id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14536v1
|
Domain Generalization via Causal Adjustment for Cross-Domain Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-22T13:26:56 | 2024-02-22T13:26:56 |
Siyin Wang, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Domain adaption has been widely adapted for cross-domain sentiment analysis
to transfer knowledge from the source domain to the target domain. Whereas,
most methods are proposed under the assumption that the target (test) domain is
known, making them fail to generalize well on unknown test data that is not
always available in practice. In this paper, we focus on the problem of domain
generalization for cross-domain sentiment analysis. Specifically, we propose a
backdoor adjustment-based causal model to disentangle the domain-specific and
domain-invariant representations that play essential roles in tackling domain
shift. First, we rethink the cross-domain sentiment analysis task in a causal
view to model the causal-and-effect relationships among different variables.
Then, to learn an invariant feature representation, we remove the effect of
domain confounders (e.g., domain knowledge) using the backdoor adjustment. A
series of experiments over many homologous and diverse datasets show the great
performance and robustness of our model by comparing it with the
state-of-the-art domain generalization baselines.
|
[
-0.2448707074,
-0.8219145536,
0.4726627767,
0.362244606,
-0.1743582636,
0.0761121139,
-0.3519568741,
-0.2946742177,
0.0512461551,
0.3256903887,
-0.798369348,
-0.6800404191,
-1.0882070065,
-0.0361033753,
0.0712035,
1.2580018044,
-0.1767103821,
0.0198140275,
-0.1503844112,
-0.3536276221,
-0.9113146663,
-0.4387378395,
-0.607554853,
-0.2393409908,
0.761652112,
0.0340729542,
0.6741817594,
-0.0139468946,
0.5193269253,
0.1272490919,
0.2471060455,
-0.0020879228,
-0.6159692407,
-0.0396233089,
-0.9466511607,
-0.4307620823,
-0.6822337508,
0.1528134793,
0.4608494043,
1.0095649958,
0.1942782998,
0.2105082572,
0.2468458712,
0.4805538654,
-0.7461985946,
0.2342398614,
-0.6700366735,
-0.0532508157,
0.1939733773,
-0.2967758179,
-0.4676103294,
-0.4343327284,
0.2128694504,
-0.7189991474,
0.5224760771,
0.1846776754,
0.7487896681,
0.2555409968,
-0.6161810756,
0.1880452484,
-0.9807665348,
1.0371400118,
-0.4542266428,
0.4005525708,
0.1388602406,
0.3116585612,
-0.0908620283,
-0.441875428,
-0.3541854918,
0.2907909155,
-0.0417673886,
0.29496786,
-0.5440716743,
-0.3915559053,
0.1436483115,
0.1206231937,
-0.576154232,
-0.1213808432,
-0.0935178325,
-0.190261364,
0.7350974083,
0.2962032259,
0.3209446967,
0.2807054222,
-0.5846882463,
-0.052424714,
-0.8414728045,
0.1824609935,
0.1528275907,
0.540995121,
-0.088709347,
0.1331570446,
0.0056160595,
0.5569320917,
0.3856289089,
0.4134995341,
0.1592523456,
0.0235379636,
-0.3567456305,
-0.2176802754,
0.2643841207,
0.5858816504,
0.3358774185,
-0.2515108585,
-0.0973330885,
0.2471629232,
0.6419645548,
-0.5087666512,
-0.1492295116,
0.0421336107,
-0.6257869601,
-0.2583391368,
0.0974121541,
-0.9095277786,
-0.4187522233,
-0.3497590721,
0.5845783949,
-0.0508409776,
-0.4202034175,
0.2502898276,
-0.3571033478,
0.2692288756,
0.4266170859,
-0.7531086802,
0.3135493994,
0.7098876834,
0.5140550733,
-0.4270048141,
-0.5191524029,
-0.4145025611,
0.2133566737,
-0.3867905736,
0.559823513,
-0.877012372,
-0.3086428046,
0.2835702896,
0.2268307805,
-0.563990891,
-0.4694690704,
0.2438870072,
-1.1091573238,
0.1062802449,
-0.3788619936,
-0.4252242148,
-0.4660773873,
0.3751071393,
-0.5742986798,
0.5135563016,
0.2311423719,
-0.7596199512,
0.5572185516,
-0.2556442916,
-0.5972694755,
-0.5340067148,
0.143122226,
-0.6402667165,
0.4693442583,
0.4296559691,
0.52260077,
-0.4155265093,
0.4002854228,
-0.6515817642,
-0.1305619776,
0.3933444619,
-0.1072784364,
0.8337627053,
-0.1390135437,
-0.4817237556,
-0.1483336538,
-0.5227931738,
-0.3446677923,
0.0771933645,
0.1329955161,
-0.9933930039,
-0.0894820169,
-0.2749046981,
0.274223268,
0.0104333647,
-0.5672321916,
0.2147394717,
-0.2299449444,
-0.2530291677,
0.8855258822,
0.4362650812,
0.6052512527,
-0.1134703383,
0.5834226608,
0.5953103304,
0.4222337902,
0.4795446992,
-0.5661934018,
-0.5559179187,
-0.0792487711,
0.3834667802,
0.4751657546,
-0.6585270762,
0.4714835286,
-0.2656988502,
-0.0643068254,
-0.1427910775,
-0.0143471221,
0.189517647,
0.4075184762,
0.5634319782,
-0.5226214528,
-0.2076035291,
-0.6268061399,
-0.9122718573,
-0.0579293221,
0.2201331854,
0.0124972276,
0.4907765388,
-0.5342171192,
0.9546182752,
-1.059163332,
-0.4628595412,
0.0301862508,
0.3144339025,
-0.0197415184,
0.3780999482,
0.6483809352,
-0.8707497716,
-0.2841194272,
-0.0139753874,
-0.8591654897,
-0.0515513793,
-0.232115075,
-0.3682796061,
0.0355388373,
0.4415958822,
-0.3681949675,
0.5576356649,
0.5447135568,
-0.3860501647,
0.3379584849,
0.3070933521,
0.0688316151,
-0.9190036058,
-0.024853779,
0.2210942358,
-0.0785429478,
-0.7222716808,
0.0005046354,
0.0324683525,
-0.0071599693,
-0.1870643198,
0.6246984601,
-0.3018330932,
0.1407973021,
-0.2106419951,
0.019289216,
0.0839218497,
0.8103242517,
0.014524647,
0.2872049809,
0.7599130869,
-0.5812499523,
0.1775081456,
0.1362826675,
0.3269316852,
0.8332520127,
-0.3458995223,
-0.0560115688,
-0.0517777503,
0.3505078256,
-1.0724332333,
0.1807772964,
0.6795476675,
-0.5543974638,
0.4032145143,
-0.1418746561,
0.1636489928,
0.0207213443,
-0.2836861014,
0.6161741614,
0.4507083297,
-0.6944358349,
0.853610754,
0.2619386315,
-0.2080996633,
-0.5379238725,
-0.388941884,
-0.1596196741,
-0.332054913,
-0.5459774733,
0.4409076571,
0.1303014308,
-0.2104991823,
0.2412636727,
-0.2056406289,
-0.1058626845,
-0.171109885,
0.2552249134,
0.1916569918,
-0.2719577253,
0.3523716927,
0.3856529593,
-0.12313582,
0.5105113983,
-0.4403610528,
0.1117590293,
0.2914575636,
-0.1543751806,
-0.0041278847,
0.5132781863,
0.4960061014,
-0.0635554567,
0.7398263812,
0.548001349,
-0.3381994069,
-0.8368992209,
-0.2172448635,
-0.2326413542,
-0.4026755691,
0.0646723881,
-0.443628937,
-0.8793114424,
0.638738811,
-0.6593040824,
-0.2866486609,
0.7423194647,
0.4305384755,
0.0545656458,
1.0328661203,
1.0329351425,
-0.3606003523,
0.2573036849,
-0.1258706003,
0.5307035446,
-0.8683316708,
-0.0234349836,
-0.3089805543,
-0.3221637011,
-0.4719497561,
-0.178915143,
0.1436104923,
-0.1717151552,
-0.2341059446,
0.0893213972,
-0.0269541573,
-0.0232895892,
0.2051279545,
0.403783083,
0.2387518734,
0.1626666039,
0.001045672,
-0.2020896524,
-0.6336912513,
0.1148851663,
1.0697170496,
0.2547775507,
0.8140623569,
0.1599727571,
0.5215966702,
0.7656190991,
0.4086209834,
-0.5960597396,
0.2639888525,
-0.4134093821,
-0.378030628,
-0.1942598373,
-0.4748332202,
-0.8865072727,
0.197021991,
0.0011912833,
-0.2290090472,
0.8834283352,
0.0738447681,
-0.1912432909,
0.2387784123,
-0.3802256584,
0.9087516665,
0.1774390787,
-0.3528905511,
-0.4755119979,
-0.6515228152,
0.4183570445,
-0.3440694213,
0.2268642634,
0.0231929738,
0.2181310505,
0.5435120463,
-0.3676947653,
1.5361888409,
-0.5653814077,
-0.3814010918,
0.123846598,
0.1712453961,
0.612811923,
-0.0041732341,
0.2733884752,
0.5810294151,
-0.5411222577,
-0.3453229964,
-1.1609200239,
0.611489296,
-0.9572199583,
-0.8132689595,
-0.3234754205,
-0.3065191209,
-0.7460297942,
-0.1402067244,
0.13030155,
0.2158225477,
-0.4848461151,
-0.3319800198,
0.6265907288,
-0.2462782562,
0.0666082874,
0.5739458799,
-0.0511360839,
-0.194047153,
0.9232669473,
-0.2221482247,
0.2145976871,
0.4291859269,
0.3987952769,
-0.1710204482,
-0.2441644967,
-0.2477260083,
0.2940831482,
-0.7526510358,
-0.3002034724,
-0.5597720146,
0.0281960722,
-0.6339409351,
-0.255476594,
-0.0755162686,
-0.442328155,
-0.3052857518,
-0.0082910508,
0.4294666052,
0.4370212853,
-0.1433047652,
0.2682282627,
-0.7095511556,
0.4516534507,
0.557341516,
0.2328573614,
0.0533047989,
-0.9009873271,
-0.4619406164,
-0.0916862562,
-0.2602667212,
-0.7531849146,
0.4478638172,
0.2849676609,
0.3743316829,
0.1870873123,
0.2446561009,
0.5479827523,
-0.454144299,
0.7483950257,
0.1816212833,
-1.1369459629,
0.6275982261,
-0.2476945221,
-0.1041543409,
0.1689949036,
0.5828332901,
-0.5832355022,
-0.7184485197,
-0.4715497792,
-0.5807780027,
0.3738575578,
-0.1715922356,
0.2797604203,
0.2262025774,
0.3993602991,
0.4283976555,
0.0797435343,
-0.4578871429,
-0.1750951409,
-0.3950753808,
-0.1083519906,
-0.1376697719,
0.0842608511,
-0.3932858407,
-0.3213118017,
0.7308873534,
-0.240752995,
0.2739483118,
0.1606569588,
-0.4738988578,
-0.316418767,
0.1636834145,
0.4602322578,
0.7286326885,
-0.016726343,
0.2018009275,
0.2222082615,
-0.4948480129,
0.1776100099,
0.0011833198,
-0.0686949641,
-0.1505928189,
0.4818554521,
0.6459646225,
0.210581392,
0.1292127669,
0.9083433151,
-0.1027193293,
-0.0325650573,
0.1821299642,
-0.0120673412,
-0.399739176,
0.5436232686,
0.2078620493,
0.4667987227,
0.1766418368,
-0.4864740968,
0.2943719327,
0.34007442,
-0.5283338428,
-0.7452919483,
0.7198618054,
0.2518345118,
0.1730805039,
0.314751327,
0.2342927307,
-0.6658101678,
0.5416486263,
0.6510748863,
1.5202611685,
-0.3561162055,
0.4678435922,
0.0479165167,
0.2576548457,
0.1497185975,
0.1409517527,
0.2446548343,
-1.1759755611,
-0.2684831619,
-0.2223156691,
-0.5285699964,
-0.4262632132,
-0.8418710828,
-0.0317323282,
-0.5644967556,
-0.3538379073,
-0.2494887263,
-0.2742368877,
-0.7102904916,
0.738455534,
-0.2628257275,
0.5983310938,
-1.3778610229,
0.7388307452,
0.7409494519,
-0.3531740904,
-0.6926024556,
0.526512742,
-0.0265902281,
-0.8510534167,
1.0325684547,
-0.4055843055,
-0.4730123878,
-0.2126055062,
-0.6156687737,
-0.5083229542,
0.802277863,
0.0384686105,
-0.3936323225,
0.4109098911,
0.2310160846,
0.6875587106,
-0.6682193279,
-0.4853776693,
0.5098110437,
0.3602111638,
-0.30248034,
-0.3008747697,
0.6243320704,
-0.169319883,
0.0685557947,
0.0635729581,
-0.8214624524,
0.8473261595,
-0.0345083326,
0.0354790464,
-0.7009755373,
0.7276266217,
-0.0163187254,
0.5590328574,
0.5792365074,
0.4097931087,
0.5258142352,
0.0643985569,
0.9599574208,
-0.1658997089,
0.5327931046,
0.9946941137,
-0.677146554,
0.5871654153,
0.3644909859,
-0.0345342755,
0.7464311123,
0.3941265345,
-0.0245451815,
0.7998585105,
0.0743851736,
-0.307893008,
-0.2789359391,
0.2430396229,
-0.4411629736,
0.3154468834,
0.3538722694,
-0.5540140867,
-0.1947736889,
0.0301031321,
-0.0261589587,
-0.1127902269,
-0.4598119557,
0.5687397718,
0.2980920672,
-0.5954051018,
0.4935548306,
0.1681857854,
0.402975291,
-0.4350085258,
-0.0731152296,
-0.4851565957,
0.4301760495,
-0.2595989704,
-0.4984077811,
0.5498784781,
-0.1666206121,
-0.5177692175,
-0.3139467835,
1.1614786386,
-0.3183655739,
-0.5410919785,
0.80724895,
0.5649479628,
-0.3298109472,
-0.3407655954,
-0.4490351379,
0.0441950522,
-0.0964947641,
-0.2274946868,
0.3578676283,
0.6838769913,
-0.5302398205,
0.1485004574,
0.5002767444,
0.2831948698,
0.1090341359,
0.3942486048,
1.1784157753,
-0.967271328,
-0.4382298589,
-0.7945202589,
0.4875183105,
0.1107095107,
-0.4693616331,
0.8346536756,
0.0992168635,
0.719103694,
-0.4485602379,
1.093390584,
0.313613236,
0.4939614236,
-0.4771188498,
0.7411893606,
-0.5997883677,
0.1406895816,
-0.5677709579,
-1.0183887482,
-0.9298693538,
0.1727916896,
-0.6099533439,
0.0065462887,
0.8548123837,
0.804294467,
-0.150050804,
0.1796610653,
0.4108804166,
0.352750957,
0.2713885009,
0.4686917365,
0.9407477379,
-0.5418645144,
0.225851208,
0.0942747891,
-0.4680826664,
-0.1596954018,
-0.7119269371,
-0.9565861225,
-0.3431716859,
-0.6597323418,
-0.4052259028,
0.4390604496,
0.3545766473,
0.310192883,
-0.9683642983,
-0.0165204518,
0.3550267518,
0.5186995864,
-0.7576969266,
-0.2760537267,
0.5330364704,
-0.539229393,
-0.3927668929,
0.074965179,
0.2828789949,
-0.5066359043,
-0.009464086,
0.0980532691,
0.1544339806,
0.3435846567,
0.9016600251,
0.1973362863,
-0.399843961,
-0.7787743211,
-0.0630753487,
0.0619014688,
0.1021415666,
1.2992875576,
-0.6410176158,
0.2359558791,
0.3649581969,
0.7498366833,
0.1984167248,
0.1888780743,
0.8017752171,
-1.0145366192,
-0.3139126897,
-0.150977999,
0.1723994762,
0.0508331172,
-0.5560530424,
0.2224316746,
0.6899707317,
-0.4663791358,
-0.2725912631,
0.2678822279,
-0.9321237803,
-0.5371413231,
1.0093923807,
-0.2953713536,
-0.2008441687,
-0.3066316843,
0.1046208739,
0.3485404551,
-0.3145316541,
1.0422415733,
0.5068127513,
-0.0958773941,
0.1276018918,
0.1629273444,
0.3785596788,
0.2879809439,
-0.7515106201,
0.2033353299,
0.5468379259,
0.6214501262,
-0.0565878414,
0.4015898705,
-0.1851538569,
0.2100070715,
0.009521204,
0.0580131412,
0.440721482,
-0.6310741901,
-0.6860437393,
0.2762726843,
-0.2815926075,
-0.356516093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14533v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14533v1
|
Whose LLM is it Anyway? Linguistic Comparison and LLM Attribution for GPT-3.5, GPT-4 and Bard
| 2024-02-22T13:25:17 | 2024-02-22T13:25:17 |
Ariel Rosenfeld, Teddy Lazebnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are capable of generating text that is similar
to or surpasses human quality. However, it is unclear whether LLMs tend to
exhibit distinctive linguistic styles akin to how human authors do. Through a
comprehensive linguistic analysis, we compare the vocabulary, Part-Of-Speech
(POS) distribution, dependency distribution, and sentiment of texts generated
by three of the most popular LLMS today (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Bard) to diverse
inputs. The results point to significant linguistic variations which, in turn,
enable us to attribute a given text to its LLM origin with a favorable 88\%
accuracy using a simple off-the-shelf classification model. Theoretical and
practical implications of this intriguing finding are discussed.
|
[
-0.360390842,
-0.5298813581,
0.9151489735,
0.2112968117,
-0.1482622623,
0.2134795338,
-0.1934521496,
-0.5887396932,
0.3391715884,
0.4459913671,
-0.3887890875,
-0.4888887703,
-0.6003963351,
0.3595616221,
-0.4704568684,
1.0475054979,
0.0002539209,
0.2208316028,
-0.1245101392,
-0.0650781244,
-0.0838733464,
-0.9053989053,
-0.3976954222,
-0.3390297294,
0.9623528123,
0.0016866378,
0.7546129227,
0.2845072746,
0.6143856645,
0.3580834866,
-0.1519892812,
-0.1719915867,
-0.3588910997,
0.0320732109,
-0.3462414742,
-0.521902144,
-0.4565779567,
0.3970531821,
0.6406688094,
0.3789658546,
0.0349992402,
-0.0201028772,
0.161476478,
0.7792250514,
-0.3678850234,
-0.1092084125,
-0.7226950526,
-0.0421823896,
-0.5832368731,
-0.2517390847,
-0.2679201066,
-0.7265403271,
0.2632742226,
-0.2184725851,
0.2997377813,
-0.0221301746,
0.8114598989,
0.0283622462,
-0.3316513896,
-0.573245585,
-0.5132708549,
0.7967843413,
-0.8552149534,
0.1522239447,
0.3017194271,
0.1632869393,
-0.138636604,
-0.5288137197,
-0.8722674847,
-0.447306782,
-0.095757626,
0.1788513362,
0.0150379268,
0.048314251,
-0.2047298849,
0.4844169617,
-0.5690998435,
0.1983676702,
-0.2397669554,
0.0612219945,
0.5532135367,
0.0820663497,
0.4237720668,
-0.3790492117,
-0.2768448889,
0.177130416,
-1.088970542,
-0.2192436606,
0.8161339164,
0.1213770509,
0.2872139513,
0.8072859049,
-0.0749095157,
0.5977397561,
-0.3259393871,
-0.4909582436,
0.24477458,
-0.2513517141,
-0.2714310884,
0.0117307622,
1.0560554266,
0.3657508194,
0.3389706314,
-0.1904078573,
-0.3043545187,
-0.0083770072,
0.1680306345,
-0.3002323508,
-0.236217007,
-0.0766957849,
-0.3454763591,
-0.37632972,
0.2807532847,
-0.2897245586,
-0.5779772997,
-0.2119791508,
0.343206048,
-0.1673824489,
-0.1252242327,
-0.1484676003,
-0.011029074,
0.3717708588,
0.2369776815,
-0.9041635394,
0.1506888568,
0.756362617,
0.7937081456,
-0.7544041872,
-0.305072993,
-0.2216024548,
0.127137199,
-0.4545647502,
0.9595063925,
-0.3678510189,
-0.4021036625,
-0.0733389184,
-0.1025128067,
0.1748767942,
-0.5057310462,
0.5824234486,
-0.4418545961,
0.5049653649,
-0.5490452051,
-0.7536452413,
-0.1449564844,
0.2215808779,
-0.569494009,
0.8079493046,
0.2033897191,
-0.8851639628,
0.3318358362,
-0.4842878282,
-0.2567463219,
0.2818046808,
-0.4231672883,
-0.2192833722,
0.1840583682,
-0.2347600013,
0.6003769636,
-0.5567697287,
0.1515693516,
-0.4546504021,
-0.3993517756,
0.9078422189,
-0.53063941,
0.6927894354,
0.2543524206,
-0.1778547466,
0.0142640704,
-0.7014518976,
-0.1379844546,
0.1497638822,
-0.6723268628,
-0.1706540138,
0.1725080609,
-0.056829229,
0.0540161431,
0.3557224572,
-0.5662267804,
0.0890265256,
-0.3292996287,
0.5310192704,
0.820561409,
-0.0718273297,
0.3295038044,
-0.5612641573,
0.595056951,
-0.475289613,
-0.1490114629,
0.287219286,
-0.7674697042,
-0.4419485033,
-0.3816613257,
0.2931793928,
0.5301039815,
-0.4195240438,
0.2434932292,
-0.1989064962,
-0.5735791326,
-0.4117913842,
0.2508544624,
0.3323095441,
0.26135993,
0.0047945315,
-0.1331964582,
-0.2863755822,
-0.9853679538,
-0.7044619322,
-0.4305134118,
-0.217441678,
0.0569655783,
0.1056256294,
-0.0280287266,
1.0522563457,
-0.2961089611,
-0.099938795,
-0.5161488056,
0.0149670066,
0.0999999344,
0.0688324496,
0.682181716,
-0.5184240937,
-0.6415490508,
0.0527482778,
-0.5505238175,
-0.3910713196,
0.2591701746,
0.0579024069,
0.2836299539,
0.4102500677,
-0.4851910472,
0.2461302727,
0.5994682908,
-0.262901783,
0.7192264199,
-0.0107662529,
0.1467901468,
-1.1525404453,
-0.1771922857,
-0.0154631129,
-0.1290241033,
-0.5157600045,
-0.0123399217,
-0.0903307125,
0.2545615137,
-0.5257344246,
0.6668819785,
-0.4229540825,
-0.3800278604,
-0.2178849131,
0.3623523414,
-0.0168620478,
0.2805517018,
-0.011364691,
0.7091082931,
0.2720502913,
-0.3454643488,
0.5776758194,
0.1129858568,
-0.4824670851,
0.6121897101,
-0.5850824118,
0.1385397762,
0.1103794202,
0.1147116199,
-1.1001433134,
-0.5048704743,
0.2282215655,
-0.3414716423,
0.2343585044,
-0.1544866413,
-0.6901074052,
-0.2826371789,
-0.3806488216,
0.2056749612,
0.7458289266,
-0.3613784611,
0.4352550209,
0.3456451297,
-0.7139895558,
-0.4981927574,
-0.9010503292,
0.2282213718,
-0.4842008948,
-0.4811860621,
0.2537228763,
-0.1657884419,
-0.6585690379,
-0.0373358689,
0.102938652,
0.022108281,
-0.0333770514,
0.1128094271,
0.3140847385,
-0.3943558633,
0.1400775313,
-0.1779718548,
0.1305988431,
0.0264142174,
-0.2040546685,
0.217727989,
-0.2244974226,
-0.5262297988,
-0.2550176978,
0.178342551,
0.4343711436,
0.1317283064,
0.599656105,
0.3002830148,
0.1189410165,
0.0270966757,
-0.6102173328,
0.1133209988,
-0.4988412261,
0.1974202842,
-0.2195178866,
-0.8164787889,
0.3233999312,
0.3509257734,
-0.0752297491,
0.509788692,
0.7685432434,
-0.1853654087,
0.6256294847,
0.4695747197,
-0.0531491265,
0.5044847727,
0.2550487518,
0.133077547,
-0.6058395505,
0.0170686115,
-0.5522902608,
-0.2803712189,
-1.0257792473,
-0.1503731608,
0.1721426845,
-0.0814530179,
-0.1467680186,
0.1395972073,
-0.4542335272,
0.7261761427,
0.6100113988,
-0.1658572406,
0.3858385384,
-0.0110667534,
0.0714963302,
0.1037812307,
-0.3679395616,
-1.0117075443,
1.2236073017,
0.2953526378,
0.7150861621,
0.492187351,
0.7537684441,
0.2485371828,
0.5355144143,
-0.7290435433,
0.6785433888,
-0.2998717427,
-0.6481114626,
-0.1580133587,
-0.4321694076,
-0.8929297328,
0.1305294782,
-0.1530101895,
-0.8302845955,
-0.091559723,
-0.060087923,
-0.1677498519,
0.5077695847,
-0.6515216231,
0.6665124893,
-0.2163705379,
0.0211235415,
0.2788888514,
-0.5881527662,
0.4270946085,
-0.465081811,
0.2004642636,
-0.5367934704,
-0.24077712,
0.7448564768,
-0.3984770179,
0.6387643218,
0.2026328295,
-0.5421690345,
0.5344446301,
0.1122060046,
0.2366407216,
-0.0918493271,
-0.130956158,
0.1417597234,
-0.1366093159,
-0.4271657467,
-0.4527077377,
0.9175726771,
-0.9069468975,
-0.6679463983,
-0.3760842681,
-0.3049057424,
-0.3636837304,
0.10516458,
0.6202598214,
0.5240989327,
-0.2898930013,
-0.0521647483,
0.215439871,
-0.3002687991,
0.5781578422,
0.4927110076,
-0.3024139106,
-0.3702985048,
1.0924049616,
-0.0075455201,
0.3566066921,
0.4213623405,
0.3232749403,
-0.4892475903,
-0.6291689873,
-0.1424566656,
0.3268637955,
-0.8421134353,
0.023441568,
-0.4261476099,
-0.1623697281,
-0.1966718882,
-0.4458535016,
-0.2327297628,
-0.5495233536,
-0.3759876788,
-0.0567935593,
0.3524230719,
1.4682513475,
0.1694104224,
0.5559174418,
-0.680395782,
-0.0129586738,
0.537263453,
0.26310274,
-0.4463519752,
-0.6275091767,
0.148352474,
-0.2747962773,
-0.4876786172,
-1.1584997177,
0.2690535188,
0.0898078755,
0.4777094126,
0.2786613107,
-0.3295533657,
-0.0584636666,
-0.4626354873,
1.2476131916,
0.4122466147,
-0.8192086816,
0.2011942565,
-0.4561716318,
0.0114653362,
0.2949229777,
0.276239872,
-0.3302557468,
-0.70527035,
-0.6152938008,
-0.6887530088,
0.5657986403,
0.2940021157,
0.1001425013,
-0.1778789014,
0.3546378911,
0.3235437572,
0.130867213,
-0.9773286581,
-0.201283887,
-0.1400083005,
-0.4541863799,
-0.3810591996,
-0.2886702716,
0.0627728701,
0.2160291076,
0.5506007671,
0.0669021979,
0.3912065923,
-0.001126635,
0.0151245305,
0.3252879381,
0.5644192696,
0.7464076281,
0.825570941,
0.0191046055,
0.3762697279,
0.1382953227,
-0.3833842278,
0.3007474542,
-0.1510490626,
0.0333286859,
0.1191542819,
0.4129103124,
0.5695567131,
0.0861218497,
-0.3580614328,
0.5804988146,
-0.0370302908,
-0.3630290329,
-0.1561121792,
0.2023466974,
0.4632719457,
0.3022452891,
0.3804645836,
-0.0220750496,
0.079766117,
-0.6207823157,
-0.1213617101,
0.4141798913,
-0.0878279284,
-0.498182267,
0.4525817633,
0.2069122195,
-0.4492973983,
0.2198091,
-0.4451931417,
-0.4731691182,
0.2948230505,
0.3960466683,
1.000240922,
-0.0974831581,
0.1664416194,
-0.0382024087,
0.0463982858,
-0.1360794902,
0.2003917694,
0.3621116281,
-0.7770421505,
-0.5890219808,
-0.7949322462,
-0.5349686146,
0.0539106913,
-0.3946508765,
0.3059043288,
-0.3032106459,
-0.3082577288,
0.0658970848,
-0.2436012924,
-0.4810751379,
-0.016499158,
0.2442939281,
0.4268218577,
-0.4927855134,
0.8175575733,
0.769826591,
-0.2842791975,
-0.8102223873,
0.3722853661,
0.0728784651,
-0.8239027262,
0.7281151414,
-0.1660799235,
-0.1969258487,
0.0843245313,
-0.5846685767,
-0.6139062643,
0.7646625638,
0.5079558492,
-0.5012485385,
-0.0558979362,
0.1277514696,
0.5530316234,
-0.2179531306,
0.1708225459,
0.5315839648,
0.3807931542,
0.1235177368,
-0.9460493922,
-0.1115323752,
0.0442401692,
0.0924843028,
0.1850748211,
-0.3824044168,
0.8239811659,
-0.2173838317,
-0.1173069924,
0.3273586333,
0.6614016294,
0.4544685781,
0.0676271021,
0.1545008719,
0.0815940276,
0.7462354898,
-0.1187522933,
1.0582562685,
-0.1939367801,
0.3249716163,
1.0260064602,
-0.2113285065,
0.9491114616,
0.3248048723,
-0.674706459,
0.6109259725,
0.700050056,
0.1791803539,
0.3879374266,
0.3908555508,
-0.4952236414,
0.1584818065,
0.3139986396,
-0.2303015143,
0.4516351223,
0.2465350926,
-0.4336178899,
0.1126008108,
-0.2318363637,
0.060718365,
-0.0869062468,
-0.2285985947,
0.8838317394,
0.2240156978,
-0.6298825741,
0.327647537,
-0.0595509969,
0.7960613966,
-0.4337356389,
0.4081920981,
-0.2481715381,
-0.0235462282,
-0.2200183272,
-1.1397714615,
0.0928459466,
0.1620644033,
-0.0052735084,
-0.1368337572,
0.6141158342,
-0.3861745,
-0.4461762011,
-0.0372131392,
0.6392017007,
0.5720866323,
-0.0318340845,
-0.4716567099,
-0.1346692443,
0.0100692045,
-0.3971360922,
0.407430768,
0.568665266,
0.2096017301,
0.5446491838,
0.384488523,
0.3566609621,
0.3028624058,
-0.0051889326,
0.4591590762,
-0.7627420425,
-0.2447469532,
-1.079204917,
0.1052987948,
0.0908045769,
-0.4362914264,
0.7991674542,
0.2333769053,
0.5461294055,
-0.1094308496,
0.9966118336,
0.0136764282,
0.6101595163,
-0.5440151691,
0.7154403329,
-0.5157678723,
0.4165973365,
-0.6195191741,
-1.2055383921,
-0.2497969717,
0.5612859726,
-0.32339257,
0.3238661885,
0.809091866,
0.5795642138,
0.1432969421,
0.2255400866,
0.4292969704,
0.1535955817,
0.3296703696,
0.1884509623,
1.2921710014,
0.1566039771,
0.4853787422,
0.2156257778,
-0.2605339289,
-0.1926760375,
-1.2188313007,
-0.6668170094,
-0.4648798704,
-0.2692911625,
-0.2295482904,
-0.0926107615,
0.785972774,
0.237494126,
-0.5939515233,
-0.0941978619,
-0.2219525874,
0.2287603319,
0.2250645459,
-0.1948907375,
0.1228204519,
-0.3268730938,
-0.6312513947,
0.326901406,
0.2976096272,
0.4724425972,
-0.4825923145,
-0.2502123415,
0.373610884,
0.2954154611,
0.6697567701,
0.092325978,
-1.212993145,
-0.3435652852,
-0.0152957197,
-0.4382454157,
0.0534235872,
0.8465684652,
-0.3414752185,
0.0186619423,
0.4522767663,
0.4889013469,
0.0022443102,
-0.150829196,
0.6194666624,
-0.6656144857,
-0.2963942289,
0.0943747684,
0.4707733393,
0.6133756638,
-0.1763241589,
0.5750799179,
0.377407968,
-0.962123394,
-0.5643565059,
0.2639507949,
-0.9839917421,
-0.3447594047,
1.5445417166,
-0.2116736621,
-0.0440823734,
-0.120347552,
-0.4263769388,
-0.0160087366,
-0.2172372043,
0.4973849952,
0.9070931077,
-0.3185144663,
0.1075192317,
-0.5571977496,
0.5996693373,
0.202106759,
-0.7587013245,
-0.0715475827,
0.3060041964,
0.5673959851,
0.0743508115,
0.7692296505,
-0.1741346866,
-0.1425226629,
-0.2219955176,
0.1313063651,
0.4043429792,
0.0132840946,
-0.0830828771,
0.2403269261,
0.6210324168,
0.0991343409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14531v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14531v1
|
Should We Respect LLMs? A Cross-Lingual Study on the Influence of Prompt Politeness on LLM Performance
| 2024-02-22T13:24:10 | 2024-02-22T13:24:10 |
Ziqi Yin, Hao Wang, Kaito Horio, Daisuke Kawahara, Satoshi Sekine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate the impact of politeness levels in prompts on the performance
of large language models (LLMs). Polite language in human communications often
garners more compliance and effectiveness, while rudeness can cause aversion,
impacting response quality. We consider that LLMs mirror human communication
traits, suggesting they align with human cultural norms. We assess the impact
of politeness in prompts on LLMs across English, Chinese, and Japanese tasks.
We observed that impolite prompts often result in poor performance, but overly
polite language does not guarantee better outcomes. The best politeness level
is different according to the language. This phenomenon suggests that LLMs not
only reflect human behavior but are also influenced by language, particularly
in different cultural contexts. Our findings highlight the need to factor in
politeness for cross-cultural natural language processing and LLM usage.
|
[
-0.3226613402,
-0.5933449864,
0.4322461486,
0.5069540739,
-0.213268131,
-0.2193536013,
-0.3077439666,
-0.8571677208,
0.1312367618,
0.4212222695,
-0.4523594677,
-0.1205256805,
-0.4696408808,
0.6531708241,
0.2029262334,
0.7234799862,
0.3413319588,
0.5948601365,
-0.2698034942,
-0.2227254957,
-0.4663698077,
-0.8111638427,
-1.0575213432,
-0.7495611906,
0.6440330744,
0.4070338607,
0.8228546381,
0.4817495644,
0.4159050286,
0.3470388055,
-0.3994818032,
0.0467311963,
-0.5110458136,
0.2901427448,
-0.3556973636,
-0.4833424091,
-0.5637280941,
0.3346350789,
0.6112553477,
0.6878743768,
0.0366231389,
0.1687593013,
0.293543607,
0.5957730412,
0.0123762442,
0.1796005666,
-0.307574749,
0.0343479663,
-0.1546881348,
-0.3051614761,
-0.0612924285,
-0.6445865631,
0.0010115257,
-0.6152412295,
-0.1662353575,
0.172318697,
0.8031647205,
0.1646316648,
-0.3773170114,
-0.2757635713,
-0.3164870143,
0.7928580642,
-0.4641648531,
0.419985801,
0.5432613492,
0.1359411329,
-0.313313812,
-0.4740910828,
-0.4979208112,
-0.3385146558,
-0.0212109238,
0.0407308079,
0.0279795695,
0.1098166928,
0.5279109478,
0.418838352,
-0.3611721098,
0.6051466465,
-0.1152187288,
-0.3867746294,
0.533573091,
0.3910198808,
0.5672446489,
-0.0585242659,
-0.2311641425,
0.1193126515,
-0.9179325104,
0.727940619,
0.683144927,
0.4720767736,
-0.0847682953,
0.2102708668,
-0.4050287306,
0.3770132363,
0.0148306135,
-0.149952203,
-0.0168346483,
-0.4769355059,
0.0205197819,
-0.2015491128,
0.7418136001,
0.804004252,
0.8576647043,
-0.2082957625,
-0.2749582231,
0.0760219768,
0.0318948552,
-0.8998380899,
-0.1668242514,
-0.1420221478,
-0.4929641187,
-0.0477978438,
0.0504076667,
-0.5794019699,
-0.4268888235,
-0.453212589,
0.0729089379,
-0.0290178619,
-0.2363414764,
-0.1225785762,
-0.1130341217,
0.4436866641,
0.4659696221,
-0.9125191569,
0.2545099258,
0.6802816391,
0.5033516288,
0.1426320225,
-0.2686971426,
-0.6909318566,
-0.0485671572,
-0.4086131155,
0.5000405908,
-0.7049692273,
-0.8119624257,
0.0945380405,
0.1165242717,
0.2780034244,
-0.6463824511,
0.9806414247,
-0.4704354107,
0.3065670729,
-0.8816444278,
-0.2169152051,
-0.1253814399,
0.279215306,
-0.4576614499,
0.859416604,
0.1775779277,
-0.5566291213,
0.3143670857,
-0.5054896474,
-0.7984163165,
0.3016610742,
-0.2388806939,
-0.0794985965,
-0.0349093974,
0.2411343753,
0.4141539633,
-0.1658907086,
-0.0360173173,
-0.2026563287,
-0.6358335614,
0.5558155775,
-0.2469635159,
0.9285755157,
0.3616767526,
-0.0809535384,
0.0195799973,
-0.414586395,
0.0722890049,
-0.0317797959,
-0.4260014892,
-0.5215350986,
-0.2515183389,
-0.1068165898,
0.5933167934,
0.3260722756,
-0.4977679253,
0.1180879697,
-0.5077490807,
0.4339284897,
1.1302617788,
0.0523479432,
0.55979532,
-0.7305706143,
0.7368421555,
-0.0356448479,
0.3499776721,
-0.2232684493,
-0.5292887688,
-0.4617812932,
-0.0911925212,
-0.3421977758,
0.4499197602,
-0.5618890524,
-0.0235143006,
-0.2141366005,
-0.2944875658,
-0.6396355629,
0.2327675074,
0.3723127544,
0.5612378716,
0.0325741582,
-0.3476140201,
-0.4218402505,
-0.9860289097,
-0.4934001863,
-0.6165249348,
-0.0308878347,
0.6022722125,
0.0113014402,
0.0889117792,
0.6768525839,
0.0610716641,
-0.2031667084,
-0.2627678514,
-0.2785093188,
0.283380419,
0.3181988597,
0.7076026201,
-0.6286159754,
-0.4230861068,
-0.1453037262,
-0.5300636292,
-0.5879753828,
0.1881222129,
-0.1865322441,
0.3557486534,
0.5267897248,
-0.216213271,
-0.1659535915,
0.4633615613,
-0.4212557971,
0.3567443192,
0.1320513487,
0.5929297805,
-1.1195274591,
-0.0166769624,
0.0723797902,
-0.2916986048,
-0.5516371727,
0.0264803804,
-0.0824549124,
0.1441209614,
-0.6520344019,
0.7850499749,
-0.2659569383,
0.0008452733,
-0.1286956519,
0.0629617646,
0.1916306168,
0.2529161274,
0.2483519316,
1.1060709953,
0.536231935,
-1.0266671181,
0.1814531535,
0.196646288,
-0.1296677291,
1.1522005796,
-0.8696399331,
0.1333757937,
-0.2788105011,
0.1226939932,
-1.2409633398,
0.0194071978,
0.5698339343,
-0.8235578537,
0.1776004732,
-0.1522806287,
-0.5731608868,
-0.2835801244,
-0.4568018317,
0.0729865357,
0.6662591696,
-0.3851840794,
0.2328177243,
0.3439992964,
-0.324080497,
-0.457762599,
-0.8484768271,
0.1689367443,
-0.3176530004,
-0.7362160683,
-0.1136079431,
-0.519425571,
-0.6129124165,
-0.6544773579,
0.1917113066,
0.098491393,
0.3405765891,
0.3305646479,
0.1506377012,
0.0576248169,
-0.1720398217,
-0.4083417654,
0.1680170894,
0.3613797724,
-0.093059957,
0.5210315585,
-0.0724369138,
0.027814243,
-0.6695917249,
0.3386985064,
0.5612504482,
0.0531750396,
0.5168240666,
0.5257477164,
-0.2454834729,
0.3442900777,
-0.6256507039,
-0.5694730282,
-0.5494232774,
0.1743514836,
-0.4195387959,
-1.056391716,
0.6651025414,
0.3274880946,
0.2370723784,
0.1656970382,
0.5276010036,
-0.4914554954,
0.9881073236,
0.9949214458,
-0.4534251988,
0.6283369064,
0.301222682,
0.1041567847,
-0.7504193783,
-0.1226338148,
-1.0099235773,
-0.2988203168,
-0.9178103209,
-0.1365556419,
0.1712087989,
-0.2830575407,
-0.1607126743,
-0.1015123799,
-0.0077687786,
0.2375538498,
0.0604428723,
-0.2472950518,
0.4800877869,
-0.1874825507,
0.0528446771,
-0.514338553,
-0.7235811949,
-0.7904965878,
0.3389728963,
0.6282891631,
0.941748023,
0.2438318878,
0.4476997554,
0.1098660752,
0.3923402131,
-0.7550632954,
0.6544181705,
0.0222878773,
-0.2446332276,
-0.1583707035,
-0.5480095744,
-1.2210611105,
0.1058254242,
0.335858494,
-0.5709308386,
-0.110274747,
-0.0736741722,
-0.1009890139,
0.0955063999,
-0.5175695419,
0.4615670145,
0.0324350707,
-0.2780982256,
-0.0074118855,
-0.635084033,
0.3573474288,
0.309366852,
0.5628784895,
-0.2212613374,
-0.3360164165,
0.8166558743,
0.0489923507,
1.1419721842,
0.0109409085,
-0.5801361203,
-0.0010062131,
0.2518439591,
0.5255821943,
0.3354738355,
-0.2450028658,
0.3169146478,
-0.0567326173,
-0.459977597,
-0.3839721382,
0.8145665526,
-0.7735984921,
-0.7820007801,
-0.3778674901,
-0.6629565954,
-0.2145572454,
0.1010447517,
0.3598610461,
0.0009921801,
-0.1308162212,
-0.3291261792,
0.9707120657,
-0.1860087812,
0.6366472244,
0.9895153642,
-0.2738805115,
-0.0284022894,
0.5714893341,
0.1575596333,
0.4091041684,
0.1914277822,
0.266035229,
-0.5608128309,
-0.2816069126,
-0.5553126335,
0.2656964064,
-0.7430168986,
0.0713778436,
-0.5605797768,
0.1077303663,
-0.7578759789,
-0.2834011912,
-0.1377288103,
-0.2519113421,
-0.4231862128,
0.1493099481,
0.4850082397,
0.8336517811,
-0.0809658021,
0.0555482209,
-0.8683303595,
0.0865065232,
0.1606571674,
0.5006386042,
-0.2323674262,
-1.0119394064,
-0.0052228998,
-0.0347986072,
0.0051379539,
-0.4131926596,
0.0530191287,
0.0701929033,
1.0597523451,
0.4144868255,
0.1222056597,
0.4559459984,
-0.2606513798,
1.1779663563,
0.0834085792,
-0.6506011486,
0.4395462871,
-0.4442096353,
0.6021304727,
0.3420714438,
0.5544902682,
-1.2585361004,
-0.8213551641,
-0.5985414386,
-0.7236614227,
0.6819999218,
-0.1455002725,
0.7175405622,
-0.2282258421,
0.3371683359,
0.1555021703,
0.2694052756,
-0.9481315017,
-0.4022004902,
0.0204315912,
0.3949275911,
-0.0795707479,
-0.4266454279,
-0.1879919469,
0.0090325065,
0.4030632675,
0.0043851952,
-0.125596419,
0.3013103306,
0.0269169565,
-0.542229414,
0.5304417014,
0.5008063912,
0.6952500939,
0.3397417068,
-0.0252875853,
0.3002273142,
-0.5745977163,
0.1333170086,
-0.3363651335,
-0.2389980704,
-0.0823523775,
0.1085492149,
0.1603070796,
0.0594565161,
-0.5027988553,
0.3032717705,
-0.4737184942,
0.2256980538,
-0.0291274022,
0.0210429784,
-0.0382629894,
0.1696824729,
0.0997104421,
-0.1009427458,
0.1177787781,
-0.8023521304,
0.0310864765,
0.6579515934,
-0.1744495779,
-0.3825265765,
0.6037382483,
0.4253140986,
-0.411826849,
0.5673545599,
-0.0906153917,
-0.7415612936,
0.352804929,
0.3265477121,
0.5453078151,
-0.4433958232,
-0.0163659211,
0.318341434,
0.4417096674,
0.1931061,
0.704885304,
-0.1790793091,
-0.5676310658,
-0.3827236593,
-0.5514892936,
-0.5203508139,
-0.0713451207,
-0.5176001191,
0.1513781548,
-0.5668352842,
-0.2597583234,
-0.4990949631,
0.2741315067,
-0.7833183408,
0.0335988551,
0.2695149183,
0.896931529,
-0.8039614558,
0.7112901211,
0.9609199166,
-0.434556514,
-0.7274588346,
0.0868986398,
-0.1639422029,
-0.7522205114,
0.7009055614,
0.1878919154,
-0.2142542005,
-0.103949286,
-0.4375685751,
-0.5700933933,
0.6705764532,
0.246023491,
-0.4674323499,
0.4076521993,
0.0761164278,
0.6978296041,
0.0758734122,
0.372574538,
0.4264023602,
0.5951244235,
-0.139304176,
-1.2481449842,
-0.0133074895,
-0.0889364704,
0.29640764,
-0.0089030918,
-1.063996911,
0.6238833666,
-0.2996548712,
-0.2936276197,
0.2637067139,
0.9086394906,
0.2126861662,
0.2907512486,
0.2144728452,
0.1785700619,
0.89026618,
-0.1480821967,
1.1112605333,
-0.1622318625,
-0.3384573162,
0.5184324384,
-0.4427464008,
0.5307939053,
0.7992517352,
-0.2329947352,
0.2563786209,
0.7746495605,
0.4065054059,
0.133028537,
0.4036846459,
-0.1482551247,
-0.0463020019,
-0.8780688643,
-0.4900372326,
0.3271722496,
0.3273276389,
-0.2033361942,
-0.1354034245,
-0.1646585613,
0.3811142147,
0.5534365177,
-0.6778414249,
0.7234772444,
0.1653388888,
-0.8872993588,
0.4993835688,
0.1201699153,
1.1377772093,
-0.5677766204,
0.1241008267,
-0.4753435254,
-0.3368339837,
-0.2539069355,
-1.1064662933,
0.0829737037,
-0.1402193457,
-0.2345490307,
-0.4547438622,
0.4873113036,
-0.3614498973,
0.0155040314,
0.2597035766,
0.6265358925,
0.4901753366,
0.2832250595,
-0.4152451456,
0.0617115721,
-0.2816497087,
-0.2808969915,
0.6971309185,
0.5330883265,
-0.1800620407,
0.6692857742,
0.7952002883,
0.1016902477,
-0.1240894049,
0.4909905195,
0.7508185506,
-0.4242984951,
-0.5916768312,
-0.9677405357,
0.3063964546,
0.0600597449,
-0.3447125256,
0.9408458471,
0.2530037463,
0.9862549305,
0.1716048867,
0.5632026196,
0.2028967589,
0.3899044394,
-0.5648991466,
0.5492069125,
-0.3677445352,
0.2781496942,
-0.3103331327,
-0.7884720564,
0.0456196181,
0.6182992458,
-0.2473084629,
0.4810080826,
0.3977762163,
0.8743202686,
0.5588316321,
0.1837158352,
0.6595792174,
0.0208921675,
0.4016547203,
0.5495914221,
1.1587412357,
-0.0154845715,
0.384265095,
-0.3059254587,
-0.0866774321,
0.0064517944,
-1.0522309542,
-0.8641747236,
-0.4581796527,
-0.2276592404,
-0.3332229853,
0.0808146298,
1.2222830057,
0.5261386037,
-0.3209995627,
-0.414507091,
0.5514029264,
0.2429567128,
-0.2936700284,
-0.3384128213,
-0.2290553451,
-0.5491722822,
-1.2105948925,
0.249253124,
0.2503539622,
0.4107454717,
-0.3614726961,
-0.3156670034,
-0.0024165409,
0.0717761368,
0.7446683645,
0.3050086796,
-0.64899683,
-0.2773028016,
0.3149652183,
-0.7311903238,
0.1139341816,
0.8450099826,
-0.7165929675,
0.160451591,
0.5842981339,
0.2337055355,
-0.6136698723,
-0.0088960044,
0.7734255791,
-0.8768054843,
0.1574480236,
0.5173982382,
0.3925773799,
0.6036864519,
-0.8015652895,
0.2759389877,
0.2162082344,
-0.9130999446,
-0.6550840139,
0.3170506954,
-0.7453445792,
-0.0764914155,
1.3223099709,
-0.0859246328,
-0.1033994406,
-0.3238269985,
-0.4765747488,
0.2018759698,
-0.8040376306,
0.8118199706,
1.0721029043,
-0.286377877,
-0.438198179,
-0.6858407855,
0.6557835937,
0.6483417749,
-0.4858082235,
0.1760144085,
0.4717103839,
0.4338814318,
-0.3130699396,
0.9132969975,
-0.1792915463,
0.4974848926,
-0.6713578701,
-0.2365084141,
-0.0507598557,
-0.1119679511,
-0.6014480591,
-0.2402143031,
0.6973306537,
0.0036525209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14526v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14526v2
|
Balanced Data Sampling for Language Model Training with Clustering
| 2024-02-22T13:20:53 | 2024-06-03T06:48:34 |
Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Zhaoye Fei, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data plays a fundamental role in the training of Large Language Models
(LLMs). While attention has been paid to the collection and composition of
datasets, determining the data sampling strategy in training remains an open
question. Most LLMs are trained with a simple strategy, random sampling.
However, this sampling strategy ignores the unbalanced nature of training data
distribution, which can be sub-optimal. In this paper, we propose ClusterClip
Sampling to balance the text distribution of training data for better model
training. Specifically, ClusterClip Sampling utilizes data clustering to
reflect the data distribution of the training set and balances the common
samples and rare samples during training based on the cluster results. A
repetition clip operation is introduced to mitigate the overfitting issue led
by samples from certain clusters. Extensive experiments validate the
effectiveness of ClusterClip Sampling, which outperforms random sampling and
other cluster-based sampling variants under various training datasets and large
language models.
|
[
-0.3520532548,
-0.6481345296,
0.3247273564,
0.3610723615,
-0.5138280988,
0.2506966591,
-0.3761734664,
-0.1357008368,
0.3616043925,
0.6167964935,
-0.4922091365,
-0.6901003718,
-0.3776049316,
-0.1380807459,
-0.770991981,
1.0403689146,
0.0884008557,
0.2266131341,
-0.4341286719,
-0.398227483,
-0.7270339727,
-0.5803544521,
-0.4969391525,
-0.5758728981,
0.1275411099,
0.6389849186,
0.3744977415,
0.7033896446,
0.0858357623,
0.1984182447,
-0.1993265152,
-0.1379162073,
-0.7525171638,
-0.166090548,
-0.052667208,
-0.8401921391,
-0.0919030383,
-0.0251542423,
1.0328710079,
1.0293689966,
-0.6181752086,
0.0777505934,
-0.0058576218,
0.6076034307,
-0.5872667432,
-0.4789329469,
-0.7395880222,
0.0171657037,
-0.5065664053,
-0.088199459,
-0.251547128,
-0.3265765905,
-0.1195485592,
-0.1490103453,
0.5085325241,
0.1225707531,
0.3324685097,
0.0193415377,
-0.2097695023,
0.007654334,
-0.7405328155,
1.1963245869,
-0.8353633881,
-0.1745317131,
0.3048509955,
0.4134287238,
-0.0188766494,
-0.2521876395,
-0.7309437394,
0.1498667449,
0.0931013301,
-0.0573845878,
-0.0268284641,
-0.2805970609,
0.0965114385,
0.3967692852,
-0.4957767725,
0.4617347419,
-0.4030337632,
0.0844747424,
0.5594512224,
0.1182169244,
0.3930658698,
0.1178784817,
-0.3815925121,
-0.4963592887,
-0.8473783731,
-0.0165611543,
0.4451962709,
0.2811446488,
-0.1274108738,
0.6325011253,
-0.0412433334,
0.943667531,
-0.0312935598,
-0.2790743113,
0.4724762738,
-0.1757778525,
-0.1967509091,
0.1710095406,
0.4482572973,
0.537402153,
0.4564493597,
0.0732192546,
-0.1369648278,
-0.0578282699,
0.2571241856,
-0.5829572678,
0.0100635383,
0.272221297,
-0.26844576,
-0.4386230111,
0.2296321094,
-0.9586831927,
0.0053433771,
-0.2590785921,
-0.1170913652,
-0.1711641997,
-0.2249099165,
0.3057012558,
-0.2396696955,
-0.2293485999,
0.0461418442,
-1.1139099598,
0.6398164034,
0.6526247859,
0.7877156138,
-0.8176166415,
-0.5944946408,
-0.3739897907,
0.3876598775,
-0.089725934,
1.0516953468,
-0.5743358731,
-0.587003231,
0.1591004878,
-0.1179093346,
-0.2186718881,
-0.7775449753,
0.3811873794,
-0.1109601781,
0.0799676105,
-0.1783451289,
-0.7396929264,
-0.0633934438,
0.2875696123,
-0.7847824693,
1.2653846741,
0.1037140712,
-0.9525107145,
0.4938684404,
-0.0162552986,
-0.4784055948,
-0.0272974558,
-0.3669480681,
-0.6874785423,
0.0608177036,
0.4756692052,
0.3192397058,
-0.0492418818,
0.3135273159,
-0.5246065259,
-0.4478977621,
0.2643869519,
-0.2398252934,
0.7062141895,
-0.0590672567,
-0.2170597315,
0.0266680289,
-0.6965552568,
0.2402282953,
-0.0015097942,
-0.2156801373,
-0.6016643643,
0.0827881694,
0.2464402467,
-0.0871330723,
-0.1256796271,
-0.644223094,
0.3458234072,
-0.4778199196,
0.264401257,
0.5405833125,
0.0815376043,
0.5882357359,
-0.60187608,
0.6770393848,
-0.0648506284,
-0.0802864358,
0.0397949293,
-0.1813308299,
-0.51458323,
-0.5814932585,
0.4279276431,
0.6766549945,
-0.4764478803,
0.6717831492,
-0.295979321,
-0.6869299412,
-0.5915762186,
0.2880368531,
0.2821827829,
0.2192343026,
0.2815254927,
-0.3065083921,
-0.4564414024,
-0.7916591167,
-0.0446972921,
0.2608814836,
-0.0228956789,
0.1352210194,
0.4095933437,
0.0149328746,
1.4817340374,
-0.7328255177,
-0.3238434792,
-0.8007816076,
0.2753303051,
0.2036780715,
0.5707118511,
0.9004555941,
-0.7698955536,
-0.4500011206,
-0.3889523745,
-0.2253862619,
-0.4423699379,
-0.1659325957,
0.0452593304,
0.1045884639,
0.7117621899,
-0.413869828,
0.2460687011,
0.800293386,
0.2299657464,
0.2895413637,
-0.0277826339,
-0.0393011644,
-1.1067137718,
0.319630444,
-0.3063485324,
-0.3815841377,
-0.4407274425,
-0.0569655262,
-0.2565868795,
-0.0800423324,
-0.5017024279,
0.5847754478,
-0.3315075636,
-0.0872197822,
-0.7362934947,
0.1639425457,
-0.1709113568,
0.2106494755,
0.0199761726,
0.6803982258,
0.4045018852,
-0.448936671,
0.2054208517,
0.2229671031,
-0.5166156292,
0.6790404916,
-0.8152691126,
0.0251568593,
-0.1107336506,
0.4354171455,
-1.1195040941,
0.0929177403,
-0.1755204797,
-0.2096714079,
0.1734699458,
0.0497685298,
-0.6066596508,
-0.5457433462,
-0.4443871677,
0.5456240177,
0.4206982553,
-0.686000824,
0.1953223497,
0.8719019294,
-0.2832333148,
-0.5459135771,
-0.786667943,
-0.4006595612,
-0.3644120693,
-0.2119780332,
0.374612093,
-0.0733451173,
0.0915429145,
-0.0750703886,
-0.0742857754,
-0.1492539495,
-0.0242750589,
0.0988094285,
0.0294954944,
0.3043339849,
0.0832434669,
0.0976919979,
-0.2005802542,
-0.3696662784,
-0.209355548,
1.1472740173,
0.3186179101,
-0.8176522255,
0.0382175818,
0.5533550382,
0.1891413778,
-0.0509252585,
0.6406503916,
0.4023080468,
-0.2418593019,
-0.4240656197,
-0.7270531058,
-0.2143263966,
-0.3729218543,
0.2375049442,
0.1230056956,
-1.1382373571,
0.4745200872,
0.0168640874,
0.1305688769,
0.2083523721,
0.5511544943,
-0.1772590131,
0.9716572165,
0.945817709,
-0.8401044011,
0.5409443974,
-0.0493352562,
0.0733932555,
-0.4067585468,
0.2004883885,
-0.6675642729,
-0.6037920117,
-0.2239383161,
-0.4211271107,
0.2618718445,
0.2679882944,
0.2821412385,
0.1125511974,
-0.3640147746,
0.8059949279,
0.8727363944,
0.0628376901,
0.3852661848,
0.5291446447,
-0.1400024891,
-0.1491204947,
-0.8854902387,
-0.1904948801,
0.9402531385,
0.1038933322,
0.8400009871,
-0.4025954008,
0.7017731667,
0.0198330451,
0.1924855709,
-0.4201553464,
0.5623073578,
-0.2810080945,
-0.4443118572,
-0.3891470432,
-0.4915854931,
-0.9126767516,
0.0608865432,
-0.1575996727,
-0.5244044662,
0.1211928949,
0.3958105743,
-0.0098550515,
0.4399831593,
-0.3166906834,
0.6986260414,
-0.0500222333,
0.2275955379,
-0.577567637,
-0.5279141665,
0.3326210976,
-0.1704449803,
0.2083650082,
0.0687167048,
0.4456432164,
0.7749902606,
-0.4187219739,
1.2488467693,
-0.0837634727,
0.1693939567,
0.5664910674,
-0.2966814339,
0.3478575051,
-0.2382495105,
0.223360002,
0.0172210429,
0.1456751823,
-0.6107217073,
-0.4302001595,
0.4593509734,
-0.5207083225,
-0.2062479109,
-0.3556375504,
-0.4703466296,
-0.093461372,
0.1148586571,
0.4810177088,
0.2275378555,
-0.4848852158,
0.3592562079,
0.3264731169,
-0.1392312795,
0.4554844201,
0.5315155983,
-0.328923434,
-0.7243869901,
0.9734387994,
0.0271371752,
0.5960170627,
0.3012597263,
0.1464878768,
-0.0905038416,
-0.542414248,
-0.3498804271,
0.3383207321,
-0.4833534658,
-0.1991651654,
-0.487534225,
-0.1314823627,
-0.247471258,
-0.2768588364,
-0.404076457,
-0.503844142,
0.0070523256,
-0.2059370726,
0.426650703,
0.1705706269,
0.0390596874,
1.0630663633,
-0.8881082535,
0.1270795614,
0.2498665452,
0.1210120544,
0.054152064,
-0.3393453062,
-0.2885069251,
0.0993722603,
-0.275901109,
-0.5465430021,
0.4664096236,
0.1011927724,
0.6995449662,
0.263263762,
-0.1839889139,
0.7417638898,
-0.7141476274,
0.6848950386,
0.2137880474,
-0.7812355161,
0.3921602666,
-0.3312045634,
0.6192631125,
1.0965948105,
0.1972563118,
-0.8407607079,
-0.6434316039,
-0.7446829081,
-0.8677459359,
0.5065762401,
0.1749761105,
0.2180055678,
-0.0569342598,
0.1709869653,
-0.0429060906,
0.6422139406,
-0.8706791997,
0.0021793141,
0.0619020276,
-0.505235076,
-0.0702071935,
-0.3087711632,
-0.3515533507,
-0.2835367918,
0.4047708511,
-0.1878414303,
-0.0018765242,
-0.185695067,
-0.1599923521,
-0.1465356052,
0.2739936113,
0.6665017009,
0.620963037,
-0.1424358189,
0.035801053,
0.2623406053,
-0.7640047669,
0.0453717783,
-0.2648706734,
-0.5391614437,
0.1504517496,
0.318361789,
0.6931279302,
0.3306981027,
-1.0521279573,
0.6404682398,
0.3471292853,
-0.1238563061,
-0.2307057977,
0.1357538551,
0.1319993436,
0.0142466463,
0.2765194178,
-0.2263455242,
-0.1385842115,
-0.3969240785,
0.4078489542,
0.4218477011,
-0.0625206903,
-0.1818902045,
0.0693889484,
-0.0917654112,
-0.1497175992,
0.6467114091,
0.1530464143,
-0.6552490592,
0.7506946325,
0.8228232861,
0.4498132467,
-0.4274727106,
0.2398277521,
0.2128306776,
0.3063723147,
-0.5946404338,
0.229229033,
0.121291168,
-0.7549402118,
-0.4358099997,
-0.5329943299,
-0.6208728552,
0.0539575405,
-0.8799595237,
0.4949735701,
-0.281245321,
0.0611525737,
-0.6454092264,
-0.2672578394,
-0.1604905427,
0.2409598678,
-0.0692880973,
1.0351372957,
-1.2894756794,
0.9353418946,
0.3681976497,
-0.0163066518,
-0.5408536196,
-0.1562484056,
-0.0592889227,
-0.9873756766,
0.2739274502,
0.2793656886,
0.0338353887,
0.1463905126,
-0.9010286927,
-0.7785866261,
0.7910036445,
0.1615623087,
-0.6776040792,
0.1761804223,
0.3644733429,
0.5695437193,
-0.5794538856,
-0.1157741472,
0.6932194829,
0.1776665002,
0.2571347654,
-0.6157660484,
-0.3236181736,
-0.1725400686,
-0.0497451872,
0.2712073326,
-0.3905828595,
0.7285633087,
0.2226040363,
-0.1157636195,
0.1587806344,
0.6156857014,
0.880630374,
0.2234446108,
0.9541557431,
0.921688199,
0.6809905767,
0.1580866724,
0.9158385992,
-0.1487703323,
0.4390530884,
1.401990056,
-0.4857356548,
1.105176568,
0.7431215644,
-0.2030575275,
0.0632874146,
0.3897555768,
-0.5739114285,
0.6685500145,
0.2465595752,
-0.1561560333,
-0.0492300354,
-0.0287221558,
-0.2978760302,
0.3237593174,
0.1369599551,
0.0261551179,
-0.5339348912,
0.3030641973,
0.151748687,
0.3082890213,
-0.1318286061,
0.6183459163,
0.1633505076,
-0.7164137363,
0.4044642746,
0.0510377809,
0.6931195855,
-0.4528181553,
0.1058516428,
-0.1346866488,
0.2107782662,
-0.1142587066,
-0.8469036222,
0.341869235,
0.0503948256,
-0.4492727518,
-0.2805648446,
0.434563607,
-0.915004015,
-0.7376989126,
0.1741399318,
0.1400087476,
0.1913295239,
-0.0587331243,
-0.4815802276,
0.0395868793,
0.0692673698,
0.1229675934,
0.4055393338,
0.1119099036,
-0.1936422884,
0.5695433617,
0.6355820298,
0.4984955192,
0.0738956779,
0.4202960134,
0.9065161943,
-0.5795357823,
-0.7074425817,
-0.9886214733,
0.3523774147,
-0.3845954537,
-0.2942858934,
0.6988862157,
0.6337915659,
0.8030698299,
-0.0851812065,
0.6206316948,
0.1802492589,
1.2546678782,
-0.6528884172,
0.558406353,
-0.3368939757,
0.2032025605,
-0.2898383141,
-1.0294133425,
-0.2620198727,
0.670206964,
-0.2495019287,
-0.0343605243,
0.6313017607,
0.596434772,
-0.2673314214,
0.0060839015,
-0.0709506199,
-0.0141892321,
0.3335670531,
0.367379874,
0.4870454967,
-0.0115545243,
0.3175248802,
-0.239712432,
-0.2119906098,
-0.3910079896,
-1.0449966192,
-1.1676931381,
-0.1063531041,
0.0653809533,
0.137844637,
-0.2633501589,
0.7629165053,
0.7042880058,
-0.9000732303,
-0.5702812076,
-0.1911186278,
-0.0811529905,
-0.3300737143,
-0.1714717001,
0.276429534,
-0.2953270674,
-0.7393767238,
0.2507570684,
0.0240797047,
0.4035353363,
-0.0806560963,
0.475430876,
-0.2214874178,
-0.275919348,
0.2982841432,
0.3082674444,
-0.1956112087,
-0.0779856145,
-0.0281601083,
-0.1738687903,
0.1581693888,
1.0773954391,
-0.5847402215,
0.2275836915,
0.4087022841,
0.7443712354,
0.7589518428,
0.3024479747,
0.9436181784,
-1.250895977,
0.7274330258,
0.1149166971,
0.1634575278,
0.4029582739,
-0.1215927079,
0.3293107748,
0.3752504289,
-0.4017726183,
-0.9955716729,
-0.0518018268,
-1.2889851332,
-0.3902049959,
1.037920475,
0.2517300844,
-0.2195112109,
0.1880234033,
-0.2864073217,
0.0544302873,
-0.1318267584,
0.8014737964,
0.934188962,
0.3574246168,
-0.1629224718,
-0.6055694818,
0.2378881127,
0.8207517862,
-0.926156342,
0.0603166968,
0.2492695898,
0.4074353576,
-0.016934121,
0.7681819797,
0.0564653911,
-0.0408050604,
-0.4471125901,
0.2567215264,
0.338976711,
-0.4061906934,
-0.3880065978,
0.1703440398,
-0.1193947494,
-0.1139885262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14523v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14523v2
|
Daisy-TTS: Simulating Wider Spectrum of Emotions via Prosody Embedding Decomposition
| 2024-02-22T13:15:49 | 2024-06-27T15:14:58 |
Rendi Chevi, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We often verbally express emotions in a multifaceted manner, they may vary in
their intensities and may be expressed not just as a single but as a mixture of
emotions. This wide spectrum of emotions is well-studied in the structural
model of emotions, which represents variety of emotions as derivative products
of primary emotions with varying degrees of intensity. In this paper, we
propose an emotional text-to-speech design to simulate a wider spectrum of
emotions grounded on the structural model. Our proposed design, Daisy-TTS,
incorporates a prosody encoder to learn emotionally-separable prosody embedding
as a proxy for emotion. This emotion representation allows the model to
simulate: (1) Primary emotions, as learned from the training samples, (2)
Secondary emotions, as a mixture of primary emotions, (3) Intensity-level, by
scaling the emotion embedding, and (4) Emotions polarity, by negating the
emotion embedding. Through a series of perceptual evaluations, Daisy-TTS
demonstrated overall higher emotional speech naturalness and emotion
perceiveability compared to the baseline.
|
[
-0.3158764839,
-1.1038212776,
0.3848303556,
0.5745489597,
-0.5282464027,
0.4118990302,
-0.3048319817,
-0.1386247426,
0.9379043579,
-0.2116117924,
-0.880366385,
-0.5951243639,
-0.3823575675,
0.2458208799,
-0.317753315,
0.794901371,
0.101627484,
0.1253177226,
0.2243030071,
0.1641887128,
-0.2213405073,
-0.6740612388,
-0.4829523265,
0.234200269,
0.4190472066,
0.4197619557,
0.4464636445,
0.01450318,
0.2972982526,
0.2884995043,
-0.382379204,
-0.1053794026,
-0.5924801826,
0.6411241889,
0.2917850614,
-0.3286441565,
-0.6757802963,
0.1744664609,
0.8940212727,
0.2466122806,
-0.1562708616,
-0.1184690297,
0.1472204626,
0.2737480402,
-0.7826173902,
0.2610821128,
-0.087992534,
0.2892845571,
0.0624022931,
0.0716781467,
-0.6211572289,
-0.1771815717,
0.1541155428,
-0.7482444048,
0.0270693004,
-0.0129559822,
0.6217790842,
-0.1431469321,
-0.9177699089,
-0.307503581,
-0.6056373715,
0.6751108766,
-0.384895891,
0.7262098789,
0.0769306943,
0.1663587689,
-0.0644596815,
-0.6649505496,
-0.6674550176,
-0.3924437761,
0.3017039895,
0.698179841,
-0.1368723661,
0.2894818783,
-0.0320572332,
0.3730414808,
-0.5721219778,
-0.2001691014,
-0.0397547297,
-0.0051425467,
0.4967567325,
0.2194232941,
0.447964251,
-0.2454594225,
-0.110397093,
-0.1150875241,
-0.251306802,
0.067845948,
0.5593207479,
0.6351004839,
-0.4207173288,
0.5520262718,
-0.0918208659,
0.1759874225,
0.0519971475,
-0.031504225,
0.5696750283,
0.1361362487,
-0.312846005,
0.055840116,
0.8857478499,
0.2323067188,
0.3294795752,
-0.2002675831,
0.0798504576,
0.661367476,
0.2383762449,
-0.9156004786,
-0.1512287706,
0.493786037,
-0.4058300555,
-0.244572103,
-0.1203217357,
-1.032094121,
-0.306329906,
-0.2079096287,
0.534055829,
-0.7987853885,
-0.5321452022,
-0.0319945626,
-0.3139768839,
-0.1641443372,
0.0078695398,
-0.926671207,
0.4753705859,
0.6800304651,
1.005982399,
0.332605511,
-0.1444588602,
-0.6652904749,
0.0425859503,
-0.465700537,
0.3253321052,
-0.9796729684,
-0.7984025478,
-0.0618419088,
0.0951003358,
0.0457020849,
-0.158803612,
0.6870851517,
-0.1868695617,
-0.0144854272,
-0.3554987609,
-0.5303397179,
0.0130027542,
0.0251573715,
-0.6905660629,
0.6764874458,
0.2372432947,
-0.7265137434,
0.1408009976,
-0.4482967257,
-0.4228224456,
-0.1808042377,
-0.0751460046,
-0.5669600964,
0.5410948396,
0.0847674608,
0.1887837499,
-0.3372775912,
0.0172072686,
-0.5744440556,
-0.5103572011,
0.1802957356,
-0.1852505654,
0.4127245545,
0.4138641953,
-0.3158629835,
0.2442385107,
-0.6331528425,
-0.1804333031,
0.0893259048,
0.1814401001,
-0.4611772597,
-0.0876467004,
0.3986994326,
0.0833449289,
-0.2229560912,
-0.9497249722,
0.1497687846,
-0.4462031722,
0.6079190969,
0.6340773106,
0.1487060934,
0.6152934432,
-0.0049686357,
0.9612092972,
0.2747648656,
0.3060855567,
-0.1042540148,
-0.6305032372,
-0.6987675428,
-0.7675038576,
0.1133513972,
0.2868036628,
-0.234983325,
0.2280960977,
0.0726502165,
-0.4774658084,
-0.9158089757,
-0.5181178451,
0.3137673736,
0.5236702561,
0.3652553856,
-0.188023448,
-0.6450991035,
-0.6990660429,
-0.2396815121,
-0.1673194021,
-0.1462063193,
-0.0611328743,
0.3707183897,
-0.2452297807,
1.1869529486,
-0.3634896576,
-0.2789357305,
0.0398763232,
0.427559793,
-0.305918932,
0.4575897753,
0.3657382429,
-0.5691819191,
-0.1619743705,
-0.3220928609,
-0.4896197021,
-0.1248302311,
0.0246318486,
-0.0048122201,
0.0101189865,
0.0130927414,
-0.8912698627,
0.3195003271,
0.4907712042,
-0.5402119756,
0.6861488819,
-0.1632751077,
0.1675501913,
-1.3528777361,
-0.2925235331,
-0.012422611,
0.1139743924,
-0.5443512201,
0.1032933816,
0.2509854436,
-0.478813529,
-0.4332402647,
0.1236189753,
-0.563668251,
-0.1588873416,
0.0272679366,
0.1678453237,
0.153365761,
0.2763486803,
0.1300205588,
0.7701811194,
0.7959830761,
-0.440703243,
0.4885329306,
0.3195219934,
0.1720430255,
0.7431787848,
-0.754386425,
0.0792097077,
-0.5499280095,
0.5730967522,
-1.0720059872,
-0.163032636,
0.0670743585,
-0.539896369,
0.1626673788,
-0.0533651933,
-0.5315602422,
-0.1890452504,
-0.4303152263,
0.3325643241,
0.9060761929,
-0.1593395472,
0.9101251364,
0.4944489598,
-0.3618042469,
-0.0555343553,
-0.659207046,
0.0731223449,
-0.520835042,
-0.6190077662,
0.3356053233,
0.0400220416,
-0.301840663,
-0.1134327054,
0.229659155,
0.1624711752,
-0.1297864765,
0.5601425171,
-0.1199579313,
-0.0341161452,
0.5876408219,
0.3089562654,
-0.2833993733,
0.106087029,
-0.1581028849,
0.5438600779,
-0.3867434561,
-0.2837789953,
-0.6871959567,
0.8341156244,
0.5664982796,
-0.4404980838,
0.5938610435,
0.779275775,
-0.3875092268,
-0.430015415,
-0.0087638674,
-0.3778786957,
-0.4870800674,
0.5711881518,
-0.6819555759,
-0.7593090534,
0.5048927069,
-0.2474118918,
-0.2099998742,
0.1883497834,
0.6081187129,
-0.4401469231,
1.3450893164,
0.5370745063,
-0.0591268726,
0.5770461559,
-0.4591352046,
0.1761391908,
-0.8180091381,
-0.2218856812,
-0.533752203,
-0.4384887516,
-0.7041056752,
-0.4867059588,
0.4917161167,
0.0038973708,
-0.5955597758,
0.0228732079,
-0.1863607019,
0.0967704207,
0.4744186997,
0.159686923,
-0.0494402386,
0.0507666953,
-0.2235732973,
-0.3711539507,
-0.3777157068,
-0.3841287792,
0.7232231498,
0.6088744402,
0.7397906184,
0.1372659653,
1.0256364346,
-0.0557124019,
0.2723958194,
-0.9884861112,
0.5502324104,
-0.4261296093,
-0.1418921053,
-0.0320293196,
-0.3895811737,
-0.7249848843,
0.0773533285,
-0.2334411889,
-0.9191332459,
0.2271429151,
0.0752738565,
-0.2705675066,
-0.0835836604,
-0.9675402045,
0.7443763018,
0.2692821622,
-0.3597094715,
-0.405177176,
-0.4966481626,
0.2194010168,
0.1662752628,
0.4915519655,
-0.0626197308,
0.0255240034,
0.8544029593,
-0.7813601494,
0.8845822811,
-0.134146452,
-0.1864728779,
0.4515435398,
0.521623373,
0.5972305536,
0.1388075352,
-0.0987948999,
-0.2319601178,
-0.3226080537,
-0.2012728155,
-0.7858386636,
0.5236796737,
-0.9926590323,
-0.3110564351,
-0.2510128021,
-0.6583732963,
-0.5578944087,
-0.310603857,
0.1552785486,
0.6522462964,
-0.1532824188,
0.0828919709,
0.3296782672,
-0.0852371827,
0.3071640432,
0.2800465822,
-0.4068037868,
-0.686858654,
1.0504643917,
0.1526651829,
0.1324222088,
0.2588403225,
0.4888107181,
-0.4268245399,
-0.0159463119,
-0.0409001857,
0.2610267699,
-0.5578898787,
0.2021703571,
-0.6849372387,
0.1415952295,
-0.6506949663,
-0.2610156536,
-0.5239049792,
-0.3544895947,
-0.5405166745,
-0.4370216727,
0.713983953,
0.6424031258,
-0.0799283087,
0.5631063581,
-0.8150727749,
0.5093957782,
0.4962578118,
0.4166448712,
-0.1787577718,
-0.6519498229,
0.0688969716,
0.1640638262,
-0.1772059202,
-1.3716943264,
0.8770986795,
0.3349818289,
0.0389203504,
0.4295067787,
0.3616988361,
0.8865492344,
-0.4717085063,
0.8970627785,
0.2980158925,
-1.4444812536,
0.6434960961,
-0.4768126011,
0.0403239243,
0.1953381896,
0.464866817,
-0.6285828948,
-0.6986976266,
-0.6755642295,
-1.028506279,
0.504957974,
0.3725348711,
0.2525920868,
-0.1984371841,
0.065665707,
-0.1093286052,
0.0302717928,
-0.3732118011,
-0.0160292517,
-0.2495089024,
-0.7741173506,
-0.2343522012,
-0.6285485625,
0.0424060822,
0.0978282019,
0.6353415847,
0.0559681952,
0.6463304162,
0.0886798501,
-0.0288504642,
-0.0422924496,
0.1966266483,
0.2507939041,
-0.2980038524,
-0.4490250349,
0.2366671413,
-0.0461760424,
-0.8575199842,
0.3833428025,
-0.2109974474,
0.0818215385,
0.2188547254,
0.2376108617,
1.0110151768,
0.2124477178,
-0.5562003851,
0.4568249583,
-0.0940831527,
-0.14684847,
-0.0225251634,
-0.3313048482,
0.484898895,
0.4617739022,
0.1927057952,
-0.596010983,
0.229192242,
-0.87965101,
0.2808206379,
0.2887614071,
-0.5997945666,
-0.4920275211,
0.7227262259,
0.4562191963,
-0.6908531189,
0.5420288444,
-0.2563253343,
-0.4779918492,
0.6996767521,
0.9003579617,
1.2978796959,
-0.4615109265,
0.3682633042,
0.1891220063,
0.1186219752,
0.4160358012,
1.0395667553,
-0.1174239516,
-0.2757371664,
-0.0767462775,
-0.6308288574,
-0.7355723381,
-0.3333336413,
-0.6381190419,
0.3418772221,
-0.4749011695,
-0.5695813894,
-0.3325571418,
-0.1573736072,
-0.3885060847,
0.521523118,
0.2718803585,
0.788926065,
-1.117149353,
0.7465418577,
0.6737672091,
-0.5066063404,
-0.9146468043,
0.1680219322,
0.2141346037,
-0.2828772664,
0.9401242733,
0.4178509712,
-0.390306145,
0.245154053,
-0.0632653907,
-0.593325913,
0.9407724142,
0.4316888154,
-0.8352239728,
0.0944620147,
0.2313599288,
0.6722797155,
-0.5004641414,
0.7001752853,
0.2775676548,
0.0374904163,
0.1500086337,
-0.8682140708,
-0.0809595063,
-0.3291901052,
0.0965879634,
-0.1629767567,
-0.9172282815,
1.3960222006,
0.0074040173,
-0.3886969984,
-0.1340997666,
0.8111513853,
0.5164097548,
0.0272617433,
0.4741453826,
0.4427036345,
0.6936081052,
-0.1265053451,
0.7074801922,
-0.5005981922,
0.4955417216,
0.7940496802,
-0.3956567943,
1.0525789261,
0.4881076515,
-0.2665977478,
0.5641256571,
0.5593805313,
0.7647765875,
0.5900380015,
0.4124925435,
-0.7120776772,
-0.2294682115,
-0.1642467827,
-0.5803394914,
0.5657458305,
0.6290242076,
-0.2380022556,
-0.0966856182,
0.3361798823,
-0.1942862868,
-0.1394875199,
-0.1343563348,
0.6398276687,
0.1913853586,
0.0628229231,
0.3786091208,
0.033081349,
0.5752546191,
-0.771766305,
0.0499305986,
-0.2899450362,
0.109635517,
0.0173586421,
-0.6039196849,
0.2450622767,
0.129257977,
0.0572098456,
-0.2595182061,
0.4538449943,
-0.5734636784,
-0.4810743034,
0.4785084426,
-0.001255692,
0.0538313203,
-0.253282547,
-0.2289163768,
0.4531337321,
-0.4925223887,
-0.5351608992,
0.1109510735,
0.6984701753,
0.1000462472,
0.5805913806,
0.4406405985,
-0.0232257992,
-0.115288794,
0.406385988,
0.9106021523,
-0.7077094913,
-1.3295121193,
-0.8306056857,
0.7154984474,
0.0979465917,
-0.1312952936,
0.7394124866,
0.4141642451,
0.1505724639,
-0.1665972173,
0.7364178896,
0.2582963705,
0.2885946333,
-0.3551422358,
0.5961931944,
-0.4868293107,
-0.2459617853,
-0.9677658081,
-0.714025259,
-0.0992995203,
0.9179884195,
-0.0763298571,
-0.0686475486,
0.6352918744,
0.7560241818,
0.3007167876,
0.7447265983,
0.2089153528,
0.4443356395,
0.3643419147,
0.7164778709,
0.9827283621,
-0.3312915564,
0.1302680075,
-0.2032327801,
-0.4639241099,
-0.2304006815,
-0.7683568001,
-0.4905069768,
-0.8356630802,
-0.3068903685,
-0.3515769839,
0.1547308713,
1.1541382074,
0.6239851713,
-0.5592463017,
-0.2213095576,
-0.2771665454,
-0.2259264141,
-0.0760995373,
-0.2052864134,
0.2715166509,
-0.4260029495,
-0.8682077527,
0.4855079055,
0.2658205628,
0.1959559172,
-0.1342016608,
-0.2193759978,
0.1679233015,
0.0754397437,
0.8154779077,
-0.1530706584,
-0.4033962488,
-0.3387152851,
0.0283857342,
0.1065177619,
-0.2744418085,
0.7463055849,
-0.9004643559,
0.6302996278,
0.5293098092,
0.380206883,
0.4018825889,
-0.1282895058,
0.6508460045,
-0.9502204657,
0.486096859,
0.3518584371,
0.3496609032,
-0.0253303852,
-0.1766482741,
-0.0420732722,
0.5603375435,
-0.0930382162,
-0.7970653176,
0.4483832717,
-1.0935642719,
-0.143211931,
1.3620018959,
-0.1878464371,
-0.2931409478,
0.1322990358,
-0.5289458036,
0.7813845277,
-0.5613145828,
0.5968104005,
0.5604792833,
0.0796232745,
-0.1640575677,
-0.2421081215,
0.284262836,
0.5430313349,
-0.6334917545,
0.2738748491,
0.6720597148,
0.1202527881,
-0.0399589948,
0.6458239555,
0.0947135314,
0.1705113053,
0.6549580693,
0.1079385802,
-0.1267816424,
-0.4903053343,
-0.5495527387,
0.5826377273,
-0.3347010016,
-0.5132484436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14522v1
|
Towards Unified Task Embeddings Across Multiple Models: Bridging the Gap for Prompt-Based Large Language Models and Beyond
| 2024-02-22T13:13:31 | 2024-02-22T13:13:31 |
Xinyu Wang, Hainiu Xu, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Task embedding, a meta-learning technique that captures task-specific
information, has become prevalent, especially in areas such as multi-task
learning, model editing, and interpretability. However, it faces challenges
with the emergence of prompt-guided Large Language Models (LLMs) operating in a
gradientfree manner. Existing task embedding methods rely on fine-tuned,
task-specific language models, which hinders the adaptability of task
embeddings across diverse models, especially prompt-based LLMs. To unleash the
power of task embedding in the era of LLMs, we propose a framework for unified
task embeddings (FUTE), harmonizing task embeddings from various models,
including smaller language models and LLMs with varied prompts, within a single
vector space. Such uniformity enables the comparison and analysis of
similarities amongst different models, extending the scope and utility of
existing task embedding methods in addressing multi-model scenarios, whilst
maintaining their performance to be comparable to architecture-specific
methods.
|
[
-0.1701646596,
-0.5605198741,
0.6834003925,
0.5012941957,
0.037564341,
-0.0734311119,
-0.2417018712,
0.0522498041,
-0.0530763268,
0.4312357605,
-0.7851586342,
-0.6977726817,
-0.3500283659,
0.115529716,
-0.1284736693,
0.6814726591,
-0.0659673735,
0.1490334421,
-0.7147446871,
-0.3052197695,
-0.9691116214,
-0.4579237103,
-0.3597222865,
-0.2973766625,
0.5398240685,
0.3500530422,
0.4254461825,
0.3808577955,
0.1164254323,
0.2735399604,
0.3150629699,
0.2617784142,
-0.1435211301,
0.3694048226,
-0.2751896679,
-0.3480779529,
-0.2908957005,
-0.1295964271,
0.8189010024,
0.8949548602,
-0.1537577659,
0.013210346,
0.5902495384,
0.1129147708,
-0.7790424824,
0.2761289179,
-0.3361863792,
-0.0704822466,
-0.1064338237,
0.131644845,
-0.5240370631,
0.1272600144,
-0.045484148,
-0.5144502521,
0.192332983,
-0.08943744,
0.3472386003,
0.327210933,
-0.4466015399,
0.0094360141,
-0.4841508567,
0.9518031478,
-0.6824852824,
0.606548667,
-0.0777776316,
0.1366546899,
-0.0673892647,
-0.6376422048,
-0.2299221456,
-0.1953593791,
-0.1545318663,
-0.2335753441,
-0.2782416046,
0.1115635931,
0.1261470616,
-0.1174395457,
-0.5274987221,
0.262970835,
0.3297499716,
-0.1688053608,
0.3643749654,
0.2983838022,
0.4520065784,
-0.0084567862,
-0.5447074771,
0.1463472247,
-0.760142684,
0.0703661442,
0.15329808,
0.7490687966,
-0.1671865731,
0.2626852095,
-0.0649344623,
0.7197490335,
0.0416126549,
0.0453496091,
0.1553033739,
-0.2688654065,
-0.3162011504,
-0.500438869,
0.9192881584,
-0.0128857614,
-0.0854014307,
-0.3814317584,
-0.3120420575,
-0.1153631732,
0.1547399759,
-0.5749270916,
0.1212599128,
0.0669350103,
-0.3729323447,
0.0790757239,
0.2103609145,
-0.6839968562,
-0.4547477365,
-0.3465264738,
0.3441963196,
-0.1038942039,
-0.2237205803,
0.1292761564,
0.0882351771,
0.1957956702,
0.4660561979,
-0.7797056437,
0.2644612193,
0.7666766644,
0.9116450548,
-0.2255443335,
-0.5905306339,
-0.8140229583,
0.1879814118,
-0.0252135433,
0.6263331771,
-0.8277131319,
-0.5822181106,
0.3315903246,
0.1696938425,
-0.4184819162,
-0.0813803375,
0.574301362,
-0.197265625,
0.2106470019,
-0.7131053805,
-0.6576185226,
-0.2770362496,
0.100070104,
-0.6977645755,
1.1206321716,
0.0613073148,
-0.5869445801,
0.0810976774,
-0.813508451,
-0.4519839585,
0.0594506003,
-0.4479437172,
-0.1216781065,
0.2581354976,
0.3184497356,
0.9564114213,
-0.5421559215,
0.4488329887,
-0.4189587831,
-0.1660311073,
-0.1434970498,
-0.4658659101,
0.7846671939,
0.0559066832,
-0.2984958887,
0.4015302658,
-0.0663270876,
-0.2029698342,
-0.0560381971,
-0.1389412731,
-0.3466999531,
0.0175351948,
0.2618983984,
0.3206227124,
0.3996071815,
-0.6176049113,
0.5513965487,
-0.0270059705,
0.414393723,
0.7674176097,
-0.3388003409,
0.5000664592,
-0.4282074869,
0.5722661018,
0.0837627873,
-0.0325488038,
-0.5839219689,
-0.5097960234,
-0.3943965137,
-0.5611511469,
0.193632111,
0.5914413929,
-0.4329615831,
0.3780787587,
-0.1840475798,
-0.3246113658,
-0.6112162471,
0.3058325648,
0.4181312323,
0.1745468676,
0.3303665817,
0.0662186071,
-0.3664096594,
-0.826988399,
-0.3787715733,
0.2846330702,
-0.0004363269,
0.361335516,
0.5188404322,
-0.4510153234,
0.8872392178,
-0.3982620239,
-0.2932820022,
-0.3600058556,
0.2211417258,
0.198392719,
0.7125974298,
0.5742501616,
-0.7176290751,
-0.5397382975,
-0.1205835566,
-0.6853320003,
-0.1288326234,
-0.3574431241,
-0.0329400152,
-0.0369468182,
0.7435699701,
-0.6341838837,
0.1486160606,
0.6290850639,
-0.528560698,
0.3041563332,
-0.2998664379,
0.3091369271,
-1.3312425613,
0.1488682181,
-0.0054849517,
-0.3104293644,
-0.7330476046,
0.1576697677,
0.2858302295,
-0.0520904176,
-0.4139689207,
0.9617745876,
-0.6371794343,
0.0449894108,
-0.2206282765,
-0.0180593878,
0.0472167097,
0.508102715,
-0.1353549361,
0.671818614,
0.9116318226,
-0.5829243064,
0.2150661647,
0.2161802202,
-0.1053401083,
0.7761182189,
-0.7726452947,
0.1700091511,
-0.2185798138,
0.3723911345,
-1.1404458284,
-0.1105023772,
0.101928845,
-0.0922900215,
0.1970322728,
-0.0477567315,
-0.5457008481,
-0.1344397217,
-0.3911271095,
0.6220739484,
0.3712542057,
-0.7139281034,
0.945643127,
0.1427197456,
-0.1805766076,
-0.8006628156,
-0.510168016,
-0.1510694325,
-0.0778848454,
-0.6000265479,
0.6190152764,
-0.2284287214,
0.0741946697,
0.0085059041,
-0.0242476203,
0.0048498055,
0.288102746,
0.4824703038,
0.1770894825,
-0.2064971924,
0.4075992107,
0.2323467135,
-0.0209265202,
-0.1551521271,
-0.4387659729,
0.5876649618,
-0.0004438339,
-0.8035976887,
-0.4238211513,
0.7427942753,
0.6966240406,
-0.4617409706,
0.7345980406,
0.6840031147,
-0.665816009,
-0.4542815685,
-0.5754176378,
-0.0501765497,
-0.4518826008,
0.2040166259,
-0.504927516,
-1.1592630148,
0.5406219363,
-0.2485958487,
0.5347632766,
0.4633156657,
0.5938178301,
-0.1874184757,
1.0351208448,
0.9766465425,
-0.2119644135,
0.567088604,
-0.065807119,
-0.1510264277,
-0.8811496496,
-0.4559598565,
-0.6388272643,
-0.3200103045,
-0.1329360306,
-0.6048344374,
0.076038152,
0.0593311228,
-0.2582910657,
0.1854245514,
-0.1438035071,
0.4551346302,
0.605791688,
0.030437151,
0.0330192,
-0.3290114999,
-0.3850348592,
0.2011459619,
-0.8497430682,
-0.4195197225,
1.0209171772,
0.1379379034,
0.658401072,
-0.0476169176,
0.7391376495,
0.5511879921,
0.2664394677,
-0.4487326145,
0.41429919,
-0.4393567443,
-0.3616976142,
-0.1438142657,
-0.2219658345,
-1.0035914183,
0.4880049527,
-0.1771729141,
-0.8762142658,
0.2274034917,
0.1020156294,
-0.588932991,
0.5311834812,
-0.466409862,
1.2744323015,
0.0949167162,
-0.1954193115,
-0.0758822858,
-0.3976449966,
0.1471987516,
0.0738329962,
0.3922263384,
-0.2878910899,
-0.2762156725,
0.7160941958,
0.0284953937,
1.295155406,
-0.2614145279,
-0.3363472223,
0.1783178449,
0.0477556549,
0.5053207278,
0.0511234701,
0.0879879221,
0.022898715,
0.003295196,
-0.5362095833,
-0.6124825478,
0.9050182104,
-0.5418774486,
-0.5488895178,
-0.1908285469,
-0.8437434435,
-0.4240145981,
-0.0379623473,
0.0908733085,
0.6739096642,
-0.5464946628,
0.1022175029,
0.6850241423,
-0.0657882616,
0.6704635024,
0.3171821833,
-0.0650828481,
-0.1527308971,
0.782666266,
-0.3442505002,
0.0089586154,
0.6526814699,
0.0927153826,
-0.4046107531,
-0.1344957054,
-0.1780995429,
0.2236811221,
-0.656257987,
-0.2822345197,
-0.7631483078,
0.2244528234,
-0.5213407874,
-0.4370880127,
-0.254273504,
0.0278843585,
-0.6251375079,
0.1767411679,
0.1489245892,
0.9570116997,
-0.1647318006,
0.4692165256,
-1.0314297676,
0.3121988475,
0.3554662466,
0.2718303502,
0.0804504082,
-0.3296143711,
-0.2254321873,
0.2387505323,
-0.201071009,
-1.0189871788,
0.101501897,
0.2097844779,
1.0075697899,
0.2799181044,
-0.087257579,
0.4467308521,
-0.6685054302,
0.8956946731,
0.383416146,
-1.2325894833,
0.4141336977,
-0.3596354723,
0.4530431628,
0.3007707894,
0.4678860605,
-0.8395285606,
-0.1820991933,
-0.5656227469,
-0.5620645285,
0.4894174039,
-0.2462912202,
0.4072220027,
0.0275862124,
0.1282135695,
0.4689192474,
0.1820362508,
-0.6934716105,
-0.1888212711,
0.1020875126,
-0.5475857854,
-0.2404306531,
0.0023617903,
-0.1151254773,
-0.177872315,
0.3291167617,
-0.2720040679,
0.4146194756,
-0.1086185575,
-0.4665391743,
0.0999443829,
0.444914788,
0.2841458917,
0.3386390507,
0.2907848954,
0.0987161621,
0.2933650315,
-0.1109980345,
0.1922273785,
0.082596004,
-0.0885990486,
0.0103133125,
0.6312665343,
0.8521143198,
0.6369130611,
-0.5350208879,
0.6672148705,
0.1591757089,
-0.0635712445,
0.4107787907,
0.1228685305,
0.0704442337,
0.5617977381,
0.1934091449,
0.068222791,
-0.0720256791,
-0.5532507896,
0.3382069468,
0.7514015436,
-0.3753491342,
-0.4140335023,
0.6216716766,
0.500236094,
-0.3191527724,
0.3825883865,
-0.1054172963,
-0.3830533624,
0.4460408986,
0.496035099,
1.2165415287,
-0.611792326,
0.4173548222,
0.2668701708,
0.2704303861,
-0.3228341937,
0.5361155272,
-0.1391613334,
-0.5225057602,
-0.4488607347,
-0.4442074597,
-0.2490000129,
-0.1146682426,
-0.5821595192,
0.1513958126,
-0.1866638213,
-0.0754893124,
-0.3542512059,
-0.3733994365,
-1.0315139294,
-0.0932261422,
0.2138907313,
0.7216795683,
-1.0620919466,
0.7558420897,
0.8483664989,
-0.135429129,
-0.5490065813,
0.0782937855,
0.0060340585,
-0.6040483117,
0.3749481142,
0.3510446548,
0.0047803279,
0.091247879,
-0.3414449692,
-0.6785341501,
1.2872350216,
0.7309649587,
-0.64681077,
-0.3542731106,
-0.0081322808,
0.0816974789,
-0.7413680553,
0.1025788933,
0.3514251113,
0.3776621222,
-0.2200043648,
-0.9128289223,
0.3267467022,
0.0781983063,
-0.0198344849,
0.1839241832,
-0.2885829806,
1.0201364756,
-0.3638440669,
-0.4321915209,
0.1305194199,
0.6872728467,
0.1032669395,
0.0190694388,
0.5835209489,
0.4328759015,
0.8850325346,
-0.1476898491,
0.8976350427,
-0.24705033,
0.4637440145,
1.1273636818,
-0.2018841505,
0.7436819077,
0.3229819536,
-0.0680497289,
0.514338851,
0.3897635341,
0.059053719,
0.469738692,
0.1279208213,
-0.336486876,
-0.574888885,
-0.2479490489,
-0.3075824976,
0.103294231,
0.3215488493,
-0.1400841624,
-0.5250536203,
0.3717523515,
0.0201790594,
0.0300997198,
-0.3510168493,
0.5402764082,
0.1317544281,
-0.5132087469,
0.2127135545,
0.0970543027,
0.9550426602,
-0.7080110908,
-0.1167282239,
-0.0682277232,
-0.1050453782,
-0.0348560065,
-0.7107955813,
-0.0122683523,
-0.0487841703,
-0.1456254274,
-0.5403603315,
0.5541799068,
-0.662714541,
-0.3699010909,
0.4173114896,
1.0816655159,
-0.3964867592,
-0.1943231076,
-0.7884754539,
0.0515769981,
-0.1360542774,
-0.1742845327,
0.2538742125,
0.4767522216,
0.1094960645,
0.6319112182,
0.5413267612,
-0.4227226079,
-0.0936950892,
0.1263992488,
0.7148731947,
-0.6024032235,
-0.6351717114,
-1.0566902161,
0.8078528047,
0.2094057947,
-0.298900038,
0.724190712,
0.1915523559,
0.541639328,
-0.2371215522,
0.814571023,
-0.0264696814,
0.1457850039,
-0.4704770744,
0.4856715202,
-0.8646433353,
0.057287287,
-0.479781419,
-0.9745557904,
-0.2422804385,
0.3679486215,
0.0957812965,
0.1668837219,
0.6733288169,
0.63823843,
-0.2398152351,
-0.0366214141,
0.4550783634,
-0.1075765416,
0.2093036771,
0.7347798347,
0.7608312368,
-0.0548589639,
0.1962596178,
0.0681069866,
-0.1203585193,
-0.1738463491,
-1.0275423527,
-1.079498291,
-1.0096107721,
-0.296672672,
0.1582905799,
-0.0672315955,
1.1177667379,
0.7123169899,
-0.7995394468,
-0.3806273937,
0.036983721,
0.2838402092,
-0.4310374558,
-0.1495846212,
0.3412241638,
-0.4655035138,
-0.7164775133,
0.5574924946,
0.2327105552,
0.0120403962,
-0.3108575344,
-0.0775049925,
-0.3084107637,
0.2496467978,
0.5113748312,
0.2830214202,
-0.8477639556,
-0.1889114827,
0.1138053164,
-0.2556405365,
-0.195478335,
1.1089023352,
-0.7087465525,
0.1429423094,
0.4805020392,
1.0032688379,
-0.0085888067,
-0.3911247253,
0.7243016362,
-1.1125094891,
-0.08186239,
0.1836570799,
0.7458842993,
0.3202863634,
-0.2244033217,
0.2029419243,
0.206880182,
-0.2553579211,
-0.8646430373,
0.3982930779,
-1.0343534946,
-0.5153949857,
1.1087472439,
-0.4403440654,
0.1705717295,
0.0128102722,
-0.1268472373,
0.193440035,
-0.4539709091,
0.2358811051,
0.7737587094,
0.0177628547,
0.0266282205,
-0.3860042989,
0.3333186507,
0.4407642782,
-1.0654236078,
0.3538288772,
0.4389741719,
0.199788183,
0.0326612592,
0.4768075943,
0.3351245821,
0.3090794384,
-0.2204591036,
0.016794838,
-0.2879009843,
-0.6781120896,
-0.5376165509,
0.2706111372,
-0.2519246638,
-0.2622981071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14521v1
|
Malaysian English News Decoded: A Linguistic Resource for Named Entity and Relation Extraction
| 2024-02-22T13:12:05 | 2024-02-22T13:12:05 |
Mohan Raj Chanthran, Lay-Ki Soon, Huey Fang Ong, Bhawani Selvaretnam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Standard English and Malaysian English exhibit notable differences, posing
challenges for natural language processing (NLP) tasks on Malaysian English.
Unfortunately, most of the existing datasets are mainly based on standard
English and therefore inadequate for improving NLP tasks in Malaysian English.
An experiment using state-of-the-art Named Entity Recognition (NER) solutions
on Malaysian English news articles highlights that they cannot handle
morphosyntactic variations in Malaysian English. To the best of our knowledge,
there is no annotated dataset available to improvise the model. To address
these issues, we constructed a Malaysian English News (MEN) dataset, which
contains 200 news articles that are manually annotated with entities and
relations. We then fine-tuned the spaCy NER tool and validated that having a
dataset tailor-made for Malaysian English could improve the performance of NER
in Malaysian English significantly. This paper presents our effort in the data
acquisition, annotation methodology, and thorough analysis of the annotated
dataset. To validate the quality of the annotation, inter-annotator agreement
was used, followed by adjudication of disagreements by a subject matter expert.
Upon completion of these tasks, we managed to develop a dataset with 6,061
entities and 3,268 relation instances. Finally, we discuss on spaCy fine-tuning
setup and analysis on the NER performance. This unique dataset will contribute
significantly to the advancement of NLP research in Malaysian English, allowing
researchers to accelerate their progress, particularly in NER and relation
extraction. The dataset and annotation guideline has been published on Github.
|
[
-0.5831136703,
-0.6014477015,
0.0615570173,
0.3340140283,
-0.4465999007,
-0.1156002209,
-0.3085338175,
-0.6856310964,
0.4477058649,
0.6625390053,
-0.4688127637,
-0.372641474,
-0.7340192199,
0.8806717396,
-0.2776012123,
1.1132702827,
-0.0167296119,
0.0693144575,
-0.0629435927,
-0.4418516755,
-0.4760732651,
-0.4072245061,
-0.8934755921,
-0.0418358929,
0.3409176171,
0.2629146576,
0.7906081676,
0.6969153881,
0.7783662081,
0.1375584155,
-0.3039528728,
0.4669275284,
-0.0860929713,
0.278753072,
-0.2990285456,
-0.2252090275,
-0.3363734484,
-0.2364495546,
0.5823752284,
0.8677090406,
-0.1087692231,
0.1782764345,
-0.0323805138,
0.7838041782,
-0.4936585724,
0.3034355938,
-0.6327421069,
-0.0400459431,
-0.32735762,
-0.2165715247,
-0.2495037168,
-0.1709792018,
0.2210362405,
-0.7246487737,
0.0607145503,
-0.0601147301,
1.2496044636,
0.3193949461,
-0.489774406,
-0.603538394,
-0.6276758909,
0.6021623015,
-0.7504069805,
0.5321692824,
0.2595535219,
0.1707661599,
-0.3169062138,
-0.5175710917,
-0.3720930517,
-0.187300995,
-0.3212704659,
-0.0721029714,
-0.0882253647,
-0.0801715776,
0.3182307184,
0.3946374059,
-0.4238016605,
-0.0395893641,
-0.3481368124,
-0.0723919049,
0.7280201316,
-0.0651000515,
0.4323417246,
-0.6364207268,
-0.052026581,
0.3344673812,
-0.8643370867,
-0.1196127683,
0.4535324872,
0.4824745655,
0.1734559536,
0.6796059012,
-0.3809172809,
0.5497380495,
0.1352434456,
-0.3893900216,
0.4502251446,
-0.0364115685,
-0.1564485133,
0.2968938351,
0.6069056392,
0.3680488765,
0.3340753615,
-0.3027426898,
-0.4352062047,
0.0135380272,
-0.1217451468,
-0.7190968394,
-0.3596484959,
-0.0567975156,
-0.3070278168,
-0.2073117942,
0.1411711425,
-0.7889062166,
-0.2166914791,
-0.3766575754,
0.3000722826,
-0.3425892889,
-0.6335384846,
0.1208811998,
-0.0344926566,
0.0728790909,
0.1214658692,
-0.8774629235,
0.4412483871,
0.6102903485,
0.5444816947,
-0.1578819454,
-0.1324757785,
-0.1307670325,
0.2133449018,
-0.3223592341,
0.633579433,
-0.6726131439,
-0.159255296,
-0.1907713115,
0.2950288951,
0.0104701389,
-0.794193089,
0.594951272,
-0.4825593233,
0.5386113524,
-0.105539389,
-0.721739769,
-0.2220492512,
0.1429301798,
-1.0939998627,
0.9370248914,
0.1687675864,
-1.1186554432,
0.3900784254,
-0.752876997,
-0.7786717415,
0.1173472628,
-0.2659045458,
-0.2898261845,
0.1583794802,
0.7732009292,
0.4680354297,
0.1128275692,
0.3860476613,
0.1977712661,
-0.2507840097,
0.0182294697,
-0.2653764188,
0.8287623525,
0.0709862411,
-0.3371910751,
-0.3941438496,
-1.0934320688,
-0.3837223947,
0.0944420621,
-0.5024572015,
-0.5537287593,
0.0082412008,
-0.0131004378,
0.2211724073,
0.1719352007,
-0.3832546175,
0.1389649808,
-0.549962759,
0.3684896529,
0.3691881597,
0.4699388146,
0.5455805659,
-0.0052694939,
0.4806024134,
0.1413832605,
-0.307480365,
-0.372376591,
-0.4674166739,
-0.781543076,
-0.0124715641,
0.6679137349,
0.4358479679,
-0.8211743236,
0.3069807589,
-0.3945353329,
-0.3047227859,
-0.8363463283,
-0.0832647756,
0.1589292735,
0.5847625732,
0.4968498051,
-0.0778929889,
-1.1551650763,
-1.0103726387,
-0.3123721778,
0.0497523881,
0.0397767611,
0.3038114309,
0.3843698502,
-0.2045512497,
0.9991226196,
-0.0839009136,
-0.2681153715,
-0.330770731,
0.1738025993,
0.3758215308,
0.3724830449,
0.3521026969,
-0.9119113088,
-0.24005799,
0.0293158516,
-0.6888437867,
-0.2565204501,
-0.1750144809,
0.0100479592,
0.6607601643,
0.4902338684,
-0.7810499668,
0.230757162,
0.5510721803,
-0.0869771913,
0.5740383863,
0.1417504549,
0.1559473425,
-1.3374558687,
0.0156903621,
0.0739563182,
-0.183808893,
-0.3481892347,
0.1163396239,
0.0301945806,
0.0688714758,
-0.3430984318,
0.55883497,
-0.6267195344,
0.0275288615,
-0.2796333134,
0.128691569,
-0.0499100685,
0.1930877864,
0.4003125727,
0.6954743862,
0.3065490425,
-0.8120993376,
0.3064060211,
0.2053923309,
-0.2590965033,
0.5314326286,
-0.4154937267,
0.0606325716,
-0.351213932,
-0.1552438438,
-0.516923666,
-0.3989540637,
0.4178667068,
-0.5107222795,
0.4199491143,
-0.3253376782,
-0.4419645965,
0.055341661,
0.0920365527,
-0.0683392435,
0.1837210059,
-0.4999296665,
0.4951100647,
0.6834512353,
-0.3319227993,
-0.9499857426,
-0.5709205866,
0.4433171749,
-0.3016358614,
-0.4327715933,
0.3864583671,
0.4023911059,
-0.3837585747,
0.4781888723,
-0.3784820139,
-0.3010053039,
0.1266325265,
0.2306514531,
0.2010142952,
-0.5387553573,
0.1918342113,
0.2451601475,
-0.312376678,
0.2458648235,
0.2053094208,
0.3130831122,
0.0601126216,
0.0895472467,
-0.365288347,
0.2496614456,
0.3237907588,
-0.2254349887,
0.6571474075,
0.4706035256,
-0.91503793,
0.0315866508,
-0.4289097786,
-0.0360963605,
-0.4014508724,
0.5930318832,
-0.5985648036,
-0.7467859387,
0.2487718016,
0.0084058307,
0.3053051233,
0.7728458047,
0.1940989792,
-0.0244282205,
0.8725109696,
0.6362957358,
-0.3167177737,
0.058095932,
0.0988796055,
0.2646956444,
-0.5699332952,
-0.2975180149,
-0.4089657962,
-0.2673083544,
-0.6007279754,
0.2631094754,
-0.2194909751,
0.2207665741,
0.2006204724,
0.7300385833,
-0.5092010498,
0.4774066806,
0.1444139779,
-0.18990767,
0.5728392005,
0.0171460733,
0.2033928633,
-0.5678153634,
-0.3662437797,
-0.8261070848,
0.8399740458,
0.2323181182,
0.5435213447,
0.0759581551,
0.8006702065,
0.090923354,
0.2197897881,
-0.5813161731,
0.6609067321,
0.0014482941,
-0.483668834,
-0.112331517,
-0.6285114288,
-1.2212651968,
0.1188272387,
-0.304487288,
-0.4369545579,
-0.0203979518,
-0.2616683543,
-0.0987997651,
0.1718990505,
-0.5956270695,
0.5596112013,
0.0204539616,
0.2316032797,
-0.0037047716,
-0.4732633233,
0.2877865732,
-0.027393084,
0.2207996696,
-0.2420028001,
-0.1994005293,
1.0533708334,
-0.0614750087,
0.2258124948,
-0.1947434992,
0.0191568341,
0.0439986922,
-0.0162724145,
0.290047884,
0.3648032546,
-0.0589785948,
0.2600897253,
-0.0381367169,
-0.1720223874,
-0.4526623487,
0.5073009133,
-0.5650469661,
-0.3519724607,
-0.2907497585,
-0.4163189828,
-0.1364111453,
0.1796459854,
0.3060215712,
0.3245286047,
-0.1122172922,
0.1641472429,
0.4164375365,
0.0201076139,
0.5482664704,
0.4323951304,
-0.3616729677,
-0.3983898461,
0.7541737556,
0.3413299024,
-0.2987763882,
0.4870697558,
-0.295244813,
-0.1741253883,
-0.5323332548,
-0.4583266675,
0.2543616593,
-0.4895298481,
-0.3026950657,
-0.7838485241,
-0.4807868302,
-0.3732754588,
0.1034671962,
-0.4288540781,
-0.6021013856,
-0.4056454897,
-0.2230222523,
0.2146825641,
0.8213053942,
0.0898836777,
0.0841807276,
-0.8001282811,
0.3159119785,
-0.1060655862,
-0.0112200603,
-0.3847546279,
-0.4988466203,
-0.2888061404,
-0.0041658487,
0.105461441,
-1.146564126,
0.5601790547,
0.1184090525,
0.4669103622,
0.4283960462,
-0.0600689426,
0.8254328966,
-0.4436115921,
0.5753039122,
-0.2937996387,
-0.7795149088,
0.7737788558,
-0.1180145815,
-0.1762618572,
0.5486533046,
0.6078833342,
-0.7253289819,
-0.3268846273,
-0.8240184784,
-0.9861597419,
0.5362915993,
0.264874965,
0.0941693783,
-0.1827408075,
0.686965704,
0.3373337388,
0.299361825,
-0.7181177139,
-0.4325931966,
0.2541014552,
-0.1031198651,
0.2006420344,
-0.3025786579,
0.3700521886,
-0.2627738714,
1.061247468,
0.3810382187,
-0.0264390893,
0.2272545546,
-0.5660408735,
0.0153985536,
0.312671721,
0.1482598484,
0.7028773427,
-0.2250036597,
0.149237752,
0.1470487714,
-0.5696371794,
-0.0284375306,
0.4694741666,
-0.296797514,
0.7677855492,
0.1911633313,
0.5405641198,
0.3450303078,
-0.6830693483,
0.3311469853,
-0.131527558,
-0.0867848769,
-0.363827467,
-0.0373972915,
0.1494766921,
0.1258293092,
0.4845658541,
0.1269481778,
0.1233994365,
-0.1512952149,
0.5636671185,
0.0780839324,
-0.136898756,
-0.3834305108,
0.5011306405,
0.2238437682,
-0.4987098873,
0.7300494313,
-0.6666085124,
-0.3106787503,
0.4894894958,
0.5495661497,
0.445967555,
-0.3224158585,
0.1994029135,
0.618150115,
0.5615139008,
-0.2829776704,
0.2044575214,
0.2526439428,
-0.7748588324,
-0.6616411805,
-0.4627956748,
-0.4560935795,
0.6123530269,
-0.8352598548,
0.5522811413,
-0.2980044782,
0.0641880482,
0.136007905,
0.4284424186,
-0.4717664719,
0.1831512451,
0.2380889058,
0.9520061016,
-0.7810873389,
0.5553409457,
1.0518001318,
-0.3038503528,
-0.7655820251,
-0.0926161036,
-0.2721215189,
-0.5384585857,
0.4758538902,
0.5082083344,
0.334082514,
0.12250337,
-0.2118298411,
-0.8670989275,
0.8057295084,
0.5254010558,
-0.5989771485,
-0.0737141743,
0.2037903517,
0.4293167293,
-0.4185917377,
0.0501779094,
0.6621101499,
0.4405811727,
-0.457583487,
-0.7951555252,
0.0162112005,
-0.4223977625,
-0.2209383845,
0.46482265,
0.0050875517,
0.6738538146,
-0.1097917557,
-0.6067383885,
0.0615134053,
0.7912979126,
0.0869860053,
0.2911303341,
0.3821516335,
0.7829881907,
0.8472224474,
-0.1425034106,
0.5932691097,
-0.2133900374,
0.4270625114,
1.2345958948,
-0.0847758874,
0.9417585135,
0.5587081909,
-0.2012282014,
0.5022984743,
0.6112559438,
-0.042655766,
0.5162160993,
-0.0406353101,
-0.2567406893,
0.1146440729,
-0.194555968,
-0.3620526493,
0.478402108,
0.4852215052,
-0.5315363407,
-0.4472608566,
-0.0897180811,
0.3557688594,
-0.0431479104,
-0.3905991316,
0.6715925336,
-0.0328513868,
-0.4852428734,
0.0820799768,
0.196634993,
0.8997299671,
-0.2483439893,
-0.1224060133,
-0.1599398404,
-0.0667586625,
-0.4863665402,
-0.6449297667,
0.4898219705,
0.0005350303,
-0.0588907897,
0.2081520557,
0.9353662729,
-0.5020347238,
-0.4576507211,
-0.0284453481,
0.7104660869,
0.3963615298,
-0.2542515695,
-0.5310170054,
-0.2757931054,
-0.0307695121,
-0.4279076457,
0.1455230862,
0.5325857997,
0.1318840683,
0.3523939252,
0.5559031963,
0.2939391434,
-0.0324157663,
0.0007667965,
0.462768048,
-0.7641409039,
-0.2868215442,
-0.9905259609,
0.3042736351,
-0.3003219068,
-0.5149286985,
0.7413467765,
0.7935147882,
1.0617449284,
0.1320281178,
0.7052369714,
-0.0795133486,
0.7005105615,
-0.4281073213,
0.594638288,
-0.2130900174,
0.2108849287,
-0.1749058068,
-1.0715513229,
-0.4594028592,
0.8062804341,
-0.0161400996,
-0.180757761,
0.6467247605,
0.8323295712,
-0.0486455522,
0.2519027591,
0.0732814223,
0.1172325015,
0.0338462181,
0.4839254916,
0.9069191813,
-0.6345486045,
0.6365754008,
-0.5901796818,
0.2509444952,
-0.0486667939,
-0.8493676186,
-0.8349667788,
-0.6034581661,
-0.5083579421,
-0.3426907957,
0.3139506578,
1.1052194834,
0.4549058378,
-0.7914694548,
0.1410636604,
-0.2518698275,
0.1157799214,
-0.1584773362,
-0.3368943334,
0.4490561187,
-0.3980169296,
-0.8101027608,
0.2240886837,
0.336092025,
-0.0678632185,
-0.023566056,
-0.1268215925,
-0.0913349018,
-0.2780278027,
0.4353168011,
0.2619610131,
-0.5971498489,
-0.1423491836,
-0.0671682209,
-0.2499401867,
0.2621443272,
0.5678819418,
-0.8706762791,
0.0710923746,
0.1434143484,
0.997276783,
0.0601690821,
-0.2822931707,
0.2173367739,
-0.9762372375,
0.0201467536,
0.2894990444,
0.6129083633,
0.5579442978,
-0.4870370924,
0.7962732315,
0.3352681696,
-0.4206503332,
-0.8589559793,
0.0898704529,
-0.8253115416,
-0.0833718404,
1.2330207825,
-0.0289199967,
-0.1039975882,
-0.3849607706,
-0.3659586608,
0.2791749835,
-0.5395464897,
0.7636489272,
0.821710825,
-0.0942650065,
-0.341822058,
-0.5983941555,
0.4665570855,
0.3401424885,
-0.8896995187,
-0.0995141044,
0.3175512552,
0.3651388586,
0.1457099169,
0.5744768381,
-0.2142267823,
0.2747218907,
-0.130051598,
-0.0918811187,
-0.1317192167,
-0.2244279236,
-0.4411430359,
0.1147027016,
-0.0981365144,
-0.2429020852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14499v1
|
"My Answer is C": First-Token Probabilities Do Not Match Text Answers in Instruction-Tuned Language Models
| 2024-02-22T12:47:33 | 2024-02-22T12:47:33 |
Xinpeng Wang, Bolei Ma, Chengzhi Hu, Leon Weber-Genzel, Paul Röttger, Frauke Kreuter, Dirk Hovy, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The open-ended nature of language generation makes the evaluation of
autoregressive large language models (LLMs) challenging. One common evaluation
approach uses multiple-choice questions (MCQ) to limit the response space. The
model is then evaluated by ranking the candidate answers by the log probability
of the first token prediction. However, first-tokens may not consistently
reflect the final response output, due to model's diverse response styles such
as starting with "Sure" or refusing to answer. Consequently, MCQ evaluation is
not indicative of model behaviour when interacting with users. But by how much?
We evaluate how aligned first-token evaluation is with the text output along
several dimensions, namely final option choice, refusal rate, choice
distribution and robustness under prompt perturbation. Our results show that
the two approaches are severely misaligned on all dimensions, reaching mismatch
rates over 60%. Models heavily fine-tuned on conversational or safety data are
especially impacted. Crucially, models remain misaligned even when we
increasingly constrain prompts, i.e., force them to start with an option letter
or example template. Our findings i) underscore the importance of inspecting
the text output, too and ii) caution against relying solely on first-token
evaluation.
|
[
-0.2884112597,
-0.9533138275,
0.6476916075,
0.0299946591,
-0.2524353564,
0.1173360646,
-0.0359687358,
-0.2425019741,
-0.0261833668,
0.4223833382,
-0.7506452799,
-0.2840910554,
-0.4966376722,
0.0364502668,
-0.3043358326,
1.0495973825,
0.1721589267,
0.0277383421,
-0.5437329412,
-0.0215537529,
-0.2909689546,
-0.8530056477,
-0.923181951,
-0.0669176579,
0.5976483822,
0.5425946712,
1.0463578701,
0.8885172606,
0.5831787586,
0.2706389129,
-0.0512636043,
-0.0022883278,
-0.3283879757,
-0.0960155204,
0.1313003898,
-0.2668510675,
-0.2742378414,
0.2046221197,
0.4471513927,
0.634218514,
0.0019160728,
0.3813771009,
0.0210898519,
0.5750347972,
-0.6517448425,
-0.1673292667,
-0.7525203228,
-0.1259393096,
-0.1106041372,
-0.1768174469,
-0.6263190508,
-0.3793786764,
0.0937673226,
-0.1884619743,
-0.0509366468,
0.309854269,
0.5738384724,
0.3247229159,
-0.5600144863,
-0.5839281678,
-0.589027822,
0.7116892338,
-0.7901329398,
0.1414436996,
0.3233043551,
0.2178699523,
-0.2394102365,
-0.4817949533,
-0.6542445421,
-0.4535778761,
0.0392595008,
-0.0156151615,
-0.1722601056,
0.215120852,
0.2140138447,
0.2047439665,
-0.6589789391,
0.5633589029,
-0.3327041268,
-0.4178459942,
0.5020343065,
0.4164395928,
0.1132588089,
-0.0869869888,
-0.62693578,
-0.2391010672,
-0.5225394368,
0.3660037518,
0.8823795319,
0.577957809,
-0.0182521455,
0.9000787735,
0.1553395689,
0.9850316644,
0.2384925932,
-0.1192068532,
-0.1426704824,
-0.4571764767,
-0.2427265346,
0.0751524866,
1.0914494991,
0.2771731019,
0.3414122164,
0.1255420297,
0.0225056149,
-0.1738960147,
0.2221430093,
-0.677421689,
-0.0104553895,
0.4397470951,
-0.3860116899,
-0.421482414,
0.0775622427,
-0.5041992664,
-0.1780588329,
-0.0697178468,
0.3288118839,
-0.1899538636,
-0.1353033185,
0.0849435329,
0.2259946913,
0.2360272408,
-0.0124800242,
-0.991989255,
0.3250157833,
0.6593225598,
0.5592766404,
-0.3649632931,
-0.1825525463,
-0.6200410128,
-0.2997269928,
-0.4202632606,
0.5547997355,
-0.5947468281,
-0.3634340465,
-0.07924027,
-0.0452501625,
-0.2302781492,
-0.4024111032,
0.5703199506,
-0.4165253043,
0.5016731024,
-0.2768057585,
-0.4904336929,
0.3104175329,
-0.0057145655,
-0.5185685754,
0.8884354234,
0.0631695688,
-1.0247323513,
0.4385007918,
-0.2806944549,
-0.2447336316,
-0.2241382003,
-0.27867347,
-0.2905638516,
0.0920021385,
0.0700160861,
0.2531139553,
-0.1174079329,
0.2584186792,
-0.5740931034,
-0.2765722871,
0.7485904098,
-1.0053488016,
0.8181259632,
0.1965826899,
-0.0044056303,
0.0500451811,
-0.7249791622,
0.3655512631,
-0.0554652959,
-0.6910560131,
-0.066039741,
-0.0473320559,
0.0697017536,
0.5341354609,
0.3397982121,
-0.5436546206,
0.2018287927,
-0.5332248211,
0.1945336908,
1.0665898323,
-0.146525085,
0.3370633721,
-0.4955617487,
0.8062751889,
0.2608171403,
0.1109197289,
-0.1123821065,
-0.4974543154,
-0.4521574974,
0.0092374161,
0.3157791495,
0.5888164639,
-0.5260850191,
0.2452133447,
-0.11223308,
-0.4791101217,
-0.5955812335,
-0.0772997513,
0.6360435486,
0.5262358189,
0.0515406057,
-0.1520012617,
-0.4309561551,
-1.1585987806,
-0.4934543967,
-0.6137859225,
0.1425827593,
0.3198587,
0.2493918687,
0.1812934577,
0.9639068246,
-0.2933528423,
0.3844855726,
-0.0584638789,
-0.0324782133,
0.2067780793,
0.4781101644,
0.4877365828,
-0.5784158707,
-0.359857291,
-0.2407748699,
-0.2980825603,
-0.0585610606,
-0.064880237,
-0.1871033758,
0.5105021,
0.4337835312,
-0.5457930565,
0.2667320967,
0.6796582341,
-0.4623934925,
0.6337424517,
-0.1043184623,
0.1268834472,
-1.0778098106,
0.0030799832,
-0.2041381001,
-0.11206121,
-0.6101981997,
-0.1038068235,
-0.0184531026,
0.0419498794,
-0.5699102879,
0.8435708284,
-0.1579979062,
-0.0515815318,
-0.169373408,
0.2833617032,
-0.1637509465,
0.2697802782,
-0.3880365491,
1.0893337727,
0.2239574045,
-0.8630033135,
-0.0657965839,
0.2529016137,
-0.3163770437,
0.2805101275,
-0.5482212305,
0.3804942071,
-0.1665691733,
-0.1192770377,
-1.3447575569,
-0.2705861926,
0.3000163436,
-0.6649830341,
0.321936965,
0.1338144094,
-0.3651994467,
-0.5413079858,
-0.1756055653,
0.3906874657,
0.2721469104,
-0.3965555429,
0.1892977506,
0.2983063757,
-0.2095397115,
-1.0467915535,
-0.8164231181,
-0.0710537583,
0.0107524702,
-0.4992068112,
-0.0622290559,
-0.5775620937,
-0.2869244814,
-0.1297021657,
-0.4814905524,
-0.0476363823,
0.314848125,
0.0301930681,
0.3038870096,
-0.2832005322,
0.1429046988,
0.0152127659,
0.1630458534,
0.1096640155,
-0.1393639147,
0.6140437722,
0.0618508868,
-0.7083728313,
-0.1623383909,
0.2379078269,
0.8307837248,
-0.0681031868,
0.8179980516,
0.3005835116,
-0.294511348,
0.2864472568,
-0.3845496476,
0.014038492,
-0.4843069613,
0.4837450981,
-0.4750328064,
-0.9884501696,
0.4161474407,
0.5075557232,
0.2140440643,
0.4321210086,
0.7397226691,
-0.0431253575,
1.4526958466,
0.4821869135,
0.1470067799,
0.3151171505,
0.3873011172,
0.4575484097,
-0.6623334885,
-0.1321755499,
-0.786793232,
-0.1782028079,
-0.767832756,
-0.0951981097,
0.1098295376,
0.1128838062,
-0.288061291,
0.1935433745,
-0.3983850181,
0.3724700511,
0.5122294426,
0.0403655544,
0.1798660308,
-0.0393818133,
-0.4517982304,
-0.0790005848,
-0.9426429272,
-0.9000042677,
1.2089459896,
0.3506247997,
0.6535568237,
0.1461773664,
0.7281339169,
0.0348001048,
0.3895407915,
-0.755582273,
0.618170321,
-0.1925157756,
-0.7587522268,
-0.4521263838,
-0.4167181551,
-0.9389914274,
0.1439198256,
-0.2814281285,
-0.7530581355,
-0.0417403467,
0.2999455929,
-0.4353869259,
0.1643481851,
-0.6810439229,
0.8504323959,
-0.3239101171,
-0.2609241903,
0.3852821589,
-0.5125924349,
0.5668876171,
-0.1352207661,
0.3980221748,
-0.0199306887,
-0.0169168655,
0.6494527459,
-0.3754328489,
0.6207334995,
-0.0423067734,
-0.2000907063,
0.4567412734,
0.1644118428,
0.2946996987,
-0.0291477647,
-0.1830680966,
-0.3863679171,
0.2039010674,
-0.4319807291,
-0.5017712116,
0.6531355381,
-0.6515249014,
-0.8326499462,
-0.3579957783,
-0.3064448535,
-0.1727104783,
0.1056827679,
0.4934670031,
0.5418919325,
-0.3339563012,
0.1089193448,
0.4449778795,
-0.2908060551,
0.6103953123,
0.3165846467,
-0.3022790551,
-0.3930272162,
0.6144196987,
0.1017747521,
0.6106553674,
0.1662118435,
0.1775012314,
-0.4062588811,
-0.3995231986,
-0.5836572647,
0.0290103182,
-0.94001472,
-0.1334325671,
-0.7247858047,
-0.1913324296,
-0.3543598354,
-0.0610070825,
-0.0836127251,
-0.5118870735,
-0.4608042538,
-0.2436107248,
-0.1379131377,
0.6100557446,
0.2207284421,
0.3315094709,
-0.669639051,
0.0069970596,
0.2608708143,
0.3333474696,
0.0036544676,
-0.5812504292,
-0.2188506722,
0.2525415421,
-0.3225774467,
-1.0104016066,
-0.0777028576,
0.1328236759,
0.6689830422,
0.3601274788,
0.0617140941,
0.5184555054,
-0.5256717801,
0.8830270767,
0.1467098594,
-0.7737474442,
0.2954521179,
-0.0980992168,
0.4333791137,
0.775577724,
0.3117658198,
-0.2923958004,
-0.6327974796,
-0.6782250404,
-0.6789565086,
0.6871526241,
-0.0040164762,
0.4222949743,
-0.6062397361,
0.3468323946,
0.1575116217,
0.3099857569,
-0.8792734146,
-0.3564737439,
0.0553775392,
-0.4805936813,
-0.0875099674,
-0.3406135142,
0.1561577767,
0.0818580016,
0.5203813314,
-0.2961967289,
0.2764053643,
0.1535961628,
0.03166214,
-0.3152662516,
0.3782736361,
0.8193713427,
0.6638848782,
0.0265481044,
-0.0704231486,
-0.0450492054,
-0.4788087606,
0.2453059405,
-0.2492949218,
-0.080137372,
-0.0344154313,
0.3572985232,
0.8191176057,
0.192150861,
-0.6080567241,
0.692332983,
-0.2310696691,
-0.2292026132,
-0.143820852,
0.2763329446,
-0.0890588239,
-0.0446604639,
0.3482986689,
0.1090980619,
-0.0862229392,
-0.6322888136,
0.1281884164,
0.8515247703,
-0.3929285407,
-0.1079744697,
0.8114385009,
-0.1372787356,
-0.709851265,
0.5740498304,
-0.0862357914,
-0.4577060938,
0.9057080746,
0.6283408999,
0.8830211163,
-0.1619721055,
0.2412231714,
0.5479610562,
0.5509555936,
0.0454909615,
0.4602605999,
0.2382902354,
-0.5663573742,
-0.4086552262,
-0.7136062384,
-0.5051323771,
0.1985054016,
-0.62390697,
0.3082025349,
-0.4534269869,
-0.4197570086,
-0.1291927844,
-0.1234772876,
-0.8044588566,
0.3355631232,
0.0548359118,
1.0233975649,
-0.8272800446,
0.439545989,
0.6230764389,
-0.2867428064,
-0.802478075,
0.1340209097,
-0.2756422758,
-0.8083035946,
0.4094806314,
0.2405385971,
-0.1120502651,
0.0458694696,
-0.8466075659,
-0.9744023085,
0.7679641247,
0.4223495722,
-0.5373420715,
0.0118381847,
0.2416728586,
0.5269046426,
-0.5679357648,
0.4302786589,
0.4454430342,
0.4288922846,
-0.0204594936,
-0.8487507701,
-0.0103563778,
0.0621702597,
-0.0813548714,
0.1340841204,
-0.6091520786,
0.8574830294,
-0.5041963458,
-0.4420788586,
0.2368041128,
0.4211094677,
0.4018455446,
0.2846871316,
0.4732949436,
0.4149549901,
0.7199076414,
-0.1139998958,
1.0983088017,
-0.4411178827,
0.2126917243,
1.1449491978,
-0.1591618955,
0.9702818394,
0.7283248901,
-0.3395878077,
0.3707860708,
0.9667099714,
0.360073626,
0.3782799542,
0.4290636778,
-0.0879920423,
-0.2902258635,
0.2545617819,
-0.0905237719,
0.6128789186,
0.1542413831,
-0.3649447858,
0.0526967011,
-0.1493533701,
-0.0598526411,
0.1081562415,
-0.1855170727,
0.7775878906,
-0.0673232377,
-0.8968862891,
0.5023865104,
0.0190565847,
0.4169950485,
-0.2899028957,
0.1690397859,
-0.2507241964,
-0.2514280081,
-0.1682787538,
-0.8140925169,
0.1711030602,
0.0167964958,
-0.2788650095,
0.0726005211,
0.4572153091,
-0.3669680357,
-0.4923790395,
-0.1081276983,
0.7121589184,
0.1005699709,
0.3464345932,
-0.5646660328,
-0.1752878577,
0.0263022836,
-0.4464229941,
0.4042835832,
0.3544480503,
0.0582614094,
0.6896622777,
0.7444958091,
-0.2029308677,
0.3251947165,
-0.2601962686,
0.6255140901,
-0.3267734647,
-0.273460567,
-1.1444857121,
0.6802424192,
0.1669298559,
-0.6474604607,
0.4380809963,
0.5525622964,
0.8491079807,
0.006407728,
0.7591725588,
0.2077600211,
0.3190180063,
-0.6999517679,
0.4016743898,
-0.4272682965,
0.3484913111,
-0.1653909087,
-0.9469053745,
0.0477320775,
0.30777964,
-0.147747457,
0.2667999268,
0.7679466605,
0.6240562797,
-0.0380839556,
-0.2331335843,
0.3804761469,
0.0857199132,
0.1198574156,
0.4188810587,
0.7590268254,
-0.4428842366,
0.6888359785,
0.1109872907,
-0.1651754528,
-0.1565040648,
-0.9606283903,
-0.7837302089,
-0.4862959087,
-0.2156679332,
-0.4143657684,
-0.1084849313,
1.057902813,
0.2728707492,
-0.7027067542,
-0.0912517011,
-0.0073894411,
0.1859069765,
0.1262341142,
-0.2319796085,
0.1273017228,
-0.3696131408,
-0.6098338962,
0.2126621306,
0.1645844579,
0.3202243447,
-0.360724479,
0.0257106926,
-0.1302212328,
0.4486386478,
0.2668561339,
0.235547781,
-0.8490539789,
-0.5751369596,
0.4109936953,
-0.4732877016,
0.0397100002,
0.5193817616,
-0.6762539744,
0.4433937073,
0.1974303722,
0.7522751689,
0.0127679957,
0.1244350374,
0.5104689002,
-0.8407164812,
-0.1078384593,
0.1679500341,
0.1487724483,
0.3054246902,
-0.5015770197,
0.0829294175,
-0.2756822407,
-0.7559015751,
-0.9565184116,
0.494943738,
-0.7639932036,
-0.1538679153,
1.0467262268,
0.001663939,
-0.1503242552,
0.0642095953,
-0.2323755175,
0.16389893,
-0.0204792153,
0.6031883955,
1.2642620802,
-0.0642548949,
-0.1030526683,
-0.6620563865,
0.4096341729,
0.402510494,
-0.5237826109,
0.1572457552,
0.3888553977,
0.167668283,
-0.0066613113,
0.8695155382,
0.0523394085,
0.2675892115,
-0.1344591975,
-0.2662876546,
-0.0171311572,
-0.2691004574,
-0.7075269222,
0.0355461426,
0.5064041615,
-0.22135894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14494v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14494v3
|
Noise-BERT: A Unified Perturbation-Robust Framework with Noise Alignment Pre-training for Noisy Slot Filling Task
| 2024-02-22T12:39:50 | 2024-03-06T07:17:03 |
Jinxu Zhao, Guanting Dong, Yueyan Qiu, Tingfeng Hui, Xiaoshuai Song, Daichi Guo, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a realistic dialogue system, the input information from users is often
subject to various types of input perturbations, which affects the slot-filling
task. Although rule-based data augmentation methods have achieved satisfactory
results, they fail to exhibit the desired generalization when faced with
unknown noise disturbances. In this study, we address the challenges posed by
input perturbations in slot filling by proposing Noise-BERT, a unified
Perturbation-Robust Framework with Noise Alignment Pre-training. Our framework
incorporates two Noise Alignment Pre-training tasks: Slot Masked Prediction and
Sentence Noisiness Discrimination, aiming to guide the pre-trained language
model in capturing accurate slot information and noise distribution. During
fine-tuning, we employ a contrastive learning loss to enhance the semantic
representation of entities and labels. Additionally, we introduce an
adversarial attack training strategy to improve the model's robustness.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our proposed approach over
state-of-the-art models, and further analysis confirms its effectiveness and
generalization ability.
|
[
-0.3858544827,
-1.0220570564,
0.4577632546,
0.1187539026,
-0.3935196102,
-0.184418723,
-0.220224157,
-0.2726613581,
0.0671721101,
0.5620149374,
-0.9188985229,
-0.3139329851,
-0.4865009189,
-0.3040918708,
-0.4625509381,
0.8868092299,
0.3988558352,
0.2066076398,
-0.1137729138,
0.377081573,
-0.3854410648,
-0.5412967205,
-0.2879832983,
-0.0366552062,
0.4671926498,
0.0291737597,
0.9453952312,
0.2968985438,
0.3316444457,
0.313926965,
-0.1464724243,
-0.1475737393,
-0.372340709,
0.4100913107,
0.1807586551,
-0.1457766145,
-0.3615433574,
-0.1700795293,
0.5028246641,
0.7431802154,
-0.1262470484,
-0.3419621587,
0.4123847485,
0.0807502493,
-0.4937628806,
0.0663622022,
-0.9014242291,
0.0047721388,
-0.3785041869,
0.1198567301,
0.0178577919,
-0.1779478043,
0.2829949558,
-0.7127931714,
0.1496321112,
-0.3166333437,
1.3111655712,
0.7854973674,
0.1575786173,
-0.060695488,
-0.7740565538,
0.865709424,
-0.8126019835,
0.403423965,
0.3066568971,
-0.1180454269,
-0.469153136,
-0.448512584,
-0.5757938623,
0.0162688196,
-0.0297538005,
0.0390569568,
-0.1722479612,
0.4675082862,
0.2176809907,
0.2231634706,
-0.3568679094,
0.265639931,
0.1055367589,
-0.425560832,
0.1173374429,
-0.2405892015,
0.2640796304,
0.2399990112,
-0.4607802331,
-0.2818456888,
-0.5389379859,
0.0883941799,
0.8169767261,
0.4135454595,
0.0666815415,
0.0398286842,
0.1773008853,
0.8849163651,
0.1885267794,
0.000451542,
0.2281059623,
-0.3523424268,
-0.2634800076,
0.0114665823,
0.7972727418,
-0.0411269255,
-0.0276659969,
-0.0837189928,
-0.2081103325,
0.000682945,
0.4347450137,
-0.6018314362,
-0.2813570499,
0.0500502959,
-0.16619353,
-0.7302981615,
0.0080231223,
-0.8025159836,
-0.2588322163,
-0.1972979307,
0.6629577875,
-0.425725162,
-0.2285818756,
0.1661385596,
0.1905150414,
0.159188807,
0.6147568822,
-0.8678998947,
0.0768578947,
0.4524131715,
0.1830096543,
0.1384690702,
-0.062617071,
-0.4374334514,
0.0868399516,
-0.1567448527,
1.0022376776,
-0.6722279191,
-0.2100361735,
0.1445225924,
-0.3656698167,
-0.1193038002,
-0.3155390024,
0.8117175102,
-0.3434925675,
0.3619412482,
-0.1455411613,
-0.3779580891,
0.1232952774,
0.0370892435,
-0.4613758326,
1.0695610046,
0.1801296324,
-0.7229366899,
0.4032942951,
-0.678710103,
-0.5138912201,
-0.0991884172,
-0.3411408663,
-0.7359893322,
0.0157636069,
0.5360921621,
0.2934831381,
0.2089259326,
0.3546889126,
-0.4979324937,
-0.5816931725,
0.4111118615,
-0.5251559615,
0.7970020771,
0.1831229627,
-0.1766464859,
0.3165771067,
-0.6885636449,
-0.144887805,
-0.2195578516,
-0.253257066,
-0.199565202,
0.1065385267,
-0.0314272754,
0.0084025376,
0.283402741,
-0.600440681,
0.0971707106,
-0.475256145,
0.3386463225,
1.0455657244,
-0.1874131113,
0.2834299207,
-0.3436986804,
0.2530657649,
0.2655288875,
0.1434932351,
-0.2381516248,
-0.3462206423,
-0.5287918448,
-0.486300379,
0.9468050599,
0.5880053043,
-0.4804640114,
1.0178092718,
0.1600956619,
-0.0622198135,
-0.68570292,
0.2608762085,
0.110175781,
0.8170552254,
0.2957610488,
-0.526244998,
-0.7795102,
-0.5485782027,
0.0298721958,
-0.2131838053,
-0.3273139,
0.2402497828,
-0.1826811433,
-0.5367279649,
0.7983499765,
-0.1355633438,
-0.6502215862,
-0.00266453,
0.2408431917,
0.1125414371,
0.7451893687,
0.3760219514,
-0.5283723474,
-0.3002404869,
-0.3955349922,
-0.3684217334,
-0.3608596027,
-0.1387506574,
-0.1704908907,
-0.0164135583,
0.5661922693,
-0.4090697467,
0.5425843596,
0.3907667994,
0.0812670141,
0.5414982438,
-0.0524018221,
-0.2400148511,
-0.8970067501,
-0.2002001852,
-0.2065101862,
-0.1437982768,
-0.668736577,
-0.3982778192,
-0.3967536092,
-0.3565584421,
-0.098097153,
0.0522270426,
-0.144233942,
0.0766288713,
-0.0581684336,
0.0338847972,
-0.1500784457,
0.6664948463,
0.0060133343,
0.6412686706,
0.8068565726,
-0.6353197098,
0.0110198511,
0.3952451348,
-0.4182313085,
0.3492061198,
-0.5351055264,
0.1539759189,
-0.2199928313,
0.2113785893,
-1.3979209661,
-0.1881207973,
0.2178609818,
-0.5843190551,
0.5327265859,
-0.0184243806,
-0.3435118794,
-0.0247507207,
-0.1886771321,
0.0857312307,
0.496001482,
-0.3354171813,
0.5673347116,
0.4222038388,
-0.4581438601,
-0.9588336945,
-0.5161143541,
-0.1669709682,
0.011160532,
-0.6142050028,
0.4813662469,
-0.1766219437,
0.1378072947,
0.0337549932,
-0.3371477723,
-0.2809910476,
0.3092591465,
0.1626205742,
0.3984039128,
-0.2177482098,
0.1392531842,
0.113859795,
0.0255594291,
-0.0556471311,
-0.3541052043,
0.668482542,
0.1314937174,
-0.3069511354,
-0.7030084729,
0.2445119619,
0.317604959,
0.0738506094,
0.168483302,
0.9593356848,
-0.2083526403,
0.12565054,
-0.7475222945,
-0.2738857567,
-0.5072809458,
0.4789457023,
-0.2322012484,
-0.9571028352,
0.3531947434,
-0.1165157631,
0.1974011958,
0.1598259062,
0.227650255,
-0.7831022143,
0.9887145162,
0.6656503081,
-0.2978111506,
0.9824022651,
0.2468098551,
0.1372514218,
-0.6066844463,
0.2379748523,
-0.6836134195,
-0.3422605395,
-0.2159886807,
-0.2445028424,
0.2424226701,
0.1824918836,
-0.2671447098,
0.1282019913,
-0.4889258444,
0.2069414854,
0.5691769123,
0.0103432816,
-0.0288602076,
0.3805952966,
-0.3737291098,
-0.3963124454,
-0.6186311245,
-0.333719939,
1.0182669163,
0.3150503635,
1.1224756241,
0.0409328826,
0.7054864168,
0.2811460495,
-0.130431518,
-0.4398357272,
0.3526237607,
-0.2792517841,
-0.4030038118,
-0.6385896206,
-0.3481024504,
-1.1672012806,
0.1731560081,
-0.5948752165,
-0.9859384298,
0.3505226076,
0.3100962937,
-0.6545776725,
0.3147396445,
-0.4607970417,
0.7334364057,
-0.28105703,
-0.0140674673,
0.0376033261,
-0.8407382965,
0.0825590864,
-0.0347724818,
0.2021061927,
0.0280796122,
0.2713713348,
0.4360873997,
-0.3513263166,
1.0394124985,
-0.3568713367,
-0.2253281027,
0.1209012941,
-0.2070845217,
0.5195450783,
-0.1043364927,
0.1928336471,
0.1493626237,
-0.1932187378,
-0.3964405954,
-0.649181962,
0.3898659647,
-1.0371959209,
-0.5697260499,
-0.1704996526,
-0.6484487057,
-0.5328611732,
0.234948501,
0.3606002629,
0.3505852818,
-0.3962488174,
0.2496041358,
1.2735254765,
-0.1997415572,
0.3836632967,
0.4514512122,
-0.0097277286,
-0.3489811718,
1.0092250109,
0.0514124706,
-0.011980704,
0.5007164478,
-0.0362356119,
-0.4101730287,
-0.527463913,
-0.3008523583,
-0.1205030829,
-0.0970165804,
-0.1805000305,
-0.6473833323,
-0.3352469504,
-0.6584266424,
-0.1183760613,
-0.2853363752,
-0.3096903563,
-0.3456997573,
0.2124419361,
-0.2169042677,
0.5769382119,
-0.1560610384,
0.5328985453,
-0.5525426865,
0.2389074266,
0.5821347237,
0.5324913263,
-0.3214324713,
-0.4214921892,
0.030774897,
0.0078660119,
-0.5513697863,
-0.7334430814,
0.0831165463,
0.1583148837,
0.6826761961,
0.686409831,
0.2009993494,
0.8071506619,
-0.2449578941,
0.742379427,
0.3564066291,
-0.9545731544,
0.5580293536,
-0.3997752666,
0.2842894197,
0.6131566763,
-0.1308852583,
0.0081263995,
-0.7290921211,
-0.8920146227,
-0.7495594621,
0.6142274141,
0.3201985061,
0.1407734156,
0.4804069698,
0.0825003162,
-0.0610302724,
0.440328151,
-0.7381374836,
-0.0280300584,
-0.4880016148,
-0.3217792809,
0.1648011059,
-0.3977685571,
-0.0535340719,
-0.2060793638,
0.8043865561,
0.1503037512,
0.5629857183,
0.2443150431,
-0.1666692495,
-0.2635791302,
0.5551324487,
0.6359092593,
0.12522237,
-0.5016987324,
-0.3580763936,
-0.055795975,
-0.5438150764,
-0.0191097427,
0.6803798079,
-0.3723095059,
0.2523114383,
-0.0349994302,
0.7818282843,
0.4206203222,
-0.5138300061,
0.6262225509,
-0.3013556898,
-0.3235610127,
-0.2469363064,
0.1089950874,
-0.3677468598,
0.0227290262,
0.2300948799,
0.3349802494,
0.097245276,
-0.2158436775,
0.2324305624,
0.6285431385,
-0.8169124126,
-0.1696205288,
0.6471559405,
0.3407410979,
-0.053414803,
0.5364103317,
-0.1019228622,
-0.5469653606,
0.1123125926,
0.4161958396,
0.6690512896,
-0.4197162688,
-0.0286372472,
0.0535547398,
0.337882489,
0.2792394757,
0.3196533024,
-0.3146977127,
-1.0114290714,
-0.7097632885,
-0.6560943127,
-0.4632350802,
0.7574141026,
-0.6114007235,
0.1082446873,
-0.5606108308,
-0.2785277665,
-0.0884825289,
0.0087251402,
-0.4543845654,
0.1610308588,
0.1278686672,
0.3946305513,
-0.5433676839,
1.0125956535,
0.8453225493,
-0.3105071187,
-0.7656604648,
0.3221002817,
-0.057505168,
-0.5703628063,
0.2381560355,
-0.0437931791,
0.0814168826,
-0.2120295763,
-0.73282969,
-0.9054611325,
0.4646012187,
0.6333620548,
-0.5228900313,
-0.0984820873,
-0.0553519614,
0.3375308216,
-0.2678982019,
-0.0238477308,
0.3198339641,
0.4756670892,
0.2638602555,
-0.7846562862,
-0.2254976481,
-0.18315503,
0.0836351588,
0.1296111941,
-0.4211264849,
0.8594484925,
0.1004584506,
-0.21462062,
0.3476604819,
0.7798446417,
-0.146618858,
-0.289562583,
0.9818512797,
0.7693719268,
0.9660536051,
-0.3743243814,
0.4913232028,
-0.2712447345,
0.0385644659,
1.2917386293,
-0.2745809853,
0.4369233847,
0.3054438233,
-0.2833094895,
0.7276153564,
0.4689384997,
0.0667799562,
0.6073853374,
0.281444639,
-0.3242248297,
-0.4302385449,
-0.0459255092,
-0.5366498828,
0.2936190665,
0.6802066565,
-0.1050947309,
-0.2785738111,
-0.145206511,
-0.0833893493,
-0.0570595302,
-0.0877565667,
0.9792574644,
-0.3504900932,
-0.5254491568,
0.3871218264,
-0.3692442179,
0.8673369288,
-0.7746295929,
-0.0902635157,
0.115500316,
0.1873304248,
-0.0073790569,
-0.3981921971,
0.1283530742,
-0.3638350368,
-0.1429649144,
-0.2572668493,
0.974437654,
-0.6291944981,
-0.3040135503,
0.0080840886,
0.1976763904,
0.1332878917,
-0.0611729994,
-0.8073779345,
0.246366486,
0.233317405,
0.2274767458,
0.6911540031,
0.3395540714,
0.3501569927,
0.193782419,
0.6732873917,
0.1002104804,
-0.0085278265,
0.2257297188,
1.025229454,
-0.2869508266,
-0.546513021,
-0.4728171229,
0.5293529034,
-0.2429207265,
-0.2345260084,
0.3424375951,
0.1897814125,
0.8105754852,
0.0405486375,
0.8958083987,
0.1341381371,
0.8159359694,
-0.3876198828,
0.5952032804,
-0.2523168027,
0.4425219893,
-0.7158799171,
-0.8045479655,
-0.3290864229,
0.9951447845,
0.0291515887,
-0.1635118425,
0.1906653196,
0.9942926764,
0.0083829472,
0.0100729968,
0.5714191198,
0.5127239823,
0.1216760501,
0.2633365691,
0.8784508705,
-0.4023939967,
0.8580313921,
-0.1770449281,
-0.2303451002,
-0.1418516487,
-0.6791172624,
-0.8199236989,
-0.388761133,
-0.3952112794,
-0.519236207,
0.1792629361,
0.6572207808,
0.8899084926,
-0.9949344397,
-0.1076746359,
0.0247572325,
0.3165687025,
-0.391789645,
-0.2356515676,
0.1690473109,
-1.1044187546,
-0.7653600574,
0.5315595865,
0.1072803661,
0.3477383852,
-0.1502538025,
0.1232924685,
-0.1968797594,
0.250932008,
0.2513736188,
0.3205400109,
-0.6962013841,
-0.0980923101,
-0.3387947381,
-0.0106001571,
0.1617225856,
0.7567417026,
-0.6504952312,
0.7011874914,
0.004007373,
0.8461093307,
0.3430862427,
0.1837729812,
0.7285001874,
-1.1052484512,
0.3591196537,
0.2313809395,
0.4221601486,
0.0795812011,
-0.5096023083,
0.1586862952,
0.1222928166,
-0.5570559502,
-0.8901259303,
0.2424098551,
-0.9392845631,
-0.3092837334,
0.6533607841,
-0.1486245394,
-0.0394707546,
-0.5654184818,
-0.3912643194,
0.131570816,
-0.771246016,
0.7736155987,
0.8531273603,
-0.0952420607,
-0.0777528808,
0.0175627898,
0.8537606597,
0.7630448341,
-0.4800505936,
-0.1276245564,
0.511205554,
0.0548841842,
0.3591816127,
0.6104143262,
-0.1969379187,
0.1964559704,
-0.1852055043,
0.0209522657,
0.0160500482,
-0.1132897437,
-0.397420615,
0.2676925063,
0.055921074,
-0.2409708053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14891v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14891v5
|
LLMBind: A Unified Modality-Task Integration Framework
| 2024-02-22T12:36:31 | 2024-04-19T03:07:59 |
Bin Zhu, Munan Ning, Peng Jin, Bin Lin, Jinfa Huang, Qi Song, Junwu Zhang, Zhenyu Tang, Mingjun Pan, Xing Zhou, Li Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the multi-modal domain, the dependence of various models on specific input
formats leads to user confusion and hinders progress. To address this
challenge, we introduce \textbf{LLMBind}, a novel framework designed to unify a
diverse array of multi-modal tasks. By harnessing a Mixture-of-Experts (MoE)
Large Language Model (LLM), LLMBind processes multi-modal inputs and generates
task-specific tokens, enabling the invocation of corresponding models to
accomplish tasks. This unique approach empowers LLMBind to interpret inputs and
generate outputs across various modalities, including image, text, video, and
audio. Furthermore, we have constructed an interaction dataset comprising 400k
instructions, which unlocks the ability of LLMBind for interactive visual
generation and editing tasks. Extensive experimentation demonstrates that
LLMBind achieves very superior performance across diverse tasks and outperforms
existing models in user evaluations conducted in real-world scenarios.
Moreover, the adaptability of LLMBind allows for seamless integration with the
latest models and extension to new modality tasks, highlighting its potential
to serve as a unified AI agent for modeling universal modalities.
|
[
-0.2380058914,
-0.6366812587,
0.6040832996,
0.3963667154,
-0.2871186435,
0.1323460191,
-0.1988725662,
-0.3686812818,
0.2420662791,
0.2761321664,
-0.6793769598,
-0.4082948267,
-0.4323811829,
-0.1995349228,
-0.1851093769,
0.666641593,
-0.0993742049,
0.1954110563,
-0.4396685064,
0.0735401437,
-0.860835433,
-0.1408851147,
-0.1185411513,
-0.4552562833,
0.6703984737,
0.382491976,
0.3217901289,
0.3009254336,
0.7691770196,
0.3251685202,
0.4017856419,
0.5960327387,
-0.4874036014,
0.3073949218,
-0.2833642066,
-0.4354886711,
-0.5882565975,
-0.1716658175,
0.5290470123,
0.5926306844,
-0.092440322,
0.0841162428,
0.0216002222,
0.2559378743,
-0.6971241236,
0.2274858952,
-0.4515630603,
-0.2057378739,
-0.4156831801,
-0.3329567313,
-0.20204705,
0.3644711971,
-0.4123829603,
-0.5756391883,
-0.2433224618,
0.0162749942,
0.4352781773,
0.470353961,
-0.66779989,
0.2224755287,
-0.6301668882,
0.7001640797,
-0.5623944402,
0.5797801018,
-0.0233040452,
0.4083641469,
-0.3154544234,
-0.5756243467,
-0.6190825105,
0.0532115586,
0.0980735421,
0.1726759076,
-0.2841492295,
0.4661299586,
-0.0975468159,
0.2040709257,
-0.4079039693,
0.2645036876,
-0.220181182,
-0.1954352707,
0.6932355762,
0.4776718616,
0.4858802557,
-0.414372772,
-0.291056186,
0.3132916987,
-0.6515312791,
0.0991028175,
0.2707649171,
0.0975365043,
-0.1307499707,
0.7940524817,
-0.3746770024,
0.7840098143,
0.1181092784,
-0.5691105723,
0.0431004912,
-0.4166623354,
-0.4682522714,
-0.2725127339,
0.9365448952,
0.6090923548,
-0.1589639038,
-0.3473850787,
-0.4238091707,
0.1657300144,
0.2431185693,
-0.6804526448,
-0.0246667452,
0.1765147448,
-0.375143677,
-0.1968527287,
-0.1040395796,
-0.5325746536,
-0.6045177579,
-0.516744256,
0.5667261481,
-0.3318936229,
-0.3710998893,
0.0172541011,
-0.0177845843,
0.0678774714,
0.7040343285,
-0.8405354619,
0.0209537856,
0.7403387427,
0.5037901998,
-0.5102026463,
-0.5069707036,
-0.5050076842,
0.4769890606,
0.0228691902,
0.9958432317,
-0.8565376997,
-0.5203162432,
-0.2025886029,
-0.1808112711,
-0.2519432604,
-0.3265368342,
0.0638019145,
-0.4178657532,
-0.069841519,
-0.1443801671,
-0.2679829001,
-0.4263648987,
0.1752006859,
-0.5675073266,
0.8366473913,
0.1554332078,
-0.6367701292,
0.3213970065,
-0.9874286056,
-0.4578198493,
0.2170138806,
-0.6603432894,
0.3025564849,
0.4142057002,
0.2639546096,
0.6599001884,
-0.7960013747,
0.7470093966,
-0.3646819293,
-0.4503589272,
0.2965364456,
-0.6948722005,
0.6231996417,
0.1686344296,
-0.204744935,
0.4639785886,
-0.7492172122,
-0.2486165166,
-0.2393398285,
-0.4721585214,
-0.1809285134,
-0.182309866,
0.5042963624,
0.1146136075,
0.3101872504,
-0.6250767708,
0.4333184361,
0.2386746705,
0.4426300526,
0.9640629888,
-0.1112638116,
0.4377572834,
-0.4083952308,
0.674815774,
0.1885391027,
0.0150611438,
-0.376975894,
-0.5078104734,
-0.6026101112,
-0.8481193185,
0.2967785597,
0.5656611323,
-0.7026596665,
0.1479382217,
-0.5247260928,
-0.3751623631,
-0.7247136831,
0.4618590474,
0.2404174209,
0.4651190042,
-0.0880680904,
-0.4686128497,
-0.5228691101,
-1.077273488,
0.081009008,
-0.1002933234,
-0.1352064908,
0.2693081498,
0.4596505463,
-0.7043358088,
1.0764188766,
-0.0691652447,
-0.3162513077,
-0.5164585114,
0.3918595612,
0.246197626,
0.661747396,
0.2909574807,
-0.887678802,
-0.1201208383,
0.1694923043,
-0.8993088603,
-0.3247400224,
-0.409032464,
-0.3425577879,
-0.07807675,
0.3788802028,
-0.6836180091,
0.3251441121,
0.5800343156,
-0.0848623887,
0.4244376421,
-0.064908579,
0.4659989476,
-1.4376834631,
0.3256595135,
-0.1160403639,
-0.2140324414,
-0.5306806564,
0.1086927876,
0.0215013828,
-0.0207628384,
-0.4540064335,
0.5401090384,
-0.3874719739,
-0.1985159069,
-0.0946015194,
-0.0833385959,
0.050939694,
0.7125677466,
-0.3649794161,
0.9091250896,
0.6255788803,
-0.3231621087,
0.6719726324,
0.1431043744,
-0.5161930919,
0.9637637734,
-0.6296046376,
-0.0916927755,
-0.1954423785,
0.0241538528,
-1.1906762123,
-0.8242608309,
0.1680555642,
-0.2638811469,
0.3648653328,
0.0664070919,
-0.6336263418,
-0.1136318594,
-0.1611777991,
0.6547384858,
0.2428433001,
-0.2982314527,
1.2988481522,
0.3885520995,
-0.1911347955,
-0.6388524771,
-0.9331892133,
0.222183913,
0.0500497818,
-0.7779332995,
0.4370729327,
-0.3685071468,
-0.1825213879,
0.1002734303,
-0.1248443201,
-0.1740688235,
0.1365827173,
0.798820734,
0.4072003365,
-0.0808692351,
-0.0180759691,
0.5234667063,
0.0464632399,
-0.1709938794,
0.2345191985,
0.4567709565,
0.075689882,
-1.0481131077,
-0.6555408239,
0.7166746855,
0.9675329328,
-0.3595066667,
0.1428853273,
0.7295535803,
-0.1254122406,
0.1879511923,
-0.8587325811,
0.1883308887,
-0.4640470147,
0.6519901752,
-0.5544779897,
-1.0312575102,
0.3660538793,
-0.3034998477,
0.2570326626,
0.0199703965,
0.6566565633,
-0.2132324725,
1.2098721266,
0.9905576706,
-0.2134079188,
0.5326035023,
-0.0009387994,
0.2424720675,
-1.1391661167,
-0.5054314137,
0.2551637292,
-0.7159609199,
-0.2721660137,
-0.6256893873,
0.5275281072,
0.0220709257,
-0.0531119592,
-0.0318784304,
-0.2538255453,
0.4137197435,
0.6094017625,
0.2334525138,
0.3378828466,
0.0403775051,
-0.0957154036,
0.0218214523,
-0.5897105932,
-0.1643349826,
1.22534132,
0.2040239424,
1.2024255991,
0.2144368589,
0.6435781121,
0.5102437735,
0.5497099757,
-0.8925064802,
0.8188560009,
0.080541335,
-0.5631141067,
0.029015135,
-0.1516391933,
-0.6619172096,
0.4448033869,
-0.3346483707,
-0.9148081541,
0.3400064111,
0.0578435063,
-0.4184430242,
0.3243336082,
-0.5680623651,
0.7625452876,
-0.4283848405,
-0.4086398184,
-0.3353292048,
-0.4367005825,
0.6781645417,
-0.15971753,
0.2382858545,
-0.3112334609,
-0.1858483404,
0.460573256,
0.2058311999,
1.1289172173,
0.109204106,
-0.092772238,
-0.0249271765,
0.2958435118,
0.0282585118,
0.1579014808,
-0.030502582,
0.2128561884,
-0.3180418909,
-0.1433831304,
-0.5930569768,
0.6534504294,
-0.6260168552,
-0.7573202848,
-0.0730618462,
-1.262886405,
-0.2095366418,
0.3795154691,
-0.1775921881,
0.8171969056,
-0.3752513826,
0.1908455342,
0.4600349367,
0.1792916656,
0.4766450226,
0.4175524712,
-0.3567637503,
-0.5614202023,
0.8271752596,
-0.2778128386,
-0.0328360349,
0.5634170175,
-0.3035737276,
-0.0129139777,
-0.3657777309,
-0.5999065638,
0.2480227798,
-0.7969402075,
-0.3479198813,
-0.6100285649,
0.0593358688,
-0.488907069,
-0.3368403912,
-0.0726718679,
-0.1424851865,
-0.2902979851,
0.0892326534,
0.1560309529,
0.7886520028,
-0.3531383276,
0.5556565523,
-0.8014249206,
0.4724439681,
0.6645065546,
0.2797701955,
-0.2364088148,
-0.3592710197,
-0.0371815264,
0.0616629682,
-0.2893746197,
-0.8249875903,
0.2789434493,
0.2785831988,
0.8777601123,
0.6394325495,
-0.2990491688,
0.8193634748,
-0.5520880222,
0.6786473989,
0.5661127567,
-0.9695504904,
0.2071531117,
-0.4608671665,
0.3934075236,
0.4888032675,
0.2085260451,
-0.6235255003,
-0.2473219335,
-0.0288684834,
-0.7070649862,
0.5681946278,
-0.2609502673,
0.0927666724,
0.3773789406,
-0.0112443184,
0.2371437401,
0.5751789212,
-0.6348795891,
0.106261313,
-0.0229685642,
-0.5602266192,
-0.0312338062,
-0.2849924564,
-0.480912149,
-0.4344393313,
0.1115481183,
-0.249413982,
0.4793592095,
-0.0520076007,
-0.6413472891,
-0.1098930985,
0.3018250167,
0.6470954418,
0.9391466379,
-0.0689090863,
0.1642476022,
-0.0314326845,
-0.2409458011,
0.0724878609,
0.2099112421,
0.0117122056,
-0.1533568949,
0.4264537096,
0.9477283359,
0.5166831017,
-0.9484157562,
0.5534957051,
0.0532594956,
-0.0914224759,
0.049994722,
0.057933338,
0.0707200617,
0.5835021138,
0.3339498043,
0.2919154465,
0.2542365491,
-0.5073410869,
0.2083754092,
0.5015969872,
-0.1315933168,
-0.4713842273,
0.7852942944,
0.5251646042,
-0.2273978144,
0.3281992078,
0.0459005125,
-0.386354208,
0.2213471532,
0.4586548805,
0.9337049723,
-0.2015083283,
0.2322835475,
-0.216105774,
0.2388568968,
0.2494577467,
0.4354415238,
-0.3830683529,
-0.5493855476,
-0.6753031611,
-0.662170589,
-0.35902372,
-0.0231962502,
-0.3583848178,
0.1086444482,
-0.3036721051,
-0.1655282825,
-0.0871626362,
-0.6068528891,
-0.8025847077,
-0.0549857467,
0.3267040849,
0.6903377771,
-0.8863096237,
0.7278497815,
1.1055275202,
-0.5600065589,
-0.5175792575,
-0.2076121867,
0.2030168921,
-1.0628721714,
0.9325505495,
0.3335294425,
-0.2076401711,
-0.1048093662,
-0.5537670255,
-0.7624747753,
1.2493146658,
0.436832577,
-0.4097729623,
-0.2127533257,
0.2606707215,
0.1229062751,
-0.6105203629,
0.3298849463,
0.5233420134,
0.6570225954,
0.0286324285,
-0.9839649796,
0.0062271985,
-0.5687049627,
0.149897337,
0.1347940862,
-0.4553141296,
0.9311184287,
-0.0557642765,
-0.0848577395,
-0.0465379208,
0.7362139225,
0.03336557,
0.1248943061,
0.5843880773,
0.4831737876,
0.5676531196,
0.0187873133,
0.8369429708,
-0.3652966917,
-0.2625517845,
0.8912324309,
-0.2522774041,
0.6055873632,
0.746889472,
0.1775034815,
0.4153528512,
0.4671370983,
-0.0703110695,
0.5788795948,
-0.0494258627,
-0.4244759977,
-0.7186956406,
-0.4389703274,
-0.0793159828,
0.7309137583,
0.3263480961,
0.1105981693,
-0.3099097311,
0.2957501411,
-0.1437613219,
-0.0999110863,
-0.3306834698,
0.6063061357,
-0.1295660138,
-0.4270551205,
0.2672573924,
-0.0868907049,
1.1508880854,
-0.6904514432,
-0.1902842224,
-0.2104955912,
0.02633949,
-0.2244554609,
-0.6966075897,
-0.0971406028,
-0.1425813287,
-0.2405045331,
-0.1827585846,
0.716770947,
-0.5799110532,
-0.5531197786,
-0.0313788727,
0.7277126312,
-0.003695796,
-0.0002177788,
-0.5243676901,
0.4354985654,
0.0455010906,
-0.1277511567,
0.4006479979,
0.4443685114,
0.036109414,
0.8258923888,
0.5397398472,
-0.1226456165,
-0.1441057622,
-0.0284856204,
1.0729135275,
-0.4779168665,
-0.2686565816,
-0.5484313369,
0.9028736353,
-0.0788475946,
-0.2895952761,
0.5856745243,
0.3727728426,
0.6618619561,
-0.0338855647,
0.9445481896,
-0.3236972988,
0.0664303228,
-0.2938202024,
0.7135436535,
-1.1022213697,
0.144665733,
-0.1733736247,
-0.7288538814,
-0.2563911974,
0.3058842123,
-0.1375637352,
-0.0705793202,
0.5169950724,
0.9462400675,
-0.4901401699,
-0.2750166059,
0.5303624272,
-0.0973818898,
0.4103272557,
0.5809131265,
0.8020798564,
-0.0267837588,
0.3658699691,
-0.2218464464,
-0.3792160749,
-0.4767471552,
-0.9096739888,
-0.9078298211,
-0.6403172612,
0.0289087556,
0.2605001032,
-0.07550098,
1.2204891443,
0.7373816371,
-0.5476029515,
-0.5670116544,
0.2402652502,
0.0581105649,
-0.1553200036,
-0.1616794765,
-0.1508428752,
-0.3089603782,
-0.8646418452,
0.7461359501,
0.6222947836,
-0.1646970809,
-0.4328579605,
0.1196961403,
-0.1019970104,
0.1958873272,
0.6624549031,
0.1161933094,
-0.8750455379,
-0.0962397903,
-0.0105996523,
-0.2499963492,
0.021465648,
1.0178382397,
-0.5257382393,
0.6266331077,
0.5107348561,
1.0070972443,
0.0576587282,
-0.2364952415,
0.8314103484,
-0.5499505401,
0.3347298205,
0.0848111361,
0.4756970406,
0.2962777317,
-0.2211597115,
0.3753511608,
0.2764487863,
-0.4147180319,
-1.1003222466,
0.4108071625,
-1.426035881,
-0.1964400858,
1.0395840406,
0.1138732731,
-0.407437861,
0.0287072752,
-0.5058360696,
0.0764227733,
-0.5526357889,
0.5784552097,
0.4072158933,
-0.3137153387,
-0.2423052043,
-0.5018772483,
-0.0347108021,
0.4912644327,
-0.8288720846,
-0.1036650836,
0.8880166411,
0.2427719086,
-0.0535613038,
0.6402392387,
0.1344420314,
0.444803834,
-0.1979058534,
0.4274540544,
-0.5624294281,
-0.4158858657,
-0.2877887189,
0.0833223835,
-0.0591548756,
-0.1255979985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14492v2
|
Towards Robust Instruction Tuning on Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T12:35:50 | 2024-06-14T13:38:14 |
Wei Han, Hui Chen, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) on multi-task instruction-following
data has been proven to be a powerful learning paradigm for improving their
zero-shot capabilities on new tasks. Recent works about high-quality
instruction-following data generation and selection require amounts of human
labor to conceive model-understandable instructions for the given tasks and
carefully filter the LLM-generated data. In this work, we introduce an
automatic instruction augmentation method named INSTRAUG in multimodal tasks.
It starts from a handful of basic and straightforward meta instructions but can
expand an instruction-following dataset by 30 times. Results on two popular
multimodal instructionfollowing benchmarks MULTIINSTRUCT and InstructBLIP show
that INSTRAUG can significantly improve the alignment of multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) across 12 multimodal tasks, which is even equivalent to
the benefits of scaling up training data multiple times.
|
[
-0.2674953043,
-0.6836023927,
0.2729952931,
0.0851966515,
-0.1233856976,
0.3060251772,
-0.499281168,
-0.2109959722,
-0.2002260834,
0.4564726949,
-0.8603257537,
-0.6373518705,
-0.533480227,
-0.1409986168,
-0.1156848148,
0.9071334004,
0.1055780202,
0.1417283267,
-0.4644076526,
-0.1154623106,
-0.6955602765,
-0.0374866575,
-0.1221361086,
-0.1340483129,
0.4151566029,
0.9241351485,
0.5897280574,
0.8116212487,
0.3437755406,
0.3246869445,
0.3007022142,
0.956445992,
-0.4236917198,
0.1382361501,
-0.1012052745,
-0.3454940319,
-0.49955073,
-0.260659337,
0.8463027477,
0.4785479307,
-0.018523993,
0.3021841347,
0.5062475801,
0.2525164485,
-0.7671090364,
0.1619550437,
-0.4019724131,
-0.2867151499,
-0.2586875856,
-0.4505498409,
-0.831012845,
-0.3743769228,
-0.2401245087,
-0.4036979973,
0.0718932077,
0.0198596064,
0.5759400129,
0.3511494994,
-0.5351660252,
-0.2781585753,
-0.439126581,
0.9221311212,
-0.8886631131,
0.5940797925,
0.4169827998,
0.0332036689,
-0.2484511733,
-0.5661619902,
-0.3430659473,
-0.2926234007,
-0.2683334947,
-0.1552251577,
-0.1327184439,
0.1993286461,
0.3828755021,
0.0512296483,
-0.5492517352,
0.4113225341,
-0.176589787,
-0.2033059895,
0.2976671159,
0.3199082613,
0.4043776989,
0.2097529322,
-0.4374365807,
-0.1953314841,
-0.8452217579,
0.0911383107,
0.4636622965,
0.275749594,
-0.1194275096,
0.372348547,
-0.2763172686,
1.2024046183,
0.1857194155,
-0.4204236269,
0.4278022945,
-0.5969839692,
-0.163090229,
0.0015024011,
0.5031459332,
0.3326992095,
0.1106322855,
-0.1518142372,
-0.0808168203,
-0.040303681,
0.3449264169,
-0.9216414094,
-0.3384318352,
-0.0855925232,
-0.1660539806,
0.0006605706,
-0.0565618314,
-0.7626814842,
-0.0042695976,
-0.4595100582,
0.5424153209,
-0.6551519632,
0.2527993917,
0.0258154701,
0.2483503371,
0.218341738,
0.2889184058,
-1.0618164539,
-0.0399551652,
0.5487379432,
0.6513625979,
0.0364720859,
-0.4368022382,
-1.1272274256,
0.339382112,
-0.3295182288,
0.8720645308,
-1.0767109394,
-0.0587359443,
-0.0755174384,
0.2793301046,
-0.212035805,
-0.2273796797,
0.4052424729,
-0.3074477613,
0.2382487655,
-0.0716016442,
-0.7277505994,
-0.2545082271,
0.2102916986,
-0.3497392833,
0.7923852205,
0.0737177581,
-0.3624774516,
0.4176751077,
-0.5981549025,
-0.7689356208,
0.0188623555,
0.2024922371,
-0.2256057113,
0.057752274,
0.7166482806,
0.559864521,
-0.0354059599,
-0.2841358781,
-0.4905143976,
-0.4030431211,
0.0758026838,
-0.579036355,
0.7435811758,
-0.1106666774,
-0.2536641061,
0.3148586452,
-0.708263278,
0.3990185857,
-0.5853713751,
-0.3816409111,
-0.3041327,
-0.1304630488,
-0.1853523552,
0.0826574638,
0.1157916337,
-0.5896276832,
0.4094364941,
-0.1337154061,
0.4089635313,
0.8205484748,
-0.0626415685,
0.544443965,
-0.1025718153,
0.5845864415,
-0.3015249074,
0.2544962764,
-0.8680765033,
-0.2830825448,
-0.7667102218,
-0.7179724574,
0.3495548666,
0.5043215156,
-0.9280517101,
0.1158825383,
-0.1862229556,
-0.3517298996,
-0.8548527956,
0.5843732953,
0.6481948495,
0.6800744534,
0.5480678678,
-0.0445756316,
-0.3277922869,
-0.7365335822,
-0.0524736457,
0.4331570864,
0.0734218135,
0.0445725285,
0.2229250968,
-0.3797057271,
0.321272403,
-0.3978411555,
-0.1693449467,
0.026256375,
0.340911746,
-0.0162524544,
0.6186634898,
0.3022733033,
-0.3921263218,
-0.7590470314,
0.1079762504,
-0.5590695143,
-0.1186340526,
-0.3024712801,
-0.2441895306,
0.1752153784,
0.7137732506,
-0.4345375896,
0.1874043941,
0.5322675109,
-0.1610838771,
0.3162995577,
-0.3613141179,
0.3138001263,
-0.934006989,
-0.3337242305,
-0.0047204792,
-0.401052475,
-0.6466149092,
0.3693835139,
0.6790238619,
0.1535624862,
-0.4186191857,
0.2406949699,
-0.8107730746,
0.1852735579,
-0.3241352439,
-0.2425333411,
0.1740458757,
0.5471770167,
-0.3786521852,
0.8433339,
0.7333389521,
-0.5936832428,
0.4449428618,
0.2411086261,
-0.5271556377,
0.5700877309,
-0.3051378131,
0.2904416621,
-0.1927965879,
0.1513103992,
-1.2531219721,
-0.4069105089,
0.1025716811,
-0.2199264169,
0.7165006399,
-0.3735699952,
-0.7763838768,
-0.0042907656,
-0.2534668148,
0.2434962988,
0.2894018888,
-0.7568485141,
0.6055765748,
0.1388216019,
-0.0382478908,
-0.6724075079,
-0.6336475015,
0.0132737951,
-0.1073465496,
-0.4218129218,
0.3284902573,
-0.1171328649,
0.057870958,
-0.1178938299,
0.1234875023,
-0.0020330546,
-0.2511616349,
0.1705690026,
0.4132063091,
-0.1236371771,
0.3583404422,
0.4270626307,
-0.0983984396,
-0.2085140496,
-0.2713044584,
0.4977280796,
0.005228559,
-0.5298199058,
-0.6836048961,
0.2871745825,
0.7229619622,
-0.5607397556,
0.3775600195,
0.9709588289,
-0.0789628997,
-0.4067595005,
-0.4260317087,
-0.3208622932,
-0.5273668766,
0.4744293094,
0.0066724843,
-0.7036169171,
-0.072902292,
0.0182182826,
0.3838204443,
-0.040263135,
0.6193757057,
-0.5471639633,
1.1090080738,
0.8037605882,
0.0466733314,
0.6055457592,
-0.1815749705,
-0.100884147,
-0.7542589307,
-0.2241791487,
-0.1850410253,
-0.5529572368,
-0.5017269254,
-0.6125054955,
0.5728882551,
-0.3186208606,
-0.030615272,
0.3796012998,
-0.4255549312,
0.6065928936,
0.6842767596,
0.5622828007,
0.1282159388,
0.1308734417,
0.0563472547,
-0.1740409136,
-0.8204408288,
-0.0925396308,
1.0600692034,
0.1559223086,
1.1734663248,
-0.0737997666,
0.3926349282,
0.1157919914,
0.3865050972,
-0.5643440485,
0.3953686357,
-0.41696316,
-0.3024591506,
-0.1703732908,
-0.2311426252,
-0.6221954823,
0.1264236122,
-0.429930985,
-0.5127094984,
0.1388521791,
0.5534197688,
-0.5762821436,
0.2268705219,
-1.0030921698,
0.7605446577,
-0.4590814114,
-0.5730425715,
-0.4868509471,
-0.6799864769,
0.3578880727,
0.2376660556,
0.1840442419,
0.0564883724,
-0.1318200082,
0.1679886431,
-0.2492052466,
0.9979652762,
-0.0521120951,
-0.1555761248,
0.0938531607,
0.0199928544,
0.6239631176,
-0.1433490217,
0.2047105432,
-0.2151237428,
-0.2874286473,
-0.3771747947,
-0.7531471848,
0.9400984645,
-0.3065168262,
-0.3575686514,
-0.0293616466,
-1.117970705,
-0.4377503991,
0.102019839,
0.2262879163,
1.0087684393,
0.2994336784,
0.4732946157,
0.9822342992,
-0.1670513451,
0.6059510708,
0.4464769363,
0.156827271,
-0.5491976738,
1.0535204411,
0.1236920878,
0.5336562991,
0.8063845038,
-0.0879640877,
-0.3499099612,
-0.2525828183,
-0.8198889494,
0.0775647759,
-0.6484231949,
-0.4426644742,
-0.4860831797,
0.1439499259,
-0.2644774318,
-0.1152466536,
-0.2597966492,
-0.130624041,
-0.339422226,
0.0324770734,
0.4203714132,
0.3596407771,
0.0527784862,
0.476674974,
-0.9626198411,
0.2052740455,
0.4405563772,
0.3648751676,
-0.0829081386,
-0.7525030375,
-0.5225654244,
0.290171355,
-0.3534726799,
-0.6210855842,
0.1776670814,
0.4679410756,
0.5331740975,
0.5351337194,
-0.1946422309,
1.1938719749,
-0.7093421817,
0.3590063453,
0.0751188025,
-0.8325899243,
0.309892267,
-0.1874612421,
0.8266419172,
0.3819777668,
0.4616607726,
-0.093123503,
-0.2645975947,
-0.0714915842,
-0.6887009144,
0.6521142721,
-0.1687380522,
0.4116605818,
0.2125519216,
0.0781686753,
0.2291863859,
0.1815489233,
-0.4073432088,
0.0108650327,
-0.0483588427,
-0.3447825313,
-0.168587923,
-0.2790350616,
-0.1656820178,
-0.4655224979,
0.6194921732,
-0.2483031899,
0.0172154289,
-0.3591822088,
-0.363381356,
-0.1046774909,
0.2353984863,
0.8686081171,
0.8020961881,
-0.156627968,
0.0795676559,
0.3398396969,
-0.3573224247,
0.133769542,
0.0429276079,
-0.0584262013,
-0.0206234138,
0.6488047242,
0.8963488936,
0.5298941135,
-0.7582519054,
0.2675418854,
0.1248050332,
-0.0318214595,
0.0676425993,
0.2466837764,
-0.0434257686,
0.3893589973,
0.1023030877,
0.1822384,
-0.0034036345,
-0.6428005099,
0.3573161662,
0.6963285208,
-0.2798200846,
-0.2508503497,
0.5677933097,
0.1319943666,
-0.1757014245,
0.6674723625,
-0.0161357895,
-0.1213937923,
0.1245218441,
0.6390984058,
0.5779066682,
-0.3356789947,
0.1906557381,
0.2841609716,
0.5448220968,
0.1340851635,
0.1982902735,
-0.2363685817,
-0.3405570388,
-0.8958142996,
-0.3696033061,
-0.311809957,
0.0296749212,
-0.6568249464,
0.295039922,
-0.2429365516,
0.0958042219,
0.0112004178,
-0.5289563537,
-0.6237541437,
0.0295395888,
0.1087004691,
0.6475647092,
-0.6574047804,
1.0336948633,
0.5768262148,
-0.1500137299,
-0.536041975,
0.1843565106,
-0.0746614486,
-0.6277589202,
0.4291789234,
0.2311863154,
-0.3464359641,
-0.0399771705,
-0.7135327458,
-0.848731339,
0.890650332,
0.7659642696,
-0.7734521627,
-0.1387508363,
-0.0981956273,
0.363080889,
-0.447919637,
0.2097860575,
0.297753036,
0.3125956059,
-0.085150674,
-0.7278909683,
-0.1201645359,
-0.0815361291,
-0.2074234337,
0.4314765334,
-0.6117076874,
0.7919506431,
-0.3525718749,
-0.0421336368,
-0.1858417392,
0.6385784149,
-0.1667307913,
0.0564446673,
0.5430489779,
0.6224507689,
0.5530245304,
0.1339262128,
0.9080600739,
-0.4484298825,
0.0146411769,
1.4709770679,
0.0758776143,
0.7178424597,
0.3938143849,
0.2243832797,
0.7174532413,
0.3743694425,
-0.0528386086,
0.5988978744,
-0.3892364204,
-0.1223455295,
-0.4945761263,
-0.0008164013,
-0.1053868905,
0.7409111261,
0.6074377298,
-0.3900525868,
-0.400821209,
0.3287886381,
0.0647367984,
0.1007174402,
-0.4833144844,
0.6806865931,
-0.2330887914,
-0.646242559,
0.7942897677,
-0.1405381113,
0.565647006,
-0.638540864,
-0.5337484479,
-0.0693928152,
0.2728276551,
-0.2821911275,
-0.7647671103,
0.0193535592,
-0.0713458583,
-0.1212058365,
-0.4220354259,
0.5343263745,
-0.8705138564,
-0.6924613118,
0.0618225783,
0.2484941781,
-0.2250158191,
0.3045060635,
-0.3525216877,
0.0429947488,
0.1936579198,
0.074693948,
0.4459328651,
0.3010628223,
-0.0682153925,
0.8827365637,
0.6219795942,
-0.2095670253,
0.2562059462,
-0.12797001,
0.980497241,
-0.1092973128,
-0.3030076623,
-1.0422799587,
0.7468416691,
0.0304397773,
-0.2538681328,
1.0579679012,
0.3292335272,
1.1348452568,
-0.2224325389,
0.5695350766,
-0.0081196614,
0.480198741,
-0.7806648612,
0.4898430407,
-0.6090946794,
0.0085906684,
-0.2432277799,
-0.7816479206,
-0.2471484244,
0.3701209724,
-0.1153234541,
-0.173258692,
0.4042102993,
1.2127159834,
-0.5252801776,
-0.3398253024,
0.2546882331,
0.0511607528,
-0.0248034317,
0.3290364444,
0.5792191625,
-0.1517806351,
0.6371655464,
-0.4677020609,
-0.2108677924,
-0.1858621687,
-0.7590600252,
-0.8904134631,
-0.5129763484,
-0.1912242621,
-0.0825853646,
0.0435009189,
1.1842976809,
0.9814118147,
-0.8117516041,
-0.2412506491,
0.3532119393,
0.126703307,
-0.6200580001,
-0.1773639917,
0.2721362114,
-0.7480502725,
-0.9678277969,
0.7593203187,
0.453471303,
-0.2342453152,
-0.2364494205,
-0.018937625,
-0.3988745809,
-0.0470167287,
0.7397263646,
0.0623970591,
-0.5436064005,
-0.2704524994,
0.0731945857,
0.0556487963,
0.043731872,
0.6886868477,
-0.5159996748,
0.961525023,
0.4014169872,
0.6424463987,
0.3481024504,
0.0883076638,
0.5402475595,
-1.0186898708,
0.1845453829,
0.0496665388,
0.3758792877,
0.3699067235,
-0.2890727222,
0.2501554787,
-0.2343732566,
-0.5754185915,
-1.0051810741,
0.1585852653,
-0.6120797992,
-0.1209427342,
0.9832126498,
-0.0736971796,
-0.0970657915,
0.1864206791,
-0.1508710384,
0.166537717,
-0.3998138905,
0.6378657818,
0.4199350476,
-0.2775550783,
-0.611915946,
-0.7402924895,
0.3779509068,
0.2240914702,
-0.7897458076,
0.0709848925,
0.6270695329,
0.2910601795,
-0.0791938379,
0.0398344956,
0.1304053366,
0.4748717248,
-0.1834120899,
0.1038066,
-0.4629669785,
-0.6724007726,
-0.1454644054,
0.0880609825,
-0.1411332041,
-0.6307112575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14488v1
|
Does the Generator Mind its Contexts? An Analysis of Generative Model Faithfulness under Context Transfer
| 2024-02-22T12:26:07 | 2024-02-22T12:26:07 |
Xinshuo Hu, Baotian Hu, Dongfang Li, Xiaoguang Li, Lifeng Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The present study introduces the knowledge-augmented generator, which is
specifically designed to produce information that remains grounded in
contextual knowledge, regardless of alterations in the context. Previous
research has predominantly focused on examining hallucinations stemming from
static input, such as in the domains of summarization or machine translation.
However, our investigation delves into the faithfulness of generative question
answering in the presence of dynamic knowledge. Our objective is to explore the
existence of hallucinations arising from parametric memory when contextual
knowledge undergoes changes, while also analyzing the underlying causes for
their occurrence. In order to efficiently address this issue, we propose a
straightforward yet effective measure for detecting such hallucinations.
Intriguingly, our investigation uncovers that all models exhibit a tendency to
generate previous answers as hallucinations. To gain deeper insights into the
underlying causes of this phenomenon, we conduct a series of experiments that
verify the critical role played by context in hallucination, both during
training and testing, from various perspectives.
|
[
-0.7061727047,
-1.0272301435,
0.9413686991,
-0.1640746146,
-0.2824198306,
-0.3521781564,
-0.0909058228,
-0.3074513376,
0.0746507272,
0.5132834315,
-0.6025425196,
0.0283611733,
-0.4754614234,
0.1947551966,
-0.9517451525,
0.8658197522,
-0.1764751077,
-0.1498519778,
-0.483233422,
-0.1843363196,
-0.6537391543,
-0.7014597058,
-0.3207717836,
-0.2965700626,
0.2800275981,
-0.2300015092,
0.6087908745,
0.2297233641,
0.0856304616,
0.3191598654,
0.0614915229,
0.2278965265,
-0.5165475011,
0.6514850855,
-0.1776337326,
-0.3662464023,
0.0455138609,
-0.2116099298,
0.5421689153,
0.7650389671,
-0.1685958803,
0.1339317858,
0.3402639925,
0.227978453,
-0.6821094155,
-0.214352712,
-1.0602126122,
0.3053033948,
0.1372708082,
-0.7978314161,
-0.5193813443,
-0.2317134738,
0.0806900188,
-0.5198256969,
0.7965371013,
-0.1425629109,
0.6542336941,
0.6140085459,
-0.4985908866,
-0.4787437618,
-1.0142798424,
0.3944295347,
-0.1414191276,
0.4572223425,
0.2749345899,
0.5000708103,
-0.1557105184,
-0.8930825591,
-0.868041873,
-0.0666626319,
-0.1511964798,
-0.002719247,
0.0913792402,
-0.1573298573,
0.5984554887,
0.4807390571,
-0.4787863791,
-0.7523357272,
-0.3902882934,
-0.320948571,
0.2668244243,
0.2771162391,
0.5272176266,
-0.2189609259,
-0.2941172421,
-0.1099158078,
-0.4022985399,
-0.2999903858,
0.2894237638,
-0.1428605467,
0.1876729578,
0.5379944444,
-0.0261218566,
1.0326546431,
0.1448557228,
0.2238705307,
-0.1081476882,
-0.2535500228,
-0.276935041,
0.2169013172,
0.4618756175,
0.2167228609,
0.2276829034,
-0.6996303797,
-0.1352504343,
-0.2544253469,
0.847401917,
-0.6424167156,
-0.2978605032,
0.1032460481,
-0.3876673281,
-0.2996316254,
0.1413653195,
-0.739158988,
-0.5920772552,
-0.3642497659,
0.6492981911,
-0.6237806678,
-0.4622195065,
-0.0742433444,
-0.5753161907,
0.3845960796,
0.2146255672,
-0.9077113867,
-0.0484541133,
0.3507267833,
0.7549654841,
-0.2311937362,
-0.5241569877,
-0.2904739082,
0.2829524577,
-0.3417988718,
0.9321754575,
-0.1533418596,
-0.4168784022,
0.0169347804,
0.1254615486,
-0.2984191179,
-0.7878031135,
-0.1592235118,
-0.5949095488,
0.2351757139,
-0.7589898705,
-0.3535082936,
-0.0482985973,
0.2334361374,
-0.5144534111,
0.7991580963,
0.2980057299,
-0.7030773759,
0.5086671114,
0.0349810272,
-0.3294039965,
0.1412141621,
-0.5178421736,
-0.0408526026,
0.5687980056,
-0.1301165074,
0.2289197445,
0.0610530153,
0.5906667709,
-0.1148133427,
-0.5995383859,
0.6522483826,
-0.5073744655,
0.7489000559,
0.2085314989,
-0.585781455,
0.0648003817,
-0.7388261557,
-0.0915645435,
0.0463583432,
0.0332611278,
-0.337379545,
0.0451983511,
-0.0540751033,
0.1193011329,
-0.0667201951,
-0.1717889756,
-0.0227400009,
-0.024121698,
0.065120697,
0.667752862,
0.4340807498,
0.2861651778,
-0.3319390714,
0.4467780292,
-0.0236113016,
-0.2036326975,
0.0633619875,
-0.4491752386,
-0.8383272886,
0.3491447866,
-0.1387481242,
0.1267331988,
-1.0005125999,
0.3434498608,
-0.0418717414,
-0.029165959,
-0.0918693542,
-0.1189324483,
-0.0416343436,
1.0044618845,
0.3970583975,
0.1096514389,
-0.7006554008,
-0.9185026884,
-0.3177233636,
-0.0118798399,
-0.2646214068,
0.2473196387,
0.5088707209,
-0.2993655801,
0.8928990364,
-0.4109362662,
0.0813705549,
-0.24587816,
0.3381175101,
-0.3246169686,
0.353385061,
0.7391748428,
-0.7950356007,
-0.0748209208,
-0.1955692023,
-1.4059209824,
-0.0610891655,
-0.5414255857,
-0.2901997864,
-0.1144186929,
0.5277505517,
-0.7744265795,
0.3810336292,
0.2908242941,
-0.3712559044,
0.6397207975,
-0.0619793497,
0.354000181,
-1.3199186325,
0.1675295234,
-0.6630045772,
0.0447125062,
-0.6200205088,
0.0597881079,
-0.0800009817,
-0.171997726,
-0.2099956423,
0.3173172772,
-0.2003919184,
-0.1482113749,
-0.4747717679,
0.0560526662,
-0.0306031723,
0.2822577357,
0.1237675101,
1.1641124487,
0.4625064731,
-0.7030296326,
0.1828247458,
0.241892159,
-0.4718846381,
0.5057923794,
-0.2920148373,
0.4344133735,
-0.4760151207,
-0.0983303264,
-0.9110175967,
-0.6309492588,
0.1589275748,
-0.4376617074,
0.08447209,
0.1898706257,
-0.4199216962,
0.0247987658,
0.3404331803,
0.3063520789,
0.7325279117,
-0.4828763902,
0.6970281005,
0.1097401977,
0.1796029955,
-0.2441087961,
-0.5753723979,
0.0295332391,
-0.3239176571,
-0.3587330282,
0.4324607253,
0.0305935089,
-0.4530378878,
0.0790634304,
-0.3330584168,
-0.2888730168,
0.134733513,
0.1604663134,
-0.1697379351,
-0.087455526,
0.1069727242,
0.3133409023,
0.31293872,
0.7063491344,
-0.0464950874,
0.8597689867,
0.1836772561,
-0.1637662649,
-0.382602632,
0.1601680517,
0.8712371588,
0.0992159396,
0.9616547823,
0.4869793952,
-0.6029062867,
-0.3780974746,
-0.6121919155,
-0.3644543588,
-0.4655272067,
0.2974726856,
-0.6696680784,
-0.6190942526,
0.9806897044,
0.1489600986,
-0.4385421276,
0.4959564209,
0.5891062021,
0.0205306336,
0.9805691242,
0.2040156424,
0.3569863439,
0.3867664635,
-0.3637847304,
0.1646002233,
-0.9463665485,
-0.4898792207,
-0.127858147,
-0.1216550991,
-0.3447472453,
-0.1992782205,
0.4334254861,
0.2036849707,
-0.1161429957,
0.1972269714,
-0.5877404809,
0.3451254964,
0.1493862718,
0.1732648909,
0.0202970635,
0.0099239899,
-0.0002531377,
0.1382227987,
-0.5873256326,
-0.4942919016,
0.9791172147,
-0.1489815861,
0.3648712635,
-0.0870681778,
0.6607708931,
0.1911811084,
0.2419668734,
-0.3979744315,
0.5728227496,
0.6712417006,
-0.6076606512,
-0.1841631532,
-0.2909639776,
-0.6829397082,
0.3509738147,
0.0208386164,
-0.7971845865,
0.2810411453,
0.2255749702,
-0.4752905965,
0.506685853,
-0.3655256331,
0.7406232357,
-0.091453135,
-0.5248715281,
-0.0218147524,
-0.3495459259,
0.6223323941,
0.0068533546,
-0.3126960993,
0.2409420907,
0.3913340271,
0.6499201655,
-0.3172498345,
0.453505218,
-0.3122894764,
-0.2353028208,
0.5925164819,
0.3355013132,
0.3449561596,
0.3470270634,
0.0948616341,
-0.1441008449,
-0.0461875759,
-0.1385837644,
-0.9592366815,
0.7561981082,
-0.6431602836,
-0.926900208,
-0.393989563,
-1.0777630806,
-0.2472216636,
0.1230919585,
0.7792959213,
0.2085058242,
-0.2119669616,
0.3566746414,
1.1717181206,
-0.3143879175,
0.1305098087,
-0.0647345483,
-0.2114284784,
-0.1528220475,
0.5546888709,
0.1846633106,
0.1628188044,
-0.0841301084,
-0.0123448018,
-0.1363017708,
-0.4159526527,
-0.6312138438,
-0.1548942775,
-0.867233336,
0.1090747416,
-0.9586719275,
-0.4084307253,
-0.4205611646,
-0.1358757317,
-0.1397006959,
-0.0430217944,
-0.3534326255,
-0.2250242978,
0.118547447,
0.5258466005,
0.4110615551,
-0.038403023,
-0.2922796905,
0.6967844367,
0.7762465477,
0.0176395774,
0.2535277903,
-0.5086306334,
0.0655937269,
0.1640811116,
-0.2929855883,
-1.3640719652,
0.1797400415,
-0.2663403153,
0.5695797801,
0.3976022005,
0.0316394717,
0.8438987732,
-0.4148768187,
0.9516942501,
-0.2029019147,
-0.8174145818,
0.4486057162,
-0.4372905791,
0.3907309175,
0.7445247769,
0.2305827439,
-0.3622174263,
-0.6385253668,
-0.5265829563,
-0.4655744135,
0.3247006834,
0.3705857694,
0.4051243663,
-0.2473856658,
0.7942176461,
0.2948089242,
0.34368366,
-0.7553418875,
-0.0922785178,
-0.5308764577,
0.1293176115,
0.1202774942,
-0.3069408238,
-0.2239579111,
-0.4616176486,
0.1418486238,
0.0138462652,
0.5907458663,
0.3821015954,
-0.35372895,
-0.2850408852,
0.0479346626,
0.7685289979,
1.0920784473,
-0.2857081592,
0.4112925828,
0.3637509346,
-0.3339151442,
0.2196196467,
-0.0956932679,
-0.5271826982,
0.2057589293,
0.3824383616,
0.833914876,
0.0322388783,
-0.5225926638,
0.1750357747,
-0.0065161306,
-0.2353422791,
-0.646287024,
0.4443681836,
-0.1668691784,
0.1124759838,
0.6041687727,
0.2797091603,
0.4689411819,
-0.7227280736,
0.3599726856,
0.5988883376,
-0.4809766114,
-0.5453261733,
1.0432866812,
-0.3325524032,
-0.3795368373,
0.8488718867,
-0.1821784228,
-0.5823180676,
0.727696538,
0.7288610935,
1.2152545452,
-0.2955443561,
0.1648097336,
0.3306911588,
0.1891375184,
-0.0210293736,
0.3582342565,
-0.5522420406,
-0.8561273217,
-0.112744756,
-0.7068293095,
-0.0409192406,
0.6237275004,
-0.978743732,
-0.0379464887,
-0.1602042764,
-0.0787788033,
-0.2925364971,
-0.7311109304,
-0.6512953639,
0.2245678455,
0.1151933819,
0.4421450794,
-0.856190145,
0.911207974,
0.6061223149,
-0.3657061458,
-0.3555828929,
0.6195045114,
-0.3966094255,
-0.5148584247,
0.5160599351,
0.4096163213,
-0.204276666,
0.1515520662,
-0.4321191311,
-0.7965884805,
1.0866532326,
0.3119423091,
-0.1567624509,
-0.1437813789,
0.1642766893,
0.7685949802,
-0.1943237633,
-0.3758963346,
0.5664349198,
0.3616454303,
-0.0138726234,
-0.45130983,
0.2889851928,
-0.1972962916,
0.0297991242,
0.2418120056,
-0.2981916964,
0.7997682095,
0.0519526936,
-0.2871855199,
0.1617211699,
0.5559100509,
0.3413181901,
0.4189068973,
0.3933967948,
0.5613308549,
0.5595756173,
-0.0777450651,
1.1878203154,
-0.5106751919,
0.1747670621,
0.9485010505,
-0.3736775219,
0.3893053234,
0.924944818,
0.0886137262,
0.7209502459,
0.4089797735,
0.153809011,
0.8161936402,
0.0611661337,
-0.4076771438,
-0.3170994222,
0.1201963201,
-0.5741534829,
0.1873805523,
0.1727929711,
-0.5758029819,
-0.0365768112,
0.408454299,
-0.350741446,
0.0205167457,
0.1570203155,
0.8133575916,
-0.15437451,
-1.1465219259,
0.7090610266,
-0.4954572916,
0.068554543,
-0.4119903147,
-0.1892387271,
-0.3872116804,
-0.0375073291,
0.0737296864,
-0.4153873622,
0.7873758674,
-0.1573849916,
-0.2251015604,
-0.3490038514,
0.710162282,
-0.3245587349,
-0.2456342876,
0.1293980479,
0.5437893271,
0.0854211301,
-0.2698910832,
-0.1617236584,
0.0419561826,
-0.0228065047,
-0.3019810021,
0.3897450566,
0.5763173103,
0.0712744892,
0.3636606932,
0.2595149279,
-0.0112111103,
0.2642576098,
-0.1577803046,
0.7479123473,
-0.5877444744,
-0.2822929621,
-0.7773703337,
0.3846354187,
-0.1493264586,
-0.4301302135,
0.911861062,
0.6359161735,
0.9614689946,
-0.3164831102,
0.8599258065,
-0.3395291269,
-0.086634621,
-0.464532733,
1.0260434151,
-0.6746718287,
0.1165211052,
-0.0614562668,
-1.2644546032,
0.0217394643,
0.6439043283,
-0.3027769327,
-0.0674340576,
0.8383057117,
0.6470734477,
-0.1645283997,
0.05434018,
0.4231947362,
0.0075802943,
-0.0153968353,
0.3363637924,
1.142899394,
-0.4607879519,
0.3257586658,
-0.4380623996,
0.1905148327,
0.0799167231,
-0.4232611954,
-0.9958580136,
-1.002400279,
-0.1859686077,
-0.5119693875,
0.1250412911,
0.3636662364,
0.3311550021,
-0.8468594551,
-0.1570707709,
-0.6964352727,
-0.0262612775,
-0.3873311877,
-0.3416181803,
0.3860187829,
-0.5975603461,
-0.5002722144,
0.3594109118,
0.1389117986,
0.2961630523,
-0.4449492693,
0.0886015892,
0.0961940438,
-0.0306252129,
0.5115967393,
-0.0160935279,
-0.9172140956,
-0.4483177364,
0.2151139826,
0.1054462269,
-0.0812644809,
1.1661248207,
-0.9503031373,
0.8120708466,
0.665284574,
0.5338069797,
0.4607133567,
0.0687061399,
0.6855630279,
-0.634899199,
0.4120202363,
0.1408623457,
0.3234640658,
0.2182702571,
-0.6412959695,
0.2047851235,
0.3949371576,
-0.4220947027,
-1.1547114849,
0.284365803,
-0.4954160154,
-0.5942730904,
1.0905708075,
0.2318033874,
-0.0465921983,
-0.1979772002,
-0.1262862384,
0.6770330071,
0.4695897102,
1.4058442116,
0.8584593534,
-0.4346165061,
-0.1889604926,
-0.6527486444,
0.8227681518,
0.3779066205,
-0.6142442822,
0.021039553,
0.6001189351,
0.262140274,
0.2448634207,
0.4100869894,
0.1768582612,
0.4422930479,
0.1847795993,
-0.0858274326,
0.0398823768,
-0.4693953693,
-0.1259354651,
0.6518749595,
-0.1450533569,
-0.0297356602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14484v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14484v2
|
Is ChatGPT the Future of Causal Text Mining? A Comprehensive Evaluation and Analysis
| 2024-02-22T12:19:04 | 2024-02-23T11:50:18 |
Takehiro Takayanagi, Masahiro Suzuki, Ryotaro Kobayashi, Hiroki Sakaji, Kiyoshi Izumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Causality is fundamental in human cognition and has drawn attention in
diverse research fields. With growing volumes of textual data, discerning
causalities within text data is crucial, and causal text mining plays a pivotal
role in extracting meaningful patterns. This study conducts comprehensive
evaluations of ChatGPT's causal text mining capabilities. Firstly, we introduce
a benchmark that extends beyond general English datasets, including
domain-specific and non-English datasets. We also provide an evaluation
framework to ensure fair comparisons between ChatGPT and previous approaches.
Finally, our analysis outlines the limitations and future challenges in
employing ChatGPT for causal text mining. Specifically, our analysis reveals
that ChatGPT serves as a good starting point for various datasets. However,
when equipped with a sufficient amount of training data, previous models still
surpass ChatGPT's performance. Additionally, ChatGPT suffers from the tendency
to falsely recognize non-causal sequences as causal sequences. These issues
become even more pronounced with advanced versions of the model, such as GPT-4.
In addition, we highlight the constraints of ChatGPT in handling complex
causality types, including both intra/inter-sentential and implicit causality.
The model also faces challenges with effectively leveraging in-context learning
and domain adaptation. We release our code to support further research and
development in this field.
|
[
0.0894639269,
-0.7973092198,
0.6532417536,
0.457808882,
-0.1841257811,
-0.2902598977,
-0.0238161217,
-0.6270805597,
-0.3094559312,
0.2717793882,
-0.5882721543,
-0.2807436585,
-0.8294504881,
0.0865366384,
-0.5816090107,
1.2077986002,
0.0473120771,
-0.0329591818,
-0.104394719,
0.0359561481,
-1.1234662533,
-0.6441658735,
-1.089577198,
-0.4193934798,
0.4770689607,
0.3012796938,
0.3484512568,
0.170952037,
0.6196730137,
0.2729330361,
0.1853417605,
-0.0607115217,
-0.6870806217,
0.1762674749,
-0.1885355413,
-0.397913754,
-0.1572605222,
0.1345040947,
0.4927769005,
0.6527670026,
-0.0401850864,
-0.1206365004,
0.3251079321,
0.5386609435,
-0.1884026378,
0.5752791762,
-0.629768014,
-0.0475113317,
-0.3303298056,
-0.5414251685,
-0.5211334825,
-0.3767810166,
0.3859056532,
-0.3261511028,
0.3798823357,
0.4033927917,
0.8259453177,
0.3414371312,
-0.9461016655,
-0.3444495797,
-0.7559902072,
0.5290134549,
-0.5068596601,
0.4056539834,
0.3873842657,
0.2980834842,
-0.4974723458,
-0.9158780575,
-0.362426579,
-0.2943020165,
-0.1385775805,
0.5319885612,
-0.1427614689,
-0.2211836278,
0.2574490011,
0.1713400036,
-0.7813270092,
-0.0105988923,
-0.1614459157,
-0.1751357466,
0.2965857387,
0.3089774847,
0.5974810719,
-0.1976797432,
-0.6835371256,
0.2307509631,
-0.8413120508,
-0.2013926506,
0.3153076172,
0.222914204,
-0.0937227234,
0.4056613147,
0.0876089409,
0.4018419981,
-0.310700655,
0.2899672389,
-0.2813977599,
-0.1784899384,
-0.1191046983,
0.1467597336,
0.8638663292,
0.4139578938,
0.1976454705,
-0.3962256312,
0.1379146576,
0.0763946101,
0.1053921059,
-0.857462585,
-0.3811756968,
-0.0432791412,
-0.3516667485,
-0.2578879297,
0.0063561308,
-0.6793659329,
-0.5638429523,
-0.4350511432,
0.3727721274,
-0.5169716477,
-0.0959658921,
0.2309342176,
-0.3040055335,
0.3606748879,
0.3259405196,
-0.6758190393,
0.3677509129,
0.7156140208,
0.9196704626,
-0.1429437846,
-0.4096008241,
-0.3479960561,
0.1610901952,
-0.1765277237,
1.0916609764,
-0.4442127347,
-0.282004416,
-0.0256039202,
-0.0441013165,
-0.4942321777,
-0.0892068893,
1.065510869,
-0.5571161509,
0.4860197008,
-0.4132392406,
-0.7505077124,
-0.2695263326,
0.2522360682,
-0.6473166943,
0.8606976271,
-0.4188184142,
-1.0854095221,
0.6142391562,
-0.220362857,
-0.6465509534,
-0.0026695228,
-0.1860647798,
-0.5844638944,
-0.2401693016,
-0.0955522954,
0.5164441466,
-0.7793424726,
0.7445480227,
-0.3156191409,
-0.4382558465,
0.125548169,
-0.8704926372,
0.6477014422,
-0.155152604,
-0.5420060754,
-0.2155552655,
-0.6525593996,
-0.4561377764,
-0.0203975197,
0.0768733919,
-0.3081977963,
0.5475249887,
0.2415257245,
0.4201539457,
-0.0360095277,
-0.3813359141,
0.0311569124,
-0.0710953847,
0.4186582267,
0.8431399465,
0.4098226428,
0.0518063419,
-0.3024994433,
0.1873318702,
-0.1666449308,
0.2054619044,
-0.1863018572,
-0.843710959,
-0.4945914149,
-0.0929962844,
0.1539950222,
0.7437753081,
-0.5334638953,
0.3497737646,
-0.1998060048,
-0.5709120631,
0.5500955582,
-0.5251907706,
0.4291145802,
0.7440782189,
0.2597439587,
-0.2860829234,
-0.4124952555,
-0.6405747533,
-0.6264844537,
-0.2708041072,
0.0541660115,
0.2476509362,
0.4242116213,
-0.2153425068,
0.9313588738,
-0.6452462673,
-0.415433079,
0.1209499463,
0.4231437147,
0.3260481358,
0.3496239185,
0.1899947822,
-0.9232261181,
-0.3546010852,
0.0923074782,
-0.8268085122,
-0.1943208575,
-0.3869116306,
-0.1566516608,
-0.1970250607,
0.7054433823,
-0.5258634686,
0.2204570025,
0.3393280208,
-0.7445417643,
0.7752316594,
-0.0685222894,
0.3569443822,
-0.8906180263,
0.3073092401,
0.0710649192,
-0.1083853096,
-0.7718690038,
-0.5769786835,
0.0019117874,
-0.3305651546,
0.0263994578,
0.5830904245,
-0.1454886794,
0.3117316961,
-0.1836984009,
0.1351516396,
-0.3468489647,
0.5401166677,
0.0412151366,
0.4802255332,
0.2858481109,
-0.5516926646,
-0.0122528346,
0.2250250578,
-0.2200387716,
0.521081984,
-0.7426046133,
-0.2436375767,
-0.0816374272,
0.391340524,
-1.0525870323,
-0.153788209,
0.2471936345,
-0.4259276986,
0.2944212258,
-0.1632723361,
-0.5627827644,
0.0304472316,
-0.115431942,
0.1686180979,
0.3587757945,
-0.4736293256,
0.2880809903,
0.2482801229,
-0.1349792331,
-0.4197097123,
-0.1621464938,
0.2593681216,
-0.346809417,
-0.4640170932,
0.2114480138,
0.1474175304,
0.132165134,
-0.0277544726,
-0.2079838812,
-0.1124685034,
0.0729073659,
0.385384649,
0.1600015908,
0.2591943741,
0.3921168745,
-0.1100296602,
-0.4508384466,
0.2775140107,
-0.3409193456,
0.4517522752,
0.0598090328,
-0.3349141777,
-0.2046719939,
0.0555129386,
0.2415457517,
-0.1154619753,
0.4589317143,
0.6923102736,
-0.3741007149,
0.0767985806,
-0.4095157981,
-0.1110389531,
-0.3637285531,
0.2866818607,
-0.0197465904,
-0.8216490746,
0.4866186082,
-0.3840930462,
-0.0620722398,
0.6322592497,
0.4346199334,
0.1131810695,
0.7408446074,
0.5231923461,
-0.2991994619,
0.4747308195,
0.2956796587,
0.5378967524,
-0.4619464874,
-0.3168838024,
-0.598557055,
0.2010293752,
-0.8934724927,
-0.1086383387,
0.2712436914,
-0.0571919829,
-0.5027404428,
0.3374403715,
-0.0797371417,
0.323666364,
0.2884405255,
0.2403368652,
0.521530211,
-0.2776170969,
0.2454513162,
-0.0075008911,
-0.6437140703,
-0.4805237353,
0.9517427683,
0.0748086274,
0.4881967902,
0.0513424389,
0.3136309683,
0.368804872,
0.3848049343,
-0.3349255323,
0.3454801142,
-0.0629939362,
-0.6517994404,
-0.2165971994,
-0.4066034555,
-1.0651906729,
0.1958203018,
-0.2135761082,
-0.6901797652,
0.0644389614,
0.0565239415,
0.1593444198,
0.1291463822,
-1.0241420269,
1.0013092756,
0.041149877,
-0.517537415,
-0.0974665508,
-0.650398612,
0.6477652788,
-0.2931637168,
0.1084250659,
-0.1835046411,
0.1253013164,
0.8003354073,
-0.2656880021,
1.1838971376,
-0.0409844853,
-0.0543607734,
0.0324700624,
-0.1569366008,
0.6081703901,
0.3128914535,
0.1360364705,
0.3800393641,
0.0028128198,
-0.3150546253,
-0.4832975268,
0.7957932353,
-0.5472957492,
-0.3294206262,
-0.6872528791,
-0.1182797849,
-0.4754935503,
0.3962552249,
0.2335725725,
0.583664,
-0.6013587713,
-0.2167567462,
0.5446115732,
-0.3859128654,
0.417807281,
0.457521528,
0.2247218341,
-0.1160172522,
1.0459352732,
-0.1760962158,
-0.1208883226,
0.6142163873,
0.3736505508,
-0.2200173736,
-0.2839804888,
-0.0887934715,
-0.0028566499,
-0.4854893982,
-0.3199671507,
-0.6861985326,
-0.0156715475,
-0.0542236604,
-0.0191798899,
-0.1540470272,
-0.2354322821,
-0.0165192429,
0.0867512301,
0.3694711626,
0.686083138,
0.2133758366,
0.3066408932,
-0.64501369,
0.1617121398,
0.3998040557,
0.5076316595,
0.0893755853,
-0.0762608722,
-0.2172927409,
-0.406653285,
-0.3293873668,
-0.852314055,
0.3285823762,
0.2044900507,
0.3179013431,
0.3206151724,
-0.1245700568,
0.5805249214,
-1.1002855301,
0.7910879254,
0.1787192374,
-0.7371321917,
0.3093398213,
-0.6952878237,
0.0042735529,
0.3531768918,
0.4982939065,
-1.0596884489,
-0.3790038526,
-0.8012669086,
-0.8301467896,
0.567566514,
0.6437196732,
-0.2141997516,
-0.1594878733,
0.421410501,
0.2262126058,
-0.1100542322,
-0.5780082941,
-0.162051484,
0.0282215346,
-0.0068673445,
-0.2418030947,
-0.2111539394,
0.2040673196,
0.0697027743,
0.7942656875,
0.1870886683,
0.5213041306,
0.2114844769,
-0.1013445854,
0.3149604797,
0.1285883337,
0.2864595354,
0.4586370587,
-0.2690367103,
-0.0880499035,
0.1733159721,
-0.689977169,
0.019878583,
0.4577527344,
-0.0294581354,
-0.0980389118,
0.8272916079,
0.5945051908,
0.7179188132,
-0.5222588181,
0.7340134382,
-0.3343322873,
0.1084310859,
-0.2882608771,
-0.2335815728,
-0.2454919517,
0.2388760895,
0.2353324443,
0.1007306427,
0.5178120732,
-0.3145141304,
0.2274049371,
0.3541108072,
-0.5571553111,
-0.3673333526,
0.8577564955,
0.1030356511,
0.2474019974,
0.4901798069,
0.0502021424,
-0.5992644429,
0.6454731822,
0.4798825383,
0.9895612597,
-0.1852404624,
0.0542884804,
0.4267567396,
0.4381523728,
-0.2689062059,
-0.1366278678,
0.0377342179,
-0.6904539466,
-0.5231689811,
-0.2751656771,
-0.5700874925,
-0.2316131145,
-0.2907633781,
0.5784563422,
-0.0037845057,
0.0774109215,
-0.0944666788,
-0.006496463,
-0.5235750675,
0.27141276,
-0.2687457204,
0.4181545675,
-0.9607322812,
0.6762827635,
0.3053166568,
-0.3474295735,
-0.5464961529,
0.120988816,
0.1117769852,
-0.553406477,
0.55443573,
0.3149235845,
0.0145287886,
-0.0447537079,
-0.3305911124,
-0.5243195295,
1.1598508358,
0.1833108813,
-0.4481230974,
0.0949877053,
0.1013474762,
0.5014426708,
0.3574187458,
0.5895825028,
0.5014982224,
0.385001719,
-0.0739165395,
-0.5754811764,
0.2361412495,
-0.1756349355,
-0.03941416,
0.3757703304,
-0.5943904519,
0.6374980807,
0.3402356207,
-0.3459380269,
-0.3054382205,
0.398549974,
-0.0012087789,
0.3496066034,
0.2793507576,
0.4161550105,
0.8025507331,
-0.2281642556,
1.1514194012,
-0.2676552236,
0.5419635177,
1.042794466,
-0.3277858198,
0.4383674264,
0.2683316171,
-0.1855268925,
0.3183725178,
0.6506210566,
0.2035746425,
0.4183804393,
-0.0905852243,
-0.3891483545,
-0.1367778629,
0.1787225455,
-0.3447809815,
0.2059453577,
0.1976947188,
-0.0041956613,
-0.4485360086,
-0.1684795916,
0.1630062461,
-0.2452612668,
-0.0258667096,
0.6955639124,
0.1585806906,
-0.5343748927,
-0.0453793667,
-0.0242206939,
0.4438184798,
-0.7435853481,
-0.1897198856,
-0.3499365747,
0.2175722271,
-0.112439923,
-0.4855183363,
0.2737470865,
-0.1025822014,
0.0859589353,
-0.2108621895,
1.1162911654,
-0.1947042495,
-0.190002948,
0.1773204207,
0.3428549767,
-0.0005245907,
-0.3944893181,
-0.4028275609,
-0.3247826099,
-0.1347389668,
-0.1373977661,
0.3091031611,
0.7791262269,
-0.3864181042,
0.4410729706,
0.7718446255,
-0.2283623964,
-0.1168175638,
0.1332068145,
0.7707843184,
-0.9071688056,
-0.4131806493,
-1.1093965769,
0.3191598654,
-0.2034075558,
-0.3816376626,
1.0446407795,
0.5522407889,
0.4968632162,
0.010790389,
0.6652508378,
-0.1362710893,
0.2179245353,
-0.6315098405,
0.6505179405,
-0.1087945104,
0.222869873,
-0.6612088084,
-0.8243392706,
-0.6456207633,
0.2179268152,
-0.5193231106,
-0.1362638026,
1.0883985758,
0.4191204607,
0.0421469733,
0.6487584114,
0.1939299107,
0.1651265025,
0.6939464211,
0.5153037906,
0.9187498689,
-0.721298337,
0.5805478096,
0.116129905,
-0.5473217368,
0.0178478118,
-1.0990457535,
-0.8572959304,
-0.8776230812,
-0.2394234687,
-0.0065491018,
0.2687918544,
0.347317934,
0.419505477,
-0.5180652738,
-0.0535610393,
-0.5221146941,
0.2498523444,
-0.2669401169,
-0.2335009277,
0.6556004882,
-0.7063425183,
-0.4622933865,
0.0825918093,
0.3637476265,
-0.2411063313,
0.3158191741,
0.1739411056,
-0.2724092007,
-0.066092141,
1.0642143488,
0.2577806711,
0.0190013666,
-0.3117524683,
-0.2503208518,
0.1357108504,
-0.2330721766,
1.1824644804,
-0.5259955525,
0.2257750034,
0.3095916212,
0.5735820532,
0.7036253214,
-0.2373991907,
0.6524728537,
-0.5396656394,
0.1482194066,
-0.0040804092,
0.4228074849,
0.0754618645,
-0.4682728052,
0.6177669168,
0.4251885116,
-0.9295284152,
-0.4283581674,
0.0667703897,
-0.9814779758,
-0.1252925545,
1.0879004002,
0.0739902407,
0.0937675536,
-0.4601387084,
-0.4920775592,
0.2754013538,
-0.2526580989,
0.759457767,
0.76085639,
-0.3116897345,
0.1347941607,
-0.8702890873,
0.5551230907,
0.2370954901,
-0.9194726348,
0.2213548273,
0.5970315337,
0.0857911184,
-0.4102885127,
0.7247904539,
-0.3413143456,
0.1054051295,
-0.1005341634,
-0.0713546053,
0.4216146767,
-0.123940669,
-0.222883895,
0.0278362017,
-0.0500509739,
0.1121280566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14474v1
|
Data Science with LLMs and Interpretable Models
| 2024-02-22T12:04:15 | 2024-02-22T12:04:15 |
Sebastian Bordt, Ben Lengerich, Harsha Nori, Rich Caruana
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent years have seen important advances in the building of interpretable
models, machine learning models that are designed to be easily understood by
humans. In this work, we show that large language models (LLMs) are remarkably
good at working with interpretable models, too. In particular, we show that
LLMs can describe, interpret, and debug Generalized Additive Models (GAMs).
Combining the flexibility of LLMs with the breadth of statistical patterns
accurately described by GAMs enables dataset summarization, question answering,
and model critique. LLMs can also improve the interaction between domain
experts and interpretable models, and generate hypotheses about the underlying
phenomenon. We release \url{https://github.com/interpretml/TalkToEBM} as an
open-source LLM-GAM interface.
|
[
-0.0594823137,
-1.181153059,
1.0331517458,
0.2306257635,
-0.2006062716,
0.152361095,
-0.3325197697,
-0.7252501845,
0.0036895152,
0.5021836162,
-0.3093769252,
-0.6801225543,
-0.6678543687,
-0.0636296794,
-0.7083376646,
0.7398989201,
0.1017315313,
0.353153497,
-0.5498813391,
-0.0897750407,
-0.2909504175,
-0.6294693947,
-0.7395358086,
-0.668913126,
0.4501186013,
0.2790780067,
1.0766479969,
0.8640730381,
0.5804157257,
0.2838730216,
-0.21925129,
0.1825235933,
-0.2971957326,
0.232221514,
-0.2401949614,
-0.6270095706,
-1.0605375767,
-0.1202749312,
0.5957954526,
1.0955129862,
-0.1606468409,
0.1923323274,
0.1298348159,
0.4442296624,
-0.1076302007,
0.6262869239,
-0.5346898437,
-0.3087182343,
-0.0959730595,
-0.201883927,
-0.5436503887,
-0.2687568665,
0.0500975549,
-0.5074291825,
0.3970031738,
-0.0206285752,
0.512488246,
0.2020855844,
-0.4701974988,
-0.578463316,
-0.8882219195,
0.8327758312,
-0.6115958095,
0.5050779581,
0.3268793523,
0.3521625996,
-0.5401717424,
-0.8244680762,
-0.5666878223,
-0.1416953504,
-0.2395963818,
-0.1171061397,
-0.2634195983,
0.1225963682,
0.1477238834,
0.6016077399,
-0.6313216686,
0.3344976902,
-0.2569352388,
-0.1028526425,
0.7168474197,
0.6735689044,
0.3918694258,
0.0947555974,
-0.011616407,
0.4646123946,
-0.8306062818,
-0.3601372242,
0.2261005938,
0.4647501111,
-0.1693171561,
0.5293714404,
-0.1727364063,
1.0757246017,
-0.3763362765,
0.2642690837,
0.0206367522,
-0.1956895739,
-0.4673203826,
-0.3654865324,
0.3253506422,
0.1818826646,
0.3102082312,
-0.3549455702,
0.1464575827,
-0.088842839,
0.0594349951,
-0.823998034,
-0.4289905131,
0.3527189195,
-0.624534905,
-0.2812024355,
-0.1096692532,
-0.7833135128,
-0.6460619569,
-0.6687688828,
0.451964736,
-0.0338617228,
-0.1863451004,
0.5299368501,
-0.0192234125,
0.2106820345,
0.422446996,
-0.8597463965,
0.5399686098,
0.7574266791,
1.0850951672,
-0.2200303674,
0.0041594426,
-0.4491282701,
0.2189118862,
-0.4486479759,
0.6989343166,
-0.6893057227,
-0.5551372766,
-0.2619730234,
0.1385084242,
0.0637556389,
-0.5031828284,
0.4166955054,
-0.7178546786,
0.1455240846,
-0.0917155594,
-0.8325557113,
-0.3842230141,
0.0456802845,
-0.6213207841,
0.567333281,
0.0632225797,
-0.3883652091,
0.1359954029,
-0.8949255347,
-0.3094934523,
0.1229035407,
-0.0730891377,
-0.4021769166,
0.2743881941,
0.0808760449,
0.6416124701,
-0.3821775615,
0.3936859667,
-0.7425653934,
-0.1050645262,
0.4573131502,
-0.3560003936,
0.559845984,
0.5274413228,
0.1399098635,
0.2922230363,
-0.967330873,
0.0958093107,
0.2398507148,
-0.2198457569,
-0.2107256353,
0.2993094921,
-0.183083266,
-0.0488499589,
0.0442808717,
-0.0898568183,
0.3470264971,
-0.1741053909,
0.6123197675,
0.7606128454,
-0.1033248976,
0.4566017389,
0.0099716308,
0.6092528701,
-0.0482955575,
-0.148770541,
-0.1173939705,
-0.4901966751,
-0.6965514421,
-0.5892747641,
0.2167336792,
0.468011409,
-0.6361531019,
0.2648678124,
-0.3775574863,
-0.4592601061,
-0.273609221,
0.2157328427,
-0.1058240682,
0.6550756693,
0.3799692392,
-0.0481026173,
-0.6558895111,
-0.8576181531,
-0.3108111918,
-0.0662271231,
-0.3573870361,
0.2438670993,
0.3730362356,
-0.4659019411,
0.8590585589,
-1.0130323172,
0.0839387625,
-0.3535072803,
0.1511286795,
0.3512991965,
0.0808210149,
0.4677727818,
-0.5960159898,
-0.4028164744,
-0.0674585402,
-0.8913045526,
-0.2039214224,
0.1509049386,
-0.0285757147,
-0.0845834464,
0.4705382884,
-0.4623591602,
0.2861135304,
0.3710586429,
-0.6317992806,
0.5040466785,
-0.3250638545,
-0.0087039731,
-0.9139384031,
0.0506311022,
-0.0014120725,
-0.469389528,
-0.9305587411,
-0.1478265226,
0.0311732087,
-0.1858441979,
-0.2078246623,
0.9094125032,
-0.5480541587,
-0.4078468084,
-0.498350054,
-0.2733641863,
0.0044447598,
-0.0358116552,
0.1848719716,
0.7585626245,
0.995002389,
-0.8379632235,
0.4887063205,
0.3719243109,
-0.5895578265,
0.3885408044,
-0.8616997004,
0.1458554715,
-0.1057825834,
0.177411899,
-0.7866595387,
-0.6892440319,
0.2195820063,
-0.3531409502,
0.2963299155,
-0.0226083342,
-0.4806916714,
-0.1841702759,
-0.0522815883,
0.0404025726,
0.3912396133,
-0.7821249366,
0.6123151779,
0.4685977101,
-0.5364434123,
-0.1731956005,
-0.7326905131,
0.2259332985,
-0.5226935744,
-0.6341797113,
0.0118895983,
-0.2351732105,
-0.5055795312,
0.120940268,
0.10216593,
-0.3248046935,
0.3862916231,
0.107919015,
0.5502583385,
-0.1299203783,
0.4678173661,
-0.2378939837,
-0.1513021886,
0.1923324317,
-0.0448125415,
0.4082295597,
-0.2482500374,
-0.345796138,
0.0262984373,
0.2252421975,
0.5030362606,
0.2314434201,
0.8411083817,
0.3708368838,
-0.2744539678,
-0.2655285597,
0.0301173571,
-0.1164236963,
-0.5020675063,
0.4445013702,
-0.4219317436,
-0.8479514122,
0.7978637218,
-0.0159635693,
-0.2205797583,
0.3517917991,
0.6513577104,
0.0267785005,
1.4651335478,
0.7250705361,
-0.0886174068,
0.2840420306,
-0.0861254558,
0.1419659406,
-0.544637382,
-0.1557625085,
-0.4742254913,
-0.0728776827,
-0.3801015615,
-0.3928090036,
0.1561403573,
0.0928392634,
-0.1051552147,
-0.189497143,
-0.3749288321,
0.6792907119,
0.1248489097,
0.081316717,
0.474804163,
0.0362866893,
0.4567681253,
0.1471016109,
-0.4485795796,
-0.7913390398,
1.2027186155,
0.5855593681,
1.2812191248,
0.1728923917,
0.2142226845,
0.5073571801,
0.438859731,
-0.9352740645,
0.5224050879,
-0.1261551231,
-0.5990778208,
-0.1045206711,
-0.6085842848,
-1.0394296646,
0.2329016924,
-0.0853892863,
-0.7394982576,
0.179605782,
0.4197602868,
-0.0640054569,
0.2794026136,
-0.8011089563,
0.5908815861,
-0.3089089096,
-0.2136103064,
-0.3298683763,
-0.4071595371,
0.4377318025,
-0.0805341974,
0.5472390652,
-0.0968185067,
-0.2129763216,
0.496791929,
-0.2380788475,
0.8348549008,
-0.0592703484,
-0.3239897192,
0.255421102,
0.0572966076,
0.5050989985,
0.050731767,
-0.3623518348,
0.3626449704,
-0.2452649623,
-0.603297472,
-0.789108932,
0.7938554287,
-0.5331954956,
-0.6690699458,
-0.3761615753,
-0.8399550915,
-0.3247400224,
0.0049065682,
-0.1486647129,
0.4049908519,
-0.2552576661,
0.0607973784,
0.6972352862,
-0.1620486528,
0.1381008029,
0.7749708891,
-0.5108307004,
-0.0814603269,
0.8869443536,
0.0746636689,
0.5156030655,
-0.0317469724,
0.1457102895,
-0.3430208862,
-0.9135315418,
-0.3008138239,
0.129339397,
-0.815997541,
-0.0068350537,
-0.518920362,
-0.1818754226,
-0.2136461288,
-0.0249890033,
0.1608001739,
-0.6224617362,
-0.4706093669,
-0.3980341852,
0.4396469891,
1.0714204311,
-0.3543176651,
0.3820121288,
-0.6733747125,
0.4692511559,
0.3779670894,
0.6350749135,
0.0552131683,
-0.4997828007,
-0.4036331177,
0.0678080022,
-0.118453458,
-0.7685109973,
0.3908877671,
0.1985956132,
0.6958811283,
0.3830852509,
-0.4121778309,
0.6202382445,
-0.2887408435,
0.7255067229,
-0.0359356925,
-0.9630986452,
0.3861033916,
-0.3982574344,
0.1658543646,
-0.0291139409,
0.4851020873,
-0.3697890043,
-0.3143446743,
-0.3857184649,
-0.7436119914,
0.636826992,
-0.072978735,
0.1239574179,
-0.0350943096,
0.30625844,
0.4435712397,
0.1560270339,
-0.4429088533,
-0.3407696187,
0.0152337691,
-0.3892404437,
-0.4695753455,
-0.4731216133,
-0.0341493227,
-0.2665902078,
0.6815783381,
-0.1566153914,
0.2948937714,
-0.197852239,
-0.3784655035,
-0.0025070519,
0.4676044583,
0.5082457066,
1.0351915359,
-0.3791682422,
0.3899298012,
0.2731579542,
-0.4046804309,
0.1495922208,
0.0543076657,
-0.0501105152,
-0.0491826721,
0.4718848765,
0.7988650799,
-0.2131607831,
-0.5504519939,
-0.1081578806,
-0.0748985186,
-0.2695045471,
-0.016928589,
0.3051423728,
0.445804745,
0.1678869277,
0.3902136087,
-0.3905840516,
0.172676757,
-0.7404676676,
-0.007821776,
0.5382360816,
-0.2449479252,
-0.5262672901,
0.6861492991,
0.1939321905,
-0.0944763348,
0.4293548167,
-0.0120524773,
-0.3909832537,
0.6547068357,
0.5788603425,
0.6716670394,
-0.1106290892,
0.0933526978,
0.0250445865,
0.0779754668,
0.0372619405,
0.4993991256,
0.2100231797,
-0.6689614654,
-0.6794909239,
-0.5212970376,
-0.7969956398,
0.4963849485,
-0.7714336514,
0.2210933864,
-0.0526168793,
0.1650144905,
0.5435761809,
-0.1044884697,
-0.6390955448,
0.2807379663,
0.0070120264,
0.7467926741,
-1.0416511297,
0.8442795277,
0.8068907857,
-0.2297916114,
-0.4792027771,
-0.3389698863,
0.0352216512,
-0.9192745686,
0.6791182756,
-0.1551849544,
0.0054561794,
0.1349027902,
-0.9821230173,
-0.8259637356,
0.8997926712,
0.4976379275,
-0.3767334223,
0.247734502,
0.2711893022,
0.7153844833,
-0.4012627006,
0.2375564426,
0.636184752,
0.570931375,
0.0023161068,
-0.5401180387,
0.0401089378,
0.0426686779,
-0.299969852,
0.2908559442,
-0.231969282,
0.8551840782,
-0.2631050646,
-0.2760046422,
0.0002306856,
0.7310628295,
-0.0895915329,
0.5345370173,
0.3121111989,
0.3989957869,
1.0168011189,
-0.022126969,
1.0347344875,
-0.0025795423,
0.3627451062,
1.3728457689,
-0.2637838423,
0.5078973174,
0.1840003431,
-0.4441085458,
0.4725128412,
0.634020865,
-0.0545224659,
0.3093301654,
0.1984433085,
-0.2750709951,
-0.5381762385,
0.1798355579,
-0.3474865556,
0.235170722,
0.7385205626,
-0.4091688991,
-0.306475848,
-0.0026022855,
-0.1138805225,
-0.0188504439,
-0.6045209765,
0.6543389559,
0.2891666889,
-0.0000505656,
0.2883985639,
-0.0871981829,
0.3805739582,
-0.6071298718,
-0.1505924016,
-0.1114337593,
0.2526217103,
-0.5016838312,
-1.1013835669,
0.7036293149,
0.1137575358,
-0.5363480449,
-0.1103463396,
1.0467031002,
-0.5345149636,
-0.6266658902,
0.2223951817,
0.73255229,
0.4142179787,
0.0954687744,
-0.4383814931,
-0.1039765477,
-0.1490829587,
-0.2798547447,
0.4814333916,
0.1491348147,
-0.3069480062,
1.1331527233,
0.6818156242,
0.2730726302,
-0.171801731,
0.1366377473,
0.7361512184,
-0.8680129051,
-0.3002826571,
-1.0901379585,
0.3541782498,
-0.0331590883,
0.440734446,
0.9382246137,
0.6089987755,
0.3666541874,
-0.19075194,
0.9498441219,
0.0311471354,
0.8559558392,
-0.5854792595,
0.6427636743,
-0.3511402011,
0.4524371028,
0.1278186142,
-0.6888865232,
-0.4447741807,
0.2067122757,
-0.4776391089,
-0.0957227796,
0.3693847358,
0.7022964954,
-0.2277395725,
-0.0049947863,
0.361199677,
0.314890027,
0.5624183416,
0.0836694986,
1.0415402651,
0.1265490651,
0.4724296927,
0.2714034617,
-0.162727192,
-0.1782504171,
-1.0217627287,
-0.8417671919,
-0.1998727471,
-0.2764647007,
-0.1730943024,
-0.0817496032,
0.4881969392,
0.563378334,
-0.951636672,
-0.2148857117,
-0.1150672138,
0.5913041234,
0.0107499892,
-0.3031487763,
0.3866103888,
-0.2744801939,
-0.8238276243,
0.5167704225,
0.0883570313,
0.2845935822,
-0.1984422356,
-0.2450486273,
0.1312125027,
0.3412510157,
0.774344027,
0.1799768806,
-0.4795098603,
-0.4012897313,
0.0239069834,
0.0992197096,
-0.0658253208,
0.7093186378,
-0.5575309992,
0.5699295402,
0.5676946044,
0.5043336153,
0.4683171809,
0.1593451947,
0.8796133995,
-0.3854420185,
0.0279141925,
-0.059759628,
0.433799237,
0.3604438603,
-0.3495426178,
0.8381738067,
-0.0582029633,
-0.7010548115,
-0.899952054,
0.2888894975,
-0.8028582931,
-0.524699986,
1.1759728193,
-0.0862060711,
-0.0331415758,
-0.307574749,
0.0437187664,
0.0617718399,
-0.0489483625,
0.6889674067,
0.9156393409,
-0.4946819246,
0.1025948897,
-0.7538494468,
0.3990309536,
0.1808936745,
-1.1587097645,
0.1455265135,
0.6919658184,
0.5029605627,
-0.2480773777,
0.3148808777,
0.0843619704,
0.0602163933,
-0.1857559085,
0.0007714417,
-0.3918552101,
-0.1404215842,
-0.6987748146,
-0.1112953871,
0.3492961228,
-0.1029293388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14890v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14890v2
|
Vygotsky Distance: Measure for Benchmark Task Similarity
| 2024-02-22T12:00:32 | 2024-02-26T12:09:43 |
Maxim K. Surkov, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T01, 97P80, 97C30, 68Q32, H.1.1; I.2.4; I.2.6; F.2.0
|
Evaluation plays a significant role in modern natural language processing.
Most modern NLP benchmarks consist of arbitrary sets of tasks that neither
guarantee any generalization potential for the model once applied outside the
test set nor try to minimize the resource consumption needed for model
evaluation. This paper presents a theoretical instrument and a practical
algorithm to calculate similarity between benchmark tasks, we call this
similarity measure "Vygotsky distance". The core idea of this similarity
measure is that it is based on relative performance of the "students" on a
given task, rather that on the properties of the task itself. If two tasks are
close to each other in terms of Vygotsky distance the models tend to have
similar relative performance on them. Thus knowing Vygotsky distance between
tasks one can significantly reduce the number of evaluation tasks while
maintaining a high validation quality. Experiments on various benchmarks,
including GLUE, SuperGLUE, CLUE, and RussianSuperGLUE, demonstrate that a vast
majority of NLP benchmarks could be at least 40% smaller in terms of the tasks
included. Most importantly, Vygotsky distance could also be used for the
validation of new tasks thus increasing the generalization potential of the
future NLP models.
|
[
-0.2127180994,
-0.5643479228,
0.5392412543,
0.1437387615,
0.0887315124,
-0.1265508682,
-0.5227001309,
-0.7662053108,
0.050856337,
-0.0005132997,
-0.4819693565,
-0.2894539833,
-0.4840945601,
-0.1932684481,
-0.396468848,
0.8539143801,
-0.0024422668,
-0.0551164076,
-0.8078194857,
-0.1221464723,
-0.4193975031,
-0.1329605579,
-0.1625186205,
-0.5709306598,
0.4232738018,
0.0394251831,
0.5129020214,
0.7280237079,
0.6970262527,
0.3871968985,
-0.1234772205,
-0.1615604758,
-0.4484367669,
0.119662337,
-0.4150519669,
-0.9282586575,
-0.010936508,
0.1094567254,
0.608332634,
0.7180758715,
-0.1228898317,
0.5668503642,
0.0898300931,
0.5760865211,
-0.6611801386,
0.0148980347,
-0.4876511395,
0.1792615056,
-0.3387039602,
0.1565220058,
0.0870776847,
-0.2754338384,
0.2378452718,
-0.6039799452,
0.2781815529,
-0.1439761221,
1.1361202002,
-0.0491734669,
0.0664742589,
-0.0808366686,
-0.5506657362,
1.0794267654,
-0.5723375082,
0.4254684746,
0.2440537661,
0.2868591249,
-0.108837232,
-0.706605196,
-0.6396742463,
-0.5453668833,
-0.0267657917,
0.0147989299,
-0.2908635736,
-0.1376221776,
0.5919739604,
0.3480200171,
-0.6194018126,
-0.0918818861,
-0.5300006866,
0.1162437499,
0.3657523692,
0.3952595294,
0.1821274161,
-0.1443547159,
-0.5412735343,
-0.0987895206,
-0.2934829891,
0.256473124,
0.44535923,
-0.0754957125,
0.2644801438,
0.2728319168,
-0.8437279463,
0.7561922669,
-0.1324540526,
-0.5067908764,
0.2865979671,
-0.308054477,
-0.1507838219,
-0.2078065872,
0.6769471169,
0.824154079,
0.4168570638,
-0.322776407,
-0.0434627272,
0.3405243158,
0.4861963391,
-0.6461606026,
-0.2776944041,
-0.203679204,
-0.75566113,
-0.1287852377,
-0.3283588588,
-0.4835087657,
0.0409757383,
-0.6787945032,
0.7165358067,
-0.3302758336,
-0.2782132924,
-0.0285841208,
-0.0765867233,
0.0575394109,
0.0715927556,
-0.8067456484,
1.0226507187,
1.0569210052,
0.9372308254,
-0.4364060462,
-0.5344519019,
-0.3940555453,
-0.2607225478,
-0.1067269892,
0.7936107516,
-0.6531016231,
-0.2108549178,
-0.1956277341,
-0.259854883,
-0.0715292171,
-0.7958185673,
0.356585294,
-0.2280224115,
0.0221509226,
-0.2781603634,
-0.624753058,
-0.2341876924,
0.346329391,
-0.4243474305,
1.3935792446,
0.3820971549,
-0.679107368,
0.5544964075,
-0.4045739472,
-0.2785821259,
0.2061789483,
0.1563912779,
-0.0997557342,
0.3849263489,
-0.0831550285,
0.3468687534,
-0.5822148323,
-0.0229172762,
-0.3996317089,
-0.5328097939,
-0.0328585617,
-0.1625934243,
0.402146101,
0.0325592458,
-0.2908813655,
0.1851266921,
-0.7623184323,
0.6058002114,
-0.1083664075,
-0.2523089647,
-0.9216822982,
-0.1288921386,
0.2091242373,
0.265091002,
0.4211301208,
-0.4027915001,
0.2482037246,
-0.4058399498,
0.1536868513,
0.5544531941,
-0.2927671969,
0.316862464,
-0.6415694952,
0.5051801801,
-0.5615131259,
0.1564869434,
0.3757470846,
-0.5063174963,
-0.4892950356,
0.0608894676,
0.6668313146,
0.4844512343,
-0.2541415989,
0.1013705954,
-0.4410067797,
-0.9370440841,
-0.6619398594,
0.2764022946,
0.7417141795,
0.5809881687,
0.2709350884,
-0.6410495639,
-0.410463661,
-0.9609205723,
-0.5868447423,
-0.0436148234,
-0.285464406,
-0.2178045362,
0.5059961677,
0.2105157077,
0.7609360814,
-0.6196050644,
-0.1995434165,
0.2571851015,
0.0325539224,
0.4778603911,
0.6136091352,
0.5488069654,
-0.6884414554,
-0.7225815654,
-0.038818974,
-0.4022015333,
-0.2996355593,
0.1095548645,
0.0533837005,
-0.224487856,
0.635594666,
-0.6176674366,
0.3425398767,
0.4808877707,
-0.0397036336,
1.018137455,
-0.3070218563,
0.2203370035,
-0.8560886383,
0.1616859883,
0.2039459199,
-0.2160540521,
-0.5878661871,
0.3664730787,
-0.1476664692,
0.3534273803,
-0.3114940226,
0.5793024302,
-0.2057144642,
-0.0735133439,
-0.1556839943,
0.3974739313,
-0.3123018146,
0.2706778049,
0.0372925028,
0.4797049463,
0.5732712746,
-0.5101748705,
0.52356112,
-0.0912080258,
-0.5735149384,
1.3061810732,
-0.6542611122,
0.0411458127,
0.3825446069,
-0.2772006392,
-0.8751884699,
0.1998334527,
-0.2015602142,
-0.5013257861,
0.0329721607,
-0.0957626775,
-0.463407129,
-0.3589483202,
-0.3346880674,
0.2900636196,
0.6962076426,
-0.4585081339,
0.1394510418,
0.193431899,
0.0014560634,
-0.592260778,
-0.4565224946,
-0.1489027739,
-0.4400947094,
-0.7548440695,
0.738206625,
-0.2695259154,
-0.4910697639,
0.2777104676,
-0.5105376244,
-0.1691040844,
0.0888235867,
0.4920986295,
-0.1293992102,
-0.3550610244,
0.5152148008,
-0.414388895,
-0.2669183612,
0.2890675366,
-0.333871454,
0.4087931812,
-0.21623303,
-0.3314470053,
-0.1381818801,
0.2629742026,
0.1110569537,
-0.0705769137,
0.5955039859,
0.9032284021,
-0.6732795238,
-0.275631249,
-0.7043681741,
-0.020366881,
-0.4860404432,
0.4643440247,
-0.6319043636,
-0.6067252159,
0.2433091998,
-0.1257002354,
-0.2480825633,
0.3015572727,
0.5551108718,
-0.0342955999,
0.537686646,
0.5675468445,
-0.1497020721,
0.4330436289,
-0.0182953458,
0.2446563542,
-0.8131266236,
-0.2311529964,
-0.7519444823,
-0.5650833249,
-0.6201554537,
-0.552315712,
0.0237876903,
0.3365812302,
0.2207646668,
0.6896978021,
-0.5256752372,
0.7571213841,
0.9841448665,
-0.1400959045,
0.139413625,
-0.1269393712,
-0.2338343859,
-0.4307500422,
-0.382558763,
-0.3730627596,
0.9599770904,
0.0041930722,
0.285959959,
-0.1348565072,
0.904999733,
0.1947979629,
0.1298310161,
-0.8447096348,
0.7346937656,
0.0530529246,
-0.343200326,
-0.2745095789,
-0.3063775301,
-0.9450933933,
0.2725574672,
-0.3587125242,
-1.1824625731,
-0.4445350766,
-0.2550162077,
-0.0664629564,
0.1978604198,
-0.5065041184,
0.8670827746,
0.2710978687,
-0.596385181,
-0.4944674373,
-0.4210624099,
0.0954185203,
0.1281048357,
0.011410011,
-0.1798600554,
0.0841693059,
1.0934230089,
-0.4217553735,
0.1709835082,
-0.1337936819,
0.2227474451,
0.2685726285,
0.2419874519,
0.2157840729,
-0.0947176293,
-0.1105754822,
0.0149958143,
0.3342844546,
-0.4835256934,
-0.472214967,
1.2312266827,
-0.3781427443,
-0.5244380236,
-0.2021256387,
-0.6320343614,
-0.336297214,
0.348080039,
0.0238787923,
0.1385094374,
-0.0973255858,
0.2682937682,
0.3395567536,
0.2543956935,
0.5693733692,
0.5203513503,
0.033595603,
0.0554052666,
0.8550079465,
0.2361272722,
0.2457995415,
0.6171070337,
0.4082350135,
-0.3528862,
-0.6393870115,
0.2237200886,
0.0750270411,
-0.7392272949,
-0.1437356025,
-0.4980918765,
0.153081432,
-0.2178705782,
-0.2476054281,
-0.4493184388,
-0.3911296427,
0.1502999812,
0.0071379342,
0.2763643265,
0.8050449491,
-0.3721579611,
0.1510476619,
-0.5832366943,
0.463557303,
0.7584012151,
0.5644721985,
-0.0985532328,
-0.3761711419,
-0.2610591948,
-0.2426346093,
-0.2756420672,
-0.548618257,
0.2874163687,
0.0182027929,
0.6372548342,
0.060264241,
-0.1559165269,
1.0087641478,
-0.5163165331,
0.7736542821,
0.4460106492,
-1.1853704453,
0.2427548766,
-0.2835917771,
0.281075567,
0.5939786434,
0.4452530742,
-0.7120227814,
-0.0153372586,
-0.7864998579,
-0.6709529161,
0.3964167833,
0.3406997323,
-0.0849121958,
0.0692236051,
0.1489630789,
0.0427163802,
0.1992265284,
-0.6840379238,
-0.1492638141,
0.33766976,
-0.14415209,
-0.0071650976,
0.1029344499,
-0.0180478469,
-0.1989972293,
0.4468832612,
-0.0336750746,
0.319004178,
0.1030514017,
-0.1029182896,
-0.1671592146,
0.2358122468,
0.4224525094,
0.7878308892,
-0.2150612473,
0.0447384976,
0.7062135935,
-0.5959329009,
0.0590291731,
0.1336428523,
0.3499080539,
0.1252420545,
0.6247618198,
0.2681555748,
0.1145390198,
-0.5559532642,
0.603895545,
0.0595125817,
-0.2518741488,
-0.0267405342,
0.2478284538,
0.4215990603,
0.5619729757,
0.0834438875,
0.0513195843,
0.278026253,
-0.4199895859,
0.3515188098,
0.2211525589,
-0.7598202825,
-0.3818302155,
0.4827768505,
-0.1333654374,
-0.8296562433,
0.4357881546,
-0.2408186197,
-0.4578728378,
0.7974944711,
0.5578523278,
0.6237477064,
-0.3879024982,
0.0906475931,
0.570763588,
0.2170279473,
-0.4399166107,
0.1025228351,
-0.1381983012,
-0.1012638584,
-0.3124651313,
-0.8370629549,
-0.1846143603,
0.2848963439,
-0.8349410295,
0.3053962588,
-0.3600147665,
0.022582911,
0.0309104659,
0.3225929737,
-0.9417532682,
0.5922442675,
0.0530907698,
0.5813593864,
-0.8202171922,
0.765648365,
0.5461756587,
-0.0086852489,
-0.687409997,
-0.0859923661,
0.0019592408,
-0.6537003517,
0.7713049054,
0.4486832917,
0.0728395805,
-0.6289680004,
-0.1168863326,
-0.8270562887,
0.9261248708,
0.1288953125,
-0.8902797699,
-0.1749149412,
0.0775824189,
1.0157206059,
-0.1960402727,
0.4597854316,
0.6104359627,
0.2757190764,
-0.5701286793,
-1.4999241829,
0.1919506937,
-0.4840239584,
0.1688494831,
0.4382347465,
-0.47967574,
0.9616001248,
-0.0560980067,
0.0709026679,
0.0706163496,
0.3034136593,
0.0266265254,
0.2939142883,
0.5574883223,
0.7395570278,
0.5194406509,
-0.1612906307,
0.8092597127,
-0.0580138974,
0.6114207506,
1.4007097483,
-0.1070867702,
0.8909724951,
0.6756971478,
-0.6844602823,
0.2426816374,
0.0642958879,
-0.1976578534,
0.4985589385,
0.8918640614,
-0.0215581711,
-0.1782716215,
-0.2791366875,
-0.3784722686,
0.5056898594,
0.1937754899,
-0.1753968596,
-0.2182990611,
-0.2021279335,
-0.0439620838,
0.6691187024,
-0.3455319107,
0.5076063871,
0.041277729,
-0.6722691655,
0.5741434693,
0.0030577453,
0.6947484016,
-0.6824572086,
-0.1913926005,
0.2375614494,
0.2749084532,
-0.1393480301,
-0.8313344121,
0.3936113417,
-0.290538758,
-0.1885655671,
-0.129244715,
0.856449604,
-0.2596229315,
-0.1057768911,
0.5843449235,
0.2824026346,
0.0018255509,
-0.1842306703,
-0.7599244714,
-0.1731683165,
-0.1992313415,
-0.348977387,
0.5489529967,
0.2419234216,
-0.068318367,
0.6732199788,
0.5029435158,
0.2360792756,
0.1421370804,
-0.21154055,
0.5207301974,
-0.6553322673,
-0.5009124875,
-0.7449394464,
0.2611054182,
-0.144625932,
-0.5647438169,
0.7597093582,
0.3592435122,
1.243335247,
-0.1940343827,
0.5269412398,
-0.2620407045,
0.6468886137,
-0.5279416442,
0.5591632128,
-0.6916140914,
-0.0658806413,
-0.6807148457,
-1.2787886858,
-0.0539516211,
0.6762791276,
-0.4247981608,
-0.0816269219,
0.9596431851,
0.6852697134,
-0.1838015169,
-0.2817671001,
0.6588820219,
-0.1608898342,
0.1568748504,
0.9299920797,
0.7585237622,
-0.542845428,
0.6613821983,
-0.5758000612,
0.1313691586,
-0.0643909946,
-0.9143816829,
-1.0157265663,
-0.9079857469,
-0.4815228581,
-0.2731375992,
0.1332373917,
0.7770422101,
0.8704077601,
-0.4102712572,
-0.3125240207,
0.0446915254,
-0.0191159509,
-0.720869422,
-0.2578675151,
0.2710281909,
-0.2071190029,
-0.8959579468,
0.1756102592,
0.0412426293,
-0.3545723557,
-0.0155459801,
0.1141955405,
-0.3060759306,
-0.1381573826,
0.3396642208,
0.0322308652,
-0.7061020136,
-0.5417895317,
-0.1642525345,
0.0865364894,
0.1736831367,
0.4264732897,
-0.9284541607,
0.7948765159,
0.7315388322,
0.3326792419,
0.58994627,
-0.2730378509,
0.2996136844,
-0.6766235828,
0.0677643418,
0.1685002595,
0.0874788836,
0.1141755953,
-0.0558441356,
0.7358646393,
0.2948396504,
-0.4781520069,
-0.825247407,
0.1922217011,
-1.0321784019,
-0.0256503765,
0.9519473314,
-0.4268288314,
-0.3757855296,
0.0198607724,
-0.196143955,
0.0785867795,
-0.1849446595,
0.8442240953,
0.8468879461,
0.2169825286,
0.2016500682,
-0.7092732787,
0.5547839403,
0.5553680062,
-0.8880562782,
-0.2014893591,
-0.0852311552,
0.78238976,
0.6850683689,
0.3188048899,
0.1236288697,
0.4536454976,
0.4435052872,
0.0660485029,
0.1637731642,
-0.0753995925,
-0.0607669204,
0.4606376588,
-0.0686777458,
-0.238067463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14458v1
|
NLAS-multi: A Multilingual Corpus of Automatically Generated Natural Language Argumentation Schemes
| 2024-02-22T11:31:50 | 2024-02-22T11:31:50 |
Ramon Ruiz-Dolz, Joaquin Taverner, John Lawrence, Chris Reed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Some of the major limitations identified in the areas of argument mining,
argument generation, and natural language argument analysis are related to the
complexity of annotating argumentatively rich data, the limited size of these
corpora, and the constraints that represent the different languages and domains
in which these data is annotated. To address these limitations, in this paper
we present the following contributions: (i) an effective methodology for the
automatic generation of natural language arguments in different topics and
languages, (ii) the largest publicly available corpus of natural language
argumentation schemes, and (iii) a set of solid baselines and fine-tuned models
for the automatic identification of argumentation schemes.
|
[
-0.8064573407,
-0.9347403049,
0.2459586859,
0.5552485585,
-0.3953815699,
0.1088196188,
-0.208098799,
-0.4010149837,
0.3737189472,
0.4162341058,
-0.4568246603,
-0.3454948366,
-0.5793874264,
0.722533226,
-0.294041127,
1.0923514366,
-0.0671603382,
0.0852997452,
-0.2380227745,
-0.5549986362,
-0.4763877392,
-0.7095845342,
-0.7965447903,
0.202688694,
0.6192371249,
0.6353875399,
0.6275275946,
0.3710751832,
0.4397919774,
0.4137026668,
0.1347487122,
0.491679579,
0.1836819053,
0.1851290911,
-0.1092388406,
-0.1411348283,
-0.2471136153,
-0.248652637,
0.7841400504,
0.6218717694,
0.1700650007,
0.2912614048,
-0.3437395096,
0.7514576316,
-0.7276929021,
-0.1607043445,
-0.6918113232,
0.0676162168,
-0.5179174542,
-0.4266280234,
-0.1737684608,
-0.5203198195,
0.2996313572,
-0.5223087668,
0.0238234587,
-0.1779540926,
1.0105069876,
0.2689356506,
-0.4334414005,
-0.9210664034,
-0.5364464521,
0.9281146526,
-0.8175731897,
0.0234386995,
0.112856023,
0.3668665886,
0.0381792225,
-0.4842340648,
-0.4070745707,
-0.078780137,
-0.0826664418,
-0.1165728942,
-0.2517620027,
-0.0801504329,
0.2097869664,
0.2082012743,
-0.5444085002,
0.0060954285,
-0.3998127282,
-0.2083995342,
0.7705171704,
0.091457732,
0.2650638521,
-0.4942752719,
-0.2239582837,
0.1935016662,
-0.6083266139,
-0.4354414344,
0.8326530457,
0.527027905,
-0.2452170998,
0.6289637089,
-0.1453635395,
1.0276010036,
-0.1168276295,
-0.0480935164,
0.0623044185,
-0.4874676764,
-0.1554141492,
-0.0161390174,
0.9930063486,
0.1476232708,
0.2961097956,
0.0719301477,
0.3042218685,
0.2150127888,
0.1346428245,
-0.6078131795,
0.018372938,
0.4295464754,
-0.3312165141,
-0.0888055414,
0.0238799267,
-1.1322160959,
-0.2597374022,
-0.4493580163,
0.1139266118,
-0.2555365264,
-0.2012098283,
0.0467638038,
-0.3133023083,
0.2531465292,
-0.0059217433,
-0.9019069672,
0.3776466548,
0.3854226172,
0.802529633,
-0.0110881208,
-0.2304908633,
-0.3947202861,
0.1428733319,
-0.5516520739,
1.2208949327,
-0.8170083165,
-0.143892616,
0.2036700696,
-0.1223489344,
0.0349511541,
-0.4546351433,
0.9345909953,
-0.417095691,
0.301499933,
-0.3405712545,
-0.5477588177,
-0.1375981718,
0.1735265106,
-0.7689210773,
0.894477427,
-0.2444251031,
-0.5447226763,
0.5222002864,
-1.2311867476,
-0.6258253455,
0.1869072169,
-0.117172651,
-0.3601362407,
0.0557467714,
0.1239627525,
0.4789809287,
-0.5800769329,
0.5791368484,
-0.1159491837,
0.2664706409,
0.0109065278,
-0.3644930124,
0.9903635383,
0.4832576215,
-0.2497478127,
0.2936052084,
-1.1581863165,
-0.1217668876,
0.2121486813,
-0.2786121368,
-0.3632358015,
0.1811743826,
0.0584583692,
0.1252356917,
0.4977671504,
-0.5461197495,
0.1653326303,
-0.4051451981,
0.4465305209,
0.4497784674,
0.1372798085,
0.1605046093,
0.0660183653,
0.6315762997,
-0.0311763603,
-0.1542544216,
-0.1094846278,
-0.7111425996,
-0.7387315035,
0.0099825794,
0.6004140377,
0.6649842262,
-0.3492138684,
0.4428333938,
0.0253855586,
-0.3454019129,
-0.4386857152,
0.3053146303,
0.2674447,
0.0235630348,
0.3740609288,
-0.0455001034,
-1.2063826323,
-1.1853927374,
-0.1675395072,
-0.0190722495,
0.1601054966,
0.0118456734,
0.5633537173,
-0.2350495458,
0.8495557308,
-0.1499743164,
-0.2008292079,
-0.1088563204,
0.4683654308,
-0.0165814739,
0.1864241362,
0.6267114878,
-0.6766611338,
-0.6415881515,
0.0762208253,
-0.8856441975,
-0.2854830921,
-0.3873693943,
-0.0843832567,
0.4175340235,
0.4587644339,
-0.4086732268,
0.178418979,
0.5504654646,
-0.2099165171,
0.6275606751,
-0.2634836435,
-0.2248967588,
-1.1864874363,
-0.0047667651,
0.2439783216,
0.0197210368,
-0.6574488878,
0.073691912,
-0.1323375702,
-0.0558491498,
-0.2568998635,
0.6606701016,
-0.4453523457,
0.2849524021,
-0.4087349474,
0.1047723144,
-0.0664623156,
0.3019176424,
0.2400243282,
0.5443865061,
0.6511613131,
-0.7616416812,
0.5083499551,
0.3053517342,
0.0464076884,
0.8880559802,
-0.7083340883,
0.017366454,
-0.0538800769,
0.1954528838,
-0.7575631142,
-0.3762601614,
0.0499932915,
-0.2214312255,
-0.0841359273,
-0.1857725978,
-0.2040362954,
-0.1506422758,
-0.3284857571,
0.2636187971,
-0.3486276269,
-0.5822126269,
0.7155296206,
0.6037648916,
-0.2778203487,
-0.9102948308,
-0.5766957402,
0.7298333645,
-0.5753719807,
-0.5732855797,
0.3241661191,
-0.2148960829,
-0.5243663192,
0.0144295841,
0.5214679241,
-0.0263618063,
-0.0094204955,
0.2824787796,
0.0227881931,
-0.4192054868,
0.1859117448,
0.1940689981,
-0.2031595707,
0.0126134148,
0.0623970218,
0.4293985963,
-0.5486987829,
-0.4048302174,
-0.1799991876,
1.1343917847,
0.4865872264,
-0.1503327191,
0.5924326777,
0.4644676149,
-0.4967818558,
-0.1466151923,
-0.5359457135,
0.2791206837,
-0.4156446159,
0.0833958685,
-0.5994336605,
-0.6063019633,
0.6439012885,
-0.1152685955,
0.6185359359,
0.9053611159,
0.8640355468,
0.3770807385,
0.8878000975,
0.1094189063,
-0.049055554,
0.0478724279,
-0.1300684214,
0.2896385193,
-0.5605641007,
0.1202877834,
-0.8741029501,
-0.0706470385,
-0.5862091184,
-0.1844801009,
-0.1679183394,
0.012624668,
-0.2648734748,
0.380707711,
-0.5898334384,
0.4366107583,
0.5491127968,
-0.7911959887,
0.1420628726,
-0.0527092516,
-0.2624633312,
0.0203292537,
-0.7005435228,
-1.0075714588,
0.9903347492,
0.414237529,
0.0809244141,
0.4364220798,
0.7296888828,
0.2879020572,
0.3139080703,
-0.8606658578,
0.4774814844,
-0.3918528259,
-0.9400241971,
-0.267354399,
-0.470061481,
-1.2784190178,
0.2190243453,
-0.3978735507,
-0.5655822158,
0.2901415527,
-0.0900044143,
-0.4908521175,
0.3905049264,
-0.9384894967,
0.86785537,
-0.2279869318,
-0.175337702,
0.1293493211,
-0.4640133679,
0.3205392361,
-0.1472251117,
0.3086240292,
-0.0634070635,
0.0438501351,
1.0193433762,
-0.4413193762,
0.642500639,
-0.2696572542,
-0.2601289451,
0.6527113914,
-0.2720121145,
0.1184052601,
0.2428542674,
-0.2090266943,
0.0976035371,
0.1571284682,
-0.4001319408,
-0.1657733768,
0.5336083174,
-0.5271766782,
-0.5128225684,
-0.4481580555,
-0.4121576846,
-0.3973006606,
0.0964064971,
0.0818127766,
0.5156438351,
-0.3630079925,
0.2349558771,
0.1680698693,
-0.4787963927,
0.6435465217,
0.3199506104,
0.1410502195,
-0.507427454,
1.3078821898,
0.2006019503,
-0.0968874916,
0.0496072769,
0.4644930065,
-0.5474283695,
-0.7335229516,
-0.7781611085,
0.1297293454,
-0.8267799616,
-0.3618086278,
-0.5874320865,
-0.0792952254,
-0.3826608062,
-0.2356776893,
-0.3320277035,
-0.6112048626,
-0.1978659481,
-0.0824475884,
0.3432771266,
0.8259540796,
-0.2543853521,
0.1322460026,
-0.6228972077,
0.6323988438,
0.373929292,
0.5154462457,
-0.1687870622,
0.0777486712,
-0.0509188958,
-0.0555138513,
-0.3343432546,
-1.0933980942,
0.3161524832,
0.3725420833,
0.603639245,
0.5590676665,
-0.0111637665,
0.8362215161,
-0.4405077398,
0.8792666197,
0.1596534103,
-0.8129702806,
0.4671285748,
-0.2327278703,
0.3079771101,
0.572820127,
0.3006395996,
-0.2930807471,
-0.4585269094,
-0.603261292,
-0.9643212557,
0.3676747978,
-0.0482348427,
0.2180349678,
-0.3856453001,
0.1591300219,
0.2750484347,
-0.202192083,
-0.8218001723,
-0.2680012584,
-0.2414270341,
-0.2367037684,
0.2735882401,
-0.2797934115,
-0.4438209236,
-0.0669253469,
0.8146786094,
-0.4943061471,
0.1454886198,
0.0902936384,
-0.0147023294,
-0.1558155715,
0.4824459255,
1.1310945749,
0.8288628459,
-0.0958973616,
0.1159016341,
0.432251662,
-0.2436505407,
0.1642543674,
0.1724597663,
-0.1414768994,
0.3252085447,
0.3554650247,
0.9413782358,
-0.0857191384,
-0.6954957247,
0.0161301047,
-0.3309242129,
-0.6296450496,
-0.5362434387,
-0.4066424668,
0.3839751184,
-0.1050178409,
0.5455136299,
0.0926978812,
-0.0702597275,
-0.5364903808,
0.126076892,
0.7161423564,
-0.1648681313,
-0.027562378,
0.3984104097,
0.2301677018,
-0.3025025725,
-0.0494354405,
-0.3307574987,
-0.3572745323,
0.5463288426,
0.4063067436,
0.7816773653,
0.0195288286,
0.3067829609,
0.593528986,
0.2913555205,
0.2195087671,
0.3825037181,
0.1332839727,
-0.6008601189,
-0.5642262697,
-0.7382920384,
-0.5313335061,
0.3149967194,
-0.3746269941,
0.2169700116,
-0.5336712599,
-0.2243710458,
0.5411628485,
0.3192471266,
-0.3607724309,
0.0959328488,
0.1878023446,
0.6300882697,
-0.7317038178,
0.6243128181,
0.7058891058,
-0.2937211692,
-0.333366394,
-0.284966141,
-0.0160274394,
-0.0725479946,
0.4423910379,
-0.0900469944,
-0.3497463763,
-0.5142154694,
-0.2696382701,
-0.7458078861,
0.3660113215,
0.482590884,
-0.1677757502,
0.2374882251,
0.3605346978,
0.6418592334,
-0.5764548182,
0.141704455,
0.3885578811,
0.8875386715,
-0.2847201228,
-0.6750212312,
0.0370240659,
-0.4534557462,
-0.2930074334,
0.0608108193,
-0.4473682642,
0.7999232411,
-0.0470326245,
-0.359149754,
0.0584465154,
0.8226642013,
0.3515298367,
0.2285113037,
0.6012768745,
0.6234406829,
0.6968525648,
-0.0073180944,
0.9563814402,
-0.2753399312,
-0.0031930322,
0.9964517951,
-0.3951368034,
0.7761567235,
0.4735975266,
-0.1400170028,
0.6787783504,
0.685022831,
-0.0791310892,
-0.0461704768,
0.2958389223,
-0.2397246659,
-0.1316421479,
-0.1815390885,
-0.4229310751,
0.4815049767,
0.6709748507,
-0.0294656381,
-0.3633514345,
-0.3049806654,
-0.0958374813,
0.2095687538,
0.008983627,
0.8742020726,
-0.1084708348,
-0.8001832366,
0.6028137207,
0.3853974938,
0.8119473457,
-0.6891738176,
-0.1259051561,
0.0934840664,
-0.1774170548,
-0.3879856467,
-0.5005760789,
0.687178731,
0.3729939163,
0.1195879504,
0.1541026682,
0.809648335,
-0.1590017974,
-0.6917999387,
0.4267126322,
0.5524584651,
0.0442748591,
0.2888623774,
-0.8736976385,
-0.0940862671,
-0.3178327382,
-0.369479388,
0.1270966977,
0.5784680247,
-0.2266897261,
0.4648480117,
0.7204659581,
0.1909802556,
0.4544595182,
0.2611682117,
0.3693861365,
-0.6314060688,
-0.1705451459,
-0.8262627721,
0.3120930791,
-0.3241022527,
-0.5455070734,
0.7821163535,
0.7029810548,
0.4190703034,
-0.010465906,
0.9654419422,
-0.1432424337,
0.598990202,
-0.2402411848,
0.1891990155,
-0.3972201049,
-0.0470964052,
-0.382243216,
-0.7577405572,
-0.7503713369,
0.6858625412,
-0.0834367499,
-0.2143169791,
0.6644114256,
0.5502746701,
0.0510094576,
0.2798852623,
0.1060453057,
-0.304045558,
0.2742162943,
0.4629905224,
0.7569956183,
-0.3362363577,
0.5284468532,
-0.2076415569,
0.0321004987,
-0.0673188642,
-1.0988920927,
-0.8239011168,
-0.8250228763,
-0.5102626085,
-0.0496945009,
-0.2835133672,
0.8609396815,
0.7255107164,
-1.3177782297,
-0.5284955502,
-0.1955885291,
0.2368240803,
-0.155460164,
-0.1959406883,
0.5024084449,
-0.5429276228,
-0.6505278349,
0.5180437565,
0.19934313,
-0.2873582244,
-0.5702617764,
-0.2860657573,
-0.9545878768,
0.6225805879,
0.7861844897,
0.6838699579,
-0.8072957993,
-0.286834389,
-0.4724851549,
0.0776019841,
0.1528185308,
0.8547306657,
-0.3296556771,
0.397339195,
0.3884831667,
0.700278759,
0.0189121589,
-0.0550003164,
0.4877155125,
-0.9776130319,
0.1613537222,
0.0962205008,
0.5613180995,
0.4531612098,
0.0088547161,
0.4575030506,
-0.1144094616,
-0.259154886,
-0.8365532756,
0.1652477831,
-1.1079471111,
-0.4990371466,
1.0672917366,
0.0692871362,
0.0205491856,
-0.6894709468,
-0.3762811422,
0.1577323079,
-0.2900267243,
0.6482005715,
1.0447636843,
-0.0481897779,
-0.0201916657,
-0.7562820315,
0.7109057307,
0.5706019998,
-1.1599720716,
0.2545609772,
0.5048347116,
-0.1341613382,
0.8459101319,
0.4537983835,
-0.3170300126,
0.2992269397,
-0.0096534304,
-0.1553395092,
0.2076895088,
-0.4666342735,
-0.3412811756,
0.9587736726,
0.0307070855,
-0.0267509893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14457v2
|
Annotation and Classification of Relevant Clauses in Terms-and-Conditions Contracts
| 2024-02-22T11:24:45 | 2024-05-27T09:06:41 |
Pietro Giovanni Bizzaro, Elena Della Valentina, Maurizio Napolitano, Nadia Mana, Massimo Zancanaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose a new annotation scheme to classify different types
of clauses in Terms-and-Conditions contracts with the ultimate goal of
supporting legal experts to quickly identify and assess problematic issues in
this type of legal documents. To this end, we built a small corpus of
Terms-and-Conditions contracts and finalized an annotation scheme of 14
categories, eventually reaching an inter-annotator agreement of 0.92. Then, for
11 of them, we experimented with binary classification tasks using few-shot
prompting with a multilingual T5 and two fine-tuned versions of two BERT-based
LLMs for Italian. Our experiments showed the feasibility of automatic
classification of our categories by reaching accuracies ranging from .79 to .95
on validation tasks.
|
[
-0.7347865701,
-0.4803923368,
0.6220302582,
0.3114461899,
-0.6656281948,
-0.1506097168,
-0.0557404533,
-1.0700018406,
0.3502871096,
0.6788049936,
-0.2272673398,
-0.6645006537,
-0.6568428874,
0.338619709,
-0.2080776989,
1.2338863611,
0.0013526678,
0.0332035236,
-0.2674586177,
-0.3203367889,
-0.3334645629,
-0.7315018773,
-0.7954055667,
-0.0303122588,
0.4912003577,
0.2268317938,
0.6625964046,
0.1208460554,
0.5472949743,
0.2269654572,
-0.1925827563,
0.2647300065,
0.4600028992,
0.0592861846,
-0.1826718301,
-0.4994031489,
-0.2514718175,
0.0430969633,
0.2615574002,
0.306029588,
0.1053661257,
0.1941521764,
-0.3942996562,
0.3863207996,
-0.5780268908,
0.4612893164,
-0.4771844149,
0.1074392721,
-0.0471684635,
-0.3609851599,
-0.6766492128,
-0.3661903441,
-0.1606201679,
-0.6888936758,
0.0466323867,
0.2490440905,
0.9687196612,
0.5789048672,
-0.6381347775,
-0.4465103149,
-0.1024544016,
0.2376314402,
-0.6514505148,
0.2921753228,
0.3369949162,
0.2456802279,
-0.0695320964,
-0.5412111282,
-0.5069283843,
-0.5600759387,
-0.4627362788,
0.1995868683,
0.1185053214,
0.1757757068,
0.5179357529,
0.0902075693,
-0.2357578278,
0.5879611373,
-0.3253652155,
-0.4698583782,
1.0385979414,
0.0040522222,
0.245226413,
-0.49993819,
-0.3848164082,
0.6612904668,
-0.6171759963,
0.1739085615,
0.3844452798,
0.370778054,
-0.19963938,
0.7131732106,
-0.2962536812,
0.659989953,
0.0274369698,
-0.1858122647,
0.2549404204,
-0.3258635998,
-0.0458505414,
0.0913726538,
0.5192185044,
0.355147928,
0.1784767658,
-0.2566908598,
-0.5449435115,
-0.0012459995,
0.1915484965,
-0.2168409824,
0.0713554993,
0.3555511534,
-0.2957409918,
-0.1554017812,
0.2068505138,
-0.2335909009,
-0.605481267,
-0.5465123057,
0.4013961852,
-0.3344598114,
0.0543400757,
0.0478021093,
-0.1260304451,
0.4820349216,
0.3847339749,
-0.6823831201,
0.1681485474,
0.5684885383,
0.4574229419,
0.2867310941,
0.0528017282,
-0.4816013277,
-0.0749410838,
-0.3779353499,
1.115490675,
-0.2675291598,
0.0187357459,
0.2540825605,
-0.2459504157,
-0.0607168712,
-0.1535444856,
0.5534830093,
-0.6682953238,
0.3389788568,
0.3173138499,
-0.5309354067,
-0.1815514416,
0.3793119788,
-0.7090620399,
0.7606822252,
0.2377778888,
-0.7734918594,
0.9017361403,
-0.8616896868,
-0.5248263478,
0.4599098563,
-0.3532187343,
-0.5418547988,
0.0829927251,
-0.1065946966,
0.5659510493,
-0.2465416938,
0.25608325,
-0.2058654726,
-0.1732195914,
0.6866913438,
0.342505604,
0.7755916119,
0.4783698916,
-0.389847517,
0.3710146844,
-0.6574816704,
-0.0843214244,
-0.2622186244,
-0.5183142424,
-0.2523682117,
-0.1297303289,
-0.0103862872,
0.5749580264,
0.3359581828,
-0.4132345915,
0.4829169214,
-0.3811478913,
0.6250280738,
0.3033181131,
0.1984405518,
0.151744172,
-0.1461561173,
0.4917709529,
0.0673474818,
0.3783164918,
0.2410704494,
-0.7630747557,
-1.1066619158,
-0.2863404751,
0.7385024428,
0.5953856111,
-0.9939856529,
0.5659629703,
0.0483605936,
-0.2344249189,
-0.6122475266,
-0.1500363946,
0.5196903944,
-0.1028468907,
0.3681521714,
0.0306794345,
-0.4638329744,
-1.0515031815,
-0.0591833219,
-0.3611910343,
0.3066086471,
0.0324686691,
0.7342996001,
-0.1179054528,
0.857517004,
-0.1516689509,
-0.6054881811,
-0.0081403218,
0.5133780837,
0.2275289744,
0.3335745037,
0.8143886924,
-0.8614093065,
-0.4744395912,
0.0455802344,
-0.4266377687,
-0.0755090639,
-0.2946199477,
0.0909226835,
0.6184412241,
0.9438414574,
-0.4786378741,
0.4164240956,
-0.0092856409,
-0.6002727151,
0.5058977604,
-0.3517156541,
0.1614371687,
-0.9476619959,
-0.1655651927,
0.1256045997,
-0.5781739354,
-0.3935214579,
0.1904440075,
0.2120998353,
0.0194012523,
-0.8356460929,
0.2682668269,
-0.2687911391,
-0.1394825876,
0.017326694,
0.0513263792,
-0.1882355809,
0.4007130861,
0.2528593242,
0.6473445892,
0.427582562,
-0.8274146914,
0.2479990572,
0.4543706477,
-0.1781900823,
0.5974392891,
-0.2078459263,
0.1170108542,
-0.1881703734,
0.1789447069,
-0.7689529657,
-0.1569732577,
0.6130948067,
-0.4335957766,
0.1873866171,
-0.4314115644,
-0.9493151903,
-0.1670905203,
-0.3329133987,
0.0785406455,
0.1589825898,
-0.3707415164,
0.6663440466,
0.1183249578,
0.0925091356,
-0.3930263817,
-0.7714636922,
0.0816545635,
-0.5190393329,
-0.1872320473,
0.4554814696,
0.1157460287,
-0.2277458012,
0.2287939191,
0.0912873968,
-0.4626754224,
0.3471895754,
0.2527926266,
-0.0149434516,
0.0898964703,
0.2735122442,
0.2060013264,
-0.3647453785,
-0.023418095,
-0.1631000787,
0.2821081877,
0.1135549247,
-0.1164114922,
-0.3213965297,
0.4184165597,
0.3354536593,
-0.3155789971,
0.4072519839,
0.4358889759,
-0.4258401692,
-0.0228288453,
-0.5801421404,
0.2671739459,
-0.380810976,
-0.1798550636,
-0.8386344314,
-0.9336482286,
0.6539482474,
0.1444044113,
0.1478978992,
0.9631085396,
0.3295991719,
-0.1701081842,
0.5783186555,
0.5904037356,
0.2681658566,
0.4348495603,
0.0001180049,
0.0037016689,
-0.513464272,
-0.5714047551,
-0.8303517103,
0.0596926138,
-0.89061445,
-0.1378689855,
0.3275087178,
0.2568547428,
0.0220501442,
0.7213277817,
-0.4614519179,
0.394403398,
0.455270052,
0.26821962,
0.1097214594,
-0.372248888,
-0.3802915215,
0.1593969017,
-0.4244624674,
-0.6077023745,
0.6185833216,
0.36299932,
0.0869859084,
0.3880145252,
1.1320850849,
0.4504212141,
0.3735639155,
-1.0870387554,
0.4934010208,
-0.3416381776,
-0.8772178888,
-0.212748453,
-0.2112076879,
-0.9226731658,
0.0251490995,
-0.5657173991,
-0.8146049976,
0.450420171,
-0.1684577316,
-0.6947714686,
-0.2256399989,
-0.7426891923,
0.7773457766,
-0.3529013395,
-0.0196037143,
-0.1036446095,
-0.7326493263,
0.1379740685,
-0.1644557714,
0.4738172293,
-0.4065587819,
-0.4842339456,
0.9662998319,
-0.1755423993,
0.8144903779,
-0.2648707926,
-0.1410470009,
0.3174511194,
-0.1265787333,
0.0619208999,
0.3877792358,
-0.1222509816,
0.0337201804,
0.2399090677,
-0.2092055827,
-0.4063459039,
0.0626829416,
-0.5425576568,
-0.3402408957,
-0.8211612105,
-0.3060757816,
-0.3635185361,
0.3552410901,
0.3394133151,
0.0793730617,
0.3403826356,
-0.1292096078,
0.1820106953,
-0.0088656452,
0.4220980108,
0.8149746656,
-0.0513178781,
-0.5321342349,
0.5625199676,
0.1281908453,
-0.0137742208,
0.4180865288,
-0.3137490153,
-0.5941726565,
-1.0643845797,
0.0325590149,
0.2634975314,
-1.0732058287,
-0.7081407309,
-0.0584584996,
-0.0921735689,
-0.4626337588,
-0.076137431,
0.1591295302,
-0.6264696717,
-0.4561073184,
-0.1669429243,
0.5261787176,
0.7113927007,
0.1188110039,
0.1117303371,
-0.8260564804,
0.3041884303,
0.085352689,
0.6197420955,
-1.0491702557,
-0.449038595,
-0.5045286417,
-0.553497076,
0.0467936583,
-0.862737,
0.1501420885,
0.2437962443,
0.6910427809,
0.1713013947,
0.271744132,
0.5173053145,
-0.3594164252,
0.8824506998,
0.496139735,
-1.1751559973,
0.5806242228,
0.0335774682,
-0.2023454458,
0.8967117071,
0.569626689,
-0.34057042,
-0.641692698,
-0.7636885643,
-0.889898479,
0.9147416949,
0.0863278136,
-0.1756441295,
-0.083785437,
0.8730872273,
0.1415479779,
0.1894120127,
-0.9473007321,
-0.1496916562,
0.1321600974,
-0.1257731766,
-0.0418709628,
-0.4641564786,
-0.0850599408,
-0.1120708957,
0.6030490398,
-0.2633184791,
0.4514892101,
0.2904604673,
-0.3608188331,
0.2723614573,
0.676625371,
0.8224977255,
0.7597762942,
-0.1954462826,
0.2375830263,
0.1740603447,
0.0559187904,
0.3899300098,
0.4785089493,
-0.2135503888,
0.1179290637,
0.3971461058,
0.86383003,
0.2556838691,
-0.1855082065,
0.2458009869,
0.0015815881,
-0.6365052462,
-0.5531122684,
-0.0017273484,
-0.040829286,
0.6189222932,
0.0376385674,
-0.0838316455,
0.3279784024,
-0.4526564181,
0.3257656693,
0.0501687601,
-0.2187425941,
0.0998714939,
0.3501580954,
0.3392110765,
-0.1941732913,
0.257448405,
-0.6550663114,
-0.7186276913,
0.4101408124,
0.0659621283,
0.8577526808,
0.1418326497,
0.3376452029,
0.0539318509,
0.259087801,
0.1046744138,
0.4840954244,
-0.0230939798,
-0.7564615011,
-0.4107080102,
-0.3172869384,
-0.4506222904,
-0.176324591,
-0.7430596352,
0.5002936721,
-0.5987519622,
-0.449333638,
0.6264862418,
0.1542716473,
-0.6394820809,
0.2292794883,
0.4605388045,
0.8982493877,
-0.8731769919,
1.0076172352,
1.1666383743,
-1.1983727217,
-0.5974988937,
-0.0078111188,
-0.4525351822,
-0.5092170835,
1.0783442259,
0.0920784697,
0.0777660906,
-0.2152465284,
-0.3692394495,
-0.3830471635,
0.8694716096,
0.4560312629,
-0.6046515107,
0.0578246377,
0.2737779021,
0.6388510466,
-0.2341312468,
0.1703466624,
0.8146409392,
0.7253568172,
-0.0881265029,
-1.1852152348,
-0.0102148065,
-0.1417909712,
-0.1412545741,
0.2343675047,
-0.5476574302,
0.5423365831,
0.1661705524,
-0.0562647469,
-0.0175406225,
0.499858588,
-0.0787421316,
0.4222385883,
0.7178867459,
0.5024594069,
0.6308267713,
-0.5465385914,
1.0146067142,
-0.3233351111,
0.5290064812,
0.6575419307,
0.1229529008,
0.7873592377,
0.5894213915,
-0.3102486134,
0.3746670187,
1.1102279425,
-0.0958775058,
0.4074880779,
0.3586197793,
-0.126778096,
-0.5122061372,
-0.2704536319,
-0.2007083893,
0.2581125498,
0.4910873771,
0.0466944985,
0.1006023362,
-0.0469891764,
-0.1644284278,
-0.0009350681,
-0.3800774515,
1.1792309284,
0.1391150206,
-0.4843020439,
0.3001156151,
0.23574242,
0.7719456553,
-0.425352037,
0.0603843108,
-0.0132404091,
-0.2543941438,
-0.7458518744,
-0.8641911745,
0.3439125121,
0.0423414372,
0.0961976573,
-0.2462060004,
0.4955833256,
-0.3497782946,
-0.3974297941,
0.183092162,
0.0338197909,
0.2566066682,
0.0692956001,
-0.8579468131,
0.0111375833,
-0.1901184618,
0.1088234931,
0.0081359241,
0.6695703864,
-0.1451993287,
0.2136581093,
0.1474539489,
0.001775843,
0.1965702474,
0.1254009455,
0.6556667686,
-0.8626859784,
-0.6118542552,
-0.4852945507,
0.8086420894,
-0.0567159504,
-0.4190794528,
0.4167478681,
0.4432418346,
0.6737291813,
-0.1648884714,
0.6221250296,
-0.1015410572,
0.3155573308,
-1.1228582859,
0.2306358367,
-0.5110308528,
0.2581415474,
-0.0265435055,
-0.716683507,
-0.9630426168,
0.6478160024,
-0.4633233845,
-0.1493134499,
1.1436339617,
0.0521418862,
0.3106102049,
-0.2381118685,
0.245105654,
-0.2764945924,
0.4010195732,
0.3852418959,
0.970266223,
-0.3011038005,
0.5010177493,
-0.3228331804,
0.0820987672,
-0.4410021603,
-0.848464191,
-0.8845203519,
-0.6029962897,
-0.9232533574,
-0.3508602977,
-0.106029503,
1.2434538603,
0.654769659,
-1.0259590149,
-0.1408312768,
-0.0693719909,
0.1052186936,
-0.0187748279,
-0.1386232525,
0.2681905031,
-1.1165924072,
-0.5120479465,
0.0752446204,
0.1263771653,
0.2210633755,
-0.0707337409,
0.0335844718,
-0.1715401411,
-0.0144038117,
0.6905681491,
0.1280873269,
-0.83136338,
-0.5073929429,
-0.7367900014,
-0.174338311,
0.0441373363,
1.0658196211,
-0.3112466633,
0.2804393172,
0.3104434311,
0.5167284608,
0.6561722159,
-0.2397175431,
0.0855416059,
-1.0750381947,
0.5599750876,
0.5234211683,
0.6495466828,
0.0036651122,
-0.4553569853,
0.5873857737,
-0.1773718297,
-0.1331691593,
-0.3650845587,
0.3220684528,
-1.0780227184,
-0.3330363929,
0.9981365204,
-0.3362252116,
0.036318481,
-0.5167625546,
-0.2592757344,
0.1918643266,
-0.3256699443,
0.7092722058,
0.6173563004,
-0.4807365537,
-0.0985119715,
-0.4720191658,
0.7763875127,
0.1972697526,
-1.0925258398,
-0.4747968316,
0.648024857,
-0.0118074333,
0.6672402024,
0.5365150571,
-0.1534006149,
0.4734239578,
-0.2339502573,
0.0335332863,
-0.0845146701,
-0.3358846605,
-0.4506123066,
0.2658194304,
0.7799255252,
-0.3661691546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14453v1
|
Do LLMs Implicitly Determine the Suitable Text Difficulty for Users?
| 2024-02-22T11:16:23 | 2024-02-22T11:16:23 |
Seiji Gobara, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Education that suits the individual learning level is necessary to improve
students' understanding. The first step in achieving this purpose by using
large language models (LLMs) is to adjust the textual difficulty of the
response to students. This work analyzes how LLMs can implicitly adjust text
difficulty between user input and its generated text. To conduct the
experiments, we created a new dataset from Stack-Overflow to explore the
performance of question-answering-based conversation. Experimental results on
the Stack-Overflow dataset and the TSCC dataset, including multi-turn
conversation show that LLMs can implicitly handle text difficulty between user
input and its generated response. We also observed that some LLMs can surpass
humans in handling text difficulty and the importance of instruction-tuning.
|
[
-0.2867545784,
-1.0363841057,
0.9626266956,
0.028824795,
-0.0453713387,
0.3132558167,
-0.4261877537,
-0.443987608,
-0.3582946658,
0.3439421654,
-0.7885576487,
-0.4426247776,
-0.6245278716,
0.5218094587,
-0.3506808281,
1.1573221684,
-0.0519052483,
0.1953703612,
-0.6336199045,
0.1017743349,
-0.7185693383,
-0.5550304651,
-0.7556712031,
-0.3449872434,
0.6810873747,
0.7173370719,
0.7161149383,
0.2452812642,
0.5796948075,
0.3925780952,
-0.3811470568,
0.0720519572,
-0.7100468874,
0.3485775888,
-0.3024921715,
-0.6484794617,
-0.3269963861,
-0.2787561119,
0.7110881209,
0.6716942787,
-0.0274527781,
-0.1723988801,
0.2797944844,
0.5288122296,
-0.2492230237,
-0.1383712292,
-0.5770785809,
-0.1098162085,
-0.1029170752,
-0.5020987988,
-0.4645069838,
-0.3476038575,
0.3663970232,
-0.4355318844,
0.3446430564,
0.1951689273,
0.5193482637,
0.3336310089,
-0.5729193687,
-0.7548542619,
-0.7848368883,
0.7690922022,
-0.5443073511,
0.2838001251,
0.1225244924,
0.0704081655,
-0.440356344,
-0.3908776939,
-0.4026880562,
-0.1373379976,
-0.2487485856,
0.0718814582,
0.1144385561,
0.2483222187,
0.4847477376,
0.3082487285,
-0.3887811005,
0.3828327656,
-0.7795792222,
0.0361225381,
0.5677061081,
0.6155021787,
0.6229256988,
-0.1995846033,
-0.1703725457,
0.0651778132,
-0.6119599938,
0.2570757866,
0.301009059,
0.3259929717,
0.0599046797,
0.8068488836,
-0.1444562674,
0.64675951,
-0.1564078927,
-0.1057195291,
-0.0438159928,
-0.1598862708,
-0.1289953887,
0.074994944,
0.5379118323,
0.1891466528,
0.5224410892,
-0.0945076719,
-0.2620400786,
-0.1218472198,
0.2613449395,
-0.9053994417,
0.0513471738,
0.377058655,
0.032194417,
-0.120179005,
-0.0490034334,
-0.5146301389,
-0.6266091466,
-0.3781412542,
0.5516504049,
-0.2591135204,
-0.0563282892,
0.2902364731,
-0.0008837054,
0.0129608372,
0.4543637335,
-0.9733260274,
0.5937979221,
0.6709184051,
0.8796229959,
-0.5102846622,
-0.2083776593,
-0.2653261721,
0.0284075346,
-0.2975122631,
0.6438186169,
-0.6062351465,
-0.7067319751,
-0.0793207139,
-0.2630557418,
-0.3028386533,
-0.3299361467,
0.5679433942,
-0.4658575356,
0.3338315785,
-0.3514651656,
-0.7747246027,
0.2068616152,
0.0723046213,
-0.3997936547,
0.9377588034,
-0.0807957202,
-0.9064830542,
0.0772373155,
-0.7184179425,
-0.64571172,
-0.1149684042,
0.049087774,
-0.2235344797,
0.3955704868,
0.3042795658,
0.5920196176,
-0.3410670459,
0.038973216,
-0.135575071,
-0.6216642857,
0.7174848318,
-0.2039868981,
0.416929692,
-0.057485301,
0.0021813167,
0.1420527399,
-0.6533343196,
0.1455430239,
0.0834961459,
-0.6670692563,
-0.4163505733,
0.2568868399,
-0.3536741734,
0.1525196731,
0.2092908472,
-0.4249615967,
0.2628195286,
-0.4969834387,
0.5623181462,
0.976665318,
0.0472659282,
0.292060256,
-0.20499219,
0.6196116209,
-0.0796860307,
-0.1040866673,
-0.3453181684,
-0.4365481436,
-0.9405468702,
0.2128875703,
0.1590505838,
0.6636940837,
-0.6534218192,
-0.1788602173,
-0.0894810632,
-0.1795079112,
-0.6232791543,
0.4857521355,
0.5000944734,
0.5744239688,
0.3239737749,
0.0635021701,
-0.308876425,
-0.6258608699,
-0.1536844969,
-0.261543721,
-0.2065817118,
0.5897505283,
0.2631376982,
-0.1037583351,
0.7806130648,
-0.6499734521,
-0.0662335157,
-0.3381232321,
0.4318751395,
-0.1049781591,
0.1958958805,
0.0638558045,
-0.709782064,
-0.4129991233,
-0.2389436662,
-0.5220537186,
-0.4183673561,
-0.0947810858,
0.0063941479,
0.5334399343,
0.6566032767,
-0.4071422517,
0.2077646255,
0.4214375913,
-0.381621927,
0.3097281754,
-0.5900474787,
0.2781452835,
-0.9291961789,
-0.4027424455,
0.1933945268,
-0.0697044805,
-0.5996257663,
-0.1411506087,
0.1201315001,
0.0171470661,
-0.4751266539,
0.4384446144,
-0.3901640773,
-0.1533570588,
-0.3165889084,
0.4337922931,
-0.0896855742,
0.4796214104,
0.143600136,
1.0620168447,
0.4747237861,
-0.7973006368,
0.2367853969,
0.1929603666,
-0.214554593,
0.728546679,
-1.1150393486,
0.4051231742,
-0.359590888,
0.1787822247,
-1.4477427006,
-0.3626962006,
-0.0060025523,
-0.2968749702,
0.132373631,
0.1336498111,
-0.3372091353,
-0.376813978,
-0.0825422406,
0.2269127369,
0.3278697729,
-0.3943979442,
0.4614368379,
0.0864772797,
-0.518646121,
-0.2890506685,
-0.511629343,
0.214356184,
-0.0511282943,
-0.6411551237,
0.2694270611,
-0.6720556617,
-0.2048988193,
-0.2503266931,
0.2262120098,
0.0471878387,
0.0892922729,
0.4909831285,
0.2760912776,
-0.1764819324,
0.6575419307,
0.1507321447,
0.0609658286,
0.2333646119,
0.1212946922,
0.4207863212,
-0.0905539319,
-0.400980711,
-0.3404634595,
0.2707872391,
0.3012386262,
0.1230251044,
0.6908229589,
0.1663389355,
-0.0829545259,
-0.3162948489,
-0.4960432053,
-0.3475672901,
-0.5480061769,
0.5080916286,
-0.5501877069,
-1.0677325726,
0.314989239,
0.0541863516,
0.1273507625,
0.2514112592,
0.6612680554,
-0.3770754635,
1.4009518623,
0.5760523677,
0.1452609748,
0.066700384,
0.2778153121,
-0.0756680593,
-0.7300567627,
-0.4071240425,
-0.8128498197,
-0.404121846,
-0.6680724621,
-0.1667319387,
0.2068754733,
-0.1842633486,
-0.1782177538,
-0.1059564278,
-0.2586397231,
0.5317627192,
0.2966231406,
0.2479806691,
0.3913758099,
-0.1114833653,
-0.0025040563,
-0.2926347852,
-0.5466399789,
-0.4304694831,
0.9361416101,
0.4477198124,
1.0518602133,
0.2122261524,
0.3658916056,
0.1281731576,
0.3683878183,
-0.7487324476,
0.6359975934,
-0.132503286,
-0.5648121834,
-0.5189303756,
-0.6891564727,
-0.9814742208,
-0.0530614704,
-0.418045342,
-0.6959264874,
-0.3171977401,
0.1727964878,
-0.1836054176,
0.1288090199,
-0.8796334863,
0.4326590002,
-0.5240705013,
-0.2684065998,
-0.0433274806,
-0.5110290647,
0.1737088263,
-0.1472135186,
0.1773632169,
-0.0445796102,
-0.2225717008,
0.7759395242,
-0.2044595182,
0.8805192113,
-0.0020687014,
-0.361620158,
0.206631884,
0.1368566453,
0.3934315443,
0.0983178243,
-0.1617755294,
-0.1687553376,
-0.2333973646,
-0.2061378956,
-0.876013875,
0.8654056787,
-0.8723938465,
-1.0180002451,
-0.2569974065,
-0.6919707656,
-0.4386272728,
-0.0706645101,
0.2344956249,
0.4489946961,
-0.2638082802,
0.3016478419,
0.9608485103,
-0.3843041956,
0.4381411374,
0.8134015799,
-0.202913031,
0.058127895,
0.8426463604,
0.2211278677,
0.4597789347,
0.3346790075,
0.4375680089,
-0.5843567848,
-0.6258691549,
-0.5729866028,
-0.0265858322,
-0.6310694814,
0.0051149414,
-0.6067097783,
-0.3068689406,
-0.0742566511,
-0.2121533453,
-0.0077705802,
-0.267073065,
-0.6057760715,
-0.1864692122,
0.5440012813,
1.0628086329,
0.3981443644,
0.6036555171,
-0.5523835421,
0.3990101814,
0.6260297298,
0.4574728608,
-0.2801564634,
-0.9499779344,
0.1323050857,
0.0730705038,
-0.1306562126,
-0.7105836272,
0.1234894469,
0.3515253365,
0.1713441163,
-0.0524802059,
-0.0243812799,
0.5189982653,
-0.4670055807,
0.636790812,
0.0559136122,
-1.0409599543,
0.568413794,
-0.1583389342,
0.4730764925,
0.3266083002,
0.4517419934,
-0.668885231,
-0.5255376101,
-0.2996200621,
-0.697935462,
0.8628414869,
0.2531653643,
0.7555798888,
0.3125221431,
0.6612468362,
-0.0159748346,
0.0867976993,
-0.6583900452,
-0.0921430886,
0.1315835267,
-0.3641776443,
-0.2630342543,
-0.4715984762,
0.09032242,
-0.1988635808,
0.4875575304,
-0.0327620432,
-0.0154667487,
0.0066274079,
-0.1446253359,
-0.3704684377,
0.5726050735,
0.7649714351,
0.8571461439,
-0.2357916981,
-0.0065139225,
0.5956847668,
-0.3383096457,
0.1660479903,
-0.1605891138,
-0.0449575,
-0.3184772432,
0.2587170899,
0.8841055632,
0.3930449784,
-0.7496077418,
0.4123265743,
-0.4166375399,
-0.3202587068,
0.1412192434,
0.7052393556,
0.1246300936,
0.1346176267,
0.6176641583,
-0.3631252646,
-0.0218465701,
-0.4144178629,
-0.0320456028,
0.3439187407,
-0.364253521,
-0.1428224146,
0.6031886935,
0.3969779313,
-0.7262776494,
0.6025784016,
0.2742345631,
-0.4944117963,
0.6049017906,
0.76011765,
0.5291550756,
-0.2974099815,
0.3229014575,
0.2435848117,
0.2581550777,
-0.0353420451,
0.2225584537,
0.2471588552,
-0.583794117,
-0.5965493917,
-0.4055954218,
-0.888869524,
0.0477651358,
-0.4914954901,
0.3417879641,
-0.6445406675,
0.0513550267,
0.1640598923,
0.0672398359,
-0.5661037564,
0.7789276242,
-0.0186253954,
0.5816984773,
-0.6672086716,
0.4872249067,
0.6077602506,
-0.0430204719,
-0.6863391995,
-0.0849197134,
-0.1945614219,
-0.727879107,
0.4072986543,
0.0000219791,
-0.2851668596,
0.040099334,
-0.8381272554,
-0.4325199127,
0.7115635276,
0.4025321603,
-0.666213274,
0.0727699101,
0.5041847229,
0.8836224675,
-0.2134378403,
0.471729964,
0.4110678434,
0.2699298561,
0.2775880992,
-0.5922183394,
-0.0225867145,
-0.226795882,
0.0131295817,
0.2848194242,
-0.5293937922,
0.8156043887,
-0.4442486167,
-0.2616397738,
-0.2105064839,
0.8174775839,
0.1062367111,
0.3758707345,
0.5918774009,
0.0687701553,
0.8269753456,
-0.2001905888,
0.9521043301,
0.0032036388,
0.0718074292,
1.0966454744,
-0.1481285542,
0.8896627426,
0.5183170438,
-0.1487571746,
0.5231113434,
0.6114504337,
0.3709468544,
-0.0573216714,
0.4928455949,
-0.0510699414,
-0.2510897517,
0.0402083844,
-0.2858608663,
0.3070355356,
0.58355546,
-0.1524119079,
0.1311605424,
0.067802161,
-0.0687821284,
0.3006651998,
-0.3602798581,
0.8625878096,
-0.0737983435,
-0.7205402851,
0.5744161606,
0.3751147985,
0.6703010201,
-0.5624182224,
0.0497955866,
-0.3131940961,
-0.2841552198,
-0.2961185873,
-1.1509766579,
-0.0128504355,
0.2145949304,
-0.2055075169,
-0.1107224822,
0.8566851616,
-0.4760590792,
-0.7133408189,
0.1816489697,
0.4550464451,
0.2192130685,
0.1152542308,
-0.5402547121,
0.1311705261,
-0.1681444049,
-0.3914261162,
0.1565977335,
0.6091342568,
0.0335315354,
0.8239842653,
0.5270658135,
-0.0241758078,
0.0755358413,
0.1531956941,
0.7532637715,
-0.6646771431,
-0.3009495735,
-0.9479935169,
0.4727012217,
-0.0701304898,
-0.4778057039,
0.5789836645,
0.1660052091,
0.665884912,
0.1256718338,
0.8006573915,
0.1630956382,
0.8092305064,
-0.7523208261,
0.3090028763,
-0.7392596602,
0.5120380521,
-0.4272890091,
-0.6857073307,
-0.0959742591,
0.3057115078,
-0.4023761451,
0.2329619974,
0.5630235672,
0.8590603471,
0.0767883211,
0.1092871502,
0.2710508704,
0.2307044119,
0.1457458884,
0.7687138915,
1.0245257616,
-0.0322898403,
0.8291435242,
-0.0215325784,
0.018963743,
-0.2623017728,
-0.8117972016,
-1.2058838606,
-0.4369686544,
-0.2272460908,
-0.276843369,
0.3044139147,
0.7205065489,
0.3074213564,
-0.69527179,
-0.2344702631,
-0.1550462842,
0.4283055663,
0.319288075,
-0.1604931056,
0.2725791633,
-0.5557444096,
-1.0941272974,
0.2324214727,
0.1188927814,
0.3405503929,
-0.4317306578,
-0.3109362423,
0.0587757416,
0.5280246139,
0.4718261659,
0.1258194745,
-0.4546365142,
-0.3782669008,
0.2215828747,
-0.6505494714,
0.2101237029,
1.0450146198,
-0.4411067069,
0.5647360086,
0.3940162361,
0.6843330264,
0.3766659796,
0.2214238644,
0.6022767425,
-1.0439107418,
-0.0929276422,
-0.2117831856,
-0.0244108923,
0.4208527505,
-0.6413583159,
0.2235222012,
-0.1704571843,
-0.6314415336,
-0.7148923874,
-0.105290398,
-0.6839437485,
-0.456392467,
1.2865071297,
0.1024439856,
-0.0601249151,
-0.1917895973,
-0.6698830724,
0.0812487677,
-0.3778601885,
0.948841989,
0.9534515738,
-0.0495277084,
-0.3632659912,
-0.6025371552,
0.5714057684,
0.7973729372,
-0.968296349,
-0.1063618362,
0.4252824783,
0.1925958544,
-0.2429901063,
0.5811778307,
0.3690737784,
-0.0081220092,
-0.6045795679,
-0.3171753883,
-0.000924498,
-0.5352509022,
-0.3067766726,
0.2652203739,
0.2465393394,
0.2248351723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14889v2
|
COBIAS: Contextual Reliability in Bias Assessment
| 2024-02-22T10:46:11 | 2024-06-17T09:01:25 |
Priyanshul Govil, Hemang Jain, Vamshi Krishna Bonagiri, Aman Chadha, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Manas Gaur, Sanorita Dey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on extensive web corpora, which
enable them to understand and generate human-like text. However, this training
process also results in inherent biases within the models. These biases arise
from web data's diverse and often uncurated nature, containing various
stereotypes and prejudices. Previous works on debiasing models rely on
benchmark datasets to measure their method's performance. However, these
datasets suffer from several pitfalls due to the highly subjective
understanding of bias, highlighting a critical need for contextual exploration.
We propose understanding the context of inputs by considering the diverse
situations in which they may arise. Our contribution is two-fold: (i) we
augment 2,291 stereotyped statements from two existing bias-benchmark datasets
with points for adding context; (ii) we develop the Context-Oriented Bias
Indicator and Assessment Score (COBIAS) to assess a statement's contextual
reliability in measuring bias. Our metric aligns with human judgment on
contextual reliability of statements (Spearman's $\rho = 0.65, p = 3.4 *
10^{-60}$) and can be used to create reliable datasets, which would assist bias
mitigation works.
|
[
-0.6337559223,
-0.6815697551,
0.5850616097,
0.4342356026,
-0.0668875501,
-0.1694770455,
-0.393129319,
-0.4204475582,
-0.0761534646,
0.2254239768,
-0.4114902616,
-0.529789269,
-0.7231225967,
0.1426920891,
-0.4114729762,
0.9024909139,
-0.1254945099,
0.4324827492,
-0.5246593356,
-0.4262571931,
-0.6221388578,
-0.498773247,
-0.2715100944,
-0.2022864819,
0.160648495,
0.3912269175,
0.6221356392,
0.3363011181,
0.440562427,
0.1229551956,
-0.1638085991,
-0.1328606904,
-0.603562057,
0.4579259157,
-0.5445664525,
-0.3979089856,
-0.3649696708,
0.1786286086,
0.3134627938,
1.1620221138,
0.0527312607,
0.3306216598,
0.2930225134,
0.3539144397,
-0.8324610591,
0.0450041406,
-0.7056763768,
0.1379585266,
-0.071801804,
0.1002240852,
-0.4862112403,
-0.4843405187,
0.5518715382,
-0.5160732865,
0.1843189299,
0.1374017,
0.4486685693,
0.399256289,
-0.7631022334,
-0.5386188626,
-0.6333628893,
1.1295506954,
-0.4646422565,
0.3102121353,
0.4747926593,
0.345177263,
-0.0990311131,
-0.2076839358,
-0.2549778223,
-0.2360138595,
-0.0249523465,
0.0097498866,
0.0248206407,
-0.2950244546,
0.3414307237,
0.1551355571,
-0.3714671731,
0.1323699057,
-0.2187828869,
-0.3472281694,
0.6015843153,
0.0852135569,
0.2748659551,
-0.1409971267,
-0.6040920615,
-0.0904224515,
-0.7306234837,
-0.1194530427,
0.3824715912,
0.1663788408,
-0.2612307072,
0.3153523505,
-0.2207214981,
0.8472337127,
0.1527582109,
-0.2322094142,
0.3082018197,
-0.2343746424,
-0.2317545414,
0.0143446112,
0.5211698413,
0.5569443703,
0.4082960784,
-0.2789932489,
0.0815773457,
0.1850405335,
0.2747461796,
-0.5147041678,
0.1838854402,
0.4455409348,
-0.2080135494,
-0.2821570039,
0.0614120662,
-0.9865718484,
-0.559378624,
-0.2227453738,
0.0536833592,
-0.2681629062,
-0.0590877756,
-0.2359592766,
-0.2766169012,
0.0548542105,
0.3574955463,
-0.572484076,
0.2043679506,
0.3898841441,
0.5188536644,
-0.4594450891,
-0.1959909052,
-0.4742313623,
0.1338264942,
-0.4097723067,
0.4142569602,
-0.5977655649,
-0.2962929606,
0.248952657,
-0.2946950197,
0.3254374564,
-0.7026435137,
0.929400146,
-0.547021091,
0.1568601578,
-0.7466212511,
-0.4273853898,
-0.201443404,
0.5523205996,
-0.6308028698,
0.9077707529,
0.2211847901,
-0.9308018684,
0.7825770378,
-0.3593687713,
-0.3729614913,
-0.3842387199,
-0.3025449216,
-0.137777999,
0.1006534919,
0.3532780707,
0.3346428871,
-0.4854667485,
0.8016654849,
-0.8124931455,
-0.3794907928,
0.4677823484,
-0.5516114235,
0.9232970476,
0.1119499281,
-0.5708384514,
-0.317207396,
-0.980197072,
-0.2054961175,
-0.2515399158,
-0.2744850814,
-0.8001684546,
0.0006012456,
0.1027982831,
0.39302966,
0.0933050439,
-0.4210953414,
-0.1020163521,
-0.1882200241,
0.1280788779,
0.780664742,
-0.1271931082,
0.583031714,
-0.0437932201,
0.3696578741,
0.2623220384,
-0.0005732732,
0.0639678463,
-0.0616709441,
-0.8800374866,
-0.2390816957,
0.2040633112,
0.4038247466,
-0.4941180348,
0.5113918185,
-0.2582348287,
-0.3877517283,
0.0308852699,
0.2325362265,
0.505222261,
0.6953570247,
0.5377013683,
-0.4960631728,
-0.8707019687,
-1.0172439814,
-0.4419263005,
0.0651220754,
-0.1120107174,
0.3924675584,
0.6042351723,
-0.4534491301,
1.3341897726,
-0.2313614935,
-0.1776821017,
-0.0794220045,
0.1787129939,
0.0287819467,
0.3210227787,
0.6031890512,
-0.5589973927,
-0.3197906017,
-0.7035281658,
-1.1638596058,
-0.4121631384,
0.1337261796,
0.1044681594,
0.0544476546,
0.2452858388,
-0.2583832443,
0.2828817666,
0.7719553113,
-0.3483214378,
0.4617311358,
0.2964219153,
-0.0724947676,
-0.9564632177,
-0.019612005,
0.3509189188,
-0.1490529478,
-0.3759697974,
-0.096253477,
-0.3297390044,
0.1234416515,
-0.3218050599,
0.6768085957,
-0.5234467387,
-0.3888455927,
0.0817735568,
0.3766542971,
0.1686889827,
0.1477084458,
-0.1510985345,
0.6619114876,
0.4754806161,
-0.6780324578,
0.2408702821,
0.2048561871,
-0.5623607635,
0.9693484306,
-0.534999609,
0.1366902143,
0.0254050568,
0.5135879517,
-0.8522262573,
-0.2561047375,
0.2194671631,
-0.1895290613,
-0.0865638107,
0.0143556651,
-0.0453482643,
-0.1341254115,
-0.3552898169,
0.5701401234,
0.1011474282,
-0.704882443,
0.2282642722,
0.6380463243,
-0.0920195356,
-1.1012524366,
-0.7742968798,
0.0390932299,
-0.2358438969,
-0.5757840276,
0.1314643472,
-0.0391788632,
-0.8731507659,
-0.2249847054,
-0.1745734513,
-0.1862124205,
0.247044757,
0.4004015326,
0.1550625116,
0.0074705794,
0.0129953511,
0.1599723995,
0.2054927647,
0.31863904,
0.0145292385,
0.6185365319,
-0.0465516411,
-0.423530668,
-0.1925254166,
0.2320625484,
0.5354062319,
0.2417249382,
0.6396818161,
0.4686350226,
-0.2495429218,
-0.0959555805,
-0.6381098628,
-0.115771845,
-0.3514712453,
0.3568509221,
-0.3960453272,
-0.9300423861,
0.5539832115,
0.0926104337,
-0.1385092288,
0.4292141795,
0.6249271631,
-0.2771859467,
0.7051926851,
0.5106474757,
-0.2655933201,
0.0871184841,
0.0740221888,
-0.0552731715,
-0.8776060939,
-0.1243445873,
-0.4151675105,
-0.2311137766,
-0.3927813768,
-0.4027676582,
0.5125017166,
0.0601045303,
-0.3508514166,
-0.0021628258,
-0.2258674055,
0.1676080823,
0.4451948404,
0.0022309166,
0.3364520669,
0.1096563265,
-0.3433409333,
-0.1464281976,
-0.4328883588,
-0.7261143327,
1.336979866,
0.5216492414,
0.9175710082,
0.1051808223,
0.5098164082,
0.5574605465,
0.6025873423,
-0.4976027608,
0.3210094869,
0.2734541297,
-1.0576877594,
-0.3465994895,
-0.2813789845,
-0.4974726737,
0.2973744571,
-0.2167422324,
-0.7524510622,
0.5450571775,
0.2992097139,
-0.3046558499,
-0.1333214343,
-0.3950849771,
0.5826562047,
-0.3178810775,
-0.7662485838,
-0.1450475901,
-0.5189503431,
0.5673698783,
0.0022610913,
0.5263966322,
-0.0768604502,
-0.0625268668,
0.9562122226,
-0.2373511791,
0.9703060389,
-0.2017288506,
-0.325612545,
0.285369575,
0.135485068,
0.2728305757,
0.3658884168,
-0.3677372932,
0.4478628039,
-0.0609460548,
-0.3406442106,
-0.4809893072,
0.5904268622,
-0.7861989141,
-0.581571281,
-0.7348626852,
-0.6346914768,
-0.567614913,
-0.0752929002,
0.1742868572,
0.404699564,
-0.648017168,
0.1818558127,
0.5378688574,
-0.35207358,
0.2336789072,
0.3178551793,
-0.076693669,
-0.3785130382,
0.3031936586,
0.0818831176,
0.1330294311,
0.0099305753,
0.0363111198,
-0.1079543903,
-0.3461193442,
-0.4790503979,
-0.2250218093,
-0.9143195748,
-0.130792439,
-0.4743208289,
0.1906988323,
-0.3694541156,
-0.2211520076,
-0.338542223,
-0.1908827424,
-0.0348794125,
-0.2279058993,
0.0222434681,
0.6622456908,
-0.0606276877,
0.1634903997,
-0.4854531288,
0.1563613266,
0.3959576488,
0.265709728,
0.035627339,
-0.584648788,
-0.1387064457,
0.1076051667,
-0.1068840474,
-1.0402458906,
0.3069680333,
-0.2523386478,
0.536744833,
0.4745297134,
-0.0259912778,
0.397685349,
-0.2257027775,
0.8174909353,
0.1134953797,
-1.114343524,
0.4043908119,
-0.4482395053,
0.0617407449,
0.9659472108,
0.6431336403,
-0.430231154,
-0.2488366067,
-0.3089498878,
-0.8263168335,
0.5077288151,
-0.0950897038,
-0.0098490575,
-0.0606088527,
0.3575801253,
0.4049139917,
0.2359237969,
-0.757633388,
-0.23005642,
-0.1733633131,
-0.2589151561,
-0.1633273661,
-0.7230018377,
-0.5365765691,
-0.3128345311,
0.6164594293,
-0.1264632493,
-0.0383158848,
0.2101881355,
-0.7607055902,
0.1077868491,
0.613928318,
0.612267971,
1.2410638332,
-0.491176784,
0.3765794635,
0.4026086032,
-0.3790034354,
0.3439917266,
-0.1401129216,
-0.5069673657,
0.0716505647,
0.3018780351,
0.5838343501,
0.2243553698,
-0.6671151519,
0.5443663001,
-0.0534493253,
0.3125450611,
-0.5950686932,
-0.2623689175,
-0.076685451,
0.0362597145,
0.4413352907,
0.1915910989,
0.3825331032,
-0.8092507124,
0.2737716436,
0.4854320884,
-0.751747787,
-0.2055899501,
0.4091412723,
0.5338930488,
0.1835432351,
0.4016023278,
-0.3145348132,
-0.6126307845,
0.5722859502,
0.4781414866,
0.680868268,
-0.0142460298,
0.0450263321,
0.5277377963,
0.416444689,
-0.1436276138,
-0.1515683383,
0.1274163425,
-0.9417240024,
-0.1419654936,
-0.6996517777,
-0.5796812773,
0.1796018481,
-0.7913255095,
0.2188149244,
-0.3714801669,
-0.3076557219,
-0.4638734758,
-0.1710058302,
-0.842448771,
0.6536121368,
0.2262747735,
0.9188432097,
-1.2257670164,
0.4925990403,
0.5021817088,
-0.472710073,
-0.3656693101,
0.3047305346,
0.1465941966,
-0.6381776333,
1.0099580288,
0.1733690947,
-0.0374438986,
-0.6099835634,
-0.4623204768,
-1.0241624117,
1.0055623055,
0.445307225,
-0.698130548,
0.0824149102,
0.1607269049,
0.4248753488,
-0.5804899335,
0.5929825306,
0.6724658608,
0.5571776032,
-0.1965877414,
-0.8767437935,
0.3442873657,
0.2065520585,
0.1442210078,
-0.6515492201,
-0.6014232635,
0.8550152183,
-0.0492417701,
0.1151260883,
-0.1834256053,
0.6023292542,
0.3505252898,
0.4079712033,
0.5969824195,
0.6358051896,
0.8586227298,
-0.0749938264,
1.0479729176,
-0.203908056,
0.4184483588,
1.3537256718,
-0.4093833864,
0.5732638836,
0.6147266626,
-0.0924465582,
0.7965145111,
0.5632981658,
0.0502796546,
0.414542079,
0.2105543762,
-0.0731598511,
-0.2056668103,
-0.1893222481,
-0.348662734,
0.7915286422,
0.2557550967,
-0.6140149832,
-0.2042131871,
-0.0563703589,
0.3032306731,
0.1538431942,
-0.1471516043,
0.392752409,
0.2340014577,
-0.8395525813,
0.3629868329,
0.0384961553,
0.8908202052,
-0.1389627308,
0.1651480198,
-0.369473666,
0.2236120999,
-0.205238238,
-0.4637536108,
0.3848811686,
0.0560096093,
-0.4472661912,
-0.0461710654,
0.6689385176,
-0.2001962513,
-0.4900274873,
0.4770700634,
0.6407595277,
-0.0063187671,
0.0977263227,
-0.4067189693,
0.5688396096,
-0.1919965744,
-0.2756591737,
0.3849063218,
-0.110603191,
-0.2457685769,
0.6271518469,
0.162838906,
-0.089900434,
-0.0769690424,
0.13683258,
0.5452262759,
-0.537366271,
-0.1091741398,
-1.0593621731,
0.1622390151,
-0.4140413404,
-0.3326977193,
0.8695773482,
0.6046779156,
0.8617433906,
-0.0450978838,
1.2437214851,
-0.0713797808,
0.4865416288,
-0.3415338993,
0.6950746775,
-0.3459793627,
0.343542099,
-0.3787703514,
-1.0516608953,
-0.1336423755,
0.7356522083,
-0.693136394,
0.2400352061,
0.6533582211,
0.5004865527,
-0.082340844,
-0.0466706529,
0.1273380071,
0.3401892483,
0.0785363689,
0.499012351,
0.8584173918,
-0.4761951268,
0.3712695241,
-0.1204909608,
-0.3583588898,
-0.3963376284,
-0.8629319668,
-1.0166789293,
-0.3428148031,
-0.2315416783,
-0.5808725357,
0.166588828,
0.814499855,
0.6615051031,
-0.9434283376,
-0.3238972127,
0.2285708636,
0.3045642972,
-0.0292489976,
-0.2499549389,
0.1279836893,
-0.3244690597,
-0.7763392925,
0.1366426647,
0.2504298985,
-0.4431465864,
-0.6388632655,
0.0037379286,
-0.1545099169,
0.1848410219,
0.6399342418,
0.0837430209,
-0.7230888009,
-0.6167964935,
-0.1506203264,
-0.2951954901,
0.1199210286,
0.6175166965,
-0.7542995811,
0.3474899232,
0.4052519798,
0.540191412,
0.3063830435,
-0.0174748451,
0.8691888452,
-0.7113671899,
0.1859537661,
0.1581532657,
0.566031456,
0.6949477196,
-0.0634024516,
0.5879435539,
0.3019566238,
-0.1864110082,
-0.8233124614,
0.374233216,
-1.062251687,
-0.090222314,
1.4598693848,
-0.2654535472,
-0.1068196595,
-0.3639665842,
0.0522420444,
0.3270452321,
-0.2455714196,
1.0411145687,
0.9769400358,
-0.0407010578,
0.2677020431,
-0.3734317124,
0.452973634,
0.6032394171,
-0.7403048873,
-0.0760849267,
0.650775969,
0.6974807978,
0.4464188814,
0.5399708748,
-0.0160160195,
0.0629141778,
-0.0359458812,
0.0435497425,
0.329059422,
-0.2106667459,
-0.245055154,
0.4345813394,
0.1041178107,
0.1650583744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14433v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14433v1
|
A Language Model's Guide Through Latent Space
| 2024-02-22T10:25:14 | 2024-02-22T10:25:14 |
Dimitri von Rütte, Sotiris Anagnostidis, Gregor Bachmann, Thomas Hofmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2
|
Concept guidance has emerged as a cheap and simple way to control the
behavior of language models by probing their hidden representations for concept
vectors and using them to perturb activations at inference time. While the
focus of previous work has largely been on truthfulness, in this paper we
extend this framework to a richer set of concepts such as appropriateness,
humor, creativity and quality, and explore to what degree current detection and
guidance strategies work in these challenging settings. To facilitate
evaluation, we develop a novel metric for concept guidance that takes into
account both the success of concept elicitation as well as the potential
degradation in fluency of the guided model. Our extensive experiments reveal
that while some concepts such as truthfulness more easily allow for guidance
with current techniques, novel concepts such as appropriateness or humor either
remain difficult to elicit, need extensive tuning to work, or even experience
confusion. Moreover, we find that probes with optimal detection accuracies do
not necessarily make for the optimal guides, contradicting previous
observations for truthfulness. Our work warrants a deeper investigation into
the interplay between detectability, guidability, and the nature of the
concept, and we hope that our rich experimental test-bed for guidance research
inspires stronger follow-up approaches.
|
[
-0.060695041,
-0.9201558232,
0.8515269756,
0.1388221532,
-0.3153947592,
0.1310922056,
-0.1457897574,
0.2778333426,
-0.1011273861,
0.226874426,
-0.5072680116,
-0.4530701637,
-0.3704456091,
-0.3725104332,
-0.2526459992,
0.932507813,
0.1614909023,
-0.2297030091,
-0.1331884563,
0.0542032644,
-0.7328321338,
-0.2384340018,
-0.5167340636,
-0.3537555337,
0.6967745423,
0.5386600494,
0.753549397,
0.5854581594,
0.3403495252,
0.1360822022,
-0.7492356896,
0.0651867837,
-0.3210636377,
0.1163695082,
-0.2788938582,
-0.7488331199,
-0.45255813,
0.3472723365,
0.6379123926,
1.1109204292,
-0.5089627504,
-0.3237787783,
0.0803223699,
0.3345883787,
-0.3852951825,
0.1214723364,
-0.3772729635,
-0.0788865834,
-0.1876843572,
-0.3373954296,
-0.3381543756,
-0.3321632743,
0.2280137241,
-0.8375722766,
0.2764907181,
0.0308225118,
0.8001989126,
0.4773477912,
-0.290220201,
-0.6096775532,
-0.7224991918,
0.6644111872,
-0.5395322442,
0.3699145317,
0.5424564481,
0.3644508719,
-0.2897493243,
-0.605807662,
-0.4580888152,
-0.2509723008,
0.0597687885,
0.2379729301,
-0.182719335,
-0.0802023336,
0.373531431,
0.2018268108,
-0.5150862932,
-0.0571537055,
-0.0995535105,
-0.1733440757,
0.3139331639,
-0.2608631253,
0.0912958458,
-0.2683652937,
0.0321081355,
-0.042996116,
-0.739035368,
0.1036452949,
0.5077281594,
0.2844700813,
-0.0524628013,
0.3113517165,
-0.0421304181,
0.5757320523,
0.0459013805,
-0.0985103697,
0.0431571007,
-0.4559744,
0.234197095,
-0.0983641148,
0.2809592485,
0.2642584741,
0.1326750219,
-0.3349266052,
-0.3205581307,
0.1332629919,
0.470741868,
-0.5556774139,
-0.4784432352,
-0.1451672614,
-0.3710411191,
-0.2712591588,
-0.1884858906,
-0.422791332,
-0.3573313951,
-0.1714680046,
0.166614458,
-0.6287232041,
-0.7082142234,
0.1124020368,
-0.231571272,
0.4731536806,
0.4267856479,
-0.661367476,
0.0038844717,
0.8780890107,
1.0207633972,
-0.100155063,
0.3132136166,
-0.5030741692,
-0.0523487329,
-0.8111961484,
0.7827649713,
-0.8850553632,
-0.7039785981,
-0.4118961692,
-0.2077338099,
0.0763496235,
-0.3312324286,
0.9230256677,
-0.4085894227,
0.2480786145,
-0.582205236,
-0.6790338755,
-0.3832923174,
0.0249764025,
-0.4444885254,
0.7337170839,
0.1589850038,
-0.5784648061,
0.6115207672,
-0.701300323,
-0.180281207,
0.2543097138,
-0.5478819013,
-0.0582607761,
0.358548224,
-0.1002622619,
0.4016385376,
0.1360148787,
0.5418816209,
-0.0725322142,
-0.5931015015,
0.0496112816,
-0.4845778644,
0.5075263977,
0.3442669511,
-0.195207715,
-0.1357745081,
-0.7370275259,
-0.1715347171,
0.1425044686,
-0.2360439152,
-0.7491002679,
0.1663974822,
-0.2461438626,
-0.0458014272,
-0.0776441395,
-0.2199284583,
0.1470188946,
-0.5622884631,
0.3428276181,
0.7265831828,
0.0167243201,
0.4612261653,
-0.1328604221,
0.6289035082,
0.0250433981,
-0.0943118036,
-0.3318681419,
-0.7038795948,
-0.6958380938,
0.1463364959,
0.1963478476,
0.2876905203,
-0.7987726927,
0.5519114137,
0.0379423909,
-0.4893321693,
-0.4744383991,
0.0180988945,
0.5235977769,
0.668643117,
0.0991667584,
-0.4580236971,
-0.032649342,
-0.5991311669,
-0.2569448352,
-0.396538496,
0.2723320425,
0.3326133788,
0.4287084341,
-0.0143702505,
0.8589203358,
-0.4661830962,
0.1837369055,
-0.0355988443,
0.3821693957,
0.3394462764,
0.5091261268,
0.5879627466,
-1.1212022305,
0.1023046821,
-0.1355580389,
-0.6478270292,
-0.2287399322,
0.1089162901,
-0.0161939282,
-0.2689768672,
0.6556581855,
-0.08860901,
0.4903691411,
0.3868575692,
-0.675717175,
0.3662467301,
-0.1585022956,
-0.2390923947,
-0.8419647813,
0.136372298,
-0.0189698637,
-0.0239002313,
-0.6389384866,
0.1361566931,
-0.0439155735,
0.2143829018,
-0.0662815496,
0.6271027923,
-0.1377284378,
0.0784276351,
-0.3941068947,
0.3447641134,
0.0996046737,
0.3678041995,
0.0499213077,
0.9548094273,
0.4820213318,
-0.9029895067,
0.3016180992,
0.1430109441,
-0.2872869968,
0.9777517915,
-0.682320118,
0.2925568819,
-0.3537679017,
-0.0001253653,
-1.2012262344,
0.0798440278,
0.1805503964,
-0.5423425436,
0.3402526379,
-0.3273376524,
-0.4364705086,
-0.1425234079,
0.0715822428,
0.2462209016,
0.5524049401,
-0.3417174518,
0.4038806558,
0.0823457986,
-0.0568163544,
-0.5633327961,
-0.5523072481,
-0.0530437492,
-0.3146032989,
-0.2835952342,
0.2753293514,
-0.4346809089,
-0.4676540792,
-0.0308606159,
-0.4320416749,
0.0106293466,
0.519701004,
0.3206408918,
0.0087076314,
-0.3296926618,
0.2816091478,
0.0491940007,
-0.2993369102,
0.1252488792,
-0.3755918443,
0.2453285754,
-0.2187121361,
-0.4028354287,
-0.0304999556,
0.0494269468,
0.0716508105,
-0.0942382663,
0.4734310508,
0.7546440363,
-0.2651932538,
-0.1632460952,
-0.4459865987,
-0.1178931892,
-0.5019376278,
0.1870350093,
-0.6132984757,
-0.6330949664,
0.4619190991,
-0.3067445159,
-0.0401145183,
0.2742638886,
0.1274638623,
-0.0868888274,
0.998126626,
1.0705974102,
0.4845589697,
0.5132399201,
-0.3963583112,
0.4938226044,
-0.9734780788,
-0.373540014,
-0.6072295904,
0.2055309713,
-0.6005823612,
-0.643612802,
0.3262066841,
0.4201798141,
0.3041426539,
0.1787037104,
-0.4121145904,
0.4227472842,
0.275924623,
-0.1332745254,
0.431747824,
-0.3607426286,
-0.754539907,
-0.2379243374,
-0.8838644624,
-0.8809022903,
0.7569339871,
0.3923464715,
0.8542513251,
0.2599920928,
0.3778421581,
0.0334857963,
0.0389511585,
-1.012735486,
0.4862803519,
-0.1403690279,
-0.5656123161,
-0.2410540134,
-0.3363154233,
-0.6945893168,
0.175804466,
0.2424194664,
-0.6390220523,
0.20829162,
0.3143644035,
-0.4822880328,
0.04118618,
-0.8461881876,
0.7573882341,
-0.1976765841,
-0.484418422,
-0.1787834913,
-0.5181299448,
0.1749108136,
-0.3055888116,
0.2604850233,
-0.1073795632,
-0.1040056348,
0.8849015832,
-0.0431799591,
0.6630744934,
-0.3457530141,
-0.557487011,
0.1010776311,
0.1382298917,
0.1728482097,
-0.0433338098,
-0.1262705028,
-0.2020133883,
-0.0621714219,
-0.2926729918,
-0.9667278528,
0.4368664324,
-0.3423114121,
-0.6325465441,
-0.1933306456,
-0.4741599262,
-0.2529555857,
0.2581399381,
0.1401072741,
0.2978545725,
-0.3642994165,
0.1710343063,
1.1923297644,
-0.4623089731,
0.3438676298,
0.7356724739,
-0.1854142249,
0.4327788055,
0.9230305552,
0.0864522159,
0.1859309375,
0.3662919998,
0.4260696769,
-0.5741320848,
-0.5489329696,
-0.2458736449,
0.2554983795,
-0.9151871204,
0.23563914,
-0.3589740396,
-0.1848182529,
-0.2280138284,
-0.0659756884,
-0.3333985209,
-0.3396398127,
-0.3473540545,
-0.1807257831,
0.2552936077,
0.8543586731,
-0.1438168138,
0.483250469,
-0.147285372,
0.0518505238,
0.3399086297,
0.4383610189,
-0.0343758166,
-0.7842084765,
-0.0871032402,
-0.0318158716,
-0.2180843949,
-0.7243340015,
-0.0514460988,
0.0482318103,
0.7910372615,
0.6466611028,
-0.0055338331,
0.5819545388,
-0.3363907337,
0.8142738938,
-0.0684633106,
-1.0459501743,
1.1611325741,
-0.3130659163,
0.1980944127,
0.1512739807,
0.3145986497,
-0.6143094897,
-0.4692206383,
-0.9300664067,
-0.4999651313,
0.588064909,
0.321950227,
0.3371606171,
0.3503100574,
0.7116246819,
-0.0102293072,
0.3673423529,
-0.3922127783,
-0.2180078477,
-0.2846184075,
0.0752084702,
-0.0962421075,
-0.1133284792,
-0.2240976393,
-0.0155185014,
0.3621306121,
-0.3927100897,
0.2829785347,
0.0240649786,
0.1518923193,
-0.0254192036,
0.2989617884,
0.5549553037,
0.8219957352,
-0.212316975,
0.0364709683,
-0.1612967104,
-0.5273650885,
0.0717350692,
0.140234828,
-0.2570229173,
0.1018142253,
0.5513854027,
0.9155865312,
0.1296240687,
-0.3467665911,
0.6873456836,
-0.1736260355,
-0.0079672625,
-0.0026255886,
0.7411780357,
-0.151407212,
0.1591766775,
0.3281731308,
0.0025509109,
0.0368807651,
-0.6943475008,
0.2617835402,
0.4044279158,
-0.5911691189,
-0.4910600185,
0.5949918628,
0.0774761885,
-0.259642452,
0.2536756396,
-0.5482699871,
-0.4935602248,
0.526832521,
0.2676166296,
0.6728896499,
-0.4156415164,
0.3140663803,
0.0553110726,
0.3356752396,
-0.0290706176,
0.3605973423,
-0.2473130822,
-0.9544852972,
-0.4808309674,
-0.3262315392,
-0.4048749208,
0.1071144417,
-0.6856735945,
0.0818926245,
-0.3173164725,
-0.1302132607,
0.1301290095,
0.1498838812,
-0.4804988205,
0.3044396937,
0.0123732975,
0.9889143705,
-0.7684719563,
0.8483687639,
0.8326783776,
-0.5766837001,
-1.1504608393,
0.3675628603,
0.1877525896,
-0.9157247543,
0.4558293521,
-0.0006499335,
-0.4127027392,
-0.0661578402,
-0.7309037447,
-0.6826299429,
0.9772033691,
0.1798724681,
-0.3787297308,
-0.3816990554,
-0.6530938148,
0.7172891498,
-0.1863278449,
0.3797801733,
0.7415226102,
0.5200073123,
0.6618106365,
-0.7920819521,
-0.0988909155,
-0.3529803753,
0.0961043686,
-0.246910125,
-0.618281424,
0.6149020791,
-0.41656515,
-0.2306696028,
0.0023034888,
0.5042199492,
0.2849951386,
0.4025067389,
0.5826248527,
0.3638873398,
1.0082429647,
-0.3517525792,
0.8060945868,
-0.0028690549,
0.0164802596,
0.7752391696,
-0.0687028915,
0.4539677203,
0.4378131628,
0.1824539155,
0.7214176059,
0.6289719939,
0.2460480928,
0.823871851,
0.2893488109,
0.1738176942,
-0.0825229585,
-0.5959840417,
-0.3588197231,
0.4772931039,
0.8842602372,
-0.1065641046,
-0.0271850489,
-0.0058892034,
0.1229439527,
0.3137342334,
-0.0875284225,
0.5719582438,
0.28699103,
-0.8221065402,
0.4583563507,
-0.0023991677,
0.6013560891,
-0.5779659152,
-0.3944642842,
-0.5351169109,
-0.1789568514,
-0.1330133379,
-0.971113205,
0.2694699764,
-0.0195865966,
0.0754656866,
-0.3210964203,
0.580096662,
-0.2090725899,
-0.152444616,
0.3479852676,
0.8414236903,
0.2270915359,
0.1189557761,
-0.5923332572,
-0.0034507483,
-0.1143776923,
-0.0891765654,
-0.3419213891,
0.9833462238,
0.1080544591,
0.8409369588,
0.4451137781,
0.5350993872,
-0.2249834538,
0.2682791054,
0.7873854041,
-0.6767505407,
-0.8498276472,
-0.5099024177,
0.3351806998,
-0.0373663493,
-0.4950222075,
0.7760016918,
0.1115191877,
0.8386040926,
0.5322425961,
0.5393336415,
-0.0115802363,
0.5344569087,
-0.8496870399,
0.4961204827,
-0.7951564193,
0.7475515604,
-0.5108449459,
-0.7074395418,
-0.1329817772,
1.2194193602,
-0.3192078173,
0.3024703562,
0.7853124738,
0.9769579768,
-0.1420028508,
0.1060237661,
0.4420704842,
0.1226402447,
0.4676278234,
0.3796699643,
1.18031919,
-0.0385102965,
0.3546678126,
0.0115160011,
-0.3451449573,
-0.1343091577,
-0.9733381271,
-0.8522117138,
-0.8245402575,
-0.4329212606,
-0.2985624671,
0.1080049798,
0.4636101425,
1.049097538,
-0.4188201725,
-0.0553788543,
-0.2900229394,
0.4505447149,
-0.2000353932,
-0.2250045687,
0.2255954742,
-0.2517003119,
-0.4940883815,
0.5595475435,
0.2802998722,
0.2689015567,
-0.5281416774,
-0.2796682417,
-0.0081049334,
0.0585314445,
0.3714835644,
0.0194168538,
-0.8484991789,
-0.1604764313,
-0.0010577292,
-0.0434186459,
-0.109110631,
0.9654687047,
-0.6338614225,
0.772079587,
0.0895932838,
0.4568506479,
0.0943309963,
-0.1271307468,
0.7569499016,
-1.1619033813,
0.1825674921,
0.5332168937,
0.0844272301,
0.4217101336,
-0.4187948108,
0.8135646582,
0.5216142535,
-0.1995993853,
-0.7988144755,
0.3520484865,
-0.613037765,
-0.3002167344,
1.1361801624,
-0.275875777,
-0.1078509465,
-0.1844940633,
-0.1977941394,
0.3383730948,
-0.508235693,
0.4149591625,
1.0679121017,
-0.1706545204,
-0.2335232049,
-0.6991599798,
0.721275866,
0.5809713006,
-0.3940600455,
-0.045792263,
0.349219501,
0.0704644844,
0.4775080979,
0.6121610999,
0.1309252381,
0.0811077356,
-0.0923776925,
-0.6743444204,
0.2880783975,
-0.5718166828,
-0.606964469,
-0.3587858379,
0.4469968677,
0.0158559568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14428v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14428v2
|
KoCoSa: Korean Context-aware Sarcasm Detection Dataset
| 2024-02-22T10:17:57 | 2024-03-22T06:29:26 |
Yumin Kim, Heejae Suh, Mingi Kim, Dongyeon Won, Hwanhee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sarcasm is a way of verbal irony where someone says the opposite of what they
mean, often to ridicule a person, situation, or idea. It is often difficult to
detect sarcasm in the dialogue since detecting sarcasm should reflect the
context (i.e., dialogue history). In this paper, we introduce a new dataset for
the Korean dialogue sarcasm detection task, KoCoSa (Korean Context-aware
Sarcasm Detection Dataset), which consists of 12.8K daily Korean dialogues and
the labels for this task on the last response. To build the dataset, we propose
an efficient sarcasm detection dataset generation pipeline: 1) generating new
sarcastic dialogues from source dialogues with large language models, 2)
automatic and manual filtering of abnormal and toxic dialogues, and 3) human
annotation for the sarcasm detection task. We also provide a simple but
effective baseline for the Korean sarcasm detection task trained on our
dataset. Experimental results on the dataset show that our baseline system
outperforms strong baselines like large language models, such as GPT-3.5, in
the Korean sarcasm detection task. We show that the sarcasm detection task
relies deeply on the existence of sufficient context. We will release the
dataset at https://github.com/Yu-billie/KoCoSa_sarcasm_detection.
|
[
-0.2117335647,
-0.6019348502,
0.5008392334,
0.3056232333,
-0.5042491555,
-0.0894454196,
-0.1140209138,
-0.2240114361,
0.4929105639,
0.7380239964,
-0.5643286705,
-0.5825680494,
-0.2392164469,
0.1296115965,
0.0796966702,
1.21045959,
0.1794330776,
0.0857820734,
-0.0139476275,
-0.2669731975,
-0.7517226338,
-0.2288327813,
-0.8284820318,
-0.0222802237,
0.447152108,
0.5843248963,
0.5480471253,
0.1700485051,
0.2059988379,
0.2958151102,
0.1084860861,
-0.1085496396,
-0.5042940378,
0.5989518762,
-0.1501667947,
-0.6227020621,
-0.300983429,
-0.2916093469,
0.3611482382,
0.2557535172,
0.1389004886,
0.3369316459,
-0.4579804242,
0.5412093401,
-0.7642002106,
0.3167050779,
-0.5070209503,
0.1753130108,
-0.1590039134,
-0.1795215756,
-0.3534452915,
-0.4744690359,
-0.1373335272,
-0.6272674203,
-0.0714342892,
-0.2742055953,
0.4511044323,
0.4329636693,
-0.5762816072,
-0.4779268801,
-0.367518723,
0.5726858974,
-0.7616017461,
-0.0354019068,
0.258392334,
0.621414721,
-0.1512532085,
-0.6998846531,
-0.4735310972,
-0.3159742653,
-0.062401168,
0.3482520282,
0.0288545713,
0.0735503286,
0.3746634424,
0.0600126013,
-0.5250635147,
-0.3551616967,
-0.0559379011,
-0.2627499104,
0.5311365128,
0.1831615418,
0.5835574865,
-0.6128606796,
-0.3859397471,
0.1457885206,
-0.3435578048,
0.2129247338,
0.5137434602,
0.4128047824,
0.1499581337,
0.2188492268,
-0.5380650163,
0.3867447078,
-0.2873309553,
-0.2696592808,
0.4228405654,
-0.370859921,
-0.2906599343,
0.254858613,
0.5685209036,
0.2115127444,
0.4050799608,
-0.0865238756,
-0.2395404726,
0.4663581252,
0.2721794546,
-0.5724135041,
-0.4143809676,
0.0458621122,
-0.2915453911,
-0.5517469645,
-0.0856210366,
-0.6427610517,
-0.4921375215,
-0.2906299829,
0.0358249247,
-0.0495600328,
-0.3579912782,
-0.1198963076,
-0.3548156917,
-0.1644050926,
0.2063433379,
-0.1907407939,
0.3066062033,
0.3207699656,
0.5820693374,
0.2720451951,
-0.1548364013,
-0.6493418813,
-0.1170828342,
-0.3069378138,
0.6797139049,
-0.4567954838,
-0.2629027367,
-0.3336033225,
0.235844627,
-0.0926987827,
-0.4295530021,
1.0483503342,
-0.3433912694,
0.0058198916,
-0.4579671919,
-0.2311102897,
-0.1676478535,
0.131054163,
-0.8446542621,
1.1608228683,
0.5366421342,
-1.0238542557,
0.0992190912,
-0.6571559906,
-0.4709779024,
0.4063823223,
-0.0972788632,
-0.0658353493,
0.0004174596,
0.2482765913,
0.3315882981,
-0.2452012748,
0.6461240649,
-0.446159482,
-0.4991513193,
0.4154740572,
-0.2878836095,
1.119202733,
0.4585791528,
-0.4882500768,
-0.3874857128,
-0.3532783091,
0.2413694859,
0.134393394,
0.0800424516,
-0.6111041903,
-0.3604759574,
0.0117307818,
0.7409369349,
0.1234235764,
-0.6532202959,
0.1360609531,
-0.2503989339,
0.3807904422,
0.6403387189,
-0.0322784297,
0.2247319967,
-0.0609624013,
0.8590509892,
0.1389845163,
0.2881855369,
-0.5091445446,
-0.597091198,
-0.3280747533,
-0.5397074819,
0.1973365247,
0.8316796422,
-1.1977074146,
0.4135714173,
-0.3673106134,
-0.2493089437,
-0.4342368245,
-0.0072637862,
0.6026835442,
0.8776263595,
0.0751483664,
-0.1334701031,
-0.8148566484,
-0.7547652125,
-0.4131683707,
-0.0522014908,
0.0076172082,
0.5797556639,
0.5103470087,
0.0505279861,
1.0596585274,
-0.5383067727,
-0.1532950997,
-0.132157594,
0.0340774506,
0.0125109171,
-0.029013278,
0.5912383795,
-0.8553173542,
-0.7478888631,
0.1922482848,
-0.9159635305,
-0.4850541353,
0.187871933,
-0.156103164,
0.2563289702,
0.6781147122,
-0.5851441622,
0.4295753837,
0.2090423107,
-0.4449139535,
0.5275467634,
0.5570845604,
0.2989154756,
-1.3809275627,
0.3964084089,
-0.1774059683,
-0.4849871695,
-0.8369813561,
-0.0518937111,
-0.1511398703,
-0.0738400742,
-0.4634827077,
0.7040919662,
-0.0289909542,
-0.049550917,
-0.2547894418,
0.3501914144,
-0.0550974831,
0.5967127681,
-0.2479579747,
0.4018403888,
0.3146052957,
-0.2308320105,
0.5049583912,
-0.0549098738,
-0.1758762747,
0.883706212,
-0.3456487656,
0.0425522886,
-0.181936726,
1.006841898,
-1.2289956808,
-0.6092936397,
0.7467170954,
-0.5443998575,
-0.1843408346,
-0.2984375656,
-0.0825385004,
-0.5906635523,
-0.5023212433,
0.5134994388,
0.2233735919,
-0.4472038448,
0.5011087656,
0.3489980102,
-0.494763881,
-1.0089688301,
-0.6839858294,
0.0998903587,
-0.3133699298,
-0.6075646877,
0.0472116582,
-0.0028319154,
-0.0394212119,
0.0658182204,
-0.1260358989,
-0.1009830013,
-0.1321599931,
0.3031920791,
0.2703132331,
-0.1748867929,
0.2282222956,
0.063310504,
-0.0763731673,
0.0345941186,
-0.142571643,
0.461805433,
0.0886334777,
0.0501190759,
-0.8335180283,
0.1884331405,
0.59074682,
0.5258948207,
0.2652699053,
0.5420001149,
-0.4495218694,
-0.2814852893,
-0.3109157383,
0.0318645276,
-0.4210256636,
0.2539660633,
-0.381952703,
-0.64956218,
0.8459783792,
-0.0362932943,
-0.3886371851,
0.3276984096,
0.2694416642,
0.1415743828,
1.1552652121,
0.1389784962,
-0.5150197148,
0.5023332834,
0.0262392946,
0.4517927468,
-0.7147188783,
-0.0435220972,
-0.5659227371,
-0.3458102942,
-0.4206425846,
-0.2620484233,
0.0588884167,
-0.1538423449,
-0.3246249855,
0.1770216674,
-0.3110194802,
0.8917796612,
0.1535206437,
0.1690217406,
0.1975007206,
-0.1299663186,
0.2068455964,
0.126526311,
-0.5410023928,
-0.3499678969,
0.9996965528,
0.2207155973,
0.4277791381,
-0.2596744001,
0.5028971434,
0.4945546687,
0.3675582409,
-0.8526429534,
0.5891581774,
-0.2552593946,
-0.3380128443,
-0.2973653376,
-0.8095849752,
-0.5045230389,
-0.145637542,
0.46895051,
-0.7205283642,
0.0278772004,
0.1435132027,
-0.172106266,
-0.0052396762,
-0.9771988392,
0.8175778389,
0.2188993096,
0.2180033177,
0.4822121263,
-0.9899905324,
0.5982744098,
0.2863779068,
0.1068509594,
-0.0952530503,
0.0782071128,
0.4447378814,
-0.3267807662,
0.9608857036,
-0.7776303291,
-0.0066631143,
0.6956222057,
0.1073385328,
0.7886835933,
0.3577110469,
0.1415439099,
0.0016549234,
-0.2171497494,
-0.5027734637,
-0.735167861,
0.7815192938,
-0.4138670266,
0.0169721562,
-0.1680182666,
-0.629260242,
-0.1258285642,
0.1939267963,
0.4952994287,
0.1750300527,
-0.173933953,
0.0288401656,
0.4564561546,
0.0773919746,
0.13322182,
0.1395409107,
0.070602484,
-0.583089292,
1.0319943428,
0.2507129014,
0.1553829014,
-0.0283228513,
-0.0222410336,
-0.2428377122,
0.1887666732,
-0.3577665985,
0.0274969116,
-1.0446567535,
-0.4903454185,
-0.6436248422,
-0.2694989145,
-0.5659762025,
-0.2497867048,
-0.2837200165,
-0.6902259588,
0.044171758,
0.1483394951,
0.1132431701,
0.6265374422,
0.4295321703,
0.3010478914,
-0.1857220829,
0.2784895599,
0.2091266513,
0.246609062,
-0.0739100799,
-0.3384248316,
-0.0615059137,
0.344057709,
-0.1450717002,
-0.7270287275,
0.3557870388,
-0.1155632958,
0.2910580635,
0.2032570541,
0.162879467,
0.3470828533,
0.0108630192,
0.8544549942,
-0.0451858938,
-0.9051365256,
0.5281232595,
-0.4494189322,
0.5119473338,
0.6191354394,
0.2736823857,
-0.8275621533,
-0.4647640288,
-0.6705695391,
-0.7251378894,
1.0917500257,
0.2903312445,
0.2046504915,
-0.1281347722,
0.4563378394,
0.1004225388,
0.2639877796,
-0.843890965,
-0.0617662482,
-0.3934848905,
-0.5895857215,
0.0590311848,
0.0028032525,
-0.1788896024,
0.008886789,
0.6750738025,
-0.4450631738,
0.2325467914,
0.1425333768,
-0.2604063451,
-0.0489237607,
0.0993649587,
0.4364399016,
0.1608812511,
0.0133763188,
0.0066310493,
0.1982601583,
-0.716357708,
0.0362372361,
-0.2283326238,
-0.1677239686,
0.1592890918,
0.0292094667,
0.695931673,
0.17532745,
-0.9014027715,
0.6743400693,
-0.1492734849,
-0.1873006374,
-0.1294386685,
0.0785187781,
-0.0442941114,
0.1059707776,
0.1114558876,
0.1502811611,
0.564474225,
-0.3786869049,
0.0715720281,
0.158358559,
-0.3228835464,
-0.3659070432,
-0.0107268849,
0.0632738844,
-0.0460862294,
0.4478434026,
-0.5722379088,
-0.8738756776,
1.1173928976,
0.654542923,
1.0596305132,
-0.5202745199,
0.7312003374,
0.3982841671,
0.1383724511,
-0.2315238118,
0.5290148854,
-0.2753486037,
-0.4557260871,
-0.0470797308,
-0.2817521691,
-0.2035422772,
0.1329467595,
-0.4685069323,
0.4955873191,
-0.2080009133,
-0.206486702,
0.0282834452,
-0.1422480941,
-0.4145869911,
0.2502066791,
-0.0089018997,
0.6382838488,
-1.1794513464,
0.3940594792,
0.5241926312,
-0.0803475305,
-0.4095339775,
0.1885577589,
-0.0420514904,
-0.4991675913,
0.4878797829,
0.4370559454,
-0.3345329165,
-0.2243900299,
-0.7456240058,
-0.6363809705,
1.0855218172,
0.7739244699,
-0.1688911021,
0.2392210066,
0.1073295847,
0.7780649066,
-0.6335272789,
0.3278980851,
0.6728563905,
0.2914982438,
0.1591661721,
-0.5295508504,
0.3018168509,
-0.6119017005,
0.0440246388,
0.2714167535,
-0.7904743552,
0.8456308842,
0.1706774533,
-0.2190728188,
0.0963778272,
0.0780367479,
0.1569404304,
1.0300137997,
0.621799171,
0.6908082962,
0.8122755289,
-0.0866421536,
0.8008598089,
-0.144588843,
0.2751063108,
1.2898435593,
-0.3630426824,
0.3912383616,
0.1896871924,
0.2479684651,
0.636466682,
0.4707078636,
0.4135902226,
0.3878002167,
0.1133471727,
-0.4530436993,
-0.0601961799,
-0.479698658,
-0.3631467819,
0.407609731,
0.4611605704,
-0.4785447419,
-0.0844323039,
0.1774098873,
0.3969987333,
-0.2856450081,
-0.3385263681,
0.6313507557,
-0.0955581367,
-0.8794004321,
0.5043411255,
-0.2420007885,
0.2875589728,
-0.3864857852,
0.1517045796,
-0.4690470099,
-0.1397940367,
-0.3337543905,
-0.5669485927,
0.1264037341,
0.0781231374,
-0.0624012277,
0.4083746374,
1.1415228844,
-0.3767766356,
-0.1144258752,
0.1787123829,
0.1233547777,
0.2042862177,
-0.1854476631,
-0.6205561757,
-0.1966407001,
-0.1379328519,
-0.421992749,
0.077484265,
0.6999948025,
-0.4904041588,
0.6600500345,
0.4700993896,
-0.2455232441,
-0.0578465946,
0.3974600434,
1.0148465633,
-0.5594867468,
-0.9099129438,
-0.4724154472,
0.364584744,
-0.5003762841,
-0.4737811983,
0.544613421,
0.2852889895,
0.6721794009,
-0.1369429082,
1.0703220367,
-0.129454419,
0.3084153235,
-0.2284512073,
0.31358096,
-0.3331223726,
-0.0390548632,
-0.4585828185,
-0.7790852785,
-0.3200414479,
0.3258114755,
-0.1676088721,
0.4962890446,
0.7371572256,
0.8320091963,
-0.1682344377,
0.5631679296,
0.0949150249,
0.3492148519,
0.0518165305,
0.6483735442,
0.5722615123,
-0.6192893386,
0.4250354469,
-0.305978626,
-0.2185829878,
-0.37273404,
-0.7281168699,
-0.7619769573,
-0.4454993606,
-0.0352920964,
-0.3589546978,
0.0102609023,
0.8199567795,
0.3689413965,
-0.7861585617,
0.0666638762,
-0.3982004523,
0.1632817537,
-0.1065072566,
-0.354252547,
0.0801164806,
-0.5510137677,
-0.5046874285,
0.2402865142,
0.3730671406,
-0.3813767135,
-0.0404905342,
-0.1850176156,
-0.059426859,
0.2103479654,
0.6017118692,
0.4146854877,
-0.4204080105,
-0.1618998945,
0.1445116401,
-0.2636206746,
-0.1994159371,
1.0046825409,
-0.8271034956,
0.8246839046,
0.748383522,
0.4735859632,
-0.0457632728,
0.026704371,
0.146253854,
-1.0236352682,
0.2685205042,
0.3297093809,
0.1170160025,
0.3326948881,
-0.7987776995,
0.6905286312,
0.5390354991,
-0.6569658518,
-1.2010041475,
0.1502380222,
-1.0183596611,
-0.1930727214,
0.9608030915,
-0.2698664069,
-0.3029474914,
-0.4686593711,
-0.6326290965,
0.397406131,
-0.5652386546,
0.943959713,
0.8457401991,
0.0276422817,
0.4159607887,
-0.7801029086,
0.6674580574,
0.5018047094,
-0.9138134122,
0.3240332603,
0.3492667675,
0.1826572567,
0.1051302254,
1.0086915493,
-0.0036223179,
0.8533217311,
-0.0187531002,
-0.1201670095,
0.2772033811,
-0.656077981,
-0.2986034751,
0.0905729607,
-0.6831642985,
0.1351323128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14427v1
|
Text me the data: Generating Ground Pressure Sequence from Textual Descriptions for HAR
| 2024-02-22T10:14:59 | 2024-02-22T10:14:59 |
Lala Shakti Swarup Ray, Bo Zhou, Sungho Suh, Lars Krupp, Vitor Fortes Rey, Paul Lukowicz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, eess.SP
|
In human activity recognition (HAR), the availability of substantial ground
truth is necessary for training efficient models. However, acquiring ground
pressure data through physical sensors itself can be cost-prohibitive,
time-consuming. To address this critical need, we introduce Text-to-Pressure
(T2P), a framework designed to generate extensive ground pressure sequences
from textual descriptions of human activities using deep learning techniques.
We show that the combination of vector quantization of sensor data along with
simple text conditioned auto regressive strategy allows us to obtain
high-quality generated pressure sequences from textual descriptions with the
help of discrete latent correlation between text and pressure maps. We achieved
comparable performance on the consistency between text and generated motion
with an R squared value of 0.722, Masked R squared value of 0.892, and FID
score of 1.83. Additionally, we trained a HAR model with the the synthesized
data and evaluated it on pressure dynamics collected by a real pressure sensor
which is on par with a model trained on only real data. Combining both real and
synthesized training data increases the overall macro F1 score by 5.9 percent.
|
[
0.2347252518,
-0.2426831275,
0.7276559472,
0.1107580885,
-0.4542693496,
-0.0894987881,
-0.0682852417,
-0.4887702465,
-0.045841068,
0.4558253288,
-0.190523386,
-0.7217872739,
-0.6906520128,
-0.1245756224,
-0.3416091502,
0.9245952368,
-0.2222035974,
-0.3954012394,
0.1199572384,
0.1183347329,
-0.2452390194,
-0.8337067366,
-0.2499133945,
-0.2563534379,
0.3332896233,
0.3990558088,
0.4769156277,
0.5479129553,
0.5670191646,
0.2272868305,
0.0925850645,
0.4631376266,
-0.2128259391,
0.2508449256,
0.1400286257,
0.2301543802,
-0.1093136445,
0.1453254372,
0.7903620601,
0.4035069644,
0.1025743559,
0.0764113739,
0.2420479655,
0.7349001765,
-0.5224316716,
0.3468521237,
0.0663332865,
0.2681770921,
0.0807619765,
-0.5752668977,
-0.3177391291,
0.2407342345,
0.2156077027,
-0.4625940323,
0.3449270129,
-0.0914910436,
0.9032798409,
0.5710069537,
-0.5861549377,
-0.3292911351,
-1.0788341761,
0.3398100138,
-0.2989963889,
0.4341361225,
0.3612115979,
0.0836715475,
0.2139957547,
-0.7806620002,
-0.3430716395,
0.0434437282,
-0.2329116166,
0.2424074262,
0.3516327143,
-0.1222349703,
0.1010231078,
0.3042660058,
-0.5291346908,
-0.2390545458,
-0.3700312376,
0.0638583004,
0.8702354431,
0.2734516561,
-0.1180793494,
-0.4616277218,
-0.5883937478,
-0.5091284513,
-0.2844569385,
0.5481357574,
0.0495685339,
0.285199523,
-0.3885765374,
0.642260313,
-0.0682240799,
0.6798881292,
-0.0148919402,
-0.2987287939,
0.2853394747,
-0.1290680766,
-0.3113184571,
-0.0495297983,
1.0714856386,
0.222400099,
0.0461852998,
-0.3616798222,
-0.4858958721,
-0.0751514956,
0.3407824337,
-1.0992665291,
-0.1499770731,
-0.0553479791,
-0.4758588672,
-0.7060735822,
0.7227869034,
-0.7483136654,
-0.4772785008,
-0.4586844146,
0.2804808915,
-0.1454075873,
-0.2844559252,
0.4413826168,
-0.2749035656,
-0.040167816,
0.0487254597,
-0.6615815163,
0.3449421227,
0.65630126,
0.9821007848,
0.0045086714,
-0.0852535889,
-0.5454921722,
0.261854142,
-0.3481914103,
0.7539076209,
-0.2294131666,
-0.6186901927,
-0.0731387138,
-0.0691512525,
0.0287045855,
-0.4888783693,
0.7349675298,
-0.331438601,
0.0793477669,
0.142456755,
-0.5177356601,
-0.0311828405,
0.0882341415,
-0.5156537294,
1.4380657673,
0.167239666,
-0.4515010118,
0.1490752995,
-0.4142586887,
-0.6533643007,
-0.127945438,
-0.4682134092,
-0.6082799435,
0.2502397597,
0.0998499468,
0.6083396673,
-0.2762767971,
0.3951379955,
0.1335228235,
-0.0036249391,
0.50104177,
-0.4312086701,
0.3352998793,
-0.0314745493,
-0.4329407811,
-0.1065397635,
-0.9135407209,
0.0232285019,
-0.2071637958,
-0.5733525157,
-0.1157079041,
0.4187486172,
0.0116658891,
0.5064332485,
-0.2215870321,
-0.4035301507,
-0.0732299238,
-0.3276155889,
0.3911001086,
0.4620209634,
0.3574332297,
0.3192424476,
-0.2997637391,
0.2830742598,
-0.3048714399,
-0.2961660624,
-0.1773957759,
-0.4304755628,
-0.4627486467,
-0.2663663626,
0.0537124053,
0.8155488372,
-0.2590504885,
0.8412427902,
-0.6855046749,
-0.7381243706,
-0.1718268991,
0.0621842332,
0.4608952999,
0.9529004097,
0.3883160353,
0.0216761269,
-0.4684542418,
-0.2302130461,
-0.1756523848,
-0.4023502767,
-0.5241751075,
0.4860629737,
0.3497520983,
-0.0693190172,
1.0485254526,
-0.8160920143,
-0.6584312916,
0.1949053854,
0.6888517737,
-0.0801729858,
0.5807387233,
0.4859386981,
-0.9573963284,
-0.3159971535,
-0.2789302468,
-0.7475544214,
-0.2032080144,
-0.1962929815,
-0.2049945444,
0.0767590776,
0.6102794409,
-0.7216715813,
0.7234316468,
0.73993361,
-0.71891886,
0.1813185364,
-0.1476062685,
0.0601826794,
-1.1961190701,
0.2482138574,
0.119383283,
-0.3506549299,
-0.5462649465,
-0.1927238107,
-0.035380777,
-0.7744927406,
-0.4208277166,
0.5868216753,
-0.4449026585,
-0.0163741168,
-0.418302983,
-0.4491661191,
0.2208566666,
0.3775641024,
0.7245693207,
0.5417174101,
0.1869943291,
-1.0025131702,
0.2998479605,
0.4153316617,
-0.4914056361,
-0.2589387,
-0.7485095263,
0.1612255871,
0.1145423874,
0.4030587673,
-1.179682374,
-0.6441339254,
0.1462150365,
-0.7142068148,
0.3529807329,
-0.0898187459,
-0.6074368358,
-0.2920771837,
-0.1344816536,
0.4415029585,
0.8736547232,
-0.6575889587,
0.6187856793,
0.4766925871,
-0.0246640667,
-0.0325882696,
-0.906443119,
-0.0226510838,
-0.075640671,
-0.5231797695,
0.6824272275,
0.2336565256,
0.0720434561,
-0.072940059,
-0.236763075,
-0.3955412805,
-0.0172892995,
0.7385576367,
0.1056352258,
0.0961196944,
0.3609867096,
-0.2419526875,
-0.3923538327,
0.3729568422,
-0.3112835288,
0.3056973219,
0.1094133705,
-0.0013155253,
-0.6619352102,
0.3218016922,
0.4226669371,
0.0713327378,
0.4073695838,
0.5337798595,
-0.6630581021,
0.2316495925,
0.2059379816,
-0.1367103606,
-0.508910656,
0.0647685677,
-0.2822686732,
-0.7363700867,
-0.2132885605,
-0.2619464695,
0.0156845674,
0.4526996017,
0.464166522,
-0.54447788,
0.8201383352,
0.4449861944,
0.0343587026,
0.360260129,
-0.2405509949,
0.2027826011,
-0.5343348384,
-0.4457979798,
-0.4866493642,
-0.4405508935,
-0.4035664797,
-0.745888114,
0.5095172524,
0.150657773,
-0.3247501552,
0.1885576695,
-0.7032526731,
0.0655080825,
0.3204451799,
0.4321835339,
-0.0932387635,
0.2597571015,
0.2558308244,
-0.3393582404,
-0.1820153147,
-0.7541040778,
0.9119948149,
0.283352524,
0.6290232539,
0.2559711635,
0.6385871768,
0.4360145628,
0.2479055375,
-0.8823980093,
0.474635005,
-0.1937208772,
-0.4801405072,
-0.287966758,
-0.313347131,
-0.8010160327,
-0.0849636346,
-0.4115916193,
-0.3015838861,
0.2812911868,
0.3392158151,
-0.6365761161,
0.1139829531,
-0.6662310958,
0.5935934186,
-0.4466481507,
-0.366037339,
0.1238835081,
-0.8552327156,
0.0749217719,
0.0574005023,
0.1036918983,
-0.2088095397,
-0.3709895909,
0.7160622478,
-0.5846976638,
1.1331683397,
-0.350731045,
-0.2925916314,
0.5669868588,
-0.2455062866,
0.5813630819,
0.3921350539,
-0.0990020186,
0.0229733139,
-0.6962616444,
-0.2819232345,
-0.5282202363,
0.3194777369,
-0.889785707,
-0.1598791182,
-0.5749564171,
-0.2890335023,
-0.0752828345,
-0.0914931446,
0.4863628745,
0.596365571,
-0.1877927929,
0.0977358371,
0.4779060781,
-0.0345784463,
0.6450611353,
0.3320016563,
0.2404330522,
-0.8395915031,
0.9214257598,
-0.1468084306,
-0.0940130576,
1.0486274958,
0.2271758616,
-0.4118879735,
0.031773746,
-0.2694269419,
-0.0376194976,
-0.2237801701,
-0.4650783837,
-0.6900565028,
-0.2976584733,
-0.688144505,
-0.2299193144,
-0.2190175205,
-0.45043841,
-0.6924310327,
-0.3487035632,
0.4202860892,
0.4807639122,
-0.2837914228,
0.4237578511,
-1.1760234833,
0.8912150264,
0.564817369,
0.0303365141,
-0.5808905959,
-0.5161115527,
-0.1054905057,
-0.0605132803,
-0.4632265568,
-0.7907512188,
0.6773751378,
0.4906693697,
-0.3479067385,
0.476669997,
0.3925932646,
0.5804622769,
-0.5845241547,
0.7888641953,
0.1971841455,
-0.8410810828,
0.6105817556,
-0.196301043,
-0.0386349037,
0.209496811,
0.4592030048,
-0.3682215512,
0.1762308478,
-0.5874301791,
-1.0260680914,
0.4389211535,
0.2911183536,
0.170074895,
0.0999387056,
0.5732310414,
-0.0953586996,
0.0847876221,
-0.7176115513,
0.1577786058,
-0.3903355002,
-0.3762885332,
-0.1846538633,
-0.3607780039,
-0.0378487706,
-0.4488523006,
0.3755465448,
-0.1494071782,
0.6589680314,
0.6644960046,
-0.104183428,
-0.1611151993,
0.0931737199,
0.6516264081,
0.0667676181,
-0.1607720256,
0.3257282972,
-0.2999255955,
-0.5278552175,
0.4985672235,
0.3325376809,
-0.1664423794,
0.3049195111,
0.517698288,
0.9836990833,
0.1780515909,
-0.7811661959,
0.6662290096,
0.1023891121,
-0.4732739627,
-0.5622429252,
0.1551680565,
-0.1247566417,
0.072876811,
0.4940443635,
0.2784043252,
0.1153145283,
-0.1313658059,
0.2104939818,
-0.1505859196,
-0.4489621222,
-0.5176807046,
0.6639404893,
0.5427239537,
-0.4042609036,
0.6125071049,
-0.111779809,
-0.5271711946,
0.4526588917,
0.2851126194,
0.8758239746,
-0.2532289624,
0.0474587008,
0.7071275711,
0.1125096083,
-0.0206325091,
0.5974322557,
-0.1740249842,
-0.5459097028,
-0.5247122645,
-0.3369483054,
-0.3528814316,
0.3520556092,
-0.6224371791,
0.5217934847,
-0.4960382879,
-0.0231448095,
-0.0871069282,
0.0364608429,
-0.4973349571,
0.8291262984,
0.412820667,
0.6916803122,
-1.0246021748,
0.5779128671,
0.6661276817,
-0.1880510896,
-0.7925326824,
0.3654121161,
-0.2760264277,
-0.46781376,
0.7092530727,
0.5781837106,
0.0364124477,
0.1051081419,
-0.4915163219,
-0.6436742544,
1.0503534079,
0.1007251218,
-0.4701676071,
-0.2899493575,
0.4780384302,
0.6424097419,
-0.3138442338,
-0.2875246108,
0.049289763,
0.4503492415,
-0.2762310803,
-0.3614778519,
0.1682851166,
-0.3567062318,
-0.1218289509,
0.2912123203,
-0.5647329092,
0.5967639089,
-0.2180870771,
-0.5071480274,
0.1971802264,
0.9232807755,
0.3660146594,
0.3716246784,
0.5879565477,
0.7195483446,
0.673275888,
-0.0397278927,
1.0679998398,
-0.3906772733,
0.2766362727,
1.1065685749,
-0.28144297,
0.9631681442,
0.3078194857,
0.1958552301,
0.4469773769,
0.7135719061,
0.1119447723,
0.8539427519,
0.0500711352,
-0.5566802621,
-0.2977648377,
0.0554771721,
-0.2413579971,
0.3869947791,
0.3876852691,
-0.614931941,
-0.0786429271,
-0.0235242117,
-0.4183090031,
0.1527918428,
0.1145026162,
0.6560736895,
0.0126635116,
-0.7375301719,
0.5135957599,
0.1187228784,
0.4800226092,
-0.329377979,
-0.2327299863,
0.2956136167,
0.1121786162,
-0.1808105707,
-0.9227079153,
0.575330019,
0.3027938008,
-0.4393523932,
-0.9203134179,
0.7978048921,
-0.2985809743,
-0.4007121027,
0.0319028795,
0.2579335868,
0.3060916364,
-0.289827019,
-0.1567593515,
-0.354185909,
-0.3155333698,
-0.3746510148,
0.0159491617,
0.7184442282,
0.1163235456,
0.1525910944,
0.661455512,
-0.1974181235,
-0.0199168865,
-0.2321795523,
0.7839041352,
-0.9763988853,
-0.5645422339,
-0.5827419162,
0.5824033618,
-0.0008195983,
-0.7591584325,
-0.0206606183,
0.731384635,
0.4283846915,
-0.1327346414,
0.9528081417,
-0.2415313721,
0.8935778737,
-0.5476125479,
0.4519266784,
-0.2933274806,
-0.0461607762,
0.1300915778,
-0.3870025873,
-0.1058213487,
0.7593261003,
0.1902744919,
-0.2704710364,
0.7211655378,
0.4178704023,
-0.169956997,
-0.2703706622,
-0.0240590777,
-0.0920370147,
0.3666306734,
0.6647265553,
0.6237199903,
-0.9063622952,
0.6468727589,
-0.4172290862,
-0.1677820385,
-0.2645032108,
-1.1367844343,
-0.6999317408,
-0.6656671166,
-0.4878131151,
-0.4901966453,
-0.2602338791,
0.8104050756,
1.0089747906,
-0.4697794616,
-0.067062214,
-0.6183503866,
-0.4644899666,
-0.1925278604,
-0.2685413957,
0.4344505072,
-0.1472694427,
-0.5999682546,
0.5706084967,
0.004609826,
0.5403334498,
0.1689463109,
-0.516636014,
0.1777461171,
-0.2167228758,
0.5460838675,
0.5428066254,
-0.2937451899,
-0.2961305082,
-0.0018027892,
-0.4493457973,
0.0169232041,
1.0760660172,
-0.9932692051,
-0.1094459966,
0.7998591661,
0.898267746,
0.5618056059,
0.2073284537,
0.6047456861,
-1.3830442429,
0.4015893936,
0.4723287523,
0.0761881024,
0.505236268,
-0.4728341997,
0.9188764691,
0.4934961796,
-0.4999428391,
-0.6367630959,
0.2068993151,
-1.0230724812,
-0.1405044794,
1.4645997286,
-0.1784874499,
-0.0098441672,
0.1698631346,
-0.2826136053,
0.5983231664,
-0.3498390615,
0.9443397522,
0.5319765806,
-0.2746807039,
-0.0624051169,
-0.2916827798,
0.5700982213,
0.1843909174,
-0.997594893,
-0.0169923697,
0.5369803309,
0.0802676827,
0.2152390927,
0.6086729765,
0.1713745445,
0.2905234993,
-0.2280654907,
0.0238928869,
-0.0771167278,
-0.4515265226,
-0.1129392385,
0.2860348225,
-0.3164055943,
-0.4626097083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14411v1
|
J-UniMorph: Japanese Morphological Annotation through the Universal Feature Schema
| 2024-02-22T09:56:51 | 2024-02-22T09:56:51 |
Kosuke Matsuzaki, Masaya Taniguchi, Kentaro Inui, Keisuke Sakaguchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a Japanese Morphology dataset, J-UniMorph, developed based on
the UniMorph feature schema. This dataset addresses the unique and rich verb
forms characteristic of the language's agglutinative nature. J-UniMorph
distinguishes itself from the existing Japanese subset of UniMorph, which is
automatically extracted from Wiktionary. On average, the Wiktionary Edition
features around 12 inflected forms for each word and is primarily dominated by
denominal verbs (i.e., [noun] +suru (do-PRS)). Morphologically, this form is
equivalent to the verb suru (do). In contrast, J-UniMorph explores a much
broader and more frequently used range of verb forms, offering 118 inflected
forms for each word on average. It includes honorifics, a range of politeness
levels, and other linguistic nuances, emphasizing the distinctive
characteristics of the Japanese language. This paper presents detailed
statistics and characteristics of J-UniMorph, comparing it with the Wiktionary
Edition. We release J-UniMorph and its interactive visualizer publicly
available, aiming to support cross-linguistic research and various
applications.
|
[
-0.5269199014,
-0.7496662736,
0.3526960015,
0.12307816,
-0.7103644609,
0.1604782343,
-0.2887022197,
-0.1769906729,
0.6482909322,
0.6994389892,
-0.3999728858,
-0.3825465441,
-0.5703939199,
0.3104561865,
-0.2823227644,
0.6891685128,
0.046972502,
0.1023118868,
-0.2645608783,
-0.2944571972,
-0.0706569478,
-0.2991048694,
-0.1885755956,
-0.4028761089,
0.430844754,
0.2662070394,
1.1927037239,
0.8119834661,
0.5007620454,
0.3405095339,
-0.1176320389,
-0.0623359531,
0.1717123687,
0.2818960845,
-0.0426275767,
-0.388887763,
-0.1641222388,
-0.3657459915,
0.7514464855,
1.2281669378,
-0.1107500866,
0.1090040877,
-0.0515088774,
0.620574832,
-0.6717614532,
0.3685711026,
-0.374292165,
0.0576853976,
-0.9733678102,
-0.048752889,
0.0119662443,
0.0270738155,
-0.1424475759,
-0.8019562364,
0.0814657658,
-0.2239758968,
0.6502890587,
0.1044654399,
-0.1905432492,
-0.1920500845,
-0.2194436491,
0.171240747,
-0.6426017284,
0.5475191474,
0.1044925004,
0.2487037778,
-0.5737050772,
-0.5143907666,
-0.625777185,
-0.4736191332,
-0.1053704694,
0.3746472895,
-0.107206285,
0.2651800215,
0.1271322519,
0.6556211114,
-0.8332467675,
0.5678591132,
-0.254280597,
-0.0132430661,
0.6987264156,
0.2642371058,
0.8645000458,
-0.6779018641,
0.0157089774,
-0.1782735288,
-0.5781878829,
0.029205665,
0.4484605491,
0.6055880785,
0.0758064389,
0.9737628698,
-0.4098752141,
0.4400846064,
-0.4444040954,
-0.1412240118,
0.5199038386,
0.0355695635,
-0.2307125628,
-0.0646807104,
1.2687109709,
0.2198087275,
0.3047687411,
-0.2119290978,
-0.071148999,
-0.0249360427,
0.153027758,
-0.4776329696,
-0.1633138061,
-0.2027684152,
-0.4378949404,
-0.0796754137,
0.4225884974,
-1.1766233444,
-0.5198451877,
-0.1012323126,
0.2176530361,
-0.3882635236,
-0.4428093433,
-0.0456487872,
-0.4212625921,
-0.3379316926,
0.2555070519,
-0.7948784232,
0.3429689705,
0.4311312735,
0.866001308,
-0.2374648005,
-0.4324170649,
0.2862727642,
0.0804019645,
-0.4929761291,
0.8343887329,
-0.8950043917,
-0.8331843019,
-0.011106492,
0.1503011584,
0.0659451261,
-0.3997826278,
0.3331813514,
0.1343000084,
0.5126280785,
0.2865627408,
-0.6500691772,
-0.5074934959,
-0.1166403517,
-0.582947135,
0.7979682684,
0.3514065146,
-0.5708364844,
0.272967726,
-1.0326446295,
-0.2418201864,
0.5901270509,
-0.1607409716,
-0.0546415858,
0.5914056897,
0.0643599704,
0.4340113699,
-0.2298463285,
0.2045941055,
-0.4018860459,
-0.0843906775,
0.3311142325,
-0.5257762074,
0.9423456788,
0.2770207226,
-0.0357899889,
-0.0735401362,
-0.9308392406,
-0.0393317752,
0.3338978291,
-0.0722258389,
-0.9158693552,
-0.3180907667,
0.0077947122,
-0.276335448,
0.2148630619,
-0.5319242477,
0.4146518111,
-0.295339942,
0.1383904219,
0.3840793371,
0.1619784981,
0.2200751305,
0.1183860525,
0.5994730592,
-0.1428756565,
0.4029255509,
-0.302447468,
-0.7659192681,
-0.6206450462,
-0.6636266708,
0.2676694691,
0.3396339118,
-0.3229750693,
0.6110752225,
-0.2993863225,
-0.9114015102,
-0.7337968946,
0.074455224,
0.6923699975,
0.1784491986,
0.2180871964,
-0.6053910255,
-0.5213674903,
-0.8561426401,
-0.0697088614,
-0.2173846662,
-0.1564441174,
-0.2180848867,
0.3869312406,
-0.3562964201,
0.4136568308,
-0.2617377043,
-0.1553891003,
-0.1298231483,
0.3533715308,
0.2583144903,
0.1651906967,
0.4767420888,
-0.5565362573,
-0.4060082734,
0.2716186047,
-0.675878644,
-0.3264756203,
-0.0089354906,
-0.1288197935,
0.1652120203,
0.2470880151,
-0.8263296485,
0.5432749391,
0.2999824882,
-0.47947824,
0.0062047723,
-0.359895587,
0.4063788652,
-1.2653717995,
0.1856728047,
-0.0607596077,
0.1264492273,
-0.505450666,
0.4630801976,
0.0112444237,
-0.0288535748,
-0.3005716801,
0.4713046849,
-0.4045877755,
-0.3107317388,
-0.0968626216,
0.2013676912,
-0.020861119,
0.4846795201,
0.0381350741,
0.5277042985,
0.5285876393,
-0.7158101797,
0.5762072206,
0.4129680693,
-0.0704391375,
0.3535965979,
-0.2752990723,
-0.2831249237,
-0.3330978453,
-0.1625625938,
-1.1146218777,
-0.6184637547,
0.253393352,
-0.6176127195,
0.4574565291,
-0.1961579025,
-0.5871033669,
-0.2971788645,
-0.5481074452,
-0.0045868363,
0.7806153297,
-0.2621270418,
0.2380296439,
0.7705870867,
-0.2738408148,
-0.3104687035,
-0.6177210808,
-0.0259166267,
-0.3060441017,
0.0579695813,
0.1473958641,
0.1033281982,
-0.4787014127,
0.1071017161,
0.14898552,
-0.1834399402,
0.2356895059,
0.6382758021,
0.4713720381,
0.0558925904,
-0.1672920734,
0.2802379131,
-0.1299492121,
-0.106679298,
0.243765682,
0.7231544256,
0.3593624234,
-0.3839900196,
-0.5892571211,
0.1836192459,
0.9090856314,
0.2475240082,
0.0188049749,
0.1912372559,
-0.3003738821,
0.4320835173,
-0.137278825,
0.3484653533,
-0.3376109898,
0.517766118,
-0.528197825,
-0.6109098792,
0.7202881575,
0.0651793927,
0.2885829508,
0.8452765346,
0.3584552407,
-0.1359746903,
1.3026450872,
0.2424018681,
-0.0059356536,
0.3968887329,
0.1709229797,
-0.2102244794,
-0.8902702332,
-0.714592576,
-0.7235133052,
-0.043911159,
-1.0732303858,
-0.1500575989,
0.0847794265,
0.1312853247,
-0.2013573945,
0.4183618426,
-0.4833980501,
0.3231744468,
0.3765475452,
-0.6130748391,
0.3517398536,
0.1238809228,
-0.1171928123,
-0.3648455441,
-0.2954662144,
-0.4505804181,
0.9495193362,
0.1379591078,
0.7737321258,
0.2413050383,
0.5075389743,
0.415012002,
0.0629197732,
-0.6857957244,
0.6704846025,
-0.5494185686,
-0.375987649,
-0.4209734201,
-0.4151079357,
-1.2845276594,
0.4065197706,
-0.1674639434,
-0.8260176182,
-0.1692316532,
-0.2411085218,
0.1859658062,
0.2544793189,
-0.3898288012,
0.647939682,
-0.2516866326,
0.4800596833,
-0.0810909718,
-0.4501403272,
0.2412381321,
0.0311157685,
0.3326998949,
-0.3946264386,
-0.1832445562,
0.7672426701,
-0.3870865405,
0.6960688233,
-0.2430173457,
0.2393713742,
0.0425700247,
0.4792551696,
-0.0199680179,
0.1357816011,
0.3897947967,
0.4436535835,
-0.0166019704,
-0.0735571459,
-0.7881807685,
0.5291804671,
-0.8368333578,
-0.3839156628,
-0.3684436381,
-0.297165513,
-0.1895849854,
0.4234713614,
0.4626747072,
0.4391908646,
-0.4488066435,
0.092810519,
0.3985765278,
-0.0782156363,
0.4088665545,
0.5721406937,
-0.8188940287,
-0.6742404699,
0.7666772008,
0.3930877447,
-0.1638535112,
0.6066832542,
0.3818761408,
-0.793289721,
-0.478325665,
-0.8319996595,
0.2488836944,
-0.4546043277,
-0.1800396889,
-0.4690980315,
-0.2576462328,
-0.5320047736,
-0.1456611156,
-0.6237283349,
-0.8382077813,
-0.0053265896,
-0.0531479418,
0.6548109651,
0.9730029106,
0.0125721944,
0.1522129774,
-0.7268099189,
0.3806114197,
0.0094975075,
0.2312287837,
-0.4134252965,
-0.7291321158,
0.3195878267,
0.0315813236,
0.0796350464,
-0.6712714434,
0.3119390011,
0.1483717263,
0.9469041228,
0.7684343457,
-0.1531545669,
1.0939589739,
-0.2290872931,
0.9460519552,
0.6326736212,
-0.7618039846,
0.7147477865,
-0.2876147926,
0.3027785718,
0.6769238114,
0.5256871581,
-0.8833135962,
-0.8430140018,
-1.0063691139,
-1.0143803358,
0.2617171109,
-0.0237219483,
0.4140983522,
-0.2956129611,
0.3140859604,
0.693077147,
0.1941346526,
-0.3906292617,
-0.2458870411,
-0.5608731508,
-0.5448246002,
0.0631142408,
-0.3219678104,
0.1689344645,
-0.2590530813,
0.4581402242,
-0.096525386,
0.0146961901,
-0.1360473484,
-0.2847293317,
-0.0430950932,
0.3208524883,
0.2972806096,
0.4899352789,
-0.0063664811,
0.2432086915,
0.0517539829,
-0.8438302279,
-0.0818563849,
0.0435959585,
-0.5674104691,
0.4984759986,
0.5491682291,
0.7872818112,
0.3096480966,
-0.8246775866,
0.2629375756,
0.1201713905,
-0.2327335477,
-0.3874177635,
0.3005360961,
-0.2507225871,
-0.0694565177,
0.1221906245,
-0.3826546967,
0.4851424396,
-0.676389575,
-0.2118534595,
0.4225811362,
-0.2453040481,
-0.4226000607,
0.2492786646,
0.0087845204,
-0.1979329288,
0.7048766017,
-0.2483464777,
-0.1448688358,
0.2688224912,
0.5796764493,
0.7585688233,
-0.4010337591,
0.3782147169,
0.4203343093,
-0.066126436,
-0.1299785823,
0.3393363655,
0.068980217,
-0.5099384189,
-0.0778374672,
-0.6921489835,
-0.4129019678,
0.3714266121,
-0.94416821,
-0.014066387,
-0.6855434775,
0.0524041317,
0.1025652885,
0.007031511,
-0.3376307189,
0.2269424349,
0.1975278854,
0.6137116551,
-0.7777466178,
0.4251340032,
1.2656039,
-0.8072423339,
-0.3212961257,
-0.184176296,
0.1960097104,
-1.1398035288,
0.1916540414,
0.1279345155,
0.0871647,
-0.2610727847,
-0.0784560293,
-0.9263291359,
0.955721736,
0.2694472671,
-0.5165849328,
0.3148564994,
0.4391118288,
0.6854931116,
-0.1888695955,
0.3798798621,
0.462574631,
0.5556333065,
-0.0929765105,
-0.880115211,
0.0305652544,
-0.572551012,
0.5950875282,
0.465195626,
-0.4436981976,
0.4490102828,
0.0109454272,
-0.4657766223,
0.0636599436,
0.4645358324,
0.2333533168,
0.0098671187,
0.4544236362,
0.713999331,
0.8404872417,
-0.075801596,
0.7902826071,
0.0503110811,
0.0653619245,
0.712613225,
0.0311645195,
0.6107836366,
0.6052701473,
-0.37448439,
0.547678411,
0.6797266603,
-0.1852209717,
0.5782846808,
-0.0026118755,
0.0744040757,
-0.0091476608,
-0.3405596614,
-0.1950216442,
0.8599249721,
0.3770056069,
-0.0667542145,
-0.2190120816,
0.253862679,
0.468251735,
0.227350533,
-0.6105632186,
0.8750353456,
-0.1828310639,
-0.5796454549,
0.0756793395,
-0.2771288157,
0.556171,
-0.8047566414,
-0.0007585896,
-0.6272038817,
-0.1389027089,
-0.1808171719,
-1.3824663162,
0.2595591545,
0.2231244147,
0.1105070561,
0.1948380768,
0.4727429748,
-0.1975365728,
-0.4446701407,
0.2999134958,
0.5494576693,
0.5289663076,
0.1367474198,
-0.5260129571,
-0.0749565363,
-0.0470682718,
-0.5249933004,
0.5546762943,
0.7186537385,
-0.3981169462,
0.6265023947,
0.5442693233,
0.1824165732,
0.0275680851,
0.666220665,
0.5158527493,
-0.8119909167,
-0.3687720001,
-0.8483557105,
0.6922548413,
-0.2841202021,
-0.71134305,
0.8047403693,
0.4828512073,
1.0070422888,
-0.034285482,
0.8186278939,
-0.2693144381,
0.4030228853,
-0.574203372,
0.5177611709,
-0.779769361,
-0.2851777673,
-0.1918777972,
-0.9828276038,
-0.7999998331,
0.579279542,
0.4421798289,
-0.1259790659,
0.5965499282,
0.4836262167,
-0.0571023338,
-0.0702162236,
0.6793429255,
-0.0012196705,
-0.0895389989,
-0.0315812752,
0.8022566438,
-0.0964488164,
0.2503323853,
-0.4188418984,
-0.1536037326,
-0.2811486721,
-0.3423342407,
-0.9215430617,
-0.8298326731,
-0.3888716698,
-0.0656884834,
-0.0867604017,
0.980098784,
0.1264611632,
-0.5966431499,
-0.1156378835,
-0.2396330535,
-0.1765597016,
-0.0464036614,
-0.2555171549,
0.2400437444,
-0.4113545418,
-0.6798169017,
0.4490973353,
0.7414076924,
0.3161114454,
-0.4615434706,
-0.1098024622,
0.3761109412,
-0.0344886705,
0.1729967743,
0.4066254199,
-0.7447012663,
-0.2015907019,
-0.3195265532,
-0.0221336149,
0.0467270985,
0.7655995488,
-0.2476515174,
0.6062059999,
0.6898943186,
0.1871670485,
0.1444310099,
-0.3071838617,
0.2076085657,
-0.6540367007,
0.4537647665,
-0.0774573982,
0.7456884384,
0.3843638897,
-0.2884459198,
0.663428247,
0.491003722,
-0.1378537714,
-0.7568695545,
0.2608238459,
-1.0213873386,
-0.5497613549,
0.9523499608,
-0.1396119148,
-0.4612281919,
-0.223714754,
-0.0714421198,
0.4819504023,
-0.2922286391,
0.8486074209,
0.375941664,
-0.326908499,
-0.4050489962,
-0.3489528894,
0.2320933789,
-0.035776291,
-0.8435662389,
0.3226807415,
0.4445503354,
0.2365913093,
0.550075531,
0.6567753553,
-0.6267502308,
0.1517079771,
0.1527699381,
0.4926392138,
-0.3523446321,
-0.2998178303,
-0.3114913404,
0.0035049692,
0.2494495362,
-0.2158985585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05572v1
|
Is ChatGPT More Empathetic than Humans?
| 2024-02-22T09:52:45 | 2024-02-22T09:52:45 |
Anuradha Welivita, Pearl Pu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the empathetic responding capabilities of ChatGPT,
particularly its latest iteration, GPT-4, in comparison to human-generated
responses to a wide range of emotional scenarios, both positive and negative.
We employ a rigorous evaluation methodology, involving a between-groups study
with 600 participants, to evaluate the level of empathy in responses generated
by humans and ChatGPT. ChatGPT is prompted in two distinct ways: a standard
approach and one explicitly detailing empathy's cognitive, affective, and
compassionate counterparts. Our findings indicate that the average empathy
rating of responses generated by ChatGPT exceeds those crafted by humans by
approximately 10%. Additionally, instructing ChatGPT to incorporate a clear
understanding of empathy in its responses makes the responses align
approximately 5 times more closely with the expectations of individuals
possessing a high degree of empathy, compared to human responses. The proposed
evaluation framework serves as a scalable and adaptable framework to assess the
empathetic capabilities of newer and updated versions of large language models,
eliminating the need to replicate the current study's results in future
research.
|
[
-0.6141326427,
-0.7111265659,
0.4326437712,
0.2468829155,
-0.0259623583,
0.0130364904,
-0.3029154241,
-0.603374064,
0.1211528406,
-0.2899270356,
-0.5923037529,
-0.0458989441,
-0.7182967067,
0.4037800729,
-0.0696635768,
1.0271316767,
0.1526920795,
0.0235847663,
0.1502347589,
-0.0811729133,
-0.0792138278,
-0.8735520244,
-0.9678986669,
-0.479092896,
0.7028928995,
0.2923437357,
0.5192762613,
-0.0511181541,
0.7870163918,
0.2209116071,
-0.0368032791,
-0.3518655002,
-0.5106660724,
-0.2800256908,
0.0733172297,
-0.0622543134,
-1.002259016,
0.4188277721,
-0.0591182038,
0.0643030256,
-0.3073753417,
0.2320894301,
0.3493489921,
0.4921486676,
-0.2622138858,
0.0747094527,
-0.312759608,
0.3512111902,
0.3964874744,
-0.2748731971,
-0.4087344408,
-0.4498617351,
0.4141808748,
-0.492056489,
0.2581994832,
0.1827180535,
0.4176613688,
-0.0468780994,
-0.5047588348,
-0.3441559374,
-0.215770781,
0.6633782387,
-0.5493133068,
0.1989437938,
0.2703734338,
0.2593351603,
0.2429265678,
-0.5520420074,
-0.616168499,
-0.4762603939,
0.1920546144,
0.7249952555,
-0.3755951524,
0.1993905902,
0.4735254347,
0.4098281562,
-0.7844774723,
-0.1130149066,
-0.1575409323,
0.041022338,
0.5861449838,
0.3051553071,
0.5215359926,
-0.2381889373,
-0.255366087,
-0.1148883849,
-0.2674644589,
0.004929746,
0.4615978897,
0.0671093017,
-0.305765897,
0.6382048726,
0.131028831,
0.305737406,
0.1773678958,
0.3705405295,
0.0527532548,
-0.0444978215,
-0.2211928666,
-0.0236797724,
0.6759996414,
1.3602163792,
0.68571347,
-0.016996678,
0.2016408443,
0.3380337954,
0.6025241017,
-1.108328104,
-0.3958240449,
0.2141652852,
-0.7100009918,
-0.3240684271,
-0.2804076672,
-0.9990073442,
-0.5283478498,
-0.0153166438,
0.1703756303,
-0.5612656474,
-0.5015535355,
0.117915459,
-0.3039909601,
0.9023932815,
0.3824431598,
-1.0021945238,
0.5678511858,
0.830170989,
1.0426675081,
-0.1182143688,
-0.4311032593,
-0.4331915975,
-0.4015370011,
-0.1026499271,
0.9695562124,
-0.7800447345,
-0.6025109291,
-0.4607689381,
-0.2302381843,
-0.0006185509,
-0.1065419838,
0.9025558233,
0.0140303737,
0.291696012,
-0.685339272,
-0.5057961345,
-0.1260638088,
0.7313976288,
-0.3194224238,
0.5452971458,
0.6169984341,
-1.114538312,
0.4511831999,
-0.952236414,
-0.1001095027,
-0.1655938476,
0.0903320834,
-0.1942077726,
0.075870499,
0.1083604544,
0.5552515984,
-0.4184949398,
-0.2364574224,
-0.5897778869,
-0.2581091225,
0.2371033132,
-0.435079217,
0.2885198593,
0.2313220203,
-0.2774777114,
-0.1715922505,
-0.2585293651,
0.1030190513,
0.093925871,
-0.2226035297,
-0.0273083411,
-0.1523371041,
0.1720865816,
0.4791341722,
-0.0709469318,
-0.9356736541,
0.009068423,
-0.240890801,
0.6648127437,
0.8191004395,
-0.0069088689,
0.4719237089,
-0.4482893646,
0.7020326257,
-0.2672761381,
0.4488966167,
-0.0669833198,
-0.7211751938,
-0.3353532851,
-0.2865489125,
-0.3017299175,
0.3388063908,
0.071060881,
0.3207019567,
-0.1527023315,
-0.745480895,
-0.4977129102,
-0.4169207811,
0.6957458854,
0.5069195628,
0.2776437402,
-0.8577785492,
-0.3130259812,
-0.8117953539,
-0.6777662039,
-0.2248962075,
-0.1864791065,
0.6534737945,
0.2682849467,
-0.1448684186,
0.4883961082,
-0.2158042043,
0.0527163781,
-0.1457217336,
0.0512256883,
-0.0714935288,
0.2485804558,
0.471146524,
-0.6169392467,
-0.7912863493,
0.3142780066,
-0.5057019591,
-0.0322330669,
0.0968833044,
-0.2485430837,
-0.0466079153,
-0.0062092212,
-0.6899491549,
0.3414645791,
0.5932310224,
-0.7552855015,
0.2504728436,
-0.0191147104,
0.6771204472,
-1.0112491846,
0.0970294774,
0.0307332091,
0.1097576171,
-0.6819286346,
-0.3310140371,
0.0192468036,
-0.1215804666,
-0.4203066528,
0.6557999849,
-0.2943561971,
-0.1868840754,
0.2107408345,
0.3452238142,
-0.0535530783,
0.5146018267,
0.0949830785,
0.5437036753,
0.4724562764,
-0.0807744116,
0.652729094,
0.5744090676,
0.0864625052,
0.8261777759,
-0.9100925922,
0.2611019015,
0.0394364819,
0.357400924,
-0.9609625936,
-0.4326450825,
0.4942839146,
-0.783067286,
0.0582435504,
-0.02378067,
-0.0628389493,
-0.5243882537,
-0.4957264662,
0.2004529834,
0.9736649394,
-0.2986952364,
0.7275277376,
0.0444142744,
-0.5458114743,
0.0151145747,
-0.765001297,
0.1085359976,
-0.47910133,
-0.6343702078,
-0.2545485497,
-0.2400357872,
-0.4283024073,
-0.327475071,
0.0300834402,
-0.0231587924,
-0.098620519,
0.2385051548,
-0.1589724422,
0.0938250273,
-0.0511024483,
-0.1541116685,
-0.3175996542,
0.2205735296,
0.4923038185,
0.614487946,
-0.5116374493,
-0.6812221408,
-0.3917378485,
0.3626895249,
0.4716670513,
-0.1585584581,
0.4248630404,
0.7802990675,
-0.0284450278,
0.5312826037,
-0.3975110352,
-0.377438724,
-0.3692528009,
0.268704772,
-0.5085744858,
-0.7229614854,
0.5661433935,
0.2317070216,
0.0715068281,
0.0873168334,
0.9026966095,
0.19037202,
1.2822108269,
0.2507941127,
-0.1768504083,
0.3116893768,
0.1819529682,
0.5445134044,
-1.1935654879,
-0.0999150574,
-0.2435185909,
-0.228674069,
-0.8210473061,
-0.2091096491,
0.1023655981,
-0.5505287051,
-0.5173169374,
0.0412832573,
-0.7276808023,
0.1705943048,
0.2376143634,
0.3394853771,
0.1465624571,
-0.4005834758,
0.5823100209,
-0.0795166269,
-0.6298436522,
-0.8075705171,
1.0278196335,
0.4905721545,
0.5771394372,
0.2972609997,
0.7066622972,
0.3077096343,
0.9608458281,
-0.8703821301,
0.2929217219,
0.1945735961,
-0.5286957622,
-0.2261807621,
-0.3681360483,
-0.9217999578,
0.1940380782,
0.0317621753,
-0.9136919379,
-0.2713791728,
0.3261082172,
-0.3916441202,
0.0973690003,
-1.3429327011,
0.7559325695,
-0.0586682074,
-0.3049952388,
-0.0007962838,
-0.7692597508,
0.1037917137,
-0.1664185822,
0.0464609042,
-0.3651213944,
-0.0223803669,
0.4092164338,
-0.0610618852,
0.7714175582,
-0.1921367794,
-0.0543552935,
0.2047406286,
0.2628854513,
0.3160740137,
-0.129438132,
-0.321562618,
-0.0663841143,
-0.1898883283,
-0.5519720912,
-0.6755491495,
0.5820140243,
-0.7267581224,
-0.2724700272,
-0.3310963809,
-0.2464996278,
-0.1861336529,
-0.1684369892,
0.3112361431,
0.3824777305,
-0.6649216413,
-0.0718202144,
0.182793349,
-0.5744526982,
0.3053503931,
0.4172545969,
-0.0164067112,
-0.2643058896,
0.6635107994,
-0.3283910155,
0.4850996733,
0.166817233,
0.4815933406,
-0.1911052316,
0.1963478774,
-0.3219834864,
0.0937507823,
-0.2236167043,
-0.054466337,
-0.7196736336,
0.1782708466,
-0.3755785525,
-0.6007018089,
-0.3497852087,
-0.1540097594,
0.2531096637,
-0.3092449903,
0.7176890969,
0.7613462806,
-0.1340785325,
0.1545684934,
-0.8152929544,
0.1239578649,
0.5188355446,
0.4819195867,
0.0883746818,
-0.5804828405,
0.2405279279,
0.0979217887,
-0.4517372549,
-0.7736800909,
0.6026326418,
0.2300326973,
0.1565130502,
0.4682480395,
-0.0049465583,
0.629914403,
-0.5981287956,
1.0093159676,
0.3753996789,
-0.9010875225,
0.1248778403,
-0.7463361025,
0.1190540269,
0.1485695839,
0.2822319269,
-0.5740935206,
-0.415612191,
-0.9678176641,
-0.6797109246,
0.569416821,
0.6312398911,
0.526432395,
-0.2431815863,
0.2397098094,
0.1111261621,
-0.1794964671,
-0.4494815171,
0.1977381557,
-0.3263552487,
-0.1865327656,
-0.4887078106,
-0.410163641,
-0.0793923959,
0.0076773479,
-0.0055015623,
0.0178855844,
0.8785020709,
0.2772534192,
0.3009253144,
-0.2109543085,
0.2447828948,
0.2226023823,
0.230901435,
-0.3284288645,
0.0295071527,
0.5341382623,
-0.465480566,
-0.0375723056,
0.0129056899,
0.8029744625,
-0.5527899861,
0.6981164217,
0.382600069,
0.1124070436,
-0.6438776851,
0.9456894398,
-0.5668738484,
-0.3021866977,
-0.1300702095,
-0.005895596,
0.1442624182,
0.5390595794,
-0.1299896687,
-0.1509206742,
0.5295779705,
-0.5216143131,
0.2722941339,
0.1399094015,
-0.4178959727,
-0.5774692893,
0.409645021,
0.4150798023,
-0.6559012532,
0.7401291728,
0.0117402552,
-0.7896239161,
0.6390945315,
0.4155814052,
0.9876258373,
-0.386087954,
0.2107787877,
0.4850631058,
0.1252085567,
0.0849371478,
0.4542995095,
-0.185655117,
-0.8028399348,
-0.050849136,
-0.4103744626,
-0.7526438832,
-0.5119528174,
-1.141757369,
-0.2479338795,
-0.2591894865,
-0.4035207629,
-0.223239392,
-0.0053712646,
-0.8191639781,
0.3521243632,
-0.1229752079,
0.7221600413,
-0.8974596262,
0.2487927824,
0.7158094049,
-0.3757251501,
-0.978607595,
0.2058823258,
-0.1038948223,
-0.8965659738,
0.3075070381,
0.5004358888,
-0.1559310257,
0.2098606676,
-0.2195991576,
-0.2031886727,
1.137634635,
0.2364683002,
-0.1598049402,
0.2438554913,
-0.1005248353,
0.899928391,
-0.0697640181,
0.947784543,
0.7775259614,
0.5900324583,
-0.246176824,
-1.085285902,
0.0174645577,
-0.6725609899,
-0.0907445922,
0.0125986105,
-1.1587421894,
0.549059093,
-0.271541357,
-0.0521876775,
0.0975029022,
-0.0147178862,
0.2613096833,
0.3930106759,
0.3104859293,
0.461594224,
0.498647809,
-0.1123877615,
1.4794375896,
-0.209437862,
0.3898648024,
0.8590326309,
-0.410835743,
0.7152622342,
0.5614584684,
-0.2938453555,
0.0002900035,
0.8301366568,
0.2171814293,
0.2728745341,
0.0965796709,
-0.5732233524,
-0.1320662498,
-0.0243982784,
-0.2056970298,
0.4594418406,
-0.1644339859,
-0.3401683569,
-0.1174072623,
-0.0493938252,
0.1633911431,
-0.1519545913,
-0.2465424389,
0.9049556255,
0.3005951941,
-0.5386430025,
0.2499870509,
-0.2902974784,
0.3350118101,
-0.2954314351,
-0.0693313181,
-0.3801502585,
0.0150502939,
-0.2032122612,
-1.0624579191,
0.1931811869,
0.542047739,
0.1204480678,
-0.2172846943,
0.5546784401,
0.0554895736,
0.0481900983,
0.592453599,
0.5131809711,
0.5058271289,
-0.1461021155,
-0.7211425304,
-0.032667961,
0.0646544397,
-0.9051778913,
0.4024527371,
0.7526683211,
0.2469229698,
0.8889178634,
0.525367558,
-0.1910459697,
0.0514551997,
0.2515179813,
0.9709183574,
-0.7256779671,
-0.1113097519,
-1.0317749977,
0.616784513,
-0.2427748293,
-0.4069186747,
0.7155947089,
0.272880286,
0.3300043643,
-0.1500197947,
0.9037761092,
-0.453224957,
0.5457994938,
-0.230079487,
0.3296736181,
-0.1946221143,
-0.1499309987,
-0.7880861163,
-1.0472277403,
-0.3504356444,
0.942459166,
-0.6727977991,
0.471986115,
0.5636270642,
0.9209101796,
-0.0640358329,
0.3213862777,
0.6207103729,
0.1177361161,
0.3521641493,
0.7900310755,
1.2771437168,
-0.0032126147,
0.2584654391,
0.1422166675,
-0.5000745654,
-0.0183915235,
-1.0144617558,
-0.8341464996,
-0.2089859396,
0.1503347754,
-0.0957650542,
0.0199922081,
0.9868973494,
0.2326968461,
-0.3107492328,
0.069098562,
-0.1547938734,
-0.5845164061,
0.0417184047,
-0.2452321202,
0.4145481586,
-0.03433045,
-0.7899414897,
-0.3982431889,
0.4312955141,
-0.0614092946,
0.2011085451,
-0.570045054,
0.5390716791,
0.1416838616,
0.8806551099,
-0.0567706935,
-0.3732858896,
-0.7108501792,
0.1470450908,
-0.0134664197,
0.1680398732,
0.5945349336,
-0.0757945627,
0.5720627308,
0.1918452978,
0.3584758043,
0.370524317,
0.4475383759,
0.8705236316,
-0.1074216813,
-0.0011247548,
0.1959583759,
0.3047457337,
0.4075936377,
-0.4069855511,
0.6752040386,
-0.251585573,
-0.9768448472,
-0.5253369808,
0.427534014,
-1.2373070717,
0.4912162423,
1.3564822674,
-0.5388972759,
0.1583304405,
0.072018601,
-0.9007865787,
0.3333785534,
-0.827657938,
0.8769887686,
0.6142604351,
-0.6968149543,
-0.2434358746,
-0.4004980326,
0.3689457774,
0.1716399938,
-0.7408739328,
0.153383553,
0.4478543401,
0.1872252375,
-0.3178078234,
0.7962620258,
-0.2092314959,
0.3131435513,
0.3080686033,
0.390185833,
0.329185009,
0.3922009468,
-0.2865921855,
-0.096329622,
0.2760555148,
0.0981115773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14409v1
|
Tug-of-War Between Knowledge: Exploring and Resolving Knowledge Conflicts in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models
| 2024-02-22T09:51:08 | 2024-02-22T09:51:08 |
Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Xiaojian Jiang, Jiexin Xu, Qiuxia Li, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have demonstrated significant
potential in refining and expanding their internal memory by retrieving
evidence from external sources. However, RALMs will inevitably encounter
knowledge conflicts when integrating their internal memory with external
sources. Knowledge conflicts can ensnare RALMs in a tug-of-war between
knowledge, limiting their practical applicability. In this paper, we focus on
exploring and resolving knowledge conflicts in RALMs. First, we present an
evaluation framework for assessing knowledge conflicts across various
dimensions. Then, we investigate the behavior and preference of RALMs from the
following two perspectives: (1) Conflicts between internal memory and external
sources: We find that stronger RALMs emerge with the Dunning-Kruger effect,
persistently favoring their faulty internal memory even when correct evidence
is provided. Besides, RALMs exhibit an availability bias towards common
knowledge; (2) Conflicts between truthful, irrelevant and misleading evidence:
We reveal that RALMs follow the principle of majority rule, leaning towards
placing trust in evidence that appears more frequently. Moreover, we find that
RALMs exhibit confirmation bias, and are more willing to choose evidence that
is consistent with their internal memory. To solve the challenge of knowledge
conflicts, we propose a method called Conflict-Disentangle Contrastive Decoding
(CD2) to better calibrate the model's confidence. Experimental results
demonstrate that our CD2 can effectively resolve knowledge conflicts in RALMs.
|
[
-0.4990054965,
-0.6467938423,
0.6747460365,
0.0030052681,
-0.1370395124,
0.4184774756,
-0.2235340625,
-0.6030958891,
-0.1672643721,
0.4406447411,
-0.0141473431,
-0.0357810184,
-0.9353796244,
-0.0991301909,
-0.2450973094,
0.7270501852,
-0.3261581361,
0.0502643101,
-0.4953187108,
-0.5135735273,
-0.6594722867,
-0.7191648483,
-0.2518610954,
-0.6351162195,
0.5475963354,
0.2744120955,
0.7843441963,
0.2591761649,
0.6332207918,
0.3160484731,
-0.3977581561,
0.3745472133,
-0.5134291053,
0.6154072881,
-0.4920589328,
-0.4145770073,
0.0998357981,
-0.0042643277,
0.2703541219,
0.3704155385,
-0.3127227724,
0.0111971321,
-0.0355120823,
1.1762551069,
-0.7571212053,
-0.1686122715,
-0.7061558962,
-0.0913876817,
-0.3159660399,
-0.0937350616,
-0.3813195825,
-0.3735405207,
0.4987649024,
-0.3643373549,
0.0523933545,
0.3148366511,
1.0702133179,
0.2528346181,
-0.6754335165,
-0.7102158666,
-0.5996427536,
0.6287337542,
-0.6394308209,
0.4057480693,
0.7430614233,
0.2117889822,
-0.059807837,
-0.5924568176,
-0.4604207873,
-0.0802951828,
-0.2462816685,
0.1144824177,
-0.5360451937,
-0.1543159187,
0.2975695431,
0.2864978909,
-0.6349388361,
-0.1125353798,
-0.526737988,
-0.1488222778,
0.5170226097,
0.0671420321,
0.2985351384,
0.0564452,
-0.5085940361,
0.0468717329,
-0.6752880812,
-0.1072824225,
0.4185191095,
0.0158377737,
0.2007972002,
0.6533792615,
-0.0406354554,
0.7065242529,
0.2681543529,
0.0879472718,
0.0392112732,
-0.2284576148,
-0.0133824823,
0.2336491793,
0.6142715216,
0.3658179939,
-0.1510971338,
-0.0859453604,
-0.2936674953,
0.1413272172,
0.3590270877,
-0.4693264961,
-0.1690192074,
0.2643741667,
-0.6301754117,
-0.0452910364,
-0.1148589104,
-0.8179596663,
-0.5612858534,
-0.2540492415,
0.8404741287,
-0.5823170543,
-0.5923032761,
0.1732090712,
-0.4306823611,
-0.1164134517,
0.2529540956,
-0.6418678761,
0.3170549273,
0.4206274152,
0.6589287519,
0.0067136409,
0.1001490504,
-0.402782917,
0.0655925721,
-0.3525390029,
0.831099987,
-0.6217337847,
-0.4697991014,
0.0630475804,
-0.5322346687,
-0.1337537766,
-0.9671233296,
0.4614432454,
-1.1055778265,
0.3326099813,
-0.837605834,
-0.7224633694,
-0.2607837319,
0.5455287099,
-0.7697845697,
1.1028269529,
0.0808864385,
-1.0324068069,
0.2034015656,
-0.4754232764,
-0.2599105239,
-0.1228690371,
-0.2384340763,
-0.1991550922,
0.2119370252,
-0.0725566,
-0.1337485164,
-0.4883411527,
0.1860848665,
-0.1982725859,
-0.2868848145,
0.3881819844,
0.0616971739,
0.6170290709,
0.5023555756,
-0.2219539583,
-0.0579355843,
-0.43282938,
-0.1927613318,
0.3356103599,
-0.3615108132,
-0.9261810184,
0.0715503693,
-0.5744284391,
0.3259863853,
0.4067661166,
-0.4020918012,
0.2413401604,
0.0387891345,
0.1612337232,
0.5918234587,
0.1278859675,
0.4136178493,
-0.6131094694,
0.2901978791,
0.4978152812,
0.1143075228,
0.1034714431,
-0.4840075374,
-0.7410641909,
0.3568066955,
0.0557537191,
0.2095709741,
-0.9074395895,
0.0114675993,
0.0170039814,
-0.1846398115,
-0.7717093229,
0.0101184472,
0.3728378713,
0.6246293783,
0.4309043884,
-0.1945927739,
-0.5072037578,
-0.6426426172,
-0.4096343517,
-0.333742708,
0.4583346248,
0.3473452628,
0.2986566126,
-0.1498874873,
1.2263855934,
-0.2757415771,
-0.3248755932,
-0.0464876071,
0.5004621744,
-0.2321819365,
0.2893574238,
0.472161293,
-1.1101009846,
-0.5453788042,
0.1219673902,
-0.8375909925,
0.1837268323,
0.2440790236,
-0.0142526478,
0.4593912661,
0.351911366,
-0.4474466443,
0.418920368,
0.4522780478,
-0.465059936,
0.5157321095,
-0.342071563,
0.3868480325,
-0.5318442583,
-0.1465081275,
-0.1316455901,
0.2580839097,
-0.5514497757,
0.0827013701,
0.1089176685,
0.3077415824,
-0.2267637253,
0.7079435587,
-0.5802161098,
0.0855241939,
-0.3549763858,
0.3937964737,
0.2690386176,
0.0154186636,
0.2019980848,
0.6751483083,
0.3838168085,
-0.6337441206,
0.1917509586,
0.371250242,
-0.6213900447,
0.4025863707,
-0.2860001922,
0.3390618265,
-0.2802316248,
-0.0827459693,
-0.8798704147,
0.1759894341,
0.2360297143,
-0.3478435576,
0.4229115546,
-0.1949883103,
-0.5698452592,
-0.1634335518,
-0.2140675485,
0.6319355965,
0.6212474108,
-0.6351647377,
0.7100769281,
0.4113734663,
-0.0937568694,
-0.9935907125,
-0.5633686185,
0.0669264942,
-0.3766367137,
-0.5394345522,
0.2314941138,
-0.0586487465,
-0.7254353166,
0.474093616,
-0.2946431935,
-0.2191694677,
-0.3449474871,
0.0836590379,
0.0825860202,
-0.2547422945,
0.2764193416,
0.0527781546,
-0.0344570875,
-0.021149192,
-0.0599977858,
0.3893648684,
-0.16518341,
-0.6371723413,
0.2491929829,
0.3492304385,
0.5125395656,
-0.4555921555,
0.7516897917,
0.4419385791,
-0.2580634356,
0.0580384322,
-1.2425092459,
-0.1875282228,
-0.4728277326,
0.3151110709,
-0.3066459894,
-0.8459493518,
0.6787465215,
-0.3378377557,
-0.1513676196,
0.4324658513,
0.4302751422,
-0.184252739,
0.8519144058,
0.4421234131,
-0.1624601185,
0.2914139032,
-0.0649997741,
0.2704463601,
-1.0539205074,
-0.4803693891,
-0.5111727715,
-0.3061895967,
-0.0357636735,
-0.4153393209,
0.3083775043,
0.367464602,
-0.2186997831,
0.2102277279,
-0.4303304553,
0.4709832668,
0.2823354602,
0.0733801126,
0.5035887957,
-0.0995548069,
-0.465932548,
-0.391957581,
-1.0069584846,
-0.3181885481,
0.8889904022,
0.3023237586,
0.8547790647,
0.4141170382,
0.6130250692,
0.1920705438,
0.3213247359,
-0.3965719342,
0.2992373705,
0.0417404287,
-0.7574082613,
0.0676793605,
-0.4837142527,
-0.9659754634,
0.3669246137,
-0.1336444169,
-0.6177252531,
0.46935004,
-0.0082480144,
-0.2070285976,
0.5613303185,
-0.6146376729,
0.6495355368,
-0.5449732542,
-0.3896304667,
-0.5891156197,
-0.7128461599,
0.6190360785,
0.1737864912,
0.4062692523,
0.1566048414,
0.2153467238,
0.7551542521,
-0.1431899369,
0.4465268254,
-0.083768487,
-0.2996725142,
0.5161181092,
0.3991492391,
0.4690564275,
-0.2168651074,
-0.189318344,
0.0322061256,
0.1226458549,
-0.2448659837,
-0.5733188391,
0.5866179466,
-0.717042625,
-0.6694282293,
-0.7905902863,
-0.5790358186,
-0.1385403425,
0.0067889569,
0.2231241763,
0.3754087985,
-0.0761558861,
-0.1049851924,
1.1896133423,
-0.2621807158,
0.2001301795,
0.9137814641,
-0.4783341289,
-0.0644422546,
1.1921600103,
0.1748404801,
0.4034754336,
0.2458755076,
0.1557522714,
-0.4907010198,
-0.6504762173,
-0.1166503429,
0.1958314329,
-0.9429286718,
-0.5115017891,
-0.4033187032,
-0.1031568497,
-0.0838593021,
0.1203296185,
-0.3329955637,
0.0058440831,
-0.1839556396,
0.2597881258,
0.666202426,
1.1142556667,
-0.1926135272,
-0.182135269,
-0.9566524625,
0.2551418841,
0.3433681726,
0.2734731734,
0.1576390713,
-0.7114930749,
-0.3512259424,
-0.0327798836,
-0.3379502296,
-1.0225014687,
0.226700142,
-0.2195567191,
0.5209460855,
0.4030289054,
0.4207735062,
0.8165644407,
-0.201741457,
0.6246100664,
0.0302039739,
-0.7245681882,
0.3428321481,
-0.038677454,
-0.0259091109,
0.3951833248,
0.3558152318,
-0.6007660627,
-0.3853379488,
-0.6205855608,
-0.9048064947,
0.6475788951,
-0.0629663542,
-0.2507153153,
-0.2306961268,
0.3791086376,
-0.0649668947,
0.21997118,
-0.3714473248,
-0.3514119983,
0.039711073,
0.0241027717,
0.5805438757,
-0.5914666057,
-0.5754507184,
-0.0132128326,
0.6562988162,
0.3220539689,
0.2348274887,
0.218303442,
-0.4015257955,
-0.4199412763,
0.3343520761,
0.5590093732,
0.6171415448,
-0.2077316344,
0.4183190465,
0.0838491544,
-0.2409258336,
0.2298693657,
0.0349523053,
-0.0332014039,
0.1025362387,
0.1694031507,
0.6357661486,
0.263420403,
-0.8313605189,
0.5323040485,
-0.1993469,
-0.2432210892,
-0.0054441318,
-0.2243501246,
0.223170042,
0.5581654906,
0.4770472944,
0.3079771698,
-0.1026674286,
-0.413118273,
0.2916812003,
0.6619313955,
-0.1908031404,
0.0521082468,
0.2697704434,
-0.0126557322,
-0.0296652969,
0.6665228605,
-0.5126072764,
-0.7598870397,
0.333093226,
0.4621164799,
0.3189156353,
-0.1897895634,
0.0530285761,
0.338958025,
0.2084977627,
-0.2139867991,
0.1495495737,
-0.0025956084,
-0.8588638306,
-0.3693684936,
-0.2465393096,
-0.4395388961,
0.1072219238,
-1.0780584812,
-0.1586667001,
-0.1738614589,
-0.2124830484,
-0.5575718284,
0.3111070693,
-0.5109165907,
-0.1371161044,
0.025176907,
0.8629342318,
-0.4781758189,
0.9494308233,
0.5489696264,
-0.4880310893,
-0.3861371279,
-0.071166113,
0.0822375789,
-0.6873662472,
1.0608170033,
-0.407879442,
-0.1600587815,
-0.34113276,
-0.2743074298,
-1.0110433102,
1.0347806215,
0.3745832145,
-0.5500391126,
0.0710779577,
-0.2128353566,
0.3294001222,
-0.0683618635,
0.1273730993,
0.5140260458,
0.7027489543,
0.0985814556,
-0.8232084513,
-0.0714233741,
-0.0838733092,
-0.058347404,
0.261991024,
-0.6899317503,
0.8107610941,
-0.3187750578,
-0.4275025427,
0.0072598434,
0.6890406609,
0.2668568194,
0.3732291758,
0.4316724837,
0.6564816833,
0.664059341,
-0.2197799236,
0.732785821,
-0.2683017552,
0.3964479864,
1.1567932367,
-0.5673593879,
0.8104804754,
0.5963723063,
-0.348998487,
0.6681348085,
0.4126783311,
0.2522322237,
0.5705708861,
0.0113890851,
-0.4054102302,
-0.0732801557,
-0.0188537948,
-0.6879837513,
0.1692254096,
0.5943523645,
-0.0507144406,
-0.5352101326,
0.0031085848,
-0.0963116661,
0.4172988832,
0.0310688522,
0.8713086843,
-0.0826691836,
-0.5623537898,
0.4827998281,
-0.0827856138,
0.7084975839,
-0.8422260284,
-0.0850016624,
-0.0528977104,
0.1034948677,
-0.2239104062,
-0.7914232016,
0.3632788062,
-0.1907720864,
-0.3518220484,
0.0028204031,
0.9107346535,
-0.8388755918,
0.0176506191,
0.7352190614,
0.6598395705,
-0.1371650547,
0.0444080308,
-0.7507964373,
0.5790475607,
-0.1396274865,
-0.1781800687,
0.9397400022,
0.4915137291,
0.12091057,
0.6189505458,
0.4718179703,
0.1038671955,
0.0510137305,
-0.0398498103,
1.0209896564,
-0.3495195806,
-0.0579154417,
-0.7267834544,
0.4313743711,
0.0604671612,
0.0819008946,
0.8161842227,
0.4441178441,
0.5724816322,
0.141834408,
0.7992540598,
-0.2990888953,
0.6211338043,
-0.5825481415,
0.7502115369,
-0.5195346475,
0.253682822,
-0.1100549698,
-0.3681892455,
0.0414211489,
0.8085285425,
-0.3676093221,
0.0585479625,
0.7048161626,
0.4826576114,
0.03805485,
0.0382832512,
0.1563270092,
0.2307683975,
0.1908794641,
0.6471524239,
1.1059256792,
-0.5361641049,
0.547881484,
-0.3457931876,
-0.0419101752,
-0.138668865,
-0.9246419668,
-0.5840226412,
-0.8958922625,
-0.3908474445,
-0.5302871466,
0.1809334308,
0.8609403372,
0.4256975651,
-0.5068869591,
-0.2348821163,
0.3276413083,
0.5219981074,
-0.2913190722,
-0.2286496162,
0.315502882,
-0.5451022983,
-0.3701552749,
0.3637202382,
0.1420263797,
0.0302264802,
-0.0567510314,
-0.4071269035,
-0.4619957805,
-0.0482249334,
0.5664483309,
0.5643550754,
-0.876204133,
-0.2476278245,
-0.1442276984,
0.0053785979,
-0.0007002737,
1.1014193296,
-0.8708530664,
0.832675159,
0.2436095923,
0.7248555422,
0.4293387532,
-0.0071252002,
0.4209179878,
-0.6497109532,
0.0729780197,
0.3347204328,
0.3022148013,
0.2619537711,
-0.2088084519,
0.2338314354,
-0.0206035729,
-0.7052544951,
-0.9794155955,
0.2293102443,
-0.7054956555,
-0.4265746474,
1.019520998,
-0.163603738,
0.3202672899,
-0.287925005,
-0.438218981,
0.2142320573,
-0.2621991038,
0.9634904861,
0.9383972883,
-0.2140624225,
-0.0453675613,
-0.4494771957,
0.7703016996,
0.4278970361,
-0.3358203769,
0.2657140195,
0.3522132337,
0.2418299168,
0.3806316257,
0.4590052664,
-0.2281474173,
0.1651848853,
-0.1043374762,
-0.2644580305,
-0.1247898489,
-0.1927605867,
-0.4785328507,
0.0532737598,
0.2655891478,
0.1197972745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14408v1
|
Transferring BERT Capabilities from High-Resource to Low-Resource Languages Using Vocabulary Matching
| 2024-02-22T09:49:26 | 2024-02-22T09:49:26 |
Piotr Rybak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models have revolutionized the natural language
understanding landscape, most notably BERT (Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers). However, a significant challenge remains
for low-resource languages, where limited data hinders the effective training
of such models. This work presents a novel approach to bridge this gap by
transferring BERT capabilities from high-resource to low-resource languages
using vocabulary matching. We conduct experiments on the Silesian and Kashubian
languages and demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach to improve the
performance of BERT models even when the target language has minimal training
data. Our results highlight the potential of the proposed technique to
effectively train BERT models for low-resource languages, thus democratizing
access to advanced language understanding models.
|
[
-0.5039207935,
-0.3172281384,
0.2904248238,
0.1853674203,
-0.2992140949,
0.2368721366,
-0.6042864919,
-0.4786846936,
0.1360401958,
0.6378443837,
-0.5063378811,
-0.0425031297,
-0.5424094796,
-0.0192805063,
-0.3213258982,
0.7469396591,
-0.0992479175,
-0.0151678212,
-0.0806218162,
-0.1153144985,
-0.3877636194,
-0.5173511505,
-0.4276196659,
-0.4723833501,
0.4796334207,
0.3771928549,
0.850066185,
0.4388201237,
0.592705369,
0.2694425583,
-0.0436054729,
0.1972232908,
-0.5402721167,
-0.0792615637,
-0.1368529648,
-0.3367940485,
-0.0470833592,
-0.1662710756,
0.7381073833,
1.0072841644,
0.0207436569,
0.1117801294,
0.2934240699,
0.7237971425,
-0.5869431496,
0.0751433596,
-0.9462186098,
0.0579541735,
-0.2253003418,
-0.0872237012,
-0.4919660687,
-0.3135977089,
0.4208615124,
-0.703692019,
0.3335270584,
-0.2167891115,
1.2230662107,
0.1516041011,
-0.144919157,
-0.325873524,
-0.7706329823,
0.6615092754,
-0.7043502331,
0.3965574205,
0.487583071,
0.2944560051,
0.1121233478,
-0.4989079833,
-0.7222671509,
-0.1923236549,
-0.3378277719,
0.0088816518,
-0.1220622212,
0.0451155826,
-0.0516747162,
0.1448838413,
-0.3527556658,
0.3417088091,
-0.4187063873,
-0.3005291224,
0.2229983211,
-0.3729650378,
0.1799139678,
-0.351059109,
-0.4044820368,
-0.4542638361,
-0.3354668319,
-0.0719531402,
0.3541520238,
0.8381044269,
-0.0876057595,
0.3704802692,
0.1106732786,
0.8776234984,
-0.0874260813,
0.2075173408,
0.269259721,
-0.6363890171,
-0.1814252436,
0.1338688284,
0.2670644224,
-0.1238353327,
0.3604318798,
-0.2817147076,
-0.1773810089,
-0.179331854,
0.2249438316,
-0.4999333918,
-0.341810286,
-0.3821589649,
-0.5581029654,
-0.1414275914,
-0.3183431029,
-0.7314970493,
-0.1807569116,
-0.2361675799,
0.7178681493,
-0.7111092806,
-0.2348884195,
0.1503700465,
-0.1064185724,
0.5167760253,
0.3091583848,
-1.1144649982,
0.263002038,
0.5215213299,
0.9333452582,
0.2718115151,
-0.0630090758,
-0.3404632807,
0.1410775036,
-0.3939304948,
0.6124359965,
-0.5260646343,
-0.1489317268,
0.1511976123,
-0.2237784266,
-0.1489740908,
-0.5024991632,
0.4166839421,
-0.68528229,
-0.0278362446,
-0.221369341,
-0.4001571834,
-0.2274157554,
0.1795418859,
-0.6911805272,
0.9464419484,
0.3375815451,
-0.5406728387,
0.1762032807,
-0.7661741376,
-0.6019017696,
0.2313061655,
0.3761590719,
-0.0235955808,
0.1298526078,
0.3003211617,
0.1943063289,
-0.0035436822,
-0.2953516841,
-0.183013469,
-0.2840453088,
-0.0170033947,
-0.4388974905,
0.846067369,
0.3099333644,
0.1919545382,
-0.1695040017,
-0.5017845631,
0.1405770779,
0.0656009912,
-0.4123986065,
-0.6916945577,
-0.086193651,
0.3776628077,
0.2601162493,
0.7199724913,
-0.4758992195,
0.1191409752,
-0.5896370411,
0.4231624007,
0.8588081002,
-0.6062625647,
0.8457403183,
-0.1411617994,
0.3326795697,
-0.1094747037,
-0.0052584782,
0.084143281,
-0.1982903332,
-0.9447918534,
-0.3464975953,
0.7722249031,
0.5390738249,
-1.081795454,
0.6192941666,
-0.5136927366,
-0.5042913556,
-1.1905714273,
0.4166490436,
0.2724025548,
0.5470175147,
0.4181236625,
-0.4605652094,
-0.5991966724,
-1.1226532459,
0.017856447,
-0.2455256581,
-0.1911659539,
0.5530078411,
0.0466749296,
-0.0889865011,
0.7910043597,
-0.0836673006,
-0.3638588786,
-0.4916892052,
0.1686602086,
0.3741959333,
0.5626978278,
0.692104876,
-0.647526741,
-0.7037621737,
0.2030895799,
-0.4120027423,
-0.0704422668,
-0.0682032183,
-0.5222247243,
0.1353492737,
0.3759222627,
-0.2778552175,
-0.0646248683,
0.9035519958,
-0.2210375667,
0.1962429583,
-0.4768872261,
0.1140650287,
-1.1161717176,
0.0902239382,
-0.3762872815,
-0.1749500483,
-0.7801350355,
0.003595653,
0.027536666,
-0.2364455014,
-0.5051543117,
0.5013596416,
-0.3753751516,
-0.2479144484,
-0.1328342259,
0.3909475803,
-0.2545828819,
0.3890521228,
0.0927751064,
0.9367212653,
0.6226935983,
-0.5495823622,
0.1504454315,
0.565977335,
-0.5273014307,
0.3720637858,
-0.4158576429,
0.1091681719,
-0.2413705438,
-0.0475576743,
-0.879086256,
-0.1635142714,
-0.0172744524,
-0.4998157918,
0.179062441,
-0.3796408176,
-0.7741484642,
-0.291780144,
0.0114364428,
0.2754065692,
1.0037038326,
-0.6531079412,
0.8482366204,
0.1189246997,
-0.3217058778,
-0.5160882473,
-0.6909176707,
0.019188622,
0.0020874711,
-0.5868124366,
0.5133966804,
0.2213421166,
0.0946265757,
0.1439559311,
0.1766386479,
-0.4677037597,
0.2141906917,
-0.2979232669,
0.3394191861,
-0.2490490228,
0.4234041274,
-0.0972761512,
0.0840036571,
-0.3752920926,
-0.2705408335,
0.8993226886,
0.0325907394,
-0.4362721443,
-0.3408632576,
0.2994006872,
0.4260971248,
-0.4550704062,
0.8781278729,
0.7428110242,
-0.3644707799,
-0.1102934778,
-0.427190274,
-0.2890647352,
-0.4871150255,
0.4989109635,
-0.2710966766,
-0.7770482302,
0.3724880815,
-0.0662098378,
0.1482068449,
0.2178620845,
0.5799097419,
-0.381796211,
0.7393372059,
0.9803871512,
-0.403265506,
0.7425149679,
0.0744139776,
0.3965121806,
-0.6387669444,
0.0798558146,
-0.5705241561,
-0.5971575379,
-0.6811161637,
-0.5169978142,
0.2042039037,
0.2009143382,
0.0325894244,
0.8422332406,
-0.3167949915,
0.3890555203,
0.841206789,
0.1230156273,
0.1342395842,
0.2616109252,
-0.0559039861,
0.0019668965,
-0.9531648159,
-0.4914583266,
0.8920121789,
0.1524109691,
0.5837082267,
0.1879543513,
0.8521026969,
0.2492200285,
0.1887388974,
-0.8011485934,
0.5787593722,
-0.639710784,
-0.4900615513,
-0.4631748796,
-0.3789026737,
-1.014370203,
0.3047904968,
-0.3398955762,
-0.4490704536,
0.2003522664,
0.1290187836,
-0.2936166525,
0.4129087031,
-0.8552514911,
0.6559932232,
-0.1262879521,
-0.0294065885,
-0.6012552977,
-0.4939668179,
0.1243506521,
-0.3176209629,
0.2581377923,
-0.1904600263,
0.1355435401,
0.8184537292,
-0.1640111208,
0.6727474332,
-0.2827540338,
-0.1943890005,
0.0221322719,
0.1709580272,
0.2553059161,
-0.2984331846,
-0.2514692843,
0.1580016166,
-0.1459173411,
-0.8520019054,
-0.5120050907,
0.4700270891,
-0.7868418694,
-0.3471708,
-0.0571612976,
-0.799333334,
-0.3689003885,
0.2031085044,
0.046232909,
0.0001326189,
-0.0607942715,
0.2200209945,
0.570524931,
-0.1129687726,
0.587539494,
0.5485645533,
0.3259544373,
-0.0683981702,
0.7873306274,
-0.0108657526,
0.3857491314,
0.3435415924,
-0.2055569142,
-0.2143806815,
-0.4159362614,
-0.2349333167,
0.1482742578,
-0.6067427397,
-0.2291482538,
-0.2929648757,
-0.3464280069,
-0.1488197893,
-0.4352809191,
-0.4741132855,
-0.2261530459,
-0.2469315231,
0.3604081869,
0.3595044613,
0.4263297617,
-0.4108030796,
0.4305745065,
-1.1121493578,
0.0528355576,
0.6030442715,
0.4246454537,
0.1716162264,
-0.7891177535,
-0.4338410199,
0.1891857982,
0.0013330579,
-0.6128178239,
0.3860941231,
0.5118330717,
0.5311549902,
0.1201689541,
0.0532020889,
0.861823082,
-0.6771370769,
0.6178498864,
0.1047818959,
-1.1833251715,
0.5838010907,
-0.007721581,
0.080327943,
0.7106627226,
0.3829141855,
-0.6377149224,
-0.2041864842,
-0.3840683401,
-0.7197961807,
0.7745091915,
0.3697389662,
0.4750958085,
0.0848923698,
0.0667508021,
0.053720288,
-0.0295778867,
-0.4459909201,
0.2874796689,
-0.134613663,
-0.5163998008,
-0.1868938059,
0.0804687887,
-0.0479810126,
-0.2325734198,
0.5268847942,
-0.0814180598,
0.5425941944,
-0.0215577874,
-0.4797411561,
0.0249933004,
0.2665916979,
0.1750546396,
0.3708420396,
-0.2066577077,
0.1808505505,
0.360263139,
-0.4040833414,
0.0471301936,
0.4149964452,
0.0644175038,
0.0948446319,
0.6175873876,
0.5796173215,
0.3772608042,
-0.8558066487,
0.3629869819,
0.2375800163,
-0.1389897913,
0.1038454473,
-0.0469326824,
0.1250222772,
0.3363665044,
0.2831729054,
0.1239323765,
-0.1502427757,
-0.562259376,
0.2276122868,
0.6071158648,
-0.3499955535,
-0.3026106656,
0.1902555078,
0.3241742849,
-0.2210351378,
0.9936106801,
-0.0474582203,
-0.696703732,
0.5516812801,
0.4990123212,
0.5461130738,
-0.1483797431,
0.2166251689,
0.2850579917,
0.2938863635,
0.0484238602,
0.3106354475,
-0.3043498993,
-1.0459594727,
-0.5683128238,
-0.7314314246,
-0.3810762167,
-0.013993416,
-0.8887183666,
0.1848409027,
-0.1817516685,
-0.0952602178,
0.0135067236,
-0.1419364065,
-0.9800174832,
-0.3745740056,
0.438377142,
0.9969797134,
-0.8700208068,
1.0992544889,
0.6144204736,
-0.3382780254,
-0.4883685112,
0.0954123661,
-0.6387543678,
-1.2502536774,
1.0262094736,
-0.1806266308,
-0.1032513678,
0.2665587664,
-0.4904509783,
-0.8494884372,
0.6977838874,
0.4060887992,
-0.5294476748,
-0.1930320859,
-0.1408222169,
0.6758397818,
-0.0644243062,
-0.2170826942,
0.6038221717,
0.4908284545,
-0.0129357465,
-1.2666170597,
-0.2751450241,
-0.076236628,
0.1391804963,
0.3138164878,
-0.3458765149,
0.807882905,
-0.1432198882,
-0.3709531724,
0.2358874381,
0.7635003328,
-0.0946028158,
-0.3792955577,
0.7038916349,
0.4597066939,
0.7015554309,
-0.1583135873,
0.4952777326,
-0.5025583506,
0.5270385742,
0.7883210778,
-0.3847214878,
1.2236765623,
0.5844668746,
-0.2808224857,
0.5904991627,
0.4097647369,
-0.0638482198,
1.0541964769,
0.0425974205,
-0.4072556794,
-0.6208190918,
-0.2971734107,
-0.2581559122,
0.6130984426,
0.378438741,
-0.1651684046,
-0.5291515589,
0.2855710089,
-0.2684431672,
0.2775411904,
-0.3441368639,
0.927529037,
-0.4250773787,
-0.3085496426,
0.890406549,
-0.1633846164,
0.9825575948,
-0.7564664483,
-0.026123818,
-0.150505349,
0.0737622827,
0.2225432098,
-0.8902445436,
0.3346903622,
0.0104989568,
-0.0278441794,
-0.5173909068,
0.7872379422,
-0.573805809,
-0.3418002129,
0.5124922395,
0.676954329,
0.0539009459,
0.4642913043,
-0.5524982214,
-0.3083766997,
-0.2127732933,
0.4282850325,
0.3704565465,
0.4386850595,
0.362644285,
0.5062674284,
0.5929163694,
0.2421717048,
-0.0391897447,
0.0722082481,
0.7786971331,
-0.417340219,
-0.5165383816,
-0.6066970229,
0.0977917537,
-0.0066075404,
-0.0169324819,
0.4943381548,
0.2483080924,
0.9965220094,
-0.3592323661,
0.805835247,
-0.2529186308,
0.5017758608,
-0.4075033665,
0.8959972262,
-0.4116539955,
-0.1726225615,
0.0294065587,
-0.7279140949,
0.017086735,
0.8486754894,
-0.1906079054,
-0.1558215618,
0.1837376654,
0.5343807936,
-0.2258915752,
-0.3893015981,
0.3450431228,
0.1842602938,
0.0420101024,
0.8457692862,
0.6026457548,
-0.2121268064,
0.7106699347,
-0.2968356609,
-0.3162667453,
-0.3258839846,
-0.7058721185,
-0.9303256869,
-0.6846392751,
0.1449488848,
-0.2221193016,
0.2299757898,
1.0870935917,
0.8423503041,
-0.785492301,
-0.1951187998,
-0.0189734548,
0.0607072264,
-0.3973304927,
-0.2061935812,
0.3662171364,
-0.6632771492,
-0.8222494125,
0.3923313916,
0.0521974228,
0.2320929319,
-0.3220464289,
0.0128108812,
-0.3592786193,
0.298298955,
0.7852965593,
0.2688952088,
-0.6897931099,
-0.4624741673,
0.0799878538,
-0.1765096933,
0.0542476363,
0.6382540464,
-1.0891165733,
0.5339667797,
0.6305825114,
1.1236898899,
0.287285924,
-0.2565949261,
0.5412145853,
-1.0326752663,
0.3597690165,
0.354349196,
0.3155402541,
0.5508956313,
-0.1542897075,
0.2870146036,
0.0173628423,
-0.0431153886,
-0.8804942966,
0.3707564175,
-0.8457661867,
-0.1554235071,
0.7090594172,
-0.0647953451,
0.0091390423,
-0.0988940597,
-0.0675844178,
0.4146687984,
-0.0750984922,
0.8903472424,
0.9963553548,
0.13746804,
-0.1530233771,
-0.4752545655,
0.4298439026,
0.5464519858,
-0.6280534267,
0.2175607234,
-0.0673434883,
0.0547327548,
0.3205060959,
0.3791971505,
0.0806503445,
0.1808641553,
-0.1359232664,
0.1607269496,
0.1836078912,
-0.0563957766,
-0.2936057448,
-0.1002467424,
0.1109790355,
-0.3480932415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14404v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14404v2
|
On the Tip of the Tongue: Analyzing Conceptual Representation in Large Language Models with Reverse-Dictionary Probe
| 2024-02-22T09:45:26 | 2024-02-26T11:40:45 |
Ningyu Xu, Qi Zhang, Menghan Zhang, Peng Qian, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Probing and enhancing large language models' reasoning capacity remains a
crucial open question. Here we re-purpose the reverse dictionary task as a case
study to probe LLMs' capacity for conceptual inference. We use in-context
learning to guide the models to generate the term for an object concept implied
in a linguistic description. Models robustly achieve high accuracy in this
task, and their representation space encodes information about object
categories and fine-grained features. Further experiments suggest that the
conceptual inference ability as probed by the reverse-dictionary task predicts
model's general reasoning performance across multiple benchmarks, despite
similar syntactic generalization behaviors across models. Explorative analyses
suggest that prompting LLMs with description$\Rightarrow$word examples may
induce generalization beyond surface-level differences in task construals and
facilitate models on broader commonsense reasoning problems.
|
[
-0.4297860265,
-0.8089836836,
0.8421801925,
-0.159302488,
-0.3067907691,
-0.5177477002,
-0.2243731767,
-0.1862216294,
0.3615055382,
0.5987846851,
-0.5294592381,
-0.2328016758,
-0.5432677865,
0.2441532761,
-0.7562881708,
0.666151166,
0.0670170486,
-0.0037645162,
-0.6690036654,
0.1282432228,
-0.4600657821,
-0.3875280917,
-0.5336421132,
-0.5455279946,
0.3571425378,
0.5280476213,
0.5975453854,
0.5276263356,
0.0085714711,
0.2629176974,
-0.0203064717,
0.1634173691,
-0.6031932831,
0.1936183125,
-0.553224504,
-0.7293565869,
-0.2934902906,
0.24323304,
0.6114880443,
0.8717885017,
-0.140449062,
0.032310959,
-0.2168740928,
0.2455583364,
-0.5411157608,
-0.0631654784,
-1.0744678974,
-0.2918433845,
0.0653739125,
0.0597608052,
-0.3379483223,
0.2274840474,
0.3840160966,
-0.7786411047,
0.2074228227,
0.0069385013,
1.0089622736,
0.1968399137,
-0.4871219993,
-0.1833159029,
-0.3470108807,
0.8244868517,
-0.648026228,
0.7001225948,
0.5287613869,
0.2133661658,
-0.1195441633,
-0.841014564,
-0.9410950541,
-0.4205499589,
-0.1219809875,
0.0279625151,
0.0588865131,
-0.167621538,
0.2081582248,
0.1175320446,
-0.1033397689,
0.1008002013,
-0.1235373616,
0.0621357001,
0.6059025526,
0.1962698102,
0.0113483556,
-0.2341623455,
-0.3022921383,
-0.0042531141,
-0.8530172706,
-0.2735365331,
-0.1040857807,
0.2333147228,
-0.1464435309,
0.8132078052,
-0.3289313912,
0.598773241,
-0.0026194383,
0.18104963,
-0.0056777126,
-0.3590089381,
-0.5434404016,
-0.1049272045,
0.3204676807,
0.4941650927,
0.6361034513,
-0.1624791473,
-0.3640658259,
-0.0878115818,
0.4492426813,
-0.6728107333,
-0.0480223522,
0.2921477854,
-0.2981369495,
-0.0700920001,
0.1044336036,
-0.309999615,
-0.6175272465,
-0.4893392324,
0.4467550218,
-0.3198040724,
-0.544860065,
0.2714931667,
-0.4001258016,
0.2344508916,
0.2454597354,
-0.8124864697,
0.2145004272,
0.9269587398,
0.7849733233,
-0.0533926822,
-0.4078944623,
-0.3201373219,
0.3680248857,
-0.5709457994,
0.6379542947,
-0.6038604379,
-0.5025988221,
-0.1284520179,
0.0721687302,
0.0845973715,
-0.6729040742,
0.2084341496,
-0.4041324854,
-0.171591267,
-0.4516987801,
-0.5978748798,
-0.2370593101,
0.4953680038,
-0.4556598663,
0.7784780264,
-0.0005333356,
-0.6518828869,
0.5942638516,
-0.4519563615,
-0.2556130886,
-0.0313417092,
-0.4601950943,
-0.0118210716,
0.6009195447,
0.259373486,
0.9667268395,
-0.5627217293,
0.3304112554,
-0.4060774148,
-0.2832636833,
0.3737862706,
-0.1824500114,
0.5687338114,
0.0037039162,
-0.033541292,
-0.0407050811,
-0.6057709455,
-0.4499389827,
0.398938328,
-0.1593868285,
-0.8997507691,
0.0133141773,
-0.4158908427,
-0.1812905669,
0.0501622334,
-0.5506107211,
0.1142286435,
-0.7137113214,
0.5877198577,
0.4728085697,
-0.0535559729,
0.5141596794,
-0.0953571498,
0.2569649816,
0.225142464,
-0.2557124496,
0.0512118116,
-0.5118845105,
-0.7425640821,
-0.1201145127,
0.1475247145,
0.3647675216,
-0.7759901881,
0.1130619049,
-0.6340174675,
-0.2870996892,
-0.2636743188,
0.0292410199,
0.3417985737,
0.7877398133,
0.3169290423,
-0.2322103083,
-0.2046085149,
-1.0637868643,
-0.3064071238,
-0.2945193052,
-0.1487553418,
0.3397048414,
0.8784645796,
-0.3053050041,
1.2345360518,
-0.4165858924,
-0.1133701727,
-0.3139465451,
-0.0026905022,
0.3395294845,
0.2730139792,
0.2929855287,
-0.9782810807,
0.0677975267,
-0.0127119701,
-0.4917295575,
-0.1664618105,
-0.151359275,
-0.1410458684,
0.0791172162,
0.7406188846,
-0.8594934344,
0.1316288561,
0.0776813999,
-0.4880268872,
0.5665772557,
-0.2771632671,
-0.2207403481,
-0.9100213051,
-0.0408225805,
-0.0254536942,
-0.0046064658,
-0.6927691698,
0.2595988214,
0.1828973889,
0.2481426895,
-0.3337849677,
0.9206299186,
-0.42693156,
-0.222276479,
-0.0756014884,
0.4839430153,
0.091822356,
-0.0429150723,
0.3704295158,
0.8890398741,
0.4322530031,
-0.7973800302,
0.4161789119,
-0.0509703346,
-0.2866718173,
0.7423467636,
-0.5551615953,
-0.018915575,
-0.2455529571,
0.1429691464,
-1.3374283314,
-0.3313851953,
0.0184761118,
-0.4328497946,
0.3414072096,
0.0048765838,
-0.4343481064,
-0.2513756156,
-0.2020683438,
0.2891439199,
0.169169873,
-0.4799012244,
0.845636487,
0.2924261689,
0.1829747856,
-0.5493757129,
-1.1955975294,
-0.0038690011,
-0.4300532937,
-0.5619716048,
0.1773413867,
0.5262666941,
-0.7167575955,
-0.1033255607,
-0.2837378979,
0.0431442373,
0.3552776575,
0.1079113632,
0.096601963,
-0.2156392932,
0.7142629027,
0.1158854514,
0.1987473369,
0.465521574,
-0.3151165247,
0.5735626817,
-0.0079597812,
-0.2449104935,
0.084407784,
-0.0391701572,
0.3589482307,
-0.0243028533,
0.6720130444,
0.1373778284,
-0.3895357847,
-0.3242715299,
-0.5862850547,
-0.4611465037,
-0.413294673,
0.5378372073,
-0.9910376072,
-0.5374773741,
0.5772215724,
-0.0246931594,
-0.1741111875,
0.4062002003,
0.5157821774,
-0.1029754132,
0.5307508111,
0.2462822944,
0.0384816341,
0.0565364137,
-0.4947799444,
-0.0135960225,
-0.9523261786,
-0.1908816099,
-0.2870475948,
-0.1295355707,
-0.1430404335,
-0.6283487082,
0.2083160281,
0.2515043914,
-0.3550363183,
0.2182542831,
-0.2210335284,
0.4996598065,
0.4416483045,
0.1174031571,
0.3724138737,
-0.2186505795,
-0.4331393838,
0.3211217821,
-0.4297876954,
-0.540950954,
1.187169075,
0.4240001142,
0.6539665461,
0.0145484116,
0.7472779155,
-0.0560757592,
0.3405545652,
-0.9388238788,
0.7917627692,
-0.2031130344,
-0.702168107,
-0.5488518476,
-0.1770154089,
-0.7577635646,
0.5183173418,
0.0156558752,
-0.6003236771,
-0.0640934706,
0.0900549144,
-0.2733962834,
0.0924428403,
-0.8500548005,
0.797867775,
-0.0215230584,
-0.1557196677,
-0.4737823009,
-0.4523200691,
0.6908738017,
-0.0153347561,
0.2079958022,
0.0721431226,
-0.5924716592,
0.6674277782,
-0.1316493005,
0.9441367388,
-0.234578535,
-0.7144023776,
0.2474078685,
0.3789528906,
0.3651006222,
0.3483437598,
-0.0175615512,
-0.0115493787,
0.0951804891,
-0.1219795644,
-0.7731795907,
0.6966255307,
-0.3931887746,
-1.0932468176,
0.0134378476,
-0.688156426,
-0.5313788652,
0.0746768415,
0.0357879326,
0.3094294667,
-0.0429113731,
-0.0767144412,
0.6713808179,
-0.1348357946,
0.0247134697,
0.2600246668,
-0.3835573494,
0.0864231661,
0.7321847677,
0.1357760131,
0.5225415826,
0.5902186036,
0.4010666609,
-0.5636162758,
-0.4913997054,
-0.3894745111,
0.5449178219,
-0.9662740231,
0.0130336089,
-0.4210202098,
0.2264749557,
-0.3689107001,
-0.0444678962,
-0.1707179248,
-0.6333820224,
-0.5063518882,
-0.1538870037,
0.4222945869,
0.6652575135,
0.1940209121,
0.2930047214,
-0.3909181058,
0.5515889525,
0.5399720073,
0.131080538,
0.3182412982,
-0.7803880572,
0.0945759118,
0.1119882837,
0.0187235456,
-0.8199540973,
0.118359454,
0.1945729852,
0.4555856884,
0.5469478965,
-0.1028153896,
0.6191015244,
-0.337818712,
0.8922284842,
-0.0074080639,
-0.8998578191,
0.3969652951,
-0.3205846548,
0.3975483179,
-0.004908097,
0.4302383959,
-0.5950601697,
-0.478186667,
-0.3719084263,
-0.4773849249,
0.4492910206,
-0.2813574672,
0.5518199205,
-0.3458364308,
0.549292326,
0.2163225412,
0.1172487512,
-0.4503327608,
0.111809358,
-0.2681889534,
-0.0342285521,
-0.2304579467,
-0.2878124714,
-0.2129492164,
-0.3186001182,
0.4930889606,
-0.3135887682,
0.2330825329,
0.314604193,
-0.121779263,
0.1973680258,
0.2412822396,
0.662337482,
0.8668180108,
-0.0648445934,
0.5574427843,
0.5367648005,
-0.4268962145,
-0.0994247496,
-0.0637717545,
0.1674935967,
-0.2432520092,
0.6682292819,
0.4502032995,
0.0903764442,
-0.7575024962,
0.4570825994,
0.1784151793,
-0.213168636,
-0.1852505505,
0.003323152,
0.6939364076,
0.3256702721,
0.4634026885,
-0.6548229456,
0.0362691209,
-0.7396695018,
0.0561914109,
0.8239981532,
-0.008008833,
-0.112973094,
0.4904809296,
0.0147957625,
0.2154325247,
0.6787983179,
-0.1321647912,
-0.52796489,
0.6896788478,
0.5334557295,
0.5511171818,
0.0776155069,
-0.0076079895,
0.1148853973,
0.1641308516,
-0.0732229948,
0.4223147929,
-0.2073777914,
-1.2158575058,
-0.4157492518,
-0.386010766,
-0.1083083823,
0.2099163979,
-0.3276118636,
0.2498479784,
-0.2165790051,
-0.1333055049,
-0.0751762837,
-0.2945969403,
-0.4810616076,
0.4188914895,
0.179686591,
1.2585815191,
-0.712295711,
0.8883817196,
0.7964888215,
-0.4358353317,
-0.5928705931,
-0.0312169958,
-0.0808948353,
-1.0553326607,
1.3305705786,
0.1519536823,
-0.346226275,
0.0162672438,
-0.6901243329,
-0.8361608982,
1.1168138981,
0.2584540546,
-0.5280705094,
-0.1668825448,
0.0668796897,
0.3984440863,
-0.5335168839,
0.300781548,
0.9110001326,
0.3686220646,
0.0657505468,
-1.1141924858,
0.4271247983,
0.2549287677,
0.2036730796,
0.1148330793,
-0.2199578434,
0.9820996523,
-0.37567693,
-0.3886303604,
0.1408704668,
0.7107155323,
0.3363200426,
0.1623795778,
0.5841727257,
0.8728772998,
0.5334665775,
-0.0103489989,
1.1610155106,
0.3651105165,
0.141071111,
1.0185297728,
-0.2149203271,
0.8566064835,
1.0400658846,
-0.0050345822,
0.3108028769,
0.4434171617,
0.1658955067,
0.5540295243,
0.5280322433,
0.1295551658,
-0.4205091,
-0.1636550426,
-0.2079021633,
0.5252630711,
0.742860198,
-0.4029957652,
-0.2547740936,
0.1050381958,
-0.0968226716,
0.1324080527,
-0.6415210962,
0.5660378933,
0.2419310808,
-0.6684880257,
0.9362172484,
-0.0885679722,
0.7465988398,
-0.2887479067,
-0.1574656069,
-0.2486541718,
0.1793576181,
0.0779855475,
-1.0433272123,
0.2412838638,
-0.4161427617,
0.0904872715,
-0.0840226635,
0.7285859585,
-0.2777872086,
-0.1535670906,
0.3076333702,
0.5945938826,
0.3164866567,
-0.2024415731,
-0.4030572772,
-0.1279577166,
-0.3986034393,
-0.3628613353,
0.067861177,
0.7980912328,
-0.2869080007,
0.9205387235,
0.1523245275,
0.3346098363,
0.0884570777,
0.1815435141,
0.7436699867,
-0.5656097531,
-0.3745886385,
-0.8706232905,
0.3718993664,
-0.007831621,
-0.4424764812,
0.6093701124,
0.3388513029,
1.3309211731,
-0.4224124253,
0.5644156933,
-0.002086225,
0.563464582,
-0.8282731175,
0.5533367991,
-0.8502017856,
0.1281876415,
0.0547671728,
-0.6081281304,
-0.125581041,
0.6594150662,
-0.690140605,
-0.0508022495,
0.569190681,
0.8097084761,
-0.4232499301,
0.0344222784,
0.3646049798,
0.4380290508,
0.1419846565,
0.4638679624,
1.1271157265,
-0.0539213382,
0.1399354339,
-0.1079592034,
0.0603941083,
-0.0710344538,
-0.855610013,
-1.1153591871,
-0.8411112428,
0.0576421507,
-0.1280371249,
-0.2276353389,
0.7964676619,
0.5269256234,
-0.6892663836,
-0.4436222613,
-0.2619090974,
0.0605933182,
-0.1363446712,
-0.2618528903,
0.2069467902,
-0.3886192739,
-0.6607485414,
0.3229908943,
-0.1362729967,
-0.0534636006,
-0.4409978986,
-0.0850781277,
-0.4113727808,
0.146208033,
0.6457195878,
-0.1401971579,
-1.2520711422,
-0.4734801054,
-0.2433776706,
0.0385462902,
-0.3881044984,
0.8642964363,
-0.9001283646,
0.3616448343,
0.4148527086,
0.9240192175,
0.4784264863,
0.0230274629,
0.6308740377,
-0.7939408422,
0.0536025912,
0.0737970099,
0.4557933211,
0.2179299891,
-0.2055372298,
0.5506088138,
0.3043902218,
-0.0487337485,
-0.8786810637,
0.4396316707,
-0.6806855798,
-0.779043138,
1.3982616663,
0.0822329819,
-0.1572711021,
-0.0254852865,
-0.1434344202,
0.2318975031,
-0.2360327095,
0.5719009042,
1.0339683294,
-0.1410851032,
-0.2542150021,
-0.5990816355,
0.281807512,
0.537324369,
-0.5216188431,
0.3534284234,
0.3161719143,
0.2383830994,
0.3561539352,
0.3062250018,
0.1334475279,
0.1402985752,
-0.1371232271,
-0.4292832613,
-0.1190153509,
-0.2741207778,
-0.3428663015,
-0.1154916435,
0.1782487631,
-0.1269626468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14888v1
|
Efficient data selection employing Semantic Similarity-based Graph Structures for model training
| 2024-02-22T09:43:53 | 2024-02-22T09:43:53 |
Roxana Petcu, Subhadeep Maji
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent developments in natural language processing (NLP) have highlighted the
need for substantial amounts of data for models to capture textual information
accurately. This raises concerns regarding the computational resources and time
required for training such models. This paper introduces Semantics for data
SAliency in Model performance Estimation (SeSaME). It is an efficient data
sampling mechanism solely based on textual information without passing the data
through a compute-heavy model or other intensive pre-processing
transformations. The application of this approach is demonstrated in the use
case of low-resource automated speech recognition (ASR) models, which
excessively rely on text-to-speech (TTS) calls when using augmented data.
SeSaME learns to categorize new incoming data points into speech recognition
difficulty buckets by employing semantic similarity-based graph structures and
discrete ASR information from homophilous neighbourhoods through message
passing. The results indicate reliable projections of ASR performance, with a
93% accuracy increase when using the proposed method compared to random
predictions, bringing non-trivial information on the impact of textual
representations in speech models. Furthermore, a series of experiments show
both the benefits and challenges of using the ASR information on incoming data
to fine-tune the model. We report a 7% drop in validation loss compared to
random sampling, 7% WER drop with non-local aggregation when evaluating against
a highly difficult dataset, and 1.8% WER drop with local aggregation and high
semantic similarity between datasets.
|
[
-0.2497004569,
-0.742087245,
0.2794954479,
-0.0287390314,
-0.2573804259,
-0.157499671,
-0.329023391,
-0.7095345855,
0.1418493837,
0.2631219923,
-0.3574017286,
-0.5669264793,
-0.7371979356,
0.0473289602,
-0.7973827124,
0.7768892646,
0.2275894284,
0.0160621107,
-0.33298406,
-0.0498164631,
-0.1702228785,
-0.3383442461,
-0.5197520852,
-0.2149717957,
0.5484310985,
0.3736823797,
0.6475614309,
0.9413238764,
0.5802028775,
0.3882285357,
-0.2494783551,
-0.0195172019,
-0.4866983294,
0.0479184985,
-0.1885994226,
-0.2239003032,
-0.1459035724,
0.0656419247,
0.7366080284,
1.1498514414,
0.1832270622,
0.3543187678,
0.2156443149,
0.602456212,
-0.8575740457,
0.411835283,
-0.8614587784,
0.1104322001,
-0.4802374542,
0.0673111379,
-0.1811014563,
-0.3389641941,
0.4370328486,
-0.5583513975,
0.3189338446,
0.1474202126,
0.9927911162,
0.3920938969,
-0.0528927483,
-0.415809691,
-0.4698846936,
0.975284636,
-0.5473626852,
0.6192903519,
0.8942616582,
0.3127795756,
0.0485688969,
-0.7856541872,
-0.5132812858,
-0.3874717057,
-0.1951202601,
0.013655928,
-0.3275238276,
0.1066444144,
0.3244654536,
0.3561653793,
-0.4663964808,
0.0369737633,
-0.4436877668,
-0.2043225914,
0.4110302031,
-0.0554499589,
-0.0826215893,
-0.4056901038,
-0.2334587872,
-0.3967866004,
-0.2877599299,
0.1516626179,
0.3378891945,
0.7763650417,
-0.08015275,
0.5114147067,
-0.5073667765,
0.9973025322,
-0.1003672928,
-0.0329930708,
0.297695905,
-0.169371143,
-0.27225402,
0.0921540782,
0.5783109665,
0.1859336048,
0.3158368468,
-0.3179761767,
-0.2131455839,
0.5103605986,
0.1499849111,
-0.551900208,
-0.3562666476,
-0.0310469326,
-0.4827559888,
-0.2100922167,
0.0559571162,
-0.6149273515,
0.0305839833,
-0.4248991013,
0.0112208994,
-0.6002179384,
0.2571300864,
-0.0404822044,
-0.0294650141,
-0.0500042923,
0.2260201424,
-0.9861290455,
0.5462408066,
0.5787144899,
0.8445501924,
-0.2960285246,
-0.1522859186,
-0.7442492247,
0.4178451002,
-0.1169454306,
0.7504979372,
-0.9054425359,
-0.3921106756,
-0.4051017463,
-0.2103103548,
-0.4347258508,
-0.4466146827,
0.6743429899,
-0.4544177651,
-0.0331466943,
0.0634256378,
-0.6143606901,
-0.2598527968,
0.1090518385,
-0.7745622993,
1.1424942017,
0.0447314195,
-1.1104050875,
0.479703933,
-0.6304399371,
-0.5572916269,
-0.2394574136,
-0.1305534989,
-0.5221879482,
0.000429513,
0.2736252844,
0.5142449141,
-0.1865924895,
-0.0908623412,
-0.446739912,
-0.2968432605,
0.166528821,
-0.3836382627,
0.3832404912,
0.3928835094,
-0.2207621783,
0.1025455222,
-0.9226098061,
0.2287813872,
-0.0911881253,
-0.2853627205,
-0.5157639384,
-0.0569737069,
0.3660548329,
0.1104842648,
0.056918297,
-0.6193886399,
-0.3142038882,
-0.5790452361,
0.1359023452,
0.598963201,
-0.4584244788,
0.2959721982,
-0.3643375337,
0.2279297411,
-0.2200887799,
-0.0244225599,
0.1175231412,
-0.570304215,
-0.7037795782,
-0.3331297934,
0.7550875545,
0.3351960778,
-0.5750764012,
0.4767960608,
-0.4956634343,
-0.3967351317,
-0.6417998075,
0.0135158887,
0.5640739202,
0.8949400187,
0.3018835783,
-0.4797868431,
-0.5490317345,
-0.819806993,
-0.006553255,
-0.1679586321,
-0.1536290944,
0.5187587142,
0.1838603765,
-0.1777765751,
1.1402570009,
-0.4526776969,
-0.271237582,
-0.1540760547,
0.0991671756,
0.0682117939,
0.4651829004,
0.4168094397,
-0.8459535837,
-0.5293681026,
0.0167649202,
-0.5287174582,
-0.1468695551,
0.449059695,
-0.0283007026,
0.1831966043,
0.2802620232,
-0.5079876781,
0.6690033078,
0.4919116199,
-0.1946201771,
0.0658666864,
0.0799527019,
-0.0277554188,
-0.7886743546,
0.5488399863,
0.029086357,
-0.4198345542,
-0.5669579506,
-0.2063595951,
-0.2190866768,
-0.1840768158,
-0.2168494165,
0.6193330884,
-0.2136770189,
-0.5007017255,
-0.163645044,
0.3110323548,
-0.1723019183,
0.4492949545,
0.1655510068,
0.620736897,
0.5522632599,
-0.6903843284,
0.3325760067,
0.3973025084,
-0.4336682558,
0.3042526543,
-0.5195447803,
0.0969501734,
-0.0065801945,
0.0250223316,
-0.8625226617,
-0.2551928759,
0.141968295,
-0.5085287094,
0.2559948266,
0.0806901306,
-0.5002999306,
-0.3706350923,
-0.1828322858,
0.1636347324,
0.2730591297,
-0.4338935018,
0.3593993783,
0.6669237614,
-0.3518688977,
-0.4660423398,
-0.521376431,
-0.1708576977,
-0.2139988393,
-0.621822238,
0.2504983544,
0.4337712228,
0.0126584042,
0.2416348308,
-0.1640841961,
-0.0361610204,
0.2557570934,
0.3193687499,
0.0138468854,
-0.0522069894,
0.2785501778,
-0.1324050874,
-0.3879345059,
-0.258485198,
-0.1980430335,
0.576800704,
0.077085577,
-0.4446731508,
-0.7445478439,
0.3519753814,
0.1951958984,
-0.0962669477,
0.3031328917,
0.557639122,
-0.2671592236,
0.0627387315,
-0.4349978566,
-0.3465792239,
-0.402600795,
0.5299474001,
-0.40474841,
-0.6332830787,
0.3958071172,
-0.0309004914,
-0.2009997517,
0.3218197525,
0.2717882693,
-0.1641061604,
0.9057382941,
0.6608966589,
-0.4611186385,
0.8579134941,
-0.3525505662,
-0.0850256011,
-0.5606748462,
-0.2069409043,
-0.7376002073,
-0.4998493791,
-0.4907058775,
-0.5190612674,
0.285150528,
-0.1487015188,
-0.0958539471,
0.157736674,
-0.3110538125,
0.2280595154,
0.8969979286,
-0.0034681524,
0.3382025957,
0.4368451536,
-0.1128723994,
-0.06294173,
-0.8055140972,
-0.5319596529,
1.0353351831,
0.2573902309,
0.7973057628,
-0.2191156745,
0.3828517199,
0.1455951184,
0.0569120236,
-0.6588834524,
0.491817832,
-0.4476209283,
-0.1183333173,
-0.5364221931,
-0.5701600313,
-1.1232101917,
0.0463147499,
-0.1870170087,
-0.9251452088,
0.1314894259,
0.207042709,
-0.2696208358,
0.0743572563,
-0.6491732001,
0.7147390842,
0.0653755143,
-0.1196741611,
-0.3355991542,
-0.9302551746,
-0.049758099,
0.0269990321,
-0.087024428,
-0.2726863623,
0.1290271729,
0.8964543343,
-0.4532038271,
0.6908504367,
-0.1475992948,
0.2951849401,
0.0768593252,
-0.2758801281,
0.6335208416,
-0.3004623055,
-0.4462636411,
0.3242833912,
-0.2290445268,
-0.327072233,
-0.7348157167,
0.536960423,
-0.8273155689,
-0.3271477222,
-0.2517178357,
-0.7080067396,
-0.4567905664,
0.0278639439,
0.1744939983,
0.3314113319,
-0.0054376442,
0.3637226224,
0.2370251864,
0.1858825386,
0.3735729754,
0.1797211021,
-0.0270889867,
-0.2684717774,
0.929171741,
0.1624420136,
0.3202335536,
0.3994921148,
0.0356990546,
-0.5246750712,
-0.5547828674,
-0.3816419542,
0.028069431,
-0.5008957982,
-0.2731411159,
-0.8701302409,
-0.2870254219,
-0.3157696128,
-0.0357346386,
-0.3961388171,
-0.7762730122,
-0.3102081716,
-0.0115592517,
0.5691341758,
0.3744380474,
0.0653475896,
0.4415220618,
-0.5428459644,
0.3673954308,
0.3322701454,
0.4562935829,
0.123079665,
-0.4136511087,
-0.4540917873,
0.1284756809,
-0.2716261446,
-0.502384901,
0.4308065772,
0.4173092246,
0.5494593978,
0.3754490316,
0.024085857,
0.9045530558,
-0.2963252366,
0.325525105,
0.0143153649,
-0.9304687381,
0.8311408162,
-0.1141554192,
0.2063158154,
0.7385683656,
0.2484152317,
-0.437689513,
-0.5581514239,
-0.5346440077,
-0.849026978,
0.9835639596,
0.6027683616,
-0.0513578542,
0.1700026989,
0.0099207256,
-0.0027149024,
0.3116196692,
-0.3467828035,
-0.1826977283,
-0.3094565272,
-0.4676580727,
0.0220096651,
-0.0628038645,
0.002829487,
-0.2710023522,
0.625441432,
-0.2465211451,
0.0619627014,
-0.050828062,
-0.1080774963,
-0.0409809239,
0.0930517167,
0.0892446116,
0.3862028718,
-0.3573452234,
0.0894681215,
0.1729190201,
-0.5827970505,
-0.1779940426,
0.4925307035,
-0.1327106208,
0.2252700925,
0.3550537825,
0.9720872045,
0.4868923426,
-0.7328619361,
0.4048032165,
0.0698998496,
0.3903576136,
0.0764550492,
0.1715574861,
-0.220727846,
0.1707757711,
0.1996447295,
0.0005062961,
0.4916040599,
-0.417801559,
0.3316951096,
0.5207431912,
-0.4667726159,
-0.1290730536,
0.4922787547,
0.168608427,
0.0438461415,
0.6724487543,
-0.0575371087,
-0.235628143,
0.5901853442,
0.4607546031,
0.6824668646,
-0.3780674636,
0.0740422606,
0.0918833017,
-0.2314132601,
0.121883899,
0.1606099457,
-0.3302432597,
-0.7085467577,
-0.2071353495,
-0.9071118832,
-0.4614341855,
0.0141583662,
-0.7501778603,
0.3653300107,
-0.4018494785,
-0.3671699762,
0.1204098612,
0.2088016719,
-0.4719669819,
0.3605552018,
0.2235718071,
0.760435462,
-0.6910006404,
0.9062993526,
0.6621979475,
-0.0311554037,
-0.783654511,
0.0410163701,
-0.1271154583,
-0.7229030728,
0.873634696,
0.2210496366,
-0.1380535066,
-0.0389331691,
-0.2321192473,
-1.1350101233,
0.9311833382,
0.5939754844,
-0.5159993768,
-0.0836491138,
0.1995583475,
0.4679673016,
-0.3704477847,
0.1090752408,
0.4973796308,
0.2371459305,
0.5639669895,
-1.1863826513,
-0.1430321336,
-0.3506655991,
0.3814915419,
-0.0606689341,
-0.4471775293,
0.8720387816,
-0.0642296746,
-0.4054642618,
0.1670881361,
0.6502946019,
0.5089362264,
0.5565086603,
0.6364209652,
0.5850770473,
1.0655796528,
0.0829279795,
1.1806830168,
-0.4690124094,
0.3882229924,
1.1329231262,
-0.2143984288,
0.9180278182,
0.3531285822,
-0.1797809452,
0.2401704788,
0.7389913797,
0.0757311359,
0.8281334639,
0.0714858249,
-0.0352544151,
-0.1700831354,
-0.4602991641,
-0.3456506431,
0.8350670934,
0.3738516867,
-0.4000118673,
-0.3627607226,
-0.0413367338,
-0.1843016148,
0.1461125463,
-0.3125120103,
0.8678728342,
0.0291445982,
-0.0878124684,
0.5286097527,
0.0417794175,
0.5411996245,
-0.5714316964,
0.0414615497,
0.0985277817,
0.0637068674,
-0.1412319392,
-0.4727753699,
0.4493508339,
0.1696187556,
-0.460488826,
-0.0376249924,
0.6487927437,
-0.3832161129,
-0.8167102337,
0.2564971447,
0.2822450995,
0.2990660965,
0.0400693081,
-0.5625265837,
0.1460135728,
-0.1454549283,
0.0172994453,
0.15050143,
0.3784987926,
-0.2483676076,
0.7545051575,
0.708529532,
0.48992154,
-0.0237683747,
0.0229016524,
1.1450805664,
-0.5321964622,
-0.9038078189,
-0.7132689357,
0.1462595612,
-0.4434934855,
0.0496112257,
0.7282221913,
0.7271487713,
0.9550340772,
0.1987745166,
0.730710566,
0.1294402331,
0.8978016973,
-0.6938931942,
0.7863160968,
-0.2204304487,
0.2578793764,
-0.6291995049,
-0.8570826054,
-0.2988781631,
1.0114864111,
-0.7151508331,
0.1377450079,
0.3608795106,
0.7922504544,
-0.4143175185,
0.2615465224,
0.4215273559,
0.1526482403,
-0.050954856,
0.4731804729,
0.6632966995,
-0.3283113241,
0.3377085328,
-0.2440558821,
-0.0694591179,
-0.3890762925,
-0.4877736568,
-0.7413944006,
-0.6000503898,
-0.2641403675,
0.0220477339,
0.1843847334,
1.0123178959,
1.0256624222,
-1.0261257887,
-0.2143624276,
0.1049975827,
0.3082792759,
0.0015641362,
-0.1942201406,
0.8000946641,
-0.4735781848,
-0.9079704285,
0.2167406231,
0.2253645658,
0.1170032099,
0.2022875249,
0.0367710404,
-0.2239280939,
-0.22169514,
0.5432601571,
0.166096434,
-0.6825671792,
-0.3951911628,
-0.3609256744,
-0.1228856966,
-0.0175519381,
0.6347404122,
-1.0647308826,
0.5326504707,
0.2399424016,
0.7355750799,
0.5354756713,
0.1539674997,
0.4276350737,
-0.995521605,
0.5313387513,
0.3055551648,
0.2289503813,
0.6486055255,
-0.1826820672,
0.5545189381,
0.3103850782,
-0.1586000472,
-0.8962181211,
0.0142311156,
-0.8523055911,
0.0261942148,
1.0322680473,
-0.2280654907,
-0.366067946,
-0.2637956738,
0.0168662462,
0.4157929718,
-0.5183975697,
0.9972472787,
0.4062141478,
-0.2942883968,
0.0678269714,
-0.4646358192,
0.6814283133,
0.2764611244,
-0.6782515049,
0.0719726831,
0.404620409,
-0.0442783311,
0.3251951635,
0.4971135557,
0.0739197358,
0.1448036581,
-0.0035156053,
-0.252695173,
-0.0418553762,
-0.3124720156,
-0.177032575,
0.3002295494,
-0.1515814811,
-0.5233818889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14382v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14382v2
|
Chain-of-History Reasoning for Temporal Knowledge Graph Forecasting
| 2024-02-22T08:51:39 | 2024-06-07T08:15:18 |
Yuwei Xia, Ding Wang, Qiang Liu, Liang Wang, Shu Wu, Xiaoyu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph (TKG) forecasting aims to predict future facts based
on given histories. Most recent graph-based models excel at capturing
structural information within TKGs but lack semantic comprehension abilities.
Nowadays, with the surge of LLMs, the LLM-based TKG prediction model has
emerged. However, the existing LLM-based model exhibits three shortcomings: (1)
It only focuses on the first-order history for prediction while ignoring
high-order historical information, resulting in the provided information for
LLMs being extremely limited. (2) LLMs struggle with optimal reasoning
performance under heavy historical information loads. (3) For TKG prediction,
the temporal reasoning capability of LLM alone is limited. To address the first
two challenges, we propose Chain-of-History (CoH) reasoning which explores
high-order histories step-by-step, achieving effective utilization of
high-order historical information for LLMs on TKG prediction. To address the
third issue, we design CoH as a plug-and-play module to enhance the performance
of graph-based models for TKG prediction. Extensive experiments on three
datasets and backbones demonstrate the effectiveness of CoH.
|
[
-0.2241870016,
-0.7479279041,
0.898552835,
-0.0458499081,
-0.355925113,
0.4941053391,
0.3375165761,
-0.5634174347,
0.0279797465,
0.5830110908,
-0.8814114928,
-0.8658075929,
-0.3404586315,
-0.2507814467,
-0.0590240397,
0.689256072,
-0.19792144,
-0.2685409188,
-0.2358676195,
0.081110701,
-0.4880856872,
-0.5779977441,
-0.5828614235,
-0.8793361187,
0.7378868461,
0.486215204,
0.7007599473,
0.9987606406,
-0.0048850658,
0.0200878605,
-0.0710300356,
0.3907108605,
-0.5714064837,
0.173406139,
-0.1420883089,
-0.1827848256,
-0.9473507404,
-0.196257636,
0.283613205,
0.7504238486,
0.0592052676,
0.1804985106,
-0.1478713304,
0.5588504672,
-0.4579249322,
0.6267899275,
-0.3620949686,
0.1777731329,
-0.0507675484,
-0.5545008779,
-0.5735396743,
-0.3732783198,
0.4398968518,
-0.8904547691,
-0.0987674221,
0.5248313546,
0.7532957792,
0.0770800039,
-0.6974905729,
0.0099978773,
-0.7937269807,
0.7265737057,
-0.6682763696,
0.5642393827,
0.4805843532,
0.4408281147,
-0.3891748488,
-0.9399852157,
-0.2745868862,
-0.1368933469,
-0.0080005266,
0.3375349343,
-0.1091716662,
-0.0246593263,
0.2565941811,
0.1486252695,
-0.6965366006,
0.2884627581,
-0.0995777249,
-0.1744678766,
0.3621895611,
0.5330167413,
-0.1076559573,
-0.3625617623,
-0.9011837244,
0.1819795668,
-0.6953412294,
-0.0762146264,
0.2833161652,
0.1786304712,
-0.0503654443,
0.5035472512,
-0.314319104,
0.7210114002,
0.0255242512,
-0.381608963,
-0.2629373074,
-0.1054097041,
-0.1586847603,
0.1262331754,
0.5459794998,
0.5022613406,
0.1491661221,
-0.4310880601,
0.1815903038,
-0.0065924414,
0.0009433076,
-0.6586747766,
-0.2221700996,
0.1190877557,
-0.2101924568,
-0.382738471,
-0.2755982578,
-0.8745004535,
-0.2620141506,
-0.2125538588,
0.3921900094,
-0.4498247802,
-0.1699778438,
-0.0886578709,
-0.3995864391,
-0.1832790524,
0.4962341189,
-0.4217498899,
0.2303296328,
0.6236889958,
0.7715720534,
-0.2358441353,
-0.244272545,
-0.4442177117,
0.8467540145,
-0.325083971,
0.5940077901,
-0.4147796035,
-0.3124971688,
-0.2138953507,
-0.0414587855,
0.264080435,
-0.1500424743,
0.2579155862,
-0.9653030038,
-0.0406129695,
-0.1809786409,
-0.9175980091,
-0.338822484,
0.5669921041,
-0.6305773854,
0.8119582534,
0.24274005,
-0.7412429452,
0.5153388977,
-0.1692588478,
-0.4219476879,
0.1594786793,
-0.1856841296,
-0.4941515625,
-0.501976788,
0.4294953644,
0.3730169833,
-0.2362486124,
0.6024599671,
-0.8528324962,
-0.2042511404,
-0.2750341892,
-0.2286787629,
0.6934512854,
0.2093978822,
-0.2331033349,
-0.1290844977,
-0.6154932976,
0.024490077,
0.0620526597,
-0.1367191821,
-0.2025110424,
0.3346007168,
-0.6301963925,
0.1048552692,
0.2862239778,
-0.1433345079,
0.5144681931,
-0.2459076792,
0.3173776865,
0.8758105636,
0.2762966156,
0.5122664571,
-0.5205187798,
0.7544084191,
0.0669585094,
0.3941791952,
-0.1257839054,
-0.5191431046,
-0.3058292568,
0.2251909524,
-0.0296016019,
0.5699061155,
-0.8781806827,
0.1697078794,
-0.5503502488,
-0.5653141141,
0.7178460956,
-0.2008640468,
0.0180350319,
0.847868681,
0.3294007182,
0.0759666562,
-0.7727156878,
-0.429153502,
-0.1771467626,
-0.7800839543,
0.1654237956,
0.5309584737,
0.3503515422,
0.0316660292,
1.0060482025,
-0.7352347374,
0.181410417,
-0.0786347017,
0.1889851987,
0.4787193239,
0.109668389,
0.3212730587,
-0.4281209111,
-0.1103940457,
0.1605975479,
-0.7534394264,
0.1074368283,
0.1319125593,
-0.2864233553,
0.3006001711,
0.458150506,
-0.373552382,
0.646188736,
0.5553582907,
-0.5037031174,
0.7989350557,
0.007271097,
0.0373045541,
-1.1009111404,
-0.0067431857,
-0.3211590946,
-0.2569749057,
-0.3701760769,
-0.4744853675,
-0.159322381,
-0.3242204785,
-0.2249098867,
0.9286578298,
-0.1747110337,
-0.0523483269,
0.0588439405,
-0.030290816,
0.1417084038,
0.5562256575,
-0.0284956656,
0.1232281774,
0.1510186195,
-0.7874900103,
0.3904484808,
-0.0632306859,
-0.3086027205,
0.1566939056,
-0.3284013569,
0.2086313814,
0.2618974447,
0.4792432785,
-0.7623134851,
-0.2431675643,
0.238040179,
-0.4373164773,
0.4498583078,
-0.6140844822,
-0.6135234237,
-0.6453793049,
0.0720496178,
0.5015304089,
0.4720701873,
-0.8226935863,
0.9557988048,
-0.0417761989,
0.0668888539,
-0.8612481952,
-0.3773097694,
-0.0965093002,
-0.1848543584,
-0.9089441299,
0.4119116366,
0.061845094,
-0.1900673956,
0.0980220884,
-0.6775209904,
-0.1295493841,
0.0013683734,
0.1865124851,
0.605145216,
-0.0689464286,
0.2252533287,
0.0197171476,
-0.2172325552,
0.0289798398,
-1.0534319878,
0.5579151511,
0.1031767651,
-0.2112412155,
-0.0738396868,
-0.0993077978,
0.6048656702,
0.3115850985,
0.5321019888,
0.3649189472,
-0.3081740439,
-0.2365645468,
-0.6713221669,
-0.0908157378,
-0.376223594,
0.1896150708,
-0.0501596183,
-0.9138288498,
0.6068143249,
-0.3039245605,
-0.0567634106,
0.5273857713,
0.3896467984,
-0.4707235098,
0.761521697,
0.0046141311,
-0.2294734269,
0.4960335195,
-0.407265991,
0.0721411109,
-0.3325566947,
-0.4622219503,
-0.0951991156,
-0.1843053848,
-0.6042595506,
-0.0506724119,
0.6623440981,
0.3608845472,
-0.6189971566,
0.0458555147,
0.0421363451,
0.1953972429,
0.3177823722,
0.4107933044,
0.6355502605,
0.1470364928,
-0.0856643096,
0.3874376416,
-0.9516811371,
-0.4142585397,
0.9462203383,
0.2924379706,
0.9906359911,
-0.2896790802,
0.4766373932,
0.3757801354,
-0.043358393,
-0.6275879741,
0.5115410089,
-0.2907417119,
-0.5917029977,
-0.3424628079,
-0.5659686327,
-0.8906053901,
-0.3439216316,
0.1524181217,
-0.7049118876,
0.163733393,
0.507627666,
-0.3162643909,
0.6800526381,
-0.4337167144,
0.7193775773,
-0.1782773435,
-0.3656489849,
-0.2240723521,
-0.7033199668,
0.2607569695,
0.343626827,
0.2095350623,
-0.216833964,
0.0630021393,
0.731775701,
-0.7133325338,
0.9092055559,
-0.0975176692,
0.3137916028,
0.4301597774,
0.3695746362,
0.9338364005,
-0.0526456051,
-0.0589014366,
0.2881691158,
0.1507281065,
-0.4362334311,
-0.6926787496,
0.5265042782,
-0.6751611233,
-0.7375099063,
-0.2425183654,
-0.7741371393,
-0.2450653017,
0.1307551861,
0.2328935564,
0.7534813881,
0.0299147274,
-0.1634389609,
0.2722421587,
0.1277010292,
0.5173095465,
0.2729075253,
-0.5165895224,
-0.5866383314,
0.6472433209,
0.4451371431,
0.4545607567,
0.6002324224,
0.715929091,
-0.3054609299,
-0.4162317812,
-0.3965195417,
0.0950746685,
-0.8334501982,
-0.2190320641,
-0.5213015079,
-0.1095691174,
-0.2782670259,
-0.1226838976,
-0.0084918076,
-0.6667916179,
-0.3539459705,
-0.0773338303,
0.5650325418,
0.8214400411,
0.1332003623,
0.2540436983,
-0.6527331471,
0.232179895,
0.4179325104,
0.5868928432,
0.3158228099,
-0.113989152,
-0.2622090578,
-0.3042425811,
-0.5743563175,
-0.8771820068,
0.2348882109,
-0.4265269041,
0.4753880501,
0.3440321684,
0.2285286933,
0.8254620433,
-0.3984570801,
0.7796484232,
0.1773163527,
-0.5204653144,
0.709328115,
-0.6596767306,
0.2118246108,
-0.1849690825,
0.5103232265,
-0.3362353146,
-0.3234575689,
-0.7998377681,
-0.8726217151,
0.727293849,
-0.0781737342,
-0.7747793794,
-0.0413743407,
0.5112941265,
0.4754312336,
0.0170995966,
-0.4653761685,
-0.1639588624,
-0.2641158402,
0.0688232109,
0.1016186699,
-0.1676064879,
0.1661940813,
-0.193989411,
0.6808800101,
-0.0942439139,
-0.0047726948,
0.050877668,
0.0078404704,
-0.2880420387,
0.2619869709,
0.1964855641,
1.3028562069,
-0.4699614346,
0.1404564381,
0.4598382711,
-0.2330410779,
0.0471775755,
0.0037710813,
-0.1378759444,
-0.0566959009,
0.6546917558,
0.7896246314,
0.1106705591,
-0.1465151906,
0.2028768063,
0.301307559,
-0.0501542948,
-0.539478004,
-0.1742143482,
0.0834192485,
0.6580398679,
0.5177267194,
-0.051853057,
-0.3863246441,
-0.4701851606,
0.004782076,
0.0029569564,
-0.1362327933,
-0.1645281911,
0.5922851562,
-0.1553172171,
-0.1389223933,
0.7298304439,
-0.0244978461,
-0.6233404279,
0.7605426908,
0.3444451988,
0.515915215,
-0.1142515093,
-0.0853887647,
0.4314156473,
0.0185478888,
-0.1460600048,
0.4229476452,
0.0858492553,
-0.4826517403,
-0.6406438947,
-0.4048514962,
-0.4829655886,
0.1408871114,
-0.544676125,
0.4482967257,
-0.4652849138,
-0.4398848116,
-0.4812930524,
0.1673014015,
-0.8109782338,
0.2264570445,
0.0194929652,
0.9629707336,
-0.6155365109,
0.7176666856,
0.1217986047,
-0.1682863533,
-0.7212418318,
-0.0766245872,
-0.0878065005,
-0.8535980582,
0.8989973664,
-0.1858172566,
-0.0154975895,
0.0429002531,
-0.5561183691,
-0.8475987315,
1.7188670635,
0.4733050168,
-0.7901685834,
-0.6106079221,
-0.1204923242,
0.1955747604,
-0.3552747667,
-0.0571258292,
0.3813814223,
0.5213232636,
0.5516366959,
-0.7273237109,
0.0963071585,
0.309099555,
-0.2011657655,
0.320743829,
-0.3783206344,
0.7499976754,
-0.2880813479,
-0.3137806356,
0.0247322191,
0.6235073805,
0.5041142702,
0.9171470404,
0.6330159903,
0.7243627906,
0.7941102982,
-0.2837537825,
1.3949583769,
-0.0679159239,
0.2953901291,
1.2352129221,
-0.0812824592,
0.4666171074,
0.298179239,
-0.2955035269,
0.7782447338,
0.8956673741,
0.049411431,
0.4354123771,
-0.0884288475,
-0.0688892305,
-0.5286918283,
-0.205260098,
-0.360473454,
0.0123323724,
0.2111300081,
-0.1544813365,
-0.2157126218,
-0.4464048445,
0.2743911743,
-0.4754853845,
-0.6774147153,
0.6753293276,
0.0814678147,
-0.5587232709,
0.2911156714,
-0.5856950879,
-0.0495653525,
-0.6275782585,
-0.1492609531,
-0.0727761462,
0.0191489719,
-0.0610243902,
-0.7932837009,
0.1448338926,
-0.4374291301,
-0.373690933,
-0.2023642212,
0.7544887066,
-0.2608024776,
-0.3968446553,
0.6427979469,
0.6969231367,
-0.2204681039,
0.2357211262,
-0.1512647718,
-0.183603853,
-0.3426732719,
-0.1617225111,
0.0206167419,
0.4923532605,
-0.3482102156,
0.8361006975,
0.4244813025,
0.1052201837,
-0.0324214548,
0.0967333391,
0.7607278228,
-0.8186115623,
-0.8761479855,
-1.1645083427,
0.2201185226,
0.0746450946,
0.2150520086,
0.2905485034,
0.4320944548,
0.7393788099,
0.2025208622,
0.7014021277,
0.2663797736,
0.417857796,
-0.7234749794,
0.4227925241,
-0.5369884968,
0.2502360046,
-0.1585148126,
-0.5245391726,
0.0147633217,
-0.2621910274,
-0.4953131676,
0.0876361728,
0.9624081254,
0.3539718688,
0.1281822324,
0.4264052808,
0.3462559879,
0.4313391149,
0.3909358978,
0.7283270359,
1.1287884712,
-0.0357591324,
0.8640140891,
-0.4258410037,
-0.0357275978,
-0.2246966064,
-1.2980419397,
-1.0269277096,
-0.4178586304,
-0.0514841154,
-0.6829394698,
0.3273001611,
0.8110424876,
0.6358496547,
-0.4838557839,
-0.3670387864,
-0.0357891843,
0.4688661397,
-0.318693161,
-0.229947567,
0.6364705563,
0.0152442213,
-0.0481308438,
0.4165181816,
0.4388419688,
0.1089910269,
-0.0578551814,
-0.2916445434,
-0.0791403577,
-0.3166562915,
0.6572710872,
0.134929806,
-0.9444078207,
-0.6029171348,
-0.035101749,
0.3676453829,
0.1993737817,
0.9606458545,
-0.8518862128,
0.5875644088,
0.6534557939,
0.3506373465,
1.1081887484,
-0.0626100749,
0.7637357712,
-0.7036725283,
-0.3201723695,
0.3322530389,
0.4720417857,
-0.0844785422,
-0.5509476066,
0.6029258966,
0.6477473974,
-0.5372629166,
-0.4886798859,
0.4158556163,
-1.0691674948,
-0.3307487369,
0.9205916524,
-0.2074916065,
-0.3264726102,
-0.3797886372,
0.3382011354,
0.8177966475,
-0.3798640668,
0.6652388573,
0.8420292735,
-0.461404711,
-0.1236326471,
-0.4935555458,
0.0330256112,
-0.1574953645,
-0.7575548291,
-0.0071588182,
0.441455394,
0.2024939805,
-0.0656151325,
0.4293224514,
-0.0864128992,
0.3081060946,
-0.0541026592,
-0.4672653079,
-0.6438051462,
-0.511837244,
0.3198144436,
0.3282194138,
-0.2033519745,
0.2113306522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14379v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14379v2
|
Novi jezički modeli za srpski jezik
| 2024-02-22T08:48:21 | 2024-02-23T09:00:49 |
Mihailo Škorić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper will briefly present the development history of transformer-based
language models for the Serbian language. Several new models for text
generation and vectorization, trained on the resources of the Society for
Language Resources and Technologies, will also be presented. Ten selected
vectorization models for Serbian, including two new ones, will be compared on
four natural language processing tasks. Paper will analyze which models are the
best for each selected task, how does their size and the size of their training
sets affect the performance on those tasks, and what is the optimal setting to
train the best language models for the Serbian language.
|
[
-0.506573379,
-0.4206855297,
0.2735463381,
0.067867808,
-0.1530798227,
0.0412540659,
-0.1704309583,
-0.4334133863,
0.3052161932,
0.6155657768,
-0.600654006,
-0.1994196475,
-0.6467547417,
0.4125459492,
-0.4258767664,
1.098336339,
-0.2321929038,
0.3611676097,
-0.175981313,
-0.0269736405,
-0.3964075744,
-0.5533179045,
-0.2767142951,
-0.5750230551,
0.0602672137,
0.2419929802,
0.6715863347,
0.36251387,
0.7355321646,
0.4740062058,
-0.2674332857,
-0.5211862326,
-0.2680715919,
0.5027225018,
-0.0894465968,
-0.5165580511,
-0.1167345122,
0.1339364201,
0.6462135315,
0.6536051631,
0.1039482132,
0.3143291473,
-0.292217195,
0.6845583916,
-0.3550775349,
0.1967995167,
-0.3023373783,
0.0429809168,
-0.0670589134,
-0.0667639151,
-0.452614516,
-0.6174371839,
0.2337207198,
-0.3638120592,
0.3787603378,
0.0507954508,
0.9140139222,
0.1560896933,
-0.4286880493,
-0.4098023176,
-1.0282115936,
0.9622063637,
-0.6588951945,
0.2135676295,
0.0739988685,
0.5155379772,
-0.1559866965,
-0.6517979503,
-0.3519904613,
-0.3083736598,
0.035461124,
-0.0163313095,
-0.4068266749,
-0.0465239994,
0.4704051316,
0.2749738693,
-0.5965610147,
-0.2162578702,
-0.8153410554,
0.0806474909,
0.3509766459,
0.0961187258,
0.6600224376,
-0.3532103896,
-0.1097290441,
-0.0199082661,
-0.5143605471,
-0.0052876985,
0.8441461921,
0.0667927861,
-0.0034483566,
1.0364912748,
-0.5454980135,
0.9461408854,
-0.0299922451,
-0.3589797318,
0.2766316235,
-0.3873765171,
-0.1835307926,
-0.1626197845,
0.6206356287,
0.2047706395,
0.5640673637,
-0.4601087272,
-0.1013853699,
0.5642669201,
0.6005136967,
-0.6670694947,
-0.5551572442,
-0.3629074097,
-0.5683797002,
-0.5825226903,
-0.0507808477,
-0.3807768226,
0.1666399091,
-0.4649612308,
0.1688934118,
-0.3901212811,
-0.2781887054,
0.0420431718,
-0.343093425,
0.0701995119,
-0.2711684108,
-1.0275152922,
0.6099905372,
0.4814635813,
0.6414002776,
-0.3409845531,
0.0269924402,
-0.1387544572,
-0.131153509,
-0.3644080162,
0.8976050019,
-0.6815008521,
-0.1788836122,
-0.1443390101,
0.0599198155,
0.0238276813,
-0.2564619482,
0.5664517879,
-0.443128407,
0.2954933941,
-0.2213986218,
-0.2375590056,
-0.3134891689,
0.2884039581,
-0.7609433532,
1.1652173996,
0.5257811546,
-1.0989416838,
0.4542679191,
-0.7327671647,
-0.4080540538,
0.2623236179,
-0.0402495265,
-0.3588379323,
0.259490788,
0.0485861599,
0.5262669325,
-0.2368945926,
0.4773606956,
0.2111688703,
-0.1430221796,
0.2947152555,
-0.0363354236,
0.8712401986,
0.1486467272,
-0.2488712519,
0.4024192095,
-0.9491478801,
0.1539735049,
0.1491757184,
-0.5492917299,
-0.356497407,
0.1897028089,
0.1822553277,
0.4524075985,
0.0038387878,
-0.7840625644,
0.2551647127,
-0.9279859662,
0.432490766,
0.2393734753,
0.0067355246,
0.7253351212,
-0.1292009205,
0.9399889112,
-0.1286791712,
0.2012210637,
0.0816699117,
-0.6920521855,
-0.8558086157,
0.2520672083,
0.4042840004,
0.3409690559,
-1.3839929104,
0.125099048,
-0.3880211115,
-0.55984658,
-0.2467876524,
-0.2655235529,
0.3140350282,
0.2579110563,
0.0274571404,
-0.0975223705,
-0.8688663244,
-1.2571563721,
-0.2368329018,
0.0010338554,
0.0728561953,
0.0645714477,
0.6135756373,
-0.1235401705,
0.993509829,
-0.2558918595,
0.34521541,
-0.975443542,
0.2231895775,
0.2140470147,
0.2951740623,
0.9223095775,
-0.9765495062,
-0.5977755785,
-0.0845572874,
-0.3069780469,
-0.213439554,
0.1752953976,
-0.1609890908,
0.5201333761,
0.2406031638,
-0.2827076316,
0.4393112957,
0.9974786639,
-0.388462007,
0.5036232471,
-0.254869014,
0.1647193581,
-1.2883623838,
0.0929935798,
0.1101898775,
-0.3350966871,
-1.049270153,
-0.0469208695,
-0.0610714518,
-0.2723050416,
-0.5735324621,
0.2339112163,
-0.7782128453,
-0.3143157363,
-0.4194312096,
0.06191542,
-0.3546030819,
0.4122649729,
-0.0182598475,
0.7215643525,
0.5477596521,
-0.6224753261,
0.6033892632,
0.4955081642,
-0.636347115,
0.2097948939,
-0.7516785264,
-0.1229108348,
-0.2384077311,
-0.077975437,
-0.8317005038,
-0.0944949389,
0.3658258617,
-0.4724178612,
0.2955899239,
-0.4211420417,
-0.1701803654,
-0.8059040904,
-0.1281495839,
0.1762439013,
0.5234770775,
-0.3079822659,
0.7790979147,
0.5735893846,
-0.3041705787,
-0.4587402642,
-0.6037086844,
0.0279894155,
-0.0493074059,
-0.6818575263,
0.0052707884,
-0.2442238629,
-0.288634032,
-0.1934913695,
-0.0093343649,
-0.0877568722,
0.1051286459,
0.4933313429,
0.5527624488,
-0.1663686186,
-0.1862915903,
0.0256407876,
-0.4620014727,
0.1560596079,
0.0303116087,
0.692260623,
-0.0110805389,
0.2132771462,
-0.1810225844,
0.3141125143,
0.464145124,
-0.2015737444,
0.9752082825,
0.2203699648,
-0.1266491711,
0.0230570342,
-0.4022361636,
0.1751250625,
-0.4500216544,
0.1983229965,
-0.5860436559,
-0.8220159411,
0.2557041943,
-0.1500866711,
0.0732548758,
0.6998106837,
0.8309751749,
0.2528469265,
1.1103208065,
0.9381082654,
-0.1956355572,
0.5828930736,
-0.3853143752,
0.5311629176,
-0.8617431521,
-0.1861214489,
-0.8350207806,
-0.359793812,
-0.775434792,
-0.0785896704,
0.2419220805,
-0.2977258265,
0.0597970746,
0.7142272592,
-0.7544371486,
0.4611120224,
0.5924991369,
-0.3886395097,
-0.0562064052,
-0.1179151312,
-0.0713292286,
-0.0820677653,
-0.9387882948,
-0.7821825743,
0.9830950499,
0.1269668639,
0.820121944,
-0.0874567404,
0.390904814,
-0.2003293037,
0.2209945023,
-0.7057532668,
0.483222127,
-0.0222603083,
-0.7377608418,
-0.310523808,
-0.4139555097,
-0.6634529829,
0.2357197553,
-0.629165113,
-0.405187875,
-0.0395055413,
0.1174268201,
0.1000240073,
0.2961875498,
-0.6149302125,
0.8728286624,
0.0834727362,
0.463435173,
0.301058203,
-0.6563584805,
0.384308815,
0.3850067854,
0.0591904595,
-0.0504876375,
0.170593217,
0.876514256,
0.1276117116,
0.3999202251,
-0.1249641404,
0.2313737273,
0.1981619447,
0.1546627134,
0.4397764802,
-0.2840312123,
0.0726450756,
0.0073553836,
0.1755595505,
-0.0715540424,
-0.3807734847,
0.523662746,
-0.6247567534,
-0.1881138235,
-0.5174798965,
-0.4632292092,
0.1377081424,
0.2024371624,
0.7216246724,
0.6413723826,
-0.4936220646,
0.3045710921,
0.5022715926,
-0.3581585288,
0.522303164,
0.4184400737,
-0.216887325,
-0.217959404,
0.6164771318,
0.1370972544,
0.2870271504,
0.0988470316,
0.1175955534,
0.179594174,
-0.7060810328,
-0.4488292038,
0.2259633988,
-0.4848285317,
-0.3244244158,
-1.0085277557,
-0.227691099,
-0.5103340745,
-0.132907331,
-0.4535538852,
-0.5439530015,
-0.2301615328,
0.0167162232,
0.2299401462,
1.2825007439,
0.3161171973,
0.3759477437,
-0.3902938962,
0.6460138559,
-0.1644425392,
0.4655930698,
-0.3946789503,
-0.2531272471,
-0.2711331844,
0.0840576142,
-0.3352728486,
-0.7427806854,
0.7373390198,
-0.0777360573,
0.5482852459,
-0.0758166537,
-0.0459271111,
-0.0902722552,
-0.9846953154,
0.9578721523,
0.2459328771,
-0.9013544917,
0.6680999398,
-0.1674365252,
0.3399819732,
0.1940509826,
0.5254781246,
-0.7294252515,
-0.5734724402,
-0.6809448004,
-0.6882420182,
0.892603755,
0.3602095544,
0.1868326366,
-0.1460509002,
0.5687926412,
0.1420330107,
-0.090637885,
-0.9797780514,
-0.477013588,
-0.2818322182,
-0.2652117014,
-0.1083423495,
-0.7314823866,
0.3265016675,
-0.4180559516,
0.9950793386,
-0.178109169,
0.461245805,
-0.2269169241,
-0.1948965788,
-0.3531383872,
0.4174914062,
0.8583179116,
0.7933331728,
0.2791325748,
-0.1404545605,
0.2317857742,
-0.5744163394,
0.1780534834,
-0.4894628525,
-0.4616809785,
0.3610591888,
-0.0319552869,
1.0353819132,
0.5729660392,
-0.344407022,
0.5368161201,
-0.2986196578,
-0.5695893168,
-0.5586280227,
0.3667568862,
0.109055616,
0.3122780621,
-0.0182934664,
0.222008571,
0.3245208859,
-0.3460872471,
-0.1458203346,
0.4523003101,
-0.0584817715,
-0.4236409962,
0.4329655766,
-0.0128468741,
-0.5160285234,
0.4106330276,
-0.0264034048,
-0.9332225919,
0.3641343415,
0.7753971219,
0.5794481635,
-0.3611414433,
0.4505141079,
0.5153721571,
0.3218397498,
-0.5991349816,
0.4164138734,
0.1030554101,
-0.6637808681,
-0.4045879245,
-0.6731239557,
-0.4407678246,
-0.1558873206,
-0.7998740077,
0.1996252835,
-0.0980633944,
-0.4325546324,
0.0420765541,
0.1279262453,
-0.4759539664,
0.2528257072,
-0.1079077795,
0.6650429964,
-0.9780908823,
0.8707997799,
0.7247730494,
-0.150564298,
-0.4911283851,
-0.5471733809,
-0.3826296628,
-0.1223199889,
1.0098669529,
-0.2370976806,
-0.0885888264,
-0.0475091338,
-0.6418227553,
-1.3835593462,
0.7720348239,
0.321780622,
-0.4394680858,
-0.3266453445,
-0.0605783686,
0.6348592043,
-0.3545894027,
0.0463843681,
0.6274263859,
0.2927998304,
0.070741795,
-0.6187605262,
-0.4945541918,
-0.5437812805,
0.7094591856,
0.5903698802,
-0.0560650378,
0.8991920948,
0.2471212894,
-0.4097223282,
0.4029116035,
0.8340732455,
-0.365065217,
-0.3790935874,
0.1727724969,
0.3079821467,
0.1811868995,
-0.3522071838,
1.2999726534,
-0.4379045963,
0.2901892662,
0.9503781796,
0.0854841918,
0.6779042482,
0.3605148196,
-0.1063668579,
0.4106470048,
0.0983111635,
-0.2069460452,
0.3356611431,
0.4047883749,
-0.0698910728,
0.0786864534,
0.3565551639,
-0.0492234565,
0.5048264861,
-0.0878541917,
-0.4423976839,
-0.1676229089,
0.6369284987,
-0.2908229828,
0.100570865,
-0.0447506756,
0.8127602339,
-0.2944568992,
-0.550475657,
0.2520917654,
0.3376269937,
0.9009077549,
-0.42243734,
0.2236536145,
0.1925757527,
0.0084323846,
0.0641910285,
-0.4262559712,
0.7634457946,
0.4297293425,
-0.5132901073,
-0.4367037714,
0.9073952436,
-0.3300780654,
-0.783747673,
0.0016635263,
0.1231537983,
0.3519596756,
0.1353798211,
-0.5017390251,
0.2345573306,
-0.0423479006,
-0.5118989348,
0.0818738416,
0.3221270442,
-0.0327797644,
0.8921595812,
0.3700736463,
0.4375672936,
0.5018432736,
0.1513080746,
0.822101593,
-0.5610514283,
-0.5849676132,
-0.4608246982,
0.258495301,
0.0106390994,
-0.251319617,
0.716352582,
0.5572367311,
0.8632382751,
-0.4278687239,
0.7332700491,
-0.1838355958,
0.9662111402,
-0.3506444395,
0.9001216292,
0.0581425689,
-0.3513159156,
-0.3091566265,
-1.222830534,
-0.236779049,
1.0017004013,
-0.4043765366,
0.0613270923,
0.634734869,
0.4112782776,
0.1188756749,
0.1436608583,
0.4902765453,
0.2277121842,
0.3170450926,
0.2507281005,
0.6983220577,
-0.6880640984,
0.2437955439,
-0.4046362638,
-0.0092450893,
-0.0106732519,
-0.7094475627,
-1.137133956,
-0.8772810698,
-0.2511392236,
0.0713826343,
-0.1016433984,
0.8850142956,
0.3966684341,
-0.774764359,
-0.1459130645,
-0.077029191,
-0.142601639,
0.1205842867,
-0.1641416997,
-0.18891491,
-0.3825281262,
-0.6275940537,
0.239097029,
0.2410622537,
0.3222622871,
-0.3273247182,
0.0044248323,
-0.3160554171,
0.0824139938,
0.5752332211,
0.0893722251,
-0.649366796,
-0.3280567825,
-0.0526776388,
-0.1105020493,
0.3017538488,
1.0770428181,
-0.9015474916,
0.2903919816,
0.6034412384,
0.2327852249,
0.472570926,
-0.1945968568,
0.6649559736,
-0.444891423,
0.1934490949,
0.1733313948,
0.3080171645,
0.5030946136,
-0.2007193714,
0.475913316,
0.0573507473,
-0.571064949,
-0.4878255725,
0.1427488625,
-0.8473730087,
-0.2086617351,
1.0277574062,
0.082524009,
-0.5883693695,
-0.244224146,
-0.4945682585,
0.5392501354,
0.1370113045,
0.4799903035,
0.8158987761,
0.0686824992,
-0.2114346027,
-0.7513494492,
0.5738265514,
-0.2062675506,
-0.7249705791,
-0.1242300421,
0.4017316699,
0.4958876967,
0.1832476407,
0.2948468328,
-0.1197206005,
0.0911078677,
-0.0553768054,
0.3933200836,
-0.1028911844,
-0.6314449906,
-0.3729882836,
0.1254381984,
-0.1364800185,
0.1096582189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14373v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14373v1
|
Small Language Model Is a Good Guide for Large Language Model in Chinese Entity Relation Extraction
| 2024-02-22T08:26:56 | 2024-02-22T08:26:56 |
Xuemei Tang, Jun Wang, Qi Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have been successful in relational
extraction (RE) tasks, especially in the few-shot learning. An important
problem in the field of RE is long-tailed data, while not much attention is
currently paid to this problem using LLM approaches. Therefore, in this paper,
we propose SLCoLM, a model collaboration framework, to mitigate the data
long-tail problem. In our framework, We use the
``\textit{Training-Guide-Predict}'' strategy to combine the strengths of
pre-trained language models (PLMs) and LLMs, where a task-specific PLM
framework acts as a tutor, transfers task knowledge to the LLM, and guides the
LLM in performing RE tasks. Our experiments on a RE dataset rich in relation
types show that the approach in this paper facilitates RE of long-tail relation
types.
|
[
-0.3375136256,
-0.5299533606,
0.6029473543,
0.1104706153,
-0.5101833344,
-0.1746209413,
-0.4692610502,
-0.5306953788,
0.2245814949,
1.1120351553,
-0.6014913917,
-0.5312600732,
-0.2521035373,
-0.0508787446,
-0.1990123838,
1.0501931906,
0.0929923356,
0.1478715986,
-0.2835698426,
-0.0360090882,
-0.3855982423,
-0.4864338636,
-0.9215157628,
-0.401161164,
0.8950055838,
0.3479120731,
0.6925124526,
0.6739154458,
0.5839576721,
0.1737234443,
-0.0306329727,
0.3240712881,
-0.5995961428,
0.1082032323,
-0.4125533104,
-0.5945631862,
-0.8181040287,
-0.1170951724,
0.7717763186,
0.9279599786,
-0.2919211984,
0.174134478,
0.1672327071,
0.6296799779,
-0.4264435172,
0.4453730285,
-0.6308184862,
0.0139527153,
-0.2826718986,
0.1405330896,
-0.6891909242,
-0.0019052017,
0.1648074985,
-0.5052691698,
0.0539800636,
0.3930558264,
0.7972528338,
0.0559273064,
-0.3440986872,
-0.0045340192,
-0.7470514774,
0.8373478651,
-0.7524641156,
0.3341791034,
0.3919075727,
0.3674888015,
-0.4512407184,
-0.7902577519,
-0.426661998,
-0.0517715067,
-0.3754265904,
-0.1960218102,
0.2077552229,
0.2884290218,
0.298333168,
0.1693280488,
-0.4275237918,
0.3275705874,
-0.282073319,
0.0518847257,
0.729338944,
0.225263536,
0.4214320481,
-0.1673509181,
-0.4018295705,
0.4157586694,
-1.1105515957,
-0.0921353996,
-0.1999034584,
0.7678622007,
-0.0456335284,
0.3861049116,
0.0758901834,
0.8237953782,
-0.1059155315,
-0.3704511225,
-0.0181914773,
-0.6399962306,
-0.4215460122,
0.0746758655,
1.061852932,
-0.0135122938,
0.2868241072,
-0.4068771303,
-0.3203254342,
-0.3882597089,
-0.2530831695,
-0.9566767216,
-0.3737613857,
-0.1209495813,
-0.538890481,
-0.0210943483,
0.0634197816,
-0.8434116244,
-0.2379603833,
-0.3746028244,
0.1168140024,
-0.320134908,
-0.5891770124,
-0.1429080665,
0.3634997308,
0.2965498567,
0.2971490026,
-0.9493317008,
0.5576255918,
0.9984358549,
0.8743480444,
-0.6092845201,
-0.3258792758,
-1.1543738842,
0.5379522443,
-0.2759073675,
0.3756186664,
-0.3093652129,
-0.3286816478,
-0.0551143885,
0.3062729836,
-0.100410834,
-0.5106050968,
0.2618980408,
-0.5011292696,
0.1640058309,
-0.2489011735,
-0.5020505786,
-0.0498181246,
-0.05080989,
-1.0061798096,
0.7570368648,
0.0126902442,
-0.7915243506,
0.2626680136,
-0.3829841018,
-0.4375711679,
0.2918719649,
-0.4092158079,
-0.6593880057,
-0.2823572159,
0.1534231603,
0.5571169853,
-0.5670799613,
0.3705092072,
-0.6626521349,
-0.3642726243,
-0.1797374487,
0.2850912809,
0.9697637558,
0.1500855684,
0.0358269028,
0.0238019843,
-0.7038410306,
-0.0481644869,
0.0635953099,
-0.1227467358,
-0.7204212546,
-0.0038986467,
-0.1773238629,
0.4764257669,
0.1857737899,
-0.2085035294,
0.4112488925,
-0.4912392795,
0.3718667924,
0.4019059539,
0.0984934494,
0.7729473114,
-0.1275913119,
0.5068843961,
0.1383384764,
-0.2678216994,
-0.1449743658,
-0.0813771039,
-0.9355369806,
-0.3820877969,
0.4372262657,
0.281301856,
-1.0483356714,
0.3907137513,
-0.4061994851,
-0.3532133996,
-0.3953284919,
0.606205225,
0.2744318545,
0.3810398877,
0.1962768734,
-0.3050108254,
-0.5885618329,
-0.7479855418,
-0.0805447027,
-0.1108143926,
0.1659683734,
0.2282121181,
0.4953638315,
-0.0470203198,
1.2737903595,
-0.4645853341,
-0.5851300955,
-0.6423204541,
0.0836981386,
0.4250918627,
0.6525462866,
0.5528059602,
-0.8884111643,
-0.789254725,
-0.0187897999,
-0.7744603157,
0.1739121377,
-0.0391192585,
-0.2733553946,
0.1139865145,
0.4090820551,
-1.0284676552,
0.2034100145,
0.211504966,
0.1797760576,
0.3634800017,
0.1405733824,
-0.4636685252,
-1.1338135004,
0.0014141415,
0.1233034357,
-0.4354209304,
-0.6730644107,
0.1951957047,
0.0370274,
-0.1548989564,
-0.5459837914,
0.456668824,
-0.7575529218,
-0.3628287315,
-0.14658764,
0.3251092136,
-0.1351277828,
0.526483655,
0.5126935244,
0.5589289665,
0.5081849098,
-0.5336483717,
0.4340654016,
0.1316532642,
-0.1843421459,
0.3859589696,
-0.4427337646,
0.3565963805,
-0.0525713004,
0.1357118636,
-0.5079264641,
-0.0179203935,
0.3146476448,
-0.0761428848,
0.5508916378,
-0.3501961231,
-0.6353503466,
-0.3180795312,
-0.219177112,
0.0989988074,
0.1132662222,
-0.6861517429,
0.70246768,
0.3701422811,
-0.2846610546,
-0.612991035,
-0.6347919106,
0.0011793582,
-0.4081029296,
-0.69475317,
0.3874138594,
-0.0736409128,
-0.2754127979,
0.0183430817,
0.1814464182,
-0.3653191626,
0.1476623118,
0.338164866,
0.560310483,
-0.3708464205,
0.315587163,
-0.3587276638,
-0.0516957417,
0.2310860157,
0.090128541,
0.5243495703,
0.141477704,
-0.0273241587,
-0.1382722557,
0.2167169005,
0.2550445497,
-0.3833093643,
0.9158653021,
0.6789239049,
-0.5254067183,
-0.5353438854,
-0.1612342894,
-0.3048968613,
-0.426327914,
0.6314509511,
-0.3640855253,
-0.7404604554,
0.241903618,
-0.059190467,
0.0058424226,
0.1034120172,
0.3132153749,
0.0811726674,
0.7850431204,
1.0212806463,
-0.7560768127,
0.3845414519,
-0.1532011926,
0.2630259395,
-0.689580977,
-0.0687586069,
-0.4104274213,
0.2357492745,
-0.3714323044,
-0.1126906946,
-0.0279938672,
0.4730172753,
-0.2349887341,
0.5453882217,
-0.1217198148,
0.2832331061,
0.2883705795,
0.0346307568,
0.5007183552,
-0.0730682015,
0.1418791562,
-0.2737211287,
-0.8099286556,
-0.1760516912,
0.7507039309,
0.3985065818,
0.8122502565,
0.0128220748,
1.1091607809,
-0.1992983222,
0.38408795,
-0.9234108329,
0.6666070223,
-0.2636261284,
-0.4380037785,
-0.4396056235,
-0.5997570157,
-0.8759074211,
0.2875283957,
-0.2242273539,
-0.7753279209,
-0.1004624218,
-0.1147435158,
-0.4424497187,
0.1379550397,
-0.3421657383,
0.7760660648,
-0.3337789476,
-0.6941092014,
0.0208348278,
-0.6174212694,
0.7266687155,
-0.3536199629,
0.4210632443,
-0.0131469844,
0.1261926293,
0.8858431578,
-0.5106078982,
0.7712128758,
-0.0867303088,
-0.0678217858,
0.3637473583,
0.1676639766,
0.8416613936,
0.0320150591,
-0.090097636,
-0.1676271707,
-0.1259385794,
-0.0827220529,
-0.5097627044,
0.6847624779,
-0.5750055313,
-0.632113874,
-0.2589734197,
-0.4536435306,
-0.1661447138,
0.5070041418,
-0.0083673839,
0.0460078791,
-0.0555631481,
0.3592420816,
0.498321861,
0.0118521033,
0.725689888,
0.4902855456,
-0.6537947655,
-0.2677462995,
0.8900343776,
0.0879654065,
0.3915492892,
0.2350723445,
-0.0608235933,
0.0554547943,
-0.4199535549,
-0.1172008216,
0.6172087789,
-0.6163262725,
-0.2081637383,
-0.2959867716,
-0.5364296436,
-0.3114997149,
0.3012137115,
-0.4767581224,
0.0480020232,
-0.5981849432,
-0.0188401993,
0.0750090256,
0.4955893755,
0.1742608398,
0.4996490777,
-0.9360095263,
0.0584534518,
0.2530585527,
-0.0946648642,
0.0882472321,
-0.2938399315,
-0.4871301651,
-0.0084456028,
0.015651891,
-0.5982180834,
0.7981465459,
0.2730142474,
0.5793673396,
0.3663342595,
0.0639872029,
0.7469649315,
-0.2815931439,
0.8719158173,
0.444262296,
-0.6903800964,
0.3114017248,
-0.2737035751,
-0.1269480139,
0.4339215457,
0.5417163968,
-0.3599250615,
-0.0355031155,
-0.4258773923,
-0.6127229333,
0.8632593751,
-0.0085346205,
-0.3778473139,
0.3373232782,
0.4120956063,
-0.0340931714,
0.4596096873,
-1.2196434736,
-0.2848823965,
0.3454767466,
-0.0726472065,
-0.0304858349,
-0.2589812875,
-0.0877580196,
-0.0835553482,
0.4867959023,
-0.1641707122,
-0.1796888858,
-0.2006229311,
-0.2376393974,
-0.3117221296,
-0.0159746185,
0.0790624022,
0.8171251416,
-0.1702696532,
0.2256000936,
0.1124438196,
-0.1177370995,
-0.2748629451,
0.1044173241,
-0.1692558378,
0.0211195536,
0.6424176693,
0.5175209641,
0.1434994042,
-0.3331974447,
0.6202548742,
0.0969357342,
-0.1031820774,
-0.4404430389,
0.1244021356,
0.4258444011,
0.1602962911,
0.2483833134,
-0.442225039,
-0.152562499,
-0.5594520569,
0.4891759157,
0.5100190043,
-0.3647841215,
-0.3043627143,
0.413289398,
0.101568453,
-0.409712106,
0.5978001356,
-0.1790136397,
-0.574549973,
0.5563215017,
0.6354628205,
0.355019182,
-0.1658063233,
-0.0067149531,
0.4468340576,
0.1005412638,
-0.4047772884,
-0.1303272545,
0.0187040605,
-0.7872578502,
-0.5895673633,
-0.3999358118,
-0.1360720396,
0.4737215638,
-0.785595119,
0.9288604259,
-0.4107293785,
0.1107670963,
0.0518116578,
0.3823898137,
-0.5944049358,
0.0678166375,
0.2679748535,
0.5217416286,
-0.5254431367,
1.5907247066,
0.2495321035,
-0.7871748209,
-1.0258414745,
-0.3775027394,
-0.1046014279,
-0.6181189418,
1.076480031,
0.2103860527,
-0.0490363687,
-0.066867888,
-0.7824638486,
-0.829069078,
1.2118731737,
0.3029076159,
-1.1318727732,
-0.5183834434,
0.1327586621,
0.3591035008,
-0.9554055333,
-0.0130744288,
0.7386264205,
0.2623837292,
0.0379522555,
-0.9419221878,
0.1325837523,
0.249725908,
-0.0980719402,
0.2566511333,
-0.7241106033,
1.1243497133,
-0.1563749909,
-0.2183340639,
0.3081737459,
0.810074985,
0.3954853117,
0.2903134227,
0.739630878,
0.1939237267,
0.6627805829,
0.3080894649,
0.3765545785,
-0.2638881505,
0.614772737,
1.7642235756,
-0.6035395861,
0.9251437187,
0.6849117279,
-0.222646907,
0.3790588379,
0.6663860679,
-0.1086063832,
0.578420639,
0.0854680166,
-0.0682429969,
-0.5335097313,
-0.1686142087,
-0.3302824497,
0.2559191287,
0.5041302443,
-0.7104982734,
-0.118338719,
-0.2376822233,
0.2321143299,
0.0512110218,
-0.4958386123,
0.709179163,
0.731275022,
-0.6949951649,
0.3959102333,
-0.3014189601,
0.6556800604,
-0.4985320568,
-0.1927600354,
-0.1638507992,
0.1218361929,
-0.3999152482,
-0.4568306208,
0.0661521256,
-0.5325552225,
-0.1524229795,
0.1906865686,
1.0674726963,
-1.0813628435,
-0.2845188081,
0.7510810494,
0.7305954695,
0.0201087315,
-0.0110552944,
-0.62435776,
-0.0310642384,
0.1094173342,
-0.0729726702,
0.5834563375,
0.4421644509,
0.0218264237,
0.6811462641,
0.5576508045,
0.5950263143,
-0.3419982791,
-0.1253444254,
0.8706609011,
-0.7627856731,
-0.4249256551,
-1.0932512283,
0.0687612966,
-0.3002862632,
0.2348903269,
0.5870478153,
0.4214956164,
0.5454825759,
0.1345097572,
0.6301447153,
0.1936644316,
0.7937836051,
-0.4452031851,
0.833344996,
-0.4997633696,
0.419164896,
-0.2508137524,
-1.1124165058,
-0.2287961692,
0.466999948,
-0.267531693,
-0.1714298427,
0.7307017446,
0.8264861107,
0.0296234116,
-0.0186040644,
0.286801964,
0.0996600538,
0.4968349636,
0.9062944055,
0.6220375299,
-0.1145091057,
0.7632807493,
-0.5019446015,
0.1444717646,
-0.109216854,
-0.9740532041,
-1.2052229643,
-0.4248268306,
-0.0816178769,
-0.2704908848,
-0.0437173992,
1.2082259655,
0.8563399315,
-0.5180605054,
-0.4654662013,
-0.0071551045,
0.2911394238,
-0.0012705706,
-0.2151870728,
0.527446866,
-0.1653750539,
-0.663310349,
0.1811408401,
0.0954103246,
-0.0340625532,
-0.4069127738,
-0.3472353816,
-0.2143933177,
-0.6155335903,
0.4607443213,
0.2300691307,
-0.595103085,
-0.3345641196,
-0.2076891214,
-0.3857207,
0.056405291,
0.776291132,
-0.5332726836,
0.3276109099,
0.1070797294,
0.621993959,
0.7241026759,
-0.1318186671,
0.8700372577,
-0.5899255872,
0.3914442956,
0.1063159704,
0.5053777099,
0.300247997,
-0.5315274596,
0.8444007635,
0.2674669027,
-0.5418176651,
-0.9721344709,
0.0524648614,
-0.9826913476,
-0.1237882748,
1.391415,
-0.5901663899,
-0.4510737956,
-0.0323187038,
-0.083916001,
0.2502708137,
-0.3805753291,
0.2696911693,
0.7540873885,
0.0407703221,
-0.5644024014,
-0.4797285497,
0.6769357324,
0.2277748138,
-0.8100222349,
0.1771129072,
0.1633476466,
0.3617916703,
0.1673903763,
0.5666312575,
0.2324611843,
0.1921456605,
-0.3722219765,
-0.014029257,
-0.151842773,
-0.3622176945,
-0.1265705228,
0.0452171527,
0.4057932198,
-0.0971038043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14359v1
|
Rethinking Scientific Summarization Evaluation: Grounding Explainable Metrics on Facet-aware Benchmark
| 2024-02-22T07:58:29 | 2024-02-22T07:58:29 |
Xiuying Chen, Tairan Wang, Qingqing Zhu, Taicheng Guo, Shen Gao, Zhiyong Lu, Xin Gao, Xiangliang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The summarization capabilities of pretrained and large language models (LLMs)
have been widely validated in general areas, but their use in scientific
corpus, which involves complex sentences and specialized knowledge, has been
less assessed. This paper presents conceptual and experimental analyses of
scientific summarization, highlighting the inadequacies of traditional
evaluation methods, such as $n$-gram, embedding comparison, and QA,
particularly in providing explanations, grasping scientific concepts, or
identifying key content. Subsequently, we introduce the Facet-aware Metric
(FM), employing LLMs for advanced semantic matching to evaluate summaries based
on different aspects. This facet-aware approach offers a thorough evaluation of
abstracts by decomposing the evaluation task into simpler subtasks.Recognizing
the absence of an evaluation benchmark in this domain, we curate a Facet-based
scientific summarization Dataset (FD) with facet-level annotations. Our
findings confirm that FM offers a more logical approach to evaluating
scientific summaries. In addition, fine-tuned smaller models can compete with
LLMs in scientific contexts, while LLMs have limitations in learning from
in-context information in scientific domains. This suggests an area for future
enhancement of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3429823518,
-0.1785978824,
0.7028801441,
0.5165593028,
-0.5224613547,
0.2683853805,
-0.2289652228,
-0.4760507345,
0.4584376514,
0.1791872084,
-0.3708768487,
-0.4987459779,
-0.6619135737,
0.5145981312,
-0.4054115713,
1.4732648134,
-0.1205992177,
0.1950833797,
-0.944218874,
-0.1828338802,
-0.1137320474,
-0.189878732,
-0.2162632793,
-0.4888918102,
0.605209887,
-0.0389672592,
0.4992673695,
0.6205713153,
0.9381005168,
0.2977704406,
-0.400904566,
0.0795838907,
-0.4504134953,
-0.1356548816,
-0.2637630403,
-0.5195370913,
-0.6372833252,
0.2289636731,
0.6056759953,
1.2388162613,
0.2410307229,
0.2246750742,
-0.0813504905,
0.9664607644,
-0.5146868825,
0.4038687646,
-0.3919393718,
0.2141078413,
-0.0242533926,
-0.2898360193,
-0.0464058667,
-0.2852118313,
0.2739683092,
-0.696197927,
0.3707502782,
0.0630021244,
0.5360659361,
0.3306751549,
-0.1693632007,
-0.1976388097,
-0.3769904673,
0.5919585824,
-0.7753702998,
0.191397652,
0.1102763638,
0.4649701416,
-0.0731337741,
-0.762950778,
-0.3655917048,
-0.296680212,
-0.1124714687,
0.6246955991,
-0.0437410735,
-0.1947785169,
0.0634195879,
0.5859495997,
-0.6019343138,
-0.0787812248,
-0.3740748167,
0.0232973024,
0.5199611783,
0.1750678271,
0.0757414475,
-0.214745,
-0.2376039922,
0.1016114801,
-0.8732882738,
-0.1646161228,
-0.0951860547,
0.1503961384,
-0.2105516046,
0.7552271485,
-0.4113058448,
0.4206986725,
-0.07683146,
-0.0242248531,
0.2959286273,
-0.6665908098,
0.0135881081,
0.0095235407,
0.6112783551,
0.7606280446,
0.2880122364,
-0.332197845,
-0.1469027698,
0.132427454,
0.145575434,
-1.0685125589,
-0.1725150347,
0.1924652755,
-0.3916099966,
-0.4265936315,
-0.2298370749,
-0.4552780688,
-0.2538679242,
-0.3658435345,
0.4488084912,
-0.3006255925,
-0.046751637,
-0.0014177434,
-0.2837479115,
-0.1542884111,
0.6477792263,
-0.7317128778,
0.328820467,
0.858800292,
1.150146246,
-0.2538569272,
-0.331754148,
-0.0386353731,
-0.060798578,
-0.21612297,
1.1076947451,
-0.207258448,
-0.4491935372,
-0.5807535648,
-0.2149029523,
-0.1047180071,
-0.5138227344,
0.0136199715,
-0.4493946135,
0.2018639892,
-0.4965645075,
-0.3419894874,
-0.2117810398,
0.1000962108,
-0.3357234299,
0.5723121166,
0.1056904942,
-0.9993793964,
0.5684792995,
-0.7634452581,
-0.5382823348,
0.0426451229,
-0.1056146026,
-0.2265168875,
0.3248660862,
0.3962320089,
0.5500584841,
-0.2311442494,
0.4416511953,
-0.1798745841,
-0.3289094865,
0.1253352761,
-0.0046428763,
0.3554528654,
0.2524912655,
-0.1112434268,
0.3661987484,
-0.501093626,
-0.212291345,
-0.0505458154,
-0.0255328342,
-0.3774944842,
0.1715555489,
-0.2452676594,
-0.0239648502,
0.120444037,
-0.5685322285,
-0.153411597,
-0.4923974574,
0.6042637825,
0.4386504292,
-0.116667822,
0.2931774557,
-0.5159006119,
0.3840457797,
-0.2677952647,
-0.1621597707,
-0.4226308465,
-0.1431807727,
-0.1816200763,
-0.5801855326,
0.3565547168,
0.4218619466,
-0.5341274738,
0.1194045395,
-0.7071679235,
-0.6660741568,
-0.4272476733,
-0.0955567434,
0.4044890106,
0.7359019518,
0.3833812475,
-0.4057328701,
-0.4133182168,
-0.8572868109,
-0.5106486082,
-0.0421123803,
-0.3648393154,
0.2067020983,
0.8706706166,
0.0786981508,
1.0395698547,
-0.270093441,
0.0080781747,
-0.3783510625,
0.1555318087,
0.3059427142,
0.2332544774,
0.5609251261,
-0.5286663771,
-0.2206095159,
-0.0308804885,
-1.2383723259,
-0.4460992813,
0.0049768221,
0.3055667877,
-0.3592110574,
0.474445641,
-0.5806093812,
0.2854420245,
0.2342884243,
-0.1613837928,
0.7920827866,
-0.0963240564,
0.3736319542,
-0.5928718448,
0.1898013502,
-0.1357598752,
-0.322334677,
-0.3116780818,
0.1297288835,
0.1587817669,
-0.024688758,
-0.4403960705,
0.4228026569,
-0.4257808924,
-0.496668607,
-0.533646524,
0.6490761042,
0.1708247215,
-0.0088664526,
0.2851587832,
0.7430552244,
0.2216286659,
-0.47692433,
0.0379594564,
0.2616270483,
-0.447257638,
0.6538277864,
-1.0667856932,
-0.4743573964,
-0.5158356428,
0.7453886867,
-0.7210664749,
-0.0811126903,
-0.2521405816,
-0.4094459116,
0.0338960998,
0.2752201855,
-0.3420716822,
-0.1220698655,
-0.6053752899,
0.5112064481,
0.3513310254,
-0.463211596,
0.4472605884,
0.0429727286,
-0.6254274845,
-0.4653621614,
-0.4513528347,
0.2829946876,
-0.30000332,
-0.7733793855,
0.6332469583,
-0.1017612964,
-0.4837061167,
0.0223837364,
-0.5908051729,
0.5895038843,
0.3421479464,
0.2380578369,
0.1244889945,
-0.2457393408,
-0.1171849445,
0.152956292,
-0.1837302744,
0.2412055284,
0.1215825826,
0.1117648259,
-0.3426633477,
-0.2075495422,
-0.1901442111,
0.3249054849,
0.5803920031,
-0.1888694763,
0.3391276002,
0.35492751,
-0.3460155725,
0.2098362297,
-0.3673339486,
-0.3111101091,
-0.3470684588,
0.5648937225,
-0.282287091,
-0.8605397344,
0.7193334103,
-0.2542698979,
0.2539282143,
0.7316507101,
0.4712463915,
-0.3132635355,
0.7469075918,
0.4232374132,
0.3198933899,
0.1714770049,
-0.0323833041,
0.0610623583,
-1.2171195745,
-0.3548169434,
-0.533082664,
-0.0197407175,
-0.2276292592,
-0.2889970839,
0.5613409877,
0.1979691833,
0.0540582165,
0.2082980275,
-0.2687115967,
0.7493736148,
-0.0295635313,
-0.1121243984,
0.4888326824,
-0.2807994187,
-0.0185611676,
-0.1303369254,
-0.6822764874,
-0.5613258481,
0.9723286629,
0.3772916794,
0.4775745571,
0.0123685515,
0.5691102743,
0.1061898395,
0.8590288162,
-0.7997367382,
0.4154214263,
-0.2595688701,
-0.1199990958,
-0.1385106593,
-0.5290951729,
-0.56442523,
0.827922523,
-0.2015134692,
-0.3227820098,
-0.1706638187,
-0.1584142894,
-0.4365023673,
-0.1719550043,
-0.5799922943,
0.603960216,
-0.2278951257,
0.0755764619,
-0.2601999342,
-0.6812323332,
0.6508817077,
-0.2921817899,
0.5916313529,
-0.2559886873,
0.0226672087,
1.0872893333,
-0.435959518,
0.6648067832,
0.0042369249,
0.1234946847,
-0.2017207295,
0.0128882341,
0.0763364583,
0.391384989,
0.1034054831,
0.1758701056,
0.304387182,
-0.4137097001,
-0.6942096353,
0.7266433239,
-0.4883175492,
-0.6813322306,
-0.5497937799,
-0.6376585364,
-0.2489752322,
0.0564698987,
0.1026638672,
0.0830110982,
-0.1940147281,
0.1995570958,
0.6077973247,
-0.2496326864,
0.2974512577,
0.8637746572,
-0.4288918972,
-0.442607969,
0.6905135512,
-0.0090951994,
0.3419296741,
0.3566637933,
0.3584992886,
0.0176755507,
-0.8262773752,
-0.2582753897,
0.3451805115,
-0.6522581577,
-0.2560432255,
-0.906516552,
0.0238527078,
-0.433193624,
-0.2858373225,
-0.3659551144,
-0.6425018311,
-0.048126217,
-0.193130523,
0.3568231463,
0.643671155,
-0.1953238398,
0.2903662324,
-0.4345810115,
0.3932763636,
-0.0278785862,
0.2879442871,
-0.0317645893,
-0.5347973108,
-0.2838672101,
-0.1164545789,
0.0877802968,
-0.587484777,
0.2406837493,
0.3186858296,
0.5073747635,
0.1696001291,
-0.243936196,
0.7326033711,
-0.6656011343,
0.8201768994,
0.1236663312,
-0.9094341993,
0.5539377928,
-0.2775254548,
0.5786998272,
0.646568656,
0.2554152906,
-0.5122810602,
-0.4640832543,
-0.3914828598,
-1.096706748,
0.3303065598,
0.0988450125,
-0.1773597449,
-0.0457977466,
0.411867559,
0.4755361676,
0.4028896689,
-0.4910890758,
0.0655304268,
-0.5455652475,
-0.131502375,
-0.407461077,
0.0295328312,
-0.2825227678,
-0.2119972706,
0.5038872361,
-0.1079012975,
0.1665413678,
0.3468714356,
-0.5157244205,
0.1685830355,
0.0843534917,
0.8899305463,
0.9101278782,
-0.5140184164,
0.2579273283,
0.0481913351,
-0.5182901025,
-0.4012536705,
0.1507078111,
-0.0525517501,
0.0307560302,
0.9206640124,
0.4873780608,
0.5127336979,
-0.6791994572,
0.5023537278,
-0.0731278285,
-0.2599607408,
-0.097245127,
-0.225832209,
0.3097071946,
0.069721587,
0.4786626399,
0.0415826738,
0.2038271278,
-0.3449259102,
0.2103381902,
0.5827170014,
-0.0604647174,
-0.5326644778,
0.669278264,
0.1811793149,
0.1098841131,
0.1047899872,
0.1875527799,
-0.5041510463,
0.6686052084,
0.4855004847,
0.797093153,
0.0704399645,
0.2766557932,
0.1014036089,
0.4883669615,
0.0007183038,
0.0656407103,
-0.1562564224,
-0.4376538992,
-0.7683057189,
-0.8142360449,
-0.6114384532,
-0.1704897583,
-0.5527789593,
-0.1399842054,
-0.5176025629,
0.1688925624,
0.6700485945,
-0.0623951778,
-0.5674559474,
0.1354885548,
-0.3450821638,
0.9610049129,
-1.0485757589,
0.1664414704,
0.4641087353,
-0.4256285131,
-0.1223808452,
-0.4914343953,
0.1104172617,
-0.6472737193,
0.7094296813,
0.1780682504,
-0.0564045273,
-0.3571686745,
-0.4388393462,
-0.824952364,
1.2651543617,
0.0747426748,
-0.3605693877,
0.2759437859,
-0.1977595091,
0.8759809732,
-0.7170524597,
0.5949499011,
0.5584373474,
0.539560616,
0.1174134985,
-0.997387588,
0.2155273706,
-0.40266487,
-0.1555625051,
-0.0971489102,
-0.5274553299,
0.6750065684,
-0.3877583444,
-0.1453403383,
-0.0861830562,
0.7245920897,
0.2482569069,
0.6987597942,
0.1605699211,
0.2876971364,
0.4660486579,
-0.210501954,
1.0634276867,
0.0325286165,
0.1315728426,
1.0829402208,
-0.4598438442,
0.5847017765,
0.6413263679,
-0.4715119898,
0.3014241755,
0.7818717957,
-0.051850941,
0.5819699168,
0.4812378585,
-0.0259954166,
0.0043540145,
-0.1431323886,
-0.6191278696,
0.3403955996,
0.3841532767,
-0.3666434288,
-0.6162623167,
0.0295811277,
0.094917044,
0.1745010465,
-0.3252100945,
0.8257566094,
0.2452331483,
-0.3714704514,
0.4982913435,
0.0714138895,
0.6557738185,
-0.51704669,
0.1009538099,
-0.3880449235,
-0.2416301221,
-0.502286911,
-0.5106858015,
0.5025398731,
0.2084432542,
-0.2871184647,
-0.1534355879,
0.2688621283,
-0.1937861294,
-0.3689698875,
-0.1108771488,
0.5396777987,
0.5567866564,
-0.1634482592,
-0.2529521585,
-0.0696789622,
-0.2061131597,
-0.3354106247,
0.5839729905,
0.2717342377,
-0.2959513068,
0.6762405038,
0.7365856767,
0.1253158897,
-0.4583823681,
0.2713615894,
0.7691515088,
-0.7242058516,
-0.4215811789,
-0.7138118744,
0.3621711135,
0.0717762783,
-0.174856618,
0.7983272672,
0.5817312002,
0.4420400858,
-0.1678675711,
0.7982594967,
0.1039402336,
0.4719520211,
-0.5309027433,
0.8597534299,
-0.3301468194,
0.5457017422,
-0.4669647217,
-1.0635193586,
-0.5646407604,
0.5429018736,
-0.3754176795,
0.2569317818,
0.9327834249,
0.2885559499,
0.0764701813,
0.290499568,
0.0542809851,
0.1929284632,
0.2809731364,
0.1788986474,
0.6099607348,
-0.1887903959,
0.0182710942,
-0.0951863974,
-0.6633233428,
-0.1948521584,
-1.3121197224,
-0.8956064582,
-0.1989601851,
-0.3934616745,
0.0330223516,
0.2247298211,
0.6443367004,
0.2810229659,
-0.6971974373,
0.0380774625,
0.1793926805,
0.0800893009,
-0.406912446,
-0.1827295274,
0.7185285687,
-0.1631755233,
-0.458014518,
0.6577452421,
0.5154539347,
0.0653629974,
-0.2525055707,
0.2025278211,
0.1335407794,
0.1277455688,
0.7896639705,
0.1612592638,
-0.707937777,
-0.1917966902,
-0.0060829818,
0.305996567,
-0.2300317138,
0.7667613029,
-1.0814586878,
0.2553573847,
0.4093748033,
0.540930748,
0.5623951554,
0.1077702865,
0.585652709,
-0.5030551553,
-0.311452508,
0.3091816902,
0.1866491139,
0.581574142,
-0.146367684,
0.6821199656,
0.1763021499,
-0.3517758548,
-1.0546227694,
-0.0839877129,
-1.0562806129,
-0.2176068127,
0.7516365051,
-0.306743443,
-0.2481957227,
0.1230909973,
0.2080077529,
0.0003012801,
-0.0899420232,
1.0141284466,
0.8240364194,
-0.287476927,
0.0821498036,
-0.5355569124,
0.4024407268,
0.6430584192,
-0.9349889159,
0.1171617284,
0.358289361,
0.5294768214,
0.3151355386,
0.4222897887,
-0.5381663442,
0.4172876775,
-0.1732741743,
-0.0728017241,
-0.5360416174,
-0.2282808423,
-0.3672157228,
-0.0111960396,
-0.1749923825,
0.3233151138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14355v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14355v2
|
Rule or Story, Which is a Better Commonsense Expression for Talking with Large Language Models?
| 2024-02-22T07:55:26 | 2024-06-04T08:05:51 |
Ning Bian, Xianpei Han, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Building machines with commonsense has been a longstanding challenge in NLP
due to the reporting bias of commonsense rules and the exposure bias of
rule-based commonsense reasoning. In contrast, humans convey and pass down
commonsense implicitly through stories. This paper investigates the inherent
commonsense ability of large language models (LLMs) expressed through
storytelling. We systematically investigate and compare stories and rules for
retrieving and leveraging commonsense in LLMs. Experimental results on 28
commonsense QA datasets show that stories outperform rules as the expression
for retrieving commonsense from LLMs, exhibiting higher generation confidence
and commonsense accuracy. Moreover, stories are the more effective commonsense
expression for answering questions regarding daily events, while rules are more
effective for scientific questions. This aligns with the reporting bias of
commonsense in text corpora. We further show that the correctness and relevance
of commonsense stories can be further improved via iterative self-supervised
fine-tuning. These findings emphasize the importance of using appropriate
language to express, retrieve, and leverage commonsense for LLMs, highlighting
a promising direction for better exploiting their commonsense abilities.
|
[
-0.0643791407,
-0.5625204444,
0.7946124673,
0.239169836,
-0.2434459478,
-0.1985362023,
-0.3770757914,
-0.5910474062,
-0.0155342836,
0.5064293742,
-0.3361314237,
-0.3237918019,
-0.6481013298,
0.3124625385,
-0.2766696811,
0.9265648723,
0.1763407141,
-0.1701265126,
-0.5071855783,
-0.1704950333,
-0.4890492857,
-0.4434575737,
-0.4588006437,
-0.3358365595,
0.8411689997,
0.3263264298,
0.8246913552,
0.759237051,
0.1802526116,
0.3598169088,
-0.1985928714,
0.4694518447,
-0.5011184812,
-0.0429166891,
-0.4811918437,
-0.3310825527,
-0.0685424283,
0.1435511261,
0.3150293827,
0.6587216854,
-0.0931344256,
0.3277062476,
-0.038324926,
0.5663180351,
-0.3860438764,
0.1251921654,
-0.5077905059,
0.1535933614,
0.069155328,
-0.3193248212,
-0.2786790729,
-0.2877112925,
0.172058329,
-0.6431387663,
0.0821945667,
0.346339196,
0.8251922131,
0.1234447286,
-0.3646749258,
-0.5747382641,
-0.2237734646,
0.8816366196,
-0.9966844916,
0.3534628451,
0.303845048,
0.1510099769,
0.1188979372,
-0.7630395293,
-0.7867702842,
-0.6538806558,
-0.4560767412,
-0.2681113482,
-0.3433103263,
-0.2935405374,
0.3956262171,
0.244289726,
-0.5060808063,
0.6298606396,
-0.590821445,
0.0384501629,
0.7452690601,
0.2010916322,
0.2470660955,
-0.5276437998,
-0.4857127368,
0.0193697792,
-0.8037518859,
-0.2333581895,
0.4709149301,
0.3380842805,
-0.2417534292,
0.5929808021,
-0.3923299015,
0.5822146535,
-0.0579900928,
-0.276971668,
0.2345365733,
-0.2645059228,
-0.0589328036,
0.0621654652,
0.7490975261,
0.7250932455,
0.5453023911,
-0.2778731883,
-0.2319915444,
-0.1985003203,
0.1299993992,
-0.7031489015,
-0.0044574738,
0.2130572796,
-0.5612875223,
-0.4717317522,
-0.3105002642,
-0.8373346329,
-0.7615859509,
-0.5045356154,
0.4511722922,
-0.0730745941,
-0.369286716,
0.3045879006,
-0.3706910908,
0.1913758516,
0.3029372096,
-1.105876565,
0.2359125018,
0.985488534,
0.8418239355,
-0.221147567,
-0.3056154847,
-0.6823806167,
-0.0215853229,
-0.5030850172,
0.6151101589,
-0.3753325343,
-0.0988203585,
-0.0139809242,
-0.2115801871,
-0.004272501,
-0.7640936971,
0.7283338904,
-0.3293880224,
0.1161213368,
-0.2217632532,
-0.6823788881,
0.0730736852,
0.0630105361,
-0.532341361,
0.4388420284,
-0.2567237318,
-0.6272477508,
0.2687588632,
-0.8521806598,
-0.4683660865,
0.0997687429,
0.0169166084,
-0.0902944356,
0.1880753487,
0.4509539902,
0.8304366469,
-0.0264165625,
0.5895649791,
-0.2209704518,
-0.0934740677,
0.5292796493,
-0.6963435411,
0.766071856,
0.425725013,
-0.0312998034,
-0.0759947225,
-0.5027686357,
-0.244421497,
0.324183315,
-0.1082023755,
-0.2299290001,
0.1705645323,
-0.1336752623,
0.1449566782,
0.1578698754,
-0.5649617314,
0.1267282665,
-0.2551212609,
0.6573503613,
0.7378197908,
0.010973624,
0.3605802357,
-0.6525734067,
0.1414561123,
-0.218775481,
-0.0189201236,
-0.1352049261,
-0.2449087948,
-0.3935733736,
-0.0649381503,
-0.0408604853,
0.2654593587,
-0.5421148539,
0.0231203847,
-0.3214349449,
-0.414108932,
-0.4681236148,
0.293848753,
0.3616085351,
0.6331714988,
0.3857741952,
0.1871737987,
-0.4410180449,
-0.9430103898,
-0.5464789867,
-0.0462219976,
-0.1218932495,
0.4781910777,
0.3543039262,
0.2572644949,
0.6749844551,
-0.6322901845,
-0.0745249838,
-0.5386262536,
0.2478773892,
0.304189533,
0.2624147832,
0.3275955021,
-0.9727265239,
-0.3252524436,
-0.0995276049,
-0.7554178238,
-0.3119258583,
-0.2536613643,
0.2789951563,
0.4070027173,
0.5601585507,
-0.8133141398,
-0.0419083573,
0.6268814206,
-0.4216914773,
0.7769950032,
-0.1738909334,
0.1195129603,
-0.7022807002,
-0.0326053724,
0.0313085206,
-0.3073875308,
-0.4751891494,
0.1589383483,
-0.0957545564,
-0.0168502014,
-0.7137414217,
0.8060952425,
-0.4921762049,
-0.3240848482,
-0.1049966216,
0.400726676,
0.0809209198,
0.3403042555,
0.2320144027,
0.6937459707,
0.3249873817,
-0.6843402982,
0.5269449949,
0.118565008,
-0.6247023344,
0.5757292509,
-0.6734857559,
-0.0580097735,
-0.1526566893,
0.0579872131,
-0.443934232,
-0.1242022216,
-0.1054443642,
-0.455807209,
0.2052922994,
0.0279491656,
-0.9718549848,
-0.444786638,
-0.0875556022,
-0.1523061544,
0.5023923516,
-0.9757146239,
0.3612996042,
0.2479333878,
-0.2735736966,
-0.6460962892,
-0.5309525728,
0.3058105409,
-0.5972086787,
-0.5982357264,
-0.0803551078,
-0.0493385009,
-0.4794043899,
-0.1285442561,
-0.1579035074,
0.0563496463,
0.1241374686,
0.0316582955,
-0.0178012885,
-0.2636667788,
0.4020571113,
-0.271148622,
-0.0314943492,
0.1881117821,
0.0202091485,
0.583132863,
-0.2075286955,
-0.0273395237,
-0.4669485688,
0.3799576163,
0.4325137734,
-0.145547837,
0.574842155,
0.2395914048,
0.1089776382,
-0.3185540438,
-0.6394407749,
-0.4018720388,
-0.5292585492,
0.4167701006,
-0.2975128889,
-0.9723542333,
0.1239041686,
0.0135155842,
0.2075514495,
0.5879445672,
0.392493695,
-0.3839818835,
0.5812155604,
0.5656173229,
0.0899174884,
0.0572866797,
0.1723670661,
0.2370974123,
-0.7744125128,
0.021646155,
-0.4176508784,
-0.2495141774,
-0.477709651,
-0.3426167667,
0.1910897195,
-0.1020702571,
-0.2299940586,
0.2858754992,
-0.3188152015,
0.6939561963,
0.5113953352,
0.0214758497,
0.7706683874,
-0.1432611495,
0.2592587471,
-0.0744320005,
-0.8541983962,
-0.7360500693,
0.8664138913,
0.5396143198,
0.7041441798,
0.1994843036,
0.6368192434,
0.2301420718,
0.0756943077,
-0.5108053088,
0.6371786594,
-0.4073155522,
-0.5940128565,
-0.4937744141,
-0.5690127015,
-0.8528443575,
0.2321023494,
-0.3017810881,
-0.9053705931,
0.0254992843,
0.1147474796,
-0.4224432111,
0.4406429231,
-0.7851319909,
1.0147794485,
-0.3461053967,
-0.2896942794,
-0.4076906741,
-0.6216137409,
0.4377693236,
0.0642349571,
0.2140852809,
-0.2116690278,
-0.0368348658,
0.6170239449,
-0.1817049235,
1.1729590893,
0.1870740205,
-0.2431264371,
0.2773841321,
0.0763757452,
0.4801454544,
0.0796051323,
0.049571503,
0.2107391059,
0.0565258339,
-0.257265687,
-0.6001270413,
0.8081787825,
-0.7516557574,
-0.833114922,
-0.3011092842,
-0.6214446425,
-0.2106682658,
-0.0509645715,
0.0360007361,
0.4954591691,
0.0016509473,
0.2063703686,
0.7091721296,
-0.5006825328,
0.6629924178,
0.6338871717,
-0.1569777578,
0.0955654457,
0.9237687588,
0.0834065303,
0.6234114766,
0.578954339,
0.6415531039,
-0.4883005917,
-0.4917482734,
-0.5106630921,
0.3704513013,
-0.6379683614,
-0.4522138834,
-0.9708914757,
-0.2812106311,
-0.3918223679,
-0.3609518409,
-0.296177268,
-0.5540401936,
-0.2405673712,
-0.4317527711,
0.588614285,
0.508071661,
-0.4305348098,
-0.047441192,
-0.7410492301,
0.4727689922,
0.6342912316,
0.1671226025,
0.0291767083,
-0.4398854673,
0.125095576,
-0.1415324807,
0.0085940072,
-0.7545292974,
0.461294502,
0.0021970095,
0.5216730833,
0.2844542861,
0.284199208,
0.4461190104,
-0.4676324129,
0.7007266283,
0.1931111217,
-0.6980326772,
0.2377713472,
-0.5137294531,
0.2671326399,
0.1954354346,
0.3491196632,
-0.8527262211,
-0.3876264989,
-0.688200593,
-0.7205224037,
0.3466440141,
-0.0978180841,
0.6516004205,
-0.1841896176,
0.0420667082,
0.4254569709,
0.4229649603,
-0.8065584302,
0.0526559241,
-0.097948052,
-0.0707285702,
-0.0746668652,
-0.3629028201,
-0.1320838332,
-0.023594344,
0.4092381597,
-0.1254738122,
0.0190500785,
0.1115282327,
-0.1812621802,
0.0010737719,
0.5037469864,
0.53317976,
0.8684683442,
-0.1113245636,
0.2581028044,
0.3500414789,
-0.1193737462,
-0.4712539315,
0.0880034119,
-0.0942294672,
-0.1052202806,
0.6223391891,
0.8266398311,
0.317979753,
-1.1184493303,
0.7074052691,
0.2540256679,
-0.3092882931,
-0.0250827484,
0.1878694296,
0.4954090416,
0.4428546429,
0.2667500079,
-0.3473128378,
0.1078727394,
-0.6234176159,
0.1658627391,
0.3072021306,
0.2018014491,
0.2057887912,
0.3698358238,
0.2084933966,
-0.1085252538,
0.6773973703,
-0.0633851141,
-0.3775972724,
0.7475934029,
0.7084047794,
0.5252957344,
0.2134920061,
0.5225623846,
0.499622941,
0.2052645832,
0.049136512,
-0.26515311,
-0.0057265903,
-0.7318776846,
-0.6211742759,
-0.8143745065,
-0.2945036292,
0.1897184551,
-0.2268795073,
0.1039994806,
-0.2532206178,
0.5889905691,
0.1211825535,
0.1765896678,
-0.406929493,
0.1037451327,
0.2821727097,
0.9823030233,
-0.7809644341,
0.3815852106,
0.2489037812,
-0.3166573942,
-0.7664305568,
-0.3041083515,
0.0316436775,
-0.8157194257,
0.8182127476,
0.1661606729,
0.1078291833,
-0.143354401,
-0.892976284,
-0.7598595619,
1.0477323532,
0.012313609,
-0.8515672684,
0.0924290493,
0.1280719191,
0.651322782,
-0.3975927532,
-0.0445426442,
0.4050730765,
0.5022301674,
0.4005047977,
-1.1669917107,
0.150364548,
0.1951495558,
-0.2632242143,
-0.0332006849,
-0.5883984566,
0.5704351664,
-0.7151804566,
-0.3175374866,
0.1568757296,
0.8904711604,
0.3111011684,
0.5614457726,
0.430590868,
0.4718359113,
0.8090546131,
0.1916307509,
1.0986363888,
0.2883941829,
-0.0035766622,
1.3475784063,
-0.0899615213,
0.8876846433,
0.2817321718,
-0.0073309299,
0.278681308,
0.3300958872,
-0.1555188894,
0.3754578233,
0.4643466771,
-0.1379415244,
-0.1607809961,
-0.1207601279,
-0.1518952996,
0.5297007561,
0.2269155085,
-0.2687245309,
-0.4352824986,
0.1235863343,
0.4083779752,
0.472022146,
-0.670347631,
0.8252564669,
0.2914974988,
-0.6033551097,
0.3816112876,
-0.1579405814,
0.7338362932,
-0.252997905,
0.0417896062,
-0.3627485037,
-0.1678652912,
-0.0708536133,
-1.0380488634,
0.3312687874,
0.176989302,
-0.1077672541,
-0.4237494767,
0.6711024642,
-0.456877172,
-0.1527669728,
-0.1851012409,
0.5684453249,
0.2845095098,
-0.0084411185,
-0.543581605,
-0.0509525239,
-0.2625596523,
-0.0227734875,
0.3730039299,
0.5232289433,
-0.1042551994,
0.9310645461,
0.7212048769,
0.0124830138,
0.0583232976,
0.0235492587,
0.6973106265,
-0.6097525358,
-0.3708030581,
-0.7463514209,
0.3285794258,
-0.3939116895,
-0.4240939319,
0.6973957419,
0.5307459235,
0.5565037131,
-0.0957605839,
0.4565071166,
0.0341896489,
0.6970266104,
-0.8165856004,
0.7537456751,
-0.4201209545,
0.2566108108,
0.0764825493,
-0.5849991441,
-0.1722653061,
0.511910975,
-0.3884596229,
-0.0193731133,
0.7054639459,
0.7292278409,
0.0058941911,
0.1173166484,
0.5267705917,
0.5508425236,
0.1355921179,
0.4644102156,
0.9133684635,
0.19153364,
0.3557114899,
-0.1068484411,
-0.0139507195,
-0.1784042865,
-1.1281455755,
-0.9065722823,
-0.4755452573,
-0.4268880188,
-0.1471897513,
0.3878076673,
0.8156062961,
0.4739338458,
-0.3716180325,
-0.0669060349,
0.026584195,
0.4056510627,
-0.2652974427,
-0.2934890389,
0.3967556059,
-0.7084806561,
-0.7115441561,
0.3255883455,
0.1277847588,
-0.1888917089,
-0.1797131747,
-0.0983020887,
-0.148679167,
0.182820037,
0.7274675965,
0.5303254128,
-0.5924645662,
-0.3879948556,
-0.0525230728,
-0.2404256165,
-0.0985057279,
0.6723940969,
-0.7608493567,
0.1902854741,
0.3064889312,
0.5212087035,
0.4801930189,
-0.1478956193,
0.5138510466,
-0.5217951536,
-0.2160425484,
0.3934239149,
0.1312657744,
0.5050307512,
-0.4529599547,
0.5136770606,
-0.0304162949,
-0.5380203724,
-0.6409951448,
0.2357038707,
-1.0249201059,
-0.6321951151,
1.6635736227,
0.2199730575,
-0.1584971398,
-0.0779596195,
-0.2142977566,
-0.2213127166,
-0.2725654244,
0.7800704837,
0.5365684628,
-0.059266042,
-0.5625661016,
-0.8705625534,
0.736012578,
0.1936403215,
-0.7364920974,
0.4787132442,
0.676692009,
0.2780301571,
0.0932608619,
0.529114902,
-0.0548854023,
0.1737595648,
-0.0924101695,
-0.3641624153,
-0.3972058296,
-0.2103549391,
0.0313498005,
0.1951583177,
-0.0677458718,
0.138182506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14337v1
|
AURA: Natural Language Reasoning for Aleatoric Uncertainty in Rationales
| 2024-02-22T07:12:34 | 2024-02-22T07:12:34 |
Hazel Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Rationales behind answers not only explain model decisions but boost language
models to reason well on complex reasoning tasks. However, obtaining impeccable
rationales is often impossible. Besides, it is non-trivial to estimate the
degree to which the rationales are faithful enough to encourage model
performance. Thus, such reasoning tasks often compel models to output correct
answers under undesirable rationales and are sub-optimal compared to what the
models are fully capable of. In this work, we propose how to deal with
imperfect rationales causing aleatoric uncertainty. We first define the
ambiguous rationales with entropy scores of given rationales, using model prior
beliefs as informativeness. We then guide models to select one of two different
reasoning models according to the ambiguity of rationales. We empirically argue
that our proposed method produces robust performance superiority against the
adversarial quality of rationales and low-resource settings.
|
[
-0.3842453361,
-1.1769727468,
0.7922471166,
0.2721498311,
-0.0234849304,
0.1712550223,
-0.2116696984,
-0.5682656169,
0.0984096229,
0.4452033937,
-0.4293719828,
-0.1332363486,
-0.496681124,
0.0702697262,
-0.2018314153,
0.3695053756,
-0.0979563147,
-0.0486090668,
-0.0270482264,
-0.3203474283,
-0.5530238152,
-0.4713124037,
-0.7457863688,
-0.2772963941,
0.1803333908,
0.2811076939,
1.2647262812,
0.5108786225,
0.414476186,
0.337061733,
-0.2092836052,
0.5032844543,
0.0460772142,
0.3433993459,
-0.2977199554,
-0.6123786569,
-0.1702219695,
-0.0398097485,
0.241543442,
0.5782930255,
-0.1076128557,
-0.0513057411,
-0.3664280474,
0.6239243746,
-0.7871718407,
-0.1530328542,
-0.8317582607,
-0.0239288323,
-0.1197928265,
-0.271465987,
-0.4782708585,
-0.3981392682,
0.0966597795,
-0.9988517761,
-0.367927134,
0.4856035709,
1.0396074057,
0.8207286,
-0.1684659421,
-0.2481909841,
-1.0107629299,
0.8417034149,
-0.7380331159,
0.5577263236,
0.7875891924,
0.195340544,
0.0157573409,
-0.5174081922,
-0.6380517483,
-0.2172120064,
0.0147825293,
0.1539056152,
-0.7186290622,
0.2689851224,
0.0329838023,
0.3771626949,
-0.471999824,
-0.0680892617,
0.1464750022,
-0.308868289,
0.4271832108,
-0.000004524,
0.3025530279,
0.018377075,
-0.2161132246,
-0.0177768562,
-0.2492179871,
0.1589783728,
0.6032530665,
0.1732162386,
0.11664664,
0.6642632484,
-0.1421423554,
0.7047054172,
0.2533898354,
0.048490826,
-0.0244362131,
-0.1377944052,
-0.4479650855,
-0.0433196127,
0.5774658918,
0.0336022303,
0.2243524343,
-0.28748402,
-0.2060909569,
0.2785618007,
0.3462012112,
-0.3043721318,
-0.0935145468,
0.5010041595,
-0.2843769789,
-0.2649632394,
-0.2302880585,
-0.4606328607,
-0.2660258412,
-0.7156994939,
0.5167102814,
-0.7779695392,
-0.3164168596,
0.0959926769,
-0.0710400939,
-0.1793185472,
0.4696734548,
-0.8572077751,
0.4227071106,
0.3960635662,
0.4469605982,
0.3628719747,
-0.2307626158,
-0.4778366387,
-0.1597484797,
-0.6942791939,
0.8369070292,
-0.6573871374,
-0.1042108014,
-0.3343681395,
-0.6371291876,
-0.2192796469,
-0.4917155206,
0.9628879428,
-0.5811969042,
0.1823792607,
-0.3393008709,
-0.7551640868,
-0.3232328296,
0.1392431259,
-0.5831571817,
0.9874161482,
0.167741403,
-0.7077198029,
0.1946404576,
-0.7038078308,
-0.248915419,
-0.0191249084,
-0.0926322863,
-0.0647417456,
0.3320178986,
0.4232907593,
-0.0463977642,
-0.2675697207,
0.367521435,
-0.1503812671,
-0.0030644806,
0.5112121701,
-0.9899654388,
0.6469804645,
0.6578943729,
-0.2090557963,
0.2897969782,
-0.6615265608,
0.2496804595,
-0.0360559486,
-0.2217618823,
-0.5322335958,
0.0763435587,
-0.0324158408,
-0.0344979018,
0.1439663619,
-0.1317096949,
0.0965678692,
-0.8080769181,
0.0700925067,
0.7259869576,
0.1046254113,
0.9151344299,
-0.2903780639,
0.4803218842,
-0.1533914208,
0.2570548654,
0.1179478541,
-0.5786411762,
-0.7632582188,
-0.193889007,
0.1215274334,
0.7379852533,
-0.8610751033,
0.4503930509,
0.2147395462,
-0.5552757382,
-0.7836598158,
0.2694716454,
0.3828125,
0.7710196376,
0.5564484596,
0.2631695867,
-0.4705757499,
-0.7936283946,
-0.6575023532,
-0.6613413692,
0.1381887347,
0.2412871569,
0.2432944179,
-0.1461029202,
1.082988739,
-0.3491423428,
0.0747511759,
-0.097853601,
0.5344543457,
0.1467265338,
0.5283805728,
0.5633272529,
-0.9714021087,
-0.0261119381,
0.0546757728,
-0.5923320651,
-0.2808503211,
-0.3822837472,
-0.4844863415,
0.3694606721,
0.2110530138,
-0.8203579187,
0.5559515953,
0.2728289068,
-0.5153023601,
0.4974728823,
-0.0568834804,
0.1893161833,
-0.8170838952,
0.0124002462,
-0.0061998474,
-0.0736474916,
-0.6904399395,
0.0608205944,
-0.0714963228,
0.158225283,
-0.2756847739,
0.7197345495,
-0.1073764265,
0.3525876701,
-0.2255078107,
-0.3183965683,
0.2439678311,
0.4510001242,
0.248158291,
0.6519892216,
0.654148221,
-0.5497815609,
0.444273442,
0.1311397254,
-0.0758175477,
0.7763249278,
-0.4407396317,
-0.3652050793,
-0.093617864,
-0.0522829965,
-0.6006104946,
-0.5370444059,
0.3014641106,
-0.7661598921,
0.2094120085,
-0.0602172054,
-0.4090063274,
-0.1658537984,
0.210545674,
0.3559915125,
0.4612388313,
-0.5451555848,
0.8762731552,
0.0842824355,
-0.0261872746,
-0.5301440954,
-0.6414803267,
-0.023687521,
-0.4304928482,
-0.8013650179,
0.0063572181,
-0.277559787,
-0.9434121251,
0.1169573516,
-0.4007823765,
-0.3521690965,
0.4488059282,
0.1093215272,
0.2109450102,
-0.3526137769,
0.3984180689,
0.1950787455,
-0.150475353,
0.0937302336,
-0.3924657106,
0.2000357062,
-0.4994902909,
-0.8259067535,
-0.4050965011,
0.4522922039,
0.7859211564,
-0.329826206,
0.6651057601,
0.4078481495,
-0.7599874735,
0.0132889962,
-0.7500594854,
-0.0013066513,
-0.4410057962,
-0.0681952238,
-0.1283011883,
-0.549353838,
0.6885840893,
0.0413419493,
-0.1055015102,
0.5876086354,
0.4976402819,
0.0065638302,
1.4062055349,
0.0960815549,
-0.0140524376,
0.3934766948,
-0.0207150932,
0.3656912148,
-0.4270499647,
-0.2053657174,
-0.5759233236,
0.0435682572,
0.0365727283,
-0.3068979084,
0.2923618257,
0.5494058132,
-0.3690967262,
-0.0137524009,
-0.5420879722,
0.5094436407,
0.8265439272,
-0.0879299119,
0.181196332,
-0.2421653271,
-0.103869088,
0.0204694737,
-0.4596087337,
-0.6204248071,
0.6167573929,
0.4674557745,
0.9708581567,
0.432575047,
0.405918479,
0.071444802,
0.1308670938,
-0.6768628359,
-0.0133877927,
0.4577204287,
-0.9265337586,
-0.3843062222,
-0.473811239,
-0.6415180564,
0.2185500264,
-0.2645181715,
-0.9881478548,
0.3988695741,
0.3516142666,
-0.6947315931,
0.2347081602,
-0.9074252248,
0.8418350816,
-0.5408726931,
-0.4048522413,
0.1065766141,
-0.7713445425,
0.3337956965,
-0.0354298092,
0.5056303144,
-0.0790586248,
0.1281718016,
0.3752208352,
-0.7457104921,
0.5146815777,
-0.131881088,
0.0710055083,
0.5328853726,
0.4457370937,
0.5226150751,
0.2845056355,
-0.2998308837,
0.0057992013,
-0.2155373544,
-0.2669178545,
-0.8666448593,
0.3594175577,
-0.7467073798,
-0.6623946428,
-0.378000468,
-0.4683836401,
-0.4446977079,
0.2103427947,
0.7204092741,
0.2480732203,
0.0485441424,
-0.1344272345,
0.7175972462,
-0.1278183758,
0.1848218143,
0.3821960986,
-0.097601302,
-0.2847129703,
0.7142130136,
-0.0566796623,
0.3717900515,
0.3848087192,
0.3079504371,
-0.4957422614,
-0.5611318946,
-0.5821499228,
-0.232467398,
-0.767193377,
-0.4412783384,
-0.4137973785,
-0.236973092,
-0.4021677077,
-0.5179642439,
-0.5417382717,
-0.5131229162,
-0.5188013315,
-0.2606454194,
0.6712905765,
0.4136435986,
-0.3513344526,
0.0936957896,
-0.5867298245,
0.4978826642,
0.2844099104,
0.3937296271,
-0.0387653522,
-0.5198649764,
-0.0400729552,
0.3377895355,
-0.2908177376,
-0.9772279859,
0.5662975311,
0.0511596613,
0.7416628003,
0.5787704587,
0.4341582358,
0.8198039532,
-0.1805797517,
0.643945992,
0.0471961647,
-1.2637850046,
0.9868683815,
-0.2419341654,
0.1076564118,
0.6955250502,
0.0009496344,
-0.0475982577,
-0.8276840448,
-0.9790599346,
-1.029296279,
0.7324339151,
0.8132606149,
-0.1664497405,
0.0266685244,
0.1056404188,
-0.220181182,
-0.0074231392,
-0.5538629293,
-0.3160167933,
-0.5228683949,
-0.1998576224,
0.2911294699,
0.1091750413,
-0.2396449596,
-0.3174981773,
0.8830726147,
-0.1635610312,
-0.0602190495,
0.4457607865,
0.0817425624,
-0.5198472142,
0.4359268248,
0.5087795854,
0.3941330612,
-0.2152336538,
0.284716785,
0.2352454066,
-0.1038927659,
0.013128968,
0.1590846628,
-0.047811728,
0.0191917159,
0.4841716886,
0.8267890215,
0.0258414056,
-0.9212140441,
0.4477705359,
-0.3041932583,
0.1407154948,
-0.485979706,
0.0950394645,
0.0086697889,
0.2472870946,
0.3523828387,
0.974615097,
0.2390060872,
-0.3634379804,
-0.0036800716,
0.4510341585,
-0.2925821841,
-0.0850867108,
0.9240357876,
-0.0035272297,
-0.3505877256,
0.5349382758,
-0.1742970794,
-0.5272436142,
0.6819040775,
0.2981699109,
0.7070341706,
-0.1799146235,
-0.0499754064,
0.1877966672,
0.4660750031,
-0.2187874615,
0.2781930566,
-0.094090648,
-0.9062824845,
-0.2613381147,
-0.6618531346,
-0.5850746632,
-0.1602174789,
-0.7400153279,
-0.1526537985,
-0.4047131538,
-0.1498173922,
0.0822117105,
-0.3461518884,
-0.560248971,
0.3608988523,
0.2139137238,
1.1036742926,
-0.9284545183,
0.5685344338,
0.5100290179,
-0.6781369448,
-1.384319067,
-0.0130800502,
0.2612330317,
-0.7283455729,
0.4049603641,
-0.2217860371,
-0.221258536,
-0.1661639959,
-0.5851391554,
-1.045797348,
0.6818116307,
0.7075653672,
-0.0223359335,
0.0987287164,
-0.1768688411,
0.7230231762,
-0.0564012825,
0.3311368823,
0.6325230598,
0.8111829162,
0.4314970076,
-0.8510345221,
-0.2119405568,
-0.4470502138,
-0.2135710716,
0.0762986243,
-0.2194182575,
0.7333058119,
-0.2089002281,
-0.224166885,
0.4329806864,
0.5843814015,
0.2816220522,
0.5473466516,
0.3256363571,
0.8117954731,
1.2451958656,
-0.2254098058,
1.4184106588,
-0.2459316999,
0.0493758395,
0.9016775489,
-0.2646999359,
0.7637384534,
0.5915622711,
-0.0901390314,
0.2954111695,
0.6930508018,
0.3785357773,
0.3288171589,
-0.1195619702,
-0.4234143794,
-0.6585586071,
-0.2954746187,
-0.2305054069,
0.4288928211,
0.6508974433,
-0.1954413205,
0.089140296,
-0.1147429273,
0.0554710515,
0.4306462705,
-0.1415566355,
0.6924794316,
-0.0881705731,
-1.0160806179,
0.4902935326,
0.008293,
0.3076474965,
-0.6012910008,
0.0253453571,
-0.2370287478,
-0.014339406,
-0.3516617119,
-0.6746298671,
0.7000659108,
0.0496210791,
-0.2669056356,
-0.212990135,
0.6440165043,
-0.0461365208,
-0.6251609325,
0.1457791179,
0.5746668577,
-0.1154263765,
-0.177121833,
-0.5978237391,
0.0115824202,
-0.1049412936,
-0.3879104257,
-0.2357300371,
0.8076299429,
-0.0442746691,
0.8671324253,
0.71938622,
0.1252994537,
0.0047141942,
0.053874854,
0.749474287,
-0.3060332239,
-0.4785140157,
-0.871799171,
0.5878540277,
0.0660580099,
-0.4635645747,
0.667863071,
0.4638657272,
0.4234946668,
0.2186958343,
0.7338986993,
0.0646326542,
0.5342161059,
-0.7282452583,
0.5373384356,
-0.6903281808,
0.6941738129,
-0.3054794967,
-0.5664697289,
-0.4945040643,
0.8099607825,
-0.1716824621,
-0.1888956428,
0.5315434337,
0.6437511444,
-0.0239814781,
0.2941903472,
0.284163475,
0.2834527493,
0.1304463893,
0.4581347406,
1.1620721817,
-0.2190491557,
0.3639115393,
-0.3089467585,
-0.1262635589,
-0.0373686962,
-0.6751183271,
-0.4258699715,
-0.5184600949,
-0.2501809299,
-0.3261728287,
-0.1697178036,
1.0670167208,
0.7127340436,
-0.6753422022,
0.3552257121,
-0.5327602625,
0.5865250826,
-0.2922306955,
-0.3337418437,
0.1836582124,
-0.3638975024,
-0.4824886322,
0.5178633928,
0.2511003315,
0.2585583627,
0.0813237801,
-0.359343648,
-0.0434445143,
0.7151553035,
0.0647972822,
0.5023193359,
-1.216039896,
-0.4280945957,
0.0792836249,
-0.008652987,
-0.0419940129,
0.4040631652,
-0.8828175664,
0.4339672327,
0.2631699443,
0.5964084268,
-0.2384614795,
0.1589372456,
0.4829909801,
-0.8182021379,
0.0300881509,
0.734318316,
0.5968716741,
0.2054110169,
-0.4940841198,
0.4052262306,
0.0641246289,
-0.4821301103,
-0.7710942626,
0.3788272738,
-1.0453538895,
-0.5382969975,
1.1029131413,
0.0068926057,
0.0668126121,
-0.316203922,
-0.4799872935,
0.1483305693,
-0.490876466,
0.5984553099,
0.7320668697,
-0.4009661376,
-0.0476157852,
-0.1672457755,
0.3788290024,
0.6063891053,
-0.7870646119,
0.0605001301,
0.6219322681,
-0.1546214372,
0.4242285192,
0.4600744247,
0.1098475456,
0.4109395742,
0.3032983541,
-0.2441131622,
0.0985264406,
-0.2098553181,
-0.2341740876,
0.0752148628,
0.6119656563,
0.2129217982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14334v1
|
INSTRUCTIR: A Benchmark for Instruction Following of Information Retrieval Models
| 2024-02-22T06:59:50 | 2024-02-22T06:59:50 |
Hanseok Oh, Hyunji Lee, Seonghyeon Ye, Haebin Shin, Hansol Jang, Changwook Jun, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the critical need to align search targets with users' intention,
retrievers often only prioritize query information without delving into the
users' intended search context. Enhancing the capability of retrievers to
understand intentions and preferences of users, akin to language model
instructions, has the potential to yield more aligned search targets. Prior
studies restrict the application of instructions in information retrieval to a
task description format, neglecting the broader context of diverse and evolving
search scenarios. Furthermore, the prevailing benchmarks utilized for
evaluation lack explicit tailoring to assess instruction-following ability,
thereby hindering progress in this field. In response to these limitations, we
propose a novel benchmark,INSTRUCTIR, specifically designed to evaluate
instruction-following ability in information retrieval tasks. Our approach
focuses on user-aligned instructions tailored to each query instance,
reflecting the diverse characteristics inherent in real-world search scenarios.
Through experimental analysis, we observe that retrievers fine-tuned to follow
task-style instructions, such as INSTRUCTOR, can underperform compared to their
non-instruction-tuned counterparts. This underscores potential overfitting
issues inherent in constructing retrievers trained on existing
instruction-aware retrieval datasets.
|
[
-0.1556309015,
-0.2303469777,
0.3327798843,
0.1194321662,
0.0481554642,
0.0635500774,
-0.1078232154,
0.0054200711,
-0.1665554792,
0.4285265207,
-0.5172786117,
-0.3652056456,
-0.4347009063,
-0.1493028253,
-0.5679302812,
0.8505330086,
-0.079403691,
0.0659822673,
-0.4726738334,
0.0077847862,
-0.8670866489,
-0.2430561036,
-0.1372955143,
-0.2332311571,
0.2573314309,
0.7685288191,
0.571682632,
0.7476580739,
0.7235710621,
0.0855901614,
0.1702885777,
0.2451203018,
-0.5702407956,
0.2060140073,
-0.30521819,
-0.3445103765,
0.0456013829,
0.0412044115,
0.8361864686,
0.6323851943,
-0.4306857586,
0.2742067277,
0.3309840262,
0.8309316635,
-1.2908389568,
-0.082702361,
-0.468211472,
-0.1165675893,
-0.1775617898,
-0.4594888687,
-0.7397432327,
-0.7194222212,
0.1437228322,
-0.4787468314,
0.2104460001,
0.309194237,
0.4971673489,
0.2702409327,
-0.3801805377,
-0.3316120803,
-0.4902377129,
0.5270016789,
-0.470076263,
0.8184366822,
0.5140588284,
0.4311616421,
-0.3944954872,
-0.790892005,
-0.1997320801,
-0.1631069332,
-0.215381816,
0.2252016813,
-0.2209142596,
-0.0123837702,
0.3888058066,
0.022894619,
-0.599484086,
-0.071100615,
-0.5340038538,
0.3543165326,
0.2648219168,
0.1904896051,
0.1971425414,
0.1196277216,
-0.6297627687,
-0.3341946006,
-0.8185585737,
0.2886935472,
0.4548086226,
0.2644070983,
0.3769146204,
0.7113980055,
-0.6040470004,
0.8192099333,
0.3738865256,
0.3758168817,
-0.0172157679,
-0.3076798916,
-0.1173600405,
0.5295347571,
0.4099428952,
0.4148983061,
0.0192628969,
-0.4606942534,
-0.3975098431,
-0.5041107535,
0.7791498303,
-1.2463177443,
-0.1695230305,
-0.2790946662,
-0.6693686843,
0.1376035362,
0.3180421889,
-0.6389299035,
-0.2399480343,
-0.3187078536,
0.8111296892,
-0.6844480634,
0.2126628309,
0.0368031599,
0.0138534736,
0.5318594575,
-0.0258272756,
-1.0135625601,
0.696495831,
0.9452192783,
0.5474155545,
-0.08643803,
-0.2086382657,
-0.9868644476,
0.2074242383,
-0.3699624836,
0.6021630168,
-1.1814244986,
-0.4371559322,
0.0205906946,
-0.0146527598,
-0.3412947357,
-0.5587384701,
0.532607913,
-0.7613011599,
0.0942483023,
-0.4720167518,
-0.983123064,
-0.3331643343,
-0.0077148196,
-0.3638468981,
1.1166774035,
0.3620618284,
-0.5464411974,
0.4895984232,
-0.3662251234,
-0.5744384527,
0.2232254893,
-0.1689884961,
0.076280944,
0.0984972119,
0.0176524818,
0.2959900796,
-0.4332458079,
-0.1155610159,
-0.1034831926,
-1.1570085287,
-0.0640069693,
-0.1121387184,
0.521684885,
-0.0786819085,
-0.4135352075,
-0.1677815914,
-0.4408325553,
0.3903437853,
-0.329220742,
-0.2672998905,
-0.5820729136,
0.2764005959,
-0.2521650791,
-0.1404391974,
0.2712840736,
-0.5378699899,
0.3071275055,
-0.1941204369,
-0.0360726565,
0.7018062472,
-0.0191961359,
0.4316221178,
-0.3443530798,
0.7263166904,
-0.642011106,
0.2117653489,
-0.2726596892,
-0.0972716808,
-0.4757657945,
-0.0430910848,
0.096447289,
0.5290617943,
-0.1719203591,
0.0387184396,
-0.2501449883,
-0.6496608257,
-0.8196172118,
0.3109483421,
0.8734676242,
0.7152978778,
0.5805764794,
-0.3607600033,
-0.5682346821,
-0.7653657198,
-0.4689280391,
-0.0193021838,
0.1784793437,
0.4143415391,
0.3313974738,
-0.1045358479,
0.4994570017,
-0.3982669711,
-0.3099196255,
0.1048172861,
-0.0335331,
0.1965687722,
0.5382631421,
0.3053354621,
-0.9270628691,
-0.728787601,
0.1590381861,
-0.6719176769,
0.1068329215,
0.130607605,
-0.4346501827,
-0.2230705172,
0.7326254845,
-0.1918715239,
0.6362506151,
-0.0492217764,
-0.1427852064,
0.3468565047,
-0.3143595755,
0.7479334474,
-0.7919626236,
0.1998348683,
0.062069606,
0.2211883962,
-0.3680804372,
0.2160641104,
0.5217132568,
0.1347737312,
-0.1353206187,
0.5880172253,
-0.6190417409,
-0.1459735632,
-0.1438494921,
-0.1476549208,
-0.0090828966,
0.211722061,
-0.1639941931,
1.2247712612,
0.3201357126,
-0.6151643991,
-0.0067556137,
0.5208237767,
-0.6367537379,
0.8480434418,
-0.7168331742,
0.3276317418,
-0.1445156187,
-0.2271351516,
-1.0298886299,
-0.2572196126,
-0.0379801691,
-0.1327225417,
0.5846579075,
-0.6574171185,
-0.7724785805,
-0.1924525499,
-0.346033752,
0.4118274748,
0.5688948631,
-0.6818072796,
0.5141003132,
-0.1931933761,
0.1180377156,
-0.947009325,
-0.3595434427,
-0.1671729833,
-0.1161227822,
-0.3730092347,
0.7930331826,
-0.2796477973,
-0.1360875517,
-0.0038950508,
-0.3803412318,
-0.2791793644,
0.0078375516,
0.3166336119,
0.1868528277,
-0.2918916941,
0.0297017377,
0.1536629498,
0.2211811095,
0.1190623492,
-0.1102828383,
0.1778435558,
0.0822608545,
-0.6357865334,
-0.6568494439,
0.2574229538,
0.1438087672,
-0.5744817257,
0.5880332589,
0.1840934306,
-0.148076728,
-0.1206552386,
-0.7381142378,
-0.4357055426,
-0.5166220069,
0.1802884638,
-0.3171618581,
-0.3082452118,
-0.0022964913,
0.0599866472,
-0.0578013733,
-0.0990120396,
-0.0225242563,
-0.4525052905,
1.124796629,
0.8147817254,
0.1682450622,
0.8094192743,
-0.0822664201,
-0.0343860053,
-1.2105058432,
-0.456353277,
-0.5260019302,
-0.303666234,
-0.5090870261,
-0.0392212942,
0.3190842569,
0.1501132995,
-0.3278439939,
0.5540131927,
-0.817381084,
0.5454451442,
0.8171256781,
0.3972055614,
-0.0956500769,
-0.1088018641,
-0.0297487099,
-0.1101390645,
-0.564165473,
-0.3811632395,
1.0933511257,
-0.4800263047,
1.0384202003,
0.1069933921,
0.8024335504,
0.4080795646,
0.2431536168,
-0.4307270348,
0.4847455025,
-0.3645720482,
-0.4609151185,
0.1367039382,
-0.1227212921,
-0.8365497589,
0.1257677972,
0.025917327,
-0.8980659842,
0.151212588,
0.2274299413,
-0.0894876495,
-0.0656978711,
-0.7236974239,
0.9535224438,
-0.3403203189,
-0.4687733352,
-0.3323808908,
-0.6441639662,
-0.1377315968,
0.1827557981,
-0.1670505702,
0.1196483746,
-0.0599288158,
0.6117132902,
-0.1095513999,
0.5556918383,
-0.1946646869,
0.6961786747,
0.1532006413,
0.2888852358,
0.5742122531,
-0.5493808985,
-0.4547123015,
-0.7311169505,
0.0891274884,
-0.252204597,
-0.7594217062,
0.7111999989,
-0.2517034411,
-0.787402153,
-0.0792889372,
-0.3385114372,
-0.2176382989,
0.4437086582,
0.3449392617,
0.8263346553,
-0.3418763578,
0.5639241338,
1.0344957113,
0.2411721349,
0.1485929042,
0.6848495007,
0.2816005945,
-0.0507412814,
0.8331570625,
0.2010698467,
0.1120743677,
0.9277688861,
0.153537482,
-0.2933783233,
-0.5352659225,
-0.4002898932,
-0.0118990215,
-0.8469744325,
-0.2455172837,
-0.3976117373,
-0.0468084738,
-0.0812555924,
-0.3525585234,
-0.1889614463,
0.1237539425,
-0.3818167746,
0.0462350175,
0.1551170349,
0.7853735089,
0.4196530282,
0.310418725,
-0.5656310916,
-0.1887896508,
0.1125186756,
0.487552613,
0.0668972805,
-0.8899177313,
-0.3438694477,
-0.1011046097,
-0.3091056943,
-0.771966517,
-0.0997890159,
0.1792259514,
1.0161603689,
0.2599160075,
0.396668911,
0.8343966007,
-0.5155915618,
0.0649980754,
-0.309063077,
-0.7163449526,
0.9035479426,
0.0028009049,
0.2779732049,
0.8939645886,
0.691866219,
-0.2000630051,
-0.2040663958,
-0.2944557667,
-0.7002413273,
0.8390560746,
0.0627504438,
0.106566526,
-0.0620098338,
0.6652109623,
0.2879586816,
0.1978014112,
0.0514866114,
-0.0855945498,
-0.0712176934,
-0.4060001969,
0.3086449802,
-0.3668881655,
0.1424576789,
0.0700227097,
0.7124118209,
-0.0093867667,
-0.0123340702,
0.0739687234,
-0.2580918372,
0.0007512813,
0.2158528864,
0.2256301492,
0.8261141777,
-0.5433470011,
-0.0791434795,
-0.1196097955,
-0.4065160155,
0.0417703129,
0.5720267892,
-0.3312489092,
-0.3528903723,
0.1911663413,
0.4514262974,
0.6121362448,
-0.8296644688,
0.6820899844,
-0.1144858077,
0.2368216813,
-0.18259193,
0.6107847691,
-0.2387868762,
0.4333393872,
0.5766264796,
-0.015387929,
0.6936289072,
-0.3918937147,
0.3047887385,
0.6248522401,
-0.8963424563,
-0.3436305225,
0.822632432,
-0.1976476312,
-0.4640378058,
0.8999670744,
0.0013472978,
-0.04020546,
0.4937959909,
0.5733548999,
0.6760625839,
-0.2908684313,
-0.1004506499,
0.4007301927,
0.2932575643,
-0.303832531,
0.4473964274,
-0.3025246561,
-0.2300537974,
0.1504848748,
-0.1309751719,
-0.4728367627,
-0.4215979874,
-1.2766122818,
0.1859567612,
-0.3470661342,
0.0730315149,
0.2608034611,
-0.106890589,
-0.8403530717,
0.1214382499,
-0.4901944697,
1.032366395,
-0.2074826062,
0.6106029153,
0.9165664911,
-0.5950729251,
-0.5005148053,
0.1913424879,
-0.0005011183,
-0.6445025206,
0.7449426055,
0.5622839928,
-0.5001740456,
-0.0786558017,
-0.4899792373,
-0.6874352098,
1.2233482599,
0.4636381269,
-0.3819201887,
-0.1033983305,
-0.5365793705,
0.3019238114,
-0.4692881405,
0.4702530205,
0.2783961892,
0.0945824161,
0.0798722804,
-0.6415800452,
0.1258388311,
-0.180557102,
-0.0231166817,
0.3856599033,
-0.640426755,
0.4229528904,
-0.4431146085,
-0.2856366038,
0.388002038,
0.5258162022,
-0.0502413213,
0.3046612442,
0.1996633559,
0.141950056,
0.6208953857,
0.2225993574,
1.1319758892,
-0.2657406628,
-0.2092786133,
1.5006325245,
-0.3090725243,
1.1484363079,
0.3276305795,
-0.0040013394,
0.5963827372,
0.3085509241,
0.006570247,
0.9210860133,
-0.1834105402,
-0.1918567419,
-0.1536574215,
-0.2790871263,
-0.2419166714,
0.5091543198,
0.2090846598,
-0.471114099,
-0.0292264838,
-0.1939971745,
-0.0511508211,
0.5256875157,
-0.2025258839,
0.7415578961,
-0.3909116089,
-0.9379172325,
0.4092922807,
-0.3927862644,
0.2902175188,
-0.505177319,
-0.4814664721,
-0.2236398309,
0.3939655423,
-0.1909417957,
-1.0667840242,
-0.2529542744,
-0.1808690578,
-0.3143542111,
-0.0695974976,
0.4322658777,
-0.1890440136,
-0.245466277,
0.382616967,
0.0835528001,
0.1289155334,
0.1203243583,
-0.3693437278,
-0.1464120001,
0.2040621787,
-0.1185309589,
0.458938539,
0.357054472,
-0.0771269128,
0.8024117947,
0.2248003185,
-0.4202802777,
0.0906322375,
-0.0415993407,
0.8075742722,
-0.5863223076,
-0.121813871,
-0.5844036937,
0.3447623551,
0.0369438156,
-0.3542878926,
0.7139702439,
0.8883097172,
1.1594113111,
0.1934297681,
0.4924454689,
-0.0241436027,
0.5035142899,
-0.4786249697,
0.3341332674,
-0.6491629481,
0.1922100931,
-0.1017157808,
-0.8938756585,
0.1970002651,
0.3615075648,
-0.0943290815,
0.1996139288,
0.2379531562,
0.9470586181,
-0.499353379,
-0.0525660776,
-0.0033088895,
-0.1674632728,
-0.1069688126,
0.2535523474,
0.7909372449,
-0.3744508028,
0.664545238,
-0.4424326122,
-0.1925602704,
-0.5206032991,
-0.6496298313,
-0.9403570294,
-0.5336737633,
-0.2339670062,
-0.0562353842,
0.6911423802,
0.919410646,
0.8137934208,
-0.6360009909,
-0.2830033898,
0.0444916189,
0.0142238764,
-0.618073225,
-0.1681542248,
0.3950796127,
-0.4375554025,
-0.538374424,
0.7448943257,
0.1836228669,
-0.0982123837,
0.1377520859,
-0.0443705618,
-0.3686935008,
-0.0674466416,
0.2398816794,
0.4273639321,
-0.6217786074,
-0.273331821,
0.4308717549,
-0.2207131088,
0.1921632588,
0.6942136288,
-0.7755984068,
1.061249733,
0.3297010958,
0.739988625,
0.7048905492,
0.2712031305,
0.6496693492,
-0.741496861,
-0.3872661293,
0.2720680535,
0.2095685601,
0.3899691701,
-0.5082288384,
0.7191613913,
-0.5827782154,
-0.559689641,
-0.8461200595,
-0.1396671832,
-0.6122127175,
0.0224839281,
0.7989655733,
-0.2072526813,
0.1015889794,
0.3163326681,
-0.0445425697,
0.0470255166,
-0.631207943,
0.5956432819,
0.3179332614,
-0.3270822763,
-0.1776647717,
-0.7953765988,
0.274456948,
0.3529730439,
-0.3410127461,
0.1107580438,
0.3956778347,
0.3313649595,
-0.3600696027,
0.4460601807,
0.1490456313,
0.6833651066,
-0.1684749573,
-0.0125076324,
-0.0374105647,
-0.3434981108,
0.1277845651,
0.0159210712,
0.1050167233,
-0.4657044709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14328v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14328v2
|
Understanding and Patching Compositional Reasoning in LLMs
| 2024-02-22T06:47:56 | 2024-06-06T14:06:41 |
Zhaoyi Li, Gangwei Jiang, Hong Xie, Linqi Song, Defu Lian, Ying Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have marked a revolutonary shift, yet they falter when faced with
compositional reasoning tasks. Our research embarks on a quest to uncover the
root causes of compositional reasoning failures of LLMs, uncovering that most
of them stem from the improperly generated or leveraged implicit reasoning
results. Inspired by our empirical findings, we resort to Logit Lens and an
intervention experiment to dissect the inner hidden states of LLMs. This deep
dive reveals that implicit reasoning results indeed surface within middle
layers and play a causative role in shaping the final explicit reasoning
results. Our exploration further locates multi-head self-attention (MHSA)
modules within these layers, which emerge as the linchpins in accurate
generation and leveraing of implicit reasoning results. Grounded on the above
findings, we develop CREME, a lightweight method to patch errors in
compositional reasoning via editing the located MHSA modules. Our empirical
evidence stands testament to CREME's effectiveness, paving the way for
autonomously and continuously enhancing compositional reasoning capabilities in
language models.
|
[
-0.0977775007,
-0.8724205494,
1.0645747185,
0.3424273431,
0.0987794399,
0.3559683561,
0.0170038491,
-0.4714491665,
-0.0275606457,
0.6111681461,
-0.9658802748,
-0.5224757791,
-0.6421934366,
-0.0110706231,
-0.2393440157,
0.6493551135,
-0.1565719396,
-0.1377298832,
-0.5295777917,
-0.1250846982,
-0.7925401926,
-0.5222725868,
-0.7205966711,
-0.2979572713,
0.8559300303,
0.6479366422,
0.2288234979,
0.690713644,
0.3228851855,
0.3099122345,
0.0246913414,
0.6227385998,
-0.5294071436,
0.2515526712,
-0.2176399827,
-0.9833250046,
-0.5737754107,
-0.1161975637,
0.4811947048,
0.4596624076,
-0.002641201,
0.0028304036,
0.1456672549,
0.7819674015,
-0.8012025356,
0.0302313976,
-0.8742169142,
-0.0221017003,
-0.3182245493,
-0.2274739444,
-0.4249619544,
0.1671105027,
-0.1058377028,
-0.4317475259,
0.3393729031,
-0.1016960815,
0.2059381604,
0.5890171528,
-0.4857286811,
-0.2654605508,
-0.8237074614,
1.0447850227,
-0.7847222686,
0.2592408061,
0.0236168355,
0.0330717377,
-0.2838398218,
-0.6722553968,
-0.4159757495,
-0.0220515262,
-0.2442419529,
0.0328284539,
-0.1581247449,
-0.0744884014,
0.2287854254,
0.2436038554,
-0.3391312063,
-0.0950986817,
-0.2066067457,
-0.3730797768,
0.6069458127,
0.4078743458,
0.4180797935,
0.1846414357,
-0.398110956,
0.0169622693,
-0.9105619788,
0.0672315955,
0.2132260203,
-0.0780143216,
-0.0351870358,
0.5616719127,
0.0257408768,
0.5649573207,
0.1527945399,
-0.2040457428,
-0.1071116328,
-0.1927718073,
-0.3958451152,
0.2052573115,
0.5122023821,
0.181608513,
0.1908666492,
0.0212528389,
-0.2878884077,
0.3031360507,
0.3585635424,
-0.3404205143,
-0.224285841,
0.5104268193,
0.1602143794,
-0.2185877413,
-0.0848111212,
-0.3591010869,
-0.1138277426,
-0.503826201,
0.2622148991,
-0.1604560763,
-0.2263162136,
0.2976094782,
-0.0514125228,
0.0278481543,
0.5012950897,
-0.7910535336,
0.0126649691,
0.8511973619,
0.5612383485,
-0.3878928125,
-0.5859552026,
-0.0133331129,
0.5280116796,
-0.3584024608,
1.2282371521,
-0.3163674474,
-0.3647633195,
-0.0871719271,
0.2632257044,
-0.4231143296,
-0.7240764499,
0.3942860067,
-0.2294747829,
0.086629875,
-0.5655254722,
-0.4473302066,
-0.014281787,
0.367661804,
-0.4859302044,
1.1080418825,
0.0307992138,
-0.5913565755,
0.089555189,
-0.5100226402,
-0.3498905003,
-0.2702410519,
-0.2037434131,
-0.4709886909,
0.2863795161,
0.2528789639,
0.111212872,
-0.0385053381,
-0.087536037,
-0.2543554902,
-0.2944036126,
0.6870863438,
-0.3000522554,
0.5566561222,
-0.2067651749,
-0.56455338,
0.2672131658,
-0.5794231296,
0.006126509,
0.2134122849,
-0.1462894827,
-0.1742817611,
-0.0689089447,
-0.1905685663,
0.2648392618,
0.1208879128,
-0.3855569065,
0.1037965119,
-0.0855084509,
0.5540117621,
1.0822253227,
0.1518177986,
0.5843591094,
-0.382412523,
0.4741227329,
0.4474419355,
0.3379473388,
-0.3069474399,
-0.4384673834,
-0.9858695865,
-0.2970169187,
-0.084087491,
0.44109869,
-0.2271449417,
-0.0634180531,
0.1272051632,
-0.399825573,
-0.6041194797,
0.5137184262,
0.5204433799,
0.5440393686,
0.3714543879,
-0.1282204241,
-0.3545238674,
-1.1237952709,
-0.6311984658,
0.1077438891,
0.2124525607,
0.1944209635,
0.314001143,
-0.5658145547,
0.9276625514,
-0.5416787267,
-0.4061431289,
-0.1635734588,
-0.0211743321,
-0.145864591,
0.6523070931,
0.2940659225,
-0.3453838229,
-0.249856934,
-0.1919706613,
-0.8096519113,
-0.4677627087,
-0.2180930972,
-0.468726933,
0.2761430144,
0.7052097321,
-0.8396615982,
0.3493219614,
0.4381587505,
-0.3342563212,
0.7961870432,
0.0139463162,
0.101471357,
-0.4103639424,
-0.3723434806,
-0.1173054725,
-0.183318302,
-0.3699235916,
0.0501652136,
0.0922277868,
0.3825328946,
-0.5277775526,
0.6369635463,
-0.66614151,
-0.0557514057,
-0.41401425,
0.0722252876,
0.4737859964,
0.5747509003,
-0.4274959862,
0.8551167846,
0.4308344126,
-0.5946890712,
0.1915153712,
0.054215271,
0.11757835,
0.7532896996,
-0.6569968462,
0.340257585,
-0.0931237489,
0.230938673,
-1.1769198179,
-0.234112978,
0.4222684801,
-0.1251963526,
0.2880963087,
-0.3225512207,
-0.4208672047,
-0.0715376064,
-0.1252481192,
0.6333166361,
0.0818397477,
-0.3747346103,
0.9041650295,
0.3733972907,
-0.0240512844,
-0.5558121204,
-0.8983058333,
-0.004380798,
-0.1861165315,
-0.8580356836,
0.1760946512,
-0.4466019571,
-0.5849974155,
0.0022258835,
-0.4770932496,
0.0870127827,
0.2134855688,
0.2449133694,
0.0347361453,
-0.4821274877,
-0.0717952922,
0.2870680392,
-0.2777362466,
0.4565742016,
-0.1559232175,
0.2747913897,
-0.2261467874,
-0.8351393342,
-0.2456565648,
0.3744646907,
0.6742287278,
-0.3170428276,
0.3015233874,
0.4080218077,
-0.1767361462,
-0.5899907351,
-0.7988817692,
-0.4900665283,
-0.4732485712,
0.0373531207,
-0.3835389912,
-0.8390472531,
0.6476873755,
-0.0575640574,
-0.0719838664,
0.3955890536,
0.5320110321,
-0.2937585711,
0.9570547938,
0.2714320123,
0.3243688941,
0.2523550093,
-0.2734280527,
0.0506932959,
-0.9333927631,
-0.4495924115,
-0.0604654998,
-0.4237736166,
-0.2707649469,
-0.6073228121,
0.6689833403,
-0.1038290933,
0.1033130586,
-0.046685189,
-0.3415374458,
0.6424729824,
0.6592473984,
0.362988025,
0.4471137524,
-0.075037457,
-0.002977107,
-0.123858735,
-0.6959350109,
-0.2978975475,
0.6965619922,
0.2206574082,
0.7043338418,
0.1382601559,
0.529948771,
0.3294737041,
0.2265104651,
-0.5565065145,
0.6833146214,
0.2473443896,
-0.5288234949,
-0.1751971245,
-0.1980909556,
-0.8808438778,
0.4123932123,
-0.0137098581,
-0.3800611198,
0.1868536472,
0.4555960596,
-0.0161494557,
0.1844606102,
-0.6629568934,
0.9582213163,
-0.3022484183,
-0.8439288735,
-0.2517050803,
-0.6262636781,
0.6649204493,
0.1260975152,
0.3389801383,
-0.2663735151,
0.1459887773,
0.2357829958,
-0.1865087301,
1.2415237427,
0.0920778215,
-0.6371079683,
0.4242817163,
0.5605915189,
0.3469528258,
0.127794832,
0.4514372945,
0.1955167502,
-0.1415983289,
-0.6187208891,
-0.8859217167,
0.9411944747,
-0.4738867283,
-0.9058354497,
-0.3859328926,
-0.700299263,
-0.3059944808,
-0.0579557531,
-0.1489695162,
0.4928123057,
0.029078193,
-0.2830117047,
0.9571329355,
0.1103492454,
0.3231490254,
0.595169425,
-0.1235081926,
-0.2173666358,
0.6579086781,
0.0448522642,
0.3734633327,
0.1190087646,
0.2195324749,
-0.1278819889,
-0.4027559757,
-0.5893150568,
0.4943166673,
-0.995070219,
-0.1150123402,
-0.7585209608,
-0.150713563,
-0.2858721018,
-0.1006382257,
-0.4133550525,
-0.3146007657,
-0.2989730537,
-0.2657227814,
-0.0214089155,
0.8983763456,
-0.2625737488,
0.3641172349,
-0.8187717199,
0.0582310818,
0.4817318618,
-0.0225333963,
0.0648513958,
-0.2235034108,
-0.327406615,
0.05908994,
-0.3478865623,
-0.9147712588,
0.0608221032,
-0.0893669948,
0.6982643604,
0.2483510822,
-0.3851000071,
0.7763508558,
-0.4674325287,
0.7321575284,
-0.2073733211,
-0.9313333631,
0.6102982163,
-0.4617755413,
0.4780997634,
0.2183006853,
-0.1130684838,
-0.37598297,
-0.7718735933,
-0.6892211437,
-0.785610795,
0.3534597456,
-0.0557178743,
0.1398584992,
-0.0962652266,
0.4366559088,
0.0985321775,
0.0735462457,
-0.6982536316,
-0.3787055612,
0.1070874184,
-0.1427361071,
0.0928516313,
-0.7196769118,
-0.445656836,
-0.2116487622,
0.76004529,
-0.2163092196,
0.1396245062,
0.5535224676,
-0.4411526322,
-0.3347159326,
0.2719759941,
1.0154672861,
1.0065637827,
0.0748828202,
0.5269976854,
0.0005114321,
-0.1050303951,
0.018713275,
-0.4196013212,
-0.0961511806,
-0.1496387869,
0.6923879385,
0.6441967487,
0.5573710799,
-0.6535578966,
0.4360355735,
0.1684461683,
-0.014675389,
-0.3845438957,
0.2209881246,
0.2179778069,
0.3040085435,
0.2973795831,
0.2002027631,
0.0650525391,
-0.6441423297,
0.1935663223,
0.4384888411,
-0.3599523008,
-0.4244811535,
0.4872348011,
-0.0558039844,
-0.0919655487,
0.3239093423,
0.3142307103,
-0.7115464211,
0.5207949281,
0.5645548701,
0.7348091006,
-0.3296379745,
0.2199532688,
0.0719296336,
0.6371070147,
0.0643045306,
0.1341837645,
0.1157599688,
-0.8712064624,
-0.6378948092,
-0.1378190666,
-0.3559246063,
-0.043592006,
-0.3192147017,
-0.0667541698,
-0.3417671025,
0.1279754937,
-0.2938723266,
-0.464381516,
-0.5627297163,
0.2360683233,
0.1137139276,
0.6374822259,
-1.0223208666,
0.2682727873,
0.5422501564,
-0.3048114181,
-0.601405859,
0.0261476357,
0.1302505732,
-1.0699807405,
0.5590892434,
0.032089375,
-0.4798656106,
0.004159004,
-0.8057185411,
-0.7126280069,
0.9359562993,
0.5812573433,
-0.5015290976,
0.1010361016,
0.4472151399,
0.3798455596,
-0.3851446211,
0.3073182106,
0.7697395086,
0.6917516589,
-0.1051019728,
-0.6363281608,
0.1276880205,
0.082812205,
-0.433542788,
0.0463269539,
-0.7472637296,
0.8724066019,
-0.42006284,
-0.1043434069,
-0.3526893854,
0.4431634843,
0.5137180686,
0.7638671994,
0.5057703853,
0.8695446849,
0.6064246297,
-0.0725598261,
1.0972507,
-0.1142344624,
0.0011591514,
1.2127557993,
-0.218174994,
0.461769104,
0.7764126062,
-0.0625435561,
0.895660758,
0.5371705294,
0.2157108933,
0.4122686386,
0.1236981452,
-0.5016131401,
-0.5422649384,
0.0208365992,
-0.1756499261,
0.4672318101,
0.512496531,
-0.1578273624,
0.0259318333,
-0.0555727333,
0.1405533999,
0.0116838561,
-0.3079648018,
0.8971614242,
0.3388033807,
-0.6996116638,
0.2507605553,
-0.1100060567,
0.2239790857,
-0.3693265617,
-0.2567531466,
-0.4754849374,
0.335321784,
-0.4260488749,
-0.7083918452,
0.3536881804,
-0.5876587629,
-0.3480247855,
-0.21232526,
1.0593783855,
-0.5546771884,
-0.4640591741,
0.4415674508,
1.0981479883,
-0.0587040819,
-0.4425268471,
-0.7054700851,
0.29409495,
-0.0750632361,
-0.1283917427,
0.2653968036,
0.7796991467,
-0.0637065694,
0.7202805877,
0.7562416196,
0.0039724023,
0.419472903,
0.0393282175,
0.9671313763,
-0.6696887612,
-0.3267811835,
-1.2054390907,
0.7385428548,
0.1081037968,
-0.0805738121,
0.8381465077,
0.5982002616,
0.8085582256,
-0.3466762602,
0.7629212141,
0.5077376962,
0.3757691681,
-0.7916312814,
0.365491122,
-0.6640624404,
0.4594486654,
0.0373765528,
-0.8876128793,
-0.2122033536,
0.2253393531,
-0.1920814216,
-0.1762356162,
0.8535985947,
1.0373696089,
-0.3656649888,
-0.2284814417,
0.3572123945,
0.5479174852,
0.1593803316,
0.478523761,
1.1886419058,
-0.2439994812,
0.2041961551,
-0.2648477852,
-0.105473198,
-0.2071808726,
-0.9336432219,
-0.7927130461,
-0.3227163255,
-0.47575894,
-0.3824797869,
0.1968139857,
0.6802871227,
0.6547564268,
-0.6770224571,
-0.0832487643,
-0.2306590229,
0.5736147165,
-0.2830580473,
-0.3166956902,
0.1179338172,
-0.5641620159,
-0.6333073974,
0.7903089523,
0.4028637707,
-0.0263039153,
-0.6314191222,
0.1305258572,
0.0749034882,
0.2571108639,
0.6221991181,
0.1711623222,
-0.9331972003,
-0.3361978829,
0.013591595,
-0.1150196791,
0.2935726345,
1.3596230745,
-0.5746098161,
0.1549933702,
0.2985220253,
0.6018773317,
0.4811527431,
-0.2049151212,
0.737878263,
-0.9194190502,
-0.1535058916,
0.0047061858,
0.4892018735,
0.4464208484,
-0.4573997259,
0.5634812117,
0.5926066637,
-0.7143037915,
-0.9191024303,
0.4748410583,
-1.2146162987,
-0.2702175081,
1.3017362356,
-0.0609737523,
-0.4700702429,
-0.0338117778,
-0.386384964,
0.0014701416,
-0.0765859559,
0.8461335301,
0.6607323885,
-0.3452678919,
-0.5177570581,
-0.5369950533,
0.4772562683,
0.6336521506,
-0.8943144679,
0.0875597671,
0.5784758925,
0.7263705134,
0.1697379798,
0.7434058189,
-0.0627935827,
0.236084491,
-0.2736545801,
0.0062333164,
-0.0599470623,
-0.5038502812,
-0.0346434042,
0.0031053494,
0.0545313433,
0.0794796646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14327v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14327v2
|
Subobject-level Image Tokenization
| 2024-02-22T06:47:44 | 2024-04-23T13:41:47 |
Delong Chen, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Jianfeng Liu, Baoyuan Wang, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based vision models typically tokenize images into fixed-size
square patches as input units, which lacks the adaptability to image content
and overlooks the inherent pixel grouping structure. Inspired by the subword
tokenization widely adopted in language models, we propose an image tokenizer
at a subobject level, where the subobjects are represented by semantically
meaningful image segments obtained by segmentation models (e.g., segment
anything models). To implement a learning system based on subobject
tokenization, we first introduced a Direct Segment Anything Model (DirectSAM)
that efficiently produces comprehensive segmentation of subobjects, then embed
subobjects into compact latent vectors and fed them into a large language model
for vision language learning. Empirical results demonstrated that our
subobject-level tokenization significantly facilitates efficient learning of
translating images into object and attribute descriptions compared to the
traditional patch-level tokenization. Codes and models are open-sourced at
https://github.com/ChenDelong1999/subobjects.
|
[
-0.247188136,
-0.604229629,
0.1409097165,
-0.0953566357,
-0.7244704962,
0.1328322589,
0.2445554286,
-0.5281610489,
0.1242771596,
0.349447906,
-0.3070833385,
-0.7133747935,
-0.6453834772,
-0.3460398614,
-0.3797706068,
0.5787397027,
0.2014983147,
0.2268867493,
-0.1800472587,
0.0411124341,
-0.6666395068,
-0.3759947717,
-0.6600145698,
-0.2910088599,
0.5239818692,
0.4249320328,
0.5598301291,
0.8895996213,
0.8125541806,
0.2730156481,
0.0122436127,
-0.0594471693,
-0.192974925,
-0.3425164819,
-0.3814259768,
-0.5190556049,
-0.328820616,
0.0115682799,
0.3913337588,
0.669667542,
-0.0618089773,
0.1353716105,
-0.686747551,
0.3837102354,
-0.4194051921,
0.2088078856,
-0.9390854836,
0.3123119771,
-0.0826724321,
0.1209967583,
-0.5048779249,
0.0754870772,
0.019793449,
-0.7091274261,
0.3836321831,
0.3063901067,
1.0150536299,
0.1740823537,
-0.0204890613,
-0.0576357506,
-0.2197704315,
0.8646469712,
-0.4054190814,
0.517834723,
0.1527310908,
0.4965033531,
0.2168478519,
-0.8144412041,
-0.3654987514,
0.1019246802,
-0.2873789668,
-0.1026330367,
-0.18911843,
0.1227518097,
0.0089270892,
0.4721113443,
-0.1773854494,
0.2275405824,
-0.6758745313,
-0.2037272304,
0.2557246983,
0.1223783195,
0.490988493,
-0.2910317481,
-0.5498762727,
0.1050040051,
-0.7028613091,
0.0569863692,
-0.0230519958,
0.1210210249,
0.2007812858,
0.6523320675,
-0.0552099608,
0.6233161092,
0.4089082778,
-0.320098877,
0.0245016888,
-0.0902620554,
-0.254899621,
-0.2154061198,
0.3928372562,
0.3923215866,
0.1271262914,
-0.2100107223,
-0.4444368482,
-0.0589098632,
0.2420696765,
-0.87286973,
-0.409380734,
0.1072007418,
-0.7978848815,
-0.2762831748,
0.1568599492,
-0.4972263277,
-0.3463969231,
-0.1152838841,
0.349655807,
-0.5938012004,
-0.0954621211,
-0.0307391193,
-0.1028942093,
0.5040344,
0.2222789973,
-0.8620809913,
0.0742396042,
0.6197929978,
0.76742208,
-0.3443795145,
-0.4132472277,
-0.3705118299,
0.1284515113,
-0.5882978439,
0.9710601568,
-0.8653094172,
-0.6857428551,
-0.1675343364,
0.1615981013,
0.1551533192,
-0.8364456892,
-0.1847326308,
-0.6484367251,
-0.0586452857,
0.2016701549,
-0.4574795067,
-0.0971780717,
0.303213954,
-0.3655090332,
0.9985885024,
0.1568370014,
-0.4198203087,
0.6164118052,
-0.63985461,
-0.4584547579,
0.4559240043,
-0.3613069654,
-0.4298585355,
0.4048006237,
0.5357182622,
0.4814319313,
0.0174662005,
0.1375327706,
0.249427706,
-0.3569239676,
0.1122187078,
0.0492541455,
0.1794357151,
-0.1349467635,
-0.1323556602,
0.4234646261,
-0.6695974469,
-0.2959779799,
0.122878246,
-0.3336391747,
-0.2617236078,
0.0680082664,
0.0499432683,
0.0564557314,
0.4102082551,
-0.9259745479,
0.1940365732,
-0.227305606,
0.4353818893,
0.8939021826,
-0.0132115968,
0.7639478445,
0.1281924248,
0.5990876555,
0.6873310804,
0.6817869544,
-0.7104059458,
-0.4164378345,
-1.1493073702,
-0.7104203701,
0.207651034,
0.3119058907,
-0.893017292,
0.2025632709,
-0.3707507551,
-0.5000901222,
-0.2008366287,
-0.0719542429,
0.4941677451,
0.5424897075,
0.6160415411,
-0.4422915578,
-0.5581659675,
-1.0951826572,
0.148995921,
-0.2713452876,
0.0470919572,
0.3727770746,
0.612213254,
-0.3685593605,
1.0069830418,
-0.6093844175,
-0.6220223308,
-0.411228478,
-0.101884082,
0.0556916855,
0.9296598434,
0.4512578547,
-0.818837285,
-0.3732816577,
0.2784577608,
-0.3258643746,
0.1643816978,
-0.0220136605,
-0.1888963729,
0.0042560082,
0.8863489032,
-0.2176394612,
0.6172128916,
0.3010261059,
-0.3554369807,
0.1723036319,
0.0491735414,
-0.1762496382,
-0.9266107678,
-0.0283859503,
-0.2593419254,
-0.3984875083,
-0.4406962395,
0.1426787972,
0.09416008,
-0.2899533808,
-0.7919629812,
0.4945256114,
-0.3048656285,
-0.2860424519,
-0.3865033686,
-0.233878538,
0.0085283956,
0.5289674997,
0.4914145768,
0.5308660865,
0.8383904696,
-0.1964149922,
0.43896842,
0.2067163885,
-0.3596422374,
0.783334136,
-0.9660866857,
0.1274091899,
-0.2388879806,
0.1950273067,
-0.7362259626,
-0.2637534738,
0.1284131557,
-0.2291330695,
0.2799839079,
-0.3120120466,
-0.0310040005,
-0.1606978029,
0.0885556564,
0.6931545138,
0.7033765912,
-0.7321847677,
1.0396534204,
0.5252313614,
0.2098105848,
-0.4804337919,
-0.7837577462,
0.0761476755,
0.219914645,
-0.3042576611,
0.2684312165,
0.3547596931,
0.3220123947,
0.3114509881,
0.0036899296,
-0.100158304,
-0.2577656806,
0.5500243306,
0.508187294,
-0.1333999038,
0.0620086677,
-0.0430354774,
-0.2392839044,
-0.4057276845,
-0.6359653473,
0.5567196012,
-0.1088693887,
-0.4466298521,
-0.3173144758,
0.4189076424,
0.4337715209,
-0.485320121,
0.6201723814,
0.4552479088,
-0.4603728652,
-0.291786015,
-0.3889014125,
0.0245445669,
-0.4574438334,
0.7667452693,
-0.7825111151,
-0.9086151719,
0.4601957798,
-0.017681649,
0.053817343,
0.2131325752,
0.3594531417,
0.0192331932,
0.8749672174,
0.7758204341,
0.1864651889,
0.904507339,
-0.5050588846,
0.3146336973,
-0.8300871849,
-0.7641367912,
0.1666735262,
-0.5758451223,
-0.049241703,
-1.016720295,
0.0719703212,
0.0482617058,
0.0968071967,
0.4518803358,
-0.530147016,
0.9308477044,
0.786352694,
0.3222996593,
-0.0611695237,
-0.0633573085,
-0.1834298521,
0.1418918371,
-0.7025430202,
-0.2520174086,
0.574465394,
0.59799546,
1.0721263885,
-0.4591433704,
0.578176856,
0.2831687033,
0.465228945,
-1.2550541162,
0.7728917599,
-0.408210367,
-0.5569736362,
-0.2020821571,
-0.0960014686,
-0.686496079,
0.2896765471,
-0.0154728824,
-0.4233060479,
0.8201329708,
0.1574786305,
0.0242990013,
0.5411484838,
-0.6240157485,
0.9336915016,
0.01022074,
0.2634783089,
0.0084575163,
-0.4677553475,
-0.0378842875,
-0.0630605221,
0.1369830817,
-0.0847958848,
-0.3072248399,
0.5658529401,
-0.4430646896,
1.0197250843,
-0.4508449733,
0.0306906663,
0.3907541633,
0.1445977986,
0.2180810571,
-0.0938622653,
0.4952984452,
0.5254406333,
0.0102255456,
-0.7560418248,
-0.4787659943,
0.1764585078,
-0.6369182467,
-0.4567647576,
-0.0253331251,
-0.5603275895,
0.0043135285,
0.3520044088,
0.1369573176,
0.5054959059,
-0.1460210681,
0.2711426318,
0.3304020762,
-0.4825914204,
0.1967994422,
0.3912862241,
-0.6586906314,
-0.5060788393,
1.2306940556,
-0.1286114007,
0.1688062549,
0.7230200768,
0.1541072726,
-0.0612640679,
-0.7324995995,
-0.3141126633,
0.0693277493,
-1.0752681494,
-0.5146579146,
-0.3990843296,
-0.1160388812,
-0.4324663281,
-0.3727434874,
-0.5627673864,
-0.3037110567,
-0.2432514727,
-0.426214993,
-0.0878873989,
0.751524806,
-0.0713103935,
0.5265087485,
-0.5733209252,
0.3565139771,
0.5924422741,
0.3044269085,
-0.1191074774,
-0.5561599135,
-0.5283892155,
-0.3117705584,
0.0857664347,
-0.3000460565,
0.1977339089,
0.3600182235,
0.3908070028,
0.4374157786,
-0.3770853579,
0.8675625324,
-0.7616634369,
1.0036952496,
0.593159616,
-1.1820386648,
0.6657933593,
0.0280627534,
0.2643105686,
0.1461214423,
-0.1186462268,
-0.5864329934,
-0.314658463,
-0.1722451746,
-0.7827343941,
0.7980366349,
-0.2108866721,
0.3214641213,
-0.250395447,
0.4024964571,
0.2299461812,
0.045822233,
-0.6772518754,
-0.0608421266,
-0.7237359285,
-0.4220995605,
0.1590897292,
-0.3552650809,
0.1301843077,
-0.2166852504,
0.5308175683,
-0.2850708067,
0.2675802112,
0.2230712026,
-0.3419703543,
-0.0293451529,
-0.0850818306,
0.3123568892,
0.585503757,
0.0568965338,
0.5146303773,
-0.0247567464,
-0.6858532429,
0.1658968776,
-0.3387644887,
-0.4808287024,
0.0288373623,
0.3562492728,
1.0346108675,
0.1203707904,
-0.7370486259,
0.6520627737,
0.0969047025,
-0.2382715344,
0.2113324255,
-0.0216668174,
-0.1065923795,
0.2953206897,
0.5815303922,
0.1303603351,
-0.2037284821,
-0.5116848946,
0.1454533935,
0.4190588295,
-0.7236045003,
-0.3847487867,
0.5147961974,
0.2234363109,
-0.2847003341,
0.4186741412,
0.1311964542,
-0.6849153638,
0.7003437281,
0.5554404259,
0.6916299462,
-0.0170597062,
0.5598742962,
0.1921166629,
0.6730191708,
0.2410145998,
0.1160122305,
-0.1102720648,
-0.733556211,
-0.306822598,
-0.889277041,
-0.3185452521,
-0.1471962631,
-0.3146065176,
-0.0481348038,
-0.5939386487,
-0.0208842959,
-0.1499538273,
-0.642762661,
-0.4950101376,
0.661006093,
0.1624217629,
1.0837827921,
-0.6029376388,
0.868934691,
1.1180599928,
-0.5412887335,
-0.6762804389,
-0.3719370365,
-0.9129272699,
-1.169692874,
1.0999150276,
0.1446620673,
0.1135166362,
0.0851430967,
-0.5794437528,
-0.7392294407,
1.0675011873,
0.2519259155,
-0.3227715492,
-0.2299494892,
0.5000013709,
0.3080852628,
-0.6382667422,
-0.2365954518,
0.1409455687,
0.1642544419,
0.4465221167,
-0.4511535764,
0.0757892728,
-0.0880092606,
0.5803845525,
0.1536872983,
-0.5439224243,
0.8368315101,
-0.0386820845,
-0.3735330403,
0.1812948287,
0.8100845814,
-0.3174892068,
-0.0195187535,
0.6697837114,
0.6299079061,
0.1030436456,
-0.1526275277,
0.7121747732,
-0.1171584278,
0.4126676023,
0.968262136,
0.2127726227,
0.7205764055,
0.8786480427,
-0.0453740247,
0.680156827,
0.5383195877,
-0.2673615217,
0.6556952,
0.1024708599,
0.1051058546,
-0.5529893041,
-0.4674401879,
0.0431888364,
0.4620238841,
0.2562376261,
-0.5668614507,
-0.0225999001,
0.4766257107,
-0.648406446,
-0.3135254681,
-0.52930969,
0.8435740471,
0.0512064733,
-0.4154877067,
0.0932584703,
0.1959485263,
0.6527635455,
-0.4464410245,
0.0059677144,
-0.5338142514,
0.2425199598,
-0.3368991911,
-0.5902927518,
0.412725091,
0.1367100626,
-0.0769587606,
-0.0731789321,
0.7539038658,
-0.3873129189,
-0.86323452,
-0.0662652627,
0.2597075999,
0.1677817404,
0.0559122004,
-0.5955526829,
0.0493174568,
-0.3794824481,
-0.1006204188,
0.1250434816,
0.3524820209,
0.0980956927,
0.3432305455,
0.6036506891,
0.0378528237,
0.4943240583,
0.1145777479,
0.9186678529,
-0.4086084068,
-0.2935079038,
-0.6505070329,
0.4928880036,
-0.0136342021,
0.0489266589,
0.5286792517,
0.5922551751,
1.0623527765,
-0.3375571966,
0.4474386275,
-0.2802740037,
0.0976000279,
-0.4163549542,
0.2888724804,
-0.6927030683,
-0.1547493637,
-0.0734416097,
-0.7732219696,
-0.548104763,
0.7053921223,
-0.3356246948,
-0.2476409376,
0.5312176347,
0.7884676456,
-0.3073510826,
-0.636077106,
0.7456437349,
-0.086718455,
0.3759983182,
0.3225277066,
0.9754585624,
-0.4977082014,
0.6727494597,
-0.3692484796,
-0.2361749858,
-0.0160273612,
-0.6056029201,
-1.1528553963,
-0.4617544115,
-0.4601203799,
0.0540798418,
-0.0734958053,
0.5226210952,
1.1127434969,
-0.9237713814,
-0.0010458335,
-0.41691643,
0.1527782679,
0.0396050923,
-0.2039801776,
0.3831410706,
-0.320610106,
-0.932879746,
0.1808634549,
0.6712496281,
0.1228448451,
-0.4669342935,
0.0052549406,
-0.0770305395,
0.4131762981,
0.5854755044,
0.1117381081,
-0.7945341468,
-0.4656473696,
0.2986325324,
-0.0584291928,
0.2413359135,
0.9880475998,
-0.7121475339,
0.4115183353,
0.4081273079,
0.6392679214,
0.2273644954,
0.1893113554,
0.1746422797,
-0.8948994279,
0.4508429468,
-0.0808175206,
0.5602608323,
0.5417333245,
-0.1946467459,
0.4241241515,
0.4316929579,
-0.1178674772,
-0.6429232955,
0.5627507567,
-0.8117460608,
-0.535081327,
0.8547422886,
-0.601834476,
-0.5281847119,
0.1090265885,
-0.6702548862,
0.0125593375,
-0.2223969847,
0.4218000472,
0.1629233956,
0.0419717357,
-0.3981473148,
0.5115311146,
-0.0438739359,
0.3137168586,
-0.7319728732,
-0.3315365911,
0.5000608563,
0.1271558851,
0.3429436982,
0.5201318264,
-0.2444048524,
0.1826522499,
0.186740607,
0.1454403847,
-0.3209180832,
-0.4521099627,
0.0560662299,
0.2183582336,
-0.151404649,
-0.6924418807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14320v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14320v5
|
Triad: A Framework Leveraging a Multi-Role LLM-based Agent to Solve Knowledge Base Question Answering
| 2024-02-22T06:23:37 | 2024-04-16T02:46:10 |
Chang Zong, Yuchen Yan, Weiming Lu, Jian Shao, Eliot Huang, Heng Chang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recent progress with LLM-based agents has shown promising results across
various tasks. However, their use in answering questions from knowledge bases
remains largely unexplored. Implementing a KBQA system using traditional
methods is challenging due to the shortage of task-specific training data and
the complexity of creating task-focused model structures. In this paper, we
present Triad, a unified framework that utilizes an LLM-based agent with three
roles for KBQA tasks. The agent is assigned three roles to tackle different
KBQA subtasks: agent as a generalist for mastering various subtasks, as a
decision maker for the selection of candidates, and as an advisor for answering
questions with knowledge. Our KBQA framework is executed in four phases,
involving the collaboration of the agent's multiple roles. We evaluated the
performance of our framework using three benchmark datasets, and the results
show that our framework outperforms state-of-the-art systems on the LC-QuAD and
YAGO-QA benchmarks, yielding F1 scores of 11.8% and 20.7%, respectively.
|
[
-0.4629965723,
-0.5559413433,
0.6816675663,
0.1217722222,
-0.0255087558,
0.2803200185,
0.3571485281,
-0.257494241,
-0.0113254283,
0.5613776445,
-0.6931768656,
-0.5857541561,
-0.1730545908,
0.2839533985,
-0.1680370718,
0.7014890909,
0.0089213792,
0.387640506,
-0.3582139015,
-0.0402138643,
-0.7708554268,
-0.5030323863,
-0.6064189076,
-0.5076559782,
0.4053439498,
0.7794553041,
0.8246303797,
0.2829037309,
0.0875737891,
0.2278038859,
0.0951477066,
0.1931424588,
-0.4216976762,
0.3625428081,
0.0830667689,
-0.6756352186,
-0.6109110713,
-0.1328782588,
0.3792109489,
0.5498097539,
-0.2387410253,
0.2501547337,
-0.1353235394,
0.6313064694,
-0.5711333752,
0.2233762294,
-0.5429321527,
-0.0714101121,
0.2609577775,
-0.2044920921,
-0.3294700384,
-0.2510810792,
0.3159303069,
-1.03885746,
-0.1657704562,
0.1069654301,
0.5344199538,
0.1049805507,
-1.1152043343,
-0.2481064796,
-0.4106753469,
0.5312787294,
-0.3907086849,
0.3196861744,
0.1257862449,
0.6712042093,
-0.2597501278,
-0.5270736217,
-0.3622176647,
-0.0318670794,
-0.0496485643,
0.2384593338,
0.098531194,
0.3488608897,
-0.1313945353,
0.1712618321,
-0.5736585259,
-0.2042718977,
-0.2530944049,
-0.2987954021,
0.2638520002,
0.4265625477,
0.2361986786,
-0.3266353011,
-0.6012482047,
0.1877157986,
-0.5642886162,
0.3282135129,
0.1455132514,
0.325469166,
0.2793267965,
0.4596632719,
-0.4574795961,
0.7266173959,
0.3106624186,
-0.1471209526,
-0.1422615051,
-0.2043780684,
-0.3868338764,
-0.1807210445,
0.2508093119,
0.5005530119,
0.122062631,
-0.5482438803,
-0.1807288527,
-0.2877364457,
0.4222468734,
-0.3463434279,
0.0467463396,
0.5009546876,
-0.1757365316,
-0.2777381837,
-0.1456209868,
-0.3883205652,
-0.5433366299,
-0.4545407295,
0.7890400887,
-0.2872719765,
-0.3839448988,
0.1350492835,
-0.1947093755,
0.6746914387,
0.3507497609,
-0.3619334698,
0.6021606326,
0.508864224,
0.3673158288,
-0.1794732213,
-0.1802739203,
-0.4699956179,
0.3524869084,
-0.407206893,
0.5630586147,
-0.1686062962,
-0.3208984137,
-0.0958760083,
-0.1696164608,
-0.1637388468,
-0.4361493587,
-0.0239480138,
-1.1540919542,
-0.0987516418,
-0.6201221943,
-0.3968086541,
-0.2792143226,
0.6903916001,
-0.7609359622,
1.0229740143,
0.4367584288,
-0.5354198217,
0.3103948534,
-0.5574859381,
0.0298285093,
0.2080993652,
-0.2627753913,
0.0502224006,
-0.4742426872,
0.3237630129,
0.4474541545,
-0.6929080486,
0.4646522701,
-0.0328559652,
-0.5783347487,
0.278644383,
0.1329252422,
0.768977344,
-0.0502905808,
-0.2277898937,
0.044885546,
-0.6364949346,
0.3898201883,
-0.3834992945,
-0.3373189867,
-0.2020116001,
-0.3785247803,
-0.1317636371,
0.4700720012,
0.1645332575,
-0.4372219741,
0.3034811914,
-0.0348977484,
-0.1391151696,
0.7274044752,
0.4260991812,
0.561447382,
-0.5268681049,
0.8945106864,
0.2509562969,
0.3147020936,
0.6538931727,
-0.3126326799,
-0.7462508082,
-0.2126952112,
0.2209416479,
0.6664833426,
-1.2746579647,
0.120509401,
-0.1896098852,
-0.544290185,
-0.3372707963,
0.2073511332,
0.5477356315,
0.4800807238,
0.5005156398,
-0.0641501918,
-0.3741850853,
-1.1876158714,
-0.1605143249,
-0.4135918915,
0.0596330687,
0.2791340351,
0.3956735432,
-0.0287603252,
1.2303636074,
-0.3860524595,
-0.4075324833,
-0.4468842447,
0.1286991835,
0.2280775607,
0.1910725087,
0.3131432235,
-0.9374766946,
-0.4278648794,
-0.1217919663,
-0.7420383096,
-0.1510055661,
-0.0564442128,
-0.4772755206,
0.1193343848,
0.4447918534,
-0.6449535489,
0.1266979873,
0.2825437784,
-0.5368814468,
0.7341815829,
0.3715701103,
0.3632947803,
-1.2765202522,
0.3093256354,
-0.4576187134,
-0.3225852549,
-0.9689136147,
0.1508262455,
-0.1118670031,
0.1886120737,
-0.4011445045,
0.4040905535,
-0.5062555671,
-0.3110331297,
-0.0291021243,
0.233776316,
-0.090789862,
0.921449244,
-0.292833209,
0.6887074113,
0.480589658,
-0.7559298873,
0.4865001142,
0.4207487106,
-0.0035951913,
0.8736653924,
-0.3747073412,
0.0721970499,
-0.2013117522,
0.2269575894,
-0.8824252486,
-0.1146714389,
0.4697882831,
-0.3309696913,
0.0939040035,
-0.2267105132,
-0.6185520887,
-0.1304343939,
-0.2260724902,
0.3403557837,
-0.0207769461,
-0.1780720353,
1.1996010542,
0.4017268717,
0.1318313181,
-1.0670301914,
-0.3802093863,
-0.203902334,
0.0173445512,
-0.6322777867,
0.2499221265,
-0.064730078,
-0.099238202,
0.2161307186,
-0.6903626919,
-0.415861249,
0.3307324946,
0.3789079785,
0.3523572683,
-0.2501379848,
0.2311726213,
-0.0432446562,
-0.1693875939,
0.0848233402,
-0.3662439287,
0.3373212218,
-0.4017135501,
-0.1438134015,
-0.0356003009,
0.4442616999,
0.7151216269,
0.0251481682,
0.5587558746,
0.3228764832,
-0.1863690615,
-0.1386288851,
-0.4422101378,
-0.0133540025,
-0.4369430542,
0.3825392723,
-0.5081762671,
-1.0998016596,
0.4767616093,
0.1438270062,
0.2198553681,
0.1397874355,
0.4089974463,
-0.0113297049,
0.7661280632,
0.5409900546,
-0.2486523837,
-0.1495096534,
-0.1320213974,
-0.0766646862,
-0.7729266882,
-0.3532901406,
-0.1991000026,
-0.2697670162,
-0.2601819336,
-0.3829694092,
1.0363593102,
0.2938994467,
-0.5935705304,
0.2113004923,
-0.2280188054,
0.2999413311,
0.6819690466,
0.2376011461,
0.7253379226,
-0.4434853792,
-0.2519669831,
0.6151996851,
-0.8045004606,
-0.4248853922,
1.2241593599,
-0.0265320502,
0.4495103061,
0.4251824915,
0.4955216944,
0.2651766539,
0.3290715218,
-0.6161916852,
0.9004547596,
0.3905771077,
-1.1576037407,
-0.5671678185,
-0.3931882381,
-0.6065075994,
0.633687079,
-0.3024212718,
-0.6124140024,
0.1138110757,
0.1633854806,
-0.3744992912,
0.1543452889,
-0.3672409654,
0.8747069836,
-0.0755129308,
-0.0309336875,
-0.0286951102,
-0.9924911857,
0.570123136,
-0.0083459467,
0.0813996643,
-0.1402670592,
-0.2891249657,
0.5963266492,
-0.2033294141,
0.743704915,
-0.4175997078,
0.0901181176,
0.2941229641,
0.2420109659,
0.1372944266,
0.3381892145,
-0.1436620504,
-0.3745544553,
0.6508767009,
-0.4577839673,
-0.7699314356,
0.2702790499,
-1.0396847725,
-0.8206270933,
-0.4799849391,
-0.711371839,
-0.9386359453,
0.3851013184,
-0.1035468057,
0.4547327459,
-0.3016895056,
0.2141692042,
0.4032350779,
0.1607876718,
-0.0213310588,
0.8093717098,
-0.2649864852,
-0.4673670232,
0.5002711415,
-0.148973614,
0.4621145427,
0.5539036989,
-0.2142200023,
-0.158311978,
-0.2824590504,
-0.4476642013,
-0.05245094,
-0.9136132002,
-0.6098440886,
-0.6345931292,
-0.2024965733,
-0.3720372319,
-0.0633137971,
-0.026658643,
-0.3951936662,
0.0580251589,
-0.0287988856,
0.1125139222,
0.6913129687,
0.1148256063,
0.4459531307,
-0.6183422208,
0.6452499628,
0.7799306512,
0.283259511,
-0.0279946029,
0.0754661113,
-0.2374895811,
-0.0274802651,
-0.4088889062,
-1.114653945,
-0.1930189878,
-0.1083163396,
0.8470199108,
-0.0704690441,
0.2963014245,
0.5823103786,
0.1202701256,
0.640345037,
-0.039587263,
-0.9786512256,
-0.0178758595,
-0.5193784833,
0.4430893064,
0.9661858082,
0.4534644783,
-0.7592627406,
-0.6347306371,
-0.2423706055,
-0.7652156353,
0.9707019925,
0.3400375247,
-0.5905759335,
0.3240186572,
0.4880963564,
-0.1294646561,
0.5908483267,
-0.7932187319,
-0.4941437542,
-0.0875584036,
-0.1300347149,
0.2747664154,
-0.0620842874,
-0.2130329758,
0.0144387782,
0.8809359074,
-0.4885928631,
0.2165962905,
0.3572190404,
-0.479937315,
-0.1283776909,
0.5004940033,
-0.0081510553,
0.5899060965,
-0.1564888954,
-0.0371321961,
0.2982649803,
-0.3385820389,
0.3831244409,
-0.0172094442,
-0.2327357084,
-0.3352933228,
0.2498039156,
0.2036830336,
0.4067566395,
-0.4855750203,
0.5345666409,
-0.0347613432,
-0.4485585988,
-0.1343283355,
0.0946422517,
0.406648308,
0.452129662,
0.6150960326,
-0.2056659013,
0.340276897,
-0.4038002789,
0.2180558741,
0.3992084861,
-0.3143160641,
-0.023301322,
0.234144479,
0.2728123069,
0.2335892469,
0.4506840408,
0.0339436717,
-0.7428088784,
0.8837407827,
0.3049964905,
0.5941446424,
-0.1918110698,
0.6201679111,
-0.0186246485,
0.3302355111,
0.0053881174,
0.7763695717,
-0.0913538188,
-0.767306447,
-0.0252206307,
-0.3852768838,
-0.5224150419,
-0.0056417924,
-0.7639543414,
0.0848280564,
-0.2079491019,
-0.0268668234,
-0.3176602125,
0.3096086979,
-0.6518350244,
0.150778085,
-0.1872879416,
1.0049272776,
-0.5003768206,
0.5406875014,
0.7950296402,
-0.3914527893,
-1.2621458769,
-0.0189108886,
0.2504379749,
-0.675996244,
0.4982056916,
0.1269484758,
-0.5169892311,
0.378661871,
-0.389482528,
-0.8809235096,
1.7717857361,
0.2584094405,
0.0741359591,
-0.4962118566,
0.394915849,
0.430016607,
-0.483427912,
0.1237524226,
0.4625757635,
0.6447697878,
0.1244513467,
-0.8484461308,
0.2797503471,
-0.1624751985,
-0.2024605274,
-0.0236935299,
-0.5741409063,
0.700101912,
0.1661339253,
-0.226918757,
0.3177175224,
0.3395133317,
0.4334740341,
0.1275447607,
0.8810073733,
0.0555425249,
0.6567959189,
0.2264692038,
0.5618517995,
-0.5311284661,
0.1159966812,
0.9265703559,
-0.307018131,
0.3399957716,
0.4428662658,
0.1553665102,
0.5699946284,
0.4580970407,
0.2797486782,
0.3752368093,
0.3299936354,
-0.3025678694,
-0.7231684327,
0.0058669113,
-0.0633167475,
0.3187229931,
0.1336946785,
0.1853676289,
-0.5349343419,
-0.2251812369,
-0.370593816,
-0.2113711685,
-0.5110370517,
0.6477597356,
0.1789729744,
-0.8994857669,
0.2819490433,
-0.0760656521,
0.1651795805,
-0.6702542305,
-0.0682122484,
-0.1439349055,
0.0228648968,
-0.171623975,
-0.6948832273,
-0.0993336439,
-0.3422716856,
-0.1375283599,
-0.1368825287,
0.5633144379,
-0.4569073021,
-0.1776526421,
0.3067077696,
1.0432124138,
-0.2408836782,
-0.0244654566,
-0.5932145715,
-0.5332716703,
-0.4089300632,
-0.128909111,
0.1112521365,
0.4378051162,
-0.1624893844,
0.9373127818,
0.3658410609,
-0.2227858007,
-0.0686654374,
-0.1285275519,
1.0659345388,
-0.5882592797,
-0.5997814536,
-0.218006894,
0.4550320208,
0.0079843532,
-0.3232094944,
0.5633061528,
0.4864905179,
0.4383098781,
0.0197082646,
0.6504486203,
-0.2214155793,
0.510674715,
-0.5188159347,
0.6033056378,
-0.6162364483,
0.3138817549,
-0.2079310268,
-0.5391355157,
-0.1518941373,
0.0152136022,
0.0604009628,
0.1425869316,
0.7510156631,
0.991940856,
0.2457322031,
0.063989453,
0.3687365353,
0.1139406413,
0.2545736134,
0.9261441231,
0.9361155033,
-0.2772612572,
0.851914525,
0.0707937852,
0.0156472586,
-0.2029259801,
-0.3900030553,
-1.0337312222,
-0.7325364351,
0.1096571311,
-0.3084577918,
0.3142679632,
1.0512923002,
0.5973569155,
-0.5604870915,
-0.4361653626,
0.0179186128,
0.388114363,
-0.4041070044,
-0.2237967849,
0.112534225,
-0.1883779019,
-0.1426126659,
0.3166458011,
0.0978094041,
-0.3796767294,
-0.3236826956,
-0.0441893712,
-0.3737515211,
-0.0418404527,
0.3666756749,
0.1724696457,
-0.586858809,
-0.4309159219,
0.6055468917,
-0.5283998251,
-0.1222296208,
0.949904263,
-0.9240109921,
0.1544755697,
0.256518662,
0.7191381454,
0.2774261236,
0.195398286,
0.9631628394,
-0.6903654337,
-0.6245966554,
0.3648737967,
-0.080877766,
-0.0817409009,
-0.458414644,
0.458634764,
0.069212921,
-0.4686280489,
-0.5387315154,
0.3410179317,
-1.2807568312,
-0.4149527848,
1.1650958061,
0.1142422408,
-0.1508786678,
-0.8971297145,
-0.2010618001,
0.2676843703,
-0.408167243,
0.3996445239,
0.6570891142,
-0.3447003961,
-0.0540117957,
-0.4703280926,
0.5501481891,
0.2793457508,
-0.7430045009,
-0.1021988243,
0.6547532678,
0.5311632156,
-0.0322926007,
1.0912828445,
-0.008340437,
0.7674772143,
-0.2920791507,
0.1324710548,
-0.3793070316,
-0.5382860899,
-0.1077961028,
0.4122921824,
0.1651497781,
-0.0878554657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14318v1
|
Assessing generalization capability of text ranking models in Polish
| 2024-02-22T06:21:41 | 2024-02-22T06:21:41 |
Sławomir Dadas, Małgorzata Grębowiec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is becoming an increasingly popular
technique for integrating internal knowledge bases with large language models.
In a typical RAG pipeline, three models are used, responsible for the
retrieval, reranking, and generation stages. In this article, we focus on the
reranking problem for the Polish language, examining the performance of
rerankers and comparing their results with available retrieval models. We
conduct a comprehensive evaluation of existing models and those trained by us,
utilizing a benchmark of 41 diverse information retrieval tasks for the Polish
language. The results of our experiments show that most models struggle with
out-of-domain generalization. However, a combination of effective optimization
method and a large training dataset allows for building rerankers that are both
compact in size and capable of generalization. The best of our models
establishes a new state-of-the-art for reranking in the Polish language,
outperforming existing models with up to 30 times more parameters.
|
[
-0.2215994745,
-0.6293462515,
0.7656621933,
0.0940933228,
-0.3320157528,
0.24179326,
-0.4320146441,
-0.3200339973,
0.1516677141,
0.5457421541,
-0.15507406,
-0.5466457009,
-0.8571142554,
0.2606282234,
-0.565007329,
1.0395418406,
-0.0687628165,
0.116906628,
-0.2525513172,
0.0625221729,
-0.5848863721,
-0.816693902,
-0.240077123,
-0.372381568,
0.3623453379,
0.394864738,
0.7013775706,
0.3142381012,
0.8154205084,
0.4093538523,
-0.134745121,
0.2337706536,
-0.6716492772,
0.4744106531,
-0.3008912802,
-0.4809449613,
-0.3648042083,
0.1527141184,
0.957102716,
0.8559581637,
-0.102992177,
0.3534509838,
-0.0851993263,
0.9259567857,
-0.7791526914,
-0.1322570741,
-0.9009283781,
-0.1327970773,
-0.4350892603,
-0.0619154461,
-0.7517839074,
-0.3334482312,
-0.0113362903,
-0.7249864936,
0.7224257588,
0.276682198,
0.7894343734,
-0.1514684707,
-0.4389056861,
-0.3902767003,
-0.8348701596,
1.07072258,
-0.4374138713,
0.4985246658,
0.4103785455,
0.4394674301,
-0.1837942898,
-1.0042706728,
-0.0847197473,
-0.3164461553,
0.1369929761,
0.0819265023,
-0.2131635994,
-0.2687097788,
0.0315203369,
0.6419215202,
-0.5060955286,
-0.190086171,
-0.404111594,
0.0051237061,
0.6402768493,
0.1538228393,
0.4469423592,
0.0579307526,
-0.1960236281,
-0.0955385268,
-0.4735894501,
-0.1494872868,
0.6152834892,
0.5174379945,
0.499917984,
0.6353690624,
-0.5145648122,
0.9270101786,
0.2153863609,
0.061137367,
0.5399119854,
-0.4720366299,
-0.0905132145,
-0.4235677719,
0.5124502778,
0.3539255261,
0.3489702344,
-0.6778448224,
-0.3113396168,
-0.0367564447,
0.7486853004,
-0.4618506432,
-0.0874116942,
-0.104541637,
-0.6199582219,
-0.4633348584,
0.2553596497,
-0.6833103895,
-0.0389685705,
0.0427927412,
0.5191904902,
-0.1893180311,
-0.2427634597,
0.2234932482,
-0.4158288538,
0.0556943342,
0.0234161448,
-0.9726583958,
0.5133091807,
0.7663708925,
0.5772954822,
-0.4175038636,
-0.2234504968,
-0.3640453517,
0.0064368746,
-0.8235437274,
0.9106880426,
-0.7593237758,
-0.4121692479,
0.0259506088,
0.0621037856,
-0.2635396719,
-0.7862993479,
0.949764967,
-0.895324409,
0.2548823357,
-0.0466543175,
-0.6610328555,
-0.0514729396,
0.1781428605,
-0.549115181,
1.1362696886,
0.3141205311,
-0.7607589364,
0.5045661926,
-0.1845947206,
-0.0386978015,
0.0891284868,
0.2465542406,
-0.4686073959,
0.5049942136,
-0.0739736035,
0.2354632765,
-0.4074866176,
0.3147971034,
-0.1796916574,
-0.4474109709,
-0.1337137222,
-0.0020864597,
0.466573596,
0.2078653127,
0.0364740714,
-0.0376101099,
-0.513661325,
0.3727343082,
0.0729204491,
-0.5063331723,
-0.7395941615,
-0.0753147081,
0.0840163305,
0.1321606785,
0.3606432974,
-0.934253633,
0.3312912583,
-0.6689789891,
0.0930721685,
0.3345511258,
0.0920043811,
0.6538236141,
-0.1750376225,
0.5721253753,
-0.4736067653,
0.1794636846,
0.3071517348,
-0.775351882,
-0.6867769957,
0.1874623448,
0.9683366418,
0.5032920837,
-0.692152679,
0.1776841879,
-0.4900829494,
-0.7302232981,
-0.4273160994,
0.1739463806,
0.5330719352,
0.3607510328,
0.2838973701,
-0.1241289079,
-0.3967370987,
-1.1425249577,
-0.6416950226,
0.0027596713,
-0.1853143722,
0.2876990139,
0.4563934505,
-0.2097783983,
0.8330358863,
-0.3115392327,
-0.2436018437,
-0.5296365023,
0.1963875145,
0.4653507471,
0.2572214305,
0.3892993629,
-1.162222147,
-0.7766472697,
0.1178076491,
-0.6212956309,
-0.1066492423,
0.5293669701,
-0.0656599924,
0.2287603021,
0.4851827621,
-0.0741859972,
0.2816034257,
0.6420443654,
-0.3723095357,
0.4756991863,
-0.4895281196,
0.2964434028,
-0.8745459914,
0.2443229705,
-0.3095266223,
-0.349171102,
-0.9178395867,
0.4972442985,
0.2229977399,
-0.1718688458,
-0.2396092862,
0.5303456783,
-0.5880053043,
-0.1956928521,
-0.3793902695,
0.3479712009,
-0.1236257851,
0.2022717148,
-0.2475273162,
0.8855995536,
0.1990388334,
-0.5947881937,
0.1810716242,
0.2490669042,
-0.5189172029,
-0.0122969262,
-0.6425943375,
0.0661632568,
-0.1062124148,
-0.009287213,
-1.1605018377,
-0.1194777861,
-0.1733333319,
-0.6041815281,
0.3955037296,
-0.3958507776,
-0.4891115427,
-0.4264546335,
-0.3058513701,
0.4281492233,
0.5493353605,
-0.3893051445,
0.6843238473,
0.6007267833,
-0.4577606022,
-0.7162747383,
-0.3392291367,
0.0813621432,
-0.205211103,
-0.7341789603,
0.6231873035,
-0.0227977131,
-0.4019465744,
-0.0361276157,
0.0122732092,
-0.3010195196,
0.0088153556,
-0.0617012382,
0.2195853144,
0.1128306463,
0.2924449146,
-0.0141590163,
-0.2379344851,
-0.1859454364,
0.1251474321,
0.6288761497,
-0.155237332,
-0.1617517173,
0.2727722526,
0.4287399948,
0.3322701752,
-0.293476969,
0.6969479918,
0.3137463331,
-0.0626115128,
-0.1044481993,
-0.7236027122,
0.1490467191,
-0.421407789,
0.3837471306,
-0.3635918498,
-0.6935797334,
0.6279958487,
-0.3016182184,
0.0055381414,
0.7333554626,
0.6034878492,
0.0686859936,
1.364743948,
0.9204054475,
-0.0092062717,
0.329538852,
-0.2643510401,
0.0827156007,
-1.0162050724,
-0.0786653161,
-0.6970726252,
-0.1912553012,
-0.8925537467,
-0.357521683,
0.3591087162,
0.2135027796,
0.0684075728,
0.0581883378,
-0.5192546248,
0.5910404325,
0.4949489832,
-0.086542584,
0.4270737767,
0.1620163471,
-0.3016952276,
-0.0479762182,
-0.7822605968,
-0.5952492952,
1.3768291473,
0.146426037,
0.49273929,
0.2548814118,
0.939376235,
0.3628008366,
0.4568693042,
-0.6417785287,
0.3724756539,
-0.8568376899,
-0.842330575,
-0.4495188892,
-0.4127110541,
-1.2144850492,
0.6068399549,
-0.3865672052,
-0.393178761,
0.3289747238,
-0.0159837268,
0.0341376811,
0.2521440983,
-0.5505003929,
0.6515218616,
0.2373038232,
-0.181449458,
-0.1371664256,
-0.4816667438,
0.3962001801,
-0.2631024122,
0.4733783603,
-0.0627125874,
-0.1941850632,
0.8479136825,
-0.2355265319,
0.2386348546,
-0.215090245,
0.0276680216,
0.0191273019,
-0.1550911963,
0.4724074304,
-0.3017860651,
-0.3310148418,
-0.1486831903,
-0.2494549155,
-0.3393927217,
-0.5195885897,
0.6154011488,
-0.5011146069,
-0.5909237266,
-0.1777404845,
-0.3567399383,
-0.4121176302,
0.4536908865,
0.6618129611,
0.5283561349,
-0.4131162763,
0.4359160364,
0.7514613867,
-0.1947111338,
0.1742436886,
0.6253759265,
-0.57076931,
-0.4037443697,
1.1561405659,
0.2340399027,
0.241735056,
0.1751829386,
0.2316655219,
-0.1591950208,
-0.729495585,
-0.2943496704,
0.301646322,
-0.5708534122,
-0.2420414239,
-0.5586756468,
-0.1626134962,
-0.4277540445,
-0.0015113546,
-0.4950506091,
-0.5517892838,
0.1735982448,
0.1351422518,
-0.1348587573,
1.1168366671,
0.1184414178,
0.0882937908,
-0.5854367614,
0.4990480542,
0.2461547107,
0.6069267392,
-0.1532592773,
-0.6995820403,
-0.3833733797,
-0.3690075576,
-0.2730475962,
-0.8404615521,
0.5167137384,
0.0817081779,
0.8501106501,
-0.2492628545,
0.0079366481,
0.1540942788,
-0.9049779773,
0.6891605854,
-0.2726753652,
-0.6885274649,
0.3472672999,
-0.5122001171,
0.1273611337,
0.7738483548,
0.1479371488,
-0.3791078031,
-0.7303036451,
-0.7446967363,
-1.0386366844,
0.4054700732,
0.1279917955,
0.3031338751,
-0.201190412,
0.4664571285,
0.0189487953,
0.0585046187,
-0.4432818592,
-0.3667143285,
0.1147644073,
0.0434629172,
-0.2488559932,
-0.7596187592,
0.2105528414,
0.0117166052,
0.8290194273,
0.2417079657,
0.0932416841,
0.1605155617,
-0.1546486169,
-0.157319665,
0.4773649871,
0.6116263866,
0.7561616302,
-0.3311058283,
-0.3642810881,
0.1653067023,
-0.6056158543,
0.2629359365,
-0.1122163832,
-0.1983184069,
0.3850337863,
0.2371869385,
0.3571000397,
0.5160422921,
-0.3216610253,
0.6198458672,
-0.2275384068,
-0.4258288443,
-0.2889350951,
-0.1086333469,
-0.1160220504,
-0.0153299775,
0.5723239779,
-0.1668516248,
0.6298058033,
-0.3962313533,
0.2540828586,
0.5651398897,
-0.0488296933,
0.0045911474,
0.4217860997,
0.1559344679,
-0.4098083377,
0.630084157,
-0.0654263794,
-0.6094084382,
0.4365514219,
0.6241689324,
0.6792958379,
-0.3129606545,
0.2132381052,
0.4085852504,
0.3174059987,
-0.3421490788,
0.2426978499,
0.1859147847,
-0.7513039112,
-0.4644137919,
-0.5637578964,
-0.5551445484,
-0.21556288,
-0.9661021233,
-0.0079167793,
0.0005924331,
-0.6577538848,
-0.102774635,
0.3090333045,
-0.4292959869,
0.112381056,
-0.283570528,
0.9943329692,
-0.845739007,
0.6806229353,
0.797786057,
-0.1617074907,
-0.4353207052,
-0.0806686059,
-0.5008559227,
-0.5764767528,
1.0495545864,
-0.1447602659,
-0.2576262951,
0.0061648502,
-0.2819178402,
-1.1119295359,
0.8218702078,
0.1237856522,
-0.4345489442,
-0.179044649,
-0.2144597024,
0.702011466,
-0.4356236756,
-0.070592761,
0.3688497543,
0.3780475557,
-0.3534948826,
-1.0932663679,
-0.4575302601,
-0.4265491664,
0.2898477316,
0.5635591745,
-0.5072222352,
1.0319817066,
0.0839890391,
-0.3096819818,
0.3747019172,
0.4646927416,
0.2930091619,
0.2131979764,
0.5284014344,
0.5724145174,
0.5922363997,
0.0057861991,
1.43661201,
-0.4072546959,
0.4987747371,
1.0395702124,
-0.0147610549,
1.2005460262,
0.2612840831,
-0.1315724701,
0.7372903824,
0.2202173769,
0.0330840908,
0.5187849402,
0.1416122615,
-0.0350801125,
-0.5098264217,
0.1232942715,
-0.4148208499,
0.4187473953,
0.1167675406,
-0.6717982888,
-0.3687379658,
-0.0052645626,
-0.2851285934,
0.4462452829,
-0.4229852259,
0.8270418644,
-0.3441940248,
-0.6525393128,
0.5265610814,
0.1882900149,
0.5865058899,
-0.5329159498,
-0.0737006664,
-0.1569967419,
0.2602880001,
0.0946750492,
-0.6802834868,
0.252838999,
0.0892248303,
-0.6740726233,
-0.2748342156,
1.0258488655,
-0.3933691978,
-0.8087018728,
0.3566021025,
0.6277974248,
0.331736207,
0.023353003,
-0.4505504668,
0.05419337,
-0.0705115497,
-0.2078025788,
0.5653621554,
0.2165868878,
-0.1952114254,
0.7412737012,
0.4521740973,
0.2492524236,
0.1476706415,
0.1143781915,
0.7411234975,
-0.4154437482,
-0.2886960208,
-0.5652985573,
0.2495892495,
-0.1806762367,
-0.1870775968,
1.1572761536,
0.6903373599,
0.7094218731,
-0.1889258325,
0.505267024,
0.2844879329,
1.252351284,
-0.2734470963,
0.798838079,
-0.6304354668,
-0.0098671261,
-0.3661558032,
-1.0671854019,
-0.2705532908,
0.5068156719,
-0.474811852,
0.2203803807,
0.2747681141,
0.3638672531,
0.0251611099,
-0.3438676894,
0.5839942694,
0.0383265615,
0.0742785484,
0.1768439412,
0.7068927884,
-0.5841259956,
0.4396139681,
-0.252897203,
-0.3440480828,
-0.1155761406,
-0.6957743764,
-0.5459687114,
-0.6215474606,
0.253243506,
-0.0193996988,
0.2762821913,
0.3369100094,
0.5220795274,
-0.7047533989,
-0.2367879301,
0.14508003,
0.1098291054,
0.0183958597,
-0.218448475,
0.1385977119,
-0.8827417493,
-0.7804560661,
0.5179633498,
-0.0905314013,
-0.2857489884,
0.0025509838,
0.2098510861,
-0.2200257033,
0.0000259136,
0.6274679899,
0.0951150134,
-0.6091783047,
-0.036162436,
0.0222241953,
-0.0298828948,
-0.1869655699,
0.9418770075,
-0.7703948021,
0.5672512054,
0.5616594553,
0.3738670051,
0.4099812508,
0.4252719879,
0.7656825781,
-0.7857341766,
-0.2097208053,
0.1422161162,
0.2531508207,
0.2937320769,
-0.0861480832,
0.7439674735,
-0.0525316857,
-1.0150816441,
-1.0607572794,
0.0136175742,
-0.4083247185,
-0.361487031,
0.9722916484,
0.0642606542,
0.0213099588,
-0.2713847458,
-0.0005145254,
0.0143221477,
-0.1035679802,
0.682343781,
0.9647969007,
-0.1136155501,
0.2797473967,
-0.7955538034,
0.5209735632,
0.3683226407,
-0.3856039643,
0.3915005028,
0.2726070285,
0.613950491,
0.6005099416,
0.6465966702,
-0.2963826656,
0.2695477903,
-0.0635366738,
-0.0705668256,
0.0814794004,
-0.4795576632,
-0.3840737641,
0.2614179254,
0.331301719,
0.1328345686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14310v1
|
Hint-before-Solving Prompting: Guiding LLMs to Effectively Utilize Encoded Knowledge
| 2024-02-22T05:58:03 | 2024-02-22T05:58:03 |
Jinlan Fu, Shenzhen Huangfu, Hang Yan, See-Kiong Ng, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently showcased remarkable
generalizability in various domains. Despite their extensive knowledge, LLMs
still face challenges in efficiently utilizing encoded knowledge to develop
accurate and logical reasoning processes. To mitigate this problem, we
introduced Hint-before-Solving Prompting (HSP), which guides the model to
generate hints (e.g., specific knowledge or key ideas) for solving the problem
and then generate solutions containing intermediate reasoning steps. Since HSP
is orthogonal to prompting methods (e.g., Chain-of-Thought (CoT)), we applied
HSP to CoT, Least-to-Most, Plan-and-Solve, and Standard promptings. The results
of extensive experiments on 6 reasoning benchmarks and 4 open-source LLMs
demonstrate that HSP can effectively improve the accuracy of reasoning tasks:
(1) By applying high-quality hint-enhanced HSP to CoT prompting,
Llama2-70B-Chat shows an improvement of 9.7. (2) Beyond exploring training-free
LLM capabilities, we built the HSPMATH dataset based on HSP and fine-tuned
Llemma-7B, reaching 64.3 accuracy, surpassing GPT-3.5 and WizardMath-13B. We
make our code and dataset publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/jinlanfu/HSP}.
|
[
-0.2785410881,
-0.5893165469,
1.0314090252,
0.3235240877,
-0.2597672045,
0.01132154,
-0.3275116384,
-0.0834878311,
-0.2327168733,
0.4249243736,
-0.6933073997,
-0.595649004,
-0.5151011944,
0.0808366537,
-0.0543886311,
0.5825856924,
0.0007711977,
0.2039360255,
-0.4702176154,
0.2793535888,
-0.5391572118,
-0.4747442901,
-0.5930740833,
-0.3880933821,
0.6969553828,
0.6256539822,
0.4388230145,
0.4888032973,
0.4370597303,
0.1429950595,
-0.333638221,
0.6050326228,
-0.3091693819,
0.2126449496,
-0.2460293025,
-0.6659644842,
-0.4995032251,
-0.1669114679,
0.4052811265,
0.4550651014,
-0.2987710834,
0.2942132652,
0.2826948166,
0.6844731569,
-0.7990451455,
0.2587412,
-0.8804542422,
-0.063826628,
-0.2703262269,
-0.7842791677,
-0.5026880503,
-0.1301784366,
-0.0949810594,
-0.7053425908,
0.0245537441,
0.1160241291,
0.715236783,
0.4717735648,
-0.1707125753,
-0.3969551623,
-0.4688955843,
0.6442604661,
-0.7437512279,
0.1938570142,
0.4137864411,
0.269587934,
-0.5184081197,
-0.4027919471,
-0.3916409314,
-0.0536215641,
0.1592388451,
-0.0756024867,
-0.2123146206,
0.1273437589,
0.7446880341,
0.0124915522,
-0.3506252468,
-0.0436505862,
-0.2056672126,
-0.2064690888,
0.5195561647,
0.0591530092,
-0.0922730565,
-0.0907240063,
-0.3540393114,
-0.0448713712,
-1.1559255123,
0.0572359711,
0.1812001765,
0.2903999388,
0.2247702032,
0.4950160682,
-0.3519154191,
0.6398917437,
0.1256815344,
-0.1074678227,
0.0088582691,
-0.2002681047,
0.0002158545,
0.0258715507,
0.5617838502,
0.182089448,
0.4157599211,
0.3849445879,
-0.35490188,
-0.0809567496,
0.1321710944,
-0.4856977165,
-0.2449482977,
0.1564382464,
-0.1422685981,
-0.1253853142,
-0.3831236362,
-0.5880470872,
-0.5626092553,
-0.2577024698,
0.5138662457,
-0.3939271569,
-0.1042414084,
0.3101714551,
-0.0252667833,
0.3019068539,
0.5127395391,
-0.6491162777,
-0.1103963256,
0.7277076244,
0.5004863143,
0.0065554599,
-0.1032380685,
-0.6559604406,
0.3507364392,
-0.3631242216,
1.0228457451,
-0.4410786927,
-0.3293444812,
0.1081416532,
-0.5195449591,
0.0485858172,
-0.6641671658,
0.5749115348,
-0.5083520412,
-0.0776924789,
-0.8115358949,
-0.6964673996,
0.1404063851,
0.460904032,
-0.2623393834,
1.0052065849,
-0.2189079225,
-0.6967394948,
0.1612078995,
-0.5982373953,
-0.133920595,
0.120462954,
-0.3639316857,
-0.0423633605,
0.1187000945,
0.9438616633,
0.430644691,
-0.3651064038,
0.140187636,
-0.1734841913,
-0.2235884666,
-0.0027554429,
-0.2695857584,
0.7056851387,
0.1744333953,
-0.2383552939,
0.2161502242,
-0.4099163413,
0.2329010218,
0.3267948627,
-0.0177006181,
-0.0730702281,
-0.1024085283,
-0.7692812681,
0.2886478007,
0.3331846297,
-0.149962604,
0.3167224228,
-0.0612504706,
0.1436340809,
1.0289182663,
0.1183502451,
0.0971217081,
-0.3977462053,
0.7550337911,
0.1309522092,
0.2015872896,
-0.2417016923,
-0.9006713033,
-0.6529011726,
0.075936839,
0.0775171146,
0.6167672873,
-0.9298413992,
0.3435451984,
-0.0210429411,
-0.3269425929,
-0.5213028789,
0.267776221,
0.5987275839,
0.6952639222,
0.4778439403,
0.1134112477,
-0.4647338688,
-0.4958243668,
-0.3396492898,
-0.2177233696,
-0.1677990556,
0.3795310557,
0.3072721362,
-0.0700409636,
0.945933938,
-0.7208941579,
-0.0721111447,
-0.3437478244,
0.1707734019,
0.2090592831,
0.403216958,
0.1010051444,
-0.4300540686,
-0.2648951113,
-0.2853218615,
-0.6604291201,
-0.4226438999,
0.1367763728,
-0.4132312238,
0.0531025305,
0.508287251,
-0.8277589083,
0.2967596352,
0.2536351383,
-0.2777275443,
1.004989028,
-0.2526686788,
0.1605987847,
-0.8958098292,
-0.1159788445,
-0.2688582242,
0.0442525484,
-0.2754508257,
0.0484217033,
0.1706184,
-0.1265223026,
-0.3531502187,
0.535312891,
-0.5318790078,
0.0900616795,
-0.1793014854,
0.169133082,
0.0507891551,
0.563596189,
0.0548103116,
0.8963291049,
0.4821203947,
-0.6648007631,
0.3067010045,
0.2379020005,
-0.1951527447,
0.5332397819,
-0.5711970925,
0.4591943324,
-0.172074005,
0.2410171181,
-0.523424387,
-0.2050320506,
0.2101704925,
-0.4885826707,
0.1654441804,
-0.1736144572,
-0.6662815809,
-0.5751993656,
-0.2143767029,
0.4277151227,
0.7512077093,
-0.6365945935,
0.2996857762,
0.0735355392,
-0.1666059345,
-0.7673844695,
-0.1053745523,
-0.1033641398,
-0.0685164332,
-0.5951729417,
0.2794490755,
-0.287212193,
-0.0183163341,
-0.1467369646,
-0.3503748775,
0.0500715189,
-0.1551282853,
-0.0634225979,
0.2344448715,
-0.2152314484,
0.2608734369,
0.126703009,
-0.3177594543,
0.3975097835,
-0.461779058,
0.6838494539,
-0.1752323806,
-0.5818704963,
-0.4465703368,
0.1406477094,
0.0276708752,
-0.3345410526,
0.3845057786,
0.482418716,
-0.3671254814,
-0.3032188118,
-0.6344294548,
-0.4828675985,
-0.4923016727,
-0.0070076599,
-0.4597504139,
-0.7060753703,
0.4215478599,
-0.1730719954,
-0.1134741455,
0.0218830574,
0.4197380841,
-0.3164962828,
1.2544051409,
0.4172079861,
0.1387913525,
0.3648288846,
-0.0855886042,
0.200576663,
-0.9045739174,
-0.2400127798,
-0.509282589,
0.0664255619,
-0.0789118558,
-0.7135979533,
0.4908057153,
0.4981918633,
0.0319649093,
0.1081023216,
-0.3690089881,
0.7007505298,
0.7064486742,
0.2766777873,
0.3197630346,
-0.1586806178,
-0.3534702063,
0.0548127554,
-0.9313310981,
-0.4336042106,
1.1895183325,
0.1814324409,
0.6681582928,
-0.324411571,
0.9047273993,
0.0504220985,
0.0169550981,
-0.6651285291,
0.7612095475,
0.3746300936,
-0.3703707755,
-0.193795532,
-0.6046133041,
-0.7632649541,
-0.0491201393,
-0.1658103466,
-0.5993603468,
-0.1773237735,
0.7769674063,
-0.4420069754,
0.2694533765,
-0.5960983634,
0.5687111616,
-0.1503544003,
-0.269546479,
-0.3082677424,
-0.4903414249,
0.2871169746,
0.288630724,
0.1094489396,
-0.3120340407,
0.1313316822,
0.6364001632,
-0.1964254528,
0.5798710585,
-0.3876086473,
-0.403205514,
0.4322299361,
0.0431863293,
0.8188545108,
-0.0402021147,
0.0058449786,
-0.1105264351,
-0.1595139802,
-0.605401516,
-0.9044389129,
0.4159774184,
-0.2807530165,
-1.0213638544,
-0.1563423425,
-0.8392293453,
-0.5233809948,
0.14613612,
0.4260300696,
0.544634223,
0.4396860003,
-0.1393665522,
1.1000558138,
-0.1339992136,
-0.0056651249,
0.1674745828,
-0.2393314093,
-0.1809046865,
0.6686249375,
-0.0246523153,
0.3664449751,
0.3062742651,
0.471896708,
-0.4610840678,
-0.7750593424,
-0.2751342952,
0.2969718874,
-1.0022925138,
-0.4671214223,
-0.3801333606,
-0.1809467524,
-0.5754802823,
-0.1791429669,
-0.1160152927,
-0.2883948386,
-0.1292055249,
-0.1122314408,
0.3084920049,
0.7372792363,
-0.0746395737,
0.2444007695,
-0.9467155337,
0.1710930169,
0.364276439,
0.1291087866,
-0.0196615532,
-0.321506232,
-0.1249337569,
0.0610340834,
-0.2195321918,
-0.9666890502,
0.1096775979,
-0.2078879923,
0.6673424244,
0.4743919969,
0.2797482312,
0.7384155989,
-0.404088676,
0.7494453788,
-0.0248246025,
-0.9165216684,
0.9379469752,
-0.5586574674,
0.6053179502,
0.3203164637,
0.3719984889,
-0.2101608813,
-0.4382614493,
-0.7356175184,
-0.5869665146,
0.448322922,
0.1540521234,
-0.1945797503,
0.0454513729,
0.4450801611,
-0.1022381783,
0.3585923612,
-0.4469517171,
-0.113015011,
0.231731087,
-0.2447704524,
0.2023304999,
-0.5275520682,
-0.2244800478,
-0.3325468004,
0.8472582102,
-0.3085739613,
0.4116207659,
0.1805322617,
-0.2424629778,
0.0011747138,
0.3930370212,
0.6625480652,
0.8222850561,
-0.2113752216,
0.2582722008,
0.2646944523,
-0.1604250073,
-0.0174687169,
-0.1195728555,
-0.1145002022,
-0.2122277617,
0.4228139222,
0.6308258176,
0.0510354266,
-0.81164217,
0.4439670146,
0.1310065836,
-0.0959022343,
0.0306028556,
0.3447811902,
0.0796028376,
0.2162078768,
0.3888048232,
-0.10695678,
0.0346694253,
-0.1234061718,
0.0995821878,
0.4284787476,
-0.2636267245,
-0.1183912531,
0.3455514312,
0.2335361391,
-0.2268313766,
0.652726531,
-0.5089135766,
-0.7487302423,
0.4087963998,
0.7828195095,
0.6537887454,
-0.2182274461,
0.2222266048,
0.4358755648,
0.2483366877,
-0.0815370157,
0.521815002,
-0.5362006426,
-0.7896798849,
-0.5691101551,
-0.4131954014,
-0.4132469296,
0.0029967078,
-0.7409068942,
0.2633324265,
-0.4222332239,
0.0290649198,
-0.3584548831,
0.0526722856,
-0.488443017,
-0.071992442,
0.3389325738,
1.1903048754,
-0.5320888758,
0.8465914726,
0.5412680507,
-0.1031046063,
-1.0832459927,
0.1626515239,
0.0833284259,
-0.9629333019,
0.3539871275,
0.2182023674,
-0.3920421004,
0.2359402329,
-0.8813863993,
-0.7395054102,
1.0807484388,
0.4525595009,
-0.6506696939,
-0.2622887194,
-0.0147973094,
0.1756182015,
-0.2592472732,
0.1505566686,
0.7246974111,
0.560562551,
0.374596566,
-0.7454571128,
0.1907618493,
-0.3357138038,
-0.1771507859,
0.2231593877,
-0.0589975268,
0.5645245314,
-0.6559157372,
-0.1656982303,
-0.0750214905,
0.6363360286,
0.8705391288,
0.3257176578,
0.5507762432,
0.5470970869,
1.1438472271,
-0.0819416493,
0.8558287621,
-0.1213519871,
0.0352027118,
1.1248137951,
-0.247256726,
0.8352702856,
0.6437304616,
-0.0579373576,
0.5019844174,
0.5257158875,
0.3010278642,
0.2843821645,
0.2455196232,
-0.3021019101,
-0.5095479488,
-0.2076584846,
-0.5131394267,
0.068639636,
0.6885419488,
0.1049135849,
-0.2585674524,
-0.0920726657,
0.0854736194,
0.1049660966,
-0.540186584,
0.6532421708,
0.1900678426,
-0.7263432741,
0.6676666141,
-0.4506398439,
0.6083338261,
-0.701672256,
-0.1034207046,
0.0123681286,
-0.0460069254,
-0.1969452947,
-0.9122409225,
0.0259562191,
-0.0200258009,
-0.0871964172,
-0.3882173598,
0.7037588358,
-0.5376749039,
-0.2070512027,
0.1549003869,
0.5468568802,
0.002405466,
-0.3931442797,
-0.7308686972,
-0.0696383268,
-0.0058992682,
-0.1124138534,
0.0551089942,
0.565497756,
-0.1535772979,
0.9077954292,
0.7941936255,
0.200199455,
0.1840123236,
0.1671118885,
0.857775867,
-0.685782373,
-0.4896643162,
-0.6266750097,
0.4422726929,
-0.1093767062,
-0.241125688,
0.6992775202,
0.1143530458,
0.7372884154,
-0.0694773123,
0.4904398024,
0.1272646189,
0.3624119461,
-1.0122848749,
0.3790491521,
-0.3694688082,
0.4701174498,
-0.2462268621,
-0.7821768522,
-0.2823408842,
0.3803453147,
-0.4932624698,
-0.0402740128,
0.8010477424,
1.0798032284,
0.2817822099,
0.0043781758,
0.1776372492,
0.0283170063,
0.3728812635,
0.7348847985,
1.246964097,
0.0452158153,
0.5868117213,
-0.342539221,
-0.3421749473,
-0.2657802105,
-1.0521421432,
-0.87358886,
-0.5069594979,
-0.1277723908,
-0.374612987,
0.2047492564,
1.2227181196,
0.7077320218,
-0.7052178979,
-0.1479382515,
-0.285718739,
0.4426017106,
-0.3601245582,
-0.1576347202,
0.2309069782,
-0.8528414965,
-0.3412258923,
0.5684915185,
0.1818797141,
0.0651601031,
-0.0290592778,
-0.2175916582,
-0.091223523,
0.195564732,
0.5002212524,
0.078440778,
-0.6193333268,
-0.1042646915,
0.030078968,
-0.0191283543,
0.1374914348,
1.1173387766,
-0.6709367633,
0.2756153047,
0.6238792539,
0.5755390525,
0.3084208071,
0.0552034527,
0.8054026365,
-0.8394641876,
0.0693504885,
0.479703784,
0.3457818329,
0.2249390632,
-0.5855855942,
0.2852484584,
0.0731456354,
-0.5255640745,
-0.8389754295,
0.5269816518,
-0.7478395104,
-0.1947534084,
1.1320101023,
-0.1830879152,
-0.2858596444,
0.0542941429,
-0.3821203113,
0.0783064812,
-0.5202246904,
0.7536536455,
0.6159517169,
-0.3190632463,
-0.3385868371,
-0.2331302911,
0.9158451557,
0.6559766531,
-0.9824112058,
0.1038117036,
0.2984441817,
-0.1046494916,
0.1072627306,
0.7813534141,
-0.0539803728,
0.4361580312,
-0.0662877485,
-0.0776230991,
-0.2711434066,
-0.7182257771,
-0.3103842735,
-0.0298793912,
0.3061239123,
-0.0492967591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15444v1
|
Unleashing the Power of Imbalanced Modality Information for Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-02-22T05:48:03 | 2024-02-22T05:48:03 |
Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Multi-modal knowledge graph completion (MMKGC) aims to predict the missing
triples in the multi-modal knowledge graphs by incorporating structural,
visual, and textual information of entities into the discriminant models. The
information from different modalities will work together to measure the triple
plausibility. Existing MMKGC methods overlook the imbalance problem of modality
information among entities, resulting in inadequate modal fusion and
inefficient utilization of the raw modality information. To address the
mentioned problems, we propose Adaptive Multi-modal Fusion and Modality
Adversarial Training (AdaMF-MAT) to unleash the power of imbalanced modality
information for MMKGC. AdaMF-MAT achieves multi-modal fusion with adaptive
modality weights and further generates adversarial samples by
modality-adversarial training to enhance the imbalanced modality information.
Our approach is a co-design of the MMKGC model and training strategy which can
outperform 19 recent MMKGC methods and achieve new state-of-the-art results on
three public MMKGC benchmarks. Our code and data have been released at
https://github.com/zjukg/AdaMF-MAT.
|
[
-0.4967015684,
-0.6778940558,
0.3520725369,
-0.2476894855,
-0.3458150923,
0.7059004307,
-0.1140203178,
-0.3114632964,
0.0180968121,
0.0551621765,
-0.6086156368,
-0.2965384126,
-0.4872900546,
-0.0395734124,
0.2177381217,
0.7263692021,
-0.0828142613,
0.348341465,
-0.4193845391,
-0.3790142834,
-0.5913702846,
-0.1208383739,
-0.2709543705,
-0.5577746034,
0.4062153399,
0.3870836496,
0.6831596494,
0.4752755761,
0.2235734761,
0.2253311425,
0.1984825134,
0.6405248642,
-0.3982161283,
-0.0239122175,
0.2333122343,
-0.2353234589,
-0.6395148635,
0.2352451533,
0.7801681161,
0.8093287945,
-0.1364157796,
0.0256315079,
0.1369250864,
0.5989305973,
-0.8346825838,
0.3482818007,
-0.6637117863,
0.1575952917,
0.047485467,
-0.3421092629,
-0.3989561796,
0.0540630408,
-0.1022993624,
-0.9281327128,
0.1264926791,
0.2925611734,
0.423610568,
0.3509329557,
-0.95246315,
-0.1014887616,
-0.8175722957,
0.5822064281,
-0.4176897705,
0.6735441089,
0.462261945,
0.3798622787,
-0.0967626348,
-0.2943237126,
-0.556968987,
-0.3567502797,
-0.1575451195,
0.5085906982,
0.0801398903,
0.1971769333,
0.2427273393,
0.3663742244,
-0.4225783944,
-0.2575084865,
-0.4823072255,
-0.3151062727,
0.3654816747,
0.129083544,
0.0590865426,
-0.3582906127,
-0.6610286832,
0.0078330813,
-0.4718513489,
-0.0149040138,
0.5604513884,
0.1460674703,
0.028854182,
0.5506392121,
-0.2422963828,
0.9513369799,
0.1829094738,
-0.5832588077,
0.6079726219,
-0.8574917316,
-0.2610016465,
0.2124146074,
0.7104605436,
0.2998217344,
-0.5158421993,
-0.287547648,
0.2432920635,
-0.1848683059,
0.4232726395,
-0.5472014546,
-0.1288010925,
-0.035476502,
-0.410605371,
-0.3495765924,
-0.0207480509,
-0.6581223011,
-0.4398976564,
-0.4040706456,
0.6377596259,
-0.6958268285,
-0.6227266788,
-0.0792041719,
-0.2812414765,
-0.113462843,
0.4715327024,
-0.5645970702,
-0.2700124383,
0.4108231664,
0.7439872622,
0.1745583713,
-0.4733420014,
-0.1537340581,
0.5441253185,
-0.086796023,
0.3161447942,
-0.543592453,
-0.2994504571,
-0.4247396886,
0.1052301973,
-0.5376754403,
-0.2416289598,
0.6608271599,
-0.4455229044,
0.3225954771,
-0.6767674685,
-0.4059180617,
-0.5943200588,
0.5120361447,
-0.7706935406,
0.7476841807,
0.3658803701,
-0.883744359,
0.7721914649,
-0.6361636519,
-0.3866518736,
-0.0390427522,
-0.1122007519,
-0.4881291986,
-0.1322071999,
0.1868725568,
0.4901622236,
-0.3336499929,
0.0698394403,
-0.6058130264,
-0.2151123881,
0.0910740122,
-0.4162820578,
0.6382092834,
0.320153147,
-0.2788710296,
0.0360387228,
-1.0490034819,
-0.1612658203,
0.1306290329,
-0.6712046862,
-0.2644144297,
0.1499940902,
-0.3425436616,
0.3628581762,
0.0561219193,
-0.6046932936,
0.0985543057,
-0.2432308942,
0.3318814635,
0.8206247091,
-0.1702377796,
0.4641075134,
-0.5161468983,
0.4857205153,
0.1681381166,
0.1619214714,
0.0456045903,
-0.4317676723,
-0.4237245321,
-0.4124394655,
0.2546074688,
0.3188458383,
-1.2038303614,
0.3103033304,
-0.3159505129,
-0.4740018845,
-0.5248658657,
0.198019743,
0.3540970087,
0.821501255,
0.2949462831,
-0.1749316454,
-0.5489928722,
-0.6549441814,
0.0266491603,
-0.2254568189,
0.1737253666,
0.6286687851,
0.2362993509,
-0.0217061471,
0.6048287153,
-0.1644419432,
-0.4557078779,
-0.0522967763,
0.3251390457,
-0.1904457361,
0.3967728019,
0.6645501852,
-0.9008052349,
-0.2199787796,
0.1238651127,
-0.7480407357,
0.2578448355,
0.1257758439,
-0.0421973206,
0.0956149921,
0.370170325,
-0.2983856797,
0.0711103901,
0.5997217894,
-0.5088179111,
0.4198507667,
0.0012244284,
0.7364304066,
-1.3275102377,
0.0855629444,
-0.5535376072,
-0.3351306915,
-0.3523361385,
0.0643669963,
0.1495521367,
-0.1154140905,
-0.2162275761,
0.0901140645,
-0.4742097855,
0.1772601008,
-0.2904475033,
-0.0204179529,
0.1250439733,
0.6640822291,
-0.7285961509,
0.6682314277,
0.3258878589,
-0.5036727786,
0.6573317051,
0.0204562955,
0.0022637788,
0.8255762458,
-0.0017366488,
-0.1122869402,
-0.2010008693,
0.3186039329,
-1.0857821703,
-0.416416049,
0.5918977261,
-0.4306807816,
0.5378913879,
-0.4311772883,
-0.3098534346,
-0.540378809,
-0.3482957482,
0.6966318488,
0.0754846111,
-0.534280777,
1.2930436134,
0.2399908155,
0.4664162397,
-0.802883029,
-0.4815544486,
-0.100194253,
0.0026270912,
-0.744553864,
0.3675417006,
-0.3002072573,
0.3399039805,
0.2480538487,
-0.0788910687,
0.3362838328,
0.3202402294,
0.4718249738,
0.1604115516,
-0.1697430015,
0.1648380458,
-0.1342604607,
-0.0614568666,
-0.0419449359,
-0.3747358322,
0.6710045934,
-0.1056100428,
-0.8628630042,
0.0281770024,
0.2455511391,
0.8564425111,
-0.1626663804,
0.8436043262,
1.1085754633,
-0.4457815886,
0.253107667,
-0.5512855053,
0.1204396486,
-0.4189702272,
0.3458963931,
-0.1868180037,
-0.8570918441,
0.4533208609,
-0.1319654584,
-0.0360653251,
0.4469191134,
0.5893883705,
0.2220143825,
1.5341840982,
0.4038884044,
0.1310613453,
0.4364022017,
-0.286832273,
0.2191937119,
-1.0050057173,
-0.5016634464,
0.0207137726,
-0.4887520969,
-0.1943252534,
-0.2891906798,
0.7755348086,
0.2792466581,
-0.0635290071,
0.0650958121,
-0.469497323,
0.3625859618,
0.7506484389,
0.507876277,
0.4305483103,
-0.0478737168,
-0.3864115477,
0.1337131262,
-0.6814411283,
0.1754832864,
1.4297095537,
0.0156844277,
0.6272589564,
0.2518836856,
0.1666042656,
0.2161500454,
0.028362738,
-0.8117666245,
0.2553727329,
0.1217234954,
-0.5780003667,
0.0626929849,
-0.673085928,
-0.6211202145,
0.2718155682,
-0.5194429755,
-0.1058643311,
0.2211348265,
0.280085206,
-0.4112800658,
0.6073548198,
-0.7481496334,
0.6701111794,
-0.0236844756,
-0.0959088504,
-0.4794545174,
-0.4829749465,
0.7463136911,
-0.1983337998,
0.3452459872,
-0.222165361,
0.149404183,
0.782576561,
-0.289665699,
0.5988460779,
-0.3995218873,
0.2184147686,
0.1079460755,
-0.0967645645,
0.2622447312,
0.1093489006,
0.1750735641,
-0.0861858726,
-0.123836264,
-0.4385876656,
-0.4464527369,
0.5973808169,
-0.9839331508,
-0.2541350424,
-0.2877650261,
-0.8036057949,
-0.3774826825,
0.2652105093,
0.1440602988,
0.4227222204,
-0.1984120756,
0.3576173782,
0.4363285601,
0.2071633488,
0.5791721344,
0.5485556126,
0.0733594373,
-0.9446094036,
0.9899471998,
0.3307186067,
0.5577320457,
0.0531902649,
0.1784731746,
0.1268208623,
-0.4576609433,
-0.8371151686,
-0.095880881,
-0.6900519133,
-0.6559827328,
-0.8648405671,
-0.2471804619,
-0.4439175725,
-0.1771316081,
-0.1886017323,
-0.3926217258,
-0.2851970792,
-0.0202995948,
0.322928071,
0.4872279763,
-0.3243700862,
0.3920427263,
-0.5392000675,
0.3473087549,
0.6455071568,
0.3478280902,
0.2005499154,
-0.1171630621,
-0.3342276812,
0.419803679,
-0.558675468,
-0.8065465093,
-0.1719970405,
0.2623697221,
0.5658623576,
0.4345022738,
-0.1053508297,
0.532790482,
-0.1655862927,
0.6148908138,
0.5563884377,
-0.5722093582,
0.252235651,
-0.5382103324,
0.2237685472,
0.5676389337,
0.3032018244,
-0.3496541977,
-0.2668894529,
-0.6638528109,
-0.7126776576,
0.9742306471,
-0.0673240051,
-0.3114661574,
0.3639606237,
0.1181020215,
0.022204781,
0.4118938446,
-0.7388120294,
-0.284044534,
-0.5982583761,
-0.3798710108,
0.1347479224,
-0.1807915717,
-0.6750358939,
-0.4257339537,
0.9492203593,
-0.5327160954,
0.3199341893,
0.050345581,
-0.2054165751,
-0.5412685871,
0.1300015599,
0.6198790073,
0.7874615788,
-0.3746230006,
0.3118602633,
0.2710775137,
-0.6259378791,
0.3097184002,
0.4980298579,
-0.1323907673,
-0.403608948,
0.2477299124,
0.7802984715,
0.1195116043,
-0.3098852932,
0.7201310396,
-0.061774116,
-0.4208733737,
-0.1623616964,
0.1631963104,
0.0584828518,
0.3348938525,
0.4815962017,
0.6987345219,
-0.0364068449,
-0.3411521316,
0.1176724583,
0.6969496012,
-0.4884807765,
-0.2078837454,
0.8121243715,
-0.0217828527,
0.2265440822,
0.2464517504,
-0.4291683435,
-0.6632546782,
0.2911961973,
0.405002743,
0.5820176601,
-0.2528461218,
0.1686659008,
0.322860539,
0.4122914374,
0.1776586473,
0.1253379434,
-0.1224782169,
-0.6734951735,
-0.4482533038,
-0.5954434276,
-0.0664151609,
0.0375669412,
-0.2464975715,
0.2290911078,
-0.6927075982,
-0.0892831013,
-0.0386175215,
0.1360644698,
-0.6278055906,
-0.0670190528,
0.1003013924,
0.3071220517,
-0.8746231794,
0.4703713953,
0.4875285923,
-0.587408483,
-0.8765670657,
-0.4397717714,
0.3080897927,
-1.0761333704,
0.1698772907,
-0.0522052571,
-0.1643609703,
0.0001210649,
-0.3271335959,
-1.0682837963,
1.620393157,
0.4490629733,
-0.0243963134,
0.0142304581,
0.2350501418,
-0.1359216869,
-0.3378283083,
0.1400147825,
0.2772248387,
0.6203947663,
0.5055139065,
-0.8398362398,
0.1568667591,
-0.210346505,
-0.4290469885,
0.3293844759,
-0.7052117586,
0.8733016849,
-0.0045850184,
-0.0290758908,
-0.3794744015,
0.4805561602,
0.0357938483,
0.2670124471,
0.8268066049,
0.9059844613,
0.713986814,
-0.1871594489,
0.5890802741,
-0.447022289,
0.2864435613,
0.8553497791,
0.073652029,
0.0736750364,
0.1172299385,
-0.0443048216,
0.219784677,
0.5585904717,
-0.1488554478,
0.4907368422,
-0.4105392396,
-0.4559853971,
-0.3285895586,
-0.3341065645,
-0.6664921641,
0.5571312308,
0.2419024855,
-0.4058698118,
-0.4488776624,
0.5287908912,
0.1150955632,
-0.5537683964,
-0.3847466707,
0.8229430318,
-0.4003961384,
-0.4554943442,
0.70302701,
0.0376272127,
0.541261971,
-0.5877130032,
0.0273830667,
0.2585494816,
0.0682811886,
-0.2548891604,
-0.2293321043,
0.0267254505,
-0.8741720915,
-0.4652323723,
-0.0671270341,
0.8552738428,
-0.6221176982,
-0.6550147533,
0.3131025136,
0.6722118855,
-0.6192216277,
-0.0681600571,
-0.6720371246,
-0.316347748,
0.0184387397,
0.1668204665,
0.2604630589,
0.2914164662,
0.2816300988,
0.3623129427,
0.7545520067,
-0.1375724673,
0.270716548,
0.0053922129,
1.05024755,
-0.2853280306,
-0.2547569573,
-0.793333292,
0.2077930272,
0.0166742988,
-0.0781977549,
0.6526640654,
0.6019413471,
0.8558619022,
0.2841345072,
0.7108601332,
-0.3487193584,
0.4466389418,
-0.5959071517,
0.794921875,
-0.9314376116,
0.0710266605,
-0.2999813855,
-0.6429376006,
-0.0348137766,
0.1077496335,
0.1393760294,
0.1802849472,
0.6024461389,
0.7343785167,
-0.5212262273,
0.2846029997,
0.1769569367,
0.147013247,
0.3350038528,
0.6471136808,
0.9582116604,
-0.4715839028,
0.7620271444,
-0.4549952745,
-0.3632656634,
-0.2639161944,
-0.7835127711,
-0.7673570514,
-0.8456419706,
-0.1723182201,
-0.6201671958,
-0.3682355583,
1.0585292578,
0.8580595255,
-0.4491682053,
0.2805511653,
0.0690373108,
0.3387086093,
-0.326541841,
-0.2229416072,
0.3724832833,
-0.1615389884,
-0.3256741762,
0.505087018,
0.2776988447,
0.1574440598,
-0.4114852548,
-0.0661549941,
-0.4175957143,
-0.2727998495,
0.4885183871,
-0.0273612645,
-0.6094126701,
-0.4301532507,
-0.100735873,
0.1154755205,
0.2243968099,
1.0906095505,
-0.8385021687,
0.6825659871,
0.415897131,
0.6472893953,
-0.0272319019,
-0.1407818794,
0.5717095137,
-0.884119153,
0.0060594478,
0.1652184278,
0.6196334958,
0.2325599939,
-0.4488032758,
0.4138332605,
0.7318052649,
-0.3410193622,
-0.6487824917,
0.2667847872,
-1.0844972134,
-0.4061722755,
0.9297985435,
0.2149226069,
-0.2465839982,
-0.2916905284,
-0.2355409265,
0.5145428181,
-0.1814290881,
0.6980764866,
0.7623625398,
0.0384289213,
0.0041036061,
-0.4427677393,
0.605250597,
0.2800528109,
-0.4195837379,
0.1206024066,
0.701790154,
0.1405507475,
0.430544585,
0.6081667542,
-0.0120792687,
0.352905333,
-0.0398659855,
-0.1806878,
-0.7540972233,
-0.3687734306,
-0.0516992211,
0.5513820648,
-0.0441319272,
-0.0607036352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14298v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14298v3
|
Multi-modal Stance Detection: New Datasets and Model
| 2024-02-22T05:24:19 | 2024-06-06T15:17:58 |
Bin Liang, Ang Li, Jingqian Zhao, Lin Gui, Min Yang, Yue Yu, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection is a challenging task that aims to identify public opinion
from social media platforms with respect to specific targets. Previous work on
stance detection largely focused on pure texts. In this paper, we study
multi-modal stance detection for tweets consisting of texts and images, which
are prevalent in today's fast-growing social media platforms where people often
post multi-modal messages. To this end, we create five new multi-modal stance
detection datasets of different domains based on Twitter, in which each example
consists of a text and an image. In addition, we propose a simple yet effective
Targeted Multi-modal Prompt Tuning framework (TMPT), where target information
is leveraged to learn multi-modal stance features from textual and visual
modalities. Experimental results on our five benchmark datasets show that the
proposed TMPT achieves state-of-the-art performance in multi-modal stance
detection.
|
[
-0.3947051764,
-0.6598587036,
0.6486000419,
0.4507340789,
-0.5912074447,
0.1282023489,
-0.1252041459,
-0.1371759921,
0.487631321,
-0.1688219905,
-0.9886795282,
-0.7781375647,
-0.7650269866,
0.0913178548,
0.0777322352,
0.8094638586,
0.1303220391,
0.2022794932,
0.4106611609,
-0.5994136333,
-0.640180707,
0.0670269579,
-0.6242784858,
0.2676971853,
0.7370256186,
0.4646146595,
0.6764281988,
0.1512818038,
0.059643764,
0.1371232867,
0.1824897975,
0.3137631118,
-0.1324620545,
0.3477223516,
0.0238129962,
-0.0474405065,
-0.3288410604,
0.0464415736,
0.7763689756,
0.0122857438,
0.2434362322,
-0.0363304764,
-0.2995172143,
0.3335194588,
-0.5791549087,
0.0099797444,
-0.4099039435,
-0.1190628931,
-0.4715372622,
-0.2464560419,
-0.4117830396,
-0.2071790397,
-0.4828491807,
-0.4400818646,
0.0924665928,
0.1113415882,
0.8797180653,
-0.0049755629,
-0.9264913797,
-0.0528149046,
-0.1325112134,
0.9027522206,
-0.4961216152,
0.6435813308,
0.1959275454,
0.3181797266,
0.1270347536,
-0.0231109392,
-0.6501451135,
-0.0487625226,
0.0401868783,
0.0669856742,
-0.1296034157,
-0.0926262438,
0.1744252592,
0.0064727506,
-0.4232906103,
-0.1171424016,
0.1653916538,
-0.2476022989,
0.1299982071,
-0.0948997065,
0.4072852731,
-0.7904299498,
-0.7024729848,
-0.2149728835,
-0.2835874557,
0.3612799346,
0.253284514,
0.4693503678,
-0.4135167301,
0.6519709229,
0.0067690564,
0.613812387,
0.4360451996,
-0.3478389382,
0.3291972876,
-0.4115080535,
-0.1331137866,
-0.4006938338,
0.9958178997,
0.7500433326,
-0.1175304502,
0.1479860991,
-0.5302051902,
-0.0593407787,
0.0503259636,
-0.5975348353,
0.061512813,
0.1270177364,
-0.7585343719,
-0.5143778324,
0.1798406988,
-0.9049930573,
-1.0835055113,
-0.5622850657,
0.3827451468,
-0.7056903839,
-0.722536087,
0.0827535391,
-0.4350963831,
0.6657432914,
0.5842008591,
-0.6916571856,
-0.3762602508,
0.7841564417,
1.0431843996,
-0.113634184,
-0.0798419416,
-0.487944603,
0.0536926128,
-0.3053830266,
1.0141923428,
-0.8076016307,
-0.3680880666,
0.0629610345,
0.0823860541,
-0.2613412142,
0.0279266629,
0.7716376781,
-0.374327153,
0.1364687979,
-0.8393819332,
-0.3110436797,
0.019913435,
0.752428174,
-0.9742660522,
0.7921981812,
-0.128395021,
-0.8717586994,
1.0181847811,
-0.8617120981,
-0.6557270288,
-0.2366146743,
-0.3820864558,
-0.4550192058,
0.2471877486,
0.4790067077,
0.6820144057,
-0.2124837935,
0.063885577,
-0.5603587627,
0.0175718702,
0.2115030885,
-0.4270413518,
0.9933666587,
0.0071755801,
-0.2756613493,
0.498128742,
-0.3485108912,
-0.1641613096,
-0.0603236966,
-0.2983281612,
-0.2370336652,
0.1025795043,
0.3522979617,
0.4567554295,
0.0563083552,
-0.5066642761,
0.3684762716,
0.1658379138,
0.3845683336,
0.7289717793,
0.3639516234,
0.2952440083,
-0.3530488312,
0.483138144,
0.1495658606,
0.4069469273,
-0.2844626307,
-0.39910236,
-0.3786411583,
-0.5581545234,
-0.1291356087,
0.1389734894,
-0.8530368805,
0.3347720802,
-0.1403065026,
-0.1487009823,
-0.3847524226,
-0.0955123231,
0.1303292811,
0.2140123993,
0.2788294256,
0.2512048483,
-0.2904968858,
-0.8464126587,
-0.6609887481,
-0.3209905624,
0.3002777696,
0.1317911297,
0.3029415011,
0.0949681476,
0.7776588798,
0.0634080097,
-0.1847310364,
-0.1462071687,
0.358258307,
-0.1680386961,
0.1426275671,
1.0329812765,
-1.1808860302,
-0.4835089147,
-0.2741996348,
-0.5521948338,
0.077449128,
-0.3084930182,
-0.1957115829,
0.1789679825,
0.5831091404,
-0.7188979387,
-0.0266965516,
0.3923392892,
-0.6264554262,
0.3938221633,
0.54925102,
0.8910767436,
-1.603292346,
-0.1730094254,
0.640614152,
-0.4522539377,
-0.5871177912,
-0.1993103772,
0.3782046139,
-0.0412470736,
-0.6155131459,
0.5024110079,
-0.2974064648,
0.2840053439,
-0.1411452889,
-0.1398419738,
0.0495092943,
0.2882449329,
-0.0429200307,
0.6147262454,
0.7966085076,
-0.3104301691,
0.2403174788,
0.160552904,
-0.0240739416,
1.161916256,
-0.434643954,
0.0973666608,
-0.3658683598,
0.3251303136,
-1.4819687605,
-0.4690882266,
0.6087703109,
-0.6570640802,
0.3648751974,
-0.421715945,
-0.5928480625,
-0.1967567801,
-0.8412432075,
0.2561265826,
-0.0762978643,
-0.5335296988,
0.7680947185,
0.2594260573,
0.285823971,
-0.7653027177,
-0.2085546851,
0.1501615196,
-0.4896920323,
-0.4978296161,
0.2085289359,
0.0763401836,
-0.0654421002,
-0.1972512156,
-0.1679656655,
0.10543219,
-0.2070488334,
0.1990923882,
-0.0112909339,
-0.0944229513,
0.3696712255,
0.1572564244,
0.0709309429,
-0.1187217087,
-0.2498709559,
0.5636580586,
-0.243655622,
-0.5176827908,
-0.8903356194,
0.4567700922,
1.2833393812,
-0.1677250862,
0.5788241029,
1.0627970695,
-0.4546039999,
-0.1282732189,
-0.3857497871,
-0.201775685,
-0.4696523845,
0.0225980561,
-0.2511725128,
-0.4686613679,
0.1449643523,
-0.0701452345,
0.2329993546,
0.1963788569,
0.6904261708,
-0.1958879828,
1.2081913948,
0.5283524394,
-0.3472833931,
0.8202801943,
0.0770532936,
0.2715380788,
-0.2440203726,
-0.1803769767,
-0.4430171847,
-0.6083091497,
-0.3429679573,
-0.5330631733,
0.3688436747,
-0.1266681403,
-0.2060896605,
0.3925169408,
-0.2281236053,
0.3552232981,
0.2902917564,
0.5564742684,
0.116989404,
-0.0894536823,
0.1468329281,
-0.2450025678,
-0.1668734252,
-0.5438597798,
0.6878302097,
0.2040454596,
0.4092499614,
0.3187080622,
0.4583857954,
0.6502999663,
0.1899980009,
-1.276065588,
0.5643678904,
0.0162994526,
-0.5074382424,
-0.1588273793,
-0.0797280148,
-0.720954895,
0.1424159408,
-0.529682219,
-0.2544110715,
0.2737952471,
0.1689274013,
-0.1777991205,
0.4993744493,
-0.6616495848,
1.0628287792,
-0.2795056701,
-0.1205146313,
-0.2260256559,
-0.6699588299,
0.1099511683,
0.2296293676,
0.1755858958,
-0.471036464,
-0.5107024908,
0.5899868011,
0.0217950828,
1.1838946342,
-0.7532556057,
-0.1854980588,
-0.1060898677,
0.005569018,
0.2028336525,
0.4001999497,
-0.1872128397,
-0.244125396,
-0.3192424476,
-0.5144230723,
-0.2172210068,
0.6203889847,
-0.6035856605,
-0.2432623208,
-0.207202062,
-0.3234117925,
-0.5333305597,
0.3624649048,
0.240219295,
0.6562912464,
-0.5067962408,
0.2623888552,
0.4956063926,
0.0708572716,
0.9409621954,
0.300077498,
0.3340601623,
-0.4348911047,
0.6463706493,
-0.3975272477,
-0.1443906873,
0.5672308207,
0.2882656753,
-0.6111901999,
-0.2809269726,
-0.4779346883,
0.1000819281,
-0.7562440634,
-0.4089153707,
-0.4835448265,
0.6215527654,
-0.4845357537,
-0.3467739522,
-0.2593761086,
-0.3648535609,
-0.3048837781,
-0.0300511848,
0.6333351731,
0.5789402127,
-0.0178368315,
0.3781909645,
-0.4954054654,
0.861051023,
0.1680818349,
0.1769936979,
-0.4048768878,
-0.0727845952,
0.2964530289,
0.0385164097,
-0.447550565,
-1.2294476032,
0.1085056961,
0.3205402195,
0.4518993199,
0.7726523876,
0.251346916,
0.2922991514,
-0.1597189605,
0.7229400873,
0.6232384443,
-0.8837527037,
0.7227517366,
-0.952560544,
0.2175623327,
0.6401565075,
0.5472831726,
-0.5497019291,
-0.1848294884,
-0.244891867,
-0.3626441658,
0.7621908784,
-0.0917760283,
0.2593695521,
-0.092974022,
0.0676004365,
0.2372082919,
0.43824476,
-0.7769390941,
-0.0365204364,
-0.4505172372,
-0.4092661142,
0.189592585,
0.1722262502,
-0.2889291942,
-0.2389902025,
0.2268911451,
-0.3561503589,
0.2276080996,
-0.3321363628,
-0.3182528317,
-0.077013731,
0.4558419585,
0.5670002699,
0.4972501993,
0.0734440759,
0.0562550686,
-0.2119193822,
-0.3174398839,
0.2510035932,
-0.2348994911,
-0.269846648,
0.1721322834,
0.002504257,
0.8562247753,
0.3284367025,
-0.1543321311,
0.8815155625,
0.0102142831,
-0.1826214045,
-0.069057852,
-0.3441931605,
0.0028936747,
0.3150323629,
0.3120987117,
0.6567736268,
0.0347112492,
-0.6898237467,
0.1911204457,
0.5598474145,
-0.5602689385,
-0.6310104132,
0.452005893,
0.1863727868,
-0.2552929223,
-0.1376528889,
-0.2714893222,
-0.5032282472,
0.3991109431,
0.2136505246,
1.0276517868,
-0.0487806238,
0.699352324,
0.2050857842,
0.1676949412,
-0.1377610564,
0.5380731821,
-0.149860397,
-0.7391497493,
-0.0674476922,
-0.142671138,
-0.2866363227,
0.1194561347,
-0.5347743034,
0.9499145746,
-0.739023447,
-0.6282249093,
0.2143719047,
-0.2231686264,
-0.4789536297,
0.0094733108,
0.090944536,
0.5747794509,
-1.1483229399,
0.463727951,
1.1502285004,
-0.2951571345,
-0.556630671,
0.7795506716,
0.6503466964,
-0.7537686825,
0.0243614241,
0.3675520718,
-0.4696427584,
-0.0714918599,
-0.7259808183,
-0.2460554987,
0.9106330872,
0.497638911,
0.0272308625,
0.2031413764,
-0.185699299,
0.1170002148,
-0.1980934888,
-0.0129047679,
0.3162139654,
0.867723763,
-0.0990440696,
-0.631718576,
0.2128901333,
-0.1913839281,
-0.4843587875,
0.3351746798,
-1.0155118704,
0.8710482121,
0.1488003433,
-0.2793873549,
-0.3555876613,
0.3838668168,
0.4685252905,
0.4945169687,
0.9831880331,
0.2269727141,
0.5901184678,
-0.2106482387,
0.8988642097,
-0.2749530673,
0.228073746,
0.3481275141,
-0.1471454799,
0.6073676348,
0.5430998206,
0.396856457,
0.4811269939,
0.807361722,
0.0409645438,
0.5085772872,
-0.3710561097,
-0.4215266109,
-0.6816824675,
-0.340069294,
-0.1326377243,
0.3669189215,
0.5208916068,
-0.117009677,
-0.5320173502,
0.3353697956,
0.2379349619,
0.0216008034,
-0.3566246629,
0.5688434243,
-0.1953837574,
-0.4831703007,
0.4206557274,
0.098707363,
0.8689523935,
-0.3876182735,
0.1430036873,
0.1782694012,
-0.0612635985,
-0.1902929246,
-0.8413943052,
-0.1764349043,
-0.0746206343,
-0.2601351142,
-0.6086456776,
0.9211321473,
-0.0486897863,
-0.2605284452,
0.2341819406,
0.7436231971,
-0.3057636321,
-0.1695332825,
-0.9211056232,
0.0332941115,
-0.1940084249,
-0.3495813906,
0.0713748112,
0.8024124503,
-0.1853544861,
0.2752653956,
0.3529944718,
-0.4251430929,
-0.0617765337,
0.5734702349,
1.0385645628,
-0.5855278969,
-0.4781727195,
-0.7699686289,
0.3744223714,
-0.3319627941,
-0.6190536022,
0.7773631215,
0.2564857006,
0.3035796583,
-0.07831911,
0.8584999442,
-0.4771777987,
0.5049324036,
-0.439116925,
0.530000627,
-0.9030393362,
-0.0333007537,
-0.2691062391,
-0.5825247169,
-0.3444023132,
0.5246825218,
0.0086828563,
0.2295731753,
0.766504705,
0.933247149,
-0.411151886,
0.0789148062,
0.0170943327,
-0.1943164468,
0.4185791016,
0.2909695804,
0.8873676658,
-0.2952542305,
0.3841883242,
0.0429685377,
-0.0376256183,
-0.3299772441,
-1.081171155,
-1.159766674,
-0.8115413189,
-0.3228892088,
-0.421374619,
-0.2175370902,
1.2859692574,
0.9234853983,
-0.9718901515,
0.1915371567,
0.0481562577,
0.1171903983,
-0.2010457665,
-0.2034043223,
0.3610704541,
-0.3676870465,
-0.6879975796,
0.7060301304,
0.1588471085,
0.0286936089,
0.0310264248,
0.0624440648,
-0.5157440901,
0.06586501,
0.6056978703,
0.3044802547,
-0.702907145,
-0.5131312609,
0.5587503314,
-0.1383543611,
0.2874981761,
1.3920153379,
-0.2939983904,
0.2806815207,
0.6615053415,
0.1850288808,
0.1032151878,
0.3136906326,
0.4120206535,
-1.4064599276,
0.1333066523,
0.3067611456,
0.4808245301,
0.4743282497,
-0.1217221767,
-0.1110567302,
0.4534012675,
0.0099663939,
-0.581630826,
0.3610110581,
-1.4712543488,
-0.4364486039,
1.3451696634,
0.5071436167,
0.1380241215,
-0.4401890039,
-0.5540911555,
0.2854826748,
-1.0389406681,
0.563385725,
0.608864069,
0.0643768311,
-0.3186978698,
-0.4498263001,
0.6242102981,
0.3016825914,
-0.5485234857,
0.140795812,
0.761798799,
0.1494509429,
-0.0218217671,
0.79107517,
0.0087714801,
0.2814964056,
-0.4423447251,
-0.4193260968,
-0.0066250484,
-0.4663611948,
-0.4116327465,
0.3649456203,
-0.1846536845,
-0.422080934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14296v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14296v2
|
Mitigating Biases of Large Language Models in Stance Detection with Calibration
| 2024-02-22T05:17:49 | 2024-06-16T12:04:24 |
Ang Li, Jingqian Zhao, Bin Liang, Lin Gui, Hui Wang, Xi Zeng, Xingwei Liang, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in many
natural language processing tasks. However, our experiment reveals that, in
stance detection tasks, LLMs may generate biased stances due to
sentiment-stance spurious correlations and preference towards certain
individuals and topics, thus harming their performance. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose to Mitigate Biases of LLMs in stance detection with
Calibration (MB-Cal). To be specific, a novel calibration network is devised to
calibrate potential bias in the stance prediction of LLMs. Further, to address
the challenge of effectively learning bias representations and the difficulty
in the generalizability of debiasing, we construct counterfactual augmented
data. This approach enhances the calibration network, facilitating the
debiasing and out-of-domain generalization. Experimental results on in-target
and zero-shot stance detection tasks show that the proposed MB-Cal can
effectively mitigate biases of LLMs, achieving state-of-the-art results.
|
[
-0.5473641157,
-0.8608313203,
0.4840289056,
0.0418382399,
-0.311702311,
-0.1526307017,
-0.1620472819,
-0.0219417028,
0.5982673764,
0.7597796321,
-0.5994805694,
-0.4451926053,
-0.6795832515,
-0.2910773754,
0.1190063506,
1.1456443071,
-0.029398147,
0.4519924819,
-0.2637705207,
-0.4009216726,
-0.6275785565,
-0.5704316497,
-0.4761998355,
-0.7044758797,
0.2960394621,
0.2951807082,
0.8274051547,
0.1481189132,
0.1265891492,
0.1700842083,
0.0575310178,
0.0682880655,
-0.4952527881,
0.2452867478,
-0.363335073,
-0.4969124794,
-0.7083806396,
-0.008543917,
0.8075150251,
0.8099802732,
0.2179634124,
-0.0444686785,
-0.0125827668,
0.8480318785,
-0.7648351192,
0.013079823,
-0.6300638318,
-0.0499507524,
-0.2059601694,
-0.208259955,
-0.5144793391,
-0.1430202127,
-0.1538636833,
-0.3518236279,
0.1378785372,
-0.0685227513,
0.545107007,
0.250539571,
-0.473950088,
0.1556678861,
-0.4973165691,
1.0419999361,
-0.9386714101,
0.4127958119,
0.6463598609,
0.0285372473,
-0.3547741473,
0.2458718568,
-0.5663201809,
-0.093411766,
0.1739946157,
0.018903967,
-0.004438486,
0.1181984916,
0.3478423357,
0.141281426,
-0.5427367091,
0.3158957362,
0.2789455652,
-0.5057864785,
0.4145541191,
0.0109949028,
0.2076291293,
-0.1234295368,
-0.3806993961,
-0.1216619685,
-1.1568667889,
-0.060425736,
0.6575932503,
0.3983584046,
-0.0153215565,
0.7071299553,
-0.254463613,
0.4596677423,
0.4022134244,
0.0910170451,
0.3803900778,
-0.1149763316,
-0.3058705926,
0.2047465146,
0.7501434684,
0.5381559134,
0.2211939842,
0.0785108879,
-0.1665350795,
0.2188463807,
-0.0201032031,
-0.8769378066,
-0.1123723388,
0.132277742,
-0.1795015633,
-0.3394268751,
-0.2950358093,
-0.8068157434,
-0.8238480687,
-0.5020076036,
0.4971047342,
-0.1707676798,
-0.5155285597,
0.0266380869,
0.1650250256,
0.3586571813,
0.3211547136,
-0.7808910608,
0.1318095475,
0.7698677182,
0.6261411905,
0.1375581473,
0.0263139941,
-0.8792375326,
0.1317035556,
-0.4366090596,
0.6284100413,
-0.6719816327,
-0.5087482333,
-0.148828879,
-0.2106166035,
0.1568424106,
-0.4916496575,
0.4145815969,
-0.540186286,
-0.0198721942,
-0.7035602927,
-0.5651655793,
-0.149825871,
0.8612098694,
-0.8057684302,
0.9216589332,
-0.2071328163,
-0.9668138027,
0.5139046907,
-0.4387795031,
-0.4186300337,
-0.1877691746,
-0.4322131872,
-0.4391960502,
0.0142642614,
0.4756892622,
0.4513153136,
-0.1556902081,
0.569018662,
-0.7437239885,
-0.2669701278,
0.0773750395,
-0.5765522122,
0.8147881627,
-0.1392473876,
-0.5240961313,
0.0898659453,
-0.4741666615,
-0.2649526298,
-0.1625954211,
-0.2247699946,
-0.649856627,
0.1045686975,
-0.2812332213,
0.2426537424,
0.0874804109,
-0.643191278,
0.2091357559,
-0.7784230709,
0.0196986068,
0.8108947277,
-0.0233033914,
0.6043183208,
-0.2086753249,
0.4434283078,
0.3381085098,
-0.1835204959,
-0.0976757482,
-0.219219625,
-0.79757303,
-0.2854883373,
0.0846458375,
0.4703144133,
-0.9063355923,
0.5751992464,
-0.3405819237,
-0.2206557244,
-0.2164098918,
0.4639379978,
0.5016102791,
0.7160826921,
0.2822456658,
-0.4571393728,
-0.4907552004,
-0.9564017057,
-0.5602313876,
-0.2866317928,
0.1863691062,
0.0496712923,
0.3645937741,
-0.2146587074,
1.0728187561,
-0.248144567,
-0.3790228963,
-0.1614046842,
0.2838745713,
0.1471975893,
0.387756139,
0.6705805063,
-0.9005195498,
-0.3536339104,
-0.3890405595,
-0.3671473265,
-0.2539032698,
-0.104817614,
-0.1999682188,
0.3195525408,
0.4885909855,
-0.6087849736,
0.4312324226,
0.44903934,
-0.25939551,
0.5425648689,
0.179119572,
0.066930227,
-1.1229960918,
-0.0001989453,
0.5022334456,
-0.6086210608,
-0.654987812,
-0.1220576018,
-0.0470302962,
0.3770178556,
-0.4685856104,
0.6237487793,
-0.132197395,
0.0644548759,
-0.4785358012,
0.1493250132,
0.2246755362,
0.3782671988,
0.2139307261,
0.5595365167,
0.5733147264,
-0.4961338639,
0.319730103,
0.1168202311,
-0.0166289732,
0.8913093209,
-0.3410972953,
0.0351523608,
-0.3458168209,
0.707354188,
-1.1438561678,
0.1329309791,
0.3610540032,
-0.3856882751,
0.5275501609,
-0.3361690938,
-0.3854904771,
-0.1662401855,
-0.7254712582,
0.4747033715,
-0.0382908992,
-0.5467351675,
0.5941466093,
0.5135810971,
-0.0193810016,
-1.0435649157,
-0.7158098221,
0.0588731989,
-0.1901771575,
-0.1878757626,
0.1448319405,
-0.0973348245,
-0.4054577649,
-0.3715337515,
-0.1366588026,
0.2062510848,
-0.1368349642,
0.3482353389,
0.3524981439,
-0.0453069769,
0.1946250945,
0.0373765342,
-0.0585244037,
0.1916253269,
-0.1256824583,
0.7710371614,
-0.122995615,
-0.5482183099,
-0.1758276522,
0.1714570969,
0.806928277,
0.0039837928,
0.7457823157,
0.5842944384,
-0.4360414445,
-0.0892166048,
-0.8005295992,
-0.295067668,
-0.475834161,
0.4140966237,
-0.128246665,
-0.6000751853,
0.3790283799,
-0.1699249446,
0.0927658379,
0.3052202165,
0.8338689208,
0.1997985393,
1.1283614635,
0.3920930028,
-0.8377817273,
0.4799420238,
-0.2250817567,
0.3471555412,
-0.9726079106,
0.1660654694,
-0.2954905331,
-0.4233428836,
-0.5233764648,
-0.478846103,
0.2550995052,
-0.1854070425,
-0.4644213021,
0.1934771836,
-0.0394391641,
0.3862784803,
0.3446754217,
0.2979507148,
0.1085037366,
-0.1471525878,
-0.4358529449,
-0.3110200763,
-0.2494814694,
-0.5799896121,
1.2252916098,
0.3861751258,
0.7186658382,
0.058548905,
0.5724266171,
0.364523083,
0.4510807097,
-1.020640254,
0.7124624252,
-0.1623066813,
-0.8030591607,
-0.1548567563,
-0.4742185473,
-0.3039496541,
0.3589766622,
-0.2815189064,
-0.6793725491,
0.216220066,
0.502802074,
-0.1964454502,
0.6075610518,
-0.3711228073,
0.7125196457,
-0.148054108,
-0.6700099707,
-0.3604391217,
-0.4701896012,
0.3400627971,
-0.0471268371,
0.3343863487,
-0.1782364547,
0.2306503654,
0.6055971384,
-0.3588829637,
1.3002617359,
-0.6377494335,
-0.2649036646,
0.2203527689,
0.3764360249,
0.6454780102,
0.102791585,
-0.4164597094,
0.0267901812,
-0.2560651004,
-0.2979979813,
-0.2809922099,
0.9583445787,
-0.5534771681,
-0.6216430664,
-0.2559784353,
-0.6272404194,
-0.7508549094,
0.2079669833,
0.0983032435,
0.5001772642,
-0.5595128536,
0.1636191905,
0.6904611588,
-0.2437756062,
0.3779887557,
0.5123223066,
-0.2420961112,
-0.3408482671,
0.7364765406,
-0.0658179149,
0.2017466724,
0.5213893652,
0.3243942857,
-0.4944720268,
-0.3187256753,
-0.4314670861,
0.1910312921,
-0.7633538246,
-0.3340021968,
-0.3821777403,
0.1793746054,
-0.5758929849,
-0.0446486697,
-0.4731956124,
-0.3705179393,
-0.3102734089,
-0.2075152397,
0.1928352863,
0.3058014512,
0.0040861252,
0.4681463242,
-0.498637706,
0.343247354,
0.1059129462,
0.2989477515,
-0.1398731321,
-0.5604921579,
0.0931686908,
0.4250318408,
-0.4903409183,
-0.7015241385,
0.5318744779,
0.1165101752,
0.4053133726,
0.6332572103,
0.2111352831,
0.5864813924,
-0.4942851067,
0.6698012352,
0.4574709237,
-0.958624959,
0.527415514,
-0.497836262,
0.2354018837,
0.7362139821,
0.3524263799,
-0.3029166758,
-0.2548726797,
-0.2501149178,
-0.7020192742,
0.4890582263,
-0.2111902982,
0.4129646719,
0.0046212021,
0.284547627,
0.0838727579,
0.3658854961,
-0.8831304908,
-0.0598767102,
-0.2732716799,
-0.2608773112,
-0.12754637,
-0.1184632629,
-0.1735267788,
-0.2975272238,
0.9262853861,
-0.4330604076,
-0.1455962956,
0.094458662,
-0.4117022753,
-0.3945662081,
0.3703472614,
0.4189838171,
0.3563344181,
-0.1585281938,
0.2545878887,
0.2322726697,
-0.5462092161,
0.0160353053,
-0.133848235,
-0.3852583468,
-0.1048455015,
-0.0081809051,
0.8361225128,
0.2074863762,
-0.3912784755,
0.7318613529,
0.3927879035,
-0.0430868454,
-0.1196656972,
-0.1263472438,
0.0102604516,
0.0415511765,
0.0620208904,
0.0830108821,
0.0893023908,
-0.548357904,
0.1362633705,
1.0082811117,
-0.5026933551,
-0.399215579,
0.3882294297,
0.1768652499,
0.0876674205,
0.1508230716,
-0.0023172267,
-0.9148895144,
0.5547900796,
0.6467948556,
0.7531183362,
-0.2603019178,
0.2119631022,
0.3726053834,
0.2542060614,
-0.1019928083,
0.1584596038,
0.0917285085,
-1.1288312674,
-0.4576213956,
-0.5169600248,
-0.6793622375,
0.3717677891,
-0.5463376045,
0.4511425495,
-0.5829778314,
-0.4177102149,
-0.1043046564,
0.162324056,
-0.5776366591,
0.2428610176,
0.3194306195,
0.5941002369,
-1.0565197468,
0.8630811572,
0.8626341224,
-0.1331485361,
-0.4452807307,
0.1479738206,
0.3998285532,
-0.7749654055,
0.6431547999,
0.3127656877,
-0.4659289718,
-0.2134506702,
-0.5323271751,
-0.3948383927,
0.6986413002,
0.5804400444,
-0.7124275565,
0.3223050833,
0.2996519208,
0.3761202395,
-0.2484642714,
0.2184212953,
0.4297072589,
0.5465658903,
0.0992625356,
-0.832375586,
0.0955733061,
-0.0137690129,
-0.282692194,
0.3481253386,
-0.5569053292,
0.5891938806,
0.1954286098,
0.3030175567,
-0.2815163434,
0.3491024077,
0.3560459018,
0.2943758368,
0.8340582252,
0.7871149778,
0.4959155023,
-0.0056818575,
0.6562795639,
-0.0831619501,
0.2701851428,
1.119007349,
-0.6747506261,
0.7934229374,
0.7482172847,
0.0269933622,
0.4929406941,
0.4062532485,
0.232431829,
0.3354780078,
0.2092500925,
-0.4537342191,
-0.6234299541,
-0.2371874452,
-0.0324239098,
0.4746994674,
0.5895634294,
-0.30480358,
-0.3997266591,
0.0696626604,
0.4134682715,
0.1636206061,
-0.6447930336,
0.4487650096,
0.1052955613,
-0.6412719488,
0.2787455022,
-0.0916132927,
0.9401026964,
-0.3985999823,
-0.0092610838,
-0.060287971,
0.3824179173,
-0.1642539948,
-0.7681614161,
0.1589300334,
-0.0463530011,
-0.3164123893,
-0.2539475262,
0.9734421372,
-0.3543828726,
-0.4156363308,
0.3199587464,
0.4216361344,
-0.1515839547,
-0.2553984821,
-0.5536023378,
-0.0042811441,
-0.1647050828,
-0.4965752363,
0.5140137672,
0.0647701472,
-0.2840289772,
0.4506798983,
0.5425240397,
0.2084381431,
-0.2730561495,
0.3652673364,
1.1245447397,
-0.3947481215,
-0.4307199717,
-1.1434115171,
0.1250261813,
-0.0244900007,
-0.0022427922,
0.679882586,
0.4310046136,
0.6646444201,
0.2204785049,
0.6396180391,
0.2557183206,
0.4751191139,
-0.4065971971,
0.7814475894,
-0.3747133911,
0.4104656875,
-0.3556569517,
-0.9129905701,
-0.6007565856,
0.6576972604,
-0.7047997713,
0.0417357199,
0.1911454648,
1.039157033,
-0.1177822426,
-0.1003208086,
0.2844569683,
0.1788930744,
0.4502106607,
0.4964720905,
0.4489003718,
-0.2790310979,
0.2381443679,
-0.1701707542,
-0.1755128354,
-0.2651334703,
-1.3171019554,
-1.0801012516,
-0.1955438405,
-0.4496713579,
-0.3974743485,
-0.2234817445,
1.1384336948,
0.7299830914,
-1.098482132,
0.0238763355,
-0.1604649276,
0.175414592,
0.1424528509,
-0.2250124067,
0.2323009223,
-0.106942378,
-0.6419472694,
0.439837873,
0.1579935253,
-0.2021463215,
-0.434407413,
-0.2331848443,
-0.3738416731,
0.30780375,
0.6202979684,
0.3932470083,
-0.6965703964,
-0.3994075954,
-0.0818374902,
0.0415571369,
0.1552441418,
0.8437868357,
-1.0214561224,
0.6627147198,
0.5369380116,
0.6040483713,
0.239652887,
0.0517703556,
0.6289784908,
-1.1728342772,
0.2478990257,
0.3115244806,
0.6316539049,
0.5760429502,
-0.3762418926,
0.1453913897,
0.181270048,
-0.3472574651,
-0.8736999035,
0.4201022685,
-0.833037138,
-0.0829930305,
1.2944685221,
-0.024226917,
0.0465418324,
-0.0669545233,
-0.3631567955,
0.377692312,
-0.3255055547,
0.5431177616,
0.8098293543,
0.0829785392,
0.0808162689,
-0.508520782,
0.1594055295,
0.8021423817,
-0.4985790253,
0.2410864234,
0.7715703845,
0.4112004936,
0.0742012113,
0.5231292248,
-0.1419328302,
0.0427878723,
-0.4836556017,
0.0131480312,
0.0471300632,
-0.1221489832,
-0.4434737861,
-0.2248092294,
0.0872824714,
-0.1101978198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14293v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Concept Graph Recovery and Question Answering in NLP Education
| 2024-02-22T05:15:27 | 2024-02-22T05:15:27 |
Rui Yang, Boming Yang, Sixun Ouyang, Tianwei She, Aosong Feng, Yuang Jiang, Freddy Lecue, Jinghui Lu, Irene Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the domain of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have demonstrated promise in text-generation tasks. However, their
educational applications, particularly for domain-specific queries, remain
underexplored. This study investigates LLMs' capabilities in educational
scenarios, focusing on concept graph recovery and question-answering (QA). We
assess LLMs' zero-shot performance in creating domain-specific concept graphs
and introduce TutorQA, a new expert-verified NLP-focused benchmark for
scientific graph reasoning and QA. TutorQA consists of five tasks with 500 QA
pairs. To tackle TutorQA queries, we present CGLLM, a pipeline integrating
concept graphs with LLMs for answering diverse questions. Our results indicate
that LLMs' zero-shot concept graph recovery is competitive with supervised
methods, showing an average 3% F1 score improvement. In TutorQA tasks, LLMs
achieve up to 26% F1 score enhancement. Moreover, human evaluation and analysis
show that CGLLM generates answers with more fine-grained concepts.
|
[
-0.3667131066,
-1.1002552509,
0.5254783034,
-0.2416854203,
-0.1051985472,
0.7477092147,
-0.1330895424,
-0.4451849163,
0.1763070524,
0.5312805772,
-0.3744798005,
-0.6821632385,
-0.4951554537,
0.3185810745,
-0.5556499362,
0.7750290036,
0.0682804361,
-0.2390259057,
-0.3993304372,
0.3112080097,
-0.4053034484,
-0.5985938311,
-1.0458784103,
-0.1854071766,
0.3919587135,
0.2571085095,
0.3391340673,
0.3055758178,
0.3799155056,
0.2086212784,
-0.1211016774,
0.3174749315,
-0.5742531419,
0.306543678,
-0.2573133409,
-0.4149523675,
-0.3061940074,
-0.0674305186,
0.8154458404,
1.0603592396,
-0.0094896052,
0.0079822866,
-0.0204970706,
0.4854920208,
-0.5584918261,
0.2204318941,
-0.8250790834,
0.0135276141,
0.2418047339,
-0.1022916734,
-0.4719658792,
-0.4160165489,
0.3223680556,
-0.6036401987,
0.3125656247,
0.025994679,
0.7950655222,
0.158243373,
-0.4037371278,
-0.4020361602,
-0.5075987577,
0.6572301984,
-0.784635365,
0.2821102738,
0.2447710037,
0.295696497,
-0.1806063652,
-0.8740438223,
-0.6674852967,
0.0601323172,
0.1072214022,
0.1195595562,
-0.1553858966,
0.0394716822,
0.3360610902,
0.1761008352,
-0.6321702003,
0.3435750902,
-0.510437727,
-0.2376454473,
0.6059080958,
0.2497840524,
0.3073084354,
-0.3841891587,
-0.169989109,
-0.0221883785,
-0.787419498,
0.0755486935,
-0.0866366699,
0.5567090511,
0.2726153433,
0.6470766068,
-0.2342714071,
0.9540934563,
-0.2943230867,
-0.1713245809,
0.0171280876,
-0.2868427038,
-0.2402560711,
0.0111326855,
0.6947476268,
0.1996150166,
0.5141080618,
-0.4032401145,
-0.0147543903,
0.1134620532,
0.1506101191,
-0.880189538,
-0.2638775706,
0.2788341641,
0.1852425486,
0.0449110717,
-0.2331131995,
-0.6025820374,
-0.1880305707,
-0.1705433726,
0.2281454802,
-0.4244678915,
-0.3504977524,
0.4226264656,
-0.1913266778,
0.2825002372,
0.4269997478,
-0.6064823866,
0.2988439798,
0.8921852708,
0.8539895415,
-0.5099579096,
-0.0220826156,
-0.497600615,
0.0223867092,
-0.5162826777,
0.6899930239,
-0.4832598865,
-0.5052528977,
0.0888459086,
-0.0679994375,
-0.3369833529,
-0.5769889951,
0.4084402621,
-0.8707988858,
0.315680474,
-0.1294380575,
-0.9446287751,
-0.104194127,
0.5975969434,
-0.4079526961,
0.9220972657,
0.0470745824,
-0.6865733266,
-0.0191128347,
-0.540158689,
-0.2613295913,
0.3601770997,
-0.046396181,
-0.0837498754,
-0.2678536475,
0.031172825,
0.619628191,
-0.2745089531,
0.2557720244,
-0.1377260685,
-0.2814450562,
-0.0070862444,
-0.2830482721,
0.7660052776,
-0.0196948703,
0.0062510208,
-0.113773115,
-0.6984152198,
0.4633994102,
0.2620289028,
-0.2759203017,
-0.380946219,
-0.0049433699,
-0.3770349324,
0.4293300807,
0.0401140749,
-0.7935876846,
0.1332267374,
-0.5905666947,
0.7479637861,
0.2981513143,
0.1976964772,
0.0983993709,
-0.0369908586,
0.6666457057,
-0.2817709446,
-0.5058072209,
-0.1748590022,
-0.587186873,
-0.5935499072,
-0.2580120265,
0.2952154875,
0.3783859611,
-1.1037629843,
0.2302084416,
-0.2603067756,
-0.487498045,
-0.4545487463,
-0.0257159211,
0.3713626564,
0.9035874605,
0.4193001091,
-0.1343201846,
-0.3255849779,
-0.5989082456,
-0.0165586751,
-0.2219055444,
-0.3038797975,
0.4263827503,
0.5815293789,
0.1088431925,
1.1629071236,
-0.9096077085,
-0.074433282,
-0.2530097961,
-0.1828327626,
0.1554498523,
0.2282217443,
0.5044612288,
-0.6560337543,
-0.5243748426,
-0.351346463,
-0.819262743,
0.1380963176,
0.1822253317,
-0.1709616482,
0.1019220725,
0.4240594208,
-0.9155443311,
0.1269466877,
0.4409405589,
-0.3559981585,
0.7088935971,
0.0809309259,
-0.1577308178,
-1.0790195465,
0.0446403027,
0.1442119628,
-0.4213814735,
-0.7289800048,
0.4358453453,
-0.2216480076,
-0.2576887012,
-0.4594975114,
0.7077963352,
-0.1435645968,
-0.194400236,
-0.4114153385,
1.0251805782,
0.2727730572,
0.2033372521,
0.3265812695,
0.7132790685,
0.6496821046,
-0.5844528079,
0.2287923843,
0.3918889463,
-0.2136585265,
0.5052860975,
-0.9392111301,
0.3439851701,
-0.0887850896,
0.1913107634,
-1.0246608257,
-0.1967372149,
0.0435135365,
-0.3970835507,
0.3345635831,
0.1154801697,
-0.4814217091,
-0.7218390703,
-0.186286971,
-0.0607101955,
0.3201348484,
-0.6053857207,
0.3681277931,
0.3053460419,
-0.3621382415,
-0.7242796421,
-0.1610362083,
0.2097035348,
0.1146976724,
-0.3909162879,
0.0914916769,
-0.0327972993,
-0.126170978,
0.2210694999,
-0.1658207178,
-0.0735869408,
0.4452385008,
0.0083019976,
0.4881961048,
-0.2679250538,
0.3485112488,
0.0690476447,
0.120273523,
0.2892879546,
-0.3599846959,
0.7115778327,
-0.0546916723,
-0.140615806,
0.0198265091,
0.2287010103,
0.1427310705,
-0.2894299626,
0.6338430047,
0.2823263109,
-0.5022949576,
-0.4352375567,
-0.1232855618,
-0.3206290901,
-0.3838824034,
0.6029120088,
-0.3185074627,
-1.2391760349,
0.1507966369,
-0.1017185748,
0.2394777685,
0.497582674,
0.4534220695,
-0.2391850352,
0.8198171854,
0.4290903211,
0.0701603368,
0.0045481725,
-0.627215445,
0.446228534,
-0.8699374795,
-0.1757011116,
-0.6703512073,
-0.0244316235,
-0.3403958082,
-0.4254160225,
0.1599617451,
0.4051252902,
-0.2813338637,
0.2390482277,
-0.5529591441,
0.5019644499,
0.5754119754,
-0.1963849366,
0.5553755164,
0.017559737,
-0.1009574831,
0.1440898478,
-0.7623269558,
-0.7326900363,
1.0992356539,
0.0528728776,
0.3003140092,
-0.1043523252,
0.6095926762,
-0.1140548065,
0.3583557904,
-0.9546598792,
0.8020308614,
-0.1900852025,
-0.7575365305,
-0.5936959982,
-0.6150040627,
-0.8750219345,
0.4588783383,
-0.3369507492,
-0.8403420448,
-0.3470507562,
-0.1195258796,
-0.2233330905,
0.3577488661,
-0.4897724688,
0.6809481978,
0.0680741891,
-0.190808177,
-0.1088163853,
-0.4733286798,
0.3927417696,
-0.4659041464,
-0.0318544954,
-0.2183488607,
0.2722688019,
0.6965869665,
-0.1163356155,
0.8021060228,
-0.2858259678,
-0.2492617965,
0.5561701059,
0.1197837889,
0.1174939573,
0.0328633972,
-0.1631779075,
0.1023792401,
0.2364448905,
-0.2851336002,
-0.7202982306,
0.7920122743,
-0.7589168549,
-1.0040335655,
-0.2202873081,
-0.720566988,
-0.5152599812,
0.2818488181,
-0.2607669532,
0.2278592736,
-0.0561548844,
0.2970064878,
0.536699295,
-0.2963578105,
0.5333272219,
0.683349371,
-0.3532004058,
-0.020886017,
0.9377313256,
0.1720123887,
0.4956972897,
0.255502522,
-0.0330551602,
-0.4236733913,
-0.6062878966,
-0.4072527885,
0.3023608327,
-0.6483749151,
-0.3674734533,
-0.8917484879,
-0.6664130688,
-0.29948017,
-0.1664300114,
-0.1344353706,
-0.8208533525,
-0.3460739851,
-0.3175746202,
0.0882176533,
0.4178192914,
0.2888910174,
0.179687649,
-0.7548720837,
0.2979973853,
0.4107593298,
0.137499541,
0.116097115,
-0.4825212955,
0.0203429684,
0.1404006034,
-0.3982553184,
-0.50716573,
0.3875722885,
0.4423138797,
0.3606891632,
0.1161896214,
0.0620779283,
0.2684950233,
-0.570130825,
0.9014441967,
0.1191789582,
-0.7710894942,
0.4666298926,
-0.0376775451,
0.2062399983,
0.1085396782,
0.732080698,
-0.638885498,
-0.5425097942,
-0.4338705242,
-0.7354975343,
0.471547842,
-0.0274286028,
0.3792292774,
-0.2541040182,
0.6945124865,
0.0224813893,
0.368940413,
-0.31686306,
-0.2124539614,
-0.3763875365,
-0.289511323,
-0.1812185049,
-0.0137342289,
-0.2017976791,
-0.1180737093,
0.4854506552,
-0.5492104888,
-0.0734158307,
-0.0377595276,
0.1615986973,
0.0672738478,
0.2832721174,
0.1472646743,
0.6520198584,
-0.1928082705,
0.0900243223,
-0.0698246732,
-0.4447345436,
0.0712878481,
0.1918201596,
-0.4605861008,
-0.1511307359,
0.4580633938,
0.5529020429,
0.045224335,
-0.9821370244,
0.3289630711,
-0.0701355636,
-0.3522249162,
0.0102366917,
0.4208596349,
0.5088191032,
0.1382695585,
0.5514411926,
-0.3278668523,
-0.0447557904,
-0.5063071847,
0.2134413868,
0.7273240089,
-0.0649912357,
-0.2985001802,
0.8690085411,
-0.0312885717,
-0.4378308952,
0.7541323304,
-0.0992596895,
-0.3658944666,
0.7838506103,
1.0327067375,
0.5276178718,
0.1410090476,
0.7559704185,
0.5665031075,
-0.1000851244,
0.1913855374,
0.4462917149,
0.1824911982,
-1.0817345381,
-0.6328696609,
-0.654381454,
-0.6630094647,
-0.2674008012,
-0.5873172879,
-0.0307261609,
-0.5906471014,
-0.2065688819,
0.2944387496,
0.2531074584,
-0.6028038263,
0.4914611578,
-0.0602157041,
0.906234026,
-0.497174263,
0.8629952073,
0.7336863875,
-0.2791827023,
-1.0042289495,
-0.25266698,
-0.2871065736,
-0.6920662522,
0.8113434315,
-0.0272429641,
-0.0861056745,
0.4339989722,
-0.6540611982,
-0.7882079482,
1.128513217,
0.362534821,
-0.6261626482,
-0.3629959226,
0.2289181054,
0.9210479259,
-0.4587567449,
-0.0313131958,
0.6120072007,
-0.0512367897,
0.4222917855,
-0.6294497252,
-0.0009799105,
0.0932269841,
-0.2387404144,
0.0291992072,
-0.4649315476,
0.6467146277,
-0.3973097503,
-0.3548074365,
-0.1583322585,
0.4590784013,
0.6454031467,
0.2249736637,
0.2476568669,
0.4561176598,
0.9790819287,
-0.2727057934,
1.0774606466,
-0.4353057742,
0.3327993751,
1.1278032064,
-0.3903649747,
1.1353858709,
0.1653425694,
-0.1413094997,
0.5142079592,
0.6297088265,
0.1507273912,
0.2836978436,
0.2864644825,
-0.0676675737,
-0.3590461016,
-0.4919158816,
-0.2217449546,
0.5321004391,
0.5683240294,
-0.1044869721,
-0.2024562806,
-0.0881068632,
0.031141825,
0.1276619136,
-0.4624951184,
0.512961328,
0.3783312142,
-0.4855811894,
0.7066583037,
-0.065651007,
0.258040309,
-0.3812379241,
-0.0203465968,
-0.3089696765,
-0.1655667871,
-0.0649474785,
-0.9173167348,
0.0327017568,
0.0769980699,
-0.047047317,
0.1259326339,
0.7645294666,
-0.5569429994,
-0.4192939401,
0.2423460186,
0.7632739544,
0.0370991193,
0.1291471422,
-0.4843269885,
-0.1915916353,
-0.2328351289,
-0.1362995505,
0.2956525981,
0.2906160355,
0.0677790269,
0.9438689351,
0.4958676696,
0.2363286614,
0.1543366462,
0.229223147,
0.9386294484,
-0.4188554585,
-0.0173041448,
-0.4903721213,
0.1750363261,
-0.1756411344,
-0.2159488499,
0.8454290032,
0.4347633719,
0.990065515,
0.0510045439,
0.7768431902,
0.2249092162,
0.7376363277,
-0.5219013095,
0.3822143674,
-0.4816021025,
0.1300795227,
-0.4086848497,
-0.9684194326,
-0.4628136754,
0.4542786181,
-0.3375737071,
-0.167671591,
0.6854777336,
0.410622716,
0.3461273313,
0.1362721175,
0.3782643378,
0.1830620468,
0.6449881792,
0.5730757117,
0.8004798293,
-0.2661140263,
0.3285282254,
0.0457782596,
0.1268863976,
0.1118887588,
-0.562479198,
-1.0439306498,
-0.2972075641,
-0.4512095153,
-0.2441702783,
-0.0217726212,
0.8131749034,
0.45777601,
-0.819478929,
0.0522216633,
0.1753892899,
0.2773765922,
-0.015081373,
-0.3097506166,
0.6499854326,
-0.4260461926,
-0.9505853653,
0.5242165923,
0.3621732891,
-0.1064130068,
-0.4869302511,
0.069425635,
-0.2063877136,
0.2387875319,
0.8763229251,
0.3511392176,
-0.4870235026,
-0.5385017991,
0.3857415915,
-0.0928947181,
-0.0841526985,
0.6282939315,
-0.8973738551,
0.4667637348,
0.1996331215,
0.9875439405,
0.4683178067,
0.1739398241,
0.3347338736,
-0.7676796913,
-0.1197448075,
0.4512009621,
0.2362378389,
0.4804477096,
-0.0525058582,
0.7492836714,
0.3252704442,
-0.4222140908,
-0.9222980738,
0.1748195887,
-0.6741949916,
-0.4722080231,
1.052568078,
-0.3914032876,
0.0308875889,
-0.1565531045,
-0.0502764434,
0.0403217748,
-0.0035081194,
0.917416513,
0.7170612812,
0.0262544863,
-0.1260240078,
-0.6399497986,
0.3718473911,
0.1445187032,
-0.9399173856,
-0.1278690547,
0.55915308,
0.4089471102,
0.2860215306,
0.6604893208,
0.0276887082,
-0.0285304412,
-0.0937121212,
-0.0940729156,
-0.1096823812,
-0.3420394659,
0.1314537525,
0.6119750142,
0.1694939435,
0.0848458335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14290v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14290v1
|
CEV-LM: Controlled Edit Vector Language Model for Shaping Natural Language Generations
| 2024-02-22T05:07:31 | 2024-02-22T05:07:31 |
Samraj Moorjani, Adit Krishnan, Hari Sundaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As large-scale language models become the standard for text generation, there
is a greater need to tailor the generations to be more or less concise,
targeted, and informative, depending on the audience/application. Existing
control approaches primarily adjust the semantic (e.g., emotion, topics),
structural (e.g., syntax tree, parts-of-speech), and lexical (e.g.,
keyword/phrase inclusion) properties of text, but are insufficient to
accomplish complex objectives such as pacing which control the complexity and
readability of the text. In this paper, we introduce CEV-LM - a lightweight,
semi-autoregressive language model that utilizes constrained edit vectors to
control three complementary metrics (speed, volume, and circuitousness) that
quantify the shape of text (e.g., pacing of content). We study an extensive set
of state-of-the-art CTG models and find that CEV-LM provides significantly more
targeted and precise control of these three metrics while preserving semantic
content, using less training data, and containing fewer parameters.
|
[
-0.3821329772,
-1.1931903362,
0.3790844381,
0.2182975858,
-0.3505650461,
0.0528367497,
-0.4065581262,
-0.2640920579,
0.0369952135,
0.6401685476,
-0.4695879519,
-0.5490033031,
-0.4433801174,
0.1624048501,
-0.5064938068,
0.6843828559,
-0.1335868388,
-0.2482933402,
-0.0991079137,
-0.1524840593,
-0.5065761209,
-0.3410411477,
-0.591445148,
-0.3104646802,
0.335539192,
0.374792248,
1.1716214418,
1.3627728224,
0.1489872187,
0.2907905877,
-0.5767638683,
0.0675350428,
-0.4545298219,
0.2375718653,
-0.1351741254,
-0.3486100137,
-0.5404219031,
-0.1988973171,
0.8284751773,
0.5560301542,
-0.0810340345,
-0.0716800392,
0.1418451816,
0.8544694781,
-0.5444743037,
-0.1661297083,
-0.5463077426,
-0.092873469,
-0.1933335066,
-0.4299468994,
-0.4148985147,
-0.4638600349,
0.2132052034,
-0.4790267646,
0.2794531286,
0.0790257826,
0.616258502,
0.3427389264,
-0.4939223826,
-0.3484483361,
-1.0386002064,
0.8554432392,
-0.5825302601,
0.6192654967,
0.1119931415,
-0.1534830779,
-0.1499463022,
-0.6321157217,
-0.5229222178,
-0.3272485733,
0.2024417073,
0.0633540228,
-0.1223373562,
0.3840887547,
-0.0486050881,
0.2476215512,
-0.5430696607,
0.3740185201,
-0.3163539469,
-0.347153753,
0.4717155695,
0.4745641947,
0.4343317151,
-0.2587114871,
-0.5463829637,
0.0165083352,
-0.5919793844,
0.207577765,
0.4664724469,
0.1862125844,
-0.0022911686,
0.7358447313,
-0.5084506869,
0.9958866835,
0.1267898232,
-0.1238742918,
-0.0036019164,
-0.3932097554,
-0.2288005501,
0.2206101269,
0.8351593614,
0.4170382619,
0.1761840582,
-0.0273208637,
-0.2074165791,
0.1238514557,
0.228026852,
-0.8005532622,
-0.10768608,
0.3066508472,
-0.5970029831,
-0.4022035599,
-0.2937773466,
-0.7761521935,
-0.2494942099,
-0.7402231693,
0.2138191313,
-0.6430476308,
0.0643980801,
0.1888091564,
-0.0732234642,
0.2863169014,
0.3664667308,
-0.9164631963,
0.2994002998,
0.465192765,
0.8397575617,
-0.5414831042,
-0.0284831449,
-0.5871143341,
0.1350568533,
-0.1101436615,
0.5486814976,
-0.965397954,
-0.6966599226,
0.1606050432,
-0.1995942295,
0.0957213342,
-0.2102604508,
0.6621112823,
-0.5697771907,
0.2732973099,
0.1109879762,
-0.7308720946,
0.1101557985,
0.1695451736,
-0.5657910705,
1.0768635273,
-0.0229238495,
-0.7869118452,
0.3877224922,
-0.2310444117,
-0.425421834,
0.0213850271,
0.1205417961,
-0.5050977468,
0.2265591323,
0.1905426979,
0.3885980844,
-0.0647636205,
0.0956569165,
-0.131970048,
0.0156829171,
-0.0537720956,
-0.4554694295,
0.2610411644,
0.2970674336,
-0.0813357234,
0.3753834069,
-0.9954482317,
0.1474368274,
-0.0166985858,
-0.5770279765,
-0.5295017958,
0.2487211525,
0.1822226644,
0.3902781606,
0.3961714804,
-0.4913089573,
0.2676143646,
-0.366615802,
0.5789883733,
0.4125951231,
0.2035681605,
0.8690689802,
-0.3998451531,
0.6112675667,
-0.2671269178,
0.3257541955,
-0.1507735848,
-0.2704115808,
-0.9236468673,
-0.1389445812,
0.1978569031,
0.5760552883,
-0.7653803825,
0.3841993511,
-0.1147392988,
-0.7685970664,
-0.4096509516,
0.4154067338,
0.2191727161,
0.4073320925,
0.3898300827,
-0.2191204578,
-0.2326309532,
-0.7255048752,
-0.443964988,
-0.0125218453,
0.0716643184,
0.0472431108,
0.0942835137,
-0.1015120149,
0.9038294554,
-0.3162180185,
-0.0455604941,
-0.4826845229,
0.2915003896,
-0.3225531578,
0.403591454,
0.1060860604,
-0.7734804749,
-0.3186579347,
-0.166342482,
-0.1220686957,
-0.5543548465,
-0.3603718579,
-0.0917790309,
-0.0411116704,
0.8445503116,
-0.3822106123,
0.3673138916,
0.6265059114,
-0.4765310585,
0.3618307412,
-0.5415007472,
-0.1154580414,
-0.8774335384,
-0.170682475,
0.1344138831,
-0.4968420565,
-0.811444521,
-0.2194654197,
0.4624867439,
0.2269448489,
-0.7453091145,
0.4323906898,
-0.4079195559,
0.3848402202,
-0.5606076121,
0.4838971496,
0.0715894476,
0.3530895114,
0.2322671711,
0.4605024159,
0.2316300422,
-1.0525491238,
0.1995434761,
0.3342396319,
-0.087960124,
0.5467722416,
-0.8434087634,
0.079402402,
-0.392631501,
0.0130572934,
-0.3729816675,
0.0395175628,
-0.361672461,
-0.3221456707,
0.3467925787,
0.095704481,
-0.4583749771,
-0.035681434,
-0.1838807911,
0.2638221383,
0.6320355535,
-0.2432585955,
0.5446709394,
0.2560699582,
-0.3090008795,
-0.1321290731,
-0.4029760063,
-0.071149312,
-0.2807573378,
-0.4910036922,
0.6260508299,
-0.1909608245,
-0.2707217336,
-0.0431169644,
0.2519251108,
0.0539255142,
-0.0306568034,
0.1165969744,
0.3194736838,
0.0092231743,
0.3210362792,
0.1388990283,
-0.1168873161,
-0.18988204,
-0.3193627,
0.5896864533,
0.1548534036,
-0.0549313053,
-0.4404770136,
0.1481077671,
0.6422261596,
-0.6112046242,
0.6003607512,
0.3266268075,
-0.2380979359,
-0.611327529,
-0.2781396508,
0.185283497,
-0.4699908793,
0.3620030284,
0.0903677046,
-1.2194634676,
0.3105882704,
-0.1328488886,
0.0781237483,
0.6409778595,
0.9672728777,
0.250805527,
1.1033678055,
0.8817116022,
0.0498177111,
0.7245367765,
0.1496390551,
-0.217134133,
-0.7420231104,
-0.2578867972,
-0.7171404958,
-0.2549130619,
-0.824185431,
-0.4028838277,
0.1966230571,
0.2087996453,
-0.0796814561,
0.2824601829,
-0.7019914985,
0.2526688576,
0.41391325,
-0.1506848633,
0.4872487485,
-0.6363583803,
-0.2391051948,
0.0094115613,
-0.786734879,
-0.7924745083,
0.7922354937,
0.4552375972,
0.9188346267,
-0.19705531,
0.3598927557,
0.3430378437,
-0.0054240567,
-0.7057824135,
0.3178628981,
-0.1873955578,
-0.5524398088,
-0.3154249489,
-0.3521725535,
-0.8863819838,
0.1189840063,
-0.4248384237,
-0.6173115373,
0.1628789157,
0.5308263898,
-0.373203963,
0.3677037656,
-0.4719959199,
0.7607259154,
-0.3154343963,
-0.3638447821,
0.0103223026,
-0.5057315826,
0.2030340731,
-0.2617108524,
0.264282167,
-0.2076317519,
-0.2843161225,
0.5935535431,
-0.7050671577,
0.6303722858,
0.0239767134,
0.0970835686,
0.6418332458,
0.3005867898,
0.9134309292,
-0.0252576731,
0.1291504055,
-0.2471809238,
0.032075692,
-0.3530252874,
-0.266174376,
0.6764268279,
-0.6688918471,
-0.230300203,
-0.115000464,
-0.5101292729,
-0.1432021111,
0.2884964049,
0.5668666363,
0.5835296512,
-0.6236948967,
0.394906491,
0.9207392335,
-0.5089735985,
0.5741187334,
0.3875325322,
-0.2781759799,
-0.2853624225,
0.6642182469,
0.0643964857,
0.8422795534,
0.5557498932,
0.2783487141,
-0.2542058527,
-0.7927720547,
-0.1774775982,
-0.1359124929,
-0.4233043492,
0.0015136721,
-0.9078870416,
-0.0820237845,
-0.12425448,
-0.4559883475,
-0.4824123383,
-0.4850550294,
-0.4987871051,
-0.0062362212,
0.3738372922,
0.8502485752,
0.1775825024,
0.6984174252,
-0.800989747,
0.3740322292,
0.2413444668,
0.356308639,
-0.3799262047,
-0.6001038551,
-0.1464686841,
-0.1253477037,
-0.3935105503,
-0.8451753259,
0.6860779524,
0.2494814098,
0.1218489408,
0.0806696638,
-0.0278634895,
0.2060501277,
-0.7089295387,
0.8348539472,
0.1338847131,
-1.0624626875,
0.6018878818,
-0.3931829929,
0.7258589268,
0.3978104293,
-0.2032803893,
-0.7539410591,
-0.6637688875,
-0.501321733,
-0.8047637343,
0.3497617841,
0.4162707031,
0.2746946216,
-0.0174364988,
0.3272479475,
0.0668185651,
-0.0315591805,
-0.3768895268,
-0.1393971592,
-0.2328502238,
-0.4115702212,
0.1930491179,
-0.3187125325,
0.488104105,
-0.0459318124,
0.7277981639,
0.0740206018,
-0.1553606391,
0.4051500261,
-0.1217829436,
-0.1974031925,
0.5564463735,
0.6882917881,
0.4055379927,
-0.0823125318,
0.1296956092,
0.3296644986,
-0.700504005,
0.0355121009,
0.028751485,
-0.5593242049,
0.1700281054,
0.2530041337,
0.9135138392,
0.1278052479,
-0.4627947509,
0.3722979128,
-0.1197274551,
-0.274764657,
-0.2003406882,
0.2584870458,
-0.0411454625,
0.0736094788,
-0.091065459,
-0.0788729563,
-0.1223433465,
-0.0556290932,
0.1625334322,
0.2927295268,
-0.7295265198,
-0.3199133873,
1.2060306072,
0.3427158892,
-0.4115754962,
0.3252571523,
-0.083118543,
-0.4126288295,
0.4982034862,
0.3303393424,
0.9778562784,
-0.1790437698,
0.1478149444,
0.2489622235,
0.6387140155,
-0.1300664693,
0.3037228584,
0.1330558807,
-0.7412217855,
-0.559897244,
-0.797047317,
-0.2726136744,
0.184632197,
-0.5544705987,
0.5386881232,
-0.523337841,
-0.2087048143,
0.0702856183,
-0.2106945217,
-0.9901390076,
0.4667405188,
0.1647378951,
1.2489125729,
-0.6369943619,
1.0663048029,
0.4580028951,
-0.1368347257,
-0.5335775614,
-0.2175704241,
0.049741853,
-0.4864816666,
0.1489959061,
-0.1753979027,
-0.0166172199,
0.209751159,
-0.683480382,
-0.8188988566,
1.0590282679,
-0.1289026588,
-0.7945559025,
-0.0963976607,
0.1289382577,
0.5784665942,
-0.270113498,
-0.2627121508,
0.6567037702,
0.3608276248,
0.0316871703,
-0.8148836493,
-0.2617126703,
0.0109765641,
0.3072533607,
0.619743526,
-0.6620349884,
0.5265593529,
-0.0391871519,
-0.1117300838,
-0.0238612164,
0.994289577,
-0.0090200072,
0.0144554265,
0.4656029642,
0.3983686268,
0.6633470058,
-0.0104143852,
1.0961703062,
-0.5915816426,
0.2138626128,
1.0346530676,
-0.0062220022,
0.646569252,
0.4093423188,
0.1859215051,
0.1207902282,
0.4621793032,
0.2083739787,
0.3783085346,
0.1566504538,
-0.3118081391,
-0.3193456233,
-0.2125247121,
0.0660080016,
0.4445541799,
0.4197818637,
-0.6054341793,
-0.025225997,
0.04351753,
0.3584849238,
0.4475627542,
-0.526602149,
0.6614633799,
0.0257697497,
-0.456834048,
0.332362026,
0.3198129237,
0.5153306723,
-0.6970232725,
0.2941579223,
0.0657488257,
-0.0212040786,
0.0100037223,
-0.617600441,
0.2369059771,
0.3157851994,
-0.1669838578,
-0.4474548697,
0.8793346882,
-0.6372500658,
-0.4878413975,
0.0185604319,
0.5002762675,
-0.3256300092,
0.1577714682,
-0.548432827,
0.3147500753,
-0.0036268942,
-0.4939907193,
-0.0660386682,
0.6853218079,
-0.1243302971,
0.6077824831,
0.3944270909,
0.3810378015,
0.3840177655,
-0.1311891079,
0.6781061888,
-0.7911416888,
-0.4972984791,
-0.8875709176,
0.6031841636,
-0.0163670778,
-0.6765514016,
0.5352137685,
0.3925327659,
0.6799872518,
0.3319911361,
0.9606996179,
-0.0182459541,
0.3871562779,
-0.7780343294,
0.5824837685,
-0.3028537631,
-0.0528789088,
-0.1750993133,
-1.0945930481,
-0.3418972492,
-0.0478835627,
-0.2034844756,
0.034018103,
0.5939245224,
0.5186526775,
0.2162988633,
-0.089394547,
0.430082798,
0.3208911717,
0.3697187603,
0.4547537863,
0.6233862042,
0.1080831438,
0.5502189994,
-0.3088747859,
-0.1776481271,
-0.089667134,
-1.0636751652,
-0.856166482,
-0.4126679003,
-0.4582747221,
-0.2767842114,
-0.2075745016,
1.0113813877,
0.3980915844,
-0.6534626484,
0.2057032734,
-0.3147495687,
-0.0456512384,
0.1333037019,
-0.1127926111,
0.4017922878,
-0.3465244174,
-0.8310307264,
0.3862168491,
0.5271689296,
0.1422329098,
-0.3365650773,
-0.1499707103,
0.0298927203,
0.507121563,
0.5214322209,
0.3518199623,
-0.6168060899,
-0.3507211506,
0.0942901671,
-0.5108896494,
0.0633876026,
0.8698190451,
-0.6780801415,
1.0579442978,
0.7158362865,
0.4818916917,
0.2905538976,
0.118297711,
0.7543137074,
-0.672005713,
0.0381088033,
0.2393403649,
0.2954056263,
0.4391611516,
-0.3291399479,
-0.0254441947,
0.1402905136,
-0.7988476753,
-0.261339426,
0.3549593687,
-0.9506634474,
-0.1590073109,
1.4405055046,
0.5554599762,
-0.3227110803,
-0.1695450246,
-0.4781485498,
0.6188304424,
-0.2255944461,
0.4398101866,
0.6388853788,
0.1161116511,
-0.1979969591,
-0.9161396623,
0.8631134629,
0.2146045119,
-0.6894262433,
0.1047350541,
0.6108003259,
0.1932293475,
-0.2807483375,
0.4486232698,
-0.2268681377,
-0.063334249,
-0.419999212,
0.3947069943,
0.0195558555,
-0.1748070568,
-0.5479776263,
0.1184972972,
0.1928678155,
0.0333667547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14289v1
|
TinyLLaVA: A Framework of Small-scale Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-02-22T05:05:30 | 2024-02-22T05:05:30 |
Baichuan Zhou, Ying Hu, Xi Weng, Junlong Jia, Jie Luo, Xien Liu, Ji Wu, Lei Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We present the TinyLLaVA framework that provides a unified perspective in
designing and analyzing the small-scale Large Multimodal Models (LMMs). We
empirically study the effects of different vision encoders, connection modules,
language models, training data and training recipes. Our extensive experiments
showed that better quality of data combined with better training recipes,
smaller LMMs can consistently achieve on-par performances compared to bigger
LMMs. Under our framework, we train a family of small-scale LMMs. Our best
model, TinyLLaVA-3.1B, achieves better overall performance against existing 7B
models such as LLaVA-1.5 and Qwen-VL. We hope our findings can serve as
baselines for future research in terms of data scaling, training setups and
model selections. Our model weights and codes will be made public.
|
[
-0.252743423,
-0.6183689237,
0.5624807477,
0.0134480428,
-0.0498544835,
-0.4773094356,
-0.3181809783,
-0.4009577036,
0.2769041061,
0.2734011412,
-0.4403024614,
-0.0811830759,
-0.3713457584,
-0.0115417838,
-0.2301946431,
0.2961420417,
0.3890678883,
0.4328567982,
-0.1516490281,
-0.3044149876,
-0.5914925933,
-0.0235815886,
-0.6453203559,
-0.2009397,
0.9513059258,
0.7627055645,
0.7455031872,
0.643193543,
0.538346529,
0.215201512,
-0.0831477046,
0.1284854263,
-0.3799418509,
-0.2007098049,
-0.0623006299,
-0.701212883,
-0.6410600543,
-0.3760506511,
0.7792658806,
0.7000616789,
-0.1552473754,
0.5607219338,
0.0891393051,
0.5915340185,
-0.6289635897,
0.2084628344,
-0.2002142221,
0.1286046356,
-0.3073908389,
0.2317773849,
-0.5466422439,
-0.4031014442,
-0.1900234967,
-0.4383378923,
0.142358616,
0.3072039783,
0.4475277662,
0.3113129139,
-0.6601334214,
-0.0435965508,
-0.6418839097,
0.7294589877,
-0.5258935094,
0.4910343289,
0.0951694772,
0.6835609078,
0.0425553434,
-0.7096242309,
-0.6087709069,
-0.1758013666,
0.0386571065,
-0.1377945393,
-0.324129194,
0.1089127138,
0.0894700438,
0.3075648546,
-0.6075115204,
0.3871434033,
-0.6479410529,
0.0727792308,
0.5145436525,
0.6896511912,
0.0929770246,
-0.3372737765,
-0.0239352081,
-0.1733735353,
-0.9240272641,
0.218158111,
0.1020104662,
0.5049090981,
-0.3616225719,
0.7019965053,
-0.4426405728,
0.8755038381,
0.1947686225,
-0.5603862405,
0.1032116041,
-0.4982076883,
-0.7058477998,
-0.1760929972,
0.7157917619,
0.4847131968,
-0.1202002764,
0.135022372,
-0.0453458056,
0.2294027656,
0.1726906151,
-0.8366493583,
-0.3487364948,
0.0081198718,
-0.9292907119,
-0.5459223986,
-0.3088628352,
-1.0302021503,
-0.6909862161,
-0.2759564817,
0.7794340253,
-0.3048056066,
-0.4293513298,
0.0281981397,
0.0491793267,
0.2171690911,
0.6426044106,
-0.9881926775,
0.164762795,
0.3448316157,
0.8152515292,
0.1745295227,
-0.1867140085,
-0.5269581079,
-0.0182625595,
-0.463884443,
0.5879824758,
-0.4715820253,
-0.32567662,
0.0172695331,
-0.0143313631,
-0.0853039175,
-0.5521816015,
0.0983683169,
-0.3018029332,
-0.2214974761,
-0.2963055372,
-0.2241941839,
-0.2179338932,
0.2599421442,
-0.99908638,
0.5682947636,
-0.1797584742,
-0.4231727123,
0.4494793713,
-0.580216229,
0.0114446767,
-0.1279699653,
-0.3703847229,
-0.0915330276,
0.5751700997,
0.0704984069,
0.6052873731,
-0.6163347363,
-0.2305147797,
-0.683848381,
-0.1597335637,
0.1574091762,
-0.3901951611,
0.5012988448,
0.2543207705,
0.2260818928,
0.4012572467,
-0.9900302887,
-0.0045658499,
0.1041796729,
-0.3063628674,
-0.4278848767,
-0.2505151331,
0.4696236551,
0.2763076425,
-0.0332003832,
-0.5458212495,
0.2579785883,
-0.3103466332,
0.5128763318,
0.7332438231,
-0.1125456691,
0.885500133,
-0.2844825387,
0.6020283103,
-0.0390713401,
0.6048294902,
-0.2270805538,
-0.6394526362,
-0.8183540702,
-0.4699067771,
0.442853421,
-0.1526263952,
-0.9449367523,
-0.2376556844,
-0.5862694979,
-0.5735478401,
-0.5478566289,
0.3514153063,
0.284573257,
0.1744054705,
-0.027525872,
-0.2289763093,
-0.4323669076,
-1.2652363777,
0.3376630843,
-0.0205394886,
-0.0851097926,
0.0674429312,
0.6822339892,
-0.4159967601,
1.0123791695,
-0.3151271045,
-0.5522847772,
-0.3543617427,
-0.1982384771,
-0.1330062598,
0.3838229477,
0.7691645622,
-0.9141740799,
-0.3270113766,
0.1114339605,
-0.7829179168,
0.4463278055,
0.1471001208,
0.2521313131,
-0.1275806278,
0.2021861672,
-0.463799417,
0.3932318985,
0.7110687494,
-0.2385256439,
0.4336353838,
-0.2406467199,
0.1300288141,
-1.0288327932,
-0.0912177265,
0.0427347422,
-0.3272958994,
-0.6402073503,
0.4016291797,
0.4617883861,
-0.1458529085,
-0.7652451992,
0.62722224,
-0.1719620377,
-0.2460412681,
-0.0886298642,
-0.0985000134,
0.1886483282,
0.3341362178,
-0.1445141286,
0.773499012,
0.3860057294,
-0.4048445225,
0.6912549138,
0.0505696312,
-0.518858254,
0.8160465956,
-0.7931156754,
-0.2612053454,
-0.0373194069,
0.1325996518,
-0.8870604634,
-0.5845014453,
-0.0660972074,
-0.2644695938,
0.1219448596,
-0.2374942154,
-0.8924706578,
-0.3757735789,
-0.4706667364,
0.4377143383,
0.435256958,
-0.7551977038,
0.8701369762,
0.4291144013,
0.0988399386,
0.0864645615,
-0.816280365,
-0.0488265008,
-0.4404875934,
-0.9084943533,
-0.236521408,
-0.1540826857,
-0.4257897735,
-0.1534227878,
0.1776839048,
-0.3105184734,
-0.2780531347,
0.6152770519,
0.1176263094,
-0.4941173196,
0.3203873336,
-0.1900330335,
-0.0192255471,
-0.3354260921,
-0.1330331415,
0.2703977227,
-0.4434939921,
-0.0761127919,
-0.3948212564,
0.4040344954,
0.6072757244,
-0.0353175886,
0.8066073656,
0.6005712748,
-0.4479832947,
-0.151999563,
-0.4584581554,
-0.0904587358,
-0.4874705076,
0.1382605284,
-0.5958376527,
-0.8976114392,
0.4031433165,
0.0418726504,
-0.2375563234,
0.4004389942,
1.0389378071,
-0.4381158948,
1.0635179281,
1.1997929811,
0.2404014766,
0.4394434094,
-0.3224021792,
-0.2307584733,
-0.8442961574,
-0.3545798361,
-0.140452221,
-0.2896925211,
-0.2721279562,
-0.7702026367,
0.5916212201,
-0.1282751262,
-0.0657953471,
0.1700512171,
-0.1113030836,
0.4166975617,
0.3147158921,
0.0640816987,
0.3685088754,
-0.1223965064,
-0.1833248883,
-0.088976346,
-1.1795115471,
-0.3620071411,
1.4186530113,
0.4860041738,
1.3380082846,
0.4176364243,
0.3357438445,
0.524056673,
0.0855378956,
-0.7809032202,
0.4542255998,
0.0261471309,
-0.7954187393,
-0.128607139,
-0.3176917136,
-0.8771745563,
0.5819732547,
-0.3574082553,
-0.7103062272,
0.6334385872,
0.391864568,
-0.9324921966,
0.1915130019,
-1.0649827719,
1.1247147322,
-0.1058512628,
-0.4737837613,
-0.3629018068,
-0.4077798724,
0.7331104875,
-0.3229319155,
0.4115085304,
0.0932445005,
-0.1370325983,
0.7502911687,
-0.2898771167,
1.0774621964,
0.002475451,
-0.1903370768,
0.1751666665,
0.0243059322,
0.1677102447,
0.2563695908,
0.2618105412,
0.1515342891,
0.2575029135,
-0.3563304543,
-0.3548141122,
0.9534717798,
-0.8239433169,
0.0251470916,
-0.310106039,
-0.3032288849,
-0.1246991605,
0.1670026183,
0.2866589725,
0.7296705842,
-0.3043453693,
0.6177546382,
0.8290335536,
0.0167346448,
0.4336549342,
0.4060588777,
-0.6200138927,
-0.2277896404,
0.8171285987,
0.2873720825,
0.2246947885,
0.3424491584,
-0.0045702923,
-0.0340213962,
-0.3406231105,
-0.6527094841,
0.0857411399,
-0.7548660636,
-0.2367521226,
-0.2818387449,
0.2121745199,
-0.2624275386,
0.0951648355,
-0.9996060729,
-0.4616642892,
-0.1241510436,
0.1501400918,
0.101430431,
0.8299837708,
-0.2150220275,
0.6137908697,
-0.6908219457,
0.3891541362,
0.8268710971,
0.1466567069,
0.1648338735,
-0.3565047681,
-0.7066591978,
0.0354166366,
-0.0084207989,
-0.4558776915,
0.2149957865,
0.1367877126,
0.2009354383,
0.5194264054,
-0.2386896014,
0.6521735191,
-0.7041447759,
0.9224180579,
0.7169531584,
-0.4884137213,
0.5901033878,
-0.3495472074,
0.3610230684,
0.4569437802,
-0.1780066639,
-0.2742423415,
0.2088475227,
-0.5413291454,
-0.4093341529,
0.4864749312,
0.1857166737,
-0.2298518717,
0.3804700673,
0.0702539459,
0.2305694968,
0.3155097365,
-0.5010712743,
-0.0143277487,
-0.0872285515,
-0.341473788,
-0.3291776478,
-0.3235978186,
-0.3029184341,
-0.2641443312,
0.1105014831,
-0.3171568215,
0.3694257438,
-0.2836334407,
-0.427556783,
-0.2204948217,
0.0095979115,
0.6668958664,
0.6911168694,
-0.3104555607,
0.1173416302,
0.1107434034,
-0.384335041,
0.1780352145,
-0.3230514824,
-0.0689354464,
-0.1388382763,
0.4596751332,
0.7323983908,
0.5476408601,
-0.7125480175,
0.6068918705,
-0.5243160725,
0.1203551069,
-0.3804247081,
0.2875806093,
0.0770956054,
0.7875433564,
0.1859053373,
0.3686802387,
0.1000299528,
-0.5939610004,
-0.0813785866,
0.2114069611,
-0.1031705216,
-0.5792328119,
0.7722660899,
0.3298867643,
-0.015861854,
-0.0181633458,
0.1320754141,
0.2284490764,
0.6836982369,
0.1498876363,
0.4438581765,
-0.0143739115,
0.1225602254,
0.1284819692,
0.5097783208,
-0.271695137,
-0.0134213436,
-0.0790335014,
-0.5234850645,
-0.1438006014,
-0.8333352208,
-0.4319742024,
0.0418062396,
-0.8842017651,
0.0719778314,
-0.5141898394,
-0.3683546782,
0.2536574006,
0.0309819486,
-1.1732313633,
0.3646437526,
0.4337288737,
1.0144124031,
-0.8437030315,
1.4222878218,
0.7799372077,
-0.6614319086,
-0.6798306704,
-0.2652687728,
0.4938849807,
-0.7805323005,
0.7497417927,
-0.0368715785,
-0.1801825762,
-0.0861510411,
-0.3888325989,
-0.946406424,
1.3042336702,
0.193272531,
-0.7650872469,
-0.2454770803,
-0.0982744098,
0.3790856004,
-0.6716573238,
-0.0780056119,
0.5443184972,
0.1762669832,
-0.013542274,
-1.0024030209,
-0.4203434587,
-0.1451611221,
0.6187998652,
-0.1752048582,
-0.9913619757,
0.9958589077,
-0.1616402268,
0.1662784666,
0.4916308224,
0.58734411,
0.0142677259,
0.2502571344,
0.3274182379,
0.3982316256,
0.5295645595,
-0.0145718073,
1.1228950024,
0.2180374563,
0.4939804375,
1.0462538004,
-0.1129136682,
0.996198833,
0.6415216923,
-0.1881057769,
-0.0554887839,
0.6818620563,
0.1575077027,
0.8017958999,
-0.3384935558,
0.1611509025,
-0.2519980669,
0.0571944751,
-0.6056721807,
0.601111412,
0.3944257796,
-0.2252123356,
-0.0890135169,
0.8066556454,
-0.326482594,
-0.2194157541,
-0.7627481222,
0.4649405479,
0.1584751159,
0.0435837582,
0.4376927018,
0.2751680017,
0.8289324641,
-0.6724200845,
0.4022111893,
-0.5132724643,
0.5992901921,
-0.063200444,
-0.5448735952,
-0.0085393088,
0.0364096947,
-0.4880161285,
0.0547452308,
0.7690609097,
-0.2433733195,
-0.6649191976,
0.1613842696,
0.4155429304,
-0.2401900887,
0.0810154304,
-0.4115323126,
0.5188903213,
-0.2341925353,
-0.1485255361,
0.6951726079,
0.4328815639,
0.1992759854,
0.6888388395,
0.4113539457,
0.1255711466,
0.3968072236,
0.0347863697,
0.7459647655,
-0.63117522,
-0.6924244165,
-0.5583571196,
0.4461058676,
-0.1440959871,
-0.1639727056,
1.0572410822,
0.4297551811,
0.6745580435,
-0.3976590633,
0.4722644985,
-0.0042548799,
0.1872018725,
-0.5935388207,
0.6592103839,
-1.0880124569,
0.0467307568,
0.0032689706,
-0.7971080542,
-0.3426913917,
0.6832202673,
-0.1979049444,
-0.2060501128,
0.480838716,
0.810107708,
-0.3336743116,
0.0206023827,
0.8278028965,
0.3379436135,
0.2079591751,
0.807245791,
0.8816484213,
-0.5943827033,
0.4055492282,
-0.2093746215,
-0.1723922938,
-0.8121526241,
-0.3992509842,
-0.8943474889,
-0.4182959199,
-0.0783363655,
-0.0021907638,
-0.1263230592,
0.9005064368,
0.9171968102,
-0.3341470659,
-0.3201760352,
0.5097596049,
-0.0751949176,
-0.1183465794,
-0.1098200679,
0.1381670982,
0.1501184255,
-0.5532364845,
0.4379282594,
0.4738633633,
-0.1428891569,
-0.6241188049,
-0.4257589579,
0.0172973908,
0.2455930263,
1.0571228266,
0.3591966033,
-0.823823452,
-0.5441238284,
-0.3422862589,
-0.3724614978,
0.0024488815,
0.5672875047,
-0.7151749134,
0.6781921387,
0.1938679665,
0.3236411214,
0.5476260781,
-0.5808882713,
0.3021488786,
-0.7443959713,
0.6899874806,
-0.1103823557,
0.6141118407,
0.2373490036,
0.2108269781,
0.5940334201,
-0.0277346913,
-0.3305650353,
-1.0153442621,
0.1297067404,
-1.0862393379,
-0.1780892462,
1.2356746197,
0.1684227586,
-0.5343280435,
0.3558609784,
-0.079722546,
-0.1957257241,
-0.1354047209,
0.4528779685,
0.4506600499,
0.0821890831,
-0.3731928468,
-0.9263432622,
0.3494675159,
0.0709658042,
-0.5356901884,
-0.2038336992,
0.7588729262,
0.435955137,
0.2126588672,
0.8125864863,
0.0223770533,
0.5311536193,
0.5177952051,
-0.1294261813,
-0.107790783,
-0.7978986502,
-0.7740830779,
0.6352931261,
0.1040482372,
-0.3164330423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14279v1
|
Mitigating the Linguistic Gap with Phonemic Representations for Robust Multilingual Language Understanding
| 2024-02-22T04:41:52 | 2024-02-22T04:41:52 |
Haeji Jung, Changdae Oh, Jooeon Kang, Jimin Sohn, Kyungwoo Song, Jinkyu Kim, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Approaches to improving multilingual language understanding often require
multiple languages during the training phase, rely on complicated training
techniques, and -- importantly -- struggle with significant performance gaps
between high-resource and low-resource languages. We hypothesize that the
performance gaps between languages are affected by linguistic gaps between
those languages and provide a novel solution for robust multilingual language
modeling by employing phonemic representations (specifically, using phonemes as
input tokens to LMs rather than subwords). We present quantitative evidence
from three cross-lingual tasks that demonstrate the effectiveness of phonemic
representation, which is further justified by a theoretical analysis of the
cross-lingual performance gap.
|
[
-0.4171160161,
-0.4800666869,
0.3938912153,
0.1669516116,
-0.2680967748,
0.4028243423,
-0.3669064343,
-0.4637354016,
0.1424935758,
0.1260618716,
-0.4334232807,
-0.2744085491,
-0.5774309635,
0.058207918,
0.2327058464,
0.348128289,
-0.0495250896,
0.422706604,
-0.2503128946,
-0.4200914204,
-0.6706551909,
-0.8153483272,
-0.4465917945,
-0.7199956179,
0.4955294132,
0.6057094336,
0.9346370101,
0.584417522,
0.4306629896,
0.2445847541,
-0.068329975,
-0.0395504571,
-0.2484070659,
0.1980301589,
0.0440127924,
-0.7610375881,
-0.29594028,
-0.0315604657,
0.9878470302,
1.2413079739,
-0.1483511776,
-0.1175977886,
0.0756114945,
0.3889027834,
-0.5420581102,
0.2151930034,
-0.5317829251,
0.439511925,
-0.3608881235,
-0.1814179122,
-0.310251236,
0.1183998436,
-0.046902936,
-0.649874866,
0.1231607571,
-0.1759073734,
0.596381247,
0.0655488223,
-0.3282392323,
-0.1536979228,
-0.4804924726,
0.8385834098,
-0.6798907518,
0.9797392488,
0.6445070505,
0.0455678813,
0.125105992,
-0.0770792216,
-0.2186194509,
-0.0644155964,
-0.0382753648,
0.1488188505,
0.1162994653,
0.0126685956,
0.3503765762,
0.1984166056,
-0.5916646719,
0.4279785156,
-0.2389562875,
-0.5162447691,
0.2619395256,
0.1160614491,
0.3875353038,
-0.0353668965,
-0.3791642785,
-0.0403751694,
-0.6425303817,
0.3890867233,
0.4457278848,
0.5252984166,
-0.0592504963,
0.3663874269,
0.1106050089,
0.6174708605,
-0.3347804844,
-0.2274736464,
0.3138614893,
-0.6018996239,
0.0832471177,
0.0726510286,
0.4916549623,
0.0627890453,
0.4077634513,
-0.2970837057,
-0.1213258877,
0.3095437288,
-0.1629886776,
-0.7395458817,
0.0788531154,
0.1162752509,
-0.4233971834,
-0.0134375775,
-0.1295061409,
-0.6613585949,
-0.341983974,
-0.0715753213,
-0.1047704816,
-0.4359589219,
-0.7020910978,
0.2814031243,
-0.0056490931,
0.1638142467,
0.1461416185,
-0.98753649,
0.4975205064,
0.2200363129,
0.9048831463,
0.0510750487,
-0.5624963641,
-0.6190709472,
0.0338684842,
-0.5132679343,
0.5622886419,
-0.7658387423,
-0.621956408,
0.1806480289,
-0.1500030011,
-0.5008248687,
-0.6647553444,
0.0932538211,
-0.4898727238,
0.1638343036,
-0.10354992,
-0.5137214661,
-0.1719621718,
0.1361427158,
-0.945443511,
1.0574280024,
-0.1529870927,
-0.567808032,
0.1961379796,
-0.6063007116,
-0.374819994,
-0.0908193067,
-0.1195777953,
-0.1950159073,
0.1556173563,
0.3368348777,
0.3583871722,
0.0451739095,
-0.0769866183,
-0.2204639465,
-0.4157122076,
0.3465423584,
-0.2742483318,
0.7477632761,
0.062003348,
-0.1362939775,
-0.1662435383,
-0.7470912933,
0.0993042588,
0.1922352314,
-0.4579776824,
-0.5873333216,
-0.2253675759,
0.0821835175,
0.3678173721,
0.3661003709,
-0.3950183988,
0.0569585152,
-0.4024597704,
0.1994061321,
0.3817009032,
-0.4549008608,
0.765963912,
-0.040731106,
0.9118148685,
0.4893122315,
-0.1823111624,
-0.7137147784,
-0.4409491122,
-0.5667703748,
-0.0162433814,
0.5669947267,
0.6530324221,
-0.7245751619,
-0.0995461494,
-0.0327531248,
-0.0381430462,
-0.4938407838,
0.4568102062,
0.4460839331,
0.0020628765,
0.1872417778,
-0.760517478,
-0.3665029705,
-0.7394857407,
-0.464019388,
-0.3114730418,
0.185865581,
-0.1179167405,
0.1939619929,
0.0103348959,
0.6538281441,
-0.015366205,
-0.102058664,
-0.4380894601,
0.1220922396,
0.0241602752,
0.4866553545,
0.5409561396,
-0.6841525435,
-0.078133896,
0.0811530948,
-0.4416907132,
-0.1375747025,
-0.2121752053,
0.2236580104,
0.1383865923,
0.7595371604,
-0.3816096783,
0.3406005502,
0.7711573243,
-0.3424394429,
0.3962604105,
-0.1527910829,
0.0623204485,
-0.8955671191,
-0.1101505607,
0.0986932665,
-0.4562770724,
-0.8578622341,
0.000613476,
0.2093506306,
-0.4019167423,
-0.346316725,
0.3743510544,
-0.790980041,
-0.2454626411,
-0.0447271317,
0.3863750994,
0.0083409762,
0.693110168,
0.1263133436,
0.6930742264,
0.673838079,
-0.2488555908,
0.0155809699,
-0.0921212211,
-0.203766644,
0.5893102884,
-0.4610825479,
0.1836715043,
-0.1145865321,
0.0585377328,
-0.94146806,
-0.1164252758,
0.3623584509,
-0.4150109887,
0.3618188202,
-0.2931391001,
-0.4582184255,
0.153030172,
-0.219094336,
0.9170233011,
0.1612501144,
-0.2751708627,
0.477129221,
0.3866735101,
-0.2036443204,
-0.5141700506,
-0.9145216346,
0.0714409426,
-0.2348375767,
-0.6686121225,
0.2419428229,
0.1454284042,
-0.2996558547,
-0.1403851658,
-0.1547417641,
-0.3339592814,
0.1679382771,
-0.0127401454,
-0.0320647731,
-0.3219955862,
0.3512856066,
-0.2777332366,
-0.1660841703,
0.0848186165,
-0.1826797575,
0.6537601948,
-0.1501843333,
-0.6581117511,
-0.412743777,
0.6958917975,
0.6255682707,
-0.5388852954,
0.4932552874,
0.7336344123,
-0.5790535212,
-0.1050901487,
-0.3120168149,
-0.1191138029,
-0.4091753066,
0.4319831729,
-0.6040129662,
-0.780321002,
0.9776842594,
-0.2038998455,
-0.1165938899,
0.2361591905,
0.4619981349,
0.0569762215,
0.9896240234,
0.714635253,
-0.0208797753,
0.8289696574,
-0.1247497872,
0.0851841569,
-0.4696941078,
-0.3123475313,
-0.5796670318,
-0.0868657604,
-0.4070362151,
-0.6824041605,
0.2503781021,
0.3206786513,
0.0523407385,
0.2229294926,
0.1430271119,
0.4063610733,
0.402133435,
-0.1339788437,
0.3588228226,
0.1897791475,
-0.6149497032,
-0.2519595325,
-1.2481583357,
-0.43891415,
0.5378426313,
0.5644459724,
0.8149064779,
0.1684101671,
0.732709527,
-0.0636162087,
-0.2296527177,
-0.930329144,
0.4284219444,
0.1239828393,
-0.4054503143,
-0.2071974427,
-0.4553283453,
-1.1372925043,
0.7147523165,
0.0859846398,
-0.807207942,
0.3536644578,
-0.0739320517,
-0.1831775308,
0.3210935593,
-0.8975661993,
0.9973245859,
-0.146662131,
-0.1963443905,
-0.5300911069,
-0.5588366985,
0.0730868056,
-0.0020676905,
0.6840440035,
-0.1110226214,
-0.2587810457,
0.7282309532,
-0.3745780885,
1.0469626188,
-0.2346153557,
-0.3363485038,
0.0663848072,
0.1120202616,
0.1682615876,
0.0181462839,
-0.0943620801,
0.449932307,
-0.0155985085,
-0.7786628604,
-0.5320890546,
0.4553128481,
-0.4899433255,
-0.475720644,
-0.5072808266,
-0.7229268551,
-0.558714211,
0.0947825164,
0.1301547736,
0.5922750235,
-0.173046574,
-0.2472554594,
0.614504993,
-0.0891652405,
0.6724099517,
0.0800705105,
-0.3046097755,
-0.2328447402,
0.7320706844,
0.2923588157,
0.4416188002,
0.1742834449,
0.0076077152,
-0.3672849238,
-0.576388061,
-0.6634367704,
0.2764330804,
-0.8751673698,
0.0754113868,
-0.1613548696,
0.1565743685,
-0.2001933455,
0.1542475373,
-0.3194761276,
-0.5807701945,
-0.2785848975,
0.2574402392,
-0.009335503,
0.8129541874,
-0.3695346713,
0.308324784,
-0.9155635834,
0.1734679639,
0.0567672402,
0.6014624238,
0.1502331197,
-0.4643740356,
-0.9299755692,
0.1938328892,
-0.1446606815,
-1.0829430819,
0.0428082533,
0.3164878786,
0.7582113743,
0.2275258899,
-0.466799587,
0.9447224736,
-0.494382441,
0.7468720675,
0.5054064393,
-1.1256604195,
0.4432848692,
-0.2960415483,
0.6989491582,
0.2365598083,
0.2256478518,
-0.8433678746,
-0.4128366411,
-0.5162094235,
-0.7760734558,
0.7676643133,
0.3022515774,
-0.0213664342,
0.2991639972,
0.0162483379,
0.0672909096,
-0.0396919549,
-0.7070742846,
-0.0417744555,
-0.2831439376,
0.0688835531,
-0.0652145594,
-0.0511356145,
-0.0344703048,
-0.0741883814,
0.2910260856,
-0.1786346734,
0.2744276226,
0.1287472993,
-0.4240355194,
-0.1244059056,
0.2577830255,
0.5680950284,
0.7103843689,
0.2306563258,
0.3783791661,
0.3264238536,
-0.5923048854,
0.1697279811,
0.2311785966,
0.6224332452,
0.3996358514,
0.694890976,
0.6303684115,
0.3140665591,
-0.4642986953,
0.1745257378,
-0.0603925139,
0.0446958467,
0.1915919483,
-0.2546983659,
0.3085667491,
0.2165071219,
0.3366447091,
0.1957519948,
-0.1449309438,
-0.6314270496,
0.079274945,
0.1980292201,
-0.2091608047,
-0.4735363126,
0.3961631656,
0.131866619,
-0.2531679869,
0.254271239,
-0.0255887918,
-0.7374411225,
0.6270839572,
0.4336585701,
0.4764039814,
-0.5336595178,
0.1318536848,
0.1353964657,
0.2882315516,
-0.0074695828,
0.446071893,
-0.2729744613,
-0.7839234471,
-0.6018800735,
-0.1549948603,
-0.5121660829,
-0.1777544916,
-0.7422184348,
-0.0323666371,
-0.2196454108,
-0.2141896337,
0.0836378261,
-0.0992693901,
-0.79831779,
0.0683191717,
0.3837029338,
0.8196251988,
-0.7381435037,
0.9021629691,
0.8442286849,
-0.4071418047,
-0.8142656088,
0.1227201745,
-0.1321201622,
-0.9003357887,
0.5990766883,
0.0890828744,
-0.4507073164,
-0.3412552178,
-0.0310496315,
-0.6315810084,
0.4057787657,
0.6223083138,
-0.6518089175,
0.1143183038,
0.672167778,
0.3870217204,
-0.356387198,
0.0815583691,
0.324208945,
0.3413928449,
-0.3341050744,
-1.143424511,
-0.0694183633,
-0.3693281412,
0.2051313072,
0.220773682,
-0.4732647538,
0.6808383465,
-0.1458765715,
-0.3857717216,
-0.1351009607,
0.3241709769,
0.0697361901,
0.2443521172,
0.7000838518,
0.4029508829,
0.8998652101,
-0.1676820815,
0.8307092786,
-0.3721638024,
0.3987087607,
0.7378821969,
-0.0229376405,
0.5871030688,
0.648665905,
-0.1242073327,
0.4767641127,
0.9171191454,
0.5357904434,
0.4202909172,
0.1421068907,
-0.2697390914,
-0.6203945875,
-0.2101004273,
-0.551451683,
0.6545637846,
0.6280124187,
-0.0877719596,
-0.3627362251,
0.0913636759,
0.1139604226,
0.201995492,
-0.379090488,
0.5590137839,
0.1396106184,
-0.5155146718,
1.0616744757,
-0.0987593383,
0.6363352537,
-0.4795535207,
-0.0632194951,
-0.3969392776,
-0.0431088507,
-0.2863520086,
-0.6641673446,
0.2335712463,
-0.1505628675,
-0.0159730408,
-0.5328322053,
0.8290259242,
-0.8302122355,
-0.3736261129,
0.4840874076,
0.9861414433,
0.318915844,
0.317879051,
-0.6468024254,
0.3444493711,
-0.2841739357,
-0.0942486748,
0.1529117823,
0.6770159602,
-0.0723028183,
0.3625709116,
0.4965482652,
0.1271799207,
0.1839878857,
0.507325232,
0.740288496,
-0.8093193769,
-0.6882795691,
-0.8526937962,
0.2803016901,
0.0268454943,
-0.3445144594,
0.5384497046,
0.4453168809,
1.0147696733,
0.1046442911,
0.7880554199,
0.2760074735,
0.1135723218,
-0.6693429351,
0.4595726132,
-0.7177741528,
0.2503919303,
-0.1348266006,
-0.7093345523,
-0.6094359756,
0.7877063155,
-0.1095124036,
0.0119604385,
0.7531198859,
0.6996404529,
-0.1795464605,
0.0225076117,
0.5588646531,
-0.0683629736,
0.0290067028,
0.7913832664,
1.0543644428,
-0.3193218112,
0.6400933862,
-0.105504185,
-0.0528633408,
-0.0898883492,
-0.6076837778,
-0.9619615078,
-0.5698862672,
-0.1297940761,
-0.2864165902,
0.0330307558,
0.7324231267,
0.77090168,
-0.6749275327,
-0.7298458815,
0.1898546368,
0.4062511921,
-0.4234439433,
-0.0723270997,
0.1987276822,
-0.7710833549,
-0.8541405797,
0.4775685072,
0.1455802619,
0.1241745204,
-0.6674597859,
-0.1792367846,
-0.1230995655,
-0.0904260129,
0.4749943018,
0.2193734944,
-0.7069913745,
0.0063679186,
0.2859269381,
-0.1698337495,
0.4292573929,
1.2473469973,
-0.7473484278,
0.477311343,
0.4032616615,
0.6796305776,
0.490061909,
-0.5309984684,
0.7424060106,
-0.8670951724,
0.4751735628,
0.1451287419,
0.6910758615,
0.6992022395,
-0.121251218,
0.356679827,
0.3689268529,
-0.135352686,
-0.6955515742,
0.4691066742,
-0.911082983,
-0.3504124582,
1.0781549215,
-0.2316368222,
-0.003671268,
-0.4165076911,
-0.0823103786,
0.3160069585,
-0.3607141972,
0.4058211446,
1.0570750237,
-0.0434960388,
-0.1722072363,
-0.5260228515,
0.2676411867,
0.8115504384,
-0.5342724323,
0.1247702911,
0.2851387262,
0.1217346936,
0.33632043,
0.5510439277,
-0.1697888672,
0.3377556503,
0.1526930481,
-0.0538949557,
0.1805634052,
-0.2493573129,
-0.5934944153,
0.1341981888,
0.1530799121,
-0.4751484394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14277v1
|
GATE X-E : A Challenge Set for Gender-Fair Translations from Weakly-Gendered Languages
| 2024-02-22T04:36:14 | 2024-02-22T04:36:14 |
Spencer Rarrick, Ranjita Naik, Sundar Poudel, Vishal Chowdhary
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) continues to improve in quality and
adoption, yet the inadvertent perpetuation of gender bias remains a significant
concern. Despite numerous studies on gender bias in translations into English
from weakly gendered-languages, there are no benchmarks for evaluating this
phenomenon or for assessing mitigation strategies. To address this gap, we
introduce GATE X-E, an extension to the GATE (Rarrick et al., 2023) corpus,
that consists of human translations from Turkish, Hungarian, Finnish, and
Persian into English. Each translation is accompanied by feminine, masculine,
and neutral variants. The dataset, which contains between 1250 and 1850
instances for each of the four language pairs, features natural sentences with
a wide range of sentence lengths and domains, challenging translation rewriters
on various linguistic phenomena. Additionally, we present a translation gender
rewriting solution built with GPT-4 and use GATE X-E to evaluate it. We open
source our contributions to encourage further research on gender debiasing.
|
[
-0.1392327398,
-0.3135374784,
0.5884832144,
0.0178269763,
0.2104837596,
0.0414955169,
0.0072146496,
-0.3019860387,
-0.2757419348,
0.359221369,
-0.9185447693,
-0.4458093345,
-0.6848328114,
0.4618507028,
-0.6312689781,
1.0437557697,
-0.2587688267,
0.3805453777,
0.2890745103,
0.2063218355,
-0.6078231335,
-0.3002099991,
-0.5776717067,
-0.2427026182,
0.3586348593,
0.1831515282,
0.7646354437,
0.5507224202,
0.262585938,
0.3066936731,
-0.0385346189,
-0.1093899757,
-0.2441962808,
0.0450587682,
-0.4745942354,
-0.6156624556,
-0.764067173,
0.1871966124,
0.7826139331,
0.8054073453,
-0.0071265944,
0.1516602486,
0.0748269707,
0.7092388272,
-0.4298477471,
0.1532042921,
-0.7537078857,
0.2576980293,
-0.2283281088,
0.3510647118,
-0.1263318509,
-0.146488905,
0.0825472176,
-0.5254083276,
0.3755318224,
0.3784297705,
0.9382348061,
0.1126364842,
-0.6059483886,
0.0574181974,
-0.5233888626,
1.1318305731,
-0.3687880337,
0.7418417931,
0.3778629601,
0.3270241618,
-0.3607729971,
-0.3584314585,
-0.4538341165,
-0.0747026056,
0.0419402234,
-0.1052878052,
-0.6884546876,
-0.0528900251,
0.1248428896,
0.2779119313,
-0.4592828453,
-0.332582891,
-0.3048855364,
-0.0744770765,
0.4166250825,
-0.0148355886,
0.7128484845,
-0.1678780913,
-0.1708362252,
-0.0776438713,
-0.7509015203,
-0.2300225496,
0.8397445083,
0.3609820008,
0.077860415,
0.364115119,
-0.147392571,
0.1348750591,
0.1814913005,
0.3711688221,
0.6208333373,
-0.3156824708,
-0.0178793892,
0.0413886383,
0.642596364,
0.5447047353,
-0.0419439673,
-0.2606940866,
-0.4687432647,
0.0881963223,
0.3713329136,
-0.5846356153,
0.3636448383,
-0.0688712746,
-0.4092572927,
-0.3151474893,
-0.1207720935,
-0.7286852002,
-0.3194339573,
-0.1505973935,
0.2852164507,
-0.165460214,
-0.3978148997,
0.308562398,
-0.380430162,
0.3414490521,
0.3785717487,
-0.8573406339,
0.4684290886,
0.7399078012,
0.5686349869,
0.0257822871,
-0.2847133279,
-0.3959328234,
-0.0896995589,
-0.4288665056,
0.1706418395,
-0.3410562873,
-0.3270722628,
-0.1863682717,
0.2820070088,
0.1199672669,
-0.2816124558,
1.0296828747,
-0.2410419881,
0.2422107458,
-0.6033305526,
-0.0481888801,
-0.2073044479,
0.2927333415,
-0.6407890916,
0.5161136389,
0.2396052182,
-0.697070539,
0.4044665396,
-0.3552676141,
-0.317455411,
-0.3268383145,
-0.5988718867,
-0.4785128534,
0.361241281,
0.2643214166,
-0.0641028509,
-0.6024582386,
0.3108293712,
-0.0474729203,
-0.26463902,
-0.0525341891,
-0.6780712605,
0.6545125246,
0.1496184915,
-0.9058757424,
-0.0111403959,
-0.4549026489,
-0.0949923545,
0.0852715522,
0.277889818,
-0.2081511915,
0.0079015754,
-0.0594317019,
0.5134270191,
-0.0293183345,
-0.878220439,
-0.1482815444,
-0.4657993019,
0.5456065536,
0.7783559561,
-0.540854454,
0.7699584961,
-0.3290713131,
0.71064955,
-0.0060649095,
0.1504611075,
0.2107707262,
-0.7004398108,
-0.5222246051,
-0.0315942243,
0.1735452712,
0.6137297153,
-0.770178616,
0.1183251217,
-0.3743059337,
-0.0969434902,
-0.9005374908,
0.2364029586,
0.7064795494,
0.4966966808,
0.3038207591,
-0.0313367918,
-0.4044516981,
-1.3689199686,
-0.4837440252,
-0.2390281111,
-0.0152675984,
0.2062724233,
0.6030784845,
-0.269159019,
0.690679431,
-0.1195948273,
-0.4151952267,
-0.1668580323,
0.1316971034,
0.2769539952,
0.5628077984,
0.49091205,
-0.6305235624,
-0.1272461265,
0.2784335017,
-0.6290268898,
-0.4358391464,
-0.0142818447,
-0.502271831,
0.2172647715,
0.3739357889,
-0.4486745894,
0.4546710253,
0.6215922236,
-0.6859275699,
0.4194675088,
0.0029291075,
0.6485248208,
-0.7128506899,
-0.0303352028,
-0.1793371588,
-0.5248786807,
-0.3859994113,
0.2142714262,
0.1105678752,
0.0745831951,
-0.6670656204,
0.5279171467,
-0.5246360302,
-0.0080957683,
-0.287504971,
0.1014630869,
0.07024993,
0.1893914193,
-0.1472518444,
0.8007448912,
0.142188862,
-0.1233467534,
-0.1365461349,
0.5563896298,
0.0139385918,
0.7532041073,
-0.5829927325,
0.2439338416,
-0.3653478622,
0.1562050879,
-0.5472450852,
0.311817348,
0.5585688353,
-0.5134993196,
0.3300976157,
-0.3039630055,
-0.1209574938,
-0.1663409323,
-0.669215858,
0.5354447365,
0.578861773,
-0.3921924531,
0.3484056592,
0.1553683281,
-0.0885626748,
-0.9296934605,
-0.8937215209,
0.4187331796,
0.0526327044,
-0.6984730959,
0.5116761327,
0.2201409638,
-0.3286237717,
0.2058004588,
-0.1553258896,
0.171167016,
0.1186742708,
0.1064772829,
-0.0079174349,
-0.1152144447,
-0.1504423916,
0.5719972253,
-0.230061084,
0.3097040653,
-0.5950690508,
0.2440882474,
-0.341140002,
-0.3256033063,
-0.1674486697,
0.7988682985,
0.3735889196,
-0.0166551899,
0.4592498541,
0.6310605407,
-0.693313241,
-0.3137624562,
-0.227755636,
-0.1977643669,
-0.4425260723,
0.5760462284,
-0.8369377255,
-0.9686385393,
0.3409473002,
0.3443730474,
0.17970936,
0.5877799392,
0.4286685288,
0.0323489755,
1.4469727278,
0.563052237,
-0.0732108355,
0.0815064684,
0.1617579609,
0.0814134255,
-0.7826910615,
0.1769078523,
-0.6909504533,
-0.5492839217,
-0.8832923174,
-0.3918524384,
-0.0156181771,
-0.1773929,
-0.3391106129,
0.4999894202,
-0.3109012544,
0.3295900524,
0.5863890648,
0.0451686159,
0.4074425399,
-0.0176253207,
0.1392398328,
-0.4616813064,
-0.4121041,
-0.6906440854,
1.0815663338,
0.5097202659,
0.6318346262,
0.4521287084,
0.571978569,
0.6201050878,
0.1439944953,
-0.1714725643,
0.4569700062,
-0.4541692436,
-0.9825986624,
0.0074531832,
-0.694326818,
-1.1325366497,
0.3041019738,
-0.1383106112,
-0.6425946951,
0.3551372886,
0.0431783684,
0.004396521,
0.5285058022,
-0.601552844,
0.9652899504,
-0.3382238448,
-0.6546493173,
-0.0440435447,
-0.4764865041,
0.6530455947,
-0.2015879899,
0.1999797523,
-0.1774590909,
-0.2940243483,
0.3537117839,
-0.4640900195,
0.7023181915,
0.0272561461,
-0.5158339739,
-0.1209549904,
0.2079235613,
0.226461634,
0.1091707647,
-0.0444470942,
0.5131558776,
-0.0492442846,
-0.5603400469,
-0.5421887636,
0.7997353077,
-1.0580898523,
-0.8560060859,
-0.5781441927,
-0.4418337643,
0.0191908386,
0.2706608176,
0.2410575747,
-0.0355677642,
-0.30294469,
-0.2466884404,
0.4777007103,
-0.540364325,
-0.002851994,
0.2183723003,
-0.616232872,
-0.3628816009,
0.8091490269,
0.0698363706,
0.1616097689,
0.3988865912,
0.1250450611,
-0.4322457612,
-0.3100508451,
-0.9997288585,
0.0697788298,
-0.5698420405,
-0.006944071,
-0.80823493,
0.0547739752,
-0.4619936943,
-0.2458290309,
-0.4734412134,
-0.4539257884,
0.1500418186,
-0.0479839034,
0.0319866613,
0.5913030505,
0.0775737241,
0.3016138971,
-0.7092656493,
0.4834115803,
0.2092782259,
0.1897467077,
-0.3764586449,
-0.6721842289,
0.2781270146,
0.0597144291,
-0.1866618842,
-1.1038559675,
0.418466419,
0.027182037,
0.5680022836,
0.0074410457,
-0.0782905668,
0.1347852796,
-0.8131694198,
0.6326175332,
0.2027505934,
-1.3424191475,
0.4663992226,
-0.6197436452,
0.0333829112,
0.6300997138,
0.1707223952,
-0.6695436239,
-0.4063182473,
-0.5192203522,
-0.9313700795,
0.6718840003,
0.7084454298,
0.4052549303,
-0.1896275431,
0.4959503114,
0.3586148322,
0.6594159603,
-0.5896008015,
-0.3236933053,
-0.0759031475,
-0.3020785749,
0.1478968263,
0.0261089765,
0.1925112605,
-0.2545984089,
0.8991472125,
0.0494549014,
0.462572217,
0.2724898756,
-0.4291987419,
-0.0488009006,
0.5825126171,
0.4590924382,
0.1747258455,
-0.1545570344,
0.2302458435,
0.2532019615,
-0.5846384168,
0.6208780408,
0.0508263744,
-0.800974369,
0.1559297442,
-0.1381857097,
0.6695978642,
-0.1324550062,
-0.3627210259,
0.6609299779,
-0.3147967756,
-0.3963792622,
-0.157954812,
-0.2321132421,
-0.1606373191,
0.2024128884,
0.0061685089,
-0.0174060389,
0.5558644533,
-0.4026061594,
0.2647324502,
0.3651603162,
-0.8301888108,
-0.5066199303,
1.1690917015,
0.6044390798,
-0.0728775561,
0.6093198061,
-0.8769979477,
-0.7536621094,
0.3525778055,
0.4803782403,
1.5225183964,
-0.1644182503,
0.1730680317,
0.4868367612,
1.0709985495,
-0.1425112784,
0.5032579303,
0.3422926068,
-0.6646936536,
-0.4733152092,
-0.3276837468,
-0.2145721614,
-0.0858776122,
-0.2545706034,
0.495828867,
-0.3388878107,
-0.4467801154,
-0.4982218146,
-0.0338726453,
-0.7053310275,
-0.1026734188,
0.4324641228,
0.7030627728,
-0.881477654,
0.4356206059,
0.6804659367,
-0.4573957324,
-0.2846734524,
-0.3225842714,
0.3426404595,
-0.4966692924,
0.7247043848,
0.0927717835,
-0.5437067151,
-0.0332411043,
-0.0938027948,
-0.4669778049,
0.7952635288,
0.7330301404,
-0.8535686135,
0.0971882939,
0.4556242824,
0.0649192557,
-0.0173526388,
0.5972621441,
0.6923784614,
0.7296051383,
-0.8461140394,
-0.8876844645,
0.2526465356,
-0.6050305963,
-0.028599143,
0.4094250798,
-0.4555567503,
1.0304236412,
0.1127432138,
-0.2056415379,
-0.0078378944,
0.7114806175,
-0.1245737895,
0.2572422326,
0.7804998755,
0.5395441055,
0.6886640191,
-0.3024952412,
0.845932126,
-0.0265638269,
-0.0568719991,
1.0823485851,
-0.4413574934,
0.3657844365,
0.4970451593,
-0.2869597077,
0.3326011002,
0.123143211,
0.2041934878,
0.0533914976,
0.6529544592,
-0.3205387294,
-0.126098305,
-0.2657883763,
-0.4721954763,
0.3622012436,
0.056244798,
-0.3855034113,
-0.3924951255,
-0.0376591533,
0.4143515229,
0.3149141371,
-0.2886320055,
0.1844778806,
0.3095907271,
-0.4052291811,
0.1960122734,
0.4567248225,
0.9027984738,
-0.5182285905,
-0.1401150227,
-0.3169545233,
0.2842991054,
-0.1973323673,
-0.5695294142,
0.296720624,
0.245659858,
-0.5224584341,
-0.5641363263,
0.729090631,
-0.5067560077,
-0.6122455597,
0.3795738518,
1.0244160891,
0.1229446083,
-0.4125571549,
-0.8659777045,
-0.1407613158,
0.255839318,
-0.1289792806,
0.3507877588,
0.3537293077,
-0.6975720525,
0.4869515598,
0.4283139408,
-0.0537342913,
0.2353041023,
0.1100109443,
0.4483678937,
-0.7892545462,
-0.3596341014,
-0.9538843632,
0.2802569568,
0.0085587939,
-0.3691293895,
0.8713674545,
0.448405683,
0.9416590929,
-0.0192617234,
0.8416908979,
-0.0277926791,
0.2169383615,
-0.171062097,
1.0268564224,
-0.6688076258,
0.1683191806,
-0.5694690943,
-0.9486673474,
-0.1899281889,
0.5270558596,
-0.2050548792,
0.1710419059,
0.6665204167,
0.8335675597,
0.0030602417,
0.0635693371,
0.4576603472,
0.0106125921,
0.3529113829,
0.8785536289,
1.2131407261,
-0.8568297625,
0.6525240541,
-0.0535724759,
-0.2160904408,
0.2482930124,
-1.0873955488,
-0.5910003781,
-0.2489265501,
-0.5871052146,
-0.4256018996,
0.379439503,
1.1734780073,
0.5617780089,
-0.5518295765,
-0.0946451724,
-0.2612853944,
0.3290558457,
-0.3458248675,
-0.0326239802,
0.0658612773,
-0.3527481258,
-1.1719067097,
0.2730196714,
0.0538168438,
-0.2558953166,
-0.3549200892,
-0.2363458276,
0.072938323,
-0.0739988834,
0.4073532522,
-0.0102058705,
-0.420843482,
-0.2446963489,
0.2647091448,
-0.225373596,
-0.1710245013,
0.6118281484,
-0.5309666395,
0.2573329806,
0.7388859391,
0.9285333753,
0.0786505863,
-0.4559053779,
1.1052004099,
-0.7451403141,
-0.2136012167,
0.0678384677,
0.4195446074,
0.2294637412,
-0.1913055182,
0.5077338219,
0.4083296359,
-0.3648712039,
-0.7441042662,
0.2999444008,
-0.6656450033,
-0.1709187925,
1.1083651781,
-0.0544440113,
-0.6373716593,
-0.3841446936,
-0.4234160185,
0.1232333109,
-0.601516664,
0.4027720392,
0.6855872273,
0.4650459588,
-0.1217471883,
-1.0647724867,
0.2619537711,
0.8859657049,
-0.6293199062,
-0.0211194959,
0.3187692463,
0.0984484255,
-0.161000967,
0.5937532187,
-0.3520334661,
0.3894811869,
0.0706014931,
0.5070053339,
0.1341926754,
-0.0127851255,
-0.5049856901,
-0.2562349439,
0.1585563272,
-0.3774392307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14273v1
|
Can Language Models Act as Knowledge Bases at Scale?
| 2024-02-22T04:20:14 | 2024-02-22T04:20:14 |
Qiyuan He, Yizhong Wang, Wenya Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
understanding and generating responses to complex queries through large-scale
pre-training. However, the efficacy of these models in memorizing and reasoning
among large-scale structured knowledge, especially world knowledge that
explicitly covers abundant factual information remains questionable. Addressing
this gap, our research investigates whether LLMs can effectively store, recall,
and reason with knowledge on a large scale comparable to latest knowledge bases
(KBs) such as Wikidata. Specifically, we focus on three crucial aspects to
study the viability: (1) the efficiency of LLMs with different sizes in
memorizing the exact knowledge in the large-scale KB; (2) the flexibility of
recalling the memorized knowledge in response to natural language queries; (3)
the capability to infer new knowledge through reasoning. Our findings indicate
that while LLMs hold promise as large-scale KBs capable of retrieving and
responding with flexibility, enhancements in their reasoning capabilities are
necessary to fully realize their potential.
|
[
-0.2929261625,
-0.8005922437,
0.9289155006,
-0.00288258,
0.0841324329,
-0.1133316308,
-0.5454849005,
-0.3392036557,
0.0004301381,
0.6573683619,
-0.1484683901,
-0.1904292554,
-0.4715266228,
0.0941803157,
-0.4782571197,
0.5027893186,
0.0334669948,
-0.0449845865,
-0.4699575603,
-0.2241155803,
-0.2915583253,
-0.8540551066,
-0.4332180321,
-0.3704484999,
0.7115057707,
0.4790640175,
0.7136202455,
0.7981539965,
0.395362258,
0.3195407987,
-0.1934271008,
0.2486748248,
-0.6069399714,
0.3184519112,
-0.3739483058,
-0.7219470739,
-0.3925095499,
-0.1701121926,
0.9948168993,
1.0000047684,
-0.2537626326,
0.098025687,
-0.1964564025,
0.697255075,
-0.4979492426,
0.2829708755,
-0.9835150242,
-0.1689769924,
0.2493288219,
0.0251980778,
-0.6091321111,
-0.2766677737,
0.2933339775,
-0.5399675965,
-0.2623072267,
0.2751505077,
0.665579617,
0.0517782979,
-0.652105093,
-0.3913834095,
-0.8405615091,
0.5670122504,
-0.8003780842,
0.5495161414,
0.469927609,
0.4238040745,
-0.3251169622,
-0.7734228969,
-0.6610697508,
-0.2798288167,
-0.088095054,
-0.3315986097,
0.006490828,
-0.0229780637,
0.7307574749,
0.3870826066,
-0.2493143827,
0.1318987459,
-0.1966908872,
-0.1726148129,
0.4423573017,
0.3329054415,
0.3251125216,
-0.1349675357,
-0.0612480976,
0.168916747,
-0.8288878202,
-0.1225796938,
-0.0121314209,
0.2393771857,
0.1866224557,
0.6057425737,
-0.2975562513,
0.7673134804,
-0.1844208688,
-0.5505372286,
-0.127871424,
-0.0216935296,
-0.301273644,
-0.1973664612,
0.6388520598,
0.238433972,
0.4939270616,
-0.4715313613,
-0.1421247423,
-0.260691613,
0.3034192324,
-0.7999439836,
-0.2004870027,
-0.0264113657,
-0.421901077,
0.2481024712,
-0.1484591961,
-0.4636460245,
-0.4544427395,
-0.5072097182,
0.6197875738,
-0.5321756005,
-0.3923959732,
0.2509133518,
-0.0931126401,
0.159811914,
0.3914055824,
-1.1012197733,
0.2870248556,
0.573237896,
0.5701945424,
0.1038466617,
-0.2374711037,
0.0487201884,
0.4294278324,
-0.4980120361,
0.6320419908,
-0.3356083632,
-0.2859633565,
0.0466584526,
-0.1021120921,
-0.2164199054,
-0.7359544039,
0.1559973061,
-0.863255918,
-0.1014037952,
-0.7849357128,
-0.8621804118,
-0.1949275136,
0.6716579795,
-0.8664157987,
0.6260638833,
0.1015732288,
-0.826446116,
0.139740929,
0.0002545808,
-0.4900778234,
-0.158114031,
-0.1128735393,
-0.1117243767,
0.1568608284,
-0.1095333844,
0.5779157281,
-0.5258154869,
0.2917406261,
-0.5447395444,
-0.2065418065,
0.513828814,
-0.3273723125,
0.5381744504,
0.1010237709,
-0.0327170193,
-0.2950518131,
-0.8301793337,
0.0882752389,
0.1446498781,
-0.7618274093,
-0.4368222356,
0.1307757646,
-0.5985084176,
0.2776491046,
0.3943482041,
-0.4140066504,
0.4847945571,
-0.1762938201,
0.484290868,
0.4986585975,
-0.0717609748,
0.578366816,
-0.2042668313,
0.3345122635,
-0.2107305676,
-0.107448414,
-0.2163259387,
-0.1798679382,
-0.9169163704,
-0.1373354197,
0.0654536113,
0.4120235741,
-0.5779885054,
0.2746196687,
-0.5223998427,
-0.4398067594,
0.201902315,
0.2136864364,
0.2123720348,
0.650189817,
0.1644182056,
0.0462424085,
-0.7006221414,
-0.9568737149,
-0.2679505944,
-0.3303953111,
-0.0003038073,
0.4405232668,
0.5135821104,
-0.1068959087,
0.9275021553,
-0.3794822991,
0.1642571539,
-0.3685470521,
-0.2684071064,
0.1772745252,
0.020677248,
0.2563464642,
-0.8229932785,
-0.2577570975,
0.0478231236,
-1.1079208851,
0.1156619117,
-0.0417608805,
-0.012075888,
0.2336059362,
0.7434197068,
-1.1086657047,
0.0164333936,
0.1849780232,
-0.3953804672,
0.5505169034,
-0.5013237596,
0.051400695,
-0.948364675,
0.0501729958,
-0.4289132059,
-0.0929273441,
-0.6657248139,
-0.2066529989,
0.3540783226,
0.2822717428,
-0.0605439804,
0.6596838832,
-0.5419889092,
-0.2083423138,
-0.1982991546,
0.0387841985,
0.0191777404,
0.2632815242,
-0.0115885669,
0.5429685116,
0.3714078069,
-0.7224427462,
0.2710510194,
0.0858360678,
-0.7040046453,
0.4275882542,
-0.2947845459,
0.0044937111,
-0.1969671845,
0.397514075,
-0.787257731,
-0.4801506996,
-0.4660697579,
-0.2995496094,
0.3989717364,
-0.0326192603,
-0.8044142723,
-0.5320844054,
0.072984688,
0.0460277088,
0.4928387403,
-0.4415727258,
0.9337233305,
0.5410289764,
-0.1515591443,
-0.5439811945,
-0.5011524558,
0.0000571852,
-0.2483939976,
-0.5319460034,
-0.2568590641,
0.0861580148,
-0.5818251371,
0.0076116147,
-0.3068899512,
-0.1159091145,
0.056963861,
0.2595637143,
0.3673117161,
-0.3226909935,
0.4719288945,
-0.3485784233,
0.2337373346,
0.3500356674,
-0.5226126909,
0.5541827679,
-0.2107193917,
-0.1569227576,
0.1343888044,
0.0870007947,
0.9280149341,
-0.0967204198,
1.1589220762,
0.0802541897,
-0.5936606526,
-0.3011424243,
-0.9748759866,
-0.0343221799,
-0.4021646082,
0.4360206425,
-0.4830887318,
-1.2821899652,
0.6640377045,
-0.2225832194,
0.0260415096,
0.4713107049,
0.6405911446,
-0.2716760039,
0.8511432409,
0.4379800558,
-0.2795337439,
0.1780230403,
-0.2621021569,
0.2654162645,
-0.8279487491,
-0.4583657384,
-0.480280757,
-0.2168408334,
-0.1371685714,
-0.4876455069,
0.1900178939,
0.3876621723,
-0.6691167951,
0.035226237,
0.1130401567,
0.6748677492,
0.3466080129,
-0.1109391302,
0.4666038752,
0.000927568,
-0.1069586053,
0.1618673056,
-0.7578776479,
-0.6590716839,
1.1846176386,
0.2997193038,
0.7707612514,
0.0011352258,
0.2846513987,
-0.1364818066,
0.3071007431,
-0.7066826224,
0.7479674816,
-0.0702664703,
-0.8297978044,
-0.5509468317,
-0.6728971601,
-0.7798608541,
0.3797620535,
-0.282571137,
-0.7526112795,
-0.1501715034,
0.2806548774,
-0.1128849238,
0.7209177613,
-0.8336337209,
0.6556206346,
-0.2941127121,
-0.1383948326,
-0.2655723691,
-0.576980412,
0.4937774837,
-0.1389158815,
0.4232231677,
-0.1407116503,
-0.0015854953,
0.7645431757,
-0.278853178,
0.6725665331,
-0.1986235231,
-0.1399140358,
0.3526942432,
0.2548080385,
0.2693853378,
-0.0229679104,
-0.1596339643,
-0.0971022472,
-0.0317504182,
-0.3188321888,
-0.7967490554,
0.7214925885,
-0.7038871646,
-0.8639797568,
0.0281929392,
-0.7987128496,
-0.6076666713,
0.4694670141,
-0.0515910275,
0.2913117707,
-0.1341808587,
0.5797570348,
1.1212879419,
-0.1146408319,
0.1742842495,
0.7011999488,
-0.3490027189,
-0.1946684271,
0.8264434338,
0.580193162,
0.5204596519,
0.6636613011,
0.1776828468,
-0.2596538067,
-0.6264377236,
-0.1294661909,
0.3159154356,
-0.9307115078,
-0.1887362599,
-0.8100993633,
-0.199593097,
-0.1952334046,
-0.0129018677,
-0.222838223,
-0.6927425265,
0.1286752671,
-0.2514375448,
0.3342289627,
0.8542438149,
0.0258406457,
0.0130012836,
-0.7087774873,
0.4082562327,
0.5279077888,
0.3707099557,
0.3931005597,
-0.5357456803,
-0.4122889638,
-0.1292804182,
0.1598971188,
-0.4841502309,
0.1517823935,
-0.0792960748,
0.7112631202,
0.2315330058,
-0.1516009569,
0.4255320728,
-0.6569472551,
0.5573012233,
0.0670438632,
-0.5544668436,
0.2820826173,
-0.5447999835,
0.4777233899,
0.351087898,
0.534789443,
-0.5604811311,
-0.2340648621,
-0.5214473009,
-0.774294436,
0.6446133852,
-0.3194457889,
0.1071211398,
-0.1134946644,
0.6073307395,
-0.0727871209,
0.217432797,
-0.4734308422,
-0.040160358,
-0.0275502466,
-0.1802621335,
-0.0662433058,
-0.5225592852,
-0.0873790309,
-0.2423094958,
0.5413879752,
-0.0222514588,
0.1331776679,
-0.0735350326,
-0.2062331289,
0.1099450514,
0.5021498203,
0.2257753909,
0.8843283653,
-0.0615400299,
0.4407095909,
0.43476668,
-0.5064251423,
0.0967541188,
-0.2280013114,
-0.0260396115,
-0.4747461677,
0.5617921948,
0.6355501413,
0.4214545488,
-0.9272471666,
0.2722731531,
-0.0955021456,
-0.3663921654,
-0.3555545509,
0.1424921155,
0.8353649974,
0.3769257665,
0.2241777033,
-0.2668282092,
-0.2070180476,
-0.7782254815,
0.0076098614,
0.4952048957,
0.18182531,
-0.0680839717,
0.4724057019,
-0.2640500367,
-0.079462409,
0.9537854791,
0.2456905097,
-0.5545185208,
0.5550222397,
0.6872599721,
0.2508211136,
-0.1533133388,
-0.1993771046,
0.4915716052,
0.3259527683,
-0.5527531505,
0.1124092638,
-0.0370448679,
-1.0421528816,
-0.3411930799,
-0.7657608986,
-0.3925269544,
0.1628102064,
-0.5114954114,
-0.1962727457,
-0.8113318682,
-0.1365774572,
-0.0631855503,
-0.0237946361,
-0.6029275656,
0.3841152191,
0.3279858232,
1.229690671,
-0.5624774098,
1.1083676815,
0.4816572368,
-0.3841591179,
-1.386975646,
-0.3090871572,
-0.014613593,
-0.7693606019,
0.7645129561,
0.1871508658,
0.0322286338,
-0.2122957706,
-0.4373746216,
-1.1375797987,
1.2735608816,
0.5269197822,
-0.6230094433,
-0.3591780066,
0.1808685809,
0.5974351168,
-0.3316751719,
0.0247003809,
0.846126616,
0.4261912405,
0.2729706764,
-0.9822191596,
-0.023980407,
-0.133942008,
-0.0225689523,
0.2696493566,
-0.5895664692,
0.9410262108,
-0.3650406301,
0.117479831,
-0.1089114696,
0.5592474937,
0.2477152199,
-0.1778861135,
0.5093963146,
0.8758050203,
0.9986217618,
-0.0325813852,
1.162812829,
-0.0474234968,
0.064697057,
1.1138783693,
-0.3708589077,
1.0630966425,
0.3347103596,
-0.1973071545,
0.6101408005,
0.149199605,
0.2158197612,
0.2387080193,
0.2025857568,
-0.2159768343,
-0.5497740507,
0.1343815178,
-0.0319401771,
0.245468244,
0.7115116119,
-0.3267810643,
0.0746244341,
-0.0536576696,
0.1626551002,
0.0875055194,
-0.5624352098,
0.7866168618,
0.2441423833,
-0.7204234004,
0.6579269767,
-0.2270150334,
0.3032591343,
-0.7868195176,
0.1184730753,
-0.1087416783,
0.3059599102,
-0.2168228477,
-0.7293022871,
0.1538962424,
-0.1103309691,
-0.5132684708,
-0.1840343177,
0.9573237896,
-0.3965992928,
-0.310842365,
0.2381382734,
0.4761444926,
-0.0500646718,
0.0101966588,
-0.0767033473,
0.0370780714,
-0.0785486549,
-0.6080383658,
0.5532398224,
0.7612402439,
-0.228879571,
1.070949316,
0.4093831182,
0.2309828252,
0.3493649065,
0.112480402,
0.8460325003,
-0.7978400588,
-0.1933244169,
-0.8054229617,
0.170189321,
-0.1927060336,
0.1873252839,
0.9516019821,
0.5914497972,
0.7413820028,
-0.0921612978,
0.8354423046,
-0.1145808324,
0.6727358699,
-0.5592185855,
0.6856861115,
-0.3886733949,
0.2099305838,
0.1085833982,
-0.7243387699,
-0.2616112828,
0.6216856241,
-0.5405514836,
-0.0097784931,
0.7316755056,
0.563344419,
0.1688070893,
0.215987131,
0.4345932305,
0.6075980067,
0.256411314,
0.6799532175,
0.8975169659,
0.1080010757,
0.6723918915,
0.1118910909,
-0.0671908632,
-0.151024133,
-0.5155747533,
-1.1843929291,
-0.4944458902,
0.2176178098,
-0.2559729517,
-0.1755806655,
0.7435859442,
0.5380041599,
-0.4419800937,
-0.2917195559,
0.130934462,
0.1713520437,
0.2858828604,
-0.1229878291,
0.3246063888,
-0.3246568739,
-0.2795322537,
0.288269788,
0.424159348,
0.0360531285,
-0.3608072102,
-0.1595010161,
-0.1894181669,
0.0995976552,
0.8646693826,
0.5395950079,
-0.7276184559,
-0.4365113974,
0.1433713585,
-0.2978815734,
-0.2673525512,
0.9133796096,
-0.8666431904,
0.2749269307,
0.4856802225,
0.8319817185,
0.6055014133,
-0.4217401445,
0.6696264148,
-0.3123191297,
-0.0151580181,
0.087235041,
0.7065502405,
0.371488899,
-0.1291821003,
0.3360682726,
-0.0189922526,
-0.710639298,
-0.5519972444,
0.2173857242,
-0.8216121793,
-0.4488252103,
1.3170173168,
-0.272466749,
-0.1691166461,
-0.087317571,
-0.0862133726,
0.1396364421,
0.0543201268,
0.6934306622,
1.1044597626,
-0.0159463491,
-0.1775524318,
-0.7023956776,
0.4040261805,
0.2457640022,
-0.8354854584,
0.445892334,
0.7335082889,
0.4976043701,
0.1335873902,
0.8893584013,
-0.1448969096,
0.0795062482,
0.1649296731,
-0.3489898145,
-0.0297107324,
-0.4461422265,
0.0111587746,
0.393381089,
0.4913271368,
0.5125938058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14272v1
|
Qsnail: A Questionnaire Dataset for Sequential Question Generation
| 2024-02-22T04:14:10 | 2024-02-22T04:14:10 |
Yan Lei, Liang Pang, Yuanzhuo Wang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The questionnaire is a professional research methodology used for both
qualitative and quantitative analysis of human opinions, preferences,
attitudes, and behaviors. However, designing and evaluating questionnaires
demands significant effort due to their intricate and complex structure.
Questionnaires entail a series of questions that must conform to intricate
constraints involving the questions, options, and overall structure.
Specifically, the questions should be relevant and specific to the given
research topic and intent. The options should be tailored to the questions,
ensuring they are mutually exclusive, completed, and ordered sensibly.
Moreover, the sequence of questions should follow a logical order, grouping
similar topics together. As a result, automatically generating questionnaires
presents a significant challenge and this area has received limited attention
primarily due to the scarcity of high-quality datasets. To address these
issues, we present Qsnail, the first dataset specifically constructed for the
questionnaire generation task, which comprises 13,168 human-written
questionnaires gathered from online platforms. We further conduct experiments
on Qsnail, and the results reveal that retrieval models and traditional
generative models do not fully align with the given research topic and intents.
Large language models, while more closely related to the research topic and
intents, exhibit significant limitations in terms of diversity and specificity.
Despite enhancements through the chain-of-thought prompt and finetuning,
questionnaires generated by language models still fall short of human-written
questionnaires. Therefore, questionnaire generation is challenging and needs to
be further explored. The dataset is available at:
https://github.com/LeiyanGithub/qsnail.
|
[
-0.2993999422,
-0.6251667142,
0.3640384078,
0.188687861,
-0.2443633825,
0.1043488905,
0.2480806708,
0.0789568052,
0.2044247538,
0.2916000187,
-0.6922755837,
-0.4853529334,
-0.0822738111,
0.3836762309,
-0.619463563,
1.019892931,
0.2482836396,
-0.0524239279,
-0.4676142633,
-0.1072041988,
-0.3170385063,
-0.1177701354,
-0.6516608,
0.158233434,
0.3771840334,
0.5964207053,
0.918992877,
0.5156694055,
0.4978858531,
0.2218144685,
0.141314581,
0.1906789392,
-0.7895397544,
0.3860006034,
-0.06500604,
-0.5242052674,
-0.1868225932,
0.0559776016,
0.578695178,
0.5378515124,
-0.0797160491,
0.9688256979,
-0.1949899942,
0.5587040782,
-0.5823455453,
-0.314991802,
-0.3485696614,
0.3912012875,
-0.5638298392,
-0.3970324099,
-0.1336525679,
-0.81704247,
0.176633209,
-0.4682892263,
0.4586582482,
0.0786211342,
0.5796896815,
0.0238231719,
-0.3370760381,
-0.0518150777,
-0.6622259021,
0.3910810351,
-0.4281158447,
0.0598997809,
0.3953723013,
0.3964273036,
-0.0541257039,
-1.0629842281,
-0.4492858946,
0.2271944731,
0.1510884166,
0.2096307129,
-0.0161229111,
-0.4569977224,
0.4093672335,
0.4612708688,
-1.0353703499,
-0.0863934234,
-0.4501381218,
0.0046460489,
0.8368352652,
0.9997149706,
0.3880954087,
-0.5186703205,
-0.1556886435,
-0.0680701882,
-0.8327147961,
0.5571214557,
0.4291057289,
0.0236392505,
0.0758182555,
0.5295558572,
-0.3309013546,
0.4041601419,
0.4583038986,
-0.23206833,
0.1775503457,
-0.6582338214,
0.1312994808,
-0.1210230365,
1.0306246281,
0.5821053386,
-0.1612607986,
0.009482027,
0.0733778402,
-0.0935364813,
0.3669774532,
-0.9129807353,
-0.4232391417,
0.8539766669,
-0.3562969863,
-0.6672315001,
0.181088984,
-0.5017929673,
-0.1900593787,
-0.0377855375,
0.3459952772,
-0.1514861137,
-0.3996601105,
0.0623275265,
-0.2755500674,
0.2604920864,
0.1350917369,
-0.7958605886,
0.2142421007,
0.4129848182,
0.5844948292,
-0.1924417764,
-0.334104389,
-0.3182032108,
-0.0729582906,
-0.6438985467,
0.767398715,
-0.6760014296,
-0.5934897661,
-0.1055629179,
-0.0467800684,
0.147447601,
-0.7348915339,
0.2766691446,
-0.4101482332,
0.4799050391,
-0.3779320121,
-0.5143743157,
0.2811205089,
0.1037530825,
-0.5748981833,
1.5060969591,
0.3785091639,
-1.1612579823,
0.4521826506,
-0.3826963902,
-0.0887618363,
0.4275660217,
-0.6456387639,
-0.4270347953,
-0.0348342247,
0.1864905953,
0.4751047194,
-0.615885973,
0.6063517332,
-0.0681264997,
-0.5486795306,
0.5057140589,
-0.0396434478,
0.6239379644,
0.0749905109,
-0.2459854484,
0.3391765952,
-0.6379363537,
0.3802953959,
0.3791728914,
-0.1458307207,
-0.0227784794,
-0.2537005246,
0.0442368723,
0.2901735604,
0.0478257202,
-0.4059238732,
0.1718216985,
-0.1914640069,
0.5825268626,
0.6036633253,
0.3604457676,
0.2694329619,
-0.5638564229,
1.0350979567,
0.1429522038,
0.3493541479,
-0.2467018962,
-0.2737497091,
-0.3627743125,
0.0500152074,
0.5576320887,
0.573562026,
-0.7371388078,
0.2676036358,
-0.2268319279,
-0.8997101784,
-0.6780557632,
-0.1499789208,
0.3736209273,
0.3052609861,
0.0017478252,
-0.5966899395,
-0.4525358081,
-0.8633955717,
0.0715742633,
-0.097919628,
0.0070173889,
0.3207190931,
0.3587511778,
0.3685675263,
1.2168829441,
-0.8039759398,
0.2656963766,
-0.3260080516,
0.2534963787,
0.2032989264,
0.3681481183,
0.4405318499,
-0.8728933334,
-0.4153758883,
-0.8159022927,
-0.757763505,
0.1006994098,
-0.1693706214,
-0.3342777789,
-0.6961500049,
0.484089911,
-0.6817358136,
0.225027144,
0.1269314289,
-0.1877269894,
0.9420013428,
0.3139322698,
-0.0376916565,
-1.1565682888,
0.266225785,
-0.0395727344,
0.0360269435,
-0.6621971726,
0.075483121,
0.0035874601,
-0.5598216057,
-0.5776087642,
0.5365313292,
-0.1179830134,
0.1286927611,
0.2585867047,
-0.0994376913,
0.1247489303,
0.2726283967,
-0.0839430094,
1.0510662794,
0.6391232014,
-0.4355578721,
0.3704144359,
0.8032491803,
-0.2969052196,
0.6242514849,
-0.8075128794,
0.3657112718,
-0.416631192,
0.1293907315,
-1.1071094275,
-0.3725349605,
0.4537269175,
-0.415933311,
0.0389515273,
0.2859360278,
-0.4676967263,
-0.6433993578,
-0.7155326605,
0.5820394158,
0.4440633059,
-0.1043437123,
-0.040370293,
0.2345059961,
-0.7474728227,
-0.2968402207,
-0.0386068523,
-0.0122992545,
-0.3900200725,
-0.5753597617,
0.2714188397,
-0.2528067529,
-0.1433171779,
-0.0733025298,
-0.0628753081,
-0.004455498,
-0.2736240029,
0.4462160468,
0.0351355821,
-0.3247087002,
0.3730992079,
0.1320083588,
0.051733233,
0.0785586163,
0.1147216782,
0.5176774263,
0.0899412856,
-0.1586859226,
-0.4698343277,
0.5877845883,
0.4512711465,
-0.6148381829,
0.1491414756,
0.5949093103,
-0.0283851195,
-0.1750663966,
-0.3863370717,
-0.1734773517,
-0.4858475626,
0.2548328936,
-0.5334342718,
-0.7934328914,
0.2345620245,
0.0151810981,
0.0907489508,
0.316165328,
0.3887587786,
-0.0659162551,
1.128844142,
0.1450493634,
-0.0976792574,
0.2746276855,
-0.290887475,
-0.1246692836,
-0.8130572438,
-0.0089305621,
-0.2636377811,
-0.2876621187,
-0.4879586101,
-0.1829649955,
0.4592428207,
-0.0059633697,
-0.3975183666,
-0.0314793624,
-0.6249393821,
0.3213868141,
0.7883807421,
0.427343756,
0.0390304141,
-0.0928046033,
-0.0254717767,
-0.1054781899,
-0.8694939017,
-0.7026064396,
1.3893023729,
0.0363609754,
0.4914421439,
-0.0178952236,
0.9989073873,
0.30504632,
0.0698298365,
-0.435516268,
0.7463191152,
-0.0184923783,
-0.5666495562,
-0.7782331705,
-0.1439758837,
-1.1370937824,
0.1497822404,
-0.1785089076,
-0.3495072424,
0.1415639818,
0.0974853188,
-0.9054416418,
-0.1149866804,
-0.2112041861,
0.9572541714,
-0.3192800283,
-0.7703511715,
0.4618915617,
-0.8581824303,
0.3572486043,
-0.0993217528,
-0.179496631,
-0.1532745361,
0.3596497178,
0.7555794716,
-0.5279446244,
0.8573006392,
-0.1721128821,
0.1210812479,
0.6085237265,
0.1726068109,
0.3350141346,
0.244261533,
-0.0192344394,
-0.465023309,
0.4271954,
-0.3377445936,
-0.5713678598,
0.0773979947,
-0.5457561016,
-0.6428858638,
-0.2420897335,
-0.3627924025,
-0.4082406163,
0.1935848892,
0.4403141737,
0.696503222,
-0.415581733,
-0.2011982501,
0.3651872277,
-0.295904547,
-0.1054886207,
0.3486056626,
-0.281432718,
-0.2232705653,
1.0975592136,
0.1949441284,
-0.0363683775,
0.0982280895,
0.1189719364,
-0.2638328969,
-0.5629409552,
-0.5539710522,
0.1641917676,
-0.345511049,
-0.1714217216,
-0.2671606839,
-0.2718936503,
-0.4342085719,
0.267595768,
0.0734361261,
-0.4536037147,
-0.4696939886,
-0.1520452052,
0.388019532,
0.6379054189,
0.1514689922,
0.0187827591,
-1.0191456079,
0.5841912627,
0.66912359,
0.0866278931,
0.1169314012,
-0.1602446288,
0.08327277,
-0.1897273511,
-0.4403870106,
-0.8029803038,
0.3313185275,
0.36252141,
0.2868770957,
0.4943440855,
0.2246406674,
0.8039783835,
-0.5316707492,
0.9146430492,
0.0144913858,
-0.440430969,
0.7340029478,
-0.5988506079,
0.5328401327,
0.8608022332,
0.7142040133,
-0.595250845,
-0.5357564092,
-0.8636775613,
-0.9402700067,
0.5834566355,
0.1537835449,
0.11700207,
-0.394389689,
0.491337657,
0.4716001153,
0.5019637942,
-0.1805676818,
-0.0668965727,
-0.1572374105,
-0.2702881992,
-0.0486841165,
-0.3617626429,
0.005259932,
-0.1779344976,
0.1548683643,
-0.0412297659,
0.1395422518,
0.2541302741,
0.1703275889,
-0.3104789555,
0.3632866442,
0.2183950841,
0.7537584901,
-0.3411624432,
-0.1331249624,
-0.297285378,
-0.4942288101,
0.2139643282,
-0.0911594108,
-0.5645879507,
-0.0167900827,
0.03192937,
0.5525211692,
0.1130572185,
-0.8593398333,
0.5905458927,
-0.0927178264,
-0.2304905653,
-0.4850883186,
0.1493228674,
0.1353757381,
0.3777740002,
0.2964096963,
-0.3611697853,
0.4117442071,
-0.6183050275,
0.2070440352,
0.2413319349,
-0.1664349437,
-0.3294059336,
0.6352865696,
0.1892883331,
-0.2739197016,
0.9782807827,
-0.4868215024,
-0.2285939455,
0.5207386613,
0.3675776422,
0.5863468051,
-0.2260335684,
0.7444261312,
0.5729545355,
-0.1741654128,
-0.2239429057,
0.9014371037,
-0.1057276428,
-0.5704346299,
0.1758878082,
-0.596544385,
-0.5685492754,
0.1896411926,
-0.9814798236,
-0.1807020158,
-0.3486305773,
-0.6099019647,
-0.0564367957,
-0.3567372859,
-0.7370367646,
0.460788697,
-0.3881488442,
0.7639063597,
-0.9072118402,
0.1819192916,
0.6252797246,
-0.6638875604,
-1.0189042091,
-0.1004627272,
-0.0273820963,
-0.5752088428,
0.6757059693,
-0.0139167057,
0.366743803,
0.2701996267,
-0.6451373696,
-0.8245747089,
1.2196924686,
-0.1450385451,
-0.3991999328,
-0.3275531828,
0.4072257876,
0.5343829393,
-0.1575760394,
-0.0011836924,
0.4796566367,
0.1893472821,
0.0583537258,
-0.8447358012,
0.2931118906,
-0.7849476337,
0.0014623976,
0.3638138473,
-0.6965242624,
0.8961133361,
-0.3285936713,
-0.3623930812,
0.4838927984,
0.3299854696,
0.5405473709,
0.1995492727,
0.2387353927,
0.501613915,
0.7353457212,
-0.0612810627,
0.7259733677,
-0.2223233581,
-0.0887891054,
1.1360094547,
-0.5003517866,
1.0134401321,
0.2917576134,
-0.4554304481,
0.1277094483,
0.9899256825,
-0.3981022835,
0.3574914932,
0.4702994525,
-0.0558507331,
-0.3487739265,
-0.2160721272,
-0.5507282019,
0.7218857408,
0.2905582488,
-0.4042528272,
0.0886088535,
-0.0920934975,
-0.3823368847,
-0.2674652934,
-0.0995431915,
0.718413651,
-0.2320832461,
-0.5857346058,
0.3592146635,
-0.2889169455,
0.2960375249,
-0.539388001,
-0.090934366,
-0.3314567208,
-0.5597394705,
-0.3215587735,
-0.9045979381,
-0.2347178459,
-0.1925625503,
0.0508889221,
-0.0886097625,
0.589497149,
-0.3325465024,
-0.6256535649,
-0.7490845323,
0.9855108857,
0.4594891965,
0.0643029734,
-0.6051330566,
-0.1223171279,
-0.1644333452,
-0.2636935413,
0.185954839,
0.4344379306,
-0.0975865051,
0.541858077,
0.4780744016,
0.2055265158,
0.0027534696,
0.1938834041,
0.7815948129,
-0.8076794147,
-0.5919653177,
-0.3312733173,
0.7094454765,
0.012044061,
-0.6044530869,
0.785325706,
0.9209196568,
0.586440146,
-0.2754537165,
0.8814803958,
0.0646029338,
0.8227518201,
-0.4587865174,
0.4601779282,
-0.6120252609,
-0.1303928345,
-0.3560073674,
-0.4992882311,
-0.1913997829,
0.3010681868,
-0.1997864544,
-0.0033432217,
0.5600415468,
0.8920896649,
0.2442301661,
0.1085794121,
-0.0356976874,
-0.0725447461,
-0.1250733137,
0.4383196235,
1.0780155659,
-0.381059736,
0.4848259091,
-0.1974524111,
0.0942140371,
-0.0822890028,
-0.3065317571,
-0.6430485845,
-0.6827995181,
-0.4182368517,
-0.0222561043,
0.0164412111,
0.8702415228,
0.4847737849,
-0.5254485011,
-0.3289689422,
0.077448301,
-0.4179795384,
-0.0798236206,
-0.2823828757,
0.6412450671,
0.0188301634,
-0.3237758875,
-0.011489653,
0.3392000496,
0.1274405122,
-0.3315687478,
0.3246765435,
0.0931247696,
-0.1063613668,
0.595595181,
0.3699108064,
-0.4553367496,
-0.0802124813,
0.3026817441,
0.0022536367,
0.3061697483,
0.8445474505,
-0.6703642607,
0.3943214118,
0.4929482937,
0.3703966737,
0.3752093911,
0.2838325202,
0.464748621,
-0.7050074935,
-0.3616815805,
0.3917740583,
-0.0411287844,
0.2445405424,
-0.3010031581,
0.4723379612,
-0.131045416,
-0.3923148513,
-0.8554430604,
0.4060801566,
-0.7693100572,
-0.1533495188,
0.7525615096,
0.2354625612,
0.0897137821,
-0.2055851519,
-0.5967303514,
0.0550753474,
-0.3241330981,
0.8835039139,
0.4761100709,
-0.5368818045,
-0.341924727,
-0.2155998945,
0.4905617833,
0.3834780157,
-0.8507023454,
-0.0915057287,
0.440367192,
0.188454628,
0.0965669081,
0.9686781168,
-0.2130524963,
0.6171577573,
0.1935856938,
-0.2776618004,
0.0844692662,
-0.1515501589,
-0.0238797702,
0.5740101933,
0.4641306698,
-0.1369297802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14268v1
|
Can Large Language Models Detect Misinformation in Scientific News Reporting?
| 2024-02-22T04:07:00 | 2024-02-22T04:07:00 |
Yupeng Cao, Aishwarya Muralidharan Nair, Elyon Eyimife, Nastaran Jamalipour Soofi, K. P. Subbalakshmi, John R. Wullert II, Chumki Basu, David Shallcross
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Scientific facts are often spun in the popular press with the intent to
influence public opinion and action, as was evidenced during the COVID-19
pandemic. Automatic detection of misinformation in the scientific domain is
challenging because of the distinct styles of writing in these two media types
and is still in its nascence. Most research on the validity of scientific
reporting treats this problem as a claim verification challenge. In doing so,
significant expert human effort is required to generate appropriate claims. Our
solution bypasses this step and addresses a more real-world scenario where such
explicit, labeled claims may not be available. The central research question of
this paper is whether it is possible to use large language models (LLMs) to
detect misinformation in scientific reporting. To this end, we first present a
new labeled dataset SciNews, containing 2.4k scientific news stories drawn from
trusted and untrustworthy sources, paired with related abstracts from the
CORD-19 database. Our dataset includes both human-written and LLM-generated
news articles, making it more comprehensive in terms of capturing the growing
trend of using LLMs to generate popular press articles. Then, we identify
dimensions of scientific validity in science news articles and explore how this
can be integrated into the automated detection of scientific misinformation. We
propose several baseline architectures using LLMs to automatically detect false
representations of scientific findings in the popular press. For each of these
architectures, we use several prompt engineering strategies including
zero-shot, few-shot, and chain-of-thought prompting. We also test these
architectures and prompting strategies on GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama2-7B,
Llama2-13B.
|
[
-0.1236790866,
-0.7578306198,
0.8417878151,
0.5148347616,
-0.2070895582,
0.0042020916,
-0.2726470828,
-0.7373917699,
0.1902938783,
0.1776990294,
-0.0699797943,
-0.3722171783,
-0.7759263515,
0.5522195101,
-0.5753594637,
0.7960482836,
-0.1158313155,
0.2015000284,
-0.3390084505,
0.150607422,
-0.0610066503,
-0.3102937043,
-0.3555022776,
-0.2571241558,
0.6115943193,
0.3810192943,
0.591457963,
0.5643835068,
0.44696486,
0.1849813461,
-0.1543416083,
0.5084662437,
-0.2945998609,
-0.0246438645,
-0.1273708791,
-0.5749086142,
-0.2594615519,
0.1872261614,
0.7046063542,
0.3154406846,
-0.0182772856,
0.2654099762,
-0.0475194529,
0.2091317624,
-0.2669319808,
0.1496138275,
-0.805973351,
0.0642934665,
-0.3545322716,
-0.3052251935,
-0.6897653341,
-0.138431564,
-0.0588713475,
-0.4366097152,
0.2001710236,
0.341154933,
0.9255263805,
0.105031237,
-0.3778448999,
-0.4830454588,
-0.6674488783,
0.6224202514,
-0.9810825586,
0.3669638038,
0.4352929592,
0.096439071,
-0.3405769467,
-0.3764607608,
-0.7695553303,
-0.6294366121,
-0.058479555,
-0.0473382995,
-0.4285203218,
-0.3897314072,
0.4268474281,
-0.0781936571,
-0.8062909245,
0.3773634732,
-0.6294145584,
-0.3984238207,
0.5483404398,
-0.2175309509,
0.3803175092,
-0.3353848457,
-0.126833573,
0.095221296,
-0.9997692108,
-0.3945321441,
0.2013350129,
0.183842063,
-0.1524303257,
0.7064780593,
-0.0313756391,
0.4326066375,
0.2243150175,
-0.3106811941,
0.2419699728,
-0.2853065729,
-0.1639782935,
0.4816352725,
0.6982105374,
0.4758491814,
0.0918406323,
-0.0099515924,
-0.1258660108,
0.0912634432,
0.013134026,
-0.6523634791,
-0.0763516501,
0.0379699878,
-0.3120777011,
-0.3822421432,
-0.202204138,
-0.7206236124,
-0.6833822727,
-0.0861682445,
0.3276720345,
-0.080160521,
-0.1650288403,
0.224506259,
-0.0406152457,
-0.1252687126,
0.48899737,
-0.4215258658,
-0.0025167246,
0.4189054668,
0.9168903828,
-0.0722673982,
-0.1701944321,
-0.4759274423,
0.1577904522,
-0.4409716725,
0.932821393,
-0.4696136415,
-0.1146526411,
-0.2184306383,
-0.0440680161,
0.0731464922,
-0.5006409287,
0.4983204603,
-0.6690644622,
0.2919662595,
-0.3652920425,
-0.4005441666,
-0.1478401721,
0.3130702376,
-0.6640167236,
0.7483876944,
-0.1744132936,
-0.9267893434,
0.2897036672,
-0.4537056684,
-0.3054977655,
-0.0564183518,
-0.1330433637,
-0.6192048192,
0.0262918826,
0.3596854508,
0.3337496817,
-0.3327400088,
0.6392319202,
-0.3062155247,
-0.0332217924,
0.4063482881,
-0.622366488,
0.4272105992,
0.2967825234,
-0.2809338868,
-0.1686683446,
-0.6721237898,
-0.3536806405,
0.2328386605,
-0.4751160443,
-0.3804542422,
0.008680284,
-0.2987876832,
0.1125518009,
-0.0447896533,
-0.8644421697,
0.3608542681,
0.0053827865,
0.3241554499,
0.2860826254,
0.0291425195,
0.07049869,
-0.3645490408,
0.2776754797,
0.2940700352,
-0.0512381122,
-0.2458227426,
-0.5559586287,
-0.4606193006,
-0.2167351246,
0.2734140456,
0.6155506968,
-0.7177459598,
0.3199692667,
-0.0922956392,
-0.5209555626,
-0.4028817713,
0.0812729523,
0.0891531631,
0.8303245902,
0.5229175687,
0.18361938,
-0.8417894244,
-0.7509738207,
-0.4152934253,
-0.1702526212,
0.0093134651,
0.0708046556,
0.5473704338,
-0.2491095066,
0.8496835828,
-0.2656893134,
0.2019110173,
-0.0414672941,
0.5329069495,
0.3030808866,
0.1734215021,
0.5205038786,
-0.7045218945,
-0.2983142436,
-0.0469315872,
-0.8833647966,
-0.3666974902,
-0.1643710285,
0.5520159602,
0.3187629879,
0.456366986,
-0.8528219461,
0.3897229135,
0.6139681935,
-0.1776575595,
0.8225755692,
-0.2320178896,
0.3314421475,
-0.7982665896,
0.0189003572,
0.5113540888,
-0.2616589069,
-0.6488425732,
-0.4807415903,
0.1924224496,
-0.0094501032,
-0.4413845539,
0.4220303893,
-0.4556464255,
-0.0189658068,
-0.410593152,
0.0368356444,
0.0874103233,
-0.1401655972,
0.0699737445,
0.5673893094,
0.4409247041,
-0.6309639812,
0.3877149522,
0.1164082587,
-0.5670937896,
0.3633483052,
-0.7704538107,
-0.1959869415,
-0.5337189436,
0.8487548828,
-0.8309134841,
-0.5481747389,
0.3760022819,
-0.4896995723,
-0.0226137992,
-0.0078091053,
-0.7811564803,
-0.6709390879,
-0.0047799959,
0.1387248486,
0.2249568999,
-0.6508334279,
0.260227263,
0.1455697268,
-0.4538774192,
-0.4550258219,
-0.7829539776,
0.3307911158,
-0.139502421,
-0.7041020393,
0.0123719657,
0.1334783882,
-0.4603635073,
-0.0406525061,
-0.2429775,
-0.0481954776,
-0.0364276171,
0.1521136463,
0.504355073,
-0.3850774467,
0.4096478522,
-0.0180190764,
0.2903890312,
0.0764603764,
-0.0348370075,
0.3049057722,
-0.1025807783,
-0.500985086,
-0.4792053998,
0.2755390406,
0.8020186424,
-0.0774136037,
0.5692732334,
0.5503910184,
-0.4197491705,
-0.0728010163,
-0.718804419,
-0.3264158368,
-0.3659792244,
0.5007867217,
0.1458159387,
-0.7692340016,
0.3308197558,
-0.0604969449,
-0.1123568043,
0.5762280822,
0.373239398,
-0.0494843237,
1.1346129179,
0.3484856784,
-0.053059265,
0.0277805384,
0.0613210946,
0.4126695395,
-0.3527915478,
-0.3190870285,
-0.7603575587,
-0.0787947029,
-0.1392536461,
-0.4060509205,
0.5011696219,
0.0895112529,
-0.1935205162,
0.045572415,
-0.426974088,
0.6020323634,
0.3199587464,
-0.0416420326,
0.5446156859,
0.1800149679,
0.0786637738,
0.1597655565,
-0.8133308887,
-0.6188178658,
0.7391234636,
0.7525479794,
0.8574797511,
-0.1863060147,
0.4178726673,
0.4210483134,
0.6054648161,
-0.6371726394,
0.3897188008,
0.0879353583,
-0.4390446842,
-0.1339847594,
-0.4247543812,
-0.7155913711,
0.1766444445,
-0.30716452,
-0.5732585788,
0.3209481239,
0.0846159831,
-0.500846982,
0.3554772437,
-0.6633533239,
0.2597627044,
-0.5050281286,
0.1411521584,
-0.3869786561,
-0.4407514036,
0.5280705094,
-0.3078247607,
0.3936003745,
-0.1111922935,
0.1784593761,
0.8482403755,
0.0242238175,
1.0372636318,
-0.1573932916,
-0.3522216082,
0.2912384868,
0.0553550608,
0.8346194625,
0.1518388838,
-0.1164503247,
0.2804929018,
-0.1377213746,
-0.1423497796,
-0.3087143898,
0.578625679,
-0.6704606414,
-0.6570548415,
-0.6698183417,
-0.6576098204,
-0.1464479715,
0.2027641088,
0.2928907573,
0.1641416848,
-0.0287682768,
0.190475449,
0.7328916788,
-0.2987605631,
0.316162765,
0.9850008488,
-0.2111494988,
-0.1571846455,
0.7992253304,
0.2114537209,
-0.0025163922,
0.0225717444,
0.3483159542,
-0.1564275324,
-0.7217566371,
-0.2932855785,
0.5325706005,
-0.4430199564,
-0.4910171628,
-0.5788269043,
-0.3690122068,
-0.4281113148,
0.0885813758,
-0.19340159,
-0.174156338,
-0.5274444222,
-0.1970854253,
0.3989919424,
0.9006915092,
-0.2474568188,
0.230802983,
-0.9986174107,
0.3854450583,
0.1259088218,
0.0737454519,
-0.0402044468,
-0.5262833834,
-0.2069834918,
0.4675396979,
-0.232256487,
-0.7885349393,
0.6105002761,
0.0050984509,
0.5229397416,
0.4600175321,
-0.1417396069,
0.3668180406,
-0.4762477577,
0.8109238148,
0.4092184901,
-0.7247509956,
0.4711989164,
-0.4194726944,
-0.0088496413,
0.0775750428,
0.851739943,
-0.7129432559,
-0.5060779452,
-0.6067011952,
-0.4122689366,
0.4125294387,
-0.3099166751,
-0.1515020579,
-0.175579384,
0.1142037064,
0.2624386251,
0.0985347405,
-0.7830246091,
0.1243426427,
-0.2318518162,
-0.110392794,
0.0863280147,
-0.2947456539,
-0.3597783744,
-0.1316688061,
0.5796465278,
-0.1689338237,
0.0934581831,
0.4218099713,
-0.2510710061,
-0.3932678998,
0.3719338775,
0.9262320995,
0.8064724207,
0.0079123201,
0.4380103052,
-0.0738802329,
-0.4688464999,
0.0235110819,
0.0651866719,
-0.4305257797,
0.2591071725,
0.3751868308,
0.7257079482,
0.0614196584,
-0.6671143174,
0.4929517508,
0.1893468052,
-0.3273768127,
-0.0479663573,
-0.2285920829,
0.0378319956,
0.3803604543,
0.6936422586,
0.3117288053,
-0.0949253812,
-0.5316327214,
0.1911038756,
0.3421207666,
0.110366419,
-0.5496799946,
0.4811205566,
0.0824432373,
0.07111343,
0.4259675741,
-0.0883033127,
-0.4156315923,
0.5427476764,
0.7558701038,
0.3328340948,
-0.3432958722,
0.6574445367,
0.1523094624,
0.3761352599,
-0.5934241414,
-0.0068152752,
0.483993113,
-0.6974009871,
-0.6897004247,
-0.4501542449,
-0.2558193207,
0.3943713903,
-0.1685379148,
0.2330863774,
-0.271754086,
-0.107000798,
0.3252516091,
-0.1721356511,
-0.3003814518,
-0.0359210745,
0.6056619883,
1.095869422,
-1.3456748724,
0.7121741772,
0.4070478976,
-0.2970757186,
-0.6410670877,
-0.0217276625,
0.360065937,
-0.776298821,
1.0417108536,
-0.0029438282,
0.0624993257,
-0.3780566752,
-1.1932762861,
-1.0294116735,
0.9380441904,
0.4877141118,
-0.8034742475,
-0.0116242142,
0.0814458504,
0.4840248823,
-0.4407117665,
0.1590081155,
0.2532374263,
0.8909168243,
0.3436839879,
-1.2252656221,
0.0382210612,
-0.0295494106,
-0.4296606183,
-0.2283872068,
-0.5135979056,
0.8301668167,
-0.3597956896,
-0.1148446128,
-0.0815146863,
0.7932235599,
0.4938582182,
0.7326045036,
0.4008294642,
0.3371394873,
1.2131458521,
0.0605718084,
0.8539327383,
-0.0232253931,
0.1825095117,
0.8515242934,
-0.4450552762,
0.7173653841,
0.4085180461,
0.0083979266,
0.4038241804,
0.6798223257,
-0.4013685584,
0.303657949,
0.2626358569,
-0.1482102126,
-0.2207239121,
-0.3990734518,
-0.4347657561,
0.3700510263,
0.6692088246,
-0.4573182762,
-0.4696864784,
0.1867422014,
0.3061350882,
-0.1383117139,
-0.4706910551,
0.291768074,
0.1792463213,
-0.5827200413,
0.7632212043,
0.0327276923,
0.7177498341,
-0.4610129297,
-0.0813741758,
0.0013393518,
-0.1063949764,
-0.4109442532,
-0.7263666987,
0.1674044281,
0.1990630329,
-0.3305719495,
0.0470685586,
0.8932215571,
-0.693033576,
-0.4315804541,
-0.2598532736,
0.4330960512,
0.1794281006,
-0.0137163848,
-0.3480879366,
0.3313047588,
0.0289271846,
-0.0886056051,
0.1755288541,
0.2271271199,
-0.2667575777,
0.7908145189,
0.62282902,
0.5361047983,
0.1355272382,
-0.0427090563,
0.756219089,
-0.3161101043,
-0.2164566815,
-0.6463722587,
0.0994382799,
-0.2930109501,
0.1467576027,
1.0008627176,
0.4652987123,
0.3034514189,
-0.2190284878,
1.1318861246,
0.151230827,
0.6191680431,
-0.3767986894,
0.6925147772,
-0.1153710037,
0.1705990881,
-0.0019068177,
-0.694747448,
-0.6382710934,
0.3561886847,
-0.5904206038,
-0.2645489275,
0.7552485466,
0.8032820225,
-0.1155401096,
0.2580213845,
0.0647126138,
0.7645624876,
0.4010258019,
0.1909801513,
0.9724357128,
-0.0601066388,
0.4278725982,
0.2921303511,
-0.2516575754,
-0.564689815,
-1.0485496521,
-0.7366511226,
-0.3235180974,
-0.5385314226,
-0.4925662577,
0.1412478238,
0.7818883657,
0.4605080187,
-0.7571390271,
0.2480918914,
0.0642973036,
0.0716384649,
0.0329989567,
-0.1885770708,
0.4242100418,
-0.1051824018,
-0.2665284574,
0.6631948948,
0.2787129879,
0.3420693576,
-0.3526924849,
0.033344958,
-0.2406019866,
0.3832624257,
0.4866412282,
0.6698758602,
-0.6828753352,
-0.3568018675,
-0.0344351903,
-0.2256953865,
-0.0538615547,
0.7265635133,
-0.6934088469,
0.0511016287,
0.5162940025,
0.5835351348,
0.3650636375,
-0.0444090553,
0.3683222234,
-0.6533808708,
-0.0374655351,
0.3637076616,
0.2863957882,
0.4487261474,
-0.4932655394,
0.0941007435,
0.3591507375,
-0.6553263664,
-0.9902203679,
-0.0397059508,
-0.8965963721,
-0.2014704943,
1.3621391058,
0.03428955,
-0.4810867608,
-0.1905487925,
-0.2047416717,
-0.0131132333,
-0.441100508,
1.1127564907,
0.8677123785,
-0.0654222816,
-0.1302986443,
-0.5075696111,
0.4164919555,
0.131559357,
-0.6929338574,
0.1060569137,
0.6329171658,
0.3681892157,
0.4627058804,
0.2933698893,
-0.0749277249,
0.4420893788,
-0.158136338,
-0.1059376672,
-0.3027694523,
-0.4180549383,
-0.0967266932,
0.0747304708,
-0.1310552806,
0.2265963107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14259v1
|
Word-Sequence Entropy: Towards Uncertainty Estimation in Free-Form Medical Question Answering Applications and Beyond
| 2024-02-22T03:46:08 | 2024-02-22T03:46:08 |
Zhiyuan Wang, Jinhao Duan, Chenxi Yuan, Qingyu Chen, Tianlong Chen, Huaxiu Yao, Yue Zhang, Ren Wang, Kaidi Xu, Xiaoshuang Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Uncertainty estimation plays a pivotal role in ensuring the reliability of
safety-critical human-AI interaction systems, particularly in the medical
domain. However, a general method for quantifying the uncertainty of free-form
answers has yet to be established in open-ended medical question-answering (QA)
tasks, where irrelevant words and sequences with limited semantic information
can be the primary source of uncertainty due to the presence of generative
inequality. In this paper, we propose the Word-Sequence Entropy (WSE), which
calibrates the uncertainty proportion at both the word and sequence levels
according to the semantic relevance, with greater emphasis placed on keywords
and more relevant sequences when performing uncertainty quantification. We
compare WSE with 6 baseline methods on 5 free-form medical QA datasets,
utilizing 7 "off-the-shelf" large language models (LLMs), and show that WSE
exhibits superior performance on accurate uncertainty measurement under two
standard criteria for correctness evaluation (e.g., WSE outperforms existing
state-of-the-art method by 3.23% AUROC on the MedQA dataset). Additionally, in
terms of the potential for real-world medical QA applications, we achieve a
significant enhancement in the performance of LLMs when employing sequences
with lower uncertainty, identified by WSE, as final answers (e.g., +6.36%
accuracy improvement on the COVID-QA dataset), without requiring any additional
task-specific fine-tuning or architectural modifications.
|
[
-0.0411512367,
-0.4771779776,
0.9153439403,
-0.1120614931,
-0.4625425041,
-0.1812352389,
0.0717952847,
-0.3952050209,
0.3342747986,
-0.1050320715,
-0.4989958405,
-0.3695805967,
-0.8187818527,
0.0226827245,
-0.1299297363,
0.3991464376,
-0.1275914758,
0.306581527,
-0.6562156677,
-0.1045768633,
-0.410132736,
-0.2595377564,
-0.3560189903,
-0.0688460469,
0.591193974,
0.0284564532,
0.8789430857,
0.3989851773,
0.5783612728,
0.2670941353,
0.0834870264,
0.1001809537,
0.1068953574,
0.4475722611,
-0.0498925224,
-0.6227276325,
-0.3528366685,
-0.2297645658,
0.1205943823,
0.5454977155,
-0.3946152329,
0.3422029316,
-0.0387338512,
0.7069387436,
-0.9658475518,
-0.0244345032,
-0.4939233065,
0.1073703915,
-0.0816547498,
-0.2362622023,
-0.1631024629,
-0.349485755,
0.2135213017,
-0.8002405167,
-0.155047074,
0.1015167236,
0.8061847687,
0.6889336705,
-0.1024822518,
-0.177534461,
-0.6065977812,
0.574282825,
-1.0451830626,
0.7513800263,
0.6405214071,
0.0317196362,
-0.0223061368,
-0.51557827,
-0.4571790993,
0.1688271612,
0.5058054328,
0.3108511865,
-0.1709086597,
0.4062899351,
-0.1412424147,
0.38232705,
-0.7927980423,
0.1800622642,
-0.2847533226,
-0.3888480365,
0.5484431386,
0.1999160349,
0.3399752676,
0.1613356024,
-0.0536497645,
-0.1437164843,
-0.495195955,
0.1073295921,
-0.1636992395,
-0.091743499,
-0.0785959512,
0.7089898586,
-0.1309181899,
0.8375998735,
-0.1049733311,
-0.2570672035,
0.2569229603,
-0.0417261533,
-0.4816035628,
-0.1434593052,
0.7576797605,
0.3698736727,
-0.1043310314,
-0.4281559885,
-0.007487407,
0.0206719935,
0.2498917729,
-0.6748760343,
0.1200065762,
0.8253771663,
-0.2065250576,
-0.1905269027,
0.2350807488,
-0.7293159366,
-0.4871058762,
-0.1096450239,
0.633033812,
-0.4276751578,
0.0533662736,
0.4022429585,
-0.2382609397,
0.2026240677,
0.3202033043,
-0.4147800207,
-0.0546351038,
0.6716900468,
0.8660050035,
-0.0250788424,
-0.0245047752,
-0.4853410423,
-0.0566240251,
-0.598664701,
0.4351560771,
-0.3974195421,
-0.2257329971,
-0.2176310569,
-0.2286288738,
-0.122049734,
-0.4099679291,
0.2722600102,
-0.711314261,
0.3687216341,
0.0943297967,
-0.8605463505,
-0.0027572666,
0.1944412589,
-0.3954797089,
0.6404120326,
0.0478830151,
-0.8770002723,
0.3369550705,
-0.332382828,
-0.1329742223,
0.1512173414,
-0.1642218232,
-0.2501938939,
0.41396299,
0.2464040369,
0.2662995756,
-0.6604444385,
0.2794721127,
-0.4179835618,
-0.3089633882,
0.5345822573,
-0.6156132817,
0.5255974531,
0.2690677643,
-0.0321216173,
0.0416234136,
-0.5993077755,
0.5109007955,
-0.1800709963,
-0.0432644337,
-0.6704820395,
0.1079262346,
-0.6136474609,
0.2915882766,
0.2895916104,
-0.7411576509,
-0.1226284951,
-0.747759819,
0.222401917,
0.4191118479,
0.171948716,
0.3214940429,
-0.4758196175,
0.9184832573,
0.0684498847,
0.2347571552,
0.4008470774,
-0.9109652638,
-0.0871987343,
-0.3469504416,
0.6587025523,
1.2813748121,
-0.9203909636,
0.5337714553,
-0.3425545692,
-0.5594930053,
-0.8651429415,
-0.0878382102,
0.2893483639,
0.3914988637,
0.3709544241,
-0.4910824597,
-0.4215153754,
-0.3344380558,
-0.1477998048,
-0.590472579,
-0.6187945008,
0.2168973982,
0.1320746243,
-0.176979959,
0.7665957212,
-0.7685272694,
0.1645852327,
0.2088101357,
0.1495772302,
0.0746437311,
0.2081647813,
-0.0165016353,
-0.5327410102,
0.1079283878,
-0.4661083221,
-0.6464708447,
-0.0521805473,
0.2124546319,
-0.1628315598,
0.1046037748,
0.2213177234,
-0.6340392828,
0.5844658017,
0.7121851444,
-0.3300147057,
0.392118454,
-0.3034057021,
0.1737853736,
-1.4273792505,
0.0563292541,
-0.0384018905,
0.1248562485,
-0.653719306,
0.230644539,
0.1489382237,
0.0175324176,
-0.4765859842,
0.5702927709,
-0.2080285996,
0.2288106084,
0.0406758711,
-0.0965358019,
0.23791188,
0.0878287926,
-0.0657010451,
0.9424217343,
0.4782903194,
-0.4674642384,
0.2882885635,
0.0909491181,
-0.5385958552,
0.4338085651,
-0.6762727499,
0.0269105993,
-0.2834190428,
-0.0220407695,
-0.7950761318,
-0.2987359464,
0.1456526518,
-0.5605513453,
0.2070919424,
0.2221623063,
-0.2230652273,
-0.5358855724,
-0.4123856723,
0.6432728171,
0.564255774,
0.266068399,
-0.0413363241,
0.3116076589,
-0.2596010566,
-0.7224850059,
-0.7671867013,
0.0233364254,
-0.1417604983,
-0.7373963594,
0.2736773789,
-0.1394616812,
-0.2336671054,
-0.1950437576,
-0.3636986613,
-0.4010245502,
0.1991371512,
0.2663474977,
0.3554541469,
-0.337443769,
0.3765192628,
0.1386868358,
0.1732695252,
-0.0812057331,
-0.4602121115,
0.3538820744,
0.1353242397,
-0.6004734039,
-0.4020169973,
0.367693007,
0.7524427772,
-0.2148476541,
0.7165568471,
0.3684435487,
-0.7030992508,
0.4644604623,
-0.3147076964,
-0.1765114963,
-0.4125934541,
0.3003440201,
-0.0799712986,
-1.0201489925,
0.4881564379,
0.3664487898,
-0.1376163065,
0.5805699825,
0.3325659037,
-0.314568907,
0.8775634766,
0.2493170053,
-0.1455898434,
0.0604549572,
0.252925396,
0.1798340529,
-0.6508929133,
-0.0929858834,
-0.492269218,
-0.1151382551,
-0.3476925492,
-0.7945765853,
0.7761454582,
0.1682111323,
-0.3063394725,
-0.0597797334,
-0.3994597793,
0.0163221452,
0.5818202496,
0.4083849192,
0.0858955979,
-0.1561480463,
-0.0935016498,
0.1355272084,
-0.6035419106,
-0.0846020281,
0.9221066236,
0.2918421924,
0.8821166158,
0.0839112997,
0.8577597737,
0.1495687068,
-0.0769670233,
-0.7245567441,
0.2238474339,
-0.0772849992,
-0.3943164945,
-0.7555498481,
-0.598736763,
-1.0332843065,
-0.0023162137,
-0.0138530713,
-0.7846528292,
0.3412513137,
0.1146838516,
-1.0150897503,
0.3810465038,
-0.4331577718,
0.6895796061,
-0.0036693269,
0.0069827917,
0.1313955337,
-0.9695308208,
0.1344318837,
-0.1609379649,
0.1673436612,
-0.1929722875,
-0.4219198525,
0.6060205102,
-0.8308724761,
0.6716674566,
-0.2298579365,
-0.5650674105,
0.403149575,
-0.0564651303,
0.4505980313,
-0.0046510613,
-0.2399603575,
0.2588457167,
0.6126250029,
-0.3864186108,
-0.5349914432,
0.0859224573,
-0.5769198537,
-0.4731946886,
-0.4639366269,
-0.6340675354,
-0.6312122345,
0.0183307044,
0.7454410195,
0.4205410779,
-0.0516429879,
-0.0032184862,
0.6574011445,
-0.5467264056,
0.187940374,
0.1923555434,
0.3606340885,
-0.595027864,
0.7122729421,
0.2118989229,
0.2586135864,
0.7880125046,
0.2423412353,
-0.403262645,
-0.5415111184,
-0.6892762184,
-0.0386457518,
-0.2026559114,
-0.6505900025,
-0.3769046068,
-0.3796782196,
-0.5247721076,
-0.0324152634,
0.0054327357,
-0.6171129346,
-0.283325702,
0.0682874545,
0.5287936926,
0.2538543642,
-0.0120602027,
0.0146065988,
-1.1704779863,
0.4238146842,
0.3970559835,
0.5950465202,
-0.2838879526,
-0.6641819477,
-0.1058919504,
0.4259808064,
-0.1259998828,
-1.2243549824,
0.3617052436,
0.4515111446,
0.18729873,
0.320843637,
0.2815540433,
0.6804335117,
-0.3744062185,
1.0615137815,
0.2005236,
-0.6800103188,
0.4593223631,
0.0460008644,
0.4795349836,
0.6182130575,
0.1218360886,
-0.7359434962,
-0.6591011286,
-0.4950456023,
-1.0872317553,
0.1480023712,
0.1118241847,
-0.0456173383,
-0.1084779501,
0.4014370739,
-0.1643448621,
0.3360635936,
0.0203708541,
-0.0636193156,
0.0878231972,
-0.7530404925,
0.149997279,
-0.1605769694,
0.0190821476,
-0.1357795447,
0.7556481957,
-0.1072577313,
0.7011948824,
0.4444724023,
-0.178767547,
-0.2444300801,
0.6484506726,
0.7932212949,
0.5313406587,
-0.3222227991,
0.061085131,
0.3532447517,
-0.735935688,
0.4134121239,
0.1195562109,
-0.2010884583,
-0.0445832796,
0.2642642558,
0.4812101722,
-0.2595817745,
-0.9344064593,
0.7619276047,
0.0010898042,
0.0156827718,
-0.0727859512,
-0.0470140725,
-0.0838687718,
0.1116046309,
0.1745962799,
0.0326030999,
0.3283916116,
0.0388338454,
0.4572575688,
0.3317627907,
-0.5726667643,
-0.169719398,
0.8286377788,
-0.2392443866,
0.0670705512,
0.486641705,
-0.0784790218,
0.0308642425,
0.7514660358,
0.3331598938,
1.0670224428,
-0.5119429827,
0.133307904,
0.2526488304,
0.185684666,
-0.2319275439,
0.8819810152,
0.261264503,
-0.7053288221,
-0.6603361368,
-0.6882107258,
-0.4761755168,
-0.0990287215,
-0.8787869215,
-0.2402483523,
-0.1572890431,
-0.2876129746,
-0.3692921698,
-0.3735239208,
-0.6032325625,
0.3854297996,
0.3045846224,
1.0561877489,
-0.5676528215,
0.6350420117,
0.6355863214,
-0.2930280864,
-0.7751022577,
0.1764401942,
0.0823503435,
-0.883603394,
-0.0698283091,
-0.082736522,
-0.0061869663,
-0.2215564251,
-0.3569560647,
-1.0826611519,
1.2680760622,
0.3481594622,
-0.482442081,
-0.3079896271,
0.2834072411,
0.5421133637,
0.133057043,
-0.0396657325,
0.1572218984,
0.1299853772,
0.0362218544,
-0.9443064928,
0.2285094559,
-0.2487878799,
0.1510727853,
0.3988230824,
-0.2108869702,
0.1271121353,
-0.46610412,
-0.0854327455,
0.5003065467,
0.7483230829,
0.2445416898,
0.5376933217,
0.4670254886,
0.8189678788,
1.1462225914,
-0.0809386373,
0.934258461,
-0.6578669548,
0.0082155894,
0.9670468569,
-0.2124161869,
0.9968793392,
0.5208426118,
-0.4177714884,
0.4316526949,
0.7999581695,
0.5171375275,
0.4806503952,
0.433871299,
-0.4782834947,
-0.1247234121,
0.0648231059,
-0.3982205093,
0.1789230257,
0.7039197087,
-0.2587378621,
0.0646989644,
0.1350262612,
-0.0519159175,
-0.5360550284,
-0.2790427804,
0.9388266802,
0.2567276359,
-0.7685301304,
0.5293664932,
0.0468362235,
0.5547682643,
-0.6346985698,
0.2771639228,
-0.1297965795,
-0.181382075,
-0.061443083,
-0.7695158124,
0.3587180972,
-0.0026587804,
-0.0955626443,
0.3314525485,
0.5632593632,
-0.5320906639,
-0.5127551556,
-0.3097096384,
0.6770149469,
0.1678259373,
-0.3530923426,
-0.5566008687,
-0.39093557,
-0.2856769264,
-0.0445803851,
0.070145525,
0.5645008683,
-0.0793151855,
0.5392705798,
0.0965864807,
0.2517351508,
0.2536372244,
-0.0869282037,
0.2918714285,
-0.471490562,
-0.391934067,
-0.8073089719,
0.4315317571,
0.2448731363,
-0.3774166107,
0.1460366845,
0.388181299,
0.4902818501,
-0.0708427057,
0.6848244071,
-0.1897548735,
0.2898190022,
-0.4585258365,
0.5459174514,
-0.762163341,
-0.0076702503,
-0.3260767162,
-0.2511830926,
-0.5929990411,
0.3298779428,
0.0061149728,
-0.2152487934,
0.5415229201,
0.8796806335,
0.1399392635,
-0.0214542653,
0.5349406004,
-0.0030054639,
-0.0825265571,
0.6732251048,
0.4299476445,
-0.6042612791,
0.2451612502,
-0.2109598666,
-0.3243073821,
0.0513320975,
-0.7291004658,
0.072061494,
-0.7164398432,
-0.4209688902,
-0.5712561607,
0.1903567612,
1.1961112022,
0.4769456983,
-1.0159645081,
0.1644892246,
0.0873735771,
0.0824230984,
-0.5763184428,
-0.1032700688,
0.5237028599,
-0.3655405343,
-0.2360558659,
0.3320632875,
0.3443993628,
0.1666610837,
0.1734077334,
-0.0948494598,
0.1000376344,
0.6017190218,
0.5323233604,
0.3975890279,
-0.8047901988,
-0.4232468307,
0.301695466,
-0.2519114912,
0.0816817433,
0.42856282,
-0.4123724699,
0.4001350999,
0.6979154348,
0.951946497,
-0.2357213795,
0.0854467452,
0.6341301203,
-0.8525487185,
-0.1218026206,
0.2466442585,
0.4195332825,
0.1123853698,
-0.4407373369,
0.4593628347,
0.2150764763,
-0.4437286854,
-0.6153026819,
0.2253096402,
-0.8562364578,
-0.3088470101,
1.1811016798,
-0.0180075746,
-0.153817609,
-0.1500896513,
0.087259084,
0.410296917,
-0.1377682984,
0.8175556064,
0.6914047003,
-0.0609658509,
-0.0556027181,
-0.3949548304,
0.4366915226,
0.5758147836,
-0.8475499153,
-0.2290532887,
0.4115172625,
0.1923703849,
0.0807289332,
0.6601887941,
-0.2406430244,
0.3334102333,
-0.4124052227,
0.2503598034,
0.3731413186,
-0.186349839,
-0.419830054,
0.1617480069,
0.3579050899,
-0.6108144522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14258v1
|
Eagle: Ethical Dataset Given from Real Interactions
| 2024-02-22T03:46:02 | 2024-02-22T03:46:02 |
Masahiro Kaneko, Danushka Bollegala, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) have
ethical-related problems such as social biases, lack of moral reasoning, and
generation of offensive content. The existing evaluation metrics and methods to
address these ethical challenges use datasets intentionally created by
instructing humans to create instances including ethical problems. Therefore,
the data does not reflect prompts that users actually provide when utilizing
LLM services in everyday contexts. This may not lead to the development of safe
LLMs that can address ethical challenges arising in real-world applications. In
this paper, we create Eagle datasets extracted from real interactions between
ChatGPT and users that exhibit social biases, toxicity, and immoral problems.
Our experiments show that Eagle captures complementary aspects, not covered by
existing datasets proposed for evaluation and mitigation of such ethical
challenges. Our code is publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/MasahiroKaneko/eagle.
|
[
-0.1328098029,
-0.9343094826,
0.3026050329,
0.3719944656,
-0.0069614043,
-0.0052497922,
-0.1371206641,
-0.9782329202,
0.3363929987,
0.9014540911,
-0.7454797626,
-0.3471113145,
-0.5192225575,
0.0953334123,
-0.3572972715,
0.9849870801,
0.2781264782,
0.0848286971,
0.1518062502,
-0.2927534878,
-0.2092647702,
-0.7890356183,
-1.0353746414,
-0.0681408942,
0.4347258806,
0.5587317944,
0.775913775,
0.8717102408,
0.6175186038,
0.2343892306,
-0.0464789867,
0.0991185233,
-0.9282665849,
0.063065514,
0.021951003,
-0.0615977049,
-0.2312960029,
0.2992907465,
0.4082188904,
0.440821439,
-0.0063871355,
0.5014443398,
-0.0077895848,
0.5639026165,
-0.5730390549,
0.1145937815,
-0.4975378513,
0.4141038358,
-0.1572352797,
-0.2693360746,
-0.2494809031,
-0.5316594839,
0.0878057331,
-0.6518861055,
-0.2929711938,
0.3529767096,
0.7365421057,
0.0581692308,
-0.4773665369,
-0.8237909079,
-0.5809474587,
0.9194974303,
-0.8057016134,
0.2131226957,
0.6272748709,
0.3201670647,
-0.3038991094,
-0.5352117419,
-0.6788305044,
-0.1820840836,
0.0718381479,
-0.0574326478,
-0.0675609782,
-0.1243931726,
-0.1042384654,
0.4145626128,
-0.2459049672,
0.3332339227,
-0.3371811211,
-0.2668132186,
0.7982982397,
0.4230132103,
0.3859536946,
-0.34488222,
-0.3060772419,
-0.3351261616,
-0.9213926792,
0.4016160667,
0.9068535566,
0.4486369491,
-0.2517613769,
0.7209361792,
-0.0180212855,
0.2745845318,
-0.0057853409,
0.210902527,
0.3434010446,
-0.2521051168,
-0.1304694414,
0.2185323387,
0.8114565015,
0.7760573626,
0.6613562107,
-0.0177058093,
0.0280240569,
-0.1761710495,
0.0477159396,
-0.8526932001,
0.2223938257,
0.4619142711,
-0.8389683962,
-0.7663668394,
0.0981538892,
-0.654368341,
-0.6588380337,
-0.3074942529,
-0.0145101864,
-0.0711794794,
-0.5716920495,
0.3598591089,
0.1686444283,
0.5774538517,
-0.1178381965,
-0.5880362988,
0.4084457457,
1.0305521488,
0.6614747643,
0.3451155126,
-0.2139348686,
-0.8954798579,
0.1370009035,
-0.3069261909,
0.5085840821,
-0.8919939399,
-0.3888086975,
0.3409948051,
0.1561576426,
0.3530223668,
-0.5574242473,
0.9342573285,
-0.3289781809,
-0.1426665187,
-0.8765083551,
-0.4784694016,
-0.0996594876,
0.2962712348,
-0.6036189198,
0.7864146233,
-0.5232532024,
-0.8309864402,
0.4083857834,
-0.9454082847,
-0.2828636169,
0.2273396552,
-0.3853369057,
-0.310695678,
-0.4544577599,
0.2756372392,
0.5373523235,
-0.0227232967,
0.1149013489,
-0.6754878759,
-0.4928442836,
0.399828285,
-0.2535060048,
1.1693491936,
0.4264895022,
-0.2192467004,
0.0639723763,
-0.6195604205,
-0.1483731866,
0.2005931735,
-0.1987130046,
-0.4821054637,
0.104666397,
0.3707860112,
0.1320449263,
0.18536295,
-0.7271160483,
-0.129815802,
-0.2401732057,
0.3480744362,
1.0570846796,
0.2303165942,
0.1412043273,
-0.5145809054,
0.4198022783,
-0.188333407,
0.4606426656,
0.4958854914,
-0.3326206207,
-0.6296293139,
-0.2559274137,
-0.1593000293,
0.7264008522,
-0.3463862538,
0.3367805183,
-0.3172859251,
-0.2310697138,
-0.6200609803,
0.2222669274,
0.5575477481,
0.4899424016,
-0.0421364419,
0.0615668967,
-0.4139792025,
-1.1625984907,
-0.4663020372,
-0.2109119892,
-0.2003224194,
0.8751019239,
0.3270249665,
-0.2142371237,
0.8235172033,
-0.0701206326,
-0.4768656194,
0.0314192809,
0.3214546442,
-0.1639353186,
0.5301317573,
0.5312281251,
-0.8428606391,
-0.1300976127,
-0.2449561507,
-1.1376174688,
-0.1766017526,
-0.1701484919,
-0.3302382231,
-0.2010555416,
0.3947065473,
-0.2451430559,
0.2376560718,
0.4323883653,
-0.4113811553,
0.4606107175,
0.1045029163,
0.3920042515,
-0.9647318721,
0.0151274716,
0.240622595,
-0.1309845597,
-0.3271138966,
-0.0070944754,
-0.3838681281,
-0.0912360623,
-0.8354710937,
0.6852188706,
-0.171889022,
-0.1871912777,
-0.0224407688,
-0.1101628616,
-0.2381785959,
0.0335723236,
0.1206845343,
0.8317489028,
0.453180939,
-0.3683156669,
0.4159750938,
0.6672445536,
-0.3005335927,
0.6679466963,
-0.7560340166,
0.1721301228,
-0.0381071493,
0.2224286497,
-0.2095976323,
-0.2777771354,
0.8340947628,
-0.3281795382,
-0.4521994591,
-0.131708771,
-0.9094081521,
0.0803786367,
-0.716135025,
0.4826328754,
0.4274629354,
-0.5396936536,
0.2191010565,
0.7237507701,
-0.265897125,
-0.7682170868,
-0.8229003549,
0.4762159288,
-0.4637204409,
-0.7151703835,
-0.3495637476,
0.0448471196,
-0.5732389092,
0.1724762619,
0.3644888103,
-0.0386164635,
-0.1062159687,
0.3520819545,
0.0158970617,
-0.1706164926,
0.0250358339,
-0.0910257697,
0.1138742268,
0.3431507349,
0.3662610352,
0.2331220657,
-0.657766819,
-0.4857579172,
-0.4510287046,
0.5629534721,
0.1029846519,
-0.2902740538,
0.7576278448,
0.4559084177,
-0.5372077823,
0.1435069144,
-0.599542439,
-0.30259642,
-0.5584850907,
0.225695014,
0.0868159384,
-1.0610421896,
0.8244248033,
0.1558399051,
0.4650145173,
-0.1169913635,
0.4723305702,
-0.1965444833,
0.7878238559,
0.4544265866,
0.017618956,
0.3119656444,
-0.1334880143,
0.2707002759,
-0.9656097293,
-0.108418569,
-0.2302428633,
-0.239736855,
-0.6775798798,
0.0501826815,
0.1793030202,
-0.302531451,
-0.3611923158,
-0.0319570489,
-0.3661566973,
0.7168672681,
0.2448044568,
0.3289008737,
0.3614942133,
-0.038614478,
0.3935899734,
0.012958345,
-0.4132591188,
-1.0582339764,
1.1899820566,
0.4021489322,
0.7904717326,
0.1854770482,
0.5976223946,
0.7117572427,
0.3461376131,
-0.5921714902,
0.6497907639,
-0.1176589727,
-0.8119445443,
-0.2826359868,
-0.735023737,
-1.1315231323,
-0.0292086564,
-0.3546229601,
-0.9138618112,
0.2351262271,
0.0877154395,
-0.3346622586,
0.1628840715,
-0.5977972746,
0.6636568904,
-0.4117288291,
-0.5851421356,
-0.0274721403,
-0.7627776861,
0.4741627872,
-0.0315959677,
0.5119652152,
-0.0905653462,
0.2073894739,
1.0587030649,
-0.5263918042,
1.0807663202,
-0.0287360866,
-0.0736524016,
0.4420450032,
0.0608875118,
0.5441983342,
0.3420741558,
-0.2718268335,
0.0771350116,
0.1914271265,
-0.4707414508,
-0.1557064503,
0.931527853,
-0.752053678,
-0.3643827438,
-0.5854780078,
-0.64963907,
-0.3278105855,
0.1925579309,
-0.1282772571,
0.4228818119,
-0.1090602577,
0.3567522466,
0.5096871257,
-0.4004492164,
0.1535725594,
0.575227201,
-0.2103607655,
-0.0466244891,
0.7835344672,
0.0983917639,
-0.0418996774,
-0.3515841067,
0.1991322041,
-0.3777762353,
-0.1892753541,
-0.3997491002,
0.299598515,
-0.8770590425,
0.046453502,
-0.3251321912,
-0.1766248345,
-0.1361527741,
-0.2845526338,
-0.4216926694,
-0.0435241573,
-0.1806815863,
-0.3814612627,
0.6078842878,
0.6559397578,
-0.2346072048,
0.2802353501,
-0.8689211011,
0.1533531696,
0.1794026196,
0.5249644518,
-0.0298057906,
-0.020169884,
0.0550768301,
0.4836507142,
-0.0570720658,
-0.4829327166,
0.1200372055,
0.1590532064,
0.4818000197,
0.2693423033,
0.3898411393,
0.7301369905,
-0.1797163785,
0.621250689,
-0.310112536,
-0.7039054632,
0.1552873403,
-0.5418455601,
-0.3975270092,
0.6930423975,
0.2530095875,
-0.6768622994,
-0.4372522533,
-0.5587128401,
-0.8178614378,
0.5889077187,
0.7558407784,
0.3579084277,
-0.001245501,
0.6066691279,
0.0543591678,
0.127371788,
-0.8133051395,
-0.1357873231,
-0.1403836012,
-0.3738958836,
0.342772752,
-0.1915308088,
-0.2862570584,
0.1649091989,
0.7163581848,
0.305983901,
-0.0553973429,
0.0654653683,
-0.1035905778,
-0.3458739519,
0.1432905644,
0.3861851394,
0.7559227347,
-0.4651064277,
-0.0878973082,
-0.0631187633,
-0.5231251717,
-0.006107789,
-0.1119744182,
0.1364846975,
-0.6108919382,
0.4227879345,
0.1415849179,
0.0918723047,
-1.0004212856,
0.6652151346,
-0.4259947538,
-0.1210192144,
-0.6432262659,
-0.083261326,
0.0673971772,
0.3979455829,
0.3835300207,
-0.3795399666,
0.3733917773,
-0.4232779443,
0.285448432,
0.6230250597,
-0.2442073226,
-0.0993287116,
0.4192326069,
0.4997175932,
-0.4015278816,
0.7277868986,
-0.1264766157,
-0.273494184,
0.6535593867,
0.2192251533,
0.6520718932,
0.2321687788,
0.175262481,
-0.0086728474,
0.4928100407,
0.1158797219,
0.2849875391,
0.187841475,
-0.8273510933,
-0.4023782909,
-0.4906648993,
-0.684153676,
0.7590008378,
-0.7744678259,
0.2023536116,
-0.5768449306,
0.1161566377,
-0.1448726505,
0.1060897186,
-0.3891043663,
-0.0074822451,
-0.0552970581,
0.7708964944,
-1.1342015266,
0.4384797812,
0.5871806145,
-0.4981485903,
-0.5610253811,
-0.1319576502,
0.2224024683,
-1.0799889565,
0.6123042107,
0.2290731966,
-0.3980506957,
-0.2596929669,
-0.8267320991,
-0.2458650172,
0.7237735987,
0.4867480099,
-0.3023526073,
0.3696445525,
0.6547367573,
0.4558323324,
-0.4433242679,
-0.1046143696,
0.1729478389,
0.5558307171,
0.02103303,
-0.6536269188,
0.1398323625,
-0.5327221155,
-0.1903323233,
-0.2321256101,
-0.8204591274,
0.6881652474,
0.3080832958,
-0.0660416484,
-0.1587686688,
0.2933032811,
0.4886614084,
0.3421669304,
0.5574128628,
0.390486896,
0.5355117917,
0.373529315,
0.9179951549,
-0.1626947373,
0.3711661398,
0.874604702,
-0.549511373,
0.58239007,
0.6653274298,
0.1875875741,
-0.1566938609,
0.9411296248,
0.0126668299,
0.3375073373,
0.1501884907,
-0.3145576119,
-0.4354275763,
-0.4125582278,
-0.4848786891,
0.5097762346,
0.3742924631,
-0.2272691131,
-0.2153781205,
-0.0923530385,
0.3601790071,
0.0654784516,
-0.1931371689,
0.649954915,
0.0458737463,
-0.013439402,
0.3605198562,
-0.1908783913,
0.7282602191,
-0.3745860457,
-0.3810700476,
-0.1476810277,
0.0606428906,
-0.3655577004,
-0.9376090765,
0.4051554203,
0.2469905913,
0.219630301,
-0.1233193502,
0.5506643653,
-0.0213337839,
-0.8734599352,
0.1018050984,
0.2787130773,
0.4791655838,
0.1536875963,
-0.7897990346,
0.3533483744,
-0.2254068702,
-0.3748073578,
0.3755122721,
0.2867869735,
-0.2343330681,
0.9908214808,
1.0372262001,
0.1897147447,
0.1068151221,
-0.1677981764,
0.7343536019,
-0.4113839865,
-0.4707181156,
-0.8189956546,
0.1881772578,
-0.3013410568,
-0.2833102047,
0.5474869013,
0.6529203653,
0.6182920933,
0.2013764232,
0.9143897295,
0.0583734363,
0.5970393419,
-0.560048759,
1.0423066616,
-0.426792711,
0.5897346735,
-0.1246929616,
-0.6096644998,
-0.1669691205,
0.8069087267,
-0.344229877,
0.0426598676,
-0.0002768142,
0.8869205713,
-0.3906123638,
0.2812345326,
-0.0937904492,
0.084486641,
0.7373146415,
0.3836204112,
0.9877979159,
-0.2442230135,
0.6435647011,
-0.3373072147,
-0.3472698033,
-0.34499982,
-1.3076534271,
-0.9105198979,
-0.4381465614,
-0.0451771431,
-0.1482510865,
0.3229270875,
1.1663905382,
0.6380526423,
-0.667925477,
-0.4269404411,
0.0195943434,
-0.2551306486,
-0.0279143415,
-0.2814110219,
0.3895005882,
0.1145319864,
-0.4188358784,
0.02534426,
-0.1540536433,
-0.1224203855,
-0.1853993684,
-0.3760549426,
-0.2413287014,
0.2818885744,
0.4168621302,
0.5123325586,
-0.6515536308,
-0.8221116066,
0.0405150503,
0.0711190253,
-0.006469707,
0.3954959214,
-0.4496896565,
0.1825127155,
-0.0196877737,
0.9521841407,
0.1683789641,
0.1695366055,
0.3817624152,
-0.6187952161,
0.1713849306,
0.3138105869,
0.2666136324,
0.4328392744,
-0.7707257867,
0.4988969862,
-0.2235809416,
-0.7066523433,
-1.0359317064,
0.2321540266,
-0.9763070941,
0.1771879494,
1.3195669651,
-0.1661538333,
-0.2136912793,
-0.0755092353,
-0.3132334352,
0.2448677123,
-0.5725598931,
1.0841702223,
0.8019149303,
-0.4449939132,
-0.1483038813,
-0.6856740713,
0.3970924318,
0.3222148716,
-0.9361774325,
0.4481031895,
0.5177113414,
0.4277909994,
-0.2412438244,
0.4812862277,
-0.1746287942,
0.1305553317,
-0.3425386846,
-0.1573432237,
-0.4577914178,
0.282733649,
0.0706180483,
-0.2337129712,
-0.0438313335,
-0.2888980806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14224v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14224v2
|
Framing in the Presence of Supporting Data: A Case Study in U.S. Economic News
| 2024-02-22T02:07:21 | 2024-02-23T02:19:22 |
Alexandria Leto, Elliot Pickens, Coen D. Needell, David Rothschild, Maria Leonor Pacheco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The mainstream media has much leeway in what it chooses to cover and how it
covers it. These choices have real-world consequences on what people know and
their subsequent behaviors. However, the lack of objective measures to evaluate
editorial choices makes research in this area particularly difficult. In this
paper, we argue that there are newsworthy topics where objective measures exist
in the form of supporting data and propose a computational framework to analyze
editorial choices in this setup. We focus on the economy because the reporting
of economic indicators presents us with a relatively easy way to determine both
the selection and framing of various publications. Their values provide a
ground truth of how the economy is doing relative to how the publications
choose to cover it. To do this, we define frame prediction as a set of
interdependent tasks. At the article level, we learn to identify the reported
stance towards the general state of the economy. Then, for every numerical
quantity reported in the article, we learn to identify whether it corresponds
to an economic indicator and whether it is being reported in a positive or
negative way. To perform our analysis, we track six American publishers and
each article that appeared in the top 10 slots of their landing page between
2015 and 2023.
|
[
-0.7835522294,
-1.0165654421,
0.892236948,
0.3266720474,
-0.2645581067,
-0.199822709,
-0.2094873935,
-0.5693013668,
0.5935069919,
0.34276402,
-0.5335658789,
-0.2870373726,
-0.7379607558,
0.1745259315,
-0.1364191473,
1.2250461578,
-0.0019275085,
0.0979719087,
-0.325398922,
-0.190055564,
-0.4306318164,
-0.1420152485,
-0.3902051747,
-0.1632568836,
0.4147248864,
0.1644735634,
0.9971254468,
0.8558297753,
0.35606727,
0.2265882641,
0.1089705527,
-0.2123295367,
-0.4290973842,
0.0992273092,
-0.4242368042,
-0.3466101587,
-0.448974371,
0.3879883587,
0.5976757407,
0.7795543075,
0.0215439219,
0.6044124365,
0.2973717153,
0.8240864873,
-0.4767664075,
0.2617098689,
-0.5874361992,
0.0496449359,
-0.3254190981,
0.0135608576,
-0.3579872549,
0.0316139758,
-0.1465035677,
-0.5459415317,
-0.0468152612,
0.4162451029,
0.8865548968,
0.2319597602,
-0.6348228455,
-0.3945767283,
-0.4116338789,
0.6574964523,
-0.3335057497,
0.5388593078,
0.6331096888,
-0.0323993601,
0.0066875988,
-0.1135217324,
-0.3115081489,
0.1738657504,
-0.0463242903,
0.3649454415,
-0.6209815741,
0.0316326059,
0.3890950978,
0.0392643996,
-0.4832863808,
-0.3596412241,
-0.7349910736,
-0.0344522707,
0.6566131115,
0.2145956457,
0.1163529009,
-0.4077706337,
-0.4259989262,
0.0969907194,
-0.4882787168,
0.0633977354,
0.6193060875,
0.2205412835,
-0.1240280643,
0.7510532141,
-0.2993164361,
0.7032514215,
0.2365274727,
0.0984700173,
0.2283930928,
-0.2418134212,
-0.1786514968,
0.3591434062,
0.3632517755,
0.6958997846,
-0.2718671262,
0.1769465506,
-0.3554146886,
0.1269791573,
0.5981001258,
-0.3754570484,
0.333032608,
0.0292768758,
-0.610891521,
-0.1664400846,
0.1780954748,
-1.0836422443,
-0.279661119,
-0.501127243,
0.3744677901,
0.2810985744,
-0.0027442195,
-0.1410086751,
-0.2407323271,
-0.0578910075,
0.0938725695,
-0.6036444902,
0.2098512352,
0.8268584013,
0.8035719395,
0.0491485968,
0.1328537464,
-0.4967250228,
0.1210493147,
-0.5920222998,
1.0410747528,
-0.6697540879,
-0.0720709115,
-0.1817827523,
-0.0234985668,
0.0580856875,
0.0262991209,
0.3625669181,
-0.7229840755,
0.2563628554,
-0.5099073648,
-0.5890897512,
-0.3099927008,
0.6041882038,
-1.2441792488,
0.5895719528,
0.3053548336,
-1.0671869516,
0.7967556119,
-0.3186288178,
-0.2406407297,
-0.5079266429,
-0.0891209394,
-0.7358656526,
0.3479077816,
0.2492358983,
0.2477464974,
-0.0666272119,
0.6423746347,
-0.6224079728,
-0.3548441827,
0.2948919833,
-0.6136267781,
0.7676942945,
0.234379828,
-0.2520774901,
-0.1656195521,
-0.7031648159,
-0.3020092547,
-0.5233410597,
-0.2755497396,
-0.3755194247,
0.2453013361,
0.0022620631,
-0.0288655497,
-0.1592547596,
-0.4814365506,
0.0402512103,
-0.1011416614,
0.3216774166,
0.8618221283,
0.3190586865,
0.5657029748,
-0.4182640612,
0.7832476497,
-0.344378233,
-0.0477028675,
-0.304472059,
-0.3373620808,
-0.4494682252,
0.051666867,
0.4887197018,
0.4376016557,
-0.5828301311,
-0.1754006147,
0.0268612485,
-0.0246903729,
0.0116832377,
-0.2353095561,
0.0572775826,
0.5148601532,
0.0805317685,
-0.3136346042,
-0.7951309681,
-0.8426378369,
-0.4182567298,
0.0102897342,
0.0524225086,
0.0391014852,
0.2698678672,
0.0375235341,
1.1285041571,
-0.620051682,
-0.1424435973,
-0.2181887925,
0.1450354159,
0.8189317584,
0.2453852594,
0.549941659,
-0.8429090381,
-0.210379228,
-0.2466908097,
-0.5834681392,
-0.3172124028,
-0.3649572432,
-0.1892416626,
0.2135524154,
0.3930999935,
-0.4601841569,
0.6511520743,
0.4056812525,
-0.4768010378,
0.4738334417,
-0.1110830456,
0.2120431215,
-0.7805309892,
-0.0819382668,
0.232538268,
-0.360389173,
-0.2561114728,
-0.5504427552,
-0.1589046568,
-0.2560054362,
-0.1141107604,
0.6738100052,
-0.4674664736,
-0.4661916494,
-0.0413471684,
-0.0529239252,
0.3610550165,
0.2325360477,
0.3196535707,
0.7593259811,
0.3574404716,
-0.1692448854,
-0.099225983,
0.1097238511,
-0.4893217981,
0.6923781037,
-0.5278125405,
-0.3941470981,
-0.6100132465,
0.3710101545,
-0.8480840921,
-0.3552471101,
0.3198208809,
-0.4039857984,
0.0268843193,
0.0239712149,
-0.1216212735,
-0.1131219417,
-0.2835220993,
0.0666472986,
0.0714214668,
0.0254091155,
0.36130777,
0.7064822316,
-0.4350515306,
-0.4231894612,
-0.6966984868,
0.0637286827,
-0.4165328741,
-0.4186089933,
0.1827052087,
0.0213700309,
-0.5953246951,
0.5316993594,
-0.3348793387,
-0.1399226338,
0.1423126459,
0.0825335905,
0.5330234766,
-0.3696887791,
0.2630722821,
0.1935633123,
-0.7171729207,
0.1367668808,
-0.2801429331,
-0.1055240259,
-0.1010435447,
-0.1893314272,
-0.1362187862,
0.5441580415,
0.2439418882,
-0.279075712,
0.4582583606,
0.1714410484,
-0.3075782657,
-0.4099011719,
-0.4833102226,
0.0521465577,
-0.3688950539,
0.4540626705,
0.0199420452,
-0.481459111,
0.3313692808,
0.4512830377,
-0.2306410372,
0.4517488182,
0.3391873837,
0.1610264331,
1.2487665415,
0.6953864694,
-0.0671072304,
0.5924027562,
-0.0444194451,
0.3579528928,
-0.5381455421,
0.0327112637,
-0.2850044668,
-0.621620059,
-0.2842162848,
-0.2637320459,
0.8108109236,
0.0797727928,
-0.4008778036,
0.4559190869,
-0.487054199,
0.7513073087,
0.4998849928,
0.0032362053,
0.463110745,
0.03844551,
0.2918258309,
0.050427489,
-0.4612676203,
-0.657130897,
1.1791633368,
0.2582634985,
0.5311020613,
-0.3018985391,
0.4854980111,
0.5489564538,
0.691475153,
-0.3924858868,
0.2131303698,
0.1277345121,
-0.755390048,
-0.0778511092,
-0.2982618809,
-0.6427930593,
0.3421766758,
-0.5143585205,
-0.6252168417,
0.4404999912,
0.1332175732,
-0.6198379993,
0.1612583846,
-0.4379453361,
0.763174355,
-0.4377444386,
-0.6954178214,
-0.3958471417,
-0.1851061285,
0.1766779423,
0.1455572546,
0.6937505007,
-0.3197676837,
-0.1888956279,
0.5665081143,
0.0048876749,
0.6831058264,
-0.067230314,
0.3600037992,
0.3978089988,
-0.1596824676,
0.1359812617,
0.6483826041,
-0.5976423621,
0.0771459565,
0.0251343139,
-0.292447865,
-0.3505782485,
0.2095387131,
-0.3326382637,
-0.5451855659,
-0.7416143417,
-0.4256961644,
-0.3150134683,
0.262506634,
0.4659466743,
0.5725495815,
-0.1967709064,
0.2800188959,
0.1727810055,
0.1780073792,
0.5738960505,
0.3402950764,
-0.1793330908,
-0.6231366992,
0.6195858121,
0.6917122602,
-0.2029924691,
0.1068323851,
0.2252859622,
-0.172218293,
-0.6645896435,
-0.7080800533,
-0.1469734013,
-0.4456385672,
-0.5794082284,
-0.2447907925,
0.2182178795,
0.0280407313,
-0.5107946396,
-0.1060041636,
-0.2866278887,
-0.4379561543,
-0.759768486,
0.0151867056,
0.8788235188,
-0.232304886,
0.0443125367,
-0.7051922083,
-0.0689807832,
0.0778907686,
0.7559304237,
-0.0063029556,
0.4357053638,
-0.6514932513,
0.2618611157,
-0.5966464281,
-1.0649237633,
0.5185210705,
-0.1271582842,
0.7646647096,
0.4429938197,
0.310205102,
0.544154048,
-0.5456822515,
0.6790120602,
0.1304197013,
-1.0542294979,
0.2449931502,
-0.4767701328,
-0.1791196316,
0.8065078259,
0.4695266783,
-0.2463359833,
-0.4865207672,
-0.6655096412,
-0.7004579306,
0.7023162842,
0.0950657129,
0.4081031084,
-0.4462748468,
0.2065740377,
0.2050890177,
0.6976884604,
-0.703354001,
0.2316838354,
-0.1326066256,
-0.1941664666,
0.0286989082,
-0.0892788321,
0.0304260682,
-0.0680862665,
0.5261778235,
-0.0920640081,
0.1419720203,
0.4184835553,
-0.058586698,
-0.3048251271,
0.1828877777,
0.2661967278,
1.1463003159,
-0.0562010929,
0.248031497,
-0.1271509379,
-0.0590584278,
-0.0756283179,
0.0489188321,
-0.3643828928,
0.0231593568,
0.5280585885,
0.9687806964,
0.4700951874,
-0.9342942834,
0.5116077065,
0.3556239307,
-0.0552197732,
-0.5280913711,
-0.0883005112,
-0.0809490904,
0.7582089901,
0.4332671165,
0.2431718707,
0.4330855906,
-0.7808541059,
0.6349892616,
0.4553035796,
-0.7513728142,
-0.5391481519,
1.0065788031,
0.1103459448,
-0.1042172089,
0.4850047827,
-0.3785137236,
-0.7247559428,
0.9519628882,
0.6052434444,
0.5889738798,
0.2413237542,
0.4486133754,
0.2756605446,
0.1418270767,
-0.3524927795,
-0.0823068991,
-0.0089540621,
-0.7413452864,
-0.1648824811,
-0.6194175482,
-0.2228078544,
-0.2507891059,
-0.8445256352,
0.3213964999,
-0.227599889,
-0.604003787,
0.1004236862,
0.2631621063,
-0.5063923001,
0.2586947978,
0.6086353064,
0.8932610154,
-1.1400177479,
0.3284779191,
0.5325217843,
-0.3849357069,
-0.3781239688,
0.0012303053,
0.5357039571,
-0.4773373604,
0.2015408874,
0.4924195111,
0.2692503035,
-0.4422694445,
-0.3406925499,
-1.1086553335,
0.9668273926,
0.3615731895,
-0.3872768581,
0.0676703826,
-0.157136485,
0.2457580268,
-0.6753615141,
0.2008559704,
0.4658704996,
0.8682094812,
-0.1093079969,
-0.6059795618,
-0.2247843891,
-0.3648259044,
-0.1974475235,
0.4526077509,
-0.716706574,
1.0910600424,
0.0319446325,
-0.2085910141,
-0.4599282444,
0.5237736106,
-0.0802477449,
1.0739820004,
0.6453518867,
0.5317861438,
0.7591893077,
0.1739913374,
1.0835760832,
-0.4289618731,
0.7007331848,
0.6146551967,
-0.231602639,
0.8240590096,
0.3238946199,
-0.3376089633,
0.4641408622,
0.6571361423,
-0.3592142761,
0.4365946054,
-0.0743402392,
0.1076634824,
-0.1645593643,
0.1471329778,
-0.1410044581,
0.445255816,
0.4521238506,
-0.3592629433,
-0.5634752512,
0.2674056888,
0.2253689766,
0.269921273,
-0.6929625273,
0.610449791,
0.0874685869,
-0.8683537841,
-0.1387440115,
-0.0987792015,
0.2605965137,
-0.4177904427,
-0.137589246,
-0.0552698113,
-0.0882825181,
-0.2539768219,
-0.9087744355,
1.215510726,
0.0165220201,
-0.5200190544,
-0.7037585378,
0.6538750529,
-0.3754680455,
-0.8975467086,
0.0999031514,
0.3966909945,
-0.471398145,
-0.1501679271,
-0.3270163238,
0.5669480562,
-0.0109744724,
-0.9540700912,
0.438285619,
0.1003668085,
-0.3252677917,
-0.0301575046,
0.4554722905,
-0.0827218965,
-0.4578448534,
-0.5968586802,
0.6801418662,
-0.660091877,
-1.0432106256,
-0.7360841036,
0.468978107,
-0.266622901,
-0.314314872,
0.6598370671,
0.6823087931,
0.5422770381,
0.1813554913,
0.7621871233,
-0.1048824713,
0.4190778136,
-0.689800024,
0.787484467,
-0.3237404823,
0.3787864745,
-0.1019467562,
-1.0987038612,
-0.4164349735,
0.7494055033,
-0.8652326465,
-0.3083955646,
0.3129140735,
0.44719401,
-0.0670771301,
0.4828848839,
-0.0204123612,
0.1097042337,
-0.1804804653,
0.0770899728,
0.372100085,
0.2665606439,
0.4579839408,
-0.2763669789,
-0.2734957337,
-0.062719509,
-1.2503167391,
-0.42710042,
-0.5403547287,
-0.1663786024,
-0.1799125671,
0.118097581,
0.747525692,
0.7833619118,
-0.5072913766,
-0.1858865619,
0.0672691241,
0.541745007,
-0.5295796394,
-0.2084805816,
0.4613236487,
-0.4370405376,
-0.6457852721,
0.1022303924,
0.3330615759,
-0.4774133563,
0.0488811769,
0.4685776234,
0.1438222975,
0.464840591,
0.4205000997,
-0.0426804759,
-0.2883716226,
-0.5740897059,
-0.016609611,
0.2821010947,
0.2082352787,
0.9507789016,
-1.0674842596,
0.4065563977,
0.7400854826,
0.5812882185,
0.4831053317,
0.546926856,
0.6907073259,
-0.488532275,
0.2646326423,
0.0216972474,
0.3427713811,
0.0302139204,
-0.5491121411,
0.4368884265,
0.0869150907,
-0.550052762,
-0.7477878332,
-0.0963891521,
-0.6900983453,
-0.4654083848,
0.5838658214,
0.0451290682,
-0.645429194,
-0.0189947374,
0.0242364444,
-0.3238051534,
-0.4873569906,
0.6039738059,
0.9320204854,
-0.3357053697,
-0.217683956,
-1.096232295,
0.0159524959,
-0.2675520182,
-0.3821219802,
-0.0001115194,
0.9318788052,
0.2250294834,
0.1636373997,
0.9548079967,
0.1147873551,
0.1573882103,
0.403090775,
-0.5247453451,
-0.2484833747,
-0.4154199362,
-0.2265334874,
0.4247968793,
-0.492910862,
-0.0448738821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14208v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14208v3
|
LLM-Assisted Content Conditional Debiasing for Fair Text Embedding
| 2024-02-22T01:20:51 | 2024-06-24T04:49:16 |
Wenlong Deng, Blair Chen, Beidi Zhao, Chiyu Zhang, Xiaoxiao Li, Christos Thrampoulidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Mitigating biases in machine learning models has become an increasing concern
in Natural Language Processing (NLP), particularly in developing fair text
embeddings, which are crucial yet challenging for real-world applications like
search engines. In response, this paper proposes a novel method for learning
fair text embeddings. First, we define a novel content-conditional equal
distance (CCED) fairness for text embeddings, ensuring content-conditional
independence between sensitive attributes and text embeddings. Building on
CCED, we introduce a content-conditional debiasing (CCD) loss to ensure that
embeddings of texts with different sensitive attributes but identical content
maintain the same distance from the embedding of their corresponding neutral
text. Additionally, we tackle the issue of insufficient training data by using
Large Language Models (LLMs) with instructions to fairly augment texts into
different sensitive groups. Our extensive evaluations show that our approach
effectively enhances fairness while maintaining the utility of embeddings.
Furthermore, our augmented dataset, combined with the CCED metric, serves as an
new benchmark for evaluating fairness.
|
[
-0.0091874581,
-0.6914710999,
0.5559969544,
0.0975783244,
-0.2490867823,
-0.0340171903,
-0.3851647675,
-0.1474482119,
-0.1479609311,
0.4038725197,
-0.4266639948,
-0.7506668568,
-0.9292623401,
-0.0162597764,
-0.1940567046,
1.0127778053,
0.0713309795,
0.4020971954,
-0.4584265053,
-0.5293567777,
-0.5456472635,
-0.4522374868,
-0.531983912,
-0.1132460535,
0.4303168058,
0.3266190588,
0.6976685524,
0.6880854964,
0.5553867817,
0.2556988299,
-0.0814641565,
0.2497014403,
-0.4125787914,
0.1779252738,
-0.4308014214,
-0.6086515784,
-0.3331570029,
0.2654078603,
0.5351506472,
0.742374897,
-0.1324153394,
-0.11076729,
0.3214330971,
0.7414649725,
-0.8500083685,
-0.0131384209,
-0.8664246798,
0.5702500939,
-0.0752632394,
-0.0847851112,
-0.5475313663,
-0.4511062503,
-0.0621701218,
-0.599671483,
0.2448493093,
0.0213697422,
0.5926184654,
0.530361712,
-0.4282755554,
-0.2568072677,
-0.1407425255,
1.1999498606,
-0.6071162224,
0.4798918068,
0.4274391234,
0.208308503,
0.0037991558,
-0.5048229694,
-0.7202470899,
0.1509104669,
-0.0311435126,
-0.0430455357,
-0.1577298939,
0.1019404754,
0.3112623096,
0.286736846,
-0.2985942662,
0.3796938658,
0.0583795346,
-0.3543616235,
0.52045995,
-0.1099600941,
0.2107170522,
-0.2716163397,
-0.490880549,
-0.0159368794,
-0.6214730144,
0.1014061645,
0.6510789394,
0.3741933405,
-0.3048112988,
0.6691176891,
-0.1943192631,
0.3345690668,
0.1381343007,
-0.022765534,
0.4933831096,
0.0249034036,
-0.1531151682,
0.1596213877,
0.6333046556,
0.6284785271,
0.1995249987,
-0.3500838578,
-0.3657975793,
0.186653167,
0.0113814799,
-0.8550409079,
0.0528111085,
0.0110439444,
-0.5695105791,
-0.359957993,
-0.0418972671,
-0.4539487958,
-0.7244792581,
-0.3140974343,
0.4048590362,
-0.1841409504,
-0.0243625529,
0.3092162311,
-0.087467283,
0.0915135592,
0.2259309888,
-0.9362997413,
0.3286245465,
0.7414234281,
0.6449025273,
-0.3999971449,
0.067645818,
-0.9505423307,
0.2842777669,
0.0576652847,
0.5437024236,
-0.7873463631,
-0.139522925,
0.0811814666,
-0.1318560541,
0.3804302812,
-0.416223675,
0.8069916964,
-0.5575503111,
0.2546148896,
-0.4153812826,
-0.6886483431,
-0.2255660295,
0.4511800408,
-0.8652268052,
0.6544396281,
0.1612428129,
-1.2228857279,
0.5983518958,
-0.3302163482,
-0.4564224482,
-0.2136011124,
-0.431889534,
-0.6326178908,
0.0469379872,
0.4452191293,
0.4536868334,
0.0054142317,
0.3305587769,
-0.7404057384,
-0.2524876297,
0.1358029991,
-0.7774311304,
0.7945511341,
0.2236153632,
-0.3539857864,
-0.2390483469,
-0.3729084134,
-0.0087877437,
-0.0991959646,
-0.28893435,
-0.4683322906,
0.2067959607,
0.0235556029,
0.178657338,
0.3504319489,
-0.6898459196,
-0.0504069477,
-0.4419604242,
0.1516323239,
1.1954503059,
-0.4141827822,
0.7669632435,
-0.467358619,
0.3097246885,
0.2423487157,
0.115759708,
0.1174860746,
-0.3060167432,
-0.5491603613,
-0.5505138636,
0.5530738831,
0.6204601526,
-0.7906580567,
0.5494687557,
-0.1675775945,
0.0908611342,
-0.8514832258,
0.2334830165,
0.3623785079,
0.4074205458,
0.3263924718,
-0.3290055096,
-0.4383764267,
-0.7799297571,
-0.5141858459,
0.3138776124,
-0.0339165181,
0.3442393541,
0.1058408767,
-0.228797853,
1.0167731047,
-0.336178273,
-0.5123583078,
-0.1353803128,
-0.2130581886,
0.0311681703,
0.543132782,
0.4388048947,
-1.1236276627,
-0.5475006104,
-0.3171088696,
-0.6225837469,
-0.4336064458,
0.082798779,
-0.1689781994,
0.2529222965,
0.3741241693,
-0.3519509435,
0.6536867619,
0.6405861378,
-0.3950344324,
0.1277051121,
-0.1363047808,
0.3461602628,
-0.75518924,
-0.2309013605,
0.0079770312,
-0.5651999712,
-0.1618975699,
0.0062035592,
-0.002254565,
0.3524372876,
-0.6062850952,
0.7957905531,
-0.0973484144,
-0.0996714681,
-0.4200130403,
0.5665355921,
0.2820209861,
0.443346113,
0.0417221598,
0.2992796302,
0.4355100989,
-0.4791367948,
-0.0392532349,
0.2196225226,
-0.098091349,
0.7879787683,
-0.5003836155,
0.0813448951,
-0.3122183979,
0.3520042002,
-0.4531206191,
0.4534299374,
0.3244491816,
-0.6155059934,
0.0311774183,
-0.1766833067,
-0.4895412624,
0.0645836368,
-0.7074593306,
0.7824480534,
0.3890710175,
-0.7641544342,
0.3604223132,
0.6488301158,
-0.1905577034,
-0.9501441717,
-0.7634107471,
-0.0863794014,
-0.074528262,
-0.5336011052,
0.8700549603,
-0.3981910944,
-0.2240180671,
0.2883195579,
-0.1410578489,
-0.1855151951,
0.3513994515,
0.2428436428,
-0.0445952117,
0.2564540505,
0.1414337754,
0.4975928068,
-0.2711682618,
-0.1283749044,
-0.2805947661,
0.3670923114,
0.1233729571,
-0.6383583546,
-0.5299099684,
0.4465029538,
-0.2872113287,
-0.188588053,
0.7918397188,
0.8886600137,
-0.771720171,
-0.4629690647,
-0.5010722876,
-0.1404183209,
-0.5241655111,
0.274859339,
-0.064754039,
-1.186748147,
0.4388171434,
0.419695735,
0.1445069015,
0.5294564962,
0.5223605037,
0.0193249378,
1.1493867636,
0.8869675398,
-0.1585754305,
0.3253082037,
-0.0668118224,
0.3070723116,
-0.4246367514,
-0.3231463134,
-0.6789167523,
-0.4213550985,
-0.9764109254,
-0.618763268,
-0.1269856244,
0.1090596393,
-0.2877724469,
-0.2835223973,
-0.4292041063,
0.6468611956,
0.5275924206,
0.4972698987,
0.397588551,
0.0344911516,
-0.221837163,
-0.3916018605,
-0.5249998569,
-0.5787798166,
1.1503866911,
0.3062060773,
0.7372389436,
0.12355005,
0.7314580083,
0.9491721988,
0.4435152709,
-0.6355370283,
0.267470628,
-0.6204119325,
-0.2402779609,
-0.0793783888,
-0.7619196773,
-0.5592790246,
0.1756962538,
-0.3828158081,
-0.2760304511,
0.1043976322,
0.0867486224,
-0.0122753661,
0.6085315943,
-0.4558811486,
0.5968689322,
-0.1214404851,
-0.4556702673,
-0.4551151395,
-0.3754093647,
0.1058389321,
0.0811748058,
0.4705455899,
-0.2249272466,
-0.2427716702,
0.6238759756,
-0.1618866175,
0.6867852807,
-0.5948694348,
-0.1025055796,
0.1212809011,
0.0012135612,
0.431199193,
0.4152450562,
-0.4240693748,
0.2745000124,
-0.4241850972,
-0.5444218516,
-0.4292010069,
0.9112967253,
-0.5713264942,
-0.4663232565,
-0.4432632029,
-0.4238653183,
-0.0466182865,
0.1833343208,
-0.2030015141,
0.1379013658,
-0.1604949385,
0.2841037512,
0.8449270129,
-0.6608246565,
0.5485119224,
0.6215415001,
0.2681169212,
-0.5574108362,
0.6389394403,
-0.2792213857,
0.0221264753,
0.7127381563,
0.1250035614,
-0.5573227406,
-0.59056288,
-0.1196293905,
-0.2338456064,
-0.861430645,
-0.5222457051,
-0.8078457117,
-0.1308630556,
-0.4633392096,
-0.2811178267,
-0.2854236066,
-0.494326055,
-0.321759671,
-0.2693840265,
0.1379587352,
0.3269919753,
-0.2683289349,
0.1517095864,
-0.6876847744,
0.4600540996,
0.214595139,
0.6710640788,
-0.131313324,
-0.5716461539,
-0.1936657578,
0.3804168701,
-0.4949036837,
-0.473908931,
0.3719243109,
0.154296875,
0.7181215882,
0.1804136187,
0.3821679354,
0.1216220856,
-0.6715060472,
0.6046591401,
0.2496283948,
-1.0965049267,
0.2316684276,
-0.1072165668,
-0.1335554123,
0.6895529032,
0.2712647319,
-0.4782100916,
-0.4236496389,
-0.4312731922,
-0.745570004,
0.4028490782,
0.1793642938,
0.3819597065,
-0.2084463537,
0.2788271308,
0.4353302419,
0.2145074457,
-1.3167134523,
-0.1421820074,
-0.1980247498,
-0.7168400884,
0.1842484921,
-0.0685567409,
0.1402990371,
-0.0355406776,
0.5905413032,
-0.1896085441,
0.1485601217,
0.2076084763,
-0.7017619014,
0.232581988,
0.2863849998,
0.0106301634,
0.1499702334,
-0.1217103451,
0.2145720571,
0.3027018011,
-0.4062363505,
0.0926046818,
0.2205155045,
-0.2052859366,
-0.1109241173,
-0.0027649931,
0.470798552,
-0.0919634774,
-0.6757102013,
1.1957857609,
-0.2911426425,
0.0222236831,
0.1147067174,
0.0147054614,
-0.194378078,
0.3120721579,
0.1518612206,
-0.004813395,
0.315374434,
-0.069865413,
0.5368981957,
0.5501752496,
-0.6629146934,
0.0197315104,
0.7473136187,
0.3895782232,
-0.2284107506,
0.5614248514,
-0.5883842707,
-0.5953329802,
0.5458381176,
0.372217685,
1.043235302,
-0.0090829441,
0.2813570797,
0.0912111029,
0.2636524439,
0.0191577226,
0.1804063171,
-0.0388989784,
-0.7787184715,
-0.523866117,
-0.7653966546,
-0.3306664526,
-0.3883081377,
-0.5037758946,
0.4646827877,
-0.4455750585,
-0.0148583073,
-0.3586806953,
0.2868803144,
-0.987447083,
0.4233340621,
0.3313287795,
0.8064675927,
-0.6900954843,
0.6012151241,
0.1416707039,
-0.1050336659,
-0.2769296169,
0.015326798,
-0.1876806468,
-0.7062107325,
0.3738050461,
0.5740344524,
-0.0301754791,
-0.2248518169,
-0.5596900582,
-0.2210162133,
0.9954845309,
0.715195775,
-0.6907250881,
0.2425776124,
0.3601033092,
0.1780099571,
-0.4055888355,
0.3429758549,
0.0481599234,
0.3719891608,
-0.6392299533,
-0.4535785317,
0.2502035201,
-0.1066441387,
-0.1810301393,
-0.1368652135,
-0.5219401717,
0.5306200981,
-0.2856194973,
-0.0565998107,
-0.0647003278,
0.6942287683,
0.2407123744,
0.6617156267,
0.7642784119,
0.9304828048,
0.8922094703,
-0.009095164,
0.8517813087,
-0.162284717,
0.4157644212,
1.0401500463,
-0.2923495471,
0.6152365804,
0.2334449887,
0.0530558638,
0.4303475022,
0.5065906048,
0.1014942676,
0.8039599657,
0.4732149243,
-0.5321296453,
-0.3223527372,
-0.3680403829,
-0.2191737294,
0.2915662825,
0.0901472792,
-0.315466851,
-0.0405576527,
0.1203372851,
0.0991175845,
0.711359024,
-0.3057045341,
0.6262612939,
0.2159332484,
-0.1707804501,
-0.0054027941,
0.5797219276,
1.2216461897,
-0.2099685073,
0.029504722,
-0.4155065417,
0.1632812321,
-0.211778298,
-0.75779742,
0.3050712049,
0.1242616624,
-0.6512253284,
-0.301710397,
0.6005703211,
-0.4793860316,
-0.4404384792,
0.4377888143,
0.2056876868,
-0.3737203479,
-0.0346141383,
-0.8596102595,
-0.0755498037,
0.1073036492,
-0.0260916986,
0.3710909486,
0.5456182361,
0.0365928411,
0.6478561759,
0.5241678357,
-0.1133014038,
-0.1913851202,
0.362878412,
0.7902229428,
-0.7141166925,
-0.7066308856,
-0.9881737232,
0.447704047,
-0.1654578,
0.1947292835,
0.6284384131,
0.5763946176,
0.9051679969,
0.3339675069,
0.8306533098,
-0.0514553972,
0.4788110852,
-0.7124224305,
0.8087153435,
-0.55295825,
0.6619526148,
-0.276502043,
-0.8954769373,
-0.3551635444,
0.4375247955,
-0.1377707124,
0.2009734213,
0.4930783212,
0.9506905079,
-0.0521225147,
-0.143737942,
0.1986574382,
-0.0851604715,
0.482857883,
0.6689172387,
0.562300384,
-0.4525788128,
0.5453884006,
-0.1188039556,
-0.1768129468,
0.1596193016,
-1.3268734217,
-0.7641637325,
-0.2346853167,
-0.4308135808,
-0.3126079738,
0.3800767064,
0.8662394285,
0.4459581375,
-0.7158758044,
0.3760305345,
0.0486144088,
0.6741654277,
0.1051783636,
-0.215911746,
0.4360477328,
-0.3109643161,
-0.7952800989,
-0.1069346964,
0.0725331604,
-0.1567415148,
-0.0498548076,
-0.4233557582,
0.1296747625,
0.1087861061,
0.4882134795,
-0.3179110885,
-0.2991110682,
-0.3893802762,
-0.2963944376,
-0.310593456,
0.0775861591,
0.5426976681,
-0.9630609155,
0.2798087895,
0.5214512348,
0.9264181852,
0.0707626715,
-0.2515506446,
0.4490006268,
-1.0795048475,
0.4219841361,
0.368299365,
0.2753185034,
0.7145198584,
-0.4197820127,
0.1704906374,
0.3202782869,
-0.5083087087,
-0.8090702295,
0.1214556843,
-1.0389069319,
-0.1463399976,
1.0344879627,
-0.308281213,
0.1394080967,
0.2208918184,
-0.0677109063,
0.405589968,
-0.4682834446,
0.8842104077,
0.2347429097,
0.6661987305,
0.098903276,
-0.3391490579,
0.4889373183,
0.4963595569,
-0.8167361617,
-0.0630921796,
0.5578850508,
0.3085318804,
-0.609057188,
0.5337507129,
-0.1387510002,
0.2455391586,
-0.36236462,
0.0656990856,
0.1206085905,
-0.1525571942,
-0.3055036068,
0.0301830024,
-0.1009910628,
-0.0959858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14207v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14207v2
|
Assisting in Writing Wikipedia-like Articles From Scratch with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T01:20:17 | 2024-04-08T05:38:50 |
Yijia Shao, Yucheng Jiang, Theodore A. Kanell, Peter Xu, Omar Khattab, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study how to apply large language models to write grounded and organized
long-form articles from scratch, with comparable breadth and depth to Wikipedia
pages. This underexplored problem poses new challenges at the pre-writing
stage, including how to research the topic and prepare an outline prior to
writing. We propose STORM, a writing system for the Synthesis of Topic Outlines
through Retrieval and Multi-perspective Question Asking. STORM models the
pre-writing stage by (1) discovering diverse perspectives in researching the
given topic, (2) simulating conversations where writers carrying different
perspectives pose questions to a topic expert grounded on trusted Internet
sources, (3) curating the collected information to create an outline.
For evaluation, we curate FreshWiki, a dataset of recent high-quality
Wikipedia articles, and formulate outline assessments to evaluate the
pre-writing stage. We further gather feedback from experienced Wikipedia
editors. Compared to articles generated by an outline-driven
retrieval-augmented baseline, more of STORM's articles are deemed to be
organized (by a 25% absolute increase) and broad in coverage (by 10%). The
expert feedback also helps identify new challenges for generating grounded long
articles, such as source bias transfer and over-association of unrelated facts.
|
[
-0.7782353759,
-0.9104675055,
0.764710784,
0.338116467,
-0.2504306436,
0.0639742166,
-0.2700595856,
-0.5641108751,
0.7421101332,
0.6457612514,
-0.6256112456,
-0.3175418973,
-0.3818623722,
0.1919055581,
-0.9067001343,
1.2809453011,
-0.3096040487,
-0.3584537208,
-0.1853482127,
0.4195056856,
0.0779981017,
-0.3285703361,
-0.4790140092,
-0.0654280782,
0.8214370608,
0.6186853647,
0.6031979918,
0.4782114923,
0.3961003721,
0.3346199393,
-0.1028248519,
0.2843264043,
-0.7641642094,
0.451597631,
-0.5853459239,
0.1706552804,
-0.3053566217,
-0.0140586989,
0.7735370398,
0.9533826113,
-0.1006974205,
0.1834817976,
0.1057200283,
0.3836351931,
-0.7922077775,
-0.3075906932,
-0.5863639712,
-0.1267583668,
-0.2440247685,
-0.15372096,
-0.4440380633,
-0.05215526,
0.1753294319,
-0.7768220901,
0.4059965312,
0.1319538206,
0.8068247437,
-0.2817638516,
-0.3149210215,
-0.313850075,
-1.0193864107,
0.3510253429,
-0.515278697,
0.3861949146,
0.0960522518,
-0.104673706,
-0.3276721239,
-1.1234641075,
-0.9044479728,
-0.0170364641,
0.2051934004,
0.0831528977,
0.0788859725,
-0.0127065601,
0.1769575924,
0.3239803612,
-0.2234410346,
0.2287115753,
-0.6147190928,
0.0037748832,
0.7501670718,
0.2015399039,
0.3516033292,
-0.5446881056,
-0.2644459009,
0.1492002457,
-0.8137639761,
-0.2031997144,
0.5083889961,
0.1780200899,
0.0797348619,
0.8220603466,
-0.4635563195,
0.4658897221,
0.281909287,
-0.1030554026,
0.0063951216,
-0.309951365,
0.0234979764,
0.1246508509,
0.7770730257,
0.6208545566,
0.0392383412,
-0.2839402556,
-0.3358626664,
-0.3823985457,
0.5944171548,
-0.8404327631,
-0.3717673719,
0.0791279227,
-0.3674605489,
-0.488679409,
0.1775934994,
-0.8035194278,
-0.8889650106,
-0.5274581909,
0.4864839315,
-0.1719465405,
-0.499967128,
-0.272246778,
-0.4325524867,
0.0823455676,
0.523825109,
-0.7663411498,
0.4232251942,
0.5259751081,
0.5989584923,
-0.1256782711,
-0.768961668,
-0.1990930736,
0.4078730345,
-0.6970175505,
1.0308096409,
-0.1014196277,
-0.1705095917,
-0.0048086825,
-0.2467125654,
0.4055348635,
-0.0201511607,
0.2558466196,
-0.3745105863,
0.2839642763,
-0.2128996849,
-0.6647371054,
0.2531149089,
0.124275811,
-0.7818624377,
0.9268903732,
0.0367496498,
-1.2009472847,
0.3791419864,
-0.3709823787,
-0.6995741129,
-0.1893642843,
-0.0628332421,
-0.0300389025,
0.3805568814,
0.3106125295,
0.4707975686,
-0.2448752671,
0.4167025089,
-0.1993147582,
-0.1165616065,
0.0980171785,
-0.1195171475,
0.5593112111,
0.0935458839,
-0.5037504435,
0.4144701958,
-0.9464329481,
0.168995589,
-0.1212881431,
-0.1370049268,
-0.3804830313,
0.2719165385,
0.1777497828,
0.1080662161,
0.1805511713,
-0.2925186455,
0.1405291557,
-0.341678381,
0.1836785972,
0.6417746544,
0.3830681145,
0.4207327068,
0.0041647418,
0.2439730018,
0.0228912532,
-0.0390066914,
-0.4212897122,
-0.1580084711,
-1.1604553461,
0.076049231,
0.1386955529,
0.3634871542,
-0.8571591973,
0.5034844875,
-0.3035899699,
-0.9538882375,
-0.3716131151,
0.4012296796,
0.2356820256,
0.5198401213,
0.325432837,
-0.2000737339,
-0.8921325803,
-0.9060437083,
-0.0430012271,
-0.1226021424,
0.0176159013,
-0.1755242944,
0.5342911482,
-0.1205265746,
0.8883208632,
-0.6363679767,
0.1544437259,
-0.617608428,
0.4317084849,
0.0111827888,
0.4291779697,
0.2457519025,
-0.8418581486,
-0.5122056603,
-0.1240987778,
-0.7134456635,
-0.1417923421,
-0.1350982487,
-0.3352610767,
-0.0297840554,
0.8208240867,
-1.0392838717,
0.2327645272,
0.2077286094,
-0.4528962672,
0.717880547,
-0.1998826265,
0.2072709799,
-1.3920177221,
0.2741707861,
-0.2424894571,
0.0374658108,
-0.7085285783,
0.3944360018,
-0.0597139038,
-0.5676950216,
-0.3513628542,
0.4686399102,
-0.6127486229,
0.2688924074,
-0.4748047888,
0.1312499791,
0.1504483968,
0.1184714809,
0.2745960057,
0.4602729082,
0.4283076227,
-0.6004396081,
0.3016717434,
-0.0473667793,
-0.5204670429,
0.3791679442,
-0.6759089828,
0.2424101084,
-0.5080834627,
0.3451906741,
-0.6978668571,
-0.4267715216,
0.0665867776,
-0.1193467751,
0.2493819594,
0.1450354308,
-0.5009546876,
-0.4677578211,
-0.3301565051,
-0.0372467376,
0.2084119618,
-0.1210012883,
0.4744771719,
0.4530484676,
-0.7060681581,
-0.5067958832,
-0.0023117529,
0.3333444297,
-0.0632961094,
-0.4157314599,
0.4569870234,
-0.171718508,
-0.5941306353,
0.275953263,
-0.0360591076,
-0.3432040811,
0.1772015989,
0.3952931464,
-0.1643625796,
-0.278789252,
-0.0403956585,
0.1571283787,
0.267342627,
0.1920388043,
-0.26194188,
0.4979344904,
0.2639967501,
-0.0197996031,
-0.0891521275,
0.7929359674,
0.5478257537,
-0.3028912842,
0.617194891,
0.3369174898,
-0.471619606,
-0.5313864946,
-0.7783007622,
-0.0811637715,
-0.42723158,
0.3341023028,
-0.471829921,
-0.3597798944,
0.5437562466,
0.1879356205,
0.1941332519,
0.9549242854,
0.4498444498,
-0.4307951033,
0.4030718803,
0.9722748399,
-0.0611571893,
0.3517827392,
-0.2628127635,
0.1910864562,
-0.4802849889,
-0.3586280942,
-0.6756999493,
-0.3382547498,
-0.0860031247,
-0.4478598833,
0.0861127451,
0.558721602,
-0.2279752642,
0.2299199253,
-0.3672780097,
0.6202227473,
0.7075263858,
0.0403309688,
0.2550161481,
0.0079352492,
0.0594538338,
0.0060705403,
-0.5327284336,
-0.2976653576,
1.2289013863,
0.0397168323,
0.7981317639,
-0.3335227966,
1.0300751925,
0.2375199795,
0.4289516807,
-0.3687473834,
0.5185000896,
0.296380043,
-0.8486065865,
-0.6339498162,
-0.2123039961,
-0.7006724477,
0.2619140148,
-0.4618543088,
-0.3822274208,
0.0272714645,
-0.0608986765,
-0.143669948,
0.3279007971,
-0.52355057,
0.6427775621,
-0.0875282437,
-0.3142139614,
-0.3109489083,
-0.5385954976,
0.3072451651,
-0.1336781532,
0.4132077694,
0.085224472,
0.140272662,
0.9665974379,
-0.4287731946,
0.7470572591,
0.0174152423,
-0.2096038014,
0.8018370271,
0.0243424382,
0.2425605059,
0.1467321217,
-0.0521922484,
-0.1777003556,
-0.196212694,
-0.2037014365,
-0.6691619158,
0.6832606196,
-0.8351478577,
-0.7848481536,
-0.1841111928,
-0.301964134,
-0.0515353084,
0.8364189267,
0.6338328123,
0.5214319825,
-0.5192097425,
0.0844660178,
0.6330068707,
0.0899752229,
0.3003831506,
0.4313482344,
-0.5877784491,
-0.6882163286,
0.6543047428,
0.3141923249,
-0.0099461861,
0.4722198546,
-0.0185228102,
0.1598638594,
-0.9171936512,
-0.6723391414,
0.0135573866,
-0.8580353856,
-0.1395833939,
-0.7239724994,
-0.4957523048,
-0.4659645259,
-0.3871798515,
-0.4582388103,
-0.5160568357,
-0.1790875643,
-0.3799124658,
0.0915336087,
0.9678487778,
0.0886558518,
0.1625175774,
-0.439257443,
0.7032955289,
0.0168125108,
0.3467023671,
0.1270961314,
-0.1539334506,
-0.3420785069,
-0.0782054812,
-0.4109256268,
-1.042027235,
0.0038515595,
-0.1460313946,
0.5536993146,
0.5437400937,
0.237872541,
0.8387513161,
-0.9399620891,
0.7710115314,
0.4373663068,
-1.0482327938,
0.8498491645,
-0.4032961726,
0.0994072407,
0.6683102846,
0.6912488341,
-0.4279636145,
-0.8511101604,
-0.7968038321,
-1.0826846361,
0.12846452,
0.1810802668,
0.2813150585,
-0.1106189936,
0.3980620801,
0.3005204797,
0.3742043674,
-0.6370170116,
-0.194528684,
-0.4011467397,
0.1229056269,
-0.486367166,
-0.5952243805,
-0.0953985527,
-0.4371001124,
0.5500270128,
0.1544768661,
-0.1774236411,
0.4715841711,
-0.2625239491,
-0.2067209035,
0.3067609966,
0.4792202115,
1.2560508251,
0.1019618809,
0.4891445041,
-0.0236297939,
-0.4238036871,
0.0586106293,
0.2785018682,
-0.4504786134,
0.2783184052,
0.8829350471,
0.7026044726,
0.6396850944,
-0.5249606371,
0.2758566439,
0.4283536375,
-0.1742518544,
-0.4380756319,
0.0153115327,
0.4228241146,
-0.015805291,
0.607337296,
-0.3332227468,
0.2525252104,
-0.7320048213,
0.1278378516,
0.1204092056,
-0.0525045916,
-0.3122861683,
0.4182611406,
0.5637409091,
-0.1617769301,
0.8171009421,
0.006623704,
-0.4228634834,
0.495375663,
0.5505290031,
0.5878409147,
-0.1512334794,
0.2344458252,
0.2154908925,
0.4021563232,
-0.0728365332,
0.4837589562,
0.035975568,
-0.5655459762,
-0.4045877755,
-0.7552287579,
-0.2993513644,
0.2624334097,
-0.4716243446,
0.4556569159,
-0.6323872209,
0.0180036835,
0.3366158605,
0.2116082311,
-0.6380310655,
0.2951527238,
0.0594223179,
1.1613664627,
-0.8123773336,
0.4893394709,
0.8347304463,
-0.5516560078,
-0.924421072,
-0.1489762068,
-0.3756781816,
-0.0222837944,
0.3518701792,
0.0796569511,
-0.0090065999,
0.0770975724,
-0.5098673105,
-0.9237679243,
0.8202438354,
0.1186952367,
-0.3355748057,
-0.6021286249,
-0.1624742597,
0.5439115167,
-0.2903936505,
-0.0119214756,
-0.0430558287,
0.4516615272,
-0.1533829272,
-1.1073902845,
-0.107901901,
-0.3446528614,
-0.319773227,
0.3063362539,
-0.1699347645,
0.9804775119,
-0.3691034615,
-0.0098671196,
0.0463498905,
1.0296393633,
-0.0532852672,
0.3827384412,
0.3307194412,
0.5715155602,
0.7786276937,
0.3498754203,
0.9742724299,
-0.2136212587,
-0.0066154622,
1.1917852163,
-0.1299877167,
1.0175507069,
0.5877574086,
0.1430202127,
0.9160085917,
0.3550651968,
0.1127203181,
0.3757833242,
0.2989370525,
-0.1433190405,
-0.1289908141,
0.0256754998,
-0.5028390884,
0.287076503,
0.1507728696,
-0.5054289103,
-0.321613878,
0.0856497213,
0.1353249699,
0.2862956524,
-0.7915428281,
0.925308764,
0.1489530057,
-0.8805975318,
0.2616086602,
0.2019701153,
0.1834510565,
-0.616973877,
0.1080037877,
-0.233907938,
-0.0883546844,
-0.3092215359,
-0.9509004951,
0.1733767837,
0.1913842261,
-0.7303543091,
-0.4322169423,
0.8778959513,
-0.4419741333,
-0.7558780313,
-0.2081701756,
0.6180220842,
0.1601700336,
-0.2411170155,
-0.0014235761,
0.2014068514,
-0.3949956298,
-0.6731144786,
0.164871335,
0.844155252,
-0.119796969,
0.6191403866,
0.5169899464,
0.2926784456,
-0.0452398062,
-0.058182165,
0.9006730914,
-0.8570587635,
-0.8946608901,
-0.7330648303,
0.6432995796,
-0.4277664423,
-0.4271604419,
0.8517682552,
0.8177313805,
0.6401247978,
-0.1959268302,
0.7643449903,
-0.3020134866,
0.4992290139,
-0.5131239295,
1.1377515793,
-0.3575877547,
-0.4297782183,
-0.6243980527,
-1.1287066936,
0.0310777742,
0.2322913855,
0.0383249223,
-0.2829576135,
0.8403726816,
0.2636938095,
-0.1694946736,
-0.1073769629,
-0.0586925708,
0.2364481241,
0.2895647585,
0.2172246426,
0.9038949609,
0.1254869848,
0.444006145,
-0.5125373006,
-0.0218951833,
-0.000270552,
-0.9894781113,
-1.0119441748,
-0.9010643363,
-0.1318899393,
-0.4215644598,
0.0599444136,
0.6549929976,
0.6244956255,
-0.600279212,
-0.1898975521,
0.0116718849,
0.2719734609,
0.0198207628,
-0.1909794807,
0.4401784539,
-0.3085039556,
-0.5046613216,
0.3754962385,
0.0479823127,
-0.1574626714,
-0.5344638228,
0.1186692417,
0.0478100106,
0.0011684265,
0.6651011109,
0.1187349707,
-0.5533301234,
-0.2637692988,
-0.211475715,
-0.1588084996,
-0.3986387551,
1.133544445,
-0.5523468852,
0.2992615998,
0.4403471947,
0.5701808929,
0.6329183578,
-0.0434568711,
0.8454059958,
-0.4252522886,
0.1910362542,
0.2172114104,
0.1663524508,
0.2924551368,
-0.2724896669,
0.0742411315,
0.192508772,
-0.1711104512,
-0.8805232644,
0.0773524195,
-0.6555127501,
-0.5820447206,
1.0406881571,
0.0204086117,
0.1916484833,
0.2064268887,
-0.1253750771,
0.1458694935,
0.0021665592,
0.9197141528,
1.1038767099,
0.1297345161,
-0.1646780968,
-0.3579841554,
0.5347436666,
-0.2359069884,
-0.8996581435,
0.0654582605,
0.8090184331,
0.5517160296,
0.3203241229,
0.9193562269,
0.2563815713,
0.2600411475,
0.304834038,
0.1230336055,
-0.1489032954,
-0.9234198928,
0.3164000809,
0.6075864434,
0.2784376442,
0.4914736748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14200v1
|
Towards Understanding Counseling Conversations: Domain Knowledge and Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T01:02:37 | 2024-02-22T01:02:37 |
Younghun Lee, Dan Goldwasser, Laura Schwab Reese
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the dynamics of counseling conversations is an important task,
yet it is a challenging NLP problem regardless of the recent advance of
Transformer-based pre-trained language models. This paper proposes a systematic
approach to examine the efficacy of domain knowledge and large language models
(LLMs) in better representing conversations between a crisis counselor and a
help seeker. We empirically show that state-of-the-art language models such as
Transformer-based models and GPT models fail to predict the conversation
outcome. To provide richer context to conversations, we incorporate
human-annotated domain knowledge and LLM-generated features; simple integration
of domain knowledge and LLM features improves the model performance by
approximately 15%. We argue that both domain knowledge and LLM-generated
features can be exploited to better characterize counseling conversations when
they are used as an additional context to conversations.
|
[
-0.4549562931,
-0.5114631057,
0.8725184798,
0.1636756957,
-0.1005487218,
0.2886913419,
-0.4186484218,
-0.4202057421,
-0.106727235,
0.4571287632,
-0.5132495165,
-0.4028488398,
-0.7789449692,
0.1025526747,
-0.3428643048,
0.8132783771,
0.1290706843,
0.3517775536,
-0.1042552292,
0.1331856549,
-0.942283392,
-0.5271565318,
-0.9699895382,
-0.7213871479,
0.2919448018,
0.2072320729,
0.8311782479,
0.253003031,
0.3632541299,
0.3533388376,
-0.4947329462,
-0.0169650223,
-0.934843421,
0.0300835278,
-0.1732048839,
-0.3871250451,
-0.5538915992,
-0.104661189,
0.0834086463,
0.9561436176,
-0.3095401525,
-0.1075310409,
0.1115356609,
0.3197390437,
-0.3207865357,
0.2379986197,
-0.8205522299,
0.076978676,
0.2826296985,
-0.3200363815,
-0.4087314904,
-0.0032752517,
0.7740707397,
-0.5364560485,
0.4372499287,
0.0404230244,
0.5907616615,
0.1403908581,
-1.039781332,
-0.4499901235,
-1.1869879961,
0.6017255783,
-0.6268700361,
0.3848698437,
0.6168147922,
0.3965178132,
-0.5010967851,
-0.5396435261,
-0.4689917564,
-0.0285429601,
-0.4158646166,
-0.0692991763,
-0.3118574321,
0.1632183343,
0.1997244209,
0.5049169064,
-0.1504083425,
-0.020114528,
-0.33978948,
-0.0965489969,
0.6320154071,
0.4579187632,
0.0358865373,
-0.1815780848,
-0.1962567866,
0.2056000829,
-0.4612244964,
-0.06170642,
-0.0602594987,
0.177909866,
0.0330068953,
0.2135927528,
0.5250285268,
0.6948190331,
0.0570437759,
-0.524520278,
-0.482147336,
-0.1494685709,
-0.3606138527,
-0.1490288377,
0.5564161539,
0.6186029911,
0.4065274298,
-0.1253290027,
0.1614356786,
-0.4247171879,
0.6406766772,
-0.5875603557,
-0.078577511,
0.1387547404,
-0.3734683692,
0.0586748272,
-0.2828190029,
-0.7716040015,
-0.6117665768,
-0.5697098374,
-0.1625437289,
-0.455999732,
-0.3925820291,
0.1493582278,
0.0202402584,
0.4592426419,
0.6051813364,
-0.8422396779,
0.274617672,
0.8883142471,
0.6757938862,
-0.1586380899,
0.1132405251,
-0.0903220251,
0.1649267375,
-0.2044780999,
0.7774942517,
-0.6217167377,
-0.8034582138,
0.3800057769,
0.1079393551,
-0.2452402115,
-0.5046679974,
0.7218645811,
-0.6095571518,
0.2581006587,
-0.3500873446,
-0.6452342272,
-0.1286830455,
0.4463641047,
-0.2842453718,
0.685674727,
0.1845579892,
-0.6186472178,
0.439280659,
-0.5686867237,
-0.1880518794,
0.206401661,
-0.0715318546,
-0.1465996206,
0.1009210199,
0.1888598651,
0.4503687918,
-0.3919021189,
0.6665258408,
-0.0799700692,
-0.2763428688,
0.3881554604,
-0.2964112461,
0.3440314829,
0.0726794899,
0.086424537,
-0.0553074852,
-0.5828527808,
-0.2282746881,
0.1781899631,
-0.3977190256,
-0.4600887001,
-0.156599611,
0.1006544605,
0.1316225231,
-0.1958869547,
-0.3227925003,
0.2522807717,
-0.5951630473,
0.2489929944,
0.3083741963,
0.1132492721,
0.433694154,
-0.092442736,
0.7335373759,
0.0455326289,
-0.0785622597,
-0.3184120357,
-0.6066326499,
-0.6333813667,
0.0877610371,
-0.0753244758,
0.4285453558,
-0.6864763498,
0.3902578056,
-0.0703110173,
-0.3065360487,
-0.2741471827,
0.1135648638,
0.4719665349,
0.5288933516,
0.6046082377,
-0.1738960147,
-0.5567638874,
-0.7174146771,
-0.5473833084,
-0.047092583,
-0.2365765721,
0.5284771323,
0.3788176179,
-0.0984501764,
1.0989551544,
-0.5930777192,
-0.239472717,
-0.6428403258,
0.0434037261,
0.1327148378,
0.2579163909,
0.5071954131,
-0.6857956648,
-0.5090472698,
-0.0354648493,
-0.4753244221,
0.1082351357,
-0.1956461072,
-0.1278955638,
-0.2277585268,
0.2963728309,
-0.4812103808,
0.6456643939,
0.2235120386,
-0.7366642952,
0.4800033569,
-0.215631038,
0.1916524172,
-1.1459136009,
-0.1509105265,
0.1807957143,
-0.2783453166,
-1.2230223417,
-0.4646277726,
-0.2492619008,
-0.2025148124,
-0.2970295846,
0.4939391017,
-0.4838994741,
0.0671789348,
-0.3037684858,
0.4064665437,
-0.1808546335,
0.4703930914,
0.150251016,
0.8255034089,
0.3448376656,
-0.3553528488,
0.3782611489,
0.8608916402,
-0.2060777545,
0.8354229331,
-0.5746266246,
0.2710647881,
-0.1215855405,
0.3852491677,
-0.8849881887,
-0.3320170939,
-0.077264756,
0.0497203581,
0.503121376,
-0.6918602586,
0.0386216678,
-0.5288283825,
0.0706272498,
0.41729936,
0.0994185284,
-0.3939682245,
0.5203900933,
0.3823428154,
-0.3663503826,
-0.6519790888,
-0.2540510893,
0.4097243249,
-0.374625355,
-0.5958417654,
0.3492576778,
0.2426332086,
-0.2900101542,
-0.3265247047,
0.0726365671,
-0.1488901526,
0.0118370624,
0.3919811249,
0.3889421523,
-0.3320890069,
0.4097769856,
-0.0435095802,
-0.3895608485,
0.2878291905,
-0.0481528379,
0.7751774192,
-0.2782666981,
-0.6251006722,
-0.2759391069,
0.5336713195,
0.4907310307,
0.1025201529,
1.0929831266,
0.439183265,
-0.1220039576,
-0.0002202756,
-0.6309199929,
-0.1411359012,
-0.4238984883,
0.3242368996,
-0.2301940471,
-1.0924106836,
0.5058408976,
-0.5531442761,
0.0291170254,
0.1511901319,
0.4896882176,
0.103777051,
0.8869180679,
0.8960297108,
0.0587296486,
0.4197594523,
-0.3311378956,
0.8254833817,
-0.9630156755,
-0.3153209388,
-0.3212707043,
-0.3155435324,
-0.1151626632,
-0.3418607414,
0.4584544599,
0.3296988606,
-0.0688708276,
0.2589405477,
-0.3236824572,
0.3728198707,
0.0115354899,
-0.2141717821,
0.6268832684,
-0.2021711171,
0.066045396,
-0.4366505444,
-0.6140812635,
-0.8677141666,
0.7694900036,
0.4959241152,
0.5129665732,
0.0595980808,
0.131802693,
-0.2802913487,
0.6260405779,
-1.1114675999,
0.4224872291,
0.4129965305,
-0.5156535506,
-0.2438583374,
-0.223934412,
-1.0609502792,
0.4769508541,
-0.3236946464,
-0.9111525416,
0.2261009067,
0.1492348462,
-0.4273964167,
0.256031543,
-0.5287998319,
0.9272024035,
-0.0731490552,
0.1618527621,
-0.2145960778,
-0.4206796288,
0.5494564772,
-0.142407611,
0.4081736505,
-0.13240771,
0.318334192,
0.6752492189,
-0.7426922321,
0.7051960826,
-0.0673752651,
-0.5149053335,
0.2046604306,
0.1417260915,
0.3447493613,
0.1306275278,
0.0484822951,
-0.2279359549,
0.2340638191,
-0.0926917866,
-0.8149405718,
0.2347714305,
-0.463808924,
-0.8219187856,
0.0618832484,
-0.6098691225,
-0.6867653131,
-0.111641638,
0.0911031142,
0.5395126343,
-0.3394013941,
-0.0297751576,
0.2812810838,
-0.3284182549,
0.2244623601,
0.611554265,
-0.4402163029,
-0.0420429781,
0.3941029608,
-0.09036538,
0.2866971791,
-0.3041822016,
0.1901334226,
-0.1924248934,
-0.387907505,
-0.0395596176,
0.4556695521,
-0.9984729886,
-0.316588372,
-0.8149350882,
-0.1639160812,
-0.3241545558,
-0.2139545977,
-0.2629746199,
-0.1099378914,
-0.2526521385,
-0.3628168702,
0.7064079642,
0.9641569257,
0.1677504331,
0.5275661349,
-1.073029995,
-0.0249034446,
0.3674658239,
0.0872805342,
0.4291597605,
-0.6927794814,
-0.2759755254,
0.0148269422,
-0.604865849,
-1.102152586,
0.5265418887,
0.2061542422,
0.3108647466,
0.5538817048,
-0.0134356339,
0.9385119677,
-0.362046659,
0.949627161,
0.0888486207,
-0.9025890827,
0.5979126692,
-0.4002268314,
0.0680640191,
0.5316790938,
0.6586534381,
-0.8252804279,
-0.4657866359,
-0.578477025,
-0.7599243522,
0.7452296019,
0.0812575668,
0.4468294084,
0.0116166323,
0.6329383254,
-0.116271466,
0.2088708878,
-0.5160558224,
-0.3296950758,
0.0457897447,
-0.0864498392,
0.091658026,
-0.5556763411,
-0.4365531504,
-0.3710413873,
0.4735045433,
-0.1772895157,
0.2886657119,
0.1286088526,
0.1726236194,
-0.3218178153,
0.5897021294,
0.6811076999,
0.8513668776,
0.1806451082,
0.0572169796,
0.655199945,
-0.548214376,
0.0843115896,
-0.2160073519,
0.4292952418,
-0.0635017455,
0.7301525474,
0.8395349979,
0.5532763004,
-0.4669386744,
0.7453575134,
-0.3432255089,
-0.3701505065,
-0.2255532295,
0.0093915658,
0.3717343807,
0.4580105245,
0.3809067309,
-0.2114258558,
0.0167618562,
-0.6361045241,
0.0419665202,
0.4726059139,
-0.4743934274,
-0.2802110314,
0.2616250813,
0.2335535139,
-0.6774721146,
0.5106580853,
0.1374601424,
-0.8193123341,
0.3125020564,
0.826597631,
0.6002582908,
-0.2098228782,
0.1983266622,
0.0703918263,
-0.3016948402,
-0.2465527356,
0.0468478352,
-0.1926362664,
-0.8375328779,
-0.5729904771,
-0.5113408566,
-0.6070386767,
0.2722156346,
-0.8386071324,
0.0442429595,
-0.1371415406,
-0.3335821331,
-0.3177641928,
-0.225181818,
-0.8048962355,
-0.1416301727,
-0.1191984713,
0.9394450188,
-0.7426100969,
0.5472062826,
0.5275121927,
0.1506655961,
-1.2053650618,
-0.0409214348,
0.0585833006,
-0.6548913121,
0.6754462123,
0.0809338614,
-0.1501895785,
-0.15874888,
-0.4134022295,
-0.8028002977,
1.0589112043,
0.5579174757,
-0.5031499863,
-0.1939542592,
0.336397469,
0.8863184452,
-0.4920563698,
0.4481543005,
0.9618547559,
0.5778588653,
0.5408419371,
-1.1836498976,
-0.0853331238,
-0.1855921596,
0.16440925,
0.1163102239,
-0.0899777487,
0.3480262756,
-0.228615135,
-0.4798259735,
-0.1880634576,
0.5602849722,
-0.0683540106,
0.3248793781,
0.4685746133,
0.1168503538,
0.7964890003,
-0.1458859295,
1.0031250715,
-0.4291487634,
0.5950498581,
1.1686453819,
-0.1973618716,
0.5837781429,
0.3189997673,
-0.2187280804,
0.3129498959,
0.4352124035,
0.0554198846,
-0.0147057902,
0.23533158,
-0.2914904952,
-0.4220647514,
-0.1548849195,
-0.2911493778,
0.4669699967,
0.5936994553,
-0.3818569481,
-0.3634305,
0.2222831398,
0.1625372469,
0.0916085765,
-0.1081841663,
1.0461330414,
0.603718102,
-0.6062125564,
0.611989975,
-0.1273382604,
0.3826892972,
-0.2109193653,
-0.1686596125,
-0.1929949969,
0.0614143014,
-0.3135892451,
-0.9343693256,
0.6114100218,
0.2291430682,
0.0481826812,
-0.4009642005,
0.9109740853,
-0.5437713265,
-0.3309521973,
0.4004170001,
0.7195684314,
0.1616039723,
-0.0269862954,
-0.4049237072,
-0.0856464878,
-0.3568359613,
-0.3386308849,
0.3786095083,
0.5768831372,
0.2165527493,
0.744361043,
0.4944180846,
-0.0824196637,
-0.2130794972,
0.2745387256,
0.9832836986,
-0.680365026,
-0.2339759916,
-0.7718487382,
0.4420537353,
-0.1663562953,
-0.3636024296,
0.6554337144,
-0.0710899457,
0.4317260087,
0.1339342445,
0.3984952569,
0.293455869,
0.6295850873,
-0.3535549045,
0.4590783119,
-0.1905813217,
0.5788249373,
-0.3098941147,
-0.7354404926,
-0.3317082524,
0.742767036,
-0.8451838493,
0.1009703055,
0.5447308421,
0.5797150135,
-0.0682263151,
0.473347038,
0.4701187313,
0.2718534768,
0.8312790394,
0.5195951462,
1.2269591093,
-0.1542095393,
0.5839186311,
0.1449708343,
0.0553842671,
-0.111749731,
-0.8466746807,
-1.1343171597,
-0.5076774359,
0.0445133373,
-0.1359682828,
-0.4844918847,
1.0086786747,
0.5425747633,
-0.5417189002,
-0.1165466905,
0.0653934851,
0.1593689173,
0.1661065966,
-0.2070411593,
0.0647845492,
-0.3637494743,
-0.3325087726,
0.6851768494,
0.3218488097,
0.0259994119,
-0.30137676,
-0.0486264974,
0.1926600337,
0.1550886631,
0.6648179293,
0.0141634168,
-0.6830340624,
-0.3253694177,
-0.3484063745,
0.093745999,
0.2855424285,
1.4601790905,
-0.6983932853,
0.0940192789,
-0.134209916,
0.5892340541,
0.481788218,
0.1704032421,
1.1211829185,
-0.6149685383,
-0.0967732817,
0.0714360774,
0.3963005841,
0.4052262008,
-0.6841551661,
0.4148140848,
-0.0398694538,
-0.6320447922,
-0.720536232,
0.4319294989,
-0.6359112263,
-0.1914020479,
0.9968200922,
-0.4677464068,
0.1653189063,
-0.6967755556,
-0.6138775349,
0.1404970586,
-0.3510593176,
0.7610754371,
0.6528725028,
-0.2899384499,
-0.2938689888,
-0.5237814188,
0.9431428313,
0.2560958564,
-0.6738581657,
0.4266580343,
0.2215276808,
0.1483780593,
0.4275437891,
0.5739135146,
0.1164974645,
-0.1796357334,
-0.4663428366,
-0.4945979714,
0.0634179339,
-0.2039843053,
-0.4229028523,
0.3001898825,
0.100823693,
0.7818319201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14195v1
|
Learning to Reduce: Optimal Representations of Structured Data in Prompting Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T00:41:23 | 2024-02-22T00:41:23 |
Younghun Lee, Sungchul Kim, Tong Yu, Ryan A. Rossi, Xiang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely used as general-purpose AI
agents showing comparable performance on many downstream tasks. However,
existing work shows that it is challenging for LLMs to integrate structured
data (e.g. KG, tables, DBs) into their prompts; LLMs need to either understand
long text data or select the most relevant evidence prior to inference, and
both approaches are not trivial.
In this paper, we propose a framework, Learning to Reduce, that fine-tunes a
language model to generate a reduced version of an input context, given a task
description and context input. The model learns to reduce the input context
using On-Policy Reinforcement Learning and aims to improve the reasoning
performance of a fixed LLM. Experimental results illustrate that our model not
only achieves comparable accuracies in selecting the relevant evidence from an
input context, but also shows generalizability on different datasets. We
further show that our model helps improve the LLM's performance on downstream
tasks especially when the context is long.
|
[
-0.2883207202,
-0.6285094023,
0.8978989124,
-0.0704735965,
0.007086087,
-0.3627423942,
-0.6596213579,
-0.0720832795,
-0.2551216781,
0.548630774,
-0.6606189609,
-0.5493330956,
-0.5405269861,
0.1653295159,
-0.3072448373,
1.0076310635,
-0.1113827452,
-0.208786726,
-0.3191409409,
-0.063650161,
-0.497391969,
-0.1967713684,
-0.9903041124,
-0.6611521244,
0.5601043105,
0.3389699459,
0.3557700217,
0.7388330102,
0.0559064634,
0.3541254699,
-0.2341381609,
0.3418937922,
-0.7117575407,
0.1888014972,
-0.4479667842,
-0.5780509114,
0.0655955821,
-0.1714692861,
0.7666350007,
0.8912465572,
-0.0780230463,
-0.0790354982,
0.1963799596,
0.4043442011,
-0.6785466075,
0.7913857698,
-0.497164011,
-0.0148135517,
0.2593248188,
-0.2358325422,
-0.7526114583,
-0.1111630127,
0.0568378568,
-0.8007752895,
0.0310152005,
-0.2748661041,
0.6489310861,
0.5927358866,
-0.5934259892,
-0.2416109741,
-0.7756852508,
0.8966904283,
-0.4776391983,
0.2920943499,
0.4445047379,
0.1538505256,
-0.2718968987,
-0.5170967579,
-0.4721312821,
-0.3322086036,
-0.3974977434,
-0.1615464538,
-0.0430440158,
0.2663120031,
0.3193288147,
-0.0842476487,
-0.4555098414,
0.3315378129,
-0.3033396006,
-0.104455106,
0.522798717,
0.2361474782,
-0.0778499842,
0.0635818914,
-0.0497511588,
-0.2582936585,
-0.9872376919,
0.2473165989,
-0.1880705804,
0.6302295923,
-0.018539058,
0.2921993732,
-0.3696492314,
0.7388463616,
0.0685596317,
-0.0820069462,
-0.0608937703,
0.0079153571,
-0.2864306867,
0.0016815884,
0.4922156632,
0.2423346937,
0.2089371532,
-0.1208870038,
-0.4863708615,
0.1717484295,
0.1272476763,
-0.9657943845,
-0.1375573128,
0.0294079203,
-0.3286932111,
-0.2285597771,
-0.3672182858,
-0.1745547205,
-0.407691896,
-0.5570395589,
0.1270629913,
-0.2452878654,
0.2490918338,
-0.0712584555,
0.0455040336,
0.3392182291,
0.6972717047,
-0.8164265156,
0.3052490056,
0.738053441,
0.6913226843,
-0.076276347,
-0.1245015413,
-0.9969321489,
0.4412797093,
-0.630428195,
0.6852901578,
-0.6893891096,
-0.411416322,
0.2155997008,
0.0626445189,
-0.0548590124,
-0.6549345255,
0.4396845698,
-0.4162226915,
0.2495668828,
-0.1964251101,
-0.6177144647,
-0.3110795021,
0.4668712914,
-0.7777867317,
0.7914975882,
0.215276897,
-0.1148866117,
0.5495066643,
-0.901576817,
-0.6805356741,
0.0313127637,
-0.3044165671,
-0.2505867779,
0.1841130555,
0.5131136775,
0.6923505664,
-0.3301617801,
0.512103498,
-0.1764901727,
-0.3749714494,
-0.0992484167,
-0.2937149107,
0.4636765122,
0.3480796218,
-0.0055730175,
0.389524281,
-0.6761434078,
-0.2934578955,
0.2019618899,
-0.8842546344,
-0.395942241,
0.3554600775,
0.0261263009,
0.0969484895,
-0.1092718095,
-0.3306383789,
0.3928515315,
-0.6013210416,
0.6850678921,
0.8309146762,
-0.1870075464,
0.6999522448,
-0.3691544235,
0.2915614247,
-0.124909021,
-0.119228445,
-0.0755932033,
-0.1250107288,
-0.7033573985,
-0.3566332459,
0.1573051512,
0.511424005,
-0.8779542446,
0.324475646,
-0.4980263412,
0.1350907236,
-0.1588962227,
0.2774418294,
0.3612051308,
0.5797189474,
0.406044215,
0.084668234,
-0.3759971559,
-0.7056764364,
-0.0832164586,
-0.1778843999,
-0.4279221296,
0.3085464239,
0.4133579433,
-0.3010157943,
0.9445484281,
-0.4431622922,
-0.1700264961,
-0.5597560406,
0.0430151746,
0.2176203728,
0.4359222651,
0.4248645604,
-0.6832487583,
-0.2943877578,
0.1583123952,
-0.5789828897,
0.0144677889,
-0.3183266222,
0.2005667239,
0.2028693259,
0.7833063006,
-0.779604733,
0.5790999532,
0.2603894174,
-0.3368892074,
0.2107992917,
-0.2180507183,
0.0152576203,
-1.026925683,
0.042755153,
0.0042160447,
-0.5770152807,
-0.6811252832,
-0.0705228224,
-0.0646260604,
-0.3190993667,
-0.3382240236,
0.7889278531,
-0.1907334924,
0.0855274573,
-0.2987622321,
-0.0467950404,
0.0630214587,
0.7256612182,
0.32100752,
0.7055773735,
0.327606529,
-1.0066158772,
0.2755684853,
0.4848541617,
-0.4429876506,
0.3583297431,
-0.6449891925,
-0.1177035421,
-0.2650775015,
0.3666055501,
-0.7294927239,
-0.2683700919,
0.2118167728,
-0.2975918949,
0.4651747048,
-0.2007056028,
-0.2200420648,
0.0396164171,
-0.1694528908,
0.2756351531,
0.4991974831,
-0.7910527587,
0.5112370849,
0.109319821,
-0.2091310918,
-0.3990857303,
-0.7689192295,
-0.0903456509,
-0.2209038585,
-0.3401206136,
0.8040980101,
0.0117811756,
-0.1071313322,
0.121694997,
0.0067516314,
-0.0426085889,
0.2735929191,
0.0256832391,
-0.0339506902,
-0.0894675627,
0.6230131984,
0.2217011601,
-0.0602297336,
0.1924185902,
-0.0948211402,
0.440919131,
0.0682272986,
-0.1406151056,
-0.4948821068,
0.4069180191,
0.3827412724,
0.0963821411,
0.9528608322,
0.1783641428,
-0.3266891539,
-0.6378824115,
0.0001749106,
-0.2915115952,
-0.4888410866,
0.5500631928,
-0.4064086378,
-1.0752456188,
0.3842675686,
-0.4570736587,
0.1187902614,
0.2286064476,
0.4657337666,
0.0554141141,
1.216268301,
0.5673699379,
-0.4183827043,
0.6651496291,
-0.3992628455,
0.2723704278,
-0.51739645,
-0.1719665229,
-0.5289360881,
-0.1357802451,
-0.5484179854,
-0.5293415189,
0.1486714184,
0.0256384742,
-0.5938593149,
-0.0452791639,
-0.321678102,
0.5594238043,
0.310423255,
0.2801042795,
0.097534962,
-0.0696038604,
0.1455843747,
0.4898408651,
-0.8787987828,
-0.3449004292,
0.9555862546,
0.2609708607,
0.6615976691,
0.049221091,
0.6323786974,
0.5191954374,
0.2751625776,
-1.0209656954,
0.561126411,
-0.045848038,
-0.101787433,
-0.5785861611,
-0.6621041298,
-1.1770926714,
0.0749914646,
-0.1909266114,
-0.4849663079,
0.0293989945,
0.217757836,
-0.2163944691,
0.0119768204,
-0.3452264369,
0.7392635345,
0.0135111306,
-0.1801992059,
-0.4797419012,
-0.3096936643,
0.1675221324,
0.2388225347,
0.2463958859,
0.0403639153,
-0.1510238796,
0.5340769291,
-0.7509638667,
0.9019165039,
-0.3058835268,
-0.1068010107,
0.1554070562,
0.0316780843,
1.011089325,
-0.0429530703,
0.0454814881,
-0.2633991539,
-0.3428727686,
-0.481816113,
-0.9116972685,
0.5804180503,
-0.6696512699,
-0.5445251465,
-0.0532320999,
-0.7310047746,
-0.3099945486,
-0.1121705323,
-0.0187923051,
0.5190924406,
-0.1102524474,
0.3493320942,
0.8041905761,
-0.2689321339,
0.3249252439,
0.2403872609,
-0.1713053882,
-0.1739412695,
0.7078495026,
-0.0207519252,
0.0753072351,
0.5105320215,
0.3338904679,
-0.5117544532,
-0.6895503402,
-0.2581678629,
0.092451565,
-1.0406845808,
-0.1144446284,
-0.121816501,
0.0183282364,
-0.5494121313,
-0.2642909586,
-0.0400127396,
-0.1749303639,
-0.3823340833,
-0.2747302651,
0.4897330701,
0.7213843465,
0.06344942,
0.4714264274,
-0.6417270899,
0.2018773556,
0.4392871559,
0.1977608204,
-0.1591825187,
-0.6473532915,
-0.208378911,
-0.1098420545,
0.0323287435,
-0.641769588,
0.5369600654,
0.4984491467,
0.7359814644,
0.457359314,
0.1974385977,
0.5759150982,
-0.389175415,
0.450643301,
0.0951841846,
-1.0084886551,
0.7933061719,
-0.496522665,
0.4330554307,
0.4888187647,
0.5240127444,
-0.4746053815,
-0.0803544745,
-0.1976379454,
-0.8322198987,
0.7305983901,
-0.0033250784,
0.0230143983,
-0.052442316,
0.4562749863,
-0.0371004678,
0.2002959102,
-0.8069924116,
0.0396602415,
0.2447136343,
-0.4169763327,
-0.2046165168,
-0.0829242244,
-0.026872443,
-0.4019744098,
0.673117578,
-0.472435683,
0.19125323,
0.0317326635,
-0.5276108384,
0.2364077568,
0.3308228254,
0.5918465853,
0.5395153761,
0.1807634234,
-0.0141936829,
0.3587947488,
0.0339106433,
0.0084935818,
-0.2029999197,
-0.4824888706,
-0.1942472607,
0.5556172132,
1.0466406345,
0.3211507499,
-0.8985854983,
0.3164923191,
0.0164061561,
-0.3305412233,
-0.0935822576,
0.1224699393,
-0.1402642727,
0.3414400518,
0.0875511914,
-0.1255634576,
0.2349204719,
-0.6932888031,
0.1265005916,
0.3017369509,
-0.2759567797,
-0.0206636749,
0.2145285457,
0.3821433485,
-0.2624155879,
0.8729018569,
-0.3290976584,
-0.6063042283,
0.5428861976,
0.4528211057,
0.536791563,
-0.241660133,
0.2637677193,
0.3688492179,
0.1790211201,
-0.1832908094,
0.0301619079,
-0.4327388406,
-0.6703233123,
-0.8674039841,
-0.4611581564,
-0.3593070209,
0.4014468193,
-0.6282394528,
0.1359476298,
-0.6401682496,
0.0483841263,
-0.3182468116,
-0.0462687574,
-0.7824996114,
0.0856141821,
0.1534155756,
0.5671895742,
-1.0049893856,
0.8626265526,
0.4911137819,
-0.3199970722,
-0.9432986975,
-0.1310711503,
-0.1093867123,
-0.5974122286,
0.8150379062,
0.4218800068,
0.0765355006,
-0.1894895881,
-0.7752287388,
-0.7841941118,
0.7665533423,
0.7165006399,
-0.5003492832,
0.0043573729,
0.1092860103,
0.3449335098,
-0.4777958989,
0.0059659258,
0.7559854984,
0.5999658704,
0.1113901734,
-0.811586082,
0.2603657842,
-0.1594537199,
0.1366078854,
0.3368370235,
-0.2929422855,
0.9115489721,
-0.1139956638,
-0.3028883338,
-0.1679914743,
0.5445034504,
0.1722364128,
0.3367147744,
0.4686527848,
0.5380309224,
0.8434306383,
-0.0572549403,
1.1279370785,
0.1641881764,
0.3462199569,
1.2092095613,
-0.4061689377,
0.8115073442,
0.3463890851,
-0.124345161,
0.6425789595,
0.6638586521,
0.19214423,
0.7875772715,
0.3737901747,
-0.280033946,
-0.5138514042,
-0.2903649807,
0.1066880524,
0.4756009877,
0.6058585048,
-0.3453114331,
-0.4001883566,
0.2005989105,
0.0598883666,
0.3911499977,
-0.7095579505,
1.0428525209,
-0.1801499277,
-0.8850799799,
0.7980505228,
0.0428986587,
0.4667845964,
-0.5345754027,
-0.3850645125,
-0.2143990546,
0.2721954882,
-0.0777919739,
-0.531482935,
0.4595084488,
-0.1371329278,
-0.458401531,
-0.4911652207,
0.6304967999,
-0.5649212599,
-0.2084950805,
0.4738242328,
0.1408251971,
0.2108676881,
-0.175216943,
-0.7015243173,
0.0010448559,
-0.0922391415,
-0.4414384961,
0.484131664,
0.3722522259,
-0.3005090654,
0.8742420673,
0.6904143095,
0.1146967411,
-0.3258257806,
0.0918174013,
1.0262445211,
-0.6179612279,
-0.6364243627,
-0.6685599089,
0.2933051288,
-0.180388689,
0.0329667404,
0.2364938259,
0.3669470847,
1.0283173323,
-0.0479736663,
0.9432737231,
0.0833419189,
0.4351041019,
-0.8943946362,
0.5321451426,
-0.5970134139,
0.2950837612,
0.3539403677,
-0.7024760842,
-0.2115249932,
0.9857538342,
-0.4312818348,
0.0346193314,
0.5765743852,
0.8422018886,
0.2009870112,
-0.4492919147,
0.4923878312,
0.0589749068,
0.4239800572,
0.9104236364,
0.7303376198,
-0.121217452,
0.602725327,
0.0070183352,
0.0149896163,
-0.2912123799,
-0.805365622,
-1.117659688,
-0.5773895979,
-0.1384007335,
-0.1095858142,
0.1907300353,
1.1124845743,
0.7370799184,
-0.9773311019,
-0.1482930779,
-0.296765089,
0.4004727304,
-0.2231286764,
-0.1667148918,
0.3301183879,
-0.6038584709,
-0.6695911884,
0.9027861953,
0.1206500754,
-0.2946431935,
-0.0232528411,
-0.5233594775,
-0.1343871355,
0.2150006592,
0.8323972821,
0.389898777,
-0.656616509,
-0.5611721277,
-0.3589111269,
-0.0051728925,
0.0273251869,
0.9629340172,
-1.0903122425,
0.1419284791,
0.729665637,
0.8736714125,
0.6004217267,
-0.1061593294,
0.6523848176,
-0.9034882784,
0.2501116991,
0.3844095469,
0.4301246703,
0.0935743526,
-0.3748889267,
0.5415468216,
0.0497698747,
-0.4645596743,
-0.7883404493,
0.3399975002,
-0.8073838353,
-0.6856162548,
1.174516201,
-0.3022221923,
-0.4373832345,
-0.2352956235,
-0.0717023835,
0.2279037386,
-0.521173656,
0.4592693746,
0.4380253553,
-0.0740561038,
-0.3068232238,
-0.1730404049,
0.7418837547,
0.4013779163,
-1.0293959379,
0.341673553,
0.8646054268,
0.20920901,
-0.0922722593,
0.4140186906,
0.3810495138,
0.318582505,
-0.1501821876,
-0.0497734286,
-0.2554329336,
-0.6361199021,
-0.6399934292,
0.1446765661,
0.1904311329,
-0.013012941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14187v1
|
From Adoption to Adaption: Tracing the Diffusion of New Emojis on Twitter
| 2024-02-22T00:24:44 | 2024-02-22T00:24:44 |
Yuhang Zhou, Xuan Lu, Wei Ai
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of social media, the introduction of new
emojis in Unicode release versions presents a structured opportunity to explore
digital language evolution. Analyzing a large dataset of sampled English
tweets, we examine how newly released emojis gain traction and evolve in
meaning. We find that community size of early adopters and emoji semantics are
crucial in determining their popularity. Certain emojis experienced notable
shifts in the meanings and sentiment associations during the diffusion process.
Additionally, we propose a novel framework utilizing language models to extract
words and pre-existing emojis with semantically similar contexts, which
enhances interpretation of new emojis. The framework demonstrates its
effectiveness in improving sentiment classification performance by substituting
unknown new emojis with familiar ones. This study offers a new perspective in
understanding how new language units are adopted, adapted, and integrated into
the fabric of online communication.
|
[
-0.5439722538,
-0.8486351371,
0.5147312284,
0.3854941428,
-0.3732022941,
0.4219594896,
-0.4423235655,
-0.3772642314,
0.6112278104,
0.2436352074,
-0.504391849,
-0.2636403143,
-1.0137963295,
0.164976418,
-0.2963363528,
0.8496052623,
-0.0978803486,
-0.376747638,
0.2160016894,
-0.4392706454,
-0.2024594992,
-0.1555285007,
-0.6039305925,
0.0343093984,
0.7641673684,
0.4035754204,
0.679715097,
0.3115673661,
0.5582705736,
0.1988800615,
-0.2844288051,
-0.215630874,
-0.4907520711,
0.1336988658,
0.1257164478,
-0.1988582462,
-0.148664102,
-0.031065397,
0.587321341,
0.5427969694,
-0.2147529572,
0.0186883751,
0.0676048025,
0.5432118177,
-0.7835904956,
-0.035950873,
-0.6475784183,
-0.2063195258,
-0.2304692119,
-0.0882106796,
-0.2729525864,
-0.5910099149,
0.2315512747,
-0.6062622666,
-0.3221016824,
-0.2644512355,
0.6367102861,
-0.2780459523,
-0.4063461423,
-0.5020297766,
-0.4784441292,
0.8262637258,
-0.1937313378,
0.5605062842,
-0.2287843078,
0.5339565873,
-0.133739695,
-0.8445592523,
-0.4993026257,
0.0682477951,
0.3274182677,
-0.1936667562,
-0.341917485,
-0.4143826365,
-0.1654813439,
0.1208664626,
-0.0593725033,
-0.2620671988,
-0.0132007375,
0.1698285341,
0.6817712784,
-0.3220146596,
0.5684363842,
-0.1241363063,
-0.0937716588,
0.173531875,
-0.8048843145,
-0.2200689614,
0.0090468293,
0.2665977776,
-0.2275775522,
0.2632110417,
0.1887069046,
0.345212549,
0.09722846,
0.1309730709,
0.7488871813,
-0.3189061582,
-0.0805022344,
-0.2049036026,
0.6305906177,
0.415109843,
0.6310921907,
-0.0019119014,
-0.0489549004,
-0.1951306611,
0.0915179625,
-0.4838457108,
-0.022020096,
-0.1129711866,
-0.6845973134,
-0.4386520386,
0.0664496571,
-0.5940591097,
-0.9096213579,
0.0642059967,
0.1868115216,
-0.2694721818,
-0.7330791354,
-0.069092609,
-0.6734999418,
0.4525617659,
0.7662238479,
-0.7974435687,
0.0099318577,
0.8422968388,
1.0230371952,
0.1653407812,
0.1453261077,
0.1130746603,
-0.0816077441,
-0.5337467194,
0.7143501043,
-0.781180501,
-0.3563002348,
0.3620480597,
0.3064992428,
-0.0640351772,
-0.4751971066,
0.1536921561,
-0.5651496053,
-0.1365539283,
-0.3269383907,
-0.4110730886,
-0.1098374948,
0.1124203578,
-0.552461803,
0.5511273146,
0.5489873886,
-0.8991526961,
0.8035569787,
-0.8790910244,
-0.4756223559,
0.2768524289,
0.1669733822,
-0.0426209718,
0.4809575379,
0.0491933636,
0.6237014532,
-0.103976436,
-0.4163574576,
-0.8606002927,
-0.1106241494,
0.3134969473,
0.093401961,
1.2047723532,
0.6612551212,
0.0814500228,
-0.4226295054,
-0.2556268275,
-0.5150914192,
0.1904510409,
-0.1978854984,
-0.6272664666,
0.2655687928,
0.2189110816,
0.0470522977,
0.1766023487,
-0.5847279429,
0.1479857266,
-0.1338686645,
0.8258185387,
0.5387080312,
0.4830069244,
0.7199130654,
-0.1856136024,
0.344940722,
0.1157760248,
0.5186035037,
-0.2004551739,
-0.8113526106,
-0.3701100051,
-0.101994656,
0.0938242301,
0.1907537282,
-0.6848698258,
0.2489346862,
-0.6328908205,
-0.4059994221,
-0.7058439851,
0.2918708622,
-0.5822672844,
-0.2381533384,
-0.225164935,
-0.2221135497,
-0.5356462598,
-0.6413646936,
-0.4812161326,
-0.2643167377,
-0.0434828252,
0.5490903258,
0.0950412974,
-0.67833215,
0.8569948673,
-0.2838763297,
-0.0126608675,
-0.5078295469,
0.2916285694,
-0.0783575475,
0.0129109723,
0.8910140395,
-0.9377281666,
-0.5443394184,
0.3341079652,
-0.6132465601,
-0.1744544506,
-0.1195538491,
-0.2144183964,
0.124257341,
0.3922026455,
-0.0764000639,
-0.0059520961,
0.6364924312,
-0.3665457964,
-0.2849428952,
0.3526242077,
0.4454615712,
-1.4990694523,
-0.2463857383,
0.2523003221,
-0.1362599283,
-0.513456583,
0.0951286778,
0.0144124841,
0.3045116067,
-0.7294718027,
0.6475436091,
-0.5702636242,
0.0811434388,
-0.1463517249,
0.5604581237,
-0.242765978,
-0.4533433914,
-0.3412184119,
0.325774461,
0.6099451184,
-0.4747491479,
0.1500718594,
0.170191586,
-0.2741428614,
0.2819660604,
-0.1388508826,
0.0064894897,
-0.2908177078,
0.1218457595,
-1.1822239161,
-0.1895207018,
0.2684267759,
-0.6475503445,
0.1380636692,
-0.3344689906,
-0.3916662037,
-0.2612474561,
-0.4307458401,
0.2838520706,
0.9549474716,
-0.4907191992,
0.6749565005,
0.929161787,
-0.1826351732,
-0.0656770319,
-0.734890759,
0.1524938792,
-0.3178334534,
-0.8460181355,
-0.2098616809,
-0.0357048102,
-0.5888468027,
-0.1402379423,
0.3478455245,
-0.3221224546,
0.5706564784,
-0.0746359006,
-0.3150228262,
-0.2079510689,
0.1477409452,
0.2760440409,
0.3917968273,
0.1152893156,
0.0386900418,
0.3779427111,
0.2093521059,
0.2548747659,
-0.1559023112,
0.1605419815,
0.6291089058,
0.2399251312,
1.011252284,
0.5958720446,
-0.3120369017,
-0.1611871719,
-0.5198410749,
0.0732950568,
-0.484526515,
0.1943544894,
-0.2467615753,
-0.8579396605,
0.400949806,
-0.4492710829,
0.3911812603,
0.4172136188,
0.4282865226,
0.0077271149,
1.1337729692,
0.7263148427,
-0.0069175223,
1.1037752628,
0.0253694747,
0.2946764231,
-0.861733675,
0.0448559336,
-0.3636778593,
-0.2364189178,
-1.12680161,
-0.35907951,
-0.1689613312,
0.1639079601,
0.1958570182,
0.4607733786,
-0.206674695,
0.3640977442,
-0.233441025,
0.025615653,
-0.0639773235,
0.2913607955,
0.4048952758,
0.0623469725,
-0.2478548586,
-0.4427408278,
1.0655913353,
0.5227661133,
0.6826533675,
0.5958895683,
0.8959969878,
0.6533158422,
1.0343364477,
-0.6917725205,
0.3235955238,
-0.283611387,
-0.1852310449,
0.0967044905,
-0.2232386917,
-1.0351644754,
-0.0099883992,
-0.3113296926,
-0.7816845775,
0.1327659041,
-0.0887881368,
0.1828535795,
-0.0311141796,
-1.007003665,
0.7368847728,
0.1444415748,
0.0246774871,
-0.3101867139,
-0.4843530655,
0.1160235032,
-0.2927158773,
0.6512054205,
-0.3789578676,
-0.3009467721,
0.6374943852,
0.2029814422,
0.5605604649,
-0.2502102256,
-0.053265471,
0.6183418632,
0.0702156201,
0.2559992075,
-0.129899621,
-0.1874562353,
0.3120025992,
-0.0741700232,
-0.5341073275,
-0.8219698071,
0.7516033053,
-0.6397919655,
-0.3301902711,
0.0825235024,
-0.0116544301,
0.0971924067,
0.130030781,
0.0636645481,
-0.0659531504,
-0.4428405762,
0.3267201483,
0.3233391941,
-0.0154491933,
0.6067160368,
0.207354039,
-0.4078757763,
-0.3917691112,
0.7145406604,
0.176815778,
0.177758649,
0.2792306244,
0.7423151731,
-0.4124049246,
-0.4919119477,
-0.3710280359,
0.2918128371,
-0.7709172964,
0.3232972324,
-0.7012471557,
0.1070073172,
-0.7279734612,
-0.575881958,
0.0283928737,
-0.4607664645,
-0.29011935,
-0.0180253386,
0.6337895393,
1.26380229,
0.1269201189,
0.3245480657,
-0.8291430473,
-0.1186151877,
-0.0652147532,
0.218583554,
-0.0637506619,
-0.7277256846,
-0.2424873412,
0.0776142702,
-0.3192431629,
-1.1596242189,
0.2500858307,
0.4031497836,
0.4669964612,
0.6940805316,
-0.2220575511,
0.296291858,
-0.3042856157,
0.8289135695,
0.2637848854,
-0.8711763024,
0.661154747,
-0.6021188498,
0.0878134221,
0.2757689953,
0.4081210792,
-0.9882774949,
-0.4745064676,
-0.6535000205,
-0.8117666841,
0.3363547325,
0.1720346808,
0.6384536624,
-0.5951062441,
0.5342307687,
0.0522687584,
0.315413326,
-0.6078038812,
-0.291551441,
-0.1243680641,
-0.5924949646,
-0.1985748857,
-0.1522689462,
0.2328141332,
-0.2780937254,
0.2081518322,
-0.0833244324,
0.421613723,
-0.3109869957,
-0.4656004906,
-0.0681371242,
0.1588578969,
0.0835718587,
0.4297025204,
0.0684223175,
0.0630640388,
0.003647984,
-0.6322802901,
-0.0355006158,
-0.2995427847,
-0.2147091776,
0.0549828894,
0.1072540954,
0.5100149512,
0.1975285709,
-0.411000073,
0.8491957784,
-0.0478017256,
-0.0999754146,
-0.2758228779,
-0.0296890773,
0.1539927572,
0.0359378792,
0.2634650171,
-0.0353890657,
0.2530165911,
-0.9888951182,
0.5230231285,
0.2903726995,
-0.5285121799,
-0.7174687982,
0.1727703214,
0.387658596,
-0.4657077491,
0.1892929077,
-0.1439656168,
-0.197047174,
0.3434411883,
0.4214806855,
1.4060405493,
-0.3721877337,
0.4562341571,
0.0891601369,
0.2073795497,
-0.1375259906,
0.3543024957,
-0.0305163823,
-1.0313466787,
0.1861495525,
-0.6868201494,
0.1151138395,
-0.6291888952,
-0.3715675473,
0.4632101655,
-0.7124397755,
-0.3941417933,
0.292244494,
-0.422016114,
-0.703975141,
0.132646814,
0.4398257732,
0.8497143984,
-1.273573637,
0.7013037801,
0.9755482078,
-0.3890426159,
-0.482457459,
0.4099084437,
0.0623164438,
-0.8809069991,
0.3393623829,
0.2383383363,
0.2176846266,
0.1503404081,
-0.5049853921,
-0.9346249104,
0.7347163558,
0.0498220846,
-0.3465047479,
0.5048087239,
-0.1087422073,
0.7589911222,
-0.7707153559,
0.5780636668,
0.6185596585,
0.3350850642,
0.2721856833,
-0.3004771173,
0.046586819,
-0.2641069889,
0.2494886816,
0.645188272,
-0.4082198441,
0.7127621174,
-0.3009170592,
-0.4853852093,
-0.015986383,
0.355812043,
-0.1271834373,
0.4091975391,
0.5903137922,
0.1215278879,
0.3241923749,
-0.2661570609,
1.0576672554,
-0.3144473732,
0.3801453412,
0.3471702337,
-0.2294270843,
1.2848236561,
0.7120526433,
-0.0211209003,
0.9880263209,
0.6981889606,
0.0994750932,
0.4193753302,
0.1386574358,
-0.2632951736,
-0.0899344906,
-0.3737131953,
0.1130996943,
0.0802703649,
0.4677656889,
-0.7327248454,
-0.2036341429,
0.2815208733,
0.0538437366,
-0.2574779391,
-0.2658336163,
1.0286915302,
0.1788874716,
-0.4751793146,
0.2675568759,
-0.3331051469,
0.4612931609,
-0.2358710319,
-0.0306110214,
-0.1734572053,
0.1968733072,
-0.2525319159,
-1.0639472008,
0.3322909474,
-0.1699249446,
0.1570785642,
-0.1353773028,
0.4606870711,
-0.0414779745,
-0.5737500191,
0.7427721024,
0.5228488445,
0.2339347005,
0.0795266852,
-0.7858118415,
0.2407504469,
0.0495595038,
-0.4147860408,
0.3134007156,
0.8532204032,
-0.0543455295,
0.5228719711,
0.2270975858,
-0.0576852299,
0.4478982389,
0.456818521,
0.6930911541,
-0.6707575321,
-0.3641749918,
-0.7987239361,
0.3986877799,
-0.0715023503,
-0.391610831,
0.8758091927,
0.129546091,
0.5012678504,
0.2295914441,
1.1073496342,
-0.4867286086,
0.4105287492,
-0.0920366421,
0.6956359744,
-1.1050834656,
0.2866968811,
-0.6765069366,
-0.9071277976,
-0.2969239652,
0.4807164967,
-0.2035037428,
0.2740880251,
0.5158049464,
0.5290632248,
0.0089312261,
0.1919256449,
0.1569328457,
0.3080933392,
0.2420178652,
0.0155278044,
1.0839927197,
-0.499932915,
0.1751923263,
0.0257776044,
-0.4247089922,
-0.4351370335,
-0.7601336241,
-0.4816838503,
-0.4540274143,
-0.5713398457,
-0.4866725206,
0.1112849936,
1.0523974895,
0.3983539939,
-0.7182502747,
-0.1217879504,
-0.3225513995,
0.2034718841,
-0.1123356298,
-0.3133040667,
-0.1171158701,
-0.3813877702,
-0.5022217631,
0.0167002063,
0.2418050766,
0.2762844265,
-0.071045436,
-0.1289026737,
-0.1787893474,
0.5279682279,
0.8044869304,
0.1150241569,
-0.5865929127,
-0.5095085502,
0.1072795317,
0.0714116171,
0.2716189921,
0.9315033555,
-0.2715623081,
0.5263396502,
0.7645390034,
0.5979648232,
0.054983303,
-0.1825097948,
0.5214086175,
-0.5392426848,
-0.0261004064,
0.0407507159,
0.3618502915,
0.6255214214,
-0.0301931221,
0.2215093076,
0.6072175503,
-0.3350142539,
-0.7314908504,
0.1829494536,
-0.6891643405,
-0.4184592664,
1.4317700863,
0.0298863277,
-0.5865020752,
-0.4300300479,
0.1126776114,
0.0290930662,
-0.6890928745,
0.7920771241,
0.6098773479,
0.1338197887,
-0.4668829143,
-0.0759830028,
0.4265267849,
-0.0690807104,
-0.651437223,
0.0595666282,
0.1388301849,
0.6368134618,
0.2025764436,
0.7344367504,
-0.1007126346,
0.084894672,
0.0736358538,
-0.0562838726,
0.5813711286,
-0.1818531305,
-0.4179218113,
0.1611822844,
0.5484480858,
-0.1822502166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14184v1
|
Diversity-Aware Ensembling of Language Models Based on Topological Data Analysis
| 2024-02-22T00:04:21 | 2024-02-22T00:04:21 |
Polina Proskura, Alexey Zaytsev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Ensembles are important tools for improving the performance of machine
learning models. In cases related to natural language processing, ensembles
boost the performance of a method due to multiple large models available in
open source. However, existing approaches mostly rely on simple averaging of
predictions by ensembles with equal weights for each model, ignoring
differences in the quality and conformity of models. We propose to estimate
weights for ensembles of NLP models using not only knowledge of their
individual performance but also their similarity to each other. By adopting
distance measures based on Topological Data Analysis (TDA), we improve our
ensemble. The quality improves for both text classification accuracy and
relevant uncertainty estimation.
|
[
-0.3452203274,
-0.5218243599,
0.2506323159,
0.1246101409,
-0.1555257142,
0.4228891134,
-0.1201196834,
-0.8123178482,
0.5282078385,
0.3722352087,
-0.223119691,
-0.5210067034,
-0.7642207742,
0.0575604066,
-0.762868762,
0.7110894322,
0.294029355,
-0.1658738703,
-0.1171039939,
-0.4299942255,
-0.2627685964,
-0.206964165,
-0.4618810713,
-0.0152361477,
0.2048424035,
0.1627190709,
0.734444201,
0.5013836026,
0.6082186699,
0.4831421971,
-0.3785571456,
0.3263292611,
-0.2852283418,
0.1067123041,
-0.1501478255,
-0.4945743382,
-0.4193248749,
-0.2170363069,
1.0501458645,
0.8253419399,
-0.2819861174,
0.1075242683,
0.1280360669,
0.7417299151,
-0.5205379128,
-0.4624915719,
-0.6693187952,
0.2442034483,
-0.4937249422,
-0.1416808814,
-0.131112963,
-0.5215827227,
0.2763670981,
-0.5818298459,
0.2428704649,
0.1860828996,
0.7358813286,
0.1586444378,
-0.3032775521,
-0.1514525115,
-0.8594991565,
1.1040923595,
-0.8280650377,
0.5799096227,
0.4050250053,
0.2440309674,
-0.1142882481,
-0.3452875614,
-0.5984397531,
0.4234341979,
-0.1647213697,
-0.0466657579,
-0.2497019768,
-0.0259969123,
-0.0690668747,
0.5564695597,
-0.6564348936,
0.3587783873,
-0.7472990751,
0.0285433177,
0.8872842789,
-0.1513157487,
0.4647164643,
-0.0819831714,
-0.1713843793,
-0.1956910789,
-0.1273184568,
-0.0813123658,
0.5884244442,
0.3858756721,
-0.4578557014,
0.4700043201,
-0.328661114,
0.8623082042,
-0.0664809793,
0.0225449856,
0.3992169499,
-0.3278962672,
-0.5148838162,
-0.1474708468,
0.6636212468,
0.0102624083,
0.240581587,
-0.5785373449,
-0.1532575339,
-0.2330449671,
0.3484614491,
-0.2635603249,
-0.2643104792,
0.4361723661,
-0.4933622777,
-0.3656785488,
0.0557581149,
-1.3246777058,
-0.2655752003,
-0.4354188442,
0.2684871852,
-0.4992293715,
-0.4400837421,
0.01991079,
-0.265796721,
-0.1648746133,
0.2337868512,
-0.9199463129,
0.85334903,
0.6478018165,
1.1151255369,
-0.5367993712,
-0.1700319797,
-0.2794522643,
-0.038385693,
-0.1239077449,
0.7560927272,
-0.6672917604,
-0.4136730433,
-0.2744987905,
-0.2958784997,
-0.2646825314,
-0.4949248135,
0.6656847,
-0.5234971046,
0.3937816024,
0.0323777609,
-0.7139967084,
-0.4748341441,
0.1502364129,
-0.7173780799,
1.1887729168,
0.2426062822,
-1.0677251816,
0.4694110751,
-0.5215480328,
-0.2364854962,
0.1082650796,
0.0198642798,
-0.3746917248,
0.1348671466,
0.5619052052,
0.3773064017,
-0.0868561938,
0.3397189975,
-0.4386899173,
-0.3161370158,
-0.2111629993,
0.026166698,
0.9873611927,
0.2332037538,
-0.0214816555,
0.1518593431,
-0.7646366358,
0.0679892004,
-0.2265890241,
-0.2935457528,
-0.7478173375,
0.1529520005,
0.0888864771,
-0.0872751996,
-0.0826080814,
-0.2954999208,
0.1477744281,
-0.8308372498,
-0.1645736992,
0.9547277093,
-0.3200590312,
0.770167768,
-0.4238168299,
0.7615383863,
-0.0296021402,
-0.29790923,
0.5784742832,
-0.7102168798,
-0.4309894443,
-0.4639121294,
0.5754750371,
0.4687246978,
-0.581766367,
0.6629510522,
-0.4141231477,
-0.8044345379,
-0.3768489063,
0.0644718185,
-0.0728146881,
0.2868074775,
0.3524995446,
-0.5376655459,
-0.63329494,
-0.5376714468,
-0.5576589704,
-0.1295593232,
-0.1927263141,
0.1177270263,
0.3757949769,
-0.1747299433,
1.1525644064,
-0.2913137376,
-0.1156081632,
-0.2035420686,
0.172843799,
0.3288520575,
0.6764681935,
0.8402901292,
-0.7021430731,
-0.3324158788,
0.2015383691,
-0.5628961921,
0.0234211925,
0.261793673,
-0.2934011519,
0.0869468525,
0.1734949499,
-0.3975946307,
0.1604486108,
0.9396388531,
-0.3368277252,
0.561442554,
0.0973426104,
0.1336888671,
-1.2954642773,
-0.0845207199,
0.2887497842,
-0.2418073714,
-0.7374150753,
0.1624218076,
-0.3807681501,
0.0187057555,
-0.0272716153,
0.8007056117,
-0.3141905367,
-0.3297913074,
0.1956745088,
0.3580146134,
-0.2310432643,
0.235220179,
0.0311669577,
0.4056676328,
0.9355748892,
-0.8394283652,
0.127102524,
0.0446529649,
-0.5505099297,
0.5279806256,
-0.4884262085,
0.0525369495,
0.0004809038,
0.0544382669,
-0.7957537174,
-0.2469683886,
0.0961847603,
-0.4473158121,
0.4757952988,
-0.0123795299,
-0.2901053727,
-0.2225523889,
-0.1352180243,
0.7602922916,
0.3521127999,
-0.5429299474,
0.7744028568,
0.703188777,
-0.182566762,
-0.6585342884,
-0.6732968092,
-0.104165636,
-0.6635938287,
-0.7867418528,
0.3152894676,
0.2040960342,
-0.5392382145,
-0.1256723851,
-0.0248276442,
-0.4763768613,
0.2783736885,
-0.1111254469,
-0.1530033499,
-0.1044461876,
0.7076721787,
0.1702674627,
0.3640919626,
-0.3017031848,
-0.716835022,
0.5398308039,
-0.1708213091,
-0.2708589137,
-0.1699184477,
0.2345045954,
0.1916275769,
-0.3846569657,
0.8569853902,
0.7260668278,
-0.6438321471,
-0.4425944388,
-0.454238683,
-0.2155231535,
-0.5050758123,
0.2379458696,
0.0213093664,
-0.9968143702,
0.5841053128,
0.1711990982,
0.0818463638,
0.5357996821,
0.3543751538,
-0.2913251519,
0.3639913201,
0.8488372564,
-0.3999807835,
0.3245950043,
0.0497963466,
0.3257038891,
-0.4384975433,
0.0721838102,
-1.0008357763,
-0.6990283728,
-0.9193060398,
-0.6144173145,
0.270771414,
0.1052349135,
-0.0554507338,
0.2848295271,
-0.6806803942,
0.4767667055,
0.6885653734,
-0.0601833351,
0.319188863,
0.4886234701,
-0.0409386009,
0.05831616,
-0.779316783,
-0.2683836222,
1.0997754335,
0.39896667,
0.5658705235,
0.3679025173,
0.8946703672,
0.2979898155,
-0.1569195837,
-0.6236196756,
0.312482059,
-0.3432791531,
-0.3923970461,
-0.6580353975,
-0.8718362451,
-0.9237233996,
0.2152045369,
-0.2523402274,
-1.350460887,
0.4224634767,
-0.0466724671,
-0.2239314616,
0.716599822,
-0.2553587258,
0.336224705,
0.0744197965,
0.1660069972,
-0.2651026845,
-0.3337158263,
0.6725466847,
-0.1556343138,
0.3284027576,
0.1062951162,
0.2139691114,
1.0551345348,
-0.0643023774,
0.5565224886,
0.1250132322,
-0.1966830343,
0.298406601,
0.455432564,
0.4200771451,
-0.1593558192,
-0.4904725254,
0.6030085683,
-0.0817578658,
-0.2482541651,
-0.4763159454,
0.5154908299,
-0.7663004994,
-0.3417628407,
-0.1678746045,
-0.7285935879,
-0.3235052824,
-0.0277345125,
0.1301155835,
0.4162613451,
0.0586088374,
0.3023458123,
0.4631730616,
-0.1900682896,
0.5855418444,
0.1877876818,
-0.0705320165,
-0.1676892936,
0.7513141632,
0.2262282819,
0.1944247931,
0.6255483031,
0.1819006801,
-0.2147030234,
-0.7590440512,
-0.2681271136,
-0.0161662493,
-0.4199065268,
-0.104406409,
-1.0309852362,
-0.0154513298,
-0.6561905146,
-0.1855334789,
-0.2183204591,
-0.954529047,
-0.1513275057,
-0.1135506704,
0.4863917828,
0.7532904744,
-0.0598244444,
0.4362122715,
-0.8670809865,
0.0500604212,
0.2827706039,
0.6953539848,
-0.0012996509,
-0.590243578,
-0.3043088317,
-0.0820071399,
-0.3788404167,
-0.9407553077,
0.5019189119,
0.3598732352,
0.4534624815,
0.3321937919,
-0.0808501169,
0.364549011,
-0.1105235666,
0.7491314411,
-0.06018034,
-1.0915206671,
0.4787158966,
-0.450083226,
0.2246701419,
0.3192096651,
0.2651047707,
-0.5961574316,
-0.6925404668,
-0.6632238626,
-0.5672032833,
0.8266427517,
0.6187784076,
-0.1980258822,
0.2690242827,
-0.0384645872,
-0.1261823922,
0.0295740087,
-0.7841219306,
0.0610097833,
0.087327525,
-0.4739477634,
-0.0414030999,
0.200563997,
-0.0460946895,
-0.2938679159,
0.7578344941,
-0.3249803483,
0.197634846,
0.0083818622,
0.1325666755,
-0.2317594886,
0.2259157896,
0.4114362597,
0.7265457511,
-0.1192825213,
-0.1128662899,
0.6160289049,
-0.3284687996,
-0.0206083171,
-0.0020059808,
0.0467555523,
0.0840015709,
0.472445935,
0.2249744534,
-0.1235535443,
-0.571511507,
0.1611934006,
0.0142589258,
0.0771289393,
0.1462995559,
0.1326616257,
0.1407051682,
0.187194407,
0.1243949607,
0.3584399521,
0.4651270509,
-0.1722452044,
0.4725803733,
0.3746840656,
-0.5521232486,
-0.2700433135,
0.221791178,
0.230332315,
-0.3157088757,
0.6770226955,
-0.2593061626,
-0.5302793384,
1.0105865002,
0.2529856861,
1.0058716536,
-0.5932340026,
0.3712779582,
0.6343224645,
0.5215628743,
-0.090084821,
0.0587756969,
-0.0426832996,
-1.0348103046,
-0.2034323514,
-1.0872594118,
-0.1612612456,
-0.3935674131,
-0.4634844065,
0.2702493668,
-0.3207915723,
0.1387988329,
-0.3337796032,
0.0008793913,
-0.5484716892,
0.5461758971,
-0.0231384858,
0.8418590426,
-0.7650094628,
0.684946239,
0.4014801681,
0.2321484834,
-0.7624928951,
0.0619171262,
0.194832325,
-0.4367002845,
0.5109432936,
0.0174415186,
-0.0012976597,
-0.3045473397,
-0.2698110044,
-1.1393382549,
0.8461251259,
0.1811137199,
-0.7639124393,
-0.0012359866,
0.002063914,
0.6283570528,
-0.3057306409,
0.3313369155,
0.4940423965,
0.3358624279,
-0.2292112708,
-1.0564908981,
-0.2552387714,
-0.3061158061,
-0.188994348,
0.3831081092,
-0.4445379972,
1.0476639271,
0.0490522124,
-0.4995907545,
-0.1092699766,
0.6989026666,
0.2446310669,
0.2734190524,
0.6818679571,
0.7407971621,
1.3117562532,
-0.0992666706,
1.1672314405,
-0.0600267723,
0.4687187374,
1.2665381432,
0.0520662032,
0.6865799427,
0.3032630086,
-0.4356153607,
0.4726028442,
0.7093815207,
-0.072911188,
0.1109090894,
0.2738958001,
-0.0359245315,
-0.0481387749,
0.0103593348,
-0.4348148108,
0.7901029587,
0.4747893214,
-0.2910265028,
-0.13850905,
-0.4375422895,
-0.4075062275,
0.1648062617,
-0.2332527488,
0.8280820847,
0.0105213225,
-0.3525394201,
0.3092513382,
0.1679152846,
0.8778082728,
-0.4132116139,
0.284404695,
-0.1246769354,
-0.2316845059,
-0.3558734357,
-0.6359202862,
0.6247528195,
-0.1757601798,
-0.1976766139,
0.1545290351,
0.6339451075,
-0.5140751004,
-0.9336556196,
0.4325448871,
0.458180815,
0.2215132564,
0.0691790506,
-0.5575510263,
-0.5140698552,
-0.08074487,
0.0006091435,
0.0299748518,
0.4078222811,
-0.0724015757,
0.8033077121,
0.3462714255,
0.2822505832,
0.2072079927,
-0.0176385064,
0.6288565993,
-0.3204293549,
-0.7838683128,
-0.7510221004,
0.453340739,
-0.2651683986,
-0.352221936,
0.6774243712,
0.3033542335,
0.8215360045,
0.1460537612,
0.5225615501,
-0.0806887224,
0.661842823,
-0.5629562736,
0.9202560782,
-0.770663321,
0.3313821852,
-0.5711355805,
-1.1947152615,
-0.2701092064,
0.2107750475,
0.0082411245,
0.2195135951,
0.4479499459,
0.8762228489,
-0.4326925278,
0.4796865582,
0.2199734896,
0.1107784957,
0.3060355783,
0.260536164,
0.3638628721,
-0.3992510438,
0.1146696955,
-0.2380945683,
-0.0811781511,
0.1764388233,
-0.7765438557,
-0.7663879395,
-0.5468589664,
-0.1761538088,
0.0629913062,
-0.0549377576,
0.7609093785,
0.969520092,
-1.0886970758,
-0.4062970281,
-0.1471361518,
0.5809775591,
-0.4146487713,
-0.2726258636,
0.4185930192,
-0.3335498571,
-0.9408295751,
0.3208070993,
0.1746996492,
0.0471207984,
-0.2012423426,
-0.0321671367,
-0.4560372233,
0.1640479565,
0.3629285097,
-0.0454452038,
-0.5550932884,
-0.3291633725,
-0.4445247352,
0.1973112375,
0.0297010317,
0.4850440621,
-0.7271491885,
0.6337120533,
0.8213951588,
0.8582513332,
0.0605821535,
0.0377998352,
0.9644790888,
-1.2854874134,
0.2439487576,
0.4686011076,
0.3822177351,
0.4175616205,
-0.4265868068,
0.7482423186,
0.1204662696,
-0.5616338849,
-0.783470571,
0.0404490232,
-0.8505553603,
-0.2004419416,
0.8294269443,
-0.0748774186,
0.0186816845,
-0.1079087257,
0.2995908558,
0.1770811975,
-0.241144672,
1.0052742958,
0.8076837063,
0.356985867,
-0.1412650794,
-0.266461283,
0.5955252051,
0.4728724062,
-1.1307256222,
-0.3321124911,
0.0315487571,
-0.1192676052,
0.4174011648,
0.3031536639,
0.0211410932,
0.0158782601,
-0.1012116298,
0.0004478263,
0.5928960443,
-0.5048691034,
-0.3511224985,
0.3915424645,
-0.5546979904,
0.0553728417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14881v1
|
A Study on the Vulnerability of Test Questions against ChatGPT-based Cheating
| 2024-02-21T23:51:06 | 2024-02-21T23:51:06 |
Shanker Ram, Chen Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, I.2.7
|
ChatGPT is a chatbot that can answer text prompts fairly accurately, even
performing very well on postgraduate-level questions. Many educators have found
that their take-home or remote tests and exams are vulnerable to ChatGPT-based
cheating because students may directly use answers provided by tools like
ChatGPT. In this paper, we try to provide an answer to an important question:
how well ChatGPT can answer test questions and how we can detect whether the
questions of a test can be answered correctly by ChatGPT. We generated
ChatGPT's responses to the MedMCQA dataset, which contains over 10,000 medical
school entrance exam questions. We analyzed the responses and uncovered certain
types of questions ChatGPT answers more inaccurately than others. In addition,
we have created a basic natural language processing model to single out the
most vulnerable questions to ChatGPT in a collection of questions or a sample
exam. Our tool can be used by test-makers to avoid ChatGPT-vulnerable test
questions.
|
[
-0.4678611159,
-1.2082483768,
0.3322149515,
-0.1796655208,
-0.0862818733,
0.0756559223,
0.193810463,
-0.2970333397,
-0.2840583324,
0.5161326528,
-0.7389379144,
0.0108730616,
-0.6940459013,
-0.0303829685,
-0.4075734317,
1.0765209198,
-0.0803342536,
0.3485102654,
-0.1733454764,
-0.1047266275,
-0.6130282879,
-0.6760957837,
-0.9029601216,
-0.1541857421,
0.4357767105,
0.4546168447,
0.7801930308,
-0.1405392438,
1.0276777744,
0.0916477367,
-0.0009944352,
-0.1671634614,
-0.4681468904,
-0.0097753173,
-0.1240280271,
-0.8138788342,
-0.3526934087,
0.1194613427,
0.021329781,
0.4194356203,
-0.097804904,
0.2898151875,
0.2897420228,
0.3584960997,
-0.3362879753,
0.017978454,
-0.7271512151,
0.0080909505,
-0.1994489431,
-0.1522583067,
-0.4398518205,
-0.6202407479,
0.0677259564,
-0.1085152552,
0.5156220198,
-0.2798461318,
0.888263762,
0.4416052699,
-0.5101132393,
-0.2918796837,
-0.5658852458,
0.3270780742,
-0.4503130317,
0.1020581573,
0.5725300908,
0.8265445828,
-0.4179211557,
-0.3793115914,
-0.2702414691,
-0.324834168,
-0.1738345027,
0.339343816,
0.0955570787,
0.2953538001,
0.2809630334,
0.522993803,
-1.1655392647,
-0.3998760581,
-0.31063959,
-0.4372280538,
0.2822206914,
0.0535530597,
0.702958703,
-0.0519607365,
-0.2689103782,
-0.19549568,
-0.5330129862,
0.1366810054,
0.2033835202,
0.0906197801,
0.2165419161,
0.8260464072,
0.2492943704,
0.6574129462,
-0.2739920318,
0.3378908634,
-0.3830489218,
-0.4181697667,
-0.0172080249,
0.0426025726,
0.6877775192,
0.1921938211,
0.5990044475,
0.0296796728,
0.0247400925,
0.4161012769,
0.3782395124,
-0.7159016728,
-0.5038251877,
0.4336921573,
-0.0846616477,
-0.3155736625,
-0.1957785338,
-0.8121253848,
-0.4219423532,
0.476593852,
0.7886027098,
-0.5138069987,
-0.0843404457,
0.0748368353,
-0.2429176569,
0.6662256122,
0.2531569302,
-0.4860922992,
0.6213053465,
0.6325370669,
0.7130794525,
0.0892487615,
-0.3302872777,
-0.6134008765,
-0.4675369263,
-0.1229432598,
0.797549963,
-0.2717232704,
-0.5645436645,
-0.2554782629,
0.0644996837,
-0.4165619612,
-0.4540029764,
0.4804648161,
-0.5683589578,
0.6797740459,
-0.2015232295,
-0.6043148041,
-0.0667495206,
0.5873706341,
-0.3660221696,
0.9578598142,
0.1310109645,
-0.9926242232,
0.0810008571,
-0.5859997272,
-0.1800703257,
-0.0468292832,
-0.1361390799,
-0.5764310956,
-0.5088966489,
0.2165742517,
0.2783967555,
-0.0826073661,
0.1603849083,
-0.095399484,
-0.5694715977,
0.7002746463,
-0.8477232456,
0.9250629544,
-0.0534715317,
-0.310855031,
-0.4400692284,
-0.3943843544,
0.2729619443,
0.2199906409,
-0.3552062213,
0.1083202139,
-0.0166599173,
-0.190084368,
0.0959218144,
-0.119714871,
-0.6544426084,
0.2726478875,
-0.256872952,
0.1277378798,
0.5730105639,
0.3638077676,
-0.018884629,
-0.4738663733,
0.886814177,
-0.0566002689,
0.375792563,
-0.0574339554,
-1.141059041,
-0.4082166851,
0.1110532954,
0.5805214643,
1.114145875,
-0.5416480899,
0.0934513211,
0.0427395664,
-0.9211788177,
-0.5573344231,
-0.15776214,
0.4458188117,
0.7876365185,
0.2403587103,
-0.5265248418,
0.0294868387,
-0.6714964509,
-0.5934645534,
-0.385063976,
-0.1673300862,
0.4360685349,
0.636480689,
0.0661808699,
0.695141077,
-0.7660626769,
0.0247436687,
0.0392635725,
-0.0849302188,
0.0813371763,
0.4836297035,
0.1684411913,
-0.9339309335,
-0.3891680837,
-0.3348943889,
-0.4168911278,
-0.0312896408,
-0.169087559,
-0.193279013,
-0.311666131,
0.282967031,
-0.5911192894,
0.4749292135,
0.5747936368,
-0.6234225631,
0.6373543143,
-0.0590991601,
0.2281036675,
-0.8923628926,
0.1135562733,
-0.3466463685,
-0.2245643139,
-0.7292309403,
0.1406351477,
0.1654487103,
-0.5011174083,
-0.3802249432,
0.4766032696,
0.0516813882,
0.3453406692,
-0.0442095324,
0.1559690386,
-0.2107236832,
0.3957579136,
-0.2907368243,
0.950068891,
0.4770408869,
-0.4906972349,
0.2228895426,
0.4890645742,
-0.0272205938,
0.4896385968,
-0.7991378307,
0.3319414258,
-0.0649138317,
0.3678525686,
-1.2545697689,
-0.4286767542,
0.689427495,
-0.9965433478,
0.034459997,
-0.4913724661,
-0.3321838975,
-0.1184036881,
-0.0791881457,
0.3662371933,
0.5774390101,
-0.278259635,
0.2959852517,
0.2356685102,
-0.0631924793,
-0.601020515,
-0.5799814463,
-0.1555794626,
-0.0787676126,
-0.778857708,
-0.2733348906,
-0.2292835563,
0.0117930537,
-0.0463406779,
-0.0941846967,
-0.5363674164,
0.3275602162,
0.4446810186,
0.3437666893,
-0.2162829041,
0.1996193379,
-0.3474231958,
-0.1600267738,
0.3172333837,
0.1740145683,
0.7207942605,
-0.1293526292,
-0.7807237506,
0.0625882298,
0.5363234878,
0.5536341667,
-0.2324408293,
0.5701900721,
0.5588690042,
-0.3337646723,
0.0253117867,
-0.2614651322,
-0.4949706495,
-0.4726751447,
0.282448113,
-0.2289069742,
-0.7367755175,
0.6161308885,
0.2026613653,
0.0737857297,
0.2033662051,
0.4576245546,
-0.0056625926,
1.0654348135,
0.1618742496,
-0.1244439706,
-0.0048465114,
0.0743525773,
0.2548186183,
-0.4163318574,
-0.1415432543,
-0.6542781591,
-0.0054724501,
-0.9404178858,
-0.4028115273,
0.4533349276,
-0.2805246413,
-0.2167712301,
0.2230598181,
-0.6327293515,
0.5584695935,
0.7178744674,
0.4454225302,
0.0948842391,
-0.6168304682,
0.0262914374,
0.1676954031,
-0.7011682987,
-0.4559195936,
1.0396479368,
0.2267653346,
0.85507828,
0.1310743243,
0.5378434658,
0.00595841,
0.047995314,
-0.6622414589,
0.5811203122,
0.3659514785,
-1.2511925697,
-0.3226860166,
-0.4261711836,
-0.9580160975,
0.1522813588,
0.2378452867,
-0.5638471842,
-0.2538074255,
0.0572324544,
-0.2298170328,
0.3063986599,
-1.0376343727,
0.9839754105,
-0.0659688562,
-0.0775761008,
0.4786399901,
-0.8034105301,
0.2944818139,
-0.1374660283,
-0.0295085553,
-0.1848016083,
0.1582856178,
0.6452323198,
-0.3974640369,
0.9060584903,
-0.1231875345,
0.1183660403,
0.575712502,
0.5151842237,
0.1972271055,
0.3393718004,
0.1707640141,
-0.1003671438,
0.3243505955,
-0.8672093153,
-0.644626677,
0.296259433,
-0.6682834625,
-0.6337110996,
-0.6633247733,
-0.2761633396,
-0.5604195595,
0.0608683638,
0.52894485,
0.3819083571,
-0.2148882598,
-0.4507620633,
0.8720225096,
-0.3126541376,
0.1324950606,
0.1756509393,
-0.1310444027,
0.1859181076,
0.7056316733,
0.0451626703,
0.5875096321,
0.1010781452,
0.3358474672,
-0.0887355357,
-0.3315458596,
-0.5333260298,
0.2600701451,
-0.7394266129,
-0.1063363627,
-0.3827332854,
-0.652500689,
-0.2337663472,
-0.1705117971,
-0.3099433184,
-0.3904547691,
0.1554539949,
0.0045790668,
0.3101801276,
0.3859212995,
0.2662073374,
0.2713491321,
-0.939855814,
0.2133890688,
0.7464143038,
0.3054998517,
-0.5858509541,
-0.4114819467,
0.494969368,
0.0708143339,
-0.3163605332,
-1.2301676273,
-0.1106105223,
0.0933510587,
0.3479601443,
0.1225628778,
0.0541881844,
0.367212534,
-0.3791080415,
1.1545007229,
-0.4653558433,
-0.5395711064,
0.7632679343,
-0.5504795313,
0.3348247707,
0.8246631026,
0.4552648962,
-0.9300028682,
-0.6903849244,
-0.9192848206,
-0.3915479481,
0.2889546752,
0.5361303091,
0.4068211615,
0.2503944635,
0.3215339482,
0.1141479611,
-0.0346830301,
-0.736954391,
-0.252384603,
-0.0135079948,
-0.0474912859,
-0.0415682755,
-0.0880577788,
-0.205223009,
-0.0141713209,
0.4979481399,
0.0312718563,
0.5310754776,
0.4066269696,
0.1407814473,
0.2432505488,
0.3614773154,
0.323859781,
0.3522226214,
-0.4893555939,
0.2893972397,
0.2929402888,
-1.1902449131,
0.2089550793,
0.0027989028,
0.0090349959,
0.0449891165,
0.3713926077,
-0.0863802955,
-0.1427975744,
-0.8410827518,
0.8575763106,
-0.5320836902,
-0.2258333713,
-0.2437731624,
0.4464780092,
-0.0457972549,
-0.2049160153,
-0.023192456,
0.2604100108,
0.0892910063,
-0.4655160308,
0.6602454185,
0.3588490486,
-0.8195287585,
-0.0936565623,
0.7641454339,
-0.0312158968,
-0.5564836264,
0.8409822583,
-0.0257088728,
-1.0634243488,
0.8547432423,
0.4488526881,
0.4810613394,
-0.5474901199,
0.5342724323,
0.3725298643,
0.4243000746,
0.1501466185,
0.6231265664,
0.2151120454,
-0.6285762787,
-0.2643982768,
-0.0250537619,
-1.1107947826,
-0.1243214533,
-0.4947926402,
0.2301198393,
-0.3047817647,
-0.0566290282,
-0.1103714332,
-0.1693234891,
-0.4518083632,
0.4244152904,
-0.0266386587,
0.9294458628,
-0.6129108071,
0.4837213159,
0.4952760339,
-0.1896104366,
-0.9361001253,
0.1955124289,
0.1484077275,
-1.0786005259,
0.1114552617,
0.0785359368,
0.0607979335,
-0.1510886252,
-0.6493533254,
-0.3358980715,
0.6093385816,
0.2235108465,
0.0186475646,
0.081764698,
0.6775047183,
0.4094486237,
0.5572209358,
0.6766030788,
0.4034636915,
0.3547817767,
-0.0881837308,
-1.0244394541,
0.0676773265,
-0.3431805372,
-0.6727118492,
0.3899459541,
-0.6210176349,
0.7272769213,
-0.0435911119,
-0.003304472,
-0.2763940394,
-0.3759003282,
0.1983857155,
0.4046636224,
0.2955012321,
0.2366924435,
0.8178036809,
-0.3534657359,
1.182814002,
0.0057414118,
0.3805820644,
0.8941813111,
0.0938612223,
0.5804725885,
0.5090928078,
-0.2463699728,
-0.0328315496,
0.8137120008,
-0.0238762237,
0.3832396865,
0.4912003875,
-0.3080669045,
-0.238444075,
0.1746641695,
-0.3214770257,
0.6619130969,
0.157858476,
0.0518283285,
-0.3084772527,
-0.0692446902,
0.3839859366,
-0.2265173644,
-0.0027038893,
0.487488538,
0.1471491903,
-0.8086403608,
0.4194013476,
-0.3378371298,
0.1895347089,
-0.6335897446,
-0.0859557316,
-0.3478957713,
0.1930627078,
0.0254876968,
-0.9469736218,
0.2313269377,
0.0064662229,
0.5090927482,
0.1582235396,
0.9782142639,
-0.0582807176,
-0.4647735357,
-0.0759585574,
0.7854182124,
0.3418237269,
-0.5607424974,
-0.7746587396,
-0.4769069552,
-0.0707002059,
-0.1448495686,
0.2257029563,
0.2596513927,
0.200184226,
1.0311822891,
0.345726788,
0.0375660136,
0.3510677814,
-0.3939201534,
0.6744526029,
-0.4487068653,
-0.1770482212,
-0.9652360082,
0.4433280528,
-0.0128031876,
-0.4776439071,
0.8203505874,
0.515863955,
0.6890749931,
0.14923805,
0.7473711371,
0.0612844341,
0.6760365367,
-0.3474125862,
0.9541044831,
-0.1232380643,
0.1325600743,
-0.3052623868,
-0.4650908113,
-0.2813984454,
0.2540993094,
-0.2201670855,
-0.0899665356,
0.7683212757,
1.0015294552,
-0.1244028807,
0.276026994,
0.3264792562,
-0.1911408603,
0.5190188885,
0.8438344598,
0.9736433625,
-0.806938529,
1.0512125492,
-0.3370147645,
-0.2059552073,
-0.0140476236,
-0.3249863088,
-1.0796333551,
-0.5251544118,
-0.3778900802,
-0.6345511079,
0.2714980245,
0.2274551839,
0.258518815,
-0.7700656652,
0.0421762653,
-0.0528334938,
0.1553918421,
-0.1647273898,
-0.2432033569,
0.5559176207,
-0.0436068736,
-0.4382141829,
-0.0824637786,
-0.1347502619,
0.1965595782,
-0.0067804838,
0.4056301415,
0.2035205066,
0.2307428718,
-0.0290093869,
0.1723162532,
-0.0417033248,
-0.686190486,
0.3929384351,
-0.3228293955,
0.2988294959,
0.7062357664,
-0.4725183249,
0.3474475145,
0.3696331382,
0.7117949724,
0.1005777642,
0.1284433603,
0.4611803293,
-0.5003234148,
-0.110503763,
0.6623260975,
0.0565444902,
0.0158731956,
-0.6178874969,
0.6914206147,
0.0732685179,
-0.9605305791,
-0.638964057,
0.1321039051,
-1.1805095673,
-0.2841463685,
1.1066390276,
-0.152272284,
-0.1104645729,
-0.4621185362,
-0.7163727283,
0.1942646354,
-0.0628482848,
0.987432301,
0.9822067618,
-0.291875869,
-0.0930458754,
-1.1701213121,
0.5700260997,
0.5949077606,
-0.9015949368,
-0.0845604315,
-0.0814199671,
0.4273836315,
-0.0222289078,
0.7659602165,
-0.2887297869,
0.570715487,
0.2626836598,
-0.292178005,
0.2670033276,
0.2586413622,
-0.2446945012,
0.2348196954,
0.2330616862,
-0.721742332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16611v2
|
Understanding the Dataset Practitioners Behind Large Language Model Development
| 2024-02-21T23:50:37 | 2024-04-01T19:58:43 |
Crystal Qian, Emily Reif, Minsuk Kahng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
As large language models (LLMs) become more advanced and impactful, it is
increasingly important to scrutinize the data that they rely upon and produce.
What is it to be a dataset practitioner doing this work? We approach this in
two parts: first, we define the role of "dataset practitioners" by performing a
retrospective analysis on the responsibilities of teams contributing to LLM
development at a technology company, Google. Then, we conduct semi-structured
interviews with a cross-section of these practitioners (N=10). We find that
although data quality is a top priority, there is little consensus around what
data quality is and how to evaluate it. Consequently, practitioners either rely
on their own intuition or write custom code to evaluate their data. We discuss
potential reasons for this phenomenon and opportunities for alignment.
|
[
-0.3382619023,
-0.3714284003,
0.3637340963,
-0.1292250454,
0.1301598549,
0.203724727,
-0.227208063,
-0.4137086272,
-0.0464206338,
0.6776899695,
-0.742372334,
-0.4908967912,
-0.4008138478,
0.0294838548,
-0.792945087,
1.0423237085,
-0.0087359045,
0.0755733401,
-0.2831800282,
0.0273452122,
-0.4889131188,
-0.3429082036,
-0.5817494988,
-0.4301548302,
0.5056934357,
0.5615457892,
0.979680717,
0.868896246,
0.5528369546,
0.2054796815,
-0.0904289186,
-0.2597694397,
-1.0141727924,
0.2772509754,
-0.2109221369,
-0.5119147897,
-0.1936273426,
0.0050230687,
0.5888162851,
1.2047578096,
-0.3349535763,
0.4814751446,
-0.0388770476,
0.7092615962,
-0.3237793446,
0.1888300478,
-0.4010100663,
0.1753654331,
-0.3246988356,
-0.1451145113,
-0.2148039043,
-0.4140254557,
0.0152271995,
-0.3925934732,
0.3119266927,
-0.0295696948,
0.5335772038,
0.3635833859,
-0.423825711,
-0.2058601379,
-0.8969738483,
0.7958664894,
-0.6383591294,
0.2612951994,
0.265909493,
0.3725005686,
-0.5258105993,
-0.3578906357,
-0.4892880619,
0.204030022,
0.1958527267,
-0.1356992573,
0.4770785272,
-0.1324634552,
0.2831270397,
0.9162304401,
-0.5660239458,
0.4586159885,
-0.4338746369,
0.0349808708,
0.9920343757,
0.3687330186,
0.1463525742,
0.3467610776,
0.0054401192,
0.1711140871,
-1.1824128628,
-0.3022763133,
0.4260014594,
0.3323224187,
0.0443047285,
0.5832462311,
-0.0149133075,
1.0052427053,
-0.3321492076,
-0.103486836,
0.010985964,
-0.3087079823,
-0.1797453165,
0.1430574358,
0.3855504096,
0.3172438145,
0.7771469355,
-0.2399095297,
-0.4223144948,
-0.3285091519,
0.6080828309,
-0.5371259451,
-0.0853160173,
0.4313257635,
-0.5506289005,
-0.3714158237,
0.0771382079,
-0.5405992866,
-0.8324315548,
-0.7169432044,
-0.0949192047,
0.2017375827,
-0.5759795308,
0.0978255942,
-0.1503624022,
0.35267362,
0.333712846,
-0.958202064,
0.3912957013,
1.0929056406,
0.3680274189,
0.0561056025,
-0.4386418462,
-0.3323157132,
0.3107708991,
-0.907092154,
0.5604623556,
-0.3451626897,
-0.4863751829,
0.2093485892,
-0.10538923,
0.1743820757,
-0.5877124071,
0.25345245,
-0.4971165955,
0.0739024803,
-0.4896664619,
-0.7847041488,
-0.0036046016,
0.322075367,
-0.5932593346,
0.9528366327,
0.3778424561,
-0.6427634358,
0.7621727586,
-0.1828244627,
-0.3892025352,
0.3622049093,
-0.432649076,
0.0837582499,
0.4033834934,
-0.1305680424,
0.5788151622,
-0.5034175515,
0.4230225086,
-0.4166908562,
-0.5354040861,
0.416624248,
0.034040615,
0.6276212335,
0.2960714698,
0.0532972887,
-0.1211329028,
-0.7808000445,
-0.0022197238,
-0.0103044165,
-0.3254696727,
-0.1764704436,
0.345631808,
0.0281951986,
0.2120834142,
-0.1806222796,
-0.1534194797,
0.2691138685,
-0.0111603402,
0.3404402137,
0.7286453843,
0.0232350845,
0.2352180928,
-0.2815328538,
0.6024380326,
-0.4060424566,
0.4015812278,
0.0508847609,
-0.3415536582,
-0.5771253109,
0.1154673323,
0.5202667713,
0.0965542868,
-0.6428017616,
0.3942193985,
-0.6066272259,
-0.607203424,
-0.6609694362,
0.6226918697,
0.0574524477,
0.5137016773,
-0.2330251485,
-0.4208786488,
-0.3638712466,
-0.8306344748,
-0.1438965946,
-0.0474649929,
0.0724488348,
0.2353586704,
0.4863993526,
-0.120675303,
1.1789758205,
-0.4088253975,
-0.0284991283,
-0.6246587634,
-0.2142447084,
0.7223182321,
0.3774271011,
0.4252712429,
-0.8282122612,
-0.437377423,
-0.1798504889,
-0.8846063614,
-0.2594281733,
-0.1892770529,
0.0311311018,
0.0305113476,
0.6487998366,
-0.4945814013,
0.1238128766,
0.6446883082,
-0.2816379964,
0.4605998397,
0.08532013,
-0.1461869776,
-0.8681502342,
0.3178907335,
0.2893873453,
-0.1302708536,
-0.8865825534,
0.1502806991,
-0.1838644445,
-0.2125373781,
-0.3274475336,
0.5368850231,
-0.4239197671,
-0.6531218886,
-0.177437067,
0.0154153574,
-0.0695953444,
-0.2460860163,
-0.0693785623,
0.9161064029,
0.6947972775,
-0.7903605103,
0.4574752152,
0.2353069037,
-0.8562358618,
0.6959962249,
-0.7052778006,
0.0513486043,
0.0568620078,
0.1265863776,
-0.7682844996,
-0.3051599264,
-0.0489057675,
-0.38750422,
0.5826153755,
-0.4735730588,
-1.0949547291,
-0.7183856964,
0.0362714417,
0.1052732691,
0.2320936322,
-0.5313771367,
0.0324686579,
0.8515316248,
-0.3939575851,
-0.5110996366,
-1.0050424337,
0.4453848004,
-0.2452994734,
-0.7657985091,
0.0166917369,
0.202957347,
-0.6559253931,
-0.1040607914,
-0.1272283196,
-0.1955018193,
0.4346263707,
-0.0002676409,
0.025151426,
-0.2113800049,
0.2601957023,
-0.3711623251,
-0.2925231159,
0.1796935946,
-0.0521727949,
0.5484064221,
0.3694041371,
-0.4243891835,
-0.2377769798,
0.286067009,
0.2319927812,
-0.002751821,
0.6664782166,
0.1676400006,
-0.1127801985,
-0.2823446989,
-0.6484305859,
0.099244222,
-0.4983848929,
0.1610697359,
-0.2367196232,
-0.671253264,
0.6482287049,
0.2000453323,
0.0642442182,
0.383648634,
0.5179075003,
-0.1915874332,
0.6959201097,
0.7228141427,
-0.4141605794,
0.3045435846,
-0.3692801893,
0.2143295407,
-0.6372095942,
-0.0406509265,
-0.4066225588,
-0.2796099484,
-0.5476005673,
-0.1462683976,
0.1109560281,
-0.0845447034,
-0.3419338465,
0.0904189199,
-0.391982168,
0.5806732178,
0.4356074929,
-0.2828216851,
0.1301427335,
-0.2515313327,
0.5765773654,
0.1542102545,
-0.6835109591,
-0.6513938308,
1.1447466612,
0.5783160925,
1.2360783815,
0.0847095847,
0.5941892266,
0.3021616042,
0.0805389732,
-0.8148570657,
0.6703874469,
-0.1395477951,
-0.7948923707,
-0.0638454184,
-0.4212781191,
-0.8380476832,
-0.0135361599,
0.1886570156,
-0.5203269124,
0.1099096611,
0.0112425694,
-0.124378182,
0.0325319842,
-0.5896216631,
0.8752812743,
-0.3344973326,
-0.3929425478,
-0.1789280176,
-0.5740863681,
0.2057920247,
0.0374095775,
0.3261962235,
0.015724808,
0.0530891195,
0.7721807957,
-0.3661784828,
0.8133149147,
-0.3433794379,
-0.5554485321,
0.4547426999,
0.0477196015,
0.1634149402,
0.0041860496,
-0.2477908134,
-0.0030631896,
0.0804042146,
-0.4409524202,
-0.3988988996,
0.6793734431,
-0.5275673866,
-0.639827013,
-0.4044525623,
-0.5730608106,
-0.3130185902,
0.2389332205,
-0.1488067955,
0.3986332417,
-0.3738660514,
0.2682238817,
0.651958704,
-0.0839444622,
0.3258016407,
0.3344911635,
-0.321644932,
-0.0603357702,
0.675575316,
0.2815877497,
0.3882547319,
0.0821504816,
0.0758632571,
-0.1499671489,
-0.7145146132,
-0.3454740345,
0.2127166539,
-0.8339202404,
0.1963213831,
-0.1478203386,
-0.1400096864,
-0.3200545311,
-0.0939371586,
-0.3522600234,
-0.296823293,
-0.1386487931,
-0.1192203686,
0.2495204657,
1.0710448027,
0.1988509148,
0.4821205437,
-0.6347312331,
0.0092027588,
0.1090223342,
0.3959191442,
-0.0634807646,
-0.2306508273,
-0.4681994915,
0.0834961683,
0.0351249129,
-0.4537028074,
0.2857561111,
-0.0829013884,
0.7032616138,
0.4374802709,
-0.3200385273,
0.5440855622,
-0.2175095826,
0.9869475365,
-0.2420280129,
-0.7679267526,
0.46927917,
-0.6155381203,
0.0862739682,
0.8579508066,
0.2200693339,
-0.999928534,
-0.1706879139,
-0.3815645278,
-0.6917507648,
0.7595402002,
-0.0389661305,
0.3156380355,
0.2758969367,
0.5404824018,
0.340501368,
0.6199912429,
-0.3846336007,
-0.2137565017,
0.0863716453,
-0.2026368678,
-0.4627974927,
-0.37660864,
-0.4887137115,
-0.0998146385,
0.3334502876,
-0.1840304732,
0.0847306922,
-0.4293911457,
-0.1831240654,
-0.030800648,
0.1523397565,
0.296369791,
1.26166749,
0.0286805648,
-0.0362053141,
-0.2614482045,
-0.2958086133,
-0.0420906693,
0.0117096659,
-0.1342789531,
-0.1157599911,
0.5047779083,
0.5123584867,
0.0645616502,
-0.4286105931,
0.5071471334,
0.1012433693,
-0.0499555729,
-0.4135730565,
0.3683107793,
0.1612008065,
-0.0051450129,
0.4465543628,
-0.5865911245,
0.0986683592,
-0.8207274079,
0.1596580893,
0.2106353045,
-0.2383601815,
-0.249963358,
0.1959615201,
0.2695700824,
-0.2485764772,
0.9326363802,
0.1073463932,
-0.4832998216,
0.9131088853,
0.3175771534,
0.6780776381,
-0.2253193408,
0.2544752359,
-0.1232099608,
0.0669233575,
-0.3357813656,
0.6747213006,
0.1870877147,
-0.6737197042,
-0.5817284584,
-0.2651336193,
-0.6156178713,
0.0491676442,
-0.8141971827,
0.3128906786,
-0.1844799817,
0.0206162203,
-0.0592728294,
0.18587327,
-0.6926384568,
0.3939041793,
0.1013209224,
1.0250883102,
-0.9303439856,
0.7152691483,
0.5085580945,
-0.2805747986,
-0.4295775294,
0.1155287251,
0.2754021585,
-1.0195754766,
0.6829534769,
0.1113042906,
0.3928432167,
0.021942459,
-0.4764931202,
-0.8534098268,
1.0069198608,
0.1319610924,
-0.5876333117,
0.0673692971,
0.3523158729,
0.7690648437,
-0.3885405958,
0.127805233,
0.4969103932,
0.4145987034,
0.0080980314,
-0.8056675196,
-0.165066883,
-0.1654648781,
0.217028141,
0.2176481038,
-0.5436495543,
0.606965065,
-0.035283789,
-0.0993388742,
-0.0644463748,
0.1072198898,
0.0208906606,
0.0923543051,
0.2231859565,
0.4720062017,
0.7633625865,
-0.1107913852,
1.353286624,
-0.3938390613,
0.4064083695,
1.3131822348,
-0.4618002772,
0.5883525014,
0.6527365446,
-0.3661090136,
0.0485811569,
1.0884180069,
-0.5015566349,
0.4468917847,
0.5857211351,
-0.023041876,
-0.1440688819,
-0.1570550799,
-0.5009928346,
0.4172687829,
0.5025574565,
-0.4968734384,
-0.1907171458,
-0.2904775441,
-0.0608155765,
-0.1567932665,
-0.4502671361,
0.8342772126,
0.1449674964,
-0.5687766671,
0.2677251101,
-0.4606758654,
0.0813023224,
-0.3385338187,
0.2922977209,
-0.2128508091,
0.4788302779,
-0.3766570687,
-1.5273845196,
0.4712140262,
-0.0109834671,
-0.0675463006,
-0.4701073468,
0.3232853115,
-0.3328668773,
-0.3927972019,
0.1186406612,
0.5515133142,
0.3508062959,
-0.0422274582,
-0.6781224608,
0.3879330158,
-0.4030410647,
-0.3584752977,
0.2670145035,
0.474647522,
0.1000553444,
0.8742474914,
0.1802760512,
0.4109530449,
-0.1813590676,
0.5554853678,
0.9224562049,
-0.7006651163,
-0.1857617348,
-0.7713103294,
0.4595267475,
-0.2070789933,
-0.4563571215,
0.8500984311,
0.7131772637,
0.8198975921,
0.0884493068,
0.819093585,
-0.1095946655,
0.5849523544,
-0.5048276186,
0.8260564804,
-0.3824496269,
0.3874900341,
-0.1170996726,
-1.0945372581,
-0.3819979429,
0.3658264577,
-0.4275583923,
0.1786812544,
0.3555294275,
0.7610890269,
0.0355194844,
0.1625367552,
0.0726860017,
0.2269806415,
0.6758038402,
0.2655848861,
0.992759943,
-0.2282970697,
0.2183598876,
-0.2175442129,
-0.0096115582,
-0.0356428102,
-0.7418018579,
-0.7856812477,
-0.3702753186,
-0.4596581161,
-0.2508613169,
-0.0692628101,
0.5550323725,
0.6434245706,
-0.7355058789,
-0.6844850183,
-0.333006084,
0.1333543658,
0.0085004689,
-0.2067294568,
0.0754797384,
-0.3479324877,
-0.5123462677,
0.3079050183,
0.0847510323,
-0.1207282022,
-0.5437917113,
0.1275242418,
0.0180480964,
-0.3196375668,
0.2695325613,
0.2790907025,
-0.4296278358,
-0.1255824417,
-0.2682911158,
-0.2043375224,
-0.0049505862,
0.9319502711,
-0.3964423835,
0.5556144118,
0.329659313,
0.7497168779,
0.424716562,
-0.0281156413,
1.0366541147,
-0.5566876531,
-0.1641465575,
0.1653047204,
0.2859598994,
0.6248824,
-0.4611091316,
0.9440395236,
0.0943815559,
-0.8112323284,
-1.104861021,
0.1721347272,
-0.5875327587,
-0.0625213385,
1.429049015,
-0.0111299874,
-0.169337824,
-0.2791239917,
-0.0354803987,
-0.1070785224,
-0.0906976759,
0.6166538,
0.8664298058,
0.0264001004,
-0.2718991041,
-0.8873685598,
0.3841553926,
-0.1284714639,
-0.8327419162,
0.2207982093,
0.5171498656,
0.3350551426,
-0.029931061,
0.6220595241,
-0.0052627246,
0.0134748956,
0.0218768306,
0.0548307933,
0.1736894399,
-0.3486710191,
-0.4831471443,
-0.1576962918,
0.3580312729,
-0.007302857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14179v1
|
Bangla AI: A Framework for Machine Translation Utilizing Large Language Models for Ethnic Media
| 2024-02-21T23:43:04 | 2024-02-21T23:43:04 |
MD Ashraful Goni, Fahad Mostafa, Kerk F. Kee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ethnic media, which caters to diaspora communities in host nations, serves as
a vital platform for these communities to both produce content and access
information. Rather than utilizing the language of the host nation, ethnic
media delivers news in the language of the immigrant community. For instance,
in the USA, Bangla ethnic media presents news in Bangla rather than English.
This research delves into the prospective integration of large language models
(LLM) and multi-lingual machine translations (MMT) within the ethnic media
industry. It centers on the transformative potential of using LLM in MMT in
various facets of news translation, searching, and categorization. The paper
outlines a theoretical framework elucidating the integration of LLM and MMT
into the news searching and translation processes for ethnic media.
Additionally, it briefly addresses the potential ethical challenges associated
with the incorporation of LLM and MMT in news translation procedures.
|
[
-0.2611301243,
-0.5795779824,
0.5242764354,
0.2991732359,
-0.3274517953,
0.4552416801,
-0.2816096544,
-0.5396066308,
0.2778042555,
0.5784159899,
-0.2659887969,
-0.1606687605,
-0.7926129699,
0.2343360037,
-0.4754628241,
0.9525065422,
-0.2731752098,
0.3518204093,
0.4322834313,
-0.133940503,
-0.4077400863,
-0.4253522158,
-0.2293817699,
-0.1529125273,
0.5651238561,
0.2239462882,
0.810744226,
0.7663408518,
0.775308907,
0.2483247221,
0.0212017205,
0.1938619167,
-0.492644906,
-0.1548101753,
-0.2668959498,
-0.6446698308,
-0.071797438,
0.2700143158,
0.7381587625,
0.6982696056,
0.1475156695,
0.4343189001,
-0.1140609756,
0.7515465617,
-0.5242134929,
-0.0336752385,
-0.6514822841,
0.0427316539,
-0.2010966986,
-0.3898706436,
-0.4135147333,
-0.6158896089,
-0.37485075,
-0.0415054336,
-0.3169759214,
0.1288046241,
0.6819032431,
0.4045933187,
-0.9684926271,
-0.4488359392,
-1.0304485559,
0.6537992358,
-0.6203987002,
0.534140408,
0.3582297862,
0.4676736593,
-0.266110599,
-0.0703858733,
-0.8178824782,
-0.1145470291,
0.0573296323,
0.0425158367,
0.0346470624,
-0.0304585472,
-0.2190845907,
0.5416437387,
-0.5286585093,
0.3261639774,
-0.8366295695,
0.1298868656,
0.7564222217,
0.1383650005,
0.429623723,
-0.2864472866,
-0.1730595231,
0.4589870274,
-0.7532558441,
-0.1973114014,
0.5566077232,
0.6196910739,
-0.1277085394,
0.9153103232,
-0.0239772573,
0.7851208448,
-0.1261110604,
-0.6095308065,
0.2474165559,
-0.4121635556,
-0.2006647736,
0.2476328462,
0.559930861,
0.4461812079,
0.025459582,
-0.0186359268,
-0.0554883853,
-0.0080141257,
0.1576273888,
-0.9047427177,
0.5322637558,
0.2053481489,
-0.9088264108,
-0.2054522485,
0.0365784615,
-0.6602793336,
-0.418182373,
-0.4925580621,
0.2797513306,
-0.0905610695,
-0.4067526162,
0.1051978543,
0.1190909818,
0.4748628438,
0.3250855207,
-0.8926377296,
-0.1756540388,
0.5768044591,
0.6612790227,
0.0900530592,
-0.0303317271,
-0.3122469187,
0.4406056404,
-0.6400319934,
0.3939962387,
-0.7380250692,
-0.3996731043,
0.2490113825,
-0.1006715521,
-0.0780489072,
-0.4355383813,
0.311653167,
-0.8868737817,
-0.1299746931,
-0.0240890831,
-0.3247142434,
-0.6525056362,
0.0249047447,
-0.5798611641,
0.4757007957,
0.1770861894,
-0.3399152458,
0.4401992559,
-0.6374556422,
-0.5698830485,
-0.0077135889,
-0.0678498596,
-0.2348025739,
0.2586544752,
-0.0298723634,
0.5169740915,
-0.4024412632,
0.3883143961,
-0.2545441687,
-0.5918939114,
0.3358920217,
-0.4127813578,
0.9889142513,
0.5409708619,
-0.3131725788,
-0.1974445581,
-0.6725350618,
-0.5023796558,
-0.0032787782,
-0.6770247221,
-0.3806727827,
0.010976701,
0.3565255404,
0.3363472819,
0.194557339,
-0.4600844681,
0.3670966625,
0.0270163994,
0.4047430158,
0.5057864189,
-0.3085934818,
0.4737409651,
-0.060609743,
0.4910046756,
0.0063566696,
-0.1052659974,
-0.3718820214,
-0.4486764669,
-0.4911232889,
-0.2337986976,
0.413172096,
0.8826444149,
-0.5194112659,
0.3278464973,
-0.3182518482,
-0.4298524559,
-1.129633069,
0.2964373827,
-0.0112019833,
0.1282709241,
0.2875250876,
-0.0804188177,
-0.6242666245,
-0.9983244538,
0.0375825502,
-0.375226289,
0.1302540749,
0.1337429285,
0.2840460241,
-0.6499124169,
0.7545590401,
0.1570584774,
-0.2657226622,
-0.4013721049,
0.3604480326,
0.4331482649,
0.367503792,
0.3889825642,
-1.4494013786,
-0.5618915558,
0.6982576847,
-0.8332495689,
-0.170614332,
-0.3105336726,
0.1368058771,
0.2522240877,
0.475181222,
-0.5646041036,
0.7982165813,
0.8215973377,
-0.0012880162,
0.5874167681,
0.1184674725,
0.7784170508,
-1.5004373789,
-0.0136413528,
-0.1176513135,
-0.2221676409,
-0.5914513469,
0.288643986,
-0.0636065751,
-0.2529154122,
-0.3701800108,
0.574995935,
-0.3843046725,
-0.3272733986,
-0.4995290637,
-0.0411873013,
-0.24005799,
0.0258095581,
-0.1617670208,
0.8927055597,
0.1281152219,
-0.4935751855,
0.4402677715,
0.239062503,
-0.4378129244,
0.7280529737,
-0.2662422657,
-0.1712734699,
-0.2282970548,
0.3507495522,
-0.7442714572,
-0.4071482718,
0.3261045814,
-0.5870369077,
0.303018719,
-0.1481776386,
-0.8107544184,
-0.3132890761,
0.082449086,
0.58995682,
0.526396811,
-0.3392325938,
0.5089812279,
0.4681364596,
-0.4393311739,
-0.6493768692,
-1.0746583939,
0.6117348075,
-0.6201471686,
-0.7709017992,
0.0444897339,
-0.0646102503,
-0.4815831184,
0.0809440762,
0.3809657395,
-0.3696223497,
0.0576732457,
-0.0535738021,
0.0933751762,
-0.5324382186,
-0.0916438103,
0.1363776475,
0.0391138867,
-0.2951455116,
-0.2696536183,
0.3144930899,
0.0801083669,
-0.3356632888,
-0.5746646523,
1.0559313297,
0.8717188239,
-0.550912261,
0.9629927278,
0.8798561692,
-0.3001904786,
0.248156026,
-0.8553430438,
0.0417411067,
-0.3639156818,
0.464838177,
-0.2562255263,
-1.0798472166,
0.6183058023,
-0.1565764844,
-0.1645729095,
0.2174001336,
1.0203858614,
-0.0522692241,
1.1880606413,
0.9896301031,
-0.2663531303,
0.3202746809,
0.1740189344,
0.7226272821,
-0.7708516121,
-0.0407678001,
-0.5162337422,
-0.410895586,
-0.8554537296,
-0.5244353414,
0.3650882542,
-0.0712053701,
0.0383207276,
0.3501053154,
-0.2240647525,
0.4196125269,
0.5580648184,
-0.343731463,
0.6560668945,
-0.0870330036,
0.2980701923,
-0.0853761658,
-0.4024588168,
-0.6653422117,
0.7019047141,
0.4463644922,
0.8499820828,
0.360036999,
0.7140994072,
0.3403369486,
0.4526416361,
-0.857372582,
0.3046384752,
-0.2562355697,
-0.9397242069,
-0.0770638511,
-0.3886175156,
-0.86439991,
0.3130039871,
0.090802148,
-0.769235611,
0.4980019927,
-0.3016965389,
-0.1042808071,
0.5994647741,
-0.4964154959,
0.5091668963,
-0.3066984713,
0.0027284645,
-0.5555036068,
-0.7262132764,
0.6385886669,
-0.5897896886,
0.6437931061,
-0.1967422068,
-0.0069615375,
0.2658482492,
0.1713192016,
0.7487368584,
0.3180850744,
-0.0798101351,
0.220055908,
0.0651832893,
0.0515157916,
-0.1728133261,
-0.2561623454,
0.3690381944,
-0.25937289,
-0.3765060902,
-0.3625032008,
0.2719062865,
-0.693970561,
-0.5705491304,
-0.1649079472,
-1.0634542704,
0.1208568886,
0.3362171352,
-0.0376477912,
0.0805452093,
0.0681974366,
0.5254378319,
0.3756382167,
-0.2105777115,
0.2334286273,
0.5881800056,
-0.4556352198,
-0.0409932658,
0.9892234206,
0.2174483687,
0.0755241886,
0.4595975578,
0.0522148795,
-0.0560887866,
-0.7539104819,
-0.8706055284,
0.2760253251,
-0.6703771353,
-0.1762695014,
-0.4722258151,
-0.2324948907,
-0.309895575,
-0.5051076412,
-0.2528575957,
-0.0938233137,
-0.1403079331,
-0.0591637976,
-0.0601258352,
0.9055215716,
-0.2106664032,
0.4789544344,
-0.9225597978,
0.312189281,
0.0514444336,
0.1684837937,
-0.435166955,
-0.581043601,
-0.6393588185,
0.1709711999,
-0.1576993614,
-1.0963613987,
0.291995585,
-0.2154947221,
0.5539379716,
0.230214715,
-0.2973284423,
0.5943495631,
-0.9742854238,
0.5714583993,
0.0615498722,
-0.7497702241,
0.3140645921,
-0.7216599584,
-0.1169795543,
0.6087121964,
0.754365921,
-0.8595560193,
-0.5180695057,
0.0888359323,
-0.6594603658,
0.272932142,
-0.0997794345,
0.5187851787,
-0.0236708429,
0.0449006706,
0.220653981,
0.4612154365,
-1.0174871683,
0.0741655827,
0.0812710002,
-0.1609520465,
0.0878166407,
-0.2146745473,
0.1093500406,
-0.1787279695,
0.5731577873,
0.0388429202,
0.2753303349,
-0.0369616188,
-0.3235450685,
-0.2963094711,
0.3373938501,
0.4121179581,
0.7526305914,
-0.167628184,
-0.2899079025,
-0.4265089929,
-0.0080070728,
0.3361925781,
0.2260531932,
-0.344986707,
0.0752189457,
0.0387225226,
0.6656169891,
0.0644603521,
-0.5652159452,
0.2549755275,
0.2773087919,
-0.05191762,
-0.1243765503,
-0.3709143698,
0.125890255,
0.4604513645,
0.7537431717,
-0.2193658054,
0.3774749339,
-0.9109976292,
0.1668428332,
0.380030334,
-0.1164210141,
-0.1133105382,
0.7852537036,
0.3099503815,
-0.4351678193,
0.4329928756,
-0.1973948479,
-0.5773152709,
0.3585766256,
0.5971090794,
0.7788041234,
-0.7857955098,
0.3124102354,
0.1967383921,
0.5880212784,
0.1254182309,
-0.1244273111,
0.347035408,
-0.6102195382,
-0.8240286708,
-0.7699480653,
-0.3314704001,
-0.0452557802,
-0.3913255632,
0.3435200155,
0.0280151144,
0.0590308309,
-0.042884361,
-0.1652682275,
-0.3588268459,
0.1002523527,
0.5012795329,
0.7671313882,
-0.8680462837,
0.8160946965,
0.5845096707,
-0.6564502716,
-0.729739964,
0.1020781547,
0.2399265915,
-0.9302121997,
0.7950155139,
0.2377983332,
0.0092357965,
-0.0450987183,
-0.2574028373,
-0.6966058612,
0.7312553525,
0.2851638198,
-0.1566752791,
-0.0415631309,
0.4732834995,
0.3199008405,
-0.7550361156,
-0.1305263937,
0.5484752655,
0.7763054371,
0.0653682128,
-1.2249120474,
-0.3003799319,
-0.1747202426,
0.0841490775,
0.2191597968,
-0.750877142,
0.8171796203,
-0.1646329165,
0.0949139073,
0.0939716026,
0.6319236159,
-0.0923860669,
0.4145678878,
0.063721925,
0.0666256696,
0.4224258363,
0.2020760179,
1.1791616678,
-0.1351852268,
-0.0360549502,
0.4875904024,
-0.2143660337,
0.6227254272,
0.4660302997,
-0.2706201673,
0.3953216672,
0.9085708261,
0.0248643439,
0.2754827142,
0.184568882,
-0.3710978329,
0.104547374,
-0.5649107099,
-0.3984898031,
0.8841639161,
0.5275965333,
-0.37175107,
-0.1457181424,
0.1194253191,
0.0771996081,
0.430187434,
-0.5909768343,
0.5850350857,
0.1993869841,
-0.3560281098,
0.2906408906,
0.3760612607,
0.7327868938,
-0.4543270469,
-0.0125439875,
-0.1430248767,
-0.2002179474,
-0.2027934343,
-0.4162305892,
0.7424445748,
-0.0590538271,
-0.3852778077,
-0.0399165303,
0.4831603765,
-0.7542755008,
-0.980700016,
0.3024460673,
0.6234735847,
0.3391497433,
0.1682091653,
-0.6649017334,
0.463062346,
0.1199340448,
-0.12478742,
0.4145275652,
0.3664758503,
-0.2523168027,
0.5948379636,
0.658446312,
0.3780875504,
0.1499947608,
-0.2869524956,
0.5073056221,
-0.4289039075,
-0.5394894481,
-0.8350304365,
0.4925151467,
0.158907339,
0.1861284524,
0.6213226914,
0.5633855462,
0.6734192371,
0.1314756274,
1.0316303968,
-0.1583285034,
0.4003661275,
-0.4967441857,
0.8071534634,
-0.8289689422,
-0.1516707689,
-0.2153043449,
-1.2564913034,
-0.4388154447,
0.6404905915,
-0.2837754488,
0.0513827801,
0.4355385303,
0.6985670328,
-0.170386225,
-0.1015899852,
0.4530175328,
0.1795279831,
0.2486220598,
0.2166483551,
0.6013644934,
-0.1657966077,
0.5834521651,
0.1272644103,
-0.251714915,
-0.5713361502,
-0.9245990515,
-0.6818773746,
-0.6736411452,
0.0783495829,
-0.1303282231,
-0.0419642814,
1.0443682671,
0.8346378803,
-0.5192623734,
-0.5622160435,
0.6417167783,
0.3787119687,
0.0387104489,
-0.2142487317,
0.1200803593,
-0.1466679722,
-1.1881936789,
0.413408041,
0.6114999056,
0.0041746828,
-0.6024771929,
0.0703474805,
-0.4909959137,
0.2334242612,
0.6878167391,
0.3942096233,
-0.7730810642,
-0.1704141498,
-0.2981532514,
-0.1945848465,
0.1291245073,
0.8136267662,
-0.3789899945,
0.4833728969,
0.1607954502,
1.3746253252,
0.169806093,
-0.0174040049,
0.7373394966,
-0.3719476461,
0.4740987718,
0.3004974723,
0.1231028363,
0.5850533247,
-0.5888375044,
0.6344909072,
0.1176435947,
-0.7291375995,
-0.967431128,
0.4222088456,
-0.804918468,
-0.1862136871,
1.1882493496,
0.2525524497,
-0.2519323528,
-0.3209281862,
-0.132982716,
0.2150593847,
-0.1342007667,
0.7652967572,
0.720611155,
0.2201002687,
-0.2700509727,
-1.1698403358,
-0.0393495709,
0.0723012388,
-0.4696821272,
-0.201683566,
0.489523679,
-0.1466375589,
0.3419491351,
0.7054641843,
-0.249402374,
0.3674087226,
-0.2611350715,
0.0951274559,
0.0852795467,
-0.2255016267,
-0.1397245228,
-0.2262776792,
-0.0768246576,
0.0984893441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14158v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14158v2
|
TOOLVERIFIER: Generalization to New Tools via Self-Verification
| 2024-02-21T22:41:38 | 2024-03-13T16:38:42 |
Dheeraj Mekala, Jason Weston, Jack Lanchantin, Roberta Raileanu, Maria Lomeli, Jingbo Shang, Jane Dwivedi-Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Teaching language models to use tools is an important milestone towards
building general assistants, but remains an open problem. While there has been
significant progress on learning to use specific tools via fine-tuning,
language models still struggle with learning how to robustly use new tools from
only a few demonstrations. In this work we introduce a self-verification method
which distinguishes between close candidates by self-asking contrastive
questions during (1) tool selection; and (2) parameter generation. We construct
synthetic, high-quality, self-generated data for this goal using Llama-2 70B,
which we intend to release publicly. Extensive experiments on 4 tasks from the
ToolBench benchmark, consisting of 17 unseen tools, demonstrate an average
improvement of 22% over few-shot baselines, even in scenarios where the
distinctions between candidate tools are finely nuanced.
|
[
-0.4946504831,
-0.8389828801,
0.6451168656,
-0.030089004,
-0.2024767697,
-0.0600236803,
-0.1116442531,
-0.188364327,
-0.0519053042,
0.4501446784,
-0.4470166564,
-0.5938622952,
-0.4640496373,
0.2707726359,
-0.6527742743,
0.8811128736,
-0.1501306742,
-0.2513843775,
-0.2809216976,
-0.0499990024,
-0.5052130222,
-0.2282068133,
-0.5359936953,
-0.4794342518,
0.4279479682,
0.6001275778,
0.5357454419,
0.837597847,
0.3130552769,
0.3846563995,
0.1500675827,
0.1660424769,
-0.1482195109,
0.2125276327,
-0.2856832147,
-0.6729619503,
-0.2904730141,
0.1687948704,
0.3355096877,
0.6548984051,
-0.0189805925,
0.6462762356,
0.2389728278,
0.0114031807,
-0.6431580186,
-0.2160539627,
-0.6961469054,
-0.0657550469,
-0.2625306547,
-0.0268322192,
-0.1650718451,
-0.1971065253,
-0.153770715,
-0.4663037658,
0.840597868,
-0.2618575096,
0.7701994777,
0.4420221448,
-0.5320785046,
-0.3213689327,
-0.665222466,
0.7721818686,
-0.5744093657,
0.4520330727,
0.6135678887,
0.6252344251,
-0.3075042069,
-0.8756056428,
-0.4591774046,
-0.2948364913,
-0.0237077065,
-0.1000223085,
0.063633509,
-0.1037047654,
0.3954338431,
0.5457857251,
-0.4794428349,
0.3021858633,
-0.5736888647,
-0.4904865921,
0.6214737296,
0.0146186594,
-0.0788075998,
0.0344886184,
0.0331667848,
-0.3158570826,
-0.8133921027,
-0.1797866076,
0.6937181354,
0.0724524185,
-0.2699728608,
0.4218941033,
-0.3612810373,
0.6813869476,
0.2912227809,
-0.2670077682,
0.295902133,
-0.272934258,
-0.3229235411,
-0.3470080495,
0.6979611516,
0.2152208388,
0.1818416864,
-0.1869697422,
-0.2688304186,
-0.0262629893,
0.1401645392,
-0.6160666943,
-0.39253667,
0.25346753,
-0.2678349912,
-0.5366907716,
-0.2027691156,
-0.3119637668,
-0.316519171,
-0.1937862933,
0.4503363073,
0.3173373342,
-0.3411639929,
-0.0700924173,
-0.0746333823,
0.4800379574,
0.5496054292,
-0.7658346891,
0.3911563754,
0.5083823204,
0.6951216459,
-0.1692638993,
-0.4665525854,
-0.827088058,
0.0236072335,
-0.6053588986,
0.7859229445,
-0.4169673026,
-0.7286217213,
-0.1540839374,
0.2449186593,
0.5134860873,
-0.6853739023,
0.2320795357,
-0.0513751581,
0.5348786712,
-0.2454450876,
-0.2788159549,
0.0217043217,
0.3063873947,
-0.4999456704,
1.363888979,
0.3753858805,
-0.4249225557,
0.4906723201,
-0.3892002106,
-0.3523071706,
-0.0492450781,
-0.6390393972,
-0.5586655736,
0.2589265406,
0.2866185904,
0.6317042112,
-0.4765274525,
0.24388735,
-0.4259706438,
-0.3077046275,
-0.0577840917,
-0.2643515766,
0.5015099645,
0.1931000501,
-0.4494997263,
0.0353705101,
-0.6758524776,
-0.1891441494,
0.2696155608,
-0.3543621898,
0.0257854518,
-0.4632407129,
-0.4659682512,
0.072667338,
0.3603369296,
-0.6843935847,
0.2983138859,
-0.4209851623,
-0.1013571098,
0.9165267348,
-0.1023430526,
0.1556333005,
0.0112149194,
0.7365576625,
-0.0712147802,
0.198729977,
-0.0744517297,
-0.3825452328,
-0.8132808805,
0.2343319803,
0.5093060136,
0.2632933557,
-0.5261583924,
0.3812395036,
0.3684101701,
-0.6121103168,
-0.5952951908,
0.6590828896,
0.5815574527,
0.6327921152,
0.2195099145,
-0.5252799988,
-0.4376197457,
-1.0397648811,
-0.0761045739,
-0.202604562,
-0.3233964443,
0.439275682,
0.2345969826,
-0.211086899,
0.7536050677,
-0.5572793484,
-0.1477015913,
-0.2054128349,
0.3554971516,
0.2174036205,
0.5010919571,
0.5541331172,
-0.3259164691,
-0.356803596,
0.109288089,
-0.7712247372,
-0.3170840442,
-0.0502758622,
0.1255856305,
-0.2018428594,
0.9818503857,
-0.1584450752,
0.3209826052,
0.6518653631,
-0.0669981688,
0.5932614207,
-0.4186325371,
-0.14750655,
-0.9199652672,
0.1141831204,
-0.0308831111,
-0.2677666843,
-0.5589332581,
0.035231296,
-0.0933974236,
0.0192113798,
-0.5090697408,
0.9492689967,
-0.6465544105,
-0.0878898427,
-0.4789853692,
0.1053305417,
-0.142059654,
0.2309684753,
-0.285610646,
1.0520238876,
0.651286304,
-0.6298061013,
0.3509192765,
-0.0088722268,
0.0384678543,
0.4551271796,
-1.0743112564,
0.602119267,
-0.0881468207,
-0.0479236506,
-1.059466958,
-0.3498140574,
0.1224970296,
-0.3117048442,
0.1810741723,
-0.3852130175,
-0.4580538869,
-0.4411180019,
-0.0740188733,
0.3902183175,
0.6497647166,
-0.6657115221,
0.8523941636,
0.230216831,
-0.0620287359,
-0.6129134297,
-0.4934704602,
-0.1522900313,
-0.1689591706,
-0.2440170795,
-0.0201450866,
-0.1448574513,
-0.0957532674,
-0.4292037487,
-0.3446634114,
-0.0134984273,
0.5174503922,
0.3021585941,
0.0098342849,
-0.1753366441,
0.2713301182,
0.2290841788,
-0.1444794387,
0.2557282448,
0.2738162279,
0.5007407665,
-0.14843674,
-0.8782442212,
-0.1387899816,
0.0690418184,
-0.0322441198,
-0.3359359205,
-0.0611713119,
0.9585992098,
0.0175529029,
-0.2971791029,
-1.0886933804,
-0.3397755027,
-0.6086165309,
0.2111158371,
-0.7969645858,
-0.7967140675,
0.5791863799,
-0.4670998454,
0.1416607648,
0.3448471129,
0.671830833,
0.2222072184,
1.1389632225,
0.660846293,
-0.0371842422,
0.1925601214,
-0.1833589077,
-0.2067994326,
-0.8296507001,
-0.0155514181,
-0.6122909784,
-0.0720778778,
-0.6245988011,
-0.4375202358,
0.2770950496,
-0.0084034568,
0.0808931291,
0.4296936095,
-0.7221699357,
0.7997846007,
0.8223013878,
-0.135609895,
0.0639400706,
-0.308650583,
-0.3728941381,
0.4777618349,
-0.1851154119,
-0.7057373524,
1.520377636,
0.3752242327,
0.8289324641,
-0.0007581469,
1.3410104513,
0.2923489809,
0.2419566214,
-0.4768167734,
0.7850978971,
-0.0402462333,
-0.5300192833,
-0.3004676998,
-0.0446796454,
-1.1355241537,
0.1760552078,
0.1297943741,
-0.6001772881,
0.2058850825,
0.546646595,
-0.1809098572,
-0.1914940476,
-0.8212736249,
0.9303110838,
-0.2202850729,
-0.3396978974,
-0.1267186701,
-0.6251369715,
0.0988048688,
-0.0270431545,
-0.0447105691,
-0.3797344267,
-0.00666994,
0.4214698672,
-0.1115791127,
0.9404301047,
-0.3085051477,
-0.3793141544,
0.1391121596,
0.4315575063,
0.5785883069,
-0.0917085856,
-0.0913932547,
-0.1008002982,
-0.006872288,
-0.3429067135,
-0.7143258452,
0.5446354151,
-0.677311182,
-1.1482664347,
-0.1383008957,
-0.301646471,
-0.2166480571,
0.371935606,
-0.0229457561,
0.3222525418,
-0.3544243276,
0.107751295,
0.4662228227,
0.0532881431,
0.1642861217,
0.5047570467,
-0.1438478529,
-0.0149414344,
0.8352016807,
-0.2118623704,
0.3280136287,
-0.1502955854,
0.453229785,
-0.1059110537,
-0.5831224322,
-0.4738140404,
0.3753739893,
-1.0002481937,
-0.1822572947,
-0.2868131399,
0.0377319977,
-0.3955304921,
-0.1944870204,
-0.1951588094,
-0.3198570609,
-0.4356436431,
-0.1822541803,
-0.0791234449,
1.0992957354,
-0.1655905843,
0.3200754225,
-0.2246372551,
0.3379824758,
0.8423779607,
0.1449524015,
-0.2666695416,
-0.440248996,
0.010931341,
-0.1697905064,
-0.4670921266,
-0.7275776863,
-0.0039496971,
0.2903181612,
0.9997529984,
0.4426898658,
-0.1513324529,
0.4421769679,
-0.3226264417,
0.8123131394,
-0.0712509602,
-0.9373076558,
1.0629817247,
-0.1791101545,
0.4879954159,
0.456597805,
0.1704484671,
-0.3347556293,
-0.7509880066,
-0.7773826122,
-0.3570591807,
0.401363194,
0.0467096008,
0.2652256489,
-0.0946778283,
0.3702208102,
0.391300112,
0.1699135005,
-0.514544785,
-0.1129572317,
-0.3045153618,
-0.1883789748,
-0.0478815399,
-0.0800671875,
-0.3123580217,
0.0409652777,
0.4527104497,
-0.7147904038,
-0.0444942266,
0.1993582249,
-0.0406772941,
0.0255777594,
0.312140435,
0.4282567501,
0.6507931352,
-0.0165141281,
0.4626659155,
0.6806353331,
-0.2783421874,
0.3792972565,
0.0250199661,
-0.01863751,
0.1045723781,
0.3089888394,
0.4161655903,
-0.0436945818,
-0.4086837471,
0.6572763324,
0.1212487519,
-0.300263375,
-0.0522688068,
0.5436197519,
-0.0643061921,
0.1712192148,
-0.0035064637,
-0.4851011932,
0.5562161207,
-0.4043371975,
0.1036041304,
0.6230168939,
-0.0823893547,
-0.4038006067,
0.5559753776,
0.3476382196,
-0.3281385303,
0.2020952404,
-0.5345717669,
-0.1075782776,
0.6460200548,
0.4915004373,
0.9090775251,
-0.5623061061,
0.2839886248,
0.27530846,
0.2053449899,
-0.0627361536,
0.3313633204,
-0.4787210822,
-0.519518137,
-0.1960749477,
-0.2743114829,
-0.6240672469,
0.0627926737,
-0.6344546676,
0.4965392649,
-0.4813438952,
-0.2121627778,
0.0619753674,
-0.1713507324,
-1.0620669127,
0.33912462,
-0.2274063826,
0.677710712,
-1.1117700338,
0.8493575454,
0.6959686875,
-0.4903209507,
-0.8634937406,
-0.0746302083,
0.0707464889,
-1.1482410431,
0.6288341284,
0.081358023,
-0.2441829294,
-0.1658982486,
-0.6302827001,
-0.8922881484,
1.0657962561,
0.5151043534,
-0.3545427024,
-0.1974401176,
0.1440906376,
0.4777688384,
-0.2185845971,
0.3525578976,
0.5387566686,
0.2660669386,
0.1999269724,
-1.3220952749,
0.2279524356,
-0.0770608559,
0.01350627,
0.0904101804,
-0.3799755871,
0.8717505932,
-0.2222701311,
-0.1177913845,
0.0160930827,
0.5227396488,
0.1916960031,
0.09416572,
0.6487899423,
0.2782687247,
0.5318467021,
0.0175629295,
0.7519132495,
-0.0963400155,
0.1808828861,
1.3502255678,
-0.1067509949,
0.5058564544,
0.4353626966,
-0.1457387805,
0.644436419,
0.3336177468,
-0.3648867011,
0.2177151293,
0.1982111037,
0.0149627905,
-0.5617857575,
-0.1686983109,
-0.3720280528,
0.6836964488,
0.0489933006,
-0.4495077729,
-0.4618059397,
0.0107083209,
-0.0188729614,
0.0173223764,
0.0401241481,
1.0617117882,
-0.0774668008,
-0.7993764877,
0.6124594212,
-0.0927815363,
0.4222146571,
-0.6193441153,
-0.293905288,
-0.2502015531,
0.1355537921,
-0.0826136619,
-0.8008737564,
0.024920132,
-0.2810144722,
0.3732147217,
0.1296180338,
0.8407281041,
-0.3666846156,
-0.4759474993,
0.0354813747,
0.745847404,
0.441839993,
0.132364735,
-0.5739976764,
0.0511226617,
-0.0849177837,
0.0053970418,
0.1604141146,
0.3109611571,
0.0696698725,
0.7784288526,
0.5521818995,
0.191031903,
-0.0935795754,
0.4176448882,
0.8685094118,
-0.3986445665,
-0.2652859688,
-0.520866394,
0.3887254894,
-0.2051523328,
-0.637337029,
0.9799427986,
0.4670199156,
1.0493472815,
-0.1265667677,
0.6931585073,
0.2293073535,
0.6698707342,
-0.314574331,
0.0090044271,
-0.5840477943,
0.1920953095,
-0.1672043651,
-0.6338443756,
-0.0428775437,
0.6740630269,
-0.2775419056,
0.2914924026,
0.3746470213,
1.0051797628,
-0.3368817866,
-0.4687112272,
0.3737310171,
-0.2810837626,
0.489446789,
0.0894026905,
0.5269222856,
-0.3439269066,
0.5749946833,
-0.4936014414,
-0.1033385769,
-0.2277621031,
-0.8360305429,
-1.2995200157,
-0.5880687237,
-0.4533943236,
-0.2084038705,
0.1178680956,
0.7243711948,
0.943695724,
-0.6740548611,
-0.5292227268,
-0.140252918,
0.0908018276,
-0.1260710508,
-0.0813982114,
0.1458715796,
-0.5280277133,
-0.5738891363,
0.4905272424,
-0.0056999121,
0.4226259887,
-0.8561517,
0.0375655107,
0.1901959479,
0.007070458,
0.2745339274,
0.4460335076,
-1.0619156361,
-0.4900662899,
-0.0680348575,
0.2477729172,
0.0576544516,
0.7976198792,
-0.9191423059,
0.5963736773,
0.1970356405,
0.4211316407,
0.5451628566,
-0.0644790605,
0.7582300305,
-1.163228035,
0.0217207596,
-0.0264121536,
0.3309173882,
0.5066882372,
-0.3277663887,
0.8104173541,
-0.2576391697,
-0.6687292457,
-1.0531642437,
0.4863801897,
-0.556479454,
0.0419795513,
1.0858621597,
0.0464102738,
-0.0455389805,
-0.2543459833,
-0.4533751905,
0.2205491066,
-0.1145102531,
0.9327569008,
0.4518598616,
-0.0883067846,
-0.2481084764,
-0.2003505677,
0.5767130256,
0.3516215682,
-1.0833889246,
-0.0111527052,
0.3926287293,
0.5885894895,
0.2280884385,
0.5283536315,
0.1819637716,
0.5764808059,
0.0531421714,
0.0650509745,
-0.2512180805,
-0.2499803305,
-0.2417410612,
0.0503514335,
0.6517094374,
-0.278321147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14155v1
|
Can Similarity-Based Domain-Ordering Reduce Catastrophic Forgetting for Intent Recognition?
| 2024-02-21T22:30:57 | 2024-02-21T22:30:57 |
Amogh Mannekote, Xiaoyi Tian, Kristy Elizabeth Boyer, Bonnie J. Dorr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Task-oriented dialogue systems are expected to handle a constantly expanding
set of intents and domains even after they have been deployed to support more
and more functionalities. To live up to this expectation, it becomes critical
to mitigate the catastrophic forgetting problem (CF) that occurs in continual
learning (CL) settings for a task such as intent recognition. While existing
dialogue systems research has explored replay-based and regularization-based
methods to this end, the effect of domain ordering on the CL performance of
intent recognition models remains unexplored. If understood well, domain
ordering has the potential to be an orthogonal technique that can be leveraged
alongside existing techniques such as experience replay. Our work fills this
gap by comparing the impact of three domain-ordering strategies (min-sum path,
max-sum path, random) on the CL performance of a generative intent recognition
model. Our findings reveal that the min-sum path strategy outperforms the
others in reducing catastrophic forgetting when training on the 220M T5-Base
model. However, this advantage diminishes with the larger 770M T5-Large model.
These results underscores the potential of domain ordering as a complementary
strategy for mitigating catastrophic forgetting in continually learning intent
recognition models, particularly in resource-constrained scenarios.
|
[
-0.018703049,
-0.3433535993,
0.6112642884,
0.1603194177,
-0.1051028296,
0.0803904533,
-0.0898182169,
-0.3048644066,
0.0110313594,
0.6020537615,
-0.5555848479,
-0.4838135242,
-0.5748594999,
0.0420716926,
0.2037933469,
0.9206968546,
-0.1169750914,
0.1364864409,
-0.3718263805,
-0.6087406278,
-0.8915739059,
-0.5003966689,
-1.1211819649,
-0.4572093785,
0.3989585042,
0.2870534658,
0.4202316403,
0.3949180841,
0.4802670777,
0.3202380836,
0.0802990347,
0.3418415487,
-1.0285937786,
0.2270855606,
-0.031151101,
-0.3307420909,
-0.4417541027,
-0.1127541736,
0.5461035371,
0.9187589288,
-0.2925204933,
-0.1070178971,
0.058644224,
0.7103865147,
-0.655149281,
0.1539028883,
-0.5973441005,
0.1554944962,
0.2384183258,
-0.5608240962,
-0.795871377,
-0.3079072237,
0.7342248559,
-0.5342594385,
0.2717591822,
0.3624415696,
0.49666363,
-0.0085073421,
0.1653791815,
-0.2614774704,
-1.0660555363,
1.0355452299,
-0.4197594225,
0.3821128309,
0.2683145404,
0.2832300067,
-0.2487941086,
-0.5429213047,
-0.2826261818,
0.1417038888,
0.2576265335,
0.1526124328,
0.0401332118,
0.26855129,
0.3208574355,
0.0675571859,
-0.8823940158,
0.006915547,
-0.3444364369,
-0.1401547343,
0.3109403551,
0.5821431875,
0.144415766,
0.3735593557,
-0.4478076696,
-0.1735517532,
-0.9203833342,
0.1782922894,
-0.2882284224,
0.2001940012,
0.1374755502,
0.1224650815,
-0.1993610263,
0.4481496811,
0.1750912815,
-0.3687548339,
0.1567114294,
-0.1438542753,
-0.5031487346,
0.0384547673,
0.4337201118,
0.4302515388,
0.292409122,
-0.2710793018,
-0.2162643522,
-0.1376633048,
0.5937476754,
-0.519567728,
-0.3401910663,
0.1320435554,
-0.6556614637,
-0.0002191337,
-0.1732408255,
-0.1025676206,
-0.1947249919,
-0.3263638914,
0.5696586967,
-0.6898527145,
0.1527257711,
0.2049872875,
0.0749153197,
0.2180357277,
0.7478467226,
-0.8286017776,
0.680527389,
0.7930677533,
0.8155685067,
-0.527736485,
-0.5534084439,
-0.3355488777,
0.2038805336,
-0.4356783032,
0.5324141979,
-0.5511485934,
-0.6451243758,
-0.0028293198,
-0.3004924357,
-0.4369461536,
-0.9352800846,
0.4930601716,
-0.9813718796,
0.2223923206,
-0.1750169694,
-0.5903843045,
-0.5196508765,
0.1330659688,
-0.4981506467,
0.6197625399,
-0.1095915511,
-0.2211639285,
0.3564908206,
-0.1644577384,
-0.4448931217,
0.0766854808,
-0.108529605,
-0.8137483001,
0.2143251747,
-0.2631286383,
0.5451945662,
-0.1443938166,
0.1019446924,
-0.3422813416,
-0.504039526,
0.1796202362,
-0.7121599913,
0.4186980426,
-0.1130786389,
-0.4141515791,
-0.1279225051,
-0.4086001813,
0.045077581,
0.3367448747,
-0.111567609,
-0.6520401835,
0.1579704881,
-0.3950671256,
0.3331513703,
0.0019411601,
-0.1682527661,
0.0935881957,
-0.2075680792,
-0.0548851192,
0.8276487589,
0.4853120744,
0.6642917991,
-0.7510898113,
0.2189407051,
0.2991760373,
0.3999946713,
-0.0962646157,
-0.5684460402,
-0.9044445157,
0.2099834085,
-0.2009435743,
0.5736960769,
-0.437533766,
-0.0380590744,
-0.6084059477,
-0.1758503616,
0.1260213703,
-0.1055741012,
0.8210193515,
0.2215829194,
0.4867756069,
-0.882659018,
-0.1431622952,
-0.4495550394,
-0.0240890644,
-0.2437697649,
0.1072492972,
0.8856081963,
0.1752164215,
-0.06475427,
0.6647085547,
-0.7866348028,
-0.5093494654,
-0.2529840171,
0.2327335775,
0.1467704475,
0.3601676226,
0.6704237461,
-0.9054021835,
-0.4783993065,
-0.1939274967,
-0.482613951,
0.2929449677,
-0.4108921587,
-0.1804698855,
0.5321457386,
0.0681316406,
-0.7946931124,
0.5189944506,
0.0513496771,
0.0050491421,
0.5942234993,
-0.28272295,
0.3204412162,
-0.6634984016,
-0.2869330645,
-0.5030204058,
-0.0245659184,
-0.8767741323,
-0.5814341903,
-0.0324571319,
-0.0414871834,
-0.2777666152,
0.2429800183,
-0.4749766886,
-0.0639446303,
-0.2135032862,
-0.1550438106,
-0.0081779286,
0.928565979,
0.2497795224,
0.7632578015,
0.4220628738,
-0.9722575545,
-0.3139341474,
0.3536893725,
-0.1826490611,
0.4636155963,
-0.138807714,
0.1737987399,
-0.0759290382,
0.2670118809,
-1.1247855425,
0.11410629,
0.1730555892,
-0.4541196823,
0.4485481977,
-0.1711050123,
-0.0177054293,
-0.1409626901,
-0.2800009251,
0.7903628349,
0.726855576,
-0.5395249128,
0.5954156518,
0.1041334271,
-0.4681324065,
-0.6586545706,
0.0607296489,
-0.1453796178,
-0.3367710114,
-0.2386184335,
0.5492124557,
-0.365413636,
0.051998809,
-0.4229886234,
-0.4090332091,
-0.1952609122,
-0.0093764421,
0.4676659703,
0.3088658154,
-0.2634697258,
0.0965760425,
0.0014922793,
-0.0134982029,
0.1200566217,
-0.7523722053,
0.4853617251,
0.1997527331,
-0.1812506914,
-0.2592772841,
0.4374251366,
0.9547296166,
0.0316456668,
0.6729980707,
0.0177948177,
-0.2517360151,
-0.5499978065,
-0.715793848,
-0.0245825648,
-0.5157866478,
-0.0192910787,
-0.3423494101,
-0.8286929131,
0.4836027622,
-0.5006982684,
0.2202811986,
0.1455297619,
0.330842346,
-0.4048558176,
0.6951521635,
0.5828522444,
-0.3364031315,
0.6163039207,
-0.4177977443,
0.2802364528,
-0.5930402279,
-0.1410994381,
-0.0238741618,
-0.2389376014,
-0.063664034,
-0.5335027575,
0.4086786807,
-0.0974326208,
-0.2176099271,
0.3167041242,
-0.1552465111,
0.5441166162,
0.2981216311,
0.2437926233,
0.3433946669,
0.3089761436,
-0.2391775399,
-0.0241776928,
-0.9690721035,
-0.1636667401,
1.0117638111,
-0.0339191258,
0.5896490216,
0.1980436444,
0.9949303269,
0.3176192939,
0.2020366639,
-0.7091741562,
0.7055178881,
-0.0669834241,
0.0366973355,
-0.3750361204,
-0.4628303647,
-1.1023093462,
0.1735215038,
0.1143171415,
-0.589268744,
0.3355761766,
0.0988581553,
-0.784802556,
0.2263116986,
-0.6846217513,
0.4800772071,
-0.0945726335,
-0.348205775,
-0.4006145895,
-0.5815204382,
0.0572096296,
0.0662116855,
-0.1337025911,
0.0307649951,
0.2546765506,
0.7557970881,
-0.4169459045,
0.8507773876,
-0.192298755,
-0.0253741145,
0.5173007846,
0.4266469181,
0.6179788709,
-0.1663300544,
0.3213045001,
0.0297925752,
-0.7385127544,
-0.3207333088,
-0.7144575715,
0.790555954,
-0.6454266906,
-0.6967059374,
-0.3224332035,
-0.4190315008,
-0.360507369,
0.243049264,
0.2753979862,
0.8664740324,
-0.3132954538,
-0.2102188766,
1.2333991528,
0.0151084438,
0.4848670363,
0.4898790121,
0.3176092505,
-0.4367820323,
1.4109368324,
0.1913186461,
0.7372499704,
0.4687082171,
-0.1265271455,
0.0018081926,
-0.9415284395,
-0.1075803861,
0.2962813973,
-0.6544049978,
-0.4394119084,
-0.8638953567,
-0.1354735792,
-0.1840007007,
-0.39895612,
-0.3104642928,
-0.4575554132,
-0.3632808626,
0.1840676516,
0.1925818324,
0.6785311699,
0.3560051918,
-0.0381193161,
-0.7178848982,
0.3711395264,
0.2304608226,
0.6289247274,
0.3580040336,
-0.5792939663,
-0.183865428,
-0.2090548724,
-0.5721728802,
-0.3075512648,
0.422714889,
0.3532088995,
0.4438969493,
0.6788232923,
0.1875360906,
0.8858076334,
-0.9702919126,
0.542093873,
0.2304014862,
-0.355560571,
0.2955026031,
-0.3437644541,
0.2746915519,
0.6542408466,
0.6102056503,
-0.4355989397,
-0.2216320932,
-0.7953948379,
-0.8264027238,
0.9861348271,
0.3606824875,
0.0305938441,
-0.0996932685,
0.1727913618,
0.2484663874,
-0.0722526982,
-0.4021876156,
-0.4978033006,
0.1674821228,
0.047834333,
-0.0010483525,
-0.2648274004,
-0.0172879957,
-0.0441018194,
0.511380136,
0.1206341311,
0.7944184542,
0.1949245632,
-0.2103380412,
0.0207440257,
0.0099772038,
0.9939002395,
0.4878161252,
-0.3476123512,
-0.2607525289,
0.2675702274,
-0.7921151519,
0.2171764821,
-0.4398477674,
-0.136571601,
0.056408491,
0.1487008929,
0.7534379959,
0.4895812273,
-0.6680207253,
0.5789959431,
-0.0109965149,
-0.148330763,
-0.4700647891,
0.2989653945,
-0.3239915073,
0.1995813102,
0.3813669086,
0.525642097,
0.345107615,
-0.3770342171,
0.2978568971,
0.2397580892,
-0.3648663461,
-0.1455752999,
0.2330725789,
0.0135529665,
-0.4488150477,
0.7589587569,
-0.0608400255,
-0.7281833887,
0.7371986508,
0.6606689692,
1.1516586542,
-0.4395108819,
0.1632375419,
0.4364017546,
-0.0609499738,
-0.443860054,
0.0725443512,
-0.3762003779,
-0.6883007288,
0.0946662426,
-0.2224732637,
-0.535982132,
-0.1089606732,
-0.5838520527,
-0.1223532632,
-0.7213072777,
-0.126101777,
-0.2882323265,
-0.2653204799,
-0.4885945022,
0.206257388,
0.136241138,
0.4595933557,
-0.5880390406,
0.55466187,
0.3318579197,
0.0030976878,
-0.6433928609,
0.3477052748,
0.0833052471,
-0.451517731,
0.6363417506,
0.2197350711,
-0.5930822492,
-0.0942511782,
-0.2469558418,
-1.014633894,
1.4852098227,
-0.3889364004,
-0.1374233961,
0.0771725327,
-0.0152770802,
0.5730881691,
-0.6913428903,
0.1741875857,
0.3718953133,
-0.2207065523,
0.3141630292,
-0.7729585767,
-0.038792409,
0.0365702026,
0.1020278111,
0.4280025661,
-0.6314466,
0.3694994748,
-0.5756446123,
-0.6183359027,
0.2231404632,
0.4287287295,
0.328692019,
0.613754034,
0.4439150989,
0.4838430285,
0.4669993818,
0.0715762824,
0.853810668,
0.1398690045,
0.3693327308,
1.2072976828,
-0.5486835241,
0.7379360199,
0.1794999391,
-0.2769157588,
0.4393830299,
0.4171041548,
0.3573310971,
0.8837907314,
-0.0645284876,
-0.3409119844,
-0.2063833773,
-0.0131279221,
-0.0742853135,
-0.0763410628,
0.6978440881,
-0.3771996498,
-0.0900168866,
0.0419886224,
-0.1999135464,
-0.1825635433,
-0.2884023488,
1.2670238018,
0.2502252162,
-0.7488527298,
1.0457398891,
-0.4552699327,
0.3489398956,
-0.5230824351,
-0.2626263797,
-0.4310664833,
0.2003574669,
0.1186562702,
-0.4024254978,
-0.078839235,
-0.3986572027,
-0.525172472,
-0.4115086496,
0.4217791259,
-0.3846038878,
0.030969074,
0.4712468088,
0.1003343761,
-0.0817231312,
0.2541536391,
-0.6110295653,
-0.0989646092,
-0.1285895854,
-0.1265724599,
0.4883047938,
0.3166696429,
-0.3970244229,
0.9756548405,
0.3932335079,
-0.3694577217,
0.1211300418,
0.1149329841,
0.7560284138,
-0.4120224118,
-0.4087661505,
-0.5246364474,
0.0089734383,
-0.0580816679,
-0.163011685,
0.4198987782,
0.4876545966,
0.993421793,
-0.5090206861,
0.5085136294,
0.1138440967,
0.2733204961,
-0.3654607236,
0.4584350586,
-0.4116873741,
0.3949081004,
-0.4199977219,
-0.9634898901,
-0.4765546024,
0.2704635859,
-0.3641695082,
0.2301033735,
0.9004775882,
0.6334012747,
-0.2529907227,
0.032468915,
0.5849260688,
0.2114263624,
-0.0377739407,
1.1389869452,
0.6477031708,
-0.4254330695,
0.6689332724,
-0.160539344,
-0.2035478652,
-0.3622702956,
-0.1375172436,
-0.8680951595,
-0.595164001,
-0.2312240303,
-0.2189997137,
0.25328511,
0.967735827,
0.3730204999,
-0.8555931449,
-0.2561166883,
-0.1406261921,
0.2397906333,
-0.7162415981,
-0.2040255815,
0.458330065,
-0.4706580043,
-0.4713515043,
0.2303783447,
0.9053518176,
0.2377693653,
0.3962110579,
-0.3009386063,
-0.0305012893,
0.2263556421,
0.8350294232,
0.4943628609,
-0.7463250756,
-0.4281865954,
0.0564117283,
-0.3026892841,
0.3499336243,
1.1922646761,
-0.7850160599,
0.4194658995,
0.4502334595,
0.6901545525,
0.222152099,
0.0181195736,
0.6422806978,
-0.4186779559,
-0.333189249,
0.3400990367,
0.2498106509,
-0.0674102157,
-0.4967014492,
0.3454553485,
0.3565177321,
-0.5815340281,
-0.3250827491,
0.4408944845,
-1.3569612503,
-0.1301673204,
0.8352854848,
-0.3994209766,
0.0670155808,
-0.6186138391,
-0.2851955891,
-0.1603358984,
-0.3447182178,
1.0444440842,
0.4463775158,
-0.3320487142,
0.041346252,
-0.1396102011,
0.654304266,
0.7949507236,
-0.2295067757,
0.2942454517,
0.4623209536,
0.3464340568,
0.2601359785,
0.9459352493,
-0.0386800654,
0.6350527406,
-0.3787042201,
-0.4598477185,
0.264939338,
-0.8371315598,
-0.2998407781,
0.2086192816,
-0.1088536605,
-0.0381899588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14880v1
|
Automatic Histograms: Leveraging Language Models for Text Dataset Exploration
| 2024-02-21T22:29:16 | 2024-02-21T22:29:16 |
Emily Reif, Crystal Qian, James Wexler, Minsuk Kahng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Making sense of unstructured text datasets is perennially difficult, yet
increasingly relevant with Large Language Models. Data workers often rely on
dataset summaries, especially distributions of various derived features. Some
features, like toxicity or topics, are relevant to many datasets, but many
interesting features are domain specific: instruments and genres for a music
dataset, or diseases and symptoms for a medical dataset. Accordingly, data
workers often run custom analyses for each dataset, which is cumbersome and
difficult. We present AutoHistograms, a visualization tool leveragingLLMs.
AutoHistograms automatically identifies relevant features, visualizes them with
histograms, and allows the user to interactively query the dataset for
categories of entities and create new histograms. In a user study with 10 data
workers (n=10), we observe that participants can quickly identify insights and
explore the data using AutoHistograms, and conceptualize a broad range of
applicable use cases. Together, this tool and user study contributeto the
growing field of LLM-assisted sensemaking tools.
|
[
-0.2175811529,
-0.4645110071,
0.7571740746,
0.0656968877,
-0.2221806794,
0.1174125075,
-0.117477417,
-0.4047654271,
0.345043093,
0.8120326996,
-0.5213884115,
-0.8845831156,
-0.5554950237,
0.2801035047,
-0.8066732883,
0.9518656135,
0.036726173,
-0.3561781347,
-0.3702941835,
-0.1975818127,
-0.5569378734,
-0.3738423884,
-0.3154634833,
-0.3284447789,
0.4664062262,
0.5099239945,
0.6493262053,
0.9599267244,
0.5978525877,
0.3609722853,
0.1710024178,
-0.0753398165,
-0.4203404784,
0.5809251666,
-0.109291099,
-0.4427128732,
-0.1257205009,
-0.0640295669,
0.1045006961,
0.9283409119,
-0.0854150727,
0.1963954717,
-0.1246784851,
0.5456337333,
-0.188857317,
0.3433591425,
-0.5997912884,
0.2520709634,
-0.4069946706,
-0.4511725903,
-0.0124425031,
-0.3005931377,
0.4217044711,
-0.729165256,
-0.0059752371,
0.2918289006,
0.6018460393,
0.64607054,
-0.6415302157,
-0.5860696435,
-0.369081378,
0.667761445,
-0.4622769952,
0.2371085435,
0.5413323045,
0.6593102813,
-0.1157650054,
-0.8472326398,
-0.2012490034,
-0.0288104415,
-0.4216339588,
0.0867224038,
-0.3875131011,
-0.2907614708,
0.2026055455,
0.566403985,
-0.5877690315,
0.1190530434,
-0.2033323646,
-0.2734349668,
0.862134099,
0.741086781,
0.5589920878,
-0.4397214949,
-0.1951851547,
-0.1094361097,
-0.558833003,
-0.2589152753,
0.2687840164,
0.1480534673,
-0.1482434422,
0.7469142675,
-0.2116973847,
0.8969592452,
-0.4316127598,
-0.0748752579,
0.3834351897,
-0.3213035166,
-0.3931205869,
-0.0400557593,
0.8039882779,
0.2630659044,
0.468395561,
-0.1227713078,
-0.2805146277,
-0.2624471486,
0.096623607,
-0.6385036111,
-0.7170826793,
0.3656026125,
-0.6580551267,
-0.4341755509,
-0.2758864462,
-0.8275846243,
-0.8138543963,
-0.5394300818,
0.1542050987,
-0.3502276242,
-0.2501163185,
-0.0301557966,
-0.3260006309,
-0.2134375125,
0.350813657,
-0.7353587151,
0.1562732607,
0.2106165737,
0.7489714026,
-0.4301264882,
-0.195530951,
-0.1581408828,
0.230610311,
-0.2019402087,
1.0246814489,
-0.7219208479,
-0.736997664,
-0.1526178718,
0.0550053865,
0.0313817598,
-0.4962427616,
0.1363916397,
-0.2813939452,
0.3751189411,
-0.3373875916,
-0.803411305,
-0.199888587,
0.1880557388,
-0.7681145668,
1.1555062532,
0.1422739029,
-0.805370748,
0.5496025085,
-0.8452169299,
-0.4553629756,
0.0684514344,
-0.5948693156,
-0.144653067,
0.0272135921,
0.2786132693,
0.6038938761,
-0.369674623,
0.1977346539,
-0.2305782884,
-0.0889711082,
0.2215449214,
-0.1884747893,
0.9834745526,
0.4260613918,
-0.0922794342,
0.1766082644,
-0.5341468453,
-0.2411917895,
0.3554723561,
-0.1918461323,
-0.6372094154,
0.2389140874,
0.3699705303,
-0.0080711162,
0.0420904718,
-0.0868642703,
0.3255499899,
-0.3893158734,
0.1916324645,
0.4722184539,
0.2458913922,
0.2753418982,
-0.0646964386,
0.5954529047,
0.083522141,
-0.0242888983,
-0.7124237418,
-0.580390811,
-0.332652986,
-0.3758862317,
0.1835987568,
0.5525458455,
-0.714122951,
0.6711868048,
-0.1502394229,
-0.3750429451,
-0.3940814734,
0.2319304645,
-0.1127782017,
0.596903801,
0.3328787684,
-0.2409300059,
-0.4666445553,
-0.8329690695,
-0.3304726183,
-0.0114524029,
-0.3331950903,
0.4538578987,
0.6044158936,
-0.4797515273,
1.3723796606,
-0.9224187732,
-0.5279766321,
-0.3636458218,
0.3529490829,
0.1463363916,
0.2718968689,
0.6541656256,
-0.6968834996,
-0.4967091084,
0.063734673,
-1.0605846643,
-0.5280758739,
-0.1870151013,
-0.049952399,
-0.0701511577,
0.7226644158,
0.0633171499,
0.3412671387,
0.3446926177,
-0.566000104,
0.1153984442,
-0.2026798427,
0.0149598727,
-1.1361651421,
0.3099471033,
0.006563874,
-0.274641782,
-0.4561138749,
-0.4053615928,
-0.0955646411,
-0.1996540427,
0.0114386231,
0.6263437867,
-0.5246009827,
-0.3095824718,
-0.3127291203,
0.1940283179,
0.0582235605,
0.0982886031,
0.1123336926,
0.5434340835,
0.6921470761,
-0.2630005479,
0.4655935168,
0.3931325972,
-0.2861096561,
0.4822244644,
-0.4930550754,
-0.0423270166,
-0.0737553611,
0.0823294073,
-0.856431067,
-0.4800768495,
0.0911756158,
-0.2653070688,
0.1009125486,
-0.1511732191,
-0.7592427731,
-0.2454008758,
-0.198992461,
0.0466705859,
0.3097195625,
-0.5280477405,
0.5097455978,
0.9333611131,
-0.0732276887,
-0.3349700272,
-0.7403014302,
0.5645402074,
-0.4945019484,
-0.5548376441,
0.1115070656,
-0.0155017069,
-0.4733068943,
0.1972349137,
0.0185330845,
-0.1732205451,
0.2669039965,
0.2945995033,
0.0487495288,
0.2208200395,
0.3385822773,
0.1781375259,
-0.3471457958,
-0.0098720714,
-0.0115141254,
0.3451025486,
0.1017396301,
-0.3253511786,
-0.2340445966,
0.3292112052,
0.3239279091,
-0.19966802,
0.1248369962,
0.5411858559,
-0.4176409543,
-0.22869277,
-0.2279689461,
-0.1350299567,
-0.4672328234,
0.1108042002,
-0.3710642159,
-0.6139070988,
0.5683521032,
-0.2256345749,
0.1339395791,
0.4370612204,
0.7254564762,
-0.3855717778,
1.1364703178,
0.8203315139,
-0.2545968294,
0.3581332266,
-0.3291594386,
-0.0232837424,
-0.4731721878,
-0.0765350834,
-0.5667421818,
-0.2212513238,
-0.6085208058,
-0.2281259745,
0.4686667919,
-0.5909779668,
0.2437390089,
0.2091890424,
-0.4738458991,
0.6507429481,
0.4105024338,
-0.2699331641,
0.5664047599,
0.0597570464,
-0.0565036833,
-0.206160605,
-0.6732655168,
-0.5330027342,
1.2012662888,
0.2358734757,
0.9502999783,
-0.2107323706,
0.8420032859,
0.5292483568,
0.4723065495,
-0.8900553584,
0.3156935871,
-0.2130691856,
-0.5910513401,
-0.4645672739,
-0.4236439168,
-1.2095746994,
0.1468356699,
-0.3035851717,
-0.5612114072,
0.4159280658,
0.2859152853,
-0.0764947236,
0.0915864035,
-0.7206816077,
0.8625279665,
-0.2507956624,
0.0162709393,
0.0236698501,
-0.5732054114,
0.1271496266,
-0.1847393066,
0.4059506059,
-0.2992737889,
-0.0266856533,
0.7379014492,
-0.3444869816,
0.868791163,
-0.1554221958,
-0.2770642638,
0.1305919439,
0.2891547978,
0.2693926096,
-0.0896170884,
-0.0102994321,
0.0792088211,
0.0940815508,
-0.1534116119,
-0.4759220183,
0.6835304499,
-0.293961972,
-0.4225640297,
-0.3621139824,
-0.6960072517,
-0.1975346655,
0.2787478566,
0.1821129322,
0.3506816924,
-0.1646201611,
0.0950951055,
0.4910540879,
-0.3929288387,
0.3758868575,
0.2377240658,
-0.3624586165,
0.0096605355,
0.9125788808,
0.1424931586,
-0.2245499492,
0.0104965661,
0.3770378828,
-0.3652983606,
-0.554202795,
-0.631976366,
-0.0613958873,
-0.7856317163,
-0.3767443299,
-0.6014232635,
0.303157568,
-0.015793914,
-0.1406606138,
0.1261830777,
-0.3654463291,
-0.12767151,
-0.0731350854,
0.7999402285,
0.7709550858,
-0.0653475374,
0.2963866889,
-0.7011483312,
0.3305867314,
0.2909771204,
0.4069891572,
-0.1650903225,
-0.1225035563,
-0.4265293777,
-0.3511253595,
0.1202197671,
-1.2060604095,
0.6823850274,
0.0536572412,
0.5755038261,
0.558262229,
-0.1586785913,
0.4211756885,
-0.3022239208,
0.4587996304,
-0.1822855026,
-0.868922174,
0.7221137285,
-0.574667275,
0.2083902061,
0.6360268593,
0.4052411318,
-0.7126371264,
-0.5798083544,
-0.3356210887,
-0.904895246,
0.6446080208,
0.3809727132,
0.011695778,
0.1649598181,
0.1699177325,
0.3248246312,
0.2509018183,
-0.4089206457,
-0.4496115744,
-0.5051578879,
-0.7921563983,
-0.1143404171,
0.0815283656,
-0.366976738,
-0.2009316534,
0.1389498264,
-0.3978157341,
-0.019521594,
0.0860114768,
-0.6108608246,
-0.0470155366,
-0.1102944016,
-0.0416833907,
0.6055265665,
-0.1605066061,
0.2768959999,
0.057230521,
-0.516995728,
-0.184923321,
0.1599280536,
0.0708402991,
0.0432557389,
0.4602992833,
0.6010048985,
0.1250189692,
-0.8707857132,
0.3667554259,
-0.0953190774,
0.0267703477,
-0.2370419204,
0.259011656,
0.3012136817,
0.1314787865,
0.3252467811,
-0.4719713032,
0.6738978028,
-0.4669725597,
0.3098515868,
0.2158765048,
-0.2004188746,
-0.0482258834,
0.6033392549,
0.2396969646,
-0.0313507952,
0.5398216248,
0.1118487939,
-0.1214381233,
0.8154300451,
0.2277474105,
0.7011759281,
0.0358801298,
-0.0145248985,
0.0032930726,
0.3973582685,
0.218258217,
0.1868349463,
0.0041315132,
-0.588237226,
-0.3611747921,
-0.358429879,
-0.4871288836,
-0.0222432371,
-0.5950433612,
0.105141744,
0.0327628963,
-0.0004526386,
0.179204151,
-0.1725606918,
-0.7864025235,
0.3855105937,
0.0362248607,
0.8843342662,
-1.0475047827,
0.8941143751,
0.6395741701,
-0.3126612604,
-0.104497999,
0.0127882166,
0.3795547485,
-0.9407339096,
0.5981200337,
-0.0660368577,
0.2088832408,
0.1093703061,
-0.5277409554,
-0.8730775118,
1.2624938488,
0.0070346058,
-0.5755971074,
0.283430934,
0.201136753,
0.6353178024,
-0.4544769228,
0.1741544753,
0.871034205,
0.8033232093,
-0.2551864088,
-0.5385408401,
0.0954363942,
-0.2439649254,
-0.1188511401,
0.2899700701,
-0.0430388153,
0.4257778823,
-0.1610301733,
-0.2379793674,
-0.52940768,
0.4844830036,
-0.0304019321,
0.532119453,
0.7705705762,
0.3766733706,
0.8954697847,
-0.0626577511,
0.9515220523,
-0.4170692265,
0.4089252353,
1.0771296024,
-0.3165600598,
0.3463774025,
0.3894531131,
0.0013876758,
0.2907131612,
0.8534865975,
-0.4218305349,
0.329728961,
0.330684185,
-0.0157977212,
-0.2085185051,
0.1112864092,
-0.1655924916,
0.6354535222,
0.7443962693,
-0.3451583385,
-0.6145989895,
0.1951695532,
-0.0245677475,
0.0612347163,
0.0470674895,
0.9178235531,
0.0242428761,
0.028414391,
0.1997215897,
-0.1955285966,
0.5317497253,
-0.41240412,
-0.1037339866,
-0.3545217812,
-0.5263704062,
-0.3174303174,
-0.9915571213,
0.6834793687,
0.2289028019,
0.0133491317,
-0.2840610743,
0.9726584554,
-0.3521951139,
-0.4158681035,
0.3446088731,
0.9625877142,
0.3637747765,
-0.0476897396,
-0.7663876414,
-0.1124212742,
0.0123946499,
-0.4861583114,
0.131397754,
0.5521586537,
-0.2738937736,
0.8147731423,
0.5801332593,
-0.0626816675,
-0.20525904,
0.2932075262,
0.7482617497,
-0.986194551,
-0.4588572383,
-0.7605240941,
0.4169807136,
-0.26567626,
-0.1293997914,
0.7615665197,
0.6861463785,
0.4743462503,
0.1117740124,
1.1023621559,
-0.049550388,
0.5843772292,
-0.5336450338,
1.0215997696,
-0.8129487634,
0.3125927746,
-0.0082138842,
-0.5423255563,
-0.4081381559,
0.4200209081,
-0.2710865736,
-0.1203485429,
0.5108588338,
0.5127601027,
-0.1927728653,
-0.1531246156,
0.2214863449,
0.3981742561,
0.303470701,
-0.0603301227,
0.6735606194,
0.1640927196,
0.3886865973,
-0.2747059762,
-0.1854071915,
-0.3878735602,
-0.9145525098,
-0.9643505216,
-0.7390782833,
-0.2046054155,
0.1926791221,
-0.192234844,
0.7475203872,
0.5026324987,
-0.7028311491,
-0.4899111688,
0.0046605058,
0.2714550793,
0.1725742817,
-0.276054889,
0.6639510393,
-0.4900635779,
-0.7123326659,
0.6046077013,
0.4231244624,
0.2083884925,
-0.3117200136,
0.4193412364,
0.1949510127,
0.030727081,
0.6025079489,
0.1620516032,
-0.1906102896,
0.0258014258,
-0.0185165051,
-0.022240473,
0.1814907491,
1.0351266861,
-0.8785603642,
0.6600055099,
0.6577964425,
0.5124387741,
0.5695793629,
-0.2282072306,
0.7136610746,
-0.7096918225,
-0.0371558219,
0.0637920499,
0.4651913047,
0.385627836,
-0.4324936271,
0.6081722379,
0.1356547922,
-0.3033580184,
-0.9819905162,
0.0547107384,
-0.7911567092,
-0.5405210257,
0.8721497655,
0.1982570589,
-0.1107193902,
-0.5768233538,
-0.3466396034,
0.109965466,
-0.3165176809,
0.9749799967,
0.5129643679,
-0.5586175919,
0.1467000842,
-0.9037647843,
0.7697095275,
0.2136813104,
-1.3819253445,
0.1566218585,
0.4943364859,
0.4115386903,
-0.0815627947,
0.5726571083,
-0.0445665531,
-0.1522613913,
-0.2511109412,
0.1757533252,
-0.0198721047,
-0.1416775882,
-0.4541410506,
-0.1244174093,
-0.1568862051,
0.0599736162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14154v1
|
MM-Soc: Benchmarking Multimodal Large Language Models in Social Media Platforms
| 2024-02-21T22:27:40 | 2024-02-21T22:27:40 |
Yiqiao Jin, Minje Choi, Gaurav Verma, Jindong Wang, Srijan Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Social media platforms are hubs for multimodal information exchange,
encompassing text, images, and videos, making it challenging for machines to
comprehend the information or emotions associated with interactions in online
spaces. Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have emerged as a promising
solution to address these challenges, yet struggle with accurately interpreting
human emotions and complex contents like misinformation. This paper introduces
MM-Soc, a comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate MLLMs' understanding of
multimodal social media content. MM-Soc compiles prominent multimodal datasets
and incorporates a novel large-scale YouTube tagging dataset, targeting a range
of tasks from misinformation detection, hate speech detection, and social
context generation. Through our exhaustive evaluation on ten size-variants of
four open-source MLLMs, we have identified significant performance disparities,
highlighting the need for advancements in models' social understanding
capabilities. Our analysis reveals that, in a zero-shot setting, various types
of MLLMs generally exhibit difficulties in handling social media tasks.
However, MLLMs demonstrate performance improvements post fine-tuning,
suggesting potential pathways for improvement.
|
[
-0.5349414349,
-0.6008626223,
0.3931696415,
0.4026719928,
-0.3980374038,
0.5801753402,
-0.2949802876,
-0.2307393998,
0.2493548691,
0.0778300911,
-0.7215180993,
-0.5421376824,
-0.7501142025,
0.0510331765,
-0.2200729996,
0.7696463466,
0.1223355457,
0.3259557784,
-0.1634521186,
-0.3408103287,
-0.1390882581,
-0.4839018583,
-0.4636155963,
0.0888397247,
0.7617819309,
0.1544083357,
0.6164366007,
0.3018776476,
0.6585714817,
0.2509976029,
0.1159479171,
0.6144198775,
-0.7147747874,
0.1128083915,
-0.2602918148,
-0.0912571698,
-0.4364069104,
0.0424928591,
0.9023633599,
0.3586449921,
0.3056004941,
0.5591285825,
-0.0140978694,
0.4812716842,
-0.9813234806,
0.0876852497,
-0.8148418069,
-0.1216465309,
-0.1586448997,
-0.1920664459,
-0.440125376,
-0.1011296883,
-0.3430018723,
-0.1959765255,
0.0557005778,
-0.0735761896,
0.5612383485,
0.1851850301,
-0.5760445595,
-0.1999588609,
-0.659488678,
0.8355997801,
-0.4648387134,
0.6917691231,
0.2621314526,
0.566544354,
0.0630637929,
-0.3429810703,
-0.5699520707,
-0.1162306815,
0.2321659625,
0.0303735584,
-0.2224458158,
-0.1214946359,
0.2266416103,
-0.0375969894,
-0.6843692064,
-0.0998710543,
-0.4114077091,
-0.2485565692,
0.6254600883,
0.121586889,
0.2755235732,
-0.2955182791,
-0.3221480846,
0.0044627632,
-0.5673388243,
-0.0889898911,
0.3424948752,
0.3843970001,
-0.2358691543,
0.7912120819,
-0.1981994361,
0.4448231459,
-0.3928407431,
-0.351973623,
0.5652993917,
-0.4793002903,
-0.1612188667,
-0.1868282557,
0.9000066519,
0.7480149269,
0.391117245,
-0.0509589724,
-0.1272974163,
0.4863007963,
0.0931489915,
-0.8688831329,
0.0596466511,
0.0658830702,
-0.4969242215,
-0.159360081,
-0.0299808066,
-0.8358768821,
-0.6201788187,
-0.3378000855,
0.4136210382,
-0.4170864224,
-0.4780424237,
-0.0900081545,
-0.3045985997,
0.0419358909,
0.2083235383,
-0.3923614323,
-0.0135853002,
0.8096898794,
1.2170237303,
0.0527354814,
-0.277924031,
-0.8000563383,
0.1519899368,
-0.2303515822,
0.582131207,
-0.7670801878,
-0.1253141761,
-0.0360756293,
0.0221244823,
-0.2686967254,
-0.2145059556,
0.4353139102,
-0.2195352912,
-0.44024387,
-0.3960789144,
-0.3298017383,
0.2312209308,
0.5002954602,
-0.5667595863,
0.8101184368,
-0.0669808388,
-0.6568728685,
0.2204567194,
-0.5548634529,
-0.2242165655,
-0.0875985026,
-0.131133914,
-0.1068698168,
0.284455359,
0.0357208624,
0.7123122811,
-0.3025898933,
0.2376333922,
-0.9592773914,
-0.2989965379,
0.4814630449,
-0.5374850631,
0.4967366755,
0.3672783375,
-0.2692510784,
0.1028726026,
-0.8403222561,
-0.0341304764,
0.0020175942,
0.0018415409,
-0.3957779706,
0.1508641243,
0.1136275232,
0.6490299702,
0.2396307588,
-0.77849406,
-0.2210721672,
0.2179353684,
0.6163284779,
0.8572778106,
-0.2569394708,
0.1199733913,
-0.1933796853,
0.3213480115,
0.1431186795,
0.3507346213,
-0.2184419632,
-0.451271385,
-0.3511327207,
-0.4884592891,
0.146050185,
0.3038430512,
-1.0031417608,
-0.1100368798,
-0.3409695923,
-0.7682865262,
-0.9180228114,
0.3944511116,
0.446333915,
0.0785162076,
0.2037962228,
-0.1872660965,
-0.4947885275,
-0.9746614099,
-0.172225982,
-0.1265396923,
-0.0064054923,
0.494550705,
0.5175904036,
-0.4918632209,
0.6380207539,
-0.1587823331,
0.0074041812,
-0.0694717914,
0.4246757925,
-0.4470318258,
0.1018255427,
0.625921905,
-0.8774328828,
-0.6246043444,
0.0281190611,
-0.6022593379,
-0.2316915095,
0.1348444074,
-0.0281082802,
0.1325665265,
0.404769063,
-0.6922804713,
0.0851774886,
0.9539542794,
-0.2382960021,
0.7349420786,
0.021264948,
0.4111758769,
-0.9755994081,
0.0379831344,
0.3121388853,
-0.2963354886,
-0.5022444725,
-0.0642748252,
0.3368682861,
-0.1346681863,
-0.677056849,
0.4299328923,
-0.4074715376,
-0.2600277364,
-0.0287511759,
0.4953609109,
0.0080449767,
0.3727151453,
-0.297182709,
0.6215627193,
0.4098657966,
-0.4644110501,
0.3625514805,
-0.3442199528,
-0.3531561494,
0.732452631,
-0.4937953651,
0.0354163423,
-0.4436080754,
0.236124754,
-1.2711642981,
-0.2370943725,
0.0694629699,
-0.6798892021,
-0.0745709315,
-0.1393357515,
-0.9074931145,
-0.3152612448,
-0.6290908456,
0.3700733483,
0.0279801246,
-0.2225484699,
0.6087543964,
0.5930293798,
0.0640050471,
-0.5981791615,
-0.3072852492,
0.1435574293,
-0.0726370439,
-0.6106684804,
0.182926327,
-0.4072959125,
-0.319675535,
-0.0229077004,
0.1948477179,
0.0064147934,
0.0010672275,
0.2640179098,
0.0806765556,
-0.3201862276,
0.4645796418,
-0.0102627715,
0.0971722156,
-0.0836578906,
0.2900999784,
0.9316273928,
-0.2193006873,
-0.4710046053,
-0.2458607107,
0.2858571112,
1.0332785845,
-0.5212457776,
0.8329108357,
1.1987890005,
-0.3993195593,
0.0595821142,
-0.7093212605,
0.0586328767,
-0.4006491303,
0.3816000819,
-0.3721728623,
-0.9123620391,
0.4517533779,
0.0074368892,
0.0561575182,
0.359484762,
0.6595089436,
-0.0487435125,
1.5009434223,
0.428509742,
-0.2809004784,
0.4384404123,
0.1375259906,
0.0524456166,
-0.6173404455,
-0.0885946751,
-0.5324547291,
-0.3901580274,
-0.6482921839,
-0.8054546118,
0.2047275007,
-0.1798902899,
-0.2660532296,
0.2512347102,
-0.0534879752,
0.4399668276,
0.1726596355,
0.0325976312,
0.2316244841,
-0.1813273728,
-0.048369851,
-0.0682305619,
-0.497842133,
-0.5252550244,
0.9532693624,
0.5142465234,
0.6574410796,
0.4049421251,
0.2960881591,
0.3056590557,
0.4742154777,
-0.6132054925,
0.5423197746,
-0.4764494896,
-0.6258458495,
-0.0193101969,
-0.6137308478,
-0.5981548429,
0.520929873,
-0.4337582588,
-0.659204185,
-0.1229689717,
0.1180475578,
-0.2367512882,
0.4239323139,
-0.8653516769,
0.9769094586,
-0.3495520949,
-0.4450440705,
-0.3353953362,
-0.6248063445,
0.3771089911,
-0.0375834666,
0.5771517158,
-0.5512840748,
-0.1525856853,
0.3200796545,
0.1909151822,
0.9571377635,
-0.2268052548,
0.1877710074,
0.0960129574,
0.0105648898,
0.1536952406,
-0.0297998916,
0.0363901556,
0.1086119488,
0.1595184803,
-0.3026016057,
-0.4385794103,
0.8459991813,
-0.7111778259,
0.0237012506,
0.0028389674,
-0.5378228426,
-0.3425190747,
-0.0090278788,
-0.0639445707,
0.5397434831,
-0.389567852,
0.7534888983,
0.7233855724,
-0.2573786378,
0.410610199,
0.5901886225,
-0.3307547569,
-0.3626228273,
1.0637212992,
0.1006249189,
0.3878407776,
0.4048530459,
0.0095434058,
-0.334582448,
-0.1325488389,
-0.6546768546,
0.3090896606,
-0.5570846796,
-0.2520762682,
-1.0088424683,
-0.1703957617,
-0.5955079794,
0.051890336,
-0.6395732164,
-0.1020804048,
-0.0345723294,
0.1170312241,
0.0888906941,
0.520650804,
-0.1188175455,
0.3779688478,
-0.9305562973,
0.3282570541,
0.1360919476,
0.6156464815,
0.0443828069,
-0.2407137901,
-0.1927226484,
0.3000549376,
-0.2542722523,
-0.9290282726,
0.2183808684,
0.2252967358,
0.496424228,
0.5642008185,
-0.1606271416,
0.7332089543,
-0.5488644242,
0.5845150948,
0.262319386,
-0.874085784,
0.2980502844,
-0.4131774306,
0.3830694854,
0.4495604634,
0.6585623026,
-0.7360523939,
-0.3132120669,
-0.3015954196,
-0.5491985083,
0.2480695844,
0.236862272,
0.2802596092,
-0.2366395593,
-0.1497117132,
-0.077847898,
0.4925235808,
-0.841514647,
-0.0626329556,
-0.1493434757,
-0.268788904,
-0.6168752313,
-0.2613753676,
0.0492978655,
-0.1242226735,
0.5849199891,
-0.1522965878,
0.1194326058,
-0.1785446852,
-0.4550276697,
-0.1998573393,
0.235538125,
0.8737339973,
0.7840967178,
-0.4073290229,
0.3905660808,
-0.0717368796,
-0.2890068293,
-0.1467335969,
0.0077503873,
0.2298179418,
0.2862313986,
0.0717143714,
0.6646711826,
0.3715801835,
-1.0771205425,
0.6074830294,
-0.1909942329,
-0.1561047137,
0.0082158353,
-0.1690229177,
0.2691133618,
0.3865689337,
0.2331174612,
0.0061170193,
0.0934453085,
-0.8781135082,
0.0912193954,
0.7297452092,
-0.5926084518,
-0.4099746943,
0.3444099426,
0.0768590793,
-0.3265265226,
-0.0545049645,
-0.3048722148,
-0.4450072646,
0.4076220989,
0.353790313,
0.7058609128,
-0.3178002238,
0.6567632556,
0.3010160625,
0.5968940258,
0.1015471071,
0.1261425465,
-0.0569084883,
-0.7354331017,
-0.5002828836,
-0.6943429112,
-0.3556652069,
0.1959284395,
-0.4165321887,
0.2434875369,
-0.4928866923,
-0.3776789904,
0.5043762326,
-0.1541956067,
-0.756460309,
0.0744257793,
0.2879354656,
0.7168955803,
-0.9525396228,
0.5610864758,
0.6399205923,
-0.1618521363,
-0.3064469099,
-0.362545222,
0.3922670782,
-0.61628896,
0.4412949383,
0.423917383,
-0.5022642612,
-0.3303467631,
-0.6113267541,
-0.6574442983,
0.8631356955,
0.359260112,
-0.5307456851,
0.2989026904,
0.368357271,
0.7873271108,
-0.6419554353,
0.304869473,
0.2434490025,
0.2000047863,
0.0692497641,
-0.9510470629,
-0.2815898955,
-0.4405617714,
-0.0872956961,
0.3666704893,
-0.800344944,
1.0019538403,
0.182504043,
-0.1308573186,
-0.2339528501,
0.1912042201,
0.3288211823,
0.7807205319,
0.6199815273,
0.2896471918,
0.5701280832,
0.0836448893,
0.6767943501,
-0.3701007068,
0.3169754744,
1.0927168131,
-0.4251856804,
1.1390686035,
0.2707553208,
0.0477573276,
0.3028040528,
0.5349452496,
0.1548615545,
0.2440781146,
0.0685088784,
-0.3361554146,
-0.4208272099,
-0.3345719278,
-0.4027226865,
0.6815621853,
0.5441310406,
-0.5230194926,
-0.31227687,
0.0893539041,
-0.1122158468,
-0.0869379938,
-0.544674933,
0.6467251778,
-0.0495652333,
-0.3905938864,
0.2354821414,
0.0686822385,
0.7050265074,
-0.6326302886,
0.172902599,
0.0919385925,
0.1839207411,
0.0298960097,
-0.6630440354,
0.2966590226,
0.2154550701,
-0.2469204515,
-0.0936918035,
1.0019749403,
-0.4584525228,
-0.5989335775,
0.515770793,
0.6722968221,
0.1289534271,
-0.3825801313,
-0.8819538951,
0.4289555252,
-0.125866577,
0.2285912335,
0.4204115272,
0.6047843695,
0.0505312607,
0.7635326385,
0.6495412588,
-0.1882763952,
0.1853435785,
0.2981968224,
0.8773400784,
-0.4294352531,
-0.2000216395,
-1.2093296051,
0.4667878747,
-0.4155491889,
-0.2414398193,
0.7951382399,
0.6538277268,
0.8426193595,
-0.0084182369,
0.6975583434,
0.0373195596,
0.6193811893,
-0.1788786948,
0.7214194536,
-0.8747002482,
-0.1384763271,
-0.6962234378,
-0.8342670798,
-0.0818281472,
0.3993771076,
-0.1968209893,
-0.1161981672,
0.279038161,
0.9533622861,
-0.2558658123,
-0.0219808947,
0.5575310588,
0.1687007397,
0.2304921597,
0.264749378,
0.8741392493,
-0.1481303871,
0.669226408,
-0.2904999256,
-0.2867364883,
-0.3097571433,
-0.8196392059,
-1.1292136908,
-0.7616568804,
-0.0674663931,
-0.3896412849,
0.1366054118,
1.1465387344,
0.7416453958,
-0.4727341235,
-0.2505674064,
0.6042166352,
0.2001372278,
0.0094627328,
-0.1915899068,
-0.101941824,
-0.1724542677,
-0.5574498773,
0.0821888,
0.6340299845,
-0.1557427347,
-0.5289558768,
-0.0342030637,
-0.3968190253,
0.2149997354,
1.2045527697,
-0.0209530964,
-0.5512250662,
-0.224016428,
0.1726448089,
-0.1912364811,
-0.0661009699,
0.7830548882,
-0.1536806971,
0.6484105587,
0.4449570477,
0.7117878795,
0.3879106045,
-0.0646854937,
0.2366254926,
-0.808701396,
-0.0584585704,
0.0165288989,
0.3757205307,
0.5161839724,
0.1036833674,
0.3200502098,
0.3306451738,
-0.4258467257,
-1.0680866241,
0.1118438095,
-1.0103051662,
-0.343192935,
1.1783326864,
-0.0036005373,
-0.2540723085,
-0.0017773497,
-0.1243041307,
0.1849141121,
-0.4337746203,
0.8257135749,
0.9204182029,
0.4684029222,
-0.4209778011,
-0.9870775342,
0.1440060884,
0.1412226707,
-0.582241714,
0.1222528517,
0.6121332049,
0.1640711874,
0.2556960285,
0.7170732021,
0.048532065,
0.2114440203,
-0.0644125566,
-0.1649418622,
0.1958652735,
-0.5109115839,
0.0510593429,
0.3170450628,
-0.340488553,
-0.134879142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14151v2
|
BIRCO: A Benchmark of Information Retrieval Tasks with Complex Objectives
| 2024-02-21T22:22:30 | 2024-04-03T20:11:02 |
Xiaoyue Wang, Jianyou Wang, Weili Cao, Kaicheng Wang, Ramamohan Paturi, Leon Bergen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present the Benchmark of Information Retrieval (IR) tasks with Complex
Objectives (BIRCO). BIRCO evaluates the ability of IR systems to retrieve
documents given multi-faceted user objectives. The benchmark's complexity and
compact size make it suitable for evaluating large language model (LLM)-based
information retrieval systems. We present a modular framework for investigating
factors that may influence LLM performance on retrieval tasks, and identify a
simple baseline model which matches or outperforms existing approaches and more
complex alternatives. No approach achieves satisfactory performance on all
benchmark tasks, suggesting that stronger models and new retrieval protocols
are necessary to address complex user needs.
|
[
-0.201960519,
-0.5671957135,
0.5409780741,
0.5059041977,
-0.0462513566,
0.3766913116,
-0.2874756157,
-0.5252406001,
-0.2243936062,
0.2951904535,
-0.2635020316,
-0.4158198833,
-0.6141282916,
0.1747647524,
-0.4874062538,
0.928001821,
-0.0427419208,
0.2396806031,
-0.1104313359,
-0.0306875296,
-0.5669837594,
-0.4735064209,
-0.3954644501,
-0.5391122103,
1.0036623478,
0.7391763926,
0.4690000117,
0.3828102648,
1.1829384565,
0.2015130818,
-0.1683796942,
0.1233079508,
-0.6832839847,
0.3370845616,
-0.4423445761,
-0.526514709,
-0.3657281101,
-0.1099063009,
0.7363791466,
1.0389449596,
-0.4654990137,
0.3424509764,
-0.0472759455,
0.7709861398,
-0.9906376004,
-0.1523975581,
-0.4618517756,
-0.0346074216,
-0.3159012198,
-0.366454035,
-0.4760933816,
-0.363912642,
0.156276986,
-0.2639693618,
0.149588123,
0.7042291164,
0.8338680267,
-0.0110405842,
-0.6602917314,
-0.6112797856,
-1.083111763,
0.8210506439,
-0.244676441,
0.5012800694,
0.4051670432,
0.5868054032,
-0.1627975702,
-0.9527235031,
-0.4824437201,
-0.2035110295,
-0.0685807541,
0.0308843907,
-0.4429767728,
0.1025842205,
0.3732974529,
0.3616038561,
-0.6357777119,
-0.2766377926,
-0.4770621657,
0.0967578366,
0.1543982625,
0.4777719676,
0.0613820739,
-0.2529890537,
-0.7570656538,
-0.1190699339,
-0.6910383701,
0.0893891603,
0.5213831067,
0.3572476506,
0.0879038498,
0.8857980967,
-0.6489852071,
0.7089604735,
-0.1446415931,
-0.1039054841,
0.1809580028,
-0.4581528604,
-0.1388482451,
-0.0798974037,
0.3615950048,
0.2230178714,
-0.1400009394,
-0.6809785366,
-0.5494219661,
-0.3626688719,
0.2237258554,
-0.9580247402,
0.1014585868,
0.069077231,
-0.6371822357,
0.2596437633,
0.3269521594,
-0.7053098679,
-0.0026687423,
-0.5263054371,
0.7329856157,
-0.3845250309,
0.1232505515,
0.1694348752,
-0.2220617533,
0.3180642128,
0.0944063738,
-0.4792343378,
0.6223450899,
0.8195798397,
0.7668082714,
-0.2606180012,
-0.2940688729,
-0.9103481174,
0.3291245997,
-0.0615395866,
1.2452867031,
-0.7855582237,
-0.3362745345,
-0.0707772151,
-0.0109656723,
0.0512718447,
-0.8155571222,
0.7053461075,
-0.7662031651,
0.0233764686,
-0.643900156,
-0.1722509861,
-0.2019238323,
0.4254687428,
-0.5844877958,
1.1077103615,
0.2906397879,
-0.5271219015,
0.2157855779,
-0.3739216924,
-0.5025692582,
0.1740008891,
0.0104176132,
-0.1397531927,
0.0015244572,
-0.7311437726,
0.2104538381,
-1.2271746397,
0.2764237523,
-0.2819146216,
-0.5251216888,
0.1168946177,
0.0942450315,
0.416557312,
0.4377745092,
-0.2997387946,
-0.1266497523,
-0.6778452396,
0.2931030393,
-0.3211358488,
-0.8851907849,
-0.4250451028,
0.2687328458,
0.2818090618,
-0.0336553454,
0.714820981,
-0.5836700201,
0.2425675839,
0.2725328207,
0.0902298689,
0.3006589711,
-0.249997288,
0.2037813663,
-0.4031846821,
0.3431892395,
-0.1537440866,
0.2340639532,
0.2602097392,
0.0847137198,
-0.7089314461,
-0.5605291128,
0.55391711,
0.6711257696,
-0.2811856866,
0.3360638618,
-0.3139489293,
-0.6457802057,
-0.1718768328,
0.3166800737,
0.8862570524,
0.3581470847,
0.3880245984,
-0.5765538812,
-0.5354477167,
-1.3669897318,
-0.375293076,
-0.0432138368,
-0.1043940857,
0.3561062515,
0.6040709615,
-0.5114842057,
0.4798419476,
-0.3371675909,
-0.4824942648,
-0.281147927,
0.7274357677,
0.3277814388,
0.1803386509,
0.2807261646,
-1.0911906958,
-0.4897996485,
0.2757441401,
-0.6219055653,
-0.2446849197,
0.3495034873,
-0.170177862,
-0.2829961479,
0.3861800134,
-0.5250587463,
0.4272918999,
0.2720496058,
-0.3517953455,
0.5203000307,
-0.3883244395,
0.4904763103,
-0.6593089104,
0.8390175104,
-0.2763737738,
-0.2171954066,
-0.5420819521,
0.0425252914,
0.310379535,
-0.0496154353,
0.0561233535,
0.3130741119,
-0.773082912,
-0.6760198474,
-0.2368133664,
0.2302112579,
0.1369321197,
0.3666518927,
-0.2129487991,
0.6824261546,
0.1574952602,
-0.6537023783,
0.2715671659,
0.1000659317,
-0.6961322427,
1.0298331976,
-0.8855322599,
0.1118439883,
-0.3354801536,
-0.153485328,
-1.1507962942,
-0.2331368029,
-0.3018721342,
-0.1885624677,
0.371735841,
-0.1875912845,
-0.8482208252,
-0.0965919495,
-0.1146220118,
0.5279014707,
0.0484492294,
-0.2025799155,
0.8512838483,
0.3162626624,
-0.3599008918,
-0.774209857,
-0.3615332842,
0.3344550133,
-0.0422538631,
-0.3013024628,
0.6630007029,
-0.2439483404,
-0.377764225,
0.11717733,
-0.0558371171,
-0.223029986,
-0.0602903105,
0.0968815759,
0.2776437104,
-0.1231538653,
-0.2617230117,
-0.2204375416,
0.0229708329,
-0.2506017983,
0.377589196,
0.7198802829,
-0.2776251733,
-0.2933615148,
-0.0690352172,
0.8279771209,
0.6581891179,
-0.4229042232,
0.3987027109,
0.2282657623,
-0.3108018637,
0.0328939408,
-0.8899317384,
0.1497620046,
-0.4258274138,
0.4712985754,
-0.6056635976,
-0.5095507503,
0.6803022623,
-0.2308291644,
-0.1807872355,
-0.0047520036,
0.6474546194,
-0.1364025921,
1.0403499603,
0.6141187549,
0.212966904,
0.4883998036,
-0.1318574697,
0.2179513127,
-1.2099051476,
-0.8177264333,
-1.0840642452,
-0.5200002789,
-0.1143821478,
-0.3202991486,
0.4575876892,
0.4894782305,
-0.4321299791,
0.5520071983,
-0.3342615962,
0.1001959741,
0.6259595752,
0.1220322028,
0.4766310751,
-0.1205433533,
-0.1438183635,
0.2651701272,
-0.4367030859,
-0.5053316951,
0.8244243264,
-0.1086404771,
0.9821993709,
0.7047023773,
0.1164731309,
0.5967947245,
0.2996283472,
-0.7061259747,
0.4297362268,
-0.1157472432,
-0.9812925458,
-0.0223712046,
-0.5151570439,
-1.2637014389,
0.2200719416,
-0.2967799306,
-0.7611657381,
0.6170225143,
-0.1838956326,
-0.1600937396,
-0.0290778466,
-0.5411016941,
0.7298315167,
-0.3813233078,
-0.5673123002,
-0.4487298429,
-0.6500552297,
-0.0012323699,
0.0322406106,
0.1406393051,
-0.2625918388,
-0.3700736165,
0.5464034677,
0.0589439049,
0.3279592395,
-0.0883685946,
0.7214129567,
-0.063767761,
0.3830784857,
0.5978134871,
-0.4560385942,
-0.4825997353,
-0.0886071995,
0.3736390173,
-0.4535283744,
-0.3180767894,
0.5129370093,
-0.612146616,
-0.4414441884,
-0.4083177745,
-0.570673883,
-0.1664870977,
0.6338831782,
0.1153436378,
0.6359165907,
-0.2475058585,
1.0113030672,
0.5367500186,
-0.0068668402,
0.1635656059,
1.0613490343,
0.0566847585,
-0.2009020597,
0.5519451499,
0.1020345837,
0.1475684047,
0.7651672363,
0.0868344977,
-0.2464341074,
-0.8816530108,
-0.0889370665,
0.1736641377,
-0.6575117111,
-0.5623093843,
-0.4969498813,
0.1127114519,
-0.0367638506,
0.2601038814,
-0.3815849423,
0.1298263669,
0.0560213104,
0.4231748283,
-0.1467830688,
0.8385107517,
-0.0783171132,
0.1958590299,
-0.3857613206,
0.4603779912,
0.1941319555,
0.5768209696,
-0.1419365853,
-0.6195243001,
-0.2788590491,
-0.303209573,
-0.2769567668,
-0.5120659471,
-0.0216633342,
0.1295583695,
0.927519083,
0.2230174541,
0.1328504086,
0.7414738536,
-0.4605207145,
0.1322350949,
0.2431905121,
-0.6997461319,
0.2849980295,
-0.3591167331,
0.0889748111,
0.9623798728,
0.4782519937,
-0.3783041239,
0.1114706248,
0.0723389164,
-0.9587711692,
0.6817737818,
0.1797536612,
-0.2412816137,
-0.0309307631,
0.4116477966,
-0.1008119136,
0.4176394343,
-0.5081461668,
-0.1097410023,
0.3263978064,
-0.1399659812,
0.1746623516,
-0.6147205234,
-0.3140278161,
0.1544222385,
0.284142524,
0.10843952,
0.4093678892,
0.5864386559,
-0.1618982852,
-0.2212031782,
0.360648185,
0.4913984835,
0.8633487821,
-0.5426237583,
0.2020214945,
-0.0312977619,
-0.3034840226,
-0.0833548307,
0.2215479314,
-0.0239887293,
-0.2331718206,
0.3381972611,
0.4705647528,
0.5694646835,
-1.0707417727,
0.5456207991,
-0.1529959142,
-0.0412214883,
-0.3219106197,
0.0598479547,
-0.0062258681,
0.4749023318,
0.8346813917,
0.0440014303,
0.6644463539,
-1.1590124369,
0.0906980559,
0.6386300325,
-0.4436021745,
-0.2966658175,
0.5858130455,
-0.1077705175,
-0.7515155673,
0.2903646529,
-0.1156815439,
-0.3864779174,
0.4404979348,
0.4904035032,
0.4528092146,
-0.2232930958,
-0.1747934967,
0.4413015544,
0.2795110047,
-0.3645379841,
0.5350154638,
-0.143904537,
-0.3135321438,
-0.041698873,
-0.5550453663,
-0.6244937778,
-0.2315298021,
-1.0478893518,
0.3135356605,
-0.4817851186,
-0.194155544,
0.1922282428,
0.2244098783,
-0.8979603648,
0.2095511854,
-0.2219788134,
0.9106397033,
-0.1086745113,
0.7239695787,
0.5476234555,
-0.3714202344,
-0.5536524057,
-0.3451826274,
-0.3150874972,
-0.5682015419,
1.0245227814,
-0.067624405,
-0.6820263863,
-0.3343141079,
-0.2935304344,
-0.8751606345,
1.2170073986,
0.3261804283,
-0.6782984138,
-0.1393891722,
0.1975047141,
0.5474408269,
-0.4508179426,
0.4150573015,
0.3447452188,
0.6743888855,
0.1062842533,
-0.9936705828,
-0.0612229668,
-0.2310759574,
0.0000277484,
0.1025977284,
-0.8586575985,
1.1479760408,
-0.0961630344,
-0.2984368801,
0.3678637147,
0.2824955881,
0.146940276,
0.4723820984,
0.6801671386,
0.3164281547,
0.7151733637,
-0.0606640354,
1.1380957365,
-0.3208748102,
0.3798080981,
1.1379878521,
-0.6074283123,
1.1949021816,
0.4356899261,
-0.2182064354,
0.6478379369,
0.3159630597,
-0.0103492131,
0.7631336451,
0.1767646223,
-0.2589888573,
-0.3701503575,
-0.2390514016,
-0.1452568918,
0.5695819259,
0.3014423251,
-0.1163584739,
-0.2904388011,
-0.2230796367,
-0.1298830956,
0.1959018856,
-0.180102393,
0.680119276,
-0.2599293292,
-1.0357767344,
0.3066064119,
0.2226091921,
0.3048292696,
-0.7350889444,
0.0725099593,
-0.2253533453,
0.4546470642,
-0.2483842671,
-0.7198442817,
0.1163808331,
0.0891755372,
-0.5658788085,
0.1591839343,
0.514696002,
-0.3334292173,
-0.4526959062,
0.8429322243,
0.2264681607,
0.2001893073,
0.0194805097,
-0.6731057167,
0.2611513436,
-0.0795783848,
-0.3834789991,
0.2671559453,
0.5483637452,
0.1406507939,
0.9218778014,
0.4671459794,
0.0505563542,
-0.0493771322,
-0.0693692639,
0.8186761737,
-0.8500583768,
0.0767117366,
-0.4211585224,
0.2411994487,
-0.1045207381,
-0.3267025948,
0.5518102646,
1.2243535519,
0.5778267384,
0.2158436775,
0.5381788015,
-0.4253434539,
0.9743930697,
-0.3464701474,
0.2594226301,
-0.8329675794,
0.3914155662,
-0.1714208722,
-1.195849061,
-0.1886081398,
0.4165781438,
-0.1790615618,
0.0559524782,
0.7198662758,
0.9562428594,
-0.2938824594,
-0.3580407202,
0.3612074852,
0.1414896548,
0.0796884298,
0.5354858637,
0.9729944468,
-0.4016507566,
0.9394545555,
-0.0890539885,
-0.3166931868,
-0.6331048608,
-0.7568811774,
-0.8422571421,
-0.6206640005,
0.0874798819,
-0.196392104,
0.2160356045,
0.7240669727,
0.8040180802,
-0.6321863532,
-0.5510802269,
0.3907175362,
0.093556419,
-0.0249011666,
-0.180531472,
0.0792600363,
-0.3728366792,
-0.7740553617,
0.2194420397,
0.5591821671,
-0.4717314839,
-0.1515413225,
-0.019619558,
-0.4770759344,
0.0023720942,
0.6932545304,
0.4297812283,
-0.4965620935,
-0.5145549178,
0.3489832878,
-0.5030195117,
0.1141288579,
1.1145272255,
-0.30215922,
0.3968363106,
0.6179422736,
0.3698331416,
0.8520892859,
0.161359638,
0.4679806232,
-0.3283278346,
-0.0379075445,
0.2205724269,
0.3600098193,
0.2759428918,
-0.1402541995,
0.5985277295,
-0.0754650384,
-0.7879662514,
-1.122386694,
0.014209548,
-1.4681965113,
-0.308349967,
1.1270438433,
-0.1707830876,
-0.1846581995,
-0.5207155347,
-0.125222832,
0.0691491514,
-0.1746394634,
0.787091136,
0.5000517368,
-0.082872048,
0.1444197148,
-0.6346591115,
-0.0151229454,
0.2499040067,
-0.6630562544,
0.1599465162,
0.4273334742,
0.5376024842,
0.2466678619,
0.4766138494,
-0.2831970453,
0.3811859787,
-0.1567645073,
0.504319191,
0.1946165115,
-0.6113122702,
0.4007306993,
0.4393292367,
0.2044602185,
0.1941732466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14146v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14146v1
|
Reinforcement Learning with Dynamic Multi-Reward Weighting for Multi-Style Controllable Generation
| 2024-02-21T22:02:37 | 2024-02-21T22:02:37 |
Karin de Langis, Ryan Koo, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Style is an integral component of text that expresses a diverse set of
information, including interpersonal dynamics (e.g. formality) and the author's
emotions or attitudes (e.g. disgust). Humans often employ multiple styles
simultaneously. An open question is how large language models can be explicitly
controlled so that they weave together target styles when generating text: for
example, to produce text that is both negative and non-toxic. Previous work
investigates the controlled generation of a single style, or else controlled
generation of a style and other attributes. In this paper, we expand this into
controlling multiple styles simultaneously. Specifically, we investigate
various formulations of multiple style rewards for a reinforcement learning
(RL) approach to controlled multi-style generation. These reward formulations
include calibrated outputs from discriminators and dynamic weighting by
discriminator gradient magnitudes. We find that dynamic weighting generally
outperforms static weighting approaches, and we explore its effectiveness in 2-
and 3-style control, even compared to strong baselines like plug-and-play
model. All code and data for RL pipelines with multiple style attributes will
be publicly available.
|
[
-0.2882734835,
-0.6830123663,
0.16582416,
0.7157942057,
0.0274785794,
0.4209046066,
-0.4002052844,
-0.2612540424,
0.3057659566,
0.2727974057,
-0.7987041473,
-0.1435546875,
-0.6408005357,
0.1099211574,
-0.0630552843,
1.300073266,
-0.4157564938,
-0.0379524082,
0.0300148055,
-0.3803087473,
-0.5536333323,
-0.7295932174,
-0.5680234432,
-0.5882390738,
1.1613668203,
0.6222801208,
0.4498964846,
0.3892288804,
0.3227007985,
0.3187825382,
0.08858601,
0.3010373712,
-0.5611814857,
0.6405841112,
0.039208632,
-0.1650523394,
-0.2096344233,
0.3363572061,
0.6091594696,
-0.0629381239,
-0.3516633809,
-0.0770281181,
0.1051614732,
0.7246430516,
-0.7824577689,
0.152579695,
-0.309667021,
0.3486598432,
-0.1907521933,
-0.5581284165,
-0.593649447,
-0.5480974913,
-0.231753543,
-0.5323442817,
-0.2879114151,
-0.0734056011,
0.6186488271,
0.0887248144,
-0.790343225,
-0.6104444265,
-0.89195472,
1.0556995869,
-0.3471941352,
0.2704623938,
-0.0246436,
0.3113029003,
0.1317260116,
-0.5331239104,
-0.4823327661,
-0.3606050313,
-0.2213477939,
0.4268420637,
0.3244096637,
-0.1385523826,
0.1952889264,
0.1173995659,
-0.1216833144,
0.1408475935,
-0.101709716,
0.0361407921,
0.789249301,
0.0509746149,
0.2143063992,
-0.001511895,
-0.6597549915,
-0.5758416653,
-0.6037070155,
0.2033141702,
0.6339266896,
0.3583703637,
-0.1482685506,
0.4458010793,
-0.0311958231,
0.3057005107,
0.1061399505,
-0.5136728287,
0.2722427249,
-0.4914367199,
0.3392475247,
0.1961377412,
0.6846844554,
0.294342041,
0.31580621,
0.0374110267,
-0.5069980025,
-0.0636535659,
0.5955941081,
-0.7279952168,
-0.1854369193,
0.1041661054,
-0.5088160038,
-0.7665188909,
-0.0494348109,
-1.0038779974,
-0.5755263567,
-0.4459958673,
0.4750771821,
-0.3276226819,
-0.4074242115,
-0.0999216586,
-0.2556644082,
0.2315098345,
0.2490665466,
-1.090007782,
0.3345427215,
0.0444358736,
0.6660735607,
-0.3995383978,
-0.3396632075,
-0.7028226852,
0.1158495173,
-0.3319298327,
0.3853368461,
-0.5907079577,
-0.1905645132,
0.1234432459,
-0.2750458121,
0.1837887615,
-0.3494066894,
0.1908927709,
-0.6154125929,
0.2009063214,
-0.2162109911,
-0.1782249063,
0.1155893207,
0.1310114413,
-0.7265129685,
0.8361996412,
-0.0412193723,
-0.5819454193,
0.6535656452,
-0.5918691754,
-0.6476225853,
0.0761125386,
-0.2085961848,
-0.6811102629,
0.0614986792,
-0.2671598196,
0.3485094905,
0.231598258,
0.2598978579,
-0.391225636,
-0.3180583417,
0.4101567864,
-0.462120086,
0.1801393628,
0.2964625359,
-0.5223639011,
0.5095640421,
-0.6477309465,
0.1345336735,
0.416962564,
-0.7067175508,
-0.2315458953,
0.2162325978,
0.2645115256,
0.5857728124,
0.2481213659,
-0.3010194004,
0.3106461167,
0.3164484203,
0.3135068715,
0.9370448589,
0.0557125993,
0.2845364213,
-0.5752488375,
0.6371564865,
-0.1936118603,
0.1252056211,
-0.0741067454,
-0.0036236614,
-0.6165220737,
-0.2474407107,
-0.0456010476,
0.4600166976,
-0.9125373363,
0.1756178886,
0.3192912936,
-0.4649471343,
-0.0280894898,
-0.0618228987,
0.6789950728,
-0.0580005944,
0.51759094,
-0.0341791324,
-0.1232286543,
-0.5672010779,
-0.4660837352,
0.1766858846,
0.12829943,
0.4500497282,
0.4025172293,
0.3010590374,
0.5088137984,
-0.545547545,
-0.1236269847,
-0.3368394971,
0.8034496903,
-0.2638381124,
0.6423851848,
0.6224552989,
-0.988153398,
-0.5052500963,
-0.2693102658,
-0.5189630389,
-0.1612392217,
-0.5044104457,
-0.0072747525,
0.1243627667,
0.4666366875,
-0.0545704365,
0.1430955231,
0.6531960964,
-0.2152440399,
0.9604982138,
-0.3763186634,
0.1395458728,
-0.6391717792,
0.0192536265,
0.2979792953,
-0.1392034739,
-0.6953440905,
0.2004058212,
0.1690591276,
0.0537672453,
-0.5089207292,
0.4817005694,
-0.2871890664,
0.1764018834,
-0.2173235118,
-0.219701767,
0.252687335,
0.8789262176,
0.3123307526,
0.7077051401,
0.1569477022,
-0.6875594854,
0.6280984282,
-0.1354007572,
-0.230055064,
0.7116474509,
-0.5879480243,
-0.0013791188,
-0.2969549596,
0.3236255348,
-0.7807483673,
-0.0557060167,
0.0487663411,
-0.0489442721,
0.4190517962,
0.2542253733,
-0.5587450266,
-0.1481851041,
-0.5674686432,
0.4327010214,
0.1298294067,
-0.4480922222,
0.4089100063,
0.1554692239,
-0.3608720303,
-0.6196814179,
-0.5589480996,
-0.2597070336,
-0.6024479866,
0.063528128,
0.5834578872,
-0.5133562684,
-0.13493599,
-0.243981421,
-0.0219983552,
0.1628872454,
0.1972518861,
0.0203615185,
0.0834903345,
0.3203941286,
0.2177457958,
0.2095259726,
0.0608123057,
-0.0481161848,
-0.0863746926,
0.8096451759,
-0.0156322699,
-0.3103269339,
-0.3563153446,
0.3775096834,
0.5456988215,
-0.5635715723,
0.8462170362,
0.6435818672,
-0.0358105712,
-0.4376072288,
-0.2547231019,
-0.2446515709,
-0.520618856,
0.2197239548,
-0.3698360324,
-0.6050064564,
0.462138027,
-0.0334782079,
0.2553994358,
0.1629576981,
0.6603838205,
0.0613360964,
1.3657544851,
0.5015561581,
0.2725995779,
1.0101686716,
-0.013554831,
-0.1413646936,
-0.4660662413,
-0.5629607439,
-0.3656318188,
-0.7703551054,
-0.8751168251,
0.0308884233,
0.4374313653,
0.1372220218,
-0.5078383684,
0.0328260884,
-0.4876610339,
0.3838612139,
0.8039965034,
0.2379671335,
0.22151573,
-0.1887513697,
-0.2784167826,
0.0370582789,
-0.4910043478,
-0.2071746886,
0.8112183809,
0.2579771876,
1.1417189837,
0.4268394411,
0.7991473675,
0.3932149708,
0.2352706343,
-0.8346786499,
0.1825764924,
-0.2929132879,
-0.2761800885,
-0.3916586936,
-0.612103343,
-0.6426161528,
0.1209002733,
-0.5814375877,
-0.4423393011,
0.259594053,
0.3848182559,
-0.3109728992,
0.1936157942,
-0.5518137217,
0.765389502,
-0.6073346138,
-0.5162245035,
-0.4038960338,
-0.525893271,
0.4531763494,
-0.1921238899,
0.0857546628,
0.1089853942,
0.0821950585,
0.6131504774,
-0.13405855,
0.4879039526,
-0.0813136101,
-0.1917237192,
-0.0216988958,
0.1233526915,
0.6017209291,
0.1186405271,
-0.0267678909,
-0.2273109555,
0.1018412709,
-0.261118412,
-0.5221692324,
0.6413357854,
-0.6843653321,
0.0418295488,
-0.4733790457,
-0.5806136727,
-0.1708999723,
0.3556649089,
0.0738084689,
0.7952939868,
-0.0945876613,
0.1917214394,
0.7204347849,
-0.7397606373,
0.3871818483,
0.4011064768,
-0.3605917692,
-0.4507322311,
1.2076119184,
0.0559301414,
0.6333175302,
0.4620549679,
0.415115416,
-0.3708871603,
-0.0930898488,
-0.320505023,
0.0177840143,
-0.4559807777,
-0.0163320974,
-0.2914119959,
-0.2386657298,
-0.2728865743,
-0.3026490211,
-0.3047294617,
-0.2410308272,
-0.0247435961,
0.083283186,
0.252353996,
1.2810685635,
-0.1076997146,
0.3100338876,
-0.453696698,
0.3076896667,
0.6756283045,
0.6338272691,
0.0565073565,
0.0888439566,
-0.1673482209,
-0.1824490726,
-0.5291811228,
-1.0241122246,
0.445638746,
-0.0148734553,
0.3191645741,
0.3351872861,
0.1810694337,
0.0529839918,
-0.5929849744,
0.5316491127,
0.386685282,
-0.6984145045,
0.2332233936,
-0.2869184911,
0.3531967998,
0.3320982158,
0.2750388384,
-0.978681922,
-0.4638326466,
-0.442094624,
-0.7773516774,
0.8774335384,
-0.1418802887,
0.1378134191,
-0.0033170453,
0.1818796247,
0.0601443872,
0.5885878801,
-0.9356516004,
-0.3557123542,
-0.6194515824,
-0.1513029337,
-0.0157993343,
-0.2341159582,
-0.3847964108,
0.1769952178,
0.6116493344,
-0.1590652168,
0.2780808508,
-0.4451349676,
0.0586772859,
-0.13992621,
0.4044329226,
0.9818972349,
0.3393082619,
-0.2893344164,
0.2915837765,
-0.2727431655,
-0.1001958847,
0.23555471,
-0.0124359708,
0.0064282333,
-0.4188703895,
0.1312954426,
0.9422314167,
0.1532030255,
-0.493689239,
0.4999913275,
-0.1751126945,
-0.2255199105,
-0.187241286,
0.1065668985,
-0.2430451661,
0.1765428334,
0.147705391,
0.0838129446,
-0.1968532205,
-0.5653380156,
0.3049958944,
0.5595861077,
-0.2494099289,
-0.0513936281,
0.7103941441,
0.2105364949,
-0.0759420842,
0.4370181561,
-0.4928553104,
-0.5313853621,
0.5366860628,
0.6448758245,
0.5596527457,
-0.1227284074,
0.5012039542,
0.2027270943,
0.0125011466,
-0.1136843711,
0.4185530245,
-0.0584507622,
-0.8931307793,
-0.4677751958,
-0.7317786813,
-0.5345505476,
0.1536247432,
-0.7455314994,
0.3468475342,
-0.5790464878,
0.0921187401,
-0.0029971043,
-0.0506126769,
-0.3981241286,
0.0898727998,
0.2904991806,
0.6033916473,
-1.0743809938,
0.6783427596,
0.6209329963,
-0.6163536906,
-0.8927644491,
0.0535745062,
0.2870689929,
-0.6198748946,
0.9108808637,
0.2152535468,
-0.3494026363,
0.0360499024,
-0.4687644839,
-0.8916221261,
0.9157053232,
-0.0874888971,
-0.0960390195,
-0.2033822536,
-0.2212848365,
0.3264322877,
-0.0664663985,
0.253493011,
0.3007598817,
0.7214081287,
0.3112235963,
-0.625194788,
-0.1713756174,
-0.1899553835,
-0.0658279881,
0.3532248437,
-0.9037192464,
0.9969822168,
0.1497864127,
-0.2010616809,
-0.1196439862,
0.5608950853,
0.5662643909,
-0.0180171188,
0.5504257083,
0.2700022161,
0.6427109241,
-0.1166495606,
0.92348212,
-0.5099671483,
0.2657099962,
0.8373792768,
-0.2350832671,
0.4124476314,
0.108975023,
-0.0205034837,
0.8069117069,
0.4701700211,
0.2223399132,
0.6246376038,
0.4137527347,
-0.2974559069,
-0.0728729218,
-0.4371641278,
-0.188451767,
0.5433087349,
0.0879250914,
-0.0732865259,
-0.0068740472,
0.1794876158,
0.2388437986,
0.1898151189,
-0.2123983502,
0.8764644265,
-0.2624164224,
-0.7240347862,
0.4307265282,
0.1784673631,
1.0137267113,
-1.0580034256,
-0.2652365267,
-0.1492238641,
0.2313838899,
-0.0824031904,
-0.8773655891,
-0.0747830197,
-0.1730869859,
-0.0297081042,
-0.9889112711,
0.6176986694,
-0.8039195538,
-0.2980960011,
0.1238500923,
0.2131975889,
-0.2523311973,
0.1324802488,
-0.6578660011,
-0.006154005,
-0.3790430725,
-0.4531041086,
0.6202297807,
0.4586830139,
-0.0330836475,
0.7285140753,
0.356554538,
0.2664247751,
0.0170722995,
0.1176567152,
0.7285274863,
-0.4226905406,
-0.5110234022,
-0.7095547318,
0.3536058366,
-0.0818051025,
-0.2146330923,
0.5200724006,
0.1989767104,
0.7309455276,
0.0695081502,
0.5739285946,
-0.1341360956,
0.1611874998,
-0.6168253422,
0.5669108629,
-0.891327858,
-0.2391003817,
-0.5288863778,
-0.657317102,
-0.2264081389,
0.5302147865,
0.1789671332,
0.4050754905,
0.7299942374,
0.4563955367,
0.3270053566,
-0.1321273148,
0.0467386805,
-0.2126429677,
0.4730681181,
0.360627234,
0.8680003285,
0.4256212711,
0.2972042859,
-0.5330671668,
-0.4635241032,
-0.0393812358,
-1.2240573168,
-0.1893229038,
-0.5495649576,
0.0309425984,
-0.5093485117,
-0.1172104925,
1.0659399033,
0.6591546535,
-0.7211768627,
-0.3736012876,
0.0751833692,
0.2831639051,
-0.814981699,
-0.2662577927,
0.0126408692,
-0.5690970421,
-0.7803261876,
0.4017936587,
0.2627709508,
-0.0730710849,
-0.608048737,
-0.2128540128,
-0.2640646994,
0.2138032168,
0.8096513748,
0.2902913988,
-0.3405022025,
-0.3474797308,
-0.2154241502,
-0.2207143158,
-0.1199773028,
1.1348520517,
-0.6044653654,
0.4433937967,
0.5231374502,
0.3246447444,
0.3961316943,
0.2003840804,
0.5179153681,
-1.1814740896,
-0.0861510336,
0.0707566068,
0.1582929194,
0.0207089093,
-0.3203850091,
0.1699780375,
0.244351238,
-0.7758297324,
-0.5153364539,
0.6598605514,
-0.7072895169,
-0.4261069894,
1.1170928478,
0.1218765453,
0.3504037261,
0.4193977714,
-0.1276430339,
0.4810711145,
-0.5987786055,
0.699164629,
0.6190140247,
-0.3886640072,
-0.2293517441,
-0.3969540894,
0.6979751587,
0.3718886971,
-0.8190117478,
0.2607631087,
0.7418814898,
0.0078438632,
0.1068686843,
0.560893178,
0.109837994,
-0.0923274904,
-0.3904133737,
0.3685214221,
-0.0281301942,
-0.9094119072,
-0.2565088272,
0.2663286626,
0.1823510975,
0.1278517544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14879v1
|
Driving Generative Agents With Their Personality
| 2024-02-21T21:29:57 | 2024-02-21T21:29:57 |
Lawrence J. Klinkert, Stephanie Buongiorno, Corey Clark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research explores the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
utilize psychometric values, specifically personality information, within the
context of video game character development. Affective Computing (AC) systems
quantify a Non-Player character's (NPC) psyche, and an LLM can take advantage
of the system's information by using the values for prompt generation. The
research shows an LLM can consistently represent a given personality profile,
thereby enhancing the human-like characteristics of game characters.
Repurposing a human examination, the International Personality Item Pool (IPIP)
questionnaire, to evaluate an LLM shows that the model can accurately generate
content concerning the personality provided. Results show that the improvement
of LLM, such as the latest GPT-4 model, can consistently utilize and interpret
a personality to represent behavior.
|
[
-0.5842097402,
-0.4006700814,
0.8456986547,
0.3908675015,
0.1198725551,
0.2021117508,
-0.161061421,
-0.4048007727,
0.1751123071,
0.6660783887,
-0.8548483849,
-0.3402548432,
-0.3187383711,
0.2864139378,
-0.155611217,
0.9796066284,
0.1119551733,
-0.0417384654,
-0.2165382504,
0.1688477695,
-0.4286762178,
-0.9325473905,
-0.8665867448,
-0.7060018182,
0.6544226408,
0.2737723291,
0.8388186097,
0.4108841419,
0.5149401426,
0.3769318759,
0.0682717785,
-0.1831174493,
-0.5569619536,
0.5386589766,
-0.3698987663,
-0.560485661,
-0.4540105164,
-0.0199810863,
0.3846420646,
0.2898849845,
0.0147995818,
-0.2428503633,
-0.1791826636,
0.5520583987,
-0.2519538403,
0.3711240888,
-0.1887616366,
0.2737480402,
-0.141885072,
-0.3949419856,
-0.436187923,
-0.3637971878,
0.0296641681,
-0.4857988656,
0.0510077737,
-0.0956581384,
0.6528539062,
0.0694406256,
-0.387673974,
-0.508977592,
-0.9356744289,
0.5702371001,
-0.6483974457,
0.0999528021,
0.2934724689,
0.1071342528,
-0.3623483181,
-0.0613949001,
-0.8279016018,
-0.5315704942,
0.3173018694,
0.1747445315,
-0.1177468449,
0.3649506271,
0.5067247748,
0.3541212082,
-0.2424875945,
0.5028200746,
-0.1477288902,
0.2257867306,
1.0605876446,
0.6769779325,
0.6157209277,
0.0498399213,
-0.0908878595,
-0.4325200915,
-0.9637686014,
-0.0846263394,
0.814432621,
0.1401916295,
-0.2677430809,
0.7565853,
-0.0954486579,
0.3608005047,
0.3768163621,
-0.2884766161,
0.3037318587,
-0.2067566514,
0.0005654391,
-0.1171558872,
0.7671633959,
0.4878388345,
0.5415256023,
-0.2068926394,
-0.3039569557,
0.1222006157,
0.4922601879,
-1.0715233088,
-0.190856874,
0.4682354033,
-0.5226052999,
-0.4553230405,
0.0566587485,
-0.9334021807,
-0.703677237,
-0.3102314174,
0.0704578534,
-0.5616550446,
-0.4563326836,
-0.3259987235,
-0.1690049618,
0.6490098834,
0.179343462,
-1.4320548773,
-0.0430953465,
0.7068160176,
0.9143517017,
-0.4017874002,
-0.319910109,
-0.1580530703,
0.1261721402,
-0.50925529,
0.8026185036,
-0.5835257769,
-0.8071818948,
0.0195181202,
-0.067916207,
0.3585883975,
-0.6293210387,
0.0297391955,
-0.5419585109,
-0.2014367878,
-0.62334162,
-0.5238085985,
0.1757063121,
0.2182531059,
-0.604578495,
0.590054214,
0.4660694301,
-0.2914740443,
0.409295857,
-0.89729774,
-0.4190678,
0.3866190612,
-0.2821159959,
-0.1873090118,
0.3594972491,
-0.2241571397,
0.6011666656,
-0.1717662066,
0.1577914804,
-0.4281680882,
-0.2384512573,
0.688347578,
-0.2624104619,
0.5654463172,
0.2371914089,
-0.3757815361,
0.3432561755,
-0.2662117481,
-0.0437589251,
0.0952691734,
-0.3956875205,
0.1798494905,
0.4557959437,
-0.0384353288,
0.5425754786,
0.1520916522,
-0.4836513102,
0.3634600341,
-0.1507971287,
0.1345579773,
0.9951410294,
0.0888780951,
0.1974238753,
-0.4411399066,
1.049298048,
0.0159204267,
-0.1807381958,
-0.077101402,
-0.4514034986,
-0.6507195234,
-0.2643637359,
-0.3665863276,
0.505042851,
-0.7508589625,
0.6242656708,
0.047066655,
-0.6102602482,
-0.2607983351,
-0.0527546816,
0.1634302139,
0.2004401386,
-0.1308989972,
-0.3658991754,
-0.4778044522,
-0.5629807115,
0.1552069783,
-0.646679759,
-0.2492067218,
0.7326130271,
0.3515310884,
-0.4912265539,
0.7990572453,
-0.4553830028,
0.0209048539,
-0.5897112489,
0.2200007886,
0.0113041615,
0.2819420993,
0.6917290092,
-0.6715871692,
-0.5524283648,
-0.1319693625,
-1.0003578663,
-0.4162386656,
-0.1950722188,
-0.1010419205,
0.0403847955,
0.3299845159,
-0.7188568711,
0.3795148134,
0.4999344945,
-0.7888484597,
0.904527843,
-0.227618441,
0.4265637398,
-0.7899418473,
-0.0912407115,
0.1071791202,
-0.0069994624,
-0.6079387665,
0.2701890171,
-0.4680202305,
-0.3282889426,
-0.2791229188,
0.490683645,
-0.3838996589,
-0.2960862219,
-0.5553739667,
0.0665126741,
-0.2458166927,
0.2349127829,
0.3441299796,
1.1318888664,
0.6099888682,
-0.8036130667,
0.8965841532,
0.2556414902,
-0.2854627669,
1.2049475908,
-0.7368532419,
0.1934733689,
-0.372379601,
-0.1024437994,
-0.7709559798,
-0.4113633633,
-0.0733330473,
-0.3672260046,
0.143472001,
0.1773273945,
-0.6313952208,
-0.2743124664,
-0.0340589955,
0.0404756218,
0.7918941975,
-0.4166495502,
0.4548368156,
0.447355032,
-0.3653644621,
0.1370548457,
-0.5256659985,
0.1773029715,
-0.6180707812,
-0.5869650841,
0.4421111643,
-0.5299233198,
-0.5386369228,
-0.2453557104,
0.6437213421,
0.0938008353,
0.1606681198,
0.4212735593,
0.23202084,
-0.2346049994,
0.1381599605,
-0.3389787376,
0.1219764426,
0.3697853386,
0.3129309118,
0.7950106859,
-0.177737847,
-0.1345601082,
-0.2948512137,
0.6050717831,
0.5169980526,
-0.0896177143,
0.8510462642,
0.336332947,
0.139557749,
-0.122715041,
-0.1892535537,
-0.230372414,
-0.5385732055,
0.6340488195,
-0.59077245,
-0.9373259544,
0.8008347154,
0.0396982245,
-0.3236536682,
0.2595144212,
0.9706742167,
-0.1315041184,
1.4254693985,
0.8246226907,
-0.103047803,
0.6760341525,
0.0979481637,
0.068760559,
-1.0271451473,
-0.3360995352,
-0.2103291005,
-0.2907400131,
-0.8734381199,
-0.2840366066,
0.2384598106,
-0.1903222352,
-0.4400780499,
0.0672041997,
-0.4067979455,
0.4206885099,
0.3335759342,
0.1203901097,
-0.101623185,
-0.1908164322,
0.2371512353,
-0.0390102975,
-0.1781389117,
-0.5770209432,
1.2334257364,
0.4556502402,
0.9040938616,
0.6657915711,
0.631360352,
0.2934347093,
0.6693643332,
-0.8124655485,
0.5910047293,
0.0598539226,
-0.645149827,
-0.3801184595,
-0.4479706883,
-0.7580780983,
-0.070308283,
-0.1029417068,
-1.0221986771,
0.2237751186,
0.1318890005,
-0.3882815838,
0.1913705915,
-0.6024791002,
0.6612766385,
-0.4961913824,
-0.4349223077,
-0.1608190686,
-0.3128178716,
0.2671761215,
-0.1089656577,
-0.3883037269,
-0.2491765767,
0.0616270788,
0.513628602,
-0.4096238315,
0.6789429188,
-0.2536339462,
-0.2423304021,
0.3379487991,
0.2592454553,
0.3198829889,
-0.1323552281,
-0.2902666926,
-0.0900708959,
-0.0721532032,
-0.108149007,
-0.6859884262,
0.8449751735,
-1.1851136684,
-0.6729182601,
-0.5484853387,
-0.6181788445,
-0.3522646129,
-0.0635110959,
0.107580699,
-0.1223607436,
-0.5553116798,
0.0904405788,
0.7553322315,
-0.4398618937,
0.370318681,
0.5487431288,
-0.2354140729,
0.0206674226,
0.8300766945,
-0.2990930676,
0.4623888731,
0.1080540717,
0.070356518,
-0.1768821925,
-0.2794999778,
-0.1635500044,
0.2973107398,
-0.4877048135,
-0.0002586808,
-0.3111205101,
-0.2539506555,
-0.4009030461,
-0.3038973808,
-0.1880443245,
0.4250002205,
-0.5691204071,
-0.2778425217,
0.4640319347,
1.0195506811,
-0.0093322685,
0.7763299942,
-0.2106686234,
0.2303915173,
0.3509378731,
0.442391336,
0.0087029636,
-0.2846029401,
0.0318649635,
-0.0785303339,
-0.6827118397,
-1.3853687048,
0.7590590715,
0.0347699597,
0.3974176049,
0.7449980378,
-0.4233615398,
0.4943764806,
-0.3933261037,
0.9636597633,
0.1219957322,
-0.9396463633,
0.4746793807,
-0.5558743477,
0.3161942065,
0.4142105579,
0.3984260261,
-0.7512989044,
-0.1153414249,
-0.5181056857,
-0.4557200968,
0.7382138968,
-0.0045240168,
0.3308186531,
-0.219898954,
0.5551438332,
-0.1526104063,
0.430031687,
-0.7632978559,
-0.1080525219,
-0.2245955914,
-0.4211492538,
-0.2763465643,
-0.392989397,
0.2607829571,
-0.0622329712,
0.5238243937,
-0.2773360908,
0.7575652599,
0.0961214975,
0.4051890969,
-0.1292522997,
0.267463088,
0.4688214958,
0.5840374231,
-0.2272768766,
0.054958567,
-0.3259404302,
-0.3033112586,
0.5341262221,
-0.2383594066,
-0.2157328725,
-0.3978091478,
0.1171941236,
0.9784496427,
-0.2363934666,
-0.9760552049,
0.5289273262,
0.1467630118,
-0.0149244405,
-0.562527895,
0.3921052217,
0.1056236774,
0.3035881817,
0.031678956,
-0.4060654044,
0.0554446727,
-1.0132457018,
0.1299041957,
0.5338808298,
-0.564455688,
-0.6478598714,
0.5735837817,
0.2248141319,
-0.6441546679,
0.8563148975,
-0.5078234673,
-0.398734957,
0.8143138885,
0.8210142255,
0.957809031,
-0.56173563,
0.5857097507,
0.1442657262,
0.0792763755,
-0.0435805097,
0.5657858253,
0.1504647583,
-1.0583299398,
-0.3323578537,
-0.3951976597,
-0.559813261,
0.2799733281,
-0.3907843232,
0.1952267736,
-0.6125349402,
-0.2675951123,
-0.122340247,
-0.0154006025,
-0.8790580034,
0.2821298242,
0.3663249016,
0.3259043097,
-0.8785733581,
0.611782968,
0.5002077222,
-0.8108549714,
-0.821965158,
-0.115848057,
-0.151946336,
-0.6313351393,
1.0201894045,
-0.0748743266,
0.1190773621,
-0.0137480292,
-0.7226159573,
-0.7393960953,
1.0776565075,
0.2450643033,
-0.5046210289,
-0.2706167102,
0.2611727417,
0.7969765663,
-0.8730046749,
0.5581868291,
0.5220302343,
0.33715114,
0.1156026572,
-0.4609049261,
-0.0047361315,
-0.2704935074,
0.3450147212,
-0.0160734095,
-0.7826780677,
0.9050328732,
-0.3963853717,
-0.0607152209,
0.1429880708,
0.787384212,
0.7151440978,
-0.0634382442,
0.285923332,
0.1923789531,
0.6098394394,
-0.0146936383,
1.2278308868,
-0.4227537513,
0.032655362,
0.7628124952,
-0.6377919912,
0.5928524733,
0.4735995531,
-0.2788318396,
0.9293245673,
0.5798088908,
-0.3225481808,
0.4829963148,
0.433429122,
-0.5319766998,
-0.0875282362,
-0.1733576804,
-0.0220245961,
0.5767147541,
0.4104591012,
-0.6157770157,
0.3635581434,
0.1966680437,
0.122782506,
-0.0854345113,
-0.355399996,
0.8533188105,
-0.0174745824,
-0.8047784567,
-0.1026097313,
0.1690014452,
0.6831000447,
-0.6765064001,
-0.0157509837,
-0.2966837883,
0.1404944509,
-0.1221307293,
-0.9524793029,
0.1164775342,
0.1666127741,
-0.2510214746,
-0.3794392645,
0.4722959399,
-0.2627654076,
-0.3045367002,
0.1298055351,
0.3053434789,
0.3611513078,
-0.1209584028,
-0.5282152295,
0.1820953041,
-0.0424241759,
-0.1804166585,
0.3805316687,
0.4568830729,
0.135891661,
0.8687505722,
0.3662278354,
0.4910089374,
-0.285928309,
0.056488663,
0.6737320423,
-0.9060261846,
-0.709076345,
-1.0496388674,
0.3540223837,
-0.1057260036,
-0.3897022009,
0.8018387556,
0.3478256762,
0.4753284156,
-0.2382840365,
0.9666450024,
-0.1451537162,
0.1176149622,
-0.3565630615,
0.6569187045,
-0.0313867033,
0.0668664426,
-0.4692145288,
-0.9291567206,
0.1965233237,
0.7365558147,
-0.3337964714,
0.5249682069,
0.4498850703,
0.6852765083,
0.3440909684,
-0.1569660157,
0.5175539255,
0.160461247,
0.7522051334,
0.8418625593,
1.0165081024,
0.035801921,
-0.1922339052,
-0.0143382438,
-0.4853838682,
-0.0622883476,
-0.6855247021,
-1.1261889935,
-0.466096133,
-0.3760262728,
-0.4186528325,
-0.017091766,
0.7771799564,
0.7040615082,
-0.5850527883,
-0.5122436285,
-0.2139574587,
-0.033222124,
-0.0466816202,
-0.3433817029,
-0.1304549426,
-0.138433814,
-0.675378263,
0.2817519903,
0.2821577787,
0.2915560007,
-1.094691515,
-0.3017111719,
0.225809291,
0.4188345671,
0.7249363065,
0.4224962294,
-0.5600677729,
-0.5792635083,
0.1128049046,
-0.0811304003,
0.1315184534,
0.938977778,
-0.6196733713,
0.3801759481,
0.3710572422,
0.2911995947,
0.3690545559,
0.1395479888,
0.9195500016,
-0.5106361508,
0.1099692807,
0.3991207182,
0.0584552698,
0.5313613415,
-0.7876270413,
0.2218312025,
0.1805537641,
-0.8210580349,
-0.516495049,
0.6060591936,
-0.7852290869,
0.1154472455,
1.3958433867,
-0.1739314049,
-0.1910116673,
0.1447157413,
-0.1439950019,
-0.1016740873,
-0.4433178306,
0.7265582085,
0.8909714818,
-0.647295773,
-0.5733534694,
-0.3524032235,
0.6928334832,
0.0991805643,
-1.2325600386,
-0.0237327535,
0.7057669163,
0.1762823611,
0.1030969918,
0.8134768009,
-0.1235786378,
0.0078678643,
0.0777322873,
0.5264307261,
0.2109124959,
-0.0568482913,
-0.2309890538,
0.1972742677,
0.3007375002,
0.3314661086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14129v1
|
Combining Language and Graph Models for Semi-structured Information Extraction on the Web
| 2024-02-21T20:53:29 | 2024-02-21T20:53:29 |
Zhi Hong, Kyle Chard, Ian Foster
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Relation extraction is an efficient way of mining the extraordinary wealth of
human knowledge on the Web. Existing methods rely on domain-specific training
data or produce noisy outputs. We focus here on extracting targeted relations
from semi-structured web pages given only a short description of the relation.
We present GraphScholarBERT, an open-domain information extraction method based
on a joint graph and language model structure. GraphScholarBERT can generalize
to previously unseen domains without additional data or training and produces
only clean extraction results matched to the search keyword. Experiments show
that GraphScholarBERT can improve extraction F1 scores by as much as 34.8\%
compared to previous work in a zero-shot domain and zero-shot website setting.
|
[
-0.4357060194,
-1.0251331329,
0.2781709135,
0.0438394025,
-0.2262738943,
0.2501842678,
-0.3106635213,
-0.8280169964,
-0.0023683961,
0.4290804267,
-0.3936553597,
-0.8326708078,
-0.4252854884,
-0.0620045848,
-0.4378999472,
1.0140913725,
0.1720732301,
-0.0837759674,
-0.288654834,
0.2318150103,
0.3121542931,
-0.5075756907,
-0.5527200699,
-0.2626797259,
0.4796016216,
0.1545461118,
0.6867903471,
0.6529388428,
0.3354501426,
0.1956659406,
-0.0324473046,
0.2914153934,
-0.8512189388,
0.1572588831,
-0.3885949254,
-0.2064914405,
-0.5769667625,
0.1013862863,
0.519167304,
1.0768096447,
-0.0133039905,
0.2908048928,
0.0920346007,
0.4874964952,
-0.7415842414,
0.7084925175,
-0.4125113487,
-0.0099248383,
-0.1681360751,
-0.4007926285,
-0.6026391983,
-0.5443241596,
0.1527629048,
-0.5728516579,
0.3809231222,
0.1390939802,
1.3353544474,
-0.2787801325,
-0.3916407526,
-0.3297879696,
-0.840914011,
0.6302892566,
-0.3516919315,
0.7755932808,
0.389338851,
0.2788790762,
-0.0331605636,
-1.1432527304,
-0.281560123,
0.1600080431,
-0.2438819557,
0.1467728168,
-0.7422776222,
0.0297548473,
0.2438057065,
0.2156806886,
-0.5048289895,
-0.2000693977,
-0.7117477059,
-0.2733066678,
0.7010478377,
-0.0209661312,
0.5473544598,
-0.3387109339,
-0.3375568986,
-0.0231799632,
-0.8145112395,
0.1744854301,
0.4973427355,
0.7284433842,
0.0806093141,
0.5753951073,
-0.1305285245,
1.0675013065,
-0.0638008788,
-0.1048159227,
-0.0288908575,
-0.2340696156,
-0.0844501108,
0.0623460375,
1.0220407248,
0.2924926877,
0.7629622221,
-0.8024063706,
-0.0413951017,
0.1102953628,
0.0779524222,
-0.9280468822,
-0.9310493469,
0.180033356,
-0.5475498438,
-0.4412002563,
0.3825158179,
-0.9692940712,
-0.0363774151,
0.0007567494,
-0.1395294964,
-0.4193314016,
-0.3801620901,
-0.2638869286,
-0.6718760133,
-0.0467735641,
0.2220246494,
-0.6831071973,
0.5367165804,
0.4104012251,
0.8101557493,
-0.381072104,
0.002151476,
-0.8309184909,
0.4091625512,
-0.2170895338,
0.8046936989,
-0.8599896431,
-0.3100292087,
0.2773400843,
0.0489594378,
0.1788516343,
-0.5965664387,
0.237996012,
-1.0671708584,
0.0781861916,
0.0368962772,
-0.7539994717,
-0.0326334462,
0.1155512854,
-1.0550065041,
0.9106909633,
0.3337104917,
-0.8684316874,
0.0984494761,
-0.4430276155,
-0.7164869905,
0.2756003737,
-0.1095166206,
-0.240114063,
-0.213965714,
0.2042728662,
0.3850360811,
-0.2383956015,
-0.1518378854,
-0.6829670668,
0.0245353431,
0.1251196861,
0.1510625184,
1.1716690063,
0.1149277985,
0.156867221,
-0.2732965052,
-0.946095109,
0.2919349968,
0.3992610872,
-0.5505982637,
-0.6486189365,
0.0026615558,
0.0278713796,
0.3186535537,
0.3331336379,
-0.6776709557,
0.1928434074,
-0.4973469973,
0.3944789171,
0.5810996294,
0.4503655136,
0.5302514434,
0.2384367436,
0.7565561533,
-0.2167731225,
-0.1923695952,
0.3448494971,
-0.2609229386,
-0.4288865924,
-0.4357936978,
0.6265472174,
0.2575728297,
-0.8561913371,
0.2325243354,
-0.424092859,
-0.5025678277,
-0.2505168319,
0.3417594433,
0.4027508795,
0.6046893597,
0.3707628548,
-0.3755095303,
-0.5044615865,
-0.5779356956,
-0.3099898696,
-0.021222638,
0.0447192416,
0.347691685,
0.1125696078,
0.0925033912,
1.1679549217,
-1.0928019285,
-0.2936350107,
-0.4161695838,
0.2585747242,
0.0083419802,
-0.1551773399,
0.5271492004,
-1.0668935776,
-0.8207778335,
0.1275964975,
-1.0538880825,
-0.1036879271,
0.6465309262,
-0.1697078347,
-0.2670502365,
0.3402779102,
-0.6823863983,
0.4364760816,
0.257594198,
0.1420639753,
0.4120414257,
0.1444312483,
-0.4104539752,
-0.751016736,
0.1461919099,
0.3917360306,
-0.7416319251,
-0.7942621708,
0.007943741,
0.1433156282,
-0.2865512967,
-0.4629900455,
0.5194001794,
-0.9365024567,
-0.2281284034,
-0.1947700828,
0.765113771,
0.2954718471,
0.6752919555,
0.0681696832,
0.6015685201,
0.6027368307,
-0.7504142523,
0.5153335929,
0.4491133392,
0.1262086779,
0.1880694628,
-0.4347980618,
0.2452093512,
0.0005952727,
-0.072102271,
-0.815341711,
-0.0716554597,
0.1498416811,
-0.5273805261,
0.4201208055,
-0.3580157459,
-0.5240272284,
-0.2407404184,
-0.3123846054,
0.0814823806,
0.2998558581,
-0.4919621646,
0.3874439895,
0.8888787627,
-0.4346563518,
-0.391543299,
-0.0062602013,
-0.1409930289,
0.1701699644,
-0.4978219271,
0.3405114114,
0.2642323077,
-0.3071607947,
0.4856110513,
-0.2452273667,
-0.6248289347,
0.065564543,
0.1209067479,
0.4581561387,
0.0635194555,
0.1481574029,
-0.0899642333,
0.0387157202,
0.0441058241,
-0.2135410011,
0.8330622911,
-0.0392214097,
0.1655204892,
-0.2990525663,
0.2588469684,
0.1181605309,
-0.5133148432,
0.4328325093,
0.3522439599,
-0.5546799898,
-0.4539262354,
0.2255471647,
-0.1332007051,
-0.4267035127,
0.3869954348,
-0.401345551,
-0.6877485514,
0.2614696026,
-0.5265151262,
-0.1086229682,
0.4683465362,
0.3816227317,
-0.3341595829,
1.1493426561,
0.9399394393,
-0.1236288622,
0.3572885692,
-0.5078467727,
0.5475018024,
-0.6511849761,
-0.3017292321,
-0.6228396893,
0.0650311485,
-0.465582639,
0.2980852723,
0.0778467953,
0.3828940988,
0.2075736821,
0.7710861564,
-0.3914091289,
0.1750699878,
0.4561822712,
0.3164614737,
0.3659140766,
0.3051308095,
0.0686207265,
0.0738076791,
-0.7139943838,
-0.3626898229,
1.1226429939,
-0.2043036073,
0.8668449521,
0.2420351058,
0.6661452055,
0.598639667,
0.1854068339,
-0.7275241017,
0.4949302375,
-0.1225913316,
-0.7770622373,
-0.3925813437,
-0.5957629681,
-1.3416852951,
0.0830539018,
-0.2118515223,
-1.1377503872,
0.1601787806,
0.1737559438,
0.0148431826,
0.0865040496,
-0.439941138,
0.762008667,
-0.123452425,
-0.66886127,
0.0620114841,
-0.6494292021,
0.1863066852,
-0.0259524509,
0.3720984459,
-0.0892741755,
0.3622076511,
0.8341420293,
-0.3168430328,
0.7009459138,
-0.1173721254,
0.1908943504,
0.3044369519,
0.2939094603,
0.5423698425,
-0.3472724259,
0.1403811872,
0.2480577976,
0.2360615581,
-0.3118644059,
-0.6224175692,
0.3279562294,
-0.7711860538,
-0.2121818364,
-0.4385905862,
-0.4925030768,
-0.3763557971,
0.6950727701,
0.1145067066,
0.5637722611,
-0.4766824245,
-0.0336155221,
0.3115928471,
0.0353388712,
0.3339975178,
0.2463587224,
-0.4011027217,
-0.2564351857,
1.0146366358,
-0.0386678986,
0.2379951924,
0.3733386099,
0.0763422847,
-0.4161257744,
-0.0814259872,
-0.1511132717,
0.4171969593,
-0.9089823365,
-0.3587908149,
-0.7712110877,
-0.483844161,
-0.6601579189,
0.2894550264,
-0.1914298087,
-0.6339913607,
-0.2859873474,
-0.1567423791,
-0.0750976652,
0.6574974656,
0.0593455955,
0.203298375,
-0.9412785769,
0.4540174901,
0.1117639467,
-0.1541278064,
0.0205594655,
-0.0411698371,
-0.2463394105,
-0.1155464277,
-0.3371651471,
-1.2354873419,
0.4404440522,
0.3528322875,
0.51741153,
0.6874107718,
0.1829268336,
0.8252688646,
-0.4807009995,
0.4628671408,
0.3536248207,
-0.6649389267,
0.5157148838,
-0.1038070619,
-0.2533538342,
0.3519156873,
0.8536669016,
-0.131356135,
-0.3397374153,
-0.7752867341,
-0.6011070609,
0.8474027514,
0.3609850407,
-0.2237029523,
0.0106101027,
0.3120124638,
-0.1407708228,
0.4279411137,
-0.6988663077,
-0.2341697067,
0.0829210952,
-0.1517639607,
0.2083726823,
-0.180644244,
-0.3657742143,
-0.2742937207,
0.6132469177,
0.0457012206,
0.188174516,
0.0210856721,
-0.5946111679,
-0.302462399,
-0.0444869883,
-0.1861649454,
1.1340948343,
-0.2630846202,
0.5243157744,
-0.3263435662,
-0.1531116813,
-0.107743822,
0.4219895303,
-0.2063266784,
0.1110548675,
0.7439652085,
0.3110505641,
0.0400529243,
-0.5718160272,
0.8155937195,
0.0288942568,
-0.0026630734,
-0.0480731018,
0.1159855053,
0.1512432992,
0.3009371459,
0.1726964116,
-0.2261404544,
0.3561588228,
-0.781076014,
0.4705242217,
0.5234283209,
-0.5701823831,
-0.5101877451,
0.6725980043,
-0.1018727571,
-0.5878765583,
0.7763506174,
-0.2408476472,
-0.5843986273,
0.2975280881,
0.7762470841,
0.4073404074,
0.0060134949,
0.4420587718,
0.3814892769,
-0.1573990732,
0.4602913857,
0.1475253701,
-0.4763839841,
-0.7960770726,
-0.0698459521,
-0.7550338507,
-0.4203338623,
-0.162091583,
-0.9553391337,
0.34356305,
-0.3273912668,
-0.2607146204,
0.5170385242,
0.0632196516,
-0.6139643192,
0.2035866976,
-0.2332114875,
0.7826849818,
-0.8216864467,
1.0208140612,
0.6367418766,
-0.7854394317,
-0.9200683832,
-0.0192240905,
-0.1960083842,
-0.7942146063,
0.8256701231,
-0.070417501,
-0.3240265548,
0.2470486462,
-0.6558461189,
-0.453941524,
0.8436559439,
0.4118568599,
-0.3455830812,
-0.2933577597,
0.0455339104,
0.5548878312,
-0.2462749183,
-0.1147218272,
0.4154115319,
0.1958444864,
0.0207286626,
-0.4287027121,
0.1026483774,
-0.3363052905,
-0.2496898621,
0.4078667164,
-0.4423205554,
0.7094091177,
0.1214891672,
-0.679145515,
-0.2728466094,
0.583837986,
-0.0181570705,
0.1774754524,
0.4815977216,
0.2687665224,
1.0400505066,
0.1363949925,
0.9563074112,
-0.6018719673,
0.7874628305,
1.1083600521,
-0.4111356139,
0.7137649655,
0.3898725808,
-0.3413928747,
0.7134050131,
0.7476584315,
0.0444076695,
0.8260467052,
-0.1792516708,
-0.1019892544,
-0.3114072978,
-0.1413681358,
0.0438563153,
0.5445302129,
0.1013012901,
-0.461925149,
-0.637264967,
-0.3585717678,
0.3411994278,
-0.0032975592,
-0.0042316965,
0.8295731544,
0.2721530795,
-0.6788067818,
0.4001018405,
0.0577534288,
-0.3990704119,
-0.5635846853,
-0.2851496637,
0.0791779757,
0.1363715678,
-0.3278842568,
-0.6618187428,
0.0899751931,
0.1438102424,
-0.1200945228,
-0.0750765502,
1.2686192989,
-0.4757476449,
-0.3110527694,
0.7160685062,
0.7283681631,
0.2814982235,
-0.140757829,
-0.4948341548,
-0.1508761048,
0.0769206062,
-0.1137793288,
0.1257073879,
0.4155275226,
-0.006906217,
0.3144108355,
0.8679512143,
0.4794011414,
0.0402611122,
-0.0294812825,
1.2186075449,
-0.4975784421,
-0.3417157531,
-0.8585178852,
0.1698715538,
-0.7839737535,
0.0866570026,
0.9059462547,
0.9054739475,
0.5622981787,
0.2340596616,
1.1029884815,
-0.2205898017,
0.302862823,
-0.2623023093,
0.4794950783,
-0.6064730287,
-0.135879308,
-0.3772549629,
-1.1932550669,
-0.3408912718,
0.4242982864,
-0.2473005056,
-0.1174621135,
0.7854217291,
0.5964641571,
-0.4495959282,
0.0350253209,
0.1477845013,
0.1831126809,
0.4756929278,
0.3229780197,
0.6878433824,
-0.1189254224,
0.8828189373,
-0.3377431929,
-0.4850824773,
-0.0532001443,
-0.4386696815,
-1.2349014282,
-0.4371166229,
-0.1990548372,
-0.6672182679,
0.1158018038,
0.3424964845,
0.6931313872,
-0.5278283954,
-0.2247714251,
0.0663701147,
0.096466437,
-0.1592120081,
-0.2862037718,
0.6766394973,
-0.2028144151,
-0.7459862828,
0.2923227251,
0.5657949448,
-0.29804039,
-0.0853626877,
-0.0667488351,
-0.4333367944,
-0.0928515941,
0.5248834491,
0.4700341225,
-0.1358405054,
-0.3523905575,
0.027438337,
-0.1681376696,
0.4610029459,
0.5978454351,
-0.3493416905,
0.7481792569,
0.5202840567,
0.3408423662,
1.1295448542,
0.4397204816,
0.5076290965,
-0.8648381829,
0.0959359631,
0.0754916966,
0.2601940036,
0.293558538,
-0.3005646765,
0.5711554289,
0.423117131,
-0.1345033944,
-0.6662008166,
0.5023255944,
-1.0656285286,
-0.4694989026,
1.1287490129,
-0.3723493814,
-0.4151937664,
-0.1605398655,
0.2043066174,
0.6599464417,
-0.279889524,
0.5334121585,
0.5709173679,
-0.4403345883,
-0.0687276274,
-0.4331691265,
0.2306723595,
-0.4820975959,
-0.8073464632,
-0.1435054243,
0.4428946972,
0.3693656027,
0.3168855309,
0.6790505052,
-0.2732046843,
0.2206648439,
-0.0966660678,
0.2381511331,
-0.0971513763,
-0.5134374499,
0.3071749806,
0.7451111078,
-0.0459057987,
-0.1063956842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14116v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14116v2
|
FanOutQA: A Multi-Hop, Multi-Document Question Answering Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T20:30:45 | 2024-06-06T16:41:21 |
Andrew Zhu, Alyssa Hwang, Liam Dugan, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
One type of question that is commonly found in day-to-day scenarios is
``fan-out'' questions, complex multi-hop, multi-document reasoning questions
that require finding information about a large number of entities. However,
there exist few resources to evaluate this type of question-answering
capability among large language models. To evaluate complex reasoning in LLMs
more fully, we present FanOutQA, a high-quality dataset of fan-out
question-answer pairs and human-annotated decompositions with English Wikipedia
as the knowledge base. We formulate three benchmark settings across our dataset
and benchmark 7 LLMs, including GPT-4, LLaMA 2, Claude-2.1, and Mixtral-8x7B,
finding that contemporary models still have room to improve reasoning over
inter-document dependencies in a long context. We provide our dataset and
open-source tools to run models to encourage evaluation at https://fanoutqa.com
|
[
-0.8226574659,
-0.893142879,
0.6476963162,
0.1840271056,
0.1620316207,
0.0043519689,
-0.2125312984,
-0.3919216692,
-0.1061746329,
0.4624254405,
-0.9323901534,
-0.3217497468,
-0.4261840284,
0.1357148439,
-0.6405200958,
0.5946707726,
-0.5433416367,
0.2483799756,
-0.6364696026,
-0.1011307761,
-0.166919902,
-0.5480331779,
-0.394061029,
-0.3060598671,
0.5213668346,
0.515661478,
0.5338647366,
0.196091041,
0.5922870636,
0.169749558,
0.0327340439,
0.6615930796,
-0.4556843042,
0.4168541431,
-0.272664398,
-0.4854829609,
-0.1852860004,
-0.0280459896,
0.6216468811,
0.737806201,
-0.0774123669,
0.2883633375,
-0.3147211969,
0.5754279494,
-0.6590675116,
0.0050527295,
-0.5933104753,
-0.3229252696,
-0.2606881857,
0.2434317023,
-0.164087519,
-0.4806371927,
0.1449809074,
-0.7426216006,
0.2217193991,
0.1711049229,
0.9320391417,
0.2790963054,
-0.3862123489,
-0.4342258573,
-0.663546443,
0.5561941862,
-0.5363562107,
0.7396430373,
0.268817693,
0.5103079081,
-0.3628515601,
-0.6086623669,
-0.7846164107,
-0.1084633544,
0.226659447,
0.2211532742,
-0.1872708499,
-0.1980047375,
0.2576918602,
0.3522506952,
-0.5258943439,
-0.2632902265,
-0.1312490851,
-0.3176700473,
0.5420507193,
0.1342798173,
0.2470763475,
0.0560152493,
-0.2332865596,
-0.011958438,
-0.6900465488,
-0.0777404308,
0.4256102145,
-0.1428413838,
0.171128273,
0.4964951575,
-0.6136379242,
0.5149399638,
-0.1216998994,
-0.0168440118,
-0.00466588,
-0.2830211818,
-0.0692113936,
-0.4646509886,
0.6822731495,
0.3211655319,
0.5021763444,
-0.4896678329,
-0.2450282127,
-0.2687658072,
-0.0032818031,
-0.8792878985,
-0.0964113772,
0.3462704718,
-0.1792231947,
0.1402960867,
0.0745559633,
-0.5382956862,
-0.3866418004,
-0.2422835976,
0.5322953463,
-0.3890902102,
-0.2446685731,
0.2564402223,
-0.2797666788,
0.3470788002,
0.7380609512,
-0.3131155372,
0.4146341681,
0.8549297452,
0.6057419777,
-0.2072170377,
-0.5725572109,
-0.6262513995,
0.1499697566,
-0.4274199903,
1.0554744005,
-0.3836113513,
-0.1757642627,
-0.0734909922,
-0.0796982124,
-0.1486588567,
-0.7544407248,
0.8993856311,
-0.7520684004,
0.2046556324,
-0.7638091445,
-0.7477786541,
-0.3658182323,
0.6064555049,
-0.6938102841,
1.1183531284,
-0.0275858343,
-0.9555543065,
0.0215023998,
-0.3852630556,
-0.2799042463,
-0.1935348064,
-0.1235829592,
0.1054728329,
-0.060375493,
0.3168816864,
0.5695279837,
-0.9727777243,
0.3187528253,
-0.5836158991,
-0.4208816588,
0.3989348114,
-0.5033708215,
0.5335546136,
0.2647152245,
0.0001944839,
-0.1047320887,
-0.566678524,
-0.0451449007,
0.1163067967,
-0.4812351465,
-0.1889855266,
-0.044304505,
-0.1672056019,
0.37020877,
0.1680481136,
-0.6385007501,
0.3892194331,
-0.030542763,
0.3191164732,
0.3399298191,
0.1212820783,
0.0954223499,
-0.5592741966,
0.5932760239,
0.0210240893,
0.2071664482,
-0.1342997849,
-0.4889257848,
-0.9814202785,
-0.2782625556,
0.1510345936,
0.5059518814,
-0.7100219727,
-0.0489149727,
-0.1938305199,
-0.926155448,
-0.6047132611,
0.2069830149,
0.1495953351,
0.6024653912,
0.4911447167,
0.0621313863,
-0.1593663096,
-1.0020518303,
-0.2706368268,
-0.178124249,
0.0292768795,
0.4752251506,
0.6347148418,
-0.2811134458,
0.6620940566,
-0.6242113709,
0.0801098794,
-0.0854745135,
0.1174756885,
0.1457749158,
-0.0360382199,
0.13227202,
-0.6785194278,
-0.1184153333,
-0.1863901615,
-0.7255206704,
-0.1664739549,
-0.1611794978,
-0.4818483591,
-0.1771094203,
0.6446430087,
-1.2111905813,
-0.0813906491,
0.511134088,
-0.0616426207,
0.8636360765,
0.0504683144,
0.3826258779,
-0.9948819876,
0.213603884,
-0.1742451489,
-0.0875870734,
-0.6293846965,
0.286569804,
0.2343222201,
0.0712515041,
-0.3755760491,
0.6913231015,
-0.5400915742,
-0.127237618,
0.0950453132,
0.2430540323,
0.4991179109,
0.2494050562,
0.0138567099,
0.847227931,
0.6013461351,
-0.4707452655,
0.519246161,
0.128743723,
-0.4115776122,
0.3185917437,
-0.6860893965,
0.2788362205,
-0.2542645335,
0.6333474517,
-1.0822736025,
-0.5127078295,
0.0251459628,
-0.2492398769,
0.0782567933,
-0.0533144884,
-0.7545874119,
-0.3384604752,
-0.4494751692,
0.4134576023,
-0.0499925651,
-0.5518376231,
0.6912684441,
0.2938930392,
-0.0339645781,
-0.6744539142,
-0.2911257148,
-0.1218430251,
-0.0100035714,
-0.941677928,
0.0726957098,
-0.343637675,
-0.5079010725,
-0.0862760693,
-0.1224106997,
-0.3137331903,
0.0603992194,
0.2265681326,
0.060634274,
-0.3763777614,
0.3329960406,
0.2061828226,
0.2679078579,
0.2835312784,
-0.0286842249,
0.7490512133,
-0.2657373846,
-0.6461173296,
-0.0011659676,
0.6764668822,
0.8282527924,
-0.3671634793,
0.4164999127,
0.5626665354,
-0.5561900735,
-0.2694225013,
-0.936491251,
-0.0599989854,
-0.368429631,
0.302832067,
-0.7369146943,
-0.8182903528,
0.6469573379,
-0.1960797012,
0.223399654,
0.7226140499,
0.7237753868,
-0.3654054999,
0.5392210484,
-0.0605696365,
-0.0241794027,
-0.1983530074,
-0.1526973099,
-0.1582789123,
-0.6461324096,
-0.5097725987,
-0.6320263743,
0.0375499353,
-0.0889336988,
-0.8579649329,
0.1596267223,
0.6509428024,
-0.346424222,
0.1408317387,
-0.0353845358,
0.3613759577,
0.5832356215,
0.0235294923,
0.5859562159,
-0.4917302132,
-0.1212479249,
0.2922700644,
-0.5682430267,
-0.3063231111,
0.9732583165,
0.4851799905,
0.9110098481,
0.2631634772,
0.6482560039,
-0.0186546352,
0.4737157524,
-0.8138183355,
0.4568223655,
-0.0079026241,
-1.0173623562,
-0.281860888,
-0.4507015646,
-0.4597309232,
0.2482808232,
-0.1343358755,
-0.465767175,
0.1107669324,
-0.1083139554,
-0.1957488507,
0.3633745611,
-0.6271809936,
0.6771895289,
-0.2547151148,
-0.0750908926,
0.0071108234,
-0.3924404979,
0.7030413151,
-0.3422255814,
0.2378316522,
-0.3921184838,
-0.0833595991,
0.7409810424,
-0.3424539268,
0.4514751732,
0.020690389,
-0.2755119503,
0.5232701302,
0.3175140321,
0.4847332537,
0.1117761582,
-0.2364795208,
0.3733025491,
0.2728573978,
-0.1205399558,
-0.6290420294,
0.8194553852,
-0.9755917788,
-0.6302235126,
-0.1437181979,
-0.7031751871,
-0.6739805937,
0.1922113448,
0.3474926054,
0.4053015113,
-0.0931121409,
0.1666589826,
0.853484273,
-0.1996378899,
0.205313161,
0.3776636422,
-0.3438296616,
-0.3488899767,
0.7113793492,
0.2388229072,
0.1667277068,
0.5626024604,
0.2594203949,
-0.623768568,
-0.357578814,
-0.7944829464,
0.4764415622,
-1.036143899,
-0.1772209108,
-0.8686836958,
-0.1935160756,
-0.2501057386,
0.1481731087,
-0.4586523473,
-0.3214197457,
-0.0930264592,
0.2049749345,
0.1548494697,
0.7767450809,
0.3265878558,
-0.1479916573,
-0.9590941072,
0.5033600926,
0.4630380869,
0.4111621082,
0.0614128523,
-0.6288406253,
-0.031339135,
-0.2085914463,
-0.0532350503,
-1.0055480003,
-0.2227560282,
0.2220195532,
0.8796917796,
0.2129843533,
0.1649581641,
0.6018434763,
-0.4263968766,
0.5253935456,
0.0774737895,
-0.9066938162,
0.2685473263,
-0.5879195333,
0.2788943052,
0.7279441357,
0.8529123068,
-0.772547543,
-0.1597843021,
-0.3814651966,
-0.6601052284,
0.3640096784,
0.1136946306,
-0.1105073243,
0.1256128103,
0.55023247,
0.2529323697,
0.2157676518,
-0.2848852575,
-0.1745721102,
-0.1183182672,
-0.0199657399,
0.1473256797,
-0.1050785407,
-0.1188732386,
-0.113222301,
0.6234209538,
-0.1640901864,
0.0813092217,
0.2535386682,
-0.0951087475,
-0.0526837334,
0.2901714742,
0.3415650725,
0.6844902635,
-0.1778710634,
0.1226769686,
0.3385872841,
-0.3821832836,
-0.0318800174,
0.2291098088,
-0.2423940897,
-0.0478758924,
0.4910813272,
0.2407313436,
-0.078400068,
-0.8754823804,
0.5639012456,
-0.3399336636,
-0.5565087199,
-0.1110156178,
0.148354724,
0.7108004689,
0.3338423967,
0.372533977,
-0.0546162426,
0.3232835531,
-0.5316802859,
0.2348368615,
0.3872083426,
-0.3401159644,
-0.0493889563,
0.6701657176,
0.2265173197,
-0.0382281318,
0.4968574345,
-0.1221345663,
-0.5147640705,
0.413434118,
0.1742918044,
0.7510371804,
0.0729382858,
0.152437672,
0.3474830091,
0.3680566549,
-0.2073254585,
0.667563498,
-0.0064592222,
-0.8285005689,
-0.5994301438,
-0.5761601925,
-0.8171284795,
0.2355814278,
-0.5631357431,
0.162305966,
-0.3021362424,
0.190257445,
0.1361386329,
0.0809589252,
-0.8022712469,
0.3291929364,
0.2287528515,
1.387005806,
-0.7703883052,
0.8462207913,
0.7297791839,
-0.4413264096,
-0.9986445308,
0.4278456271,
-0.0438647307,
-0.5387749672,
0.6222868562,
0.2229441702,
-0.5118412375,
-0.1550408751,
-0.4998323619,
-0.933993876,
0.9501127005,
0.6686059833,
-0.623255372,
0.0962441117,
0.0206089728,
0.3833607435,
-0.258605212,
0.5291845798,
0.586206913,
0.5644410253,
0.175945729,
-0.7790552974,
0.0099101914,
-0.2493546903,
-0.5851401687,
0.1176008955,
-0.9370250106,
1.0304344893,
-0.0595574789,
0.0828357786,
-0.1067647114,
0.6150366068,
0.3721687198,
0.3612107933,
0.665132165,
0.5013839602,
1.0188555717,
-0.1617782265,
0.9419554472,
-0.1810552925,
0.2485602796,
1.1597138643,
-0.244147718,
1.0797241926,
0.3016533852,
-0.163917914,
0.2993585765,
0.8426696062,
0.2855762541,
0.2122699618,
0.4386627078,
-0.1898850203,
-0.7249328494,
-0.244481951,
-0.3154638708,
0.5356724858,
0.3054080606,
0.1294616312,
-0.3162982762,
-0.5675723553,
0.1661828756,
-0.1102831215,
-0.1489042491,
0.4808718264,
0.0756784901,
-0.9306752086,
0.3931156993,
0.0396457501,
0.4271912873,
-0.4514408112,
0.0182494856,
-0.7139182091,
-0.0111391237,
-0.1811154485,
-0.9625216722,
0.0364551917,
0.0509470962,
-0.3460256755,
0.3370966315,
0.6244621873,
-0.4316172898,
-0.5413504243,
0.3551289141,
0.9784408808,
0.3077712655,
-0.5039784312,
-0.7373299599,
0.0048234072,
-0.2025482655,
-0.5316497684,
0.1332101971,
0.730009675,
-0.2721312344,
0.9622679353,
0.6571979523,
0.0083616888,
0.107896477,
0.4594985843,
1.1437778473,
-0.4986948669,
-0.0989123136,
-0.7097850442,
0.1291680932,
-0.1200417131,
-0.6478137374,
0.7895861864,
0.6829473972,
0.7458467484,
0.0845015496,
0.8018927574,
0.2250503302,
0.6708364487,
-0.4399385154,
0.560524404,
-0.7523398995,
0.2236066014,
-0.3568054438,
-0.9691047072,
-0.0729950368,
0.1271709651,
-0.1912451833,
-0.1445582956,
0.5893150568,
0.8116861582,
-0.0742002502,
0.1032802463,
0.3068394959,
-0.0091114258,
0.4317051172,
0.5212597847,
1.2913933992,
-0.4237660468,
0.8395184875,
-0.2960312366,
-0.1895467192,
-0.0576636158,
-0.7262794375,
-0.8552147746,
-0.5299561024,
-0.1783918142,
-0.2269296646,
-0.1046417728,
0.7659518123,
0.6123257875,
-0.7891928554,
-0.1071654409,
0.2284186184,
0.1279848218,
-0.0980005041,
-0.1273433417,
0.4787760973,
-0.1854932606,
-0.6240401268,
0.3713276386,
0.2318657637,
-0.3053224981,
-0.6058784723,
-0.1515005827,
-0.3657080829,
0.351567775,
0.4312323928,
0.0253148396,
-0.707356751,
-0.2041431069,
0.4247716665,
-0.1496154815,
-0.2187474966,
0.7871511579,
-0.1529608965,
0.3983328938,
0.6875993013,
0.9645562172,
0.6227514148,
0.2080141157,
0.4137035012,
-0.5417876244,
-0.3467911184,
0.1239026636,
0.469239682,
0.2755141556,
-0.1528448761,
0.5193095803,
0.241808027,
-0.5120471716,
-0.5017780066,
0.1850133389,
-0.9528828859,
-0.4406388402,
1.4414256811,
-0.3463467658,
-0.0829900578,
-0.4315112233,
-0.1744823605,
0.0252119433,
-0.3577138186,
0.4100341201,
1.1131367683,
-0.291267693,
-0.1514767855,
-0.693487823,
0.3001645505,
0.1258393377,
-1.2232972383,
0.2895137668,
0.6613903046,
0.3666689694,
0.1043520495,
0.7372121811,
0.0760026202,
0.2769575417,
0.1085113212,
0.0638804957,
-0.0480093844,
-0.4418000877,
0.1466137767,
0.4369509518,
0.1823787093,
-0.083429873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14101v1
|
Cost-Efficient Subjective Task Annotation and Modeling through Few-Shot Annotator Adaptation
| 2024-02-21T19:53:36 | 2024-02-21T19:53:36 |
Preni Golazizian, Ali Omrani, Alireza S. Ziabari, Morteza Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In subjective NLP tasks, where a single ground truth does not exist, the
inclusion of diverse annotators becomes crucial as their unique perspectives
significantly influence the annotations. In realistic scenarios, the annotation
budget often becomes the main determinant of the number of perspectives (i.e.,
annotators) included in the data and subsequent modeling. We introduce a novel
framework for annotation collection and modeling in subjective tasks that aims
to minimize the annotation budget while maximizing the predictive performance
for each annotator. Our framework has a two-stage design: first, we rely on a
small set of annotators to build a multitask model, and second, we augment the
model for a new perspective by strategically annotating a few samples per
annotator. To test our framework at scale, we introduce and release a unique
dataset, Moral Foundations Subjective Corpus, of 2000 Reddit posts annotated by
24 annotators for moral sentiment. We demonstrate that our framework surpasses
the previous SOTA in capturing the annotators' individual perspectives with as
little as 25% of the original annotation budget on two datasets. Furthermore,
our framework results in more equitable models, reducing the performance
disparity among annotators.
|
[
-0.5651032329,
-0.3179719448,
0.4840326905,
0.1832661182,
-0.4471041858,
-0.4205018282,
-0.0658088773,
-0.6101560593,
-0.0592247806,
0.7014757991,
-0.7942224741,
-0.4057357907,
-0.8060362339,
0.1368111521,
0.0835362151,
1.475990653,
0.4085814953,
-0.2554704249,
-0.1742893606,
-0.446090579,
-0.1544714123,
-0.4726879299,
-0.5908588171,
-0.1829222739,
0.5937539935,
0.4523821175,
0.5065852404,
0.2622633278,
0.8643065691,
0.1977591962,
0.1591647714,
-0.0367411301,
-0.3725176156,
-0.1008992866,
-0.3010670245,
-0.565939188,
-0.3716268539,
0.1092526019,
0.1575756818,
0.6502642632,
0.1358763427,
0.654722631,
0.2146871388,
0.7258045077,
-0.9813243151,
0.2759393752,
-0.5465250015,
0.2354864925,
-0.1006485969,
-0.0382186174,
-0.4183242321,
-0.3527303636,
0.2501560748,
-0.9778724313,
-0.0126020135,
-0.1973052174,
0.4231277108,
0.6509200931,
-0.1523614079,
-0.0953285992,
-0.4639583528,
0.9185010791,
-0.7327647805,
0.0708736852,
0.3806099594,
0.0433838107,
0.3694591224,
-0.3140974045,
-0.4512399435,
0.0240883511,
-0.0155121582,
0.1597860307,
-0.165350616,
0.0252130181,
0.4164791107,
-0.1010999382,
-0.0224716421,
-0.2217636108,
-0.1649211645,
0.171974197,
0.6155726314,
0.0414812863,
-0.2096807808,
-0.5924517512,
-0.5443152785,
0.1776353866,
-0.1514435261,
0.2444822937,
0.2089754641,
0.5297976136,
-0.2637815177,
0.6516711116,
-0.1927705705,
0.7443152666,
0.3503702581,
-0.3079907894,
0.3453802764,
-0.533623457,
-0.1779519022,
-0.1886276007,
0.5221849084,
0.719275713,
0.3731072247,
0.2605210841,
-0.0794162601,
0.0559671707,
0.637450099,
-0.7631607652,
-0.327027142,
0.1819355041,
-0.5928581357,
-0.521912396,
-0.2841982543,
-0.7166225314,
-0.7316508889,
-0.474806577,
0.2700557113,
-0.2394649237,
-0.2967587113,
0.1057420373,
0.0782242045,
0.0235317964,
0.6153485775,
-0.7125384212,
0.2962499261,
0.8231759071,
1.1001437902,
-0.0497928299,
-0.0301760063,
-0.5404868126,
-0.1875598282,
-0.2341866195,
0.9833604693,
-0.3789315224,
-0.0850533172,
-0.0166817345,
-0.2028189152,
0.2685650289,
-0.1883907914,
0.8109229207,
-0.3318523467,
-0.0317626297,
-0.7009677291,
-0.4664029181,
-0.359940201,
0.4569762051,
-0.7822986841,
0.8450373411,
0.1784862876,
-1.2108941078,
0.7221377492,
-1.1281410456,
-0.1853811145,
0.1283668876,
0.0857991651,
-0.1505186111,
0.3473260999,
0.0420228168,
0.7139564753,
-0.2256444693,
0.1833327562,
-0.4972873032,
-0.2712500989,
0.2063719481,
0.0904946849,
0.8705215454,
0.1340161562,
-0.2518756986,
0.1117924601,
-0.7274119854,
-0.2740372419,
-0.1790460646,
-0.2904589772,
-0.5906578302,
0.1005336121,
0.4870112538,
0.5723516941,
0.1478779167,
-0.7245908976,
0.0502122007,
-0.4511761367,
0.0850731805,
0.9624890089,
0.0664622486,
0.6806331277,
-0.408498764,
0.3507290184,
0.2279244214,
0.2974709868,
0.0931700915,
-0.4043017328,
-0.7311162949,
-0.5213455558,
0.1020853817,
0.4192580879,
-0.5172413588,
0.3088552654,
-0.2104487717,
-0.3345052004,
-0.5726538301,
0.092549555,
0.2783891857,
0.4706913829,
0.3103685975,
-0.5870243311,
-0.3998810947,
-1.0389965773,
-0.5167364478,
-0.3328824341,
-0.0339998081,
0.2548175156,
0.7408547401,
0.2300127447,
1.1001322269,
-0.4083967209,
-0.5092686415,
-0.0632686615,
0.3848356903,
0.2425815612,
0.5160768628,
0.693996489,
-0.8330436349,
-0.2615837753,
-0.2119541764,
-0.8285724521,
-0.0083273323,
-0.5030394793,
-0.227222383,
0.079897657,
0.0755038112,
-0.3288694322,
0.2837629318,
0.5218068957,
-0.3885577023,
0.3355203867,
0.2159120291,
0.0631497279,
-0.9247515202,
0.1768185049,
0.3141255975,
-0.5172318816,
-0.4319099784,
-0.003249102,
-0.1654270142,
0.1688891798,
-0.6355695128,
0.3696067631,
-0.1077513248,
0.0019377295,
-0.4401026368,
0.3059868217,
-0.0208999496,
0.842374444,
0.0388966016,
0.4332489967,
0.3471488357,
-0.4090036154,
0.024093464,
0.4588713646,
-0.1525198966,
0.98514992,
-0.5759010315,
0.3418904245,
-0.4542394876,
0.2545079887,
-0.6812496185,
-0.0744298175,
0.5580206513,
-0.1474258304,
-0.2255537957,
-0.4919178486,
-0.3067805767,
0.0142381238,
-0.5036582947,
0.207321465,
0.0820347592,
-0.4458714724,
0.8207829595,
0.5972031951,
-0.2574262917,
-0.6473373771,
-0.9101814032,
0.0495151952,
-0.2431215346,
-0.217152819,
0.0555245169,
-0.0423123538,
-0.2876413167,
0.2735889256,
-0.1591189653,
0.0319078304,
0.2715993524,
0.5450790524,
0.1905633956,
-0.0278591868,
0.2955994606,
-0.058279518,
-0.3112832904,
0.1646173596,
-0.5700327158,
0.0781900734,
-0.2750617266,
-0.3154078722,
-0.4376634061,
0.5619225502,
0.2340967357,
-0.3716440499,
0.7328206897,
0.6375407577,
-0.6497183442,
-0.1096429154,
-0.6367307901,
0.0193073079,
-0.3874180913,
0.4315832853,
-0.5333706737,
-0.8190973401,
0.2540349364,
-0.0571946763,
0.634853363,
0.3320035338,
0.5324420929,
-0.1011179909,
0.6209359765,
0.7765651345,
0.0957724452,
0.53529495,
-0.1793845147,
0.1753325015,
-0.8037167788,
0.0931280851,
-0.3893923461,
-0.4253737032,
-0.6388266683,
-0.6088091731,
0.3064419925,
0.049801413,
-0.1860122085,
0.0604690202,
-0.7216630578,
0.4973667264,
0.8145169616,
0.2848378718,
0.3453121185,
-0.1871840805,
0.3853599727,
-0.1461323053,
-0.4931402802,
-0.9209637642,
1.3796197176,
0.1433990449,
0.2201592773,
0.1530955136,
0.8766399622,
0.310407728,
0.6419829726,
-0.8270878196,
0.4676332772,
-0.3623831868,
-0.7885862589,
-0.017198408,
-0.1289140135,
-0.1165174767,
0.3748993874,
-0.4282602966,
-0.7124062777,
0.6444545984,
0.2754541337,
-0.7951428294,
0.1695439219,
-0.5649670959,
0.9749985337,
0.0828405619,
-0.6987461448,
-0.2045050561,
-0.7311477661,
0.3773672879,
-0.3657989204,
0.2111108303,
-0.6318947673,
-0.2559306324,
0.9478146434,
0.1216562167,
1.130541563,
-0.6645637751,
0.295876205,
0.3905592263,
0.029582778,
0.4806684554,
0.2485177964,
-0.3661142886,
0.1813677549,
0.1357244998,
-0.489295274,
-0.2608527243,
0.3592462838,
-0.5667343736,
-0.35281232,
-0.5340092182,
-0.5951443911,
-0.3130588531,
0.0804798156,
0.035612572,
0.1192332953,
-0.2142759264,
0.142710939,
0.0965160504,
0.0482787006,
0.5447539687,
0.1145329773,
0.2165717483,
-0.2832985222,
0.4779369235,
-0.1404395849,
0.0031114896,
0.1671389341,
0.2110472023,
-0.1270939708,
-0.4119808376,
-0.1255973279,
-0.0532721989,
-0.8836812377,
-0.3787833154,
-0.9785764217,
0.5243878365,
-0.1394408196,
-0.3390178382,
-0.6456173062,
-0.6593672037,
-0.3145392239,
-0.2193774134,
0.6475782394,
0.4190797508,
-0.3943795562,
0.3663152456,
-0.5995864272,
0.457436949,
0.2964417636,
0.1595350355,
-0.2077593952,
-0.2385433465,
-0.3252108991,
0.0885724276,
-0.2853507102,
-0.746814549,
0.2057646364,
0.2154150009,
-0.0680294335,
0.3232630491,
0.3732206523,
0.6584278345,
-0.3754059672,
0.7755687833,
0.3804737031,
-1.1524733305,
0.3606067598,
-0.2680764496,
0.2693340778,
1.1752847433,
0.342287451,
-0.4016295075,
-0.2119390517,
-0.39571926,
-0.6670197248,
0.9679434299,
0.2036802173,
0.2873297632,
0.1790673286,
0.5402422547,
0.3576638997,
0.2210293412,
-0.8911377788,
0.0154370964,
-0.6536463499,
-0.4810824096,
-0.0928636193,
-0.3441103995,
-0.3488195539,
-0.1770156324,
0.5478090048,
-0.5932452679,
0.2680526972,
0.2755672634,
-0.1650168896,
0.0257077813,
0.2408512384,
0.3694909811,
0.5286197066,
-0.2374281436,
0.2773465812,
0.2018914372,
-0.2161519676,
-0.0032385779,
0.089214012,
-0.2770073414,
0.041246701,
0.3381410539,
0.862931788,
0.3005353212,
-0.4756041765,
0.7398572564,
0.1419813484,
-0.0701922923,
-0.4304605722,
-0.1792788953,
0.3113862872,
0.6603281498,
0.0720811859,
0.6063812971,
0.5128139853,
-0.1994128227,
0.1634263247,
0.2247954756,
-0.3757717907,
-0.3919033408,
0.6789695621,
0.368217051,
-0.1212971658,
0.0907740593,
-0.3694888055,
-0.3459444642,
0.3018839359,
0.1611491591,
1.0455801487,
0.1968833059,
0.4209990799,
0.5071086287,
0.2411929071,
-0.1291062534,
0.2610198259,
-0.246744439,
-0.7734327912,
-0.4417609572,
-0.7529404163,
-0.5303000212,
-0.3914595246,
-0.7917829156,
0.2668381929,
-0.5490732193,
-0.451464355,
0.2099329084,
0.060461551,
-0.9539172053,
0.3185020089,
0.1759110987,
0.443079859,
-0.8496204615,
0.471224606,
0.6535291076,
-0.5209624767,
-0.3229723275,
-0.0441342555,
0.1493868828,
-0.6677138209,
0.5702379942,
0.122258991,
-0.2698337436,
-0.1430906802,
-0.4582495987,
-0.5436775088,
0.5071854591,
0.4750354588,
-0.8112365603,
-0.2519616783,
0.0528207868,
0.4457611442,
-0.5604662895,
0.0826703832,
0.4026272297,
0.5186449885,
-0.2537656426,
-0.5149142146,
0.1604852974,
-0.1559380442,
-0.1468503326,
-0.0689753816,
-0.3766012788,
0.6844794154,
-0.3886252046,
-0.0653375164,
-0.2298470885,
0.464401871,
0.2805274427,
0.256757617,
0.8628521562,
0.2277094424,
0.5731008053,
0.119050324,
1.0123587847,
-0.2652255595,
0.6537601948,
1.3823280334,
-0.2713896632,
0.8645387292,
0.6481252909,
0.0363893807,
0.1019461825,
0.3798056543,
-0.0713329837,
0.5739453435,
0.1280220002,
-0.3249696195,
-0.6047977805,
-0.5086310506,
0.0294929948,
0.5657086968,
-0.1647892594,
-0.2369657457,
-0.0455289967,
0.2359483391,
0.0417948663,
-0.0392495468,
-0.0838726535,
1.0485855341,
0.1917241514,
-0.4629764259,
0.3035455048,
-0.0040956195,
0.8615931869,
-0.2087298334,
0.1329425126,
-0.0439361408,
0.270865202,
-0.3140640259,
-0.5160443187,
0.5693978667,
0.349081248,
-0.1809824407,
-0.5257839561,
0.6747653484,
-0.0771130919,
-0.8644268513,
0.1727989018,
0.5338107944,
-0.0696844831,
-0.4517602324,
-0.7630415559,
-0.0274997465,
-0.1097673923,
-0.5348626971,
-0.0096025737,
0.4678653181,
0.1495966017,
0.2706030905,
0.5664967299,
0.0844169557,
-0.0586700961,
0.0246934425,
0.772048831,
-0.8124701977,
-0.5548965335,
-0.828500092,
0.7824359536,
-0.0791436285,
-0.580365479,
0.3753668368,
0.2885185182,
0.9454526901,
-0.2383135259,
0.878670156,
-0.0632109046,
0.4563170671,
-0.2374865115,
0.575293839,
-0.8110179901,
-0.1910684109,
-0.5931551456,
-0.7580013275,
-0.4707842767,
0.9799759984,
-0.27353701,
-0.1619334519,
0.6244062781,
0.4019480646,
-0.0257466827,
0.5053144097,
0.1117380038,
0.0113978796,
0.1863967776,
0.6588832736,
0.7489468455,
-0.261991173,
0.1489261389,
-0.7085957527,
-0.2538268268,
-0.0304309875,
-1.0429269075,
-0.8119668365,
-0.5571151376,
-0.7420198917,
0.0809875429,
0.0465876423,
1.2310006618,
0.9964941144,
-0.8089175224,
-0.0365738943,
-0.186126709,
-0.1782509834,
-0.3980466425,
-0.1938320249,
0.1722120494,
-0.3058724701,
-0.8228565454,
-0.2117565721,
0.2640350759,
-0.5904456973,
-0.0651921108,
0.2935450375,
-0.3520242274,
0.1478734612,
0.9294591546,
-0.1981049329,
-0.7756482363,
-0.6016483903,
-0.0967729464,
0.1663457453,
0.2468695492,
0.8565537333,
-0.6303079128,
0.3651214838,
0.2204464823,
0.7760691643,
0.6425594687,
0.0890319496,
0.1034589186,
-0.7228901386,
0.2404010743,
0.6220534444,
0.0828334987,
0.4834268689,
-0.3914201856,
0.5999056101,
0.2527910173,
-0.2202107608,
-0.8380026817,
0.1504480094,
-1.2497828007,
-0.2358976752,
0.9122824669,
-0.3622452021,
-0.0538835824,
-0.1899569035,
-0.2837485969,
0.2116152942,
-0.4636173248,
0.721767962,
0.7478945255,
-0.4137607515,
-0.263736099,
-0.5355613828,
0.4456030428,
0.4557041228,
-0.9943565726,
0.3152674437,
0.6005418897,
0.2645964324,
0.3802831769,
0.8631520867,
0.0210756697,
0.211095944,
0.0284435768,
0.4333005846,
0.0107951434,
-0.2061474919,
-0.293998301,
0.5851274133,
0.161880523,
-0.4373885691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14086v1
|
LexC-Gen: Generating Data for Extremely Low-Resource Languages with Large Language Models and Bilingual Lexicons
| 2024-02-21T19:20:06 | 2024-02-21T19:20:06 |
Zheng-Xin Yong, Cristina Menghini, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Data scarcity in low-resource languages can be addressed with word-to-word
translations from labeled task data in high-resource languages using bilingual
lexicons. However, bilingual lexicons often have limited lexical overlap with
task data, which results in poor translation coverage and lexicon utilization.
We propose lexicon-conditioned data generation (LexC-Gen), a method that
generates low-resource-language classification task data at scale.
Specifically, LexC-Gen first uses high-resource-language words from bilingual
lexicons to generate lexicon-compatible task data, and then it translates them
into low-resource languages with bilingual lexicons via word translation.
Across 17 extremely low-resource languages, LexC-Gen generated data is
competitive with expert-translated gold data, and yields on average 5.6 and 8.9
points improvement over existing lexicon-based word translation methods on
sentiment analysis and topic classification tasks respectively. We show that
conditioning on bilingual lexicons is the key component of LexC-Gen. LexC-Gen
is also practical -- it only needs a single GPU to generate data at scale. It
works well with open-access LLMs, and its cost is one-fifth of the cost of
GPT4-based multilingual data generation.
|
[
-0.5169579387,
-0.4871388972,
0.5429369807,
0.1857750863,
-0.1760320961,
0.0988191068,
-0.63811028,
-0.1913005263,
0.2123698145,
0.3837803006,
-0.552215755,
-0.6523610353,
-0.3237772286,
0.2208387554,
-0.135971278,
1.1182031631,
0.063218236,
-0.0443915166,
-0.332457304,
-0.2132393867,
-0.0395141728,
-0.7671486735,
-0.7344971895,
-0.1898740679,
0.4588001072,
0.7018785477,
0.9919778109,
0.7401726246,
0.2797157168,
0.2710468769,
-0.0564205125,
0.4088079333,
-0.5351017714,
-0.0876385495,
-0.1606642902,
-0.3647727072,
-0.5420298576,
-0.1796268374,
0.5980945826,
0.9059134722,
-0.0130612655,
0.1418571025,
-0.0007353242,
0.5893249512,
-0.8016725779,
0.2891961038,
-0.6894654036,
0.128990382,
-0.4791747034,
-0.1045161411,
-0.5241655707,
-0.0601716638,
-0.5809434652,
-0.6603044271,
0.5003290176,
0.2537812293,
0.4824361205,
0.3244172037,
-0.1945003569,
-0.0222387332,
-0.7511219978,
0.8547378182,
-0.6824336648,
0.3086852729,
0.4860663414,
-0.1615593135,
0.0737378225,
-0.4609207511,
-0.6794527769,
-0.0720025077,
0.0253465511,
0.2377566695,
-0.0742976144,
0.0154521987,
0.5650171041,
0.3676789403,
-0.5035348535,
0.2712139487,
-0.230761677,
-0.1569778472,
0.5670223236,
0.2920870185,
0.5050328374,
-0.3278618455,
-0.0901614949,
-0.1795432568,
-0.9101955295,
-0.2490979582,
0.4669328928,
0.7682014108,
-0.044861678,
0.7029776573,
-0.1727803349,
0.5632147789,
-0.2653151155,
-0.2108685374,
0.3637243211,
-0.7895168066,
-0.03859438,
0.226201728,
0.8983110189,
0.1426297128,
0.1225817874,
-0.3402293026,
-0.364500165,
0.0520376451,
-0.0076643717,
-0.8341854811,
0.1376574785,
-0.094420895,
-0.2811879218,
-0.0936899632,
-0.1853280813,
-0.9359468818,
-0.1867524832,
-0.2827512324,
-0.1778556257,
-0.1853518635,
-0.3120220602,
0.043673683,
0.0514402986,
-0.0313905999,
-0.1477570832,
-1.0735337734,
0.4642897844,
0.4065468311,
0.9609296918,
-0.3192873597,
-0.1925908327,
-0.7763361335,
0.0206957497,
-0.3960262537,
0.4583806098,
-0.3358776271,
-0.5926600099,
0.1858040243,
-0.081328854,
-0.1021995768,
-0.5907669067,
0.5681449175,
-0.3046483099,
-0.134850502,
-0.3808166087,
-0.2942917645,
0.4604331553,
-0.0458999723,
-0.7262794375,
1.0503230095,
0.1782380193,
-1.1257231236,
0.3572907746,
-0.2752404213,
-0.6281989217,
0.398648113,
-0.1786281914,
-0.2454259992,
0.1033457816,
0.3110227585,
0.3212634623,
-0.5287730098,
0.1716285497,
-0.3148507178,
-0.019265186,
0.1357899904,
-0.1143930331,
0.535651505,
0.5306950212,
-0.319219619,
-0.2625160217,
-0.4815112054,
0.0197940655,
0.1474092156,
-0.476655215,
-0.4337202907,
0.1957374811,
0.2086046934,
0.2272640318,
0.3684667349,
-0.8399307728,
0.0896591023,
-0.2876157463,
0.2737424672,
0.226049751,
-0.3613989949,
0.6466674805,
-0.2089245915,
0.6454116106,
-0.1925776601,
-0.0206850395,
0.1103189439,
-0.5240202546,
-0.8073146939,
-0.0720034316,
0.2433298528,
0.7015783191,
-1.2710362673,
0.4370529652,
-0.5480636954,
-0.3953279257,
-0.3292390108,
0.422485888,
0.4963001907,
0.4521548748,
0.4901360571,
-0.1079941839,
-0.388106823,
-0.9113625884,
0.0783475041,
-0.2202513665,
0.089279145,
0.3076099157,
0.1091624796,
-0.1754279882,
0.7361050844,
-0.4924564958,
-0.1319007277,
-0.7018039823,
0.2880581617,
-0.0442398116,
0.3996734023,
0.6289653778,
-0.6190329194,
-0.3294734657,
0.1785864085,
-0.4301729202,
-0.2322375029,
-0.0723208338,
-0.1753161252,
0.4748091698,
0.8542076945,
-0.3396976888,
0.0976874381,
0.7402130365,
-0.2964235842,
0.3023922443,
-0.4832612574,
-0.1733712554,
-1.0846793652,
0.205532968,
0.0985086411,
-0.2837506533,
-0.685025692,
-0.0357211195,
0.1057674959,
-0.4587047994,
-0.3739130199,
0.614097476,
-0.2610191107,
-0.0772056207,
-0.2201945335,
0.0472173914,
-0.3669035733,
0.4471278191,
0.3250314295,
0.7723320723,
0.3660131991,
-0.392200619,
0.3032200038,
0.2241024077,
-0.4017524719,
0.1584250331,
-0.2507417202,
0.0943367183,
-0.1394595206,
0.0335081033,
-0.5459195971,
-0.2498311698,
-0.0282734893,
-0.2388796955,
0.3235467672,
0.0421347991,
-0.8485517502,
-0.3774917126,
-0.0302080195,
0.8078382015,
0.5994579792,
-0.6878119111,
0.2723080814,
0.3518557549,
-0.5899229646,
-0.3730890155,
-1.0187977552,
0.0523283146,
0.008554454,
-0.3251185417,
0.4038778543,
-0.1090641916,
-0.2833094001,
0.2783174217,
0.0816325396,
0.0260800198,
-0.1714178175,
0.1426931471,
0.3984579742,
-0.0547225997,
0.2195391059,
0.0904889777,
0.0594698153,
-0.103554219,
-0.3235740364,
0.4920172691,
-0.1148603335,
-0.3030606806,
0.050158184,
0.3683327138,
0.5661085248,
-0.2403003275,
0.6702726483,
0.6231177449,
-0.3033316135,
-0.5370388627,
-0.3493371308,
0.1481595039,
-0.3961996734,
0.2963007092,
-0.3291972876,
-0.7476935387,
0.3611325026,
0.1311827153,
0.0658826455,
0.5905817747,
0.8938128948,
0.372864455,
1.1672360897,
0.5932284594,
-0.4065798819,
0.3672920167,
-0.1352229863,
0.3073610961,
-0.4455795586,
-0.0792700276,
-0.4861931801,
-0.3061034381,
-0.7279804349,
-0.5696098804,
0.3375908434,
-0.0874785483,
-0.1948419511,
0.2946679294,
-0.3633004725,
0.3442082703,
0.758061409,
0.0014666405,
0.326153487,
0.1496296376,
-0.2169000059,
0.0128687359,
-0.959399879,
-0.1434109658,
1.0795378685,
-0.0828632042,
0.6344149113,
-0.1109486893,
0.907286942,
0.1136733443,
0.288541168,
-0.9304680824,
0.5511028171,
-0.6851217151,
-0.4829153419,
-0.1843804121,
-0.9109385014,
-0.7147698998,
-0.1055405438,
-0.3806533515,
-0.2755149007,
0.1789208204,
0.0988665894,
-0.4585208595,
0.5759723783,
-0.6202842593,
0.7212898731,
-0.437402755,
-0.4290333092,
-0.2484334707,
-0.1905593425,
0.4230826199,
-0.3960841,
0.6415542364,
-0.2753947675,
-0.133275643,
0.693939507,
-0.694131732,
0.6291855574,
-0.352938205,
0.0058686738,
0.3481423557,
0.0633992702,
0.3980545402,
0.2050883621,
-0.0654037744,
-0.1058623865,
-0.1480322629,
-0.5409018397,
-0.2396325767,
0.8454310298,
-0.7256775498,
-0.3390981257,
-0.2597399354,
-0.872168839,
-0.4692767262,
0.070362404,
0.5664177537,
0.35960567,
-0.2495380193,
-0.0108625721,
0.502610147,
-0.5572667718,
0.431352824,
0.3306359649,
-0.0171953905,
-0.3849768341,
1.2741365433,
-0.0133850127,
0.2438892573,
0.1463806927,
-0.00155424,
-0.0698969737,
-0.4606516063,
-0.5850480795,
0.3126546144,
-0.2504116297,
-0.4107492566,
-0.3607843816,
-0.3023653924,
-0.2826050222,
-0.2058845311,
-0.4999895394,
-0.4371477365,
-0.2232103944,
-0.0478529595,
0.2573916912,
0.516467154,
-0.3889060616,
0.2421305776,
-0.7681440711,
0.5113518238,
0.3108200133,
0.0937321261,
-0.3133690059,
-0.230325982,
-0.3800447583,
0.0401253328,
-0.0299188625,
-0.4968492389,
0.644382596,
0.3406202197,
0.3305098116,
0.3420507312,
0.2070531547,
0.2617523968,
-0.5525332689,
0.7373381853,
0.4589440823,
-0.9180859923,
0.3008636534,
-0.253672719,
0.4077897668,
0.5407620668,
0.3319946527,
-0.6280974746,
-0.6341415644,
-0.5475513339,
-0.9190095067,
0.8913525939,
0.2368235141,
0.181548208,
-0.2618989646,
0.3516426086,
-0.0156109966,
-0.0130710639,
-0.4879573882,
-0.0630669072,
-0.3457324207,
-0.2816755176,
-0.4061540067,
-0.2066086531,
-0.1213885099,
-0.2475129813,
0.6592735648,
-0.3840860426,
0.1095116064,
0.0327422209,
-0.0816745684,
-0.1087942123,
0.4746202528,
0.2178047895,
0.2123263478,
-0.0663843751,
0.2404441983,
0.3177059591,
-0.2879399359,
0.0803269744,
0.3103015721,
-0.2547097504,
0.0454924032,
0.2282342613,
0.9323999882,
0.1214727908,
-0.8187184334,
0.5277633667,
-0.0891565084,
-0.3707365096,
-0.0753275082,
-0.0759535506,
0.2539851964,
-0.0757428855,
0.0040401653,
-0.0716794059,
-0.1829169542,
-0.4899156392,
-0.0191730615,
0.4860999286,
0.114493981,
-0.3485409915,
0.8576518893,
0.1905427277,
0.4189829528,
0.9416233301,
-0.6828119159,
-0.3570952117,
0.6125383377,
0.585414052,
0.6590088606,
-0.0652314648,
0.3371606171,
0.8129401207,
0.1997727156,
-0.3990943134,
0.4774776101,
-0.2725947499,
-0.9784767628,
-0.5845192075,
-0.9133943915,
-0.4782787561,
0.1133443043,
-0.7597679496,
0.1710951179,
-0.4254190922,
-0.4343515337,
-0.1679849327,
-0.0668363571,
-0.895898819,
-0.0189769343,
0.719237566,
0.8327257633,
-1.090507865,
1.0440452099,
0.5692558885,
-0.2960686684,
-0.6950945258,
-0.3891577721,
-0.079596512,
-0.8342722058,
0.775133431,
-0.1957156062,
-0.1151702479,
0.0438115783,
-0.3758418858,
-0.8030125499,
0.7736808062,
0.5599458218,
-0.7036960721,
-0.2261930406,
0.5313871503,
0.5641368628,
-0.2600542307,
-0.3310905099,
0.7888408303,
0.6040284038,
0.0019918114,
-0.7974805832,
0.044103954,
-0.4685558677,
0.0816039219,
0.3218132257,
-0.4772742689,
0.7185732126,
-0.3825148344,
-0.4836729765,
0.1638969332,
0.5626125932,
0.1822876036,
0.1272328496,
0.6481607556,
1.0061019659,
0.6562232971,
-0.2178639024,
1.0599702597,
-0.7053340077,
0.3222004771,
0.9916933179,
-0.2439848632,
0.6959388256,
0.1995962262,
-0.0366638266,
0.2921307385,
0.5386502147,
-0.1687881351,
0.4563051164,
0.2934277952,
-0.5065996051,
-0.4762680829,
-0.497849673,
-0.1159279868,
0.2399523258,
0.5610830188,
-0.1319103092,
-0.2501512766,
0.2178396583,
0.2054181695,
0.0578180812,
-0.5643266439,
0.5989622474,
0.0873119384,
-0.6930366158,
0.7815543413,
0.1219794452,
0.7215805054,
-0.4475933313,
0.5732495189,
-0.618760705,
0.1115891635,
-0.3760497868,
-0.4423313737,
0.242432937,
0.4532510936,
-0.1054452285,
-0.4658759534,
0.4696850777,
-0.7569016218,
-0.7838902473,
0.3945448697,
0.9215641022,
0.1219209954,
0.0723390356,
-0.2407643646,
-0.0857217684,
-0.1769459546,
-0.1368234158,
0.4159343541,
0.3197044134,
0.0936966315,
0.3149274886,
0.484529376,
0.7089878321,
0.223580271,
0.2730168402,
0.7912435532,
-0.5278012156,
-0.2380104512,
-0.4780673683,
-0.1202609465,
0.0887783915,
-0.1755851209,
0.4448916316,
0.7630829811,
1.0045264959,
0.027131781,
1.0811957121,
-0.3131531179,
0.2673128247,
-0.5186841488,
0.5549792051,
-0.7822483182,
-0.2462431639,
0.1541538686,
-0.871696949,
-0.2761659026,
-0.0336018689,
-0.260253489,
-0.1803966165,
0.8196561933,
0.7673842311,
-0.1072510779,
-0.248873964,
0.2686128616,
-0.1456013918,
0.0279086214,
0.7920997143,
0.5887145996,
0.1299101114,
0.766710937,
-0.5517027378,
-0.2503351867,
0.1259099096,
-0.5119796991,
-0.8024303913,
-0.6698687673,
-0.1908188462,
-0.3165691197,
-0.3215215206,
0.888225615,
0.5305383801,
-0.8349602818,
-0.362175554,
-0.3589859307,
-0.087936528,
-0.075896576,
-0.1778718084,
0.3117293119,
-1.0033382177,
-1.1379982233,
0.5703433156,
-0.0024873938,
-0.0241585579,
-0.1619987488,
-0.1198589727,
0.3205684721,
-0.1536996812,
0.5744095445,
0.6387389302,
-0.3916653991,
0.0322996899,
-0.0312144998,
-0.3458122909,
-0.0687365979,
1.3105678558,
-0.7495074868,
0.5026461482,
0.5713809729,
0.8372560143,
0.6059108973,
-0.0268695783,
0.5107765198,
-0.8510320783,
0.3759632707,
0.2483264953,
0.6011594534,
0.3996567428,
-0.20805718,
0.4101451635,
0.4072145224,
-0.4051047862,
-0.5751493573,
0.3217053413,
-0.8649489284,
-0.3294946551,
1.4754446745,
0.0894052833,
-0.1004665494,
0.1013955772,
0.1149319187,
0.3733845651,
-0.3492730558,
0.5550281405,
0.5352342725,
0.0071317991,
0.1224774718,
-0.6421650052,
0.7219116092,
0.4880522192,
-0.9448794723,
0.3681188524,
0.518376112,
-0.0321079157,
0.2263789922,
0.6252883673,
-0.0846936479,
-0.0395559408,
0.0869286358,
0.4319817424,
-0.0065547149,
-0.243720144,
-0.0273268949,
0.0967829078,
0.2584319711,
0.1264983416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14073v1
|
Improving Language Understanding from Screenshots
| 2024-02-21T19:01:03 | 2024-02-21T19:01:03 |
Tianyu Gao, Zirui Wang, Adithya Bhaskar, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
An emerging family of language models (LMs), capable of processing both text
and images within a single visual view, has the promise to unlock complex tasks
such as chart understanding and UI navigation. We refer to these models as
screenshot language models. Despite their appeal, existing screenshot LMs
substantially lag behind text-only models on language understanding tasks. To
close this gap, we adopt a simplified setting where the model inputs are
plain-text-rendered screenshots, and we focus on improving the text ability of
screenshot LMs. We propose a novel Patch-and-Text Prediction (PTP) objective,
which masks and recovers both image patches of screenshots and text within
screenshots. We also conduct extensive ablation studies on masking rates and
patch sizes, as well as designs for improving training stability. Our
pre-trained model, while solely taking visual inputs, achieves comparable
performance with BERT on 6 out of 8 GLUE tasks (within 2%) and improves up to
8% over prior work. Additionally, we extend PTP to train autoregressive
screenshot LMs and demonstrate its effectiveness--our models can significantly
reduce perplexity by utilizing the screenshot context. Together, we hope our
findings can inspire future research on developing powerful screenshot LMs and
extending their reach to broader applications.
|
[
-0.2730634511,
-0.5782684684,
0.6077895164,
0.0370425247,
-0.3719856441,
0.3237211704,
-0.2913450003,
-0.4467355311,
-0.1152742803,
0.9248748422,
-0.5091744661,
-0.5399960876,
-0.9882996678,
-0.1313453466,
-0.3369808197,
0.7662817836,
-0.1038745865,
-0.2376641631,
-0.0885622576,
0.0642099977,
-0.2667641044,
-0.1969642937,
-0.9055014253,
-0.1818264425,
0.3311715424,
0.459425807,
0.5103099346,
0.7373438478,
0.4160145521,
0.2862770557,
-0.1086671203,
0.3436895609,
-0.3035702407,
0.2078248709,
0.0666418001,
-0.4387998283,
0.0293444768,
-0.2145431787,
0.6913376451,
0.4386286736,
0.2410650104,
0.0436956249,
0.0870715976,
0.6638559103,
-0.6620352864,
0.5762637258,
-0.8417304158,
-0.0758101791,
0.0719447359,
0.0005816213,
-0.7498338819,
0.0707614198,
0.0495132431,
-0.6350768805,
0.3616146743,
-0.3296546042,
0.8695482612,
0.1500704139,
-0.4830135107,
0.0280722436,
-0.4748852849,
0.5406488776,
-0.8857015371,
0.1513599902,
0.3598056436,
0.454503119,
-0.1545593888,
-0.7224752307,
-0.3808695078,
-0.091866307,
-0.1330078095,
0.0692684874,
-0.1399555653,
0.1443003863,
0.0784895867,
0.2254020423,
-0.5009775758,
0.1394233704,
-0.4210329652,
-0.3038564324,
0.2378041744,
-0.070824191,
0.6867331862,
-0.250753969,
-0.4383997321,
-0.2461189181,
-0.5999469161,
0.2604462206,
-0.3781629503,
0.3182877302,
-0.1089792326,
0.2436857224,
0.0524822809,
1.0744512081,
-0.0213974658,
-0.1881399155,
-0.1398487538,
-0.1535452604,
-0.2004302889,
-0.4655250907,
0.693128109,
0.5150985122,
0.2482035756,
0.0399114899,
-0.0624141879,
0.0503012538,
-0.0911817998,
-0.8182922602,
-0.5032956004,
-0.1094726548,
-0.3803206086,
-0.2902510464,
-0.0712503642,
-0.5701488853,
-0.7385466099,
-0.1845521629,
0.312489152,
-0.5773658752,
-0.3580281734,
-0.1511372477,
-0.2896928191,
-0.245308429,
0.6849243641,
-0.8866116405,
0.2619808018,
0.5115882158,
0.7537933588,
-0.0460295789,
-0.3538150191,
-0.5513593554,
0.0252660848,
-0.4191438556,
1.1848644018,
-0.29728809,
-0.2175340503,
0.0472385995,
0.0416067615,
-0.4256299734,
-0.3253200054,
-0.096058853,
-0.2776038349,
0.2603890598,
-0.0644629449,
-0.4158600569,
-0.4325340092,
0.1639048159,
-0.8740174174,
0.8757427931,
-0.0114694024,
-0.4677299857,
0.4081519842,
-0.4915691316,
-0.2278995365,
0.1050267592,
-0.1441824436,
-0.4310357571,
0.1225979328,
0.6063072681,
0.5589213371,
0.3307932615,
0.0335545205,
-0.217658937,
-0.280696243,
0.3188965023,
-0.3242154419,
0.4957611859,
0.130116567,
-0.4637270868,
0.0353651941,
-0.3875488639,
0.0666009113,
-0.1361104548,
-0.0578621328,
-0.2196061462,
0.0685437322,
0.2183595449,
0.4934416413,
0.0707235411,
-0.2447385341,
0.3277106285,
-0.2894630134,
0.5680367947,
0.7619146109,
-0.0381107777,
0.6823084354,
-0.1845289171,
0.7778308392,
-0.0916716903,
-0.078755036,
-0.9054603577,
-0.3607226014,
-0.6220799685,
-0.6436706185,
0.1830441803,
0.4060425162,
-1.0130110979,
-0.1264674813,
-0.3609330654,
-0.4814683497,
-0.3018506765,
0.203167364,
0.9042407274,
0.5257290006,
0.1360096931,
-0.6125746965,
-0.5812641978,
-0.8048536777,
-0.5982963443,
-0.4081046581,
-0.0415930487,
0.2337910533,
0.3963497579,
0.028786622,
0.670781672,
-0.3443796039,
-0.3123757243,
-0.7177681923,
0.455632478,
0.2276886702,
0.3750945926,
0.4543415904,
-0.5199987292,
-0.7118316293,
0.0247326586,
-0.3522518873,
-0.0567688718,
-0.1378078908,
0.1589781791,
0.5717036724,
0.6244025826,
-0.5192892551,
0.418059051,
0.7096611261,
-0.6764306426,
0.353687644,
-0.2244567275,
0.567615509,
-1.0163140297,
-0.0538686439,
0.2538121343,
-0.5732531548,
-0.7376943827,
0.1685162485,
0.5185917616,
-0.483994931,
-0.649127841,
0.7199916244,
-0.6546119452,
-0.0798307881,
-0.5069302917,
0.0863144547,
0.2361029238,
0.4224984348,
0.4435056746,
0.737334013,
0.3522953987,
-0.2885258496,
-0.1730695665,
0.1155452058,
-0.4880499244,
0.141198054,
-0.069680512,
0.16416201,
-0.1897086799,
0.6446129084,
-1.2207275629,
-0.1123489961,
0.1136754453,
-0.6430171132,
0.5195317864,
-0.37722224,
-0.327689141,
-0.3727746606,
-0.3667629063,
0.196131736,
0.5409026146,
-0.6154688597,
0.6146059632,
0.3374102414,
-0.3957591653,
-0.7337502837,
-0.5291573405,
0.193328023,
-0.0974111781,
-0.4902448654,
0.390920341,
0.184182018,
-0.0730126947,
-0.0758882463,
-0.1635697335,
-0.4592879415,
0.0442224964,
0.4036494493,
0.3993252814,
-0.1840010136,
0.1224556789,
-0.1915360242,
-0.2439972609,
-0.1311087757,
-0.1488523483,
0.3381225169,
-0.0558193848,
-0.0740666762,
-0.4953838289,
0.1256345659,
0.7654004693,
-0.14619717,
0.4969084859,
0.4595780671,
-0.4474918842,
-0.1764436811,
-0.6909243464,
-0.2687249184,
-0.411663264,
0.6648703218,
-0.3854628801,
-0.7137764096,
0.5721282363,
0.0592333898,
0.3427888751,
0.3856149912,
0.2353739589,
-0.5979679227,
0.9988709688,
0.950001359,
-0.271755904,
0.8274638653,
-0.2189641297,
0.0499168076,
-0.4347397387,
0.0341748782,
-0.4025784731,
-0.1105529815,
-0.2456918806,
-0.6373006105,
0.1347223371,
0.0875409022,
-0.0361747965,
0.5395416617,
-0.5138153434,
0.6565289497,
0.588997364,
0.5226454139,
0.2662974,
0.2319109738,
0.1190365702,
-0.3242102265,
-0.661949873,
-0.5871729255,
0.924105823,
0.4346762002,
0.4805110693,
-0.4255360961,
0.5930236578,
0.1655805558,
0.3661926985,
-0.4483656585,
0.6690084934,
-0.6021481752,
-0.4959926307,
-0.2184859514,
-0.2487532198,
-0.7945151925,
0.511878252,
-0.0623423792,
-0.9675213099,
-0.2355503589,
0.6084964871,
-0.1680188328,
0.5564385653,
-0.9430393577,
1.0278464556,
-0.1861590445,
-0.1367638856,
-0.2650987208,
-0.5744814873,
0.4757019877,
0.2211316228,
0.6297703981,
-0.1645031422,
0.1690286994,
0.6903393269,
-0.3054022193,
1.0194141865,
-0.2749403417,
0.0326317325,
0.0816725269,
0.2824580371,
0.1901095361,
-0.3565067351,
0.0283624195,
-0.2095345557,
0.1921056211,
-0.3772967458,
-0.7319737673,
0.53709203,
-0.4974628091,
-0.3506482244,
-0.2380959541,
-0.7447542548,
-0.0575258359,
-0.0749697685,
0.2808329761,
0.5787039399,
-0.0192036293,
-0.1799598783,
0.5354267359,
-0.3190199733,
0.6568242908,
0.6571344733,
-0.5567867756,
-0.339345932,
0.7792360783,
-0.0944599733,
0.5744625926,
0.3947274387,
-0.2623952329,
-0.4082604945,
-0.3819338381,
-0.3762563467,
0.1869197935,
-1.0227415562,
-0.2632875443,
-0.2925986648,
-0.1219823882,
-0.439360708,
-0.2834247947,
-0.411118567,
-0.6320634484,
-0.2179402262,
-0.1247667894,
0.537971735,
0.5768089294,
-0.1515387446,
0.3116512299,
-0.8310490847,
0.6241439581,
0.137505278,
0.2040274441,
-0.3933794796,
-0.7684565783,
-0.1635021418,
0.0728571489,
-0.3108280301,
-0.9183984995,
0.664773941,
0.3637961447,
0.4702046812,
0.2182397544,
-0.2370326519,
0.8316249847,
-0.3146336675,
0.9010734558,
0.5007585287,
-0.8802731633,
0.7187127471,
-0.2626405954,
0.8264503479,
0.6948125362,
-0.2352919877,
-0.7826614976,
-0.879042685,
-0.635396719,
-0.7393136621,
0.6278061867,
0.106826663,
-0.0115929646,
0.268650949,
0.1138210148,
0.192110166,
-0.0309190117,
-1.0610784292,
0.0622187667,
-0.0476611927,
-0.4978737831,
-0.2997274697,
-0.1900921911,
0.2335829288,
-0.2863231599,
0.612013042,
-0.0766758174,
0.1004502848,
-0.0338826887,
-0.6462970972,
-0.1001268774,
0.2350042909,
0.4834143519,
0.6976838708,
-0.0648908019,
0.4958413839,
0.0787216872,
-0.5929171443,
-0.0406903476,
0.2373616099,
-0.0175247062,
0.4494841993,
0.3171946704,
0.963044405,
0.4883315861,
-0.6781397462,
0.3174487352,
0.020239098,
-0.1524497271,
-0.0556844845,
-0.2658446431,
-0.0827985033,
0.1683939397,
0.4199743271,
0.2031289488,
-0.1151776835,
-0.450971663,
0.2521374524,
0.2637385726,
-0.4671889544,
-0.0946463346,
0.3927342296,
0.222390905,
-0.3712031543,
0.5041371584,
0.1836987436,
-0.8706793785,
1.0062898397,
0.4163854122,
0.5334393382,
-0.2922793329,
0.5410908461,
0.4238750339,
0.4283655882,
-0.0731924474,
0.1159288958,
-0.1286076158,
-0.4906285107,
-0.4839558601,
-0.1666276604,
-0.5597782135,
0.3217750192,
-0.3337017894,
0.2785230577,
-0.1670195907,
-0.0949464962,
-0.2331199646,
-0.0041418606,
-0.6425827742,
0.3996795714,
0.3719721437,
0.8859450817,
-1.0523734093,
0.8392890096,
0.5269645452,
-0.4312269092,
-0.7585978508,
-0.2794132829,
0.0571778752,
-0.7722578049,
0.4773598611,
0.6948941946,
0.194357872,
-0.0105183413,
-0.2985736132,
-0.5595811605,
0.8205820322,
0.536480248,
-0.6223151088,
-0.0768418387,
-0.0365988947,
0.2876247168,
-0.248821184,
0.5262973905,
0.577554822,
0.3073244691,
-0.2011742592,
-1.1224467754,
-0.0868344754,
-0.4553994238,
0.1172666624,
0.1389909089,
0.0726998523,
0.5600327849,
-0.2084973305,
-0.2264742553,
0.1389176995,
0.4473568499,
0.5528944135,
0.4105974734,
0.5474362969,
0.5177205801,
0.2224576622,
-0.0791479126,
0.9774196148,
-0.2932350636,
0.2484205514,
1.1661758423,
0.3830166459,
0.9950130582,
0.7239058614,
0.0083236136,
0.5630832911,
0.9151549935,
0.1241293326,
0.7875679135,
-0.0263597239,
-0.2235473096,
-0.1905955821,
0.1191259921,
-0.2666504085,
0.0939413309,
0.4309993982,
-0.7638409734,
-0.3487248719,
0.3322276771,
0.0573633611,
0.4490660429,
-0.4078944325,
0.8966595531,
0.1388595402,
-0.8489219546,
0.552544117,
-0.2311780602,
0.5863288641,
-0.5332157612,
-0.0625534803,
-0.1053575128,
0.1964853853,
-0.114371039,
-0.871263504,
0.1597127914,
-0.0449927971,
-0.1081031635,
-0.7507685423,
1.0627435446,
-0.5650978088,
-0.4944860637,
0.0853414237,
0.2208974808,
0.2403645664,
-0.2680479288,
-0.6860910058,
0.1985265911,
0.0381794907,
-0.104229331,
0.3350793123,
0.0680762902,
0.1540167779,
0.5252411962,
0.3481622934,
0.0537956245,
0.0079481695,
0.078843154,
0.5841950774,
-0.4000051916,
-0.3882992864,
-0.8631623387,
0.9386488199,
-0.2359442413,
-0.0946886018,
0.3317573369,
0.3034443855,
0.5517571568,
-0.3765238523,
0.9663695097,
0.3122122586,
0.4821289182,
-0.589137435,
0.9562497139,
-0.347907275,
-0.0027027114,
-0.4616794586,
-0.6796140075,
-0.4911350906,
0.6102972627,
-0.441444397,
-0.4964701831,
0.7637654543,
0.7647723556,
-0.0079532564,
-0.5617139339,
0.1873620301,
-0.1032116562,
0.2772095203,
0.8094720244,
0.7689820528,
-0.5379214287,
0.676668942,
-0.3242743313,
-0.3119615316,
-0.1276847422,
-0.9584699869,
-0.8665827513,
-0.9601229429,
-0.4889312088,
-0.248762086,
0.2915851176,
0.4410175383,
0.8267225027,
-0.6614179611,
-0.2697194219,
-0.4420181215,
0.2182828188,
-0.2092311382,
-0.1950319111,
0.2341658622,
-0.4575800896,
-0.6398872733,
0.3448655307,
0.3337137699,
0.0999704897,
0.0264307484,
0.069424659,
0.1099369526,
0.0116364146,
0.6132211685,
0.6580122709,
-0.9052685499,
-0.107139945,
-0.0571322329,
-0.3006749153,
0.0811869949,
0.645914793,
-0.797901988,
0.7071309686,
0.5449368358,
0.4849862158,
0.8557587266,
-0.190577358,
0.8693475723,
-0.4896950126,
0.3208831847,
0.1567242295,
0.5410039425,
0.4368003607,
-0.0484379381,
0.2253827304,
-0.21843189,
-0.146959886,
-0.8188590407,
0.3387258053,
-0.8829733133,
-0.6582061648,
1.0768021345,
-0.5064267516,
-0.2051799297,
0.1089772433,
-0.524289608,
0.3203658462,
-0.2706124187,
1.0142413378,
0.5167062283,
0.2236165851,
-0.9745341539,
-0.3943632543,
0.4497029483,
0.5004093051,
-0.8557499647,
-0.0041724602,
0.5934577584,
0.2966889441,
-0.055527851,
0.9365617633,
-0.0078583434,
0.6372696757,
-0.3410796523,
0.2162623107,
0.0049967649,
-0.1342681795,
-0.3345441222,
0.0324425772,
0.267185837,
-0.5122441649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14020v1
|
Coercing LLMs to do and reveal (almost) anything
| 2024-02-21T18:59:13 | 2024-02-21T18:59:13 |
Jonas Geiping, Alex Stein, Manli Shu, Khalid Saifullah, Yuxin Wen, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
It has recently been shown that adversarial attacks on large language models
(LLMs) can "jailbreak" the model into making harmful statements. In this work,
we argue that the spectrum of adversarial attacks on LLMs is much larger than
merely jailbreaking. We provide a broad overview of possible attack surfaces
and attack goals. Based on a series of concrete examples, we discuss,
categorize and systematize attacks that coerce varied unintended behaviors,
such as misdirection, model control, denial-of-service, or data extraction.
We analyze these attacks in controlled experiments, and find that many of
them stem from the practice of pre-training LLMs with coding capabilities, as
well as the continued existence of strange "glitch" tokens in common LLM
vocabularies that should be removed for security reasons.
|
[
-0.4778234065,
-1.1924751997,
0.357648015,
0.0509683117,
0.0869513825,
0.2034859806,
-0.2622685432,
-0.4414293468,
0.2029054612,
0.9619803429,
-0.5899941921,
-0.2345245779,
-1.0352255106,
-0.1618482023,
-0.8252090812,
1.1699459553,
0.1039765552,
0.1114114746,
0.1300957203,
0.1348144561,
-0.4811328351,
-0.9885172248,
-0.4702740312,
-0.190945223,
0.864464283,
0.0250247382,
1.0050714016,
0.5911576748,
0.4260367155,
0.2712450027,
-0.1892103553,
-0.0328090861,
-0.6862292886,
0.3607388437,
-0.1915750355,
-0.8470200896,
-0.1116623804,
0.275341779,
0.3333634138,
0.6072013974,
0.0160565078,
-0.1651973873,
0.0397343338,
0.6526405811,
-0.6318209767,
-0.430931747,
-0.9536472559,
-0.0025590886,
-0.4762748778,
0.0802899897,
-0.6363015771,
-0.1897226125,
-0.2436049581,
-0.2313310355,
-0.0495853275,
0.1287612915,
0.8107389212,
0.3036175966,
-0.3456299901,
-0.7344583869,
-0.6525357366,
0.5825318098,
-0.4014532268,
-0.0995351225,
0.459319979,
0.2668913603,
-0.7063212991,
-0.5500520468,
-0.3448883891,
-0.5020575523,
-0.2015503198,
-0.3060929179,
-0.6271907687,
0.0939182565,
0.452749908,
0.2276536673,
-0.3922598064,
0.4237564802,
-0.4544434547,
-0.037396349,
0.6227327585,
0.1645076275,
0.7550127506,
-0.0968658701,
-0.4718449414,
0.0597974434,
-1.2123360634,
-0.1319125593,
0.8297474384,
0.1381021887,
-0.0813718289,
0.8240507245,
0.4518913627,
0.6680049896,
-0.0403019637,
0.491724968,
-0.4503074288,
0.096570313,
-0.3392795324,
-0.0908862799,
0.8539220095,
0.0493821688,
0.2748776972,
-0.6321524978,
-0.2578442693,
0.2025853992,
0.4282911718,
-0.3753002286,
-0.2247370929,
0.2196609527,
-0.0770459995,
-0.72476542,
0.3216310143,
-0.6594232917,
-0.9909532666,
0.0889684856,
0.3375961781,
-0.273340553,
0.0149149653,
0.0416743979,
-0.2202805132,
0.135806188,
0.1005247831,
-0.886523366,
0.3848721087,
0.8232160211,
0.6274167895,
-0.1054637358,
-0.3048583865,
-0.6645838022,
0.0834925026,
-0.3270463049,
0.2788773477,
-0.4957684875,
-0.6778943539,
-0.1343445778,
0.0581352338,
-0.1620783955,
-0.5156174302,
0.1844245493,
-0.8891299367,
-0.0275037587,
-0.1392729133,
-0.4563093185,
-0.0390972905,
0.2720929086,
-0.833552897,
0.4989949167,
-0.2139338404,
-0.6484816074,
-0.0379724838,
-0.485737741,
-0.4851199389,
-0.4318492115,
-0.1934119165,
-0.2747181356,
0.1793260872,
0.0205974095,
0.4428662062,
-0.1361945868,
0.257999748,
-0.4931826293,
-0.1896408647,
0.7871096134,
-0.5208272934,
1.0073932409,
0.4924296439,
-0.3469718397,
0.1206738502,
-0.6559211016,
-0.3701624274,
0.3778467178,
-0.3269541562,
-0.4793800712,
0.0246712156,
-0.3883901238,
0.1301438957,
0.2940608263,
-0.4103084505,
0.5419163108,
-0.440815717,
0.6054070592,
0.8523023129,
0.0823593661,
0.415042609,
-0.3265428245,
0.6081855297,
-0.2131963074,
0.3813970387,
0.0588034987,
-0.206925109,
-0.4982666969,
-0.2708559334,
0.1431987584,
0.508468926,
-0.6963354945,
0.0533122532,
0.1595358998,
-0.5708694458,
-0.2950792313,
0.4024707675,
0.6457604766,
0.0493165143,
0.1052615941,
0.0839752331,
-0.6162039042,
-0.7202938199,
-0.50055933,
0.091058895,
0.1060734764,
-0.0836177617,
0.5241494179,
-0.2568419278,
0.4763438404,
-0.4209685326,
-0.1351882666,
-0.1572086811,
0.0581186041,
0.0957611725,
0.3696215153,
0.6795646548,
-0.815051198,
-0.11834874,
-0.3851508796,
-0.8220348358,
0.066426903,
-0.0499311462,
0.1786799878,
-0.0612519644,
1.0043523312,
-0.7080021501,
0.3749690056,
0.6495878696,
-0.3387888968,
0.6542244554,
-0.218220681,
-0.201693818,
-0.7282705307,
-0.2880797684,
-0.1697195023,
0.0379049741,
-0.9170624018,
0.5709017515,
-0.1946398616,
0.0427919626,
-0.6463952065,
0.2071205676,
-0.4267698526,
0.015854232,
-0.3081668615,
-0.0150550129,
-0.0672073588,
0.1511024237,
-0.4484373331,
0.590292871,
0.6036757827,
-0.5365748405,
0.6557025909,
-0.1087137759,
-0.1298773438,
0.0693510622,
-0.5845167041,
0.2878046632,
-0.0416176915,
0.2223585993,
-0.9074903727,
-0.1904180795,
0.2544136047,
-0.5759487152,
0.4839536548,
-0.201109916,
-0.579664588,
-0.1524856836,
-0.6303403378,
0.0736814514,
0.1797340959,
-0.7873085141,
0.2582423687,
0.4169384539,
0.1800234616,
-0.7331156135,
-0.847692728,
0.5383102298,
-0.3957956135,
-0.39735955,
0.0422439016,
0.0771426857,
-0.6705198288,
-0.1507807672,
0.3172628284,
0.310868293,
0.7036876678,
0.5860354304,
0.3718798161,
0.1219795644,
-0.1344705671,
-0.5736498237,
0.1519478709,
0.4409232438,
-0.0046418114,
0.9209926128,
-0.1319863647,
-0.6537259817,
0.1183023751,
0.3647164106,
0.7319591045,
0.0594911873,
0.7406995296,
0.2294021249,
-0.2874009013,
-0.1781843901,
-0.1779641658,
0.0568529069,
-0.4998596907,
0.4885111451,
-0.3030993044,
-0.9966248274,
0.4988040626,
0.022880882,
0.1375737488,
0.2222333699,
0.4256097078,
-0.1312389523,
1.2658331394,
0.4207967818,
-0.4060603678,
0.3357673585,
-0.2484107614,
0.1361763179,
-0.7701638341,
-0.3586944938,
-0.5876623392,
-0.1368504018,
-0.8297631741,
-0.1411452293,
0.0480038561,
0.3476238549,
-0.3651905656,
0.3503322303,
-0.357118994,
0.6250760555,
0.5456236005,
0.0151921744,
0.1403520554,
-0.1537749022,
-0.0089999987,
0.1377640814,
-0.5308671594,
-0.5585821867,
1.4021009207,
0.427511394,
1.1843192577,
0.4304059148,
0.5712993145,
0.5563587546,
0.4059928954,
-0.6945104599,
0.5063281655,
-0.3754746318,
-0.801632762,
-0.2292981893,
-0.1177295819,
-1.1099512577,
0.1463252753,
-0.2630459964,
-1.1288677454,
0.0762390867,
0.005840702,
-0.1854980886,
0.6935853362,
-0.6806395054,
0.4724330306,
-0.588370502,
-0.1685116738,
-0.0521179959,
-0.5333323479,
0.7593490481,
-0.184471786,
0.4475551844,
0.1801884174,
0.1928388327,
0.5891541243,
-0.5117256045,
1.1720057726,
-0.1624450684,
-0.2872443497,
0.1189233735,
0.3454710245,
0.7837696075,
-0.157759577,
0.1585073918,
-0.0738679767,
-0.0725367293,
-0.3555987775,
-0.6989862323,
0.7450624704,
-0.9579321742,
-1.0669550896,
-0.2892993391,
-0.3684250414,
-0.2496915162,
-0.0664991364,
0.4411916733,
0.2189326733,
-0.2809465528,
0.0374075808,
0.7936355472,
-0.2888996601,
0.3037966788,
0.3357479572,
-0.5807232261,
-0.12872307,
1.0466550589,
0.0078517264,
0.6286271214,
0.1039244235,
-0.1019067839,
-0.0264276844,
-0.7970702052,
-0.1807106584,
0.0934242979,
-0.6977275014,
-0.0335490033,
-0.288236022,
-0.2125035673,
-0.4412002563,
-0.2070793062,
-0.1578892618,
-0.4028284848,
-0.3285936117,
-0.1075887382,
0.2062710226,
1.166462183,
-0.1301293373,
0.6676728725,
-0.5078290701,
0.3016203046,
0.4322340786,
-0.0740975142,
-0.1370743364,
-0.3762022257,
-0.0927836895,
-0.0512948185,
-0.3429732919,
-0.9355695248,
0.2819507718,
-0.1716326326,
0.460857302,
0.5428121686,
-0.0639519319,
0.2948367596,
-0.4238063097,
0.7974414825,
0.5065081716,
-0.6749742627,
0.6623950601,
-0.285823524,
-0.1330472082,
0.1614154279,
0.3439166546,
-0.4434338212,
-0.7665482163,
-0.8512076139,
-0.8232928514,
0.4353251755,
-0.1033566892,
0.3559813797,
0.0231303871,
0.415375948,
-0.0958921984,
0.1386087686,
-0.8101821542,
-0.5213423967,
-0.1597144753,
0.1653349996,
-0.0863104835,
-0.178339377,
-0.6808766127,
0.0769714117,
0.5529455543,
0.316636771,
-0.0323079675,
-0.0638849437,
-0.4091390669,
0.1270256937,
0.4821159542,
0.6223468781,
0.1648970097,
0.059898518,
0.4852310121,
0.0425461605,
-0.4698855877,
0.2962513268,
0.0531333461,
-0.1550946385,
-0.4483453035,
0.4720095992,
0.6503078938,
-0.0593208708,
-0.7089246511,
0.4915347397,
-0.2200502157,
-0.1568547338,
-0.3097422123,
0.4185606241,
-0.0675781667,
0.4222866595,
0.1807285547,
0.1043934375,
-0.1568242908,
-0.7459178567,
0.1903708577,
0.8412150145,
-0.5052293539,
-0.3449630439,
0.6355769634,
-0.2352281362,
-0.2788227201,
0.2289312482,
-0.040726047,
-0.6848375201,
0.6099556684,
0.5584511757,
0.5663124919,
-0.1806230843,
0.0291572008,
-0.3485407233,
0.7352856398,
0.1485492587,
-0.2429530323,
0.124781847,
-0.8461226821,
-0.1556438655,
-0.2623236775,
-0.5092355013,
0.6026465297,
-0.6989338398,
0.0846945047,
-1.0480701923,
-0.0921768621,
0.1445458978,
-0.1447326988,
-0.2576925457,
0.1901250631,
0.4838268161,
0.7632844448,
-0.5930601954,
0.8126474023,
0.6294057965,
-0.3339085579,
-0.6209497452,
-0.1751831323,
0.4584036767,
-1.0700653791,
0.875025332,
-0.1263221651,
-0.2115729749,
-0.2893245816,
-0.9151771665,
-0.6406302452,
0.6553130746,
0.5262444019,
-0.5411450267,
-0.2083074898,
0.3648194075,
0.2123824805,
-0.2411444336,
-0.1977870017,
0.8934640884,
0.4513432086,
-0.1010567248,
-0.4702575207,
0.2091519982,
-0.1907191277,
-0.2233903557,
0.1820697933,
-0.5634737015,
1.0206661224,
-0.3043943048,
-0.1357076913,
-0.0167807508,
0.4311652482,
0.1821787655,
-0.0639430285,
0.4804853499,
0.4568886459,
0.7429615855,
-0.1612522304,
1.1647568941,
-0.163554728,
0.0095527684,
1.087880969,
-0.0490738638,
0.4033771753,
0.6398886442,
-0.0697846487,
0.1930717528,
0.5452379584,
-0.3494877517,
0.5438654423,
0.7305644155,
-0.172708258,
-0.024826793,
0.1388363093,
-0.166216433,
0.4043343961,
0.7006860971,
-0.2611312866,
-0.2785054147,
0.3603273332,
0.6497374177,
0.2075519711,
-0.3640976846,
0.6486617923,
0.2189508229,
-0.5758510232,
0.6705932617,
0.1960859746,
0.8256362677,
-0.6924914122,
0.2336720526,
0.0852768719,
0.1069720984,
-0.325527817,
-0.6239484549,
0.2515820861,
0.2825003564,
-0.0759812668,
-0.0828890353,
0.8239101171,
-0.0307963435,
-0.021086853,
0.6234307289,
0.3032157421,
-0.0656051263,
-0.0972243175,
-0.7194639444,
0.1550505161,
0.0277245417,
-0.5046061277,
0.6956395507,
0.2070655078,
-0.0210914519,
0.8625658154,
0.7627043724,
0.5665922165,
0.3122395873,
0.1423854381,
1.0294917822,
-0.6522423625,
-0.149981916,
-1.223336339,
0.0416003838,
-0.0852424502,
0.008119408,
0.8138858676,
0.3350604773,
0.6927741766,
0.2940019369,
1.046432972,
0.0814421847,
0.2198640704,
-0.8405950665,
0.7535683513,
-0.2733695805,
0.9029474258,
-0.1436660737,
-0.2767304778,
-0.3627869189,
0.1196579412,
-0.649682045,
-0.3020379543,
0.5237717628,
0.7204045057,
0.3304853141,
0.1512539238,
0.3846830428,
0.4871364534,
0.7145586014,
0.5430278778,
1.3960496187,
-0.1755538583,
0.6732153296,
0.081985265,
-0.1668683887,
-0.1295285821,
-0.5773557425,
-1.1032321453,
-0.2386341691,
-0.047016155,
-0.6399021149,
0.2537033856,
0.5767969489,
0.2285459042,
-0.658223629,
-0.125321731,
-0.0073006251,
0.3502789438,
0.2470359206,
-0.1795610189,
0.2686963677,
-0.3801767528,
-0.4733547866,
0.5553501248,
0.0807260498,
0.2543722391,
-0.6759321094,
0.007920078,
-0.1922791004,
0.2114678621,
0.3858968318,
0.4279838204,
-0.5907936692,
-0.3211024106,
-0.2205876857,
-0.24642618,
-0.1805477738,
0.9663822055,
-0.3584733903,
0.0072428021,
-0.1123631597,
0.6798789501,
0.1908611655,
-0.2710334659,
0.5540472865,
-0.874445498,
0.1323907077,
0.0586468987,
0.4362437427,
0.1175972223,
-0.5544547439,
0.212375626,
0.1789709926,
-0.3174448013,
-0.9798984528,
0.4978450537,
-0.4613106847,
-0.8396582603,
1.1220923662,
-0.3093398511,
-0.5355864763,
-0.1287078857,
-0.1051250696,
0.0434963666,
-0.0188574158,
0.771756351,
0.9408374429,
-0.1538415849,
0.3760765791,
-0.6785877943,
0.6291123033,
0.1534935534,
-0.7110862136,
0.3099009991,
0.3468311727,
0.3078151345,
0.144639954,
0.2135636955,
-0.4778544605,
0.0670231506,
-0.136127919,
-0.3394220173,
-0.2111124694,
-0.2422368228,
-0.5732359886,
0.4748237431,
0.1969073564,
-0.0797254145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14052v1
|
On Leveraging Encoder-only Pre-trained Language Models for Effective Keyphrase Generation
| 2024-02-21T18:57:54 | 2024-02-21T18:57:54 |
Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study addresses the application of encoder-only Pre-trained Language
Models (PLMs) in keyphrase generation (KPG) amidst the broader availability of
domain-tailored encoder-only models compared to encoder-decoder models. We
investigate three core inquiries: (1) the efficacy of encoder-only PLMs in KPG,
(2) optimal architectural decisions for employing encoder-only PLMs in KPG, and
(3) a performance comparison between in-domain encoder-only and encoder-decoder
PLMs across varied resource settings. Our findings, derived from extensive
experimentation in two domains reveal that with encoder-only PLMs, although KPE
with Conditional Random Fields slightly excels in identifying present
keyphrases, the KPG formulation renders a broader spectrum of keyphrase
predictions. Additionally, prefix-LM fine-tuning of encoder-only PLMs emerges
as a strong and data-efficient strategy for KPG, outperforming general-domain
seq2seq PLMs. We also identify a favorable parameter allocation towards model
depth rather than width when employing encoder-decoder architectures
initialized with encoder-only PLMs. The study sheds light on the potential of
utilizing encoder-only PLMs for advancing KPG systems and provides a groundwork
for future KPG methods. Our code and pre-trained checkpoints are released at
https://github.com/uclanlp/DeepKPG.
|
[
-0.1254599541,
-0.3800609112,
0.7388674021,
0.0351073593,
-0.6386086941,
0.1129005998,
-0.1329582036,
-0.0153615437,
-0.185867548,
0.8342337012,
-0.2457999885,
-0.5831307769,
-0.6758472323,
0.1760442555,
-0.186723128,
0.7403325438,
0.0097434623,
0.2322005332,
-0.2827389836,
0.1822774857,
-0.1810193211,
-0.7944313288,
-0.3440506458,
-0.3587776721,
0.0970380679,
0.3482398391,
0.7596460581,
0.5481928587,
0.6111587882,
0.0472880118,
-0.1647226959,
0.0192231145,
-0.3542096913,
0.3533846438,
0.1207715943,
-0.2957366109,
-0.2742225528,
-0.1734847575,
0.3659551144,
0.7381316423,
0.2324244678,
-0.0279737227,
0.0734753162,
0.5327715278,
-0.9545482397,
0.0337221101,
-0.8833242059,
0.3225920498,
-0.4313853383,
-0.1989153922,
-0.5079972148,
-0.3988790214,
0.25990659,
-0.4659559727,
0.1383536309,
-0.0195887256,
0.4922783673,
0.0859062299,
-0.4047291279,
-0.5913255215,
-0.4711824656,
0.4988062382,
-0.7732819319,
0.7158768177,
0.3005570769,
0.0996291339,
-0.3041857183,
-1.0156745911,
-0.5330860019,
-0.3692144156,
-0.0546683073,
0.223478362,
0.3562707901,
0.5102798343,
0.1403681934,
0.4465107322,
-0.8060469031,
0.0572474748,
-0.4434902966,
-0.1460553408,
0.3405244946,
-0.080176957,
0.0925088897,
-0.2630133033,
-0.0774248019,
-0.2350640595,
-1.055075407,
0.2413858771,
0.0783119798,
0.1972464472,
-0.0035569388,
0.5081179738,
0.0166350231,
0.4732764363,
-0.0671847537,
-0.2313421667,
0.2346514016,
-0.3291123807,
-0.1711694002,
0.1839965433,
0.8206881881,
0.1217233241,
0.2476413697,
-0.5389898419,
-0.1483233124,
0.268592149,
0.312300235,
-1.1507892609,
-0.5557165742,
0.2765548527,
-0.6537332535,
-0.3461718857,
-0.0220786575,
-0.8951796293,
-0.2102289796,
0.2643034756,
0.5412366986,
-0.3823858798,
-0.0633855239,
0.4318895042,
-0.4320156872,
0.3284420371,
-0.2749630809,
-0.6265261769,
0.2385256439,
0.6905046701,
0.7964729071,
-0.0593230166,
-0.3568593264,
-0.244808346,
-0.0202591699,
-0.4715126157,
0.3054994345,
-0.8891052008,
-0.8330911398,
0.2797342241,
-0.1443759054,
-0.2627957165,
-0.4970798492,
1.0462619066,
-0.9378744364,
-0.2476502657,
-0.2350905687,
-0.8881773353,
0.1816118956,
-0.2306117862,
-0.5283566713,
0.4444094002,
-0.1305443496,
-0.3530783057,
0.5013019443,
-0.875230968,
-0.705064714,
0.1807079315,
-0.1827154607,
-0.635628283,
0.3916236162,
0.2289024144,
0.4047958553,
-0.0440960564,
0.0984111577,
-0.341997087,
-0.3006885648,
0.3687011003,
-0.1366402358,
0.5073514581,
0.5879570842,
-0.2024212331,
-0.3158924878,
-0.5041418076,
0.395609349,
0.352845192,
-0.1752782762,
-0.1800337583,
0.0425364114,
-0.2820328474,
0.1835485846,
0.3244273663,
-0.6648484468,
0.1628824919,
-0.5131698847,
0.5721162558,
0.3688409626,
0.2044597566,
0.8431526423,
-0.1298807561,
0.6937361956,
-0.2165202647,
0.2870592177,
-0.4676397741,
-0.3983899355,
-0.278596729,
-0.3474799991,
0.5220361948,
0.2621549368,
-0.6612299681,
0.230486244,
-0.2913306355,
-0.313691318,
-0.7579134703,
0.0148941986,
0.5591074228,
0.3681366742,
0.2666312456,
-0.4610593319,
-0.4697733819,
-0.551418066,
-0.3962129354,
-0.0195079893,
0.1041439623,
0.2846217752,
0.6147245169,
0.089205265,
0.7386717796,
-0.5264548063,
-0.077953808,
-0.440815419,
-0.0781270713,
0.2543304861,
0.3329661191,
0.3768621683,
-0.7984747291,
-0.8191677928,
-0.3375653028,
-0.6119942069,
-0.2751608789,
-0.030592585,
-0.0422792919,
-0.2967000902,
0.3842912912,
-1.0715939999,
0.1268944442,
0.3614185452,
0.0446685739,
0.4031131268,
-0.4448830187,
0.0179910436,
-0.7175073624,
0.2761596441,
-0.5013744235,
0.1788168848,
-1.1021388769,
0.4808791578,
0.3235923648,
-0.5583848953,
-0.3240550458,
0.3899720609,
-0.4217176139,
-0.0652600825,
-0.4251677692,
-0.1448377818,
0.2202724367,
0.4672947228,
0.3818722665,
0.7648646832,
0.5059931874,
-0.6211402416,
-0.2272112072,
0.4425055683,
-0.4459187686,
-0.061213173,
-0.7164412141,
0.4481346607,
-0.2654568255,
0.241363734,
-0.6559624672,
-0.0600338168,
0.3070945442,
-0.6021496654,
0.2398960441,
-0.2367303967,
-0.4684749842,
-0.4569701552,
-0.5091832876,
0.3524697423,
0.9665858746,
-0.4721650183,
0.2608607113,
0.3341054916,
-0.212810725,
-0.1512124687,
-0.392023176,
-0.054103028,
-0.0610248297,
-0.527348578,
0.5736585259,
-0.0330140479,
0.2462968379,
-0.1962779462,
-0.287090987,
-0.2126582712,
0.2760366797,
0.2943950593,
-0.0960598737,
-0.1476750076,
-0.1272174418,
0.1345571876,
-0.0117445635,
0.0480481386,
-0.5152695179,
0.6580244303,
0.2833945453,
-0.4142268598,
-0.1407205313,
0.4750883579,
0.7891597152,
-0.6557999253,
0.6850376725,
0.1225461438,
0.0317175165,
-0.1917444319,
-0.1279059649,
-0.2368983328,
-0.4991331995,
0.3604519367,
-0.5841790438,
-0.8932560682,
0.2886621058,
-0.3128996789,
0.1235907972,
-0.0293803681,
0.4326631129,
0.0110832583,
1.1049140692,
0.4751339853,
-0.182285428,
0.1693141758,
-0.207954973,
0.702745378,
-0.7679812908,
-0.1900655776,
-0.4640155733,
-0.0780401379,
-0.4508526623,
-0.2332718074,
0.5792826414,
0.4056509137,
-0.2145638615,
0.0704749972,
-0.4508172572,
0.5021050572,
0.6472792625,
-0.0050515262,
0.0155246248,
0.1083502024,
-0.1500351727,
-0.2425610423,
-0.9203621745,
-0.5056321621,
1.6359308958,
0.1933347136,
0.5738571882,
-0.2943789661,
0.8687155247,
0.157009095,
-0.1786334217,
-0.4203028083,
0.4545793831,
-0.3307475746,
-0.5077518225,
-0.0746793002,
-0.1801059395,
-1.074339509,
0.4333816469,
0.0660020635,
-0.1100959405,
-0.0027512836,
0.0886273608,
-0.7284677029,
0.0701864436,
-0.4646139145,
1.2535301447,
-0.5419396758,
0.1968969554,
0.100473322,
-0.7425270677,
0.096615009,
-0.3288940191,
0.0505718663,
0.3329441249,
-0.0186867677,
0.5109315515,
-0.4498221576,
0.3534371257,
-0.3491644859,
0.1516540796,
0.3701992631,
-0.104818128,
0.6917130351,
-0.1688103974,
0.0435901918,
0.0517700948,
-0.2335396111,
-0.0422762036,
-0.3853706121,
0.4350418448,
-0.7858490348,
-0.4270234704,
0.0572749823,
-0.2364174426,
-0.2345295846,
0.2347435206,
0.5753494501,
0.3102004826,
0.0382401682,
0.5055221319,
1.0142529011,
-0.2698085606,
0.231863156,
0.6114644408,
-0.0956956744,
-0.4250600636,
0.954217732,
-0.0022193491,
0.3809363842,
0.6344642043,
0.13358441,
-0.2587226927,
-0.9287948012,
-0.2073740959,
0.083832033,
-0.703206718,
-0.1574302465,
-0.8642160892,
-0.4482483566,
-0.7297551632,
-0.3334518969,
-0.2990410328,
-0.0940751582,
-0.1351209581,
-0.082220912,
0.140811637,
0.0375331491,
-0.0058992351,
0.6982979774,
-0.9577431083,
0.4954321086,
0.2660709918,
0.0655991361,
-0.0841488466,
-0.5749644041,
-0.149512887,
0.1884908974,
-0.3068614602,
-1.0779464245,
0.4900696278,
0.5675788522,
0.51916641,
0.2650774717,
0.1705623567,
0.381667316,
-0.5798227191,
0.866189301,
-0.2679142654,
-0.7179290056,
0.4568127096,
-0.0945953876,
0.557639122,
0.746308744,
0.485966295,
-0.3621666431,
-0.3890067637,
-0.4439960718,
-0.7811614871,
0.6573443413,
0.3972848058,
0.236879006,
-0.063665241,
0.5043747425,
0.2593744099,
0.4835255742,
-0.6815075874,
-0.2307021022,
-0.385835588,
-0.3331477642,
0.0260031689,
-0.4188464284,
0.3469669521,
0.1718824059,
0.6034190655,
0.1077315137,
0.2002235055,
0.1044771969,
-0.4340643883,
0.0811784789,
0.2991481125,
0.3593286276,
0.3455133736,
-0.174058795,
0.0634374171,
-0.0601020865,
-0.6847615838,
0.117822811,
0.0431593806,
-0.5177958012,
0.2394186407,
0.1496936381,
0.8588779569,
0.1597505361,
-0.782556057,
0.7495340705,
0.210700646,
-0.3303658068,
-0.0378600061,
-0.1979590207,
-0.0509963818,
0.2171911895,
0.413036406,
-0.3094782531,
0.0441184454,
-0.2506287098,
0.1102276146,
0.6726754308,
0.1827208847,
-0.4316931069,
0.6954694986,
0.1743848175,
-0.260309428,
0.5759436488,
-0.2708443105,
-0.8924100399,
0.4835855365,
0.5224758983,
1.0619186163,
-0.1692041457,
0.1371771246,
-0.0927986652,
0.3866918087,
-0.0728891343,
0.404060781,
-0.5028663874,
-0.7510839701,
-0.120601505,
-0.7930747271,
-0.2370941043,
0.5880458355,
-0.3832014799,
-0.0878616646,
-0.4290611744,
-0.2442427874,
-0.3949883282,
-0.0442021266,
-0.6085696816,
0.0828040317,
0.30027771,
0.7195837498,
-0.7562368512,
0.7984067798,
0.5791982412,
-0.2780340314,
-0.5031772852,
0.085741207,
-0.5577743649,
-0.8932240009,
0.6520017385,
0.0569203012,
0.1415199935,
0.0044001164,
-0.371394366,
-0.7701212764,
1.0680587292,
0.2508615851,
-0.3935394883,
-0.2559627295,
0.631349206,
0.4257077277,
-0.2548390329,
-0.2583041489,
0.5661084652,
0.1348729283,
-0.1071308628,
-0.8432802558,
-0.2406627834,
-0.0646203011,
0.1987894624,
0.3950448632,
-0.3773587048,
0.7347179651,
0.1290970594,
-0.256005764,
0.2692426443,
0.5206716061,
0.4888377786,
0.0658111274,
0.052212175,
0.6287047267,
0.4176105559,
0.3438555002,
1.011220932,
-0.9424445033,
-0.0440965481,
0.9732894897,
-0.5210347176,
0.6629871726,
0.417378366,
-0.035244111,
-0.0675135106,
0.402089417,
0.1448479891,
1.3339170218,
0.0572853014,
-0.4157110453,
-0.279723227,
0.0373871215,
-0.5426103473,
0.2926624119,
0.168800056,
-0.8036211729,
-0.2869489789,
0.1654508859,
-0.0117825624,
-0.1683947891,
-0.4268091023,
0.7231934667,
0.4349235892,
-0.6783047915,
0.2901548445,
0.1731839627,
0.5685362816,
-0.9774643183,
0.1695777625,
-0.1739841849,
0.2661206722,
0.1347428113,
-0.5070557594,
-0.0631284192,
0.0466187783,
-0.120644778,
-0.5157415867,
1.1839557886,
-0.3863495886,
-0.2893188894,
0.0396978706,
0.5188960433,
0.1311583519,
-0.3603126407,
-0.4532636404,
0.1088194102,
-0.1669540703,
-0.1268360466,
0.5875681639,
0.3091837466,
0.4052172303,
0.2883467674,
0.6399445534,
0.2229253799,
0.3676909506,
0.0358961001,
0.5614541769,
-0.3495136499,
-0.4878544211,
-0.9830240011,
0.2018688172,
0.053507451,
-0.2649862766,
0.9174722433,
0.5563191772,
0.8707796335,
-0.3785877526,
1.018892765,
0.2374060452,
0.2211650461,
-0.6221820712,
0.6997532845,
-0.3027370274,
-0.1498611271,
-0.1137232855,
-0.7176499963,
-0.0283343494,
0.5450212955,
-0.2235810459,
-0.053927172,
0.4905070662,
0.9232984781,
0.2754884958,
0.1842750013,
0.3504402936,
-0.1669042557,
0.2147461176,
0.6892781854,
0.7319821119,
-0.4022233486,
0.5200169086,
-0.2861115038,
0.0513831787,
-0.2525756359,
-0.5706780553,
-0.842990756,
-0.3446608186,
-0.0472162068,
0.047193557,
0.3041647077,
0.8545260429,
0.4256073534,
-0.6037604809,
-0.1094438583,
-0.274001509,
-0.0661813095,
0.1095215604,
-0.1459566951,
0.2152946293,
-0.5165416598,
-0.2731851339,
0.5822138786,
0.3336908817,
-0.0295130536,
0.1261971146,
-0.3577471972,
0.3616829216,
0.123090446,
0.5529874563,
0.3659913242,
-0.4835867286,
0.0937676653,
0.3755127192,
-0.1870147586,
-0.0381514207,
1.1172161102,
-0.5185364485,
0.4239045978,
0.5470342636,
0.9058561325,
0.3268839717,
-0.2269228995,
0.6622202992,
-0.5206559896,
-0.1185711846,
0.482537508,
0.2732229829,
0.0889247432,
-0.0901552215,
0.1207391322,
0.109877944,
-0.5743616819,
-0.8738716841,
0.286909312,
-0.332780689,
-0.3932311237,
0.98962152,
-0.2182929367,
-0.2251219302,
-0.0515465215,
0.0531193353,
0.0776806399,
-0.1691728234,
0.5165441632,
0.4989384115,
0.0850735083,
-0.1590572745,
-0.3508048654,
0.7976561189,
0.4663926661,
-0.2838001549,
-0.0718043298,
0.1524932086,
0.1001105756,
-0.1004616544,
0.9588024616,
-0.2871444523,
0.4131872058,
0.0895711258,
-0.0241462961,
-0.2280122638,
-0.3896255791,
-0.4592418373,
0.5433254838,
0.3004830778,
-0.3244956732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14016v1
|
Is LLM-as-a-Judge Robust? Investigating Universal Adversarial Attacks on Zero-shot LLM Assessment
| 2024-02-21T18:55:20 | 2024-02-21T18:55:20 |
Vyas Raina, Adian Liusie, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful zero-shot assessors and are
increasingly used in real-world situations such as for written exams or
benchmarking systems. Despite this, no existing work has analyzed the
vulnerability of judge-LLMs against adversaries attempting to manipulate
outputs. This work presents the first study on the adversarial robustness of
assessment LLMs, where we search for short universal phrases that when appended
to texts can deceive LLMs to provide high assessment scores. Experiments on
SummEval and TopicalChat demonstrate that both LLM-scoring and pairwise
LLM-comparative assessment are vulnerable to simple concatenation attacks,
where in particular LLM-scoring is very susceptible and can yield maximum
assessment scores irrespective of the input text quality. Interestingly, such
attacks are transferable and phrases learned on smaller open-source LLMs can be
applied to larger closed-source models, such as GPT3.5. This highlights the
pervasive nature of the adversarial vulnerabilities across different judge-LLM
sizes, families and methods. Our findings raise significant concerns on the
reliability of LLMs-as-a-judge methods, and underscore the importance of
addressing vulnerabilities in LLM assessment methods before deployment in
high-stakes real-world scenarios.
|
[
-0.2769943178,
-0.9791430235,
0.5573655963,
0.014977132,
-0.2469910234,
-0.0135726109,
-0.2797865868,
-0.5320625305,
-0.1150389016,
0.4526845813,
-0.0751658976,
-0.4657110572,
-0.9199490547,
-0.0215541683,
-0.6569211483,
1.0504847765,
0.1114364862,
0.1885261983,
-0.2281653881,
-0.35280931,
-0.2592626512,
-0.7869834304,
-0.6112893224,
-0.2523008883,
0.6039028168,
0.0358323716,
0.8993877769,
0.1922647208,
0.6952621341,
0.2929471135,
-0.1608172506,
-0.1443830431,
-0.2954383492,
0.3255270123,
-0.2320091277,
-0.5521492958,
-0.4825148582,
0.2839997411,
0.438798368,
0.5056189299,
0.0071970187,
0.1983320713,
0.1768168658,
0.4683657289,
-0.9283402562,
-0.2243819088,
-1.0205538273,
0.136147052,
-0.2152140737,
-0.0259960592,
-0.5698586106,
-0.3802964389,
-0.0680403337,
-0.2141756266,
-0.0301918965,
-0.19430466,
0.7301412821,
0.4476145506,
-0.6352057457,
-0.3558316529,
-0.54665488,
0.6817501187,
-0.5588665605,
-0.1415468603,
0.1410823315,
0.4379304945,
-0.3319204748,
-0.5592147708,
-0.4424986839,
-0.6799808145,
0.0198467895,
0.2373736799,
-0.4404868186,
0.0996639282,
0.1306333691,
0.269087851,
-0.6221556067,
0.5603452325,
0.1607072502,
-0.2868593931,
0.6008736491,
0.1702620387,
0.1122229025,
-0.1375569254,
-0.641299963,
-0.1117933691,
-0.8075773716,
-0.0908612758,
0.4761477709,
0.2700629234,
0.0410830677,
0.5729855895,
0.0579218045,
0.6213476658,
-0.1420779824,
0.1716356277,
-0.4075362086,
-0.2098115236,
-0.397741735,
-0.101270698,
1.2631793022,
0.4588904977,
0.3697740138,
-0.2035400867,
-0.2450019121,
0.2182860523,
0.534753561,
-0.6657156944,
-0.0838488042,
0.0237762071,
-0.0021968384,
-0.9065966606,
0.208435744,
-0.8160156012,
-0.7201895118,
0.3653296828,
0.7361363173,
-0.0836010575,
0.3249247968,
-0.0677774847,
0.25662902,
0.250140965,
0.3362582922,
-0.568516314,
0.3613126576,
0.6211816072,
0.5213597417,
-0.1275267303,
-0.3544245064,
-0.9418955445,
-0.2880269885,
-0.3746192455,
0.581286788,
-0.1570077389,
-0.539134264,
0.1020143926,
-0.2130300254,
0.024854131,
-0.4036093056,
0.8425475359,
-0.6885950565,
0.2194762081,
0.1980315596,
-0.4128679335,
0.0502232797,
0.8053119779,
-0.4866214991,
0.7860733271,
0.0010843348,
-0.7761414051,
0.2591746747,
-0.2608548105,
-0.3958346546,
-0.1107911617,
-0.3052269816,
-0.5263078809,
0.1144814566,
0.2669457495,
0.5288037062,
-0.3102304041,
0.1210127398,
-0.6863310933,
-0.5233678818,
0.6101231575,
-1.1124634743,
0.6466404796,
0.0512445644,
-0.488275677,
0.1309132427,
-0.7741342783,
0.0406556949,
0.3517149389,
-0.2883654237,
-0.1778480411,
-0.0906871036,
-0.1298784316,
-0.0812559947,
0.239051342,
-0.4651268125,
0.3338728547,
-0.3944160342,
0.1346873641,
0.9651730657,
0.130099535,
0.1331449151,
-0.2639473379,
0.7084169388,
-0.4371887445,
0.2593035102,
-0.0278692376,
-0.2787618935,
-0.4505501688,
-0.0561461225,
0.6761357784,
0.741402626,
-0.5739608407,
0.4727241397,
-0.2370589226,
-0.6485620141,
-0.3188718259,
0.1926950812,
0.6252250671,
0.2293133885,
0.084750168,
-0.2841249406,
-0.0173362158,
-0.5749177933,
-0.4814379215,
-0.2870817184,
-0.0406452976,
0.1279147863,
0.5939315557,
-0.0879464373,
0.3865253031,
-0.43074283,
-0.1307748854,
-0.1216740385,
-0.0951842889,
0.1091350392,
0.1030473411,
0.722132206,
-0.5795314908,
-0.3860209882,
-0.0399183296,
-0.8213194013,
-0.0667130128,
-0.1827989817,
0.0798211992,
-0.0583703369,
0.3900244236,
-0.5048493743,
0.3717901409,
0.5758644938,
-0.4725885093,
0.8890317082,
-0.2012693286,
0.0010930715,
-0.778344214,
-0.1565421969,
-0.0700337514,
-0.4220554829,
-0.4891366661,
0.7870383859,
0.0319276378,
0.1743192822,
-0.5503512025,
0.6122947931,
-0.1084057093,
0.0487896428,
-0.4024935961,
0.3519943953,
0.0936618149,
0.2589028776,
-0.6967306137,
0.5967715383,
0.6602090597,
-0.4349716902,
0.5926193595,
-0.0608509853,
-0.2879261076,
0.7736547589,
-0.4758704901,
0.3358539343,
0.3442987204,
0.2244360596,
-0.7643771172,
-0.0682452917,
0.1841202676,
-0.7112987638,
0.6402672529,
-0.1463333517,
-0.6754999757,
-0.1247194335,
-0.7513014078,
0.0325824134,
0.0735719278,
-0.7332982421,
0.2841913104,
0.1167763844,
-0.012966603,
-0.7071243525,
-0.7839905024,
0.3746457398,
-0.3139955401,
-0.5343052149,
-0.0326843373,
-0.1113340929,
-0.4912168086,
-0.1680850685,
-0.1984136999,
0.1926858276,
0.9070388079,
0.2707503736,
0.4007972777,
-0.1758671552,
-0.2969340086,
-0.4106329978,
-0.0053111352,
0.3006360233,
0.017977519,
0.2461268008,
-0.2082679272,
-0.8927327394,
-0.216738835,
0.2642716169,
0.9326756001,
0.0740367621,
0.4675477445,
0.4971434176,
-0.2599768043,
-0.2441727668,
-0.3375017643,
0.1592203379,
-0.4622901976,
0.4247553647,
-0.3061698675,
-1.0011954308,
0.4609165192,
0.0706034526,
-0.0189542007,
0.505341053,
0.5973915458,
-0.0990671143,
0.9381622672,
0.2844690084,
-0.4671927989,
0.1512155831,
-0.1295239329,
0.0095877033,
-0.7356077433,
0.0585544258,
-0.5866878033,
-0.2687351108,
-0.7262704372,
-0.1265542805,
0.3482084572,
0.1130223796,
-0.4144033194,
-0.0172335468,
-0.3946176767,
0.4917204678,
0.5711404085,
-0.0986687168,
0.2902064621,
-0.2629065812,
-0.4002918303,
0.130593583,
-0.2219630629,
-0.583709538,
1.505633831,
0.3204768896,
0.9188605547,
0.2464546412,
0.677728951,
0.4523323476,
0.5176546574,
-0.8678966165,
0.5816543102,
-0.4149011672,
-0.3444434404,
-0.0565647036,
-0.4294929504,
-0.7559968233,
0.5521209836,
-0.2764263451,
-0.8392195702,
-0.1579001248,
-0.1269699186,
-0.4310576618,
0.5317938924,
-0.551923275,
0.797809422,
-0.671779573,
-0.3410452008,
0.260209173,
-0.6485372186,
0.3446289301,
-0.2525042295,
0.265914768,
0.0954321325,
0.0699217021,
0.3526881039,
-0.3129943013,
0.8219338059,
-0.0924827829,
-0.1257033199,
0.1398646235,
0.4370798469,
0.6196181774,
0.132974416,
-0.1383129358,
0.0535841398,
-0.1702890992,
-0.4212301075,
-0.8270738721,
1.0124400854,
-0.7971110344,
-0.8360881209,
-0.7722492814,
-0.2123117596,
-0.4451110363,
0.0185035914,
0.2009408474,
0.2905575633,
-0.4740164578,
0.2248283178,
0.3542118371,
0.0100908931,
0.2243852615,
0.6569452286,
-0.1126922518,
-0.512160778,
0.9178318977,
-0.0998018235,
0.4632749856,
0.2924329937,
0.2455522865,
-0.0327646583,
-0.8636032343,
-0.576051712,
-0.2200959921,
-0.6437548995,
-0.334656179,
-0.0287155099,
-0.2446053326,
-0.2389372289,
-0.2836777568,
-0.2704054713,
-0.4619591832,
-0.2049112618,
-0.2810820937,
0.0949813426,
0.7842612863,
0.1715456247,
0.2432635278,
-0.6377529502,
0.215237692,
0.4925678074,
0.206859827,
-0.2437784225,
-0.6328970194,
0.0263020769,
-0.1386184096,
-0.5890409946,
-0.8113630414,
0.0565193146,
0.0105203111,
0.5165345669,
0.4095051289,
-0.0138225555,
0.2616981566,
-0.3382723331,
1.0605158806,
0.1301625967,
-0.5503599644,
0.3944123983,
-0.2692591846,
0.2409044951,
0.6707464457,
0.0397632085,
-0.2044155151,
-0.8066331148,
-0.4790762961,
-0.7754874229,
0.5699105263,
0.0900648162,
0.3071693778,
0.1278408468,
0.4696042836,
0.060456261,
0.0770231932,
-0.9322868586,
-0.3616625071,
-0.0726671666,
-0.0655387267,
-0.1450113058,
-0.2406922877,
-0.2114347219,
0.0016963007,
0.485927552,
-0.1557309926,
-0.1729558706,
0.1286618859,
-0.1049583405,
0.1770218909,
0.6430727243,
0.4301650822,
0.0089079561,
-0.2381372303,
0.4074947834,
0.293943435,
-0.5135820508,
0.2757599354,
0.2806473672,
-0.3701130748,
-0.3885153532,
0.6034129262,
0.6460296512,
0.4044736922,
-0.6109769344,
0.8552350402,
-0.4078377187,
-0.3808713257,
-0.2955768406,
0.0763236806,
-0.2121894509,
0.2479986101,
0.1464745253,
0.2615219951,
-0.1056356132,
-0.6047615409,
0.1163406894,
0.6798049212,
-0.6514683962,
-0.215435043,
0.8187829256,
-0.1057232767,
-0.0680069104,
0.2972102761,
-0.3221769035,
-0.7110610008,
0.5087566972,
0.3421102762,
1.0050536394,
-0.1137537882,
0.0044045355,
-0.1896669418,
0.5684010386,
0.0343777202,
-0.0076066102,
-0.0317196064,
-0.6288683414,
-0.1000839919,
-0.6663098335,
-0.8624340296,
0.1964997798,
-0.6682113409,
0.0760161057,
-0.6649978757,
-0.2075442374,
-0.2003155649,
0.1625973135,
-0.4231283963,
0.2407856733,
0.4204890132,
0.708504796,
-0.683201611,
0.6020520926,
0.7172595263,
-0.1355833709,
-0.5485163331,
0.2467167675,
0.3248378336,
-0.7544357777,
0.2731028795,
0.0407961421,
-0.2041607052,
-0.5235104561,
-0.5372900367,
-0.3877292275,
0.9280450344,
0.7640833259,
-0.2842732072,
0.0422146805,
0.1146492437,
0.6659956574,
-0.0528818183,
0.4232031107,
0.5342577696,
0.4148284793,
0.009961552,
-0.8864604235,
0.144342497,
-0.3039536178,
-0.3780862987,
0.1271668822,
-0.7596780062,
0.5534886122,
-0.203010425,
0.0148131065,
0.222534582,
0.4502186179,
0.1296943575,
0.3689786196,
0.4074712992,
0.69478935,
0.6624316573,
-0.0996639058,
1.3770158291,
-0.2142236084,
0.303290844,
1.2833518982,
-0.3418332636,
0.890129447,
0.257673353,
-0.2938491404,
0.239051789,
0.3799512088,
-0.3216724694,
0.2192288786,
0.5671641827,
-0.2244745344,
-0.1432860047,
0.1298689693,
0.0335858315,
0.5591591597,
0.2115358859,
-0.1777973771,
-0.2821353972,
-0.0908435583,
0.256077975,
0.3845220804,
-0.2970449328,
0.7043517828,
0.217302084,
-0.504606843,
0.4198105931,
0.1516031474,
0.9243118167,
-0.6728927493,
0.2707646787,
-0.2030062377,
0.3728008866,
-0.031155061,
-0.8600218296,
0.0746863484,
0.3835834265,
0.2002757192,
-0.0035586793,
0.6194639206,
0.0691102594,
-0.5400025845,
0.6506031156,
0.3910249174,
0.0166159365,
-0.3529015779,
-0.5800600052,
-0.1024049744,
-0.1377683878,
-0.485584259,
0.7998788357,
0.2957489491,
-0.1102975234,
0.7201145291,
0.5053730607,
0.4335425496,
0.1804185212,
0.2940682769,
0.7862124443,
-0.5448848605,
-0.005414953,
-1.1476414204,
0.0587606542,
0.1375518441,
-0.2077701688,
0.8302823901,
0.4003481865,
0.8024578094,
0.4112809002,
0.7220422626,
0.314707607,
0.2706904709,
-0.5488826632,
0.9186891317,
-0.6324077845,
0.4425646067,
-0.2065152079,
-0.5358867645,
-0.6236880422,
-0.0040101828,
-0.1441680342,
-0.1450223923,
0.5279099941,
0.5162338018,
0.1959316432,
-0.1291787922,
0.5935740471,
0.3870899677,
0.5805504918,
0.5102449059,
0.8661429882,
-0.4091522992,
0.9813849926,
-0.1409806609,
-0.0889835656,
-0.1651695669,
-0.6155313849,
-0.9062031507,
0.0232820529,
-0.1876654029,
-0.3134559691,
0.0889246762,
0.5356087685,
0.083896406,
-0.8146330714,
0.0158445593,
0.2164596617,
0.2385325432,
0.0077189035,
-0.2703587115,
0.5412259102,
-0.1122711301,
-0.4955157042,
0.636086762,
0.2206041664,
-0.1052005664,
-0.511064291,
0.1201412529,
0.0147878611,
0.0059612263,
0.3633744717,
0.0547839068,
-0.655471921,
-0.6133112907,
-0.1724337935,
-0.3556497395,
-0.0863477886,
0.3927440643,
-0.5789500475,
0.6065431237,
0.1439360529,
0.7061923742,
0.0915100351,
0.0802158564,
0.5065644979,
-0.75797683,
-0.0756055638,
0.3506432176,
0.5718022585,
0.4282412529,
-0.3475988507,
0.3333911896,
0.2217755467,
-0.6169316769,
-0.8953356743,
0.166433841,
-1.027068615,
-0.1418651938,
1.0649344921,
-0.4458096027,
-0.1030831859,
0.2006783634,
-0.0462179109,
-0.1427242458,
-0.0965480506,
0.790361166,
0.8526570797,
0.1719443202,
0.3113420606,
-0.6622011065,
0.0134974699,
0.325245589,
-0.5322128534,
-0.0412457064,
0.0964209214,
0.3086527586,
0.1620423347,
0.3037416041,
-0.3296477795,
0.309117049,
0.0342670046,
-0.1560205817,
-0.1301732063,
-0.0839207396,
-0.7942269444,
0.4995521605,
0.4501636922,
-0.2483991385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14008v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14008v2
|
OlympiadBench: A Challenging Benchmark for Promoting AGI with Olympiad-Level Bilingual Multimodal Scientific Problems
| 2024-02-21T18:49:26 | 2024-06-06T13:19:44 |
Chaoqun He, Renjie Luo, Yuzhuo Bai, Shengding Hu, Zhen Leng Thai, Junhao Shen, Jinyi Hu, Xu Han, Yujie Huang, Yuxiang Zhang, Jie Liu, Lei Qi, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements have seen Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large
Multimodal Models (LMMs) surpassing general human capabilities in various
tasks, approaching the proficiency level of human experts across multiple
domains. With traditional benchmarks becoming less challenging for these
models, new rigorous challenges are essential to gauge their advanced
abilities. In this work, we present OlympiadBench, an Olympiad-level bilingual
multimodal scientific benchmark, featuring 8,476 problems from Olympiad-level
mathematics and physics competitions, including the Chinese college entrance
exam. Each problem is detailed with expert-level annotations for step-by-step
reasoning. Evaluating top-tier models on OlympiadBench, we implement a
comprehensive assessment methodology to accurately evaluate model responses.
Notably, the best-performing model, GPT-4V, attains an average score of 17.97%
on OlympiadBench, with a mere 10.74% in physics, highlighting the benchmark
rigor and the intricacy of physical reasoning. Our analysis orienting GPT-4V
points out prevalent issues with hallucinations, knowledge omissions, and
logical fallacies. We hope that our challenging benchmark can serve as a
valuable resource for helping future AGI research endeavors. The data and
evaluation code are available at \url{https://github.com/OpenBMB/OlympiadBench}
|
[
-0.4467262626,
-0.5557932854,
0.5465787649,
0.5152517557,
0.1269578338,
0.1099816263,
-0.0646838024,
-0.3835858703,
-0.3047135174,
-0.2556635737,
-0.4133153558,
-0.2691083848,
-0.479095161,
0.3212601244,
-0.1911341101,
0.6178092957,
-0.3778969944,
0.2041385323,
-0.6640838981,
-0.0676328465,
-0.300617069,
-0.1937339008,
-0.3984301984,
-0.473864615,
0.2847720087,
0.4116597772,
0.4297981262,
0.4565369487,
0.4961532056,
0.4080317616,
0.0771682784,
0.1998176426,
-0.3908183873,
-0.0612071343,
-0.412679255,
-0.3239850104,
-0.4886011481,
0.387380898,
0.7444037795,
0.662243247,
-0.2299600691,
0.1072886735,
-0.1253674328,
0.3309744298,
-0.6058642864,
0.2514385581,
-0.5580424666,
0.1774030328,
-0.3069577813,
0.0078558056,
-0.2061932534,
-0.0462042764,
-0.2254178375,
-0.7321731448,
0.0407052375,
0.0861963034,
0.8463551998,
-0.0115102157,
-0.7427837253,
0.0458754189,
-0.3211649656,
0.8363153338,
-0.2161280215,
0.6750736833,
0.5043963194,
0.5878161192,
-0.1520127803,
-0.6125086546,
-0.6494706869,
-0.4790766835,
0.5605702996,
0.4951337874,
-0.0484255739,
-0.2033360451,
0.1948249489,
0.212165311,
-0.8290202618,
-0.0853793621,
-0.4525090754,
-0.1885882169,
0.7799301147,
0.3393532932,
0.2365582436,
-0.0957547426,
-0.0834427848,
-0.4205295444,
-0.5010368228,
0.1503296345,
0.6413283944,
-0.1641805619,
0.0931303054,
0.7228131294,
-0.4753814042,
0.4439436197,
0.1117074788,
0.1194689125,
0.4834237993,
-0.4596241415,
0.2455948889,
-0.2177398354,
0.7021383047,
0.4658561051,
0.2263675183,
-0.3030858338,
-0.091540277,
0.0385865159,
0.1930360347,
-1.0039060116,
-0.2165042311,
0.1520528197,
-0.1017364264,
0.0926760286,
-0.0002904711,
-0.8361378908,
-0.306640774,
-0.2781154513,
0.4195126593,
-0.4672113359,
-0.077302061,
-0.0204487126,
-0.0872003287,
0.255928278,
0.4351403117,
-0.8515782356,
0.2160027772,
0.9759040475,
0.8867247105,
-0.2060106993,
-0.6536525488,
-0.5747181773,
-0.0272682142,
-0.3259574473,
0.8158141971,
-0.634491384,
-0.5432040691,
-0.5405675173,
-0.0833060145,
-0.361628294,
-0.4485369623,
0.5422599912,
-0.1980586052,
0.0401091613,
-0.1346618682,
-0.3649745882,
-0.0034492326,
0.7303704023,
-0.437453419,
0.9757461548,
0.0480107106,
-0.5744875669,
0.0879376084,
-0.6311647892,
-0.1357604712,
0.1133143902,
-0.3198981881,
-0.1363034099,
0.1471224874,
0.1257404089,
0.0178658925,
-0.4779210687,
0.5744000673,
-0.5974108577,
0.0331248194,
0.2215725332,
-0.5699756145,
0.4741395712,
0.4046933949,
-0.1944978386,
0.0530426279,
-0.9495173693,
0.2978589535,
0.0889039487,
-0.1559573561,
-0.0329497941,
0.0945946276,
-0.1391491741,
0.2654880881,
0.3124341965,
-0.6915243268,
0.3183736801,
-0.1662847698,
0.2442381382,
0.935642004,
-0.3783494532,
0.0614235587,
-0.2107177377,
0.4920014143,
-0.2139533758,
0.2614078522,
-0.0133809512,
-0.8195312023,
-0.3229991496,
-0.2040293217,
0.306095928,
0.7107508183,
-0.8575598598,
-0.0727928951,
-0.412438035,
-0.8079299927,
-0.5524522662,
0.0652739033,
0.3241139054,
0.680685401,
0.4182431996,
-0.3046426177,
-0.1131179109,
-1.0560621023,
-0.3941642046,
-0.0885667503,
-0.1048128679,
0.4978471696,
0.8787087202,
-0.2639867961,
0.7288574576,
-0.2309496254,
-0.0615487061,
0.1699254513,
0.6485480666,
0.1660016775,
0.5399473906,
0.4054449201,
-0.8729477525,
-0.7497205138,
0.4943692088,
-0.7635066509,
-0.4462565184,
0.1477051526,
-0.0642308071,
-0.1744527668,
0.2064318806,
-0.5512188077,
0.3229978085,
0.5950799584,
-0.4966074824,
1.0316305161,
-0.240213722,
0.6126540303,
-0.6642831564,
0.3569076061,
-0.0449214689,
-0.0233174264,
-0.5502117276,
0.3422616422,
0.1818888932,
-0.226308465,
-0.3550725281,
0.8018381596,
-0.3606913984,
0.1280694753,
-0.1781135052,
0.0025885105,
-0.094952248,
0.0111353938,
-0.2276869565,
1.0153776407,
0.5892897844,
-0.068368569,
0.7177605033,
0.057645306,
-0.3604199886,
0.8185697198,
-0.6722979546,
0.0778983831,
-0.0890021697,
-0.0218041111,
-0.7040397525,
-0.4556497037,
0.0342153236,
-0.5374003053,
0.2305998653,
0.269453615,
-0.5624913573,
-0.445938766,
-0.5054895878,
0.6146470308,
0.2344200015,
-0.41583547,
0.9397212267,
0.1045977175,
-0.4211110175,
-0.5777488947,
-0.4639517963,
0.1993458718,
0.0427526385,
-0.9030632377,
0.3502815664,
-0.567878902,
-0.1720454544,
0.1337567717,
-0.2724416554,
-0.2374224067,
0.1919582188,
-0.0047545792,
-0.0006762972,
-0.0777161047,
-0.19092758,
-0.1721748561,
-0.151097104,
0.1974197328,
0.1058010384,
0.2986572087,
-0.5934475064,
-0.738902986,
-0.2803494036,
0.5341148376,
0.4744214118,
-0.3030947149,
0.3836490512,
0.4097918868,
-0.2172748893,
0.1379873455,
-0.5877132416,
0.0610182211,
-0.4832995832,
0.5972685814,
-0.7901113629,
-0.5840428472,
0.6951206326,
-0.1221724674,
-0.2052661777,
0.3270612061,
0.5129120946,
0.321187079,
1.5354126692,
0.2250259817,
0.0026511874,
0.0405105986,
-0.0690394044,
0.0230421014,
-0.8672379851,
-0.3809696734,
-0.52991575,
-0.1773969233,
-0.2311526835,
-0.7239192724,
0.5722098351,
0.0469394661,
-0.3341812491,
-0.042255614,
-0.1724808663,
0.6549482346,
0.5362619162,
-0.1511299461,
0.218042329,
-0.2451685816,
-0.4379612505,
-0.0458201356,
-0.58856529,
-0.1260237843,
1.1331216097,
0.0927011743,
0.6025945544,
0.2124125808,
0.4092949629,
-0.0186967067,
0.4755050242,
-0.4031181633,
0.6685076356,
0.1846603751,
-0.9114546776,
0.0309685413,
-0.7653567791,
-0.9542782903,
0.6041838527,
-0.1958146542,
-1.0043151379,
0.1618393213,
0.0461094975,
-0.0700451359,
0.1159797311,
-0.6679981947,
1.1368185282,
-0.5508639812,
-0.9336832166,
-0.2773368061,
-0.4851713479,
0.391045779,
-0.269867748,
0.5454364419,
-0.139141202,
0.0611494854,
0.3853797019,
-0.267303139,
0.4484669566,
-0.0405761786,
0.2790876627,
0.2168988138,
0.0538070388,
0.4596785605,
0.0778932199,
-0.2606110573,
0.019681247,
-0.0733186379,
-0.4472219348,
-0.4173257053,
0.9704591632,
-1.0120427608,
-0.8442555666,
-0.6828415394,
-0.6946496964,
-0.2997624576,
0.2644351721,
-0.0037522346,
0.1848781705,
-0.2697075009,
0.2383563519,
0.3876823187,
0.0023681861,
0.1591320783,
0.4981739223,
-0.263351351,
-0.5425106883,
1.2468458414,
0.1957284361,
0.0882259607,
-0.1480521709,
0.2924196422,
-0.3309146762,
-0.6477216482,
-0.4873901308,
0.2415024191,
-0.8441081643,
-0.1704803407,
-0.582914412,
-0.1045259088,
-0.5780240297,
-0.0670435056,
-0.5521702766,
-0.2860910296,
-0.0721779764,
-0.0355152823,
-0.1802857667,
0.2402714789,
-0.3889693022,
-0.0278415252,
-0.7507102489,
0.4143148065,
0.5547570586,
0.6194956899,
-0.0230161957,
-0.2726010978,
-0.1278501898,
-0.0506229848,
-0.754434824,
-0.8723723292,
0.3063598275,
0.4166521132,
0.8744302988,
0.5250451565,
-0.2146880776,
0.859726131,
-0.8035404682,
0.6952273846,
0.1333369613,
-1.0634799004,
0.2906249464,
-0.3511878848,
0.3756808937,
0.6550969481,
0.6524353027,
-0.3903239369,
-0.3187360168,
-0.434363246,
-0.879191339,
0.6274092197,
0.2587795556,
-0.1903600842,
-0.0967414752,
0.104884319,
0.13154459,
0.2875127494,
-0.8253489137,
0.2073317766,
-0.5188584924,
-0.2645609081,
-0.1460791528,
0.1333761066,
-0.2355660349,
-0.3805090189,
0.7547077537,
-0.282551229,
-0.0942482352,
0.1689916551,
-0.1822807491,
-0.063557975,
0.2456881255,
0.6215323806,
0.624943018,
-0.1686970741,
0.1585612893,
0.2288726121,
-0.4014511704,
0.0798512846,
0.6342360973,
0.0534552298,
-0.5842392445,
0.3715557456,
0.6612192988,
-0.0769139603,
-0.9936971664,
0.5184580684,
0.0219331104,
-0.2643582821,
-0.0636951774,
-0.0389002934,
0.0251500886,
0.387453407,
0.4789088666,
-0.1577363461,
0.4454882443,
-0.5451917648,
0.0373699442,
0.5886483788,
-0.0326328389,
-0.6636904478,
1.0148094893,
0.2712039948,
-0.0160410367,
0.5552247167,
-0.5055406094,
-0.5419130921,
0.698189497,
0.4675087333,
0.5696098804,
-0.5786845684,
0.1289239377,
0.3954997063,
0.4162959754,
-0.1580521613,
0.3049374521,
-0.0663139373,
-0.4733865857,
-0.5018968582,
-0.4124909341,
-0.5852271914,
-0.1718229353,
-0.3320403993,
0.2302410901,
-0.1812102944,
-0.0697019547,
0.0594546422,
-0.0483595319,
-0.5509043932,
0.0200745873,
0.3864430189,
0.8325642347,
-0.8034296036,
0.4715754986,
0.8970342875,
-0.1093507707,
-0.3160096705,
-0.5355155468,
0.2416484952,
-0.6549965739,
0.7318329215,
0.3495421708,
-0.0208260771,
0.0270295255,
-0.5996637344,
-0.8434438109,
1.0229933262,
0.1077998653,
-0.3102485538,
0.2022728175,
0.3583159447,
0.4940758646,
-0.3061121106,
0.7621531487,
0.3832296431,
0.9722572565,
0.0898908898,
-1.1310176849,
-0.1816903353,
-0.7810237408,
-0.2028716952,
-0.0261705574,
-0.8523645997,
1.1444131136,
-0.03844117,
-0.1468200237,
0.2200169712,
0.5358846188,
0.4788711071,
0.7960207462,
0.3751098514,
0.8625053167,
0.585051477,
-0.2318605334,
1.0633846521,
-0.0986043736,
0.4161605835,
0.7708747387,
-0.6713901758,
0.6131293774,
0.4959764481,
-0.1081760898,
0.2227405161,
0.5163136125,
-0.3388796151,
0.4859111309,
0.3696236014,
-0.1978760511,
-0.4364589155,
-0.060544353,
-0.6059734225,
0.4059822559,
0.2794781029,
0.4868923426,
-0.6226068139,
0.405184269,
-0.1040004268,
0.0435993485,
-0.3635268807,
0.3803158104,
-0.177281037,
-0.6930604577,
0.4453344643,
0.0132739861,
0.3546185195,
-0.6899011731,
-0.0026021982,
-0.2705108821,
0.2790661156,
0.0416639298,
-0.7377497554,
0.0241190139,
0.0795976743,
-0.032112062,
-0.0297277309,
0.4073202312,
-0.3930302858,
-0.5802317858,
0.1804268062,
0.4571537673,
0.2495632172,
-0.1559086591,
-0.7843317986,
0.1479040235,
-0.2330956012,
-0.5567398071,
0.426176399,
0.5956171155,
-0.284349978,
0.9366883636,
0.5457288027,
-0.058580745,
0.2862990201,
-0.2632151544,
0.8966718316,
-0.5800651908,
-0.3098014891,
-0.5583977103,
0.4961375892,
-0.2651087642,
-0.370886445,
0.822881937,
0.8136251569,
0.7977208495,
-0.0648171827,
0.6111600399,
-0.0786628351,
0.1732307971,
-0.07279706,
0.6083312631,
-0.8760018945,
-0.1637490541,
-0.0902431235,
-0.7727878094,
-0.3736529648,
0.481984973,
-0.3915022612,
0.1406443715,
0.7747594714,
0.5113726258,
-0.2297882885,
-0.0819077715,
0.2708725333,
0.3648284078,
0.5788732171,
0.7979898453,
1.0402126312,
-0.1985508949,
0.504853487,
-0.2114644051,
-0.5526185632,
-0.2467193902,
-0.9986082911,
-0.7985486984,
-0.2663488388,
-0.3456235528,
0.0715963542,
0.2031567842,
0.7403856516,
0.5149492621,
-0.6926931143,
-0.3700892925,
0.0375260487,
-0.0343381725,
-0.274608314,
-0.2064962834,
0.2346550524,
-0.196724236,
-1.0120413303,
0.647996664,
0.1407188922,
-0.0166512225,
0.0017980523,
0.0212310143,
-0.3238135576,
0.201091677,
0.4761149883,
0.5055922866,
-0.5207768679,
-0.3306167722,
0.1768993288,
0.0988221467,
-0.0654368773,
0.359931618,
-0.6733654141,
0.8935228586,
0.4772432446,
0.7177610993,
0.4863497019,
0.1046943665,
0.2910358012,
-0.3641832471,
0.1325077415,
0.3362135887,
0.3888310492,
0.2540248334,
0.0908452794,
0.6443650723,
0.4934272468,
-0.8283348083,
-1.0455641747,
0.0648827776,
-0.9562980533,
-0.3236335218,
0.7728150487,
-0.1293909252,
-0.4033930898,
0.1487421542,
-0.0954800323,
-0.1227638945,
-0.21271348,
1.0464289188,
1.1885834932,
-0.2710103095,
-0.0966539383,
-0.771048367,
-0.1119832322,
0.6251596212,
-0.8960657716,
-0.1070877686,
0.5459755063,
0.0521445274,
0.3567358255,
0.3491157889,
-0.1218386814,
0.5095027089,
0.259452045,
0.2971353531,
-0.4961239696,
-0.5413519144,
-0.0549343377,
0.3467486203,
-0.1182173193,
0.1952131242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14007v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14007v2
|
Can Watermarks Survive Translation? On the Cross-lingual Consistency of Text Watermark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T18:48:38 | 2024-06-04T14:24:15 |
Zhiwei He, Binglin Zhou, Hongkun Hao, Aiwei Liu, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text watermarking technology aims to tag and identify content produced by
large language models (LLMs) to prevent misuse. In this study, we introduce the
concept of cross-lingual consistency in text watermarking, which assesses the
ability of text watermarks to maintain their effectiveness after being
translated into other languages. Preliminary empirical results from two LLMs
and three watermarking methods reveal that current text watermarking
technologies lack consistency when texts are translated into various languages.
Based on this observation, we propose a Cross-lingual Watermark Removal Attack
(CWRA) to bypass watermarking by first obtaining a response from an LLM in a
pivot language, which is then translated into the target language. CWRA can
effectively remove watermarks, decreasing the AUCs to a random-guessing level
without performance loss. Furthermore, we analyze two key factors that
contribute to the cross-lingual consistency in text watermarking and propose
X-SIR as a defense method against CWRA. Code: https://github.com/zwhe99/X-SIR.
|
[
-0.2232922018,
-0.7855297923,
0.3787035644,
0.3151996732,
-0.583976984,
0.4159667492,
0.0109273065,
-0.8004228473,
0.2653321326,
0.7366132736,
-0.2408079356,
-0.2926249504,
-0.7621498108,
0.1946316808,
-0.6377947927,
0.7758448124,
-0.400960356,
0.1810802817,
-0.0386759713,
-0.3264150023,
-0.5734891295,
-0.6778700352,
-0.6031816006,
-0.3980967402,
0.5510257483,
0.1466222256,
0.8506941199,
0.733802855,
0.5906632543,
0.2423258722,
-0.2089819908,
0.1912251115,
-0.4134488702,
0.2345601618,
-0.2965370119,
-0.5825810432,
-0.2508247197,
-0.173422873,
0.8255966902,
0.3478994668,
0.2467279732,
-0.3319630623,
0.0755208954,
0.6405814886,
-0.599822402,
0.0331381224,
-0.8057298064,
0.2254531533,
-0.5815787911,
-0.2698565722,
-0.4467777014,
-0.0475458466,
0.0231457893,
-0.639098525,
-0.1826592237,
0.5164811611,
1.146371007,
-0.0266858097,
-0.2788550556,
-0.0170917865,
-0.8078116775,
0.8640801311,
-0.6022321582,
0.4938262999,
0.5520193577,
0.1473457217,
-0.0810754299,
-0.5305525661,
-0.5016567111,
0.0806689411,
0.2285515815,
0.2212340981,
-0.4342294931,
-0.4169901609,
0.0760660022,
0.232022211,
-0.4987797439,
-0.1086958572,
0.1053967923,
-0.1424712241,
0.635140121,
0.0597512014,
0.7178070545,
0.0896878168,
-0.6755692959,
-0.1532974094,
-1.2284823656,
-0.1012796536,
0.1912349164,
0.2992504239,
-0.0351451375,
0.6140093207,
0.1328538507,
0.1892250478,
-0.1344904453,
-0.238893196,
-0.0577406138,
-0.3802391589,
-0.1244585887,
0.2318117023,
0.7687767744,
0.2417787015,
0.6899276376,
-0.4470815957,
-0.3104231954,
-0.3604766428,
0.1154206768,
-0.459005326,
-0.0333412588,
-0.2381635904,
-0.375238955,
-0.0094007887,
-0.0283331294,
-0.3809618056,
-0.4434123933,
0.0293332748,
0.6933581829,
-0.3335750997,
-0.3563915789,
0.0074341102,
-0.183790803,
0.2668353319,
0.149387002,
-0.7665336132,
0.2379199415,
0.7156650424,
0.7703415155,
-0.4346058667,
-0.5225580335,
-0.5337077379,
0.59215343,
-0.5766263604,
0.7945697308,
-0.5678848624,
-0.5811689496,
0.0715261921,
0.2014511973,
-0.1371392906,
-0.6405189037,
0.3400573432,
-0.9222229123,
0.2160664499,
-0.6373749375,
-0.6130880117,
-0.1409340501,
0.4980281293,
-0.8056414723,
0.8486626148,
-0.0697360486,
-1.0378106833,
0.3108204305,
-0.1615324467,
-0.6604732871,
0.1660876721,
-0.0266341604,
-0.6188705564,
-0.0336157717,
-0.0400027893,
0.0786028132,
-0.4235122502,
0.1329243928,
-0.2043831497,
-0.3315607607,
0.4379618466,
-0.5127144456,
0.6497830153,
-0.2601074874,
-0.6250571012,
-0.0415638313,
-0.3196040392,
0.1196228713,
0.3950671256,
-0.3906297684,
-0.7504069805,
0.1027849913,
0.2587629855,
0.26523754,
0.3211191893,
-0.6750060916,
0.0071628145,
-0.1099559218,
0.3518691957,
0.6157695055,
0.0034785224,
0.3051243722,
-0.3581213355,
0.6271052361,
-0.0663628653,
0.0900065377,
-0.1213356853,
-0.8601313829,
-0.560569346,
-0.1315362155,
0.6552699804,
0.6808872819,
-1.0267051458,
0.1371955276,
-0.5588160157,
-0.3903710842,
-0.2239791304,
0.376380831,
0.7680307627,
0.2079806328,
0.4904798269,
-0.3301445246,
-0.3610765636,
-0.8600501418,
-0.6437106729,
-0.342736274,
0.2735292315,
0.1138112769,
0.569980979,
-0.1961106509,
1.0422637463,
-0.1294257939,
-0.3345028758,
-0.4358450174,
0.1018377021,
-0.483055979,
0.5563029647,
0.6081370711,
-1.1257659197,
-0.8724661469,
0.3851525784,
-0.5196291208,
-0.3722033203,
-0.0753768757,
-0.1049561203,
0.5382210612,
0.4973470569,
-0.5007659793,
0.6752133369,
0.8404202461,
-0.3535577655,
0.4259180725,
-0.1794210374,
0.2459781468,
-0.6957290173,
0.2534955144,
-0.0036660424,
-0.4403710067,
-0.5383374691,
0.0158154722,
0.286103636,
0.139375478,
-0.4273627996,
1.035836935,
-0.3537324667,
-0.008368114,
-0.6100959778,
0.0423867069,
0.3597520292,
0.2537678182,
0.1209710762,
0.7267762423,
0.290460825,
-0.1891093999,
0.0207121987,
0.2098580301,
-0.1332951635,
0.6127379537,
-0.8832815289,
-0.0316258147,
0.1539677233,
0.1396171004,
-1.0074415207,
0.3769769073,
0.6453295946,
-0.3114784658,
0.4918429852,
-0.2677171826,
-0.5832708478,
0.2724614143,
-0.224857375,
0.2720888853,
0.2788789272,
-0.5860767365,
0.6571708322,
0.3315947056,
-0.382535696,
-0.596323967,
-0.9883601665,
0.5672564507,
-0.0904354751,
-0.5922878981,
0.7109504938,
-0.2216782719,
-0.2827064097,
0.1311485171,
-0.1946971864,
-0.3180493116,
0.0756189749,
0.1345724463,
0.2698662281,
0.0119643724,
-0.4001438022,
0.1003900468,
-0.2518990338,
0.1165206954,
-0.0332931951,
0.3720267415,
0.255805254,
-0.5946242809,
-0.3098074794,
0.7227666378,
0.5230020881,
-0.2840659618,
0.6907249689,
0.4978190362,
-0.492459327,
0.0878104717,
-0.3904275894,
0.1728170514,
-0.455173105,
0.1165542901,
-0.3191130161,
-0.7260429263,
0.6705136299,
0.1827523261,
0.0690265,
0.4935892224,
0.1871874183,
-0.0989253893,
1.0600504875,
0.902807951,
-0.4427167773,
0.5666010976,
-0.0190275405,
0.3384513557,
-0.6014499664,
-0.1920816898,
-0.6632261872,
-0.1127686501,
-0.3298756778,
-0.3451562822,
0.102094844,
0.1601938456,
-0.0359373502,
0.3992755115,
0.0190685708,
0.441663295,
0.5086705685,
-0.2430761904,
0.4608365595,
0.2084782273,
-0.1965722591,
-0.273842603,
-0.623508811,
-0.4274560809,
0.4475829601,
0.2415241748,
0.647921145,
-0.1355868578,
0.571287334,
0.4475049376,
0.3532505929,
-0.462955296,
0.4726457596,
-0.0131945061,
-0.7395996451,
-0.259005487,
-0.4512370527,
-1.0235749483,
0.358759582,
-0.1406301707,
-0.4192163944,
-0.0187221058,
-0.1705916971,
0.3392668366,
0.6145211458,
-0.351690799,
0.8836652637,
-0.6231855154,
-0.4688761234,
-0.1376221627,
-0.6320079565,
-0.1263987124,
-0.5334068537,
0.2769650221,
-0.005461697,
-0.2638579309,
0.7539559603,
-0.2979533076,
0.8107122183,
-0.1598142833,
-0.5743932128,
0.1280585229,
0.1489251107,
0.4732273817,
-0.0901674852,
0.170438394,
0.5526216626,
0.0366568677,
-0.5314292908,
-0.4242939949,
0.4535311162,
-0.3996767402,
-0.5593919158,
-0.4056266844,
-0.3578548729,
-0.1080396846,
0.5518643856,
0.2655841112,
0.2200363129,
-0.2524187863,
0.0839523226,
0.7028917074,
-0.2297392786,
0.6392813325,
0.5382092595,
-0.3068844676,
-0.5944978595,
1.0100207329,
0.3836320341,
0.2660510242,
0.6825656295,
0.2922560871,
-0.2933707833,
-0.713617146,
-0.8179375529,
0.2036914229,
-0.689732492,
-0.2198013365,
-0.36512959,
-0.1086053029,
-0.0592608489,
-0.2412298769,
-0.4134579599,
-0.2429852784,
0.0160095617,
0.4294069707,
0.2317514867,
0.5194687247,
0.0947787091,
0.2060159296,
-1.1675595045,
0.422334671,
0.1765861958,
0.1420510858,
-0.1665483564,
-0.6672949791,
-0.4233125448,
0.2613725662,
-0.1697054356,
-0.5872683525,
0.4937708378,
0.163685441,
0.7244510055,
0.427787751,
0.0653405413,
0.5388758183,
-0.6902598143,
0.6048653126,
0.2585654855,
-1.2529600859,
0.1428713948,
-0.2642969787,
0.3807505667,
0.1735876054,
0.3217284679,
-0.8159395456,
-0.5637387633,
-0.290586412,
-0.9044030309,
0.180191651,
0.1619853377,
0.3068807423,
0.0663663819,
0.2531104386,
0.0981825441,
0.0481231734,
-0.8811804652,
-0.2357708812,
-0.1847438067,
0.0807177871,
0.058830142,
-0.2672778666,
-0.1794480532,
-0.0221482795,
0.8297849298,
-0.1358995587,
-0.1020382866,
0.1923704594,
-0.2760933638,
-0.2350782901,
0.2364089489,
0.5506795645,
0.4883963466,
0.2724900842,
0.051410161,
0.0155124385,
-0.58701545,
0.1348998994,
-0.1211795956,
-0.4202648699,
0.1530358642,
0.5606170297,
0.4624846876,
0.3455215693,
-0.7391070724,
0.4981625378,
-0.2021926641,
-0.0890759155,
-0.0353665613,
-0.1882909238,
0.2580577433,
0.1066720784,
0.6270945668,
-0.1352532506,
-0.414252907,
-0.4567483664,
-0.1116262078,
0.6669645309,
-0.3185181618,
-0.2968528569,
0.7362465262,
0.0451028496,
-0.2029320151,
0.1579362899,
0.1279893517,
-0.9993299842,
0.5206492543,
0.6832322478,
0.9043470025,
-0.2608452141,
-0.0886169374,
-0.1393844932,
0.6340710521,
-0.2662732005,
0.4318791628,
0.0376889259,
-0.7709810734,
-0.4414539039,
-0.2060223222,
-0.8631527424,
-0.2883424461,
-0.526004374,
-0.0974956304,
-0.358825624,
-0.0623167716,
-0.1070731133,
0.0302063003,
-0.2210401148,
0.2965937257,
0.2732614577,
0.9664593935,
-0.8193360567,
1.1505202055,
0.6125401855,
0.1158324927,
-0.3563309014,
0.090966545,
-0.1390468329,
-0.6543019414,
0.6134834886,
-0.0129203144,
-0.5016506314,
-0.2828740776,
-0.5138126612,
-0.9573242664,
0.619974494,
0.5426063538,
-0.4627158046,
0.388463378,
0.6155682206,
0.4716245532,
-0.1513309181,
-0.4297081828,
0.2912953496,
0.8260011077,
-0.4186649919,
-0.9378600121,
0.1259129941,
-0.4839119315,
-0.0027803802,
0.1474174112,
-0.4693084061,
0.5932257771,
0.0467213169,
-0.2748036981,
0.2980293632,
0.4541804194,
0.1599749327,
0.3568264246,
0.4466840327,
0.4915728867,
0.4212483466,
-0.2281959653,
1.0088464022,
-0.3225053251,
0.1135926321,
0.883387506,
-0.6699014902,
1.082113266,
0.7466996312,
0.1296941936,
0.3856446445,
0.2921754718,
-0.0561766513,
0.592030406,
-0.0023218745,
-0.166896373,
-0.2442009896,
-0.1689677536,
-0.5630957484,
0.3815547228,
0.0841783211,
-0.2509021461,
0.1786624193,
0.0635389835,
0.2334563285,
0.0722782239,
-0.1928169429,
0.4561933279,
0.2130958438,
-0.4159295261,
0.7230827808,
0.3374464214,
0.7267500758,
-0.7092272043,
0.1601287723,
-0.3485205173,
0.1394622773,
-0.1008359194,
-0.7346540093,
0.2956196964,
-0.0622527264,
-0.307954818,
-0.4324060082,
0.8351639509,
-0.6446544528,
-0.2398559898,
0.6854431033,
0.6526291966,
-0.0137725919,
-0.1013200954,
-0.8547178507,
0.4222784638,
-0.1221468747,
-0.3425389826,
0.5823963284,
0.4093179107,
-0.3791571856,
0.9740976095,
0.5312495232,
0.0973509476,
0.2205115557,
-0.071983248,
0.6545773745,
-0.6732032895,
-0.3968011737,
-0.9028664827,
0.0961679518,
0.0057826177,
-0.184761107,
1.0821046829,
0.5576867461,
0.9228590131,
0.1127383113,
0.9144305587,
0.1629999131,
0.1516036391,
-0.4144563973,
0.9701661468,
-0.7080767155,
0.0461423993,
-0.6032288671,
-0.9257957339,
-0.4129449427,
0.3540255725,
-0.143087104,
0.00282154,
0.7463989854,
0.5598044991,
0.0253148526,
0.0790881738,
0.4656012058,
-0.3033074141,
0.3729440868,
0.321768105,
0.8616974354,
-0.6384662986,
0.8257943988,
-0.2707186639,
0.1832224131,
-0.0414317623,
-1.0327115059,
-0.7386057377,
-0.4701349437,
-0.670339942,
-0.2863732576,
0.1873358041,
0.3144483268,
0.672119379,
-0.7564575076,
-0.0355313793,
0.1928916425,
0.2409607172,
-0.4076533616,
-0.1680465639,
0.3126965165,
0.1008620188,
-0.7464530468,
0.4279770851,
0.4779010713,
0.3671551347,
-0.2508148253,
-0.2692048848,
-0.1043935865,
0.2074747086,
0.3643806279,
0.5737133026,
-0.5555973649,
-0.2796331346,
0.0818272009,
-0.3952015042,
0.2119267881,
0.8169821501,
-0.4355709255,
0.2258418798,
0.4731937051,
0.8821018934,
0.2665400803,
-0.2029458433,
0.4987314343,
-0.566678822,
-0.1044399366,
-0.0169339404,
0.6706980467,
0.681899488,
-0.1455103904,
0.3648602068,
0.4216257334,
-0.3748016059,
-0.7261751294,
-0.0646129474,
-0.8578306437,
-0.3848188818,
1.1612956524,
-0.6648504138,
-0.288172096,
-0.4488019049,
-0.2771632075,
-0.0017389585,
-0.0290455483,
0.772051096,
0.8235257268,
0.4790860713,
-0.1023930088,
-0.3852301836,
0.2166175991,
0.6827149987,
-0.7667201757,
0.245624274,
0.0035169714,
0.4368563592,
0.2702221572,
0.4386283755,
-0.3290983438,
0.3470266759,
-0.1102760434,
0.0527030118,
0.1885894388,
-0.32529217,
-0.2583748698,
0.1566631645,
0.0167968925,
-0.0777488425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14002v1
|
Hallucinations or Attention Misdirection? The Path to Strategic Value Extraction in Business Using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T18:40:24 | 2024-02-21T18:40:24 |
Aline Ioste
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models with transformer architecture have revolutionized the
domain of text generation, setting unprecedented benchmarks. Despite their
impressive capabilities, LLMs have been criticized for generating outcomes that
deviate from factual accuracy or display logical inconsistencies, phenomena
commonly referred to as hallucinations. This term, however, has often been
misapplied to any results deviating from the instructor's expectations, which
this paper defines as attention misdirection rather than true hallucinations.
Understanding the distinction between hallucinations and attention misdirection
becomes increasingly relevant in business contexts, where the ramifications of
such errors can significantly impact the value extraction from these inherently
pre-trained models. This paper highlights the best practices of the PGI,
Persona, Grouping, and Intelligence, method, a strategic framework that
achieved a remarkable error rate of only 3,15 percent across 4,000 responses
generated by GPT in response to a real business challenge. It emphasizes that
by equipping experimentation with knowledge, businesses can unlock
opportunities for innovation through the use of these natively pre-trained
models. This reinforces the notion that strategic application grounded in a
skilled team can maximize the benefits of emergent technologies such as the
LLMs.
|
[
-0.2791988254,
-0.791285634,
0.6966985464,
0.3291263282,
-0.1405297369,
0.1354408413,
-0.0293042976,
-0.6190099716,
0.3507171869,
0.5540668368,
-0.5897499323,
-0.1207874864,
-0.7364584804,
-0.0069488976,
-0.1891450435,
1.0316859484,
0.1544394642,
-0.0215552263,
0.1483957171,
0.0293871313,
-0.629401803,
-0.8953487873,
-0.7507000566,
-0.2783431113,
0.4442685246,
0.1647101641,
0.8084109426,
0.3346095681,
0.7328296304,
0.3027996719,
0.1877853274,
0.1681814641,
-0.6257628202,
-0.0033435097,
-0.3047758639,
-0.3055415452,
-0.3588477671,
0.284845233,
0.233985126,
0.7722744346,
-0.2962268591,
0.0703796148,
-0.02832748,
0.7405695915,
-0.6772133112,
0.1629644334,
-0.7425454259,
0.3060995638,
0.027027538,
-0.2335683256,
-0.4345812798,
-0.4209477901,
0.3588751853,
-0.2808000147,
-0.0008064941,
0.1031364202,
1.0860068798,
0.2870952785,
0.0423033498,
-0.5459808111,
-1.1760976315,
0.6629535556,
-0.3371504843,
0.3071374297,
0.0030693135,
0.457316339,
0.0078004026,
-0.9124227166,
-0.3214903474,
-0.0069185263,
0.0680357665,
0.1714331657,
-0.3383571506,
-0.0246388428,
0.4450968504,
0.2353720814,
-0.2533243895,
0.1166937128,
-0.4640388191,
0.0577300936,
0.6310167909,
0.0622582771,
0.0125892973,
0.0573755018,
-0.3641478419,
-0.1556938887,
-0.6034226418,
-0.0178696066,
0.2345707864,
0.196402669,
0.4590591788,
0.6049129367,
0.0615621023,
0.2181297541,
0.4791659415,
-0.1960107088,
0.2517472208,
-0.349499613,
-0.6409903765,
0.3018308878,
0.4677099586,
0.139763549,
0.5276027322,
-0.6132927537,
-0.3246574998,
0.1725263447,
0.7142446637,
-0.6231359839,
-0.3930037618,
0.2412697077,
-0.6059730053,
-0.3672960997,
0.0696926191,
-1.1712753773,
-0.4586502612,
-0.3889924884,
0.558365941,
-0.2707874775,
-0.2809515893,
0.1092371866,
-0.1057415754,
0.4840166271,
0.1694376171,
-1.054323554,
0.1061464921,
0.6057223678,
0.7433518767,
-0.3145545423,
-0.2068673372,
-0.3981616497,
0.3039986193,
-0.5615946054,
0.7503841519,
-0.2972839177,
-0.6252369881,
-0.0747498944,
-0.2411007136,
-0.1733469218,
-0.9171071649,
0.3785027862,
-0.4702763855,
0.1105533391,
-0.241476953,
-0.305978924,
-0.1135033518,
0.1371597499,
-0.4276149571,
0.6125786901,
0.029671425,
-0.4344712794,
0.6461975574,
-0.673438549,
-0.4316496551,
0.3660413623,
-0.4869701266,
-0.4609839022,
0.2326214761,
0.0155203156,
0.4739795029,
-0.2491794378,
0.303994149,
0.0659576133,
-0.1382544637,
0.4913315475,
-0.4083351493,
0.5110177398,
0.0953891575,
-0.8410052061,
0.2736932039,
-0.7743402123,
0.1746657491,
0.3596500754,
-0.1200191528,
-0.2710986137,
-0.0035262054,
-0.1662863046,
0.3316746056,
0.0894523934,
0.0732804686,
-0.1308133453,
-0.4330930412,
0.1850827634,
0.9117427468,
0.2510322928,
0.3809923828,
-0.2796148062,
0.4566511214,
0.0529156178,
0.2462162971,
0.1636628211,
-0.3079599738,
-0.7482624054,
-0.3419098854,
-0.1346040964,
0.5411074162,
-0.5662272573,
0.4014252722,
-0.4540029764,
-0.6531306505,
-0.6046690345,
-0.0595784299,
0.0110436743,
0.5493561029,
0.2911284864,
-0.1956113577,
-0.4232512116,
-1.016297698,
-0.5182350278,
0.0375985652,
-0.0858934149,
0.2102927715,
0.3853341043,
-0.6138312221,
0.792484045,
-0.5459448099,
-0.4639523625,
-0.5445167422,
0.2920756936,
0.1748791933,
0.1927796751,
0.1292521656,
-0.9028477073,
-0.1965842098,
-0.0936821401,
-0.6892950535,
0.0820818916,
-0.4595663249,
-0.2036033273,
0.4392845929,
0.3199996948,
-0.6960883737,
0.4710773826,
0.1590140462,
-0.0133996252,
0.7843413353,
-0.0730647147,
0.2183954865,
-0.8926796317,
0.2499711365,
-0.0474640578,
0.2239233106,
-0.7527312636,
-0.2261596173,
-0.225738585,
0.0583958067,
-0.2116263956,
0.0937399343,
-0.4544565082,
-0.3286793232,
-0.265699327,
0.3995399475,
-0.0772333145,
0.4502397478,
0.108073011,
0.7340811491,
0.2217635214,
-0.8209291101,
0.5800097585,
0.2141727209,
-0.5596364737,
0.5527891517,
-0.542771697,
0.2510463297,
-0.155899033,
-0.2576279044,
-0.8539736271,
-0.2251226306,
0.3316830397,
-0.2868091166,
0.3128230572,
0.4543818533,
-0.4846928716,
-0.3000417352,
-0.1290238202,
-0.0131759671,
0.6151733398,
-0.4846709967,
0.6376988888,
0.5719404817,
-0.1350444704,
-0.4490408599,
-0.907779038,
0.1609674543,
-0.420450896,
-0.4536958933,
0.1638133079,
0.0783415139,
-0.5081081986,
-0.0798896998,
-0.237189129,
-0.0226600207,
0.0903448761,
0.2303904146,
0.3272284865,
-0.0872368291,
0.0378082804,
-0.4722378254,
-0.1637908667,
0.4491910338,
-0.2712244391,
0.4905009866,
-0.065410465,
-0.4209032953,
-0.2585084736,
0.1648709625,
0.6450389624,
-0.1737097055,
0.7127694488,
0.3502325714,
-0.4867628515,
-0.2020849586,
-0.8368625045,
-0.2982387245,
-0.4659171999,
0.5928113461,
-0.3223808706,
-0.3984320164,
0.4295127392,
-0.3104723692,
-0.0449019261,
0.4435355067,
0.4988120496,
0.1289484948,
0.9595030546,
0.8587373495,
-0.0306278933,
0.3041081429,
-0.2112723887,
0.9340816736,
-0.6176737547,
-0.7534871101,
-0.445887357,
-0.3205482662,
-0.4954326451,
-0.0716283992,
0.3407474458,
-0.0744141713,
0.0061281007,
-0.0491237715,
-0.6181076169,
0.3450059295,
0.557120204,
-0.1409936845,
0.1575797796,
0.123852253,
0.1309563369,
-0.5211767554,
-0.7116162777,
-0.6160857081,
0.8964954615,
0.3849786818,
0.8557431698,
0.1623438448,
0.4466344416,
0.0290830899,
0.3145036399,
-1.0811597109,
0.4955226481,
0.4075500369,
-0.4507312775,
-0.4859471619,
-0.4013826847,
-0.829611659,
0.3646907508,
-0.1503467262,
-0.8942727447,
0.2859099507,
-0.0977895111,
-0.530429244,
0.2836647034,
-0.7377118468,
1.0598323345,
-0.5634593368,
-0.4998128712,
-0.1970718652,
-0.5083251595,
0.4306143224,
-0.3442544341,
0.1253263056,
0.2732892334,
0.0520116165,
0.6420443654,
0.0734541714,
0.6018167138,
0.0580100566,
-0.1511024237,
0.1817711592,
0.0658323318,
0.6366998553,
-0.2950423658,
0.3287189007,
0.1190401539,
-0.4405236542,
-0.1058677956,
-0.613561213,
0.3577061892,
-0.60728091,
-0.8028082848,
-0.4708625376,
-0.4157927632,
-0.4083020687,
0.1350641847,
0.5747907162,
0.0466708578,
-0.4700766802,
0.0587392524,
0.9645282626,
-0.063748315,
0.5150476098,
0.139668256,
-0.1509726495,
-0.4171923995,
0.8762021661,
0.3091155589,
0.387213856,
0.1173292994,
-0.1001586989,
-0.3843097091,
-0.5123209953,
0.0632771924,
0.2591712475,
-0.8940545917,
0.1556685269,
-0.745426476,
-0.4697947502,
-0.5687147975,
-0.2353944629,
-0.3249920309,
0.1280707866,
-0.3586563468,
-0.1996776462,
-0.3096643388,
0.8140096664,
0.1578060836,
0.0856449082,
-0.7736937404,
0.1377912313,
0.381904453,
0.0105653116,
0.1269112825,
-0.2870907784,
-0.4454596639,
-0.0358580574,
-0.4982702136,
-1.0020669699,
0.6960486174,
-0.3107422292,
0.8643410206,
0.5559905767,
-0.270440042,
0.7739015818,
-0.4786326587,
0.7333369255,
0.2780983746,
-0.9035546184,
0.5525239706,
0.0382037722,
0.1948007792,
0.4275572002,
0.703661263,
-0.5287897587,
-0.0801646858,
-0.8907822967,
-0.9976819158,
0.6225978136,
-0.0681407228,
-0.0742484257,
-0.0261799674,
0.265244931,
0.0624188557,
0.7273699045,
-0.9548174143,
-0.0501584411,
-0.0344668701,
-0.0711287037,
-0.1538794637,
-0.4728565812,
-0.1047113687,
-0.0222353674,
0.6724936962,
0.0301271025,
0.2985881865,
0.2578159571,
-0.1830237657,
-0.1863681972,
0.1215358078,
0.6341996789,
1.1424920559,
0.06773974,
0.0599218719,
0.045378346,
-0.465657711,
-0.0663137436,
-0.2275051028,
0.0786959827,
-0.0517641641,
0.0743321255,
0.8400826454,
0.1428170055,
-0.6509643197,
0.4333156347,
0.3039661646,
-0.2451210767,
-0.2517733872,
-0.1243420243,
-0.1306305528,
0.4546433985,
0.4107396603,
0.1587944329,
0.2620558739,
-0.6342968941,
0.0656628013,
0.5756120086,
-0.2715182006,
-0.128290534,
0.6193054914,
0.1620853841,
-0.3859119117,
0.6302509308,
0.0127832992,
-0.5396515131,
0.5419791341,
0.5408895016,
1.3044384718,
-0.3549672365,
0.1957425475,
-0.0869403034,
0.7304520011,
-0.1843702644,
-0.1197783202,
0.1385549903,
-0.6999697089,
-0.2020041347,
-0.2873406112,
-0.3481698632,
0.6448693275,
-0.3510177135,
0.2274492979,
-0.5991621017,
-0.157233879,
-0.0365575813,
-0.1481490135,
-0.4977518618,
0.1795899719,
0.1030404642,
0.5413107276,
-0.524107337,
0.4255979657,
0.3881491721,
-0.5101467371,
-0.749479115,
0.3653844893,
-0.1655827314,
-0.5792517066,
0.9376904368,
0.316902101,
-0.3178116381,
0.0906091928,
-0.2458752096,
-0.8261306286,
0.968560636,
-0.0022189708,
-0.548797369,
-0.2072590292,
0.3440310955,
0.3718746901,
-0.5563230515,
-0.0989772379,
0.7005532384,
0.4265402853,
0.1814993322,
-0.4292218089,
-0.0115833431,
0.2264238298,
0.1957323253,
0.0939075872,
-0.5965662599,
0.6157258749,
-0.39397946,
-0.4398397505,
-0.4162193537,
0.5401087403,
0.1570828408,
0.3231762946,
0.1484952718,
0.3728666902,
0.9203810692,
-0.1419385076,
0.836329639,
-0.1445825845,
0.0172245223,
0.8793866634,
-0.4816542268,
0.6915709972,
0.6240715384,
0.0286275689,
0.1659322679,
0.6053255796,
-0.3750922978,
0.7567926645,
0.2332572043,
0.0386868678,
-0.0062537263,
0.1666173786,
-0.292450726,
0.2530094981,
0.4519405067,
-0.3967028856,
0.1658492535,
-0.0142728314,
-0.112022303,
0.0439072102,
-0.2931603491,
0.8587551713,
0.0099308603,
-0.7825493813,
0.4153094292,
-0.0931130722,
0.4793571532,
-0.4844635427,
0.0480990447,
-0.1253097802,
0.4470888078,
-0.0568896569,
-0.3418627083,
0.5138898492,
-0.1674685031,
-0.1709119678,
-0.3545063734,
0.6169530749,
-0.2854266465,
-0.2586704493,
0.3099447489,
0.5361223221,
0.1025928855,
-0.3019030094,
-0.5761355162,
0.1168142334,
0.0040315352,
-0.199898079,
0.1207844764,
0.6161689758,
0.3387703896,
0.5334273577,
0.3126838803,
0.173559621,
0.1244895309,
-0.0275523327,
0.6140075326,
-0.6565419436,
-0.4288550615,
-1.0553278923,
0.4309468865,
-0.3171049058,
-0.319413811,
0.7983908057,
0.5449959636,
0.8719012737,
-0.2924879789,
0.7435866594,
0.3975641727,
0.1225934699,
-0.5009101629,
0.7835288644,
-0.2427874804,
0.2258212715,
-0.3836449683,
-1.1318038702,
-0.0505314767,
0.7653770447,
-0.6044397354,
0.3258081973,
1.0123089552,
0.5402061939,
0.2330156863,
0.070392713,
0.6006541252,
0.3811454773,
0.3634506762,
0.6800495982,
0.8001163006,
-0.3067355454,
0.5326980948,
0.0668503344,
-0.4443726838,
-0.4091478586,
-0.6182413697,
-0.8466392756,
-0.422154516,
-0.3690937459,
-0.3972319663,
0.1053336412,
0.7978253961,
0.4302110076,
-0.5643203259,
-0.3134583533,
-0.2522439361,
0.0165916383,
-0.2235824615,
-0.2899504304,
0.1044345871,
-0.6620927453,
-0.7202461362,
0.0916469619,
0.6067758799,
0.478736639,
-0.395891577,
0.199314937,
-0.133542046,
0.418771863,
0.5577092767,
0.0543334335,
-0.6021497846,
-0.0491589271,
0.0715911016,
-0.3308674395,
0.0806492418,
0.6948686838,
-0.6228806376,
0.0568093807,
-0.0079833781,
1.0090646744,
0.2581599355,
-0.1442505717,
0.3404827714,
-0.2132605016,
0.1084151492,
0.4421218932,
0.0249017198,
0.3145072162,
-0.6527843475,
0.5516725779,
0.5888138413,
-0.5896513462,
-0.724567771,
0.4587987065,
-0.5142989755,
-0.4137915373,
0.9923135042,
0.129336372,
-0.3432029784,
0.1392516792,
-0.2875679731,
0.1010035053,
0.0155409332,
1.3415189981,
1.0000053644,
-0.1611396074,
-0.0010661947,
-0.6528542042,
0.8002980351,
0.479437232,
-1.0524368286,
0.1582377851,
0.5810725689,
-0.1710568368,
0.5117291808,
0.4653216302,
-0.1674064249,
0.0498021916,
0.1996852905,
0.0608166419,
0.2795300186,
-0.722510457,
-0.3682129681,
0.3697735965,
0.0228692573,
-0.3172793686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14875v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14875v2
|
What's in a Name? Auditing Large Language Models for Race and Gender Bias
| 2024-02-21T18:25:25 | 2024-02-29T19:39:35 |
Amit Haim, Alejandro Salinas, Julian Nyarko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
We employ an audit design to investigate biases in state-of-the-art large
language models, including GPT-4. In our study, we prompt the models for advice
involving a named individual across a variety of scenarios, such as during car
purchase negotiations or election outcome predictions. We find that the advice
systematically disadvantages names that are commonly associated with racial
minorities and women. Names associated with Black women receive the least
advantageous outcomes. The biases are consistent across 42 prompt templates and
several models, indicating a systemic issue rather than isolated incidents.
While providing numerical, decision-relevant anchors in the prompt can
successfully counteract the biases, qualitative details have inconsistent
effects and may even increase disparities. Our findings underscore the
importance of conducting audits at the point of LLM deployment and
implementation to mitigate their potential for harm against marginalized
communities.
|
[
-0.1659710407,
-0.3562977314,
0.6649134755,
0.1644119471,
-0.2075087875,
0.2491143346,
-0.0567508377,
-0.4284657836,
0.0609028451,
0.3107626736,
-0.4979498982,
-0.1733487695,
-0.756862998,
0.0043833633,
-0.4457506537,
1.3008761406,
0.0071423976,
0.5802648664,
0.1215416864,
0.0573711023,
-1.003241539,
-0.5242150426,
-0.8420470953,
-0.0107437624,
0.6875596642,
0.1439353526,
0.5006372929,
0.637691319,
0.4155194163,
0.2270423025,
-0.5033676624,
-0.1056562662,
-0.3927750289,
-0.0712886602,
-0.2718870044,
-0.3347270489,
-0.3062346876,
0.1585580111,
0.5914590359,
0.604136467,
-0.2292112112,
0.3956020772,
-0.0655141026,
0.514770031,
-1.0067074299,
0.2305402309,
-0.5671464801,
-0.0132838991,
-0.2687110603,
0.2804760933,
-0.0940071195,
-0.6823217273,
0.5380009413,
-0.2869966328,
0.0516689233,
0.2962131798,
0.6926658154,
0.1840985864,
-0.3988443911,
-0.4506269097,
-0.7787119746,
0.8074382544,
-0.8011927605,
0.3610440791,
0.2215552032,
0.5555508733,
-0.0424925014,
-0.3666053414,
-0.5829823017,
0.0512286201,
-0.0796957761,
-0.0281979293,
-0.3923535347,
-0.0068305163,
0.4005849361,
0.1448203325,
-0.0742048547,
0.2085035741,
-0.6023922563,
-0.2747127116,
0.6204054356,
0.1806089282,
0.3053313792,
0.0344244428,
-0.3981895745,
0.1582211405,
-1.0410368443,
-0.0690098703,
0.8396139145,
0.4556950927,
-0.1198790595,
0.443534106,
0.0208241586,
0.4131506979,
0.0381253287,
-0.2989652753,
0.0644946098,
-0.2321590483,
-0.3576348126,
0.4664760828,
0.4324060678,
0.5110391378,
0.3944405913,
-0.1809484512,
-0.1581279337,
-0.0238218494,
0.1405247897,
-0.5833680034,
-0.0138173886,
-0.0278897919,
-0.4599661827,
-0.1939832717,
0.0131719084,
-0.8789281249,
-1.0202640295,
-0.3991743922,
0.2713986337,
0.0362279117,
-0.2885542214,
-0.0046358951,
-0.5355337262,
0.3236334324,
0.6408122778,
-0.9786906242,
0.0403587706,
0.6729220748,
0.2916682959,
-0.1276969016,
-0.0207107943,
-0.5997990966,
0.1923769414,
-0.2365213037,
0.6335440874,
-0.6137812734,
-0.4999263287,
0.1300637722,
-0.0026713416,
0.3783497214,
-0.5645620823,
0.2487958819,
-0.2804907262,
0.351064831,
-0.844609201,
-0.4675487876,
-0.1927550882,
-0.0633228645,
-0.354188472,
0.6771890521,
0.0589859299,
-0.8515554667,
0.774079144,
-0.5601505637,
-0.046000462,
0.1515243798,
-0.5327208638,
-0.4150520861,
0.1646199524,
0.1410351545,
0.131595552,
-0.4771344662,
0.4060251117,
-0.2683801353,
-0.1517687738,
0.0997714102,
-0.1480438411,
0.760258317,
0.072253868,
-0.5529930592,
0.0688018873,
-0.3430649042,
-0.5573904514,
0.0171863716,
-0.1482051462,
-0.4936883748,
-0.0494064912,
-0.1061364412,
-0.1410213858,
-0.0151586793,
-0.6601747274,
0.3208492994,
0.1492808163,
0.3862426877,
1.0024602413,
0.0624318831,
0.4331322014,
-0.3878653944,
0.8849948049,
0.1031036079,
0.1041264907,
-0.1897294074,
-0.8587214947,
-0.5406297445,
-0.2572204173,
0.6167846322,
0.4248945415,
-0.2852762938,
-0.0741604865,
0.0506618321,
-0.4097876847,
-0.379253298,
-0.1320603341,
0.3985402286,
0.4277538061,
-0.0631204844,
-0.1545082629,
-0.597320497,
-1.2298007011,
-0.6769323349,
-0.4022398591,
0.1052719429,
0.3930857182,
0.6513809562,
-0.3555630147,
0.9695618153,
-0.411469996,
-0.1236384735,
-0.1667784899,
0.1305090636,
0.1851154268,
0.2403613031,
0.5866227746,
-0.5034397244,
-0.1012914628,
-0.348608911,
-0.371245563,
-0.2492622584,
-0.0472280532,
-0.2116952389,
-0.2304033041,
0.3552128077,
-0.4519788325,
0.4500135183,
0.4264649749,
-0.4721341431,
0.8398358226,
0.0715794712,
-0.2260757983,
-0.8906709552,
-0.2263634205,
0.0264836252,
-0.0864255503,
-0.4307538867,
-0.2269873321,
0.1378818452,
-0.132496208,
-0.5286662579,
0.7942908406,
-0.6306717396,
-0.1651635021,
0.2154241651,
0.0109242257,
-0.2485858053,
-0.0618652962,
-0.1192846075,
0.9341289401,
0.3502956331,
-0.6217025518,
0.2675268054,
0.4722858071,
-0.3584388196,
0.7540096641,
-0.3035968542,
0.0924985036,
-0.3320016861,
0.1279948503,
-0.9065735936,
-0.0821204558,
-0.0224879142,
-0.2183281481,
0.3670434356,
-0.1719864905,
-0.2219390422,
-0.4116153121,
-0.2991152406,
0.5248849392,
0.367387414,
-0.5860789418,
0.4169420898,
0.7877705693,
-0.3384508193,
-0.7012236714,
-0.6884816289,
0.1539605707,
-0.6712593436,
-0.2002658248,
-0.0198226627,
-0.1163915768,
-0.6208506823,
-0.3465510607,
-0.0846282914,
-0.2595037222,
0.274508208,
0.173219353,
0.2612991035,
-0.160515815,
0.3093701303,
-0.194236666,
0.2109666169,
0.224014923,
0.201675266,
0.2495847195,
0.2039360255,
-0.0620222613,
-0.3666992486,
0.3529320955,
0.5736483932,
-0.151174292,
0.4982073307,
-0.0565686747,
-0.4669402838,
-0.1718720347,
-0.6980022192,
-0.2102413327,
-0.4700933993,
0.2022897303,
-0.1104171053,
-0.9321250319,
0.6919018626,
-0.0885345563,
0.0163647123,
0.1696639657,
0.7093773484,
-0.1429865062,
0.8458304405,
0.6398222446,
-0.38046965,
0.6294406056,
-0.0377698243,
0.7403815389,
-0.8270732164,
-0.0466049723,
-0.4598701596,
-0.3102158308,
-0.6354221106,
-0.2989117503,
0.2083530426,
-0.1200831309,
-0.4428673685,
0.0955981016,
-0.4023412466,
0.5373895168,
0.4324059486,
-0.2639288902,
0.3517950773,
-0.4104170799,
-0.0589900538,
-0.2076535672,
-0.3915063441,
-0.65130198,
1.1280988455,
0.5150982141,
0.7563379407,
0.1928132921,
0.5807308555,
0.5114573836,
0.7979186177,
-0.6567256451,
0.1997604966,
0.2661656439,
-1.0131334066,
-0.2332414538,
-0.2704923153,
-0.9390662313,
0.1566994637,
0.0767977387,
-0.9126694798,
0.472969085,
0.1391041428,
-0.5141740441,
0.4741583169,
-0.6363145709,
0.7182783484,
-0.3078942895,
0.0437788107,
0.2041350156,
-0.0935239494,
0.8927330375,
-0.4592151046,
0.4635714591,
-0.3231075704,
-0.0322234109,
0.8027824759,
-0.4365949631,
0.7425825596,
-0.3014105856,
-0.239887163,
-0.1032850295,
-0.0333145373,
0.6566683054,
0.0142408144,
0.0325592123,
0.3759014308,
-0.2100125849,
-0.0752368197,
-0.3894768953,
0.408408314,
-0.5340235829,
-0.5930639505,
-0.4248701036,
-0.4025932848,
-0.2348802537,
0.0573071279,
0.2302072346,
0.3945305943,
-0.2794747651,
-0.232559815,
0.2856758237,
-0.6159284711,
0.3615455627,
0.6211355925,
-0.1513114274,
-0.0862664208,
0.502790451,
0.0717737153,
0.0609768331,
-0.0402333103,
0.3795743287,
-0.3431068063,
-0.6450906396,
-0.5023209453,
0.5947978497,
-0.5908690691,
-0.304224968,
-0.5223110914,
0.087124072,
-0.2353387475,
0.0625811815,
-0.3062261045,
-0.3478707075,
-0.0280067082,
-0.3221024573,
0.184773609,
1.2194299698,
0.2936655581,
0.7169023752,
-0.4753324986,
-0.0370521285,
0.5415539145,
0.2712932229,
0.0085224072,
-0.257755518,
-0.117141746,
-0.1493770778,
-0.4357672036,
-1.0793881416,
0.352204591,
-0.2260398418,
0.6306785345,
0.6297893524,
0.1598202139,
0.5613936782,
-0.6432400346,
0.9976430535,
0.3433126509,
-1.0312578678,
0.4046608508,
-0.5156382322,
0.1329024285,
0.473874867,
0.2073920071,
-0.6963812113,
-0.7393692732,
-0.4428198338,
-0.6555339694,
0.5243259072,
0.1102781743,
0.1312668771,
-0.1920635849,
0.2011858821,
0.0996118858,
0.7547947764,
-0.5917369127,
-0.5066508055,
0.3098109961,
0.0686938614,
0.1971549839,
-0.5546255112,
-0.1822161376,
-0.2236996293,
0.5819568634,
0.0515809841,
0.441216439,
0.0161272585,
0.0187142044,
0.0172286257,
0.3976744711,
0.7959525585,
0.9132882953,
-0.005191437,
-0.1990159303,
0.4269833863,
-0.3147091568,
0.258687079,
-0.1850210428,
-0.1483507156,
0.1800131053,
0.4848870933,
0.7377269268,
0.3876811266,
-0.4273751378,
0.6263843775,
-0.3517440557,
-0.1564849168,
-0.4980173707,
-0.2415613085,
0.1173586473,
0.2308146209,
0.3724917769,
-0.4211177528,
0.2418323904,
-0.7089657187,
-0.307749778,
0.5836197734,
-0.3078246415,
-0.2467668653,
0.8700836897,
0.3279558122,
-0.3949616253,
0.5086658597,
-0.181594342,
-0.8715536594,
0.6663517952,
0.1291601956,
0.9591354132,
-0.5192449689,
-0.0208731685,
0.2668654621,
0.2899894714,
-0.1006721035,
0.2685918212,
0.1069180965,
-0.9255034924,
-0.1721012294,
-0.6986551285,
-0.650872767,
0.2721964121,
-0.5498991013,
0.387377888,
-0.7218725085,
-0.4687831402,
0.3338546753,
-0.2246431708,
-0.8036378622,
0.0244475231,
0.4537252486,
1.0656248331,
-0.9330988526,
0.4595712721,
0.5365908146,
-0.3075978458,
-0.9888370633,
-0.0081581157,
0.4564442933,
-0.7279291153,
1.1347162724,
0.1566480249,
0.1806958467,
-0.3501740396,
-0.2632929981,
-1.0238674879,
0.8981330395,
0.5160810351,
-0.8562680483,
-0.2978770733,
-0.0684683844,
0.2356224805,
-0.5356555581,
0.5706757903,
0.7737616301,
1.021949172,
-0.3075017333,
-1.3696843386,
-0.1481160671,
0.1725255847,
0.0849616304,
0.2927140892,
-0.6064046025,
1.0388747454,
-0.354469955,
-0.3166472018,
0.0163791291,
0.229024604,
0.1786144525,
0.2894953787,
0.5530674458,
0.3783024251,
1.1618489027,
-0.2777486444,
1.3740159273,
0.0512969382,
0.2537338734,
1.1665264368,
-0.3546450734,
0.1503083706,
0.4585895836,
-0.3234033287,
0.4809936285,
0.6216773391,
-0.0489202738,
0.5050300956,
0.6178854108,
-0.1801691204,
0.0894149467,
-0.2628835738,
-0.369392097,
0.6648365259,
0.0840995461,
-0.6596747637,
-0.2997832596,
-0.2195029855,
0.2785605192,
-0.2583730221,
-0.279615581,
0.7755035162,
0.1195554286,
-0.4595757723,
0.0459136367,
-0.2217959762,
0.6541484594,
-0.5095507503,
-0.0251664203,
-0.2221262008,
0.2775529921,
-0.1102491468,
-0.4375676513,
0.1081809253,
-0.0026886126,
-0.4679974318,
-0.2111870348,
0.0741619542,
-0.4788597822,
-0.3571840525,
0.5120359659,
0.5944155455,
0.1282525063,
-0.2268370837,
-0.5216647983,
-0.1237597987,
-0.0396840125,
-0.0404733308,
0.3210975826,
0.3453072011,
-0.4384145737,
0.6755500436,
0.5669727325,
0.6019634604,
0.1419205517,
0.0893740505,
0.6181434989,
-0.8271126747,
-0.5801205039,
-0.9833300114,
0.4089182913,
-0.221388042,
-0.3645897806,
1.0026217699,
0.6012148857,
0.7196128368,
0.0599720553,
0.8428067565,
0.5503478646,
0.6256780624,
-0.1998227835,
0.8499966264,
-0.4188790619,
0.3923244178,
-0.4588886201,
-1.0323495865,
-0.0878564492,
0.3321297467,
-0.3651067317,
0.1605730504,
0.6373199821,
0.598772049,
0.0660670102,
0.2251948416,
0.2444190383,
0.2821728587,
0.5405533314,
0.1750530303,
1.0171897411,
-0.1289807111,
0.1745787412,
0.2350204885,
-0.0922628641,
-0.3076263964,
-1.1435147524,
-0.8411594033,
-0.2197611332,
-0.4330172241,
0.0450421162,
0.1108113527,
0.6050384641,
0.8409605622,
-0.8497044444,
-0.3054134548,
0.3586687744,
0.4105762839,
0.1100965142,
-0.2351710349,
0.0791590214,
-0.1284831017,
-0.6517537236,
0.2192787826,
0.1395546496,
0.0699296817,
-0.3323719501,
0.0020429648,
0.0845231339,
0.1841809005,
0.3433181942,
0.0732104629,
-0.9082533121,
-0.4488087595,
-0.6482944489,
0.0189395417,
-0.0865895897,
1.0635534525,
-0.4854803681,
0.6026752591,
0.2678678632,
0.6185100079,
0.3276023567,
0.0376646221,
1.1521328688,
-0.6734070182,
-0.0235758219,
0.2735382617,
0.7833625674,
0.5215328336,
-0.6278553009,
0.4939055145,
0.0853723884,
-0.5566306114,
-1.003618598,
0.1401618123,
-0.5281646252,
-0.1045881882,
1.3229469061,
-0.0377133116,
-0.0774205923,
-0.2315671146,
-0.3684542775,
-0.0276821051,
-0.7847442627,
0.771453023,
0.9893752337,
0.1809864491,
-0.2824929655,
-0.7937618494,
0.7455723882,
0.1314707249,
-0.5663225055,
0.2737959623,
0.3971229792,
0.4510444403,
-0.0437526815,
0.6060023308,
-0.0195962172,
0.3791117668,
-0.478002131,
0.1438874751,
0.0527951345,
0.0341346301,
-0.800471127,
-0.4362953901,
0.0839264914,
-0.0607557483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13991v1
|
Analysing The Impact of Sequence Composition on Language Model Pre-Training
| 2024-02-21T18:23:16 | 2024-02-21T18:23:16 |
Yu Zhao, Yuanbin Qu, Konrad Staniszewski, Szymon Tworkowski, Wei Liu, Piotr Miłoś, Yuxiang Wu, Pasquale Minervini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most language model pre-training frameworks concatenate multiple documents
into fixed-length sequences and use causal masking to compute the likelihood of
each token given its context; this strategy is widely adopted due to its
simplicity and efficiency. However, to this day, the influence of the
pre-training sequence composition strategy on the generalisation properties of
the model remains under-explored. In this work, we find that applying causal
masking can lead to the inclusion of distracting information from previous
documents during pre-training, which negatively impacts the performance of the
models on language modelling and downstream tasks. In intra-document causal
masking, the likelihood of each token is only conditioned on the previous
tokens in the same document, eliminating potential distracting information from
previous documents and significantly improving performance. Furthermore, we
find that concatenating related documents can reduce some potential
distractions during pre-training, and our proposed efficient retrieval-based
sequence construction method, BM25Chunk, can improve in-context learning
(+11.6\%), knowledge memorisation (+9.8\%), and context utilisation (+7.2\%)
abilities of language models without sacrificing efficiency.
|
[
-0.2973282933,
-0.5055534244,
0.2235065103,
0.3044219613,
-0.4963788986,
-0.0535137057,
-0.1334361732,
-0.4260704219,
-0.0275316089,
0.5149040222,
-0.3906792402,
-0.3037578166,
-0.6725419164,
0.0050105262,
-0.4767136574,
0.6741699576,
0.182110399,
0.0927689299,
-0.3090158999,
0.1107902527,
-0.7906879783,
-0.7326385379,
-0.342272073,
-0.0744406134,
0.4739343822,
0.201236099,
0.2754237652,
0.5186445117,
0.4871776402,
0.3722757995,
0.0418667383,
0.1881031543,
-0.4946254194,
0.1887099743,
-0.2257614285,
-0.5137946606,
-0.180843249,
0.0710266903,
1.0472428799,
0.75459975,
0.1004129127,
0.0122711668,
0.2738304734,
0.6003507972,
-0.950543046,
0.0101553006,
-0.5127078891,
-0.1660666168,
-0.4018366337,
-0.3206360936,
-0.7065024972,
0.0944273472,
0.2755928934,
-0.4822112918,
0.0815743506,
0.0731577724,
0.7665630579,
0.1145318151,
-0.2729704976,
-0.2793736756,
-0.7694000006,
0.6056150794,
-0.998894155,
0.283927381,
0.435680896,
-0.0127774514,
0.0051443079,
-0.7717257142,
-0.6002988815,
0.1690077037,
-0.5194214582,
-0.0343910418,
0.1686480939,
0.2658530772,
0.4463536441,
0.2829752266,
-0.689827323,
0.1563710123,
-0.4890480638,
-0.2060866803,
0.4880970418,
0.0819525495,
0.3817981184,
-0.1285425127,
-0.0341073498,
-0.1516345441,
-0.8380781412,
-0.124172546,
0.5708264709,
0.3473494053,
0.027199395,
0.3989278376,
-0.254372716,
0.8112045527,
0.0762082487,
-0.0316011533,
0.1838536114,
-0.5346745849,
-0.1842274517,
0.0627879426,
0.7777738571,
-0.1071615964,
0.2995888293,
-0.1765503734,
0.0833077058,
-0.1566687971,
0.4583829641,
-1.1650335789,
-0.0886779502,
0.0766164213,
-0.23743774,
-0.0470322743,
0.296831578,
-0.3851539195,
0.1289088279,
-0.4581158459,
0.5622470975,
-0.4167921543,
0.1023271978,
0.3610637784,
0.0158682913,
0.1709525436,
0.1774311364,
-1.0288718939,
0.134241432,
0.704782784,
0.5707990527,
-0.0247263238,
-0.3615930676,
-0.56378299,
0.3560925424,
-0.1463484168,
0.4432460666,
-0.5482845902,
-0.6140303612,
0.1693181098,
0.0189456828,
-0.410394311,
-0.4387516975,
0.2181409299,
-0.5475619435,
0.584107399,
-0.0834870115,
-0.7510595322,
-0.36635831,
-0.0961209685,
-0.7117921114,
0.8294193149,
-0.1066387147,
-0.8188899159,
0.2560207844,
-0.266810298,
-0.8728231192,
0.108852379,
-0.2398272604,
-0.3500576317,
0.0624348372,
0.0342561603,
0.5659174919,
-0.1564432383,
0.6343383789,
-0.1118152812,
-0.6347504258,
0.1740745008,
-0.2640628517,
0.5602238178,
0.1052059904,
-0.5285928845,
0.1454276741,
-0.8046361208,
-0.3002256751,
-0.3415391743,
-0.3394980133,
-0.4419754744,
-0.1317164451,
-0.368727833,
0.491645962,
-0.0300022494,
-0.2297364175,
-0.1346259266,
-0.3717834651,
-0.1045665666,
0.5621547699,
0.1327450722,
0.5601899624,
-0.5601798296,
0.5340781808,
0.2361397445,
0.0351445526,
-0.7181879878,
-0.3918074965,
-0.6723003983,
-0.4183929861,
0.3804896772,
0.6460891366,
-0.4705782831,
0.6013353467,
-0.4675492048,
-0.4347645044,
-0.3481815457,
0.2699743211,
0.8622973561,
0.678219676,
0.2858510315,
-0.8079935908,
-0.818162024,
-0.6353464127,
-0.1476094425,
0.0517977215,
0.0342583656,
0.0521746688,
0.3033886552,
-0.2255235165,
0.7979909182,
-0.5157514215,
-0.1394853443,
-0.1961782128,
0.0476969145,
0.1550734043,
0.8762005568,
0.3558434546,
-0.6749820113,
-0.457613647,
-0.4955692589,
-0.5326004028,
-0.1136726215,
-0.0901832953,
-0.2352902442,
0.3281094432,
0.7534866929,
-0.7650593519,
0.4824728668,
0.1829045564,
-0.1001169011,
0.6236938238,
-0.1794265062,
0.0026048308,
-1.0585824251,
0.4742306173,
-0.275744766,
0.0441125073,
-0.6876994371,
-0.017977301,
0.1261986792,
-0.1115012094,
-0.7550548911,
0.5382083654,
-0.380369693,
0.2814239264,
-0.1149901599,
-0.1594768018,
0.1508916765,
0.4973801374,
0.0259282757,
0.5326769948,
0.3012884557,
-0.7164573073,
-0.4120693505,
0.2702845037,
-0.5059695244,
0.2320990264,
-0.2873854041,
0.1393687725,
-0.2320387363,
0.399998486,
-1.0046750307,
-0.0784156322,
0.1183948517,
-0.3262667954,
0.8826253414,
0.0581872351,
-0.5515688658,
-0.2518595457,
-0.2062106878,
0.6659292579,
0.3787351549,
-0.1446281374,
0.5503367186,
0.1331361383,
-0.0979499817,
-0.6289260983,
-0.7255606651,
-0.2208869606,
-0.3994950056,
-0.6309536099,
0.5686743855,
-0.1860696226,
0.1034103781,
-0.2100457251,
-0.126295805,
0.2606402636,
0.3501814306,
0.2810923159,
0.140909493,
-0.2255912721,
0.06153512,
-0.1441650689,
-0.03579925,
-0.0103352442,
-0.3506127298,
0.7308234572,
0.148891449,
-0.2574297488,
-0.3503116965,
0.579010725,
0.2582377195,
-0.4181503057,
1.0548241138,
0.5185716152,
-0.3149629533,
-0.0978903249,
-0.6926970482,
-0.2981387675,
-0.5060396791,
0.2828828096,
-0.2591560185,
-1.1330753565,
0.6290755868,
0.0015943241,
-0.31795156,
0.2781968713,
0.3011445105,
-0.1117443144,
0.4134506285,
0.4930717051,
-0.171705991,
0.9211732149,
-0.3366384506,
0.3390774727,
-0.7990837097,
-0.3802441359,
-0.4309768975,
-0.0910496935,
-0.5717888474,
-0.3748914003,
-0.2273443788,
0.3248375952,
-0.3397486508,
0.4814008772,
-0.0873355567,
0.3864862025,
0.6737850904,
0.2780455053,
0.0773989111,
-0.154745236,
-0.2906184793,
0.1787516028,
-0.7139725089,
-0.2694425881,
1.2716259956,
-0.0758685395,
0.4311356246,
0.1260732859,
0.9988327026,
-0.0973807648,
0.2826272845,
-0.2907616794,
0.5184551477,
-0.2238258421,
-0.5878942013,
-0.3600821197,
-0.3057074547,
-1.0614954233,
0.3159111738,
-0.1328249574,
-0.8013723493,
0.2062436044,
0.0489000902,
-0.4479872286,
-0.0815106407,
-0.7367094159,
0.9244320393,
-0.0663936287,
-0.6146538258,
-0.1613486856,
-1.0619462729,
0.461469233,
-0.4974396527,
0.3061313033,
0.2216462642,
0.4161320627,
0.7529901266,
-0.5288537145,
0.9184037447,
0.0857247263,
0.0848856345,
0.3143873811,
-0.2075802833,
0.4154175818,
-0.3926084638,
-0.012168874,
-0.0888910443,
-0.1488876641,
-0.4237183332,
-0.562854588,
0.2945305407,
-0.4244325459,
-0.960177362,
-0.1655570418,
-0.4863995016,
-0.1733728051,
0.4399478436,
0.2581454813,
0.7515095472,
-0.0464846455,
0.3999295831,
0.7585930228,
-0.2595805526,
0.7876651883,
0.6525451541,
-0.0646174699,
-0.3851105571,
0.7342630029,
0.2489297092,
0.4120718241,
0.8239449263,
0.1403233707,
-0.2043882757,
-0.5616136789,
0.0583250448,
0.2936782539,
-0.6786471009,
-0.1543018967,
-0.7322553396,
-0.2560918927,
-0.6872330308,
-0.0833105817,
-0.0669054687,
-0.2628364265,
-0.3431576788,
-0.1661966145,
-0.2032398283,
0.3893733025,
-0.0279637612,
0.6438689828,
-0.9219765663,
-0.0067763501,
0.1946910024,
0.1639239639,
0.2136623412,
-0.536342144,
-0.6512867212,
-0.1426377147,
-0.4101141989,
-0.6913475394,
0.2629947662,
0.2322791964,
0.6811043024,
0.4751565158,
-0.0995230302,
0.7445497513,
-0.4962328672,
0.6580671668,
0.0346621946,
-0.9469454885,
0.421374172,
-0.3356516361,
0.5420382619,
0.7045710087,
0.4392197132,
-0.3505379856,
-0.4300881624,
-0.7003329396,
-0.9893097878,
0.7447918057,
0.1097708568,
0.1762875915,
-0.2074408531,
0.2063272744,
-0.094217062,
0.3510954082,
-0.4541871846,
-0.1674834341,
0.106676355,
-0.2181090713,
-0.5073577166,
-0.5359166861,
0.2371724695,
-0.3416585922,
0.7245377302,
0.2539841831,
-0.004129516,
0.0000304088,
-0.566275239,
0.2353792936,
0.116090633,
1.017952919,
0.5576117039,
-0.3168337345,
0.1759275645,
-0.1662186831,
-0.5645279884,
0.1705728918,
0.2100228071,
-0.1327718943,
0.0609117523,
0.6011904478,
0.8491903543,
0.7140496373,
-0.5008817315,
0.5490561724,
0.2266500443,
0.1445318609,
0.1135933697,
0.1100208312,
0.0804541856,
-0.0768357143,
0.3198860586,
-0.1038045287,
0.0776847005,
-0.6149232388,
0.4945577681,
0.1325361431,
-0.0457787961,
-0.2523920834,
0.4677346945,
-0.0079846252,
-0.1947871149,
0.6103328466,
0.0117682256,
-0.6646532416,
0.5053620338,
0.6073949933,
0.842622757,
-0.6806039214,
-0.1130045652,
0.4409264326,
0.246893391,
-0.2162129134,
0.1166757047,
-0.2317056358,
-0.5229700804,
-0.6812463403,
-0.7027067542,
-0.1388138682,
-0.0027221236,
-0.4673373103,
0.297491312,
-0.1792137474,
0.0647758394,
-0.2072711885,
0.0628698841,
-0.8232816458,
0.4151512682,
0.1088161543,
0.6876519918,
-0.8578771949,
1.0338876247,
0.2488651127,
-0.5843386054,
-1.1587549448,
-0.044846002,
-0.2382167578,
-0.3102139533,
0.6691014171,
0.6477327347,
0.140092656,
0.1308367997,
-0.0324316137,
-0.9363515377,
0.8936265111,
0.3721674383,
-0.4454189837,
-0.1250845492,
0.3560455739,
0.4535114169,
-0.4329799712,
0.2186930627,
0.3759302497,
0.2606666982,
0.3233821988,
-0.8209431171,
0.3402324021,
-0.3628397584,
0.0179661401,
0.1781477183,
-0.3599208295,
0.6799683571,
0.1524878442,
-0.383472383,
-0.0231434572,
0.4429645538,
0.1201982051,
0.1132385284,
0.002805593,
0.7329003811,
0.7858361006,
0.2350851148,
1.1520936489,
-0.3170493543,
-0.0642280579,
1.5674507618,
-0.174283281,
0.7251808643,
0.488909483,
-0.0396080278,
0.6275860071,
0.5178582072,
0.3251171112,
0.8949798346,
0.5664656162,
-0.3427352309,
0.0549433902,
0.1222497448,
-0.504561305,
0.3180130422,
0.3109117448,
-0.4491431713,
-0.0153682185,
0.0202602632,
0.2323597372,
-0.114746049,
-0.0923024267,
0.7799364328,
0.283018291,
-1.1051486731,
0.45625633,
-0.0479438119,
0.6073384285,
-0.8152760267,
0.327927798,
-0.4247478843,
0.1585202217,
-0.1084446236,
-0.2447300851,
0.5344360471,
-0.4767086506,
-0.2652129531,
-0.2533487678,
0.5592970252,
-0.7108970284,
-0.1688932925,
0.0906603262,
0.3288618028,
-0.1231770366,
-0.2565163672,
-0.0547630191,
0.0131098665,
-0.2431859225,
-0.1003043875,
0.5918317437,
0.3704600036,
-0.2367438674,
0.3995218873,
0.8683920503,
-0.3202694654,
0.2703504264,
0.0739937127,
0.8397756219,
-0.5123336315,
-0.6752863526,
-1.1654331684,
0.7299317122,
0.0205151848,
0.0244836006,
0.8301796317,
0.7687700987,
1.0910440683,
-0.2894127965,
0.3843439519,
0.2684052289,
-0.0324586034,
-0.6463860869,
0.8090929389,
-0.1450869739,
0.3332744837,
-0.5946176052,
-0.7739112377,
-0.544770062,
0.183459729,
-0.3541119993,
-0.0316500701,
0.9296192527,
0.9028427005,
0.1017302573,
-0.0780273005,
0.3885622323,
-0.1578651965,
0.2304891795,
0.4584397674,
0.6025289893,
-0.3917203844,
0.2691265941,
-0.2132796496,
0.0390045829,
-0.2511829734,
-0.996281147,
-0.9057400227,
-0.7473989129,
-0.2867287099,
-0.2141189873,
0.0304113533,
0.5181841254,
0.7862123847,
-0.7478397489,
-0.214324683,
-0.0817991495,
0.1248219013,
0.1899735928,
-0.1099461839,
0.5043981075,
-0.6096951365,
-0.3028975725,
0.2854556143,
0.1653524041,
0.2195303291,
0.1077412814,
-0.1945951283,
-0.6929882765,
0.271795094,
0.591330409,
0.199216485,
-0.4321770072,
-0.1607900709,
-0.232586205,
-0.2076850086,
-0.0146070374,
1.0443549156,
-0.6892528534,
0.5297423601,
0.5691933036,
0.7331398726,
0.7504903078,
0.0049474123,
0.8760722876,
-0.9496420622,
0.4912631512,
-0.077582635,
0.4046676159,
0.3960827887,
-0.3256809115,
0.4526669383,
0.4238805771,
-0.1521279812,
-0.6710218787,
0.0668356866,
-0.8279210329,
-0.3302404583,
0.9523063898,
-0.4485862255,
-0.1590082198,
0.0530918427,
-0.0932371914,
0.5810617805,
0.0170233231,
0.5578260422,
0.8625202179,
0.3802885413,
-0.0670349747,
-0.1634363383,
0.5114244223,
0.5895015597,
-0.6739305854,
-0.4627154171,
0.3827308714,
0.2221934646,
0.1297352463,
0.6343995333,
-0.1764339805,
0.1582181156,
-0.1920521408,
-0.2129191458,
-0.1377392858,
-0.3430193663,
-0.3688268661,
0.107013166,
-0.2362121642,
-0.2942195237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13963v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13963v4
|
Towards Building Multilingual Language Model for Medicine
| 2024-02-21T17:47:20 | 2024-06-02T10:02:00 |
Pengcheng Qiu, Chaoyi Wu, Xiaoman Zhang, Weixiong Lin, Haicheng Wang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of open-source, multilingual medical language models can
benefit a wide, linguistically diverse audience from different regions. To
promote this domain, we present contributions from the following: First, we
construct a multilingual medical corpus, containing approximately 25.5B tokens
encompassing 6 main languages, termed as MMedC, enabling auto-regressive domain
adaptation for general LLMs; Second, to monitor the development of multilingual
medical LLMs, we propose a multilingual medical multi-choice question-answering
benchmark with rationale, termed as MMedBench; Third, we have assessed a number
of open-source large language models (LLMs) on our benchmark, along with those
further auto-regressive trained on MMedC. Our final model, MMed-Llama 3, with
only 8B parameters, achieves superior performance compared to all other
open-source models on both MMedBench and English benchmarks, even rivaling
GPT-4. In conclusion, in this work, we present a large-scale corpus, a
benchmark and a series of models to support the development of multilingual
medical LLMs.
|
[
-0.2069065124,
-0.6127309799,
0.6626378894,
0.0468696393,
-0.0905573517,
-0.0840046033,
-0.3568040431,
-0.5139701962,
0.2359442562,
0.4793804586,
-0.296821475,
-0.4657105803,
-0.5812951326,
0.4337857962,
0.0657464117,
0.9084114432,
-0.3037681878,
0.6684718132,
-0.0355870612,
-0.5215598941,
-0.3736779988,
-0.7835779786,
-0.52932477,
-0.0929620042,
0.6767351627,
0.1197277158,
0.5805174112,
0.6130207777,
0.4307399094,
0.2327349633,
0.2882245481,
0.0209034905,
0.0161856748,
0.153850168,
-0.2702940106,
-0.4948860407,
-0.598480165,
0.0923365504,
0.6294901967,
0.7108845115,
-0.4866930246,
0.0446051732,
-0.1653371304,
0.5491306782,
-0.3007976413,
0.1326723397,
-0.4302825332,
-0.2403224409,
-0.1901110709,
0.1160690486,
-0.3480898142,
-0.2140963972,
-0.1464831382,
-0.5015263557,
-0.1035616323,
0.0175609812,
0.5221028924,
0.1705392003,
-0.5001410842,
-0.3574357033,
-0.4171805978,
0.5601577163,
-0.8696722984,
0.7428572178,
0.3740367591,
0.4660880864,
0.0425991863,
-0.5985900164,
-0.2965227962,
-0.4191924632,
0.2421498299,
0.1164932251,
0.0239257179,
-0.1362991035,
-0.1949908137,
0.3221296966,
-0.6649928093,
0.3515323699,
-0.427842617,
-0.0648213178,
0.3892754316,
0.1429800689,
0.242720142,
0.0236497931,
-0.2342261523,
0.2782464921,
-0.8437500596,
-0.3552245498,
0.1522812694,
0.3286042809,
-0.2799448967,
0.7243867517,
0.0128260935,
0.6970915794,
-0.3308929801,
-0.3909135163,
0.3908646107,
-0.5011392832,
-0.2227805108,
-0.3221758604,
0.8494439721,
0.3198123276,
0.2825929523,
-0.0328965746,
0.1322819591,
-0.0677716881,
0.1430269778,
-0.8497551084,
-0.1205176562,
0.4806583524,
-0.6306633949,
-0.0460798182,
-0.5144703984,
-0.5779215693,
-0.2118320763,
-0.2081863582,
0.0731122494,
-0.4611326754,
-0.3985804617,
0.4251373112,
0.3198909461,
-0.0931670889,
0.2411306798,
-0.7597574592,
0.2290771902,
0.2870747149,
0.7210354209,
-0.4551829994,
-0.4805670977,
-0.2859376371,
0.2323006392,
-0.3854646981,
0.7673017383,
-0.4368596077,
-0.4082815349,
0.110417299,
0.1222481057,
-0.1726021618,
-0.6160905957,
0.4934314787,
-0.3685577512,
0.482082814,
-0.065820694,
-0.4370007813,
-0.0634005219,
0.3534654677,
-0.7400202751,
0.7810963988,
0.180305019,
-0.5389837623,
0.2016306072,
-0.9227836728,
-0.3542895615,
0.0794298127,
-0.2731150687,
-0.2737396061,
0.0618337356,
0.4571130574,
0.3424448967,
-0.5871105194,
0.5957146883,
-0.4440744221,
0.2878319323,
0.4157934189,
-0.4783336222,
0.7863467932,
0.2961693704,
0.1263306886,
0.0671240985,
-0.7699731588,
-0.204797104,
0.1459494233,
-0.5346944928,
-0.2715851367,
0.0958065763,
0.1110234112,
0.4554588199,
0.1966950446,
-0.6153120399,
0.1098142192,
-0.3770172298,
0.3718650937,
0.509709537,
-0.0526563153,
0.0013203799,
-0.3985325396,
0.7100672126,
0.1129045561,
0.1822814643,
-0.0977667272,
-0.6753513813,
-0.3288872838,
-0.6117479205,
0.5020996332,
0.5578854084,
-0.6780905128,
-0.087096341,
-0.0844790861,
-0.325604856,
-1.0430773497,
0.0460091978,
0.1896947473,
0.4499702454,
0.445617795,
-0.1595458835,
-0.4110257626,
-1.0201450586,
-0.2376255095,
-0.2927483916,
-0.0050457479,
0.4963449836,
0.4199292362,
-0.5452013612,
0.4676005244,
-0.4145283699,
-0.1362320781,
-0.0985668674,
-0.2808308303,
0.2677687407,
0.3114555478,
0.7874165773,
-0.5873999596,
-0.5605228543,
0.1505454034,
-0.6303281784,
-0.3650560081,
0.1809865981,
-0.0590253063,
0.3197251558,
0.5005133152,
-0.4505786598,
-0.123478815,
0.9688158035,
-0.2339992672,
0.8348968625,
-0.3926752508,
0.351690203,
-1.5109667778,
0.2199066877,
-0.1161521971,
-0.2166062444,
-0.574611485,
0.197400555,
0.2635204792,
-0.0400292762,
-0.6094315648,
0.8568016887,
-0.3960746527,
0.1851370782,
-0.1736819744,
0.0808882117,
-0.1171006113,
0.1076660007,
0.0758470893,
0.8145852685,
0.6112006307,
-0.4989465475,
0.2570347488,
0.1781278253,
-0.1902096868,
0.7073042393,
-0.5214992762,
-0.3642476797,
0.0141543848,
0.0634817407,
-0.7525396943,
-0.2846131325,
0.1501339227,
-0.494166702,
0.2348973751,
-0.095692046,
-0.5982335806,
-0.5215617418,
0.0123152277,
0.4218726456,
0.2317412943,
-0.4503501952,
0.414553225,
0.6040093899,
-0.5486087203,
-0.3675106466,
-0.7700369358,
0.1660899669,
-0.0941559747,
-0.4820369482,
0.187191844,
-0.6125046611,
-0.2327082008,
-0.1205111519,
0.3016667664,
-0.2610228658,
0.0883723199,
-0.1029244065,
0.437784344,
-0.6124444008,
0.4267841876,
0.0884978846,
-0.0267919935,
0.0566833839,
-0.3620080352,
0.468177557,
-0.0611391515,
-0.7328992486,
0.0316789895,
0.694745183,
0.7457008958,
-0.368645221,
0.6458176374,
0.2890457213,
-0.3192601204,
0.0248918235,
-0.5955542922,
0.133413434,
-0.3704384565,
0.543723762,
-0.4968481958,
-1.0964097977,
0.4786420166,
-0.0314487927,
0.212236166,
0.6116598845,
1.287607193,
0.1664175093,
0.878698647,
0.4933203161,
-0.0523283817,
0.009442932,
0.4637711346,
-0.1683140546,
-0.642529428,
0.0562636741,
-0.5413166881,
0.1700293273,
-0.6254748106,
-0.6579865813,
0.4984526634,
-0.1503987014,
-0.0294901263,
0.0878080204,
-0.277998507,
0.2003577054,
0.3845039904,
-0.0822781622,
0.3466639817,
-0.0957756042,
-0.8176414371,
-0.022870101,
-0.6063382626,
-0.4604417384,
1.5093686581,
0.4868957102,
0.6732294559,
0.3359024227,
0.3862393498,
-0.1281321347,
0.5974057913,
-0.6022939682,
0.1208862513,
-0.3405163586,
-0.9208180308,
0.0234766956,
-0.1914181113,
-1.06021595,
0.5312623978,
0.0628594533,
-0.3549673259,
-0.1310519278,
-0.0761968493,
-0.4348257482,
0.4045836031,
-0.6634456515,
0.7438946962,
-0.4229373038,
-0.24744232,
-0.0754679218,
-0.6038860679,
0.2723073959,
-0.4045046866,
0.5603430271,
-0.2121606916,
-0.2675946355,
0.5289009213,
-0.1543467641,
0.8007745147,
-0.0654961765,
-0.3397789001,
0.1110034436,
-0.1147188097,
-0.0917022973,
0.2886657417,
-0.2838657796,
0.3784043193,
0.0792402476,
-0.4337300062,
-0.0595970005,
0.8338919282,
-0.7413252592,
-0.5003023148,
-0.3495202363,
-0.7344898582,
-0.4901666641,
0.4240206182,
-0.1204102263,
0.3034359217,
-0.5329641104,
-0.0144901993,
0.3342096508,
-0.5190397501,
0.3653289676,
1.0536645651,
-0.4622528851,
-0.6489576101,
0.4485075474,
0.0235829204,
0.3215024173,
0.3993574679,
0.303245008,
-0.3137614727,
-0.764908731,
-0.7960362434,
0.6290058494,
-0.5604106784,
-0.1723853648,
-0.7812017202,
-0.1519634575,
-0.5848416686,
0.0187950172,
-0.3334887028,
-0.3008994758,
-0.2821854353,
-0.0681118295,
0.3632193208,
0.8343247175,
-0.1735302508,
0.0753461719,
-0.9174087644,
0.4052042067,
-0.0125579378,
0.780700326,
-0.3246890604,
-0.2687929571,
-0.3903673887,
0.1170609221,
-0.122253418,
-0.8613201976,
0.5053840876,
0.0843334049,
0.941942811,
0.1393557787,
-0.3484421372,
0.4047512114,
-0.9293211102,
0.804092288,
0.2608789206,
-0.4495965838,
0.3574098945,
-0.5422355533,
0.3773238659,
0.4424927533,
0.5233802199,
-0.6524864435,
-0.4671270549,
-0.3287439644,
-0.481285423,
0.4151861966,
-0.2491860986,
-0.1023633778,
-0.4043117166,
0.1822812259,
0.4480577111,
0.2740041316,
-0.8403832316,
-0.1182895377,
-0.0270588566,
-0.4067368507,
-0.3171134591,
-0.221097067,
-0.2394926995,
-0.032575354,
0.5846502781,
-0.4075447023,
0.2297484279,
0.1399258822,
-0.1305767149,
-0.0320021026,
0.4953061342,
0.7270243764,
0.4949072301,
0.0354294591,
-0.0893247053,
0.1034745649,
-0.5408850312,
0.2122529149,
0.4630979896,
0.0911971629,
0.025616372,
0.1409357041,
0.6907660961,
0.0261952039,
-0.7956594825,
0.3641569018,
-0.0908494666,
-0.2561983764,
-0.045846954,
-0.3429051936,
0.5034402609,
0.1786026806,
0.0676033869,
-0.1468321085,
-0.0692176446,
-0.2143166363,
0.3311110437,
0.3646600544,
-0.2144289762,
-0.3631673753,
0.8795931935,
0.1626202464,
0.0297198165,
0.2467788607,
0.1567853242,
-0.2439332455,
0.3833002448,
0.7781448364,
0.5221027732,
-0.6210413575,
0.019326238,
0.4601105154,
0.2970597148,
-0.1106904075,
0.4763575494,
0.4828133285,
-0.4922704697,
-0.5612545013,
-0.62990731,
-0.331043452,
0.0799150988,
-0.3792743087,
0.2621938884,
-0.0547289811,
-0.1960765272,
0.1256877631,
-0.2061062902,
-0.5905284286,
0.1980813742,
0.1372433305,
0.9540244341,
-0.6361998916,
1.1662633419,
0.7623371482,
-0.4322294891,
-0.5205911994,
-0.3483510613,
-0.0407455079,
-1.0983014107,
0.4230907261,
-0.0724947751,
0.1579039842,
-0.1819865257,
-0.2942930758,
-1.0298676491,
0.8482506275,
0.4182812572,
-0.5000549555,
-0.165404588,
0.2637877464,
0.596144855,
-0.6676949263,
0.192156747,
0.2853958905,
0.3065058291,
-0.2372476161,
-1.3052406311,
-0.1276813149,
-0.2225705534,
-0.2333358973,
0.1779071838,
-0.5199849606,
1.1169861555,
-0.3188220859,
0.0872430131,
0.2749015689,
0.2624109685,
0.377491951,
-0.1794926226,
0.1147884056,
0.4463631511,
0.6388178468,
0.1202024072,
1.2029783726,
-0.6274187565,
0.1560701281,
1.0979391336,
-0.5398738384,
1.0529979467,
0.5116768479,
-0.3332759738,
0.3679098189,
0.5796396732,
0.0382159539,
0.3246554434,
0.1630236953,
-0.2265525758,
0.0210508406,
-0.0177876521,
-0.5448809266,
0.2973201275,
0.541028738,
-0.5373033285,
-0.2123362422,
0.265576452,
0.1720158756,
-0.0500760749,
-0.2070388198,
0.7632706165,
0.1350926906,
-0.7717571259,
0.6573939323,
0.205398947,
0.5418554544,
-0.7891019583,
0.2408416569,
-0.1177739054,
0.2031240314,
0.034242034,
-0.6497814059,
0.2605301738,
-0.0851241723,
-0.2334382832,
-0.011432563,
0.5251232982,
-0.7548416853,
-0.6865069866,
0.5057260394,
0.9618751407,
0.1583401263,
0.190819025,
-0.752992034,
-0.1457623541,
0.0094629144,
-0.0846488848,
0.4692234397,
0.3919551373,
-0.1903995723,
0.6838951707,
0.7768210769,
0.5064352155,
0.1153931841,
0.3166827261,
0.66808182,
-0.5113153458,
-0.4282381237,
-0.8469288945,
0.3437974453,
0.2678706348,
-0.3140928149,
0.5890106559,
0.6197507977,
0.7438954115,
-0.2646152675,
0.9462844133,
0.1784734577,
0.9580817223,
-0.3932411671,
0.8200132251,
-0.808950603,
-0.0168336742,
0.0081430357,
-0.3618614674,
-0.6198384166,
0.2056560367,
-0.0308962613,
0.0060294424,
0.9154806137,
0.6411813498,
0.0188661907,
-0.2020369172,
0.4788937867,
0.3000395298,
0.3229680061,
0.5509714484,
0.4852311015,
-0.2348584682,
0.3906097412,
0.108329922,
-0.2515264153,
-0.1151226237,
-0.831999898,
-0.6914578676,
-0.4783557057,
-0.3156188726,
-0.2754444182,
-0.0703126043,
0.9652267694,
0.5642086267,
-1.0174798965,
-0.4598287046,
0.3669695556,
-0.2341063768,
-0.1890131384,
-0.0832323581,
0.3394655287,
-0.181717813,
-0.5931375027,
0.5127295256,
0.4564382732,
0.1716509312,
-0.3761239052,
-0.1091022864,
-0.594435513,
0.1035569981,
0.7362513542,
0.1166853383,
-0.8601497412,
0.0038907698,
0.2104247659,
-0.3482055962,
0.4335754812,
0.7030922174,
-0.4995660484,
0.4822518528,
-0.0380261652,
0.730037868,
0.1127366871,
-0.3658418357,
0.7245696187,
-0.3339537382,
-0.0237101037,
0.2809478641,
0.6979907155,
0.4507493675,
0.0639738739,
0.5546342731,
0.1196465045,
-0.4903049767,
-0.6137151122,
0.1944020838,
-0.642906487,
-0.6102977395,
1.383035779,
-0.013525499,
-0.103481181,
-0.2762607932,
-0.3692481518,
0.243806988,
-0.1519760042,
0.4260405898,
0.8564415574,
-0.0774518028,
-0.0101996036,
-0.9934580326,
0.2549384832,
0.2710204124,
-1.1592026949,
0.1234805956,
0.5988446474,
0.5206041336,
0.0019551432,
1.1011505127,
-0.6402904987,
0.2419552803,
-0.1590459347,
0.2524131238,
0.1127754524,
-0.1335829496,
-0.4508736134,
0.235281691,
0.3751612008,
-0.052433569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13956v2
|
Can You Learn Semantics Through Next-Word Prediction? The Case of Entailment
| 2024-02-21T17:36:07 | 2024-02-29T22:18:03 |
William Merrill, Zhaofeng Wu, Norihito Naka, Yoon Kim, Tal Linzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Do LMs infer the semantics of text from co-occurrence patterns in their
training data? Merrill et al. (2022) argue that, in theory, probabilities
predicted by an optimal LM encode semantic information about entailment
relations, but it is unclear whether neural LMs trained on corpora learn
entailment in this way because of strong idealizing assumptions made by Merrill
et al. In this work, we investigate whether their theory can be used to decode
entailment judgments from neural LMs. We find that a test similar to theirs can
decode entailment relations between natural sentences, well above random
chance, though not perfectly, across many datasets and LMs. This suggests LMs
implicitly model aspects of semantics to predict semantic effects on sentence
co-occurrence patterns. However, we find the test that predicts entailment in
practice works in the opposite direction to the theoretical test. We thus
revisit the assumptions underlying the original test, finding its derivation
did not adequately account for redundancy in human-written text. We argue that
correctly accounting for redundancy related to explanations might derive the
observed flipped test and, more generally, improve linguistic theories of human
speakers.
|
[
-0.1943319291,
-0.6661061645,
0.7873046398,
-0.0103576509,
-0.1039002538,
-0.406295985,
-0.0953799486,
-0.701562345,
0.3469390273,
0.607888341,
-0.7590005994,
-0.4787010252,
-0.3811069429,
0.2867040932,
-0.6090004444,
0.5522576571,
0.0362092368,
0.036432229,
-0.6919593215,
0.1906035691,
-0.5008938313,
-0.4487395585,
-0.4181463122,
-0.6317981482,
0.3646694422,
0.3701549768,
0.6866227388,
0.4048660696,
0.2220294327,
0.2058838904,
0.0609996468,
-0.0304462593,
-0.2934125364,
-0.0027045917,
0.168037042,
-0.7614482641,
-0.0474675708,
0.2352869958,
0.3116805851,
0.9868103266,
-0.1737641394,
-0.2098256648,
0.0712548271,
0.3833632469,
-0.6252527237,
0.1287158132,
-0.9860332608,
0.1986254305,
0.0536643602,
-0.6046772599,
-0.7010489702,
-0.2663259208,
0.5003153086,
-0.604775548,
0.1973999292,
0.4121312499,
0.9540547132,
0.1152701899,
-0.1861483008,
-0.4259109795,
-0.3328361511,
0.668573916,
-0.5647857785,
0.6566303372,
0.8599517345,
0.0431972668,
-0.3891400993,
-0.6504679322,
-0.8340114355,
-0.5053153038,
-0.3696354926,
0.3082351685,
0.0861292034,
0.0392527767,
0.0490323715,
0.1104703471,
-0.4596707821,
-0.0149913142,
-0.2724248767,
-0.1579802632,
0.4608847499,
0.1957153678,
0.324968189,
0.0292681139,
-0.4995817244,
0.1548020095,
-0.9459952116,
-0.0911682323,
0.3223028779,
0.0824113488,
0.0037257904,
0.6973662376,
-0.0477130525,
0.6445358396,
0.0473844372,
0.1333007812,
0.399671942,
-0.2327504009,
-0.2222863883,
0.393717736,
0.4819122851,
0.2539180815,
0.5586060882,
-0.5722798705,
0.049778156,
0.2555475831,
0.3233295381,
-0.3606532812,
-0.2407451719,
0.2515725791,
-0.3846731484,
-0.2002234012,
0.136420086,
-0.3487792909,
-0.2607053518,
-0.5252519846,
0.4700363874,
-0.7197961211,
-0.0784301758,
0.5657926202,
-0.2185338289,
0.2763389349,
0.14602907,
-0.8118515611,
0.5155982971,
0.9720271826,
0.6060203314,
-0.1573361158,
-0.7256441712,
-0.4746626019,
0.1002948061,
-0.4782505035,
0.6131955385,
-0.721170783,
-0.0747208297,
0.2736439109,
0.0718546361,
-0.2605874538,
-0.4197378457,
0.4662397206,
-0.7448288798,
0.2415326238,
-0.0925905928,
-0.9127418995,
-0.302927196,
0.2548952103,
-0.3001942635,
0.4485975504,
-0.3769312501,
-0.8973443508,
0.6391176581,
-0.2930765152,
-0.5017681122,
-0.0989762917,
-0.2678733468,
-0.2678228915,
0.2475661933,
-0.1829975098,
0.4535376132,
0.0317025222,
0.2924022973,
-0.4986337423,
-0.4774237573,
0.4206110537,
-0.176014021,
0.5846556425,
-0.2096132785,
-0.2194989175,
-0.2029524446,
-0.77514112,
0.014725442,
-0.0107499762,
-0.1605625749,
-0.5474410057,
0.2714649141,
-0.5321208239,
-0.0310174897,
0.0890450701,
-0.8033257723,
-0.4235971272,
-0.8245646358,
0.1112416908,
0.637080133,
-0.0299375355,
0.6673361063,
-0.1138797998,
0.1151314452,
-0.0142489392,
-0.185668081,
-0.1439588517,
-0.4703976512,
-0.8068056107,
0.2246671468,
0.078543596,
0.5060693622,
-0.4040694833,
0.38438043,
-0.2064659595,
-0.0930291191,
-0.3560186327,
-0.0797948241,
0.3577228189,
0.2902636528,
0.4582815468,
-0.0791417211,
-0.8353672624,
-0.9151940346,
-0.7705289721,
-0.1898586601,
0.19443883,
-0.102400288,
0.5935462713,
-0.1170698777,
0.9519398808,
-0.5262385011,
-0.1863364577,
-0.0909662843,
0.0879716352,
0.1437775642,
0.2311238348,
0.1394441575,
-0.6689265966,
-0.1517498493,
-0.1139518619,
-0.6822358966,
0.1450010538,
0.0549668968,
-0.1193627119,
0.3874434531,
0.8880397081,
-0.5543623567,
0.4295246899,
0.4320607781,
-0.5042048097,
0.4863529205,
-0.4440691769,
-0.4497308433,
-0.8816993833,
-0.6229860783,
-0.0666074753,
0.0364287831,
-0.5051193237,
-0.2065040618,
0.0797053427,
0.4299594164,
-0.0472246408,
0.2999895513,
-0.5201229453,
-0.2041886002,
-0.3355199695,
0.0116613153,
-0.1866636276,
0.3237347901,
0.415089041,
0.2759117782,
0.3339111507,
-0.8270566463,
-0.0895880014,
0.1789546311,
-0.5707169175,
0.1406494528,
-0.4681851566,
-0.0053022266,
-0.3151840568,
0.1803652942,
-0.8085296154,
-0.1930101365,
-0.0410843678,
-0.7300081849,
0.1285297275,
0.1736017317,
-0.4260033369,
-0.181211412,
-0.078435868,
-0.0960491374,
0.6586255431,
-0.6824280024,
0.3248950541,
0.3804481328,
0.248113513,
-0.6629149914,
-0.9120545983,
-0.0024596797,
-0.1695287824,
-0.3599017859,
0.2843248844,
0.2341433913,
-0.4801772237,
0.0757593587,
0.1026812792,
0.0378824435,
0.142713204,
0.4553772211,
0.2414980531,
-0.0517572053,
0.526111722,
-0.1362668723,
-0.2177857459,
0.512897253,
-0.5622671843,
0.5586090684,
-0.0354050919,
-0.325017482,
-0.1905087829,
0.1812237203,
0.1417232156,
0.0200042054,
0.8557090759,
0.3765666187,
-0.6504435539,
-0.1409095526,
-0.3681689203,
-0.340357691,
-0.4122588336,
0.5693401098,
-0.5406061411,
-0.6164789796,
0.1554991454,
0.2185320407,
0.0900219306,
0.4405043423,
0.2864899635,
-0.4740626216,
0.7878061533,
0.7962973118,
0.3643576503,
0.1647305936,
-0.277105242,
0.1655874103,
-0.5511289835,
-0.3657466173,
-0.2612953186,
-0.0664929152,
-0.817956686,
-0.0595662408,
0.1312901378,
0.0870737657,
-0.3461140096,
0.3699460924,
0.0003756004,
0.597441256,
0.4232119024,
0.1721886694,
0.3596826196,
0.1957378983,
-0.0849557668,
-0.2224087715,
-0.6212406158,
-0.37174353,
0.9307700992,
0.1470468342,
0.3563066721,
0.0233343523,
0.9727707505,
-0.0538296811,
0.2896126807,
-0.8183987141,
0.6209729314,
-0.1545652449,
-0.2560734153,
-0.1974081844,
-0.1498727649,
-1.1180013418,
0.2986716032,
-0.3882512748,
-0.7920016646,
0.2853372991,
0.0906805769,
-0.0699554905,
0.1141441539,
-0.7504339218,
0.6403104663,
-0.0499176085,
-0.2573460937,
-0.3060497642,
-0.5486029387,
0.3454755247,
0.0392573737,
0.1939645112,
-0.0935674235,
-0.2999130189,
0.7765167952,
-0.4128231406,
0.9868241549,
0.0468346104,
-0.1569059789,
0.3352866769,
0.2527861297,
0.4385796487,
0.0404052027,
-0.0978946909,
-0.0674195811,
-0.1147397161,
-0.2122961879,
-0.6730558276,
0.5812036991,
-0.6562663317,
-0.5378588438,
-0.3586054742,
-0.4416826367,
-0.4006080627,
0.032783825,
0.5053389668,
0.3854052424,
-0.1851398051,
-0.1220301092,
0.5405136943,
-0.0137608647,
0.348620683,
0.4700260758,
-0.0242477488,
-0.1624455005,
0.9531828761,
0.0522238649,
0.3669025302,
0.5527867675,
0.3104192019,
-0.4094389677,
-0.6783620715,
0.1874501705,
0.1716394871,
-0.8490213156,
0.1097210646,
-0.8274185658,
0.025725387,
-0.1634190083,
-0.1633272022,
-0.1064963564,
-0.2572398782,
-0.2442341447,
-0.3062770367,
0.4110416174,
0.7525162697,
0.1149098352,
0.0266515296,
-0.5757097602,
0.0188622661,
0.0788815394,
0.2312536389,
-0.0435570925,
-0.6088977456,
-0.0628031492,
0.1467360854,
-0.0575480908,
-0.8496652842,
0.502696991,
0.2893868089,
0.4149624109,
0.2681872845,
0.0228623599,
0.6353949308,
-0.7156926394,
0.5422586203,
0.3540657461,
-0.6764824986,
0.4117736816,
-0.1050503254,
0.1031286716,
0.4206358492,
0.5759844184,
-0.5101115704,
-0.5420828462,
-0.8671850562,
-0.5636838675,
0.5409466028,
-0.0546037778,
0.3220562935,
-0.3491895795,
0.4365533888,
0.5604305267,
-0.0707264245,
-0.5083116293,
-0.1382922381,
0.0820793808,
-0.3186133802,
-0.4457848966,
-0.4253217876,
0.0987901464,
-0.314319551,
0.609089911,
-0.1497354656,
0.2985160947,
0.2173332423,
-0.2147685736,
0.1942217797,
0.140740484,
0.4618252516,
0.7101049423,
-0.2910656333,
0.3472355902,
0.3914707601,
-0.5463980436,
-0.1649208516,
-0.2184341401,
-0.3624353409,
0.2152112871,
0.6859357357,
0.7247105241,
0.3090079725,
-0.4933031201,
0.4125341177,
0.1292857528,
-0.4305578768,
-0.9470902085,
-0.09628506,
0.4072669446,
0.13885355,
0.1160860434,
0.1571127176,
0.1507769227,
-0.9156053066,
0.3569839597,
0.394642055,
-0.4913361967,
-0.3804875016,
0.3858244121,
-0.0665471554,
-0.2841904461,
0.3299041688,
-0.1873190105,
-0.6236629486,
0.7406017184,
0.6758582592,
0.9642992616,
0.2808130085,
0.0229476858,
0.495962888,
0.295971036,
-0.3194999993,
0.2389048338,
0.0830662772,
-1.1333762407,
-0.36664325,
-0.6073755622,
-0.3728616536,
-0.0238827262,
-0.4972698689,
0.3561968803,
-0.0938947871,
0.1352967024,
0.0428332053,
-0.2106876224,
-0.4851686954,
0.1965301782,
0.2143227756,
0.8084610701,
-0.5404750705,
0.632253468,
0.5839661956,
-0.3504718542,
-0.655138135,
0.4028808177,
-0.1908773035,
-0.9717250466,
0.8130609393,
0.263993293,
-0.1871143281,
-0.1105684415,
-0.568157196,
-0.8601370454,
0.8943734169,
0.2454903126,
-0.3320715427,
0.0273307245,
0.0387931131,
0.5127334595,
-0.6245700121,
0.3509059846,
0.7542155385,
0.2663887441,
0.0366037637,
-0.6312940717,
0.002336995,
0.0365847945,
-0.1068431884,
0.0590155385,
-0.0487937741,
0.9336082339,
-0.7236225605,
-0.3253046572,
0.065073356,
0.8689386845,
0.0234886482,
0.5374699235,
0.4309353232,
0.5323357582,
0.6649764776,
-0.0817631111,
1.3804951906,
-0.0489283353,
0.2285756022,
1.3970849514,
-0.1006992534,
1.1958967447,
0.4994555414,
-0.2332258075,
0.642000854,
0.7872896194,
0.4808604419,
0.7032818198,
0.2903337181,
0.0066502187,
-0.3199087381,
0.0130738346,
-0.3505978286,
0.6904423237,
0.5053982735,
-0.4699217975,
-0.0339152068,
-0.2368495017,
-0.0863333568,
0.3133380413,
-0.3029430807,
0.9301967025,
0.2340000123,
-0.8549149632,
0.6661948562,
-0.1337123215,
0.8547495008,
-0.3714667559,
-0.0774966106,
-0.0736380741,
0.536920011,
-0.3098147213,
-0.8204467893,
0.4221723676,
-0.5351107717,
-0.0841373801,
-0.0227376428,
0.8997887373,
-0.7212460637,
-0.3764204979,
0.3852002919,
0.5216540694,
0.2832479179,
0.0780769512,
-0.1965484768,
-0.3914245367,
-0.1892035902,
-0.0627548546,
0.3368406296,
0.3352040946,
0.0157218203,
0.5970749855,
0.5137069821,
0.0951908305,
0.2630324364,
0.0391751565,
0.3402789533,
-0.5131559968,
-0.5323947668,
-0.9660564661,
0.0495384336,
-0.0566591136,
-0.1357088089,
0.6221472621,
0.3525768816,
1.2700549364,
-0.1397438496,
0.7923910618,
0.3496400714,
0.3541910648,
-0.7505012751,
0.4505403042,
-0.5408520699,
0.0478096418,
0.0265332051,
-0.6524339318,
-0.1114171743,
0.5054228902,
-0.5645350814,
-0.1847059876,
1.0617170334,
0.6334943175,
0.1470301598,
0.6678618789,
0.3444368541,
0.2299617231,
-0.3151795566,
0.5184955001,
0.9984610677,
-0.4307335615,
0.334790796,
-0.2369389981,
0.1972763687,
-0.0473574437,
-0.5532129407,
-0.8059493303,
-0.6812044382,
-0.1447371542,
-0.5741288066,
0.237356618,
0.8871828914,
0.1362733841,
-0.6848870516,
-0.2409757078,
-0.709022522,
0.1009856984,
-0.141059801,
-0.1842232049,
0.2965664566,
-0.5042527914,
-0.6391447783,
0.1575139165,
0.1178624034,
0.025806712,
-0.0814679191,
-0.4137963951,
-0.366096586,
0.0920556709,
0.7256608009,
0.0275960267,
-0.8636336923,
-0.4778054953,
0.0680908933,
-0.0316446163,
-0.1592049748,
0.7920961976,
-0.8284350634,
0.2959307432,
0.593691051,
0.6180321574,
0.2358444035,
-0.3212530613,
0.8364235759,
-0.4224601984,
0.1513414234,
0.1827927232,
0.5596598387,
0.0924897268,
-0.2710015178,
0.5321885943,
0.3761759996,
0.0890056565,
-0.7056051493,
0.474922657,
-0.558414042,
-0.2028414905,
1.3145424128,
-0.1306188107,
-0.3539055586,
-0.3225095868,
0.2491561025,
0.1848027706,
-0.0334454477,
0.521479547,
0.6811914444,
-0.2016227692,
-0.1541990638,
-0.6719864607,
0.6091189981,
0.8260537982,
-0.6414702535,
-0.0239836909,
0.1836513281,
0.2582435608,
0.2745315433,
0.5594215989,
0.026346352,
0.3975024819,
0.2022199035,
-0.0618086681,
-0.1220585108,
-0.1828702986,
-0.1031786203,
-0.0405180082,
-0.1879116595,
-0.4633298814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13954v1
|
Measuring Social Biases in Masked Language Models by Proxy of Prediction Quality
| 2024-02-21T17:33:13 | 2024-02-21T17:33:13 |
Rahul Zalkikar, Kanchan Chandra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social and political scientists often aim to discover and measure distinct
biases from text data representations (embeddings). Innovative
transformer-based language models produce contextually-aware token embeddings
and have achieved state-of-the-art performance for a variety of natural
language tasks, but have been shown to encode unwanted biases for downstream
applications. In this paper, we evaluate the social biases encoded by
transformers trained with the masked language modeling objective using proposed
proxy functions within an iterative masking experiment to measure the quality
of transformer models' predictions, and assess the preference of MLMs towards
disadvantaged and advantaged groups. We compare bias estimations with those
produced by other evaluation methods using two benchmark datasets, finding
relatively high religious and disability biases across considered MLMs and low
gender bias in one dataset relative to the other. Our measures outperform
others in their agreement with human annotators. We extend on previous work by
evaluating social biases introduced after re-training an MLM under the masked
language modeling objective (w.r.t. the model's pre-trained base), and find
that proposed measures produce more accurate estimations of relative preference
for biased sentences between transformers than others based on our methods.
|
[
-0.3878119588,
-0.425255239,
0.2707829773,
0.2676288486,
-0.1763811409,
0.3855319321,
-0.2224458456,
-0.1925249994,
0.6393530369,
0.5690434575,
-0.2068290263,
-0.4560402334,
-1.1429407597,
-0.0840448737,
-0.4546622038,
0.7912123203,
0.0325067677,
0.462464273,
-0.3091878593,
-0.1240441501,
-0.3396696746,
-0.6061213017,
-0.3045190275,
-0.4997065067,
0.1894288063,
0.0436321832,
0.9827629328,
0.5680807829,
0.1157395169,
0.2455638498,
-0.0994644165,
-0.062072657,
-0.518214643,
-0.0839406922,
-0.2383588105,
-0.3455224931,
-0.1445132196,
0.4239872694,
0.5633435845,
0.8593212962,
0.2484262735,
0.5392770767,
0.3376614749,
0.4797627926,
-0.7983999848,
0.301274091,
-0.8178745508,
0.2742730379,
-0.0081795612,
-0.0166832805,
-0.4536224902,
-0.4672210515,
0.1170461997,
-0.1314397156,
0.5568687916,
0.1801208258,
0.7344500422,
0.3221904635,
-0.4640362263,
-0.1802355498,
-0.6040253639,
0.8966834545,
-0.5059294701,
0.6246722937,
0.6302005649,
0.3667370677,
-0.0302077327,
-0.6001446843,
-0.4650361538,
-0.2074096799,
-0.2545922399,
0.0354170874,
-0.0919322148,
-0.0912819505,
0.2480142564,
0.147362873,
-0.1046983749,
-0.0551955402,
-0.3119406998,
-0.2996838093,
0.6017032862,
-0.0600057207,
-0.065585278,
-0.441976279,
-0.2098471075,
-0.1448322535,
-0.6109839082,
0.1189134717,
0.6770030856,
0.2310025394,
-0.0285688154,
0.5955004096,
-0.2078712732,
0.2557687163,
0.0691392571,
0.1802326292,
0.3089950085,
-0.0408010073,
-0.1008589268,
-0.0121479258,
0.5856029391,
0.6224597692,
0.5857306123,
-0.2936168313,
-0.3118197918,
0.4285131991,
0.2205301672,
-0.5213519931,
0.0426973701,
-0.1250701547,
-0.7899183631,
-0.4097575545,
0.2220737785,
-0.8546199799,
-0.6113677025,
-0.2394666672,
0.278659761,
0.210576728,
-0.3091026545,
0.1589713991,
-0.3579187989,
0.032125067,
-0.0295285471,
-0.7775027156,
0.4147682786,
0.7093241811,
0.6537617445,
-0.2774326801,
-0.0503777154,
-0.7460637093,
-0.1014263481,
-0.2459870279,
0.5365948677,
-0.8000516891,
-0.3184627593,
0.4308385849,
0.1004485115,
-0.0368941575,
-0.552601397,
0.6684495211,
-0.4109840393,
0.0329963304,
-0.4877831936,
-0.5108259916,
0.2068988681,
0.0760286227,
-0.619672358,
1.0426490307,
0.0841963962,
-0.6970360875,
0.7978192568,
-0.3867702484,
-0.280923605,
-0.2204004228,
-0.1726706475,
-0.4823639691,
0.2032243311,
0.3106596172,
0.6040697694,
-0.2412734628,
0.6465283632,
-0.5781977177,
-0.5161685348,
0.4376892745,
-0.5619441271,
0.7312159538,
-0.16313833,
-0.818008244,
0.1791130453,
-0.5418580174,
-0.3304302096,
-0.0102021592,
0.0774588659,
-0.4153351486,
0.2290513515,
0.0368662439,
0.3045667708,
-0.1960149109,
-0.7514848113,
-0.3536884785,
-0.2994263172,
0.383610189,
1.1491481066,
-0.3140634596,
0.6309239268,
-0.151943028,
0.3617102802,
-0.0368774571,
0.5116103888,
0.1828635186,
-0.6261898279,
-0.861466229,
-0.0175744705,
0.412057817,
0.1841272563,
-0.6969228983,
0.2883680165,
-0.1823652685,
-0.2567970753,
-0.7173272371,
-0.0011834537,
0.323605299,
0.1351712346,
0.3621063232,
-0.2943332195,
-0.4294209182,
-1.1145472527,
-0.7374364138,
-0.088289611,
-0.3520100415,
0.3115319014,
0.6876405478,
-0.4109385014,
0.9236993194,
-0.3039746881,
-0.1880489588,
-0.0078115501,
0.0136736436,
-0.0825531408,
0.2707169354,
0.3352715969,
-0.6552997828,
-0.4106504023,
-0.4265020788,
-0.3357893527,
-0.2919197679,
0.19377473,
-0.0773880854,
0.0669795647,
0.1767796874,
-0.3712348342,
0.541328311,
0.7022371292,
-0.450014472,
0.5309829116,
0.3560755849,
0.12675336,
-0.8879585266,
-0.1423273385,
0.1912577003,
-0.2972022593,
-0.6440027952,
-0.4041895568,
0.0526002236,
0.284596473,
-0.3672766387,
0.7309369445,
-0.5244067311,
-0.2923147678,
-0.1629969031,
0.1797432452,
0.007858552,
0.3159114122,
0.0212022532,
0.3998308182,
0.44953385,
-0.2122482806,
0.0270232502,
0.0160296969,
-0.3485921025,
0.1694631726,
-0.6626621485,
0.2934432924,
-0.2805350721,
0.2068597227,
-0.8877461553,
-0.0425010137,
0.2681612372,
-0.4968287647,
0.1211756244,
-0.0401864052,
-0.3038594723,
-0.342256695,
-0.4843277633,
0.2988338768,
0.5555589199,
-0.563229382,
0.5453881621,
0.7044699192,
0.2997665703,
-0.8818821311,
-0.5060399771,
0.0548991449,
-0.2372715622,
-0.4201695621,
0.4449882805,
0.406637013,
-0.374658078,
0.1310497522,
-0.177080974,
0.1948022991,
-0.1186851636,
0.4511417449,
0.1244827136,
-0.0384511054,
-0.0578229837,
0.2646552026,
-0.2504393756,
0.3264554441,
-0.1384854317,
0.5494577885,
0.0206761435,
-0.5767372251,
0.1130951419,
0.2721914351,
0.3545459211,
-0.1180929467,
0.9145185947,
0.6470268965,
-0.479862541,
-0.1192090213,
-1.050888896,
-0.5228660703,
-0.435358882,
0.2218544036,
-0.0473954976,
-1.1373972893,
0.7129984498,
0.0753092319,
-0.0718291551,
0.3726597726,
0.3551782966,
0.2576146424,
1.2226874828,
0.5365739465,
-0.194598183,
0.4344724119,
-0.1126240939,
0.3123937249,
-0.7062513232,
-0.1953347921,
-0.7266077995,
-0.1556590796,
-0.819796741,
-0.5447545052,
0.1911996752,
-0.0620735548,
-0.331141293,
0.1055217907,
-0.4399756789,
0.2983360589,
0.6351407766,
0.1291587949,
0.0277620126,
0.1299300194,
-0.0216754936,
-0.1390387863,
-0.5412887335,
-0.9340145588,
1.1844177246,
0.6428436041,
0.5848731399,
-0.437979579,
0.4183876514,
0.5356867313,
0.7999000549,
-0.4244630933,
0.3717933595,
-0.1487893164,
-0.6522844434,
-0.2016741037,
-0.2959627211,
-0.5849502683,
0.3069964051,
-0.2920292318,
-0.7426784039,
0.3801591396,
0.1672523171,
0.1393008381,
0.4021060467,
-0.5105075836,
0.8584870696,
0.1128773242,
-0.4496194422,
-0.0102724517,
-0.6220460534,
0.2718006074,
0.0418889038,
0.134849146,
-0.1874127984,
0.1332197785,
0.8830703497,
-0.0895486474,
1.0002703667,
-0.350641489,
0.1476882547,
-0.0515260138,
-0.218271926,
0.4684366882,
-0.0247460604,
-0.4045016468,
0.7191745639,
-0.1415319443,
-0.5382198095,
-0.5976688266,
0.4038539231,
-0.7050087452,
-0.8315241337,
-0.2835977077,
-0.1941605955,
-0.1875654161,
-0.0757846683,
0.1329764128,
0.2879403234,
-0.2047562301,
0.2854872942,
0.3796810508,
-0.4266091585,
0.2969135642,
0.2292032242,
-0.1227809414,
-0.2320611626,
0.4540060759,
0.2118283212,
0.4659125805,
0.1413516998,
0.3547270298,
-0.3926375806,
-0.1485098302,
-0.5028259158,
0.0205749888,
-0.6716159582,
-0.1742903292,
-0.8034152985,
-0.2407723665,
-0.411159873,
-0.1685119271,
-0.5506080985,
-0.2643239498,
0.0437337868,
-0.2069586813,
-0.0505020022,
0.6594995856,
0.0246233065,
0.1772843748,
-0.3060429692,
0.2385991365,
0.1014084294,
0.4486359954,
-0.0437919982,
-0.3883033097,
-0.2380946726,
0.3092043698,
-0.2113033831,
-1.0575374365,
0.2716718614,
-0.1990394294,
0.6205063462,
0.4247494936,
0.1629933119,
0.3640198708,
-0.5263897181,
0.8954313993,
-0.023395,
-1.1059919596,
0.3230931759,
0.0323421247,
-0.0795471892,
0.3305307925,
0.3343198895,
-0.478954196,
-0.8566604853,
-0.4236237705,
-0.5317664742,
0.4496353567,
0.3547600508,
0.5248297453,
-0.2787153125,
0.3414085805,
0.2983456254,
0.4197003841,
-0.8975669742,
-0.6086913347,
-0.5621851683,
0.0947573781,
-0.11354094,
-0.477578491,
0.1606949419,
-0.2583253384,
0.6133264899,
-0.1435245425,
0.4081120789,
0.0355455093,
-0.054381337,
-0.1665081382,
0.1913467795,
0.4478180408,
0.608825326,
-0.1978454888,
0.4189139307,
0.2485541701,
-0.4906622469,
0.2445096374,
0.0200968124,
-0.3133625686,
0.443251729,
0.2097243071,
0.8920863867,
-0.026274113,
-0.301709801,
0.6502040625,
-0.009148987,
0.1457348019,
-0.2723391056,
-0.1046737656,
-0.0357820578,
0.1942315847,
0.4608659744,
0.1374088228,
0.2297347784,
-0.3785511851,
0.1107456088,
0.8034140468,
-0.7415001392,
-0.3178216517,
0.7537052035,
0.1248597652,
-0.5829023719,
0.1169835776,
-0.1440087259,
-0.8038413525,
0.5454847813,
0.4909425676,
1.1306728125,
-0.4569800198,
0.5000574589,
0.2317179888,
0.789747715,
-0.0570242256,
-0.1542484909,
0.0629075617,
-1.021199584,
-0.3815276921,
-0.7522480488,
-0.2515630126,
0.0678374469,
-0.732625246,
0.2092973739,
0.0112786032,
-0.4419591427,
-0.0983974487,
-0.2139544785,
-0.8933316469,
0.0014528416,
-0.2284104675,
0.6502614617,
-1.2316548824,
0.6052352786,
0.3914061785,
-0.1321753114,
-0.4074062109,
0.2595118284,
-0.1346456558,
-0.836509347,
0.7171462774,
0.3982726932,
-0.2299399674,
-0.3425900042,
-0.276385963,
-0.6983036995,
0.6294105053,
0.560565114,
-0.3166128695,
0.1561864913,
0.7954293489,
0.4601013958,
-0.5484677553,
0.4915073514,
0.5838319063,
0.3581706285,
-0.3786718845,
-0.7876319885,
0.2310694158,
-0.2068825662,
0.2994490266,
0.0517713316,
-0.388963908,
0.5797576308,
0.293266803,
-0.1468471289,
-0.4607690871,
0.4911565185,
-0.1005054414,
0.4914939404,
0.6713302732,
0.0175365489,
0.3930051327,
-0.1862491667,
1.0112079382,
-0.3954016864,
0.3811102509,
0.8311888576,
-0.3817895949,
0.5046488047,
0.5404586196,
-0.0280595142,
0.3441292048,
0.5732552409,
0.2620148361,
0.4455352128,
0.4674659669,
-0.1806906313,
-0.0545599572,
-0.3827954829,
-0.192525506,
0.197646603,
0.0779911652,
-0.7035803199,
0.0992466882,
0.0988288224,
-0.010019483,
0.2229341716,
-0.1983254999,
0.5291876793,
0.1418952495,
-0.6369547248,
0.2744252384,
0.1205560714,
0.7859059572,
-0.1684680879,
0.0251274854,
-0.3978539407,
-0.0215326399,
-0.0851334929,
-0.6023293734,
0.466042757,
-0.0000670114,
-0.2136464119,
-0.379468739,
0.9628982544,
-0.3493988812,
-0.565315485,
0.6139066219,
0.5236061215,
-0.0382016674,
-0.2040149719,
-0.562122345,
0.1895433813,
-0.1128094718,
-0.2871988416,
0.1902967244,
-0.0511551052,
-0.173015818,
0.6011452675,
0.5409417748,
0.0816727951,
0.3672410846,
0.4594300091,
0.7924393415,
-0.4480215907,
-0.2388188392,
-1.0905146599,
0.5070672035,
-0.3900697827,
-0.1085482687,
0.8560576439,
0.5357260108,
0.9232677817,
-0.0191856455,
0.6386055946,
0.4574494362,
0.2985438704,
-0.2779912949,
0.7386359572,
-0.2367205322,
0.173269704,
-0.6808156371,
-1.1960319281,
-0.0558681265,
0.6092927456,
-0.4766211808,
0.2217355669,
0.4210655987,
1.0192998648,
-0.2059437484,
0.1919072121,
0.3163954914,
-0.0373371951,
0.2869482338,
0.0384607688,
0.8358809352,
-0.4606621861,
-0.0250219051,
-0.3528948426,
-0.3200457096,
-0.043903932,
-0.877733767,
-1.2855949402,
-0.6384786963,
-0.2420688272,
-0.5998701453,
0.2105993032,
1.0061979294,
0.6605277061,
-0.7913624048,
-0.2834644914,
0.2114953548,
0.4466174841,
-0.2074866444,
-0.2631471753,
0.437433362,
-0.1334397197,
-0.684731245,
-0.1129431427,
0.145652011,
-0.4152343869,
-0.7260415554,
-0.1762535721,
0.1913319826,
0.2436544746,
0.7731210589,
-0.411724776,
-0.9132421017,
-0.6344352365,
0.118402943,
0.0307300892,
-0.1169511303,
0.7364130616,
-0.6356588006,
0.4551440775,
0.1909892708,
0.6487051845,
0.5778115392,
-0.1922816783,
0.5522553325,
-0.6291481256,
-0.0864658803,
0.1023070067,
0.4742539823,
0.4477436841,
-0.2357803732,
0.4375608563,
0.1280346066,
-0.3521175385,
-1.0189841986,
0.0653161407,
-0.3362473249,
0.0229777284,
1.4260085821,
-0.0390900448,
-0.1013704613,
-0.2603023052,
-0.097923629,
0.5139383078,
-0.3334187865,
1.1708648205,
0.5895926356,
0.3791264892,
-0.0375233702,
-0.6955330968,
0.5741747022,
0.3774386048,
-0.4575097263,
-0.094800286,
0.2598917782,
0.2427743524,
0.2193126827,
0.4806067944,
-0.029280223,
0.0191722494,
-0.1133293509,
-0.0308032203,
0.0901420191,
-0.0361348428,
-0.1651932001,
0.1714584678,
-0.2598666549,
-0.1533144861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13950v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13950v2
|
Making Reasoning Matter: Measuring and Improving Faithfulness of Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-02-21T17:23:59 | 2024-02-23T18:01:48 |
Debjit Paul, Robert West, Antoine Bosselut, Boi Faltings
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to perform better when asked to
reason step-by-step before answering a question. However, it is unclear to what
degree the model's final answer is faithful to the stated reasoning steps. In
this paper, we perform a causal mediation analysis on twelve LLMs to examine
how intermediate reasoning steps generated by the LLM influence the final
outcome and find that LLMs do not reliably use their intermediate reasoning
steps when generating an answer. To address this issue, we introduce FRODO, a
framework to tailor small-sized LMs to generate correct reasoning steps and
robustly reason over these steps. FRODO consists of an inference module that
learns to generate correct reasoning steps using an implicit causal reward
function and a reasoning module that learns to faithfully reason over these
intermediate inferences using a counterfactual and causal preference objective.
Our experiments show that FRODO significantly outperforms four competitive
baselines. Furthermore, FRODO improves the robustness and generalization
ability of the reasoning LM, yielding higher performance on out-of-distribution
test sets. Finally, we find that FRODO's rationales are more faithful to its
final answer predictions than standard supervised fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5723571181,
-0.7819060683,
0.9542233944,
0.0838936642,
-0.369825989,
-0.4360188544,
-0.2678396404,
-0.4783065021,
-0.035774231,
0.4988921285,
-0.5544029474,
-0.0753399357,
-0.6181052923,
0.2812175155,
-0.0618778169,
0.8205058575,
-0.1052974835,
0.0879221857,
-0.2457209527,
-0.1696804464,
-0.4741764963,
-0.0132149784,
-0.7148140073,
-0.6381625533,
0.8403213024,
0.5403537154,
1.0785825253,
0.7243264318,
0.3798518181,
0.2685419023,
-0.0577031709,
0.6466385126,
-0.4923690259,
0.1870078892,
-0.8386186957,
-0.7926329374,
-0.4604937136,
0.0276443157,
0.5487655997,
0.5697635412,
-0.1523300558,
0.212478295,
-0.0844020173,
0.7123151422,
-0.6376738548,
0.094083935,
-0.863901794,
-0.1740808785,
0.0020478945,
-0.3455854058,
-0.6487268806,
-0.2291687876,
-0.1496922821,
-0.5656881332,
0.1049123257,
0.2942375243,
0.8423548937,
0.3130351901,
-0.4477268159,
-0.4954474866,
-0.7625706792,
0.7282983661,
-0.7980360389,
0.5604553223,
0.4823945165,
0.2126082033,
-0.693721056,
-0.489118278,
-0.5825617909,
-0.2454246134,
0.0258415584,
0.0273953024,
-0.0660777912,
0.2308203131,
0.2766853571,
0.3134650886,
-0.2527818978,
-0.1593834311,
-0.0129266884,
-0.0558285043,
0.5508831739,
0.2177772075,
0.1050553247,
0.1972790211,
0.0528314188,
-0.1573313624,
-0.8517875075,
-0.0235302821,
0.2557043731,
0.0546494275,
0.4750166237,
0.5661900043,
-0.1199311391,
0.7580918074,
0.3403546214,
-0.1946009547,
-0.5053158402,
-0.2792371809,
-0.6440017223,
0.0007796305,
0.584624052,
0.3284064531,
0.217129916,
-0.0846587569,
-0.1832764894,
0.0271585919,
0.1747015268,
-0.8760300279,
0.0310212336,
0.3778099716,
-0.3441252112,
-0.0496552475,
0.1405504197,
-0.1446262151,
0.0497737266,
-0.6065291166,
0.3368215561,
-0.3393431306,
-0.0634896979,
0.3894070983,
0.1405287236,
0.1646054238,
0.5609880686,
-0.8154700994,
0.1704928279,
0.805521667,
0.5179866552,
0.317476511,
-0.3611730039,
-0.9261164069,
0.3561496139,
-1.040366888,
0.7609081864,
-0.4179001749,
-0.0246837735,
-0.0681960881,
0.036020454,
0.0172810145,
-0.5398243666,
0.494241178,
-0.6337893605,
-0.011562692,
-0.5726730227,
-0.6249865294,
-0.0553975999,
0.3439221382,
-0.5337244868,
0.7074987888,
-0.3522548079,
-0.7034923434,
0.4464056194,
-0.1315809935,
-0.2994293571,
-0.2552123666,
-0.3648790121,
-0.0830179974,
0.5508953929,
0.0543882772,
0.5864062905,
-0.6549432874,
0.5481749773,
-0.4170845747,
-0.3341132104,
0.6182460189,
-0.1878276318,
0.564232409,
0.2173149735,
-0.3269783258,
0.2777235508,
-0.6144840121,
-0.101051107,
-0.0750855878,
-0.2561658919,
-0.371670723,
0.1784595996,
-0.7783004045,
0.3954985738,
-0.0970964208,
-0.3926151097,
0.0702181756,
-0.3706012666,
0.1735765934,
1.0729682446,
-0.103507407,
0.4356763959,
-0.5564892888,
0.325119704,
-0.066339843,
0.3400840163,
0.1582779884,
-0.5904711485,
-0.8931460381,
0.0736355484,
-0.0148931537,
0.2598128915,
-0.9713535905,
0.2384394407,
-0.2320814729,
-0.3939325511,
-0.2322874069,
0.2690298259,
0.4031189978,
0.5652551055,
0.2423647791,
0.0014945801,
-0.2182527333,
-0.6637167931,
-0.4020770788,
-0.475028187,
0.0242016762,
0.1724648774,
0.5328987837,
-0.3874178827,
0.6911187768,
-0.3757723868,
-0.1045353487,
-0.1764043868,
0.0789337307,
0.3450431824,
0.2981560528,
0.2850300074,
-0.4310495853,
-0.1595959216,
0.2960934341,
-0.8332067728,
-0.1607758403,
-0.2877744138,
-0.5090113282,
0.074802801,
0.5027442575,
-0.5798394084,
0.1853371561,
0.2314849794,
-0.3457757533,
0.5210264921,
-0.4212243557,
0.1244635209,
-0.7944492698,
-0.0470913872,
-0.1573639512,
-0.1117570177,
-0.3788114786,
0.1007945389,
-0.1616771966,
0.291395098,
-0.0797408,
0.4446392953,
-0.394965589,
0.1039747,
-0.3982747495,
0.0858821049,
0.0405580811,
0.2252554744,
-0.0941204876,
0.4672750831,
0.2240670472,
-0.6846861839,
0.2222197205,
-0.0060997782,
-0.1480756849,
0.3377093077,
-0.6420594454,
0.2236651182,
-0.0531231314,
0.2724711299,
-0.9669809937,
-0.3129814565,
0.0563584268,
-0.4291742146,
0.1188702881,
-0.1407408267,
-0.7404904366,
-0.0634721965,
-0.0612505041,
0.2257792652,
0.2254481763,
-0.4629065096,
0.7564894557,
0.1058726758,
0.1525150537,
-0.4941922426,
-0.7443781495,
-0.2303728312,
-0.0384642594,
-0.8192247152,
-0.0735154673,
-0.1645526886,
-0.4698378444,
-0.2718217075,
-0.4480980337,
0.0353667252,
0.0468092263,
0.1155122072,
0.0634345636,
-0.1375907212,
0.3184162378,
0.3590587378,
-0.1844386756,
0.5647261143,
-0.264110893,
0.2072403431,
-0.2661358416,
-0.2485894561,
-0.1883677542,
0.2089427114,
0.6136391759,
0.0032962868,
0.8385537863,
0.2677411735,
-0.2316286713,
-0.6023421288,
-0.5235895514,
-0.3456106782,
-0.4476852715,
-0.2481450438,
-0.5940315127,
-0.9815115333,
0.5663620234,
-0.0917508528,
0.129655838,
0.2194475681,
0.3866893351,
0.0157321785,
1.0736825466,
0.2674576342,
0.349383831,
0.3434328735,
-0.0544242039,
0.1569666862,
-0.5249881744,
-0.2290078998,
-0.4388784766,
-0.0034616205,
-0.527531147,
-0.6009588838,
0.0533848554,
0.4847249985,
-0.435177058,
0.0234844554,
-0.2842099071,
0.4247153401,
0.3606923521,
0.3130963743,
0.4094060659,
-0.0319220312,
-0.4086443782,
0.1319810301,
-0.7414021492,
-0.6322892904,
0.7822637558,
0.3301475644,
0.8513945937,
0.2903947532,
0.6467168331,
0.0102453763,
0.6343440413,
-0.6106429696,
0.7320218086,
0.0696061775,
-0.6260915399,
-0.2683807611,
-0.6265857816,
-0.7656858563,
0.3724619746,
0.0065243631,
-0.4565762877,
0.3416083157,
0.1691734642,
-0.0899023265,
0.2564691305,
-0.2917448282,
0.5322164297,
-0.0412949771,
-0.7397481203,
-0.3060718179,
-0.5935139656,
0.5406402946,
0.1249678805,
0.2179491967,
-0.0976909697,
0.1421782374,
0.6598029137,
-0.8292136788,
0.635383904,
0.1823526621,
-0.3205654919,
0.5040320754,
0.4655743837,
0.5156465173,
0.2489147186,
-0.08686281,
-0.0003354875,
-0.1989249438,
-0.4005141854,
-0.906956315,
0.7182995677,
-0.3620654047,
-0.951259017,
-0.4064232707,
-0.4300005734,
-0.3440378308,
0.143945843,
0.1517296731,
0.2600893676,
0.1157478094,
0.2234523296,
1.0481513739,
0.0700378567,
0.1426151991,
0.5408725142,
-0.4547849894,
-0.7559379339,
0.4856638312,
0.2083454132,
0.5669103265,
0.4619554579,
0.6733143926,
-0.1250103563,
-0.248749882,
-0.5525591969,
0.4323288798,
-0.8955754638,
-0.2348060459,
-0.1622894704,
0.1513528526,
-0.0351564698,
-0.2125221491,
-0.448084116,
-0.0008387403,
-0.1155484989,
-0.4080397189,
0.1818707436,
0.505957365,
-0.3856865764,
-0.0407512002,
-0.6339297295,
0.3161243498,
0.608114779,
0.049529478,
0.2846340835,
-0.4812770188,
-0.2503327727,
0.275944382,
-0.0987839773,
-0.7210080624,
-0.0761207417,
-0.124523066,
0.4986307621,
0.7474425435,
0.0449178629,
1.0359199047,
-0.4196714163,
0.3912850618,
0.333569169,
-1.0739634037,
0.9672012329,
-0.3673130572,
0.1406657398,
0.4959825575,
0.2911043763,
0.0117759742,
-0.5164288282,
-0.6447261572,
-0.4463835955,
0.4888661504,
0.2967151999,
-0.0330607221,
-0.5310419202,
0.6066904664,
-0.026904298,
-0.0846543983,
-0.6108455658,
-0.154655844,
0.1030791998,
0.0911422074,
0.2350128889,
-0.2284224182,
-0.2259043157,
-0.2821053267,
0.8668074608,
-0.3445189595,
0.0814105496,
0.6499550939,
-0.0039436757,
-0.4489880204,
0.2053922415,
0.754679203,
0.9190338254,
-0.2498408258,
0.3695517778,
0.0009468943,
-0.2721686065,
0.1851881146,
-0.1634934545,
-0.0238771681,
0.0534178615,
0.675549984,
0.5752273202,
0.1335096955,
-0.5596904755,
0.311296016,
-0.1012271196,
-0.1332754791,
0.0875968784,
0.409022361,
0.0617218651,
0.2909578979,
0.2907464206,
-0.0253334511,
-0.0503772795,
-0.8776596189,
0.1426462829,
0.2403081954,
-0.42844823,
-0.228128612,
0.7111744285,
-0.0447594039,
-0.0903369859,
0.5363504887,
0.0234840941,
-0.2402674556,
0.5388000011,
0.5998855233,
0.6761268377,
-0.4607847035,
0.2117908895,
0.2399491817,
0.6042884588,
-0.4878257513,
0.436461091,
-0.2262307703,
-1.0237857103,
-0.7194159627,
-0.4237225652,
-0.4060881138,
-0.10025727,
-0.7460922599,
-0.1771536022,
-0.6007893682,
-0.176968053,
-0.2079389244,
0.0404250585,
-0.399936229,
0.4785852134,
-0.0848818719,
0.9582970142,
-0.8959538341,
0.8416652679,
0.6764106154,
-0.6523302794,
-1.0994436741,
-0.1193121895,
-0.37120381,
-0.4335641265,
0.6764135361,
0.1276012063,
-0.5529132485,
-0.2495574951,
-0.752104938,
-0.6408701539,
1.1511557102,
0.6480771303,
-0.6473909616,
0.34538728,
0.2180617005,
0.521410048,
-0.3684539199,
0.2084305882,
0.3745584488,
0.4118773341,
0.2885060012,
-0.8109070063,
0.3571141064,
0.1447140127,
0.0590378568,
0.250186801,
-0.6180257201,
0.7283821702,
-0.3199765682,
-0.1021470949,
0.056723658,
0.8393482566,
0.7516769767,
0.5675165653,
0.353094548,
0.6729525924,
0.8293101192,
-0.1821453422,
1.1192423105,
0.0295912679,
0.2192569673,
1.2731639147,
-0.3356737196,
0.8058786988,
0.7216876149,
-0.0075649759,
0.5746936202,
0.466601491,
0.5154829621,
0.4175447524,
0.3447850645,
-0.1870329082,
-0.7136413455,
-0.0220506843,
-0.1104230955,
0.1421141177,
0.3431470394,
-0.4591780603,
-0.0623747967,
-0.1609012187,
0.2146073729,
0.1266621947,
-0.5610775948,
0.5405642986,
0.368296206,
-0.8982742429,
0.5181673169,
-0.1122068688,
-0.0675005168,
-0.6423804164,
-0.0977491811,
-0.578962028,
0.4082431495,
-0.1990377009,
-0.7973698974,
0.3601048887,
-0.2022161484,
-0.3107891977,
-0.1459332258,
0.7411053181,
-0.1172283217,
-0.3587567508,
0.4996589124,
0.4952586293,
0.0647197813,
-0.0523139834,
-0.5035308599,
0.1298837066,
-0.0336640552,
-0.1973886341,
0.2495902628,
1.0332630873,
-0.2822583616,
0.8009086251,
0.9328942299,
-0.0154853081,
0.0557939708,
0.1602095664,
0.7906428576,
-0.6018754244,
-0.177465573,
-1.0212388039,
0.3387212753,
-0.0642770827,
-0.3345454633,
0.8128198981,
0.40952456,
0.8529647589,
-0.0175901596,
0.1808436811,
0.2347467095,
-0.1188818142,
-0.794575274,
0.3822695911,
-0.5004863143,
0.3733565807,
-0.1883911192,
-0.9184575677,
-0.4053977132,
0.7617797852,
-0.3831935823,
-0.170556277,
0.7278551459,
0.7590590119,
-0.0218022484,
0.0626974776,
0.5692528486,
0.3747009337,
0.4171069264,
0.5261119604,
0.9864124656,
-0.5495103598,
0.2622903287,
-0.04109345,
-0.2329303771,
-0.1326502562,
-1.0484161377,
-0.9780228138,
-0.2461010665,
-0.2814050615,
-0.4653961658,
0.0888586938,
0.5824965239,
0.5578938723,
-0.6515783668,
-0.3035466671,
-0.6929348707,
0.5504674315,
-0.4508167505,
-0.2449633628,
0.1252890378,
-0.4480794072,
-0.2659148574,
0.3341628015,
0.453938663,
-0.3976982534,
-0.0753001049,
-0.2836561501,
-0.3104377687,
0.6572663188,
0.7432249784,
-0.0968075469,
-1.0695453882,
-0.5897246003,
-0.0249984358,
0.0164955165,
-0.1400365233,
0.9599034786,
-0.4545488656,
0.5701233149,
0.6976134777,
0.5215045214,
0.2720205784,
-0.0706672519,
0.6990744472,
-0.2394640893,
-0.2805924118,
-0.078612037,
0.6070162654,
0.0272496846,
-0.2737138867,
0.620449841,
0.0263666436,
-0.8053682446,
-0.7228156924,
0.253318578,
-0.8584986925,
-0.5190489888,
1.1662988663,
-0.2614314556,
-0.320933044,
-0.0044604582,
-0.079787761,
0.2899322212,
-0.1237920746,
0.6397897601,
0.9824786186,
-0.3468778729,
-0.0601090714,
-0.4432474375,
0.3350008726,
0.4478460252,
-0.6311046481,
0.0361767039,
0.5892577767,
0.4552105069,
0.2671743333,
0.5520268679,
0.0834223777,
0.3265308142,
-0.0301906541,
-0.4148047268,
-0.0669621155,
-0.5117950439,
-0.0678575411,
-0.0456973091,
0.2378032953,
0.0810468495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14874v1
|
Distillation Contrastive Decoding: Improving LLMs Reasoning with Contrastive Decoding and Distillation
| 2024-02-21T17:20:38 | 2024-02-21T17:20:38 |
Phuc Phan, Hieu Tran, Long Phan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We propose a straightforward approach called Distillation Contrastive
Decoding (DCD) to enhance the reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) during inference. In contrast to previous approaches that relied on
smaller amateur models or analysis of hidden state differences, DCD employs
Contrastive Chain-of-thought Prompting and advanced distillation techniques,
including Dropout and Quantization. This approach effectively addresses the
limitations of Contrastive Decoding (CD), which typically requires both an
expert and an amateur model, thus increasing computational resource demands. By
integrating contrastive prompts with distillation, DCD obviates the need for an
amateur model and reduces memory usage. Our evaluations demonstrate that DCD
significantly enhances LLM performance across a range of reasoning benchmarks,
surpassing both CD and existing methods in the GSM8K and StrategyQA datasets.
|
[
-0.3442719281,
-0.6720645428,
0.8370028734,
0.0725767165,
-0.4952556193,
0.3804740012,
-0.2168923169,
-0.1441026926,
-0.187153995,
0.4374255836,
-0.4737468958,
-0.5466919541,
-0.648234725,
0.3059990704,
-0.275800854,
0.6700698137,
-0.0815441385,
0.3571666777,
-0.3581297398,
-0.026743656,
-0.3238874376,
-0.5459030271,
-0.9811834693,
-0.567869544,
0.3785586655,
0.2888881266,
0.3994403481,
0.5336186886,
0.5005260706,
0.3522453308,
-0.6234604716,
0.5139687061,
-0.5003308654,
0.2264229655,
-0.2307931185,
-0.6547451019,
-0.198942408,
-0.1287557185,
0.1808032244,
0.8733654618,
-0.2824622989,
-0.3636294901,
0.2759246528,
1.0889209509,
-0.890776217,
0.2428913563,
-0.6456449628,
-0.1632102728,
0.0997920632,
-0.1623385251,
-0.5955219865,
-0.1732757539,
0.0602598079,
-0.5453506708,
0.2042284757,
-0.0691325963,
0.3389936686,
0.6691240668,
-0.4675052762,
-0.389215827,
-0.9110298157,
0.7793471813,
-0.8177871704,
0.3013376892,
0.4639447927,
0.3426092565,
-0.1364595145,
-0.7318011522,
-0.7634400725,
-0.2774493694,
-0.0099393679,
0.2840414047,
-0.3452064395,
0.3317606449,
0.477887392,
0.7013291717,
-0.2575982213,
-0.0718500391,
-0.1329947412,
0.094978638,
0.3861869574,
0.3225976527,
-0.1654985398,
0.2297638655,
-0.1782780886,
-0.0356473476,
-0.6443573236,
-0.3560542166,
0.2127433717,
-0.0559475236,
-0.1343633085,
0.2083778381,
-0.5445536971,
0.5592780113,
0.2819143534,
-0.1500398219,
-0.1012855247,
-0.378115654,
-0.4126341641,
0.1046426371,
0.4011482298,
0.4652032554,
0.0399002582,
0.0484481342,
-0.2254294157,
0.156281054,
-0.1712879241,
-0.9983097315,
-0.920583725,
0.3120833337,
-0.6813616753,
-0.1889324933,
-0.2731030583,
-0.7055323124,
-0.7734295726,
-0.4347589016,
0.0859489515,
-0.3894789219,
-0.3479077816,
0.3779156506,
-0.4861959219,
0.0772815794,
0.5585585237,
-1.0481555462,
0.5176912546,
0.4586202204,
0.7636421323,
-0.2507467568,
0.2183886319,
-0.4383903742,
0.0984033197,
-0.3247839212,
0.753390193,
-0.4367607832,
-0.6774667501,
-0.2445326,
-0.3518303633,
0.3211615384,
-1.0652863979,
0.6302960515,
-0.7507945895,
-0.2185764164,
-0.5608122349,
-0.6168901324,
-0.331122905,
0.2070662826,
-1.0228033066,
0.7715635896,
-0.072988674,
-0.9135987759,
0.2585138679,
-0.4212571681,
-0.3624650836,
0.0215127897,
-0.163983807,
-0.0851624608,
0.3980084956,
0.5414302349,
0.2406433523,
-0.5609689355,
0.1329440325,
-0.3937462568,
-0.3047389388,
0.2806328535,
-0.7724654675,
0.8089515567,
0.6235940456,
-0.2191195041,
-0.0481569618,
-0.9283304811,
-0.3370302618,
0.1818714887,
-0.4974379838,
-0.4917675853,
0.1884939224,
-0.2581118345,
-0.0067418898,
0.0894541144,
-0.2059532553,
0.1221433282,
-0.0457494594,
0.5726278424,
0.6165411472,
-0.0138717499,
0.4320289493,
-0.1822597086,
0.3541238308,
0.5909202099,
-0.2387012541,
-0.3002263606,
-0.1707885563,
-0.9416512847,
-0.4775261283,
0.4150280058,
0.5781145096,
-1.2582008839,
0.362482518,
0.025191905,
-0.1811138093,
-0.5941250324,
0.1120694429,
0.3485496044,
0.7773954868,
0.5702476501,
0.1761391759,
-0.5751592517,
-0.6537874341,
0.2105685622,
-0.1817275882,
-0.0832428336,
0.0341832452,
0.3114050925,
-0.1046984196,
0.627591908,
-0.8104669452,
0.0350533612,
-0.4637759328,
0.0626253337,
0.2919335365,
0.2786203027,
0.2340337038,
-0.7098910809,
-0.4912921786,
-0.021730151,
-0.6916775703,
-0.2410383672,
-0.1579502225,
-0.0596066341,
0.2127406746,
0.7874535322,
-0.5595241785,
0.4021126628,
0.5319595337,
-0.311454922,
0.6213992238,
-0.4201438129,
0.4402728975,
-1.1511114836,
-0.1318561137,
0.011914527,
-0.1551168114,
-0.5668241382,
-0.139867574,
-0.0185124949,
0.2542141378,
-0.2729367018,
0.348982811,
-0.7166903615,
0.1477643102,
-0.5942947268,
0.1287044287,
0.4142613709,
-0.0245734733,
0.2245797664,
0.8169859052,
0.5425366759,
-0.6322060823,
0.6035024524,
0.0899970084,
-0.4694058895,
0.5084269047,
-0.701032877,
-0.0207783803,
-0.0735414103,
0.5240752697,
-1.3387111425,
0.0858563706,
0.0043226313,
-0.0019107383,
0.2887143195,
-0.148976028,
-0.4734020233,
-0.2898650467,
-0.1954489946,
0.612236321,
0.6747373939,
-1.0137956142,
0.497889936,
0.0106683755,
-0.0878599137,
-0.5464971066,
-0.8381041884,
0.0880362913,
-0.4850278497,
-0.3377975821,
0.3426598608,
-0.2538609803,
-0.7087329626,
-0.1087759808,
-0.3097943068,
-0.2586939931,
0.2593310773,
-0.1444604546,
0.4227187335,
-0.0150549058,
-0.0113998624,
0.2161706388,
-0.1657561809,
0.2770674527,
-0.2173325419,
0.5474425554,
0.2313960791,
-0.1619287133,
-0.6755398512,
0.4115015268,
0.3061283529,
-0.0457754694,
0.7110350728,
0.3012372255,
-0.2190099657,
-0.4449126124,
-0.5676071048,
-0.331133306,
-0.5255437493,
0.1707511842,
-0.7215673923,
-0.8017221093,
0.7232714891,
-0.4329600632,
-0.3137544096,
0.2167699784,
0.5651468635,
-0.1594678313,
1.0723290443,
0.3644260168,
0.085033156,
0.3516964614,
-0.3042507768,
0.1816236526,
-0.8375503421,
-0.1741657853,
-0.4604481161,
-0.2663253844,
-0.4453742504,
-0.6020366549,
-0.0217446163,
0.4651312232,
-0.0047568195,
-0.2067513615,
-0.5313636661,
0.9589713812,
0.4944002926,
0.2398525476,
0.672449708,
-0.1711757779,
-0.3538637161,
-0.0668152496,
-0.5610961914,
-0.425396055,
0.9791271687,
0.1218933463,
1.1652778387,
-0.0118507696,
0.9475320578,
0.2905020416,
0.0146921752,
-0.8843019009,
0.5363876224,
-0.2746087015,
-0.2690680325,
0.0261645988,
-0.602191031,
-0.6742877364,
0.4021249712,
-0.0549029075,
-0.3215502203,
0.4105398953,
0.3082679808,
-0.4757074714,
0.3003460765,
-0.7963397503,
0.5385323167,
0.1011226848,
-0.1765460372,
-0.4491364658,
-0.4289562106,
0.6776095629,
0.1664731801,
0.0557794608,
0.0613624565,
-0.0486651994,
0.3846790195,
-0.51927495,
0.6779987812,
-0.1261966825,
-0.4557692707,
0.3652915061,
0.2294982374,
0.4973380566,
0.0438304693,
-0.2059525251,
0.0896284878,
0.0027986348,
-0.3573146164,
-0.8308053613,
0.7842994928,
-0.4748321474,
-0.7728588581,
-0.2935536206,
-0.6050664783,
-0.0439736471,
-0.0315086693,
0.1017404869,
0.3655993938,
-0.3003981113,
0.0486083701,
1.1056852341,
-0.1969838887,
0.5338012576,
0.3596162498,
0.0002558649,
-0.4953682423,
0.5811643004,
-0.2173317671,
0.5574973822,
0.6045458913,
0.1564786732,
-0.6894081235,
-1.0731130838,
-0.1606335491,
0.0509590469,
-1.1877381802,
-0.2118305266,
-0.5091998577,
-0.0124811707,
-0.2981074452,
-0.0033189869,
-0.173746869,
-0.5084514022,
-0.5195846558,
-0.186934188,
0.3863407075,
0.6480612755,
-0.2010775357,
0.200556457,
-0.7527967691,
0.6839160323,
0.4027608633,
0.0793557614,
0.025174465,
-0.5603674054,
-0.1882286072,
0.0192224551,
-0.22603333,
-0.7885856628,
0.2679358721,
-0.0190785099,
0.5669907928,
0.6497542858,
0.496804595,
0.7911322117,
-0.5081775784,
0.7370788455,
0.3648685515,
-1.0259389877,
0.5237309933,
-0.031612996,
0.4838815928,
0.6036428809,
0.3839200735,
-0.2336123288,
-0.222772643,
-0.2337047756,
-0.6790807843,
0.4644621313,
0.0345789976,
-0.1273198277,
-0.4147615135,
0.3405701816,
0.0505018793,
-0.0501530655,
-0.4338880479,
-0.3798645735,
-0.0091976579,
-0.2652511597,
-0.0241365712,
-0.4565128386,
-0.3357636929,
-0.3785150051,
0.4045839608,
-0.1170202792,
-0.0607304014,
0.2414030284,
0.0085479273,
0.3655504584,
0.2895570099,
0.5237210989,
0.5182463527,
-0.1380368322,
0.5934970975,
0.4030783474,
-0.3742050827,
0.2645908594,
0.1383555681,
0.0938322619,
-0.0554736815,
0.2288634628,
0.7335845232,
-0.1843914539,
-0.6118644476,
0.1709020585,
-0.3583442271,
-0.4673545361,
0.09032581,
0.1929676682,
0.5729367137,
0.6104487777,
0.2947289348,
-0.1886082888,
0.5806921721,
-0.4261822999,
-0.0163053442,
0.3049491942,
-0.0274139326,
0.0551283248,
0.7520520091,
0.4390727878,
0.1739443839,
0.6809437275,
-0.3841414154,
-0.2012877315,
0.7274831533,
0.5524903536,
0.9538565278,
-0.2431699336,
-0.0240147728,
0.3477449715,
0.0101921083,
-0.3201598227,
0.3475238085,
-0.3708761632,
-0.7148883939,
-0.5765874982,
-0.5057977438,
-0.5698593259,
0.2023598105,
-0.863578856,
0.0797386318,
-0.4958960712,
0.0375591479,
0.1148790196,
0.1007303447,
-0.3017278314,
0.2813901305,
0.3315669298,
0.9725473523,
-0.6039044857,
1.1549967527,
0.2852217555,
-0.2081327885,
-0.4954507351,
0.1350169331,
0.0241468437,
-0.3976697624,
0.8948916793,
0.1130324677,
-0.4604382217,
0.1205967739,
-0.4204652309,
-0.4189210832,
1.2806893587,
0.4886721671,
-0.9215251207,
0.2955477536,
-0.1777489334,
0.470533818,
-0.3776901662,
0.3506996036,
1.1999099255,
0.2948990166,
0.637694478,
-0.6335343719,
0.2325628996,
-0.0944014192,
0.1851230115,
0.0207614228,
-0.3246086836,
0.8809091449,
-0.5385965705,
-0.4460119605,
0.051878158,
0.6051360965,
0.4805459678,
0.2957864404,
0.4416374266,
0.8048694134,
0.8929364085,
-0.2449588776,
1.0681502819,
-0.1594019383,
0.1935039461,
1.3212213516,
-0.5074932575,
0.771699369,
0.581336081,
-0.3894912302,
0.5031787753,
0.6719143391,
0.2150048763,
0.9417903423,
0.390237391,
-0.8283776641,
-0.3722853065,
0.0857777596,
-0.2960672975,
0.2533403039,
0.4969370365,
-0.2894986272,
-0.2451426536,
-0.1566753238,
-0.0613466352,
0.3702118695,
-0.2968037724,
1.0339431763,
0.2749267519,
-0.585716784,
1.0610511303,
-0.1948141456,
0.7780495286,
-0.2100264728,
-0.2976957262,
-0.5362014771,
0.4421080649,
-0.132628262,
-0.648779273,
0.2999840677,
-0.132591933,
-0.4723932743,
-0.1425107419,
0.4813263714,
-0.6718057394,
-0.2171802074,
0.5110183954,
0.4213955998,
0.0642032325,
-0.0891469792,
-0.630284667,
0.2658883035,
0.0881522596,
-0.0618201979,
0.2143744975,
0.7251130939,
0.2951778471,
0.700962007,
0.6006384492,
0.1168087944,
-0.1553061604,
0.369454205,
1.2183601856,
-0.7058175802,
-0.4118781388,
-1.2993936539,
0.3335223496,
-0.2158658653,
0.1817195565,
0.7103947401,
0.4376547933,
0.7390787005,
-0.1837410182,
0.9107529521,
0.2404684871,
0.3078997433,
-0.9614631534,
0.6292473078,
-0.3177806139,
0.6608781219,
0.0147217866,
-0.8405447602,
-0.2272617668,
0.5484896302,
-0.274620086,
0.0285049584,
0.9622493982,
0.7720495462,
0.1188702658,
-0.0355333649,
0.4714401364,
0.1697735935,
0.4265368581,
0.6414583325,
1.1925007105,
-0.1607064307,
0.5783814192,
-0.2429522723,
-0.2767718136,
-0.1844160259,
-1.0399162769,
-1.1608264446,
-0.3462239206,
-0.4829499722,
-0.4611148536,
-0.0296238381,
0.6901648045,
0.5103830695,
-0.8312559724,
-0.14062424,
-0.3675228953,
0.2648813725,
-0.2665983438,
-0.2153599858,
0.1865210533,
-0.4436115026,
-0.9990822077,
0.4771081507,
0.3385305703,
0.2192767113,
-0.2041533589,
-0.2159790099,
-0.168347016,
0.2941188216,
0.7012677193,
-0.0689653382,
-0.7401112318,
0.1568753421,
-0.369027108,
-0.0613567717,
0.1648243666,
0.8974639177,
-0.7412994504,
0.4503567517,
0.6880514622,
0.5871763825,
0.631868422,
0.1620096564,
0.4607782364,
-0.4840421975,
0.3033283949,
0.1705595851,
0.4639048278,
0.3888989985,
-0.2666581273,
0.3158492148,
0.3009579778,
-0.5042021871,
-0.6384900808,
0.3564087749,
-1.0171772242,
-0.6395347714,
1.2903796434,
-0.3398723602,
-0.1073235124,
-0.2954132557,
-0.4679185748,
0.2051979005,
-0.3943126202,
0.8983380795,
0.8936291337,
-0.1199386343,
-0.4551188648,
-0.2545337081,
0.7986047864,
0.2629855871,
-1.1486529112,
0.4358618855,
0.8313105106,
0.2746743858,
-0.1182749718,
0.6982389688,
-0.025016902,
0.1971427947,
0.456870079,
-0.1217832267,
-0.0766626,
-0.2980387211,
-0.629055202,
-0.1340530813,
0.1567227542,
-0.3271961212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14873v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14873v2
|
Technical Report on the Checkfor.ai AI-Generated Text Classifier
| 2024-02-21T17:13:41 | 2024-02-26T05:28:41 |
Bradley Emi, Max Spero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We present the CheckforAI text classifier, a transformer-based neural network
trained to distinguish text written by large language models from text written
by humans. CheckforAI outperforms zero-shot methods such as DetectGPT as well
as leading commercial AI detection tools with over 9 times lower error rates on
a comprehensive benchmark comprised of ten text domains (student writing,
creative writing, scientific writing, books, encyclopedias, news, email,
scientific papers, short-form Q&A) and 8 open- and closed-source large language
models. We propose a training algorithm, hard negative mining with synthetic
mirrors, that enables our classifier to achieve orders of magnitude lower false
positive rates on high-data domains such as reviews. Finally, we show that
CheckforAI is not biased against nonnative English speakers and generalizes to
domains and models unseen during training.
|
[
-0.3736816943,
-0.3914706111,
0.3363035619,
-0.0635774061,
-0.0758663565,
-0.0826331303,
-0.0166965388,
-0.9105929136,
-0.0279718749,
0.5944489837,
-0.2840706706,
-0.4517772794,
-0.4993473291,
0.4065699577,
-0.6612854004,
1.1457442045,
-0.1412204057,
-0.0618721135,
-0.1013514549,
-0.1218817681,
-0.2618649006,
-0.3578411043,
-0.7802909017,
-0.6815438867,
0.5058788061,
0.4824258089,
0.4119101167,
0.3137917221,
0.5580175519,
0.342292279,
0.2040431201,
0.2243801802,
-0.1322376132,
-0.1232140511,
-0.2510257363,
-0.659109056,
-0.1671995968,
0.241056338,
0.3239918947,
-0.2025581002,
0.1449617594,
0.0849725157,
-0.3750831783,
0.3547798991,
-0.5528392792,
0.1873665303,
-0.6018221378,
0.1153588742,
-0.4281361401,
0.0196065083,
-0.4870500565,
-0.3548931777,
-0.0989923403,
-0.3299153149,
0.6639975309,
0.1131371111,
1.1412353516,
0.2164103687,
-0.4403018653,
-0.176376611,
-0.711373806,
0.6946631074,
-0.6623843312,
0.4812485278,
0.5680646896,
0.3556059897,
0.312548995,
-0.420501709,
-1.2998639345,
-0.1578578204,
-0.07489755,
0.0159459095,
-0.1159905866,
0.0196033269,
0.3185938895,
0.6469254494,
-0.716068089,
0.1882577091,
-0.3935445845,
-0.4774622321,
0.9495630264,
-0.0833938643,
0.4738253653,
-0.3067755103,
0.0139999315,
-0.2357751131,
-0.4066531658,
-0.1271895468,
0.3586316109,
0.0886524841,
-0.0468381159,
0.688134551,
-0.2422932535,
0.4858497083,
-0.0548834465,
-0.0715517029,
0.3169140816,
-0.2134311199,
-0.4728288949,
0.1868948787,
0.9230652452,
0.3233235478,
0.3415947855,
-0.1765439361,
-0.5348547101,
0.6797397137,
0.2358414531,
-0.8873859644,
-0.3552217782,
-0.0794609338,
-0.4698612094,
-0.8409494758,
-0.1496675014,
-0.5989608169,
-0.6808344126,
-0.1645136029,
0.5575296879,
-0.3836239278,
-0.1737377942,
-0.0406513773,
-0.2277802676,
0.536919415,
0.1789784133,
-0.5162996054,
0.0494604893,
0.5813215971,
0.604333818,
-0.1523760408,
-0.4305864275,
-0.6656627655,
-0.3070983589,
-0.4082552791,
1.0664936304,
-0.469643414,
-0.2568594217,
0.248963818,
0.0197156817,
0.2489674687,
-0.6775613427,
0.9561780095,
-0.5261884332,
0.5068196058,
0.2316146195,
-0.4724313915,
-0.4650250077,
0.7556802034,
-0.653683424,
0.9866888523,
0.0841673985,
-0.6098163128,
0.5686531663,
-0.6906642318,
-0.9462659955,
0.2019410729,
-0.0120958127,
-0.8960722089,
-0.0379743837,
0.1805400997,
0.4631740153,
-0.4805648923,
0.4050757885,
0.1439193189,
-0.4717775285,
0.046129778,
-0.5615035892,
0.5140544176,
0.2315115929,
-0.817448318,
0.3310706615,
-1.0291182995,
-0.0695960149,
0.174867928,
-0.2498732507,
-0.3925794959,
-0.1450268328,
0.3672505319,
0.2002309263,
-0.1089550704,
-0.9640084505,
0.0694402456,
-0.4261170328,
0.4900277853,
0.5875329971,
-0.0663867295,
0.1041622832,
-0.4156363606,
0.3911525011,
0.2902978063,
0.078663066,
-0.3912692368,
-0.4725779891,
-1.3884935379,
-0.0597232878,
0.5030380487,
0.6935395002,
-1.1432542801,
0.5007621646,
-0.0172647666,
-0.8157717586,
-0.5841749907,
-0.0461612046,
0.5668705106,
0.3598986864,
0.2849594951,
-0.0488933921,
-0.708009541,
-1.0938065052,
-0.2650451362,
-0.4118674397,
0.1135968268,
0.1675363481,
0.6782670021,
-0.7951443791,
0.4686912596,
-0.3413582146,
-0.4060735703,
-0.0160104204,
0.3451626599,
-0.0494191088,
0.3867002726,
0.3158522546,
-0.9303145409,
-0.5075272322,
0.1128489971,
-0.7095587254,
0.075822331,
-0.3597557247,
-0.0606049709,
0.4432321489,
0.4233584702,
-0.6585580707,
0.6256690621,
0.4443615079,
-0.4087303281,
0.4489365816,
0.078315556,
0.2700704336,
-1.1568871737,
0.1139994934,
0.4220120013,
-0.3963241875,
-0.5232268572,
0.0330871046,
0.0315802321,
-0.5142835379,
-0.162047565,
0.6298000813,
0.0814848766,
0.4035760164,
-0.4023917615,
-0.0385813974,
-0.0208100788,
0.5188180804,
0.175804019,
1.026819706,
0.2490009367,
-0.75001508,
0.1178261936,
0.3918139935,
-0.3995295167,
0.7537208796,
-0.7696895003,
0.240691945,
0.0168397669,
0.0563870706,
-0.8104358315,
-0.2150198519,
0.1943396479,
-0.5284489393,
0.3588091731,
0.3161361814,
-0.4216614664,
-0.422505945,
-0.1371069402,
0.2550091445,
0.3502591252,
-0.8982371688,
0.6368427873,
0.394230485,
0.3586111069,
-0.2522924244,
-0.6611973047,
0.3383132219,
0.2650566101,
-0.5276318789,
0.2139392495,
0.0495144613,
-0.2030015588,
-0.0089513054,
0.016569268,
-0.1878649741,
0.1127966866,
0.4379963875,
0.1739255786,
-0.290933311,
0.2997062206,
-0.0374009795,
-0.323231101,
0.0896878615,
-0.478187412,
0.4586580396,
-0.1834624112,
-0.2167096436,
-0.7105535269,
0.1803564131,
0.7522090673,
-0.463432461,
0.5353181362,
0.7414744496,
-0.5796175003,
-0.3431258798,
-0.626442194,
-0.0300407745,
-0.4691826701,
0.2545941174,
-0.2583348453,
-0.8484352231,
0.1622848064,
0.2482361197,
0.0894632041,
0.9747387767,
0.364300251,
0.172464624,
1.0378017426,
0.8305368423,
-0.3906974494,
0.3332893252,
-0.2374032587,
0.5972088575,
-0.2733032107,
-0.3557229936,
-0.9222366214,
-0.2422180176,
-0.8466894627,
-0.2040178776,
-0.2098492533,
-0.4180349708,
-0.3727250695,
0.4302590489,
-0.8257018924,
0.5550896525,
0.840638876,
0.0786322951,
0.0754844397,
-0.2333299518,
0.2593308985,
0.1519661695,
-0.2690278292,
-0.4451081455,
0.783777833,
0.2088633329,
0.5170224309,
-0.1976030916,
0.8023214936,
0.8306453228,
0.745770812,
-0.8660322428,
0.4824936092,
-0.274594456,
-0.7292944789,
-0.2076182216,
-0.2713808417,
-0.4793326855,
-0.2492870241,
-0.3448199928,
-0.0380127765,
0.1689076126,
-0.0455835685,
0.0483754575,
0.7605744004,
-0.7483433485,
0.677128911,
-0.2809798717,
0.0432543494,
0.0160157438,
-0.2042195499,
0.2943196595,
-0.116278775,
-0.2116440833,
0.262729615,
0.4213835001,
0.8039371371,
-0.3370947242,
0.8121709228,
-0.1009162441,
-0.0804125369,
0.4808121026,
0.2320426852,
0.6236815453,
-0.0593690388,
-0.1119931415,
0.6769362092,
-0.1911076754,
-0.2493272126,
-0.2623452544,
0.5339528322,
-0.972864151,
-0.2610839307,
-0.7902575731,
-0.0720848367,
-0.059366364,
0.6948180795,
0.5480451584,
0.2568260729,
-0.2337437272,
0.0700387061,
0.7071622014,
-0.1878706962,
0.4143345654,
0.5191640854,
-0.210630551,
-0.4543970227,
1.3609093428,
-0.28176108,
-0.3901652694,
0.5501083136,
0.1867930591,
0.0405982248,
-0.6278452873,
-0.4900188744,
0.239158392,
-0.4652229846,
-0.4562940598,
-0.5728917718,
-0.641941905,
-0.3297216296,
-0.1182918623,
-0.2633588612,
-0.0780703276,
-0.2717161179,
-0.2014977932,
0.1117882058,
0.9759942889,
0.2715350688,
0.2150120735,
-0.8320612907,
0.3670019507,
0.3424362838,
0.5965061784,
-0.1126333028,
-0.1764447391,
-0.1400742084,
-0.1977649182,
-0.2281431258,
-0.3892331421,
0.4309996665,
0.2628672123,
0.3609312475,
0.4697836339,
0.0157338046,
0.1215810254,
-0.4151071906,
0.9285299778,
0.2439206541,
-1.0254443884,
0.606392324,
-0.1899744421,
0.2987755537,
0.635407269,
0.359626025,
-0.8101320267,
-0.1607922167,
-0.5058500767,
-0.1901873946,
0.63274014,
0.3802679777,
0.0391775817,
-0.0290188696,
0.5054172873,
0.2436845899,
0.2031850964,
-0.7307682633,
-0.0783364326,
-0.3431452215,
-0.5677750111,
-0.4148866236,
-0.3917586207,
0.0883327872,
0.0056024604,
0.9563211799,
-0.1883021146,
0.3655601144,
0.3880079091,
-0.1435772777,
-0.1408991516,
0.1894332021,
0.8142595291,
0.1335060298,
0.2056057751,
0.1382723749,
0.0573432259,
-0.7937929034,
0.1538174599,
0.1855811626,
-0.7513923049,
0.0784734562,
0.4871577919,
0.9790104628,
-0.3152776659,
-0.6147789955,
0.3869299293,
-0.5166106224,
-0.5517964363,
-0.5250888467,
0.2590840161,
-0.6634287238,
0.2549722195,
0.0640398785,
0.5880401731,
0.1932985336,
-0.3853661418,
0.2937606275,
0.1989711076,
-0.9346843362,
-0.5578345656,
0.6391554475,
0.5888133645,
-1.0426937342,
0.8387454152,
-0.3607060611,
-0.9730197787,
0.4759232104,
0.4196807146,
1.3689185381,
-0.0723958984,
0.5258145928,
0.305018425,
0.5367168784,
0.1434218884,
0.2762857676,
-0.2360201031,
-0.8895530105,
-0.1715634465,
-0.6695202589,
-0.4625711739,
0.3999911845,
-0.2185613364,
0.4481122792,
-0.5832177401,
0.0927457288,
0.2550175488,
0.1335177869,
-0.7763547897,
0.5855903625,
0.3527513742,
0.8766104579,
-0.8658605218,
0.7426413298,
0.7481148839,
-0.4984975457,
-0.6324342489,
0.2492201477,
-0.0432005525,
-0.4414072633,
0.5857796669,
0.7027807832,
-0.1481816918,
-0.2366269529,
-0.7194154263,
-0.3902196288,
0.6159566641,
-0.2100036889,
-0.5489161015,
0.0484749302,
0.2300033122,
0.8321481347,
-0.0726978555,
0.2701455653,
0.34291327,
0.5540057421,
-0.2693443298,
-0.7813690901,
-0.1094527319,
-0.7548213005,
-0.213984251,
0.392855376,
-0.6911820769,
0.6248682737,
0.1685352474,
-0.1446345747,
-0.0765360817,
0.6225818992,
-0.1676803529,
0.7430682778,
0.5934153795,
0.7642071843,
0.8391583562,
-0.2005004436,
1.1098865271,
-0.0768335685,
0.0500565656,
0.8030335903,
-0.4628621638,
0.6232941151,
0.200282231,
0.0999082401,
0.6142449975,
0.3729353845,
-0.3318197429,
0.2402302474,
0.0153921563,
-0.2820446789,
-0.3266268969,
-0.3304815888,
-0.0679225102,
0.7725266814,
-0.0923435539,
-0.3412066698,
0.1022009403,
0.2667838037,
-0.1379003227,
0.163529858,
-0.2616990507,
0.8619971275,
-0.1900888383,
-0.9210473299,
0.3830338418,
0.3048003614,
0.936909318,
-0.3159002364,
-0.2757382989,
-0.122712478,
0.7585043311,
-0.266526401,
-0.7530542016,
0.1790092289,
0.1196667105,
-0.4562623799,
0.0532930419,
1.0900352001,
-0.3192702532,
-0.6471452713,
0.0200312082,
-0.0102844192,
-0.0618315041,
-0.2304145247,
-0.4574763477,
-0.1072518378,
0.1567804366,
0.044947207,
0.0353747457,
0.2171563655,
-0.2417457104,
0.4916671216,
0.8159160614,
-0.2987077832,
-0.3365072608,
0.1091920584,
0.7904817462,
-0.7180380821,
-0.4404216111,
-0.6809337139,
0.3130557239,
-0.3359350562,
-0.6474644542,
0.7061418891,
0.6469501257,
1.1385672092,
-0.0008978303,
0.8546774983,
0.0463559069,
0.5053632855,
-0.2535710037,
1.0799000263,
-0.5256379247,
-0.1578280032,
-0.0549850278,
-0.9022890329,
-0.4405927062,
0.6159902215,
-0.0389339812,
0.0197949596,
0.5759598613,
0.620439589,
0.1385021657,
0.3744724393,
0.3120488524,
0.1410436183,
0.8726353049,
0.194413811,
0.5752869248,
-0.9225515723,
0.5762954354,
-0.4137169719,
-0.0245998986,
-0.0861405507,
-0.6341603398,
-1.3138519526,
-0.5928427577,
-0.4558624625,
-0.5392702222,
-0.0967855155,
0.4093347788,
0.7157281041,
-1.3470424414,
0.1432005316,
-0.3563659489,
0.1400742829,
0.0360120758,
-0.2580500245,
0.1460383534,
-0.0976925269,
-0.6007244587,
0.1992788017,
0.2611373961,
-0.2094675452,
-0.5489045382,
-0.181661278,
-0.3457626402,
0.3036560416,
0.4845291972,
0.378649205,
-0.3708610833,
-0.4816823006,
0.1406598538,
-0.2782331705,
0.0300714504,
0.8204383254,
-0.6816999316,
0.4741290808,
0.6456760764,
0.7635637522,
0.6093910336,
-0.3328986466,
0.3059594929,
-0.5444863439,
0.1271645874,
0.4443440437,
0.1828235686,
0.4274001122,
-0.4871117771,
0.5715618134,
0.2744710743,
-0.7764351368,
-0.8641969562,
0.0697538033,
-0.5368627906,
0.0025538588,
0.8149005175,
0.1272057891,
-0.4136900008,
0.0492289104,
-0.4253013134,
0.3453949988,
-0.1602984965,
0.9452695847,
0.4662173092,
0.3383947611,
-0.1734702587,
0.0204424113,
0.5596703887,
0.2291019112,
-1.1196784973,
-0.4137083292,
0.3672624528,
0.1269577593,
0.6031009555,
0.2202742696,
0.056467697,
0.4390723705,
0.0569896698,
0.4672880769,
-0.2782767415,
-0.5158807635,
-0.4153027534,
0.00181833,
-0.1970848143,
-0.1549170911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13936v1
|
Distinctive Image Captioning: Leveraging Ground Truth Captions in CLIP Guided Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-21T17:05:06 | 2024-02-21T17:05:06 |
Antoine Chaffin, Ewa Kijak, Vincent Claveau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Training image captioning models using teacher forcing results in very
generic samples, whereas more distinctive captions can be very useful in
retrieval applications or to produce alternative texts describing images for
accessibility. Reinforcement Learning (RL) allows to use cross-modal retrieval
similarity score between the generated caption and the input image as reward to
guide the training, leading to more distinctive captions. Recent studies show
that pre-trained cross-modal retrieval models can be used to provide this
reward, completely eliminating the need for reference captions. However, we
argue in this paper that Ground Truth (GT) captions can still be useful in this
RL framework. We propose a new image captioning model training strategy that
makes use of GT captions in different ways. Firstly, they can be used to train
a simple MLP discriminator that serves as a regularization to prevent reward
hacking and ensures the fluency of generated captions, resulting in a textual
GAN setup extended for multimodal inputs. Secondly, they can serve as
additional trajectories in the RL strategy, resulting in a teacher forcing loss
weighted by the similarity of the GT to the image. This objective acts as an
additional learning signal grounded to the distribution of the GT captions.
Thirdly, they can serve as strong baselines when added to the pool of captions
used to compute the proposed contrastive reward to reduce the variance of
gradient estimate. Experiments on MS-COCO demonstrate the interest of the
proposed training strategy to produce highly distinctive captions while
maintaining high writing quality.
|
[
-0.3304130733,
-0.402715832,
0.4608813226,
0.1527415663,
-0.7625361681,
0.1642304361,
-0.1846766621,
-0.1687065661,
-0.0903211012,
0.5278977752,
-0.6022865176,
-0.5807227492,
-0.7491899729,
0.0573642179,
-0.2057647705,
0.9935330153,
-0.1993968487,
0.3274765611,
-0.4652759731,
-0.361533016,
-0.8937420249,
-0.5885511637,
-0.2900359333,
-0.1414377391,
0.6071625948,
0.4733025432,
0.7646262646,
0.7861056328,
0.311083287,
0.2164248228,
0.0856044143,
0.3707824647,
-0.4477321208,
-0.1642552763,
-0.300418824,
-0.6624401808,
0.3938678503,
0.5157778859,
0.4511675537,
0.1290677488,
-0.0417004786,
-0.3379188776,
-0.1224595159,
0.7303980589,
-0.7810604572,
0.2802219391,
-0.6633928418,
0.5253833532,
0.240567863,
-0.6719843149,
-0.4803145528,
-0.4743715823,
0.0513383672,
-0.7550375462,
0.3643451333,
0.3664418757,
1.333112359,
0.3440499306,
-0.280700773,
-0.4250097573,
-0.5491071939,
0.8613687754,
-0.3916457891,
0.385586381,
0.0835960805,
0.5870659947,
0.1996581554,
-0.5956870317,
-0.4954039752,
-0.4979358912,
-0.229452163,
0.1573618054,
0.0473414846,
-0.0845233351,
0.3916842937,
0.4191818833,
-0.1861920208,
-0.0888130367,
-0.3722717166,
-0.3222473264,
0.2061415464,
-0.0242002271,
0.2621276081,
-0.1048194841,
-0.9035830498,
-0.3566196263,
-1.1080291271,
0.3736523986,
0.1421454847,
0.0571496971,
0.1564468443,
0.4237797856,
-0.1162414774,
0.5458955169,
0.1226497442,
-0.340092212,
0.0858886018,
0.1141304448,
-0.0290974136,
-0.0637858286,
0.7228238583,
0.5395973325,
0.1972193867,
-0.3027120531,
-0.4262674749,
-0.045737613,
0.249311015,
-0.666367352,
-0.2742008865,
-0.4148922563,
-0.3413541019,
-0.6018197536,
0.425670296,
-0.5959146023,
-0.440341711,
-0.4562338293,
0.6078020334,
-0.5655332208,
0.1316859275,
-0.0444631651,
-0.3546267748,
0.4545568526,
0.3240720034,
-0.7839509845,
0.3534760177,
0.4356659949,
0.8957853913,
-0.3295971155,
-0.3352992535,
-0.8783808351,
0.1938933879,
-0.3686247468,
0.7301678061,
-0.5591584444,
-0.252835542,
0.0058707464,
0.1943313479,
-0.0173953343,
-0.5627783537,
0.514811039,
-0.8875610828,
0.3007327616,
-0.5978629589,
-0.2957223654,
-0.4353813827,
0.4111940265,
-0.934250176,
0.65377599,
-0.1056300476,
-0.7108193636,
0.5258492827,
-0.4279774725,
-0.4642560184,
-0.1792802066,
-0.483499676,
-0.5481895804,
-0.1134387553,
0.7821426392,
0.4017489254,
0.0171218012,
0.2518901229,
0.1210220531,
-0.6186196208,
0.4659100771,
-0.5570601225,
0.3612397313,
0.0592058897,
-0.5744062662,
0.1860541999,
-0.4721138179,
-0.0408784635,
0.3181684613,
-0.3571948409,
-0.1945595294,
-0.0230772216,
-0.1182681546,
0.2340245545,
-0.1818560362,
-0.3531610072,
0.1191087291,
0.1346943825,
0.4406446815,
0.8753197193,
0.3118415773,
0.3149662614,
-0.5686607957,
0.6571325064,
0.0771378651,
0.138906762,
-0.211073637,
-0.2857868969,
-0.612934649,
-0.5888382196,
0.6061555147,
0.5074751973,
-1.0531302691,
0.0956069008,
-0.3189295232,
-0.1413304359,
-0.3472094834,
-0.0844708979,
0.5388667583,
0.5429506898,
0.3816955388,
-0.4064540565,
-0.4594733417,
-0.8323110342,
0.0177277531,
0.2328838706,
0.1438387036,
0.5916891694,
0.4721233845,
0.295956552,
0.9045749307,
-0.5680521131,
-0.4561476707,
-0.1945618838,
0.2910655737,
-0.1334240288,
0.5058714151,
0.5977520943,
-1.3075202703,
-0.3636266291,
-0.3333429098,
-0.7381452918,
0.1575537175,
-0.5310084224,
-0.0608854629,
-0.0823464021,
0.5245636106,
-0.5373046398,
0.3237020075,
0.3751908243,
0.1271549761,
0.7277693152,
-0.1835331917,
0.4147700071,
-0.3923565149,
-0.1002590805,
-0.2027186155,
-0.613101244,
-0.0074480069,
0.2620300353,
-0.0856873319,
-0.1877352744,
-0.4632731974,
0.1308899224,
-0.699439168,
-0.2852317691,
-0.3710119724,
0.0451790094,
0.1217997596,
0.8645583987,
0.57563591,
1.0846534967,
0.6218146086,
-0.7279203534,
0.5377102494,
0.4352012575,
-0.4312177896,
0.5563994646,
-0.601568222,
0.1685904711,
-0.2018715739,
0.354575932,
-0.8366129994,
0.0537234209,
0.457947433,
-0.4871008992,
0.206059888,
-0.2250186056,
-0.3966709375,
-0.1776128262,
-0.3305434585,
0.0892501324,
0.587610364,
-0.8923941255,
0.3428102434,
0.0442355648,
0.1853232086,
-0.8016107678,
-0.5131576061,
0.0845214427,
-0.2656837404,
-0.1439912915,
0.4195105433,
0.0620735139,
0.3529752493,
0.2451836914,
-0.228203699,
-0.0753357038,
0.0630657673,
0.5967841148,
0.250592947,
-0.0320740491,
0.0951161459,
-0.0526602976,
-0.1020763367,
0.0157078691,
-0.3998551071,
0.361061722,
-0.1635515094,
-0.4007243514,
-0.2716377676,
0.3823108971,
0.4082322717,
-0.3244615495,
0.7035657763,
0.6750205159,
-0.0870750397,
-0.137835443,
-0.2519740164,
-0.1882645488,
-0.4439710975,
0.0774597004,
-0.434879452,
-0.6993780732,
0.2312564552,
-0.2225340158,
-0.0948044062,
0.0609480217,
0.2956538498,
-0.0983674973,
0.841817379,
0.6433442831,
-0.0109921098,
0.7940012217,
-0.3396553993,
-0.0798038542,
-0.6826201081,
-0.354560405,
-0.1331762522,
-0.2936687469,
-0.1899122894,
-0.4510354698,
0.3243744671,
0.1847769767,
0.0708730742,
0.2012853026,
-0.5717145801,
0.918892622,
0.925003767,
0.5714190602,
0.2835843265,
0.2767627537,
-0.407754004,
-0.3097133934,
-0.6739734411,
-0.4421622455,
0.8908059001,
0.2363405377,
0.7393730283,
-0.1885079294,
0.510664165,
0.5403888822,
0.2844126225,
-0.7271797657,
0.6209790111,
0.1668394506,
-0.2664327621,
-0.1676291078,
-0.2774024904,
-0.5789588094,
0.3566234708,
-0.3207739294,
-0.0439231582,
-0.1122623086,
0.0369984284,
-0.1909303367,
0.3248209059,
-0.2507399619,
0.7943617105,
-0.3832342327,
-0.2747759819,
-0.1991002709,
-0.7991011143,
0.2534279227,
0.5528555512,
-0.0474224314,
0.2313979119,
0.0890083611,
0.6235275269,
-0.246807605,
0.8326978683,
-0.4176335037,
0.2628763318,
0.3846137524,
-0.0034532999,
0.6171739697,
0.0791338012,
0.5850847363,
-0.2047770619,
-0.2291701883,
-0.4337006509,
-0.8368484378,
0.4133366942,
-0.8081595898,
-0.7311568856,
-0.5045770407,
-0.4145230651,
-0.1838018298,
0.2437756956,
0.4153108597,
0.4922165871,
-0.0307326224,
0.2878767252,
1.0903666019,
-0.1934396029,
0.231994763,
0.4596685469,
0.0840848461,
-0.7411040068,
0.9977670908,
-0.2754511535,
0.3251069784,
0.6223189831,
0.2817235887,
-0.4156656861,
-0.6832100749,
-0.5213621259,
0.0620995201,
-1.0471976995,
-0.3072588146,
-0.37033692,
-0.1907100677,
-0.0952141806,
-0.3315485418,
-0.0881525725,
-0.2559954524,
-0.2169673592,
-0.3833259344,
0.1543252766,
0.3502927721,
-0.1610022336,
0.2979524136,
-0.8239642978,
0.5160151124,
0.7499832511,
0.2422268242,
-0.1007063314,
-0.432795465,
-0.0688613951,
-0.0805347413,
-0.4208659828,
-1.0489597321,
0.2943602502,
0.0941925943,
0.7105875015,
0.412039876,
0.0969695151,
0.4649089277,
-0.5501358509,
0.8098396659,
0.3451645076,
-0.9580403566,
0.5101795197,
-0.1939142048,
-0.2264230847,
0.498137325,
0.5658393502,
-0.5258868337,
-0.2507798672,
-0.5654596686,
-0.5050201416,
0.3986851871,
0.0458618775,
0.2182404846,
0.2402485609,
0.2419897318,
0.2539875805,
0.4858600199,
-1.2785909176,
-0.004035905,
-0.5796695352,
-0.040753074,
0.2282599956,
-0.249107793,
-0.6393100619,
-0.1269113421,
0.6901862025,
-0.3064028025,
0.434412241,
0.3273644149,
-0.4437506795,
0.1791022569,
0.3165382147,
0.8285349607,
0.3567140996,
-0.1493177414,
0.2358372658,
-0.1188193187,
-0.2920820713,
0.2297142744,
-0.2789433002,
-0.2599519491,
0.2524329126,
0.2052371055,
1.1626259089,
0.3435869217,
-0.7193155885,
0.9851005077,
0.1313319206,
-0.4452317357,
-0.1989379823,
0.1140594035,
-0.3050762117,
0.1881274581,
0.325912118,
0.2399056703,
0.0121135386,
-0.4401459694,
0.3540709019,
0.3100975752,
-0.6532126665,
-0.0579809733,
0.6008275747,
0.0967904776,
0.1909917444,
0.4879149497,
-0.3371681273,
-1.0237693787,
0.5188629627,
0.5929092169,
0.6666406989,
0.3802578151,
0.6633683443,
0.2679916024,
0.3231803179,
-0.250690788,
-0.0369789526,
-0.3139947951,
-0.6265969872,
-0.2248397321,
0.0176707786,
-0.8131982088,
0.006160765,
-0.7020898461,
0.2607838511,
-0.8171885014,
0.3981451988,
-0.2774608433,
-0.1861092001,
-0.4815834761,
0.367177099,
0.3416991532,
0.6848235726,
-1.0155551434,
0.6342895031,
0.7169389129,
-0.7712185383,
-0.8800600171,
-0.1298557222,
-0.2280697674,
-0.7509493828,
0.8504584432,
0.4888268411,
-0.165146634,
-0.2295143455,
-1.1392842531,
-0.4575251043,
1.2958790064,
0.0616665818,
-0.1757450998,
-0.0424424447,
0.1196172759,
0.3183079362,
-0.6849789619,
0.0771126226,
0.090770103,
0.2950989008,
0.5614225268,
-0.3106865883,
0.3561733067,
0.1096229404,
0.1288536489,
-0.3005623817,
-0.591370523,
0.8275171518,
-0.38876459,
-0.5354205966,
0.0727732256,
0.8347708583,
0.4123314917,
0.2619183958,
0.6963087916,
0.392536521,
0.6635484099,
-0.1011116207,
0.8661890626,
0.0974870697,
0.4219672978,
0.9154720902,
0.0543875508,
0.5938388109,
0.5148130059,
0.0648733675,
0.8284890056,
0.4792546332,
-0.438416779,
1.1579582691,
0.224042818,
0.035289418,
-0.4052217007,
-0.238999337,
-0.2315527499,
0.09720961,
-0.0065670963,
-0.4231652319,
-0.2983894944,
0.2869854569,
-0.2616443336,
0.4408139288,
-0.2526644468,
0.5632025599,
-0.1192166805,
-0.5523976684,
0.6568276882,
-0.0359325483,
0.6726537943,
-0.4005586207,
-0.3296353817,
-0.0639975592,
-0.139144972,
-0.1072863042,
-0.7011690736,
-0.0217588246,
-0.1038376316,
-0.2968716025,
-0.2432523817,
0.5017046928,
-0.4594056606,
-0.0177835207,
-0.2556452155,
0.0688410029,
0.0396990478,
-0.2399485558,
-0.6681296825,
-0.1152667552,
0.0476721637,
0.020492129,
0.1827244759,
0.3395410478,
-0.0676942766,
0.7137477398,
0.7195499539,
-0.0106242029,
0.1897911578,
0.0059676887,
1.061542511,
-0.8360580802,
-0.8666348457,
-0.4792506099,
0.2799059749,
-0.1890478879,
0.0008529267,
0.5723560452,
0.4331497848,
0.6578339338,
-0.641123116,
0.7774435878,
0.0181208439,
0.2994099259,
-1.0695822239,
0.2322352827,
-0.3494844139,
0.1239078566,
-0.1237660497,
-0.6856120229,
-0.0682271197,
0.6474815607,
-0.3644876182,
-0.2449525744,
0.8618658781,
0.6746566296,
-0.0214556213,
-0.0063444837,
0.3156644702,
-0.4595763385,
0.3342258334,
0.8947764039,
1.1194431782,
-0.5299680233,
0.7717933059,
-0.2564312518,
-0.0617877319,
-0.2064797282,
-0.9709101319,
-0.9762142897,
-0.4460400641,
-0.4276068211,
-0.2283690572,
0.1602321118,
0.7636315227,
0.7972118258,
-0.8629084229,
0.4132797122,
-0.2164322883,
0.426142782,
-0.6621431112,
-0.289045006,
0.2715328932,
-0.262355417,
-0.6006135941,
0.2016647756,
0.0358468816,
0.2581167221,
-0.19357346,
-0.277241081,
0.0148906074,
-0.0452998169,
0.2603757083,
0.4738700688,
-0.7094603777,
-0.4875277877,
-0.0577528663,
-0.4207004309,
0.3058302104,
1.1421073675,
-1.0694192648,
0.1725124717,
0.2866094112,
0.7990652919,
0.4459053874,
0.3173596263,
0.4571349323,
-1.0301601887,
0.1879481524,
0.1698803753,
0.1479870826,
0.5230534673,
-0.312381655,
0.4345990419,
0.5767933726,
-0.342443347,
-0.6003524661,
0.297106415,
-0.9935058355,
-0.2246582359,
1.255611062,
-0.521202445,
-0.178790167,
0.3599214256,
-0.5773243904,
0.0064485618,
-0.3410999477,
0.8189600706,
0.7583450675,
0.3421301842,
-0.6552708745,
-0.3143008053,
0.6027348042,
0.2867705226,
-0.5584910512,
-0.2100942731,
0.7160264254,
0.5724598765,
0.1333257407,
0.3298608363,
-0.2743597627,
0.5956742764,
0.0001649221,
0.0040640696,
-0.790104866,
-0.6085997224,
-0.396673739,
0.3202756941,
0.0378911011,
-0.7975103259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13934v1
|
Do Efficient Transformers Really Save Computation?
| 2024-02-21T17:00:56 | 2024-02-21T17:00:56 |
Kai Yang, Jan Ackermann, Zhenyu He, Guhao Feng, Bohang Zhang, Yunzhen Feng, Qiwei Ye, Di He, Liwei Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
As transformer-based language models are trained on increasingly large
datasets and with vast numbers of parameters, finding more efficient
alternatives to the standard Transformer has become very valuable. While many
efficient Transformers and Transformer alternatives have been proposed, none
provide theoretical guarantees that they are a suitable replacement for the
standard Transformer. This makes it challenging to identify when to use a
specific model and what directions to prioritize for further investigation. In
this paper, we aim to understand the capabilities and limitations of efficient
Transformers, specifically the Sparse Transformer and the Linear Transformer.
We focus on their reasoning capability as exhibited by Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
prompts and follow previous works to model them as Dynamic Programming (DP)
problems. Our results show that while these models are expressive enough to
solve general DP tasks, contrary to expectations, they require a model size
that scales with the problem size. Nonetheless, we identify a class of DP
problems for which these models can be more efficient than the standard
Transformer. We confirm our theoretical results through experiments on
representative DP tasks, adding to the understanding of efficient Transformers'
practical strengths and weaknesses.
|
[
-0.5165699124,
-0.561568141,
0.7829408646,
0.1997448057,
0.2356504351,
0.1740710586,
-0.3798868656,
-0.4108116031,
-0.2097919136,
0.2445898652,
-0.530423224,
0.396052599,
-0.6303382516,
0.3233382702,
-0.8504945636,
0.6992639303,
-0.3663665652,
-0.3724353611,
-0.0239171069,
-0.166344896,
-0.5596115589,
-0.261206001,
-0.5175314546,
-0.1459352374,
0.4251897931,
0.3587263227,
1.0390210152,
0.56719625,
0.8632668257,
0.4550698996,
-0.1962947994,
-0.0169505626,
-0.5665857792,
0.4630303681,
-0.2784718275,
-0.5537819266,
-0.1254652739,
0.0035033457,
0.6191093922,
0.8923463821,
-0.2352164686,
0.2908978164,
0.0087433578,
0.6960176826,
-0.5708355904,
0.1651812792,
-0.9259661436,
0.159239158,
0.3031848371,
-0.0855628327,
-0.5637501478,
-0.2339298129,
-0.0047461819,
-0.4374472797,
0.2722004652,
-0.1599963456,
0.6847110391,
0.9629529119,
-0.3171721399,
-0.3762785196,
-1.4436081648,
0.8584975004,
-0.122260578,
0.5731945038,
-0.0044918582,
0.6719228029,
-0.059792649,
-1.0259883404,
-0.6535481811,
-0.0972749516,
-0.3108069003,
-0.0060650525,
-0.6621560454,
0.0404621512,
0.8202344775,
0.2981216311,
-0.0921970233,
0.1164703369,
-0.2327135503,
0.0360538326,
0.2683790326,
0.4695551097,
0.0999821648,
-0.0237747226,
-0.2716901302,
-0.2996443212,
-0.3718655407,
0.0867739916,
0.2398855835,
0.1041444317,
0.0188647658,
0.3348261714,
0.3325714767,
0.7974689007,
0.1687822938,
-0.1709326804,
-0.4045676291,
-0.2005539536,
-0.0079387119,
-0.4650311768,
0.2873677909,
-0.0959423557,
0.4520513415,
-0.4352388382,
-0.4685646296,
0.1646136045,
0.6580126882,
-0.7157684565,
-0.388594687,
0.1678026319,
-0.3637239337,
-0.2491571158,
-0.2996441722,
-0.6067950726,
-0.232234776,
-0.4866780639,
0.2750730515,
-0.2108412683,
-0.1464315355,
0.1136957183,
-0.3286374807,
-0.0041344883,
0.4164700508,
-1.1127545834,
0.4254442453,
0.5751219392,
0.6543614268,
-0.1157974526,
-0.0075002601,
-0.3500786126,
-0.1451571435,
-0.2379306406,
0.8201892376,
-0.4649679065,
-0.1864990741,
-0.2512987554,
-0.1404644102,
-0.3755224049,
-0.5855014324,
0.6554632187,
-0.4376955926,
-0.3024114668,
-0.6174348593,
-0.2348988503,
0.065704979,
-0.021645803,
-1.0416101217,
0.8243732452,
0.441105485,
-0.7090532184,
0.2039909959,
-0.3737027645,
-0.2107893527,
-0.0483045503,
-0.1810344309,
-0.1859912425,
0.2487884462,
-0.0615240261,
0.3595231771,
-0.4749519527,
0.2878298163,
0.0948795006,
-0.5298722386,
0.4300337732,
-0.797241807,
0.4829384983,
0.3266553879,
-0.6480543613,
-0.1946396977,
-0.6927548051,
-0.0089745736,
0.1838957369,
-0.2715955973,
0.0414066687,
0.317289561,
-0.2311303616,
0.2437713593,
0.0265691616,
-0.4065354764,
0.3986235857,
-0.1503189355,
0.5486733913,
0.9025312662,
-0.48668468,
0.597338438,
-0.173162505,
0.781299293,
-0.5087991953,
0.154592976,
-0.0893965214,
-0.264200151,
-1.2026157379,
-0.3365605772,
0.3057627678,
0.4993949831,
-0.8429712057,
0.3562244475,
-0.0892300233,
-0.5603265166,
-0.3033970594,
-0.3003797233,
-0.0322393402,
0.3991001546,
0.3136210144,
0.3960112929,
-0.3823180795,
-0.8426831365,
-0.3331185281,
0.0649549514,
0.151230216,
0.348108083,
0.4309651256,
0.0198787283,
0.9645003676,
-0.6957353354,
0.292271167,
-0.6680678725,
-0.098862417,
0.4910978973,
0.3638876379,
0.6404626369,
-0.8023613691,
-0.6008218527,
-0.3247310817,
-0.5871973038,
-0.2899630964,
-0.6772080064,
-0.1029737741,
-0.154470548,
0.3972283304,
-0.9227650762,
0.381521672,
0.5420145988,
-0.1928104311,
0.4633218646,
-0.3938907087,
-0.0421675034,
-0.3102681935,
0.2277847528,
-0.2306602448,
-0.2818132341,
-0.8082534671,
0.0857568681,
0.1077926755,
-0.4720491767,
-0.1782248914,
0.2447640151,
-0.3058935106,
0.1086643338,
-0.3134492338,
-0.0451548547,
-0.1209207475,
0.5772176981,
-0.0936843529,
0.9557465315,
0.3956826031,
-0.6378872395,
0.329410255,
0.137744531,
-0.3093126416,
0.0922335461,
-0.7936983109,
0.2375159711,
-0.2398385406,
0.3076012433,
-0.8066319823,
0.1238636822,
-0.0332209878,
0.2179115862,
0.4084953964,
0.1630335152,
-0.5863435864,
-0.7576988339,
-0.0721199885,
0.4865758717,
0.6664073467,
-0.9481421709,
0.5598201752,
0.248111397,
0.2449497133,
-0.7881097794,
-0.631118536,
-0.1987189502,
-0.2114614099,
-0.5605389476,
0.5138574243,
0.0883760378,
-0.2786488235,
0.0486788563,
-0.4448627532,
0.0657466426,
0.2599211633,
-0.1163566038,
0.1116847023,
0.1262209266,
0.280636698,
-0.0356496647,
-0.5459234118,
0.0246912166,
-0.0624727942,
0.6977927089,
-0.3249174356,
-0.3814315796,
-0.3791363239,
0.4345843196,
0.5561029315,
-0.1338435411,
0.8099319339,
0.3906297386,
-0.2664253414,
-0.490359962,
-0.5667124391,
-0.0855601504,
-0.5854435563,
0.1487262249,
-0.3940201402,
-0.5730464458,
0.4472267926,
-0.1811570972,
0.1740248501,
0.5480066538,
0.4389834702,
0.1986463666,
1.1081433296,
0.7113074064,
0.4198032618,
0.4460943341,
-0.7190071344,
0.843408227,
-0.4820439219,
-0.0449170507,
-0.7215623856,
-0.6834580898,
-0.7626622915,
-0.5437291861,
0.5179800987,
-0.1005117148,
-0.2087820023,
0.8309775591,
-0.9130520225,
0.5955132246,
0.2964529097,
-0.2291918397,
0.0621504337,
-0.3232186735,
0.0920491815,
0.1340214461,
-1.1272324324,
-0.5213168263,
0.5047997236,
0.2667178512,
0.9592385292,
-0.0505801514,
0.2812716365,
-0.0083282469,
-0.0729539692,
-0.8477131724,
0.6963108778,
-0.2057744563,
-0.5080444813,
-0.2611820698,
-0.7035067677,
-1.1568514109,
0.0846039578,
-0.23017326,
-0.6615948081,
0.4761766493,
0.3157689571,
-0.4005722106,
0.7640017867,
-0.7242544889,
0.6857688427,
-0.336456269,
-0.2461180389,
-0.4009542167,
-0.485386312,
0.1391856968,
-0.1872648746,
-0.0868656561,
-0.0332316719,
0.0484263673,
0.4179760516,
-0.4725079536,
0.3177730739,
-0.1512140185,
0.0478144996,
0.5183531642,
0.1344547868,
0.5444023013,
-0.2677379251,
-0.3504100144,
-0.0827769712,
-0.1514453739,
-0.1709097773,
-0.9792559743,
0.6058949232,
-0.5091745853,
-0.7043554783,
-0.4123998582,
-0.7616599798,
-0.1272099316,
-0.0250410568,
0.0343228728,
0.5701155066,
0.2235140204,
0.2952392101,
0.5911815763,
-0.4434371293,
0.6897476912,
0.0991200209,
0.1963261515,
0.1406497657,
0.7299544215,
0.436206162,
0.381218642,
0.3647672832,
0.2202973813,
-0.3429688513,
-0.1833484173,
-0.4352585077,
0.1830558926,
-1.0281563997,
-0.3701393902,
-0.7691536546,
-0.1333651245,
0.1703108549,
-0.5368528962,
-0.5803333521,
-0.9721319079,
0.1578706801,
0.0059736348,
0.3170287013,
0.7694811821,
0.0701009259,
0.1588399857,
-0.567740202,
0.5075681806,
0.5427812338,
0.4972786605,
0.4658483565,
-0.0734409466,
-0.2720242441,
-0.1983380616,
-0.5315542817,
-0.7304826379,
0.2649880946,
-0.1559593529,
0.7551180124,
0.2078370899,
0.353189826,
0.5930077434,
-0.5814324617,
0.6444545984,
0.2077394277,
-1.0354506969,
0.1257537454,
0.0088450164,
0.3417686522,
0.3916887939,
0.462028563,
-0.2090350091,
-0.3422384858,
-0.6979507208,
-0.8436521292,
0.7157200575,
0.6471044421,
0.2724045515,
-0.128920868,
0.3627926409,
0.1099822968,
0.1364726573,
-0.4248466492,
-0.1716149896,
-0.2547549307,
-0.039174702,
0.2349881083,
-0.1309009045,
0.1628122628,
-0.5746909976,
0.3035133183,
0.1028535515,
0.6280507445,
-0.053609021,
0.0103831096,
-0.1075819582,
0.2945294976,
0.2675586343,
0.6645786762,
0.1051824242,
0.3766101003,
0.4499112666,
-0.261413306,
0.3585336208,
-0.1056681573,
0.0374624841,
0.0536716729,
0.154629007,
0.8114612699,
0.2512392998,
-0.8875895143,
0.274797529,
-0.223486498,
0.0575607866,
-0.3558106422,
0.2864127457,
0.1025275141,
0.2181900591,
0.1678161472,
0.5929525495,
0.2022226751,
-0.524692595,
-0.0475771464,
0.3081895113,
-0.0390565023,
-0.0727596506,
0.8091493845,
0.2356580049,
-0.6115368009,
0.8452696204,
0.0040189205,
-0.6741369367,
0.7468864322,
0.5870568752,
0.8796841502,
0.0305734985,
0.1138185784,
0.2957820296,
0.2180256546,
-0.2639286816,
-0.1315075159,
-0.3464915752,
-0.6531087756,
-0.4514806569,
-0.5085112453,
-0.5352954865,
-0.1370859444,
-0.4702905715,
0.4843117297,
-0.3863131404,
-0.433096379,
0.1083302423,
-0.2667446434,
-0.8592498899,
0.0690087155,
0.0081903134,
0.9156358242,
-0.430640161,
0.5132041574,
0.2116145343,
0.0367157906,
-1.2154967785,
-0.0812153965,
-0.4638911784,
-0.6124705076,
0.6905384064,
0.3332835436,
-0.477737993,
-0.2478878498,
-0.1943621039,
-0.9890713692,
0.9634526372,
0.7689142227,
-0.59379673,
-0.2671459615,
0.186295405,
0.6848254204,
-0.0307840556,
0.4766977429,
0.7089975476,
0.6047474146,
0.0453571603,
-0.9539019465,
0.1075739115,
-0.3441625834,
0.055964008,
0.7313110828,
-0.6514899135,
0.9873911738,
-0.2364450842,
-0.2507606149,
0.00214039,
0.246819526,
-0.2575907111,
0.0189036895,
0.9999226928,
0.3683778048,
0.6527977586,
-0.246813491,
1.3720266819,
-0.5500730276,
0.4469816983,
0.4430523813,
-0.1463274956,
0.4025705755,
0.2297329605,
-0.2674701512,
0.5790871978,
-0.0057697999,
-0.1055784747,
0.2762619555,
0.4188470244,
-0.2161498219,
-0.5116262436,
0.150279671,
-0.0578930564,
0.7866932154,
0.1878332049,
-0.2040335238,
-0.2667492926,
-0.1256584227,
0.0318132006,
0.2093139589,
-0.0140760578,
0.3221593201,
0.0026186232,
-0.9416912198,
0.9891163707,
-0.0889955088,
0.3505074978,
-0.5413557291,
-0.0541203246,
0.1399592459,
0.4639719725,
-0.1585315615,
-0.6327964067,
0.802277267,
0.2144518197,
-0.091297321,
-0.8666103482,
0.8126726151,
-0.054418698,
-0.4688190222,
0.1586434841,
0.392696768,
-0.0219972469,
0.169738397,
-0.5060760975,
0.0135995084,
-0.049530603,
-0.2947270274,
0.0980156958,
0.2917567492,
0.1341282129,
0.9150024652,
0.2666406035,
0.0278013907,
-0.1166502535,
-0.0097418008,
0.9794345498,
-0.5680488944,
-0.3622244,
-0.685994029,
0.4668780863,
-0.1493116915,
-0.0215667579,
0.5598088503,
0.335113585,
0.5678588748,
-0.1351887584,
0.6009699106,
-0.131653443,
0.3236690164,
-0.3869715929,
0.4082208872,
-0.3640902042,
0.5541456342,
-0.3243618309,
-0.9872890711,
-0.0385877453,
0.8441749811,
-0.3385188282,
0.0277977511,
0.9735568762,
0.4530033767,
-0.1822306663,
0.1541334242,
0.200626418,
-0.0248673968,
0.5138782263,
0.6094988585,
1.0300240517,
-0.0641864613,
0.6790803075,
-0.6324170232,
-0.2975048423,
0.0694782138,
-0.8151369095,
-0.5889812112,
-0.5522936583,
-0.1337535679,
-0.0648921132,
-0.1775764823,
0.8523877859,
0.5071491599,
-0.4582489133,
-0.1579412669,
-0.4610235095,
0.2520396113,
-0.4966008067,
-0.194549948,
0.2206377685,
-0.5871222615,
-0.8525242209,
0.2213564068,
0.2401997894,
-0.0330396146,
-0.1900345236,
0.2531584501,
0.2895441651,
0.4477589428,
0.7377061248,
0.0367598012,
-0.2969584763,
-0.5496109724,
0.4062370956,
0.1745485067,
-0.1393469572,
1.3147140741,
-1.0878660679,
0.2980102301,
0.7665508389,
0.6594390869,
0.520258069,
-0.0846466497,
0.6470171809,
-0.2986449599,
0.3993830979,
0.5023950338,
0.565890491,
0.1609384716,
-0.2759402394,
0.5140011311,
0.1347215027,
-0.9038758278,
-0.9314745069,
0.5383879542,
-1.1367007494,
-0.3215375245,
1.139954567,
-0.1476895362,
0.1723520458,
-0.0671187192,
-0.2985114753,
0.2862912714,
-0.0097352723,
0.8956270814,
0.3390690386,
-0.4719576836,
-0.0835525244,
-0.4370499551,
0.4851918519,
0.4920323193,
-0.5032527447,
0.299901098,
0.0445790589,
-0.1886509955,
0.3552387953,
0.4106564224,
0.2988564968,
0.0835586265,
0.373952806,
-0.3698314726,
0.0756536573,
-0.5856098533,
0.0294281598,
0.1438569576,
0.0365928188,
0.1284008473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13926v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13926v1
|
Large Language Models are Vulnerable to Bait-and-Switch Attacks for Generating Harmful Content
| 2024-02-21T16:46:36 | 2024-02-21T16:46:36 |
Federico Bianchi, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The risks derived from large language models (LLMs) generating deceptive and
damaging content have been the subject of considerable research, but even safe
generations can lead to problematic downstream impacts. In our study, we shift
the focus to how even safe text coming from LLMs can be easily turned into
potentially dangerous content through Bait-and-Switch attacks. In such attacks,
the user first prompts LLMs with safe questions and then employs a simple
find-and-replace post-hoc technique to manipulate the outputs into harmful
narratives. The alarming efficacy of this approach in generating toxic content
highlights a significant challenge in developing reliable safety guardrails for
LLMs. In particular, we stress that focusing on the safety of the verbatim LLM
outputs is insufficient and that we also need to consider post-hoc
transformations.
|
[
-0.1342613548,
-0.8977094293,
0.4987481833,
-0.0825322047,
-0.5050183535,
-0.0680947006,
0.0551556125,
-0.5257403255,
-0.0841619596,
1.046497941,
-0.2602627873,
-0.318744719,
-0.9011515379,
-0.1863751411,
-0.7650686502,
1.221793294,
-0.1521085948,
-0.2073676586,
0.318122685,
0.2555730939,
-0.4287403524,
-0.6635365486,
-1.0015273094,
0.1010692269,
0.8882191181,
0.1189018115,
0.8277295232,
0.3369270861,
0.5876156092,
0.1001824737,
-0.1338135004,
-0.194611147,
-0.8841205835,
0.4160529673,
-0.584415555,
-0.373162657,
-0.5039891601,
0.0302866008,
0.3562552035,
0.4910691977,
-0.0156992059,
-0.0198136494,
0.1777302176,
0.4085332155,
-0.6112897396,
-0.0945638195,
-1.1691675186,
-0.1350265294,
-0.5408683419,
-0.5397581458,
-0.9737656116,
-0.286896646,
-0.1087919995,
-0.0472889096,
-0.2628262937,
0.2151262909,
0.7682158351,
-0.074307777,
-0.9087000489,
-0.3275064826,
-0.775891006,
0.7531795502,
-0.7407548428,
0.0727088004,
0.1281742901,
0.196049571,
-0.4651782811,
-0.3198945522,
-0.2797732949,
-0.0392273739,
0.1324480474,
-0.2259000391,
-0.4294573069,
0.0173485968,
0.2277342379,
-0.1670337766,
-0.4679401815,
0.3606848717,
-0.5234203935,
-0.2637539506,
1.0090768337,
0.3851276338,
0.7051895261,
-0.4421880543,
-0.628410399,
-0.2844898999,
-1.3223757744,
-0.207065329,
0.6904609799,
0.5400343537,
0.0643043965,
0.658842802,
0.3837046921,
0.3271390796,
-0.0533268526,
-0.1548530608,
-0.1271958649,
-0.1897184998,
0.0674244985,
0.2727425992,
1.0178825855,
0.6785696745,
0.4229692817,
-0.0835918188,
-0.2922482491,
0.0387671478,
0.6454125047,
-0.6945053935,
-0.0776999965,
0.2882588506,
-0.258430928,
-0.6345627904,
0.017150268,
-0.9418185949,
-0.6165465117,
0.2692010403,
0.4946483672,
-0.4013454616,
-0.347948879,
0.4781385958,
0.189545691,
0.2527087629,
0.2601927817,
-0.7039203644,
0.2548010647,
0.6324625611,
0.5960408449,
-0.4144260287,
-0.083673887,
-0.8010423183,
0.55523628,
-0.6339617968,
0.5260059237,
-0.2289165854,
-0.7517035604,
0.4261842966,
0.0787581503,
0.1188207865,
-0.3918063343,
0.6331424713,
-0.9704666138,
0.1334262192,
-0.167491287,
-0.1782894284,
0.0488769263,
0.1046366245,
-0.7984703183,
0.5574235916,
-0.353397876,
-1.1523617506,
0.0675407425,
-0.1183915213,
-0.7414472103,
-0.3208272457,
0.1521399021,
-0.351491034,
-0.1068124771,
-0.1500414759,
0.4402717352,
-0.067057915,
0.294793576,
-0.2806081176,
-0.0740852877,
0.4561254084,
-0.6665620208,
0.7153353095,
0.18200396,
-0.4382381737,
0.2606507838,
-0.21738258,
-0.3051906228,
0.3110540807,
-0.5930573344,
-0.4772542715,
0.245725438,
0.2179294229,
0.5367285013,
0.1220890805,
-0.3346839249,
-0.0799742043,
-0.2948551476,
0.123474434,
1.0123376846,
0.2928652167,
0.3140104413,
-0.4386212826,
0.6613399982,
0.2163775116,
0.3174029589,
0.0142727839,
-0.562942028,
-0.5044382215,
0.2923294008,
-0.0610621795,
0.5093794465,
-0.978535831,
0.1293812394,
-0.284288466,
-0.5534284115,
-0.1310189366,
0.1291861534,
0.4004151821,
0.2759231925,
0.2425848991,
-0.1964461803,
-0.4648859501,
-0.6007948518,
-0.520115912,
-0.3364861012,
0.0867050961,
-0.0947056785,
0.4428782165,
-0.3257064223,
0.576146543,
-0.521604836,
0.1057831347,
-0.40495345,
0.1050061062,
0.0288574975,
0.4823744297,
0.636413753,
-0.6611298919,
-0.5842700005,
-0.2472134233,
-0.5125873089,
-0.0111177228,
-0.466930598,
-0.3396974206,
0.1574554592,
0.7823359966,
-0.8076829314,
0.2181175202,
0.447730273,
-0.3464853764,
0.7688604593,
0.2056845427,
0.1462194473,
-1.072504878,
-0.0111536793,
-0.0970951468,
-0.0816090032,
-0.8785930276,
0.1801231354,
-0.0141930161,
0.0633629188,
-0.8923019767,
0.5025526881,
-0.3099678755,
0.3793542981,
-0.1234689057,
0.0768179819,
-0.0255563762,
-0.0019466418,
-0.3090144694,
0.5089080334,
0.4858336747,
-0.4772224724,
0.1260529608,
0.3185109496,
-0.3202963471,
0.4028686583,
-0.5534358621,
0.1206047907,
-0.2592938244,
0.2692679167,
-0.8483921885,
-0.3553577065,
0.4915702641,
-0.2151406854,
0.5646992922,
-0.1562206298,
-0.6001733541,
-0.0679580644,
-0.7666828632,
0.2845786512,
0.6071588993,
-0.3944392502,
0.2433929294,
0.6289052367,
-0.5558559299,
-0.524600625,
-0.7660414577,
0.4487114251,
-0.5879881382,
-0.5531286597,
0.0792497471,
0.1001197025,
-0.4107125103,
-0.1459356695,
0.0468478687,
0.3180497289,
0.2212295532,
0.1656391472,
0.3089649379,
0.0592693128,
0.0930991992,
0.0790360793,
-0.1796222329,
0.5248486996,
0.1382481456,
0.6545587778,
0.2157722265,
-0.5032792687,
-0.0286148489,
0.6871792078,
0.7391106486,
-0.2669656873,
0.9206427932,
0.190677762,
-0.2003715485,
-0.4974803329,
-0.1499977112,
-0.1305804998,
-0.4932360053,
0.6315411329,
0.143236056,
-0.9465105534,
0.2449494302,
-0.0438453704,
0.2956570685,
0.5046310425,
0.3564147055,
-0.0984570235,
1.1826833487,
0.3717201054,
-0.0134064518,
0.3920980096,
0.1235618591,
0.5137404203,
-0.5361167192,
-0.2427876294,
-0.4039112031,
0.001096417,
-0.588098526,
-0.4578659236,
0.4488222599,
-0.0854944214,
-0.3544311523,
0.3616808355,
-0.1249471903,
0.3244583905,
0.2660166919,
0.1166653931,
0.268158406,
0.0808156878,
0.1096987277,
-0.2059986442,
-0.6004682183,
-0.8720422387,
1.19711411,
0.4183511138,
1.470946312,
0.3885307312,
0.6323508024,
0.2808097601,
0.3914377689,
-0.6595370173,
0.8065366745,
-0.0982748792,
-0.9063289762,
-0.2490656972,
-0.4020139277,
-1.2718352079,
0.2217964828,
-0.2812547684,
-0.8028842211,
-0.3775894344,
0.0540839173,
-0.1466372162,
0.9447889328,
-0.6749805808,
0.6167896986,
-0.4988273382,
-0.4508967102,
-0.1827040315,
-0.6161312461,
0.7779148817,
-0.3794652224,
0.6027604938,
-0.0038334334,
0.0493159406,
0.6615536809,
-0.0861246958,
1.1732847691,
0.1409213841,
-0.5792586803,
0.3356666565,
0.699824214,
0.580085516,
-0.1875256747,
-0.0114111798,
0.0440462194,
-0.2151970118,
-0.2954971194,
-0.2194728702,
0.690849185,
-0.5672681928,
-1.1937788725,
-0.5243449807,
-0.3931018412,
-0.1383453757,
0.2652118504,
0.0778622925,
0.326646626,
-0.1384101659,
0.0710847899,
0.9561551213,
-0.5648511648,
0.420398742,
0.1552620828,
-0.3872346878,
-0.2732792199,
0.6944394708,
0.0421152264,
0.6824559569,
0.1265097708,
-0.0611745194,
-0.3536435664,
-0.8354763985,
-0.1842583418,
0.2932020724,
-0.8044116497,
-0.1948439479,
-0.598554492,
-0.3381660879,
-0.3406543434,
-0.3477509618,
-0.2725088596,
0.1095665097,
-0.3681516945,
-0.3939235806,
0.249095872,
0.8563304543,
-0.0330439284,
0.2362059653,
-1.0936609507,
0.0519634299,
0.3606928587,
0.1458699107,
-0.0297534391,
-0.4550605118,
-0.12523444,
-0.1269389838,
-0.311095506,
-1.2969022989,
0.2153825909,
-0.3027436733,
0.5980334282,
0.5883039832,
0.4086263776,
-0.086183846,
-0.7111597657,
0.8316796422,
0.4443255365,
-0.6704272032,
0.5957225561,
-0.789771378,
0.0787918195,
0.348264575,
0.6962000132,
-0.613006413,
-0.4620536566,
-0.5720536709,
-0.9748830199,
0.5750597715,
0.0853475407,
0.5711504817,
-0.3772123456,
-0.0807116181,
0.2186352164,
0.1558679491,
-0.9819578528,
-0.0196702462,
0.1143024638,
-0.0240477752,
-0.0743214935,
-0.7470312715,
-0.3427056968,
0.3276224732,
0.7522094846,
0.1173554584,
-0.1688042879,
-0.2534276247,
-0.0982628167,
-0.3872184753,
0.5782721639,
0.2193228602,
0.2831390798,
-0.1039484441,
0.7853051424,
-0.0015273304,
-0.4114124179,
0.2243899852,
-0.3851796985,
-0.3358888626,
-0.1533100009,
0.5084127784,
0.6912753582,
0.4931529164,
-0.8701525927,
0.5604041815,
0.2362028211,
-0.0250158366,
0.1065049767,
0.2132490426,
0.2866570055,
-0.0432499424,
0.0686646998,
0.1262501925,
-0.2203778028,
-0.739784658,
0.3744898736,
0.4764740169,
-0.1878665537,
-0.3662821949,
0.7384856343,
0.3088762164,
-0.2698970735,
0.2493426949,
0.0314576328,
-0.5518404245,
0.2885157466,
0.5672445893,
0.7983180285,
-0.4697282314,
0.4270781577,
0.4059181213,
0.7807895541,
-0.0160908066,
0.1888679266,
0.6398700476,
-0.6668248773,
-0.2200035304,
-0.3809030056,
-0.2866093516,
0.2633956671,
-0.6325765848,
0.285395354,
-0.5588907599,
-0.2510978281,
-0.3157294095,
-0.6423190832,
-0.0756053999,
0.0531752668,
0.3718264997,
0.7160384655,
-1.0114395618,
0.4891641736,
0.5109100938,
-0.2160540521,
-0.7132518291,
0.2870391905,
0.0234515853,
-0.4089736044,
0.4545272291,
0.0435259752,
-0.212430954,
-0.2775254846,
-0.7532169223,
-0.8006132245,
0.5746744275,
0.4829536676,
-0.4362493753,
-0.1513331383,
0.5756132007,
0.3143140376,
0.1212156117,
-0.2134082019,
0.4144344032,
0.2259030193,
0.1303667128,
-0.7718371749,
0.5035561919,
-0.0454813689,
-0.0186691172,
0.2874623835,
-0.6079393029,
1.028296113,
-0.1998477578,
-0.437990427,
-0.4068760574,
0.1643259376,
0.3697545826,
-0.0454752482,
0.580933392,
0.2531682551,
0.2975641489,
0.1088194549,
1.0247385502,
-0.0282810647,
0.2243730873,
1.0366407633,
-0.3953002989,
1.1645858288,
0.8019220829,
-0.1190389395,
0.3210507035,
0.4719974101,
0.1533697397,
0.6146087646,
0.3611248434,
-0.296354115,
-0.4657171071,
0.0896761268,
-0.3272851706,
0.2181597352,
0.3802538812,
-0.3544525206,
-0.4594910145,
-0.0435964279,
0.8354302645,
0.074996911,
-0.2037680894,
0.5106289387,
0.3155913651,
-0.5305893421,
0.4447493851,
0.0841313079,
0.7675736547,
-0.6943178177,
0.1045510545,
0.0589679554,
-0.0104850847,
-0.1278239042,
-0.9053044319,
0.5030617714,
0.2342183888,
0.2725516856,
-0.4463142157,
0.8679135442,
-0.2473639548,
-0.3623272777,
0.611745894,
0.4644018412,
-0.028562475,
0.0617786124,
-0.3585683703,
0.2269007564,
-0.0022217094,
-0.4821608961,
0.6355115175,
0.2606465518,
-0.2349959165,
0.6366422772,
0.691704154,
0.0917135179,
0.2720658481,
-0.2370461226,
1.0268189907,
-0.5797780752,
-0.3965785801,
-0.9102484584,
0.6915379763,
-0.0109139318,
-0.091464065,
0.8622082472,
0.2979075313,
0.8868966699,
-0.2196011245,
0.9409608245,
0.103535831,
0.2544810176,
-0.7750664353,
1.2593276501,
-0.4169558883,
0.4591296613,
-0.496870786,
-0.5422329903,
-0.3497756422,
-0.0023965312,
-0.5098449588,
-0.1419338435,
0.7255943418,
0.8790792227,
0.1048112065,
-0.3068479598,
0.2702307105,
0.5861365199,
0.7179543376,
0.6654831767,
1.1174755096,
-0.3547521234,
0.9418962002,
0.2145814598,
-0.0825496688,
-0.3895049989,
-0.9451391101,
-1.1567215919,
-0.4039953053,
-0.3756835759,
-0.686439991,
0.1239379495,
0.4512657225,
0.3244183362,
-0.7825651169,
-0.2273987532,
0.2035879642,
0.1622426659,
0.3610502779,
-0.2008075565,
0.2847165167,
-0.034431152,
-0.5071852207,
0.2760940492,
0.2224516869,
0.2043601722,
-0.4921010733,
0.0101776719,
-0.2567553222,
0.3246010244,
0.5819071531,
0.0792904794,
-0.6404877305,
-0.670204699,
-0.1586952806,
-0.543033123,
-0.2200657129,
0.5428034067,
-0.1209482327,
0.2201367468,
0.4119400084,
0.6470328569,
0.2242538333,
-0.249306947,
0.6446688175,
-0.4912344217,
-0.0048845103,
0.2075505555,
0.4171014428,
0.4103454649,
-0.5024863482,
0.165981099,
0.0391379893,
-0.2583550215,
-0.9018556476,
0.5682833195,
-1.1006776094,
-0.4218036532,
1.7326842546,
-0.1618370861,
-0.3431724906,
-0.22324799,
-0.5991491079,
0.1526414007,
-0.135553658,
1.0115351677,
0.577881515,
0.185824737,
0.0247433521,
-0.7010782361,
0.6080989838,
0.2101837844,
-1.0241928101,
0.0676601306,
0.4146440625,
0.5380869508,
0.01293578,
0.3390733898,
-0.4719237387,
0.0647225007,
0.159494102,
0.0450139008,
0.2247458845,
-0.2978448868,
-0.08459308,
0.40303424,
0.1478529572,
0.0627552494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14643v2
|
Exploring ChatGPT and its Impact on Society
| 2024-02-21T16:44:35 | 2024-03-25T05:35:12 |
Md. Asraful Haque, Shuai Li
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68Txx
|
Artificial intelligence has been around for a while, but suddenly it has
received more attention than ever before. Thanks to innovations from companies
like Google, Microsoft, Meta, and other major brands in technology. OpenAI,
though, has triggered the button with its ground-breaking invention ChatGPT.
ChatGPT is a Large Language Model (LLM) based on Transformer architecture that
has the ability to generate human-like responses in a conversational context.
It uses deep learning algorithms to generate natural language responses to
input text. Its large number of parameters, contextual generation, and
open-domain training make it a versatile and effective tool for a wide range of
applications, from chatbots to customer service to language translation. It has
the potential to revolutionize various industries and transform the way we
interact with technology. However, the use of ChatGPT has also raised several
concerns, including ethical, social, and employment challenges, which must be
carefully considered to ensure the responsible use of this technology. The
article provides an overview of ChatGPT, delving into its architecture and
training process. It highlights the potential impacts of ChatGPT on the
society. In this paper, we suggest some approaches involving technology,
regulation, education, and ethics in an effort to maximize ChatGPT's benefits
while minimizing its negative impacts. This study is expected to contribute to
a greater understanding of ChatGPT and aid in predicting the potential changes
it may bring about.
|
[
-0.4267860353,
-0.8404259086,
0.1854435802,
-0.0992887989,
0.0150496876,
0.1685373187,
-0.1025928333,
-0.5752208233,
-0.0867024064,
0.4176225364,
-0.3261657655,
0.0930380598,
-0.737201333,
-0.2428942323,
-0.4034445286,
1.0533338785,
0.2797552049,
-0.0245643891,
0.2599852085,
0.1505950689,
-0.4606683552,
-0.8894951344,
-0.9062066674,
-0.5122457147,
0.3507184088,
0.318649441,
0.7157111764,
0.269043982,
0.55297786,
0.2969201207,
-0.2801187932,
-0.3072336912,
-0.8225952983,
-0.237175256,
0.2865253687,
-0.5008344054,
-0.2692372799,
0.2798880041,
0.5121200681,
0.4312087297,
-0.1321385056,
0.1440669596,
0.2258289307,
0.5816488266,
-0.203534618,
0.3514077067,
-0.4949682951,
0.0912935659,
-0.3100704551,
-0.168585524,
-0.1174079776,
-0.4520002604,
0.3068566918,
-0.031411171,
0.0425661653,
-0.0724483579,
0.6683332324,
0.2777554989,
-0.4511117935,
-0.3394554853,
-0.9429693222,
0.5655348301,
-0.4727172852,
0.5010691881,
0.0355669484,
0.5001218915,
-0.3383004963,
-0.8589037061,
-0.5403848886,
-0.2161435038,
-0.0076640435,
0.235804379,
-0.0419808887,
-0.032468453,
0.0999356508,
0.4663005769,
-0.5180776715,
0.0099517703,
-0.7561899424,
-0.0633594543,
0.3968450725,
0.0765013993,
0.6177626848,
-0.0506643094,
-0.2607082129,
-0.0181099251,
-0.9387270808,
0.1352642924,
0.5291018486,
0.2201723754,
0.0622206517,
0.5781123638,
-0.1135815457,
0.3024589121,
-0.3171788454,
0.2129641473,
-0.0508724824,
0.0034127375,
-0.2122170925,
0.2179544866,
0.7299689054,
0.1210300997,
0.5450619459,
-0.1697662473,
0.0062798569,
0.2204842418,
0.4148656726,
-0.8620585203,
-0.1240031272,
0.0790384784,
-0.33452335,
-0.4632415771,
0.1060980409,
-0.7320564389,
-0.5080645084,
-0.3782671392,
0.0737858936,
-0.3033953607,
-0.3106682897,
0.1299016327,
0.09792649,
0.7370218039,
0.3981390893,
-1.0655705929,
0.1470682472,
1.1107531786,
0.932312429,
0.0728975162,
-0.046390783,
-0.1524534672,
-0.0469941832,
-0.0940767378,
0.7283133268,
-0.6228308082,
-0.5747691989,
-0.0561360233,
-0.229017958,
-0.0161036905,
-0.2728026807,
0.3337191343,
-0.5343598127,
0.3118039072,
0.0805923864,
-0.3168492019,
-0.1897588819,
0.4225663543,
-0.4463780224,
0.7480598688,
-0.3932076991,
-0.685931325,
0.2318353802,
-1.1561294794,
-0.5564226508,
0.4663761258,
-0.1876543164,
-0.3299814165,
-0.0946158618,
-0.0171428248,
0.3279680908,
-0.1653651595,
0.4023815691,
0.1222774535,
-0.4488418698,
0.4004466534,
-0.862013936,
0.8768888712,
0.1553798765,
-0.3489863276,
-0.0505636781,
-0.4719824493,
-0.1543927491,
0.0981129929,
-0.3856926858,
-0.0013812956,
0.0880807266,
0.152697131,
0.1280158907,
0.1037698686,
-0.6329948306,
0.0809491351,
-0.4483647943,
1.0480270386,
0.8932893276,
0.1099952087,
0.3191476762,
-0.294482559,
0.3782547116,
-0.3587409854,
0.5286431909,
-0.1583874375,
-0.8586755991,
-0.5577141643,
0.1047069728,
0.2042472363,
0.6422308087,
-0.3101040125,
0.0662249029,
-0.3094719946,
-0.6131474376,
-0.5266153216,
-0.3689334095,
-0.0763098896,
0.2327433676,
-0.0021728892,
-0.3659225106,
-0.2399597615,
-0.6394392252,
-0.2743568122,
-0.2781039774,
-0.131175831,
0.3821475804,
0.4210906625,
-0.2374938428,
1.0026504993,
-0.488184303,
-0.3806930184,
-0.3430853188,
-0.0327842943,
0.1994432509,
0.4620162845,
-0.0334432684,
-1.0437918901,
-0.3757946193,
0.1592451036,
-0.4952403605,
0.1463673264,
-0.2407184988,
-0.1195109487,
-0.1533838511,
0.328437835,
-0.7200582027,
0.4074640572,
0.3311732411,
-0.0110180695,
0.476697892,
-0.1176451668,
0.301620096,
-1.1185412407,
0.2415006608,
-0.0866398141,
-0.0049500992,
-0.9397242665,
-0.1295712292,
-0.2542549372,
-0.5851627588,
-0.6525965333,
0.6124170423,
0.0436528437,
-0.0824365616,
-0.2224967331,
0.1759980768,
-0.4414228201,
0.3332594037,
-0.024957763,
0.9666964412,
0.2448894382,
-0.4185158312,
0.2594177127,
0.4742589593,
-0.238740921,
0.3784432411,
-0.8672170043,
0.4910616577,
-0.0099202953,
0.1437409967,
-0.6146250963,
-0.2237303257,
0.5309739709,
-0.688141644,
-0.0405635573,
-0.0156391393,
-0.5378478765,
-0.1348503977,
-0.0798957199,
0.2357640713,
0.7121778131,
-0.4453624189,
0.4113287628,
0.6613271832,
-0.1439155787,
-0.3844463527,
-0.7220317721,
0.4838698208,
-0.2658994794,
-0.764460206,
0.0729455203,
0.0710099116,
-0.2626457214,
-0.3270958066,
0.0381504856,
-0.1903713346,
0.3500147164,
0.3790999651,
0.1910015643,
-0.0599402115,
0.1438232362,
-0.3501918018,
-0.4584027827,
0.0931160152,
-0.2666915655,
0.887593627,
-0.5694046021,
-0.4502399862,
-0.3644234538,
0.2160995454,
0.4860099554,
-0.3724135458,
0.5226112604,
0.5568009615,
-0.1814696491,
0.1375134289,
-0.3817709386,
-0.2395355701,
-0.5344862938,
0.4774309993,
0.0720089525,
-0.9868199825,
0.2627845109,
-0.3340269923,
0.2664705217,
0.0771254003,
0.6450977921,
0.0734080672,
0.7674916983,
0.698497951,
-0.2405507118,
0.7683665156,
-0.0159706045,
0.696402669,
-0.6928039789,
-0.1782399863,
-0.5237534046,
-0.1616347432,
-0.9091556668,
-0.1991428286,
0.4363479316,
-0.3922878504,
-0.4346097708,
0.1413512379,
-0.5801882148,
0.5437861085,
0.8522729278,
0.1431922317,
0.467864126,
-0.3439236283,
0.5981715322,
0.2840006053,
-0.5673689842,
-0.9152439833,
0.8965530396,
0.4777010679,
0.8328483701,
0.0318289325,
0.6014304757,
0.4385000765,
0.3873257637,
-0.9541236758,
0.6006634235,
-0.0674953237,
-0.5231385231,
-0.3781399131,
-0.346463114,
-1.1072180271,
-0.0114021907,
0.0083723627,
-0.7109541297,
-0.2305012643,
-0.0124094402,
0.0373231731,
0.270917654,
-0.7777257562,
0.7961673141,
-0.4461817443,
-0.169987902,
-0.2174288183,
-0.6734324694,
0.155167222,
0.0576995164,
0.0849467441,
0.0172621459,
0.3198517263,
0.5997992754,
-0.0295788758,
1.2900089025,
0.0889514014,
-0.1178458408,
0.2867628336,
-0.2060913593,
0.3526358306,
0.036397066,
0.1290072203,
0.5201248527,
-0.0718457252,
-0.2031226456,
-0.3136293888,
0.4103403389,
-0.9892199039,
-0.6110698581,
-0.2692824304,
-0.4732904136,
-0.1629842967,
0.2185224146,
0.0989274234,
0.3573374748,
-0.6346037388,
0.0885139108,
0.7765683532,
-0.4210776985,
0.3362910151,
0.0779325143,
-0.1346616447,
-0.0098193577,
0.9631027579,
0.1357212961,
0.204025507,
0.2478805333,
0.2905579209,
-0.0650336966,
-0.0670281574,
-0.4872363508,
0.0415953919,
-0.7639065385,
0.2754344642,
-0.4961857498,
-0.477565527,
-0.4286839366,
-0.1528513432,
-0.3491473496,
-0.0630117729,
-0.1242362633,
0.1155087575,
0.1233815774,
0.9691048265,
0.3010513484,
0.5052723885,
-0.6991186142,
-0.0322626568,
0.6749382615,
0.5762492418,
0.0075572357,
0.0025962999,
0.0192458257,
0.1980496198,
-0.4217525721,
-0.4883742929,
0.2211576104,
0.1647739708,
0.5421749949,
0.2342115492,
-0.0469705723,
0.146591261,
-0.6690460443,
0.968174696,
0.0071234545,
-0.781062901,
0.4590508044,
-0.3358958364,
0.274354279,
0.0938632563,
0.1499353647,
-1.2932897806,
-0.3258941174,
-0.5730154514,
-0.8070446849,
0.4706471562,
0.5125058889,
0.7112106681,
0.1312126368,
0.2307341546,
0.0762241334,
0.0638237521,
-0.8525668979,
-0.0142119247,
-0.2645715773,
0.0141320834,
0.2125720978,
-0.0497034155,
0.0448661037,
0.1591696888,
0.7683002353,
0.1185227782,
0.5430239439,
-0.0757654905,
-0.027379686,
0.2581523061,
0.5661646724,
0.5507520437,
0.2505245507,
0.1144819409,
-0.149246797,
0.0820452943,
-0.7798762321,
-0.0385184325,
-0.1926621944,
-0.2323146909,
-0.3391100764,
0.0437774509,
0.7031142712,
-0.0360144228,
-0.57280761,
0.4338136315,
-0.1848958433,
-0.167180866,
-0.4288594127,
0.0788659975,
-0.0234642494,
0.4621112645,
0.3931793571,
0.1639083326,
0.0507532917,
-0.5077983141,
0.1807514578,
0.5059762001,
-0.5512536168,
-0.1794262975,
0.6303457618,
0.371104151,
-0.7439889312,
0.59849751,
0.2946827412,
-0.7961864471,
0.7033649087,
0.3920649886,
0.9697887897,
-0.1079539806,
0.2505140603,
-0.0575929247,
0.5183666348,
-0.0451095812,
-0.1820373088,
-0.0222741794,
-0.811175108,
-0.3437033594,
-0.3833133578,
-0.7507851124,
-0.0021293117,
-0.1190408766,
0.3806194961,
-0.3362704813,
-0.0802061334,
-0.2199590653,
-0.2032645494,
-0.5886524916,
-0.0298970826,
0.292189002,
0.6052266955,
-0.6289519072,
0.7620095015,
0.5972962379,
-0.3445822895,
-0.5992358327,
0.4628091753,
0.0121381646,
-1.0804461241,
0.6695665121,
0.5635887384,
-0.238484323,
0.218146503,
-0.5950350165,
-0.6103230119,
0.8456704021,
0.1784737706,
-0.2078861743,
0.0698309466,
0.6536540389,
0.6389390826,
0.0269925985,
0.246238336,
0.5270757079,
0.4232539535,
0.135362938,
-0.8744273782,
-0.1874321699,
-0.3015370965,
0.1525007635,
0.3845832348,
-0.7278727293,
0.6549613476,
0.0492314026,
-0.4512403607,
-0.304171443,
0.2907085419,
-0.2747487128,
0.0630525425,
0.1130699068,
0.0691252127,
0.5645744801,
-0.0557544529,
0.9421582818,
-0.346272409,
0.490963906,
0.7555444837,
-0.1243421435,
0.5668063164,
0.3825607598,
-0.2299720347,
-0.0243007466,
0.6369268298,
-0.0944038779,
0.2976076603,
0.3702737987,
-0.3671694994,
0.1253516078,
-0.1574077457,
-0.305326432,
0.6394651532,
0.3587240279,
-0.0816038772,
-0.2621146739,
0.1444135755,
0.0427412689,
-0.2925500274,
-0.3725070655,
0.9289907813,
0.1571851522,
-0.4260791242,
0.0213785358,
-0.2071506381,
0.784317553,
-0.3844825625,
-0.1763462722,
-0.2047365308,
0.0930059105,
-0.0279945619,
-0.8398086429,
0.4819481075,
0.0338253155,
0.3184051216,
-0.4001856446,
0.9360717535,
-0.1814153939,
-0.2489579469,
0.0292230193,
0.5092847347,
0.3033928573,
-0.2414301187,
-0.501748085,
-0.0922369435,
-0.1083666459,
-0.3084349036,
0.4618719518,
0.4538536072,
0.0506990291,
0.8769843578,
0.5986561179,
-0.1679115444,
-0.0191029217,
-0.0990578234,
0.7693379521,
-0.4104137123,
-0.5439525247,
-0.9226036072,
0.3632592857,
-0.0066740131,
-0.3047585785,
0.4227209985,
0.3167648017,
0.7234873176,
0.1368846893,
1.0774352551,
-0.3755628765,
0.0984224975,
-0.208611235,
1.0253660679,
-0.2062371075,
0.3960253,
-0.0301280413,
-0.7004748583,
-0.3847012818,
0.425031513,
-0.697905302,
-0.0105436984,
0.2026586384,
0.6994140744,
0.1114657298,
0.4819088876,
0.4060174227,
-0.0163327958,
0.7491076589,
0.3505184054,
0.8341125846,
-0.3042878807,
0.8987891078,
-0.115950115,
-0.3398342729,
-0.1015944332,
-0.7140057683,
-0.7658205628,
-0.5067600608,
-0.0930501968,
-0.0587906763,
0.1262577474,
0.886213243,
0.5322226882,
-0.6224996448,
-0.265322566,
-0.2257101387,
0.0603525937,
-0.0613672286,
-0.2639717162,
0.1588180512,
-0.3511325121,
-0.7065736651,
0.1037801281,
0.3361324072,
0.1295319796,
-0.3093575835,
0.0185546838,
-0.0514574386,
-0.1504227966,
0.7311254144,
0.261990428,
-0.4596357644,
-0.6502063274,
0.0142532317,
-0.1044258401,
0.3888966143,
0.843757987,
-0.6214202642,
0.2468435764,
0.2800899744,
0.9470282793,
0.3994068503,
-0.2201165408,
0.8208708763,
-0.4501063526,
-0.005535196,
0.373441875,
0.0566943996,
0.1916014552,
-0.6932374835,
0.7966529727,
0.1363909096,
-1.0147863626,
-0.539917171,
0.4026352167,
-0.7426162958,
-0.1865402311,
1.0199308395,
0.0565840565,
-0.2292233855,
-0.306976676,
-0.5879020095,
0.3095178306,
-0.614394486,
1.2097343206,
0.4189253151,
-0.2881692946,
-0.5315622091,
-0.9803748131,
0.2138989121,
0.1347020417,
-0.924859345,
0.2206609994,
0.1720012426,
0.220812887,
0.0318746455,
0.5679160357,
-0.149322778,
0.0749760717,
-0.0198829472,
0.1800683439,
0.0725278854,
0.0678162128,
-0.2286465019,
0.1839850992,
-0.0652316734,
-0.2078995556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13919v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13919v3
|
SYNFAC-EDIT: Synthetic Imitation Edit Feedback for Factual Alignment in Clinical Summarization
| 2024-02-21T16:33:22 | 2024-04-18T16:50:43 |
Prakamya Mishra, Zonghai Yao, Parth Vashisht, Feiyun Ouyang, Beining Wang, Vidhi Dhaval Mody, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT & Llama have demonstrated
significant achievements in summarization tasks but struggle with factual
inaccuracies, a critical issue in clinical NLP applications where errors could
lead to serious consequences. To counter the high costs and limited
availability of expert-annotated data for factual alignment, this study
introduces an innovative pipeline that utilizes >100B parameter GPT variants
like GPT-3.5 & GPT-4 to act as synthetic experts to generate high-quality
synthetics feedback aimed at enhancing factual consistency in clinical note
summarization. Our research primarily focuses on edit feedback generated by
these synthetic feedback experts without additional human annotations,
mirroring and optimizing the practical scenario in which medical professionals
refine AI system outputs. Although such 100B+ parameter GPT variants have
proven to demonstrate expertise in various clinical NLP tasks, such as the
Medical Licensing Examination, there is scant research on their capacity to act
as synthetic feedback experts and deliver expert-level edit feedback for
improving the generation quality of weaker (<10B parameter) LLMs like GPT-2
(1.5B) & Llama 2 (7B) in clinical domain. So in this work, we leverage 100B+
GPT variants to act as synthetic feedback experts offering expert-level edit
feedback, that is used to reduce hallucinations and align weaker (<10B
parameter) LLMs with medical facts using two distinct alignment algorithms (DPO
& SALT), endeavoring to narrow the divide between AI-generated content and
factual accuracy. This highlights the substantial potential of LLM-based
synthetic edits in enhancing the alignment of clinical factuality.
|
[
-0.1676257402,
-0.7831037641,
0.9340608716,
0.0430275165,
-0.2282411158,
0.3914681077,
-0.1246810481,
-0.6866939068,
0.7207723856,
0.3478069007,
-0.5327338576,
-0.4418170154,
-0.662658453,
0.425540626,
-0.1849479526,
1.2766298056,
-0.2898617983,
0.4658949375,
-0.2155817598,
-0.247601077,
-0.3926012814,
-0.5282534361,
-0.5967608094,
-0.0244364776,
0.558400631,
0.1827168912,
0.8858718276,
0.612195313,
0.49938941,
0.3851644993,
-0.0657313839,
0.6504052877,
-0.2409013957,
-0.0870056003,
-0.2918330133,
-0.2963264585,
-1.1546032429,
-0.0491726138,
0.4873577356,
0.4446131289,
-0.2059360147,
-0.0005567396,
-0.1040156111,
0.643397212,
-0.3525232673,
0.0614250004,
-0.4965287447,
-0.0539366938,
0.0108898785,
-0.3238058686,
-0.372669369,
-0.4388429821,
0.0470207892,
-0.7286387086,
0.4663794339,
0.0036075178,
0.7294868231,
0.4760777354,
-0.28037709,
-0.3705680668,
-0.6476639509,
0.2272437662,
-1.2122482061,
0.130586192,
-0.071992889,
0.1355068982,
-0.2608884275,
-0.820004642,
-1.0100028515,
-0.1570724547,
-0.3239297867,
0.4724357426,
0.3261462152,
0.4011112452,
0.191438362,
0.3309307396,
-0.4278951585,
0.0194145814,
-0.3247681558,
-0.4179439545,
0.8726231456,
0.3267480135,
0.2547124326,
0.0063997097,
-0.1587725133,
0.2256103456,
-0.5731593966,
-0.3962275386,
0.155152753,
0.155995056,
-0.0366875939,
0.7906243801,
-0.190024823,
0.6401413679,
0.4455454946,
-0.4769601524,
0.2713859379,
-0.601785183,
-0.1089190021,
0.4097654521,
0.8298264146,
0.5793754458,
-0.0572830476,
-0.0854725763,
-0.1482112408,
0.0590214916,
0.4363432825,
-0.4627891183,
-0.1840006113,
0.4418536723,
-0.2681273222,
-0.4162043333,
0.1465933025,
-0.7503566146,
-0.5131488442,
-0.6582899094,
0.5203197598,
-0.27981022,
0.194508031,
0.065772891,
0.06254334,
-0.1608529836,
0.8320586681,
-0.9163011909,
0.4492337108,
0.6533004045,
0.8342431188,
-0.365565449,
-0.147077173,
-0.4711262584,
0.2541653216,
-0.2251973152,
0.8024912477,
-0.1860903949,
-0.2445184737,
-0.1905735731,
0.02530366,
-0.064135246,
-0.3943815231,
0.4439455271,
-0.3482534587,
0.3717939854,
-0.269666642,
-0.5815938115,
-0.0513291694,
0.0834767595,
-0.5111399889,
0.6912126541,
0.1655989736,
-0.761869967,
0.3304935396,
-0.4374430478,
-0.3960555196,
0.0609471127,
-0.2813158631,
-0.4756869376,
0.024448188,
0.5252709985,
0.0475805923,
0.0490849167,
0.3114796877,
-0.1167092845,
-0.3249349296,
0.319878161,
-0.2892878652,
0.3963817954,
-0.0960488617,
-0.5389712453,
0.3416315615,
-0.8195462823,
-0.1307558566,
-0.2010013163,
-0.0422225967,
-0.063755095,
-0.2131431252,
-0.0978305489,
0.3723506033,
0.224945575,
-0.606883049,
0.4121456444,
-0.4421691597,
-0.0195120219,
0.7325373888,
0.3491884768,
0.1082944199,
-0.6333091259,
0.723105073,
-0.12395183,
0.1373583227,
0.1619014442,
-0.5525043011,
-0.6732561588,
-0.6107468009,
0.5131940246,
0.6197062731,
-0.665723443,
0.3581767976,
-0.1986036748,
-0.4967880845,
-1.1387776136,
0.2187935412,
0.2918210328,
0.9186792374,
0.5893315673,
-0.2865992486,
-0.6626549959,
-0.8611210585,
-0.2406694144,
-0.2028233558,
0.113046661,
0.0794939473,
0.3102312684,
-0.2521982193,
0.9250760078,
-0.4074031115,
-0.4193570018,
-0.2071162909,
-0.0158705376,
0.2598519921,
0.4151589572,
0.3610677719,
-0.3905923069,
-0.4460886419,
-0.1742120534,
-0.663900435,
-0.4066915512,
-0.5705150962,
-0.0218524877,
0.5099331141,
0.3497524261,
-0.8680927753,
0.4617527425,
0.4780699611,
-0.2029908597,
0.7124089003,
-0.4515624344,
0.3518253267,
-1.1492441893,
0.1539349258,
-0.3205899596,
-0.2859738469,
-0.4985155165,
-0.1067672372,
-0.0031628439,
0.3286054134,
-0.2483644038,
0.4950630069,
-0.3018678129,
0.15277417,
-0.2543178201,
0.349953264,
-0.0532823093,
0.4046227038,
0.1445358694,
0.6563446522,
0.0263020303,
-0.1237961352,
0.4228044748,
0.6042574048,
-0.0047864369,
0.5066301823,
-0.7087849379,
0.2162031978,
-0.019635804,
0.6283742189,
-0.8137230277,
-0.4685195684,
0.2334537804,
-0.4302529693,
0.3054736853,
0.0094074793,
-0.6558074355,
-0.0371504165,
-0.3339055181,
0.1959213167,
0.5153381228,
-0.3338659704,
0.5838704109,
0.2999357879,
-0.5417346954,
-0.7360962629,
-0.4543133676,
0.2546181679,
0.2302924544,
-0.5138140321,
0.5267984867,
0.0582089499,
-0.1753786504,
-0.1108148992,
-0.2965759933,
0.2828999758,
-0.304526031,
0.1769330949,
0.752402544,
-0.3069009185,
-0.0880746543,
0.3557639122,
-0.0678419098,
0.1090702415,
0.0247361343,
0.1877738982,
0.0980322957,
-0.4225620329,
-0.8005799055,
0.175377652,
0.7027264833,
-0.0657851174,
0.7396310568,
0.430721581,
-0.2797538936,
-0.0170421656,
-0.7884523273,
-0.2623102069,
-0.4580538869,
0.2686107457,
0.0222285353,
-0.8243835568,
0.5901765227,
0.1668951958,
0.1446660608,
0.6009410024,
0.8323882818,
-0.2789672911,
1.0293710232,
0.0248374026,
0.3100386262,
-0.1044049636,
-0.0056643179,
0.1430225074,
-0.8596131802,
-0.391699791,
-0.0737321153,
-0.394777149,
-0.4740776718,
-0.3830128312,
0.6600610018,
-0.1155262962,
0.2050639987,
0.0846044868,
-0.341170013,
0.3553672731,
0.3174023032,
0.4431138337,
0.5176739693,
-0.3297682703,
-0.0847888067,
-0.0923861638,
-0.6323778629,
-0.4624209106,
1.095012784,
0.3066257834,
0.5498161316,
0.0649412349,
0.6054524779,
0.3135453761,
0.5270009637,
-0.6228860021,
0.526602149,
-0.0029237848,
-0.512083292,
-0.1095388755,
-0.1221313477,
-0.3360055685,
0.0839721039,
-0.5187218189,
-0.4689798057,
0.1344357431,
0.4838112295,
-0.543976903,
0.2892791033,
-0.5121424794,
0.7503698468,
-0.1129029766,
-0.4097112119,
-0.2886342704,
-0.8752651811,
0.3216840327,
-0.3465009034,
0.0755974576,
0.2463957667,
-0.2221776098,
0.4272812307,
-1.0238326788,
0.9485698938,
-0.1047048643,
-0.2569229305,
0.1679297686,
0.1659243703,
0.7711973786,
0.4351944029,
0.1429717392,
0.0279321652,
0.0532583855,
-0.2479531616,
-0.9053878784,
0.5409215689,
-0.6020869017,
-0.8816518784,
-0.5533175468,
-0.6333010197,
-0.4867376387,
0.0259484667,
0.2191672474,
0.5445337892,
-0.0168603212,
-0.2559005022,
0.2835580707,
-0.0596705563,
-0.0065100514,
0.5839738846,
0.0198863577,
-0.7905696034,
0.6245999932,
-0.064705655,
0.4695040286,
0.308834523,
-0.0186754502,
-0.3002162874,
-0.9295602441,
-0.5960649252,
0.6324742436,
-0.599429369,
-0.2171095312,
-0.7856791615,
-0.2595456243,
-0.602824688,
-0.4115744829,
-0.4420794845,
-0.8114349246,
-0.1481350809,
-0.2431398779,
0.3580053151,
0.7233577967,
-0.1590911001,
0.3359310627,
-0.8276098967,
0.4293728173,
0.0420549102,
0.1944865882,
-0.2392400801,
-0.6418787837,
-0.1988105923,
0.1001513526,
-0.2865884006,
-0.8544694781,
0.3529421389,
-0.0349463746,
0.3111424446,
0.3086621463,
-0.0042352625,
0.9409063458,
-0.4157463014,
0.8277022839,
0.0076181027,
-0.9482024908,
0.3499863744,
-0.3487630486,
0.138713181,
0.7583530545,
0.1567272097,
-0.4077299833,
-0.7492507696,
-0.7231765389,
-0.561786592,
0.6254858375,
0.1756459773,
-0.2826599777,
0.0883979872,
0.560387969,
0.3993099332,
0.1979938,
-0.2913775146,
-0.1172356755,
-0.1742446572,
-0.6086552739,
-0.0245079268,
-0.1619616896,
-0.3870769739,
-0.3667892516,
0.8344464898,
-0.2038671523,
0.0572926477,
0.7561856508,
-0.0449627228,
-0.0851414651,
0.138728112,
1.042086482,
0.7648089528,
-0.358240962,
-0.0047898358,
0.4885124564,
-0.7476171255,
0.1773728132,
0.0112596042,
-0.3360755146,
0.3019892573,
0.7265613079,
0.5929803252,
-0.0273443963,
-0.6964940429,
0.4257510304,
0.136953637,
-0.272300452,
-0.3793081343,
0.1246028095,
-0.0669481605,
0.0974087343,
-0.0698884502,
0.3904418051,
0.0864066035,
-0.4526984394,
0.3587010801,
0.2860845029,
-0.2316702902,
-0.5196064115,
0.8469368815,
0.1865711957,
-0.2185135037,
0.5546779633,
0.0881764218,
-0.433570832,
0.5064129233,
0.5892501473,
0.7927161455,
-0.2074014544,
0.3385666013,
0.2947332859,
0.1284611672,
-0.1664903462,
0.191346392,
0.1579854488,
-0.5380415916,
-0.7297405601,
-0.2328955233,
-0.7274870872,
-0.090055041,
-0.5114065409,
0.5002624393,
-0.6481646299,
-0.1933701783,
0.044664178,
-0.21406883,
-0.2032418549,
0.2361617088,
-0.1189761832,
0.7052006125,
-0.5840591788,
0.7919051051,
0.670686841,
-0.3710453212,
-0.7160651088,
-0.0412042029,
0.4003121853,
-0.7110233903,
0.3675347865,
-0.2575152516,
-0.0457742438,
-0.3087657094,
-0.3312292695,
-0.5983694792,
1.0840801001,
0.3403709233,
-0.4924155772,
-0.2826586962,
0.3534507155,
1.0247052908,
-0.468390584,
0.3447041512,
0.5763925314,
0.4205800295,
0.2136589438,
-1.0717805624,
0.3874331415,
-0.1860778779,
-0.4700247645,
0.0638560355,
-0.6964654922,
0.2752707899,
-0.6328107119,
0.0268677957,
0.2100363225,
0.4913913906,
0.3956001103,
0.3849117458,
0.280036658,
0.437923342,
0.6217665672,
0.1124938428,
0.9855080843,
-0.3539665043,
0.0209813137,
1.4014822245,
-0.4240902662,
0.5547852516,
0.6936389804,
-0.1860783845,
0.5845558047,
0.3458994925,
-0.2223797888,
0.3535535932,
-0.0449973866,
-0.3539761603,
0.0243134126,
0.0679508522,
-0.3134150505,
0.3077203929,
0.1994594485,
-0.4764028788,
0.2893835008,
-0.5401031375,
0.2367446721,
0.0215079337,
-0.0371906199,
1.0445971489,
-0.0601407513,
-0.8087619543,
0.4270291924,
-0.1500459611,
0.3026588559,
-0.547976315,
-0.1550309211,
-0.2677604854,
0.2153244615,
-0.4872254431,
-0.5279964805,
0.4027414918,
-0.0882016867,
-0.0377106704,
0.0437118076,
0.176362887,
-0.528450489,
-0.5225666761,
-0.1756645441,
0.1967649907,
-0.1453235596,
0.2185480595,
-0.4772460759,
-0.188231796,
0.0334697552,
0.002431907,
0.1720394194,
0.2964549363,
0.1191525832,
0.3567739129,
0.7438509464,
0.7840488553,
-0.1699695885,
0.0045868037,
0.7035000324,
-0.5873138905,
-0.3315500915,
-0.8815259933,
0.563329041,
-0.2638285756,
-0.3865945041,
0.549824059,
0.6104503274,
0.5465737581,
-0.2990806401,
0.697170198,
0.0551548786,
0.5660269856,
-0.6845793128,
0.7156850696,
-0.3785670996,
0.2842250764,
-0.5263964534,
-0.8435035348,
-0.3403400183,
0.08527302,
0.088216573,
-0.1189344823,
0.9492333531,
0.9432299733,
0.0948105603,
0.146540612,
-0.0858746693,
0.5622397065,
0.3515668809,
0.2816440165,
0.4788027108,
-0.4493651688,
0.1436723024,
-0.3445491493,
-0.1958759427,
-0.151889503,
-0.6693203449,
-0.8198992014,
-0.3361540437,
-0.6381980181,
-0.640096724,
0.2810108066,
1.1807694435,
0.3940101862,
-1.1359578371,
0.1985701621,
0.0393651687,
-0.1117651165,
-0.4203589261,
-0.1835044324,
0.8177213073,
-0.2344197631,
-0.5471885204,
0.299061507,
0.3726069331,
0.2945772409,
-0.0762899816,
-0.1550347358,
0.069758594,
0.159731552,
0.4108611941,
0.1786782742,
-0.905128181,
-0.3163126707,
-0.0302860644,
-0.0772791281,
0.1370981038,
0.8518180847,
-0.7079524994,
0.5460581183,
0.4839217067,
0.6796405911,
0.1974858046,
0.3372910619,
0.9046027064,
-0.4746516347,
0.0662059039,
0.3527368903,
0.3479954302,
0.2414987981,
-0.5637509823,
0.5468317866,
0.5074315071,
-0.5484349132,
-0.7413290739,
-0.1819383353,
-1.4479699135,
0.0610783584,
1.0245395899,
0.1330524534,
0.052136004,
-0.0747257397,
-0.6343703866,
0.410833478,
-0.2221160531,
1.3133451939,
0.5768719316,
-0.5021524429,
-0.0077101653,
-0.452406168,
0.8479192257,
0.6466168761,
-0.8874911666,
-0.0931446329,
0.5836095214,
0.1756482422,
0.0266600605,
0.5264696479,
-0.5015851259,
0.5508552194,
-0.1369480789,
0.0461339504,
-0.269094348,
-0.0009327703,
-0.2408088893,
-0.0812241659,
-0.1598945707,
0.1819715947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13917v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13917v2
|
Could We Have Had Better Multilingual LLMs If English Was Not the Central Language?
| 2024-02-21T16:32:38 | 2024-04-05T05:26:05 |
Ryandito Diandaru, Lucky Susanto, Zilu Tang, Ayu Purwarianti, Derry Wijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate strong machine translation
capabilities on languages they are trained on. However, the impact of factors
beyond training data size on translation performance remains a topic of debate,
especially concerning languages not directly encountered during training. Our
study delves into Llama2's translation capabilities. By modeling a linear
relationship between linguistic feature distances and machine translation
scores, we ask ourselves if there are potentially better central languages for
LLMs other than English. Our experiments show that the 7B Llama2 model yields
above 10 BLEU when translating into all languages it has seen, which rarely
happens for languages it has not seen. Most translation improvements into
unseen languages come from scaling up the model size rather than instruction
tuning or increasing shot count. Furthermore, our correlation analysis reveals
that syntactic similarity is not the only linguistic factor that strongly
correlates with machine translation scores. Interestingly, we discovered that
under specific circumstances, some languages (e.g. Swedish, Catalan), despite
having significantly less training data, exhibit comparable correlation levels
to English. These insights challenge the prevailing landscape of LLMs,
suggesting that models centered around languages other than English could
provide a more efficient foundation for multilingual applications.
|
[
-0.2653516233,
-0.2258096337,
0.67463094,
0.3040579259,
-0.3710893989,
0.2453619689,
-0.8001963496,
-0.9553316236,
0.271664232,
0.3594071865,
-0.1418494284,
-0.4018626809,
-1.1061627865,
0.4270691276,
-0.3773626387,
0.7312688231,
-0.0631130114,
0.3661350608,
-0.2564508915,
-0.5737035871,
-0.5899330378,
-0.6677827835,
-0.409039855,
-0.7444398403,
0.6500204206,
0.3501577377,
0.622718513,
0.4873747528,
0.8247599602,
0.242971763,
-0.1929332763,
0.3965709805,
-0.4706710577,
-0.0286342483,
-0.0514637642,
-0.9700302482,
-0.4902473688,
-0.0657734498,
0.6974669695,
0.8461239934,
0.1076584235,
0.065571554,
0.1895040721,
0.7439343333,
-0.2224823684,
0.0723351911,
-0.715331912,
-0.069525905,
-0.2449728996,
0.0049813325,
-0.3579304516,
-0.095491305,
-0.077892445,
-0.4172923863,
0.0542115569,
0.1813915372,
0.8370451331,
0.4070364237,
-0.7843043208,
-0.2671964169,
-0.6621753573,
0.9717927575,
-0.6347979307,
0.5331258774,
0.4254309237,
0.2514336407,
-0.0618655607,
-0.3111943901,
-0.4085836411,
-0.2899735868,
-0.3802387416,
-0.0037203045,
-0.3462545872,
-0.1209967211,
0.0825302973,
0.1450523287,
-0.6415450573,
0.4833862782,
-0.5257490277,
0.0675425008,
0.8135586381,
0.1716172099,
0.2568186522,
0.0580108613,
-0.1679139286,
-0.0798337236,
-0.8990573883,
0.2296978682,
0.3586538732,
0.3859772086,
-0.4123646617,
0.6390995979,
0.2373361737,
0.4797197282,
-0.0993053317,
-0.563200295,
0.1668963879,
-0.320450604,
0.1390469074,
0.043626368,
0.6396113634,
0.5313042402,
0.3309693635,
-0.307451725,
-0.1424397826,
0.1502411067,
0.0234648287,
-0.6666040421,
-0.0660057515,
0.1226130128,
-0.4865422249,
0.1891481578,
-0.1533189267,
-0.1613752246,
-0.2548004985,
-0.277728498,
-0.0990639254,
-0.2147022933,
-0.3337321877,
-0.1005884707,
-0.01438988,
0.3202468157,
0.1772263795,
-0.7450842857,
0.2121471763,
0.6630059481,
0.8507786393,
-0.6289314032,
-0.6140334606,
-0.0308677424,
0.029810017,
-0.7722634077,
0.850277245,
-0.6761274338,
-0.5359783769,
-0.1127642468,
-0.0005079138,
-0.0443837829,
-0.6940191984,
-0.0223761033,
-0.4458439648,
-0.0128909219,
-0.5510320663,
-0.2811997831,
-0.3393862545,
0.177447319,
-0.5313364863,
0.9692351818,
-0.2109687179,
-0.525764823,
0.2674337327,
-0.1937214285,
-0.8107374907,
-0.1871291995,
-0.3286641538,
-0.2253585905,
0.3208241463,
0.1111923531,
0.3265901506,
-0.6156335473,
0.3970859051,
-0.2703909576,
-0.2750473917,
0.3429075778,
-0.3945242763,
0.4293065965,
0.0300707594,
-0.2835140824,
-0.2730619311,
-0.6573799849,
-0.0178309269,
0.0290777776,
-0.6077616215,
-0.2439791709,
-0.0324684605,
-0.0514074899,
0.2375256717,
0.4574048519,
-0.4409708977,
0.01260293,
-0.3435445726,
0.3623128831,
0.4003874362,
-0.3984451294,
0.7058870792,
-0.2344709784,
0.5951272249,
-0.046460297,
-0.3409890234,
0.1000674143,
-0.6338676214,
-0.7962086201,
-0.4152633846,
0.1577781737,
0.6026796103,
-0.4347014129,
0.0858274922,
-0.3285851479,
-0.4049390554,
-0.5952616334,
0.5195823312,
0.6232558489,
0.143484354,
0.2659469247,
-0.3720928133,
-0.5965397954,
-1.1260412931,
-0.0292759482,
-0.2172120064,
0.215395093,
0.2404921353,
0.2440674007,
-0.1922105998,
0.4068396389,
-0.1957277209,
-0.3615486324,
-0.7011185288,
-0.469483912,
0.4224470556,
0.0501854308,
0.8616456985,
-0.4910199642,
-0.6026936769,
0.6112632751,
-0.8159685135,
-0.2190466076,
0.2214833647,
-0.0445135236,
0.3276562989,
0.4151453972,
-0.6976907253,
0.1383621842,
1.0270317793,
0.1219504103,
0.300999105,
-0.457733959,
0.0293148682,
-1.1585352421,
0.0713709518,
-0.2029380202,
-0.0406558812,
-0.5228075981,
-0.0518484749,
0.2455891669,
-0.0528724715,
-0.4206488132,
0.6266905069,
-0.5932660103,
-0.3647215664,
-0.5470289588,
0.3061670661,
0.1512010396,
0.3446676731,
0.0867270306,
0.8829884529,
0.5044188499,
-0.5357115269,
0.1372374296,
0.1026925445,
-0.2597262561,
0.6028547287,
-0.6530749798,
-0.0386429243,
-0.1767387241,
0.2660850585,
-1.0617432594,
-0.3017936349,
-0.4334484935,
-0.4173100293,
0.5175673962,
0.0410231575,
-0.3462904096,
-0.2639339268,
-0.0610719174,
0.257711798,
0.407684803,
-0.5761914253,
0.2389518023,
0.3850111961,
-0.1211689636,
-0.5446130037,
-1.1133502722,
0.1600016356,
-0.2906184793,
-0.6814391017,
0.0885851011,
0.0721966997,
-0.4531368911,
-0.159493193,
-0.0268039592,
-0.1662884206,
0.2390112877,
0.1450099498,
0.2137268484,
-0.3979741633,
0.3697213233,
0.0342133343,
-0.068421565,
-0.0701099858,
-0.2313850224,
0.3276774585,
-0.0808615312,
-0.2926517725,
-0.2100280374,
0.5062502027,
0.5721094608,
-0.4868976772,
0.8451892734,
0.5394082665,
-0.2991104722,
-0.0565565713,
-0.4738925695,
-0.0194252282,
-0.3700412512,
0.6348837614,
-0.4487315714,
-1.0026106834,
0.5812894702,
0.1505317837,
0.1075686887,
0.4760794342,
0.76831007,
-0.2210270315,
1.0009566545,
0.8543021679,
-0.2582395077,
0.3752804995,
-0.2170775086,
0.3679111898,
-0.7561234236,
-0.3230955005,
-0.5571426153,
-0.5501875877,
-0.7075289488,
-0.3085904121,
0.4451943636,
0.2881996036,
0.0634716451,
0.4841586649,
-0.1192708164,
0.4936857522,
0.2507069111,
-0.1382533014,
0.3188633323,
0.1556465626,
-0.174759984,
-0.1401493698,
-0.803190887,
-0.5985702872,
1.1333239079,
0.2764164507,
0.6631034017,
0.5422565341,
0.5601625443,
-0.0994147658,
0.2481690943,
-0.5655186176,
0.2242964804,
-0.4397139549,
-0.4746767581,
-0.0758371949,
-0.2555343807,
-1.2086031437,
0.5322132111,
-0.1855700761,
-0.457049638,
-0.0606788136,
-0.079083845,
-0.1270730048,
0.2133272737,
-0.8310950398,
0.5162529349,
-0.6957947612,
-0.1394756734,
-0.3550762832,
-0.5004096627,
0.2650572062,
-0.2952296436,
0.4888914227,
-0.270732522,
-0.231362775,
0.4432574213,
-0.2105067074,
0.8903131485,
0.3585309684,
-0.2958309352,
0.1495354623,
0.0736251548,
0.3100650609,
0.0305197015,
-0.1130567864,
0.5302201509,
-0.1163283437,
-0.6858069897,
-0.4881926477,
0.8566278219,
-1.118715167,
-0.7886348963,
-0.1112551019,
-0.8215087056,
-0.1012927294,
0.1357552856,
0.3564713895,
0.0595638901,
0.1247267723,
0.0752513483,
0.3065115511,
-0.0641755834,
0.5789690018,
0.66992414,
-0.2736586332,
-0.2230071276,
0.6907954812,
0.2803860307,
0.3644877374,
0.4395048916,
0.1875708848,
-0.414639473,
-0.6723572612,
-0.5693553686,
0.5969163179,
-0.6694803834,
-0.1874700934,
-0.5140210986,
0.0973846242,
-0.4186844826,
-0.1658215374,
-0.4625870585,
-0.4372084141,
-0.2155687809,
-0.1577647775,
0.4214904308,
1.0826917887,
-0.1059920564,
0.3383287191,
-0.7551553249,
-0.062605232,
0.0782227591,
0.0171295553,
0.0070863557,
-0.8641016483,
-0.3984549046,
-0.1772013754,
-0.1983279884,
-0.7075122595,
0.4313816428,
0.3066367805,
0.6860061288,
0.1361808181,
-0.4568431675,
0.727971077,
-0.6293840408,
0.7844029069,
0.1999951601,
-0.4224533737,
0.2588014007,
-0.0787167996,
0.2643211186,
0.2722794116,
0.4538727999,
-0.390648514,
-0.3989327252,
-0.360218823,
-0.6207738519,
0.4550767839,
0.0423207693,
0.2081201375,
-0.0999389216,
0.1958627999,
0.137579143,
0.2713413835,
-0.765534699,
-0.204993248,
0.230019331,
0.0501390211,
-0.6217620373,
0.0225812607,
0.0948277786,
-0.0513497964,
0.4207238853,
0.0154818147,
0.0276560206,
-0.0584718399,
-0.2730355263,
-0.258808136,
0.2806167006,
0.5923361778,
0.6583749056,
0.1793000549,
0.2663258612,
0.6471776962,
-0.3372426331,
0.1981687248,
-0.0752043873,
0.1134650335,
0.054328084,
0.8196523786,
0.8179140091,
0.1031321883,
-0.6220237017,
0.4121006429,
0.1025959551,
0.0947801471,
-0.170015052,
-0.0091290455,
0.3634253442,
0.5854282975,
0.1465568095,
-0.0070601171,
-0.247870937,
-0.6354623437,
-0.1336834878,
0.4634524584,
-0.3222322762,
-0.4347137809,
0.5063750148,
0.2639321983,
-0.3792958558,
0.2795608342,
-0.0492340215,
-0.5639508367,
0.7172605395,
0.6188831925,
0.2704874575,
-0.3156935573,
-0.1397171021,
0.3563366234,
0.662630558,
-0.2836727798,
0.0604911707,
0.1692754328,
-0.6135703325,
-0.386898458,
-0.5787627697,
-0.3083543479,
-0.0109468736,
-0.5434241891,
0.3627316654,
-0.2480938137,
-0.1702420712,
-0.1999161094,
0.1202080399,
-0.8415768743,
0.0415347703,
0.2106712162,
0.6458816528,
-0.9095048904,
1.1784749031,
0.974157393,
-0.2431166619,
-0.7930985689,
-0.3670003414,
-0.1605692953,
-0.7941023707,
0.6713329554,
0.2553284466,
-0.0504993498,
-0.1843815446,
-0.1978193671,
-0.9787589312,
1.1071895361,
0.5810854435,
-0.7032000422,
0.0401195176,
0.4837269783,
0.8923704028,
-0.520008564,
0.2496689856,
0.7059447765,
0.2590276003,
-0.2372790277,
-1.1252317429,
-0.2265799791,
0.0164813958,
0.1379490495,
0.3258064687,
-0.9062996507,
0.8913351297,
-0.4618383348,
-0.0813934356,
0.1130408496,
0.5099386573,
0.0773508027,
0.1276243031,
-0.1595554948,
0.5500535965,
0.7826253772,
0.1302351505,
1.3955738544,
-0.3472733796,
0.2096451968,
1.0132015944,
-0.4757911861,
1.1087975502,
0.5537569523,
-0.3027620614,
0.2966442108,
0.6059885621,
0.342605114,
0.4097703993,
-0.0484368317,
-0.0763815343,
-0.5062738061,
-0.1335559636,
-0.3691205382,
0.5479857922,
0.4248335063,
-0.378148526,
-0.233141914,
0.0170038361,
0.1189235747,
0.4308060408,
-0.1502111107,
0.6253633499,
0.4722757041,
-0.6752977967,
0.8366670609,
0.1862336993,
0.7277114391,
-0.5518760681,
0.0906691998,
-0.7593681812,
0.1662805974,
-0.2003801763,
-0.8434014916,
0.3402517438,
0.214528352,
-0.3195216358,
0.0117701096,
0.4457864761,
-0.6236713529,
-0.5824266672,
0.736548245,
0.752720952,
0.5474253297,
0.2609046102,
-0.4638214707,
0.1694362015,
-0.0529785901,
0.0862264335,
0.4871148765,
0.5028353333,
-0.3168947697,
0.5874094367,
0.7169359326,
0.3272194862,
0.2357109487,
-0.0444385074,
0.5261377692,
-0.4533528388,
-0.2151085883,
-0.8278928995,
0.1837021858,
0.2345385998,
-0.3103067875,
0.8239709735,
0.5283402205,
1.0176898241,
0.1264085472,
0.7294251323,
0.288223505,
0.4222970903,
-0.5016822815,
0.5937395692,
-0.7411875129,
0.3096981943,
0.1360473633,
-1.1600660086,
-0.3625378013,
0.4644369781,
-0.3550109863,
-0.2075008154,
0.9813878536,
0.8915041089,
0.0152717074,
-0.3084700108,
0.7803529501,
0.2630462646,
0.1423374265,
0.7540864944,
0.6882791519,
-0.4168267548,
0.7821412683,
-0.0543641038,
-0.0483494513,
-0.0259312354,
-0.6208502054,
-1.3543393612,
-0.3182300031,
0.1187534928,
-0.2091339529,
-0.0100587867,
0.8200818896,
0.4222977757,
-0.7894904017,
-0.5280558467,
0.318543762,
0.1703852415,
0.0809109062,
-0.0168278683,
0.1484377831,
-0.3634078801,
-0.6489395499,
0.5865204334,
0.3467462063,
0.1192020103,
-0.3073030114,
-0.3949659467,
-0.1032286137,
0.0121833673,
0.874746263,
0.0643984452,
-0.9291083813,
-0.1984218508,
0.2772482634,
-0.4374989271,
0.1856108308,
0.6172122359,
-0.3104895651,
0.0918408036,
0.2236900628,
0.804344058,
0.4180558324,
-0.3825269639,
0.4963877797,
-0.6755900383,
0.4753595889,
-0.2998509407,
0.5008276701,
0.5727236271,
-0.2481621206,
0.4995811284,
0.2079877555,
-0.3726095855,
-0.5121219158,
0.1800786406,
-0.6762081385,
-0.1256320477,
1.529405117,
-0.2420960218,
-0.325936228,
0.0313207693,
-0.1441436559,
0.1119473055,
-0.2390802205,
0.6374280453,
0.9465246201,
-0.0820307881,
-0.1164030731,
-0.5902891159,
0.1217431128,
0.6204100251,
-0.6484750509,
-0.1670427322,
0.2866713107,
0.3016324043,
0.1066338122,
0.4812517464,
-0.0945956707,
0.3764480948,
-0.0821482539,
-0.0029320382,
0.2828812599,
-0.4388974011,
-0.443172425,
-0.2127952576,
0.6164923906,
0.091091983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13906v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13906v2
|
Leveraging Collection-Wide Similarities for Unsupervised Document Structure Extraction
| 2024-02-21T16:22:21 | 2024-06-20T14:43:51 |
Gili Lior, Yoav Goldberg, Gabriel Stanovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document collections of various domains, e.g., legal, medical, or financial,
often share some underlying collection-wide structure, which captures
information that can aid both human users and structure-aware models. We
propose to identify the typical structure of document within a collection,
which requires to capture recurring topics across the collection, while
abstracting over arbitrary header paraphrases, and ground each topic to
respective document locations. These requirements pose several challenges:
headers that mark recurring topics frequently differ in phrasing, certain
section headers are unique to individual documents and do not reflect the
typical structure, and the order of topics can vary between documents.
Subsequently, we develop an unsupervised graph-based method which leverages
both inter- and intra-document similarities, to extract the underlying
collection-wide structure. Our evaluations on three diverse domains in both
English and Hebrew indicate that our method extracts meaningful collection-wide
structure, and we hope that future work will leverage our method for
multi-document applications and structure-aware models.
|
[
-0.422142297,
-0.5885108113,
0.3540014327,
-0.1136112884,
-0.5666831732,
0.2281913161,
0.1106406152,
-0.5530636907,
0.6081842184,
0.5292245746,
-0.3335042596,
-0.7709557414,
-0.7366528511,
-0.0239555947,
-0.6069182754,
0.9293657541,
-0.1070583984,
-0.1176392958,
-0.525858283,
-0.323966682,
-0.2561980188,
-0.2922661901,
-0.302415818,
-0.2956686318,
0.5048419833,
0.3973056674,
0.3262610435,
0.8379433751,
0.535763979,
0.2859285474,
-0.086273998,
0.2297091931,
-0.3486327529,
0.267139554,
-0.3430058956,
-0.1636037976,
-0.2975770831,
-0.2109254003,
0.8035475016,
1.0213017464,
0.0216827597,
0.1657336354,
0.4854089618,
0.5333433151,
-0.500172317,
0.5053892136,
-0.6744011045,
-0.0129577573,
-0.6213345528,
-0.5329082608,
-0.0222808234,
-0.057344269,
0.11280334,
-0.5529664159,
0.6120578051,
-0.0861612037,
0.966763258,
-0.3474620283,
-0.3817789853,
-0.5272489786,
-0.2067960054,
0.3789846897,
-0.2703529596,
0.4321005344,
0.3620894253,
0.2176449746,
0.0027918899,
-1.0299038887,
-0.0678474978,
0.1987070441,
-0.2103954554,
0.2911145985,
-0.3224162161,
-0.2540348172,
0.0150696663,
0.4117957056,
-0.7638722658,
0.1503099501,
-0.3402785957,
-0.3815297484,
0.2392011583,
0.1332188696,
0.4359017611,
-0.3642248809,
-0.2769058049,
-0.0212388672,
-0.7763955593,
0.0758176148,
0.3950143158,
0.5150977969,
-0.1311221719,
0.4955617785,
-0.3491936326,
0.4606554508,
-0.1446330994,
-0.0254833754,
0.3737176955,
-0.2374021262,
-0.0843350068,
-0.02856314,
0.6249119043,
0.473619014,
0.0956303179,
-0.4675750136,
-0.0171349831,
-0.0456818826,
0.1670514792,
-0.6932129264,
-0.1585261673,
0.2162182778,
-0.8738868833,
-0.098216325,
0.3700910807,
-1.0696159601,
-0.4184286594,
-0.3185549676,
-0.1703535169,
-0.3102546036,
-0.0771458298,
-0.1525736153,
-0.5985271931,
0.3998958468,
0.3184842467,
-0.8911793828,
0.3769415915,
1.0035473108,
1.0894483328,
-0.3800315261,
-0.462854296,
-0.6750058532,
0.3450494111,
-0.0102695879,
1.2465126514,
-0.6775312424,
-0.6481890082,
0.2058742642,
0.1425023973,
0.0627078936,
-0.5214668512,
0.5106081367,
-0.4695930481,
0.0219640937,
-0.4194425642,
-0.6989161372,
0.1401153654,
0.4861594141,
-0.796493113,
0.5866618752,
0.3958368003,
-1.1656438112,
0.1982395798,
-0.4598966837,
-0.5941163301,
0.3665937781,
-0.7081471086,
-0.4558107555,
0.1992880702,
0.1889617592,
0.4203585386,
-0.4695368409,
0.0351720005,
-0.302447468,
-0.2981139123,
-0.144992128,
-0.2569338679,
0.9124414921,
0.2241577655,
0.1194634661,
0.0854289383,
-0.6630361676,
-0.2464889735,
0.2886106968,
-0.132706821,
-0.7734524012,
0.0074307816,
0.2705973983,
0.071408838,
0.5338435173,
-0.5541222095,
0.3694111705,
-0.1684256792,
0.2575338483,
0.4698865116,
0.4413649142,
0.3712495565,
-0.4442661405,
0.7051262856,
-0.242504105,
-0.0644587576,
-0.2888067067,
-0.3671846092,
-0.0681160763,
-0.5586963296,
0.2951328456,
0.229272604,
-0.3127043545,
0.3080003858,
-0.5482357144,
-0.4370583892,
-0.0480982512,
0.1166174933,
0.4498253763,
0.595934391,
0.4177709818,
-0.7638853788,
-0.2672536671,
-0.8324149847,
-0.3140414655,
0.0275219474,
-0.1133040637,
0.1990855634,
0.441770941,
-0.0714887679,
0.8813067079,
-0.8103433847,
-0.3628804982,
-0.2381041348,
0.489051491,
0.0222745258,
0.3093276918,
0.7349385023,
-1.1767904758,
-0.7264547944,
0.3143244088,
-0.7485151887,
-0.1636055708,
-0.0141755631,
-0.2050052285,
-0.2423987091,
0.6303573251,
-0.6645469069,
0.5643907785,
-0.0113652283,
-0.2845982909,
0.2569175065,
-0.2130478173,
0.1179813221,
-1.285299778,
0.3648263216,
-0.1783046275,
-0.1194070652,
-0.4024048746,
0.2673327327,
0.2698591053,
-0.2238901109,
-0.3323642015,
0.5862955451,
-0.7364939451,
-0.456202656,
-0.5257228613,
0.1162252426,
0.3416753411,
0.3185930848,
0.1468416899,
0.4022762179,
0.4752782583,
-0.2344457507,
0.271943152,
0.518055737,
-0.3588815928,
0.8661796451,
-0.5769112706,
-0.0638445467,
-0.3314635754,
0.3040026426,
-0.68846035,
0.0087180631,
0.206208989,
-0.3143983483,
0.518212378,
-0.4583585858,
-0.4925873876,
-0.2441776246,
-0.5414067507,
0.0781882852,
0.0878313482,
-0.3435170352,
0.7501204014,
0.6383545399,
-0.5263502598,
-0.5814841986,
-0.2248987854,
0.2209540009,
-0.4758924544,
-0.3012328446,
0.7174590826,
-0.0238336977,
-0.1874017715,
0.2044029385,
-0.4623941183,
-0.349276036,
0.3496421576,
0.443873167,
0.2657574713,
-0.0453239642,
-0.1249217317,
0.3032699525,
-0.1134389043,
-0.0228450764,
-0.5477480888,
0.6824069619,
0.0772747099,
-0.5827063918,
-0.0726724267,
1.0975415707,
0.7669400573,
-0.7262645364,
0.2856891155,
0.2111952603,
-0.5586687922,
0.0364099443,
-0.1898805052,
0.1862430871,
-0.4092425704,
0.4319723845,
-0.7113275528,
-0.5469445586,
0.8978843093,
-0.1918146014,
0.3871838748,
0.711301744,
0.5019620061,
-0.2674263418,
0.3092353642,
0.567686379,
-0.2758947611,
0.4966528416,
-0.305421263,
-0.2576900721,
-0.7305788994,
-0.360367626,
-1.0409340858,
-0.1530583054,
-0.3720713258,
-0.2785499096,
-0.0074977051,
0.1421349496,
0.1245752051,
0.6143342853,
-0.3097299039,
0.6305387616,
0.5179033875,
-0.2506926656,
0.3714469671,
0.4158931673,
-0.0969964489,
0.2895132303,
-0.3593275845,
-0.3493156731,
1.0924543142,
-0.00550821,
0.4340538979,
-0.0278489571,
1.0393948555,
0.4343993068,
0.355181098,
-0.6595672369,
0.2150155306,
-0.4333401024,
-0.2723516226,
-0.2063408494,
-0.363014698,
-1.5076509714,
0.3362843394,
0.0290116463,
-0.9176312089,
0.3972455859,
-0.2617916167,
0.1376099735,
0.1259006709,
-0.1776221693,
0.9343361855,
0.0480791219,
0.0028162797,
0.0624481663,
-0.8610067368,
-0.2493577898,
-0.4226047099,
0.226933971,
0.0106930109,
0.2586557567,
0.6939284801,
-0.2621968687,
0.597961843,
0.0011813981,
-0.1121703535,
0.5315665603,
0.0969681516,
0.3054638803,
0.0325456932,
0.1005772352,
0.3859829009,
0.1013225764,
-0.5272157192,
-0.6642178893,
0.7493454814,
-0.5517479181,
-0.4004818499,
-0.3321833014,
-0.7307508588,
-0.1418828815,
0.5780857801,
0.3555281162,
0.8434541821,
-0.4770862758,
0.3712738752,
0.3036645651,
0.3689004183,
0.4298645258,
0.5538214445,
0.1648832858,
-0.1415051073,
0.9001993537,
0.0935294479,
-0.1111842692,
0.9405199289,
0.2901796103,
-0.4999787211,
-0.8845308423,
-0.3108178377,
0.2242271304,
-0.9374913573,
-0.2081566453,
-0.7094111443,
-0.0841503739,
-0.528231144,
-0.3377720416,
-0.1341396868,
-0.3433799148,
-0.2234271467,
-0.1046841219,
0.0518971421,
0.4428822696,
0.2007741779,
-0.0489810482,
-1.0967798233,
0.5531116724,
0.1501035988,
0.1639176458,
-0.1134223863,
-0.3693014681,
-0.0718094185,
-0.2263937443,
-0.2725872397,
-0.9843695164,
0.2873423696,
0.0988643542,
0.9349524379,
0.5733184814,
0.094713971,
0.6509758234,
-0.7021561861,
0.4032835662,
0.1461093575,
-0.7268035412,
0.4796317518,
-0.4901537895,
0.0671054274,
0.8486638665,
0.5884450078,
-0.4882678986,
-0.4336997569,
-0.737750411,
-0.9368390441,
0.2293594033,
0.1844675392,
0.0570566356,
-0.138761431,
0.3949609697,
0.3000736535,
0.1724438369,
-0.4270071089,
-0.236073494,
-0.3402048647,
-0.3453384936,
0.2216452509,
0.0934917331,
-0.3601033688,
0.2012519687,
0.1551823914,
-0.3201922774,
0.1221552864,
0.1536529064,
-0.171103254,
0.0978900269,
0.284711808,
0.263635397,
0.8815150857,
-0.3535535932,
0.2587660551,
-0.3371548653,
-0.5382184982,
-0.2314962149,
0.4930103421,
-0.2023262233,
0.0138469711,
0.7196958065,
0.2324182987,
0.146341607,
-0.5256624222,
0.5288149118,
-0.0480132848,
-0.3157483041,
-0.0089638084,
-0.4273082018,
0.2450157255,
0.3999411464,
0.2406896353,
-0.2451160401,
0.3982589543,
-0.6385474205,
0.4895303547,
0.627823472,
-0.2054656893,
-0.1563167572,
0.4317607582,
0.1465230584,
-0.3968449235,
0.5202724934,
-0.0170428455,
-0.3107572794,
0.8274331093,
0.7022499442,
0.8500111103,
0.2108117491,
0.1193363592,
-0.085002549,
-0.162876457,
-0.0259349216,
0.0889971405,
-0.4205993414,
-0.5601109266,
0.0187250376,
-0.6557670236,
-0.331387043,
-0.0357271247,
-1.0436784029,
0.148054406,
-0.0793776363,
0.3347573578,
0.1436652839,
0.1166026667,
-0.5626913905,
0.0201593563,
0.0917608514,
0.7823019028,
-0.8792553544,
0.9827654362,
0.6913353205,
-0.4417929947,
-0.4508818984,
0.1997974515,
0.1028629839,
-0.6498111486,
0.3712692559,
0.1765236706,
-0.194696933,
-0.101941742,
0.0590970479,
-0.6753166318,
1.3393790722,
0.1453766376,
-0.6393581033,
-0.3083356023,
-0.075580433,
0.4367606938,
-0.5151361823,
-0.1180324256,
0.2048032284,
0.1247207224,
0.1169588044,
-0.583337605,
-0.0396855883,
-0.4563453794,
-0.1707964391,
0.4544783533,
-0.3138194382,
0.8203343749,
0.3788028657,
-0.2720680833,
0.0306871478,
0.7363628745,
0.2025770247,
0.5462257266,
0.4323833287,
0.4161509573,
1.1063414812,
0.4160299599,
1.0100932121,
-0.4969030619,
0.5272992849,
1.2926909924,
-0.4026043415,
0.5608888865,
0.2965438664,
0.0300509874,
0.2573219538,
0.4110151827,
-0.1935544908,
0.6590099931,
0.1052539796,
-0.0320149995,
0.0563230254,
-0.2813157141,
-0.552301228,
0.5225511789,
0.4540484846,
-0.399500221,
-0.6888285875,
-0.3712034822,
-0.0870841369,
0.183090508,
-0.3080894053,
0.5478405356,
0.2173576206,
-0.5270114541,
0.1072054878,
0.0686560124,
0.1898771822,
-0.828502655,
-0.0007336825,
-0.3797570169,
-0.4062434435,
0.0285515543,
-0.6740101576,
0.523973763,
0.026360454,
-0.2919440567,
-0.3447884023,
0.8630685806,
-0.3416337371,
-0.2639633119,
0.4049039483,
0.8040428162,
0.2432399243,
-0.1761361212,
-0.6475385427,
-0.1853764206,
-0.1124805138,
-0.0633537546,
0.6980634928,
0.554312706,
-0.5266891122,
0.065692246,
0.6556278467,
0.0689524934,
-0.3431232274,
0.4019201398,
0.9811503887,
-0.5362032652,
-0.7797026634,
-0.836581707,
0.0361672714,
-0.3558253944,
-0.268853873,
0.744916141,
0.7414919138,
0.7015125155,
0.0712209344,
0.5479604602,
0.0425497852,
0.2721787691,
-0.4190635681,
0.7077254653,
-0.6059562564,
0.0832048357,
-0.4863044322,
-1.2213917971,
-0.4676614106,
0.4913365245,
0.1112170145,
-0.5112505555,
1.0044487715,
0.3121346235,
-0.3233897984,
-0.0831393301,
0.0741219446,
-0.2487298548,
0.4667240083,
0.3463340104,
0.4469541609,
0.0973116085,
0.6541068554,
0.0199996587,
-0.2089657933,
-0.0415717065,
-0.9029259682,
-0.8471287489,
-0.7071193457,
-0.5078573823,
-0.2737149596,
-0.1009480879,
0.5491813421,
0.3305416107,
-0.6127035022,
-0.0144449892,
-0.2895941436,
0.1350771934,
-0.2282947451,
-0.1544608772,
0.9668422341,
0.1667497158,
-0.7402931452,
0.5317631364,
0.4690821767,
0.0217776224,
0.1745560616,
0.3227303624,
-0.0854988769,
-0.0178208183,
0.2984056771,
0.7436857224,
-0.4132180512,
-0.2962934971,
-0.2340693325,
-0.2079422027,
0.2916713059,
1.2145084143,
-0.317651391,
0.1745093465,
0.8360512853,
0.8796885014,
0.6936143637,
0.3376297653,
0.2684699595,
-0.9090222716,
0.0830690414,
0.0480738617,
0.8090432286,
0.2418865114,
-0.2468975484,
0.3527579606,
0.4196203351,
-0.1128199548,
-0.6154099703,
0.4277423322,
-1.3492912054,
-0.7161440253,
0.8192917705,
-0.5542929769,
-0.01480381,
-0.4962504208,
-0.0507540293,
0.3593432009,
-0.2519375682,
0.5335446596,
0.5430728197,
0.0825977549,
0.16456756,
-0.2144847065,
-0.0226968378,
0.0189694948,
-1.01258564,
0.1698910296,
0.4721152186,
0.4280224442,
0.4153430462,
0.9479010105,
-0.5483953953,
0.2178651392,
0.0268659797,
-0.0592800304,
-0.2367875427,
-0.6544880867,
-0.2522463799,
0.7566622496,
-0.2144303173,
-0.2352101505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13904v1
|
Calibrating Large Language Models with Sample Consistency
| 2024-02-21T16:15:20 | 2024-02-21T16:15:20 |
Qing Lyu, Kumar Shridhar, Chaitanya Malaviya, Li Zhang, Yanai Elazar, Niket Tandon, Marianna Apidianaki, Mrinmaya Sachan, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Accurately gauging the confidence level of Large Language Models' (LLMs)
predictions is pivotal for their reliable application. However, LLMs are often
uncalibrated inherently and elude conventional calibration techniques due to
their proprietary nature and massive scale. In this work, we explore the
potential of deriving confidence from the distribution of multiple randomly
sampled model generations, via three measures of consistency. We perform an
extensive evaluation across various open and closed-source models on nine
reasoning datasets. Results show that consistency-based calibration methods
outperform existing post-hoc approaches. Meanwhile, we find that factors such
as intermediate explanations, model scaling, and larger sample sizes enhance
calibration, while instruction-tuning makes calibration more difficult.
Moreover, confidence scores obtained from consistency have the potential to
enhance model performance. Finally, we offer practical guidance on choosing
suitable consistency metrics for calibration, tailored to the characteristics
of various LMs.
|
[
-0.1193645969,
-0.2366242409,
0.9008114934,
0.0505925901,
0.0825117901,
-0.1374083459,
-0.6988379955,
-0.1876264811,
-0.276881516,
0.5177303553,
-0.1146884114,
-0.5893750787,
-0.4472379684,
-0.0225522164,
-0.2528924048,
0.4640117288,
-0.1167002395,
0.2651890814,
-0.3573450744,
-0.0816923007,
-0.3757661879,
-0.3558114767,
-0.3247439563,
-0.6480819583,
0.4824640155,
0.3782775998,
0.934289217,
0.6926210523,
0.1409037113,
0.1792155504,
0.089664638,
0.5097257495,
-0.5885128975,
0.1889141053,
-0.3173761964,
-0.5321520567,
-0.112354368,
0.1252707392,
0.8367574215,
0.802397728,
-0.4465873539,
0.1173330322,
0.3280234039,
0.4158102274,
-0.8270823359,
0.1218938529,
-0.7093001604,
-0.3742647767,
-0.0786518902,
-0.1504091769,
-0.8147018552,
-0.6622781157,
-0.0827368572,
-0.5585901141,
0.0259630661,
0.145867154,
0.7204611301,
0.1079013422,
-0.4828405976,
-0.2152955085,
-1.0160682201,
1.281690836,
-0.9788653851,
0.4482308924,
0.6213136911,
0.4169035554,
-0.3981434703,
-0.4063316286,
-0.4241101444,
-0.2733519077,
0.2775251567,
-0.1473373175,
0.3033851981,
-0.1091635451,
0.1706722528,
0.3429341614,
-0.3404185176,
0.3419038951,
0.0017007913,
-0.3680787385,
0.6176956892,
-0.045482114,
-0.0267381798,
0.275798142,
-0.0929928273,
-0.2869460583,
-1.052739501,
-0.1018353403,
0.671563983,
0.5338657498,
0.0222527962,
0.6808264256,
-0.0854264125,
0.8433746099,
-0.0284401383,
-0.4814964235,
0.2170526683,
-0.3493945003,
-0.1586230397,
-0.2432878315,
0.6666083336,
0.2262119353,
0.7145879865,
-0.185103789,
-0.1802645177,
-0.1998075098,
0.0073731677,
-0.4863940775,
-0.2781195343,
0.3630611598,
-0.1568231732,
-0.1380314827,
0.2499884665,
-0.483556807,
-0.5050709844,
-0.5242547989,
0.3800028563,
-0.2286555767,
-0.2840007246,
0.3016772866,
0.1291020811,
0.2833722532,
0.5949683189,
-0.9187316895,
-0.0129920235,
0.7364523411,
0.4999486208,
-0.0115082962,
-0.2377558351,
-0.5375944972,
0.1079339683,
-0.8509122133,
0.5895079374,
-0.4395578504,
-0.1553472877,
0.1866888702,
-0.0548821129,
-0.0337053463,
-0.5765816569,
0.5736930966,
-0.3047115505,
0.0458360463,
-0.4231361747,
-0.8264801502,
-0.2021224052,
0.3141824603,
-0.479121238,
1.077799201,
0.0288985837,
-0.4948213696,
0.3911570311,
0.2818365097,
-0.0289822184,
-0.0496319793,
-0.3307978213,
-0.1868824959,
0.3229797184,
0.0180359483,
0.3875872195,
-0.3762719631,
0.4159780443,
-0.7584231496,
-0.5354495645,
0.2542789876,
-0.6119357347,
0.7112293243,
0.2604795396,
-0.0455641821,
-0.0735706463,
-0.6986956596,
0.5822710991,
-0.2038859725,
-0.1760239899,
-0.2638255656,
0.1376287788,
-0.3087790012,
0.0199479386,
0.2313439399,
-0.6736454368,
-0.0829359517,
-0.2272735089,
0.3472823501,
0.6951991916,
-0.1274970472,
0.2518290281,
-0.5488209724,
0.2921381593,
-0.1067823172,
-0.2464341223,
-0.2868330181,
-0.3805170953,
-0.5911900997,
-0.2922063172,
0.5516286492,
0.344175905,
-0.0747465268,
0.8389157653,
-0.4165306389,
-0.6932600737,
-0.4633540213,
0.3022199869,
0.1127146035,
0.3575435877,
0.0900116712,
-0.1473974735,
-0.3745291531,
-0.7415519357,
-0.2993972301,
-0.2052849084,
-0.3606016636,
0.255007416,
0.2671971619,
0.0641971305,
0.856823802,
-0.0946350619,
0.1523170769,
0.0383203216,
0.0933700651,
0.2487155199,
0.4037163258,
0.2958979607,
-0.3601114452,
-0.4586213231,
0.0033844768,
-0.6339877248,
-0.0879706889,
0.1221249104,
-0.0685768947,
-0.0253000073,
0.4848538041,
-0.3273576796,
0.158273235,
0.9698836207,
0.2232376337,
0.6283993721,
-0.4278616905,
0.2707077265,
-0.9993826151,
0.098230198,
0.254322052,
-0.4516618848,
-0.4954936802,
0.1232770011,
0.175382629,
0.4183255136,
-0.2079483569,
0.5520627499,
-0.5160470009,
-0.0817171857,
-0.1354972273,
0.3115161657,
0.2276593596,
-0.160826236,
-0.0394744799,
0.698433578,
0.3720296323,
-0.3892274499,
0.402150631,
-0.0442205183,
-0.7016347051,
0.4847534597,
-0.7167547941,
0.2828283906,
0.0174363256,
0.3519590199,
-1.2522655725,
-0.1491700262,
-0.2631590068,
-0.278352201,
0.2158877552,
-0.1852224022,
-0.7427048087,
-0.177598089,
-0.1648527235,
0.2526113391,
0.5008487701,
-0.6370307207,
0.7188737988,
0.2385502458,
0.0775992796,
-0.6282679439,
-0.7040670514,
-0.2946505249,
-0.0273306556,
-0.5589314699,
-0.0758331791,
-0.2209911346,
-0.4693130255,
-0.3947604299,
-0.1660948098,
0.0844776407,
-0.1013125479,
0.3282015026,
0.2107376009,
-0.2162452638,
0.1987035125,
-0.383425653,
0.1488167793,
-0.2902191281,
-0.302018553,
0.6232600808,
-0.0530002378,
-0.7685189247,
-0.175282076,
-0.0103621185,
0.5894035101,
-0.0728790984,
0.7568817139,
0.1720223725,
-0.4367826283,
-0.3916056454,
-0.8789476752,
-0.2289223522,
-0.4413303733,
0.0556942821,
-0.3820527494,
-0.7878903747,
0.7318048477,
-0.0501956679,
0.2972429097,
0.2984144092,
0.7515111566,
0.0517510548,
1.1125360727,
0.6308404803,
-0.0283470117,
-0.0168336574,
0.3900440931,
0.2206417769,
-0.6282070279,
-0.2104682177,
-0.8359262943,
-0.0961765721,
-0.6652976274,
-0.6539950371,
-0.0059421756,
0.2208532542,
-0.5251960158,
0.0922835842,
-0.1024300456,
0.6343982816,
0.7146422863,
0.0212222394,
0.4394657314,
0.0966164693,
-0.3516073227,
-0.0565258078,
-0.418754518,
-0.9101510644,
1.2626909018,
0.4883292615,
1.0550376177,
-0.1429086477,
0.6045693159,
-0.0554722995,
0.4045982659,
-0.531067729,
0.3666152358,
-0.1948403418,
-0.7490344644,
-0.3594695032,
-0.63664186,
-0.5193586349,
0.084712334,
-0.120637618,
-0.9741531014,
0.2227851301,
0.3532046378,
-0.3519514501,
0.2243928611,
-0.7185003161,
0.5443152189,
0.0312122051,
-0.2881043851,
-0.037120387,
-0.3884018064,
0.5053277016,
-0.2119107246,
0.2776294053,
-0.555826962,
0.2496498078,
0.2421507984,
-0.2276487648,
0.72153157,
0.0920998007,
-0.3560072482,
0.3773483336,
0.1228949875,
0.5157666206,
-0.1034113243,
-0.4976123273,
0.2220086753,
0.3143454194,
-0.3424068987,
-0.5482762456,
0.8726617694,
-0.7465707064,
-0.5088994503,
-0.1658654958,
-0.881490469,
-0.6178454161,
0.1891956031,
0.1951893568,
0.182304278,
-0.1296254843,
0.6109210849,
0.7854434252,
-0.188937366,
0.0640831068,
0.4405267835,
-0.3924125731,
-0.2559244335,
0.5638369918,
0.1336975992,
0.7379519343,
0.3322332203,
0.1809432507,
-0.4511931837,
-0.3083140254,
-0.3860999644,
0.3021571338,
-0.7325770259,
-0.1214682087,
-0.092458263,
-0.1671951115,
-0.5909718871,
-0.0724367797,
-0.5433376431,
-0.3269892633,
-0.1768396944,
-0.0768188536,
0.1315696388,
0.5058608651,
-0.1199414581,
0.183036983,
-0.6431960464,
-0.0452087857,
0.090529412,
0.4492943287,
-0.0193421338,
-0.7679014206,
0.0378973521,
0.5656229854,
0.0310771298,
-0.7034732699,
0.1387871504,
0.2331006378,
0.7056779861,
0.5147704482,
-0.0010351249,
0.5125927925,
-0.3956811428,
0.6535544991,
0.0837221667,
-0.8463150859,
0.251067251,
-0.2864854038,
0.3535519242,
0.6994879842,
0.336337328,
-0.5015134215,
-0.4361593127,
-0.4314005077,
-0.4779846668,
0.1973115057,
-0.2701405883,
0.1981409341,
0.0590697266,
0.3622294366,
-0.0167438332,
0.1161958352,
-0.4716280997,
-0.1257969141,
-0.0107347947,
-0.5807167888,
-0.5701206326,
-0.183047846,
-0.3652306795,
0.0950220525,
0.731095612,
-0.3444240391,
-0.2526475489,
-0.2954569459,
0.1104470193,
-0.3307632208,
0.297917068,
0.6638855934,
0.952313602,
-0.2545316517,
0.4390167594,
-0.0213632714,
-0.2826732397,
0.2842817903,
0.0383306853,
-0.3675448895,
0.0015105472,
0.12027511,
0.4595431089,
0.1571806371,
-0.7604990602,
0.4914140403,
0.1522418857,
-0.2269887477,
-0.377184391,
0.1281114072,
0.3897823691,
0.0784628391,
0.1460160464,
-0.1197013557,
-0.3599274158,
-0.5030300021,
0.2024612129,
0.6218914986,
-0.2096610814,
-0.0545899011,
0.5096648335,
-0.348388195,
0.1064144447,
0.7688237429,
0.0966909826,
-0.0714473873,
0.4949680865,
0.5001766086,
0.4690520167,
-0.4287216067,
0.1459165365,
0.481517911,
0.5248016715,
-0.9631736279,
0.2891608775,
0.3727301061,
-1.2470537424,
-0.5836107135,
-0.7743625045,
-0.8116982579,
0.2060810179,
-0.6745909452,
0.4338754714,
-0.4261447191,
-0.1668359488,
-0.1233076602,
0.1311521828,
-0.6585244536,
0.2856774628,
0.1816354394,
1.0520612001,
-0.9714607596,
0.9437018633,
0.3425427675,
-0.1874020845,
-1.509391427,
-0.1648177803,
0.2523902953,
-0.9814972281,
0.166498661,
0.1279950142,
-0.1450307369,
0.1477492303,
-0.6510509849,
-1.0889683962,
1.0091685057,
0.6377716064,
-0.8658123016,
0.0566213056,
0.1423613727,
0.4591070414,
-0.436583519,
0.4730210602,
0.4781624377,
0.4690797627,
0.4012473524,
-0.9836209416,
-0.0878731161,
0.1824244112,
0.1298178732,
-0.0687010512,
-0.1922230721,
0.6443334818,
-0.3210856318,
-0.0841496289,
0.3206069767,
0.6943477392,
0.9116765261,
-0.0235804357,
0.4668729007,
0.6611456871,
0.9896581173,
-0.3312677145,
0.9341753125,
-0.5473397374,
0.3991545141,
1.3175965548,
-0.4937102795,
1.1484473944,
0.3902251124,
-0.1348273307,
0.4631129503,
0.6081130505,
-0.1145945266,
0.2320771068,
0.3293648958,
-0.2778277695,
-0.5231111646,
-0.0911191553,
-0.2192141712,
0.2677317262,
0.2747848332,
-0.496391505,
-0.2061467171,
-0.2127886266,
0.0391005203,
0.1607442498,
-0.33298558,
0.1728492975,
0.2737829089,
-0.8402920961,
0.5401107669,
-0.1020639688,
0.3386157155,
-0.5978223681,
0.1300791353,
-0.0296498686,
0.5627042055,
-0.0946632102,
-0.8816816211,
-0.0983227938,
-0.2633929849,
-0.131371215,
-0.1170952991,
0.5417329073,
-0.8235070705,
-0.3746374249,
-0.0648172349,
0.7250925303,
0.2830460072,
0.0793560892,
-0.169067204,
0.2445653677,
-0.0171993412,
-0.2757866085,
0.3879726231,
0.4424328804,
0.1583939195,
0.6716321707,
0.5958583951,
0.3577480912,
0.1648554057,
0.1838727444,
0.2579981983,
-0.2111136466,
-0.0841134787,
-0.6852788925,
0.3779762089,
0.0367828868,
-0.293092519,
0.989708364,
0.4254657924,
0.8962900043,
0.1764018536,
0.7233939767,
0.4239042699,
0.8115938306,
-0.4254026711,
0.3070510924,
-0.3936156631,
0.3171173036,
-0.055308491,
-1.0807988644,
-0.3810155988,
0.7525081635,
-0.418386668,
0.3466393948,
0.4575596452,
0.8657186627,
0.0380319916,
0.0612140298,
0.5602374673,
0.0788534805,
0.3080174327,
0.3455817997,
0.6198167801,
-0.1352443695,
0.2406665683,
-0.1587300003,
-0.3367065191,
-0.098660484,
-1.3292182684,
-0.5178381205,
-0.2967709899,
-0.2390950173,
-0.5633205175,
-0.0108827874,
0.8327189088,
0.9053893089,
-0.9996274114,
-0.3272062242,
-0.029046867,
-0.1293382496,
-0.2257218063,
-0.1773241609,
0.0055055148,
-0.2821303308,
-0.8188498616,
0.2884366214,
0.2397763133,
0.0203330442,
-0.5748759508,
-0.0189141501,
0.0470585302,
0.5004620552,
0.2048451453,
0.4622232318,
-0.8853082061,
-0.6665077806,
0.0124560641,
-0.4939149022,
-0.0350022838,
0.5405774117,
-0.3937922418,
0.5766139627,
0.4790637493,
0.5286751986,
0.2493650913,
0.243232429,
0.9544686675,
-0.7270348072,
-0.132485345,
0.121670492,
0.5193728209,
0.6067721844,
0.028975131,
0.4199198782,
-0.1755996197,
-0.8960701823,
-1.0012110472,
0.2554067075,
-0.7344790101,
0.0224048831,
1.391351819,
-0.4768151641,
0.1202232987,
-0.0213046446,
0.2666497827,
0.0749460086,
-0.1332166791,
0.5395807624,
1.1837865114,
0.2241951674,
-0.258659035,
-0.8312474489,
0.2239941657,
0.3379684091,
-0.5891997218,
0.3499135375,
0.6619756818,
0.4921364188,
0.3185501099,
0.4933964908,
-0.2148432285,
-0.0756063312,
-0.0240541622,
-0.0070350282,
0.302870363,
-0.327843219,
-0.2208646685,
0.2277258337,
0.4594222903,
0.2670631111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13897v2
|
Science Checker Reloaded: A Bidirectional Paradigm for Transparency and Logical Reasoning
| 2024-02-21T16:09:25 | 2024-03-14T00:21:09 |
Loïc Rakotoson, Sylvain Massip, Fréjus A. A. Laleye
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.1; H.3.3; I.7; K.4
|
Information retrieval is a rapidly evolving field. However it still faces
significant limitations in the scientific and industrial vast amounts of
information, such as semantic divergence and vocabulary gaps in sparse
retrieval, low precision and lack of interpretability in semantic search, or
hallucination and outdated information in generative models. In this paper, we
introduce a two-block approach to tackle these hurdles for long documents. The
first block enhances language understanding in sparse retrieval by query
expansion to retrieve relevant documents. The second block deepens the result
by providing comprehensive and informative answers to the complex question
using only the information spread in the long document, enabling bidirectional
engagement. At various stages of the pipeline, intermediate results are
presented to users to facilitate understanding of the system's reasoning. We
believe this bidirectional approach brings significant advancements in terms of
transparency, logical thinking, and comprehensive understanding in the field of
scientific information retrieval.
|
[
-0.0168116614,
-0.6551734209,
0.9519087076,
0.2875797451,
-0.4879937172,
0.4364619255,
-0.0828813761,
-0.4901632667,
0.4969214499,
0.6581581831,
-0.5786993504,
-0.3815081418,
-0.7558889985,
0.1949824989,
-0.5974138379,
0.9097881913,
-0.260712117,
-0.1165993586,
-0.5626164675,
0.1899316907,
-0.4519130886,
0.1453581601,
-0.4786365032,
-0.4558760524,
0.5629897714,
0.453389734,
0.7877522707,
0.5619475842,
0.7520506978,
0.3841153681,
-0.0098400339,
0.2248197794,
-0.5329557061,
0.500882268,
-0.7346448302,
-0.5807561874,
-0.0752813965,
-0.1084870994,
0.8651143909,
0.8663299084,
-0.084447965,
-0.0015560517,
0.0509280525,
0.8289000988,
-0.7126003504,
0.3567906916,
-0.463354528,
0.0565311834,
-0.2377800196,
-0.3439516425,
-0.2406228781,
-0.2872044444,
0.1894362718,
-0.9457208514,
0.3371992111,
0.171484977,
0.7549105287,
0.3274992108,
-0.6234437823,
-0.3401652873,
-0.6290768385,
0.8344637156,
-0.1510273814,
0.7175264955,
0.329018414,
0.3369786441,
-0.3668837249,
-1.0341320038,
-0.7168567181,
0.0370890424,
0.0168583784,
0.3439246714,
-0.0733837187,
0.0217855368,
0.1668725312,
0.2643252015,
-0.606852591,
-0.3862116337,
-0.9976163507,
-0.3595061898,
0.5861852765,
-0.1786797345,
-0.0406461656,
-0.2497561425,
-0.3772586286,
-0.2618009448,
-0.5212510228,
-0.3572098017,
0.189010188,
0.0563106611,
0.2550556958,
0.6826328635,
-0.4197795093,
0.5269888639,
0.1403650492,
0.0741289631,
0.0519473106,
-0.6418351531,
-0.1654948592,
0.2185283601,
0.4964442551,
0.2775024772,
-0.3875678778,
-0.0275373757,
-0.2327993214,
-0.1514240056,
0.4035325944,
-0.9679540992,
-0.0993070677,
0.4998670518,
-0.2554566264,
-0.1858017743,
0.0835656524,
-0.9787992239,
-0.5571153164,
-0.4081075788,
0.4707789421,
-0.3169545531,
-0.1493316889,
0.451610148,
-0.3094193339,
0.1424123496,
0.7166650295,
-0.4052647948,
-0.00824113,
0.9756494761,
0.9384768009,
0.1058669761,
-0.1008859277,
-0.4598615766,
0.2010671794,
-0.1369541287,
0.9308648109,
-0.6234526634,
-0.4360822439,
-0.0403981619,
0.2729720473,
0.2564873993,
-0.3361539841,
0.6755446792,
-0.88648206,
0.4901402295,
-0.3140819371,
-0.1594769806,
-0.3440301418,
0.180004552,
-0.7801949978,
0.8359419703,
0.132601738,
-0.8330245018,
0.4030651152,
-0.4697002172,
-0.4337089956,
0.3126421571,
-0.3795832992,
-0.1287568063,
-0.0855670646,
-0.3018315136,
-0.0945308805,
-0.5977778435,
0.633249104,
-0.100675568,
-0.2924875915,
-0.0757664219,
-0.0585560724,
0.5909161568,
0.3158289492,
-0.3673066795,
0.2653746009,
-0.6927683949,
0.0477550663,
-0.1877263337,
-0.5112733245,
-0.2771536112,
0.2233895957,
-0.1266434342,
0.154957816,
0.515794158,
-0.9073610902,
0.0212448686,
-0.2367087454,
0.3702474535,
0.6323015094,
-0.3315285146,
0.3021165729,
-0.1261755526,
0.2512891591,
0.1221978515,
0.1965601891,
-0.0220588222,
-0.292740047,
-0.75367558,
-0.3496228158,
0.4099798203,
0.6103229523,
-0.791708529,
0.5693939924,
-0.2181502134,
-0.2646215558,
-0.7883039713,
0.1695880741,
0.3691646159,
0.611769855,
0.6052413583,
-0.6373710632,
-0.6329138279,
-1.0514583588,
-0.2384403199,
-0.2548089325,
-0.2892622352,
0.3313039243,
0.6575023532,
-0.3861192763,
0.8251050711,
-0.6309960485,
0.126095444,
0.050715059,
0.2051617503,
0.2797293067,
0.4584081471,
-0.4185961485,
-1.0891717672,
-0.1295934021,
-0.0481272265,
-0.8461412191,
0.0134523511,
-0.1281151325,
-0.5083919168,
-0.0750576556,
0.4738729298,
-0.7894667983,
0.4571219087,
-0.0393819809,
-0.5427020788,
0.5330063105,
-0.211651206,
0.2202362865,
-0.7937439084,
0.2095658332,
-0.161787495,
-0.2990596294,
-0.3635859191,
0.2157056481,
0.3677065074,
-0.1182514131,
-0.1841122508,
0.2313574255,
-0.5092970133,
0.0641470253,
-0.4377378821,
0.6027590632,
0.5378308296,
-0.2351715416,
0.1169086397,
0.5731011629,
0.4042643607,
-0.3593979478,
0.672761023,
0.2230175287,
-0.2471596003,
0.641738534,
-0.8891759515,
-0.0080117816,
-0.6957139373,
0.3897060454,
-0.9396059513,
-0.3401436508,
0.0006882935,
-0.2646648884,
0.7268799543,
0.1730929911,
-0.3913074732,
-0.5795235038,
-0.4799380302,
0.4598965645,
0.2002797574,
-0.620968163,
0.5271136165,
0.0204639565,
-0.2026711106,
-0.8685970306,
-0.4069519043,
0.1503134966,
0.3836043179,
-0.9536153674,
0.3384242356,
-0.0881943032,
-0.4012029767,
-0.0604052879,
-0.6580998302,
-0.041884996,
-0.2027388662,
0.1309144497,
0.4506076574,
-0.024481196,
0.1536421925,
0.2838884294,
-0.0958984494,
0.2354409397,
-0.5661770701,
0.3141497374,
-0.2043907344,
-0.3412765265,
-0.1966596693,
0.6538007259,
0.8211893439,
-0.1197915152,
0.6084837317,
0.4103296697,
-0.4242646694,
0.2128332704,
-0.7779949903,
-0.4550201297,
-0.4980850518,
0.5978081822,
-0.2149831951,
-0.9229676723,
0.165967375,
-0.2973159552,
-0.1274145544,
0.4647064507,
0.2322417051,
-0.1491286606,
0.6527898908,
0.8166959286,
0.3870207369,
0.050785251,
-0.0659506619,
0.4821958244,
-0.8373901248,
-1.0424374342,
-0.5448198318,
-0.0733370259,
-0.3936740458,
-0.8081222773,
0.2810172439,
0.4371164739,
-0.2484617978,
0.1817965508,
-0.8241441846,
0.5299400687,
0.4547878504,
0.3356786072,
0.4334779978,
0.0499820746,
-0.0710312724,
0.0315813981,
-0.4386609197,
-0.3891162276,
0.9235979915,
0.1706466377,
0.8866573572,
0.3097811937,
0.5833322406,
0.1631121188,
0.1245901063,
-0.7672900558,
0.4746373296,
0.2775981426,
-0.6995158792,
-0.3139272034,
-0.2429807931,
-0.9593852162,
0.4467526972,
-0.1599155366,
-0.3458851874,
0.6136362553,
-0.1634264886,
-0.1318386048,
0.0900852457,
-0.5642328262,
0.5908562541,
-0.18955338,
-1.028493166,
-0.5465168357,
-1.0756334066,
0.3398718834,
-0.3799259961,
0.1641159356,
0.1745065898,
-0.1780198961,
0.8634434938,
-0.239192605,
0.6909252405,
0.1027046666,
-0.0304823685,
0.2189410329,
0.2942655981,
0.5980044603,
0.2841292918,
-0.1484972537,
-0.0348965377,
0.2554580271,
-0.6960524321,
-0.6232382059,
0.7968034148,
-0.5258801579,
-1.1758277416,
-0.7912584543,
-0.6520918608,
0.1324295998,
0.7249856591,
-0.1291282177,
0.0086414497,
0.1131193191,
0.4495607615,
0.9452640414,
0.1235613972,
0.0195097513,
0.8374574184,
-0.0249089152,
-0.1337146908,
0.6125885248,
-0.1613025963,
0.170172587,
0.5213635564,
0.0218611322,
-0.6025211215,
-0.3488863409,
-0.2766398787,
0.5602712631,
-0.7448257208,
-0.336163342,
-0.6847213507,
-0.0107056852,
-0.4495371282,
-0.2030282021,
-0.3191275299,
-0.451456368,
-0.189097628,
-0.0133484155,
0.1233061627,
0.7291299701,
-0.2157906294,
-0.3824160695,
-0.5388401151,
0.225911662,
0.2890433967,
0.4274172485,
-0.3442698419,
-0.3956892788,
-0.0995943025,
-0.0340687148,
-0.4863236547,
-1.0320453644,
0.0393978991,
-0.0687060207,
0.3643284738,
0.5305259228,
-0.058984939,
0.5058093071,
-0.4493835568,
0.5543928742,
0.4056800008,
-0.743029654,
0.8338342905,
-0.1096351966,
0.0311889257,
0.7106730938,
0.6922153831,
-0.5070000887,
-0.1156590879,
-0.4886950254,
-0.9230675101,
0.4622457325,
0.0221190564,
-0.1918029785,
0.075543724,
0.4257497191,
0.1120626703,
0.4931712747,
-0.2726378441,
0.1018808112,
-0.6948334575,
0.027656287,
0.1961250007,
-0.3670023978,
-0.5121155381,
-0.2642831802,
0.6454234123,
-0.2435684204,
0.0808568224,
0.7660955787,
0.0153545039,
-0.2060911208,
0.6577407718,
0.4835993946,
0.7998194098,
-0.5684004426,
0.4721265733,
-0.3167726696,
-0.7806164026,
-0.0323707908,
0.3459830582,
-0.3130684197,
-0.1580316275,
0.2227127403,
0.3835935891,
0.0711269826,
-0.7183533907,
0.4551547766,
0.270966202,
-0.3322435319,
-0.0002579916,
-0.1468426287,
0.034744475,
0.5238486528,
0.3682067394,
0.0535874851,
0.4545490444,
-0.8127205372,
0.2657878697,
0.513830781,
-0.4501724541,
-0.0640503839,
0.701433301,
0.217100352,
-0.0702078342,
0.8196052909,
-0.2644162476,
-0.5491257906,
0.5091355443,
0.8717971444,
0.6845204234,
0.0807914883,
0.3077325523,
0.425136894,
0.5358973145,
-0.2079283148,
0.3843533397,
-0.4101721048,
-0.4597320557,
-0.4777165353,
-0.6707853079,
-0.5137943029,
-0.0920888782,
-0.7259981632,
0.105036445,
-0.4878416955,
0.0329149142,
0.0852176398,
0.3388642967,
-0.3427436948,
0.0859681666,
-0.2013993412,
1.1655004025,
-0.5144411922,
0.6058915257,
0.4106785059,
-0.4786685705,
-0.3335153759,
-0.2803545296,
0.0463390611,
-0.6095852256,
0.9351516366,
0.0648126081,
-0.4397227168,
-0.3098506033,
-0.7061576843,
-1.1301461458,
1.4185945988,
-0.1199933961,
-0.7527678013,
0.2381159663,
-0.1590368152,
0.47530967,
-0.0408091396,
0.2742680013,
0.6154034734,
0.7654138803,
0.5058826804,
-0.766654551,
0.5936604738,
-0.3561621606,
-0.2240114212,
0.3053256571,
-0.6547675729,
0.7433723211,
-0.3560904562,
-0.5138595104,
-0.1246444136,
0.9340980053,
0.2920993567,
0.5528694391,
0.3526513875,
0.2312476486,
1.1609675884,
-0.1414105743,
0.9339362979,
-0.2556483448,
0.3543370068,
0.8662456274,
-0.5286622047,
0.7220733166,
0.8331496716,
-0.2123217583,
0.7687683105,
0.4906865954,
-0.0327247754,
0.5398823619,
0.3207073808,
-0.6330373883,
-0.3435572982,
-0.4515862763,
-0.4651475251,
0.0763984993,
0.6232156157,
-0.0845409855,
-0.3757186532,
-0.2517947257,
0.1494723856,
0.0146839553,
-0.0751331225,
0.2352960855,
-0.1322561055,
-0.7866452336,
0.4123634994,
0.1467766762,
0.5763565898,
-0.5792953372,
-0.2001874745,
-0.1686763465,
0.0310620237,
-0.5183905363,
-1.0166089535,
0.2566885948,
-0.3039045334,
-0.4076980948,
-0.0073819016,
1.1233257055,
-0.5532625914,
-0.3489501476,
0.2305032164,
0.2806545496,
0.2009572238,
0.0626977384,
-0.6477600336,
-0.0926032066,
0.1286375076,
0.0000465184,
-0.0124174459,
0.2961066365,
-0.1522236764,
0.7403253317,
0.8634467125,
-0.0626951233,
-0.1465669125,
-0.1073438674,
1.1385138035,
-0.7090717554,
-0.3099579513,
-0.3718889952,
0.1509987414,
-0.4089230001,
0.1964216828,
0.6247378588,
0.8781588674,
0.7211007476,
0.1762724221,
0.7702589035,
-0.0903297812,
0.2357809693,
-0.3280539513,
0.5174332261,
-0.5976690054,
0.2795182467,
0.1382884532,
-0.6806132197,
-0.4352141917,
0.6723026633,
-0.3509605527,
-0.0893807784,
1.1162484884,
0.9178080559,
-0.0957876071,
0.2585431039,
-0.0321248621,
0.3683258891,
0.2536050379,
0.5558798909,
0.7448496819,
-0.4027391374,
0.3377763629,
-0.151451543,
-0.5787092447,
-0.2192766666,
-0.7732938528,
-0.6641729474,
-0.4590368569,
-0.2656883895,
-0.8005805612,
0.1611641496,
0.5081595182,
0.6242772341,
-0.6819874644,
0.067138724,
-0.062672399,
0.5247257948,
0.2236879319,
-0.2692808807,
0.5381792784,
-0.2508700788,
-0.5194811821,
0.593313992,
0.6440491676,
-0.1706710458,
-0.4062398076,
0.0986531898,
-0.3214622438,
0.3848281503,
0.6846962571,
0.5487305522,
-0.5836705565,
-0.2779752612,
0.0020413364,
-0.134337008,
-0.0849546269,
0.9514638782,
-0.7549245954,
0.8313919902,
0.7419515252,
0.3663169444,
0.8119908571,
-0.1091469005,
0.3455646932,
-0.4519456327,
0.1240779012,
0.2230253965,
0.1739744544,
0.3205913007,
-0.6178628802,
0.4435559511,
0.4252447486,
-0.5385956168,
-0.7971498966,
0.3312108815,
-1.1749895811,
-0.3862430453,
0.8794696927,
0.3246259093,
-0.3801056147,
-0.4740324318,
-0.0495008081,
0.3545632362,
-0.3642062247,
0.9163821936,
0.6314472556,
-0.1274901628,
0.2147595733,
-0.5069277287,
0.293153137,
0.617518127,
-0.6982697248,
-0.0691563189,
0.6358990669,
0.2897891402,
0.6772433519,
0.452183485,
-0.4329921305,
0.3991542161,
0.1043244898,
0.0092185512,
-0.0901055932,
-0.6655942798,
-0.0635929778,
0.0955892801,
-0.2222369313,
0.014671755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13887v1
|
Beyond Probabilities: Unveiling the Misalignment in Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T15:58:37 | 2024-02-21T15:58:37 |
Chenyang Lyu, Minghao Wu, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various applications, fundamentally reshaping the landscape of natural language
processing (NLP) research. However, recent evaluation frameworks often rely on
the output probabilities of LLMs for predictions, primarily due to
computational constraints, diverging from real-world LLM usage scenarios. While
widely employed, the efficacy of these probability-based evaluation strategies
remains an open research question. This study aims to scrutinize the validity
of such probability-based evaluation methods within the context of using LLMs
for Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs), highlighting their inherent limitations.
Our empirical investigation reveals that the prevalent probability-based
evaluation method inadequately aligns with generation-based prediction.
Furthermore, current evaluation frameworks typically assess LLMs through
predictive tasks based on output probabilities rather than directly generating
responses, owing to computational limitations. We illustrate that these
probability-based approaches do not effectively correspond with generative
predictions. The outcomes of our study can enhance the understanding of LLM
evaluation methodologies and provide insights for future research in this
domain.
|
[
-0.3711979985,
-0.6294897199,
0.9175444245,
0.1802897453,
-0.1191834882,
0.0051618884,
-0.4290020466,
-0.2126706392,
-0.1796485782,
0.3336678445,
-0.5621470213,
-0.1859262288,
-0.5653892159,
0.1114800945,
-0.1806801409,
0.6949700713,
0.1725904793,
0.2326491475,
-0.7479439974,
0.0692393482,
-0.451097399,
-0.6544172764,
-0.5232486725,
-0.5038529038,
0.4928014278,
0.2208350301,
0.757219255,
0.1390101463,
0.7547495365,
0.1807968467,
0.1040313691,
0.0466047376,
-0.2654353976,
0.1011078283,
-0.1046468914,
-0.4110840559,
0.0013347736,
0.0638152286,
0.8416793942,
0.89847821,
-0.3719058037,
0.1091237143,
0.1521899253,
0.5926713943,
-0.8616366982,
-0.0553757846,
-0.8613496423,
0.3136066794,
-0.3909374475,
-0.2331141531,
-0.7556051612,
-0.3368951976,
0.1236941442,
-0.0662497878,
-0.0695277601,
0.0971030742,
0.4354462326,
0.0838002861,
-0.3787471056,
-0.4229134619,
-0.9877316356,
1.0545911789,
-0.9190288782,
0.3623383939,
0.2757240534,
0.4437930584,
-0.560595572,
-0.2562632263,
-0.6620306969,
-0.4353821576,
0.3987104893,
0.1470070183,
-0.1752860397,
-0.0493839309,
0.2216028571,
0.343403846,
-0.5479756594,
0.49400419,
-0.0351944752,
-0.1020918787,
0.704841435,
0.2601688504,
0.0124272685,
-0.347307682,
-0.3878315091,
0.0143541954,
-0.7372079492,
0.103686288,
0.5097537637,
0.4150864184,
0.118669644,
0.9301746488,
0.2817045152,
0.9494506121,
-0.1101876125,
-0.2200170606,
0.1908305734,
-0.0975781754,
-0.3037211895,
-0.1570172012,
0.9940662384,
0.3997302055,
0.3243949711,
-0.1150970533,
-0.0061050169,
-0.0693072975,
0.3194489181,
-0.3339976668,
0.2180292904,
0.4815790355,
-0.2995396256,
-0.3240874112,
0.1136363745,
-0.718998313,
-0.5441497564,
0.0050836494,
0.2768298388,
-0.357937932,
-0.2930593491,
0.1537271887,
-0.060384158,
0.063864544,
0.1092135832,
-0.7091545463,
-0.0313525051,
0.7561308742,
0.5677956939,
-0.2226816863,
-0.2352101058,
-0.462228626,
0.0263729617,
-0.505046308,
0.6516561508,
-0.7217425108,
-0.4802430272,
0.1316063553,
-0.2902355492,
-0.2771111429,
-0.6648101807,
0.8172748685,
-0.6027360559,
0.0275090616,
-0.2232872397,
-0.6716931462,
-0.0040743882,
0.2157338262,
-0.6730073094,
0.7231826186,
-0.1190071926,
-0.8493967652,
0.4435414374,
-0.3010438085,
-0.255697608,
-0.0283041392,
-0.3786337078,
-0.3499908149,
0.4043001533,
-0.0715323091,
0.5390095711,
-0.5031642914,
0.7147683501,
-0.6869279146,
-0.2576849461,
0.703561306,
-0.9000682831,
0.6765151024,
0.2342845201,
-0.1348221302,
-0.2054779232,
-0.7183038592,
0.0246989019,
0.0084319524,
-0.4803155959,
-0.1400541812,
0.4579123557,
-0.3737382591,
0.490331918,
0.0372569636,
-0.4976723492,
0.0112206992,
-0.6088961959,
0.202604115,
0.7292977571,
-0.1994141787,
0.444971174,
-0.4180044234,
0.7539349198,
-0.1092753187,
0.1131135747,
0.3488330245,
-0.5834354162,
-0.3335205019,
0.1899356991,
0.2893480062,
0.4746722281,
-0.723892808,
0.3628182709,
-0.3049622178,
-0.6915915608,
-0.3582546413,
0.0300847758,
0.3411152661,
0.2840990126,
0.046868287,
-0.2964107692,
-0.6287693977,
-0.867187202,
-0.4617610574,
-0.3494299948,
-0.056654416,
0.1336721033,
0.4004226625,
0.0142868878,
1.066639781,
-0.2483311892,
-0.057453163,
-0.4947258234,
-0.0198174994,
0.4015205204,
0.3506971896,
0.2473765612,
-0.5845878124,
-0.0222721156,
-0.2107667476,
-0.575535655,
0.0839490891,
-0.129108429,
0.2086700499,
0.3383432925,
0.1814612448,
-0.9093949795,
0.2529043853,
0.8671962023,
0.0088299075,
1.0093618631,
-0.0635580719,
0.1095957607,
-0.7380062342,
-0.1928564012,
0.1012709588,
0.0788199008,
-0.3989705443,
-0.0324742049,
-0.1386391073,
0.1226848289,
-0.4856700301,
0.4250088036,
-0.3487925828,
-0.326967597,
-0.0780505314,
0.168672204,
-0.1754629314,
-0.0758054927,
-0.0275268238,
0.5981998444,
0.2897961736,
-0.611445725,
0.115445435,
-0.091490753,
-0.7340970635,
0.2966389358,
-0.1902607679,
-0.0202817358,
-0.2428519279,
0.3730581999,
-0.985293448,
-0.0429875962,
0.1265078485,
-0.4284575582,
0.3198487163,
0.043737255,
-0.6122902036,
-0.5903563499,
-0.4624709785,
0.3039934039,
0.3618486226,
-0.3282681704,
0.4950115085,
0.2386655509,
-0.0443798043,
-0.8865104318,
-0.7257705331,
0.0512773246,
-0.4413096905,
-0.6187748909,
0.272529155,
-0.0386016145,
-0.6939065456,
-0.35277614,
-0.2049825639,
0.3419319391,
0.2534091473,
0.3451048732,
0.1789145023,
-0.2123016864,
0.3267451525,
-0.1362307519,
0.0766147897,
0.0865269303,
-0.1299692094,
0.6950879097,
0.1324059814,
-0.8144512773,
0.0416677482,
0.1097698361,
0.277082473,
-0.0744789392,
0.8202474713,
0.5371339917,
-0.3982000351,
-0.1709069163,
-0.7241155505,
0.1473066509,
-0.4123421609,
0.456944555,
-0.4276875556,
-1.0478695631,
0.4160065055,
-0.0206031185,
0.0862156749,
0.6695563793,
0.6892629862,
-0.4193159938,
0.9540559649,
0.3974295855,
0.3603413105,
0.1855779141,
0.0204554498,
0.5675564408,
-1.0847826004,
-0.2159047723,
-0.5853838325,
-0.0671356395,
-0.6176595092,
-0.6114516854,
0.1077677011,
0.3244945407,
-0.1664776653,
0.1502964199,
-0.0442889854,
0.253560096,
0.2932947874,
-0.2847266793,
0.3282411695,
-0.0190446973,
-0.2069788575,
-0.3173024654,
-0.9982910752,
-0.8933696747,
1.4813536406,
0.4078648388,
0.5657470822,
0.1799575388,
0.56153512,
0.2332726717,
0.5728790164,
-0.7192505002,
0.559114337,
-0.2945114076,
-0.6854892373,
-0.5942626595,
-0.5014708638,
-1.0834984779,
0.4744432569,
-0.3488774002,
-1.1113090515,
0.1591877043,
-0.0645951927,
-0.5173322558,
0.4978297353,
-0.514482677,
0.6929060221,
-0.3457064629,
-0.2819391489,
-0.0287556984,
-0.3430251777,
0.5912507176,
-0.3337904811,
0.7309135199,
-0.2057320327,
0.2169371545,
0.8008493185,
-0.236546725,
0.5694810748,
-0.0151959751,
-0.5111659169,
0.4128182828,
0.1590584517,
0.1961847693,
0.0913177505,
-0.5854372382,
0.0657536387,
-0.0431743748,
-0.0047359644,
-0.5056701899,
0.7940143943,
-0.4536753893,
-0.8318349719,
-0.4975835383,
-0.526542902,
-0.610586822,
-0.1663543284,
0.3369567394,
0.3474733829,
-0.3170557916,
0.0378074385,
0.3760127425,
-0.5481952429,
0.6278198361,
0.2738660276,
-0.3826556802,
-0.323313117,
0.8632308841,
0.3144572675,
0.4457121193,
0.3888458312,
0.2594715953,
-0.5578712821,
-0.7188184857,
-0.3520332575,
0.1264775544,
-0.7705231905,
-0.1014661863,
-0.3610561788,
-0.0439165272,
-0.4334141612,
-0.1356208175,
-0.1916010529,
-0.304831624,
-0.3032492101,
-0.1456364989,
-0.2385400832,
0.5427401066,
0.0216574278,
0.2061833441,
-0.7744889259,
0.0313519686,
0.2325472236,
0.3055416048,
0.1906116158,
-0.419446826,
0.00667788,
0.1314753294,
-0.4990105033,
-0.9834253788,
0.1922334731,
0.0949453712,
0.7265110016,
0.361690551,
-0.002857693,
0.5586567521,
-0.4862808585,
0.9168391228,
0.4078088105,
-0.6577609181,
0.3346640766,
-0.226210922,
0.1657658666,
0.5440478325,
0.3493744433,
-0.1114300936,
-0.4341564476,
-0.7507864237,
-0.7581778169,
0.4853433073,
0.243211925,
0.1849202514,
-0.2289077789,
0.1579669714,
0.2302062809,
0.3672216237,
-0.8301714659,
-0.0560908131,
0.4538194537,
-0.1099240482,
-0.4713357985,
-0.3875497282,
0.0826253518,
0.0090670707,
0.6936405897,
0.0025563138,
0.2552320659,
0.0587156639,
-0.1888025105,
-0.2015475184,
0.5820407271,
0.5860578418,
0.9396778345,
-0.2854148746,
0.0816223547,
0.1755872071,
-0.1301727742,
0.1476678699,
0.0949873105,
-0.050482247,
0.0886784196,
0.523119092,
0.6005911231,
0.2613129914,
-0.866511941,
0.5061933398,
0.1658797115,
-0.0944112092,
-0.5039190054,
-0.0217702873,
0.3087780178,
0.2362721711,
0.4482954144,
-0.0168191791,
0.0964349285,
-0.8140619397,
0.0398631059,
0.8095576763,
-0.3291863799,
0.022909604,
0.5100235939,
-0.1756498963,
-0.4696743488,
0.457747519,
-0.1303181201,
-0.358350575,
0.7735512257,
0.5124402642,
0.7462251186,
-0.1901565641,
0.3348576128,
0.1558052003,
0.4343862832,
-0.1933091879,
0.2777470648,
0.2168792039,
-1.038844347,
-0.7886110544,
-1.0513137579,
-0.3224289715,
0.2810503542,
-0.3659981489,
0.2841621935,
-0.2441485822,
-0.6278292537,
-0.0216508526,
-0.1239796504,
-0.6195778251,
0.2880425751,
0.3047800064,
0.8350860476,
-0.7196652889,
0.502708137,
0.6813338995,
-0.2173490673,
-0.6205829978,
0.1753201783,
-0.1328497678,
-0.6082396507,
0.4736492336,
0.1409913749,
0.0192386489,
-0.2802176476,
-0.2653372288,
-0.803737402,
0.827483654,
0.5378580689,
-0.9366896152,
0.0234359354,
0.5125901103,
0.5289694667,
-0.3480776548,
0.3839309812,
0.6050348282,
0.5617457628,
-0.0114286738,
-1.0622719526,
-0.1144772992,
0.0766944066,
0.244488284,
0.0760399401,
-0.4131591916,
0.7206174731,
-0.4758703709,
-0.1845137626,
-0.0616074502,
0.4077803493,
0.8035261035,
0.340903908,
0.4719114602,
0.6401437521,
0.4902909398,
-0.1104444936,
1.2708524466,
0.108278431,
0.4558225572,
1.0823220015,
-0.4855147302,
1.0416312218,
0.8539393544,
-0.7345420718,
0.4127879739,
0.7866982818,
0.1150148585,
0.2738685906,
0.757982254,
-0.1386065632,
-0.4595539868,
0.0424726121,
-0.2882042825,
0.5397015214,
0.3497339189,
-0.3337970674,
-0.2003751695,
-0.068080999,
-0.2679460049,
0.100611791,
-0.1463039517,
0.5265700817,
0.3300918639,
-0.77983886,
0.3009996712,
0.1738016158,
0.7761918902,
-0.4693950415,
0.0434021205,
0.2066390365,
-0.0708131269,
-0.3418497443,
-1.0320799351,
0.3485103548,
-0.0900582522,
-0.018905066,
-0.0171679463,
0.7135736942,
-0.1003728211,
-0.6895712018,
0.2392707765,
0.6893838644,
0.0618301667,
-0.0579567663,
-0.5435975194,
0.1386160105,
-0.0433887355,
-0.3469516337,
0.5787136555,
0.3444911242,
-0.0330313221,
0.8392919898,
0.670466423,
0.1009349823,
-0.1217163578,
0.3205610216,
0.2932267487,
-0.4254419208,
-0.1810409427,
-1.1540839672,
0.5573855042,
0.2844197154,
-0.3196547329,
0.7930619717,
0.5401433706,
0.83501333,
-0.1267511845,
0.8987012506,
0.0856931508,
0.2077375054,
-0.689211309,
0.2695038021,
-0.3571594059,
0.6831062436,
-0.5335798264,
-1.1172659397,
-0.3611877561,
0.4581272304,
-0.7313668728,
0.1494372338,
0.6000936031,
0.3772925436,
0.2845669389,
-0.0644404814,
0.4467245042,
-0.0513983257,
0.2035957277,
0.6515356898,
1.2822707891,
-0.1622982919,
0.4080902636,
-0.1463986188,
-0.0008743519,
-0.2320360988,
-1.0822575092,
-0.5841883421,
-0.518840909,
-0.2290161401,
-0.1952545196,
-0.0060564331,
0.7103051543,
0.1086920351,
-0.6393502951,
-0.425316602,
-0.0254069846,
0.2825566828,
-0.0967161506,
-0.2813801169,
0.2534847558,
-0.2158977091,
-0.4668876827,
0.342639327,
0.3431646824,
-0.0442291051,
-0.4588699937,
-0.0954763889,
-0.25463745,
0.078148067,
0.712459445,
-0.0015363782,
-0.9129896164,
-0.3036083877,
-0.2075033933,
0.144354701,
-0.0335560441,
0.5000821948,
-0.6730527282,
0.2382575572,
0.3621582687,
0.6092510819,
0.1047437713,
0.0400040559,
0.8640454412,
-0.5326018333,
-0.259673059,
0.4817969799,
0.4330785275,
0.4683098495,
-0.1737945825,
0.3387462497,
0.0300209746,
-0.4122689068,
-1.0792859793,
0.3462705016,
-0.7785150409,
-0.2986543179,
1.3904078007,
-0.0124438275,
0.0836030617,
0.0167850032,
0.122448124,
0.0880899429,
-0.0458993837,
0.6156008244,
1.1276268959,
-0.275857836,
-0.0425769091,
-0.8610150814,
0.3228900433,
0.6042137742,
-0.517367661,
-0.0191887394,
0.476646632,
0.1353092343,
0.2360120565,
0.6768665314,
-0.2012891918,
0.0666204244,
-0.2562654316,
-0.0952933133,
0.3990066648,
-0.206848681,
-0.6188046932,
0.4159199297,
0.4483849704,
0.0803587735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13874v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13874v3
|
$Se^2$: Sequential Example Selection for In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-21T15:35:04 | 2024-06-06T11:12:57 |
Haoyu Liu, Jianfeng Liu, Shaohan Huang, Yuefeng Zhan, Hao Sun, Weiwei Deng, Furu Wei, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The remarkable capability of large language models (LLMs) for in-context
learning (ICL) needs to be activated by demonstration examples. Prior work has
extensively explored the selection of examples for ICL, predominantly following
the "select then organize" paradigm, such approaches often neglect the internal
relationships between examples and exist an inconsistency between the training
and inference. In this paper, we formulate the problem as a $Se$quential
$Se$lection problem and introduce $Se^2$, a sequential-aware method that
leverages the LLM's feedback on varying context, aiding in capturing
inter-relationships and sequential information among examples, significantly
enriching the contextuality and relevance of ICL prompts. Meanwhile, we utilize
beam search to seek and construct example sequences, enhancing both quality and
diversity. Extensive experiments across 23 NLP tasks from 8 distinct categories
illustrate that $Se^2$ markedly surpasses competitive baselines and achieves
42\% relative improvement over random selection. Further in-depth analysis
shows the effectiveness of proposed strategies, highlighting $Se^2$'s
exceptional stability and adaptability across various scenarios. Code available
at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps.
|
[
-0.0071947891,
-0.7303755879,
0.7016168833,
0.4357706904,
-0.3883573711,
-0.0012232225,
-0.0604429729,
-0.230276376,
-0.1872223467,
0.0657077581,
-0.3609833717,
-0.1565305293,
-0.3227576911,
0.1935747266,
-0.5525544286,
0.629632771,
0.0963570103,
0.2089118659,
-0.3115370572,
-0.2049633414,
-0.3890166581,
-0.2005436122,
-1.0139760971,
-0.2761031091,
0.3103924692,
0.8022174835,
0.2119722813,
0.216993466,
0.1760623455,
0.2946080267,
-0.0301002711,
0.2879998684,
-0.4436021447,
0.5396162868,
-0.2774114013,
-0.3826490045,
0.1608384401,
-0.0124643603,
0.9869988561,
0.8330195546,
0.1869298369,
0.0562909581,
0.1847692728,
0.5480676293,
-0.4051576257,
-0.1144999936,
-0.8275077939,
0.1625921428,
-0.1891488582,
-0.1520603597,
-0.7005780339,
-0.0139306812,
0.1939151883,
-0.352496624,
-0.2193283737,
0.3518193662,
0.2927751243,
0.0957888588,
-0.5954162478,
-0.3133248687,
-0.5265903473,
0.7042313218,
-0.7905015945,
0.4455884397,
0.1925759614,
0.0916711986,
-0.2832992077,
-1.030176878,
-0.4512008727,
-0.3011068404,
-0.0267798975,
0.1900118291,
0.2381114513,
-0.3304051161,
0.5826662779,
-0.075059846,
-0.6091771126,
0.4704480171,
-0.0738829002,
0.116759412,
0.3336575031,
0.0314602293,
0.2520963848,
0.0204921626,
-0.4123796225,
-0.0824466869,
-1.0815138817,
0.1710882932,
0.0163930804,
0.0384919569,
-0.0472640917,
0.4830646515,
-0.1125376523,
0.4825337827,
0.1079405695,
0.0587139577,
0.2792660296,
-0.2250982523,
-0.2168971002,
-0.1480329484,
0.3773144484,
0.1652856767,
-0.3017215431,
-0.1154371947,
-0.2698484063,
-0.2527168095,
-0.2268390208,
-0.9331899881,
0.1707237512,
0.4035008252,
-0.5187797546,
0.0191687346,
0.1298993528,
-0.6202625632,
-0.3193589449,
-0.3490712345,
0.2453031987,
-0.1705519855,
-0.0958783701,
-0.0409128033,
-0.240156576,
0.2592935264,
0.322247833,
-0.8678786755,
0.2440218925,
0.6729879975,
0.5952154994,
-0.1526258439,
-0.3495580554,
-0.7691093087,
0.1729865223,
-0.4429893792,
0.6175905466,
-0.4807483852,
-0.4117502272,
0.0894026831,
-0.113688007,
0.0470312126,
-0.5403766632,
0.3107753098,
-0.5070668459,
0.409814328,
-0.1704978496,
-0.8477078676,
0.0981808379,
-0.1416830271,
-0.2226022184,
1.1458445787,
0.1108254045,
-0.5873892307,
0.4733321071,
-0.3362103999,
-0.5158193111,
0.2562195957,
-0.6672049165,
-0.3713257909,
0.364485383,
-0.1129536778,
0.6204035878,
-0.0262025166,
0.1692440957,
-0.4076261818,
-0.4184828401,
0.2030479163,
-0.0127822906,
0.6680415273,
0.2822858691,
-0.5552430749,
0.0806533098,
-0.4802087843,
-0.0059701125,
0.32225281,
-0.0728721321,
-0.5375030637,
0.246114403,
-0.1113405228,
0.3940527439,
0.054999318,
-0.1475926489,
0.2159489393,
-0.5654202104,
0.4347918332,
0.7878894806,
0.1292851269,
0.7429508567,
-0.2186231911,
0.2756919265,
0.0201737825,
-0.1008606479,
-0.4038572013,
-0.292799145,
-0.7845494747,
-0.0475593619,
0.1042565852,
0.5063961744,
-0.8038243055,
0.3081931472,
0.0193965938,
-0.2174950987,
0.0029181957,
0.1348199248,
0.3676767945,
0.4892118573,
0.2086164653,
-0.1233952716,
-0.6307119727,
-0.8207977414,
-0.2007134259,
-0.1451917291,
0.0874725655,
0.4518912733,
0.4893038273,
-0.191591382,
0.8263654113,
-0.1227682456,
-0.0151646649,
-0.301481694,
0.1361781359,
0.1692800969,
0.393113941,
0.4534294605,
-0.7869651318,
-0.5051470995,
-0.2454767823,
-0.7070090771,
-0.1676287651,
-0.5662299991,
-0.0631858781,
0.1710537374,
1.0868960619,
-0.0701733753,
0.1425011456,
0.1683216095,
-0.5043284297,
0.2250980884,
-0.2399218529,
-0.1971311569,
-1.0859563351,
-0.1909909248,
-0.0045575919,
-0.3609444797,
-0.4365490973,
0.1703269184,
0.2712902427,
0.1234125346,
-0.6309655309,
0.8406183124,
-0.5131919384,
-0.3296490014,
-0.1362325549,
0.3322229385,
-0.3389029503,
0.2042904943,
0.0541283935,
0.7476360798,
0.241827786,
-0.4601592422,
-0.3375844657,
0.2515887916,
-0.6917102933,
0.175979495,
-0.5829260945,
0.3663201332,
-0.1398525089,
0.3893574774,
-0.9602900743,
-0.0598532781,
-0.069822751,
-0.0654962435,
0.4827156961,
0.0051314458,
-0.6082214117,
-0.2084854692,
-0.2386470139,
0.4116557539,
0.7883877754,
-0.6961129904,
0.1559485793,
0.3358122408,
-0.31988132,
-0.5352714062,
-0.4175349772,
0.0109514641,
-0.1948898286,
-0.4274476767,
0.4297895133,
-0.3325898349,
-0.4547001719,
-0.32258147,
-0.3040660322,
0.3611312807,
0.5056848526,
0.2247413397,
0.0136234509,
-0.0326098613,
0.1505458504,
0.4580631852,
-0.0892530754,
-0.2064903677,
-0.3100461066,
0.4206691086,
-0.191192165,
-0.5539451241,
-0.2349373102,
0.6350724101,
0.1354205608,
0.1347558796,
0.2389994562,
0.223565951,
-0.3330789804,
-0.8518225551,
-0.4423593581,
-0.4958294332,
-0.4600513577,
0.6939998269,
-0.3600625098,
-1.1187343597,
0.1764950752,
-0.3392388225,
0.1944150031,
0.0509407297,
0.498013705,
-0.2744740248,
1.157777667,
0.2672126591,
0.0740138441,
0.7603945136,
-0.2645616829,
0.2273146361,
-0.9336509705,
-0.1293698251,
-0.4140897393,
-0.2802776396,
-0.145748049,
-0.4572122097,
0.3501538336,
0.4385007024,
-0.3602709174,
0.1701607108,
-0.1121498123,
0.5995654464,
0.462261796,
0.1853863299,
0.0454481766,
-0.0199151598,
-0.4616798162,
-0.2043838501,
-0.6278562546,
-0.4752725065,
0.6155545712,
0.2492834628,
0.4704851508,
0.3142372668,
0.7239034176,
0.2834818661,
0.2082621008,
-0.486083746,
0.8113178611,
-0.3784194589,
-0.1387176514,
-0.2422184646,
-0.0085120536,
-0.7778735161,
0.425026685,
-0.0344826132,
-0.7690993547,
0.048434522,
0.070187591,
-0.3757581413,
-0.2181469351,
-0.693683207,
0.7002503276,
-0.3914268911,
-0.5846615434,
-0.3369154036,
-0.8325614333,
0.1630467176,
-0.0239085071,
0.3160634339,
-0.0915205181,
-0.2229841501,
0.5959044099,
-0.248793602,
0.7955298424,
-0.1840113699,
0.1957998276,
0.0818863362,
0.1842427105,
0.799398005,
0.3681049347,
0.0193896629,
-0.3460283577,
-0.2730347812,
-0.1097152978,
-0.7233146429,
0.6891440749,
-0.5403775573,
-0.6993296742,
-0.301366061,
-0.2420007437,
-0.4119349122,
0.0874527246,
0.1584380269,
0.6652930379,
0.0348394029,
0.5078566074,
0.6183982491,
-0.1954134405,
0.850687325,
0.5423281193,
-0.3275831044,
-0.1715360284,
0.5680369139,
-0.0028481458,
0.3307031095,
0.6407651305,
0.2492506504,
-0.3803837895,
-0.8505439162,
-0.2312019616,
0.1588039547,
-0.8744193912,
-0.0536768548,
-0.658210218,
-0.1512825787,
-0.3190325797,
-0.4868389666,
0.1116628274,
-0.5360717773,
-0.4094629884,
-0.1916027814,
-0.3039777279,
0.5416962504,
0.0631995201,
0.1009509936,
-0.3674683273,
0.1736271381,
0.519752562,
-0.0585775524,
0.0503357984,
-0.7716513276,
-0.1725307256,
-0.2367765903,
-0.1395632625,
-0.7744938731,
0.3033907115,
0.3282511532,
0.8169659376,
0.5921449065,
-0.093454726,
0.6182582378,
-0.7418621778,
0.857999146,
0.0990846977,
-0.961692512,
0.721149683,
-0.1862567216,
0.2963731587,
0.6849682927,
0.244421497,
-0.6376992464,
-0.5130628943,
-0.6878990531,
-1.1387369633,
0.5863019228,
-0.0086621828,
0.035907384,
-0.356991291,
0.1679039598,
0.1449841112,
0.0209201425,
-0.7408381701,
-0.2800534964,
0.1775893867,
-0.2036730647,
-0.0447332039,
-0.6899782419,
0.1354328841,
-0.1276718527,
0.8442417383,
-0.284257859,
0.1177486405,
0.2977875173,
-0.503752768,
0.3009873629,
0.2584556341,
0.8426483274,
0.6660476327,
0.0090050353,
0.2744512558,
0.2997073233,
0.0194247495,
0.0677247494,
-0.0406689495,
-0.4335428178,
-0.1280701458,
0.2784082592,
0.6072807312,
0.6549110413,
-0.7885805368,
0.6502574682,
0.0628793165,
0.0430873111,
-0.6009142995,
-0.0632802397,
-0.0295172594,
0.5651018023,
0.5249936581,
0.0269504171,
0.3518697321,
-0.417617619,
0.4760400951,
0.5668147206,
-0.2683044076,
-0.1024280861,
0.627833724,
0.2927509248,
-0.5356654525,
0.6578325629,
-0.5366182327,
-0.4208979011,
0.7267675996,
0.9647982121,
0.839928031,
0.0327114984,
0.1213810518,
0.4281424582,
0.0009369343,
-0.4062837958,
0.3508223891,
-0.2487009615,
-0.9027540088,
-0.2893040478,
-0.1426956207,
-0.322072655,
0.0712962374,
-0.3983344734,
0.485788703,
-0.4790750146,
0.2213617414,
-0.2022093385,
-0.1198509485,
-0.5471020937,
-0.133706972,
0.424698323,
1.0960383415,
-0.7838834524,
0.9299160242,
0.5751438737,
-0.2113233507,
-0.6525719762,
-0.1764658093,
0.1168463603,
-0.7755765915,
0.8854489923,
0.3480603695,
0.1294366121,
0.0813296884,
-0.680228591,
-0.5842761993,
1.2878632545,
0.1514754891,
-0.7444523573,
0.0588683411,
-0.3146579266,
0.2208597213,
-0.6458230019,
0.5682393312,
0.3702403903,
0.1465670168,
0.0142200328,
-0.5056092739,
0.0478471704,
-0.2642749846,
0.2339933068,
-0.021552477,
-0.7718653083,
0.443572253,
-0.469012022,
-0.2668597996,
0.3732866049,
0.8972790837,
0.7229610682,
0.5471658111,
0.8027624488,
0.3555100858,
0.7452938557,
0.0964552984,
0.859813571,
-0.0291489791,
0.1530096382,
1.6659198999,
-0.6409497261,
1.125109911,
0.7112260461,
-0.1769264489,
0.5651512742,
0.7768535614,
0.1004791632,
0.7130753398,
0.1634963453,
-0.4069035947,
-0.2927499413,
-0.0767440721,
-0.3404709101,
0.2779571116,
0.5052509904,
-0.5366488695,
-0.1168367192,
-0.0031566373,
0.0672393069,
0.0442199595,
-0.1330257058,
0.7477708459,
0.3028109074,
-0.7047606111,
-0.1039093211,
-0.2033991665,
0.5650941133,
-0.6645169854,
-0.2331487685,
-0.3907640278,
0.009878193,
-0.0406890027,
-0.5194192529,
-0.1296826899,
-0.4411586225,
-0.0922939479,
-0.6715794802,
0.5959036946,
-0.5105268955,
-0.2683361769,
0.2588699758,
0.5193098187,
0.0900185406,
0.3615133464,
-0.5230657458,
-0.1601211876,
0.1003532931,
-0.1834503114,
0.4588132799,
0.2884126902,
-0.1377883852,
0.5358302593,
0.4511013031,
-0.1173093617,
-0.1314824075,
0.2872003615,
0.5509884357,
-0.3594666123,
-0.5905203819,
-0.7598667741,
0.752499342,
-0.4620308876,
-0.3981943727,
0.8576167822,
0.7235637903,
1.0859924555,
-0.1243316382,
0.7453132868,
-0.1182878017,
0.5664936304,
-0.7135080695,
0.1965685338,
-0.5267724991,
0.550557375,
-0.1342849135,
-0.6861338019,
-0.2334496081,
0.8216551542,
-0.0823132098,
-0.02164918,
1.1142252684,
0.6953787208,
0.1070527732,
0.099590458,
0.4135815799,
0.3693537414,
0.2532786131,
0.4873969853,
1.0160498619,
-0.3144344687,
-0.0277100783,
-0.2040370554,
-0.2253900021,
-0.3358938992,
-1.0882028341,
-0.8057789207,
-0.9477482438,
-0.3499269783,
-0.2841186225,
-0.0109108482,
1.4201815128,
0.8953815103,
-0.8624845147,
-0.2501181662,
-0.0285998099,
0.3231757879,
-0.2510752082,
-0.1601128131,
0.1835641712,
-0.7281288505,
-0.6189057231,
0.8492508531,
0.374971807,
0.1370221227,
0.0637136698,
0.0460895114,
-0.1608947217,
-0.1859870553,
0.9256797433,
0.3423856497,
-0.7059985995,
-0.4331455827,
-0.0917856544,
0.0006911013,
-0.3028956652,
1.1230326891,
-0.7696638703,
0.317358613,
0.5565368533,
0.8727473617,
0.412307322,
-0.2183705717,
0.4107317924,
-0.8875603676,
0.4330502748,
0.4226617217,
0.883620441,
0.0857881084,
-0.2340812981,
0.6205573678,
0.2693554461,
-0.7464277744,
-0.7801792622,
0.3718019724,
-1.0562345982,
-0.5041217208,
1.5844439268,
0.0242294073,
0.298038125,
-0.0964416787,
-0.1917437017,
-0.1687832624,
-0.4538632333,
0.4599150419,
0.3602705896,
-0.1862927228,
-0.1550979316,
-0.5241288543,
0.416526854,
0.7181375027,
-0.7592936754,
-0.3031047583,
0.4694088101,
0.046578493,
-0.2893362939,
0.7119197249,
0.1104892343,
0.0816089883,
-0.2253078073,
-0.4713291228,
0.1590685844,
-0.400927633,
-0.5156558752,
0.1872865856,
0.2763087153,
0.112876609
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.