3357734382,
0.0200538877,
0.9864459038,
-0.5525265932,
0.1948897243,
0.2805652022,
-0.2206466645,
-0.0773719102,
-0.0605275854,
0.7658603191,
0.1127293557,
-0.3083340824,
-0.0955288634,
0.1492590159,
0.5890411139,
-0.838403821,
0.1419975311,
-0.8030679822,
0.1274707019,
-0.3909224272,
-0.4517697692,
-0.5869556069,
-0.2278232723,
-0.1993792802,
-0.5233502388,
0.542140007,
-0.0081429137,
0.7256798148,
0.3955320716,
-0.3792898655,
-0.3983513415,
-0.6580915451,
1.0046377182,
-0.4681318998,
0.3302338123,
0.1900657266,
0.172058031,
-0.5505850911,
-0.0922466889,
-0.895021677,
-0.1453255564,
0.2066273391,
0.4003102183,
-0.3391803503,
-0.1430056393,
0.2541285455,
0.1370307356,
-0.7571804523,
0.2598895729,
0.1888487935,
-0.387185663,
0.4389487505,
0.1224513054,
0.1168600619,
-0.1073419303,
-0.3434821367,
-0.298641175,
-0.506763041,
-0.3860957921,
0.6631566882,
0.0569571927,
-0.1177985743,
0.5017011762,
0.0716219619,
0.4111997485,
-0.1604181826,
-0.1534968019,
0.5841739774,
-0.2463503182,
0.0821096599,
-0.3376637697,
0.9235572815,
0.4461198151,
0.4776510596,
0.2360644788,
-0.2710945606,
0.3190448582,
-0.2530684471,
-0.6995589733,
-0.1410999,
0.0753611401,
-0.4824373126,
-0.3528994322,
0.0344801992,
-1.1531641483,
-0.8107255101,
-0.0767876878,
0.1420776844,
-0.3347877562,
-0.5486425757,
0.2508020997,
-0.1838308871,
-0.1846872419,
0.0889368206,
-1.030749321,
-0.0692308098,
0.4617320299,
0.9163777232,
-0.1932591051,
-0.3259975016,
-0.5229781866,
0.1254147738,
-0.2759875953,
1.175756216,
-0.2946913242,
-0.4949546158,
-0.0247171503,
-0.514085412,
-0.3381461501,
-0.8732030988,
0.7391683459,
-0.1222252548,
0.2018697858,
-0.0149327666,
-0.6046688557,
0.2782014906,
0.411413908,
-0.7809981108,
1.187661171,
0.0057550617,
-1.0809959173,
0.5858069062,
-0.7231103778,
-0.2377438098,
-0.3078593612,
-0.2626131773,
-1.0640343428,
-0.0022162013,
0.719145596,
0.46117118,
-0.0915522575,
0.2605845332,
-0.4983436465,
-0.224280864,
0.5710315704,
-0.9803094268,
0.5914297104,
0.2300403714,
-0.0992009416,
0.0519249849,
-0.8994159698,
-0.2894293368,
0.1421134472,
-0.4647930264,
-0.2740096152,
0.404414326,
0.0754705369,
0.1342279315,
0.0762313828,
-0.4267500043,
0.1035876796,
-0.1231120005,
0.1843479872,
1.0114835501,
0.1281201541,
0.0913574845,
-0.4770529568,
0.3893449008,
0.293943882,
0.0507639199,
-0.2535544336,
-0.4652612507,
-0.6347388029,
-0.6091961265,
0.1098392159,
0.7398741841,
-0.9149082303,
0.6887008548,
-0.1089025959,
-0.28178671,
-0.3894220293,
0.1423674077,
0.184611246,
0.2129454762,
0.2792556584,
-0.0121385548,
-0.6704546809,
-0.7362049818,
-0.3090605736,
-0.2508687675,
-0.1521277875,
0.1148287579,
0.3681557775,
-0.2725559175,
0.9176525474,
-0.9442411065,
-0.4444509149,
-0.1964620799,
0.2285386324,
0.0517905056,
0.3593595624,
0.4596969187,
-0.8860480785,
-0.4782078862,
-0.0904759169,
-0.7011392117,
-0.5925704837,
-0.4611171484,
-0.1503709406,
0.1890270263,
0.3997115791,
-0.7700747848,
0.1364778578,
0.5130336285,
-0.0626225322,
1.0174146891,
-0.4545418322,
0.0501678064,
-1.2480843067,
-0.2310405076,
0.4178010821,
-0.0588796549,
-0.619431138,
-0.0394318141,
0.2232566029,
0.1867130399,
-0.1740663052,
0.3359036148,
-0.5217110515,
0.0385945924,
-0.3435169458,
0.2158608586,
-0.2489353716,
0.2981034219,
-0.2027543485,
1.0256255865,
0.2389599532,
-0.4579158425,
0.1786293685,
0.1421700418,
-0.065852806,
0.7261304855,
-0.1089713424,
0.0336690992,
-0.2659054697,
0.3739572465,
-0.843560636,
-0.0647726804,
0.338724941,
-0.6760726571,
0.0464094616,
0.1254866272,
-0.9283863902,
-0.5618402362,
-0.5307452679,
-0.0224785339,
0.1607523561,
-0.6379170418,
0.4426857531,
0.3866819143,
0.1667698026,
-0.7412831783,
-0.4078742862,
0.0048128916,
-0.3888036907,
-0.7513226271,
0.082109876,
-0.3259576261,
-0.0784095749,
-0.5245542526,
-0.0685151368,
-0.2497657537,
-0.0895772576,
-0.1450825483,
0.2600030899,
-0.1250217706,
0.2857210338,
0.1665788144,
-0.4302848279,
-0.1324354261,
-0.2966778874,
0.8207765222,
0.1375989616,
-0.4874607027,
-0.2852315009,
0.4597983658,
0.6742012501,
-0.4402974248,
0.8241770267,
0.9799003005,
-0.2674250305,
-0.3131116629,
-0.7476292253,
0.0079853497,
-0.5138041973,
0.5312167406,
-0.4629960358,
-0.7544999123,
0.5809572339,
-0.1032587513,
0.0034857802,
0.3576472104,
0.7296357751,
0.1467092633,
1.2047815323,
0.3761074543,
-0.243581742,
0.6214152575,
-0.0574448258,
0.0174585115,
-0.7262205482,
0.0956058502,
-0.6416582465,
-0.0090354327,
-0.7327713966,
-0.550804615,
0.4050756395,
-0.132112518,
-0.1064301804,
0.0881079212,
-0.5721204877,
0.7598773241,
0.5541120172,
0.2488084584,
0.454254806,
-0.0104494141,
-0.2496960014,
-0.1399350315,
-0.3506343961,
-0.4477473199,
1.2426861525,
0.0929812267,
0.6134699583,
0.1678229272,
0.8193021417,
0.2606963217,
0.2138233483,
-0.3697123826,
0.5631713867,
-0.4970803261,
-0.236040473,
-0.0626686662,
-0.810520649,
-1.0745029449,
0.7134358883,
-0.3230394125,
-0.6783641577,
-0.0402999446,
0.1627434641,
0.1408474147,
0.4370408654,
-0.9833918214,
0.7458510995,
0.2403609753,
0.1131692305,
-0.1553507447,
-0.3263504505,
0.3785315156,
-0.3378431201,
0.2430846095,
-0.2356877923,
-0.0644043162,
0.3675613403,
-0.0800908357,
0.5939272642,
-0.3107091188,
-0.0969035178,
0.1707987636,
-0.1324370056,
0.7122160196,
-0.0935275704,
-0.0513934046,
-0.1500516385,
-0.3883981109,
-0.4700511694,
-0.341252476,
0.5211074948,
-0.7290763259,
-0.3211159706,
-0.2075360268,
-0.7251797318,
0.0345218182,
0.2065030485,
0.5160674453,
0.2239837795,
-0.2302925587,
-0.1175604314,
0.9166061878,
-0.3108669817,
0.535360992,
0.3378479779,
-0.0578616895,
-0.3602744341,
0.9766501188,
-0.0390833914,
0.33624354,
0.6011586785,
0.4231274128,
-0.4123806655,
-0.7608470917,
-0.7028918266,
0.0878009275,
-0.5688543916,
-0.1496262401,
-0.7094274759,
-0.0804905817,
-0.2232369781,
0.0550588258,
-0.1618440896,
-0.0025678771,
-0.5319042802,
0.0856746137,
0.0580391996,
0.1356059164,
-0.1572322994,
0.4578826427,
-0.8104400039,
0.4787612855,
-0.0863963738,
0.1028984487,
-0.184907198,
-0.134720996,
-0.0412668101,
0.0958639011,
-0.6389786005,
-0.9166307449,
0.5357185006,
0.1852342784,
0.5926185846,
0.7030256987,
0.1618382186,
0.5451024175,
-0.5130740404,
0.3271457255,
0.2593301833,
-0.871442616,
0.3205173016,
-0.453966707,
0.3927563727,
0.2209796757,
-0.0815886259,
-0.7294199467,
-0.8384551406,
-0.3496582806,
-0.5924178958,
0.4109710753,
0.3996676207,
0.1548892111,
-0.2034976929,
-0.0780154541,
0.0417459346,
0.0249100011,
-0.8084495664,
-0.1950686872,
0.1461037844,
-0.5510134101,
0.1329934597,
-0.084844619,
0.116909802,
0.2917489409,
0.5591387153,
-0.2357940227,
0.5496387482,
0.0505044423,
-0.2001028955,
-0.0360268354,
0.2710511088,
0.853746295,
0.4121361673,
-0.059803959,
0.2919896245,
0.1437110901,
-0.8856256604,
0.3027150333,
0.3588201702,
-0.1812364459,
0.1243196204,
0.260836482,
0.4528969526,
-0.1426386386,
-0.7773572803,
0.4973759949,
0.0233219154,
-0.2492013276,
-0.2561280131,
-0.0368840545,
0.0556096137,
0.2772243321,
0.5459363461,
0.3717606962,
0.0169067644,
0.0613545813,
0.5182740688,
0.4832243323,
0.1832332909,
0.0806969479,
0.6220422387,
0.0462720506,
-0.2037933618,
0.3928841949,
-0.4997316897,
-0.7280882001,
0.7495088577,
0.6545103788,
0.8067495227,
-0.4226576388,
0.2817674279,
0.1171551645,
0.4207484126,
-0.2377054542,
0.0751018077,
0.2908017039,
-1.1970686913,
-0.4558638334,
-0.2958164811,
-0.1951564848,
0.1127171814,
-0.2573936582,
0.4706370533,
-0.2534479499,
-0.129033491,
0.2054316401,
-0.0805101991,
-0.2634188533,
-0.2291456014,
0.0396786854,
0.486022979,
-0.9026826024,
0.626481235,
0.1847703904,
-0.1057031602,
-0.4136993289,
0.2923883498,
0.2831168175,
-0.7423440218,
0.0135551747,
0.4427930713,
-0.1038108915,
0.0395991206,
-0.2418725044,
-0.5056948066,
0.8852413893,
0.3462097049,
-0.5627170205,
0.3003299534,
0.1448689997,
0.344410181,
-0.2367938012,
0.3015763164,
0.4857054949,
0.4989475906,
0.1001756638,
-0.693338275,
-0.078839995,
0.0046829144,
-0.0357956998,
0.7551891208,
-0.5912454128,
0.8714248538,
-0.0787806511,
-0.295864135,
0.1034347564,
0.4410827756,
0.7543942928,
0.5740776658,
0.6680187583,
0.7161061168,
1.0305657387,
-0.0507027805,
0.7597520947,
0.1364120394,
0.6709551811,
0.7946276665,
-0.3016289175,
0.6908698678,
0.3538706303,
-0.3768692315,
-0.0247882307,
0.7494865656,
-0.2538286448,
0.4260693491,
0.5197467804,
-0.7755534649,
-0.1606031209,
0.2594026029,
-0.3467775583,
0.2257408351,
0.3143646121,
-0.3665394485,
-0.3537032306,
0.1008046567,
0.2487709224,
0.2619297802,
-0.0849823952,
0.5068303347,
-0.242576316,
-0.3780793846,
0.4980271757,
0.2509016991,
1.0669401884,
-0.3598985076,
0.0743189305,
-0.2900461853,
0.505151093,
0.0310374331,
-0.5274310112,
0.2056185305,
0.1043492407,
-0.3154150844,
0.0421580561,
0.8942539692,
-0.5397009254,
-0.5811142325,
0.1307994276,
0.6339619756,
0.1060045883,
-0.2545827031,
-0.6872947216,
0.0387359262,
0.2671302855,
-0.0662468076,
0.3649693727,
0.6537449956,
-0.0976348892,
0.8907558918,
0.9886728525,
0.1569295675,
0.1414403766,
0.2530966997,
0.6907845736,
-0.2429403961,
-0.7006232142,
-1.3541671038,
0.1034867167,
-0.3841409087,
-0.411945641,
0.5092432499,
0.7873383164,
0.6014849544,
-0.201649785,
0.7733005881,
0.1619698405,
0.6746836305,
-0.6033342481,
0.6982058287,
-0.1465417743,
0.4740651846,
-0.474082917,
-1.2679163218,
-0.5945147872,
0.6719534397,
-0.0083634593,
-0.1334829181,
0.6811099052,
1.071528554,
-0.0566193238,
0.0852724314,
0.3113107383,
-0.0175367948,
0.7254536152,
0.6753268242,
0.8863584995,
-0.0836684853,
1.0398242474,
0.2242859155,
-0.4085026979,
-0.1457136571,
-0.8431147337,
-0.8598642945,
-0.4759853184,
-0.2283022553,
-0.1557698846,
0.0552972294,
0.875320375,
0.6402885914,
-0.529143393,
-0.1232149899,
-0.2482877225,
0.2989336848,
-0.321176976,
-0.2800892889,
0.4618809521,
-0.111130856,
-0.8334241509,
0.1230027974,
0.2121300846,
0.3181716204,
-0.2397544682,
-0.0372066759,
-0.2232210785,
0.1290477216,
0.4855112731,
-0.1160826832,
-0.4306085408,
-0.2504257262,
-0.228467375,
-0.0482459106,
0.2649145126,
0.8538048267,
-0.3627745807,
0.4728985429,
0.3302979469,
0.5909217596,
0.5746887326,
-0.0105198231,
0.3662134111,
-1.1608721018,
0.096311748,
0.0489887185,
0.2738464773,
0.408054322,
-0.3897795081,
0.4378655553,
0.5247965455,
-0.6808586121,
-0.7102323771,
0.3584759831,
-0.9008734822,
-0.2249508351,
1.0333762169,
-0.0939864516,
0.2273190022,
-0.1007918268,
-0.3908278644,
0.3919411302,
-0.680234611,
0.8922024965,
0.9372957945,
-0.0666854158,
-0.3201084733,
-0.8057850003,
0.199306339,
0.15067105,
-1.0496811867,
0.2448355407,
0.6242937446,
0.0787953809,
0.0239583608,
0.7429665327,
0.0394947715,
0.0683490336,
0.2170603573,
0.0034661861,
-0.0060597728,
0.0202740077,
-0.0018074194,
0.0118636638,
-0.3073090911,
-0.6605812907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16040v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16040v4
|
EHRNoteQA: An LLM Benchmark for Real-World Clinical Practice Using Discharge Summaries
| 2024-02-25T09:41:50 | 2024-06-27T04:28:12 |
Sunjun Kweon, Jiyoun Kim, Heeyoung Kwak, Dongchul Cha, Hangyul Yoon, Kwanghyun Kim, Jeewon Yang, Seunghyun Won, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discharge summaries in Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are crucial for
clinical decision-making, but their length and complexity make information
extraction challenging, especially when dealing with accumulated summaries
across multiple patient admissions. Large Language Models (LLMs) show promise
in addressing this challenge by efficiently analyzing vast and complex data.
Existing benchmarks, however, fall short in properly evaluating LLMs'
capabilities in this context, as they typically focus on single-note
information or limited topics, failing to reflect the real-world inquiries
required by clinicians. To bridge this gap, we introduce EHRNoteQA, a novel
benchmark built on the MIMIC-IV EHR, comprising 962 different QA pairs each
linked to distinct patients' discharge summaries. Every QA pair is initially
generated using GPT-4 and then manually reviewed and refined by three
clinicians to ensure clinical relevance. EHRNoteQA includes questions that
require information across multiple discharge summaries and covers eight
diverse topics, mirroring the complexity and diversity of real clinical
inquiries. We offer EHRNoteQA in two formats: open-ended and multi-choice
question answering, and propose a reliable evaluation method for each. We
evaluate 27 LLMs using EHRNoteQA and examine various factors affecting the
model performance (e.g., the length and number of discharge summaries).
Furthermore, to validate EHRNoteQA as a reliable proxy for expert evaluations
in clinical practice, we measure the correlation between the LLM performance on
EHRNoteQA, and the LLM performance manually evaluated by clinicians. Results
show that LLM performance on EHRNoteQA have higher correlation with
clinician-evaluated performance (Spearman: 0.78, Kendall: 0.62) compared to
other benchmarks, demonstrating its practical relevance in evaluating LLMs in
clinical settings.
|
[
-0.20493716,
-0.5469619632,
0.9711637497,
-0.0167481583,
-0.1126263663,
0.1185833886,
-0.0319572613,
-0.398794502,
0.1460665166,
0.5771528482,
-0.2759851515,
-0.6691768765,
-0.5320419073,
0.1523989737,
-0.2464151084,
0.9800313115,
-0.1747287363,
0.1931328326,
-0.2344363481,
-0.3555948138,
-0.254986167,
-0.4966697097,
-0.483840704,
-0.2514806986,
0.5235897899,
0.2447012514,
0.329633832,
0.4285613298,
0.7059955001,
0.2526884675,
-0.1655695587,
0.3144799471,
-0.4140765965,
0.3318258822,
0.2989653945,
-0.458078742,
-0.7451694608,
-0.2299158275,
0.8362606764,
0.5181919336,
-0.558826685,
0.3679415882,
-0.1579927653,
0.6146452427,
-0.7451325059,
-0.1733894199,
-0.3949615657,
0.1671949178,
-0.0714074075,
-0.0203259252,
-0.1786163002,
-0.6848464012,
0.2727695107,
-0.3945107758,
0.155061096,
0.0045399293,
0.7798188329,
0.1469088197,
-0.419683367,
-0.3015710711,
-0.5330100656,
0.5937677622,
-0.7825847864,
0.4803441167,
0.1690600961,
0.6764146686,
0.0902164429,
-0.8691938519,
-0.3824081123,
-0.3853465319,
-0.1102675721,
0.5832102299,
-0.1656695008,
0.3242784739,
0.4854300022,
0.3782574534,
-0.6138548255,
0.086527735,
-0.4591901302,
-0.1019442752,
0.4854844511,
0.5595459342,
0.1871430427,
-0.2571992278,
-0.2601003349,
0.1002422348,
-0.6815378666,
-0.0206941403,
-0.0082725706,
-0.3218587339,
-0.2689199746,
0.5291300416,
-0.3165384531,
0.3624689281,
-0.087121591,
-0.2337689847,
0.1096924618,
-0.0159547199,
-0.1357646585,
0.0077866246,
0.8277611732,
0.5847210288,
0.0756043568,
-0.1059452295,
-0.0889371559,
-0.2616305351,
0.3784214258,
-0.8381684422,
-0.3233960867,
0.6020320058,
-0.5311886072,
-0.1128403917,
0.0453272872,
-1.0840098858,
-0.2700963914,
-0.0044133272,
0.3359746039,
-0.2343275249,
-0.1417199075,
-0.1088640243,
-0.0419926085,
0.1032026857,
0.5169764161,
-0.4944961369,
0.6957662702,
0.873947084,
0.9544917941,
-0.3417422771,
-0.1932448447,
-0.866964519,
-0.144003883,
-0.3134203553,
0.7125886679,
-0.1606359035,
-0.3898743391,
0.265041858,
-0.2333376259,
-0.151826337,
-0.9177886248,
0.703704536,
-0.2796830833,
0.1045369282,
-0.168200627,
-0.6953492165,
0.0920490846,
0.3545840383,
-0.7618964314,
1.023827672,
0.2661609054,
-0.550373733,
0.3236120641,
-0.2566682398,
-0.0394955203,
0.1757997274,
-0.4798440337,
-0.5319800973,
0.1385947913,
-0.0539829992,
0.4321207106,
-0.5879374743,
0.329881072,
-0.13657327,
-0.2383060306,
0.1782221943,
-0.214053914,
0.355038166,
0.1768559664,
-0.1043629646,
-0.0598166138,
-0.5525265932,
0.2764602304,
-0.174875617,
-0.2985306084,
-0.1674220264,
-0.1546685249,
0.0641194806,
0.2989302278,
-0.0870168284,
-0.4983059764,
-0.0993541554,
-0.3580107689,
0.234776929,
0.3884380758,
0.2724957466,
-0.01398913,
-0.9300346375,
0.7991966605,
-0.1487999558,
0.130724296,
-0.3631603718,
-0.5681157708,
-0.5177875161,
-0.6635479927,
0.2621737421,
0.4202601016,
-0.2969136238,
0.1667285264,
-0.3537875116,
-0.6136494875,
-0.7575442791,
-0.0284849722,
0.6613582969,
0.7032631636,
0.4780301452,
-0.3105738163,
-0.2598748803,
-1.015306592,
-0.3425170183,
-0.2610872686,
-0.1214297861,
0.4538434744,
0.609593749,
-0.0704467073,
0.6964355111,
-0.5265234709,
-0.2337485105,
-0.434431076,
0.2766962349,
0.2835613787,
0.0860903561,
0.1937676072,
-0.5456638336,
-0.4791225195,
0.0120793767,
-0.8174778223,
-0.391584456,
-0.1509872675,
-0.1513545513,
-0.2056302428,
0.2261640877,
-0.6412016153,
0.3117441833,
0.4663792253,
0.0159812719,
0.7711273432,
-0.5458651781,
0.3908907175,
-0.9877681136,
0.2242057025,
-0.0542226806,
-0.312940985,
-0.5713002682,
0.2306292355,
0.3487328887,
0.1906121671,
-0.4090202749,
0.686098814,
-0.3434827924,
0.0140310703,
0.2222740501,
0.1201784611,
0.1314299256,
0.1139524579,
-0.0147516811,
0.502821207,
0.2786180675,
-0.4853596985,
0.4762724936,
0.2717706263,
-0.3110557795,
0.7025607824,
-0.8760535717,
-0.039743457,
0.0668321475,
0.4081710875,
-0.8690852523,
-0.3055606484,
-0.1476315856,
-0.0938208103,
0.0822620392,
-0.147860527,
-0.3895166218,
-0.2868421376,
-0.4243755341,
0.5476998091,
0.7102264166,
-0.2882842124,
0.8202481866,
0.2509132028,
-0.4085023105,
-0.3855711222,
-0.3776661158,
0.0070588728,
-0.2970976233,
-0.3793723583,
0.5909044147,
-0.04697093,
-0.4681209922,
-0.277685374,
-0.0122635942,
-0.2603284419,
-0.0594806857,
0.3517926931,
0.2518972754,
-0.2302615345,
0.1909788251,
0.2133920193,
0.0869612545,
0.319652766,
0.1929496825,
0.3911444843,
-0.0268872473,
-0.6935940981,
-0.585441947,
0.5686812401,
0.8220064044,
-0.2144522369,
0.5285843611,
0.3665976226,
-0.6250928044,
-0.2000048906,
-0.9862850904,
-0.1627861261,
-0.3640699387,
0.5042918324,
-0.3259400129,
-0.4749193788,
0.631821394,
-0.1965894401,
0.2641407847,
0.3460665643,
0.5578565001,
-0.2600740492,
0.7291810513,
0.1364073008,
0.1408583224,
-0.0935809091,
-0.1843875498,
0.0205806941,
-1.1088402271,
-0.3838731647,
-0.3998897672,
0.0642205849,
-0.5462859869,
-0.4197837114,
0.8561605215,
0.0942098945,
-0.0928887576,
-0.1128825396,
-0.1392616928,
0.1462770402,
0.1944556236,
0.3517413735,
0.5557901263,
-0.3644368947,
-0.2873136103,
-0.0863517523,
-0.5862386823,
-0.6406035423,
1.2983332872,
0.4680084586,
0.568906188,
0.4247837961,
0.9319995046,
0.3297628164,
0.4924847782,
-0.7176709771,
0.3950207531,
0.0125924163,
-0.3292277753,
-0.0853475183,
-0.5499275923,
-0.6201435924,
0.3705903888,
-0.3060515523,
-0.5877861381,
-0.2775350809,
0.0930170044,
-0.7066794038,
0.1678074151,
-0.3675398231,
0.7277761698,
-0.3822815716,
-0.3657156825,
-0.1662687361,
-0.4562060237,
0.3512128592,
-0.361908406,
0.2324252725,
-0.0435360558,
-0.280630976,
0.6401237845,
-0.51518929,
0.3893208802,
0.2610653341,
-0.1155939549,
0.0135339526,
0.102160491,
0.3044303954,
0.3530214727,
-0.0299807675,
0.2036978602,
0.379160881,
-0.1980880797,
-0.6233815551,
0.6275444031,
-0.5481570363,
-0.4789144993,
-0.5016235113,
-0.1397089958,
-0.377687037,
0.0623922013,
0.3963736594,
0.7968817353,
-0.6010477543,
0.0001827736,
0.649854362,
-0.3585473895,
0.0236989334,
0.5513849258,
-0.1719001681,
-0.3479823172,
0.4268069863,
0.1462712288,
0.4938342869,
0.4792378545,
0.2118764967,
-0.5112585425,
-0.5670513511,
-0.6926146746,
0.4657509923,
-0.6472672224,
-0.0477275215,
-1.0864374638,
-0.3243443966,
-0.1176986694,
0.0502475388,
-0.3153440654,
-0.1821060628,
0.0649813861,
0.0306718368,
0.1541544795,
0.8397018909,
0.3077532053,
-0.0378261171,
-0.9811047912,
0.5964409709,
0.4236262441,
0.2431866378,
0.02534125,
-0.734116137,
-0.1411097497,
-0.2137360275,
-0.3975624442,
-1.0968595743,
0.4053462446,
0.386590302,
0.8059788346,
0.376870513,
0.0684651583,
0.5951118469,
-0.7797979116,
0.6298476458,
0.2017130703,
-0.6593625546,
0.4130682945,
-0.422847122,
0.3021107614,
0.6095277071,
0.476772815,
-0.6470719576,
-0.4443205297,
-0.5531083941,
-0.8429243565,
0.4289711118,
0.2497618943,
-0.2014799714,
0.0449889973,
0.3482153118,
0.0135282045,
0.1296646893,
-0.078848049,
-0.293571353,
0.2976669669,
-0.5148100257,
0.0165831838,
-0.3066044748,
-0.331580013,
0.0154452939,
0.2097568214,
0.0243528076,
0.3088976145,
0.4360803962,
-0.1475173086,
0.0409559235,
0.445404321,
0.4288209975,
0.8066056371,
-0.3183825314,
0.0072424174,
0.4995178878,
-0.6555435658,
-0.0531128943,
0.1188682839,
0.0686843917,
0.281701088,
0.5514512658,
0.237985909,
0.3724096119,
-1.1142506599,
0.5180045962,
-0.2059806883,
-0.2597534657,
-0.4334419668,
-0.0075760619,
-0.0992061123,
0.1313543022,
0.3350709975,
-0.3100624084,
0.4124560356,
-0.5409906507,
0.3579859138,
0.1553947031,
-0.4358378947,
-0.1930698156,
0.5615596175,
0.0550861545,
-0.185309872,
0.4162436128,
0.19741036,
-0.4342318177,
0.8684157133,
0.3319168091,
0.8249980211,
-0.1747288108,
0.2836524844,
0.6695125699,
0.0038142647,
-0.3245339692,
0.3503884077,
0.1423758566,
-0.3658823371,
-0.140774861,
-0.4985137284,
-0.8725355268,
0.0735164508,
-1.1330835819,
0.142863363,
-0.5016915202,
-0.2204079926,
-0.1299828142,
-0.1903569996,
-0.6863512993,
0.2222892344,
0.0293361489,
0.8402493,
-0.5795958638,
0.4290649593,
0.6266770363,
-0.1814523041,
-0.7221072316,
-0.0819396004,
0.303052932,
-0.4752985835,
0.4208178222,
0.1160224825,
-0.1222709641,
-0.2100181431,
0.1459663659,
-0.3959024847,
1.2880618572,
0.0339875631,
-0.6532589793,
0.0377807394,
0.0738110542,
0.8122724891,
-0.468178153,
0.898532331,
0.6213821173,
0.1169733033,
-0.2144027352,
-1.2192239761,
0.0697210133,
-0.2899881005,
-0.2338680625,
0.1672780067,
-0.7367183566,
0.7881107926,
-0.3939704299,
-0.1974724233,
0.3896694779,
0.1937926561,
0.6185976267,
0.4859229624,
0.1110945195,
0.6084079742,
0.8899159431,
-0.1662382334,
1.0402710438,
-0.3138425052,
0.2625855505,
1.2601069212,
-0.6031301022,
1.0839465857,
0.2778309584,
-0.2810384035,
0.4002812505,
0.3939146996,
0.2462962717,
0.2894857526,
0.256280452,
-0.5086385012,
-0.2051443607,
-0.1662557423,
-0.6261183619,
0.2940577567,
0.314598918,
-0.54493922,
-0.0639188588,
-0.294159621,
-0.0326659307,
0.0593534894,
-0.1267406195,
0.9710003138,
0.2650664747,
-0.7870568633,
0.5963070989,
-0.1095345244,
0.2633976638,
-0.6242210865,
-0.3725594282,
-0.3389235735,
0.0632382855,
-0.2486366928,
-0.5743138194,
-0.0610042885,
0.3690278232,
0.025551945,
-0.0032469507,
0.172418341,
-0.2653191984,
-0.3423032761,
0.2079194933,
0.7692143917,
0.1993309259,
-0.0334419869,
-0.5970223546,
-0.156006068,
-0.3584517539,
-0.0611225106,
0.3159381449,
0.4975053668,
0.087288402,
0.7936943769,
0.3980197608,
0.5694684982,
0.0296196528,
0.3603810072,
0.8939569592,
-0.5918354392,
-0.4357475638,
-0.8001891375,
0.409816891,
-0.2055530101,
-0.7497599721,
0.5149630308,
0.7629377842,
0.4770320058,
0.151204586,
0.7940143347,
0.2834265232,
0.8987908959,
-0.7661392093,
0.7182505131,
-0.5541859269,
0.3831083179,
-0.1510679573,
-0.6730638146,
-0.0272031184,
0.3830869198,
-0.2120400965,
0.1993427426,
0.7847040296,
0.5946047902,
0.032190267,
-0.0905340984,
0.5193862319,
0.2622407079,
0.4102163613,
0.7012273073,
0.932685256,
-0.4375360906,
0.2573233247,
-0.2530235052,
-0.3290809393,
-0.2883143723,
-0.650888741,
-0.8964084387,
-0.2565667629,
-0.2420506328,
-0.2169580758,
0.2533403635,
1.1323214769,
0.701898396,
-0.7844138741,
-0.162216723,
0.2693634927,
-0.1806130409,
-0.283521384,
-0.1391972303,
0.4061667621,
0.0255975202,
-0.5181446075,
0.0385806374,
0.3484404981,
-0.1746491492,
-0.2246706784,
-0.1990814954,
0.2199258506,
-0.1837586761,
0.3869718611,
0.2276031673,
-0.8156875372,
0.2870054543,
0.0267794151,
-0.4118390977,
0.1089923009,
0.7864533067,
-0.5576413274,
0.6538398862,
0.365537405,
0.6756581068,
0.4059018195,
0.2829332352,
0.4949584603,
-0.2489636242,
-0.481869638,
0.5495809913,
0.4305902123,
0.0355536416,
-0.2880004942,
0.2321804613,
-0.1554121524,
-0.5824061036,
-0.7283393145,
0.0727009103,
-0.8862621188,
0.2252284139,
1.2430189848,
-0.4878304899,
0.1510737985,
-0.5304126143,
-0.1910336763,
-0.0545257106,
-0.4754961431,
0.8816127777,
0.5178408027,
-0.2246305794,
-0.3536838591,
-1.0728420019,
0.5636435151,
0.4653775096,
-1.0711836815,
-0.073503308,
0.5481210351,
0.2161811441,
-0.2029688507,
0.8326428533,
-0.2274478972,
0.6829033494,
-0.2802821696,
-0.2956666946,
0.1198445037,
-0.3166436553,
-0.4567835033,
0.2247694582,
0.001526091,
0.0824033096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16039v1
|
Understanding Public Perceptions of AI Conversational Agents: A Cross-Cultural Analysis
| 2024-02-25T09:34:22 | 2024-02-25T09:34:22 |
Zihan Liu, Han Li, Anfan Chen, Renwen Zhang, Yi-Chieh Lee
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, H.5.2
|
Conversational Agents (CAs) have increasingly been integrated into everyday
life, sparking significant discussions on social media. While previous research
has examined public perceptions of AI in general, there is a notable lack in
research focused on CAs, with fewer investigations into cultural variations in
CA perceptions. To address this gap, this study used computational methods to
analyze about one million social media discussions surrounding CAs and compared
people's discourses and perceptions of CAs in the US and China. We find Chinese
participants tended to view CAs hedonically, perceived voice-based and
physically embodied CAs as warmer and more competent, and generally expressed
positive emotions. In contrast, US participants saw CAs more functionally, with
an ambivalent attitude. Warm perception was a key driver of positive emotions
toward CAs in both countries. We discussed practical implications for designing
contextually sensitive and user-centric CAs to resonate with various users'
preferences and needs.
|
[
-0.4595089853,
-0.5703530312,
0.2142968178,
0.4697526991,
-0.1712115854,
0.4343460202,
-0.2726240158,
-0.9389169216,
0.4916712642,
0.0638038293,
-0.2715760171,
-0.466724664,
-0.2491391748,
0.0239691641,
-0.0899588987,
0.8179863095,
0.2686212659,
0.0955398008,
0.0464017205,
-0.1464964449,
-0.0250423644,
-0.8002656698,
-0.727383554,
-0.5825066566,
0.6534677744,
0.0313218869,
1.2201490402,
0.0064962767,
0.2487105876,
0.2628739476,
0.1185185313,
-0.1175146401,
-0.3800610304,
-0.1026415601,
-0.0236592665,
-0.4530532956,
-0.3282412589,
0.1554181129,
0.063232787,
0.4220323563,
-0.0247265603,
0.011542487,
-0.022542892,
0.3749442995,
-0.6339056492,
0.2261008322,
-0.3712658584,
0.4110382795,
0.0629742742,
-0.116440326,
-0.3089975417,
-0.2801650763,
0.5703970194,
-0.7046368122,
0.024376044,
-0.3604206443,
0.9053428173,
0.2086727172,
-0.8505696058,
-0.2883270383,
-1.0964193344,
0.7748296261,
-0.428779006,
0.212128073,
0.3797132969,
0.3625259101,
0.0879362524,
-0.4355017841,
-0.7879890203,
-0.3736539185,
-0.0887822136,
0.3674333096,
-0.3377538323,
0.0153274545,
0.1248695254,
0.0178688932,
-0.6278712749,
-0.0432271212,
-0.3606348336,
-0.3645303249,
1.074441433,
0.1462771744,
0.9036359191,
0.1101078093,
-0.2303530574,
-0.1621359289,
-0.441280961,
0.5729310513,
0.1807366014,
0.3124326468,
-0.6482913494,
-0.0556333102,
-0.19015719,
0.2594929039,
-0.2059104592,
-0.0566095449,
0.2593303919,
-0.09588404,
-0.22337313,
0.1097355634,
0.693578124,
0.558942616,
0.6794532537,
-0.005903488,
0.1933290064,
0.1952500492,
0.481348753,
-0.8217198849,
-0.0733902231,
0.1528029144,
-0.8137648106,
-0.052641239,
0.5008243322,
-0.4652424753,
-0.8155223131,
-0.3641086519,
0.0130177811,
0.2569241226,
-0.4828299582,
-0.260795027,
-0.0691919252,
0.5783641934,
0.4271433353,
-0.5672662854,
0.2437016666,
0.6800733209,
0.835980773,
-0.2248593569,
-0.2482132763,
0.1862231791,
-0.2527252436,
-0.4100165665,
0.6459743977,
-0.6333732009,
-0.6216545105,
0.1241561323,
-0.0554195791,
-0.0257911626,
-0.2247520685,
0.1461461633,
-0.5571106076,
0.1495095491,
-0.7984324694,
0.3902744353,
-0.0814705119,
0.4636373818,
-0.490287751,
0.4135097861,
-0.2136592418,
-0.6184231639,
0.5025082231,
-0.7606781125,
-0.7444785237,
-0.0617278293,
-0.3623036146,
0.1543304473,
-0.0720639899,
0.3621040285,
0.4224677384,
-0.4291184247,
-0.0389850438,
-0.3278396726,
-0.6706164479,
0.6453282237,
-0.6387954354,
1.0641510487,
0.7209268808,
-0.5302267075,
0.1136629879,
-0.1835789829,
-0.2829875052,
0.114219524,
0.0360609405,
-0.3635867834,
0.0976794511,
-0.1236491948,
0.3525813222,
0.227497831,
-0.7019069195,
-0.101672627,
-0.4614931345,
0.6528596282,
0.5106885433,
0.0088108275,
0.247557044,
-0.464374274,
0.6027974486,
0.2030334324,
0.4944922626,
0.0407954678,
-0.531965971,
-0.5380583405,
0.1948500276,
-0.554900527,
0.5053130984,
-0.7016999722,
-0.1206346899,
-0.0535496436,
-0.8791377544,
-0.5331709385,
-0.2438149005,
0.2057644725,
0.2406222969,
0.0155546591,
-0.1860114038,
0.1213948652,
-0.8728215098,
-0.0798184127,
-0.7633505464,
-0.0036364542,
0.9093778133,
0.2067715675,
-0.2384287268,
0.943787992,
-0.4237108529,
0.0373474322,
-0.2589462698,
0.2492946684,
-0.295540899,
0.115630962,
0.6687610149,
-1.1094089746,
-0.9036598802,
0.3203570843,
-0.8449403644,
0.0229095295,
-0.3083133101,
0.0649530739,
0.4811431468,
0.2009595037,
-0.4511986673,
0.8034614325,
0.4303643703,
-0.0358015932,
0.3469951749,
0.1484254003,
0.6781092882,
-1.0405195951,
0.1314051002,
0.21322909,
0.3746842146,
-0.8955840468,
-0.1360971779,
-0.2429594994,
-0.4145118594,
-0.8677744865,
0.5869838595,
-0.2555517256,
-0.3435725272,
-0.3597118855,
0.1256421059,
-0.0035839332,
0.524641633,
0.2894036472,
1.0003476143,
0.6306901574,
-0.5204380155,
0.4892118871,
0.0732119009,
-0.1641514003,
0.4850601554,
-0.9419203401,
0.2491560429,
-0.0938065723,
0.750077188,
-0.9009609818,
-0.1951458603,
0.3612781167,
-0.6351078153,
-0.484041065,
0.4879615307,
-0.0701752454,
-0.3455715179,
-0.2720156014,
0.5572495461,
0.3664647639,
-0.4770246744,
0.6524555683,
0.4200291336,
-0.2088042051,
-0.6211779118,
-0.9104219079,
0.3279499412,
-0.1894138306,
-0.81004107,
0.2319205403,
0.0713352934,
-0.8829908967,
-0.3918034732,
0.1929172575,
-0.23360008,
0.3629950583,
0.404843688,
0.0266031865,
-0.1531787515,
0.0099215601,
-0.2296226174,
-0.0722873583,
0.2869897783,
0.2938055694,
0.421330303,
-0.3110226095,
-0.7252613902,
-0.9972428679,
0.280703336,
0.7256013751,
-0.257409215,
0.5964394212,
0.6934623718,
-0.4645268619,
-0.0845272541,
-0.3199749887,
-0.3253905475,
-0.4871828556,
0.0790783688,
-0.0699030757,
-0.5664535761,
0.7871568203,
0.482932657,
0.2221490145,
0.0239161402,
0.7344575524,
-0.0029946237,
1.3457950354,
0.4973709881,
-0.6444302201,
0.5025421977,
0.1171000749,
0.289934814,
-0.2561091781,
-0.1018457636,
-0.6739199162,
-0.5553657413,
-0.5943126678,
0.0012940407,
0.4027151465,
-0.7987247705,
-0.309184581,
0.0588270612,
-0.5590769053,
0.3282284439,
0.4514063895,
-0.0081421286,
-0.063263528,
-0.225693956,
0.3615720272,
0.1597312093,
-0.2433801591,
-0.6161498427,
0.6049280167,
0.4105220735,
0.7399098277,
0.2085407376,
0.3428260088,
0.6697931886,
0.3234995902,
-0.6818020344,
0.5561427474,
0.0006164467,
-0.68466115,
-0.3077894151,
-0.1085752696,
-1.1126234531,
0.1799443811,
-0.1718800962,
-0.9454609752,
0.1835917234,
-0.0940585211,
-0.530068934,
0.0075538675,
-0.6610311866,
0.7039209008,
-0.375741154,
-0.1498378962,
-0.4607255161,
-0.8317227364,
0.1986527592,
0.3060177863,
0.1230062172,
-0.0902606547,
0.2693618834,
0.3128628433,
-0.208996594,
1.1629645824,
-0.2707312405,
-0.2039037645,
0.5838327408,
-0.1047383621,
0.1522670239,
-0.0482379347,
-0.2469023168,
0.3732577562,
-0.0134275798,
-0.6149513721,
-0.7784619927,
0.5394743085,
-1.4017742872,
-0.7508034706,
-0.3847117126,
-0.4850536287,
-0.0292735118,
-0.2238128781,
0.0489078909,
0.2816085517,
-0.5533592105,
0.1289134026,
0.1867409199,
-0.6567741632,
0.3425013423,
0.5166658759,
0.0947657079,
0.1130944416,
0.9792485237,
0.1090225056,
0.3258971274,
0.3373053372,
0.2650505304,
0.0761866942,
0.0632381514,
-0.3015173376,
-0.0151369115,
-0.5662515163,
0.4617063403,
-0.432731241,
-0.3585623205,
-0.640863359,
-0.4671430886,
-0.1938125044,
-0.0168430749,
-0.4183234274,
0.0173413735,
-0.036513254,
0.7707759142,
0.0696928948,
0.4930648506,
-0.4715960622,
0.0342573412,
0.4611648619,
0.0327791013,
0.3128706813,
-0.1316671371,
-0.3292972445,
0.2778716981,
-0.3658362627,
-0.8376879096,
0.3525990248,
-0.0503212959,
0.5076011419,
1.0016974211,
0.4238450229,
0.7775706649,
0.2571438551,
1.5198346376,
-0.2819663286,
-0.8003723025,
0.3490726948,
-0.3325854242,
0.2282180637,
0.2976993024,
0.4824578166,
-0.8392080665,
-0.3663786948,
-0.4103922248,
-0.4867421091,
0.6818504333,
0.0725553706,
0.7428872585,
0.1087970957,
0.0728470534,
0.0590125769,
0.0896467865,
-0.7921693325,
-0.4761077166,
-0.4864948988,
0.1229648814,
-0.1864451766,
0.1130349562,
-0.1435379833,
0.229896009,
0.4513796866,
-0.0126301898,
0.3082536459,
0.1751294136,
-0.0064499187,
-0.1974917352,
0.2054991573,
0.7933091521,
0.5723386407,
-0.076043196,
0.094270438,
0.096489884,
-0.4063925147,
-0.0874671862,
-0.1859508008,
-0.1247615442,
-0.3716977239,
0.4426496923,
0.6129075885,
-0.2218635976,
-0.553637445,
0.578076601,
-0.2807729244,
0.0051542991,
-0.3626592159,
0.0818544328,
0.0155285047,
0.3508753181,
0.5049261451,
-0.1018185392,
0.3333029151,
-0.9716767073,
-0.0801277757,
0.7004974484,
-0.5985688567,
-0.7164462805,
0.5734889507,
0.7531725168,
-0.5476692915,
0.3896327317,
-0.0829616636,
-0.6836645603,
0.7368099689,
0.4775396287,
1.0381108522,
0.0882573426,
0.4656287432,
-0.051380977,
0.2773069441,
0.3294023275,
0.0659970492,
-0.5251660943,
-1.128606081,
0.2562074363,
0.051495675,
-0.7453029156,
-0.1494727284,
-0.6718551517,
0.0899341553,
-0.5192207098,
-0.4523727298,
-0.0947507322,
0.2030731142,
-0.7646557689,
0.3055049777,
0.4982810915,
0.5919630527,
-0.9578180909,
0.7270503044,
0.9612929821,
-0.5268680453,
-0.6442196369,
0.3891432583,
0.3743569851,
-0.9270795584,
0.5776380301,
0.2341178507,
-0.2808894217,
-0.5594560504,
-0.7137708068,
-0.6098585725,
1.1840516329,
0.1272508651,
0.0965583771,
0.186145559,
0.5129299164,
0.942312181,
-0.4281577766,
0.6486170888,
0.5327433944,
0.3405216932,
0.1227798834,
-1.0584858656,
-0.1175462753,
-0.6704850793,
-0.130735442,
-0.208604902,
-1.3170872927,
0.8131796122,
0.0886303708,
-0.4404521286,
-0.2518146038,
0.6121513844,
0.1600022912,
1.0657262802,
0.5017734766,
-0.2958861589,
0.5825256109,
0.2345559746,
0.7894836664,
-0.5276809931,
-0.3631640673,
0.4987390935,
-0.7944378853,
0.4030256271,
0.0935004205,
-0.0869197771,
0.7688942552,
0.6302945018,
0.3043876588,
0.0171001013,
0.0834163129,
-0.4055573642,
-0.081640698,
-0.654694438,
-0.4467828274,
0.6759042144,
0.3188981116,
-0.1083417237,
0.0345037393,
0.2179147303,
0.1320538968,
0.1636449099,
-0.1866065562,
0.9647657871,
0.0311227888,
-0.735788703,
0.1174604967,
-0.0763837844,
0.5949755311,
-0.3484652638,
0.1040065512,
-0.3362748027,
-0.2535915971,
-0.3017084002,
-0.5997635126,
0.2489111722,
0.1845592856,
0.0956365094,
-0.2307352573,
0.8325503469,
0.0257896781,
-0.0907430574,
0.3869485855,
0.3688049018,
0.7193821669,
-0.1469989419,
-0.9587020278,
0.2349782139,
0.1453896463,
-0.3714921474,
0.2324122638,
0.4145111442,
-0.4547175467,
0.8780517578,
0.5931861401,
-0.0324125737,
-0.4618334174,
0.2023812085,
0.7694122195,
-0.6920351386,
-0.6337526441,
-0.7291264534,
0.5616625547,
-0.0152490744,
-0.5411192179,
0.5710459948,
0.0567979962,
0.5935846567,
0.3448185027,
1.0657963753,
-0.0093278419,
0.0824721307,
0.054724168,
1.0286016464,
-0.4594616592,
0.1875658035,
-0.4433530867,
-0.7857592702,
-0.1078681722,
0.5672599673,
-0.5424257517,
0.2512226105,
0.0665018633,
0.8861727715,
0.2806760669,
0.4915846884,
0.3794513643,
0.0885699764,
0.6779394746,
0.3753653765,
0.9996046424,
0.0532836467,
0.4157342613,
-0.3134577572,
-0.2588201761,
-0.1106005087,
-0.5739521384,
-1.0480765104,
-0.582737267,
-0.1082405299,
-0.1830336452,
-0.1652325094,
1.4357124567,
0.6530322433,
-0.8396221995,
-0.4618532658,
0.4631768763,
0.1862289608,
-0.0419384539,
-0.3175008893,
0.3166965246,
-0.0064218794,
-0.7951155305,
0.0693175346,
0.136567235,
0.0802960172,
-0.6524328589,
-0.2166307867,
0.2847515345,
0.4538896978,
0.6569030881,
0.5988634229,
-0.8580565453,
-0.488735348,
0.2757567167,
-0.4083434343,
-0.0250977036,
0.7125941515,
-0.6711268425,
0.5324428082,
0.3765348196,
0.533787787,
0.1156142205,
0.6023362279,
0.8628976345,
-0.3515447974,
0.2887493372,
0.10349188,
-0.0216969997,
0.288223356,
-0.4914931357,
0.2428738028,
0.1656188369,
-0.7185243368,
-0.6739049554,
0.1439159513,
-0.9564585686,
-0.4116243124,
1.1322643757,
-0.1810998321,
0.0620390885,
-0.2712913752,
-0.466142416,
0.2853438258,
-0.8043833375,
1.1319237947,
0.6778927445,
-0.2823322415,
0.1976969689,
-0.2297776937,
0.3821825385,
0.2823005021,
-0.8039494157,
-0.0472444296,
0.3460291624,
-0.3382749259,
0.3609200716,
0.6411857605,
0.369120717,
0.4445723593,
-0.0131930402,
0.0544579141,
0.0484197028,
-0.3859855533,
-0.090023078,
0.0319142789,
-0.104911916,
0.0271407422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16038v1
|
Deep Learning Approaches for Improving Question Answering Systems in Hepatocellular Carcinoma Research
| 2024-02-25T09:32:17 | 2024-02-25T09:32:17 |
Shuning Huo, Yafei Xiang, Hanyi Yu, Mengran Zhu, Yulu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In recent years, advancements in natural language processing (NLP) have been
fueled by deep learning techniques, particularly through the utilization of
powerful computing resources like GPUs and TPUs. Models such as BERT and GPT-3,
trained on vast amounts of data, have revolutionized language understanding and
generation. These pre-trained models serve as robust bases for various tasks
including semantic understanding, intelligent writing, and reasoning, paving
the way for a more generalized form of artificial intelligence. NLP, as a vital
application of AI, aims to bridge the gap between humans and computers through
natural language interaction. This paper delves into the current landscape and
future prospects of large-scale model-based NLP, focusing on the
question-answering systems within this domain. Practical cases and developments
in artificial intelligence-driven question-answering systems are analyzed to
foster further exploration and research in the realm of large-scale NLP.
|
[
-0.4478622079,
-0.8521051407,
0.8366789222,
-0.0966614559,
-0.0302833915,
0.3114742935,
-0.1444226503,
-0.5732029676,
-0.2528907061,
0.6560630798,
-0.5729173422,
-0.3179694116,
-0.5073829293,
0.1009797528,
-0.5731601715,
0.9066841602,
0.2961652875,
0.4258372486,
-0.3215667307,
0.0071690315,
-0.3841334879,
-0.5724713206,
-0.8161630034,
-0.4732592404,
0.7617871761,
0.3521255255,
0.9190167785,
0.2764422297,
0.6989455819,
0.2318369299,
-0.3126829863,
-0.1313001961,
0.0013555817,
0.290001303,
-0.1366508752,
-0.2762362063,
-0.1646280736,
-0.1859851182,
0.5299308896,
1.1662400961,
-0.268042177,
-0.3599219024,
-0.0692879334,
0.7133632898,
-0.3787538111,
-0.0432116799,
-0.6292775273,
0.2175983042,
0.1331888735,
-0.2269678414,
-0.3024334908,
-0.6307333708,
0.4608210623,
-0.4210013449,
0.1206958592,
-0.1469712853,
0.724180758,
0.4173547626,
-0.2949363589,
-0.4732703567,
-0.6790043712,
0.4827913046,
-1.216390729,
0.1660235971,
0.3048358858,
0.6277498603,
-0.3017689586,
-0.750007093,
-0.3192830086,
-0.3701417744,
-0.0694987476,
-0.1359375119,
0.1835498512,
0.3308099806,
0.1465768367,
0.5538779497,
-0.7203058004,
0.2636625171,
-0.383864969,
0.1241761446,
0.6503520012,
0.2584831417,
0.4577822983,
0.0402825586,
-0.1632922292,
0.0864203721,
-0.7882295251,
-0.1884012967,
-0.0534299649,
0.3766218722,
0.3665004671,
0.5896535516,
-0.4458182156,
0.7893080711,
-0.3311721981,
0.3956490457,
-0.1072774231,
-0.1823831201,
-0.6272216439,
0.0393345915,
0.5848605633,
-0.0946492478,
0.3257930875,
-0.2774341106,
0.3008157909,
-0.1385234594,
0.4832932651,
-0.842663765,
-0.1388177127,
0.5377011895,
-0.5133299232,
-0.2291245162,
-0.3656401336,
-0.7918716073,
-0.522492528,
-0.1391848624,
0.4242870212,
-0.3763471246,
-0.1762267947,
0.4980989993,
-0.1397339255,
0.4694351852,
0.3556546271,
-0.7873952985,
0.3715117574,
0.6278033853,
0.2604374886,
0.0161459763,
-0.0837316066,
-0.5517534018,
0.140032813,
-0.4580578804,
0.7162872553,
-0.6692669392,
-0.2087277174,
0.2211693376,
-0.0845557973,
-0.1448028982,
-0.5750418305,
0.4706394076,
-0.7992743254,
0.4395205379,
-0.3664431274,
-0.9159373641,
-0.1732083261,
0.341637373,
-0.5899407864,
0.6896187067,
-0.0779309273,
-0.60362643,
0.1051998511,
-0.9564759135,
-0.4824178815,
0.3730778396,
-0.0242598876,
-0.2339840531,
0.1694807559,
0.4022916257,
0.6748729348,
-0.4471447468,
0.4331379533,
-0.1351465285,
-0.2901785076,
0.1600445956,
-0.2705536485,
0.9843987823,
0.5193588138,
-0.4651809335,
0.1019761562,
-0.4859966338,
0.2068984807,
0.0402146876,
-0.4712331295,
-0.1420043856,
0.1736867726,
-0.3496165574,
0.1548139006,
0.2446149588,
-0.6156054139,
0.3355918527,
-0.602373898,
0.4993415177,
0.2240727991,
0.043159347,
0.1371808648,
-0.0057528405,
0.4154261947,
-0.2128254622,
0.1913825125,
-0.1231902763,
-0.7547097802,
-0.5605147481,
0.4611286521,
0.1999772787,
0.7066991925,
-0.9815366864,
0.2076784968,
-0.0850819349,
-0.4291901886,
-0.4064714313,
-0.0782747567,
0.1130783781,
0.4779511988,
0.6878359914,
-0.070748046,
-0.29308635,
-0.9825018048,
-0.3143303394,
-0.3083382845,
-0.2548215985,
0.4743222296,
0.3398361504,
-0.1013846919,
0.6271659136,
-0.745912075,
-0.2988918722,
-0.3993064761,
0.1362309903,
0.193041414,
0.3697793484,
0.1879985183,
-0.8181615472,
-0.51149863,
0.2083887607,
-0.7655363083,
0.0665188655,
-0.0833074749,
0.1595416516,
-0.0472740009,
0.7477698326,
-0.5924478173,
0.5578911304,
0.3423776031,
-0.316513747,
0.2785508037,
-0.4019107819,
0.3404811323,
-0.9062345624,
0.136669144,
-0.1837492734,
-0.124721393,
-1.0088255405,
0.1177094206,
-0.2258985341,
-0.0290388353,
-0.3564360738,
0.302313298,
-0.3204094768,
-0.2979090214,
-0.4581362307,
-0.1891883165,
-0.0043576751,
0.4014063776,
0.3378023803,
0.7161304355,
0.2854442,
-0.3796036541,
0.2116995007,
0.385196954,
-0.4803251028,
0.2072884142,
-0.8106470108,
0.090181075,
-0.0172653813,
0.2149969786,
-0.9597459435,
-0.1984741092,
-0.0921810567,
-0.6881682277,
0.2964792848,
0.2294477075,
-0.5288019776,
-0.7007356882,
0.0380514823,
0.2525200248,
0.4410944581,
-0.2825956345,
0.2891944945,
0.2702732682,
-0.6182442904,
-0.6149469614,
-0.7141426206,
0.5122081041,
0.1234202832,
-0.3444286883,
0.132853508,
-0.1924011707,
-0.1633370519,
-0.2065164,
0.3426560163,
-0.491229564,
0.3297256827,
-0.2627060711,
-0.0883196592,
-0.2859993279,
0.3683549166,
0.2095086426,
0.2251600772,
0.2297905236,
-0.1349449307,
0.6996687055,
-0.2892225981,
-0.345448643,
-0.6422924995,
0.7421426773,
0.5726474524,
-0.3005526066,
0.6378980875,
0.7102540135,
-0.5891087055,
0.2638078034,
-0.506533742,
-0.3590799272,
-0.3600748479,
0.3634219468,
-0.0340607017,
-1.1169543266,
0.2700788379,
-0.0178176034,
0.1879524589,
0.5956897736,
0.9097175598,
-0.2932545245,
1.1162661314,
0.7082903385,
-0.1635848433,
0.2091860622,
-0.0271297935,
0.2366710156,
-0.6992914081,
-0.1114438996,
-0.9592601061,
-0.1361719072,
-0.6517922282,
-0.3942211866,
0.3651251495,
-0.2618461251,
-0.4060559869,
0.2288483083,
-0.7374405861,
0.2273568809,
0.5674289465,
0.1442297995,
0.3062039316,
-0.2435531616,
0.0539191626,
0.240720883,
-0.8579119444,
-0.236355111,
1.0973751545,
0.6175029278,
0.5568169951,
-0.1145119146,
0.44081074,
0.2114364058,
0.2769144475,
-0.5224443078,
0.3734425008,
-0.2977388203,
-1.0827767849,
-0.6629816294,
-0.2321537137,
-0.9912375212,
-0.0318391882,
-0.1054350957,
-0.6218987703,
0.3030810654,
-0.0772176534,
-0.6662540436,
0.6631895304,
-0.3306405842,
0.6774790287,
-0.2067639232,
-0.191946283,
-0.1362596452,
-1.144852519,
0.0678333342,
0.4904316068,
-0.0631817803,
0.0609816946,
0.0095751034,
0.5960063934,
-0.3358921111,
0.7687602639,
-0.406042397,
-0.3297229707,
0.3014369607,
-0.1636422127,
0.2647319734,
0.1656156331,
-0.2823288441,
0.0096431505,
0.0461192392,
-0.5752915144,
-0.1529814452,
0.5612088442,
-0.6158793569,
-0.5839841366,
-0.1235527843,
-0.6563570499,
-0.5092993379,
0.1007109508,
0.1458305717,
0.1021841243,
-0.0179124139,
0.4719859958,
1.0328155756,
-0.7424149513,
0.5694059134,
-0.1292684525,
-0.0056161964,
-0.2692885101,
0.7128126025,
-0.4008017182,
0.335926652,
0.5859314799,
0.2415173203,
-0.2150344104,
-0.9024326801,
-0.5867192149,
-0.1518078893,
-0.4732767344,
-0.2334279269,
-0.9182883501,
-0.6130337119,
-0.3844901025,
-0.2588821054,
-0.2569274604,
-0.1914613694,
-0.4147695899,
-0.0290635154,
0.2680517733,
0.6769138575,
0.0660360008,
0.3258055747,
-0.8254855871,
0.3714511693,
0.6908133626,
0.4397444725,
-0.0176842585,
-0.2494900525,
-0.1916579306,
0.1511760056,
0.0123621579,
-0.776597321,
0.5395860076,
0.3562915921,
0.437432766,
0.0264615025,
-0.3255119026,
0.2858979106,
-0.2427208126,
0.9143058658,
0.0490352288,
-0.5137683749,
0.6635586023,
-0.6822923422,
0.585783422,
0.8991333842,
0.4511909783,
-0.6445018053,
-0.3222535551,
-0.5174977183,
-0.6734431386,
0.4399949908,
0.1474499255,
0.1186833382,
0.0975351036,
0.6532616615,
0.2998414338,
0.5747061372,
-0.5882224441,
-0.0764508173,
-0.1621899903,
-0.1352003366,
-0.1447256207,
-0.2352516353,
-0.1009419262,
-0.4315314591,
0.5369980335,
-0.5652300715,
0.4640930891,
0.3776544929,
0.0271312874,
-0.0790111199,
0.544483006,
0.5704380274,
0.4494455159,
-0.3436762691,
-0.2398497313,
0.368613869,
-0.449110955,
-0.0191257335,
0.1280596107,
-0.0732605681,
-0.2018560022,
0.3688385785,
0.4973062873,
-0.3616033792,
-0.8095484972,
0.5295817852,
-0.3328350186,
-0.3669998348,
-0.2842604518,
-0.0529606268,
0.4189216495,
0.242222175,
0.6607501507,
-0.0921823159,
0.5184283257,
-0.6146284342,
0.1654531509,
0.5191250443,
-0.895419538,
0.1320422292,
0.6284894943,
-0.0597318634,
-0.1391215175,
0.8460788131,
0.3767504394,
-0.482870698,
0.921235621,
0.2887588739,
0.8194352984,
-0.2634118497,
0.2548066676,
0.3156601489,
0.3296500444,
0.0975758955,
0.4940096736,
-0.030281214,
-0.4185522795,
-0.553848207,
-0.6071925163,
-0.554415226,
0.4142220914,
-0.458086282,
-0.1849907786,
-0.6663794518,
0.296980679,
0.1986563802,
0.3433762491,
-0.5752427578,
0.7476553917,
0.4880030453,
1.0150729418,
-0.6763406992,
0.9989278316,
0.670378387,
-0.1835324764,
-0.4691806138,
-0.0041674143,
-0.4129781425,
-0.4911285639,
0.4845491648,
0.1903930455,
0.2114888579,
0.0155954035,
-0.8482715487,
-0.7597765923,
0.9037377834,
0.0662879944,
-0.4703652263,
-0.2793063223,
0.3503113091,
0.9738476872,
-0.3787057102,
0.1066366658,
0.7423891425,
0.6811445951,
0.0513681956,
-0.8814445734,
-0.2143039405,
-0.0840745345,
-0.0700409785,
-0.076525338,
-0.2940709591,
0.7990989685,
-0.3823436201,
0.1339372396,
0.4898543954,
0.5853842497,
-0.1415866464,
0.1509501487,
0.234873116,
0.6813473105,
0.5536367297,
-0.1561357826,
1.0328400135,
0.1946988851,
0.1106162518,
0.7463417053,
-0.1765067726,
0.8319242001,
0.4453663826,
-0.2397557199,
0.6184154749,
0.6785314679,
0.0813625753,
0.3844522238,
0.3041259944,
-0.1611054093,
-0.5409958363,
-0.0117904693,
-0.5342392921,
0.2200179249,
0.726667285,
-0.330041945,
-0.1987857968,
0.0211210102,
-0.1482436508,
0.150432229,
-0.2307510823,
1.2448321581,
0.0275805295,
-0.6746501327,
0.6068913341,
-0.3135353923,
0.5625227094,
-0.4062527716,
-0.0761106834,
-0.2342684567,
-0.0256105457,
-0.2106827646,
-0.9922488928,
0.50879848,
-0.2151665837,
0.025593739,
0.0756695792,
0.7484619617,
-0.3050761521,
-0.4348339736,
0.3351505399,
0.5913171172,
0.0319933333,
-0.2121733427,
-0.7389165759,
-0.2038968205,
0.0302518066,
-0.3420040309,
0.3010990024,
0.0408867598,
0.0725531355,
0.9113094807,
0.5594712496,
0.0029173179,
-0.1048451886,
0.0670871809,
0.966899693,
-0.8799874187,
-0.1333799213,
-0.5744674206,
0.2368981093,
-0.1621144414,
-0.2498667836,
0.1317808628,
0.2927488685,
0.4602062702,
0.0962388664,
0.9099097252,
-0.1123368964,
0.7266862392,
-0.3089379668,
0.8854638934,
-0.7143410444,
0.29930529,
-0.2213183641,
-0.653292954,
-0.8008731008,
0.1659427583,
-0.445790261,
0.1367080808,
0.7251639366,
0.45839715,
0.3704423308,
0.3004267812,
0.4004410207,
0.4044637382,
0.5789787173,
0.8288484216,
0.69389081,
-0.5871605873,
0.4854249358,
-0.2233872861,
-0.0308028013,
-0.4482554197,
-0.6347072124,
-0.7682074308,
-0.781247437,
-0.0733329207,
-0.0265461877,
0.2522911429,
0.5954836607,
0.6568369865,
-0.948330462,
-0.21521689,
-0.3139177263,
0.2167734206,
-0.1255817413,
-0.15003483,
0.4713716507,
-0.5149864554,
-0.6061832905,
0.519097805,
0.3382788599,
-0.1233972535,
-0.4177426994,
0.1692704409,
-0.7174042463,
0.1388624012,
0.7103421092,
0.5436954498,
-0.3969244659,
-0.0846956074,
0.2784573138,
-0.2042935789,
0.198438108,
0.6427704096,
-1.0426180363,
0.1338489205,
0.5748028159,
1.1361864805,
0.3548309505,
-0.1618264318,
0.6859343052,
-0.2490706295,
-0.3143084645,
0.7482770085,
0.03615674,
0.5210369229,
-0.6429826617,
0.3988812864,
-0.2196644545,
-0.8090071678,
-0.5956206918,
0.1537073106,
-0.8773987293,
-0.922960937,
0.8964252472,
0.0267399419,
-0.0587868914,
-0.4138534665,
-0.2067087889,
0.072514385,
-0.1360724121,
0.9512737989,
0.403055191,
-0.3194518387,
-0.1894348562,
-0.857891202,
0.8335396647,
0.6451833844,
-1.4042556286,
0.1241088063,
0.4014993906,
-0.0191274714,
-0.0114501454,
0.440602541,
-0.2791711688,
0.5798369646,
-0.4142377079,
0.1630651951,
0.4082556665,
-0.404723376,
-0.3128628135,
0.5675035715,
0.1741365641,
0.186754927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16035v1
|
Text Understanding and Generation Using Transformer Models for Intelligent E-commerce Recommendations
| 2024-02-25T09:19:11 | 2024-02-25T09:19:11 |
Yafei Xiang, Hanyi Yu, Yulu Gong, Shuning Huo, Mengran Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid development of artificial intelligence technology, Transformer
structural pre-training model has become an important tool for large language
model (LLM) tasks. In the field of e-commerce, these models are especially
widely used, from text understanding to generating recommendation systems,
which provide powerful technical support for improving user experience and
optimizing service processes. This paper reviews the core application scenarios
of Transformer pre-training model in e-commerce text understanding and
recommendation generation, including but not limited to automatic generation of
product descriptions, sentiment analysis of user comments, construction of
personalized recommendation system and automated processing of customer service
conversations. Through a detailed analysis of the model's working principle,
implementation process, and application effects in specific cases, this paper
emphasizes the unique advantages of pre-trained models in understanding complex
user intentions and improving the quality of recommendations. In addition, the
challenges and improvement directions for the future are also discussed, such
as how to further improve the generalization ability of the model, the ability
to handle large-scale data sets, and technical strategies to protect user
privacy. Ultimately, the paper points out that the application of Transformer
structural pre-training models in e-commerce has not only driven technological
innovation, but also brought substantial benefits to merchants and consumers,
and looking forward, these models will continue to play a key role in
e-commerce and beyond.
|
[
-0.4536409676,
-0.7235460877,
0.490097791,
0.1714892238,
-0.3056180179,
-0.1789423078,
-0.1192682087,
-0.7138023973,
-0.1239968687,
0.6967508793,
-0.7445563078,
-0.4154810607,
-0.367731452,
0.1657921225,
-0.7085577846,
1.2299048901,
0.0380003154,
-0.0000023042,
-0.1496317387,
0.4398016334,
-0.4852699339,
-0.781329155,
-0.5250640512,
-0.4103922248,
0.1809734255,
0.2589990199,
0.410944283,
0.1177558228,
0.6923786402,
0.4478193223,
0.2617913783,
-0.1947734058,
-0.5071700811,
0.1943639219,
-0.1231713593,
-0.8002980947,
-0.6257838607,
-0.0553995147,
0.2022669911,
0.4290770888,
-0.3500464857,
0.1950514317,
0.0589471571,
0.6247957945,
-0.3475106955,
-0.026326783,
-0.4685436785,
0.0831199512,
0.0668592602,
-0.0077663511,
-0.6554669142,
-0.1951058507,
0.595698297,
-0.7928507328,
0.4389508367,
0.5205631256,
1.1031935215,
0.2242932022,
-0.4996021092,
-0.400178045,
-1.3779553175,
0.7168129086,
-0.5073642731,
0.570445776,
0.384670198,
0.5323956013,
-0.022676738,
-1.0870790482,
-0.4914593101,
-0.0945459679,
-0.4776027203,
0.3846238554,
-0.4720036089,
0.0493147783,
0.2082110792,
0.4246868193,
-0.4663031697,
0.0330711156,
-0.3410457969,
0.1505099833,
0.5662543178,
0.1525901854,
0.1659268588,
-0.0186787657,
-0.1439703256,
-0.0746661052,
-0.4938218594,
0.2393629998,
0.5531598926,
0.0365916416,
-0.0679446384,
0.3170597553,
-0.2839664221,
0.6627064347,
0.3089286983,
-0.17376782,
0.2070603967,
-0.4556348622,
-0.3454059064,
-0.1158008575,
0.6095403433,
0.2721707225,
0.579790175,
-0.0358531848,
-0.1643125713,
-0.1588897705,
0.6941958666,
-0.8963913321,
-0.1558388919,
0.0740714297,
-0.8952511549,
-0.3357439041,
0.3414215744,
-0.6036599278,
0.0037684301,
-0.4792045057,
0.0730793923,
0.0062824748,
-0.1783813536,
0.3694467247,
0.0585880689,
0.1484063566,
0.1969268024,
-0.8065166473,
0.4910050631,
0.5565533638,
0.4596597254,
-0.0212251712,
-0.1053544283,
0.0450769253,
0.2398233265,
0.1458221674,
0.9522613287,
-0.4793173969,
-0.3535896242,
0.1498039961,
0.1654811502,
0.0671207905,
-0.3423507512,
0.6449221373,
-0.6769800186,
0.1135789901,
0.2393028885,
-0.5174142718,
-0.3355571032,
0.4815467,
-0.7356724739,
0.4555859566,
-0.2536256015,
-0.5385800004,
0.3620853126,
-0.5969401002,
-0.677020371,
0.2123375684,
0.2820304632,
-0.7735948563,
0.2059170455,
0.3432330787,
0.5847372413,
-0.5807262063,
0.2422225177,
-0.0578625239,
-0.3284803331,
0.3208048344,
-0.3077071309,
0.3121582866,
0.2633266151,
-0.4382972419,
0.0540290922,
-0.4670627117,
-0.2584612668,
0.2638174891,
0.070031926,
-0.0717128962,
0.1829851419,
0.4106923938,
0.0542946272,
0.2433165163,
-0.3161967993,
-0.0574739277,
-0.5612577796,
0.5661625862,
0.6185455918,
-0.1078486219,
0.4626141787,
-0.1186955348,
0.8042966127,
0.1237778962,
0.5773058534,
-0.7156648636,
-0.3490643799,
-0.7609510422,
0.2639797032,
0.3821853101,
0.5261964798,
-0.5420778394,
0.6204791069,
-0.1877563149,
-0.6740859747,
-0.1619236469,
-0.192474097,
0.1563663185,
0.2613243759,
0.2907019258,
-0.0578551106,
-0.5171513557,
-0.9627889395,
-0.585983932,
-0.1221446618,
-0.0413614698,
0.3498601019,
0.2064471245,
-0.6194660664,
0.9998189807,
-0.7469641566,
-0.3768652678,
-0.6106957197,
-0.0823361129,
0.3827388287,
0.1664421707,
0.3772772253,
-1.1918208599,
-0.4858136177,
-0.0374313481,
-0.3185750246,
-0.0148948543,
-0.2305357456,
-0.0513850898,
-0.1236939356,
0.2069844157,
-0.3433538973,
0.5071258545,
0.4607879817,
-0.3100887537,
0.4847572148,
-0.3812325299,
0.2791413963,
-1.2591296434,
-0.1818497479,
0.5559628606,
-0.309484303,
-0.9576744437,
-0.2954045236,
-0.1229553595,
-0.2413222492,
-0.3193764091,
0.1377581805,
-0.1665808558,
0.1178015769,
-0.330609858,
-0.0522412024,
0.1802213192,
0.2801834941,
0.093006596,
0.5759631395,
0.1513479501,
-0.7999118567,
0.2063899189,
0.3933719993,
-0.4646958709,
0.5343587399,
-0.9063708186,
-0.0272773951,
-0.052871149,
0.3199720979,
-0.7612698674,
0.1001222953,
0.1222539693,
-0.1886027455,
0.132533893,
0.1359186321,
-0.4204479754,
-0.6930451989,
0.0635004193,
0.2679858506,
0.5396738052,
-0.5139293075,
0.9506414533,
0.3622981906,
-0.2004325837,
-0.3368419707,
-0.5432167649,
-0.0319364704,
-0.2416645139,
-0.6571068764,
0.6216127872,
-0.2572586238,
-0.0249168575,
-0.1822911054,
0.1251371056,
0.0712413192,
0.1949161887,
0.285163343,
0.3800574243,
-0.1402475238,
0.2664665878,
0.0363219716,
-0.5655805469,
0.1009938717,
-0.5552649498,
0.5602779388,
-0.275070399,
-0.3809742928,
-0.5801731944,
0.1245939955,
0.1266254485,
-0.2018580735,
0.6027430892,
0.4456968307,
-0.1316250563,
-0.133716628,
-0.7987418771,
-0.3859909177,
-0.5645826459,
0.6019407511,
-0.4010895491,
-0.8142105341,
0.0772371963,
-0.5198429823,
-0.0478312038,
0.4826011062,
0.5301656723,
-0.2970404327,
1.2725461721,
1.2111912966,
0.038991306,
0.6795062423,
-0.0212004539,
0.9116411805,
-0.4159156084,
-0.3035217524,
-0.7183742523,
-0.2502290606,
-0.6056495309,
0.2764567435,
0.1334539056,
0.0852149799,
-0.2952940464,
0.3941657841,
-0.506739378,
0.4202840626,
0.45393309,
0.2177758217,
0.4282931387,
0.2145945728,
0.1863518059,
0.0284768399,
-0.3745778203,
-0.7489275336,
1.0088734627,
0.3578467667,
0.8300711513,
-0.2274489254,
0.160449937,
0.3078094125,
0.2051471025,
-0.8890334964,
0.3155955374,
-0.340572238,
-0.3075399399,
-0.0127606839,
-0.1537011564,
-0.7898884416,
-0.1266274899,
-0.3684641123,
-0.2869428396,
0.0089938752,
0.3723009825,
-0.2871623933,
0.1507886052,
-0.70911479,
0.8158870339,
-0.6192982197,
-0.104769446,
-0.2076934427,
-0.4141288102,
0.092754446,
-0.2311550528,
0.2934317887,
0.3739503622,
0.2272420377,
0.9037242532,
-0.0490176231,
0.6451452374,
-0.0105239004,
0.0455580205,
0.114958331,
-0.3281317651,
0.6560005546,
-0.2473495156,
0.0226771031,
0.1852246374,
-0.1052120849,
0.0826256126,
-0.6076621413,
0.1064536572,
-0.8184198141,
-0.8075805902,
0.0373611711,
-0.2002330422,
-0.1638822109,
0.2874085903,
0.3661056459,
0.1170896515,
-0.3597495854,
0.4056244493,
0.7027301788,
-0.2442509681,
0.358294487,
0.4253687859,
-0.2993477583,
-0.2700101137,
0.6587358117,
-0.1917290092,
-0.079480432,
0.4623963833,
0.2805051804,
-0.276448518,
-0.5468847752,
-0.1870520562,
0.193579033,
-0.6925721765,
-0.1428356469,
-0.8921204805,
-0.0418845452,
-0.3182508647,
-0.2755230963,
-0.061340522,
-0.0705601051,
-0.1845337451,
-0.3699851036,
0.2695330679,
1.1321772337,
0.6076655984,
0.8226161599,
-1.0109823942,
0.2287947237,
0.2699675858,
0.3398119211,
0.145389393,
-0.2705575526,
-0.7336400747,
0.0002257254,
-0.3443905115,
-0.6290796399,
0.3362853229,
-0.03221016,
0.6073360443,
0.6925798059,
-0.1667442769,
0.3806537986,
-0.6067285538,
0.8846086264,
0.2896473408,
-1.0091768503,
0.5109415054,
-0.1970323771,
0.1251584888,
0.3977548182,
0.6306830049,
-0.502713263,
0.0162559673,
-0.4795307517,
-0.7983777523,
0.7946537733,
0.0876449719,
0.4005821347,
0.3255057335,
0.4610850811,
0.3072426021,
0.4347920716,
-0.8706031442,
-0.3288854957,
-0.3661854863,
-0.3140619397,
-0.2373682261,
-0.4030715823,
0.3496311605,
-0.1216059402,
0.9283549786,
0.0879299119,
0.1437098533,
-0.2312407345,
-0.3392407298,
0.0014877156,
0.3098089695,
0.4627062678,
0.5107761621,
0.2522084713,
-0.3659840524,
0.085517168,
-0.7170069814,
0.1428855956,
-0.0683629885,
-0.1460867524,
-0.3886095881,
0.1371016353,
0.7077001333,
0.0685209185,
-0.529537499,
0.6288941503,
-0.4062087834,
-0.0736052766,
-0.4544742405,
-0.0740282759,
0.0737805963,
0.1865347028,
0.2419905961,
0.1356595457,
0.2916616201,
-0.3065179288,
0.0856470764,
0.1952251792,
-0.4572530687,
-0.3885565996,
0.432862699,
0.2862167358,
-0.5385897756,
0.7282373905,
0.3992689848,
-0.7410479188,
0.5221684575,
0.8971158266,
0.999373734,
-0.3517899513,
0.2083077282,
0.0978073925,
0.4700779319,
-0.1570631266,
-0.1299656332,
-0.275067538,
-0.9075457454,
-0.1395483464,
-0.7458851337,
-0.3208140433,
-0.2208026946,
-0.5786569715,
0.6598194242,
-0.1934421808,
-0.2719413638,
-0.2192592025,
-0.229911074,
-1.0447682142,
0.5152249336,
-0.0577294417,
0.4765975177,
-0.7848098278,
0.6464017034,
0.5335199833,
-0.3718925416,
-0.853592813,
0.025139574,
-0.3893857598,
-0.4016956985,
0.8266178966,
0.3666503727,
-0.4547809064,
-0.0222157184,
-0.2240324169,
-0.5326223373,
1.0866606236,
0.0897431076,
-1.0145665407,
-0.1506549269,
0.5237166286,
0.6306109428,
-0.6648269892,
0.8315367699,
0.6212407947,
0.5637847781,
0.0881871358,
-0.4571631551,
-0.0996407643,
-0.4266165793,
0.2308627665,
0.0602621436,
-0.3683543205,
0.7233726382,
0.2461473644,
-0.1346204579,
-0.0896055475,
0.3899447322,
-0.139463082,
0.1896636337,
0.6917607784,
0.5366612077,
0.5060629845,
-0.0410482623,
1.062229991,
-0.4369516373,
0.2987812459,
0.8962879181,
-0.3270191848,
0.670737803,
-0.0191967208,
-0.1744880974,
0.8668036461,
0.6975747943,
-0.1750475019,
0.2852285802,
0.0064920005,
0.1234101355,
-0.2683964968,
0.0021771351,
-0.3737591207,
0.2844813466,
0.2342954129,
-0.5099515319,
0.0499484092,
0.2910436988,
-0.4067360759,
-0.0350465141,
-0.2584092021,
1.0480732918,
0.153136462,
-0.3420161009,
0.0078540565,
0.0509065948,
0.8007289767,
-0.6475660801,
-0.0007139881,
0.1969307661,
0.3406900167,
-0.3381404877,
-0.2900824845,
0.21991615,
0.1487821341,
-0.4717828035,
-0.5353145599,
1.0536706448,
0.056581039,
-0.6579170823,
0.4818643928,
0.3679304123,
-0.1329550743,
-0.1879900247,
-0.7202176452,
-0.2630850971,
-0.07308577,
-0.6560232043,
0.0945212618,
0.2948417962,
0.2546584308,
0.4651961625,
0.7626289725,
-0.2296183854,
-0.1090226024,
0.3716762364,
0.592364192,
-0.7791141272,
-0.8399172425,
-0.8592994213,
0.5940176845,
-0.1571306586,
-0.0010516974,
0.7594583631,
0.3841256499,
0.9705172181,
-0.1110239178,
0.7662198544,
0.5122698545,
0.3229091167,
-0.3463407457,
0.889438808,
-0.4329669774,
0.4023013413,
-0.2776818871,
-1.323653698,
-0.2537858486,
0.4688165784,
-0.6185128093,
0.2817848325,
0.7938744426,
0.4778522849,
-0.1268032938,
0.6078271866,
0.3870695829,
0.2038419992,
0.4214968979,
0.1560447365,
0.887540102,
-0.5551613569,
0.720897913,
-0.1046888456,
-0.1384070218,
-0.2404839993,
-0.775187254,
-0.9863246679,
-0.5877900124,
-0.0043190243,
0.0275552347,
-0.2051038891,
0.9071592689,
0.8110241294,
-0.7645015717,
-0.4456862807,
-0.2710597515,
-0.0781750381,
-0.2458618879,
-0.1900715679,
0.1229661405,
-0.3370833695,
-0.76737082,
0.0948328525,
0.3656422198,
0.1419500113,
-0.2355100065,
0.1396583617,
0.0375496373,
0.1418537647,
0.757563591,
-0.3035317361,
-0.530908227,
0.0402567647,
0.2612639964,
0.3822749853,
0.014285218,
1.2592012882,
-0.8745023012,
0.2943747044,
0.3603809178,
0.6795725226,
0.7712595463,
-0.0027693021,
0.8039617538,
-0.029515991,
0.0284973271,
0.0471481346,
0.4638375044,
0.1516543031,
-0.5963484645,
0.155976668,
-0.1670551896,
-0.5812405348,
-0.4057145715,
0.5296826363,
-0.5267308354,
-0.3128277957,
0.5638746023,
-0.2273185402,
-0.22501041,
-0.4150838852,
-0.2620597184,
0.2737833858,
-0.1343166083,
0.7687867284,
0.580673933,
0.1845659167,
-0.1951716542,
-0.1501985937,
0.1957169324,
0.3451811373,
-1.0703710318,
-0.1067187563,
0.1390569955,
-0.0046548895,
0.1555483341,
0.1945221573,
0.2413816601,
-0.016795326,
-0.3925017416,
0.0084767211,
-0.1796179265,
-0.6212753057,
-0.3332237601,
0.3446761072,
-0.0838713944,
0.3187695742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16034v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16034v2
|
Emotion Classification in Short English Texts using Deep Learning Techniques
| 2024-02-25T09:17:22 | 2024-03-10T15:58:56 |
Siddhanth Bhat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Detecting emotions in limited text datasets from under-resourced languages
presents a formidable obstacle, demanding specialized frameworks and
computational strategies. This study conducts a thorough examination of deep
learning techniques for discerning emotions in short English texts. Deep
learning approaches employ transfer learning and word embedding, notably BERT,
to attain superior accuracy. To evaluate these methods, we introduce the
"SmallEnglishEmotions" dataset, comprising 6372 varied short English texts
annotated with five primary emotion categories. Our experiments reveal that
transfer learning and BERT-based text embedding outperform alternative methods
in accurately categorizing the text in the dataset.
|
[
-0.2913197577,
-0.4677334428,
0.5512842536,
0.0849280134,
-0.5412535667,
0.1889583766,
-0.4982766807,
-0.7100133896,
0.1328067183,
-0.0093037039,
-0.4871826172,
-0.4541009963,
-0.7599033117,
0.4097723961,
-0.2459580451,
0.7763853073,
-0.2676331103,
0.0973495245,
-0.100745894,
-0.3364073336,
-0.4589756131,
-0.3845042586,
-0.6320875287,
-0.3837251365,
0.7944509983,
0.7862061262,
0.6045740247,
0.0180280022,
0.6315507889,
0.2880423367,
-0.0043400009,
0.1582713574,
-0.4812473655,
0.1326999664,
0.0246198885,
-0.5422333479,
0.2723090351,
-0.0410351828,
0.3655285537,
0.2174481004,
0.3047701716,
-0.1470407546,
0.2270808816,
0.9083482623,
-0.7403991222,
0.1142295748,
-0.2249929011,
0.6021196246,
-0.3736736774,
0.045507282,
-0.5399442911,
-0.5903962851,
0.4895606637,
-0.0769238099,
-0.058882121,
0.1935956031,
0.6603962779,
0.1954635084,
-0.7840917706,
-0.7982022166,
-0.4114540815,
1.0554959774,
-0.574365139,
0.3284834921,
0.1998752058,
0.1701984406,
0.4719409347,
-0.6859950423,
-0.5943337679,
-0.1733689755,
-0.3785935938,
0.1712149233,
-0.3205098212,
0.2017784566,
-0.027843101,
0.3423504829,
-0.6209482551,
0.5286325216,
-0.3302110732,
0.1051470041,
0.7468133569,
0.2338309139,
0.2978785932,
-0.5230690241,
-0.1287838668,
-0.1850355566,
-0.5376009941,
0.1298098713,
0.315895915,
0.302762717,
-0.0886171609,
0.3745936453,
0.2955439389,
-0.0895681679,
-0.1111341193,
0.1632544547,
0.3229914904,
0.2336341292,
-0.4560594261,
0.2420287281,
0.8548234701,
0.3977308869,
0.5716113448,
0.1974694729,
-0.2444395125,
0.0964729041,
0.1155306175,
-0.8995261192,
-0.2900955081,
0.3705243766,
-0.7316359282,
-0.388928324,
-0.3658149838,
-1.1085571051,
-0.7505888939,
-0.098108694,
0.3714447916,
-0.4792994559,
0.1096602008,
0.0620089285,
-0.0577105954,
0.0062503414,
0.1935734898,
-0.839384079,
0.0978311747,
0.5197072029,
0.7669351101,
-0.3091261685,
-0.1740418226,
0.0089274133,
-0.4059894383,
-0.4296551943,
0.7354706526,
-0.6272506714,
-0.341850549,
0.4003642797,
0.2046171576,
0.0583065972,
-0.3795989156,
0.7086684108,
-0.2679198086,
0.6129791141,
-0.1001298055,
-0.8475607038,
-0.2518040538,
0.1366968453,
-0.6836040616,
1.0802881718,
-0.2124689072,
-0.6935688257,
0.0835529417,
-0.5740232468,
-0.7904648781,
-0.1821590662,
0.1108834818,
-0.3323072195,
0.5780828595,
0.0964382514,
1.0130449533,
-0.1820381284,
-0.2789860964,
-0.3273523152,
-0.4833407998,
0.2169809341,
-0.2601178586,
0.4616698623,
0.4376164079,
-0.4321724772,
-0.2469452322,
-0.4961848259,
-0.0067420825,
0.2414106429,
-0.08161515,
-0.747574091,
0.0391384438,
-0.0474121682,
0.0750790462,
0.1542548686,
-0.5502763987,
0.1611936092,
-0.4919184148,
0.2021612972,
0.6960936785,
-0.0597968288,
0.6333810687,
0.0514558367,
0.5020413995,
0.0068994132,
-0.035886243,
0.0788624287,
-0.4324196875,
-0.8021375537,
0.0830927119,
0.2436882257,
0.5494500399,
-0.5336893797,
0.4514745176,
-0.0593623482,
-0.5334671736,
-1.0276767015,
-0.0758327469,
0.2752683163,
0.3706334829,
0.429777205,
0.1294912249,
-0.405749023,
-0.7047606707,
-0.2341337204,
0.0448150784,
0.1231044456,
0.5157573223,
0.4625291526,
-0.5244312882,
0.4841840565,
-0.5664583445,
-0.3381047547,
-0.0862727836,
0.7344375849,
-0.1957095861,
0.2834812403,
0.775164485,
-0.7197709084,
-0.8206925392,
0.1353909373,
-0.6723499894,
0.0021989637,
-0.1540618837,
0.1520871371,
0.368008703,
0.1166119203,
-0.4813050032,
0.3518945277,
0.5652040839,
-0.0918979868,
0.1885346323,
-0.0018067074,
0.2701776028,
-0.9147563577,
-0.3616927266,
0.017587781,
-0.2118396312,
-0.485852927,
-0.3179554939,
0.2898844779,
0.0734232515,
-0.7194409966,
0.638081193,
-0.4788088799,
0.1962457299,
-0.4777867198,
0.2161840647,
0.2035130858,
0.1975979358,
0.1011433378,
0.3607200384,
0.3305155635,
-0.2568123937,
0.737672925,
0.2475537509,
-0.3779177368,
0.4930081666,
-0.1615857333,
0.3241278529,
-0.4398040771,
-0.0441773683,
-1.0754628181,
-0.1261096597,
-0.0372336544,
-0.3069416285,
0.3951065242,
0.0531641617,
-0.3071565628,
-0.5159335732,
-0.6098364592,
0.1922525764,
0.9888979793,
-0.733526051,
0.4172229767,
0.0885026827,
-0.288706094,
-0.6080816388,
-1.070166111,
-0.1629220396,
-0.290004015,
-0.3052641451,
0.0517898798,
-0.0348420329,
-0.1980588734,
0.1665975004,
0.2392329127,
-0.4034242034,
0.1099438444,
0.1849328876,
-0.1796826869,
-0.0474654734,
0.6437575817,
0.4643695951,
0.177607432,
0.1972901672,
0.25203228,
0.214881897,
-0.2512187362,
-0.1309979558,
-0.4848906994,
0.5953512788,
0.470007509,
0.1392227858,
0.5321142077,
0.9184575677,
-0.6078661084,
-0.6683705449,
-0.2878683805,
-0.1676872969,
-0.4660386741,
0.4217343628,
-0.2179645598,
-1.0500361919,
0.3596073389,
-0.1553451717,
-0.3545667827,
0.5929507613,
0.6041458249,
-0.8206398487,
0.9606735706,
0.7148481607,
-0.4932678342,
0.372512877,
-0.0435087197,
0.2493320107,
-0.261726439,
-0.058398176,
-0.6810464263,
-0.8218030334,
-0.7517123818,
-0.2070187181,
-0.1771899313,
-0.2142733634,
-0.0877554938,
0.0658602193,
-0.5387057662,
0.7868340611,
0.2516668439,
-0.0117114205,
-0.2205324918,
-0.0900847465,
0.1604990661,
-0.5668542385,
-0.2496581674,
-0.3174508214,
0.6314446926,
0.5367280841,
0.955637455,
0.0286733788,
1.0091103315,
0.6472197771,
0.4523256719,
-1.3630478382,
0.2733061314,
-0.6096561551,
-0.3212057948,
-0.2861019969,
-0.3152172863,
-1.0805482864,
-0.1712597311,
-0.2063481808,
-0.7127863765,
0.4543273449,
-0.078944847,
-0.2970578074,
0.255926609,
-1.0540485382,
0.9179416299,
-0.4863370359,
-0.0060505201,
-0.3784590662,
-0.6468839645,
0.2654027343,
-0.2376192957,
0.1935522407,
-0.2109335363,
-0.0420213342,
0.8177272677,
-0.1582402736,
0.9163461924,
-0.2299855649,
-0.0108104767,
0.331622988,
0.2280284762,
0.6909940839,
-0.2783271074,
0.0284380391,
-0.1006873176,
-0.1781953871,
-0.2377913147,
-0.5350399613,
0.7282090187,
-0.7503446341,
0.0388919152,
-0.4751183391,
-0.1907235682,
-0.2306218594,
0.16496934,
0.2841921747,
-0.1565753073,
-0.1909422725,
0.4794971943,
0.6056222916,
-0.3429727852,
0.7404828668,
0.2684712112,
0.0049140197,
-0.2471470982,
0.9097948074,
0.0682251379,
-0.2469859719,
0.5217449665,
0.4690225422,
-0.4260664582,
-0.470618993,
-0.0121706789,
0.0224130545,
-0.7398608327,
-0.4135868251,
-0.3573048115,
0.1033027992,
-0.2903530896,
-0.536970973,
-0.5051249266,
0.0576800704,
-0.6390283704,
-0.4509366155,
0.4167357981,
0.9185239673,
-0.057488706,
0.2898559272,
-1.2983958721,
0.1468441486,
0.596247375,
0.3465781212,
0.0083653638,
-0.4201878309,
-0.3952895105,
-0.2316887826,
-0.1483512074,
-1.1170066595,
0.8336032629,
0.4992187023,
-0.0507151559,
0.5267003775,
0.4524092674,
0.4946317375,
-0.5344639421,
0.9884648919,
0.2008537799,
-1.1757507324,
0.7206433415,
0.1769748479,
-0.1384077072,
0.6080582142,
0.9135277271,
-0.7237187028,
0.088450782,
-0.4146998525,
-0.8215283751,
0.4474105835,
-0.0009974092,
0.3500807881,
-0.1865867078,
0.2919695973,
0.2614722252,
0.1314808428,
-0.647485733,
-0.197808221,
0.2166781574,
-0.9425737262,
-0.1709638536,
-0.4495279491,
0.0748768672,
-0.2293016016,
0.3432965875,
-0.2238615602,
0.4199881256,
0.2425186783,
-0.4976480901,
-0.0308607332,
0.2984767556,
0.5024723411,
-0.0846802592,
-0.3841347694,
0.138416186,
0.4429834783,
-0.4535745084,
0.4085421264,
0.0999018177,
0.3370440602,
0.360817045,
0.4233631492,
0.8663995862,
0.2388264388,
-0.6391665339,
0.9808409214,
-0.1975749731,
-0.0687523037,
-0.0834117457,
-0.418225199,
0.0633667856,
0.5167040229,
0.2768387794,
-0.2506254017,
0.4250927567,
-0.4455618858,
0.1403782517,
0.1767059863,
-0.5857809186,
-0.334330231,
0.0754333064,
0.5678200126,
-0.1751145273,
0.6700066328,
-0.2291022092,
-0.5424961448,
0.5055985451,
0.1614563018,
1.2632623911,
-0.2615820765,
0.1420331895,
-0.212685436,
0.3780042231,
-0.0463849381,
0.5166733861,
0.1535770595,
-0.7249703407,
-0.6203669906,
-0.420830369,
-0.809648335,
-0.0086436449,
-0.7387917042,
0.1489381045,
-0.2862805426,
0.0689820573,
-0.1351934969,
0.3712815642,
-0.9337627292,
0.6258199811,
0.6770741343,
0.9334127903,
-1.1564788818,
1.0141525269,
0.7290745378,
-0.0238381159,
-0.6250247359,
-0.0686810613,
0.0289128795,
-0.7502772212,
0.8654674888,
0.4856320918,
-0.0410581082,
-0.0613032877,
-0.6484414935,
-0.265042752,
0.7604522705,
0.1770715714,
-0.7793425322,
0.1361485422,
0.0930800959,
0.8490930796,
-0.2573383749,
0.2615655065,
0.4977416098,
0.4935677946,
-0.4396391213,
-0.4522091746,
-0.24545376,
-0.0346130021,
-0.3938366175,
0.269805938,
-0.717538476,
0.6205025911,
0.0611326098,
-0.3730311096,
-0.0844773799,
0.9036819935,
-0.4043881297,
0.5193273425,
0.4657407105,
0.5473562479,
1.1945266724,
-0.2848068774,
0.9603655934,
0.0594630502,
0.7583625913,
0.7586758137,
-0.4317292273,
1.0856187344,
0.3524328768,
-0.276019603,
0.6638459563,
0.888820529,
0.0190958176,
0.6296585798,
0.2159670442,
-0.1815187186,
0.0777967274,
-0.0381154828,
-0.2255735695,
0.2617371976,
0.4154746234,
-0.4152146876,
0.1192609519,
0.6946702003,
0.0301960576,
-0.1089831442,
-0.3979785442,
0.8540754318,
0.303165555,
-0.1297903508,
0.1449331641,
-0.3394015431,
1.1038855314,
-0.4010972977,
0.2073535472,
-0.5359238386,
0.2715269029,
-0.2104974985,
-1.2487745285,
0.3052623272,
0.2059410512,
-0.0487568006,
-0.3949839473,
1.1007162333,
-0.4412530363,
-0.3217453957,
0.5614438653,
0.2641588748,
0.3211372495,
-0.0755332485,
-0.65246737,
-0.0895847082,
-0.0386408083,
-0.5555335879,
0.3719526827,
0.9512203336,
0.3507186174,
0.4192813039,
0.0893835872,
-0.0569929965,
-0.1209763438,
-0.0176286288,
0.4922141433,
-1.0226401091,
-0.3207557499,
-0.9481082559,
0.5981383324,
-0.0180225018,
-0.2537306547,
0.5697333217,
0.1907859445,
0.7116982937,
-0.472869575,
0.8068589568,
0.087673381,
0.545506537,
-0.366897285,
0.5643151999,
-0.7388585806,
-0.3784256876,
-0.3699473143,
-0.5415394902,
-0.4306534231,
0.6227183938,
-0.2117152214,
-0.2616295218,
1.0036146641,
0.1306839436,
0.1493261755,
0.1472739428,
0.3651091456,
0.2455616742,
0.0519058071,
0.8247596622,
1.0795695782,
-0.490324378,
0.48550421,
-0.649302125,
0.0916678533,
-0.5975438952,
-1.137188077,
-0.7734773755,
-0.3981556296,
-0.316182673,
-0.3024728596,
-0.0016809057,
1.0335026979,
0.4703927934,
-1.0269123316,
0.1299576163,
0.2914080322,
0.2944712639,
0.0893166214,
-0.310990572,
0.5822799206,
-0.4751934409,
-1.0451719761,
0.3813736141,
0.1542243063,
0.3516651988,
0.0871027708,
-0.1626357287,
0.0821765959,
0.1653769761,
0.770109117,
0.2223077714,
-0.3045341372,
-0.7364147305,
-0.1567052305,
-0.4917868674,
-0.0498456061,
0.5990256667,
-0.44322142,
0.2341381609,
0.8284342885,
1.0312818289,
0.3642200828,
-0.2351465672,
0.0939479098,
-1.2094683647,
0.180255428,
0.6658874154,
0.5754799843,
0.2252615839,
-0.6258266568,
0.4204394221,
0.2029341161,
-0.793271482,
-0.8151691556,
-0.0532244295,
-1.0232764482,
-0.3646007776,
0.8513968587,
-0.3016284108,
-0.1991178989,
0.3960997462,
-0.3991178274,
0.0655529276,
-0.3866834044,
0.7533282042,
0.8778914213,
-0.2295546681,
-0.4059778452,
-0.2282987535,
0.7396196127,
0.7619475126,
-0.8919605613,
-0.1373123527,
0.5269638896,
-0.224607259,
0.1502190977,
0.1384896785,
0.3938550055,
-0.0141587937,
-0.3429933786,
0.191429913,
0.3748144507,
-0.3080148995,
-0.6719225049,
0.3561228812,
-0.2022486478,
-0.3529148698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16030v1
|
Don't Forget Your Reward Values: Language Model Alignment via Value-based Calibration
| 2024-02-25T08:45:10 | 2024-02-25T08:45:10 |
Xin Mao, Feng-Lin Li, Huimin Xu, Wei Zhang, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) significantly
enhances the generation quality of Large Language Models (LLMs), recent studies
have raised concerns regarding the complexity and instability associated with
the Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) algorithm, proposing a series of
order-based calibration methods as viable alternatives. This paper delves
further into current order-based methods, examining their inefficiencies in
utilizing reward values and addressing misalignment issues. Building upon these
findings, we propose a novel \textbf{V}alue-based \textbf{C}ali\textbf{B}ration
(VCB) method to better align LLMs with human preferences. Experimental results
demonstrate that VCB surpasses existing alignment methods on AI assistant and
summarization datasets, providing impressive generalizability, robustness, and
stability in diverse settings.
|
[
-0.0610757098,
-0.1387208104,
0.3364459872,
0.1580822468,
0.0115565415,
0.0872185379,
-0.0500813387,
-0.0964585468,
0.2736391127,
0.5089032054,
-0.5701283216,
-0.1676546335,
-0.293923974,
-0.2583744526,
0.3338265121,
1.0377938747,
0.0184143931,
0.2359364629,
-0.3925887346,
-0.4555151761,
-0.6718114018,
-0.5906733871,
-0.4533855915,
-0.6373996139,
0.7834110856,
0.6044337749,
0.9648423791,
1.0231697559,
0.471429944,
0.2772863507,
-0.0470104329,
0.5449363589,
-0.6038615704,
-0.071138978,
-0.1551159918,
-0.3640679419,
-0.6260150075,
-0.0252232179,
0.3099178374,
0.6118934751,
-0.6206173897,
-0.0025838683,
-0.215190798,
1.0095008612,
-1.0710594654,
0.0595288314,
-0.2875401378,
-0.2088362426,
0.0716143847,
-0.2924085855,
-0.5287568569,
-0.9000999331,
0.1579311192,
-0.5014423132,
-0.3728654981,
0.1348530799,
1.2078129053,
0.4464390278,
-0.3250577152,
-0.231245175,
-0.6175661683,
1.2805956602,
-0.6172149181,
0.2722362578,
0.4412898719,
0.2661549747,
-0.3479367495,
-0.202701211,
-0.4876936972,
-0.0661896542,
0.0535002351,
0.3241795599,
0.1433328241,
0.1674054116,
-0.1150482669,
0.2461810708,
-0.3987799883,
0.3172718585,
-0.0637774989,
-0.1960996687,
0.640857935,
0.1770900786,
0.1094076708,
0.176869005,
-0.2250018418,
-0.6782947779,
-1.0037771463,
0.4198314548,
0.5731275678,
0.2449043989,
0.1283922344,
0.5785669684,
0.0554436371,
0.7816494107,
0.3494619429,
-0.3048473597,
0.3312489986,
-0.2708087265,
-0.202699542,
0.2971197069,
0.7050496936,
0.5175939202,
0.2610066831,
-0.0541908406,
-0.1580780745,
-0.1006746069,
0.371542424,
-0.4830045998,
-0.029020315,
0.2622870505,
-0.1628735065,
-0.4401304126,
-0.0036700922,
-0.2630044818,
-0.2962218523,
-0.4985417724,
0.3818435669,
-0.2734230161,
-0.0581785105,
0.0337773338,
0.1715112925,
0.4665127099,
0.3733083606,
-1.3982894421,
0.1191022694,
0.7070759535,
0.4710955024,
0.0094815437,
-0.324578464,
-0.8070513606,
0.1801900715,
-0.6578783989,
0.6523829699,
-0.3874493837,
-0.3209658563,
-0.0358447768,
-0.2391893566,
0.1003729254,
-0.7730823755,
0.4535316527,
-0.6005232334,
0.3540942669,
-0.6448437572,
-0.4168455899,
-0.0074029695,
0.2302577198,
-0.541241467,
0.9441666007,
0.2246043682,
-0.4971989691,
0.311294049,
-0.2572867572,
-0.2073511928,
-0.0819247365,
-0.2572028339,
-0.6083297729,
0.1074601337,
0.3107933998,
0.0706928521,
-0.1423009485,
0.4747106135,
-0.2591863275,
-0.5195663571,
0.3893010616,
-0.4568186104,
0.6300256848,
0.0988168716,
-0.1770898253,
0.4056673944,
-0.4314998984,
0.1801399887,
-0.0986730456,
-0.4120950103,
-0.2857043445,
0.3049139082,
-0.3500790298,
0.1932125837,
0.38871032,
-0.2355120778,
0.1688399911,
-0.7628954649,
0.3082012534,
1.1662451029,
-0.3424112797,
0.6780456901,
-0.7467777133,
0.5746350288,
-0.0227728151,
0.0507363901,
0.0485056117,
0.0450166054,
-0.6333405972,
-0.0948030725,
0.4083096385,
0.8732014894,
-0.3747564256,
0.7326598763,
-0.4475763738,
-0.3680617809,
-0.6887024641,
0.059792012,
0.6109228134,
0.5727128386,
0.2496979982,
-0.3987335265,
-0.2528075278,
-0.9887285233,
-0.0761071593,
-0.6899355054,
-0.0343359187,
0.3787763119,
-0.0312789455,
0.0147743365,
0.9864171147,
-0.3920435905,
-0.037559405,
-0.0366344862,
0.1160835177,
0.0825243369,
0.3971711695,
0.4015030563,
-0.6154171228,
-0.1193157062,
0.0447136797,
-0.4410378635,
-0.3066780567,
-0.1183564812,
-0.2694646716,
0.3160600364,
0.2965386212,
-0.1570452452,
-0.0795547813,
0.6292530894,
-0.0154300882,
0.3608656824,
-0.3323974907,
0.1788896322,
-0.9380928278,
-0.0637759343,
-0.1135606021,
-0.4609142244,
-0.2441084981,
-0.3660069704,
0.3740963638,
0.2671827078,
-0.5623990893,
0.558885932,
-0.1743522286,
0.1205857694,
-0.326983124,
0.0393916294,
-0.005898464,
0.513217926,
0.1332693845,
0.899038136,
-0.0096912524,
-0.562553823,
0.2487962693,
0.228633225,
0.0112588722,
0.880987525,
-0.4430596828,
0.0340796001,
-0.4135243297,
0.1049388796,
-0.8824135065,
-0.023776222,
0.2812840343,
-0.4696313441,
0.4343597293,
0.0795950592,
-0.122021772,
0.0010144463,
-0.5137975216,
0.5258034468,
0.4232060909,
-0.5495296717,
0.3568182588,
0.6053084731,
-0.2207749188,
-1.1509753466,
-0.2387200892,
-0.089346543,
-0.273383975,
-0.323577255,
0.5820323825,
-0.3919478655,
-0.2211981565,
-0.2117372751,
-0.3417673707,
0.1909021139,
-0.0050753518,
0.2369942814,
0.5369392633,
-0.1016310304,
0.1013641581,
0.0511759818,
-0.3259714842,
-0.175035283,
-0.1933888197,
0.3328683376,
-0.3556822836,
-0.1205365583,
-0.235512048,
0.0847760439,
0.5363066196,
-0.2213964313,
0.715223074,
0.1784107387,
-0.146796152,
0.1156090721,
-0.6702314615,
-0.025708586,
-0.5123791099,
0.3730933964,
-0.0263022184,
-0.8063049316,
0.2198181599,
-0.0196623243,
0.1854871064,
0.1034927741,
0.7508365512,
-0.2838224173,
1.066044569,
0.7567790747,
-0.4009085298,
0.7812018394,
0.2171741128,
0.3425489664,
-0.5893232822,
-0.2319731414,
-0.4186203778,
-0.3653785884,
-0.6178671718,
-0.1406006217,
0.1493466347,
0.2563704252,
-0.6564576626,
0.2898823917,
-0.3316349089,
0.7751154304,
0.5905301571,
0.1235926747,
0.0924916342,
-0.0655212402,
0.1059067324,
-0.3049370348,
-0.6210292578,
-0.6450184584,
1.0393884182,
0.1381944269,
0.8020656705,
0.1546301991,
0.7691553235,
0.1764199287,
0.5649749637,
-0.8150929213,
0.2774244845,
-0.1579886973,
-0.0459566414,
-0.5338562131,
-0.5399632454,
-0.9541978836,
0.1719057113,
0.1272530109,
-0.7497209311,
0.3744708896,
0.5220777988,
-0.660882473,
-0.1145318821,
-0.7792872787,
0.9054254293,
-0.651301384,
-0.3964434862,
-0.0409566574,
-0.6708887219,
0.0814235732,
0.2745762765,
0.2532502115,
-0.2054194659,
-0.0805361196,
0.6354531646,
-0.7663043141,
0.4448178709,
0.047032468,
-0.0939415917,
0.0683943629,
0.0583318993,
0.5936357975,
-0.1111003682,
-0.0007711743,
-0.1054112613,
-0.0818392262,
-0.5815685391,
-0.5119130611,
0.8938508034,
-0.9749205112,
-0.4428412616,
-0.6485416293,
-0.7206039429,
-0.3481918871,
0.0488654226,
-0.0420748405,
-0.0168121699,
-0.1124766767,
-0.050147552,
0.7169570923,
-0.3099845052,
0.4703628421,
0.3725144267,
0.2005133927,
-0.8367791176,
1.1526764631,
0.0301962048,
0.4160498679,
0.759786427,
0.2806151807,
-0.3222471476,
-0.1107393876,
-0.4843855202,
0.4669490159,
-0.5292700529,
-0.442799747,
-0.1804185063,
0.0674604923,
-0.3780249655,
-0.6004888415,
-0.6270228624,
-0.3349161446,
-0.1977221221,
-0.1277804673,
0.153942734,
0.266302526,
-0.1061574817,
0.4832087457,
-0.6384806633,
0.0855328217,
0.301235646,
0.2801927924,
-0.2055001408,
-0.3421639204,
-0.3553001285,
0.2702638507,
-0.5741579533,
-0.8595774174,
0.493255049,
-0.1829932332,
0.4703433514,
0.339094013,
-0.0185735226,
0.9374696612,
-0.287471652,
0.6114516258,
0.3490543365,
-1.0161812305,
0.4335921109,
-0.0711348653,
0.2639224231,
0.712714076,
0.1518224031,
-0.6805229187,
0.0485410318,
-0.4599635601,
-1.1852347851,
0.8695388436,
-0.0750963986,
0.1083257049,
0.1451991796,
0.3576459587,
-0.172977522,
0.3923920393,
-0.9156038165,
-0.2315513343,
-0.2358786613,
-0.611084342,
0.0138094686,
-0.1367603987,
-0.0620597675,
0.0317345336,
0.8951840401,
-0.1995878965,
0.0056158449,
-0.0819116458,
-0.1652705222,
-0.4088740945,
0.3048169315,
0.7945443988,
0.8840532303,
-0.4502317309,
-0.1555465609,
0.0714943185,
-0.1601507962,
0.4788527489,
-0.2132909745,
-0.1475437135,
-0.47303316,
0.0746688023,
0.7404457331,
0.1598155648,
-0.9797843695,
0.7135441899,
0.0201877207,
-0.0302346777,
-0.2517191172,
0.2043262124,
0.1442391276,
0.1401427239,
-0.0407963842,
-0.1328903437,
-0.2840377986,
-0.3947623074,
0.0035308739,
0.4767352939,
-0.638807416,
0.0462169237,
0.570841372,
-0.0749743879,
-0.4536207318,
0.8094812036,
-0.0730707571,
-0.2604888082,
0.6466231942,
0.4919230044,
0.7381495237,
-0.4100326002,
0.3190534711,
0.2993691266,
0.347781539,
-0.4665113091,
0.2304484397,
-0.0586210042,
-0.8629991412,
-0.6258830428,
-0.5145964026,
-0.7060998082,
-0.0559877492,
-0.6135202646,
0.3280666173,
-0.4645691812,
-0.1267207414,
-0.2359481156,
-0.0939408541,
-0.3974866569,
0.1596562862,
0.0353877507,
0.2759419978,
-0.9344965816,
0.6756227016,
0.6577209234,
-0.562714994,
-1.0147571564,
-0.1571131349,
0.085577406,
-0.9391099811,
0.6829611063,
-0.1106780916,
-0.2552744448,
-0.1356917918,
-0.4579054415,
-0.916431427,
1.1511079073,
0.5826821327,
-0.6610949636,
-0.1195804775,
-0.0114115877,
0.3932582736,
-0.3027696013,
0.5707045197,
0.4929507077,
0.4578644931,
0.257298857,
-0.8800504208,
-0.1690015048,
-0.0437951647,
0.2520856261,
0.4315192699,
-0.9146309495,
0.3697599471,
-0.2207769305,
0.1148416102,
-0.0462721437,
0.6637995839,
0.5161274076,
0.0289764237,
0.3266277611,
0.7336674333,
0.8140071034,
-0.1232503131,
0.8209114671,
-0.0054082223,
0.1755772531,
1.0887444019,
-0.380117178,
0.7545697093,
0.753249824,
-0.2772790492,
0.4523481429,
0.8785009384,
0.2252135575,
0.7295230031,
0.4013224542,
-0.0138393566,
-0.253639102,
-0.1629211158,
-0.1890417337,
0.0662383586,
0.2042510659,
-0.0919909105,
-0.0597169548,
-0.4101915956,
0.1321993321,
0.2551148236,
-0.2934666872,
0.8844637275,
-0.0392960459,
-0.9813136458,
0.6515183449,
0.1367503554,
0.4973846972,
-0.6658102274,
-0.0648857057,
-0.4338425398,
0.400534898,
-0.1354685873,
-0.4115829468,
0.1254848391,
-0.337369889,
-0.3469131291,
-0.5364189148,
0.0144998878,
-0.5295040607,
-0.3330095708,
0.0138069037,
0.2593807578,
-0.1411994398,
0.2139650732,
-0.6150228977,
-0.0644569173,
0.0256837346,
-0.1536208391,
0.463079989,
0.1778426468,
-0.3713299632,
0.5484563708,
0.4153647721,
0.2168037891,
-0.2523658276,
0.1274084747,
0.3761411905,
-0.7490086555,
-0.5130230784,
-1.005479455,
0.4942316413,
0.1352591068,
-0.2442689836,
0.3037208021,
0.5070977807,
1.1906567812,
0.1667903513,
0.5046855211,
0.3231428266,
0.1625838131,
-0.4542995393,
0.3970946074,
-0.4911409318,
0.4057848454,
-0.3286685944,
-0.8520610929,
-0.4968942404,
0.78327775,
-0.4111653566,
0.0822743401,
0.5700156093,
1.0993789434,
0.1097741723,
-0.3172095716,
0.1637001485,
-0.1716616005,
0.3918785453,
0.7391200066,
0.5588470697,
-0.3813279867,
0.6038501263,
-0.162011981,
-0.4002732933,
-0.3745952547,
-1.023283124,
-0.3631113768,
-0.3696018755,
-0.4341430664,
-0.5781492591,
0.2025888711,
1.2960402966,
0.7477468848,
-0.9129876494,
-0.7431558967,
-0.0952410921,
0.4687451124,
-0.5358484387,
-0.1703578979,
0.492110461,
-0.299551338,
-0.7011945248,
0.1711694002,
0.5507079363,
0.1391870975,
0.012894785,
-0.5738580227,
-0.1438019872,
0.2552514076,
0.3521972299,
0.5118402839,
-0.8478167653,
-0.2751885951,
0.1153352186,
-0.284460187,
0.3854646087,
0.8203498721,
-0.7191974521,
0.5191780329,
0.5412011147,
0.8707826138,
0.1704707444,
0.2815185487,
0.8614316583,
-0.6131111383,
-0.1190824285,
0.3513770401,
0.302082628,
0.2631495297,
-0.3335931003,
0.2228794247,
0.0211756695,
-0.7273415923,
-0.8019860983,
0.4267078042,
-1.0275862217,
-0.0698394701,
0.6232373118,
0.0065939464,
-0.3366906643,
0.3221825361,
-0.3190009296,
0.1533115953,
-0.5887947679,
1.0201376677,
0.8511521816,
-0.1982924193,
-0.296189785,
-0.1202746034,
0.3609750867,
0.8926866055,
-0.7383551598,
0.1717212498,
0.7958779335,
0.0436361507,
0.0480682142,
0.7852885723,
-0.2786830962,
0.3400036395,
-0.5180185437,
0.1436927319,
0.0026004326,
-0.2434361428,
-0.419033438,
-0.0378497615,
0.5103992224,
-0.1933569759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16029v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16029v5
|
GraphWiz: An Instruction-Following Language Model for Graph Problems
| 2024-02-25T08:41:32 | 2024-07-03T06:39:59 |
Nuo Chen, Yuhan Li, Jianheng Tang, Jia Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive success across several
fields, but their proficiency in understanding and resolving complex graph
problems is less explored. To bridge this gap, we introduce GraphInstruct, a
novel and comprehensive instruction-tuning dataset designed to equip language
models with the ability to tackle a broad spectrum of graph problems using
explicit reasoning paths. Utilizing GraphInstruct, we build GraphWiz, an
open-source language model capable of resolving various graph problem types
while generating clear reasoning processes. To enhance the model's capability
and reliability, we incorporate the Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
framework into the graph problem-solving context. The enhanced model,
GraphWiz-DPO, achieves an average accuracy of 65% across nine tasks with
different complexity levels, surpassing GPT-4 which has an average accuracy of
43.8%. Moreover, our research delves into the delicate balance between training
data volume and model performance, highlighting the potential for overfitting
with increased data. We also explore the transferability of the model's
reasoning ability across different graph tasks, indicating the model's
adaptability and practical application potential. Our investigation offers a
new blueprint and valuable insights for developing LLMs specialized in graph
reasoning and problem-solving.
|
[
-0.1238233894,
-0.8950808644,
0.6431878209,
-0.096166946,
0.1578280628,
0.4614212215,
-0.1530232728,
-0.244298175,
-0.2216905355,
0.8092119098,
-0.6785678267,
-0.7107357979,
-0.6626093388,
-0.1984523833,
-0.2608219087,
0.7388196588,
-0.2643759251,
-0.0726803318,
-0.3105579019,
0.2790609896,
-0.3813485205,
-0.0916717201,
-0.6408199668,
-0.4514119327,
0.410300076,
0.6607400179,
0.7705687284,
0.6884553432,
0.1823955774,
0.2937975526,
-0.0126220724,
0.6634633541,
-0.7158594728,
-0.1722278297,
-0.0197678972,
-0.2468172014,
-0.4314936996,
0.0659016296,
0.6120808721,
1.148337245,
-0.0309781041,
0.0780795068,
-0.0405134484,
0.8459832668,
-0.4347916543,
0.6056573391,
-0.6063275337,
-0.065408133,
0.0205766279,
-0.0019092048,
-0.8608152866,
-0.4850743711,
-0.0487631522,
-0.7176468372,
0.0708755851,
0.1668417901,
0.6143294573,
0.1979073286,
-0.5573525429,
-0.2454123199,
-0.5275996923,
0.2722999454,
-0.6187820435,
0.4384949505,
0.4397245347,
0.1374842077,
-0.5289285183,
-0.8697547913,
-0.3321274221,
-0.0813112706,
0.3043614328,
-0.0455936417,
-0.2999092638,
0.3150711656,
0.295707643,
0.0107332384,
-0.4896564484,
0.3554785252,
-0.2514563203,
-0.0666582137,
0.4237402081,
0.3617058992,
0.6908947825,
0.0236140974,
-0.0011415236,
0.0694672167,
-0.7444389462,
0.2113439292,
0.7142938972,
0.5971106291,
0.0474938452,
0.4448417723,
-0.4326443374,
1.1994798183,
0.0738341436,
0.0532462895,
0.1522966325,
0.0446502231,
-0.010943166,
0.0251262859,
0.5036826134,
0.314375937,
0.4957304597,
-0.3246195912,
0.0349301398,
-0.0435441062,
0.1007204205,
-0.9654930234,
-0.7873804569,
0.133327052,
-0.0433272384,
-0.2222169191,
-0.200446099,
-0.2600189447,
-0.4078526199,
-0.3080953658,
0.1137278602,
-0.6317540407,
-0.1890626252,
0.5669125915,
-0.1573261917,
-0.2745892406,
0.3610424697,
-0.9552350044,
0.1841607094,
0.7806435823,
0.6897915006,
-0.1103860736,
-0.3487438262,
-0.5170053244,
0.2751155794,
-0.7222064137,
0.7445480824,
-0.9399434328,
-0.392459482,
-0.0961947888,
0.0752136037,
-0.3016315997,
-0.3352117538,
0.4485479593,
-0.6102619171,
-0.1105485559,
-0.1857019365,
-0.9411929846,
-0.2050351948,
0.0801905766,
-0.5913450718,
0.9580495358,
0.4312288165,
-0.8280996084,
0.0620734543,
-0.4296431839,
-0.5918245912,
0.2873058319,
-0.1613464952,
-0.3197702467,
-0.1821507663,
0.246701777,
0.1546151191,
-0.0504859015,
0.0421372615,
-0.388284862,
-0.6103696823,
-0.1230802536,
-0.1390481293,
1.1246470213,
-0.2000062764,
-0.1496373117,
0.1842778921,
-0.5670526028,
0.458095938,
0.350269258,
-0.2415997237,
-0.2147344649,
0.1836987436,
-0.5643059015,
0.0679151341,
0.2624925971,
-0.6920503974,
0.441441834,
-0.4457583129,
0.6447786689,
1.090927124,
-0.1906763911,
0.3464839458,
0.206512481,
0.4056205153,
-0.4334224761,
0.345533669,
0.039577812,
-0.5563228726,
-0.6111710072,
-0.1496664733,
0.0643318519,
0.5269524455,
-0.710662365,
0.2244638056,
-0.3883117139,
-0.4612902999,
-0.2049586028,
0.1713000685,
0.2673159242,
1.0149679184,
0.3128680587,
0.2268580198,
-0.2147833705,
-0.7129294276,
0.0386648253,
-0.0356057361,
0.3429644704,
0.623259604,
0.1753856093,
-0.3303101957,
0.7744458318,
-1.0645962954,
0.0839607716,
-0.5685855746,
-0.3486110568,
0.293397665,
0.0465533435,
0.5098239779,
-0.5572888851,
-0.891407311,
0.1524279267,
-0.4286883771,
-0.1494778991,
0.580470562,
-0.3587010205,
-0.0042048735,
0.363491267,
-0.6584377289,
0.1862678528,
0.6011279821,
-0.4679179192,
0.5688246489,
-0.171680674,
-0.0116526075,
-0.6042408943,
-0.276003629,
-0.1621031165,
-0.1371098757,
-0.4618451595,
-0.1100048423,
0.0500543937,
-0.4260512888,
-0.0616590977,
0.4370130897,
-0.3860480785,
-0.0234822556,
-0.3861016035,
0.1633808017,
0.3002409041,
0.445464015,
-0.3397392333,
0.7928468585,
0.6763896942,
-0.4450703561,
0.6717163324,
0.4161532223,
-0.4561766982,
0.012816852,
-0.5700073242,
0.4857267439,
-0.1531534493,
0.1683330834,
-1.0196905136,
-0.2852664888,
0.4045889974,
-0.222961992,
0.4874944687,
-0.6389123201,
-0.6494846344,
-0.7009925842,
0.0185114034,
-0.0164160989,
0.4296233654,
-0.6413226128,
0.3779886365,
0.3560214937,
-0.2673667669,
-0.7027141452,
-0.2410892546,
-0.0274049863,
0.319684267,
-0.6771267056,
0.3335630894,
-0.1121026054,
0.0355911888,
0.2219257355,
-0.2380483001,
-0.1125966609,
0.0694864467,
0.0956519321,
0.4211828113,
0.1129223108,
0.1410303414,
0.1563071609,
-0.2293053418,
-0.0013286332,
-0.4301900864,
0.6484873295,
-0.0067370227,
-0.5472427607,
-0.1982178092,
0.1431958526,
0.0818144605,
-0.4321368635,
0.359115541,
0.148144722,
0.0182633307,
-0.7083037496,
0.0730861574,
0.0461888909,
-0.538974762,
0.8244834542,
-0.3458780944,
-0.6927984953,
0.1897701323,
-0.3143443465,
0.0408671424,
-0.0570071973,
0.1923328936,
-0.2654396594,
1.4116994143,
0.5320500731,
-0.1217276603,
0.6997486353,
-0.4040860534,
0.3640803397,
-0.5524862409,
-0.0931685194,
-0.2800103724,
-0.042574238,
-0.4750091434,
-0.4016195238,
0.1889049411,
-0.0589753799,
-0.5707587004,
0.1543821692,
-0.6800549626,
0.7215103507,
0.2883693576,
0.479806006,
0.1377189755,
0.1712871939,
0.1448038667,
0.1538098603,
-0.9614740014,
-0.252861321,
0.9730782509,
0.0153410677,
0.7126275301,
-0.1234958842,
0.5202675462,
0.2267375588,
0.1920798272,
-0.7351710796,
0.6040579081,
-0.6343140602,
-0.4481774569,
-0.4420312941,
-0.6278320551,
-0.899332583,
-0.1036697254,
0.1770334691,
-0.856216073,
-0.3270726204,
0.3438438773,
0.2102590203,
0.5601164699,
-0.7540278435,
1.0086462498,
-0.402831316,
-0.2324762493,
-0.2136284262,
-0.2863694727,
0.1182830483,
0.4214757085,
0.1588299125,
-0.5161589384,
0.130616352,
0.2920823991,
-0.3910210729,
0.9087634087,
-0.3457958698,
-0.0520203896,
0.4252528846,
0.2028821409,
0.8579238057,
-0.5098472834,
-0.2430687547,
-0.0372804031,
-0.3457775116,
-0.3992494643,
-0.9399174452,
0.726791501,
-0.8278836608,
-0.7656530738,
0.2367926836,
-0.7462646365,
-0.4883990586,
0.5352094173,
0.1335650086,
0.7515662909,
-0.0288816895,
-0.1863820702,
0.7873952985,
-0.1422251314,
0.037794739,
0.241699636,
-0.3120860457,
-0.1553444713,
1.1862545013,
0.31988886,
0.3851515353,
0.2061297745,
0.2594006062,
-0.0444919392,
-0.8265240788,
-0.7361675501,
0.0994532108,
-1.0859316587,
-0.0692719519,
-0.4992311597,
-0.273078084,
-0.2307894379,
-0.1242867187,
-0.5623650551,
-0.2622013986,
0.0015264397,
-0.3406566381,
0.522117734,
0.6784118414,
0.4390619695,
0.0339863598,
-0.4632915556,
0.1245010495,
0.1660091579,
0.7079995275,
-0.0415853113,
-0.3986101449,
-0.4300414622,
0.0736225098,
-0.1491457075,
-0.7756451368,
0.0032112545,
0.1141806319,
0.7483671904,
0.1750202179,
0.208062619,
0.3824953735,
-0.7013931274,
0.2433340997,
-0.0250098985,
-0.8319332004,
0.5115487576,
-0.4030978978,
0.0549374446,
0.2784935236,
0.4381399155,
-0.2263531238,
-0.1961830854,
-0.3522632122,
-0.8740424514,
0.6903062463,
-0.0525553226,
0.305932194,
-0.0271760374,
0.6177877784,
0.0376358069,
0.0019200712,
-0.4717901945,
-0.3672713935,
-0.3120798767,
-0.4258632362,
0.0301247276,
-0.0598552562,
-0.1063287109,
-0.3074590862,
0.7070980072,
-0.3890292645,
0.0317870975,
-0.3455584347,
-0.0288057178,
-0.0844939351,
-0.0680771396,
0.0860434398,
0.8570272923,
-0.037935257,
0.0768867359,
-0.0430423729,
-0.3705030978,
0.1476361305,
0.293400377,
-0.3823353052,
-0.2306156456,
0.4168333709,
0.9969753027,
0.1212640926,
-0.6784336567,
0.4318573773,
0.3344273865,
0.0661343113,
0.0394224413,
0.480830133,
0.3994379938,
0.0381674133,
0.1984710842,
-0.2713764012,
0.2538167238,
-0.2267681658,
-0.0311651025,
0.5064135194,
-0.3927870393,
-0.1763371378,
0.3837865889,
0.3573532701,
-0.36996454,
1.1167603731,
-0.2150216401,
-0.6078539491,
0.9685112238,
0.7788339853,
0.4358735085,
0.0253369045,
0.4738243818,
0.3054277897,
0.158506453,
0.1570880562,
0.1280481368,
0.10108307,
-1.0877146721,
-0.4752683043,
-0.0000752666,
-0.6033505797,
-0.2273529023,
-0.452745378,
0.2135113925,
-0.5608001947,
-0.2319811136,
0.0819229782,
0.0972581282,
-0.4092829525,
0.0757159516,
0.0225456487,
0.8404896259,
-0.6969841719,
0.7596811652,
0.6252474785,
-0.2113784105,
-0.894469738,
-0.0957845524,
-0.2176704258,
-0.9018540978,
0.7468056679,
0.2065501511,
-0.5190568566,
0.3858141005,
-0.8595046997,
-0.7976889014,
0.873128593,
0.8670037389,
-0.5166074634,
-0.1669210643,
-0.0179609302,
0.2057584375,
-0.3500236273,
-0.0694923028,
0.3910009563,
0.3044753075,
0.0074441396,
-0.5039963722,
-0.0135751804,
-0.0965288356,
-0.2098670602,
0.3869123459,
-0.9161916375,
0.8331153989,
-0.5972026587,
-0.1333203018,
-0.3885728121,
0.2707297206,
0.312823385,
0.2664504349,
0.4101752043,
0.3170942366,
0.9630910158,
0.1278428137,
1.2078641653,
-0.5748310089,
0.2383424044,
1.2798968554,
-0.3334121406,
0.4627840817,
0.0002957096,
-0.3584589362,
0.8492732048,
0.7355480194,
0.0696973279,
0.4871281981,
0.1440733671,
0.0152666215,
-0.5471115112,
0.0514418036,
-0.1469896585,
0.4096809924,
0.3251675665,
-0.2594861388,
-0.0655177757,
-0.2969765067,
0.1692169905,
0.2048526406,
-0.3896796405,
0.2649941742,
-0.1417962909,
-0.3228515685,
0.2641975582,
-0.0708820596,
-0.0135862259,
-0.6292393208,
-0.1868854761,
-0.16687648,
0.0959199443,
-0.2471110374,
-0.9705097079,
-0.054480236,
-0.2678946555,
-0.3509454131,
0.0272225179,
0.7546033859,
-0.1742371619,
-0.638756454,
0.4944704175,
0.351346761,
-0.106197685,
0.1977178007,
-0.6982523799,
0.1056019962,
0.2465344667,
-0.17972444,
0.1913579255,
0.4253692627,
0.0007845084,
1.0741578341,
0.4567866623,
0.1036542654,
-0.1038415879,
0.3627165556,
1.0639904737,
-0.2933042049,
-0.4526240528,
-0.6597134471,
0.2374918908,
-0.2702531219,
-0.0821278542,
0.8360345364,
0.6401817203,
0.7585209608,
0.1529916376,
0.937861383,
0.2112528235,
0.3662670851,
-0.5397487283,
0.3723486066,
-0.2615171671,
0.0251426473,
-0.4220949113,
-0.6554328799,
0.0540910922,
0.4844096601,
-0.6236029267,
0.1316333413,
0.1637349129,
0.6064317822,
-0.0710947067,
-0.1663120091,
-0.0157633461,
0.0659786388,
0.348954469,
0.7648203373,
0.7433926463,
-0.0204120111,
0.7345568538,
-0.2113423645,
-0.3076865375,
-0.0956174061,
-0.665107131,
-0.9365724921,
-0.2051926553,
-0.4517506063,
-0.3091425002,
0.2278505415,
0.7819190025,
0.6817436814,
-0.4698021412,
-0.0273887683,
-0.2943543494,
0.4389232695,
-0.1896744668,
-0.2019534409,
0.5238600373,
-0.3776487112,
-0.8100873232,
0.5731335878,
0.3763829172,
-0.0481951721,
-0.0972327739,
-0.1422602385,
0.1565763503,
0.1517552435,
0.5354010463,
0.2278454155,
-0.3300552964,
-0.5503123999,
0.1312977374,
-0.185769707,
0.194938004,
0.7856639028,
-0.2936642468,
0.7295233011,
0.4464205205,
0.5910500884,
0.7094696164,
-0.0575456917,
0.4930220842,
-0.4658424258,
0.1659074724,
0.081142284,
0.3719892502,
0.4415965676,
-0.5363625884,
0.4517379403,
0.1937667727,
-0.3591524363,
-0.8176447749,
0.6715981364,
-0.5090906024,
-0.640440464,
1.0256832838,
-0.2822059095,
-0.0508467406,
-0.0845845193,
-0.1770916283,
0.3146310747,
-0.2704795301,
0.6073639989,
0.6174705029,
-0.7477836013,
-0.3381496668,
-0.4722950757,
0.3466557562,
-0.1346981525,
-0.6654839516,
0.3849956989,
0.6926271319,
0.5093536973,
-0.2583305836,
0.6628314853,
0.1710671633,
0.140938282,
0.4242460728,
0.0785203576,
-0.7074115872,
-0.3503746986,
0.3154482543,
0.111289978,
0.3027452528,
-0.095265992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16024v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16024v2
|
HiGPT: Heterogeneous Graph Language Model
| 2024-02-25T08:07:22 | 2024-05-19T02:28:56 |
Jiabin Tang, Yuhao Yang, Wei Wei, Lei Shi, Long Xia, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Heterogeneous graph learning aims to capture complex relationships and
diverse relational semantics among entities in a heterogeneous graph to obtain
meaningful representations for nodes and edges. Recent advancements in
heterogeneous graph neural networks (HGNNs) have achieved state-of-the-art
performance by considering relation heterogeneity and using specialized message
functions and aggregation rules. However, existing frameworks for heterogeneous
graph learning have limitations in generalizing across diverse heterogeneous
graph datasets. Most of these frameworks follow the "pre-train" and "fine-tune"
paradigm on the same dataset, which restricts their capacity to adapt to new
and unseen data. This raises the question: "Can we generalize heterogeneous
graph models to be well-adapted to diverse downstream learning tasks with
distribution shifts in both node token sets and relation type heterogeneity?''
To tackle those challenges, we propose HiGPT, a general large graph model with
Heterogeneous graph instruction-tuning paradigm. Our framework enables learning
from arbitrary heterogeneous graphs without the need for any fine-tuning
process from downstream datasets. To handle distribution shifts in
heterogeneity, we introduce an in-context heterogeneous graph tokenizer that
captures semantic relationships in different heterogeneous graphs, facilitating
model adaptation. We incorporate a large corpus of heterogeneity-aware graph
instructions into our HiGPT, enabling the model to effectively comprehend
complex relation heterogeneity and distinguish between various types of graph
tokens. Furthermore, we introduce the Mixture-of-Thought (MoT) instruction
augmentation paradigm to mitigate data scarcity by generating diverse and
informative instructions. Through comprehensive evaluations, our proposed
framework demonstrates exceptional performance in terms of generalization
performance.
|
[
-0.3814176321,
-1.2175079584,
0.1683038175,
0.0873809382,
-0.1327517033,
0.0231002383,
-0.1221742406,
-0.3934384286,
-0.0232524537,
0.4422707856,
-0.4205851555,
-0.538571775,
-0.4916216433,
-0.2246199697,
0.2140140533,
1.168992877,
-0.1302087754,
-0.1190343052,
0.1635797918,
-0.2521600425,
-0.4860425591,
-0.3437652886,
-0.5039567947,
-0.5274274349,
0.5588315129,
0.2119004875,
0.8328278661,
1.0414167643,
0.3714679778,
0.1749659479,
0.0258818157,
0.0426796265,
-0.7904567122,
-0.2694410682,
-0.2103684545,
-0.0528050289,
-0.4838090241,
0.045444306,
0.8095869422,
1.0498495102,
-0.0166761391,
0.0819759518,
0.1440100819,
0.1866129488,
-0.6335184574,
0.4953354001,
-0.7006061077,
0.2658476532,
-0.067332767,
0.038413804,
-0.3242019117,
-0.285349369,
0.2651477754,
-0.7184112668,
0.2314332575,
0.2651363015,
0.9348055124,
0.1041878685,
-0.4047352076,
0.0845894888,
-0.6837425232,
0.2735627294,
-0.5646218657,
0.3670391738,
0.0831959397,
0.5312311053,
0.1579770446,
-1.1390042305,
-0.3767031431,
-0.0340803638,
0.1491490304,
0.1417342275,
0.0477240309,
0.1078850925,
0.3169052601,
0.3360852599,
-0.3177820444,
0.3307863176,
-0.0073273284,
-0.3292471766,
0.0420514978,
0.1642693728,
0.2729906142,
-0.2250928879,
-0.5699566603,
-0.0423380211,
-0.6330481172,
-0.3156603575,
0.6001292467,
0.5994771123,
-0.1789307594,
0.3460948765,
-0.0773469657,
0.6628090143,
0.0261319503,
0.156295687,
0.4373933375,
-0.2200840265,
-0.2488134056,
-0.0924155712,
0.6947338581,
-0.0087493332,
0.190902397,
-0.2311649621,
-0.1281062663,
-0.1574704349,
-0.0631167963,
-1.0271002054,
-0.5072917342,
-0.3334128261,
-0.5017776489,
-0.0771007314,
0.0593644567,
-0.9274024963,
-0.0097755715,
-0.1512503475,
0.2347942889,
-0.4072663486,
-0.2313963622,
0.1060757861,
-0.1323193163,
-0.1160463169,
0.2678471804,
-0.9205818772,
0.3209297657,
0.5611128807,
0.6749721169,
-0.1218056381,
-0.7430810332,
-0.7884400487,
0.4014797509,
-0.006199182,
0.4810764194,
-0.7708849311,
-0.1582750529,
0.0332600921,
0.1010289639,
-0.5018537045,
-0.1646090895,
0.2228788733,
-0.6305981278,
0.3121032417,
-0.1673056036,
-0.5514242053,
-0.0762981027,
0.4938108027,
-0.6161546111,
0.8592995405,
0.6642492414,
-1.0359746218,
0.1084099114,
-0.7572581768,
-0.5636000633,
0.314691335,
-0.2038349509,
-0.5307238102,
-0.3883047104,
0.0784374401,
0.3914983869,
-0.29140836,
-0.085698083,
-0.5729450583,
-0.4808102548,
-0.3769141734,
-0.3862628043,
0.7716930509,
0.1097027734,
-0.2554813325,
0.1898461431,
-0.4102391005,
0.1198211685,
0.0939615816,
-0.5636092424,
-0.1391091794,
-0.2000104636,
0.1408842355,
0.3721163571,
0.0759572014,
-0.4510169327,
0.1214926764,
-0.37251091,
0.8367827535,
0.8947778344,
0.2808820307,
0.4318667352,
-0.0414881557,
0.4162072837,
-0.141675204,
0.0459764786,
-0.1200160012,
-0.5633679628,
-0.3413842916,
-0.2048522234,
0.4185732305,
0.6775408387,
-0.6886834502,
0.3812058568,
-0.5196510553,
-0.1237246618,
-0.0809185356,
0.0032010318,
0.328158021,
0.8836300373,
0.387101382,
-0.2383286506,
-0.2925924659,
-0.5368216038,
0.0413197279,
-0.061232321,
0.2451501936,
0.7153119445,
0.4785205722,
-0.7982834578,
0.7115523815,
-0.8187997341,
-0.0171546601,
-0.093377918,
0.1293391585,
-0.120034501,
0.495076865,
0.5439485312,
-0.8939073086,
-0.6201320291,
0.4405377209,
-0.6629239917,
0.3338073194,
0.3970723748,
-0.3011310995,
-0.3060628176,
0.6628744602,
-0.4805082977,
0.2746085823,
0.4998871386,
-0.277341485,
0.5335350037,
-0.3313251734,
-0.1846091896,
-1.1298300028,
-0.0892440453,
-0.124704808,
-0.2277026772,
-0.2417201251,
0.1360224783,
-0.0077544204,
-0.5109956861,
-0.3572039306,
0.3510269821,
-0.3779340386,
-0.1034688875,
-0.0680502877,
-0.1229520366,
-0.1335092336,
0.5864583254,
-0.289357394,
0.5984804034,
0.6170115471,
-0.4949096739,
0.6771588326,
0.3628504872,
0.1365355998,
0.4710283875,
-0.5704490542,
0.2915561199,
-0.1600832045,
0.331556648,
-0.8950254917,
-0.5295701027,
0.4610162675,
-0.085786283,
0.3119116127,
-0.5666136742,
-0.3870069087,
-0.5324397683,
0.1045033634,
0.3558886647,
0.626647234,
-0.6094487309,
0.752916038,
0.2065175921,
0.0902028829,
-0.5501691699,
-0.3947698474,
-0.0613502674,
-0.1121671796,
-0.5955017209,
0.242099002,
0.0510548577,
0.3517892957,
0.4143133759,
-0.0211815126,
-0.1704014093,
0.1128066108,
0.237834543,
0.3264917135,
-0.6094271541,
0.3873838484,
-0.111133568,
-0.1893639117,
-0.0628009886,
-0.8951323628,
0.9346083403,
-0.2616121471,
-0.5897146463,
-0.1254674941,
0.1060471162,
0.2250221819,
-0.5097752213,
0.6543804407,
1.0162104368,
-0.3951579332,
-0.1669561267,
-0.0045836405,
-0.0784660056,
-0.4051451981,
0.8116956949,
-0.6656996012,
-1.0649889708,
0.5805761218,
-0.4631362557,
-0.2476083338,
0.421372205,
0.574680984,
-0.0100157931,
0.8860437274,
0.6237192154,
-0.3224596679,
0.6439528465,
-0.2555993497,
0.499050349,
-0.6861007214,
0.1891983151,
-0.4129697382,
-0.1675385237,
-0.9126337171,
-0.2138214111,
0.2118231803,
-0.139031589,
-0.6365766525,
0.1474829167,
-0.4157400131,
0.6585085392,
0.3204877973,
0.2310523242,
-0.1070114747,
0.2661629617,
-0.0984176919,
0.3859958351,
-0.8774337173,
-0.2009678483,
0.9121770263,
0.3521021008,
0.7372091413,
-0.1165757924,
0.5988798738,
0.1748206913,
0.3796774745,
-0.6090831757,
0.2071435601,
-0.2692681253,
-0.3351843953,
-0.5845636725,
-0.7670131922,
-0.989733696,
0.1599407494,
-0.0390186422,
-0.8662163615,
0.0897659659,
0.3304405808,
-0.0740396976,
0.5851020813,
-0.8489349484,
1.2404386997,
0.2558384836,
-0.400796771,
0.1250361055,
-0.8249105215,
0.2019742727,
0.1548287123,
0.017439967,
-0.1735481769,
0.2541365921,
0.2929454148,
-0.1653523743,
0.9280304313,
-0.3219900727,
0.1816211045,
0.3864811957,
0.0058294199,
0.7902370691,
0.0477173626,
-0.13314192,
-0.026418956,
-0.3322566748,
-0.6801025271,
-0.4660278261,
0.7079841495,
-0.9530394673,
-0.3259007931,
0.1513119042,
-0.8543031216,
-0.4215770364,
0.5139827728,
0.5809700489,
0.3031504154,
-0.4416368306,
-0.0474069938,
0.660861969,
0.1196155921,
0.1070924178,
-0.2518239021,
-0.1048169732,
-0.2225625366,
1.2560354471,
0.0312731788,
0.6145840883,
0.2548469603,
0.3735266924,
-0.1268791109,
-0.484115243,
-0.580286324,
0.1725858301,
-0.9804345369,
0.1456874311,
-0.9013682604,
-0.3431595862,
-0.4131643772,
-0.0748323873,
-0.221209079,
-0.1184666306,
-0.2818874121,
-0.0914561972,
0.0489828996,
0.4754349291,
0.2068633288,
0.4662386477,
-0.5779568553,
0.2454822659,
0.6151840687,
0.4287879467,
-0.0356244631,
-0.2534183562,
-0.3377510607,
0.2018799335,
-0.0712487027,
-0.6741552949,
-0.0051093465,
0.1841535717,
0.4395158887,
0.1845064461,
-0.2607721686,
0.3980464339,
-0.4373300076,
0.3241877258,
0.2549484968,
-0.7631174326,
0.120887205,
-0.6067823768,
0.1058915854,
0.2543159723,
0.3498319387,
-0.5158901215,
0.2272213399,
-0.6870214343,
-0.6122747064,
0.5277855992,
-0.1088334695,
0.4257281125,
0.1327637881,
0.3896803558,
0.0509212948,
0.2807990909,
-0.6902900338,
0.0039344942,
-0.7674674988,
-0.3209346533,
-0.0795987174,
0.075531587,
-0.2468069494,
-0.2460510284,
0.3570508659,
-0.6342182159,
0.3544700742,
-0.3027528226,
0.0483531803,
-0.1218311936,
0.2473873943,
-0.1900497526,
0.6102564931,
-0.2831243873,
0.3474162221,
0.1327347755,
-0.5335299373,
0.0462924242,
0.5280767679,
-0.3360233903,
-0.2229932398,
0.3746388853,
1.1871269941,
-0.0508516021,
-0.3363544047,
0.4780625999,
0.1595628113,
-0.0962490663,
0.4146424532,
0.2180021852,
0.3713860214,
-0.1882407814,
-0.1667963862,
0.1740116477,
-0.0226951763,
-0.7303478718,
0.1386030465,
0.1620712429,
-0.6494692564,
-0.3069464266,
0.5321458578,
0.1358187795,
-0.3314066231,
0.9470009208,
-0.4875983596,
-0.6331562996,
0.6556425691,
0.9706632495,
0.6465929747,
-0.1090137288,
0.2743285,
0.2869614065,
0.0837012902,
0.1052079946,
-0.0264739152,
0.0858386308,
-1.0414469242,
-0.1841374189,
-0.3020942509,
-0.1654470116,
-0.2198939174,
-0.3683801889,
-0.0195041802,
-0.703151226,
0.0030596606,
0.1744231433,
-0.2884033918,
-0.7280923128,
0.2035457492,
-0.2824496031,
0.4818662107,
-0.8570821881,
0.8145651817,
0.7606828809,
-0.4372562468,
-1.0701054335,
0.1852543652,
-0.3817141056,
-0.923335433,
0.5284156799,
0.0011095197,
0.0506884679,
0.4273608029,
-0.5903027058,
-0.5220781565,
0.8603643775,
0.5051150918,
-0.20614326,
-0.3930612206,
0.2263024747,
0.3659456968,
-0.6208047867,
-0.100141488,
0.3704593778,
0.3773554564,
0.3487504423,
-0.6123433709,
-0.0101292916,
-0.1226892918,
0.0954205692,
0.3933457732,
-0.6827551126,
1.4891115427,
-0.123618342,
-0.1109812036,
-0.5381093621,
0.4179427028,
-0.0916862264,
0.3089504242,
0.4366930425,
0.5569865704,
0.8821277618,
-0.0137595832,
1.2002938986,
-0.1167346165,
0.5396947861,
1.303237319,
-0.5654224157,
0.2456067801,
0.2464159727,
0.0119270189,
0.3779767454,
0.650986135,
0.0099196173,
0.4704024196,
0.2263742238,
-0.1910413802,
-0.3567512631,
-0.1169968024,
-0.51092273,
0.2256836146,
0.2363188267,
-0.1628692746,
-0.5024835467,
0.0706860274,
-0.1166186556,
-0.0056337868,
-0.232067883,
0.443821311,
-0.1041474268,
-0.3217023015,
0.5706207156,
0.1547578126,
0.3060424626,
-0.545009017,
-0.1260594726,
0.1938758194,
0.105145067,
-0.2120101005,
-0.5315946341,
0.049998913,
-0.4534882009,
-0.2357895225,
0.1168622971,
0.8820158839,
-0.1681935489,
-0.1829957962,
0.324346751,
0.7112087011,
-0.2864967585,
-0.0061578862,
-0.7088514566,
-0.1046755016,
0.0581254885,
-0.1434390098,
0.3197367489,
0.9037865996,
-0.2350539118,
0.5402514338,
0.6489693522,
-0.1432797909,
0.2289214581,
0.1920538247,
1.0326151848,
-0.3139665425,
-0.7985488176,
-0.5980987549,
0.0432587601,
0.0422928967,
-0.4588363767,
0.7647803426,
0.5341027379,
0.9480262995,
0.0200036634,
0.9380862117,
-0.0576675907,
0.0279667955,
-0.5218132138,
0.3530604243,
-0.1698101759,
0.0261269081,
-0.2794736922,
-0.9808704257,
0.0323574133,
0.5427641273,
-0.5365260243,
0.2848693728,
0.5380750895,
0.5311514139,
-0.6671097279,
0.2344532609,
-0.0080960914,
0.1671111137,
0.3094287217,
0.6908172369,
0.8033745289,
-0.291064471,
0.3942153156,
0.0781716853,
-0.0779920667,
-0.2839355767,
-0.6582189202,
-0.8701164722,
-0.3987046182,
-0.3697529435,
-0.493445456,
0.3034315109,
0.8389235735,
0.9700319767,
-0.3556899726,
-0.012173838,
-0.3291796148,
0.2235077769,
-0.1685971618,
-0.233839035,
0.5744707584,
-0.3075221479,
-0.5627644658,
-0.0668726563,
0.3117586076,
0.3381082118,
0.02115779,
-0.3787593842,
-0.1881451607,
-0.255286783,
0.452008009,
0.2889471054,
-0.0551243611,
-0.4618263841,
-0.0985446498,
-0.3510839343,
0.4646424353,
0.7732876539,
-0.3333004713,
0.2669200599,
0.4658765495,
0.9431718588,
0.928974092,
-0.0447573364,
0.2129682302,
-0.7996818423,
0.3983594477,
0.506603241,
0.2211470157,
0.2508297265,
-0.5420914292,
0.4616657495,
0.5926142335,
-0.2137931734,
-0.6309816837,
0.5928978324,
-0.7744569182,
-0.3688125014,
0.8740964532,
-0.3804007769,
-0.3467466831,
-0.1343159229,
-0.0773278028,
0.5943735838,
-0.1511373222,
0.3451474607,
0.5412054062,
-0.0157902706,
0.0192043204,
-0.5297302604,
0.0519150496,
-0.0125806844,
-1.0863819122,
0.0711088777,
0.5405094624,
0.476377517,
-0.1016553864,
0.6951550245,
0.0293963999,
0.1279769093,
0.229867816,
-0.0650351569,
-0.2186054587,
-0.1940255314,
0.0755467042,
0.5169513226,
-0.1069203913,
-0.1767509431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16021v1
|
TMT: Tri-Modal Translation between Speech, Image, and Text by Processing Different Modalities as Different Languages
| 2024-02-25T07:46:57 | 2024-02-25T07:46:57 |
Minsu Kim, Jee-weon Jung, Hyeongseop Rha, Soumi Maiti, Siddhant Arora, Xuankai Chang, Shinji Watanabe, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, eess.AS
|
The capability to jointly process multi-modal information is becoming an
essential task. However, the limited number of paired multi-modal data and the
large computational requirements in multi-modal learning hinder the
development. We propose a novel Tri-Modal Translation (TMT) model that
translates between arbitrary modalities spanning speech, image, and text. We
introduce a novel viewpoint, where we interpret different modalities as
different languages, and treat multi-modal translation as a well-established
machine translation problem. To this end, we tokenize speech and image data
into discrete tokens, which provide a unified interface across modalities and
significantly decrease the computational cost. In the proposed TMT, a
multi-modal encoder-decoder conducts the core translation, whereas
modality-specific processing is conducted only within the tokenization and
detokenization stages. We evaluate the proposed TMT on all six modality
translation tasks. TMT outperforms single model counterparts consistently,
demonstrating that unifying tasks is beneficial not only for practicality but
also for performance.
|
[
-0.1958170235,
-0.7019196749,
0.4827878177,
0.1399116963,
-0.8586751819,
0.3356422782,
-0.2054738402,
-0.4834650755,
-0.0964420661,
0.1703542471,
-0.3075556457,
-0.4062412083,
-0.4729350209,
0.0992011204,
-0.3877440393,
0.7480796576,
-0.1582117826,
0.4540193975,
0.3310490549,
-0.0124556581,
-0.6615630984,
-0.2946111858,
-0.4361657798,
-0.2944983244,
0.5077190995,
0.1590192467,
0.7707728744,
0.5958834291,
0.4762334824,
0.1818083674,
0.2054128647,
0.2923230529,
-0.031648621,
-0.1059665382,
-0.0529086702,
-0.441693902,
-0.2980553508,
-0.1069786176,
0.8455011249,
0.7633132935,
0.4020808339,
0.0676289871,
-0.1987108737,
0.2217808366,
-0.2825974524,
-0.0162539128,
-0.4256994426,
-0.023587089,
-0.4679355621,
-0.4506680965,
-0.3715318739,
-0.1255803406,
-0.0899297819,
-0.4544028044,
-0.006793343,
0.1013264358,
0.4480569363,
0.3667638302,
-0.966658175,
0.2148636281,
-0.8524766564,
0.7412377,
-0.4870065749,
0.6085264087,
0.1049282104,
0.4289796948,
0.1750722677,
-0.7346307039,
-0.6154144406,
-0.1424118131,
0.060049966,
-0.0705420971,
-0.0437124707,
0.1623472571,
-0.2458704263,
0.4302177429,
-0.3813737929,
-0.1499563307,
-0.3586795628,
-0.0898467451,
0.1043426469,
0.1671865731,
0.6964634061,
-0.429962337,
-0.8054754138,
0.16518794,
-0.2726557851,
-0.0288083218,
-0.2007498592,
0.4534808695,
-0.3199700415,
0.6343111992,
0.2451065779,
0.7479157448,
-0.1168964282,
-0.2479572892,
0.3219189346,
-0.7194780111,
-0.2659204602,
-0.1113724038,
0.774730742,
0.4298638403,
-0.2031165957,
-0.6113327742,
-0.2285904884,
0.0451736189,
0.2109146118,
-0.6256992221,
0.3413962424,
0.1946315467,
-0.6594991088,
-0.383502543,
-0.1180386096,
-0.5199359059,
-0.0551288836,
-0.445548147,
0.7475840449,
-0.6048082113,
-0.5060682893,
0.345905751,
-0.080013521,
0.1383375376,
0.2424187958,
-0.52884835,
0.2423250824,
0.463167578,
1.0843205452,
-0.3695591986,
-0.4761310518,
-0.2639353275,
0.6117045879,
-0.3246907294,
0.5913392305,
-0.841132462,
-0.4077382982,
-0.3367511928,
-0.2235810608,
-0.4536065161,
-0.0829097182,
0.3989642262,
-0.446490854,
0.4750583768,
-0.1958936304,
-0.123758316,
-0.3914630711,
0.2527078688,
-0.8017184138,
0.6702164412,
-0.0123646483,
-0.5903758407,
0.1557392478,
-1.0208193064,
-0.6793267131,
0.1936610043,
-0.1998184919,
-0.1652656049,
0.4157123566,
0.17802912,
0.3150184453,
-0.7517228127,
0.4795646071,
-0.159599334,
-0.3466868997,
0.479078114,
-0.6192953587,
0.6157230735,
0.1603436023,
-0.2958788276,
0.0988966972,
-0.5149563551,
0.0465614386,
-0.0345200598,
-0.425128907,
-0.2806889117,
-0.3200380802,
0.6312201619,
0.6209079623,
0.3863352537,
-0.6794705391,
0.1647659987,
-0.0225021578,
0.829654038,
0.4754589498,
0.056245558,
0.452057302,
-0.4670677483,
0.2877419889,
0.3147717416,
0.1442000717,
-0.1133653298,
-0.2945961356,
-0.409858942,
-0.582444489,
0.3017769158,
0.3643499911,
-1.1361074448,
-0.1782646179,
-0.5190560222,
-0.1906845272,
-0.7672553658,
-0.3844513595,
0.4525960386,
0.5432136059,
0.6143494248,
-0.2939483225,
-0.401933372,
-0.9294767976,
-0.4892743528,
0.0627093911,
0.0200182181,
0.0982843414,
0.2175118774,
-0.1202546731,
0.5908481479,
0.0791354179,
-0.4455694854,
-0.2763708532,
0.4813235402,
-0.0518517122,
0.6273180842,
0.4990956783,
-1.0255689621,
-0.3059413731,
0.3438428342,
-0.5182031393,
0.0962238312,
-0.3350212872,
0.0846084654,
0.1877339631,
0.3429891467,
-0.5442119837,
0.289560169,
0.4805518687,
-0.1403162032,
0.0335189924,
-0.0108819315,
0.5184381604,
-1.6436775923,
0.4380494356,
-0.4242645502,
-0.4690266252,
-0.7147617936,
-0.0916298926,
0.2149808854,
-0.1972786188,
-0.644305706,
0.3238761127,
-0.3589502871,
-0.1442566216,
-0.1293713003,
-0.1896094978,
0.0299618915,
0.6740857363,
-0.0554381944,
0.8806241155,
0.4841531813,
-0.453466624,
0.2012670338,
0.0654380396,
0.0695618093,
0.8887078166,
-0.5573982596,
0.2558788061,
-0.0206487626,
0.2333022654,
-0.9205340743,
-0.2997808754,
0.2780826688,
-0.366006434,
0.3132771254,
0.0450887233,
-0.5794740319,
-0.1222869232,
-0.0983411893,
1.0702949762,
-0.0005129884,
-0.2366356403,
0.8718537092,
0.3093338609,
0.1386134177,
-0.3083471656,
-0.9303171635,
0.570207417,
-0.1736689806,
-0.4379355609,
0.5778835416,
-0.0103610754,
0.1903304011,
0.260186255,
-0.2837336361,
-0.3367683887,
-0.135197863,
0.0274766944,
0.2124886066,
-0.0134996558,
0.4284578264,
0.0485690199,
-0.1028815806,
-0.3122683465,
-0.7108257413,
0.5866814852,
-0.2833800912,
-0.3473266363,
-0.6800934672,
0.7662261128,
1.1190069914,
-0.4818595648,
0.5262432694,
0.9608764648,
-0.4876933396,
0.3020910323,
-0.4286094904,
0.1489375532,
-0.3709177673,
0.440967977,
-0.8170457482,
-0.7395927906,
0.2055276185,
-0.207022205,
0.0942070708,
0.2882195711,
0.6621035337,
-0.0423122309,
1.2139804363,
0.5539199114,
0.2365751266,
0.7315236926,
-0.0124569861,
0.3315536082,
-0.7324389815,
-0.4876957536,
-0.2400662452,
-0.6198747158,
-0.2870739102,
-0.7577015162,
0.7029121518,
-0.1823827028,
-0.166473791,
0.3333065212,
-0.4154935777,
0.5518761873,
0.5570799708,
0.4682492316,
0.6073869467,
-0.0031313617,
-0.3450231552,
-0.0911342129,
-0.428643018,
-0.4547798932,
1.0253278017,
0.1275705993,
0.4982337356,
0.28893435,
0.4422653019,
0.2043396384,
0.0018446195,
-0.8485540748,
0.455008775,
-0.3777399957,
-0.6750281453,
-0.0322705358,
-0.3902928829,
-0.7587987781,
0.4265328944,
-0.0670728758,
-0.3876456618,
0.1048647836,
-0.3026070297,
0.0023329691,
0.7541177273,
-0.5957794189,
0.7953788042,
-0.5829516053,
-0.0968397707,
-0.4448854923,
-0.8729374409,
0.3974877298,
-0.3147462606,
0.3033027053,
-0.0003811948,
-0.5769104362,
0.3265560567,
0.0195701011,
0.8728553653,
0.0256135557,
0.1836424023,
-0.1896292716,
0.4220508337,
-0.1525861025,
-0.0897009149,
0.0889004022,
0.3702375591,
0.2210146636,
-0.371562928,
-0.3934466243,
0.2201821059,
-0.8913117647,
-0.1703266352,
-0.1863140017,
-1.2530517578,
-0.2391882539,
0.6938990951,
0.2493970245,
0.569748342,
-0.2861941457,
0.2418138683,
0.1810912788,
0.1969868243,
0.7107123137,
0.450317204,
-0.0896411687,
-0.8331716061,
0.9138388634,
-0.0870536044,
0.4725051522,
0.7164445519,
0.0660561621,
-0.292650491,
-0.4745895565,
-0.6576997042,
0.315759033,
-0.4379471838,
-0.2914740145,
-0.6979056597,
0.1292692572,
-0.072143957,
0.0013415638,
-0.574814558,
-0.7761380672,
-0.3948404789,
0.3417088091,
-0.1632732898,
0.746743381,
-0.2488385737,
0.2508312762,
-0.8586995602,
0.816319108,
0.3766898513,
0.4852268994,
-0.2072823197,
-0.4380112886,
-0.2807776332,
0.2365859002,
-0.2621791065,
-0.9031612277,
0.4001350999,
0.2188169509,
0.3598140478,
0.0498625375,
-0.1072664931,
0.7902914286,
-0.450971067,
0.6839462519,
0.6498719454,
-1.267832756,
0.2896544933,
-0.4479398131,
0.4082551897,
0.3796828985,
0.1265296042,
-0.8927986026,
-0.1119830087,
-0.1980028152,
-0.5035516024,
0.7810810208,
0.1578409076,
-0.1208166182,
0.1669739783,
-0.0429324433,
0.2607726455,
0.4340125024,
-0.7741665244,
0.0752903894,
-0.4411277771,
-0.2130216807,
0.1895942688,
0.0709629804,
-0.465321511,
-0.2960769534,
0.191027239,
-0.1417691857,
0.5031222701,
0.0343839116,
-0.4521797895,
-0.3129508793,
0.5017067194,
0.7033104897,
0.2806007862,
0.001214984,
0.5384017229,
-0.0652042106,
-0.2624998987,
0.2411405444,
0.0968233496,
-0.0713068768,
0.1243182197,
0.0089037726,
0.9171664119,
0.4325703084,
-0.1627620012,
0.5624114871,
-0.17567949,
-0.001052406,
0.2332469672,
-0.5270826221,
-0.00026593,
0.4394823313,
0.4803087711,
0.6276310086,
0.1089451462,
-0.3786536753,
0.1075221971,
0.2919712365,
-0.2608146369,
-0.7105161548,
0.8973655701,
0.2887824178,
-0.4084932804,
0.0704171658,
0.1815280318,
-0.453605473,
0.1306589842,
0.7664061189,
1.1999915838,
-0.2296937853,
0.2642069757,
0.0119388532,
0.3734481037,
-0.0626688302,
0.3718425333,
-0.22772865,
-0.3363130093,
-0.382670939,
-0.3742948174,
-0.3007616401,
-0.0820317343,
-0.5029302239,
0.2910492122,
-0.0927989706,
-0.3103013337,
-0.1935786605,
-0.3732118905,
-0.767142415,
0.0366892032,
0.3248152435,
0.4878698289,
-0.7608748674,
0.9325105548,
0.9143865108,
-0.6399147511,
-0.6202028394,
-0.0219858158,
-0.1622980833,
-0.7027176023,
0.4016696513,
0.0739302337,
-0.386642307,
0.2667291164,
-0.3996186554,
-0.9084879756,
1.0733817816,
0.7545153499,
-0.0996246636,
-0.3736468256,
0.6778215766,
0.3133073449,
-0.4293791354,
-0.0504766442,
0.4594472349,
0.463272959,
0.1432739347,
-1.4164315462,
0.0888881162,
-0.302708894,
0.3170210421,
0.1034744531,
-0.6865537763,
1.0920863152,
0.0203739852,
-0.4553812742,
-0.1114857718,
0.2333505303,
-0.0848159418,
0.2032581717,
0.3833885193,
0.3653246462,
0.5245603919,
0.012581504,
0.8696421981,
-0.4437527955,
0.2296084166,
0.8890439868,
0.2119192779,
0.5043774247,
0.9150078893,
0.1943006068,
0.1398252994,
0.4491906464,
0.3951713443,
0.6225495934,
-0.3847973049,
-0.5314823389,
-0.619132936,
-0.5928516984,
-0.4673855603,
0.6793463826,
0.3187396824,
-0.3047476113,
-0.5487859249,
0.3554629087,
-0.2105898708,
-0.1124189422,
-0.3086969852,
0.4483363628,
0.2140800655,
-0.2956552505,
0.7533986568,
0.0728729218,
0.4113608003,
-0.3282056749,
0.1121214703,
0.036001347,
-0.0684476271,
-0.112510927,
-0.5876556039,
0.2960790992,
-0.3012134135,
-0.1659577936,
-0.4940310121,
0.4754073918,
-0.7219987512,
-0.405318439,
0.0343440436,
0.8046878576,
0.002149557,
-0.0035372349,
-0.5276775956,
0.2947650552,
-0.1832811981,
0.0060905362,
-0.0456233025,
0.7104354501,
-0.1791629493,
0.5000629425,
0.4905657172,
-0.0364695527,
0.2968200445,
0.0830235928,
1.087225914,
-0.7710053325,
-0.5993116498,
-0.6965181828,
0.5615316629,
0.2111999691,
-0.1009674817,
0.3004155457,
0.489230603,
0.6176617742,
-0.0389128737,
0.9021351933,
-0.197851494,
0.2669965625,
-0.416621238,
0.3606927693,
-0.8452541232,
0.0597589388,
-0.1215153337,
-0.7189850211,
-0.6859068871,
0.306653291,
-0.2649861574,
-0.1236275509,
1.0235620737,
0.3960340619,
-0.3230590224,
0.1331875175,
0.4237239957,
0.0256636553,
0.4620501399,
0.8871825933,
0.6486749053,
-0.6878585815,
0.8486533165,
-0.1288323998,
0.0352768376,
-0.1200225204,
-0.7024303675,
-0.9316183925,
-0.7975997925,
0.0729738176,
-0.1150208563,
-0.3520179987,
1.0332978964,
0.6965469718,
-0.5564284325,
-0.1875341684,
-0.1550734937,
0.0133434916,
-0.2283652276,
-0.0866073444,
0.1758798808,
-0.3979534507,
-1.0159066916,
0.5907914042,
0.5666962862,
0.2024704516,
-0.1898855716,
0.1085491478,
-0.1442780495,
-0.0864377916,
0.533059299,
0.137616694,
-0.9342984557,
-0.4267851412,
0.1694131941,
-0.3944600523,
0.2959390581,
1.1847888231,
-0.6385198832,
0.8359268904,
0.3962678313,
0.8242360353,
0.7204883695,
-0.1448610276,
0.7809380293,
-0.6594859958,
0.1966360062,
0.391338706,
0.0624196939,
0.3476356566,
-0.0377439372,
0.2944943011,
0.3849530816,
-0.1533670574,
-0.8677620292,
0.4785580337,
-1.306725502,
-0.3523750305,
0.8657933474,
0.3120717406,
-0.2165243477,
-0.3053680062,
-0.3662500083,
0.7656892538,
-0.2795817554,
0.7054637074,
0.3517846167,
0.1058980748,
-0.4167528749,
-0.435757339,
0.1059083417,
0.4308259189,
-0.4921352565,
-0.2678017914,
0.415189743,
0.333425343,
-0.038445171,
0.5679278374,
-0.465820998,
0.4122897983,
-0.245802477,
0.178766802,
-0.4799706936,
-0.2986346483,
-0.4273549914,
0.3854552805,
-0.2742296755,
-0.7806944251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00812v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00812v2
|
LoRA Meets Dropout under a Unified Framework
| 2024-02-25T07:09:10 | 2024-05-27T02:16:43 |
Sheng Wang, Liheng Chen, Jiyue Jiang, Boyang Xue, Lingpeng Kong, Chuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the remarkable capabilities, large language models (LLMs) have emerged
as essential elements in numerous NLP applications, while parameter-efficient
finetuning, especially LoRA, has gained popularity as a lightweight approach
for model customization. Meanwhile, various dropout methods, initially designed
for full finetuning with all the parameters updated, alleviates overfitting
associated with excessive parameter redundancy. Hence, a possible contradiction
arises from negligible trainable parameters of LoRA and the effectiveness of
previous dropout methods, which has been largely overlooked. To fill this gap,
we first confirm that parameter-efficient LoRA is also overfitting-prone. We
then revisit transformer-specific dropout methods, and establish their
equivalence and distinctions mathematically and empirically. Building upon this
comparative analysis, we introduce a unified framework for a comprehensive
investigation, which instantiates these methods based on dropping position,
structural pattern and compensation measure. Through this framework, we reveal
the new preferences and performance comparisons of them when involved with
limited trainable parameters. This framework also allows us to amalgamate the
most favorable aspects into a novel dropout method named HiddenKey. Extensive
experiments verify the remarkable superiority and sufficiency of HiddenKey
across multiple models and tasks, which highlights it as the preferred approach
for high-performance and parameter-efficient finetuning of LLMs.
|
[
-0.6218305826,
-0.7024752498,
0.3336338401,
-0.032298699,
-0.0075841625,
-0.0737006515,
-0.3625363708,
-0.4700931907,
0.2217274904,
0.549531281,
-0.7018356323,
-0.5024741292,
-0.5435479283,
-0.061719466,
-0.8819537759,
1.1391005516,
-0.196963504,
-0.4271054268,
0.1113278642,
-0.26304847,
-0.4492353797,
-0.3993167281,
-0.5204969645,
-0.8357455134,
0.8557643294,
0.201981917,
0.7600539923,
0.63331002,
0.677329123,
0.2428508401,
-0.5269954801,
-0.0417163745,
-0.3740844429,
-0.2566537559,
-0.185272038,
-0.7119572759,
-0.2011528909,
-0.0143632349,
0.5759314895,
1.0212632418,
-0.3528465629,
0.1262513846,
0.1724778116,
0.7158763409,
-0.8145913482,
-0.1334818304,
-0.795630753,
0.5520379543,
-0.3197709322,
-0.0519411899,
-0.4345933795,
-0.2754516006,
0.0318096206,
-0.5902183056,
0.2602866888,
-0.3740909696,
1.0751538277,
0.7409351468,
-0.3149417341,
0.0236110855,
-1.0716362,
0.9156029224,
-0.843218565,
0.3700185716,
0.3615477085,
0.3900790215,
0.0570036806,
-0.5220177174,
-0.3536685407,
-0.2579062879,
-0.0108168889,
0.0599860102,
-0.2147824466,
0.1538959891,
0.389852494,
0.5094043612,
0.0357029773,
0.691388309,
-0.3349597156,
0.054657232,
0.232534647,
0.1322748661,
0.1577698886,
-0.1834686548,
-0.2737998962,
0.1014670283,
-1.146723628,
-0.0807051882,
0.3772101402,
0.5688657761,
-0.1770360917,
0.4830779433,
-0.2829908729,
0.3009094298,
0.1117873937,
-0.0234361086,
0.0412079133,
0.0932767838,
-0.3426968753,
-0.2102398723,
0.7492451668,
0.1439832598,
-0.01276018,
-0.2810871303,
-0.0271131899,
-0.005241815,
0.1918711811,
-0.6320654154,
-0.0056646536,
0.2955227196,
-0.532199502,
-0.4667338729,
-0.2185108662,
-0.5945563912,
-0.416249454,
-0.2912806869,
0.3855732083,
-0.2069587857,
-0.2308033407,
0.1707384437,
0.0413317978,
0.4711099863,
0.3430008292,
-1.0716962814,
0.3685835898,
0.7406843901,
0.8213815689,
-0.5592737794,
-0.1758361012,
-0.6164790988,
0.176603809,
-0.1761506796,
0.5067354441,
-0.1369550228,
-0.1420053989,
0.3019449711,
-0.3092870414,
-0.0954625085,
-0.5498895049,
0.7823246717,
-0.5857201219,
0.3083266914,
-0.1069218814,
-0.4517107308,
-0.3097824752,
-0.0471619666,
-0.8601731062,
0.944547534,
0.0172982719,
-0.7316747308,
0.3658191264,
-0.9868234992,
-0.489218533,
0.0532362834,
-0.1998571306,
-0.391327858,
0.3392623961,
0.1383384466,
0.4898962975,
-0.4591878653,
0.0468648858,
-0.1393780261,
-0.500299871,
0.234898448,
-0.736661911,
0.7660390735,
0.1390470415,
-0.3938682675,
-0.2976997197,
-1.049095273,
0.2900350094,
0.0814776048,
-0.8209087253,
-0.347359091,
0.0899964273,
0.3706238866,
0.0522425659,
-0.1013905108,
-0.5573393703,
0.1405742764,
-0.8845875859,
0.8391322494,
0.5950973034,
-0.31170699,
0.545501411,
0.0936064944,
0.4454349875,
-0.2342200428,
0.2836667597,
0.1308400035,
-0.1402024031,
-1.0638964176,
-0.4194205105,
0.5453157425,
0.4238834679,
-0.3152440488,
0.7010430694,
0.0369721241,
-0.3593077958,
-0.5384213924,
0.0269365627,
0.4929754138,
0.2780212462,
0.2903992832,
-0.0423853062,
-0.4992355704,
-0.792929709,
-0.2277395427,
0.1733016372,
-0.1542408466,
-0.1345704347,
0.3542494774,
-0.398976177,
1.3393578529,
-0.5830659866,
-0.5589431524,
-0.4748032987,
-0.2237112671,
0.5441823602,
0.4904237092,
0.6345037222,
-0.55149436,
-0.225769937,
0.2475868911,
-0.7752646208,
-0.0246273205,
0.1169442683,
0.0245897695,
0.4393074214,
0.4099513888,
-0.9921469688,
0.6403076053,
0.631141305,
0.0812085569,
0.3864670694,
-0.0347898602,
-0.2901741862,
-1.3210422993,
0.2531333268,
-0.2519917786,
-0.0774617493,
-0.6973074675,
0.2850688994,
0.0459682643,
-0.144077003,
-0.6174826622,
0.5154495239,
-0.3323741257,
0.0502277687,
-0.1701274961,
0.1976339221,
0.1752731502,
0.5217773914,
-0.2186366469,
0.1805689484,
0.3183641136,
-0.5546735525,
0.1911859363,
0.3750825822,
-0.3718396425,
0.2558559775,
-0.9518249035,
0.0388239548,
-0.0818713605,
0.0817072988,
-0.7279139757,
-0.2596140504,
0.0614782684,
0.0914329067,
0.2289090008,
-0.328582108,
-0.4845056236,
-0.3943771124,
-0.3030075133,
0.0667125359,
0.4825850129,
-0.7460926175,
0.7195996642,
0.1304950118,
0.0516449884,
-0.8992446661,
-0.9664555788,
-0.2122201622,
-0.5350583792,
-0.26595667,
0.33335343,
-0.2610066533,
-0.0361160524,
-0.3422942758,
-0.2603528798,
-0.2152744681,
0.1715478152,
0.5279312134,
0.122807987,
-0.2431776375,
0.1795499325,
0.3722832501,
-0.4416868687,
-0.0218560658,
0.1794515103,
0.7165772915,
-0.076924175,
-0.7392725945,
-0.6378388405,
0.4407686293,
0.3933741748,
-0.1379170716,
0.7702628374,
0.5470606685,
-0.2715131938,
-0.2971290052,
-0.6292683482,
-0.1354863644,
-0.5700930953,
0.5703456402,
-0.4981679022,
-0.7449774742,
0.8478150368,
-0.0152053405,
0.4958419502,
0.4444228411,
0.4364228547,
-0.075005278,
0.6068573594,
1.1730431318,
-0.1129615009,
0.5639622211,
-0.5765769482,
0.4605385661,
-0.5831364393,
0.0016881768,
-0.6023058891,
-0.3526645601,
-0.5673309565,
0.0322927423,
0.0673048347,
0.3649841845,
-0.1959911287,
0.4538924396,
-0.4647652805,
0.7999725938,
0.6863431931,
-0.1706552207,
0.6571962833,
0.2089223117,
-0.0095171072,
-0.2634173036,
-0.6407397985,
-0.210418433,
0.8626520038,
0.4650902152,
0.9556298852,
0.1099966988,
0.9098514915,
0.1970356405,
0.0925994366,
-1.0298113823,
0.4869618118,
-0.1813281626,
-0.4453401566,
-0.5643656254,
-0.2808270454,
-0.9819017053,
0.3628319204,
-0.2049893439,
-0.6838518381,
0.1446056813,
0.2366118431,
-0.692047894,
0.5307503343,
-0.5799255371,
0.5315204263,
0.0918657109,
0.1121158823,
-0.067296803,
-0.6583864093,
0.1628825516,
-0.3524811864,
-0.0075266701,
-0.2384474128,
-0.1019777581,
0.6817823648,
-0.5885597467,
0.9629073143,
0.0670176521,
-0.6593557,
0.0435620397,
0.1616248339,
0.6500854492,
-0.098999761,
-0.2389062494,
0.4718378782,
-0.0522279441,
-0.0287816264,
-0.9481344819,
0.7389195561,
-0.9064218998,
-0.2098213136,
-0.0708406046,
-0.4337611496,
-0.2424448431,
0.3363166153,
0.70660007,
0.5241932869,
0.0168758277,
0.3739071786,
0.6282236576,
-0.2605469525,
0.9345040917,
0.500320971,
-0.2372384816,
-0.4041409194,
0.6153379083,
0.2134733647,
0.4196634889,
0.6244601607,
0.4666048586,
-0.2357239276,
-0.6066066623,
-0.1256967634,
0.3032900393,
-0.8645064235,
-0.2862493396,
-0.5403184891,
-0.6315644383,
0.1038129181,
-0.2840184271,
-0.8362035751,
-0.5480104685,
-0.227146104,
-0.1905272901,
0.4288490117,
0.6552426815,
-0.003132948,
0.6071065664,
-0.7081640959,
0.292465806,
0.2838579416,
0.5982472897,
0.030171603,
-0.7825219631,
-0.2718481421,
-0.1480069309,
-0.2316478491,
-0.3884701431,
0.2613744438,
0.3559624255,
0.5825005174,
0.6489531398,
0.1497546881,
0.5373044014,
-0.6772097349,
0.6050565839,
0.5331320763,
-1.0241500139,
0.6049311757,
-0.4922412634,
0.1774317026,
0.4381987751,
0.0576776303,
-0.5318425298,
-0.279949069,
-0.4874977171,
-1.2707407475,
0.5987211466,
0.304689914,
0.3866269886,
0.3314608335,
0.3261809051,
0.3273592293,
0.3119236231,
-0.9940363169,
-0.4581770897,
0.095471181,
-0.1938040853,
0.162805438,
-0.1000901163,
-0.2822095752,
-0.0215233825,
0.3959219754,
-0.1700189412,
0.0960879624,
-0.495344013,
-0.0760953575,
-0.0938843265,
0.5392680168,
0.3957901299,
0.7296731472,
-0.0202622078,
-0.1886860579,
0.2836999595,
-0.4369283617,
-0.0692297369,
-0.0700293183,
-0.6886597872,
0.2511235476,
0.4196764231,
0.8176808357,
0.3493038118,
-0.5878964067,
0.383954227,
0.170758158,
-0.3066619039,
-0.2524358928,
0.1163566113,
-0.0616253205,
0.1832459569,
0.4563831091,
0.2074297369,
0.1906169951,
-0.2043204159,
-0.1595258862,
0.435207963,
-0.4785416126,
-0.1113609001,
0.511508584,
0.3820203543,
-0.4275690615,
0.4023258984,
0.4695607126,
-0.0457352288,
0.4343347847,
0.4930551946,
0.9478386045,
0.0893932432,
0.3478749394,
-0.1770981997,
0.2923330367,
-0.1252556443,
-0.0552224293,
-0.0115964357,
-0.5954267979,
-0.7510918379,
-0.7227991223,
-0.4274430573,
0.4358860552,
-0.956451416,
0.1510710865,
-0.4784553945,
-0.2518578768,
-0.0775433779,
0.0006203181,
-0.528362453,
0.0029021068,
-0.1027762741,
0.6785652637,
-0.7831013203,
0.4596054852,
0.3187206089,
-0.4957033098,
-0.8327494264,
0.0113590546,
-0.2117734849,
-0.6209372282,
0.6679831147,
0.1033788398,
-0.2305674255,
-0.1650098711,
-0.4879782498,
-1.3079061508,
0.8397580981,
0.8328044415,
-0.7051588297,
-0.2825866044,
0.351906389,
0.4859786034,
0.1478310227,
0.1033650488,
0.7404267192,
0.1361322552,
0.1023339331,
-0.9964361787,
-0.1505514532,
0.0375375636,
0.2300060689,
0.5129360557,
-0.7116565704,
0.7160016894,
-0.2341898829,
-0.2254414856,
0.2610481977,
0.5102277398,
0.0845452771,
0.0497606657,
0.2919040024,
0.5660171509,
0.6339765787,
-0.1136141717,
0.8435659409,
-0.1031908765,
0.6257157326,
1.2318300009,
-0.3254027069,
1.2684060335,
0.5429663062,
-0.467061609,
0.2373940796,
0.4564067423,
0.2377032936,
0.615452528,
0.1689765453,
-0.056408897,
-0.0597041436,
0.1201730222,
-0.4907202423,
0.5093339682,
0.1120743528,
-0.2372950017,
-0.2833062708,
0.1895440966,
0.1192344576,
0.0005781407,
-0.3634467721,
0.6298291683,
0.3008646071,
-0.2938116193,
0.8498597145,
-0.0562687591,
0.8135591149,
-0.5772926807,
0.1953739077,
-0.6831268072,
0.38345927,
-0.3907366395,
-0.4912505746,
0.1638155282,
-0.0761001855,
-0.4295402169,
-0.0809661895,
0.366330415,
-0.2996453345,
-0.3197783232,
0.3388851285,
0.4876852036,
0.0871625543,
-0.0412621871,
-0.5118588805,
0.2145493776,
-0.2635407746,
-0.1647135764,
0.3055084944,
0.2632026672,
0.1940855086,
0.9049173594,
0.5549443364,
0.1738152504,
0.1507681757,
0.7786840796,
0.7900890708,
-0.6406659484,
-0.6042080522,
-0.9734346867,
0.3827320933,
0.0114321141,
-0.3758282065,
0.7914629579,
0.2620429397,
0.5562646389,
-0.1915493011,
0.6894403696,
0.0190129355,
0.7433995605,
-0.741037488,
1.0227553844,
-0.56765306,
0.4217342436,
-0.6069104671,
-1.1923880577,
-0.411208719,
0.3763349056,
-0.0030260358,
0.1081497148,
0.7508717179,
0.5703917742,
-0.1467561722,
-0.3192689419,
0.5569688082,
0.0377386287,
0.3035420477,
0.4150895774,
0.9039090276,
-0.7071092725,
0.7574156523,
0.0272349808,
0.1582870185,
-0.3541873395,
-0.7700576186,
-0.9698096514,
-0.3803624809,
-0.4116272628,
-0.01350547,
0.0138374269,
0.7522204518,
0.8824409842,
-0.7954323292,
-0.0748587847,
-0.0814573392,
0.193775177,
-0.2414066643,
-0.2003507763,
0.4687837362,
-0.1307620704,
-0.7154227495,
0.3756180704,
0.2889621854,
0.1337857097,
-0.4723720849,
0.1105402857,
0.130661726,
0.1241738573,
0.8535180092,
0.5086836815,
-1.0615105629,
-0.1103361621,
-0.3502409458,
-0.0879599676,
0.1716633886,
0.7473915815,
-0.5731952786,
-0.1765363812,
0.2940861285,
0.768702209,
0.328002125,
-0.1728656143,
0.4138182104,
-0.992095232,
0.3100785911,
-0.0189317688,
0.1723701507,
0.2764934599,
-0.2025326639,
0.6609275341,
-0.1173505783,
-0.3519435525,
-1.0644634962,
0.4044888616,
-0.9524808526,
0.0722284764,
1.1423304081,
0.0807460248,
-0.1214667559,
0.0051635425,
-0.1421811134,
0.0129171638,
-0.3236414194,
0.7997894883,
0.3193559647,
0.0070131379,
-0.2037189007,
-0.523665905,
0.5856097341,
0.5816708803,
-0.9420850277,
0.1073630974,
0.3185939491,
0.2772723436,
0.460259527,
0.2986085117,
0.1857199818,
0.0483911,
-0.2673092186,
0.2734706104,
0.1162656918,
-0.3912473321,
-0.5941610336,
0.4568741322,
0.0514837503,
-0.2845233977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16009v1
|
PST-Bench: Tracing and Benchmarking the Source of Publications
| 2024-02-25T06:56:43 | 2024-02-25T06:56:43 |
Fanjin Zhang, Kun Cao, Yukuo Cen, Jifan Yu, Da Yin, Jie Tang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
Tracing the source of research papers is a fundamental yet challenging task
for researchers. The billion-scale citation relations between papers hinder
researchers from understanding the evolution of science efficiently. To date,
there is still a lack of an accurate and scalable dataset constructed by
professional researchers to identify the direct source of their studied papers,
based on which automatic algorithms can be developed to expand the evolutionary
knowledge of science. In this paper, we study the problem of paper source
tracing (PST) and construct a high-quality and ever-increasing dataset
PST-Bench in computer science. Based on PST-Bench, we reveal several intriguing
discoveries, such as the differing evolution patterns across various topics. An
exploration of various methods underscores the hardness of PST-Bench,
pinpointing potential directions on this topic. The dataset and codes have been
available at https://github.com/THUDM/paper-source-trace.
|
[
-0.2419700921,
-0.3262961209,
0.9215859771,
0.2225040644,
-0.1912998706,
0.4198033214,
0.0332485102,
-0.3010798693,
0.1224429682,
0.2443509251,
-0.4955187738,
0.0033796062,
-0.7151074409,
0.0533409752,
-0.6012397408,
0.8393696547,
-0.0880254135,
0.0552788228,
-0.2261931896,
-0.1555823237,
0.0455593504,
-0.3430748284,
-0.2746759951,
-0.1965904832,
0.2245139927,
0.1779503673,
0.0695077628,
0.977186203,
0.7634814978,
0.1640835255,
-0.151587978,
0.1327112913,
-0.6502851248,
0.32952106,
-0.4329490066,
-0.29961133,
0.0856324807,
-0.1839102358,
0.7130203843,
0.5127570033,
0.0299348049,
0.5959948897,
-0.0009006678,
1.0224723816,
-0.6491978168,
0.2083335817,
-0.3723967075,
-0.1219234839,
-0.7865208983,
-0.7342965603,
-0.426692456,
-0.5212696195,
0.0315251946,
-0.481967479,
0.6377622485,
-0.2535796463,
0.817823112,
0.1078348756,
-0.2553842664,
-0.2611736059,
-0.7887306213,
0.5128908157,
-0.1650606245,
0.1247162148,
0.1415082514,
0.6462679505,
-0.1624289751,
-0.9625785947,
0.0469984934,
-0.1736536175,
0.1938934922,
0.1139513403,
0.0613412,
-0.7466535568,
0.3318882287,
0.0644367188,
-0.5317297578,
-0.6457201242,
-0.4377022982,
0.1329956204,
0.4766733944,
-0.1009263396,
-0.0490978882,
-0.0527057722,
-0.1854892969,
-0.26600945,
-0.5487306714,
-0.2982394099,
0.2329740822,
0.5211170912,
0.3289736211,
0.2878658175,
-0.098998785,
0.6037391424,
0.1371398419,
-0.0709663704,
0.1820471883,
-0.3762104809,
0.3475589752,
-0.0575785786,
0.4700812101,
-0.1928142756,
-0.2071217448,
-0.3025470674,
0.2123632878,
-0.2612659931,
0.2875673473,
-0.6682100892,
-0.450746119,
-0.2472070456,
-0.4732867181,
-0.2664739192,
0.1564359218,
-0.881486237,
-0.8581772447,
-0.3911616206,
0.4175087512,
-0.4912779629,
-0.5932129622,
-0.2836686373,
-0.3505643606,
0.246235624,
0.4683631361,
-0.3039495349,
0.2151184827,
0.6900405288,
0.99816221,
-0.0370155573,
-0.1635968834,
-0.4048852921,
0.3710534573,
-0.313126862,
1.0224620104,
-0.4334273338,
-0.2541316748,
-0.3641300201,
-0.0160952955,
0.1922761053,
-0.1855585128,
0.6508372426,
-0.2765722573,
-0.088989839,
-1.1405047178,
-0.3967293203,
-0.1399001628,
-0.0445717089,
-0.5771778822,
0.9432239532,
0.2756124735,
-0.98444134,
0.1853129119,
-0.605830729,
-0.3242811859,
0.2875992358,
-0.3661412001,
-0.3916760385,
0.3376924694,
0.0313300714,
-0.1697315723,
-0.6204973459,
0.4213701189,
-0.3241648972,
-0.3637733161,
-0.0241184141,
0.0911336541,
1.2970870733,
0.3392534852,
-0.5764241219,
-0.480966717,
-1.0765391588,
-0.1297553033,
0.3114084005,
0.061676994,
-0.4023397267,
0.3818448484,
0.0772096887,
0.0781481415,
0.2059546262,
-0.5565212965,
0.1422973126,
0.5559834242,
0.6384890676,
0.7585490942,
0.1700870246,
-0.0648281947,
-0.4372495711,
0.3325320482,
-0.4376643896,
-0.0458010547,
-0.1657630652,
-0.2833614349,
-0.2948598266,
-0.1655671149,
0.4913442731,
0.2662115097,
-0.24111332,
0.0985827073,
-0.2179281861,
-0.8578009605,
-0.1958637387,
-0.2314064205,
0.1620929092,
0.7274695635,
0.2696734071,
-0.1904093921,
-0.6203030944,
-0.7881712317,
-0.6077150106,
-0.1171356663,
-0.1139530689,
0.208546713,
0.3607664108,
0.2159012854,
1.1483230591,
-0.6200432777,
0.1029339582,
0.3409487009,
0.5835556984,
-0.0225973725,
0.5502261519,
0.8032891154,
-0.7012550831,
-0.5965784788,
-0.2643366456,
-0.6552325487,
-0.5114199519,
-0.1527293324,
-0.2512337863,
-0.4000112116,
0.7163747549,
-0.2907803953,
-0.1015342623,
0.0663806722,
-0.2499675155,
0.7715486288,
0.0407207645,
0.2785366476,
-1.0406631231,
0.7263427377,
0.1784065664,
0.0917162448,
-0.175491184,
0.2066902816,
0.3592905998,
-0.4496296048,
0.1001996472,
0.1140831038,
-0.7204089165,
-0.266291976,
-0.2229552418,
-0.1912513971,
0.0396276675,
0.1033427417,
-0.0491458736,
0.7336902618,
0.5148887634,
-0.078567259,
0.1146324202,
0.0724982098,
-0.1907020956,
0.6495556831,
-0.1508513242,
0.2728182673,
-0.1998264045,
0.3640274704,
-0.9850947261,
0.1120108888,
-0.1803932935,
-0.3009410203,
0.2444939166,
-0.4150556326,
-0.8546431065,
-0.4073137343,
-0.323040396,
0.2350486666,
0.2834280133,
-0.5847427249,
0.3232136369,
0.2234874219,
-0.3676729202,
-0.3403179646,
-0.3708103299,
0.1573102325,
0.0325100534,
-0.4825081229,
0.3918609023,
-0.2308941782,
-0.2168165892,
0.0749214739,
-0.5369159579,
-0.1195349097,
-0.203041777,
0.2014913559,
-0.0933195204,
-0.2782856226,
0.0325624719,
-0.211339578,
-0.1216442436,
0.2697594166,
-0.288611412,
0.3716127574,
-0.1193454117,
-0.4469054043,
-0.1443995535,
0.2252086252,
0.884626925,
-0.2406678498,
0.1565214843,
0.3579431176,
-0.2560443282,
-0.1339764595,
-0.6737319231,
-0.136767149,
-0.4417688251,
0.1280721575,
-0.4039117098,
-0.2126954347,
0.5350772738,
-0.6120567322,
-0.1591723859,
0.5745977163,
-0.030640889,
0.1147943065,
0.8162003756,
0.6039488316,
-0.0627551377,
0.4958434403,
-0.0703459531,
0.1280519068,
-0.733533144,
-0.1331534088,
-1.2915232182,
-0.2322580367,
-0.636305809,
-0.0729717761,
0.1296017319,
0.0553790107,
-0.4868383706,
0.5831201673,
-0.9201266766,
0.6003513336,
0.6235256791,
0.2264182419,
0.3684917688,
0.0485125072,
0.0893269554,
-0.1490796059,
-0.2631786764,
-0.0798189938,
1.0843368769,
0.060595002,
0.5580795407,
-0.209527418,
0.8203533888,
0.3292120099,
0.216541484,
-0.114359051,
0.4570761621,
-0.018140588,
-0.5984487534,
0.0256025009,
-0.5079365373,
-0.5299806595,
0.0605834164,
0.246302411,
-0.5854548216,
0.6849105358,
-0.1435518265,
-0.0616002791,
0.3649944663,
-0.592125535,
0.5463106632,
-0.4190045595,
-0.7495825291,
-0.0525065251,
-0.6087822318,
0.2676828504,
-0.3156253397,
0.0579794385,
-0.037349157,
0.079238236,
1.0513752699,
-0.5319439173,
0.29206267,
-0.383438915,
0.2100333273,
0.3031843305,
0.338757664,
0.7224629521,
0.1144687533,
-0.288585633,
-0.1993167996,
0.1492662728,
-0.7951077819,
-0.0950679779,
0.8104914427,
-0.6822136641,
-0.3098449707,
-0.9244264364,
-0.4368806779,
-0.5396072268,
0.4925792515,
0.3807679713,
0.2778161466,
-0.0764770433,
0.2677125931,
0.5150111914,
0.0962397009,
0.2869385481,
1.0047441721,
0.1932276338,
-0.1261828095,
1.1077109575,
0.3897429109,
-0.4047338367,
0.2339521348,
0.3633579016,
-0.1585485637,
-0.8824613094,
-0.1392877251,
0.385833621,
-0.4922204614,
-0.4360579252,
-0.2279883176,
-0.1695865095,
-0.1513679624,
-0.3551270664,
-0.3327241838,
-0.5489993095,
-0.0828961805,
0.0505773798,
0.5021893382,
0.4480405152,
-0.2953541875,
0.0343251117,
-0.4048502743,
0.2564868033,
0.3231161237,
0.5869267583,
-0.068576619,
-0.0714671016,
-0.0454934537,
-0.1998168379,
-0.5201877356,
-1.0296758413,
0.3239817917,
-0.126393646,
0.3696110249,
0.2998864651,
0.1593718082,
0.7247339487,
-0.3746505082,
0.6436964869,
0.0846814215,
-0.7837307453,
0.7648583651,
-0.9240881205,
0.2172215283,
1.0116760731,
0.4279747307,
-0.1136537194,
-0.1898246408,
-0.8874846101,
-0.8233022094,
0.9330445528,
0.1090818122,
-0.569704771,
0.2978082597,
0.4481821656,
0.1904190332,
0.1112708747,
-0.2762432098,
0.110798046,
-0.3951747715,
0.2506985962,
0.1628738791,
-0.0306487363,
-0.3861870766,
-0.2811718583,
0.6964787841,
0.1080506146,
0.1924554855,
0.1735633612,
-0.1504434347,
-0.5338048339,
-0.0374071933,
0.513818562,
1.3679292202,
-0.8317177296,
0.2623293996,
-0.6050081849,
-0.6420193315,
0.0522270389,
0.5609358549,
-0.4274711907,
0.228311196,
0.174139902,
0.0815070644,
-0.2219364941,
-0.487313658,
0.2676488757,
0.1097187996,
-0.2730662525,
-0.1035307944,
-0.3854070902,
0.3661299348,
0.1313658953,
1.0227166414,
0.2247520685,
0.1897020489,
-0.4516493976,
0.4188222885,
0.1968674362,
-0.0927301422,
-0.289023459,
0.4708406627,
0.1214533001,
-0.2977119982,
0.4682836831,
-0.2356430888,
-0.3134123087,
0.835526526,
0.587947011,
0.7721262574,
-0.2106862366,
0.3659521341,
0.5031936765,
0.2032812089,
-0.3647974432,
0.1589984447,
-0.2294335365,
0.1780099422,
-0.2490412295,
-0.5220925808,
-0.678814888,
0.5599607825,
-0.7681825161,
0.227790609,
-0.3731818795,
0.1333690435,
0.4116055369,
0.3619821072,
-0.2938875556,
-0.287470758,
-0.1835021824,
1.061476469,
-0.9756724238,
0.6380439401,
0.4773565531,
-0.2793189287,
-0.3170177937,
0.0891658813,
0.3122042716,
-0.497502625,
0.5005821586,
-0.1003941223,
-0.0867166817,
-0.002468507,
-0.6723542809,
-1.1418716908,
1.0106930733,
0.5488309264,
-0.5562575459,
0.1900849342,
-0.1448863894,
0.6190669537,
0.1607918292,
0.2010260969,
0.2702744901,
0.6572903991,
-0.0197878871,
-0.4032853842,
0.2591538727,
-0.4748246074,
-0.0329802223,
0.5006299019,
-0.7116913795,
1.0211071968,
0.2284923792,
-0.0505742393,
-0.1322769523,
0.2435035408,
0.3859252334,
0.3283506036,
0.169934839,
0.4025033414,
0.5767544508,
-0.1769686639,
0.5228652358,
-0.3468034863,
0.5441020131,
1.0522738695,
-0.3427306414,
0.5884174705,
0.4652796984,
-0.4022981524,
0.4963193536,
0.7001241446,
-0.5567232966,
0.6635673642,
0.3484818935,
-0.0325893275,
0.075272128,
0.1100141332,
-0.7688353062,
0.0139687862,
0.3895872831,
-0.3629135191,
-0.7604318857,
-0.2752425969,
-0.0568317994,
-0.0506246835,
-0.0724378899,
0.4481571317,
-0.2652410567,
-0.6127345562,
0.4666582048,
-0.2694098949,
0.282484144,
-0.8850316405,
0.039673157,
-0.3206186891,
0.1776618063,
-0.0965499431,
-0.5130212307,
0.2709184885,
-0.0179842766,
-0.1785490066,
-0.5064333677,
0.673609674,
0.1528097242,
-0.4069796205,
0.1568644792,
0.6096661091,
-0.0237554405,
-0.1259463429,
-0.6815593839,
0.0865153596,
-0.1282799989,
-0.4020660222,
0.6058699489,
0.597094655,
-0.0093511976,
0.2647010684,
0.5737242699,
0.1813465357,
-0.1407734752,
-0.3822216094,
0.7317604423,
-0.6218293905,
-0.5503917336,
-0.5411519408,
-0.1256301254,
-0.3525043726,
-0.2723468542,
0.7177234292,
0.8523578644,
0.3629938066,
-0.0677348375,
0.8916162848,
-0.4196606576,
0.798943162,
0.2757732868,
0.78346771,
-0.3110507429,
0.038613677,
-0.476900667,
-0.8758584857,
-0.1568876207,
0.4258975983,
-0.0971043929,
-0.1975910068,
0.8232893944,
0.472252965,
-0.4994068146,
0.2957945168,
-0.5646942854,
0.1814562529,
0.4716689587,
0.2015033364,
0.4537145495,
-0.1491076201,
0.8057169914,
-0.493716687,
-0.6530606151,
-0.4927705228,
-1.1610338688,
-0.1745335758,
-0.9174089432,
-0.3770439625,
-0.4254596829,
0.5336115956,
0.150701344,
0.7656760216,
-0.787753284,
-0.3003898263,
-0.6869957447,
-0.2889593244,
-0.8219189644,
-0.2532334924,
1.0862056017,
-0.3258307874,
-0.1173652187,
0.3942946196,
0.0809802189,
-0.1294073015,
-0.0574547797,
0.2697133422,
-0.560680151,
0.0229765922,
0.3384698629,
0.9469745159,
-0.0501393229,
-0.1035702154,
0.1384003609,
-0.0816149712,
0.1129370704,
1.2290707827,
-0.6020828485,
0.5380849242,
0.9080914855,
0.6610198617,
1.1946123838,
0.0159686543,
0.536854744,
-0.7356899381,
-0.1974566728,
0.4450449646,
0.2403084487,
0.3314587772,
-0.0941106156,
0.9434314966,
0.5780937076,
-0.6656118035,
-1.2900085449,
0.0086145643,
-1.1654310226,
-0.6610171795,
0.6586814523,
0.1377345771,
-0.0602481849,
-0.0522949286,
-0.1533586979,
0.2708690166,
-0.2471142262,
1.3091950417,
0.8207343221,
-0.6540387273,
-0.2365094125,
-0.4920900464,
0.7424408197,
0.2538051009,
-0.8262842298,
0.418456167,
0.2509406209,
0.2960056663,
0.7820215821,
0.5629414916,
-0.2143993527,
0.4406483173,
0.365254879,
-0.3960603476,
-0.2458639145,
-0.148215577,
0.0871750116,
0.6062145829,
0.0922619924,
-0.1574720591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16006v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16006v2
|
ASETF: A Novel Method for Jailbreak Attack on LLMs through Translate Suffix Embeddings
| 2024-02-25T06:46:27 | 2024-06-04T02:59:58 |
Hao Wang, Hao Li, Minlie Huang, Lei Sha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The safety defense methods of Large language models(LLMs) stays limited
because the dangerous prompts are manually curated to just few known attack
types, which fails to keep pace with emerging varieties. Recent studies found
that attaching suffixes to harmful instructions can hack the defense of LLMs
and lead to dangerous outputs. However, similar to traditional text adversarial
attacks, this approach, while effective, is limited by the challenge of the
discrete tokens. This gradient based discrete optimization attack requires over
100,000 LLM calls, and due to the unreadable of adversarial suffixes, it can be
relatively easily penetrated by common defense methods such as perplexity
filters. To cope with this challenge, in this paper, we proposes an Adversarial
Suffix Embedding Translation Framework (ASETF), aimed at transforming
continuous adversarial suffix embeddings into coherent and understandable text.
This method greatly reduces the computational overhead during the attack
process and helps to automatically generate multiple adversarial samples, which
can be used as data to strengthen LLMs security defense. Experimental
evaluations were conducted on Llama2, Vicuna, and other prominent LLMs,
employing harmful directives sourced from the Advbench dataset. The results
indicate that our method significantly reduces the computation time of
adversarial suffixes and achieves a much better attack success rate to existing
techniques, while significantly enhancing the textual fluency of the prompts.
In addition, our approach can be generalized into a broader method for
generating transferable adversarial suffixes that can successfully attack
multiple LLMs, even black-box LLMs, such as ChatGPT and Gemini.
|
[
-0.4450548887,
-0.9421628118,
0.2631144822,
0.4381221831,
-0.4359599352,
0.3422022462,
-0.2062430531,
-0.1874782145,
0.1766120642,
0.6683219671,
-0.7696828246,
-0.752356708,
-0.8391111493,
0.2469270974,
-0.4175301492,
0.6802557111,
-0.0501371659,
0.1639820933,
0.181039229,
0.0368940458,
-0.3360758424,
-0.4345133305,
-0.7633284926,
0.0183036495,
0.2299397141,
0.3465251029,
0.6461815238,
0.7299264073,
0.5824710727,
0.228546679,
0.0215469673,
0.2485679984,
-0.2852143943,
0.1809018552,
0.0468175188,
-0.2500485182,
-0.3931975663,
-0.2258789241,
0.3430358171,
0.1731359512,
-0.0715761632,
-0.2280827463,
-0.2736668289,
0.6467993259,
-0.5257496834,
-0.4217892587,
-0.8676154017,
0.1753536761,
-0.4399936497,
-0.2329939157,
-0.2657728493,
-0.3072279096,
-0.2614213824,
-0.4306074977,
-0.1825282872,
0.2281833738,
0.8011642098,
0.4155734181,
-0.4392125607,
-0.4719603956,
-0.2548384964,
0.4558498263,
-0.6587232351,
0.126163274,
0.2551998198,
0.204198584,
-0.6552753448,
-0.5864990354,
-0.2886177897,
-0.2638984621,
0.2883773446,
0.0646520779,
-0.3232865036,
0.2666698396,
0.1913791746,
0.2266812474,
-0.4011470973,
0.2262514383,
-0.1307923198,
-0.1785367429,
0.5372260213,
0.0220462419,
0.7324553728,
-0.3025442958,
-0.9147652388,
0.0677923411,
-1.28548944,
-0.1022744402,
0.6289845109,
0.2973216772,
0.1735435277,
0.4516132474,
0.0808051229,
0.249778375,
-0.040499799,
0.0046642371,
-0.0910566822,
-0.11723952,
-0.1050569713,
0.2204533517,
1.0525738001,
0.3893420696,
0.3392815888,
-0.4320049584,
-0.1975319535,
-0.122473821,
0.3800634444,
-1.1325238943,
0.0013140686,
0.1889113933,
-0.0264985953,
-0.6212607026,
0.2061588019,
-0.7449544072,
-0.5729009509,
0.456715703,
0.1221296489,
-0.776403904,
0.1118438169,
0.0807514265,
-0.0974528864,
0.1621304005,
0.0619087853,
-0.7429512143,
0.4458886981,
0.6418070793,
0.7223832607,
-0.1378431618,
-0.1985610425,
-0.7154015303,
0.2286030799,
-0.2497137338,
0.663536489,
-0.3077150285,
-0.8358328342,
0.0005912859,
-0.1900493354,
-0.0803551078,
-0.386746943,
0.5629954338,
-0.8602771163,
-0.4978773594,
-0.0361035131,
-0.4277673066,
-0.1451054662,
0.3385967612,
-0.6427852511,
0.7313739657,
-0.429253459,
-0.6202311516,
-0.0006825688,
-0.5995841622,
-0.7884623408,
-0.0265465714,
-0.132964462,
-0.3505226672,
0.0090561863,
0.5879054666,
0.388186574,
-0.5357606411,
0.2049521506,
-0.2490804046,
-0.2404509783,
0.4331116974,
-0.4894344509,
0.7428427935,
0.2631606162,
-0.3971197009,
0.2429952621,
-0.4362963736,
-0.2066891342,
0.2188427001,
-0.346586436,
-0.4188818336,
0.107059814,
-0.2031356543,
0.0982487723,
0.0789419338,
-0.748249948,
0.3137829304,
-0.6269111633,
0.4591728747,
0.8351627588,
0.2870998085,
0.4304629564,
0.1639165282,
0.685769856,
-0.2240398675,
0.194186002,
-0.073744379,
-0.4067828953,
-0.4959276319,
-0.4982028604,
0.3471832573,
0.797844708,
-1.1258819103,
0.3244490623,
-0.2151596844,
-0.0972016826,
-0.5240908265,
0.4706966877,
0.6023409367,
0.0773751289,
0.3822490573,
0.070296213,
-0.5120752454,
-0.7036474347,
-0.482812047,
-0.0382719263,
0.0342453085,
0.1589185297,
0.4868226349,
-0.3020321429,
0.4494967759,
-0.5281642675,
-0.2212735713,
-0.138936013,
-0.2570042312,
-0.0390354879,
0.4178373814,
0.5758299828,
-0.701574564,
-0.3384083807,
-0.2764978707,
-0.6527096033,
-0.2347364277,
-0.1092702895,
-0.2971205413,
-0.0229478087,
0.8720145226,
-0.4295324683,
0.4181851149,
0.2222692817,
-0.6771587133,
0.3390200138,
0.1038855538,
0.1307865828,
-1.0725671053,
-0.2687865496,
-0.2119082808,
-0.4680149257,
-0.5890299082,
0.5617665648,
0.084869206,
-0.0515094846,
-0.6139833331,
0.550532639,
-0.4537678659,
0.3011694252,
-0.0808410421,
0.1996553689,
-0.2667171657,
0.2428520471,
-0.4713786542,
0.7524815202,
0.446036756,
-0.3605878353,
0.5737624168,
0.413173914,
0.0730564669,
0.3303160965,
-0.5090053678,
0.2181415111,
0.1581195593,
0.0631189421,
-0.8349078894,
0.0624282137,
0.4855469465,
-0.5191051364,
0.5307952762,
-0.3493610024,
-0.6422870755,
-0.2659608722,
-0.7980658412,
-0.0285563599,
0.5067793131,
-0.7803552151,
0.6082114577,
0.1668956876,
-0.0328829065,
-0.8351928592,
-0.7810927629,
0.4412065446,
-0.5063213706,
-0.9091582894,
0.5468838811,
0.0367970765,
-0.2182247788,
0.030698305,
-0.0968815163,
0.3050147891,
0.5637159944,
0.3846399188,
0.3692135215,
-0.1749456674,
-0.2054645717,
0.1413317621,
-0.1379469037,
0.2724031508,
-0.3769769967,
0.4201951623,
-0.0983498618,
-0.4088471532,
-0.0159422401,
0.4184432328,
0.5717830062,
-0.0574579947,
0.8381482959,
0.4642198682,
-0.2982042432,
-0.5188288093,
-0.3958490491,
-0.1281658858,
-0.5305277109,
0.3613504469,
-0.4676225781,
-0.915137887,
0.5448227525,
-0.429371953,
0.0272038374,
0.2284396589,
0.2295124233,
0.149963662,
0.8115321994,
0.4015473127,
-0.0820202753,
0.4897443652,
-0.1046070084,
0.1788217723,
-0.935099721,
-0.3107956052,
-0.1123448461,
-0.0970107242,
-0.3827955127,
-0.4619874656,
0.2261785418,
0.4530267417,
-0.3461595178,
0.3835382164,
-0.1766195744,
0.4209897518,
0.1506978571,
-0.0216410235,
0.1812473834,
0.3028616607,
-0.4179462492,
-0.0632034987,
-0.3315527439,
-0.394503206,
1.16928792,
0.4604853392,
0.8057116866,
0.5130737424,
0.6915346384,
0.3462222219,
0.3797485828,
-0.81347543,
0.7122630477,
-0.5659521222,
-0.2294769734,
-0.1008071303,
-0.4376571178,
-0.6642819643,
0.3163999915,
-0.0643242225,
-0.9252870083,
-0.0970070064,
-0.1277258247,
-0.3450936973,
0.6294150352,
-0.3883659542,
0.6124023795,
-0.3139115274,
-0.2352403402,
0.037035916,
-0.515137136,
0.4818443656,
-0.1220918745,
0.1685063541,
-0.1813935339,
-0.216042608,
0.7081084847,
-0.8631655574,
0.6173119545,
-0.2825967073,
-0.0036157996,
0.207485199,
0.2400460392,
0.7841254473,
0.4059233963,
-0.1009585932,
0.0058151381,
-0.3660465777,
-0.2312350422,
-0.7247176766,
0.8991450667,
-0.6919656992,
-1.0163927078,
-0.2840640843,
-0.1964477897,
-0.1099789217,
0.1141139343,
0.3804521263,
0.3774283528,
-0.3393355608,
-0.0683322325,
0.759346664,
-0.3191809654,
0.5169069171,
0.5277532339,
-0.1475238353,
-0.6796366572,
1.0066562891,
-0.0324789882,
0.1331278533,
0.252227366,
-0.0978950411,
-0.3162798285,
-0.7925717831,
-0.8913490176,
0.0509800762,
-0.8212674856,
-0.6400693655,
-0.5660031438,
-0.2401855886,
-0.3100341558,
-0.4251435697,
-0.3754790723,
-0.4564515054,
-0.0704643726,
-0.1755071729,
0.6902591586,
0.6310648918,
0.0656937435,
0.3244300187,
-0.5588828325,
0.2701742649,
0.0249547288,
0.1383336931,
-0.0513369404,
-0.4969713092,
0.2161367685,
-0.2311744243,
-0.17933999,
-1.1317183971,
0.5123971701,
0.1490507722,
0.3194206357,
0.3968630135,
0.3341743946,
0.6468058228,
-0.7537714839,
0.5036373138,
0.238286972,
-0.9232955575,
0.534707725,
-0.2624198794,
-0.0691590756,
0.5710257888,
0.0310284216,
-0.2647605538,
-0.2336671799,
-0.5213239789,
-1.4022941589,
0.6582359076,
0.3924342096,
0.1258129478,
-0.0549028032,
0.4648166001,
-0.3273673654,
0.2581664622,
-0.2673919201,
-0.6928997636,
-0.1411705911,
-0.1799923927,
0.3495105803,
-0.3033335805,
-0.2046368569,
-0.0157794692,
0.9392593503,
0.1004950926,
0.2128688544,
0.1011181697,
-0.271884352,
0.3203155994,
0.3508795798,
0.3198634088,
-0.3338701427,
-0.0815139413,
0.2876611352,
0.4684400558,
-0.8419331312,
0.3663175106,
0.2916403115,
-0.1788901836,
-0.4395645857,
0.1543563902,
0.7215292454,
0.0365924798,
-0.6404884458,
0.7111119628,
-0.2841796577,
0.0401498862,
-0.5734080672,
0.0301234312,
0.0080599692,
0.0489907153,
0.3765405118,
0.2619223595,
0.1147512347,
-0.3276171088,
0.3672526777,
0.4075323045,
-0.5486577153,
-0.0737337247,
0.6201169491,
0.3741528392,
-0.3362480104,
0.5790095329,
-0.4346475899,
-0.8713024259,
0.7760326266,
0.8073136806,
0.9498348832,
-0.3299748898,
-0.0128473947,
-0.0643767864,
0.593193233,
-0.0015934343,
0.1318925917,
0.1742913574,
-0.728803575,
-0.0930923373,
-0.6569005847,
0.0101378849,
0.1609877944,
-0.4400024414,
0.1896584332,
-0.9266206622,
-0.060684219,
-0.1828537881,
-0.1641270518,
-0.2419882864,
0.0028660323,
0.2666168511,
1.0952460766,
-0.5992226601,
0.6305296421,
0.9156830907,
-0.1589518487,
-0.5590711236,
0.1701374054,
0.3713201582,
-0.7980062366,
0.5033586621,
0.1772065312,
-0.6081257463,
0.1390993744,
-0.4534937441,
-0.8085852861,
0.9172613621,
0.5716034174,
-0.2082306445,
0.1046731547,
-0.1104531288,
0.1170563251,
-0.3876380026,
-0.0469213687,
0.7894420028,
0.4833688438,
0.1940862983,
-0.2335226685,
0.6920320988,
-0.6250850558,
0.1194699854,
0.242474705,
-0.4998483956,
0.4840356708,
-0.2399668097,
-0.480486989,
0.2022503316,
0.6117645502,
0.2550145686,
-0.1850450784,
0.3067511618,
0.4729973376,
0.5461350679,
-0.2420838177,
1.2951799631,
-0.234539032,
-0.0845543221,
0.8268993497,
-0.031497743,
0.7891502976,
0.6261759996,
-0.0353735276,
0.3322417438,
0.5144742131,
-0.2312478572,
0.7257861495,
0.6537750363,
-0.4436365962,
-0.1718271226,
-0.0644584224,
-0.0963413492,
0.0800581053,
0.8122768402,
-0.1635956168,
-0.196204558,
0.435169965,
0.5502915382,
0.1969647259,
-0.3254262805,
0.6708663702,
0.3831040859,
-0.3661265671,
0.5529176593,
0.6143953204,
0.9499302506,
-0.6777940989,
0.2003897727,
-0.0432058685,
0.2529485822,
-0.3165859282,
-0.4719621837,
0.2074816674,
0.2943728566,
0.0216700882,
0.0255507566,
0.7935563922,
-0.2039617002,
-0.3630001545,
0.7207961679,
0.1248247698,
0.0593732744,
-0.0830007046,
-0.7938562632,
0.1492593884,
0.2209566385,
-0.3820648193,
0.2403601557,
0.1210197136,
-0.1504107565,
0.7592083216,
0.6813055873,
0.2354633063,
0.1850596517,
0.1579428762,
1.0403540134,
-0.5113196373,
-0.5137569904,
-1.2563712597,
0.3528311253,
-0.2373007685,
-0.1390815675,
0.8816981316,
0.2835072875,
0.3912165165,
0.1799675524,
0.890900135,
-0.0312478486,
-0.1198400036,
-0.8538120389,
0.8000320196,
-0.2839938998,
0.8879646659,
-0.1541219503,
-0.4582505822,
-0.4741567969,
0.3750821054,
-0.4570713937,
-0.2288058698,
0.8351421952,
0.7743483782,
0.1487788707,
0.055028487,
0.2491509467,
0.2369210869,
0.4443089962,
0.6195676923,
0.8043316603,
-0.6895728111,
0.7170482278,
0.1014345959,
-0.0844117031,
-0.1535997987,
-0.701056838,
-1.3834457397,
-0.0785287693,
-0.2844724357,
-0.5001498461,
0.5348947048,
1.0845706463,
0.4496351182,
-0.8275809288,
0.1580943167,
-0.2200564444,
0.2595549524,
0.150377512,
-0.1579204798,
0.4882522225,
-0.1719373167,
-0.4302293062,
0.8319476843,
0.2911820412,
0.1584765762,
-0.1428435147,
-0.1141142026,
-0.2442213744,
0.3194592595,
0.2356647849,
0.2175285369,
-0.7847542763,
-0.1315176636,
-0.1371984184,
-0.1954770684,
-0.140814513,
0.7106407881,
-0.4082803726,
0.3537821472,
0.2559888959,
0.9432643652,
0.1864596307,
0.166272223,
0.7427477837,
-1.0849353075,
0.2033093423,
-0.0244326927,
0.4472583234,
0.4891466796,
-0.7542827725,
0.4112294614,
0.2145319134,
0.0067009185,
-0.7855933905,
0.4195540845,
-0.5385216475,
-0.5777177215,
1.3775253296,
-0.5353372693,
-0.5361490846,
-0.2535639703,
-0.126660496,
0.0382281169,
-0.7556957006,
0.3235809505,
0.4654280245,
0.2259153873,
0.1976764351,
-0.6649363041,
0.851365149,
0.3098422885,
-0.6139925122,
0.0130465059,
-0.0892394409,
0.3888200819,
0.063520439,
0.2971819639,
-0.4012104571,
0.1423500478,
0.1479904354,
-0.1649531126,
-0.6625155807,
-0.2517718971,
-0.4838459194,
0.25712955,
-0.003347507,
-0.2573529184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15992v1
|
A Machine Learning Approach to Detect Customer Satisfaction From Multiple Tweet Parameters
| 2024-02-25T05:16:43 | 2024-02-25T05:16:43 |
Md Mahmudul Hasan, Dr. Shaikh Anowarul Fattah
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Since internet technologies have advanced, one of the primary factors in
company development is customer happiness. Online platforms have become
prominent places for sharing reviews. Twitter is one of these platforms where
customers frequently post their thoughts. Reviews of flights on these platforms
have become a concern for the airline business. A positive review can help the
company grow, while a negative one can quickly ruin its revenue and reputation.
So it's vital for airline businesses to examine the feedback and experiences of
their customers and enhance their services to remain competitive. But studying
thousands of tweets and analyzing them to find the satisfaction of the customer
is quite a difficult task. This tedious process can be made easier by using a
machine learning approach to analyze tweets to determine client satisfaction
levels. Some work has already been done on this strategy to automate the
procedure using machine learning and deep learning techniques. However, they
are all purely concerned with assessing the text's sentiment. In addition to
the text, the tweet also includes the time, location, username, airline name,
and so on. This additional information can be crucial for improving the model's
outcome. To provide a machine learning based solution, this work has broadened
its perspective to include these qualities. And it has come as no surprise that
the additional features beyond text sentiment analysis produce better outcomes
in machine learning based models.
|
[
-0.5121910572,
-0.685220778,
0.3840689659,
0.6780384779,
-0.3028033972,
0.3485896289,
0.0320364088,
-0.5761450529,
0.3284632266,
0.4089492857,
-0.8036816716,
-0.4546484649,
-0.5599506497,
0.0893584266,
-0.312220633,
0.9222494364,
-0.2610003054,
0.1638567746,
0.1600720137,
-0.2105021179,
-0.2924869657,
-0.6046172976,
-0.8397575021,
-0.245074898,
0.6088406444,
0.4169270992,
0.4079542458,
-0.0605345592,
0.7459405065,
0.298889637,
0.1684837788,
0.3008880615,
-0.3270276785,
0.3791888356,
0.2220653296,
-0.0051887343,
-0.078435868,
-0.1034079269,
0.4562250078,
0.7613359094,
-0.0708486661,
0.1905492693,
0.376609534,
0.8201788068,
-0.2614077032,
0.0458146818,
-0.4194193482,
0.2552547157,
0.311177671,
-0.2781195343,
0.0074809548,
-0.7242021561,
0.1639928222,
-0.4121605754,
0.0377911814,
-0.1250402778,
1.2481789589,
0.2494618744,
-0.6744015813,
-0.4023386836,
-0.9510421753,
1.0172247887,
-0.5082051158,
0.4040001333,
0.1341336221,
0.4622811079,
0.0521330982,
-0.2267490923,
-0.3155348599,
-0.1921309233,
-0.0601466894,
0.1515102088,
0.0489549339,
-0.1736573577,
-0.0648183972,
0.0121583929,
-0.5370772481,
0.0627919361,
0.0797559172,
0.0118220858,
0.4249663055,
0.0145926047,
0.039220266,
-0.2474029362,
-0.3051503599,
0.0902201235,
0.213092804,
0.3802803457,
0.3096271753,
0.152230978,
0.1690410674,
0.3794951737,
-0.5353068113,
0.3312908113,
0.0153233418,
0.0167399291,
0.4470774531,
0.0170301609,
-0.5084239841,
-0.0551905148,
0.8192614913,
0.4174374342,
0.3813446462,
-0.1273179203,
-0.4811501205,
-0.042681288,
0.3604242802,
-0.9051252007,
0.0980136693,
0.6748352647,
-0.955414474,
-0.6275552511,
0.3477445841,
-0.6656467915,
-0.5305466652,
-0.5127957463,
0.1888688803,
-0.4971163571,
-0.4843726158,
-0.0370851494,
-0.2606536746,
0.2506796122,
0.4937099516,
-0.527575314,
-0.1625981331,
0.8434814811,
0.8421282768,
0.1559909731,
-0.3119707406,
-0.3737398386,
-0.0063814833,
-0.5870761275,
1.003182292,
-0.4301037192,
-0.2797475755,
0.1307891756,
-0.2011857331,
0.0478847735,
-0.3940901756,
0.7502962947,
-0.6679667234,
0.126387462,
-0.3112076819,
-0.8023129106,
-0.4726373553,
0.5367862582,
-0.4950782359,
0.6896748543,
0.190933764,
-0.6932888627,
0.5821306705,
-0.8594232202,
-0.6850022078,
0.2181986719,
-0.0684695914,
-0.9992492199,
0.3997107148,
0.4984633923,
0.6528462768,
0.2549381852,
0.0364005193,
-0.8668589592,
-0.1584961116,
0.4577798247,
0.0734279305,
0.9387542605,
0.4932469428,
-0.1377756745,
0.0834276155,
-0.3222289085,
0.3346613944,
-0.0989267007,
-0.4066826999,
0.0191128664,
-0.1387816966,
0.3547133505,
0.2497719079,
0.1675997078,
-0.6046317816,
0.062542282,
-0.3334074318,
0.245442301,
0.5143764615,
0.776329875,
0.1187667847,
-0.2994472682,
0.4600722492,
0.2711143196,
0.5206049085,
0.1948811561,
-0.4499228597,
-0.7593922615,
0.0339124352,
0.0898032039,
0.4458557963,
-0.4331905842,
0.6466734409,
-0.2651796937,
-0.7598635554,
-0.7653969526,
0.2785350978,
-0.1465003192,
0.2849850357,
0.0631139055,
0.1398715079,
-0.9597768784,
-0.6001394391,
-0.6132518649,
-0.2090553641,
0.0405457839,
0.070279181,
0.3062838614,
-0.4139239788,
0.7734751701,
-0.5440381169,
-0.5661830902,
-0.195475623,
0.2308006883,
0.3146705925,
0.2620679736,
0.630643189,
-1.080275774,
-0.9178302288,
0.3493745327,
-0.9782884717,
0.1793800592,
-0.2372338325,
-0.058142744,
0.4106203616,
0.0457402207,
-0.4332346618,
0.4513524473,
0.3453234434,
0.0197769832,
0.3580318689,
0.1727548093,
0.5845900774,
-1.1042010784,
0.0931350812,
0.4102120101,
-0.1069355756,
-0.6781742573,
-0.3768883944,
-0.1906442344,
-0.1422305852,
-0.2060159594,
0.1798039675,
-0.0495664924,
-0.0757132322,
-0.508621037,
-0.3865178525,
0.1947972625,
0.4397257268,
-0.1453984231,
0.2994709909,
0.4455839992,
-0.4887508452,
0.5371696949,
0.1202739701,
-0.3014858067,
0.4891504645,
-0.4221981764,
-0.0375354886,
-0.1301493198,
0.267311722,
-1.2574687004,
-0.2153074443,
0.2995159924,
-1.1424773932,
-0.2951377034,
-0.0492915176,
-0.5801648498,
-0.3972165883,
-0.3218319714,
-0.2687654495,
0.4031737447,
-0.4360533655,
0.7777254581,
0.4199505448,
-0.0012011413,
-0.4432153404,
-0.5850926042,
0.249549225,
-0.3543969393,
-0.6138906479,
-0.0050199907,
0.180448845,
-0.0569160096,
0.0325103663,
-0.0072484165,
-0.3737327754,
0.3584814966,
0.4575655758,
0.1405011564,
0.012502417,
0.110077396,
-0.1678581685,
-0.0321263112,
0.0562897511,
-0.5481453538,
0.5137268901,
-0.4472104013,
0.0646513477,
-1.0476893187,
0.6296916008,
0.4894691706,
-0.1685060561,
0.9637709856,
1.0341408253,
-0.6081406474,
-0.120193772,
-0.7208960652,
-0.1021011919,
-0.4385526776,
0.2816550732,
-0.5791741014,
-0.4483574927,
0.597155571,
-0.1472567171,
-0.0556224585,
0.5600689054,
0.5596613288,
-0.5933142304,
1.2636612654,
0.8930618763,
-0.2970426083,
0.6039021611,
-0.2625287473,
0.4225699604,
-0.1404519677,
-0.4666550159,
-0.76477319,
-0.3334245384,
-0.8295488954,
0.3894328177,
0.0902910456,
-0.0255617518,
-0.1493372917,
0.1797543764,
-0.4545503557,
0.2162479013,
0.3789094388,
0.2300742865,
0.0213218126,
0.2691321373,
-0.0666547939,
0.104071781,
-0.2007524222,
-0.6226936579,
0.6644527912,
0.5181778669,
0.5290620923,
0.072111845,
0.8647363782,
0.4841043055,
0.3169596791,
-0.8344318867,
0.390001595,
-0.2284671515,
-0.3527099788,
-0.2557311952,
-0.8178301454,
-0.7655501962,
-0.2017300725,
-0.0761838257,
-0.5187361836,
0.001277841,
-0.1730256975,
-0.3457675278,
0.1190023571,
-0.8622458577,
0.7108135223,
-0.3573386669,
-0.0422271006,
-0.1517102122,
-0.4807990491,
0.1628804803,
-0.2950493395,
-0.1407267898,
-0.106885545,
-0.2767844498,
0.9192324281,
-0.3053151667,
0.6678470969,
-0.3352922499,
0.0533134751,
0.0813108981,
0.0470874682,
0.2482302189,
-0.0081528956,
-0.3866068125,
0.2087653726,
-0.04922406,
-0.5373519659,
-0.5936531425,
0.8595798612,
-1.1572134495,
0.0596700758,
-0.2265449166,
-0.100518845,
-0.5675631762,
0.3864353895,
0.006617636,
0.1005753204,
0.0785432756,
0.1771286428,
0.1198316291,
-0.1075456813,
0.757989049,
0.0455869585,
-0.4691673219,
-0.6281694174,
0.9718273282,
0.1133689508,
-0.2994888127,
0.5764565468,
0.228822276,
-0.6514726877,
-0.3866621554,
-0.030268006,
0.085634321,
-0.6940113306,
-0.1072696894,
-0.8323494196,
-0.2729061246,
-0.6241086125,
0.0505758338,
-0.2205653489,
-0.2294295877,
-0.3980670571,
0.0133341113,
0.1071775556,
0.7236626148,
0.3159118593,
0.4720867574,
-0.9784693718,
0.4683670998,
-0.0446202308,
0.5852922797,
0.2924786806,
-0.081936121,
-0.5404924154,
-0.0243475288,
-0.6219003201,
-0.8434363008,
0.5077531338,
0.0183303766,
0.4964393675,
0.7746172547,
-0.0135846753,
0.7063465714,
0.095647119,
0.5810192227,
0.3165688813,
-0.8807267547,
0.6274479032,
-0.2631973326,
0.0226004794,
0.5146713257,
0.6740817428,
-0.8316602111,
-0.3493384719,
-0.6461210847,
-0.3850655258,
0.5011837482,
0.3393727541,
-0.0122413039,
0.4508764744,
0.3351599276,
0.1705118269,
0.6200931072,
-0.5401995778,
0.0373158306,
-0.5339648128,
-0.2264962047,
-0.1084708273,
-0.1057200953,
0.3827278018,
-0.0551628582,
0.8090725541,
0.1006277427,
0.2555238903,
-0.1313776076,
0.1510406286,
-0.2845740318,
0.0061307028,
0.349880904,
0.723672092,
-0.5596475601,
-0.1124241948,
-0.1828931421,
-0.023430841,
-0.0307601411,
-0.0121587478,
0.0894053876,
0.3352951109,
0.3548159003,
0.5012455583,
-0.6851226687,
-0.1599099636,
0.419608295,
-0.1830935031,
-0.3230752349,
-0.4910136759,
-0.2098819017,
-0.0592942163,
0.1003422439,
0.7483564019,
0.5618454814,
0.4103043675,
-0.3175728917,
0.4443356693,
0.364957124,
-0.6951653957,
-0.0034583996,
0.1844051778,
0.4362069964,
-0.5931348205,
0.5738361478,
-0.1535185575,
-0.9333285689,
0.4912920296,
-0.1571977586,
1.2586773634,
-0.2475597858,
0.437582016,
0.1412287056,
0.205999583,
0.2215752006,
0.4488752484,
0.2265431285,
-0.6006041765,
-0.5000649691,
-0.6227471828,
-0.4731134772,
0.2172693759,
-0.5499668717,
0.4313355982,
-0.6186368465,
-0.4981179535,
0.2516153753,
0.4593770802,
-0.7454234958,
0.5653508306,
0.1870308816,
0.5139216185,
-0.8619526029,
0.5703040957,
0.7013576031,
-0.5088970065,
-0.8278051615,
0.5303921103,
-0.329397887,
-0.5525965691,
0.7148042321,
0.7542205453,
-0.2049399167,
-0.1390910894,
-0.2514649928,
-0.0349647216,
0.3362644315,
-0.0852878764,
-0.4153034687,
0.3120072484,
0.4220592678,
0.7248228192,
-0.4519554973,
0.2762378752,
0.1288118064,
0.3409139812,
0.0355388336,
-0.5728440881,
-0.2049907744,
-0.1290456057,
0.2087994218,
0.1489479542,
-0.5834312439,
0.5441766381,
-0.0169535391,
0.0974128097,
-0.2568015754,
0.6904177666,
0.1084971279,
0.5373569727,
0.7625508308,
0.4647303522,
0.6689326167,
0.1225735247,
0.9287392497,
-0.1342726201,
0.8098461032,
0.7215941548,
-0.1473136097,
1.0613255501,
0.758321166,
0.0675389543,
0.3879974484,
1.0193098783,
-0.2906577885,
0.5243056417,
-0.0486405641,
-0.0468157344,
-0.4406498075,
-0.2436016053,
-0.2120546103,
0.1992809922,
0.1045683101,
-0.1369616538,
-0.2233663052,
0.3451139331,
-0.2998933196,
-0.1959064752,
-0.1422781348,
1.0144133568,
0.126900956,
-0.8817772269,
0.4544731677,
0.1221322864,
0.2433308512,
-0.3186555207,
0.0241180174,
-0.2312762588,
0.5068581104,
-0.5216665268,
-1.0985242128,
0.4262567461,
-0.025182182,
-0.0860423446,
-0.4087961912,
0.6814840436,
0.0309719462,
-1.0114291906,
0.5675112009,
0.5895045996,
0.110696204,
-0.5463808179,
-1.0484688282,
0.2024732232,
0.309338361,
-0.3400334716,
-0.2103305608,
0.5632410645,
0.3975052834,
0.870650351,
0.6216800213,
-0.0849336311,
-0.0137311509,
0.3846010566,
0.6423920393,
-0.6935638189,
-0.9213203788,
-1.0086938143,
0.3142150939,
-0.4814828932,
-0.0317693911,
0.7658440471,
0.6598340869,
0.467618525,
-0.111488156,
1.0626045465,
0.1629825085,
1.1293752193,
-0.1126196459,
0.6257467866,
-0.7664612532,
0.51797539,
-0.2930280268,
-0.7807794809,
-0.512385726,
0.5675689578,
-0.4762525856,
0.3858955801,
0.7347981334,
0.5675430298,
-0.0904143378,
0.2456500828,
0.1605727971,
-0.0597043075,
0.7695035338,
0.3988947868,
1.1538985968,
-0.4399851263,
1.000144124,
-0.2792878151,
-0.1213110462,
-0.8874054551,
-0.8337352872,
-0.97367239,
-0.5138121843,
-0.4689899087,
-0.7109360099,
-0.0814446583,
0.8193725944,
0.7461101413,
-0.8430999517,
-0.2778511941,
-0.1313080788,
0.2002357543,
-0.4027279019,
-0.3116728067,
0.2699416578,
-0.7392623425,
-0.335957408,
-0.3458518684,
0.1626367867,
0.2003625333,
-0.1658544689,
0.0079454621,
-0.0157306232,
-0.0509155244,
0.2676177323,
-0.2209924459,
-0.5396718979,
-0.0280396752,
0.0622662604,
-0.2982521653,
0.1527034491,
0.5791896582,
-0.3407793343,
-0.0426605232,
0.5079760551,
0.9681310058,
0.5465654135,
0.0513162613,
0.183544457,
-0.6670606136,
-0.3908908665,
0.3649993241,
0.197339654,
0.4212296605,
-0.4858773351,
0.1415145248,
0.1236948967,
-0.6006245017,
-0.5714852214,
0.0702630803,
-1.3510112762,
-0.4564702213,
1.0499622822,
-0.0112029882,
-0.0800179467,
-0.1297366917,
-0.2411602288,
0.3382438719,
-0.812861383,
1.0872520208,
0.7063122392,
-0.4610107839,
-0.0730538741,
-0.4607804716,
0.3483908772,
0.3085254133,
-0.9739795923,
-0.389732331,
-0.0697076097,
0.3026470542,
0.0540764332,
0.4570961893,
0.5008092523,
0.1682635844,
-0.237757653,
-0.3131668866,
0.0706591755,
-0.2311897725,
-0.2444944084,
0.6719048619,
0.0785719529,
-0.7818339467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15991v1
|
$C^3$: Confidence Calibration Model Cascade for Inference-Efficient Cross-Lingual Natural Language Understanding
| 2024-02-25T05:07:56 | 2024-02-25T05:07:56 |
Taixi Lu, Haoyu Wang, Huajie Shao, Jing Gao, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual natural language understanding (NLU) is a critical task in
natural language processing (NLP). Recent advancements have seen multilingual
pre-trained language models (mPLMs) significantly enhance the performance of
these tasks. However, mPLMs necessitate substantial resources and incur high
computational costs during inference, posing challenges for deployment in
real-world and real-time systems. Existing model cascade methods seek to
enhance inference efficiency by greedily selecting the lightest model capable
of processing the current input from a variety of models, based on model
confidence scores. Nonetheless, deep models tend to exhibit overconfidence, and
confidence distributions vary across languages. This leads to the emission of
confident but incorrect predictions by smaller models, hindering their ability
to generalize effectively across test languages. In this study, we introduce a
confidence calibration model cascade ($C^3$) method. This approach, simple yet
effective, involves calibration prior to cascade inference, thereby enhancing
cascade accuracy through more reliable predictions. Extensive experiments
conducted on three cross-lingual benchmarks demonstrate that $C^3$
significantly outperforms all state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.2579858005,
-0.5631107092,
0.3479633927,
0.5782626271,
-0.0807817578,
0.0824097544,
-0.2470177561,
-0.5591049194,
-0.2981863916,
0.2040614039,
-0.2260391414,
-0.4830566049,
-0.4509521127,
0.0456259921,
-0.0318290144,
0.6063241363,
-0.049120985,
0.5349255204,
0.0290410463,
0.0981437564,
-0.3693975806,
-0.3694531322,
-0.698646605,
-0.5733769536,
0.6583705544,
0.3478330672,
0.8565722108,
0.2616259158,
0.1504662931,
0.1068779752,
-0.0627384707,
0.0919538438,
-0.5147926211,
-0.2797861695,
-0.0852871686,
-0.6758401394,
-0.3439674377,
0.0581076108,
0.6597117782,
0.9959745407,
-0.0506041758,
-0.1015843451,
0.4235156178,
0.6340279579,
-1.2026467323,
0.1638418734,
-0.6806364059,
0.0763361305,
0.033123441,
-0.1316330284,
-0.7643399835,
-0.3680438697,
0.1311739087,
-0.9181985855,
0.0698801056,
0.1656445712,
0.6524319053,
0.2506487966,
-0.4780855477,
-0.0962968469,
-0.6175923347,
1.1625372171,
-0.8276952505,
0.7295262218,
0.5654864311,
0.3707548976,
-0.0510546714,
-0.5861604214,
-0.5844452977,
-0.2040353119,
-0.0313413553,
0.1792462766,
-0.1607504338,
0.0348763838,
-0.0025251186,
0.3856703043,
-0.5459308624,
0.2138614804,
0.1061216444,
-0.2660051286,
0.3007586896,
-0.2004631907,
0.2605484426,
-0.1510477811,
-0.2942250967,
-0.1883885711,
-0.8080810905,
0.0512866341,
0.3216921687,
0.4955851138,
-0.0971556604,
0.3575183153,
-0.1497000158,
0.7346681356,
0.1288030297,
-0.2592067122,
0.079951711,
-0.2909862697,
-0.4712539613,
0.0972437263,
0.6069426537,
0.2208876461,
0.4391014278,
-0.1448767781,
0.1952654123,
-0.1265832186,
0.0597097985,
-0.7527065873,
-0.1880779862,
0.2157128751,
-0.2040498555,
-0.1157579646,
-0.0648200512,
-0.5028271675,
-0.2157692909,
-0.332719624,
0.3499836326,
-0.48276636,
-0.285667032,
0.1660853028,
0.2397009432,
0.3973793685,
0.3882600665,
-0.7985141873,
0.3007379472,
0.753728807,
0.6983587146,
-0.2001532018,
-0.5136888027,
-0.6853829622,
0.1420008838,
-0.6241039038,
0.3832836151,
-0.2417815328,
-0.4238652289,
-0.0555516407,
-0.1342549026,
-0.3433887959,
-0.3442630172,
0.6724659801,
-0.5738014579,
0.1402089894,
-0.1484781951,
-0.2933710814,
-0.4405872524,
0.4751641154,
-0.6696852446,
1.1223269701,
0.0970732495,
-0.9919723868,
0.2369755656,
-0.1578194201,
-0.3896638453,
0.0996113345,
-0.0654540807,
-0.0856210589,
-0.0724936724,
0.5224068165,
0.4554125369,
-0.5745185614,
0.4062348604,
-0.4888468385,
-0.5612463951,
-0.0729883835,
-0.6130903363,
0.9993742108,
0.1158345938,
-0.3131180704,
-0.2610892951,
-0.595952034,
0.1148359179,
-0.3780097365,
-0.2593866885,
-0.4197707474,
-0.0883510858,
0.0032861438,
0.1867898852,
0.0218095388,
-0.5366688967,
-0.2080556601,
-0.4741365612,
-0.0720128641,
0.407104373,
-0.1255140007,
0.5686416626,
-0.0799864829,
0.57069695,
0.1518925875,
0.2243812978,
0.0644705594,
-0.5952951908,
-0.7734377384,
-0.2054281235,
0.4759548008,
0.7328748107,
-0.8968208432,
0.2082188129,
-0.4176980257,
-0.5671871305,
-0.5397197604,
0.2068918347,
0.5103167892,
0.718973279,
0.6197834015,
0.0291610621,
-0.2855578363,
-0.8885046244,
-0.6991479397,
-0.2648777962,
-0.2844009697,
0.143696785,
0.3211319149,
-0.1231578141,
0.7717536092,
-0.3140594661,
-0.1393273473,
-0.3283174634,
0.5513731241,
0.1673298925,
0.6074634194,
0.4214294851,
-0.8570811749,
-0.6768223643,
0.1442451328,
-0.343493253,
0.0275601987,
-0.1157426536,
-0.1896792799,
0.2359341532,
0.2802867293,
-0.4153165519,
0.3879856169,
0.8993805051,
0.0937248021,
0.5541464686,
-0.0471546389,
0.2214891165,
-1.0180536509,
0.136801824,
0.1289772391,
-0.2878519893,
-0.7252833843,
0.1007778347,
0.4090387821,
0.2915769815,
-0.6308419704,
0.6324897408,
-0.5081453919,
0.1959430724,
0.0232204124,
0.2620551288,
0.1966990232,
0.4962779284,
0.3422936797,
0.3507100046,
0.5751172304,
-0.636975944,
-0.1230565608,
-0.1310743392,
-0.3137843013,
0.7287943959,
-0.3776909709,
-0.1040533409,
0.1875513941,
0.5875203013,
-0.7740974426,
-0.1359516531,
0.0140730357,
-0.526047349,
0.3477595448,
-0.2379381806,
-0.3488271832,
-0.2192519307,
-0.2491252273,
0.6554442644,
0.2203645855,
-0.7505041957,
0.9472792149,
0.2432854772,
0.0056691295,
-1.181604147,
-1.2117465734,
-0.0409112535,
0.2089733034,
-0.4367919266,
0.3651008904,
-0.1422418952,
-0.1249535978,
-0.3984673321,
-0.1343857348,
-0.1317596734,
0.050428059,
0.2372654229,
0.3597291708,
-0.1987967193,
-0.1277690679,
-0.0008579311,
-0.0918826237,
0.0024925093,
-0.2136321515,
0.312748611,
-0.2151349932,
-0.4958734214,
-0.6506137848,
0.2508948445,
0.4394316673,
0.014185627,
0.7577649355,
0.746989429,
-0.6973509192,
-0.2945491672,
-0.6845723987,
-0.0167180635,
-0.3870388865,
0.1723082662,
-0.5316980481,
-0.8377375603,
0.3306191564,
0.1297679394,
-0.0027720467,
0.4182393253,
0.4589195251,
0.2048665732,
1.2979215384,
0.5878314972,
-0.0871668607,
0.1158824787,
-0.083410643,
0.583501339,
-0.9428118467,
-0.2740600407,
-0.7159243226,
-0.0037938803,
-0.6572366357,
-0.8424776196,
0.0504776277,
0.4765301645,
-0.3219769597,
0.2299216688,
0.0132372659,
0.4162538648,
0.4819111228,
0.0241682902,
0.4592197835,
-0.275967747,
-0.4104442894,
-0.0885720626,
-0.7147839665,
-0.3588679731,
0.7750434875,
0.3918257356,
0.7905897498,
0.1825157404,
0.4358095527,
-0.1604226828,
0.7430320978,
-0.8373655677,
0.2259238213,
0.0011070685,
-0.677503705,
-0.0558652133,
-0.6726159453,
-0.475381285,
0.3608258963,
-0.0813764855,
-0.9000187516,
0.5471330285,
0.4654344618,
-0.4732422531,
0.4525495768,
-0.7010258436,
0.8272839189,
0.0139813079,
-0.4619150162,
-0.1421267837,
-0.6450997591,
0.7851806879,
-0.2546775043,
0.4020633101,
-0.1627378166,
0.0082990006,
0.389402926,
-0.2382999063,
0.7607392669,
-0.1312505454,
-0.300986588,
0.1404876113,
0.5073134303,
0.531014502,
0.333981365,
-0.4141436219,
0.2247743607,
0.038019456,
-0.452559799,
-0.527926147,
1.0081658363,
-0.5137968659,
-0.3357196152,
-0.39352265,
-0.6664432287,
-0.4984199405,
0.1377504021,
0.199621439,
0.2661628723,
-0.3010379374,
0.2766416073,
0.3431259692,
-0.4103760123,
0.4908359945,
0.4738005996,
-0.190361172,
-0.3671070635,
0.7258221507,
-0.1064905301,
0.5967095494,
0.7049447894,
0.1420070082,
-0.4448606372,
-0.3267715871,
-0.265534997,
0.037582621,
-0.7797368169,
-0.3538453281,
-0.7160943151,
-0.0520047545,
-0.526527822,
-0.3543295264,
-0.4890063107,
-0.4098190665,
-0.3302730024,
0.0878521577,
-0.0339237563,
0.4414195418,
-0.2470085472,
0.3894066513,
-0.6303547621,
0.3914966285,
0.3227252364,
0.3993307948,
0.2158074081,
-0.4881536663,
-0.2101064771,
0.3436512053,
-0.2009972781,
-0.767788291,
0.4713435769,
0.1682609469,
0.4895292819,
0.3302078545,
-0.0123858079,
0.9698331952,
-0.2837474048,
0.8914678097,
0.2868281901,
-1.2854132652,
0.2327613384,
-0.0963419527,
0.5306050181,
0.7737680674,
0.5767331719,
-0.6075382829,
-0.3146888614,
-0.4608839154,
-0.7139356136,
0.5764837265,
0.0918864906,
-0.1047474518,
-0.0563051067,
0.1089469045,
-0.1575943083,
-0.1403050423,
-0.9591511488,
-0.0822694823,
-0.2049378604,
-0.2278367132,
-0.3300451636,
-0.0071314313,
0.1286162734,
-0.3697993159,
0.9913824797,
-0.487599194,
-0.2963283658,
0.2924203873,
-0.4537888467,
-0.1257622242,
0.221102044,
0.3554024696,
0.6501075625,
-0.3840461075,
0.387124598,
0.5679433346,
-0.6400126219,
-0.1059330031,
0.1253165752,
0.0140284691,
-0.1255008429,
0.3873147368,
0.437561512,
0.5568782091,
-0.3101632893,
0.6238369346,
-0.3333197534,
-0.1248024851,
-0.0003642974,
-0.1695264578,
0.336422652,
-0.1541237235,
0.4650220275,
0.2226475775,
0.1208767965,
-0.3473520279,
0.1211599782,
0.403773427,
-0.6977521181,
-0.0505913571,
0.591258347,
0.092638433,
-0.1257067323,
0.5222147107,
-0.0726531073,
-0.5878512263,
0.3503589332,
0.5890755057,
0.8138470054,
-0.442414403,
0.1896360815,
0.6291596889,
0.3750602007,
-0.3354520798,
0.1661868691,
-0.0953235328,
-0.8436183333,
-0.7688158154,
-0.9061584473,
-0.704909265,
-0.0171601642,
-0.7664877772,
0.2055534422,
-0.2566380501,
0.0684920624,
-0.1895559728,
0.0959232673,
-0.7152408361,
0.5124465227,
0.2935946584,
1.2831829786,
-0.7697175145,
0.9945425987,
0.0600746758,
-0.1056530476,
-1.0370789766,
0.1901092529,
0.0863813683,
-0.7016525269,
0.5985330939,
0.4068698883,
-0.7213546634,
0.2318273187,
-0.4365822971,
-0.659929812,
1.0035529137,
0.5073357224,
-0.6123140454,
0.1410301179,
0.1708746403,
0.4084317088,
-0.5206956863,
0.5533001423,
0.7852873802,
0.5654113889,
0.1182348579,
-0.7588928938,
0.0302434303,
-0.1154306978,
0.2032497525,
-0.0526376404,
-0.2330652326,
0.7699583769,
-0.2706757486,
-0.2437702715,
-0.0031126901,
0.7144770026,
0.6108193994,
-0.0315721221,
0.7893302441,
0.4480774701,
0.7045165896,
-0.2048723549,
1.2999798059,
-0.4773521125,
0.3957422972,
1.4002324343,
-0.2542255521,
1.215028286,
0.6673489213,
0.0596173666,
0.6438298225,
0.8524413705,
0.4465258718,
0.2021618187,
0.1513678879,
-0.3592792749,
-0.4115194976,
-0.1088118032,
-0.2240453362,
0.2503670156,
0.3930768669,
-0.1206635237,
-0.0839561149,
-0.2840923369,
0.2221495956,
-0.2166841477,
-0.3090828359,
0.2935221493,
0.2415645868,
-1.0369282961,
0.7286149859,
-0.0615371503,
0.5848277211,
-0.4854025543,
0.0060511185,
-0.1458068192,
0.4507766068,
-0.1698263437,
-0.5571668148,
0.0054679555,
-0.0788538605,
0.1757416874,
-0.1922015697,
0.3830744028,
-0.5088990927,
-0.6992166042,
0.6901153922,
0.4345884025,
-0.0141634392,
-0.288515687,
-0.7472991347,
-0.1561413109,
-0.1194010749,
-0.2334528416,
-0.0804668143,
0.1102120206,
0.1191375479,
0.5870965719,
0.6856471896,
0.1474856436,
0.0170206763,
0.584055841,
0.4854378402,
-0.325540334,
-0.4613113105,
-0.7412658334,
0.5865444541,
0.0026672916,
-0.2729723752,
0.7174312472,
0.5714219213,
0.9706956148,
0.1807874739,
0.6286372542,
0.1216947958,
0.3997117877,
-0.459970355,
0.5769432187,
-0.6260856986,
0.1798287183,
-0.4809444845,
-0.9297039509,
-0.8810175061,
0.5649796128,
-0.2614540756,
0.094988361,
1.006508708,
0.9299110174,
-0.2323807776,
0.2218584567,
0.3474895358,
0.2701452971,
0.1818091273,
0.686011076,
0.661978364,
-0.5068691373,
0.4699410498,
-0.5401971936,
-0.3869558871,
-0.1493408531,
-1.2429746389,
-0.7215492129,
-0.2689725757,
-0.0709848404,
-0.3157304823,
-0.1441190392,
0.6330667734,
0.98603791,
-1.0199614763,
-0.2525169849,
-0.2612132132,
0.2221870422,
-0.3386898339,
-0.2246524543,
0.2575070262,
-0.3820954561,
-0.8561219573,
0.3776747286,
0.2637723386,
0.0654399246,
-0.4597932994,
-0.3678306341,
-0.5670589805,
0.289673388,
0.4587398469,
0.2302028537,
-0.894839704,
-0.2417756617,
0.0004138911,
-0.2149500549,
0.1016197577,
0.7146949768,
-0.725548923,
0.4314022064,
0.5226897001,
0.6515436769,
0.5779793262,
0.077094391,
0.9780312181,
-0.7938344479,
0.0805691034,
0.2005955726,
0.4395546913,
0.7042643428,
-0.3215775192,
0.4468534589,
-0.1102067381,
-0.4095056951,
-0.9446979761,
0.1139803603,
-0.8274504542,
-0.2418980896,
0.922303021,
-0.3244458139,
-0.256642729,
-0.1060097963,
-0.0094741462,
0.5130954981,
-0.0390814915,
0.3325166702,
0.6690526009,
0.0192423314,
-0.1602036208,
-0.6389309168,
0.6655460596,
0.7289748192,
-0.8311992884,
0.2295783758,
0.147098437,
0.1287482679,
0.3784694076,
0.3439912498,
-0.0510537662,
0.3194990754,
-0.1054819971,
0.1792925447,
0.5737006664,
-0.4890092611,
-0.4137830138,
0.1597878784,
-0.0291248914,
0.1247594878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15987v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15987v2
|
Likelihood-based Mitigation of Evaluation Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-25T04:52:02 | 2024-03-01T06:44:44 |
Masanari Ohi, Masahiro Kaneko, Ryuto Koike, Mengsay Loem, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used to evaluate natural language
generation tasks as automated metrics. However, the likelihood, a measure of
LLM's plausibility for a sentence, can vary due to superficial differences in
sentences, such as word order and sentence structure. It is therefore possible
that there might be a likelihood bias if LLMs are used for evaluation: they
might overrate sentences with higher likelihoods while underrating those with
lower likelihoods. In this paper, we investigate the presence and impact of
likelihood bias in LLM-based evaluators. We also propose a method to mitigate
the likelihood bias. Our method utilizes highly biased instances as few-shot
examples for in-context learning. Our experiments in evaluating the
data-to-text and grammatical error correction tasks reveal that several LLMs we
test display a likelihood bias. Furthermore, our proposed method successfully
mitigates this bias, also improving evaluation performance (in terms of
correlation of models with human scores) significantly.
|
[
-0.3407567739,
-1.0628527403,
0.7656117678,
0.1314771324,
0.0433253422,
-0.2534277439,
-0.485016495,
-0.227891475,
-0.1157649085,
0.5527763963,
-0.4031996429,
-0.4467415512,
-0.5159175396,
0.1025682464,
-0.2252642512,
1.0773715973,
0.0492274463,
0.2670286596,
-0.7077954412,
-0.0455220826,
-0.4332331717,
-0.6984733939,
-0.4813150465,
-0.4559825659,
0.374550879,
0.2057581395,
0.5810176134,
0.1720416546,
0.4891262352,
0.2066348791,
-0.1002729386,
0.0830792189,
-0.5559858084,
0.1056195796,
-0.3037001789,
-0.5337747931,
-0.4405950606,
-0.0964111611,
1.0201369524,
1.029941678,
0.2901684046,
0.1078144461,
0.4570799172,
0.7791351676,
-1.0764142275,
-0.0261304639,
-0.7198380828,
0.0447738059,
-0.2328129709,
-0.3042586148,
-0.5707501769,
-0.2676582932,
0.120773457,
-0.2756209373,
0.2338079214,
-0.01881212,
0.468428582,
0.15652816,
-0.4168759584,
-0.0948569998,
-0.6731156111,
1.1619793177,
-0.8801447153,
0.1223224178,
0.5040921569,
0.0317698754,
-0.608892858,
-0.2070839554,
-0.3875619173,
-0.4122065902,
-0.0400949605,
0.0665591657,
-0.1742114425,
0.2041330487,
0.4780927598,
0.3058886826,
-0.4463269413,
0.3501598537,
-0.0898867697,
-0.2874544263,
0.7216148973,
0.0869229212,
0.0301563945,
-0.1658342928,
-0.1632374674,
0.0612661242,
-0.8400089145,
-0.156867519,
0.489605397,
0.2538916171,
0.0703397319,
0.8605690002,
-0.2935660481,
0.6767197251,
0.0464096703,
-0.0016075878,
0.234993726,
-0.1838536114,
-0.5104936361,
0.0154901268,
0.6371355653,
0.4061126411,
0.1785176694,
0.0417823717,
-0.4705005288,
0.3022216558,
0.1500328928,
-0.686593771,
0.0996742696,
0.1699132621,
-0.394600749,
-0.4076420963,
-0.0367015004,
-0.8105870485,
-0.5234417319,
-0.1473258436,
0.643204391,
-0.1693948954,
0.2105331719,
-0.0285896771,
0.1520088613,
-0.1795383543,
0.105019331,
-0.7662969232,
0.4142261147,
0.6384702325,
0.4360828102,
-0.1861102879,
-0.2580558658,
-1.1226878166,
-0.1217829883,
-0.2736562788,
0.6611422896,
-0.5410333276,
-0.2978752851,
0.1944576949,
-0.3665711582,
-0.1183476076,
-0.6626783609,
0.7509562969,
-0.4227597415,
0.6418825388,
-0.1397072524,
-1.0692967176,
-0.1388145089,
0.1594876796,
-0.5917878151,
1.0845829248,
0.1025749743,
-1.0329395533,
0.6901832819,
-0.6412914395,
-0.5835156441,
-0.1729569137,
-0.339961648,
-0.6541410685,
0.5377762318,
0.508539319,
0.5528270602,
-0.325317651,
0.4568800032,
-0.3352849483,
-0.6295164824,
0.4339722097,
-0.8772876263,
0.6075510383,
0.0090481471,
-0.5921946764,
0.2873893678,
-0.7537326813,
-0.0630005673,
-0.1889855713,
-0.5599289536,
-0.4949634671,
0.1528265178,
0.1178661436,
0.0294518918,
-0.0601736605,
-0.442566067,
0.0629296154,
-0.6467260122,
-0.0083088484,
0.7177108526,
0.2086884826,
0.6477374434,
-0.5302306414,
0.5041105747,
-0.2165181935,
0.1412242353,
0.0472418666,
-0.3605308831,
-0.8423047066,
-0.2777256668,
0.2645875216,
0.2941969633,
-0.4961040914,
0.6746520996,
-0.1958050728,
-0.2015680373,
-0.312033236,
0.371661514,
0.4186785221,
0.4255762696,
0.1531244963,
-0.221960634,
-0.3864327669,
-0.8941876888,
-0.5994005203,
-0.0930268988,
-0.3283626735,
0.1071705893,
0.498639822,
-0.1509929299,
1.1613733768,
-0.2456932664,
-0.3113622069,
-0.5090420246,
0.0111358548,
0.1761608273,
0.3630932868,
0.3907460272,
-0.4847609699,
-0.0612215213,
-0.4383514822,
-0.5092325211,
-0.4617999494,
-0.4056458473,
-0.1251620799,
0.6097818017,
0.4017658234,
-0.5934467912,
0.5061643124,
0.4849170148,
-0.3022757769,
0.6211372614,
-0.1373742819,
-0.0100562181,
-0.7830927372,
0.0448674224,
0.2508103549,
-0.1317446083,
-0.3930146098,
0.0088271936,
0.0142227029,
0.4252493978,
-0.4509536028,
0.6452692151,
-0.2794718146,
-0.2064447999,
-0.2290261388,
0.1422257572,
0.2396479994,
0.2750640512,
-0.0065424345,
0.4707480669,
0.3462178409,
-0.6616036296,
0.0174967889,
-0.1139177009,
-0.6802241802,
0.5472843647,
-0.2484838814,
0.1130583435,
-0.1961936951,
0.415165484,
-0.8678390384,
-0.1472491175,
0.2087130398,
-0.1402285546,
0.1981917024,
-0.0197819807,
-0.6793628335,
-0.1719953865,
-0.5471668839,
0.3609372973,
0.142496556,
-0.5884275436,
0.3276055753,
-0.0130528994,
0.0099204639,
-0.5420421362,
-0.5071317554,
-0.0868069455,
-0.581597209,
-0.5392538905,
0.3670219481,
-0.1550327092,
-0.5578315854,
-0.3693861961,
-0.0379090905,
0.1506377608,
0.2407569289,
0.1877555698,
0.4815551341,
-0.1144419536,
0.4189722836,
0.1663711071,
0.2050278783,
0.1946849972,
-0.2417256534,
0.499643296,
0.1329508126,
-0.5321753621,
-0.2333463281,
0.1134235859,
0.436024338,
0.0212456994,
0.6379230618,
0.5194643736,
-0.4538064301,
-0.2248412073,
-0.9419997334,
-0.4015519917,
-0.4052290618,
0.6234650016,
-0.1758470386,
-0.7986873388,
0.1931701005,
0.1159858704,
0.2385307699,
0.4051986337,
0.6449666023,
-0.0715127587,
0.7731624842,
0.4341248274,
-0.4269442856,
0.3919062018,
-0.0355747826,
0.1773961186,
-0.9129467607,
0.1369766146,
-0.3331774175,
-0.3129914701,
-0.4174053669,
-0.4597584009,
0.3721374869,
0.2206187993,
-0.0863117874,
-0.2450068891,
-0.0410082676,
0.4056640565,
0.4763617516,
0.1118184254,
0.3724962175,
0.3861506283,
-0.2947538793,
-0.1643387377,
-0.8096990585,
-0.6663510203,
1.4124879837,
0.5670643449,
0.6070121527,
-0.0440546572,
0.5688457489,
0.4122744203,
0.4197280705,
-0.829097569,
0.4027078152,
-0.0420749672,
-0.6327428818,
-0.4085654616,
-0.597632885,
-0.6578024626,
0.4187093973,
-0.4824146032,
-0.8963006139,
-0.0988657027,
0.0881974772,
-0.4387332201,
0.2568696737,
-0.4707318246,
0.7325356603,
-0.2974211276,
-0.8395957351,
-0.1894595921,
-0.1930373162,
0.4300836623,
-0.3787381947,
0.4379465878,
0.0905149207,
0.2688522637,
0.6559990644,
-0.389858067,
0.9795066714,
-0.1068373621,
-0.2286692709,
0.1920025051,
0.1331862062,
0.5622138381,
0.1259335876,
-0.3536068499,
0.0532366224,
-0.4646852314,
-0.3211554587,
-0.6389196515,
0.6337326169,
-0.3861846924,
-0.5760051608,
-0.2571484745,
-0.6707534194,
-0.4309340715,
-0.1526831985,
0.5684668422,
0.4967919886,
-0.3151814938,
0.0461817458,
0.3648536503,
-0.4923317134,
0.4803607464,
0.2786687016,
-0.3478929996,
-0.1878251433,
0.4875306189,
-0.100174427,
0.5203561187,
0.3515596986,
0.4533875287,
-0.3634633124,
-0.4626237154,
-0.3410018981,
0.1414818317,
-0.7231860161,
-0.095641911,
-0.382920742,
-0.0162825659,
-0.2863972187,
-0.1059736013,
-0.1866507828,
-0.3993725181,
-0.1991400123,
-0.0599531308,
0.0866520554,
0.6925272346,
0.2975704968,
0.3762437701,
-0.5063723922,
-0.0833516568,
0.0354830846,
0.257992655,
0.0426289588,
-0.805753231,
-0.237529844,
-0.0361629203,
-0.3210483193,
-0.4189050198,
0.3529196978,
0.3155030608,
0.5602837205,
0.3982385695,
0.007940582,
0.4960985184,
-0.3495346904,
0.6851919293,
0.0616309345,
-1.0158190727,
0.5704092383,
-0.1479462683,
0.4721659422,
0.5026012063,
0.0309336875,
-0.1968994737,
-0.6089749932,
-0.3810205758,
-0.8433128595,
0.4045066237,
0.4756015539,
0.2088111192,
-0.0571806543,
0.2947701216,
0.1194865331,
0.1660223603,
-0.8484210968,
-0.0689081103,
0.46372509,
-0.1362379193,
-0.1675644666,
-0.5776253343,
-0.0400901511,
-0.1084342524,
0.7469029427,
-0.1348848194,
-0.1007046625,
0.2744468749,
-0.5601693392,
-0.2149480879,
0.6155185699,
0.6219607592,
0.7257022262,
-0.206417501,
0.0043107802,
0.410884887,
-0.3294705749,
-0.0943647847,
-0.0603197366,
-0.4465823472,
0.0873907879,
0.6402598023,
0.7243123651,
0.4474861324,
-0.7526373267,
0.5841858983,
0.1375757158,
0.0323625542,
-0.3215134442,
-0.0628276244,
-0.2187571377,
0.2136628628,
0.4533705413,
0.0510834903,
0.2512514293,
-0.4860722423,
0.2512882352,
0.6125451922,
-0.3654142916,
0.0082079833,
0.4766552448,
0.0879908651,
-0.0610748753,
0.5480149984,
-0.0561384968,
-0.5866135359,
0.5558565259,
0.5711071491,
0.9037959576,
-0.0937457457,
-0.0957939774,
0.2661621571,
0.3214385808,
-0.0266523622,
-0.0292568374,
0.1404575258,
-0.7241516709,
-0.6110129356,
-0.84536165,
-0.1279407144,
0.4016117454,
-0.4962643087,
0.473969847,
-0.3158404827,
-0.3870712817,
-0.0533073582,
0.0138797779,
-0.5918940306,
0.139781639,
0.4602592289,
0.684612155,
-0.8920275569,
0.744004786,
0.6206755042,
-0.1824339181,
-0.37546736,
0.3504488766,
0.0860873088,
-0.2075590491,
0.6868991852,
0.2871703804,
0.0207617581,
-0.3457181752,
-0.0961583257,
-0.610565722,
0.6162787676,
0.4223893583,
-0.8722184896,
0.1785610616,
0.2927747369,
0.4876429141,
-0.5248564482,
0.4408232272,
0.6705639958,
0.3587190211,
-0.2855958939,
-1.0311129093,
-0.0388139263,
0.0532971919,
0.1472515315,
-0.04066208,
-0.110525243,
0.4923565388,
-0.1637667269,
0.0197020359,
0.031620536,
0.5331468582,
0.5162678361,
0.3175537884,
0.6062344313,
0.3060742319,
0.8063784838,
0.2206495553,
1.2486718893,
0.0880334899,
0.4224969447,
1.4053530693,
-0.4078271985,
0.851683557,
0.7369677424,
-0.2506282926,
0.2649433911,
0.4938177168,
-0.0131423976,
0.2353983521,
0.775673449,
-0.5236169696,
-0.165496394,
-0.0952439457,
0.0495451838,
0.4279207289,
0.3301435411,
-0.5857263803,
-0.1043545157,
0.140689075,
0.1385154426,
0.2922100425,
-0.4006040096,
0.4959021509,
0.0375015065,
-0.7100712061,
0.4876970351,
-0.0037991875,
1.0268490314,
-0.2161626965,
0.0254955404,
-0.3145751357,
0.3092694283,
-0.442620188,
-0.4964564443,
0.2314181775,
0.1558711529,
-0.3081243038,
0.1118186563,
0.6559453011,
-0.3170011044,
-0.9086917639,
0.4188483357,
0.3839829862,
0.0747890547,
-0.4653306305,
-0.3720975518,
0.286049217,
-0.0012153557,
-0.4312367737,
0.4469320178,
0.034327846,
-0.3443425894,
0.4702861309,
0.4807226658,
0.1268576384,
0.1002265811,
0.5519139767,
0.6666975617,
-0.2869172692,
-0.1810342818,
-1.2714955807,
0.3730659187,
-0.0838851482,
-0.0796249881,
0.7613948584,
0.8876901269,
0.8763084412,
-0.0591833889,
0.8735589981,
0.2170604914,
0.3772182167,
-0.7475104928,
0.7871624827,
-0.398144275,
0.7606807947,
-0.569637835,
-1.4621751308,
-0.6290983558,
0.593909204,
-0.5653017163,
0.137300998,
0.6551114917,
0.74277246,
-0.0099401912,
-0.2140173018,
0.4897652268,
0.1925267577,
0.2086834759,
0.5209425092,
0.8632499576,
-0.416644007,
0.3461389542,
-0.342063278,
-0.2590806782,
-0.2998274565,
-0.9262843728,
-1.1006222963,
-0.1760027856,
-0.4583857358,
-0.3409089744,
0.2054336071,
1.040433526,
0.3588210344,
-0.7645823359,
-0.4014839232,
-0.1079016402,
0.2027104795,
-0.0424347445,
-0.2822628915,
0.5182816386,
-0.5595785379,
-0.8581348658,
0.4702355266,
0.2352601886,
-0.2707188725,
-0.3507674634,
-0.0252981633,
-0.1103654653,
0.0343729369,
0.7859274745,
-0.2950710952,
-0.8666176796,
-0.4493803978,
-0.261100173,
-0.03610266,
0.0774141327,
0.6896314621,
-0.9514808655,
0.4703369737,
0.3939459026,
0.4595557749,
0.2533724606,
-0.0462737419,
0.97951442,
-0.9324375987,
0.0744772851,
0.1797217429,
0.5104958415,
0.4399066567,
-0.5468216538,
0.4443529248,
0.100442104,
-0.4977918267,
-0.7624839544,
0.059893582,
-0.6369081736,
-0.2299323082,
1.2985010147,
-0.1172739863,
0.0014359729,
0.0606048442,
-0.0923027173,
0.1797648817,
-0.2329752147,
0.910539031,
0.8052733541,
0.0024813979,
0.144994989,
-0.7951225638,
0.4627212286,
0.8802987933,
-0.7332005501,
0.0726170093,
0.69583565,
0.3842433095,
-0.1384949386,
0.3255899549,
-0.1366366297,
0.1968752444,
-0.3922751248,
0.0258628614,
0.4086092114,
-0.1354487836,
-0.743622601,
-0.0409173071,
0.160937652,
-0.0102131199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15985v1
|
Phonetic and Lexical Discovery of a Canine Language using HuBERT
| 2024-02-25T04:35:45 | 2024-02-25T04:35:45 |
Xingyuan Li, Sinong Wang, Zeyu Xie, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This paper delves into the pioneering exploration of potential communication
patterns within dog vocalizations and transcends traditional linguistic
analysis barriers, which heavily relies on human priori knowledge on limited
datasets to find sound units in dog vocalization. We present a self-supervised
approach with HuBERT, enabling the accurate classification of phoneme labels
and the identification of vocal patterns that suggest a rudimentary vocabulary
within dog vocalizations. Our findings indicate a significant acoustic
consistency in these identified canine vocabulary, covering the entirety of
observed dog vocalization sequences. We further develop a web-based dog
vocalization labeling system. This system can highlight phoneme n-grams,
present in the vocabulary, in the dog audio uploaded by users.
|
[
-0.5353614688,
-0.4316935837,
0.3239334226,
0.7189645767,
0.1728951484,
0.0472295359,
-0.2686300874,
-0.6588760018,
0.6755103469,
0.2371269614,
-0.3053229451,
-0.6335852742,
-0.2157215923,
0.134901166,
-0.345132798,
0.5957778096,
0.3898943961,
0.08172445,
0.1981849819,
0.0089229411,
0.0155835887,
-0.5299969912,
-0.9250663519,
-0.3937980831,
0.6762993932,
0.3071226478,
0.5234855413,
0.7142680287,
0.3092346787,
0.2955541611,
0.0115766693,
-0.1698571742,
-0.0074007907,
0.0663704053,
0.0161850359,
-0.2633627355,
-0.5645052791,
0.349503845,
0.6461461782,
0.8117644191,
-0.6246668696,
-0.0828538537,
-0.2686119378,
0.4258706868,
-0.5147613287,
0.2563949823,
-0.5342709422,
0.047965236,
-0.568120718,
-0.307780236,
-0.3324236572,
-0.1990206242,
0.1204026788,
-0.8279736042,
0.4644483328,
-0.1043539196,
1.123328805,
-0.1223494112,
-0.1255893707,
-0.5216069221,
-0.6858807802,
0.9276453853,
-0.6260715127,
0.6392751336,
1.0965061188,
0.0591712967,
-0.3377769291,
-0.9540957808,
-0.3718833029,
-0.5379753113,
-0.1294945031,
0.0139346309,
-0.3045670986,
0.0943987295,
0.1289333105,
0.3839207292,
-0.5509985089,
0.0864953101,
-0.3877220154,
-0.3953841329,
0.8389680386,
-0.0895094946,
0.5002159476,
-0.1246584728,
-0.1703026146,
-0.1216447055,
-0.178822279,
0.2483359426,
0.2755898237,
0.3753743172,
-0.0887722597,
0.3937562704,
-0.2362355739,
0.5276606679,
0.1935904771,
-0.4411855936,
0.538233757,
0.0586479381,
-0.0616274737,
0.4739553034,
0.8903210163,
0.1179726049,
0.0772973821,
-0.2672997415,
-0.2276396602,
-0.2619654238,
0.3315746188,
-0.4432500303,
-0.5182387233,
0.0108848279,
-0.5298044086,
-0.4565339684,
0.1338994503,
-0.0480196737,
-0.2336235046,
-0.2158777714,
0.4293514788,
-0.6937070489,
-0.3708047569,
0.2745511532,
-0.6825756431,
0.4665959775,
0.091577448,
-1.3521600962,
0.5342947245,
0.3899215162,
0.6136877537,
0.2815670669,
-0.5290572643,
-0.3175071478,
0.3570609093,
-0.7261104584,
0.5437698364,
-0.4155235291,
-0.4028480351,
-0.3111688793,
0.1821008474,
0.1296011806,
-0.9301797152,
0.4618418813,
-0.2488884628,
-0.1007916331,
-0.2340069115,
-0.6359265447,
-0.2715501189,
-0.0371444151,
-0.4967804849,
1.2793710232,
0.2323921472,
-0.8030974269,
0.3047847748,
-0.3843750954,
-0.5126857162,
0.2941066325,
-0.2237382531,
-0.0107592391,
0.1642982364,
0.0553216562,
0.5925100446,
0.135780856,
0.3695500791,
-0.2907143235,
-0.2103805542,
0.3403137028,
0.1718830615,
0.8276528716,
-0.0772414282,
-0.3227339685,
-0.150859952,
-1.2350491285,
0.3867864609,
0.2084790766,
-0.379781276,
-0.7059275508,
-0.0674505383,
-0.15999569,
-0.1377839595,
0.4207054675,
-0.7304373384,
0.2596845031,
-0.0849557295,
0.196937263,
0.2835570872,
-0.2178811729,
0.1768395305,
-0.3272266984,
0.2476125062,
-0.5104806423,
0.2265763134,
0.0493094847,
-0.5610679984,
-0.7462232709,
-0.5266506672,
0.502212882,
0.6350243688,
0.2522587478,
0.6262463927,
0.0664786324,
-0.5557435155,
-0.6336562037,
0.0192008503,
-0.0862251967,
0.2202383876,
0.3091603518,
-0.5794006586,
-0.5766085386,
-1.3061116934,
0.2232170552,
-0.4032349586,
-0.2870150805,
0.4184420705,
-0.0109563777,
-0.347263813,
0.8483070731,
-0.2548890114,
-0.1866822988,
-0.2465067208,
0.5555197001,
0.1119362414,
0.3440757096,
0.524318099,
-0.2658670247,
-0.5249806643,
0.2352977693,
-0.933062613,
-0.541244626,
0.1856917888,
0.0761021078,
-0.2204003036,
0.8805848956,
-0.3888382912,
0.3251087368,
0.2846692502,
0.4267534018,
0.3679451644,
-0.1487429142,
-0.0183882471,
-0.4831041098,
-0.0150985979,
-0.0844012648,
-0.0349895284,
-0.8756815791,
-0.477394253,
0.1965627968,
0.1365629882,
0.0427773669,
0.2880831957,
-0.5943235755,
-0.2157554179,
-0.3492261469,
0.2948982418,
-0.0832947865,
0.1456234008,
0.3867600858,
0.5657208562,
1.1290597916,
-0.652749896,
0.2544180453,
0.3538325429,
-0.0260268841,
0.4213328362,
-0.5242259502,
0.165624544,
-0.0218600053,
0.1063271686,
-0.7097354531,
-0.1973963529,
0.1950825155,
-0.8269187808,
0.4273562431,
-0.2021250874,
-0.2100881487,
0.0553519912,
-0.2688480318,
0.0990424305,
0.2865390778,
-0.521940589,
0.1702251136,
0.6504346132,
-0.3474228382,
-0.468937248,
-0.169638589,
0.3889277577,
-0.1347656995,
-0.8879316449,
0.5212928653,
0.136777848,
-0.3641488552,
-0.2256475091,
-0.0698488727,
-0.3164926767,
0.1008356288,
0.2043234557,
-0.1710177213,
-0.5182335973,
0.5113216043,
-0.3288702369,
0.0556394868,
0.1781351417,
-0.2836999297,
0.436062336,
-0.2633144855,
0.2539429367,
-0.6837038398,
0.4092687666,
0.575473249,
-0.0621763207,
0.2918521166,
1.0383700132,
-0.4755545855,
-0.162658006,
-0.7135677934,
-0.2060341537,
-0.4903860688,
0.085421063,
-0.4116335511,
-0.3931385279,
0.4148621261,
-0.2439479828,
-0.6380137801,
0.1322165579,
-0.0184615552,
-0.5739859343,
0.7810865641,
0.8820213675,
-0.3554296494,
0.4007606804,
-0.167809248,
0.1172891781,
-0.9283883572,
-0.3463103473,
-0.4603435695,
-0.0797909871,
-0.8403117061,
-0.0987084582,
0.070392549,
0.5290522575,
0.2166047245,
0.2060785592,
-0.3872177899,
0.3023201227,
0.9037533402,
-0.2995956242,
0.1069141999,
0.2260859311,
-0.4020556509,
-0.2523110807,
-0.6012527347,
-0.4289724827,
0.6498721242,
0.4431717694,
0.7374736071,
0.1765910387,
0.9972642064,
0.2844001949,
-0.0520688705,
-1.0995196104,
0.5949939489,
0.1630523503,
-0.6596679091,
-0.7150665522,
-0.0702873468,
-1.1581014395,
0.1627351493,
-0.1067953706,
-1.1955341101,
0.0416541286,
-0.17971389,
0.1218638942,
-0.0498465225,
-0.441367805,
0.6884307861,
-0.3519831896,
-0.0955725089,
-0.1952914894,
-0.7506189346,
0.2166276276,
-0.0585927665,
0.0600758195,
-0.3932735622,
-0.0482990071,
0.7797654271,
-0.6322264075,
0.7852137089,
0.0256012138,
-0.3197511137,
0.309651792,
-0.104641363,
0.3214913309,
-0.0827516839,
0.2283341885,
0.2089746892,
-0.1079550907,
-0.3805366755,
-0.450055927,
0.609585464,
-0.5064151287,
-0.3718939126,
-0.4140285552,
-0.0776824057,
-0.4491157532,
0.2693919241,
0.4031931162,
0.2193502784,
-0.2770535052,
-0.0479147919,
0.5598732829,
-0.3209600449,
0.4898623824,
1.0907622576,
-0.3954181671,
-0.4802832007,
1.1461524963,
-0.0132615156,
0.0111999558,
0.2314150929,
0.5416731238,
-0.3271591961,
-0.541888535,
-0.3330023587,
0.7329506874,
-0.4518049061,
0.2643508315,
-0.5860908628,
-0.4484985173,
-0.3936794102,
-0.0642837733,
-0.5417808294,
-0.4784542024,
-0.101824984,
0.0778790489,
0.2032877058,
1.3065437078,
-0.7100767493,
0.4163836837,
-0.9292974472,
0.2168492973,
0.4666311741,
0.3849591315,
-0.0274746511,
-0.269775182,
-0.2502493858,
-0.2489982545,
-0.3369487226,
-1.0853307247,
0.3798896968,
0.3614545763,
0.7996100187,
0.4137099385,
-0.1456628144,
0.712523222,
-0.3814972937,
0.5292412639,
0.1811204106,
-1.1105508804,
0.9238391519,
-0.7102040052,
-0.0649154782,
0.2584071457,
0.5653471351,
-0.940395236,
-0.7170716524,
-0.965325892,
-0.8181421757,
0.5840349197,
0.3437986672,
-0.1363461614,
-0.1511024833,
0.1404456794,
0.0605772473,
0.2015663385,
-0.3627640307,
-0.4277217686,
-0.1586478353,
0.3625273108,
-0.0523615368,
-0.1386288553,
-0.0152469473,
-0.7061623931,
0.9268906713,
-0.0232806485,
0.1100174561,
0.4305287898,
0.0741596892,
-0.0025620526,
0.3870743811,
0.9006928802,
0.5521972775,
-0.5513219237,
0.0779198632,
-0.0030711293,
-0.7936299443,
0.0962857604,
0.0883654729,
0.0595722198,
0.6016005278,
0.3565818667,
0.6230818033,
-0.0637559891,
-0.4428183734,
0.5637550354,
-0.0685744211,
-0.3489659727,
-0.6672763228,
-0.2740593553,
0.3217550516,
0.0660220385,
0.3879873753,
-0.2544761002,
0.3866796196,
-0.510840714,
0.3644111454,
0.5957567096,
-0.4971629977,
-0.4364210367,
0.3140189946,
-0.0496037416,
-0.176558733,
0.7401310802,
-0.4771188498,
-0.3617259264,
0.4333098829,
0.557091713,
0.8885422945,
-0.5531938076,
0.4327711463,
0.3397580683,
0.3154967427,
-0.0692011118,
0.2135849446,
-0.2645436823,
-0.8469017148,
0.0592956655,
-0.636808753,
-0.2749069333,
0.8479076028,
-1.031471014,
0.3892545998,
-0.3893945515,
-0.4424086213,
0.778596282,
-0.2893327475,
0.0588220395,
0.1988832951,
0.4702688754,
0.6063714623,
-0.4711507261,
0.9356982112,
0.7160505056,
-0.040934287,
-1.0418316126,
0.0851903036,
0.0006952508,
-0.6843576431,
1.0309544802,
0.0995833427,
-0.4877172112,
-0.1318688095,
-0.6430388689,
-0.95071733,
0.8050070405,
-0.0113977017,
-0.288005203,
0.3705280125,
-0.1175881177,
0.459254235,
-0.0861348659,
-0.0202440117,
0.5772188902,
0.4823639691,
0.0379105695,
-1.4264963865,
-0.2777359188,
-0.4548791349,
-0.2526181936,
0.2816271186,
-0.5455947518,
0.6991300583,
-0.3260528743,
-0.4083494544,
-0.0396855734,
0.4349125028,
-0.1117535233,
0.39614591,
0.2414600104,
0.5152741671,
1.1805896759,
0.2979460359,
0.4430843294,
-0.1567578465,
0.2975796461,
1.0804892778,
-0.2116651982,
0.8959807158,
0.2757420242,
-0.4753000438,
0.3959342241,
0.5720930099,
-0.1242377609,
0.2384410799,
0.7889738083,
-0.6686946154,
-0.3540414274,
-0.4369208515,
-0.4379703701,
0.7555125356,
0.610040009,
-0.3582650721,
0.0659751594,
-0.1446314156,
-0.1570691317,
-0.4014268219,
-0.0862795636,
0.9433150887,
-0.0448887534,
-0.219496578,
1.1328676939,
0.1201278642,
0.6763228774,
-0.5492606759,
-0.0609787293,
-0.1407108009,
-0.0412469022,
-0.4366261959,
-0.4802712798,
0.1772456318,
-0.4902123809,
-0.2217826545,
-0.0024308693,
0.910947144,
-0.4520108998,
-0.1200632453,
0.4379512072,
0.4636126161,
0.6175891161,
-0.0233781543,
-0.2312799096,
-0.1899206638,
-0.0270027686,
0.1661198884,
0.2594566345,
0.43378672,
-0.1348714083,
0.8411730528,
0.2891587913,
0.2561976612,
0.5537141562,
0.3444434404,
0.2858408988,
-0.9701811671,
-0.3456365466,
-0.3697471619,
0.0794534832,
-0.2544395626,
-0.0283780713,
0.7967668176,
0.7887964845,
0.9404052496,
-0.2288151234,
1.211468339,
-0.1109014153,
0.6463118196,
-0.2778590322,
0.5166245699,
-0.466268748,
0.0807498023,
-0.181940794,
-0.4385024309,
-0.1604096889,
0.9520635605,
0.0795292258,
-0.2129822224,
0.8473313451,
0.9437741041,
-0.1982981116,
0.2701158524,
0.6244965196,
-0.1149308234,
-0.1008300558,
-0.2072494179,
1.2285186052,
-0.2792442441,
0.4110352099,
-0.5649582148,
-0.1717852056,
-0.0071401703,
-0.479944855,
-0.7944763303,
-0.8053205013,
-0.4694696963,
-0.2537096739,
-0.0573299192,
0.8067465425,
0.8753213882,
-0.7546205521,
-0.5721346736,
0.1526343077,
-0.201319769,
-0.2276881039,
-0.2949385345,
0.087171331,
-0.6447844505,
-0.4747546613,
0.7248509526,
0.4793601334,
0.6264129281,
-0.0793460682,
-0.1822923571,
-0.0088019269,
0.1691652536,
0.4538858831,
0.618041873,
-0.9189079404,
-0.1323535591,
0.1958587319,
-0.2962445617,
0.4112500846,
1.0503122807,
-0.4252641499,
0.3228343427,
0.2081114948,
0.1529255211,
0.649395287,
0.0087436493,
0.4069526494,
-1.0200704336,
-0.0383955874,
0.088924326,
0.0731370449,
0.4425038099,
-0.1688941419,
0.4501004219,
0.2884376645,
-0.3133341074,
-0.4090324342,
0.1372558326,
-1.3421969414,
-0.1561086923,
0.9601305723,
-0.0914213806,
-0.1082070023,
-0.3751579821,
-0.3998883069,
-0.0599883758,
-0.5407273769,
0.6672931314,
1.0195996761,
-0.6172063351,
-0.1259668618,
-0.8503613472,
0.7559320331,
0.1594596207,
-0.4071193039,
-0.1357880086,
0.3075557649,
0.5563347936,
0.4901123941,
1.0497555733,
0.0683656111,
0.0371806212,
0.1947090924,
0.2982492745,
0.4194263518,
-0.3574249446,
-0.0474053547,
-0.0637919381,
0.4719387591,
-0.6637454629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15967v1
|
Direct Punjabi to English speech translation using discrete units
| 2024-02-25T03:03:34 | 2024-02-25T03:03:34 |
Prabhjot Kaur, L. Andrew M. Bush, Weisong Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech-to-speech translation is yet to reach the same level of coverage as
text-to-text translation systems. The current speech technology is highly
limited in its coverage of over 7000 languages spoken worldwide, leaving more
than half of the population deprived of such technology and shared experiences.
With voice-assisted technology (such as social robots and speech-to-text apps)
and auditory content (such as podcasts and lectures) on the rise, ensuring that
the technology is available for all is more important than ever. Speech
translation can play a vital role in mitigating technological disparity and
creating a more inclusive society. With a motive to contribute towards speech
translation research for low-resource languages, our work presents a direct
speech-to-speech translation model for one of the Indic languages called
Punjabi to English. Additionally, we explore the performance of using a
discrete representation of speech called discrete acoustic units as input to
the Transformer-based translation model. The model, abbreviated as Unit-to-Unit
Translation (U2UT), takes a sequence of discrete units of the source language
(the language being translated from) and outputs a sequence of discrete units
of the target language (the language being translated to). Our results show
that the U2UT model performs better than the Speech-to-Unit Translation (S2UT)
model by a 3.69 BLEU score.
|
[
-0.0649945661,
-0.5097615719,
0.4171299338,
0.6562045813,
-0.4905128181,
0.0903353468,
-0.478284955,
-0.4615504742,
-0.0114028351,
0.1627515405,
-0.4366312027,
-0.1848716438,
-0.5236265063,
0.5238121748,
-0.699795723,
0.3484747708,
0.3711203933,
0.2795755565,
0.048696395,
0.1549152583,
-0.7888444066,
-0.1785333157,
-0.5312911868,
-0.523011744,
0.3806114197,
0.5201981068,
0.6944090128,
0.4912618995,
0.5749440193,
0.2384480536,
-0.0404117219,
-0.0631161258,
-0.2353459299,
0.0482750684,
-0.2048609853,
-0.4088611007,
-0.1846355647,
-0.1013648435,
0.8655480742,
0.7683140039,
-0.1134611592,
-0.0680984929,
-0.0298446864,
0.4432533085,
-0.1471035033,
0.1976610124,
-0.5759689212,
-0.0326789841,
-0.5009397268,
-0.0050951475,
-0.9062923789,
-0.5884143114,
-0.105762355,
-0.4831533432,
-0.3984949887,
-0.160464853,
0.3683029115,
0.407432735,
-0.5828270912,
-0.3971962333,
-1.430236578,
0.7510110736,
-0.7742756009,
0.6471768618,
0.3212142587,
0.1066682711,
0.168064788,
-0.8334082365,
-0.6728953719,
-0.1359711438,
-0.309127152,
0.2170140892,
-0.3748627901,
-0.0973502547,
-0.0679067746,
0.360692203,
-0.6379653811,
0.138526395,
-0.4999210835,
0.2308725119,
0.7874439359,
-0.1048801765,
0.489095062,
-0.5307358503,
-0.253197968,
-0.0974078998,
-0.5515242815,
0.0758051202,
0.0693288296,
0.6133050919,
-0.2948441803,
0.6656162739,
-0.0593860596,
0.4644599259,
0.2907378078,
-0.4198662639,
0.0977843404,
-0.2848296463,
-0.2397084236,
0.5265052915,
0.7667585611,
-0.0839965343,
0.2315390706,
-0.1752455086,
-0.0987571999,
0.1776891947,
0.0504667461,
-0.6529811621,
0.0485595353,
0.0914147124,
-0.1770327389,
-0.0551632866,
-0.4101703167,
-0.4121307731,
-0.0120459031,
-0.3945246041,
0.2836233974,
-0.83913517,
-0.679335773,
0.0870539993,
0.3770560622,
0.6496704817,
0.1852570176,
-0.9459093213,
0.4008778632,
0.5407313704,
0.935942471,
-0.2207526565,
0.0500000939,
-0.1892149746,
0.2727977633,
-0.6280389428,
0.8353019953,
-0.6955393553,
-0.8209862113,
0.0793193206,
-0.2980051041,
-0.402828306,
-0.3523366749,
0.6965997219,
-0.348056674,
0.0928456932,
0.0514288917,
-0.4298858047,
-0.0524249151,
-0.4657550156,
-0.4549154639,
0.878508985,
0.1676576287,
-0.3852931261,
0.0144471275,
-0.7274965644,
-0.8725069165,
0.6054310203,
-0.319185406,
-0.1492290348,
0.270837456,
0.1203811094,
0.1932688057,
-0.3991819918,
0.2675286829,
0.348556459,
-0.3986886442,
0.3078209162,
-0.567376852,
0.9342434406,
0.5113828778,
-0.3432133198,
0.1195065752,
-0.4601474106,
-0.0102241542,
0.0347483233,
-0.0786818489,
-0.3504216373,
0.0259111337,
0.3348054886,
0.2236800045,
-0.0413272157,
-0.7236992717,
0.0542348772,
-0.5163570642,
0.5605326295,
0.4781229198,
-0.3260536194,
0.7856363654,
-0.0416023955,
0.3124037683,
-0.00294259,
0.0836300254,
-0.0515031405,
-0.7594531775,
-0.3474249542,
-0.3981184363,
0.6271605492,
0.7691072822,
-0.5723686814,
0.304748565,
-0.6771922708,
-0.5478574634,
-1.0174516439,
-0.1361707598,
0.0167027377,
0.3696745634,
0.1739647537,
-0.2313678861,
-0.4095180035,
-0.8925042152,
0.1527133882,
-0.3964405358,
-0.3413223326,
-0.0325993486,
0.1135347486,
-0.3984814286,
0.8189202547,
-0.1350384057,
-0.5929227471,
-0.5039534569,
-0.0671673268,
0.1147505119,
0.535664022,
0.180783242,
-1.0035492182,
-0.7185902596,
0.329215914,
-0.8173133731,
-0.2414336354,
-0.4330707192,
0.0321961716,
0.207624346,
0.3546281159,
-0.7475717664,
0.4986800849,
0.699906826,
-0.1575747281,
0.0774153471,
-0.0371591039,
0.2080989778,
-1.2074850798,
0.0553069301,
-0.1796000153,
-0.2255660444,
-0.7290502787,
0.164170146,
0.2355012596,
-0.3197155595,
-0.6660919785,
0.3136026561,
-0.1259753108,
-0.0109208031,
-0.0884861872,
0.389154315,
-0.2933322191,
0.1447712779,
0.030699838,
1.2535518408,
0.2766728699,
-0.4321759939,
0.3441953361,
0.6328411102,
-0.2573911548,
0.7115576863,
-0.5676047206,
0.2227210104,
0.2748550475,
0.1692641228,
-1.0092269182,
-0.1952296197,
0.021265449,
-0.7366575599,
0.4016110897,
0.1880059242,
-0.4263141751,
-0.1083651707,
0.0092380745,
0.5875316262,
0.7022632957,
-0.3654266298,
0.6545697451,
0.4123187959,
-0.5760499239,
0.0375749171,
-0.8514121175,
0.336869061,
-0.0636262968,
-0.806714952,
0.5154470205,
-0.1678350121,
-0.3791197538,
-0.049855385,
0.0805237889,
-0.1996782422,
-0.2316231728,
0.3136455119,
-0.0240274575,
-0.2677052319,
0.097799927,
0.1637749821,
-0.0958416462,
0.0128393136,
-0.2457708269,
0.693855226,
-0.0167408735,
-0.3172014356,
-0.7567846775,
1.0078583956,
0.6609416604,
-0.2625469267,
0.5532351136,
0.5701906681,
-0.5058037639,
0.0862968341,
-0.3962114453,
-0.0446808003,
-0.4477371871,
0.2788520157,
-0.778998971,
-0.3833858371,
0.3222913146,
-0.307836175,
-0.2362393588,
0.7296225429,
0.6520728469,
-0.1149230003,
1.0847640038,
0.6820774078,
-0.1843990982,
0.2509392202,
-0.0257752221,
0.6091802716,
-0.7155116796,
-0.4670423865,
-0.5682865977,
-0.0884415805,
-0.7087709904,
-0.3006244004,
0.2968353629,
0.0873127431,
0.1992498636,
0.5395717621,
-0.5685838461,
0.0959211662,
0.7396283746,
-0.0832853317,
0.5614118576,
0.1191828847,
-0.0947716609,
-0.4891049564,
-0.5787925124,
-0.4072506428,
0.7221186161,
0.2879447043,
0.6255306602,
0.3872085214,
0.5967046022,
0.5076652169,
0.0974559188,
-0.9115809202,
0.4508913457,
-0.3130837679,
-0.3531107605,
-0.5375034809,
-0.3693469167,
-0.8615161777,
0.0717044175,
0.2316897213,
-0.3094073534,
0.2605502307,
-0.5172461271,
-0.2982863486,
0.3010381758,
-0.8498159051,
0.2829320729,
-0.2053986937,
-0.1331014186,
-0.3605924845,
-0.3985696435,
0.3297566772,
-0.3097968996,
0.3882949054,
0.0704442039,
0.2009545714,
0.5724872351,
-0.0271466207,
0.5260587335,
0.2052338123,
-0.2534401417,
0.094136022,
-0.0047546863,
0.1469170451,
0.1915144175,
-0.2157638967,
0.3548577726,
-0.0534532219,
-0.4339002967,
-0.282142967,
0.6509269476,
-0.9650937915,
-0.4932350218,
-0.5340980887,
-0.7928086519,
0.0172967315,
0.1708916724,
0.4760995507,
0.2555770874,
-0.0428744182,
0.348756671,
0.7019124627,
-0.1421327889,
0.6499329805,
0.5120227933,
-0.2574568987,
-0.3359158039,
0.606790185,
0.3448703289,
0.2506901622,
0.4706112444,
0.067917794,
-0.5775458217,
-0.4545240998,
-0.659088254,
0.3892727494,
-0.3986593485,
-0.311023891,
-0.4809674025,
-0.5697219372,
-0.8370079994,
-0.2085705847,
-0.4793957174,
-0.5103661418,
0.0682379827,
0.0049316729,
0.3464694619,
1.1047942638,
-0.4672948122,
0.452926904,
-0.4152418971,
0.35501948,
0.608104527,
0.2413800359,
-0.3849986792,
-0.9289926291,
-0.2135742754,
0.1494080424,
-0.1553645432,
-0.9915625453,
0.6421462893,
0.374445349,
0.1331288517,
0.1071275175,
0.3881416321,
0.8308878541,
-0.88688761,
0.7280882597,
0.2666240633,
-1.0211427212,
0.7970452905,
-0.2805753946,
0.4309389889,
0.2343298197,
0.3093349934,
-0.8313966393,
-0.3995418847,
-0.2175506353,
-1.0427154303,
0.5992675424,
0.4761248827,
0.3484657109,
-0.0806660354,
0.0504919179,
-0.1293995529,
-0.1497449875,
-0.7411257625,
-0.2847235203,
-0.1550199538,
-0.1559646726,
-0.0077099791,
-0.2216774374,
0.0635696575,
-0.4675984979,
0.7268943191,
0.3630151451,
0.5488528609,
0.2742339373,
-0.290543288,
-0.3738051653,
0.5320272446,
0.8523308635,
0.4476889968,
-0.3766563833,
-0.1052422374,
0.160494253,
-0.7312611341,
0.2993950546,
0.2523850501,
-0.4192599058,
0.4852405488,
0.1617342234,
0.4883931875,
0.2930063903,
-0.2400841713,
0.4398008883,
-0.25845173,
0.0391167775,
-0.7465469241,
-0.4283421636,
0.2487793714,
0.0474776216,
0.7478381991,
0.125463143,
-0.0429134518,
-0.4365483522,
0.349244535,
-0.0412438624,
-0.4239924252,
-0.3229793906,
0.8968630433,
0.585911274,
-0.7687496543,
0.6543110609,
-0.1161404252,
-0.1122683734,
0.0744174272,
0.8502770066,
0.975710094,
-0.9231513739,
0.2866417468,
0.2588475049,
0.4855908155,
-0.0152446497,
-0.0472016037,
0.1621520072,
-0.212572366,
-0.880800724,
-0.5834743977,
-0.5787972212,
0.2124672979,
-0.8550251722,
-0.0301711131,
0.0915288627,
-0.0590314306,
-0.0880988762,
-0.0071941707,
-0.5836501718,
0.1748174578,
0.33194682,
0.9683731198,
-0.9074548483,
1.3924168348,
0.446044296,
-0.5375605226,
-1.012544632,
-0.2007883936,
-0.2510878742,
-0.5614449978,
0.7062110901,
-0.0938625187,
-0.2671951056,
0.3935292661,
-0.1065996587,
-0.8001997471,
0.9160886407,
0.5140599608,
-0.8579900265,
-0.0650866851,
0.8359387517,
0.3967303038,
-0.3062432706,
0.2364456803,
0.5235586166,
0.3935363293,
-0.0150290336,
-1.1538484097,
-0.2318578213,
-0.1419465244,
0.2975266576,
-0.1450636089,
-0.4629576504,
0.8725814819,
0.1726743579,
-0.3510959148,
-0.0149968155,
0.7695131302,
-0.1604140699,
0.2370254695,
0.274110049,
0.3123858869,
0.5254226923,
-0.1454561055,
1.0833922625,
-0.3314036727,
0.1112722382,
0.8651927114,
-0.5230938196,
1.2670656443,
0.516592145,
-0.3657845557,
0.3720759451,
0.3682341576,
0.5660705566,
0.6695946455,
-0.1295356303,
-0.7650625706,
-0.0605675615,
-0.3767871261,
-0.6205765009,
0.6433740258,
0.4472799003,
-0.0363271125,
-0.02617516,
0.3165917993,
-0.0521134697,
0.6223889589,
-0.3391162157,
0.8156517744,
0.2894037366,
-0.4137209356,
0.6290549636,
0.0749215856,
0.7863631248,
-0.6724218726,
0.0632994473,
-0.5881443024,
0.184920311,
-0.2674694955,
-0.5665205717,
0.5212982297,
0.2046026886,
-0.1528574079,
-0.5269522667,
0.4621602595,
-0.6178081036,
-0.8189479709,
0.5397479534,
0.4417263269,
0.1142010018,
-0.0144700613,
-0.2524657249,
0.1700490117,
0.1337677985,
0.1192647666,
0.3199003935,
0.4763694406,
0.1413886696,
0.5281136632,
0.4429252148,
0.3303727508,
0.220005706,
-0.0716816634,
0.5284333825,
-0.5177402496,
-0.3141201437,
-0.7354629636,
0.5114627481,
-0.0027739052,
-0.0077908603,
0.8132274151,
0.6850333214,
1.1295353174,
-0.1134351641,
0.8714143634,
-0.065503031,
0.5409577489,
-0.1519793272,
0.7787091136,
-0.0678552985,
0.1607251912,
-0.1398889124,
-0.7741908431,
-0.2430838048,
0.9161435962,
-0.295203656,
-0.6222494841,
0.6848577857,
0.5884867311,
-0.0708921403,
0.1097425893,
0.8415965438,
0.1600285619,
0.254009068,
0.3628877103,
0.5252165198,
-0.7198393941,
0.8256559372,
-0.2866352499,
-0.1374003589,
0.0204071067,
-0.3964392841,
-0.2656495273,
-0.7579689026,
-0.3345522583,
-0.2242347151,
0.0324058756,
0.9178730845,
0.7754276395,
-0.9250763059,
-0.6758363843,
0.2017331123,
-0.0038302511,
-0.2132130712,
-0.172412172,
0.2021887898,
-0.2678734958,
-0.9515823126,
0.6282566786,
0.3314655423,
-0.2074882388,
-0.0703667551,
-0.2005709559,
-0.4765188694,
0.3454446197,
0.950747788,
0.2134732306,
-0.825838387,
-0.3004595041,
0.0983746946,
-0.2487882823,
0.2921446264,
0.5947363377,
-0.7825875878,
0.339479804,
0.0293653291,
0.7293909788,
0.4030908048,
-0.2258712649,
0.654720962,
-0.9758642912,
0.2663387358,
0.3389428258,
-0.0106635028,
0.5390147567,
-0.2150420099,
0.5653089881,
0.1481268406,
-0.519628942,
-0.9537522197,
0.3159866035,
-1.0025970936,
0.0042750845,
1.1112185717,
0.0558893383,
-0.0132921655,
-0.0627439171,
-0.2406745404,
0.5868822336,
-0.573245585,
0.6588895917,
0.3660662472,
0.0253102668,
-0.3855024874,
-0.5642827153,
0.3820357323,
0.4471353292,
-0.431316942,
-0.0852835253,
0.1237004846,
0.0323583297,
0.3337035179,
0.7962487936,
-0.167312786,
0.1177458465,
0.0859173685,
-0.0497374386,
0.3073406816,
-0.0675664023,
-0.5131726861,
0.046548143,
0.2044735998,
-0.3665222526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00811v1
|
Cognitive Bias in High-Stakes Decision-Making with LLMs
| 2024-02-25T02:35:56 | 2024-02-25T02:35:56 |
Jessica Echterhoff, Yao Liu, Abeer Alessa, Julian McAuley, Zexue He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) offer significant potential as tools to support
an expanding range of decision-making tasks. However, given their training on
human (created) data, LLMs can inherit both societal biases against protected
groups, as well as be subject to cognitive bias. Such human-like bias can
impede fair and explainable decisions made with LLM assistance. Our work
introduces BiasBuster, a framework designed to uncover, evaluate, and mitigate
cognitive bias in LLMs, particularly in high-stakes decision-making tasks.
Inspired by prior research in psychology and cognitive sciences, we develop a
dataset containing 16,800 prompts to evaluate different cognitive biases (e.g.,
prompt-induced, sequential, inherent). We test various bias mitigation
strategies, amidst proposing a novel method using LLMs to debias their own
prompts. Our analysis provides a comprehensive picture on the presence and
effects of cognitive bias across different commercial and open-source models.
We demonstrate that our self-help debiasing effectively mitigate cognitive bias
without having to manually craft examples for each bias type.
|
[
-0.5171880722,
-0.9696570635,
0.7851350904,
0.3467456996,
0.1057927012,
-0.0231944919,
-0.405893594,
-0.2259713709,
0.0309979729,
0.7987930775,
-0.8268001676,
-0.3491923809,
-0.7749020457,
-0.1978054494,
0.2506068945,
1.0693582296,
0.0511832461,
0.3717817366,
-0.497273922,
0.1722552329,
-0.8891683221,
-0.6028601527,
-0.8271484375,
-0.5592281222,
0.4303435683,
0.6114758849,
0.6674256325,
0.3058670759,
0.4078607857,
0.1251115948,
-0.1916678399,
-0.2468274087,
-0.6326092482,
0.1499370784,
-0.4604094326,
-0.5413603187,
-0.5197749138,
0.2067528665,
0.164658159,
0.5328792334,
-0.1175294742,
0.4024867117,
0.251683712,
0.6582893729,
-0.9054405689,
0.2115564644,
-0.7968840003,
0.0980491266,
-0.2089592516,
-0.0225267932,
-0.4625994563,
-0.3951144516,
0.2146650404,
-0.573816359,
0.294377774,
0.1066421494,
0.419201225,
0.6356831193,
-0.2177709043,
-0.3727193773,
-0.6302499175,
0.9639949799,
-0.3954819739,
0.0257675927,
0.561647892,
0.319068253,
-0.2140339315,
-0.0349848568,
-0.306314379,
-0.1337004155,
0.1831268072,
0.2425912917,
-0.1126676202,
0.1816338152,
0.4978118241,
-0.067997545,
-0.3055548668,
0.3756774068,
-0.1277326196,
-0.3291860521,
0.560305059,
0.1682610065,
-0.1903218329,
-0.3654804826,
-0.4458045065,
-0.0699505284,
-0.6555258036,
-0.0416413471,
0.3768119216,
0.0287393872,
0.1319588423,
0.6563215256,
-0.2072944194,
0.4074236751,
0.4201325178,
0.0010742908,
-0.0975498557,
0.0041592773,
-0.2333913296,
0.3461027741,
0.4063117504,
0.5771359205,
0.8640519977,
0.2155884057,
-0.0944616422,
0.4768184721,
0.1222478375,
-0.5811312795,
-0.0187694542,
0.3171519041,
-0.4552271664,
-0.314629823,
-0.4319981039,
-0.9112836719,
-1.0049645901,
-0.3266799748,
0.2215782255,
-0.1267085075,
-0.0042889505,
0.322460711,
-0.1298305243,
0.1534581929,
0.4470294118,
-0.5691284537,
0.0787904337,
0.3931959867,
0.4221642315,
-0.4218664467,
-0.0795338899,
-0.5003794432,
0.2462016195,
-0.1924497932,
0.8597237468,
-0.6005240679,
-0.619258225,
-0.0550828911,
-0.3194566667,
0.3852683604,
-0.7066479325,
0.9596555233,
-0.3534234464,
0.1785815507,
-0.5679448843,
-0.3521336019,
0.0107125798,
0.389298439,
-0.6196511984,
1.0836367607,
-0.172046259,
-0.8236077428,
0.7711659074,
-0.5542635918,
-0.3127129376,
0.071213983,
-0.5196143985,
-0.2512846589,
0.0483634062,
0.4912018478,
0.4641966224,
-0.6549669504,
0.4144632518,
-0.5805034637,
-0.1397007108,
0.3637387156,
-0.6721090078,
0.7456328273,
0.0479304604,
-0.5576943755,
0.1525984555,
-0.4648245573,
-0.2158105671,
0.0603042804,
-0.2689494491,
-0.6123309731,
0.0781069696,
-0.0609383807,
0.4971065819,
0.322699815,
-0.4198037088,
0.1631685346,
0.1573501229,
0.2150976956,
1.2979437113,
0.1128819957,
0.3037849665,
-0.3610392213,
0.5747184753,
0.1823827922,
0.4139069915,
0.1817760617,
-0.3430589736,
-0.7166508436,
-0.4799219668,
-0.030351473,
0.5221238136,
-0.5009035468,
0.4881171584,
-0.1005450487,
-0.1867951155,
-0.5670523047,
0.1289709955,
0.2364361137,
0.4825473726,
0.3051208854,
-0.0944307074,
-0.4295844138,
-1.0374822617,
-0.5022016764,
0.0938688591,
-0.0745497346,
0.2703387141,
0.4485752881,
-0.3182339072,
1.1921138763,
-0.6719877124,
-0.5064404011,
-0.0128500471,
-0.0259636454,
0.1342382729,
0.4351026714,
0.1283282638,
-0.464007169,
0.1108988971,
-0.6675436497,
-0.647369504,
-0.3364354074,
-0.3959542513,
-0.4247827232,
0.1345346272,
0.4617367089,
-0.7174111605,
0.413803041,
0.2610907853,
-0.4462063015,
0.6541333199,
-0.114810504,
-0.0509001948,
-0.7628925443,
-0.1891385764,
0.1118684933,
0.0472324826,
-0.0953744203,
-0.4579165578,
-0.109014973,
0.2941713333,
-0.0577976592,
0.6484626532,
-0.4033414721,
-0.0006525764,
-0.2972268164,
0.4540834129,
-0.073969692,
0.3272886872,
0.1675695479,
0.541105032,
0.4478570819,
-0.6495603919,
0.0846505836,
0.3837731183,
-0.4570085406,
0.9945918322,
-0.574893117,
-0.003572233,
-0.4077727199,
0.5593891144,
-0.858255744,
-0.0650803149,
0.213401705,
-0.2540359199,
-0.2131949812,
-0.190490514,
-0.2597474158,
-0.5431024432,
-0.4047163129,
0.4359383583,
0.385040164,
-0.5138844252,
0.5299460292,
0.4448460639,
-0.3885599971,
-0.7916522026,
-0.8002842069,
0.0815152973,
-0.3728839755,
-0.3883953393,
0.2656265199,
-0.4350234866,
-0.494466126,
-0.2141905129,
-0.1512158066,
0.2397519201,
0.0697374046,
0.5335936546,
0.482804805,
0.2544853389,
0.1874360591,
-0.0215523671,
-0.2397686839,
0.3825559318,
-0.5253878236,
0.5755109191,
0.2265622765,
-0.5995500088,
0.0449772961,
0.0556590818,
0.6132841706,
-0.3430496752,
0.3256494701,
0.3176346123,
-0.3755399883,
-0.2467837334,
-1.1275528669,
-0.2594998479,
-0.447037071,
0.2664048374,
-0.2029770166,
-0.8086640239,
0.3729876876,
-0.0701322109,
0.0088253459,
0.162786305,
0.955644846,
0.0894550756,
0.9527138472,
0.1981320679,
-0.3642006516,
0.5047229528,
-0.003097188,
-0.0592232533,
-0.7299231887,
-0.0781691596,
-0.3201113641,
-0.2791702449,
-0.4389658272,
-0.6811687946,
0.3002775908,
-0.1377954334,
-0.3926611841,
-0.3499072194,
-0.52128613,
0.5292537212,
0.6500835419,
0.2502909005,
0.3019337654,
-0.1118914634,
-0.139802292,
-0.1486790478,
-0.6193469167,
-0.6623083353,
1.1416008472,
0.2884503007,
1.0890280008,
-0.2333488613,
0.4950450063,
0.67861408,
0.2458726466,
-0.8420511484,
0.5646511912,
0.3839709461,
-1.0329318047,
-0.3155751228,
-0.4076142311,
-0.8204511404,
0.2761791348,
-0.4456785917,
-0.5318219662,
0.2690907121,
0.2335100174,
-0.434812963,
0.0776959509,
-0.4530998468,
0.5699487925,
-0.4492363632,
-0.7239492536,
-0.433237642,
-0.3475092649,
0.3627773225,
-0.2602390647,
0.4183425009,
-0.4000582993,
0.0044035912,
0.8781859875,
0.2274282873,
0.9858587384,
-0.3661595881,
-0.2846710682,
0.3111205697,
0.2305269092,
0.6752901673,
0.3084949255,
-0.3035479486,
0.1457442492,
-0.1953239441,
-0.5565792918,
-0.4027967751,
0.7351899147,
-0.5887315869,
-0.7786823511,
-0.4478635788,
-0.6440713406,
-0.3027426004,
0.1374572366,
0.1913947761,
0.0727427378,
-0.5020359755,
-0.1334595829,
0.7713816762,
-0.2457173467,
0.344358772,
0.5480220914,
-0.0076185763,
-0.4765302837,
0.2854899466,
0.1548867822,
0.1817958355,
-0.038343735,
0.3277481794,
-0.2081567347,
-0.4243353605,
-0.2095472813,
0.0669027939,
-0.779504776,
-0.0229427367,
-0.3382824659,
0.3053944707,
-0.3236458898,
-0.2917907536,
-0.1942014247,
-0.2927315831,
-0.0260281786,
-0.3738897145,
0.3340039253,
0.7856838703,
0.1218369976,
0.3676654398,
-0.3195301294,
0.2403269112,
0.2423839122,
0.3026362658,
0.0513277613,
-0.2587373555,
-0.1350589544,
-0.058982186,
-0.2796524167,
-0.6908600926,
0.0910283774,
-0.5243089795,
0.6125658154,
0.5156339407,
0.3571601212,
0.4210579395,
-0.3014434576,
0.7099656463,
0.1457039416,
-0.9231907129,
0.4597484469,
-0.3556918502,
0.4062891901,
0.7280189991,
0.2938197851,
-0.4933441281,
-0.1781995147,
-0.4981550574,
-0.732755363,
0.6208000779,
0.0649450645,
-0.2080504298,
-0.1480145305,
0.3977666795,
0.0314023197,
0.2054407746,
-0.7190154195,
-0.1544672251,
0.0550678447,
-0.2630858123,
-0.2107067555,
-0.3989042938,
-0.2701538503,
-0.0790876821,
0.6818529963,
-0.1914018542,
-0.0731187239,
0.4371868968,
-0.3467597067,
-0.1610930413,
0.4523398578,
0.3010100126,
0.4773957133,
-0.0995685756,
0.1964301616,
0.5708443522,
-0.449760139,
0.1405346543,
0.0336842835,
-0.2958693802,
-0.4752107263,
0.2007802129,
0.5091595054,
0.1742067188,
-0.8638956547,
0.4691361189,
0.0802397579,
0.0480877273,
-0.479678154,
-0.1019192711,
0.1000212654,
0.2926378548,
0.3194114268,
-0.0478302129,
0.0692738071,
-0.2384809405,
0.0232554227,
0.6987044811,
-0.5472269058,
0.1073577181,
0.4902826548,
0.3878361881,
0.0218010787,
0.3857416213,
0.1400794834,
-0.4254680276,
0.4671393335,
0.3354775012,
0.8773166537,
-0.1457711011,
0.029648941,
0.0547857955,
0.5187487602,
-0.0828049928,
0.1248693019,
0.0204110648,
-0.8608213663,
-0.3434447646,
-0.3388472795,
-0.4929234087,
0.1508956254,
-0.6904201508,
0.3862823248,
-0.5670749545,
-0.6263718605,
-0.1393164098,
-0.0350418501,
-0.8630547523,
0.1494232118,
0.3171412945,
0.8819558024,
-0.6208299398,
0.6045295596,
0.5638596416,
-0.2719181478,
-0.1120322943,
0.2487329841,
0.1293085963,
-0.9122642279,
0.6426250935,
0.1182661653,
-0.3541503847,
-0.2228333354,
-0.4751253128,
-0.7885597348,
0.9917085767,
0.5053273439,
-0.6552756429,
-0.2744735181,
0.1131446511,
0.030015463,
-0.2586157322,
0.5663380623,
0.7454000115,
0.8680189252,
-0.2322674543,
-0.5918830037,
0.1910197884,
0.3919052482,
-0.1302549541,
-0.0078672841,
-0.6471775174,
0.7068007588,
-0.2021701038,
0.174535349,
-0.4940575063,
0.3901170194,
0.5289794803,
0.3071889877,
0.7108020186,
0.319883883,
1.0379132032,
0.1499182284,
0.6402190328,
-0.2600701749,
0.140254572,
1.3366000652,
-0.6490991116,
0.4370339513,
0.6694235802,
0.1642259508,
0.4792974889,
0.5755087137,
-0.0285530686,
0.1325017512,
0.6245475411,
-0.2136793286,
-0.5704449415,
-0.3260114491,
-0.0202787463,
0.3624462485,
0.5435178876,
-0.2515335381,
-0.0568584651,
0.1027706638,
0.2966887057,
0.0973537043,
-0.4376526475,
0.5682305694,
0.0500301197,
-0.9241867661,
0.3513790667,
-0.2420849353,
1.0149964094,
-0.5584020615,
0.250618726,
-0.0458840169,
0.5343511701,
-0.1540550739,
-0.8708558679,
-0.2179142535,
0.059133932,
-0.5293120146,
-0.2667187452,
0.7707261443,
-0.1598851979,
-0.3744541705,
0.6473626494,
0.6610093713,
-0.1834552884,
-0.4710842967,
-0.8132312894,
0.0629909262,
-0.0653813556,
-0.4674891829,
0.0724577457,
0.281742841,
-0.47995767,
0.8833754659,
0.5073891878,
0.0800882503,
-0.1008577421,
0.0787938535,
0.6603197455,
-0.9182496071,
-0.3929282725,
-1.0318137407,
0.0535805412,
-0.2143347263,
-0.2681361139,
0.824313283,
0.5056626797,
0.7174744606,
-0.0835023299,
1.1940401793,
0.3385193944,
0.2776421607,
-0.4528507888,
0.5732083321,
-0.0410689935,
0.2526151538,
-0.3167791069,
-0.7566035986,
-0.0498968661,
0.4280640483,
-0.8010280728,
0.2400577664,
0.3925192058,
0.8199300766,
0.15691939,
-0.0249524936,
0.1411963254,
0.1353623122,
0.3018076718,
0.6136409044,
1.1078572273,
0.2667219043,
0.5613856912,
0.1152101979,
-0.5060723424,
-0.3204804063,
-0.9979428649,
-1.1052814722,
-0.0990710407,
-0.1516488791,
-0.3302198052,
0.1716068685,
1.2937755585,
0.725343883,
-0.6111981869,
-0.3242393136,
0.03125057,
0.3464562595,
-0.0116166743,
-0.2429772317,
0.1611657888,
-0.2473601103,
-0.4735316336,
0.2182319313,
0.0324937738,
-0.0373639427,
-0.4487543404,
-0.1839113384,
-0.117203109,
0.6331574321,
0.5605289936,
-0.2710673809,
-0.7877117395,
-0.2903968096,
-0.1588038355,
-0.1203815565,
-0.0089734858,
0.9771186113,
-0.9433730245,
0.3252341747,
0.3660598695,
0.4559882581,
0.5617738962,
-0.0170517545,
0.5529216528,
-0.4025222957,
0.07295724,
0.2652150393,
0.3700570166,
0.3691512942,
-0.5295299888,
0.4164407551,
0.1150861681,
-0.6030516028,
-0.4793549776,
0.380427748,
-0.8948462009,
-0.5011687279,
1.2964339256,
0.2670305073,
-0.050482519,
-0.1371124536,
-0.7520865798,
0.1640614867,
-0.6602412462,
0.9475275278,
0.9216126204,
-0.0961865634,
0.1856760681,
-0.5920395255,
0.6094889045,
0.7417718768,
-0.7287083268,
0.6486873627,
0.7709328532,
0.2979381084,
-0.0479584672,
0.5440087914,
0.0396134518,
-0.0079615796,
-0.3330923915,
0.534983933,
0.0670480579,
-0.1927687526,
-0.603566885,
-0.0599832237,
0.2678501904,
0.0128313918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15951v1
|
GreenLLaMA: A Framework for Detoxification with Explanations
| 2024-02-25T01:56:47 | 2024-02-25T01:56:47 |
Md Tawkat Islam Khondaker, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Prior works on detoxification are scattered in the sense that they do not
cover all aspects of detoxification needed in a real-world scenario. Notably,
prior works restrict the task of developing detoxification models to only a
seen subset of platforms, leaving the question of how the models would perform
on unseen platforms unexplored. Additionally, these works do not address
non-detoxifiability, a phenomenon whereby the toxic text cannot be detoxified
without altering the meaning. We propose GreenLLaMA, the first comprehensive
end-to-end detoxification framework, which attempts to alleviate the
aforementioned limitations. We first introduce a cross-platform pseudo-parallel
corpus applying multi-step data processing and generation strategies leveraging
ChatGPT. We then train a suite of detoxification models with our cross-platform
corpus. We show that our detoxification models outperform the SoTA model
trained with human-annotated parallel corpus. We further introduce explanation
to promote transparency and trustworthiness. GreenLLaMA additionally offers a
unique paraphrase detector especially dedicated for the detoxification task to
tackle the non-detoxifiable cases. Through experimental analysis, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of our cross-platform corpus and the robustness
of GreenLLaMA against adversarial toxicity.
|
[
-0.0303010121,
-0.8260782361,
0.8673093319,
0.0714149326,
-0.1466395557,
-0.0343013294,
-0.1398752332,
-0.4450879097,
0.1500843912,
0.3301391602,
-0.6668806076,
-0.9232053757,
-0.5991871953,
0.0628946796,
-0.642110765,
1.282066226,
0.1594437808,
-0.0266476627,
0.1536982656,
-0.0088045355,
-0.285838604,
-0.1783239096,
-0.7395157814,
-0.358997345,
0.7907249331,
0.4802438915,
0.9363405704,
0.0682574511,
0.1894604862,
0.1790702492,
-0.0448023863,
0.0038389922,
-0.8073780537,
-0.0620590635,
-0.4517413974,
-0.736682117,
0.0842880905,
0.0955615342,
0.1768472344,
0.2423779666,
-0.1110047922,
-0.0503552184,
-0.193188414,
0.5975636244,
-0.7436456084,
-0.143564716,
-0.6265836358,
0.4402000308,
-0.0295248367,
-0.4060896337,
-0.2866118252,
-0.4444930255,
-0.1757560223,
-0.8179256916,
-0.2279719263,
-0.0119408881,
1.0159438848,
0.3832530975,
-0.1918662339,
-0.1921551228,
-0.6408662796,
0.6052946448,
-0.6353706121,
0.3069924712,
0.3160322607,
0.4666569233,
-0.1217833906,
-0.8143325448,
-0.6071781516,
-0.3702875376,
0.0922828093,
0.4567743242,
-0.2286970466,
0.0045213443,
-0.3219709992,
0.3609343767,
-0.7743031383,
-0.0516183041,
-0.5767456293,
-0.2922067344,
0.2091124952,
0.1073330417,
0.8501412868,
0.1442337185,
-0.8000009656,
0.2485448271,
-0.8492295146,
-0.435741663,
0.4351973534,
0.1996084005,
0.0231875274,
0.2941986024,
-0.0299646761,
-0.0543916523,
-0.2089631259,
0.3209673762,
0.0273234379,
-0.4617563486,
-0.3095006645,
0.0955465138,
0.8086022139,
0.6405521631,
0.0313128307,
-0.5970993042,
0.3477419317,
0.0575249195,
0.5076560378,
-1.1605654955,
-0.542165339,
0.7642631531,
-0.6816962957,
-0.3165434897,
-0.3476285636,
-1.0772514343,
-0.3063502908,
-0.075741291,
0.3901774883,
-0.6339235306,
-0.528093338,
0.2745580971,
-0.3137575984,
-0.0901754349,
0.3908016086,
-0.6851038933,
0.2373846322,
0.6338732243,
1.2116605043,
-0.1357278526,
-0.0345139243,
-0.3643461168,
0.087612614,
-0.326297313,
0.7506744862,
-0.7637107968,
-0.2348789275,
-0.0915899798,
-0.0225724615,
-0.0206028316,
-0.6222453713,
0.6100666523,
-0.4671106637,
0.2421185672,
-0.4289185107,
-0.305906117,
-0.6185554266,
0.3395798206,
-0.2579982877,
0.7575230002,
-0.1944307536,
-0.8300178647,
0.1181671694,
-0.7548958063,
0.0016119838,
0.1090095937,
0.1372935772,
-0.1077808812,
0.0615002364,
-0.2840285599,
0.2317669988,
-0.3252586126,
0.3469306529,
-0.5990709662,
-0.4894180298,
-0.0447338186,
-0.3649228811,
1.0794403553,
0.7324784398,
-0.3161072731,
0.4854613245,
-0.5240877867,
0.1913986653,
-0.006958825,
-0.1871268898,
-0.375207603,
-0.2916183472,
0.6264564991,
0.5489569306,
0.2818228006,
-0.5743373036,
-0.6364816427,
-0.1172330454,
0.6490546465,
0.5986477733,
0.094118908,
-0.0386769958,
-0.43747738,
0.7440677881,
-0.0078682648,
0.1969913691,
-0.0574603081,
-0.614354074,
-0.2789772153,
-0.224685207,
-0.1817935407,
0.7773694992,
-0.3124435842,
0.2439943552,
-0.2071364671,
-0.8314848542,
0.0065909438,
0.2083759904,
0.5731457472,
0.3961936831,
0.7733923793,
-0.0129184844,
-0.2601138651,
-1.0323339701,
-0.1382277012,
-0.2168250978,
-0.0637797639,
-0.0678865165,
0.6910021901,
-0.436968714,
0.6366586685,
-0.3266294599,
-0.2195968628,
0.0192396808,
0.0487025939,
-0.0035816806,
0.3087373376,
0.4156826735,
-0.7632576227,
-0.3465188444,
0.0627309531,
-0.8683122993,
-0.2421256155,
-0.3462311924,
-0.4400488138,
-0.7307156324,
0.6184233427,
-0.4331192672,
0.1950520426,
0.3900993764,
-0.0226219594,
0.5942685008,
-0.4829638302,
-0.0970780775,
-0.9213605523,
0.3843015432,
0.3109629452,
-0.2820035517,
-0.8880832195,
0.4696291387,
0.1302894056,
-0.3702468872,
-0.6426127553,
0.466793716,
-0.122030884,
0.3416004777,
-0.4516033828,
0.1916833371,
0.129806295,
0.4353037775,
0.3282920718,
0.5332016349,
0.2877506912,
-0.4488108456,
0.0373844355,
0.1847129166,
0.2045918852,
0.7463448048,
-0.6789215803,
-0.1339763105,
-0.1548170894,
0.6082760692,
-0.9822079539,
0.0927054882,
0.8084636331,
-0.0024640232,
-0.0463717356,
-0.0047340863,
-0.5613976121,
-0.0973547325,
-0.3457431793,
0.0358819999,
0.5016203523,
-0.6212280393,
0.1148496866,
0.4436639547,
0.0363311954,
-0.2833459675,
-0.6327388287,
0.5359521508,
-0.8098521233,
-0.3781290948,
0.4877937734,
-0.2625560462,
-0.2809192538,
-0.2987498343,
-0.3021321893,
-0.2058154941,
0.3052751124,
0.2630963326,
-0.1304452568,
0.0393427834,
0.2293128967,
0.2342860103,
-0.2918604314,
0.3073779047,
-0.2314464003,
0.3093152642,
-0.2596123219,
-0.2332790345,
-0.7221366167,
0.5386268497,
0.4459783733,
-0.0626326501,
0.6514110565,
0.7137410045,
-0.6244484782,
-0.1704088748,
0.0240851883,
0.0865863562,
-0.5004603863,
0.2792962193,
-0.0962336287,
-0.4232620895,
0.5454188585,
-0.3399189413,
0.2280248106,
0.3364488184,
0.921415031,
0.0942181349,
0.4840628505,
0.3077874184,
0.3620339334,
0.329448849,
-0.0223158598,
0.3536219597,
-0.7054995894,
-0.4038723409,
-0.4320039451,
-0.4147239327,
-0.1453399211,
-0.587452352,
0.1691652983,
0.1323848218,
-0.2854546607,
0.422051996,
-0.6220352054,
0.5110293627,
0.307462424,
0.2992455959,
0.2597721219,
-0.309751302,
-0.3555775285,
0.1159496829,
-0.3441390097,
-0.822412312,
0.9931024909,
0.5907678008,
0.5593025088,
0.0824235752,
0.8965258002,
0.2057726383,
0.5744042397,
-0.3592085242,
0.6100425124,
0.0248641279,
-0.9826729894,
-0.0488803536,
-0.2061693519,
-0.6127693057,
0.3897826076,
0.0339656174,
-0.917109251,
0.2793387473,
-0.072156541,
-0.5101442337,
0.2676450312,
-0.8566410542,
0.9758132696,
-0.1594263017,
-0.6129796505,
-0.3758050203,
-0.8030932546,
0.6492050886,
-0.3953972757,
0.4713729918,
-0.397134304,
-0.1239890233,
0.5508801937,
-0.747363925,
0.8943903446,
-0.268053472,
-0.4021629989,
0.2741207778,
0.0744668841,
0.2015267909,
0.4144574702,
-0.07799422,
0.5631030202,
0.2323288769,
-0.2981545627,
-0.2783076763,
0.7589383721,
-0.4350990951,
-0.4514095187,
-0.2114542127,
-0.5695878267,
-0.0975175872,
0.339289248,
0.1887415498,
-0.2771102488,
-0.1976431459,
0.0169049799,
0.6774562001,
-0.6630983353,
0.0979714543,
0.1548733711,
-0.3519072533,
-0.0470995344,
1.0232003927,
-0.2388585806,
0.2920066416,
0.6221099496,
0.4666545987,
-0.4661984444,
-0.9644521475,
-0.1004302129,
-0.1401194334,
-0.938765049,
0.2320126146,
-0.8028408885,
-0.0774435177,
0.1249484643,
-0.0340899788,
-0.1545471698,
-0.2070232481,
-0.425655216,
-0.3032948077,
0.3639191091,
0.2865580022,
-0.4118215442,
0.1465351135,
-0.8370978236,
0.5404264927,
-0.0129332468,
-0.0618600287,
-0.0473903082,
-0.1970692575,
-0.1633206457,
0.1853358746,
-0.3530226648,
-1.2875816822,
0.4374385774,
0.252407223,
0.6101745367,
0.6790115237,
0.1631217003,
0.7450305223,
-0.6324701309,
0.8036897779,
0.3512685597,
-0.7177839875,
0.6088216305,
-0.4697104394,
-0.0503852405,
0.805359304,
0.4276783466,
-0.8028504252,
-0.8714892864,
-0.3263676465,
-0.9143842459,
0.2568499446,
0.4823731482,
0.278190136,
-0.4369329214,
0.3731828332,
0.4832809865,
0.0067696478,
-0.5984030366,
0.001818754,
-0.5761548877,
-0.3651602864,
0.0608898848,
-0.031576328,
-0.4635272026,
0.223804906,
0.72701478,
-0.0484870635,
0.219037801,
0.0356152467,
-0.4333849847,
0.0023829869,
0.4160551131,
0.5160449147,
0.7200298905,
-0.2541876435,
0.1408341825,
-0.0793462172,
-0.4020579159,
0.1743974984,
0.0090121934,
-0.1133102775,
-0.0646870807,
0.0091220653,
0.456679821,
0.346137017,
-0.8878986835,
0.0854090899,
-0.1298598349,
-0.314145267,
-0.2657955289,
0.3278202116,
0.4334632456,
0.2974167764,
0.3349988461,
0.0109334448,
0.3933637738,
-0.6259794235,
0.3036762774,
0.5721697211,
-0.3983671665,
-0.3130934536,
1.3107782602,
0.062640667,
-0.0860029459,
0.2660738528,
0.1275746822,
-0.3226118386,
0.6330190897,
0.5584116578,
0.8910996318,
0.2011970431,
0.5992266536,
0.3831685781,
0.325122714,
0.1071881577,
0.2023127675,
-0.1666952521,
-0.3729354739,
0.128638044,
-0.6918743253,
-0.4007030427,
0.3271430433,
-0.5058817267,
-0.1124626398,
-0.8870088458,
0.0799679533,
0.1272498518,
-0.2242501974,
-0.3067184389,
0.225430727,
0.1952990294,
0.9923799634,
-1.2131954432,
0.6446909308,
0.4945613742,
-0.7998517156,
-0.2175153494,
0.4203641713,
0.278432399,
-0.9201880097,
0.702686727,
0.6598502398,
-0.024520535,
-0.1302835047,
-0.0424541607,
-0.4537977576,
0.9561007619,
0.4517596066,
-0.464030683,
-0.2130955011,
-0.1075112075,
0.6967363358,
0.1840034425,
0.5621724725,
0.3046064675,
0.7841853499,
0.066862382,
-0.4467805326,
0.4467977881,
-0.5316201448,
0.3056381643,
-0.188449204,
-0.8110465407,
0.4653273523,
-0.2102275342,
-0.3097767532,
0.2226094455,
0.48734954,
0.2116614133,
0.2372751981,
0.3805846572,
0.8485156298,
0.9420329332,
0.0948157832,
0.873478055,
-0.3859568536,
0.1998126805,
1.0851784945,
-0.4306758642,
0.6068760753,
0.5069507957,
-0.2879295349,
0.6511002779,
1.1770222187,
0.1230476946,
0.8307568431,
0.3703275323,
-0.3722313344,
-0.4382427335,
-0.0107654287,
-0.441031307,
-0.0707991496,
0.6117377281,
-0.5088381171,
-0.912311852,
0.0715603456,
0.1775290817,
0.1301623136,
-0.0506741256,
0.4058524072,
0.2209516615,
-0.4595292211,
0.5689091086,
0.0972400308,
0.4854699373,
-0.5985834599,
0.0562544204,
-0.1271763444,
0.1790949255,
-0.3576279283,
-0.5122566223,
0.6531608701,
-0.1714977473,
0.0892164111,
-0.5235527158,
0.605914712,
-0.425037235,
-0.303164959,
0.5120984912,
0.2952608466,
0.5556506515,
-0.1339476854,
-1.1055442095,
-0.2214849591,
-0.1047643498,
-0.1233801693,
0.5256341696,
0.381018132,
0.000150122,
0.6281905174,
1.0324956179,
0.0117540406,
0.1161041558,
-0.1954160482,
0.5454332232,
-0.4024421871,
-0.7188552618,
-0.9490879774,
0.3633208275,
0.0505730212,
-0.1920883954,
0.7581985593,
0.5509476662,
0.3305009305,
0.2197538167,
0.8420000076,
0.1779428124,
0.0701974779,
-0.5314434767,
1.0379834175,
-0.7850289345,
0.2530961037,
-0.0634234026,
-0.7883523703,
-0.2486370951,
0.7055570483,
-0.2270643711,
0.1138086244,
1.0256048441,
0.842607379,
-0.0462784022,
0.4969435632,
0.1678804904,
0.2340111285,
0.5374596715,
0.859252274,
0.6677999496,
-0.1744740307,
0.6781659722,
-0.0529124029,
-0.2921721339,
-0.3038171232,
-0.9963585734,
-0.8690881133,
-0.3377578259,
-0.4937032461,
-0.3779558539,
0.3447055221,
0.421366334,
0.6754550338,
-0.6481898427,
0.330640316,
-0.673117578,
0.1380969137,
-0.5084323883,
-0.2140414864,
0.1818555892,
-0.3454273343,
-0.7768486738,
0.6317449808,
0.5072291493,
-0.4703657925,
-0.4703857303,
-0.1101092696,
-0.3664364815,
0.0201688651,
0.1632288545,
0.6410563588,
-0.7316527963,
-0.3625591695,
-0.5560095906,
-0.0253387038,
0.1385712475,
0.3059402704,
-0.544670403,
0.4208310544,
0.4346469343,
0.684907198,
0.3657448292,
-0.257542789,
0.4874486029,
-0.2282163352,
-0.0099532399,
0.1430437863,
0.3373385668,
0.1805211455,
-0.5994113088,
0.4316931665,
0.0932424292,
-0.2090693265,
-0.6797103286,
0.1179123297,
-0.7211754918,
-0.5195251107,
1.3559963703,
-0.5728051066,
-0.2899754047,
-0.4737837613,
-0.0268351361,
0.1767022312,
-0.1698556691,
0.7599378228,
0.7891092896,
0.1334448606,
-0.0132724866,
-0.8917464018,
0.0379795954,
0.3241878152,
-1.2965275049,
0.1827223599,
0.5046413541,
0.7968603969,
0.2599603832,
0.902384758,
-0.3918013275,
0.3122141659,
-0.0502961911,
-0.3064169884,
-0.1877667308,
-0.2976169288,
-0.1298204213,
0.3509820104,
-0.5584802628,
-0.3002654612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00810v1
|
Bootstrapping Cognitive Agents with a Large Language Model
| 2024-02-25T01:40:30 | 2024-02-25T01:40:30 |
Feiyu Zhu, Reid Simmons
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models contain noisy general knowledge of the world, yet are
hard to train or fine-tune. On the other hand cognitive architectures have
excellent interpretability and are flexible to update but require a lot of
manual work to instantiate. In this work, we combine the best of both worlds:
bootstrapping a cognitive-based model with the noisy knowledge encoded in large
language models. Through an embodied agent doing kitchen tasks, we show that
our proposed framework yields better efficiency compared to an agent based
entirely on large language models. Our experiments indicate that large language
models are a good source of information for cognitive architectures, and the
cognitive architecture in turn can verify and update the knowledge of large
language models to a specific domain.
|
[
-0.075139381,
-0.6490627527,
0.8782356381,
0.1730793566,
0.1112431884,
0.1860168576,
-0.7737688422,
-1.0342736244,
0.1359253079,
0.4794596434,
-0.3371841609,
-0.1915967613,
-0.6143426895,
-0.4690806568,
-0.3851127028,
0.6531676054,
0.2178141922,
0.1567465514,
-0.3151021898,
0.0369630307,
-0.480701834,
-0.3966237307,
-0.8565272093,
-0.732919693,
0.300155133,
0.1274936497,
1.0885921717,
0.4459098279,
0.0815629959,
0.510265708,
0.1862287819,
0.1410102993,
-0.2277930081,
0.3931401372,
-0.4833617508,
-0.5060192943,
-0.3755201399,
-0.0804927945,
0.2465381324,
0.7212796807,
-0.213534385,
0.2161244303,
0.1041796207,
0.4947183728,
-0.7538630962,
1.0096765757,
-0.5999776721,
-0.309155196,
0.202072069,
0.0060928199,
-0.6273448467,
-0.1781736016,
-0.1299462914,
-0.9490936995,
-0.1579878181,
-0.0939966366,
0.681389451,
0.3837660551,
-0.2575953603,
-0.4359948933,
-1.064134717,
0.8921652436,
-0.426589787,
0.2999369502,
0.7237228155,
0.4981519878,
-0.0921341181,
-0.7435743213,
-0.4453433156,
-0.4676223397,
-0.0940140784,
-0.0501470044,
-0.1812514365,
-0.0995316654,
0.0164804794,
0.1172219515,
-0.104447253,
0.2477154732,
-0.1867125183,
-0.2717016339,
0.6251331568,
0.1458946019,
0.4889147282,
0.3117822707,
-0.2141580284,
-0.4267970622,
-0.1921048313,
-0.1242817268,
0.109270446,
0.2782561779,
-0.0489686877,
0.297575891,
-0.2600878179,
0.7157242894,
-0.0489581898,
0.0279635899,
0.1870927364,
0.0203522798,
-0.1799219549,
-0.072266534,
0.5274505615,
0.4034969211,
0.6647800803,
-0.5616070032,
-0.5936102271,
0.3391177952,
0.6456971765,
-0.6408399343,
-0.1802650839,
0.3868130445,
-0.2226905376,
-0.3660189807,
-0.1920927763,
-0.5059345365,
-0.416787833,
-0.5574484468,
0.4716567099,
-0.6217166781,
-0.4384850264,
0.3047275245,
-0.1738712043,
0.5290813446,
0.6550920606,
-1.1170822382,
0.6776533723,
0.9012722373,
0.581517756,
0.1137375906,
-0.2324396223,
-0.5111524463,
0.2220397443,
-0.7763245702,
0.7437342405,
-0.6276346445,
0.0991189778,
0.1547475904,
0.0854108185,
0.0151797701,
-0.5646001101,
-0.0200524367,
-0.9618080258,
-0.0327124782,
-0.4463038743,
-0.4031147659,
-0.2024229318,
0.341568321,
-0.7383068204,
0.977802515,
0.3881179094,
-0.1958083808,
0.3701241314,
-0.6677953005,
-0.5965330601,
0.2785646617,
-0.245110184,
0.0618769377,
0.0299341716,
0.1778939366,
0.7376580834,
-0.71560359,
0.33907184,
0.0114333052,
-0.3583356142,
0.4682306349,
-0.0489161238,
0.9167888165,
0.4205991924,
-0.5140317082,
-0.0069326409,
-0.7706997991,
0.0604160167,
0.2932799757,
-0.4546649158,
-0.4765678942,
0.1259237379,
0.1942115277,
0.065593645,
0.3207814097,
-0.35467574,
0.1215393469,
-0.1069403812,
0.4940525889,
0.862981081,
-0.1635359526,
0.7386422753,
-0.7023561597,
0.4145807326,
-0.0908707306,
-0.0393751711,
0.0286520552,
-0.4180008173,
-0.6038486958,
-0.6218624711,
0.3316072822,
0.2977903783,
-1.0274091959,
0.2639722824,
-0.3061785996,
-0.4718870819,
-0.4157378674,
0.0787483677,
0.2982206643,
-0.0312087629,
0.2872757614,
-0.3844770789,
-0.1649199575,
-0.6382668614,
-0.1658181101,
-0.258888185,
-0.2360890508,
0.0683433041,
0.430950731,
-0.0447252318,
0.5558776855,
-0.4287557602,
-0.0604263619,
-0.2163111567,
0.0809364691,
-0.1860600859,
0.7445822954,
0.5811840296,
-0.5920723677,
-0.2146835625,
0.2092069238,
-0.9144932032,
0.1430380791,
-0.3516205549,
-0.3288811445,
-0.0599010214,
0.7312455177,
-1.0189324617,
0.115941979,
0.221777752,
-0.2359580547,
0.5017212629,
-0.252194941,
0.0835078284,
-1.0135065317,
-0.0385211036,
-0.2338232249,
-0.3385228217,
-0.5457394123,
0.5844712257,
0.0996578634,
0.1467717886,
-0.2260373682,
0.5263656974,
-0.9005938172,
-0.1139886603,
-0.3548920453,
-0.0536718145,
-0.1316735297,
0.7685604692,
0.1930600256,
0.5326179862,
0.7609217167,
-0.8475354314,
0.5200936198,
-0.0760910511,
-0.7663258314,
0.4517484605,
-0.4046243727,
0.1205747426,
-0.1276752353,
0.345795095,
-0.9060873389,
-0.4818823636,
0.189152047,
-0.2633712292,
0.5292705894,
0.1221615374,
-0.7218378782,
-0.1119269878,
-0.1249748319,
0.46017766,
0.7110726237,
-0.6101868749,
0.8967162371,
0.3371317983,
0.1805609465,
-0.476390779,
-0.888882041,
0.0657346174,
0.1607459038,
-0.4304265976,
0.1444798261,
0.0339556597,
-0.6254891753,
0.0355391428,
0.0160964616,
-0.207666859,
0.1803497821,
0.3647072315,
0.1048063189,
-0.4691116214,
0.5343369842,
-0.3426049352,
-0.1408239454,
0.2801668048,
-0.6721915603,
0.7157878876,
-0.0496492982,
-0.3329124749,
-0.262499541,
0.1198245883,
1.0443900824,
-0.2810343504,
0.9846467376,
0.4064292312,
-0.5529954433,
-0.4030659497,
-0.8512082696,
-0.2388463318,
-0.4892631173,
0.348791182,
-0.3110340536,
-0.3977199495,
0.5131697059,
-0.1846476346,
0.1870674491,
0.2309138179,
0.599529624,
0.1186200157,
0.4726689458,
0.6314408183,
-0.1337205917,
0.5021021366,
-0.2487030476,
-0.1629820168,
-0.6378704906,
-0.3794092238,
-0.675903976,
-0.4146269262,
-0.2734162509,
-0.8533353209,
-0.1391320825,
-0.5875840187,
-0.4379636645,
0.3899199665,
-0.4811063409,
0.4536632001,
0.6284810305,
0.2555092573,
0.388120681,
0.0194755737,
-0.0999295413,
0.4144264758,
-0.6405035853,
-0.5583136082,
0.9662374854,
0.1143459827,
0.863442719,
0.1099910736,
0.2553976178,
0.1587519646,
0.2866315246,
-0.885230124,
0.7180039883,
0.3365784287,
-0.8218601942,
-0.3982489109,
-0.3076167405,
-1.0952197313,
0.2552806139,
-0.3761021495,
-0.8554513454,
0.279583782,
-0.0743462518,
-0.1169770658,
0.4354434907,
-0.7624396682,
0.6719516516,
-0.0935268775,
-0.4299324751,
-0.4739139378,
-0.5905575156,
0.2989424467,
-0.1710911095,
0.4957642257,
0.1118008792,
-0.321108222,
0.6358593106,
-0.5860189199,
1.038774848,
-0.1361881644,
-0.2129480839,
0.4666034877,
0.2560506463,
0.6461907029,
-0.4520082474,
-0.1669128537,
0.0609738901,
-0.0277659446,
-0.7566140294,
-0.8473796844,
0.6123279333,
-0.9241033792,
-0.4962518513,
-0.3453059494,
-0.6688625216,
-0.4143873155,
0.002075946,
0.1066524014,
0.348079741,
-0.3645581305,
0.19591479,
0.499099344,
-0.0822014138,
0.4063689411,
0.6889477372,
-0.1512710303,
0.2257331908,
0.645334065,
0.2466647923,
0.4787915349,
0.56942904,
-0.0285055116,
0.0742800236,
-0.2926109433,
-0.2624634802,
-0.0096198544,
-0.7081866264,
-0.1180682853,
-0.6167616248,
-0.2321490943,
-0.0934745371,
-0.3915242255,
-0.767142117,
-0.5516957045,
0.1177655011,
-0.1251648813,
0.2472248375,
1.0124605894,
-0.0717879087,
0.2576542795,
-0.3870600462,
0.2605094016,
0.6695905328,
0.278790921,
0.6363300085,
-0.1711493433,
-0.5414185524,
0.0540866666,
-0.11488498,
-0.8069714904,
0.0153274126,
-0.1182231456,
0.3902032971,
0.4465007186,
0.2368755639,
0.5879404545,
-0.3353051543,
0.9409245253,
0.2625195086,
-0.8516545296,
0.0510116406,
-0.2640135586,
0.5395396948,
0.2733849585,
0.1724087596,
-0.2012786567,
-0.6575961113,
-0.5889143944,
-0.8118454218,
0.7254911065,
0.2015437484,
0.3050659895,
-0.1222949922,
0.1112942249,
0.0444591977,
0.2387425452,
-0.5848730803,
0.1839444637,
-0.035751529,
-0.1573027521,
-0.2343535572,
-0.052535478,
-0.2649070024,
-0.150936231,
0.8066135645,
-0.1396549344,
0.3593118489,
-0.0879625827,
-0.3980535269,
-0.385423243,
0.2731671333,
0.0948669463,
0.5675522685,
0.1451807469,
0.35646227,
0.1567336023,
-0.5085991621,
0.2882217169,
-0.2702592909,
-0.0336933732,
-0.3674675226,
0.7723781466,
0.4432002306,
0.596917212,
-0.8358489275,
0.576728344,
0.0747836605,
-0.277291894,
-0.3381780386,
0.2617789209,
0.5039814115,
0.6391422749,
0.304810822,
0.346570462,
-0.0978399813,
-0.8959590197,
-0.0358268395,
0.537681818,
-0.1333424747,
-0.3258167803,
0.6458570957,
-0.1633522958,
-0.2119971216,
0.7937108278,
-0.1247368082,
-0.2364309728,
0.7329009771,
0.5292319059,
0.7830145955,
-0.2421750426,
0.2846459746,
0.170095399,
0.6415531635,
-0.4100278914,
-0.1086172163,
-0.4604397118,
-0.8376083374,
-0.5401393771,
-0.5393882394,
-0.3183203936,
0.1896815896,
-0.7535123229,
-0.1182512417,
-0.6040380001,
-0.0792030767,
0.1124878377,
-0.0814102888,
-1.0150822401,
0.2914412916,
0.0951842889,
0.7043589354,
-0.7140207887,
0.8289182782,
0.9736276269,
-0.3848978579,
-1.0104316473,
0.0392456129,
-0.2229680866,
-1.1158634424,
0.5387763381,
-0.0221058596,
-0.3289908469,
-0.3440836668,
-0.8984746933,
-0.8294737339,
1.2698763609,
0.6834328771,
-0.4323144257,
-0.1671854705,
-0.1021858901,
0.7435520291,
-0.4941078722,
0.1916826367,
0.3344321847,
0.5953583717,
0.259073019,
-0.7396521568,
0.603928566,
-0.2634833753,
-0.0564473309,
0.0004382964,
-0.9360815883,
0.7185804844,
-0.1601227522,
-0.1669206321,
0.1582977176,
0.7230169773,
-0.3781494796,
0.2843407989,
0.5949198008,
0.3054853082,
0.94864434,
0.1328731179,
1.0333410501,
-0.5532098413,
-0.0318265483,
1.2575441599,
-0.2437404692,
0.8690431714,
0.2358700782,
0.0501151495,
0.7178749442,
0.3288737833,
0.3180502355,
0.3266561627,
0.2107758522,
-0.1228052601,
-0.6932457089,
0.1931955814,
-0.1819640398,
0.5870094895,
0.41516307,
-0.1962148994,
-0.0451844782,
-0.0153998286,
0.1594028771,
0.1511054933,
-0.1451188624,
0.8546039462,
0.0486826114,
-1.0370219946,
0.6105012298,
-0.0073733027,
0.156291157,
-0.6847509146,
0.0457142629,
0.2018196732,
0.1741104424,
-0.0697085112,
-0.413879931,
0.1051592529,
-0.1906221658,
-0.0003888879,
-0.3283735216,
0.6819402575,
-0.2640842497,
-0.2104037851,
0.6118538976,
0.7458935976,
0.2248734534,
-0.3471319377,
-0.4058473408,
0.0655280128,
-0.4536783695,
-0.3887241185,
0.4768047035,
0.5448923111,
-0.1701434851,
0.7202088833,
0.6500800252,
-0.041063074,
-0.1971024722,
-0.2939157784,
1.0692070723,
-0.6838713288,
-0.5911040306,
-0.6794434786,
0.40875718,
-0.1028288454,
0.1556170732,
0.4162806869,
0.3524100184,
0.6570045948,
-0.2635624707,
0.6616725922,
-0.0432904512,
-0.093356967,
-0.6498606205,
0.80018121,
-0.5401868224,
0.4162458479,
-0.2755639255,
-1.0093739033,
0.0586864874,
0.7921978235,
-0.3354196548,
0.2170628905,
0.9249099493,
0.8639074564,
-0.2433811575,
0.1134484336,
0.5604669452,
0.7106107473,
-0.0028977168,
0.6585752964,
0.9079326391,
-0.1010051668,
0.1697870046,
-0.0052603469,
-0.4866727889,
-0.1515129209,
-0.6185782552,
-0.8873387575,
-0.8754919767,
-0.4354957938,
-0.4983737767,
0.1664036363,
1.0540457964,
1.1490857601,
-0.5486278534,
-0.4279441237,
0.1706463993,
0.026275333,
-0.8756763935,
-0.1844908148,
0.0883591548,
-0.639564395,
-0.6108413935,
0.4453479052,
0.0807483643,
-0.2203198373,
-0.3170070648,
-0.1207370311,
-0.1068660617,
0.7082239389,
0.7293950319,
0.1773318201,
-0.4141869247,
-0.3470573723,
-0.3617105484,
-0.3180100024,
-0.0734726042,
0.7932978868,
-0.8848523498,
0.4424053729,
0.065418832,
0.7005133033,
0.8796631098,
-0.3651847243,
0.6955759525,
-0.4184804857,
0.2925338745,
0.1346425861,
0.3537885547,
0.3497794867,
-0.5347573161,
0.56587708,
-0.039158877,
-0.5054083467,
-0.4478175938,
0.2357453406,
-1.1394435167,
-0.7180773616,
1.2233967781,
-0.0411000922,
-0.6248691082,
-0.1843134761,
-0.1464743018,
0.2731056511,
-0.419593811,
0.8438021541,
0.9194726944,
0.343629837,
0.2981340289,
-0.6504634619,
0.3803670406,
0.3882935345,
-0.6369934082,
0.1305553615,
0.5498605371,
0.4231364429,
0.3700624406,
0.8357850909,
-0.099423334,
0.2990289927,
0.4898447096,
0.2719593346,
-0.0661583543,
-0.2886629701,
0.0153487148,
0.3189840615,
0.3205785751,
-0.2993586957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16906v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16906v6
|
Debug like a Human: A Large Language Model Debugger via Verifying Runtime Execution Step-by-step
| 2024-02-25T00:56:27 | 2024-06-06T06:01:41 |
Li Zhong, Zilong Wang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are leading significant progress in code
generation. Beyond one-pass code generation, recent works further integrate
unit tests and program verifiers into LLMs to iteratively refine the generated
programs. However, these works consider the generated programs as an
indivisible entity, which falls short for LLMs in debugging the programs,
especially when the programs contain complex logic flows and data operations.
In contrast, when human developers debug programs, they typically set
breakpoints and selectively examine runtime execution information. The
execution flow and the intermediate variables play a crucial role in the
debugging process, yet they are underutilized in the existing literature on
code generation. In this study, we introduce Large Language Model Debugger
(LDB), a novel debugging framework that enables LLMs to refine their generated
programs with the runtime execution information. Specifically, LDB segments the
programs into basic blocks and tracks the values of intermediate variables
after each block throughout the runtime execution. This allows LLMs to
concentrate on simpler code units within the overall execution flow, verify
their correctness against the task description block by block, and efficiently
pinpoint any potential errors. Experiments demonstrate that LDB consistently
enhances the baseline performance by up to 9.8% across the HumanEval, MBPP, and
TransCoder benchmarks, archiving new state-of-the-art performance in code
debugging for various LLM selections.
|
[
-0.2601273656,
-1.0403697491,
0.5217248797,
0.1255465597,
-0.2358665764,
0.3180812597,
-0.2415620685,
-0.4606126249,
-0.2358396351,
0.8029132485,
-0.3610999286,
-0.6296647787,
-0.3304620683,
-0.0205838587,
-0.2861385047,
0.7466328144,
0.088031888,
-0.1930266917,
-0.0223905742,
0.1741224378,
-0.4364798665,
-0.4618133008,
-0.7049031854,
-0.4023855925,
0.2366920263,
0.2957577705,
0.6860220432,
0.6567460895,
0.3839693367,
0.3127823472,
0.0032829165,
0.082233645,
-0.4213843942,
0.0791248903,
-0.1586285979,
-0.4114839435,
-0.4517057836,
-0.321424365,
0.4042226076,
0.6223124266,
-0.0916465297,
0.3386711478,
0.0092555108,
0.669178009,
-0.4062572122,
0.0180441756,
-0.38229087,
-0.0358418599,
-0.3540413678,
-0.282579273,
-0.4990700483,
-0.4872374535,
-0.4118445218,
0.1932966262,
0.1500140131,
0.0048883827,
0.7424939871,
0.4403383136,
-0.5428057313,
-0.2045407444,
-0.7358077765,
0.6535645723,
-0.905356288,
0.4503388405,
0.0163061526,
0.127834633,
-0.3430538476,
-0.5077172518,
-0.598693192,
-0.5645751953,
0.0086923018,
-0.5595424771,
-0.0767823756,
0.0063419142,
0.5212536454,
0.4078939855,
-0.5589903593,
0.3533717394,
-0.3739241064,
-0.1496147811,
0.4199355543,
0.2812537551,
0.3715913594,
-0.2702357769,
-0.3139365315,
0.0427281111,
-0.9613432884,
0.0953881592,
0.5652316809,
0.175856486,
-0.031632062,
0.4216114283,
-0.1077016667,
0.9955869913,
-0.0025953155,
-0.0589432344,
0.1131727472,
-0.2143432349,
-0.1311427802,
0.0137791084,
0.6879733205,
0.2297288328,
0.4099587202,
-0.1205903292,
-0.2780049741,
-0.1651115716,
0.3193138838,
-1.0582687855,
-0.2317221612,
0.2885218859,
-0.4016925693,
-0.4139178991,
-0.2153900564,
-0.5878304839,
-0.5179359913,
-0.3264684379,
0.0905286148,
-0.4040777981,
-0.2640063167,
0.0413502418,
0.3784979284,
0.5451756716,
0.2467888147,
-0.7946094871,
0.0371616893,
0.7700640559,
0.611213088,
-0.0772934109,
-0.0991383791,
-0.840260148,
0.2060943842,
-0.6803176403,
0.5950610638,
-0.359295696,
-0.2500431538,
-0.2282152176,
-0.1041250303,
0.1084515899,
-0.8274283409,
0.0612444803,
-0.5019830465,
-0.4279931188,
-0.1030317843,
-0.5455032587,
0.0108838314,
0.3424898684,
-0.6885361075,
1.0206485987,
0.0795802251,
-0.6074091196,
0.1224640682,
-0.5171379447,
-0.3633639812,
0.040025223,
-0.4954357743,
-0.1749679595,
0.2705219984,
-0.0150551135,
0.5167009234,
-0.6148402095,
0.3534376621,
-0.3240737915,
-0.4929005802,
0.1996913999,
-0.1280383021,
0.924518168,
-0.0197616182,
-0.5103280544,
0.1791310757,
-0.9451983571,
0.1748681217,
0.0891802683,
-0.629824698,
-0.1521432996,
0.0169742089,
-0.26054582,
0.1971844733,
0.2406270802,
-0.5769823194,
0.2452568114,
-0.0954561755,
0.256308198,
0.9503576756,
0.0178755987,
-0.0505136251,
0.0976488963,
0.8785373569,
0.0190406721,
0.007943348,
-0.3113413155,
-0.182251811,
-0.6647155285,
-0.2498258948,
0.3134335279,
0.5745401382,
-0.5944155455,
0.6187024713,
-0.0039895913,
-0.4749052525,
-0.4454161227,
0.5135891438,
0.3926909864,
0.5911798477,
0.0334306955,
0.0821221173,
-0.3826733828,
-0.9908001423,
-0.1732720137,
-0.3716513515,
-0.1184780896,
0.1718970537,
0.4336009622,
-0.4863060117,
0.7369992733,
-0.6867328286,
0.3115096986,
-0.6012821794,
0.1409618556,
0.2228044868,
0.543266356,
0.4035123885,
-0.4372081459,
-0.229526177,
-0.0729116425,
-0.5311715603,
-0.4666402638,
-0.2427846789,
-0.239174813,
0.3629857302,
0.773221314,
-0.3440443575,
0.2691578865,
0.7566005588,
-0.7800041437,
0.8219925165,
-0.3498186469,
0.0844334811,
-0.7047890425,
0.2819612324,
-0.3674908876,
-0.4370688796,
-0.1872448772,
0.2194597721,
0.2010812461,
-0.1050979868,
-0.1739099622,
0.426179558,
-0.3229981661,
-0.1925389767,
-0.3300931454,
-0.2342672795,
0.0845085233,
0.2299384773,
-0.2134402692,
0.6220906377,
0.522416234,
-0.4473151565,
0.6945047975,
-0.3288081586,
-0.5216749907,
0.4082803428,
-0.9710222483,
0.3714599013,
-0.0853626728,
0.0983861312,
-1.0156306028,
-0.0368652381,
-0.1485626847,
-0.148037523,
0.4108836353,
-0.0824424699,
-0.9588271379,
-0.3571616113,
-0.0775429532,
-0.0271780789,
0.6380769014,
-0.6672701836,
0.3606427014,
0.0595843121,
-0.0831654444,
-0.3839345872,
-0.5358947515,
0.0408415385,
-0.1722280681,
-0.7792794108,
0.0155025106,
-0.345402658,
-0.4656476676,
-0.4009343088,
-0.1801338196,
-0.1997636706,
0.3387769163,
0.1978829056,
0.4740531147,
-0.2070970088,
0.112528868,
0.0184340943,
-0.1822578013,
0.2381652892,
0.2644341588,
0.5206705928,
-0.194329828,
-0.4211153984,
-0.1844750792,
0.2199429572,
0.585809052,
-0.3168995678,
0.6326307654,
0.7214798927,
-0.1485454142,
-0.4525928795,
-0.5123960376,
-0.2113769948,
-0.463380754,
0.2937568426,
-0.4821583927,
-0.7890478969,
0.5784207582,
-0.2888874412,
0.0464606844,
0.0558097735,
0.4802209139,
0.3859338164,
0.8173249364,
0.7238675952,
0.0842160806,
0.1528396159,
-0.0759351254,
0.3093291819,
-0.8235225677,
-0.0837967172,
-0.5300832391,
-0.2608433068,
-0.3643534482,
-0.7021494508,
-0.0494965054,
0.6050111055,
-0.2725110948,
0.2165677547,
-0.3171521723,
0.7039573789,
0.3458514214,
0.0077038491,
0.4458640218,
-0.5334906578,
-0.1785185337,
-0.0259567443,
-0.2746065557,
-0.6958681345,
0.9072862267,
0.4811887741,
1.0859018564,
0.2249579281,
0.9483268857,
0.2943179905,
0.2540103793,
-0.4900817871,
0.6529717445,
-0.0647588894,
-0.6364296675,
-0.132255733,
-0.4479967058,
-0.5584192276,
0.2635122538,
0.359385401,
-0.8476291299,
0.00020252,
0.4591804147,
-0.6241334081,
0.2204410136,
-0.6729446054,
1.2283791304,
-0.2950227559,
-0.4942871928,
-0.2704594135,
-0.3697768748,
0.6023977399,
-0.3106181622,
0.0818230063,
-0.1764159054,
0.0060178852,
0.3936107159,
-0.4731274247,
0.8922995925,
-0.2706118822,
-0.6413847804,
0.2619659603,
0.4767197669,
0.6993867159,
0.0471266508,
-0.0372896753,
0.114950642,
-0.1650448591,
-0.2010701001,
-0.5043724775,
0.9461730719,
-0.3047739565,
-0.5462132096,
-0.0777284577,
-0.2946008742,
-0.0460811816,
0.0899273008,
-0.1024467126,
0.5125641227,
0.0151430778,
0.3422675729,
0.7670757174,
-0.7493318319,
0.3758798838,
0.6969867349,
-0.4664818943,
0.1372261494,
0.4840524793,
-0.234685868,
0.3505571187,
0.1759317815,
0.1637258381,
-0.0617353506,
-0.4489420652,
-0.5967354178,
0.1643047631,
-0.5852018595,
-0.3220867515,
-0.4254215956,
0.0321325921,
-0.143119216,
-0.1787416935,
-0.6504091024,
-0.056980636,
-0.0339143872,
-0.1448978484,
0.170139432,
0.6000567675,
-0.0288488306,
0.1966635436,
-0.8113248944,
0.5776281953,
0.2795464098,
0.3346868455,
-0.0274033919,
-0.3551632166,
-0.2293999344,
-0.1706596166,
-0.2961130738,
-0.7748289704,
0.2422494143,
-0.0746143311,
0.2950949669,
0.3825576901,
0.0574756972,
0.7057257891,
-0.6461441517,
0.7898239493,
-0.0097026071,
-1.2299131155,
0.6490235329,
-0.2836141884,
0.3940901756,
0.1621622443,
-0.1016605273,
-0.196402967,
-0.4582596421,
-0.3665448725,
-0.9468830228,
0.6528129578,
-0.12696217,
0.064699091,
-0.2103184164,
0.2507138252,
0.1023952365,
0.1152145416,
-0.7017458677,
-0.0650391206,
0.308531642,
-0.0135428179,
0.0076126242,
-0.2565898895,
0.0186469685,
-0.1184263527,
0.3200557828,
-0.1620889306,
0.0494492948,
-0.1885495633,
-0.2382525802,
-0.2297496945,
0.3129231036,
0.5138329268,
1.0007185936,
-0.398753494,
0.2961477637,
-0.1037938222,
-0.0897287279,
0.1398372054,
-0.0712400749,
0.0550122075,
0.064243339,
0.4789028168,
0.7386747599,
0.0745396391,
-1.1759644747,
0.4136647582,
0.0655805767,
0.3214242756,
-0.3164721429,
0.3919959664,
0.3805300593,
0.5585411191,
0.2438113987,
-0.4307501614,
0.1097420454,
-0.5367614627,
0.0476989597,
0.2058276087,
0.0324985981,
-0.4004658461,
0.5932515264,
0.2906229198,
-0.1609084904,
0.7595953345,
-0.075242348,
-0.2092207521,
0.8157576919,
0.6532681584,
0.8906031847,
-0.3230004609,
0.0569261946,
0.3057685494,
0.402844131,
0.1023277491,
0.348523885,
-0.0268447418,
-0.4972334504,
-0.7967492938,
-0.8770722151,
-0.3166704774,
0.2562541962,
-0.5511716604,
0.2008875757,
-0.3614731729,
0.0389447659,
0.0277200229,
-0.1787561476,
-0.5472612977,
0.0372620486,
0.3807842433,
0.9337911606,
-0.55056566,
1.0809255838,
0.5957725048,
-0.2026601583,
-0.6757583022,
0.0482510887,
-0.1696860045,
-0.4460463524,
1.2204645872,
0.3091365397,
-0.104645744,
0.0338632427,
-0.3897057176,
-0.6422093511,
0.9466066957,
0.7724852562,
-0.7447135448,
-0.0813726112,
0.0994901955,
0.4804215729,
-0.2547058761,
0.0622266941,
0.6493184566,
0.3983782232,
-0.0393423215,
-0.754899621,
0.4015957415,
0.0206330996,
0.2535559535,
0.3883280754,
-0.4206440449,
0.9015654325,
-0.4862981737,
0.2459437549,
-0.1346373856,
0.335524857,
0.4755465388,
-0.1743884534,
0.4425674975,
0.3976190686,
0.5910981894,
0.0307078622,
1.1681008339,
-0.5272807479,
0.2283626646,
1.2313723564,
-0.3283364177,
0.8007176518,
0.4925039709,
-0.1469706893,
0.7350625992,
0.2969523668,
0.1751665771,
0.1603995413,
0.6242417693,
-0.1804468036,
-0.4469054639,
0.2942870259,
-0.2480482161,
0.6098026633,
0.2014859021,
-0.5931396484,
-0.2891081274,
-0.0746234581,
0.1534838825,
-0.2508024275,
-0.1173431948,
0.4044231474,
-0.0694170743,
-0.4964810312,
0.8769477606,
0.1911634952,
0.3975060284,
-0.6268583536,
-0.1880889833,
-0.3874025941,
0.6459744573,
-0.0720151216,
-0.6032751203,
0.5045645237,
0.3119832873,
-0.2017102391,
-0.203883782,
0.6318914294,
-0.2884634733,
-0.185251072,
0.4442655742,
0.283554852,
0.214334622,
-0.2274465412,
-0.5761133432,
0.5218376517,
0.339275986,
-0.604681313,
0.1633336544,
0.5534940362,
0.070418179,
0.7217418551,
0.5199472308,
0.1466047317,
0.2087597698,
0.0555655733,
0.7330065966,
-1.0450094938,
-0.3405691981,
-1.2019938231,
0.6657432914,
-0.0178728215,
-0.1061238348,
0.7330302596,
0.5172526836,
0.6121895313,
-0.2091795951,
0.6171527505,
-0.2863010168,
0.5265825391,
-0.4142000079,
0.4897926152,
-0.1587478369,
0.5563774109,
-0.1755990982,
-0.9377491474,
-0.127314508,
0.5806288123,
-0.0291784257,
0.0109997652,
0.4894120991,
0.8341077566,
0.0613861904,
-0.5759988427,
0.3516023755,
0.3033681214,
0.6741445661,
0.5329020023,
0.7231229544,
0.0232599489,
0.4615916014,
-0.1393023133,
-0.2899737358,
-0.1858188212,
-0.9475771189,
-0.9821148515,
0.0203132499,
-0.536020875,
-0.4481633604,
-0.0264120717,
0.6904819608,
0.6174346209,
-0.5447269082,
-0.463283658,
-0.1150548533,
0.1095376238,
0.0626333505,
-0.2810208499,
0.1627036631,
-0.3777586818,
-0.7145656347,
0.2976204157,
0.2487118542,
-0.1237364188,
-0.7115143538,
-0.2279534489,
0.0168083832,
0.1546174735,
0.6775455475,
0.1542282403,
-0.6122818589,
-0.1748955548,
-0.4191375673,
-0.2322255522,
-0.2819537818,
0.7541642785,
-0.832485497,
0.3468771279,
0.5145747066,
0.5695192218,
0.1748054326,
-0.0071532205,
0.6706556082,
-0.7597017288,
0.0702570677,
0.1174055412,
0.2804155648,
0.3244376481,
-0.3961308897,
0.5434119701,
-0.0346712396,
-0.6032811999,
-1.0424915552,
0.3781228364,
-0.676089406,
-0.3672477603,
1.0991773605,
-0.3078898489,
-0.2606700659,
0.2082490921,
-0.2411097884,
-0.014132943,
-0.2282529026,
0.7144042253,
0.6067695618,
-0.2485416234,
-0.1696876287,
-0.659894526,
0.3859531581,
-0.0422227904,
-1.0056872368,
0.4822179079,
0.7908831239,
0.4692876041,
0.0257968493,
0.5388641357,
-0.2038839608,
0.0363643542,
-0.0637353286,
0.5031240582,
-0.1454514265,
-0.1114021167,
-0.1998241246,
0.0475495607,
0.2623186409,
-0.1303973496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15938v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15938v3
|
Generalization or Memorization: Data Contamination and Trustworthy Evaluation for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T23:54:41 | 2024-05-31T17:49:03 |
Yihong Dong, Xue Jiang, Huanyu Liu, Zhi Jin, Bin Gu, Mengfei Yang, Ge Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
Recent statements about the impressive capabilities of large language models
(LLMs) are usually supported by evaluating on open-access benchmarks.
Considering the vast size and wide-ranging sources of LLMs' training data, it
could explicitly or implicitly include test data, leading to LLMs being more
susceptible to data contamination. However, due to the opacity of training
data, the black-box access of models, and the rapid growth of synthetic
training data, detecting and mitigating data contamination for LLMs faces
significant challenges. In this paper, we propose CDD, which stands for
Contamination Detection via output Distribution for LLMs. CDD necessitates only
the sampled texts to detect data contamination, by identifying the peakedness
of LLM's output distribution. To mitigate the impact of data contamination in
evaluation, we also present TED: Trustworthy Evaluation via output
Distribution, based on the correction of LLM's output distribution. To
facilitate this study, we introduce two benchmarks, i.e., DetCon and ComiEval,
for data contamination detection and contamination mitigation evaluation tasks.
Extensive experimental results show that CDD achieves the average relative
improvements of 21.8\%-30.2\% over other contamination detection approaches in
terms of Accuracy, F1 Score, and AUC metrics, and can effectively detect
implicit contamination. TED substantially mitigates performance improvements up
to 66.9\% attributed to data contamination across various contamination setups.
In real-world applications, we reveal that ChatGPT exhibits a high potential to
suffer from data contamination on HumanEval benchmark.
|
[
-0.3272666633,
-1.0452760458,
0.7038229108,
-0.1052432507,
-0.275563091,
0.0540288351,
-0.4624273181,
-0.3061701953,
-0.4975985587,
0.7389060855,
-0.2979096472,
-0.8954127431,
-0.7431504726,
-0.3309984505,
-0.6451658607,
1.0698763132,
-0.005603435,
-0.270732522,
-0.2894220948,
-0.1088940203,
-0.3808918297,
-0.7947567701,
-0.7407944798,
-0.3057001829,
0.3435553312,
0.3401996195,
0.7102071643,
0.8665644526,
0.6137362123,
0.3308016956,
-0.3272791505,
0.2946728766,
-0.6882285476,
0.3693459332,
-0.2736623585,
-0.5330102444,
-0.3725436926,
-0.1104625165,
0.6234197617,
0.4805241525,
-0.2076347917,
-0.079280965,
0.2333693802,
0.7522584796,
-0.8694280982,
0.1615923643,
-0.6577963233,
0.0078670224,
-0.2813339233,
-0.3745271564,
-0.6259070635,
-0.4486248791,
-0.1351425499,
-0.5880625248,
0.2824306786,
-0.1507173479,
0.804582119,
0.3892236054,
-0.351308763,
-0.2220425457,
-1.0955401659,
1.0628077984,
-0.5098593831,
0.3355249763,
0.5461683273,
0.4142103195,
-0.2039884478,
-0.6211025119,
-0.4548217654,
-0.1284908056,
0.155657351,
0.0958129913,
-0.2703135908,
-0.0126855541,
0.2511498332,
0.4214035571,
-0.4568298757,
0.1705276668,
-0.0944095999,
-0.3298349977,
0.551782608,
0.1175489053,
0.4739154875,
0.067815803,
-0.5735138655,
-0.4310842454,
-1.0778602362,
-0.3561245203,
0.4198511243,
0.0498473532,
-0.1815920025,
0.2391394675,
-0.1202216819,
0.3238346875,
-0.1983545125,
-0.0617531352,
0.24954243,
-0.663821578,
-0.4770588577,
-0.228354916,
0.8687574863,
0.0777562335,
0.4967780709,
-0.1563422531,
-0.2393805683,
-0.0437359922,
0.2034904361,
-0.6561836004,
-0.4042195082,
0.3104945421,
-0.2192744911,
-0.4349247813,
-0.0535548441,
-0.7058628201,
-0.5874785185,
-0.4495940506,
0.3662848175,
-0.4788965583,
-0.2887558639,
0.0771036074,
0.1099908203,
-0.3744921386,
0.5507489443,
-0.8984501958,
0.2967090607,
1.007866621,
0.583884418,
-0.3464282453,
0.0995001793,
-0.6901188493,
0.4200882614,
-0.3096189201,
0.7502149343,
-0.4928591549,
-0.4674569666,
0.1218749285,
-0.2711367011,
0.0421516486,
-1.081822753,
0.9829904437,
-0.455360949,
-0.1205591112,
-0.0185770374,
-0.7057209015,
-0.1088067517,
0.1507790983,
-0.7752588391,
1.1177047491,
-0.017014211,
-1.1319720745,
0.5984072685,
-0.2237717509,
-0.2687117159,
0.1233364195,
-0.2346268594,
-0.5578973293,
-0.1372134686,
0.1937511265,
0.4189639688,
-0.0796730965,
0.4553714693,
-0.4606172442,
-0.4696134329,
0.2671310902,
-0.8917682767,
0.7529052496,
0.3300115764,
-0.2967900336,
0.1947772056,
-0.8739684224,
0.1625727415,
-0.163646251,
-0.4730637372,
-0.5870060921,
0.0314242058,
0.1279933006,
-0.0335857347,
-0.1459988654,
-0.3501424491,
-0.1191502586,
-0.0248891022,
0.156476438,
1.0583771467,
0.2224406451,
0.2773818672,
-0.518063128,
0.4044298828,
0.3997796178,
0.3178862333,
-0.1558941454,
-0.3149667382,
-0.6760177612,
-0.6311766505,
0.3646070659,
0.4874114096,
-0.6693990827,
0.6711214781,
-0.4446185231,
-0.5086590648,
-0.220764026,
0.3495919108,
0.4436479807,
0.3539915979,
0.2064388543,
-0.1910441816,
-0.3034141958,
-0.7572187185,
-0.0695430189,
0.021911962,
-0.3644270301,
0.39828825,
0.4257555902,
-0.3017542064,
0.7787666321,
-0.4320987463,
-0.4147909582,
-0.0227703527,
-0.0096817585,
0.0264179856,
0.5960898995,
0.2043596357,
-0.6095676422,
-0.4382444918,
0.0628746599,
-0.7514346838,
-0.1357587427,
0.0127523802,
-0.1798653752,
0.1076297462,
0.6837491393,
-0.4248992503,
0.3540382981,
0.5449737906,
0.0482464395,
0.4876737297,
-0.479706943,
0.0727946907,
-0.7157197595,
0.19142133,
-0.067862466,
-0.3981373906,
-0.661038816,
0.1342684031,
0.2118358761,
0.2959958911,
-0.5343663096,
0.3248973787,
-0.1396790147,
0.0737437978,
0.0232693013,
0.5533440113,
0.0658832788,
-0.0290040448,
-0.0647329465,
0.7624386549,
0.3837676346,
-0.5563209057,
0.3266946375,
0.2147189826,
-0.6016746163,
0.4785881341,
-0.6008254886,
0.2616564035,
0.1269702762,
0.3492888808,
-1.0280529261,
0.1104961932,
0.2846762538,
-0.1854173988,
0.4316666424,
-0.0584030598,
-1.0091638565,
0.1160901487,
-0.3344984353,
0.4245957434,
0.4214635789,
-0.9475904703,
0.0032302004,
0.1561725587,
0.0554031953,
-0.6218571663,
-0.5893296003,
-0.0720463544,
-0.4532497227,
-0.770159483,
-0.0687365755,
-0.2633599937,
-0.2765678465,
-0.2117295712,
-0.2387153506,
-0.236642912,
0.3871227503,
0.3477973044,
0.1985691935,
-0.0252575818,
0.2515879869,
0.0393366106,
-0.0977261737,
0.0816034004,
0.234627381,
0.6003903747,
0.4282985926,
-0.4867530465,
-0.3548563123,
0.0426109061,
0.2916197181,
-0.0716761127,
0.5849362612,
0.4946316779,
-0.3704434335,
-0.6544581652,
-0.5260213017,
-0.0239052102,
-0.5703374743,
0.2834578156,
-0.212776497,
-0.396175921,
0.3372410536,
-0.1852981895,
-0.2075137347,
0.2037910521,
0.4775103629,
0.0024562164,
0.666234076,
0.4852222502,
-0.0302149914,
0.3506597579,
-0.1708842367,
0.1163526252,
-0.8648854494,
-0.0817203447,
-0.6150468588,
0.0767209157,
-0.5097608566,
-0.6386505961,
0.2230049074,
0.0225748643,
-0.1480319798,
0.0528654195,
-0.3671435714,
0.6171922088,
0.5523297191,
0.1208694354,
0.8742234707,
-0.065560624,
-0.4153979421,
0.030573288,
-0.2674285471,
-0.6803545356,
1.4459010363,
0.4716526866,
0.9348784089,
-0.0982043967,
1.0500069857,
0.4507766366,
0.3650968373,
-0.3679324389,
0.5031379461,
-0.2375503927,
-0.687985301,
-0.2368942052,
-0.623452127,
-0.9350176454,
0.2629927695,
0.0712881908,
-0.7313040495,
0.2145114541,
-0.1224500984,
0.0953027382,
0.3529583812,
-0.7217999697,
0.6029971242,
0.018114198,
-0.39799124,
-0.2663024366,
-0.3596884012,
0.7104325294,
-0.4593668282,
0.422850728,
-0.0791970193,
0.100422658,
0.5202559829,
-0.2578958869,
0.6494000554,
0.0284933466,
-0.5764030218,
0.0614495687,
0.1212886497,
0.5983896255,
0.0077203126,
0.131211102,
0.1792227924,
0.0146465013,
-0.0968543068,
-0.3913204074,
0.7697066069,
-0.6833863258,
-0.4398019612,
-0.4728612304,
-0.7424676418,
-0.2314980775,
0.1327816844,
0.3077124059,
0.2126668543,
-0.2435236871,
0.428594321,
0.9592523575,
-0.5575125217,
0.3694860637,
0.4095279872,
-0.140283823,
-0.2473275959,
0.8790875673,
-0.0969261229,
0.7977850437,
0.4193347096,
0.101454936,
-0.2520600259,
-0.7615454197,
-0.1999240518,
0.1791154295,
-0.9467322826,
-0.2422743738,
-0.4702939987,
-0.1716559231,
-0.0682748482,
0.2167501748,
-0.3198594749,
-0.2133607864,
-0.2349527329,
-0.2121349871,
0.0486778356,
0.6852434874,
-0.0898142233,
0.329385221,
-0.6778550148,
0.3168191314,
-0.0362335742,
0.4171124995,
-0.1209929138,
-0.3615364432,
-0.1453766823,
0.2338287681,
-0.5877530575,
-0.49497509,
0.3292047083,
0.0882582441,
0.5248917341,
0.8069292903,
0.1276201457,
0.3274662197,
-0.2715655267,
0.5032740831,
-0.0344614163,
-1.0841023922,
0.4651342034,
-0.5358244181,
-0.0530996472,
0.3970718086,
0.0861803815,
-0.5492548347,
-0.9657543302,
-0.6659819484,
-0.7398221493,
0.6399841309,
0.2504493296,
-0.0145591144,
0.0400574543,
0.1026836336,
0.1443342119,
0.1450772136,
-0.3632693589,
-0.314243257,
0.1454519629,
-0.1753489971,
-0.1455060095,
-0.3566427529,
-0.281978935,
0.1796302348,
0.6467311978,
0.2709006965,
-0.1106141955,
-0.0527726598,
-0.2996288538,
-0.0630622581,
0.4381340444,
0.4693703055,
0.6935446262,
-0.3305796385,
0.3108227253,
-0.1375367641,
-0.7742616534,
0.2602912784,
-0.2098285258,
-0.4408020675,
-0.0047606733,
0.3375073373,
0.2238100022,
0.2313125283,
-0.8165895343,
0.6053003669,
-0.0377817303,
-0.0254446231,
-0.2099861205,
0.3651478887,
0.3329724073,
-0.0865711644,
0.2706441879,
-0.0683959648,
0.2618584037,
-0.541166544,
0.6305532455,
0.3468944132,
-0.1331632584,
-0.0649135113,
0.6923232079,
0.0201017559,
0.2627317011,
0.6578401923,
-0.044975169,
-0.2855458856,
0.7997201681,
0.4046788216,
0.656494379,
-0.5249132514,
0.1778622866,
0.2033139914,
0.3302989006,
0.0448083282,
0.0778398439,
0.0870919749,
-0.8270129561,
-0.3501940966,
-0.3175877333,
-0.5056551695,
0.4658802152,
-0.813419342,
0.3187665641,
-0.5810623765,
0.0228270087,
0.1105897278,
-0.0370561741,
-0.6162715554,
0.3034076095,
0.1613298208,
0.6908850074,
-0.9566876292,
1.0130213499,
0.0503856018,
-0.2353652716,
-0.5518994927,
0.0504023768,
-0.0221241657,
-0.7893004417,
0.8404969573,
0.0301526319,
0.3445235789,
-0.4087727368,
-0.2875737846,
-0.6965841651,
0.9769726396,
0.5551152229,
-0.5620774031,
0.3559250534,
0.3292976916,
0.5536597967,
0.1136638448,
0.4085276127,
0.8456923366,
0.696429193,
-0.0806889981,
-0.8137367368,
0.3114316761,
-0.0167749003,
-0.0192112178,
0.2525524199,
-0.3885383308,
0.6236948371,
-0.1065844148,
-0.6023719907,
0.142362833,
0.0643772185,
0.3344554901,
0.3162386119,
0.4438943267,
0.6370795369,
0.8985283375,
-0.330929637,
1.0163486004,
0.0294009,
0.5893222094,
1.3161079884,
-0.3268773258,
0.785248518,
0.2833436131,
-0.4035364091,
0.0906803682,
0.4275416434,
-0.2738050222,
0.6432864666,
0.6367785335,
-0.5525180697,
0.0598715805,
-0.1770963222,
-0.337703228,
0.2621112764,
0.2574676871,
-0.4320940673,
-0.4625715613,
-0.0302507393,
0.245841831,
0.2394273281,
0.0589476004,
0.7654930353,
-0.0661593378,
-0.3726623952,
0.7939888835,
-0.1704410315,
0.4615624845,
-0.3786326647,
-0.0479387492,
-0.4628673494,
0.5404405594,
-0.3665391803,
-0.6480603218,
0.3105449677,
-0.1605388075,
0.015526602,
-0.1794714481,
0.5813906193,
-0.5278444886,
-0.1656963676,
0.5715078712,
0.4323881269,
0.1726719737,
-0.2443024516,
-0.226971209,
0.4300867319,
-0.0400411449,
-0.1055197418,
0.5387768745,
0.503265202,
0.0063347989,
0.9341384172,
0.7775462866,
0.2903262377,
0.1952311397,
0.2490161657,
0.7894733548,
-0.2883845866,
-0.2571504712,
-0.7937589288,
0.169765383,
0.0226601362,
0.1017253175,
0.7571018934,
0.7653944492,
0.8222349286,
-0.0301576965,
0.9681283832,
0.4269554615,
0.5331660509,
-0.5212036371,
0.7815388441,
0.0227140877,
0.6269363761,
-0.3162040412,
-1.029299736,
-0.2625195384,
0.2529055774,
-0.1809595078,
0.0911563262,
0.96207726,
0.6388439536,
-0.2907394171,
-0.0066155037,
0.4678175449,
0.3723379076,
0.7775297761,
0.5959229469,
0.7679256201,
-0.3457413912,
0.8099229336,
-0.4998928308,
-0.2527907789,
-0.0738191456,
-0.8702456355,
-0.7417196035,
-0.335891813,
-0.5623411536,
-0.2237060666,
0.1706051081,
0.1778711826,
0.613594532,
-0.8872461915,
0.0162323639,
-0.2843659222,
0.3438069224,
-0.3489323854,
-0.2373752892,
0.6799068451,
-0.4555630684,
-1.1032079458,
0.269498229,
-0.0474751741,
0.0010877352,
-0.1325344294,
0.2732732594,
0.1493278891,
0.005689085,
0.3856908977,
-0.0848156735,
-0.5574530959,
-0.5934910178,
-0.4172980785,
-0.2429669797,
0.1585760564,
0.4654749036,
-0.5173639059,
0.5130243301,
0.481675297,
0.5286775231,
0.4686947763,
0.2068589479,
0.5358290672,
-0.9520147443,
0.0064789834,
0.0252062883,
0.316965133,
0.4802494347,
-0.583484292,
0.7929227352,
0.0026938145,
-0.674023211,
-0.9957796931,
-0.0191731062,
-1.0927041769,
0.0434619188,
1.5510144234,
-0.5403875709,
0.0366656482,
-0.2133724689,
-0.0796859041,
0.2462076843,
-0.3739504218,
0.8446360826,
0.8979890943,
0.4158486724,
0.1302110106,
-0.9401642084,
0.4037196934,
0.2323427647,
-1.1223503351,
0.4627310634,
0.5730503201,
0.6857867837,
0.0137925176,
0.4146655202,
-0.5290350318,
0.1131688803,
-0.0789485499,
-0.0924665108,
-0.0079670176,
-0.2031734884,
-0.4160692394,
-0.031513717,
-0.1333749294,
-0.4527477324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15933v1
|
Bridging the Gap between 2D and 3D Visual Question Answering: A Fusion Approach for 3D VQA
| 2024-02-24T23:31:34 | 2024-02-24T23:31:34 |
Wentao Mo, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In 3D Visual Question Answering (3D VQA), the scarcity of fully annotated
data and limited visual content diversity hampers the generalization to novel
scenes and 3D concepts (e.g., only around 800 scenes are utilized in ScanQA and
SQA dataset). Current approaches resort supplement 3D reasoning with 2D
information. However, these methods face challenges: either they use top-down
2D views that introduce overly complex and sometimes question-irrelevant visual
clues, or they rely on globally aggregated scene/image-level representations
from 2D VLMs, losing the fine-grained vision-language correlations. To overcome
these limitations, our approach utilizes question-conditional 2D view selection
procedure, pinpointing semantically relevant 2D inputs for crucial visual
clues. We then integrate this 2D knowledge into the 3D-VQA system via a
two-branch Transformer structure. This structure, featuring a Twin-Transformer
design, compactly combines 2D and 3D modalities and captures fine-grained
correlations between modalities, allowing them mutually augmenting each other.
Integrating proposed mechanisms above, we present BridgeQA, that offers a fresh
perspective on multi-modal transformer-based architectures for 3D-VQA.
Experiments validate that BridgeQA achieves state-of-the-art on 3D-VQA datasets
and significantly outperforms existing solutions. Code is available at
$\href{https://github.com/matthewdm0816/BridgeQA}{\text{this URL}}$.
|
[
-0.7903902531,
-0.7075781822,
0.6953039765,
0.0144023672,
-0.2174177021,
0.0774514303,
0.6414521933,
-0.5589150786,
-0.0702266395,
0.5831338167,
-0.5598121285,
-0.0846822113,
-0.2998794615,
0.0097140269,
-0.2906542122,
0.3049154878,
-0.1913023144,
0.1638511568,
-0.6875506639,
-0.0455062799,
-0.5268107653,
-0.0799594373,
-0.3364768028,
-0.079857491,
0.4256128669,
0.5077315569,
0.7692146897,
0.3346284926,
0.5612560511,
0.2767556906,
-0.1552598476,
0.2447429299,
-0.3808963299,
0.0071755857,
-0.1817501038,
-0.5866989493,
-0.1573385447,
-0.2279361933,
0.4672347307,
0.7533583641,
0.22725676,
0.0233719479,
-0.110626854,
0.8803814054,
-0.6918104291,
-0.0946613327,
-0.3078974783,
0.0213764664,
-0.0426838882,
0.1308425814,
0.2501240373,
-0.2296165824,
0.3593344092,
-0.5239585042,
0.2768218517,
0.0236545876,
0.9612079263,
0.6131093502,
-0.7400168777,
0.3922023475,
-0.6528751254,
0.2570658922,
-0.1116600782,
0.5568061471,
0.1967047155,
0.9176832438,
0.3863018751,
-0.8199605942,
-0.8319666386,
0.2066327631,
-0.1893208325,
0.6439359784,
-0.2684036791,
-0.023594901,
0.1475732774,
0.6693041325,
-0.8645275235,
-0.062402647,
-0.7781230807,
-0.2604946792,
0.4582222402,
0.139947027,
0.168057248,
-0.5703302622,
-0.8547579646,
-0.4004151225,
-0.5209351182,
0.3010230362,
0.1064303964,
-0.0948772356,
-0.2503819168,
0.7506074905,
-0.3896656036,
0.6360413432,
0.1487254053,
0.4403152466,
0.1740609258,
-0.6812443137,
-0.2891333699,
-0.3506530821,
0.4875528216,
0.6872774363,
-0.1218665391,
0.0194107089,
-0.0668855458,
0.0229585394,
0.3802066743,
-0.4852256477,
-0.3913187385,
0.4637108743,
-0.2766287029,
0.1203248426,
0.2134990692,
-0.9860516787,
-0.6188669205,
-0.0879472569,
0.7831323147,
-0.0421875529,
-0.4601446688,
0.2500619292,
-0.6765692234,
0.665220201,
0.4923493266,
-0.6523469687,
0.0389584824,
0.3992241621,
0.5085673332,
-0.0267052241,
-0.0382921733,
-0.2574012578,
0.226184532,
-0.3755393326,
0.8874140978,
-0.1317750067,
-0.3530778587,
0.0372972824,
-0.0887400731,
0.0536933951,
-0.6233415008,
0.1943207383,
-0.700071156,
0.6522314548,
-0.5076335669,
0.098520413,
-0.2581245303,
0.4058707058,
-1.0728305578,
0.9276720881,
0.5893599391,
-0.7474066019,
0.0137312375,
-0.1884605289,
-0.2013981789,
0.1522741914,
-0.6065158248,
-0.222864911,
-0.0521654524,
0.561142683,
0.0121998694,
-0.4695718586,
-0.190652892,
-0.1386097819,
-0.2462864816,
-0.1627236009,
-0.2073618919,
0.6479973197,
0.0005011212,
-0.2974287868,
0.0619197115,
-0.4408115447,
-0.1753264517,
0.2552692294,
0.0916099772,
-0.2034017146,
-0.3550966084,
-0.0355207548,
0.5730971694,
0.2100661546,
-0.4512414634,
0.1506187916,
-0.5424356461,
0.0780856237,
0.346008867,
0.0100581823,
0.5711749792,
-0.3407928646,
0.5459414721,
0.3487634957,
0.2884533405,
-0.1430484354,
-0.654630661,
-0.8286523819,
-0.0587817617,
-0.0301651005,
0.8687583804,
-1.5077880621,
-0.1869661808,
-0.1496564746,
-0.2789302766,
-0.5619108677,
-0.0525393486,
0.3190326989,
0.4803040922,
0.6662217975,
-0.1987716258,
-0.6205554605,
-1.2669702768,
0.2387666851,
-0.3172900081,
-0.4726322591,
0.0976821408,
0.2906442583,
0.1623470485,
0.923258841,
-0.524020195,
-0.3343067467,
-0.4394412041,
-0.2832836807,
0.1290578991,
0.2345486134,
0.5031685233,
-1.4501839876,
-0.0505648553,
-0.0301418006,
-0.7241988778,
0.0211473778,
-0.1754758358,
-0.3052276373,
-0.122991398,
0.7156793475,
-0.6725965738,
0.5969879031,
0.5643023849,
-0.3180709183,
0.1569935828,
0.2216198444,
0.1244406179,
-1.1471465826,
-0.1096014008,
-0.1526640505,
0.1261982322,
-0.6914738417,
-0.1169723943,
0.1276340187,
0.1556498259,
-0.6438548565,
0.6961584687,
-0.3248335421,
-0.0258393511,
-0.1493798345,
0.4102674127,
0.4478670657,
0.7255213261,
0.1350537986,
0.410593152,
0.4386682212,
-0.3252655864,
0.4565953612,
0.6204344034,
-0.3049223125,
0.7393091917,
-0.8671364188,
-0.0919995606,
-0.3864498138,
0.3068943024,
-1.3408720493,
-0.2160092294,
0.353569597,
-0.4510438144,
-0.044679679,
-0.0704167858,
-0.1861233413,
-0.5960834622,
-0.2297737598,
0.7401531935,
0.2506969273,
-0.6836242676,
0.9534674287,
0.3911713958,
0.0036696729,
-0.4743881226,
-0.7560581565,
0.05347161,
0.0568364039,
-0.9432413578,
0.4456522763,
0.0908064693,
-0.3060413897,
0.0556724779,
-0.4287393391,
-0.1679427773,
-0.216965124,
0.401465565,
0.6821935177,
-0.2463709414,
-0.1562844813,
0.1916409582,
-0.2355339527,
0.1511494517,
-0.1442811638,
0.1821781844,
-0.2163950503,
-0.4211688936,
-0.1493468434,
0.7347690463,
0.7606922388,
-0.3410091698,
0.3668524623,
0.7508291006,
-0.4173260927,
0.0532638207,
-0.6406821609,
-0.0723256022,
-0.4430109859,
0.4199551344,
-0.6613713503,
-1.1330089569,
0.2009402215,
0.0150412582,
0.0496852361,
0.5155197978,
0.6145179868,
-0.3949770331,
0.9663257003,
0.6416956186,
0.3913143873,
0.1123831794,
-0.3646962941,
0.4649576545,
-0.923966527,
-0.7493576407,
-0.2273845077,
-0.3160194159,
-0.321146816,
-0.9353392124,
0.8340938687,
0.3778277636,
-0.2263675332,
0.1703641415,
-0.3111941218,
0.4645240307,
0.6933425665,
-0.0336337872,
0.2132488936,
-0.2504795492,
-0.094342865,
0.3848078549,
-0.8676986694,
-0.0120083885,
0.4764209986,
0.2472349852,
0.3871266544,
0.5289493799,
0.1353068054,
-0.1717551202,
-0.3893261254,
-0.5301579833,
0.3866964877,
0.1677565426,
-0.6059632301,
-0.3547329903,
-0.2313852459,
-0.697637856,
0.6187873483,
-0.3210708201,
-0.4707517326,
0.6062315106,
0.200257808,
-0.6506664157,
0.3984147906,
-0.5682429671,
0.852989912,
-0.1244376749,
-0.4797256291,
-0.0332238227,
-1.1354988813,
0.7661203146,
0.0750655979,
0.0679075569,
0.1023898795,
0.0199595243,
0.1594016105,
-0.233101517,
0.5245636106,
-0.01533309,
-0.1579819471,
0.2717630565,
0.0524087511,
0.0272673387,
0.437186569,
0.454074949,
0.4476200342,
0.3320229053,
-0.4865078628,
-0.8440378904,
0.3529113829,
-0.6625851989,
-0.8179014325,
-0.2915637493,
-0.5110214353,
-0.6782006621,
-0.008481429,
0.2560153604,
0.3357014656,
0.0459181443,
0.2495713979,
0.6185399294,
-0.130768463,
0.3336167037,
0.1559164524,
-0.4076777101,
-0.4958127439,
0.5106109977,
-0.4594809115,
0.3968214989,
0.7931262255,
-0.048150111,
-0.5007103086,
-0.2282510996,
-0.9437955022,
0.1496894062,
-0.5782225132,
-0.3902051747,
-0.5089521408,
-0.6403254867,
-0.3400813341,
-0.2154462785,
-0.2773665786,
-0.6332291961,
0.1644452512,
-0.2110827714,
0.0242347773,
0.49520123,
-0.195941031,
-0.0596668757,
-0.8935846686,
1.0971598625,
1.0298614502,
0.3148177266,
-0.1356763691,
-0.2487622201,
-0.1066142246,
0.1698195934,
-0.0829681084,
-0.692394495,
-0.1130955294,
-0.2386387289,
0.5752776265,
0.1164540127,
-0.0203526355,
0.646264255,
-0.3010169566,
1.0278739929,
0.3785378337,
-0.6583198905,
0.5534958243,
-0.1086314768,
0.7322118282,
0.5416270494,
0.3085468709,
-0.5312392116,
-0.1698245257,
-0.3043784201,
-0.8652297854,
0.5739305019,
0.4015715718,
-0.0822787136,
0.2772389352,
0.0324957035,
-0.055036746,
0.0125552537,
-0.1563339829,
-0.3024224937,
-0.7109937668,
0.1211072579,
0.2381999493,
-0.2393247038,
-0.4240010381,
-0.3470020592,
0.134785071,
-0.2029673308,
0.1137587503,
0.3085358143,
-0.0780968219,
-0.0547960065,
-0.1006140187,
0.2218177319,
0.6380583644,
-0.0067849685,
0.2660404146,
0.2644324005,
-0.4509052932,
-0.2406768352,
0.1650449634,
-0.0954535976,
-0.0457872115,
0.2452055961,
0.8523188829,
0.0207332112,
-0.6015896201,
0.7723610401,
-0.2812043428,
-0.6104570627,
-0.0811869502,
-0.0460739955,
0.1046991348,
0.7832816243,
0.4660423696,
0.1752208918,
0.2310890853,
-0.2769278884,
0.2793556154,
0.3314379454,
-0.4754496813,
-0.145643875,
0.77053231,
0.358848691,
0.1530792415,
0.6475270987,
0.3234096766,
-0.5133426189,
0.6201359034,
0.0425565988,
0.7784906626,
-0.2212939113,
0.3144303262,
0.546789825,
0.4531112611,
0.2520788908,
0.410427928,
-0.2294568121,
-0.6816382408,
-0.2274828851,
-0.4898648858,
-0.4299696088,
-0.0447271504,
-0.769743979,
0.1930046082,
-0.1036779955,
0.3336715996,
-0.2776267529,
-0.2895123363,
-0.7237325311,
0.3508092761,
0.7522310019,
0.9091848135,
-0.7088958621,
0.7079893351,
0.5262447596,
-0.4770154655,
-0.5100120306,
-0.0802047551,
0.3613833487,
-0.8098589778,
0.2222409546,
0.0052148132,
-0.3855944872,
-0.1750370115,
-0.3061133623,
-1.0210789442,
1.158688426,
-0.0715893805,
-0.3956950009,
-0.243443206,
0.4750107229,
0.3200499415,
0.0763042048,
0.3033543527,
0.6518207192,
0.5033126473,
0.8743909597,
-0.7798632979,
-0.1567385495,
-0.6116310358,
0.2447877973,
0.2078086883,
-0.4422824681,
0.564609468,
-0.3398730159,
-0.2863148451,
0.139594838,
0.8635500669,
0.2221062928,
0.3064963222,
0.9075746536,
0.4201084375,
0.2696684599,
-0.1884681731,
0.8050422668,
-0.1363073736,
-0.0412438922,
1.0458385944,
-0.0606308095,
0.6334617734,
0.6869366765,
-0.0597755238,
0.5042661428,
0.5975759625,
-0.007971568,
0.5106542706,
-0.0284889862,
-0.0592397526,
-0.5992200971,
0.0063907602,
-0.4597495198,
0.5356848836,
0.323867172,
0.3217383325,
-0.4678326845,
0.1125687361,
-0.4828751087,
-0.0509467125,
-0.1937004328,
0.6633239388,
0.1589153111,
-0.6098619699,
0.4671719968,
-0.4409429729,
0.099796176,
-0.5578662157,
-0.3660909534,
-0.6213306189,
-0.1711632013,
-0.1617091745,
-1.009247303,
0.2958879769,
-0.2894987166,
-0.2680012584,
-0.2623100281,
0.1817648262,
-0.5339744687,
-0.3995833695,
0.0374222398,
0.9643312693,
-0.3233882487,
-0.1929791421,
-0.4337951243,
0.0453753509,
-0.0190347563,
0.0172612052,
0.1609488428,
0.3976656795,
-0.1876785308,
0.3995709121,
0.3452174664,
-0.5049058795,
-0.0824059695,
0.1750054061,
1.146920085,
-0.4708506465,
-0.287701726,
-0.2490275651,
0.9289451241,
-0.1589701772,
-0.4894539714,
0.7825416923,
0.6316391826,
0.9978203773,
0.2063078284,
0.6805164218,
-0.1454272717,
0.420830518,
-0.6374393702,
0.3165630102,
-1.0127837658,
0.3611130118,
-0.1150972098,
-0.901712656,
-0.4698486328,
0.2524245381,
-0.1475322098,
-0.1876759827,
0.8740205765,
0.8868710995,
-0.0789750442,
0.0822580159,
0.4386359751,
0.1103712767,
0.2072669864,
0.8539845943,
1.0926147699,
-0.5054063797,
0.8346176147,
-0.4130862057,
-0.2022136003,
-0.1665520221,
-0.2087640315,
-0.7086194158,
-1.0689780712,
-0.2026164681,
-0.3093017936,
-0.187672928,
0.2292428315,
0.4189902544,
-0.5129938126,
0.0294779595,
0.1761701703,
0.2398624867,
-0.3772259057,
-0.1676767766,
0.523896575,
0.2376145869,
-0.6620374322,
0.4368421733,
0.5342134237,
0.001856012,
-0.3889405131,
0.2552778423,
-0.1434456408,
0.0514582582,
0.6539853811,
0.3248243034,
-0.7609930634,
-0.2968500257,
0.2544283867,
-0.2455579191,
0.1941868067,
0.6134915948,
-1.0830575228,
0.6981314421,
0.8260498643,
0.6713149548,
0.6315863132,
0.1790312082,
0.626857698,
-0.2891465425,
-0.1781612933,
0.3599732518,
0.2149381042,
0.2364593744,
-0.0672375634,
0.3847163916,
0.1159933433,
-0.1018926501,
-0.3211343586,
0.5457813144,
-1.4076424837,
-0.4411642253,
0.9289646745,
0.36330688,
-0.2226047069,
-0.3389796913,
-0.4780365825,
-0.0493211411,
0.3948588669,
0.7641248703,
0.1545465589,
-0.2033660561,
-0.5272223949,
-0.5657724738,
0.549469769,
0.3863168657,
-0.8188619614,
-0.2913366258,
0.7124115825,
-0.2342590988,
0.1684645414,
0.242595166,
-0.1701911688,
0.7997046113,
0.1949672103,
-0.1100337133,
-0.1444604099,
-0.5103288889,
-0.3779794872,
0.4847552776,
-0.6803703904,
-0.4692827165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15931v1
|
Frustratingly Simple Prompting-based Text Denoising
| 2024-02-24T23:23:06 | 2024-02-24T23:23:06 |
Jungyeul Park, Mengyang Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel perspective on the automated essay scoring
(AES) task, challenging the conventional view of the ASAP dataset as a static
entity. Employing simple text denoising techniques using prompting, we explore
the dynamic potential within the dataset. While acknowledging the previous
emphasis on building regression systems, our paper underscores how making minor
changes to a dataset through text denoising can enhance the final results.
|
[
-0.3820067048,
-0.9640952945,
0.6283723712,
0.2352162898,
-0.0179083291,
0.2367196679,
0.1394086182,
-0.4383184314,
0.2894774973,
0.301237613,
-0.8458381295,
-0.4308550358,
-0.4834661782,
0.6949071288,
-0.6726878285,
1.0238112211,
-0.103233166,
-0.3471126258,
-0.1321963072,
-0.0591553114,
-0.5275943279,
0.1282682568,
-1.4087445736,
-0.1408486813,
0.3830160201,
0.576633513,
0.3741801977,
0.7297924161,
0.5643373132,
0.2713675499,
0.1424145103,
-0.1269983351,
-0.1696500033,
0.5452664495,
0.3013923466,
-0.6780665517,
0.0243596509,
-0.03224032,
0.8398681283,
0.8232138157,
0.0334139355,
0.1825723946,
0.4363320768,
0.8434413671,
-0.4881377518,
0.2343396991,
-0.6195418835,
0.1903875321,
-0.050759878,
-0.0560373478,
-0.4856326282,
-0.3794060051,
0.0548946783,
-0.4440348744,
0.3820333779,
0.1938926578,
0.7762895823,
0.6553149223,
-0.5629096627,
-0.2547104657,
-0.7891972065,
0.8977085352,
-0.1261023134,
-0.0768589377,
0.2964981198,
0.0778761506,
0.0713606626,
-0.6755458117,
-0.4151987135,
-0.0570866279,
0.0749936476,
0.0622512214,
-0.3261088431,
0.4989956915,
0.4892966449,
0.3545191884,
-0.2891922891,
0.0090484181,
-0.4197874069,
-0.0404620208,
0.6416578889,
0.1863206178,
0.2842234671,
-0.3372756839,
-0.1777285039,
0.0592027344,
-0.4121742547,
0.624232769,
0.3012582064,
0.502779305,
-0.0050875032,
0.3588132858,
-0.0699851215,
0.7281415462,
0.0890938118,
0.2199540436,
0.1032866836,
0.3729552925,
-0.1831937432,
0.16345191,
0.3031799495,
0.5757011771,
0.1591692567,
0.1243865341,
-0.4858414531,
0.4264872372,
0.4666453004,
-0.3025947511,
-0.238649711,
0.2942883968,
-0.6590306163,
-0.6784629226,
-0.0126568908,
-1.0409097672,
-0.421782434,
-0.5510625243,
0.5240647197,
-0.2517691255,
0.4136271477,
-0.1379382163,
-0.3080881238,
0.1739217639,
0.5895449519,
-0.7905328274,
0.7145767808,
0.2215988487,
0.8280215859,
-0.1415172666,
-0.0747096688,
-0.4612678289,
-0.1743728966,
-0.6213883162,
1.214127779,
-0.6291897297,
-0.6849001646,
0.0428707488,
-0.0882988647,
-0.2039220631,
-0.4452822804,
0.6703098416,
-0.3431066573,
0.1653092653,
-0.6779558659,
-0.5757929087,
-0.239250645,
0.0921903774,
-0.7410152555,
1.441511631,
0.0233534928,
-0.4135818779,
0.3399363756,
-0.7958372235,
-0.3997987807,
0.2886370122,
-0.3556637168,
-0.0752828941,
0.141203478,
0.3918057084,
0.2342064232,
0.0790429041,
-0.1548307538,
-0.1371220648,
-0.5263217688,
-0.1291132271,
-1.0075552464,
0.5043957829,
0.457555443,
-0.2552021742,
-0.4563936889,
-0.9959301353,
-0.0131389135,
-0.1702489704,
-0.4438444078,
-0.5378941298,
-0.1084753498,
-0.1781284064,
-0.1436692178,
0.2794857323,
-0.504513979,
0.373123467,
-0.4349458516,
0.06885387,
1.0294698477,
0.4497061372,
0.3085002601,
-0.9016867876,
0.8623920679,
-0.4948224127,
-0.1993836313,
-0.5840009451,
-0.7974330783,
-0.4869863689,
-0.4476296902,
0.3482289612,
0.8383587003,
-0.7276639342,
0.2097136229,
0.1322575808,
-0.1823077351,
-0.6231077313,
0.0578352995,
0.2867765427,
0.8370966911,
0.4283318818,
-0.0005824006,
-0.5005555153,
-0.709274888,
-0.5340610147,
-0.2432726324,
-0.2514680326,
0.0658976436,
0.1432672888,
0.0301563963,
0.951546967,
-0.7280952334,
-0.3482347727,
-0.198213622,
0.6803359389,
0.0228732154,
0.5161577463,
0.6895499229,
-0.6652616262,
-0.699521482,
-0.7808776498,
-0.651003778,
-0.6070097089,
-0.4296764135,
0.5035803318,
0.1139591485,
0.9959014058,
-0.445740968,
0.7796110511,
0.2667590082,
-0.2721313834,
0.5916858912,
-0.1269910336,
0.6726582646,
-0.8246894479,
0.0518157035,
0.2919931412,
-0.1184708774,
-0.5472379923,
-0.0968781486,
-0.3530275226,
-0.2188070863,
-0.1265915036,
0.5642424226,
-0.2947953343,
0.3570247591,
-0.1945830584,
-0.2711752057,
0.3115445673,
0.2273297906,
-0.3775375783,
0.8868374228,
0.2940913439,
-0.7381906509,
0.2025933713,
0.6384564638,
-0.1429902613,
0.7196086645,
-0.6267616153,
-0.0421405993,
-0.7017475367,
0.159668833,
-1.5999059677,
-0.4419222772,
-0.0045181448,
-0.4180404246,
0.369830966,
-0.3022615016,
0.091465354,
-0.4279464185,
-0.8115723133,
0.2345233113,
0.6247685552,
-0.3582507074,
0.5650163293,
0.2619811594,
-0.9368925095,
-0.5133594275,
-0.6067286134,
0.3290268481,
-0.264280647,
-0.1976362616,
0.6209149361,
-0.1539514959,
-0.5661373734,
0.0166360494,
-0.1182520986,
-0.2149811238,
-0.0555673763,
0.4226054549,
0.5080541968,
-0.1589110196,
0.380931437,
0.5908421278,
-0.099885799,
0.3354137838,
0.2084188312,
0.1671588421,
0.0300267134,
-0.2473005801,
-0.9162119031,
0.6737957597,
0.4994080663,
0.3421522975,
0.5392416716,
-0.0921227038,
-0.662317574,
-0.3997580409,
-0.3345980644,
-0.3450813293,
-0.5808030963,
-0.1517491192,
-0.3865576982,
-0.5622563958,
0.6422672272,
-0.2828908265,
0.3780041337,
0.7801526189,
-0.1443496346,
-0.5692826509,
1.3416694403,
0.6990579367,
-0.090166688,
0.5520151258,
-0.2410883605,
0.1213246584,
-0.3711016178,
-0.1049902588,
-1.066434741,
-0.4772922099,
-0.408703208,
0.2593746483,
0.394685775,
-0.1392979026,
-0.0403180942,
-0.2831036747,
-0.7818396688,
0.7430871725,
0.4773178101,
0.151492998,
0.0088871252,
0.2100948691,
-0.1431379467,
-0.3948727548,
-0.4591420889,
-0.7005646229,
1.1304217577,
0.2124135345,
0.5975933075,
-0.3430165648,
0.7793566585,
1.0199893713,
0.1335906237,
-0.7107465267,
0.6521204114,
-0.2807240486,
-0.2780060768,
-0.517308414,
-0.2398933023,
-1.0181974173,
-0.3200031221,
-0.4584927857,
-0.8556133509,
0.1349503994,
0.2601586878,
-1.076592207,
0.1456473619,
-0.8872509599,
0.4498818219,
0.503246665,
-0.1982211173,
0.0436059311,
-0.5091784596,
0.0698849186,
0.0945235267,
0.5261170268,
0.0825303122,
-0.0363627188,
1.2475901842,
-0.3424212039,
0.8747116923,
-0.4252540469,
0.113520436,
0.5780228972,
0.2108590305,
0.6855547428,
-0.0269376002,
-0.2786239088,
-0.356711328,
0.1654903144,
-0.3086272776,
-0.574914515,
0.6600450277,
-0.5285178423,
-0.5289916992,
-0.537971437,
-0.2305557877,
-0.2610297203,
0.1956899464,
0.2240769565,
0.6073873639,
0.0100186281,
0.2303318679,
0.8601289988,
-0.0310594235,
0.6788498163,
0.2664529085,
-0.1259483546,
-0.1657913476,
0.7308525443,
0.3238684833,
-0.3164482415,
0.2928332984,
0.1340936273,
-0.5381249189,
-0.537170589,
-0.4121260643,
-0.0000025377,
-0.8880075812,
-0.1285497695,
-0.8605603576,
-0.1213514432,
-0.5653244257,
-0.8127183914,
-0.1477394551,
-0.6984318495,
-0.4055694938,
-0.4648475349,
0.475879401,
0.9685587287,
-0.0772906244,
0.3753244281,
-1.006084919,
0.6624593735,
0.3815323114,
0.2998095751,
-0.2598205209,
-0.6679323912,
0.1528344303,
-0.0982327312,
-0.2161886841,
-0.8264715075,
0.3886711001,
0.2226125002,
0.4088626504,
0.5540923476,
0.4857294858,
0.6244841814,
-0.4129763544,
1.1519933939,
-0.1445589811,
-0.8596465588,
0.7028450966,
-0.3294772506,
0.1873690486,
1.1752535105,
0.5135732889,
-0.5144931674,
-0.5241113901,
-0.6693591475,
-0.9630618691,
0.7192611098,
0.0595735386,
0.2400112301,
0.2088622302,
0.8651610613,
0.1355356127,
0.4576049447,
-0.5840585232,
-0.3453802168,
0.133160606,
-0.8562763929,
-0.0228738859,
-0.4264633358,
0.1184835136,
-0.5129847527,
0.6537125707,
0.0150270313,
0.411172837,
0.2994883955,
0.3276894987,
-0.3655595779,
0.0045336625,
0.3616505265,
0.0475790873,
-0.1610770524,
0.0222232826,
0.3153827786,
-0.7413005829,
0.4149005711,
0.0781397969,
-0.6205734611,
0.1128776446,
0.3511976898,
0.4460593462,
0.0182705596,
-0.4913741946,
0.3544770777,
-0.1415150911,
-0.2776811421,
-0.2982781231,
0.2788674235,
-0.6628702879,
-0.3444462121,
0.7803379893,
0.6683491468,
0.3881750107,
-0.235224545,
0.512891829,
0.2393465936,
-0.6197553277,
-0.2242566943,
0.8219596148,
0.3039223552,
-0.6233045459,
0.6183599234,
-0.1057493016,
-0.3727634251,
0.9004297853,
0.2304969728,
0.9032785296,
-0.5575768352,
0.357976824,
0.3690612912,
0.4896793962,
-0.3467530608,
0.6431232095,
-0.1553652734,
-0.5457033515,
-0.1557698846,
-0.639357686,
-0.5957853198,
0.4353202283,
-0.6862336993,
0.5658928752,
-0.7018762231,
0.0735855475,
0.2733921409,
0.0533331372,
-0.3791678846,
0.7141751647,
-0.2002549917,
0.9421405196,
-1.2174499035,
0.3667412996,
0.8295867443,
-0.0603091419,
-0.89151299,
0.2185722291,
0.4067599773,
-0.5533085465,
0.1138087362,
0.4458824694,
-0.1955887973,
0.2837758064,
-0.5699517727,
-0.6737530828,
0.5299322605,
0.1498708427,
-0.2200707942,
-0.3158877492,
0.1013685092,
0.5787536502,
-0.2175623626,
0.1449347287,
0.4734658897,
0.7209299803,
-0.1474835128,
-0.3019027412,
-0.0860561952,
-0.5862919092,
-0.3788343966,
0.0557404272,
-0.3779232204,
0.8882389069,
0.0840297341,
-0.1046276689,
-0.2580808699,
0.1505063772,
-0.2400736511,
0.8264515996,
0.7282119989,
0.4313447773,
0.8583679199,
-0.0376273878,
0.8889791965,
-0.2762028575,
-0.1088108122,
0.7114328742,
-0.3742457628,
0.5761953592,
0.5324151516,
-0.3471282125,
0.6618657112,
0.5931079388,
0.1204238683,
0.3290131688,
-0.308956176,
-0.6353079081,
-0.0173408091,
0.1010950282,
-0.0277108923,
0.6022728682,
0.5258066058,
-0.1713739485,
-0.2607594132,
0.2693715394,
-0.2454292923,
0.3510134816,
-0.3058506548,
0.8851608634,
0.0260098949,
-0.8766393065,
0.1381380111,
0.1031163931,
0.4502954483,
-0.6781364083,
-0.3639708161,
-0.1396466643,
-0.1660054177,
-0.145889461,
-0.5510562062,
0.779737711,
0.1061155498,
-0.4171096683,
-0.5468841195,
0.88758111,
-0.1393735111,
-0.4832084775,
-0.1550982445,
0.1932601184,
-0.0839662254,
0.0048919241,
-0.6753664017,
-0.1824909151,
0.1621444821,
-0.5419672132,
0.0822840706,
0.5288729668,
-0.0079009747,
0.6859802604,
0.6147142053,
0.0450596847,
-0.2661732137,
-0.3320475817,
0.4370020926,
-0.7631375194,
-0.9622707963,
-0.690005064,
0.3080874979,
-0.0928440467,
-0.3627906442,
0.7414223552,
0.5189050436,
0.401573807,
0.0337768309,
1.1370600462,
0.0938579068,
1.0620495081,
-0.4904980063,
0.7150579691,
-0.4702941477,
0.7338824272,
-0.4676371217,
-0.6349814534,
-0.4407734871,
0.5852398872,
-0.1571861953,
-0.0033726597,
0.7249330282,
0.7238693833,
0.2264579982,
0.4910835028,
0.3305051327,
0.1636632085,
0.1142834723,
0.0083870823,
0.7528961897,
-0.4914032817,
0.3228083849,
-0.2300804853,
-0.5513516068,
-0.2043428868,
-0.7700474858,
-0.5517033935,
-0.6419724226,
-0.5998675823,
-0.2716920972,
-0.0104230754,
1.1182633638,
-0.0286397524,
-0.9144281745,
0.1799206585,
-0.5638996363,
0.1771503091,
-0.4664247036,
-0.3617899418,
0.3057507277,
-0.5176407695,
-0.6753566861,
0.488147378,
0.2933908999,
0.503767848,
0.1531417966,
0.4343090653,
0.0620332733,
0.6777279973,
0.3139406741,
0.4174479544,
-0.0899587721,
-0.5288127661,
-0.1255864799,
-0.0087172436,
0.008234147,
0.6788145304,
-1.0940082073,
0.2125481069,
0.3126170635,
0.6186595559,
-0.0712110549,
0.0670510828,
0.3757084608,
-0.8551619053,
0.1724436432,
0.4250243604,
0.2064347714,
0.0902332664,
-0.7259958982,
0.0736493766,
0.5770422816,
-0.6236937046,
-1.0915669203,
-0.0040446431,
-0.727258265,
-0.4221090078,
0.7328796387,
-0.0081604384,
-0.2162239403,
-0.709046483,
-0.5343700647,
0.0282046627,
-0.6224762797,
1.4874227047,
0.7388840318,
-0.2118901014,
-0.1636338979,
-0.4649115205,
1.1031416655,
0.4861505926,
-0.7153297067,
-0.0195953865,
0.5256949663,
0.013760644,
-0.0313186646,
0.9290733933,
0.3801189363,
0.2769344151,
0.4622251093,
-0.2630763948,
0.1647245884,
-0.7213540673,
-0.7852026224,
0.530117929,
-0.037956208,
-0.2783791423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15930v1
|
Evaluating Prompting Strategies for Grammatical Error Correction Based on Language Proficiency
| 2024-02-24T23:17:56 | 2024-02-24T23:17:56 |
Min Zeng, Jiexin Kuang, Mengyang Qiu, Jayoung Song, Jungyeul Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The writing examples of English language learners may be different from those
of native speakers. Given that there is a significant differences in second
language (L2) learners' error types by their proficiency levels, this paper
attempts to reduce overcorrection by examining the interaction between LLM's
performance and L2 language proficiency. Our method focuses on zero-shot and
few-shot prompting and fine-tuning models for GEC for learners of English as a
foreign language based on the different proficiency. We investigate GEC results
and find that overcorrection happens primarily in advanced language learners'
writing (proficiency C) rather than proficiency A (a beginner level) and
proficiency B (an intermediate level). Fine-tuned LLMs, and even few-shot
prompting with writing examples of English learners, actually tend to exhibit
decreased recall measures. To make our claim concrete, we conduct a
comprehensive examination of GEC outcomes and their evaluation results based on
language proficiency.
|
[
-0.0391816162,
-1.1545790434,
0.5969830155,
-0.0393335745,
0.3547047079,
0.2050027996,
-0.4324058592,
-0.2494814396,
-0.200390622,
-0.0510385372,
-0.3718083203,
-0.7228400707,
-0.5451830029,
0.3545416594,
-0.1920648962,
0.9321115017,
-0.1640768349,
0.1372836977,
-0.4561626911,
-0.0014249017,
-0.7479391694,
-0.3938648701,
-1.0055058002,
-0.2377964556,
0.6567770243,
0.953453958,
0.2302822024,
0.1748025566,
0.2556702793,
0.3349653184,
-0.1427139789,
0.3324723542,
-0.6043634415,
-0.0853851438,
-0.2481357753,
-0.8213163018,
-0.493514061,
-0.0731748566,
0.7484610677,
0.3914010227,
-0.1799469888,
-0.0297042262,
0.3701092005,
0.7491159439,
-0.8682756424,
0.0888353214,
-0.5554270148,
-0.1158754677,
-0.2422881871,
-0.1811240911,
-0.59117347,
-0.3799608946,
-0.3060325682,
-0.4214509428,
0.4271323979,
-0.2410041243,
0.7100915909,
-0.0825930387,
-0.1961849034,
-0.4604540467,
-0.6671520472,
0.7165654898,
-0.7623325586,
0.126007542,
0.6677570343,
-0.0314803943,
-0.002947459,
-0.1974686235,
-0.6586875319,
-0.3284269273,
-0.0631333366,
0.5003592372,
-0.2929139137,
0.1597047895,
0.4256100655,
0.1304993778,
-0.5715261698,
0.3777967989,
-0.6016325951,
-0.1133782119,
0.4246545136,
0.1598435193,
0.2506768405,
0.005771474,
0.0857186019,
0.1475959271,
-0.8938527703,
0.438764751,
0.6515433192,
0.452441752,
0.015215449,
0.5160853863,
-0.1994007379,
0.7295114994,
0.0693140253,
-0.1958012134,
0.04116356,
-0.1805545688,
0.0166086704,
-0.0978524685,
0.2901754975,
0.795748353,
0.7005196214,
0.1137852743,
-0.1554799527,
0.2761301696,
-0.0100367386,
-0.3153706789,
0.0661750734,
0.0100812726,
-0.0135499807,
0.0365630202,
0.2167041153,
-0.6421968937,
-0.1373505592,
-0.2083415985,
0.6419155598,
-0.3157102466,
0.1121234894,
0.1588497013,
0.031251967,
0.0347507931,
0.2235644311,
-1.0854808092,
0.5044891834,
0.8091906309,
1.0086126328,
-0.1750543416,
-0.7710748315,
-0.543808043,
-0.01268268,
-0.3882789016,
0.7922924757,
-0.1555448025,
-0.739459753,
0.6314862967,
-0.0066804192,
-0.4324391782,
-0.5075445175,
0.3942136168,
-0.355522275,
0.28650859,
-0.4219372272,
-0.8584950566,
-0.1963549852,
0.2832284868,
-0.4416049719,
1.0354268551,
0.1706301123,
-0.3279434443,
0.5193886757,
-0.3307983875,
-0.7286643386,
-0.175365448,
-0.0236376878,
-0.2821753919,
0.1394910365,
0.1397655308,
0.5286545753,
0.1428434849,
-0.0086201373,
0.1885985434,
-0.5822975636,
0.0898240656,
-0.3137472272,
0.3952971399,
-0.1706122607,
-0.2681147754,
-0.0323502235,
-0.819439888,
0.1310949773,
-0.0093805501,
-0.6753305197,
-0.1173268631,
0.0224318635,
-0.3940512538,
0.0203286,
0.0391430445,
-0.4954960644,
0.3031010926,
-0.430485785,
0.2107335925,
0.5046408176,
0.1744655371,
0.3994945288,
-0.5595384836,
0.5998830199,
-0.3412652314,
-0.0406068228,
-0.2897701561,
-0.4542785287,
-1.1454468966,
0.2604182363,
0.0257566236,
0.9694696665,
-0.3197033107,
0.3821796775,
-0.0272108931,
-0.2009678781,
-0.5735139251,
0.6300573945,
0.8963931203,
0.5841088295,
0.4354107976,
-0.1226628125,
-0.5332646966,
-0.3997781873,
-0.3292464912,
-0.5544120073,
0.1231464744,
0.0142431278,
0.3638271987,
0.1350536048,
0.762968421,
-0.3978555501,
-0.5446197987,
-0.594538331,
0.1781993806,
0.0756193995,
0.4359592199,
0.4935595989,
0.2185064554,
-0.7508822083,
0.1178934574,
-0.3793805242,
-0.2340428978,
-0.2745676935,
0.1681699604,
0.9856268167,
0.884568572,
-0.369053632,
0.4740539193,
0.2581345737,
-0.1782663912,
0.480126828,
-0.5217075348,
0.3282308578,
-0.5767558217,
-0.0363223031,
-0.0383375734,
0.0548061319,
-0.6040658355,
-0.0314733051,
0.2100021988,
0.3122983873,
-0.2447657138,
0.3496819735,
-0.4613957107,
0.2038445473,
-0.1002459303,
0.135906741,
0.0562221557,
0.3002655506,
-0.1062519699,
0.753513813,
0.4330678284,
-0.3872307241,
0.1216233745,
0.0201954972,
-0.2850540578,
0.5698062778,
-0.595621407,
0.2884042859,
-0.4065272808,
-0.1432125121,
-1.4615386724,
-0.1292195171,
0.0256293546,
-0.6433992982,
0.6567252278,
-0.0874588341,
-0.1461043507,
-0.4221478105,
-0.4439412057,
-0.1035705134,
0.6793217063,
-0.236088872,
0.1092765406,
-0.338668108,
-0.4068861306,
-0.4314465523,
-0.8108282089,
-0.0957841799,
0.1783311367,
-0.5116730928,
0.0020801176,
0.0101199066,
-0.3173980415,
-0.2013636082,
0.2663752437,
0.3367703259,
-0.0776700079,
0.139263317,
0.2705516219,
-0.3555487096,
0.2229167223,
-0.0224804319,
-0.1419775188,
0.0129601471,
0.194317311,
0.3521947861,
-0.1518171877,
-0.5622037053,
-0.450340867,
0.3465510905,
0.2479906976,
0.0517097637,
0.6659111977,
0.1906780154,
-0.2444415092,
-0.1418625116,
-0.9191384912,
-0.1141609102,
-0.4227598608,
0.4229717851,
-0.2750428319,
-0.5462656021,
0.7651367784,
0.5026171207,
-0.0850574821,
0.2992067337,
0.4852212965,
-0.3111256063,
0.7227864861,
0.4113475382,
-0.2412032336,
0.2986297905,
-0.3040361702,
0.12158259,
-0.3500466943,
-0.3592179716,
-0.6718276143,
-0.2116592973,
-0.2017165273,
-0.3428332806,
0.1138348877,
0.3935305774,
-0.1348360628,
0.0946281478,
0.0481746346,
0.8420136571,
0.627538383,
0.0020439157,
0.4371273816,
0.158907339,
-0.19659172,
-0.4758868515,
-0.7239559889,
-0.4664185941,
0.8326488733,
0.3307626247,
0.7303661704,
0.2234491855,
0.5847299099,
0.1311625093,
0.103506811,
-1.0779528618,
0.427632302,
-0.2601498961,
-0.445011884,
-0.4208964109,
0.0098958788,
-0.8222565651,
-0.1167795882,
-0.2246528417,
-0.5992515087,
-0.0258565526,
0.404037416,
-0.6500295997,
0.2497087568,
-0.8170211315,
0.6708120108,
-0.062181402,
-0.4245912135,
-0.2259322107,
-0.4582833946,
0.1278942972,
0.2317823023,
0.0673073009,
0.1918684095,
-0.0260353684,
0.2888713181,
-0.333569169,
1.0252403021,
-0.1423782408,
-0.1632480025,
0.6723061204,
0.2595878243,
0.718631506,
-0.2566173077,
-0.1636227369,
-0.1750290543,
-0.4920774996,
-0.2767159045,
-0.64951092,
0.6865639091,
-0.6945227981,
-0.7046394944,
-0.3476161659,
-0.1247573793,
-0.353004247,
-0.2163568884,
0.7175993919,
0.3058225513,
-0.401691556,
-0.1341593564,
0.3005192876,
0.1028515473,
0.5959985256,
0.8253151774,
0.103251189,
-0.2423197478,
0.7778269649,
0.5750675201,
0.6274110079,
0.1838718206,
0.1466035992,
-0.2647277415,
-0.797585845,
-0.3871467412,
0.2329731137,
-0.8840822577,
-0.1769100279,
-0.356259346,
-0.1341102123,
-0.6654846668,
-0.5879608393,
0.0350647233,
-0.1295182109,
-0.4939455092,
-0.4654454589,
0.4250728786,
0.8201861978,
-0.237367779,
0.5435062647,
-0.7338205576,
-0.2012408674,
0.436899662,
0.0756957531,
0.2733272016,
-0.8522512317,
-0.181937322,
-0.2577827871,
-0.303027004,
-0.7666864395,
0.009003778,
0.5044819117,
0.5364015698,
0.4069103897,
-0.571816206,
0.9273198843,
-0.6656014323,
0.9077474475,
0.1832986176,
-1.1572573185,
0.7160281539,
-0.296469152,
0.3382392526,
0.6616616845,
0.2562496066,
-0.8933927417,
-0.4662460089,
-0.5252962708,
-0.6949254274,
0.6257727146,
-0.0641889721,
0.1908220798,
-0.3039742708,
0.417802006,
-0.126535356,
-0.1249734461,
-0.5352374911,
-0.0031976919,
0.220090881,
-0.1186440811,
-0.2431717962,
-0.6490672827,
0.0301091168,
-0.1791675538,
0.8902879953,
-0.1344549209,
-0.2237873822,
0.3648510575,
-0.2274698019,
-0.5184201002,
0.5486424565,
0.9722300172,
0.6055405736,
0.0942864642,
0.0488917008,
0.7258015871,
-0.3495545983,
0.1109594107,
-0.4230520129,
-0.3624296486,
0.0578528903,
0.9292749763,
0.5895627141,
0.2482794076,
-0.3287789822,
0.5498992801,
0.4994256794,
-0.2662259042,
-0.0781577229,
0.2536580861,
0.097823821,
-0.0590383112,
0.0806936771,
0.0279753376,
-0.050575126,
-0.6265485287,
0.0769539177,
0.2903563976,
-0.3326416612,
-0.3802510202,
0.2520538867,
0.3904876709,
-0.4016808867,
0.4585297108,
-0.4343261719,
-0.4200244248,
0.6801047921,
0.7261735201,
0.5013413429,
-0.5740164518,
0.4211946428,
0.7918697,
0.5188294649,
-0.2376951575,
0.5493077636,
0.2560145855,
-0.664023459,
-0.5504025817,
-0.0339182019,
-0.1895305812,
0.1310298294,
-0.8306958079,
0.4092256725,
-0.7179811597,
-0.0789206028,
-0.1322873235,
-0.0027517262,
-0.3631419241,
0.0021895957,
0.1247263774,
0.7251306772,
-1.1709651947,
0.5325579643,
0.7166814804,
-0.5038064122,
-0.812055707,
-0.1721553952,
0.4026161134,
-0.9442844391,
0.5591934323,
-0.015980117,
-0.3247972429,
-0.0685425326,
-0.2694063783,
-0.3734484315,
0.6788128614,
0.0682579279,
-0.9413172007,
0.1119753644,
0.230338946,
0.7746939659,
-0.0940016881,
0.2307773679,
0.7494080663,
0.4492917359,
0.0507495664,
-0.9183330536,
-0.1665596068,
0.0206691083,
0.0993080661,
0.0335529856,
-0.5511865616,
0.8328179121,
-0.6106870174,
-0.3251126707,
0.4272261262,
0.3974161148,
0.1475577801,
0.4110293388,
0.2542203069,
0.4640618861,
0.7919899821,
-0.0833096653,
0.6323483586,
0.1280407161,
0.4998061657,
1.1840516329,
-0.4273606837,
1.2734034061,
0.5503373146,
-0.4710128903,
0.542734623,
0.2066932172,
-0.0789807662,
0.1279289573,
0.2862207294,
-0.4608612061,
-0.0881871283,
0.1040618047,
-0.2441114336,
0.2111029327,
0.4241419733,
-0.3257383406,
-0.2860182822,
-0.0489547737,
0.3588341177,
0.7007802129,
-0.6510781646,
0.926762104,
-0.1368274987,
-1.0402492285,
0.8355167508,
0.0399134941,
0.7192037702,
-0.4377539158,
-0.0541701652,
-0.5443342924,
0.2403846979,
-0.5975391269,
-1.0741285086,
0.2319907099,
0.3198445737,
-0.4468557835,
0.1197437346,
0.7973945141,
-0.858748436,
-0.4766205847,
0.2653588355,
0.5240088701,
0.1793909371,
0.209540695,
-0.4377174675,
-0.1562738717,
-0.0005770146,
0.0569168478,
-0.1281349957,
0.1556473821,
0.0451971702,
0.2868306637,
0.4865310788,
0.3484982252,
0.0843456611,
0.6091305614,
0.1784050465,
-0.4943858683,
-0.2926455438,
-1.0161108971,
0.6638702154,
0.124043934,
-0.6401973367,
0.7561537623,
0.4706143141,
0.957418561,
-0.4714035392,
0.6828737259,
0.1051442996,
0.6260254383,
-0.8763998151,
0.3412924707,
-0.3255006671,
0.0684667602,
-0.2296067029,
-0.6248700619,
-0.4765134752,
0.6854483485,
-0.2503604293,
-0.0435797572,
0.8117440939,
1.1069167852,
0.2932188809,
-0.1956108063,
0.6441628337,
0.0875441283,
-0.108827129,
0.7771075964,
0.9329127073,
-0.4218132496,
0.4410944879,
-0.0354998372,
-0.126551196,
-0.3911816478,
-0.7107762694,
-1.0436208248,
-0.3105462193,
-0.3302560449,
-0.5640639663,
0.3726377785,
0.7155866027,
0.1322937161,
-1.0321251154,
-0.1856853515,
-0.3529059291,
0.0751263574,
-0.1456893384,
-0.1831629127,
0.1676175892,
-0.7659097314,
-0.9086492062,
0.3547867835,
0.0742608532,
0.4354208112,
-0.1685201824,
-0.2722786963,
-0.1660408527,
-0.1130185947,
0.6073740125,
0.6069085002,
-0.8547055125,
-0.3941151798,
0.232169956,
-0.3089413047,
0.1710334718,
0.9353040457,
-0.4449978471,
0.4985692799,
0.7064367533,
0.2599643469,
0.0360643789,
0.0228860267,
0.4852930009,
-1.0394524336,
0.0817880332,
0.0092944941,
0.2506131232,
0.3427204788,
-0.498965621,
0.4118561745,
0.2017099261,
-0.5911009908,
-0.4044457078,
0.0613075569,
-0.5774153471,
-0.0477874912,
1.3654466867,
-0.4240154624,
0.2192113996,
-0.0794809982,
-0.552195847,
0.1398571581,
-0.4152754247,
0.6256763339,
1.3393404484,
-0.046675913,
-0.0159162842,
-0.5610576868,
0.6959093809,
0.8834973574,
-0.6470217705,
0.0159749873,
0.546440959,
0.3438082933,
0.1689125001,
0.6237096786,
0.01593397,
0.6529669762,
-0.1225068644,
-0.0482003205,
0.0162418634,
-0.5248839855,
-0.8748092055,
-0.1448550522,
0.478393048,
-0.1652074456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15929v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15929v1
|
QuaCer-C: Quantitative Certification of Knowledge Comprehension in LLMs
| 2024-02-24T23:16:57 | 2024-02-24T23:16:57 |
Isha Chaudhary, Vedaant V. Jain, Gagandeep Singh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on
several benchmarks. However, traditional studies do not provide formal
guarantees on the performance of LLMs. In this work, we propose a novel
certification framework for LLM, QuaCer-C, wherein we formally certify the
knowledge-comprehension capabilities of popular LLMs. Our certificates are
quantitative - they consist of high-confidence, tight bounds on the probability
that the target LLM gives the correct answer on any relevant knowledge
comprehension prompt. Our certificates for the Llama, Vicuna, and Mistral LLMs
indicate that the knowledge comprehension capability improves with an increase
in the number of parameters and that the Mistral model is less performant than
the rest in this evaluation.
|
[
-0.2316800207,
-0.6410622597,
0.9524331689,
0.3252741992,
-0.1968634427,
0.3716234267,
-0.0583028197,
-0.4346624613,
-0.3333310783,
0.3135873377,
-0.0349971801,
-0.7130755782,
-0.5127304196,
0.0001534187,
-0.6122332811,
0.3720019162,
-0.0545326173,
0.3316813111,
-0.6984422803,
0.0947511941,
-0.2067712545,
-0.7565380931,
-0.7704258561,
-0.2613975704,
0.5981485248,
0.2188476026,
0.7147812247,
0.5454758406,
0.4413631558,
0.278082937,
-0.4950939715,
-0.0432753488,
-0.3426842988,
0.0240969174,
-0.077469863,
-0.9262769222,
-0.6589156985,
-0.0992014557,
0.8594563603,
0.6395077109,
-0.1488200426,
0.1592253894,
0.0524379387,
0.6478537917,
-0.9045252204,
0.0978993699,
-0.484495908,
-0.0795484632,
0.1226959005,
-0.142534256,
-0.5937875509,
-0.7238646746,
-0.0187941883,
-0.8057252765,
-0.20801346,
0.0799474344,
0.4213116169,
0.5380465388,
-0.7527863979,
-0.0669360235,
-0.8611448407,
0.6314560771,
-0.5139111876,
0.726115644,
0.4584723413,
0.6671782732,
0.0281604584,
-0.9125937819,
-0.6965036988,
-0.3656259775,
0.2348463982,
0.1738640517,
0.0348684154,
0.3460564017,
0.1300245076,
0.5841885805,
-0.5438947082,
0.0394762903,
-0.4337289631,
-0.2223047018,
0.4310352802,
0.3636279404,
0.0254414324,
0.2864813209,
-0.5800427794,
-0.0735052601,
-0.8405722976,
0.1927909553,
-0.0968669578,
-0.4377535284,
-0.177610144,
0.569681406,
-0.4451230168,
0.7386116982,
-0.1907056868,
-0.7213184834,
-0.1415869594,
-0.1087704301,
-0.2564043105,
-0.0146097904,
0.4560533464,
0.1731371433,
0.3235138059,
-0.2184590697,
-0.1510208398,
0.1458156407,
-0.2546857297,
-0.7233603001,
-0.2064892352,
0.508725822,
-0.1388944387,
-0.2353764325,
-0.0079344986,
-0.0887485966,
-0.2865308821,
-0.4400665164,
0.6332913637,
-0.3042422831,
-0.1375892013,
0.4893123806,
-0.1852742881,
0.5599325299,
0.3984921873,
-0.2826352715,
0.2512772679,
0.8369084001,
0.6501402259,
-0.1426074207,
-0.1856561899,
-0.0724377707,
0.2411097139,
-0.602142632,
0.7714639902,
-0.5867159963,
-0.2179009616,
0.1245609298,
-0.3030720055,
-0.1494967341,
-0.3405028582,
0.421921432,
-1.1618520021,
0.0539708585,
-0.3533026576,
-0.7978051305,
-0.4168967009,
0.578954041,
-0.6144807935,
1.0370562077,
0.345951736,
-0.8869819641,
0.4205728173,
-0.0823082775,
-0.1695263237,
0.2346781194,
-0.2525910437,
0.011837014,
-0.3185034096,
-0.0499784872,
0.3541447818,
-0.6604126096,
0.31725806,
-0.2986454368,
-0.6294971108,
0.921525538,
-0.4974447191,
0.6846026182,
0.2087474912,
-0.0525527038,
0.1311371028,
-0.8335445523,
0.2279617935,
-0.2000412047,
-0.5002393126,
-0.1510727406,
-0.354546845,
-0.3347475827,
0.1788496971,
0.5072194934,
-0.3199115098,
-0.1079231054,
-0.2693658769,
0.4609699547,
0.3908866048,
0.31489259,
0.5644345284,
-0.5939525366,
1.1086153984,
0.0053532571,
0.3621970117,
0.1023050025,
-0.3794365525,
-0.9253723025,
-0.6894637346,
0.666654408,
0.7351112366,
-0.9279860854,
0.2907316089,
-0.2323069274,
-0.7156403065,
-0.3829226494,
0.0858164057,
0.538358748,
0.3064963222,
0.2236305922,
0.1875977069,
-0.1164716557,
-0.571695745,
-0.213522613,
-0.4115831852,
-0.0224642456,
-0.0063619222,
0.3033157587,
-0.0777885914,
0.9396085739,
-0.4413785934,
-0.1303170025,
-0.2416829914,
-0.2379572839,
0.0544339195,
0.2072675973,
0.4265746176,
-0.5877195597,
-0.4839622676,
-0.1237763241,
-0.5902485251,
0.1209110394,
0.0955449045,
-0.1619217098,
0.0489763767,
0.8525467515,
-0.2476513982,
0.183022216,
0.7561264634,
-0.2350241393,
0.5905900598,
-0.1418796927,
0.1607926786,
-0.8143099546,
0.0636305064,
-0.252353251,
-0.4688866735,
-0.4668986797,
0.2252034098,
0.2593933046,
0.1326306164,
-0.7237882018,
0.6999984384,
-0.3620108068,
0.10178902,
0.0929785967,
0.3761662543,
0.1116821021,
0.286670655,
0.1608711183,
0.7954781055,
0.6751182079,
-1.0337728262,
0.2307900935,
0.3780381978,
-0.3785820305,
0.7832728624,
-1.0179952383,
-0.0096098287,
0.0204833541,
0.3689140081,
-0.9173918962,
-0.3236579001,
0.0412666649,
-0.5503750443,
-0.0673538819,
-0.2272426188,
-0.4356363118,
-0.2795691788,
-0.1556707472,
0.7416174412,
0.4230394661,
-0.5961568952,
0.5907213092,
0.1244926453,
0.037261188,
-0.4413006008,
-0.8566376567,
-0.187197417,
-0.2285303026,
-0.6716619134,
-0.0340726674,
-0.2890283465,
-0.3929951191,
-0.249847576,
0.0188189745,
-0.3600940108,
0.3181286752,
0.240666315,
0.1524960399,
-0.383410275,
0.1193135381,
0.3607230783,
-0.2642561793,
0.2609236836,
-0.2262268364,
0.2121294439,
-0.0860360265,
-0.6973084807,
-0.4328769445,
0.0051197507,
0.74079597,
-0.4520874619,
0.7986300588,
0.3737055361,
-0.4054444432,
-0.1020887643,
-0.7045254111,
-0.0648678765,
-0.5065768957,
0.0068881763,
-0.6543623805,
-1.4122968912,
0.5110983849,
-0.158646971,
-0.246903345,
0.2541969419,
0.3314388394,
0.0905837864,
0.9641723633,
0.2808755636,
-0.045065742,
0.1524880379,
-0.1114397123,
0.0855260938,
-0.7450227141,
-0.4666566849,
-0.6815494895,
0.1128976792,
-0.4241580963,
-0.6607211828,
0.7456424236,
0.5556907654,
-0.5370818377,
-0.1141371503,
-0.3689950705,
0.5562475324,
0.4800969958,
0.0974065959,
0.8331224918,
-0.2947747409,
-0.1744628251,
0.0572544113,
-0.8230205178,
-0.9036994576,
0.9752437472,
0.5695664287,
0.5357811451,
0.4205339849,
0.5774688721,
0.1472903341,
0.331014961,
-0.7581298351,
0.6775606275,
0.1787785143,
-0.7915841937,
-0.404614687,
-0.4027396142,
-0.8641327024,
0.3868784904,
-0.2322416604,
-0.4708503485,
0.2900512815,
0.1164984033,
-0.4423337579,
-0.0245118756,
-0.3291438818,
0.6640511751,
-0.2351530641,
0.0306348838,
-0.2149826586,
-0.3141286969,
0.7346119881,
-0.2110676169,
0.132763654,
-0.1680801362,
-0.4936826229,
0.6786782146,
-0.1711324602,
0.7079460621,
-0.1920551211,
-0.1847414672,
0.4335378408,
0.3906761408,
0.4126342833,
0.3944169879,
-0.2385460138,
-0.1859125495,
0.5356560946,
-0.4353502691,
-0.5087097883,
0.3702807426,
-0.6587170959,
-0.4889322519,
-0.4882685244,
-0.2504208088,
-0.4747162759,
0.100292787,
0.2128430009,
0.1618342549,
-0.4367631376,
0.2709558606,
1.0202124119,
-0.1736965626,
-0.0098243356,
0.7157292366,
-0.1464283168,
-0.8510222435,
0.7110161781,
-0.1728139818,
0.471914202,
0.6657957435,
0.0169810746,
-0.4851712286,
-0.8119064569,
-0.1056146994,
0.2465418279,
-0.9998683333,
-0.2753669024,
-0.6035790443,
-0.4640870988,
-0.1899890751,
-0.1338679194,
-0.0231802706,
-0.6504724622,
-0.2838509679,
-0.0917400494,
0.4447881579,
0.8118572831,
0.1835444123,
0.5243578553,
-0.7246497869,
0.2122121155,
0.5822434425,
0.1784083098,
-0.0246335845,
-0.8948449492,
-0.2444195896,
-0.0616453812,
-0.1235852316,
-0.7256204486,
-0.0014379841,
0.1148742214,
0.7014091611,
0.587951839,
0.3297385275,
0.6084150672,
0.053208217,
0.8175948858,
0.077677764,
-1.2297224998,
0.31668818,
-0.4076615274,
0.2295388132,
0.6978660822,
0.4379074574,
-0.4296667874,
-0.8035089374,
-0.5386265516,
-0.6976006627,
0.0298627876,
-0.116443865,
-0.0527799539,
-0.0511281751,
0.5982927084,
-0.2047618777,
0.1065331176,
-0.6019900441,
-0.0482840873,
0.263981998,
-0.1700488627,
0.0200335756,
-0.6338840127,
-0.1382594109,
-0.2364706844,
0.6463353038,
-0.189119935,
0.0813976601,
0.4558933973,
-0.3993666172,
0.2590654194,
0.3724556863,
0.6604724526,
0.9328861833,
0.1682562083,
0.3562568128,
0.5021054149,
-0.2821800113,
0.3320329189,
-0.2140148282,
-0.101415135,
-0.3328517079,
0.5801190138,
0.2583773434,
0.4460102916,
-0.5247647166,
0.7260785103,
-0.1306936294,
-0.5214957595,
-0.6763706803,
0.3748417199,
0.4789499938,
0.5809720159,
0.3439752162,
-0.4509583116,
0.1747452319,
-0.0591878593,
-0.0286884606,
0.1432276964,
-0.3743474185,
-0.0802611634,
0.7627593279,
0.1539331973,
0.2910797,
0.3489504158,
-0.3959638178,
-0.6815693974,
0.4045982659,
0.4929117858,
0.5556944609,
-0.2799796462,
0.1905535311,
0.5508190989,
0.2533490658,
-0.316955328,
0.6340608597,
-0.1935919821,
-0.6113775373,
-0.657111764,
-0.6819281578,
-0.8302556872,
-0.2057454437,
-0.9067541957,
-0.1458905339,
-0.6457329988,
-0.2613700926,
-0.5347162485,
-0.0586062968,
-0.5688694119,
0.3658851385,
0.020855071,
1.4296832085,
-0.7778556943,
0.9584582448,
0.570582509,
-0.3470467627,
-1.0081796646,
-0.1947348118,
-0.3238034248,
-0.7615074515,
0.464392215,
-0.3570442796,
-0.2048287094,
0.1985570788,
-0.4137867689,
-0.877143085,
1.5868400335,
0.6082979441,
-0.7644472718,
0.1887569427,
0.4322462678,
0.5497944951,
-0.10915301,
0.1132015809,
0.8243352771,
0.7209603786,
0.334050864,
-0.7909548879,
0.1659609973,
0.2283871323,
0.1613786221,
-0.2095230073,
-0.5942130089,
0.3994933069,
-0.153072536,
-0.1313806772,
0.3811208904,
0.9160435796,
0.9043592215,
0.4686258435,
0.4088579714,
0.4027555585,
1.1198271513,
-0.2113739997,
0.9511711597,
-0.5763592124,
-0.0465004891,
1.1253530979,
-0.051573813,
1.2269597054,
0.2944476902,
-0.4982491136,
0.4637864232,
0.7328655124,
0.3584287167,
0.0306690019,
0.3430372775,
-0.4958180785,
-0.6767148376,
-0.1282239109,
-0.5013804436,
0.3216328025,
0.3806227148,
-0.1446342021,
0.4704008698,
-0.3196279705,
-0.0175298899,
0.1623894274,
-0.3877470195,
0.7545459867,
0.5892897844,
-0.5091281533,
0.7013076544,
-0.0169725511,
0.3080775738,
-0.3733903766,
0.3557377756,
-0.2952673137,
0.1841025203,
-0.25596416,
-0.7369714975,
0.0530692227,
-0.2268678546,
0.1230769083,
0.2537369728,
0.5931657553,
-0.528647244,
-0.4535147846,
0.1832049191,
0.6513479352,
0.1750863343,
-0.3441026509,
-0.4293501079,
0.0360498019,
-0.2834436893,
-0.1037538275,
0.0609375462,
0.7591184378,
-0.0338787772,
1.0004872084,
0.5324909687,
0.101358518,
0.2260237187,
0.2208307385,
0.7020333409,
-0.57415241,
-0.6107904315,
-0.5109965801,
0.586067915,
0.1884629726,
-0.1571740806,
0.6927636862,
0.5909282565,
0.7334650159,
0.0450537466,
0.674636364,
0.4972320497,
0.2658834755,
-0.7076095343,
0.7138751149,
-0.3550953269,
0.3958635628,
0.0682412684,
-1.084356308,
-0.5532122254,
0.4433788955,
-0.3268248439,
0.2428249419,
0.8774861693,
0.7887286544,
0.161187008,
-0.1445372999,
0.8059849739,
0.1577874273,
0.0704018325,
0.6293019652,
1.3089505434,
-0.3247355521,
0.7284194231,
0.0263720881,
-0.2464411855,
-0.1502030492,
-0.7459428906,
-1.1158342361,
-0.5754189491,
-0.4572823346,
-0.3822648525,
0.09237203,
0.4911561906,
0.7250468731,
-0.5875948071,
-0.0509954207,
-0.0223314352,
0.2000244111,
-0.1180399805,
-0.1738182008,
0.1711898148,
-0.2171168029,
-0.287817657,
0.3479171395,
0.0648035407,
0.3021261394,
-0.4947407246,
-0.5958043933,
0.4118523896,
0.4130610526,
0.5976045728,
0.1864675581,
-0.7488334179,
0.0166273154,
-0.0261584576,
-0.3271960318,
-0.1273054481,
0.7697924972,
-0.6615675688,
0.0133052729,
0.6121150851,
0.4797851443,
0.4774653912,
-0.0506248139,
0.4613680243,
-0.3414702117,
0.0854759365,
0.3057097495,
0.3582993448,
0.2603950799,
-0.2745838761,
0.2942031026,
-0.2389331758,
-0.6947625279,
-0.720158577,
0.1991556287,
-1.2051384449,
-0.0775976107,
1.3620740175,
-0.2908902764,
-0.2291215211,
-0.4051558375,
-0.0205452628,
0.0904614851,
-0.1616623104,
0.3464121819,
0.444842726,
0.3813254535,
-0.2232512534,
-0.3356014788,
0.3707200587,
0.4049887359,
-0.723935008,
-0.0842105076,
0.3173996508,
0.4821746945,
-0.0990093797,
0.8085147738,
-0.4561729133,
0.5503085852,
-0.1068060473,
0.0415696278,
0.0155406436,
-0.4588843584,
-0.4676218629,
0.1795908064,
1.1238064766,
0.0158612002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15925v1
|
MultiContrievers: Analysis of Dense Retrieval Representations
| 2024-02-24T23:01:21 | 2024-02-24T23:01:21 |
Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Pedro Rodriguez, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Patrick Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Dense retrievers compress source documents into (possibly lossy) vector
representations, yet there is little analysis of what information is lost
versus preserved, and how it affects downstream tasks. We conduct the first
analysis of the information captured by dense retrievers compared to the
language models they are based on (e.g., BERT versus Contriever). We use 25
MultiBert checkpoints as randomized initialisations to train MultiContrievers,
a set of 25 contriever models. We test whether specific pieces of information
-- such as gender and occupation -- can be extracted from contriever vectors of
wikipedia-like documents. We measure this extractability via information
theoretic probing. We then examine the relationship of extractability to
performance and gender bias, as well as the sensitivity of these results to
many random initialisations and data shuffles. We find that (1) contriever
models have significantly increased extractability, but extractability usually
correlates poorly with benchmark performance 2) gender bias is present, but is
not caused by the contriever representations 3) there is high sensitivity to
both random initialisation and to data shuffle, suggesting that future
retrieval research should test across a wider spread of both.
|
[
-0.5328347087,
-0.5531206131,
0.368167758,
0.0262102317,
0.1102896184,
0.0484528765,
-0.2762053907,
-0.5883696675,
-0.0950026587,
0.2066339105,
-0.5909405351,
0.0025551885,
-0.9009608626,
0.0893701091,
-0.7693761587,
0.704267025,
0.2355545312,
0.3441331089,
-0.0554313213,
-0.1697037369,
-0.5710412264,
-0.756947875,
-0.5653928518,
-0.180184111,
0.6625670195,
0.5753696561,
0.5500378013,
0.2770683169,
0.4139383137,
0.3297939301,
-0.1196505278,
0.0037825485,
-0.8415983915,
0.2000788897,
-0.1443397701,
-0.4058993757,
0.5558013916,
0.3098036945,
0.7039189339,
0.61488235,
-0.3890202045,
0.2464172691,
0.2639240921,
0.6074175239,
-0.748254776,
-0.061731793,
-0.7644920349,
0.0525373705,
-0.2166866362,
-0.1377366334,
-0.5487303138,
-0.5003446341,
0.5341540575,
-0.4776679277,
0.7338910699,
0.2800136805,
0.6081069112,
-0.0285305958,
-0.4485734105,
-0.6299679279,
-0.875877738,
1.073171854,
-0.1410392672,
0.6985307932,
-0.0323469192,
0.4752273858,
-0.1291147023,
-0.6031786799,
-0.5322642922,
-0.3605640829,
-0.1949357092,
-0.0438507386,
-0.03165875,
-0.1548851877,
0.3803841472,
0.3210105896,
-0.447474122,
0.0126287043,
-0.6063315272,
-0.2445400953,
0.5212160349,
-0.1723347455,
0.3413294852,
-0.1681431383,
-0.3823197186,
-0.3269548118,
-0.3742066622,
0.0698355064,
0.58606112,
0.1808695495,
0.1499034017,
0.8125662208,
-0.0232123118,
0.2101830393,
0.0167203359,
0.1197388098,
0.1702962667,
-0.3789359927,
0.1878206134,
0.2481238097,
0.6664845347,
-0.0912386477,
0.4914537668,
-0.4290108681,
0.0953920633,
-0.3653053641,
0.3911221027,
-0.8289336562,
-0.2596308887,
0.2346528918,
-0.9072046876,
0.0499965325,
0.2440547794,
-0.6923838258,
-0.474381417,
-0.515532434,
0.1127909645,
-0.8072285056,
-0.4452545941,
-0.0041547022,
-0.8370890021,
0.3808023632,
0.2914617658,
-0.9344875813,
0.2143628001,
0.6178951263,
0.6207535863,
-0.2547198832,
-0.3106936812,
-0.4745528996,
0.0824428946,
-0.0537094288,
0.7140458226,
-0.5757565498,
-0.250654757,
0.0562588945,
-0.0432731137,
-0.1467221826,
-0.5430230498,
0.6331914067,
-0.432595253,
0.0415254571,
-0.7903926373,
-0.5482407808,
-0.1896853149,
0.2351868153,
-1.0970532894,
1.1822668314,
0.0366848148,
-1.033901453,
0.5270907283,
-0.1751537323,
0.2135567069,
-0.1607062519,
-0.5877854824,
-0.1145796627,
0.2347294986,
-0.0802892894,
0.3876319528,
-0.3986294866,
0.23526375,
-0.5343671441,
-0.4408054352,
0.397357583,
-0.488919884,
0.9351391792,
0.082510449,
-0.0669171438,
-0.461073339,
-0.7797317505,
-0.178725481,
0.0143597256,
-0.4879996777,
-0.5645183325,
0.2186295986,
0.196228832,
0.3767308593,
0.2556968331,
-0.8049225807,
0.058803279,
0.2190035731,
0.0933509022,
0.6279511452,
-0.0326173194,
0.5703201294,
-0.2245022207,
0.2707562447,
0.3674290478,
0.1005486473,
0.2900804579,
-0.2305278778,
-0.5950614214,
-0.2794536054,
0.32380566,
0.3987832963,
-0.6944402456,
-0.1627479643,
-0.1981628984,
-0.7169665098,
-0.4331583083,
0.2250690311,
0.3113493621,
0.2232123017,
0.2281322926,
-0.2954894006,
-0.6701647639,
-1.0975741148,
-0.5897396803,
-0.0119886333,
0.113882862,
0.2667833567,
0.5587577224,
-0.1509472728,
0.7638813853,
-0.4215294123,
0.0297846999,
-0.120897226,
0.4229778051,
0.1202566251,
0.7259423733,
0.5388683677,
-1.0050069094,
-0.0218248516,
-0.2220339626,
-0.8619619012,
0.4446302652,
-0.0543273203,
-0.2584524751,
-0.3806944191,
0.5955588222,
-0.9018099904,
0.1113964617,
0.2539051175,
-0.129022792,
0.8082438111,
-0.2666192949,
-0.0326371752,
-0.5667096972,
0.2999216914,
0.0507349633,
0.0856560916,
-0.4502169192,
0.0087936595,
0.1526550651,
-0.03695691,
-0.5979285836,
0.3425603807,
-0.734523654,
-0.2077839226,
0.220746547,
0.0339220501,
-0.005374711,
0.3391487002,
-0.1001421511,
0.7780640721,
0.058410082,
-0.7326450348,
-0.0012715088,
0.2983883321,
-0.3543756604,
0.5431639552,
-0.5299543142,
0.2167344242,
-0.7375915647,
0.1277061254,
-1.1438826323,
-0.0226369891,
-0.0663764551,
-0.4613423347,
0.4693542719,
-0.0540048964,
-0.6800121069,
-0.3444350064,
-0.4226169288,
0.3403242528,
-0.0118304649,
-0.4133916795,
0.6171421409,
0.395460248,
-0.0156480987,
-0.9034754634,
-0.6348657012,
-0.3963815272,
-0.2301859111,
-0.3332138956,
0.1383367926,
-0.314805299,
-0.1998582035,
-0.1553677469,
-0.069655396,
-0.3104728162,
0.1917168349,
0.1003724411,
-0.0054103122,
-0.0198097918,
0.254352957,
-0.0733500198,
0.0827489644,
0.2146221548,
-0.0692729875,
0.4970960617,
0.0991063267,
-0.089092195,
-0.0332954265,
0.694049418,
0.2161615193,
-0.2934919298,
1.0387423038,
0.9693200588,
-0.4897687733,
-0.05968339,
-0.851549387,
-0.2411137521,
-0.4505248964,
0.2990734875,
-0.3946455419,
-0.7681325674,
0.6739641428,
-0.0089345304,
0.1745217443,
0.7030007243,
0.3994401693,
-0.3608542383,
0.8390496373,
0.7676354647,
0.1173698828,
0.6960564852,
-0.5419758558,
-0.1394455582,
-0.805847764,
-0.7100081444,
-1.0228245258,
-0.4365590215,
-0.7655693889,
0.0597758256,
-0.0140220588,
0.2459810972,
-0.3547769189,
0.3483116329,
-0.6374525428,
0.4855644405,
0.7246848345,
0.1266698688,
0.1447138339,
-0.019120194,
-0.1427467167,
-0.3238673508,
-0.8849494457,
-0.3303927481,
1.1432366371,
0.1541338414,
0.7512095571,
0.2752073407,
0.6682767868,
0.2352366447,
0.3746089637,
-0.475638479,
0.1469148695,
-0.3203528225,
-0.9772866368,
-0.0755157024,
-0.5846168399,
-1.1540087461,
0.4370980859,
-0.3835125566,
-0.760533154,
0.7909516692,
-0.2626599073,
-0.2755965889,
0.0183543507,
-0.8192511201,
0.7375727892,
-0.216120854,
-0.2381696701,
-0.180049628,
-0.5599455237,
0.6623430252,
-0.0264804307,
0.2257311195,
-0.2010185421,
0.0669030696,
1.0040910244,
0.0976271033,
0.4817798138,
-0.2505089045,
0.0233998857,
0.3218349218,
0.261105001,
0.2587103546,
0.128649652,
-0.3496462405,
0.1445041895,
0.2986904979,
-0.3520510793,
-0.4677970409,
0.5529433489,
-1.00048244,
-0.2423328906,
-0.4591997862,
-0.518630147,
0.2223176509,
0.3199354112,
0.3186332881,
0.5940212011,
-0.4269298017,
0.428283453,
0.9556122422,
-0.2140650302,
0.4622919261,
0.3144964874,
0.1854101568,
-0.1254878491,
0.7177051306,
0.5428020954,
-0.0458851531,
0.4149414599,
0.0535062104,
-0.4490443766,
-0.3612606227,
-0.143553704,
0.1259025335,
-0.9261961579,
-0.0101463376,
-0.8102328181,
-0.2239523232,
-0.1133338809,
0.1974013448,
-0.3946351111,
-0.4098519683,
-0.5447075963,
0.0838058814,
0.0638235137,
0.6618563533,
0.0703343377,
0.3061714172,
-0.7640731931,
0.4224925637,
0.2982703745,
0.0747764707,
0.2098026276,
-0.2755715549,
-0.3584162295,
-0.1004390866,
-0.3657174706,
-0.9511120915,
0.1312114745,
0.116540134,
0.8463421464,
0.3500950933,
-0.1377270967,
0.5362408757,
-0.4858381152,
0.6643762589,
0.1855341494,
-0.6895085573,
0.1976318061,
-0.13276048,
0.0334870778,
0.9436641932,
0.6048529148,
-0.3482919037,
-0.3615548909,
-0.8257331252,
-0.5864834785,
0.6496506929,
0.2376296669,
0.0808740556,
-0.1506311446,
0.6705284119,
0.3582761884,
0.312412411,
-0.4573792219,
-0.2889653444,
0.0010286488,
-0.1251251996,
-0.0334710591,
-0.5923732519,
0.0048289513,
-0.128553912,
0.2398128659,
0.0742477775,
0.4465199709,
0.359649092,
-0.4585660994,
0.2172685415,
0.1067189798,
0.2723279595,
0.6974574924,
-0.4388193488,
0.3860920966,
-0.0337852277,
-0.5621266365,
0.2157546878,
0.2639253438,
0.1038545519,
0.2943035662,
0.3582799435,
0.2028255314,
0.4698037803,
-0.6610088944,
0.5106009245,
-0.5406969786,
0.0718845204,
-0.571178019,
0.0251712613,
-0.0476630144,
0.440462321,
0.6846951842,
0.1104804426,
0.5764416456,
-0.6622125506,
0.1988920718,
0.669056952,
-0.2998489141,
-0.1286139786,
0.703363359,
-0.0425543934,
0.0527578816,
0.9161521792,
-0.0860707015,
-0.2875424325,
0.6692060828,
0.1471738666,
0.673609674,
-0.0831852853,
0.0084769512,
0.6165452003,
0.5683656335,
-0.357116729,
0.3096413016,
0.0731800869,
-0.701972127,
-0.2903989255,
-0.2820164561,
-0.3121994734,
-0.1404325515,
-0.8079620004,
0.2295482159,
-0.130384773,
-0.1767615229,
0.2538691461,
0.2587121725,
-1.1840952635,
0.1309660822,
0.0608412847,
1.006685257,
-0.5696072578,
0.5890837908,
0.1432915777,
-0.6651408076,
-0.656463623,
-0.2417754531,
-0.1995486319,
-0.5259107947,
0.6473098397,
0.4900760949,
0.2301692069,
-0.0016288928,
-0.8103888631,
-1.1145033836,
1.2006243467,
0.8099820018,
-0.6330666542,
-0.2423492372,
-0.0906166509,
0.2014530152,
-0.0370123908,
0.8128088713,
0.7454422116,
0.3985622227,
-0.2155611962,
-0.5273196101,
0.0177774113,
-0.0395462178,
0.0684668422,
-0.1065407097,
-0.6784233451,
1.1629918814,
0.0541329719,
-0.3499840498,
-0.1237979382,
0.7222867608,
0.438246578,
-0.0415387414,
0.3370185792,
0.3130461574,
1.0914921761,
-0.0439948216,
1.4029773474,
-0.0552512631,
0.4484513104,
0.9780558944,
0.0738021284,
0.7590647936,
0.6578019261,
0.0647080243,
0.5119630098,
0.650097847,
0.1396832913,
0.4233069122,
0.2442314923,
0.0380158387,
-0.0217528045,
-0.0866480023,
-0.4099320173,
0.3702617288,
0.2654876113,
-0.4136269689,
-0.2707202435,
-0.1969038546,
-0.0529279485,
-0.2172502279,
-0.0443966389,
0.6069175005,
0.2243703604,
-0.7041137815,
0.5238579512,
-0.0228662994,
0.4921746552,
-0.5268253088,
-0.0395563133,
-0.1966889352,
0.1766043305,
-0.1803203225,
-0.6937142015,
0.1790985465,
-0.318708092,
-0.4400711358,
-0.0089819934,
0.9115754962,
-0.6995322108,
-0.4842098653,
0.5109597445,
0.6801348925,
0.1402176172,
-0.255802989,
-0.729916811,
0.1883505434,
-0.1609253287,
-0.2568457723,
0.172563374,
0.7449842691,
0.030377524,
0.7133002877,
0.7076045275,
-0.1084487289,
0.5464001298,
-0.0070576081,
0.8084695935,
-0.668279171,
-0.0299799908,
-0.9371679425,
0.3855183423,
-0.1754309088,
-0.2990422249,
0.9215919375,
0.8205730915,
0.665631175,
-0.0290700085,
0.6099496484,
-0.0063438718,
0.2912722826,
-0.4617012441,
0.687580049,
-0.3066471815,
-0.2384788543,
-0.3024117053,
-1.1684740782,
0.1946202368,
0.2319623381,
0.0360582545,
-0.0216667745,
0.7077730894,
0.4765872061,
-0.3995530307,
0.1115061492,
-0.127822876,
0.0300230533,
0.2965959609,
0.5377274156,
1.081140995,
-0.4565793276,
0.7161309123,
-0.0669751987,
-0.0364065915,
-0.1547022462,
-0.6380397677,
-0.7444335222,
-0.4885620177,
-0.0242809616,
-0.3261044323,
-0.177092582,
0.5013889074,
0.6965492368,
-0.5311608315,
-0.2480365634,
0.1059644297,
0.3041324317,
-0.1800419092,
-0.1968543828,
0.2121574134,
-0.3565774858,
-0.5575915575,
0.1142070517,
-0.2982724011,
-0.1123833135,
-0.4832763672,
-0.1223124787,
-0.4894630909,
0.003677961,
0.4755616784,
0.129559502,
-0.2931793928,
-0.2451446205,
-0.1896947771,
-0.1912740469,
0.0203306731,
1.0070781708,
-0.6467440724,
0.5863431096,
0.5187438726,
0.6799967289,
0.8314950466,
-0.0249883216,
0.4787605703,
-0.9689967632,
0.3363477588,
0.0773564726,
0.3916092813,
0.3857681751,
-0.3628669977,
0.4058818221,
0.1415741891,
-0.4377247691,
-0.720117867,
-0.1076281294,
-0.8097230196,
-0.2489113808,
1.0838403702,
0.1647195518,
-0.0595289953,
-0.2286900878,
-0.2494436353,
0.5055674314,
-0.5367976427,
0.6215037107,
1.0371266603,
0.1989382207,
-0.2876848876,
-1.0186511278,
0.4820738137,
0.2015206367,
-0.4991396368,
-0.1376871467,
0.3849136531,
0.3966393173,
0.3302339017,
0.6745272875,
-0.1397546083,
0.2369364798,
-0.0840563923,
0.129807815,
0.3175926208,
-0.3346506953,
-0.2699797153,
0.3493376672,
-0.0286488887,
-0.1264556199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15911v1
|
PRP: Propagating Universal Perturbations to Attack Large Language Model Guard-Rails
| 2024-02-24T21:27:13 | 2024-02-24T21:27:13 |
Neal Mangaokar, Ashish Hooda, Jihye Choi, Shreyas Chandrashekaran, Kassem Fawaz, Somesh Jha, Atul Prakash
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are typically aligned to be harmless to humans.
Unfortunately, recent work has shown that such models are susceptible to
automated jailbreak attacks that induce them to generate harmful content. More
recent LLMs often incorporate an additional layer of defense, a Guard Model,
which is a second LLM that is designed to check and moderate the output
response of the primary LLM. Our key contribution is to show a novel attack
strategy, PRP, that is successful against several open-source (e.g., Llama 2)
and closed-source (e.g., GPT 3.5) implementations of Guard Models. PRP
leverages a two step prefix-based attack that operates by (a) constructing a
universal adversarial prefix for the Guard Model, and (b) propagating this
prefix to the response. We find that this procedure is effective across
multiple threat models, including ones in which the adversary has no access to
the Guard Model at all. Our work suggests that further advances are required on
defenses and Guard Models before they can be considered effective.
|
[
-0.3137578368,
-1.1420501471,
0.4635907412,
0.3132863343,
-0.2754560709,
0.0333344303,
-0.1463237107,
-0.393737942,
0.1452201754,
0.9247049689,
-0.2653574646,
-0.370551765,
-0.7433264256,
-0.1618896276,
-0.5809859633,
0.7739495039,
0.2508823276,
-0.0408373438,
0.4298535287,
0.3366631269,
-0.5498852134,
-0.8285284042,
-0.7138763666,
-0.1620565057,
0.4955662489,
0.2779257894,
0.8645279408,
0.3792084455,
0.7239204049,
0.1972518414,
-0.2227884233,
-0.1021666974,
-0.1752704531,
0.513491869,
-0.2164161056,
-0.3559986949,
-0.5669381022,
-0.1226595342,
0.7294976711,
0.2719847858,
-0.1324466914,
-0.0522348024,
-0.1655437946,
0.5341672301,
-0.5501834154,
-0.4618185461,
-0.9743947387,
-0.1127569452,
-0.5348895788,
0.1126874983,
-0.818597436,
-0.0457721129,
-0.1374144703,
-0.2008243203,
-0.0140875168,
-0.0859342739,
0.6583327651,
-0.0238840319,
-0.3367856443,
0.0063115163,
-0.8515514135,
0.4622351825,
-0.6861192584,
0.047909569,
0.1092154682,
0.1414291859,
-0.6916509867,
-0.8317508101,
-0.5348259211,
-0.5733454823,
0.1800650954,
-0.2367542237,
-0.4918276668,
0.2145017385,
0.1970789731,
0.0773219764,
-0.502284646,
0.3205950856,
-0.2746435702,
-0.1109297201,
0.6272268891,
-0.0093622776,
0.584235549,
-0.108553201,
-0.7406928539,
-0.2734459341,
-1.1921949387,
-0.2172839195,
0.7412748337,
0.2777170837,
-0.1199299842,
0.4914658368,
0.1477419585,
0.8346695304,
-0.1412430257,
0.1265319437,
-0.3699857295,
-0.0282064453,
-0.1911563128,
-0.0751513839,
1.0147526264,
-0.0445494652,
0.3574910462,
-0.221897006,
-0.1280880719,
0.1402673572,
0.5866572261,
-0.6314682364,
-0.3770478964,
0.1591495126,
0.035650976,
-0.5120415688,
0.1770090908,
-0.8286129236,
-0.7057366967,
0.1910658926,
0.3906945288,
-0.3409848511,
-0.4056559503,
0.2321547717,
0.0382227711,
0.2946897447,
0.0942104235,
-0.8964272738,
0.5418532491,
0.9358404875,
0.8593428731,
0.1252590418,
-0.2538858652,
-0.5360130668,
0.3062392175,
-0.4743968844,
0.755323112,
-0.4840120077,
-0.7365831137,
-0.1987380385,
-0.2506579161,
0.0290183853,
-0.2576680481,
0.8154436946,
-0.8493236899,
-0.1974651515,
0.0593617335,
-0.164011538,
0.0189179853,
0.1754251122,
-0.6772172451,
0.5414383411,
-0.224884063,
-0.9284268618,
-0.2261832207,
-0.7439312339,
-0.4670606256,
-0.1527366042,
0.0468086079,
-0.1913257688,
0.2331932932,
0.1233128086,
0.2935808599,
-0.2354177237,
0.1405239254,
-0.4429673254,
-0.0185706932,
0.267694205,
-0.4479961693,
0.7446615696,
0.280335784,
-0.0590515286,
0.30427894,
-0.524798274,
-0.0132027501,
0.5615639687,
-0.0152901458,
-0.5323219895,
0.2448712438,
-0.3436672986,
0.0529926941,
0.0977422446,
-0.4794555902,
0.6414399743,
-0.3961902857,
0.4352274537,
0.9616776705,
0.3430817425,
0.3567554057,
-0.0066093262,
0.5956884623,
-0.2988840938,
0.4185599983,
-0.1766047329,
-0.5606195331,
-0.3778703213,
-0.248807624,
0.3428424001,
0.6200760007,
-0.3485583067,
0.147124812,
-0.0488383509,
-0.6299141049,
-0.3228557706,
0.2244327664,
0.4987987578,
0.2839723229,
0.362180531,
-0.6461911201,
-0.6423392296,
-0.8616697192,
-0.4795858562,
-0.4375050664,
-0.061555516,
-0.3651234508,
0.1973879188,
-0.2084760368,
0.7155908346,
-0.6243010759,
-0.0954798535,
-0.3017662466,
0.1209538728,
0.195185259,
0.5401437283,
0.5077942014,
-0.7105583549,
-0.3831994236,
-0.3123545945,
-0.3560340106,
-0.1726208627,
-0.1013943702,
-0.123520121,
-0.1240563318,
0.3526114225,
-0.6744236946,
0.1958411485,
0.608240068,
-0.5156019926,
0.886488378,
-0.1807598472,
-0.2547969818,
-0.9381502271,
-0.1407709122,
0.142547071,
-0.0877154469,
-1.1315505505,
0.6072036028,
-0.0248635914,
-0.2134378403,
-0.4316888452,
0.6449099183,
-0.2865555584,
0.1182950884,
-0.3746984005,
-0.05312033,
-0.1334410608,
0.0524809398,
0.0131039834,
0.560374856,
0.5742676258,
-0.5762862563,
0.3927292526,
0.1865681708,
-0.040282011,
0.2652153373,
-0.7962484956,
0.5504000187,
-0.0472722575,
0.4349153638,
-0.8522693515,
-0.2831166983,
0.4439359009,
-0.6538180709,
0.6282953024,
-0.5197622776,
-0.561078608,
-0.2842603624,
-0.4845648408,
0.0026087253,
0.5113092661,
-0.4370462298,
0.3204242885,
0.4601171017,
-0.2094403207,
-0.6602517962,
-0.6511697769,
0.6156610847,
-0.3574826121,
-0.7831605673,
0.2946385443,
0.0095527032,
-0.6756837964,
-0.3522534072,
-0.0812596157,
-0.0837420002,
0.6153616905,
0.2629956901,
0.2818131447,
-0.019994095,
-0.2520524263,
-0.4517402351,
-0.1215872765,
0.2846060097,
-0.2920811772,
0.8309372067,
0.0458954684,
-0.6457729936,
-0.3052181005,
0.3220563829,
0.641658783,
-0.3531036079,
0.7757415175,
0.3766658306,
-0.0274152216,
-0.3395957947,
-0.450968653,
-0.3182531297,
-0.4906046987,
0.4688239098,
-0.4074313939,
-0.6870063543,
0.3494070172,
0.0486269258,
0.2538968027,
0.27820912,
0.3479821384,
0.1823231429,
1.0115221739,
0.71496737,
-0.3150889277,
0.5033511519,
-0.0318240337,
0.3382256031,
-0.9053106308,
-0.1589577347,
-0.6766394973,
0.0357956104,
-0.4888466299,
-0.3462391496,
0.1892277598,
0.5208407044,
-0.4539136589,
0.6410664916,
-0.4190714955,
0.3330070078,
0.4985388815,
0.0250693541,
0.3190867901,
0.1059531793,
-0.1029645428,
0.1294936836,
-0.4266743958,
-0.6421076655,
1.3682768345,
0.7695596218,
1.0358041525,
0.4665651917,
0.5617747903,
0.5947922468,
0.3562144935,
-0.4754921794,
0.7131072283,
-0.1574305892,
-0.5639929175,
-0.0628513619,
-0.2712442875,
-0.8246093392,
0.5910583138,
-0.0183521491,
-1.0496425629,
-0.2169056833,
0.2046991736,
-0.2769621909,
0.6972135901,
-0.8635417819,
0.7341542244,
-0.520483613,
-0.4043765366,
-0.2462276667,
-0.6798675656,
0.8175076842,
-0.1946664155,
0.1460182667,
-0.0091413809,
-0.0724691078,
0.5470183492,
-0.2064186186,
0.9015334249,
-0.2299059033,
-0.2846108377,
0.320007354,
0.471558243,
0.7908097506,
0.131730929,
0.0361722559,
0.0107120015,
-0.3881530166,
-0.3645377159,
-0.3985573947,
0.6883673668,
-0.6445550323,
-1.2190734148,
-0.3878241479,
-0.165341273,
-0.2292466015,
0.0648867488,
-0.1138798669,
0.2317187488,
-0.2383681834,
-0.0751873255,
0.8166537285,
-0.2448330522,
0.4274966121,
0.8152594566,
-0.2220150381,
-0.3487696946,
0.4811910093,
-0.2607988715,
0.6182594299,
0.2599206269,
0.1317917556,
-0.1598225385,
-0.7041091323,
-0.2853401005,
0.2606064081,
-0.4971159399,
-0.2064518631,
-0.5277543664,
-0.21882689,
-0.5568982959,
0.1230619103,
-0.2878631353,
-0.2802174985,
0.1463199407,
-0.1129215732,
0.3833822608,
0.8577611446,
-0.2093048394,
0.5629686713,
-0.8001405001,
0.3572186828,
0.3444192111,
0.2344284952,
-0.0221910868,
-0.7883228064,
0.2227023393,
-0.0735804588,
-0.602517426,
-1.3180048466,
0.4380479157,
-0.1392534673,
0.4503432214,
0.4761447012,
0.2060873508,
0.3816733956,
-0.6504648924,
0.7260536551,
0.3428943157,
-0.8719925284,
0.5447806716,
-0.3598090708,
0.0448524766,
0.2073856741,
0.2545146346,
-0.6404197812,
-0.4236305356,
-0.795124352,
-0.8549106121,
0.5931354761,
-0.059538465,
0.3796141446,
-0.0256798211,
0.2476322055,
-0.4431819022,
-0.00560892,
-0.9471844435,
-0.1808607429,
0.1300092489,
0.3932313621,
0.2131521106,
-0.5845295191,
-0.2601535618,
0.2012450099,
0.7370015383,
0.1981515139,
0.1253137887,
0.2166058719,
-0.1101703495,
-0.0418194085,
0.6036062241,
0.5469556451,
0.4507099986,
-0.1482531428,
0.3305105567,
0.0018737799,
-0.6320231557,
0.358484894,
-0.1073942184,
-0.3002001643,
-0.1785130054,
0.3609064221,
0.6120193601,
-0.0834807977,
-0.5080373287,
0.4159289598,
-0.037752416,
0.1003526598,
-0.3181763589,
0.0643857121,
-0.0378037058,
0.0966015458,
0.3723531961,
0.0743952543,
-0.4045262337,
-0.5395849347,
0.2754898667,
0.6776964664,
-0.3201190531,
-0.5629870892,
0.6429131031,
0.0715448633,
-0.4794070423,
0.3501271605,
-0.0691811815,
-0.8117457032,
0.6251718402,
0.8531941772,
0.9069643021,
-0.6519709229,
0.0492575467,
0.2047400773,
0.8065305352,
-0.2110304236,
-0.008581345,
0.1810049117,
-0.6429404616,
-0.6756800413,
-0.5583632588,
-0.5403748751,
0.458648771,
-0.3097594082,
0.2372744083,
-0.8564178348,
-0.0810747892,
-0.1414559484,
-0.1972096562,
-0.0529689416,
-0.09426523,
0.5030114055,
1.1276887655,
-0.7988367081,
1.1082310677,
0.7233223915,
-0.3834883273,
-0.7672165632,
0.2620682418,
0.1416636854,
-0.5351504683,
0.7564450502,
-0.0850931406,
-0.119797878,
-0.1604634821,
-0.5476108193,
-0.8097307682,
0.4439500868,
0.4947572351,
-0.5272476673,
-0.096531257,
-0.0200139899,
0.3598352075,
-0.0239818525,
0.0386803932,
0.5521991849,
0.579413116,
-0.1914662868,
-0.7671576142,
0.1302101016,
0.0654437244,
0.0027140619,
0.4792013466,
-0.6965159774,
0.8161074519,
-0.298343271,
-0.2483034432,
0.0787087753,
0.6339044571,
0.355329752,
-0.2986761332,
0.3798432648,
0.7076538801,
0.2973448336,
0.0175922457,
1.1782511473,
-0.3351777196,
0.0386972465,
1.1201937199,
-0.443747282,
1.0291237831,
0.4701610208,
-0.3873566389,
0.3961405456,
0.2804952562,
-0.1111246794,
0.3979468346,
0.6244490743,
-0.4472747445,
-0.0709078386,
0.1137561947,
-0.361568898,
0.3591096699,
0.4246106744,
-0.1645183414,
-0.3527227342,
-0.2188104242,
0.5240902901,
0.2654292881,
-0.3204790354,
0.5985211134,
0.2015364766,
-0.641135335,
0.5085664392,
0.5755002499,
0.7215288281,
-1.2038097382,
0.0730794966,
-0.1710188836,
0.254915148,
-0.1615532488,
-0.6148925424,
0.28107059,
0.4257199764,
-0.0747861713,
-0.1989266723,
0.8210306764,
-0.0915313736,
-0.0710489079,
0.6161462069,
0.064397715,
-0.1924785823,
-0.2827597857,
-0.6520457864,
0.0946609154,
0.0224827491,
-0.4748655856,
0.7308715582,
-0.2056515813,
-0.1950568259,
0.7700973749,
0.8346520662,
0.4572573304,
0.1543787867,
-0.0106779002,
0.8317102194,
-0.3780473769,
-0.3580776453,
-1.2806944847,
0.2513448298,
-0.0213101022,
0.0962493494,
0.9897754788,
0.2439273149,
0.5833269358,
0.1430274844,
0.7868414521,
-0.2071477473,
0.3913916945,
-0.4720938504,
0.5251523852,
-0.0358299054,
0.6592649817,
-0.3187030852,
-0.7917115092,
-0.5506473184,
0.2008208334,
-0.3480516076,
-0.4070489705,
0.5569438338,
0.8666090965,
0.1281748116,
-0.1472786814,
0.2190062255,
0.3637191653,
0.5964007378,
0.4718258977,
0.8893952966,
-0.145288527,
0.6123626232,
-0.1910510659,
-0.1605926454,
0.1350027323,
-0.9889616966,
-0.7356334925,
-0.1439859718,
0.0573168173,
-0.6808992624,
0.3621359766,
0.7275572419,
0.6345057487,
-0.8043820858,
-0.3462045491,
-0.1225140989,
0.1996593475,
0.0568932742,
-0.2184776515,
0.2851369381,
-0.3215581179,
-0.2265967727,
0.7962619066,
0.099184379,
0.0448005646,
-0.547565043,
0.1133759171,
-0.3573023677,
0.1705726534,
0.2493892163,
0.6630405188,
-0.7050254941,
-0.2271566242,
-0.3378539383,
-0.0580545887,
-0.1665695012,
0.8346871138,
-0.4604065716,
0.2524721324,
0.4246760607,
0.6525531411,
0.1219183356,
0.2027623206,
0.8582351804,
-0.9131180644,
0.3457574248,
0.2181069404,
0.3889855444,
0.324354589,
-0.2669756413,
0.5289918184,
0.3002346754,
-0.453720361,
-1.0081281662,
0.7394974232,
-0.5372158289,
-0.5480393171,
1.1946518421,
-0.2270264924,
-0.1911056638,
0.1108073741,
-0.1091238782,
-0.1118721291,
-0.4268397391,
0.6960425377,
0.5031208396,
0.159968242,
0.0364538506,
-0.7315495014,
0.440774411,
0.352206707,
-0.6663973927,
0.2552629113,
0.2514697909,
0.3674058616,
0.3183887601,
0.345772475,
-0.323810637,
0.0862675682,
0.01138971,
0.1040084064,
-0.2592964768,
-0.5663303137,
-0.6107627153,
0.4548941851,
0.5270941257,
-0.0554521903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00809v1
|
Abdelhak at SemEval-2024 Task 9 : Decoding Brainteasers, The Efficacy of Dedicated Models Versus ChatGPT
| 2024-02-24T20:00:03 | 2024-02-24T20:00:03 |
Abdelhak Kelious, Mounir Okirim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces a dedicated model aimed at solving the BRAINTEASER task
9 , a novel challenge designed to assess models lateral thinking capabilities
through sentence and word puzzles. Our model demonstrates remarkable efficacy,
securing Rank 1 in sentence puzzle solving during the test phase with an
overall score of 0.98. Additionally, we explore the comparative performance of
ChatGPT, specifically analyzing how variations in temperature settings affect
its ability to engage in lateral thinking and problem-solving. Our findings
indicate a notable performance disparity between the dedicated model and
ChatGPT, underscoring the potential of specialized approaches in enhancing
creative reasoning in AI.
|
[
-0.2141975164,
-0.9017174244,
0.6009942889,
0.3206662536,
-0.2433891594,
0.2184213996,
0.0463621207,
-0.4689128399,
0.1626795679,
0.5291399956,
-0.7182765007,
-0.0916587189,
-0.7047019005,
0.2100689113,
-0.190180257,
0.8444062471,
0.031896919,
0.1113924831,
-0.1739286333,
-0.1103869677,
-0.8507991433,
-0.5097993016,
-0.8148460984,
-0.5465807319,
0.2149942219,
0.2536226213,
0.7583469748,
0.2253568619,
0.9347051978,
0.3294751346,
-0.0719032064,
-0.0960126221,
-0.435613215,
0.2033963203,
-0.3055156171,
-0.4552348554,
-0.4379874468,
0.0422031842,
0.2526807785,
0.6680514812,
-0.2911891937,
0.0304722879,
-0.039233651,
0.8468340635,
-0.3894571066,
0.1336757243,
-0.6700065732,
0.0788864866,
-0.0391889587,
-0.1423376501,
-0.4201048315,
-0.2124644667,
0.2041203827,
-0.3476921618,
0.0171000455,
-0.0177037381,
0.4813625216,
0.6587026715,
-0.6386891603,
-0.0745452866,
-0.3699436486,
0.6167482138,
-0.6218596697,
0.486879617,
0.3431483507,
0.3513478935,
-0.0778379962,
-0.7716367245,
-0.2740808725,
-0.2079496831,
0.3224972785,
0.3221434057,
-0.4207180738,
-0.0401261598,
0.3422615528,
0.1208910793,
-0.7475443482,
-0.0814748034,
-0.6230624914,
-0.1434474885,
0.6818643808,
0.4765790999,
0.3613712788,
-0.0707295313,
-0.2749495208,
0.1407389343,
-0.4189249277,
0.337395072,
0.2854213715,
-0.1963675171,
-0.0025427188,
0.6639794111,
-0.2273478806,
0.3703013659,
0.0297197718,
0.4909754694,
0.2299649864,
-0.1010794714,
-0.1246143728,
-0.0698155835,
0.4742256403,
0.4703923464,
0.1059361771,
-0.3600892723,
-0.139012441,
0.2413183898,
0.4676012695,
-0.7460269928,
-0.7916887403,
0.2116891146,
-0.3547130823,
-0.249983713,
-0.44463256,
-0.4227152169,
-0.507866919,
-0.1142329946,
0.7669907212,
-0.6798442602,
-0.2706751227,
0.4070770741,
-0.4280935526,
0.3994167149,
0.418692112,
-0.7318384051,
0.2293814868,
0.6764889359,
0.7229762077,
-0.4480596781,
-0.3582116663,
-0.0648553669,
-0.1206408739,
-0.345020771,
1.0813173056,
-0.7380206585,
-0.3724932075,
-0.5618785024,
-0.0839259475,
-0.4368392825,
-0.3820109069,
0.6287682056,
-0.5899127722,
0.0347562991,
-0.6172793508,
-0.5077123642,
-0.4906162918,
0.4510039389,
-0.6533517241,
0.8507351875,
-0.0612718388,
-0.8585200906,
-0.0308804829,
-1.0768070221,
-0.3205887973,
0.2880094945,
-0.2858740389,
-0.1552670449,
0.1116125882,
0.3683689237,
0.2694070041,
-0.2949647903,
0.1237829551,
-0.1723979563,
-0.308583647,
0.5994173884,
-0.3492075503,
1.1414939165,
-0.0294119101,
-0.4386315048,
0.1478543878,
-0.5625788569,
0.2723127902,
0.4703719616,
-0.2142412215,
0.1963097453,
-0.1191295534,
-0.3065428436,
0.0938461497,
0.3759422004,
-0.5095914006,
0.2128282636,
-0.3871558309,
0.6546033025,
0.690444231,
0.251993984,
0.3944323957,
-0.3930996954,
0.8371931314,
0.0794565082,
-0.1310020685,
-0.1157608926,
-0.939940989,
-0.7630306482,
0.019008521,
0.2248887867,
0.8551607132,
-0.7648504972,
0.0661988184,
0.077468127,
-0.7384185195,
-0.494620353,
-0.304030478,
0.2028497308,
0.6691887975,
0.3952908814,
-0.2641381025,
-0.4048804045,
-1.1984221935,
-0.6248505712,
0.2006712705,
0.2191364467,
0.1653533876,
0.8904058933,
-0.1521657854,
0.487513572,
-0.4850896597,
0.0093334736,
-0.5432770848,
0.1370914429,
0.2616124749,
0.5683656335,
0.4458992183,
-0.7356429696,
-0.4163426161,
-0.1280115098,
-0.8900226951,
-0.0025417521,
0.1567016989,
-0.0135618057,
0.1532014012,
0.355388999,
-0.7991627455,
0.6981871724,
0.4362390935,
-0.6628614664,
0.610540688,
-0.1207313538,
0.4822790325,
-0.5633176565,
0.0767355412,
-0.3489093781,
0.0753737614,
-0.8996503353,
0.1981644183,
0.0481021926,
-0.4451189637,
-0.188564688,
0.1235297173,
-0.3955134749,
0.1904678643,
-0.4058185816,
-0.26586321,
-0.0725941807,
0.6387994885,
0.037927866,
0.6461390257,
0.5411910415,
-0.2858903408,
0.2715734541,
0.2912198901,
-0.3460397422,
0.2438133508,
-1.1535559893,
0.5707900524,
-0.2840005159,
0.1445767432,
-1.1168366671,
-0.1338095665,
0.1456890255,
-0.5591272116,
-0.0256055016,
0.2230181545,
-0.1679371893,
-0.3684481978,
0.0279732849,
0.5095043778,
0.7147254944,
-0.1279378831,
0.8100075722,
0.5223977566,
-0.1545671821,
-0.4575165808,
-0.8145273328,
0.0325552598,
-0.5270369053,
-0.8556815982,
0.3425886035,
-0.2362928391,
-0.1598275602,
-0.1395882368,
-0.1434850991,
-0.1005466282,
0.2726690173,
0.2701728642,
0.0550119355,
-0.0138539793,
-0.3360075355,
-0.1387880445,
-0.1582782269,
0.511487186,
0.2196882665,
0.5751405954,
-0.4823862016,
-0.4737742841,
-0.3439801633,
0.6198809743,
0.3834533095,
-0.5097793341,
0.6934756041,
0.6396609545,
-0.3743491471,
-0.1435904503,
-0.6636508107,
-0.3676464856,
-0.5407752991,
0.3968304694,
-0.6672983766,
-0.8038092852,
0.8332647681,
0.1908383518,
-0.1369212866,
0.2884423435,
0.5972443819,
-0.0721122473,
1.270408988,
0.5325300694,
0.3541165292,
-0.1075955331,
-0.3511610627,
0.4481316209,
-0.8032283783,
-0.5249807239,
-0.3003672659,
-0.5632873178,
-0.4485233426,
-0.274227947,
0.6361190081,
-0.0724842399,
-0.3614340723,
0.3261624575,
-0.8164795041,
0.6593385339,
0.7282093167,
0.4140861332,
0.0122652529,
-0.3106085062,
-0.0882571712,
-0.3037537038,
-0.8063364625,
-0.0985515192,
1.0398329496,
0.2925570905,
0.3723700345,
0.3147174418,
0.5863958597,
0.0577302016,
-0.2484276742,
-0.648704946,
0.8171826005,
0.2973487377,
-0.8068356514,
-0.2541143,
-0.1854679286,
-1.0872092247,
0.5303197503,
0.1307805181,
-0.969273448,
-0.0709339231,
-0.1517901719,
-0.3877658546,
-0.0309447441,
-0.7546275854,
1.2049120665,
-0.2313826978,
-0.3420441151,
-0.4613982737,
-0.6221949458,
0.2092248201,
0.1403709352,
-0.0617790781,
-0.2808149159,
-0.058182355,
1.0072484016,
-0.0322031118,
0.5581904054,
-0.2206428796,
0.2047486454,
0.3480452895,
0.3544392288,
0.4433515072,
-0.0347677991,
-0.1321517825,
0.0770648867,
0.1568523049,
-0.5438544154,
-0.6944363713,
0.4388550818,
-0.8388583064,
-1.2109256983,
-0.5480899811,
-0.923974812,
-0.3863805532,
0.2706815302,
0.3139439225,
0.3682664633,
-0.2095380276,
0.4340103567,
0.6196644306,
-0.1892290413,
0.4398899674,
0.5748029351,
-0.0125816176,
-0.3294606507,
0.5744639635,
0.2257663906,
-0.0462746769,
0.1479515582,
0.1733331233,
-0.0917899832,
-0.7324878573,
-0.032167647,
-0.1407813579,
-0.8548682332,
-0.1359202266,
-0.8313109279,
-0.4931679964,
-0.4230799079,
-0.2767405808,
-0.4627883434,
-0.6258963346,
0.069919005,
-0.0511869788,
0.1518360078,
0.5793820024,
-0.1030772999,
0.0913521796,
-0.4642423689,
0.2009165287,
0.1337764412,
-0.1867865473,
-0.1211077273,
-0.5854955912,
-0.0229529236,
0.0892788917,
-0.5677043796,
-1.1449626684,
0.4598609805,
-0.2604453266,
0.6304749846,
0.0626015589,
-0.0636458099,
0.587551415,
-0.5148072243,
0.8510289192,
0.0976006463,
-0.7957703471,
0.7025966048,
-0.5659759641,
0.8694272637,
0.3957091868,
0.5179983974,
-0.2131114304,
-0.2609125376,
-0.8147572875,
-0.5631972551,
0.5064501166,
0.418623805,
-0.0874831975,
0.1570235491,
0.0916695893,
0.0749440193,
0.0154083055,
-0.6813808084,
-0.0631621778,
-0.1310483068,
0.0536390133,
0.0367973186,
-0.1750396043,
0.0044056587,
-0.609597981,
0.5434079766,
0.1496387571,
0.4617698789,
0.1294683814,
0.0005612519,
0.2408152968,
0.2412255108,
0.316668272,
0.6846889257,
-0.1044551954,
0.0254539773,
0.4614578784,
-0.3920910954,
-0.0288796108,
0.1754558384,
-0.0738857985,
-0.3262842596,
0.4137958586,
0.7332900763,
0.2296218872,
-0.5869356394,
0.439807713,
0.0122235771,
-0.2331711352,
-0.3618846834,
0.3261400163,
0.3174528182,
0.6250702143,
0.3650866151,
0.4269211888,
0.6074002385,
-0.4855741858,
0.1029699519,
0.4584151208,
-0.1374047548,
-0.4912228584,
0.8673382998,
0.2054433078,
-0.3752562404,
0.8398734927,
-0.1771875471,
-0.9671775699,
0.978304565,
0.5999310613,
0.7468954921,
-0.4365699887,
0.0361401439,
0.225873962,
0.4489610195,
0.0597927049,
0.719561398,
-0.032782089,
-0.9228698611,
-0.2676026225,
-0.0401324965,
-0.3736114502,
0.1249575466,
-0.6020464897,
0.008693262,
-0.2050896436,
-0.3791445196,
0.2073781192,
0.0929620638,
-0.9601178765,
-0.0062998873,
-0.0516312011,
0.911581099,
-0.4873684645,
0.7508333325,
0.8376489282,
-0.3689997792,
-0.764887929,
-0.419919312,
0.0433314741,
-0.8347073197,
0.6657693982,
0.3208830357,
-0.0846734792,
0.211858049,
-0.3259104788,
-0.8388652205,
1.1664923429,
0.4736490548,
-0.1453999281,
-0.2904771864,
0.2269153297,
0.3706647456,
-0.2232220322,
0.4368326366,
0.7354124188,
0.412237674,
0.0952333286,
-1.1305990219,
-0.0068664337,
-0.5485262275,
-0.1432890296,
0.0191225167,
-0.8031268716,
0.8931124806,
-0.3685156405,
-0.1917301267,
-0.0462893099,
0.7267016172,
0.3454188704,
0.3749411404,
0.14294146,
0.7498819828,
0.6357677579,
0.060050644,
0.8738936186,
-0.2519160807,
0.0031906685,
0.9963079691,
-0.3144892454,
0.8642206788,
0.3601839244,
-0.0892420188,
0.34975034,
0.304484725,
-0.0217572823,
0.7524242401,
0.0394513346,
-0.0992908999,
-0.3820359707,
0.0375095531,
-0.4955668151,
0.8348158598,
0.4362781048,
0.0018380258,
-0.1196049079,
0.2027223557,
-0.1769815534,
0.1023748666,
-0.3415938914,
0.4802287519,
0.1887692064,
-0.9245052934,
0.4760007858,
-0.0010456721,
0.3062965572,
-0.2407612652,
0.0765323788,
-0.1229701117,
0.5254843235,
-0.0175740756,
-0.8854624033,
0.4639228582,
-0.314504236,
0.182705909,
-0.2301196009,
0.9166558981,
-0.1161254793,
-0.5014873147,
-0.0075286496,
0.6814339161,
0.2216295749,
-0.2147277296,
-0.9803063273,
0.4302843511,
0.1528374255,
-0.5616049767,
0.0417996794,
0.4921934903,
0.2341234982,
1.0562660694,
0.1692431569,
-0.4398333728,
-0.0212555174,
-0.294451803,
0.6914566755,
-0.7788176537,
-0.6903776526,
-0.9636996388,
0.5164740682,
-0.0903254971,
-0.4219830036,
1.0313413143,
0.7573248148,
0.5844233036,
-0.3257472515,
0.6132848263,
-0.018699253,
0.2691990137,
-0.3623265624,
0.7144482136,
-0.1798464805,
-0.0121707991,
0.0522064082,
-0.773216188,
-0.0617295839,
0.7392138243,
-0.7183059454,
0.057303004,
1.033170104,
0.8222174048,
-0.0303126425,
0.6562302709,
0.3676322699,
0.0841630995,
0.190162912,
1.0589940548,
1.1228666306,
-0.4303319156,
0.264916569,
-0.3535392582,
-0.1983568519,
0.061352551,
-0.5840834379,
-1.3681880236,
-0.7710250616,
-0.4723981321,
-0.2251506448,
0.2662294805,
0.722862184,
0.405795753,
-0.6087210178,
-0.0871618614,
-0.2384797633,
-0.326103121,
-0.3160555065,
-0.2196506113,
0.2971072793,
-0.2614623904,
-0.4990417063,
0.526386261,
0.2451144308,
-0.2334569097,
-0.0675146133,
0.1568392068,
-0.1884553283,
0.3156078756,
0.5185456276,
-0.1018897444,
-0.6072564125,
-0.2132789344,
0.1694415361,
0.1404738873,
0.0457622558,
0.7471386194,
-0.8712077737,
-0.0828638449,
0.6949174404,
0.8228549957,
0.6290692687,
-0.0419287346,
0.6011110544,
0.1839323044,
0.1541457474,
0.7280805707,
0.3956803679,
0.1983080059,
-0.3776670992,
0.7980153561,
0.1617011577,
-0.8973675966,
-0.7797584534,
0.3345839977,
-1.0962436199,
-0.3969210088,
0.9581099153,
-0.0540686287,
-0.3750397861,
0.0920638815,
-0.2779117823,
0.0179311298,
-0.2390563935,
0.8695379496,
0.7774570584,
-0.5686432123,
-0.4741887748,
-0.7539542317,
0.4284861982,
0.7520534992,
-0.4846717119,
-0.2701579034,
0.291372478,
0.2485564649,
-0.1206931546,
0.7091348171,
-0.0298160668,
0.4833007455,
0.3757480681,
-0.3713099957,
-0.3101617098,
-0.2072353959,
-0.0923300087,
0.4271814525,
-0.0978051946,
-0.0340208299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15873v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15873v2
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8: Weighted Layer Averaging RoBERTa for Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-02-24T17:44:56 | 2024-04-09T10:19:48 |
Ayan Datta, Aryan Chandramania, Radhika Mamidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This document contains the details of the authors' submission to the
proceedings of SemEval 2024's Task 8: Multigenerator, Multidomain, and
Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection Subtask A (monolingual)
and B. Detection of machine-generated text is becoming an increasingly
important task, with the advent of large language models (LLMs). In this paper,
we lay out how using weighted averages of RoBERTa layers lets us capture
information about text that is relevant to machine-generated text detection.
|
[
-0.2707375288,
-0.9293441176,
0.6898257732,
0.3273884058,
-0.2024259865,
-0.1852096617,
-0.0015694943,
-0.5333046913,
0.1471080035,
0.8253065944,
-0.5372405648,
-0.5396354198,
-0.8882163763,
0.2170650661,
-0.5325169563,
1.1997350454,
0.0949487165,
-0.3444091082,
-0.3025554717,
-0.1725863665,
-0.3317899704,
-0.6421662569,
-0.8385565877,
-0.3154082596,
0.6385185122,
0.2952999175,
0.1701203436,
0.2929738164,
0.5294584632,
0.4024312794,
0.1455700845,
0.2887105942,
-0.1698216647,
0.3949674964,
0.0159983318,
-0.3218548,
-0.9088643193,
0.268597573,
0.8105881214,
0.1679104269,
0.0438490175,
0.4300988615,
-0.0190585013,
0.4752922356,
-0.4975074828,
-0.1854225248,
-0.6521827579,
0.1636104733,
-0.5038375258,
-0.7638118267,
-0.7329173088,
0.1992178857,
-0.2561482787,
-0.2845413089,
0.0452432819,
0.1751134992,
0.5401895046,
0.2277481705,
-0.6010504961,
-0.4439490736,
-0.489567548,
1.1172578335,
-0.6189172864,
0.1974344403,
0.3115549982,
0.0218459461,
-0.0962889567,
-0.6473955512,
-0.4078237116,
0.0145120677,
0.2823912203,
0.2873092294,
-0.4394447207,
-0.3481178284,
0.4044516385,
0.1354277581,
-0.5739173889,
0.0391881391,
-0.5393361449,
-0.3075966239,
0.6246825457,
0.0914473832,
0.5865064263,
-0.2415726334,
-0.6073642969,
0.1584035456,
-0.2959966063,
-0.1575798988,
0.490028888,
0.0666582957,
-0.2845469713,
0.5229833126,
0.0825388581,
0.8235164285,
-0.2554462552,
-0.4062517583,
0.4686117172,
-0.5127565861,
-0.2595332861,
0.1089711115,
0.9481778145,
0.2389372736,
0.3370361924,
0.1071301699,
-0.3427715003,
-0.048764091,
0.5164518356,
-0.8132069111,
-0.2007743567,
0.3776759207,
-0.6530027986,
-0.6270931363,
-0.1365959346,
-0.8039594889,
-0.2642201483,
-0.0930977836,
0.4596658945,
-0.1100301296,
-0.2452522665,
-0.0901027471,
-0.3694651723,
0.0116373021,
0.4754140377,
-0.2590145469,
0.3230994046,
0.4133456051,
0.5946039557,
-0.409473896,
-0.473818928,
-1.0417095423,
0.1652001441,
-0.1993628442,
1.0468586683,
-0.4355277419,
-0.0265464671,
-0.2494079769,
0.2923336327,
0.1619704068,
-0.4930184782,
0.6991451383,
-0.4833865166,
0.5182123184,
0.0666120797,
-0.3527664244,
-0.2301860452,
0.3347200155,
-0.5397408009,
1.2740809917,
0.0976491347,
-0.8374893069,
0.3307215571,
-0.457511276,
-0.5540860891,
0.3256761432,
0.1203268021,
-0.9907426834,
0.1164618433,
0.2807838619,
0.7014936209,
-0.2997240424,
-0.0142609375,
-0.2349743843,
-0.2323914021,
0.4557571709,
-0.5000414848,
0.9784327745,
0.2110606134,
-0.5254071951,
0.2579610646,
-0.8220871687,
0.1459960043,
0.2018211931,
-0.410181433,
-0.4850234389,
-0.0914006233,
0.3402632773,
0.211712569,
0.6123417616,
-0.4637570381,
-0.1436127126,
0.129524827,
0.2626366019,
0.7518437505,
0.1359526217,
0.4315797985,
-0.3455485702,
0.9021832347,
0.3456699252,
-0.1407653689,
-0.4138447642,
-0.6591524482,
-0.6165459752,
-0.3774809241,
0.4898164868,
0.606667161,
-0.6099643707,
0.2335958034,
0.1742298603,
-0.3094729781,
-0.2883174419,
0.4273504615,
0.4528261721,
0.0641045347,
0.3619043529,
-0.3002705872,
-0.65088135,
-0.7840663195,
-0.1747353226,
0.2487827986,
0.0011907094,
0.192854628,
0.7396900058,
-0.1799115986,
-0.0069655743,
-0.511954248,
-0.478859216,
-0.3135589659,
0.350833863,
0.0281534791,
0.4096990228,
0.8257674575,
-0.7353135347,
-0.6550162435,
-0.1484495103,
-0.8767444491,
-0.468988359,
0.0430099741,
-0.2232436389,
0.2317232788,
0.6373323798,
-0.2881751657,
0.2513768971,
0.7351153493,
-0.2947108746,
0.3807103932,
-0.4117018878,
0.3980058134,
-1.3480550051,
-0.2880190313,
0.3265538514,
-0.64081496,
-0.7173444033,
0.3036645949,
0.1730134785,
-0.1564506143,
-0.1911188066,
0.5067691803,
-0.7310670018,
-0.355828315,
-0.6288939714,
0.4197268486,
0.0295882896,
0.3103345037,
-0.4109314978,
1.0102688074,
0.3436952829,
-0.5190917253,
0.2007176131,
-0.2515330017,
-0.2477193475,
1.0846972466,
-0.7208913565,
0.2298682779,
-0.1628731489,
0.162157923,
-0.9084168673,
0.0496765524,
0.1765771061,
-0.7416349649,
0.1893519163,
-0.0904718935,
-0.3641904294,
-0.2357505113,
-0.5088080168,
0.5015001297,
0.4514865875,
-0.0954267606,
0.8269809484,
0.8891518116,
-0.1933587641,
-0.4931425154,
-0.8530830145,
0.342903018,
-0.4611596465,
-0.3509463072,
0.4039546251,
-0.0942746475,
-0.1736898869,
0.0350465663,
0.2859880626,
-0.1122238114,
0.3931352198,
0.1647560149,
0.0638688803,
-0.1757411212,
-0.3252268434,
-0.177945599,
-0.2198190391,
0.1315038055,
-0.5579356551,
0.6444172859,
0.35945189,
-0.1411473751,
-0.2616544962,
0.5421123505,
0.6414749026,
-0.4910025001,
0.6281005144,
1.0147422552,
-0.5153529048,
-0.65845716,
-0.3199319839,
0.3252623081,
-0.4103532732,
0.2666240036,
-0.4084868133,
-0.7695816159,
0.5673095584,
0.3906818032,
-0.2032268643,
0.6013836265,
0.8513379097,
-0.1050640419,
1.2445315123,
0.7604026198,
-0.1619536132,
0.5182520747,
-0.1055720225,
0.0750802979,
-1.0955711603,
0.0027562885,
-0.7360260487,
-0.1730429083,
-0.7158001661,
-0.5815769434,
0.536192596,
-0.282841742,
0.002342693,
0.3699535728,
-0.6751589775,
0.183256954,
0.8631446958,
0.3462306261,
0.197804302,
0.053784769,
-0.0577316843,
0.1521091014,
-0.2404137999,
-0.3380428851,
1.1530896425,
0.2805348635,
0.5234529972,
0.1731929928,
0.8787419796,
0.716570437,
0.0290363189,
-0.6512301564,
0.6356863379,
-0.4375300705,
-0.5555530787,
-0.2534079552,
-0.3568738997,
-0.9978641868,
0.2114855945,
-0.0025889403,
-0.5484147072,
-0.1424979568,
-0.0198309366,
0.1561017781,
0.0151312789,
-0.3578786552,
0.8699705005,
-0.2446784675,
-0.1321746409,
-0.3204072714,
-0.0978614613,
0.2655554712,
-0.267819047,
0.3154169619,
-0.2753040493,
-0.1450088322,
0.8697539568,
-0.0520965792,
0.6694263816,
-0.4194995165,
-0.2396191806,
0.4624477923,
0.1198910102,
0.6079106927,
-0.3562017679,
0.0085218018,
-0.0159001183,
-0.2275359929,
-0.5495865345,
-0.2354737669,
0.6007668972,
-0.5280401707,
-0.4295745194,
-0.6203311682,
-0.6105463505,
0.3388260305,
0.311914444,
0.1556099355,
0.6207245588,
0.1466625184,
0.4540337026,
0.6266523004,
-0.36997509,
0.2917240858,
0.5663515925,
-0.2743477225,
-0.4934721291,
1.019828558,
0.3427618444,
-0.0367340446,
0.5702036023,
0.1027857214,
0.025617905,
-0.9111375809,
-0.4296030104,
-0.1405949742,
-0.6518530846,
-0.4592837691,
-1.0765684843,
-0.4855526984,
-0.2618651986,
-0.0616412833,
0.2166720927,
-0.3690608144,
-0.3331379294,
0.0829594731,
0.1681703925,
0.7258406878,
0.3988665342,
0.2920561731,
-0.6064355373,
0.443926692,
0.1602632254,
-0.2588402629,
-0.0539474748,
-0.8486144543,
-0.3163107634,
-0.1474451125,
-0.3776390851,
-0.7569211125,
0.5541341901,
0.1212404594,
0.6984289289,
-0.018122375,
-0.1717089862,
0.524330616,
-0.6113418341,
0.782460928,
-0.0191873144,
-0.8725793362,
0.6711785197,
-0.4422545135,
0.7142288089,
0.0771539062,
0.2129831016,
-0.2994443774,
-0.7708435059,
-0.507322669,
-0.5963950157,
0.6305488944,
0.2049912363,
0.2025596499,
0.0803015977,
0.0774397701,
-0.2089352161,
0.3320956826,
-1.2148470879,
-0.0383666009,
-0.0685319826,
-0.7099424601,
-0.0900763199,
-0.5725995302,
0.0233390126,
0.2096688449,
0.6804618835,
-0.2397865206,
0.5715918541,
-0.1495794803,
-0.3779933453,
-0.2562272847,
0.3809723258,
0.9769135714,
0.4764490724,
0.1154052243,
0.5069327354,
0.3836429417,
-0.454027921,
0.0835208818,
0.1179070473,
-0.4432090819,
-0.2627032995,
0.6930915117,
0.5975602269,
0.3030916154,
-0.4053196609,
0.5837677717,
0.0872644261,
-0.3210840225,
-0.5350964665,
0.1383323967,
-0.0182064306,
0.2935337722,
0.5042720437,
0.0464323424,
0.3617997468,
-0.5965207219,
0.535954535,
0.7194084525,
-0.3059149683,
-0.3622616827,
0.789893508,
0.0225440115,
-0.3918898106,
0.1272987723,
-0.2972278595,
-0.9523527026,
0.8684105873,
0.7204800248,
0.9472748637,
-0.328644067,
0.1447252184,
0.2490791231,
0.4415292144,
0.1899012327,
0.5442973971,
-0.0295131579,
-0.8257670999,
-0.2854351401,
-0.7896482348,
-0.1528202891,
0.1728931963,
-0.431694746,
0.3720872402,
-0.3328436315,
-0.2579125166,
0.4614014924,
0.2381969094,
-0.5437474847,
0.2318449914,
-0.000273038,
0.7031689882,
-0.8180561662,
0.7166708112,
0.8049818873,
-0.4140073657,
-0.5831776261,
-0.1152400821,
0.262163341,
-0.9190269113,
0.6287561059,
0.0865086317,
-0.1345209777,
-0.1332806945,
-0.442404747,
-0.7272472978,
0.9432384372,
0.0429120921,
-0.1728696376,
0.0880830213,
-0.1473337263,
0.5069368482,
-0.6507257819,
0.3010301292,
0.065064393,
0.5625995398,
-0.3098649085,
-0.6982468367,
0.0086417394,
-0.4361960292,
-0.1268390268,
0.408873558,
-0.6531618834,
1.0833711624,
0.1698429883,
0.0925512686,
-0.050229501,
0.6168321967,
0.3684789538,
0.4163608551,
0.5819590092,
0.7892044187,
0.6548528671,
0.0176010858,
0.9610507488,
-0.3782125711,
0.2010578066,
1.0489830971,
-0.3244411945,
0.7393314242,
0.027262019,
-0.3325460851,
0.5779677629,
0.5571370721,
-0.2756690681,
0.3096962869,
-0.0968514234,
-0.2868483365,
-0.183190003,
-0.0156541783,
-0.1022713184,
0.6728900671,
0.2640305459,
-0.5274874568,
0.0211176723,
0.2767680287,
0.1422199458,
0.0695004836,
-0.4561598897,
0.8767076731,
0.1372704804,
-0.7314972878,
0.1659891158,
0.2939724922,
0.765206039,
-0.4630149007,
-0.0750130415,
0.1550462842,
0.3396493196,
-0.2467621267,
-0.8332977295,
0.051298134,
0.1398019791,
-0.4063472152,
-0.3330027461,
1.090380311,
-0.7709268332,
-0.9452940226,
0.5094017982,
0.3840294182,
0.2228339165,
0.0911464095,
-0.8864560127,
0.2501176596,
-0.0316053778,
-0.2540719211,
0.3973831534,
0.866512239,
-0.0884942785,
0.5610292554,
0.4909298122,
0.2362758815,
0.2022345662,
0.2273846716,
0.4769479334,
-0.6089330912,
-0.4192892611,
-0.7202312946,
0.4522419274,
-0.1218480691,
-0.1782792509,
1.0931389332,
0.6148334146,
0.7673733234,
0.0048738425,
0.7978702188,
-0.1226949319,
0.6101104617,
-0.6812931299,
0.4661768675,
-0.9379978776,
0.1589415371,
-0.4086445868,
-1.0629639626,
0.0097879581,
0.5670740604,
-0.0138523849,
0.3472519517,
0.8219931722,
0.587549448,
-0.16225411,
-0.2983089983,
0.4419144392,
0.1710973829,
0.2305728346,
0.4424882233,
0.6013182402,
-0.7052319646,
0.4610503614,
-0.1353754401,
-0.1450480521,
-0.1112225279,
-1.0833150148,
-1.0614470243,
-0.702765584,
-0.3892218173,
-0.4070445895,
-0.102768518,
0.6156471968,
0.6999007463,
-1.1546012163,
-0.3784514964,
0.2665585577,
0.2395164818,
-0.155286938,
-0.2589974403,
0.0825018883,
-0.4653463066,
-0.9974262714,
0.3023122549,
0.6470370293,
-0.0034523192,
-0.5245540738,
0.141299203,
-0.348571986,
0.1100926474,
0.8173441887,
-0.3581746817,
-0.4610943794,
-0.3298563361,
-0.2236349285,
-0.2967404127,
0.0373252258,
0.8583009839,
-0.475822717,
0.2003473639,
0.6779395938,
0.3673712313,
0.6501092911,
0.0873387679,
0.6218898892,
-0.842500031,
0.3279684484,
-0.0328334086,
0.4713607132,
0.3544082642,
-0.5394520164,
0.4703192115,
0.2448631078,
-0.7528164387,
-1.0259435177,
0.0236109756,
-1.0172455311,
-0.3747062087,
0.9189547896,
-0.1365052611,
-0.5165160298,
-0.0878643245,
-0.0152877495,
-0.0683006793,
-0.253280282,
0.2476662397,
0.7490823269,
0.0900902972,
-0.7441059351,
-0.9280831814,
0.3582392335,
0.1373180896,
-1.0262402296,
-0.2698421478,
0.3792695403,
0.3890306056,
0.2636579573,
0.9644421339,
-0.1683179289,
0.3468197584,
-0.0578583479,
-0.0195678137,
0.106636852,
-0.7234209776,
-0.167204082,
0.4843413532,
-0.046560429,
0.0228826795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15862v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15862v2
|
SportQA: A Benchmark for Sports Understanding in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T17:12:10 | 2024-06-18T03:29:51 |
Haotian Xia, Zhengbang Yang, Yuqing Wang, Rhys Tracy, Yun Zhao, Dongdong Huang, Zezhi Chen, Yan Zhu, Yuan-fang Wang, Weining Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A deep understanding of sports, a field rich in strategic and dynamic
content, is crucial for advancing Natural Language Processing (NLP). This holds
particular significance in the context of evaluating and advancing Large
Language Models (LLMs), given the existing gap in specialized benchmarks. To
bridge this gap, we introduce SportQA, a novel benchmark specifically designed
for evaluating LLMs in the context of sports understanding. SportQA encompasses
over 70,000 multiple-choice questions across three distinct difficulty levels,
each targeting different aspects of sports knowledge from basic historical
facts to intricate, scenario-based reasoning tasks. We conducted a thorough
evaluation of prevalent LLMs, mainly utilizing few-shot learning paradigms
supplemented by chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. Our results reveal that while
LLMs exhibit competent performance in basic sports knowledge, they struggle
with more complex, scenario-based sports reasoning, lagging behind human
expertise. The introduction of SportQA marks a significant step forward in NLP,
offering a tool for assessing and enhancing sports understanding in LLMs.
|
[
-0.2882627249,
-0.5225915909,
0.6879816055,
0.1188872159,
-0.1935843527,
0.4382932484,
-0.2636434138,
-0.5000935197,
-0.2620722055,
-0.0529701523,
-0.7766174078,
-0.4963945746,
-0.6750535369,
0.0136592286,
-0.2240706831,
0.7157238722,
-0.2593612969,
0.2705046535,
-0.2657926381,
-0.5060795546,
-0.6725629568,
-0.6820856333,
-0.912671864,
-0.6057165265,
0.2800747454,
-0.1193651929,
0.4219855964,
0.2297055125,
0.55164814,
0.3266637027,
-0.4763884842,
0.3840855956,
-0.7052130699,
0.4917011559,
-0.4190053642,
-0.4847327769,
-0.3664090931,
0.1101696268,
0.829895854,
0.9466447234,
0.0351357497,
0.4597947299,
-0.0145944236,
0.6402606964,
-0.7650702596,
0.0288510416,
-0.5351201892,
0.1944232881,
-0.2021219581,
-0.2984916568,
-0.1185838133,
-0.0316646397,
0.0480325185,
-0.5895192623,
0.0767609477,
0.0761361346,
0.5966955423,
0.2474144995,
-0.5711584687,
-0.0047355397,
-0.7158639431,
0.7199100256,
-0.6227529049,
0.7965077758,
0.414029628,
0.5211147666,
-0.3402445018,
-0.3417505026,
-0.4993878305,
-0.0828155503,
0.4473932683,
0.345012337,
-0.0630820543,
-0.1215555668,
0.3876429498,
0.0849344954,
-0.6740605831,
0.1069083288,
-0.1617961228,
0.2932523489,
0.8010604978,
0.3096400201,
0.0424275734,
0.0730626434,
-0.3092993796,
0.1597612947,
-0.6532509923,
0.4733207524,
0.1074328199,
0.2217805684,
0.0138774216,
0.362675041,
-0.7799887657,
0.5383329988,
-0.0738416389,
-0.2285006046,
0.2546333969,
-0.1633776873,
-0.3857714832,
-0.0212810226,
0.6362851262,
0.2316375226,
0.0679459795,
-0.4984083176,
0.0085414033,
-0.3575436771,
0.1222502813,
-0.5765368938,
0.0044352636,
0.3119793832,
-0.4186224937,
0.0808392316,
-0.0129644852,
-0.44002527,
-0.6750181913,
-0.3438182771,
0.5318100452,
-0.3788781762,
0.0453914031,
0.4168647826,
-0.3325671852,
0.681836009,
0.3607269228,
-0.6989744902,
0.2018159032,
1.0487205982,
0.6979860663,
-0.1466558874,
-0.2429647893,
-0.6936927438,
0.1801429987,
-0.4235170484,
1.0281677246,
-0.5070801377,
0.0819970891,
0.1948907524,
-0.4850965738,
0.2750608027,
-0.4682783484,
0.683511138,
-0.6708432436,
-0.1970979422,
-0.35954386,
-0.7181288004,
-0.3393449783,
0.5975695848,
-0.5283170342,
1.3104966879,
-0.0415956378,
-0.3987391293,
1.0196108818,
-0.4468059242,
-0.4739470184,
0.4430501163,
-0.1136381328,
-0.0841450468,
0.1682550907,
0.3835953176,
0.3892591596,
-0.5578324199,
0.2631563246,
-0.5719031692,
-0.3653448522,
0.3946770132,
-0.475410223,
0.3778556883,
-0.1111930311,
-0.2096678019,
-0.1623075902,
-0.5753529072,
0.2454920113,
-0.0781235397,
-0.3839016259,
-0.3934791982,
0.2094151825,
-0.3640551865,
0.5151833296,
-0.0241386481,
-0.2553341389,
0.107521601,
-0.5748779178,
0.3616889715,
0.5796201825,
-0.1153713986,
0.3965427279,
-0.2124310583,
0.6385369301,
-0.2387437373,
0.1719072759,
0.110181354,
-0.4043815732,
-0.3970406651,
-0.1425914168,
0.2955322266,
0.2345843166,
-0.6634114981,
0.1848333031,
-0.3261142075,
-0.667103529,
-0.4468255341,
0.3199721277,
0.2237903476,
0.3673917651,
0.4538507164,
-0.1249934584,
-0.4085249901,
-0.5639904141,
-0.6280843019,
-0.1958850324,
0.0392211303,
0.460703671,
0.6424104571,
0.3104343712,
0.6275702715,
-0.3016176224,
-0.2315041572,
-0.383852154,
0.2587478161,
0.3601639271,
0.1280163229,
0.4995103478,
-0.7346524,
-0.3467849493,
-0.2605038881,
-0.7749246359,
-0.0943716615,
-0.1797647476,
-0.4082352221,
-0.3230686784,
0.314473778,
-0.664802134,
0.4122428298,
0.5615887046,
-0.5296105742,
0.6077305079,
0.0158307254,
0.5005970001,
-0.5251247287,
0.22143583,
0.0741850734,
-0.3049660921,
-0.5831664205,
0.1640869528,
-0.3108774424,
0.3439669609,
-0.5454499722,
0.6440733671,
-0.3433265388,
-0.3332666457,
-0.2053625435,
0.2594465017,
0.1891678572,
0.1635171473,
0.308180213,
0.6908254623,
0.4461030364,
-0.7583658695,
0.4156460762,
0.4512394667,
-0.7245419621,
0.664506495,
-0.5574461818,
0.0022737742,
-0.1914681941,
0.4030799568,
-0.8640167117,
-0.0935202017,
0.0874565318,
-0.3512038887,
0.060909003,
-0.1798120439,
-0.3564273119,
-0.5853376389,
-0.1784345508,
0.7995390892,
0.2019675076,
-0.4266383946,
0.5962049961,
0.5745813847,
-0.0201744568,
-0.7162560821,
-0.3066066206,
0.150735423,
-0.2891332805,
-0.1934094578,
0.0761823207,
-0.2293001115,
-0.240836218,
-0.3064239621,
-0.6258007884,
-0.5575558543,
0.3888959885,
0.0446865335,
0.1030364111,
-0.528324306,
0.3698854446,
-0.1052201986,
0.2822217047,
0.2051519603,
-0.2399549931,
0.6312047243,
0.0202334598,
-0.1224523485,
-0.4313647747,
0.2801552713,
0.1493999213,
-0.1960256249,
0.7783734202,
0.3092193604,
-0.3031059802,
-0.5892783999,
-0.4477982521,
0.0805945918,
-0.4362158179,
0.5185585618,
-0.7148180008,
-1.0271304846,
0.247644648,
-0.2366319001,
0.0312968455,
0.4991518259,
0.6789163351,
-0.5471087694,
1.0751923323,
0.095895879,
-0.0602474473,
-0.057488583,
-0.0028395515,
0.0416920371,
-0.76997298,
-0.4590797126,
-0.641964972,
-0.6574257016,
-0.0876409039,
-0.6629751921,
0.0945787877,
0.2692143023,
-0.705675602,
0.3189576566,
-0.0891181231,
0.8461642265,
0.3588672578,
0.2235221416,
0.3270541131,
-0.6576936841,
0.0463023782,
-0.1751747131,
-0.9001712799,
-0.3133116961,
0.8189294934,
0.3702434599,
0.6138907671,
0.5607972741,
0.6916931272,
0.2643408179,
0.2997665107,
-1.1959934235,
0.4003036022,
-0.1706545651,
-0.9452864528,
-0.3431901932,
-0.4973961115,
-0.7711219788,
0.2182712108,
-0.6388161778,
-0.5508804917,
-0.0907121599,
0.0380400196,
-0.7407638431,
0.3445451558,
-0.0062478427,
0.5721868277,
-0.4111811221,
-0.4656754434,
0.0384725481,
-0.103704147,
0.6193393469,
-0.1709869057,
0.4383065999,
-0.3863722682,
-0.2776996493,
0.8401902318,
-0.06224332,
0.4163096845,
0.2138683051,
-0.0079908855,
0.0843108445,
0.2974736392,
-0.170443356,
0.102042377,
-0.1073800474,
-0.0194607992,
0.2251882255,
-0.4936455488,
-0.6179224849,
0.4905977249,
-0.5691384673,
-0.6786715388,
-0.6388860345,
-0.4621133208,
-0.8138538003,
0.0684136227,
-0.1504588425,
0.3063309193,
-0.3611619174,
0.5748532414,
0.6356911063,
-0.3364526927,
0.2899380922,
0.5827537775,
0.0418231972,
-0.0370598063,
0.3590985239,
-0.1669732034,
-0.1045055613,
0.5333445668,
0.2294577807,
-0.7597064972,
-0.8889238834,
-0.1034006402,
0.2473669052,
-0.861371398,
-0.571749866,
-0.2601032853,
-0.1150079966,
-0.3118665218,
0.1232944801,
-0.409427762,
-0.1694720089,
0.0266623497,
-0.1608482599,
0.053965915,
0.9268865585,
0.1470094472,
0.2310821712,
-0.901956439,
0.5203129053,
0.2375712097,
0.7593404055,
-0.0093724066,
-1.0001516342,
-0.1127611995,
-0.1171061844,
-0.0838586763,
-0.6833820343,
0.2731219828,
0.4036533237,
0.9707818031,
0.2865501642,
0.0005538042,
0.7889422774,
-0.8256229162,
0.9704802632,
0.3713214695,
-1.1208018064,
0.366196692,
-0.280046761,
0.479929328,
0.8924655318,
0.6177588105,
-0.5355063677,
-0.1258115172,
-0.4283174574,
-0.6529451609,
0.5926311612,
-0.0707232505,
0.0774635375,
-0.0304462351,
0.5469779372,
0.1452769637,
0.2153246701,
-0.6381357908,
-0.0004196731,
0.1040410548,
-0.0207382012,
-0.1408076435,
-0.067272909,
-0.0669832379,
-0.3356262743,
0.6991114616,
-0.1027073339,
-0.1231394932,
-0.0011995146,
-0.2083114982,
0.0145756844,
0.1297770888,
0.3941529095,
0.7383269668,
-0.0501171574,
0.0711947456,
0.6508433223,
-0.1108794808,
0.071285367,
-0.2197159082,
0.0148743298,
-0.1430945545,
0.6781209111,
0.6637475491,
0.7089933157,
-0.9329678416,
0.4581918716,
0.0185584612,
-0.654085815,
0.1552842259,
0.0320339538,
0.1036409512,
0.5431630015,
0.4456010461,
-0.1455453783,
0.4080577195,
-0.8847359419,
0.3740590811,
0.6284999847,
-0.5233106613,
-0.1496538669,
0.9852008224,
0.2754894793,
-0.1260151863,
0.1466361433,
0.0071670869,
-0.8203032613,
0.3414195478,
0.1878124177,
0.4802900255,
0.1241308451,
0.3682645559,
0.672211349,
0.1288430244,
-0.272685647,
0.3233955204,
-0.1227257475,
-0.7548803687,
-0.7429566979,
-0.8789724112,
-0.4750565588,
0.2502273917,
-0.5365550518,
0.0332482569,
-0.4835574031,
-0.4405226111,
0.3105686307,
0.2374865115,
-1.1482690573,
0.4559983909,
0.8415222764,
1.2926927805,
-0.7093089223,
0.6798327565,
0.5456925631,
-0.5406598449,
-0.8339820504,
0.0338262841,
-0.0103083365,
-0.6728850603,
1.1660672426,
0.0547720753,
-0.178665027,
-0.2999906838,
-0.5654169917,
-0.4793036878,
0.9768710732,
0.0661833212,
-0.3615175486,
-0.0679583028,
0.3269965351,
0.5286422372,
-0.2109891623,
0.3857107162,
0.962690413,
0.4030798674,
0.3499619067,
-0.921399951,
-0.0836493745,
0.0973316506,
-0.2298900187,
-0.0086105876,
-0.6399428844,
0.4675920308,
0.0241294689,
0.0510700382,
0.171495229,
0.7679362893,
0.3938460052,
0.2460746318,
0.3345322907,
0.2473361492,
0.8512823582,
-0.1948554218,
0.85700804,
0.1581767499,
0.3268447518,
1.3671633005,
-0.586304903,
1.1655709743,
0.1589596272,
-0.4177747667,
0.2101059109,
0.4101471901,
0.1325563937,
0.1285694987,
0.4617432058,
-0.3582810163,
-0.892660737,
0.0597685166,
-0.2524174452,
1.1570007801,
0.1302988678,
-0.0728671625,
-0.3662662208,
-0.2301884294,
-0.0964885578,
0.3844104111,
-0.6328682303,
0.8851056695,
0.1332613081,
-0.7082105875,
0.2751232386,
-0.2219152898,
0.6074810028,
-0.6673733592,
-0.0651275292,
-0.0615690276,
0.0535547398,
0.1208214313,
-1.2798155546,
0.0865529031,
0.2721031904,
-0.0462284461,
-0.1615845263,
0.5048022866,
-0.4297034442,
-0.2324668318,
0.330275476,
0.6349933743,
0.2087671906,
-0.1862237155,
-1.0327105522,
0.1583283097,
-0.497456938,
-0.1989129186,
0.3907503188,
0.7260012627,
0.3018089533,
0.6881518364,
0.6193859577,
0.3170969188,
0.0144514292,
0.2387624383,
0.6232210398,
-0.6383565664,
-0.3695408404,
-0.8126642704,
0.2749103904,
-0.2933797836,
-0.6946033835,
0.6107330918,
0.7934080958,
0.4757675529,
-0.007151695,
0.6892423034,
0.2429143935,
0.4296417832,
-0.6340305805,
0.9357024431,
-0.6188080311,
0.1000243798,
0.0534675643,
-0.6797688007,
-0.5622876883,
0.5316548347,
-0.4791158438,
-0.0870921388,
0.4853506684,
0.038329836,
0.0821696445,
0.0695124418,
0.5161623955,
0.0613384508,
0.2516674995,
0.8045299053,
0.9768970013,
-0.5381968617,
0.6989693046,
0.1089166403,
-0.2782571018,
-0.0641813874,
-0.9749520421,
-1.2640317678,
-0.4954726398,
-0.2432434261,
-0.3802429736,
0.1925509572,
1.1752482653,
0.7178482413,
-0.8937888741,
-0.1663647443,
0.4280927777,
-0.1203561723,
-0.4633247256,
-0.1466433555,
0.2241510004,
-0.5286887884,
-0.7714860439,
0.5587459803,
0.2718358636,
-0.4350339472,
0.0247211196,
-0.2177546173,
-0.581089735,
0.3832258582,
1.0219641924,
0.6058624983,
-0.6771195531,
-0.382461071,
0.0780746713,
0.0552094281,
0.0084135933,
0.7056506276,
-1.0478345156,
0.3185380101,
0.5420792699,
0.9081070423,
0.4212035537,
0.0416718945,
0.5859236717,
-0.5338534117,
0.0094187791,
0.5046185851,
0.2107323706,
0.0583138019,
0.1251368523,
0.4946065247,
0.2112160176,
-0.2685467303,
-0.7888368964,
-0.0210775249,
-1.0044013262,
-0.418143481,
1.1969755888,
0.0698525384,
-0.1641156375,
-0.23859182,
-0.0788321421,
0.1390155852,
-0.1001504213,
0.701756537,
0.9496487379,
-0.0707946271,
-0.1424476951,
-0.798890233,
0.7898069024,
0.2461946011,
-0.7331883311,
0.0795242637,
0.3095641434,
0.0764871016,
-0.4450506568,
0.5898374915,
0.3366777897,
0.4266366661,
-0.0386008024,
-0.3690260351,
0.1811266094,
-0.3516592085,
-0.0265476014,
0.2963974476,
-0.0189227741,
0.0397786684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15861v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15861v4
|
MATHWELL: Generating Age-Appropriate Educational Math Word Problems
| 2024-02-24T17:08:45 | 2024-04-16T13:52:01 |
Bryan R Christ, Jonathan Kropko, Thomas Hartvigsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math word problems are critical K-8 educational tools, but writing them is
time-consuming and requires domain expertise. We suggest that language models
can support K-8 math education by automatically generating problems. To be
educational, generated problems must be 1) solvable, 2) accurate, and 3)
appropriate. Existing datasets are unlabeled for these criteria, making them
ill-suited for training problem generators. To address this gap, we use domain
expert annotation to curate a high-quality synthetic training dataset for this
task. We show the value of this data by using it to iteratively finetune
Llama-2 (70B) to create MATHWELL, a K-8 word problem generator. Domain experts
find MATHWELL has a 40% higher share of problems that have executable solutions
and meet all criteria than existing open-source models, with 74% of its
problems with executable solutions being solvable, accurate, and appropriate.
MATHWELL achieves 94.9% of GPT-4 Turbo's performance on this task while
outputting problems written at a more appropriate reading level for K-8
students. MATHWELL's performance despite being trained by finetuning only
highlights the quality of our synthetic data for training age-appropriate word
problem generators. We release our model, data, and annotations.
|
[
-0.1398876011,
-0.602858901,
0.3841206133,
0.1775020659,
0.0581449904,
0.021810919,
-0.013495204,
-0.2296616286,
-0.3287479579,
0.2728892267,
-0.6677924395,
-0.2442575097,
-0.6706798673,
0.244877845,
-0.267424494,
1.0717488527,
-0.2197476029,
-0.0409666486,
-0.4364120364,
0.1415341496,
-0.6002262235,
-0.3944977224,
-0.6069651246,
-0.5604431629,
0.1776420921,
0.4837379456,
0.7132872939,
0.7693094611,
0.4560602009,
0.3309186399,
0.2423201054,
0.3744989932,
-0.6549395919,
0.2016282976,
-0.072344698,
-0.3349446058,
-0.3911401033,
0.2347464561,
0.212126866,
0.8979880214,
-0.1344300359,
0.1253339052,
-0.1515066177,
0.624776721,
-0.4327557981,
0.4459662139,
-1.0159190893,
0.3465355337,
-0.3684830666,
-0.1667180806,
-0.084971115,
-0.5547881722,
-0.052818872,
-1.0812706947,
0.2997937799,
0.1765237153,
0.5560150743,
0.2753406465,
-0.144464165,
-0.706040144,
-0.4718342721,
0.821593523,
-0.7856953144,
0.2269821167,
0.6804640293,
0.3756019175,
-0.4573853016,
-0.5397363901,
-0.7629129291,
-0.0483566746,
0.269045651,
0.1535087675,
-0.140474543,
-0.3232535124,
0.5218866467,
0.4227825105,
-0.4845527709,
0.0101495972,
-0.8062336445,
-0.4659387171,
0.7584863901,
0.5534425974,
0.3814966977,
0.0045227748,
0.1189877763,
0.0653486624,
-0.8860177994,
-0.0077775861,
0.705352366,
0.2842691541,
0.3226271868,
0.7583273649,
-0.0568164103,
0.700784564,
-0.0510200933,
-0.2259982377,
0.1412888616,
0.0310622342,
-0.0265115723,
0.1016244739,
0.5213576555,
0.1840283126,
0.8027510643,
-0.1119122207,
-0.5850508213,
0.4854158461,
0.0839327946,
-0.7754976749,
-0.5655314922,
0.1117391065,
0.1981980354,
-0.496221602,
-0.2205912471,
-0.5392804742,
-0.4360727072,
-0.616961062,
0.607165575,
-0.4991428256,
-0.0774855614,
0.1583726555,
-0.2297327667,
-0.3476973772,
0.2189703435,
-0.8482287526,
0.0782415941,
0.545153439,
0.4347030222,
0.0677983537,
-0.2757000029,
-0.6533674002,
0.074793011,
-0.5209106207,
0.7640272975,
-0.714804709,
-0.5825716257,
0.1169186383,
-0.162221998,
-0.0273730159,
-0.7831271887,
0.1542417109,
-0.1997737885,
0.4402541816,
0.022093568,
-0.6962439418,
0.3288089335,
0.1983597726,
-0.4816603959,
1.028924346,
0.4692070186,
-0.5865373611,
0.152288869,
-0.5516005754,
-0.2300297916,
0.3783921599,
-0.2642142177,
-0.4567453563,
0.1243348941,
0.3710304201,
0.169801712,
-0.0362587944,
0.4888029993,
-0.012816431,
-0.1810703278,
0.1924171448,
-0.4174342155,
0.5966995358,
0.2435134202,
-0.4608740509,
-0.4006293118,
-0.8830307126,
0.3010321856,
0.3606497049,
-0.2463518083,
-0.2984198928,
-0.1210775748,
-0.2958365083,
-0.0449553877,
0.3033850491,
-0.632451117,
0.2689007521,
-0.5499219894,
0.333729893,
0.75944525,
-0.085429661,
0.1890218109,
-0.4883107245,
0.6635348201,
0.0709610656,
-0.0796804503,
-0.1181167513,
-0.7187364697,
-0.7525393963,
0.1654398143,
0.2246130258,
0.645201087,
-0.9218643308,
0.2192426622,
-0.1610388458,
-0.6514750719,
-0.5544520617,
0.3248739839,
0.4523039758,
0.7878399491,
0.3224473596,
-0.0200491939,
-0.3255396187,
-0.7895636559,
-0.3559364974,
0.1693924963,
0.0261022653,
0.3920305967,
0.4458600879,
-0.241799891,
1.0906450748,
-0.7412653565,
-0.49014166,
0.0902918428,
0.4654451907,
0.0577284172,
0.4297836125,
0.3029561341,
-0.4567681253,
-0.4372434914,
0.0536000691,
-0.6833966374,
-0.6895904541,
0.1373848617,
-0.1967774034,
0.0513427854,
-0.0163188279,
-0.5107831955,
0.6213843226,
0.2483308613,
-0.2714107037,
0.5900120735,
-0.177098304,
-0.0862040296,
-0.9349094629,
0.0496084876,
-0.0304519553,
-0.0638615191,
-0.4737321138,
0.0382252671,
-0.1682218313,
-0.8036635518,
-0.1448797882,
0.4904274344,
-0.2975366414,
0.2127449363,
-0.2826848924,
0.3107825816,
0.0557945408,
0.1909952015,
-0.2060829252,
1.0491900444,
0.1793039888,
-0.4859837294,
0.6134482622,
0.2054137439,
-0.2864025533,
0.5783523321,
-0.6099110246,
0.270617336,
-0.1652813405,
0.0273113586,
-0.5814305544,
-0.2877891958,
0.2117223144,
-0.6276878119,
0.0953608677,
0.2703490555,
-0.1506650448,
-0.4845989048,
-0.2312443256,
0.3095529675,
0.5351554155,
-0.3468022943,
0.1702776253,
0.4877353311,
-0.4290810823,
-0.5266122222,
-0.5558450818,
-0.1362773925,
0.0687532425,
-0.4401819706,
0.0555530116,
-0.2617782056,
-0.2401584238,
0.4478133619,
-0.2601796091,
-0.3767981827,
-0.0622775629,
0.1807580739,
0.1956380755,
-0.0548142716,
0.1539152861,
0.2145338207,
-0.2743964493,
0.2101775557,
-0.199878782,
0.155107215,
0.0976689756,
-0.1611570418,
0.1307438761,
0.5260055661,
0.2552897632,
-0.2374759167,
0.213637948,
0.440182507,
-0.8125950098,
-0.683879137,
-0.1632775664,
-0.1015089005,
-0.4578810334,
0.2147825807,
-0.2652837038,
-0.845143199,
0.2452799231,
-0.0079155564,
0.4786421657,
0.5862298608,
0.5167056322,
0.0693117231,
1.1115849018,
0.3496496677,
0.1626493037,
-0.0238177683,
-0.4631947577,
0.4548383951,
-0.4260766506,
-0.416048646,
-0.4116990268,
-0.2101390809,
-0.3040975928,
-0.1948179901,
0.391051352,
0.0657808632,
-0.2736800611,
0.376840055,
-0.839157939,
0.5249837041,
0.4249626696,
-0.293758899,
0.1798466444,
0.373295486,
-0.2189971805,
-0.5219488144,
-0.6296415329,
-0.4002852738,
0.9217864871,
-0.0468692258,
0.8050481677,
0.1345736831,
0.6596045494,
0.3201023936,
0.6547502875,
-0.9075103402,
0.421793133,
-0.2067579329,
-0.9148896337,
-0.3747084439,
-0.6442195773,
-1.10151124,
-0.2162391543,
-0.2325437069,
-0.5153109431,
-0.1442325711,
0.2916589975,
-0.4037070274,
-0.0059836311,
-0.7049021125,
0.5790093541,
0.0074123507,
-0.2985624969,
-0.1405960768,
-0.159378022,
0.3937672973,
-0.5303791761,
0.4303326607,
-0.4528887868,
0.2385134399,
0.7432573438,
-0.988869369,
0.7506340146,
-0.3421227932,
-0.4014385641,
0.6672230363,
0.3801353574,
0.3431247175,
-0.1185993031,
0.0291385353,
-0.2143345773,
0.0655099899,
-0.1290539354,
-0.8153740168,
0.9451797605,
-0.9319865704,
-0.8285323977,
-0.5998107195,
-0.7515771985,
-0.340947628,
0.2383254468,
0.206826359,
1.0007101297,
0.4623237848,
-0.0205312502,
0.5261184573,
-0.0018390282,
0.3527310491,
0.3303563297,
-0.2055222839,
-0.7220898867,
1.5121158361,
0.7295346856,
-0.0890941024,
-0.0987627581,
0.4923140407,
-0.2711034417,
-0.1110042557,
-0.6400210857,
0.0185002256,
-0.8458100557,
-0.59964329,
-0.1717352569,
-0.649184525,
-0.4331254661,
-0.3761366606,
-0.0586929061,
-0.574424684,
-0.2759857178,
0.0743928105,
0.5241602659,
0.8976339698,
-0.1462287009,
0.3624682128,
-0.8772869706,
0.2187846303,
0.6780724525,
0.1955007762,
-0.0985785276,
-0.5488000512,
-0.1395681798,
0.1411842555,
-0.7368503809,
-0.6887222528,
0.3793179989,
0.5686554313,
0.4029141963,
0.0990871191,
0.0774286836,
0.7098327279,
-0.7739182711,
0.8627858758,
0.084268041,
-1.0066461563,
0.5597832799,
-0.3079977036,
0.3014605939,
0.2463498414,
0.4437659681,
-0.4078720212,
-0.2912825346,
-0.6843687296,
-0.7821326256,
0.4562944174,
0.3737867177,
0.4128933549,
-0.0733821914,
0.3626836836,
0.4119557738,
0.2937974036,
-0.4287252724,
-0.0360308699,
-0.5133132339,
-0.7619971633,
0.3368941247,
-0.0384529233,
-0.1075103581,
-0.2554315925,
0.8255034685,
-0.1260749847,
0.2891828716,
-0.0919920132,
-0.0626882762,
-0.4615879059,
0.0766480193,
0.6528868675,
0.9529290795,
0.1392506957,
0.1842888445,
-0.0139242709,
-0.8306481242,
0.3170868456,
0.4253594279,
-0.074895829,
-0.094721131,
0.4231177568,
0.6479299068,
0.0161020979,
-0.740002811,
0.5113167763,
0.1111072004,
-0.5289748311,
-0.472797513,
0.3710001707,
-0.0646301508,
-0.0472205579,
0.4385693669,
-0.1810210794,
0.0240266938,
-0.1256187856,
0.1238753572,
0.2697176933,
0.0026793052,
-0.4234597087,
0.803976059,
0.3352641165,
-0.679797411,
0.9066793323,
-0.2420624346,
-0.5767148733,
0.6185073853,
0.9884414673,
0.4970285296,
-0.2461121827,
0.1723993868,
0.392173171,
0.1377156675,
0.2371287942,
0.5898965001,
0.1283223629,
-0.7777534723,
-0.4612776935,
-0.3858954012,
-0.459961772,
0.3867362142,
-0.5071689487,
0.1491207182,
-0.5975740552,
-0.3137941658,
0.0283099469,
0.2471180856,
-0.8723792434,
0.6559198499,
0.0590160415,
0.720084846,
-0.8292458653,
0.363748461,
0.8540574908,
-0.1121312678,
-1.0632721186,
-0.449665606,
-0.0894289762,
-1.1221352816,
0.5617849827,
0.3202465773,
-0.0346271805,
0.4628200531,
-0.8680096865,
-0.565779984,
0.9362069368,
0.2414771765,
-0.6417530775,
0.1240167022,
0.4726619124,
0.3142740428,
-0.2807723582,
-0.0241608322,
0.2872655988,
0.43852368,
0.0008344011,
-0.6469780207,
-0.2679591477,
-0.621499598,
0.0114237824,
0.2383725196,
-0.251472801,
0.7061203718,
-0.2377041429,
-0.1329672039,
-0.1056233197,
0.6202884912,
0.6401138902,
0.64464432,
0.3612555563,
0.9405714869,
0.7670384645,
-0.1953651607,
0.6733319759,
-0.4655128419,
0.2559707761,
0.6765521765,
0.0276616216,
0.4936842322,
0.2085279524,
-0.2032533884,
0.1940527111,
0.6192063689,
0.0052526253,
0.4514392316,
0.5708466172,
-0.2585596442,
-0.384436816,
-0.2331659049,
-0.5562157035,
0.2811627686,
0.5087432265,
0.0143828839,
-0.3833986819,
-0.1495637745,
0.2249208987,
0.2501645982,
-0.368545413,
0.2698741257,
0.4361304641,
-0.4058704674,
0.3990882933,
-0.0119564096,
0.3827164769,
-0.5028108954,
-0.3435164988,
-0.4377356768,
0.110777013,
-0.2078964412,
-0.7717970014,
0.1089135036,
0.2336318344,
-0.1351920366,
0.1078407392,
0.7729543447,
-0.7816717625,
-0.8953202963,
-0.6653218865,
0.5121486187,
0.2701378167,
0.4000172019,
-0.4294497073,
-0.0392273702,
-0.2873090804,
-0.1508595794,
0.114837043,
0.7996938229,
-0.1192260459,
0.5636998415,
0.6990317702,
0.3328953683,
0.1540919691,
-0.0419110097,
0.7611828446,
-0.276396513,
-0.2279257029,
-0.5598137975,
0.5264758468,
-0.048138313,
-0.7661402225,
0.664606154,
0.3423393369,
0.7866727114,
-0.1281064749,
1.0494976044,
0.1136939973,
0.3430603743,
-0.2281638384,
0.6166481376,
-0.4371072948,
-0.1869876683,
-0.0707384497,
-1.0627689362,
-0.1470529586,
0.8563021421,
-0.3635352552,
0.1620098799,
0.5386018157,
0.6225914359,
0.0503955781,
0.1648979038,
0.3239970207,
-0.2672353387,
0.445443809,
0.8228036165,
0.833764255,
-0.4654135704,
0.3297764659,
-0.4605043828,
-0.2206189334,
0.1455603987,
-0.8642508984,
-0.8548699617,
-0.4075582623,
-0.2590313256,
-0.2501024604,
-0.0934152752,
0.9940875769,
0.2689468861,
-0.7005363107,
0.0618137494,
-0.0411871858,
-0.1775627732,
0.1894801259,
-0.2447073311,
0.2142870128,
-0.4358274937,
-0.751018405,
0.3455269635,
-0.1077051759,
0.2002081573,
-0.4752929211,
0.1985263526,
0.6451149583,
0.3273890615,
0.4154393673,
0.2007357478,
-0.3898337781,
-0.4675178528,
0.0849738643,
-0.1161277741,
-0.376476258,
0.7937058806,
-0.6326480508,
0.6564328671,
0.2681084573,
1.0078718662,
-0.0546109378,
-0.0425853617,
0.5204339027,
-0.5836904049,
-0.0250995439,
0.2674582601,
0.078316167,
0.5715717673,
-0.4980606139,
0.4360468984,
0.7739223242,
-0.6353642941,
-0.8224585652,
0.0886355266,
-0.0917974859,
0.0626102313,
1.0834027529,
-0.0771026313,
-0.2062848508,
0.0639330819,
-0.2499570251,
0.1767435819,
-0.2398709506,
0.9399093986,
0.8214295506,
0.0452636853,
0.099979423,
-0.5994474292,
0.5132524371,
0.3282965422,
-0.7051262856,
-0.0996482149,
0.5524277687,
0.2340010554,
0.0793010294,
0.4812681973,
0.0942190215,
0.2063843757,
0.2802313864,
0.0126967793,
-0.6112528443,
-0.4138560593,
0.2500818968,
0.0493593477,
0.1025943458,
0.1208380237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15833v1
|
Prompt Perturbation Consistency Learning for Robust Language Models
| 2024-02-24T15:00:58 | 2024-02-24T15:00:58 |
Yao Qiang, Subhrangshu Nandi, Ninareh Mehrabi, Greg Ver Steeg, Anoop Kumar, Anna Rumshisky, Aram Galstyan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on a
number of natural language processing tasks, such as question answering and
text summarization. However, their performance on sequence labeling tasks such
as intent classification and slot filling (IC-SF), which is a central component
in personal assistant systems, lags significantly behind discriminative models.
Furthermore, there is a lack of substantive research on the robustness of LLMs
to various perturbations in the input prompts. The contributions of this paper
are three-fold. First, we show that fine-tuning sufficiently large LLMs can
produce IC-SF performance comparable to discriminative models. Next, we
systematically analyze the performance deterioration of those fine-tuned models
due to three distinct yet relevant types of input perturbations - oronyms,
synonyms, and paraphrasing. Finally, we propose an efficient mitigation
approach, Prompt Perturbation Consistency Learning (PPCL), which works by
regularizing the divergence between losses from clean and perturbed samples.
Our experiments demonstrate that PPCL can recover on average 59% and 69% of the
performance drop for IC and SF tasks, respectively. Furthermore, PPCL beats the
data augmentation approach while using ten times fewer augmented data samples.
|
[
-0.2852801979,
-0.933206737,
0.7289944887,
0.1663217396,
0.0031766191,
0.0317439102,
-0.4145113826,
0.0585246645,
-0.3325394094,
0.5682168603,
-0.5125334263,
-0.6104266047,
-0.5919651985,
0.3765767515,
-0.0579876415,
0.7500283122,
0.0135148708,
-0.0611242987,
-0.2161114961,
0.0181431733,
-0.6598704457,
-0.5881953835,
-0.7287345529,
-0.1564678252,
0.443505317,
0.6377126575,
0.7203202248,
0.7355518937,
0.1163204312,
0.3316587508,
-0.2916307747,
0.3140345514,
-0.4389542937,
0.5433910489,
0.0811992362,
-0.337999016,
-0.2628650367,
-0.1094563529,
0.8681387305,
0.9048497081,
-0.1496106237,
-0.2942277193,
0.6332584023,
0.3192977607,
-0.6442267299,
0.1149992272,
-0.7250003815,
-0.1366060227,
-0.2663829625,
-0.1184134856,
-0.5285536051,
-0.1876996011,
0.0125234025,
-0.5751442909,
0.1375902891,
-0.1068154424,
0.8701982498,
0.5013232827,
-0.0808250755,
-0.0400572084,
-0.6496250033,
0.8948554397,
-0.8042007685,
0.4202084839,
0.6884037256,
-0.0302492362,
-0.582508564,
-0.4195965827,
-0.595713079,
-0.4129388928,
-0.0235443003,
-0.2946080863,
-0.0368697792,
0.3394602835,
0.5016726255,
0.163166821,
-0.4576734602,
0.4967446923,
0.4598700702,
-0.4847044051,
0.1824252158,
0.3414971828,
0.1474883109,
0.115083985,
-0.2570677996,
-0.2904984653,
-0.7907596827,
0.436668247,
0.5830618143,
0.5080257654,
0.0136484578,
0.4082961082,
-0.1456631422,
0.8291028738,
0.4130196571,
-0.4321584404,
0.0947198346,
-0.4557382464,
-0.1645652652,
-0.1946995556,
0.7909588814,
-0.2285043597,
0.1315807849,
-0.0431228019,
-0.3169776499,
-0.2520035505,
-0.1320122778,
-0.4670654535,
-0.3692562282,
0.0602760576,
-0.0441047959,
-0.0240392815,
0.0055531403,
-0.4864153564,
-0.4833123088,
-0.3766022623,
0.2535246015,
-0.4217908978,
0.2248408496,
0.1342218965,
0.3753576279,
0.1589319557,
0.5995116234,
-0.9612148404,
0.3665135205,
0.6124107242,
0.6543729305,
-0.2427072376,
-0.3269059658,
-0.9766162634,
-0.0184704121,
-0.1834351569,
0.805908978,
-0.6072585583,
-0.4447553754,
0.0631932542,
-0.0117876232,
-0.1020953134,
-0.7051575184,
0.5605756044,
-0.3751047552,
0.2060078681,
-0.4899133742,
-0.5644947886,
0.1443647593,
0.2984256446,
-0.4710595608,
0.9051733613,
-0.0353514813,
-0.7462514639,
0.2414104044,
-0.1888483316,
-0.5007608533,
-0.1013705283,
-0.1414960176,
-0.6710600257,
-0.0228145961,
0.2325351238,
0.6028470993,
0.0114958156,
0.3307030201,
-0.4595986009,
-0.4508011043,
0.2143751532,
-0.5184520483,
0.6383560896,
-0.0273666661,
-0.1220710278,
0.3334467709,
-0.8256907463,
-0.456689626,
-0.2415556461,
-0.651131928,
-0.2506556213,
0.1064967886,
-0.2576133907,
0.1075667441,
0.2854317129,
-0.5022290945,
0.2358123958,
-0.3763554394,
0.1742139906,
0.979724586,
0.058969941,
0.2837288976,
-0.3331036866,
0.4404446185,
0.093613185,
-0.0663468987,
-0.6102619171,
-0.3052101731,
-0.5398852229,
-0.4347203076,
0.3580108285,
0.5811898708,
-0.6761418581,
0.7325550914,
0.0369346254,
-0.1007721797,
-0.2288331836,
0.5080083013,
0.4428874552,
1.0308307409,
0.3685030341,
-0.1939469725,
-0.4570809603,
-0.6646162868,
-0.2684538662,
-0.2397399247,
-0.3071184158,
0.1605185866,
-0.1052375436,
-0.1550812721,
0.8682544231,
-0.1616214812,
-0.3126495481,
-0.1659323722,
0.1557225734,
0.239966765,
0.5266396403,
0.1406926215,
-0.5053755641,
-0.6205019951,
-0.2330129296,
-0.2457633018,
-0.3505341709,
-0.2340486795,
0.3189044595,
0.2544390857,
0.5280694962,
-0.2992750406,
0.2380344272,
0.4916783273,
-0.275967896,
0.7248031497,
-0.1646395475,
-0.0697631389,
-0.8742049336,
0.0533953905,
0.2218498588,
-0.4727700353,
-0.686187923,
-0.5310934186,
-0.0551291071,
0.0865297988,
-0.3255544901,
0.5439052582,
-0.3750801086,
0.1434595436,
-0.2892337143,
0.0188607965,
-0.0472870059,
0.4649002552,
-0.1314034164,
0.8411843181,
0.5859831572,
-0.9180671573,
-0.063458994,
0.4062708318,
0.0524941124,
0.258449316,
-0.7372075915,
0.2116653174,
-0.2123349607,
0.1095266566,
-1.505094409,
-0.4257524908,
0.1787084192,
-0.4661261439,
0.5942915678,
0.0173018631,
-0.6319861412,
0.0831794068,
-0.4317915142,
0.1625004709,
0.4690447152,
-0.6257069707,
0.5585782528,
0.2178434581,
-0.2528499663,
-0.6460192204,
-0.3410901129,
-0.1210997924,
-0.1064654887,
-0.4438481927,
0.2996382117,
-0.0542967133,
-0.0861555561,
-0.3654484451,
-0.1162172109,
0.1159708574,
0.5207963586,
0.1588627398,
0.1915740073,
-0.0470294878,
0.13324821,
0.1072522923,
-0.0211840235,
-0.1887616366,
-0.0488355756,
0.7260767221,
-0.0204051528,
-0.2214224935,
-0.8052198887,
0.0866236761,
0.4472236931,
-0.0468548462,
0.6536980271,
0.5154793859,
-0.3527919948,
0.0336174741,
-0.6801526546,
-0.3914494812,
-0.5251620412,
0.2483956367,
-0.4293939173,
-1.0672780275,
0.6823320985,
0.032612469,
0.1673544943,
0.2712687552,
0.4889501035,
-0.1834586263,
1.1801269054,
0.7712549567,
-0.1406162977,
0.6966935396,
0.2007814199,
-0.0793577433,
-0.7578867078,
-0.1634635031,
-0.6612526774,
-0.0588928647,
-0.3418230712,
-0.0548997,
0.413872242,
0.2112481892,
-0.3448382914,
0.1227255836,
-0.1115848869,
0.2619817853,
0.4656599164,
0.0951128304,
0.2739131749,
0.0888137445,
-0.307842046,
-0.1632384956,
-0.6044802666,
-0.7034640312,
0.8220560551,
0.4715664089,
0.8743697405,
-0.1024870053,
0.4925736785,
0.1469120234,
-0.0462654792,
-0.5072078109,
0.5255973935,
-0.2851000428,
0.0604095943,
-0.3581132293,
-0.3309383094,
-1.0313376188,
-0.0538008958,
-0.2445224822,
-0.8549319506,
0.3043547869,
0.6066912413,
-0.5647401214,
0.1808226556,
-0.4449546933,
0.6382283568,
0.0101681985,
-0.581820488,
0.2069762349,
-0.7106764913,
0.2703901529,
0.0735412836,
-0.1705254614,
-0.0645254403,
-0.2628237307,
0.4626871645,
-0.2212968022,
0.975563705,
-0.2393410653,
-0.2832273543,
-0.0089326072,
0.1253643036,
0.7528201938,
0.1890641153,
-0.0045287227,
-0.0226958562,
-0.3095728755,
-0.4693741798,
-0.5401645303,
0.716832459,
-0.6364367008,
-0.7012335658,
-0.1661705375,
-0.5082216859,
-0.6738151908,
0.1131558791,
0.4252592027,
0.4704151452,
0.153174147,
0.1972483993,
1.3238456249,
-0.2867040634,
0.5550018549,
0.3392374218,
0.0592674874,
-0.3660337925,
0.6486107111,
0.0382065661,
0.1227729619,
0.4742497504,
0.2550806999,
-0.4074193835,
-0.7412560582,
-0.1405344158,
0.2648586631,
-0.4601214826,
-0.2796131968,
-0.7132822871,
0.1810170561,
-0.5770709515,
-0.0320839547,
-0.2341225892,
-0.0793377981,
-0.7057468295,
0.217429474,
0.0756645203,
0.4664565921,
0.2302124947,
0.4488889575,
-0.6960678697,
0.103111729,
0.2237738818,
0.3627100289,
-0.2171246707,
-0.7215645909,
0.0669609904,
-0.1322009116,
-0.4208208621,
-0.9693607092,
0.2079880238,
0.2441829145,
0.6544651389,
0.6354136467,
0.1021744311,
0.6020396948,
-0.333642751,
0.9374964833,
0.0365840197,
-0.9478217959,
0.4501535594,
-0.5030575991,
0.6288635731,
0.7068224549,
0.4842083752,
-0.336807251,
-0.3864940107,
-0.443757683,
-0.9050523043,
0.4768640399,
-0.2683790326,
0.0434569605,
-0.097322382,
0.5259782076,
0.2469197661,
0.1836098731,
-0.4779313803,
-0.095948413,
0.0702617913,
-0.4089757502,
-0.2425986826,
-0.4793031216,
0.2223654687,
-0.1078521609,
0.6282717586,
-0.2909869254,
0.0582920015,
0.282772243,
-0.1206989586,
-0.028308522,
0.2551504076,
0.7813466787,
0.3869117796,
0.0509808734,
0.1920052171,
0.1834488958,
-0.3423602581,
0.1857028753,
0.1126376465,
-0.3318449259,
-0.1262932867,
0.2455312163,
0.7694448233,
0.1988019049,
-0.8546692133,
0.3686098158,
-0.1193975061,
0.0150047783,
-0.1346728206,
0.128389135,
-0.4002256393,
-0.0686272159,
0.3375511765,
0.1365811378,
0.1755106002,
-0.3689191043,
0.2237725258,
0.5223503709,
-0.3991075158,
-0.5339438915,
0.6323043108,
-0.1004220471,
-0.2496013343,
0.5561625361,
-0.0886314213,
-0.5443042517,
0.1645223945,
0.5384840965,
0.8135171533,
-0.4426615238,
-0.0265312307,
0.3663849235,
0.0369203761,
-0.3150418699,
0.1408508569,
-0.273375988,
-0.5456030369,
-0.6040614247,
-0.5486503243,
-0.4215630591,
0.4324314892,
-0.3640114069,
0.2985351086,
-0.7984465361,
-0.1389549077,
-0.3245908618,
0.0802448019,
-0.4715805054,
-0.061565537,
0.0634031519,
0.7171103358,
-0.7860743999,
0.8228443861,
0.8208819628,
-0.1054782569,
-0.9385364652,
0.3264865279,
-0.0447801016,
-0.283085376,
0.3021959364,
0.0797602087,
-0.1088791862,
-0.0188440531,
-0.6123951077,
-0.9542343616,
0.6872912049,
0.7212461233,
-0.6611494422,
-0.0303391162,
-0.1637995839,
0.4598226547,
-0.1930298954,
0.0041718255,
0.5517117977,
0.4668566883,
-0.0394319929,
-0.983471632,
0.0745391473,
0.0715758204,
0.2263385803,
-0.0242207777,
-0.3795545697,
0.9178816676,
-0.123744607,
-0.3030857742,
0.4153850675,
0.7432364821,
0.4244228005,
0.0296413302,
0.5338612199,
0.4134162068,
0.9728687406,
-0.2467252165,
1.0368317366,
-0.0818052143,
0.206522271,
1.1539297104,
-0.3331011832,
0.7793293595,
0.5517228246,
-0.1517372429,
0.3514142036,
0.7532513142,
0.1622802913,
0.3809198141,
0.1087563038,
-0.27180323,
-0.3051479757,
-0.0800043866,
0.0946923196,
0.2522771657,
0.3539851606,
-0.1130339801,
-0.1349186599,
0.2104903907,
0.0640267506,
0.5076476932,
-0.2718220651,
0.9574394822,
-0.2710601091,
-0.8623181581,
0.7071159482,
-0.0142788785,
0.8423017859,
-0.5151634812,
-0.1617988646,
-0.2918314636,
0.1829987615,
-0.1287235469,
-0.5455468297,
0.1191305071,
-0.2799326777,
-0.2659940124,
-0.1283034831,
0.7571690083,
-0.5925431848,
-0.020165015,
-0.1622967124,
0.1088471338,
-0.1679466665,
0.1075863987,
-0.4306364655,
0.3173532784,
-0.0634078607,
-0.1886345148,
0.513174355,
0.173762098,
0.0021524879,
0.7238450646,
0.5042882562,
0.0358304121,
0.2235665023,
-0.2341818362,
0.8343723416,
-0.1590641737,
-0.3519456983,
-0.9819220901,
0.3869790137,
0.0928761214,
-0.3269208968,
0.9498034716,
0.2935962677,
0.8624192476,
-0.0608803295,
0.5892474055,
0.3362922072,
0.6101722121,
-0.6377849579,
0.2353031337,
-0.1789503843,
0.6431437135,
-0.2312004119,
-0.7770741582,
-0.5859754086,
0.4738180637,
-0.2768859863,
0.0802033916,
0.2270724922,
0.6612417102,
0.0994981378,
-0.3654054701,
0.5429706573,
0.3155988753,
0.4297609329,
0.304323554,
0.7684150338,
-0.1914302409,
0.2915185988,
-0.1835139692,
-0.2431578636,
-0.2096207887,
-0.7910850644,
-0.7792918086,
-0.627400279,
-0.4584704936,
-0.5310567617,
0.1739693582,
1.0011935234,
0.613804996,
-0.9579676986,
-0.0828232318,
-0.2676045001,
0.3339013457,
-0.1976079345,
-0.2363612205,
0.2551577985,
-0.899679184,
-0.8238555193,
0.4338989854,
0.2541357875,
0.1814400703,
-0.2258541286,
-0.1654273868,
-0.1955628544,
0.0019415258,
0.3609560132,
0.6047481298,
-0.7978916168,
-0.2119324803,
0.1817337275,
-0.0411020033,
0.210745126,
0.7211021185,
-0.9208201766,
0.3779515922,
0.5736851096,
0.9899384975,
-0.0584165454,
0.338866204,
0.5972092152,
-1.1206475496,
-0.0495404154,
0.361258775,
0.5229944587,
0.5153758526,
-0.570407927,
-0.0602055006,
0.1412946284,
-0.7452147007,
-0.9162454009,
0.3538844287,
-0.915358305,
-0.1226041764,
1.2516194582,
-0.3531940877,
-0.1368367821,
-0.3669457436,
-0.3100983799,
0.1440437138,
-0.5274549127,
0.7103229761,
0.5512791276,
-0.37105757,
-0.2561193705,
-0.0072366395,
0.6833336949,
0.6683700085,
-0.5213240385,
0.1817915589,
0.6067308784,
0.4541516006,
0.0992914811,
0.4534502327,
-0.0068639508,
0.3160968423,
-0.4807120562,
-0.2521567643,
-0.229485184,
-0.568790257,
-0.805614233,
0.4121760428,
0.4886743426,
-0.1075845137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00808v1
|
IPED: An Implicit Perspective for Relational Triple Extraction based on Diffusion Model
| 2024-02-24T14:18:11 | 2024-02-24T14:18:11 |
Jianli Zhao, Changhao Xu, Bin Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Relational triple extraction is a fundamental task in the field of
information extraction, and a promising framework based on table filling has
recently gained attention as a potential baseline for entity relation
extraction. However, inherent shortcomings such as redundant information and
incomplete triple recognition remain problematic. To address these challenges,
we propose an Implicit Perspective for relational triple Extraction based on
Diffusion model (IPED), an innovative approach for extracting relational
triples. Our classifier-free solution adopts an implicit strategy using block
coverage to complete the tables, avoiding the limitations of explicit tagging
methods. Additionally, we introduce a generative model structure, the
block-denoising diffusion model, to collaborate with our implicit perspective
and effectively circumvent redundant information disruptions. Experimental
results on two popular datasets demonstrate that IPED achieves state-of-the-art
performance while gaining superior inference speed and low computational
complexity. To support future research, we have made our source code publicly
available online.
|
[
-0.3964954913,
-0.860984683,
0.76535815,
0.5280600786,
-0.2114833891,
-0.0097485911,
0.4898026288,
-0.4940578341,
-0.1055082381,
0.4404013455,
-0.180493921,
-0.6250329614,
-0.6855144501,
-0.0621781759,
-0.5190702081,
0.9820641875,
-0.3493373692,
-0.1444055438,
-0.291733712,
0.0565251447,
-0.4180421531,
0.1884779632,
-0.6810054779,
-0.2664126158,
0.2509205341,
0.4356215298,
0.2195509076,
0.7389387488,
0.1541406661,
0.1305902749,
0.0255172569,
0.1345174164,
-0.3888021111,
0.2448901981,
0.015830677,
-0.0807478875,
-0.7382660508,
0.1511559039,
0.9194890261,
0.8586004376,
-0.2442651838,
0.0606976971,
0.0453373715,
0.9203227758,
-0.7553634048,
0.6015571952,
-0.6694751382,
0.2364721149,
-0.1489812434,
0.1838536114,
-0.2614221275,
-0.5473154187,
0.250197202,
-0.696357131,
0.2004026026,
0.0261894614,
0.6440809369,
0.0047971485,
-0.5309377313,
0.1605248302,
-1.0162100792,
0.1144091636,
-0.1300134212,
0.1136929989,
0.0753549859,
0.0273515899,
-0.085913308,
-0.635227859,
-0.7459170222,
0.009476617,
-0.0049120877,
0.0325228274,
-0.2906594574,
-0.0753379613,
0.3089597821,
0.3878798187,
-0.0975915641,
-0.2806769311,
-0.2945195735,
0.4234269857,
0.4830263555,
-0.2735315263,
0.2814210653,
-0.0229193456,
-0.547793746,
0.3633118272,
-0.9228236675,
-0.4565617144,
0.2491749823,
0.1109890714,
-0.0389436632,
0.4581475854,
-0.2005850971,
0.6573905945,
0.066747278,
0.0865678564,
0.141195178,
-0.04637824,
-0.1206363291,
-0.0077835461,
0.8382703662,
0.2093323916,
0.1350641102,
-0.2946429551,
0.0100153135,
-0.4065763056,
0.0016382227,
-0.7959833145,
-0.3436618149,
0.4548307657,
-0.2261284143,
-0.3303751647,
0.2464948893,
-1.1797513962,
-0.4571949542,
0.0547853224,
0.2421698421,
-0.2360856384,
-0.9827330112,
-0.1144347042,
-0.3829883039,
-0.0942170769,
0.3833951354,
-0.7020479441,
0.645067513,
0.7303703427,
1.2618457079,
-0.589810133,
0.0453338549,
-0.4194439054,
0.9314075112,
-0.1940052211,
0.7428010106,
-0.3696480393,
-0.5787109137,
-0.2193100452,
-0.4014561474,
0.1158567294,
-0.5589373112,
-0.0038668383,
-0.7437271476,
0.0522796735,
-0.0068319007,
-0.4591193497,
-0.2464735657,
0.1843033582,
-1.2006511688,
1.1350362301,
0.0777537674,
-0.9465479851,
0.473769486,
-0.8964810967,
-0.2698548734,
0.3868928552,
-0.1809429526,
-0.6526254416,
-0.1193881333,
0.170363158,
0.405425787,
-0.2525477409,
0.4715499282,
-0.6177328229,
-0.3710832298,
-0.2181283236,
-0.0548306778,
0.7768087387,
-0.0937792286,
-0.5447869897,
-0.1051913351,
-0.8440679312,
-0.2141797245,
0.2297265679,
-0.0829508975,
-0.489051044,
0.1296615899,
-0.3772048354,
0.2275379151,
-0.2248903066,
-0.6376544237,
0.424061656,
-0.2453036606,
0.03499268,
0.6710152626,
0.5460061431,
0.6214801669,
-0.0050741183,
0.3388293386,
0.356130451,
-0.0678136349,
0.3218265474,
-0.6306273937,
-0.4876325727,
-0.7362905741,
0.5307185054,
0.5304681063,
-0.7026081085,
0.057315249,
-0.6086760759,
-0.2310946435,
-0.2649132907,
0.0144902151,
0.2640544772,
0.6248051524,
0.5237258673,
0.0452993251,
-0.3374154568,
-0.9032235146,
-0.1362633258,
-0.1171360984,
-0.001780998,
0.3668090999,
0.6554396152,
-0.056146685,
0.959703207,
-0.7864558697,
-0.3616222739,
-0.13857539,
0.3561524451,
0.1520493329,
0.7337322831,
0.0888809487,
-1.0130399466,
-0.8154094219,
-0.0001086514,
-0.8024663329,
-0.183485195,
0.200019747,
-0.3376208842,
-0.0697570592,
0.2996029854,
-0.716619432,
0.5712333918,
-0.022157412,
0.0563562587,
0.1868092716,
0.197831735,
-0.1952254921,
-0.7788767219,
0.1481059641,
0.071283035,
-0.2736539841,
-0.7702153921,
0.0477572344,
0.2259163707,
0.0135091133,
-0.3804413676,
0.5745487213,
-0.9297372103,
-0.1761122942,
-0.0612134747,
0.2800135612,
0.1062079072,
0.3253039718,
0.2581406236,
0.5343188643,
0.4721653759,
-0.7026623487,
0.2233622968,
0.1634145677,
-0.0970802903,
0.7799800634,
-0.5118896961,
0.1762118042,
-0.3573139906,
0.2957035899,
-0.7295999527,
-0.0963671654,
0.7565764785,
0.0722623095,
0.6107706428,
-0.6455437541,
-0.3808790147,
-0.2773599625,
-0.3413490951,
0.4686564505,
0.2465185225,
-0.6830572486,
0.8101109862,
0.7065446973,
-0.2881815135,
-0.7745491862,
-0.2501218021,
-0.198045522,
-0.2612943649,
-0.4290255308,
0.8462466598,
0.0783677623,
-0.4626162052,
0.4371568263,
-0.4821332395,
-0.4615751505,
0.052919738,
0.4430629611,
0.4132781327,
0.0795672983,
0.0761652365,
0.0555986091,
-0.0804895759,
0.2019035518,
-0.4259828329,
0.3303701282,
-0.1502352208,
-0.1717117578,
-0.419875145,
0.7424228787,
0.2831944525,
0.1011353061,
0.886334002,
0.3950653076,
-0.6802080274,
-0.1298220605,
-0.5693742037,
0.397675246,
-0.3611606061,
0.120038338,
-0.4408427477,
-0.5892648697,
0.3241018653,
-0.2932220101,
-0.1588689536,
0.6191999316,
-0.0849931389,
-0.0307387374,
1.1698522568,
0.7467221022,
0.2967897952,
0.2663748562,
-0.3662829399,
-0.1895507723,
-1.0238890648,
-0.631139338,
-0.3391754329,
0.102164112,
-0.3086412549,
-0.1159704477,
0.5028973222,
0.3824520111,
-0.1764067858,
-0.2830218077,
-0.3301279843,
0.6406645179,
0.5294447541,
0.3032371998,
0.5998338461,
0.0978622288,
0.0083545363,
0.2667266428,
-0.2005988061,
-0.1863847822,
1.013559103,
0.0831788108,
0.3401698172,
0.4603629708,
0.7033294439,
0.3045437634,
0.6440856457,
-0.4515703321,
0.482460618,
0.4139031768,
-0.6728204489,
-0.1421997696,
-0.673151195,
-0.6887687445,
0.5532614589,
-0.2116539329,
-0.7053282857,
0.3496893942,
0.0767666996,
-0.1291151345,
0.4666828513,
-0.6283864975,
0.671440959,
0.26690346,
-0.9199029803,
0.0556439161,
-0.491073817,
0.9147945046,
-0.3194630146,
0.1344235986,
-0.3512692153,
-0.2167405635,
0.5566009879,
-0.5578122139,
0.3849340677,
-0.6465752125,
0.0615509339,
-0.0311848428,
0.1955831498,
0.5146281719,
0.5572243333,
0.0636577457,
0.2473931313,
-0.139272213,
-0.4369918704,
-0.5603070259,
0.785464406,
-0.4846273661,
-0.8256437182,
-0.7426703572,
-0.3854579031,
-0.1776006222,
0.5617022514,
-0.245381102,
-0.0837643668,
-0.2884350419,
-0.1505517364,
0.7754205465,
0.1417093873,
0.6736555696,
0.6377246976,
-0.3697688878,
-0.3292962313,
0.6375530362,
-0.044868201,
0.1037113592,
0.2961475849,
-0.0356440172,
-0.2372234613,
-0.7592315674,
-0.4709400237,
0.388384223,
-0.4656808376,
-0.2291992903,
-1.1165533066,
-0.0921028778,
-0.1521099955,
0.2678410709,
-0.3236951232,
-0.3641285002,
-0.4023507237,
-0.2127149403,
0.1239259839,
1.0853811502,
-0.2632505894,
0.2729624212,
-0.5946229696,
0.6220017076,
0.5613421202,
0.5582351089,
-0.0298931003,
0.393645823,
0.1224832684,
-0.1305924207,
-0.1524098068,
-1.2851550579,
0.3651044965,
0.0884783566,
0.5335630774,
0.1071690023,
-0.0825665966,
0.7482655644,
-0.5151478648,
0.4839391708,
0.0167640578,
-1.1203591824,
0.5277711153,
-0.2030007094,
-0.1592915505,
0.5296922326,
0.7734678984,
-0.0940094888,
0.0439421684,
-0.7433568239,
-1.0747591257,
0.8689407706,
0.2882712781,
-0.341075629,
-0.0276717842,
0.4542373121,
0.1427514851,
0.5154376626,
-1.1543371677,
-0.4163477123,
-0.0303631835,
0.0783126354,
0.7102010846,
-0.4820280373,
-0.2198161781,
-0.2208117396,
0.8762561083,
0.2969530821,
0.4092992544,
0.1772311181,
-0.2807014585,
-0.0321386419,
-0.0237428192,
0.100668788,
0.5851448774,
-0.5478062034,
0.1664345413,
-0.1224505752,
-0.5891521573,
0.2514598966,
0.5637074709,
-0.4924696088,
-0.096661672,
-0.0273311902,
0.5163139105,
-0.2615049779,
-0.0049778642,
1.0129051208,
-0.2655661404,
-0.0965206623,
-0.5024502277,
-0.0874024406,
-0.0687332973,
0.1043909937,
0.3859428763,
0.121645987,
0.4558840394,
-0.0974839851,
0.1316571832,
0.4989733696,
-0.501957655,
-0.1099701524,
0.7640806437,
0.1756143719,
0.0507343188,
0.8296536207,
-0.3741904199,
-0.1019944921,
0.4187473655,
0.5768945813,
0.8433558941,
-0.144385621,
0.3209028542,
0.2974849939,
0.013432621,
-0.317484051,
0.2582648098,
-0.3266356289,
-0.7072661519,
-0.3246936202,
-0.3148599267,
-0.1765735,
0.1974964887,
-0.7587485909,
0.2050228268,
-0.4862735271,
0.1953038722,
-0.0479856804,
-0.0635354966,
-0.4264897108,
-0.2216407359,
-0.0364513919,
0.6669450402,
-0.7409376502,
0.8468215466,
0.0718016028,
-0.5486697555,
-0.429197371,
0.1538654864,
-0.1127519235,
-0.5560820103,
0.8919897676,
0.3291328251,
-0.2516510785,
0.3708345592,
-0.4636880159,
-0.8438726664,
1.0546953678,
0.1329723448,
-0.1055117175,
-0.0758072957,
-0.1716488451,
0.0188307278,
-0.4901899099,
0.393895328,
0.6470549107,
0.4954859018,
0.3176846802,
-0.217658177,
0.2143488377,
-0.5520032644,
0.1927793324,
0.3282063007,
-0.158185184,
0.8290677071,
-0.11214526,
-0.5943450928,
-0.2754455507,
0.6688154936,
0.3169718981,
0.163142994,
0.7249248624,
0.4579706192,
0.8310157061,
-0.1445088089,
0.9662547112,
0.0382392853,
0.0754073262,
1.2021057606,
-0.678383708,
0.6769864559,
0.2715292573,
-0.2471198142,
0.8720792532,
0.2744426727,
0.1605666131,
0.6550059319,
0.051346343,
-0.7502395511,
0.2366401553,
-0.0160325989,
-0.5002914071,
0.0894550905,
0.6109212041,
-0.1519015878,
0.0184618942,
-0.396079123,
0.2700172663,
-0.3571725786,
-0.2509268522,
0.9622500539,
-0.2586375475,
-0.520509243,
0.3088127673,
-0.2364446372,
0.2600209713,
-0.1775791347,
-0.6608954668,
-0.2794221938,
-0.3381285071,
-0.2181688994,
-0.6219955087,
0.2030779868,
-0.1989280879,
-0.3798668385,
-0.3875139952,
0.635861516,
-0.5534902811,
-0.2021286637,
0.2061646283,
0.631178081,
-0.0243391842,
-0.3585169315,
-0.5064728856,
-0.1782560796,
-0.0217586346,
-0.1469037235,
0.0480138212,
0.4387558699,
0.0410237275,
0.4456137121,
0.5315808058,
0.3768658936,
-0.1686903834,
-0.1758167297,
0.8694853187,
-0.6721860766,
-0.3609878719,
-1.0733200312,
0.6088126898,
-0.795876503,
0.1729306281,
0.5100975037,
0.6407122612,
0.5201466084,
0.0041631255,
0.7747391462,
-0.0445305742,
0.7077158093,
-0.4915395081,
0.4161872268,
-0.2983307242,
0.6930444837,
-0.5243353844,
-1.126447916,
-0.617974937,
0.3334862888,
-0.1864580363,
0.0729185641,
0.8092904091,
0.4958703816,
-0.1253586113,
0.1327950805,
-0.2369333506,
0.3025050759,
0.3824633956,
0.2899102271,
0.9245052934,
-0.312938422,
0.5878332853,
-0.355360806,
-0.4269478619,
0.0593051016,
-1.2683689594,
-0.5295599699,
-0.5473240018,
-0.4756962657,
-0.3999366462,
0.0157697238,
0.4888635278,
0.6743668318,
-0.3850051165,
0.1213633493,
-0.6216652989,
0.5865290761,
-0.069520101,
-0.3054344952,
0.4228241146,
0.2967481315,
-0.7621992826,
0.3005588949,
0.391890049,
0.3624224663,
-0.0439813286,
0.4718621373,
-0.4912198484,
-0.4168171883,
0.3841650188,
0.3328532875,
-0.3965117335,
-0.1538688093,
-0.5934449434,
0.1054529324,
0.276484549,
0.4100616872,
-0.8737582564,
0.3361838758,
0.2995339036,
0.2716825008,
1.1905816793,
0.1790934801,
0.8563970327,
-0.9283181429,
0.0725297332,
0.1217332482,
0.1918021888,
0.3498411179,
-0.4802055657,
0.8504889607,
0.5451818109,
-0.2622813284,
-0.8952668309,
0.2702754438,
-0.8373692632,
-0.3173489869,
1.1296107769,
-0.1073636934,
-0.2023279369,
-0.5124670267,
0.0627734959,
0.3771159947,
-0.436665982,
0.6261312962,
0.4387214482,
-0.2758240104,
-0.1807269007,
-0.5394166708,
0.6524966359,
-0.1081246063,
-0.8624728322,
0.0052859248,
0.7251935005,
0.4013813138,
0.005282206,
1.0321381092,
-0.2797019184,
0.0041491124,
-0.0190632883,
0.2881674469,
-0.1380874217,
-0.5206483006,
-0.3182635307,
0.6299538612,
-0.1447017491,
-0.041572202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15818v1
|
Linguistic Intelligence in Large Language Models for Telecommunications
| 2024-02-24T14:01:07 | 2024-02-24T14:01:07 |
Tasnim Ahmed, Nicola Piovesan, Antonio De Domenico, Salimur Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a significant advancement in the
field of Natural Language Processing (NLP), demonstrating remarkable
capabilities in language generation and other language-centric tasks. Despite
their evaluation across a multitude of analytical and reasoning tasks in
various scientific domains, a comprehensive exploration of their knowledge and
understanding within the realm of natural language tasks in the
telecommunications domain is still needed. This study, therefore, seeks to
evaluate the knowledge and understanding capabilities of LLMs within this
domain. To achieve this, we conduct an exhaustive zero-shot evaluation of four
prominent LLMs-Llama-2, Falcon, Mistral, and Zephyr. These models require fewer
resources than ChatGPT, making them suitable for resource-constrained
environments. Their performance is compared with state-of-the-art, fine-tuned
models. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to extensively
evaluate and compare the understanding of LLMs across multiple language-centric
tasks in this domain. Our evaluation reveals that zero-shot LLMs can achieve
performance levels comparable to the current state-of-the-art fine-tuned
models. This indicates that pretraining on extensive text corpora equips LLMs
with a degree of specialization, even within the telecommunications domain. We
also observe that no single LLM consistently outperforms others, and the
performance of different LLMs can fluctuate. Although their performance lags
behind fine-tuned models, our findings underscore the potential of LLMs as a
valuable resource for understanding various aspects of this field that lack
large annotated data.
|
[
-0.3284250796,
-0.9023442864,
0.6862117052,
0.0741754845,
-0.2718850076,
0.1704963148,
-0.4743472934,
-0.7075705528,
0.1298657209,
0.6940973997,
-0.5102788806,
-0.5710964203,
-0.6325675249,
0.418963939,
-0.3789850771,
0.7058157325,
0.2804530859,
-0.0951817706,
0.092360951,
-0.1250600219,
-0.4793721139,
-0.6434271336,
-0.4565558732,
-0.6254783273,
0.3518420756,
0.4420542419,
0.6377031207,
0.4065280259,
0.5021370649,
0.2872610092,
-0.3262791336,
0.0697151944,
-0.5449393392,
0.015514425,
-0.075232394,
-0.5466756225,
-0.480299145,
-0.1452605873,
0.7581700683,
0.8384444118,
-0.0871231705,
0.347777307,
-0.148799628,
0.6540513635,
-0.394724071,
0.1935602874,
-1.136477828,
0.1391619444,
-0.2056955546,
-0.3846981823,
-0.4944347143,
-0.0735177398,
0.2251806706,
-0.5895599127,
-0.0332037732,
0.1138883308,
0.7135718465,
0.4256636798,
-0.5196338892,
-0.3684803247,
-0.8266335726,
0.8901560903,
-0.8091210127,
0.4487242103,
0.0968597308,
0.2392217964,
-0.0389496163,
-0.4874188602,
-0.545006156,
-0.288120538,
0.306070745,
0.1651414633,
-0.2197861224,
0.0646946877,
0.2999837995,
0.220803231,
-0.4028496444,
0.7297834754,
-0.3626928627,
0.0207411461,
0.5369363427,
0.2788075209,
0.0474707745,
-0.0935591459,
-0.1771749556,
0.4593751431,
-0.7514513731,
-0.0521938503,
0.242189005,
0.3071097136,
-0.1493329257,
0.7584844828,
-0.3799883425,
0.6831489801,
-0.1443377137,
-0.111170426,
0.1333368868,
-0.2597743869,
-0.5906590223,
0.1286112517,
0.9210764766,
-0.0391422547,
0.5927040577,
-0.318552345,
-0.1939996481,
-0.1335739344,
0.2881240845,
-0.8102747798,
0.1361782253,
0.2417864501,
-0.3892246783,
-0.1546613276,
-0.2902992666,
-0.3557037711,
-0.2398224324,
-0.4610178769,
0.1807656586,
-0.384786427,
-0.5044188499,
0.5358073711,
0.1976376027,
0.3150431216,
0.2897509933,
-0.9513877034,
0.1468012482,
0.8505535126,
0.8944026232,
-0.0067826621,
-0.2232164592,
-0.4179620147,
-0.0575124994,
-0.4078428149,
0.7269104123,
-0.5583440661,
-0.2594323754,
0.0993660763,
-0.2576566637,
-0.1575461775,
-0.6143356562,
0.6873534918,
-0.944473803,
-0.2460171878,
-0.0966910645,
-0.586240232,
-0.3692080975,
0.2099854797,
-0.5754095912,
0.7672942281,
0.0714448318,
-0.5733708739,
0.1930531114,
-0.7166016698,
-0.3207163513,
0.3785749376,
-0.0879963264,
-0.222861588,
0.2739808857,
-0.1252204329,
0.6494368315,
-0.6077853441,
0.2970913351,
-0.4350706339,
-0.4509821534,
0.3757168353,
-0.3577297926,
0.7291054726,
0.252784133,
-0.3264392614,
0.0179420151,
-0.6376307011,
0.1038838103,
0.123661086,
-0.2293542176,
-0.0674806237,
-0.0378298014,
-0.0634714589,
0.2494481355,
0.1693808734,
-0.5935010314,
0.0529426634,
-0.4803826511,
0.6429044008,
0.4564017355,
-0.1742753237,
0.4497793317,
-0.0929591209,
0.4419342279,
-0.0388154052,
0.0600776747,
-0.2357105017,
-0.3366663456,
-0.9821982384,
-0.0874124989,
0.1218829826,
0.5352100134,
-0.6897910237,
0.2319949269,
-0.5985149145,
-0.5739175081,
-0.3546188176,
0.4406069815,
0.1802454293,
0.311930716,
0.3212823272,
-0.0645436272,
-0.2011020482,
-0.9498490691,
-0.1628917754,
0.0213846117,
0.058255367,
0.4007666111,
0.4021494687,
-0.2523853779,
0.7948140502,
-0.2794854939,
-0.2681924403,
-0.4763565958,
-0.0280092414,
0.5257849693,
-0.0715951547,
0.5228478312,
-0.5257623196,
-0.301740706,
0.265573293,
-0.943431139,
-0.1720254868,
-0.1544016898,
0.2287778407,
0.2686484158,
0.4062540829,
-0.8122597933,
0.0975676626,
0.497300148,
-0.1037951857,
0.6999194026,
-0.1118976623,
-0.1137115732,
-0.762850821,
0.0822565407,
0.2741063833,
-0.0773636252,
-0.9749776125,
-0.097154893,
-0.0590971485,
-0.066349417,
-0.5095311403,
0.4240872562,
-0.6590188742,
-0.3614150286,
-0.3464306891,
0.2524392009,
-0.2481201887,
0.3781456351,
0.23435992,
0.800188899,
0.5735470057,
-0.6320735216,
0.3081857264,
0.1377876997,
-0.6579248309,
0.206652686,
-0.8780871034,
0.1195609421,
-0.0383982472,
0.0522358343,
-0.6719792485,
-0.0850545093,
-0.0616897345,
-0.2372491956,
0.0582957827,
-0.0879893228,
-0.653863132,
-0.115918532,
0.0370169841,
0.3503990769,
0.3423953354,
-0.2851873636,
0.4295823574,
0.3721106052,
-0.3883633316,
-0.6159448028,
-0.6499347091,
0.4536870718,
-0.2827817798,
-0.5750448108,
0.2408202291,
0.121660769,
-0.3016008735,
-0.2647659183,
0.0282665864,
-0.1226153374,
0.2703223825,
0.2830833495,
0.2534638047,
-0.5188498497,
0.1363295317,
-0.1915282756,
-0.1410923898,
0.2404325157,
-0.3797595799,
0.6038767695,
-0.263497442,
-0.4944184124,
-0.6123974919,
0.1515990049,
0.6777134538,
-0.3361983001,
0.728539288,
0.5166033506,
-0.1302395165,
-0.355823189,
-0.8193109632,
0.0982338116,
-0.4605299234,
0.4278155863,
-0.4043794274,
-1.2672438622,
0.5011219382,
-0.1803943515,
0.2005170882,
0.5094378591,
0.6072415113,
0.2291028351,
0.6179103851,
0.8694357872,
-0.1491979361,
0.3559625149,
-0.3295415342,
0.3962192535,
-0.7981988788,
-0.3558205068,
-0.5637322664,
-0.0184865594,
-0.4497404993,
-0.2928392887,
0.3677163422,
0.0093407994,
-0.364032805,
0.2631731927,
-0.25321877,
0.4973744452,
0.228250429,
-0.2034658194,
0.502507329,
0.1471005082,
-0.0060577919,
0.2967673838,
-0.8240461946,
-0.8785073161,
1.1326414347,
0.5469878912,
0.6640017629,
0.2663881779,
0.2929944396,
0.0437601581,
0.2750502229,
-1.028200984,
0.5443564653,
-0.2528184354,
-0.3631475568,
-0.3063992858,
-0.5875188112,
-0.724321723,
0.1139421463,
-0.2312168777,
-0.803722918,
-0.1861640364,
-0.2822791636,
-0.5050302148,
0.3664292395,
-0.6405060291,
0.5368663073,
-0.4281856418,
-0.2940388322,
-0.4123601317,
-0.4377447367,
0.5531595945,
-0.5062718391,
0.1166600063,
-0.3785297871,
-0.2146984786,
0.5171374083,
-0.0655496418,
0.8166590929,
0.1646235883,
-0.3137113154,
0.234066397,
0.1214630827,
0.0715201274,
0.025939133,
-0.7155032754,
0.6808872819,
0.005330273,
-0.1621002406,
-0.3333665431,
0.7299461961,
-0.8538698554,
-0.6070348024,
-0.2263111174,
-0.6056996584,
-0.2354611456,
0.3416961133,
0.1203187332,
0.5581427813,
-0.0120622544,
0.3900246322,
0.6328395605,
-0.3641396463,
0.6651832461,
0.6574546099,
-0.0906049535,
-0.078108035,
0.6287961602,
0.2341344506,
0.4482963979,
0.4117047489,
-0.1916144937,
-0.5971347094,
-0.953404665,
-0.4658515453,
0.371915102,
-0.6292568445,
-0.2210719734,
-0.7653005719,
-0.5536980629,
-0.1057081446,
0.0349927247,
-0.2466827184,
-0.2948774099,
-0.4645504653,
0.1803113669,
0.1704015732,
0.9253857732,
0.4521506131,
0.5623206496,
-0.8553352356,
0.2324349284,
0.0077993562,
0.5277496576,
0.1102862805,
-0.6920663118,
-0.3438583612,
0.0977297872,
-0.3345323801,
-0.5909385681,
0.3438882828,
0.3018139005,
0.674685955,
0.3274011612,
-0.0018320311,
0.4501476884,
-0.5295861363,
0.8179491758,
0.2227377594,
-0.9754599333,
0.2015186995,
-0.4378831983,
0.3183493912,
0.3027653992,
0.3485020995,
-0.3977531195,
-0.1990820765,
-0.5395447016,
-0.4853154123,
0.6446236372,
0.1958001405,
0.3660400808,
0.0876481235,
0.492828697,
-0.0624900721,
0.1561295688,
-0.6555342674,
-0.0458200015,
0.0254995544,
0.0265424307,
-0.130230844,
-0.3220901191,
0.1362854838,
0.0275570527,
0.4966929853,
-0.1920572221,
0.1248570159,
0.0508895032,
-0.1651538759,
-0.0175080113,
0.5390974879,
0.7045940161,
0.9216732979,
-0.1231931522,
0.1002368107,
0.5107495189,
-0.3600042462,
0.0408954173,
-0.1782053709,
0.0707019642,
0.0798333511,
0.4196296036,
0.7454693913,
0.2124030441,
-0.7341085076,
0.4513831437,
-0.0242751502,
-0.2957243919,
-0.4718331397,
0.1880513281,
0.1812202632,
0.3189488649,
0.4373895228,
-0.0366161764,
-0.0795236304,
-0.4160870016,
-0.1075645611,
0.7376763821,
-0.2441100627,
-0.3231039643,
0.5911124349,
0.2516187131,
-0.3443340063,
0.5263590813,
-0.161760971,
-0.5027302504,
0.7075796723,
0.6402223706,
0.7498263121,
0.0876546055,
0.0781832784,
0.1400842071,
0.4915372729,
-0.072079435,
-0.0881029591,
-0.0189481471,
-0.9099141955,
-0.8474773169,
-0.8540989161,
-0.4475270212,
0.3896844387,
-0.3306394219,
0.3847565353,
-0.6060612202,
-0.2950356901,
0.2398618758,
0.2175774574,
-0.7403717637,
0.0561965071,
0.2969311178,
1.1969037056,
-0.5495195985,
0.9534292817,
0.5888707042,
-0.083394587,
-0.8461768627,
-0.1310887933,
-0.0428247042,
-0.895749867,
1.0398690701,
0.297830075,
-0.4376759231,
0.2226648331,
-0.1723073423,
-0.6476866603,
1.1561527252,
0.5190530419,
-0.6928227544,
0.1770483404,
0.5448454618,
0.5221828222,
-0.403570801,
0.770341754,
0.5911275744,
0.1650438607,
0.1094482094,
-1.2393125296,
-0.1597836167,
-0.1512348801,
0.0189097896,
0.1868419647,
-0.8135516644,
0.6858659983,
-0.2390842885,
-0.3216728568,
0.0014974092,
0.5233197212,
0.0922140032,
0.2135011554,
0.4952338934,
0.3747564256,
0.5328464508,
0.0690407529,
0.7782286406,
-0.5346560478,
0.2487656325,
0.8053923249,
-0.6214457154,
0.9960023165,
0.2352856398,
0.0219660196,
0.2619802952,
0.4944113791,
0.1665599495,
0.0468362235,
0.1612576693,
-0.3802614808,
-0.4570702016,
-0.3642453849,
-0.1867236346,
0.7722389698,
0.4307631552,
-0.0960467085,
-0.286690712,
-0.3187829852,
-0.0361182652,
-0.072619848,
-0.3761580288,
0.8067330122,
0.3357690275,
-0.5027666688,
0.8646474481,
0.1722834408,
0.8538725972,
-0.6574276686,
0.2180047333,
-0.0612885207,
0.0105872639,
-0.3190778196,
-0.9115034938,
0.4124319553,
0.4150843918,
0.0414330661,
-0.187547639,
0.6378372908,
-0.0986070409,
-0.3208068013,
0.3887084424,
0.5375142097,
0.3050740659,
-0.1338735819,
-0.5514870286,
0.2788441777,
-0.0929127932,
-0.1136776134,
0.2697948813,
0.5613588691,
0.1949274242,
0.981711328,
0.7645713091,
0.2921943069,
-0.0327018909,
0.219263345,
0.7110058069,
-0.6002472639,
-0.1285887212,
-1.020791173,
0.1986769289,
-0.0404485539,
-0.3743859828,
0.6681978703,
0.5250064731,
0.6428912282,
-0.0137135517,
0.7806569338,
0.3443514407,
0.1726371795,
-0.6597997546,
0.6863878965,
-0.4084607065,
0.6131924391,
-0.0199078061,
-1.045227766,
-0.2648431361,
0.3372780383,
-0.6340142488,
-0.1191963255,
0.4549047053,
0.7992507219,
-0.2115942389,
0.3187187612,
0.4958038926,
0.1988786757,
0.3694396317,
0.6890256405,
0.9849323034,
-0.2156928331,
0.5931267738,
-0.018111039,
-0.1093475819,
-0.278375566,
-1.0564192533,
-1.0120332241,
-0.2767762542,
-0.0890398547,
0.1723430455,
-0.1775852591,
0.864741385,
0.7772592902,
-0.4935483038,
-0.472935617,
-0.0252446532,
0.0369916894,
0.1911560893,
-0.1545880288,
0.0464586541,
-0.5606256723,
-0.5270739794,
0.4200772643,
0.6538048983,
-0.1456351578,
-0.2927762866,
0.0238337126,
0.0050093224,
0.1153324768,
0.9294304848,
0.1090115011,
-0.8898104429,
-0.2548172474,
0.289493978,
-0.1138015687,
-0.0828819126,
0.6153871417,
-0.7552704811,
0.0601698346,
0.2692710757,
0.878167212,
0.2769395709,
-0.0926914066,
0.2774659097,
-0.4111517072,
0.1444045305,
0.2521234751,
0.3232800364,
0.3021413684,
-0.3445256948,
0.4609802663,
-0.0170805138,
-0.8325430751,
-0.6851317286,
0.2840803862,
-1.1610975266,
-0.1365896612,
1.4339588881,
0.0418460071,
0.0303075276,
-0.2515339553,
0.0244030915,
0.2020865381,
-0.2083307952,
0.6175493598,
0.5632809401,
-0.0892758518,
-0.3039414585,
-1.1355077028,
0.1300042123,
0.5871155858,
-0.9490388036,
0.0772298276,
0.3364248276,
0.4674788117,
0.0205256082,
0.6839601398,
0.1564536393,
-0.1241331697,
-0.2992746234,
-0.2371422499,
-0.2796653807,
-0.2550765872,
-0.3115362823,
0.1812809259,
0.2541601658,
0.1154830083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15814v2
|
On Efficiently Representing Regular Languages as RNNs
| 2024-02-24T13:42:06 | 2024-06-18T15:14:18 |
Anej Svete, Robin Shing Moon Chan, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CC, cs.LG
|
Recent work by Hewitt et al. (2020) provides an interpretation of the
empirical success of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) as language models (LMs).
It shows that RNNs can efficiently represent bounded hierarchical structures
that are prevalent in human language. This suggests that RNNs' success might be
linked to their ability to model hierarchy. However, a closer inspection of
Hewitt et al.'s (2020) construction shows that it is not inherently limited to
hierarchical structures. This poses a natural question: What other classes of
LMs can RNNs efficiently represent? To this end, we generalize Hewitt et al.'s
(2020) construction and show that RNNs can efficiently represent a larger class
of LMs than previously claimed -- specifically, those that can be represented
by a pushdown automaton with a bounded stack and a specific stack update
function. Altogether, the efficiency of representing this diverse class of LMs
with RNN LMs suggests novel interpretations of their inductive bias.
|
[
-0.0807487592,
-0.3181307912,
0.4045872986,
0.3375306129,
0.1133926362,
0.211502865,
-0.3879035711,
-0.4141073823,
0.2254852504,
0.3199320734,
-0.2247186899,
-0.2655180693,
-0.4724285901,
0.5185270309,
-0.6565309763,
0.8333717585,
0.2177974135,
0.0307792798,
-0.052632723,
-0.1785879731,
-0.1836060733,
-0.6180795431,
-0.5380820036,
-0.6383510232,
0.6340839267,
-0.1992629468,
1.1295018196,
1.2071852684,
0.5309671164,
0.3657865524,
-0.2311133444,
-0.0684121996,
-0.4330489337,
0.1725290865,
0.2965285778,
-0.3656078279,
-0.2372399271,
0.0063287816,
0.9827925563,
1.1188030243,
-0.1888427734,
-0.1329092532,
0.1099084988,
0.8313853741,
-0.1580250561,
0.0559959263,
-0.7148171663,
0.2770239115,
-0.3142299652,
-0.2480436862,
-0.7100992203,
-0.4084138572,
0.181026876,
-0.3945381343,
0.1200727001,
-0.0569066741,
0.9361903071,
0.3748700023,
-0.2181854099,
-0.0439069793,
-0.8182205558,
0.7989102006,
-0.6408946514,
0.4704180658,
0.0669728294,
0.3168441653,
-0.4616879821,
-0.6855093241,
-0.0527817644,
-0.6862649918,
-0.2755362988,
-0.0593882762,
-0.0772843063,
0.2864144444,
0.4306889176,
0.9417211413,
-0.5084058046,
0.2764959335,
-0.1027923897,
-0.1509316266,
0.3510884345,
0.3743733764,
0.3656351268,
-0.1616730988,
-0.4318086207,
0.2936606109,
-0.7202864289,
-0.2073082179,
0.2045475394,
0.3307956159,
0.0873560086,
0.4970427752,
-0.0231214222,
1.288756609,
-0.2292668819,
0.1243590117,
-0.0684862956,
-0.1096281111,
-0.3046706319,
-0.4036732614,
0.6951932907,
0.0143452864,
0.8594416976,
-0.4047903717,
-0.1805863678,
0.0426335596,
0.3244965672,
-0.5260246396,
-0.4232386947,
-0.0310346056,
-0.8015853167,
-0.394274205,
0.0847445801,
-0.4842908382,
-0.2724392414,
-0.2529449761,
-0.0970702767,
-0.1596893519,
-0.1164385453,
0.1086366326,
0.0335815176,
-0.0191332661,
0.1892235428,
-0.6743359566,
0.6044906378,
0.7652700543,
0.8973348737,
-0.1038876325,
-0.1801853776,
-0.2745580971,
-0.1259257942,
-0.5477169156,
0.481983453,
-0.5893934369,
-0.1065703407,
0.2268870175,
-0.2396050394,
-0.0139861954,
-0.6585617661,
-0.0367395245,
-0.6921314597,
0.1648723334,
0.1493765116,
-0.6495559812,
0.1169928312,
0.0423346423,
-1.0111371279,
0.713681221,
0.2091189176,
-0.6237004995,
-0.1297856718,
-0.3332008123,
-0.5617050529,
-0.0289805736,
-0.331622988,
-0.2058240473,
0.171348989,
-0.2893691659,
0.2759186924,
-0.2658077478,
0.1816100329,
-0.1024413779,
-0.2770460844,
0.5617389679,
-0.4667165577,
0.9087805152,
0.4653823972,
-0.2708541155,
-0.0100461375,
-0.8101644516,
-0.0572301559,
-0.0037116574,
-0.7020574808,
-0.3465527892,
0.0286314283,
-0.2634621561,
0.1040966064,
0.1618819684,
-0.5001015067,
0.4291090369,
-0.3825669885,
0.4967939258,
0.7564502358,
-0.3243635595,
0.6425113678,
-0.3240924776,
0.5706463456,
-0.2680564225,
-0.0899401382,
-0.3775783181,
-0.5738437176,
-0.8321611881,
-0.312060982,
0.6564703584,
0.3597814143,
-0.3392920792,
0.2745368779,
-0.2906260788,
-0.0230572168,
-0.6196879148,
-0.0993052199,
0.3537631631,
0.4436728656,
0.1572207212,
-0.3217139542,
-0.9792401791,
-1.1095169783,
-0.5692934394,
-0.1767641008,
0.0437620096,
0.226788342,
0.211406365,
-0.1346491575,
0.807448864,
-0.0290479921,
-0.0112765273,
-0.3176804781,
0.0586421043,
0.3710236251,
0.4242310226,
0.2217515558,
-0.6385030746,
-0.4831636846,
0.0138040083,
-0.6762103438,
0.0201965962,
-0.328133285,
0.1944595873,
0.2205095291,
0.3096498251,
-0.4053726792,
0.6210951805,
0.3216829896,
-0.0550627522,
0.3050852418,
0.0382118151,
-0.1502696276,
-0.7484474778,
-0.0911080837,
0.0774606839,
-0.5920699835,
-0.7134383917,
0.0294592101,
-0.071730718,
-0.2581644654,
-0.0462322198,
0.5811088681,
-0.6161495447,
-0.3188489079,
-0.1320333183,
0.0983962715,
-0.3482557833,
0.3951912522,
0.3591864407,
0.3741495907,
0.4456341565,
-0.6626827717,
0.1816313267,
-0.0313761346,
-0.4461743832,
-0.0891452655,
-0.7140425444,
-0.0143618342,
-0.24079445,
0.5464479327,
-0.6400380135,
-0.1940728724,
0.0138847427,
-0.4413039386,
0.3294576108,
-0.2861085236,
-0.3310170174,
-0.3742464185,
0.012062395,
0.3228180707,
0.5981920362,
-0.6375985742,
0.3913978338,
0.3702061474,
0.2133870423,
-0.6169979572,
-0.9473246336,
0.2151664197,
0.0001985725,
-0.4777181447,
0.1411653757,
0.1688715667,
-0.5418573022,
0.2090225965,
0.0756242052,
-0.0021231668,
0.1256039888,
0.1886561215,
0.1699886918,
-0.3768958151,
-0.0223827828,
-0.7651968002,
-0.3143589795,
-0.1625683606,
-0.5018992424,
0.4497638345,
-0.3674166799,
-0.1040455624,
-0.6792272925,
0.5454760194,
0.4277078807,
-0.1147194803,
0.7037810087,
0.1079569906,
-0.5072773099,
-0.16997765,
-0.3993534446,
-0.1524644941,
-0.411102891,
0.384396106,
-0.3354905248,
-1.0682271719,
0.5887807608,
0.1882238686,
0.2864178121,
0.451916188,
0.4986138046,
-0.0039540664,
1.045493722,
0.5336845517,
-0.2739615738,
0.574443996,
-0.2294562906,
-0.0005737834,
-0.879285574,
-0.2843917012,
-0.665600419,
-0.5079779029,
-0.8045738935,
-0.3321070373,
-0.0616738498,
-0.1330803484,
-0.4777322412,
0.5460391045,
-0.6138814092,
0.3299991488,
0.5327126384,
-0.244134143,
0.3627455831,
0.1332674026,
-0.0834424943,
-0.2129906863,
-1.0682045221,
-0.5751511455,
0.7022484541,
0.811062932,
1.0671466589,
-0.0040949835,
0.809081912,
0.1605527252,
0.6165335774,
-0.7099328637,
0.5837312937,
-0.4081772566,
-0.7492982149,
-0.0991713628,
-0.8825925589,
-1.1528582573,
0.2294590175,
0.1867544353,
-0.6647764444,
0.4055536389,
0.1681009978,
-0.3946607113,
0.6457740068,
-0.3624176681,
0.5992303491,
-0.1939153373,
-0.0185656697,
-0.0227118563,
-0.8173230886,
0.3141934276,
0.5679152608,
0.0405832343,
0.1991347522,
-0.1269043088,
0.7427815199,
-0.5134735107,
0.8075137138,
0.0539864451,
0.0139147025,
0.4292791188,
0.4293894768,
0.4833941758,
-0.1272663623,
-0.2847818136,
0.095311515,
-0.4004195035,
-0.481760025,
-0.8004062176,
0.6665875912,
-0.4413311779,
-0.4540605843,
-0.651025176,
-0.8093212843,
-0.0726553649,
0.0349830426,
0.1204636246,
0.9066322446,
-0.1581984907,
0.3915857077,
0.7083845735,
-0.0246294234,
0.4739154279,
0.1226651743,
-0.4217383862,
-0.3129499555,
0.6834567785,
0.3100791574,
0.4505753815,
0.6193343997,
0.1526319236,
-0.1844759732,
-0.4824905694,
-0.5793086886,
0.0997212306,
-0.5408130884,
-0.1138360351,
-0.5470462441,
-0.4975144267,
-0.1434416026,
0.0836463645,
-0.3789567649,
-0.9449235201,
-0.1189521402,
-0.1174988002,
0.3051248491,
1.2982620001,
-0.2778875232,
-0.1126923934,
-0.5976368785,
0.2985655963,
0.4417152107,
0.499212712,
0.45322299,
-0.614766717,
-0.2529663444,
-0.0868120939,
0.1857117712,
-0.7240071893,
0.0730623007,
0.2412193865,
0.5722997785,
0.3141808808,
-0.2632753253,
0.6080619097,
-0.7131141424,
0.7320907116,
0.1311125308,
-0.4698758423,
0.2025169432,
-0.4216026962,
0.1928502619,
0.4020546079,
0.5534515977,
-0.5667159557,
-0.5687741041,
-0.793389976,
-0.679204464,
0.4084304273,
0.2632822394,
0.2779537141,
-0.3508333862,
0.5831373334,
-0.0399358906,
0.0565207042,
-0.9522945881,
-0.605425477,
-0.1750517488,
-0.3368222713,
0.3446990848,
-0.3898768127,
-0.0012281557,
0.0431405008,
0.3996224701,
0.3313501775,
0.4690034389,
0.3410341442,
-0.1353559196,
0.0617223792,
0.220064804,
0.6815210581,
0.4225506186,
-0.1365150958,
0.4692723453,
-0.1434761286,
-0.2243032306,
0.1349356622,
-0.0633926094,
-0.3246434629,
0.2030394077,
0.6519622803,
0.672862649,
0.2844997346,
-0.2689618766,
0.0091011189,
-0.0305955261,
0.1624666005,
-0.1857670397,
-0.1863764673,
-0.0061124233,
-0.1123854443,
0.3422627449,
0.4240378737,
-0.0519261062,
-0.793432951,
0.4613113701,
0.3342429101,
-0.5840859413,
-0.2929300368,
0.6186549067,
0.3948015869,
-0.8173624873,
0.768619895,
-0.1088406444,
-0.7173985839,
0.5136657357,
0.8592434525,
0.8867697716,
-0.1929466724,
-0.120914273,
0.5668560863,
0.4211863875,
-0.2480785698,
0.0240196493,
0.0191747528,
-0.6996858716,
-0.5429140925,
-0.5249561071,
-0.2555790544,
0.0437816046,
-0.8185284138,
-0.3211689889,
-0.6461969018,
-0.1141403094,
-0.2818045914,
-0.3402298093,
-0.5315077305,
0.1731613278,
0.2308887541,
1.1092302799,
-0.4829063118,
0.6198065877,
0.5318483114,
-0.3647550046,
-0.8154360652,
-0.0973162577,
-0.0351992361,
-0.7043661475,
0.7922227383,
-0.0671710148,
-0.2056079209,
-0.015159769,
-0.3752462268,
-0.7136318684,
0.5371395946,
0.2239815742,
-0.6762410402,
-0.1249729916,
0.025377905,
0.6369713545,
-0.7430171967,
0.0696216896,
0.331656158,
0.3730983138,
-0.2937269509,
-0.8503969312,
0.0320676304,
-0.447532475,
0.4456991851,
0.238800019,
-0.4326633811,
0.7727047801,
-0.293718785,
-0.3579739034,
0.5709635019,
1.016649127,
0.1031713858,
-0.044851169,
0.3970789611,
0.6540380716,
0.6323696375,
-0.2613405287,
1.6262559891,
-0.0591152906,
0.1755137891,
1.2050409317,
0.0914839506,
0.660494566,
0.1959851384,
-0.2988653183,
0.9069401622,
0.6236557961,
0.1371359527,
0.4791609943,
0.7253056765,
-0.0637495443,
-0.459682703,
-0.0629550517,
-0.4661000669,
-0.0018683688,
0.041680079,
-0.4196392298,
-0.1755110025,
-0.2078345269,
-0.1982118487,
0.5027907491,
-0.3825832605,
0.590438962,
0.3966960609,
-0.4886643589,
0.6281958818,
-0.1615258008,
0.6495000124,
-0.4299753606,
-0.0986453295,
-0.1298184395,
-0.0642256737,
-0.3944915533,
-0.6445912719,
0.3259985745,
-0.0000681989,
-0.2626234889,
-0.3942843378,
0.777364552,
-0.6015771031,
-0.3254171014,
0.1622806191,
0.2403843552,
0.3456066251,
0.4984630048,
-0.4957394898,
0.1041803136,
-0.0530897789,
-0.1915973425,
0.1848679781,
0.3697301745,
0.0119617525,
0.9418779016,
0.4019072056,
0.3663871586,
0.4189722538,
0.4508064985,
0.436422199,
-0.8679657578,
-0.215803802,
-0.7781201601,
0.5844733119,
-0.0658744499,
-0.1898280382,
0.7715400457,
0.6106448174,
0.6976097226,
-0.1001861989,
0.6871461272,
0.0259108096,
0.5941682458,
-0.3850836158,
0.5704129338,
-0.3313082457,
0.3342382908,
-0.0075568873,
-0.7741889954,
-0.6625473499,
1.1125422716,
-0.1652487218,
0.2854439914,
0.5518675447,
0.644474864,
0.2018819302,
0.0862225816,
0.2770354152,
0.2752372324,
-0.0281033218,
0.4160398841,
1.2511030436,
-0.4324055314,
0.4518189728,
-0.3913972974,
-0.214075014,
-0.1310875714,
-0.8931373358,
-0.7998545766,
-0.4602094591,
-0.3633178174,
-0.5489593148,
0.052101694,
0.9294891953,
0.7603473067,
-0.8828375936,
-0.4385685325,
-0.2589196563,
0.5729111433,
-0.2313183993,
-0.2057047784,
0.2450200617,
-0.3684222102,
-0.6378552318,
0.5807025433,
0.3710931838,
-0.0453988314,
-0.389870286,
-0.2267744541,
-0.1629213095,
-0.1279361844,
0.5769830942,
0.6468318105,
-0.6993433833,
-0.28812325,
0.3123235703,
-0.3788346052,
0.1760605574,
1.2106076479,
-0.9610792994,
0.270475924,
0.5578150749,
0.9136816859,
0.0897419825,
-0.0370193906,
0.7939202189,
-0.5775203705,
0.0586461313,
0.5674691796,
0.4058232903,
0.4868085384,
-0.0148992157,
0.6094205379,
-0.0224400815,
-0.625115931,
-0.8694887161,
0.7284424305,
-0.7431325316,
0.0039219894,
1.284691453,
-0.0630274862,
-0.2741292715,
-0.4461214244,
0.2645342946,
0.0829855353,
-0.2172570229,
0.7222752571,
0.4480214119,
-0.2309455574,
-0.0137586035,
-0.5842656493,
0.5641801357,
0.5929140449,
-0.283657521,
0.031790562,
0.1940156519,
0.187330097,
0.2910415828,
0.723215282,
-0.4300822318,
0.2286208272,
-0.3591552079,
-0.1226431951,
-0.2212464064,
-0.4864768386,
-0.5390189886,
-0.0915003195,
0.1914181709,
-0.0982592255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15813v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15813v3
|
Measuring Bargaining Abilities of LLMs: A Benchmark and A Buyer-Enhancement Method
| 2024-02-24T13:36:58 | 2024-06-04T08:12:04 |
Tian Xia, Zhiwei He, Tong Ren, Yibo Miao, Zhuosheng Zhang, Yang Yang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT
|
Bargaining is an important and unique part of negotiation between humans. As
LLM-driven agents learn to negotiate and act like real humans, how to evaluate
agents' bargaining abilities remains an open problem. For the first time, we
formally described the Bargaining task as an asymmetric incomplete information
game, defining the gains of the Buyer and Seller in multiple bargaining
processes. It allows us to quantitatively assess an agent's performance in the
Bargain task. We collected a real product price dataset, AmazonHistoryPrice,
and conducted evaluations of various LLM agents' bargaining abilities. We find
that playing a Buyer is much harder than a Seller, and increasing model size
can not effectively improve the Buyer's performance. To address the challenge,
we propose a novel approach called OG-Narrator that integrates a deterministic
Offer Generator to control the price range of Buyer's offers, and an LLM
Narrator to create natural language sentences for generated offers.
Experimental results show that OG-Narrator improves the buyer's deal rates from
26.67% to 88.88% and brings a ten times multiplication of profits on all
baselines, even a model that has not been aligned.
|
[
-0.4863954484,
-0.5799606442,
0.5911642313,
-0.0628246963,
-0.2783301473,
0.1114267707,
-0.4679269195,
-0.8384978771,
0.1394470483,
0.196208939,
-0.4088174403,
-0.2953769565,
-0.5572755337,
0.100061737,
0.074705027,
0.7590684891,
0.3158052862,
0.0587531067,
-0.1216071844,
-0.0772776455,
-0.2106184661,
-0.2930358946,
-0.9261550307,
-0.1904684603,
0.2637392581,
0.1632367969,
0.9024003744,
0.646465838,
0.3050223291,
0.3853809237,
-0.2456727922,
0.1391718835,
-0.470466584,
0.3543083668,
-0.2779156268,
-0.5869104862,
-0.7431633472,
0.3552101851,
0.4562121928,
0.5812757611,
-0.2404868007,
0.2162394524,
0.2139478773,
0.501108706,
-0.6473955512,
0.1010118052,
-0.7535225749,
0.0834873468,
0.162844941,
-0.3178421557,
-0.3804288507,
-0.336258918,
0.0475110561,
-0.7501510382,
0.0219023209,
-0.0861895233,
0.8657053709,
0.3868505955,
-0.459779799,
-0.4811348021,
-0.7064122558,
0.5925161242,
-0.6897853017,
0.4054196775,
0.3347861171,
0.2457762212,
-0.2955769897,
-0.5959826112,
-0.2451205105,
-0.7244945765,
-0.039478872,
0.47772789,
-0.5582034588,
0.0927905068,
0.4137369096,
0.4676616192,
-0.2494725287,
0.2910194397,
-0.4405017197,
-0.1154022217,
0.8955333829,
0.375089556,
0.1617517769,
-0.0770334005,
-0.7952998877,
0.074222073,
-0.2374937087,
0.3392182589,
0.8191592693,
0.2525592446,
0.1051774472,
0.8353803754,
-0.4534279108,
0.7571130991,
0.0896186233,
-0.2939536273,
0.0014230254,
-0.3281755447,
-0.2952608466,
-0.0348004587,
0.6540822983,
0.519749999,
-0.0227731224,
-0.1816528291,
-0.2579134107,
0.0463608429,
0.3761353195,
-0.4486090839,
0.0513686538,
0.1736263484,
-0.6131341457,
-0.2508100271,
-0.0820727795,
-0.7349708676,
-0.3509951234,
-0.3352529407,
0.4823794067,
-0.2600843906,
-0.102560319,
0.0819778144,
-0.4841096103,
0.4361679256,
0.1841187626,
-0.53745085,
0.7069388032,
0.4694979489,
0.6400455236,
0.0903915092,
-0.5583038926,
-0.5734428167,
0.0979953706,
-0.4233232737,
0.8250240684,
-0.1597269922,
-0.3731358647,
-0.2183655649,
-0.5589948893,
-0.0879101455,
-0.6102990508,
0.5531499982,
-0.4410929978,
0.2113728225,
-0.0022289411,
-0.7809667587,
0.1752225459,
0.6370067596,
-0.6075188518,
0.8165428042,
0.0281394888,
-0.2428113222,
0.4697554111,
-0.5706515312,
-0.3698775172,
0.1038591564,
-0.1415108144,
-0.1696851403,
0.3397565186,
0.2400926799,
0.3322630525,
-0.5667567253,
-0.0044259415,
-0.0503988452,
-0.3706727922,
0.7991738915,
-0.5911634564,
0.656919837,
0.1254644841,
-0.4112451971,
-0.2168949395,
-0.3860985339,
0.0114103267,
0.1520239264,
-0.6942694187,
0.1062220559,
-0.2339150459,
-0.3291749954,
-0.0313241407,
0.4136449993,
-0.3239848018,
0.3088027537,
-0.393411845,
0.0145270815,
0.6717007756,
0.0459199734,
0.5434905887,
-0.7455065846,
0.8374069929,
-0.5115568638,
0.4490290582,
0.0443891101,
-0.383754909,
-0.6589070559,
-0.5785211325,
0.3928194046,
0.3333109617,
-0.6388533115,
0.3751179278,
-0.1352714598,
-0.6065842509,
-0.5232195854,
-0.0138377212,
0.4253073633,
0.1909362823,
0.1941540241,
-0.4597634375,
-0.3211457431,
-0.7746431231,
-0.721919775,
-0.4055914879,
-0.4063606262,
0.3565016985,
-0.1806456894,
0.2164378762,
0.634254694,
-0.5611135364,
-0.6556501985,
-0.3289896846,
0.3306935728,
0.1233724058,
0.136771366,
0.562700808,
-0.2811914086,
-0.4012250602,
-0.0284325611,
-0.5596514344,
-0.0413019173,
-0.3250924051,
-0.183251977,
0.43618536,
0.6029065847,
-0.8810591102,
0.5337594151,
0.2563131154,
-0.6071251035,
0.8133468628,
-0.6558181047,
0.2996829152,
-0.6145167947,
-0.2222601473,
-0.0603076927,
-0.2674293518,
-0.5017107725,
0.2239737213,
-0.2944158912,
0.0631665811,
-0.4585367143,
0.3185778558,
-0.9358536005,
-0.5723625422,
-0.3918141723,
0.5741506815,
-0.0425923727,
0.5430589318,
0.014194482,
0.5707493424,
0.4400367141,
-0.8837131858,
0.3921579123,
0.2460908294,
-0.4385887682,
1.0722962618,
-0.4515846372,
0.17134808,
0.032335829,
0.2319782376,
-0.6715764999,
0.091016084,
0.4668664932,
-0.5299792886,
0.1895339638,
-0.2614601254,
-0.2612397373,
-0.018590169,
-0.3440266848,
0.01603714,
0.612097621,
-0.4533860087,
1.0522954464,
-0.0165328681,
-0.2433130592,
-0.6135267615,
-0.2947913706,
0.4208507538,
-0.3143843114,
-0.4687083364,
0.3031059206,
-0.2955694795,
-0.4070226252,
0.0819586962,
-0.092367053,
0.0363687575,
0.1980775744,
-0.0648705587,
0.2243966758,
-0.1935839802,
0.1261259466,
-0.0250525791,
-0.5499501228,
0.1116827726,
-0.0135137709,
0.4139974415,
0.0975554511,
-0.3412794769,
-0.3247260451,
0.0483999886,
0.36642012,
-0.0512903407,
0.3513745666,
0.2689826787,
-0.114689596,
-0.0980775431,
-0.6647561193,
-0.1945213377,
-0.4121059477,
0.2216583937,
-0.6756206155,
-0.2728193104,
0.5197100639,
-0.1369440109,
-0.101308994,
0.3542223871,
0.4810017347,
-0.0308849066,
0.7428942323,
0.2081442028,
0.0564700589,
0.3186999857,
-0.120599173,
-0.1293937862,
-0.8379385471,
-0.3461052477,
-0.4896197617,
-0.7062219977,
-0.2237891704,
-0.3733338118,
0.2057335526,
0.3184613585,
-0.3581755459,
0.2255178243,
-0.3724528551,
0.6833843589,
0.8047127128,
0.4666855633,
0.8158612847,
-0.3653137088,
0.1717404425,
-0.1962841898,
-0.387902528,
-0.5443643332,
1.0222197771,
0.3184248507,
0.421163708,
0.4322763383,
0.5232235789,
0.3659671247,
0.0820898488,
-1.0259898901,
0.845564723,
0.2779691815,
-0.5001140833,
-0.6585472822,
-0.5200051665,
-1.1318050623,
0.4987995923,
-0.3121072948,
-0.8592798114,
0.3948273957,
-0.0746601149,
-0.3859634995,
0.1878293753,
-0.462191999,
0.7817417383,
-0.7737520337,
-0.1562038958,
-0.2842758894,
-0.3161483705,
0.0059984974,
0.1745315194,
0.1594631672,
-0.4131680429,
-0.6819664836,
0.5445349813,
-0.1193918586,
0.6075471044,
-0.3369214237,
0.1697808951,
0.0247978419,
0.459645927,
0.7445768714,
-0.1310192943,
-0.1354542375,
-0.0190512259,
-0.4265009761,
-0.4926704466,
-0.8352819085,
0.1906185448,
-0.5953443646,
-0.6858634353,
-0.2198286802,
-0.6522967815,
-0.3336113095,
-0.0766633898,
0.3706919253,
0.1988899708,
-0.5822176933,
0.0616159253,
0.0652209595,
-0.0138815744,
0.3247893155,
0.7175924182,
-0.110668309,
-0.5258327127,
0.6593316793,
0.0352386497,
0.5737181902,
-0.0166692063,
0.241982609,
-0.2596414089,
-0.7682216167,
-0.1919479966,
0.0347692519,
-0.8318471909,
-0.4136732221,
-0.4859701693,
-0.0545537733,
0.0513172746,
-0.3759323955,
-0.2235056013,
-0.3126914203,
-0.3327097893,
-0.5292485356,
0.3423086405,
0.6797066927,
-0.3972546756,
0.2854394019,
-0.4285393357,
0.4500063956,
0.709828496,
0.2053497881,
0.0728122368,
-0.5197543502,
-0.2240841389,
0.1400542855,
-0.2181190699,
-0.7685682178,
0.3521955013,
0.0357589908,
0.9950933456,
0.4540153444,
0.5093982816,
0.6216024756,
0.0747485012,
0.9378045797,
0.3316167295,
-1.1797152758,
0.1815088838,
-0.3010872006,
0.0776120946,
0.3720411658,
0.0564473942,
-0.0329662636,
-0.688354969,
-0.8022488356,
-0.9417128563,
0.9209123254,
0.4897083044,
0.028120093,
0.2235189378,
-0.0269364454,
0.131362468,
0.2674249709,
-0.5243439078,
-0.2104546279,
0.140880093,
0.0315350108,
-0.1857852489,
-0.4214057624,
-0.1538755596,
-0.1492159069,
0.5996467471,
-0.1490551531,
0.1982779652,
0.1838031262,
-0.2753246427,
0.0085696196,
0.3946530521,
0.32043311,
0.675280273,
-0.2674220204,
0.1033862233,
0.3034406602,
-0.0935052931,
0.2200735807,
0.3488621712,
0.2777733207,
-0.2482528389,
0.3426540494,
0.6125763059,
0.4325699508,
-0.743920505,
0.3985810876,
-0.1514127851,
-0.6166220307,
-0.2684162259,
0.0985115245,
0.166491434,
0.9972546101,
0.5197517872,
-0.0890171155,
0.461961925,
-0.6467219591,
0.0639344677,
0.3279595375,
-0.455817908,
0.1123864725,
0.5915768743,
0.1257472634,
-0.6005311012,
0.7821934819,
-0.3178598285,
-0.4412972927,
0.8288770318,
0.3213754594,
0.8728934526,
-0.1287684441,
0.4842551351,
0.0079662539,
0.5958282948,
-0.0334383771,
0.2726267278,
-0.2314527482,
-0.7465615869,
-0.0038991605,
0.0578939915,
-0.6201786399,
-0.150880456,
-0.9548279047,
0.0839079842,
-0.0192164835,
-0.3786956668,
0.182573691,
0.2614007294,
-0.9180060029,
0.049540136,
-0.0529714972,
0.6721320152,
-0.4855745435,
0.216081664,
0.4582805634,
-0.6117797494,
-0.5531183481,
0.0974551365,
-0.1611951292,
-0.5843235254,
0.3544206321,
-0.0626131445,
-0.043186482,
0.0056529157,
-0.4617433548,
-0.5023466349,
1.2328847647,
0.9955655932,
-0.3578177392,
0.0583627336,
0.0354934931,
0.6012675762,
-0.5546354055,
0.4931425452,
0.7496657968,
0.6607242823,
0.0538668372,
-0.9502249956,
0.1213804185,
-0.0773707554,
-0.1674927473,
-0.0138675543,
-0.4690640867,
0.7521098852,
-0.2003767639,
-0.2044062763,
0.4672778249,
0.3483579159,
0.3360157013,
0.5927122235,
0.725309968,
0.4808008671,
0.9515809417,
0.0197133496,
1.1509821415,
-0.0425104536,
0.3032910824,
1.285924077,
-0.3308519125,
0.8696545362,
0.1184064969,
-0.3394711912,
0.3020114005,
0.3747844696,
0.008135506,
0.0916712433,
0.3198762238,
-0.1952793598,
-0.5272659659,
-0.1376602501,
-0.1390728652,
0.5053558946,
0.1359745711,
-0.4726512134,
-0.0449444465,
-0.1125095189,
-0.0400758497,
0.2970175743,
-0.1719662547,
1.1887814999,
0.1028489321,
-0.3496292531,
0.2994039953,
-0.2608986795,
0.4570417702,
-0.5512119532,
0.1644732952,
-0.3605357409,
0.0353954844,
0.1124764383,
-0.5899688005,
0.0442185737,
-0.2689510584,
-0.0553112105,
-0.0133846123,
0.6076205969,
-0.3939433992,
-0.2780901194,
0.5839634538,
0.7360399365,
0.3480137587,
-0.2309069186,
-0.5916900039,
-0.0198572539,
-0.2217480838,
-0.5172587037,
0.3641556799,
0.3125562966,
0.4593014419,
0.5077824593,
0.5587414503,
0.1519356221,
-0.2327035069,
-0.2377806753,
0.5535361767,
-0.9223444462,
-0.5054827332,
-0.6511263251,
0.7850631475,
-0.478959918,
-0.1446544379,
0.7435562611,
0.6910606623,
0.8389372826,
0.096642755,
0.546890974,
0.3750733733,
0.3500522375,
-0.6367035508,
0.6235838532,
-0.4391571283,
0.3759877384,
0.0246781856,
-1.1884924173,
0.2057522237,
0.3469074965,
-0.1639935225,
0.0392029881,
0.6930246949,
0.4075298905,
0.0753630102,
0.0250973087,
0.6967371106,
0.2598501742,
-0.0669023097,
0.3770004511,
1.2076054811,
-0.3691982627,
1.015694499,
-0.1280102283,
-0.2440563291,
-0.0340157114,
-0.7013770938,
-0.8733547926,
-0.2599149644,
-0.5690882802,
-0.2826195061,
0.1094822884,
0.9174858928,
0.5049616694,
0.0196128786,
-0.6266816854,
0.3531370163,
0.1989261955,
-0.8169500828,
-0.1828595996,
0.1046625823,
-0.4479265809,
-0.8078535795,
0.6954866052,
0.215792045,
0.0543413647,
-0.17119883,
-0.3575285971,
0.1689388603,
0.5315577984,
0.3755826056,
0.1839632243,
-0.5689533353,
0.0571996197,
-0.1332704872,
0.0377461277,
0.0013586482,
0.9390580654,
-0.8153262734,
0.6139189005,
0.0455165133,
0.3354453146,
0.5828153491,
0.121765554,
0.8120436668,
-0.4668279886,
0.2365466356,
0.2926545739,
0.3305139244,
-0.0520844087,
-0.4716044664,
0.6327201128,
-0.2557210922,
-0.5141879916,
-0.7773994803,
0.3387641907,
-0.8561929464,
-0.4186699688,
0.9012280107,
-0.1914309859,
0.1262214184,
-0.2604390681,
-0.3196879029,
0.0562226586,
-0.5586851239,
0.8244717121,
0.3723115027,
-0.0765795782,
-0.1295933425,
-0.2657024562,
0.2910665572,
0.0901525021,
-0.7691284418,
-0.0594318509,
0.7829148173,
-0.3006352186,
-0.0236492548,
0.7853941917,
0.1993337572,
0.4009470046,
0.3297861218,
0.0615785271,
-0.3108593524,
-0.1410473734,
-0.3554884493,
0.2585306764,
0.5633531809,
-0.4503668547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15810v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15810v2
|
OAG-Bench: A Human-Curated Benchmark for Academic Graph Mining
| 2024-02-24T13:15:54 | 2024-06-20T04:15:12 |
Fanjin Zhang, Shijie Shi, Yifan Zhu, Bo Chen, Yukuo Cen, Jifan Yu, Yelin Chen, Lulu Wang, Qingfei Zhao, Yuqing Cheng, Tianyi Han, Yuwei An, Dan Zhang, Weng Lam Tam, Kun Cao, Yunhe Pang, Xinyu Guan, Huihui Yuan, Jian Song, Xiaoyan Li, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the rapid proliferation of scientific literature, versatile academic
knowledge services increasingly rely on comprehensive academic graph mining.
Despite the availability of public academic graphs, benchmarks, and datasets,
these resources often fall short in multi-aspect and fine-grained annotations,
are constrained to specific task types and domains, or lack underlying real
academic graphs. In this paper, we present OAG-Bench, a comprehensive,
multi-aspect, and fine-grained human-curated benchmark based on the Open
Academic Graph (OAG). OAG-Bench covers 10 tasks, 20 datasets, 70+ baselines,
and 120+ experimental results to date. We propose new data annotation
strategies for certain tasks and offer a suite of data pre-processing codes,
algorithm implementations, and standardized evaluation protocols to facilitate
academic graph mining. Extensive experiments reveal that even advanced
algorithms like large language models (LLMs) encounter difficulties in
addressing key challenges in certain tasks, such as paper source tracing and
scholar profiling. We also introduce the Open Academic Graph Challenge
(OAG-Challenge) to encourage community input and sharing. We envisage that
OAG-Bench can serve as a common ground for the community to evaluate and
compare algorithms in academic graph mining, thereby accelerating algorithm
development and advancement in this field. OAG-Bench is accessible at
https://www.aminer.cn/data/.
|
[
-0.5721642971,
-0.5235632062,
0.5572317243,
-0.2461234629,
0.0156846512,
0.3728622198,
-0.2339849472,
-0.6091411114,
0.0063456157,
0.2811275721,
-0.4283108413,
-0.9781996608,
-0.3313736022,
0.045801226,
-0.2907828689,
0.9842552543,
-0.4554142654,
0.1127696782,
-0.7232486606,
-0.4925042689,
-0.1258012056,
-0.3426614702,
-0.5600674748,
-0.5650957823,
0.5911150575,
0.3003219068,
0.1786112636,
0.6909613013,
0.5697131157,
0.2068064958,
0.0331883021,
0.3646726608,
-0.6785492301,
-0.0582664795,
-0.208941564,
-0.2838808298,
-0.5678133965,
0.0742454305,
0.6558713913,
1.1507983208,
-0.0198572185,
0.5372473598,
-0.002284294,
0.7354775071,
-0.7360909581,
0.5834248066,
-0.2715628743,
-0.1940206885,
-0.9131931067,
0.314678371,
-0.2154919207,
-0.3955570757,
-0.1830878109,
-0.6528014541,
0.1349966675,
0.3092517853,
0.8415122032,
0.0239880942,
-0.1109371409,
0.3142624795,
-0.3321811855,
0.5884456635,
-0.1534726173,
0.192991823,
0.434686631,
0.591177702,
-0.1856776625,
-0.8327713013,
-0.2084066123,
0.1741432399,
-0.2573599219,
-0.1727299392,
0.0907079205,
-0.1650255471,
-0.0797595754,
0.3686260283,
-0.391387701,
0.082549423,
-0.3381409645,
-0.0357760005,
0.505662024,
0.1415497661,
-0.051726982,
0.0889929309,
-0.3212171495,
-0.1993662566,
-0.7051401734,
0.0424353108,
0.4513448179,
0.3890710175,
0.2557770014,
0.3552113771,
-0.6095507741,
0.641556561,
-0.4374853075,
0.425059706,
0.472904712,
-0.3506492972,
0.1513658464,
0.0609223209,
0.8813778758,
0.2973124087,
0.1362022609,
-0.3743681014,
-0.0933446288,
0.0998832658,
0.1844520122,
-0.783628583,
-0.3944905698,
0.0287005678,
-0.3855439723,
-0.1852517575,
0.233458057,
-0.99397403,
-0.7160893083,
-0.1424717009,
-0.004506404,
-0.4235915244,
-0.029343199,
-0.1448261738,
-0.1749087274,
-0.2558912635,
0.3572742641,
-0.3952510357,
0.5488497019,
0.7900668979,
1.0487604141,
-0.2140056789,
-0.4093824327,
-0.686422646,
0.1552973986,
-0.0672832653,
1.1097276211,
-0.8635451198,
-0.3587796688,
0.1286323965,
-0.1679109335,
0.1125129461,
-0.4181667864,
0.8892614841,
-0.2410336286,
-0.0978063792,
-0.5789455771,
-0.4557830393,
-0.0795404762,
0.1788218915,
-0.6593100429,
1.2206120491,
0.4513953328,
-0.5866994262,
0.4449616969,
-1.1172063351,
-0.2906159163,
0.375669539,
-0.4593368769,
-0.2456343025,
-0.1307498962,
0.2524472773,
0.204004243,
-0.5706347823,
0.0781711638,
-0.7115716934,
-0.323097229,
-0.0193531141,
0.2958167493,
0.5104166269,
0.0136729339,
-0.0571366474,
0.055871971,
-0.9361186624,
0.1222901791,
0.4994221926,
-0.007155933,
-0.6028855443,
0.3003078699,
0.2799949944,
-0.164917022,
0.225740239,
-0.9346712232,
0.3576847613,
-0.0252294876,
0.7139760256,
0.7919811606,
-0.1199470237,
0.0590072051,
-0.386239022,
0.0467468016,
-0.3487852514,
-0.0613573268,
-0.1190839484,
-0.4649769068,
-0.2911188602,
-0.4874993265,
0.6379694939,
0.286498487,
-0.2183634192,
0.4743683636,
-0.5268972516,
-0.7919952869,
-0.9635716677,
0.1642365158,
0.5377329588,
0.5606611967,
0.545589447,
-0.6858431697,
-0.2403166145,
-0.7098296881,
-0.3726159632,
-0.1360392123,
-0.1157457978,
0.5193970203,
0.5216696262,
-0.1732103676,
1.0950917006,
-0.9764758945,
-0.9142673612,
0.390917927,
0.608304143,
-0.086029835,
0.2398324907,
0.6903322339,
-0.3706485331,
-0.4764161706,
0.1767570823,
-0.7421229482,
-0.4535333216,
0.34051615,
-0.2456724495,
0.0503171273,
0.4489231408,
-0.4062820971,
0.3985437155,
0.1678953767,
-0.438468039,
0.3741475642,
0.0356106423,
0.2778448761,
-0.3007463515,
0.488619566,
0.112132445,
-0.3861509264,
-0.1786211282,
0.250756532,
-0.0674983263,
-0.060484644,
0.0255974345,
0.7110754848,
-0.2378608584,
0.060673967,
-0.0684388429,
0.4154672325,
0.1603518128,
0.3075599074,
-0.2894571126,
0.5187912583,
0.4372110367,
-0.1468452513,
-0.000547389,
0.4889964461,
-0.5972499251,
0.9803751111,
-0.5671226978,
0.2144719213,
-0.1221833825,
0.4024574161,
-0.9510318637,
-0.3338718712,
0.0384695791,
-0.1174453273,
0.1403887719,
-0.1018720567,
-0.7811713219,
-0.3950066864,
-0.4409953058,
0.3995261788,
0.3030055761,
-0.7250425816,
0.3391195536,
0.5666247606,
-0.2083556801,
-0.2264882475,
-0.3394335508,
-0.0316856988,
0.1334960312,
-0.5680776834,
0.7415028214,
0.0508677363,
-0.2174834907,
0.33205235,
-0.0961096585,
-0.0750559345,
0.0301833395,
0.561647296,
0.152898103,
0.1660195738,
-0.0348602198,
-0.1486295015,
-0.0468686223,
0.181137532,
-0.221955508,
0.6126339436,
-0.313964963,
-0.6325672269,
-0.0536912344,
0.2293197364,
0.2805063128,
-0.4583206475,
0.3604426384,
0.8343806267,
-0.4578880668,
-0.0518582016,
-0.3344349861,
-0.032844305,
-0.421420902,
0.2456881553,
-0.1280071586,
-0.6112766862,
0.4201239049,
-0.4414658844,
0.4352857172,
0.5264337659,
0.2162011713,
-0.0625853091,
0.9743968844,
0.1805539578,
-0.3979239762,
0.3025934696,
-0.2362546474,
-0.0356556848,
-0.9373914003,
-0.3234712183,
-1.0118204355,
-0.5824053288,
-0.2208535224,
-0.272611022,
0.2492340356,
0.1361155063,
-0.3746032119,
0.1260845214,
-0.6615365744,
0.5487560034,
0.7220702767,
0.0283854511,
0.3670824468,
-0.0125980759,
-0.0261326693,
0.1632651389,
-0.2547656894,
-0.4755073786,
1.1883261204,
0.1482637674,
0.638672173,
-0.2110195905,
0.8986730576,
0.3005244732,
0.521386683,
-0.2144572139,
0.5844381452,
-0.2342694253,
-0.6119657159,
-0.237272054,
-0.4084590971,
-0.9823191166,
-0.0056383996,
-0.181003809,
-1.0956614017,
0.1351304799,
-0.1771453321,
-0.1373247951,
0.3698095679,
-0.515137434,
1.0095095634,
-0.0937902406,
-0.4681004286,
-0.091836907,
-0.3845124841,
-0.008875668,
-0.1486378908,
0.4994772673,
-0.2879573405,
0.1481612027,
0.8143032193,
-0.4400875866,
0.7535838485,
-0.5431365967,
0.4740039706,
0.3421834707,
-0.1329299062,
0.6354643106,
0.1644513905,
-0.1265906841,
0.6959162951,
0.0237740073,
-0.5145536661,
0.043060258,
1.0700830221,
-0.9112494588,
-0.2914127111,
-0.5619676113,
-0.3762955666,
-0.2125320435,
0.575919807,
-0.0774947107,
0.0962392464,
-0.5269086361,
0.3153523803,
0.129135251,
0.1974758059,
0.3153170943,
0.3642992079,
-0.3847739995,
-0.4320402741,
1.012537241,
0.3730596006,
-0.2281078696,
0.0322729796,
0.0867820606,
-0.2542632818,
-0.8654350042,
-0.5061009526,
0.1489418745,
-0.6966533065,
-0.2419880331,
-0.5323442221,
0.0598413311,
-0.3615297973,
-0.1880325973,
-0.1722819954,
-0.2155340165,
-0.1399584413,
0.0488512069,
0.3700877726,
0.6660735607,
0.2650595605,
0.0331908911,
-0.5725658536,
0.2149908543,
0.0939397812,
0.9729707837,
-0.0535900891,
0.1621174365,
-0.2453927249,
-0.1408642828,
-0.480825752,
-0.2115380764,
-0.1081725508,
0.4671837389,
0.6261854172,
0.3331634998,
0.219426319,
0.6643003225,
-0.6395485997,
0.5516030192,
0.0082169818,
-0.610460043,
0.1861263365,
-0.4222127497,
0.3309012949,
1.1645485163,
0.4050909877,
-0.1160905138,
-0.2723402679,
-0.4049269855,
-1.0986680984,
0.705779314,
0.0986278653,
-0.5320852995,
0.1185164154,
0.2999153137,
0.3994643688,
0.3166142106,
-0.4368032217,
-0.2239881456,
-0.3041330576,
-0.22112149,
-0.0941460356,
0.3418043256,
-0.5994381309,
-0.0900021642,
0.5322129726,
-0.3319762945,
0.0264953002,
0.1038463339,
0.0233475678,
-0.3848527372,
0.1243971661,
-0.0808462128,
0.6574000716,
-0.6559434533,
-0.0608972237,
0.0282107629,
-0.3605843782,
-0.2580193877,
0.6713862419,
-0.361325562,
-0.0233709775,
0.1670575589,
0.5155240893,
0.0524301156,
-0.8365207314,
0.2499238104,
0.0146707399,
-0.2511895895,
-0.2862289846,
0.0928360596,
0.0459612086,
0.0597502217,
0.5419098735,
0.1523879617,
0.209866792,
-0.6826468706,
-0.0601503737,
0.4809778929,
-0.566539824,
-0.179673925,
0.7881198525,
0.1550836414,
-0.2354060262,
0.4646807015,
-0.3879680932,
-0.0721121058,
0.2252400219,
0.0178747568,
0.6833334565,
0.231283918,
0.0618845113,
0.2252007425,
-0.0706366077,
-0.1587692797,
0.2299242616,
0.2262292802,
-0.091528073,
-0.2774255872,
-0.8149248958,
-0.4807077646,
-0.0193990357,
-0.7459806204,
0.4444541931,
-0.4880455136,
-0.1816656142,
0.5921934843,
0.1147097871,
-0.798281908,
-0.0136911878,
0.0071157631,
1.0068911314,
-0.4506156743,
0.821277976,
0.9842969179,
-0.2646746039,
0.1071394086,
-0.4408035576,
0.1894643456,
-0.6899553537,
0.2262059301,
0.4074576199,
0.0284593664,
-0.1095425189,
-0.3828644454,
-0.5219172239,
1.2275166512,
0.1423756331,
-0.5946048498,
0.1453826278,
0.1886406392,
0.605125308,
-0.4148542881,
0.1916062534,
0.693946898,
0.8473708034,
-0.0933512077,
-0.5934702754,
0.1883612424,
-0.3620871603,
-0.3661316633,
0.7575876117,
-0.736806035,
1.020909667,
0.2196982056,
-0.1544513553,
0.0093852486,
0.4598077536,
0.1229904592,
0.6305497885,
0.620875895,
0.7892643809,
0.9761974812,
-0.4405568838,
1.0178369284,
-0.3449792266,
0.3152802289,
1.0870957375,
-0.8588754535,
0.8668909073,
0.3073013723,
-0.360226661,
0.8000116944,
0.5601152778,
-0.3695395589,
0.5600566864,
0.1884959489,
-0.0587921664,
-0.22469607,
-0.6397327185,
-0.5054553151,
0.2556617558,
0.2358973473,
-0.0650705248,
-0.541945219,
-0.2953467965,
-0.0496009327,
0.4080964029,
-0.559687078,
0.6296697855,
-0.1592202634,
-0.6463903189,
0.4332969785,
0.1326913685,
0.282622844,
-0.6571608186,
0.0340569392,
0.0963501558,
0.1907011569,
-0.320504874,
-0.771566987,
0.0036597182,
-0.0432681255,
0.0191894658,
-0.20343858,
0.773190558,
-0.2270822078,
-0.3319838047,
0.334292829,
0.3244231641,
-0.0402826741,
-0.3483207524,
-0.4201862216,
-0.0182342138,
-0.4088353813,
-0.113257125,
0.8633670807,
0.3467266858,
-0.3599849939,
0.3356517255,
0.749935627,
0.0456861109,
-0.3833688796,
0.1329960376,
1.1534852982,
-0.5122181177,
-0.3968756199,
-0.6034367681,
0.2603184581,
-0.4957875311,
-0.3295829296,
0.4841824174,
0.65872401,
0.9580963254,
0.1321640313,
1.0554164648,
-0.2909069359,
0.5798388124,
-0.0574006625,
0.8335037231,
-0.4832468033,
-0.1874955744,
-0.1543934643,
-0.9520726204,
-0.2388546169,
0.4276610613,
-0.3308465183,
-0.1171739027,
0.7023411393,
0.3286677599,
0.0133333523,
0.1678378582,
-0.2847964466,
0.0898361802,
0.4003690183,
0.4296033084,
0.2240806073,
-0.1728666723,
0.7962611318,
-0.1823131144,
-0.4302526712,
-0.5108100176,
-0.8978313804,
-1.1837389469,
-0.4750661254,
-0.486959517,
-0.2568751276,
-0.1079897955,
0.8106190562,
0.6711431742,
-0.8985279202,
-0.1229056939,
-0.2479735017,
-0.0357428826,
-0.5613428354,
-0.1824146211,
0.4765272439,
-0.3091695905,
-0.7289985418,
0.4627783895,
0.2381617725,
-0.2373201251,
-0.4985350668,
0.1148477048,
-0.4230875373,
-0.0585561953,
0.2377188355,
0.4926753342,
-0.2062767744,
-0.4037429392,
-0.1730102152,
-0.0437013656,
0.1616869569,
0.6171229482,
-0.6874155998,
0.6362457871,
0.4287716746,
0.6848028898,
0.7338528633,
0.1048433632,
0.2570217252,
-1.0484473705,
-0.0721129626,
0.1126976758,
0.6511436105,
0.3145759106,
0.0181239378,
0.9832534194,
0.3729260266,
-0.6658774614,
-1.2469214201,
-0.1302983463,
-0.8811368346,
-0.36697644,
0.6841369867,
-0.4419061244,
-0.4217668176,
-0.2546599209,
-0.2813162208,
-0.049275212,
-0.6887544394,
1.1502584219,
0.9183607697,
-0.0480229519,
0.4330665469,
-0.527625978,
0.364844054,
0.0527951568,
-1.0879285336,
0.2414384037,
0.403790921,
-0.1607400626,
0.5265004635,
0.4452799559,
-0.1189580485,
0.1443337351,
-0.0627468824,
0.2437086403,
-0.5231155157,
-0.3431239724,
0.2529163957,
0.7472066879,
0.1770311296,
-0.0292148646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15809v1
|
Empowering Large Language Model Agents through Action Learning
| 2024-02-24T13:13:04 | 2024-02-24T13:13:04 |
Haiteng Zhao, Chang Ma, Guoyin Wang, Jing Su, Lingpeng Kong, Jingjing Xu, Zhi-Hong Deng, Hongxia Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Model (LLM) Agents have recently garnered increasing interest
yet they are limited in their ability to learn from trial and error, a key
element of intelligent behavior. In this work, we argue that the capacity to
learn new actions from experience is fundamental to the advancement of learning
in LLM agents. While humans naturally expand their action spaces and develop
skills through experiential learning, LLM agents typically operate within fixed
action spaces, limiting their potential for growth. To address these
challenges, our study explores open-action learning for language agents. We
introduce a framework LearnAct with an iterative learning strategy to create
and improve actions in the form of Python functions. In each iteration, LLM
revises and updates the currently available actions based on the errors
identified in unsuccessful training tasks, thereby enhancing action
effectiveness. Our experimental evaluations across Robotic Planning and
Alfworld environments reveal that after learning on a few training task
instances, our approach to open-action learning markedly improves agent
performance for the type of task (by 32 percent in AlfWorld compared to
ReAct+Reflexion, for instance) highlighting the importance of experiential
action learning in the development of more intelligent LLM agents.
|
[
0.2972262502,
-0.7443677187,
0.4962753952,
-0.0598147959,
0.2357730716,
0.2241636664,
-0.4285399318,
-0.0388970487,
0.1811178774,
0.4297454357,
-0.4699055851,
-0.4493816495,
-0.438801527,
-0.1671977788,
0.0320457518,
0.8176044226,
-0.2906669974,
-0.1296761781,
0.0057292003,
-0.3496243358,
-0.3318371773,
-0.1934091747,
-0.974460423,
-0.6246954799,
0.6298060417,
0.4868449569,
0.6917819977,
0.3798479736,
0.3304943144,
0.437733531,
0.184589237,
0.3804457188,
-0.55370152,
0.0985949561,
-0.4771338999,
-0.5477170348,
-0.3678127825,
-0.1228012666,
0.8045572042,
0.6969557405,
-0.5205801725,
-0.1912855208,
-0.0892948955,
0.6615079641,
-0.452695936,
0.6532744765,
-0.3429148495,
0.1770658642,
0.2712982297,
-0.0814298242,
-0.3844991028,
-0.1313316077,
-0.0561544187,
-0.7226756811,
-0.0824847966,
0.0223453268,
0.3904177845,
0.3369481862,
-0.1707495302,
-0.3724519908,
-0.967526257,
0.6678159237,
-0.6352238655,
0.2613661587,
0.1796274781,
0.3293451071,
-0.4466695487,
-0.6696389318,
-0.6437289715,
-0.3654457927,
0.1141336486,
0.0057816203,
0.0172547698,
0.0987791047,
0.4327893555,
0.0430801883,
-0.4354929924,
0.2959533036,
-0.2384686172,
0.0301210303,
0.5100337863,
0.2147984803,
0.2916189134,
0.3152910173,
-0.259955138,
-0.633022964,
-0.7250057459,
0.3976700008,
0.3029091656,
0.5436149836,
-0.0170033462,
0.6104736328,
-0.1961079389,
0.3772651255,
-0.4301481247,
-0.1365956664,
0.085377641,
0.1805985272,
-0.4622331858,
-0.179692924,
0.497735709,
-0.1223408803,
0.2099895924,
-0.136937663,
-0.3904594779,
-0.3314875364,
0.5888559818,
-0.5824493766,
0.046274215,
0.4158006907,
-0.0763721168,
-0.0043911133,
0.2406429201,
-0.4431050718,
-0.6904992461,
-0.2451367229,
0.6934725046,
-0.6446807981,
-0.437789619,
0.2294694781,
-0.0871723592,
0.4798004925,
0.6177363396,
-0.7224826813,
0.3449302018,
0.7337258458,
0.5562028289,
0.1083301678,
-0.8063734174,
-0.9019412994,
0.114387542,
-0.718133688,
0.6472608447,
-0.5906515718,
-0.1217034161,
0.3488041162,
-0.0751244202,
-0.371448487,
-0.6997280121,
0.108480148,
-0.6341825128,
-0.2312557548,
0.0287767705,
-0.4195781946,
-0.5623295903,
0.3598465323,
-0.6570968032,
0.6866003275,
0.4432809353,
0.0257748105,
0.4873242974,
-1.1580787897,
-0.455467701,
0.0844695419,
-0.2111362368,
-0.2785563767,
0.2546086311,
-0.1188485697,
0.439524591,
0.1087233052,
-0.0397933125,
-0.3141927421,
-0.179952085,
0.4138805568,
-0.1362948865,
0.437600255,
-0.1293094605,
-0.359308362,
0.4629318714,
-0.3733792603,
0.1104625911,
0.2295393497,
-0.6738387942,
-0.1484047472,
0.2580420971,
-0.4361751676,
0.2590301037,
-0.098775804,
-0.3204873204,
0.4527272284,
-0.5464197993,
0.1707490534,
0.8573830724,
-0.1070514321,
0.581756115,
-0.3706376851,
0.487999022,
-0.0711172,
0.0179795623,
-0.4330173731,
-0.0496221557,
-0.7972496152,
-0.1965405345,
-0.0290067103,
0.249094829,
-0.975353837,
0.2281080037,
-0.1990181357,
-0.3745142221,
-0.1796711385,
0.4929447472,
0.2709621489,
0.0970296338,
0.1507922113,
-0.4022840261,
-0.1964806169,
-0.206189543,
-0.2362747341,
-0.3208304346,
0.2974460721,
0.4448904991,
0.746856451,
-0.2157669961,
0.7897560596,
-0.3592103124,
-0.4189454317,
-0.6519066095,
0.1434542388,
0.0954416692,
0.2879430652,
0.2827046514,
-0.7570749521,
-0.2804989517,
0.2530486286,
-0.8814222217,
0.3689952791,
-0.1816062182,
0.0737445578,
0.3423227668,
0.5582671165,
-0.6233866215,
0.4946010113,
0.3175649941,
-0.4371409714,
0.223479107,
-0.6589067578,
-0.0738903359,
-0.6592671871,
-0.0633197501,
-0.25562343,
-0.192208305,
-0.7450593114,
0.3949653804,
0.0919340551,
-0.2301774621,
-0.7803470492,
0.8921686411,
-0.4009702504,
-0.3339006901,
-0.4236966074,
0.1071798131,
-0.453971684,
0.931902349,
0.2940259874,
0.4140253365,
0.6097695231,
-0.7820039392,
0.2670759857,
0.1496043205,
-0.2122262865,
0.1117176935,
-0.4337677658,
0.1465799361,
-0.0649244487,
0.1409164369,
-0.812479198,
-0.5192881823,
0.2050247788,
-0.3206051588,
0.3353173733,
0.2963040173,
-0.4802232683,
-0.2610290051,
-0.2477916628,
-0.0546338595,
0.3597432375,
-0.6579425335,
1.0585633516,
0.0566209406,
-0.0156384688,
-0.6726391315,
-0.2683854997,
-0.1863947511,
-0.0067464504,
-0.3212583661,
-0.2097369879,
0.0218713693,
-0.4691409171,
-0.1209552735,
-0.1278504878,
0.1225319728,
0.2817366123,
0.3669533134,
-0.1645958871,
-0.0615880117,
0.3702128232,
-0.1537637264,
0.0217779391,
-0.060010653,
-0.313203603,
0.7606084943,
-0.1266710609,
-0.6783915758,
-0.0746057108,
0.2324173748,
0.7136129141,
-0.35945189,
0.8193555474,
0.1840259433,
-0.3127133548,
-0.6424316168,
-0.0057225819,
-0.1170344502,
-0.489384234,
0.5921979547,
0.0388059765,
-0.7419983149,
0.2533985376,
-0.5071455836,
0.4665608406,
-0.0316578113,
0.4551413953,
-0.1887521893,
0.6995583177,
1.1418759823,
0.1216614544,
0.7144262791,
-0.4434025288,
0.2200229764,
-0.7011420727,
-0.2792985141,
-0.25778687,
-0.4569508731,
-0.1080594286,
-0.851403594,
0.1788590848,
0.0413718112,
-0.6076213121,
0.2350087464,
0.24931705,
0.3085356355,
0.4758839309,
0.159341529,
0.1259703934,
0.1354071647,
-0.0326926261,
0.181295529,
-0.6182755828,
-0.4937883317,
1.1113984585,
0.3525792658,
0.8271358609,
0.5191894174,
0.806440413,
0.3265439868,
0.4753555655,
-1.0707250834,
0.5812320709,
0.2057211399,
-0.0813080892,
-0.7179471254,
-0.0959142745,
-1.0429701805,
0.2185491174,
-0.0866715387,
-0.5992324352,
-0.0381914936,
0.111718595,
-0.2775172591,
0.3776209056,
-0.5634914637,
0.6712480187,
-0.3884745538,
-0.4183101952,
-0.5307385325,
-0.2969703972,
-0.1526159048,
-0.0283183679,
0.1970394552,
0.1530340761,
-0.4680383801,
0.4686627686,
-0.3577535152,
1.2004147768,
-0.3675736189,
-0.4167812467,
0.300580591,
0.1478041112,
0.8778350353,
-0.2712907195,
-0.0668485537,
-0.2880862355,
-0.88015306,
-0.3963538408,
-0.8999498487,
0.2616132498,
-0.7770119905,
-0.5952968001,
-0.3454230428,
-0.605787456,
-0.3133175671,
0.1919366121,
-0.441439867,
0.3442332745,
-0.371876061,
0.2853028178,
0.7919430733,
-0.4269754589,
0.881550312,
1.1099247932,
-0.3899315298,
-0.3978822529,
0.800146699,
-0.040001303,
0.4697945416,
0.5284113884,
0.1213118955,
-0.1373348385,
-0.5545400381,
-0.1539326161,
0.4321240783,
-0.7345967293,
-0.002234394,
-0.5668843389,
0.0220771171,
-0.3923769891,
-0.1817432195,
-0.3184067905,
-0.0756454915,
-0.0529620349,
-0.1570005119,
0.2540168166,
0.7716948986,
-0.2180187702,
0.4809087515,
-0.4794754088,
0.1589945853,
0.4259281754,
0.1887101382,
0.1070770696,
-0.4048007429,
-0.3378018439,
-0.0306207091,
-0.5065213442,
-0.446887821,
0.5860599279,
0.4937617481,
0.7077257037,
0.5643199086,
0.0289768372,
0.4294528067,
-0.4536825418,
0.6564855576,
0.1124211699,
-0.5892013907,
0.6257703304,
-0.3188825548,
0.277956903,
0.1178755239,
0.37242347,
-0.5715386271,
-0.3748703897,
-0.8387470841,
-0.8523035049,
0.9435281754,
-0.0404261462,
0.3172999024,
0.1978015304,
0.2068210393,
0.1140548885,
0.418048948,
-0.7864735126,
0.0503531992,
0.0851734802,
-0.0040704119,
-0.3678077459,
0.2492154241,
-0.3099610806,
-0.0675623193,
0.6544877887,
-0.721241653,
0.2941313088,
0.0729637146,
-0.3048393428,
-0.2464757711,
0.2426896393,
0.5682226419,
0.5618994236,
0.2253204882,
-0.103460364,
0.1518359035,
-0.418056041,
0.0671286136,
-0.1476579905,
0.2534732521,
-0.5364074707,
0.6926168203,
0.9222024679,
0.2751630843,
-1.2436146736,
0.5439519882,
0.0751768053,
-0.1698494554,
-0.5380613208,
0.6250625849,
0.018100515,
0.7248134017,
0.3715615869,
0.0247328635,
-0.3033652604,
-0.9621191621,
0.2021459192,
0.2819605768,
-0.6023865938,
-0.1551029682,
0.138836652,
0.0451027006,
-0.7554565072,
0.5985667706,
-0.2081739306,
-0.4907090962,
0.8021828532,
0.5987868905,
0.9205159545,
-0.2590845823,
0.4437553883,
0.2303494513,
0.4208776355,
-0.2162534446,
0.3072451651,
-0.2519946098,
-0.8638000488,
-0.4499125779,
-0.5612922907,
-0.6870914102,
0.1027680486,
-0.3817459047,
0.2543367743,
-0.7020273209,
0.4163950086,
-0.6088520885,
0.1373923719,
-0.535330832,
0.1689298749,
-0.0277645867,
0.9960135221,
-0.845351994,
0.8976082802,
1.0738456249,
-0.4569310248,
-1.1071288586,
0.1801117957,
-0.1461651921,
-0.886115849,
0.7849158645,
0.2694436014,
-0.0337704867,
-0.0413071178,
-0.6621168256,
-0.8328864574,
1.2238864899,
0.228611052,
-0.363106221,
0.0303301122,
0.0388607644,
0.6683630347,
-0.4968844652,
0.2128121853,
0.3364215791,
0.2437525392,
0.0685801432,
-0.5374862552,
-0.0487870872,
-0.0644851774,
-0.1577965617,
0.2896914482,
-0.8536581993,
0.8456693292,
-0.7379055023,
-0.1784962118,
0.005538966,
0.8760378957,
0.3083162308,
0.2773849964,
0.5020437241,
0.4822889268,
0.8973719478,
0.0506272502,
0.9770948291,
0.2690373063,
0.3415033519,
1.1489748955,
-0.6416930556,
1.1339093447,
0.3241021633,
0.0510541163,
0.6217608452,
0.2603629231,
0.3622937799,
0.5255655646,
0.1164275631,
-0.351087451,
-0.3229706585,
0.2639685571,
0.3719900548,
0.5611932278,
0.6069366336,
-0.2871194482,
-0.454862535,
0.4431704283,
-0.0061996048,
0.2236917466,
-0.5147985816,
0.8776983619,
-0.0942450389,
-0.7205850482,
0.1744690537,
-0.3102271259,
0.2651194334,
-0.8446109891,
-0.52040869,
-0.1593936682,
0.5442137718,
-0.0245104376,
-0.6564338207,
0.1269618571,
-0.1692833304,
0.1820553243,
-0.2565122545,
0.5777242184,
-0.3461997807,
0.1013596505,
0.5883566141,
0.5029819012,
0.1877729893,
0.0501628034,
-0.5575891137,
-0.0652700439,
-0.0906877965,
-0.4119553566,
0.4600907266,
0.4922964573,
-0.1505930722,
1.0394711494,
0.4380599558,
0.2374861538,
-0.2098730952,
-0.2777405977,
0.8785269856,
-0.7009652257,
-0.3016811013,
-0.6193618178,
0.6571119428,
-0.1049266979,
-0.1477986127,
0.3940961659,
0.1942878962,
0.9691755176,
-0.0749856308,
0.8460766673,
-0.3452767432,
0.3241993785,
-0.5925495625,
0.5641211867,
-0.5405982733,
0.2005539238,
-0.0228281114,
-0.6543370485,
-0.1401012689,
0.5540724993,
-0.2919652462,
0.0641708001,
0.8658571839,
0.8801380396,
0.0993371159,
-0.2124269456,
0.67614609,
0.3114467263,
0.5923530459,
0.5379463434,
0.7897840738,
-0.2960365713,
0.4095819592,
-0.062021859,
-0.3976479471,
-0.1309216172,
-0.7815591693,
-0.9533563256,
-0.479329139,
-0.2591137886,
-0.2146113813,
-0.0255445596,
1.2745519876,
0.4048312902,
-0.5879881978,
-0.3899031579,
-0.2090357095,
0.2483323514,
-0.8415424228,
-0.1478831768,
0.258990407,
-0.7069014907,
-0.9059470296,
0.5462168455,
0.3673262298,
-0.0991764367,
-0.175929755,
-0.5627042055,
-0.17200993,
0.1068700701,
0.68028754,
0.9014615417,
-0.5163950324,
-0.2114156187,
-0.1094812453,
0.1040921137,
-0.0429601669,
1.0703173876,
-0.7806259394,
0.322188735,
0.1688004136,
0.8774957061,
0.1157537326,
-0.3805525601,
0.7010535002,
-0.6517414451,
0.1024997085,
0.1222773567,
0.3654440343,
0.1753175259,
-0.2191439867,
0.6493954659,
0.0618358217,
-0.4234793186,
-0.6558043361,
0.1151115447,
-0.7078713775,
-0.3041662574,
1.3787994385,
-0.3750201464,
-0.5541126728,
0.0448708497,
-0.431648612,
0.2202888131,
-0.4869579077,
0.5609083176,
0.4355665147,
-0.3565749526,
-0.1550438255,
-0.4712868035,
0.4329028428,
0.1668862551,
-1.0308760405,
0.454547435,
0.3601019382,
0.059621349,
0.2432255,
0.6016336679,
0.0953398272,
0.5238916278,
-0.047954537,
0.2042763084,
-0.1235815138,
-0.8041838408,
-0.6151595116,
0.1929389536,
0.3702361286,
0.006737153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00807v1
|
Enhancing Cloud-Based Large Language Model Processing with Elasticsearch and Transformer Models
| 2024-02-24T12:31:22 | 2024-02-24T12:31:22 |
Chunhe Ni, Jiang Wu, Hongbo Wang, Wenran Lu, Chenwei Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.DL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are a class of generative AI models built using
the Transformer network, capable of leveraging vast datasets to identify,
summarize, translate, predict, and generate language. LLMs promise to
revolutionize society, yet training these foundational models poses immense
challenges. Semantic vector search within large language models is a potent
technique that can significantly enhance search result accuracy and relevance.
Unlike traditional keyword-based search methods, semantic search utilizes the
meaning and context of words to grasp the intent behind queries and deliver
more precise outcomes. Elasticsearch emerges as one of the most popular tools
for implementing semantic search an exceptionally scalable and robust search
engine designed for indexing and searching extensive datasets. In this article,
we delve into the fundamentals of semantic search and explore how to harness
Elasticsearch and Transformer models to bolster large language model processing
paradigms. We gain a comprehensive understanding of semantic search principles
and acquire practical skills for implementing semantic search in real-world
model application scenarios.
|
[
-0.4062237442,
-0.8084517121,
0.9073852897,
-0.0223980788,
-0.0355388187,
0.1283935159,
-0.2710310817,
-0.5229254961,
0.2118149996,
0.8503044844,
-0.7843637466,
-0.6205263138,
-0.7197381854,
0.1515675634,
-0.9040307403,
0.3600721359,
-0.0036209407,
0.1034287885,
-0.2341258228,
0.1301825643,
-0.3519558311,
-0.5118198991,
-0.5677139759,
-0.2979259789,
0.3795261085,
0.2333790213,
1.019515872,
0.8459998965,
0.5552137494,
0.4094946384,
-0.3717770576,
0.0061787684,
-0.608286202,
0.6792913079,
-0.2607244253,
-0.759401679,
0.0508385748,
-0.2522332072,
0.6661266088,
0.5182934403,
-0.2284163088,
-0.1206254065,
-0.4239748418,
0.4273044169,
-0.5246367455,
0.3030952513,
-1.2740677595,
-0.0170451757,
-0.381062001,
-0.23007828,
-0.1631390452,
0.0690315142,
0.159334138,
-0.5730604529,
0.5716953874,
-0.0091175493,
0.7031247616,
0.3846734166,
-0.4708383679,
-0.1967538744,
-0.7037185431,
0.83290869,
-0.6588310599,
0.7468957901,
0.4115459323,
0.5202627778,
-0.5573897958,
-1.078918457,
-0.5990930796,
-0.2355618179,
0.1194845662,
-0.1981636584,
0.0839942172,
0.2155604661,
0.1154928356,
0.445733875,
-0.4387679696,
0.6012193561,
-0.2612004578,
-0.0167739484,
0.6069099903,
0.4482117593,
0.3927845955,
-0.039776288,
-0.1150898188,
-0.2699424028,
-0.7253775001,
-0.0812182203,
0.0384682491,
0.5072151423,
0.4396194518,
0.7697638869,
-0.3664075732,
0.7626050711,
-0.5195864439,
-0.0666246787,
-0.1152365878,
-0.1976895332,
-0.0482951067,
0.0851417631,
0.4201054871,
0.069351688,
-0.181236133,
-0.5364246368,
-0.6213742495,
0.3040535748,
0.6146037579,
-0.8117547631,
0.3644457161,
0.34980762,
-0.4115453959,
-0.212079972,
0.0852243155,
-0.633259356,
-0.3025757372,
-0.5490322113,
0.1049314737,
-0.1600317657,
0.0434999093,
0.3703771234,
-0.2611634731,
0.6044842005,
0.242072925,
-0.8263147473,
0.5089683533,
1.2265794277,
0.6535333991,
-0.0190776214,
-0.3671585917,
-0.5230344534,
0.0866266266,
-0.3987755775,
0.7258284688,
-0.8350014687,
-0.3953045309,
0.3754862249,
0.1882107556,
0.1833364367,
-0.4617318809,
0.904805541,
-1.1478849649,
-0.017436441,
0.0935072154,
-0.7918339968,
-0.3731759489,
0.1371192932,
-0.8502457142,
1.1083527803,
-0.0077867997,
-0.3655986488,
0.2579597831,
-0.7048276067,
-0.4127652347,
0.5134015679,
-0.0618434362,
-0.2857470214,
0.4099702239,
0.4232864678,
0.7878090143,
-0.9228002429,
0.2486957014,
-0.2924674153,
-0.356866926,
0.0667290464,
0.0163736586,
0.2202322334,
0.0499678627,
-0.4076423943,
0.0898413882,
-0.5599814057,
0.0932832062,
0.493121475,
-0.0656068325,
-0.4723889232,
0.4251552522,
0.3856470287,
0.1755622029,
0.3546753824,
-0.4290930033,
0.0908250511,
-0.5585574508,
0.7655651569,
0.3722201586,
-0.4133171439,
0.3680644333,
0.0411247723,
0.4850731492,
-0.1609742492,
0.0675160736,
-0.2649211586,
-0.2861223519,
-0.7345964909,
-0.1077952608,
0.1620945185,
0.3475482166,
-0.6159647703,
0.6546550989,
-0.5149473548,
-0.7543446422,
-0.9198777676,
0.2922888398,
-0.2151485831,
0.1695370078,
0.3791604638,
0.1440493166,
-0.5447736382,
-0.9477329254,
-0.1094598919,
0.312893033,
-0.1852822453,
0.3187203407,
0.3919519186,
-0.8357707858,
0.9207632542,
-0.639197886,
-0.4815630317,
-0.2242867053,
-0.101649873,
0.240840286,
-0.0315640904,
0.2582333088,
-1.3623944521,
-0.0330571532,
0.0064313766,
-0.5085453391,
0.0370060951,
0.3108237386,
-0.0341173671,
0.070918873,
0.8329817057,
-0.6889079213,
0.243016243,
0.5970266461,
-0.1943694055,
0.0859362483,
-0.2218057513,
-0.0712945685,
-1.0218666792,
0.0157060809,
-0.1524445713,
-0.3700488806,
-0.340788722,
0.6570105553,
-0.0094672404,
-0.262737602,
-0.473811388,
0.4489141703,
-0.3102380633,
-0.2331340015,
-0.5272169113,
0.3392640352,
-0.0461408794,
-0.1347992718,
0.1676041037,
0.8704084754,
0.7053841949,
-0.7980625033,
0.7326526046,
0.3334837258,
-0.414478749,
0.1789782792,
-0.8261119723,
0.0591467954,
-0.3532947004,
0.4173695147,
-0.8177660108,
-0.1993500441,
-0.7618845105,
-0.0707161948,
-0.0008047767,
0.0319095813,
-0.8194441199,
-0.560680449,
-0.2853232622,
0.1557791382,
0.3994675279,
-0.8135294914,
0.8325634599,
0.6468675137,
-0.1743630022,
-0.4223263562,
-0.4634117186,
0.3257444501,
-0.065004915,
-0.8513572812,
0.834802568,
0.3154398203,
-0.0769863874,
0.073911801,
0.1280574501,
-0.1185406819,
0.4324338734,
0.1330421865,
0.3312396705,
-0.2296733409,
0.1560971439,
-0.2099781632,
-0.1904330254,
-0.069237344,
-0.3855087161,
1.0176802874,
-0.1524226964,
-0.3282334208,
-0.0972102806,
0.4066168368,
0.9785530567,
-0.4681714177,
0.940710783,
0.4526788294,
-0.4505190253,
-0.3007427454,
-0.78962183,
-0.3922160566,
-0.4793164134,
0.577381134,
-0.3889600933,
-1.2893834114,
0.6275216937,
-0.1611123681,
-0.1631250232,
0.7681946754,
0.7593942285,
0.0589426421,
1.2464405298,
0.8264663219,
-0.1989807934,
0.468346566,
-0.1719341576,
0.3532248437,
-0.8905858397,
-0.2025613934,
-0.8357070684,
-0.1052027717,
-1.0104488134,
-0.4036775827,
0.3808670044,
-0.1753968149,
-0.231466651,
0.4325583875,
-0.5195663571,
0.5001734495,
0.5482448339,
-0.0012360421,
0.1438732743,
-0.0356331617,
0.0282892492,
-0.0549016148,
-0.5142641664,
-0.3534269631,
0.8750383854,
0.3946103752,
0.8638671041,
-0.0115036769,
0.352145344,
0.0554228611,
-0.1948187351,
-1.1667028666,
0.5321425796,
-0.2635933757,
-0.5080329776,
-0.5324594975,
-0.3373401761,
-1.2832913399,
0.4255427718,
-0.3069838583,
-0.4122155309,
-0.3135611117,
-0.3412780166,
0.2508553565,
0.2783748507,
-0.2198393345,
0.6829782724,
-0.5699496269,
-0.0988722891,
-0.5916546583,
-0.4682341516,
0.0798747763,
-0.2272116691,
0.1166343987,
0.0463038236,
-0.2714174688,
0.5147304535,
-0.3119692802,
0.4799817801,
0.2223055363,
-0.0497490577,
-0.0399351567,
0.1156004742,
0.8596127629,
-0.183989346,
-0.0495076478,
0.2448221594,
-0.0027334385,
-0.3031725585,
-0.5739335418,
0.7912358642,
-0.7348257303,
-0.7735339403,
-0.1822689474,
-0.4282020926,
-0.0465770438,
0.3543242216,
0.0913700089,
0.0074763997,
-0.3162774444,
0.5651148558,
0.709844172,
-0.2142919451,
0.1692287475,
0.5617238283,
-0.4250295758,
-0.0942568406,
0.6630333662,
-0.0187109113,
-0.1745394915,
0.8043325543,
0.2792779803,
-0.6296825409,
-0.4184821248,
-0.0340116732,
0.3661764264,
-0.7052003145,
-0.1345623434,
-0.8275826573,
-0.3568135202,
-0.487310499,
-0.2996862829,
-0.5039868355,
-0.0792983249,
-0.1473936439,
-0.0535213016,
0.5363426208,
0.6611885428,
0.7341572642,
0.3786159456,
-0.8314116597,
0.3084425926,
0.2691518068,
0.5291754603,
-0.042225495,
-0.2792650461,
-0.063449949,
-0.0581911728,
-0.0455683917,
-0.4449073076,
0.5787896514,
-0.0061946167,
0.73178792,
-0.0225668661,
-0.1994478852,
0.5841034651,
-0.6470249891,
0.8576866984,
-0.1229563057,
-0.972248435,
0.5808250308,
-0.3055513799,
0.1353086382,
0.3604698777,
0.3959808946,
-0.8112727404,
-0.1916142404,
-0.6657956243,
-1.3125751019,
0.683182478,
0.0882519037,
0.291230768,
0.233498022,
0.3287028968,
-0.1449596584,
0.2349220216,
-0.3664389551,
0.030553164,
0.0267058406,
-0.1360384673,
-0.3479320109,
-0.3277721703,
-0.0016786646,
-0.1146411896,
0.6907356381,
-0.2046611905,
0.1338608414,
-0.0975793377,
-0.216360718,
0.1192856729,
0.1758835912,
0.3509326577,
0.3049468994,
-0.0149456505,
0.1197236776,
0.103945531,
-0.262709111,
-0.0360855386,
0.1602452099,
-0.0987598673,
0.0082030306,
0.1445948631,
0.9331129789,
0.3151973486,
-1.0209335089,
0.5030801296,
-0.1995823085,
0.0647668317,
-0.6746655107,
0.1084165275,
0.3800058365,
0.190272823,
0.3634490669,
-0.6457062364,
0.354157269,
-0.3598186374,
0.0792515203,
0.7127833366,
-0.031572558,
-0.0204296447,
0.791194737,
-0.0532880574,
-0.3614673615,
0.9116477966,
0.4312668741,
-0.8619247675,
0.6258558631,
0.6350722909,
0.9951783419,
-0.1801665127,
-0.0813118219,
-0.1723266095,
0.3299653232,
-0.3978643417,
0.0101372767,
-0.0973089635,
-0.7523762584,
-0.5224353075,
-0.8386173248,
-0.5459706783,
0.3525108695,
-0.3847411573,
0.6269122362,
-0.1845867634,
0.0411956571,
0.1850025952,
-0.163372919,
-0.9269951582,
0.1772545725,
0.2157393247,
1.1313157082,
-0.5760900974,
0.5654097795,
0.8109411001,
-0.1899932623,
-0.5749967098,
-0.2711116076,
-0.1268179268,
-0.9641466141,
0.8403683901,
0.112486586,
-0.1932568252,
-0.1023582593,
-0.6227115989,
-1.1020516157,
1.0996189117,
0.3730942607,
-0.5631777644,
-0.0719003081,
0.3917509615,
0.771351099,
-0.3521067798,
0.3195557892,
0.5774823427,
0.3462832272,
0.2622081041,
-0.6956344843,
-0.0843745396,
0.0399416946,
0.7141366601,
0.3570135236,
-0.3791130483,
0.6705776453,
0.4481982887,
-0.0330456346,
-0.1710740924,
0.6409115195,
0.085269019,
-0.0007032203,
0.3801690042,
0.5586004853,
0.7162207961,
-0.0502349287,
1.3081336021,
-0.5622009635,
0.2779910266,
0.7199501991,
-0.5464115739,
1.1579813957,
0.3199900985,
0.0143090896,
0.1659053862,
0.5659096837,
0.0193650853,
0.2693894506,
0.1552713215,
-0.3446807861,
-0.4099028111,
-0.2368613482,
0.0152856791,
0.765752852,
0.5905517936,
-0.3733370602,
-0.3750320971,
-0.1246947572,
-0.0691698268,
0.2383776009,
-0.4273848534,
0.8189121485,
0.0007603606,
-0.5452523232,
0.4054808021,
0.4142664969,
0.7012199759,
-0.7309520245,
0.0302808564,
0.1824695021,
0.2509494424,
-0.1931825876,
-0.7213565707,
0.2790516317,
-0.206920445,
-0.3339535594,
-0.1555285752,
0.8287746906,
-0.3754765391,
-0.5897652507,
0.6606069803,
0.3089667559,
-0.1091808081,
-0.2614532411,
-0.6701898575,
0.2317799926,
-0.5048057437,
-0.2657262683,
0.2892509401,
0.3816026449,
-0.1570342183,
0.8471795917,
0.8515117168,
0.2280007005,
0.0860848874,
0.0532608144,
0.8435195684,
-0.8444638848,
-0.5854150653,
-0.7175840735,
0.024548538,
0.0643220842,
0.0819442943,
0.392013669,
0.4960660934,
0.8971285224,
0.0096853636,
0.7402792573,
0.1782980114,
0.5018468499,
-0.6463916302,
0.5265449286,
-0.6125535965,
0.1517670453,
0.0475014374,
-1.2255988121,
-0.4422396719,
0.611976862,
-0.271319747,
-0.1109784693,
0.3808913231,
1.0182696581,
-0.204859972,
0.0825453699,
0.5225704312,
0.2925605476,
0.6731896996,
0.1082866639,
0.8126889467,
-0.3684909642,
0.1272306293,
0.0634679198,
0.0363957584,
-0.3902995288,
-0.8358793855,
-0.5188865662,
-0.8337906003,
0.149266094,
-0.2056799829,
-0.248235479,
0.9347302914,
0.6339049935,
-0.528534174,
-0.2597397268,
-0.3496144414,
0.1486840695,
-0.0619492643,
-0.2509324849,
0.2525651455,
-0.6872501969,
-0.8602837324,
0.6635891199,
0.2282377481,
-0.1366789043,
-0.5014364719,
0.1036812738,
-0.0061340854,
0.0249487963,
0.7023923397,
-0.0212903507,
-0.666300118,
0.0205167904,
0.0400477462,
-0.2494151294,
-0.1583414376,
0.9590852857,
-0.8889374733,
0.4153026938,
0.546482563,
1.2680588961,
0.7773647904,
-0.3496032357,
0.6281405091,
-0.2491323799,
0.2539931834,
0.2959582806,
0.5123448372,
0.4644623399,
-0.521052599,
0.5157489181,
0.0372542404,
-0.5605835319,
-0.6901996136,
0.1912628561,
-0.8704945445,
-0.3520840704,
1.0815191269,
0.4180974364,
-0.4699264169,
0.0442656316,
-0.1143213958,
0.0588543527,
-0.1677053869,
0.7050516009,
0.6531280279,
0.1665323675,
-0.011609924,
-0.6900709271,
0.1564327627,
0.3682175577,
-0.5739322305,
0.0526021197,
0.288649112,
0.1205862984,
0.1222960949,
-0.0701744854,
-0.2503299415,
-0.0278023202,
-0.2363610268,
0.1722028702,
0.0558240041,
-0.1283194721,
-0.4830255508,
0.2540944815,
0.1476902515,
0.2353270799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00806v1
|
Enhanced User Interaction in Operating Systems through Machine Learning Language Models
| 2024-02-24T12:17:06 | 2024-02-24T12:17:06 |
Chenwei Zhang, Wenran Lu, Chunhe Ni, Hongbo Wang, Jiang Wu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
With the large language model showing human-like logical reasoning and
understanding ability, whether agents based on the large language model can
simulate the interaction behavior of real users, so as to build a reliable
virtual recommendation A/B test scene to help the application of recommendation
research is an urgent, important and economic value problem. The combination of
interaction design and machine learning can provide a more efficient and
personalized user experience for products and services. This personalized
service can meet the specific needs of users and improve user satisfaction and
loyalty. Second, the interactive system can understand the user's views and
needs for the product by providing a good user interface and interactive
experience, and then use machine learning algorithms to improve and optimize
the product. This iterative optimization process can continuously improve the
quality and performance of the product to meet the changing needs of users. At
the same time, designers need to consider how these algorithms and tools can be
combined with interactive systems to provide a good user experience. This paper
explores the potential applications of large language models, machine learning
and interaction design for user interaction in recommendation systems and
operating systems. By integrating these technologies, more intelligent and
personalized services can be provided to meet user needs and promote continuous
improvement and optimization of products. This is of great value for both
recommendation research and user experience applications.
|
[
-0.5730347633,
-0.9242515564,
0.7137545347,
0.1958482563,
0.0963614285,
0.1730916947,
-0.116263859,
-0.7594437599,
0.0679605752,
0.5871804953,
-0.5789489746,
-0.0787877664,
-0.0033070461,
-0.0350359827,
-0.13512142,
0.7569257021,
-0.0458380356,
0.115034543,
-0.4010229111,
0.0200141408,
-0.6762216091,
-0.9191747308,
-0.6736459136,
-0.5476749539,
0.378354162,
0.2104668766,
0.8055416346,
0.0523772128,
0.5565907359,
0.5155118704,
0.2224048674,
0.2499247789,
-0.2355334759,
0.3522842526,
-0.1951643974,
-0.2266224325,
-0.2867951095,
-0.1157468036,
0.4607450962,
0.812479496,
-0.1011996642,
-0.3538920581,
0.0730742589,
0.7328940034,
-0.3895578384,
0.2442383468,
0.0605863072,
0.1292547435,
0.3278165758,
-0.1306987107,
-0.4114895165,
-0.451040715,
0.3783022463,
-0.9264977574,
-0.4148873687,
0.5044730902,
0.7281700373,
0.0955360532,
-0.3004845977,
-0.4596437514,
-1.0017540455,
1.085419178,
-0.7135506868,
0.6490549445,
0.3312608302,
0.3426586688,
-0.5422099829,
-0.4617164731,
-0.5992280245,
-0.7385579944,
-0.18319498,
-0.2799553275,
-0.2399823219,
0.1899305433,
0.3583216965,
0.2817189395,
-0.2319044024,
0.2741042376,
-0.3476831615,
-0.1809672415,
0.6357555389,
0.1751261503,
0.539308548,
0.3559685946,
-0.4485330284,
-0.3295065165,
-0.5213501453,
0.3885035813,
0.4543754458,
0.1826628298,
0.1348858178,
0.5260275006,
-0.3643436134,
0.9109342098,
-0.1866985708,
-0.1037357002,
0.3155416846,
-0.3353687823,
-0.3802774251,
-0.1285674572,
0.754612267,
0.4455575943,
0.5290370584,
-0.0191213768,
-0.174131006,
0.0401467234,
0.2411277294,
-0.8518024087,
-0.045680441,
0.1497891396,
-0.5275920033,
-0.3712452948,
0.1168902591,
-0.4645613432,
-0.4381487668,
-0.7746593356,
0.3718627691,
-0.4829924107,
-0.3000963926,
0.1983745694,
-0.2634017169,
-0.3281756639,
0.5155797601,
-0.8359473348,
0.5057238936,
0.6583300829,
0.4132975042,
-0.3212233484,
-0.357940495,
-0.5674256086,
0.2116740197,
-0.205589354,
0.6029325724,
-0.8764752746,
-0.4806426764,
0.0949898958,
0.0598804988,
0.1831592321,
-0.5968663692,
0.3213419616,
-0.661283195,
0.27456218,
-0.1640801132,
-0.6291933656,
-0.4878927469,
0.0754312128,
-0.4282288253,
0.8747881651,
0.2824159563,
-0.3755465448,
0.2969829142,
-1.066067934,
-0.6345871687,
0.1188663095,
0.1269365996,
-0.2958630025,
0.1709026396,
0.0185866933,
0.5287461281,
-0.1463251561,
0.1750809252,
-0.682862699,
-0.4809187055,
0.5850723982,
0.0302543528,
0.5943425298,
0.5116317272,
0.0232975725,
0.3526283503,
-0.510109067,
0.0618751235,
0.0401181951,
-0.5119726062,
-0.5432884097,
0.1678372324,
0.4167561829,
0.1050205231,
0.5236949921,
-0.5531301498,
0.3511954546,
-0.261448741,
0.479275912,
0.5647088885,
-0.1252993494,
0.314809531,
-0.0996273309,
0.4637421966,
0.2096692175,
0.0677646846,
-0.4762442708,
-0.4274996817,
-0.5236341357,
0.0738205239,
0.2602963746,
0.6937422752,
-0.8592714071,
0.4086941481,
0.3401387632,
-0.1185597926,
-0.4450849891,
0.3463346064,
0.3270228505,
0.3140142262,
0.1194841117,
-0.3280543685,
-0.8361971378,
-0.703461051,
-0.1806356758,
-0.3374490738,
-0.2057848424,
0.6742824316,
0.1260437667,
-0.6252757907,
1.1032561064,
-0.5582097173,
0.0051508052,
-0.2065712065,
-0.2537491918,
0.163374275,
0.2560844421,
0.4764814973,
-0.8049017787,
-0.4532012641,
0.4853429794,
-0.9587919712,
-0.0650278702,
0.2356923968,
0.0808445439,
0.351162672,
0.2457189113,
-0.0560707189,
0.0891143531,
0.4922225475,
-0.4901909828,
0.5028933287,
-0.689586997,
0.4225791693,
-0.9384660721,
0.0004906991,
0.5207184553,
-0.2005856484,
-0.6904054284,
-0.0547199696,
-0.1259600073,
-0.3453869522,
-0.2331310809,
0.8223987818,
-0.2095358819,
-0.1745024174,
-0.5482165813,
-0.0534640923,
-0.0510027222,
0.3411030769,
-0.0250225384,
0.9464694858,
0.4350186884,
-0.6739187837,
0.5896497369,
0.1994635612,
-0.5261619091,
0.6214595437,
-0.6988884211,
-0.035662666,
0.2108351141,
-0.0580968373,
-0.9519817829,
-0.206578657,
0.0894485787,
-0.0917148367,
-0.0390640981,
0.1682391018,
-0.4846023321,
-0.5185460448,
-0.0851527527,
-0.0576612353,
0.5677801967,
-0.5880807042,
0.4498345852,
0.4705715477,
-0.3184930086,
-0.3580646515,
-0.2873983979,
0.1365162432,
-0.211958915,
-0.8272746205,
0.0931083634,
-0.3477362394,
-0.4147137105,
-0.133410275,
0.4968956709,
0.0070677307,
0.2630722821,
0.553193152,
0.5714814663,
-0.2929987609,
0.2114178687,
0.0413149074,
-0.2156704664,
-0.16832228,
-0.4174813628,
0.3851812184,
-0.4132885635,
-0.3001893759,
-0.8661168218,
0.5161950588,
0.5799074769,
-0.0427131094,
0.6271185279,
0.6808156967,
-0.0362448283,
0.2179342955,
-0.7182991505,
-0.3095992208,
-0.5795055032,
0.3886938691,
-0.4905528128,
-1.1282423735,
0.1457568854,
-0.4062873125,
-0.0448383093,
0.0612981133,
0.6431251764,
-0.3728565276,
1.4560872316,
1.0130287409,
-0.3673821688,
0.9008526802,
0.064442277,
0.5445021391,
-0.70717448,
-0.1748625785,
-0.5299555063,
-0.1950980127,
-0.6174108386,
0.1861498952,
0.2141231596,
0.0087545505,
-0.2914693654,
0.3123602867,
-0.4930196702,
0.1713051796,
0.8411666155,
0.1913326383,
0.2191007584,
0.3291464448,
-0.3596988618,
0.0278250892,
-0.2762868702,
-0.5169281363,
0.6794608235,
0.6153828502,
0.9727575183,
-0.1660018563,
0.2185468376,
0.7048792839,
0.0441096015,
-0.7800498605,
0.4778177142,
0.0606310479,
-0.2342411876,
-0.4891087711,
-0.4129991829,
-0.7598241568,
-0.0858007669,
-0.3066497445,
-0.9812208414,
0.2464094907,
0.224457413,
-0.2806257308,
0.0159193538,
-1.066006422,
0.6115008593,
-0.2559595108,
-0.5123550892,
-0.3949908614,
-0.2592463195,
-0.0569138713,
0.1430505365,
0.1721066535,
0.1458431482,
0.1946984231,
0.7765927315,
-0.280144006,
0.6691607237,
-0.3177419603,
-0.0124322921,
0.0095765591,
0.0513145141,
0.5197708607,
-0.3970988095,
-0.4230450094,
-0.0491916314,
0.1816298664,
-0.1131904572,
-0.5287389159,
0.983042419,
-0.9721607566,
-0.7289264202,
-0.139384225,
-0.6176018119,
-0.2354763746,
0.2335423976,
-0.554965198,
0.2661447823,
-0.336008817,
0.28005445,
0.4960878789,
-0.2883806825,
0.3902889192,
0.5167992711,
-0.6585605145,
-0.3772886992,
1.1292717457,
-0.2422674149,
-0.0920958072,
0.2444052994,
0.366969496,
-0.2049584836,
-0.4204287529,
-0.4623222351,
0.1141247302,
-0.3088222444,
0.2538558245,
-0.7824792266,
-0.0017082631,
-0.3078341186,
-0.3297727704,
0.2322881371,
-0.245154202,
-0.0592082329,
-0.0198247973,
0.3910416365,
0.9300733805,
0.1101972163,
0.5474399328,
-0.6136573553,
0.2421319932,
0.2851335406,
0.508297205,
0.0558620133,
0.0671754852,
-0.5768750906,
-0.0212404523,
-0.4615367055,
-0.6015639901,
0.3448118269,
-0.0809518918,
0.8460285068,
0.9118213654,
-0.2235445231,
0.1725604087,
-0.3490854204,
0.6180744767,
0.269285053,
-0.7212215662,
0.392832756,
-0.2729642391,
0.040376097,
0.2962643504,
0.4381377697,
-0.7371175885,
0.1826095879,
-0.2599845231,
-0.4068885446,
0.874180913,
-0.0480655096,
-0.0119635342,
0.4416881502,
0.1847178638,
0.0745207593,
0.3923784494,
-0.2979186475,
-0.1001483724,
0.1311242431,
-0.0605585761,
-0.3169386387,
-0.3982718587,
0.0833196193,
-0.2185545862,
0.9350301623,
-0.0397240259,
0.0928376392,
-0.2559801638,
0.1902651042,
-0.1650052369,
0.0814176202,
0.5550804734,
0.6243430972,
-0.188197419,
-0.3601478934,
0.0046348511,
-0.196222648,
0.1201716959,
-0.0186566897,
-0.0356076658,
-0.3990261853,
-0.1915077567,
0.9625244141,
0.0518902615,
-0.8167408109,
0.1523384899,
-0.2010279447,
0.2282937318,
-0.2583760619,
0.5166688561,
0.2557140887,
0.2499143332,
0.35038203,
0.0129090603,
0.375187993,
-0.9154577255,
0.0143807558,
0.5295902491,
-0.6969194412,
0.0289495233,
0.232895121,
0.3843233585,
-0.8825222254,
0.655418992,
0.2998825908,
-0.4714964628,
0.4238859713,
0.6712377667,
0.5793468356,
-0.4932182431,
0.0182550214,
0.0666022375,
-0.0487933196,
0.1451567113,
0.1203836948,
-0.3804663718,
-0.6362529993,
-0.2922319472,
-0.7280341387,
-0.77821064,
-0.1455362886,
-0.2472131699,
0.4332556725,
-0.3543488383,
-0.1355703771,
0.1754497737,
0.3376787603,
-0.5780641437,
0.2991098464,
0.0971459821,
0.5699943304,
-0.8491295576,
0.6492480636,
0.8939449787,
-0.2615001202,
-0.308789283,
-0.4187467694,
-0.2257324457,
-0.5622989535,
0.6946805716,
0.0798645839,
-0.1848072261,
-0.4242689013,
-0.3397864103,
-0.4417356253,
0.6437113285,
0.1566299796,
-0.569119215,
0.0331024975,
0.1276498884,
0.6495341659,
-0.6827160716,
0.5364682674,
0.4820028543,
0.7103322148,
0.1941916943,
-0.8006321788,
-0.0276825689,
-0.4860222936,
0.415713191,
0.2479200512,
-0.3182563186,
0.4577447176,
-0.1780617535,
0.2563817203,
0.1024268195,
0.6227631569,
0.3783040941,
0.622469604,
0.4653038383,
0.3615441918,
0.6376481652,
0.0248625521,
1.2965302467,
-0.2346774638,
0.0228010193,
0.7530450821,
-0.4662110806,
0.8479257226,
0.4886505008,
-0.430184871,
0.6728422642,
0.7740376592,
0.0208791029,
0.40521577,
0.0676928088,
-0.3537500501,
-0.2541267574,
-0.2265625596,
-0.3949511647,
-0.0464320034,
0.5451365113,
-0.3641308248,
0.1711883247,
0.5563095808,
-0.0360302217,
-0.0068081291,
0.0948396549,
1.0804412365,
0.0630203485,
-0.6750156283,
0.2588624954,
0.1800804585,
0.5840167999,
-0.5159221292,
-0.2770269215,
0.0637084842,
0.3433825374,
-0.2896166444,
-0.8088591099,
-0.1759094745,
-0.2784292102,
-0.4466579854,
-0.2703823745,
0.9354773164,
-0.0176760703,
-0.638248086,
0.3871674538,
0.2244192213,
0.2874441743,
-0.0234936122,
-0.6557280421,
0.2778374851,
0.0456697717,
-0.2264528573,
0.4635651112,
0.3337228298,
-0.0421745852,
0.9895804524,
1.0184592009,
0.0087840697,
-0.2150046676,
-0.0362996347,
0.751979351,
-0.5367392898,
-0.7192786932,
-0.6807194352,
0.306127131,
-0.2779293954,
0.0228189081,
0.6166953444,
0.5380263329,
0.739890933,
-0.1387933046,
1.0065509081,
0.1149277613,
0.5263707042,
-0.3029828966,
0.59066993,
-0.5281709433,
0.2512135506,
-0.3137473464,
-0.9244379997,
0.0447113812,
0.4349402189,
-0.5860852003,
0.4877175689,
0.4362564385,
0.6740678549,
-0.2898931503,
0.1415758878,
0.7344402671,
0.1427156627,
0.4049970508,
0.2690436244,
0.8561545014,
-0.1854505688,
0.1056285724,
-0.1259191483,
-0.5078834891,
-0.8469698429,
-0.6860513091,
-0.8997840285,
-0.8490144014,
-0.0247743372,
-0.3734365404,
0.3148674369,
0.9778888822,
0.8591120839,
-0.930260241,
-0.5922997594,
0.1961236149,
0.1525312811,
-0.2656461298,
-0.2429237366,
0.107308276,
-0.3456433713,
-0.8875719309,
0.5249661207,
0.393647939,
0.021461308,
-0.6852589846,
-0.2859754562,
0.0839715078,
-0.0521085933,
0.825825572,
0.481495291,
-0.5931931734,
-0.032296218,
-0.0267434679,
0.0221879594,
-0.0202192739,
0.8952391744,
-1.0782818794,
0.593167305,
0.4812572896,
0.7306079268,
0.4922764003,
-0.0522270612,
0.9399169683,
-0.0362075642,
0.0656270012,
-0.3094321489,
0.4132501483,
0.3210993111,
-0.624322772,
0.2505858839,
-0.1065712273,
-0.6270484328,
-0.6150384545,
0.2788568437,
-0.9829998016,
-0.2861415446,
0.892285645,
-0.3003946245,
-0.2203551084,
-0.2848017514,
-0.6974098682,
-0.038890861,
-0.7319200039,
0.9448763132,
0.7450174689,
-0.3261075616,
-0.0447987579,
-0.6501306891,
0.2811609209,
0.2860016823,
-0.8851671219,
-0.180410713,
0.4494080842,
0.1416180879,
0.2163952589,
0.1059319079,
0.2484987825,
0.2031762153,
-0.4586377144,
0.1635110229,
-0.4407980442,
-0.2908937335,
-0.1592063606,
0.3123505712,
0.1951460391,
-0.0966884643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15764v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15764v2
|
Look Before You Leap: Problem Elaboration Prompting Improves Mathematical Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T08:40:30 | 2024-03-27T01:23:58 |
Haoran Liao, Jidong Tian, Shaohua Hu, Hao He, Yaohui Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) still grapple with complex tasks like
mathematical reasoning. Despite significant efforts invested in improving
prefix prompts or reasoning process, the crucial role of problem context might
have been neglected. Accurate recognition of inputs is fundamental for solving
mathematical tasks, as ill-formed problems could potentially mislead LLM's
reasoning. In this study, we propose a new approach named Problem Elaboration
Prompting (PEP) to enhance the mathematical capacities of LLMs. Specifically,
PEP decomposes and elucidates the problem context before reasoning, therefore
enhancing the context modeling and parsing efficiency. Experiments across
datasets and models demonstrate promising performances: (1) PEP demonstrates an
overall enhancement in various mathematical tasks. For instance, with the
GPT-3.5 model, PEP exhibits improvements of 9.93% and 8.80% on GSM8k through
greedy decoding and self-consistency, respectively. (2) PEP can be easily
implemented and integrated with other prompting methods. (3) PEP shows
particular strength in handling distraction problems.
|
[
-0.443125993,
-0.656383872,
0.7210187912,
0.4428508878,
-0.0801880583,
-0.1292426884,
-0.1088380888,
-0.1768421233,
0.0088114049,
0.0034528205,
-0.61755234,
-0.1489036977,
-0.4834554493,
0.2058944106,
-0.2431640327,
0.6739299893,
0.0838338733,
-0.1003874913,
-0.5932902694,
0.5753589272,
-0.5459042788,
-0.2703970671,
-0.6907629371,
-0.262840867,
0.4391682148,
0.3684929311,
0.3469858766,
0.4927314818,
0.2083256543,
0.3387041986,
-0.4982110262,
0.2294329405,
-0.1693034768,
0.1921050102,
-0.2401647717,
-0.521304369,
-0.3745839894,
-0.0481089614,
0.3726186156,
0.781054616,
-0.1887795925,
-0.1134663597,
0.423838973,
0.5945366025,
-0.8924045563,
0.4039655924,
-0.5430390239,
-0.1466906965,
0.1546057463,
-0.4818019569,
-0.400342375,
-0.072209999,
0.3662746251,
-0.881926477,
0.1688162237,
-0.366925627,
0.5094316602,
0.5076164603,
-0.284040153,
-0.471588701,
-0.6040815115,
0.8034332991,
-0.5417212248,
0.3313617408,
0.5005635619,
0.0599026643,
-0.4153211415,
-0.5559740663,
-0.4569645524,
-0.0110164136,
-0.162556231,
-0.0842183828,
-0.3097567558,
-0.2442398518,
0.695034802,
-0.0327510238,
-0.2530000806,
-0.3269311488,
-0.3111584485,
-0.2260022163,
0.4964787662,
-0.0369522646,
0.1372841001,
-0.2613806427,
-0.0437834635,
0.0719738379,
-0.9222871065,
0.1301244348,
-0.0238503776,
0.1505918205,
0.0947589278,
0.3927335739,
-0.046753481,
0.592715621,
0.0309587307,
0.00732585,
0.1101376116,
-0.2467062473,
-0.1721038371,
-0.0519019738,
0.0899738222,
0.2518743873,
0.5910716057,
0.6663309932,
-0.0461922027,
-0.1091068685,
0.0880222842,
-0.7368231416,
-0.4153395593,
0.1237197667,
0.068516396,
0.1010590121,
-0.2180232555,
-0.687680006,
-0.2298115492,
-0.4828051925,
0.2427559346,
-0.5940915346,
-0.1263920665,
0.2114047706,
0.1016870514,
0.1891479492,
0.8679550886,
-0.8600602746,
-0.1519624293,
1.0708976984,
0.8012732863,
0.2241664529,
-0.1394282877,
-0.7735761404,
0.0681604818,
-0.3601396978,
0.8602452874,
-0.3716391027,
-0.5700436234,
0.0036964519,
-0.1413902491,
-0.1553080827,
-0.6219218969,
0.8349362612,
-0.3683984876,
0.0981175527,
-0.2617604733,
-0.5029614568,
-0.1142896116,
0.4189891219,
-0.4333472252,
1.0171377659,
-0.1577642858,
-0.5302322507,
0.2396082729,
-0.8624182343,
-0.4768833816,
0.2795193791,
-0.2013986409,
-0.2243628055,
0.364834398,
1.0136733055,
0.270892024,
0.2365653664,
0.0430116542,
0.0974563137,
-0.2075547576,
0.2607612014,
-0.2291784734,
0.6068720818,
0.2084062248,
-0.2340932637,
-0.1881421804,
-0.4127712846,
0.2600664794,
0.2226707339,
-0.0483761393,
-0.7271392345,
0.1322501004,
-0.5122201443,
0.1240862384,
0.2377255261,
-0.1817672849,
0.3385336995,
-0.554428637,
0.5116388798,
0.7958346605,
0.0696794689,
0.179714486,
-0.2197532952,
0.7755055428,
-0.0199726466,
-0.1320124865,
-0.8853273988,
-0.8277856708,
-0.451236546,
-0.2487148345,
0.2937705219,
0.5804486871,
-0.595341742,
0.2893176079,
-0.020417992,
-0.0284657236,
-0.2005466074,
-0.142442286,
0.3414616287,
0.7259034514,
0.3567050397,
0.3806892335,
-0.3572609127,
-0.6951131821,
-0.4028753042,
-0.1276708692,
-0.341545403,
0.4457298219,
0.4863846004,
0.1155028492,
0.9575946927,
-0.7365629077,
0.0140762599,
-0.2371371388,
0.2854995728,
0.3184921145,
0.5352792144,
0.2511561215,
-0.9488063455,
-0.5837383866,
-0.2421410084,
-0.1643906236,
-0.630161643,
-0.0459533781,
-0.1035765931,
0.0423776843,
0.5637938976,
-0.5902192593,
0.5737530589,
0.2040803879,
-0.4256561697,
0.6168113351,
-0.2413045317,
0.2252202481,
-0.8863955736,
0.0547211654,
0.0385060236,
-0.116364561,
-0.5093314052,
-0.1108376607,
0.2821457982,
-0.3314368129,
-0.5702013373,
0.4698832929,
-0.4861968458,
0.0276983716,
-0.1892962903,
0.271250844,
0.2181094289,
0.1406760961,
-0.009363519,
1.2049924135,
0.4696446061,
-0.8699530959,
-0.1370580196,
0.2834139466,
-0.409796536,
0.6714311838,
-0.8190372586,
0.0663831979,
-0.2476350367,
0.1120886952,
-0.995239377,
-0.1753807813,
0.1235485151,
-0.6308017373,
0.1209701523,
-0.3413189054,
-0.2112522274,
-0.5104154348,
-0.2658481598,
0.6945289373,
0.5130520463,
-0.7153124213,
0.4754726887,
0.0184327681,
-0.4380609095,
-0.6428363919,
-0.4235375822,
-0.2193558663,
-0.1955060214,
-0.4996257126,
0.4863996804,
-0.3587674201,
-0.2440528721,
-0.1013861299,
-0.1954633743,
-0.0253095869,
0.0670374259,
-0.044810731,
0.3437083066,
0.0203916077,
0.269493103,
0.0429796763,
-0.1652617306,
0.3188281953,
-0.3850494325,
0.4728877842,
0.06024836,
-0.2836997509,
-0.5777333379,
0.3396231234,
0.4664033949,
-0.3512691557,
0.2306659073,
-0.0528932363,
-0.6227899194,
-0.342959106,
-0.278907299,
-0.3029005527,
-0.5322496295,
0.194579646,
-0.5214252472,
-0.6497380733,
0.3381225765,
-0.3016009331,
-0.019586673,
0.0481021628,
0.5315838456,
-0.0074527566,
1.1959314346,
0.5442312956,
0.3563955426,
0.6508921385,
-0.1569484919,
0.4029835165,
-1.0564956665,
-0.4888802171,
-0.4919047952,
-0.1680692285,
-0.0214356706,
-0.6518836617,
0.5724111795,
0.4834507108,
0.102127105,
0.2176885754,
-0.4237371683,
0.9622287154,
0.2177191824,
-0.0105963955,
0.2444773614,
0.1237872317,
-0.336781919,
-0.4872353971,
-0.6787637472,
-0.3040072322,
0.9107249379,
0.1444529891,
0.6394162178,
-0.0834400728,
0.742790997,
0.008845035,
0.3487876058,
-1.1889852285,
0.6205440164,
0.4591463208,
-0.4506145418,
-0.3427607417,
-0.5376156569,
-1.176025629,
0.2882009745,
0.1160546616,
-0.8755248189,
0.1864320338,
0.4357186556,
-0.7019992471,
-0.1779686511,
-0.7550154924,
0.6974229813,
-0.1433848292,
-0.4187712371,
-0.1430069357,
0.0260247253,
0.2207375169,
-0.0490929596,
0.4957057834,
-0.1422814578,
-0.3919921815,
0.5992208123,
-0.5003373027,
0.4547192454,
-0.1632803679,
-0.5359480977,
0.4552202523,
0.4189279675,
0.730658114,
0.2739177346,
-0.0160262976,
-0.3004391491,
-0.2873910367,
-0.3285815418,
-1.1778504848,
0.7006779313,
-0.1263241619,
-1.0550637245,
-0.2856762707,
-0.7090258598,
-0.1718816161,
0.146400094,
0.1227672249,
0.3994123042,
0.1579579413,
-0.0166194625,
0.705368042,
-0.0937454551,
0.6310073137,
0.4283309579,
-0.2771358788,
-0.3467294872,
0.4252167642,
0.0791543201,
0.1723855138,
0.1666126847,
0.3672698438,
-0.6196534038,
-0.4072625041,
-0.2740629911,
0.1692229956,
-0.7599274516,
-0.3594759703,
-0.5517446995,
0.1161004826,
-0.5587070584,
-0.3296540082,
-0.3109017313,
-0.3851422966,
-0.1389076114,
0.1664440781,
0.3812433779,
0.5609342456,
-0.1341005415,
0.1596667767,
-0.7440457344,
-0.1086579859,
0.4479807317,
0.0703683421,
0.2095101327,
-0.5697655082,
-0.2184194624,
-0.1705144495,
-0.4398492575,
-0.8759690523,
0.7285644412,
0.0382138081,
0.5458853245,
0.4441845715,
0.0814832076,
0.8004366159,
-0.6532457471,
0.7187811136,
0.0501942523,
-1.4194475412,
0.9062551856,
-0.3324186802,
0.4382722676,
0.0306895375,
0.6407802105,
-0.303453356,
0.0940238014,
-0.6738181114,
-0.8640294075,
0.4941971898,
0.2780968249,
0.0640329421,
-0.0781572089,
0.4344746172,
-0.3227600753,
0.1309609264,
-0.5470399261,
0.1132047623,
0.0285392571,
0.2357699424,
-0.0457128026,
-0.1900259256,
-0.1023489311,
-0.5872868299,
0.49789235,
-0.2826164961,
0.3467859924,
0.5444992185,
0.0212091915,
-0.3085227609,
0.3804808855,
0.813552022,
1.0078722239,
0.2811500728,
0.1622855663,
0.3360946476,
-0.2115011662,
0.0816112682,
0.0805923641,
-0.1262209862,
-0.078526929,
0.4447677433,
0.276116848,
0.3047207594,
-0.7078782916,
0.4429651797,
0.1919074506,
-0.1776603162,
-0.1545722485,
0.1073297709,
0.1761417538,
0.2330145389,
0.6066257954,
-0.3774613738,
0.1562360823,
-0.3432914615,
0.3312531114,
0.3248745203,
0.3053262234,
-0.0555888005,
0.3870162666,
0.0496597774,
-0.5996354222,
0.607408762,
-0.1465023011,
-1.0304054022,
0.896844089,
0.9646119475,
0.5390902758,
-0.6621072888,
0.1810234189,
0.6638512611,
0.1117031574,
0.0291446149,
0.3656591177,
-0.2438711077,
-0.5245315433,
-0.9854596257,
-0.2094561309,
-0.4249441922,
0.3038364351,
-0.6048408747,
0.4626297951,
-0.4100343287,
0.1323759109,
0.0466474891,
-0.0400767401,
-0.3273952305,
-0.0041332967,
0.1303261518,
0.9448213577,
-0.4545560777,
0.5297577977,
0.7619978189,
0.231080994,
-0.9564692974,
0.3739039004,
-0.0198156312,
-0.6758353114,
0.6752964854,
0.352419138,
-0.0488789007,
0.1159363836,
-0.6737976074,
-0.8079531789,
0.777487874,
0.2535225451,
-0.8090044856,
0.0665836707,
-0.2052981704,
0.2811771333,
-0.5281980634,
0.2311826497,
0.4378692508,
0.5759634376,
0.4581677318,
-0.8511060476,
0.145619303,
-0.3416082859,
-0.0171724968,
0.4248534441,
-0.0988768265,
1.0313936472,
-0.6881965399,
-0.2979552448,
-0.0395114198,
0.5260459781,
0.5506321788,
0.4423907399,
0.6494038105,
0.4018741548,
0.9472442269,
0.0439200662,
0.9311069846,
-0.1498919576,
0.3398741484,
0.9507064223,
-0.0903184414,
0.8695646524,
0.6323489547,
-0.2612376213,
0.4463505447,
0.5963581204,
0.2927283347,
0.4281666875,
0.4131955802,
-0.3218792081,
-0.4390631616,
-0.0041384054,
-0.6240667701,
0.1794656664,
0.8521432877,
-0.2144190669,
-0.4434621632,
-0.0253121946,
-0.0989027321,
0.2118314654,
-0.6195109487,
0.3921931386,
0.2572143972,
-0.9118738174,
0.8320381045,
-0.1768628508,
0.3717447817,
-0.3710098267,
-0.3606593311,
-0.2524485588,
0.1216537282,
-0.1897755414,
-0.7531360984,
0.361913085,
-0.0327097178,
-0.1057870388,
-0.2177111059,
0.5462573767,
-0.4548015296,
-0.3989777267,
0.1013044268,
0.7027335763,
0.2035921812,
-0.3394867778,
-0.7587672472,
-0.0117594656,
-0.1573101878,
-0.1603877395,
0.0284210369,
0.7930697203,
-0.1149889529,
0.7667195797,
0.8924125433,
-0.1101985499,
-0.1391478032,
-0.0659502596,
1.0260870457,
-0.6911753416,
-0.8604371548,
-1.0065159798,
0.4836625755,
0.0621583052,
-0.2119250447,
0.869579494,
0.3293832242,
0.7967248559,
-0.2231651843,
0.3656105101,
0.1223795637,
0.4108304679,
-0.5041881204,
0.1898873895,
-0.547634542,
0.5635600686,
-0.4326349795,
-0.9257634878,
-0.4838416576,
0.9579504132,
-0.7452948093,
0.0857845768,
0.7190949917,
0.8162334561,
-0.027287297,
0.0100479368,
0.3002401292,
-0.1659363806,
0.3308049738,
0.9245153666,
1.2144443989,
0.0601825714,
0.5661073923,
-0.0935214758,
-0.4763717353,
-0.3620004356,
-1.2180943489,
-0.9227881432,
-0.2726456523,
-0.4270507395,
-0.4516251981,
-0.0631688237,
1.1819214821,
0.7376032472,
-0.6938953996,
0.1365535706,
-0.3097024858,
0.4260943532,
-0.3143297434,
-0.2329957336,
0.267138809,
-0.5357720852,
-1.0842592716,
0.6362614036,
0.1451134086,
0.2658518255,
-0.1626263559,
-0.0157271791,
-0.0506174527,
0.3361935318,
0.6367697716,
0.3360454738,
-0.3983960152,
-0.046239309,
-0.0120809767,
0.1539969891,
0.3111713231,
1.3846851587,
-0.9170990586,
0.2415912449,
0.528142035,
0.6742972136,
0.2935409844,
0.2012286186,
0.6128338575,
-0.5404844284,
0.2292961776,
0.3402207792,
0.3671783507,
0.1544970274,
-0.6792291999,
0.3884723485,
0.3465746939,
-0.3972472548,
-0.7854153514,
0.5070747137,
-0.4826980531,
-0.3818022907,
0.8867609501,
-0.4829809368,
-0.344484508,
-0.0513237715,
-0.3650192916,
-0.1008697525,
-0.5498572588,
0.7759306431,
0.7925922871,
-0.4683997631,
-0.4399541914,
-0.3615058661,
0.639252007,
1.1032493114,
-0.8668984175,
0.2533453107,
0.4088330865,
-0.0091336323,
0.3316447437,
0.2886017561,
-0.1608261764,
0.4008146524,
-0.2500053346,
-0.4884256423,
-0.2892609835,
-0.7147413492,
-0.5149611235,
0.0911927521,
-0.0837872922,
-0.0282794852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17786v1
|
Stepwise Self-Consistent Mathematical Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T08:22:39 | 2024-02-24T08:22:39 |
Zilong Zhao, Yao Rong, Dongyang Guo, Emek Gözlüklü, Emir Gülboy, Enkelejda Kasneci
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Using Large Language Models for complex mathematical reasoning is difficult,
primarily due to the complexity of multi-step reasoning. The main challenges of
this process include (1) selecting critical intermediate results to advance the
procedure, and (2) limited exploration of potential solutions. To address these
issues, we introduce a novel algorithm, namely Stepwise Self-Consistent
Chain-of-Thought (SSC-CoT). SSC-CoT employs a strategy of selecting
intermediate steps based on the intersection of various reasoning chains.
Additionally, SSC-CoT enables the model to discover critical intermediate steps
by querying a knowledge graph comprising relevant domain knowledge. To validate
SSC-CoT, we present a new dataset, TriMaster100, tailored for complex
trigonometry problems. This dataset contains 100 questions, with each solution
broken down into scored intermediate steps, facilitating a comprehensive
evaluation of the mathematical reasoning process. On TriMaster100, SSC-CoT
triples the effectiveness of the state-of-the-art methods. Furthermore, we
benchmark SSC-CoT on the widely recognized complex mathematical question
dataset, MATH level 5, and it surpasses the second-best method by 7.2% in
accuracy. Code and the TriMaster100 dataset can be found at:
https://github.com/zhao-zilong/ssc-cot.
|
[
-0.3961065412,
-0.7159382105,
0.9691891074,
0.3818777502,
-0.1120127812,
0.5170968175,
-0.2129022181,
-0.184614107,
-0.0839530677,
0.5401275754,
-0.7772101164,
-0.7095683813,
-0.2629925311,
0.0858642384,
-0.2535123229,
0.7328839302,
-0.4813664258,
0.3028883934,
-0.2027382702,
-0.2367448509,
-0.2901510894,
-0.456995368,
-0.6576356888,
-0.2364450991,
0.2506092191,
0.4887200594,
0.7524060607,
0.5201185346,
0.6563974619,
0.1790333688,
-0.1503647715,
0.4220161438,
-0.3268064857,
0.2332291305,
-0.2235916257,
-0.3120034039,
-0.3918660581,
-0.3506986797,
0.3555466831,
0.7761111856,
-0.3288735151,
0.1667312533,
-0.048077587,
0.8844628334,
-0.6240357161,
0.0983339474,
-0.2429114878,
-0.1899738312,
-0.1799666584,
0.0254705455,
-0.2674770951,
-0.51804322,
-0.0310974959,
-0.3695994318,
0.1173092052,
0.0374518298,
0.375103265,
0.2784723341,
-0.3089955747,
-0.4129884541,
-0.9629558325,
0.7619979382,
-0.5936670899,
0.6037001014,
0.3226428032,
0.470765084,
-0.1822928488,
-0.4336718619,
-0.384108901,
-0.2088867277,
0.2900924385,
-0.0024632046,
0.0194410942,
0.0410439745,
0.5092123747,
0.3264288902,
-0.5714604855,
-0.3642937839,
-0.456461817,
-0.2367235571,
0.8063696027,
0.2346131057,
0.394641012,
-0.1420949996,
-0.4238921404,
-0.1005213112,
-0.732414782,
-0.0694741905,
0.3202691674,
0.2042685002,
-0.0571675599,
0.5211723447,
-0.2040581256,
0.6711043715,
0.0417997874,
0.1114687622,
0.0996885672,
-0.3884760737,
0.0671848804,
0.0753698498,
0.770163238,
-0.0949641392,
0.5944014192,
0.2140918225,
-0.1156075001,
-0.1854228824,
0.2248646617,
-0.3993421495,
-0.4038459063,
0.4929759502,
0.1229890436,
-0.1459456831,
-0.1190272272,
-0.5405515432,
-0.0067385919,
-0.5208857059,
0.3375896215,
-0.620267272,
-0.0602708124,
0.287130028,
0.2977597713,
0.0380202346,
0.58881253,
-0.4554162025,
0.3279426396,
0.8704958558,
0.9281185269,
-0.3359899819,
-0.302262485,
-0.3257047236,
0.1022491083,
-0.8741913438,
0.8183643818,
-0.424000442,
-0.1050024182,
-0.2716746926,
-0.2314021438,
0.0796350092,
-0.4676987529,
0.6752513051,
-0.3816587627,
0.011733993,
-0.4144338071,
-0.5913871527,
-0.0610483438,
0.4968674183,
-0.7064872384,
1.332972765,
-0.0024997212,
-0.5890459418,
-0.1581147462,
-0.400970161,
-0.2363396585,
-0.0539995432,
-0.3900329173,
-0.2882779241,
-0.0030683638,
0.3250586987,
0.1531139016,
-0.5556897521,
0.3017678261,
-0.6877110004,
-0.1131401956,
0.047659453,
-0.4320878088,
0.9326357245,
0.2645082474,
-0.3687700331,
-0.0294687934,
-0.6136054993,
0.3223294914,
0.0884625316,
0.2261463702,
-0.3281949759,
-0.3388420939,
-0.3950107694,
0.3677551746,
0.2838405371,
-0.5525017977,
0.2496609241,
-0.0467891321,
0.2679362595,
0.8097259998,
0.1938647628,
0.0718672872,
-0.0726317614,
0.5196700096,
0.0340790749,
0.3723859489,
0.0061315694,
-0.2869459987,
-0.7324612737,
-0.0499749072,
0.373110503,
0.432500273,
-0.7877345085,
0.4916015267,
0.0259326659,
-0.6000254154,
-0.1525878459,
-0.0125883492,
0.4893490076,
0.394328475,
0.5843424797,
0.0607274175,
-0.1873551905,
-0.7457982898,
-0.3780995309,
-0.0787803307,
0.0593394265,
0.1695890576,
0.4746472239,
0.1415399611,
0.6460561752,
-0.937053144,
0.0021200173,
-0.1054807007,
0.2943815589,
0.1978069544,
0.6578341126,
0.1687315404,
-0.4543569088,
-0.5109719634,
-0.106696181,
-0.7556735277,
0.079824172,
-0.2308057696,
-0.6578452587,
-0.143279165,
0.6273508072,
-0.254032135,
0.5643082857,
0.407032311,
-0.2616533935,
0.7301860452,
-0.3780925274,
0.2471501976,
-0.8975340724,
-0.0547948256,
0.0762738958,
-0.464230895,
-0.5713208914,
-0.0551360063,
0.3391917944,
0.0859632343,
-0.208452791,
0.3532953262,
-0.366596669,
0.0213461742,
0.0031662092,
-0.0806133822,
-0.0641098768,
0.5980086327,
0.0483017303,
0.7045463324,
0.5964119434,
-0.5783070922,
0.3871446252,
0.1962816715,
-0.2017996013,
0.6290413737,
-0.7368145585,
0.3170854449,
0.0360471979,
0.4056601822,
-1.0074703693,
-0.0635019839,
0.1068711951,
-0.3305627406,
-0.0338993445,
-0.0466554016,
-0.4123130441,
-0.5066387057,
-0.2396341562,
0.9806797504,
0.104813531,
-0.5724464655,
0.9042652249,
0.0946001858,
-0.1003076956,
-0.429492414,
-0.3675189018,
-0.1158767566,
0.2228237391,
-0.5158320665,
0.1036341563,
-0.3458984792,
-0.0652190372,
-0.3981066048,
-0.5694173574,
-0.0588691905,
-0.2331787199,
-0.0169619285,
0.4880637228,
0.0005153649,
0.1357669532,
0.19784078,
-0.2660405934,
0.2497417778,
-0.3738292158,
0.8970128894,
-0.3604137003,
-0.6960997581,
-0.5097216964,
0.175841555,
0.7160162926,
-0.2761021256,
0.1931550801,
0.1851070821,
-0.5987204313,
-0.3874524236,
-0.6095582247,
0.0009659781,
-0.3906475604,
-0.0687991232,
-0.6631131172,
-0.541505754,
0.605958879,
-0.2606784999,
0.0934512615,
0.7201002836,
0.3434359729,
-0.1659600288,
1.2200409174,
0.1668498367,
0.3886683881,
0.1614187658,
-0.5497936606,
0.3190157413,
-0.9646922946,
-0.3577660024,
-0.5249854922,
-0.0393501446,
-0.3155223727,
-0.6867645383,
0.5145068765,
0.1601886749,
-0.6388365626,
0.4221875072,
-0.4683015049,
0.555646956,
0.3270221055,
0.3372381032,
0.4307287037,
-0.088963896,
-0.5407904387,
0.2086146772,
-0.5220617056,
-0.1981663108,
0.9635186791,
0.1288952678,
0.9382115006,
-0.0079927268,
0.7147218585,
0.1631633192,
-0.0419147424,
-0.6682494283,
0.4558887184,
-0.1030113399,
-0.86335814,
-0.5181575418,
-0.7965060472,
-0.4094418585,
0.0062493328,
0.1647650748,
-0.5407276154,
0.148912549,
0.0179408845,
-0.6723008156,
0.4252553284,
-0.3314513266,
0.6715461612,
-0.5762677193,
-0.4234519899,
-0.1876924485,
-0.5743643045,
0.2385804653,
-0.2356597632,
0.1995930672,
-0.3176477849,
0.08845108,
0.6103662252,
-0.5987976789,
0.4703682661,
0.1175569668,
-0.2145309597,
0.5504849553,
0.75968045,
0.479957819,
0.0549840555,
0.1564560235,
0.3613626957,
0.4443837404,
-0.6202964187,
-0.697173059,
0.6856239438,
-0.600720048,
-0.4989583492,
-0.7402539849,
-0.3794530332,
-0.5839232206,
0.289796263,
0.0206881166,
0.5865927935,
0.047933694,
0.0991382301,
0.6198260188,
0.2252932638,
0.3364867866,
0.0533889681,
-0.2688599527,
-0.848371923,
0.670776248,
0.2576445043,
0.4615386426,
0.1633117944,
0.4277428687,
-0.483002007,
-0.2011166364,
-0.6889027357,
0.4736588001,
-0.6544502974,
-0.4128631949,
-0.404163897,
-0.5269427299,
-0.2114440799,
-0.094141908,
-0.7934513688,
-0.5222676396,
0.088590689,
0.1072521731,
0.1106793433,
0.7531576753,
-0.0106620062,
-0.1234358847,
-0.7666224837,
0.4553374648,
0.332855016,
0.551953733,
0.1521063149,
-0.280708909,
0.0422872268,
0.1921396554,
-0.2367517799,
-0.6003385782,
-0.0857263356,
-0.1585411578,
0.3704791963,
0.3185599744,
0.2921642959,
0.9809039235,
-0.4226300716,
0.6231687069,
0.4581893682,
-1.389138341,
0.5363642573,
-0.2062254995,
0.4835221171,
0.8122179508,
0.6096345782,
-0.5573025346,
-0.2769996524,
-0.818665266,
-0.5586059093,
0.5313801765,
0.5438779593,
-0.4199813306,
0.2327755392,
0.5605912805,
0.0481521077,
-0.0706699863,
-0.2700673342,
-0.0276970714,
0.0844587311,
-0.5477332473,
0.2109592706,
0.0722225457,
-0.3155616522,
-0.3030458987,
0.5780288577,
-0.4617253244,
-0.082390368,
0.4240030944,
0.1072969064,
-0.2620433569,
-0.0841806829,
0.3783870637,
1.1603437662,
-0.0344681069,
0.3220731318,
0.4834674001,
-0.5635909438,
0.1075047627,
-0.1516104639,
-0.1705220044,
-0.1913471669,
0.5577511191,
0.2517576218,
0.2017075717,
-0.5340516567,
0.4621017575,
-0.072638154,
-0.2296569943,
-0.4084858,
0.0674599558,
-0.0570341758,
0.2316256613,
0.3515417874,
0.2864339948,
0.0448415987,
-0.3400096297,
0.2870480716,
0.2353774458,
-0.5996912122,
-0.194582969,
0.4240236878,
-0.1581240594,
-0.1913394928,
0.6140415072,
0.1941540241,
-0.6880050898,
0.7035757899,
0.2411511987,
0.977827549,
-0.3749085069,
0.3665300906,
0.7535011768,
0.1237266436,
-0.5251723528,
0.6356109977,
-0.3277582824,
-0.448481679,
-0.4152449369,
-0.5505964756,
-0.6211006045,
-0.4637469947,
-0.7289219499,
0.4660299718,
-0.7264107466,
0.0555604808,
-0.0267028324,
0.030941179,
-0.6045373082,
0.3808836937,
0.2665016353,
0.8981510997,
-0.6460767388,
0.7163200974,
0.2229186147,
-0.3296836615,
-1.0920826197,
0.2571910322,
-0.0441929884,
-0.8850682974,
0.0695843622,
-0.017510578,
-0.6767421961,
-0.1666609943,
-0.7594569325,
-1.1563090086,
1.0388089418,
0.2889400423,
-0.8309124112,
-0.0777218565,
0.2341155559,
0.5574651957,
-0.4254232049,
0.4258228838,
0.5439481735,
0.2671073377,
0.9630949497,
-0.8423166275,
0.1840818375,
0.1662799567,
0.1315884441,
0.2907667756,
-0.8487342596,
0.7930888534,
-0.3247627914,
-0.0635797679,
-0.0432632305,
0.7102828026,
0.7098588943,
0.4306938052,
0.8250099421,
0.5326712132,
0.8793711066,
-0.1146187112,
0.6246715784,
-0.5414612293,
0.841340363,
1.184345603,
-0.2563481033,
0.8029690385,
0.1604513228,
-0.4427286685,
0.6852699518,
0.7433024645,
0.2417598963,
0.078693673,
0.1569467187,
-0.0772978961,
-0.9464342594,
0.2257122546,
-0.466940403,
0.412052989,
0.2145607769,
0.0135068865,
-0.3567110002,
-0.3790438771,
0.2016281039,
-0.0970485061,
-0.3630589545,
0.6354322433,
0.1805437803,
-0.7191319466,
0.7010210156,
-0.4709139466,
-0.1359875947,
-0.6210095286,
-0.2038963437,
-0.2836695015,
0.2712903321,
-0.2494130284,
-1.1765017509,
0.2868911028,
0.0043630982,
0.2990165651,
-0.0687956586,
0.3644625545,
-0.4477707744,
-0.9843054414,
0.133356303,
0.6889949441,
0.0011342394,
-0.305726856,
-0.7366294861,
0.1123356968,
0.1379184872,
0.1017223299,
-0.3132893443,
0.7128154039,
-0.2503408492,
0.7549064755,
0.7535176873,
0.0120255221,
-0.1264880002,
0.1907726228,
1.0501197577,
-1.0123238564,
-0.6042861938,
-0.8080468178,
0.2042797655,
-0.2050466388,
-0.4849891067,
0.5479615927,
0.8312183619,
0.8065981269,
0.2659127712,
0.5285727978,
0.1449369639,
0.3621189296,
-0.5233224034,
0.290797472,
-0.5107049346,
0.3056147397,
-0.3120070696,
-1.0338287354,
-0.5291597843,
0.445905149,
-0.4077529609,
0.1326193213,
1.2099659443,
0.395871222,
-0.2271177471,
0.4732369184,
0.19507882,
0.1088405475,
0.4783709645,
0.5776727796,
0.7717080116,
-0.3670606315,
0.6152560711,
-0.5111241341,
-0.4189782143,
0.0664031282,
-0.5666157007,
-0.7894587517,
-0.5224761367,
-0.345087558,
-0.7013755441,
-0.126221478,
1.1493705511,
0.6561916471,
-1.0298968554,
-0.3300760984,
-0.4822216928,
0.2027227581,
-0.4701224566,
-0.1559053063,
0.549133122,
-0.3449179232,
-0.5247738361,
-0.0346897356,
0.4897618592,
-0.1395466477,
-0.5925248265,
0.0824183151,
-0.2719729841,
0.3107182682,
0.3601800501,
0.1562912166,
-0.6496401429,
-0.3225383162,
0.1493923664,
-0.1292003542,
0.2670373023,
1.1074427366,
-0.3350946605,
0.6485314369,
0.5818049908,
0.3593385518,
0.8572710752,
0.1858650595,
0.5319893956,
-0.125979349,
-0.3659108281,
0.4734986722,
0.2843239307,
0.267226696,
-0.4079509377,
0.6813980341,
0.2328924686,
-0.4393355846,
-0.5861876011,
0.3634409904,
-1.1279348135,
-0.2616001964,
1.0972318649,
-0.1002532542,
-0.7131295204,
0.0561372489,
-0.2966824472,
0.1163967401,
-0.2481421232,
0.7750602365,
0.87038517,
-0.5995765924,
-0.0386733934,
-0.2297722548,
0.397007823,
0.4101008475,
-0.8749681115,
0.2703404427,
0.3281795382,
0.4547851384,
0.3315057755,
0.2874565125,
-0.2681207359,
0.1543385983,
-0.0711339638,
-0.128655985,
0.1332938224,
-0.8111811876,
-0.1297042668,
0.2041742951,
-0.3225397766,
-0.040246278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15758v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15758v2
|
Chimera: A Lossless Decoding Method for Accelerating Large Language Models Inference by Fusing all Tokens
| 2024-02-24T08:10:39 | 2024-04-18T16:23:16 |
Ziqian Zeng, Jiahong Yu, Qianshi Pang, Zihao Wang, Huiping Zhuang, Hongen Shao, Xiaofeng Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various tasks. However, their widespread application is hindered by the
resource-intensive decoding process. To address this challenge, current
approaches have incorporated additional decoding heads to enable parallel
prediction of multiple subsequent tokens, thereby achieving inference
acceleration. Nevertheless, the accuracy of these decoding heads falls short of
the auto-regressive decoding approach.
In light of these limitations, we propose Chimera, a novel framework
specifically designed for speculative sampling. Within this framework, we
introduce a lightweight draft model that effectively utilizes previously
generated tokens to predict subsequent words. To ensure both accuracy and
efficiency, we present two strategies within the lightweight draft model.
Firstly, we focus on capturing short-range dependencies at the bottom layer.
Secondly, we leverage the readily available representations from the original
LLM.Through empirical evaluation on the Vicuna and LlaMA-2 series, Chimera
demonstrates impressive results, achieving an average latency speedup ratio of
2.7x compared to the vanilla auto-regressive decoding approach. This highlights
the potential of our proposed framework in significantly improving the
efficiency of large language models during the decoding process.
|
[
-0.0889612809,
-0.6389489174,
0.5196828842,
0.3149007261,
-0.5826172829,
0.2800527811,
-0.1375843138,
-0.6989002228,
0.4278681576,
0.4605103135,
-0.4379638135,
-0.3402633965,
-0.6961242557,
0.1822317243,
-0.6110207438,
0.4976130128,
0.2264784276,
0.1547327191,
0.1806975752,
-0.0064596902,
-0.4625428617,
-0.2460203767,
-0.4812147617,
-0.2722052336,
0.4664553404,
0.3050515056,
0.6259213686,
0.9835532904,
0.0425191335,
0.3119698763,
-0.1045293882,
0.1399749517,
-0.5918286443,
0.0200470593,
-0.0273061711,
-0.8082668781,
-0.3256545067,
-0.1204309091,
0.5990902781,
0.7875677347,
-0.1961464584,
0.1410947144,
-0.0308867116,
0.2877304852,
-0.6270459294,
0.138574183,
-1.0708472729,
-0.2712465227,
-0.322981894,
-0.4073128104,
-0.4587206542,
-0.2381055653,
-0.1353951842,
-0.3479842246,
0.329500854,
0.2784321606,
0.4551377296,
0.1429633349,
-0.0415502973,
-0.0224722773,
-0.7188892365,
0.9149619341,
-0.973330617,
0.4353847504,
0.4775185883,
0.2413767576,
-0.3064334691,
-0.5167555809,
-0.6718241572,
-0.0330969989,
0.2848909497,
-0.2192105353,
-0.200913623,
-0.1379865557,
-0.0178192947,
0.2995975316,
-0.4185847044,
0.4049323797,
-0.3295338452,
-0.271520108,
0.4693388045,
0.2137126029,
0.0771191344,
-0.0678280145,
-0.1370987743,
-0.2366471142,
-0.6900230646,
-0.2124786675,
0.2625353038,
0.4560321271,
-0.4839684963,
0.6841164827,
-0.2196996212,
0.564222455,
0.1377370656,
-0.1324118525,
0.0532646179,
-0.2319433093,
-0.3015034199,
0.0852310359,
0.6745784879,
0.0994912684,
-0.1216806099,
-0.2412204742,
-0.1084378362,
0.2957194746,
-0.1293690205,
-1.0112377405,
-0.1793144494,
0.3994954526,
-0.7162890434,
-0.2984625399,
-0.0110868979,
-1.0064579248,
-0.409778446,
-0.0895978361,
-0.1000681221,
-0.5038633943,
-0.1620284319,
0.4874433875,
-0.0774538144,
0.3895426691,
0.4117207527,
-0.8871680498,
0.0725371316,
0.68069309,
0.8036394715,
-0.1285850853,
-0.3004606962,
-0.6008658409,
0.0920197144,
-0.652484715,
1.1339181662,
-0.7266854644,
-0.3375741839,
-0.1701105535,
-0.1073881537,
0.1967234462,
-0.2200773954,
0.5419490337,
-0.6972395182,
-0.0177635588,
-0.1232076958,
-0.6748960018,
-0.292268157,
-0.0401816294,
-0.7412182689,
0.7347331047,
0.2436282039,
-0.8358540535,
0.3488477468,
0.1335855871,
-0.2566126883,
0.0675073937,
-0.2692919075,
-0.0970317572,
0.4263128638,
0.3504696488,
0.5797448158,
-0.9394981861,
0.2242285609,
-0.68935287,
-0.8441827297,
0.0298778079,
-0.602207005,
0.5878347754,
0.1907700151,
-0.3779815137,
0.0758375153,
-0.7159819603,
-0.1190832257,
0.2309207171,
-0.3524821997,
-0.3508313,
0.1379379034,
0.1228013635,
-0.0323360413,
-0.062707223,
-0.4063913524,
0.1419804394,
-0.4916855693,
0.2409985214,
0.8082157373,
-0.1651359946,
0.3277161121,
-0.1897461414,
0.7792463303,
0.0136386463,
-0.2520292997,
-0.3934198618,
-0.3706643879,
-0.6385233998,
-0.4517645538,
0.4577493072,
0.3243355751,
-0.9720811248,
0.6946670413,
-0.4341656864,
-0.6123116612,
-0.6765217781,
0.2438645363,
0.1574923694,
0.1540936232,
0.284229964,
-0.0588523559,
-0.5705804825,
-0.7685580254,
-0.2594510913,
-0.3019942939,
-0.067557171,
-0.1754216552,
0.0825933963,
-0.3895375133,
0.6439999938,
-0.33590886,
0.0431957543,
-0.6355823874,
0.1862487495,
0.3261357546,
0.4831420779,
0.6467882991,
-0.3071704507,
-0.0922469199,
-0.0515440032,
-0.4678504467,
-0.088048853,
-0.3146119416,
-0.2435597032,
0.1284264326,
0.592428863,
-0.4977989495,
0.2206422091,
0.9352864027,
-0.5050880313,
0.4216293693,
-0.0742524713,
0.1460023075,
-1.2789740562,
0.0989382118,
-0.1736365259,
-0.2357583195,
-0.3436312675,
0.08028166,
0.0656316578,
0.0681731999,
-0.2006258518,
0.6528750062,
-0.5845580101,
0.0215179473,
-0.6829642653,
-0.1096474752,
-0.1190261841,
0.2814820111,
0.0915573314,
0.9189911485,
0.4910746515,
-0.4167098701,
-0.108078666,
0.0558816753,
-0.2829696238,
-0.0114830928,
-0.705389142,
0.0140300589,
-0.2796273232,
0.5388163924,
-0.8720424175,
-0.2125741988,
0.2283361554,
-0.255381763,
0.2424951345,
0.0217688344,
-0.5614588857,
-0.2634324133,
-0.4470459223,
0.7504079342,
0.6779778004,
-0.4577418268,
0.9295504689,
0.3879899085,
-0.1369566023,
-0.5871498585,
-0.7110647559,
0.1976553202,
-0.094310917,
-0.1459324807,
0.1343836337,
0.0089537641,
-0.0114637408,
-0.1145351082,
0.0450893193,
0.133073613,
0.0493799374,
0.0703077912,
0.4554565549,
-0.2836089134,
-0.1183119714,
0.1645605564,
-0.2268895954,
-0.0996678546,
-0.3813818097,
0.881229043,
0.0876218379,
-0.2149055451,
-0.6078788638,
0.5082815886,
0.6578992605,
-0.1251106262,
0.7565023303,
0.5213481188,
-0.3501513898,
-0.4917916954,
-0.7946138382,
-0.2619908452,
-0.4593150616,
0.2953828871,
-0.3324949443,
-0.9093350172,
0.6820042133,
0.0018300832,
0.062122874,
0.5171780586,
0.6268751621,
0.3196699023,
0.8653720021,
0.9527084827,
-0.4941949844,
0.3428676128,
-0.1719450057,
0.1800701767,
-0.5142392516,
-0.1704123616,
-0.85665977,
-0.0508925393,
-0.3781200647,
-1.0766780376,
-0.1800025403,
0.3597999513,
0.288333565,
0.4568477869,
-0.1001574919,
0.3755188286,
0.3134261668,
-0.1786247492,
0.4670054615,
0.2118961811,
-0.1722898781,
0.169529289,
-0.9870187044,
-0.3208733797,
1.0478419065,
0.4128819108,
1.1998968124,
-0.1946670264,
0.4435453713,
0.2158739418,
0.433726579,
-0.7931024432,
0.5319976211,
-0.0973612294,
-0.3889469206,
-0.0222251937,
-0.5389767885,
-0.7871032953,
0.3127304912,
-0.4406373203,
-0.6003628373,
0.4286612272,
0.2616569102,
-0.3110241592,
0.4893367887,
-0.3454552591,
0.3882582188,
0.0400516875,
-0.3062019348,
-0.4860451221,
-0.3655697107,
0.7934834361,
-0.5218476653,
0.0647687316,
-0.2802973688,
-0.1406864673,
0.5651084185,
-0.2460308224,
0.9695366025,
0.1688124388,
-0.4238478541,
0.2961924076,
0.232362628,
0.5765302181,
0.0044942992,
-0.3729946315,
0.3248342872,
0.1054480225,
-0.6294196844,
-0.5402213931,
0.6270326972,
-0.4539253712,
-0.2318783253,
-0.4444268942,
-0.5945179462,
-0.3517611623,
0.2674706876,
0.2345507294,
0.4854748845,
-0.1366061717,
0.1462490112,
0.3212832808,
-0.2854363322,
0.2950274944,
0.3977702856,
-0.1646852791,
-0.4045378864,
0.6855919361,
-0.2872554958,
0.0985621884,
0.321527034,
0.108529292,
-0.5082646012,
-0.9651222825,
-0.4433430433,
0.5660823584,
-0.5345440507,
-0.3761526644,
-0.8263678551,
0.2476783246,
-0.4949367046,
-0.1759607047,
-0.4777779579,
-0.2527225912,
-0.2291207016,
0.0291957855,
0.2623697221,
0.5164532065,
0.1310110837,
0.3837323785,
-1.0605127811,
0.4782542288,
-0.162048772,
0.3383615911,
0.4383211136,
-0.4646148086,
-0.2656292319,
-0.1386000216,
0.3454551995,
-0.7737842202,
0.3826954663,
0.0116164945,
0.47361058,
0.6478455663,
0.1040992141,
0.9700573683,
-0.4430340528,
0.5773361325,
0.1986302137,
-0.8452951908,
0.0527678356,
-0.364933759,
0.441950351,
0.7611086965,
0.1905351579,
-0.408780694,
-0.5489339232,
-0.4216280282,
-0.8113033175,
0.562451005,
-0.0597305074,
0.2871118188,
-0.2731119692,
0.3575587869,
0.3716368377,
0.1533677727,
-0.2843979895,
0.0561696775,
0.0009071827,
-0.229386583,
-0.3531043828,
-0.4870052934,
0.1681964546,
-0.1635516882,
0.6292178035,
-0.4773833752,
0.2884947956,
-0.0455943123,
0.0488858633,
-0.2115150094,
0.096241802,
0.3090077341,
0.4668235779,
-0.1677843034,
0.1251400411,
0.0969467834,
-0.3530817032,
0.1297165304,
0.2284901887,
-0.2084964961,
-0.020663701,
0.7926698327,
0.6722056866,
0.3387826383,
-1.0675573349,
0.1797387302,
-0.2506764233,
0.0196786094,
-0.0000283316,
-0.1414069384,
0.2740632594,
0.2963508964,
0.4377985001,
0.0477631092,
0.1037064344,
-0.6540901661,
0.2543749213,
0.4174553156,
-0.0647384077,
-0.3567274809,
0.8304763436,
0.1106014475,
0.2402980328,
0.4259547889,
-0.0517813563,
-0.2165286988,
0.401917547,
0.7215909958,
1.1830296516,
-0.0791021511,
0.0277934112,
0.2600467503,
0.2174516171,
-0.3902461529,
0.4130397737,
-0.0262763835,
-0.6967677474,
-0.6430341601,
-1.0429672003,
-0.0591884553,
0.0355193652,
-0.4675945044,
0.0067937924,
-0.5088641644,
-0.0710842684,
-0.3597232997,
-0.1380786896,
-0.5552355051,
-0.0464008301,
0.148650825,
1.2458765507,
-0.8229038119,
0.9922781587,
0.1526174545,
-0.0420710109,
-1.1565988064,
0.3420370519,
-0.0242827144,
-0.734134376,
0.2653447688,
0.151624009,
-0.6243883371,
-0.0324685015,
-0.2727861702,
-0.8665732741,
0.9964494705,
0.5189933181,
-0.6462703943,
-0.1689210236,
-0.2073598504,
0.4013922215,
-0.529972136,
0.2603162825,
0.7285051346,
0.2602679133,
0.2935005426,
-0.4116710722,
0.3482806087,
-0.192763716,
0.3669896424,
-0.1776414812,
-0.4822677374,
0.7290996909,
-0.2381167114,
-0.4370269179,
0.6497356296,
1.1192128658,
0.4770746827,
-0.1579050422,
0.5085182786,
0.2660961747,
0.6337066293,
0.1988575608,
1.2672599554,
-0.627096951,
0.0830105022,
1.0085629225,
-0.2659273148,
1.1122262478,
0.4710299075,
0.0362357646,
0.3470531702,
0.652202487,
0.1434560269,
0.2809006572,
-0.0245653763,
-0.1234791204,
-0.4964430332,
-0.1615811139,
-0.3782795668,
0.706969142,
0.2604744732,
-0.3305637538,
-0.4343344569,
-0.2397293448,
-0.0200661421,
0.0595485866,
-0.1830081642,
0.4043813944,
0.1688616127,
-0.5432276726,
0.7430109978,
0.4513067007,
1.0396673679,
-0.7774689198,
-0.1419803798,
-0.280649364,
0.1771540195,
0.1819215715,
-0.1945168376,
0.1049390063,
-0.0439814366,
0.0485787727,
0.163141191,
0.5618100762,
-0.5515426993,
-0.9496092796,
0.57051754,
0.6034635305,
0.042347312,
0.1224276051,
-0.5943400264,
0.5349581242,
-0.0728211775,
-0.1213779971,
0.156246528,
0.3221321702,
-0.0438541509,
0.6667110324,
0.9278546572,
0.3894150555,
0.0264252964,
0.0459056161,
1.0025086403,
-0.6804026365,
-0.731959641,
-0.6816524267,
0.0579718463,
0.2222650945,
-0.0970354155,
0.7709363699,
0.4499155879,
0.4824906886,
-0.1581579745,
0.6972305179,
0.1467090398,
0.4774564803,
-0.8319007158,
0.6913775802,
-0.5200146437,
0.3679683208,
-0.1948284805,
-1.0550957918,
-0.1448801458,
0.3566641808,
0.0774995759,
0.0158031471,
0.5810341835,
0.8229673505,
-0.1888557076,
0.0608045533,
0.1938605458,
0.2991760969,
0.3221248686,
0.381195277,
0.5781781673,
-0.3444530666,
0.2360474765,
-0.121768266,
-0.1913057417,
-0.2727092505,
-0.9287747145,
-0.988219738,
-0.2254853249,
0.1051101089,
-0.4228187799,
-0.0207343325,
1.0699201822,
0.7984278202,
-0.7936960459,
-0.3660883009,
-0.0023996017,
-0.1782839447,
-0.3333494663,
-0.1676245928,
0.3811791539,
-0.1632097214,
-0.9852041006,
0.7787246108,
0.1560160816,
0.1852537841,
-0.4603191316,
-0.037355084,
-0.0966259912,
0.4621497989,
0.5421789289,
0.3124465048,
-0.6782605052,
-0.0854708031,
-0.1777619421,
-0.0060840235,
-0.2204658091,
1.0960686207,
-1.0070588589,
0.1594118327,
0.81597054,
1.0824157,
0.3614036739,
0.2695025504,
0.9462370872,
-0.066889219,
0.6144253612,
0.3476979733,
0.4052581191,
0.2367769182,
-0.3006620407,
0.0870914087,
0.2128892392,
-0.0024229137,
-0.7740848064,
0.1251752228,
-1.0720421076,
-0.5944427848,
0.977373302,
0.0486538857,
-0.5343758464,
-0.092542842,
0.0388425291,
0.1087863818,
-0.4248941839,
0.8675986528,
0.3783731759,
0.2470992357,
-0.2529215813,
-0.3297334611,
0.3586260676,
0.4910305738,
-0.7908912897,
0.3697505891,
0.6504436731,
0.2758710086,
-0.1312380135,
0.897146225,
-0.1636110991,
0.1066877395,
0.3673543036,
-0.0935274363,
-0.0554732047,
-0.4984856546,
-0.5367895961,
0.2534389496,
0.1564212441,
0.1363780648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15755v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15755v2
|
Dental Severity Assessment through Few-shot Learning and SBERT Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-24T08:02:19 | 2024-04-06T08:18:57 |
Mohammad Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dental diseases have a significant impact on a considerable portion of the
population, leading to various health issues that can detrimentally affect
individuals' overall well-being. The integration of automated systems in oral
healthcare has become increasingly crucial. Machine learning approaches offer a
viable solution to address challenges such as diagnostic difficulties,
inefficiencies, and errors in oral disease diagnosis. These methods prove
particularly useful when physicians struggle to predict or diagnose diseases at
their early stages. In this study, thirteen different machine learning, deep
learning, and large language models were employed to determine the severity
level of oral health issues based on radiologists' reports. The results
revealed that the Few-shot learning with SBERT and Multi-Layer Perceptron model
outperformed all other models across various experiments, achieving an
impressive accuracy of 94.1% as the best result. Consequently, this model
exhibits promise as a reliable tool for evaluating the severity of oral
diseases, enabling patients to receive more effective treatment and aiding
healthcare professionals in making informed decisions regarding resource
allocation and the management of high-risk patients.
|
[
-0.1304472983,
-1.0136235952,
0.677023232,
-0.1856969744,
-0.2585660517,
-0.0400414392,
-0.3104325235,
-0.5486950278,
0.039215982,
0.2253424078,
-0.3948167264,
-0.5571625233,
-0.8029835224,
0.2372718453,
0.0382757708,
0.6323312521,
0.26519382,
0.7228751183,
-0.2261996567,
0.0800446123,
-0.6375003457,
0.142114833,
-0.5363570452,
-0.4304270148,
0.6468737125,
0.5537952781,
0.8000381589,
0.2944611907,
1.1989535093,
0.3546532989,
0.1829310358,
0.1963253766,
-0.3216172159,
0.0689888149,
-0.1638973653,
-0.2389288247,
-0.3533299267,
-0.5301190615,
0.1753759682,
1.0450334549,
0.1572766453,
0.3627743721,
-0.0465764664,
0.4551994205,
-0.5516914129,
0.102848202,
-0.5618488789,
0.3584060073,
-0.3450878561,
-0.1516099274,
-0.2246151417,
-0.278078407,
0.3845345676,
-0.3277336359,
-0.1848370731,
-0.3946715295,
0.8649385571,
0.543250978,
-0.1560710669,
-0.1434937865,
-0.7193092108,
0.803806603,
-0.6114333868,
0.1764446497,
0.3989167511,
0.4961758852,
-0.0742957294,
-0.6467999816,
-0.2385359406,
-0.1245935634,
0.0431797467,
0.2394227982,
-0.5870012045,
0.213571474,
0.1890984029,
0.15475519,
-0.7772542238,
0.6433523893,
-0.4461898506,
-0.1580430418,
0.3156221807,
0.4757046103,
0.3924675882,
-0.4861548245,
-0.4212417006,
-0.1957681775,
-0.3348220289,
0.2158559561,
-0.271538049,
0.9429830313,
0.2268102169,
0.3160113692,
-0.2062118053,
0.5847756863,
0.171805799,
-0.6686076522,
0.3634754121,
-0.0553012937,
-0.6924027801,
0.1269018352,
0.6401278973,
0.1964458674,
-0.4375477433,
0.1609562188,
-0.2435371131,
0.1257742047,
0.4397273958,
-0.8817072511,
-0.163067311,
0.2256109864,
-0.539742291,
-0.5107575655,
-0.1392928958,
-0.6233548522,
-0.4739235044,
-0.3752874136,
0.6062073112,
-0.62500453,
-0.2328478396,
0.0099541554,
-0.0138652828,
0.071916841,
0.6766497493,
-0.7188701034,
0.3675245047,
0.5627934933,
0.7511453629,
-0.199067995,
0.018102359,
-0.5986074209,
-0.2014437169,
-0.2826449871,
1.1420657635,
-0.5367508531,
-0.1845648438,
-0.1503399909,
-0.250960201,
-0.1228616163,
-0.9366195798,
0.2672522366,
-0.1859377027,
-0.4084246755,
0.229559347,
-0.3810141385,
-0.272439003,
0.2027843595,
-0.4556048512,
0.455344528,
0.6273369789,
-0.2611581087,
0.5520150661,
-0.2211438566,
-0.715933919,
0.6242815852,
-0.0560825467,
-0.8566105962,
0.496766001,
0.139354527,
0.638907373,
-0.2852623463,
0.2101211548,
-0.4504079521,
-0.0870189071,
0.0619359799,
-0.1590644121,
0.7177783251,
0.1631656736,
-0.0484718829,
0.391392976,
-0.6427532434,
0.1727813631,
-0.0332365595,
-0.091602765,
-0.2056151032,
-0.405747503,
-0.2117282748,
0.2877495289,
0.0066924701,
-0.1333839297,
-0.0037575159,
-0.5103982687,
0.3111628592,
0.7940986753,
0.4238767624,
0.021759266,
-0.5066372156,
0.5815314651,
0.2846788168,
0.5275617242,
-0.1954312325,
-0.4839500785,
-0.2283878624,
-0.2221286595,
0.5876585245,
0.5762783885,
-0.3443443775,
0.4368529022,
-0.5808724761,
-0.800806284,
-0.7445605397,
0.2592923939,
0.554960072,
0.6490345001,
0.3886785805,
-0.6929838657,
-0.1563987285,
-0.5835828781,
0.1462613195,
0.1070755869,
0.0872666016,
0.3731318712,
0.4417332113,
-0.4838141203,
0.6908429265,
-0.3145416677,
-0.6835725307,
-0.1570438147,
0.2352650911,
0.0450909324,
0.5121372342,
0.5025652647,
-0.5537458658,
-0.6130561829,
0.3373513222,
-0.7655791044,
0.1995909065,
0.249775067,
0.3199103475,
0.1540459543,
0.0820239335,
-0.2933126986,
0.6806532145,
0.3332743645,
0.2446294725,
0.3834174871,
-0.2554284036,
0.069462128,
-0.3122297525,
-0.1235673055,
0.2999789417,
-0.3714278042,
-0.5011829138,
-0.1187037453,
0.0387993865,
-0.3387364149,
-0.8646503687,
0.2398941666,
0.1700500101,
0.0430485643,
-0.2023947239,
-0.2818302214,
-0.1585495621,
0.0622445233,
-0.2980300784,
0.4391974509,
0.8528056741,
-0.7462545633,
0.5407071114,
0.0589103848,
-0.4597876668,
0.4082306921,
-0.6260488033,
0.0703050718,
-0.0566018485,
-0.0972303525,
-0.8140698075,
-0.6649001837,
0.0318448693,
-0.6937729716,
0.4721969068,
-0.0493081473,
-0.2705973089,
-0.5543988943,
-0.256313771,
0.0517522618,
0.3450089991,
-0.1828377247,
0.3158145845,
0.5270853043,
-0.479073137,
-0.5043981075,
-0.7515864372,
-0.0563353933,
-0.1797658205,
-0.7751272917,
0.4768103659,
-0.0021249747,
-0.3497410417,
0.1237127408,
-0.2313224077,
-0.4172065258,
0.209566474,
0.3958756626,
0.1484906077,
-0.582270503,
0.3771943152,
0.2435391545,
-0.4368268251,
-0.3418408036,
0.0621803552,
0.5793227553,
-0.2340043038,
-0.3229943216,
-0.9646456242,
0.0290616211,
0.3167508543,
-0.1622044444,
0.3548340797,
0.4781644642,
-0.7252796888,
0.0669168755,
-0.323494494,
-0.289801091,
-0.4047741592,
0.4059186876,
-0.5434995294,
-0.7018748522,
0.5074402094,
-0.4495943189,
-0.367246747,
0.5682798624,
0.6683502197,
-0.3242024481,
1.1303166151,
0.5510361195,
-0.0090428255,
0.3515675962,
-0.0380076542,
-0.0217191167,
-0.1681482196,
-0.1504479647,
-0.5249239802,
-0.1642028391,
-0.6991574764,
0.1116409823,
0.6382252574,
-0.064874202,
-0.1702862829,
0.312841922,
-0.5059512258,
0.3538111448,
0.3581664264,
0.6374975443,
0.12818259,
-0.0972806066,
-0.0604094118,
-0.1449303627,
-0.543151021,
-0.5228151083,
1.0228575468,
0.4219682515,
0.7668264508,
0.1362368017,
0.7376926541,
0.5527016521,
0.0416035503,
-0.9882546663,
-0.0116667114,
-0.6809960604,
-0.2772137821,
-0.6666355133,
-0.4913235903,
-1.1248947382,
0.1542247981,
-0.2642836273,
-0.5342490673,
0.2932623029,
0.0005738822,
-1.284748435,
-0.1830181181,
-0.8228724599,
1.1772518158,
-0.4049094319,
-0.2289513797,
-0.4588500559,
-0.955483973,
0.1110676751,
-0.0211825874,
0.2483516186,
-0.365447551,
0.2971293032,
0.6045790315,
-0.2173286676,
0.9440889359,
-0.0597955287,
0.140691638,
-0.1090702489,
0.0464482121,
0.0643314123,
0.2951328754,
-0.0878634155,
0.0783106089,
-0.0445254408,
-0.3809922636,
-0.5726063848,
0.6695200205,
-0.9874843955,
-0.4132125378,
-0.4130259454,
-0.1422589719,
-0.2490082532,
0.6995819211,
-0.0128188627,
0.422834456,
-0.4109015167,
-0.2158400565,
0.8159764409,
-0.4052790105,
0.223595649,
0.244169578,
0.0441697203,
-0.4956074357,
1.0201339722,
0.2825625837,
0.2516340911,
0.5151166916,
0.5419940948,
0.2608398795,
-0.6578732133,
-0.4133888483,
0.0832511187,
-0.9699949622,
-0.9553410411,
-0.2675999105,
-0.1897255182,
-0.7599861026,
-0.0338120721,
-0.4411161244,
-0.017864285,
-0.5576770902,
-0.0661040545,
0.2184602469,
0.7072914839,
-0.0112398509,
0.4694640934,
-0.8098548651,
0.4458443522,
0.4483189583,
0.2527624369,
-0.252361238,
-0.4431847036,
-0.144973129,
-0.1450740546,
-0.4175617993,
-0.5596752763,
0.5312013626,
0.0877984688,
0.3328931034,
0.7865905762,
0.071991697,
0.8478714228,
-0.1880463362,
0.392026484,
0.3815454245,
-0.906847775,
0.8043459058,
-0.1132069677,
0.2102696151,
0.8880844712,
0.4598098695,
-0.3881020546,
-0.1018249914,
-0.5764371157,
-0.6259747148,
0.7081651688,
-0.4444375038,
-0.0400214121,
0.0459055677,
0.0864679888,
0.432939738,
-0.2237476856,
-0.3786833882,
-0.0517043509,
-0.2837611735,
-0.1922562867,
0.2157527655,
-0.135321781,
0.0016166113,
-0.5510748625,
0.6579543948,
-0.1510130316,
0.2367227525,
0.0566530935,
-0.8186266422,
-0.7208907008,
0.3359864652,
0.9956846237,
1.0078657866,
-0.5350750685,
0.3931062222,
0.2511580586,
-0.2805583775,
-0.2246635407,
0.0098664975,
0.0569679812,
0.0699797869,
0.5024619102,
0.7326571345,
0.0908879191,
-0.6017794609,
0.7833265066,
0.1377686858,
-0.1366990805,
-0.2435475588,
0.1093421802,
-0.2117440552,
0.0776527599,
0.244291991,
0.5774097443,
0.1036850959,
-0.4372715354,
0.3379977345,
0.3383477926,
-1.0274243355,
-0.2126006484,
0.1157416999,
0.3492920399,
-0.1325595826,
1.0525772572,
-0.2422170639,
-0.3652759492,
0.777520597,
0.4615328908,
0.3908033967,
-0.5523376465,
0.1736729145,
0.4268517196,
0.2014104426,
0.1423006803,
-0.1652414501,
0.4300188124,
-0.5770165324,
-0.3866659701,
-0.5574406385,
-0.2364411354,
0.2073920965,
-0.8249372244,
0.6243165731,
-0.6387467384,
-0.3366619945,
0.68339926,
0.3318852484,
-0.822558105,
0.4243614674,
0.4050424695,
0.6431799531,
-0.8673234582,
0.5052854419,
0.5779901147,
-0.8989650607,
-0.4122756422,
-0.2629449666,
0.3904468715,
-1.2944099903,
0.8657220602,
0.30439502,
-0.1233022735,
0.0107173007,
-0.3700090349,
-0.7459400892,
0.9175908566,
0.4288122952,
-0.5949255824,
0.1797410697,
0.1661790162,
0.4857767224,
-0.0426673889,
0.4264900982,
0.6381210089,
0.6783861518,
-0.1067425013,
-1.4144271612,
-0.0043442044,
0.1415287554,
0.0986340865,
0.1418685615,
-0.2853999734,
0.8135691881,
-0.497913748,
-0.2590227723,
-0.2322683036,
0.386864841,
-0.1431557685,
0.4401708245,
0.2836806774,
0.8957461119,
0.9579026103,
0.043247018,
0.9171788096,
0.0575420633,
0.2654469907,
0.653395772,
-0.1269744039,
0.6906120777,
-0.0126711456,
-0.5287798643,
0.2268862724,
0.8074072599,
-0.2375473678,
0.6062257886,
0.3748343289,
-0.1903863698,
-0.5302944183,
-0.2209585905,
-0.2758702934,
0.7202933431,
0.5220894814,
-0.2271410227,
-0.3303622901,
0.6721563339,
-0.045295544,
-0.236893177,
-0.7113192081,
1.1834360361,
0.08757025,
-0.2834922671,
0.3651197851,
0.0664707944,
0.7231795192,
-0.3608815372,
-0.0930012688,
0.024848558,
0.4932626188,
-0.6192200184,
-0.5654375553,
0.3538978696,
-0.182332769,
-0.3951741755,
-0.126357466,
0.936142385,
0.0954292715,
-0.5741193295,
0.0933481008,
0.4717128873,
0.2940555215,
-0.1610778719,
-0.686640501,
-0.0409147255,
-0.264069438,
0.1534624249,
0.4711109996,
0.4273189604,
0.0420123003,
0.5918946862,
0.340901196,
0.0267267805,
-0.0762353316,
0.3915805519,
0.5763037801,
-0.587300837,
0.133096993,
-1.0364587307,
0.3225423694,
0.3265498281,
-0.3287266791,
0.4363176823,
0.4813352823,
0.8293432593,
-0.1650110483,
0.6836919785,
0.2251517177,
0.7387923002,
-0.2995224297,
0.6020890474,
-0.413507849,
0.0323914997,
-0.4567324817,
-0.0369187184,
-1.0471259356,
0.6745128632,
-0.2535353899,
-0.061130397,
0.6214851141,
0.6040594578,
0.0063703121,
-0.3471695185,
0.4805629551,
0.1329063922,
0.1243617833,
0.4083735347,
0.6485829353,
-0.2085631341,
0.4624938369,
-0.6474024057,
-0.2417941391,
-0.6990733743,
-0.4063208401,
-0.5161064267,
-0.297660917,
-0.4984653592,
-0.1465151608,
0.0567416064,
1.0993916988,
0.7858315706,
-0.8255476356,
0.0498214625,
0.1211662143,
0.227296561,
-0.5463088155,
-0.1680495888,
0.6370349526,
-0.806196332,
-0.4013476074,
0.2262486517,
0.6134508848,
0.101828672,
-0.1009123623,
0.0466752648,
0.4051451385,
-0.4915398955,
0.6560478806,
0.1850419939,
-0.8925933242,
-0.149407804,
0.0715298504,
-0.4158770144,
0.5331197381,
0.3272898197,
-0.9112263322,
0.528161943,
0.1884380281,
0.6778982878,
0.4194849133,
-0.2173820734,
0.1048969403,
-0.3463796079,
-0.3249391913,
0.7094547749,
0.031613186,
0.202761665,
-0.3710089028,
0.1051079109,
0.1483265609,
-0.3712635636,
-0.9301675558,
-0.0644269288,
-1.1642147303,
-0.6092903614,
0.683673501,
-0.1774330288,
-0.35618788,
-0.1391022652,
0.2907428145,
0.3615570962,
-0.4519754946,
0.7810112238,
0.3891304135,
-0.7409957647,
-0.1560045183,
-0.560202837,
0.4769699574,
0.1829247773,
-0.891450882,
-0.3492738903,
0.122848995,
0.3395093679,
0.14029935,
0.4430238307,
0.0048317164,
0.5943145156,
-0.0462073609,
0.0209864713,
0.0484766774,
-0.3037909269,
-0.4692088366,
0.2627852261,
0.2738656998,
0.0845618546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15754v1
|
HD-Eval: Aligning Large Language Model Evaluators Through Hierarchical Criteria Decomposition
| 2024-02-24T08:01:32 | 2024-02-24T08:01:32 |
Yuxuan Liu, Tianchi Yang, Shaohan Huang, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a promising alternative to
expensive human evaluations. However, the alignment and coverage of LLM-based
evaluations are often limited by the scope and potential bias of the evaluation
prompts and criteria. To address this challenge, we propose HD-Eval, a novel
framework that iteratively aligns LLM-based evaluators with human preference
via Hierarchical Criteria Decomposition. HD-Eval inherits the essence from the
evaluation mindset of human experts and enhances the alignment of LLM-based
evaluators by decomposing a given evaluation task into finer-grained criteria,
aggregating them according to estimated human preferences, pruning
insignificant criteria with attribution, and further decomposing significant
criteria. By integrating these steps within an iterative alignment training
process, we obtain a hierarchical decomposition of criteria that
comprehensively captures aspects of natural language at multiple levels of
granularity. Implemented as a white box, the human preference-guided aggregator
is efficient to train and more explainable than relying solely on prompting,
and its independence from model parameters makes it applicable to closed-source
LLMs. Extensive experiments on three evaluation domains demonstrate the
superiority of HD-Eval in further aligning state-of-the-art evaluators and
providing deeper insights into the explanation of evaluation results and the
task itself.
|
[
-0.4888703227,
-0.8215825558,
0.5871167779,
-0.0072548413,
-0.0319594108,
0.3089360297,
-0.5727577806,
0.0788243711,
0.0024715264,
0.4221011102,
-0.4386456907,
-0.6556542516,
-0.3746594787,
-0.0260938723,
-0.2710103393,
1.0788736343,
-0.0493465811,
-0.198673293,
-0.4763843119,
-0.0014105478,
-0.3053557575,
-0.4310874045,
-0.3286089599,
-0.4394631982,
0.401797235,
0.407569766,
0.8030411005,
0.8630201817,
0.5942708254,
0.2950144708,
-0.094056569,
-0.0137920184,
-0.5134153962,
-0.0880049765,
-0.3583291173,
-0.0212021749,
-0.6163167953,
-0.0622428618,
0.8036894798,
0.8169202209,
-0.4398820102,
0.3998384774,
0.2451068163,
0.9065825343,
-1.0081868172,
0.1060576513,
-0.6097825766,
-0.1871579587,
-0.0568119213,
-0.4045818746,
-0.518609643,
-0.4266383052,
0.0689169914,
-0.330775857,
0.0107489834,
0.1082385182,
0.773648262,
0.3848383427,
-0.4837505817,
0.1839244366,
-0.6472792029,
0.944875598,
-0.4613875449,
0.5452768803,
0.4069495797,
0.3980320096,
0.0588448644,
-0.0600566529,
-0.4713163972,
-0.1731609553,
-0.0431886278,
-0.0574546084,
-0.1665697992,
0.2352324277,
-0.0978294462,
0.4484955668,
-0.6893258691,
0.4689981937,
-0.2877700627,
-0.2425328046,
0.676302433,
0.327458322,
0.117123045,
-0.2885929644,
-0.4157729745,
0.0655206814,
-0.5612078905,
-0.0173592325,
0.3231574595,
0.3896811008,
-0.1490315944,
0.5846558809,
-0.1661833674,
0.820853591,
0.2589175403,
-0.3211432099,
0.2746504545,
-0.3762387335,
-0.2595089078,
0.2047555298,
0.9248946905,
0.41204831,
-0.0251430329,
0.0490924455,
-0.4604846537,
0.3428119719,
0.4372738004,
-0.7114402652,
0.1070359722,
0.4234478772,
-0.4747356474,
-0.4277243316,
-0.2083164752,
-0.8101268411,
-0.4613697827,
-0.7257413864,
0.3312768042,
-0.1502887011,
-0.1394168288,
0.0833024457,
0.2558688819,
0.1678132564,
0.2582754195,
-1.1199553013,
0.4626112282,
0.9614736438,
0.5481036305,
-0.428640008,
-0.3335172236,
-0.9059926867,
-0.0971745029,
-0.3309103847,
0.7516652346,
-0.7719780207,
0.022896722,
0.1531583518,
-0.4374131858,
-0.0394976474,
-0.6402739882,
0.5134849548,
-0.5542083383,
0.2448163331,
0.0375226773,
-0.5574995279,
0.1174004823,
0.5037741065,
-0.547778368,
1.0765180588,
0.3490415215,
-0.670103848,
0.2763157189,
-0.77305758,
-0.152020067,
0.2067986876,
-0.2026463002,
-0.3408484459,
0.0370767377,
0.4039054513,
0.3992466331,
-0.5441130996,
0.6365523934,
-0.2061353922,
-0.4725586474,
0.027340943,
-0.4509369731,
0.8607413173,
0.2015193403,
-0.1932183057,
0.5954736471,
-0.6902274489,
-0.0054056291,
-0.261862129,
-0.6098954678,
-0.1747211963,
-0.0780260786,
0.1123565286,
0.0039560902,
0.4198081493,
-0.4513529241,
0.197873041,
-0.4143773615,
0.190001443,
0.9724363685,
-0.278364867,
0.5682963729,
-0.2405366153,
0.8331856728,
-0.1876561791,
-0.0280833524,
-0.1666166484,
0.1287971139,
-0.5312879682,
-0.4947778583,
0.3099680543,
0.3509231806,
-0.3935935199,
1.0486921072,
-0.5897042155,
-0.2119200081,
-1.0316040516,
0.3997404873,
0.4844609499,
0.6755321026,
0.2262507975,
0.1192378923,
-0.6486274004,
-1.1629936695,
-0.0252789389,
-0.2580598295,
0.0190874487,
0.0608123504,
0.5384628773,
-0.4427439868,
1.0694859028,
-0.3679664135,
-0.4267477095,
-0.4250065982,
-0.0216110963,
0.1023291349,
0.2404317111,
0.2138779312,
-0.5527070761,
-0.4932244718,
0.323612839,
-0.441496253,
-0.3280245662,
0.0553394407,
-0.2624591589,
0.2348800302,
0.1088257208,
-0.4071736932,
0.1823753417,
0.6612848639,
-0.287245363,
0.7666171193,
-0.1301847845,
0.1729357988,
-0.9343426228,
0.2489312887,
0.1776212752,
-0.2655848861,
-0.3513621986,
0.197603628,
0.1560914963,
0.0319028609,
-0.269269526,
0.7384803891,
-0.2340464443,
-0.2103240043,
-0.2079199404,
0.4092270136,
0.1427641362,
0.6122151613,
0.1244527102,
0.6238862872,
0.5706487894,
-0.3618894517,
0.2544924617,
0.4100306928,
-0.672319293,
0.7535222769,
-0.2246069163,
0.1805379838,
-0.2818303108,
0.2197361737,
-0.8159579635,
-0.1004418433,
-0.0787715465,
-0.022566516,
0.1308880746,
-0.083457917,
-0.3229494095,
-0.306555301,
-0.5894085169,
0.4291657209,
0.7206099033,
-0.6959257126,
0.518617034,
0.4394159317,
-0.1371642798,
-0.7297038436,
-0.2008714229,
0.0631935149,
-0.4027160108,
-0.4426420629,
0.4893451035,
-0.1987910867,
-0.6103166342,
-0.0241256393,
-0.2179203033,
-0.0880215317,
0.1343777776,
0.0954906046,
0.5221738219,
-0.272308588,
-0.1820422858,
-0.0915504992,
-0.2322348207,
-0.049157422,
-0.1600484997,
0.4905162156,
-0.3545278907,
-0.3942983747,
-0.69085747,
0.3389430046,
0.5272247791,
-0.3753408194,
0.3653022945,
0.2720945179,
-0.3522691727,
-0.1287944764,
-0.6175474524,
0.1399789602,
-0.4575321078,
0.4966415167,
-0.2062347382,
-0.7469659448,
0.1064528748,
0.1980499178,
0.2180831283,
0.2560028136,
0.8386098146,
-0.0304568037,
1.2570403814,
0.6301714778,
-0.2066964507,
0.2795253396,
-0.1605059654,
0.2075620741,
-1.2204530239,
-0.1168908775,
-0.5192930698,
-0.3504672945,
-0.1550994515,
-0.2364786267,
0.275313139,
-0.0145492069,
-0.4094969928,
0.1616501659,
-0.4397094846,
0.6339023709,
0.0465863086,
0.0033826556,
0.2659949958,
-0.0048513315,
0.0316334069,
0.0073263799,
-0.4625868797,
-0.703335166,
0.856716454,
0.5920908451,
0.666174829,
0.0117776869,
0.8686761856,
0.3489573896,
0.6158604622,
-1.2146337032,
0.4778252244,
-0.1343219131,
-0.3586374521,
-0.3591621518,
-0.378713578,
-0.8619900346,
0.498893857,
0.0768347681,
-1.0649194717,
-0.1385305077,
0.2905674279,
-0.5388283134,
0.0509648249,
-0.5518345833,
1.0235356092,
-0.41732499,
-0.3426064849,
-0.3193729818,
-0.3103305697,
0.4716210067,
-0.3054966927,
0.4634141922,
-0.1844821572,
0.0662702993,
0.804669559,
-0.4498659968,
0.6744157672,
-0.1256163418,
-0.4421489537,
0.0118087633,
0.1903114319,
0.3900231421,
-0.3078068197,
-0.3267480135,
0.0674363822,
-0.0544865876,
-0.2785634398,
-0.8021417856,
0.6649551392,
-0.5080678463,
-0.8662039638,
-0.0782127902,
-0.6691885591,
-0.381998539,
0.0737875029,
-0.1427752078,
0.4491565228,
-0.164602533,
0.2779575884,
0.1810638458,
-0.0489346124,
0.1754992008,
0.4026637673,
-0.4732331932,
-0.48153615,
0.921818912,
-0.3475711644,
0.2869822681,
0.6135957837,
0.5938783884,
-0.4334584177,
-0.6005885005,
-0.3945933878,
-0.017732298,
-0.7391993403,
-0.1728764176,
-0.4220929444,
-0.0118897175,
-0.1581053883,
-0.4638320506,
-0.3217378259,
-0.054798305,
0.0542748831,
-0.2265162319,
-0.024402855,
0.5182991624,
0.2941688597,
0.3211070895,
-0.702370584,
0.4793217182,
0.1420587152,
0.4657393396,
-0.0158766825,
-0.644454062,
-0.3303686976,
0.1797044873,
-0.1930011213,
-0.4705826938,
0.4046309888,
0.1164059341,
0.4199770689,
0.5701980591,
0.0679800957,
1.0993841887,
-0.4975548983,
0.670268178,
0.2426236868,
-1.1357370615,
0.4452592134,
-0.3455675244,
0.244173944,
0.8654757142,
0.2559151053,
-0.3599426448,
-0.3008251488,
-0.3381536305,
-0.6675781012,
0.815413475,
-0.033327911,
0.0112578934,
0.0553172454,
0.0572852381,
0.344501555,
0.1422704905,
-0.5554786921,
-0.0519887023,
0.0873568878,
-0.4308190942,
0.0439236909,
-0.2726951838,
-0.2864687741,
-0.4756545722,
0.6241394281,
-0.3743026257,
-0.149330005,
-0.3085550666,
-0.2682955265,
-0.2662566602,
0.6178729534,
0.2030215561,
0.9648680091,
-0.2955032885,
0.2969706953,
-0.0734156966,
-0.0109969312,
0.3078237176,
-0.0398172401,
-0.0509022288,
-0.4185606539,
0.5039471984,
0.8135120273,
0.4521651864,
-0.9174913764,
0.6596333385,
0.1519303769,
-0.1928643882,
-0.0005705172,
0.0117330058,
-0.008245578,
-0.0353517383,
0.2235101014,
-0.075680241,
0.0260404777,
-0.6564760804,
0.2865769267,
0.5559757948,
-0.3675136566,
-0.4259545505,
0.4941497743,
0.3338553607,
-0.5081592798,
0.6925967336,
-0.1099105105,
-0.640540719,
0.3888355196,
0.5986923575,
1.1113202572,
-0.2387858629,
0.3816343248,
0.2590868771,
-0.0692784414,
0.0694273412,
0.2003139108,
-0.4344221056,
-0.7692179084,
-0.6718485355,
-1.0441806316,
-0.283041209,
0.2475948334,
-0.8193621635,
0.3364650309,
-0.1865203232,
0.1764448732,
0.2386251688,
-0.1657912582,
-0.7879523039,
-0.1637145281,
0.1910416335,
0.7525944114,
-0.7950658202,
0.8378148675,
0.6877618432,
-0.1444694102,
-0.5386886597,
0.1495951861,
0.1479497254,
-0.8505343795,
0.885695219,
0.3538062572,
-0.0660929158,
-0.0487513021,
-0.198359862,
-0.7088909745,
0.7479193807,
0.6412603259,
-0.6913202405,
-0.0090334583,
-0.002551035,
0.547191143,
-0.532053113,
0.3058731258,
1.0647691488,
0.7514953613,
-0.0207222868,
-1.1820368767,
0.0136462031,
-0.3383478224,
-0.0584750175,
0.3644491136,
-0.3161300421,
0.3763581216,
-0.3693506122,
-0.303691119,
-0.0904588699,
0.2538425028,
0.3604305983,
-0.012711375,
0.6004335284,
0.3751957417,
0.6907118559,
0.0624672845,
1.122800827,
-0.2460316867,
0.3498355746,
1.0964955091,
-0.6176151633,
0.9772642851,
0.5005589128,
-0.3232465088,
0.5869449377,
0.532107234,
0.1649030745,
0.3902028501,
0.1567050666,
-0.1555165499,
-0.4496389031,
-0.3630107045,
0.2557397187,
0.6957478523,
0.2161104381,
-0.0833580941,
-0.488402307,
-0.1132061258,
-0.2269795537,
0.287481457,
-0.2354962379,
0.8721445203,
-0.1961289644,
-0.9106786251,
1.0042408705,
-0.0358413868,
0.5559461713,
-0.5100304484,
-0.0611266308,
0.0720674694,
0.1803860962,
-0.4659772217,
-0.8405730128,
0.2754513025,
0.1884822398,
-0.0651083365,
-0.5480009913,
0.2622267604,
-0.5784144402,
-0.194172442,
0.1573864967,
0.248522386,
0.006992531,
-0.1366129667,
-0.594648242,
0.2631335557,
0.0219428614,
-0.3578404784,
0.4108182788,
0.048349645,
-0.2153027952,
0.6608551741,
0.5158959627,
0.0481140316,
-0.4333221614,
0.2950328588,
0.6193709373,
-0.7633705139,
-0.4361950457,
-1.1034463644,
0.8507285714,
0.1215242818,
-0.1333084852,
0.5849024653,
0.8228386641,
0.5855465531,
0.1538312435,
0.8622646332,
0.1552254558,
0.1108943447,
-0.5119701624,
0.4540804923,
-0.3844063282,
0.5495281219,
-0.0906928629,
-1.2088061571,
-0.1229676157,
0.4610619247,
-0.2919823229,
0.0021109686,
0.7442064881,
0.6500672698,
0.0187370386,
-0.2882530689,
0.3509337008,
0.0355025344,
0.3930060565,
0.4914083183,
0.9537138939,
0.0053923135,
0.327832818,
-0.3415025473,
-0.3729348183,
-0.261885345,
-1.0133767128,
-0.7878783941,
-0.6544475555,
-0.5665290356,
0.0798965767,
-0.2123034745,
1.3662923574,
0.6882144809,
-0.6625596285,
-0.418418169,
0.1703147292,
0.3161464334,
-0.3910309374,
-0.324146688,
0.7146618962,
-0.3156066239,
-0.8850393295,
0.6004955173,
0.4978226125,
-0.4195795059,
-0.6480523944,
-0.2490664423,
0.1296387315,
-0.0603103526,
0.7488218546,
-0.0628850535,
-1.00766325,
-0.3621122241,
-0.214831695,
-0.0334003419,
0.3266784847,
0.7859979868,
-1.0245736837,
0.5341368318,
0.469163388,
0.8371148705,
0.0559590161,
0.2979562283,
0.6493899226,
-0.8781297207,
-0.2412824333,
0.2445168346,
0.4309387207,
0.3349280953,
-0.345705092,
0.3198109269,
-0.3450884521,
-0.4528076053,
-1.0946495533,
0.0921159834,
-1.0341235399,
-0.0760381818,
1.4397780895,
0.2522455454,
-0.3337885737,
-0.0385684706,
-0.3096880019,
-0.2906778753,
-0.4576962292,
1.0199270248,
0.6565440297,
-0.1566828936,
-0.0503265262,
-0.3665494323,
0.3845896125,
0.3327558339,
-0.9845203161,
0.6685735583,
0.6930893064,
0.141055122,
0.1994505972,
0.6788255572,
-0.1328202039,
0.3296279311,
-0.3940281868,
0.1217080727,
-0.1088273153,
-0.2575109601,
-0.6963596344,
0.13308236,
0.1589076817,
-0.006014002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15751v1
|
Sparse MeZO: Less Parameters for Better Performance in Zeroth-Order LLM Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-24T07:22:04 | 2024-02-24T07:22:04 |
Yong Liu, Zirui Zhu, Chaoyu Gong, Minhao Cheng, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Yang You
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for specific tasks often
yields impressive results, it comes at the cost of memory inefficiency due to
back-propagation in gradient-based training. Memory-efficient Zeroth-order
(MeZO) optimizers, recently proposed to address this issue, only require
forward passes during training, making them more memory-friendly. However, the
quality of gradient estimates in zeroth order optimization often depends on the
data dimensionality, potentially explaining why MeZO still exhibits significant
performance drops compared to standard fine-tuning across various tasks.
Inspired by the success of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT), this paper
introduces Sparse MeZO, a novel memory-efficient zeroth-order optimization
approach that applies ZO only to a carefully chosen subset of parameters. We
propose a simple yet effective parameter selection scheme that yields
significant performance gains with Sparse-MeZO. Additionally, we develop a
memory-optimized implementation for sparse masking, ensuring the algorithm
requires only inference-level memory consumption, allowing Sparse-MeZO to
fine-tune LLaMA-30b on a single A100 GPU. Experimental results illustrate that
Sparse-MeZO consistently improves both performance and convergence speed over
MeZO without any overhead. For example, it achieves a 9\% absolute accuracy
improvement and 3.5x speedup over MeZO on the RTE task.
|
[
-0.5664814115,
-0.7486887574,
0.4414859414,
0.2347074449,
-0.6287553906,
0.0333669074,
-0.3771012723,
-0.4327194393,
0.2651935816,
0.322966665,
-0.7107800841,
-0.5057573915,
-0.4927493632,
-0.0598321147,
0.1815653443,
0.6867219806,
0.1550839096,
0.0609765165,
0.1573619395,
-0.1759950668,
-0.3954607248,
-0.2955560386,
-0.6944236755,
-0.2775871456,
0.8560089469,
0.6774947643,
0.46627298,
0.8609561324,
-0.1845679879,
0.2862072289,
-0.1145395339,
0.2531145811,
-0.6815040112,
0.0120415613,
0.1488696039,
-0.2374088019,
-0.7786676884,
-0.0121775819,
0.4900771379,
0.6701344848,
-0.2048631757,
0.1064776331,
-0.0575376339,
0.4902921021,
-0.967281878,
-0.2060216069,
-0.7702363729,
0.0544513278,
-0.2520115674,
-0.2763788998,
-0.1781443059,
-0.0449667573,
-0.2814764678,
-0.636280477,
0.4021446407,
0.0759826526,
0.6461088657,
0.4325559139,
0.4796847105,
0.18565844,
-0.6539686918,
1.0587568283,
-0.773901403,
0.6526732445,
0.2989197373,
0.0911640301,
-0.0234194342,
-0.2499785125,
-0.3296353519,
-0.1138553321,
0.4909041524,
0.0901414528,
-0.0036151903,
0.4956252277,
0.2086572349,
0.3203445077,
-0.6724101901,
0.3283860385,
-0.3599046171,
-0.2897655964,
0.3779609501,
0.3223329186,
-0.0709835961,
0.2227066755,
-0.272135824,
0.0046099317,
-0.8782874942,
-0.1610238254,
0.4217013121,
0.4737539887,
0.0892627239,
0.0877072662,
-0.684220612,
1.0040745735,
0.108237192,
-0.4048542082,
0.0207189843,
-0.2683310211,
-0.3454966843,
0.1274490803,
0.6983539462,
0.0688859746,
0.1646731794,
-0.4040415585,
-0.1863167435,
-0.1480740607,
0.1872573644,
-1.1792913675,
-0.2649046779,
-0.0307237655,
-0.3185033202,
-0.0359521471,
-0.3887008727,
-0.9288406372,
0.0864078477,
0.02988795,
0.4302838445,
-0.1905439049,
0.1579587311,
0.3216010928,
0.2405988872,
-0.0108018443,
0.7633737326,
-1.3007777929,
0.4937875271,
0.5003247857,
0.8218266964,
0.1442449391,
-0.436224252,
-0.7881703973,
0.2760528624,
-0.4837948084,
0.6731026173,
-0.6768451333,
-0.2525313199,
-0.4430736601,
-0.2618321776,
-0.1226886064,
-0.7676001191,
0.3646581471,
-0.2518286407,
-0.2843120098,
-0.1570648551,
-0.1080206186,
-0.1424138695,
-0.027107155,
-0.3184551001,
0.870495379,
0.2744683921,
0.0731441155,
0.4543325901,
0.0183282439,
-0.2675839961,
0.027109677,
-0.3543485999,
-0.4167298675,
0.3453178108,
-0.080914855,
0.643312633,
-0.3936001658,
-0.3217146993,
-0.4270932972,
-0.9207541347,
-0.2678218186,
-0.533877492,
0.2396614403,
0.3461979926,
-0.3203525841,
-0.0869360492,
-0.9356692433,
0.0893978626,
-0.0684756786,
-0.5529120564,
-0.3170285821,
-0.008319838,
-0.1931404918,
-0.0202534162,
0.3883510232,
-0.7163156867,
0.1044418439,
-0.3998388052,
0.4989674091,
0.7511242032,
-0.2535801232,
0.6658755541,
-0.1424095482,
0.1907427907,
-0.3107852638,
0.4552461207,
0.0522066541,
-0.5131494999,
-0.6198497415,
-0.6128430963,
0.2513447106,
0.3893019855,
-0.3214251697,
0.1070312783,
-0.0963090882,
-0.3464846313,
-0.3402698338,
0.6774013638,
0.417978555,
0.5616748929,
0.53406775,
0.0826324522,
-0.0324291922,
-0.7597568035,
0.1659555584,
0.0449830778,
-0.1027745157,
0.6988603473,
-0.0484278761,
-0.066798389,
0.1219797879,
-0.7289775014,
-0.1653603464,
-0.1751004606,
-0.0016379149,
0.2668590248,
0.6910779476,
0.7276640534,
-0.270647347,
-0.4003445208,
0.027442582,
-0.0298695415,
-0.2576574981,
-0.070999749,
-0.1362355649,
0.2167906761,
0.3289556801,
-0.5869899988,
0.1037109345,
0.3073202074,
-0.1570343822,
0.092957288,
-0.7379137874,
-0.1200721636,
-0.7024213672,
-0.2485574186,
-0.1593865007,
-0.10031192,
-0.4184172451,
-0.299596101,
0.08190763,
-0.0557584055,
-0.0309742447,
0.4561834633,
-0.5061671734,
0.03585409,
-0.1646485478,
-0.1140941679,
0.189454928,
0.89392519,
-0.3299768269,
0.8855440617,
0.1881331354,
-0.5848726034,
0.0006187595,
0.0277461503,
-0.1766256839,
0.3013286591,
-0.4896935523,
0.1565283388,
0.1437584609,
-0.51075387,
-1.0200581551,
0.1398323625,
0.4979803264,
-0.3442002237,
0.8955286145,
-0.1746951044,
-0.5835775137,
-0.0605484433,
-0.5743666887,
0.4943593442,
0.4960650802,
-0.4595561028,
0.1225097552,
0.1129498556,
-0.26004228,
-0.7081493735,
-0.4551459551,
-0.0541716665,
-0.1370034218,
-0.0567550287,
0.4040792286,
-0.2644946575,
-0.0005448416,
-0.1877208054,
-0.4570660293,
-0.4035941064,
0.4108953774,
-0.1405549794,
0.0242900103,
-0.4266136289,
-0.1089893132,
0.5800446868,
-0.2863602936,
-0.5054513216,
-0.169162944,
0.6749970317,
0.0357182957,
-0.0024999627,
-0.2310451865,
0.3029762805,
0.5394012928,
-0.0062769265,
0.6793851256,
0.3424039483,
-0.2206211984,
-0.6362472177,
-0.718947053,
-0.0929102525,
-0.5107992291,
0.3915123045,
-0.3272961378,
-0.9715387821,
0.4135144353,
-0.1147787645,
-0.0702930614,
0.0622561462,
0.4354884028,
-0.1598581523,
0.8654516935,
0.4822029471,
-0.3567006588,
0.7285071611,
-0.2364784628,
0.1921405792,
-0.654280901,
-0.1658087522,
-0.5561575294,
-0.4983778298,
-0.3841439784,
-0.6096591353,
0.1050450951,
0.2944025695,
-0.2331015915,
0.297093749,
-0.5291420817,
0.5719880462,
0.3768234551,
0.2543615699,
0.1649406403,
0.2230137587,
0.0743135735,
-0.0361195244,
-0.8123285174,
-0.1031412482,
0.6999301314,
0.011225597,
0.9290575385,
-0.3323607445,
0.6522508264,
0.1538712829,
-0.1274692863,
-0.5925145149,
0.5527077317,
-0.3520391881,
-0.1529939026,
-0.5204474926,
-0.3775667548,
-0.8022817373,
0.322401464,
-0.069842279,
-0.7483358383,
0.3764075637,
0.0741936564,
-0.8223666549,
0.2767210603,
-0.5126028061,
0.6732308269,
-0.0772504434,
-0.6994624734,
-0.6869309545,
-0.4094882011,
-0.1557358652,
0.0390138738,
-0.2789526284,
-0.6217491031,
-0.4510668516,
0.4004637301,
-0.7744894028,
0.5884193182,
-0.3073533773,
0.0403050035,
0.144317463,
0.0593126751,
0.2816883624,
0.1312274039,
-0.2381248325,
0.4715061784,
-0.1219400838,
-0.4959870875,
-0.676741302,
1.0203049183,
-0.6843445301,
-0.5885733962,
0.144727841,
-0.7167670131,
-0.1547490805,
0.1885210127,
0.1512831151,
0.689594388,
0.1571258754,
-0.0079362616,
0.9767715335,
-0.369084537,
0.454618156,
0.5494759083,
0.5473970771,
-0.6557141542,
1.2470741272,
0.6420875788,
0.0582262129,
0.5764043927,
0.1280135065,
-0.0311449263,
-1.1061136723,
-0.9970971346,
0.4288010895,
-0.2484228462,
-0.5172914863,
-0.2988554239,
-0.0640969053,
0.075157553,
-0.4193675816,
-0.6545184851,
-0.5178178549,
-0.4019110501,
0.0503819697,
0.3979462683,
0.3257288933,
-0.0220686272,
0.4479224086,
-0.5200751424,
0.2347109914,
0.2605832517,
0.7419115901,
0.0280347671,
-0.3289079964,
-0.3316120207,
-0.043708805,
-0.1203944832,
-0.5532388687,
0.1912210137,
0.3004862964,
0.7720893025,
0.7238705158,
-0.040422529,
1.1742321253,
-0.6437202692,
0.2450655401,
-0.0783618763,
-0.7465453148,
0.3188874722,
-0.5343680978,
-0.1583224386,
0.8271127343,
-0.0435858816,
0.1447367072,
-0.3088196218,
-0.3820442557,
-0.7594782114,
0.8188920021,
0.0001828882,
0.4572086632,
0.1227170601,
1.0132858753,
0.2585376799,
0.437283963,
-0.1779904515,
-0.4664197564,
-0.0247022137,
-0.0178159419,
-0.3826981783,
-0.7389416099,
0.2844984829,
-0.4504992962,
0.3808996081,
-0.1940349638,
0.3231189549,
0.0977286547,
-0.0239208285,
-0.4520026147,
0.1067903489,
0.938778162,
0.5359287858,
-0.4596025348,
0.0848450959,
0.3840921223,
-0.484292388,
-0.0010679683,
0.0728862956,
-0.3925635815,
0.0337655619,
-0.1184909493,
0.6329212785,
0.6680840254,
-0.7115984559,
0.3924805522,
0.2023738921,
-0.2116767764,
0.2530782223,
0.4815976024,
-0.1866559386,
0.4589733183,
0.1430769563,
0.0739820302,
0.3163876832,
-0.1178234443,
0.0608119667,
0.6734662056,
-0.0916945785,
-0.4636954963,
0.8283840418,
-0.1487089545,
-0.0845742822,
0.3183746338,
0.0068722162,
-0.0537044592,
0.5814422965,
0.4975494444,
0.7227323651,
-0.4201526046,
0.0263676103,
0.3534021974,
0.2374156564,
-0.0412387215,
0.3798158765,
-0.7179525495,
-0.5105849504,
-0.3297072351,
-0.7849300504,
-0.4022231698,
0.2544623613,
-0.3845089078,
0.0478992835,
-1.2680530548,
0.2679450512,
-0.2523606718,
0.3905310035,
-0.103025876,
0.2055021673,
0.3682500422,
0.9153237343,
-0.4451293945,
1.0533269644,
0.3926790655,
-0.1018917784,
-0.5820554495,
-0.115815185,
-0.537874043,
-0.8917371631,
0.1846014559,
0.0799796954,
-0.4154880941,
0.0839702785,
-0.4382615387,
-0.8109275103,
1.1878277063,
0.8016405702,
-0.5289579034,
0.3038860559,
0.0284669884,
0.4520397782,
-0.1913289279,
-0.0084993392,
0.2753119767,
0.1413768828,
0.3781627119,
-0.5833200812,
0.0750668645,
-0.0645200908,
0.1058584377,
0.477211684,
-1.2586054802,
1.1405837536,
-0.2204565108,
0.0115702245,
0.4594323933,
0.4902564883,
0.1478642225,
0.3691131473,
0.2490767241,
0.6321030855,
0.8184816241,
0.0872638375,
0.6983997822,
-0.4602055252,
0.1367898881,
0.8069885373,
-0.097292684,
0.8279227614,
0.3964091837,
-0.0505418554,
0.2951125205,
0.8330564499,
-0.0710475072,
0.889963448,
0.1453880221,
-0.3384034336,
-0.4306060374,
-0.0174992029,
-0.2466251999,
0.1619435102,
0.3995856047,
0.0354652889,
-0.558398962,
-0.351709187,
0.241649285,
-0.1055103466,
-0.6942965388,
0.5622974038,
0.0172672775,
-0.2229386866,
0.9460179806,
0.0610578135,
0.5450963974,
-0.5853828788,
-0.1957099587,
-0.5329825878,
0.3800178766,
-0.0542344153,
-0.0481462032,
0.2912923396,
-0.1954244077,
-0.3782038093,
-0.3046378195,
0.657836616,
-0.3824621439,
-0.2171226144,
0.5190282464,
0.5284352899,
0.1258390397,
-0.1799982637,
-0.7079207897,
0.0378213786,
-0.319065541,
-0.2579858005,
0.7399750948,
0.3417090476,
0.053570874,
0.5816205144,
0.5734540224,
0.3343547881,
0.2049004734,
-0.0282185972,
0.9650744796,
-0.4454436898,
-0.3123487234,
-0.9886384606,
-0.2214119881,
0.2340128869,
-0.1034040824,
0.7598840594,
0.6981563568,
0.8111542463,
0.0059354878,
0.2923296988,
0.188185811,
0.2356805056,
-0.5339902043,
0.7539544702,
-0.8221454024,
0.2813105285,
-0.26968503,
-0.8266833425,
-0.3655844331,
0.8574076891,
-0.1660795659,
0.0774927139,
0.0382701159,
0.8653032184,
-0.0513683818,
-0.3992823362,
0.997405529,
0.291976124,
-0.3028112054,
0.834225595,
0.7219706774,
-0.4730193615,
0.3587749898,
-0.5401849151,
-0.0250824951,
-0.163539201,
-0.3891319335,
-0.9510765076,
-0.1905189455,
-0.1074866876,
-0.0361517593,
0.1853427142,
0.8314444423,
0.7500229478,
-0.8077107668,
-0.185740158,
-0.1728618145,
0.3527681828,
-0.0819203109,
-0.0620559305,
0.0458995774,
-0.4800407588,
-0.9356253147,
0.4935610294,
0.8055315018,
-0.0179488976,
0.0969002992,
-0.2381035984,
0.1414689124,
0.2295758873,
0.4072805047,
0.4065354764,
-0.5145366788,
-0.1431161314,
0.0595612079,
-0.0044171233,
0.4086869657,
0.6471008062,
-0.6834209561,
0.2475142628,
0.3840189278,
0.5080785751,
0.5290192366,
-0.0900683552,
0.3828286231,
-0.4750491381,
0.4831038117,
0.0557017326,
0.355851233,
-0.0141453976,
-0.5388401151,
0.3920564353,
0.4871445596,
-0.216855064,
-0.7587126493,
-0.2425855845,
-1.0797926188,
-0.3916954696,
0.9036787152,
-0.064020291,
-0.2204460055,
-0.0935215503,
-0.0296477936,
0.100977622,
-0.5034243464,
0.7735684514,
0.1962446272,
-0.2728856504,
-0.3269949555,
-0.7325586081,
0.5440526605,
0.5053877831,
-0.3633863628,
0.0960025191,
0.4921013415,
0.4392137825,
-0.1612129658,
0.7502022386,
0.0812324882,
0.3079125881,
0.0915316343,
-0.2565626204,
-0.3434146643,
-0.6787531376,
-0.3002010584,
0.259254843,
0.158366546,
-0.3548032045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15745v1
|
GAOKAO-MM: A Chinese Human-Level Benchmark for Multimodal Models Evaluation
| 2024-02-24T06:57:15 | 2024-02-24T06:57:15 |
Yi Zong, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated great abilities in
image perception and language understanding. However, existing multimodal
benchmarks focus on primary perception abilities and commonsense knowledge
which are insufficient to reflect the comprehensive capabilities of LVLMs. We
propose GAOKAO-MM, a multimodal benchmark based on the Chinese College Entrance
Examination (GAOKAO), comprising of 8 subjects and 12 types of images, such as
diagrams, function graphs, maps and photos. GAOKAO-MM derives from native
Chinese context and sets human-level requirements for the model's abilities,
including perception, understanding, knowledge and reasoning. We evaluate 10
LVLMs and find that the accuracies of all of them are lower than 50%, with
GPT-4-Vison (48.1%), Qwen-VL-Plus (41.2%) and Gemini-Pro-Vision (35.1%) ranking
in the top three positions. The results of our multi-dimension analysis
indicate that LVLMs have moderate distance towards Artificial General
Intelligence (AGI) and provide insights facilitating the development of
multilingual LVLMs.
|
[
-0.3331018388,
-0.6096327305,
0.5281171203,
0.2873966694,
-0.0777926147,
0.0068147681,
-0.1693398803,
-0.6041734219,
-0.3266923726,
0.2122689039,
-0.4801433384,
-0.4105671942,
-0.4001735449,
0.0440035835,
-0.0615340956,
0.357562989,
0.2578403354,
0.2441764027,
-0.3934901059,
-0.2516177595,
-0.4322547019,
-0.3106441498,
-0.4213011861,
-0.0990846381,
0.5484759808,
-0.0409065001,
0.6011756659,
0.4225425124,
0.5512494445,
0.4298559725,
0.0337934047,
0.3189237714,
-0.1357610524,
-0.3029545248,
0.1328676492,
-0.3573625982,
-0.5987651348,
0.1891946942,
0.9742725492,
0.6347412467,
-0.0761810467,
0.1580377817,
-0.0287145972,
0.6841154695,
-0.8282781839,
0.3111490309,
-0.4401350319,
0.2106583416,
-0.0416998044,
0.1776594073,
-0.5398691893,
-0.1042492762,
0.2749759555,
-0.977540195,
-0.0111563457,
0.1290042847,
0.9190535545,
0.0674720109,
-0.7205383182,
-0.0028204105,
-0.121444501,
0.9360382557,
-0.6507142782,
0.6341012716,
0.2264134437,
0.7080606222,
-0.0946126506,
-0.5134928823,
-0.5655315518,
-0.7107053995,
-0.0750782043,
0.5821384788,
0.0894847512,
0.0317506902,
0.2492033988,
0.2266227901,
-0.7800887227,
0.0494571477,
-0.5459889174,
-0.3637422025,
0.6946115494,
0.3371709883,
0.3109111488,
-0.138400957,
-0.4482817352,
-0.3121680021,
-0.2565564513,
0.3546538353,
0.2806942761,
0.1972045749,
-0.0949272811,
0.384596467,
-0.6138970256,
0.8645364046,
-0.3260321319,
-0.4112962186,
0.5909700394,
-0.4132978022,
-0.3488836288,
-0.4770593941,
1.0343074799,
0.6308964491,
0.3151350021,
-0.1664076895,
-0.0112836249,
0.2712510228,
0.1727872789,
-0.7446296215,
-0.1645237505,
0.1028983444,
-0.6616284847,
-0.3328689635,
0.2477582395,
-0.8770238757,
-0.5091726184,
-0.1536574513,
0.5537575483,
-0.4355791211,
-0.2643343508,
-0.2252004296,
-0.0613903143,
0.3136763573,
0.6276600957,
-0.6782944798,
0.078706421,
0.5522150993,
0.9187059999,
-0.3343091011,
-0.839173615,
-0.5718245506,
-0.0279615372,
-0.4741203189,
0.6903685331,
-0.5777975321,
-0.2966368496,
-0.0852859542,
0.0745602995,
0.021176884,
-0.5222378969,
0.5386716723,
-0.234549135,
0.2289205492,
-0.2728483975,
-0.1955809593,
-0.4026134312,
0.6254878044,
-0.6819638014,
0.7754298449,
0.1514257938,
-0.2349344343,
0.5542814136,
-0.5050176978,
-0.1538175344,
0.1742464751,
-0.2636273503,
-0.1392168105,
0.0531795807,
0.3571116328,
0.3879768252,
-0.3879063427,
0.2345716059,
-0.4162369668,
-0.3300293386,
0.21057944,
-0.6548742056,
0.8077769279,
0.2029521465,
0.0266797394,
0.4436102509,
-0.9960535169,
0.2476916909,
0.2355037928,
-0.3930873871,
-0.2664666474,
0.1722559482,
0.1395708025,
0.4899814427,
0.2736837566,
-0.3414638937,
0.4075463116,
-0.1437918842,
0.3912344873,
0.8985024095,
-0.5336281061,
0.3281666934,
-0.0890366361,
0.1803311557,
0.1445266753,
0.6332778335,
-0.2821121216,
-0.8321487308,
-0.5491393209,
-0.4018223286,
0.0226957221,
0.5472200513,
-0.9230269194,
0.1401381195,
-0.1678485572,
-0.6691200733,
-0.7211174369,
0.0926510394,
0.5010743141,
0.5395309925,
0.320382148,
-0.3928184509,
-0.0825083256,
-0.9405267239,
0.0482368395,
-0.4417580068,
-0.2698937953,
0.4376823604,
0.5207574964,
-0.3040916026,
0.4404928982,
-0.2484609187,
-0.4584419727,
0.1539767087,
0.1950728297,
-0.0168118849,
0.1239492446,
0.6424981356,
-0.9769012928,
-0.4394307137,
0.3103766739,
-1.002448678,
-0.1112309322,
0.0449918844,
-0.0042912145,
0.2140758038,
0.0807692558,
-0.2336162627,
0.2192720622,
0.8330411911,
-0.4318549037,
0.7951307893,
-0.533357203,
0.6235248446,
-0.7274779081,
0.0539855845,
0.1387257129,
0.0692492276,
-0.6195725799,
0.41809237,
0.3361878693,
-0.1208407953,
-0.4978417158,
0.7062342763,
-0.5832175612,
-0.2456026077,
-0.1818413883,
0.4902167618,
-0.0498095006,
0.5392433405,
0.0106853312,
0.7367985845,
0.8105905652,
-0.4785777926,
0.7356314659,
-0.1039653644,
-0.6502248645,
0.771164,
-0.621920228,
-0.0498814583,
0.1303085685,
-0.0989446416,
-1.0938791037,
-0.2486219704,
0.1264481843,
-0.5561693907,
-0.1892243475,
0.0851379186,
-0.5262843966,
-0.3873000741,
-0.3692466021,
0.5180625319,
0.4816203117,
-0.4040007293,
0.9076563716,
0.2129002213,
0.3320240378,
-0.7611653805,
-0.3640958071,
0.047357142,
-0.0722078606,
-0.8650952578,
-0.0095342854,
-0.1800360978,
-0.1055140719,
-0.2415815443,
0.4096401334,
-0.0706638098,
0.0581187494,
0.2315259427,
0.5313328505,
-0.3328176439,
-0.0462594815,
-0.47809273,
-0.0934511498,
0.0276807323,
0.0721694008,
0.3672028184,
-0.5814517736,
-0.4147571623,
-0.3939383924,
0.0995335951,
0.6895846725,
-0.4261182845,
0.4743946791,
0.9060022235,
-0.2157261819,
0.1717413217,
-0.4992395639,
0.1988202333,
-0.4529186487,
0.6175452471,
-0.4268522859,
-0.5299094915,
0.5232878923,
-0.0940798745,
-0.0269484054,
0.4592125714,
0.6400226355,
0.0673387274,
1.2039493322,
0.437345922,
-0.2084109634,
0.3597972095,
0.0333901085,
-0.286639899,
-0.9073518515,
-0.4230549634,
-0.2015559971,
-0.1830196828,
-0.6640971303,
-0.5255098343,
0.3289828897,
-0.1013118401,
-0.161743477,
0.1335884184,
-0.4037484825,
0.2715687156,
0.7143052816,
-0.0240270644,
0.3510151803,
-0.3553058803,
-0.1736233383,
0.0094473232,
-0.3542955518,
-0.3262713253,
0.9948931336,
0.147215277,
0.5877892971,
0.1949485391,
0.0219265986,
0.3045283258,
0.3050447404,
-0.6770963073,
0.783164978,
-0.2474012375,
-0.7086758614,
-0.3871777058,
-0.6199653149,
-0.735607028,
0.8121296763,
-0.5541460514,
-0.8972868919,
-0.0285090171,
0.0429757498,
-0.0547618084,
0.0957891643,
-0.8750021458,
1.1812367439,
-0.5481940508,
-0.4298004508,
-0.1012953818,
-0.6979084611,
0.6184445024,
0.0015185563,
0.4288798273,
-0.3227991164,
-0.1664416343,
0.5014926791,
-0.1181822196,
0.4761423469,
-0.1860165894,
0.0662741512,
0.161535114,
-0.1372269988,
0.159852609,
-0.1081674471,
-0.0296131205,
0.3820210397,
0.1686722189,
-0.4113921523,
-0.636682272,
0.5373855233,
-1.0570498705,
-0.4063890576,
-0.5500546694,
-0.5616660118,
-0.1698455513,
0.3007412255,
0.0631943643,
0.3168053329,
-0.404166162,
0.340082258,
0.1038346142,
-0.4124476612,
0.2565810978,
0.6479061246,
-0.5317189097,
-0.5521970987,
1.0857082605,
0.1200800389,
0.3903840482,
0.3557404876,
0.5363195539,
-0.2216033787,
-0.3260498047,
-0.7643210292,
0.0769912302,
-0.8085657358,
0.2083114833,
-0.2822312415,
-0.2180679291,
-0.4129725397,
0.0158915222,
-0.3813020885,
0.1531764567,
0.148945719,
0.3513221443,
-0.2294238955,
0.4493275285,
0.0321523696,
0.130273208,
-0.6469475031,
0.5925981402,
0.4885148704,
0.3737977743,
0.2133894712,
-0.5559226274,
-0.2075003684,
0.0612289049,
-0.350775212,
-0.4923768938,
0.2974570096,
0.1778407395,
0.9443187714,
0.7722412348,
-0.2283543795,
0.8545561433,
-0.5580102801,
0.9430938959,
0.4108546674,
-0.7838925719,
0.5733035803,
-0.3381913304,
0.3733460605,
0.3365603685,
0.2114819437,
-0.598700285,
-0.268332243,
-0.2326907665,
-0.6302840114,
0.6438227892,
0.2301852554,
-0.0621901304,
0.1816864759,
-0.1584593207,
0.0345274694,
0.1451884657,
-0.9546597004,
-0.1878864169,
-0.3877255321,
-0.0038001689,
-0.1741763055,
-0.0704799518,
0.0359891243,
-0.1692583859,
0.420473069,
-0.157768935,
0.1370058656,
-0.1328617781,
-0.1250953376,
0.0884692296,
0.1380812526,
0.9088805914,
0.7328147888,
-0.3682037294,
-0.0561806932,
0.2725010514,
-0.7431049943,
0.0067446278,
-0.0843443647,
-0.1564201266,
-0.3123255372,
0.5990511775,
0.6096728444,
-0.1667787582,
-1.0234638453,
0.6247089505,
-0.2129229456,
-0.1136632338,
-0.1873293966,
0.1126177087,
-0.1040012762,
0.3462136984,
0.4734932184,
-0.1241116151,
0.2176178545,
-0.9656086564,
-0.1056841463,
0.495467782,
-0.392704159,
-0.368986994,
0.7321905494,
0.3650762141,
-0.1929115653,
0.6974098682,
-0.0728073418,
-0.2327998281,
0.6040003896,
0.3415035605,
0.6953552365,
-0.3038227856,
0.0567700118,
0.7114088535,
0.5019664764,
-0.193898797,
0.0105828838,
0.0229930524,
-0.7248722315,
-0.2212854326,
-0.4744560719,
-0.5176748633,
0.1677576154,
-0.5641735792,
0.3805577159,
-0.3619001806,
-0.0198851582,
-0.0300165918,
-0.0591864586,
-0.5272992849,
0.5718279481,
0.4496878684,
0.6605921388,
-0.6529299021,
0.8761721849,
0.6125158668,
-0.4614133835,
-0.3200725317,
-0.2918477654,
0.2360033095,
-0.9549484849,
0.7784246802,
0.3839755356,
-0.1762870252,
-0.4963451922,
-0.3638597131,
-0.7322950959,
1.3667814732,
0.110166885,
-0.5569728613,
-0.1027707383,
0.0707839876,
0.595600009,
-0.3697497845,
0.5567117929,
0.1811558753,
0.5388407111,
0.0148387579,
-1.0117769241,
-0.2476766109,
-0.5382167101,
0.1066965833,
-0.025144564,
-0.9976597428,
1.1489140987,
-0.2115787566,
-0.0782026649,
0.280276984,
0.6166268587,
0.4729850292,
0.5452493429,
0.6158624291,
0.3173554242,
0.5765460134,
-0.3010555208,
1.017028451,
-0.1187012717,
0.184605062,
0.8699764013,
-0.2668967545,
1.0486218929,
0.2766891718,
-0.2922266722,
0.2997110784,
0.4793516994,
-0.2635940611,
0.6935925484,
0.0449926555,
0.0404928103,
-0.3931193948,
-0.0007117384,
-0.6017330289,
0.7115118504,
0.1785553545,
-0.1308353096,
0.0494622923,
0.1566398144,
-0.5514008403,
0.0194618143,
-0.4248346388,
0.6046515107,
-0.1753967255,
-0.5583090186,
0.3699030578,
-0.0628641546,
0.776646018,
-0.8935313821,
-0.0237061828,
-0.1338673532,
0.2980255783,
0.0676699877,
-0.8094872236,
-0.1920869499,
-0.1346988231,
0.0386338755,
0.1991741508,
0.5860549212,
-0.1517685652,
-0.7371175289,
0.6001601815,
0.4315485358,
0.2842965126,
-0.2359927446,
-0.6967788339,
0.0315276496,
-0.3616163731,
-0.2326013595,
0.4420697093,
0.5383438468,
-0.2059872448,
0.9373906255,
0.7126008868,
-0.0326333456,
0.042971734,
0.3533309102,
0.5709577799,
-0.6747677922,
-0.3970061243,
-0.883130908,
0.5441643,
-0.2199584395,
-0.630274415,
0.8214944601,
0.5954560041,
1.0432072878,
-0.2737493515,
0.70170784,
0.031500984,
0.0631899312,
-0.5119359493,
0.9243888855,
-1.1530916691,
-0.2600002289,
-0.6017295718,
-0.8616091609,
-0.2353525013,
0.756957233,
-0.2582619488,
0.196266979,
0.4937316775,
0.6159871221,
0.1053339913,
-0.3982442915,
1.0995789766,
-0.0445602164,
0.2445903867,
0.8868813515,
1.2577031851,
-0.595990181,
0.6820156574,
-0.2869022191,
-0.3722222149,
-0.2979644239,
-0.8141341209,
-1.0388661623,
-0.7203538418,
0.0058658919,
0.035247013,
-0.1535758823,
0.5096493959,
0.6831180453,
-0.6006893516,
-0.4061512947,
0.430501312,
-0.1302846819,
-0.5788873434,
-0.1477089077,
0.2916081846,
-0.011130699,
-0.7725195885,
0.190912649,
0.5190138817,
-0.1541754156,
-0.4778032899,
-0.3935162127,
-0.2375714928,
-0.1349371076,
1.1066477299,
0.042044431,
-1.328166604,
-0.4026602507,
0.2417555153,
-0.2816264629,
0.1597122699,
0.4847187996,
-0.6912525296,
0.8786170483,
0.4975650609,
0.2640547752,
0.0751845986,
0.0847468302,
0.2610425055,
-0.3696981668,
0.3466563225,
-0.125770852,
0.5526296496,
0.3042175472,
0.0541915037,
0.6033408046,
0.4386962354,
-0.5572504997,
-0.7129768133,
-0.0666351914,
-1.3874504566,
-0.3525163233,
0.9578325748,
-0.226979062,
-0.3062006235,
0.0736071244,
-0.3884397447,
0.0237503946,
-0.2716555893,
0.9811649323,
0.9203248024,
0.1737365723,
-0.440979749,
-0.9106552601,
0.0337412395,
0.0554614887,
-1.0092632771,
-0.0354712047,
0.5293281078,
0.0535101071,
0.488650769,
0.6948498487,
-0.0840044767,
0.6178095341,
0.3705148995,
0.1230361313,
-0.3175580204,
-0.4359638989,
0.0517906845,
0.2216692418,
-0.1310680211,
-0.2099057883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14652v1
|
MemeCraft: Contextual and Stance-Driven Multimodal Meme Generation
| 2024-02-24T06:14:34 | 2024-02-24T06:14:34 |
Han Wang, Roy Ka-Wei Lee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
Online memes have emerged as powerful digital cultural artifacts in the age
of social media, offering not only humor but also platforms for political
discourse, social critique, and information dissemination. Their extensive
reach and influence in shaping online communities' sentiments make them
invaluable tools for campaigning and promoting ideologies. Despite the
development of several meme-generation tools, there remains a gap in their
systematic evaluation and their ability to effectively communicate ideologies.
Addressing this, we introduce MemeCraft, an innovative meme generator that
leverages large language models (LLMs) and visual language models (VLMs) to
produce memes advocating specific social movements. MemeCraft presents an
end-to-end pipeline, transforming user prompts into compelling multimodal memes
without manual intervention. Conscious of the misuse potential in creating
divisive content, an intrinsic safety mechanism is embedded to curb hateful
meme production.
|
[
-0.6817558408,
-0.9401031733,
0.4277208745,
0.4411019683,
-0.5557456613,
0.5127064586,
-0.0129380086,
0.0241257437,
0.4886803627,
0.413601011,
-0.8961973786,
-0.3259539604,
-0.613779664,
-0.0518094376,
-0.3045603037,
0.8997222185,
0.1521098763,
-0.2752006948,
-0.3601015508,
-0.1705384254,
-0.256338805,
-0.328640759,
-0.3994900286,
-0.2298757583,
0.6120624542,
0.385058254,
0.6831841469,
0.5123551488,
0.1712846458,
0.3368075192,
0.1406917274,
0.0632267892,
-0.4224362969,
0.3184330165,
-0.4471468925,
-0.1616633385,
-0.2574597299,
0.3283050954,
0.2867290676,
0.1791885495,
0.0088044293,
0.4444382191,
-0.0017472215,
0.2802849412,
-0.3901360035,
-0.3152165711,
-0.9256366491,
0.1515826136,
-0.5990815163,
-0.5788502693,
-0.0782650113,
-0.3385341465,
-0.1794121414,
-0.2525041997,
0.0036479596,
0.0394242741,
0.3643667102,
-0.066062659,
-0.5483033061,
-0.4394722581,
-0.5116884708,
1.0266895294,
-0.7203816772,
0.1937561929,
-0.2206555456,
0.4018649161,
-0.3782095611,
-0.8551952243,
-0.9290457368,
0.1139273867,
0.4907659888,
0.1735050827,
-0.0509067923,
-0.3350279331,
0.1636947691,
0.3483809233,
-0.4745367169,
-0.0553724431,
-0.4099321067,
-0.1697253734,
0.5327656865,
0.3826211691,
0.5830478668,
-0.6290487051,
-0.7715471983,
-0.2958859205,
-0.8322229981,
0.142845571,
0.8821431398,
0.0708065331,
-0.1289373785,
0.6846528649,
-0.0408999808,
0.5914415121,
0.0787783563,
-0.5329737067,
-0.0519348718,
-0.1532404125,
-0.095016107,
-0.0468827672,
0.8444659114,
0.6900395155,
-0.0373552591,
0.4151113331,
0.0613385886,
0.2391159832,
0.2690908611,
-0.840282619,
-0.2019770592,
0.3422826231,
-0.6486403346,
-0.6892781258,
0.1432088763,
-0.9762734175,
-0.6900532246,
-0.2953893244,
0.0891686678,
-0.0840155557,
-0.7620643377,
-0.2633463442,
-0.7062365413,
0.1462249458,
0.2999700606,
-0.6646624207,
-0.1855434179,
0.6103788018,
0.9414771795,
0.0506700985,
-0.1047144979,
-0.2942728698,
0.1655022353,
-0.3063675165,
0.661246419,
-0.7746717334,
-0.4520029724,
-0.0583611652,
0.1010224223,
0.3951232433,
-0.3964803815,
0.159465611,
-0.3827901781,
0.0910207257,
-0.2008926272,
-0.4152081013,
-0.1311599612,
0.5399336815,
-0.6937456131,
0.5819866061,
0.0304110777,
-0.5094621778,
0.512105763,
-0.7886564136,
-0.2427887768,
0.1607652307,
-0.3736141622,
-0.1803565472,
0.3945222199,
-0.2850512564,
0.6837686896,
-0.4039239585,
0.1872110516,
-0.5483242869,
0.1559005231,
0.2065517008,
-0.7213503718,
0.6740612388,
0.5041033626,
-0.4225582182,
0.1275891513,
-0.6634330153,
-0.0030295637,
0.3338564932,
-0.4541513324,
-0.380977571,
0.33369115,
0.2343839556,
0.7305833697,
0.2160472572,
-0.6234311461,
0.1840271801,
0.060943272,
0.6290878057,
1.0197985172,
-0.0931705683,
0.2074195147,
-0.3334597051,
0.3653254211,
0.1884977818,
0.3494752049,
-0.1895071566,
-0.5874677896,
-0.1544580013,
-0.1327074021,
-0.2988005877,
0.377461642,
-0.9392784834,
-0.0592247844,
-0.001990651,
-0.6296050549,
-0.474520117,
0.5717252493,
-0.1062895209,
0.1593234986,
0.1563852429,
-0.3684439957,
-0.4520623088,
-0.6791618466,
-0.389757365,
-0.1990272403,
0.0380965583,
0.2513348162,
0.0730176494,
-0.4295092225,
0.4333412051,
-0.0028791195,
0.0204105563,
-0.4207805395,
0.3877075911,
0.0962051824,
0.3703188896,
0.6168907881,
-0.7286041975,
-0.6060643196,
-0.1487305015,
-0.7551527023,
-0.1898980886,
-0.3815360069,
-0.1212611124,
-0.0803219303,
0.6475058198,
-0.2896076143,
0.1312672943,
0.9352575541,
-0.4951044321,
0.3984155357,
0.0972058624,
0.5243087411,
-1.424713254,
-0.3595302403,
-0.2126044333,
-0.3662428558,
-0.4339835942,
-0.0371315628,
-0.2983551621,
-0.2948642671,
-0.8817333579,
0.61574018,
-0.4436348379,
0.2859930694,
-0.3958414197,
0.110269241,
0.0937273726,
0.0251096822,
-0.1875981539,
0.3900455236,
0.3527284861,
-0.4591340721,
0.5612183809,
-0.0257974714,
-0.1752747148,
1.0726433992,
-0.3953547776,
0.2790648937,
-0.1565152109,
-0.1079145595,
-0.9383398294,
-0.382034421,
0.2725140452,
-0.1550188214,
0.2614393234,
-0.020716453,
-0.410518676,
-0.6240522265,
-0.6036745906,
0.3220810294,
0.4016551673,
-0.7000619173,
0.5388975739,
0.5930696726,
-0.1401378661,
-0.4298191369,
-0.3684572875,
0.2750091553,
-0.4676839709,
-0.7717320919,
0.071634002,
-0.3717058003,
-0.5324299335,
-0.0489686914,
0.0879955813,
0.3067749739,
-0.0532637052,
0.3745148182,
-0.3150884807,
-0.1207901537,
0.0319542363,
0.4700516164,
0.0428022631,
-0.0799055025,
-0.271230042,
0.7952386141,
0.0024454943,
-0.5706715584,
-0.1014705226,
0.7024862766,
0.939733386,
-0.0326968506,
0.5359287262,
0.6156986952,
-0.169415772,
-0.2771252394,
-0.6383768916,
-0.1705245227,
-0.5563320518,
0.0760964528,
-0.3364869654,
-0.849170506,
0.1125369221,
-0.7938140035,
0.5328356028,
0.2939578593,
0.7322539687,
-0.2432971895,
1.1424255371,
0.2958458066,
0.2950116098,
0.4622578621,
0.0488300398,
0.1596198231,
-0.5888975263,
-0.1095305309,
0.0207605921,
-0.7021390796,
-0.5238568783,
-0.7781637311,
0.3390625715,
-0.1132251024,
0.0553985871,
-0.0695690885,
-0.5911340714,
0.3902845383,
0.6358489394,
-0.0359030217,
0.0017336915,
0.445568949,
-0.1732622534,
-0.3260510266,
-0.496758759,
-0.8196656704,
0.9782499075,
0.0815697983,
0.816275239,
0.2359797806,
0.550437212,
0.8068466783,
0.463626951,
-0.4878064394,
0.5747957826,
-0.1925221086,
-0.6138260961,
-0.102504231,
0.0891433135,
-0.6998529434,
0.0293188877,
-0.5373273492,
-0.2173222303,
-0.2734848857,
0.4063975513,
0.0516206957,
0.7423606515,
-0.26213938,
0.8855501413,
-0.3106811941,
-0.6084050536,
-0.5426982045,
-0.4843748808,
0.2085376978,
0.2394010574,
0.4392747581,
-0.4043286443,
0.110056743,
0.1465445161,
-0.3070500195,
0.9738427997,
-0.2834867835,
0.2274697274,
0.7894842625,
0.440416187,
0.2244125307,
-0.1197940186,
0.1256646961,
0.3545442224,
-0.1452165991,
-0.4227018654,
-0.2362155765,
1.1012963057,
-0.6858810782,
-0.7403792143,
0.0021809025,
-0.3810804188,
0.3152651191,
0.1284801066,
0.1990381777,
0.5359834433,
-0.538827002,
0.5138158798,
0.5511597395,
-0.2775037587,
0.5525458455,
-0.0367757306,
-0.1965709776,
-0.427850157,
1.277641654,
0.2452868968,
0.2143444568,
-0.0291514881,
0.4277368188,
-0.3587409854,
-0.1218955591,
-0.9200193882,
-0.1540098935,
-0.7832480073,
-0.0798763707,
-0.6288903952,
0.0879909769,
-0.0369695239,
-0.515167892,
-0.3331926763,
-0.4155531824,
-0.1484143585,
-0.0977452844,
0.2265224606,
0.9802690744,
-0.2458893806,
0.4319801927,
-0.4092201889,
0.1089104563,
0.7631902695,
0.1759332418,
-0.1580921412,
0.0051937252,
0.2478471398,
-0.065401569,
-0.6836076975,
-1.2760783434,
0.1292853355,
0.1033490524,
0.4340920746,
0.6930885315,
-0.1676477641,
0.5006793141,
-0.6881169081,
1.0457651615,
0.5220947862,
-0.78512007,
0.5831616521,
-0.4060277939,
0.0989227593,
0.0448364317,
0.1935620606,
-0.5348163247,
-0.6091928482,
-0.7408174872,
-0.8335091472,
0.0927557945,
-0.0831248388,
0.7460279465,
-0.529613018,
0.0732768476,
0.3390368521,
0.5631715059,
-0.8334963918,
-0.062626183,
-0.8645161986,
-0.2097371221,
0.1440333724,
-0.4818487465,
-0.2894335985,
-0.1520739645,
0.6258132458,
-0.3101351559,
-0.0650899485,
0.0623236075,
-0.1118845418,
-0.3569639623,
0.2488417029,
0.6392707825,
0.6006338,
0.1375882626,
0.6323382258,
-0.1081538573,
-0.2502827048,
0.3298079967,
-0.5269349813,
-0.1161572784,
0.095094189,
-0.2937183976,
0.6093302369,
-0.1621997952,
-0.4781684577,
0.4364056885,
0.0316499658,
-0.1051263735,
-0.4757249057,
-0.0476296544,
0.4474577606,
0.5878672004,
0.0459585786,
0.0584436283,
0.1032031327,
-0.5609980226,
0.2139858902,
0.8012210131,
-0.4832587242,
-0.6063920259,
1.0665454865,
0.3211936653,
-0.4133118093,
0.0064891092,
-0.1723470241,
-0.0563780069,
0.4008223414,
0.7942226529,
0.8736799359,
-0.457279712,
0.5362700224,
0.3410020471,
0.4399614036,
0.3428773582,
0.3388388157,
-0.0253392197,
-0.4715396464,
-0.0335865952,
-0.7044548392,
-0.2729543149,
0.3626815677,
-0.0340873636,
0.4746238887,
-0.9207988381,
-0.3472704291,
-0.0843757242,
-0.4085728228,
-0.5064478517,
0.1154552922,
0.3818555176,
0.6434856057,
-0.8888998032,
0.2953679264,
0.8680161834,
-0.2096166909,
-0.2606968284,
-0.1337392479,
0.5679342151,
-0.4998187423,
-0.0575355105,
0.3429780602,
-0.1289518178,
0.0599723533,
-1.0640232563,
-0.4547269642,
1.0996986628,
0.2289931327,
-0.416698277,
0.522369504,
0.2299313545,
0.2886228561,
-0.6207353473,
-0.014685805,
-0.0705539808,
0.3389508128,
0.101900965,
-0.2393452525,
0.2058778703,
-0.4001714885,
0.0886367038,
0.1436882913,
-0.7259119749,
1.1415554285,
0.0647188947,
-0.0584976189,
-0.2706447244,
0.4890733063,
0.3138046563,
0.3540519178,
0.7655841112,
0.2084557265,
0.4404763579,
0.0724561736,
1.0436198711,
-0.4747622609,
-0.2107666731,
0.6569381952,
0.0661346838,
0.608155787,
0.8211627603,
0.2321557999,
0.7886720896,
0.5033165812,
0.1088013723,
0.3388687372,
0.3187749386,
-0.6209706664,
-0.5482159853,
-0.2618792355,
-0.2637941241,
0.3770447373,
0.5169337392,
-0.268961519,
-0.2886205018,
-0.0544291809,
0.2800753713,
0.3829009533,
-0.2315273732,
0.7456608415,
0.0953537151,
-0.3729144931,
0.1197298765,
-0.0185396839,
0.4982748926,
-0.5753292441,
-0.3113945425,
0.1183220744,
0.0302108843,
-0.1153179258,
-0.6981653571,
0.3152918518,
-0.0877319872,
-0.2405882925,
-0.2904671133,
1.0163420439,
-0.4353992641,
-0.3860825598,
0.2963977456,
0.8593262434,
0.2151081115,
0.0057530738,
-0.9858610034,
0.0971835405,
-0.0370116234,
-0.3259827793,
0.351805836,
0.5860912204,
-0.3333979249,
0.4030688107,
1.0141049623,
-0.0474048518,
0.2798599601,
0.0994383395,
0.8711288571,
-0.465672493,
-0.2093107253,
-1.1561427116,
0.8432372212,
-0.4750005901,
-0.1603200734,
0.7979285121,
0.1644873321,
0.7264928222,
-0.2429629564,
1.0938689709,
-0.5394200683,
0.2691037953,
-0.0604111589,
0.8331133723,
-1.0291889906,
-0.0707404539,
-0.3490316272,
-0.8160482049,
-0.0050312751,
0.46797961,
0.3745679259,
-0.447722137,
-0.049881611,
0.6243956089,
-0.3618805707,
-0.1473466605,
0.6206739545,
0.0939579308,
0.6229926348,
0.065034017,
1.1787129641,
-0.0336035676,
0.3967364728,
-0.234893769,
-0.3322236538,
-0.1176808998,
-1.1965560913,
-1.2539277077,
-0.5839126706,
-0.1026030257,
-0.4177731276,
-0.3306301534,
1.3500585556,
0.6249042749,
-0.658801198,
-0.3776025474,
0.1049078479,
0.3143929541,
-0.0606172606,
-0.217146337,
-0.2578881383,
-0.1051718816,
-0.8980317116,
0.4171251357,
0.7743460536,
0.1065537408,
-0.7297690511,
0.0132070305,
-0.2589685023,
0.6230482459,
1.0124855042,
0.2250187248,
-0.75453192,
-0.2713454962,
0.0657737479,
0.1567692012,
-0.1016114876,
0.8189027309,
-0.3044945002,
0.9902388453,
0.617896378,
0.2533498704,
0.0277324393,
-0.107353285,
0.5831634402,
-0.8670534492,
0.5329319835,
-0.0612881742,
0.303355068,
0.5993975997,
-0.083431311,
0.2387387604,
0.5189801455,
-0.2408925891,
-0.7181372046,
0.3958554864,
-0.5418792963,
-0.2674399316,
0.9973338246,
0.2913559973,
-0.253732264,
-0.176009059,
-0.3906736076,
0.1354772747,
-0.2647554576,
0.8968889713,
0.6438185573,
0.1704030335,
-0.111415118,
-0.5831775665,
0.5220235586,
0.1761675626,
-0.6288313866,
-0.3242580593,
0.5857342482,
0.3891819715,
0.4254162312,
0.6490895152,
-0.0516482666,
0.1237309873,
0.0674212649,
0.2399553061,
0.126180917,
-0.5306082368,
0.359336406,
0.4296761751,
-0.0766758993,
0.0033113281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15733v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15733v2
|
ArEEG_Chars: Dataset for Envisioned Speech Recognition using EEG for Arabic Characters
| 2024-02-24T06:05:15 | 2024-04-01T06:59:21 |
Hazem Darwish, Abdalrahman Al Malah, Khloud Al Jallad, Nada Ghneim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
Brain-Computer-Interface (BCI) has been a hot research topic in the last few
years that could help paralyzed people in their lives. Several researches were
done to classify electroencephalography (EEG) signals automatically into
English characters and words. Arabic language is one of the most used languages
around the world. However, to the best of our knowledge, there is no dataset
for Arabic characters EEG signals. In this paper, we have created an EEG
dataset for Arabic characters and named it ArEEG_Chars. Moreover, several
experiments were done on ArEEG_Chars using deep learning. Best results were
achieved using LSTM and reached an accuracy of 97%. ArEEG_Chars dataset will be
public for researchers.
|
[
-0.4044813812,
-0.6691993475,
0.4269326031,
0.2674617767,
-0.3593635261,
0.2509612441,
-0.2358258665,
-0.5419859886,
0.5751053691,
0.34730497,
-0.423997134,
-1.0039004087,
-0.5599576831,
0.1337835044,
-0.304878056,
0.436542511,
0.0535016619,
0.3838516176,
0.3840103149,
-0.3276339769,
-0.5948247313,
-0.4673709869,
-0.7752511501,
-0.2802433372,
0.4591498375,
0.4321619272,
0.3478118181,
0.2622843087,
-0.0206792932,
0.3289423287,
-0.0014751513,
0.2393808812,
-0.0530701913,
0.0431871973,
0.1955631226,
-0.1581596285,
-0.328897357,
-0.4691222012,
0.6456808448,
0.5491714478,
-0.0659352764,
-0.1435580403,
-0.1235723048,
0.6926136017,
-0.4259188473,
0.1117192954,
-0.4757414162,
0.2248460203,
-0.223284021,
0.1337771863,
-0.3211946189,
-0.6808533072,
-0.1495380849,
-0.0898437053,
-0.1390789151,
0.308458209,
0.5377393961,
-0.0524264127,
-0.5774409175,
-0.1849236488,
-0.4932088852,
0.8452345133,
-0.8143402338,
0.6294395924,
0.5060470104,
0.3229982257,
-0.1740274429,
-0.6606947184,
-0.5232722163,
-0.0613180064,
0.1716461182,
-0.0320975035,
-0.421497792,
0.301189065,
0.3279712498,
0.1131749228,
-0.6856844425,
0.4804945886,
-0.2756247222,
-0.4633383453,
0.9211420417,
-0.0169816744,
0.5805242062,
0.1525496691,
-0.0843771994,
0.0323877186,
-0.8158364892,
0.0808920935,
0.3021562397,
0.2558605373,
-0.3466096222,
0.3936534226,
-0.0659968629,
0.6828065515,
-0.007067183,
0.0048056026,
0.6531559825,
0.0987799838,
-0.178635329,
0.9091914892,
0.5522179008,
0.0615023486,
0.4871797264,
-0.2092698663,
-0.0746558607,
-0.2159106135,
0.1593842655,
-0.711140871,
-0.0381916314,
0.2281198502,
-0.637745142,
0.2958121896,
-0.191732645,
-0.6663810611,
-0.4005607367,
-0.4057616293,
0.1007394344,
-0.7016671896,
-0.2474860698,
0.1612697542,
0.2269298434,
0.4344915152,
0.1547549218,
-0.8926742077,
0.3219123185,
0.1786782444,
0.6940794587,
-0.0755463317,
0.0715912953,
-0.2052125037,
-0.0098512499,
-0.2290901095,
0.6394241452,
-0.3940954506,
-0.5292602181,
0.2218481451,
-0.0836583376,
0.0054465532,
-0.4212837219,
1.0470528603,
-0.5796069503,
-0.2791530192,
-0.410585314,
-0.7472527027,
-0.7714687586,
-0.216200009,
-0.5469555259,
0.2388604581,
-0.3831520081,
-0.6918785572,
0.1441089064,
-0.420370549,
-0.5858696699,
0.4779727757,
-0.5859689713,
-0.6154718399,
0.1724219322,
0.6347469687,
0.3799799681,
-0.0206275266,
-0.0201146603,
-0.1952169985,
-0.5021186471,
0.5149300098,
-0.5090741515,
0.8370977044,
0.4076039195,
-0.1833136678,
-0.2230809778,
-1.0113215446,
0.7422372699,
-0.2593592405,
-0.2803741693,
-0.1285710037,
0.3318757117,
0.5411036015,
-0.1843297482,
0.132266283,
-0.8942258954,
-0.1419237703,
-0.5382983088,
0.2753682137,
0.4283898473,
0.0740842298,
-0.1953762621,
0.0110119898,
0.3741819263,
0.1809333712,
-0.5122333765,
0.1124083251,
-0.5056186318,
-0.8398740292,
-0.5566108823,
0.6406856179,
0.7203314304,
-0.545772016,
1.0079196692,
-0.1682421416,
-0.6621018052,
-0.4643420875,
-0.5116943717,
0.4377552271,
0.203583777,
0.290102154,
-0.2003543973,
-0.9360755682,
-1.3463821411,
-0.4102811813,
-0.2708972096,
-0.2469461113,
0.2538927197,
0.1683633178,
-0.3904755414,
0.7161354423,
-0.3788954914,
-0.3684542477,
-0.1890893877,
0.3904787004,
0.5044974089,
0.6061047912,
0.4892995656,
-0.6360785961,
-0.4407481253,
0.0738942623,
-0.6948993206,
-0.1750792116,
0.2097488344,
0.1684682369,
0.1036344245,
0.3266411126,
-0.1629289985,
0.5275815725,
0.2916683853,
-0.3568790555,
0.1563273966,
-0.0372771583,
0.477807641,
-1.0251539946,
-0.0557866581,
-0.0427786224,
-0.2219990641,
-0.6000881195,
-0.5779238343,
0.2609820664,
-0.1371518224,
-0.5612763762,
0.3394446671,
-0.4580494165,
0.0564859957,
-0.3203009665,
-0.2535356283,
-0.508754313,
0.5860548615,
0.3105012178,
0.8364691138,
0.9993011355,
-0.5401138067,
0.5055007935,
0.438800633,
-0.78722471,
0.4866349399,
-0.5832873583,
0.6274713278,
-0.0124958595,
-0.3173282444,
-0.8813455701,
-0.2137958109,
0.0496129356,
-0.4840462506,
0.5809630752,
0.3299839199,
-0.3195774257,
-0.2312846631,
-0.025665462,
0.5566340089,
0.7916882038,
-0.6821795106,
0.528863132,
0.7806816101,
-0.4125870466,
-0.5059834123,
-0.8012979031,
0.2584119141,
-0.205340296,
-0.4621263444,
0.404928565,
-0.0036412044,
-0.0168227758,
-0.3693384826,
0.0363940746,
-0.286817342,
-0.3558280468,
0.4627410769,
-0.1736994684,
-0.0202275589,
0.1606157869,
0.5644439459,
-0.0485329963,
-0.0425812714,
0.1255534738,
0.3611681163,
-0.1564840376,
-0.4721906483,
-0.6523246169,
0.5457191467,
0.3266519606,
-0.0964493528,
0.3570523262,
0.2896543741,
-0.7293276191,
-0.0442473479,
-0.6455411315,
0.0448362827,
-0.5150447488,
0.8897678852,
-0.32580778,
-0.6177629232,
0.3487785459,
-0.2631816864,
-0.0574985482,
-0.1353109032,
0.6312978268,
-0.0344867371,
1.3359069824,
0.3897077739,
-0.4001730978,
0.0986746028,
0.1373933703,
0.4100184143,
-0.5965977311,
-0.2842459977,
-0.6578205824,
-0.6057476401,
-0.4602887928,
0.2190638483,
0.5799360871,
-0.3199036717,
-0.0591426529,
0.1931667179,
-0.4005640149,
0.492546767,
0.3044152558,
0.5062828064,
-0.0552012697,
0.4215534329,
-0.0694728643,
-0.406986922,
-0.3232191205,
-0.7457457185,
0.8758574128,
0.2342815846,
0.9639940858,
0.0323258676,
0.593182981,
0.7343534827,
-0.2932460904,
-0.6181178689,
0.764408648,
0.0767136887,
-0.3374290466,
-0.0913760439,
-0.0210468657,
-1.161955595,
-0.1891564429,
-0.1536052078,
-0.9866611362,
0.4819450378,
0.0416572429,
-0.3397892118,
0.2582152486,
-0.7092697024,
0.1519061625,
-0.2792095244,
0.0416281968,
-0.4916759431,
-0.5836941004,
0.0253741164,
-0.0954117477,
0.0011541342,
0.0090892771,
0.1320211142,
1.2130563259,
-0.1944147199,
0.6597008705,
-0.1173060909,
0.1401712745,
0.4342116117,
-0.3313621283,
0.2517695725,
0.0163260568,
-0.2532645464,
0.696841538,
-0.0715456903,
-0.3867909312,
-0.1732740253,
0.8274164796,
-0.9618356228,
-0.3029814065,
-0.6116807461,
-0.2559323311,
-0.4389515817,
0.1286833584,
0.4134860933,
0.584105432,
-0.7269511819,
0.0716538355,
0.697334826,
-0.3742513657,
0.6785011888,
0.441280663,
-0.1479385793,
-0.8546678424,
0.8487228155,
0.5206298232,
-0.6030845642,
0.256087333,
-0.4671972096,
-0.3999972045,
-0.834700644,
-0.4742230475,
0.3155895472,
-0.6225702763,
-0.305881232,
-0.3960707486,
-0.6920906305,
-0.3102756739,
-0.0692543909,
0.1736808419,
-0.1981235445,
-0.489287287,
-0.3767121136,
0.4106145203,
0.5248234272,
-0.0675823763,
0.3974131346,
-0.7787075043,
0.2275386304,
0.3826429248,
0.1331724674,
-0.0609497093,
-0.2469564378,
-0.677990973,
0.2460413426,
-0.4136970639,
-1.151794076,
0.866425693,
0.4364463091,
0.5520271659,
0.6128605008,
-0.0502973907,
0.4688399136,
-0.8231176734,
0.615745008,
0.3294947743,
-1.1141813993,
0.3360075057,
0.0676761195,
0.2293922007,
0.387842834,
0.4181407988,
-0.6039901376,
-0.0033848679,
-0.2427979112,
-0.5848264694,
0.8039788604,
0.3774328232,
-0.005985349,
0.0976374149,
0.3263903558,
0.4680987298,
0.3680306375,
-0.3967475593,
-0.4333566725,
0.0164832193,
-0.7091112733,
0.1818466038,
-0.5037912726,
0.2368026674,
-0.3605516255,
0.7610182166,
0.168445304,
0.6299951077,
-0.0029809333,
-0.1021916643,
-0.106267646,
0.4750360548,
0.3389588296,
0.4573142231,
-0.1443240047,
0.15027529,
0.4830348194,
-0.9205164313,
0.4006016552,
0.038883768,
-0.1335153729,
0.2140513062,
0.3060572445,
1.1121197939,
-0.3004508018,
-0.8223958611,
0.1371942908,
-0.2188895345,
-0.1912417412,
-0.9009387493,
0.1998097301,
-0.1581401527,
0.3988093436,
0.4409551919,
-0.1415043026,
0.21137546,
-0.0965406895,
0.1034125164,
0.4378139675,
-0.2860005498,
-0.3478331566,
0.3573464751,
0.4065406024,
-0.8743672967,
1.0230218172,
0.1275635362,
-0.3561713696,
0.6453781724,
0.5235942602,
1.0970898867,
-0.378254205,
-0.2035381645,
0.4461637735,
0.0520381927,
0.3676097989,
0.8905588388,
0.0085865259,
-0.7763777375,
-0.2149970531,
-0.6177316308,
-0.3604526818,
0.3121528327,
-0.3970719278,
0.6180813313,
-0.4674600363,
-0.3807724714,
-0.1613075733,
-0.0367779173,
-0.5406177044,
0.4020783603,
0.6385182738,
0.7868282795,
-0.7996436954,
0.9703401923,
0.5499599576,
-0.10309425,
-0.4373683929,
-0.2299387604,
-0.2884033918,
-0.9273734689,
0.7967836261,
0.3135416806,
-0.069722034,
0.5005601048,
-0.7938133478,
-0.8651809692,
0.8289018869,
0.4947957098,
-0.9267734289,
0.0761114061,
0.3513309062,
0.1912167221,
-0.3728087246,
0.3623560667,
0.3021180034,
0.7161059976,
-0.3222980797,
-0.5990366936,
-0.163685292,
-0.2202909142,
0.0695297271,
0.0505103432,
-0.4309226274,
0.3099603355,
-0.0231331941,
-0.4058552682,
0.2372004539,
1.2315708399,
0.2431625426,
0.3578289747,
0.4196033478,
0.6701393723,
0.7020747662,
-0.1586756855,
0.2859557271,
-0.170602724,
0.0064045489,
0.6545084715,
-0.3890000284,
0.5810562372,
0.3995334506,
-0.34711501,
0.644118309,
0.7196407318,
0.0253509283,
0.8189468384,
0.3085673451,
-0.6457679868,
-0.3104133308,
0.0750542805,
-0.4504993558,
0.4276283383,
0.6686546206,
-0.3314986229,
-0.0545694828,
0.39921996,
0.0374182723,
-0.0128679415,
-0.4795430005,
0.6756930947,
0.189049542,
-0.2673142552,
0.7518028617,
0.094181411,
0.516199708,
-0.8198652267,
-0.2210358083,
0.1985334307,
0.0088670729,
-0.208841607,
-0.4134141803,
0.0654913634,
0.0389140584,
-0.1350368112,
0.1017670929,
0.7425358295,
-0.4539204538,
-0.7197412848,
0.0635271817,
0.3250505626,
0.5777649283,
0.1645231992,
-0.5287902951,
0.0745563284,
0.1923096627,
0.0245910864,
0.1290745586,
0.2088114768,
0.0830752701,
0.432931602,
0.1232861727,
0.3602215946,
0.1502859592,
-0.1049174964,
0.5263505578,
-0.8987060785,
-0.5434221625,
-0.844343245,
0.315150708,
-0.1382576823,
-0.0881056562,
0.7765064836,
0.6466019154,
0.3157347441,
-0.2383653075,
0.9992268085,
-0.0860937014,
0.7597059011,
-0.6901838183,
1.0061888695,
-0.1949617267,
-0.0785534903,
-0.0011046719,
-0.6974212527,
-0.2403891683,
0.566822052,
-0.0059663286,
0.2943920791,
0.6814499497,
0.7625621557,
-0.0173823219,
0.4165839255,
0.691519022,
0.3551707566,
0.172220245,
0.752654016,
0.4894892573,
-0.3774808049,
-0.1499754637,
0.0958233997,
-0.2200113386,
-0.195406571,
-0.6215129495,
-0.978255868,
-0.6240805387,
-0.5118207335,
-0.0644878075,
0.3118886352,
1.1507004499,
0.6419588327,
-1.1904181242,
-0.4385189712,
-0.1699377596,
0.079314962,
-0.320566535,
0.0117441257,
0.8665098548,
-0.0514353514,
-0.9869150519,
0.6262958646,
0.1002751663,
0.1822042465,
-0.0401376374,
-0.0512857661,
-0.2739644945,
0.1792292744,
0.2269747108,
0.5776949525,
-0.4323261976,
-0.3279416263,
-0.2168271393,
0.1217997968,
0.2485296577,
0.5015038252,
-1.0269913673,
0.3414011896,
0.4187749922,
0.6306627393,
0.2221199423,
-0.3875735104,
0.48138991,
-0.6700201631,
0.2738716006,
0.3359438181,
0.7191833258,
0.3002717197,
-0.1685841233,
0.223231703,
-0.017255092,
-0.8633844256,
-0.6237043142,
0.3170267045,
-1.0672827959,
0.1612045467,
0.8944788575,
-0.1048888415,
-0.2227229178,
-0.3780578375,
-0.7655658722,
0.5873741508,
-0.5383476019,
0.7214087844,
0.5630992055,
-0.2876398861,
-0.094462961,
0.0695465729,
0.2425718307,
0.416292876,
-0.6721228957,
-0.2165062875,
0.5337255597,
-0.2209298611,
-0.0340454318,
0.3110725582,
0.0488366634,
0.0462240092,
-0.194959864,
0.43446064,
-0.0188633502,
0.0120560443,
-0.5077940226,
0.078087002,
0.2369061857,
-0.6841878891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15729v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15729v2
|
How Do Humans Write Code? Large Models Do It the Same Way Too
| 2024-02-24T05:40:01 | 2024-06-17T06:00:41 |
Long Li, Xuzheng He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Program-of-Thought (PoT) replaces natural language-based Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) as the most popular method in Large Language Models (LLMs) mathematical
reasoning tasks by utilizing external tool calls to circumvent computational
errors. However, our evaluation of the GPT-4 and Llama series reveals that
using PoT introduces more reasoning errors, such as incorrect formulas or
flawed logic, compared to CoT. To address this issue, we propose Human-Think
Language (HTL), which leverages a suite of strategies that help integrate PoT
and CoT, encompassing: (1) a new generation paradigm that uses full CoT
reasoning to control code generation. (2) Focus Attention, that directs model
attention to the CoT reasoning during PoT to generate more logical code. (3)
reinforcement learning that utilizes the accuracy of both CoT and PoT responses
as rewards to prevent repetitive reasoning steps in LLMs when solving difficult
math problems. Our method achieves an average improvement of 6.5% on the
Llama-Base model and 4.3% on the Mistral-Base model across 8 mathematical
calculation datasets. It also shows significant effectiveness on five
out-of-domain datasets by controlling the model's information flow, exhibiting
strong transferability. Additionally, HTL shows the most significant
improvement in non-mathematical natural language inference task, contributing
to a unified reasoning task framework
|
[
-0.3174773753,
-0.8541804552,
0.715677917,
0.3608649075,
-0.0733686388,
0.401669234,
-0.4545694888,
-0.2988884449,
-0.2989269793,
0.5952987075,
-0.4222665429,
-0.4690113068,
-0.3030642569,
0.0959467962,
-0.0555633716,
0.9210835695,
-0.2483229488,
-0.0664581433,
-0.1485103518,
0.3069833517,
-0.4977380931,
-0.8289089799,
-0.5177114606,
-0.4992393255,
0.5850069523,
0.3767587841,
0.7546595335,
0.3550492525,
0.7352160215,
0.1850744337,
0.2187119871,
0.3459911048,
-0.4663108587,
-0.2215368152,
-0.2067393512,
-0.7781481743,
-0.4378505349,
-0.1418203712,
0.1179785952,
0.4587554336,
-0.3794369102,
0.1276564002,
-0.1671869308,
0.7575435042,
-0.6844376326,
0.3718218803,
-0.6232859492,
0.176662609,
0.002904837,
-0.4674580991,
-0.8448370099,
-0.3948203325,
-0.0938621685,
-0.5302069783,
-0.0512275584,
0.1674518585,
0.4832188189,
0.4421226382,
-0.2813312709,
-0.3295209408,
-0.8181287646,
0.8457860351,
-0.6521881223,
0.0980528295,
0.622261405,
0.1901370287,
-0.4934341013,
-0.4462766945,
-0.8276706338,
-0.2924460471,
0.1230921224,
-0.0934009328,
-0.1471519917,
-0.0478624068,
0.3839578629,
0.0075377086,
-0.375859946,
-0.255176723,
-0.5280990601,
-0.0938037634,
0.7351903319,
0.1030116081,
0.3445634544,
-0.0637478009,
-0.2103357613,
-0.1480424702,
-0.9908755422,
-0.0740398839,
0.035260357,
0.1291719973,
-0.0347198285,
0.5556592345,
0.1147302985,
0.6306772232,
-0.1082871556,
-0.1628165245,
0.0853698328,
-0.080793567,
-0.5306692123,
-0.0040200469,
0.7410805225,
0.1134237424,
0.7136548162,
-0.1762787998,
-0.1969303042,
0.6152163148,
0.5509319901,
-0.48042503,
-0.4870783091,
0.027343506,
-0.0529429279,
-0.4853644967,
-0.0601016842,
-0.5297611356,
-0.4463755786,
-0.7134802938,
0.3888592124,
-0.3511220515,
-0.1089826375,
0.353281647,
0.1749600917,
0.2943067551,
0.3014878929,
-0.7918166518,
0.5312293172,
0.6926401854,
0.4779587984,
-0.2027836591,
-0.448703438,
-0.6254367232,
0.2166719735,
-0.6897860765,
0.7753181458,
-0.5144648552,
-0.2319738269,
-0.3676496744,
-0.4393968284,
-0.0300765317,
-0.5301302075,
0.375069499,
-0.483055383,
0.1682138294,
-0.643026948,
-0.3852823079,
0.0708988756,
0.1732115895,
-0.4675860107,
1.0312212706,
0.1841617227,
-0.7627678514,
0.3613623977,
-1.0840070248,
-0.4827711284,
-0.0309064649,
-0.3967107832,
-0.493919611,
-0.0514437184,
0.295480758,
0.1629665196,
-0.5303063989,
0.4039871693,
-0.1441044211,
-0.5219650865,
0.5468394756,
-0.420540899,
0.6904039383,
0.2627380192,
-0.8015195131,
0.3785377443,
-0.2673469186,
0.2286427766,
0.459297657,
-0.2903733552,
-0.0124266883,
-0.0630410835,
-0.2125652134,
0.3889101446,
-0.3130600154,
-0.4179443419,
0.3613647819,
-0.2113863379,
0.6712805629,
0.7606443167,
-0.0117924856,
0.3973588049,
-0.5470433831,
0.6153469682,
0.0729814619,
0.0647057667,
0.0595213883,
-0.5673581958,
-0.8311137557,
-0.1529958248,
0.1048522368,
0.5985767841,
-0.8845260143,
0.2930798233,
-0.0184719097,
-0.3102988899,
-0.435701102,
0.4002449214,
0.5542721152,
0.4619386196,
0.3527745306,
-0.1111883074,
-0.5688164234,
-0.4880481958,
-0.1170611903,
-0.2691626847,
0.0741521493,
0.1352060884,
0.5996767879,
-0.2586369514,
0.9931199551,
-0.7327358723,
0.0391632393,
-0.5189500451,
0.2630607486,
-0.0249098614,
0.2879963517,
0.2469380498,
-0.6555083394,
-0.4183634222,
-0.0215981565,
-0.7616853714,
-0.0125799673,
-0.2832536399,
-0.6098883748,
0.2860113978,
0.367287904,
-0.744601965,
0.7338938117,
0.1215031445,
-0.4616371989,
0.6289276481,
-0.365038842,
0.0532911383,
-0.7354070544,
-0.0711071342,
-0.0965205878,
-0.163653031,
-0.3074932694,
0.2271961272,
0.1190367416,
-0.0311974641,
-0.3520445228,
0.3141025007,
-0.4874371886,
-0.2962147295,
-0.3465821147,
-0.0659450814,
0.159630239,
0.9918494225,
-0.023922734,
1.0004230738,
0.3528701961,
-0.6061982512,
0.5223997235,
0.1635695547,
-0.3516683578,
0.1988528222,
-0.6409050822,
0.4525992274,
-0.0835174769,
0.535425961,
-0.6790294647,
-0.1940914392,
0.1622505784,
-0.3337917924,
0.0645470917,
0.4060311913,
-0.6923252344,
-0.6467624307,
-0.2089867443,
0.3583660722,
0.7028266191,
-0.5217326283,
0.4443202019,
0.3633126915,
-0.0774139166,
-0.5246085525,
-0.7589406371,
0.2262496948,
-0.0496174991,
-0.4220592082,
0.1876093596,
-0.0472758226,
-0.4409933984,
-0.0343772285,
0.0640840679,
-0.0552676022,
0.1014946327,
0.0849082097,
0.5434296727,
-0.1009140387,
0.3192303777,
-0.1544039249,
-0.0176885128,
0.2524340749,
-0.3849456608,
0.8183399439,
-0.487722218,
-0.4937810302,
-0.2293626964,
0.1608269215,
0.6134337187,
-0.5272091031,
0.4176407754,
0.3493980467,
-0.2753279507,
-0.4805425704,
-0.281248033,
-0.1064157039,
-0.4287418127,
0.2012867033,
-0.3363155127,
-0.5909264684,
0.0545695648,
0.1710311472,
0.168330282,
0.1477339119,
0.9041205645,
-0.2139104158,
0.7821672559,
0.7042372823,
-0.1432610005,
0.142302677,
-0.3826687336,
0.3814984858,
-0.8682841063,
-0.0723552033,
-0.0930568203,
-0.2382455915,
-0.2298286259,
-0.8977778554,
0.2282641381,
0.034010835,
-0.543584466,
0.4489118159,
-0.592613399,
0.7644580603,
0.6797517538,
0.2573322952,
0.4359827638,
-0.1023663133,
-0.3688737154,
0.1483300477,
-0.7539248466,
-0.504585743,
1.3319666386,
0.2357972562,
0.9959160089,
0.146076709,
0.6990221739,
0.4209467471,
0.7993415594,
-0.67925632,
0.4391824603,
0.2920123637,
-0.5298662186,
-0.4412709177,
-0.53546983,
-0.820477128,
0.16038315,
0.0738023669,
-0.6048983932,
-0.2027546465,
0.3239066303,
-0.5042921901,
0.4858725071,
-0.9021698833,
0.6721461415,
-0.4835367501,
-0.5355081558,
-0.3206563294,
-0.4826600552,
0.4703879356,
-0.0846615955,
0.2451351136,
0.1986470819,
0.1893901378,
0.3455679715,
-0.434125185,
0.9142559767,
0.1045164838,
-0.4151039124,
0.8357889056,
0.2390256375,
0.5993871093,
-0.0648046285,
0.1947407722,
-0.1432142109,
-0.3334230483,
-0.4725130498,
-0.6794469953,
0.4164811075,
-0.7896289825,
-0.503922224,
-0.3780321777,
-0.7505130768,
-0.3320815861,
-0.0509092622,
0.1663401723,
0.3919054568,
0.05243304,
-0.0999716073,
0.6103880405,
-0.3439913392,
0.3297274411,
0.0907323584,
-0.4358555973,
-0.2852914929,
0.9515077472,
-0.3409173191,
0.465767175,
0.4737423956,
0.2820565403,
-0.1978195906,
0.0876686424,
-0.5352718234,
0.3286357224,
-0.6709631681,
-0.2263973951,
-0.6604842544,
-0.1736627072,
-0.2597372234,
-0.376136452,
-0.103079401,
-0.0730353817,
0.1807155609,
-0.1288568974,
0.3204398751,
0.7275194526,
0.3395142853,
0.1704446822,
-0.4962374568,
0.4872089624,
0.4363100231,
0.3910569847,
0.227783516,
-0.1147897914,
-0.0499377064,
0.1320426464,
-0.6113513708,
-0.6704353094,
0.4412539601,
-0.1460144371,
0.1864511818,
-0.0120498538,
0.079315424,
0.5607860088,
-0.4841388762,
0.3532600105,
0.4025267065,
-1.1133686304,
0.415238291,
-0.33979702,
0.5047120452,
0.2888815403,
-0.1292333901,
-0.5202556849,
-0.4204489589,
-0.5215016603,
-0.3204036951,
0.5279955864,
0.3729698658,
-0.0960088372,
-0.2357636988,
0.069888629,
-0.0717263892,
0.2416664362,
-0.7937546968,
0.2784283459,
-0.0776457414,
-0.2947260141,
0.1244899109,
0.1039560288,
-0.1205328628,
-0.381950736,
0.4008429348,
-0.3452926874,
0.4724061489,
0.1611205786,
-0.2739258707,
-0.5053705573,
0.536291182,
0.717549026,
1.014369607,
0.0407604128,
0.2049812675,
0.08507099,
-0.4544204175,
0.196075514,
-0.5039194226,
-0.0898831785,
-0.4172159433,
0.369184494,
0.7586763501,
0.2759298086,
-1.1068185568,
0.4926526248,
-0.0016769648,
-0.3483217061,
-0.4533869028,
0.2596603632,
0.4177840948,
-0.0534870699,
0.1275497824,
0.3151817918,
-0.1366413981,
-0.7636914253,
0.1776123047,
0.1328454018,
-0.1467660218,
-0.2333672047,
0.5897982717,
0.3360243738,
-0.295076102,
0.6963640451,
-0.3972969949,
-0.8925247192,
0.8683816791,
0.7541605234,
0.786308825,
0.1893617511,
0.388707906,
0.1554200649,
0.3228700161,
-0.1063327715,
0.6236249804,
-0.1689879745,
-0.7300307155,
-1.002369523,
-0.4017430544,
-0.4722432792,
-0.16133596,
-0.4133422971,
0.3132074475,
-0.7091386318,
-0.118986249,
-0.1283663809,
-0.0182166919,
-0.7556176782,
0.1410479397,
0.407137394,
0.6494555473,
-0.5369387269,
0.9637494087,
0.4655143619,
-0.4733960629,
-1.1605502367,
0.0208195765,
-0.0644601434,
-0.7454849482,
0.9060391784,
0.1263189018,
-0.4165769815,
-0.0152014112,
-0.8194286227,
-0.7934173942,
0.9300778508,
0.1881094426,
-0.6269883513,
-0.2120662481,
0.0659312084,
0.5893509388,
-0.4584975243,
-0.0082851611,
0.6879571676,
0.4044354856,
0.1556066424,
-1.0111649036,
-0.0025892796,
-0.2658855021,
-0.1612628251,
0.6255005002,
-0.5922574401,
0.9030533433,
-0.934566021,
-0.1350592673,
-0.215667367,
0.436221391,
0.5095047951,
0.2708755732,
0.371512413,
0.6742063761,
0.9690882564,
-0.0134788183,
1.3267850876,
-0.0148301944,
0.2172330022,
1.2899739742,
-0.5659564137,
0.8423038125,
0.3710059822,
-0.4631320536,
0.7301351428,
0.1807428151,
-0.0302293301,
0.3064566553,
0.7405692339,
-0.0687082112,
-0.3134119809,
0.3286185563,
-0.1608409435,
0.423597306,
0.3747732639,
-0.1520076692,
0.0643884391,
-0.0097598787,
0.2382277697,
0.2805091143,
-0.1486565471,
0.7322840691,
0.1974143088,
-0.9509665966,
0.7279799581,
-0.0463511795,
0.614584744,
-0.3067528903,
-0.2119885683,
-0.0538243838,
0.39156425,
-0.1202118471,
-0.6348104477,
0.1956738234,
0.319658041,
-0.1669081151,
-0.057042595,
0.3462055922,
-0.3661750853,
-0.6650743484,
-0.0184057057,
0.4685662389,
-0.006969972,
-0.0850909427,
-0.568050921,
-0.0681403428,
0.0675798059,
0.0372252017,
0.1802435219,
0.5332112312,
-0.4610987306,
0.9855786562,
0.884899199,
0.2391620427,
0.1305522025,
0.338609755,
0.9441666007,
-0.9624866247,
-0.6234542131,
-0.8620829582,
0.2219540328,
-0.2012227029,
-0.4557594657,
0.3959812522,
0.314178884,
0.7910062075,
-0.0700926483,
1.0687266588,
0.044046443,
0.3479367495,
-0.4239114523,
0.5009067655,
-0.0250796005,
0.4320739806,
-0.5163143277,
-0.9446280599,
-0.2870686948,
0.680596292,
-0.6538988948,
-0.0212790947,
1.0658055544,
0.4836492538,
0.2315636575,
0.0551394708,
0.2700775862,
-0.028781509,
0.6781901717,
1.0645186901,
0.9300720096,
-0.1803607047,
0.5705759525,
-0.2212085426,
-0.3091893196,
-0.0532282963,
-0.7014774084,
-0.9629108906,
-0.1821363419,
-0.2231148332,
-0.2669952214,
-0.1363575608,
1.3001654148,
0.5192949176,
-0.6914598942,
-0.3745498657,
-0.5791110396,
-0.0008355696,
-0.3000026345,
-0.2381596863,
0.4147621393,
-0.6284570098,
-0.4199776053,
0.0406020358,
0.4624070823,
-0.2197372168,
-0.4062614441,
-0.3440557718,
0.0062638195,
0.3511564136,
0.7463730574,
0.2393380553,
-0.8689283133,
-0.0561265089,
0.3560591638,
-0.4795636535,
0.1103507802,
1.2045359612,
-0.8225103617,
0.4639748633,
0.2127390951,
0.806887567,
0.3090650439,
0.0475310199,
0.8738449812,
-0.2459891289,
0.0686551183,
0.4420848191,
0.3142864704,
0.4032701552,
-0.4439888895,
0.560285449,
0.1464861929,
-0.6153075695,
-0.6375524998,
0.3986548185,
-0.7799941301,
-0.4480077028,
1.174366951,
-0.0244393218,
-0.5227372646,
-0.1545675397,
-0.6107638478,
0.0261090137,
-0.3402644098,
1.1151993275,
0.7398719788,
-0.2561406195,
-0.1508661211,
-0.3619658649,
0.4970414937,
0.4401226044,
-1.2016947269,
0.2280335128,
0.4338418841,
0.1548459828,
0.0527681522,
0.7166157961,
-0.2439984083,
0.5769743323,
0.0801679492,
0.3261362612,
-0.0648354962,
-0.4862989485,
0.2585667074,
-0.1167006567,
0.1427222639,
0.143817246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15721v1
|
Hal-Eval: A Universal and Fine-grained Hallucination Evaluation Framework for Large Vision Language Models
| 2024-02-24T05:14:52 | 2024-02-24T05:14:52 |
Chaoya Jiang, Wei Ye, Mengfan Dong, Hongrui Jia, Haiyang Xu, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Vision Language Models exhibit remarkable capabilities but struggle
with hallucinations inconsistencies between images and their descriptions.
Previous hallucination evaluation studies on LVLMs have identified
hallucinations in terms of objects, attributes, and relations but overlooked
complex hallucinations that create an entire narrative around a fictional
entity. In this paper, we introduce a refined taxonomy of hallucinations,
featuring a new category: Event Hallucination. We then utilize advanced LLMs to
generate and filter fine grained hallucinatory data consisting of various types
of hallucinations, with a particular focus on event hallucinations, laying the
groundwork for integrating discriminative and generative evaluation methods
within our universal evaluation framework. The proposed benchmark distinctively
assesses LVLMs ability to tackle a broad spectrum of hallucinations, making it
a reliable and comprehensive tool for gauging LVLMs efficacy in handling
hallucinations. We will release our code and data.
|
[
-0.3969252408,
-0.8156968951,
0.6575834751,
0.1673385352,
-0.3294972777,
-0.0540881492,
-0.3071162403,
-0.7048616409,
0.2747468352,
0.67108953,
-0.3004024029,
-0.8103444576,
-0.2764777839,
0.0804283395,
-0.6936018467,
0.7706876993,
-0.0356081389,
0.1750311702,
-0.1252865791,
-0.2224181592,
-0.2519131303,
-0.805470407,
-0.4210287929,
-0.2555051446,
0.4853246808,
-0.2183897346,
0.7254654169,
0.2977882922,
0.6833282709,
0.141989395,
0.026357837,
0.4989745915,
-0.5055096745,
0.1744788885,
-0.1465376467,
-0.1336332858,
-0.4870781302,
-0.3854110837,
0.4806405604,
0.7136717439,
-0.5218490362,
0.1812638044,
0.0871752053,
0.6297694445,
-0.8675228953,
-0.0236910433,
-0.7623563409,
0.538026154,
-0.1789964139,
-0.3715379536,
-0.5355841517,
-0.3114686906,
-0.0792383552,
-0.4466844201,
0.1886147857,
0.2554442585,
0.5155062079,
0.234603256,
-0.0476205498,
-0.5754458904,
-0.8022853136,
0.6060631871,
-0.2719515562,
0.6956099868,
0.2677160501,
0.3959350288,
0.0535891056,
-0.797516942,
-0.3244547248,
-0.6442224383,
0.1573944837,
-0.2045727372,
-0.2420431674,
0.2497624308,
0.1367699206,
0.3368856609,
-0.6304557323,
0.1376290917,
-0.4116565287,
-0.304489553,
0.6049752831,
0.721557498,
0.1255742162,
-0.1187895685,
-0.3643611073,
0.1591133475,
-0.4912603199,
-0.3223340511,
0.029476935,
0.2049310058,
0.1795760393,
0.6403191686,
-0.1614215076,
0.551299572,
-0.1953597963,
-0.0507865697,
0.2135880888,
-0.1040513813,
-0.4764100909,
0.2361721843,
0.4893661439,
0.6081094146,
0.2338986099,
-0.431330055,
-0.368901968,
0.2642976344,
0.5366987586,
-0.7216203809,
-0.1909821033,
0.1968393475,
-0.7237773538,
-0.2576700747,
0.0404722355,
-1.0602016449,
-0.9505454302,
-0.3963933587,
0.5996252894,
-0.4166770875,
0.0662054718,
0.3611165285,
0.1372414678,
0.3414975405,
0.3207237422,
-0.672809422,
0.3420997858,
0.6523448229,
0.6135101318,
-0.6702111959,
-0.3704396784,
-0.6555002928,
-0.004911656,
-0.5491360426,
0.6656904221,
-0.6823633313,
-0.3453974426,
0.3497755826,
-0.013272265,
0.2267867625,
-0.8125126362,
0.5821906328,
-0.3942990005,
-0.3244658411,
-0.0673177168,
-0.4739224017,
-0.2062457353,
0.0557206422,
-0.4571946561,
0.6970031261,
0.0438177325,
-0.2009165287,
0.4724364281,
-0.3565315306,
-0.149043411,
0.4840863943,
-0.3646750748,
-0.2066245675,
0.4336708188,
0.0611710772,
0.5270355344,
-0.123575598,
0.5502228141,
-0.2891974449,
-0.6012405157,
0.2523323894,
-0.6716674566,
0.2767672837,
0.166638732,
-0.2919864357,
0.4851645529,
-1.0650072098,
-0.1326957941,
-0.0008535984,
-0.191065833,
-0.3401349783,
0.2366722226,
0.2450658679,
-0.3334998488,
0.2975845337,
-0.1781949252,
0.1972772181,
-0.2910495698,
-0.201836288,
0.7185329795,
0.1111986116,
0.2710592151,
-0.1197222397,
0.470954597,
-0.2097934037,
0.5025491714,
-0.0159268454,
-0.1369480789,
-1.0138963461,
-0.0407413952,
-0.2743265927,
0.2284327894,
-0.6518296003,
0.5030956864,
-0.0154793356,
-0.367429167,
-0.293346107,
-0.0525088832,
0.5325804949,
0.137598142,
0.3863038421,
-0.2282075882,
-0.8279695511,
-0.9864153266,
0.0881753638,
-0.1330184489,
0.0033217564,
0.1677943468,
0.459443301,
-0.5529608727,
0.4496115446,
-0.227962479,
-0.6179111004,
-0.1370177716,
-0.0175041575,
-0.2725154459,
0.0877995342,
0.3491479158,
-0.527831912,
-0.0608252361,
0.284830153,
-0.9697344303,
-0.1452379376,
-0.3587180376,
0.0042611011,
0.6773432493,
0.3726518154,
-0.1954541951,
0.7095351815,
0.3317972422,
-0.6609337926,
0.8784049749,
-0.0995928198,
0.3303017616,
-0.2913683653,
-0.0982829928,
-0.364575386,
-0.0525690764,
-0.5724000931,
0.4265778065,
-0.0893367231,
0.2229998112,
-0.6673612595,
0.5698144436,
-0.3365514874,
-0.3486583233,
0.0231427513,
0.2467926443,
-0.0411857069,
0.4138529897,
0.0527226739,
0.3803619146,
0.7004547715,
-0.5748693347,
0.5972629189,
0.1744741648,
-0.7029175758,
0.4264367819,
-0.0640329942,
0.0520426817,
-0.031693656,
-0.0078740316,
-0.5429623723,
-0.3416353166,
0.3013053834,
-0.0283096451,
0.0572025739,
0.3452693224,
-0.49951455,
-0.1963406205,
-0.3727258146,
0.3707085252,
0.5347562432,
-0.7217344046,
0.7955147028,
0.0992842019,
0.3683148026,
-0.3302519023,
-0.5312783718,
0.3383895457,
-0.2794809341,
-0.262293756,
0.1095854267,
-0.2773864567,
-0.5843973756,
-0.1225359291,
-0.1285236329,
0.0420298465,
-0.0796338245,
0.3342654407,
0.2549463511,
-0.3126316369,
0.0139187248,
-0.3301003575,
0.1570342183,
0.1119866669,
0.1151786149,
0.9935577512,
-0.2873348892,
-0.7496592402,
-0.4275938272,
0.2084951997,
0.4984117746,
0.1870066375,
0.408334583,
0.641266346,
-0.5625572801,
-0.3285778165,
-0.759832263,
0.0153420474,
-0.4047264457,
0.680342555,
-0.5444070697,
-0.6445875168,
0.7275850177,
0.3694876134,
-0.1919230968,
0.4265621305,
0.7208967805,
0.2027163506,
1.0131157637,
0.2434453219,
0.291736424,
-0.0346029773,
-0.0578652993,
0.0472594202,
-0.9760739207,
-0.6542082429,
-0.1196641698,
-0.1019360647,
-0.0140396804,
-0.5999048352,
0.1300932467,
0.3112379014,
-0.1693020761,
-0.2178883255,
-0.7386776805,
0.6326910257,
0.1718654931,
-0.0526091568,
0.4469973445,
0.1334808469,
0.1471472085,
-0.2214015275,
-0.1918596029,
-0.7242833972,
0.9848015904,
0.2896829247,
0.778945446,
-0.1868485063,
0.6610258818,
0.6809391379,
0.3888590038,
-0.6774910688,
0.7417469621,
-0.2499128282,
-0.4068781435,
-0.3039658964,
-0.0826461762,
-0.7614751458,
0.4536493123,
-0.0931116492,
-1.2591700554,
0.3349974453,
-0.1549503356,
-0.3914339244,
0.4856775999,
-0.1134855226,
0.6173741221,
-0.418704927,
-0.1300693154,
-0.3495362997,
-0.1510728002,
0.674439013,
-0.3577777743,
0.2631257474,
-0.1804831177,
-0.0355169922,
0.794708848,
-0.0165293682,
0.8357822299,
0.0007818606,
-0.2490089536,
0.3688624203,
0.5877305269,
0.1922783554,
-0.0342019796,
-0.0368643589,
0.508675158,
0.1454360336,
0.2276490331,
-0.5171329379,
0.6282839775,
-0.4538001418,
-0.3369913697,
-0.2053550482,
-0.3896846771,
-0.1748713702,
-0.3473937511,
0.2397643328,
0.6011505723,
-0.5699279904,
0.2278835624,
0.4551341236,
-0.3886854947,
0.3630038202,
0.43915838,
-1.1567473412,
-0.4271015823,
1.0555378199,
-0.1291582286,
0.0813778341,
0.141080752,
-0.0401160493,
-0.1881180257,
-0.7957981229,
-0.2728234828,
-0.0372124761,
-1.0113532543,
-0.260212332,
-0.631177783,
-0.5255465508,
-0.1577424407,
-0.5240473747,
-0.3449663222,
-0.0301916208,
-0.416079849,
0.0216647722,
-0.0154161034,
0.8038128018,
-0.0787352845,
-0.0030604552,
-0.6763690114,
0.6664995551,
0.0736029223,
0.3700268567,
0.2928217649,
-0.4770881832,
-0.1220586225,
-0.250287354,
-0.235621959,
-0.5883251429,
0.584407568,
0.2352064401,
0.6457644105,
0.7626791596,
0.0520987585,
0.8737199903,
-0.5806530118,
1.0753754377,
0.5168921351,
-0.9913526177,
0.6486096382,
0.0755039603,
-0.1816886365,
0.4959303439,
-0.016367184,
-0.5163627863,
-0.5475433469,
-0.4236575961,
-0.8295797706,
0.4209366143,
0.1515517682,
0.0694733709,
-0.1868537366,
0.2486049086,
0.5989921689,
0.0653372481,
-0.8750165701,
-0.1850091517,
0.2276753485,
-0.0591429435,
-0.0069840094,
-0.6365024447,
-0.2146435529,
-0.4749208689,
0.2322952151,
0.0914172083,
0.0081075495,
0.2042738944,
-0.2230463475,
-0.283131659,
0.093144834,
0.6481301785,
0.9405449033,
-0.430241257,
0.2554390728,
0.3683871925,
-0.4606921971,
-0.0384652019,
-0.2633865774,
0.0562510304,
0.051463671,
0.7100834846,
1.0691713095,
0.2246297598,
-1.1105710268,
0.4273533821,
-0.0684998482,
-0.3533082306,
-0.4243785739,
0.3659515977,
-0.4572822452,
0.5106850266,
0.5621886849,
-0.1098832116,
0.4614439905,
-0.6156737804,
0.426023066,
0.3980160356,
-0.4888583422,
-0.3339624405,
0.6977424026,
-0.0281869117,
-0.7116715908,
0.4104040265,
-0.37717098,
-0.5094568729,
0.6463586092,
0.4934613407,
1.0664910078,
-0.1936997175,
0.1737496704,
0.2281828076,
0.3614087999,
0.1120070741,
0.224637568,
0.0185022764,
-0.5744902492,
-0.1284492761,
-1.3829356432,
-0.2366065532,
0.4175140858,
-0.6607585549,
0.2617431581,
-0.1796723455,
0.1901018769,
-0.1107652709,
-0.2688852549,
-0.6501099467,
0.0326242186,
0.7110645771,
0.6325041652,
-0.5817539096,
0.5982362628,
0.2574631572,
-0.2300217599,
-0.1815461367,
0.1106574833,
-0.2030639946,
-0.8905171752,
0.7701768875,
0.2425833344,
-0.0392668433,
-0.2364067137,
-0.4888035357,
-0.680480063,
0.8398535848,
-0.0773669556,
-0.8469688296,
-0.0430736057,
0.2631611228,
0.7035449743,
-0.7237473726,
-0.1822766662,
0.9433991909,
0.5915064216,
0.174272269,
-0.7384940386,
-0.0074781966,
0.2104150504,
0.0794438273,
0.0348656848,
-0.2074621916,
0.3666541874,
-0.2572311163,
-0.3015557528,
0.3381829262,
0.5091989636,
0.4281698465,
0.7389409542,
0.3756802082,
0.435297668,
0.7175351381,
-0.0426900983,
1.0472531319,
-0.1738666445,
0.2965881228,
1.1170599461,
-0.4844683409,
0.8495110869,
0.3793191314,
-0.2937098145,
0.131526947,
0.4868305922,
-0.3045105636,
0.5934643745,
0.4246547818,
-0.2247845083,
-0.3664411604,
-0.155002594,
-0.3939571381,
0.4814393818,
0.5380147696,
-0.2240047008,
-0.2370655239,
0.711414516,
-0.5838457346,
-0.1377372742,
-0.5443660617,
0.69749403,
0.0603346191,
-0.3413930237,
0.798371315,
-0.3236579299,
0.650467813,
-0.3705600202,
-0.1481905133,
-0.2019886076,
0.1686051041,
-0.1765320152,
-0.7582444549,
0.557303369,
-0.0208231229,
0.0598979145,
0.2176233828,
0.6190782189,
-0.2519487441,
-0.5475049019,
0.6791410446,
0.1829742491,
0.6861872077,
-0.1417128444,
-0.3163025975,
0.8162898421,
0.1845139712,
-0.2120977789,
0.163652122,
0.3561965227,
-0.0931867734,
0.5913053751,
0.3623708189,
0.2036218345,
0.1375354677,
0.6517212391,
0.4324296713,
-0.6620804071,
-0.0038482016,
-1.1095893383,
0.469820857,
0.0893497244,
-0.4281156659,
0.4247651994,
0.7664217353,
0.5106112957,
-0.1380168051,
0.3849624693,
0.0902315751,
-0.0357888341,
-0.5846295357,
0.7055503726,
-0.8614144921,
0.2524918616,
-0.0432335585,
-1.2828719616,
-0.4455760121,
0.5857064724,
0.1428198069,
-0.3156627715,
0.7439691424,
0.5952242017,
0.0532959066,
-0.0361760557,
0.9804672003,
0.4064882994,
0.1440428197,
0.5516082644,
1.3258620501,
-0.1440829337,
0.3876688182,
-0.1152409092,
-0.0987181962,
-0.6049660444,
-0.6054517031,
-0.9062814713,
-0.8690584898,
-0.4057463109,
-0.3048846722,
0.2516466379,
0.8125689626,
0.3913955986,
-0.8182712197,
-0.1345469952,
0.0396922827,
-0.1463446021,
0.1514685601,
-0.3172495067,
0.5772312284,
-0.5016233921,
-0.5732331872,
0.3068387508,
0.6605479121,
0.0164369512,
-0.8120789528,
-0.2122160494,
0.4702929854,
0.222672075,
0.9082298279,
-0.2080919743,
-1.4025709629,
-0.4016621709,
-0.2840804458,
-0.165219903,
0.0064934194,
0.5414589047,
-0.6940338612,
0.4603068233,
0.0029607986,
0.3838099241,
0.2726733685,
-0.3324857056,
0.0600896068,
-0.4077774584,
0.1046982631,
0.3937997818,
0.4254944026,
0.0635886192,
-0.448551774,
0.6780806184,
-0.0311487131,
-0.5013945103,
-1.2430700064,
0.0548053011,
-1.3457789421,
-0.4709121287,
1.4293652773,
0.3953163922,
-0.1484417319,
-0.024990702,
-0.4465605021,
-0.0888917148,
0.0122436685,
1.0360635519,
0.7302241921,
-0.3519434333,
0.0156285968,
-0.6311091185,
0.6059659719,
-0.0501391664,
-0.7503958344,
0.4130532444,
0.8091967106,
-0.223093316,
0.2865757346,
0.5333499908,
-0.0219930857,
0.230528146,
0.040486861,
0.4982214868,
0.1004580706,
-0.6636999249,
-0.4673766196,
0.5281764269,
-0.2122239769,
0.0273891278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15713v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15713v1
|
Making Pre-trained Language Models Better Continual Few-Shot Relation Extractors
| 2024-02-24T04:32:44 | 2024-02-24T04:32:44 |
Shengkun Ma, Jiale Han, Yi Liang, Bo Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Continual Few-shot Relation Extraction (CFRE) is a practical problem that
requires the model to continuously learn novel relations while avoiding
forgetting old ones with few labeled training data. The primary challenges are
catastrophic forgetting and overfitting. This paper harnesses prompt learning
to explore the implicit capabilities of pre-trained language models to address
the above two challenges, thereby making language models better continual
few-shot relation extractors. Specifically, we propose a Contrastive Prompt
Learning framework, which designs prompt representation to acquire more
generalized knowledge that can be easily adapted to old and new categories, and
margin-based contrastive learning to focus more on hard samples, therefore
alleviating catastrophic forgetting and overfitting issues. To further remedy
overfitting in low-resource scenarios, we introduce an effective memory
augmentation strategy that employs well-crafted prompts to guide ChatGPT in
generating diverse samples. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method
outperforms state-of-the-art methods by a large margin and significantly
mitigates catastrophic forgetting and overfitting in low-resource scenarios.
|
[
-0.3462250829,
-0.6524958014,
0.6264942884,
0.0902008116,
-0.2369198799,
-0.0079974821,
-0.2345916182,
-0.2308464646,
-0.3991636634,
0.3126049638,
-0.7636579275,
-0.1975517422,
-0.5024287105,
0.1074509472,
-0.0093388353,
1.0671057701,
0.1544452608,
-0.0130440993,
-0.1570946425,
-0.2051847428,
-0.661906302,
-0.5450447202,
-1.0929788351,
-0.2201363593,
0.6505383849,
0.5885262489,
0.4247986376,
0.2261265069,
0.2932747006,
0.3490209579,
0.0398952477,
0.0788400397,
-0.8309272528,
0.2001861632,
-0.2126172632,
-0.3975957036,
0.0633572489,
0.0396511294,
0.5743708014,
0.7028349638,
-0.0685782284,
-0.2348663658,
0.2889110446,
0.5849825144,
-0.8577414155,
0.2610715032,
-0.6914998889,
-0.192559436,
-0.093693547,
-0.2367452085,
-0.3637703061,
-0.3741025329,
0.3146165609,
-0.6409324408,
0.1676642597,
0.0517963022,
0.9007084966,
0.3250211477,
-0.244531855,
-0.1553579718,
-0.6384359002,
0.8347986937,
-0.495079726,
0.4796838164,
0.5236620307,
0.5629276633,
-0.1891619563,
-0.7688696384,
-0.4469610453,
-0.4536244273,
-0.3067048192,
0.1468049735,
-0.2665406466,
0.0473927371,
0.406421572,
0.1884412467,
-0.4309725165,
0.000899504,
-0.311608851,
-0.1082566753,
0.1201048866,
0.1536360383,
0.2486044765,
-0.0907653421,
-0.1920713782,
-0.0250640661,
-0.7568012476,
0.0871149004,
0.0459491536,
0.5193271041,
-0.0145711405,
0.0421443544,
-0.0007747032,
0.6431264281,
0.2101683468,
-0.0992395729,
0.1253557056,
-0.3185068369,
-0.1512060165,
-0.1606989205,
0.699096024,
-0.1198714003,
0.3685616851,
-0.0393779166,
-0.1654328704,
-0.1336086392,
-0.062239036,
-0.835124433,
-0.3384341598,
0.0022412313,
-0.2782624066,
0.0480541885,
-0.1723541915,
-0.7172411084,
-0.2107952386,
-0.2610546947,
0.2935968041,
-0.8356591463,
-0.2304622084,
-0.0699854568,
-0.1132160202,
0.2173782289,
0.4086987972,
-0.9726575017,
0.4810674489,
0.4826606512,
0.7821680307,
-0.0575395003,
-0.2129430175,
-1.0687968731,
-0.1340273321,
-0.229945153,
0.9373697042,
-0.6722666621,
-0.5022553802,
0.0088987639,
-0.0983574167,
-0.1849339902,
-0.5252717733,
0.3757487237,
-0.4166991413,
0.5602067709,
-0.4850707352,
-0.4596127272,
0.0980437025,
0.3925285637,
-0.6166034937,
0.9677272439,
0.4584757984,
-0.6891066432,
0.2763875723,
-0.286008805,
-0.1587197185,
0.1177337319,
-0.4009949863,
-0.2001226544,
0.0347757414,
0.407888025,
0.4276125133,
-0.3775757849,
0.2346484065,
-0.1627400815,
-0.2868145108,
0.0889248699,
-0.3879354298,
0.639526844,
0.2637987435,
0.104241401,
-0.0553197004,
-0.8174530268,
-0.2762231231,
0.015792476,
-0.2834852934,
-0.3827383816,
-0.279206872,
-0.133642301,
0.562138021,
-0.0571088456,
-0.3300104439,
0.0867213383,
-0.5668232441,
0.1834975332,
0.6619276404,
0.2659651339,
0.5763609409,
-0.3770043254,
0.7140931487,
0.2510401905,
-0.0408296734,
-0.9285168052,
-0.0127601009,
-0.9552733898,
-0.2716029882,
0.1208662093,
0.6581444144,
-1.0002987385,
0.1947471499,
-0.1573983133,
-0.2581957877,
-0.2803296745,
0.4463500082,
0.485093832,
0.9082372785,
0.622238934,
-0.1528922468,
-0.5870881081,
-0.5581316948,
0.0788593963,
-0.2844692469,
-0.0556663051,
0.4019482136,
0.3049253821,
-0.1248835176,
1.1128983498,
-0.5410168767,
-0.3205247521,
-0.4495727718,
0.291754365,
0.2165993303,
0.6844885349,
0.6407490373,
-0.5722526908,
-0.4416274428,
-0.1159189641,
-0.5398407578,
-0.0679517314,
-0.4360367954,
-0.1398351341,
0.1951425225,
0.716663003,
-0.5748590231,
-0.0332134031,
0.045412723,
0.0036615985,
0.5390290022,
0.0021928893,
-0.004080202,
-0.8723647594,
0.1888102144,
0.0431969799,
-0.1991085112,
-0.5462734699,
-0.1802007407,
-0.0519398414,
-0.2192673683,
-0.5935905576,
0.9172883034,
-0.5820470452,
0.3359968364,
-0.1962955445,
0.0299635343,
-0.0164178181,
0.6300452948,
0.2792278826,
0.6284868717,
0.6235285401,
-0.7070392966,
0.085369274,
0.3088585734,
-0.0675068647,
0.5372633934,
-0.5782356858,
0.2403870523,
-0.4942224324,
0.3159375489,
-1.2262089252,
-0.0557014905,
0.4179319143,
-0.3637883961,
0.6073778272,
-0.2607086301,
-0.2343724668,
-0.1568181217,
-0.1879935116,
0.2822115719,
0.7805124521,
-0.6692470908,
0.6905708313,
-0.1227490902,
-0.4953577816,
-0.7069513798,
-0.4036916792,
-0.325411886,
-0.1324249059,
-0.2699795067,
0.2230090052,
0.0150071112,
-0.1132335514,
0.0145495022,
-0.2368814796,
-0.3493201733,
-0.019089736,
0.0098937443,
0.2954027355,
-0.3914777935,
0.4601316154,
-0.1677727252,
-0.3410639465,
-0.1063492075,
-0.0276104435,
0.6325684786,
0.0182497017,
-0.0713503808,
-0.2444307655,
0.4279219508,
-0.0291111469,
-0.1094729677,
0.6355946064,
0.5139616728,
-0.3274568319,
-0.0308707356,
-0.810025692,
-0.3705266118,
-0.4891423881,
0.2516916096,
-0.4888220727,
-0.9816887975,
0.510212779,
-0.3030245006,
0.0538197532,
0.2847955823,
-0.0049453243,
-0.1301085502,
0.6212044954,
0.9022989869,
-0.263137728,
0.7527579069,
-0.1209395751,
-0.1546889395,
-0.4263026714,
-0.1413283795,
-0.7075099349,
0.1984238476,
-0.2759073973,
-0.194190681,
0.01848148,
0.4471435547,
-0.4288666844,
0.2882308662,
-0.0114372186,
0.6298404336,
0.3556756079,
0.1949353665,
-0.0394416824,
-0.086450465,
-0.2041735798,
-0.2153954953,
-0.8714145422,
-0.2386493087,
0.5211348534,
0.16238074,
0.7221039534,
-0.1125430763,
0.966361165,
-0.2626471817,
0.4291779101,
-0.7315110564,
0.2909560502,
-0.1172325388,
-0.3867967725,
-0.1443342119,
-0.5068930984,
-0.7992326021,
0.0933145508,
-0.3139626682,
-0.6988524199,
0.4495076835,
0.5197495222,
-0.7358499765,
-0.1506042778,
-0.6120663881,
0.799500525,
-0.1342686713,
-0.6302062273,
0.0080698505,
-0.8153309226,
0.4520547986,
-0.1409845203,
-0.0200201124,
0.0663842633,
0.0383329503,
0.503490448,
-0.4096453488,
1.060705781,
-0.1231651902,
0.1525553614,
0.3602719009,
0.026922226,
0.5469889045,
-0.0561508238,
-0.0945671573,
-0.1902253926,
-0.2161462754,
-0.5686679482,
-0.8220207095,
0.4624059498,
-0.5238731503,
-0.671890378,
-0.489145577,
-0.0511138439,
-0.3951248229,
0.0561548918,
0.4226112664,
0.4989067614,
-0.5575718284,
-0.0353713147,
0.697314322,
-0.4801048338,
0.6456531286,
0.4591110349,
0.1027508304,
-0.4190794826,
0.9259461761,
-0.0793189928,
0.2792475522,
0.4424120188,
0.2652744949,
-0.3475839496,
-0.199789241,
-0.0608425885,
0.2269113362,
-0.8625308275,
-0.3458976746,
-0.86026752,
-0.244007051,
-0.4708054066,
-0.302834332,
-0.2028109431,
-0.218931511,
-0.532915771,
-0.0567927621,
0.3140195906,
0.1897968054,
-0.2014829516,
0.7711443305,
-1.1408393383,
0.2777502239,
0.5280695558,
-0.0476848744,
0.1084845141,
-0.5555192232,
0.046742484,
-0.4459088445,
-0.3150203824,
-0.7492940426,
0.4731595218,
0.4471597672,
0.7677010894,
0.6538920999,
0.0215305313,
0.9235292673,
-0.5970657468,
0.7348828912,
0.5126067996,
-0.8300597668,
0.5770502687,
-0.1704309285,
0.7074356079,
0.9669624567,
0.8449972868,
-0.5177829266,
-0.0787771791,
-0.7839811444,
-0.7510298491,
0.6463860869,
-0.0011489576,
0.4368732274,
-0.3619294465,
0.2738242447,
0.3258832693,
0.0549490862,
-0.6239879131,
-0.0574181117,
-0.2636437714,
-0.1686224788,
-0.2353345305,
-0.5257220864,
0.2905364633,
-0.1394420564,
0.5830974579,
-0.1301997155,
0.0154761178,
0.0445703641,
-0.2850116491,
0.0575197153,
0.6007093191,
0.3591316342,
0.5742554665,
-0.2528544068,
0.1638356149,
0.3932809532,
-0.2236701399,
0.0933246091,
0.3475964367,
0.0781015679,
-0.0115065714,
0.6837037206,
0.8932431936,
0.5650739074,
-0.5865232348,
0.5757420063,
0.0033033609,
0.1975724399,
-0.1761215925,
0.1725185364,
-0.0101706712,
0.0131905116,
0.5102042556,
0.0972693488,
0.0044863778,
-0.6136407256,
0.5478793979,
0.2436858118,
-0.5583056808,
-0.2134758383,
0.2716677487,
0.3713001311,
-0.0334245563,
0.7982693315,
-0.2173021138,
-0.6103420854,
0.3400816321,
0.6693707108,
0.6462525725,
-0.4910859764,
0.194191739,
0.8188560009,
0.083328411,
-0.3578736782,
0.1074904278,
-0.4308634102,
-0.8169497848,
-0.5041299462,
-0.4028555453,
-0.2408450544,
0.2730850577,
-0.5279275179,
0.4991104007,
-0.615077436,
0.0843926445,
-0.2009803206,
0.1281145066,
-0.8208494782,
0.1924501061,
0.027368471,
0.8766358495,
-0.9179247618,
0.8646095395,
0.3164660037,
-0.8010652661,
-0.7209712863,
-0.1014406234,
0.0455421768,
-0.5909030437,
0.9451854229,
0.3929558098,
-0.1515249312,
0.1280163825,
-0.7538891435,
-0.635959506,
0.6422693133,
0.5594824553,
-0.8611025214,
-0.0622706115,
-0.3281150758,
0.3508790433,
-0.3584223092,
0.5561289191,
0.7099606991,
0.2473608255,
0.552190721,
-0.5017145276,
0.0998193994,
-0.1773379743,
-0.1742565036,
0.0269376207,
-0.3475830555,
0.758318305,
-0.2862606645,
-0.5931547284,
0.0448354185,
0.7152828574,
0.4587272108,
0.1228957027,
0.5615395904,
0.2131176144,
0.7711448669,
0.0251126736,
1.0050451756,
0.168526873,
-0.1291263849,
1.6462284327,
-0.409188807,
0.7149378061,
0.5093902349,
0.0968547165,
0.3909774125,
0.6837449074,
0.1899276823,
0.6746894717,
0.1247653142,
-0.3715518117,
-0.6037436128,
-0.2193080634,
-0.3154124618,
0.1800706834,
0.4320423603,
-0.2280802429,
-0.62886554,
0.0750913024,
0.1167113855,
0.1632290483,
-0.2018900216,
0.9391664863,
0.4653373957,
-0.6715092063,
0.7194539309,
-0.507825613,
0.8042413592,
-0.7954474092,
-0.3277885914,
-0.485236913,
-0.1069587991,
-0.0049724672,
-0.2348987609,
-0.0065499316,
-0.0784940869,
-0.0599263646,
-0.0760576651,
0.8623175621,
-0.664678514,
-0.3333646953,
0.2530952096,
0.7475361228,
0.0217946228,
0.0035953799,
-0.765216589,
-0.0322371237,
-0.1747924387,
-0.1527237743,
0.264079541,
0.5258398652,
-0.0224614851,
0.695720017,
0.5989681482,
0.0483893007,
-0.2227858156,
0.1541994959,
1.1313229799,
-0.7445350885,
-0.5696314573,
-1.0244292021,
0.5272624493,
-0.1869859397,
-0.4191617072,
0.3456503749,
0.2022362798,
0.5654985905,
-0.1354038566,
0.7092544436,
0.0533148907,
0.349876523,
-0.6928229928,
0.3396587074,
-0.2607028484,
0.1839803755,
-0.3202235699,
-0.8080211282,
-0.3193126321,
0.6352646947,
-0.302583009,
0.0976929963,
0.8917779326,
0.7606194615,
-0.2096097618,
-0.1795874834,
0.4778798521,
-0.0089929523,
0.1979404688,
0.9038285613,
1.13527596,
-0.2595537007,
0.7022442222,
-0.1506566703,
-0.200598225,
0.0852853581,
-1.1006939411,
-1.1431609392,
-0.6960975528,
-0.3602703214,
-0.0499777235,
0.1921347082,
1.1800376177,
0.789953351,
-0.833106339,
0.1044107601,
-0.1613175124,
0.0100044226,
-0.0305316523,
-0.1801325977,
0.3313750923,
-0.9761219025,
-0.6113327146,
0.4626187682,
0.0266185086,
0.3666779995,
0.0430920683,
-0.2037267834,
-0.2805263996,
-0.0885435566,
0.5510627031,
0.6272577047,
-0.3594478667,
-0.2567610145,
-0.0822627991,
-0.2104796022,
0.1721664518,
0.9886354804,
-1.2375422716,
0.1969864964,
0.5220016241,
0.8770663142,
0.406860888,
0.1181621403,
0.8179286718,
-1.0393959284,
0.4643176496,
0.2382071912,
0.3799982667,
0.5290061235,
-0.5017318726,
0.4564364851,
0.0568215922,
-0.2300119102,
-0.5807906389,
0.3431658149,
-0.8156422377,
-0.43969962,
1.0060184002,
-0.3892777562,
-0.1269014031,
-0.2391352803,
-0.3501508236,
0.2695630789,
-0.5435118079,
0.560370326,
0.7284296751,
-0.0596560687,
-0.7258790731,
-0.2513102889,
0.9318538308,
0.3821426034,
-0.8508085012,
-0.0140448175,
0.7264427543,
0.2783997655,
0.0713160634,
1.0600507259,
0.0458449237,
0.4046593308,
-0.0688897297,
-0.3148598373,
-0.06875664,
-0.3973847032,
-0.6324181557,
0.14046745,
0.0864315182,
-0.0402533077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15708v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15708v2
|
Query Augmentation by Decoding Semantics from Brain Signals
| 2024-02-24T04:08:51 | 2024-03-03T09:18:07 |
Ziyi Ye, Jingtao Zhan, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Maarten de Rijke, Christina Lioma, Tuukka Ruotsalo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Query augmentation is a crucial technique for refining semantically imprecise
queries. Traditionally, query augmentation relies on extracting information
from initially retrieved, potentially relevant documents. If the quality of the
initially retrieved documents is low, then the effectiveness of query
augmentation would be limited as well. We propose Brain-Aug, which enhances a
query by incorporating semantic information decoded from brain signals.
BrainAug generates the continuation of the original query with a prompt
constructed with brain signal information and a ranking-oriented inference
approach. Experimental results on fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging)
datasets show that Brain-Aug produces semantically more accurate queries,
leading to improved document ranking performance. Such improvement brought by
brain signals is particularly notable for ambiguous queries.
|
[
-0.5171787143,
-0.9213830829,
0.6691141129,
-0.0387701504,
-0.2257092744,
-0.1910889,
-0.1523414552,
-0.6010308862,
0.5472992063,
0.484654665,
-0.9361835718,
-0.422957927,
-0.6204819083,
0.0694542974,
-0.344052285,
0.6834982634,
0.7405472398,
0.2515225708,
-0.4114014804,
-0.0904066712,
-0.6043044925,
-0.4320316017,
-0.8808735609,
-0.4575238526,
0.5391660333,
0.105993025,
0.7422447801,
0.4885358214,
0.4562676847,
0.245572716,
-0.0012240954,
0.460624218,
-0.4671409428,
0.3675352037,
-0.0835437849,
-0.7643870115,
-0.2981966138,
-0.263618499,
0.5348294973,
1.1655130386,
0.1308646351,
-0.397195816,
-0.0439771526,
0.7811188102,
-0.6559017897,
0.1478802264,
-0.7889582515,
-0.2569247186,
-0.0991250649,
-0.759349525,
-0.4569069445,
-0.3444393575,
-0.1157802641,
-0.6427407265,
-0.0181974825,
0.1941200644,
0.9945830703,
0.5332604051,
-0.3859493732,
-0.1077417955,
-0.2207375616,
0.4367000759,
-0.5344647169,
0.6124219298,
0.8321974277,
0.1250444651,
-0.435058862,
-0.8703659773,
-0.5843666792,
-0.1472412646,
-0.3568412364,
0.2295532078,
0.0299421884,
0.248980701,
0.5397052169,
0.1420598328,
-0.4479758143,
-0.0501422435,
-0.3529038131,
-0.2853940427,
0.6145710349,
0.1622087061,
0.6179506183,
-0.2649363279,
0.0125732394,
-0.1791166067,
-0.6046718359,
-0.0610013269,
0.3769982457,
0.0054717222,
0.64678967,
0.6211531758,
-0.585565567,
1.2592898607,
0.2962660789,
0.2750343084,
0.4584544301,
-0.1737341881,
-0.03711918,
0.3185683489,
0.423517406,
0.6522631645,
-0.2057590783,
-0.4560101628,
-0.2328300625,
0.145227015,
0.3653137982,
-0.6854129434,
-0.1672578603,
0.4275584221,
-0.4953952432,
0.0934718028,
0.1374403238,
-0.5656379461,
-0.3027534485,
-0.3561076224,
0.636709094,
-0.9266937375,
-0.2008325607,
0.1736554205,
-0.6360542178,
0.609480679,
0.25184533,
-1.0682076216,
-0.0121631194,
0.7850936055,
0.5034646988,
-0.1138764769,
-0.1425837874,
-0.5705866218,
0.1687656492,
-0.2980432808,
1.0567649603,
-0.7769923806,
-0.5827610493,
-0.3497479558,
0.0987287462,
-0.0667264983,
-0.3721866608,
0.8533266187,
-1.1201244593,
0.3332668543,
-0.558717072,
-0.6608636975,
-0.3109541833,
0.2643512785,
-0.5979966521,
0.8982797265,
0.1444968134,
-0.6493193507,
0.6023511887,
-0.8725178838,
-0.7637742162,
0.0792547613,
-0.1762028486,
0.2361603677,
0.1208954528,
0.6851734519,
-0.0560970344,
0.0376599282,
-0.3418214321,
-0.1746333987,
-0.5552731156,
0.2178944349,
-0.2223441601,
0.9257132411,
0.2110218704,
0.1216275841,
-0.136637941,
-0.675652504,
0.4521802068,
-0.0869219378,
-0.3174586594,
-0.8039078116,
0.0492015406,
-0.2718596756,
-0.08593034,
0.4095653594,
-0.6116163731,
0.203324616,
-1.1089541912,
0.3938076198,
0.2036813647,
0.2854277492,
0.5380482674,
-0.3367373347,
0.1080576703,
-0.0871922001,
-0.222175777,
-0.466581732,
-0.7564163804,
-0.6149452329,
-0.3306913376,
0.4305636883,
0.5917999148,
-0.7031770945,
0.583815217,
-0.4025077224,
-0.1741011292,
-0.9638839364,
-0.4214557707,
-0.2456903905,
0.8505809307,
0.5025637746,
-0.1599179506,
-0.4958254397,
-0.7998041511,
-0.632837832,
-0.0191662963,
-0.3320767283,
0.1965006292,
0.0507477149,
-0.1261402667,
0.8033158183,
-0.6921530366,
-0.3043282032,
0.3390936553,
0.4189714193,
0.3555387557,
0.4922211468,
0.2767982185,
-0.8531312346,
0.1261926889,
-0.0557408482,
-0.929766655,
-0.2741540968,
-0.0670428276,
-0.4056810439,
0.0704500303,
0.5121725202,
-0.8666129112,
0.3167721927,
-0.2649395168,
-0.2625996768,
0.109327659,
-0.3465782702,
0.7574739456,
-0.7404090762,
-0.0179600045,
-0.4073428214,
-0.0398549438,
-0.1935667694,
0.2205573618,
0.1486694813,
-0.1314027607,
0.1157051474,
0.2454396039,
-0.7541066408,
-0.0797542408,
-0.6440787315,
0.2163863629,
0.1944479197,
0.4278692901,
-0.0349980034,
0.7208473086,
0.6645803452,
-0.5281802416,
0.1596251875,
0.5277258158,
-0.1131278276,
0.9109696746,
-0.4312345386,
0.3009709418,
-0.6299978495,
0.017034784,
-1.4425845146,
-0.3676146567,
-0.0224994794,
-0.9545004368,
0.3064625263,
-0.0436174497,
-0.4507116675,
-0.1785738021,
-0.1629747152,
0.2655594349,
0.5446414948,
-0.629406929,
0.7258473039,
0.6062694192,
-0.0117010474,
-0.5725842118,
-1.0453276634,
0.1908330172,
0.1018114388,
-0.8521128893,
0.7042973638,
0.2264704108,
0.1443551332,
0.1807653755,
-0.1472180784,
-0.0820642635,
-0.0668012798,
0.2453494221,
0.1973553002,
-0.046263732,
0.2204250991,
0.6016375422,
-0.0932190418,
0.3980307877,
-0.5358992815,
0.4148038924,
0.1277469397,
-0.5381768942,
-0.2402156293,
0.6156828403,
0.5747147799,
-0.5473228693,
0.4119939208,
0.5443287492,
-0.7728947997,
0.0789773092,
-0.611184299,
-0.8407009244,
-0.5125595927,
0.1571618319,
-0.5625501275,
-0.6827432513,
0.4317454696,
-0.2030590326,
-0.2674313486,
0.4649028778,
0.3908787668,
-0.3721665144,
1.5192551613,
0.2524636984,
0.2431207597,
0.4453867972,
-0.258972317,
0.1059361026,
-0.8828954697,
-0.5246921182,
-0.522284627,
-0.5492489338,
-0.3602973819,
-0.1641258746,
0.579534173,
-0.0647534281,
0.2934843898,
0.1266081333,
-0.8858271241,
0.3790340424,
0.574557066,
0.6926234365,
0.3517205119,
0.3833232224,
-0.2935561538,
-0.2002863735,
-0.636490643,
0.069734104,
1.0852977037,
-0.3082305491,
0.673317194,
-0.0972916931,
0.5503886342,
0.3524205387,
0.1344912499,
-0.9509334564,
0.5509881377,
0.2664033175,
-0.5279365778,
-0.143096596,
-0.2002609372,
-1.3269999027,
0.4331850708,
-0.5564850569,
-0.8794984221,
0.4667111635,
-0.2490043491,
-0.3514487147,
-0.325658381,
-0.793025136,
0.587973237,
-0.219882071,
-0.4217803776,
-0.5645884275,
-0.7313144207,
0.310403645,
0.092859298,
-0.1241113842,
0.1710684001,
-0.3129344881,
0.7219290733,
-0.4127086699,
0.1708424836,
-0.2527271211,
0.3024297357,
0.2036580592,
-0.330304563,
0.4284251332,
0.0004022247,
-0.5513191223,
-0.0191029534,
0.1239295676,
-0.3472919762,
-1.0457429886,
1.0204921961,
-0.387761265,
-0.7924312353,
-0.2501410246,
-0.6997402906,
-0.4636320472,
0.5321930051,
0.2619463801,
0.3887122571,
0.2387104332,
0.1632908583,
0.6866585016,
0.0708955377,
0.3466068208,
0.4466640055,
-0.0672080368,
-0.4153584242,
0.801199913,
0.3206860721,
-0.3966852725,
0.647390604,
-0.2859913409,
-0.8272448182,
-0.7189496756,
-0.1365160346,
0.1884871423,
-0.8029519916,
-0.0532462746,
-0.9383200407,
-0.0184234995,
-0.3575814664,
0.0760419667,
0.2657518089,
-0.5725753903,
-0.0777493566,
-0.2014630884,
0.4101522863,
-0.1127560735,
-0.1024126858,
0.4748280048,
-0.8212845325,
0.5471925139,
0.1217262521,
0.1864891201,
-0.2261593938,
-0.1818968207,
-0.1296545565,
0.2154923528,
-0.1178467423,
-1.4090070724,
0.3872250021,
0.1663096994,
0.912063539,
0.2474066764,
0.17508775,
0.7747098804,
-0.1723192483,
0.6786573529,
0.0059655691,
-0.5366911292,
0.8918437362,
-0.4604187012,
0.4902023375,
0.7570702434,
0.4158383608,
-0.0488951281,
-0.2695983052,
-0.4742974043,
-1.1324466467,
0.6896797419,
0.0788194984,
0.1110175475,
-0.4437918961,
0.7031882405,
-0.0518886112,
0.0613907501,
0.0109815374,
-0.2433373034,
-0.1564502567,
-0.134842366,
0.6357306838,
-0.0110308537,
-0.2238349766,
-0.5339249372,
0.4806983471,
-0.1853318959,
0.6210838556,
0.4705172479,
-0.3115081489,
0.0888505429,
-0.1002688706,
0.1378974169,
0.6053298116,
-0.4058166742,
-0.1596855521,
0.2710550427,
-0.562984705,
-0.08434847,
0.4212388098,
-0.2133563757,
-0.0310707819,
-0.1468505114,
0.7107269764,
-0.1515274495,
-0.6324548721,
0.3564548492,
-0.1669424325,
0.0042221514,
-0.0520111211,
0.1815552562,
0.067967169,
0.1539130062,
0.8282700777,
0.2608393133,
0.7361270785,
-0.3188115358,
0.5180362463,
0.7956004739,
-0.1834195405,
0.1832703054,
1.0342180729,
0.1346598566,
-0.2341374159,
1.0286297798,
-0.0174176209,
0.0227603633,
0.4359390438,
0.4534185231,
0.7255757451,
0.1382990181,
-0.3645255864,
0.4319199324,
0.4862506688,
-0.0105291437,
0.6538837552,
-0.3477970958,
-0.6111167073,
-0.8005065918,
-0.5264893174,
-0.2122135907,
0.0884583816,
-0.7464582324,
0.3270701468,
-0.2104527205,
-0.6736837626,
0.1929178685,
-0.2403134406,
-0.4514605403,
0.6065896749,
0.0075809732,
0.9031278491,
-0.2670461535,
0.8356601596,
0.9689728022,
-0.6815921068,
-0.4334889948,
0.0886573717,
-0.4532740712,
-0.8762601614,
0.630371809,
0.1910631508,
-0.2292090505,
0.4657874703,
-0.4227927625,
-0.6727602482,
0.9245737791,
0.484570384,
-0.043637678,
-0.1781447381,
-0.0746689439,
0.4363109171,
-0.1875389069,
0.7734251022,
0.5735414624,
0.7640032768,
-0.0609691702,
-0.3640547693,
0.2675958872,
-0.3465492725,
-0.0691414401,
0.2296984941,
-0.1622773558,
0.2663167119,
-0.160938248,
-0.397990793,
-0.0717455447,
1.0857325792,
0.0292081088,
0.4542600513,
0.4066531062,
0.7833583951,
1.0097775459,
-0.5177924633,
1.1834481955,
-0.8731953502,
-0.0741047412,
0.6291289926,
0.1462170184,
0.8323651552,
0.6368016601,
0.1285280138,
0.4110819399,
0.8052346706,
0.1649945676,
0.655353725,
-0.1545402259,
-0.2319567502,
-0.2884891033,
0.0574681908,
-0.513987422,
0.5371710062,
1.0148314238,
-0.2316989601,
-0.371727705,
0.1713364571,
-0.264185816,
0.0318726562,
-0.3902844787,
0.8231462836,
-0.0065900804,
-1.2244461775,
0.9387574792,
0.0331709236,
0.6236030459,
-0.6846778989,
-0.1052059457,
-0.2298055291,
-0.2604690492,
-0.5561867952,
-0.7389732599,
0.6075300574,
-0.5734317303,
-0.2725869715,
-0.022118574,
1.1973177195,
-0.4135207236,
-0.1743936539,
0.130652532,
0.5308660865,
0.3349679112,
-0.4510850608,
-0.5558894277,
-0.0930711329,
-0.3179637492,
-0.1301639229,
0.3419037163,
0.362598747,
0.0157073624,
0.4862993956,
0.9655339718,
-0.0666511282,
0.0882370919,
-0.1596512645,
0.9299241304,
-0.7558515072,
-0.7291250229,
-0.5728581548,
0.3592467904,
-0.3524538577,
0.1314755082,
0.8193123937,
0.44995296,
0.598375082,
-0.1190125123,
0.8245583773,
-0.1023723334,
0.1842450202,
-0.5826773047,
0.9864292145,
-0.7409086823,
0.1937006265,
0.24444139,
-0.8891579509,
-0.2171782553,
0.5747963786,
-0.5202847719,
0.1118055657,
0.8228290677,
1.215200901,
0.0265435819,
0.3690206409,
0.3073598444,
0.0021153891,
-0.2534869015,
0.3939078152,
0.7582876682,
-0.4736241996,
0.4525094628,
0.1171782762,
-0.2596073151,
-0.3448573351,
-0.6013891697,
-0.4876026213,
-0.5423772931,
-0.2930349112,
-0.5768885612,
0.2733450234,
0.5974744558,
0.7446562052,
-0.4988500476,
0.1995215118,
-0.0723637938,
0.2995738089,
-0.6258954406,
-0.308273226,
0.3257860243,
-0.7221217752,
-0.8952135444,
0.9082943201,
0.3373675644,
-0.4711720347,
-0.0079188375,
0.3079129159,
-0.3487102985,
0.2792344987,
0.5972821712,
0.2447942793,
-0.4983350933,
-0.1024675891,
0.1285656095,
-0.1655900031,
0.2315479368,
0.5227108598,
-1.313087821,
0.5799233913,
1.1091445684,
1.0765904188,
0.7311793566,
0.1942583025,
0.5797524452,
-0.7120790482,
-0.0000120994,
0.1124122664,
0.3428492546,
0.4337586462,
-0.7560290694,
0.3899736404,
0.260605514,
-0.3790521026,
-0.6218859553,
0.0915721506,
-1.3188574314,
-0.3347441256,
0.8800777197,
0.3098591566,
-0.67504251,
-0.0897630975,
-0.3822952211,
0.2060421109,
-0.4560140371,
0.6721408367,
0.6388573647,
-0.5613560081,
-0.1310814023,
-0.4527147412,
0.3287149966,
0.6460621953,
-0.7648258209,
-0.5307835937,
0.7740963697,
0.2094780505,
0.2367762476,
0.7083038092,
-0.4629958272,
0.4932923019,
0.2422209233,
-0.2965532541,
-0.2524493337,
0.2043391168,
-0.1773519069,
0.6658892035,
0.0348782577,
-0.5196228623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15700v1
|
CoRelation: Boosting Automatic ICD Coding Through Contextualized Code Relation Learning
| 2024-02-24T03:25:28 | 2024-02-24T03:25:28 |
Junyu Luo, Xiaochen Wang, Jiaqi Wang, Aofei Chang, Yaqing Wang, Fenglong Ma
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Automatic International Classification of Diseases (ICD) coding plays a
crucial role in the extraction of relevant information from clinical notes for
proper recording and billing. One of the most important directions for boosting
the performance of automatic ICD coding is modeling ICD code relations.
However, current methods insufficiently model the intricate relationships among
ICD codes and often overlook the importance of context in clinical notes. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach, a contextualized and flexible
framework, to enhance the learning of ICD code representations. Our approach,
unlike existing methods, employs a dependent learning paradigm that considers
the context of clinical notes in modeling all possible code relations. We
evaluate our approach on six public ICD coding datasets and the experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach compared to
state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.0718345717,
-0.1548913419,
0.3314692974,
0.1998342574,
-0.4958276153,
-0.0855494961,
-0.2279578894,
-0.5675265789,
0.1782017499,
0.3129597902,
-0.1612705588,
-0.8381890655,
-0.4060170054,
0.1233702675,
-0.0009017815,
1.2243033648,
-0.1506469101,
0.4523678422,
-0.3924141526,
-0.372767359,
-0.4429726303,
-0.8198106885,
-0.2896144986,
-0.3280160129,
0.2392107993,
0.4502476156,
0.2037391812,
0.9484373331,
0.711841464,
0.0936356336,
0.0947592333,
0.0475830287,
0.0947142318,
0.0794823989,
-0.148083806,
-0.3498511314,
-0.7294557095,
-0.3261235952,
0.3485657871,
0.8090990782,
-0.0621410124,
0.1323984563,
-0.0557605959,
0.4920956492,
-0.4391893446,
0.5446517467,
-0.3021047115,
-0.0166948214,
-0.0237754975,
-0.5555087328,
-0.4728354812,
-0.0366701297,
0.1245839894,
-0.332724005,
0.2849749029,
-0.2618047297,
0.527751863,
0.1709476262,
-0.646759212,
-0.6984293461,
-0.6347787976,
0.1931218803,
-0.4470663071,
0.2367550582,
0.3183607459,
0.3400796652,
0.3268467188,
-0.773216784,
-0.1385876685,
-0.1287347525,
-0.4000688791,
0.0438135937,
0.2676828802,
-0.0042440896,
0.2299187779,
0.4511145949,
-0.2024659067,
-0.2374015152,
-0.4141491055,
0.1032733843,
0.6575978994,
0.0980130583,
0.7396812439,
-0.3182475567,
-0.2480476648,
0.1358393431,
-0.8036668897,
0.1212630421,
-0.4830439389,
0.2940434217,
-0.6726151705,
0.0980418101,
0.0088035287,
0.5486598015,
0.5595790744,
-0.6231142879,
0.5536081791,
-0.1450144649,
-0.1424054056,
0.4406197965,
0.238999933,
0.3531350493,
-0.3215816915,
-0.3266986609,
-0.1284353137,
-0.0606640652,
0.4558609426,
-0.59642452,
-0.4060624838,
0.0728953555,
-0.6110991836,
-0.1837562323,
-0.0142635591,
-0.4753319025,
-0.0916711167,
-0.5952817202,
-0.0330193415,
-0.4377368093,
-0.0838766471,
-0.1003561243,
0.2231668234,
-0.0468087308,
0.3310942352,
-0.8288343549,
0.2838489115,
0.4007467628,
0.6373236775,
-0.2831615508,
0.0376536474,
-0.5293079019,
0.4941798151,
-0.1356522888,
0.6977831125,
-0.6070036292,
-0.6239615083,
-0.0271068942,
-0.0663385242,
0.0265808497,
-0.6579497457,
0.6459777951,
-0.4958719611,
-0.2831737995,
-0.080156669,
-0.4206689298,
0.0325935036,
0.2668626606,
-0.9106391072,
0.6105555296,
0.4755043983,
-0.9845752716,
0.3929837644,
-0.5383673906,
-0.9480031729,
0.2516064346,
-0.5733953118,
-0.4050027728,
-0.0340175517,
0.4238505065,
0.5625844598,
-0.1392885745,
0.7609031796,
-0.0406595655,
-0.0630019903,
-0.1435802579,
0.1609568447,
0.772959888,
0.2924010456,
-0.4259145856,
0.2264400721,
-1.0164330006,
-0.3389652073,
-0.2823491991,
-0.5042411685,
-0.54487288,
-0.0157143343,
0.1619566828,
0.2866463065,
-0.2541262805,
-0.2357589304,
0.4408400357,
-0.4068471491,
0.2899054885,
0.314771384,
0.3726638258,
0.6368562579,
-0.3946637213,
0.5919238329,
0.313470453,
-0.0756710693,
-0.5139632225,
-0.2569855154,
-0.3344179094,
-0.2668732107,
0.2938100994,
0.4299193025,
-0.8616705537,
0.4489888847,
-0.5162547231,
-0.2413746566,
-0.2119569182,
0.0935088769,
0.596706748,
0.9823326468,
0.5599304438,
-0.5195838809,
-0.6018691659,
-0.5795545578,
0.0920506567,
-0.174012959,
-0.1130388007,
0.6074655056,
0.3284854293,
-0.5093254447,
1.0479636192,
-0.457498163,
-0.4835897386,
-0.4267196357,
0.0585044138,
0.0920310542,
1.0807442665,
0.7109150887,
-0.8073500991,
-0.6824889183,
0.2144978344,
-0.562944293,
0.0181625467,
-0.2023118734,
0.134551093,
-0.1732543707,
0.5722224116,
-0.1331758201,
0.5440644026,
0.2252197713,
-0.0960252061,
0.3966057301,
-0.4476777315,
0.1033195928,
-1.0243701935,
0.4067239761,
0.0983616784,
-0.3287506402,
-0.7323616743,
0.1875968874,
0.6080553532,
-0.178666845,
-0.47306633,
0.5591159463,
-0.4261968732,
0.0330705345,
0.0790074393,
-0.1270058751,
0.0570520312,
0.3992972672,
0.2884261608,
0.5948851109,
0.6206927896,
-0.8126762509,
0.1225119531,
0.1664730012,
-0.233529374,
0.5757768154,
-0.4656593204,
-0.1771724373,
-0.2170949578,
0.6491638422,
-0.5097541809,
-0.4276933074,
0.188661322,
-0.4207003117,
0.7059571743,
-0.4440370202,
-0.3613626361,
-0.0937193483,
0.1496973187,
1.064863205,
0.4828031063,
-0.8161014915,
0.6045426726,
0.624345541,
0.0552191027,
-0.2932908237,
-0.5374385118,
-0.0951192528,
-0.2165374309,
-0.3001473248,
0.7165658474,
-0.0379634947,
-0.2102550566,
-0.1640070528,
-0.2777662873,
-0.2350032926,
0.170811668,
0.3381085098,
0.2137204707,
-0.2926245928,
0.3605032563,
0.1445338726,
-0.2102165073,
0.0781531855,
-0.4013222754,
0.1909025908,
0.1647982448,
-0.3694880307,
-0.4830819666,
0.454264462,
0.5097022653,
-0.4333094358,
0.2838805616,
0.2335828692,
-0.8139397502,
-0.3984243572,
-0.1343303621,
-0.0491542108,
-0.4019909799,
0.2662939131,
-0.2725049853,
-0.6016565561,
0.5325568914,
-0.101072304,
-0.3011911213,
0.3020452261,
0.4175228775,
0.2090005875,
1.1987971067,
0.9336404204,
-0.2852008343,
0.1460744441,
-0.2138611674,
0.1009030119,
-1.1241322756,
-0.3832212687,
-0.539593339,
0.2115107775,
-0.2342119962,
-0.4795390666,
0.6741550565,
0.2598650455,
-0.1062162444,
0.004532564,
-0.5440506935,
0.3859727085,
0.0358187482,
0.2987417579,
0.3732977808,
0.0455272421,
-0.4026457965,
0.0945089683,
-0.9001274109,
-0.284502238,
1.297639966,
0.2361353636,
0.7495138645,
-0.1077045724,
0.5461371541,
0.409922421,
0.9187346697,
-0.5282265544,
0.0159214903,
-0.0872776061,
-0.3295398057,
0.4232129157,
-0.2680203319,
-0.6900697351,
-0.1710282564,
0.0520594716,
-0.7575103045,
0.4264271557,
0.5995605588,
-0.4919577837,
0.1885796636,
-0.5562875271,
0.7745043039,
-0.3194631338,
-0.300124228,
-0.0940723494,
-0.8182344437,
0.308714956,
0.1969720125,
0.3734144866,
0.2663324773,
0.0637202188,
0.6467393637,
-0.2986582518,
0.9999064803,
0.1335618645,
-0.297395885,
0.0705472305,
-0.0256677121,
0.2259680331,
0.7996735573,
0.2254151255,
-0.1502055973,
-0.1062825695,
-0.4807238579,
-0.4285632074,
0.9061754346,
-0.6818117499,
-0.1987532079,
-0.3508583307,
-0.3513325453,
-0.3759810925,
0.300619781,
0.2331892699,
1.2684568167,
-0.0266787913,
-0.0761785358,
0.6896814704,
-0.1968690604,
0.1577924639,
0.2961217463,
0.1478773057,
-0.4958341718,
0.5759151578,
-0.1493540555,
0.0532923527,
0.5682250857,
-0.1516742557,
0.04559898,
-0.4965491295,
-0.5154461861,
0.3464036584,
-1.1658192873,
-0.421307534,
-0.7349249125,
0.0669635236,
-0.6545827389,
-0.4696332812,
-0.0723285452,
-0.1645851582,
-0.4914327562,
-0.2122226655,
0.1400121599,
0.6676411629,
0.0760988891,
0.1774806678,
-0.9899163246,
0.2939371765,
0.1039681956,
0.7113864422,
0.2433470786,
-0.0464869589,
-0.7087225914,
-0.1017421633,
-0.1301889718,
-0.9553194046,
0.2853681743,
0.1388518959,
0.7107941508,
0.7084891796,
0.3550418615,
0.7365073562,
-0.6028751731,
0.6417079568,
0.1693912596,
-1.0559238195,
0.7140778303,
-0.2213887572,
0.3760187626,
0.5296108127,
0.5582108498,
-0.6116502881,
-0.0760568976,
-0.9067219496,
-0.8720120788,
0.7934613228,
-0.205463618,
-0.0852708817,
-0.2915604115,
0.863660574,
0.1049691141,
0.1213246733,
-0.5419565439,
-0.4400146902,
-0.0829385221,
-0.5318456292,
-0.2130235434,
-0.171364069,
-0.2967638075,
-0.4963238239,
0.3048382699,
-0.3277499676,
0.3656640947,
0.8011131287,
-0.505766809,
-0.1967066973,
-0.0385417975,
0.6303624511,
1.0079301596,
-0.1510241479,
0.3770320117,
-0.1625195891,
-0.4822009206,
-0.0370651037,
0.0080567561,
-0.2670195401,
0.0756848752,
0.532858789,
0.6427891254,
0.3972003758,
-0.856061101,
0.6010923386,
-0.0849303305,
0.0638016462,
-0.30832389,
0.0334680267,
-0.0046379878,
0.0148408208,
0.3437295854,
0.3358433843,
0.2347255051,
-0.5040688515,
0.8134459853,
0.0916126743,
-0.6990750432,
-0.5965906978,
0.7165447474,
0.572475791,
-0.2909224033,
0.2875042856,
-0.1975995302,
-0.7985029817,
0.9201198816,
0.8417831063,
0.5741256475,
-0.1344920099,
-0.0228423811,
0.5607283115,
-0.1418166012,
0.0474162996,
-0.1887866855,
-0.5846970677,
-0.4090474248,
-0.4021581411,
-0.0956596583,
-0.1115266234,
0.1496832222,
-1.1172622442,
0.4559240341,
-0.582226634,
0.0586706772,
-0.333467871,
-0.0841897056,
-0.4739245474,
0.3853654265,
0.3500412405,
0.9695311785,
-0.6377999783,
1.1668162346,
1.0056277514,
-0.2875835598,
-0.7864546776,
0.1927567571,
-0.1719292551,
-0.3148755133,
0.8040322065,
0.3849222958,
0.1320504695,
0.0858932137,
-0.1665820181,
-0.9215289354,
0.9905999303,
-0.0362024345,
-0.2167908102,
-0.0414233841,
-0.3043537438,
0.5808309913,
-1.0270072222,
0.2185332626,
0.5481110215,
-0.2864219546,
-0.1664749384,
-1.0021524429,
0.264637351,
-0.6772960424,
-0.2088608593,
0.0653090253,
-0.3601472676,
0.6011947393,
-0.2739621401,
-0.4004730284,
-0.2867182195,
0.3740360141,
0.057971552,
0.4471522272,
0.2232994139,
0.2324987501,
0.5033302307,
0.2735238671,
0.97358042,
-0.915720582,
0.4525494874,
1.1079167128,
-0.3987594247,
0.4555245936,
0.2465943396,
0.0468984246,
0.4846461117,
0.4315368533,
0.1301809847,
0.593151629,
-0.0035430677,
-0.213904053,
-0.1621324867,
0.1743661016,
-0.6823249459,
-0.1382757574,
0.6311347485,
-0.5450630188,
-0.4218165278,
0.3208371401,
-0.0474412851,
0.2234187424,
-0.4416968226,
0.8542858362,
-0.0091175772,
-0.7849089503,
0.670353055,
0.1765099168,
0.3803418875,
-0.367646426,
-0.196814537,
-0.1434685141,
0.3529677391,
-0.2537517548,
-0.0154912146,
0.3265774846,
-0.0158289112,
-0.3896446526,
-0.2365252525,
0.6358107924,
-0.5378374457,
-0.3193614185,
0.2182170153,
0.197449252,
-0.3411518335,
0.5332357883,
-0.5441743731,
-0.1327079237,
-0.0295868367,
0.3344076276,
0.5509695411,
0.3059927225,
-0.1324170381,
0.6536590457,
0.398042351,
0.0978826135,
-0.371119231,
-0.1306294352,
1.1257303953,
-0.409160018,
-1.0746575594,
-0.4935468435,
0.4521982074,
-0.0220036842,
-0.2768462002,
0.4637293518,
0.525998354,
0.9761484265,
-0.0989974961,
0.8899158239,
-0.0553088412,
0.5647571683,
-0.388220638,
0.681276083,
-0.3539114892,
0.6767830253,
-0.258048296,
-0.3257387578,
-0.8960175514,
0.5683241487,
-0.3038513064,
-0.3327063918,
0.6524765491,
0.27322644,
-0.2542921305,
-0.165768519,
-0.2143049538,
-0.0171503406,
0.4189505875,
0.4194409847,
0.2809731364,
-0.2518208325,
0.1802358329,
-0.7781941295,
-0.2074872851,
-0.4061487913,
-0.8902785778,
-0.9660090208,
-0.5888025761,
-0.5739488602,
-0.3191335797,
0.0286484156,
1.3075457811,
0.9284332991,
-0.84664464,
-0.1902368665,
-0.0842447355,
0.2198614925,
-0.3283994198,
-0.1178255677,
0.8317348361,
-0.3886849582,
-0.3468454182,
0.0365369208,
0.2765160799,
0.1014943942,
0.2533612549,
-0.1030795127,
0.0491224602,
-0.4638772011,
0.5496305227,
0.228563562,
-0.3571763039,
0.0237755235,
-0.25276196,
-0.1784126014,
0.5815601945,
1.4033904076,
-0.9529178143,
0.3130618334,
0.2831362784,
0.5922846198,
0.2844612002,
0.516671598,
0.4845151305,
-0.7962239981,
0.206369698,
0.5023337007,
0.1613430679,
0.2152730227,
-0.5401539207,
0.1431572288,
0.3397016823,
-0.3313132524,
-0.8907764554,
0.2367806584,
-0.8917601109,
-0.2163062692,
0.9599669576,
-0.4144869745,
-0.3204119802,
-0.4766705632,
-0.1886061579,
0.2106586099,
-0.2719699442,
0.7888252735,
0.0123906881,
-0.3269175291,
-0.0117959464,
-0.3082136512,
0.9366480112,
-0.0082916413,
-0.7209327221,
-0.0386224575,
0.5181379318,
0.330394268,
0.2381433398,
0.8070124984,
-0.305627197,
0.5165764689,
-0.3831403553,
0.0286253802,
0.1379359663,
-0.4417947233,
-0.4929213524,
0.2692261636,
-0.0004603979,
0.2763837576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15690v1
|
Foot In The Door: Understanding Large Language Model Jailbreaking via Cognitive Psychology
| 2024-02-24T02:27:55 | 2024-02-24T02:27:55 |
Zhenhua Wang, Wei Xie, Baosheng Wang, Enze Wang, Zhiwen Gui, Shuoyoucheng Ma, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have gradually become the gateway for people to
acquire new knowledge. However, attackers can break the model's security
protection ("jail") to access restricted information, which is called
"jailbreaking." Previous studies have shown the weakness of current LLMs when
confronted with such jailbreaking attacks. Nevertheless, comprehension of the
intrinsic decision-making mechanism within the LLMs upon receipt of jailbreak
prompts is noticeably lacking. Our research provides a psychological
explanation of the jailbreak prompts. Drawing on cognitive consistency theory,
we argue that the key to jailbreak is guiding the LLM to achieve cognitive
coordination in an erroneous direction. Further, we propose an automatic
black-box jailbreaking method based on the Foot-in-the-Door (FITD) technique.
This method progressively induces the model to answer harmful questions via
multi-step incremental prompts. We instantiated a prototype system to evaluate
the jailbreaking effectiveness on 8 advanced LLMs, yielding an average success
rate of 83.9%. This study builds a psychological perspective on the explanatory
insights into the intrinsic decision-making logic of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3933844268,
-1.1442327499,
1.0925806761,
0.0422812961,
-0.210988149,
0.3763585687,
-0.3092441857,
-0.4329638183,
0.0043246625,
0.6484567523,
-0.6161959171,
-0.2208246291,
-0.6009564996,
-0.0902742743,
-0.0658790544,
0.8262488246,
-0.0720554292,
0.1208684742,
-0.1034234688,
0.167538926,
-1.0338317156,
-0.5033017397,
-0.514750421,
-0.4654621482,
0.1497545391,
0.3990161717,
0.7427043915,
0.4477826953,
0.4881660342,
0.2451810837,
-0.1430457979,
-0.4160302281,
-0.3202281594,
-0.0898208246,
-0.2136958539,
-0.876113832,
-0.1222135723,
0.1273029298,
0.0498923846,
0.5174235106,
-0.2719671726,
-0.0988074243,
-0.0429872386,
0.8199669719,
-0.4285241961,
0.0253484342,
-0.7740039825,
-0.0312262513,
-0.1381224394,
0.0883205682,
-0.6264730096,
-0.2080489397,
-0.1254241467,
-0.0173105095,
-0.1416812241,
-0.0041186013,
0.3353253603,
0.2738607824,
-0.3214662671,
-0.3880609274,
-0.6344289184,
0.3177934289,
-0.6545295715,
0.4735155702,
0.7659549117,
0.1584433913,
-0.3271535635,
0.0597833358,
-0.5274400711,
-0.5543662906,
0.0935779512,
-0.4239007533,
0.0457100011,
0.0357896052,
0.4223720431,
0.0513889678,
-0.3622199297,
-0.1184281558,
-0.3591633737,
0.0096361097,
0.2949435115,
0.1297967285,
0.4708039165,
-0.0398987308,
-0.2240679562,
-0.1397158206,
-0.6784877181,
0.158613041,
0.2409416288,
0.1316224635,
-0.2856395841,
0.5422901511,
0.1979897916,
0.6820657849,
0.2821761072,
-0.1425352693,
0.0367936641,
0.0426589027,
-0.1745169014,
0.2930032909,
0.6696331501,
0.4286349118,
0.6078507304,
-0.4071976542,
-0.2746233642,
0.1916363388,
0.587153554,
-0.5521681309,
0.0430748947,
0.5251291394,
-0.3434739411,
-0.5271359086,
0.0108193271,
-0.5731289983,
-0.6194741726,
-0.0567244738,
0.3314483762,
-0.7426006198,
-0.2348127365,
0.2906329036,
-0.0231691618,
0.3469216526,
0.1958969533,
-0.8795906305,
0.3874271512,
0.7269678712,
1.0137053728,
0.0614518002,
-0.2419017851,
-0.4181547165,
0.2421786338,
-0.4560274184,
0.413738817,
-0.4506489336,
-0.3850568235,
-0.2125451863,
-0.0911761895,
0.0653607994,
-0.5803670287,
0.1387881637,
-0.563064456,
-0.4266186357,
-0.0648140535,
-0.4162127376,
-0.077997297,
0.5010234118,
-0.46200037,
0.5249965787,
-0.0889214575,
-0.3760102689,
0.2821290493,
-0.3282806575,
-0.3900432587,
-0.0969781578,
-0.1390608102,
-0.1375734806,
0.3277873099,
0.1062037721,
0.3138317466,
-0.3162764907,
0.5067486763,
-0.5695176125,
-0.0619707629,
0.6100775003,
-0.2622001767,
1.0990372896,
0.3443087339,
-0.5560312271,
-0.1993130893,
-0.4610258639,
-0.2724246681,
0.4504654706,
-0.2573003173,
-0.5787849426,
0.0863795206,
-0.391415298,
0.3043199182,
0.2898492217,
-0.7606164217,
0.2720721662,
-0.2529005408,
0.4953263104,
0.9971632957,
-0.0005929146,
0.4085513055,
-0.2432280779,
0.41150859,
-0.069105804,
0.366201818,
-0.1261469573,
-0.269901365,
-0.2977988124,
-0.0168388262,
-0.0843006968,
0.6897643805,
-0.4528347254,
0.3512392044,
0.1004383713,
-0.6293424368,
-0.3372695148,
0.3648579419,
0.4982204139,
0.2527858615,
0.1193495169,
-0.2425014228,
-0.1026806161,
-0.6265285015,
-0.3194760978,
-0.5053067207,
0.2497967035,
0.1920356303,
0.6647577286,
-0.1611652672,
0.733886838,
-0.5450322628,
-0.1491643041,
-0.2908293307,
-0.2917954624,
0.5440037251,
0.5944753289,
0.3601889014,
-0.5660762787,
-0.188514486,
-0.2497200519,
-1.0377472639,
0.0617046505,
-0.3217270672,
-0.1683545262,
-0.147940129,
0.8903762698,
-0.9908144474,
0.5020392537,
0.2462074012,
-0.7663902044,
0.8226318359,
-0.3140857518,
-0.0396810621,
-0.5942283869,
-0.5712468624,
-0.0077051139,
0.0003504019,
-0.5539984107,
0.4463151395,
0.2653361857,
-0.0754626989,
-0.2389288396,
0.2545808554,
-0.4786187112,
0.009962461,
-0.2883536518,
0.1802509278,
-0.3826844096,
0.3684893548,
-0.0850079134,
0.4469780028,
0.4627062082,
-0.4084609449,
0.4511577487,
0.1969719827,
-0.5731945038,
0.4777085185,
-0.5482985377,
0.2479978502,
0.0063776323,
0.2623872459,
-1.1788372993,
-0.0715786442,
0.2077477574,
-0.3342779577,
0.1853761077,
-0.191758126,
-0.5725916028,
-0.3258964419,
-0.1754928976,
0.5510497689,
0.4423963428,
-0.5802916288,
0.5445734262,
0.4360592663,
-0.1599466801,
-0.0676613599,
-0.4600095451,
0.313826859,
-0.1984777153,
-0.8262944221,
-0.0569246709,
-0.2264383882,
-0.8553296924,
-0.4272872508,
-0.2003270984,
0.2524638772,
0.3744279742,
0.2675466537,
0.4135337174,
0.004253455,
-0.0674000755,
-0.3643129468,
0.0010397619,
0.6270481348,
-0.3250034153,
0.7399358153,
-0.1230405048,
-0.394679606,
-0.2572725415,
0.049625583,
0.8618677258,
-0.2798814774,
0.92742908,
-0.2376989573,
-0.2445370257,
-0.0665548891,
-0.7536062598,
-0.3546017706,
-0.4749376178,
0.0076488173,
-0.5041869283,
-0.6710107327,
0.4501287639,
-0.231614545,
-0.0944876075,
-0.3258203566,
0.4563112855,
-0.1815125793,
0.9287242889,
0.8132189512,
-0.273601532,
0.5804433823,
0.1482379586,
0.2310928702,
-0.8984130621,
-0.3099041879,
-0.4757641256,
-0.2697925568,
-0.2783065736,
-0.299062103,
0.1866667271,
0.4049536586,
-0.5102863908,
0.3530164063,
-0.3931198418,
0.4825855792,
0.1793887615,
0.4233035147,
0.2959538102,
-0.2829950154,
-0.436667949,
0.2200442106,
-0.3135088682,
-0.4532934427,
1.1497286558,
0.4913484752,
1.0521656275,
0.2915979922,
0.6687498689,
0.2327943593,
0.3169240654,
-0.7970573306,
0.6756549478,
0.4006411731,
-0.6166251302,
-0.1923559308,
-0.1140654609,
-0.7714079022,
0.2065774798,
-0.1672241688,
-1.3168865442,
0.1157275066,
-0.0577058643,
-0.2158584297,
0.413728714,
-0.7117243409,
0.6814619899,
-0.756162405,
-0.3916834295,
-0.3887058198,
-0.7831417322,
0.6980265379,
-0.4254553318,
0.7341805696,
-0.0225150641,
0.2144218236,
0.6492600441,
-0.7414087653,
0.9618584514,
-0.3600518405,
-0.2947551608,
0.0506366156,
0.4607756138,
0.9177911878,
-0.0042086462,
-0.0251879022,
0.0771415383,
-0.2139902562,
-0.2709871829,
-0.6477370858,
0.3507064283,
-0.6309894919,
-0.8948805332,
-0.361651659,
-0.4255788028,
-0.4467576444,
-0.0391273052,
0.1050769538,
0.1623442322,
-0.1165902689,
0.041437272,
0.7612450123,
-0.2818678021,
0.3992818296,
0.6427199841,
-0.6289373636,
-0.2406645715,
0.4694494903,
-0.1418293566,
0.4089669585,
0.1397323906,
0.3952442408,
-0.0326205753,
-0.7135725617,
-0.3040329218,
0.452996552,
-0.4873293638,
0.0629408062,
-0.3813191056,
-0.0170283783,
-0.2360177934,
-0.4714346528,
-0.2042509466,
0.1905712485,
0.4334741533,
-0.4151515365,
0.2662178874,
0.9044510126,
0.086715512,
0.4929473698,
-0.8155008554,
0.4468996227,
0.1467076093,
0.2735402584,
0.3598353565,
-0.3499677181,
-0.3694551885,
-0.0564361289,
-0.2112966627,
-1.3083702326,
0.0355481319,
-0.5355936885,
0.4172160923,
0.5349783301,
0.1474356055,
0.4147181809,
-0.5531556606,
0.5764483213,
0.4009705186,
-0.9095862508,
0.7917100787,
-0.5131373405,
0.205299139,
0.4609951079,
-0.0318534747,
-0.5617132783,
-0.7208548188,
-0.6363752484,
-0.7934072614,
0.6723145843,
-0.0580362827,
0.0835956931,
-0.2091451883,
0.332982868,
-0.0141841164,
0.2108182907,
-0.8553460836,
-0.1513084322,
0.0908106267,
-0.0547492392,
-0.2378140688,
-0.0782747045,
-0.2105468363,
-0.2277560681,
0.5108332634,
0.0495783277,
0.004488755,
0.0354619473,
-0.4014190137,
-0.136209473,
0.3684899211,
0.354896903,
0.6328468323,
-0.2925675511,
-0.1183246523,
0.05776041,
-0.6609669328,
0.5900521278,
-0.4117906094,
-0.2739845514,
-0.4105613232,
0.3162316084,
0.7804521918,
0.0313103274,
-0.824454248,
0.5403707623,
-0.0437005647,
-0.0759257972,
-0.3850097954,
0.2443511933,
-0.0410074145,
0.5139718652,
0.3444903791,
0.0344032273,
-0.3093141615,
-0.9861313105,
0.2928288579,
0.7719265819,
-0.3780806661,
-0.0626230836,
0.666790247,
0.0662219152,
-0.6695125103,
0.9408265352,
0.0828847811,
-0.4929111004,
0.6324025393,
0.7906019092,
0.9954453111,
-0.0587404668,
0.2784141004,
0.1041897163,
0.8283475637,
-0.2319863439,
0.1194061786,
-0.1526969224,
-1.0754774809,
-0.3759606481,
-0.5652604103,
-0.3500858247,
0.2221339941,
-0.7227156162,
0.0547926016,
-0.8806895614,
-0.1973885745,
-0.3641480207,
-0.358573854,
-0.3755016625,
0.3275226951,
0.236518383,
1.2340023518,
-0.6190333366,
0.8404108882,
0.5975871086,
-0.1914404482,
-0.90290308,
0.3056969047,
0.2754438221,
-0.8905566931,
0.6228500605,
0.1570645571,
-0.0453366563,
-0.252387315,
-0.8167363405,
-0.5921376348,
0.6301409006,
0.4982630312,
-0.7557257414,
-0.0384170897,
-0.0314207375,
0.1750227213,
-0.383665204,
0.0909898281,
1.034657836,
0.7500892878,
-0.2501946986,
-0.6408081651,
0.3919991851,
-0.1689824909,
-0.3770928681,
0.669272244,
-0.6776378751,
0.6245907545,
-0.8235949278,
0.2691078484,
0.0809556618,
0.154774338,
0.4579693079,
0.2269511521,
0.6635366678,
0.7382495403,
0.7784551382,
-0.1609822959,
1.0571628809,
-0.3718481064,
-0.0020055231,
1.0199798346,
-0.2330484986,
0.8388403654,
0.7068997025,
-0.1940521896,
0.5882942677,
0.4122737944,
-0.018356856,
0.5736868382,
0.310762614,
-0.2610405087,
-0.3395037949,
0.302541852,
0.0045991847,
0.6825992465,
0.521101594,
-0.275285542,
-0.1276829392,
0.3821978569,
0.1576599032,
-0.0909409523,
-0.5263325572,
0.9944079518,
0.2902619839,
-0.7123906612,
0.5275092125,
0.0740070343,
0.4210994542,
-0.7425774932,
0.1976340413,
0.0584940575,
0.1366878152,
-0.1607719809,
-0.9451351166,
-0.0261664949,
0.2646169662,
-0.2167541981,
-0.2438009232,
0.5377566814,
-0.0415565073,
-0.1506341398,
0.7788563371,
0.5400774479,
0.1750221103,
-0.2556177378,
-0.7222582698,
0.2706658542,
0.0902969018,
-0.2437524945,
0.6874400377,
0.4621934891,
-0.0944422036,
0.7893357277,
0.8357893825,
0.2698501945,
-0.1580245942,
-0.2056779861,
0.6950320005,
-1.0900233984,
-0.5953074694,
-1.3713428974,
0.3718546033,
0.0612720512,
-0.0552191921,
0.6509580612,
0.2408228219,
0.8530186415,
0.0862462819,
0.9496209025,
-0.0884518996,
-0.0846125558,
-0.7849003673,
0.6229662299,
-0.2695391774,
0.7005847096,
-0.477153331,
-0.8844591975,
0.1789623797,
0.7650969625,
-0.5602991581,
-0.110808529,
0.8858060837,
0.6701875329,
0.2314762324,
0.0949631259,
0.3312226236,
0.5819996595,
0.3337694407,
0.6801610589,
0.8143026829,
-0.0248107165,
0.6096372604,
-0.1588917673,
-0.4300000072,
-0.0287696905,
-0.5589844584,
-0.8805440068,
-0.2959589362,
-0.0681961104,
-0.6656960249,
0.0798249319,
0.9351585507,
0.4480648935,
-0.5210222602,
-0.6025622487,
-0.2834582627,
0.3123318553,
-0.2252681255,
-0.2495710999,
-0.0787365809,
-0.4183913171,
-0.1228509024,
0.5116881132,
0.5541263819,
-0.1296548843,
-0.1894358546,
-0.2275481522,
-0.2056385279,
0.2295572609,
0.4092565179,
0.1498865485,
-0.5806771517,
-0.2671659589,
-0.3977007568,
-0.1111482382,
0.1318431199,
0.9134623408,
-0.8441690803,
0.343611449,
0.2389691174,
0.7005497217,
0.2960589826,
-0.034153387,
0.7547307611,
-0.3957872093,
0.0614510961,
-0.1142015085,
0.4728932977,
0.1344027966,
-0.5026270747,
0.4466650188,
0.2947501838,
-0.6052384973,
-0.618132174,
0.4345339537,
-0.623197794,
-0.7346562743,
1.0770379305,
0.0938724726,
-0.5287934542,
-0.3634369075,
-0.4030815363,
-0.0867413953,
-0.5691873431,
0.8548036218,
1.0439225435,
0.002794493,
-0.2584960163,
-0.6711677909,
0.2950534821,
0.1871339679,
-0.6057090759,
0.3836918473,
0.4750840068,
0.4117357731,
0.2151768506,
0.6800260544,
-0.1071908176,
0.292152524,
0.0321402512,
-0.1557884663,
0.0017821549,
-0.2761579156,
-0.3466370702,
0.187168017,
0.1581003666,
0.1486810893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15663v1
|
Leveraging ChatGPT in Pharmacovigilance Event Extraction: An Empirical Study
| 2024-02-24T00:38:29 | 2024-02-24T00:38:29 |
Zhaoyue Sun, Gabriele Pergola, Byron C. Wallace, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advent of large language models (LLMs), there has been growing
interest in exploring their potential for medical applications. This research
aims to investigate the ability of LLMs, specifically ChatGPT, in the context
of pharmacovigilance event extraction, of which the main goal is to identify
and extract adverse events or potential therapeutic events from textual medical
sources. We conduct extensive experiments to assess the performance of ChatGPT
in the pharmacovigilance event extraction task, employing various prompts and
demonstration selection strategies. The findings demonstrate that while ChatGPT
demonstrates reasonable performance with appropriate demonstration selection
strategies, it still falls short compared to fully fine-tuned small models.
Additionally, we explore the potential of leveraging ChatGPT for data
augmentation. However, our investigation reveals that the inclusion of
synthesized data into fine-tuning may lead to a decrease in performance,
possibly attributed to noise in the ChatGPT-generated labels. To mitigate this,
we explore different filtering strategies and find that, with the proper
approach, more stable performance can be achieved, although constant
improvement remains elusive.
|
[
-0.0343990028,
-0.8533471823,
0.7647535801,
0.0366780199,
-0.4673214257,
-0.0165104158,
-0.4246613979,
-0.8002570868,
0.0775566027,
0.4549941123,
-0.4394741356,
-0.5136377215,
-0.7260524035,
-0.0488482192,
-0.3022598326,
1.2621687651,
0.1279861778,
0.1554763615,
0.1430734098,
0.2887012959,
-0.5682633519,
-0.7805957198,
-0.8945713639,
-0.6424302459,
0.6081345081,
0.3433098495,
0.3521049619,
0.3793191314,
0.8847503066,
0.0997550637,
-0.2883749902,
0.1514743716,
-0.564084053,
0.185419634,
0.0927473679,
-0.2999246418,
-0.5132309794,
-0.0011304449,
0.5717688799,
0.4055236876,
-0.3865575194,
-0.030384168,
0.2824434936,
0.4483605921,
-0.5496508479,
0.465092361,
-0.5057738423,
0.2176317126,
-0.138855949,
-0.1998402178,
-0.3353930116,
-0.3078385293,
0.6105157733,
-0.5137856007,
0.0629705787,
0.1619823873,
0.7815221548,
0.0705740005,
-0.1734129936,
-0.3191135824,
-0.6620907187,
0.4575508535,
-0.8040118814,
0.3438020349,
0.2278414965,
0.2994842529,
-0.4614820182,
-1.0746201277,
-0.3414239883,
-0.4527873099,
-0.1455901861,
0.2899353504,
-0.2108153403,
0.3150347471,
0.3084161878,
0.4576726854,
-0.5388427973,
0.2846707702,
-0.4257495403,
-0.3623602092,
0.2611875832,
0.2769755423,
0.4133303165,
-0.2343884557,
-0.3985155523,
0.0300277211,
-0.8292967677,
-0.0782662034,
-0.1503713578,
0.3208821118,
-0.0424307697,
0.7875252962,
-0.015015956,
0.3863116205,
-0.2753127515,
-0.0646611005,
0.0250836127,
-0.4292898476,
-0.2911046445,
0.255733043,
1.0516011715,
0.4568194449,
0.158695206,
-0.082355231,
-0.0733634979,
-0.1432245076,
0.0420447513,
-1.2287181616,
-0.8001610637,
0.2779435813,
-0.5786683559,
-0.5510280728,
-0.1995594949,
-1.1083840132,
-0.5830219388,
-0.0467267856,
0.3968392611,
-0.734601438,
-0.1229338944,
0.3481042683,
-0.2491077185,
0.1963524222,
0.2001650482,
-0.8294779658,
0.2037860751,
0.6816501021,
0.8382146358,
-0.6229868531,
0.1135691255,
-0.562782526,
0.0861545801,
-0.2640056014,
0.9378495812,
-0.4351388812,
-0.8184580803,
-0.1082992181,
-0.1064764634,
-0.1983004808,
-0.6575233936,
0.7516732216,
-0.3696986735,
0.1053752527,
-0.2542509139,
-0.6991030574,
0.0564744249,
0.1011865661,
-0.4267325997,
0.7642694116,
-0.2600330412,
-0.4423849583,
0.540435791,
-0.6909269094,
-0.5924653411,
0.2326568961,
-0.2340078652,
-0.7466378808,
0.0788001418,
0.4421504438,
0.4148534536,
-0.2197131366,
0.1915400326,
-0.2004986405,
-0.2693099678,
0.721708715,
-0.7361228466,
0.5037100315,
0.278318882,
-0.0638376325,
-0.1284669191,
-0.7144606709,
-0.194180727,
0.0760159418,
-0.6369170547,
-0.0219375677,
0.1304565221,
0.1989277154,
0.0170774125,
0.1644440144,
-0.6066285372,
0.2455958426,
-0.5021669269,
0.3403041363,
0.6043172479,
0.7311148643,
0.0506610312,
-0.2162516713,
0.4314136207,
-0.1201022193,
0.2473342419,
-0.1041048765,
-0.6042317152,
-0.4301260114,
-0.6069386005,
0.4669983387,
0.5922513604,
-0.5198874474,
0.1974658817,
-0.1777646393,
-0.2641497552,
-0.1131420508,
0.0159378052,
0.2952302694,
0.5729978085,
0.2036627829,
-0.3651151657,
-0.522454083,
-0.8892748952,
-0.3662489653,
-0.3291856945,
-0.1953386664,
0.3123974204,
0.1426162124,
-0.2808243632,
0.6629357934,
-0.9100779295,
-0.280851841,
-0.3428395092,
0.0436358862,
0.1144390404,
0.3013748527,
0.3921177387,
-0.4685930014,
-0.2757813036,
0.2478833497,
-0.5672976375,
-0.5178936124,
-0.0630523935,
-0.0976998881,
-0.3101779819,
0.52387923,
-0.683820188,
0.5271273851,
0.3672420979,
0.0442119278,
0.5507793427,
-0.1773915291,
0.1523108631,
-0.906262815,
-0.1844781041,
0.1979726702,
-0.3049591184,
-0.720959425,
-0.4178483188,
-0.0912522674,
-0.3065505028,
-0.4529898465,
0.3988507986,
-0.4044880867,
0.2237946987,
-0.3876349628,
0.0204989538,
0.0129725793,
0.3288128972,
0.1489375979,
0.6235873103,
0.3794308603,
-0.4939831495,
0.1711497754,
0.2508170903,
-0.3579729795,
0.2211796939,
-0.7096117735,
-0.2437696606,
0.174990505,
0.0393155217,
-1.041225791,
-0.5374711156,
0.5769850016,
-0.2791486681,
0.4557788968,
-0.5792754292,
-0.5906170607,
-0.0741633549,
0.0047831885,
-0.0854613632,
0.9466015697,
-0.30486992,
0.3206335604,
0.6781032085,
-0.5243889093,
-0.0746524632,
-0.5367279053,
0.0566151217,
-0.3218208253,
-0.0986993164,
-0.0195840001,
0.1981750727,
-0.1166965812,
-0.3099601567,
-0.1278275102,
0.0880883485,
-0.1096239537,
0.4002316594,
0.5363438725,
-0.2169898748,
0.3654220402,
-0.138249442,
-0.085101001,
0.2145220339,
-0.1511194706,
0.3690413535,
-0.043420393,
-0.5898481011,
-0.5715427995,
0.2831188738,
0.3647413552,
-0.2136778384,
0.7303621173,
0.5970212221,
-0.2460195422,
-0.0003780589,
-0.4035856426,
-0.6014246345,
-0.4527483881,
0.3702858984,
0.1199396327,
-0.7187416553,
0.4565107822,
-0.2772089541,
-0.1113226786,
0.1879550368,
0.7794526219,
-0.139441222,
0.8318416476,
0.187789768,
0.1453303397,
1.0019923449,
0.1404533237,
0.3068735301,
-0.7498503327,
-0.1289867014,
-0.1856868267,
0.015241364,
-0.5755536556,
-0.3270426095,
0.9321354628,
-0.2637830377,
0.0511623845,
-0.0791328698,
-0.4796535671,
0.3862028718,
0.269341737,
0.6191289425,
0.3482910991,
0.2869833112,
0.1509125978,
-0.2602305412,
-0.7770935893,
-0.3237671852,
1.2166177034,
0.3117980063,
0.7046076059,
0.0510273986,
0.3194575012,
0.0843110383,
0.3156621158,
-0.7261757255,
0.5702335238,
-0.2426826954,
-0.4377388954,
-0.0226303283,
-0.3477752209,
-1.0744971037,
0.262164861,
-0.4268876612,
-1.1164652109,
0.3094134331,
-0.0533821248,
-0.5378866792,
0.0782989934,
-1.1792488098,
0.8118240237,
-0.1323242635,
-0.2789776921,
0.0567631572,
-0.4526052773,
0.1947391182,
-0.2296734303,
-0.0007760452,
-0.2739768624,
0.1319659799,
0.6180366278,
-0.3745397329,
1.1621005535,
0.186506629,
-0.0718978718,
0.3650719225,
-0.1441926211,
0.6286791563,
0.254378587,
0.2362261117,
0.2009353936,
0.1012876183,
-0.1783417612,
-0.5089431405,
0.5982373357,
-0.4546151757,
-0.4115777016,
-0.3224210143,
-0.3800613284,
-0.3024578989,
0.1805788279,
0.2822431326,
0.6535884142,
-0.3249543309,
0.1018319353,
0.6548230052,
-0.389013052,
0.2798087001,
0.6105965376,
-0.1635392159,
-0.2306844443,
0.9417691827,
0.1721836776,
0.3541083336,
0.2565184236,
0.3635751009,
-0.2077331841,
-0.8913576603,
-0.087187916,
0.0870852545,
-0.6910817623,
0.047209844,
-0.6549919248,
-0.2995488346,
-0.4353604019,
0.2749042809,
-0.4444764555,
-0.4480846822,
-0.2640415728,
-0.2089107037,
0.7331849337,
0.4337490201,
-0.1064659581,
0.5942041874,
-0.9804601669,
0.350946039,
0.231368959,
0.2573547363,
-0.4151425064,
-0.2057780176,
-0.1401807815,
-0.0214465987,
-0.3203071356,
-1.0858926773,
0.4661193192,
0.2347638309,
0.6735491157,
0.2380743772,
-0.0716989636,
0.6124226451,
-0.4375389814,
0.8426185846,
0.0440075062,
-0.4838249385,
0.8676306009,
-0.6191803813,
0.1492198706,
0.3584156036,
-0.0017486766,
-0.4948677421,
-0.4540129304,
-0.5094947815,
-1.0788770914,
0.3718644381,
0.5795305967,
-0.2715541422,
-0.0511292368,
0.5370103121,
-0.072144866,
0.0039361781,
-0.4800877273,
-0.153250128,
0.4631856382,
-0.0619413927,
-0.0388279743,
-0.3513772786,
-0.2299815565,
0.038260743,
0.616505146,
0.0469598584,
0.339936018,
0.5094370842,
-0.0295320302,
0.2174932659,
0.480738014,
0.2988732755,
0.41181463,
-0.2827335298,
-0.1586042494,
0.2628332675,
-1.1052213907,
-0.2135068625,
0.5128633976,
-0.0021029599,
-0.1722183228,
0.3886469603,
0.7296419144,
0.2467345744,
-1.0319035053,
0.3331434727,
-0.231468305,
0.1288440377,
-0.0934913456,
0.2327155024,
-0.364520669,
0.4743565321,
0.3312219083,
-0.1907288283,
0.4228742421,
-0.2956243753,
0.4087042212,
0.4316240251,
-0.458892405,
-0.0076321987,
0.5297083855,
-0.0536729321,
-0.0904628336,
0.4136861563,
0.2889343202,
-0.343205601,
0.5093526244,
0.3304187953,
0.6447506547,
-0.0137963565,
0.0451606512,
0.1921584308,
0.3020046055,
0.0522942133,
0.02184573,
0.2491721511,
-0.6816792488,
-0.5190052986,
-0.4411274195,
-0.7160444856,
0.0896996334,
-0.5813519955,
0.3167251348,
-0.1134899408,
-0.4138198793,
0.2736825645,
-0.064147301,
-0.2147900313,
0.0593473502,
0.193033874,
0.4820644557,
-0.7615243196,
0.6615464091,
0.5794645548,
-0.2323927581,
-0.8720796704,
0.0676072687,
0.1770141274,
-0.7069305182,
0.2215561271,
-0.1639810801,
0.2266584039,
-0.2450906485,
-0.330506742,
-0.4342714846,
0.9365212321,
0.2435617447,
-0.5891240239,
0.1061720252,
0.3835393488,
0.8553186655,
-0.235831663,
0.0474858992,
0.8734277487,
0.2564573884,
0.297375381,
-0.9481007457,
-0.1240159944,
-0.1776078045,
-0.2127750367,
0.1327534169,
-0.3418578506,
0.5491325259,
-0.0998479053,
-0.1700338572,
-0.1501915753,
0.18542853,
0.4186425805,
0.2558143735,
0.0914755091,
0.1286871731,
0.792958796,
-0.2213017642,
1.2641382217,
-0.1375581771,
0.3597812653,
0.9984940886,
-0.3685466647,
0.8526977301,
0.546505928,
-0.286098212,
0.0638927147,
0.8334813118,
0.0294404514,
0.7002651095,
-0.1232634261,
-0.6120507121,
-0.256916374,
0.022134671,
-0.4093963504,
0.2795009613,
0.9117899537,
-0.5600751042,
-0.1841637194,
0.2982804179,
-0.1423126459,
-0.6112804413,
-0.1798155308,
1.1313705444,
0.2982358336,
-0.565217793,
0.3254298866,
-0.4095156491,
0.0024140426,
-0.5884045362,
-0.1095557511,
0.0237963181,
0.4595200419,
0.0172666479,
-0.832261622,
0.1562936306,
-0.0702059865,
0.1793752909,
0.068303369,
1.2129021883,
-0.4309550524,
-0.4300335944,
-0.0067386688,
0.5329397321,
0.2869904935,
-0.1064676344,
-0.4744310081,
0.1193917692,
0.1058857217,
-0.4523116648,
0.521782577,
0.5963948369,
0.1193222925,
0.6042773724,
0.9274330735,
0.587643981,
-0.0040202346,
-0.0440926738,
0.9244115353,
-0.2617606819,
-0.3210458755,
-1.1660542488,
0.3677658439,
-0.2322155237,
-0.0759071782,
0.7158389091,
0.5425361395,
-0.0224508848,
-0.0318396874,
0.8013453484,
0.3826332688,
0.5417145491,
-0.7479362488,
0.7615172267,
-0.1648045033,
0.7164558768,
-0.1161901355,
-0.5162771344,
-0.4648286104,
0.3542688489,
-0.6024413109,
-0.3218576312,
0.4661433101,
0.8915697932,
0.0439199507,
0.3021059036,
0.2032185644,
0.2857983112,
0.6010250449,
0.5975179076,
0.8732879162,
-0.4910287857,
0.6656704545,
-0.0710212737,
-0.1815231591,
-0.3213562071,
-0.8951977491,
-0.9596626163,
-0.1780093461,
-0.3816713691,
-0.4661368132,
0.3946165144,
0.969972074,
0.624782145,
-0.7839133143,
0.3307227492,
0.0216214359,
0.0034872727,
-0.1110669523,
-0.1985987872,
0.3722726405,
-0.2508791983,
-0.4842528701,
0.3545380235,
0.4042801857,
0.4255583882,
0.1932940185,
0.2888501883,
0.206504792,
-0.0089949537,
0.6693924069,
0.3442843556,
-0.3228576779,
-0.1947320104,
-0.1055750623,
-0.2162302136,
0.2096323818,
0.8929973841,
-0.6648037434,
0.3910009563,
0.4185036421,
0.5756397247,
0.8600698113,
-0.1024326757,
0.7774108648,
-0.7341577411,
0.180516243,
0.207501173,
0.4431856573,
0.0667366758,
-0.4953629076,
0.4809956253,
0.14876993,
-0.7967432737,
-0.79450804,
0.0366366468,
-1.2288404703,
-0.1165021136,
1.5213568211,
0.0044144099,
-0.2109399885,
-0.2348491102,
-0.715665102,
0.162538141,
-0.4458960891,
0.728589952,
0.7362719774,
-0.4618915617,
-0.4008337855,
-1.1831473112,
0.6870427132,
0.0455089435,
-0.8328402042,
0.2312569767,
0.5725278258,
0.3089598417,
-0.0028495409,
0.796476841,
-0.3583318889,
0.2927111089,
-0.0738512725,
-0.2140986919,
0.2045460939,
0.2687387168,
-0.3095805943,
0.1429306865,
0.0523361117,
-0.3067307472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00804v1
|
Uncovering Customer Issues through Topological Natural Language Analysis
| 2024-02-24T00:15:09 | 2024-02-24T00:15:09 |
Shu-Ting Pi, Sidarth Srinivasan, Yuying Zhu, Michael Yang, Qun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
E-commerce companies deal with a high volume of customer service requests
daily. While a simple annotation system is often used to summarize the topics
of customer contacts, thoroughly exploring each specific issue can be
challenging. This presents a critical concern, especially during an emerging
outbreak where companies must quickly identify and address specific issues. To
tackle this challenge, we propose a novel machine learning algorithm that
leverages natural language techniques and topological data analysis to monitor
emerging and trending customer issues. Our approach involves an end-to-end deep
learning framework that simultaneously tags the primary question sentence of
each customer's transcript and generates sentence embedding vectors. We then
whiten the embedding vectors and use them to construct an undirected graph.
From there, we define trending and emerging issues based on the topological
properties of each transcript. We have validated our results through various
methods and found that they are highly consistent with news sources.
|
[
-0.3655646443,
-1.2760071754,
0.2450119555,
0.055168964,
-0.3547818065,
0.5086128712,
-0.0517200679,
-0.8478378057,
0.4830358922,
0.5694098473,
-0.8951832652,
-0.5445914268,
-0.4164030552,
0.2605395615,
-0.3983264863,
1.1493883133,
0.2117251605,
-0.4080178738,
-0.1924931407,
-0.0278670508,
-0.4735012949,
-0.6524122357,
-0.8161847591,
0.0301546026,
0.3328733146,
0.7845576406,
0.5240169764,
0.3667572141,
0.6901124716,
0.4016073644,
-0.1789585948,
0.4351817071,
-0.5363778472,
0.3840068579,
0.3905470669,
-0.0916479006,
-0.0816466436,
-0.3064850569,
0.5006890297,
0.8355435133,
-0.1721624881,
0.312810123,
0.1022579968,
0.7266747355,
-0.0931151137,
-0.0412358679,
-0.6884225607,
0.3047469854,
-0.107767947,
-0.2686468065,
-0.1375497282,
-0.4880452752,
0.6258063912,
-0.692502737,
0.2237802297,
0.1508686393,
1.0679783821,
0.3660154045,
-0.6077107787,
-0.3843566179,
-0.8417093158,
0.3476178646,
-0.2943395674,
0.4700107574,
0.3049477041,
0.4170280397,
-0.3548472524,
-0.6662430763,
-0.2398446798,
0.1385267079,
-0.4400281608,
-0.1356051415,
-0.4924975634,
-0.5465744138,
0.0522028431,
0.2106032223,
-0.5982721448,
0.2336365134,
-0.650852561,
-0.0746100172,
0.6543492079,
0.2365391105,
0.3610309958,
-0.231476739,
-0.3836102784,
0.3197315931,
-0.1482380629,
0.3282466233,
0.3110047877,
0.2626752853,
-0.1384728104,
0.3418085575,
-0.2379625291,
0.545573175,
0.1287169904,
0.4791231453,
0.3453771472,
0.1206154823,
-0.3316174746,
0.2868491113,
0.6193885207,
0.2394856066,
0.2256601304,
-0.2627193034,
0.1650938094,
-0.3635855913,
0.5858415961,
-0.5350515842,
-0.3767440021,
0.5802952647,
-0.2652065158,
-0.3511533439,
0.3083235621,
-1.2599533796,
-0.7464672923,
-0.5824251771,
-0.2461204529,
-0.1394818127,
-0.3038785458,
-0.1578745842,
-0.1188604608,
0.0786309615,
0.1455586106,
-0.4656048715,
0.436227411,
0.9952676296,
0.9126707315,
-0.1678813547,
0.2203578949,
-0.5569860935,
0.1111806706,
-0.3862320781,
0.8852255344,
-0.5268707275,
-0.0607067682,
0.1440278292,
0.1716337949,
0.2042925209,
-0.5734632611,
0.6738420725,
-0.3415614367,
0.1786232442,
0.1076396257,
-0.4564895332,
-0.2303997427,
0.7147395611,
-0.5852173567,
0.9156810045,
0.1045405269,
-0.8886863589,
0.2791597843,
-0.4745279551,
-0.3570392728,
0.4026151299,
-0.2221875638,
-1.1104453802,
0.0553543083,
0.3408315778,
0.5823874474,
-0.1484017521,
0.3427695334,
-0.4078097939,
-0.1177303791,
0.3029651344,
0.2126397938,
0.8022682071,
0.2576519251,
-0.3339076936,
0.1817601025,
-0.7130157948,
-0.2251286656,
0.3765070438,
0.0767673925,
-0.3236214817,
0.0496030934,
0.1560061127,
-0.0337874666,
0.1025992557,
-0.4255723655,
0.2306684703,
-0.4312964678,
0.3206504583,
0.8471821547,
0.4529772103,
0.1482263505,
-0.2022013813,
0.4378834665,
0.1358707845,
0.2311812192,
-0.0876427293,
-0.9094611406,
-0.8744250536,
-0.2160459757,
-0.1259253919,
0.5928761363,
-0.4705542028,
0.4916954041,
-0.3956349492,
-0.5324235559,
-0.2058492899,
0.1323451698,
-0.0470887609,
0.5377181172,
0.3061596751,
-0.1053340137,
-0.6073009372,
-0.8572250605,
-0.5281575918,
0.1943482161,
0.0381735675,
0.617805779,
0.0472921245,
-0.5874762535,
1.2311941385,
-0.943257153,
-0.4424724281,
-0.163612932,
0.4577111006,
0.4485419989,
0.4670312107,
0.2278631628,
-1.1277559996,
-0.6135968566,
0.5194827318,
-0.6553419232,
-0.0668428391,
-0.3269445896,
0.0199142639,
0.3175592422,
0.5407390594,
-0.274305582,
0.4431269765,
0.2034822851,
-0.464749217,
0.2563145459,
-0.204255566,
-0.154007718,
-1.1782544851,
-0.0229772329,
0.4225226939,
-0.1773464084,
-0.997916162,
-0.3452473879,
-0.2850827873,
-0.7106440663,
-0.1210704446,
0.2147368938,
-0.2065289617,
-0.2135022879,
0.1262455732,
0.069474943,
0.0239079762,
0.5306461453,
-0.137490049,
0.0430288203,
0.4471147954,
-0.7494461536,
0.4727553427,
0.4732263982,
-0.2725019455,
0.3000215292,
-0.5878635049,
0.3625445068,
-0.1150818989,
0.1757071316,
-0.9250104427,
-0.1604628414,
0.6333419085,
-0.7481477261,
0.1662092358,
-0.3033462465,
-0.3333082199,
-0.5128064156,
0.0559539758,
0.2695602179,
0.4122377038,
-0.4012618363,
0.6655625701,
0.4809011519,
-0.3287604451,
-0.1503011733,
-0.5213751793,
0.259100914,
-0.5408690572,
-0.6790328026,
-0.061551895,
0.3482631743,
-0.1052762493,
-0.0959755704,
-0.0352038778,
-0.5124322772,
0.5367693901,
0.1251499504,
0.0117877983,
-0.1105034053,
0.2747808397,
-0.3827595413,
-0.4346324205,
0.3662786782,
-0.8292022943,
0.5018078685,
-0.0918273032,
-0.0365287513,
-0.6245711446,
0.5324472189,
0.3084729612,
-0.4468369186,
0.3236016035,
0.7501495481,
-0.6714025736,
-0.3229199648,
-0.3519982994,
-0.0232996531,
-0.5520802736,
0.253886342,
-0.0146318888,
-0.7002714276,
0.4561237991,
-0.3943704963,
-0.0560185052,
0.427431941,
0.3155043721,
-0.2898300886,
0.8769805431,
0.9602345228,
-0.049013909,
0.2807889879,
-0.3615176678,
0.9109606743,
-0.4382109344,
-0.6873286366,
-0.723272264,
-0.5953288078,
-1.0273935795,
-0.158573553,
0.4612618983,
0.1346803159,
-0.0284860898,
0.3581459522,
-0.5700410604,
0.0525880493,
0.3485774994,
0.0736354664,
0.1416135281,
0.2490876317,
-0.195241496,
0.0506600812,
-0.3450341523,
-0.3116489649,
0.5514323711,
0.5005024672,
0.3963215947,
0.3599182367,
0.572232306,
0.411623925,
-0.0739024654,
-0.7780973911,
0.11710722,
-0.1725070924,
-0.2542829812,
-0.2934329212,
-0.7027185559,
-1.1446152925,
-0.219153136,
-0.3824003637,
-1.1986829042,
0.4216704965,
0.0348289981,
-0.20940952,
0.3299688101,
-0.5917955041,
0.9206146002,
-0.3835011423,
-0.168822825,
0.1160128191,
-0.5497720242,
0.0295157377,
-0.1190814599,
0.3476630151,
-0.1042262763,
0.2411159873,
0.6334787607,
-0.139963448,
0.8788125515,
0.0690697357,
-0.0593698397,
0.1171382144,
0.0352323316,
0.6443969607,
0.2920655608,
0.2997020185,
0.1308058202,
-0.2575268447,
-0.6048721671,
-0.5843081474,
0.2883836627,
-0.6371722221,
-0.3968616128,
-0.5062807202,
-0.1544561833,
-0.5968632698,
0.1841721982,
0.014628158,
0.5005920529,
-0.2868489325,
0.2136960179,
0.6188933849,
-0.2787736654,
0.4385959208,
0.1341759861,
-0.2761609852,
-0.1865202785,
1.2131836414,
-0.1389205754,
-0.2156744748,
0.2696507573,
0.5936202407,
-0.0152920969,
-0.5355666876,
-0.4074046016,
-0.0103206206,
-0.4081092775,
-0.1853595674,
-1.0793271065,
-0.0863583386,
-0.5771806836,
-0.0691119656,
-0.0827717409,
-0.1427463293,
-0.4438994527,
-0.112776354,
0.5393103957,
1.1099892855,
0.3818969429,
0.2232457548,
-1.1569256783,
0.4490423203,
0.3071099222,
0.4848659635,
-0.1724223495,
-0.0650459826,
-0.3834609687,
0.1026327536,
-0.4039597213,
-0.8831956983,
0.5846396089,
0.1193816736,
0.3957139254,
0.7039449811,
0.1521225572,
0.657433033,
-0.401707232,
0.5992106795,
0.2098998576,
-0.9069879055,
0.6167681813,
-0.5414572954,
0.0098689124,
0.3164912462,
0.8498011827,
-1.1420248747,
-0.2975916266,
-0.7392758131,
-1.0196076632,
0.5393992066,
0.2200727016,
0.1411469579,
-0.0879114419,
0.3431715667,
-0.0621995181,
0.0994283706,
-0.4749363661,
-0.3485493362,
-0.0509538315,
-0.2217128575,
0.0254589077,
-0.1965853572,
0.0080654724,
-0.3593272269,
0.3400174081,
-0.2793179452,
0.1925694793,
0.2654221058,
-0.0044294624,
-0.1585121751,
0.1539074183,
0.5760137439,
0.7012156844,
-0.224538371,
-0.3166197836,
0.1096710414,
-0.452223599,
-0.3767199814,
0.2077832371,
-0.0563478172,
0.155218482,
0.1625497043,
0.5359514952,
-0.0156398304,
-0.5405983329,
0.5308679342,
-0.1168442518,
-0.2654963434,
-0.7532887459,
-0.5709911585,
-0.1282426715,
0.2511400878,
0.6749055386,
-0.0951700434,
0.5492986441,
-0.5865966678,
0.6421923637,
0.3500353694,
-1.0986691713,
-0.098730199,
-0.0119262822,
0.4234075546,
-0.5748503208,
0.8997181654,
-0.176782459,
-1.0833607912,
1.0081577301,
0.4346292019,
1.143311739,
-0.0113480138,
0.3718232214,
0.0267243721,
0.4211871326,
0.7143136859,
0.0853814855,
0.323667258,
-0.4121876061,
-0.0993365273,
-0.3561733663,
-0.395495981,
-0.0654603317,
-0.8048454523,
0.5571033955,
-0.5361773372,
0.2083523422,
-0.0746646225,
0.2653787136,
-0.6511720419,
0.3549563587,
0.3261375427,
0.5796332359,
-0.8758334517,
0.4984126389,
0.5713503361,
0.0519089028,
-0.5226235986,
0.0962087214,
0.3051145375,
-0.5911824107,
0.7121885419,
0.6885342598,
0.1367079765,
-0.2607851326,
-0.2303237468,
-0.7651807666,
0.9571797848,
-0.1699248552,
-0.5279350281,
0.3019589484,
0.4309481084,
0.4934470356,
-0.6629638672,
-0.0530076511,
0.5622943044,
0.3848051727,
-0.020704532,
-0.4361802936,
-0.0918313414,
-0.5059247017,
-0.3781869411,
0.6951462626,
-0.4064511359,
0.6041969657,
0.0347973891,
-0.4829722643,
-0.4128909409,
0.5988300443,
-0.3752479851,
0.7552571297,
0.6479388475,
0.8454998732,
1.2142193317,
-0.2097016275,
0.9411062598,
0.0854244605,
0.4559496939,
1.1297471523,
-0.1071135923,
0.5830536485,
0.3094281852,
0.172877878,
0.606218636,
0.9052323699,
-0.3555043936,
0.2587954998,
0.7071694732,
0.1766685098,
-0.1323450357,
-0.3169316351,
-0.3350106776,
0.5438513756,
0.5044880509,
-0.0133664869,
-0.1454695016,
-0.1210208833,
-0.1994521916,
-0.0219207592,
-0.1779083312,
1.2487701178,
-0.087481387,
-0.1166967675,
0.2749764919,
-0.2414684743,
0.236845091,
-0.2715697587,
-0.1700690985,
-0.2241575271,
0.1097467244,
-0.4095301926,
-0.3132619858,
0.653337121,
0.0049436996,
0.2230279148,
-0.0616886318,
0.4023976624,
-0.2161115706,
-0.8593708873,
0.4486515522,
0.3860055506,
-0.0074196472,
-0.0937478244,
-0.8007734418,
-0.1335739642,
-0.024435319,
0.0015749305,
-0.1450740844,
0.7362967134,
-0.0910717547,
0.7263008952,
0.8133630157,
-0.2114512622,
0.1068082079,
-0.0932422802,
1.0052256584,
-0.7179272175,
-0.8076912165,
-0.6906075478,
0.7441119552,
-0.6963536143,
-0.6455047727,
0.5638398528,
0.5145392418,
0.5876678824,
0.3864865899,
0.4632079601,
0.3369467258,
0.691206038,
-0.3732091188,
0.5209705234,
-0.5379809737,
0.4550563097,
-0.3154619336,
-0.7773593068,
-0.4218136668,
0.2243460119,
-0.2980075181,
-0.3606606424,
0.8975508213,
0.2474967986,
-0.1794597507,
0.3590051234,
-0.115580976,
0.2988650203,
0.54315871,
0.342923671,
0.9215911627,
-0.1887291521,
0.7129072547,
-0.4984048605,
-0.0574259199,
-0.4228804111,
-1.0132762194,
-0.883795023,
-0.5290810466,
-0.4545639753,
-0.1895840466,
-0.0039255004,
0.927457273,
0.6206842065,
-0.9706736803,
-0.1487588733,
-0.2533800602,
0.3225805759,
-0.2086033672,
-0.2651337981,
0.4416840374,
-0.6960433722,
-0.3668138981,
-0.0060960734,
0.3247894347,
-0.032285586,
-0.1168177128,
0.3347891569,
-0.3693949878,
-0.2194106728,
0.2423387468,
0.0628279373,
-0.4478081465,
-0.1890622675,
0.2469863445,
0.1653838754,
0.1646177918,
1.1987733841,
-0.6267575622,
0.2915576398,
0.3714284599,
1.3817557096,
0.5924004316,
0.0725683495,
0.7612868547,
-0.9458141923,
-0.0811394528,
0.5265516639,
0.2745611072,
0.4581380486,
-1.0018239021,
0.3722769916,
0.1832369566,
-0.336327523,
-0.5246337652,
0.4245639145,
-0.9381275177,
-0.5993878841,
0.842550993,
-0.0883643851,
-0.198418349,
-0.7240238786,
0.0221479051,
0.1781071424,
-0.2015880942,
0.8987484574,
0.3812276423,
-0.116143167,
-0.1640483886,
-0.4968966246,
0.4687309563,
0.3430375159,
-1.1011302471,
0.0404656976,
0.3469494879,
-0.1357504874,
0.4276720285,
0.1303341985,
0.4122635126,
0.0711072907,
-0.5504938364,
-0.6154001951,
0.0025305606,
-0.6165963411,
-0.4421108961,
0.2117313445,
-0.4196018279,
-0.0882934406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15654v1
|
Exploring Failure Cases in Multimodal Reasoning About Physical Dynamics
| 2024-02-24T00:01:01 | 2024-02-24T00:01:01 |
Sadaf Ghaffari, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present an exploration of LLMs' abilities to problem solve
with physical reasoning in situated environments. We construct a simple
simulated environment and demonstrate examples of where, in a zero-shot
setting, both text and multimodal LLMs display atomic world knowledge about
various objects but fail to compose this knowledge in correct solutions for an
object manipulation and placement task. We also use BLIP, a vision-language
model trained with more sophisticated cross-modal attention, to identify cases
relevant to object physical properties that that model fails to ground.
Finally, we present a procedure for discovering the relevant properties of
objects in the environment and propose a method to distill this knowledge back
into the LLM.
|
[
-0.387481153,
-1.1391233206,
1.1877282858,
0.1385211349,
0.0089453245,
0.1892035604,
0.0879642442,
-0.3400453031,
-0.0696192607,
-0.0141441626,
-0.8726488948,
-0.4507910907,
-0.4006868899,
0.142410472,
-0.1015601605,
0.6368634105,
-0.4197523594,
-0.1384710968,
-0.6236301064,
-0.1485703737,
-0.7294402122,
-0.6781007051,
-0.053400185,
-0.4613339007,
0.4008722007,
0.5909733176,
0.5132426023,
0.2278182209,
0.6060553193,
0.2984828353,
-0.1614543051,
0.4643965364,
-0.2621518075,
0.1922868639,
-0.3901468813,
-0.6320369244,
-0.0389714316,
0.0157967843,
0.6009290218,
0.8918337822,
-0.0208117627,
-0.2078100294,
-0.2510797977,
0.1126600876,
-0.6431640983,
0.0666302964,
-0.5899029374,
0.682090044,
0.1455447078,
-0.4794144332,
-0.3517582119,
0.2937266827,
0.0035599386,
-0.7485947013,
0.3232128024,
0.3719748855,
0.8615432978,
0.5317709446,
-0.8911451697,
-0.2624655366,
-0.9466276765,
1.0647923946,
-0.1328113377,
0.5361027122,
0.2062761337,
0.3897833228,
-0.3694951236,
-0.1902320087,
-0.6451650858,
-0.3303425014,
0.2071384341,
0.388178885,
0.3038753569,
0.0039686481,
0.3548988402,
0.1086274683,
-0.3853387535,
-0.1966383308,
-0.3398538828,
-0.2591547668,
0.289070189,
0.4935321808,
0.2588182092,
-0.3296404779,
-0.723926723,
-0.3122015297,
-0.5619487166,
0.1112159193,
-0.0226422418,
0.0428770855,
-0.1147261411,
0.9559813142,
-0.0012421447,
0.6289297342,
-0.0921871737,
-0.648715198,
0.1643946916,
-0.532972455,
-0.2246834636,
0.0270631555,
0.3393989503,
0.5750382543,
0.0838682577,
0.0817572623,
-0.1066111699,
-0.1179394871,
0.3913882673,
-0.2452387214,
0.0660504773,
0.4959342182,
-0.5598415732,
-0.0070182821,
-0.1550076008,
-0.4034705162,
-0.3496480882,
-0.4255062044,
0.6122811437,
-0.5726723075,
-0.2884827256,
0.1868336946,
-0.3839248717,
0.0608528331,
0.5706466436,
-0.6314259768,
-0.2581813633,
0.4794513583,
0.9368894696,
0.0275158212,
-0.742120862,
-0.1898994148,
0.5660497546,
-0.3920592666,
1.0014721155,
-0.1683662683,
-0.5521389246,
-0.0148388669,
0.226323843,
-0.0704831704,
-0.6048896909,
0.2902548015,
-0.1544036567,
-0.0727635175,
-0.3435599804,
-0.2630226314,
-0.3146907091,
0.82898283,
-0.4579824805,
0.7331284881,
-0.1405520141,
-0.7523977757,
0.5341370106,
-0.547962606,
-0.5565102696,
-0.2282811403,
-0.2190243155,
-0.3424603939,
0.3989331722,
-0.1559477895,
0.5758367777,
0.2263916433,
0.0753627792,
-0.6366950274,
-0.3591581881,
0.5225450397,
-0.452262491,
0.356687367,
-0.0881609768,
-0.2344725877,
-0.1422360986,
-0.779052496,
-0.252039969,
0.2320081294,
-0.3496315181,
-0.3224665523,
0.3748779893,
0.146021083,
0.4511563182,
0.4080468416,
-0.455658406,
0.2618375421,
-0.0373364538,
0.1545215398,
0.5899654031,
0.1731911898,
0.2642648816,
-0.4270433784,
0.4537781477,
0.4435993135,
0.1635926515,
-0.3749450147,
-0.4374203682,
-0.7853206992,
0.170297578,
-0.5098121166,
0.6695405245,
-1.0139440298,
-0.3237923682,
0.1340151131,
-0.162379846,
0.1020297781,
0.1851812005,
0.5740149021,
0.6403220296,
0.3775264323,
-0.0379369855,
-0.4157847464,
-0.8557887673,
0.1095371619,
-0.150546506,
0.1194744259,
0.7296261787,
0.5947833657,
-0.4398376346,
0.8004051447,
-0.3632657826,
-0.3538953364,
-0.125921011,
0.2279952168,
0.104730688,
0.1555498391,
0.4101019204,
-0.7635444999,
0.1628700495,
0.232799679,
-1.4057518244,
0.0720560029,
-0.198038429,
0.0941546634,
0.3929444849,
0.5343910456,
-0.6736246943,
0.4047936797,
0.4999036491,
-0.5751119256,
0.7759841681,
-0.3727878034,
0.2435141057,
-0.8935707211,
-0.1589619964,
0.3797959685,
-0.1594712734,
-0.3537505269,
0.0425758548,
-0.337498337,
-0.249533236,
-1.0149649382,
0.6586632133,
-0.7895095944,
-0.4560896158,
-0.2635188997,
0.4459639788,
-0.051205799,
0.4671626985,
0.2846927643,
0.4806728959,
0.5076472759,
-0.7595653534,
0.7223294377,
0.1866935045,
-0.0813914463,
1.0424414873,
-0.5287176967,
-0.1175802648,
-0.279366076,
-0.1162214801,
-1.0608901978,
-0.5061565638,
0.0730582997,
-0.2328343093,
0.1934237182,
-0.3563425541,
-0.5807109475,
-0.2798978686,
-0.2828755975,
0.575645864,
-0.1073893011,
-0.4181500971,
0.6714463234,
0.2839232087,
0.1016375497,
-0.4220551848,
-0.9241857529,
-0.0519482307,
-0.3116074204,
-0.5480632186,
-0.0133987498,
-0.3567334116,
-0.5996641517,
0.0197050609,
-0.0914304703,
-0.0683636069,
0.3356018662,
0.5139641762,
0.1074879467,
-0.0622699559,
0.241056636,
0.0412971042,
-0.1193191335,
0.2123907954,
0.2966274619,
0.3307531178,
-0.3648266792,
-0.9879854918,
-0.4364888072,
0.3361974061,
0.7348953485,
0.374066323,
0.5911756754,
0.2535507381,
-0.4999203682,
-0.1540571302,
-0.3323289454,
-0.177080363,
-0.4560185373,
0.426884383,
-0.6001304388,
-0.6445451379,
0.522403717,
-0.1649218053,
-0.1241385639,
0.0253285635,
0.7580674291,
-0.5610738993,
0.9938641787,
0.7536199689,
0.348644197,
0.3811326027,
-0.280215919,
0.2493520379,
-0.8591822982,
-0.8553596139,
-0.0585606024,
-0.5040181279,
-0.1358609051,
-0.7124659419,
0.9025259018,
0.1405246407,
-0.2590889931,
0.088137202,
-0.2952913344,
0.4301870167,
0.4801043868,
0.2484128177,
0.482806623,
0.0899866521,
-0.5425094962,
-0.0958338082,
-0.8473835588,
-0.4801734388,
0.7874043584,
0.3561255336,
0.8839598298,
0.243430987,
0.4690743983,
-0.0710566714,
0.1611218154,
-0.9193371534,
0.6008158326,
0.3974016011,
-0.7605390549,
-0.4029342532,
-0.339527607,
-0.8560529947,
0.27299124,
-0.1969267726,
-0.6200700402,
-0.0534677319,
0.2483738363,
-0.2186129689,
0.2398661077,
-0.7108632326,
0.9896110892,
-0.648396492,
-0.5465505123,
-0.1649835259,
-0.4692133367,
0.6287690997,
0.2257932574,
0.5314004421,
-0.2252804637,
-0.0216639005,
0.1566696018,
-0.2490247786,
0.9209834337,
-0.0801647753,
-0.208504647,
0.4466094077,
0.5648303628,
-0.0041266503,
0.2551846802,
0.2208652496,
0.1863999665,
0.0195416845,
-0.3231114149,
-0.6693600416,
0.6261394024,
-0.6711809635,
-0.5199790001,
-0.5749343634,
-0.7946358323,
-0.3115023673,
0.0033399074,
0.0969820991,
0.5084814429,
0.0524138063,
0.1336160004,
0.8576853871,
-0.1548084617,
0.7919631004,
0.54934448,
-0.3566909134,
-0.0777385756,
0.8002815247,
0.1981444955,
0.1318784356,
0.2726804912,
-0.0175820254,
-0.3684400022,
-0.3465534151,
-0.4790745676,
0.1043872833,
-0.9232862592,
-0.195381701,
-0.4095107913,
-0.1469635665,
0.2160110772,
-0.3571669161,
-0.2029985636,
-0.2433952391,
-0.2815345824,
-0.2510974109,
0.2884023488,
0.7072509527,
-0.194207415,
-0.0173012931,
-0.940107882,
0.2796938717,
0.3410898149,
0.208875075,
0.0053101312,
-0.4386911988,
-0.2719019055,
0.082227774,
-0.5979223251,
-0.8441256285,
0.2499901652,
-0.013096666,
0.9090448022,
0.356236428,
-0.2646134198,
0.6500502825,
-0.5494898558,
0.8619474769,
0.2063509077,
-0.8869706988,
1.0017591715,
-0.4795912206,
0.3634181023,
0.2482617646,
0.5978599191,
-0.3679013848,
-0.3033915758,
-0.4510268569,
-0.6829798818,
0.3861159682,
-0.0341459289,
0.0326500535,
-0.2149704248,
0.4259130955,
-0.1253518015,
0.1516609192,
-0.9569985867,
-0.2425451279,
-0.1958229095,
-0.1041686609,
-0.0716382563,
-0.2206510603,
-0.3673283458,
-0.0645684004,
0.3798484206,
-0.4052970707,
0.3604522049,
0.5351383686,
-0.3046900034,
-0.2011766136,
-0.1009683758,
1.1054116488,
0.7347207665,
-0.1415175349,
0.4991506934,
0.3199437559,
-0.0760914758,
0.3733968437,
-0.3031878471,
0.1261810213,
-0.0746122897,
0.654820621,
0.4862786233,
0.7629642487,
-1.0660324097,
0.5058979392,
0.1071031243,
-0.2707761526,
-0.3167895377,
-0.1871511191,
-0.031191092,
0.5192123055,
0.4641451836,
-0.1911664754,
0.1363446862,
-1.0923885107,
0.1900604218,
0.618686378,
-0.3903689384,
-0.4110125899,
0.7651803493,
-0.0501070842,
-0.2516947091,
0.483340919,
-0.2951638103,
-0.6701296568,
0.885699749,
0.5393516421,
0.4235412776,
0.1288561523,
0.1898433715,
0.0419324152,
0.405153811,
-0.0138249565,
0.3828898072,
-0.0546939187,
-1.1116538048,
-0.5187029839,
-0.2887572348,
-0.9310932755,
-0.2246222347,
-0.1550185829,
0.164035067,
-0.8286044598,
-0.0965997353,
-0.4505721927,
-0.0944276005,
-0.5591308475,
0.2468292564,
0.2361389101,
0.5674661398,
-1.1513718367,
0.2253406048,
1.2397192717,
-0.5390395522,
-0.5795245171,
0.002419824,
0.3331854343,
-0.7950034738,
1.0216319561,
0.0367154926,
-0.2985368967,
-0.5453053713,
-0.5199670792,
-0.8676304221,
1.2266750336,
0.3002331555,
-0.455745101,
0.3445834517,
0.0222338866,
0.5465165377,
0.0671201646,
0.3818037212,
-0.1226486936,
0.5255200267,
0.2569873631,
-1.192817688,
-0.1906060725,
0.0673569068,
-0.1877319813,
0.0179488193,
-1.2384461164,
0.9964509606,
-0.416475445,
-0.0048149549,
-0.3387892246,
0.4886509776,
0.9133425951,
0.9518553615,
0.3129360378,
0.9305263162,
0.5201014876,
-0.1001494601,
1.2466422319,
-0.1294212341,
0.6148263216,
0.6758244038,
-0.5675749183,
0.7111340165,
0.666044116,
0.0081324605,
0.5718281865,
0.618285954,
0.1616963595,
0.5535889864,
-0.0006564069,
-0.3908686638,
-0.5488801599,
-0.0962557867,
-0.0734167695,
0.5810280442,
0.1681050956,
0.2282645404,
-0.2768190205,
0.5367720127,
-0.3442768157,
0.0693140253,
-0.3955303133,
0.4064984918,
0.1848147213,
-0.3404116333,
0.2735189795,
-0.0479803644,
0.510042727,
0.0089468807,
-0.3166692853,
-0.2888587415,
0.2328017056,
-0.223633498,
-1.0345110893,
0.4993129671,
-0.5090932846,
-0.4292401075,
-0.4416392744,
0.8185072541,
-0.185894832,
-0.6159115434,
0.275568217,
0.6689668298,
0.4784854054,
0.1512681544,
-0.5058650374,
0.2782325149,
-0.3141849041,
-0.2338566929,
0.3454611897,
1.0271166563,
-0.1396135986,
1.2930098772,
0.4234213829,
-0.3184892833,
0.2999839187,
-0.135658443,
0.6229569912,
-0.9772931337,
-0.0827422068,
-0.6861692667,
0.5249049067,
0.1097215265,
-0.2293934971,
0.9384028316,
0.5683501959,
0.8744772673,
-0.2333915979,
0.5756998062,
0.2030213773,
0.4154016972,
-0.9056703448,
0.3598472476,
-0.8245918155,
0.1614842564,
-0.059385851,
-0.9194726348,
-0.4498565495,
1.0002639294,
-0.138505131,
0.1297463328,
0.9150515795,
0.5975362062,
-0.2364502996,
-0.6398000717,
0.7086773515,
0.2772044241,
0.1707328856,
0.9893960357,
1.3575650454,
-0.3136624098,
0.5491247177,
-0.2558545768,
-0.1049600765,
-0.4016138613,
-1.1590094566,
-1.0080630779,
-0.4830851853,
-0.4159110188,
-0.2247234285,
0.0394488089,
0.6352734566,
0.8602862358,
-0.3380320668,
0.0532981381,
0.0376545675,
0.6044299603,
0.0706593469,
-0.2863179743,
-0.2540161014,
-0.3185665011,
-0.6677777171,
0.8221578598,
0.5379735231,
0.3479740918,
-0.5409198403,
-0.0001810602,
-0.1841151267,
-0.1281623244,
0.7987655997,
0.3471792042,
-0.6621037126,
-0.6901342869,
-0.0192254446,
0.0144049907,
-0.054931365,
0.7959176302,
-0.8860829473,
0.225286141,
0.1894189119,
0.3732845485,
0.5855520964,
0.0038266731,
0.3164952397,
-0.9706041217,
0.4189505875,
0.1312754154,
0.7344632149,
0.3222910464,
-0.249208346,
0.3348757327,
0.7581802607,
-0.6151247025,
-0.7632081509,
0.2959330976,
-1.2861044407,
-0.4693263471,
1.3000863791,
0.0083498145,
-0.3882985115,
-0.2980115712,
-0.349976778,
-0.1025952548,
0.0314954445,
0.960355401,
1.0199695826,
-0.4200702012,
-0.6635997295,
-0.68647331,
-0.0411122851,
0.4356517196,
-0.760846436,
-0.4145718217,
0.7460612655,
0.3733925223,
0.6485424042,
0.2810421586,
0.1370676458,
0.2753053904,
0.0585058704,
0.1410105526,
-0.1488656551,
-0.747035861,
-0.2979954481,
0.3318181038,
0.1377886683,
-0.165002048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15637v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15637v2
|
Addressing Order Sensitivity of In-Context Demonstration Examples in Causal Language Models
| 2024-02-23T22:39:12 | 2024-06-06T12:01:09 |
Yanzheng Xiang, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning has become a popular paradigm in natural language
processing. However, its performance can be significantly influenced by the
order of in-context demonstration examples. In this paper, we found that causal
language models (CausalLMs) are more sensitive to this order compared to prefix
language models (PrefixLMs). We attribute this phenomenon to the
auto-regressive attention masks within CausalLMs, which restrict each token
from accessing information from subsequent tokens. This results in different
receptive fields for samples at different positions, thereby leading to
representation disparities across positions. To tackle this challenge, we
introduce an unsupervised fine-tuning method, termed the Information-Augmented
and Consistency-Enhanced approach. This approach utilizes contrastive learning
to align representations of in-context examples across different positions and
introduces a consistency loss to ensure similar representations for inputs with
different permutations. This enhances the model's predictive consistency across
permutations. Experimental results on five benchmarks suggest that our proposed
method can reduce the sensitivity of CausalLMs to the order of in-context
examples and exhibit robust generalizability, particularly when demonstrations
are sourced from a candidate pool different from that used in the training
phase, or when the number of in-context examples differs from what is used
during training.
|
[
-0.3303734958,
-0.709502697,
0.2911669612,
0.367601335,
-0.1951076239,
-0.3101383746,
-0.1965393573,
-0.3765408099,
-0.3256937563,
0.3013163507,
-0.2470154613,
-0.3920665383,
-0.7546312213,
0.2054858208,
-0.3087522686,
0.8758363128,
0.0521109253,
-0.1279947907,
-0.3061320782,
-0.368067801,
-0.6093899012,
-0.5735574365,
-0.7295513749,
-0.3302209973,
0.2941368222,
0.3601603806,
0.7322238684,
0.8772243261,
0.3305383027,
0.3885142207,
0.0330324471,
0.2678235471,
-0.3730302453,
0.1530505419,
-0.4776510894,
-0.1910568625,
-0.1126076654,
-0.1244042814,
0.7129559517,
0.9512384534,
0.0658759251,
0.0660267025,
0.4699219465,
0.2628574967,
-0.8390856981,
0.326695472,
-0.7218019962,
-0.3133910596,
0.1773412675,
-0.2891491652,
-0.7034294009,
-0.0391760245,
0.1375416964,
-0.6581691504,
0.4327832758,
0.1648300141,
0.903021574,
0.429633677,
-0.5074430108,
0.1959400177,
-0.7194282413,
0.7275983691,
-0.782483995,
0.5343360305,
0.4428946674,
0.2421347797,
-0.4325997233,
-0.7670292258,
-0.4690333605,
0.1089676321,
-0.4490497708,
0.0338375531,
-0.3458881974,
0.0580682307,
0.4514633715,
-0.0973170102,
-0.4184454679,
0.4309957325,
0.0700682998,
-0.265722543,
0.3188539445,
0.2983267903,
-0.1672971547,
0.1299086213,
-0.4391246438,
-0.3315588832,
-0.7002938986,
0.2168783396,
0.0594408587,
0.4894711077,
-0.0918848142,
0.472230643,
-0.6111085415,
0.966756165,
0.6100039482,
0.2016596347,
0.2170746475,
-0.2461296916,
-0.6632207632,
0.0589370988,
0.6231544018,
0.3716908693,
-0.2131002247,
-0.0060601584,
-0.0621904656,
0.0869806334,
0.0912552625,
-0.8224151731,
-0.1371103972,
-0.0537414737,
-0.2189048976,
-0.1678782403,
0.1804356873,
-0.5046340823,
-0.4963350594,
-0.5806136727,
0.6098259091,
-0.2123790532,
0.1381389052,
0.2814986408,
0.2425481677,
0.1062252074,
0.3313380182,
-1.000998497,
0.4682445526,
0.6399264336,
0.3165546656,
-0.1527107954,
-0.4776658118,
-0.8822333813,
0.4004893899,
-0.2673837245,
0.7122341394,
-0.6018756032,
0.1436262876,
0.1284260601,
0.0905822292,
-0.1988058984,
-0.6250692606,
0.3863502145,
-0.5871660113,
0.3481343687,
-0.167981267,
-0.6568120122,
-0.0757574216,
-0.0999832153,
-0.2754255831,
0.8374539018,
-0.0225373358,
-0.978435576,
0.7070331573,
-0.3137606978,
-0.5434759259,
-0.2535061836,
-0.4498179257,
-0.536032021,
0.1462784111,
0.2799906433,
0.6085672975,
-0.063094981,
0.5815334916,
-0.2093775719,
-0.4574232101,
0.156728521,
-0.5819841623,
0.538736105,
-0.0337290056,
-0.6942359209,
0.4852431118,
-0.8202833533,
-0.2673546374,
-0.0884568542,
-0.2436131388,
-0.690608561,
0.1784639806,
-0.1457713395,
0.4955330789,
-0.0632312,
-0.3727030456,
-0.0888540894,
-0.5295959711,
0.1393504292,
0.8874732256,
0.1551324725,
0.4410967231,
-0.0403828621,
-0.0846610144,
0.3417606056,
0.3870308697,
-0.0832399353,
-0.364054054,
-0.8568176627,
-0.190758571,
0.0703583136,
0.1782020181,
-0.5094097257,
0.5647297502,
-0.2970207632,
0.0128998887,
-0.1894169897,
-0.0611427017,
0.7165458202,
1.0046072006,
0.4583125412,
-0.3301329315,
-0.375161767,
-1.0799095631,
-0.379126668,
-0.2042523026,
-0.1064216122,
0.1348034739,
0.1675949544,
-0.1107700244,
0.8557180762,
-0.4342335463,
0.0158273168,
0.1140584424,
0.2957871556,
0.1726821363,
0.5829876065,
0.2865198851,
-0.9874418378,
-0.3833701015,
-0.0768733174,
-0.4000666738,
-0.1816846281,
-0.1461804956,
-0.2166855633,
0.27229774,
0.8516308665,
-0.1718768924,
0.6169129014,
0.1947201639,
-0.6899940968,
0.1932655126,
-0.4142892063,
0.0532161593,
-0.9371098876,
-0.1546852738,
-0.1377820522,
-0.13999632,
-0.8329852223,
-0.1129901186,
0.1705694199,
0.3018130958,
-0.3501348794,
0.6466671824,
-0.2916298211,
-0.0895866826,
-0.2503681779,
-0.0511518046,
0.1516419351,
0.6049660444,
0.077434212,
0.5337918401,
0.5860604644,
-0.9857629538,
-0.2788053453,
0.2856803834,
-0.3447847068,
0.5996142626,
-0.602751255,
-0.0871434361,
-0.1026171446,
0.005638836,
-1.1814031601,
-0.3438711762,
0.0988015309,
-0.1887746751,
0.6574442387,
0.0162110124,
-0.6124106646,
0.0580890067,
-0.0909224451,
0.4474006295,
0.3474476635,
-0.6732283235,
0.2589836121,
0.106705904,
0.0822334737,
-0.5773051381,
-0.4631191194,
-0.3511380255,
-0.3908255398,
-0.232193917,
0.3906808197,
-0.1171180308,
-0.2317286581,
-0.2442452312,
-0.2879768014,
-0.0740014464,
0.3327958584,
0.3640039265,
0.0996506885,
-0.103461802,
0.2712138891,
0.1874140799,
-0.1361316741,
-0.1490829587,
-0.1411167085,
0.4868071675,
-0.0441308133,
-0.5410045385,
-0.3545506597,
0.283510983,
0.4103069305,
-0.0782082826,
0.6295176744,
0.434946835,
-0.3697363436,
0.0812489912,
-0.5854094625,
-0.3279112279,
-0.5185692906,
0.3629805446,
-0.3204442263,
-0.9115658402,
0.5412271023,
0.0273514464,
0.1278334856,
0.3861751258,
0.5236415863,
0.1437770724,
1.1673957109,
0.7001854777,
-0.2220995277,
0.7146573067,
0.1107180342,
-0.0654873252,
-0.8608933091,
-0.1840098351,
-0.4263698757,
-0.0811401159,
-0.4845942259,
-0.2096512467,
0.2021948546,
0.3762557805,
-0.7989183664,
0.2992047966,
-0.3838148117,
0.5417590141,
0.4559400082,
0.1075932235,
0.4333979785,
0.2931716442,
-0.2906190753,
-0.0217190608,
-0.8680241108,
-0.3727584481,
0.6822655201,
0.0801654533,
0.5649161935,
0.1667805761,
0.4525057971,
-0.0064911554,
0.2818013132,
-0.2397182584,
0.3211131394,
-0.227452293,
-0.2654379904,
-0.4550903738,
-0.1142470762,
-1.2707115412,
0.3857350349,
-0.0730431005,
-0.9082584977,
0.7378185391,
0.1928422004,
-0.3894684911,
-0.1417974234,
-0.7469965816,
0.9026661515,
0.1307244152,
-0.7347711921,
-0.0372471735,
-0.9317735434,
0.1173787341,
0.1242024973,
0.1852303892,
0.1534196883,
0.2104625553,
0.4475485384,
-0.4235722125,
1.1777309179,
-0.0284745302,
-0.0808933824,
-0.0545067079,
0.1820391119,
0.7217288017,
-0.0279323347,
-0.0333160274,
-0.1200219169,
-0.56665802,
-0.4776699245,
-0.7166965604,
0.7186017632,
-0.6348503828,
-0.7656684518,
-0.087216638,
-0.4727349281,
-0.4784542024,
0.1349770427,
0.5158393979,
0.7156093121,
0.0767503083,
-0.0405468307,
0.6553960443,
-0.1644801348,
0.5756842494,
0.7413500547,
0.106803216,
-0.1732198298,
0.7782611847,
-0.0260159653,
0.4982968867,
0.5563646555,
0.1890467554,
-0.3252534568,
-0.6263408661,
-0.2449300587,
0.0244824383,
-0.8658807874,
-0.2642440498,
-0.5974416733,
0.1452557147,
-0.5291405916,
-0.2067141384,
-0.1367717385,
-0.2897582352,
-0.4326016009,
-0.1148108467,
0.2450072765,
0.6488744617,
0.1183671206,
0.1796257794,
-0.167253539,
0.3460054696,
0.5163744688,
0.4947070479,
-0.030348666,
-0.8739730716,
-0.1238424778,
-0.2779554427,
-0.1680490822,
-0.5841324925,
0.1760790199,
0.2160173506,
0.6410923004,
0.6304293275,
0.2279083133,
1.0611163378,
-0.5617223978,
0.4754127264,
0.0821004957,
-0.910685122,
0.5168547034,
-0.3165934384,
0.300304383,
0.5965075493,
0.1658879668,
-0.2652118504,
-0.754555881,
-0.7235767841,
-1.0332438946,
0.7172265053,
0.1881484985,
-0.1235719994,
-0.2393746674,
0.2268565446,
0.2136463225,
0.0830171481,
-0.5063263774,
-0.392087996,
-0.2501890659,
-0.1036249995,
-0.3104980886,
-0.1998206526,
-0.1153685153,
-0.3559986353,
0.3577107191,
-0.1888908893,
0.0263732616,
0.391667217,
-0.1408590972,
0.0234416816,
0.2758192718,
0.866271019,
0.6011596322,
-0.0492375381,
0.4670872688,
0.1589632928,
-0.2136151195,
0.1354070902,
0.2665455639,
-0.3109245002,
0.0468577258,
0.5625855923,
1.0569573641,
0.5357441306,
-0.2891687453,
0.5334275365,
0.0256875735,
0.1939181089,
0.1589776427,
-0.1213755906,
-0.4257540405,
0.3640567958,
0.2132889628,
0.0504305772,
0.4687516391,
-0.4077240825,
0.3564078808,
0.30059129,
-0.4327513874,
-0.2054289579,
0.6883686781,
-0.2337100804,
-0.0009171301,
0.2537026703,
-0.1219285578,
-0.3794299066,
0.655749023,
0.8743193746,
0.7243458033,
-0.3414495587,
0.0004296078,
0.3566994965,
-0.0184469074,
-0.1668103486,
0.1031143963,
-0.1222036257,
-0.7423593998,
-0.2120372951,
-0.3831358254,
-0.228344053,
0.0519347191,
-0.7741174698,
0.183280319,
-0.3387226462,
-0.054672692,
0.0009082119,
-0.2966218591,
-0.7256076336,
0.2413627952,
-0.0558122434,
0.5665253401,
-1.133908987,
0.7300570607,
0.6599102616,
-0.2292134613,
-0.8544577956,
0.1143048406,
-0.3357111216,
-0.512090385,
0.8815743327,
0.0514172539,
-0.038783934,
-0.0190596599,
-0.4395003617,
-0.8758100271,
1.0257861614,
0.6220211983,
-0.3907529414,
0.4063610435,
0.0388082452,
0.5930609107,
-0.4837865829,
0.2448143512,
0.3052922487,
0.2681182623,
-0.1008941233,
-0.8590407372,
0.3182127774,
-0.0447432511,
0.0847252533,
0.0346101709,
-0.6580830216,
0.7858224511,
-0.1491312534,
-0.4559313059,
-0.1421984285,
0.6854689121,
0.3904949129,
0.3755538762,
0.4833671451,
0.2787397504,
0.6977640986,
0.0135664046,
1.2058264017,
-0.1029678583,
0.1220978424,
1.5863865614,
-0.2875500619,
0.7123483419,
0.6768040657,
0.0012799161,
0.525378108,
0.638196826,
0.215185374,
0.8013061285,
0.1549915373,
-0.0376682766,
-0.3189474046,
-0.3301725686,
-0.2041300237,
0.0955637023,
0.119656682,
-0.3597754836,
-0.3099468052,
0.073888436,
-0.2075498551,
0.2559413612,
-0.407351315,
0.9331613183,
-0.2151648849,
-0.5753084421,
0.9200283885,
-0.1707909405,
0.4708113968,
-0.3567323089,
-0.2047968954,
-0.438626945,
0.1946647912,
-0.1256810576,
-0.5059637427,
0.1209021881,
-0.2546224892,
-0.406595856,
-0.0443020463,
0.5424043536,
-0.4710584283,
-0.2565310895,
0.3063465953,
0.1315916926,
-0.0285103414,
0.068864651,
-0.3126715422,
-0.0637687892,
-0.2381303459,
-0.2551821172,
0.6047714353,
0.5592415929,
-0.5989148617,
0.5389683843,
0.3483377397,
-0.3738950193,
0.309607923,
0.4288194776,
0.8780808449,
-0.2908162773,
-0.3549571335,
-0.9513480067,
0.4942058921,
-0.194118157,
-0.2546962202,
0.882763207,
0.5633693337,
1.0930758715,
-0.1871682107,
0.3144052327,
0.312877506,
0.2843791842,
-0.4989437163,
0.3459814191,
-0.3639683425,
0.3543224037,
-0.421043545,
-0.6056551933,
-0.624973774,
0.4967089891,
-0.3184828162,
-0.2438818216,
0.5880509615,
0.7294791341,
-0.1674592644,
-0.3203496635,
0.52914083,
0.3973260522,
0.1766982377,
0.5095357299,
0.6578405499,
-0.5108023286,
0.124281235,
-0.3239903152,
-0.1231299862,
-0.1999214888,
-0.8545123935,
-0.8121451735,
-0.6944241524,
-0.4822538793,
-0.1928342432,
0.0505258814,
0.7974706888,
0.5255524516,
-1.0003538132,
-0.071183607,
-0.3172971904,
0.2116455436,
-0.3489877284,
-0.2315481603,
0.717199564,
-0.5786472559,
-0.63830024,
0.3902366459,
0.3217470646,
0.1884996444,
0.2268322408,
0.0400527641,
-0.1343667507,
0.0027941961,
0.7303580046,
0.3425327837,
-0.7572500706,
-0.6156891584,
-0.1812313497,
-0.1410132498,
0.1121966839,
0.7195085287,
-0.8822664022,
0.5126992464,
0.4331874251,
0.607437849,
0.3072949052,
0.1870537549,
0.5522018671,
-0.9367800951,
0.3685339093,
-0.063586846,
0.4334640205,
0.3245522678,
-0.4253919125,
0.335796684,
0.0736455843,
-0.393776238,
-0.730880022,
0.4954538047,
-0.9601152539,
-0.3736055791,
1.1322981119,
-0.1828876585,
0.1488378942,
-0.4716789126,
-0.0543303266,
0.477055788,
-0.2716670334,
0.867251873,
0.4096010625,
-0.3321480453,
0.1791543663,
-0.2474527657,
0.6055892706,
0.7657212019,
-0.5067502856,
0.4227673411,
0.4999369979,
0.1630393416,
0.1248639897,
0.3707871735,
-0.0874673948,
0.1837497503,
-0.3903237879,
-0.2373058349,
-0.0299795456,
-0.3778422177,
-0.8139274716,
0.0668838099,
0.1669102162,
-0.1426511556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15631v1
|
Fine-Grained Self-Endorsement Improves Factuality and Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T22:24:40 | 2024-02-23T22:24:40 |
Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Lifeng Jin, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work studies improving large language model (LLM) generations at
inference time by mitigating fact-conflicting hallucinations. Particularly, we
propose a self-endorsement framework that leverages the fine-grained fact-level
comparisons across multiple sampled responses. Compared with prior ensemble
methods (Wang et al., 2022;Chen et al., 2023)) that perform response-level
selection, our approach can better alleviate hallucinations, especially for
longform generation tasks. Our approach can broadly benefit smaller and
open-source LLMs as it mainly conducts simple content-based comparisons.
Experiments on Biographies show that our method can effectively improve the
factuality of generations with simple and intuitive prompts across different
scales of LLMs. Besides, comprehensive analyses on TriviaQA and GSM8K
demonstrate the potential of self-endorsement for broader application.
|
[
-0.456155628,
-0.7063883543,
0.8199724555,
0.2805343866,
-0.0366824009,
0.0054306155,
-0.2756782472,
-0.6530290842,
0.3376992047,
0.718528688,
-0.2643146515,
-0.2698408365,
-0.4889737666,
0.2833676934,
-0.4057238698,
0.9280797243,
0.5342110991,
-0.2073598206,
-0.3816766441,
0.0196926501,
-0.0889139399,
-0.2919650972,
-0.8814054132,
-0.3493068218,
0.5701239705,
0.3881308138,
0.6719232202,
0.6587626934,
0.2210558355,
0.4252242148,
-0.0413703248,
0.5810927749,
-0.519608438,
0.3416939974,
-0.3595203161,
-0.1825366169,
-0.428674221,
0.1586553454,
0.4128685594,
0.5903602839,
0.0360978022,
0.1484716684,
0.2827219367,
0.6629283428,
-0.773394227,
0.0382868163,
-0.7686979771,
-0.0025769842,
-0.0993411019,
-0.2174542844,
-0.6351683736,
-0.5192092657,
-0.0324026123,
-0.3471990526,
0.5404127836,
0.2164520472,
0.5530529618,
0.291670531,
-0.1903576553,
-0.4020499587,
-0.8127531409,
0.7229793072,
-0.8632696867,
0.3683498502,
0.3473496139,
0.2742774785,
-0.4097195864,
-0.5750562549,
-0.7412340045,
-0.3748728633,
-0.3595075905,
0.0993218049,
-0.0340479948,
0.3010155559,
0.3003963828,
0.506986022,
-0.43543607,
0.2823655307,
-0.3383499384,
-0.5090383291,
0.6256942153,
0.0896518752,
0.1282636523,
-0.4555377662,
-0.3392109275,
-0.0274224225,
-0.6979663968,
-0.2320016026,
0.3529442847,
0.4443505704,
0.0098479791,
0.5100761652,
-0.7189590335,
0.5590446591,
0.5715131164,
-0.2087842971,
0.317422092,
-0.3445616663,
-0.2589915395,
0.4267062545,
0.786753118,
0.2477448583,
0.2365572453,
-0.224701494,
-0.0644682273,
-0.0848513246,
-0.0431575179,
-1.0030994415,
-0.100348711,
0.5138456225,
-0.5463245511,
-0.1092983782,
0.0937814862,
-1.3314776421,
-0.8596832752,
-0.3443410099,
0.5310431719,
-0.2380508631,
0.0497516952,
0.2312138677,
-0.0838336349,
0.1544962823,
0.3675013185,
-1.1631009579,
-0.1301071495,
0.6006721854,
0.5873048902,
-0.0486662537,
-0.2700729668,
-0.8563413024,
0.1537981778,
-0.3825010359,
1.1574221849,
-0.6808098555,
-0.1927155703,
0.0314667039,
-0.216391921,
0.1535908431,
-0.7404008508,
0.5250571966,
-0.263467133,
0.5029038191,
-0.187696889,
-0.461507529,
0.0468973368,
0.0426746011,
-0.4396861792,
1.1801979542,
-0.1432372928,
-0.532366693,
0.5688313246,
-0.181415543,
-0.5270544291,
0.0068546538,
-0.3729774356,
-0.2626408339,
0.3054990172,
0.3770652413,
0.770599544,
0.0107232453,
0.2995042503,
-0.5549508929,
-0.1413179338,
0.035632398,
-0.625757575,
0.4625012279,
0.4552307129,
-0.4654069841,
0.0492961183,
-1.1438421011,
-0.1844085008,
-0.2479726374,
-0.3440297544,
-0.4367442429,
0.0007311954,
-0.6341506839,
0.2381290346,
0.218021661,
-0.6115181446,
0.2071463019,
-0.5796984434,
0.0885410011,
0.7695522904,
0.0609983206,
0.2608627975,
-0.2127406001,
0.1883657128,
0.0992909819,
0.0103244185,
-0.216992259,
-0.3338816166,
-0.9006471634,
-0.5254991651,
0.3475908041,
0.1535547972,
-0.6558870673,
0.7585342526,
-0.1449777335,
-0.2869258821,
-0.507979095,
0.1776630133,
0.1485568136,
0.5209425092,
0.5053191781,
0.0312535092,
-0.626686573,
-0.9898918271,
-0.3852200508,
-0.3551084101,
-0.0688828751,
0.21354267,
0.1651250571,
-0.1947184205,
0.8484439254,
-0.4760506451,
-0.258308053,
-0.0625051185,
0.3832208216,
-0.001508737,
0.3859551549,
0.4049359858,
-0.307084322,
-0.2527762353,
-0.0918047726,
-0.7606281042,
-0.3333717287,
-0.5556783676,
-0.1634652913,
0.144330129,
0.4672119617,
-0.7063347101,
0.2800824642,
0.4577828348,
-0.600586772,
0.4891840219,
-0.3508496284,
0.3951001763,
-0.9429172873,
-0.3329361379,
0.0321793519,
-0.2605982125,
-0.5265314579,
-0.1717012823,
-0.1349933296,
0.4155077338,
-0.1056157202,
0.670514226,
-0.2904089391,
-0.1580657214,
-0.4108391404,
0.4092569649,
-0.023950709,
0.0819707438,
-0.1195178106,
1.0395327806,
0.4391048551,
-0.5928062201,
-0.0756639615,
0.1518377811,
-0.5062807202,
0.4829096198,
-0.2934446633,
0.0950827301,
-0.3227296472,
0.1753372401,
-1.0712532997,
-0.4451937079,
0.1987464279,
-0.2299844921,
0.2251476347,
0.2843543887,
-0.4131047726,
-0.4339265823,
-0.4160174131,
0.0587858781,
0.3438276052,
-0.9979518056,
1.036208868,
0.0993522182,
-0.051377628,
-0.490190804,
-0.5552639365,
0.3009848893,
-0.3216553926,
-0.4498283565,
0.1575049609,
-0.2795901895,
-0.4131480753,
-0.3908216655,
-0.2125651538,
0.0999997184,
0.0145995794,
0.0850748047,
0.1589935273,
-0.2686622739,
0.2523624301,
0.2045689076,
0.0652919561,
0.0095630875,
-0.1635898501,
0.3225923777,
-0.0905194506,
0.0407826006,
-0.2592136264,
-0.0138787888,
0.5217030048,
-0.0941301957,
0.5448245406,
0.5669518113,
-0.109421514,
-0.4383706748,
-1.109778285,
-0.4086548388,
-0.5255177617,
-0.0384844616,
-0.3153083622,
-1.1802083254,
0.3075450659,
-0.0400038697,
-0.1231411994,
0.6404131651,
0.7284505367,
0.0327887014,
0.8766768575,
0.1120777503,
0.0107615758,
0.3667666912,
0.0808722749,
0.227208674,
-0.6687936187,
-0.1140215695,
-0.5632837415,
0.0771888122,
-0.6178659201,
-0.4608228505,
0.0635045171,
-0.0578731708,
-0.0909373984,
0.0465603471,
-0.5925417542,
0.4839511514,
0.2999984324,
0.1846146584,
0.5192086697,
0.0994596928,
0.0556605086,
0.1555230469,
-0.6073964238,
-0.6744180918,
0.9225129485,
0.2353787273,
0.815038085,
-0.0207926705,
0.8337005973,
0.6396260262,
0.3146842122,
-0.5841647983,
0.8074445128,
-0.2492692173,
-0.8411964774,
-0.4180848598,
-0.4976839423,
-0.9134227037,
0.3271579146,
-0.5546392202,
-0.9252246022,
0.4887396395,
0.3522953391,
-0.9723935127,
0.0673842207,
-0.6870614886,
0.4953243732,
-0.1082204431,
-0.480273366,
-0.43680951,
-0.3477052152,
0.5518857837,
-0.3118781745,
0.2550570369,
-0.2723517716,
0.3000197709,
0.6939591765,
-0.137088269,
1.0476002693,
-0.0606640279,
-0.2350848615,
0.4940645695,
0.1030445024,
0.5692281723,
0.055922579,
-0.3155763149,
0.1571266204,
-0.0447355472,
-0.1222587898,
-0.7641873956,
0.8435624838,
-0.496416837,
-1.1071807146,
-0.2578959465,
-0.511611104,
-0.3701052368,
0.2757448852,
-0.0380448177,
0.6029513478,
-0.0878875256,
0.5527260303,
0.691049993,
-0.1404567212,
0.4042498767,
0.3900691867,
-0.2978185415,
-0.4737127721,
0.7720308304,
0.0813471526,
0.3898976445,
0.1354573667,
0.7076207399,
-0.3693792224,
-0.5399434566,
-0.309487164,
0.2026018798,
-0.7761974931,
-0.1658758521,
-1.0222285986,
-0.0576564148,
-0.6584687829,
0.072030589,
-0.2677359283,
-0.5168238878,
-0.1308246553,
-0.2023656666,
0.1073518544,
0.7658995986,
-0.3590420783,
0.3392008543,
-0.478976965,
0.6998823285,
0.663880229,
0.2479806989,
0.106068939,
-0.5237033367,
-0.1482716054,
-0.0868960693,
-0.2531909645,
-0.4472704828,
-0.2042700648,
0.3232396245,
0.6342978477,
0.724732697,
0.1304784119,
0.7976692915,
-0.4302532971,
0.9205573797,
0.1159608886,
-0.9396657944,
0.3825807571,
-0.1799874157,
-0.0419636443,
0.7515339851,
0.0211601779,
-0.155619815,
-0.7089554667,
-0.5406089425,
-0.4063080549,
0.405235976,
0.2019068599,
0.2633203566,
-0.3521192074,
0.4560110271,
0.2942877114,
0.1564088166,
-0.5962194204,
-0.1549290717,
-0.2783118188,
-0.3584116697,
0.0275742058,
-0.5725286007,
0.0561097339,
-0.2466824651,
0.8757988214,
-0.4892704487,
0.0410305634,
0.5051674843,
0.2975508869,
-0.0953214616,
0.316411525,
0.596100986,
0.4431997836,
-0.0649323687,
0.5090687871,
0.3747121692,
-0.195738107,
0.0699750334,
-0.0272324961,
-0.288061142,
-0.1494835764,
0.5152633786,
0.5580813289,
0.1584830284,
-0.3223206103,
0.1981472522,
0.154490307,
-0.0299984142,
0.2091734558,
0.4228981435,
-0.0353042856,
0.445310086,
0.3173852265,
-0.1254732013,
0.3623506725,
-0.7349479795,
0.3211728632,
0.6066547632,
-0.0203690864,
-0.0835511908,
0.687887907,
0.2088912576,
-0.1743771583,
0.1940893084,
-0.2372150123,
-0.2889125049,
0.4000475407,
0.6051796079,
0.9658010602,
-0.3300800622,
0.3439469039,
0.6251600385,
0.2588627934,
-0.4141181409,
-0.0274703484,
-0.0515428074,
-0.8573017716,
-0.5173399448,
-0.7390289903,
-0.1529437602,
0.2788937092,
-0.3583706021,
0.0998167321,
-0.4088970721,
-0.1561129093,
0.3049547374,
-0.0584750511,
-0.401769042,
0.5064542294,
0.3350428641,
0.7016057968,
-0.7137144208,
0.7359780669,
0.1139297113,
-0.2845631242,
-0.7207841277,
0.4717953205,
-0.1263924241,
-0.7299385071,
0.6237188578,
0.2417808175,
-0.4633296132,
0.0647517815,
-0.5504664779,
-0.8152109981,
0.8285734653,
0.2213870734,
-0.6544975042,
0.0259402674,
0.0903767198,
0.6573131084,
-0.6625950336,
0.2084007412,
0.7594242096,
0.6337667704,
0.3147321045,
-0.5646191835,
0.1432267129,
0.4388749301,
-0.1682030112,
-0.1004833281,
-0.7302149534,
0.5504987836,
-0.2137420177,
-0.2480450571,
0.2312516421,
1.2455378771,
0.4385119081,
0.4536516368,
0.8091461658,
0.2837345302,
1.0677435398,
0.170484066,
0.8694379926,
-0.6377808452,
0.4502143562,
1.4236665964,
-0.2017262131,
0.6177899241,
0.5138077736,
-0.1576278359,
0.733478725,
0.5316191316,
-0.1837703884,
0.3008612096,
-0.0201245099,
-0.2847933173,
-0.7665736675,
-0.1966962218,
-0.2411176264,
0.4913952351,
0.1754672229,
-0.3599832356,
-0.3790442348,
-0.0652691722,
-0.0293813236,
0.2830980122,
-0.3176085651,
0.7070288062,
0.2020569593,
-0.8904533386,
0.3181958199,
-0.3882285058,
0.5870255828,
-0.3715765774,
-0.0324033238,
-0.2941165566,
-0.0090187676,
-0.4332360923,
-0.746712923,
0.0922822878,
-0.0677619576,
-0.1831805408,
0.1295315921,
1.0505723953,
-0.5141987801,
-0.5007981062,
0.3406621814,
0.5188661218,
0.1446309984,
0.011725124,
-0.4792239666,
-0.0802524611,
-0.0768604279,
-0.2651125193,
0.0893243179,
0.524953723,
0.0941174328,
0.6004452705,
0.5853638649,
0.2766323984,
0.0135884462,
0.2065988779,
0.5539980531,
-0.584816277,
-0.3621825278,
-1.0448048115,
0.2368825823,
-0.2721321285,
-0.1326608658,
1.1438341141,
0.6725463271,
0.6937579513,
-0.0102115469,
0.7046304941,
0.0057073776,
0.4079167247,
-0.7321001887,
0.5013840199,
-0.5575995445,
0.2613316178,
-0.2215845436,
-0.9431346655,
-0.2735654414,
0.5279696584,
-0.5632567406,
0.2016345412,
0.5680626631,
1.0616990328,
0.0186801236,
0.1066974103,
0.5797329545,
0.5486155152,
0.1701467931,
0.0508947782,
0.9942994118,
-0.143156752,
0.2799698412,
-0.1779514253,
-0.0773408338,
-0.2955694497,
-0.9728670716,
-1.3086531162,
-0.2600486577,
-0.4558266103,
-0.7385854721,
0.0556945801,
1.347460866,
0.7007744908,
-0.9656040668,
0.029213544,
0.1698398143,
0.2314217687,
-0.0437788591,
-0.1894693226,
0.2119770497,
-0.6142143011,
-0.6805417538,
0.6525646448,
0.4599929154,
0.0199986044,
-0.5287406445,
0.0474808738,
0.0382567272,
0.6016640663,
0.8225197196,
0.061111521,
-0.9394665956,
-0.920178771,
-0.3800137043,
-0.1901676506,
0.4283155501,
0.7238019705,
-0.8413829207,
0.5770820975,
0.4867225587,
0.5779912472,
0.1021209136,
0.3794815838,
0.1431777477,
-0.4648841918,
-0.0844341591,
-0.2144094855,
0.3317387998,
0.3371221721,
-0.8027197123,
0.4844576716,
0.2178163528,
-0.5808804631,
-0.6255581975,
0.0938031748,
-0.9250251651,
-0.2701941431,
1.4502931833,
0.13981691,
-0.1898274124,
-0.2094442248,
-0.186269626,
0.1126381457,
-0.4223513007,
1.3499584198,
0.674724102,
-0.0682694092,
0.1143788025,
-0.440834254,
0.6400228739,
0.4186220169,
-1.018286705,
0.4402331114,
0.5871604085,
0.167881012,
0.2924705744,
0.4444078207,
0.1558178514,
0.0127559733,
-0.1029634252,
0.0838252828,
0.0336088128,
-0.7051582336,
-0.3412733972,
0.2491490096,
0.1430092901,
0.1448129416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15623v1
|
Language-Based User Profiles for Recommendation
| 2024-02-23T21:58:50 | 2024-02-23T21:58:50 |
Joyce Zhou, Yijia Dai, Thorsten Joachims
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Most conventional recommendation methods (e.g., matrix factorization)
represent user profiles as high-dimensional vectors. Unfortunately, these
vectors lack interpretability and steerability, and often perform poorly in
cold-start settings. To address these shortcomings, we explore the use of user
profiles that are represented as human-readable text. We propose the
Language-based Factorization Model (LFM), which is essentially an
encoder/decoder model where both the encoder and the decoder are large language
models (LLMs). The encoder LLM generates a compact natural-language profile of
the user's interests from the user's rating history. The decoder LLM uses this
summary profile to complete predictive downstream tasks. We evaluate our LFM
approach on the MovieLens dataset, comparing it against matrix factorization
and an LLM model that directly predicts from the user's rating history. In
cold-start settings, we find that our method can have higher accuracy than
matrix factorization. Furthermore, we find that generating a compact and
human-readable summary often performs comparably with or better than direct LLM
prediction, while enjoying better interpretability and shorter model input
length. Our results motivate a number of future research directions and
potential improvements.
|
[
-0.353695482,
-0.3965097666,
0.5866689682,
0.0915910006,
-0.3360511661,
0.2810752094,
-0.1668368578,
-0.3740019798,
0.5142810941,
0.8196999431,
-0.676094234,
-0.5103567243,
-0.291656673,
0.0819625929,
-0.4039341807,
1.2905292511,
-0.0682267398,
-0.0686292499,
-0.369082123,
0.02052797,
-0.5787734985,
-0.7055641413,
-0.553615272,
-0.8253642917,
0.6201692224,
0.5565267205,
0.9324353933,
0.7456453443,
0.3074917495,
0.1892652065,
0.02771613,
0.2934670448,
-0.6087033749,
0.2284896523,
-0.0313905366,
-0.1081883907,
-0.3173953593,
-0.0150123853,
0.3794125617,
0.7026971579,
-0.146554783,
0.1223339438,
0.1129541248,
0.7203007936,
-0.3371303678,
0.3168702424,
-0.0190952625,
0.0825148895,
-0.036367707,
-0.1920532882,
-0.3656715155,
-0.1622914523,
0.4259896874,
-0.3485700786,
0.4248552322,
0.4452104568,
0.4771932065,
-0.2655262947,
-0.4584536254,
-0.2763596177,
-1.2600131035,
0.7190437913,
-0.4735686779,
0.6245042086,
0.9296832085,
0.379009366,
-0.0628605559,
-0.2125266045,
-0.325635612,
-0.3006945252,
-0.4559859931,
-0.2308251858,
-0.2504660487,
-0.1624578983,
0.1781428903,
0.3699374497,
-0.61410743,
0.0120147625,
-0.4228648245,
-0.390100807,
0.4699762762,
0.2883618772,
0.1501413584,
-0.0782989115,
-0.3872941136,
-0.154653132,
-0.599337101,
0.3315357268,
0.3386555016,
0.4470937848,
-0.2085760683,
0.6968003511,
-0.4207345545,
0.4169944823,
0.2845768034,
-0.095612444,
0.0472159311,
-0.4876614511,
-0.1519145072,
0.0687610805,
0.7076116204,
0.7185530066,
0.5770384073,
-0.399825871,
-0.3550829887,
-0.2528810799,
0.032572221,
-1.1101363897,
-0.2418420762,
0.222854048,
-0.6365640759,
-0.1776821464,
0.2304987162,
-0.6931300759,
-0.8170307875,
-0.2128107995,
0.0410164185,
-0.4528877139,
0.004869625,
0.1589813977,
0.1944086403,
-0.1337105036,
0.1688753814,
-0.8860695362,
0.3687518537,
0.3855345249,
0.8407155871,
-0.2755927145,
-0.1729120016,
-0.7934166193,
0.0080873743,
0.0459971689,
0.8273475766,
-0.7351480722,
-0.6801531315,
0.4261291921,
-0.0045329714,
0.3772937357,
-0.3846725523,
0.4414037168,
-0.5270155072,
0.4173313677,
-0.4668267369,
-0.429710269,
-0.1999193281,
0.098565653,
-0.5831121206,
0.9160583019,
0.1288220882,
-0.4419825375,
0.5343903303,
-0.5213549137,
-0.4727264047,
0.1186627075,
0.099187158,
-0.1168478504,
-0.0838315561,
0.5417313576,
0.9441476464,
-0.2500101626,
0.3906185329,
-0.1617709994,
-0.7016500235,
0.1947139651,
-0.1659362316,
0.2742840648,
0.2363571227,
0.1629981101,
0.3913969994,
-0.7215282321,
-0.4848757088,
0.0111116823,
-0.5655477643,
-0.1357516646,
0.2892351449,
0.4231557548,
0.1324291676,
0.4564104974,
-0.6151826382,
-0.0073821917,
-0.39406389,
0.2704926729,
0.7588125467,
-0.1526007652,
0.7562497854,
-0.280821234,
0.7471651435,
0.0955853015,
-0.2515302598,
-0.465734005,
-0.2705726624,
-0.6655997634,
-0.0942215547,
-0.0468454137,
0.6428849697,
-0.8959429264,
0.5138605237,
-0.1324452311,
-0.421066761,
-0.1370951682,
0.5382332206,
0.3857953548,
0.3333623409,
0.3497818708,
-0.4121213853,
-0.4901629984,
-0.9602338076,
-0.1078947112,
-0.501904726,
-0.2073626965,
0.5456233621,
0.1803383529,
-0.4723944664,
0.8591482043,
-0.8373470902,
-0.4554969072,
-0.7170932889,
-0.273860395,
0.5495877266,
0.13646245,
0.3875330985,
-0.2731155157,
-0.5455585718,
-0.0860190764,
-0.5127237439,
0.0140109602,
-0.1221611202,
-0.1435139775,
-0.3155842423,
0.4256666601,
-0.3426531851,
0.1419208795,
0.3731614649,
-0.9997359514,
0.2822894454,
-0.5247582793,
0.0556603223,
-1.2098493576,
-0.016644422,
0.6529323459,
-0.5785962939,
-0.6506549716,
-0.2947363853,
-0.1991105825,
-0.4131367505,
-0.1873223782,
0.7143517137,
-0.0654322803,
0.1004386991,
-0.2901320755,
-0.1381695718,
0.0201967321,
0.6313388348,
-0.0450995341,
0.6829884648,
0.3677546084,
-0.3525751531,
0.3005127311,
0.3376497626,
-0.598013103,
0.5374329686,
-0.631254971,
0.2900621891,
-0.290263921,
0.4107283354,
-0.7817425132,
-0.121154055,
0.2092066854,
0.101689212,
0.0933684185,
-0.1267275363,
-0.506754458,
-0.136202231,
-0.4354741275,
0.1770985872,
0.4640762806,
-0.5716376901,
0.7656273246,
0.162988618,
-0.1604570001,
-0.4148405194,
-0.1821283996,
0.1773260385,
-0.202804625,
-0.518796742,
0.4058758914,
-0.3187392056,
-0.1251591146,
-0.2014622837,
0.258143425,
-0.1159092039,
-0.1109126508,
0.4556313753,
0.4754648507,
-0.0959250852,
0.0468359664,
-0.3242803216,
-0.111625649,
-0.219522506,
-0.2013265938,
0.6706578135,
-0.2326993495,
0.2662861645,
-0.3701761663,
0.5336697698,
0.4651053548,
-0.2408165932,
0.7911574841,
1.0518803596,
-0.1717773974,
-0.1861872673,
-0.46754843,
-0.4776191115,
-0.4931202829,
0.4249959886,
-0.0456296802,
-1.1854691505,
0.4774134457,
0.2316367626,
0.037668217,
0.0823877007,
0.6057329178,
-0.5129037499,
1.0777827501,
1.0892957449,
-0.3145987988,
0.7285023928,
-0.1002994701,
0.3049550354,
-0.5445607901,
-0.3446281552,
-0.3257570267,
-0.4391614497,
-0.3809473813,
-0.1325574368,
0.0668298081,
0.1588608623,
-0.0886034518,
0.4381430149,
-0.2550432086,
0.5595852137,
0.5311499238,
0.1303920895,
0.2397915125,
0.201460883,
-0.1980223209,
-0.170567438,
-0.4353668094,
-0.5295564532,
0.8778401017,
0.4792919457,
0.9779024124,
0.1676801741,
0.4503671527,
0.774782896,
0.2094097733,
-0.8941368461,
0.5482724905,
-0.5271953344,
-0.416336298,
-0.2028692812,
-0.1360667497,
-0.7664810419,
-0.0315882303,
-0.5894039273,
-0.8725558519,
0.2724084854,
0.3086256981,
-0.4058236778,
0.1636684537,
-0.5952984095,
0.5689788461,
-0.1489194483,
-0.1901579648,
-0.0877834409,
-0.1233036593,
0.1591659486,
-0.1334878653,
0.2331373245,
-0.2493419349,
0.3289460242,
1.0016486645,
-0.321675837,
0.9049851894,
-0.2219373435,
0.1016141921,
-0.0798358396,
0.44829005,
0.6893570423,
0.0942365155,
-0.231989041,
0.1227028891,
0.0902042165,
-0.1296331584,
-0.7182825208,
0.7636064291,
-0.7034901381,
-0.6106677055,
-0.2982337773,
-0.4316469729,
-0.2924291492,
0.2922488451,
-0.1385214776,
0.7976697683,
-0.306665659,
0.3249447346,
0.2294277102,
-0.2648002803,
0.3064884543,
0.6666184664,
-0.7024724483,
-0.493640393,
1.1365562677,
-0.2400613874,
-0.3259061277,
0.33773157,
0.3098839223,
-0.2203793973,
-0.5433863997,
-0.6440918446,
0.3500026166,
-0.71119982,
0.1355418414,
-0.4676020443,
0.2491240054,
-0.0711166114,
-0.3424035311,
-0.0479013696,
0.0174885262,
-0.2647353709,
-0.2348191887,
0.3935070336,
1.0007821321,
0.3675500751,
0.3336429894,
-0.430087775,
0.2302535176,
0.0055670706,
0.6122978926,
-0.164268434,
-0.3736203611,
-1.0112477541,
-0.3552573621,
-0.0413538143,
-0.5039381981,
0.4740379453,
0.280485481,
0.3111896813,
0.6637376547,
0.0301877446,
0.256816417,
-0.5575833321,
0.7594269514,
0.1411899775,
-0.5586889386,
0.4538308978,
-0.3445896506,
0.6087939739,
0.6864201427,
0.3761972487,
-0.7172667384,
-0.0921342149,
0.1756953597,
-0.611070931,
0.7412276268,
0.1627434939,
0.3701708019,
0.2151530236,
0.487018317,
0.3102454245,
-0.0369496681,
-0.327462852,
-0.2699374557,
-0.191072464,
-0.1121098548,
-0.9096532464,
-0.6527181268,
0.284805119,
-0.2175271064,
0.5683130026,
-0.1786552072,
0.1467843056,
0.0094997864,
0.0147332037,
-0.3379400074,
0.1840312928,
0.5262773037,
0.6714852452,
-0.8780071139,
0.0150124198,
-0.0798965916,
-0.4435876906,
0.1315176338,
-0.0477854609,
-0.2105816156,
-0.1000971422,
0.4040293694,
0.9587088227,
0.1857729703,
-0.8261865973,
0.2602807581,
-0.3416258395,
0.0606676452,
-0.2999592721,
-0.0230403356,
0.1387376934,
0.1133549735,
0.2469349205,
0.2578313053,
0.0043603149,
-0.7991367579,
-0.0051854248,
0.2035551667,
-0.9430174828,
-0.4714416265,
0.415948391,
0.5302824974,
-0.5401486754,
0.6826207042,
0.2361998856,
-0.2577235103,
0.0748651922,
0.442474395,
1.0919106007,
0.096828118,
0.4476285577,
0.2262318581,
0.0075756111,
-0.0946537554,
0.0871373042,
-0.1866999716,
-1.1132175922,
-0.2718961537,
-0.968549192,
-0.3962596059,
0.0005597619,
-0.7018326521,
0.4046219587,
-0.6503756046,
-0.2652405202,
0.2009685338,
-0.0200108141,
-1.0006905794,
0.097890988,
0.1214359924,
0.6195522547,
-0.7394596338,
0.9582805037,
0.7849817872,
-0.311930269,
-0.3963837922,
-0.033570122,
0.0601844937,
-0.4676347673,
0.6387324333,
0.1490302086,
-0.397754401,
-0.2122064084,
-0.0153682539,
-0.6582752466,
1.0654258728,
0.2698128223,
-0.3225433528,
-0.0584477,
0.0219093133,
0.6713502407,
-0.8246065378,
0.0839640871,
0.5132582784,
0.2038482726,
0.060477864,
-0.7518378496,
0.0984502882,
-0.344342351,
-0.0192383882,
0.0571967922,
-0.1654060781,
0.5482969284,
-0.2265074402,
-0.2119708955,
-0.1582770199,
0.6330964565,
-0.0161077697,
0.1916201264,
0.5520752668,
-0.0387144387,
0.5081806779,
0.291426748,
1.4634908438,
-0.4188673198,
0.060384322,
0.9380477667,
-0.3694035113,
1.0802809,
0.3014169633,
-0.2106900364,
0.8748419881,
0.5955730677,
-0.1760946065,
0.4526107311,
-0.1384429038,
-0.0634058788,
-0.5674230456,
-0.3663092554,
0.1841728091,
0.5182097554,
-0.0055207768,
-0.7333174944,
-0.1053281575,
0.0707965121,
0.0445133597,
0.233989045,
-0.1326523125,
0.7153556347,
0.0673620701,
-0.4936987758,
0.2676610947,
0.5391796231,
1.0031933784,
-0.4884939194,
-0.1019816622,
-0.3386955559,
0.1477769017,
-0.2195072174,
-0.7997169495,
-0.0198121276,
0.2945638895,
-0.8041940331,
-0.7474025488,
0.9281646013,
-0.4043669701,
-0.9237651825,
0.2811402977,
0.6955423951,
0.1759113371,
0.1285615563,
-0.3815107346,
-0.1348003447,
0.1675133556,
-0.0544746928,
0.3619225025,
-0.4234394431,
-0.1789263487,
0.9082398415,
0.8297954202,
0.0637626052,
-0.6330823898,
0.222364977,
0.4635879397,
-0.8914317489,
-0.6775745153,
-0.9167692661,
0.1614710838,
0.3398014605,
-0.3830727637,
0.7400385737,
0.5156703591,
0.6690222621,
-0.0569302514,
0.5617794991,
0.3987138271,
0.4558015168,
-0.5198195577,
0.7956585884,
-0.2972103059,
0.7230473161,
-0.0144010568,
-1.2154377699,
-0.0084957536,
0.2073794156,
-0.2706106901,
0.3540404141,
0.3149121106,
0.7492536306,
-0.0388929136,
-0.2450944334,
0.5778986812,
0.0301377326,
0.4449288249,
0.371789068,
0.5260811448,
0.0758520439,
0.4409318864,
-0.4016047418,
-0.0742166713,
-0.4557101727,
-0.7335707545,
-1.4064295292,
-0.7137118578,
-0.2497340143,
-0.6089631319,
-0.0919151604,
1.2204580307,
0.7689447999,
-1.0263962746,
-0.6630179882,
0.4565898478,
-0.0116146952,
-0.0909894407,
-0.214942649,
0.4141793251,
0.4875166416,
-0.5235154629,
0.7696842551,
0.2615583241,
-0.1454306543,
-0.9423682094,
-0.3714976609,
0.1863982677,
0.217451483,
0.7266085744,
0.0958172753,
-0.7830627561,
-0.3281953037,
0.0431032144,
-0.0772271752,
-0.1301459372,
1.1036128998,
-0.9942889214,
0.679063797,
0.5133880377,
0.1999507695,
0.6344640851,
0.1187919378,
1.1861337423,
-0.6964199543,
-0.2563902438,
-0.0684836358,
0.4638159871,
0.5297418237,
-0.7215076685,
0.2087867856,
-0.0499173403,
-0.2172787935,
-0.5635089874,
0.1211389601,
-1.0584020615,
-0.0668199584,
1.1032402515,
-0.1949488372,
0.2244022936,
-0.3434706032,
-0.3195772171,
-0.2445637286,
-0.8575689197,
0.6467936635,
0.7664263248,
-0.1533052474,
-0.2695981562,
-0.5061480403,
0.5334689617,
0.1387630403,
-0.3145830035,
0.1425725669,
0.3940484524,
0.3093091846,
-0.0495342277,
0.4239315689,
0.3639968336,
0.108540684,
-0.4389817119,
-0.1211296543,
-0.5494296551,
-0.1647869349,
-0.3830088079,
0.2171167284,
0.1616058648,
0.4217563868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15613v1
|
Towards Efficient Active Learning in NLP via Pretrained Representations
| 2024-02-23T21:28:59 | 2024-02-23T21:28:59 |
Artem Vysogorets, Achintya Gopal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) is now a common approach for text
classification in a wide range of applications. When labeled documents are
scarce, active learning helps save annotation efforts but requires retraining
of massive models on each acquisition iteration. We drastically expedite this
process by using pretrained representations of LLMs within the active learning
loop and, once the desired amount of labeled data is acquired, fine-tuning that
or even a different pretrained LLM on this labeled data to achieve the best
performance. As verified on common text classification benchmarks with
pretrained BERT and RoBERTa as the backbone, our strategy yields similar
performance to fine-tuning all the way through the active learning loop but is
orders of magnitude less computationally expensive. The data acquired with our
procedure generalizes across pretrained networks, allowing flexibility in
choosing the final model or updating it as newer versions get released.
|
[
0.0903741717,
-0.5631468892,
0.3643349111,
0.045693092,
-0.3950849175,
-0.1382946521,
-0.7217358351,
-0.4316435158,
0.0305316076,
0.6444557309,
-0.2605406642,
-0.5435394049,
-0.6626837254,
0.1370059997,
-0.3793014586,
1.0270975828,
-0.2657573223,
-0.0383884758,
0.1598662883,
-0.1397333145,
-0.0538006797,
-0.6439006329,
-0.8281268477,
-0.5110852122,
0.8790649176,
0.1200519502,
0.5766167045,
0.605222106,
0.3689320087,
0.3165491521,
-0.2111714929,
0.5341645479,
-0.5785863996,
0.3937579393,
-0.0089220824,
-0.650162816,
-0.6051785946,
0.2735441923,
0.8027735949,
0.818405509,
-0.1510391831,
0.0213856846,
0.1045877635,
0.5001616478,
-0.7272641063,
0.1317588091,
-0.9336625934,
0.2295987755,
-0.2076845914,
-0.2546444237,
-0.5486901999,
-0.1537691951,
0.0202279575,
-0.7229775786,
0.1779240221,
-0.0266581625,
0.9885458946,
0.4708167315,
-0.2557277381,
-0.2800150216,
-0.7953350544,
0.7341611981,
-0.5165988803,
0.4570409358,
0.6110235453,
0.0838018134,
-0.0341337435,
-1.1709339619,
-0.4171802104,
-0.1213051379,
0.0608328618,
0.0942897797,
-0.1517967582,
0.3285424709,
0.3028717041,
0.5322001576,
-0.2242362946,
0.4433876872,
-0.1959409714,
-0.0387582146,
0.6053705812,
-0.2416411638,
-0.0543047041,
0.2893896997,
-0.1303048581,
0.0051651835,
-0.6876000166,
-0.2175223529,
0.2099890858,
0.6826221347,
0.3046117127,
0.5762881637,
0.0634019002,
0.8659231067,
-0.0087270429,
0.034194883,
0.406332165,
-0.1737302989,
-0.3653334677,
0.0386468843,
0.6541216969,
-0.1641702652,
0.4504213631,
-0.2737755477,
-0.6139352918,
-0.1462633461,
0.5472956896,
-0.7681632042,
-0.5063691139,
-0.016082637,
-0.3532088399,
-0.199996531,
-0.1199810803,
-0.066527985,
-0.2518877089,
-0.6087075472,
0.6717793941,
-0.1074938178,
-0.054305777,
0.4177460372,
0.3312245309,
-0.1175501347,
0.6072707176,
-0.9614036083,
0.1249501035,
0.6130163074,
0.7734844685,
-0.203895092,
0.0137735512,
-0.6825180054,
0.2234120965,
-0.4299625456,
0.5809420347,
-0.5746678114,
0.0294150114,
0.1837051511,
0.1098158062,
0.0158505812,
-0.5341287851,
0.5753033161,
-0.7485923767,
-0.0814491957,
0.132624343,
-0.6912581921,
-0.1702241302,
0.341966331,
-0.7613883018,
1.1193454266,
-0.0514118001,
-0.5564386249,
0.465082854,
-0.4446755946,
-0.4019435644,
0.0446679704,
0.0125019597,
-0.6818632483,
0.1118267998,
0.1586880535,
0.9584369659,
0.18283768,
0.1258725375,
-0.093009375,
-0.247003749,
-0.0209692772,
-0.3433070481,
0.5124490261,
0.2365336269,
-0.1883009076,
0.3249909878,
-0.8433038592,
-0.0125804199,
-0.0828577429,
-0.8282396793,
-0.4646672904,
0.0529852659,
-0.1931490004,
-0.1389936656,
0.3959688246,
-0.3363513947,
0.492836386,
-0.4753531516,
0.1954635084,
0.7392747402,
-0.239882201,
0.6353404522,
0.0739247873,
0.4051126838,
-0.2472823709,
-0.0384998284,
-0.2641738951,
-0.2382109016,
-0.9395826459,
-0.2903347611,
0.770159483,
0.351911962,
-0.6260817647,
0.65890944,
-0.0307935253,
-0.560428977,
-0.5396513343,
0.5605230927,
0.3471660614,
0.0240911264,
0.515465796,
-0.1790979803,
-0.3559632003,
-0.5444230437,
-0.3080976009,
0.0246514697,
-0.091912128,
0.2208647877,
0.1544953734,
-0.4871917069,
0.513694346,
-0.4428227544,
-0.4366175532,
-0.4414689541,
0.3649793267,
0.2698220015,
0.4769324362,
0.4752019644,
-0.738445878,
-0.5553438067,
0.0344415009,
-0.5243556499,
-0.186132431,
-0.2281959504,
-0.1137982085,
0.0500997193,
0.824514091,
-0.3185553253,
0.2470068783,
0.6119167209,
-0.1192613766,
0.1244462579,
-0.418589741,
-0.3768649697,
-0.7350614667,
0.0133950869,
-0.1216966733,
-0.4650120437,
-0.5243811607,
-0.1014085561,
0.2365424484,
-0.2360846847,
-0.2768551111,
0.4376522005,
-0.8669043779,
0.099575907,
-0.2733647823,
0.136044383,
-0.1538554728,
0.4309336841,
0.1045986265,
0.6006025076,
0.6673581004,
-0.8301212192,
0.2245205641,
0.0962206647,
-0.436057657,
-0.3047092557,
-0.5359874964,
0.1683470011,
-0.2204888016,
0.3026402295,
-0.6186582446,
0.0187390521,
0.0477023795,
-0.1803257912,
0.7682541609,
-0.1235871688,
-0.6466995478,
-0.1083622277,
0.0168447886,
0.2019426227,
0.3330176473,
-0.7209377885,
0.795398891,
0.428699255,
0.0651549548,
-0.4909092784,
-0.5328875184,
-0.0968708396,
0.0351116024,
-0.1587405801,
0.483228147,
0.2898794413,
0.0849128142,
-0.0700410008,
-0.1403876692,
-0.0265432969,
0.3602721393,
-0.0306538101,
-0.1840692014,
-0.0600097068,
0.5460905433,
-0.0409613997,
-0.3017502725,
-0.1897022277,
-0.2875289619,
0.3712224066,
0.1847446859,
-0.3421554565,
-0.3679136932,
0.0527402982,
0.2912755311,
-0.5708527565,
0.8704229593,
0.7332348824,
-0.3878811598,
-0.6385520697,
-0.3788662851,
-0.1041064262,
-0.4674627781,
0.4482236207,
-0.0723533854,
-0.9187147617,
0.2832608819,
-0.5027356744,
0.5761891007,
0.2632903755,
0.4187762141,
-0.0937870517,
1.1021488905,
0.9291943312,
0.1624024957,
0.9288444519,
-0.4489423335,
0.2955231369,
-0.6477193236,
-0.2444098294,
-0.5357629657,
-0.5010996461,
-0.1729820669,
-0.787776053,
0.0125155831,
0.5080233216,
-0.1764298975,
0.171849981,
-0.5565518141,
0.5276499987,
0.4141225815,
0.2000511885,
0.1510132551,
-0.0335979052,
0.034721829,
-0.0943730101,
-0.8350225687,
-0.6416790485,
1.2694087029,
0.4611675143,
0.8862566948,
-0.0493715554,
0.752502799,
0.0985480696,
0.5899856091,
-0.9998620749,
0.5564427376,
-0.5372372866,
-0.5574384332,
-0.2046993226,
-0.452542305,
-1.2525078058,
0.1170858666,
-0.6181389689,
-0.2924603522,
0.0172064416,
0.3790624142,
-0.3966710269,
0.3868975937,
-0.6670196652,
0.7996223569,
-0.5127310753,
-0.3415308297,
-0.2710195482,
-0.5099743009,
-0.011296642,
-0.4749084413,
-0.186964646,
-0.1705065221,
-0.2638534904,
1.0642310381,
-0.2950199544,
1.0558155775,
-0.2784534395,
-0.0843512043,
0.1919115186,
-0.3410877883,
0.6312785149,
-0.0317794643,
-0.3376993239,
-0.0429026857,
-0.6340813637,
-0.3600705862,
-0.5567945838,
0.4480451345,
-0.917111814,
-0.375225991,
-0.3515852392,
-0.1770690531,
-0.3144584894,
0.3047436476,
-0.0748325139,
0.4551777542,
-0.0099415239,
0.4661496878,
0.9891744852,
-0.2248822153,
0.3966867328,
0.559694767,
-0.2231943011,
-0.0969012529,
0.5544339418,
0.3500438631,
0.045782391,
0.5202013254,
-0.0005852199,
-0.3104022145,
-1.1053909063,
-0.012015718,
0.3289442956,
-0.7669868469,
-0.492865473,
-0.8124488592,
-0.2751497626,
-0.1492823362,
-0.2365725487,
-0.579100132,
-0.3769721687,
-0.7288922668,
-0.2597512007,
0.390609771,
0.7562704682,
-0.0022217059,
0.657017529,
-0.8274765015,
0.4498841763,
0.5263385773,
0.508428216,
0.0754929185,
-0.6835231781,
-0.5404953957,
-0.1313380003,
-0.3648218811,
-0.6401947141,
0.3492507041,
0.7285167575,
0.8544861078,
0.4710122049,
0.2478504628,
0.7551383972,
-0.5785443187,
0.5542521477,
0.1033378765,
-0.7544250488,
0.7013696432,
-0.2164669484,
0.2498758137,
0.8234868646,
0.7321360707,
-0.1124474332,
-0.3976686001,
-0.566967845,
-1.2891488075,
0.5873416066,
-0.0021644961,
0.3160206974,
-0.0309608392,
0.7021949887,
0.0556906126,
0.1100016236,
-0.8709155321,
-0.1421955228,
-0.0685720816,
-0.1881621927,
-0.3321192265,
-0.2028244436,
-0.0714204013,
-0.4481063783,
0.8378871083,
-0.1824397892,
0.0709461197,
0.0596360788,
-0.3694096506,
-0.0120219728,
-0.1089415625,
0.1128231809,
0.6670772433,
-0.2035279125,
0.344994396,
0.2321240604,
-0.4847349823,
-0.1148584336,
0.0613594726,
0.0450713411,
0.1789870262,
0.6158899665,
1.0415824652,
0.5153359175,
-0.5702269673,
0.485814333,
-0.1978672445,
-0.1744261384,
-0.2595714033,
0.2348257303,
0.0366626456,
0.1348451972,
0.504391849,
0.1095143482,
-0.26066944,
-0.4769402742,
0.306619525,
0.1797136515,
-0.4322369397,
-0.2685626745,
0.5658755302,
0.541772604,
-0.3053052425,
0.7605743408,
-0.0563783273,
-0.6521540284,
0.1114815325,
0.4544934034,
0.8185955286,
-0.280553937,
-0.1616648883,
0.5344488025,
0.1765214503,
-0.4488879442,
0.0597146749,
-0.1514466107,
-0.8140562177,
-0.7711680532,
-1.0080862045,
-0.2993567586,
0.0954884365,
-0.6578224897,
0.5363057256,
-0.6001304388,
-0.2801805139,
0.0045973808,
0.2352444082,
-0.5166279674,
0.3481227756,
0.2547369003,
1.0382368565,
-0.9712250233,
1.0884875059,
0.9455485344,
-0.0402708612,
-0.9967420697,
-0.1919257045,
-0.4756985605,
-0.6991745234,
0.6865522861,
0.3305118978,
0.0668044537,
0.2145804167,
-0.6243155003,
-0.7114213705,
0.8275820017,
0.3202372491,
-0.8844102621,
0.012845343,
-0.4521794915,
0.5901241899,
-0.2779663503,
-0.0640004799,
0.2697213292,
0.4153104424,
-0.0103179347,
-0.8432535529,
-0.2451452464,
-0.3889835775,
-0.2361290008,
0.4080041051,
-0.3022435009,
0.6741652489,
-0.0499429516,
-0.2345346957,
-0.3424301147,
0.9931167364,
0.0793461427,
0.0593405627,
0.6969277263,
0.7199510336,
1.1026614904,
-0.2539230883,
0.8377919197,
-0.2639940679,
0.2398808151,
0.8386850953,
-0.0382354297,
1.0339765549,
0.2381399125,
-0.1120690703,
0.1091198027,
0.7579528689,
-0.0332555026,
0.5942423344,
0.3559308648,
-0.3763277531,
-0.6834344268,
0.1188645735,
-0.263798207,
0.5557118654,
0.4500736594,
-0.4645049274,
-0.1535941362,
0.118137151,
0.1466597021,
0.269516021,
-0.6914179921,
0.9576054215,
0.1990816444,
-0.5320268869,
0.8028600812,
0.0141656259,
0.976570189,
-0.9022190571,
0.0893146247,
0.0785679072,
0.4149084091,
-0.2824575603,
-0.5719342232,
0.3163807392,
0.0353915691,
-0.1175366342,
-0.8640463352,
0.7318215966,
-0.6991364956,
-0.4578317702,
0.3667981029,
0.1786986738,
0.2443092018,
-0.0377214924,
-0.7615781426,
0.1141991392,
0.0799838006,
-0.5120209455,
0.2766813636,
0.7553248405,
-0.0347419344,
0.599951148,
0.6898372173,
0.3897333443,
0.3188141584,
0.223427549,
1.102506876,
-0.527120769,
-0.3930557966,
-0.5530750155,
0.4107373953,
-0.0302052312,
-0.3807596564,
0.7121065259,
0.4969850779,
0.7497591972,
0.1403702348,
0.5141196847,
0.1875577867,
0.5199427605,
-0.7001797557,
0.8663873076,
-0.7062286139,
0.3475214839,
0.0348956808,
-1.0980021954,
-0.6781366467,
1.0754772425,
-0.2023104429,
-0.0040373737,
0.4763604701,
0.5362739563,
-0.1665605754,
-0.2036994994,
0.1503499597,
0.265594095,
0.2366512865,
0.2441010475,
0.6479574442,
-0.3114029765,
0.523165524,
-0.120529145,
-0.3261533082,
-0.1499779969,
-1.0211011171,
-1.0543322563,
-0.456928432,
-0.4847083986,
-0.0651463047,
0.1652278155,
0.7634189725,
0.7819252014,
-0.6569199562,
0.1021673977,
-0.0442372411,
-0.0645074025,
-0.1118127331,
-0.0530323163,
0.4592443109,
-0.7099307179,
-0.8188114762,
0.4138281941,
0.014431336,
0.0716483444,
-0.1976238042,
-0.0571162179,
-0.4330576956,
-0.1043293029,
0.6593023539,
0.1929947734,
-0.3774827123,
-0.0023664283,
-0.2693674862,
-0.0508409888,
-0.0918406695,
0.8968927264,
-0.7769004703,
0.4489462674,
0.5804001093,
0.9739701748,
0.7606568933,
-0.0977584645,
0.7026121616,
-0.9665151238,
0.3302843571,
0.6752144694,
0.2490465194,
0.385741204,
-0.0710388497,
0.4915615022,
-0.1458826512,
-0.6605742574,
-1.0927875042,
0.1078664884,
-1.1179511547,
-0.351983726,
1.2065736055,
-0.5372533202,
-0.1700444072,
-0.2827789187,
-0.0181169789,
0.4364787638,
-0.1855545789,
0.6309164166,
0.4267504215,
0.0288666487,
-0.2044202983,
-0.5274526477,
0.6396604776,
0.5492096543,
-0.5316191316,
0.3390238881,
0.1617777944,
-0.0641748831,
0.2003065348,
0.6092019081,
0.0173249561,
-0.1540192366,
-0.3445943892,
0.1274018139,
-0.2442082912,
-0.6081237197,
-0.2820893526,
0.0801652595,
0.2919710279,
-0.0712109655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15610v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15610v2
|
Selective "Selective Prediction": Reducing Unnecessary Abstention in Vision-Language Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T21:16:52 | 2024-06-12T21:09:39 |
Tejas Srinivasan, Jack Hessel, Tanmay Gupta, Bill Yuchen Lin, Yejin Choi, Jesse Thomason, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Selective prediction minimizes incorrect predictions from vision-language
models (VLMs) by allowing them to abstain from answering when uncertain.
However, when deploying a vision-language system with low tolerance for
inaccurate predictions, selective prediction may be over-cautious and abstain
too frequently, even on many correct predictions. We introduce ReCoVERR, an
inference-time algorithm to reduce the over-abstention of a selective
vision-language system without increasing the error rate of the system's
predictions. When the VLM makes a low-confidence prediction, instead of
abstaining ReCoVERR tries to find relevant clues in the image that provide
additional evidence for the prediction. ReCoVERR uses an LLM to pose related
questions to the VLM, collects high-confidence evidences, and if enough
evidence confirms the prediction the system makes a prediction instead of
abstaining. ReCoVERR enables three VLMs (BLIP2, InstructBLIP, and LLaVA-1.5) to
answer up to 20% more questions on the VQAv2 and A-OKVQA tasks without
decreasing system accuracy, thus improving overall system reliability. Our code
is available at https://github.com/tejas1995/ReCoVERR.
|
[
-0.4095835984,
-0.443669498,
0.5448966622,
0.0917044133,
-0.2424008101,
0.0881009251,
-0.0541668274,
-0.6737778783,
0.1274578571,
0.8811632395,
-0.4195205569,
0.0014868409,
-0.3917538226,
0.01017721,
-0.3949784636,
0.6779255867,
-0.1137850732,
0.1423202306,
0.0408097543,
-0.1172844246,
-0.5975721478,
-0.185773775,
-0.7280169725,
-0.2364698052,
0.4296652973,
0.3685181439,
0.3038087785,
0.5763521791,
0.778203547,
0.3025712371,
-0.2169392854,
0.0251625609,
-0.6365120411,
0.4227850735,
-0.3410414755,
-0.6946215034,
0.1188747957,
-0.3964695632,
0.7899898887,
0.3938578665,
-0.4248404503,
-0.0273088384,
-0.0108499229,
0.8988105059,
-1.1816387177,
-0.196098119,
-0.9231048226,
-0.0134827448,
-0.1550837308,
0.0391707718,
-0.7022725344,
-0.2507824302,
0.2774241269,
-0.6002540588,
0.3226439059,
0.1199740916,
0.7670078874,
0.6699296236,
-0.0062388685,
0.426101625,
-1.1032723188,
1.0165855885,
-0.1199710295,
0.4024549127,
0.491556704,
0.8052026033,
0.0526086651,
-0.5463705063,
-0.5493130684,
0.0104027912,
0.0447571203,
0.4019140899,
-0.2259723544,
0.0934740379,
0.2762269676,
0.0455408804,
-0.4351696968,
-0.119224593,
-0.6301481128,
-0.3219100535,
0.4238370359,
0.2196208388,
-0.1953785419,
0.2151748687,
-0.4413770735,
0.099138245,
-0.6818249226,
-0.0427861288,
-0.2858157158,
0.0929030403,
0.2201584578,
0.7164853215,
-0.5433108211,
0.889939189,
0.1380025148,
-0.1125166491,
0.2404892147,
-0.3228016198,
-0.3173538148,
0.1438213736,
0.2864064574,
0.3752265573,
0.4083682597,
0.1147436351,
-0.471437335,
0.6834773421,
0.3463738561,
-0.7041785717,
-0.3292790949,
0.1332656443,
-0.5065286756,
0.0542828925,
-0.0972900689,
-0.6664608717,
-0.4588244855,
-0.0986103415,
0.3163304031,
-0.4233816564,
-0.1627523005,
0.1010713354,
-0.3777739406,
0.4218664169,
0.7274613976,
-0.4248435497,
0.2920656502,
0.4450839162,
0.6082362533,
-0.2703855932,
-0.0949422494,
-0.7620131373,
0.3026989698,
-0.4323186874,
0.8511068821,
-0.5869486928,
-0.2315196246,
-0.3032789528,
0.0899278075,
-0.1724438071,
-0.5458157659,
0.5724503994,
-0.5231195092,
0.0175756235,
-0.4561733007,
-0.5531050563,
-0.3057042658,
0.4646888673,
-0.6208657026,
0.5671077371,
-0.0063416427,
-0.8081460595,
0.6014375091,
-0.1892952472,
-0.1788039953,
0.1887151897,
-0.2006062418,
-0.4180777967,
0.0769826621,
0.2624851167,
-0.0465351492,
-0.0316230245,
-0.1125054732,
-0.3652112186,
-0.4279184341,
0.0955085307,
-0.4673701823,
0.5579456687,
0.3789997995,
-0.1460250467,
0.1602955312,
-0.6772908568,
0.122555308,
0.1736814082,
-0.3829168677,
-0.4510543644,
0.3787361681,
-0.1777798682,
0.0072374223,
0.0023636892,
-1.0563081503,
0.0006900608,
-0.6188415885,
-0.002841779,
0.7613320351,
-0.1421922296,
0.4506826997,
-0.4688474536,
0.5426371694,
0.0318763256,
0.2468905449,
-0.0083653806,
-0.4877944589,
-1.078400135,
-0.3812139332,
-0.0526586436,
1.0627706051,
-1.1973700523,
0.0134604145,
-0.0450345501,
-0.4141027033,
-0.606464088,
0.0531803109,
0.9035745859,
0.674890101,
0.5276213288,
-0.2475020736,
-0.7854090929,
-0.9441462755,
-0.197306633,
-0.3589504361,
-0.0854375511,
0.0810405388,
0.4684868753,
-0.1461269706,
0.9742559791,
-0.6323739886,
-0.5224615335,
-0.3844635785,
-0.6776217818,
-0.0488836803,
0.5443353653,
0.6734378934,
-0.9425984621,
-0.5258318782,
-0.0587710291,
-0.6151896119,
0.210055083,
0.1067792922,
-0.2059479952,
0.4908645451,
0.2222267985,
-0.6218360662,
0.7547194362,
0.2999634147,
-0.4298075438,
0.5038534403,
0.02931251,
-0.1267619431,
-0.638548255,
0.0330589004,
-0.0624099225,
-0.1724790037,
-0.5901899338,
0.1004065946,
0.0396128073,
0.4223245978,
-0.3468531966,
0.8368002176,
-0.3446496129,
0.1518213004,
-0.3377907872,
-0.0416404791,
-0.0001664797,
0.0085086366,
0.546007812,
0.5988690257,
0.6612702608,
-0.5846941471,
0.1183079332,
0.3966352046,
-0.436668396,
0.3573181331,
-0.6391572952,
-0.0395704769,
-0.4579081237,
-0.019519154,
-0.8150168061,
-0.1950854808,
0.526560545,
-0.4311434925,
0.2294505388,
-0.3260716796,
0.2719962001,
-0.6110902429,
-0.1260752529,
0.2664507627,
0.4816453457,
-0.5006741881,
0.8026781082,
0.4174491763,
-0.1966928393,
-0.9689702988,
-0.8874307871,
-0.2266578376,
0.1758763194,
-0.183896482,
0.2302886844,
-0.1685103774,
-0.5078553557,
0.2733753622,
-0.2260938883,
-0.153262347,
0.0673523769,
0.1840059608,
0.5093420148,
-0.0140501754,
0.0083798459,
-0.0456837267,
-0.3172877431,
-0.2557471693,
-0.4704564214,
0.2842136621,
-0.2973619401,
-0.3773044646,
-0.2715216875,
0.2277733386,
0.2938210368,
-0.4194367826,
0.6926221848,
0.3429708481,
-0.5067793727,
-0.1606690139,
-0.8846464753,
-0.2251928598,
-0.4683058262,
0.3204801381,
-0.4611131549,
-0.6906003952,
0.4529013932,
0.5939650536,
0.2456393242,
0.220052436,
0.359349668,
0.0464900993,
1.0768114328,
0.6899285913,
-0.1184690148,
0.7735619545,
-0.2323852926,
-0.2155358046,
-0.631945312,
-0.4124555886,
-0.473446697,
-0.1744427085,
-0.2363302708,
-0.3406231701,
-0.0218488835,
-0.1230571046,
-0.0913464651,
0.1009779871,
-0.7854642868,
0.6974723339,
0.6595088243,
0.181231901,
0.1520089656,
0.1946933717,
0.0077222316,
-0.0602919012,
-0.6544167399,
-0.1339331418,
0.8613520265,
0.0223107934,
0.8867957592,
0.011603862,
0.7004662156,
-0.2131817341,
0.5895646214,
-0.8839769959,
0.5049133897,
-0.3433538377,
-0.8572126031,
-0.2983185649,
-0.6071494818,
-0.8338893652,
0.4294822812,
-0.1794576645,
-0.8144741654,
0.525868535,
0.4820126593,
-0.4701969624,
0.2320821583,
-0.6216645837,
0.3904793859,
-0.1027760506,
-0.3261808455,
-0.2200781554,
-0.7020580173,
0.3094313145,
-0.1183837131,
-0.1021647379,
-0.0933445692,
-0.0301557388,
0.5906242728,
-0.1640180349,
0.7377502918,
-0.5292419195,
0.3594103754,
0.6161552072,
0.3422499895,
0.4208099246,
-0.2150031924,
-0.2955442965,
-0.2153032124,
0.0944800004,
-0.4537375271,
-0.4870068729,
0.4322595,
-0.3866662383,
-0.7356786728,
-0.4333873093,
-0.2540435195,
-0.1028591841,
0.3348559737,
0.3697161674,
0.1621869802,
-0.0239935219,
0.2487846166,
0.5942052007,
-0.0400834866,
0.5201144218,
0.6872780323,
-0.3413219452,
-0.7809391022,
0.8045197725,
0.1674930453,
0.3947071433,
0.498324275,
0.1381129771,
-0.3091722429,
-0.8634781837,
-0.2049820274,
0.078856416,
-0.7130538821,
-0.2721093595,
-0.3393315077,
-0.2656823695,
-0.0999794975,
-0.2102904469,
-0.4325030744,
-0.5557298064,
-0.0127403373,
-0.1238937527,
0.3107461631,
0.4021052718,
0.0315754935,
0.2586838603,
-0.84262079,
0.4326920807,
0.0347228982,
0.4487293661,
-0.3653280437,
-0.6119151711,
0.0016192659,
0.0471917689,
-0.0765999109,
-0.5736687779,
0.5460802913,
0.3818393946,
0.8939915895,
0.6982858181,
0.4209390879,
0.7638035417,
-0.3629941046,
0.4233686328,
0.3678168356,
-0.5698824525,
0.8770888448,
0.1820766628,
0.3134897053,
0.7133345604,
-0.0170410033,
-0.1645566076,
-0.5680964589,
-0.1346146017,
-0.7344529629,
0.6211104989,
0.1673374325,
-0.2331772447,
-0.0627624243,
0.3713181019,
0.1218906865,
0.0766954347,
-0.5758906603,
-0.0298317671,
-0.3377653658,
-0.2641657293,
-0.138492167,
-0.4676195085,
-0.1789711714,
-0.3348432183,
0.5530794263,
-0.2234478444,
0.015445902,
0.5874174833,
-0.1188118383,
-0.1291445196,
0.0942326486,
0.4224109948,
0.6461023092,
-0.2680235207,
0.0912215263,
0.2098752558,
-0.8572657704,
0.069873333,
0.1037197784,
-0.9618850946,
-0.1961770505,
0.1863173544,
0.749230504,
-0.4236228764,
-0.8250269294,
0.251345396,
-0.2740014493,
-0.1574441344,
-0.5345323086,
0.1604652107,
-0.415640682,
0.3673709333,
0.4538260102,
0.8290604353,
0.1267376095,
-0.007567605,
0.1693707407,
0.5267179012,
-0.7165589333,
-0.0437754467,
0.794513464,
0.2930144072,
-0.1176663265,
0.6119315624,
-0.0543351434,
-0.5796923041,
0.7044198513,
0.5728902221,
0.9769433141,
-0.3403759897,
-0.0151654333,
0.3220255375,
0.434615463,
-0.3906368017,
0.8089742064,
0.2091094255,
-1.2488176823,
-0.6073467135,
-0.6353657246,
-0.1920960397,
-0.2661887407,
-0.6534653306,
-0.1318686306,
-0.6736436486,
-0.3748015165,
-0.172785446,
-0.1329393238,
-0.3576051891,
0.2321061194,
0.109877415,
1.0826580524,
-0.3270426393,
0.9469342828,
0.5318441987,
-0.2675752044,
-0.5525579453,
-0.0152848987,
0.1514805108,
-0.7332123518,
0.573861897,
0.2200386226,
-0.4601436853,
-0.1435923874,
-0.4997214973,
-0.9538117647,
0.8798488379,
0.6800670624,
-0.9697644114,
0.333101213,
-0.4774679542,
0.2674106658,
-0.0794390589,
-0.118574515,
0.5050745606,
0.4663105607,
0.3669023812,
-1.0097244978,
0.0699786171,
-0.2327672839,
0.0084851207,
0.343593359,
-0.4779048264,
0.5342852473,
-0.8242173791,
-0.368625015,
0.4138303995,
0.4051779807,
0.5382618904,
0.4449006319,
0.7121819258,
0.4404382706,
0.8146976829,
-0.2761981189,
1.2829273939,
-0.1505765766,
0.1417805254,
1.075586915,
-0.4685952961,
1.1494623423,
0.7465227842,
0.0374815613,
0.1878816038,
0.4885258973,
-0.0715159029,
0.7820038795,
-0.0682801902,
-0.3226445913,
-0.645752728,
-0.0597719364,
-0.3054414093,
0.5614363551,
0.5111073852,
-0.2264154404,
0.1481990665,
0.0524193272,
-0.3526240587,
0.0160388481,
-0.6309472919,
0.7314181924,
0.1178739816,
-0.9294331074,
0.6975263357,
-0.3973916173,
0.3596676886,
-0.3168169558,
0.0055201012,
-0.185683161,
0.9112966061,
-0.0443997681,
-0.8607224226,
0.4391992092,
-0.326943785,
-0.3815412521,
-0.0167554878,
1.0788490772,
-0.4223504663,
-0.7447760701,
0.5380933881,
0.5122670531,
-0.1857570559,
-0.1209267378,
-0.4765983522,
-0.0592731684,
0.1604384035,
-0.3997589946,
-0.0525425449,
0.1301031709,
-0.2034020871,
1.3547850847,
0.4337577522,
0.3304176629,
0.0469575226,
0.1153089106,
0.9337086082,
-0.5557397008,
-0.4070249796,
-0.7651939392,
0.3366027474,
-0.040399272,
-0.0974939913,
0.4642345607,
0.5639032722,
0.8737601638,
-0.2501797974,
0.9583517313,
0.0597941391,
0.7310694456,
-0.6224640012,
0.5988601446,
-0.4956887662,
0.3147987127,
-0.1172455698,
-0.722623229,
-0.5896309018,
0.7424852848,
-0.4899272025,
-0.1533022374,
0.4067626595,
0.8133420348,
0.2339745909,
-0.283715874,
0.281196475,
0.2421617657,
0.0379446335,
0.5881505609,
1.159514904,
0.0134048667,
1.0297143459,
-0.3752874434,
-0.1402652562,
-0.2905898988,
-0.4628690481,
-0.5248578787,
-0.162124157,
-0.2175381333,
-0.3477585614,
0.4259776175,
0.4730082154,
0.692635119,
-1.0985529423,
0.0449965969,
-0.2273996621,
0.3067952096,
-0.4486637414,
-0.1960863471,
-0.1808320135,
-0.1237815246,
-0.4863898158,
0.479254216,
0.2634336352,
0.1847114265,
0.1832129061,
-0.3710383475,
0.1342958808,
-0.0672484785,
0.5897875428,
0.5748760104,
-0.9844846129,
-0.5414470434,
0.2473241687,
0.1473845392,
-0.0495601408,
0.5002022386,
-1.1289670467,
0.6286779046,
0.6393560171,
0.4990552962,
0.6729019284,
0.1636929363,
0.6167970896,
-0.5431345701,
0.3718327284,
0.4806638956,
0.6577138305,
0.2657681704,
-0.1178101301,
0.5511226654,
0.3951413929,
-0.2798796594,
-0.7939147949,
0.5633083582,
-0.8859141469,
-0.4945710599,
1.1112833023,
-0.1429220885,
-0.2031038254,
-0.4255417883,
-0.455571413,
-0.1268226802,
-0.4821785092,
0.6983245611,
0.1998726428,
-0.1398872584,
-0.643333137,
-0.3061051071,
0.4378575087,
0.4387727082,
-0.4699675143,
0.0746264607,
0.6857665777,
0.4857036173,
0.3675042689,
0.7573236823,
0.1064041108,
0.4117380679,
0.2274263203,
0.0096840924,
0.0782909989,
-0.6481080055,
-0.1295032054,
0.1566838473,
0.1321629435,
-0.5398224592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15594v1
|
Alternating Weak Triphone/BPE Alignment Supervision from Hybrid Model Improves End-to-End ASR
| 2024-02-23T20:26:54 | 2024-02-23T20:26:54 |
Jintao Jiang, Yingbo Gao, Mohammad Zeineldeen, Zoltan Tuske
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this paper, alternating weak triphone/BPE alignment supervision is
proposed to improve end-to-end model training. Towards this end, triphone and
BPE alignments are extracted using a pre-existing hybrid ASR system. Then,
regularization effect is obtained by cross-entropy based intermediate auxiliary
losses computed on such alignments at a mid-layer representation of the encoder
for triphone alignments and at the encoder for BPE alignments. Weak supervision
is achieved through strong label smoothing with parameter of 0.5. Experimental
results on TED-LIUM 2 indicate that either triphone or BPE alignment based weak
supervision improves ASR performance over standard CTC auxiliary loss.
Moreover, their combination lowers the word error rate further. We also
investigate the alternation of the two auxiliary tasks during model training,
and additional performance gain is observed. Overall, the proposed techniques
result in over 10% relative error rate reduction over a CTC-regularized
baseline system.
|
[
-0.2941431701,
-0.4216282964,
0.0520454794,
0.0625133738,
-0.4950667918,
0.1259815544,
-0.3834343851,
-0.5602104068,
0.2158845365,
0.412145257,
-0.2524775565,
-0.3539263606,
-0.5930390358,
-0.0090620657,
-0.2369627357,
0.9535797238,
-0.1642253995,
0.3522768021,
0.1618603617,
-0.0838084295,
-0.3789786398,
-0.4859391749,
-0.970580101,
-0.5948948264,
0.4032319188,
0.2304845005,
0.7309930325,
0.4450468421,
0.7105817795,
0.2934422493,
-0.405754447,
0.3524768949,
-0.3701592386,
-0.3344850838,
-0.3364005685,
-0.2498930395,
-0.8199247122,
-0.2599696219,
0.7854599357,
0.7298622727,
-0.3910188973,
0.0060244268,
0.2711083293,
0.5157667398,
-0.7063342929,
-0.356358856,
-0.3045140803,
-0.1434120983,
-0.1468719393,
-0.3286954165,
-0.3587059081,
0.0115560647,
0.1438286602,
-0.5114273429,
0.3724782467,
0.2193211168,
1.2513515949,
0.3191175163,
-0.5317319036,
0.1679299027,
-0.9930968285,
0.6382526159,
-0.7901220918,
0.7779326439,
0.2297341526,
0.1279266775,
0.0309879389,
-0.3995061219,
-0.6913635135,
0.157983005,
-0.2621226907,
0.7099653482,
0.1118400991,
0.5837788582,
0.1425572485,
0.6603682041,
-0.2772680819,
0.3431268632,
-0.4227270782,
-0.5077313781,
0.6673341393,
0.01791122,
0.1233435124,
0.0621096566,
-0.4960258901,
-0.1960929483,
-0.4920958579,
0.120828338,
0.5924945474,
0.3108550012,
-0.4413343072,
0.6238020658,
0.1816506237,
0.8024470806,
0.3388195634,
-0.0831041336,
0.305965811,
-0.6623944044,
-0.3509665132,
0.2804201245,
0.6987201571,
0.376044333,
-0.0529357195,
-0.3335862756,
-0.3689844906,
0.4974170923,
0.0954768732,
-0.3097730279,
-0.0974705294,
0.0176972691,
-0.6326303482,
0.2119686157,
0.3126867414,
-0.3186426163,
-0.1199370027,
-0.8322889805,
0.5575726628,
-0.6932535172,
-0.0008447621,
0.3336455524,
-0.3001642227,
0.6569087505,
0.2783476412,
-0.5625677109,
0.6678337455,
0.3551450968,
0.8943728805,
-0.4784409702,
-0.0875016302,
-0.4467414021,
0.6489796638,
-0.2037240863,
0.6905701756,
-0.2275517285,
-0.4756534398,
-0.3896272779,
0.0176164284,
-0.3556389213,
-0.5733936429,
0.6208104491,
-0.3100070357,
0.192449972,
0.1108338982,
-0.2674571276,
-0.2364962399,
0.0118929632,
-0.2152732313,
1.0366829634,
-0.1157542542,
-0.8048532009,
0.2012226731,
-0.3986147344,
-0.7245241404,
-0.3681198657,
-0.0024130649,
-0.7604766488,
0.0945785418,
0.3364413083,
0.1853488237,
-0.2737887502,
0.1418357044,
-0.1327220052,
-0.7844257355,
0.1082133576,
-0.1263446957,
0.8341152668,
-0.1607376933,
-0.3070505559,
0.3393169045,
-0.9715750813,
-0.0805639848,
-0.2796018124,
-0.6179329753,
-0.6315630674,
-0.1039426625,
0.2333855778,
0.0975894779,
-0.0023740847,
-0.6249109507,
0.0525573529,
-0.6075527668,
-0.2724102736,
0.7721535563,
0.1861724406,
0.4129225612,
-0.4825838506,
0.206800431,
0.1782331616,
-0.0513542295,
0.2282350212,
-0.2755464911,
-1.127445817,
-0.4216947556,
0.6903501749,
0.7819533944,
-0.7314683795,
0.9062473774,
-0.1226613671,
-0.1463517994,
-0.8393675685,
0.1954455376,
0.732634902,
0.5619351268,
0.7452502847,
-0.9138561487,
-0.9274787307,
-1.0157973766,
-0.1750822365,
-0.071979247,
-0.3300456703,
0.1516776532,
0.0409801342,
-0.3486014605,
0.4976221323,
-0.0935114101,
-0.3502220213,
-0.2139552236,
0.1490767896,
0.2922654152,
0.8283551335,
0.092381902,
-0.4076080918,
-0.61152035,
0.0734985769,
-0.3831499815,
-0.1876476705,
-0.2364941835,
-0.4977944195,
0.1692762971,
0.2339357436,
-0.650314033,
0.4727607965,
0.2388817966,
-0.2760148644,
0.3647238314,
-0.2117002457,
-0.0029689525,
-1.0827411413,
-0.0035634555,
0.2236736715,
-0.128779009,
-0.7005886436,
-0.1895878464,
0.2692955732,
0.2180685848,
-0.0553418845,
-0.0526180938,
-0.7896278501,
-0.2325962037,
-0.2048178464,
-0.1911339909,
-0.0022817689,
0.4979194999,
0.418839395,
0.5467358232,
0.7498332262,
-0.5845526457,
0.1779439449,
0.299985081,
0.0832384899,
0.368655473,
-0.650449276,
0.4394439161,
-0.1602249295,
0.5195255876,
-0.7744444609,
0.0734088123,
0.316395998,
-0.2595545352,
1.0227071047,
-0.0646234676,
-0.4851354063,
-0.330950141,
-0.3567766845,
0.0867158175,
0.5447580218,
-0.5678790808,
0.7661972642,
0.0611815006,
0.0429868475,
-0.3029367924,
-0.7909056544,
-0.0651137903,
-0.2187030613,
-0.4231328666,
0.8205373883,
0.2472935468,
-0.1930853873,
-0.2460890561,
-0.3596286476,
0.1342065483,
-0.4252689779,
0.1137775406,
0.5743370652,
-0.3144351244,
-0.1499682963,
0.1522791088,
-0.1404334456,
-0.2563906014,
-0.4183309078,
0.3631993234,
0.0732822344,
-0.2632855475,
-0.8265054822,
0.3236054778,
0.0542774126,
-0.1284352243,
0.5558102131,
0.4973220229,
-0.3655048311,
0.1001510844,
-0.7897230387,
-0.2545743585,
-0.5029207468,
-0.0007316266,
-0.1637033969,
-0.2504927218,
0.4952264428,
0.2198690325,
-0.1953124702,
0.2530266345,
0.3696522415,
-0.4072838426,
0.9234434366,
0.7213759422,
-0.1475963891,
0.5210024118,
-0.4341750145,
0.092809163,
-1.1329817772,
-0.3083103001,
-0.1492574066,
-0.5615190268,
-0.4484534264,
-0.4573532641,
0.4357736409,
0.2482199967,
-0.262147814,
0.3909704387,
-0.576910913,
0.0550837815,
0.8026729226,
0.6648859382,
0.3255954981,
-0.0618952103,
-0.1305661052,
0.0388435163,
-0.64741081,
-0.2546301186,
0.934542954,
0.3912793994,
0.8929888606,
0.2044061124,
0.7449476719,
0.0942831263,
0.0141750546,
-0.7172425389,
0.4197745323,
-0.1445288509,
-0.4739049971,
-0.1915136129,
-0.3296304047,
-0.3597592115,
0.319103092,
-0.1470940113,
-0.7473769188,
0.6221936345,
0.5034598708,
-0.5695685148,
0.2470056713,
-0.918238759,
0.4579636455,
-0.3792204559,
-0.5996089578,
-0.03735153,
-1.0715025663,
0.2676064372,
0.2026277184,
-0.1581849903,
0.3427121937,
-0.1274969876,
0.8554307818,
-0.7964379787,
0.9689987898,
-0.2914247215,
0.0549920127,
0.5051056743,
-0.4015449882,
0.8368956447,
-0.1793667376,
0.0794482157,
0.209018454,
-0.4416551888,
-0.44087556,
-0.4232681692,
0.2596209049,
-0.7796766162,
-0.3671172261,
-0.2888087928,
-0.6193951368,
-0.5620912313,
-0.1961032003,
0.6343061924,
0.3114844561,
0.4727591872,
0.1085744575,
0.6060742736,
-0.0270049591,
0.4574762285,
0.6920975447,
0.3766621351,
-0.3634795249,
0.9011799693,
0.1297061592,
0.3119160533,
0.3999490142,
-0.0057786806,
-0.1874588579,
-0.7137995958,
-0.3924596906,
0.325937897,
-0.3399886489,
-0.458532244,
-0.6732714772,
-0.2743478119,
-0.4118746519,
-0.2810568213,
-0.4862003922,
-0.4868169427,
-0.156200543,
-0.0526569225,
0.2959825695,
0.0454185344,
-0.1854322553,
0.8648728132,
-0.5843193531,
0.2831459045,
-0.1060721427,
0.4193330705,
-0.166043818,
-0.9259889126,
-0.2110317647,
-0.101611197,
-0.3686707914,
-0.8058811426,
0.1379653364,
0.4010108113,
0.3623972237,
0.5287373662,
-0.026105335,
1.1539386511,
-0.2485152185,
0.3680706322,
0.5818202496,
-0.9323406219,
0.4338797629,
-0.3198598623,
0.3403068185,
0.4560137093,
0.2047151327,
-0.1517659128,
-0.4880525768,
-0.4415586889,
-1.0347139835,
0.9152668715,
0.3359445035,
-0.2856131792,
0.4753935039,
0.0200179126,
0.1029411033,
-0.053476505,
-0.6485980749,
-0.2495335937,
-0.2335323691,
-0.3105802834,
-0.0285112578,
-0.1580210179,
-0.0159565005,
-0.5150848627,
1.2362467051,
0.0359956957,
0.3646790683,
0.3121754825,
0.1195124015,
-0.3366103172,
0.2382201701,
0.1195416749,
0.0637168512,
-0.3333080411,
0.0573639348,
0.5171610713,
-0.3550637364,
-0.0171521306,
0.3955062926,
-0.3152089119,
0.1098620072,
0.3661130667,
0.8554441333,
0.2273048609,
-0.3736484945,
0.368951261,
0.3123446405,
-0.064566195,
-0.19889763,
-0.0230190996,
0.0447900817,
0.0543631688,
0.1956847906,
0.1326072961,
0.3843075633,
-0.4836977124,
0.1542127579,
0.3374112546,
-0.4458131492,
-0.408351481,
0.654242456,
0.0972191915,
-0.0351896212,
0.5048726797,
0.1491712332,
-0.3603666127,
0.4705582261,
0.9231693745,
0.6765866876,
-0.5418428183,
-0.2841340601,
0.1909502745,
0.3490926921,
0.0102676358,
0.5173149705,
-0.1297632754,
-0.7863241434,
-0.4479287267,
-0.5703891516,
-0.4635709524,
0.0170003846,
-0.9057016969,
0.6133629084,
-0.4196483791,
-0.1287566721,
-0.0576410629,
-0.3448065817,
-0.4140108228,
0.5283383131,
0.1882603914,
0.5644858479,
-0.8054862022,
0.8034161925,
1.0116041899,
-0.4382609427,
-0.9318884611,
0.152479589,
0.0314080305,
-0.3409696817,
0.1901042014,
0.0222210214,
-0.2532621026,
-0.0019321968,
-0.315349102,
-0.871494472,
0.923199296,
0.0399960093,
-0.8376324773,
-0.233618319,
-0.1368802041,
0.6362860203,
-0.2539051771,
0.2194360495,
0.5715962648,
0.2698163092,
0.2493515313,
-1.2770863771,
-0.0266427696,
-0.3448923528,
0.1654741466,
0.3085274696,
-0.754188478,
0.4050730765,
-0.0996508971,
-0.2926262915,
-0.1526201963,
0.7758187652,
0.1558619589,
0.45700863,
0.5575863123,
0.5382502079,
0.3467569351,
-0.0560787916,
0.8918203115,
-0.2092943341,
0.095259957,
1.4526714087,
-0.302893281,
0.6807447672,
0.7469202876,
-0.1842069775,
0.3644654453,
0.747790575,
0.088558659,
0.6523495317,
0.023193391,
-0.1978885382,
-0.2023450434,
-0.1580460072,
-0.4044743478,
0.5102338195,
0.3498797119,
-0.4924969375,
0.0441522337,
0.0552435182,
-0.2710673511,
0.065180175,
-0.5255910754,
0.8812052608,
0.2000125796,
-0.4130055904,
0.7972461581,
0.1001658142,
0.9768431783,
-0.5369779468,
0.2029249668,
-0.1155187562,
0.3528927267,
-0.419795692,
-0.1627106816,
0.443544209,
-0.1481434256,
-0.1705072969,
-0.0375521928,
0.8203058839,
-0.6005337834,
-0.5266819596,
0.5061552525,
0.1943695694,
-0.0658321604,
0.288785398,
-0.4616309702,
-0.1195755452,
-0.0620103255,
-0.2579461038,
0.1461313665,
0.0645842031,
-0.0786068514,
0.2103419304,
0.5714356899,
0.3101387322,
0.2662110925,
0.2115181237,
1.0297027826,
-0.5702243447,
-0.6028493047,
-0.5797502398,
0.5706297755,
-0.3691509962,
-0.1164866611,
0.6113160253,
0.8608247042,
0.8703879118,
0.0339659974,
0.8700544238,
-0.0372422524,
0.7514814138,
-0.7406565547,
0.3844256699,
-0.388779074,
0.4347028732,
-0.3008322418,
-0.9498375058,
-0.3353137374,
0.4418978095,
-0.2925610542,
-0.0386193842,
0.5764164329,
0.8809450269,
-0.5910721421,
-0.0114304954,
0.156635806,
0.1060097292,
-0.2403293103,
0.4038422704,
0.6942703128,
-0.6703829169,
0.5201607347,
-0.5453532338,
-0.1942655593,
-0.0279223267,
-0.3467467129,
-0.8927637339,
-0.1677821279,
-0.6568001509,
-0.4546817541,
0.4685955942,
0.9441623092,
0.5170681477,
-1.1533341408,
-0.3567105234,
-0.19776164,
-0.2788740396,
-0.4642597139,
-0.2363958061,
0.5880948901,
-0.0645223185,
-0.6245781183,
0.5647466779,
0.2155774981,
0.4625723958,
0.3325478137,
-0.2649231851,
-0.4110044241,
0.0828906447,
0.2169370949,
0.195356831,
-0.7138926387,
-0.3200445175,
-0.2976016402,
0.0349600501,
0.1482501775,
0.8077260852,
-0.4201363325,
0.3972965181,
0.2856411934,
0.4072525799,
0.5940532684,
0.4949575663,
0.810726583,
-0.8633993268,
0.2843692601,
0.220437482,
0.4531903565,
0.5032603145,
-0.4832078516,
0.5655747056,
0.4403418005,
-0.1794101894,
-0.6340923905,
0.0223155115,
-1.157999754,
0.1031180769,
1.2650481462,
0.028580429,
-0.0971461535,
-0.2804116011,
-0.3799565732,
0.7723841071,
-0.3876248002,
0.6894788146,
0.2460748255,
-0.3893654644,
0.0016986465,
-0.2035335451,
0.115449883,
0.7421879768,
-0.4452302158,
-0.244867444,
0.5394914746,
0.0360532142,
0.1604152322,
0.5779840946,
-0.0613640025,
0.2639490664,
-0.0289867371,
0.3875306547,
0.0154316165,
-0.1477992088,
-0.3714955449,
-0.2600510716,
-0.2059912831,
-0.5321745872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15589v1
|
Prompting LLMs to Compose Meta-Review Drafts from Peer-Review Narratives of Scholarly Manuscripts
| 2024-02-23T20:14:16 | 2024-02-23T20:14:16 |
Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu, Sanjeev Kumar Sinha, Naman Bansal, Alex Knipper, Souvika Sarkar, John Salvador, Yash Mahajan, Sri Guttikonda, Mousumi Akter, Matthew Freestone, Matthew C. Williams Jr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, I.2.7
|
One of the most important yet onerous tasks in the academic peer-reviewing
process is composing meta-reviews, which involves understanding the core
contributions, strengths, and weaknesses of a scholarly manuscript based on
peer-review narratives from multiple experts and then summarizing those
multiple experts' perspectives into a concise holistic overview. Given the
latest major developments in generative AI, especially Large Language Models
(LLMs), it is very compelling to rigorously study the utility of LLMs in
generating such meta-reviews in an academic peer-review setting. In this paper,
we perform a case study with three popular LLMs, i.e., GPT-3.5, LLaMA2, and
PaLM2, to automatically generate meta-reviews by prompting them with different
types/levels of prompts based on the recently proposed TELeR taxonomy. Finally,
we perform a detailed qualitative study of the meta-reviews generated by the
LLMs and summarize our findings and recommendations for prompting LLMs for this
complex task.
|
[
-0.6127799749,
-0.3829073012,
1.0072203875,
0.0520974919,
-0.3482559621,
0.0089263814,
-0.0243669059,
-0.2819221318,
0.3315017521,
0.3962071836,
-0.5319755673,
-0.7165719271,
-0.4730731845,
0.6548289061,
-0.3007815182,
1.4920691252,
-0.3507731259,
-0.1170360744,
-0.0597789511,
0.1775082052,
-0.4123004377,
-0.0649168417,
-0.3605022132,
-0.3588001728,
0.773573041,
0.3618633151,
0.6211864948,
0.1619337052,
0.4563661516,
0.2060864568,
0.0834383518,
0.4279336333,
-0.1010653004,
0.4527225792,
-0.029748166,
-0.4037715197,
-0.6594414711,
0.1264401525,
0.6561613679,
0.3458251357,
-0.0123197874,
0.5760877132,
0.3436118066,
0.8081733584,
-0.4059950113,
0.0595862046,
-0.6285406947,
0.3563626707,
-0.2829963267,
-0.3072368503,
-0.3863889873,
-0.4249616861,
0.2863736451,
-0.7360008359,
0.4326125085,
-0.0882439539,
0.6072903275,
0.2768980563,
-0.3170456886,
-0.5035136938,
-0.824209094,
0.2958191335,
-0.5784359574,
-0.1216615364,
0.3628091216,
0.2374878377,
0.2986616194,
-0.7038274407,
-0.6860535145,
-0.1941477954,
-0.2740239501,
0.397870034,
0.0459035486,
0.162648797,
0.0744477883,
0.2471069396,
-0.5688333511,
0.1956665963,
-0.5162479281,
-0.0028869216,
0.5002353191,
0.5518373251,
0.0060076187,
-0.3312217295,
-0.0310853738,
-0.0060505108,
-1.0396384001,
-0.0819151625,
0.3965453804,
-0.0436181948,
0.1840329915,
0.7031647563,
-0.03417366,
0.5984250903,
0.1996026933,
-0.1083578244,
0.1148150936,
-0.4987906516,
-0.2075220793,
-0.1112951413,
1.1032544374,
0.5899445415,
0.3658025861,
0.0790927857,
-0.3217369318,
-0.0958440751,
0.3947395086,
-0.6685242057,
0.0653167218,
0.572861433,
-0.6842340827,
-0.601429522,
0.2673817873,
-0.870970726,
-0.3666272759,
-0.424792856,
0.1580762714,
0.0299240891,
-0.1077370048,
-0.0044796164,
-0.0982681215,
0.0737452507,
0.4542998075,
-0.912794888,
-0.0131579302,
0.6050180197,
0.9107637405,
-0.1557616591,
-0.4091517925,
-0.4683846831,
0.4715118408,
-0.2963995636,
0.9188352823,
-0.4869981706,
-0.6822396517,
0.3282887638,
-0.2811896205,
-0.0048965509,
-0.333553642,
0.5378093123,
-0.5159368515,
0.4028696418,
-0.2884424031,
-0.1715346277,
0.0039261081,
0.4868983328,
-0.5909707546,
0.9261235595,
-0.0076045692,
-0.9113962054,
0.391321063,
-0.7181386948,
-0.342647016,
0.1740712523,
-0.2019521743,
-0.5203052759,
0.3318064511,
0.7145524025,
0.6243057251,
-0.5846170187,
0.4514352083,
-0.0181439295,
-0.2020589262,
0.2270420492,
-0.1984746456,
0.3018050492,
0.1810147464,
-0.4866709411,
0.333925426,
-0.2145035118,
-0.210974142,
0.0122769615,
-0.2808872163,
0.0401601084,
0.0743346289,
-0.1357551664,
-0.055548735,
-0.1903176159,
-0.2040792406,
0.4165091515,
-0.0958707184,
0.6618704796,
0.7876034379,
0.2891497612,
0.3338611722,
-0.6363680363,
0.7833783627,
-0.3309987485,
0.1589755416,
-0.6258071661,
-0.4122194052,
-0.6755928993,
0.0469467714,
0.4589911401,
0.3531973064,
-0.8249174953,
0.3058091402,
-0.2595432401,
-0.679510057,
-0.6972183585,
0.2070068568,
0.2434847951,
0.257527709,
0.1460655928,
0.0555882342,
-0.1683069766,
-0.6068699956,
-0.2610351741,
-0.5346620083,
-0.223985225,
0.3911917806,
0.5103403926,
-0.4982659817,
0.9929349422,
-0.4747426212,
-0.6077331305,
-0.2268984914,
0.2391850054,
0.0087379981,
-0.1145408526,
0.3373149335,
-0.5317667127,
-0.7273733616,
-0.165457502,
-0.7173364162,
-0.5010767579,
-0.4034786224,
0.1438801438,
0.2265043408,
0.5580522418,
-0.7359101176,
-0.0519784763,
0.4476708472,
0.0562222749,
0.7965347767,
-0.0373886935,
0.0321389921,
-1.0635890961,
0.2469872385,
-0.0432071425,
-0.0021890511,
-0.2699812055,
0.055856213,
-0.2644734085,
-0.1186453551,
-0.0602942966,
0.3611243367,
-0.6908289194,
0.0873366371,
0.0093466779,
0.2691685259,
-0.1027306765,
0.1896010339,
0.1821377426,
0.5999153256,
0.478279978,
-0.4957323372,
0.1756034642,
0.3586428463,
-0.273080349,
0.3720116913,
-0.9748364091,
0.213439405,
-0.375602603,
0.7195884585,
-1.0793899298,
-0.4212789237,
0.3417077363,
-0.3321106434,
0.0480215847,
-0.1697963774,
-0.6228715181,
-0.4959185421,
-0.6359384656,
0.1774439961,
0.3130070865,
-0.3782629967,
0.950510323,
0.2644118071,
-0.5929114223,
-0.3832710087,
-0.5459675193,
0.25216344,
-0.1760027409,
-0.3949315548,
0.3973502517,
-0.0162657723,
-0.2466377467,
-0.0660351515,
0.2298932672,
0.5517248511,
-0.2265493125,
0.3816115856,
0.3496042192,
0.0280959979,
0.1217757761,
0.2233838737,
-0.2734288871,
0.2676595151,
-0.3138579428,
0.3719079494,
-0.097332865,
-0.5154098272,
-0.3419388831,
0.2985325456,
0.7625249028,
-0.3779039085,
0.1706610918,
0.6876941919,
0.1325242072,
-0.3618073165,
-0.7724606991,
-0.4348230958,
-0.442622602,
-0.0114407772,
-0.1992326528,
-0.951085031,
0.3131481111,
-0.0092690429,
0.4021378756,
0.5693166852,
0.9638773799,
-0.2038407922,
0.773680985,
0.2722270489,
-0.1403983384,
0.3875356615,
-0.2878185213,
-0.0526438765,
-0.9448624849,
-0.3284211457,
-0.3750578761,
-0.4334716499,
-0.5411893725,
-0.3569740951,
1.028747797,
-0.5691694021,
0.0690473169,
0.0024053173,
-0.5678639412,
0.4916803539,
0.5140405893,
-0.0122136762,
0.3194199204,
0.1099500805,
-0.3735240698,
0.2545649111,
-0.7108026743,
-0.9067153931,
1.4559572935,
0.3952640295,
0.6484360099,
-0.2082342654,
0.8527341485,
0.2371283621,
0.6603211761,
-0.6445538998,
0.6080928445,
0.1429621726,
-0.4962847829,
-0.2116186172,
-0.1872095019,
-0.8799155951,
0.2131757885,
-0.2896150053,
-0.0532968976,
-0.1147973761,
0.1742713004,
-0.6496374607,
0.1941240728,
-0.0817391425,
0.4668166041,
-0.0715193078,
-0.2080199867,
-0.3171859086,
-0.820958972,
0.5126286745,
-0.2099140584,
0.0733977035,
0.0442221463,
-0.2670517266,
0.5954644084,
-0.3084498048,
1.0507690907,
-0.1087838709,
-0.3644128144,
0.683273077,
0.4230850637,
0.6601771116,
0.4983025193,
-0.0006353818,
-0.1050730944,
-0.1297035068,
0.2642837465,
-0.2075411826,
0.3811923265,
-0.7500758767,
-0.753688097,
-0.5005825162,
-0.3270300627,
-0.2222724259,
0.0200625584,
0.5360845327,
0.3678209186,
-0.2322907299,
-0.1536714137,
0.6142772436,
-0.0460994951,
0.4879630804,
0.5822405815,
-0.2884318829,
-0.8079871535,
0.4555894732,
-0.0320642591,
0.1255123168,
0.3264903724,
0.2127084881,
-0.0954718366,
-0.7263590693,
-0.6849011779,
0.3949880004,
-0.4158774912,
-0.4195945859,
-0.7924200296,
-0.0196628645,
-0.134805575,
-0.1656716317,
0.2917560339,
-0.2114425153,
-0.337986052,
-0.1509653777,
0.041383151,
1.1703869104,
0.0229766574,
0.38766855,
-1.1594289541,
0.3257143199,
0.5630437136,
-0.0079789367,
0.2198801041,
-0.3212984204,
0.0503738895,
-0.2740904391,
-0.6019515991,
-0.9367691875,
0.1335732192,
0.2541410327,
0.4106604159,
0.4732663035,
-0.1641205549,
0.1804050803,
-0.7843844891,
1.134297967,
0.027122125,
-0.7445918918,
0.5621011257,
-0.822254777,
0.3671076,
0.6153965592,
0.6582418084,
-0.5136287808,
-0.5744124055,
-0.2722560763,
-0.6550078392,
0.4510103762,
0.0714788437,
0.3250744939,
-0.0332283974,
0.3233457804,
0.3931513429,
0.2705523968,
-0.821990788,
0.0660631359,
-0.1367835104,
-0.0701296851,
-0.0548150316,
-0.6470268369,
-0.3760308921,
0.2157830298,
0.6438475251,
-0.3285593987,
0.225514099,
0.3296445012,
-0.0964768529,
-0.3343304992,
0.2982736528,
0.7444502115,
0.5855934024,
0.0022498516,
0.0142918061,
0.1037355885,
-0.374198854,
0.0647773966,
-0.0150847621,
-0.5373163223,
0.124981828,
0.5485402942,
0.5146144629,
-0.146352306,
-0.2915792763,
0.3834449649,
-0.0339952148,
-0.5951904655,
-0.0694912449,
-0.1489026695,
0.1392247081,
0.0868388861,
0.4509353638,
-0.0893628299,
0.2141359299,
-0.3636142612,
-0.2438976318,
0.6310807467,
0.1102064177,
-0.5148537159,
0.575173378,
0.632819593,
-0.0228197686,
0.5263661742,
-0.1367993802,
-0.7979652882,
0.2666864693,
0.3407319784,
1.2004572153,
-0.0017932005,
0.5905365944,
0.4660093188,
0.62289083,
-0.1045298502,
-0.0091560939,
-0.2803326845,
-0.3248066902,
-0.5248677731,
-0.5926039815,
-0.704975009,
-0.0270351414,
-0.3693349361,
0.3007113039,
-0.4739897847,
-0.4949143529,
-0.0708890557,
-0.2294348329,
-0.4911845028,
-0.2767487764,
0.2480839044,
0.7022109032,
-0.9545758963,
0.2581462264,
0.5455447435,
-0.4437170923,
-0.8020553589,
0.3095455468,
0.1240236163,
-0.6471593976,
0.6103302836,
0.0226909295,
-0.1777620614,
-0.0912177265,
-0.2479136884,
-0.4755233526,
1.210103035,
0.092904456,
-0.8737329245,
-0.2120296359,
0.3137225211,
0.7198600173,
-0.3215688765,
0.5115736723,
0.2470162064,
0.7720404267,
-0.1005077884,
-0.9834171534,
0.0975718349,
-0.2033289224,
-0.0472449027,
0.1864854693,
-0.7897735238,
0.6079399586,
-0.3838879466,
-0.0767867118,
0.0394535437,
0.5222839117,
0.4491088986,
0.2454164773,
0.4474799931,
0.2889508605,
0.5815867782,
0.0345909297,
0.9957204461,
-0.4354714453,
-0.053378772,
0.8511664271,
-0.406253159,
0.6686062217,
0.414652586,
-0.2416450977,
0.7322763205,
0.706109345,
-0.3225916028,
0.1806519926,
0.1974734217,
-0.2952786088,
-0.0761770606,
0.0051767454,
-0.4627896249,
0.1739662439,
0.2324884385,
-0.5585730076,
-0.1800231338,
-0.0931987464,
0.0367146544,
-0.1789310873,
-0.4009266198,
1.0353838205,
0.1535816491,
-1.2169377804,
0.1941569,
0.0269503593,
0.6159468293,
-0.6879797578,
0.0494632162,
-0.2004383653,
-0.2629561424,
-0.4086439312,
-1.0173757076,
0.0550087057,
0.3326521218,
-0.2652694881,
-0.6079274416,
0.5051633716,
-0.4613822997,
-0.5757722259,
-0.1150469035,
0.7297818661,
0.0865856484,
0.0616226345,
-0.4590859115,
0.0611217357,
-0.183965683,
-0.2218216062,
0.1106036231,
0.4472215772,
-0.0581465885,
0.5116586089,
0.785925746,
0.2401717305,
-0.3195090592,
0.2640677989,
0.8039968014,
-0.250939697,
-0.3897217214,
-1.1048430204,
0.4704490006,
0.293736577,
-0.3652914166,
0.6491400003,
0.313798815,
0.480004549,
-0.4152183533,
1.0151560307,
0.1280324161,
0.3440323174,
-0.6265016794,
0.7901459932,
-0.2145252228,
0.2685443759,
-0.4006233811,
-1.3017188311,
-0.3836265504,
0.2361064255,
-0.1907951981,
0.190138787,
0.7890557647,
0.7013328671,
0.2275488377,
-0.096250616,
-0.1397135407,
-0.0311749689,
0.5602104664,
0.6149559617,
0.9512937069,
-0.0558011532,
0.5916844606,
0.3154653311,
-0.0431451164,
-0.2869048417,
-1.3511480093,
-1.2200678587,
-0.5068547726,
-0.1400415599,
-0.2841394246,
-0.1287526637,
0.8757789731,
0.2615559995,
-0.684726119,
-0.1731132716,
-0.1036821529,
-0.0331126228,
0.1601353288,
-0.1199526712,
0.4373827577,
-0.4616909325,
-0.5785189271,
0.0771271735,
0.2208241373,
0.1616097838,
-0.5670891404,
-0.0424993485,
0.4850073159,
0.0441949479,
0.4183790088,
-0.1289855093,
-0.831658721,
0.1127788723,
0.0441717841,
-0.1238488629,
-0.2316730618,
1.3106156588,
-0.7773977518,
0.3335088789,
0.56366992,
0.4574184418,
0.4349830449,
-0.114955008,
0.7397729754,
-0.3652664125,
-0.5879030228,
0.3390115201,
0.3300167322,
0.3286862671,
-0.1955475658,
0.6474428773,
-0.0017674066,
-0.7244801521,
-0.925018549,
-0.0250723381,
-0.7822095752,
0.0591832362,
1.4091132879,
0.1331623495,
0.2290437967,
0.2339878082,
-0.5952014327,
-0.1300826669,
-0.1587512195,
0.9027813077,
0.8492631316,
0.0977804437,
-0.0117711751,
-0.4027957022,
0.7572826147,
0.3454215527,
-0.9877280593,
0.1604141295,
0.3855269253,
0.3371909857,
0.1297792792,
0.6706429124,
-0.0674869567,
0.3810757995,
-0.3482936025,
-0.2579596043,
-0.3808959424,
-0.4472465515,
-0.2820845842,
0.2588838339,
0.1592084914,
0.4506492019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14651v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14651v1
|
DOSA: A Dataset of Social Artifacts from Different Indian Geographical Subcultures
| 2024-02-23T20:10:18 | 2024-02-23T20:10:18 |
Agrima Seth, Sanchit Ahuja, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Generative models are increasingly being used in various applications, such
as text generation, commonsense reasoning, and question-answering. To be
effective globally, these models must be aware of and account for local
socio-cultural contexts, making it necessary to have benchmarks to evaluate the
models for their cultural familiarity. Since the training data for LLMs is
web-based and the Web is limited in its representation of information, it does
not capture knowledge present within communities that are not on the Web. Thus,
these models exacerbate the inequities, semantic misalignment, and stereotypes
from the Web. There has been a growing call for community-centered
participatory research methods in NLP. In this work, we respond to this call by
using participatory research methods to introduce $\textit{DOSA}$, the first
community-generated $\textbf{D}$ataset $\textbf{o}$f 615 $\textbf{S}$ocial
$\textbf{A}$rtifacts, by engaging with 260 participants from 19 different
Indian geographic subcultures. We use a gamified framework that relies on
collective sensemaking to collect the names and descriptions of these artifacts
such that the descriptions semantically align with the shared sensibilities of
the individuals from those cultures. Next, we benchmark four popular LLMs and
find that they show significant variation across regional sub-cultures in their
ability to infer the artifacts.
|
[
-0.3646129966,
-0.7653315067,
0.3644997478,
0.1498959512,
-0.2365473956,
0.0882671475,
-0.3006059229,
-0.282286942,
0.7144539952,
0.0366282761,
-0.5887436271,
-0.5805404782,
-0.5179333091,
0.2856314182,
-0.315374583,
0.6578631401,
-0.0091339052,
0.1359789073,
-0.5332359076,
-0.2864271402,
-0.3792895377,
-0.6557559967,
-0.4824404418,
-0.2189880759,
0.5147176385,
0.3880226612,
0.2955815792,
0.3075787425,
0.3978464603,
0.2198015004,
-0.0805273429,
0.3964861333,
-0.6339874864,
0.1805296987,
-0.4056036174,
-0.759469986,
-0.0965436175,
0.0850157812,
0.0875806436,
0.5160887241,
-0.6105018854,
0.5757135153,
-0.1583307236,
0.2855659127,
-0.6866992712,
0.3224298656,
-0.5359009504,
0.2141979337,
-0.4146346748,
-0.2655145526,
-0.0685060918,
-0.4665105045,
-0.2228768915,
-0.8236581683,
0.4878214896,
0.0136202425,
0.651971221,
0.1765638143,
-0.2730544508,
-0.551644206,
-0.8095318675,
0.941221118,
-0.6016545296,
-0.0317301862,
0.9425413013,
0.4010494053,
-0.1629706174,
-0.5499309897,
-1.0930125713,
0.4370484948,
-0.0080165034,
0.1484306008,
0.086705476,
-0.6598337889,
0.0280685667,
0.5119332075,
-0.2861265242,
-0.0262881238,
-0.5486698151,
0.0602527224,
0.692461133,
0.326585561,
0.5470734835,
-0.4686287344,
-0.6135887504,
-0.1282750815,
-0.863987267,
0.105863452,
0.3151417971,
0.3475906849,
-0.3769625127,
0.5056706667,
-0.4243869185,
0.4752421379,
-0.0421743728,
-0.1526695341,
0.3909008801,
-0.3162498176,
-0.2055430561,
-0.2024714649,
0.7227880359,
0.4902950227,
0.2562866509,
-0.1129063219,
0.0344653577,
0.131451264,
0.1695751995,
-0.4959194958,
-0.1516940743,
0.147650063,
-0.5079707503,
-0.3107350767,
-0.1400573403,
-0.5881296992,
-0.6759470105,
-0.5405600667,
0.1107691824,
-0.2285834253,
-0.6566187143,
-0.0749820843,
-0.0095774205,
0.5833659172,
0.3358370066,
-1.0763047934,
0.0583786331,
0.8316258192,
0.9695590138,
-0.1189277694,
-0.3346793652,
0.2308722287,
0.0833753869,
-0.3570615351,
0.8081247807,
-0.6736932993,
-0.5781370401,
0.1623153239,
0.0580965392,
0.1015962809,
-0.6773738861,
0.321229279,
-0.3950636685,
0.1123834103,
-0.9777896404,
-0.2093323916,
-0.281399101,
0.7471157908,
-0.3517451882,
0.9917277694,
0.0305481069,
-0.6837397218,
0.814211309,
-0.3204506338,
-0.2650621235,
0.1247726083,
-0.5266194344,
0.0440876409,
0.1159729883,
0.4506965578,
0.6406980753,
-0.4278514981,
0.3785558939,
-0.2935021222,
-0.4103843272,
0.147570312,
-0.3458320796,
0.8961056471,
0.4388507009,
-0.0189063158,
0.0985923111,
-0.4926683605,
-0.4727108479,
0.2535646856,
0.0145914908,
-0.7297387719,
0.1332599968,
-0.0531276725,
0.0450870916,
-0.0694744885,
-0.7073219419,
0.2644746602,
-0.2469124049,
0.4728369713,
0.9257950783,
0.0116823604,
0.4125057161,
-0.5855859518,
0.6682563424,
0.2033700198,
0.4458263516,
0.0984066725,
-0.4478713572,
-0.5995351076,
-0.2329387069,
0.1242922619,
0.2420644909,
-1.0740557909,
-0.2501655221,
-0.3238459826,
-0.5922672749,
-0.2803010643,
0.0467999205,
0.0986388996,
0.3783027828,
0.2501486242,
-0.5777429342,
-0.4815616012,
-0.6621000171,
0.3876244426,
-0.2205521762,
-0.3710236847,
0.3526899219,
0.2772291005,
0.0963994414,
1.0763434172,
-0.4075114727,
-0.4856753945,
-0.0028807845,
0.1292167008,
-0.0732819811,
0.1374953985,
0.2904309332,
-0.9282457829,
-0.4069027305,
-0.25378263,
-1.0771993399,
0.0638506338,
0.3020783961,
-0.179154247,
-0.1296192408,
0.2928967774,
-0.2781216204,
0.3765711784,
0.6611666083,
-0.1646278501,
0.1988217682,
-0.0727639124,
0.4022355378,
-1.5986568928,
-0.1354195774,
0.0161733534,
0.1794951558,
-0.3491583169,
0.3045847714,
-0.209831357,
-0.1474545002,
-0.5912783742,
0.764007628,
-0.560751915,
0.2230050266,
-0.1961735785,
0.09448383,
-0.280482173,
0.4589404762,
0.2941582501,
0.9200459719,
0.4855450392,
-0.4530082047,
0.2458204627,
0.3837352395,
-0.4235237837,
0.9515265822,
-0.6126011014,
0.172350511,
-0.2885017395,
0.197454676,
-0.6490004659,
-0.2952997983,
0.2557184398,
-0.3894096017,
-0.1856761426,
-0.1527936906,
-0.6380209923,
0.0931153372,
-0.1383712292,
0.7338777781,
0.4748644829,
-0.3755269051,
0.5436620712,
0.9636036158,
-0.1568289548,
-0.3850485981,
-0.5686943531,
0.0552430004,
-0.4566514194,
-0.5490242839,
-0.169345811,
0.1533114165,
-0.5325934291,
-0.3179347813,
0.1970044076,
-0.0575443916,
-0.0043215933,
0.4923462868,
-0.1265384853,
0.0349251218,
0.1987231672,
-0.1386363357,
0.0826068521,
-0.0160057414,
0.3334240317,
0.7220489979,
0.0106534511,
-0.6211134195,
0.0808743685,
0.5020555854,
0.117565006,
-0.4096253216,
0.6738645434,
0.6665325761,
-0.4140886366,
-0.1885408461,
-0.5520249009,
-0.1592407674,
-0.4187506437,
-0.1532975286,
-0.2415294796,
-0.7694860697,
0.8211852908,
-0.0783322752,
-0.1810348183,
0.1340835541,
0.7876853943,
-0.1214307249,
0.2426291257,
0.680957973,
0.0527696796,
0.1928462237,
-0.3149040639,
0.2233803719,
-0.9551638961,
-0.402492106,
-0.2794248462,
-0.5236198306,
-0.4904224277,
-1.1225193739,
0.4783096611,
0.079129748,
0.0939362347,
0.0752614364,
-0.4692376256,
0.5007856488,
0.6277962327,
0.1286209822,
0.259647131,
0.0246916916,
0.1822190732,
-0.034813419,
-0.6438627839,
-0.6051297784,
1.2473505735,
-0.0332834534,
0.7327401638,
0.512088716,
0.7365933657,
0.5346596837,
0.7452952266,
-0.5794014931,
0.5730093122,
-0.1071700081,
-0.5940505862,
-0.181446299,
0.0076164179,
-1.042539835,
0.1604085118,
-0.2846381068,
-0.5737082362,
0.7383809686,
-0.1732801795,
-0.3210663497,
0.2541309297,
-0.5180321336,
0.4002438188,
0.3500789404,
-0.3225350082,
-0.1005522907,
-0.4789557457,
0.3607526422,
0.1404302716,
0.5838359594,
-0.389667958,
0.3302963078,
0.3779526055,
-0.226665929,
1.1801130772,
-0.2984252274,
-0.0894442126,
0.4569461346,
0.0469304211,
0.1937217563,
0.1322108507,
-0.1491988301,
0.4925568402,
0.1721157134,
-0.6702671051,
-0.3304224908,
0.6413282752,
-0.8037055135,
-0.5970007181,
-0.4965238869,
-0.549939692,
-0.2929745317,
-0.3357759714,
-0.1994003206,
0.3180987239,
-0.2030318081,
0.2769274116,
0.8868667483,
-0.2847232223,
0.2488548607,
0.3838096857,
-0.1711847335,
0.0371313654,
0.7574702501,
0.0642876476,
0.1226830408,
0.2352605164,
0.2735941112,
-0.1702260524,
-0.3694932461,
-0.3938649595,
-0.0524524301,
-0.7202086449,
-0.1034251899,
-0.424149543,
0.0494266488,
-0.5234025121,
-0.2377074361,
0.020747155,
-0.103457287,
-0.1206139401,
-0.2587485313,
0.2604668736,
0.7769013643,
-0.3318305314,
0.0595184751,
-0.4446105361,
0.225358367,
0.4517972469,
-0.0143093495,
0.2579927444,
-0.119810611,
-0.0923101529,
0.086863704,
0.0401414484,
-0.9581989646,
0.3705956042,
-0.2859087288,
0.6450286508,
0.1999689043,
0.2706748247,
0.6029980183,
-0.2676768899,
1.0555716753,
-0.0649771765,
-0.3980515897,
0.5050585866,
-0.6230297685,
0.140444234,
0.6361624002,
0.6829597354,
-0.803622067,
-0.3126865029,
-0.3495670855,
-1.1326020956,
0.384542346,
0.0149734812,
0.7168944478,
-0.612549305,
0.2682908475,
0.2793310285,
0.1484764516,
-0.5549010038,
-0.0711001456,
-0.1839585751,
-0.1147633791,
0.0148138665,
-0.3667290509,
-0.4697649181,
-0.0020405604,
0.5878739357,
-0.1214606017,
-0.0664291605,
0.4152207673,
-0.0477232262,
0.0375255533,
0.1563281417,
0.5520004034,
1.0445616245,
0.0359132476,
0.1861507595,
0.2233228832,
-0.4840988517,
0.1960003525,
-0.1963387579,
-0.5294441581,
-0.3185551763,
0.0892980695,
0.3759778738,
-0.1923960447,
-0.3956758082,
0.4700936973,
-0.3047625721,
0.0974110812,
-0.5484615564,
-0.0875972211,
0.3058953285,
0.2408017963,
0.411516577,
-0.2925611138,
0.1261719465,
-0.7097433209,
-0.0905660987,
0.3853420019,
-0.3105824888,
-0.1506455988,
0.5480577946,
0.4242272377,
-0.4626007676,
0.5000933409,
-0.4552224874,
-0.0219377708,
0.543543458,
0.1309770644,
0.6660773158,
0.0297956094,
0.5492928028,
0.5477709174,
0.1994834691,
0.0526892059,
0.3332510591,
-0.4437811077,
-0.882255137,
-0.3657110035,
-1.1375848055,
-0.4443807304,
-0.2599256933,
-0.6257457137,
0.0404932871,
-0.3318570256,
-0.1485425085,
-0.3557089567,
-0.1381162554,
-0.6763345003,
0.1590364724,
-0.0130155543,
0.6746072173,
-1.2513808012,
0.7803198099,
0.6943942904,
-0.7525431514,
-1.0017185211,
0.2528475225,
0.1408798546,
-0.9648762941,
0.729706347,
-0.3041873574,
0.0782522857,
-0.324377656,
-0.3917067349,
-0.7999685407,
1.3107624054,
-0.2178667635,
-0.340890348,
0.1085798368,
0.2470464706,
0.7156150937,
-0.0868000686,
0.2269120812,
-0.0752799213,
0.1516043246,
0.2765375972,
-0.8658704758,
0.2063806802,
-0.3411321044,
0.3152589202,
0.0348661728,
-0.8859066963,
1.0453071594,
0.1232533082,
-0.2960897982,
-0.0624693558,
0.786721766,
0.5413076878,
0.4129368961,
0.4507114887,
0.5179654956,
0.646930635,
-0.169819057,
1.0058205128,
-0.0689261928,
0.3940170109,
1.1931208372,
-0.3831166327,
0.851039052,
0.7823739052,
-0.5503302813,
0.4943455756,
0.7760043144,
0.1689826846,
0.4406219721,
0.5996174216,
-0.5079744458,
-0.1453290582,
-0.4026292861,
-0.395996362,
0.6471654177,
0.1729881912,
-0.0727368072,
-0.3552012742,
0.0306248572,
0.0880541056,
0.5817798376,
-0.2952132523,
0.8615797162,
0.0642548203,
-0.4989706278,
0.1615347415,
-0.0021543393,
1.080794096,
-0.6856315136,
-0.1761347204,
-0.8014359474,
-0.1574900448,
-0.0931657329,
-0.531437695,
0.6146285534,
-0.1063754782,
-0.3950782418,
-0.3440922201,
0.6435874701,
-0.2866613567,
-0.5490464568,
-0.144214347,
0.5020832419,
0.3235067725,
0.1088472456,
-0.2461197227,
-0.0902868137,
-0.3076702058,
-0.0537719503,
0.5923937559,
0.5795465112,
-0.439412564,
0.5163856149,
0.9143354893,
0.1867519468,
0.0136359865,
0.1537958533,
0.4820961654,
-0.3345635533,
-0.2086100876,
-0.6443478465,
0.2231438607,
-0.1131139025,
-0.4001218975,
1.0036188364,
0.4045779705,
1.3262574673,
0.0620147102,
0.6234089136,
-0.5753580928,
0.4509494901,
-0.4457621872,
0.8279824257,
-0.5479964018,
0.2026480883,
0.1407082528,
-0.5680814385,
0.0363039449,
0.4777361155,
-0.3227859139,
-0.0845598802,
0.1153265238,
0.84486413,
-0.0333118513,
0.024557922,
0.2481526881,
-0.0661493093,
0.4005442858,
0.1597673148,
0.9220141768,
-0.163349241,
0.0573619828,
-0.4419313371,
-0.1964113265,
0.2483772933,
-0.8787826896,
-0.5526986122,
-0.9050074816,
0.0438448898,
-0.2270141989,
-0.0396621078,
0.8896829486,
0.757029891,
-0.6375445127,
-0.4460945725,
0.237914905,
-0.0053576445,
-0.1718291044,
-0.3038301468,
0.2372452617,
-0.116171822,
-1.0011022091,
0.1455685198,
0.1826368272,
-0.3135851324,
-0.8956862688,
0.168970108,
-0.5378850102,
0.2343025357,
0.7011108398,
0.3263138235,
-0.665938139,
-0.2263469696,
0.0825353712,
0.0611184277,
-0.1654139012,
0.8003549576,
-0.6798654795,
0.5779048204,
0.5780848265,
0.3545232713,
0.4519807398,
0.0252647959,
0.5069697499,
-0.9107965827,
0.2444373518,
0.1644898802,
0.2074665278,
0.5822790265,
-0.1959225237,
0.7887868285,
0.2907037139,
-0.522187531,
-0.6935301423,
0.1822343469,
-0.9199461341,
-0.2823090851,
1.3565766811,
-0.3128418028,
-0.3210100532,
-0.1173302084,
-0.1512993574,
0.2337711304,
0.0765104443,
1.2853562832,
0.8732279539,
-0.0186265931,
0.1203424558,
-0.4691081941,
0.2655464709,
0.2264273912,
-0.9760103822,
-0.0234608799,
0.4548979998,
0.5101644993,
0.3075602949,
1.2482514381,
-0.187798664,
-0.11777284,
0.0555308089,
0.2183943093,
-0.0230094958,
0.0426739231,
0.1404085159,
0.3212738931,
-0.0062794508,
-0.1405851841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15579v1
|
CI w/o TN: Context Injection without Task Name for Procedure Planning
| 2024-02-23T19:34:47 | 2024-02-23T19:34:47 |
Xinjie Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This paper explores the challenge of procedure planning in instructional
videos, which involves creating goal-directed plans based on visual start and
goal observations from videos. Previous research has tackled this problem with
gradually weaker training supervision, from heavy intermediate visual
observations or language instructions to task class supervision. However, with
the advent of large language models, even given only the task name, these
models can produce a detailed plan. In this study, we propose a much weaker
setting without task name as supervision, which is not currently solvable by
existing large language models since they require good prompts with sufficient
information. Specifically, we hypothesize that previous intermediate
supervisions can serve as context information, and we use captions of visual
start and goal observations as a much cheaper form of supervision. This
approach greatly reduces the labeling cost since the captions can be easily
obtained by large pre-trained vision-language foundation models. Technically,
we apply BLIP to generate captions as supervision to train the context feature
with contrastive learning loss. Afterward, the context feature is fed into the
generator to aid in plan generation. Our experiments on two datasets with
varying scales demonstrate that our model can achieve comparable performance on
multiple metrics, which validates our hypothesis.
|
[
-0.1947386861,
-0.4720432758,
0.5419946313,
0.104002431,
-0.2807721496,
-0.6785339117,
-0.2594358623,
0.0160189178,
0.2547463477,
0.891859889,
-0.8001540899,
-0.6378859282,
-0.6797063351,
-0.1898443997,
-0.4871687889,
0.7660084963,
-0.06177219,
0.0570626147,
-0.0476708934,
0.3229523003,
-0.5506340861,
-0.1097083017,
-0.6555576324,
-0.1714499444,
0.4323914647,
0.6878349781,
0.09957923,
0.8102852106,
0.4995717108,
0.3265357316,
0.1640748233,
0.1664080024,
-0.1803088188,
-0.1614331454,
-0.2366145253,
-0.438988328,
-0.1977442056,
-0.1600974351,
0.313165009,
1.0184451342,
-0.0978571922,
-0.0024107816,
0.1475880146,
0.5754827857,
-1.0756950378,
0.3149131238,
-0.6188140512,
0.3617515266,
0.1172764003,
-0.4183376133,
-0.4565992951,
0.2781565785,
0.5062809587,
-0.5726701021,
0.3788419664,
-0.1305099577,
0.5831928849,
0.4439190626,
-0.2619658709,
-0.3428825438,
-0.7921921015,
0.7724852562,
-0.4089067578,
0.1288776249,
0.2730873823,
0.5652826428,
-0.1913124919,
-0.8147316575,
-0.4837578535,
-0.138251096,
-0.0544499531,
0.2624206543,
0.2043552399,
0.5744206905,
0.5850644708,
-0.0335996971,
-0.474165976,
-0.1064870656,
-0.5585139394,
-0.0172700919,
0.2682226896,
0.1520428061,
0.0509116054,
-0.2438386232,
-0.640599072,
-0.1325779855,
-0.7630668283,
0.1197913736,
-0.0623211712,
0.5817811489,
-0.3557349443,
0.7735455036,
-0.6069066525,
0.7736493945,
0.0736951083,
-0.3737467527,
-0.2163940072,
-0.0558388047,
-0.8501105905,
0.1398466229,
0.5282699466,
0.5213291645,
0.3655596077,
-0.0095864497,
0.0604613163,
-0.1612388641,
0.395177424,
-0.9357315898,
-0.3497235179,
0.0352227688,
-0.2236066312,
0.0570597611,
0.1579825133,
-0.4677286744,
-0.09077546,
-0.7391511798,
0.2212840021,
-0.3969857991,
0.1050345451,
-0.0948007703,
-0.2360623777,
0.2619965076,
0.5254917145,
-0.9815792441,
0.1492672265,
0.5227404237,
0.6594110727,
-0.1836120635,
-0.3636637628,
-0.8792509437,
0.7127057314,
-0.3740693629,
0.629082799,
-0.2827576399,
-0.6054457426,
0.5721811652,
0.30587551,
0.1675244272,
-0.3639018238,
0.1071530282,
-0.0124775274,
0.1637024581,
-0.3757174015,
-0.4839966297,
0.0061961748,
0.2627164125,
-0.2087953836,
0.2914996445,
0.0431314185,
-0.5862565637,
0.8883903623,
-0.6736510992,
-0.6653090119,
0.1785579473,
-0.5453295112,
0.0073490855,
-0.2071077228,
0.1644522846,
0.6890640259,
0.1898821294,
0.5104115605,
0.0640400276,
-0.4739940464,
-0.2594173551,
-0.0537347347,
0.6016440988,
0.0398903191,
-0.6306535006,
0.3139716983,
-0.5147153735,
-0.1200712696,
-0.509434104,
-0.1016856059,
-0.332898885,
0.013669054,
-0.0586950481,
0.1403244287,
-0.0343329944,
-0.2573292255,
0.2290209532,
-0.3605110347,
0.1234277263,
0.4740179777,
0.2275618911,
0.6586683989,
-0.014482772,
0.5004908442,
0.0451345965,
0.2645777762,
-0.2433805019,
-0.3498906493,
-0.8757987618,
-0.2522237301,
-0.1638493091,
0.5638935566,
-1.3009353876,
0.0384564176,
-0.045056887,
-0.3158323765,
0.244182542,
0.1094571799,
0.8623663187,
0.9752906561,
0.5061336756,
-0.0781898573,
-0.6939783692,
-1.2630975246,
-0.0154639082,
-0.0865485817,
-0.3378756344,
0.2581595778,
0.4678404629,
0.2246667445,
0.6065699458,
-0.8439133167,
-0.7577353716,
-0.4743266702,
0.106493026,
0.1776272804,
0.5936335921,
0.3059954941,
-0.9063446522,
-0.5681986213,
-0.2088871598,
-0.7336891294,
0.0477350354,
-0.3532580137,
-0.2664276063,
0.1571248472,
0.7313963175,
-0.3999502957,
0.6049862504,
0.3044750094,
0.0427583605,
0.7246082425,
-0.1736127287,
0.1927999556,
-1.2001142502,
0.1553705782,
0.2764858603,
0.0816494375,
-0.8093994856,
-0.0514941514,
0.0261385571,
-0.2111460865,
-1.0758140087,
0.6375504732,
-0.5701639056,
0.0385721512,
-0.3030308485,
-0.0016660376,
-0.2139327228,
0.8367605805,
0.6870145798,
0.8317850828,
0.7292791605,
-0.9947680235,
0.0299009439,
0.555719614,
-0.2698119879,
0.8456225395,
-0.5190941691,
-0.5653715134,
0.1011311933,
0.0716276094,
-0.5726786852,
-0.6253442168,
0.5337852836,
-0.2236935794,
0.4944511652,
-0.5503438711,
-0.053860005,
-0.2077660859,
-0.0871542171,
-0.0283786152,
0.4208725691,
-0.377322644,
0.2400467694,
0.1714690924,
0.0280445069,
-0.8894205093,
-0.963675797,
0.1234201938,
-0.4371365607,
-0.1199279204,
0.678594172,
0.0741009191,
-0.100051105,
-0.1869687289,
-0.26079005,
-0.3898946047,
-0.3704079986,
0.5343541503,
0.0935784578,
-0.0806844234,
0.0342240445,
0.2248768061,
0.1586346924,
0.1720703989,
-0.2327846587,
0.1043141335,
0.4773085117,
-0.1561362743,
-0.736161232,
0.5933527946,
0.2579468489,
-0.002253518,
0.4721194208,
0.1210344732,
-0.468143791,
-0.3606100678,
-0.3847463727,
-0.1499002129,
-0.5297400951,
0.2346861064,
-0.4242403209,
-0.5635799766,
0.0789901316,
-0.0803384185,
0.1296097934,
-0.1002845168,
0.2651133239,
-0.2122093588,
0.6416091919,
0.8285706639,
0.5181053281,
0.9056431055,
-0.5568882227,
-0.1128107682,
-0.9195378423,
-0.3115255237,
-0.132389769,
-0.0522018634,
-0.4196173847,
-0.4552433193,
0.4381634593,
0.0453901477,
-0.2048427612,
0.6260082722,
-0.5877023339,
0.2580542266,
0.6641843915,
0.1010662019,
0.0751377866,
0.0588212274,
0.1072075069,
-0.0469438024,
-0.5952392817,
-0.5943117738,
1.0617083311,
-0.3126578331,
0.3484577835,
-0.3531094491,
0.8872711658,
0.0956323147,
0.3026319444,
-0.7235688567,
0.9228292108,
-0.2780188024,
-0.2518590391,
-0.5332241058,
-0.0926940069,
-0.9217441678,
0.0915481821,
-0.0405387245,
-0.8584856391,
0.2512666583,
0.5234352946,
-0.2442032099,
0.085613139,
-0.8958387971,
1.0451105833,
0.0568252876,
-0.6245131493,
0.2126968354,
-0.6802664995,
0.6321026087,
0.3123834133,
-0.0645666122,
0.2484984249,
-0.0601983555,
0.6146823168,
-0.8702107668,
0.9503215551,
-0.5374729633,
0.1374697089,
0.485894382,
-0.0996038467,
0.3290374279,
0.0839213207,
0.3662993312,
-0.3921293318,
-0.0933218002,
-0.3376698494,
-0.6200939417,
0.6737181544,
-0.0238176174,
-0.8886266351,
-0.031153122,
-0.48426947,
-0.1904605478,
0.3406427801,
0.3956955075,
0.6794272661,
0.0421785489,
0.0839753672,
0.5511479378,
-0.2119459212,
0.5738030076,
0.2848585844,
0.1400673389,
-0.1101947278,
0.7799885869,
0.061874304,
0.3940504193,
0.5164563656,
-0.1192587763,
-0.1433987767,
-0.7747275233,
-0.5010367632,
0.0432435572,
-0.651373148,
-0.0640544817,
-0.4304435253,
0.0283893943,
-0.3225483894,
-0.5083415508,
-0.2463925928,
-0.1858842373,
-0.1721288115,
0.1007771939,
-0.1908615977,
0.1806746125,
0.0846070871,
0.7655884624,
-0.3537423909,
0.3221194744,
0.3318032026,
0.0401174091,
-0.2470093966,
0.0015117456,
-0.2105249763,
-0.0514062606,
-0.3665993512,
-0.9246308804,
0.4513781965,
0.1242153794,
0.3496735692,
0.8223942518,
0.2694222033,
1.0807470083,
-0.7583656311,
0.8671515584,
0.3160324395,
-0.6887914538,
1.048506856,
-0.2744501829,
0.4551110268,
0.6836363673,
0.4392924607,
-0.100426048,
-0.6529890895,
-0.5227323174,
-0.7606802583,
0.6616020203,
0.1043927222,
0.11760021,
-0.1992032379,
0.3709889054,
0.0854098648,
0.4176179767,
-0.4921584725,
-0.0635121986,
-0.2178932428,
0.1465737224,
0.057772778,
-0.0867813155,
-0.3366056681,
-0.0341729075,
0.4089174271,
-0.2303796709,
0.0955891162,
0.3978551924,
-0.024395315,
0.1013293862,
0.1995621622,
0.8152821064,
0.7662249804,
-0.0206601918,
0.0958177969,
0.0594710372,
-0.335080117,
-0.1664749235,
-0.1642774791,
-0.2248888463,
0.0355789661,
0.5975723863,
0.6982862949,
0.658921659,
-0.8606930375,
0.5946785212,
0.1966016144,
-0.5823819637,
-0.7137482166,
0.4234322608,
-0.1326372027,
0.4070824385,
0.1334437281,
-0.1878667027,
0.4610682428,
-0.5196800232,
0.2780657709,
0.3205634952,
-0.5651043057,
-0.0699937493,
0.7040910721,
0.1148667112,
-0.4704793692,
0.3855135739,
-0.1992620826,
-0.1628182083,
0.7811996937,
0.2909308672,
0.5665946603,
-0.1838540584,
0.4262570143,
0.5764788389,
0.0648276657,
-0.0716552734,
0.3820450604,
-0.4123868644,
-0.0753034502,
-0.5069854259,
-0.3901050687,
-0.4172055125,
0.153710559,
-0.7963873744,
0.6149255037,
-0.3187250793,
0.174972862,
-0.1375753731,
-0.2434402108,
-0.6228931546,
0.4965298176,
-0.0898145363,
0.9084060788,
-0.6735879183,
0.8135327697,
0.6847915053,
-0.5027070045,
-0.7135249376,
0.0807157829,
-0.1124508008,
-0.3968788981,
0.8423772454,
0.4314555526,
0.1227211431,
-0.2767864764,
-0.5205618143,
-0.4050916135,
1.0680763721,
0.0886317566,
-0.590765357,
-0.5507867336,
0.0370655358,
0.4957560897,
-0.460133791,
-0.2433558851,
0.1554200351,
0.4403699338,
0.6741191149,
-0.6064167619,
0.0043229698,
0.1851025522,
-0.0692391619,
0.1473950595,
-0.1416617632,
0.5563109517,
-0.490308702,
-0.3738990128,
0.068414636,
0.7353540063,
0.2585901916,
0.4036957026,
0.5485120416,
0.1058364734,
0.0064726165,
0.0494284816,
1.0766106844,
-0.0472123772,
-0.1916281581,
1.5076556206,
-0.0311046932,
0.7793667912,
0.9373214245,
0.0556828976,
0.2017664313,
0.4521326423,
-0.074348107,
0.9505627155,
0.2350684851,
0.0110695194,
-0.2329837084,
-0.1803425401,
-0.0516233407,
0.508271277,
0.3263948858,
-0.3204991817,
-0.1940317601,
0.2180895507,
-0.0438821241,
0.2197429687,
-0.3744726479,
0.6045159698,
-0.0166030712,
-1.1477127075,
0.4446873665,
-0.3590282202,
0.3353681564,
-0.5680910349,
-0.2295273989,
-0.1898384243,
-0.0158314537,
-0.1792601496,
-0.5830387473,
0.5215198398,
0.023342628,
0.0927838311,
-0.3560269177,
0.1335240453,
-0.7516376972,
-0.3035421968,
-0.0261101425,
0.413235575,
0.2499653101,
-0.0575700365,
-0.2375320792,
-0.4427492619,
-0.1176612377,
-0.1897419244,
0.3929405212,
0.3358996809,
-0.1483425945,
0.6089619398,
0.3290582001,
0.0945582986,
-0.092688106,
-0.0469213128,
0.7240251303,
-0.4017192423,
-0.4793660939,
-0.5214983225,
0.7909557223,
-0.2882081568,
-0.3177926838,
0.3177118301,
0.5259952545,
0.9460350275,
-0.4505651891,
0.5090405941,
-0.0630286038,
0.1225001812,
-0.8031664491,
0.4577600658,
-0.7593070269,
0.0250144266,
-0.4827813506,
-0.8791529536,
-0.3564493358,
0.2980504334,
-0.2926614583,
-0.196486786,
0.8420586586,
0.7254747152,
-0.18915084,
-0.4042449296,
0.5394995213,
-0.2460380942,
0.3497344851,
0.6851114631,
0.4784090519,
-0.0016803049,
0.7046298981,
-0.5787953734,
-0.2939406633,
-0.2206154913,
-0.9736072421,
-1.3118673563,
-0.795779109,
-0.3959237039,
0.2285397053,
0.3584941924,
0.5649982691,
1.036904335,
-0.5195464492,
-0.4109996259,
-0.3066968918,
-0.0341601968,
-0.3360178769,
-0.2498574853,
0.4638874531,
-0.4182073176,
-1.0243622065,
0.5417064428,
0.1752136946,
0.0038694364,
-0.2239350379,
-0.0533553734,
-0.0696311966,
-0.2636713684,
0.5765426755,
0.48068434,
-0.9601386189,
-0.4177514315,
-0.1118069068,
0.0755965933,
-0.1898254752,
0.9658809304,
-0.5096248984,
0.5438023806,
0.0945252329,
0.2906615734,
0.8084798455,
-0.054052148,
0.6316494942,
-0.9993052483,
0.4172836542,
-0.0374453627,
0.3785618544,
0.0417803191,
-0.3622304201,
0.5786729455,
-0.1363103539,
-0.111201942,
-0.780448854,
0.477576077,
-1.2886737585,
-0.1948990077,
1.0320937634,
-0.4019214511,
-0.2310418189,
0.1396380216,
-0.3799827695,
0.3750452995,
-0.2799815536,
0.7825026512,
0.4259529114,
-0.3309179246,
-0.2629935443,
-0.9109845161,
0.6983774304,
0.2008900642,
-0.7840434313,
0.0344936103,
0.6000202894,
0.1044827998,
0.0198613405,
0.623352766,
0.1862440854,
0.4816357791,
-0.0982792079,
0.0674016252,
-0.3567569256,
-0.7500146031,
0.2593114376,
0.3940577805,
-0.2618713677,
-0.4879544675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15571v1
|
Social Convos: Capturing Agendas and Emotions on Social Media
| 2024-02-23T19:14:09 | 2024-02-23T19:14:09 |
Ankita Bhaumik, Ning Sa, Gregorios Katsios, Tomek Strzalkowski
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media platforms are popular tools for disseminating targeted
information during major public events like elections or pandemics. Systematic
analysis of the message traffic can provide valuable insights into prevailing
opinions and social dynamics among different segments of the population. We are
specifically interested in influence spread, and in particular whether more
deliberate influence operations can be detected. However, filtering out the
essential messages with telltale influence indicators from the extensive and
often chaotic social media traffic is a major challenge. In this paper we
present a novel approach to extract influence indicators from messages
circulating among groups of users discussing particular topics. We build upon
the concept of a convo to identify influential authors who are actively
promoting some particular agenda around that topic within the group. We focus
on two influence indicators: the (control of) agenda and the use of emotional
language.
|
[
-0.6080465913,
-0.9254895449,
0.4557849765,
0.4372105598,
-0.6164193153,
0.1554699987,
-0.1277693659,
-0.4992257357,
0.8668321371,
0.5480586886,
-0.6836630106,
-0.6025534868,
-1.1395127773,
-0.22154136,
-0.5688122511,
0.905587554,
0.2025084645,
-0.1913991421,
0.3709422946,
-0.0559977256,
-0.0341064483,
-0.3499543965,
-0.8505347967,
-0.2488445342,
0.6640453339,
0.2572486103,
0.5381596684,
0.1618068963,
0.2870438099,
0.2261072397,
-0.1044268534,
0.3202704191,
-1.0863204002,
0.1971092373,
-0.309117049,
-0.0528919511,
-0.0266475864,
0.0513271131,
0.412673831,
0.2327837497,
-0.0703077316,
0.0957891196,
0.1839809567,
0.7237151265,
-0.5301808715,
0.2040696293,
-0.6947466731,
-0.1939187795,
-0.637111485,
-0.457497716,
-0.2959468067,
-0.6817010641,
-0.0164560489,
-0.4589199722,
-0.3161510825,
-0.0321981199,
0.5605016947,
-0.0365109146,
-0.7451425195,
-0.7433268428,
-0.5736799836,
0.6792955995,
-0.2933579683,
0.2261036634,
0.3179580271,
0.1463627368,
-0.482121259,
-0.5324438214,
-0.5162950754,
0.5407056808,
0.0618165284,
0.0970767811,
-0.7353851795,
-0.1932285577,
-0.0521889366,
-0.1116737425,
0.0461946651,
-0.1836852431,
-0.5198776126,
0.0559221059,
0.833121419,
0.0193103459,
0.4922786951,
-0.1175413206,
-0.1305750757,
0.2096226513,
-0.5633980036,
0.2852008343,
0.4363840818,
0.1346464604,
-0.603438735,
0.3953328133,
-0.1311966777,
0.3060339689,
0.5336378813,
0.2193417251,
0.0917484015,
-0.402952373,
0.1042750925,
0.1025229394,
0.9976335764,
0.629722178,
0.500184834,
0.1948094368,
0.1653643101,
0.0284055378,
0.0319472104,
-1.0075205564,
-0.0387480967,
0.1549062282,
-0.8188285232,
-0.1573094577,
0.3427561224,
-1.310855031,
-1.103990078,
-0.1563566029,
0.0944983512,
-0.1569409817,
-0.7995798588,
0.2137054205,
-0.4624622166,
0.2366503477,
0.3508469462,
-0.7541880608,
0.1815543473,
0.9986501336,
0.8857372999,
0.1576675028,
0.5164339542,
-0.3513389528,
-0.0196161531,
-0.3580076098,
0.8133766651,
-0.8151977062,
-0.3601752222,
0.4863831997,
0.2018141001,
0.2932858169,
-0.0508753099,
0.3247993886,
-0.6593589783,
-0.2764225602,
-0.646489501,
-0.5955311656,
-0.233687669,
-0.0399952047,
-0.4428525269,
0.5742923021,
-0.0458070859,
-0.6086012721,
0.319667697,
-0.4719548225,
-0.5656112432,
0.1850989014,
-0.3201920092,
-0.0880129486,
0.2115494311,
0.1221145466,
0.7407396436,
-0.2570215464,
0.0594813228,
-0.6634070277,
-0.1417531818,
0.2783872187,
-0.0541020185,
0.777526319,
0.0891902521,
-0.3271156847,
0.282007277,
-0.5048113465,
-0.3768272698,
-0.1928602159,
0.2220782042,
-0.8008257151,
0.322711736,
-0.0812462345,
0.114416264,
0.0452780575,
-0.3987041414,
0.2488010228,
0.1813461781,
0.3324996233,
0.666923821,
1.2116630077,
0.3287582099,
-0.2288758457,
0.4723349512,
0.0622973852,
0.1218915358,
0.2279015183,
-0.6878955364,
-0.3942990899,
-0.1049101204,
-0.3778784871,
0.1917408854,
-0.7557023168,
0.2042106986,
0.1193977818,
-0.9792331457,
-0.5717574954,
0.3311353326,
0.1716293842,
-0.1165572107,
-0.0157315861,
0.096331872,
-0.4788074493,
-0.5381417274,
-0.4803080261,
-0.0046083592,
0.2064798474,
0.2373178154,
0.2198825181,
-0.1935979575,
0.3668507338,
-0.3634389341,
-0.1407913417,
-0.3324679434,
0.51983881,
0.338277638,
0.1849632412,
0.6731020212,
-0.9821120501,
-0.7953267097,
0.1458371878,
-0.4468437135,
-0.3967581689,
-0.3132035136,
-0.581348002,
-0.3229523003,
0.7498688102,
-0.3518386483,
0.4966402352,
0.3724208772,
-0.5671954751,
0.2040624171,
0.3294413388,
0.6035913229,
-0.8082909584,
-0.3720989227,
0.5562489629,
-0.1287457049,
-0.6895307899,
-0.7304951549,
-0.186384514,
0.2021868378,
-0.4147998691,
0.3986575603,
-0.4282167852,
0.5034258962,
-0.062290214,
0.4395110607,
-0.2422885746,
0.2494785339,
-0.1734597832,
0.1363154054,
0.6942799091,
-0.5196146369,
0.2423090488,
0.1096229553,
-0.6467021704,
0.749258101,
-0.5363566875,
0.2852309048,
-0.422146678,
0.0249945484,
-1.2976380587,
-0.2970059514,
0.5362699628,
-0.2649898231,
-0.0051297578,
-0.372736454,
-0.1765156537,
0.0230182353,
-0.2258192003,
-0.2429730296,
0.42475757,
-0.0508473814,
0.6955276132,
1.1531504393,
0.0203746781,
-0.3408962786,
-0.1542332768,
-0.1426957101,
-0.3597219288,
-0.3742930591,
-0.0320831016,
0.463717103,
-0.5687838197,
0.2029996961,
0.0856879205,
0.1335730702,
-0.1961739361,
0.7371972799,
-0.4364019632,
0.1474391222,
0.216117084,
0.3164513707,
0.1854218245,
0.3257394433,
0.1326026171,
0.8004613519,
-0.0716588646,
0.0474870428,
-0.8265923262,
0.6354767084,
0.9167121649,
-0.1786958724,
0.6522483826,
0.5296731591,
-0.4509990215,
-0.4569125473,
-0.3467462063,
-0.2147340029,
-0.5123232603,
0.2527146637,
-0.0002625298,
-0.449053973,
0.784514606,
-0.3240648508,
0.0494344048,
0.3129229844,
0.673163712,
-0.1256593764,
1.0601115227,
0.5882733464,
-0.2009123415,
0.964340806,
-0.4326289892,
0.0072733872,
-0.4406428039,
-0.3490267098,
-0.4982100725,
-0.5086942911,
-0.7600166798,
-0.0936595052,
0.3076444268,
-0.1208218634,
-0.0556420572,
0.1702410877,
-0.4594297707,
0.1182097495,
0.3450097144,
0.4790434837,
-0.1657489687,
-0.1283945292,
0.4769358635,
0.092927739,
-0.4705083072,
-0.447124511,
0.518107295,
0.1008994356,
0.7992914319,
0.1299702674,
0.4112960398,
0.9279909134,
0.7648323774,
-0.5574480891,
0.6813355088,
-0.1653684378,
-0.5864607692,
-0.1164424345,
-0.1636494845,
-1.1790091991,
0.0572694317,
-0.6698135734,
-1.0117553473,
0.7317627072,
0.0178282913,
-0.2329876423,
0.3570044935,
-0.4192659259,
0.8759096861,
-0.1387779117,
-0.2558679581,
-0.6373743415,
-0.5983544588,
0.1434116066,
-0.0366308168,
0.390326649,
-0.5564712882,
0.0518035777,
0.803447485,
-0.0559932813,
1.0442614555,
-0.4093832374,
0.1022437364,
0.6227467656,
-0.0278319884,
0.6501032114,
-0.0417305343,
-0.1928917021,
0.2604694366,
-0.0994753018,
-0.0478910469,
-0.6301435232,
0.4784708321,
-0.7247998118,
-0.408377856,
0.068077825,
-0.1573579013,
0.1859651804,
0.2221521288,
0.3006345332,
0.5272868276,
-0.2302880138,
0.3966606259,
0.1878885776,
0.2547323108,
0.3930750787,
0.2365558445,
-0.1945274025,
-0.5302563906,
0.6748769283,
0.4398904443,
0.2616844177,
0.0165306795,
0.45128721,
-0.0964758471,
-0.3582567871,
-0.0745604485,
0.2438401878,
-0.5459457636,
-0.1467588842,
-0.7284735441,
0.282120496,
-0.2894306183,
-0.4036658406,
-0.203534618,
0.0663781911,
-0.3774885237,
0.0609268881,
0.5823854208,
0.8514657617,
-0.1824334413,
1.0450663567,
-0.4401355982,
0.1617396325,
0.0021346142,
0.1520933658,
-0.109847419,
-0.0132520013,
-0.2350180745,
0.0184535757,
-0.3225092888,
-1.7910761833,
0.3829679787,
0.1871790439,
0.3587193489,
1.3601676226,
0.3688677251,
0.5048465133,
0.0250789896,
0.6070491076,
0.1408881247,
-1.0492568016,
0.56973809,
-0.4724440873,
0.0107748602,
0.5684692264,
0.6497382522,
-0.8819820881,
-0.8425251842,
-0.7738702893,
-0.6364400983,
0.2301813364,
-0.019743925,
0.2010780871,
-0.2657475471,
0.4381996691,
-0.1815772653,
0.4215571582,
-0.4052380025,
-0.1967176497,
-0.0082913749,
-0.2717047632,
0.2950502932,
-0.4672693014,
-0.1362388581,
-0.0067347442,
0.6256785393,
0.2641333044,
-0.0709577203,
0.2404661179,
0.5350227356,
-0.262339741,
-0.057243865,
0.1620677114,
0.4615163803,
-0.2221185267,
0.3918320835,
-0.3645401895,
-0.5254352689,
0.0417271517,
-0.2691518068,
-0.2688564956,
0.1828340888,
0.2340247184,
0.4941359162,
0.1474018991,
-0.3064364493,
0.439882189,
-0.0351073705,
-0.0538502075,
-0.2899083197,
0.1573491693,
0.1532143652,
0.5155448914,
0.4580976367,
-0.1470348686,
0.2612615824,
-0.7398517728,
0.301127255,
0.6580813527,
-1.0652507544,
-0.719006896,
0.3826074898,
0.5446375012,
-0.5429065228,
0.1608482897,
-0.3965753317,
-0.5960576534,
0.7384382486,
0.2660665512,
0.8676816225,
-0.2044385076,
0.0464877076,
0.1352567226,
0.3847633004,
0.1141673699,
0.6074778438,
-0.0445621125,
-0.9416512251,
-0.2091486007,
0.0512041859,
-0.4073812068,
0.1115529984,
-0.6489004493,
0.6144830585,
-0.4601325691,
-0.7028864026,
0.5691213608,
0.0842237175,
-0.4450985789,
-0.2555486262,
-0.0235655028,
0.5872460604,
-1.0861952305,
0.4876161218,
0.5695747137,
0.0798380971,
-0.6757694483,
-0.0191484336,
0.2763246,
-0.3871288002,
0.1801221967,
0.2012140304,
-0.3318803012,
0.0006970679,
-1.0510333776,
-0.4829473197,
0.4603603482,
0.055303175,
-0.5601087213,
0.5684977174,
-0.2782002687,
0.3974065483,
-0.6501958966,
-0.1486951709,
0.5157910585,
0.670288682,
0.0852579847,
-0.1878096163,
0.1497464627,
-0.4372820556,
-0.6704575419,
0.6124831438,
-0.773383379,
0.3871254921,
-0.0223884173,
-0.5866475105,
-0.5963401794,
0.688323617,
-0.0184596311,
0.6934209466,
0.869548738,
-0.3134862483,
0.8210955858,
-0.0323766433,
1.0094347,
-0.6588892341,
0.172225967,
0.7299726009,
-0.120344907,
0.5827537775,
0.607922852,
0.1899786741,
0.4471878707,
0.6241412163,
0.1864559799,
0.6722922325,
0.285142988,
-0.2398073375,
-0.3809938133,
-0.3672514558,
-0.2639847696,
0.4622546732,
0.9380114079,
-0.1752298772,
-0.0465488583,
0.1199490055,
0.5493210554,
0.086213626,
-0.5313339829,
0.6492917538,
0.1451408863,
-0.6515017152,
-0.0060108476,
-0.4221755564,
0.4604206383,
-0.6664637923,
-0.1936628073,
0.008858162,
0.2158806175,
-0.0855321139,
-0.8026863337,
0.416890204,
-0.1345705837,
0.1892788559,
-0.1283127815,
0.9076968431,
-0.690905571,
-0.4348395467,
0.4475214779,
0.4204205573,
0.353752017,
-0.14947249,
-0.3690018654,
0.2370890528,
0.0947850347,
-0.3552962542,
-0.3494725823,
0.8547874689,
-0.0728709847,
0.5000616312,
0.5698001385,
0.3359093666,
-0.0531419702,
-0.0369453281,
0.7489486337,
-0.3808458447,
-0.2190628052,
-1.0522686243,
0.395069629,
-0.5596762896,
-0.5142455101,
0.9080604315,
0.1546616107,
0.2632187605,
0.2615396976,
0.5538930893,
-0.169209972,
0.2482903749,
0.0059784744,
1.0079489946,
-0.4224525988,
-0.0524577722,
-0.5362559557,
-0.1830971539,
-0.1156778038,
0.3397592008,
-0.2482174337,
-0.4960345626,
-0.101456441,
0.6401066184,
0.2000468373,
0.2872098386,
-0.0589848682,
0.3764021993,
0.5676230788,
0.3084090948,
0.9185763597,
0.0881796032,
0.3443579078,
-0.1338961273,
-0.5081328154,
-0.4271039069,
-1.0345230103,
-0.9662641287,
-0.5607218742,
-0.4988482296,
-0.6332499385,
0.0886828527,
1.1212594509,
0.8720568419,
-0.5994608402,
-0.1841164231,
0.0800950676,
0.7860431671,
-0.6240411401,
-0.1684938222,
0.6973425746,
0.0325545035,
-0.7094456553,
0.0012051022,
0.2632326782,
-0.0309690703,
-0.2083912194,
0.4090120196,
-0.3582910597,
0.6877525449,
0.462818563,
0.1880156994,
-0.1901910156,
-0.2344669849,
-0.0937339142,
-0.0434841737,
-0.2984661758,
0.9006075263,
-0.1582955122,
0.4433754086,
0.6547442675,
0.1136116311,
0.6007651091,
0.1883407831,
0.3042320609,
-0.5734080672,
0.3334345818,
0.0195924137,
0.393263638,
-0.0226979386,
-0.5921687484,
0.3630815148,
0.3021917045,
-0.4252259135,
-0.6891177893,
-0.0197407398,
-1.2283346653,
-0.0127079478,
1.4758501053,
0.0729785562,
-0.2510551214,
-0.4223849773,
-0.2903597653,
0.383951664,
-0.8227989078,
0.8745831251,
0.62958318,
-0.2376842201,
-0.1775894165,
-0.6779690981,
0.5366883874,
-0.1487599462,
-0.8444998264,
0.0299293119,
0.3478563428,
-0.1340144724,
0.2501704693,
0.7862083912,
-0.0274107363,
-0.1958283633,
-0.1044653654,
-0.0454941764,
0.2693428993,
-0.2381927818,
0.1811780334,
0.6335244179,
-0.8394511342,
-0.3979404569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15570v1
|
Fast Adversarial Attacks on Language Models In One GPU Minute
| 2024-02-23T19:12:53 | 2024-02-23T19:12:53 |
Vinu Sankar Sadasivan, Shoumik Saha, Gaurang Sriramanan, Priyatham Kattakinda, Atoosa Chegini, Soheil Feizi
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a novel class of fast, beam search-based
adversarial attack (BEAST) for Language Models (LMs). BEAST employs
interpretable parameters, enabling attackers to balance between attack speed,
success rate, and the readability of adversarial prompts. The computational
efficiency of BEAST facilitates us to investigate its applications on LMs for
jailbreaking, eliciting hallucinations, and privacy attacks. Our gradient-free
targeted attack can jailbreak aligned LMs with high attack success rates within
one minute. For instance, BEAST can jailbreak Vicuna-7B-v1.5 under one minute
with a success rate of 89% when compared to a gradient-based baseline that
takes over an hour to achieve 70% success rate using a single Nvidia RTX A6000
48GB GPU. Additionally, we discover a unique outcome wherein our untargeted
attack induces hallucinations in LM chatbots. Through human evaluations, we
find that our untargeted attack causes Vicuna-7B-v1.5 to produce ~15% more
incorrect outputs when compared to LM outputs in the absence of our attack. We
also learn that 22% of the time, BEAST causes Vicuna to generate outputs that
are not relevant to the original prompt. Further, we use BEAST to generate
adversarial prompts in a few seconds that can boost the performance of existing
membership inference attacks for LMs. We believe that our fast attack, BEAST,
has the potential to accelerate research in LM security and privacy. Our
codebase is publicly available at https://github.com/vinusankars/BEAST.
|
[
-0.3986935616,
-1.3008002043,
0.2428473532,
0.2536104023,
-0.3229234815,
0.2074793726,
0.0093706846,
-0.3605426848,
0.2195744812,
0.6150644422,
-0.5756293535,
-0.2839605808,
-0.5782511234,
-0.3556801677,
-0.6854599118,
0.6716628075,
0.7073906064,
-0.0287786257,
0.3817238212,
-0.0617511347,
-0.3789084256,
-0.4703834057,
-0.9552246928,
-0.2118700594,
0.5282661915,
-0.2158302665,
1.2457101345,
0.914200604,
0.5705692768,
0.3175651133,
-0.2906630933,
0.0244586039,
-0.6678299308,
0.1570382118,
-0.0832848549,
-0.1187246367,
-0.2958371639,
-0.1725540012,
0.3245462775,
0.3027352393,
-0.2488770336,
-0.035801366,
-0.0235736631,
0.6541723013,
-0.623416245,
-0.0318193734,
-0.9444844127,
0.2616815865,
-0.4925971925,
-0.1334378272,
-0.4839797616,
-0.2790944874,
-0.1953839809,
-0.4043073952,
0.4956474304,
0.057626266,
0.8084979057,
0.3679029346,
0.0731383264,
-0.1769412458,
-0.4665075839,
0.2882090211,
-0.5750483871,
0.3880045712,
0.0210245661,
0.3242520988,
-0.5619197488,
-0.7612802982,
-0.3817949593,
-0.3786866963,
0.0041578542,
-0.2065529674,
-0.622846365,
0.1370344609,
0.4794395566,
0.2574087977,
-0.7690062523,
0.251217097,
-0.3376363814,
-0.3278149962,
0.5927792192,
0.3698758781,
0.4570795,
-0.1686516553,
-0.3510974348,
-0.2366656363,
-0.6042164564,
0.1965979189,
0.5782404542,
0.4896833003,
0.1418649107,
0.2693497241,
0.0915783197,
0.7015277147,
-0.0041563474,
0.1515848339,
-0.174369067,
0.1165924668,
-0.2567404509,
0.2050655484,
1.2926677465,
0.0055655716,
-0.2741473019,
-0.4444805086,
-0.1440576017,
0.2760400772,
0.5892596245,
-1.1217962503,
-0.2900988162,
0.2844631374,
-0.2998936474,
-0.5343254209,
-0.0579614677,
-0.9605674148,
-1.0510058403,
0.4390415251,
0.4507310987,
-0.5820875764,
-0.172387138,
0.3702421784,
-0.0300889444,
0.2402522862,
0.0588485934,
-0.8102385998,
0.2329437733,
0.8211567998,
0.8626723289,
-0.0295868851,
-0.2364809662,
-0.9712007046,
-0.2819080651,
-0.4221716523,
0.6065239906,
-0.389981091,
-0.7775436044,
-0.2181249112,
-0.1970111132,
-0.0572326593,
-0.4701240063,
0.7092310786,
-0.578147769,
0.0679475516,
0.1444261372,
-0.3741213977,
-0.1405355334,
0.0501032956,
-0.923301816,
0.8309910893,
-0.1988367736,
-0.8394368291,
-0.2429268062,
-0.7996726632,
-0.4698742926,
0.2142873257,
-0.0261763316,
-0.3210087419,
0.2654543817,
0.279078126,
0.3893845379,
-0.2636964023,
0.2542366683,
-0.5111990571,
-0.6039270759,
0.5441859961,
-0.4277547002,
0.931263566,
0.4457752705,
-0.4527171552,
0.212843433,
-0.6604223251,
0.215618059,
0.4709356725,
0.0821265057,
-0.2341563255,
0.2456812263,
-0.0398848802,
-0.021616701,
0.100498043,
-0.4398249388,
0.3237739801,
-0.4248677194,
0.4174404144,
0.6908444762,
-0.218042165,
0.1130664349,
0.098588638,
0.4819573462,
-0.3332021832,
0.4440267384,
-0.1629213393,
-0.3545654416,
-0.4652640522,
-0.3166177273,
0.1640817672,
0.5621013641,
-0.9443056583,
0.1643529832,
0.0975356773,
-0.8137977719,
-0.9196478128,
0.0564345047,
0.7428004146,
0.2682955861,
0.3108571172,
-0.2866693437,
-0.3835024834,
-0.8492690921,
-0.6465084553,
-0.3202715814,
-0.0716644898,
0.1525127739,
0.2640738189,
-0.3567161262,
0.6188066602,
-0.6375492215,
-0.1952724457,
-0.3834426701,
0.185486719,
0.2007819563,
0.2732542455,
0.7999998331,
-0.568169415,
-0.1365772337,
-0.1530597061,
-0.8181062341,
-0.1304884702,
-0.1273048669,
-0.248942852,
-0.1361225843,
0.4739535749,
-0.5750796199,
0.2667765915,
0.4033461809,
-0.5019497871,
0.3175714314,
-0.0989305973,
-0.048691351,
-0.9862520695,
-0.1564788967,
-0.0071801539,
-0.0620348155,
-0.9942406416,
0.4846888781,
0.0527399927,
-0.4761218727,
-0.7998916507,
0.6562843919,
-0.1814227551,
0.1521330923,
-0.5081179142,
0.2152009755,
-0.1112551317,
0.6130653024,
-0.2212194204,
0.8099338412,
0.6676369309,
-0.4529847801,
0.3864910901,
0.0205750056,
-0.2382151335,
0.0651246086,
-0.8282356858,
0.6585903764,
-0.0684832856,
-0.0709739402,
-0.5265781283,
0.035213612,
0.4921652675,
-0.7718530893,
0.3327580988,
-0.0211866926,
-0.2385365963,
-0.1797184944,
-0.4454031289,
-0.1088326424,
0.177551955,
-0.7021263838,
0.5838276148,
0.409450829,
0.1794034839,
-0.9290184379,
-0.4922182262,
0.3360750973,
-0.1167160049,
-0.5510802269,
0.1613411456,
-0.0019823413,
-0.407661587,
0.0235057045,
0.0646323711,
0.0695814416,
0.6633280516,
0.2773365974,
0.2700035572,
-0.0854519606,
-0.3311127424,
-0.4065447748,
-0.0977085978,
0.308175087,
-0.1150656939,
0.7343367338,
-0.3967742026,
-0.2913408577,
-0.6128339171,
0.378539294,
0.7532889843,
-0.2609265149,
0.8864682317,
0.764329195,
-0.3798238635,
-0.2037331611,
-0.236513406,
-0.286549896,
-0.5208123326,
0.790489614,
-0.3449056447,
-0.7816858292,
0.5770802498,
0.4473239779,
0.1819528043,
0.2523460984,
0.3770564795,
0.3431990147,
1.2288277149,
0.5602805614,
-0.539875567,
0.5324816704,
-0.3115725517,
0.3179935813,
-0.5535311699,
-0.2587933838,
-0.681920588,
-0.1352253258,
-0.5149014592,
-0.3699595034,
0.027950678,
0.0371920876,
-0.0897613764,
0.3080554903,
-0.5513571501,
0.4233962893,
0.4253355265,
0.1283279061,
-0.060733825,
-0.1896378845,
-0.0065550171,
-0.1244355291,
-0.6720437407,
-0.2474284917,
0.8998039961,
0.3486717641,
1.0664689541,
0.1305261105,
0.3120431602,
0.6830436587,
0.3524335027,
-0.7859876752,
0.819444716,
-0.1640457958,
-0.6185106039,
-0.0886544809,
-0.4860994518,
-0.9285444021,
0.5913999081,
-0.2616446614,
-0.8496590257,
-0.2114910781,
-0.0182951074,
-0.5461047292,
0.7821106911,
-0.6501752138,
0.9991304874,
-0.4364118874,
-0.4503358901,
-0.1515893638,
-0.4643211067,
0.5249468088,
-0.0430922434,
0.210433498,
-0.1332451403,
0.4152770042,
0.6738622189,
-0.2511403263,
0.6889855862,
-0.3085356355,
0.1109716371,
0.1162671223,
0.4500448108,
0.5496976972,
0.1708439291,
0.0796865448,
0.2147322744,
-0.4254285693,
-0.3250330389,
-0.9038336873,
0.5311035514,
-0.6795072556,
-0.9455586672,
-0.5327019691,
-0.4981386065,
0.0915742815,
-0.1885192245,
0.1675586551,
0.5500666499,
-0.448299706,
0.1674637198,
0.8264274597,
-0.2961587012,
0.4910055101,
0.6681147218,
-0.5240929127,
-0.3452182114,
1.0856271982,
-0.2298810929,
0.115940325,
0.2274091691,
0.0748359486,
-0.2201292515,
-0.6393275857,
-0.6588394642,
0.1879251152,
-0.3844771683,
-0.1876538843,
-0.7000973225,
-0.405302465,
-0.3004946113,
0.0620225556,
-0.8543912768,
-0.1125070006,
-0.1525376588,
0.1709714234,
0.3944199681,
0.5881664157,
0.2459088862,
0.5429786444,
-0.8561059237,
0.3125936091,
0.2676029205,
0.1255151182,
-0.1190560982,
-0.5641971827,
-0.2722244561,
-0.0199986417,
-0.4350916147,
-1.0342652798,
0.5494741797,
0.0015351099,
0.5719906092,
0.7813687921,
0.089975886,
0.7000290155,
-0.301943928,
0.6348235607,
0.1539250761,
-0.9683927894,
0.4274466038,
-0.0776590332,
0.2091319114,
0.2462876439,
0.1052275971,
-0.7744690776,
-0.6387602687,
-0.5600741506,
-0.602142334,
0.8591117859,
0.468803525,
0.1216865629,
0.16362077,
0.26930511,
0.0173032284,
0.0412516929,
-0.4146366417,
-0.7807461619,
-0.3364144266,
0.2683166265,
-0.1097407714,
-0.1947707236,
0.0408999585,
-0.0780484006,
0.7995699048,
-0.0756528452,
0.2155794352,
-0.0757215619,
-0.1491340697,
0.1609227657,
0.4215131402,
0.5519890189,
0.2332864702,
-0.3136587441,
-0.0299855899,
0.0700033605,
-0.7814720869,
-0.0204314422,
0.5231097341,
-0.2989933491,
0.1590289772,
0.1136637405,
1.0984374285,
0.0357038565,
-0.6701905131,
0.2266615331,
-0.7178729177,
-0.0670881122,
0.040974699,
0.2087766081,
0.0392649136,
0.5002570748,
0.3722049296,
0.042574361,
0.0027727862,
-0.4282572567,
0.0065166317,
0.6323939562,
-0.5779864788,
-0.3706783354,
1.0610390902,
0.018625414,
-0.5929637551,
0.5931307077,
-0.3721645772,
-0.6651077271,
0.4732292593,
0.4837410748,
1.2389853001,
-0.5394604206,
0.3214062452,
0.063793771,
0.5130146146,
0.0230182465,
-0.0143123092,
0.2832860053,
-0.7257682681,
-0.045197431,
-0.6081479192,
-0.6004854441,
0.5058507323,
-0.7133820057,
0.1558050513,
-0.5691766739,
-0.1826674342,
0.1018784195,
-0.0317229964,
-0.165109396,
-0.0462195165,
0.3619271815,
0.7441356778,
-0.427893281,
1.0201649666,
0.5629677773,
-0.0176356062,
-0.5702697039,
-0.3477090597,
0.179347381,
-0.5897139311,
0.2702680528,
0.2306460887,
-0.4163182974,
-0.2561407983,
-0.5059944987,
-0.5820066929,
0.6680260301,
0.7620328069,
-0.5455734134,
0.0111164777,
0.0049978634,
0.4068326056,
-0.1744610518,
0.1456866711,
0.7614322901,
0.1008121893,
-0.1221649796,
-0.5266076326,
-0.0103904167,
-0.5283111334,
-0.0559506081,
0.3600639105,
-0.6206233501,
0.8721495867,
-0.2499994189,
-0.258851856,
-0.1278020144,
0.8744627237,
0.1956892461,
0.2006956488,
0.5342285037,
0.6083106399,
0.8620717525,
-0.1919507533,
1.0321559906,
-0.5068645477,
0.3028086126,
0.9022743702,
-0.1521628946,
0.5602167845,
0.2735639811,
0.0322958641,
0.1329836547,
0.6435618997,
-0.018309338,
0.5539965034,
0.289766252,
-0.2884706259,
-0.2238639444,
-0.0646553412,
-0.6417999864,
0.3330516517,
0.4532262385,
-0.0625422746,
-0.189171508,
0.2658903897,
0.6244170666,
0.0341868252,
-0.4115386009,
0.4951520562,
-0.0106237298,
-0.3479336798,
0.7512695193,
0.2382276505,
0.6598890424,
-1.0290310383,
0.356947273,
-0.3855441213,
0.5450074077,
0.0347730964,
-0.4439969957,
0.073573254,
0.2216407657,
-0.0144411465,
-0.0270730313,
0.7136098146,
-0.1417041123,
-0.4300402999,
0.4841581881,
0.3758818209,
0.1564023644,
-0.3633119762,
-0.8523969054,
0.2173359096,
0.10104049,
-0.4502959847,
0.4734820724,
0.0484815165,
0.0793256983,
0.9277291894,
0.5718752742,
0.0236998275,
0.1115168706,
0.0719984993,
1.0166742802,
-0.7510677576,
-0.3640736341,
-1.2755293846,
-0.0464799553,
-0.0301459227,
-0.1891880035,
0.8391962051,
0.7414052486,
0.7257651091,
0.1580435187,
0.6779242158,
-0.0463827066,
0.2011931688,
-0.5521945357,
1.085523963,
-0.4831453562,
0.4250522554,
-0.1601233035,
-0.5061227679,
-0.2437591106,
0.1651582271,
-0.0776706561,
-0.4073947966,
0.740009129,
1.1155636311,
0.2555288374,
0.1932824999,
0.3791454434,
0.2379734218,
0.5913170576,
0.5882562399,
0.9036580324,
-0.3768636286,
0.8522241712,
-0.3554414809,
0.1191326827,
-0.0586549118,
-0.5228351951,
-1.2208511829,
-0.1028306857,
-0.2885919511,
-0.6290354729,
0.4287294149,
0.9048730135,
0.379291147,
-0.6193333268,
-0.2444821894,
0.3446853757,
0.2047594637,
-0.2043314874,
-0.2347259372,
0.5185310841,
-0.2427195162,
-0.7031838894,
0.7116099,
0.2406985611,
-0.2168911099,
-0.4309909642,
-0.1478576213,
0.0745678693,
0.1715383232,
0.1988963038,
0.4310355484,
-0.731484592,
0.0151881259,
0.1492659748,
-0.4128997028,
0.1160876751,
0.9601380825,
-0.8544721007,
0.5407806039,
0.276406914,
0.7953387499,
0.3323466778,
-0.0715359971,
0.3385367393,
-0.4411388636,
0.4406127036,
0.1129444093,
0.40591833,
0.3425394297,
-0.3878162205,
0.3163953424,
0.3940845728,
-0.1634324491,
-1.0141367912,
0.1326852143,
-0.7504598498,
-0.4994927347,
0.7951222062,
-0.150876537,
-0.6016966105,
0.1125863269,
-0.3554173708,
0.1491071135,
-0.5579506159,
0.979319036,
0.2988586426,
0.0896337926,
0.1871225089,
-0.6041768789,
0.6537905335,
0.1936118305,
-0.7027126551,
0.2029539496,
0.1517971605,
-0.0836418569,
0.0917980671,
0.3138577342,
-0.1437301785,
0.4166778028,
0.1624682844,
0.2473904192,
-0.445635289,
-0.2010585666,
-0.4923647642,
0.5590102673,
-0.2904549837,
-0.301833421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15506v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15506v3
|
AgentOhana: Design Unified Data and Training Pipeline for Effective Agent Learning
| 2024-02-23T18:56:26 | 2024-03-20T06:00:14 |
Jianguo Zhang, Tian Lan, Rithesh Murthy, Zhiwei Liu, Weiran Yao, Juntao Tan, Thai Hoang, Liangwei Yang, Yihao Feng, Zuxin Liu, Tulika Awalgaonkar, Juan Carlos Niebles, Silvio Savarese, Shelby Heinecke, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Autonomous agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have garnered
significant research attention. However, fully harnessing the potential of LLMs
for agent-based tasks presents inherent challenges due to the heterogeneous
nature of diverse data sources featuring multi-turn trajectories. In this
paper, we introduce \textbf{AgentOhana} as a comprehensive solution to address
these challenges. \textit{AgentOhana} aggregates agent trajectories from
distinct environments, spanning a wide array of scenarios. It meticulously
standardizes and unifies these trajectories into a consistent format,
streamlining the creation of a generic data loader optimized for agent
training. Leveraging the data unification, our training pipeline maintains
equilibrium across different data sources and preserves independent randomness
across devices during dataset partitioning and model training. Additionally, we
present \textbf{xLAM-v0.1}, a large action model tailored for AI agents, which
demonstrates exceptional performance across various benchmarks. Begin the
exploration at \url{https://github.com/SalesforceAIResearch/xLAM}.
|
[
-0.0182686243,
-0.6272847056,
0.5941895247,
-0.0932619795,
-0.0202506799,
0.3392172456,
-0.0353587978,
-0.3282352686,
0.3060869575,
0.7466452718,
-0.4090135694,
-0.6743246317,
-0.311709702,
-0.3188486397,
-0.424849242,
0.7602251172,
-0.1184288934,
-0.0216259435,
-0.2300590873,
-0.5395329595,
-0.6234830022,
-0.3421741128,
-0.7926370502,
-0.5748984814,
0.6849883199,
0.5946191549,
0.8272716403,
0.9547950029,
0.1850475818,
0.4259777069,
0.5129420757,
0.4891806245,
-0.4657341838,
0.5646702647,
-0.1104077771,
-0.5184041262,
-0.6746653914,
-0.2113209367,
0.5736057162,
0.504920423,
-0.6121761203,
0.0947962999,
-0.3534613848,
0.3227600455,
-0.6180950403,
0.3027333319,
-0.5660011768,
0.0130206803,
-0.0197932273,
-0.1540629417,
-0.4456730783,
-0.1336263269,
-0.0877800435,
-0.8472590446,
-0.1224560216,
0.1532849967,
0.6037169099,
0.4847316444,
-0.6877222061,
-0.3192173243,
-0.9453312755,
0.7461115718,
-0.2859543562,
0.1987091601,
0.0589844771,
0.7443316579,
-0.0367612094,
-0.8111297488,
-0.5102331042,
-0.0216957182,
0.2415857613,
-0.076012142,
-0.0687495247,
0.0152441822,
-0.1029595584,
0.1833776981,
-0.7165207267,
0.3424561322,
-0.0011884996,
0.0017044788,
0.8916717768,
0.6623541713,
0.4232276678,
0.3500028253,
-0.3720878661,
-0.5002967715,
-0.6818044782,
0.0118296007,
0.4746820927,
0.6314306855,
-0.0470298342,
0.4009836614,
-0.1513468623,
0.4842291474,
-0.1405006498,
-0.0447730273,
0.2461965233,
0.0969254076,
-0.2348337322,
0.0058336137,
0.7933828235,
-0.1014783829,
-0.2605518699,
-0.3823599517,
-0.2661991417,
-0.009700397,
0.6179367304,
-0.8535336852,
0.0074682776,
0.6207520962,
0.0669757873,
-0.1289020926,
-0.1270367205,
-0.654792726,
-0.5976011753,
-0.7206977606,
0.3866842389,
-0.304178983,
-0.3418211043,
-0.0224407334,
0.2107190639,
0.489713341,
0.3225639164,
-0.7161054611,
0.2774166465,
0.8162440062,
0.6255631447,
-0.3161010742,
-0.5159591436,
-0.8095341921,
0.2021958828,
-0.5227313042,
0.919518888,
-0.6336590052,
-0.140038684,
0.2559096515,
-0.0218439344,
-0.0477317236,
-0.5704237819,
0.2178505957,
-0.6666388512,
-0.216258809,
0.044940453,
-0.715611577,
-0.2804989815,
0.2180490345,
-0.7435664535,
0.6464450955,
0.0716950372,
0.1877955049,
0.2967552245,
-0.7021829486,
-0.5001364946,
0.0903076231,
-0.515938282,
-0.669423759,
-0.2089341879,
-0.1402250379,
0.3503561616,
-0.2883366942,
0.3487341106,
-0.346280843,
-0.1650419384,
0.0000563134,
-0.1710190177,
0.745742321,
0.3027585447,
-0.3530596197,
0.490457356,
-0.9322111607,
0.118205376,
0.3387929797,
-0.2039275616,
-0.2020507157,
0.0085575376,
0.1079832241,
0.2238598764,
0.0986303315,
-0.1879707575,
0.4779586792,
0.1008445323,
-0.025021214,
0.9134147763,
-0.3343375027,
0.5481160283,
-0.2639153302,
0.7897591591,
-0.0814054534,
0.1886742711,
-0.1524081826,
-0.1361614466,
-0.6119374037,
-0.4174771309,
-0.1080505252,
0.2722935379,
-0.769528687,
0.4670110345,
-0.2803329527,
-0.7220594883,
-0.5491030216,
0.4277701378,
0.161210984,
0.0628073663,
0.2904425859,
-0.0645578653,
-0.4354926348,
-0.4717109203,
0.1550654471,
0.0342636257,
0.0023686097,
0.1423982829,
0.2297837883,
-0.5554713011,
0.9962053895,
-0.4408221245,
-0.4076600075,
-0.524102211,
0.2856601477,
-0.2373588383,
0.2938726544,
0.6558684111,
-0.620942235,
-0.50518924,
0.226232782,
-1.0271105766,
0.0363138281,
-0.206876263,
-0.4873650074,
0.241907537,
0.3948756456,
-0.8693233728,
0.2705661952,
0.5042949915,
-0.3650956452,
0.0804298073,
-0.1351832747,
-0.2563645244,
-1.2775183916,
0.0682791471,
-0.3107867837,
-0.3312778175,
-0.613738656,
0.3472617865,
-0.1481395215,
-0.0902786702,
-0.5004464388,
0.7098133564,
-0.5444916487,
-0.2267919928,
-0.6340617537,
0.0806915015,
-0.1035031676,
0.7078482509,
0.0344910733,
0.4366918504,
0.7426382899,
-0.6160054207,
0.7298009396,
0.2699141502,
0.1225076914,
0.5289788842,
-0.5468239188,
0.4964717627,
-0.1291093081,
0.3094833493,
-0.7617344856,
-0.2951635122,
0.1869138032,
-0.1813783199,
0.1779019535,
0.2073494196,
-0.5827922225,
-0.0002608659,
-0.122789897,
0.3422843516,
0.4300381541,
-0.7652746439,
1.2341468334,
0.6309152246,
0.2327098548,
-0.6420238614,
-0.2250039726,
-0.013053135,
-0.2686797678,
-0.2272506803,
-0.1540530324,
-0.2130679488,
-0.3462913036,
-0.1883073896,
-0.0035169767,
-0.1367839575,
0.0310527477,
0.4890442789,
0.2682054937,
-0.0242527537,
0.2937043905,
0.009901342,
-0.1150551885,
0.0892737135,
-0.3335590065,
0.6904969811,
0.09897203,
-0.424182415,
-0.1413360834,
0.3649671376,
0.6863624454,
-0.1254690737,
0.8005604744,
0.512624681,
-0.1795241535,
-0.7143294215,
-0.0470070429,
-0.0367507488,
-0.4650996625,
0.354888171,
-0.1962938756,
-0.4927798808,
0.5751883984,
0.0435938761,
0.4621076286,
0.1781588495,
0.7041738629,
0.1194235831,
1.0054706335,
0.6457582712,
-0.3133712709,
0.5637575984,
-0.5910127163,
0.0857519358,
-0.3132837117,
-0.2005191594,
-0.3838673532,
-0.3083298802,
-0.4596621394,
-0.4183175862,
0.0520807356,
-0.7220892906,
-0.4191611707,
0.3122883737,
-0.1742279083,
0.3848194182,
0.4091373682,
-0.0751549378,
0.3541118801,
-0.059781719,
0.3898052275,
0.5387712717,
-0.7326753139,
-0.4643203318,
1.4492065907,
0.2141540796,
1.0051300526,
0.3411044776,
0.6228001714,
0.3351821899,
0.3681254387,
-0.9096997976,
0.6289639473,
0.2745127976,
-0.7723332047,
-0.5951032639,
-0.463833034,
-1.5344519615,
0.3996241093,
-0.0084895724,
-0.3374931812,
0.0329461917,
0.0966252014,
-0.3408571184,
0.3323757946,
-0.555516541,
0.8065030575,
-0.4302058816,
-0.452175647,
-0.272384882,
-0.5059784651,
0.1443965435,
-0.069831863,
-0.0521645397,
-0.1846706867,
-0.1896890849,
0.3298435211,
-0.8393452764,
0.8878902197,
-0.0851881877,
-0.5021358728,
0.658716023,
-0.1351144314,
0.6819936633,
-0.0551233888,
0.2319169194,
0.1216171533,
-0.4862253666,
-0.6721237898,
-0.5888763666,
0.5661352277,
-1.0680360794,
-0.1951011568,
-0.5341780186,
-0.8208656907,
-0.1773756444,
0.124907203,
-0.0862628222,
0.5386882424,
-0.242417261,
0.0650932342,
0.5187081099,
0.0957160518,
0.4400597811,
0.9224339128,
-0.376707077,
-0.1850406975,
1.0963888168,
0.0698976517,
0.1651841402,
0.4823928475,
-0.2770905793,
-0.3423443437,
-0.4253008366,
-0.362088412,
0.0099123036,
-0.7127669454,
-0.2992783785,
-0.5712797642,
-0.1281993836,
-0.4798809886,
0.010684873,
-0.7257926464,
-0.0240125079,
-0.1924164444,
-0.2766068578,
0.2368892431,
0.7391106486,
-0.0135757849,
0.4963952303,
-0.5428984165,
0.5402003527,
0.7270687222,
0.2796928287,
0.0246354248,
-0.2905862927,
-0.4958417416,
-0.1757773459,
-0.5138403773,
-0.4397567213,
0.4661337733,
0.1267341077,
0.7540427446,
0.5514068604,
0.1089942753,
0.3401494026,
-0.3750206828,
0.3979050517,
-0.1042357236,
-0.6025871634,
0.4793775678,
-0.4148688912,
0.404322207,
0.4769812226,
0.3941676319,
-0.2265755534,
-0.51936692,
-0.5745723844,
-1.0379786491,
0.7470510602,
0.2922411859,
0.0512055904,
0.2752431929,
0.0841208845,
0.3573874831,
0.3176845908,
-0.5598368645,
-0.5899307728,
-0.1336548626,
-0.3812107742,
-0.2883505523,
0.3036504388,
-0.2218066603,
-0.1070680842,
0.7616282105,
-0.4033982754,
0.1364970058,
-0.3155825734,
-0.3800196648,
-0.177429527,
0.0205654763,
0.3565114737,
0.7147679925,
-0.1627947092,
0.0346442275,
-0.2116554528,
-0.5802756548,
0.569707334,
0.260220021,
-0.1308484823,
0.050555665,
0.4899885952,
0.9205521941,
-0.091804184,
-1.0080169439,
0.1210601777,
-0.2542575002,
0.0611996464,
-0.5071733594,
0.4376607835,
-0.1969994158,
0.471790731,
0.4238743782,
-0.1080482826,
0.1638960689,
-0.8712844253,
0.0355565287,
0.2811656594,
-0.1561484188,
-0.3859768808,
0.4697083831,
0.3746884465,
-0.3657993078,
0.498408556,
-0.3219401538,
-0.126309827,
0.8644276261,
0.2059502304,
1.187325716,
-0.5445446372,
0.3085359335,
0.1592974514,
0.180322364,
-0.1199397966,
0.1040051952,
-0.119891949,
-0.7614634037,
-0.1915940493,
-0.3870605528,
-0.732124269,
0.1546520442,
-0.4379687905,
0.2192721665,
-0.351423353,
0.0814401954,
-0.2561992407,
0.0157680549,
-0.684586525,
0.1323789358,
0.350001812,
0.5356464982,
-0.7167351246,
0.9703787565,
0.9183824062,
-0.4754199088,
-0.9616891146,
-0.1410889477,
0.0710483417,
-0.8899980783,
0.0987592414,
0.095431529,
-0.1753433794,
-0.1678631753,
-0.6830130219,
-0.7540864348,
1.4040801525,
0.6617239714,
-0.4312707782,
0.0881818905,
0.5778613687,
0.5960308313,
-0.7032648921,
0.330850333,
0.6736955643,
0.3047944903,
0.1824563742,
-0.3789100647,
-0.1227868497,
-0.2533508539,
-0.1534071118,
0.0097298119,
-0.9692014456,
0.8492004871,
-0.0313322656,
0.003612417,
-0.0539660826,
0.770763576,
0.4484790564,
0.6029330492,
0.4727623463,
0.5678824782,
0.8869402409,
0.1943286061,
0.9607694745,
-0.1178859398,
0.3109174073,
1.4610501528,
-0.6017325521,
0.6378818154,
0.1009432673,
-0.021967601,
0.6196074486,
0.5110822916,
0.3266093433,
0.4491631091,
0.0023734309,
-0.1421488523,
-0.3900333941,
-0.0694475546,
-0.1237638146,
0.7655336857,
0.096445702,
0.0024625186,
-0.1793722659,
0.0817374215,
0.0678557158,
0.0868684575,
-0.4486814141,
0.7769876122,
-0.0064003002,
-0.6249558926,
0.4233674109,
-0.4737198949,
0.1930249333,
-0.7499916553,
-0.1448202282,
-0.6356022358,
0.3257860541,
0.0564354397,
-0.4656936526,
0.1199727505,
-0.1384592801,
0.1028263941,
-0.1184660122,
0.3887780309,
-0.5581676364,
-0.300191015,
0.556492269,
0.4100173116,
0.0545333214,
-0.1257530004,
-0.5185907483,
0.2788981497,
-0.381282568,
-0.2775327861,
0.388981849,
0.6263697743,
0.1782472432,
1.0058284998,
0.2811887264,
-0.2152713239,
-0.0517583936,
0.04336299,
0.7570597529,
-0.5734171867,
-0.6046353579,
-0.5191246867,
0.4707263112,
-0.1102628931,
-0.1365803182,
0.7586494684,
0.5630963445,
0.5559231043,
0.0946382135,
0.7214818001,
0.1332689971,
0.2279666364,
-0.4203710258,
0.6494078636,
-0.7652159333,
0.2910395265,
0.0910806507,
-0.9900497794,
0.1434006393,
0.1547679007,
0.1037957296,
0.1405698061,
0.6206777692,
0.5425907969,
-0.094058454,
-0.2453072518,
0.4481886029,
0.2354603261,
0.5265206099,
0.5786837339,
0.7681903243,
-0.4502765238,
0.7235482931,
0.0862484127,
0.0525017492,
-0.4110580683,
-0.451403141,
-0.9861565828,
-0.5168451071,
-0.4466512799,
-0.0192454811,
-0.0665332824,
1.2252854109,
1.0353597403,
-0.7115359306,
-0.5870084763,
-0.2535690963,
0.315518111,
-0.3358177841,
-0.1524163187,
0.0744466931,
-0.4014524221,
-0.9272450209,
0.4534889758,
0.0852618292,
0.0119786644,
-0.5081836581,
-0.4539600015,
0.018719703,
0.3681297898,
0.6064733267,
0.5922560096,
-0.2749796808,
0.0045933854,
-0.2792892456,
-0.3467010856,
0.2275794446,
0.6625697017,
-0.6459742188,
0.3876851499,
0.1513850987,
0.7964259386,
0.3454304039,
-0.113306649,
0.6762116551,
-0.704768002,
0.4217954278,
0.1616774946,
0.2669748068,
0.2366171032,
-0.4684294164,
0.730561614,
-0.0492966771,
-0.5991988182,
-0.8003085852,
0.0139086219,
-1.1726967096,
-0.2595575154,
1.0533120632,
-0.0414026268,
-0.4150090218,
0.0226424094,
-0.1389276534,
0.3469545543,
-0.7494724989,
0.8778916001,
0.3679843247,
-0.1118115783,
-0.088391155,
-0.484607935,
0.2155900449,
0.2468837798,
-1.3830772638,
0.0801763162,
0.7026033401,
-0.1524735987,
0.1803014427,
0.4971526563,
0.4078023434,
0.2228819877,
0.1827591211,
0.3823743165,
-0.0483372696,
-0.6808905005,
-0.4879487753,
0.2421285361,
0.0020609715,
-0.4144678712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00801v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00801v1
|
Self-Retrieval: Building an Information Retrieval System with One Large Language Model
| 2024-02-23T18:45:35 | 2024-02-23T18:45:35 |
Qiaoyu Tang, Jiawei Chen, Bowen Yu, Yaojie Lu, Cheng Fu, Haiyang Yu, Hongyu Lin, Fei Huang, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Yongbin Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rise of large language models (LLMs) has transformed the role of
information retrieval (IR) systems in the way to humans accessing information.
Due to the isolated architecture and the limited interaction, existing IR
systems are unable to fully accommodate the shift from directly providing
information to humans to indirectly serving large language models. In this
paper, we propose Self-Retrieval, an end-to-end, LLM-driven information
retrieval architecture that can fully internalize the required abilities of IR
systems into a single LLM and deeply leverage the capabilities of LLMs during
IR process. Specifically, Self-retrieval internalizes the corpus to retrieve
into a LLM via a natural language indexing architecture. Then the entire
retrieval process is redefined as a procedure of document generation and
self-assessment, which can be end-to-end executed using a single large language
model. Experimental results demonstrate that Self-Retrieval not only
significantly outperforms previous retrieval approaches by a large margin, but
also can significantly boost the performance of LLM-driven downstream
applications like retrieval augumented generation.
|
[
-0.3365535736,
-0.6088178754,
0.663757503,
0.0636992082,
-0.0802839249,
0.2250989079,
-0.2641511261,
-0.5116975904,
0.4239562452,
0.6803824306,
-0.2769284844,
-0.2169567347,
-0.3515906632,
0.2891635299,
-0.7675131559,
0.7348329425,
0.0759303123,
-0.0394626632,
-0.1469558179,
0.0838478059,
-0.2541261315,
-0.658503592,
-0.2657823563,
-0.3487692177,
0.6102182269,
0.4031931758,
0.4795153439,
0.7392225862,
0.5772929788,
0.2921605408,
0.3626800179,
-0.2264477313,
-0.5353089571,
0.4816834927,
-0.4111152887,
-0.47392717,
-0.1994236261,
-0.0639669001,
0.7313520312,
0.2289624065,
-0.241144672,
0.5231941342,
0.0528804995,
0.76584059,
-0.6846404076,
-0.1620222777,
-0.5417898893,
-0.1532974839,
-0.3667893112,
-0.3362877071,
-0.5565800071,
-0.0757219046,
0.1028334498,
-0.139968574,
-0.0798475817,
0.1687654555,
0.3997015059,
0.1548711807,
-0.2971552014,
-0.39803195,
-0.6709783077,
0.4731168747,
-0.594424665,
0.4099739194,
0.1681289226,
0.4149434268,
-0.0862502307,
-0.8672535419,
-0.4147233963,
-0.3166733384,
-0.0937276632,
0.1065443605,
-0.1426894367,
-0.0959176943,
-0.2500255704,
0.4798980653,
-0.5033577085,
-0.0065681175,
-0.4812049568,
0.0749642774,
0.4395489395,
-0.0565625653,
0.4268731177,
-0.3915172219,
-0.435823828,
0.0459034853,
-0.7438974977,
-0.4736068845,
0.3207813203,
0.5216834545,
0.5361639261,
0.7227725387,
-0.3758493364,
0.4179140329,
-0.0891870484,
0.0333439931,
0.0295370221,
-0.1977228671,
-0.2595359087,
0.2217808068,
0.7738426924,
-0.0591948479,
-0.0267127585,
-0.3832751215,
-0.6369085908,
-0.2952457368,
0.5061022043,
-0.831743896,
0.3927207291,
0.1132541373,
-0.6796105504,
-0.1221654192,
-0.0540109351,
-0.7349185348,
-0.0488628708,
-0.4343672991,
0.8841998577,
-0.3293212652,
-0.3805938661,
0.0531040467,
0.1049840301,
0.4474868178,
0.1312850565,
-0.7797369957,
0.5260558128,
0.5446458459,
0.925745368,
-0.2568597794,
-0.1881546378,
-0.4170309305,
0.2430952936,
-0.4535841346,
0.8380167484,
-0.6028391123,
-0.4365108609,
0.0015012226,
-0.2493375242,
0.3266662657,
-0.6443329453,
0.339941144,
-0.7823494077,
0.2317474782,
0.0091227405,
-0.4979737401,
-0.0085531082,
0.4080687463,
-0.4219844043,
1.1291015148,
-0.0297871623,
-0.455575496,
-0.1808392853,
-0.5304914117,
-0.4147241116,
0.3141947091,
-0.3774878085,
0.0705775097,
0.3004105985,
-0.0598001368,
0.4741386473,
-0.6972247362,
0.2735155225,
-0.2516194582,
-0.2447957695,
-0.1701724082,
-0.3082571328,
0.2200530469,
0.4120590985,
-0.0736433417,
-0.254786402,
-0.6279805899,
0.1744146347,
0.1826240271,
-0.6387185454,
-0.5623059869,
-0.0975930467,
-0.2312594056,
0.2824366689,
0.9438475966,
-0.8114154339,
0.4774330258,
-0.3055367172,
0.1997494698,
0.691421628,
-0.2408719957,
0.5428693891,
-0.2071865946,
0.4545453191,
-0.3169935942,
0.1322462112,
-0.4929320514,
-0.0024141639,
-0.6476353407,
-0.0949025005,
0.1320272386,
0.3770634234,
-0.274045676,
0.3829101026,
-0.3649442196,
-0.5348756909,
-0.8299936652,
0.3413994908,
0.3883488178,
0.4542120695,
0.5365711451,
-0.2580922842,
-0.4985715151,
-1.0482195616,
-0.0720241666,
-0.2389231771,
-0.0816546306,
0.3262454271,
0.462463975,
-0.3988561928,
0.9356334805,
-0.5298320651,
-0.6665751934,
-0.2642467022,
0.2756012082,
0.4125062227,
0.2684726715,
0.2021575123,
-0.7381983995,
-0.4802983403,
0.1179507524,
-0.8901225328,
-0.1966996789,
-0.0551481284,
-0.2103327215,
0.0725724772,
0.5921234488,
-0.4476363957,
0.2727905214,
0.1407944858,
-0.0929646939,
0.583150506,
-0.6609205604,
-0.0482228361,
-0.8678889871,
0.2569731772,
-0.356190443,
-0.2497323155,
-0.3448161781,
0.3385199904,
0.2503828108,
0.0413356647,
0.0260841399,
0.8124797344,
-0.9364281297,
-0.5730063319,
-0.5818682313,
0.1705854237,
0.0548875742,
0.2071551234,
-0.1949049979,
0.9768429399,
0.5032379627,
-0.6743505001,
0.2360202521,
0.0913738534,
-0.1841391176,
0.4329947829,
-0.4843957722,
0.1713153869,
-0.7098246813,
0.0491203219,
-0.9066668749,
-0.1156344414,
-0.3212937415,
-0.4261576533,
0.5085817575,
-0.1490566283,
-0.6621357203,
-0.3491019309,
-0.2370545119,
0.1284680516,
0.419893384,
-0.9427672029,
0.9941532612,
0.4214093387,
-0.4634094238,
-0.617135644,
-0.5704029799,
0.5441488624,
0.0409072675,
-0.5446942449,
0.393428117,
-0.308902353,
-0.1060298383,
-0.1025336534,
-0.0145463059,
0.0950920284,
0.0507062785,
-0.0223926678,
0.2226920277,
-0.2065535933,
0.6229307652,
-0.1456064135,
-0.0217287131,
0.0361563712,
-0.3775064349,
0.5960183144,
-0.108935222,
-0.4117643535,
0.0389357023,
0.6453544497,
0.5265825391,
-0.5747414827,
0.4031322002,
0.1434999853,
-0.2605040073,
-0.1251848191,
-1.0256797075,
-0.10760656,
-0.4987313151,
0.3285684884,
-0.6232179999,
-0.7598717809,
0.4597043693,
-0.1466162503,
0.026456112,
0.3913531899,
0.4906821847,
-0.1794118434,
0.9155517817,
0.7357285619,
-0.2348292619,
0.5600534678,
-0.1524277776,
0.1756154895,
-1.0926561356,
-0.3786420524,
-0.5711189508,
-0.1834859699,
-0.3311946392,
-0.2759142816,
0.3448444903,
0.1282312125,
-0.2500749826,
0.3084310293,
-0.686485827,
0.3833130598,
0.6612179279,
0.1200303212,
0.5245873928,
-0.0702555776,
-0.2652789354,
0.1862502545,
-0.3381832242,
-0.5664149523,
1.1644718647,
0.205222398,
1.1382699013,
0.4163723886,
1.0945272446,
0.4094010293,
0.7255190015,
-0.5322255492,
0.5489684343,
-0.1792072803,
-0.6580875516,
-0.3224560022,
-0.3397080302,
-0.8145998716,
0.4503497481,
0.2051428109,
-0.7438705564,
0.1184837371,
-0.3774880469,
-0.1162162647,
0.0594486222,
-0.6518104076,
0.538685739,
-0.7086495757,
-0.5197710991,
-0.3716843724,
-0.5495272875,
0.1768826246,
-0.4547404647,
0.3109630644,
-0.0937168524,
-0.1966005862,
0.5399438143,
-0.1092595384,
0.5640652776,
0.0739449486,
-0.117749773,
0.4167152941,
0.5061838031,
0.4392131567,
-0.1341511309,
-0.5595440269,
-0.2106832862,
0.0606978908,
-0.0633516014,
-0.7857860923,
0.8291809559,
-0.6865178943,
-0.9009267688,
-0.4072662294,
-0.0341052003,
0.1969520301,
0.6659675241,
-0.0082083447,
0.4739361405,
-0.3200879395,
0.1835043281,
0.3937340975,
-0.1072401181,
0.5158531666,
1.0169594288,
-0.5998250246,
-0.1384904534,
0.918137908,
0.3088626266,
0.1410765052,
0.6340520382,
0.306299597,
-0.7118016481,
-0.4169399738,
-0.2853477597,
0.4294271767,
-0.8384481668,
-0.4443435073,
-0.6891524196,
-0.178509295,
-0.6304639578,
0.1055496633,
-0.515900135,
-0.0619782358,
-0.4227577448,
-0.078134954,
-0.0151318926,
1.0453345776,
-0.3199579418,
0.0985941887,
-0.8406906128,
0.2669879198,
0.2672003508,
0.6199449897,
0.131660834,
-0.8508014679,
-0.1569585651,
-0.3031331301,
-0.2003184557,
-0.7780665755,
0.6768023968,
0.2748194933,
0.6495879889,
0.3506822288,
0.1563539952,
0.5905407667,
-0.6070418954,
0.3697056472,
0.0083734384,
-0.6701567173,
0.5991459489,
-0.1700230241,
0.3316046596,
0.6037842035,
0.3964032829,
-0.6034445763,
-0.1887517869,
-0.1925838739,
-0.936727345,
0.4994001091,
-0.1779726297,
0.3851055205,
-0.3947423697,
0.5964418054,
0.0434221327,
0.1144716889,
-0.8271083236,
0.0705806985,
-0.0005682635,
-0.1983916163,
0.2414965034,
-0.465266645,
0.0843747705,
0.0996640548,
0.7349899411,
-0.4606402218,
0.3224280179,
0.762073338,
-0.1948337555,
-0.1917620748,
0.4984836578,
-0.1620899439,
0.4861952662,
-0.2800680697,
0.2564863861,
-0.138561219,
0.0689982474,
0.1797202528,
-0.0424947217,
-0.0750791505,
-0.3273387849,
0.1020207256,
0.1343244165,
0.2288990468,
-0.8520452976,
0.4753604829,
-0.0896056518,
0.2918280959,
-0.5978138447,
-0.1384329647,
0.0309868287,
0.2838224173,
1.0798305273,
-0.6372374296,
0.4348942935,
-0.7757939696,
0.5744979382,
0.6466973424,
-0.0762628391,
-0.0767720789,
0.5663912296,
0.0330990851,
-0.3511123657,
0.6289448142,
-0.0736236423,
-0.2773629427,
0.3321217597,
0.7537224293,
0.9239211082,
-0.4649781883,
0.1145149916,
0.4247302413,
0.2535520792,
-0.3651662469,
0.2056522071,
-0.2415795475,
-0.5361424088,
-0.3900623024,
-0.9381994009,
-0.1388811171,
-0.0428870544,
-0.5306379795,
0.1912665814,
-0.3207595348,
-0.0128352083,
-0.284620285,
-0.0493903495,
-0.3767877221,
0.2109820247,
0.3159318268,
1.0519043207,
-0.0533150472,
0.7075589895,
0.3927732408,
-0.6061524749,
-0.4164890349,
-0.2614823282,
-0.3769957125,
-0.8022484779,
1.0230246782,
0.3195502758,
-0.33852157,
0.1395955533,
-0.4681965113,
-1.3150815964,
1.1880699396,
0.2983835936,
-0.5721418858,
-0.3731648624,
0.0216010679,
0.7208829522,
-0.5796554685,
0.7381227612,
0.3687846363,
0.3053198755,
0.1341576725,
-0.8251350522,
0.061085701,
-0.0756557584,
-0.0065698819,
0.2341485471,
-0.8113058209,
0.7255975604,
-0.3112616837,
-0.5218583345,
0.17376405,
0.8767558932,
-0.2794867158,
-0.1401292831,
0.2626347244,
0.4604685903,
0.5027198195,
0.4211446643,
1.1357495785,
-0.7025586963,
0.2940945327,
1.2158263922,
-0.354185164,
1.1840173006,
0.3234917521,
0.0674194992,
0.2994899154,
0.3333460093,
0.1621580124,
0.4446699917,
0.1813149154,
-0.3859598041,
-0.4053338766,
-0.2098625451,
-0.148000434,
0.6355756521,
0.4071610272,
-0.5146285295,
-0.6817608476,
-0.0631293282,
-0.3397036493,
0.1482286751,
-0.2563163638,
0.774510622,
0.0483239256,
-0.8950380683,
0.1287699193,
0.0727666691,
0.7164526582,
-0.761294663,
-0.0531638637,
-0.3416688442,
-0.0353464857,
-0.1530999094,
-0.823841989,
0.2395716161,
-0.1603407711,
-0.0496045798,
-0.5510175824,
1.0930114985,
-0.3993653953,
-0.3929840326,
0.9890103936,
0.7650424242,
0.274662286,
-0.2060734481,
-0.4798012376,
-0.1852356195,
-0.1653439403,
-0.5946865678,
0.6984722018,
0.4261311591,
0.2460423708,
1.2115740776,
0.6589373946,
-0.0054816375,
0.1717244983,
-0.0506774411,
0.942070663,
-0.8705961108,
-0.379027009,
-0.8383978009,
-0.1003564969,
0.216473639,
0.0252768826,
0.5380615592,
0.8258859515,
0.6495896578,
0.3042606115,
0.8934118152,
-0.1278731227,
0.6577453613,
-0.2451366782,
0.5546827912,
-0.8341002464,
0.2710413635,
0.0674404502,
-0.802601397,
0.0819215849,
0.4218060374,
-0.1079179496,
0.0141167659,
0.2954880893,
0.813763082,
0.0157716274,
-0.2189779133,
0.6490681171,
0.4459381998,
0.374211669,
0.1490095109,
0.7086040378,
-0.2760719955,
0.6623645425,
0.0717029721,
-0.2518378794,
-0.2268606126,
-0.6071148515,
-0.4871852696,
-0.68610394,
0.2288547456,
-0.0880316868,
0.0517794602,
0.89388448,
0.4971233606,
-0.2008969635,
-0.382303983,
0.145588547,
0.0406495444,
0.4428729415,
-0.2398430407,
0.0452878401,
-0.7452887893,
-0.6297258139,
0.7395570874,
0.6974756718,
0.021785697,
-0.8332030177,
0.0480907299,
-0.4546831846,
0.0278438143,
0.5926246643,
0.4628743231,
-0.5197834969,
-0.2245562375,
0.2315330207,
-0.4389093518,
0.3195947111,
0.7976247668,
-1.116669178,
0.6582135558,
0.3670525849,
0.910313189,
0.6525749564,
0.0174640417,
0.7309715748,
-0.5893923044,
-0.4706491828,
0.2447021455,
0.336790204,
0.3090711832,
-0.690579474,
0.675367713,
-0.2085933089,
-0.6894217134,
-0.5730923414,
0.1552190483,
-0.5177060962,
-0.4007070065,
1.0093204975,
0.1117890626,
-0.4888398945,
-0.0635238066,
-0.0990180448,
0.1335974634,
-0.4748368859,
0.8805395961,
0.555924356,
-0.1527360827,
-0.1714426875,
-0.4379577041,
-0.0667416602,
0.420948565,
-0.7283318043,
0.2063145489,
0.3262809217,
0.3924668133,
0.5012851357,
1.0281726122,
-0.2147095501,
-0.0978178307,
-0.4725503325,
0.4063004553,
0.1135268733,
-0.4464125931,
-0.2749549747,
0.2591601312,
0.119863376,
0.1486700028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16893v1
|
The Good and The Bad: Exploring Privacy Issues in Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
| 2024-02-23T18:35:15 | 2024-02-23T18:35:15 |
Shenglai Zeng, Jiankun Zhang, Pengfei He, Yue Xing, Yiding Liu, Han Xu, Jie Ren, Shuaiqiang Wang, Dawei Yin, Yi Chang, Jiliang Tang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is a powerful technique to facilitate
language model with proprietary and private data, where data privacy is a
pivotal concern. Whereas extensive research has demonstrated the privacy risks
of large language models (LLMs), the RAG technique could potentially reshape
the inherent behaviors of LLM generation, posing new privacy issues that are
currently under-explored. In this work, we conduct extensive empirical studies
with novel attack methods, which demonstrate the vulnerability of RAG systems
on leaking the private retrieval database. Despite the new risk brought by RAG
on the retrieval data, we further reveal that RAG can mitigate the leakage of
the LLMs' training data. Overall, we provide new insights in this paper for
privacy protection of retrieval-augmented LLMs, which benefit both LLMs and RAG
systems builders. Our code is available at
https://github.com/phycholosogy/RAG-privacy.
|
[
-0.3637208939,
-0.5856323838,
0.3868884444,
-0.1022673473,
-0.1437790543,
0.4566931427,
0.0626298487,
-0.6735147834,
0.1790557057,
0.910274744,
-0.1873418391,
-0.3391389549,
-0.6455183029,
-0.2286469191,
-0.531984508,
1.2715910673,
0.3144556582,
-0.0760586634,
-0.1347658038,
-0.1070049033,
-0.2889313102,
-0.7721424103,
-0.5338781476,
0.0187069215,
0.4783127904,
0.1658053398,
0.5451232195,
0.4714004993,
0.6884366274,
0.3110753298,
-0.3238990307,
0.1882646829,
-0.8527577519,
0.6292711496,
-0.4140815437,
-0.5136108398,
-0.4228159785,
-0.0863901749,
0.674084425,
0.3173721731,
-0.1760574579,
0.6124917865,
0.1672951579,
1.0399528742,
-1.1428810358,
-0.2632963061,
-0.8221706748,
-0.0492511317,
-0.7212945223,
-0.3075303435,
-0.6772326231,
-0.4240492582,
-0.1878002435,
-0.1834900826,
0.4857847393,
0.2651982009,
0.7745742798,
0.2942394614,
-0.3275650144,
-0.0699129403,
-0.8553923368,
0.7855548859,
-0.3514059782,
0.3784840405,
0.7177909017,
0.5023444295,
-0.4418462813,
-0.5554205179,
-0.3599432111,
-0.2191122472,
-0.1515289098,
-0.1664893478,
0.0671377555,
-0.1462201774,
0.2956611216,
0.7622890472,
-0.5117166042,
0.0389141105,
-0.2935302556,
-0.1981102675,
0.8741492033,
0.0310888328,
0.0511085913,
-0.5105654001,
-0.6649625301,
-0.0568493307,
-0.9238619208,
-0.1068747267,
0.7956796288,
0.1484340876,
-0.1165545955,
0.6572108865,
0.1166573688,
0.5244067311,
-0.0451872982,
-0.1442165673,
0.2721139193,
-0.0947917253,
-0.1278276592,
-0.1351554394,
0.7324824929,
-0.0160749741,
0.08833009,
-0.4765990973,
-0.2596841156,
-0.3904772401,
0.3812602758,
-0.4935250878,
0.2628602087,
0.2323627323,
-0.4822454453,
-0.509018302,
0.1706388891,
-0.9550243616,
-0.9649327993,
0.0595006756,
0.4457841516,
-0.1261692792,
-0.4805908203,
0.0376143456,
-0.1009333283,
0.3053004146,
-0.1572173834,
-0.8179662228,
0.5492994785,
1.1388061047,
0.4381310046,
-0.2911766171,
-0.0498198755,
-0.7925571799,
0.4419037998,
-0.2401278168,
0.6159383655,
-0.2987453341,
-0.8115442991,
-0.0401936509,
0.0202017333,
0.1549210399,
-0.739433527,
0.3917998672,
-0.8937598467,
0.1496504098,
0.0353169143,
-0.4833010733,
0.2013294399,
0.2641772926,
-0.7191092968,
0.8269754052,
0.0234938059,
-1.0539420843,
-0.066634126,
-0.3747523129,
-0.2541517317,
0.0172063783,
-0.2342656851,
-0.655985117,
0.3584679961,
-0.1012529284,
0.3707428277,
-0.1115731522,
0.0300504584,
-0.2310596704,
-0.3877339363,
0.7594739199,
-0.2981354892,
0.9161746502,
0.5036487579,
-0.1935303658,
-0.4579621851,
-0.8178354502,
0.0790578574,
0.1948111802,
-0.2134186625,
-0.5851979852,
-0.1495454013,
-0.4617216885,
-0.2935125828,
0.5568801761,
-0.6190590858,
-0.0427791029,
-0.4769327939,
-0.276571095,
0.8183615208,
0.4032268822,
0.8152313828,
-0.3002668619,
0.7803424597,
-0.2972339094,
0.3771749437,
0.003238057,
-0.3296763301,
-0.2544527054,
-0.2514657974,
0.6322317719,
0.4740961194,
-0.4965258241,
-0.0780913532,
-0.0159220397,
-0.4061643481,
-0.4497091472,
0.0886797309,
0.7473201752,
0.3858718276,
-0.0019490246,
-0.2277827561,
-0.4525873065,
-0.8666601181,
-0.7004867792,
0.0774530098,
0.0480344072,
0.6677016616,
0.1649853289,
-0.2477598786,
0.7361391187,
-0.4338252842,
-0.2534582615,
0.1428193003,
-0.1202702001,
0.0933620334,
0.6639122963,
0.3588107824,
-0.9136353731,
-0.5056100488,
-0.1359843314,
-0.6023099422,
0.0316628814,
0.1980033368,
-0.4145593345,
0.384981364,
0.3855807781,
-0.5618175268,
0.6045410037,
0.8091387153,
-0.2345243543,
0.5661212206,
-0.2052722722,
-0.1106237546,
-1.1236194372,
0.0868083611,
-0.3925302625,
-0.3798980415,
-0.4949086308,
0.4269347787,
0.0972740948,
-0.3941741586,
-0.6231846213,
0.6146124601,
-0.6703457832,
-0.3315796256,
-0.3656896055,
-0.2246934623,
0.0355314128,
0.0652842149,
-0.4916185141,
0.9715970159,
0.5313752294,
-0.580223918,
-0.1128420234,
0.1931072026,
-0.0047969986,
0.194564417,
-0.1722960919,
0.6480953097,
-0.2014497519,
0.0914698318,
-0.6428607702,
-0.365878731,
0.3062940836,
-0.9067159295,
0.8991647363,
-0.2797986865,
-0.5342537761,
0.0738573447,
-0.6617914438,
0.3329541087,
0.5511706471,
-0.6422382593,
0.6168347001,
0.8493071795,
0.022527162,
-1.1708146334,
-0.7349941134,
0.2465688437,
-0.4331048727,
-0.4596247375,
0.4080860317,
0.064337492,
-0.4213726521,
0.0788106099,
-0.114856191,
-0.1294315159,
0.3662304878,
0.3377341032,
0.229846552,
0.1715617478,
-0.1705499738,
-0.1887917072,
-0.4366520941,
0.1783653945,
0.2355919778,
0.6087388992,
0.057666529,
-0.2859213352,
-0.1119746715,
0.5145815015,
0.129852891,
-0.5179811716,
0.9736483097,
0.4041517973,
-0.2333103269,
-0.4498867691,
-0.6704403758,
-0.1524701267,
-0.5781369209,
0.062922366,
-0.04711679,
-0.7912939191,
0.4001826644,
-0.1038825512,
-0.0485633835,
0.0271249451,
0.298067987,
-0.1819167137,
0.8530867696,
0.8671108484,
-0.0041453727,
0.4580441415,
-0.3149589896,
0.2319086641,
-1.1271506548,
-0.277780354,
-0.6091554761,
-0.2802709043,
-1.1326572895,
-0.3648793399,
0.3964423835,
0.0949712396,
-0.3205733001,
0.0646244287,
-0.6989127398,
0.8031753302,
0.4186137021,
0.1780927777,
0.4731557965,
0.1356842071,
0.2941319048,
-0.0651820451,
-0.1223612726,
-0.4573129714,
1.3122221231,
0.340444386,
1.1087683439,
0.4039380848,
1.453030467,
0.1026687622,
0.2352037579,
-0.3848048747,
0.7170763016,
-0.463436842,
-1.0493434668,
-0.1844416857,
-0.5880459547,
-1.2274906635,
0.0891008452,
-0.0736923069,
-0.9112219214,
0.5009176731,
0.0939828455,
-0.0991481319,
0.3028738201,
-0.7438658476,
0.3486090302,
-0.2101808041,
-0.7129729986,
0.0441536196,
-0.7158831954,
0.6096280217,
-0.3555291891,
0.3485802114,
0.140232712,
-0.1604706496,
0.7016485929,
-0.2698281705,
0.6953594685,
-0.3687033653,
-0.0504352599,
0.1213646308,
0.4228808284,
0.6789149046,
0.2368414551,
-0.1143501028,
0.0382713266,
-0.2243688405,
-0.2608808577,
-0.4930942953,
0.7857480645,
-0.4892995059,
-0.8746733665,
-0.6428027749,
-0.5450319648,
-0.4567148089,
0.1831244081,
0.1412303448,
0.1439340264,
0.1487813294,
0.3222866654,
1.0044282675,
-0.5797208548,
0.1660592854,
0.7678906322,
-0.5137127042,
-0.3060534894,
1.1908179522,
0.0579728,
0.3382694721,
0.1336825043,
0.3610982895,
-0.1136294603,
-0.7126293182,
-0.1102479249,
0.6188074946,
-0.4196417332,
-0.4444322288,
-0.4479766488,
-0.3617834747,
-0.3357860744,
0.2764448524,
-0.4737648964,
-0.5356352925,
-0.1365280896,
-0.143488735,
0.4588990211,
0.7202311158,
-0.3850130737,
0.0278599467,
-0.8820608258,
0.5324574709,
0.1087477505,
0.4667312503,
-0.0965775698,
-0.3997156918,
-0.202463612,
-0.2346008122,
-0.466165036,
-0.854812324,
0.3639630079,
-0.1199802384,
0.5257530808,
-0.0051749344,
0.1126845852,
0.339058876,
-0.7134543061,
0.762394011,
-0.2412653118,
-0.5235543251,
0.3937639892,
-0.4075847864,
-0.1753769219,
0.598634541,
0.2529311478,
-0.1241850182,
-0.5874271393,
-0.967671752,
-0.9251099825,
0.593793571,
0.0679321438,
0.364957124,
0.0981472507,
0.5185437799,
0.1689990312,
0.3718063831,
-0.6430564523,
-0.5851256251,
0.1238416433,
0.145028308,
0.1856636107,
-0.4723764062,
-0.1593440473,
0.1383949816,
0.57573241,
0.4825660884,
0.2732467055,
-0.0961511135,
0.13008295,
-0.0750794709,
0.2454502136,
0.2677862644,
0.379917711,
-0.1749522388,
0.1543660015,
0.0151203582,
-0.7821165919,
0.2711403966,
0.2836298645,
-0.2806628048,
0.0412965231,
-0.027654022,
0.3039624095,
0.0648722351,
-0.387599349,
0.5267502666,
-0.1249481812,
-0.0503939874,
-0.4969763756,
0.2038253993,
0.0677872971,
0.1938034743,
0.4436478615,
0.0086060921,
0.3534689546,
-0.3785605431,
0.1701990813,
0.5977575183,
0.1202188507,
-0.1068090796,
0.6097104549,
-0.1308527589,
-0.6046817303,
-0.0044331807,
-0.2686245441,
-0.3092848659,
0.3085273206,
0.5944091082,
0.8665972948,
-0.614313364,
0.2184950858,
0.0827398151,
0.1200060546,
0.031952858,
0.270399183,
-0.1148213595,
-0.4186732769,
-0.3821711242,
-0.594329536,
-0.6623354554,
0.1962886602,
-0.9604144096,
-0.0918988734,
-0.4234003723,
-0.2890186012,
-0.5376358628,
-0.0041998359,
-0.3809273243,
-0.1193044558,
0.2298756242,
0.5656628609,
-0.1346140355,
0.5962494612,
0.3415209651,
-0.1271555871,
-0.8496723175,
0.1018375158,
-0.0711162835,
-0.722725749,
0.7446373701,
-0.1186656058,
-0.2553834021,
-0.2394286096,
-0.5301879048,
-1.145824194,
0.8923837543,
0.6447832584,
-0.5611673594,
-0.0995368883,
0.4322972,
0.4596920907,
0.2388822883,
-0.4998525083,
0.505666852,
0.2318744063,
-0.2798069119,
-0.7603247166,
-0.1386678815,
0.0106410543,
0.0301542655,
0.4637487233,
-0.6289557219,
0.8693468571,
-0.0483607426,
-0.4379828274,
0.1353630275,
0.4402085841,
0.5929483771,
0.502804637,
0.332421124,
0.677496314,
0.8456066847,
0.2544642091,
1.4670408964,
-0.243691653,
0.3654336333,
1.2196985483,
-0.3186544776,
0.8815351129,
0.5523574948,
-0.0272604749,
0.306560427,
0.1294892579,
0.2574102581,
0.6684402823,
0.3824046552,
-0.5177744627,
0.3681254089,
0.0068196058,
-0.5821022391,
0.2120859474,
0.4156363904,
-0.4601278901,
-0.1711802781,
0.1506504565,
0.2746584713,
0.2974368334,
-0.2137505561,
0.9153246284,
0.3171836436,
-0.3341011107,
0.5994433165,
-0.2013975829,
0.6073023081,
-0.482771188,
0.051821366,
-0.2300068736,
0.2871799171,
-0.4540414512,
-0.6682885885,
0.4123884141,
0.3163447678,
0.0119832717,
-0.1356177479,
0.991199851,
-0.0398836695,
-0.1645161211,
0.3138175905,
0.5393263102,
0.1804654002,
0.1024918854,
-0.5913182497,
0.2749290168,
-0.0791762993,
-0.4499097168,
0.7902272344,
0.5798096657,
0.0450994074,
0.5428905487,
0.6337563396,
0.3637640476,
0.3060958982,
0.0761911049,
0.8115023971,
-0.6690081358,
-0.3299830854,
-0.7819763422,
0.3991096914,
-0.2251436561,
-0.0038511613,
1.1537038088,
0.6136164069,
0.7347345352,
0.1481805444,
0.5429538488,
0.1836800128,
1.325496912,
-0.5077923536,
1.0621210337,
-0.3258281946,
0.6402712464,
-0.1863012463,
-0.8947106004,
-0.3331128359,
0.221164003,
-0.3662115633,
-0.0227044169,
0.658362031,
1.0401582718,
0.087365903,
-0.1204170957,
0.1607884467,
0.3359069526,
0.5181546807,
0.0246761721,
0.9785947204,
-0.3682903647,
0.4836796224,
-0.4891990721,
-0.1376317441,
0.1283142865,
-0.810044229,
-0.6698703766,
-0.3656284511,
0.0356977321,
-0.5934337974,
0.2855080068,
0.2585286498,
0.3527372181,
-0.4451112747,
-0.2132849842,
0.0923116356,
0.0228156243,
0.2610947788,
-0.2613815367,
0.4574207067,
-0.314910084,
-0.5711289048,
0.4721376598,
-0.0532354154,
0.0383782722,
-0.5744403601,
0.0197618548,
-0.1184987947,
-0.1319581866,
0.2789238989,
0.4626319408,
-0.2602570057,
-0.1555280536,
-0.0624270588,
-0.1220840588,
-0.0517882779,
0.7451915741,
-0.8579096198,
0.4043491185,
0.398914665,
1.0030117035,
0.7273207903,
0.2577738762,
0.292026639,
-1.0573329926,
0.2508909702,
0.5168207884,
0.1828338355,
0.5175842643,
-0.8355365396,
0.5825203657,
-0.204132691,
-1.0188064575,
-1.480484128,
0.2833833098,
-0.7435400486,
-0.1462372243,
1.1989357471,
0.0708765835,
-0.7278829217,
-0.0845185593,
-0.2249319404,
0.0383433178,
-0.2958540618,
0.8746045828,
0.2874760926,
0.0364871249,
0.204366371,
-0.9039510489,
0.6393982172,
0.2278685123,
-0.6280505061,
0.1504551619,
0.2195384204,
0.2875654697,
0.3085368872,
0.6491602063,
-0.6910113096,
0.3156523407,
-0.3244127333,
-0.3444551528,
-0.1862877458,
-0.227748394,
-0.4576618373,
0.099142842,
0.1380693763,
-0.4635654092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15491v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15491v2
|
API-BLEND: A Comprehensive Corpora for Training and Benchmarking API LLMs
| 2024-02-23T18:30:49 | 2024-05-20T14:52:31 |
Kinjal Basu, Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Subhajit Chaudhury, Soham Dan, Maxwell Crouse, Asim Munawar, Sadhana Kumaravel, Vinod Muthusamy, Pavan Kapanipathi, Luis A. Lastras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There is a growing need for Large Language Models (LLMs) to effectively use
tools and external Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) to plan and
complete tasks. As such, there is tremendous interest in methods that can
acquire sufficient quantities of train and test data that involve calls to
tools / APIs. Two lines of research have emerged as the predominant strategies
for addressing this challenge. The first has focused on synthetic data
generation techniques, while the second has involved curating task-adjacent
datasets which can be transformed into API / Tool-based tasks. In this paper,
we focus on the task of identifying, curating, and transforming existing
datasets and, in turn, introduce API-BLEND, a large corpora for training and
systematic testing of tool-augmented LLMs. The datasets mimic real-world
scenarios involving API-tasks such as API / tool detection, slot filling, and
sequencing of the detected APIs. We demonstrate the utility of the API-BLEND
dataset for both training and benchmarking purposes.
|
[
-0.5642504692,
-0.749222815,
0.3952718973,
0.2473475039,
0.0028536101,
0.5935621858,
-0.3761601448,
-0.4504601359,
0.0613258854,
0.6353777051,
-0.6726196408,
-0.5978450179,
-0.2495200783,
0.3218656182,
-0.7383375764,
0.6197386384,
-0.4094747305,
0.27023229,
-0.3367061615,
-0.1799157262,
-0.8221482635,
-0.5042757392,
-0.5642632842,
-0.3228362501,
0.363252461,
0.2360039204,
0.3498110473,
0.6047308445,
0.2456992269,
0.2948718071,
0.2071779519,
0.3619624078,
-0.4320940673,
0.3168786168,
-0.0871523172,
-0.8578956127,
-0.157507509,
0.1858623028,
0.4217573106,
1.1481734514,
0.0913470536,
0.4086197913,
0.0750678629,
0.2383647561,
-0.5298529267,
0.1604858935,
-0.7748561502,
0.2044230103,
-0.2758789957,
-0.2925962806,
-0.1303265691,
-0.3505113721,
0.0448884331,
-0.7495698929,
0.2826665342,
0.4783444703,
0.4474738836,
0.2318257093,
-0.2610071003,
-0.3419553638,
-0.6060481668,
1.1272058487,
-0.4613173902,
0.5988239646,
0.2816878855,
0.2650505602,
-0.2860940099,
-0.5925414562,
-0.5049619079,
0.0140842805,
0.1305030286,
-0.0366150886,
0.1202360988,
-0.2132942975,
0.1800047904,
0.5760747194,
-0.6858952641,
0.1848856807,
-0.2944303751,
-0.3012174666,
0.3952678442,
0.1932918429,
0.3586871624,
0.476069659,
-0.2966729403,
-0.3779245615,
-0.8712541461,
-0.1903667152,
0.5823333859,
0.5500295758,
0.0140703162,
0.6975795627,
-0.1488053054,
0.7945843935,
-0.2946138978,
-0.2471442372,
0.6325367689,
-0.3433254659,
-0.319740355,
-0.0250303205,
0.5285203457,
0.1548772156,
0.1457493901,
-0.5281412601,
-0.3619968891,
0.4477377236,
0.3726136982,
-0.5198375583,
0.0344230644,
0.5396869779,
-0.2386417836,
-0.2876548171,
-0.3115558922,
-0.5941369534,
-0.2938342094,
-0.9531694651,
0.0402485505,
-0.4353642166,
-0.4527107477,
0.0459926575,
-0.2698039711,
0.3576008379,
0.1412684619,
-0.5932343602,
0.5001728535,
1.2373220921,
0.7487538457,
-0.7366549969,
-0.2918854356,
-0.6863716245,
-0.0953957587,
-0.5345262289,
0.9574804306,
-0.6854019165,
-0.4354873002,
0.5263715386,
0.122139819,
0.1256182343,
-1.1592437029,
0.5102235079,
-0.3497152925,
-0.0881377906,
-0.204574734,
-0.7673722506,
0.1715238541,
0.6093102098,
-0.524551034,
1.6432803869,
0.6079204679,
-0.3813204765,
0.4015140831,
-0.4132465422,
-0.4479136467,
0.0500166379,
-0.358179003,
-0.1153303683,
0.0323284157,
-0.1392572522,
0.0470236912,
-0.4604118764,
0.1420508921,
-0.6586113572,
-0.3870655894,
0.3993492126,
-0.131176576,
0.6545661688,
0.2603849173,
-0.1551588029,
0.2016388923,
-0.944270134,
0.0665365085,
-0.1657639593,
-0.331386745,
-0.4912465811,
-0.3097963929,
0.3688186109,
0.1055312902,
0.2526490092,
-0.7309322953,
0.1709238589,
-0.4268988371,
0.3514261544,
0.6619539261,
-0.4212374091,
0.511500299,
-0.2788707912,
0.5451302528,
-0.0162207335,
0.150384441,
-0.1122850254,
-0.21176745,
-0.8291656375,
-0.3329062164,
0.4610419273,
0.696646452,
-0.7284229994,
0.6765816808,
-0.098465912,
-0.5138799548,
-0.7651721835,
0.4636110663,
0.1495822817,
0.5822718143,
0.3019179404,
-0.4864287078,
-0.8230443597,
-0.7843965292,
-0.0924995765,
0.0949969068,
-0.400946945,
0.2770654559,
0.2165265679,
-0.3687670529,
1.1253112555,
-0.386366874,
0.0395337567,
-0.111211434,
0.2036521137,
0.137773782,
0.4475139678,
0.3754774034,
-0.6902305484,
-0.4015938342,
-0.1928807944,
-0.7167190909,
-0.4858233929,
-0.0173401013,
-0.5136763453,
-0.0485173278,
0.7456960678,
-0.3911103904,
0.0809155032,
0.6476332545,
0.1125580221,
0.7432680726,
0.2501514554,
-0.0862497538,
-0.8651950359,
0.1561412662,
-0.1723489314,
-0.3664472401,
-0.3096019924,
0.1187693775,
0.0946371406,
-0.2594895363,
-0.4854004085,
0.9045969248,
-0.4922492504,
-0.4444589317,
-0.4010545909,
-0.1325565279,
0.0237839855,
0.3566739857,
-0.0657876134,
1.0283322334,
0.8162372112,
-0.4915934801,
0.4446252882,
0.4397082031,
-0.2490224689,
0.8175132871,
-0.4713855684,
0.0790214315,
0.2176065594,
0.0773483217,
-1.084077239,
-0.036422845,
0.1355254501,
0.0984478816,
0.0567333251,
-0.3342238367,
-0.850376308,
-0.3247103691,
-0.4011676311,
0.415957123,
0.5050392151,
-0.6785945296,
0.8114672303,
0.4420661032,
-0.2619744539,
-0.4031194746,
-0.6653805375,
-0.0062534385,
-0.3536893129,
-0.4603356123,
0.3815130889,
-0.3761534393,
-0.2058505416,
-0.1280874759,
-0.2628957331,
-0.0674450547,
0.0327294767,
0.3535279334,
0.4815225005,
-0.1445070952,
-0.0881888494,
-0.1009558812,
0.1194943115,
0.106301859,
-0.2452290207,
0.8464813232,
0.1982321441,
-0.6299257278,
-0.0900961235,
0.4305301607,
0.3863221407,
-0.2279667705,
0.2883554995,
0.6256883144,
-0.0547702648,
-0.4258492589,
-0.779080987,
0.0201564729,
-0.4991304874,
0.05891601,
-0.2164211869,
-0.7123983502,
0.6563600302,
-0.7919054627,
0.3943435252,
-0.0551900193,
0.5385953784,
0.0962804109,
0.6917330027,
0.5220221877,
-0.2319005728,
0.5591268539,
-0.3098208308,
0.0953433812,
-0.9492881894,
0.05897424,
-0.5539233685,
-0.203228265,
-0.4607120752,
-0.4852851331,
0.2363904417,
-0.2704281211,
-0.2148676068,
0.3544877768,
-0.3397955596,
0.3568942547,
0.6985715032,
-0.0489749126,
0.1816368103,
0.1033149064,
-0.0738804191,
0.2270382345,
-0.373775363,
-0.4376733303,
1.6130069494,
0.1734861732,
0.801584661,
-0.283996582,
0.7188197374,
0.1624842733,
0.3943133652,
-0.8543488383,
0.6221879125,
0.0379429497,
-0.4165189564,
0.0348297209,
-0.3052633107,
-1.0087351799,
0.0985149518,
-0.158331722,
-0.2145127654,
0.1315843612,
0.0543432571,
-0.1475650668,
0.0397081524,
-0.8218848109,
0.8869429231,
-0.4514116943,
-0.3101401031,
0.1038521081,
-0.339430362,
0.1700131297,
-0.2232413888,
0.2675240934,
-0.3008297682,
-0.1594649851,
0.354369849,
-0.3741388023,
0.8716301918,
0.1010193899,
-0.1800861061,
0.1805006713,
0.0637160838,
0.3990319967,
-0.0973441452,
-0.1213482842,
0.2254809141,
-0.0099822097,
-0.3947709799,
-0.3183310032,
0.5820028782,
-0.6823478341,
-0.1756956726,
-0.3691695929,
-0.9046580791,
-0.6383600235,
0.1775078923,
-0.1785860956,
0.5843045712,
-0.2496071458,
-0.0561854467,
0.7952744365,
-0.3323362172,
0.0396745466,
0.4376297891,
-0.2597662508,
-0.1489437521,
0.7794593573,
-0.2878149748,
0.1873825788,
0.0081181405,
-0.1842989326,
-0.3700407147,
-0.5918449163,
-0.3370344639,
0.0013970743,
-0.5040659904,
-0.2596177161,
-0.3681243658,
-0.0492050312,
-0.362411201,
-0.1201088205,
-0.4961689711,
-0.0258796886,
-0.111175634,
0.1705057919,
0.2464988679,
0.3138647377,
0.1611794233,
0.110814698,
-0.5299124718,
0.2853117883,
0.0389483869,
0.5425848961,
-0.2107357532,
-0.1183525026,
-0.004232666,
-0.1024568453,
-0.1887558252,
-0.452958703,
0.4188165069,
0.0488782935,
0.6186833978,
0.022837406,
-0.1498815417,
0.7229946256,
-0.6957030892,
0.5555654764,
-0.082633175,
-0.4505994618,
0.2984724939,
-0.1930036247,
0.2367135137,
0.8612942696,
0.4063258469,
-0.4296694696,
-0.6377006769,
-0.4093083441,
-1.1511292458,
0.3783646226,
0.0844023526,
0.014999507,
0.0916146114,
0.1952995807,
0.5942675471,
0.5310867429,
-0.1608086824,
-0.1979391575,
0.0955727324,
-0.6001833081,
0.1833758056,
0.0898938626,
-0.6965633035,
-0.0320661105,
0.5460819006,
-0.2760302126,
0.0931588188,
-0.1901544929,
-0.208023876,
0.2405745685,
0.2208222747,
0.0587638244,
0.7742447257,
-0.2347347587,
0.130530864,
-0.0952457637,
-0.3939444423,
0.0021798958,
0.3735604286,
-0.1851719618,
0.0768193379,
0.1052802876,
0.6071661115,
0.324182868,
-1.4417747259,
0.1745873392,
-0.0856483504,
-0.0589796714,
-0.661957562,
0.1692783684,
0.0452342369,
0.2381402999,
0.3192829788,
-0.0663068593,
0.3896694779,
-0.8959857821,
0.1901889741,
0.3887297511,
0.1262870729,
-0.062895,
0.3001301289,
0.2600810826,
-0.1413286775,
0.5018081069,
-0.4026894271,
-0.2931331694,
0.4691599905,
0.5071092248,
0.6145852208,
0.1577430218,
-0.0626124069,
0.2419947237,
-0.0889910087,
-0.2631111443,
0.4187284112,
-0.0425289162,
-0.6138285995,
-0.484760344,
-0.8691276312,
-0.7250042558,
0.3092166781,
-0.6398770809,
0.319794029,
-0.1429315805,
-0.0021873326,
0.1011784524,
-0.1526838243,
-0.8935003281,
-0.0594725683,
0.2304503769,
1.1843471527,
-0.9960036874,
0.5948946476,
0.6551073194,
-0.1388022453,
-0.6226592064,
-0.2876940668,
0.1374072731,
-1.0192101002,
0.4879121482,
0.1534242779,
0.2649116516,
-0.3656989634,
-0.4679680467,
-0.774417758,
0.8386824727,
0.5330156088,
-0.5247898698,
0.134976387,
0.6918851733,
0.507335186,
-0.4325473607,
0.1873221099,
0.8834245801,
0.2902758121,
0.0917789415,
-1.0370932817,
-0.1617994159,
-0.2651497126,
0.2089730948,
0.1193974838,
-0.259698689,
0.7852313519,
0.7013621926,
0.1039288938,
0.0712762475,
0.4178315401,
0.6040187478,
0.1819370985,
0.7334260345,
0.6503378153,
0.7953947783,
-0.2572942078,
0.8985999227,
-0.4292927384,
-0.0280719306,
1.2701292038,
-0.8219184279,
0.8395761251,
0.6101850271,
-0.2726156116,
0.4130034447,
0.9757185578,
-0.2049122155,
0.4294936955,
0.3416988552,
-0.3459254503,
-0.1851950586,
-0.319401592,
-0.3070968091,
0.390928328,
0.2599597871,
-0.051905293,
-0.3022883236,
0.2108898461,
-0.0565695874,
-0.0058407527,
-0.2690703869,
0.6716449857,
-0.1261327863,
-0.8556243777,
0.444227159,
-0.2935622931,
0.9636197686,
-0.6913968325,
-0.0809232444,
-0.2376067191,
0.1556336135,
-0.0186898876,
-0.8624389172,
0.363455534,
0.0130996853,
0.0245211478,
-0.3104550838,
0.6406440735,
-0.7539625764,
-0.5784233212,
0.2851400673,
0.5299572349,
0.2607992589,
-0.0821918696,
-0.7631585002,
0.5417406559,
-0.3371883333,
0.0086852666,
0.6387693882,
0.4757694304,
0.1024368256,
0.6572550535,
0.7816154361,
0.2776145339,
0.3078146875,
0.2258082926,
0.9970200658,
-0.2586266398,
-0.5252506733,
-0.4659738243,
0.1873968095,
-0.2789896131,
-0.2339306474,
0.5548818707,
1.1835565567,
1.0558713675,
-0.112308301,
1.1048029661,
-0.0823846459,
0.7997867465,
-0.415932864,
0.1237488613,
-0.4284074306,
0.140168786,
0.1937825382,
-0.9090944529,
0.0630998909,
0.2074981481,
-0.0423659272,
-0.1802074462,
0.4248497188,
0.862003684,
-0.4918504655,
-0.0652928576,
-0.1144847572,
-0.0487732477,
0.2685785592,
0.2660216689,
0.6357477903,
-0.3237245679,
0.6553949714,
-0.1681329608,
-0.2865908444,
-0.1045598835,
-0.7362040281,
-0.9265816212,
-0.5211126804,
-0.3661283255,
-0.2360492796,
-0.1449029893,
0.9887706041,
0.8662920594,
-0.8713547587,
-0.5262005329,
-0.159375906,
-0.2107595801,
-0.3795713484,
-0.1819396317,
0.1244406626,
-0.71356529,
-0.9031934142,
0.6110883951,
0.0871515945,
-0.0158787668,
-0.4995869398,
0.1701990217,
0.0685552359,
-0.0625932366,
0.6806691289,
0.5061194301,
-0.4130889177,
0.0559123009,
0.1498898268,
0.0938874707,
0.1118533984,
0.9717776775,
-0.8894445896,
0.4545585215,
0.253639847,
1.0986250639,
0.3781327903,
-0.1677370369,
0.7617427111,
-1.1126503944,
0.4266635478,
0.0985756069,
0.4579254389,
0.5453270078,
-0.0350168869,
0.9608927965,
0.0854414254,
-0.3592448235,
-1.2574186325,
0.0697689131,
-1.2857425213,
-0.2185012698,
1.148244381,
0.0540831201,
-0.3455292583,
-0.4244349301,
-0.3605147898,
0.2135758996,
-0.1927568465,
0.6744765639,
0.7359045148,
-0.238754943,
0.3036779165,
-0.8672180176,
0.3789746761,
0.2068561018,
-1.1591582298,
0.264036417,
0.3724555969,
0.5669685602,
0.2219103724,
0.4374226928,
-0.0218525156,
-0.0311525073,
-0.0070718108,
0.1811217964,
0.0114375688,
0.0057719364,
0.1642210037,
0.0347895101,
0.0401219837,
-0.1851663738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15481v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15481v4
|
Prejudice and Volatility: A Statistical Framework for Measuring Social Discrimination in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T18:15:56 | 2024-05-24T20:02:10 |
Y Liu, K Yang, Z Qi, X Liu, Y Yu, C Zhai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This study investigates why and how inconsistency in the generation of Large
Language Models (LLMs) might induce or exacerbate societal injustice. For
instance, LLMs frequently exhibit contrasting gender stereotypes regarding the
same career depending on varied contexts, highlighting the arguably harmful
unpredictability of LLMs' behavioral patterns. To augment the existing
discrimination assessment with the capability to account for variation in LLM
generation, we formulate the Prejudice-Volatility Framework (PVF) that
precisely defines behavioral metrics for assessing LLMs, which delineate the
probability distribution of LLMs' stereotypes from the perspective of token
prediction probability. Specifically, we employ a data-mining approach to
approximate the possible applied contexts of LLMs and devise statistical
metrics to evaluate the corresponding contextualized societal discrimination
risk. Further, we mathematically dissect the aggregated discrimination risk of
LLMs into prejudice risk, originating from their system bias, and volatility
risk, stemming from their generation inconsistency. While initially intended
for assessing discrimination in LLMs, our proposed PVF facilitates the
comprehensive and flexible measurement of any inductive biases, including
knowledge alongside prejudice, across various modality models.
We apply PVF to 12 most commonly adopted LLMs and compare their risk levels.
Our findings reveal that: i) prejudice risk is the primary cause of
discrimination risk in LLMs, indicating that inherent biases in these models
lead to stereotypical outputs; ii) most LLMs exhibit significant pro-male
stereotypes across nearly all careers; iii) alignment with Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback lowers discrimination by reducing prejudice, but
increases volatility; iv) discrimination risk in LLMs correlates with
socio-economic factors like profession salaries.
|
[
-0.1130916178,
-0.7381275892,
0.3447296321,
0.184656933,
0.2004741728,
0.0393749848,
0.001252488,
-0.3724267483,
0.0258766618,
0.4781983495,
-0.2939443588,
-0.3904242218,
-0.7847173214,
-0.1253978461,
-0.4153411984,
0.7288863659,
0.2804622054,
0.2937214077,
-0.4225129783,
-0.1601239443,
-0.5713405013,
-0.9097425938,
-0.2257809341,
-0.1710323095,
0.3809466362,
0.1402598172,
0.4350637496,
0.4583940208,
0.3914531171,
0.25450176,
-0.2389461398,
-0.3499226868,
-0.5172150135,
0.593455255,
-0.1690291762,
-0.7179799676,
-0.0754688829,
0.0007409015,
0.4079323709,
0.7522344589,
-0.2616524398,
0.2856131792,
0.0477988645,
0.642585218,
-0.7938819528,
0.1257760227,
-0.7500029802,
0.1822904944,
-0.6215055585,
-0.1157369316,
-0.2854796052,
-0.5044546723,
0.1240758449,
-0.1561395228,
0.3514275849,
0.1286770552,
0.4493008554,
0.2057407945,
-0.7547059059,
-0.4232698083,
-0.8025458455,
0.9081712365,
-0.3028655648,
0.4172842503,
0.2732306719,
0.2585220039,
-0.2924765348,
-0.2515809536,
-0.4354170263,
-0.2514070868,
0.2244902402,
0.0405572951,
0.2267102003,
-0.2354109287,
0.3580373824,
0.503416419,
-0.4519661665,
0.1387264132,
-0.2373421788,
-0.2375214547,
0.4985217154,
0.4601740539,
0.1458588839,
-0.2794540823,
-0.1293936074,
-0.046072457,
-0.8002812862,
0.2334251255,
0.7830776572,
0.3631081879,
-0.0481571034,
0.6580062509,
0.1830097586,
0.3752147853,
-0.140944168,
-0.1880991012,
0.4732823074,
-0.0156983994,
-0.074572511,
0.1325035244,
0.6195709109,
0.4050361216,
0.2463605553,
0.199530378,
-0.1265868545,
0.1782547235,
0.1056329533,
-0.5194531679,
0.2148379683,
-0.0452889279,
-0.2662783861,
-0.626891911,
0.0439926311,
-1.1760302782,
-0.9158989787,
0.0255565643,
0.0548411384,
-0.1527357996,
-0.4451128542,
0.0905050114,
-0.1418225467,
0.4443021417,
0.2874548137,
-0.8286603093,
-0.0635941997,
0.6907843947,
0.7005283833,
-0.1965540946,
0.0461977981,
-0.468703717,
0.0670052692,
-0.438524425,
0.3446455598,
-0.6163707376,
-0.5706521273,
0.4785120189,
-0.1196479052,
0.2459904701,
-0.5389350057,
0.5816961527,
-0.3322081268,
0.1995600611,
-0.4557243288,
-0.4837776423,
-0.005137031,
0.1344092786,
-0.4422772229,
0.9950457811,
0.1427604109,
-1.013664484,
0.9519269466,
-0.5557844043,
-0.1725292206,
0.0900440067,
-0.480115205,
-0.4842908978,
0.2287546694,
-0.2812229097,
0.229451552,
-0.4915745556,
0.4317720234,
-0.6878382564,
-0.2526049912,
0.4401510954,
-0.6132177711,
0.9214993119,
0.0292943977,
-0.3166053891,
-0.0620323755,
-0.6668708324,
-0.6015831232,
0.2002350986,
-0.3281584084,
-0.6347190738,
0.3475294411,
-0.1161272377,
0.2122044563,
0.0566826425,
-0.405667454,
-0.0276997667,
-0.4159791768,
0.1293109506,
1.2147166729,
-0.0171217602,
0.4621613026,
-0.2465241402,
0.5011718273,
0.1250434369,
0.356598407,
0.4883647561,
-0.3206758201,
-0.6832164526,
-0.2685459256,
0.0038888538,
0.5365147591,
-0.6897835135,
0.2204220891,
-0.1634896547,
-0.3107714653,
-0.113427259,
0.042734094,
0.1433189213,
0.3970576227,
-0.1533392966,
-0.3265135288,
-0.6041724086,
-0.7484130263,
-0.5832890272,
-0.5974889398,
0.0756295472,
0.2535112798,
0.4248792827,
-0.1367134303,
0.9279311299,
-0.2808745801,
-0.1728360206,
0.1416723877,
0.1623645425,
0.2499393374,
0.2222119421,
0.7830275297,
-0.7641506195,
-0.3090703785,
-0.1256010085,
-0.6203612685,
-0.2239676267,
0.3794682026,
-0.0392927974,
0.2813946605,
0.3842177093,
-0.353208214,
0.4586363137,
0.3765414953,
-0.528259635,
0.7671675086,
0.2690149248,
0.1235868931,
-0.9367879629,
-0.4202638566,
0.4774286449,
-0.0006515247,
-0.3813386858,
-0.2956064939,
-0.2617195249,
0.3576940596,
-0.450302422,
0.4096675515,
-0.0207687952,
-0.0778080374,
0.0490785874,
-0.1535813361,
-0.3526002169,
-0.0417713709,
-0.417571038,
0.8220463395,
0.6161756516,
-0.72153157,
0.2842675745,
0.0072882478,
-0.4049207866,
0.7272782326,
-0.3655870259,
-0.2917684019,
-0.4520525634,
-0.2153625041,
-0.9750905037,
-0.2916368842,
0.195082739,
-0.4560715556,
-0.0555295497,
-0.1098833755,
-0.4101906419,
-0.3477780819,
-0.247962743,
0.3616423011,
0.6392293572,
-0.3930298388,
0.5636773705,
0.6583080292,
-0.2557690442,
-0.8530002236,
-0.7324023843,
-0.2592734694,
-0.6788028479,
-0.414432168,
-0.143509984,
-0.0124503998,
-0.8125867248,
-0.3319384456,
-0.1934332848,
0.1209915727,
0.237278372,
0.4485787153,
0.18669568,
0.1479137391,
0.4214635789,
-0.0623891167,
0.1529333591,
0.3214021623,
-0.1962905377,
0.5404169559,
-0.0511400066,
-0.4969119728,
0.3438491523,
0.1841301471,
0.7337270379,
0.0870221481,
0.7364454269,
0.5301047564,
-0.2085594386,
-0.0315719545,
-0.5521976352,
0.0572282933,
-0.4589061439,
0.5746232867,
-0.1806126535,
-1.187902689,
0.6106157303,
0.1103435606,
0.0985828191,
0.4617281556,
0.9483035803,
0.0752461031,
0.9806499481,
0.8943763375,
0.0475018322,
0.6598706245,
0.3004089594,
0.1166139916,
-0.4435497522,
-0.305396229,
-0.7516080737,
0.1734463423,
-0.9149857759,
-0.2892428041,
0.4011203051,
-0.0214007311,
-0.6294715405,
-0.2359097153,
-0.3967422247,
0.2596768141,
0.4355994463,
-0.4363311231,
0.2859068215,
0.2495714724,
-0.1891489774,
-0.4476954937,
-0.4366419017,
-0.500567317,
1.375495553,
0.40581429,
0.8427534699,
0.4854230881,
0.3891989887,
0.6212822199,
0.7057293057,
-0.5259912014,
0.2526821792,
-0.0410274975,
-0.8753035069,
-0.3879085779,
-0.5793680549,
-0.6780593991,
0.2963908017,
-0.335742414,
-0.8314328194,
0.7894615531,
0.1958693415,
0.0940195769,
0.2431179136,
-0.338029027,
0.5593091249,
-0.0046505877,
-0.5455918312,
0.161627084,
-0.2763532102,
0.7661743164,
-0.4192414284,
0.5290948153,
-0.3755660951,
0.2256394923,
0.5427744985,
-0.3928355873,
0.9071535468,
-0.2364745289,
-0.3089850545,
0.0259909797,
0.2148737311,
0.5228773355,
0.2606626749,
-0.6023868918,
0.2522179484,
-0.1658090353,
-0.3511272371,
-0.1794042438,
0.5372561216,
-1.0102250576,
-0.6583782434,
-0.7824963927,
-0.5173193216,
-0.1425856203,
-0.2124938518,
0.4121264815,
-0.0286448933,
-0.3952231705,
0.328338325,
0.6092348099,
-0.5619974732,
0.099820964,
0.6311493516,
-0.4781706333,
-0.3000773191,
0.656408906,
0.2407868803,
0.3361383677,
0.0835856348,
0.1316922605,
-0.324522227,
-0.1989270449,
0.1124438047,
-0.0256461296,
-0.7321341634,
-0.0042961035,
-0.5622680187,
-0.0007815946,
-0.7230591774,
-0.0853061527,
-0.3240306973,
0.1092335805,
-0.1840038896,
-0.1215269193,
0.5563499928,
0.6597355604,
-0.2304846048,
0.2710829973,
-0.1255575269,
-0.0331431329,
0.5204094648,
0.1974057555,
-0.2685576975,
-0.7640625238,
-0.0648061633,
-0.1430300921,
-0.263433516,
-0.8581169248,
0.4204982519,
-0.1083315611,
0.5708019137,
0.2829507887,
0.1597009003,
0.2650254667,
-0.2994161546,
0.9696028233,
0.4695157409,
-1.0243916512,
0.3172997832,
-0.3601258397,
-0.3506528139,
0.3619701862,
0.2376904339,
-0.7148777843,
-0.5827407241,
-0.3537272215,
-1.0069500208,
0.6317121983,
0.0394165739,
0.2651520669,
-0.2937447131,
0.424406141,
0.1674914956,
0.3558213413,
-1.0666911602,
-0.4519229829,
-0.376916796,
-0.1754226685,
-0.0984741151,
-0.5881214142,
-0.2754468024,
-0.2231105417,
0.5730614066,
0.0704349279,
-0.0034416281,
0.0258446261,
-0.1168371141,
-0.2100675851,
0.3761802316,
0.4360840917,
0.5513353944,
-0.1539297104,
0.0576455519,
0.3076122105,
-0.4646146595,
0.5765846372,
-0.1673869193,
-0.23087883,
0.0068317628,
0.0998453125,
0.8219240904,
-0.3549727798,
-0.5211510062,
0.7577265501,
-0.1481163055,
-0.3653252721,
-0.7089766264,
0.155690819,
-0.0784886777,
0.3848593235,
0.3643334508,
-0.0763418525,
0.0465547293,
-0.5451865792,
0.00009553,
0.4777142406,
-0.6414227486,
0.0157538801,
0.73634094,
0.1778405309,
-0.384403944,
0.1642749012,
-0.2845745981,
-0.197926119,
0.5952349901,
0.2448732257,
0.7377858758,
-0.3899109364,
0.3046972752,
0.1587891579,
0.4814476073,
-0.2137874365,
0.033765357,
0.4590547383,
-0.8704143763,
-0.4510210156,
-0.8670092225,
-0.3170443475,
0.0341318846,
-0.6144176126,
0.2704225183,
-0.3946050406,
-0.3590697348,
-0.2507118881,
-0.3251698613,
-0.6278461814,
-0.0679936558,
0.0667068213,
0.4191952944,
-1.1216537952,
0.3841238916,
0.5335271955,
-0.4190781116,
-0.4056898654,
0.2974773049,
0.2835476696,
-0.6774666905,
0.9776107073,
0.0000207463,
0.130354926,
-0.466884315,
-0.6168728471,
-0.8082305789,
0.8806323409,
0.6766129732,
-0.6726958156,
0.2392158955,
0.4400101006,
0.3997248411,
-0.2983563244,
0.1736626625,
0.6223374605,
0.4192476869,
-0.0324169993,
-0.5275112987,
-0.130635336,
-0.0767112896,
0.4734413028,
0.0874443799,
-0.6121122837,
1.1623191833,
0.1572555155,
-0.0895320773,
-0.3064410686,
0.445415318,
0.5251099467,
0.1437011659,
0.5443118811,
0.2250624746,
0.7378541827,
-0.4361351132,
0.9151343107,
-0.2148710638,
0.5658236742,
0.7311600447,
-0.6106546521,
0.2965168357,
0.5523976088,
-0.421051681,
0.4392891824,
0.5209425092,
0.1143506393,
0.2846230865,
0.6494791508,
-0.4583061635,
-0.3318091929,
-0.2737146318,
-0.4736775458,
0.3874922991,
0.5204482675,
-0.4212787449,
-0.1370235831,
0.1450116187,
-0.2131957561,
0.2253096998,
-0.2583808303,
0.5258108377,
0.1583704948,
-0.1462152749,
0.0879141912,
-0.069535926,
0.8875875473,
-0.4464065135,
0.1607703716,
-0.3535676003,
0.0730173886,
-0.0859429836,
-0.6758921146,
0.3034166992,
0.0799585208,
-0.5186460614,
0.0982496291,
0.54100281,
-0.2020762563,
-0.5927105546,
0.4494322538,
0.4989203811,
0.0309907701,
0.0757011473,
-0.5763243437,
0.2283468693,
0.0743361339,
-0.357884258,
0.4072085023,
0.7779718041,
-0.0525347479,
0.7024642229,
0.4947735667,
0.2030073553,
0.2182520926,
0.2945259213,
0.4339737892,
-0.6447403431,
-0.4382938743,
-1.0212090015,
0.414087534,
-0.1352202892,
-0.2563611567,
0.7652284503,
0.2703245878,
0.6452026367,
0.102277495,
1.0219732523,
0.0008058063,
0.5269629955,
-0.3447773159,
0.5423125625,
-0.7495024204,
0.5244458318,
-0.4957854748,
-0.913359344,
-0.2171460241,
0.5006312728,
-0.6910232306,
0.1941852421,
0.2969560325,
0.8161486387,
0.4535770118,
-0.1823223382,
0.4855712652,
0.4158808589,
0.6137425303,
0.3307574391,
0.9678866267,
-0.2204440385,
0.6616443992,
0.2494152784,
-0.0648721159,
-0.5001632571,
-0.7728065848,
-0.6504541039,
-0.3661161661,
-0.3381345272,
-0.8091718554,
0.1189368442,
0.7681411505,
0.4280935228,
-0.6403024197,
-0.3744202852,
-0.272860378,
0.4444862604,
0.0679498538,
-0.3837720454,
-0.0310700778,
-0.2417829633,
-0.7489256859,
-0.3147604465,
0.4383387268,
0.0809597299,
-0.5134081841,
-0.1247525588,
0.1561840028,
0.1753404588,
0.6978666186,
0.1816790402,
-0.6976882815,
-0.4733786285,
-0.2817596197,
-0.2525517941,
-0.0145772155,
0.5731812119,
-0.3075044155,
0.3529255986,
0.4650585651,
0.3922926486,
0.2055054307,
-0.4047885239,
0.683655858,
-0.8361464143,
0.2921605408,
0.1176522151,
0.491402626,
0.295674175,
-0.456579566,
0.3696010113,
0.5857463479,
-0.5611044168,
-1.1124626398,
0.611387074,
-0.4248564243,
-0.1430350691,
1.2236590385,
0.2685174346,
-0.1717027277,
-0.3301174641,
0.1219230518,
0.2157591581,
-0.4131895006,
1.0106140375,
0.991684258,
0.1472236514,
-0.0854199901,
-0.760699749,
0.5984963179,
0.3901643157,
-0.5448231101,
0.2112159431,
0.6092629433,
0.5366863012,
0.0757849142,
0.567928195,
-0.3638865948,
0.133696571,
0.0508155823,
0.4885714054,
0.2811426818,
0.0854569077,
-0.3193024099,
0.3900683522,
0.1987162977,
0.2281996757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15473v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15473v2
|
Leveraging Domain Knowledge for Efficient Reward Modelling in RLHF: A Case-Study in E-Commerce Opinion Summarization
| 2024-02-23T18:05:06 | 2024-04-18T06:38:22 |
Swaroop Nath, Tejpalsingh Siledar, Sankara Sri Raghava Ravindra Muddu, Rupasai Rangaraju, Harshad Khadilkar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Suman Banerjee, Amey Patil, Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh, Muthusamy Chelliah, Nikesh Garera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has become a dominating
strategy in aligning Language Models (LMs) with human values/goals. The key to
the strategy is learning a reward model ($\varphi$), which can reflect the
latent reward model of humans. While this strategy has proven effective, the
training methodology requires a lot of human preference annotation (usually in
the order of tens of thousands) to train $\varphi$. Such a large-scale
annotation is justifiable when it's a one-time effort, and the reward model is
universally applicable. However, human goals are subjective and depend on the
task, requiring task-specific preference annotations, which can be impractical
to fulfill. To address this challenge, we propose a novel approach to infuse
domain knowledge into $\varphi$, which reduces the amount of preference
annotation required ($21\times$), omits Alignment Tax, and provides some
interpretability. We validate our approach in E-Commerce Opinion Summarization,
with a significant reduction in dataset size (to just $940$ samples) while
advancing the SOTA ($\sim4$ point ROUGE-L improvement, $68\%$ of times
preferred by humans over SOTA). Our contributions include a novel Reward
Modeling technique and two new datasets: PromptOpinSumm (supervised data for
Opinion Summarization) and OpinPref (a gold-standard human preference dataset).
The proposed methodology opens up avenues for efficient RLHF, making it more
adaptable to applications with varying human values. We release the artifacts
(Code: github.com/efficient-rlhf. PromptOpinSumm: hf.co/prompt-opin-summ.
OpinPref: hf.co/opin-pref) for usage under MIT License.
|
[
-0.3892046511,
-0.5985817909,
0.2717077136,
-0.0121835396,
-0.2386031002,
-0.0302557219,
-0.3460339308,
-0.4630170763,
0.3466760516,
0.6913493276,
-0.8714359403,
-0.4221482873,
-0.3466358185,
-0.1066926867,
0.1406756639,
1.4416182041,
-0.0023400651,
-0.1544279456,
-0.5367598534,
-0.3651311696,
-0.0875779688,
-0.9809048176,
-0.4389432371,
-0.6130855083,
0.6983058453,
0.6195536852,
0.3269084692,
0.4294360876,
0.4608528018,
0.1140709892,
0.1837402433,
0.4129030704,
-0.7124416232,
0.1705493182,
-0.1155339554,
-0.3226093054,
-0.6685810685,
0.0349012576,
0.0204180814,
0.5998771787,
-0.3971065879,
0.2847186327,
0.1153029576,
1.0429582596,
-0.793921411,
0.362454772,
-0.1527881473,
0.1640755683,
0.0386895798,
-0.4949091673,
-0.4880673885,
-0.4306632578,
0.5149865746,
-1.0016764402,
-0.1183558032,
0.2723213732,
0.9596968889,
0.238778308,
-0.2247940004,
-0.1687039435,
-0.5670733452,
0.9791413546,
-0.6466349959,
0.1618175209,
0.4664361477,
0.1938957572,
0.1565005332,
-0.5628654957,
-0.3136231899,
-0.1195507199,
-0.2357758433,
0.3568538427,
0.1038689241,
-0.0283310991,
0.18006365,
0.2091944367,
-0.5206481218,
-0.1086325496,
-0.0432927348,
0.0076401043,
0.8548843861,
0.227459535,
0.0054317806,
-0.0912524983,
-0.5408543348,
-0.3465010822,
-0.7933526039,
0.4125130475,
0.3748966455,
0.4280457795,
-0.0627937987,
0.3971325159,
-0.3875431418,
0.7842200398,
0.2112720758,
-0.3474506438,
0.3264948428,
-0.0446364656,
-0.074352406,
-0.0330054909,
0.5793771148,
0.6364983916,
0.3693262339,
0.079404898,
-0.3748547733,
-0.1870179921,
0.4519448578,
-0.9342257977,
-0.2949473858,
0.3166142106,
-0.6245670915,
-0.3521758318,
0.199117586,
-0.5685972571,
-0.4741358161,
-0.3922004104,
0.425490737,
-0.1806888878,
-0.2845870554,
0.1698846072,
-0.0822472498,
0.0185441021,
0.4064561725,
-1.1189935207,
0.3172620833,
0.924369812,
0.5582945943,
-0.4491083324,
-0.3348610401,
-0.5781683922,
-0.0237535704,
-0.1284375191,
0.9403350949,
-0.3810552657,
-0.4732381999,
0.1666684151,
-0.1624407917,
0.0519841686,
-0.6992654204,
0.5712540746,
-0.7870774269,
0.2745658159,
-0.349607408,
-0.8119091392,
-0.2645676434,
0.4322330952,
-0.6203945279,
0.747913003,
0.1494706869,
-0.7455566525,
0.5211262703,
-0.756151557,
-0.5328841209,
0.0452468321,
-0.005474282,
-0.6613304615,
-0.1290899962,
0.3092075288,
0.535276413,
-0.0477990694,
0.339715749,
-0.2454797029,
-0.1898889393,
0.3795686066,
0.0916722268,
0.4607301056,
0.2103390843,
-0.347186327,
0.3831794262,
-0.5079233646,
-0.1747752279,
0.1549784541,
-0.3545173407,
-0.5354346037,
-0.0926165953,
0.2391732186,
0.0477428995,
0.2191586643,
-0.2773648798,
0.3931553662,
-0.5316755772,
0.1620745063,
0.8458293676,
0.3303091824,
0.5674339533,
-0.4596512318,
0.6827406883,
-0.123067528,
0.261431694,
-0.1395234168,
-0.3482735157,
-0.5988348722,
-0.2195907831,
0.3909490407,
0.4093697965,
-0.6501930952,
0.4218194783,
-0.2912449241,
-0.268743664,
-0.364730984,
-0.0918088257,
0.2621519566,
0.5948668718,
0.3388822973,
-0.3404984176,
-0.3798334897,
-1.0011734962,
-0.3732384443,
-0.2922720611,
0.0308559742,
0.5995366573,
0.3814955354,
0.0930329859,
1.2256675959,
-0.7516724467,
-0.4399240017,
-0.5621564388,
0.355262965,
0.3221560121,
0.3484617174,
0.2459742278,
-0.8985836506,
-0.3470422029,
-0.1711928546,
-0.7609351277,
-0.0833116844,
-0.228334114,
-0.0737412497,
0.2233152539,
0.1063188016,
-0.3512594402,
0.2751214504,
0.2131783217,
-0.3315106034,
0.4478258193,
-0.1764651388,
0.4747389257,
-0.7579889894,
0.1377968639,
0.2374191135,
-0.5259234309,
-0.5698615909,
-0.0646382198,
0.1539830863,
0.1097225621,
-0.5307346582,
0.6213869452,
-0.1243157759,
0.0506689213,
-0.4400876462,
0.1556010842,
0.0137818381,
1.0182722807,
0.5418123007,
0.5589414835,
0.0395739712,
-0.8499929905,
0.1981072724,
0.3053945005,
-0.3221544027,
0.7022459507,
-0.6156110168,
-0.1368770301,
-0.0704636872,
0.2534568012,
-0.5358836651,
-0.291308254,
0.4882390201,
-0.4724038541,
0.1503148377,
-0.1134983152,
-0.2147367597,
0.0122624496,
-0.5295628309,
0.4451135397,
0.5418928862,
-0.7338454127,
0.6268919706,
0.7549877763,
-0.3296949565,
-0.7423859835,
-0.5114089251,
-0.1488131732,
-0.3489934206,
-0.3640203476,
0.5050449967,
-0.0813254341,
-0.218382895,
0.0602557845,
0.0906832814,
0.2359872758,
0.1178015396,
0.1960224211,
0.471729666,
0.219106704,
0.33833009,
-0.1453066766,
-0.4331390858,
0.0883455724,
-0.537127614,
0.23451446,
-0.111460954,
-0.379254669,
-0.3222132027,
0.2934601307,
0.142313689,
-0.2778640687,
0.5648821592,
0.2991674244,
-0.2768626809,
-0.563175559,
-0.3294843137,
-0.5831429362,
-0.3708716929,
0.3279921114,
-0.1279833764,
-1.0001797676,
0.1713019758,
-0.1601672322,
0.3575843275,
0.3708799779,
0.640199244,
0.0973247662,
0.9416985512,
0.666959703,
-0.1451439857,
0.5185946822,
-0.2261501253,
0.3283912241,
-0.5530951619,
-0.3106665909,
-0.239839375,
-0.2920112014,
-0.2040179521,
-0.0864856392,
0.5380365252,
-0.073275879,
-0.1298218966,
-0.0310670752,
-0.4493956268,
0.3302727044,
0.5994514227,
0.2974535525,
0.4220686257,
-0.002121486,
0.1815003604,
-0.0761448517,
-0.7494478822,
-0.4122079611,
1.2009316683,
0.254270345,
0.8750106692,
0.0996575728,
0.7184953094,
0.6745470762,
0.3832032681,
-1.03832829,
0.3919219375,
0.1024916619,
-0.2094570845,
-0.3998439312,
-0.432561934,
-0.7541649342,
0.1625400633,
-0.3122355938,
-0.4932106137,
0.2203837633,
0.5551339388,
-0.7006804943,
0.1710457951,
-0.5361885428,
0.9999967217,
-0.2753940821,
-0.5964171886,
-0.2893882394,
-0.7211854458,
0.355404526,
0.3051721752,
0.2738521397,
0.0306118112,
0.1162437797,
1.0227808952,
-0.6665968895,
0.8813250661,
-0.3223424852,
-0.0633166432,
0.1360187829,
-0.1055273935,
0.6654479504,
0.0525062568,
0.1564702094,
-0.2013863176,
-0.2767420113,
-0.3910655677,
-0.7184547186,
0.4288565218,
-0.7221699357,
-0.4886942208,
-0.6099928617,
-0.3639791906,
-0.5116557479,
-0.110929437,
0.1713915765,
0.4496337175,
-0.198197633,
-0.0323543698,
0.9543202519,
-0.0561517961,
0.2923488915,
0.3566145003,
-0.4165922105,
-0.4331386685,
1.0468236208,
-0.1725841165,
0.1886038929,
0.67928195,
0.294380337,
-0.4397055209,
-0.1403755546,
-0.6087709069,
0.1810698658,
-0.7716799378,
-0.1874516457,
-0.7681956887,
0.1278972626,
-0.2686758637,
-0.1299436241,
-0.334718436,
-0.6897116899,
-0.2687403262,
-0.2655543983,
0.5807304978,
0.8424143195,
0.0283784829,
0.0436416008,
-0.8166127205,
0.1570839882,
0.5871730447,
0.2038076222,
0.3381898105,
-0.5350788832,
-0.6454563737,
-0.1024309173,
-0.0240421668,
-0.5945423841,
0.5380214453,
-0.0065454817,
0.5833022594,
0.3496991694,
0.4144465029,
0.4799707532,
-0.1007122323,
0.9355492592,
0.163863197,
-0.8734749556,
0.3932721913,
-0.2317586243,
0.1139045805,
0.6936552525,
0.4758834839,
-0.7042292356,
0.0064892536,
-0.6672967076,
-1.0744773149,
0.9021213651,
-0.1875699759,
-0.2404479682,
0.2442861497,
0.2962946296,
0.376921773,
0.4771921337,
-0.6163903475,
-0.4333754778,
-0.2904809713,
-0.3119918704,
-0.0185962114,
-0.3147218525,
-0.2756025493,
-0.0310413316,
1.071428895,
-0.1989409477,
-0.0142642073,
0.2642541826,
-0.3856560886,
-0.0350577459,
0.3100126684,
0.5673714876,
0.7463524342,
-0.2700992823,
0.1669335067,
-0.1137851551,
-0.2336691171,
0.0588096678,
-0.1309265047,
-0.2307868153,
-0.37057814,
0.2989865541,
0.7547838688,
0.1464324892,
-0.9355591536,
0.7241820097,
-0.1542517841,
-0.3247278035,
-0.1698336005,
-0.1474416554,
0.0774012953,
0.0722589195,
0.327021271,
0.0043439455,
0.3098821938,
-0.4463178515,
0.338232547,
0.13921763,
-0.6153843999,
-0.1571065336,
0.4017430842,
0.3518752456,
-0.1404753327,
0.3088504076,
-0.344769448,
-0.6604498625,
0.2841693759,
0.2928274572,
0.8656172752,
-0.0027866988,
0.390268743,
0.3218547702,
-0.1555430442,
-0.2425896972,
0.0629196912,
-0.2956602275,
-0.6706893444,
-0.1570916474,
-0.4902839363,
-0.7555909157,
-0.3003594577,
-0.7483626008,
0.0398156866,
-0.2431882173,
-0.0982105434,
-0.2491975129,
-0.1781928986,
-0.3790619671,
0.2061757892,
-0.1279792041,
0.5048313737,
-0.7185028195,
0.5881809592,
0.7655525804,
-0.5437142849,
-0.790583849,
-0.0602145456,
0.0389763899,
-0.7070525289,
0.7242253423,
-0.0745903105,
-0.2873522639,
-0.2152131796,
-0.367968142,
-0.33322981,
0.9838969111,
-0.1194308773,
-0.3872281313,
0.317869544,
-0.0251491535,
0.4117788672,
-0.7668395638,
0.238812387,
0.5330582261,
0.4944120944,
0.0411468968,
-0.5385174155,
-0.0032058044,
-0.3873213232,
-0.1716435254,
0.1704137623,
-0.5198879838,
0.75548172,
-0.3208668232,
-0.1433436424,
-0.2109417617,
0.6635842323,
0.4589569569,
0.2732370794,
0.6863031983,
0.6126021147,
0.7629020214,
0.1608341485,
1.1009261608,
-0.3551791608,
0.6124892235,
1.0634993315,
-0.385355711,
0.9531303048,
0.4744866788,
-0.0861379653,
0.498295635,
0.885525465,
0.2529868186,
0.8662152886,
0.222136125,
-0.1913413405,
-0.5322600007,
-0.3945458829,
-0.221508801,
-0.0282457191,
0.0592741705,
-0.0894510895,
0.0268968362,
0.0061995098,
0.0810322389,
0.2311262786,
-0.2804673016,
1.1356415749,
0.0540915094,
-0.8989267945,
0.4339857101,
-0.0361162312,
0.7725319266,
-0.6521260738,
-0.206305638,
-0.1834252626,
0.2190472484,
-0.27595824,
-0.591594398,
0.0178130995,
-0.0773506314,
-0.2745524347,
-0.5183384418,
0.6877006292,
-0.5256152749,
-0.1791356057,
0.1402336508,
0.5708171725,
-0.1813050061,
-0.1298554987,
-0.5070354939,
-0.2036278397,
0.0832993314,
-0.5799971223,
0.3280567527,
0.1222651824,
-0.0067130416,
0.6446175575,
0.5706137419,
0.106653817,
-0.5519492626,
0.3792322874,
0.7020167708,
-0.7500537634,
-1.0140062571,
-0.8143303394,
0.5831924677,
-0.2439085245,
-0.3026017845,
0.6504530311,
0.5543686152,
0.8402158022,
-0.262095511,
1.0457692146,
0.2643413246,
0.7595787048,
-0.5672796965,
0.6219562292,
-0.7237793207,
0.4546110928,
-0.1922345012,
-0.6124567389,
-0.2893984318,
0.5145071149,
-0.2781876922,
0.0757857636,
0.6443690658,
0.6920126677,
0.1628018022,
0.2830103338,
0.1806666553,
-0.1640409827,
0.2156217396,
0.5763533711,
0.9447032809,
0.0055153091,
0.2887054682,
-0.4014971554,
-0.5157560706,
-0.5137669444,
-0.9498819709,
-0.7652244568,
-0.576756537,
-0.403906703,
-0.2568024099,
0.1737069786,
1.5021746159,
0.9179496765,
-0.9504904747,
-0.5466939807,
0.1959979832,
0.2904883027,
-0.6493890285,
-0.2170972526,
0.4920036197,
-0.3020501435,
-0.4518187344,
0.0565863624,
0.4895267487,
-0.1968226731,
-0.2874622643,
-0.3111276329,
-0.0998827964,
-0.0302038174,
0.7322013974,
0.2529012859,
-0.6137238145,
-0.2520651221,
0.1490938067,
0.0784773827,
0.0766332969,
1.2202688456,
-0.9159100056,
0.2716332078,
0.4840028584,
0.8986754417,
0.5931969285,
0.4005495608,
0.6945895553,
-0.6432599425,
-0.1494019777,
0.3028429151,
0.4037844241,
0.3502871096,
-0.4684900641,
0.4405954778,
0.3448784649,
-0.6151929498,
-0.4451528788,
0.3744432628,
-1.0731356144,
-0.476184845,
0.9970092773,
-0.2354785055,
-0.4108943939,
-0.094759874,
-0.2303860635,
-0.0929185897,
-0.8626749516,
0.9566590786,
0.4572139978,
-0.4638637304,
-0.1911405176,
-0.1170352474,
0.8547273278,
0.5099807382,
-0.9977793694,
0.4518704712,
0.4631511867,
-0.0397180878,
-0.0234843399,
0.8425694704,
0.1073187813,
0.3780816495,
-0.3644419014,
0.2829006612,
-0.3285719156,
-0.3477386832,
-0.4093351066,
0.4749285281,
0.2811665237,
0.011025778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00800v1
|
Brain-Inspired Two-Stage Approach: Enhancing Mathematical Reasoning by Imitating Human Thought Processes
| 2024-02-23T17:40:31 | 2024-02-23T17:40:31 |
Yezeng Chen, Zui Chen, Yi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although large language models demonstrate emergent abilities in solving math
word problems, there is a challenging task in complex multi-step mathematical
reasoning tasks. To improve model performance on mathematical reasoning tasks,
previous work has conducted supervised fine-tuning on open-source models by
improving the quality and quantity of data. In this paper, we propose a novel
approach, named Brain, to imitate human thought processes to enhance
mathematical reasoning abilities, using the Frontal Lobe Model to generate
plans, and then employing the Parietal Lobe Model to generate code and execute
to obtain answers. First, we achieve SOTA performance in comparison with Code
LLaMA 7B based models through this method. Secondly, we find that plans can be
explicitly extracted from natural language, code, or formal language. Our code
and data are publicly available at https://github.com/cyzhh/Brain.
|
[
-0.4327389598,
-1.2285549641,
0.8984100819,
0.5160346627,
-0.1211041659,
-0.0609611869,
-0.1194010377,
-0.3447349966,
0.1700438708,
0.7101615667,
-0.9673558474,
-0.2110412419,
-0.199257955,
-0.2954812646,
0.0405068323,
0.6637417674,
0.1444156021,
0.462553829,
-0.3325152099,
0.3578834534,
-0.5702072978,
-0.3418525457,
-0.8337122798,
-0.6898310184,
0.3714338839,
0.3521930873,
0.6535891294,
0.4365792572,
0.5027800798,
0.1404854804,
-0.0038573421,
0.1378161311,
-0.0954414457,
-0.1998779476,
-0.4976474941,
-0.5112017393,
-0.4404276609,
-0.3244811893,
0.1171266437,
0.755738318,
-0.3511023223,
-0.099997595,
-0.0353786647,
0.6220436096,
-0.5353043079,
0.5629971623,
-0.6165499687,
-0.1149831116,
0.0234249216,
-0.1239016652,
-0.4406030476,
-0.4587714672,
-0.0107292105,
-0.748252809,
-0.2679324448,
-0.4403169155,
0.2987113893,
0.2966790497,
0.0641963854,
-0.57103163,
-0.498039782,
0.5959768295,
-0.8072066307,
0.131043762,
0.472378552,
0.3846870661,
-0.3982468545,
-0.8203067183,
-0.7384666204,
-0.0185524207,
0.1235672683,
0.1343245357,
-0.2333849519,
-0.1466314495,
0.7064755559,
-0.3125836849,
-0.3929990232,
-0.1524886638,
-0.2796812952,
-0.0080314809,
0.6596137881,
0.1715723276,
0.4251866639,
-0.1677099168,
-0.003752375,
-0.1481567472,
-0.5853764415,
0.28434062,
0.1810910702,
0.081327714,
0.2845679224,
0.5748769045,
-0.4914706349,
0.683637321,
-0.1477609724,
0.1689509153,
0.0522186123,
0.0279191602,
-0.2294171602,
-0.0620393455,
0.2332212925,
0.2070383281,
0.4361965358,
0.0228958763,
-0.1832467914,
0.7732121944,
0.3302980065,
-0.8509963751,
-0.5086740851,
0.0575588495,
-0.2547425628,
-0.111086376,
-0.2762613893,
-0.732359767,
-0.2310570478,
-0.7212267518,
0.7621871829,
-0.8284507394,
-0.1307915896,
0.5455809236,
0.0808058232,
-0.0570933186,
0.4258005619,
-0.9206811786,
0.4046054482,
1.0631655455,
0.3195367754,
0.4477413595,
-0.2102415562,
-0.2953505516,
-0.0044139661,
-0.4988086522,
1.1556335688,
-0.6548942924,
-0.0129014291,
-0.3280918598,
-0.6888221502,
0.1440374851,
-0.5851098895,
0.6258167624,
-0.5916613936,
0.1829802096,
-0.522300303,
-0.4429343343,
-0.5512228608,
0.0584202595,
-0.3967418969,
0.7623618245,
-0.0396291353,
-0.491087079,
0.095081754,
-1.0453773737,
-0.4588202536,
0.0396452509,
-0.3536239266,
-0.1525564194,
0.2627399862,
0.7213054299,
0.2112075984,
-0.3239987791,
0.4679169953,
-0.3704853356,
-0.2509996891,
0.3514454067,
-0.1811558306,
1.180346489,
0.1936832368,
-0.3522698581,
0.1520284861,
-0.906441927,
0.4769037068,
0.2500464022,
0.1416893452,
-0.4965883791,
0.2542649508,
-0.3990575075,
0.4671079218,
0.1752424091,
-0.3837082386,
0.2168447971,
-0.6142860055,
0.8245620131,
0.5477918983,
0.2479766756,
0.3596976995,
-0.4374680817,
0.212898612,
-0.1131147742,
0.037134897,
-0.2318892032,
-0.7587047219,
-0.5472950339,
-0.3153870702,
0.2076612413,
0.6501179934,
-0.7622437477,
0.3769783378,
0.0868075117,
-0.4099389017,
-0.3325121999,
-0.1113738418,
0.2473047972,
0.6122159958,
0.3156786561,
-0.3328059018,
-0.579208374,
-0.9683476686,
-0.3757892251,
-0.0741892457,
-0.2917450368,
0.2312914431,
0.454526484,
-0.1451979578,
0.9893324971,
-0.8282868266,
-0.1009116471,
0.0967403725,
0.2839412987,
0.4776719809,
0.4488853812,
0.2732331455,
-0.4100996256,
-0.1039006487,
-0.2771710455,
-0.9227858782,
-0.429017216,
-0.2262791842,
-0.6718625426,
-0.1436231583,
0.2602978647,
-0.6462626457,
0.6381713152,
0.040228989,
-0.605799675,
0.3932271302,
-0.1502668411,
-0.112641111,
-0.9512126446,
-0.0941261873,
-0.1657713652,
0.1552490443,
-0.4126476347,
0.3838079274,
0.3830884695,
-0.2557510734,
-0.250682801,
0.2358161807,
-0.1549286693,
-0.1704971343,
-0.4416478872,
-0.0930796564,
-0.0025938239,
0.8605600595,
0.0755225122,
0.6477513313,
0.6693789363,
-0.5568450689,
0.0311477184,
0.3116341233,
-0.5739861131,
0.5551117063,
-0.6328635216,
0.3076624572,
-0.3422729671,
0.1098495424,
-0.6904675364,
-0.104328528,
0.1756433696,
-0.4095317423,
-0.1484245509,
0.326748997,
-0.5938206911,
-0.3279127777,
-0.051428806,
0.2473148108,
0.6405487657,
-0.4539723396,
0.7872270942,
0.3709025085,
-0.5608603954,
-0.1492145956,
-0.7304916382,
0.1223973259,
0.1342196912,
-0.7231066227,
0.4893971682,
-0.3721515834,
-0.4839278162,
0.1367774457,
-0.0093080448,
-0.2146602869,
0.0290708691,
0.0465502366,
0.3025525212,
-0.0611062348,
-0.0440804623,
0.5700166821,
-0.0635480583,
0.6604856253,
-0.4419660866,
0.5714024305,
0.076065287,
-0.2739002407,
-0.6002020836,
0.4789101779,
0.5604153872,
-0.3610599637,
0.2927150726,
0.0891392007,
-0.962308526,
-0.348834604,
-0.3007299006,
-0.6115504503,
-0.3675361276,
0.2716387212,
-0.7741245627,
-0.3723449707,
0.4437339306,
-0.1119712815,
0.1109713539,
0.1422289014,
0.8748852611,
-0.1941251904,
1.1934494972,
0.2402255833,
0.5384905934,
0.3932389319,
-0.4122582376,
0.1552262753,
-0.7683723569,
-0.4537364542,
-0.1452575177,
-0.4325227439,
0.1658295542,
-0.6554113626,
0.3321232796,
0.3668597937,
-0.0217431858,
0.3221085072,
-0.5025018454,
0.5553867817,
0.6843221188,
0.6152167916,
0.1559690982,
0.2829883099,
-0.5413382649,
-0.2478598058,
-0.6313919425,
-0.4423771203,
1.1032385826,
0.1215140969,
0.4633263648,
-0.0273460858,
0.4541912079,
-0.0337131061,
0.3182322979,
-0.7067520618,
0.7177794576,
0.1033634096,
-0.6854329109,
-0.269956708,
-0.3687859476,
-0.6645083427,
0.3746504486,
-0.4082456231,
-0.6868377924,
-0.0069640563,
-0.1754704714,
-0.5972954035,
-0.0036700568,
-0.6699262857,
0.5655345917,
-0.278698504,
-0.631536305,
-0.9122935534,
-0.2099568546,
0.4320917428,
-0.3014202416,
0.3205024302,
-0.0091540832,
0.3303137124,
0.7044104934,
-0.3087170124,
0.6472869515,
-0.2837316692,
-0.0277344696,
0.7031564713,
0.3616552055,
0.4271398187,
0.2560489774,
-0.0602352358,
0.2716296911,
-0.2511764765,
-0.5035135746,
-1.0082191229,
0.746948421,
-0.5926375985,
-0.5799205303,
-0.135182023,
-1.0643662214,
-0.3631365299,
0.3040881753,
-0.2267535925,
0.5003070235,
0.1233617812,
-0.006713856,
0.4956832826,
0.000314007,
0.5522105694,
0.1985296458,
-0.2476889938,
-0.8403365612,
0.3693532348,
0.2522320151,
-0.1277188212,
0.4273129702,
0.3221165836,
-0.3178401887,
-0.3029325902,
-0.3722687662,
0.1811120212,
-0.5527617931,
-0.1598982364,
-0.6394737363,
-0.0460399762,
-0.4280147254,
-0.0794658586,
-0.2426363826,
-0.7251864672,
-0.0867327601,
0.0734560341,
0.1708120555,
0.5338675976,
-0.1926851869,
0.2081838846,
-0.2771919668,
0.4866741598,
0.6199561954,
0.2833753228,
0.2215073854,
-0.1808958799,
-0.1457445174,
0.401728034,
-0.6195060015,
-0.8338798881,
0.4623408914,
-0.2952975333,
0.4860024452,
0.276609987,
-0.1877146214,
0.9747213125,
-0.5430853963,
0.1701801866,
0.2366901934,
-1.0977334976,
0.7340047359,
-0.2053518146,
0.2827789783,
0.2748776674,
-0.018819442,
0.1558514386,
0.0397832431,
-0.6113787889,
-0.3558376133,
0.6498252153,
0.4087471962,
-0.1664164662,
0.1057813093,
0.5383632779,
0.1429590434,
0.0536090732,
-0.3250248432,
0.3897487223,
-0.1547655016,
-0.3320365846,
0.3141280115,
-0.0815709382,
0.0360018387,
-0.5983171463,
0.4898058474,
-0.2521032095,
0.3356310427,
0.1258509159,
0.1521193087,
-0.1957623214,
0.0178531799,
0.6830637455,
1.0123002529,
-0.0184707474,
0.1388189495,
0.193443954,
-0.314625144,
-0.1973705292,
0.1668599993,
-0.3619462252,
-0.4370780587,
0.1666072756,
0.5487957597,
0.3309867978,
-0.8163582087,
0.0272217579,
-0.0365247913,
-0.437582612,
-0.3539114594,
0.1864453852,
0.4389241338,
0.7183539867,
0.2737709284,
0.4679333866,
0.1588021368,
-0.6042603254,
0.2869615555,
0.3238711357,
0.1038653478,
-0.4573193789,
0.8581829667,
-0.2364874035,
-0.6858795881,
0.7411924005,
-0.0247327089,
-0.3884979486,
0.6546545029,
0.9725145698,
0.5779391527,
0.1246306375,
0.0535073876,
0.4077283442,
0.2280971408,
-0.1852743328,
0.9147710204,
-0.0647896752,
-0.6818160415,
-0.9040496349,
-0.4186909795,
-0.2951959372,
0.0483245254,
-0.6307606101,
0.3979233801,
-0.7932825089,
-0.1682547778,
0.1928736269,
-0.0660317764,
-0.596971035,
0.3256811798,
0.2579998076,
0.9391604662,
-0.6096927524,
1.0530350208,
0.9491360188,
-0.2979340553,
-0.7724307179,
-0.0857370645,
-0.4312859476,
-0.9350514412,
0.466683358,
0.0551714003,
0.060408216,
0.2478929311,
-0.5358623862,
-0.7386718988,
0.8971816301,
0.5092855096,
-0.5663313866,
-0.1371364743,
-0.1991624385,
0.5149697661,
-0.3811368644,
0.2847895622,
0.4133064747,
0.3192129433,
0.2823673785,
-0.4445224702,
-0.0351195149,
-0.2355442643,
0.0553317666,
0.111935325,
-0.1744544357,
0.9417646527,
-0.5349214673,
-0.0545822792,
-0.0774125457,
0.7889890671,
0.8700684309,
0.7036728263,
0.4035362601,
1.0748537779,
0.7363093495,
0.2293564081,
0.6025567651,
-0.3162706196,
0.1509834826,
0.9175517559,
-0.3535739481,
1.0925126076,
0.5118318796,
-0.0989710838,
0.8906288743,
0.333078593,
0.2633304596,
0.8942327499,
0.3219883144,
0.0441397503,
-0.3842357993,
0.2577680945,
-0.0125241438,
0.4146489501,
0.7892177105,
-0.1047712117,
-0.2178844512,
0.0144654419,
-0.060202837,
0.518268466,
-0.4746244848,
0.5215141773,
0.217768535,
-1.0416398048,
0.4289287925,
0.0888573304,
0.2364581972,
-0.3047021925,
-0.3080787957,
-0.0538268685,
0.3818878531,
-0.0022241143,
-0.7445607185,
0.4534589052,
0.0259533748,
-0.2149122804,
-0.2735758126,
0.6093084216,
-0.0489855483,
-0.8578717113,
0.1131853759,
0.5362712145,
0.0980166718,
-0.4155409038,
-0.7312217355,
-0.2009794861,
-0.0378347933,
-0.0890195444,
0.1211081594,
0.5756592751,
-0.3852465153,
0.5844721794,
0.9340695143,
0.1154138222,
-0.0620125793,
0.0862134919,
0.8682919741,
-0.9296093583,
-0.7269076705,
-1.0227537155,
0.3551238179,
0.0069730757,
-0.2174546719,
0.2705034614,
0.5008832812,
0.8432235718,
-0.1768667996,
0.6437625289,
-0.0644408166,
0.3647986948,
-0.6119604111,
0.4783389866,
-0.1965809315,
0.1957187057,
-0.2680502236,
-1.0567358732,
-0.5663076639,
1.1260820627,
-0.3805217445,
-0.2365586758,
0.9194644094,
0.8415336609,
-0.0869935155,
0.4584304988,
0.3132407367,
0.1624123752,
0.2634100914,
1.1830861568,
0.8308756948,
-0.1920726597,
0.2398832291,
-0.4676751494,
-0.7324095964,
0.003597049,
-0.6247435808,
-1.0230436325,
-0.3029545844,
-0.3883380592,
-0.4157887697,
-0.0558825321,
0.9646707773,
0.59164536,
-0.6798597574,
-0.2045124024,
-0.7125897408,
-0.1903907061,
-0.6290624142,
-0.1834526062,
0.2436076254,
-0.2216831446,
-0.6516628265,
0.5022016764,
0.32676965,
-0.4326069057,
-0.3720981181,
0.1983442754,
-0.0753399953,
0.4432883263,
0.7844337821,
-0.1530604362,
-0.816093266,
-0.0348415896,
0.3113135397,
-0.1499097347,
-0.1268465221,
0.8931282759,
-1.1603720188,
0.3132779896,
0.6479987502,
0.6443145275,
0.5530493259,
-0.1975647211,
0.4397910833,
0.0743656904,
-0.0107619157,
0.3908369839,
0.3355880976,
-0.0259831641,
-0.3173686564,
0.5728821754,
0.2680512965,
-0.2623782754,
-0.5679875612,
0.3742174506,
-0.8474346995,
-0.6475791335,
0.7114300132,
0.0944442078,
-0.5273439884,
0.2855198979,
-0.53148067,
0.3029374778,
-0.2384518981,
1.2295114994,
0.6949453354,
-0.5865926743,
-0.0163955819,
-0.4785244167,
-0.0276601259,
0.5960645676,
-0.9457333684,
-0.098295331,
0.3815175295,
0.1474882662,
0.2448140532,
0.4876255989,
-0.3456237912,
0.4065630138,
0.2004867047,
0.2485408038,
-0.1851622909,
-0.4007306099,
-0.0633976534,
0.4246884286,
-0.2017814815,
-0.0525190532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00799v1
|
An Empirical Study of Data Ability Boundary in LLMs' Math Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T17:38:43 | 2024-02-23T17:38:43 |
Zui Chen, Yezeng Chen, Jiaqi Han, Zhijie Huang, Ji Qi, Yi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are displaying emergent abilities for math
reasoning tasks,and there is a growing attention on enhancing the ability of
open-source LLMs through supervised fine-tuning (SFT).In this paper, we aim to
explore a general data strategy for supervised data to help optimize and expand
math reasoning ability.Firstly, we determine the ability boundary of reasoning
paths augmentation by identifying these paths' minimal optimal set.Secondly, we
validate that different abilities of the model can be cumulatively enhanced by
Mix of Minimal Optimal Sets of corresponding types of data, while our models
MMOS achieve SOTA performance on series base models under much lower
construction costs.Besides, we point out GSM-HARD is not really hard and
today's LLMs no longer lack numerical robustness.Also, we provide an Auto
Problem Generator for robustness testing and educational applications.Our code
and data are publicly available at https://github.com/cyzhh/MMOS.
|
[
-0.4347521067,
-1.0397555828,
0.7565742731,
0.0194711927,
-0.0680721775,
-0.096588701,
-0.3460936844,
-0.1752097458,
-0.2827958763,
0.868455112,
-0.7883034348,
-0.6579040289,
-0.4977683723,
-0.0347941816,
-0.0073386012,
0.9733942747,
-0.0656970665,
-0.0117529007,
-0.6638686061,
0.0395889208,
-0.3762556314,
-0.4808747172,
-0.4517160058,
-0.1453801543,
0.1636619717,
0.5686939359,
0.8310671449,
1.0659939051,
0.8245452046,
0.3119725585,
0.1038380265,
0.6923540831,
-0.4885615408,
0.1376033127,
-0.1631553322,
-0.6492086053,
-0.8229382634,
-0.2243473232,
0.5934829116,
0.8352069855,
-0.0594575629,
0.1744478941,
-0.0395128988,
0.7311617732,
-0.5318158865,
0.2540668845,
-0.7444382906,
-0.0513713248,
-0.2282251716,
-0.2212095261,
-0.34574157,
-0.4502398372,
0.0230659675,
-0.8186914921,
0.0305183809,
-0.0959372297,
0.6428875923,
0.8407950401,
-0.2963392437,
-0.3184034824,
-0.5416343212,
0.9312422276,
-0.5625929236,
0.5055006742,
0.5939055085,
0.4053848982,
-0.3446381986,
-0.3553684354,
-0.0467261486,
-0.1652414352,
0.1459618807,
0.0676225722,
-0.1068894193,
-0.0050999168,
0.5980292559,
0.3380438983,
-0.2994433641,
0.1381924599,
-0.2576694489,
-0.0605975948,
0.7976323962,
0.400084734,
0.1390542537,
0.0524057187,
-0.0363357514,
0.085784629,
-0.6498750448,
0.1908797175,
0.4800985456,
0.3999574482,
-0.0358549096,
0.9605673552,
-0.3869724274,
1.0118478537,
-0.1325204223,
-0.3298127055,
0.2186530977,
-0.3876089156,
-0.2174685001,
-0.3767096102,
0.4440820217,
0.1727472246,
0.4951884449,
-0.2333981991,
-0.2168821096,
0.0540560521,
0.0187674277,
-0.6370888352,
-0.2072612494,
-0.0595614575,
-0.1588712633,
-0.1047619581,
-0.0943382978,
-0.5209269524,
-0.2108943462,
-0.7380546927,
0.2016243041,
-0.5929991603,
-0.1196661592,
0.3898302913,
0.0077581825,
-0.2453746647,
0.2914923131,
-0.954206109,
0.5118804574,
0.9030032754,
0.6327803731,
-0.0598299727,
0.004571659,
-0.7949489355,
-0.0368027166,
-0.3335620761,
0.5415909886,
-0.6289179921,
-0.1901156008,
-0.2909249961,
-0.2242528349,
-0.0500525236,
-0.5593881011,
0.8973360658,
-0.4601459801,
0.1259297282,
-0.220689103,
-0.6265968084,
0.0077726408,
-0.0856075063,
-0.4620912671,
0.9928248525,
0.2775083184,
-0.5997584462,
0.3757641613,
-0.7865335345,
-0.3450557888,
-0.0632588416,
-0.0800603554,
-0.5310301781,
0.0583750531,
0.5218648911,
0.5200791359,
-0.2485231459,
0.401156038,
-0.444626689,
-0.3648616672,
0.1126488447,
-0.4270971715,
0.9042695165,
0.2950863242,
-0.1004772261,
-0.1409920752,
-0.8856684566,
0.2155742198,
0.1621299833,
-0.2992201149,
-0.6186617613,
0.1764333099,
-0.5309891105,
-0.0152644878,
0.2093606591,
-0.2753489017,
0.3796066344,
-0.5229505897,
0.3079430163,
0.9108837247,
-0.208295092,
0.5908725858,
-0.2748072445,
0.3514684737,
-0.1729511172,
0.1532266438,
-0.0264407378,
-0.6020739079,
-0.6805541515,
-0.5083957911,
0.4055443704,
0.7360076904,
-0.8376979232,
0.727378726,
-0.2167746723,
-0.1932717264,
-0.6292518973,
0.4596474767,
0.2764079273,
0.5596942306,
0.424944818,
0.0558156148,
-0.4254130423,
-0.8188624382,
-0.0153043587,
0.2077672333,
-0.2264563143,
0.5440783501,
0.3206201494,
-0.3388100564,
1.0859656334,
-0.7086075544,
-0.1916622967,
0.1262119561,
-0.2558423877,
0.3402980864,
0.2710759342,
0.4859516919,
-0.657102406,
-0.1249334216,
-0.0572857,
-0.9930930734,
-0.5461478233,
0.0386526696,
-0.3206442595,
-0.0150564816,
0.1998199821,
-0.4332361817,
0.2311742306,
0.3564387262,
-0.2678958774,
0.3805932403,
-0.2205913365,
-0.1084441617,
-0.7151690125,
-0.4676834643,
0.3281018734,
-0.0288225096,
-0.4223459065,
0.1143602058,
0.0371006653,
0.0092841685,
0.0011641553,
0.2731202841,
-0.3309147358,
-0.1297218949,
-0.2203629315,
0.0331028663,
-0.2738065124,
0.4331789315,
0.0220558252,
0.8232235312,
0.767880559,
-0.7143287063,
0.4418486953,
-0.1128679663,
-0.1410465091,
0.6643332839,
-0.5569563508,
0.0395478681,
-0.0617903359,
-0.004671609,
-0.8761653304,
-0.2740699947,
0.0242574103,
-0.4499619007,
-0.1386478096,
-0.3071644604,
-0.730748713,
-0.3029518723,
-0.129649058,
0.2525114715,
0.5722442865,
-0.6610454917,
0.4563440979,
0.4125186801,
-0.1615796685,
-0.3460739255,
-0.4168684483,
-0.2373879254,
-0.3596590459,
-1.0544654131,
0.158017531,
-0.248878777,
-0.5264065862,
0.0549531877,
0.1272745281,
-0.1612788588,
0.2439131588,
0.2791480422,
0.3915932775,
-0.2219045311,
0.2362967581,
0.4613453746,
-0.2774571478,
0.1785256118,
-0.2216292471,
0.3058843017,
-0.2658357322,
-0.5898042321,
-0.0216994993,
0.0493997224,
0.1959132999,
-0.1613054872,
0.4580335617,
0.3208006322,
-0.4389326274,
-0.4203472435,
-0.3809219897,
-0.1922406107,
-0.5011286139,
0.1194682419,
-0.6367899776,
-1.0361697674,
0.3658144772,
-0.3139899373,
0.2361028194,
0.3975282013,
0.525221169,
0.0290568173,
1.2639621496,
0.3106074929,
0.1282662749,
0.0872872323,
-0.3432601988,
0.05554704,
-0.7814352512,
-0.1245689839,
-0.1928108484,
0.0345092826,
-0.4397225678,
-0.5629175901,
0.3941380978,
0.2253417969,
-0.1965019256,
0.0916585103,
-0.6254483461,
0.5581015348,
0.4874972403,
0.176381588,
0.58156389,
0.259137392,
-0.1786705405,
-0.2949670553,
-0.6168653369,
-0.3925973773,
1.2455737591,
0.5736092329,
0.8301283717,
0.0680064484,
0.5004091859,
0.1110293567,
0.2356464863,
-0.7784826756,
0.6226944923,
-0.3072735071,
-0.3588282168,
-0.447963804,
-0.8648982644,
-0.7438995242,
0.2109873444,
-0.3280041814,
-0.6241876483,
-0.2706053555,
-0.0139004765,
-0.1787744612,
0.1888513863,
-0.8216303587,
0.3242159784,
-0.3371163011,
-0.6788937449,
0.1585446745,
-0.2796202898,
0.6355509162,
-0.2585134506,
0.3612262905,
-0.0683656558,
-0.0315709859,
0.4967981875,
-0.5823898911,
0.6664885879,
-0.1240268648,
-0.2199982107,
0.402361691,
-0.1213196814,
0.5703520179,
0.1859825253,
-0.1419149935,
0.200180918,
-0.4088051915,
-0.2966981232,
-0.7810103893,
0.7327187657,
-0.7034830451,
-0.7056557536,
0.0512549728,
-0.814180553,
-0.5091404319,
0.0900687575,
-0.028228078,
0.2170080245,
0.2998223007,
0.3066447079,
0.8833521605,
0.1152900383,
0.0377174206,
0.4575535059,
-0.2000649869,
-0.3880115747,
0.9407767653,
0.4054920971,
0.2317586839,
0.0345898271,
0.2807735801,
-0.3894961178,
-0.5370643139,
-0.7394943833,
0.1900852919,
-0.492770195,
-0.1845810115,
-0.4213604033,
-0.4010386169,
-0.381090939,
-0.2056792229,
-0.2462952882,
-0.4336096644,
-0.2674168944,
-0.1560932398,
0.6869379878,
0.3687847853,
-0.2326341569,
0.3076435626,
-0.4473470151,
0.3549621403,
0.3775114119,
0.4522798359,
-0.1414326429,
-0.5049439073,
-0.1741542965,
0.2875699997,
-0.309452951,
-0.3433732986,
0.1489977986,
-0.1978826076,
0.7316660881,
0.4016188681,
-0.0528833605,
0.6237183809,
-0.3468204737,
0.2430019677,
0.0698458552,
-0.8824121952,
0.6419411302,
-0.6220092773,
0.0686255917,
0.2849478126,
0.1932043433,
0.22891289,
-0.4130042791,
-0.7588916421,
-0.5993703604,
0.5410214663,
0.4837524891,
-0.0208105668,
0.3629156649,
0.4639009535,
0.1470238864,
0.0006092422,
-0.4230727553,
-0.127066493,
0.0306394678,
-0.3771809042,
0.1948546618,
0.1720421016,
-0.1416199505,
-0.5505287647,
0.3815003037,
-0.2945870459,
-0.0463141277,
-0.1796559095,
0.1759250313,
-0.1015547514,
0.0954295397,
0.4497119188,
0.812541008,
-0.2789354324,
0.138655439,
0.4370529354,
-0.4689904153,
0.0867485702,
0.2984153926,
-0.230420351,
-0.3629931211,
0.2913931906,
0.7108696699,
-0.1575151384,
-0.7435818315,
0.2539867759,
0.1817146391,
-0.4797465503,
-0.109273605,
0.571906805,
0.0688494518,
0.2633701563,
0.3757256866,
-0.0729067847,
0.1969688684,
-0.2226602584,
0.314977318,
0.530796051,
-0.0103922645,
-0.0021175551,
0.5589565635,
0.0386156552,
-0.2833603323,
0.5001948476,
-0.237419337,
-0.2471660525,
0.73528862,
0.6757454872,
0.2383512408,
-0.0703994408,
0.0387832001,
0.2058379501,
0.3940918446,
-0.107308045,
0.1866247654,
-0.0211164709,
-0.8251624703,
-0.6463540196,
-0.3211211562,
-0.4224246144,
0.1405165642,
-0.5217617154,
0.4192633927,
-0.5474504828,
-0.1990132034,
0.0483254865,
0.2080975026,
-0.6735084653,
0.5224087834,
-0.0305070877,
0.668723464,
-0.7492674589,
0.6691641808,
0.4931940138,
-0.0841697082,
-0.7067449689,
-0.4098529816,
-0.024298504,
-1.0335310698,
0.5098013282,
-0.1224831492,
-0.1643788666,
0.0509571992,
-0.673777163,
-0.9438877702,
0.9117084742,
0.4768974781,
-0.5679745078,
0.2120951116,
0.1565202028,
0.6272211671,
-0.4915681779,
0.2863402963,
0.6254492998,
0.4730374813,
0.2613228858,
-0.6732591987,
-0.0287345778,
-0.1978639811,
-0.1621688008,
0.3336671889,
-0.4858658612,
0.7283880711,
-0.4290986955,
0.0370625071,
-0.1944303364,
0.5787068605,
0.7554634809,
0.6834129691,
0.6160043478,
0.918723464,
0.9468598366,
-0.2300778627,
0.9313428998,
0.1050077528,
0.2405540198,
0.9444835782,
-0.1089039296,
0.5255886912,
0.1813332736,
-0.1951582879,
0.2553900182,
0.7380716205,
-0.228906557,
0.5675994158,
0.5265905261,
0.0225693062,
-0.511873126,
-0.1040197313,
-0.3870367706,
0.3457345963,
0.5552868843,
-0.316203773,
-0.140844956,
-0.0241980311,
0.1143424287,
0.134108603,
-0.329515487,
0.5855455995,
-0.0383173861,
-0.4834668934,
0.5268631577,
0.0695412382,
0.5604096055,
-0.3753307164,
-0.1492423266,
-0.1553451717,
0.0596821159,
-0.400467962,
-0.9475535154,
0.2300051153,
0.1716895401,
-0.2146621943,
0.092381835,
0.8513585329,
-0.2379699051,
-0.7830988765,
0.137788415,
0.6792989373,
0.1973269433,
0.0721943304,
-0.5834437013,
-0.0331916586,
-0.0159111209,
-0.064245984,
0.3121538758,
0.8138638735,
-0.3299632668,
0.7782083154,
1.1227762699,
0.2083202451,
-0.0392604247,
0.2027751207,
1.1126323938,
-0.4741587937,
-0.3164432645,
-1.048230648,
0.4734702706,
-0.3368342519,
-0.3497945666,
0.8623632193,
0.6826537251,
0.69938308,
0.2076933533,
0.8404528499,
0.400978744,
0.5162025094,
-0.7839154601,
0.1950185448,
-0.5244776011,
0.4646588564,
-0.2608089149,
-0.9223250151,
-0.3482784629,
0.6952776909,
-0.7001544237,
0.0006113036,
0.3036363721,
0.6108956337,
-0.3636170328,
0.0834257379,
0.2451063544,
-0.2401707321,
0.1871203631,
0.8745663762,
0.8433126807,
-0.2028056234,
0.3613446653,
-0.2448402792,
-0.6898629069,
-0.1103956029,
-0.6806588173,
-1.0765221119,
-0.2685189843,
-0.2099569291,
-0.213947162,
-0.0355908349,
0.6441575885,
0.7206935883,
-0.3568984866,
-0.0279490221,
-0.2464113384,
0.3812973201,
-0.1316217035,
-0.2763247192,
0.3125555813,
-0.2834581137,
-0.7296225429,
0.3934683204,
0.2206986398,
0.0376809053,
-0.2227039039,
-0.1508950442,
0.3363829255,
0.1848648787,
0.625918448,
-0.1070250273,
-0.5229772329,
-0.0454092585,
0.4128498733,
-0.0768785104,
-0.0738100559,
0.6587503552,
-0.4873820245,
0.4510675073,
0.2832359374,
0.9244709015,
0.3113011718,
0.3198466003,
0.3888368905,
-0.5250648856,
-0.0546217337,
0.1326683313,
0.3169135153,
0.1511192769,
-0.6019691825,
0.9218919277,
0.3285607398,
-0.5402613282,
-0.8736431599,
0.0328984149,
-0.8827637434,
-0.1980141699,
1.2668894529,
0.000690167,
-0.0212349351,
-0.0941688493,
-0.198851794,
-0.0046816668,
-0.3873645961,
0.7604365945,
0.8110717535,
-0.3946397305,
-0.1221098602,
-0.7784193158,
0.2915021181,
0.3008108735,
-1.1119418144,
-0.0736512914,
0.5870527625,
0.1075639129,
0.1491933912,
0.5182198286,
0.0188753027,
0.0760807917,
-0.0754214674,
-0.4436730146,
-0.4628489316,
-0.4589940906,
0.0479976088,
0.1616573185,
-0.1570518911,
-0.0626945198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15449v1
|
Repetition Improves Language Model Embeddings
| 2024-02-23T17:25:10 | 2024-02-23T17:25:10 |
Jacob Mitchell Springer, Suhas Kotha, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig, Aditi Raghunathan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent approaches to improving the extraction of text embeddings from
autoregressive large language models (LLMs) have largely focused on
improvements to data, backbone pretrained language models, or improving
task-differentiation via instructions. In this work, we address an
architectural limitation of autoregressive models: token embeddings cannot
contain information from tokens that appear later in the input. To address this
limitation, we propose a simple approach, "echo embeddings," in which we repeat
the input twice in context and extract embeddings from the second occurrence.
We show that echo embeddings of early tokens can encode information about later
tokens, allowing us to maximally leverage high-quality LLMs for embeddings. On
the MTEB leaderboard, echo embeddings improve over classical embeddings by over
9% zero-shot and by around 0.7% when fine-tuned. Echo embeddings with a
Mistral-7B model achieve state-of-the-art compared to prior open source models
that do not leverage synthetic fine-tuning data.
|
[
-0.1634030193,
-0.8777316809,
0.5738951564,
0.2035649866,
-0.6275408864,
0.3444496691,
-0.2627553344,
-0.3093780577,
0.2459563017,
0.5703853369,
0.0521263704,
-0.4877219796,
-0.9166955948,
0.0035335757,
-0.6800461411,
0.6514894962,
-0.2715354264,
0.0712828785,
-0.061355941,
-0.2346424162,
-0.60709548,
-0.7667004466,
-0.7026501298,
-0.196502775,
0.5262973309,
0.2383226156,
0.566178441,
1.1255426407,
0.1881025434,
0.2149759084,
0.0012852321,
0.223982662,
-0.3119176924,
0.292260468,
0.1534156203,
-0.4723972678,
-0.1093572453,
-0.0900806934,
0.9797500968,
0.7058930397,
-0.3518312573,
0.1246543974,
0.5113118887,
0.3073094189,
-0.5859891176,
0.3400518894,
-0.6841517687,
-0.212361604,
-0.1389804035,
-0.2664172947,
-0.5878427625,
-0.2507051229,
-0.1330609024,
-0.2496256679,
-0.0759965703,
0.0135425534,
0.5476740599,
0.1440087557,
-0.2596248984,
-0.3347052038,
-0.7362508774,
0.8127228618,
-0.7818305492,
0.6950649023,
0.2199637592,
-0.1285443157,
-0.1046040729,
-0.9278457165,
-0.4480646849,
-0.1359091401,
0.0903503597,
-0.337756902,
-0.3801779151,
-0.2197849303,
-0.0495951399,
0.0903213918,
-0.1574873328,
0.2546370029,
-0.0498189144,
-0.1079468578,
0.1602374762,
0.2698450983,
0.1122033,
0.0716653764,
-0.4176929891,
-0.4564447701,
-0.7960062623,
-0.0113324942,
0.1743773371,
0.3862070143,
0.0917181224,
0.3906145692,
0.325240463,
0.5245921016,
0.2270352095,
0.1662879288,
0.345079273,
-0.1410977989,
-0.1027750596,
-0.2415914387,
0.555573225,
0.0130332271,
-0.0757294297,
-0.2059615552,
-0.4233464897,
-0.4145089686,
0.110996373,
-0.6186619997,
-0.0922757909,
0.0667773709,
-0.7460147142,
-0.2703883052,
0.2526229024,
-0.5340221524,
-0.1962104738,
-0.2691093385,
0.3847409189,
-0.3924762905,
-0.2961653471,
0.0570053793,
-0.2710325122,
0.1691586375,
0.2546772063,
-0.8855322599,
0.4747341573,
0.9089732766,
0.8216965199,
-0.2113221288,
-0.5507466197,
-0.5511080027,
0.1699905097,
-0.4659473598,
0.6177629232,
-0.9219640493,
-0.6081467271,
0.1662069112,
-0.0506655276,
-0.0193515029,
-0.8640329242,
-0.0124356896,
-0.4981378019,
0.2779047191,
-0.2474853694,
-0.7484846115,
0.027389247,
-0.1409152299,
-0.6394279003,
1.2306017876,
-0.1088024527,
-0.4582121074,
0.4810555279,
-0.4251293838,
-0.3428961933,
-0.1848001182,
-0.2711547613,
-0.3338427544,
0.5843486786,
0.2865549624,
0.3837080002,
-0.0777929276,
0.2784647644,
-0.5014097095,
-0.4365079105,
0.1575671285,
-0.7669852376,
0.5752499104,
0.0643069223,
-0.4298713505,
-0.1785048991,
-0.4181593657,
-0.1047487482,
0.1214808002,
-0.4419256747,
-0.4150064886,
0.0949241593,
-0.147822991,
0.0133241406,
0.391630888,
-0.3738619685,
0.3730564415,
-0.2624754906,
0.3721095622,
1.0201942921,
0.063089788,
0.3882570267,
-0.4308970869,
0.5071017146,
0.2161778361,
-0.0849508941,
-0.5318917632,
-0.3166632056,
-0.8461927772,
-0.5289689302,
0.4341733754,
0.4560972154,
-0.5650456548,
0.4256342947,
-0.3476733565,
-0.1274367124,
-0.7518805861,
0.337518096,
0.2775251865,
0.036726974,
0.4164967239,
-0.5753678679,
-0.7251496315,
-0.7235631943,
-0.4232536256,
-0.2496712953,
0.2224012166,
0.3884479105,
0.4121270478,
-0.1412911564,
0.8383444548,
-0.4208143651,
0.0584338307,
-0.266138345,
0.5255496502,
0.1033784375,
0.5620706677,
0.3897133172,
-0.3037608564,
-0.4547268152,
-0.3357065916,
-0.5513506532,
-0.1171264201,
-0.3085398972,
0.1044199392,
0.2148590684,
0.7182878852,
-0.5646771789,
0.4049203992,
0.5802428722,
-0.1763109118,
0.2017192245,
-0.3042666018,
-0.0382312052,
-1.2265511751,
-0.0073277904,
-0.6326718926,
-0.5475263,
-0.2838364244,
0.005506658,
0.030210197,
-0.0395887122,
-0.2791830897,
1.0121346712,
-0.6744249463,
-0.0114000421,
-0.492213428,
0.0709266216,
-0.1198570505,
0.3001851737,
-0.0749750063,
0.6810189486,
0.5335333347,
-0.5353041291,
0.1690912098,
-0.0734430626,
-0.2620626986,
-0.0115885306,
-0.5851271749,
0.4690018892,
-0.0611378103,
0.3789503574,
-1.0122449398,
0.0920986682,
0.1219296753,
-0.4582158029,
0.5294327736,
-0.0944169536,
-0.8669856787,
-0.1847095042,
-0.4358613193,
0.4021482468,
0.8173328638,
-0.8566739559,
0.4629561901,
0.4596571326,
-0.2882546782,
-0.6060914993,
-0.5589507818,
0.2436178774,
-0.0966214314,
-0.0047851256,
0.1336022615,
0.1726601273,
-0.0118515817,
0.2152905017,
0.0053779702,
0.0633340552,
0.2634821236,
0.1650002897,
0.0883772746,
-0.2460030019,
0.4151471257,
0.135411948,
-0.1929335445,
-0.098226957,
-0.6607907414,
0.9345189929,
0.1911596209,
-0.5943750739,
-0.7672083378,
0.6192263961,
0.4745302498,
-0.0531054102,
0.9644116759,
0.5413861871,
-0.4333129823,
-0.2603813708,
-0.7829436064,
-0.3353437185,
-0.4882363081,
0.4337900579,
-0.2085525692,
-1.1368144751,
0.444155246,
-0.159946695,
0.3017897606,
0.3395447731,
0.472003907,
-0.4305106103,
1.1364430189,
0.7251750827,
-0.3890827,
0.8300324082,
-0.0297945235,
-0.0620366968,
-0.8684538603,
0.0120207621,
-0.4204617441,
-0.2515498698,
-0.4505698085,
-0.583941102,
-0.0511005782,
0.3842896223,
-0.1088819504,
0.2550187409,
-0.1539426297,
0.2565003037,
0.5769690275,
0.0741701052,
0.1166692749,
0.3649937212,
-0.1966775656,
0.0461849421,
-0.7006770372,
-0.681085825,
1.2443588972,
0.5917684436,
0.7235459685,
0.0155365486,
1.2315753698,
0.3469201326,
0.5913240314,
-0.3952990174,
0.3929434121,
-0.4193733037,
-0.3456468284,
-0.1771787107,
-0.3646488786,
-1.1546472311,
0.1648420244,
0.1114595458,
-0.7167487741,
0.3206479251,
0.4492286444,
-0.2422902882,
0.4381105602,
-0.4850040972,
0.4913511872,
0.0196379665,
-0.1095123366,
-0.364790827,
-0.0463741571,
-0.2191596627,
-0.111604102,
0.3628034294,
0.3067906201,
-0.2772531807,
0.7636826038,
-0.4845665693,
1.2386046648,
-0.2796021104,
-0.1457683891,
0.4816071987,
0.0307510626,
0.8844371438,
-0.170199424,
0.0365757272,
0.129131034,
-0.2839587331,
-0.370757252,
-0.7489640117,
0.6777432561,
-0.6093068123,
-0.8106358647,
-0.1741351783,
-0.0419858061,
-0.0793648139,
0.1682055146,
0.0611861423,
0.6756106019,
-0.2123395354,
0.7406107783,
0.3449232578,
-0.1481849551,
0.7410686612,
0.1851947904,
-0.4123847485,
-0.6640523076,
0.7741898894,
0.0978493989,
0.2682831883,
0.3239092827,
0.0597002693,
-0.3520447016,
-0.5108193159,
-0.1696310341,
0.3418744206,
-0.7525494695,
-0.1627906859,
-0.8938212991,
0.0077584698,
-0.5736287236,
0.0478792712,
-0.5390560627,
-0.6243969798,
-0.5348892808,
-0.2186335176,
0.107644029,
0.9263806939,
-0.3495957851,
0.3619580865,
-0.9111580253,
0.1042829677,
0.3646807075,
0.3241745532,
0.2834834754,
-0.786786437,
-0.5129556656,
0.1140297577,
-0.1798001677,
-0.7738279104,
0.3624759018,
0.1612763703,
0.7607952356,
0.1350820214,
-0.3799571693,
0.8787053823,
-0.6022223234,
0.8647821546,
0.0442381278,
-1.1806606054,
0.312990576,
-0.0729957595,
0.4369118512,
0.4353411198,
0.0608271696,
-0.4549200535,
-0.6092127562,
-0.7867647409,
-0.8907521367,
0.4814692438,
0.1009564176,
0.6741665602,
-0.3881013989,
0.480589956,
0.3041960299,
0.3915907741,
-0.6676108241,
-0.3740167618,
-0.0850132853,
-0.2944146693,
-0.1185518429,
-0.5181816816,
0.06690038,
-0.0564339049,
0.462382257,
0.1981877089,
0.5260679126,
0.0116576059,
-0.361803174,
0.0856428146,
0.1074708328,
0.4779099524,
0.4265354574,
0.000591486,
0.3311563134,
0.399248749,
-0.4374853075,
-0.0292591657,
-0.0084492294,
0.1154015288,
0.3928405046,
0.831581533,
0.8880414367,
0.3054242134,
-0.3826346695,
0.444596827,
0.0417744778,
0.1247463673,
-0.3087544143,
0.025568163,
-0.0368210934,
0.3262061477,
0.4714013636,
-0.1679899693,
-0.1397167742,
-0.7624980211,
0.6035720706,
0.3698384464,
-0.3048585057,
-0.353954196,
0.5030008554,
0.0973247141,
-0.5373175144,
0.5808808208,
0.029790638,
-0.411375463,
0.4523794353,
0.8349033594,
1.0832512379,
-0.3850661516,
-0.0042662281,
0.2608818114,
0.2420924753,
-0.3403882384,
0.4787667394,
-0.1121463403,
-0.6482772827,
-0.1595666409,
-0.4089145064,
-0.253619045,
-0.068538554,
-0.7736378312,
0.282791853,
-0.6858810186,
-0.366193831,
-0.494335413,
-0.3437883854,
-0.9701705575,
-0.0043992009,
0.2202343792,
0.6966164708,
-0.6167097688,
1.0633727312,
0.455696553,
-0.1305404007,
-0.6880690455,
0.0248243641,
-0.2422680259,
-1.0022331476,
0.6844996214,
0.1863820255,
-0.1486143768,
0.2394223958,
-0.7005826831,
-1.0874450207,
1.0829540491,
0.2737460732,
-0.5755659938,
-0.0230438802,
0.055288408,
0.544357121,
-0.819806993,
0.183970347,
0.2947901189,
0.2289878875,
-0.3668299615,
-0.8441921473,
0.0132500948,
-0.0442284383,
0.066686295,
0.1822054535,
-0.448120743,
0.8375347257,
-0.1256947815,
-0.5188279748,
0.1440531462,
0.694431603,
0.2014055997,
-0.1536867023,
0.604875505,
0.593177855,
0.7493841648,
-0.0130471159,
1.2032163143,
-0.5351504087,
0.4547293782,
1.656269908,
-0.0856069997,
1.3258554935,
0.6074910164,
0.0631433651,
0.8036555052,
0.3246657848,
0.0500728525,
0.6176760197,
0.030916119,
-0.0634239465,
-0.3234058022,
-0.0432830378,
-0.5053297877,
0.587823987,
0.3069371879,
-0.8239496946,
0.0125705302,
0.1384253502,
0.154347688,
-0.2591856122,
0.2502999902,
0.9698957801,
0.2772730291,
-0.364646554,
0.6228530407,
-0.0315553844,
0.5099592805,
-0.3135884404,
-0.2537069023,
-0.4381021559,
-0.0173968542,
0.30379197,
-0.5146561861,
0.2006752491,
-0.0101723373,
-0.0455054939,
-0.6123822927,
0.2473854125,
-0.5197635889,
-0.4147169888,
0.4433937073,
0.593218863,
0.0225956645,
0.1864094883,
-0.5250137448,
0.3668116629,
-0.0230695866,
-0.4650495648,
0.1581757814,
0.5231018662,
0.3088083565,
0.710283339,
0.7020658255,
0.2445336282,
0.1691858768,
0.0987963602,
0.9208499193,
-0.9816220403,
-0.3806257546,
-1.132091403,
0.4690452516,
-0.0851457641,
-0.3544350564,
0.4228764474,
0.5574123263,
0.7083476186,
0.1356182396,
0.7625237107,
0.2780975699,
0.5777394176,
-0.6210421324,
0.4075591862,
-0.7275866866,
0.6159742475,
0.0004735109,
-0.9490751028,
-0.2253884673,
0.4965444505,
0.0423094556,
0.0669358894,
0.7946371436,
0.564011097,
-0.0021764175,
-0.3022150099,
0.2219620049,
0.3584333658,
0.4599655271,
0.2341218591,
0.8508610725,
-0.457364589,
0.3659508526,
-0.0693142414,
-0.0799249187,
-0.2722165585,
-0.7951913476,
-0.7753224373,
-0.6411568522,
-0.2377102822,
-0.1980009824,
0.1677170098,
1.0308778286,
0.6398816705,
-0.8334505558,
-0.3022404015,
0.1555643529,
0.0684506968,
-0.1671467572,
-0.1930433512,
0.4498026073,
-0.5619745255,
-0.7118911147,
0.4517682493,
0.2962021232,
0.2260845006,
-0.1430923939,
0.1889649332,
0.0055445926,
0.3249007165,
0.4324128628,
0.1916495413,
-0.7959387302,
-0.8377292156,
0.0257010031,
-0.2908889055,
0.1591789722,
0.8445556164,
-0.8029215932,
0.5343289375,
0.4764654934,
0.7915152907,
0.2441036999,
-0.0202900711,
0.9002674222,
-0.6836438179,
0.1074395776,
0.1719045937,
0.5616779923,
0.2401276976,
-0.0775854066,
0.0854256004,
0.1075958684,
-0.2135724872,
-0.9390619993,
0.0861984193,
-0.4206948578,
-0.3306064308,
1.0943077803,
-0.2576704919,
0.0910826847,
-0.0989564583,
-0.0427159108,
0.3760004342,
-0.5462139249,
0.8794022799,
0.9670211077,
0.0181426257,
-0.2787730992,
-0.2167310268,
0.3304244876,
0.6728065014,
-0.6074996591,
0.2208678722,
0.1224765703,
0.3622207642,
-0.0070082354,
0.6190546751,
-0.3536977172,
0.0068458337,
0.1588772684,
-0.1000782177,
-0.1485235095,
-0.3892291486,
-0.6424089074,
0.174400717,
0.2970513999,
-0.4248225987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15422v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15422v2
|
A Data-Centric Approach To Generate Faithful and High Quality Patient Summaries with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T16:32:28 | 2024-06-25T17:02:10 |
Stefan Hegselmann, Shannon Zejiang Shen, Florian Gierse, Monica Agrawal, David Sontag, Xiaoyi Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Patients often face difficulties in understanding their hospitalizations,
while healthcare workers have limited resources to provide explanations. In
this work, we investigate the potential of large language models to generate
patient summaries based on doctors' notes and study the effect of training data
on the faithfulness and quality of the generated summaries. To this end, we
release (i) a rigorous labeling protocol for errors in medical texts and (ii) a
publicly available dataset of annotated hallucinations in 100 doctor-written
and 100 generated summaries. We show that fine-tuning on hallucination-free
data effectively reduces hallucinations from 2.60 to 1.55 per summary for Llama
2, while preserving relevant information. We observe a similar effect on GPT-4
(0.70 to 0.40), when the few-shot examples are hallucination-free. We also
conduct a qualitative evaluation using hallucination-free and improved training
data. We find that common quantitative metrics do not correlate well with
faithfulness and quality. Finally, we test GPT-4 for automatic hallucination
detection, which clearly outperforms common baselines.
|
[
-0.1400359273,
-0.5520373583,
0.9215524793,
-0.0276275538,
-0.3591424227,
-0.4365098774,
-0.214806214,
-0.4727155864,
0.5796349645,
0.6245312095,
-0.1708149761,
-0.5704019666,
-0.7363005877,
0.377682656,
-0.6311837435,
1.3618257046,
-0.1437372267,
0.3754641116,
-0.0379832499,
-0.1616088897,
-0.2659829855,
-0.8332672715,
-0.2811920047,
-0.3408508897,
0.6312583089,
0.3086264431,
0.8287591934,
0.7320446372,
0.6595534086,
0.1824894696,
0.1760119796,
0.2920578718,
-0.5966446996,
0.2739965618,
-0.0528119504,
-0.3552351296,
-0.6476576328,
-0.0726687983,
0.5747247934,
0.8681570292,
-0.2691819966,
-0.2116477489,
-0.1025969014,
0.7596285939,
-0.0845862329,
0.1264232397,
-0.4481335878,
0.2892316282,
-0.0117292674,
-0.4117782116,
-0.4049890041,
-0.6000953913,
0.1535882801,
-0.6460720897,
0.5962926149,
-0.2691450119,
0.856556952,
0.3458153605,
0.0199724473,
-0.4891718924,
-0.4786589444,
0.4316963553,
-0.9076374173,
0.2518436015,
0.6250158548,
0.2341536582,
-0.1846919805,
-0.6536581516,
-0.4926398396,
-0.1734137535,
-0.3401249051,
0.2111392617,
0.2885618806,
0.1225409135,
0.4460677207,
0.4467669725,
-0.5642222166,
-0.0393549725,
-0.4679698944,
-0.1875667125,
0.749728322,
0.4374859929,
0.2249436378,
-0.087847501,
0.2134656906,
0.0721145794,
-0.6660961509,
-0.5694411993,
0.2971906364,
0.0494272001,
-0.0919837356,
0.8288371563,
-0.1702750474,
0.4906368554,
-0.0664348081,
-0.5731746554,
0.4028221369,
-0.2119540572,
-0.1831358671,
0.1987899542,
0.8847225308,
0.7486907244,
0.5001461506,
-0.5215991735,
-0.2905152142,
0.1894437075,
0.5212161541,
-0.9311800599,
-0.6360182166,
0.428489387,
-0.6079340577,
-0.4525632262,
-0.0497009419,
-0.7146086693,
-0.5440150499,
-0.5544043779,
0.2718139887,
-0.6609149575,
-0.1225563511,
0.1346229911,
-0.0423457734,
-0.0560522303,
0.5536904335,
-1.1152540445,
0.1992166191,
0.5526589155,
0.9237914681,
-0.2710182965,
-0.4870371819,
-0.5357486606,
0.2172593027,
-0.5207670331,
0.7828632593,
-0.0989885554,
-0.508202076,
-0.0341943018,
0.098665759,
-0.0122326426,
-0.8117402792,
0.2176997662,
0.1362400949,
0.3084353507,
-0.4513528645,
-0.6290122271,
-0.138186872,
0.0831378028,
-0.6424529552,
0.4776419699,
0.462623775,
-0.7943938971,
0.5216819048,
-0.1630236953,
-0.7082340121,
-0.0379453972,
-0.4773600399,
-0.6477761269,
0.4478061199,
0.2033188492,
0.5676236153,
0.1455326825,
0.5541825294,
0.0971306637,
-0.5685907602,
0.3728044033,
-0.1819399297,
0.4073261917,
0.0641092435,
-0.2973331809,
-0.0679169223,
-0.6386775374,
-0.3390208185,
0.1505878419,
-0.255474627,
-0.1498776972,
-0.0053768978,
-0.1207704619,
0.1327139586,
-0.2185574323,
-0.2014303803,
0.2323975414,
-0.4911628664,
0.0843717009,
0.4479667246,
0.2830685079,
0.0446720123,
-0.5925569534,
0.3358924091,
0.2706839442,
0.1725006402,
-0.3074426055,
-0.4394101501,
-0.6564378738,
-0.2101719826,
0.0331490599,
0.3565615416,
-0.7492194176,
0.3089923263,
-0.3786673546,
-0.254086256,
-0.6313678622,
-0.0702645332,
0.4450077713,
0.8877197504,
0.4732020497,
-0.5429596305,
-0.4948787391,
-0.8269782662,
-0.1364277154,
-0.2505214214,
-0.2134043276,
0.2260247022,
0.5888184905,
-0.3700594902,
0.5803214312,
-0.4716120958,
-0.5067985058,
-0.2611885965,
0.0315665416,
0.0061840829,
0.2915031016,
0.497232914,
-0.3567782938,
-0.2407060713,
-0.1097801104,
-1.258995533,
-0.0085748509,
-0.4607013166,
0.1151855439,
0.4245398939,
0.1462014765,
-0.5515444279,
0.4195128679,
0.2976806462,
-0.1733137816,
0.5979067683,
-0.4536883235,
0.2507258654,
-1.2299656868,
0.1082811132,
-0.0973632857,
-0.2912064493,
-0.7438197136,
-0.2823914587,
-0.1215499043,
0.0553242229,
-0.0340867229,
0.1423596889,
-0.1776337177,
-0.0203118101,
-0.2404584438,
0.1823476255,
0.026858801,
0.2951595187,
0.3428945839,
0.6002888083,
0.4202488661,
-0.3159502149,
0.0574155264,
0.526314795,
-0.1201172322,
0.5535796285,
-0.5741824508,
0.0752619207,
-0.3919373453,
0.1305076182,
-0.660508275,
-0.836411953,
0.1842690855,
-0.5593525767,
0.3340953887,
0.1229587197,
-0.570391953,
-0.1801914871,
-0.3454326987,
0.0245710146,
0.4663554728,
-0.2499109805,
0.1753148884,
0.4270751476,
-0.2779500484,
-0.3248973787,
-0.984349072,
0.2769422233,
-0.0336788669,
-0.1616812348,
-0.023403896,
0.0918316618,
-0.1787781566,
-0.1439335793,
0.029628098,
-0.1342933178,
-0.1201634929,
0.392740041,
0.1723715514,
-0.1038407385,
0.1627270877,
0.209693864,
-0.0913738087,
0.3646728992,
0.0272600856,
0.4744783342,
0.0620980598,
-0.3055413067,
-0.7371417284,
0.6103754044,
0.6745516658,
0.1498815417,
0.7537324429,
0.3711736798,
-0.5634103417,
-0.0329244733,
-0.652571857,
-0.5595012307,
-0.3368796408,
0.430147022,
-0.2294737548,
-0.5677298903,
0.5175561905,
0.3499420583,
0.1023864746,
0.3958833516,
0.7163913846,
-0.1250642091,
1.0935925245,
0.3138948977,
-0.0703069866,
0.0034011386,
-0.1025981382,
0.2417804897,
-0.6049087048,
-0.4393701553,
-0.300860554,
0.1370933205,
-0.531353116,
-0.1614976674,
0.4840757549,
-0.1169563383,
0.129479304,
0.0046945158,
-0.7841432691,
0.4247466922,
0.2691875994,
0.3270100057,
0.4448269308,
0.253572762,
0.3756063282,
-0.3134481907,
-0.4152343273,
-0.6637639999,
1.1932698488,
0.4079051018,
0.7538468242,
-0.0694126859,
0.8525010347,
0.0860937312,
0.3752232492,
-0.6811007261,
0.3110096455,
-0.1628581434,
-0.2630063593,
-0.3362582028,
-0.5709767342,
-0.6527838707,
0.1235601604,
-0.1052575633,
-0.4519414008,
-0.0316829346,
0.2009896785,
-0.3863310814,
0.2208757997,
-0.7280921936,
0.3834208846,
-0.2140912563,
-0.0793499574,
-0.0718691573,
-0.7187935114,
0.4880096316,
-0.3160103261,
-0.0643833354,
0.0857827961,
0.1764616668,
0.7140839696,
-0.6153925061,
0.7253754139,
-0.2100501359,
-0.2381057143,
0.0396599025,
0.1217772588,
0.4191899002,
0.2421594858,
-0.0110516753,
0.3672817945,
-0.0766265616,
-0.2464025319,
-0.5083850622,
0.5634235144,
-0.709508121,
-0.3661170006,
-0.3823308647,
-0.8470478654,
-0.2235878259,
0.089888148,
0.5490314364,
0.5241674185,
0.0401669666,
-0.122625187,
0.8461271524,
-0.4663066864,
-0.0337474272,
0.3262423575,
-0.1118747815,
-0.5569309592,
0.86526227,
0.4052209854,
0.190286994,
0.0326718055,
0.1195879802,
-0.2060595453,
-0.8047195077,
-0.5859271288,
0.7086268067,
-0.708871305,
-0.0497551747,
-1.0510804653,
-0.3253184855,
-0.4308219552,
-0.3023514748,
-0.1633283049,
-0.3213887513,
-0.3650918007,
-0.2322158068,
0.4627920389,
0.8936132789,
0.114925459,
0.1927722543,
-0.608682394,
0.6320989728,
0.018739881,
0.418415755,
-0.0684297383,
-0.5879356265,
-0.3745906651,
-0.0570902228,
-0.046759516,
-1.0194557905,
0.6173858047,
-0.0773162842,
0.300198704,
0.5901869535,
-0.2453207374,
0.7470346093,
-0.4537549913,
0.8517156243,
0.3622969687,
-0.6964206696,
0.6097495556,
-0.5444732308,
0.1738352329,
0.8883814216,
0.2569274902,
-0.5235751867,
-0.7623398304,
-0.5510442257,
-0.7653484941,
0.6911394596,
0.1653501242,
-0.025734188,
-0.1448268443,
0.6377204657,
0.4604774117,
0.2944900692,
-0.6135821939,
-0.1843719035,
-0.4072614312,
-0.3311389387,
-0.1488325149,
-0.4474835098,
-0.1984243542,
-0.363760829,
0.5503661036,
-0.0733257383,
0.2972904444,
0.5053488612,
-0.0977813751,
-0.1905656755,
-0.0969368964,
0.820630312,
0.8838792443,
-0.2629499733,
0.2524183393,
0.2000651956,
-0.8582359552,
-0.0468629524,
-0.016513871,
-0.274323374,
0.5271684527,
0.4835063517,
0.7195822001,
-0.2710785568,
-0.66277349,
0.6251552701,
-0.1112662256,
-0.4841518104,
-0.3279344738,
0.0682609603,
-0.051965367,
-0.1043903157,
0.031076299,
-0.226210326,
0.3300657868,
-0.452142477,
0.3704465926,
0.0222270824,
-0.3153562546,
-0.3996678293,
0.8010057807,
-0.2063092589,
-0.111881271,
0.7691913247,
-0.0209153667,
-0.2407027334,
0.3081605732,
0.6128932238,
0.7259371877,
-0.2997076213,
0.3543140292,
0.480601579,
0.3093751371,
-0.4681796134,
0.4245327413,
0.2097088993,
-0.2673196495,
-0.477311641,
-0.3255036473,
-0.5551709533,
0.3361800313,
-0.7023355961,
0.1043641716,
-0.3451576233,
0.0038748421,
0.0239813179,
-0.3021093309,
-0.2902465761,
0.3594264686,
0.0118869152,
0.3037197292,
-0.8808218241,
0.8447037339,
0.355553627,
-0.6102089882,
-0.9701397419,
0.0547128581,
-0.147743389,
-0.5791030526,
0.0812783763,
0.2583549619,
0.1543643326,
-0.3827886581,
-0.3346246779,
-0.3640561104,
0.8403871059,
0.4022918344,
-0.7355710864,
-0.1741136461,
0.4544191658,
0.8945479393,
-0.1981881559,
0.164550215,
0.726149857,
0.1941009462,
-0.1212203801,
-0.8717657328,
0.1588241458,
-0.1223091558,
-0.2526446879,
0.1861106604,
-0.2997957766,
0.8119750023,
-0.4347673953,
0.0284408461,
-0.0847098008,
0.3256253302,
0.2099131495,
0.4067615569,
0.2420497984,
0.5799743533,
1.0160522461,
-0.1551917344,
1.2363842726,
-0.1766368449,
0.1843007803,
1.1068253517,
-0.4046688974,
0.4037210941,
0.6597630978,
0.1623941958,
0.2442706972,
0.3157290518,
-0.154809922,
0.4787230194,
0.1790594906,
-0.14500238,
0.0543197133,
-0.0504172705,
-0.6089479923,
0.0543236136,
0.2901573479,
-0.8260005116,
-0.1430560052,
0.1510697901,
0.4019131064,
-0.0477522351,
-0.0772307068,
1.0919359922,
0.2436743677,
-0.8772439957,
0.8012937307,
-0.330085814,
0.2045077235,
-0.3744260669,
-0.1796105504,
-0.5133141875,
0.1059510708,
-0.5782809258,
-0.6432573199,
0.4910197854,
0.2405245006,
-0.3087297678,
-0.1057635397,
0.2668941021,
-0.5366157889,
-0.460311234,
-0.0931727737,
0.3977531493,
0.7122984529,
-0.0130288471,
-0.1845449507,
-0.0821625218,
0.1481741667,
-0.2389758974,
0.3349809349,
0.5539001822,
-0.1325556636,
0.3490275741,
0.3788385391,
0.5952997208,
-0.282749325,
0.4924207032,
0.8945959806,
-0.579212904,
-0.3738740087,
-0.8607372642,
0.3222296834,
-0.1330591589,
-0.3502399325,
0.6131973863,
0.7939445972,
0.5145487189,
-0.3076611161,
0.8881579638,
0.226895377,
0.6818867326,
-0.518545568,
1.0214216709,
-0.4784165919,
0.1143740788,
-0.3551742733,
-0.6895539165,
-0.5288962722,
0.6536632776,
-0.1699225157,
-0.1377892196,
0.8391005993,
0.8049167991,
-0.0088232048,
0.0046865446,
0.4316586554,
0.274951756,
0.3410175145,
0.6452895403,
0.5669130087,
-0.3627491295,
0.2070515752,
-0.4062770605,
-0.123350814,
-0.2923283875,
-0.4054206908,
-1.2097212076,
-0.4661801755,
-0.3730410635,
-0.6194893122,
0.1940063834,
0.716345787,
0.530431211,
-0.898011744,
0.1510634124,
-0.0665567368,
-0.2975873351,
-0.1148476228,
-0.1754498333,
0.7814260125,
-0.345528543,
-0.4454458654,
0.0578006357,
0.4066438377,
0.3150336146,
-0.1710527837,
-0.1930687726,
0.5609841943,
-0.0948052481,
0.5710023046,
-0.183034569,
-0.6908137202,
-0.1304309517,
0.001892412,
-0.3310806453,
0.3038576543,
0.8210828304,
-0.551225543,
0.5995043516,
0.2979826331,
0.4074679613,
0.4439095259,
0.1418692172,
0.4512322843,
-0.365878731,
0.0270234141,
0.512511611,
0.3126645684,
0.4675710499,
-0.6052239537,
0.56136024,
0.2416889071,
-0.5730668306,
-1.0184305906,
-0.1114087626,
-0.8821194768,
-0.1683647633,
1.1451178789,
-0.0639504939,
0.0002313686,
-0.2336321026,
-0.3140639365,
0.4041980803,
-0.2317495793,
1.3536818027,
0.593665719,
-0.2557756603,
0.0354694091,
-0.8764225841,
0.7584968805,
0.4544840157,
-1.1211234331,
0.2333357781,
0.8033835888,
0.2567081749,
-0.0211577248,
0.8722136021,
-0.4219267666,
0.4514874518,
-0.0113652479,
0.0614734776,
-0.1324964166,
-0.4806096852,
-0.4213816524,
0.2186056972,
-0.0262507126,
0.0777085274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15420v1
|
PREDILECT: Preferences Delineated with Zero-Shot Language-based Reasoning in Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-23T16:30:05 | 2024-02-23T16:30:05 |
Simon Holk, Daniel Marta, Iolanda Leite
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Preference-based reinforcement learning (RL) has emerged as a new field in
robot learning, where humans play a pivotal role in shaping robot behavior by
expressing preferences on different sequences of state-action pairs. However,
formulating realistic policies for robots demands responses from humans to an
extensive array of queries. In this work, we approach the sample-efficiency
challenge by expanding the information collected per query to contain both
preferences and optional text prompting. To accomplish this, we leverage the
zero-shot capabilities of a large language model (LLM) to reason from the text
provided by humans. To accommodate the additional query information, we
reformulate the reward learning objectives to contain flexible highlights --
state-action pairs that contain relatively high information and are related to
the features processed in a zero-shot fashion from a pretrained LLM. In both a
simulated scenario and a user study, we reveal the effectiveness of our work by
analyzing the feedback and its implications. Additionally, the collective
feedback collected serves to train a robot on socially compliant trajectories
in a simulated social navigation landscape. We provide video examples of the
trained policies at https://sites.google.com/view/rl-predilect
|
[
-0.2889690101,
-0.7175553441,
0.7555391192,
-0.2564620972,
-0.2092614174,
-0.0533348471,
-0.5661150217,
-0.0943646356,
0.4061133564,
0.7290415764,
-0.8031361103,
-0.6478236318,
-0.4696840048,
-0.0104748756,
0.0757122338,
1.2676208019,
0.0114964619,
-0.4636493027,
0.0211327281,
-0.1813758165,
-0.1306724548,
-0.6780725121,
-0.3658713102,
-0.5645696521,
1.0451245308,
0.8043035269,
0.6829512119,
0.3701937199,
-0.0053701615,
0.276142329,
0.164073512,
0.2222237885,
-0.7735576034,
0.1596012115,
-0.4722886086,
-0.5138674974,
-0.2352581024,
0.1680223197,
0.3084687889,
0.6514416337,
0.0274289008,
-0.088669695,
-0.0057736384,
0.7880670428,
-0.9103527069,
0.1468583643,
-0.5550287962,
0.0883397982,
0.0844300836,
-0.4222625494,
-0.5391860604,
-0.3552643359,
0.2968111634,
-0.9027884007,
-0.0286687911,
-0.1993385404,
1.0714088678,
0.455529213,
-0.3940382302,
-0.1081015617,
-0.7855837941,
0.9510316849,
-0.20444718,
0.4074620605,
0.6403782368,
0.2530879676,
-0.2456852347,
-0.2203365713,
-0.6770008206,
-0.3955203891,
0.055675,
0.2191036791,
0.1384307891,
0.3475953639,
0.2267435342,
-0.0772881284,
-0.6319959164,
0.0768985152,
-0.2755045295,
-0.2142537236,
0.7075765729,
-0.1226502582,
-0.050797198,
-0.1583563834,
-0.2720181942,
-0.713958621,
-0.7029138803,
0.5258710384,
0.5371592641,
0.4363876283,
-0.1618908793,
0.6726698279,
-0.5923813581,
0.6435360312,
0.1379670203,
0.0886577517,
0.4849416912,
-0.0388091616,
-0.1743835658,
-0.1411935091,
0.7835416794,
0.5034406185,
0.5183303356,
-0.2000615001,
-0.133650437,
-0.0035893917,
0.3134271502,
-0.7415420413,
-0.4070061445,
0.3027171791,
-0.2925525606,
-0.1781259775,
-0.1113835126,
-0.4840636253,
-0.3294604123,
-0.3967494071,
0.5549637079,
-0.3195295334,
-0.2720011771,
0.5351846218,
-0.2601738274,
0.3322057426,
0.5454437137,
-0.8592524529,
-0.0103879338,
0.4333087206,
0.5134170651,
-0.0932849348,
-0.3565067351,
-0.558935523,
-0.0194480885,
-0.2783529758,
0.9168992639,
-0.4751297832,
-0.5638175607,
0.0221306346,
-0.0317604207,
-0.0065412424,
-0.3235658705,
0.3809433281,
-0.572434783,
0.356947422,
-0.2602679729,
-0.4928454459,
-0.2501941621,
0.6124534607,
-0.5365694165,
0.4886759222,
0.2284623235,
-0.3241468966,
0.7522860765,
-0.8734503984,
-0.4886153638,
0.1075986996,
-0.2340786755,
-0.168220222,
-0.271227926,
-0.0129306214,
0.4907987118,
0.3792507946,
0.113408111,
-0.5028552413,
-0.2621645033,
0.1348385066,
-0.3365882635,
0.4407272637,
0.1019840389,
-0.2190172821,
0.6849992871,
-0.475353688,
0.11072772,
0.0883337557,
-0.3929472268,
-0.3062576056,
0.2169064134,
-0.3623596728,
0.1618221849,
0.4085719883,
-0.3381106853,
0.2256987542,
-0.3365888596,
0.0588419586,
0.8796139359,
-0.0396316461,
0.7917109132,
-0.1936638504,
0.6630755663,
-0.2311465442,
0.3982554674,
-0.2273008674,
0.0157824568,
-0.6476791501,
-0.1880102754,
0.0115909586,
0.4157601893,
-0.9344483614,
0.4971007705,
0.0648044869,
-0.3098358214,
-0.1085398719,
-0.0179529469,
0.3639617562,
0.5191133618,
0.5383315682,
-0.1644789726,
-0.2702792585,
-0.6718984842,
0.0553916618,
-0.3224267662,
-0.0747346878,
0.7668130994,
0.3214137554,
-0.081586048,
0.9446423054,
-0.7363441586,
-0.0145405075,
-0.6563259363,
0.0024958365,
0.146812588,
0.0913018361,
0.5098432899,
-0.7673699856,
-0.3059888482,
-0.3141202331,
-0.5205123425,
0.1737801284,
-0.0885878876,
-0.4613376856,
0.2485765815,
0.3701747358,
-0.4730554223,
0.4665940404,
0.246529907,
-0.3182804883,
0.5522196889,
-0.4880014658,
0.1277866066,
-0.6131280661,
0.0304468218,
0.156176731,
-0.2732839882,
-0.4213252366,
-0.097140342,
-0.1491417438,
0.1605935395,
-0.5764806867,
0.668795526,
-0.0114012444,
0.0519769229,
-0.3891043067,
0.2727550268,
-0.0100538479,
0.7419468164,
0.6874895096,
0.5354709625,
0.2537800074,
-0.9495491982,
0.0752965659,
0.0434144512,
0.0777876303,
0.3319734037,
-0.7179392576,
0.0075200759,
-0.1447563916,
0.4596429467,
-0.7506154776,
-0.3374801278,
0.4801598191,
-0.5636665225,
-0.1356848031,
-0.0908580646,
-0.2409284562,
-0.1794688553,
-0.4590222538,
0.2069254965,
0.469976902,
-0.5055183172,
0.3563183248,
0.4565432668,
0.2684499323,
-0.7515641451,
0.0485794581,
-0.3814329207,
-0.1478612423,
-0.2703948915,
0.1443968117,
-0.1626057327,
-0.0759435892,
-0.0479018614,
0.0280891396,
-0.0468420573,
0.41466254,
0.22583808,
0.4586103559,
0.1784920394,
0.2126924545,
-0.0186741743,
-0.1224327236,
-0.151887536,
-0.1971724182,
0.8492760062,
-0.0165052693,
-0.1924115568,
-0.2518069148,
0.1610476077,
0.1823059469,
-0.165266484,
0.4772929251,
0.1715202481,
0.185021162,
-0.4494717717,
-0.0382271223,
-0.5193548799,
-0.4668248296,
0.3068812788,
-0.202276662,
-1.170822382,
0.141794309,
-0.1005806625,
0.1243415922,
0.1283971071,
0.4028177857,
-0.2465261519,
0.7364432216,
0.6417790651,
0.1121667475,
0.6688332558,
-0.2732572854,
0.0645818785,
-0.3144953251,
-0.3438221216,
-0.3954104483,
-0.2632792592,
-0.5221707821,
-0.4666839838,
0.310002178,
-0.0304673966,
-0.5382855535,
0.3299798965,
-0.3664279282,
0.6531698704,
0.7693912983,
0.2817406654,
-0.0190274324,
-0.1580426544,
-0.1797362119,
0.2356663942,
-0.5349677205,
-0.475577265,
1.255479455,
-0.0411572829,
0.6874708533,
-0.0764668807,
1.0313463211,
0.2174599767,
-0.0861890614,
-1.126755476,
0.7556524873,
-0.1170320362,
-0.4493858516,
-0.5719305873,
-0.4059366882,
-1.2478574514,
0.1870364547,
-0.4661797881,
-0.6341015697,
-0.0732024834,
0.504134655,
-0.5591094494,
0.0666681528,
-0.6035429835,
1.0049574375,
-0.5352203846,
-0.5860353112,
-0.3948269188,
-0.8326653838,
0.190817073,
0.3758018315,
-0.1428261548,
-0.2137791663,
0.2244968861,
0.5210068226,
-0.238939032,
0.7346470952,
-0.4106941223,
0.1800089926,
0.1172564179,
-0.0199591257,
0.2371096909,
-0.2383927256,
0.1422789842,
-0.0037998029,
-0.1610713005,
-0.2937656939,
-0.6560828686,
0.1771154255,
-0.8982720971,
-0.5237650871,
-0.4190049767,
-0.4202792645,
-0.2407678068,
0.1603811085,
-0.0561433621,
0.1564206183,
-0.16134049,
0.2348338962,
0.7567258477,
-0.5614282489,
0.2781319618,
0.7781335115,
-0.3952039778,
0.0771792457,
0.9414867163,
-0.0624415539,
0.2905232906,
0.6453695893,
0.2871253192,
-0.6719639301,
-0.3513799906,
-0.3881362379,
0.1527573019,
-0.3217006326,
0.2077738792,
-0.4647066891,
-0.0216057226,
-0.1914710402,
-0.3885586858,
-0.4155060947,
-0.3236813545,
-0.2538302839,
-0.1038327739,
0.3491107821,
0.528790772,
-0.2719779909,
0.3665995598,
-0.6478607059,
0.4352769256,
0.3389361799,
0.3281918466,
-0.2961419225,
-0.396412164,
-0.0881187245,
0.0039804089,
-0.1115661711,
-0.6329453588,
0.3007952571,
-0.184444204,
0.6784561276,
0.5469010472,
0.4508368075,
0.3694427907,
-0.543771565,
0.7239136696,
0.1937184632,
-0.5915231109,
0.8585606813,
-0.398768127,
0.1478554904,
0.923961103,
0.6755498648,
-0.4579415321,
0.0158103947,
-0.7221801281,
-1.073474288,
0.72419101,
-0.2263469696,
0.023760682,
-0.1148785576,
0.33398664,
0.1174212322,
0.2144313902,
-0.649770081,
-0.2329801023,
-0.3422491252,
-0.0977181569,
-0.2563279867,
-0.0297376476,
-0.123221159,
-0.0485319272,
0.4544907808,
-0.2977107465,
-0.1374204755,
0.1028193831,
-0.1702144742,
0.3084669113,
0.4973836839,
0.6303994656,
0.3176291883,
-0.5200338364,
0.0439614505,
-0.2751280367,
-0.0958775356,
0.2659138441,
-0.1742876321,
-0.3318621516,
-0.3723096251,
-0.0882532075,
0.8211866021,
0.1199763119,
-0.8480080962,
0.6066859365,
-0.1996239126,
-0.38831231,
-0.2686827183,
0.5538158417,
-0.3404360414,
0.2300754339,
0.1026784927,
-0.0591289178,
0.0688987449,
-0.5671467781,
0.3481696546,
0.5154044032,
-0.5715728998,
-0.2947382927,
0.2832683027,
0.4475131929,
-0.3555828631,
0.3695751131,
-0.6315299869,
-0.6132671237,
0.3678742349,
0.0902380645,
0.6771258712,
0.0961955413,
0.824254334,
0.4605399072,
0.0726427138,
-0.1854346842,
0.1721716374,
-0.7065639496,
-1.1491596699,
-0.577624619,
-0.357645005,
-0.778393209,
0.1261947453,
-0.5525226593,
0.1703700572,
-0.5964654684,
-0.0337383933,
-0.3136044145,
0.0036309187,
-0.4839984179,
0.1372739822,
0.0784579143,
0.4593876004,
-0.7824325562,
0.9424522519,
0.6492936611,
-0.6351155639,
-1.1101154089,
0.0565337837,
-0.0660069063,
-0.8809846044,
0.986766994,
0.0581182092,
-0.6252883077,
-0.4090913236,
-0.7421664596,
-0.4276662767,
0.7012858987,
0.2881165147,
-0.4352068305,
0.0898444355,
-0.1644059867,
0.321503073,
-0.1881869882,
0.4720389545,
0.4053772688,
0.389254272,
0.2988064289,
-0.7433081269,
-0.2097890079,
-0.0306250807,
-0.4680006206,
0.0851895362,
-0.6802451015,
0.6987652183,
-0.3284556866,
-0.10942173,
-0.3771855831,
0.5011920333,
0.678648591,
0.356990248,
0.8446940184,
0.3466979563,
0.8531038165,
0.2172262818,
1.0967546701,
-0.2226446271,
0.1318613291,
1.2484660149,
-0.5881243944,
1.0831871033,
0.2910900116,
-0.0216571074,
0.6434511542,
0.6610488892,
0.4782690406,
0.66660887,
0.1921221465,
-0.3300170302,
-0.6997663379,
-0.2814432979,
-0.0789719597,
0.5940071344,
0.227077648,
-0.0122713558,
-0.3220720291,
-0.213456437,
0.1644327939,
0.3383948505,
-0.2855007648,
0.7737779617,
-0.3233868778,
-0.950021565,
0.237989068,
-0.3422988355,
0.9632689357,
-0.7369834781,
-0.1997687519,
-0.1105487794,
0.2574260533,
-0.051106561,
-0.9914805889,
-0.0144495368,
-0.0561108552,
-0.3437416255,
-0.3755965829,
0.5471282601,
-0.4553225935,
0.0583031438,
0.4530635178,
0.4837177396,
0.3715697825,
-0.0803525299,
-0.6929029822,
-0.2163199484,
0.2731445134,
-0.1103621274,
0.4734983444,
0.3336366117,
0.0164242703,
0.6199541092,
0.7367944121,
0.2380677164,
-0.2567108274,
0.2431226075,
0.791503489,
-0.6802561879,
-0.4798795879,
-0.7390460968,
0.4210791588,
-0.2727296352,
-0.2571602464,
0.665157795,
0.4555453062,
1.1829890013,
0.0177415274,
0.8182373643,
0.086213626,
0.6309295297,
-0.5347864032,
0.5836787224,
-0.6447551847,
0.0447257981,
0.0066828388,
-0.5479357839,
-0.2113671452,
0.9676566124,
-0.534974277,
0.1139419824,
0.4355810881,
0.7817591429,
0.187229991,
-0.3235834241,
0.4989939332,
-0.2293620259,
0.3474096358,
0.6676845551,
0.8418868184,
0.2765991986,
0.6020806432,
-0.1735803634,
-0.2796015143,
-0.2991068363,
-0.8687428832,
-0.8657636642,
-0.4347272813,
-0.1323447675,
-0.2506692708,
0.1806099117,
1.4031469822,
0.8311837316,
-0.45594576,
-0.4033015668,
-0.0457873642,
0.4277888834,
0.2103291452,
-0.2325259894,
0.2233479768,
-0.5012196302,
-0.5503035784,
0.4756982028,
0.3496596813,
-0.161487624,
-0.1687936038,
-0.4628086984,
-0.2048320025,
-0.0118884072,
0.7603091598,
0.7657120824,
-0.4647274911,
-0.4874260724,
0.1366700828,
0.0694063976,
0.0318738222,
0.7795980573,
-0.9607604146,
0.4824418724,
0.4776655734,
0.5219708085,
0.6362378001,
0.0559619218,
0.5935512781,
-0.6000275016,
0.3125318885,
0.3090925217,
0.1535838246,
0.1215913296,
-0.0640986711,
0.3174792528,
0.1285208464,
-0.6575169563,
-0.4064376056,
0.4408584833,
-1.1395295858,
-0.4817506075,
1.315402627,
-0.2324503511,
-0.4388192296,
-0.2075316608,
-0.2466479689,
0.0904260203,
-0.9370414615,
0.6255995631,
0.4016177654,
-0.4396234751,
-0.2952618003,
-0.3281830251,
0.637871325,
0.423312366,
-0.8244324923,
-0.0589700118,
0.8009785414,
0.1230711043,
0.0128616123,
0.9858733416,
0.1746139824,
0.3163265288,
-0.3353389204,
0.3413334191,
0.0058681555,
-0.6258035898,
-0.2644217312,
0.2623901665,
0.2692747414,
-0.3485377729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15400v1
|
Faithful Temporal Question Answering over Heterogeneous Sources
| 2024-02-23T16:03:17 | 2024-02-23T16:03:17 |
Zhen Jia, Philipp Christmann, Gerhard Weikum
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Temporal question answering (QA) involves time constraints, with phrases such
as "... in 2019" or "... before COVID". In the former, time is an explicit
condition, in the latter it is implicit. State-of-the-art methods have
limitations along three dimensions. First, with neural inference, time
constraints are merely soft-matched, giving room to invalid or inexplicable
answers. Second, questions with implicit time are poorly supported. Third,
answers come from a single source: either a knowledge base (KB) or a text
corpus. We propose a temporal QA system that addresses these shortcomings.
First, it enforces temporal constraints for faithful answering with tangible
evidence. Second, it properly handles implicit questions. Third, it operates
over heterogeneous sources, covering KB, text and web tables in a unified
manner. The method has three stages: (i) understanding the question and its
temporal conditions, (ii) retrieving evidence from all sources, and (iii)
faithfully answering the question. As implicit questions are sparse in prior
benchmarks, we introduce a principled method for generating diverse questions.
Experiments show superior performance over a suite of baselines.
|
[
-0.1461784393,
-1.0882498026,
1.0471282005,
0.7272337675,
-0.2221058011,
0.0516759939,
0.2028173059,
-0.5981631875,
0.0074370089,
-0.0314270481,
-0.9281149507,
-0.3055179119,
-0.0849161372,
0.2133220881,
-0.1881281137,
0.9035617709,
-0.1847498417,
0.1105944589,
-0.3770614862,
-0.4188809991,
-0.3772387207,
-0.5137486458,
-0.500428021,
-0.3419666588,
0.5353357196,
0.2773726881,
0.7832820415,
0.5891097188,
0.1415306181,
0.2195456177,
0.0757964179,
0.2876622975,
-0.1977687925,
0.3347502351,
-0.2191993147,
-0.3010235131,
-0.1293496341,
0.0222178232,
0.4512143433,
0.8617212772,
-0.1036859155,
0.4644612372,
-0.3452369273,
0.0282789599,
-0.8305028677,
-0.1755319536,
-0.7059671879,
0.3302658498,
-0.0320507921,
-0.5324584842,
-0.1680725962,
-0.7711452842,
0.2571092248,
-0.8927824497,
0.2734937668,
-0.2748178244,
1.1423197985,
0.4384418428,
-0.4534838498,
-0.0165764615,
-1.0639431477,
0.618308723,
-0.4337395728,
0.2366874069,
0.4071181118,
0.5773342252,
0.141572088,
-0.8897787929,
-0.6428669691,
-0.0047028265,
0.1190356314,
0.118441537,
-0.0295495223,
-0.5019187927,
0.2569857836,
0.0133256242,
-0.6705399156,
-0.2577191591,
-0.0489219166,
-0.2911122143,
0.2358466089,
0.3812999725,
0.4079895318,
-0.0668759122,
-0.3292988241,
0.1892271787,
-0.4121452272,
0.0350331292,
0.2007451206,
-0.0954409689,
0.2077927291,
0.5851586461,
-0.2848295867,
0.3933499753,
0.3311946392,
0.1182954684,
-0.1756727844,
-0.5014737844,
0.0427015908,
-0.0237765796,
0.3984045982,
0.0999165028,
-0.0263621006,
-0.5335652828,
0.2065993696,
0.2177419662,
0.1456602216,
-0.7532884479,
0.1107628345,
0.6212351918,
-0.1059643254,
0.113639906,
-0.2542611361,
-0.8410393,
-0.0329014957,
-0.2244719565,
0.6159689426,
-0.3706664145,
-0.09455809,
-0.1779495925,
-0.3696047962,
0.369674027,
0.460016489,
-0.4265869558,
0.3923056722,
0.4795351028,
0.5068662763,
0.1946455389,
-0.1703847051,
-0.94298172,
0.3869391978,
-0.3230743408,
0.7169638276,
-0.6245735884,
-0.1070941612,
-0.0344021656,
-0.0773540661,
0.0841333419,
-0.2021175176,
0.194997564,
-1.1148227453,
0.7012047768,
-0.3714726865,
-0.3978406489,
0.3025794625,
0.4297313392,
-0.437672168,
0.8481738567,
0.0908748507,
-0.5547602177,
0.2523395717,
-0.3016995788,
-0.2154817581,
-0.0944935977,
-0.3732435405,
-0.2239937186,
-0.2440966815,
0.5606489778,
0.237072736,
-0.1344274879,
0.391574502,
-0.3991727531,
-0.2320526689,
0.2143800557,
-0.4772239923,
0.7954155803,
0.4385189712,
-0.4218070209,
-0.4150563478,
-0.658217907,
0.3435346782,
0.1653036326,
-0.2072441429,
-0.3635178208,
0.1821191609,
0.0174318925,
0.1595779657,
0.5124726892,
-0.8186584115,
0.1557271481,
-0.0764229819,
0.3998731971,
0.6411576271,
0.3408985734,
0.3874459863,
-0.2581355572,
0.4736187756,
-0.0502101593,
0.5075293183,
0.1444939226,
-0.4258189797,
-0.2677330673,
0.266864866,
-0.0197014585,
0.6974934936,
-0.936645031,
-0.1042643711,
-0.4053710997,
-0.4113045633,
-0.1348564476,
-0.1300035566,
0.3924854696,
0.6005398631,
0.6571729183,
0.1729881316,
-0.4209691286,
-0.7321394682,
-0.1862202287,
-0.4613146484,
-0.1830723733,
0.3879647553,
0.3859760761,
0.0735791177,
1.0566912889,
-0.6795148849,
0.2378881276,
0.3252701163,
0.4572794139,
0.0908366516,
0.3451904356,
0.4105168581,
-1.0118198395,
-0.1793502569,
-0.0943012238,
-1.0114974976,
-0.1230794564,
-0.2657187879,
-0.1066537797,
0.1365413219,
0.6284033656,
-0.3911204338,
0.2086360157,
0.5473762155,
-0.705059886,
0.3226823211,
0.0404685661,
0.2068279982,
-1.0038205385,
0.110261187,
-0.33056584,
-0.1733107269,
-0.4441078901,
-0.1132927835,
0.0383451469,
-0.2669797838,
-0.4382228255,
0.769867897,
-0.1969668567,
0.1771495938,
0.1075759679,
-0.1139435768,
0.3190329373,
0.5472462177,
0.0556008816,
0.6984107494,
-0.179191798,
-0.6537714005,
0.0160525348,
0.3282715082,
0.0231805481,
0.5989647508,
-0.9518608451,
0.443479687,
-0.2756199241,
0.1982504278,
-0.5608666539,
-0.1524443626,
0.2034998536,
-0.5372482538,
0.0452297255,
-0.3128115833,
-0.2100821286,
-0.1508502662,
0.036639519,
0.6925555468,
0.3449693024,
-0.5505245924,
1.0400730371,
-0.0842949077,
-0.3204728365,
-0.9666007161,
-0.5230926275,
0.0315743275,
0.1156927273,
-0.7806175947,
0.5781282783,
-0.2844503224,
-0.4834893942,
0.555382967,
-0.614821136,
-0.6926468611,
0.0451235436,
0.0713774934,
0.284450978,
-0.3974555135,
0.1494891942,
0.152288422,
0.2879803479,
0.0392942466,
-0.4339616597,
0.3887887001,
-0.0874765515,
-0.4452107847,
-0.3086598516,
0.7221648693,
0.6131826043,
-0.1878620833,
0.5453840494,
0.7001332045,
-0.5317440033,
-0.0224175341,
-0.7957670093,
-0.1467982829,
-0.4155571163,
-0.0254750401,
-0.3338490725,
-1.0230680704,
0.6178239584,
0.4995555282,
0.2515986264,
0.4946771264,
0.4463748634,
-0.3054387867,
0.96560812,
0.2990309298,
0.1424415559,
0.3723497689,
0.1931156069,
-0.33337152,
-0.2676360905,
-0.5738047361,
-0.7629056573,
0.0067629809,
-0.2515643537,
-0.2861139178,
0.6437985897,
0.0838917717,
-0.5189589262,
-0.1132803857,
-0.2033472061,
0.2433438599,
0.6008460522,
0.3448500335,
0.3074736893,
-0.2475196868,
0.0784465298,
0.1276616752,
-0.8568295836,
-0.469791472,
0.9020203948,
0.2547655106,
0.6205313802,
0.3338092268,
0.3221360147,
0.2207177132,
0.1530468017,
-0.0635360703,
0.3171077371,
0.0955746919,
-1.0418730974,
-0.5636551976,
-0.5816750526,
-1.0263935328,
0.0157223362,
-0.2697178423,
-0.4702270925,
0.5072408319,
0.1444426626,
-0.8164054155,
0.1351834387,
-0.7245032191,
0.7338199019,
-0.1756924391,
-0.7548556328,
0.0485727601,
-0.9035915732,
0.1586852372,
0.1625075638,
-0.2341698855,
-0.3748984337,
-0.2031273246,
0.6774525046,
-0.6092834473,
0.5723109245,
-0.300298214,
0.2494838834,
0.4126006961,
0.1499754637,
0.4690458179,
0.7002263069,
0.1367966235,
-0.1078703478,
0.7614715695,
-0.9211437702,
-0.9100950956,
0.5302606821,
-0.9715248942,
-0.5656198859,
-0.6462666392,
-0.6230126023,
-0.6219902635,
-0.0168692674,
0.125097692,
0.6417050958,
-0.4303338826,
-0.0338501558,
0.8958343863,
-0.3481664956,
0.423203975,
0.8585560322,
0.1087671816,
-0.1549579501,
0.5484316945,
-0.0310098995,
0.1565670371,
0.6664666533,
0.3186268508,
-0.5265971422,
-0.4561991096,
-0.4223741591,
0.1437191814,
-0.5257988572,
-0.0578166693,
-0.974522531,
-0.2053144127,
-0.6533461809,
0.1122709587,
-0.2314124852,
-0.5185223818,
-0.3487647772,
0.3002983928,
0.3569679558,
0.2753513753,
0.0515404604,
-0.2921037376,
-1.0442461967,
0.9365628362,
1.1689844131,
0.3127376139,
-0.3863097429,
-0.2342659533,
0.1526524872,
-0.0131581128,
0.054415822,
-0.8968257904,
0.0254493188,
0.1356379688,
0.601808548,
0.086403653,
0.1476769745,
0.6761628389,
-0.659090817,
0.9152787924,
-0.1342393607,
-0.778421402,
0.6124799252,
-0.4640816748,
0.6178790331,
0.7127500176,
0.5619677305,
-0.5745878816,
-0.4004742801,
-0.6300175786,
-0.6330475807,
0.3751958311,
0.3500427306,
0.0738457367,
-0.1109762415,
0.5354893804,
0.1438308805,
0.1307432055,
-0.4149774313,
-0.2149029225,
-0.6026440263,
-0.0105290553,
0.1782446355,
-0.2501885891,
-0.3379906118,
-0.1161493734,
0.5157150626,
-0.2403091341,
0.3975050151,
0.6529441476,
-0.1701741666,
-0.2243618518,
0.5822249651,
0.5050499439,
0.9292892814,
-0.4676690996,
0.1646837443,
0.2225070894,
-0.5201389194,
0.4057810307,
0.4305586219,
-0.4547807574,
0.0947044641,
0.3710274994,
0.2986902595,
-0.2366197705,
-0.4157329202,
0.4030333757,
-0.3500522077,
0.0013732983,
-0.465654552,
-0.2623052299,
-0.0643979758,
0.4481617808,
0.6519877315,
-0.1107880697,
-0.0965744704,
-0.7164970636,
0.1578026116,
0.228645578,
-0.4523538947,
-0.2473139316,
0.9227167964,
0.0974693596,
0.1004162803,
0.7409387231,
0.0227669701,
-0.3300088346,
0.807010591,
0.3208626807,
0.641136229,
-0.1495783627,
0.3999400735,
0.1859309375,
0.2800043821,
0.0114842877,
0.8197556138,
0.1075631902,
-0.6934015751,
-0.7366832495,
-0.5561856627,
-0.5151955485,
0.1922147423,
-0.6079902649,
-0.4120907187,
-0.6464403272,
-0.0716057569,
0.02218863,
0.0586825721,
-0.8821541667,
0.4520445168,
0.0117768049,
0.9601027966,
-0.7431051135,
0.4634944499,
0.5657916069,
-0.6592807174,
-0.8145779371,
0.0425236635,
-0.2014734596,
-0.7539941669,
0.5783078074,
-0.4581788182,
-0.0214328226,
-0.0879110172,
-0.8153333664,
-0.7064228654,
1.1048464775,
0.46684286,
-0.0811877474,
-0.3110120893,
0.0500251912,
0.6847894788,
0.1710513383,
0.0754728392,
0.3307345808,
0.6342574358,
-0.0308425948,
-0.6454405785,
0.0985551924,
-0.6499948502,
-0.3304297626,
-0.0593401529,
-0.4550407827,
0.8169618845,
-0.0433018953,
-0.4530968368,
0.3177464008,
1.0010379553,
0.1255508661,
0.8297940493,
0.56664294,
0.4838241339,
0.7378019094,
-0.292717278,
1.1598372459,
0.0633530468,
-0.0877194405,
1.3517690897,
-0.1770085692,
0.4802316129,
0.7636423111,
-0.1261693984,
0.7097774744,
0.6208053827,
0.2068268061,
0.3354906142,
-0.1263808608,
-0.3735951483,
-0.628177762,
-0.4879980981,
-0.6979096532,
0.2075276971,
0.0555381626,
0.1277461946,
-0.4038498998,
-0.2177155316,
0.0034861411,
0.274707824,
-0.2559568584,
0.5102882385,
-0.1992208511,
-0.9310609102,
0.1705032587,
-0.1671935171,
0.1170605794,
-0.8565106392,
-0.1432838142,
-0.5036844611,
-0.1947216541,
0.0344412848,
-0.7328136563,
0.2467796952,
-0.0415199474,
-0.4299874008,
-0.1840027273,
0.391417712,
-0.3252613544,
-0.3286816478,
-0.0819627345,
1.0166370869,
-0.2924686372,
-0.1897907257,
-0.4478835464,
-0.2950309813,
-0.5492702723,
-0.1504487246,
-0.005822232,
0.7270923853,
-0.2590790391,
0.7904836535,
0.4528109133,
-0.0102400174,
0.3700183332,
-0.0400737822,
0.6979148984,
-0.5018602014,
-0.5178614259,
-0.4415075183,
0.146399349,
-0.1103512496,
-0.3730170429,
0.766589582,
0.3174663782,
0.4934641123,
0.1764087528,
0.5833237171,
-0.1567919999,
0.4385575652,
-0.6699746251,
0.3287613988,
-0.7782529593,
0.0951209143,
-0.1962553859,
-0.7691357732,
-0.081030719,
-0.1150624529,
-0.197306484,
-0.0530319251,
0.9346328378,
0.4888299704,
0.1120423451,
0.186400637,
0.0312172007,
0.0144518623,
0.228902936,
0.9463136196,
1.2478952408,
-0.2872041166,
0.9742071033,
-0.4093815982,
0.160443902,
0.0405981094,
-0.8218163848,
-0.5950286984,
-0.5761291385,
-0.3365858495,
-0.6691370606,
0.5037706494,
0.9314103723,
0.5877307057,
-0.7856681943,
0.3293737173,
0.2837694883,
0.1162765548,
-0.4491517246,
-0.1793841869,
0.5122437477,
-0.2539967597,
-0.6805405021,
0.4072772861,
0.04908612,
0.0236207824,
-0.138091743,
0.1615096182,
-0.4661108553,
0.1229863167,
0.4449930787,
0.7228639126,
-0.3433107734,
-0.701280117,
0.4927057028,
-0.2576193511,
-0.1266169399,
0.9059599638,
-0.77827847,
0.277539283,
0.6309680343,
0.9694529772,
0.648175776,
0.112756975,
0.7234836817,
-0.8262481689,
-0.1984514147,
0.7758055329,
0.0282219499,
0.0089124255,
-0.5088039637,
0.4999899268,
0.3471279144,
-0.3974738717,
-0.463375479,
0.2172121257,
-1.2315000296,
-0.72816962,
1.1437244415,
0.0622796789,
-0.2304717153,
-0.7580271959,
0.3319578469,
0.442309916,
-0.2133169174,
0.8919300437,
0.5634893179,
-0.0701440722,
0.1702671945,
-0.3868959248,
0.3256461918,
0.6354456544,
-0.9321433306,
-0.4654230773,
0.7119669318,
0.4531774223,
0.2783987224,
0.8707998991,
-0.3165414631,
0.7847054601,
0.0204889737,
-0.2878326178,
-0.2853431702,
-0.5209236145,
-0.1074816883,
0.7478231788,
-0.2149671912,
-0.1284440905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15390v2
|
Explorations of Self-Repair in Language Models
| 2024-02-23T15:42:12 | 2024-05-26T20:47:41 |
Cody Rushing, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prior interpretability research studying narrow distributions has
preliminarily identified self-repair, a phenomena where if components in large
language models are ablated, later components will change their behavior to
compensate. Our work builds off this past literature, demonstrating that
self-repair exists on a variety of models families and sizes when ablating
individual attention heads on the full training distribution. We further show
that on the full training distribution self-repair is imperfect, as the
original direct effect of the head is not fully restored, and noisy, since the
degree of self-repair varies significantly across different prompts (sometimes
overcorrecting beyond the original effect). We highlight two different
mechanisms that contribute to self-repair, including changes in the final
LayerNorm scaling factor and sparse sets of neurons implementing Anti-Erasure.
We additionally discuss the implications of these results for interpretability
practitioners and close with a more speculative discussion on the mystery of
why self-repair occurs in these models at all, highlighting evidence for the
Iterative Inference hypothesis in language models, a framework that predicts
self-repair.
|
[
-0.0111425621,
-0.6371120811,
0.7312324047,
0.2440809458,
0.2717860043,
-0.271868974,
-0.3112978637,
-0.5360574722,
0.4814361036,
0.6940628886,
-0.6976149082,
0.2745137811,
-0.5334194899,
0.1352666467,
-0.6718105674,
1.1230708361,
-0.0371198058,
-0.2606261373,
-0.202551499,
-0.3371920586,
-0.4028793275,
-0.4571375549,
-0.9089269042,
-0.2011575252,
0.6421762109,
0.4870382547,
0.5363308191,
1.0973249674,
0.3582164943,
0.4468493164,
-0.0116500212,
-0.4663980901,
-0.6044980288,
0.3569005132,
-0.4933961332,
-0.5674037337,
-0.5858227611,
-0.0165592972,
0.793153882,
0.8526839614,
-0.2532176077,
-0.0523995645,
0.3376803398,
0.8529407382,
-0.5322508216,
-0.0678839311,
-0.5236099958,
-0.1822696775,
-0.1244378537,
-0.1226328909,
-0.3454015553,
0.270391047,
0.1046441421,
-0.2486182153,
0.6018909812,
-0.0446440093,
0.1852035224,
0.6141995788,
-0.114970766,
-0.1843490899,
-0.9362381101,
0.7795114517,
-0.8278084993,
0.234874174,
0.5342198014,
0.2314814031,
-0.0461933948,
-0.629748702,
-0.3007128835,
0.0576395355,
-0.1184845269,
0.0588867739,
-0.2995489538,
0.0692317337,
0.3119708598,
0.6951152682,
-0.4860340655,
0.1630256325,
-0.5053883195,
-0.2037589997,
0.4367191494,
0.2324988544,
0.4253247976,
0.0349622406,
-0.1574198902,
0.1358626187,
-0.6478956342,
-0.1732520163,
0.641808629,
0.1996435523,
-0.0520762131,
0.3566346765,
-0.298879385,
0.62162745,
0.0614774749,
0.0181489494,
0.0018282665,
-0.2200463712,
-0.3468782604,
0.108536534,
0.7072041035,
0.0664007813,
0.3756282032,
-0.3144889772,
-0.0350803137,
-0.3415082693,
0.4235110283,
-0.5734251738,
-0.5165289044,
0.3876229823,
-0.5680840611,
-0.197802484,
-0.332020551,
-0.2456897944,
-0.4446407855,
-0.2409432977,
0.3721991777,
-0.3452908695,
-0.7905708551,
0.3299048841,
0.0169497989,
-0.2011461109,
0.2614420354,
-1.2933001518,
0.0682438686,
0.2723331153,
0.6888666153,
-0.0195975117,
-0.85756284,
0.0276098326,
0.0117804036,
-0.3239709437,
1.0478643179,
-0.1289984882,
-0.0166578777,
-0.1702111363,
0.3697755337,
-0.2978930771,
-0.5661575198,
0.4309585094,
-0.06470038,
-0.0753854513,
-0.5039833188,
-0.4368006587,
-0.0726626143,
0.0786588043,
-0.5321158767,
0.4295749664,
0.2168937474,
-0.9516077638,
-0.0236429311,
-0.246187821,
-0.3330292404,
-0.3599550426,
0.3059405088,
-0.4687209129,
0.4963420928,
-0.1971654147,
0.3327606618,
0.1123367846,
-0.1839836538,
-0.6241142154,
-0.1671535373,
0.3271040022,
-0.4814075232,
0.8433349729,
0.0048375172,
-0.3035642207,
0.0868619904,
-0.8086500168,
-0.1879725009,
0.2523174286,
0.1429943144,
-0.4260618687,
0.1403949857,
-0.3355578184,
0.2602202296,
0.1479714066,
-0.6667023897,
0.3219042718,
-0.6067366004,
0.7026337981,
0.9667258263,
0.113815017,
0.5634105802,
-0.0958539024,
0.4615894854,
0.218733564,
0.1314730793,
-0.5048977733,
-0.0932039022,
-0.9358469844,
-0.2782157063,
0.1344451457,
-0.0172301419,
-0.3801114857,
-0.0194039159,
-0.0089638345,
-0.2738980651,
-0.6758022308,
0.2181773931,
0.3414778709,
0.6400574446,
0.4215084612,
-0.4314408302,
-0.605640471,
-1.1720753908,
-0.4944254756,
-0.1394270808,
0.194824636,
-0.1117695048,
0.2793035507,
-0.5341895223,
0.8324626088,
-0.4861284196,
-0.4940899611,
-0.1493163407,
0.0715114847,
-0.1501798332,
0.6001462936,
0.5585200191,
0.0376883298,
-0.1944814324,
-0.3529465497,
-0.6323712468,
-0.1322435737,
-0.2339170724,
0.0657285973,
0.1367880702,
0.6824572086,
-0.3193636537,
0.4739338458,
0.6294680238,
-0.4525197744,
0.5984315872,
-0.4874979258,
-0.0176266488,
-0.6130251288,
-0.0102503896,
-0.244545877,
-0.2426050305,
-0.8011158705,
-0.1414704472,
-0.0651125982,
0.4695643187,
-0.0914160013,
0.6427400708,
-0.5099459887,
-0.3406708539,
-0.8922455907,
0.0267434586,
-0.2183105201,
0.3788857162,
-0.1153195277,
0.4643909931,
0.7152761221,
-0.4665169418,
-0.0810192898,
0.1858572513,
-0.0486982018,
0.5239643455,
-0.8953965902,
0.2125447989,
-0.4887833893,
-0.0058378144,
-1.3754743338,
-0.2952899635,
0.316681385,
-0.2774367034,
0.3082205653,
-0.1398621649,
-0.2009955049,
-0.1133564115,
-0.0938393176,
0.6157337427,
0.2970380485,
-0.6526238918,
0.3968944252,
0.2073490918,
-0.3253753781,
-0.5943105221,
-0.7114982605,
-0.0157074071,
-0.1721907407,
-0.545296669,
-0.2213172466,
-0.4824646413,
-0.5220803618,
0.1144998223,
-0.2407782972,
-0.228575334,
0.468862623,
0.229261443,
-0.2644292116,
-0.3396299183,
0.1698915362,
0.0434904806,
-0.1599821746,
0.2186873555,
-0.0371159948,
0.3778628409,
-0.1113654524,
-0.4049498141,
-0.02682635,
0.1073214486,
0.4177746773,
-0.2256664336,
0.6565487981,
0.2722556293,
-0.257599324,
-0.1894342452,
-0.7168391347,
-0.2926156521,
-0.5032979846,
0.2569599748,
-0.3914207518,
-0.6548258066,
0.676764667,
0.3754339814,
-0.0731007084,
0.887294054,
0.5058916211,
-0.3363853693,
1.0199323893,
0.8315786123,
-0.0196736008,
0.3888781965,
-0.1570232064,
0.1023086309,
-0.8819736242,
0.2968560159,
-0.4313485324,
-0.0376768224,
-0.3403989971,
0.0611664541,
-0.0228667948,
0.172551021,
0.004942569,
0.1970262825,
-0.488063097,
0.4770245254,
0.4168190956,
0.1550718099,
0.3920677602,
-0.1696209908,
0.4440654814,
-0.0312145352,
-0.568852067,
-0.085290134,
0.8675461411,
0.631511569,
0.8279390335,
0.0122841811,
0.693400979,
-0.0342195965,
0.5953949094,
-0.7102037668,
0.1544330418,
0.0189761743,
-0.7191262245,
-0.6577568054,
-0.283934027,
-1.1889661551,
0.209535107,
0.2057929933,
-0.85946697,
0.2862336636,
0.623925209,
-0.3228629529,
0.2002375871,
-0.6385293007,
1.1763905287,
-0.0881900266,
-0.1277083158,
-0.3045185208,
-0.6738979816,
0.4803019464,
-0.1010427773,
0.2875525653,
-0.129986912,
0.3703467548,
0.6815738678,
-0.2050991207,
0.9924634695,
-0.169143945,
-0.3247748911,
0.2028373182,
0.3540918529,
0.1742647141,
-0.0892787278,
0.320035845,
0.1417380869,
0.2031131089,
-0.5078673959,
-0.70421803,
0.6033678055,
-0.7434854507,
-0.7606738806,
-0.3803493381,
-0.71372509,
-0.2342465371,
0.3687874675,
0.1742365807,
0.5121955872,
-0.115271017,
0.141866222,
0.7044371367,
-0.0137635171,
0.6236491799,
0.6830012798,
-0.1545351148,
-0.1284843236,
0.8571355939,
0.2570960224,
0.4648287594,
-0.1366708428,
0.2395564318,
-0.0050202459,
-0.6603019238,
-0.2612397671,
0.5885649323,
-0.6875211596,
0.126745671,
-0.7316061854,
-0.1679836363,
-0.3968660533,
0.054970488,
-0.6967020035,
-0.6183689833,
-0.2443070114,
-0.1543509662,
0.0426059291,
1.0610307455,
-0.4636276066,
0.3487808406,
-0.5199166536,
0.1454614252,
0.3541792929,
0.5642911792,
0.2386310399,
-0.7406572104,
-0.5243402719,
0.1541038752,
0.0332627669,
-0.6201289296,
0.3220364451,
0.1646501869,
0.4009030163,
0.3708021045,
-0.1242149919,
0.7073500752,
-0.8196360469,
0.5239129066,
0.1594408453,
-0.7462899685,
0.3685860336,
-0.3339447379,
0.4942594171,
0.360399127,
0.0630679131,
-0.6971793771,
-0.8214834332,
-0.9336367846,
-0.691174984,
0.5942752361,
-0.1499530524,
0.1509757191,
-0.181843102,
0.6321492195,
0.3047813773,
-0.1983819753,
-0.5314460397,
-0.3598195016,
-0.5256206989,
-0.3617775738,
-0.5692434311,
-0.7817437649,
-0.1568064094,
-0.0238754507,
0.563549459,
-0.3485143483,
0.4460224807,
0.537836194,
-0.3625882268,
-0.4530081153,
0.127762571,
0.7162083387,
0.8116561174,
-0.1669538617,
0.0594981275,
-0.1656517535,
-0.2201106548,
0.0287207067,
-0.0353797898,
0.0236374419,
-0.2968550622,
0.64805305,
0.7608854175,
0.2388532162,
-0.4767466784,
0.5273798704,
-0.1640060246,
0.0025038228,
-0.496722877,
0.1547278166,
0.0452394448,
0.2773837745,
0.2177180052,
0.2763575613,
0.5189043283,
-0.891888082,
0.1337003708,
0.382827729,
-0.5264865756,
-0.8326574564,
0.7694447637,
-0.2466131151,
-0.1627969891,
0.5461021066,
0.1630114019,
-0.3283501267,
0.4697278142,
0.5128435493,
1.0936838388,
-0.642922163,
0.1345275939,
0.3801778257,
0.4295019507,
-0.2786760926,
0.0578695126,
0.1607525945,
-0.9171372652,
-0.4541249871,
-0.3207154274,
-0.2070851773,
0.1081981659,
-0.7459977269,
-0.3811700344,
-0.3705644906,
0.1384506673,
0.240042001,
-0.6553295255,
-0.5317910314,
0.4465551376,
-0.237981692,
0.5676550269,
-0.9230430126,
0.6646296978,
0.4671108425,
-0.4887621999,
-0.4823929667,
0.2718157768,
-0.1151165366,
-0.8434401155,
0.4778232574,
0.0248615108,
0.045582518,
0.0064196526,
-0.6036630273,
-1.1315376759,
0.5489655733,
0.5204944611,
-0.3261012435,
-0.1685131043,
-0.0410196818,
0.8305654526,
0.0650011823,
0.3884038031,
0.6043341756,
0.1157008708,
-0.293109864,
-1.0232524872,
0.1167281196,
0.1956639588,
-0.2658053041,
0.0987317637,
-0.830888629,
0.8039703965,
-0.3408690095,
0.0373195149,
0.1586410999,
0.7156572342,
-0.3620566428,
-0.1763242036,
0.6932555437,
0.5562835336,
0.4471117258,
0.1442293227,
1.0908329487,
-0.2939495146,
0.6032200456,
1.2971946001,
0.1912294179,
0.5532085299,
0.421615541,
-0.053121455,
0.3407836854,
0.3824393451,
0.315480262,
0.6389142871,
-0.010819356,
0.0220679678,
-0.111852847,
0.1913129687,
-0.1267729998,
0.5391286016,
0.0728487,
-0.422398895,
-0.1526729017,
0.111827068,
-0.1242886856,
-0.1947826743,
-0.4356462955,
0.7400088906,
0.205952093,
-0.6491569281,
0.5441637635,
-0.313000679,
0.1066440418,
-0.351751864,
0.0626454726,
-0.4149301946,
0.58374542,
-0.3149705231,
-0.7663531303,
0.750729084,
-0.6153020859,
-0.5168129206,
-0.4219111204,
0.8891685605,
-0.5115854144,
-0.1428981274,
0.265650183,
0.5011181831,
0.1957943887,
-0.2531091273,
-0.474380374,
0.0743670464,
0.1264013201,
-0.5394062996,
0.5639556646,
0.5415218472,
0.3548390269,
0.8491626978,
0.1080019251,
0.0949319303,
0.1567575932,
0.0040784883,
0.5341796279,
-0.5668390989,
-0.1687604487,
-0.872140944,
0.7294678092,
0.1553122848,
-0.3356028199,
0.8717756867,
0.2136293501,
0.7353335619,
-0.1813231409,
0.7763184309,
0.2026515305,
0.8334355354,
-0.409147948,
0.4304850698,
-0.5389525294,
-0.0006890391,
-0.260063976,
-0.6970553994,
0.0735034868,
0.4951417148,
-0.238095507,
-0.0896968395,
0.8278580904,
0.4902070165,
-0.0618518181,
0.0141029647,
0.5068973303,
0.959220767,
-0.0032818494,
-0.0196214784,
0.8122423291,
-0.2190010399,
0.4552403092,
-0.4057595134,
-0.2774108052,
0.0304123592,
-0.5338871479,
-0.8303438425,
-0.7488822937,
-0.5736060143,
-0.4678610563,
0.0326820388,
0.4615028799,
0.4306958318,
-0.7663268447,
-0.0390365534,
-0.049533654,
0.0331499614,
-0.438758105,
-0.2139503062,
0.3274264038,
-0.6704462767,
-0.5006634593,
0.4339529574,
0.3162780404,
-0.0474785492,
-0.545763135,
0.338437736,
0.337959528,
0.0837331638,
0.5556718707,
0.7807277441,
-0.7314811349,
-0.770622015,
-0.113901861,
0.0888253376,
0.1195425913,
0.8200170398,
-0.4061643183,
0.5640136003,
0.2174025923,
0.7486807108,
0.4571371675,
-0.276217401,
0.8083749413,
-0.7512937188,
-0.0570126921,
-0.0083679231,
0.8479838371,
0.4620842338,
-0.4425772429,
0.5933080316,
0.2517726123,
-0.8282390833,
-0.9279660583,
0.4193241894,
-0.6442148685,
-0.3459538817,
1.194393158,
-0.3350497186,
-0.2540639937,
-0.0581514612,
-0.2532339394,
0.0419664495,
0.2976101637,
0.8394937515,
0.9069139361,
-0.266639322,
-0.4983467758,
-0.550483644,
0.4515932798,
0.5102782249,
-0.416426748,
0.3725380599,
0.4423320293,
0.8814535737,
0.1522038281,
1.019187212,
0.1816480011,
0.1646447033,
-0.0644071922,
0.2055044025,
0.307575196,
-0.4602858722,
-0.6735259891,
-0.0951405987,
0.4210710227,
0.1795268059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15370v1
|
Dual Encoder: Exploiting the Potential of Syntactic and Semantic for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction
| 2024-02-23T15:07:13 | 2024-02-23T15:07:13 |
Xiaowei Zhao, Yong Zhou, Xiujuan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Aspect Sentiment Triple Extraction (ASTE) is an emerging task in fine-grained
sentiment analysis. Recent studies have employed Graph Neural Networks (GNN) to
model the syntax-semantic relationships inherent in triplet elements. However,
they have yet to fully tap into the vast potential of syntactic and semantic
information within the ASTE task. In this work, we propose a \emph{Dual
Encoder: Exploiting the potential of Syntactic and Semantic} model (D2E2S),
which maximizes the syntactic and semantic relationships among words.
Specifically, our model utilizes a dual-channel encoder with a BERT channel to
capture semantic information, and an enhanced LSTM channel for comprehensive
syntactic information capture. Subsequently, we introduce the heterogeneous
feature interaction module to capture intricate interactions between dependency
syntax and attention semantics, and to dynamically select vital nodes. We
leverage the synergy of these modules to harness the significant potential of
syntactic and semantic information in ASTE tasks. Testing on public benchmarks,
our D2E2S model surpasses the current state-of-the-art(SOTA), demonstrating its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.31209144,
-0.6678688526,
0.6240579486,
0.3229240179,
-0.3694945574,
0.2061796337,
-0.2738995254,
-0.5673770905,
0.39570719,
0.459577471,
-0.5051277876,
-0.3546844423,
-0.7006696463,
0.0227698404,
-0.2250266373,
1.0998244286,
-0.1829584539,
0.1178862154,
-0.1339553744,
-0.0892815664,
-0.1954925805,
-0.5885677338,
-0.654925406,
-0.1972740144,
0.5996471643,
0.2918804884,
0.5578399301,
-0.018435603,
0.4729447365,
0.211296007,
-0.0891529769,
0.059089303,
-0.068993479,
0.2826013565,
-0.0696485117,
-0.2952650189,
-0.5697122216,
-0.0556474663,
0.6456928253,
0.5767657757,
0.2704358995,
0.0983966887,
0.4390357435,
0.5313512683,
-0.2839150429,
0.4763310552,
-0.5673645735,
0.0068791457,
0.0086746057,
0.0240048151,
-0.1119192615,
-0.3029601872,
0.0077193584,
-0.0688077658,
0.0669379383,
-0.3401739895,
1.1070609093,
0.2937619686,
-0.416480273,
-0.0259464309,
-0.6362082958,
0.3054259419,
-0.4803997576,
0.4949224591,
0.0922101885,
0.0551808886,
0.3372829854,
-0.7490459085,
-0.7567272782,
-0.0123088285,
-0.1353473961,
0.3111855388,
-0.1305689812,
0.2329937816,
-0.0433155186,
0.719848454,
-0.134657681,
0.0777463764,
-0.1535716057,
-0.1902801245,
0.4979006052,
-0.0057301717,
0.2479041964,
-0.7586234212,
-0.5293516517,
0.0406204052,
-0.4208366275,
0.2159220874,
0.547663331,
0.3869895041,
-0.0946138278,
0.6277605891,
0.0741676614,
0.2720843554,
0.0839304775,
0.4263404906,
0.2892440856,
-0.6327444911,
-0.0754318684,
-0.1361602247,
1.0904195309,
0.4813825786,
-0.2606414258,
-0.2675840557,
-0.467541337,
0.4235919714,
0.3374948502,
-0.6421255469,
-0.1919913441,
0.4042544067,
-0.2938224077,
-0.3443000615,
0.2004452646,
-1.2326644659,
-0.3611220717,
-0.2715343833,
0.4297499061,
-0.434206605,
-0.563822031,
0.0911933109,
-0.4903657734,
0.1311712414,
0.201524049,
-0.755663693,
0.3739355803,
0.7721976042,
0.852645278,
0.0162378419,
-0.1969190091,
-0.2617374957,
0.0168570373,
0.1858787388,
0.6711181998,
-0.4987725317,
-0.1728503704,
0.11889752,
-0.096826978,
0.0539874919,
-0.2612706721,
0.4303222299,
-0.7477506995,
0.0415941142,
-0.2431209087,
-0.239192456,
-0.4555447698,
0.2868410945,
-0.8448215127,
1.1966302395,
0.1685892493,
-0.8748294115,
0.261949122,
-0.8423316479,
-0.5358475447,
-0.1513931304,
-0.4791734517,
-0.4049259722,
0.2330040038,
0.0054387846,
0.4026346207,
-0.350117594,
0.1372585446,
-0.3719390631,
0.1952301413,
0.1945513636,
-0.358548224,
0.5106209517,
-0.1942526698,
-0.3640100956,
0.1700117737,
-0.4566223919,
-0.0806412473,
0.1427863836,
-0.4345214665,
-0.2044201493,
-0.0557742678,
0.1965403557,
0.4950440824,
0.500001967,
-0.9895243645,
-0.0093238279,
-0.518420577,
0.6446738839,
0.5018860102,
0.0320833996,
0.4500406086,
0.2362907827,
0.2609513998,
0.2028405219,
-0.1470396668,
0.4074582756,
-0.3652738333,
-0.9115733504,
-0.016821174,
0.2904404402,
0.4601936936,
-0.9504826069,
0.7789022326,
-0.4601323307,
0.1789448708,
-0.7809590101,
0.0694724917,
0.3802228868,
0.1101414859,
0.389295727,
-0.3368095458,
-0.538272202,
-0.9928652644,
-0.1167313457,
-0.1329555809,
0.0442897752,
0.0859341919,
0.4042520225,
-0.1797056198,
1.1360231638,
-0.5396381021,
-0.3110824227,
-0.6862523556,
0.1128573194,
0.047311563,
0.1688724607,
0.3518420458,
-0.953620255,
-0.4510855675,
0.0427765623,
-0.7761595845,
0.0582940355,
0.2249562591,
-0.151088208,
0.2821880281,
0.2958670557,
-0.7089529634,
0.3640587032,
0.4494550228,
-0.399587363,
0.1411150247,
-0.0147223948,
0.0025799088,
-1.1401596069,
-0.133891359,
-0.0188696049,
-0.2111164629,
-0.5711942315,
0.0324220769,
0.2871564627,
-0.0874441713,
-0.0869476572,
0.2729442716,
-0.5088937879,
-0.1347820014,
-0.2129833549,
0.1060284823,
0.3586649001,
0.5749387741,
0.1571102291,
0.4630801976,
0.4292201698,
-0.1843444109,
0.616689682,
0.106646724,
0.0602932908,
0.3230074346,
-0.4994539917,
0.3300550878,
-0.1631058306,
0.2777417302,
-0.7157453895,
-0.1540956795,
0.371221751,
-0.4662618041,
0.6241419911,
-0.1069311127,
-0.8010023832,
-0.7040630579,
-0.7015477419,
0.1211609468,
0.3483666182,
-0.6321756244,
0.7457127571,
0.5368506312,
-0.2509315908,
-0.2381069362,
-0.858166337,
0.1466805488,
-0.2193790972,
-0.7547113299,
0.2220609039,
0.3201291561,
0.0448174514,
0.2726071775,
-0.2372472584,
0.0080245594,
-0.0964693204,
0.2763522267,
0.3255535662,
-0.368160069,
0.1434254497,
0.0430177376,
-0.2921441197,
0.2765048444,
-0.5377559662,
0.6859399676,
-0.3379754424,
-0.3564732671,
-0.4865611196,
0.7755067945,
0.4069178402,
-0.3402876854,
0.5485112667,
0.6226516366,
-0.4440260231,
-0.0719515234,
-0.5248736739,
-0.2529456913,
-0.3934475482,
0.7458602786,
-0.5231503844,
-0.9277037382,
0.3883505166,
0.1548030674,
-0.2157909274,
0.4716789424,
0.3945973814,
-0.0392334685,
0.9808639884,
0.6304024458,
-0.1394486427,
0.430754751,
-0.4110091627,
0.5802000761,
-1.2114815712,
-0.2292439193,
-0.1132856235,
-0.3722169697,
-0.3704470694,
-0.5030542612,
0.5062437057,
0.2107286006,
-0.079177998,
0.178920269,
-0.4095876813,
0.122164458,
0.5209682584,
0.3610259593,
0.0916701332,
0.1990983635,
0.1470299661,
-0.0541438274,
-0.3904231489,
-0.5396606326,
0.8420158029,
0.6465467811,
0.4769580364,
0.4118517935,
0.6680062413,
0.0400761403,
-0.3394848406,
-0.9677689672,
0.6197628975,
-0.6063858271,
-0.1351088136,
-0.0299864393,
-0.2308376282,
-0.5900209546,
0.1900493354,
0.0474771038,
-0.9277828336,
0.1276037842,
0.129541561,
-0.6452826858,
0.3933792114,
-0.5952089429,
0.9809353948,
-0.1964636147,
-0.5153245926,
-0.2393822223,
-0.8778088689,
-0.0533023812,
0.1073418036,
-0.1032717153,
-0.1438053101,
-0.1988651454,
0.5584720373,
-0.2581650317,
1.0358296633,
-0.3759313524,
0.0558845885,
0.3118086755,
-0.0345435254,
0.3247587681,
0.3165975809,
-0.0775875226,
0.4321448505,
-0.2508352101,
-0.1119503975,
-0.5640354156,
0.8045317531,
-0.9699249268,
-0.5546086431,
-0.324416995,
-0.2638502419,
-0.3694922626,
0.0010887438,
0.281434983,
0.5833098888,
-0.0691543519,
-0.1500649452,
0.3193744719,
0.0858872309,
0.543155849,
0.2093624622,
-0.0679116473,
-0.4828229249,
0.8880311251,
-0.041076798,
0.4735372066,
0.4447344244,
0.1467502266,
-0.3244192302,
-0.3991862237,
-0.6269620061,
0.1766891927,
-0.6991297007,
-0.4554462135,
-1.1090055704,
-0.6917499304,
-0.4149217606,
-0.0658566803,
-0.5278606415,
-0.4745509028,
-0.1301474571,
-0.1888037175,
0.594897151,
0.8511028886,
-0.1926001608,
0.1301895529,
-0.7868328094,
0.3585113585,
0.3097505569,
0.3429187536,
-0.194922626,
-0.1620199084,
-0.0043619722,
0.1204839945,
-0.2023505121,
-1.0877264738,
0.2619992197,
0.0990908295,
0.3300195932,
0.1213236973,
-0.2370682508,
0.2439600229,
-0.2973941267,
0.922082901,
0.2887463868,
-0.8431609273,
0.714001894,
-0.2001396418,
0.1525753587,
0.7121436,
0.0784528479,
-0.4967201054,
-0.5169976354,
-0.5673726797,
-1.1146725416,
1.1158320904,
0.182821393,
0.0969261378,
-0.0538516119,
0.196591422,
0.2020628154,
0.3387772143,
-0.8337637782,
-0.0732475743,
-0.4482012391,
-0.5834816694,
0.2983423471,
-0.5277124643,
0.0120557342,
-0.2413339764,
0.5069341063,
-0.0843926817,
0.566599369,
0.0672334954,
-0.0810378268,
0.1861170083,
0.2480439693,
-0.1105133593,
-0.2644913793,
-0.243114844,
0.5632497072,
0.0858452916,
-0.5059821606,
-0.2174080461,
0.4522656798,
-0.0298405308,
0.0076646013,
0.186487034,
1.0669164658,
0.2602025867,
0.0688024014,
0.8309652805,
-0.0520909838,
0.09112259,
-0.3168365061,
-0.2428993732,
0.1386741847,
0.2937756181,
-0.1377350241,
0.2580132484,
0.3866872787,
-0.5739166737,
0.1068590358,
0.3989315927,
-0.6420506835,
-0.7086048126,
0.3940300345,
0.6304265261,
-0.057053525,
0.4897339046,
-0.5462875962,
-0.9514476657,
0.6705768108,
0.4933424294,
1.2052414417,
0.0737193376,
0.1436555684,
0.3341505229,
0.0548176058,
0.0978264511,
0.4702519476,
-0.1666503102,
-1.0495713949,
-0.0748074353,
-0.9919732213,
0.1233842224,
-0.0721938834,
-0.8018829823,
0.3540971577,
-0.2994297147,
-0.1707557589,
0.1468203366,
-0.1391805708,
-0.7557051778,
-0.1321250349,
0.4519790709,
0.4930334985,
-0.8592072129,
0.9368214607,
1.0532119274,
-0.8043413162,
-0.8552125692,
0.300419867,
0.1626477242,
-0.8245910406,
0.6736281514,
0.4426043034,
-0.3522014022,
-0.0056846752,
0.0750770196,
-0.635253787,
0.9012097716,
0.0331274271,
-0.2732176185,
-0.1184230372,
0.2534407079,
0.483135283,
-0.4375105798,
0.2826859355,
0.7680321336,
0.4129053354,
0.165148139,
-0.9169414043,
0.1540288478,
-0.420788914,
0.2515906096,
0.6224680543,
-0.5901041627,
0.7323854566,
-0.0348454453,
-0.3198545873,
-0.2350585461,
0.6690892577,
-0.2673739493,
-0.0081181666,
0.6341583133,
0.4532902837,
0.3358862698,
-0.1463872492,
1.0234504938,
-0.3574202061,
0.4439291358,
1.090559721,
-0.3465290964,
1.0511966944,
0.4875164926,
-0.1705138534,
0.5527451634,
0.4647963941,
0.1998665631,
0.6338594556,
-0.2404667586,
-0.585760951,
-0.169322595,
-0.1151444614,
-0.169553712,
0.5713800192,
0.5857722759,
-0.3432508409,
-0.2683915198,
0.0889242142,
0.1824771315,
0.0249740146,
-0.3049720526,
1.0484093428,
0.1851881295,
-0.3917991817,
-0.040488556,
-0.0752774999,
0.820573926,
-0.5933513641,
0.0783383846,
0.1134752035,
0.3811006248,
-0.3787805438,
-1.3267008066,
0.5836978555,
0.0670715347,
-0.346142441,
-0.4003997147,
0.9117770791,
-0.7144958377,
-0.5671386719,
0.8746236563,
0.3136736155,
-0.2176581472,
-0.2240099907,
-0.4815964103,
0.0572952293,
0.0805745199,
-0.1764486581,
0.1597341746,
0.6682846546,
0.2120175213,
0.0001981508,
0.1538054198,
0.196980536,
-0.2590261102,
0.4702153504,
1.1540762186,
-0.756454587,
-0.6396918297,
-0.9769874811,
0.6082856059,
-0.555573523,
-0.0670226365,
0.6220306754,
0.5991321802,
0.4761537611,
0.0966717005,
1.0263371468,
-0.3526462018,
0.3574374914,
-0.6233623028,
0.4932724535,
-0.5050104856,
0.2188605815,
0.1327119768,
-0.7807489634,
-0.1680083275,
0.4091619253,
-0.4227758348,
-0.0931085497,
1.0060149431,
0.711917758,
-0.2010553628,
0.4735191166,
-0.1118444875,
0.3916095197,
0.1218920723,
0.6700449586,
1.0225732327,
-0.3466997445,
0.2831378579,
-0.3312057257,
-0.3879056871,
-0.1696884632,
-0.5438178778,
-0.7538344264,
-0.5798280239,
-0.393201977,
-0.5383886099,
0.0378090926,
0.9374155402,
0.3313187659,
-0.6934587955,
0.0752904192,
-0.1292437017,
-0.0385337099,
0.0989818126,
-0.2524848878,
0.4451329708,
-0.4882357717,
-0.5829795599,
0.1927177161,
0.6908822656,
-0.1931113601,
-0.2419279069,
0.2331247032,
-0.0159018114,
-0.1350777596,
0.6946773529,
-0.1799353957,
-0.8037409782,
-0.8178585768,
-0.344447732,
-0.2955978215,
0.2894448042,
0.7664267421,
-0.5424004197,
0.3011269271,
0.4823393226,
0.5106449127,
0.3817849159,
-0.2071523815,
0.6149981022,
-0.8090417981,
0.1549861729,
0.4208283126,
0.4026043415,
0.4980760217,
-0.5183871984,
0.270570457,
0.1857748777,
-0.2113742977,
-0.3219327629,
0.4155243635,
-1.1414952278,
-0.1245867163,
1.5765336752,
-0.0237117521,
-0.1677035987,
-0.1475236267,
-0.1468625367,
0.28262797,
-0.5667869449,
0.3354957998,
0.4667702615,
-0.3247529268,
0.1403695792,
-0.668441236,
0.4404365122,
0.2937351465,
-0.7579146624,
0.0475070402,
0.4426044524,
0.1995913088,
0.2696613371,
0.6644477844,
-0.126780659,
0.0732690245,
0.2833214104,
0.4028514624,
0.0894421786,
-0.2654128671,
-0.4841946363,
0.3050787151,
0.1666587591,
-0.5029135942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15343v1
|
NuNER: Entity Recognition Encoder Pre-training via LLM-Annotated Data
| 2024-02-23T14:23:51 | 2024-02-23T14:23:51 |
Sergei Bogdanov, Alexandre Constantin, Timothée Bernard, Benoit Crabbé, Etienne Bernard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive abilities in data
annotation, opening the way for new approaches to solve classic NLP problems.
In this paper, we show how to use LLMs to create NuNER, a compact language
representation model specialized in the Named Entity Recognition (NER) task.
NuNER can be fine-tuned to solve downstream NER problems in a data-efficient
way, outperforming similar-sized foundation models in the few-shot regime and
competing with much larger LLMs. We find that the size and entity-type
diversity of the pre-training dataset are key to achieving good performance. We
view NuNER as a member of the broader family of task-specific foundation
models, recently unlocked by LLMs.
|
[
-0.4049900174,
-0.1095231995,
0.6061916947,
0.1534578949,
-0.3397689164,
0.0577553287,
-0.2180026025,
-0.3073880374,
0.3643695116,
0.7097770572,
-0.3504888415,
-0.4978785217,
-1.0272842646,
0.3738098145,
-0.6731556058,
0.9511630535,
-0.1950116158,
0.3105795979,
0.1304010898,
-0.0252996217,
-0.1744315475,
-0.6667711735,
-0.7021205425,
-0.3356622756,
0.618281126,
0.4678907692,
0.354996562,
0.7611144781,
0.7488678098,
0.2627179921,
0.1139976978,
-0.2421055734,
-0.6384084821,
0.1773542166,
0.0222178418,
-0.6694714427,
-0.3045914769,
-0.2508303821,
1.0455790758,
0.7252010703,
0.0059856134,
0.1142694727,
0.0368088633,
0.436879456,
-0.4599615932,
-0.0141484141,
-0.8032920957,
-0.043139521,
-0.3703133762,
-0.1203607991,
-0.2857401073,
-0.2729526758,
0.2069319338,
-0.5469219685,
0.3393617868,
0.1309672892,
0.8255226612,
0.5917482972,
-0.5127145648,
-0.2929972708,
-0.9600866437,
0.748047471,
-0.4892138541,
0.8632131219,
-0.0304312278,
0.4607071579,
-0.4707955122,
-0.8392801881,
-0.5991238952,
0.0215278249,
-0.0113712708,
-0.2326345444,
-0.0958926976,
0.0757019073,
0.4549600482,
0.380813241,
-0.3648996651,
0.1985221058,
-0.2571813464,
-0.0347264148,
0.38117221,
-0.0157009363,
0.2030023187,
-0.0103552481,
-0.3453759849,
-0.0811011121,
-0.9861242175,
-0.2497347444,
0.2246143669,
0.1226127073,
0.1193232536,
0.6796414852,
-0.2897121012,
0.4908806086,
0.0210920256,
-0.2684298158,
0.0711850077,
0.3855035007,
-0.2922686338,
0.3194046319,
0.5962935686,
0.0656903461,
0.4091202021,
-0.469619751,
-0.6657396555,
-0.0679031909,
-0.0434836522,
-1.0501760244,
-0.4424233437,
-0.0673715249,
-0.3052419126,
0.0032914213,
0.1406283528,
-0.5391297936,
-0.3581908643,
-0.4512663782,
0.3190853298,
-0.0678391904,
-0.1695256084,
0.1218699962,
-0.0952876061,
0.3798164427,
0.316374898,
-0.7767887115,
0.8198333383,
0.6293586493,
0.6743471622,
-0.1364773661,
-0.1287347227,
-0.818729043,
0.3163355291,
-0.333650738,
0.8479281068,
-0.5496471524,
-0.2507193685,
-0.3370419145,
0.2017208934,
0.0270430911,
-0.5877494812,
0.3054480553,
-0.6885333657,
-0.3623701632,
-0.2390690893,
-0.7517109513,
-0.1400989741,
0.3673578501,
-1.1863025427,
0.8113514185,
0.1647114903,
-0.8760156035,
0.5977186561,
-0.6656005979,
-0.143860206,
0.3571968973,
-0.4561001658,
-0.2691426575,
0.3343072534,
0.3348988295,
0.6845768094,
-0.4584608078,
0.3973582089,
-0.0415800437,
-0.4948560596,
0.2505272925,
-0.2379543632,
0.3266272843,
-0.2223345637,
-0.2645293474,
0.0426356569,
-0.8705173135,
-0.3119643331,
0.3230260611,
-0.488119036,
-0.2978020906,
-0.0489699803,
0.1219759434,
0.1113857776,
0.1661913246,
-0.6110429168,
0.1429928839,
-0.3555622995,
0.4911216795,
0.3713231385,
0.0125743458,
0.639223516,
-0.1296960264,
0.3975483179,
0.0447630025,
-0.0459790118,
0.1313710809,
-0.2256606221,
-1.1758121252,
-0.3611157238,
0.7453956604,
0.3498835862,
-0.7628517151,
0.1457132995,
-0.6409677863,
-0.4093355834,
-0.554826498,
0.3202322721,
0.0238411538,
0.29603073,
0.3283737004,
-0.0977669656,
-0.8702716827,
-1.1036006212,
0.0475904122,
-0.0594144315,
-0.0420229323,
0.2148686796,
0.7828497291,
-0.3944954574,
0.9358306527,
-0.3670360446,
-0.4074703455,
-0.3624894321,
0.067884177,
0.1419130862,
0.64329952,
0.3413506448,
-0.9241034985,
-0.2006339878,
-0.2643187642,
-0.5017977953,
0.0333655626,
-0.0059907003,
-0.143590197,
-0.0860470235,
0.6513707638,
-0.5317364335,
0.254440099,
0.5441604853,
0.2028294951,
0.2285616398,
0.0651583374,
0.0436010808,
-1.0260449648,
-0.1949989945,
-0.1655427963,
-0.3613249958,
-0.6057188511,
-0.1219406351,
0.1100083366,
-0.0229413789,
-0.4883490801,
0.558981359,
-0.742544353,
-0.2661080062,
-0.2424058765,
-0.0735647753,
-0.0993214101,
0.1412347108,
0.4621096551,
0.5496844053,
0.6301190853,
-0.6634927392,
0.1987327039,
0.1301985532,
-0.2456956506,
0.3545706868,
-0.8651323915,
0.3168444335,
-0.2804267108,
0.2208608091,
-0.4058304727,
-0.4758880734,
0.0556665175,
-0.1183954775,
0.4175213873,
-0.4583173692,
-0.8385313153,
-0.1677452624,
0.0012715432,
0.4776270986,
0.3924115896,
-0.9062494636,
1.0191206932,
0.3949138522,
-0.0470151901,
-0.48941347,
-0.6757265329,
0.0964343771,
-0.3184717894,
-0.2492590845,
0.4984326065,
0.1669345945,
0.0037236987,
0.0065216571,
-0.0422160514,
-0.1848952323,
0.1271460056,
0.5464037061,
0.1599344611,
-0.4904544055,
0.2872845531,
0.0078749666,
-0.3191674352,
0.0541268699,
-0.1896550506,
0.5200081468,
-0.1444046497,
-0.4400101602,
-0.0656146482,
0.3325366676,
0.2293834835,
-0.1767329723,
0.7718963623,
0.3795208633,
-0.9324750304,
-0.231519416,
-0.7618307471,
-0.269908458,
-0.391305089,
0.3084840477,
-0.6106027961,
-1.1238099337,
0.3796238005,
-0.3909559548,
0.0577822775,
0.3539051712,
0.1791373491,
0.1207999885,
0.8804315925,
0.9820024371,
-0.1037550494,
0.4085193574,
-0.2768345475,
0.2231722772,
-1.0119898319,
-0.3168309927,
-0.490888685,
-0.4780025482,
-0.475507766,
-0.3747420013,
-0.0359377861,
0.5907641053,
-0.4076032639,
0.4605847299,
-0.4701703191,
0.6162835956,
0.4960587323,
-0.1850538403,
0.2793672383,
-0.383777529,
0.2083896548,
-0.1658318937,
-0.5763952136,
-0.9252067208,
1.0860397816,
0.4459237754,
0.8486359119,
0.0561209284,
1.255877614,
-0.3528776467,
0.6159716249,
-0.840741396,
0.6361076832,
-0.2065495551,
-0.4605283737,
-0.1309828758,
-0.3065289557,
-0.7382768989,
-0.0301843341,
-0.4618190825,
-0.7227612138,
0.2850331664,
-0.001567592,
-0.2465793043,
0.3620508015,
-0.4436818063,
0.7661536932,
-0.3214190006,
0.3686088622,
0.4278225005,
-0.3565990031,
0.2614427805,
-0.339841336,
-0.1511482745,
-0.1797179431,
-0.2895212471,
1.0218608379,
-0.134822458,
0.5308538079,
-0.1947220415,
0.2459705472,
0.0139304912,
0.045472648,
0.5923424363,
0.3016135991,
0.0509260781,
0.21122621,
-0.1347483546,
-0.1137144789,
-0.8154146075,
0.642464757,
-0.6642178893,
-0.6095632315,
-0.36266312,
-0.4553820789,
0.0624226108,
0.3096120656,
0.3708120584,
0.398478955,
-0.3543061316,
0.5438864231,
0.7920019031,
0.0878091827,
0.3250445127,
0.4621549547,
-0.3824546039,
-0.3120230734,
0.6271081567,
0.3321515918,
-0.081078358,
0.5708121657,
-0.2434030473,
-0.2254201323,
-0.8375627398,
-0.3699308634,
0.2951681316,
-0.9446520209,
-0.387753576,
-1.04570961,
-0.453499347,
-0.2039725631,
-0.2524603605,
-0.4506980777,
-0.3363463581,
-0.5235381722,
-0.1677512974,
0.4195991755,
0.9865694642,
0.1288464963,
0.7687088251,
-0.666359961,
0.409827143,
0.40485093,
0.400985986,
-0.3335749805,
-0.2754345834,
0.0445109606,
-0.247757569,
0.2403670698,
-1.0096501112,
0.3770811856,
0.3157612085,
0.6689450741,
0.3585436046,
0.0238250848,
0.4657882452,
-0.6210805178,
0.4265908301,
0.0369542465,
-0.8436142206,
0.5775930285,
0.1361714154,
-0.0330576263,
0.5599945188,
0.6002560854,
-0.1462580413,
-0.1134840548,
-0.4922657311,
-0.7759769559,
0.4416000545,
0.2039821297,
0.0933687016,
-0.1813369244,
0.4591857195,
0.0470083021,
0.1855494827,
-0.8921616077,
0.0007972826,
-0.1366386116,
-0.3739878833,
-0.1488158554,
-0.3904184997,
0.1413179338,
-0.108568497,
0.6593340635,
-0.2003608197,
0.138456732,
0.1183595732,
-0.678952992,
0.1722994596,
0.5179950595,
0.0164104663,
0.2051743567,
-0.1599865407,
0.387565136,
0.4912329614,
-0.4773755074,
0.1505749822,
0.3157006502,
-0.1542484909,
0.1287927032,
0.2301428914,
0.8903275132,
0.6523965597,
-0.6060003638,
0.5220716596,
-0.2495354265,
-0.1179371998,
-0.5440151691,
0.2112211585,
0.2892661989,
0.4621022046,
0.3797724843,
-0.1781687438,
0.3937691748,
-0.16800192,
0.0685349032,
0.2923563719,
-0.4260234833,
-0.1164819747,
0.6027380228,
-0.0539217591,
-0.3426171243,
0.7229374051,
-0.2586451769,
-0.7966882586,
0.584521234,
0.7254710793,
0.7790518403,
-0.1711508632,
-0.0401399396,
0.3097556829,
0.4151301086,
-0.4437898695,
0.3058988154,
0.0155100171,
-0.8131710291,
-0.2247356474,
-0.8731122613,
-0.3278036118,
0.2351420522,
-0.7426634431,
0.5613893867,
-0.5267013907,
-0.2256827354,
0.0957594365,
-0.0813199803,
-1.1332144737,
0.3165057003,
0.1908895373,
0.8943801522,
-0.6678750515,
0.9142189026,
0.7993831635,
-0.2631960809,
-0.9623374939,
-0.1006383896,
-0.1641896516,
-0.4300742447,
1.0663856268,
0.5302785635,
-0.1352690905,
0.4671239853,
-0.5146553516,
-1.096963048,
1.2234756947,
0.6889159679,
-0.9618852735,
-0.1966311783,
0.1217332855,
0.2286827415,
-0.8254436851,
0.1202574521,
0.7256426811,
0.2291416228,
0.1203130409,
-0.5760662556,
0.0280395858,
-0.186202243,
0.2324242145,
0.4101422131,
-0.0468521826,
0.9400455952,
-0.1408370137,
-0.3603288233,
-0.0833105445,
0.8778759241,
0.3715858459,
-0.0736332387,
0.7336812615,
0.4648011923,
0.7176220417,
-0.2470306009,
0.8249410391,
-0.1440349519,
0.0342937447,
1.351377964,
-0.4339036047,
1.1370190382,
0.497441262,
0.2266534865,
0.4542507231,
0.4933573902,
-0.205351159,
0.401812762,
0.3684076369,
-0.1879506707,
-0.3112574816,
-0.1787839979,
-0.1981441826,
0.4654195905,
0.4373171926,
-0.3726190627,
-0.1984718442,
0.1424045414,
-0.299180299,
-0.1826597303,
-0.4478053749,
0.9281042218,
0.3055820465,
-0.0705625266,
0.0533891544,
-0.0159359295,
0.8748330474,
-0.3759257495,
-0.2933032513,
0.2732377946,
0.0279054809,
-0.202369839,
-0.6104887724,
0.1668723375,
0.1341337562,
-0.2612413466,
0.0596533902,
1.0436854362,
-0.4622006714,
-0.5451900363,
0.5214793086,
0.4551888406,
0.4736071527,
-0.3248106837,
-0.3689659238,
0.1280183792,
-0.5155300498,
-0.2583864331,
0.1578305513,
0.6199864745,
-0.1330552101,
0.5814657807,
0.5536057353,
0.2005365342,
0.3034349382,
0.3763130903,
0.9578694701,
-0.7584132552,
-0.3918233216,
-0.7155460119,
0.2968146503,
-0.0863002762,
-0.1716496348,
0.4184397459,
0.6918858886,
0.9176182151,
0.0412679687,
0.5901842117,
0.1919186562,
0.506044507,
-0.5833287835,
0.6631322503,
-0.2899035215,
0.140763849,
-0.1293657869,
-1.3260662556,
-0.4717936218,
0.6779524684,
-0.4374715686,
0.0201057903,
0.4517507255,
0.7714630365,
-0.1195759103,
0.1488684267,
0.3158890009,
-0.0034306606,
0.1542043686,
0.682710886,
1.0414711237,
-0.5492770672,
0.3952445984,
-0.3145432174,
0.0261610672,
-0.2066182643,
-0.9611934423,
-1.0800449848,
-0.6184908748,
-0.3490439355,
0.0893290862,
-0.0688431785,
1.1554319859,
0.8426697254,
-0.9208442569,
0.0745032132,
-0.115876846,
0.021086257,
0.2758748829,
-0.1288401037,
0.1119700745,
-0.0356533304,
-0.7791545391,
0.329002589,
0.2069710195,
0.5115959644,
-0.2309493124,
-0.2611972988,
0.0444993638,
-0.0354373716,
0.3184431195,
0.0753098801,
-0.6938757896,
-0.2634409964,
0.0334334038,
-0.0607636832,
0.0005654516,
0.8805201054,
-0.917858839,
0.0925668553,
0.2230415791,
0.9491386414,
0.5624133945,
-0.3231891394,
0.5254707336,
-0.6417163014,
0.0567957871,
0.3787201643,
0.7989042401,
0.7138016224,
-0.4092729688,
0.4572496116,
-0.1879673898,
-0.4170596004,
-0.9835206866,
0.1195487753,
-0.8814017773,
0.107852824,
1.0153651237,
-0.1994079202,
-0.3115878403,
-0.2035926878,
-0.1204534695,
0.3980646133,
-0.2771288157,
0.1765817106,
0.6071177125,
0.1093472168,
-0.564375937,
-0.5613600016,
0.4443961978,
-0.0433310308,
-0.8451562524,
-0.3490027785,
0.2419235855,
0.5139485002,
0.1390323043,
0.7361551523,
-0.0413799845,
0.0342418663,
0.0599947833,
0.1950888187,
-0.0565040968,
-0.7456523776,
-0.3852950037,
0.123797439,
0.3783367276,
-0.0837210119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15337v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15337v2
|
Ranking Entities along Conceptual Space Dimensions with LLMs: An Analysis of Fine-Tuning Strategies
| 2024-02-23T14:17:01 | 2024-06-05T10:42:40 |
Nitesh Kumar, Usashi Chatterjee, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Conceptual spaces represent entities in terms of their primitive semantic
features. Such representations are highly valuable but they are notoriously
difficult to learn, especially when it comes to modelling perceptual and
subjective features. Distilling conceptual spaces from Large Language Models
(LLMs) has recently emerged as a promising strategy, but existing work has been
limited to probing pre-trained LLMs using relatively simple zero-shot
strategies. We focus in particular on the task of ranking entities according to
a given conceptual space dimension. Unfortunately, we cannot directly fine-tune
LLMs on this task, because ground truth rankings for conceptual space
dimensions are rare. We therefore use more readily available features as
training data and analyse whether the ranking capabilities of the resulting
models transfer to perceptual and subjective features. We find that this is
indeed the case, to some extent, but having at least some perceptual and
subjective features in the training data seems essential for achieving the best
results.
|
[
-0.8242206573,
-0.5902320743,
0.9269276857,
-0.0663741231,
-0.3413032889,
0.1971407831,
-0.4666232169,
-0.4453437626,
0.2575221658,
0.4211996794,
-0.4711466432,
-0.7700255513,
-0.7711291313,
0.0134995282,
-0.3172003627,
1.0219677687,
0.0807891488,
-0.1078656241,
-0.5927258134,
-0.2173558325,
-0.4642539322,
-0.5592570305,
-0.4712539017,
-0.2387509793,
0.6018899083,
0.598423481,
0.7037352324,
0.6414980888,
0.6179582477,
0.3183752,
-0.2613370717,
0.1700935215,
-0.8465490341,
0.0933265686,
-0.3670405447,
-0.4025447667,
-0.4204366505,
0.3294012249,
0.7221148014,
1.2579050064,
-0.1257793456,
0.3581987917,
0.0519830398,
0.5102038383,
-0.6054041386,
0.0744628459,
-1.0830075741,
0.0338147804,
-0.3407637179,
-0.3651570678,
-0.0073191985,
-0.1964027286,
0.2323624939,
-0.6807019711,
0.3848672807,
0.2245333195,
1.0493149757,
0.518653214,
-0.490010947,
-0.2871982753,
-0.7395852208,
0.8882262707,
-0.3797216415,
0.3773333728,
0.2139858752,
0.0185153689,
-0.0074735819,
-0.4352655411,
-0.5428164005,
-0.525606811,
-0.0500714891,
-0.0913230106,
0.0767346621,
-0.0063855872,
0.3616219163,
0.3889779449,
-0.2062629908,
0.2643919885,
-0.1312356293,
-0.0255157929,
0.81147331,
0.2907067537,
-0.0542786978,
-0.1200236082,
-0.3056620061,
-0.0913231894,
-0.6338745356,
-0.0973743349,
0.2693421245,
0.2158097774,
0.1151817963,
0.7276970148,
-0.4296979308,
0.5226030946,
0.2716693878,
-0.2750682533,
0.1785627156,
-0.2773667872,
-0.0263839681,
0.010134967,
0.4597114027,
0.3785426319,
0.327924639,
-0.3149921894,
-0.3945032358,
0.0944036767,
0.5334675312,
-0.5948013663,
-0.2921589315,
-0.0490880162,
-0.1182709187,
-0.403134197,
-0.1093989238,
-0.4245426059,
-0.2573218048,
-0.6760590672,
0.3511175811,
-0.4104426801,
-0.1404964626,
0.0729282424,
-0.0045106211,
0.2251491398,
0.5789128542,
-0.9227673411,
0.31985116,
0.8191928267,
0.7729315162,
-0.3180793524,
-0.2659189403,
0.0190795325,
0.0849065855,
-0.6353980303,
0.9969894886,
-0.6746887565,
-0.5754558444,
-0.1685750932,
-0.3128400743,
0.1937345415,
-0.7912424207,
0.4376282394,
-0.5276014805,
-0.0238909237,
-0.543264389,
-0.9015175104,
0.1298969984,
0.3765023947,
-0.4109846652,
0.8976125121,
0.2135056555,
-0.6589539647,
0.6795986891,
-0.6834864616,
-0.3795075715,
0.0007551853,
-0.2818582654,
-0.1272617429,
0.4650866389,
0.1715083569,
0.6948113441,
-0.1636962593,
0.096366927,
-0.5706893802,
-0.2888356745,
0.2753183544,
-0.101197049,
0.3418059647,
0.2871720493,
-0.1034496129,
-0.1465703398,
-0.7920444012,
-0.0110029941,
0.1952200681,
-0.4358275533,
-0.5418784022,
0.0100597711,
-0.1469569355,
0.1237466186,
0.3085041344,
-0.3054367602,
0.3346112072,
-0.4008981884,
0.2864672244,
0.6586996913,
0.239570722,
0.8274256587,
-0.0724595264,
0.3002149463,
0.2387100756,
-0.0647763759,
0.3982588947,
-0.2516645491,
-0.8801404238,
-0.2784537673,
0.5415383577,
0.2687288523,
-0.6556961536,
0.6347763538,
-0.6074627042,
-0.6534526944,
-0.4410001338,
0.335193485,
0.2334336787,
0.3432488143,
0.1501351893,
-0.5226649046,
-0.1361132264,
-0.9955838323,
-0.1455705464,
-0.1452066451,
-0.0392197073,
0.4564210474,
0.5313081145,
0.1341794282,
0.8414094448,
-0.761629045,
-0.3241371214,
0.0472802073,
-0.212516427,
0.1073722914,
0.2521736622,
0.6355246902,
-0.7623476386,
-0.1559496224,
-0.2197173387,
-0.9092170596,
0.1105786636,
0.1650124788,
-0.0492784642,
-0.2189200968,
0.6057901382,
-0.7319512367,
0.1052382588,
0.0835555196,
-0.2380622178,
0.275023371,
-0.0494200401,
0.0055184006,
-0.8495788574,
-0.1860052049,
0.2807084024,
-0.1195007935,
-0.4276195467,
0.3053543866,
-0.2003346086,
-0.0266443659,
-0.4797330201,
0.5463366508,
-0.4466822743,
-0.0773315281,
-0.1552569717,
0.5038372874,
-0.1107854918,
0.5585402846,
0.0704650134,
0.6316532493,
0.4313416779,
-0.8076326847,
0.23167485,
0.2334647775,
-0.4551564753,
0.9062575698,
-0.3353241682,
0.2362411618,
-0.1769149899,
0.0456231274,
-0.865933001,
-0.0471376069,
-0.0535579249,
-0.3807352185,
0.5164735913,
-0.1099902317,
-0.5587936044,
0.0391772911,
-0.3190566897,
0.3502243757,
0.2311332971,
-0.2019012868,
0.204767704,
0.7736592889,
-0.0259799883,
-0.4870181978,
-0.2575870454,
0.1124414578,
-0.5554341078,
-0.369204849,
0.6194968224,
0.1315530986,
-0.262100637,
0.2338210642,
-0.2370565832,
0.3120360374,
0.4313883185,
0.4074165523,
0.1384959519,
-0.2298850417,
0.1394754201,
-0.0890306458,
-0.2609705031,
0.0920765102,
-0.5550247431,
0.3344084918,
-0.1969560981,
-0.2753253281,
-0.0790690407,
-0.0106730796,
0.4550856352,
-0.1975779682,
0.7843403816,
0.4124390483,
-0.4643809497,
-0.2340899855,
-0.6228815317,
-0.0104800472,
-0.4301414788,
0.6255891323,
-0.5817327499,
-1.1096342802,
0.3879517019,
-0.4051286876,
-0.0739010125,
0.5406778455,
0.6821578741,
-0.4291216433,
0.8299475312,
0.9477136731,
-0.2080377936,
0.4093503952,
-0.5311726332,
0.2830524445,
-0.923291564,
-0.3937672079,
-0.591973722,
-0.5926190615,
-0.7435787916,
-0.281483084,
0.5359880924,
0.2793231308,
-0.2467921376,
0.1548270136,
-0.4055869877,
0.6993915439,
0.4039213657,
0.086670801,
0.2952380776,
0.1307926625,
-0.3940241337,
-0.1386221349,
-0.5600050688,
-0.6630349159,
1.0702186823,
0.437363714,
0.6996204853,
0.1278300732,
0.7210044265,
-0.0000011123,
0.1228554845,
-0.9931223989,
0.7066302299,
-0.2336131036,
-0.5444642305,
-0.6346335411,
-0.3886256814,
-0.7273142934,
0.1747274697,
-0.4197817445,
-0.6556916833,
0.2869901061,
-0.1691108644,
-0.430780828,
0.1673748791,
-0.4748063087,
0.6018202305,
-0.2314013988,
-0.2078742385,
-0.417136997,
-0.3545129001,
0.2881606817,
-0.1228244975,
-0.06063186,
-0.3825251758,
-0.1917066276,
0.629712224,
-0.1499380618,
0.5761275887,
-0.1943818182,
-0.3056055009,
-0.121076718,
0.1124350876,
0.0516250506,
0.4676555991,
0.1374280751,
0.3677838445,
0.0097908471,
-0.481524229,
-0.7819826603,
1.0001635551,
-1.0787990093,
-0.8257191181,
-0.2218212783,
-0.2741964161,
-0.6652159095,
0.0426452346,
0.3695760369,
0.1242017224,
-0.3051187992,
0.2146387994,
1.023688674,
0.0631595999,
0.1285485774,
0.3412697017,
-0.1045797318,
-0.1628776193,
0.9638887048,
0.4478700757,
0.038533628,
0.5157083273,
-0.2603515685,
-0.4981310368,
-0.9589527249,
-0.0572546646,
0.2092010081,
-0.7935752273,
-0.2323260605,
-0.5132848024,
-0.4830982387,
-0.115460746,
-0.0496428646,
-0.5190588832,
-0.7412247658,
-0.395581156,
-0.1997059882,
0.0799225792,
0.6378201246,
0.1517922133,
0.0032317627,
-0.4414769113,
0.3620411456,
0.3644006252,
0.5478866696,
0.0625943318,
-0.5444663763,
-0.4495233595,
-0.1753737777,
-0.5403960347,
-0.5323169231,
0.0449341759,
0.0988885388,
0.6241413355,
0.4697137475,
-0.1236870289,
0.8718402386,
-0.593144834,
0.8758481145,
0.0218749903,
-0.8709816337,
0.7362513542,
-0.1072691455,
0.069137916,
0.6387548447,
0.5971227884,
-0.362665385,
-0.4049036503,
-0.8150337934,
-0.7777404189,
0.55500108,
0.1933591664,
0.3645828366,
0.0118232751,
0.8499302864,
-0.1105328947,
0.3727992177,
-0.3380231857,
-0.3730065525,
-0.1482405663,
-0.0512126945,
-0.336958766,
-0.1971742809,
-0.2072485685,
-0.4595184922,
0.4977222979,
0.0078089396,
0.067537345,
0.0599649996,
-0.1924259961,
-0.0059186919,
0.1142517626,
0.4338722825,
0.7373616099,
-0.0622641332,
0.1725064814,
0.465430975,
-0.2983364165,
0.2641589642,
-0.058573395,
-0.117942512,
-0.0285117868,
0.3907608986,
0.9595035911,
0.5012156367,
-0.2223913372,
0.3988983333,
0.0906076133,
-0.3570998609,
-0.297403276,
0.4178405404,
0.1386223882,
0.3857076466,
0.213123858,
0.0822517946,
0.1709089875,
-0.6047955155,
-0.0129582705,
0.6264456511,
-0.444773227,
-0.3265920281,
0.4707258642,
0.1179487258,
-0.0562063567,
0.6373928785,
-0.1213285401,
-0.3078039587,
0.3216778636,
0.0730479807,
0.6094139814,
0.077433303,
0.1241207421,
0.1279526502,
0.2929615378,
0.0331449732,
-0.2214416713,
-0.1673880517,
-1.0749758482,
-0.2039483488,
-0.970608294,
-0.3823965788,
0.2951131165,
-0.6258302927,
0.3431820571,
-0.6208595037,
-0.4024575055,
0.3880326152,
0.4495129883,
-1.0456089973,
0.2752839923,
0.503659308,
0.9165149927,
-0.5653579831,
0.7976468801,
0.941285193,
-0.3615999222,
-0.7186558843,
0.0091823898,
-0.0088256709,
-0.6585178971,
0.7300459743,
-0.285843581,
-0.107983999,
0.1620162576,
-0.7253069282,
-1.0682514906,
1.0800461769,
0.5904403925,
-0.6076875329,
-0.3363159299,
0.2249001116,
0.649102509,
-0.5223661661,
0.0972203016,
0.6673281789,
0.3094863594,
0.1091394573,
-0.8680083752,
0.0265650731,
-0.039805457,
0.4275866449,
0.1549576372,
-0.7861021757,
0.4619541764,
-0.1713822186,
-0.28437078,
-0.0989541486,
0.701929152,
0.1418349445,
0.1975573003,
0.6240900755,
0.9179707766,
0.8010200858,
-0.1371892542,
0.7591528296,
-0.2924352884,
0.6482217312,
0.83262676,
-0.5117613673,
1.0789208412,
0.476803571,
-0.2055122256,
0.4015292227,
0.7904059887,
-0.1132680327,
0.7824161053,
0.4196610451,
0.060740117,
-0.4983034134,
-0.0719484389,
-0.2570028603,
0.7719988823,
0.6122300625,
-0.0189086311,
-0.3504267931,
-0.0674831048,
-0.3049556315,
0.0569532067,
-0.2236106396,
1.1439913511,
0.3059812486,
-0.4584906399,
0.6034545898,
0.0477095954,
0.6357455254,
-0.3101045191,
-0.024224773,
-0.3723583817,
-0.1112755761,
-0.1489551663,
-0.907849431,
0.1631932855,
-0.0354833305,
-0.1648398042,
-0.2146551609,
0.6066129208,
-0.1860549599,
-0.3956772983,
0.1823855191,
0.6877188683,
0.1532490402,
-0.1666459441,
-0.6614044905,
-0.1675158888,
-0.2765612602,
-0.245413512,
0.5786511898,
0.9081779122,
-0.0844908357,
0.6186771989,
0.6170938015,
0.2612796426,
-0.1989988238,
0.1119390801,
1.0273984671,
-0.8807131052,
-0.2560001314,
-0.8514285088,
0.3160020411,
-0.0736586601,
-0.3825899661,
0.6159178019,
0.4510542452,
1.3257876635,
0.002269933,
0.3954966366,
0.2036176026,
0.2819303274,
-0.8782198429,
0.8366844058,
-0.6844866276,
0.6311824322,
-0.0973801613,
-1.344632268,
-0.1547433883,
0.5211303234,
-0.304377377,
0.060207773,
0.6688098907,
0.7206472754,
-0.0975940302,
-0.202317819,
0.5816004276,
0.3578416109,
0.0558528453,
0.4634600282,
1.2450985909,
-0.0553967059,
0.1677795351,
-0.3500942886,
-0.1247277483,
-0.1749034375,
-0.7624890208,
-0.8801169395,
-0.6861967444,
-0.4503132999,
-0.0444760919,
-0.1903465688,
0.8194085956,
0.8989306688,
-0.7405228019,
-0.0409370661,
0.2948005199,
0.1711718738,
0.0499437377,
-0.2188331038,
0.0984411761,
-0.5069152117,
-0.6225389838,
0.1651515663,
0.4196899235,
-0.1474242806,
-0.6261895299,
0.1631771028,
0.0637884662,
0.0682769865,
0.6750484109,
-0.2691618204,
-0.9177629352,
-0.4407860041,
0.0080081597,
-0.1790366024,
0.0385535173,
0.8052494526,
-0.8508467674,
-0.0385493785,
0.1205164269,
0.5047475696,
0.4972965419,
-0.3009690344,
0.2394980341,
-1.1199139357,
-0.0817278028,
0.1920338869,
0.3286210895,
0.4290668964,
-0.4274773896,
0.5911282897,
0.295384407,
-0.4508299232,
-0.7638224363,
0.0581301339,
-0.989302814,
-0.2909990847,
0.9696464539,
-0.0089671379,
-0.1177745163,
0.1436656713,
-0.0436588712,
0.1460143179,
-0.229765445,
1.057677269,
0.9917972088,
-0.1203362197,
-0.0584365949,
-0.5035524368,
0.6526360512,
0.2825413346,
-0.5599880219,
-0.2736508548,
0.3644308448,
0.5379378796,
0.6202524304,
0.452970922,
-0.0558563806,
-0.0763119981,
-0.116973266,
-0.3228415847,
0.0937555134,
-0.5333574414,
-0.385309279,
0.2609144747,
0.5289112926,
0.0131418658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15319v1
|
GPTVQ: The Blessing of Dimensionality for LLM Quantization
| 2024-02-23T13:39:16 | 2024-02-23T13:39:16 |
Mart van Baalen, Andrey Kuzmin, Markus Nagel, Peter Couperus, Cedric Bastoul, Eric Mahurin, Tijmen Blankevoort, Paul Whatmough
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this work we show that the size versus accuracy trade-off of neural
network quantization can be significantly improved by increasing the
quantization dimensionality. We propose the GPTVQ method, a new fast method for
post-training vector quantization (VQ) that scales well to Large Language
Models (LLMs). Our method interleaves quantization of one or more columns with
updates to the remaining unquantized weights, using information from the
Hessian of the per-layer output reconstruction MSE. Quantization codebooks are
initialized using an efficient data-aware version of the EM algorithm. The
codebooks are then updated, and further compressed by using integer
quantization and SVD-based compression. GPTVQ establishes a new state-of-the
art in the size vs accuracy trade-offs on a wide range of LLMs such as Llama-v2
and Mistral. Furthermore, our method is efficient: on a single H100 it takes
between 3 and 11 hours to process a Llamav2-70B model, depending on
quantization setting. Lastly, with on-device timings for VQ decompression on a
mobile CPU we show that VQ leads to improved latency compared to using a 4-bit
integer format.
|
[
-0.3372589052,
-0.3179455101,
0.1610043943,
0.2566322386,
-0.5337916613,
0.2226135284,
-0.2505284846,
-0.0001686828,
0.2224893123,
0.2359995246,
-0.1468301713,
-0.3948927522,
-0.5895965099,
-0.2490947843,
-0.2582574785,
0.7274690866,
0.2279216349,
0.3760630786,
-0.4101699591,
-0.0414292924,
0.0495804213,
-0.7863745093,
-0.7839823365,
-0.0912533849,
0.5195555091,
0.0267223343,
0.8337337971,
0.934920311,
0.6865102053,
0.2943874598,
-0.3289440274,
0.0526192896,
-0.4105267227,
-0.0467628948,
0.2624817193,
-0.4254417121,
-0.6552661061,
-0.081976302,
0.885938108,
0.4338518083,
-0.2215829492,
0.4800191522,
-0.1117098629,
0.7209839225,
-0.6739204526,
-0.0592978038,
-0.3522498012,
0.4091064632,
0.0611376613,
-0.3718960583,
0.0282095391,
-0.4350330234,
-0.0072489572,
-0.5004277825,
0.237127766,
-0.2070712745,
0.5836085081,
0.6173539162,
-0.5207109451,
0.2868409455,
-0.8800467253,
0.7501419783,
-0.6651395559,
0.4494439662,
0.2815464139,
0.3111384809,
0.2536915541,
-1.0340560675,
-0.571532011,
-0.0998522788,
0.2908753753,
0.0530451201,
-0.0315331444,
0.1819203645,
0.6232927442,
0.6453986168,
-0.6742542982,
0.1480958909,
-0.3491643369,
-0.3277634084,
0.7077025175,
0.1187781319,
0.2254169136,
-0.1095996946,
-0.2742085457,
-0.1974290162,
-0.8755828738,
0.0463459641,
0.4225936234,
-0.255366683,
0.1769869328,
0.5605887771,
-0.4415389895,
0.5363041162,
-0.3805837929,
-0.1897510141,
0.1729596704,
-0.535859406,
-0.4512305558,
0.0344401076,
0.8679189682,
0.3642651439,
-0.0564121716,
-0.0428951904,
-0.1790672094,
0.0279741082,
0.1185586154,
-1.2114895582,
-0.4843169749,
0.4019678533,
-0.7524407506,
-0.2761645317,
-0.433493644,
-0.4418886304,
-0.3069927096,
-0.5173459649,
0.6828202605,
-0.2890186608,
-0.2523547411,
0.1798992157,
-0.0913278013,
0.4088174403,
0.3991071284,
-0.917090416,
0.2573805749,
0.6259157062,
0.9528685808,
0.2014734298,
0.1434700191,
-0.8094993234,
-0.1714904159,
-0.439991504,
0.4108726084,
-0.1852547079,
-0.268330425,
-0.2403122038,
-0.4642505944,
0.2984995544,
-0.4803152978,
0.3002873361,
-0.6206229329,
0.0357811972,
-0.3577931225,
-0.4189925492,
-0.0198247861,
0.1067419499,
-0.5448336005,
0.9579802752,
0.0114820441,
-0.7089326978,
0.2509024143,
-0.1596686989,
-0.0710257292,
0.1762126386,
-0.1013195664,
-0.5277327299,
0.3339634538,
0.5586138368,
0.6007591486,
-0.3569176495,
-0.152337417,
-0.0908626392,
-0.6092665792,
0.2105567604,
-0.5680738091,
0.8037407398,
0.2281247228,
0.0205164384,
0.0831867158,
-0.7547039986,
0.6023525,
-0.1257157773,
-0.5592295527,
-0.2729112208,
-0.1712166965,
-0.2710181177,
0.2515365779,
0.3147628903,
-0.405819416,
0.546723783,
-0.2642177939,
0.753773272,
0.5603483915,
-0.2178083807,
0.5706647038,
0.0867230967,
0.6390559077,
-0.2359014153,
0.4110122025,
0.1394068301,
-0.2375732213,
-0.6801165938,
-0.4858964682,
0.9719475508,
0.5785127282,
-1.2026200294,
0.2490315437,
-0.6755897403,
-0.3199131787,
-0.3328057826,
-0.2160995454,
0.4103086889,
-0.1435056478,
0.2011662573,
-0.5814582109,
-0.4840930402,
-0.6504067779,
-0.0864136592,
-0.0714120716,
-0.5119003654,
0.121331498,
0.2287569195,
0.0242802836,
0.3747031391,
-0.1962000132,
-0.1189716235,
0.1612778604,
0.0670765787,
0.1497171223,
0.486496985,
0.4175916314,
-0.6472246051,
-0.4271197915,
0.0884884745,
-0.7505534291,
0.1630656272,
0.0137368562,
-0.1271806806,
0.0083663529,
0.7008756995,
-0.6378911138,
0.5033848882,
0.6494556665,
-0.2793848217,
0.3417493403,
-0.313524276,
0.1800089031,
-0.919175148,
-0.3882074058,
-0.0122910533,
-0.5229731202,
-0.4727687538,
-0.1775860041,
0.1501723677,
-0.1392368674,
-0.5456228256,
0.1006563604,
-0.5493929982,
-0.5186826587,
-0.0282049216,
-0.0240924787,
-0.0675225854,
0.6071581841,
-0.2878616154,
0.9191760421,
0.3976492882,
-0.6039896607,
0.6180295944,
0.1958149225,
-0.2833794355,
0.3783199787,
-0.8932983875,
0.1710389704,
-0.3467759192,
0.0370894559,
-0.7860876918,
0.2893269062,
0.1494656503,
-0.7195724845,
0.4487832785,
-0.4972489476,
-0.4529545605,
-0.2161999047,
-0.5073933601,
0.7004817724,
0.5960716009,
-0.588514328,
0.7171023488,
0.2763085067,
0.0170075875,
-0.6594102979,
-0.5651054978,
0.2159211934,
-0.2407642454,
-0.571256578,
0.5661350489,
-0.056142766,
-0.0591133945,
0.0224559531,
-0.1819122434,
-0.0785783455,
-0.0407847837,
-0.0136534628,
0.1174005866,
-0.2936624587,
0.1425485909,
0.0737802908,
-0.0995222554,
0.1645140052,
-0.7158634067,
0.3455997407,
-0.1991822869,
0.1721378863,
-0.4857337177,
0.1645295918,
0.2936015129,
-0.4922990501,
0.7790356278,
1.0013537407,
-0.4058697522,
-0.1907911152,
-0.2445915937,
-0.0086515443,
-0.4710488617,
0.4622770548,
-0.4076028168,
-1.0085316896,
0.324963659,
-0.1108588129,
-0.2517732978,
0.2316731662,
0.4738675654,
0.0246367361,
1.0803239346,
0.5547143817,
-0.0362027846,
0.669095993,
-0.7180888057,
0.3638075292,
-1.1020687819,
-0.0183576997,
-0.4112073481,
-0.3441122472,
-0.5671593547,
-0.896266818,
0.4878041446,
0.4043900669,
-0.379235357,
0.0769983903,
-0.5701161623,
0.6966359019,
0.7245159745,
0.0987798646,
0.2118605226,
0.3804366589,
0.2185641527,
-0.2706077993,
-0.9381245375,
-0.1811995655,
1.4570250511,
0.3434852064,
0.5004708767,
0.2676135004,
0.5534586906,
0.2619840205,
0.3059208393,
-1.0612410307,
0.480684042,
-0.3112183809,
0.1622870415,
-0.745164156,
-0.8147522807,
-0.5711305737,
0.6736633778,
-0.302908659,
-0.5855122805,
0.1204973012,
0.1057909578,
-0.7098973989,
0.363085717,
-0.5743291974,
0.6209801435,
-0.0801575333,
-0.3312401474,
-0.1694493294,
-0.5062610507,
0.4261992872,
0.1931526363,
-0.2349104583,
0.0123584857,
-0.214711383,
0.7222228646,
-0.7866944075,
0.339787066,
-0.0869829729,
-0.1629024744,
0.1067240387,
0.09469603,
0.5197618008,
0.4048669934,
0.2414323986,
0.4829702377,
0.1763647646,
-0.370167464,
-1.0431257486,
0.5806319714,
-0.8445842862,
-0.4407093227,
-0.3606473207,
-0.4003359675,
-0.2240877897,
-0.161817953,
0.2377374172,
0.7627908587,
0.1525937468,
0.4144924879,
1.0799827576,
-0.3977635205,
0.5645836592,
0.0577371754,
-0.0497902445,
-0.8818774819,
1.1100698709,
0.2531953156,
0.2108162642,
0.7085440159,
0.026590243,
-0.2865058482,
-0.8791260123,
-0.3789128363,
0.1535775661,
-0.575774312,
-0.5309106708,
-0.5657576919,
-0.4108895659,
-0.3259468973,
0.4381074607,
-0.6671862602,
-0.7468007207,
-0.2089661807,
0.1050124541,
0.3188118637,
0.3739178479,
-0.3311652541,
0.3392750919,
-0.968111515,
0.3838281333,
0.6735642552,
0.2349300683,
-0.0937845856,
-0.799020052,
-0.5823358297,
0.0179699399,
-0.1884802282,
-0.2761521041,
0.6327015758,
0.2046426088,
0.2661918998,
0.2126017809,
-0.2323577702,
0.4102991819,
-0.5087345839,
0.8412108421,
0.2388183773,
-1.1296697855,
0.1450478286,
-0.0953609571,
0.1397361457,
-0.1045248136,
0.4364314973,
-0.51949054,
0.2455467135,
-0.3437496722,
-0.852997005,
0.2721763849,
0.3227605224,
0.1944630593,
0.2573463619,
0.4860011935,
-0.4645427167,
0.4630191326,
-0.4061676264,
-0.4040066302,
-0.368126452,
-0.0502696894,
-0.091767326,
-0.7044910192,
-0.0014519742,
-0.5897085667,
0.6077000499,
-0.3519648612,
0.7881033421,
0.260452956,
0.1514056474,
0.2075679302,
-0.0270543024,
0.6232539415,
0.6912590265,
0.028024992,
0.1057312191,
0.1181010827,
-0.5829313993,
0.2290838808,
-0.0464683399,
0.0445539504,
-0.1201298684,
0.1176826954,
1.0386680365,
-0.1724652201,
-0.1846387833,
0.7747832537,
-0.5087555647,
-0.6239006519,
-0.3722512722,
-0.1467938274,
-0.0970840678,
0.644895196,
0.0969411731,
0.0519656725,
0.2540089786,
-0.0616370328,
-0.0762868822,
0.5190630555,
-0.1088333949,
-0.2056173682,
0.913012445,
0.013141389,
-0.229145214,
0.7893571854,
-0.2371781617,
-0.4716685712,
0.6347787976,
0.1207768992,
0.817193687,
-0.2148999423,
0.5418994427,
0.3558176458,
0.2924990654,
-0.1772298664,
0.4221513867,
-0.1105695218,
-0.8169025779,
-1.0724526644,
-0.660191834,
-0.1466028094,
0.2407551557,
-0.6451205611,
-0.1040398479,
-0.5985202193,
-0.2467260808,
-0.1850402504,
0.0996255577,
-0.7639860511,
0.3564817905,
0.1793087423,
0.6573752761,
-0.2821623981,
0.9954090118,
0.3901111186,
-0.0608473644,
-0.9315946102,
-0.0431643538,
-0.3676726818,
-0.5239893794,
0.7225834727,
-0.179108575,
0.2162520289,
0.3131364584,
-0.6127346158,
-1.1850765944,
1.2864857912,
0.4294120669,
-0.6920782924,
0.1299459934,
0.0441537239,
0.6411580443,
0.0325862579,
0.2743273079,
0.5378608108,
-0.0555253625,
0.0920167863,
-0.6488460302,
-0.0633876324,
-0.2099911869,
0.7635267377,
0.2901510894,
-0.6352066398,
0.8951927423,
-0.2324709296,
-0.0026038524,
0.121222496,
0.9897265434,
-0.1203363612,
-0.2807341516,
0.3101817369,
0.7579855323,
0.9188125134,
-0.0285594221,
1.2544099092,
-0.213733241,
0.5130783319,
0.7328029275,
0.1909344792,
0.7472660542,
0.5881678462,
-0.5803209543,
-0.0006303586,
0.6378022432,
0.1553958356,
0.5089048147,
0.7447258234,
-0.5801778436,
-0.3998502195,
-0.0041807354,
-0.4040476382,
0.3564754128,
0.2805367708,
-0.1049718559,
0.2841745913,
0.1977666914,
-0.209480077,
-0.2677993178,
-0.6054158211,
0.5163474083,
0.1377312094,
-0.0916893259,
1.0119570494,
0.0459622629,
0.5982919335,
-0.2792342007,
-0.0228353962,
-0.3391628563,
0.0724051669,
-0.1169769093,
-0.3590541482,
0.1312868297,
-0.4326527715,
-0.176352784,
-0.3079625666,
0.4157659411,
-0.5177611113,
-0.4707650244,
-0.1952917874,
0.5277676582,
0.1505033821,
-0.4487770796,
-0.4138646126,
0.2175488323,
-0.0486751758,
-0.4462280869,
0.4407629073,
0.6364558935,
0.067820318,
0.6572900414,
0.5489527583,
0.2971987128,
0.2539739013,
0.2107289582,
0.8459717035,
-0.6194523573,
-0.2988700867,
-0.6607666612,
0.3453094065,
-0.0306842253,
-0.2446058095,
0.6341750026,
0.3941292465,
1.0760905743,
-0.087736778,
0.7560715079,
0.2531470954,
0.1232080832,
-0.9123520255,
0.4760525227,
-0.6264804006,
0.5528544784,
0.1536163241,
-0.9965512753,
-0.5412415266,
0.6492227912,
-0.1942614913,
-0.0153156556,
0.7969881296,
0.7195547819,
0.1699160635,
-0.2571179569,
0.6244280338,
-0.03415123,
0.227568835,
0.5637440681,
0.8856583238,
-0.8632499576,
0.5934222341,
-0.3953924179,
-0.1618453562,
0.0877481997,
-0.8103174567,
-0.9309316278,
-0.332942307,
-0.7239682078,
-0.4952928722,
0.0113815991,
0.6866833568,
0.7389404774,
-0.3964266479,
0.0378942043,
0.0328668505,
0.0968254954,
-0.2992556095,
-0.2159262151,
0.4499558806,
-0.032064639,
-0.7052724957,
0.2070066929,
0.2134073079,
0.1891102344,
-0.3942368925,
-0.0913411528,
0.3961311579,
-0.0629850477,
0.9115898013,
0.0655607283,
-0.2965497375,
-0.2442555428,
-0.1321392506,
-0.0595582165,
0.1819248945,
1.1487783194,
-0.7881733775,
0.1949138641,
0.7064190507,
0.7892199159,
0.657607615,
-0.1207724959,
0.5789102316,
-0.8489164114,
0.3126934469,
0.2550495863,
0.2180957049,
0.3790145516,
-0.6372703314,
0.4156810641,
0.2393222004,
-0.76431638,
-0.7111980915,
0.0579286478,
-0.8041194081,
-0.0900026262,
1.156686902,
-0.0593394078,
-0.4172853827,
0.4079802036,
-0.091761604,
0.2455694973,
-0.1722341925,
0.6031412482,
0.3575359881,
0.19549568,
-0.5290338397,
-0.6969618201,
0.8672807813,
0.2691587508,
-0.6537998915,
-0.2431832999,
0.2626131475,
0.1485948414,
-0.2838770449,
0.7522169352,
-0.0901283622,
0.2073644251,
0.1112155616,
0.3111391664,
-0.181348294,
-0.361849755,
-0.6146004796,
-0.0906174779,
-0.1234214157,
-0.38690418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15313v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15313v2
|
ArabianGPT: Native Arabic GPT-based Large Language Model
| 2024-02-23T13:32:47 | 2024-02-26T09:54:47 |
Anis Koubaa, Adel Ammar, Lahouari Ghouti, Omar Najar, Serry Sibaee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The predominance of English and Latin-based large language models (LLMs) has
led to a notable deficit in native Arabic LLMs. This discrepancy is accentuated
by the prevalent inclusion of English tokens in existing Arabic models,
detracting from their efficacy in processing native Arabic's intricate
morphology and syntax. Consequently, there is a theoretical and practical
imperative for developing LLMs predominantly focused on Arabic linguistic
elements. To address this gap, this paper proposes ArabianGPT, a series of
transformer-based models within the ArabianLLM suite designed explicitly for
Arabic. These models, including ArabianGPT-0.1B and ArabianGPT-0.3B, vary in
size and complexity, aligning with the nuanced linguistic characteristics of
Arabic. The AraNizer tokenizer, integral to these models, addresses the unique
morphological aspects of Arabic script, ensuring more accurate text processing.
Empirical results from fine-tuning the models on tasks like sentiment analysis
and summarization demonstrate significant improvements. For sentiment analysis,
the fine-tuned ArabianGPT-0.1B model achieved a remarkable accuracy of 95%, a
substantial increase from the base model's 56%. Similarly, in summarization
tasks, fine-tuned models showed enhanced F1 scores, indicating improved
precision and recall in generating concise summaries. Comparative analysis of
fine-tuned ArabianGPT models against their base versions across various
benchmarks reveals nuanced differences in performance, with fine-tuning
positively impacting specific tasks like question answering and summarization.
These findings underscore the efficacy of fine-tuning in aligning ArabianGPT
models more closely with specific NLP tasks, highlighting the potential of
tailored transformer architectures in advancing Arabic NLP.
|
[
-0.6177396178,
-0.7087877989,
0.3559524715,
0.2927534878,
-0.2829634249,
0.3671839833,
-0.2357657999,
-0.4773179293,
0.1342002451,
0.3840295076,
-0.2603490353,
-0.6419996023,
-0.8734361529,
0.2395305485,
-0.4670425355,
1.2584724426,
-0.3215312064,
-0.1722286195,
0.3544472754,
-0.070730038,
-0.4299547672,
-0.4321015179,
-0.6836205125,
-0.3606023788,
0.2314121723,
0.3593140543,
1.368930459,
0.5367184877,
0.5611283779,
0.2100553215,
-0.1667702198,
0.1720386147,
-0.0655703023,
0.0140645877,
-0.0732792839,
-0.1754767299,
-0.7097297311,
-0.3154359758,
0.442643553,
0.6852007508,
-0.3456537426,
0.1286462247,
-0.0525235422,
0.6338902712,
-0.518148005,
0.204510808,
-0.5823447704,
-0.0471266061,
0.0383873992,
0.3159902096,
-0.1365384758,
-0.0984591916,
0.0308177359,
-0.0875729397,
0.2736225426,
0.0269591752,
0.7151362896,
0.2968126833,
-0.5405796766,
-0.2951982915,
-0.8060716987,
0.6754316688,
-0.8398891091,
0.4125163853,
0.27972579,
0.2838100195,
-0.0192273334,
-0.8717912436,
-0.467923969,
-0.6026292443,
-0.1071162671,
0.1753664315,
-0.2477636039,
0.1684628427,
-0.1229718328,
0.6252622008,
-0.6545342803,
0.0908934474,
-0.1697281301,
-0.0987784192,
0.5099533796,
0.277956903,
0.4130215943,
-0.0659816712,
-0.0812520832,
0.195926711,
-0.9667482972,
-0.0894293636,
0.1623106897,
0.3895798624,
-0.1586182863,
0.5234698653,
-0.2581658363,
0.5507531762,
-0.0349833257,
-0.1671680063,
-0.2626066804,
-0.0008566735,
-0.0385453478,
0.2817286551,
0.5809851885,
0.163864553,
0.3895490766,
-0.2852451801,
-0.4086945653,
0.0797346458,
0.1308321506,
-1.0946004391,
-0.1989605874,
0.2217573822,
-0.4065598845,
-0.1187716797,
-0.0776654407,
-0.2362923175,
-0.1894836575,
-0.302741468,
0.3127639592,
-0.426024735,
-0.1822628379,
0.4366652369,
0.3173902631,
0.2290921956,
0.3896379769,
-1.0210615396,
0.4706560373,
0.7639530301,
1.180410862,
-0.5631012917,
-0.1541997641,
-0.1959627569,
0.3238817751,
-0.2587245107,
0.7196038365,
-0.7035530806,
-0.5389304161,
0.1236663908,
-0.2405773699,
0.1075806171,
-0.3935127556,
0.7047588229,
-0.695792079,
0.0366604663,
0.1444025338,
-0.4745010138,
-0.4036220312,
0.3030349016,
-0.7085852623,
0.8149502873,
0.1128228009,
-0.6202149987,
0.0463447832,
-0.9302087426,
-0.4508847594,
0.0180986039,
0.0276183151,
-0.3756700456,
0.1861265898,
0.5767449141,
0.2877523601,
-0.4447790086,
0.1759486496,
0.3218707442,
-0.6081190705,
-0.078731373,
-0.5325633883,
0.2086989284,
0.1599380821,
-0.3656021059,
0.1452317834,
-0.587408185,
-0.1511459947,
-0.0858785138,
-0.2569454014,
0.1112389117,
0.012620003,
0.4749950767,
0.2000190765,
0.3483379185,
-0.3700508177,
0.2693404257,
-0.5924971104,
0.4116872847,
0.5300883055,
-0.0375645123,
0.3052332103,
-0.3721983731,
0.902954936,
-0.0994602665,
-0.0361727923,
-0.2699887156,
-0.4352203012,
-0.9749960899,
-0.3954711556,
0.3814244568,
0.6047822833,
-0.5466057658,
0.2881020606,
-0.3721882403,
-0.7670902014,
-0.4828301668,
-0.1346545219,
-0.0066465074,
0.2574282289,
0.5185518861,
-0.2268460989,
-0.1488506943,
-1.1451157331,
-0.4334791303,
0.009762642,
0.0107621402,
0.0181258358,
0.5081470609,
-0.2343659699,
0.9459275007,
-0.3992522955,
-0.2018047869,
-0.5909838676,
0.1792432964,
0.5798953176,
0.3384843767,
0.3640331924,
-0.7046231627,
-1.0247573853,
0.3649831414,
-0.2461867034,
-0.2318133712,
0.1612976789,
0.2913191319,
0.2960709929,
0.4557416439,
-0.9393641949,
0.4965432286,
0.5939180255,
-0.3774076998,
0.5899267793,
-0.0028746517,
-0.0357346982,
-1.1534816027,
0.0104866195,
-0.1689675599,
-0.3558772802,
-0.6393480301,
0.1457847208,
-0.0807435364,
-0.1130845696,
-0.4812833667,
0.7175280452,
-0.2981024683,
0.2068575323,
-0.7196632028,
-0.2876670063,
-0.185820058,
0.3393388093,
0.1194238588,
1.4231327772,
0.3738869429,
-0.3507517278,
0.0940376222,
0.2840904593,
-0.2721551359,
-0.0003633461,
-1.1928061247,
0.2231712341,
-0.2250775546,
-0.017026322,
-0.800435245,
0.0045054704,
-0.0937278122,
-0.1685162932,
0.2977049351,
-0.2657282948,
-0.4586287439,
0.2109217048,
-0.1850888282,
0.2906760871,
0.8184210658,
-0.2531232536,
1.0246409178,
0.0694716796,
-0.8496646881,
-0.5316331387,
-0.1059942469,
0.2593609393,
-0.1934145093,
-0.6192576289,
0.5984497666,
0.4462898076,
-0.2260571569,
-0.2170194238,
-0.1139535308,
0.1793639213,
0.0290248822,
0.3254571855,
0.1709051281,
-0.4004662633,
0.0688770562,
0.1912643611,
-0.3510349691,
-0.0919952095,
-0.3240911961,
0.8819239736,
-0.5146266818,
-0.4694749713,
-0.192553103,
0.5509422421,
0.54945153,
-0.6301614642,
0.9591369033,
0.7804529071,
-0.1649893075,
-0.0783676282,
-0.4371936619,
-0.1136656106,
-0.5130525827,
0.8181126118,
-0.4503017962,
-0.9551488161,
0.5200680494,
-0.1818009019,
0.10260389,
0.5316118002,
0.8337929249,
0.2577596009,
1.4312926531,
0.8106735945,
-0.4245126247,
0.1721525937,
-0.012139813,
0.3755255938,
-0.6545109749,
0.2803897262,
-0.4869191051,
-0.2404707074,
-0.8053497076,
-0.1359756589,
0.6453322768,
0.1179236546,
-0.6431639194,
-0.0847911835,
-0.1908975393,
0.6754466295,
0.5108460784,
-0.2620380223,
0.5199094415,
0.3229591548,
0.0773974732,
-0.131842941,
-0.5465862155,
-1.0485570431,
1.0275422335,
0.3592147827,
0.7318248153,
0.5078716278,
0.3329955339,
0.4945478439,
0.4537653327,
-0.73104316,
0.2400805503,
-0.2426973134,
-0.1965079606,
-0.039534919,
0.0940331519,
-0.7717968225,
0.2695510685,
0.0835423693,
-0.6395416856,
-0.3723963201,
-0.0020170354,
-0.281876266,
0.1733555943,
-0.5895957351,
0.7666010857,
0.047627572,
-0.3211202621,
-0.1753720492,
-0.4395179749,
0.0690047964,
-0.1166646928,
-0.0434165448,
-0.1449434459,
-0.235717833,
0.6136496067,
-0.4871391356,
0.7151132226,
0.1105500609,
-0.1731970608,
0.2011055946,
0.4016500413,
0.7175042033,
0.1259702146,
-0.0725316107,
0.3209167719,
-0.1649185121,
-0.517763257,
-0.5484076738,
0.536759913,
-1.0161299706,
-0.9174893498,
-0.475561738,
-0.7021875978,
-0.4320067167,
0.1203798354,
0.0212242678,
0.1535688788,
-0.1754063815,
-0.1232543215,
0.2395268977,
-0.1644133478,
0.4177302718,
0.69345963,
-0.5300776362,
-0.2484004945,
0.7258533835,
-0.1476555765,
0.2219500989,
0.2778978348,
-0.1172707677,
-0.2703157365,
-0.9667827487,
-0.6155426502,
0.2311581075,
-0.7031591535,
-0.2598674595,
-0.5876915455,
-0.3228101134,
-0.0471661128,
-0.1108174399,
-0.4077059925,
-0.5706761479,
0.061120525,
-0.160190165,
0.6048566699,
0.949694097,
0.1972844154,
0.777590096,
-0.9827492237,
0.0592219457,
0.1605411917,
0.1412750632,
0.076741159,
-0.8059856296,
-0.2750716209,
0.0478866696,
-0.5622680187,
-0.7123224139,
0.662617743,
0.3413321078,
-0.0868279263,
0.1617583334,
-0.3578900695,
0.393896699,
-0.8972468376,
0.8920061588,
-0.2428620905,
-1.0737961531,
0.3756174743,
-0.5103083253,
0.3882055879,
0.405823499,
0.4615879357,
-0.944875896,
-0.3842645586,
-0.3002638519,
-0.9671087861,
0.4843005538,
0.4441373944,
0.3548008204,
-0.0427024253,
0.4752496183,
0.2782011628,
0.211254552,
-0.5303862095,
-0.3298719525,
-0.0815627053,
-0.5166196823,
-0.1734104007,
-0.143106088,
0.3414081335,
-0.1625527889,
0.8589912057,
-0.1523923129,
0.0722323731,
0.0165489558,
-0.2731972933,
0.2034918815,
0.3625008464,
0.6003239751,
0.7321738005,
-0.2052478194,
0.0849733651,
0.2662045658,
-0.909783721,
0.2727103829,
0.2904008925,
-0.3362449408,
0.1687710732,
0.566998899,
0.6158955693,
-0.3330671787,
-0.652793467,
0.3868653178,
0.0324040689,
0.3332836926,
-0.4317939579,
0.1348580569,
0.2334484011,
0.0988250524,
0.4390995204,
0.0089357039,
0.2371840328,
-0.3039496541,
0.0154289557,
0.4669040143,
-0.4161348939,
-0.3619192839,
0.6187210679,
0.0842008516,
-0.3421929479,
0.6531122923,
-0.0442562401,
-0.8129769564,
0.627104342,
0.7297453284,
0.6260439754,
-0.3131542504,
0.0904558226,
0.0275758356,
0.3316794336,
0.1398540437,
0.2590023279,
0.2656012774,
-0.7384298444,
-0.7757507563,
-0.7720857263,
-0.5035454035,
-0.0112585919,
-0.3559325933,
0.1927679777,
-0.3300660551,
-0.0077894675,
-0.1209990308,
-0.0152428346,
-0.5925926566,
0.1012781337,
0.0299195349,
1.006128788,
-0.7911570668,
0.7257400155,
0.9005622268,
-0.4707752764,
-0.8910382986,
-0.0606496818,
-0.4158194661,
-1.0596665144,
0.6801959276,
0.1408542991,
-0.2580497563,
0.2600132227,
-0.3375367522,
-0.9457820058,
0.9512730837,
0.3181246817,
-0.4822754264,
0.1311679482,
0.7296124697,
0.5179384351,
-0.2504287958,
0.5916745663,
0.7440391183,
0.3165491223,
-0.0850237086,
-1.1983873844,
-0.0913210511,
-0.2546664178,
0.1581872702,
0.6270722151,
-0.7072342038,
1.1222242117,
0.0355323106,
0.038641613,
0.1496947557,
0.7206783295,
0.1500187218,
-0.2867582142,
-0.0188263059,
0.4535544515,
0.3943677247,
-0.0588983782,
1.151565671,
-0.6517569423,
0.2947643697,
0.8848139644,
-0.3782663643,
0.8389149308,
0.4647548497,
-0.3731164336,
0.57299155,
0.2907457352,
0.2464802712,
0.4857953787,
0.1229317263,
-0.7255123258,
-0.2450940758,
-0.3818053305,
-0.5435319543,
0.6599949002,
0.3248703182,
-0.3201184571,
-0.3842775524,
-0.1199615821,
0.3304221928,
-0.014237212,
-0.5814303756,
0.7089725733,
0.1517280042,
-0.5075421333,
0.5433703661,
0.7771959305,
0.6694870591,
-0.6480605006,
-0.2242639661,
-0.5680395365,
0.1373865306,
-0.0750714689,
-0.4750608206,
0.2487415373,
0.143149361,
-0.1740965843,
0.1058079526,
0.8296551704,
-0.3484198451,
-0.9245730042,
-0.2839960754,
0.8065712452,
0.0148794521,
-0.4953448772,
-0.4417175651,
0.035545636,
-0.0008781161,
-0.2573780417,
0.137074843,
0.2575723529,
-0.3241535425,
0.5926626325,
0.5474156737,
0.3023518622,
-0.2297256291,
0.0963499025,
0.6401412487,
-0.8446799517,
-0.5518760085,
-1.2008692026,
0.3104039729,
0.1590489298,
-0.1694203317,
0.6382918358,
0.5011694431,
0.358264178,
-0.2373274863,
0.9024276733,
0.3026790321,
0.4329048991,
-0.6339584589,
0.858712554,
-0.213438943,
0.1730059087,
0.0384590179,
-1.1309844255,
-0.3588504493,
0.7600788474,
-0.400321722,
0.4142151773,
0.5241256356,
0.8062535524,
-0.2008771598,
0.2765363455,
0.0931367353,
0.2033844888,
0.565042913,
0.6056001782,
1.0498937368,
-0.5037362576,
0.1830897182,
0.0264260229,
0.0542861931,
-0.0572641753,
-0.897004962,
-0.9555487037,
-0.1501490623,
-0.2266167849,
-0.0542296655,
0.1514268219,
1.2486433983,
0.5008894205,
-0.9036331773,
-0.1868966967,
-0.2304638624,
-0.1843976229,
0.1256771237,
-0.1989656538,
0.8438849449,
-0.1931482553,
-0.7034956217,
0.0755091906,
0.4054671228,
0.3152039945,
-0.1680822223,
-0.1625269651,
0.2596410811,
0.0118232286,
0.7204092741,
-0.0906154662,
-0.6810586452,
-0.2157817483,
0.0001303656,
0.0921779722,
0.1317413151,
0.5489438772,
-0.8791741729,
-0.2192749977,
-0.1776879877,
0.7429170609,
0.5066968203,
0.0042590108,
0.6588482261,
-0.6294112802,
0.3383798897,
0.4585529566,
0.3822430372,
0.4108720124,
-0.0659262016,
0.4006689191,
-0.3558258414,
-0.4498547018,
-0.4466249347,
0.3374418318,
-0.6025339961,
-0.037389636,
1.0606862307,
0.095170185,
0.1083444357,
-0.2144249529,
-0.5944281816,
-0.0145892752,
-0.3840799332,
0.9272319674,
0.9818680286,
-0.0754557699,
-0.1359197497,
-0.6355192661,
0.5732524991,
0.802978158,
-0.6842859983,
-0.2101886719,
0.2179457396,
0.1496434361,
0.0570427999,
0.338370651,
0.1028238386,
0.371111542,
-0.2985191941,
0.0919695199,
-0.1549351662,
-0.1146994457,
-0.3170087039,
0.2358599603,
0.6782253981,
0.2388730645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15309v1
|
Counterfactual Generation with Identifiability Guarantees
| 2024-02-23T13:24:19 | 2024-02-23T13:24:19 |
Hanqi Yan, Lingjing Kong, Lin Gui, Yuejie Chi, Eric Xing, Yulan He, Kun Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Counterfactual generation lies at the core of various machine learning tasks,
including image translation and controllable text generation. This generation
process usually requires the identification of the disentangled latent
representations, such as content and style, that underlie the observed data.
However, it becomes more challenging when faced with a scarcity of paired data
and labeling information. Existing disentangled methods crucially rely on
oversimplified assumptions, such as assuming independent content and style
variables, to identify the latent variables, even though such assumptions may
not hold for complex data distributions. For instance, food reviews tend to
involve words like tasty, whereas movie reviews commonly contain words such as
thrilling for the same positive sentiment. This problem is exacerbated when
data are sampled from multiple domains since the dependence between content and
style may vary significantly over domains. In this work, we tackle the
domain-varying dependence between the content and the style variables inherent
in the counterfactual generation task. We provide identification guarantees for
such latent-variable models by leveraging the relative sparsity of the
influences from different latent variables. Our theoretical insights enable the
development of a doMain AdapTive counTerfactual gEneration model, called
(MATTE). Our theoretically grounded framework achieves state-of-the-art
performance in unsupervised style transfer tasks, where neither paired data nor
style labels are utilized, across four large-scale datasets. Code is available
at https://github.com/hanqi-qi/Matte.git
|
[
-0.6265749335,
-1.00015378,
0.5969733,
0.1955185682,
-0.3292749822,
0.1571096182,
-0.0949825868,
-0.1042547077,
0.0448129736,
0.4407752156,
-0.805642724,
-0.2191926688,
-0.7269808054,
-0.1690994203,
-0.3730735481,
1.2599425316,
-0.3141900599,
-0.055646427,
-0.436722964,
-0.2632848024,
-0.3738142848,
-0.4064664841,
-0.2921299338,
-0.3594084382,
0.2954233885,
0.2427497804,
0.7645506263,
0.0092540067,
0.2739084959,
0.2693901956,
0.4604005516,
0.4698567092,
-0.4689030051,
0.1234305501,
-0.5353131294,
-0.1327468306,
-0.2544082403,
0.4229250848,
0.2405203581,
0.5316640139,
0.0241925567,
0.0602957718,
0.0877560824,
0.6165340543,
-0.6504644156,
0.0523197576,
-0.7472664118,
0.0193800647,
-0.02500524,
-0.2706778049,
-0.4252806604,
-0.2189812064,
-0.0656268522,
-0.7457926273,
0.514890492,
-0.1129302159,
1.064150691,
0.336707741,
-0.413222611,
-0.1689449996,
-0.8729194999,
0.9049524665,
-0.4824961424,
0.3452686965,
0.6283827424,
0.1079984009,
-0.2832380533,
-0.6090808511,
-0.9607669711,
0.0185495391,
-0.1417507976,
0.4050727189,
-0.3312297463,
-0.3285758495,
0.0959682092,
0.2171488851,
-0.6478579044,
-0.0991893709,
0.1719734669,
0.045239117,
0.638587296,
-0.0026883853,
0.2721726894,
-0.0087526534,
-0.5168706775,
-0.2298864871,
-0.7187021971,
-0.2438501567,
0.2414328605,
-0.0393801816,
-0.177717939,
0.3686293066,
-0.1030017212,
0.2271595895,
0.5140963793,
0.2085212171,
0.3521147668,
-0.5651645064,
-0.1215265542,
-0.1532888412,
0.6958372593,
0.6783635616,
0.1198145151,
-0.1072925627,
-0.3002629876,
0.1874039024,
0.4799066186,
-0.8669516444,
-0.3597770035,
0.2143486738,
-0.1937560588,
-0.3471440971,
0.0732038394,
-0.9631189704,
-0.4428091049,
-0.3126352131,
0.6153081059,
-0.3112872243,
-0.3977893591,
-0.1908037364,
-0.1721615642,
0.0013136576,
0.3353896439,
-0.6918324828,
0.209963873,
0.3229360878,
0.7416807413,
-0.2933424413,
-0.1756554544,
-0.518987,
0.0020153199,
-0.8169502616,
0.4030708373,
-0.5508642793,
-0.4212106764,
-0.0314410254,
0.2559711337,
-0.1375974566,
-0.4755372107,
-0.0242975708,
-0.7101051211,
0.147175312,
-0.4275440872,
-0.4060741663,
-0.101327911,
0.0253761169,
-0.5662885904,
0.8085669279,
0.3767704368,
-0.8656402826,
0.5868837237,
-0.3961185813,
-0.4002911747,
0.0609786585,
-0.3894022405,
-0.9676837921,
0.3600527942,
0.0380401909,
0.3692513108,
-0.1598737836,
0.6601141691,
-0.5560125113,
-0.121682249,
0.5781621337,
-0.5795410275,
0.5179851055,
0.2770885229,
-0.645924747,
0.00986904,
-0.7398794293,
-0.2819091082,
0.3719174564,
0.1092153564,
-0.2778404653,
0.0170234274,
0.3173594177,
0.2478106171,
0.0090233432,
-0.6023232341,
0.0034531837,
0.230775997,
0.2563124895,
0.698497057,
0.4050492346,
0.2107902467,
-0.4793751836,
0.3412936926,
0.5038874149,
-0.126341939,
-0.2150469422,
-0.2494851798,
-0.6704284549,
-0.2478631884,
0.1768503487,
0.5151501894,
-1.284337163,
0.1534852386,
0.0297105536,
-0.2977276444,
0.0219624992,
0.1010141373,
0.6772910357,
0.5803858638,
0.5667434931,
-0.3855265081,
-0.5481901765,
-0.845066309,
-0.011462112,
-0.1179916859,
0.023492001,
0.4185223877,
0.4999567866,
-0.260722518,
1.0220482349,
-0.6763179302,
-0.1329651922,
0.0218010992,
0.743891418,
0.0326307379,
0.8887891769,
0.9173795581,
-1.2047926188,
-0.4792640507,
-0.1860290468,
-0.6838801503,
-0.1637732834,
-0.5970261097,
-0.05157087,
0.4253983498,
0.6805855036,
-0.3503685296,
0.5516468287,
0.5243411064,
-0.137328282,
0.5220973492,
-0.1248388439,
0.4158955216,
-1.1324425936,
0.1206613109,
0.458001107,
-0.1144996583,
-0.5240790844,
-0.1277260333,
-0.1682939827,
0.1100937128,
-0.3621399701,
0.5619018674,
-0.1534313709,
0.1353424788,
-0.208502993,
-0.1667153537,
0.3336256444,
0.7505401373,
0.3981096148,
0.815677166,
0.4433250427,
-0.336583674,
0.0424032658,
0.175284043,
-0.1803192049,
0.9620800018,
-0.6659522653,
0.1786381751,
-0.2495558858,
0.2944819927,
-1.3262395859,
-0.2068320364,
0.2178718895,
-0.297938168,
0.4071294963,
-0.2929515243,
-0.475977838,
-0.0989957452,
-0.2361337095,
0.2295662314,
0.4111735225,
-0.6741982698,
0.36599648,
0.2538565099,
-0.1454528272,
-0.5489776134,
-0.6678082347,
0.0798262805,
-0.3408677578,
-0.1499195099,
0.5182371736,
-0.5605648756,
-0.2049476504,
-0.0189087931,
-0.2430699319,
-0.2146880329,
0.2006171793,
0.4473625124,
0.5486112833,
-0.2351796478,
0.0976657197,
0.2443781942,
0.048133105,
-0.0130239641,
-0.3816975951,
0.2163366824,
-0.053633552,
-0.2736951411,
-0.0323889442,
0.4754920304,
0.5017219782,
-0.1491332054,
0.6925064325,
0.9330483079,
-0.3974163532,
-0.3308447897,
-0.3879873753,
-0.0494920425,
-0.4664919674,
0.4509336948,
-0.569801271,
-0.3234136701,
0.5520379543,
-0.0535252243,
-0.001475932,
0.4254411459,
0.3657903969,
-0.127927646,
0.9598858356,
0.5156786442,
0.3562680781,
0.6222705245,
-0.0971054062,
0.0314520299,
-0.5210100412,
-0.0865331441,
-0.1478271782,
-0.1110184193,
-0.7561845183,
-0.3320140243,
0.3113311827,
0.1399527788,
-0.2067238837,
0.1250950396,
-0.1598006338,
0.4293732643,
0.4644974768,
0.1901002675,
0.0524767786,
0.163991645,
-0.1993606538,
-0.1411387175,
-0.3808303177,
-0.3397299051,
0.8375108242,
0.1034150869,
0.6938592196,
0.2467633039,
0.4640601277,
0.5724828243,
0.2258075178,
-0.458886385,
0.4046781063,
-0.7103453875,
-0.3777253628,
-0.1160655767,
-0.4145205319,
-0.6499764323,
0.051666759,
-0.4759643376,
-0.7071096897,
0.5317189693,
0.2322752178,
-0.0746062621,
0.1774618179,
-0.6476333141,
0.6724529862,
-0.0429293811,
-0.8209792972,
-0.0392070673,
-0.5028308034,
0.177711919,
-0.6247859001,
-0.0122822234,
0.0843143985,
0.2860880792,
0.7413646579,
-0.273761332,
1.0189017057,
-0.1734766662,
-0.2180259824,
0.3088804185,
0.3797522485,
0.3349501491,
0.3256940246,
0.2251971215,
0.4120122194,
-0.0325772576,
-0.2963567972,
-0.7165982127,
0.860706389,
-0.8272975087,
-0.6071417928,
-0.1864775866,
-0.3843556046,
-0.5247993469,
0.4329373837,
0.5258911252,
0.6048974395,
-0.3628067672,
0.128725186,
0.7699955106,
-0.2339543104,
0.6127578616,
0.5759320259,
0.0176683404,
-0.4118709266,
1.3525308371,
0.3677245677,
0.236839667,
0.2778875828,
0.1418386102,
-0.4137653112,
-0.5112802982,
-0.7357767224,
-0.0992620066,
-0.6401163936,
-0.0336755551,
-0.578671515,
-0.2973918617,
-0.0841067061,
-0.3736409247,
-0.4666487873,
-0.3771632612,
-0.4041888118,
0.0920215026,
0.3127652705,
0.7488217354,
-0.1970008016,
0.1904445142,
-0.4460274577,
0.6196494102,
0.3391819894,
0.427003324,
-0.1614905,
-0.4258431196,
-0.145104602,
0.0322936997,
-0.3166275024,
-0.7153084278,
0.3426190317,
0.1493653953,
0.4725656211,
0.2538083792,
0.3326183856,
0.3484694362,
-0.4414264262,
0.724296391,
0.3471926153,
-0.9727822542,
0.4329053164,
-0.4414545,
0.1239545122,
0.4999741614,
0.6331451535,
-0.352927655,
-0.4108237326,
-0.8265537024,
-0.8170276284,
0.5386324525,
0.0903591216,
0.0969714448,
-0.0631092563,
0.1766920686,
0.5080422163,
0.4685856104,
-0.4608003497,
-0.1823914349,
-0.9415217042,
-0.2106155008,
-0.324303329,
-0.0687091127,
-0.3746183813,
0.3327253759,
0.7561171055,
-0.3286927938,
-0.0203922335,
0.2027066946,
-0.1925371289,
-0.2830571532,
0.2008315921,
0.7145547271,
0.5952875018,
-0.352078557,
0.4503512979,
-0.2810456455,
-0.5214506388,
0.2029921263,
0.1964824349,
-0.277320981,
0.0733172372,
0.2093501985,
0.7424616814,
-0.2607292831,
-0.2676385045,
0.6745886803,
-0.141637221,
-0.2430962324,
-0.2718653977,
0.0265136342,
-0.3384183049,
0.1031220183,
0.4515149295,
0.3337008953,
-0.0170346089,
-0.3635575771,
0.7606240511,
0.4199324846,
-0.435757637,
-0.559546411,
0.7214176059,
0.0958549678,
0.1198327988,
0.4629025757,
-0.4266588092,
-0.2921542823,
0.7139151692,
0.5649824739,
1.0101709366,
-0.0338465422,
0.5348860025,
0.4164401591,
-0.0335437134,
0.1612336934,
-0.0057981028,
-0.0239761602,
-0.9093792439,
-0.0666467622,
-0.4599356651,
-0.2944896519,
0.5593752861,
-0.5815113187,
0.0146289533,
-0.5229691863,
-0.2419596314,
0.1082286611,
0.0299232844,
-0.6112797856,
0.503305614,
0.2009079307,
0.2470680177,
-1.3970535994,
0.6331292391,
0.5716061592,
-0.6813413501,
-0.2642740309,
0.3374165595,
0.2068163902,
-0.5457268357,
0.675835371,
-0.0706780329,
-0.3248736262,
-0.1760812104,
-0.6009681225,
-0.7147367597,
0.733313024,
0.2984437048,
-0.5320267081,
0.4258374274,
0.0312843435,
0.529260993,
-0.4541612566,
0.0696164817,
0.2414391786,
0.3420707583,
0.4293156862,
-0.5374314785,
0.2864554226,
-0.3912944496,
0.0375886895,
-0.2448935956,
-0.5806522965,
0.745046556,
-0.309917748,
-0.3466076553,
-0.0429172851,
0.5725668669,
0.2004822493,
0.5874116421,
0.5097523928,
0.2234683931,
0.4564280212,
-0.0786915496,
0.6688088179,
-0.2707891464,
0.3565506041,
1.3905795813,
-0.2364456207,
0.5274859667,
0.4781632125,
-0.0542164408,
0.4634270668,
0.7900370359,
-0.3035216331,
0.6764212251,
-0.0414968245,
-0.0180094596,
-0.2762781084,
-0.5579024553,
-0.1884863973,
0.4834145606,
0.3206813931,
-0.344176203,
-0.007051317,
-0.1211238801,
0.2265283316,
0.2153303325,
0.0071224016,
0.6799764037,
-0.1034418121,
-0.7955245972,
0.6987795234,
-0.190815568,
0.4608078897,
-0.3333019614,
-0.509583652,
-0.4500215948,
0.0923628062,
-0.2323081493,
-0.7635580301,
0.1469359249,
-0.2539132833,
-0.4379323125,
-0.2671152651,
0.5556249022,
-0.5020309687,
-0.5418806672,
0.0482252203,
0.5065782666,
-0.2072304934,
0.3310527802,
-0.6075000763,
0.0551000163,
-0.0661301762,
-0.3149428368,
0.3788665533,
0.3845216036,
-0.3130952716,
0.1929866672,
0.545294404,
-0.1463922262,
-0.1824333221,
0.0009134778,
0.7869880199,
-0.2847909927,
-0.5195474029,
-0.7432602644,
0.3418187201,
-0.0408742875,
-0.2775220573,
0.654741466,
0.2331366092,
0.8688374758,
-0.2703620195,
0.8411887288,
-0.0110041331,
0.1233907491,
-0.6146928072,
0.7178507447,
-0.7186162472,
0.1982501,
-0.5436906815,
-0.7083261013,
-0.0602686144,
0.2765128314,
-0.2495107949,
0.2723471522,
0.5768819451,
0.8546974659,
-0.2018951923,
-0.2149990052,
0.3083424568,
0.1441086978,
0.3454990983,
0.3708604574,
0.6551132202,
-0.2408869117,
0.0688212663,
-0.1105384231,
-0.2023877352,
-0.1574577838,
-1.0278320312,
-0.7236152291,
-1.0667761564,
-0.8627912998,
-0.5308895111,
0.0527856909,
0.6165580153,
0.996378541,
-0.9056376219,
0.3121851981,
-0.1929889768,
0.1610788852,
-0.3698790967,
-0.2595850527,
0.313131988,
0.0602192581,
-0.7916559577,
0.2471672595,
0.1834617853,
0.443123877,
-0.1938538551,
0.0458864719,
-0.0819858611,
0.6192784905,
0.3922032416,
0.3457129598,
-0.5318847299,
-0.330733031,
-0.3640004694,
-0.004343912,
0.1431987882,
0.6738678217,
-0.6861139536,
0.5617850423,
0.3281443119,
0.5677483678,
0.3767940104,
0.0627704114,
0.4605897069,
-1.1908172369,
-0.0386124738,
-0.3108783364,
0.3048992753,
0.3492474258,
-0.4719681442,
0.5042902231,
0.5605918169,
-0.1773529351,
-0.6452207565,
0.5217171907,
-0.8827049732,
-0.5319593549,
1.0191832781,
-0.4233752191,
-0.0162164494,
-0.0757739842,
0.1521538645,
0.2346706837,
-0.3215821385,
0.8036115766,
0.5588122606,
-0.1407871246,
-0.0962717012,
-0.2322596759,
0.4789705276,
0.4397732019,
-0.6382777095,
0.084676452,
0.6404177547,
0.351872623,
0.3879537582,
0.5380871892,
0.0143257622,
0.2789732218,
0.3024939895,
-0.142828688,
-0.0868709907,
-0.4945363402,
-0.1122087464,
0.1676107496,
-0.1176843196,
-0.369943589
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.