id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13228v2
|
Smaug: Fixing Failure Modes of Preference Optimisation with DPO-Positive
| 2024-02-20T18:42:34 | 2024-07-03T13:46:33 |
Arka Pal, Deep Karkhanis, Samuel Dooley, Manley Roberts, Siddartha Naidu, Colin White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Direct Preference Optimisation (DPO) is effective at significantly improving
the performance of large language models (LLMs) on downstream tasks such as
reasoning, summarisation, and alignment. Using pairs of preferred and
dispreferred data, DPO models the relative probability of picking one response
over another. In this work, first we show theoretically that the standard DPO
loss can lead to a reduction of the model's likelihood of the preferred
examples, as long as the relative probability between the preferred and
dispreferred classes increases. We then show empirically that this phenomenon
occurs when fine-tuning LLMs on common datasets, especially datasets in which
the edit distance between pairs of completions is low. Using these insights, we
design DPO-Positive (DPOP), a new loss function and training procedure which
avoids this failure mode. Surprisingly, we find that DPOP outperforms DPO and
other fine-tuning procedures across a wide variety of datasets and downstream
tasks, including datasets with high edit distances between completions.
Furthermore, we find that the DPOP-tuned model outperforms the DPO-tuned model
(all else equal) on benchmarks independent of the fine-tuning data, such as
MT-Bench. Finally, using DPOP, we create and open-source Smaug-34B and
Smaug-72B, with the latter becoming the first open-source LLM to surpass an
average accuracy of 80% on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
|
[
-0.4976447225,
-0.5629135966,
0.6718658805,
0.1389871091,
-0.2961957753,
-0.0620157383,
-0.2521011233,
-0.0895422325,
-0.0308973137,
0.5472804308,
-0.6841372848,
-0.1808805317,
-0.7184653282,
0.2582094967,
-0.1662973166,
0.7560313344,
-0.1071558893,
-0.1351431906,
-0.3769806027,
-0.0729994699,
-0.3765851259,
-0.6052250862,
-0.6703429818,
-0.3279249966,
0.4535126686,
0.7306120396,
0.8403943181,
0.673745513,
0.6192349195,
0.250892669,
-0.2071260661,
0.4866994023,
-0.7266309857,
0.0364067852,
0.1048195735,
-0.7666435838,
-0.7770132422,
0.235150665,
0.5635171533,
0.6919453144,
-0.2029263824,
-0.1255721748,
0.2695966363,
1.2801879644,
-0.4098325968,
0.0729052573,
-0.9383752942,
0.0473628156,
-0.2684099674,
-0.3732371032,
-0.4568492174,
-0.3789177835,
0.0567544661,
-0.4076898396,
-0.0075696171,
0.108189933,
0.6552194357,
0.6360797882,
-0.4258084595,
-0.1889224648,
-0.6774905324,
0.9288844466,
-0.7739166617,
0.3636392951,
0.4203121662,
0.0183226336,
-0.5413975716,
0.0419012569,
-0.505110085,
-0.3051433265,
-0.0100170905,
0.0403090306,
0.0466209836,
0.2585570216,
0.2083837986,
0.7871755958,
-0.2286153436,
0.1038196459,
-0.0780284554,
-0.0722581968,
0.6223955154,
-0.0000972601,
-0.0941585004,
-0.2473172992,
-0.2315787077,
0.1238471568,
-0.892283082,
-0.0729357451,
0.6027434468,
0.3901874423,
0.2184700966,
0.4892732203,
-0.2510117888,
0.9443010092,
0.619936049,
-0.4366699159,
0.3662887812,
0.0108973235,
-0.2253571451,
0.0198452175,
0.5747125149,
0.527479291,
0.3201313019,
0.0567073636,
-0.1534592211,
0.0245679412,
0.0561572947,
-0.4097044766,
-0.1548468918,
0.4210057855,
-0.3891836107,
-0.6064729095,
-0.2551507354,
-0.2350623906,
-0.3765899241,
-0.5595860481,
0.3939228058,
-0.4288904071,
-0.2722485065,
0.4062036276,
0.0859016925,
0.0188554153,
0.2924541831,
-0.9490342736,
0.174957186,
0.7883228064,
0.9488816857,
-0.3265924752,
-0.2820604444,
-0.8783994913,
0.0192732774,
-0.3896916211,
0.6969881654,
-0.2439109236,
-0.4743771851,
-0.2582389712,
-0.0319358967,
-0.2105609179,
-0.7242274284,
0.7818970084,
-0.2096473426,
0.1855376363,
-0.4691039324,
-0.7347750664,
-0.1280802786,
0.2407762706,
-0.5693272948,
0.9445611238,
0.1199170947,
-0.8878360391,
0.5713179708,
-0.5004495978,
-0.4264113307,
-0.2185169458,
0.0074854624,
-0.5901857615,
0.3382381499,
-0.0449352041,
0.5825895071,
-0.0183044858,
0.2493835837,
-0.7955273986,
-0.4794426858,
0.0145927081,
-0.1393635869,
0.8116664886,
-0.086110644,
-0.2643647194,
0.1663455963,
-0.7535418272,
-0.3261085749,
0.1233791262,
-0.2414818108,
-0.5575575829,
0.2973616123,
-0.3720125556,
0.3949919939,
0.1094051003,
-0.6127381921,
0.4533589184,
-0.3689752519,
0.5590746403,
1.0641816854,
-0.2514191568,
0.4089093208,
-0.4787478149,
0.3328817487,
0.0455691665,
0.403172344,
0.2615008354,
-0.3367823958,
-0.8175615072,
-0.224745661,
0.2106758803,
0.6398233771,
-0.5404501557,
0.5159862041,
0.0887796655,
-0.2690526843,
-0.5510742068,
0.3868938982,
-0.0011565996,
1.0290429592,
0.0096686883,
-0.1755892485,
-0.4467610419,
-0.9607929587,
0.1010637507,
-0.3115732074,
0.121569626,
0.5504729152,
-0.0285834596,
-0.3813102543,
0.6962227225,
-0.6467109919,
-0.3671267033,
-0.2352901846,
-0.3203173578,
0.3368865252,
0.1855984181,
0.8234129548,
-0.7958872318,
-0.5983438492,
-0.1237917021,
-0.3034383655,
-0.1802084446,
0.1938174963,
-0.2166855782,
0.4463677704,
0.1198904365,
-0.4642896354,
0.0797881037,
0.7111344934,
-0.2315954268,
0.6526243687,
-0.1759660095,
0.4560093284,
-0.8791791201,
-0.1026290655,
0.0390738323,
-0.3655068576,
-0.4522649348,
-0.272061348,
0.0727689639,
0.012814844,
-0.5300897956,
0.3167276084,
-0.0243984014,
0.1705563217,
-0.323143214,
0.1159154773,
-0.2418818474,
0.3516870737,
-0.0320009813,
0.6882074475,
0.6692538261,
-0.7173549533,
0.2515506148,
0.4078266025,
0.0059311157,
0.6022059917,
-0.5419216156,
0.1094873324,
-0.2054031342,
0.0866114348,
-1.1142463684,
-0.3204731047,
0.2080667615,
-0.1097729504,
0.3971279263,
-0.3684716523,
-0.4707867205,
-0.4489958584,
-0.478872925,
0.0985415801,
0.4366002381,
-0.6171394587,
0.1863866001,
0.4252358377,
-0.2553495467,
-0.5182447433,
-0.4315350354,
-0.1124888435,
-0.4881578088,
-0.7857736945,
0.3725120425,
-0.4102516472,
-0.2127782404,
-0.3505199552,
-0.2867229879,
0.0707730129,
0.2905325294,
0.2675341666,
0.3884056807,
0.1246334463,
0.0880345851,
0.1092915758,
-0.3232255578,
-0.2784841657,
0.0573903322,
0.4489952922,
-0.3541901708,
-0.2005355358,
-0.2419674546,
0.2855314016,
0.7313409448,
-0.0838293582,
0.6735714674,
0.2692401111,
-0.187727645,
-0.2340215743,
-0.482832104,
-0.1784003228,
-0.5412825942,
0.0442117415,
-0.4359437823,
-0.955365181,
0.2751348913,
0.0369281955,
0.1995536536,
0.4460314214,
0.3055948317,
-0.174950555,
1.1233261824,
0.980907321,
-0.231096074,
0.5537093282,
-0.0016371397,
0.1723383367,
-0.5790202618,
0.2321294248,
-0.3121650815,
-0.2316337228,
-0.6643531322,
-0.0725831389,
0.4256800115,
0.3131031096,
0.0062486734,
0.2115843743,
-0.4273984134,
0.3293791711,
0.6087555885,
0.1641411781,
0.5252861977,
-0.0012470232,
0.0072744591,
-0.1609152257,
-0.7813316584,
-0.4613877833,
1.1148393154,
0.3341990411,
0.7281988859,
-0.1053473726,
1.001303792,
0.241538167,
0.2488797307,
-1.013936162,
0.461920321,
-0.581340611,
-0.355037272,
-0.1733513623,
-0.5648097396,
-0.5609351993,
-0.0708212703,
-0.0440492034,
-0.3317828178,
0.1725294292,
0.7627882361,
-0.3965907693,
0.3239405453,
-0.7453529239,
0.821901679,
-0.3249529004,
-0.3434386849,
-0.2023872733,
-0.3216247857,
0.5402621031,
-0.0200119279,
0.0388466567,
-0.3554002345,
0.0595897026,
0.4435574114,
-0.2052993476,
0.4492433667,
-0.1349056065,
-0.2085808516,
0.1450446993,
0.177422896,
0.3322399259,
0.0984805301,
-0.428832829,
0.1410154402,
-0.0209978446,
-0.3939551711,
-0.4436150193,
0.9802648425,
-0.6357329488,
-0.6479358673,
-0.4238030314,
-0.2996474504,
-0.465082556,
0.1661212593,
0.1279855669,
0.5346400738,
0.2135949731,
0.193723768,
0.7887709141,
-0.0085644675,
0.2643866837,
0.5855318904,
-0.0927864164,
-0.3739564121,
0.7740502357,
0.0644023418,
0.4983947873,
0.1676267833,
0.3305618465,
-0.3049054742,
-0.6449092627,
-0.4528097212,
0.3665612638,
-0.4591712952,
-0.2456256598,
-0.3935864866,
-0.1409048885,
-0.1884444207,
-0.1267999709,
-0.5749982595,
-0.5325849056,
-0.1885649264,
-0.1485192776,
0.4462319314,
0.4773604274,
-0.2269734442,
0.0323045105,
-0.534239471,
0.3386902809,
0.2192616463,
0.8586592674,
-0.2217016667,
-0.4669958353,
0.0324618071,
0.1059311777,
-0.4037974477,
-0.8072977662,
0.1891108155,
0.2716545761,
0.5207760334,
0.2468922734,
0.1251060367,
0.5463527441,
-0.5044615269,
0.4210573733,
-0.0068323938,
-0.6359477639,
0.8166697621,
-0.6632091999,
0.1470181048,
0.8331499696,
0.5800082088,
-0.4700925946,
-0.1978737414,
-0.4566983283,
-0.6627442837,
0.6185949445,
0.0066352044,
-0.297005415,
-0.214339152,
0.7152357697,
0.5002600551,
0.399946928,
-0.5723854303,
-0.548794508,
0.0146025904,
-0.0836674199,
-0.3356577754,
-0.3966047764,
-0.131790176,
-0.2395434231,
1.0868452787,
-0.2189121693,
-0.056232024,
0.3222322762,
-0.021627441,
-0.3744439185,
0.3346984982,
0.4989086986,
0.5930259228,
-0.7202172279,
-0.1470326781,
-0.2283688933,
-0.2382445782,
0.1986419559,
0.1760598272,
-0.3438720703,
-0.2115752399,
-0.1121656522,
0.7633137107,
0.0199698061,
-0.5425863266,
0.3041206598,
-0.1893730462,
-0.3027561009,
0.0299448222,
0.1155858487,
-0.1929033995,
-0.2402049005,
0.3026860952,
0.3209559023,
0.2581599057,
-0.5703443289,
0.3862601817,
0.4495023191,
-0.524557054,
-0.1838134229,
0.4929435551,
0.4619635642,
-0.2279673964,
0.3702013791,
-0.3563836515,
-0.5492188931,
0.2600551546,
0.3590908647,
0.8623821139,
-0.06725768,
0.4341242611,
0.2512951195,
0.2562547922,
-0.3339102268,
0.3017300963,
0.0708133355,
-0.6021925211,
-0.5633016229,
-0.7374514937,
-0.6573736668,
0.3268109262,
-0.4960682988,
0.3923821747,
-0.3777265549,
-0.1636710763,
-0.1947639585,
0.2436621189,
-0.5884658694,
0.167101562,
0.1472982466,
0.7315177321,
-0.88129884,
0.5260058045,
0.7201772332,
-0.0100424262,
-0.4978174865,
0.0434269793,
0.2181307673,
-0.5790091157,
0.0968888924,
0.0879525468,
-0.0940697864,
-0.1227303594,
-0.154164508,
-0.9697517157,
0.7475731969,
0.6716132164,
-0.9672778845,
0.141763553,
-0.0577437468,
0.358518213,
-0.2537622154,
-0.0968211815,
0.7610120177,
0.2859780192,
-0.1355390847,
-1.3670463562,
-0.1214370131,
0.1127714589,
-0.4605868757,
0.5189925432,
-1.0962616205,
0.6371731162,
-0.156307146,
0.1732885391,
-0.076094225,
0.1142512783,
0.3101965487,
0.1477685422,
0.9014031291,
0.6182083488,
0.6740500927,
-0.1953285784,
1.0907096863,
-0.3015901148,
0.3385437131,
0.9446532726,
-0.2463528365,
0.9720410109,
0.5984660983,
-0.2118606865,
0.2823830843,
0.7689674497,
0.4411750734,
0.6519491673,
-0.0678889453,
-0.0578075051,
-0.3651086688,
0.1705054492,
-0.3543838859,
0.4781564176,
0.1215306371,
-0.1662089229,
0.0977098495,
0.0017810059,
-0.1778711677,
0.1089773402,
-0.4321349859,
0.6500043273,
0.1624740511,
-0.6897991896,
0.739716053,
-0.1993331909,
0.797051847,
-0.5512911677,
0.221264869,
-0.4435044527,
0.4455065727,
-0.3280708492,
-0.6564376354,
0.5018869042,
-0.3754564524,
-0.4377756119,
-0.2895316184,
0.8368673325,
-0.3798194826,
-0.5323461294,
0.2758613825,
0.2936752141,
-0.3218899071,
-0.186617136,
-0.7787399292,
0.2595169246,
0.261441052,
-0.1583684534,
0.2891080976,
0.1427435428,
0.2600302696,
0.7762996554,
0.3011939824,
0.1396625042,
-0.2310035527,
0.0358408093,
0.6729069352,
-0.4762018919,
-0.542509973,
-0.8332711458,
0.5343303084,
-0.1492102146,
-0.2248923033,
0.8249260187,
0.4319865108,
0.8666092157,
-0.0785514787,
0.8010203242,
0.0560726412,
0.7461267114,
-0.3301458955,
0.5242488384,
-0.7724786997,
0.2220885009,
-0.486972034,
-1.0489288568,
-0.1747126877,
0.5491401553,
-0.5375900269,
-0.3696939051,
0.2769289911,
0.6135555506,
-0.3068442047,
-0.2225153893,
0.2901378572,
0.2077948749,
0.3076193631,
0.5537648797,
0.5520453453,
-0.4319563508,
0.5434533954,
-0.6144106984,
-0.6643304825,
-0.3721560836,
-1.0544871092,
-0.915979147,
-0.5315870643,
-0.5693825483,
-0.1926018,
0.1787904352,
0.7416704893,
0.7888335586,
-0.6954869628,
-0.1078810841,
-0.0966794193,
0.2399228662,
-0.1897999048,
-0.2682148218,
0.0945190266,
-0.2442371547,
-0.567599237,
0.3606630266,
0.6678313017,
0.0745995194,
-0.1002420932,
-0.1989936978,
-0.0239318889,
0.1417756379,
0.7493696809,
0.1647409201,
-0.7325174809,
-0.4177425504,
0.1442839205,
0.166612491,
0.2332780361,
0.5998075008,
-0.5163894892,
0.4578713775,
0.3924229443,
0.5122725964,
0.3140053153,
-0.0150778601,
0.8141767383,
-0.5615890026,
0.1357433349,
0.1241738722,
0.492526412,
0.5597164035,
-0.4289766252,
0.4594844878,
0.2647013664,
-0.8077657223,
-1.0095205307,
0.4224603176,
-1.1577066183,
0.1000088081,
1.1015217304,
0.2030382454,
-0.1163673252,
0.2413662821,
-0.6349724531,
-0.1072538346,
-0.4770747721,
1.1359736919,
0.8500270247,
-0.4763619304,
-0.0072705178,
-0.3543578088,
0.9978551865,
0.4606623352,
-0.5341868401,
0.1418492645,
0.5710904598,
0.5822883844,
-0.0650446638,
0.7728336453,
0.0398986414,
0.3690263629,
-0.2308344692,
-0.5097429752,
-0.1512486935,
-0.2786054313,
-0.1962552369,
0.0703713298,
0.3606415689,
-0.1254851371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13225v1
|
AgentMD: Empowering Language Agents for Risk Prediction with Large-Scale Clinical Tool Learning
| 2024-02-20T18:37:19 | 2024-02-20T18:37:19 |
Qiao Jin, Zhizheng Wang, Yifan Yang, Qingqing Zhu, Donald Wright, Thomas Huang, W John Wilbur, Zhe He, Andrew Taylor, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Clinical calculators play a vital role in healthcare by offering accurate
evidence-based predictions for various purposes such as prognosis.
Nevertheless, their widespread utilization is frequently hindered by usability
challenges, poor dissemination, and restricted functionality. Augmenting large
language models with extensive collections of clinical calculators presents an
opportunity to overcome these obstacles and improve workflow efficiency, but
the scalability of the manual curation process poses a significant challenge.
In response, we introduce AgentMD, a novel language agent capable of curating
and applying clinical calculators across various clinical contexts. Using the
published literature, AgentMD has automatically curated a collection of 2,164
diverse clinical calculators with executable functions and structured
documentation, collectively named RiskCalcs. Manual evaluations show that
RiskCalcs tools achieve an accuracy of over 80% on three quality metrics. At
inference time, AgentMD can automatically select and apply the relevant
RiskCalcs tools given any patient description. On the newly established RiskQA
benchmark, AgentMD significantly outperforms chain-of-thought prompting with
GPT-4 (87.7% vs. 40.9% in accuracy). Additionally, we also applied AgentMD to
real-world clinical notes for analyzing both population-level and risk-level
patient characteristics. In summary, our study illustrates the utility of
language agents augmented with clinical calculators for healthcare analytics
and patient care.
|
[
0.0315391086,
-0.6923075914,
0.7691813707,
-0.0414627157,
-0.1291076094,
0.378357172,
-0.1284432858,
-0.2670019567,
0.1494080126,
0.5715400577,
-0.2703920901,
-0.7878186107,
-0.7688974142,
-0.2263278067,
0.2030076087,
0.6704261899,
-0.0522910766,
0.5254004598,
-0.5320065618,
-0.1384188682,
-0.3099651039,
-0.3529018462,
-0.7657662034,
-0.4527546167,
0.6073781252,
0.475089252,
1.2632135153,
0.6306057572,
0.6321051717,
0.3013934493,
0.4886418879,
0.188789919,
-0.1614618152,
0.3811090291,
-0.0505564176,
-0.527984798,
-0.8849133253,
-0.0451181158,
0.3173820674,
0.8315440416,
-0.310157001,
-0.012566587,
-0.4037598968,
0.2044127285,
-0.6152185798,
0.5323581696,
-0.3302229941,
0.0264534652,
0.0775748789,
-0.6396023035,
-0.5136620402,
-0.5533478856,
0.2679879665,
-0.4760891795,
0.0417240709,
-0.3734149337,
0.1250042766,
0.3059217632,
-0.6402936578,
-0.4298141301,
-0.5890513062,
0.4669714272,
-0.3155451119,
0.1633942276,
0.7195534706,
0.852470696,
-0.2997380793,
-0.5877486467,
-0.1641591489,
-0.3032803237,
0.3488779664,
0.0107974187,
-0.131948933,
0.2951301038,
0.104379721,
-0.0121711725,
-0.5399714708,
0.2576878071,
-0.140959546,
-0.6804775,
0.7942034602,
0.3686398566,
0.5471471548,
0.2819447517,
-0.1539597958,
-0.5270976424,
-0.8774220943,
-0.2077378482,
-0.0514455549,
0.1903767586,
-0.0050404123,
0.3754185438,
0.3343943357,
0.2110957503,
-0.4328761399,
-0.4002553225,
0.4574774802,
0.1356676072,
-0.1440700889,
0.5320746899,
0.7816438079,
0.3246464431,
0.027366763,
-0.168095082,
0.1045655981,
0.0221202374,
0.5475895405,
-0.8999778032,
-0.2433710247,
0.4623765945,
-0.0174593404,
-0.5210977793,
-0.2522321045,
-0.5693303943,
-0.8420007825,
0.0036624286,
0.4446597993,
-0.4293887317,
-0.2862786651,
0.1083737835,
-0.020586485,
-0.1190590113,
0.6039924622,
-0.2396727502,
0.3448756337,
0.5774559975,
0.6455791593,
-0.1884986758,
-0.1279142499,
-0.9205062985,
0.0255965479,
-0.6137420535,
0.773229003,
-0.5187592506,
-0.8293358684,
0.2137198448,
0.0915051848,
0.0704982057,
-0.4517017007,
0.5375324488,
-0.179495126,
-0.2066477984,
-0.0205610264,
-0.3678173423,
-0.0039649382,
0.1496383697,
-0.8228731155,
0.7192248702,
0.5745335817,
-0.2372676134,
0.5550990105,
-0.3956817091,
-0.5750519633,
0.3686267138,
-0.2570626438,
-0.6170396805,
-0.1445633471,
0.0108767655,
0.5217352509,
-0.5497255325,
0.32053563,
-0.5272613168,
0.0953925475,
0.4445436895,
-0.5756039619,
0.454197824,
0.4863010347,
-0.1847840846,
0.2913808525,
-0.5847099423,
0.1815632731,
0.0305701941,
-0.0182962604,
-0.3196415901,
-0.116300948,
0.0682003722,
0.3490068316,
-0.0889482051,
-0.3629921377,
-0.0988410041,
-0.2794089317,
0.2512634993,
0.5602787733,
0.1278286576,
0.4331337512,
-0.4530614913,
1.2697994709,
-0.0002979898,
0.1648964584,
-0.1057398319,
-0.445829004,
0.0501825474,
-0.3918862045,
0.049450729,
0.5111299753,
-0.8903644681,
0.0945908427,
-0.3152211905,
-1.0053397417,
-0.5019158721,
-0.0535057932,
0.4357545972,
0.3247648478,
0.1685384214,
-0.3351074755,
-0.2586510479,
-0.2912915647,
-0.2050581425,
-0.2572459877,
0.004498532,
0.4824207723,
0.0804824606,
-0.6803995371,
0.6574326754,
-0.6949822903,
-0.3001677692,
-0.5136274695,
0.0329979919,
-0.1196034849,
0.3252504766,
0.4568921924,
-0.5168128014,
-0.3998302817,
0.2686082721,
-0.5763169527,
-0.1162822247,
-0.0146956677,
-0.1032925472,
0.0626825243,
0.4069054425,
-0.6402438879,
0.5805311203,
0.341216892,
-0.2970058322,
0.5674555898,
-0.7565535307,
-0.0303390976,
-1.1903289557,
-0.2360100746,
-0.011003376,
-0.454084754,
-0.6085166335,
0.0130927386,
0.2282152772,
-0.1535408944,
-0.5471135974,
0.7231591344,
-0.3767801225,
0.1798498183,
-0.2457728982,
0.0458670557,
-0.2135458589,
-0.124284178,
-0.041826278,
0.755785346,
0.6474972963,
-0.4667667449,
0.365843147,
0.1071070582,
-0.0900061652,
0.3338509798,
-0.4448308647,
-0.0289912708,
-0.0316425711,
0.3261396289,
-0.6373957992,
-0.2558943331,
-0.028304914,
-0.4630567729,
0.364967823,
-0.0011973047,
-0.3077265918,
-0.4833391011,
-0.3388161957,
0.317357868,
0.3796648681,
-0.0237248037,
0.7440847158,
0.9250645638,
-0.4237792194,
-0.4899943173,
-0.552377522,
0.2401399612,
0.0644408613,
-0.2945229709,
-0.128908664,
-0.0534499176,
-0.3115418851,
-0.279895246,
-0.0455633663,
-0.095398508,
0.0195392519,
0.6630060077,
0.406393975,
-0.0139256921,
0.6086637378,
0.2242425382,
-0.2363167405,
0.4930611253,
-0.2510013282,
0.45222646,
0.0042950236,
-0.6264643669,
-0.0305159632,
0.0826567113,
0.7774719596,
-0.2309460491,
0.5995382071,
0.6279534698,
-0.5484114885,
-0.3879369497,
-0.425135076,
-0.169086501,
-0.4333191812,
0.5691700578,
-0.2750204802,
-0.5853515267,
0.4824450016,
-0.2140452713,
-0.1234745458,
0.4439360201,
0.9969595671,
0.5013554096,
1.3958259821,
0.2300926298,
0.125352785,
0.0760240555,
-0.3380669653,
-0.0837587267,
-0.4327677488,
-0.3265396655,
-0.4045703411,
0.152355209,
-0.6853039861,
-1.0569624901,
0.7067046165,
-0.7632973194,
-0.1313711405,
0.2859184444,
-0.3207917809,
0.1801149249,
0.2534577847,
0.3555402458,
0.0612926185,
-0.2204305977,
-0.3887200356,
0.1721582413,
-0.6573588848,
-0.5406787395,
1.6489030123,
0.5564704537,
1.1021263599,
0.1267651916,
0.6679742932,
0.6481005549,
0.5335361362,
-0.9199022055,
0.4081613123,
0.200838387,
-0.5235241055,
-0.3787438273,
-0.5714527965,
-1.040460825,
0.1080001816,
-0.0675651133,
-0.3702432215,
0.0974273086,
0.0117983576,
-0.5170642138,
0.0079981834,
-0.8060289621,
0.8715175986,
-0.2737165093,
-0.4836878181,
-0.2792828977,
-0.615611136,
-0.153871417,
-0.1875435114,
0.4716050923,
-0.1911265403,
-0.216838643,
0.221042946,
-0.8847057819,
0.6984024644,
-0.0200575944,
-0.3463578522,
0.3335080147,
0.5279194117,
0.4823062718,
0.3793102205,
-0.1580822766,
-0.1848384142,
0.427203536,
-0.26461941,
-0.5014415979,
0.7648197412,
-0.70148772,
-0.4559636414,
-0.7667481899,
-0.7193830013,
-0.4576670527,
0.292517066,
-0.090360269,
0.947263062,
-0.5896614194,
-0.1133714616,
0.3394023776,
-0.316706121,
0.0786967054,
0.6316959858,
0.0214336701,
-0.4428390265,
1.0110172033,
-0.1502359509,
0.5361022949,
0.3822997212,
0.3502682745,
-0.5135930181,
-0.3109285533,
-0.2580953538,
0.0290096421,
-0.9140483737,
-0.3314564228,
-0.7967104316,
-0.155969888,
-0.5308459401,
-0.288163811,
-0.1928818226,
-0.4253741801,
-0.0547471568,
-0.3872430623,
0.3837421536,
0.4118031859,
-0.0713326409,
0.1751275659,
-0.7072882056,
0.1311164349,
0.1968922764,
0.2556384802,
-0.2458261997,
-0.0702096894,
-0.1940015107,
0.187326476,
-0.3039772809,
-0.7786064148,
0.9268931746,
0.3517542481,
0.505097568,
0.7514386773,
0.2529951036,
0.3790218234,
-0.529009521,
0.2211435884,
0.2933377922,
-0.4938087165,
0.5008815527,
-0.1438957304,
0.2564308643,
0.6558911204,
0.4935809672,
-0.4510706663,
-0.5661604404,
-0.7161185145,
-0.3902207315,
0.6447820067,
-0.0375002027,
-0.0858220905,
-0.167371273,
-0.1306311339,
0.3559879065,
0.1273429394,
0.1471581906,
-0.110645555,
-0.0123839974,
-0.5156679153,
-0.5910385847,
0.0379415192,
-0.3397976756,
-0.1890810281,
0.4772107303,
-0.4578163624,
0.1982239485,
0.300809145,
-0.430900991,
-0.3990264833,
0.2137173861,
0.4105036259,
0.8962350488,
-0.3842355013,
0.537746191,
0.1146906242,
-1.1764868498,
0.0768757835,
0.3978281617,
0.3605774939,
0.1013826355,
0.4137599468,
0.5801503062,
0.3026944101,
-1.3011409044,
0.5726986527,
-0.2423272133,
-0.1260273904,
-0.4942969978,
0.2413095683,
-0.122204408,
-0.1240816265,
0.1179156229,
0.1379835457,
0.3251724541,
-0.7159411907,
0.4527319968,
0.4156607091,
-0.9885373116,
-0.1173879504,
0.8810375929,
0.1631797999,
-0.4478665888,
0.1497874856,
-0.1269777715,
-0.4484567046,
0.984880805,
0.425001204,
0.9108535051,
-0.4119113982,
0.7257874012,
0.1496624798,
0.1493412256,
-0.0019721442,
0.1736979783,
0.1892713159,
-0.4751682878,
-0.2961593866,
-0.2719585299,
-0.9053755999,
-0.3267714381,
-0.4059385955,
0.2598317266,
-0.5080803037,
-0.4645061195,
0.2493187785,
0.2041620612,
-0.7025308609,
0.15153943,
0.0633025616,
0.9218075275,
-0.3773954213,
0.8690066338,
0.896710813,
-0.3554251492,
-0.8955618143,
-0.4422963262,
0.4062614739,
-1.0260618925,
0.105321072,
0.1825304329,
-0.0060370411,
-0.1177568212,
-0.0529716425,
-0.3607445061,
1.3178430796,
0.4103497267,
-0.070268549,
0.0855561867,
0.5775519013,
0.6946341991,
-0.5759198666,
0.8330551982,
0.5080038309,
0.1665252298,
0.4001918137,
-0.9719560146,
0.3407468498,
-0.2791272998,
-0.3460781276,
0.2237573117,
-0.1165694818,
0.5504773259,
-0.7512034774,
0.0559007861,
-0.2227300107,
-0.0312434025,
0.0298034102,
0.693616271,
0.2492112219,
0.3231117129,
0.7524872422,
-0.0126217306,
1.2330421209,
-0.2984884083,
0.1843589246,
0.9272432923,
-0.5059913993,
0.4444457293,
-0.0388934463,
-0.3650399745,
0.3714892864,
0.4246718884,
0.338026315,
0.1067646816,
0.0513024516,
-0.5393023491,
-0.504609406,
-0.1657314301,
-0.3206142783,
0.3046215475,
0.6049879193,
-0.4535342455,
-0.2109035552,
0.2061835676,
0.1398901343,
0.0232427567,
-0.3077472746,
0.6670312285,
0.299012363,
-0.645842433,
0.4130960405,
-0.3561467528,
-0.1576962322,
-0.7820466161,
-0.1987099946,
0.0728701875,
0.5977035761,
0.0833509788,
-0.769947052,
-0.14766258,
-0.4005863369,
0.2819545567,
-0.160736084,
0.8541277647,
-0.520362258,
-0.6185135245,
0.0960765332,
0.6166283488,
0.1330407709,
-0.3150869906,
-0.4237562418,
-0.1279929578,
-0.535879612,
0.2397639155,
0.4029660821,
0.6189107895,
-0.217265591,
1.2862989902,
0.680513382,
0.4029126167,
-0.3623005152,
0.3101762533,
0.7717933059,
-0.3717516363,
-0.468780458,
-0.7012531757,
0.0252328739,
0.052485276,
-0.1905778199,
0.5688529015,
0.4782476127,
0.2404372394,
-0.0756018609,
0.6718994379,
0.3152275085,
0.395201385,
-0.0062018624,
1.0239117146,
-0.4601385891,
0.2106906474,
-0.324616462,
-0.3921668231,
-0.3829156756,
0.0454352833,
-0.3593256176,
-0.1151216477,
0.7240362763,
0.7093190551,
0.4179742038,
-0.1893512458,
0.4944697618,
0.1783367991,
0.6014271379,
0.5672763586,
0.2734826803,
-0.2690034509,
0.4945549965,
-0.225730747,
-0.4396774769,
-0.5225542784,
-0.621548593,
-0.9492845535,
-0.3645339012,
-0.4155731201,
-0.3946623802,
0.0691300705,
1.3643835783,
0.5182931423,
-0.6411129832,
0.0082349377,
-0.0034433389,
0.3457500339,
-0.3165633976,
-0.1315822303,
0.5875371099,
-0.1410318613,
-0.4848673642,
0.1586527079,
0.4039947093,
-0.0170716923,
-0.3425634503,
-0.3540491164,
0.2543401122,
0.0963864923,
0.700553298,
0.2904830277,
-0.3171266019,
0.0931700766,
0.0008443812,
-0.4614900351,
-0.1681473851,
0.6335558295,
-0.8000804186,
1.0026469231,
0.1863663793,
0.6728855371,
0.1053255051,
-0.1925308555,
0.837844193,
-0.1921714842,
0.181510523,
0.6129797697,
0.1975934952,
0.0010879789,
-0.5455293059,
0.4640284181,
0.0129206702,
-0.4586485922,
-0.8298122883,
-0.1049346551,
-1.086184144,
-0.0727840737,
1.2218335867,
0.0283984076,
-0.371537894,
-0.2578133047,
-0.5330528617,
0.2254283577,
-0.5384969711,
0.5931185484,
0.264695704,
0.1746513098,
0.0217955299,
-0.8419687748,
0.6701692939,
0.0152160274,
-0.9012864828,
-0.0716557577,
0.4926157296,
0.175271675,
-0.0347557813,
0.7003112435,
-0.3004666865,
0.765486896,
0.0293206275,
0.2214967757,
-0.1993369013,
-0.072680749,
-0.030732777,
-0.0007842029,
0.1867195666,
0.0440362692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13222v1
|
RoCode: A Dataset for Measuring Code Intelligence from Problem Definitions in Romanian
| 2024-02-20T18:32:47 | 2024-02-20T18:32:47 |
Adrian Cosma, Bogdan Iordache, Paolo Rosso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly powerful and
have become capable of solving a plethora of tasks through proper instructions
in natural language. However, the vast majority of testing suites assume that
the instructions are written in English, the de facto prompting language. Code
intelligence and problem solving still remain a difficult task, even for the
most advanced LLMs. Currently, there are no datasets to measure the
generalization power for code-generation models in a language other than
English. In this work, we present RoCode, a competitive programming dataset,
consisting of 2,642 problems written in Romanian, 11k solutions in C, C++ and
Python and comprehensive testing suites for each problem. The purpose of RoCode
is to provide a benchmark for evaluating the code intelligence of language
models trained on Romanian / multilingual text as well as a fine-tuning set for
pretrained Romanian models. Through our results and review of related works, we
argue for the need to develop code models for languages other than English.
|
[
-0.1196752787,
-0.6040495038,
0.1378340423,
0.071490705,
-0.1268908828,
-0.0381345376,
-0.7432262897,
-0.2096454352,
-0.0144815631,
0.2877165377,
-0.5531253219,
-0.8003304005,
-0.4315346181,
0.3197719157,
-0.2613569498,
1.1364188194,
-0.2642877102,
0.4684237242,
-0.3460859954,
-0.3288439214,
-0.6759643555,
-0.4036763608,
0.0877154022,
-0.1515573263,
0.3031598628,
0.9201441407,
0.3962100148,
0.1422656924,
0.9559601545,
0.2472781092,
0.4245049655,
0.0568986721,
-0.5380242467,
0.0694834441,
-0.1447571963,
-0.6936442852,
-0.4086868167,
-0.0137862982,
0.464379102,
0.5151806474,
-0.0763114765,
0.4455441535,
-0.0099103656,
0.5421678424,
-0.3926247954,
0.2049050927,
-0.8403179646,
-0.0092238067,
0.0027031675,
-0.3917436302,
-0.4466394186,
-0.5979856849,
-0.3365651667,
-0.3798688054,
0.4459311068,
0.014562509,
0.858684957,
0.3837644458,
-0.0250604954,
-0.7184885144,
-0.782830894,
1.0250185728,
-0.3616322875,
0.2752908766,
0.0520238094,
0.2131940424,
-0.1911571771,
-0.3623067737,
-0.3574783802,
-0.4324447215,
0.127121985,
-0.0785353184,
-0.3418288827,
-0.2632605731,
0.2094629705,
0.1210305691,
-0.8707885742,
0.150392741,
-0.6301180124,
-0.04981599,
0.6966175437,
0.2110604793,
0.4978898168,
0.0335529521,
-0.1857911497,
-0.0670235679,
-1.0268900394,
0.1137196571,
0.4142425358,
0.2278111875,
-0.119088985,
0.6071648002,
-0.0409695804,
0.6205021739,
-0.4615052342,
0.1328381896,
0.1871526688,
-0.2899863124,
-0.1247385442,
0.0480088741,
0.6054394245,
0.1755199134,
0.5958191156,
-0.2415639162,
-0.2011985928,
0.4111851752,
0.27811414,
-0.8321287036,
-0.3682495952,
0.1752829701,
-0.3200660348,
-0.3738957644,
0.0672964901,
-0.647419095,
-0.0973361954,
-0.045393195,
-0.0192861278,
-0.3268607259,
-0.2085533738,
0.2405313849,
0.0987199172,
0.6473366618,
-0.2111245692,
-0.6169668436,
0.171829164,
0.8909450769,
0.4954207838,
-0.0443910472,
-0.2468733042,
-0.5934671164,
-0.5410820246,
-0.7702804804,
0.9095825553,
-0.7966327071,
-0.3840877712,
-0.0427295528,
0.0633712187,
0.0558981299,
-0.4580022693,
0.6935344338,
-0.4472247064,
-0.1202009767,
-0.0779833868,
-0.4389300942,
-0.0235613864,
0.1647607237,
-0.3433967233,
1.0883036852,
0.1384413242,
-0.6989153028,
0.3245762885,
-0.3620853424,
-0.3567899466,
0.4124193192,
-0.7139416933,
-0.4398225248,
0.226918906,
0.0496743731,
0.4522532821,
-0.6047151685,
0.5069875121,
-0.1007956862,
-0.3662077487,
0.1571124494,
-0.0791096613,
0.9620312452,
0.209657222,
-0.4928429723,
0.0493995883,
-0.5514022112,
0.300766319,
0.1438232511,
-0.2644185722,
-0.2093994617,
0.2500254512,
-0.1012394726,
-0.0634018406,
0.196875006,
-0.7043907642,
0.206508249,
-0.0540232584,
0.3002358079,
0.5760029554,
-0.2812835276,
0.174141109,
-0.3722706437,
0.9278316498,
-0.3382385075,
-0.045671083,
0.0928605124,
-0.7516853809,
-0.7536181808,
-0.0470692292,
0.4393278658,
0.7559953332,
-0.4688337445,
0.2556763887,
-0.6259574294,
-0.677090466,
-0.5689064264,
0.5435382128,
0.539732039,
0.3020569682,
0.1535883397,
-0.0262287389,
-0.475931704,
-0.9366670847,
-0.0680513009,
0.1070701852,
-0.0207783189,
0.5152710676,
0.6859248877,
-0.3207687736,
0.7099264264,
-0.3921488225,
-0.4497602582,
-0.8012021184,
0.0732296407,
0.2265015543,
0.4526010752,
0.5774531364,
-0.7049401402,
-0.361208111,
0.1559507698,
-0.8254271746,
-0.1105613559,
0.1040529832,
-0.0536794588,
0.0898400098,
0.6005324721,
0.0597732477,
0.1671916544,
0.9615874887,
-0.1305874437,
0.6794036031,
-0.5829475522,
0.1461663395,
-0.9431749582,
0.2267841995,
0.0971074551,
0.224853754,
-0.4741893709,
0.5582568049,
0.3113012612,
-0.44389382,
-0.2320829481,
0.319745928,
-0.6815662384,
-0.1111147925,
0.1430157274,
0.2858541608,
-0.1843583882,
0.435069114,
0.2609799802,
0.9083727002,
0.5615774393,
-0.5398553014,
0.7930370569,
0.2557114661,
-0.7891774178,
0.4428632259,
-0.923206985,
0.1282120794,
-0.0235583689,
0.0876538828,
-0.8048671484,
-0.0724962056,
-0.2852190733,
-0.7722318769,
0.0613611601,
-0.1981644332,
-0.259483099,
-0.3385096788,
-0.1465132535,
0.7474979758,
0.6241398454,
-0.2773975134,
0.1985641271,
0.3079555929,
-0.3553067744,
-0.6540651321,
-0.7536165118,
0.1270056218,
-0.1552137733,
-0.8192747831,
0.0748419091,
-0.2830089927,
-0.5263281465,
-0.075747937,
0.3512391448,
-0.3954092264,
0.0379287265,
0.0993785933,
0.416872263,
-0.5200862288,
0.2853987515,
-0.2337531149,
-0.2953694463,
0.1624977142,
-0.0516521335,
0.4736989141,
-0.2799256444,
-0.1233377978,
-0.1336451769,
0.3101620078,
0.2353446335,
-0.8318547606,
0.4069368541,
0.2815437913,
-0.1991809309,
-0.7821930051,
-0.2197345048,
0.2012257129,
-0.4099850655,
0.5345130563,
-0.515211761,
-0.5318620205,
0.4355757236,
0.1495037973,
0.1960809976,
0.1292959005,
0.711592257,
0.0669532865,
0.8303715587,
0.8619221449,
-0.2149748355,
0.2196554691,
-0.5076706409,
0.4245130718,
-0.5303342938,
-0.1180997789,
-1.0669558048,
-0.2819816768,
-0.7950760126,
-0.6255255938,
0.262571007,
-0.2045778036,
0.1357211471,
0.6195345521,
-0.6208881736,
0.6316123009,
0.4045498669,
0.0811352655,
0.3042969108,
-0.0321296975,
-0.1701410264,
-0.183063671,
-0.9030575156,
-0.5421535373,
1.385627389,
0.0289892834,
0.9947261214,
-0.0559867211,
0.7648433447,
0.3257300556,
0.2023587674,
-0.6895883679,
0.3628986478,
-0.1716518253,
-0.6036841869,
-0.0766411573,
-0.6046254635,
-1.0325375795,
-0.2836169004,
-0.0771451443,
-0.2457126975,
0.1254625618,
-0.0300543532,
-0.3843120635,
0.2513869405,
-0.4782666862,
1.0398126841,
-0.4351188838,
-0.2022896111,
-0.5494724512,
-0.0086800326,
0.3457153141,
0.0697257295,
0.5358158946,
-0.1747603714,
0.1052002236,
0.7384421229,
-0.2747726738,
0.3692993224,
0.1242794245,
-0.2364424318,
0.3993535042,
0.3132118285,
0.3661112189,
0.13113451,
-0.212823689,
0.1874495298,
-0.13091515,
-0.5262266397,
-0.3115212023,
0.843175292,
-0.6009081602,
-0.3110872507,
-0.3037807941,
-0.6078559756,
-0.0138270427,
0.0522454791,
0.5942256451,
1.1030752659,
-0.4726577699,
0.4040581286,
0.9061187506,
-0.6183959842,
0.1881890595,
0.5128539205,
0.1379161626,
0.0164485052,
1.1452767849,
-0.1416260898,
0.0900748819,
0.2459323704,
-0.0470443591,
0.0700351298,
-0.632329464,
-0.4489640296,
0.0441779085,
-0.5027422905,
-0.3142155409,
-0.253696084,
-0.080252938,
-0.2049818486,
-0.4621006846,
-0.2344172895,
-0.0339591727,
0.0980333611,
-0.0085313069,
0.2174876779,
1.090105772,
-0.1618109494,
-0.3955287635,
-0.6150105,
0.5059292316,
0.1925848722,
0.4708850682,
-0.3163323402,
-0.3872099519,
-0.396291554,
0.2153193653,
-0.0469396487,
-0.7777448893,
0.3546668887,
0.2651045322,
0.7093396783,
0.1026355028,
0.255184561,
0.2613292933,
-0.4217677414,
0.5571061373,
-0.1529337168,
-0.6853297949,
0.7459087968,
-0.1969880015,
-0.0289794356,
0.5695453882,
0.4329133332,
-0.5479894876,
-0.4831409156,
-0.5068528056,
-0.3702723384,
0.5067819357,
0.1195641384,
0.2960321307,
-0.1243268177,
-0.0053432221,
-0.0175717119,
-0.096826598,
-0.6398038864,
-0.0682845265,
0.2591659427,
-0.2760081589,
-0.1784055382,
-0.2118634284,
0.0526247732,
-0.1668215543,
0.5877344608,
0.0521160774,
0.2580187023,
0.0225998331,
-0.6020410657,
-0.1089748964,
0.4189651608,
0.7026461363,
0.9172496796,
-0.1015391275,
-0.1471278369,
0.0237009097,
-0.494928956,
0.0985389352,
-0.2070744336,
-0.1252564192,
0.1103951409,
0.5097358823,
0.2444832623,
0.3412576318,
-0.9914808273,
0.6389102936,
-0.3539788425,
-0.2453810126,
-0.2200167179,
0.3705292344,
-0.15306364,
-0.1067830548,
0.2729088962,
-0.1664237678,
-0.1099099889,
-0.5427197218,
0.3452840447,
0.5356547236,
-0.5417442918,
-0.1784213185,
0.5044828057,
0.6268206835,
-0.5280496478,
0.8961250782,
-0.3746882081,
-0.6782714128,
1.1264400482,
0.1590082794,
0.7692825794,
-0.0989057124,
0.3606204093,
0.6537491679,
0.5379580855,
0.2733258307,
0.4340295494,
-0.0425438955,
-0.8468623757,
-0.2684477866,
-0.5756467581,
-0.2800902128,
-0.0478269011,
-0.825853765,
0.509954989,
-0.3785995543,
0.2770735025,
-0.2251205444,
0.3354432285,
-0.7786830664,
0.0404247083,
0.0578754656,
1.1316248178,
-0.8048125505,
0.8962026834,
0.7171825171,
-0.2983568311,
-0.5732996464,
-0.435443908,
-0.2952245474,
-0.946287334,
0.7891557813,
0.0705697685,
-0.1553559899,
0.0148754483,
-0.7317764163,
-0.4986930788,
0.8051480651,
0.1700760573,
-0.530929625,
0.0923263133,
0.1721256375,
0.4362187684,
-0.6078193784,
0.2289227545,
0.6871902943,
0.2586001158,
-0.3858919442,
-0.7448909283,
-0.3394904733,
-0.5252285004,
-0.0865761638,
0.2421572208,
-0.4998256266,
0.7795959115,
-0.6801335216,
-0.2800482512,
0.1449346095,
0.4057514369,
0.0983901247,
-0.1979343295,
-0.0104081025,
0.4242395461,
0.5914483666,
-0.130934611,
0.9065033197,
-0.7934293747,
0.4030115008,
1.0786355734,
-0.2211488336,
0.8963323832,
-0.0929126292,
-0.0307884198,
0.8056730032,
0.3958536088,
-0.1443524361,
0.1751667112,
0.3503742218,
-0.0083392495,
-0.4162272513,
0.0157470386,
-0.5392276645,
0.5911635756,
0.3658950329,
-0.1212586239,
-0.4470550716,
-0.0488898382,
0.0724375173,
0.4256763756,
-0.2016542852,
0.5393303037,
-0.1086729243,
-0.7203635573,
0.755141139,
0.1048662961,
0.6147364974,
-0.6176741719,
-0.195064202,
-0.5896062255,
0.4299837351,
-0.1419327259,
-0.727507472,
0.0999111533,
0.602673173,
-0.0030039253,
-0.2111359984,
0.1086738929,
-0.410681814,
-1.0373920202,
0.3332631886,
0.3175201416,
0.3299134076,
0.2411866486,
-0.7267512083,
0.1876286715,
0.1115808785,
0.1838625669,
0.0461897701,
0.5415685177,
0.1158172563,
0.7207009792,
0.2843323052,
0.3694160879,
0.2282888442,
-0.1516481191,
0.6824752092,
-0.5231575966,
-0.3309164643,
-0.4656382203,
0.2841937542,
0.3322443068,
-0.6346826553,
0.7031224966,
0.7189484239,
0.964794457,
0.1431821734,
0.8760562539,
-0.3083290756,
0.321672678,
-0.3555417657,
0.511985302,
-0.4121537805,
0.1276138127,
-0.2494169176,
-0.9461659193,
-0.165730074,
0.683672905,
-0.3981615901,
-0.060879387,
0.6993694305,
1.1039533615,
-0.0087695261,
-0.2654256225,
0.3637987077,
0.2573096156,
0.2050178051,
0.9784208536,
0.5817497969,
-0.4768213034,
0.9194193482,
-0.1967923343,
-0.5625391603,
-0.2062706947,
-0.791506052,
-0.9073662162,
-0.5205495954,
-0.1427533776,
-0.1627233922,
0.037978027,
0.79117769,
0.4104447961,
-1.1618685722,
-0.6363629103,
-0.1639574021,
0.28422001,
-0.1444295794,
-0.1315044761,
0.1518749595,
-0.8013451099,
-0.5283901691,
0.2560622394,
0.016716443,
-0.4037564099,
-0.4713003039,
-0.3581211865,
0.0840731934,
0.0408270881,
0.1903234273,
0.2662650347,
-0.3051836193,
-0.0456530303,
0.3052722514,
-0.171487838,
0.2366598397,
1.1522806883,
-0.6624797583,
0.5475248694,
0.4874520302,
0.3911601901,
-0.1212658286,
-0.0423647352,
0.813190043,
-0.4687961638,
0.3005116582,
0.2785924077,
0.508961916,
0.2218535841,
-0.1785425842,
0.4689189196,
-0.0231914688,
-0.6731407046,
-0.748339653,
0.2590424716,
-0.4095907509,
-0.2939784825,
1.2302367687,
-0.1868359745,
-0.3279700875,
-0.1473272294,
0.0577799529,
-0.1276093721,
-0.1630774885,
0.7140389681,
0.6257039905,
-0.0252991766,
0.0311453063,
-0.7231123447,
0.6955247521,
0.2587048709,
-0.7087709904,
0.3333284557,
0.5210287571,
0.2633946538,
0.0045814887,
0.5563846231,
-0.0458588079,
0.6933060884,
0.1956980079,
0.4688619375,
0.0469830483,
-0.7516575456,
-0.3950745761,
-0.1818890274,
0.1317996234,
-0.0095675839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13220v1
|
How Easy is It to Fool Your Multimodal LLMs? An Empirical Analysis on Deceptive Prompts
| 2024-02-20T18:31:27 | 2024-02-20T18:31:27 |
Yusu Qian, Haotian Zhang, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The remarkable advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have
not rendered them immune to challenges, particularly in the context of handling
deceptive information in prompts, thus producing hallucinated responses under
such conditions. To quantitatively assess this vulnerability, we present
MAD-Bench, a carefully curated benchmark that contains 850 test samples divided
into 6 categories, such as non-existent objects, count of objects, spatial
relationship, and visual confusion. We provide a comprehensive analysis of
popular MLLMs, ranging from GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, to open-sourced models, such as
LLaVA-1.5 and CogVLM. Empirically, we observe significant performance gaps
between GPT-4V and other models; and previous robust instruction-tuned models,
such as LRV-Instruction and LLaVA-RLHF, are not effective on this new
benchmark. While GPT-4V achieves 75.02% accuracy on MAD-Bench, the accuracy of
any other model in our experiments ranges from 5% to 35%. We further propose a
remedy that adds an additional paragraph to the deceptive prompts to encourage
models to think twice before answering the question. Surprisingly, this simple
method can even double the accuracy; however, the absolute numbers are still
too low to be satisfactory. We hope MAD-Bench can serve as a valuable benchmark
to stimulate further research to enhance models' resilience against deceptive
prompts.
|
[
-0.2831524909,
-0.8621734381,
0.8754047751,
0.2364427,
0.0426821224,
0.0154431658,
0.055247236,
-0.280583322,
-0.365680486,
0.3758279383,
-0.8581674099,
-0.4113576114,
-0.6076942682,
0.2786775827,
-0.466293335,
0.6466531157,
0.1097529158,
0.2439621985,
-0.3711086214,
-0.2337120324,
-0.7649378777,
-0.7078710794,
-0.2832555473,
-0.0242021251,
0.5914988518,
0.0616675876,
0.4541586637,
0.1898960918,
0.5133113265,
0.271333009,
0.230661124,
0.4076415598,
-0.5201206207,
0.3813505173,
-0.0538340434,
-0.6999662519,
-0.1039016023,
0.1372097284,
0.2842573524,
0.4045246243,
-0.1737318784,
0.1060085744,
-0.0300975367,
0.6751176119,
-0.7281513214,
0.0814280733,
-0.910693109,
-0.0770099983,
-0.1006726697,
-0.1167826131,
-0.8127754331,
-0.2495342791,
-0.2085036486,
-0.3854494989,
0.240012601,
0.2957341075,
0.7851358652,
0.4963401258,
-0.4214768708,
-0.1890153885,
-0.5516434908,
0.780728817,
-0.5840067267,
0.3790112734,
0.4494836628,
0.6513827443,
-0.3065548837,
-0.5897619128,
-0.4330716729,
-0.8005805612,
0.1777403206,
0.0418715328,
-0.443159312,
-0.131175518,
0.5354081392,
0.0025462136,
-0.6077040434,
-0.0322869383,
-0.0656034574,
-0.4392710626,
0.3944436312,
0.5247733593,
0.2277155221,
-0.0703704432,
-0.5157871842,
-0.3389338255,
-0.7162345648,
-0.0464409776,
0.4717117548,
0.3401505053,
-0.0778605491,
0.7845668793,
0.0733391792,
0.7616662383,
0.1227944344,
-0.4085035324,
0.1764855385,
-0.4085203707,
-0.1122325957,
-0.0256300066,
0.6996461153,
0.3940860331,
0.4954451025,
-0.0748790354,
-0.4967109263,
0.3859787285,
0.3875493407,
-0.7042730451,
-0.2453668565,
0.3007708788,
-0.2828234434,
-0.1717549711,
-0.2085181177,
-0.6835228801,
-1.0447574854,
-0.2200012207,
0.6923305988,
-0.7456825972,
-0.145068258,
0.046880845,
-0.125336051,
0.1591234207,
0.5102706552,
-0.5242710114,
0.1428056955,
0.5259858966,
0.8857986331,
-0.3247452378,
-0.4190956652,
-0.4851695299,
-0.0597378314,
-0.2539210916,
0.9272189736,
-0.5890025496,
-0.4406822026,
-0.2071900666,
0.0207819976,
-0.3069958687,
-0.5186380148,
0.5142533183,
-0.2771605849,
0.08316347,
-0.520291388,
-0.203494668,
-0.1964615136,
0.707169354,
-0.6365338564,
0.8770198822,
0.0300300606,
-0.8175043464,
0.116940178,
-0.2246360332,
0.0155100562,
-0.4553367794,
-0.390509665,
-0.2018771023,
0.2277377099,
0.3826996386,
0.2728006542,
-0.1834155172,
0.325648874,
-0.5172328949,
-0.386768043,
0.7544461489,
-1.2402341366,
0.6961169243,
0.1593545377,
-0.2898361087,
0.1376557648,
-0.7983700037,
-0.2202774733,
0.2608340681,
-0.0405777469,
-0.2903707922,
-0.3157437444,
-0.2451256067,
0.2802096903,
0.1863178909,
-0.346516788,
0.2424174994,
-0.1348851174,
-0.0418755449,
0.9846808314,
-0.0282797962,
-0.105595313,
-0.5656492114,
0.5710422993,
0.2923982441,
0.215121761,
-0.321731478,
-0.5997579098,
-0.4700120389,
-0.5460038185,
0.234909296,
0.6002548933,
-0.7495468259,
-0.2363933325,
-0.0789233744,
-0.575480938,
-0.7236514688,
0.0366821364,
0.4231382012,
0.4378333986,
0.224937439,
-0.0922130644,
-0.3674818277,
-1.1114811897,
-0.5435528159,
-0.120277755,
-0.0653653145,
0.3327505589,
0.5646723509,
-0.169350192,
0.5949280262,
-0.2347163856,
-0.0237487666,
-0.0027794004,
0.2844201326,
0.207471326,
0.145069778,
0.5363022685,
-0.6040763855,
-0.3168238401,
-0.3268752694,
-0.6590792537,
-0.2227749079,
-0.2665077746,
0.0963052511,
0.3733671904,
0.2289020568,
-0.9566956758,
0.2947089076,
0.5865136981,
-0.4575973749,
1.0135717392,
-0.2225137651,
0.3321310878,
-0.7061632276,
0.0032273985,
-0.0719043761,
-0.1319836974,
-0.5171508789,
0.0319745913,
0.2582168281,
0.0919319391,
-0.4736212194,
0.3930771649,
-0.5406263471,
0.0224410538,
-0.1816480458,
0.1337799132,
0.0459707528,
0.5631381869,
-0.5589646697,
0.9899047017,
0.5810582638,
-0.6405139565,
0.4458824098,
-0.075482212,
-0.5390623808,
0.7958851457,
-0.5458026528,
0.1352087557,
-0.3797488213,
0.1512670368,
-1.227248311,
-0.3216810524,
0.4930459261,
-0.3462201357,
0.4174480736,
0.0915031359,
-0.5957418084,
-0.3465834856,
-0.435305357,
0.2478019446,
0.346709162,
-0.5087195039,
0.6879982948,
-0.0087739928,
0.0505005345,
-0.7217768431,
-0.7206020951,
0.1566980928,
-0.2982123792,
-0.5069770813,
-0.0449467041,
-0.4354728758,
-0.520685792,
-0.3308247328,
-0.2779778242,
0.2172946185,
0.0913146883,
0.4366742373,
0.2581904531,
-0.2103144228,
0.0458004065,
-0.2983459234,
0.0850461572,
0.374915421,
0.2246742249,
0.6408069134,
-0.2318444103,
-0.9937493205,
-0.4472615123,
0.2005941421,
1.0423176289,
0.011548968,
0.6038690209,
0.6045936346,
-0.1844927073,
-0.0004841323,
-0.7455416918,
-0.2396199256,
-0.4669682384,
0.2542268038,
-0.6861097813,
-0.4278575778,
0.5297212005,
0.0416132808,
0.0409247689,
0.1321822554,
0.7458340526,
0.2129928917,
1.4903329611,
0.2801196873,
0.229137212,
0.2081571519,
0.1841092557,
0.0088661239,
-0.5653626323,
-0.5579300523,
-0.421677053,
-0.3152104914,
-0.4403679371,
-0.5432775021,
0.4383312762,
-0.2240210474,
-0.3008068502,
-0.0159026869,
-0.3888704479,
0.2549014986,
0.6178280711,
0.1393013746,
0.3314386904,
-0.0331587493,
-0.2545978725,
-0.2450187802,
-0.5033753514,
-0.3374570906,
1.1446293592,
0.3696519434,
1.0793172121,
0.3991572857,
0.2622141838,
0.2259302884,
0.3022622466,
-0.6610161662,
0.5270274282,
0.3236680329,
-0.7955097556,
0.0194072034,
-0.2885432243,
-0.7530612946,
0.5380729437,
-0.1154844612,
-0.7059125304,
0.1525224596,
0.0102171302,
-0.4344140589,
0.1609306037,
-0.976677537,
0.7110622525,
-0.5317658782,
-0.5203194618,
0.0717416629,
-0.5115908384,
0.8404500484,
-0.3193126917,
0.2519264817,
-0.3687348962,
-0.1506418139,
0.439054817,
-0.0672560483,
1.1472352743,
-0.1910395175,
-0.3165459633,
0.1349154264,
0.368955642,
0.8780688643,
-0.0325705558,
0.0336442031,
-0.0055814157,
0.0568085611,
-0.3509658575,
-0.753140986,
0.7984139919,
-0.676112473,
-0.9684352875,
-0.4995495379,
-0.8733249307,
-0.6466688514,
0.0326297507,
0.0736680329,
0.5259668231,
0.0082563758,
0.0214946494,
0.854793787,
-0.2274251878,
0.3520622551,
0.6239084601,
-0.2162231207,
-0.3113768697,
0.8125923276,
-0.0119592054,
0.2941197157,
0.1384948045,
0.2263628244,
-0.5383866429,
-0.5329635739,
-0.4847383499,
0.2376090437,
-0.7578180432,
-0.1914644241,
-0.7609776258,
0.0801603869,
-0.4203783274,
0.3168080449,
-0.336564064,
-0.2272744179,
-0.2012722492,
-0.0295767635,
0.3275071681,
0.6669076681,
0.0608600266,
-0.0281051733,
-0.7484630346,
0.3826763928,
0.3532165885,
0.1081569791,
-0.0156072034,
-0.7612442374,
0.2430658638,
0.2667763829,
-0.3365873396,
-1.1350240707,
0.4024993479,
-0.1902915835,
0.8112356663,
0.5121674538,
0.2875585854,
0.8336009383,
-0.5265467763,
0.8438788056,
0.2774128914,
-0.5437235236,
0.2917926908,
-0.298343271,
0.3390955925,
0.5633456111,
0.4384464324,
-0.2420198917,
-0.5141068697,
-0.4495761096,
-0.4857600927,
0.4636829495,
0.012986742,
0.2210577279,
0.1010916755,
-0.0465816371,
0.4861379564,
0.3078951538,
-0.8609008789,
-0.4576619267,
-0.3351977766,
-0.2456732392,
0.0175335445,
-0.3023199439,
-0.3552769721,
-0.159188211,
0.3155073822,
-0.0587984435,
0.2248115242,
0.0999826416,
-0.1503745168,
0.1573023051,
0.3152504563,
1.0051859617,
0.7185720205,
-0.3515260816,
0.5732073188,
0.2737793624,
-0.4796293378,
0.2347435951,
0.0047734696,
0.0727469176,
0.101226002,
0.3844078779,
0.934461534,
0.1625399888,
-0.9543861151,
0.611410439,
-0.1636270285,
-0.1847470999,
-0.1149474978,
0.0098669166,
-0.086212121,
0.3573457599,
0.1946211904,
0.3516656458,
0.0059931269,
-0.6054323316,
0.0412969515,
0.6286851168,
-0.3186392784,
-0.2799841464,
0.6376181245,
-0.1237515211,
-0.2038193196,
0.4626367986,
-0.2208090723,
-0.3836421967,
0.4012933373,
0.8100623488,
0.672247231,
-0.233014822,
0.2428828031,
0.2434442937,
0.6212463379,
-0.2566469312,
0.1612739861,
0.1440878212,
-0.5553715825,
-0.1999714226,
-0.4806508124,
-0.4207573533,
0.3749113083,
-0.4522773325,
0.0507043488,
-0.2958196402,
-0.1957350671,
-0.246878475,
-0.2203297317,
-0.5699733496,
-0.1392995715,
0.3166439235,
1.0713375807,
-0.7655072212,
0.6908813715,
0.3955183029,
-0.3366672099,
-0.5077899098,
-0.0521998145,
0.3478245139,
-1.0806956291,
0.454903245,
0.382863909,
-0.2130336612,
-0.1690721363,
-0.73153162,
-0.7112292647,
0.9347807765,
0.5308870673,
-0.6969220042,
-0.0837500766,
0.1729151458,
0.3044210672,
-0.2148110121,
0.4059483409,
0.6291354299,
0.8472182155,
0.2202408165,
-0.6413034201,
0.3138266206,
-0.15523009,
-0.1572768241,
-0.0911607072,
-0.4053184092,
1.0665080547,
-0.4888555706,
-0.331389606,
0.1260532737,
0.3439225852,
0.7525524497,
0.5134788752,
0.5488874912,
0.3418275714,
0.9941285253,
-0.0829318315,
1.1753180027,
-0.2294341177,
0.0130201718,
0.9294640422,
-0.2714404762,
0.6542764902,
0.7180033326,
-0.1459778696,
0.4642255306,
0.6488563418,
-0.2938636839,
0.6805127859,
0.3003776968,
-0.2084791511,
-0.5590322614,
-0.0471371301,
-0.4716853499,
0.257222712,
0.4990777373,
-0.1500320584,
-0.3196887672,
0.1436931789,
-0.016575424,
-0.0645883232,
-0.214405179,
0.4086969197,
0.2089800388,
-0.6990881562,
0.8398504257,
-0.1953603774,
0.7463821769,
-0.6424788237,
0.0659290478,
-0.320092231,
0.1775387377,
0.0723262951,
-0.4983709157,
-0.0382373035,
0.0094285198,
-0.0773847848,
-0.048731748,
0.6338985562,
-0.2403437346,
-0.5000162125,
-0.0537789166,
0.8141659498,
0.2433256358,
-0.4123119414,
-0.9157924652,
0.3633379042,
-0.0312478375,
-0.3647539318,
0.4442114234,
0.607483089,
-0.0688398704,
1.0217893124,
0.6720159054,
-0.2166819721,
0.2277995348,
0.2059227377,
0.7302739024,
-0.7862084508,
-0.052373752,
-1.0841391087,
0.4264689684,
-0.0185579639,
-0.2668393254,
1.1566879749,
0.2327603102,
0.4139283597,
-0.1805016845,
0.5777264237,
0.3140836656,
0.2482767105,
-0.5507384539,
0.6696294546,
-0.6609885097,
0.4866154194,
-0.079085581,
-0.6844703555,
-0.1853989214,
0.1907331795,
-0.3314779699,
0.149513796,
0.8497312665,
1.264092207,
-0.0013879999,
-0.0995742232,
0.6848468184,
0.5206845403,
0.1774544716,
0.6055819988,
1.2766009569,
-0.1758077592,
0.7444627285,
-0.184761703,
-0.1107432395,
-0.3627663851,
-0.6701366901,
-1.1143285036,
-0.3736616969,
-0.1452187151,
-0.5880738497,
0.0693193302,
0.6488493085,
0.2917739451,
-0.7835381031,
0.1751089543,
0.0994635001,
0.1155045629,
-0.3443748653,
-0.1887866557,
0.236012131,
-0.2502478659,
-0.646645844,
0.6253502965,
0.1215368137,
0.2916936576,
-0.5618892312,
0.0450733565,
-0.0952219963,
0.3842721283,
0.6200290322,
-0.0583072379,
-1.0646814108,
-0.293753773,
0.270671308,
-0.4431816936,
-0.0552250966,
0.6553043127,
-0.9227240682,
0.3943078816,
0.3002026081,
0.5189358592,
0.0999888554,
0.0694525987,
0.4044229686,
-0.663339138,
-0.0188671201,
0.0940012112,
0.3175458014,
0.5028360486,
-0.2060695738,
0.2025089413,
0.4304305911,
-0.2596275508,
-1.2237278223,
0.3707079887,
-1.0947655439,
-0.5897608399,
1.4279429913,
0.0965517834,
-0.4507493079,
-0.2597868443,
-0.5382239223,
-0.0506008342,
-0.2593173981,
1.0185265541,
0.8922787309,
-0.2272931933,
-0.2241488248,
-0.8497718573,
0.3559499085,
0.3661178052,
-0.5877930522,
0.3185180128,
0.6715812683,
0.2182522863,
0.2514785826,
0.2642726302,
-0.1393920332,
0.2868008316,
0.5218032002,
-0.1762814969,
-0.485819757,
-0.3437370062,
-0.4195376039,
0.3733217418,
0.0786808431,
-0.2628583014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13213v1
|
Softmax Probabilities (Mostly) Predict Large Language Model Correctness on Multiple-Choice Q&A
| 2024-02-20T18:24:47 | 2024-02-20T18:24:47 |
Benjamin Plaut, Khanh Nguyen, Tu Trinh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although large language models (LLMs) perform impressively on many tasks,
overconfidence remains a problem. We hypothesized that on multiple-choice Q&A
tasks, wrong answers would be associated with smaller maximum softmax
probabilities (MSPs) compared to correct answers. We comprehensively evaluate
this hypothesis on ten open-source LLMs and five datasets, and find strong
evidence for our hypothesis among models which perform well on the original Q&A
task. For the six LLMs with the best Q&A performance, the AUROC derived from
the MSP was better than random chance with p < 10^{-4} in 59/60 instances.
Among those six LLMs, the average AUROC ranged from 60% to 69%. Leveraging
these findings, we propose a multiple-choice Q&A task with an option to abstain
and show that performance can be improved by selectively abstaining based on
the MSP of the initial model response. We also run the same experiments with
pre-softmax logits instead of softmax probabilities and find similar (but not
identical) results.
|
[
-0.2338706404,
-0.9090895057,
0.7583577037,
-0.0440093838,
0.0679956749,
-0.0296873488,
-0.3779086173,
-0.4837869108,
-0.0857864991,
0.4867952168,
-0.4352823198,
-0.1449543536,
-0.6564184427,
0.1204645932,
-0.2816095352,
0.8693091273,
0.0338910408,
0.0438455194,
-0.293794632,
-0.3744237721,
-0.6115611196,
-0.4446353912,
-0.6282067895,
-0.1512780935,
0.5621380806,
0.5194650292,
1.0570915937,
0.4152561724,
0.2712339163,
0.2745499015,
-0.0463433079,
0.1950484365,
-0.3889400065,
0.2529036105,
-0.1479035765,
-0.6314334273,
-0.5399647355,
0.1745235026,
0.4106816649,
0.4503714442,
-0.3482802808,
0.0559454784,
0.2183049321,
0.4498298764,
-0.8364898562,
-0.2657543421,
-0.7881954312,
-0.0206723567,
-0.1088317707,
0.0447798967,
-0.5960136056,
-0.2523824573,
0.0084806653,
-0.423266083,
0.0870750099,
-0.0300927572,
0.5072462559,
0.2459578067,
-0.5884259939,
-0.1447364241,
-0.920280695,
0.9465197921,
-0.893851161,
0.4903824031,
0.556047976,
0.0271168686,
0.0443866514,
-0.1375224143,
-0.6110898852,
-0.415501982,
0.2076250315,
0.1294866055,
-0.1890627295,
0.0705031753,
0.3589234948,
0.2009774446,
-0.7606627345,
0.3008844256,
-0.2148185521,
-0.2138788402,
0.6352596879,
0.1509151608,
-0.0475702658,
0.1406769753,
-0.1855782717,
0.2694463432,
-0.8274273872,
0.0059612677,
0.2974780202,
0.3390357494,
0.3750329614,
1.0284179449,
-0.0420940593,
0.5220953822,
0.0309164263,
-0.1566217542,
0.4432493448,
-0.3813683689,
-0.2347338647,
-0.1895868927,
0.6212607026,
0.0467151403,
0.7479820848,
-0.0698991045,
-0.4066933393,
0.0013346168,
0.2003330588,
-0.5785702467,
0.2207042128,
0.6748338938,
-0.2469584197,
0.1052309647,
-0.1846836209,
-0.1972226053,
-0.3849164546,
-0.139629811,
0.5833329558,
-0.2751506567,
-0.472327143,
0.1510917395,
-0.0212768521,
-0.150296554,
0.2538255751,
-0.4229406416,
0.2435078472,
0.6191895604,
0.6498286724,
-0.189787969,
-0.4106799364,
-0.7622032762,
-0.025843462,
-0.4889675677,
0.7464123964,
-0.4836438894,
-0.3265444636,
0.0629704818,
-0.0545664355,
-0.2941886187,
-0.6774705052,
0.6482344866,
-0.4330505431,
0.1577347964,
-0.3512265384,
-0.67985183,
0.0332961492,
0.3384613395,
-0.6463951468,
0.7456380725,
-0.0697336271,
-0.6740157008,
0.4953562915,
-0.224897325,
-0.3979109526,
-0.0923044086,
-0.0164839663,
-0.3029161692,
0.1240893453,
0.0618777052,
0.3424437344,
0.074557364,
0.153401807,
-0.6266820431,
-0.2770808637,
0.8384785056,
-0.6813854575,
0.7622383833,
0.2853161395,
-0.3764643669,
0.0164166633,
-0.3699140251,
0.2240377814,
-0.0374291651,
-0.4745050073,
-0.2648584247,
0.0516937822,
-0.2477448732,
0.7333695292,
-0.1169576347,
-0.7461027503,
0.1765135229,
-0.5148192048,
0.3296439648,
0.8595499992,
-0.1835890412,
0.3112778366,
-0.5304434896,
0.7498671412,
0.0300052576,
0.3748125434,
0.4005976617,
-0.6966638565,
-0.5976664424,
-0.179433912,
0.3557624817,
0.9454553723,
-0.6364427805,
0.0337671004,
0.0704765096,
-0.3096807599,
-0.5113025904,
0.590498209,
0.5269457698,
0.2618432641,
0.2913570702,
-0.3941693902,
-0.3083164692,
-0.9973090291,
-0.3707738519,
-0.2356397808,
-0.0718827024,
0.5132318139,
0.5257635713,
-0.0998125672,
0.9198327661,
-0.5174121857,
-0.2887531221,
-0.4138457179,
-0.0107235545,
0.3782798648,
0.3817635179,
0.4089692235,
-0.8284626603,
-0.3574507535,
-0.5580378771,
-0.1759072691,
0.0693779588,
0.0945689529,
-0.0433093235,
0.6501107216,
0.2535899282,
-0.9503286481,
0.1599068642,
0.4944380522,
-0.3762795031,
0.8895290494,
-0.17357409,
0.1175692156,
-0.9267593622,
0.1327172518,
0.1823457628,
-0.248435095,
-0.4704751074,
-0.0416824594,
0.0367186926,
0.3264951408,
-0.5006394982,
0.4654642045,
-0.2874496579,
0.0421837941,
-0.2103413194,
0.0835778117,
-0.1161299497,
0.3312333524,
0.0533215627,
0.7895259857,
0.3785848618,
-0.4904251099,
0.1279418319,
0.2095339894,
-0.2359794676,
0.1784406155,
-0.7252164483,
0.0786195919,
-0.1869677454,
0.2140342146,
-1.2506110668,
-0.0636415333,
-0.1701717973,
-0.6161445379,
0.2415283769,
-0.1665465832,
-0.4449306726,
-0.5003488064,
-0.245576784,
0.2974382341,
0.4305973649,
-0.0686917081,
0.3709824979,
0.3526004255,
-0.5016627312,
-1.122656703,
-0.8148993254,
-0.0699710995,
0.1152321994,
-0.4573324323,
-0.075989984,
-0.4874957204,
-0.4360094965,
0.0303641874,
-0.1513347328,
-0.1248327419,
0.1468515247,
0.3560781479,
0.3662794828,
-0.3682959676,
0.2846491337,
-0.4018246531,
-0.1493195146,
-0.1453255117,
-0.1314411014,
0.4141911566,
-0.2530074418,
-0.4765920341,
0.1167695746,
0.3382416666,
0.6731635332,
-0.2577109933,
0.8961640596,
0.3481910825,
-0.3294018209,
-0.1480559856,
-0.7758311629,
-0.1259369254,
-0.4587788284,
0.2308605015,
-0.1832065284,
-0.9481006265,
0.5044278502,
0.4004895687,
0.4428665936,
0.5712809563,
0.4552540779,
0.0111180162,
1.6582911015,
0.5656641126,
-0.0667891353,
0.279612571,
-0.1661119908,
0.0756163001,
-0.4621693492,
-0.0447534621,
-0.7225273848,
-0.1532590091,
-0.640704453,
-0.3853523135,
0.2473928034,
-0.0920478106,
-0.2858017087,
0.1464602649,
-0.1887792796,
0.4401975274,
0.5504475236,
0.036347758,
0.2457968146,
-0.3098179698,
-0.1818320006,
0.1196008846,
-0.9021590948,
-0.194657281,
1.2852364779,
0.3129474223,
0.558632493,
0.2908273339,
0.481394887,
0.1860195249,
0.482952714,
-0.7544881105,
0.4222186804,
-0.2136661708,
-1.195243001,
-0.4681672454,
-0.6147292852,
-0.8419337273,
0.1534476727,
-0.5076160431,
-0.5710099339,
0.2099980861,
0.2909099162,
-0.696190834,
0.1124454588,
-0.6947571635,
0.8197514415,
-0.2489319146,
-0.5410499573,
-0.1824382246,
-0.5750258565,
0.4103062153,
-0.0242717434,
0.5067502856,
-0.0863620341,
-0.1737401932,
0.5978398919,
-0.1529060155,
0.6250554323,
-0.0368257165,
-0.20395796,
0.5848705769,
0.2860068083,
0.6453235149,
0.0962804481,
-0.358664602,
-0.1973110139,
-0.1464740634,
-0.4649484456,
-0.3391833901,
0.6410965919,
-0.6747857928,
-0.6958866119,
-0.4119019806,
-0.2876624167,
-0.5025609136,
0.109170489,
0.3065423071,
0.6999751925,
-0.0188223068,
0.2495461106,
0.8425344825,
-0.1571890712,
0.3726305366,
0.6460673213,
0.0286758281,
-0.3345148563,
0.6840005517,
0.5266382098,
0.5141468048,
0.1095189601,
0.2566740811,
-0.596840024,
-0.8026798964,
-0.4728266895,
0.2176178843,
-0.6405903101,
-0.2963891625,
-0.7143476605,
-0.2844164371,
-0.5168089867,
-0.2145787776,
-0.4418307841,
-0.5798458457,
-0.0810952783,
-0.3242907524,
0.0714447796,
0.5917271376,
-0.2413924932,
-0.2722102404,
-0.9074344039,
0.2419768423,
0.5299274325,
0.4085695148,
-0.1726113558,
-0.7302229404,
-0.0909697488,
0.2570612729,
-0.2189557254,
-0.8783374429,
0.3282276392,
0.475415051,
0.8746640682,
0.4992759228,
0.210848093,
0.2643452585,
-0.3453832865,
0.7372589111,
0.0654397234,
-0.6288867593,
0.2663688362,
-0.2645587921,
0.3443854153,
0.7442728281,
0.5617774129,
-0.5469321012,
-0.9031848907,
-0.7509014606,
-0.8701691628,
0.2985174358,
0.083950907,
0.2194541693,
-0.1000116989,
0.297993809,
0.3452548683,
0.3626606166,
-0.8518186212,
-0.2344803959,
0.0681526139,
-0.0311751924,
-0.5730783939,
-0.4491676688,
-0.0964037478,
0.0492399558,
0.8908810019,
-0.1748443544,
0.1052898243,
0.1290037036,
-0.1650541872,
-0.4727306962,
0.6125107408,
0.7080451846,
1.0169053078,
-0.2657464445,
0.3101084828,
0.4060550928,
-0.4197041988,
0.1320220083,
-0.0756382048,
-0.1946766824,
-0.1310451776,
0.3643057942,
0.4074124992,
-0.0974121541,
-0.9509214163,
0.6525688767,
-0.0093224691,
-0.2239546329,
-0.3260788023,
0.229443267,
0.0553574376,
0.210120067,
0.5035489798,
0.2273528725,
0.1451394409,
-0.6749351025,
0.2689536512,
0.6366274357,
-0.2976012528,
-0.0721749663,
0.5947265625,
0.0796419382,
-0.1696989536,
0.5895513296,
-0.1652470231,
-0.7602702379,
0.6740472913,
0.4127969742,
0.6944466233,
-0.2975797951,
0.3791817725,
0.5036528111,
0.4986785948,
-0.3223521411,
0.4192203879,
0.3681542575,
-0.8604928851,
-0.8698494434,
-0.5269525051,
-0.4515234828,
0.2939964533,
-0.318046689,
-0.0486361273,
-0.2237550318,
-0.4462697506,
-0.1123389527,
0.2298242301,
-0.5841028094,
0.3385794461,
0.2775182724,
0.9916128516,
-0.995660305,
0.6185694933,
0.4734098315,
-0.282296747,
-0.8621096015,
-0.1738079935,
0.1371776611,
-0.6009515524,
0.247661069,
0.1247399077,
-0.1314720362,
-0.281616807,
-0.7451395988,
-1.0550729036,
0.6000579596,
0.2997850776,
-0.6028441191,
0.319310993,
0.1467653066,
0.3717917502,
-0.0714866221,
0.3621828258,
0.3314347565,
0.3890850246,
0.0961940214,
-1.1776769161,
0.0412734821,
-0.1497268379,
-0.3374804854,
0.1206540763,
-0.4387424588,
0.9377416372,
-0.8003887534,
-0.1617540419,
0.0422598384,
0.392844677,
0.3769161701,
0.4448937476,
0.8540248871,
0.4156195521,
0.5197398663,
0.154224515,
0.9031051397,
-0.1040337458,
0.2067523599,
1.0327836275,
-0.4222731888,
1.2230195999,
0.4309910834,
-0.104385905,
0.1527646184,
0.5282661915,
0.4306194484,
0.3568973839,
0.0702898204,
-0.1429138929,
-0.7953544259,
0.0234895721,
-0.1964510083,
0.5125498772,
0.3378169835,
-0.1807828248,
0.109295629,
0.0484562702,
0.0195627138,
-0.0331202187,
-0.3585507274,
0.569419384,
0.0623593032,
-1.027482748,
0.6223655343,
0.0180472936,
0.7875288725,
-0.5774143934,
0.1767035425,
-0.2724002004,
0.2961502671,
-0.2258683294,
-1.1163563728,
0.1888822466,
-0.0674545765,
-0.085648194,
-0.2546151578,
0.9593167901,
-0.564651072,
-0.3758696318,
0.0547901243,
0.9882208109,
0.0346105583,
-0.2262338251,
-0.7894003391,
-0.3960421681,
-0.1879172325,
-0.5395306945,
0.3581137657,
0.2028761953,
0.1122920513,
0.9673365951,
0.623785913,
0.0865811035,
-0.0432413816,
-0.1529211551,
0.629011631,
-0.2941409051,
-0.311771065,
-0.8225534558,
0.4355662465,
0.0561126769,
-0.5150519013,
0.7848746777,
0.6230989695,
0.7196797729,
0.0975381732,
0.8061698079,
0.1055568084,
0.6450765729,
-0.4806098044,
0.4791832864,
-0.721978426,
0.0227017906,
-0.2896918058,
-0.8208173513,
-0.0920364857,
0.4296732247,
-0.3910508752,
0.1474403441,
0.5612996221,
0.8489657044,
0.0788285807,
-0.0838389695,
0.389205426,
0.3189947903,
-0.0035855244,
0.7957041264,
0.8877974153,
0.0234089363,
0.7622596025,
-0.1625345945,
-0.139861539,
-0.5037636161,
-0.8408532739,
-0.5213666558,
-0.4990670979,
-0.3250528574,
-0.7681458592,
0.0056556645,
0.9569706917,
0.4307285249,
-0.8823627234,
-0.0778693333,
0.1475884616,
0.3246398866,
-0.4846540987,
-0.1218426302,
0.0511434749,
-0.1646972299,
-0.3895083964,
0.3206518888,
-0.0731731877,
0.0743260086,
-0.0606854074,
-0.1693482101,
-0.2884545326,
0.470659405,
0.5756305456,
0.5059251189,
-0.4510489106,
-0.5074698925,
0.3828168511,
-0.3657951355,
-0.0533635505,
0.7792675495,
-0.457888037,
-0.0142590264,
0.5323280096,
0.2646994293,
0.2383160293,
0.0163271949,
0.5753209591,
-0.7002755404,
-0.0837928653,
0.5490509272,
0.445682168,
0.1827809811,
-0.2414813489,
0.3240172565,
0.0971697643,
-0.7094554901,
-0.9249216914,
0.3062360287,
-0.8275011182,
-0.6660854816,
1.6338423491,
-0.0810051858,
-0.0607017912,
-0.4043174982,
-0.1315756291,
0.0174537767,
-0.3273926377,
0.5450497866,
0.6847108006,
-0.1193384007,
-0.0315700658,
-0.9472398162,
0.376156956,
0.6742027998,
-0.4760818183,
0.3254754245,
0.7321387529,
0.5475780964,
0.2227872163,
0.800543189,
0.2689276934,
0.5051518083,
-0.0613604933,
-0.1773323864,
-0.0808963478,
-0.4926430285,
-0.1751455963,
0.5296287537,
0.4551271498,
0.0323945321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13212v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13212v2
|
Soft Self-Consistency Improves Language Model Agents
| 2024-02-20T18:22:38 | 2024-06-05T19:50:19 |
Han Wang, Archiki Prasad, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Generations from large language models (LLMs) can be improved by sampling and
scoring multiple solutions to select a final answer. Current "sample and
select" methods such as self-consistency (SC) rely on majority voting to score
answers. However, when tasks have many distinct and valid answers, selection by
voting requires a large number of samples. This makes SC prohibitively
expensive for interactive tasks that involve generating multiple actions
(answers) sequentially. After establishing that majority voting fails to
provide consistent gains on such tasks, we demonstrate how to increase success
rates by softening the scoring criterion. We introduce Soft Self-Consistency
(SOFT-SC), which replaces SC's discontinuous scoring with a continuous score
computed from model likelihoods, allowing for selection even when actions are
sparsely distributed. SOFT-SC improves both performance and efficiency on
long-horizon interactive tasks, requiring half as many samples as SC for
comparable or better performance. For a fixed number of samples, SOFT-SC leads
to a 1.3% increase over SC in absolute success rate on writing bash programs, a
6.6% increase on online shopping (WebShop), and a 4.7% increase for an
interactive household game (ALFWorld). Finally, we show that SOFT-SC can be
applied to both open-source and black-box models.
|
[
-0.0278960783,
-0.6082169414,
0.6990702748,
0.3511466384,
0.1846091002,
0.1732179075,
-0.6057946682,
-0.1454032958,
0.1434347183,
0.6245425344,
-0.4059545398,
-0.4910015762,
-0.3401149511,
0.186831072,
-0.119778797,
0.9165825844,
0.0415865183,
-0.3503010273,
-0.2226786166,
-0.3555804789,
-0.2027332634,
-0.2549934089,
-0.4735752642,
-0.4102983773,
0.4618636668,
0.6239901185,
0.9558155537,
0.7303860784,
0.4042212665,
0.474047631,
0.3102423549,
0.2745811045,
-0.5533132553,
0.8589298725,
-0.2538561523,
-0.2328897715,
-0.5832569599,
0.2019565254,
0.6236040592,
0.6226204634,
-0.5314610004,
-0.0102163199,
0.5038404465,
0.8187880516,
-0.6147826314,
0.1344917864,
-0.529958427,
-0.2893692553,
0.00483002,
0.1160138398,
-0.3666613698,
-0.3260191679,
-0.2383160144,
-0.4494318962,
0.2886978686,
-0.390760988,
0.4777282774,
0.0723027289,
-0.4377022684,
-0.1856423765,
-0.9406121373,
0.835944891,
-0.8917390108,
0.4494090676,
0.1877829283,
0.0526744984,
-0.4682446122,
-0.4673148096,
-0.5489305258,
-0.5424049497,
0.2684472799,
0.13812989,
0.1563244164,
0.2192871124,
0.1669501662,
0.0999740809,
-0.2706670761,
0.0498951338,
-0.186597839,
-0.2498920411,
0.9258221388,
0.1841863692,
-0.066051349,
0.0415008813,
-0.1134765819,
-0.206886068,
-0.602186501,
0.1535147727,
0.4109478593,
0.5801464915,
0.1140751466,
0.6147802472,
-0.3732976019,
0.4862566292,
0.3292154968,
-0.5706899762,
0.3891143799,
-0.368501395,
-0.0719887763,
-0.451853931,
0.8012430072,
0.0113831116,
0.3058708608,
-0.0718190894,
-0.5402280688,
-0.1459969878,
0.1122567877,
-0.5613857508,
-0.1355727613,
0.442615062,
-0.5211948752,
-0.0086300392,
0.1370773613,
-0.5601901412,
-0.291652143,
-0.4730474055,
0.4070943594,
-0.2803558707,
-0.5215335488,
0.0586545132,
-0.0636100918,
0.1825255603,
0.5650032759,
-0.9307028651,
0.6525971293,
0.7144554257,
0.8103892803,
-0.3534181416,
-0.507199049,
-0.6835462451,
0.1452319175,
-0.5865353346,
0.9183311462,
-0.375610888,
-0.2602889538,
-0.0232945606,
-0.1455083042,
-0.0212329924,
-0.8237036467,
-0.0375403836,
-0.000064316,
0.1057733148,
-0.2736272514,
-0.5873052478,
0.2359371185,
0.373349458,
-0.6248899102,
1.1916451454,
0.1296010613,
0.082815662,
0.507013917,
-0.3288497031,
-0.4211085141,
0.0553404093,
-0.2253610194,
-0.4041662812,
0.3633745909,
-0.2286401242,
0.4991571009,
0.3121969402,
0.0609869696,
-0.7593252063,
-0.5110121369,
0.2275089025,
-0.5747505426,
0.4089430273,
0.2652131319,
-0.6193653941,
0.0941264033,
-0.3849112391,
0.3748725951,
-0.0013827869,
-0.5497102737,
-0.1393390298,
0.083976388,
-0.0775540322,
0.3296059072,
0.3171466887,
-0.5312540531,
0.58935076,
-0.2206839919,
0.0210550446,
0.9832425714,
-0.3190508187,
0.4632711112,
-0.5480553508,
0.4319458604,
-0.0793110058,
0.2581691444,
-0.1307454258,
-0.3917530179,
-0.770585537,
-0.3180417418,
0.4907621145,
0.3751713037,
-0.4647352993,
0.5076192617,
-0.1536270231,
-0.477598995,
-0.6667686701,
0.8313949704,
0.1619410664,
0.0356390662,
0.1606019437,
-0.5010063052,
-0.1201845706,
-0.69971627,
-0.1428003013,
-0.2323642224,
0.063967146,
0.4182460308,
0.2587171793,
-0.0353302956,
1.0564187765,
-0.2915570736,
-0.4315372705,
-0.453468591,
0.1910054386,
0.3271272779,
0.5480859876,
0.2451214045,
-0.5320422649,
-0.6080311537,
-0.2944480479,
-0.593588233,
-0.0928342491,
0.0013254134,
0.0951515064,
0.5366460085,
0.3950995803,
-0.4513641298,
0.2354627103,
0.7533269525,
-0.2828425765,
0.4574469328,
-0.573890686,
0.3962788284,
-0.7437284589,
-0.130018875,
0.0568586551,
-0.5562617779,
-0.5308741927,
0.0795661435,
0.0733663663,
0.2660134435,
-0.4922569394,
0.5005018115,
-0.542637527,
-0.0029344924,
-0.4953691661,
0.1008147225,
0.029551046,
0.4049395025,
-0.0803978518,
0.8731363416,
0.269037962,
-0.6373851299,
0.1780050546,
-0.1939357221,
0.1303652972,
0.4247377813,
-0.7713376284,
0.585441649,
-0.1758892238,
0.1555920392,
-1.1261539459,
0.0321862996,
-0.0311543811,
-0.0948834941,
0.3253331184,
-0.2268594503,
-0.4922127724,
-0.1426201463,
-0.4550620615,
0.1455480605,
0.5747115612,
-0.2793473303,
0.9668629169,
0.2496164292,
-0.1419127882,
-0.6082391143,
-0.3888188601,
-0.0356904566,
0.1893200725,
-0.4536351562,
0.0471012779,
-0.4548172355,
-0.4060931802,
-0.0117116524,
-0.2229278237,
0.1160568371,
0.1121548265,
0.1264649481,
0.1635722816,
-0.2790209949,
0.220202595,
-0.0446104854,
-0.1332919896,
-0.4055522382,
-0.304851234,
0.3498490155,
-0.3345367014,
-0.5861384869,
-0.1197744906,
0.5507365465,
0.5793952942,
-0.0191171579,
0.5900281668,
0.1340715438,
-0.1305139065,
-0.3589264452,
-1.0049823523,
-0.3469374478,
-0.55715096,
-0.0203825738,
-0.558257401,
-0.9447405934,
0.4049760401,
-0.1096748859,
0.4069928825,
0.3608435392,
0.4575381577,
-0.2752555907,
1.2947158813,
0.6980101466,
0.0472828858,
0.4312129021,
0.04451463,
-0.11453107,
-0.3463117182,
-0.1250741482,
-0.5531358719,
-0.2584808767,
-0.7113425136,
-0.3143061101,
0.3398874998,
-0.0895757005,
-0.238806963,
0.0280873477,
-0.4427301884,
0.559045434,
0.727784276,
0.2309850156,
0.4275195599,
-0.0632565469,
-0.0769917369,
-0.0813251734,
-0.6433671117,
-0.5129744411,
1.0861247778,
0.2470019162,
0.9616346359,
0.2939656973,
1.1686962843,
0.4968446493,
0.435808897,
-0.5357661843,
0.6731105447,
-0.3845318258,
-0.6599895954,
-0.5814346671,
-0.4710709751,
-1.2317386866,
0.2327921391,
-0.2544952631,
-0.3831772506,
0.0752717108,
0.3690444529,
-0.3785494566,
-0.0094796438,
-0.691403389,
0.7573017478,
-0.2569960058,
-0.7354140282,
-0.2327044308,
-0.2431339324,
0.052778516,
0.1876214445,
0.0734729096,
-0.5357764959,
-0.2542702854,
0.6007220745,
-0.3727523386,
0.9774361849,
-0.1635967195,
-0.1139301062,
0.4707968533,
0.3776693642,
0.6244033575,
-0.2252342403,
-0.2013137341,
0.1230952665,
-0.0539625995,
-0.5743795633,
-1.0508116484,
0.7532148361,
-0.6776130795,
-0.9997675419,
-0.6458339095,
-0.4309357107,
-0.1161613166,
0.1278032809,
-0.3107751012,
0.3825000226,
0.0387131274,
0.454528749,
0.7458568215,
0.4012927413,
0.5412714481,
0.8750645518,
-0.1003989726,
-0.3512377143,
0.6361598969,
0.3480696082,
0.5036137104,
-0.241450578,
0.3208394647,
-0.4975271523,
-0.4450071156,
-0.4043381214,
0.3477656245,
-0.5524622202,
-0.3137126863,
-0.5447990298,
-0.1482411772,
-0.7729461789,
-0.0916376635,
-0.5813134909,
-0.2971918285,
-0.0580767989,
0.0427349843,
0.2050250322,
1.0140088797,
-0.4169375598,
-0.0612247884,
-0.6692098975,
0.3500612676,
0.445430547,
0.702702105,
-0.2887966037,
-0.5219973922,
0.1212906837,
-0.0519617945,
-0.2612175047,
-1.0611566305,
-0.0355545431,
0.4092485011,
0.7479082942,
0.2453852743,
0.0359138437,
0.6543833613,
-0.4811798632,
0.5710628033,
0.0606475212,
-0.9004648328,
0.5310993791,
-0.3671201468,
0.4959107637,
1.0151500702,
0.0737248957,
-0.4829756618,
-0.7618579865,
-0.7525240183,
-0.7792946696,
0.4255157411,
0.0812026411,
0.4463858306,
-0.0368505828,
0.3646282256,
0.2900974452,
0.1833964288,
-0.7717603445,
-0.2889965475,
-0.1632722616,
-0.6315482855,
-0.1857677251,
-0.2157116681,
0.0580961891,
-0.0054385373,
0.8005991578,
-0.5718291402,
-0.1983809173,
0.2703623772,
0.2134277821,
-0.2388778627,
0.4252010882,
0.3340533674,
0.5821121335,
-0.0234277342,
0.3003955483,
0.0849013031,
-0.4498112202,
0.4289707541,
0.0395637862,
-0.3827655911,
-0.2077749074,
0.22688362,
0.0852362812,
0.1796695739,
-0.6740684509,
0.5823265314,
0.1340928525,
-0.1369153857,
-0.2667414248,
0.5470228195,
-0.1796456873,
0.3550978601,
0.4972175658,
0.0160586927,
0.2399330735,
-0.8325369954,
0.4299126863,
0.5571073294,
-0.3668198287,
0.0803560764,
0.337605834,
0.0964776576,
-0.4549857974,
0.8450112343,
-0.33603701,
-0.2680989504,
0.5599209666,
0.670819521,
0.7148684859,
-0.5590369105,
0.4671015143,
0.1613442898,
0.2625382841,
-0.6469647288,
0.5570867658,
-0.0329246745,
-0.7138977051,
-0.4494491518,
-0.3522083759,
-0.6444725394,
-0.0279570073,
-0.3283705115,
0.2618978918,
-0.4425040185,
-0.213627547,
-0.4317377806,
0.3884738982,
-0.6076952219,
0.2731118202,
0.1636108756,
0.7270576358,
-0.9138888717,
0.7693143487,
0.3976500034,
-0.4245150387,
-1.0584944487,
-0.1304852962,
-0.0356809646,
-0.4090028405,
-0.0526461825,
0.1822713912,
-0.1857861727,
-0.069616802,
-0.6793513894,
-1.235290885,
0.9415131807,
0.404083252,
-0.7582470179,
0.3005775511,
-0.0066244416,
0.5709905624,
-0.420199126,
0.4797343612,
0.5057248473,
0.3692004681,
0.1358807087,
-0.9023663402,
0.17705217,
-0.1737634689,
-0.2430889606,
0.1083333865,
-0.768026948,
0.5236093998,
-0.3864526153,
-0.019641947,
0.0258481503,
1.2270773649,
0.9055845737,
0.4376989007,
0.9652274251,
0.1350472122,
0.9215142131,
-0.0549185276,
0.765395999,
-0.2039149702,
0.2736582756,
1.2025797367,
-0.7018856406,
1.0300701857,
0.2164758891,
-0.1507104635,
0.8349523544,
0.2332903147,
-0.1580878049,
0.2885534763,
0.0053877016,
-0.2213895172,
-0.6438720822,
-0.0116117457,
0.0077338591,
0.5931316614,
0.0556051061,
0.0626053065,
-0.0479844473,
-0.0300174877,
0.0454730093,
0.3809204102,
-0.0900898576,
0.7725057602,
0.0833375901,
-1.0306462049,
0.1510491818,
-0.1759614199,
0.6412728429,
-0.8388739228,
-0.2839136422,
-0.3976535201,
0.2943930626,
-0.0470029749,
-0.9754913449,
0.0155498553,
-0.2706674933,
-0.1760822088,
-0.3525852859,
0.9418866634,
-0.6295779347,
-0.5205278397,
0.2458622009,
0.9464011192,
0.1760549396,
0.0101950699,
-0.8148037791,
0.1038880721,
-0.3229360878,
-0.5002560616,
0.3345906436,
0.3840949535,
0.1192615628,
0.7826464772,
0.6465573311,
0.0854729787,
-0.1141326353,
0.1556026787,
0.6681395173,
-0.6360983849,
-0.3784460425,
-0.7994238734,
0.390231967,
-0.2351236641,
-0.2741365731,
0.8825647235,
0.6359576583,
0.4795701206,
0.2717902064,
0.7916247845,
-0.050510522,
0.4384822547,
-0.2610899806,
0.3480474651,
-0.5678418875,
0.0931408778,
-0.1275426596,
-0.9743748307,
-0.1433425099,
0.3687477112,
-0.2170867026,
0.5371580124,
0.4973008335,
0.7434348464,
-0.0868222117,
-0.369436264,
0.5646609664,
0.1733528823,
0.1794407219,
0.248551771,
0.6145375967,
-0.1044485644,
0.6372341514,
-0.313967973,
-0.3586576283,
-0.0661070943,
-0.9713374376,
-0.6292697191,
-0.4785060883,
-0.556553185,
-0.8568918705,
0.2590543926,
1.2466988564,
0.9727743864,
-0.8779277205,
-0.3863293529,
0.22400859,
0.1266371012,
-0.6637084484,
-0.1997636557,
0.0642721578,
-0.7744173408,
-0.6753721833,
0.4681467414,
0.3506528139,
0.0406652652,
-0.4630930126,
-0.1193911806,
0.0665669367,
0.4378298819,
0.2375872433,
0.4361455142,
-0.7141084075,
-0.372479558,
0.3771187663,
-0.4293685555,
0.2853663564,
0.8691731095,
-0.9081484675,
0.2334654331,
0.3910821676,
0.1916138828,
0.4062841833,
0.2665962875,
0.6325452924,
-0.4655743241,
-0.1754514873,
0.2925136387,
0.3375412524,
0.5062220693,
-0.4432697594,
0.4807969332,
0.1580132842,
-0.7425087094,
-0.3776254058,
0.1677351892,
-0.9932279587,
-0.3833242655,
1.4324402809,
-0.2319133282,
-0.4157696962,
-0.4881522655,
-0.0456112809,
-0.1079785898,
-0.7003048062,
0.9263521433,
0.4977506995,
-0.1906172186,
-0.0674139857,
-0.2632595301,
0.3040930331,
0.5501172543,
-0.5693789721,
0.0821045712,
0.6090996265,
0.6566366553,
0.1039361432,
1.2316888571,
0.1266845316,
0.2620921731,
-0.070107609,
0.0100031104,
0.0223534647,
-0.5629923344,
-0.4123300612,
0.5440571308,
0.2404470146,
0.1857740432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13211v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13211v2
|
Can Large Language Models be Good Emotional Supporter? Mitigating Preference Bias on Emotional Support Conversation
| 2024-02-20T18:21:32 | 2024-06-05T13:39:59 |
Dongjin Kang, Sunghwan Kim, Taeyoon Kwon, Seungjun Moon, Hyunsouk Cho, Youngjae Yu, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotional Support Conversation (ESC) is a task aimed at alleviating
individuals' emotional distress through daily conversation. Given its inherent
complexity and non-intuitive nature, ESConv dataset incorporates support
strategies to facilitate the generation of appropriate responses. Recently,
despite the remarkable conversational ability of large language models (LLMs),
previous studies have suggested that they often struggle with providing useful
emotional support. Hence, this work initially analyzes the results of LLMs on
ESConv, revealing challenges in selecting the correct strategy and a notable
preference for a specific strategy. Motivated by these, we explore the impact
of the inherent preference in LLMs on providing emotional support, and
consequently, we observe that exhibiting high preference for specific
strategies hinders effective emotional support, aggravating its robustness in
predicting the appropriate strategy. Moreover, we conduct a methodological
study to offer insights into the necessary approaches for LLMs to serve as
proficient emotional supporters. Our findings emphasize that (1) low preference
for specific strategies hinders the progress of emotional support, (2) external
assistance helps reduce preference bias, and (3) existing LLMs alone cannot
become good emotional supporters. These insights suggest promising avenues for
future research to enhance the emotional intelligence of LLMs.
|
[
-0.7011620402,
-0.5589351654,
0.7171424031,
0.2274585664,
-0.291849494,
0.0141842887,
-0.6629444957,
-0.4628635645,
0.5025385022,
0.5040482283,
-0.7292633057,
-0.1554497778,
-0.6787372231,
0.2731975913,
0.0380423963,
1.2407909632,
0.0241127685,
0.1776980907,
-0.4669041336,
-0.2456544638,
-0.5066128373,
-0.6058331728,
-0.9026796818,
-0.460023582,
0.6984380484,
0.7713047862,
0.4428676963,
0.206676513,
0.2656264007,
0.2806922495,
-0.2497545034,
0.0658975095,
-0.509893775,
0.6452587247,
0.1590532064,
-0.5844460726,
-0.4937827289,
-0.4130305946,
0.2167200744,
0.4732069373,
-0.4805147648,
-0.0370964482,
0.2881515622,
0.8923586011,
-0.510481894,
-0.0995174423,
-0.923032999,
0.049327556,
-0.2294231951,
0.0850083679,
-0.5350474119,
-0.1248501241,
0.1833803952,
-0.3652323186,
-0.1364632547,
0.0716549307,
0.4645804465,
0.1572376192,
-0.5669150949,
-0.4023401439,
-0.7421543598,
0.8630052805,
-0.7116531134,
0.1810709834,
0.5876045227,
0.2227247506,
-0.0269669984,
0.0783815905,
-0.265168041,
-0.4249999523,
0.2250511944,
0.1488449126,
-0.3161306083,
0.3734968305,
0.4887661338,
-0.0466927141,
-0.1966116726,
0.427577436,
0.0471545495,
-0.0934477448,
0.4711927176,
0.139026612,
0.1132012159,
0.0117655098,
-0.0058939173,
0.1802418679,
-0.6801965833,
0.2634184659,
0.5269078016,
0.1990443915,
-0.0537100956,
0.6886614561,
-0.3071920276,
0.1894389391,
0.1858479083,
0.3652387261,
-0.0310660712,
0.2337650508,
-0.0381460041,
0.231125474,
0.5063494444,
0.4929487407,
0.6796016693,
0.1007408425,
-0.2550105453,
0.2123489976,
0.1569078267,
-0.9078323841,
0.3332298696,
0.3528435826,
-0.6612015367,
0.0483880565,
-0.1017125472,
-0.716722846,
-0.8544957042,
-0.3706055284,
-0.2067204863,
-0.0920585617,
-0.4884496033,
0.0640713274,
0.1105429083,
0.2352167219,
0.4482488632,
-1.103802681,
0.4276989698,
0.7042890787,
0.7820163369,
-0.1328648329,
0.2126704752,
-0.593126893,
-0.0477436967,
-0.2393371314,
0.9011315703,
-0.7270613313,
-0.736343503,
0.2282171994,
0.040096432,
0.2382605672,
-0.4786916673,
0.9972604513,
-0.1045652777,
-0.1350280195,
-0.720457375,
-0.4924968481,
0.2399408668,
0.3353537619,
-0.5361870527,
0.5881717205,
-0.3491118252,
-0.7181057334,
0.1769966334,
-0.4149562716,
-0.4516374171,
-0.1682181805,
-0.2247444391,
-0.344981432,
0.3984369338,
0.1998348087,
0.6882918477,
-0.3160424531,
0.0086262971,
-0.8687913418,
-0.0774357244,
0.4499203563,
-0.2851647139,
0.2571074963,
0.1654869616,
-0.4246129394,
-0.0811632574,
-0.4732933939,
-0.3223880827,
0.1397580802,
-0.1210921258,
-0.4961289465,
0.439560771,
-0.0813042521,
0.267293185,
-0.0189301446,
-0.6624693274,
0.1684969366,
-0.3920065761,
0.3591701984,
1.1121768951,
-0.0609204769,
0.4435785115,
-0.1744809151,
0.7899491787,
-0.1491475999,
0.0491095223,
-0.0296893585,
-0.4687475562,
-0.9376913309,
-0.0335368812,
-0.2417729646,
0.0922282189,
-0.6016589999,
-0.0824816823,
0.0887809321,
-0.3814530969,
-0.4573351741,
0.0889807418,
0.2715025842,
0.4175557494,
0.1719732732,
0.0300598219,
-0.7915408015,
-1.2420684099,
-0.1356257647,
-0.2887935638,
0.1628437191,
0.6557854414,
0.1811446398,
0.0179240201,
0.5680752397,
-0.3718053401,
-0.1454368532,
-0.3442484438,
-0.3017509878,
0.0617772155,
0.0490646325,
0.6299423575,
-0.7713360786,
-0.6685125232,
0.0322808549,
-0.2663367391,
-0.3444860876,
0.182836771,
-0.2207863927,
0.5337014794,
0.4055817425,
-0.4818416536,
0.1376302093,
0.819219768,
-0.401283741,
0.3298484981,
0.0630491301,
0.232307598,
-0.9696620107,
-0.1730535924,
0.3059446216,
-0.1849261224,
-0.6059895754,
-0.5752420425,
-0.065264523,
0.3028012216,
-0.4313707948,
0.3702681363,
-0.3345223367,
0.1755532473,
-0.4472681582,
0.1087524146,
-0.2069743425,
0.1719544828,
0.4413502514,
0.2292051017,
0.7425292134,
-0.4227561653,
0.3449350297,
0.165175274,
0.1165433675,
1.0227454901,
-0.8597700596,
0.1623874009,
-0.3283440471,
0.4411877692,
-1.0648803711,
0.0410600863,
0.0567821711,
-0.368337661,
0.2986184657,
-0.2665619552,
-0.131289646,
-0.43331936,
-0.2098287046,
-0.1244741082,
0.3836886883,
-0.25328812,
0.8514233828,
0.4657759964,
-0.4255159199,
-0.5854827762,
-0.6498205662,
0.0805035755,
-0.4542362988,
-0.5312405229,
0.1175009459,
-0.4580542147,
-0.4934702516,
-0.1875719577,
-0.1076455116,
0.4353773892,
0.2032884657,
0.5498802662,
0.319069773,
-0.1652196497,
0.3201130629,
-0.2670568824,
-0.1060110778,
0.1525429636,
-0.0486148074,
0.5880409479,
-0.2948797643,
-0.5388091207,
-0.1210875362,
0.6965206861,
0.7722187638,
-0.3164059818,
0.904221952,
0.2495591342,
-0.4036256671,
-0.3742738366,
-0.9517885447,
-0.3956820965,
-0.4553205073,
0.5233989954,
-0.1808788478,
-0.8325789571,
0.5032738447,
0.3425267041,
0.0408775955,
0.118629694,
0.744643867,
-0.1627059728,
1.5575346947,
0.3894226849,
-0.3652972877,
0.6291402578,
0.0469275787,
0.0863998979,
-0.8668964505,
-0.2217550278,
-0.8362861872,
-0.3748927116,
-0.4457066059,
0.2642651498,
-0.043815203,
-0.5399364233,
-0.2047950476,
0.0162560847,
-0.3107206523,
0.1256381124,
-0.0803706869,
0.1263957173,
-0.0081849033,
-0.0059565334,
0.1708108336,
-0.332262665,
-0.512806952,
-0.4136081338,
0.7442306876,
0.7470425963,
0.9360810518,
0.2092175931,
0.4465965629,
0.0945061892,
0.2956630886,
-1.0340545177,
0.643630445,
-0.128515631,
-0.4561844766,
0.0875652283,
-0.3638040721,
-0.788960278,
0.1123232991,
-0.5645910501,
-0.734531343,
0.0075143618,
0.1777910292,
-0.261851877,
0.2060967833,
-0.8081418872,
0.4738336205,
-0.2936288416,
-0.4885286689,
-0.2309465408,
-0.4177575707,
-0.1248731241,
0.0714432895,
0.1768672913,
-0.2211221159,
-0.0585150681,
0.8095824122,
-0.2787816226,
0.830150187,
-0.2193462253,
-0.0682514459,
0.1739508063,
0.0988036543,
0.8893531561,
-0.0253885873,
-0.4512449503,
-0.286801219,
-0.3343136013,
-0.4230087698,
-0.5877594948,
0.957243979,
-0.7584676743,
-0.9865683317,
-0.2087063491,
-0.1649923027,
-0.6723223925,
-0.1242589056,
0.0101376884,
0.1934804469,
-0.2300703526,
0.7137041092,
0.9197932482,
-0.0012193327,
0.6544035673,
0.5718101263,
0.0563918091,
-0.171667248,
0.3696385026,
0.1885615587,
0.5259635448,
0.039233882,
0.4115206301,
-0.3593316972,
-0.3996050656,
-0.19400087,
0.339880079,
-0.6799539924,
-0.1499856412,
-0.8819672465,
0.1406050324,
-0.3466184139,
-0.2014483958,
-0.5919532776,
-0.1363554448,
-0.3471733928,
-0.5163329244,
0.5072777867,
0.7189189196,
0.3704645932,
0.0224186089,
-0.5616027713,
-0.1648035347,
0.2202354521,
0.2070003897,
0.2674084902,
-0.3590695858,
-0.3821324706,
0.0099929711,
-0.2444308251,
-1.0120471716,
0.2141664326,
0.0356461965,
0.7772541046,
0.7010518312,
0.2618827224,
0.5440768003,
-0.3806276023,
0.8714394569,
0.153920576,
-0.8407053947,
0.5516049862,
-0.5663530231,
-0.0354962535,
0.4087692201,
0.3990946412,
-0.6730079651,
-0.3729864061,
-0.6055560708,
-0.8587281108,
0.6089933515,
0.110803619,
0.3365355432,
-0.0901706591,
0.1256080568,
-0.2606391907,
0.3891507685,
-0.764764607,
-0.3439112008,
0.0742484927,
-0.0826589391,
0.1283770949,
-0.426007539,
-0.1853257865,
0.300866127,
0.8356534839,
-0.3335913718,
0.1060759649,
0.2352612913,
0.4340392947,
-0.5171718001,
0.4501754344,
0.4786276221,
0.1617830396,
0.0633869469,
0.0830863789,
0.4326744378,
-0.2149447799,
-0.0312816985,
-0.058953315,
0.1750104278,
-0.3762518466,
0.0861029476,
0.9260336161,
0.0165056344,
-0.5933564305,
0.5798426867,
-0.2044007778,
-0.0629291758,
-0.1743287295,
-0.0993036479,
0.4533711672,
0.1734277308,
0.2675629556,
-0.0368734784,
-0.057505019,
-0.5795925856,
-0.1461371481,
0.8486638069,
-0.5755043626,
-0.2188805789,
0.3798475862,
0.4301600158,
-0.3978394568,
0.3059999645,
0.1165266261,
-0.6855537891,
0.8493174314,
0.6547920704,
0.708101213,
-0.3426563144,
0.2078520358,
0.0899395943,
-0.0788698122,
-0.2608644962,
0.0189409945,
0.1686984003,
-0.8885124922,
-0.1842310876,
-0.2720181942,
-0.5495108366,
-0.0782029256,
-0.6875982285,
0.534457922,
-0.218676731,
-0.3443367183,
-0.3611749411,
-0.0159416217,
-0.7023291588,
-0.0698085502,
0.6305679679,
0.7859640718,
-0.9057757258,
0.6364260912,
0.8829228282,
-0.2717440128,
-0.8965337276,
-0.1274445206,
0.2197968811,
-0.7445866466,
0.3438129425,
0.0623835251,
-0.1253309697,
-0.2879071832,
-0.4089729488,
-0.4569772184,
0.8485703468,
0.353504777,
-0.7804652452,
0.1358462423,
-0.0588250272,
0.7615443468,
-0.7165416479,
0.7055230141,
0.2040173262,
0.5029308796,
0.1875797063,
-0.7304813862,
0.0557419956,
-0.2266688347,
0.0005234422,
0.0959043875,
-1.1023701429,
0.4452166855,
-0.1601947397,
0.1081535071,
0.1193924099,
0.5079988837,
0.3503632545,
0.2453127503,
0.9514822364,
0.2282746583,
0.6410612464,
0.0350858197,
1.0216519833,
-0.1990337819,
0.2181887776,
0.726403296,
-0.5392090678,
0.9565454721,
0.8738638163,
0.1224551052,
0.4874547422,
0.6490346193,
0.1870414764,
0.1483578533,
0.3126913607,
-0.3646085262,
-0.4797124267,
-0.6627302766,
-0.1791460216,
0.1098187268,
0.3966495097,
-0.4058039486,
0.1397057474,
0.2421961427,
0.2741069198,
0.2470127195,
-0.5150893331,
0.6183564067,
0.365724951,
-0.8280792236,
0.0954537541,
-0.3034065664,
0.7187880874,
-0.8107105494,
0.1001343355,
-0.2433754802,
0.060197223,
-0.5786519647,
-0.7215408683,
0.0294075683,
0.2189047039,
-0.0583642088,
-0.2230785787,
0.8199833632,
-0.3651858568,
-0.1045357883,
0.6044713259,
0.5427015424,
-0.3601169586,
-0.1293655634,
-0.6140264273,
0.1777879447,
0.0868606865,
-0.7431498766,
0.492488265,
0.5485410094,
0.1691179127,
0.8561809659,
0.5805177093,
0.3562772274,
-0.48205024,
0.2792490721,
0.9501906633,
-0.3737550974,
-0.519516468,
-1.0922180414,
0.7498276234,
-0.0359556898,
-0.0876023844,
0.960593462,
0.0974828154,
0.4338822663,
0.1409945786,
0.7995651364,
0.0466052815,
0.1966316104,
-0.50892061,
0.5165719986,
-0.5904724598,
0.4685962796,
-0.3312833905,
-0.890534699,
-0.0002147361,
0.4746227264,
-0.4468538463,
0.1799772233,
0.4505785108,
0.9592826366,
0.3305106163,
0.248576358,
0.4004100263,
0.3468418717,
0.5937731266,
0.7144754529,
1.2317752838,
0.4263107479,
0.5826138854,
-0.0528083518,
-0.191781342,
-0.2532144189,
-1.0538976192,
-1.0606036186,
-0.48907125,
-0.2088167518,
-0.6821083426,
0.0809421688,
1.6019002199,
0.7443706393,
-0.6144738197,
-0.1662285179,
-0.0159164183,
0.0893477798,
0.1091219634,
-0.1842198968,
-0.0521915555,
0.0003454694,
-0.8583968878,
0.1290078312,
0.0619593151,
0.0256115496,
-0.3126505613,
-0.3159187436,
0.1247658879,
0.2421455085,
0.467838347,
0.2532389462,
-0.4983987212,
-0.3335481286,
0.5272988081,
-0.1436571926,
0.1648806632,
0.9666016698,
-0.4144666791,
0.4708638191,
0.4552569091,
0.795324862,
0.1122284234,
-0.142048642,
0.6278340816,
-0.3529391289,
-0.044920411,
0.3538124263,
0.793380022,
0.5357435346,
-0.6427155137,
0.2336391658,
0.0247817822,
-0.8657901287,
-0.7432450056,
0.3611639738,
-0.8321755528,
0.0098038511,
1.7877801657,
-0.0466027036,
-0.143862322,
0.0681762472,
-0.7226105928,
0.0594601259,
-1.0696057081,
0.4474113882,
1.0717289448,
-0.4239446521,
-0.2692640126,
-0.5711043477,
0.411595434,
0.6490383744,
-0.5374672413,
0.2437154651,
0.3342483938,
0.0567046143,
-0.0898726732,
0.5770784616,
0.2192538232,
-0.1239097714,
-0.5899436474,
-0.1189318895,
-0.0416585915,
-0.1133666188,
-0.5428760648,
-0.044566486,
0.5257380009,
0.2152434438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13208v1
|
How do Hyenas deal with Human Speech? Speech Recognition and Translation with ConfHyena
| 2024-02-20T18:19:08 | 2024-02-20T18:19:08 |
Marco Gaido, Sara Papi, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The attention mechanism, a cornerstone of state-of-the-art neural models,
faces computational hurdles in processing long sequences due to its quadratic
complexity. Consequently, research efforts in the last few years focused on
finding more efficient alternatives. Among them, Hyena (Poli et al., 2023)
stands out for achieving competitive results in both language modeling and
image classification, while offering sub-quadratic memory and computational
complexity. Building on these promising results, we propose ConfHyena, a
Conformer whose encoder self-attentions are replaced with an adaptation of
Hyena for speech processing, where the long input sequences cause high
computational costs. Through experiments in automatic speech recognition (for
English) and translation (from English into 8 target languages), we show that
our best ConfHyena model significantly reduces the training time by 27%, at the
cost of minimal quality degradation (~1%), which, in most cases, is not
statistically significant.
|
[
-0.4504802227,
-0.2481916249,
0.2349333912,
0.3990916014,
-0.3690439463,
-0.1562260836,
-0.29593274,
-0.7971698642,
0.1820248812,
0.2984857559,
-0.3193460703,
0.0906927586,
-0.6859203577,
0.1192264557,
-0.4278660715,
0.6147528887,
0.1887445897,
-0.2527939975,
0.1137310937,
-0.5529515147,
-0.5117435455,
-0.609618187,
-0.6513564587,
-0.5414286256,
0.7512001991,
0.5008807778,
0.829541862,
1.0341085196,
0.339074105,
0.2616343796,
-0.0336221084,
-0.1614075154,
-0.4605295956,
0.1654496938,
-0.2356628627,
-0.2607139051,
-0.1022246405,
0.0555752888,
0.5649017096,
0.536103189,
-0.3106698394,
0.563811183,
0.0960633233,
0.7361895442,
-0.7641321421,
0.1856998652,
-0.3517434001,
-0.0663015321,
-0.3785909116,
0.1626945734,
-0.0132261161,
-0.3280931413,
0.4472059011,
-0.6513845325,
0.2304851115,
-0.0245866943,
0.5757151842,
0.8492709398,
0.0293621086,
-0.2454051822,
-0.819529891,
0.5994331241,
-0.4479017556,
0.7342782021,
0.2968151271,
0.3460321426,
-0.4305313528,
-0.7916505933,
-0.7011384964,
-0.2023039758,
0.2904092968,
-0.3006264567,
-0.6079176068,
0.0842024162,
0.3299190104,
0.239612475,
-0.4911611676,
0.0728794411,
-0.6013421416,
-0.3213173449,
0.5292241573,
-0.3271666467,
0.1646531373,
0.0112938536,
0.0101060541,
-0.104384549,
-0.490396589,
0.4235206842,
0.1570797265,
-0.0837485045,
-0.0290806964,
0.3977918923,
-0.2573129535,
0.8880935311,
0.3454861641,
0.0196154099,
-0.0919711143,
0.3638565242,
-0.6000564694,
0.4494687319,
0.8298697472,
0.0013105096,
0.6106408834,
-0.2341554016,
0.1043863222,
0.487420857,
0.2838012576,
-0.8651120067,
-0.4426811934,
0.3316286504,
-0.3655448556,
-0.0110893762,
-0.5585529208,
-0.8318650126,
-0.2837789357,
-0.3163812757,
0.3798105717,
-0.1033906937,
-0.1278468221,
0.4042870402,
-0.0182130281,
0.2185210437,
0.2634077966,
-0.9750092626,
0.5883588195,
0.5334083438,
0.8770702481,
-0.276147157,
-0.1933786869,
-0.9329155087,
-0.0758347884,
-0.2294932902,
0.6903076768,
-0.4068776071,
-0.1196483374,
-0.1881447881,
0.0177382715,
-0.1217904314,
-0.6915331483,
0.6259057522,
-0.3668518662,
-0.1853129417,
-0.1329949349,
-0.3260807991,
-0.5092204213,
-0.1519630253,
-0.8693965673,
0.5728572607,
0.0942913294,
-0.5394018888,
-0.1867400706,
-0.5475757122,
-0.6165727973,
0.0363901593,
-0.0288399141,
-0.3912906349,
0.0230379887,
0.0967796743,
0.4414013028,
-0.6819642186,
0.0373454839,
-0.1601442546,
-0.4093312323,
0.2692044675,
0.1078667194,
0.6405187249,
0.5165828466,
-0.4837642908,
0.197182864,
-0.7802421451,
-0.3204161525,
0.0878572017,
-0.4624277651,
-0.3770264089,
-0.1149079725,
0.0421846844,
0.5273462534,
0.102067925,
-0.6808466315,
-0.1626562923,
-0.3561681509,
0.8898763657,
0.3783306777,
-0.0781483501,
0.6510228515,
-0.2562433779,
0.5846251845,
-0.0628176183,
0.2840067148,
0.0373393297,
-0.5050133467,
-0.9629332423,
-0.2491143346,
0.2454692423,
0.3797796369,
-0.3509363532,
-0.1541247219,
-0.0819269717,
-0.68724823,
-0.9658915401,
0.1823065132,
0.3811537027,
0.7352935076,
0.4079562724,
-0.1576450914,
-0.6013011932,
-0.8452374339,
-0.0464668944,
-0.1513269842,
0.112778008,
-0.194542706,
0.2111770362,
-0.1999411434,
0.5119299293,
-0.1402852237,
-0.4187828898,
0.0696867853,
-0.1114814058,
0.2525294721,
0.6152617335,
0.5626475811,
-0.693924129,
-0.2692496479,
0.0081847478,
-0.4224782586,
0.1179926097,
-0.1367183179,
-0.1002380326,
-0.0201192163,
0.4551805258,
-0.7264059186,
0.4474819303,
0.7556080222,
0.0223798361,
0.3211669326,
-0.042963393,
-0.0135903228,
-0.775824666,
0.0273879711,
0.3334904611,
-0.3622898459,
-0.7359351516,
-0.1727077961,
0.1424325258,
-0.3339397013,
-0.6117186546,
0.4436231256,
-0.4399398267,
0.0899085924,
-0.3714434505,
-0.1669912785,
-0.220663771,
0.8795438409,
0.0481130816,
0.9114551544,
0.5218455195,
-1.0079489946,
0.5492427945,
0.500464797,
-0.3144336939,
0.4705173075,
-1.0251265764,
0.4424979389,
-0.0596099459,
0.0075071747,
-0.8589006066,
-0.2398048192,
0.4843795598,
-0.44264552,
0.3234866858,
-0.1179914027,
0.0367624424,
-0.3870018423,
-0.1832608581,
0.6810222864,
0.7448129654,
-0.6991064548,
0.438498348,
0.7387613654,
-0.1539259255,
-0.35633111,
-0.5617259145,
0.1919678003,
-0.1431437582,
-0.5879787803,
0.4560077488,
-0.0351024531,
-0.2528832555,
-0.1784009337,
-0.2802428603,
-0.022280803,
-0.0744501054,
0.2470341176,
-0.4196505845,
-0.2976645827,
0.1860778034,
-0.2647091448,
0.0880840123,
0.0172468536,
-0.5422030687,
0.4751151204,
-0.0262062028,
0.2223469019,
-1.0066084862,
0.4193341136,
1.142385602,
-0.6334143281,
0.1163877994,
0.4211350977,
-0.6541008949,
0.1080808863,
-0.5577271581,
0.0489385463,
-0.4395848215,
0.3004249632,
-0.4025915563,
-0.5234695077,
0.3887404799,
-0.0050679455,
-0.0919387937,
0.349396199,
0.5046955347,
-0.2683878839,
0.7221345901,
0.7946853638,
-0.4208135903,
0.729460001,
-0.1932566762,
-0.0140588675,
-1.0577532053,
-0.2783592045,
-0.7833337784,
-0.3100895286,
-0.7103097439,
-0.1941148639,
0.2950046659,
-0.3018525541,
-0.1794004291,
0.6712691188,
-0.59756428,
0.1330088228,
0.6043287516,
0.1012701765,
-0.0668941364,
-0.0411610641,
0.4965153337,
0.0270361863,
-0.7400305271,
-0.2263899744,
0.6962922215,
0.4926739335,
1.0457183123,
0.0598312281,
0.5126716495,
0.3954944015,
0.1548529267,
-1.0512086153,
0.2575342059,
-0.2224323899,
-0.1846875399,
-0.5894240737,
-0.0433357693,
-1.0080797672,
0.4151754975,
-0.0820480734,
-0.5526400208,
0.7561965585,
0.2926018536,
-0.5866048932,
-0.0411556773,
-0.4697279334,
0.884097755,
0.0134681603,
-0.4836320579,
-0.3699889779,
-0.548015058,
0.3149217963,
-0.1959920973,
0.0431338809,
-0.292229116,
0.0678880215,
0.9950279593,
-0.2296779007,
0.5680291653,
-0.120928742,
-0.2482207865,
0.2310548574,
0.1824834049,
0.4968241155,
-0.1125919595,
-0.2721772194,
0.1446476877,
0.1645611227,
-0.4179715812,
-0.4514300227,
0.4180461466,
-0.7469027638,
-0.650397718,
-0.6512573957,
-0.5290364623,
-0.079800725,
0.0621946491,
0.2473043799,
0.3097788692,
-0.2847530544,
0.0846837312,
0.7268545032,
0.0965173021,
0.5429036021,
0.3307283521,
0.1452344209,
-0.4921911657,
0.662280798,
0.1713909805,
-0.007049582,
0.0541355461,
0.302313596,
-0.3640474975,
-0.4532123804,
-0.5456404686,
0.4934797585,
-0.6251149774,
-0.1039457545,
-0.7656255364,
-0.0571705215,
-0.5836241245,
0.2275404036,
-0.376159817,
-0.3626277447,
-0.6177595258,
0.2963505983,
0.2232962549,
0.515583992,
0.0129327187,
0.6008915305,
-0.5671303272,
0.7612004876,
0.7791838646,
-0.0073932838,
0.0393908061,
-0.8391122818,
-0.3377689719,
0.1086025909,
-0.1708735228,
-0.9191675782,
0.5005260706,
0.6019518971,
0.5251699686,
-0.0137605472,
0.0600446016,
0.734085381,
-0.5518328547,
0.2487671971,
0.1890772581,
-0.9430299401,
0.369987905,
-0.0841422379,
0.6116518378,
0.2176201642,
0.1591481417,
-0.9772670269,
-0.2393016666,
-0.2565375268,
-0.2420967966,
0.5334947109,
0.3728512228,
0.1501294672,
0.232963562,
0.5796307921,
-0.0934064016,
0.0848581567,
-0.0782303736,
-0.0619133338,
-0.4158547223,
-0.2143822759,
-0.2070456594,
-0.2547517121,
0.0612803102,
-0.6826620102,
0.5749191642,
-0.1195171997,
-0.0003172922,
0.4800064564,
-0.3118187487,
-0.3063278794,
0.1647022069,
0.8007397056,
0.4217404127,
-0.14109236,
0.0274315104,
0.0158472881,
-0.7406881452,
0.5321173668,
0.1390387118,
-0.1620907784,
0.0835518166,
0.1223631129,
0.7514611483,
0.2323755175,
-0.2971040905,
0.1755364537,
-0.3619609773,
-0.0171734001,
-0.2485524416,
0.1259892583,
0.0974554196,
0.254753828,
0.2897068858,
0.2575108707,
0.3328786194,
-0.5505413413,
0.2382547259,
-0.1349181682,
-0.4874378145,
-0.4574459493,
0.9127924442,
0.3901544213,
-0.5706905723,
0.4219620526,
0.2730445266,
-0.4728412926,
0.7652193308,
0.582881093,
1.126147151,
-0.8279371262,
0.0702953562,
0.2560989857,
0.3166349232,
-0.239369005,
0.3604691029,
-0.2513389289,
-0.3483853936,
-0.1180343255,
-0.8243271708,
-0.4683952034,
0.1945784688,
-0.7139271498,
0.1220698282,
-0.3334565163,
-0.2205590904,
0.5458582044,
-0.3164197206,
-0.6937409639,
0.1377493143,
0.185541451,
1.0287688971,
-0.5030056834,
1.2155995369,
0.5644820929,
-0.3108821511,
-0.3567670584,
-0.0043905769,
-0.4253780544,
-0.3485042155,
0.2863585353,
0.2177896649,
-0.6186698079,
0.3207551837,
-0.5507256389,
-0.8722992539,
0.5253507495,
0.9879006147,
-0.99545753,
0.1092545614,
0.0431195907,
0.5248163342,
-0.1724488735,
-0.7742154002,
1.0666530132,
0.4766950905,
-0.0603188239,
-1.1064370871,
0.0358423293,
-0.1328998655,
-0.1208292618,
-0.1658066809,
-0.8316723108,
0.7911820412,
-0.5060113668,
-0.3274217844,
0.0040768352,
1.0117871761,
-0.1882774085,
0.0361544378,
0.4644933343,
0.2626728415,
0.9499821067,
0.212457329,
0.7916174531,
-0.0532977469,
-0.0662422851,
1.0372140408,
-0.2482896,
0.7637211084,
0.6391026378,
-0.0363770723,
0.2159681022,
0.7612255216,
0.277761519,
0.6824614406,
0.4450453818,
-0.131855756,
-0.3413570225,
-0.2957229018,
-0.1020779312,
0.7112756968,
0.3453779519,
0.0650933012,
0.0247458816,
0.4245749712,
-0.0745591149,
0.2254856974,
-0.5021289587,
0.7869994044,
0.4541193545,
-0.8983796239,
1.1317142248,
-0.1589271277,
0.5867421031,
-0.3498416841,
-0.0365534015,
-0.101077266,
0.4062614739,
-0.0640439764,
-0.3814558983,
0.2883377671,
-0.1104591265,
-0.3570669293,
0.256039083,
0.4556587934,
-0.6708347797,
-0.2887743711,
0.2717619538,
-0.1647662967,
0.0492540821,
-0.582190752,
-0.5479708314,
0.1885379404,
-0.3265402019,
0.040466018,
-0.065427281,
0.0757700652,
-0.3964070082,
0.8650505543,
0.6493498683,
-0.0725631341,
0.3548227549,
-0.0410485752,
0.7460156679,
-0.6102132797,
-0.7623199821,
-0.8333154917,
-0.195545733,
0.2834302485,
-0.215791747,
0.2382626683,
0.3390572965,
0.5961128473,
-0.1821269542,
0.7583430409,
0.3582279682,
0.0578986518,
-0.3828299642,
0.8902593255,
-0.2890659273,
-0.4486375451,
0.0671648905,
-0.6456241608,
-0.1980501115,
0.4957605898,
0.2226138115,
-0.5453321934,
0.6029048562,
0.3881518245,
-0.1625161618,
-0.015457754,
0.4819128811,
0.1024075598,
0.5354169607,
0.8776253462,
0.6187008619,
-0.6032684445,
0.6691661477,
-0.4119133055,
-0.1897999495,
-0.2696101665,
-0.559980154,
-0.8725273609,
-0.7925348878,
-0.3645688891,
-0.2228170484,
0.2964713871,
1.0187083483,
1.0193253756,
-0.8806896806,
-0.4153467119,
0.2644059062,
0.0774139538,
-0.4354974627,
-0.0052295388,
0.5301380754,
-0.2391307205,
-0.8095915914,
0.423838973,
0.3699935973,
0.3652991951,
-0.4013850987,
-0.1565121859,
-0.187045455,
0.2212157398,
0.445020467,
0.9329362512,
-0.6850598454,
-0.2094362676,
0.0751808286,
-0.4147061408,
0.2071513981,
0.7076600194,
-0.6449912786,
0.5327129364,
0.5823299885,
0.7299184799,
0.81816113,
-0.194813624,
0.7846153378,
-0.167964682,
0.6049354672,
0.2301298976,
0.4714228213,
0.547958672,
-0.5749496818,
0.3950684071,
0.041875042,
-0.5487818122,
-0.6070408821,
0.1276979446,
-1.0558246374,
0.2164324522,
1.0513093472,
-0.0466220267,
-1.020924449,
-0.4083045721,
-0.4764054716,
0.6338527203,
-0.4534213841,
0.9373842478,
0.551536262,
-0.0628731698,
-0.214759931,
-0.5474914312,
1.0128172636,
0.1480025053,
-0.5575515628,
0.2020886689,
0.2507179677,
0.4315240681,
0.1014943868,
0.6749976277,
0.073727347,
0.847854197,
-0.5196108222,
0.2666271031,
-0.1031485051,
-0.5530533195,
-0.6718960404,
-0.0025338489,
-0.0206603985,
-0.942235589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13188v1
|
Question Calibration and Multi-Hop Modeling for Temporal Question Answering
| 2024-02-20T17:56:24 | 2024-02-20T17:56:24 |
Chao Xue, Di Liang, Pengfei Wang, Jing Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many models that leverage knowledge graphs (KGs) have recently demonstrated
remarkable success in question answering (QA) tasks. In the real world, many
facts contained in KGs are time-constrained thus temporal KGQA has received
increasing attention. Despite the fruitful efforts of previous models in
temporal KGQA, they still have several limitations. (I) They adopt pre-trained
language models (PLMs) to obtain question representations, while PLMs tend to
focus on entity information and ignore entity transfer caused by temporal
constraints, and finally fail to learn specific temporal representations of
entities. (II) They neither emphasize the graph structure between entities nor
explicitly model the multi-hop relationship in the graph, which will make it
difficult to solve complex multi-hop question answering. To alleviate this
problem, we propose a novel Question Calibration and Multi-Hop Modeling
(QC-MHM) approach. Specifically, We first calibrate the question representation
by fusing the question and the time-constrained concepts in KG. Then, we
construct the GNN layer to complete multi-hop message passing. Finally, the
question representation is combined with the embedding output by the GNN to
generate the final prediction. Empirical results verify that the proposed model
achieves better performance than the state-of-the-art models in the benchmark
dataset. Notably, the Hits@1 and Hits@10 results of QC-MHM on the CronQuestions
dataset's complex questions are absolutely improved by 5.1% and 1.2% compared
to the best-performing baseline. Moreover, QC-MHM can generate interpretable
and trustworthy predictions.
|
[
-0.302233845,
-1.0289131403,
0.7451636791,
0.0110663427,
-0.0731015801,
0.2552753389,
0.3769852221,
-0.4380978942,
-0.0664136857,
0.5075330138,
-0.8333411217,
-0.1059186235,
-0.3341296613,
0.0716823563,
0.0444764122,
0.7905014753,
-0.1196435988,
0.0956715345,
-0.2865711749,
-0.2556795478,
-0.5333490968,
-0.5053621531,
-0.5675989985,
-0.5124579072,
0.5877448916,
0.028842587,
0.6584228277,
0.3698105216,
0.007556045,
0.1825518459,
-0.1571320295,
0.344196707,
-0.2180120945,
0.1102192625,
0.1826617867,
-0.5159193277,
-0.359074533,
0.0761295706,
0.61728549,
0.9018045068,
-0.0376760326,
0.467492342,
-0.1720902175,
0.512440443,
-0.6081579924,
0.2723869085,
-0.590400517,
0.0468620025,
0.21102193,
-0.6394301057,
-0.4281421304,
-0.6633128524,
0.2173336595,
-0.6549077034,
-0.1644509286,
0.0665989816,
0.6728826761,
0.2975797355,
-1.100881815,
-0.1615691781,
-0.8176000118,
0.6542881131,
-0.7089670897,
0.6194962263,
0.3546558022,
0.7574148178,
0.0110566458,
-0.6442014575,
-0.5730837584,
-0.1068778783,
-0.0065586958,
0.1938907504,
0.1683389544,
-0.1485977322,
0.4238184094,
-0.0194919147,
-0.7038046718,
-0.3650309443,
-0.2679392695,
-0.3624194264,
0.1460296512,
0.4253776073,
0.1282768697,
-0.2772366107,
-0.3134809434,
-0.148135379,
-0.3524516225,
0.5478910804,
0.4817549884,
0.14838624,
0.203881681,
0.5582889318,
-0.4335667193,
0.8038172722,
-0.0904952213,
-0.2649006546,
0.0800578147,
-0.4322337508,
-0.0206317734,
-0.2447432131,
0.3401338458,
0.3087750673,
0.3228666782,
-0.2660399079,
0.3896274567,
-0.2618489563,
0.1405637264,
-1.0914882421,
-0.2682287395,
0.5461156964,
-0.075061731,
-0.1613728404,
-0.1421315968,
-0.6027888656,
-0.1505383551,
-0.3505937755,
0.611933589,
-0.4351666868,
-0.157003209,
0.119399704,
-0.1354347169,
0.3346099854,
0.4540100098,
-0.2242722809,
0.0057164249,
0.3241472542,
0.4675171971,
0.6118010283,
-0.3311907351,
-0.8017903566,
0.418951422,
-0.3749484122,
0.469763279,
-0.6299055219,
-0.219119817,
-0.3543545008,
0.0299776569,
-0.4331408441,
-0.1962126195,
0.0620145015,
-1.3054456711,
0.3229817748,
-0.2953322232,
-0.5813378096,
-0.3488682806,
0.8238527179,
-0.6046532393,
0.7245689034,
0.2425546944,
-0.894765079,
0.0638977289,
-0.3790998459,
-0.1565643847,
-0.134753108,
0.0887603983,
-0.2857054472,
-0.550465405,
0.6244992018,
0.2204312384,
-0.3072805405,
0.3862888813,
-0.3872272372,
-0.1725688875,
0.394662708,
-0.3584638536,
0.9358091354,
0.3405580223,
0.2455154508,
-0.2404123694,
-0.6034568548,
0.5961685181,
0.012529809,
-0.6076767445,
-0.1311527193,
-0.0324348323,
-0.4875277877,
0.2970978022,
0.1672341079,
-0.7178721428,
0.2719519436,
-0.1997599304,
0.5542445779,
0.5079424381,
0.3794143796,
0.3531766534,
-0.6770766973,
0.8053007126,
0.1897691488,
0.3593939841,
-0.3610137999,
-0.5156903863,
-0.2355820984,
0.1655340046,
0.3473741114,
0.8318582177,
-1.0464400053,
-0.0674701557,
-0.4938784838,
-0.6319517493,
-0.4976034164,
-0.1943880916,
0.2494134754,
0.8635187745,
0.5338801742,
0.052251,
-0.1824903339,
-0.4619159997,
-0.2682499886,
-0.5614174008,
-0.1342293024,
0.6623212695,
0.387847513,
0.0431673005,
1.1162176132,
-0.7366903424,
0.2143627703,
0.0036275755,
0.4272527099,
0.26880005,
0.3363346159,
0.3886386454,
-0.9954965115,
-0.2524871528,
-0.4003161192,
-0.5043210983,
-0.0283548087,
-0.1714476943,
-0.0180588998,
-0.2828875184,
0.328368783,
-0.4889141917,
0.264033854,
0.6358107328,
-0.2943570316,
0.8885910511,
0.0331540368,
0.5831114054,
-1.2105282545,
0.0687189698,
-0.4169895649,
-0.3521713614,
-0.6787508726,
-0.0148469722,
0.3456880748,
-0.2934085131,
-0.6075989604,
0.7269245386,
-0.1615599692,
0.2030207962,
0.0599400327,
-0.0789783224,
0.5114989281,
0.6963648796,
-0.3449908197,
0.6083849669,
0.1496938169,
-0.84772259,
0.3733326495,
0.3705062568,
-0.1339206845,
0.3571592271,
-0.8079253435,
0.4429319501,
-0.3040764928,
0.6094641685,
-1.0359846354,
-0.0346465223,
0.2749607265,
-0.7164385915,
0.241838187,
-0.6856113076,
-0.5189065337,
-0.5301707983,
-0.1187636778,
1.0635672808,
0.2274039239,
-0.3515595794,
1.0156971216,
-0.0427158214,
-0.045842804,
-0.6130058765,
-0.5097279549,
-0.3922498524,
0.0029341669,
-0.8221098781,
0.2571221292,
-0.3696653247,
0.2332772464,
0.0503577627,
-0.1909784377,
-0.1996601224,
0.0487098135,
0.070404917,
0.218616873,
-0.1906448901,
0.2665481269,
-0.0172357019,
-0.0381642208,
0.0340573154,
-0.3888916969,
0.7255657315,
0.0262758154,
-0.5669128895,
-0.3251981735,
0.2273168266,
0.7692561746,
-0.4324593544,
0.803062439,
0.5799920559,
-0.3274081349,
0.2336278409,
-0.541785717,
-0.3876790106,
-0.4046969712,
0.2271061093,
-0.5544751287,
-1.0049849749,
0.6303302646,
-0.1195719391,
-0.0152186612,
0.1930784136,
0.1348292381,
-0.1565748155,
1.1101882458,
0.161654681,
-0.0113931838,
0.294569701,
-0.2671313882,
0.2362869829,
-1.0518426895,
-0.2484477609,
-0.5805354714,
-0.1683034003,
-0.5508698225,
-0.4679571688,
0.8171921968,
0.4164752364,
-0.5955332518,
0.0527277179,
0.0279601291,
0.1215995625,
0.6504638195,
0.2762875855,
0.2549464703,
-0.3750531077,
-0.4242787659,
0.1489713788,
-0.8351726532,
-0.3838763833,
1.1163328886,
0.2467814237,
0.6945191622,
-0.0470903814,
0.2225422412,
-0.0472716838,
-0.0076142312,
-0.4175912738,
0.4250830114,
0.2314581424,
-0.8938236833,
-0.5089576244,
-0.9409325719,
-0.7617728114,
0.1747542918,
-0.0549661107,
-0.7353457808,
-0.111884959,
0.1797462255,
-0.6916018724,
0.6571176052,
-0.7091175318,
0.9200489521,
-0.0768539384,
-0.0608444214,
0.1795540452,
-0.8310075402,
0.2087149173,
0.0117504755,
0.1918836236,
-0.393375814,
0.2819702327,
0.6775055528,
-0.3321863115,
0.6548085809,
-0.3057754636,
0.3236213923,
0.5406726599,
0.3199445903,
0.5906985998,
0.1858020127,
-0.1158066317,
-0.2358049601,
0.6877568364,
-0.5763596892,
-0.7559440136,
0.2280616164,
-0.8097852468,
-0.5048639178,
-0.2133211046,
-0.9461862445,
-0.664096117,
0.1573307514,
-0.0907054245,
0.8674417138,
0.167172879,
0.040485166,
0.3644784391,
-0.3810736835,
0.2488935143,
0.5535753369,
-0.3097288013,
-0.4484229386,
0.519672811,
0.1922560632,
0.4250636995,
0.7607698441,
0.3960742354,
-0.6278145909,
-0.1502494961,
-0.544226706,
0.3474124074,
-0.7259646654,
-0.2637449801,
-1.0861011744,
-0.4000970721,
-0.6968610287,
0.2568712533,
-0.2128974497,
-0.596827209,
-0.1744310409,
0.1345216334,
0.3696650267,
0.1609436423,
0.373474896,
0.3561438918,
-1.1734825373,
0.5092551708,
0.8249695301,
0.2496963143,
0.1175063699,
-0.5044481158,
0.033788532,
0.3359930217,
-0.4562217891,
-1.1356348991,
0.0644823015,
0.0666778758,
0.353520304,
0.0790373385,
0.4053762555,
0.8864042759,
-0.4230059981,
0.6574565768,
-0.0823844299,
-0.6385881305,
0.570127666,
-0.2950776517,
0.6592915058,
0.4690054953,
0.4444855452,
-0.8020341992,
-0.3633067906,
-0.4112630188,
-0.7020005584,
0.5131986141,
0.0656298101,
0.0898431093,
0.1267908365,
0.5056707859,
-0.1029647365,
0.4364602268,
-0.5502530932,
-0.3067270517,
-0.1471335888,
0.0762224942,
0.1143839136,
-0.3204080462,
0.087812908,
-0.1251500696,
0.6046037674,
-0.3012533486,
0.3205095828,
0.2135435194,
-0.0619750954,
-0.2155465782,
0.508248508,
0.0614951178,
0.8345699906,
-0.4457789063,
0.1026799232,
0.2732538283,
-0.2420845181,
0.3060173392,
0.2576579452,
-0.369618535,
-0.2894822359,
0.3448094726,
0.4679582119,
-0.0957345068,
-0.3263541162,
0.3483921587,
-0.0217558984,
-0.0406384245,
-0.0780268982,
-0.0806072727,
0.1892505586,
0.514605701,
0.405754894,
-0.0044053467,
-0.149804756,
-0.4923828542,
0.1536429971,
0.2972412109,
-0.2853142917,
-0.2310150117,
0.9652804136,
-0.1740941554,
0.0060599083,
0.8884955049,
-0.1856394559,
-0.8912763596,
0.863399744,
0.3613821268,
0.4545430541,
-0.3350380063,
0.4237139225,
0.55041641,
0.2773853838,
0.3248684406,
0.6490359306,
-0.0204686634,
-0.8285295367,
-0.6116504669,
-0.6500820518,
-0.5152690411,
0.0544516295,
-0.6363232732,
-0.1120423377,
-0.1389374137,
-0.2922686636,
-0.2025957108,
0.2336774468,
-0.844412446,
0.3864909708,
-0.2072598189,
0.8872507811,
-0.7291532755,
0.7572176456,
0.6426714659,
-0.3024020493,
-1.1165835857,
0.0538692698,
-0.2444309741,
-0.7139139175,
0.3812756836,
0.190439567,
-0.0684846714,
0.3074861467,
-0.306417942,
-0.7752328515,
1.5082490444,
0.2628472447,
-0.1526285261,
-0.3502575159,
0.4026026726,
0.3025579453,
-0.1735730916,
0.4046872258,
0.2547037601,
0.481529355,
0.4449985921,
-0.7452446818,
-0.0404057689,
-0.1820477843,
-0.250944078,
0.3115989268,
-0.6476261616,
0.9882538915,
-0.409812957,
-0.1344453394,
0.0535314605,
0.3771435618,
0.5509030819,
0.6379421353,
0.7267102003,
0.5095009208,
0.7720549107,
-0.1589131355,
1.1346254349,
-0.4587075412,
0.3608515263,
1.2185657024,
-0.1633618623,
0.5218752623,
0.4632422626,
-0.3218665719,
0.2765216529,
0.7374227643,
0.3396023214,
0.4540462494,
0.090102829,
0.0174572729,
-0.4927219152,
-0.1804268062,
-0.5575355887,
0.2566714585,
-0.0149586592,
0.1221688688,
-0.3020106256,
-0.0804651231,
-0.0884595737,
-0.3637408018,
-0.2683769464,
0.3839754164,
-0.1853816062,
-0.6925307512,
0.2368448973,
-0.0800779313,
0.0089224624,
-0.7845954895,
0.017111551,
-0.1996778846,
-0.1317614317,
0.2289097756,
-0.6123061776,
0.0610468611,
-0.2502910197,
-0.1431847215,
-0.1330618113,
0.4356122315,
-0.5018436313,
-0.5576753616,
0.2495283931,
1.0171631575,
-0.1188313141,
-0.3315877318,
-0.6080322862,
-0.4839724004,
-0.1861696839,
-0.2955919802,
-0.0355975293,
0.5387026668,
0.0800510198,
1.0393537283,
0.537111938,
0.0015936963,
0.5117756128,
0.1957226098,
0.8732652068,
-0.5873391628,
-0.719224453,
-0.4831703007,
0.4160709679,
0.3952979147,
-0.0621375106,
0.3845965862,
0.4772937,
0.7732294798,
0.1590324193,
0.4824042022,
0.0511572324,
0.7033720613,
-0.6755045652,
0.4236718118,
-0.7882370353,
0.187720269,
-0.3001235425,
-0.7178148627,
-0.0712172613,
-0.0009912502,
-0.4180789292,
0.3535217345,
0.7047143579,
0.7584653497,
0.0503019579,
0.1993820965,
0.2831257284,
0.0112445392,
0.5698855519,
0.9797549248,
1.091003418,
-0.5585964918,
1.0042545795,
-0.5736083388,
0.0373299345,
-0.0568412356,
-0.8610062599,
-0.6503435969,
-0.6050874591,
-0.3175966442,
-0.3954502642,
-0.1592571288,
0.6709692478,
0.766503036,
-0.7848439217,
0.1419345886,
0.3980487585,
0.2042546123,
-0.36408481,
-0.2362915576,
0.4696113169,
-0.156199187,
-0.4335943162,
0.136673063,
0.0419325978,
0.2940751612,
0.0677692145,
-0.0004605296,
-0.3989839256,
0.0492496453,
0.5036342144,
0.0934429094,
-0.4213662446,
-0.5196064711,
0.4220079184,
0.0475818552,
0.0349955894,
0.7984817028,
-0.7661857009,
0.7035548687,
0.489433229,
0.827778399,
0.6198458672,
0.2820899189,
0.2386296839,
-0.861243844,
-0.304027766,
0.4782791734,
0.2223581821,
0.1126513779,
-0.2217642069,
0.3513426185,
0.1374524385,
-0.6684602499,
-0.4756627977,
0.505943656,
-0.870318234,
-0.3186942041,
0.9974594116,
-0.0920902044,
-0.1856809258,
-0.2957563996,
-0.0495073833,
0.6345759034,
-0.1075507626,
0.6991466284,
0.7042965889,
-0.1347507387,
-0.1384091526,
-0.8449677229,
0.0167981759,
0.301107794,
-0.5954152346,
-0.1103504673,
0.5154392123,
0.3826487958,
0.1026493683,
0.7813468575,
-0.1722576171,
0.353235662,
-0.2592855692,
-0.4529715478,
-0.5233616829,
-0.5055413246,
0.1937641054,
0.5129715204,
-0.0322751738,
-0.36917454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13184v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13184v2
|
What if LLMs Have Different World Views: Simulating Alien Civilizations with LLM-based Agents
| 2024-02-20T17:49:46 | 2024-02-21T04:54:22 |
Mingyu Jin, Beichen Wang, Zhaoqian Xue, Suiyuan Zhu, Wenyue Hua, Hua Tang, Kai Mei, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we introduce "CosmoAgent," an innovative artificial
intelligence framework utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs) to simulate
complex interactions between human and extraterrestrial civilizations, with a
special emphasis on Stephen Hawking's cautionary advice about not sending radio
signals haphazardly into the universe. The goal is to assess the feasibility of
peaceful coexistence while considering potential risks that could threaten
well-intentioned civilizations. Employing mathematical models and state
transition matrices, our approach quantitatively evaluates the development
trajectories of civilizations, offering insights into future decision-making at
critical points of growth and saturation. Furthermore, the paper acknowledges
the vast diversity in potential living conditions across the universe, which
could foster unique cosmologies, ethical codes, and worldviews among various
civilizations. Recognizing the Earth-centric bias inherent in current LLM
designs, we propose the novel concept of using LLMs with diverse ethical
paradigms and simulating interactions between entities with distinct moral
principles. This innovative research provides a new way to understand complex
inter-civilizational dynamics, expanding our perspective while pioneering novel
strategies for conflict resolution, crucial for preventing interstellar
conflicts. We have also released the code and datasets to enable further
academic investigation into this interesting area of research. The code is
available at https://github.com/agiresearch/AlienAgent.
|
[
-0.474357754,
-0.929882288,
0.5499722362,
0.2437788844,
-0.0154562071,
0.4300153255,
-0.2764310241,
-0.7481408119,
0.3150928617,
0.4198873043,
-0.7967245579,
-0.3752889633,
-0.3316042423,
-0.0375367589,
-0.1850426346,
0.6891596913,
0.3842206597,
0.0028217018,
-0.5648283362,
0.0316284299,
-0.1788428128,
-0.5589451194,
-0.6478322148,
-0.4066068232,
0.2861116827,
0.2647762597,
1.0119974613,
0.3941360116,
0.8832267523,
0.3635492325,
-0.2971040905,
0.2440878749,
-0.6170200706,
-0.1818377972,
-0.3663907051,
-0.4524219036,
-0.206895709,
0.3227844238,
0.0728521571,
0.6207085848,
-0.082991831,
0.2252563834,
0.0019235018,
0.0596159212,
-0.1234635487,
0.10146299,
-0.4036329389,
0.3581890464,
0.3262374997,
-0.295922637,
-0.0801162943,
-0.5404954553,
0.196216017,
-0.8223959804,
-0.1044278145,
0.5707467198,
0.5680832267,
0.6087429523,
-0.1443805993,
-0.4728075862,
-0.9580596685,
0.8188591599,
-0.4608798623,
0.3061464131,
0.0494943969,
-0.0035498079,
-0.4810619354,
-0.4350863695,
-0.8656340837,
-0.6839226484,
0.1343494207,
0.4477828741,
-0.1376116723,
-0.1950909048,
0.0823754668,
0.1151715964,
-0.4491864741,
0.215340957,
-0.5120584369,
-0.0310497154,
0.5505055785,
0.2990279198,
0.3308535814,
-0.0066380352,
-0.5297920108,
-0.069976747,
-0.6564136147,
0.4420730472,
0.5100451708,
0.0585756972,
-0.4717992246,
0.5409226418,
0.3178879023,
0.1394844502,
0.1434648335,
0.1634474397,
-0.3305512965,
-0.0316257775,
-0.1848196387,
-0.0188530628,
0.563395679,
0.6911985874,
-0.1679407507,
-0.2027157992,
0.3335704505,
0.2222964466,
0.3526603281,
-0.7502346039,
-0.0283581726,
0.4302088916,
-0.5907039642,
-0.4574570358,
0.1198010892,
-0.797973156,
-0.658003211,
-0.4055655897,
0.1995579004,
-0.2987269461,
-0.3116023839,
0.0779963955,
-0.0137201194,
0.3606750965,
0.3061665595,
-0.3314889669,
0.4270943105,
0.8882246614,
0.4892182052,
-0.1604187936,
-0.4274096489,
-0.2729489803,
0.0627919361,
-0.3610308766,
0.565664649,
-0.6247026324,
-1.130302906,
-0.3508004546,
-0.2714159191,
0.2903364599,
-0.3390279412,
0.5307633281,
-0.650542438,
0.1003415138,
-0.4433373213,
-0.5744228959,
-0.4286718071,
0.5315146446,
-0.6613289118,
0.4662759304,
-0.2020858377,
-0.4438265264,
0.1521943063,
-0.8822960854,
-0.0896408409,
0.4683541656,
-0.6140845418,
-0.4906622767,
-0.1943415403,
-0.2929003537,
0.1449942738,
-0.4092762768,
0.3543109298,
-0.5866183043,
-0.4519316852,
0.492975384,
-0.2166121304,
0.7871838808,
0.4077267647,
-0.257301867,
0.0407355018,
-0.5617949963,
0.0107331071,
0.1989806443,
-0.3788506389,
-0.4093343318,
0.4510989189,
-0.1170445085,
0.1857353747,
0.4444485307,
-0.726632297,
0.0806422234,
-0.1355392337,
0.1291099042,
0.7096845508,
0.0910448357,
0.602816999,
-0.6461913586,
0.5041084886,
-0.1138340458,
0.4182406664,
0.1404188573,
-0.4360164106,
-0.7994506359,
-0.0612075292,
-0.519998014,
0.8370859027,
-0.1966217607,
0.4593834877,
-0.0746513978,
-0.5996252298,
-0.2605819702,
-0.1854645759,
0.3359846771,
0.1085866541,
0.2635712326,
0.0792942271,
-0.7717410922,
-0.4956873953,
-0.4939039648,
-0.3963693976,
0.3898454607,
0.4146150947,
0.4963183403,
-0.5617288351,
1.0931351185,
-0.1685484797,
0.1335155815,
-0.030804541,
-0.3403844833,
0.1385726184,
0.6035656929,
0.262727201,
-1.0642439127,
-0.0728237778,
0.2920969129,
-1.0205792189,
0.394208014,
-0.0513615645,
-0.0757963136,
-0.2612294257,
0.8149918914,
-0.3181301951,
0.4431155324,
0.7367113233,
-0.3732692897,
0.3175826371,
-0.3705650568,
0.3628309071,
-1.2199575901,
-0.0673877522,
-0.0006498434,
0.1039868146,
-0.4471350312,
0.3303402662,
-0.2392971516,
-0.150706917,
-0.6146230102,
0.4641364515,
-0.1510390043,
0.0703021288,
-0.1670289636,
-0.0572403036,
-0.0918124765,
0.1917592436,
-0.1565603167,
0.7600349784,
0.1387388706,
-0.6651651263,
0.4196656048,
0.4479251504,
-0.2881891727,
0.7828173637,
-0.5299677849,
0.313350141,
-0.2310498357,
0.3196909428,
-0.4278006852,
-0.0678197891,
0.2858380973,
-0.4218523502,
-0.5487653017,
-0.02616168,
-0.3051002622,
-0.3498674035,
-0.0814865753,
0.2612541914,
0.5940716267,
-0.5160748363,
0.8370180726,
0.3592171669,
-0.2515933514,
-0.5257768035,
-0.4668599069,
0.3490217626,
-0.4796189368,
-0.7442184687,
0.3651328087,
-0.5250424743,
-1.0186573267,
0.1520937681,
0.1994316578,
0.1602559239,
0.2654756904,
0.7572247982,
0.5305992365,
0.095406197,
-0.4423162937,
0.1379261613,
-0.001509569,
0.2644796371,
-0.6038089395,
0.3834683895,
-0.5029942393,
-0.4760722816,
-0.4012379944,
0.6410061121,
0.4668945968,
-0.0854785666,
0.5247965455,
0.4566080868,
-0.4272382259,
-0.0103501873,
-0.4338332117,
0.0124842655,
-0.549613893,
0.5712864399,
-0.2798912227,
-1.0306239128,
0.7966151834,
-0.3602785468,
0.254273206,
0.1052046642,
0.9104177356,
-0.1613250673,
0.4304981232,
1.037800312,
0.1457434446,
0.1521383524,
-0.3724426031,
0.3422561884,
-0.5666748881,
-0.7275729179,
-0.2491902113,
-0.1377385259,
-0.8004031777,
-0.8247861862,
0.6075076461,
-0.2429952174,
-0.1093420386,
0.0539346598,
-0.410204649,
0.9408332109,
0.3779625297,
-0.3660244644,
0.3655624092,
-0.0830405131,
-0.3027006388,
0.3757261038,
-0.3144234121,
-0.769882977,
0.6452337503,
0.1024642959,
1.0457754135,
0.4539082348,
0.6949717402,
0.544742763,
0.4853551984,
-0.6112305522,
0.6480474472,
-0.1220173165,
-0.6042393446,
0.0134166069,
-0.373711586,
-0.958355844,
0.3169185519,
-0.4100068212,
-0.5742909908,
0.3220488727,
-0.0792454779,
-0.7659417987,
0.4200259447,
-0.5927832127,
0.306858331,
-0.2047053874,
-0.4607948363,
-0.607694149,
-0.6302128434,
0.1645458192,
0.0668898672,
0.575191617,
-0.2689181566,
-0.109050937,
0.3513589501,
-0.1137520671,
0.844050467,
0.0982553586,
-0.3472073674,
0.6053679585,
0.2280354202,
0.2725007236,
0.5044351816,
-0.3251830637,
0.4063694775,
0.1168754697,
-0.1827252954,
-0.0932633877,
0.9785985947,
-1.3662070036,
-0.6625976562,
-0.3356365561,
-0.8903599381,
0.1600218415,
0.0380484276,
0.1601005048,
-0.0165558793,
-0.9676808715,
-0.1307608187,
0.4692118168,
-0.4952639043,
0.4775595665,
0.5925950408,
-0.2369024754,
-0.3200217783,
0.7618454099,
-0.1790266633,
0.0746854916,
0.3371810019,
0.2172564268,
-0.207109347,
-0.150794521,
-0.33308056,
-0.1056284159,
-0.6257090569,
0.1533109993,
-0.5591759682,
-0.17723988,
0.0512786955,
-0.4961202741,
-0.2143292427,
0.0140715847,
-0.1971266568,
0.159716785,
0.2301295847,
0.9828894138,
-0.1687770784,
0.1830691099,
-0.6429688931,
0.0078858268,
0.2348210961,
0.1077712327,
-0.1735273898,
-0.1625080258,
-0.2999716401,
0.0971250385,
-0.3566171527,
-0.2902810574,
0.2198736221,
-0.1878084242,
0.353289336,
0.1765373647,
-0.0148489056,
0.6282250285,
-0.5816120505,
0.7414164543,
0.0897132158,
-0.800014019,
-0.0235597994,
-0.4190618992,
0.0376950502,
0.3454792798,
0.1200287491,
-0.7196035385,
-0.5584463477,
-0.6219204664,
-0.5185381174,
0.3173438311,
0.1869608164,
0.25482288,
0.0984691828,
0.595146656,
0.3419586122,
-0.0619858131,
-0.6329571009,
-0.2057743222,
-0.0194818061,
-0.1431829482,
-0.0881715417,
0.3751762807,
-0.4281250834,
0.1579181403,
0.2859450579,
0.0573070869,
0.3381763399,
0.363904655,
-0.0806869417,
-0.3377734423,
0.3140076399,
0.4798043966,
0.5373176336,
-0.0817809775,
0.1465642154,
0.2335696816,
-0.6034862399,
0.4459924698,
0.2907656133,
-0.1346672624,
-0.6111949682,
-0.0394812487,
0.3479140401,
-0.4382619858,
-0.6876545548,
0.3479063809,
-0.5871422291,
-0.1710072011,
-0.9439888,
0.1836161911,
0.2073809505,
0.8748717308,
0.3712258935,
0.5159047246,
-0.07089331,
-0.4582664669,
0.118008934,
0.4012062848,
-0.2355426997,
-0.5170721412,
0.8934943676,
0.4623207748,
-0.6763539314,
0.1828252077,
-0.5849523544,
-0.3462220728,
0.9952740669,
0.388317138,
0.4784585834,
-0.0954795033,
-0.0845702589,
-0.0273696296,
0.5351322889,
0.2224749327,
0.219081983,
0.2267807871,
-0.806613028,
-0.5477108359,
-0.534358561,
-0.8917906284,
0.0513234325,
-0.2850200236,
0.2386787981,
-0.7765915394,
-0.0482206419,
-0.2206715047,
0.2461850792,
-0.7415082455,
0.1142861396,
0.504207015,
0.6565486193,
-0.4153394401,
0.497538209,
0.831066072,
-0.1080416292,
-0.5913246274,
0.3046805263,
0.3707997501,
-0.7157245278,
0.4082182944,
0.1240511164,
-0.6160651445,
0.046293702,
-0.7123393416,
-0.8931279182,
1.0604320765,
0.3471570909,
-0.5497358441,
0.2941859365,
0.1754071414,
0.4696864188,
-0.4197098017,
-0.0318322405,
0.5300495625,
0.3218185306,
-0.0301356446,
-0.5518272519,
-0.0190100111,
-0.5340494514,
-0.0954634845,
-0.0656451955,
-1.2033983469,
0.7508598566,
-0.7078565955,
0.0289714169,
0.490349263,
0.9255439043,
0.3760634661,
0.58390975,
0.6185443401,
0.4176649153,
0.7013718486,
0.2700077295,
0.8592924476,
-0.4817801118,
0.3895491958,
0.6545660496,
-0.4607472122,
0.3334326148,
0.4279419184,
-0.2673185468,
0.5583435297,
0.5776308775,
-0.1648022085,
0.1895069331,
0.214425087,
-0.4621190131,
0.000417153,
-0.27440238,
-0.1685242802,
0.691067934,
0.4835985005,
0.2099712789,
0.0995225236,
-0.1927844286,
0.1909559965,
0.150193736,
-0.0761853755,
0.5593867898,
0.2108889371,
-0.765071094,
0.0769630522,
0.0849698856,
0.826741755,
-0.3906879127,
-0.007952516,
-0.0355452672,
0.3402959704,
-0.3054563105,
-0.4888114035,
0.2128372639,
0.0615584664,
-0.055706691,
0.0306856055,
0.2455032021,
-0.2900969684,
-0.5302714705,
0.5168565512,
0.6318926811,
0.024451185,
0.5969697237,
-0.6905204654,
0.3168584704,
-0.030347066,
0.1049598008,
0.1018607467,
0.1607740819,
-0.0718953758,
0.6915299296,
0.9916062951,
-0.0283897314,
-0.0039308672,
-0.0923346877,
0.8616743684,
-0.7624985576,
-0.7531459332,
-1.0581399202,
0.1811964214,
-0.1200471148,
-0.1093258858,
0.6631011963,
0.5452406406,
0.738707006,
0.1691130102,
1.0910801888,
-0.3107069433,
0.1449476182,
-0.1118698344,
0.7070378065,
-0.3757207394,
0.3993733227,
-0.0737393647,
-0.7061104178,
-0.2001855075,
0.4486542642,
-0.2672511339,
-0.0600733906,
0.4351712763,
0.7796432972,
0.1337297857,
0.3649715483,
0.3866217136,
0.1681507826,
0.7497038245,
0.4710757136,
1.3938192129,
0.1130864546,
0.6671516299,
0.0131640965,
-0.297275722,
-0.2362682372,
-0.6702516675,
-0.8449284434,
-0.3022930026,
-0.0008998649,
-0.3695005476,
0.0489298552,
1.5240385532,
0.5519468784,
-0.2533295453,
-0.5580272675,
0.0137757147,
-0.0067744246,
0.0506763943,
-0.1955123991,
0.117470637,
0.1913612783,
-0.9092594981,
0.3968027234,
0.487347275,
0.2638844848,
-0.6295951605,
-0.2857534587,
0.2837012112,
0.5861951709,
0.5600574613,
0.2228941768,
-0.7728605866,
-0.3741160035,
0.2057410777,
-0.0051798578,
-0.0675309598,
0.7138524055,
-0.6656589508,
0.2421493232,
-0.2645100653,
0.548083365,
0.0155399777,
-0.1052094027,
0.3256720603,
-0.3361373246,
0.6514791846,
0.4031749666,
0.1138610095,
0.3070446849,
-0.7116417885,
0.2061810493,
0.0606696568,
-0.8057549,
-0.3947869241,
0.4476352334,
-0.9692229033,
-0.0978338793,
1.1474715471,
-0.1588336676,
-0.3575807214,
-0.1639861614,
-0.2380004376,
0.0570650399,
-0.500246048,
1.0866738558,
0.3342206478,
-0.3741291463,
0.3277043998,
-0.2740705907,
0.2602924407,
0.3672138155,
-1.0419796705,
-0.245100379,
0.3914299905,
0.2951997221,
0.3880445063,
0.4583708346,
-0.0124502331,
0.1598031074,
0.031964805,
0.1553766578,
-0.0821061134,
0.0455379672,
-0.0359113589,
-0.0069433949,
-0.0724251717,
0.1284139007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13178v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13178v2
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Medicine
| 2024-02-20T17:44:06 | 2024-02-23T16:46:58 |
Guangzhi Xiong, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Aidong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While large language models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance
on a wide range of medical question answering (QA) tasks, they still face
challenges with hallucinations and outdated knowledge. Retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) is a promising solution and has been widely adopted. However,
a RAG system can involve multiple flexible components, and there is a lack of
best practices regarding the optimal RAG setting for various medical purposes.
To systematically evaluate such systems, we propose the Medical Information
Retrieval-Augmented Generation Evaluation (MIRAGE), a first-of-its-kind
benchmark including 7,663 questions from five medical QA datasets. Using
MIRAGE, we conducted large-scale experiments with over 1.8 trillion prompt
tokens on 41 combinations of different corpora, retrievers, and backbone LLMs
through the MedRAG toolkit introduced in this work. Overall, MedRAG improves
the accuracy of six different LLMs by up to 18% over chain-of-thought
prompting, elevating the performance of GPT-3.5 and Mixtral to GPT-4-level. Our
results show that the combination of various medical corpora and retrievers
achieves the best performance. In addition, we discovered a log-linear scaling
property and the "lost-in-the-middle" effects in medical RAG. We believe our
comprehensive evaluations can serve as practical guidelines for implementing
RAG systems for medicine.
|
[
-0.5108987689,
-0.6202593446,
0.573885262,
0.1625196487,
-0.2564570606,
0.2386137247,
-0.0181765333,
-0.3993909657,
0.2702694833,
0.350143671,
-0.2685884237,
-0.3841182292,
-0.5081074834,
0.3669119179,
-0.3598028123,
1.246991992,
0.0394527465,
0.3763688207,
-0.2777458429,
-0.3581475616,
-0.4782042205,
-0.4776635468,
-0.796905458,
-0.1581588387,
0.6218870282,
0.0247531906,
0.7432875633,
0.4380145371,
0.7335950732,
0.1663829833,
-0.125820592,
0.4790594578,
-0.6202330589,
0.3591412008,
-0.2102707326,
-0.3116689622,
-0.3648172319,
-0.2497090995,
0.5749064088,
0.5263774395,
-0.3673509657,
0.4889741242,
-0.1703151613,
0.8805425763,
-0.8196050525,
-0.4061777592,
-0.619456768,
0.0017663444,
-0.2246651947,
-0.4677375853,
-0.1695427597,
-0.5905193686,
0.0116723003,
-0.6267290115,
0.2093684524,
0.2993792892,
0.9384148121,
0.5076034665,
-0.1734127551,
-0.2527576685,
-0.4517490566,
0.4492156506,
-0.5630182028,
0.4834072292,
0.2419659495,
0.6609187126,
-0.3491719961,
-0.9201411009,
-0.405300796,
-0.1626812518,
0.163171798,
0.1818418056,
-0.1161046997,
-0.2125763595,
0.2753280699,
0.602781713,
-0.65513587,
-0.122197412,
-0.3479312658,
0.0448501892,
0.3743996918,
0.2852743268,
0.2759016454,
-0.1563512087,
-0.4946862757,
-0.1785089225,
-0.8952479959,
-0.2668861747,
-0.2979905903,
-0.0893517509,
0.300319016,
0.6768692136,
-0.2204407603,
0.6066823006,
0.0920863748,
-0.3730009496,
0.4289577901,
-0.3401650786,
-0.2827524245,
-0.3792194426,
0.739294827,
0.4713447988,
-0.1612090766,
-0.2715396285,
-0.4099619687,
-0.1087160856,
0.5080783963,
-0.8267452121,
-0.2259979695,
0.2273519486,
-0.4109241068,
-0.3075823188,
-0.3805930614,
-0.9182825685,
-0.7718271017,
-0.1058934107,
0.7337396741,
-0.4635874033,
-0.1785014123,
0.0348634012,
-0.1493138075,
0.2270412445,
0.1189509183,
-0.5042473078,
0.6199805737,
0.8163993359,
0.6111474037,
-0.3992996812,
0.0490305983,
-0.8087487817,
-0.2175274938,
-0.5996677279,
1.0347648859,
-0.2983407974,
-0.4427185953,
-0.137332961,
-0.4855629206,
-0.0955311954,
-1.3232330084,
0.6935718656,
-0.5439071655,
0.3410284817,
-0.3383871019,
-0.5302437544,
0.1108867228,
0.4591312408,
-0.4870078564,
1.3006497622,
0.2570632994,
-0.7398047447,
0.6314781308,
-0.3497848809,
-0.1243332028,
0.2570385337,
-0.4857489467,
-0.4852388203,
0.1974705458,
0.4508648813,
0.2165704519,
-0.7851893902,
0.2616193295,
0.0441372991,
-0.4611188471,
0.3771379888,
-0.4030226767,
0.3674423397,
0.3437532783,
-0.2939274311,
-0.146491006,
-0.8221618533,
0.2738384306,
0.0278166533,
-0.4659259319,
-0.303978622,
-0.1197702736,
-0.0340633951,
0.2617060542,
0.1690489352,
-0.4061600268,
0.0362998322,
-0.4752933085,
-0.2826336026,
0.3962294459,
0.4227900803,
-0.0857087672,
-0.7385598421,
0.6883772016,
-0.1029253528,
0.2155873924,
0.0953169763,
-0.4700007141,
-0.5989943743,
-0.4153768718,
0.4810915589,
0.5189117789,
-1.0853718519,
0.0225101113,
-0.145589903,
-0.4822750092,
-0.9246252179,
0.0074839559,
0.7006547451,
0.7159090638,
0.5502300262,
-0.2441615015,
-0.3537985086,
-0.9208579063,
-0.5210233331,
-0.1220953837,
-0.1637021899,
0.6890639067,
0.205142647,
-0.2816100121,
0.5011895895,
-0.3564067781,
0.0817195848,
0.1019964814,
-0.020839259,
0.3582895398,
0.1171063632,
0.3638339341,
-0.8077551126,
-0.31854707,
-0.0159129687,
-0.5685517192,
-0.3829680383,
0.1612485051,
-0.2305149734,
0.0504729114,
0.1474067867,
-0.2740867436,
0.3176144063,
0.654807508,
-0.265304029,
0.7219184041,
-0.4132598937,
0.5620816946,
-1.1038188934,
0.480160147,
-0.2480581254,
-0.131915018,
-0.5432606339,
0.1786964536,
0.1123763546,
-0.0047788383,
-0.2744895518,
0.7323740125,
-0.3521095216,
-0.2164421082,
-0.2752833068,
0.1807546318,
0.0621089041,
0.0711392537,
-0.3751410842,
1.1392165422,
0.2224989682,
-0.5810764432,
0.1066410691,
0.0645903572,
-0.3577817976,
0.824213922,
-0.6181054115,
0.1171421409,
-0.1119293198,
0.1099118665,
-0.8490191102,
-0.0914458707,
-0.0254768878,
-0.4034029841,
0.3360618651,
0.1992675066,
-0.6624355316,
-0.4399185777,
-0.206973359,
0.5461643934,
0.6877853274,
-0.573826313,
0.4234232008,
0.4793950021,
-0.1472903341,
-0.7541467547,
0.0299370419,
0.2413439006,
-0.2045120746,
-0.2971212566,
0.137746647,
0.0073435889,
-0.302339375,
-0.1910174489,
-0.3073170781,
0.0194063932,
-0.0424418859,
0.1471588165,
0.3901990652,
-0.2277751267,
0.2862583399,
0.1810372323,
-0.1560963541,
-0.0493447147,
-0.0322760716,
0.5482481718,
-0.0072109667,
-0.2778590322,
0.0636567175,
0.1187854707,
0.5441948771,
-0.3646903932,
0.4178809822,
0.4206637144,
-0.3435844481,
-0.117396608,
-0.9036140442,
-0.0061481227,
-0.4291334748,
0.3538505137,
-0.3802723587,
-0.5646726489,
0.2819099724,
-0.3576208055,
0.1753423661,
0.6552144885,
0.7357198,
-0.0229438674,
0.9227208495,
0.133959651,
0.1906013936,
-0.0921873599,
-0.0492025502,
-0.0909904763,
-1.1005735397,
-0.4079822302,
-0.5156107545,
-0.2772905529,
-0.5279866457,
-0.7576720715,
1.168897748,
0.2046246976,
-0.1174967661,
-0.1056612954,
-0.6782810092,
0.3069088757,
0.3774350882,
0.2900863886,
0.4126048982,
-0.0891368091,
-0.4685992599,
0.0996637493,
-0.7577846646,
-0.4442109466,
1.3624577522,
0.2244075239,
0.6751207113,
-0.0666283295,
0.8137148619,
0.0322513022,
0.7230837345,
-0.4197744429,
0.5359384418,
-0.3147959411,
-0.734147191,
-0.007340203,
-0.5643184781,
-1.0674562454,
0.4935637116,
-0.5920000672,
-0.3566381335,
-0.0222716928,
0.0086911181,
-0.4724120498,
0.1973364204,
-0.3700930476,
0.4171329439,
-0.1494726986,
-0.3170198202,
-0.039049387,
-0.5529891849,
0.3197393417,
-0.3300522864,
0.2183175534,
-0.0942339525,
-0.4581563771,
0.6885154843,
-0.3253422678,
0.1800441444,
-0.1288506687,
0.0428204164,
0.0851959214,
0.0679346547,
0.213972643,
-0.0436564274,
-0.1280216724,
-0.0891281366,
0.3406203985,
-0.2425035983,
-0.6216377616,
0.6623463631,
-0.512656033,
-0.4240233898,
-0.3200882375,
-0.5890703797,
-0.5767572522,
0.2236059308,
0.3772618175,
0.5932353139,
-0.3792225122,
0.0762690082,
0.7739806175,
-0.534771204,
-0.1873915344,
0.4573006928,
-0.6153912544,
-0.7719790936,
0.8665378094,
0.0939515531,
0.1583041549,
0.3126911521,
0.2969829142,
-0.2920238972,
-0.6253450513,
-0.8162315488,
0.3905487955,
-0.4336117208,
-0.3981308937,
-0.7263177633,
-0.1821359545,
-0.0709885806,
0.1879712194,
-0.2434977293,
-0.2479796708,
-0.0231994111,
0.3388984203,
0.2493469268,
0.854496479,
0.1264567822,
-0.2247410566,
-0.772626996,
0.7078319192,
0.1504094899,
0.5369530916,
-0.2045843154,
-0.4293038249,
-0.1278171092,
-0.1582594812,
-0.3507466614,
-0.7620481253,
0.2557016611,
0.1019059196,
0.6227238178,
0.2175377756,
-0.1214964241,
0.6801576018,
-0.7723590732,
0.698436439,
0.0639639497,
-0.3530348539,
0.3421376944,
-0.2769123018,
0.2792869508,
0.7966992259,
0.2581300139,
-0.3928680122,
-0.4883540273,
-0.7168675065,
-0.8120411634,
-0.0166106056,
0.1132384315,
-0.2643931508,
-0.2940107584,
0.5475540161,
0.1978999525,
0.2460284531,
-0.0148520628,
-0.3404134512,
0.4014710784,
-0.2252636403,
0.0088574998,
-0.2212547511,
-0.3198767304,
-0.0048608459,
0.5417131186,
0.1175477356,
0.1314935535,
0.3323791325,
0.2640052736,
-0.1478783488,
0.2695106566,
0.5759120584,
0.8421679139,
-0.0419105329,
-0.0049705184,
0.3782412708,
-0.6714657545,
0.1290939152,
0.2444711924,
-0.1444577426,
0.1321438253,
0.0136156455,
0.353946656,
0.1923615336,
-0.9942377806,
0.4052052796,
-0.0718095154,
-0.1199350134,
0.058262486,
0.1335250288,
-0.1810577065,
0.2593051493,
0.5554176569,
0.008518395,
0.5124306679,
-0.3028171062,
0.4066856205,
0.4499246776,
-0.0016040043,
0.1108911633,
0.7298931479,
-0.09970548,
-0.2458150983,
0.3364861608,
0.0384819694,
-0.3324936628,
0.4040660262,
0.5425814986,
0.6484039426,
-0.1650779247,
0.0200198982,
0.4404053986,
0.1104594767,
-0.1734228432,
0.4700586498,
0.1009223163,
-0.2195574343,
-0.3903491497,
-0.7382404208,
-0.6003749967,
-0.0158409122,
-0.7287957072,
0.0756917149,
-0.2985173166,
-0.434086442,
-0.0373395532,
0.1556478739,
-0.7354648709,
0.3634052277,
-0.1496085078,
1.0409103632,
-0.3842769861,
0.3544996083,
0.7304742932,
-0.1547506899,
-0.7784961462,
-0.061779812,
-0.1014175564,
-0.8845630288,
0.4436971843,
-0.2078405619,
-0.1343929023,
-0.2549753785,
-0.3137747347,
-0.8038306832,
1.0360198021,
0.1149242818,
-0.4534440339,
0.0121240662,
-0.1756878346,
0.9061593413,
-0.2394636124,
0.2100990266,
0.6239562035,
0.1284011751,
0.1150851771,
-1.2908143997,
-0.0031505297,
-0.4292683899,
0.0366904251,
0.415268302,
-0.4905642569,
0.7899667025,
-0.2519356012,
-0.2925946116,
0.4392751455,
0.244131282,
0.8580392599,
0.629447937,
0.3424569666,
0.7379573584,
0.9208749533,
-0.1069427952,
1.4114387035,
-0.4564032853,
0.0407916568,
0.8992940187,
-0.2147728503,
1.1197427511,
0.4518652558,
-0.2607173026,
0.4440819621,
0.3198317885,
0.2698220015,
0.403781414,
0.50992167,
-0.4909987748,
0.1525057703,
-0.1029405668,
-0.6984139681,
0.0537200607,
0.4473511577,
-0.5432887077,
-0.1391088516,
0.0967224762,
0.0355213657,
0.0112316236,
-0.2796798646,
1.1164432764,
-0.0923577026,
-0.8602677584,
1.0252623558,
-0.3261156976,
0.4024281502,
-0.2949215174,
-0.1887310743,
-0.3357871473,
0.1000499502,
-0.1344486028,
-0.5700906515,
-0.1013545468,
0.1664295048,
0.0319291167,
0.2231349647,
0.665255487,
-0.3144613802,
-0.5170238018,
-0.1063165888,
0.7085191607,
0.4074234664,
0.1430302858,
-0.6387560368,
0.0652145967,
-0.2738178074,
-0.1471129507,
0.3961646855,
0.5792527199,
0.1021151543,
0.7144706249,
0.5782198906,
0.5472691059,
0.1646752656,
0.0246603936,
1.1668747663,
-0.4481939375,
-0.0014915821,
-0.4112848341,
0.2643738985,
-0.1257179379,
-0.5131534338,
0.6509541273,
0.8408944011,
0.4104983509,
0.2465860993,
0.4880290926,
0.1119795442,
1.0772026777,
-0.3702626526,
0.8024017811,
-0.7839534283,
0.3156509697,
-0.2612700164,
-0.9471560121,
-0.3081391454,
0.2807879746,
-0.1466418505,
0.1551328003,
0.5961402059,
0.7257395983,
0.241980046,
-0.2368064225,
0.4221090972,
0.117978096,
0.2377277613,
0.5275490284,
0.701982975,
-0.615898788,
0.4305063188,
-0.1066675931,
-0.420494467,
-0.10461808,
-0.4287583232,
-0.5493982434,
-0.4347415864,
0.0408576503,
-0.7530757189,
0.3855468035,
0.8978120685,
0.4440586567,
-0.5452717543,
-0.0113402931,
0.3227480948,
-0.2351491302,
-0.3032208979,
-0.1485931575,
0.4694640934,
-0.5372732282,
-0.4490869343,
0.4186299443,
0.4234553874,
-0.2506875396,
-0.2983081639,
0.0641217828,
-0.0705405101,
0.111969173,
0.5580727458,
0.3513307571,
-0.6217649579,
-0.056055095,
0.2545873225,
-0.4019140303,
0.0787040591,
0.72814399,
-1.1082341671,
0.702437222,
0.3279156983,
0.9464846253,
0.3938236833,
0.3202584684,
0.4298815429,
-0.4635972977,
-0.4349335134,
0.6054481864,
0.1429865956,
0.2626068592,
-0.1420174241,
0.6756585836,
-0.0891792178,
-0.8932122588,
-0.9541128278,
-0.256595701,
-0.6180049777,
-0.1308919936,
1.1448340416,
0.2223457843,
-0.0046723573,
-0.1377187222,
-0.5427264571,
0.1226991862,
-0.0355380438,
0.9397155643,
0.3081548512,
-0.3009712398,
0.0061955028,
-0.7865177989,
0.6767925024,
0.6268532872,
-1.0124254227,
-0.1783996522,
0.5495433211,
0.3690448105,
0.1284305155,
0.9184460044,
-0.4590171874,
0.5876925588,
-0.0295859128,
-0.089669086,
0.1665734202,
-0.2301214337,
-0.2876663804,
0.2370591909,
0.1012350395,
-0.1395963132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14857v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14857v2
|
Is the System Message Really Important to Jailbreaks in Large Language Models?
| 2024-02-20T17:39:40 | 2024-06-18T19:22:19 |
Xiaotian Zou, Yongkang Chen, Ke Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) has rendered them
indispensable in modern society. While security measures are typically to align
LLMs with human values prior to release, recent studies have unveiled a
concerning phenomenon named "Jailbreak". This term refers to the unexpected and
potentially harmful responses generated by LLMs when prompted with malicious
questions. Most existing research focus on generating jailbreak prompts but
system message configurations vary significantly in experiments. In this paper,
we aim to answer a question: Is the system message really important for
jailbreaks in LLMs? We conduct experiments in mainstream LLMs to generate
jailbreak prompts with varying system messages: short, long, and none. We
discover that different system messages have distinct resistances to
jailbreaks. Therefore, we explore the transferability of jailbreaks across LLMs
with different system messages. Furthermore, we propose the System Messages
Evolutionary Algorithm (SMEA) to generate system messages that are more
resistant to jailbreak prompts, even with minor changes. Through SMEA, we get a
robust system messages population with little change in the length of system
messages. Our research not only bolsters LLMs security but also raises the bar
for jailbreaks, fostering advancements in this field of study.
|
[
-0.3144071102,
-0.5841433406,
0.5770174265,
0.2385036051,
-0.3756136894,
0.1163663119,
-0.071942471,
-0.6806644797,
0.4574916959,
0.6328313947,
-0.4526534081,
-0.0240583289,
-0.6676279306,
0.0434754118,
-0.4954916239,
1.127800703,
0.0156917181,
-0.0841836035,
0.1065909863,
-0.0494918674,
-0.8173883557,
-0.7458834648,
-0.325617671,
-0.0773972124,
0.4535343945,
0.3700252175,
0.3337314725,
0.6018519998,
0.6021265388,
0.2586223185,
-0.4210003912,
-0.0493496694,
-0.5390581489,
0.6384571195,
-0.2151624709,
-0.5851251483,
-0.2657300234,
-0.37217924,
0.4192634523,
0.5058276057,
0.1364988536,
0.1406096816,
-0.0111707123,
0.8543687463,
-0.6239102483,
-0.2721448243,
-0.6738497615,
-0.1366958469,
-0.3804374039,
-0.094512552,
-0.4365672469,
-0.2070844769,
-0.1015380919,
-0.1386152506,
-0.278726995,
0.1309277266,
0.4974392951,
-0.0680746064,
-0.2026663423,
-0.4888851047,
-0.7401755452,
0.657767117,
-0.8246301413,
0.1562097669,
-0.0788049921,
0.3034296632,
-0.6075282693,
-0.1955670714,
-0.2553212643,
-0.5359149575,
0.1462774426,
-0.3845466673,
-0.1657827049,
-0.0495484844,
0.131049335,
-0.0077752727,
-0.193416968,
0.4420908689,
-0.693043232,
-0.2586941719,
0.5509285331,
0.4379331768,
0.6874083281,
-0.2013407499,
-0.2942609787,
-0.0417397767,
-1.1642386913,
-0.1023849174,
0.3990807831,
0.2437373549,
-0.2810808718,
0.2265823483,
0.1881823093,
0.5360596776,
-0.1517542601,
-0.188785404,
-0.0307906102,
-0.1139612198,
-0.0789491162,
0.2842858434,
0.8801060319,
0.2827335298,
0.1834926903,
-0.1512993723,
-0.185809657,
-0.0749841332,
0.1105100363,
-0.7827709317,
0.1991168559,
0.259044826,
-0.3281866908,
-0.5692952275,
0.4065694809,
-0.8335288167,
-0.7020007372,
0.336001873,
0.1315410882,
-0.2711896896,
-0.1229542419,
0.0864546746,
-0.1758615971,
0.0026074296,
0.4437929988,
-1.2008559704,
0.171012491,
0.8077943325,
0.7820357084,
-0.0396412164,
-0.27797997,
-0.6151790023,
0.2404151708,
-0.3729449511,
0.5769390464,
-0.3485571444,
-0.5451925397,
-0.2883694768,
0.1814177334,
-0.0012582171,
-0.5127135515,
0.2577227056,
-0.5345622301,
-0.232276544,
-0.0889090225,
-0.5159285069,
0.2399065644,
-0.0430938639,
-0.4898658395,
0.3685972393,
-0.3726282716,
-0.590413034,
0.0946661085,
-0.5454964042,
-0.6527020335,
0.0929629356,
0.0874598995,
-0.3410854638,
0.4025927782,
0.0322541445,
0.5243231654,
-0.1623875499,
0.3631100953,
-0.621250093,
-0.4908283055,
0.5558801889,
-0.3037094772,
0.6092174053,
0.6507579088,
-0.6565044522,
-0.2237332761,
-0.4316582382,
-0.10705024,
0.3105369806,
-0.4949673116,
-0.4597285688,
0.2340021282,
-0.190867722,
-0.1042267233,
0.4288997352,
-0.6900485158,
0.3863765001,
-0.4212506115,
0.8654540181,
1.0389826298,
0.1439201236,
0.4474900663,
-0.0148531049,
0.4317460358,
-0.1216756254,
0.260553509,
-0.4691803455,
-0.4290902019,
-0.1793831885,
-0.14447923,
-0.0776615962,
0.7454633117,
0.0229754988,
0.2993968129,
0.0550217368,
-0.5895493627,
-0.1091857851,
0.1689970195,
0.4390605986,
-0.0816288963,
-0.113484174,
-0.1215100661,
-0.639312923,
-0.8544209599,
-0.4228931665,
-0.5229326487,
0.3416538835,
0.2736645639,
0.3369680643,
-0.3709405065,
0.4672468603,
-0.4399803579,
0.3696205318,
-0.6850055456,
-0.3312934041,
0.1815495491,
0.3395287693,
0.7730646729,
-0.302983284,
-0.1057041213,
-0.1969101578,
-0.8061704636,
-0.4251299202,
-0.3102258444,
0.0931873098,
-0.1347203553,
0.7312479019,
-0.6333557367,
0.2451948673,
0.6792341471,
-0.5915381908,
0.7365108132,
-0.331579417,
0.0836770236,
-0.9826830029,
-0.2016568482,
-0.1006315872,
-0.1897743046,
-0.8179920316,
0.4748883545,
0.0601707473,
-0.0522558056,
-0.5255222321,
0.6021690965,
-0.3757339418,
-0.2424594909,
-0.4163058698,
0.2178215683,
-0.2638432086,
-0.3185195327,
-0.6065886021,
0.7901339531,
0.5230770707,
-0.5561330318,
0.4286700189,
0.0484083705,
-0.4025658071,
0.2807153761,
-0.4794743061,
0.2678380311,
-0.01926676,
0.1188226193,
-0.8618820906,
-0.1624102294,
0.1743845046,
-0.2146927714,
0.0487632528,
0.0927764624,
-0.4091751277,
-0.4343259633,
-0.1588393301,
-0.1280904561,
0.397742033,
-0.5686144233,
-0.0371916704,
0.4506024718,
-0.1293227822,
-0.2528222799,
-0.6766458154,
0.5421828628,
-0.4824058414,
-0.7893733978,
-0.1755960435,
-0.2051646113,
-0.5909834504,
-0.5293810964,
-0.2157803625,
0.3022181392,
0.8420913815,
0.5485163331,
0.4193084836,
-0.2012004256,
0.1130897254,
0.2213362157,
0.0610124618,
0.3313845992,
-0.2742118835,
0.5285496116,
-0.3976485133,
-0.1130122095,
-0.3420693576,
0.3254604638,
0.9138660431,
0.0087335352,
1.0740001202,
-0.0184447654,
0.0182627682,
-0.2756824493,
-0.3114399016,
-0.3971152604,
-0.4774918854,
0.3535931408,
-0.3001582623,
-1.2030670643,
0.4567777216,
-0.153912738,
-0.0416775905,
-0.0015941308,
0.4155845642,
-0.2039681971,
0.9449215531,
0.6722872257,
-0.5098109841,
0.6537376046,
0.2807019949,
0.340046823,
-0.6111288071,
0.0120421126,
-0.7036532164,
-0.282333672,
-0.6269701719,
0.2422968298,
0.0610884912,
0.3418096006,
-0.3603244424,
0.5229785442,
-0.5450238585,
0.4693262875,
0.1056600139,
0.0220787078,
0.3446967006,
-0.0941661596,
-0.0242593531,
0.1449385136,
-0.3641889393,
-0.7596849203,
1.1424894333,
0.4947581291,
1.0272901058,
0.1719457358,
1.1130516529,
0.3894448578,
0.4364934266,
-0.3199580312,
0.8520200849,
-0.0308193825,
-0.7055819035,
-0.1580550373,
-0.4603734016,
-0.9710895419,
0.1883980483,
-0.086888887,
-1.2958883047,
-0.005816373,
0.0288209394,
-0.4347812235,
0.4321152568,
-0.7435631752,
0.6153212786,
-0.3664031923,
0.1792215258,
-0.1066697314,
-0.8550397754,
0.5076748133,
-0.1869959384,
0.7539097071,
-0.2709094882,
0.1362310052,
0.761785686,
-0.7134578228,
0.7835703492,
-0.2019249052,
-0.2025114149,
0.2420521379,
0.3900063932,
0.7097870708,
0.2208002061,
0.0843234807,
-0.1807260066,
0.1746539921,
-0.1657344401,
-0.378991425,
0.8738772869,
-0.8826331496,
-1.0956587791,
-0.2552358806,
-0.4217086434,
0.0375605337,
0.1232611388,
0.1863519251,
0.2064318806,
0.158609733,
0.1345935166,
0.7404063344,
-0.2883535922,
0.3794164062,
0.2607781887,
-0.5951125622,
-0.2487215102,
0.725364387,
-0.1373046339,
0.6573869586,
-0.0882273614,
0.3722571433,
0.4908802807,
-0.822817862,
-0.6019377708,
0.3151184022,
-0.553272903,
-0.1423200071,
-0.6278796196,
-0.1430639476,
-0.1437327713,
-0.3714119792,
-0.1996646374,
-0.3066775203,
-0.3705027401,
-0.3071495593,
0.4111601114,
0.9070346355,
-0.1863860488,
0.4132033885,
-1.1677104235,
0.2810907066,
0.1447407454,
0.0616655536,
-0.1164567322,
-0.6225501895,
-0.2096117735,
0.0244196244,
-0.0494713373,
-1.3644704819,
0.140293628,
0.1016531661,
0.5262287259,
0.3420805633,
-0.1037332639,
0.4219075441,
-0.3443457186,
0.7477458119,
0.2341293544,
-0.8814673424,
0.7583461404,
-0.4313188493,
0.152797997,
0.4071885347,
-0.2408971637,
-0.7956572175,
-0.9076641202,
-0.3338229656,
-0.7825281024,
0.6163645387,
-0.1670631617,
0.7282425165,
-0.1855613291,
0.5734519362,
0.1120732501,
0.187793076,
-0.673813343,
-0.2383780777,
0.1949745566,
0.0108472565,
0.228845492,
-0.2611469626,
0.0860867202,
0.0487828553,
0.3456340134,
0.2969648242,
0.1162547991,
-0.052202452,
-0.0843739286,
-0.2140810192,
0.7705531716,
0.6184365153,
0.2564367056,
-0.1753826141,
-0.0279299188,
0.1667979658,
-0.8471016884,
0.5560122132,
-0.386202246,
-0.31100896,
-0.3059308827,
0.2275713533,
1.0151083469,
-0.0780712217,
-1.0033801794,
0.4438484311,
0.0680163503,
-0.1701809168,
0.0665977076,
0.3944619,
0.0922518224,
0.2959098816,
0.4426716864,
0.2459276766,
-0.1311967373,
-0.9880865812,
0.034577243,
0.4041751027,
-0.3413220942,
-0.3848519623,
0.626873076,
0.0836506635,
-0.4104997814,
0.5222992897,
-0.1867425889,
-0.4423988163,
0.7265407443,
0.9773362279,
0.7950710654,
-0.4163343608,
0.3137823343,
-0.0748849958,
0.7764353156,
-0.4424043894,
0.0673987567,
0.2194073796,
-0.6233045459,
-0.3765707314,
-0.7065246701,
-0.4263085425,
0.1182170659,
-0.3402131796,
0.2960667312,
-0.7839252353,
-0.0843429789,
-0.2520968914,
-0.6798689365,
-0.0320375152,
0.1372379661,
0.4955479801,
1.035240531,
-0.9124618173,
0.5798344016,
0.6319238544,
0.2283156216,
-0.8536980748,
-0.2024305165,
0.0879038721,
-0.4741109312,
0.7915457487,
0.3686715066,
-0.040021088,
-0.2867706418,
-0.880735755,
-0.9918761253,
0.6893028021,
0.5952679515,
-0.879622817,
0.0529088192,
0.0195834786,
0.5061271787,
-0.582087636,
-0.0971238837,
0.7188467979,
0.4910130799,
-0.0745295957,
-0.8019927144,
0.2773554027,
-0.1254981458,
-0.019834144,
0.7100973129,
-0.6187462211,
0.6269155741,
-0.7359079123,
-0.1806723028,
0.325546205,
0.3694788516,
0.7114025354,
0.2167909145,
0.3593720496,
0.4318648577,
0.5072433352,
-0.1225751564,
0.9682287574,
-0.2445720285,
0.0821516961,
0.835760355,
-0.4121315181,
0.7679530978,
0.7268738747,
-0.1343397349,
0.5990941525,
0.4533871114,
0.020023305,
0.433244139,
0.6396126151,
-0.117861703,
-0.2435994148,
0.437627852,
-0.3667083681,
0.2467896044,
0.518766582,
-0.3732453287,
-0.2005822212,
0.5535677075,
0.4303911328,
-0.028018713,
-0.3628149927,
0.7995594144,
0.3831377327,
-0.4370966554,
0.504730463,
0.1725884527,
0.5721072555,
-0.3470240235,
0.402064085,
-0.4013369977,
0.0686700866,
-0.2797890902,
-0.6004755497,
0.1780036092,
0.2730641365,
0.0560744219,
-0.0853050426,
0.9628617764,
0.2442396134,
-0.0912899077,
0.4356595576,
0.3174664974,
0.3704825342,
-0.0593156517,
-0.4977813661,
0.390660584,
0.1032519788,
-0.4824572802,
0.5880250931,
0.1625893265,
-0.1883954406,
0.9000953436,
0.7568635345,
0.4808427393,
0.4155840874,
-0.1274168789,
1.0804548264,
-0.7919715643,
-0.6723225713,
-1.3008778095,
0.3947584629,
0.0328282639,
0.0069680065,
0.832990706,
0.1702088565,
0.3100434542,
0.0874284282,
1.1378513575,
-0.1380681843,
0.210445866,
-0.4200021327,
0.6766707897,
-0.2737695873,
0.9644586444,
-0.3813834488,
-1.0219023228,
-0.0433984846,
0.098743923,
-0.5836022496,
-0.1958294064,
0.5886423588,
0.4477873743,
0.3307990432,
0.2877808213,
0.1260630339,
0.1329992563,
0.4781601727,
0.6251451969,
0.9471728802,
-0.4118028581,
0.7025486231,
0.3287466466,
-0.3702312708,
-0.3810773194,
-0.5993279815,
-0.8158893585,
-0.1556373686,
-0.1230926663,
-0.5488596559,
0.6013567448,
0.8088382483,
0.2869693935,
-0.7766980529,
-0.507167995,
-0.2699962854,
0.1732725352,
-0.021670796,
-0.185439229,
-0.2570307255,
-0.3311447501,
-0.0389079973,
0.5242572427,
0.8327780962,
0.1966332495,
-0.3752272725,
-0.0765705183,
0.1056762338,
0.2639562488,
0.417360574,
0.4621429443,
-0.4014678299,
-0.5076432824,
0.1537679732,
-0.404681474,
0.0367723145,
0.7437161803,
-0.418422699,
0.1877551228,
0.4295522869,
0.5348650813,
0.2853057981,
-0.408806026,
0.5741310716,
-0.4728206098,
0.1798337698,
-0.0974528641,
0.5686964989,
0.3174861968,
-0.485154599,
0.0439692251,
0.3006156981,
-0.7298921347,
-1.1068123579,
0.5883831382,
-0.4015981853,
-0.5014359951,
1.3342847824,
-0.0944451243,
-0.668217361,
-0.1896456182,
-0.3344301581,
-0.3644461036,
-0.500567019,
0.7081959248,
0.7475403547,
0.1980525553,
-0.354065299,
-0.5331602693,
0.1627871394,
0.2878716588,
-1.0416404009,
0.2041561604,
0.2590070665,
0.3560045362,
0.2718831897,
0.3664726317,
-0.2347534746,
0.3121384978,
-0.2145261765,
-0.1168523878,
0.0283964928,
-0.2605884373,
-0.1962875873,
0.2953861952,
0.2571601272,
0.1616737247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13152v1
|
AnnoTheia: A Semi-Automatic Annotation Toolkit for Audio-Visual Speech Technologies
| 2024-02-20T17:07:08 | 2024-02-20T17:07:08 |
José-M. Acosta-Triana, David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
More than 7,000 known languages are spoken around the world. However, due to
the lack of annotated resources, only a small fraction of them are currently
covered by speech technologies. Albeit self-supervised speech representations,
recent massive speech corpora collections, as well as the organization of
challenges, have alleviated this inequality, most studies are mainly
benchmarked on English. This situation is aggravated when tasks involving both
acoustic and visual speech modalities are addressed. In order to promote
research on low-resource languages for audio-visual speech technologies, we
present AnnoTheia, a semi-automatic annotation toolkit that detects when a
person speaks on the scene and the corresponding transcription. In addition, to
show the complete process of preparing AnnoTheia for a language of interest, we
also describe the adaptation of a pre-trained model for active speaker
detection to Spanish, using a database not initially conceived for this type of
task. The AnnoTheia toolkit, tutorials, and pre-trained models are available on
GitHub.
|
[
-0.6595730782,
-0.8882799149,
0.2616404295,
0.2334267646,
-0.3037116528,
-0.141994521,
-0.3849667907,
-0.8817929029,
0.5575283766,
0.4428662062,
-0.4353781343,
-0.4625791311,
-0.2295314074,
0.246473372,
-0.5115715265,
0.4762466252,
0.1294730753,
-0.0949766189,
0.0303072892,
-0.1069806069,
-0.2624674737,
-0.0684130564,
-0.487251848,
-0.0034564824,
0.2349267602,
0.6189742088,
0.4997158647,
0.6070760489,
0.1775595248,
0.4354988635,
0.1532222331,
0.2623383701,
0.0460344069,
0.1723235101,
0.0062731779,
-0.309577018,
-0.2342964709,
-0.0200736299,
0.64530164,
0.4765397608,
-0.0075672604,
0.5898115635,
-0.2446318567,
-0.0654973984,
-0.488122642,
0.2676356733,
-0.396653384,
0.1442119628,
-0.5621756315,
-0.4547626376,
-0.102751106,
-0.1912001222,
0.4107523859,
-0.8249850273,
0.0457577966,
0.1450413018,
0.5765616894,
0.7446078658,
-0.0436453559,
-0.2212923765,
-0.7625212073,
0.5661011934,
-0.3549957275,
0.4347731173,
0.6819095016,
0.5007399917,
0.0241591632,
-0.6723078489,
-0.7755434513,
-0.3699351847,
0.1670598388,
-0.1510738432,
-0.549353838,
-0.0366808213,
0.235399425,
0.2995330989,
-0.4238546789,
0.3778102994,
-0.451905787,
-0.6479007006,
0.326458931,
-0.500808239,
0.5346184969,
-0.3314345181,
-0.1083098203,
-0.0962927416,
-0.312622875,
-0.2038524002,
0.4583269656,
0.3742227852,
-0.2985603511,
0.5493741035,
-0.0162106697,
1.0684183836,
-0.3592661023,
-0.3042945564,
0.6026409268,
-0.0179838799,
-0.2270615399,
0.4245639741,
0.7653508782,
0.0123944087,
0.4243343771,
0.0228489712,
-0.1107698753,
0.3752119243,
0.0224996135,
-0.4707013667,
-0.4232344627,
0.078834556,
-0.0671579912,
-0.1874686182,
-0.1476553082,
-0.5168013573,
-0.3200759888,
-0.3624135256,
0.565027535,
-0.1432784945,
-0.3229047358,
-0.1140456051,
-0.1322937608,
-0.2226081192,
0.3542334437,
-0.640401721,
0.2493935227,
0.1190007031,
0.8705479503,
0.1084961519,
-0.3870313168,
-0.8506297469,
-0.0633772537,
-0.2132001966,
0.9923790693,
-0.4254293144,
-0.3049103916,
0.1024812162,
0.1767830253,
0.1865270585,
-0.543526113,
0.6300333142,
-0.0069308141,
0.4358939528,
-0.094695963,
-0.3200056553,
-0.2227029353,
-0.0342066064,
-0.6976673007,
1.1652084589,
-0.0497127138,
-0.7459157705,
0.2094735056,
-0.5974521041,
-0.4560260177,
0.3285885751,
-0.3751657605,
-0.2804304361,
-0.0081046447,
0.2797009945,
0.3589947224,
-0.2177230269,
-0.0692398399,
-0.1475794613,
-0.2286086082,
0.1512581557,
-0.2106342018,
0.7057376504,
0.2913331985,
-0.4894478321,
0.1729135811,
-0.9932727218,
-0.1869474351,
-0.0170538854,
-0.0067614815,
-0.555333674,
-0.1618632078,
0.4646721184,
0.3335115016,
0.4132060707,
-0.8956915736,
-0.0860984847,
-0.4121686518,
0.518276751,
0.4267720282,
-0.02574417,
0.2514519095,
0.1023385972,
0.4735074043,
-0.2656297088,
0.2057510614,
-0.3615249693,
-0.522616446,
-0.8032699823,
-0.6796714664,
0.1897966862,
0.7417961359,
-0.8580794334,
0.2650655806,
0.0794224888,
-0.5529419184,
-0.9409653544,
0.2339963019,
0.4330346584,
0.6846696734,
0.3562872708,
-0.1773844063,
-0.7866731286,
-1.1464132071,
0.1185777113,
-0.4138154387,
-0.2008369267,
0.1469469368,
0.4284228981,
-0.0538504831,
0.7926578522,
-0.0585323498,
-0.7784934044,
0.1285461038,
0.2812827528,
-0.0010321772,
0.269299686,
0.7075282931,
-0.8711938858,
-0.1521244198,
0.2413804531,
-0.7391026616,
-0.5984055996,
0.1724128425,
0.1281569749,
0.0486384109,
0.4811840951,
-0.0857606083,
0.302575469,
0.7787559032,
-0.1998786181,
-0.0732873827,
-0.3988362551,
0.1799482703,
-0.9332126975,
0.1762894243,
0.3554246724,
-0.4865796268,
-0.5656678081,
-0.4996770322,
0.0307556204,
-0.2320833802,
-0.7095852494,
0.7805328369,
-0.5038219094,
-0.4709750116,
-0.3659445941,
0.3533084691,
-0.4058660865,
0.458604157,
0.4476737976,
0.9016568065,
0.8235913515,
-0.5009784698,
0.4875158966,
0.3312619328,
-0.3597788215,
0.636708498,
-0.5698111653,
-0.0705795512,
0.1182485074,
-0.1306960732,
-0.8277558088,
-0.2946919501,
0.1166734472,
-0.3825465739,
0.1854861081,
-0.2813385427,
-0.5617032051,
-0.3410068154,
-0.0906947851,
0.3759006262,
0.4422279298,
-0.7064005136,
0.4757420421,
1.0312986374,
-0.1550567001,
-0.3104018867,
-0.7208741307,
0.1786671132,
-0.222645089,
-0.6317937374,
0.3375950456,
0.3163898587,
-0.2899257541,
-0.0069302903,
0.1798843592,
0.0066807251,
-0.0427143462,
0.3634701371,
0.0911168158,
0.1148970053,
0.1298268586,
-0.2018933445,
-0.270304203,
-0.2129397243,
-0.5585099459,
0.3070088029,
-0.1209463328,
-0.4185476601,
-0.937622726,
0.1013628691,
0.5343129635,
-0.5537365079,
0.1429861039,
0.710403502,
-0.6578586698,
-0.2714442909,
-0.8435489535,
-0.0403075293,
-0.4253932834,
0.3607781529,
-0.1935826093,
-0.6268268824,
0.7551923394,
0.0815863088,
0.1527388841,
0.3158170581,
0.6949923038,
-0.1335272491,
0.7086751461,
0.7356986403,
0.0952901095,
0.9267636538,
-0.1606257856,
-0.0814207196,
-0.5576815009,
-0.2869623899,
-0.6851304173,
-0.1893915981,
-0.6208100319,
-0.6047219634,
0.4385233819,
-0.5902902484,
0.0975563824,
0.5197731853,
-0.6179590225,
0.3207601011,
0.8529855609,
-0.0906274989,
0.2454361171,
0.0195970125,
0.1746718287,
-0.1270677894,
-0.4634998143,
-0.6631628871,
0.7300871015,
0.440066874,
0.5906718969,
0.0192438997,
0.7117774487,
0.5764736533,
0.1237589866,
-0.7614491582,
0.4796096087,
0.0228448901,
-0.629621923,
-0.4673840106,
-0.2593865395,
-0.6468387842,
0.1513134241,
-0.183120504,
-0.821523428,
0.5084584355,
0.5527645946,
-0.3608339131,
0.1094140932,
-0.7995646,
1.1896138191,
-0.3943170309,
-0.3206008375,
0.050872989,
-0.4396702051,
-0.0280599575,
-0.134206295,
0.4306837022,
-0.139453575,
-0.0521644801,
1.0575218201,
-0.2925462723,
0.8449483514,
-0.4462014139,
0.0390991159,
0.4242112935,
0.0507911332,
0.3463326991,
-0.1552714556,
0.1426040828,
0.1069403738,
0.0722044259,
-0.3377369344,
-0.0665132627,
0.6568042636,
-0.6248957515,
-0.1166296601,
-0.3578337431,
-0.1805294454,
-0.0921758488,
0.2870335281,
0.1923322231,
0.4135432541,
-0.4737219214,
-0.1733873039,
0.5620031357,
-0.2494694889,
0.4086898863,
0.4722655118,
-0.4144150317,
-0.3616207838,
0.970688045,
0.262712419,
-0.06983421,
0.1602735668,
-0.0085056573,
-0.3729025722,
-0.4734019637,
-0.613832891,
0.3666086197,
-0.753596127,
0.1717222184,
-0.6037605405,
0.4244344532,
-0.227536872,
-0.0091279736,
-0.6211847663,
-0.6685274839,
-0.3438659012,
-0.1175935045,
0.3494235277,
0.4645213783,
-0.1082885191,
0.2592674196,
-0.250667423,
0.5138638616,
0.4812144637,
-0.0741901919,
-0.4092724919,
-0.611282289,
-0.1864264458,
-0.2050790489,
0.0964055359,
-1.0436309576,
0.5749481916,
0.4839518666,
0.6451085806,
0.4244054854,
0.0278030299,
0.7039991617,
-0.4315790534,
0.3984853029,
0.0033716334,
-0.8803999424,
0.962939024,
-0.2166044563,
0.2116734087,
0.6457241178,
0.1177180856,
-0.4754430354,
-0.6387308836,
-0.5966932774,
-0.5653809905,
0.6715514064,
0.2357568592,
-0.0656441301,
-0.1037495583,
-0.1920948625,
-0.1003195643,
0.2206859738,
-0.590775609,
-0.1193111837,
-0.4005202055,
-0.2382956892,
-0.1152216569,
0.059763547,
-0.227668643,
-0.2084709704,
0.8250482082,
-0.1440389901,
0.1210791022,
0.3043774366,
-0.4156251252,
-0.3456191421,
0.0787680447,
0.4681073725,
0.4945308268,
-0.2405367494,
0.2308804244,
0.0981561691,
-0.4842672646,
-0.1171621308,
0.6232964993,
-0.1046872586,
0.3574882448,
0.5181525946,
0.8881835938,
0.549867928,
-0.879598856,
0.4966770411,
-0.1068933755,
0.0903556347,
-0.7988226414,
-0.1878781915,
-0.1284162402,
0.2858744562,
0.4427891076,
0.0065825311,
0.2424211949,
-0.7163940668,
0.136756897,
0.1920290589,
-0.391297549,
-0.4476473629,
0.7414050698,
0.5935497284,
-0.5760444403,
0.2332439274,
-0.1525974125,
-0.4562958479,
0.3866095841,
0.27307266,
0.6716874242,
-0.5110222101,
0.2393877804,
0.1704317331,
0.4170631468,
-0.0087830732,
0.5297105908,
-0.4158850014,
-0.4129493237,
-0.2150575668,
-0.6899240613,
-0.459364593,
-0.2426019907,
-0.4430514574,
0.5809956193,
-0.1794435233,
-0.3789788485,
0.4271235466,
-0.0385889448,
-0.7434881926,
-0.0164929759,
0.5938189626,
0.788828671,
-1.3708746433,
0.8516629338,
0.9406918287,
-0.3562706709,
-0.4371113777,
-0.5388066769,
0.1799557954,
-0.8096715212,
0.4361564517,
0.0663897321,
-0.2240065783,
0.1028449908,
-0.0627106205,
-0.5150567293,
0.7816210985,
0.701541841,
-0.5132812858,
0.0736358687,
-0.0192494672,
0.7128003836,
-0.2539836466,
0.1960833669,
0.4167802632,
0.6925693154,
0.0816769227,
-1.5080353022,
-0.4500754476,
-0.3840836287,
-0.341594696,
0.2188654244,
-0.1922179013,
0.5531539917,
-0.0178305022,
-0.236810118,
-0.134927392,
0.746209681,
-0.0407249331,
0.4896765947,
0.5747230649,
0.4580326378,
0.8800085187,
-0.1138882115,
0.7715975642,
-0.2329748422,
-0.0326259881,
0.983245194,
-0.0375812538,
0.8062859178,
0.6363366246,
0.0611772127,
0.0197339058,
0.7926305532,
0.0215163194,
0.4301413596,
-0.0307171997,
-0.3114881516,
-0.4588361681,
-0.4764134288,
-0.2720108628,
0.7023876905,
0.3535216749,
-0.3611705899,
-0.0470836721,
0.4840261936,
-0.094318226,
0.2254346758,
-0.236062035,
0.669362545,
0.0260971263,
-0.561311841,
0.5217786431,
-0.3022822142,
0.4643797278,
-0.457326442,
-0.050545603,
0.0822560713,
-0.0511979498,
-0.3362942636,
-0.5775197744,
-0.0208179243,
0.34788239,
0.2314004451,
-0.1347138882,
0.5007691979,
-0.5243963003,
-0.620038271,
0.2677529752,
0.5399279594,
0.3748435676,
0.1731053144,
-0.462246418,
0.2389237583,
0.0461505912,
-0.1328341663,
-0.1489884853,
0.525647521,
-0.2678112388,
0.6254475713,
0.5447228551,
0.3202254474,
0.203982681,
0.3646704555,
0.6320743561,
-0.2376062125,
-0.7585862875,
-0.5093188882,
0.3422471285,
-0.2433886081,
-0.4775861502,
0.8915705085,
0.4856692553,
0.908958137,
0.1388593465,
0.6128294468,
0.0387750678,
0.6014800072,
-0.3670462668,
0.328990221,
-0.5035453439,
0.3223935366,
-0.6210186481,
-1.1612136364,
-0.4865943789,
0.8963744044,
-0.4005507827,
-0.2530310452,
0.2664790452,
0.7024589777,
-0.2710244954,
0.0056554927,
0.4075399339,
0.1793541759,
0.2592225373,
0.075493969,
0.8338217735,
-0.1736216396,
0.3274941146,
-0.4728468359,
-0.4805492163,
-0.2234671563,
-0.8108143806,
-0.8822152019,
-0.7911469936,
-0.5467038155,
0.2243581861,
0.1237068474,
1.0436688662,
0.8475764394,
-0.5940995216,
-0.2856553495,
0.252232641,
-0.2654142976,
-0.0028203938,
-0.0284821596,
0.3967061639,
0.1587969661,
-0.9840218425,
0.6416703463,
0.4258638024,
0.1859794259,
-0.6136790514,
0.0605549291,
-0.2084742785,
-0.2157960832,
0.1984800994,
0.9590238929,
-0.5703752041,
-0.148443535,
-0.2655898631,
0.3066057265,
-0.1215915978,
0.4564284682,
-0.933141768,
0.9554427862,
0.4358176291,
0.3063986897,
0.6713786125,
-0.1600730419,
0.3251197338,
-0.7781703472,
0.9196512103,
0.4353249371,
0.6337801218,
0.6388537288,
0.0808025524,
0.4167320728,
0.0831968486,
-0.4100245237,
-1.2307538986,
0.012834508,
-1.0782986879,
0.045557268,
0.9023261666,
0.0918545946,
-0.382396549,
-0.2891944945,
-0.4768030643,
0.3887073398,
-0.41609478,
0.6033351421,
0.3310664296,
-0.071649082,
-0.2242847085,
-0.9465605617,
0.5813592672,
0.1736498028,
-0.7846692801,
0.0313114002,
0.714025259,
-0.0496535785,
0.4755553305,
0.7128468156,
0.078977786,
0.5518380404,
-0.2199301422,
0.3704427183,
-0.4416882098,
-0.5337891579,
-0.1504636854,
-0.0505772047,
0.2131539434,
-0.5597164631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13145v2
|
CMDAG: A Chinese Metaphor Dataset with Annotated Grounds as CoT for Boosting Metaphor Generation
| 2024-02-20T17:00:41 | 2024-02-21T03:18:04 |
Yujie Shao, Xinrong Yao, Xingwei Qu, Chenghua Lin, Shi Wang, Stephen W. Huang, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Metaphor is a prominent linguistic device in human language and literature,
as they add color, imagery, and emphasis to enhance effective communication.
This paper introduces a large-scale high quality annotated Chinese Metaphor
Corpus, which comprises around 28K sentences drawn from a diverse range of
Chinese literary sources, such as poems, prose, song lyrics, etc. To ensure the
accuracy and consistency of our annotations, we introduce a comprehensive set
of guidelines. These guidelines address the facets of metaphor annotation,
including identifying tenors, vehicles, and grounds to handling the
complexities of similes, personifications, juxtapositions, and hyperboles.
Breaking tradition, our approach to metaphor generation emphasizes grounds and
their distinct features rather than the conventional combination of tenors and
vehicles. By integrating "ground" as a CoT (Chain of Thoughts) input, we are
able to generate metaphors that resonate more with real-world intuition. We
test generative models such as Belle, Baichuan, and Chinese-alpaca-33B using
our annotated corpus. These models are able to generate creative and fluent
metaphor sentences more frequently induced by selected samples from our
dataset, demonstrating the value of our corpus for Chinese metaphor research.
The code is available in
https://github.com/JasonShao55/Chinese_Metaphor_Explanation.
|
[
-0.6892912984,
-0.5976871848,
0.4244421124,
0.4866644144,
-0.8586494327,
-0.3411809504,
-0.4451437891,
-0.2979722619,
0.2984232605,
0.4638456404,
-0.4794667065,
-0.4493370056,
-0.4979477823,
0.1001619026,
-0.3491542041,
0.8229674101,
0.239487648,
0.005034925,
-0.1292960048,
-0.0761716962,
-0.8688872457,
-0.5153027773,
-0.5853146315,
-0.0895382091,
0.7414236665,
-0.044288639,
0.8435928822,
1.0461496115,
0.2296085209,
0.1547603607,
0.0596334264,
0.4044181705,
-0.2367649674,
0.0763808489,
-0.1083561331,
-0.3299708664,
-0.2129753083,
0.4420689642,
0.3714472353,
0.5646136403,
-0.0835034847,
-0.0428039022,
0.0502041318,
0.1112159491,
-0.6628204584,
0.2595899999,
-1.1034239531,
0.2620661259,
-0.2874982059,
-0.5608680248,
-0.2606050074,
-0.3238741457,
-0.1353064775,
-0.9450828433,
0.0648329481,
0.2658318877,
0.9871191382,
0.2576076388,
-0.4472984672,
-0.0694661438,
-0.1061006337,
0.7184083462,
-0.4233510196,
-0.1141108796,
0.185751915,
0.7091854215,
-0.0598614141,
-0.8890749216,
-0.7029972672,
-0.361877799,
-0.0182432365,
0.209651053,
0.4825598001,
-0.0367267914,
0.4175243676,
0.3720231354,
-0.2020950764,
-0.0995725393,
-0.316627264,
-0.2342230678,
0.353394419,
0.2114798874,
0.6602638364,
-0.1410479695,
-0.9231316447,
-0.2266788483,
-1.037134409,
-0.2321897447,
0.1998956501,
0.5036749244,
-0.204116717,
0.3860089183,
0.1648071557,
0.8394053578,
-0.1957158744,
-0.0755509958,
0.2217324674,
-0.2552027404,
-0.2035843432,
0.3239269555,
0.7161433697,
0.7501323223,
0.5460544825,
-0.3219060004,
-0.1930660307,
0.4879896641,
0.3574382365,
-0.7302507758,
-0.3009189665,
0.0468169674,
-0.4588350058,
-0.6143628359,
0.4844819605,
-0.7946339846,
-0.5645285845,
-0.646873951,
0.1031596065,
-0.5850289464,
-0.1979911029,
-0.1741138846,
-0.4165964127,
0.4436250329,
0.1628559232,
-0.8919972777,
-0.1608263105,
0.7257373929,
0.7018908858,
-0.1879185289,
-0.5834794641,
-0.4834229052,
0.2737505436,
-0.7743727565,
0.7625789642,
-0.4776101708,
-0.0930430442,
0.1375496387,
-0.0530236438,
-0.0544447303,
-0.3861622214,
1.1408317089,
-0.0373180881,
0.1606765091,
-0.7032718658,
-0.3553066552,
-0.0610606745,
0.4400457442,
-0.6701866388,
0.7458033562,
0.067246072,
-1.0306788683,
0.4300118089,
-0.4579773545,
-0.0999871045,
0.1855055988,
-0.8793882728,
0.1950400919,
0.0266250391,
0.4098183811,
0.4409261346,
-0.8590102792,
0.4698952734,
-0.0003940862,
-0.6328371167,
0.3249084651,
-0.3074942827,
1.0957291126,
0.4980023503,
-0.2998417914,
0.0708256066,
-0.6795542836,
0.1581652313,
0.205288291,
0.0370962471,
-0.3932709992,
-0.2245510072,
0.6394328475,
0.5615459085,
0.0341874734,
-0.3588690162,
-0.0972508192,
-0.2845912278,
0.517475605,
0.6131362915,
0.0242012292,
-0.077421613,
-0.5952896476,
0.5706282258,
0.4132069051,
-0.2125284374,
-0.7403425574,
-0.2770643532,
-0.39357391,
-0.2988832593,
0.5461956859,
0.130399704,
-0.9967793226,
0.8478772044,
-0.2113699764,
-0.5506622791,
-0.6128172874,
-0.266754806,
0.178580299,
0.6683998108,
0.2915306985,
-0.0712390542,
-0.4638964832,
-0.8436107635,
0.0880480111,
-0.0810717791,
-0.2955838442,
0.203309685,
0.0842273235,
-0.0442689881,
0.885058701,
-0.3923059702,
-0.3117492795,
0.0087722987,
0.2070576698,
-0.2369220853,
0.4647422135,
1.1222519875,
-1.07690835,
-0.0620175116,
-0.1688455343,
-0.930239737,
-0.4114896357,
-0.6184869409,
-0.6593214869,
-0.2279352397,
0.3421191871,
-0.6502466202,
-0.029398229,
0.4594319761,
-0.342898488,
0.8521233201,
0.1385018378,
0.3181714416,
-1.2414098978,
0.1238475963,
-0.1297899038,
0.2632883787,
-0.1925947219,
0.4869229198,
0.1023007929,
0.0882605612,
-0.5455763936,
0.5091149807,
-0.292801559,
0.2666016519,
-0.4374371469,
0.6793863773,
0.154344365,
0.3599606752,
0.1457974017,
0.8513221741,
0.972833097,
-0.6536720991,
0.7077636719,
0.1425572187,
-0.1833395362,
0.554697752,
-0.4272669554,
-0.0152729256,
-0.1583577991,
0.4165743291,
-0.8441469073,
-0.1553331167,
0.2967382371,
-0.2537446916,
-0.2678833008,
0.3316831589,
-0.7342591286,
-0.1108222455,
-0.4322480559,
0.5269846916,
0.4823498726,
-0.9491093755,
0.2639576495,
0.245636493,
0.4110277593,
-0.6122349501,
-0.6958152056,
0.3856889606,
-0.7155196667,
-0.390530318,
0.4402621984,
-0.0506719463,
-0.1707898825,
-0.2668646276,
0.1168982238,
0.0494178124,
0.0451902747,
0.2833119631,
0.2850948274,
-0.2553811669,
0.1616570055,
0.1105286628,
-0.0721694306,
0.5365312696,
-0.3665763736,
0.6602039337,
0.1944029331,
0.0220397655,
-0.0307450648,
0.0410254262,
0.5567544103,
-0.1812282354,
0.7117960453,
0.7773451805,
-0.7007151246,
-0.3370255828,
-0.1931157559,
-0.0046433662,
-0.416944176,
-0.1166924611,
-0.4022490382,
-0.227560088,
0.4428901672,
-0.0459375232,
0.1594593376,
0.6464727521,
0.6356762052,
0.1987350285,
0.3543410599,
0.3748264015,
-0.1620239168,
-0.0299327988,
0.0478982516,
0.0333638601,
-0.8533399701,
0.0720053315,
-0.4164496064,
-0.1153495982,
-0.5208204389,
-0.5875787735,
-0.0775792077,
0.0350820385,
-0.103466928,
0.4252506793,
-0.6485877633,
0.3890006542,
0.327252835,
-0.1541392803,
0.109408617,
-0.0519776344,
-0.6053789258,
-0.2970561385,
-0.5730701685,
-0.8047079444,
0.736142695,
0.1590237767,
0.341627568,
-0.3825455606,
0.3849600554,
0.1310332716,
0.3150863349,
-0.5808058381,
0.6316975355,
-0.0280332472,
-0.418712914,
0.1132554263,
-0.3176463544,
-0.7800599933,
0.3906109333,
-0.384344697,
-0.5536328554,
-0.0763713643,
0.1070250049,
-0.273699671,
0.1450829655,
-0.2193513364,
0.8271899223,
-0.3165811002,
-0.0254607759,
0.160948962,
-0.612445116,
0.7597109079,
-0.2839321196,
0.0240504388,
0.0145965582,
-0.0971925408,
0.5863230228,
-0.1189557314,
0.4430861175,
-0.0527277328,
-0.2863506973,
0.7399501204,
-0.0913561881,
0.1361364424,
-0.1687128991,
-0.0783295557,
0.2558620572,
0.0773529261,
-0.2928279638,
-0.4910850525,
0.7138258219,
-0.4007248282,
-0.3331701756,
-0.4135623872,
-0.6607600451,
-0.0537566505,
0.0527179502,
0.5675233006,
0.0582648478,
-0.1971149594,
0.3431524336,
0.124604404,
-0.5266022682,
0.1748047918,
-0.4557725787,
-0.1274376363,
-0.466362983,
0.641964376,
0.0231386349,
0.1259683222,
0.1670009196,
0.1241732836,
-0.2235219777,
-0.2125140727,
-0.5162062645,
0.0146085657,
-0.8717483282,
-0.1916042417,
-0.4408113658,
-0.5288404822,
-0.1945005208,
-0.3537909985,
0.0236221235,
-0.3412345052,
0.0210860763,
-0.3335152864,
0.2895228863,
0.0015695016,
0.2957040966,
0.4023955166,
-0.3087756336,
0.4736527503,
-0.0629468635,
0.0703835636,
0.0916022286,
-0.2071205974,
-0.1688409001,
0.2749926448,
-0.4255856574,
-0.8292425871,
0.366376102,
-0.1752699018,
0.4087199271,
0.8398170471,
0.2976628244,
0.7769467235,
-0.5113420486,
1.0910265446,
0.4412226975,
-0.7300533652,
0.3543211818,
-0.668845892,
-0.1374165267,
0.2852302194,
-0.0734357685,
-0.612734139,
-0.5352736115,
-0.6523045301,
-0.8831940293,
0.2729910314,
0.4856408238,
0.3865349293,
-0.4087822437,
0.5414179564,
0.129583925,
0.3572231531,
-0.7523556352,
-0.4275977015,
-0.4810734689,
-0.2304920405,
-0.0922259241,
-0.0302082039,
-0.3529867828,
0.0186798554,
0.2867463231,
-0.2630194128,
0.2076694071,
0.0125202946,
0.2310681492,
-0.1261901557,
0.0113125788,
0.3034833372,
0.6562462449,
0.1177706048,
0.4087916911,
0.0824944302,
-0.3461057842,
-0.1121354327,
-0.0762476996,
-0.2432515919,
0.0904872119,
0.1635677814,
0.4954347908,
-0.0847246051,
-0.9498714209,
0.247418493,
-0.0037162083,
-0.0491146222,
-0.6209843755,
0.3477666974,
0.244928211,
-0.0527646169,
0.2977191806,
-0.23036322,
0.0444570482,
-0.4779492915,
0.1704522669,
0.3332618773,
-0.1212366447,
-0.005510157,
1.1234371662,
0.0964660272,
0.0519728474,
0.3331981301,
-0.1540960968,
-0.2979928553,
1.0099767447,
0.734193027,
1.0154474974,
0.2597866356,
0.102772221,
0.4883106053,
0.3591983914,
-0.2035394013,
-0.1516372561,
0.01306911,
-0.7943416834,
0.0632599965,
-0.6478979588,
-0.1667955518,
0.4058306217,
-0.4490404725,
0.6886721253,
-0.5277175307,
0.0726468191,
-0.0346480198,
-0.1153569221,
-0.561626792,
0.6780531406,
0.5733194351,
1.0974897146,
-0.9056488276,
0.987511754,
0.7750852108,
-0.6344006062,
-0.8682513833,
0.490324229,
-0.2378414124,
-0.3342016041,
0.5043182969,
0.5955405235,
-0.0798797011,
-0.1336905807,
-0.7048066854,
-0.296299696,
1.4904384613,
0.4322559237,
-0.2512064576,
0.0401429385,
0.0553810261,
0.7009017467,
-1.0427860022,
0.1270126998,
0.4687642157,
0.468144685,
0.1972303689,
-0.5059047937,
0.4063971937,
-0.2967121005,
0.3071769178,
-0.3911831677,
-0.6975418925,
1.1308921576,
0.0817055926,
-0.2495595813,
0.3898249865,
0.7600538731,
0.9855351448,
0.3600898683,
0.6699448824,
0.3207949996,
0.6181859374,
-0.2447978556,
0.8134353161,
-0.5941779613,
0.0529647805,
0.9063999653,
-0.1076667309,
0.3747275472,
0.4576584101,
0.3569677472,
0.2839644253,
0.8662267327,
-0.2572676241,
0.3409207463,
0.4255073071,
-0.1270298511,
-0.1973490268,
-0.3741073012,
-0.5036127567,
0.3398948014,
0.2659794688,
-0.799588263,
-0.2780059278,
-0.1545764655,
0.0745751932,
0.4923857749,
-0.1809165627,
0.194647491,
0.1921454221,
-0.7676771283,
0.7360830903,
0.2392693907,
0.6037108898,
-0.3139933348,
-0.3537280858,
0.0010839892,
-0.2085058391,
0.0181965586,
-0.4504184127,
0.0334081538,
-0.0119071659,
0.2955451906,
-0.006428387,
0.4792927802,
-0.4986819029,
-0.4095512331,
0.3782478571,
0.4373137653,
0.3203411996,
-0.1210206002,
-0.6023658514,
0.00137134,
-0.2029779553,
-0.0904150382,
0.1914685369,
1.0716859102,
-0.3001987338,
0.3528170884,
0.4660385251,
0.2954383492,
-0.0997632518,
0.1859422922,
0.960873127,
-0.8563116789,
-0.7303475142,
-0.8058385253,
0.341009438,
-0.0472278595,
-0.5013985634,
0.4933545291,
0.4019066095,
0.6400948167,
-0.2182951272,
0.9576975107,
-0.2790706754,
-0.0543323308,
-0.700641036,
1.0270721912,
-0.3008340299,
0.2868021727,
-0.3667960465,
-1.1086568832,
-0.3499549031,
0.8411013484,
0.16853562,
0.2393505424,
0.8263713121,
0.6605865955,
-0.1659619659,
0.0415186286,
0.4290558994,
0.1582819372,
0.2886524796,
0.5041591525,
0.8623933196,
-0.5146719813,
0.3434095085,
-0.2378495932,
0.018225193,
0.1903082281,
-1.0969340801,
-0.9957610965,
-0.7066671252,
-0.2643265724,
-0.3306664228,
-0.0102437353,
1.2311559916,
0.5285330415,
-0.5359925032,
-0.096035786,
-0.3133964539,
-0.2195358723,
-0.464042753,
-0.2859627306,
0.5168697834,
-0.6666581035,
-0.8372482061,
-0.0691123754,
-0.0721586868,
-0.0807323679,
-0.3261982203,
-0.0059675109,
0.0146606481,
0.3383659124,
0.4879888594,
-0.1635452807,
-1.002581954,
-0.3816236854,
-0.3580983579,
-0.4012954235,
0.0351954959,
0.8383345008,
-0.9910574555,
0.2699881196,
-0.0005697614,
0.6735939384,
-0.2636592984,
0.5324327946,
0.6469578743,
-0.8904661536,
0.3946142197,
0.0739657357,
0.5650857687,
0.4112300277,
-0.4023470879,
0.566660285,
0.315654844,
-0.1967568547,
-0.8689846992,
0.0982941091,
-1.2962883711,
-0.3078682721,
1.3065772057,
-0.3116244972,
-0.0922725275,
0.2942826152,
-0.7559775114,
0.4462110996,
-0.0762512386,
1.3096452951,
1.0452055931,
0.3181642294,
-0.2913630605,
-0.5702000856,
0.6651039124,
0.1553628743,
-0.9382627606,
0.4703501165,
0.6794497371,
-0.028873723,
0.2458135337,
0.2378878444,
-0.3357961476,
0.3428234458,
0.2653791606,
0.2327062339,
-0.0194977578,
-0.3702754676,
-0.0343465507,
0.2128237188,
0.0078265332,
-0.4381929338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13137v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13137v2
|
The Hidden Space of Transformer Language Adapters
| 2024-02-20T16:53:26 | 2024-06-10T06:53:58 |
Jesujoba O. Alabi, Marius Mosbach, Matan Eyal, Dietrich Klakow, Mor Geva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We analyze the operation of transformer language adapters, which are small
modules trained on top of a frozen language model to adapt its predictions to
new target languages. We show that adapted predictions mostly evolve in the
source language the model was trained on, while the target language becomes
pronounced only in the very last layers of the model. Moreover, the adaptation
process is gradual and distributed across layers, where it is possible to skip
small groups of adapters without decreasing adaptation performance. Last, we
show that adapters operate on top of the model's frozen representation space
while largely preserving its structure, rather than on an 'isolated' subspace.
Our findings provide a deeper view into the adaptation process of language
models to new languages, showcasing the constraints imposed on it by the
underlying model and introduces practical implications to enhance its
efficiency.
|
[
-0.2159617245,
-0.0557280555,
0.5735068321,
0.0107334917,
0.0681665391,
0.2546126544,
-0.2370773703,
-0.2879049182,
-0.0993634909,
0.5377727747,
-0.479277432,
-0.0617795996,
-0.605681181,
-0.2272889763,
-0.0458650254,
0.770339191,
-0.0304546934,
-0.2155766934,
0.0273523144,
-0.0781515315,
-0.7524515986,
-0.1052944958,
-0.3580372036,
-0.4640646279,
0.0682387948,
0.6691765189,
1.023903966,
0.8479632735,
0.1189955324,
0.3358939886,
-0.1642165631,
-0.5996864438,
-0.4882276356,
0.0291431043,
-0.2268108726,
-0.9843124151,
-0.1366697401,
-0.2324008197,
0.8549214602,
0.6809663773,
-0.2004521787,
-0.143233642,
-0.0684490874,
0.4542430043,
-0.4223721325,
0.2495142967,
-0.89585495,
0.2912221849,
0.0410504378,
0.3332793713,
-0.7019944787,
-0.1480859518,
0.2758162916,
-0.4904844463,
0.3897988498,
-0.1227094382,
0.5449953675,
0.2650530338,
-0.1791068763,
0.0370484814,
-1.1866184473,
0.7198471427,
-0.3767401576,
0.4997522533,
-0.0038531222,
0.7543892264,
-0.1950007379,
-0.6082431674,
-0.5427405834,
-0.1348062307,
-0.1798039526,
0.2031601816,
-0.8612033725,
-0.3351811767,
0.1638198644,
0.3017555773,
-0.1804946512,
0.2851021588,
-0.468560487,
-0.0902194604,
0.3410433829,
-0.218087554,
0.3497847617,
0.0436350554,
-0.1002181321,
-0.4005008042,
-0.5355621576,
-0.1029433459,
0.1616307348,
0.2315306962,
-0.3875389695,
0.2578391135,
0.2075268626,
0.3555632532,
0.1208031029,
0.2073780596,
0.2493047267,
0.4076088071,
-0.1622681469,
-0.1439087838,
0.4318168461,
-0.0038485976,
0.2346518785,
-0.2979185581,
-0.1735696793,
-0.0745404363,
0.3873287141,
-0.4522526264,
-0.6200713515,
-0.3302899301,
-0.3131821752,
-0.0437870994,
-0.3075692356,
-0.3953305483,
-0.3388988674,
0.3704938591,
0.2314414829,
-0.4067339599,
-0.5440110564,
0.038142655,
-0.2880418897,
0.2109915614,
0.316647172,
-1.0048286915,
0.8785952926,
0.5003132224,
0.6424592733,
-0.1145369187,
-0.368586868,
-0.1789053977,
0.1474463791,
-0.467066288,
0.9094631672,
-0.8258758783,
-0.1916414797,
0.0128643336,
0.4053090215,
-0.3596816957,
-0.6849855185,
0.4547446072,
-0.716129899,
0.3164019585,
0.0318119116,
-0.2777792215,
-0.3092419207,
-0.313339442,
-0.9749125242,
0.7807887197,
0.3658921719,
-0.1873953193,
0.4275870323,
-0.8665230274,
-0.1681965441,
0.2070210874,
0.1357946843,
-0.3038682342,
0.7558851838,
0.2164683789,
0.3677696586,
-0.1113634408,
-0.3285464346,
0.0367944837,
-0.2345920056,
0.5118036866,
-0.2856161892,
0.4139473736,
0.1830116957,
-0.2200197428,
-0.0079690618,
-0.6256920695,
-0.2422282994,
0.2153268903,
-0.4585677683,
-0.3756909966,
0.0567542315,
0.0688238963,
0.2910623252,
-0.1477916539,
-0.5572869182,
0.380176574,
-0.4255732894,
0.4052502811,
0.6255278587,
-0.34133178,
1.0899846554,
0.1324628145,
0.7958258986,
0.2677059472,
0.1026482359,
-0.2870795429,
-0.5720626116,
-1.0195361376,
0.2310626656,
0.2864899933,
0.3292143345,
-0.7876660228,
0.115739204,
-0.510401547,
-0.5696573257,
-0.6634117961,
-0.0862700418,
0.0116792629,
-0.0091488482,
0.0854317248,
-0.0629076585,
-0.2136511207,
-1.0689880848,
-0.3805606663,
-0.1492799371,
-0.105388388,
0.1642557234,
0.4537905157,
-0.2911344171,
0.6763913631,
-0.7042796612,
-0.0688265637,
-0.4762158692,
-0.3231562674,
0.5730435848,
0.5734556317,
0.7499216795,
-0.7559615374,
-0.6539237499,
0.3537531495,
-0.3301639259,
0.1364569366,
-0.1332168579,
0.0243299045,
-0.1273287535,
0.5637363791,
-0.4994056821,
0.1688715518,
1.0369250774,
-0.3160081208,
0.0500383861,
-0.2534451783,
-0.4667761326,
-1.0350846052,
-0.2006092668,
-0.4528373182,
-0.2494512498,
-1.0524326563,
0.0476435684,
0.2340509295,
-0.3103435338,
-0.2907197475,
0.5459716916,
-0.7715887427,
-0.0783248544,
-0.5537688136,
0.1916356981,
-0.2799945474,
0.4497766197,
0.1470883191,
0.58155936,
0.8982086778,
-0.3138674796,
-0.1655894667,
0.1479204446,
-0.300468564,
-0.1914603561,
-0.4053893685,
0.4253849983,
-0.0696040764,
-0.0165779535,
-0.9762665629,
-0.1316705048,
0.1311971247,
-0.1269255728,
0.3977252245,
-0.5374110341,
-0.0184808783,
-0.3468848169,
0.0198908225,
0.4790737331,
0.8688946366,
-0.389464587,
0.7681115866,
0.6403596997,
0.0678230152,
-0.4644577503,
-0.8086204529,
0.0660511404,
-0.0258365031,
-0.4214158058,
0.1573960483,
-0.1732039303,
-0.0355861001,
0.3138943017,
-0.1188325509,
-0.2401460856,
0.1559039056,
0.3910184205,
-0.035964068,
-0.573143959,
-0.1245048195,
0.2928012013,
-0.1790254116,
-0.1017149761,
-0.5614101291,
0.6102887988,
-0.274075985,
-0.2374431938,
-0.0029003436,
0.1036171913,
0.7908830643,
0.321188122,
1.0905028582,
0.4167818725,
-0.6414625049,
-0.2689805329,
-0.4498243034,
0.0616841726,
-0.5696898699,
0.47753492,
-0.638422668,
-0.8452708125,
0.8195842505,
-0.2388922125,
-0.036456611,
0.7276350856,
0.3203653693,
0.2751123905,
0.8289186358,
1.4100888968,
-0.0960678086,
0.5975989103,
-0.1518690735,
0.248473078,
-0.9037134647,
-0.1967198849,
-0.5136988163,
-0.3188360035,
-0.8509745598,
-0.8313115835,
0.1430842876,
0.2822588384,
0.3260989189,
0.8255579472,
-0.3925599456,
0.764795959,
0.1482862979,
-0.2164993733,
-0.1124423444,
0.1393628865,
-0.3089848161,
-0.3053051829,
-1.2042546272,
-0.1241903454,
0.5495932698,
0.7813860178,
0.6401461363,
0.257062465,
0.3515265882,
0.0268980972,
0.3689802885,
-0.7760736942,
0.2659517527,
-0.3514054716,
-0.4911697805,
-0.2204263806,
-0.058962401,
-0.9621391892,
0.2871417105,
-0.0613249168,
-0.8548871875,
0.5081594586,
0.0229781512,
-0.0940843672,
0.4634317756,
-0.8809753656,
0.6527468562,
0.2046785653,
-0.0775948912,
-0.2950959206,
-0.44211182,
0.0535404868,
-0.2564479113,
0.3402808607,
0.0413761102,
0.2872194648,
0.9077185988,
0.0387594253,
0.7790330052,
-0.3008024395,
0.0281894226,
0.0187684707,
0.5018078685,
0.4069941044,
-0.2666444182,
-0.1165068299,
0.1843774021,
-0.3073579073,
-0.4860077798,
-0.6639239788,
0.5019815564,
-0.9297325015,
-0.7923355699,
-0.213939622,
-0.783767879,
-0.063309066,
0.4134448171,
0.0258725546,
0.0740512758,
-0.263050884,
0.1764790118,
0.5453903675,
-0.6033707261,
0.5812235475,
0.7092927694,
-0.2998602986,
0.0169825982,
0.5690965652,
-0.0972590744,
0.3444593549,
0.7597718835,
0.5990362763,
-0.0575228445,
-0.7063768506,
-0.5102660656,
0.3837163448,
-0.9396442771,
-0.0044038841,
-0.603047967,
-0.4930813611,
-0.2610730231,
-0.2681576312,
-0.6224876046,
-0.6843482256,
-0.0321519785,
-0.1604915708,
0.2740601897,
1.0809426308,
-0.1303753406,
0.8345555067,
-0.8718606234,
-0.0066886591,
0.3198646605,
0.4303306043,
-0.0764444396,
-0.8687802553,
-0.6766573787,
-0.2356044203,
0.1177672669,
-0.6901903152,
0.476056695,
0.3809545934,
0.7724219561,
0.283709228,
-0.3396672606,
0.6306733489,
-0.9710775614,
0.7127501369,
0.1593102217,
-1.0693510771,
0.3806638122,
-0.107100971,
0.8395583034,
0.0971230716,
0.1025099605,
-0.5649225116,
-0.4328019023,
-0.6469600201,
-0.3997998834,
1.0402303934,
0.1507323384,
0.7548541427,
0.3239973187,
0.4975364506,
0.338078022,
0.0584556796,
-0.9372326732,
-0.2317959964,
-0.1806425303,
0.1417428255,
-0.1651859879,
-0.4537377954,
-0.0601962917,
-0.1334289312,
0.1646267325,
-0.2863245606,
0.8460906148,
-0.4193778336,
-0.2553651929,
-0.606726408,
0.2553997338,
0.5397190452,
0.4512716234,
0.1498169154,
0.2260012776,
0.4909322262,
-0.7111252546,
-0.0295967162,
-0.2475809008,
0.0126274629,
0.0807712227,
0.5819185972,
1.2392327785,
0.4054009914,
-0.1922606975,
0.3857170343,
-0.3246061206,
0.1717601717,
-0.5472000837,
0.3833323419,
0.1781917512,
0.5244991779,
0.4281782806,
0.8253892064,
-0.0711234212,
-0.6027085781,
0.2769021392,
0.223140195,
-0.6956490874,
-0.9073878527,
0.7001537681,
-0.2879259586,
-0.5953333378,
0.3638210595,
0.2736280262,
-0.7512152791,
0.2546447814,
1.0538914204,
1.2340246439,
-0.7752408981,
0.3842106462,
0.0041641467,
0.6523401737,
0.0520289466,
-0.0925362185,
0.0527131334,
-1.1319783926,
-0.2824869752,
-0.6383258104,
-0.0926541388,
0.0058989306,
-0.6126093864,
0.2473790646,
-0.3307699263,
0.1658575237,
-0.0861678645,
-0.5670986772,
-0.7550809383,
0.0432106517,
0.2497973591,
1.3288160563,
-1.1916007996,
1.246442914,
0.5873215795,
0.2860600352,
-0.7676418424,
0.2130224556,
-0.4443922341,
-1.2587697506,
0.5242537856,
-0.2258258462,
-0.2541567683,
-0.1797320396,
-0.3668609262,
-1.1276124716,
0.8536931276,
0.6917866468,
-0.5426489115,
0.0286760274,
0.2247747332,
0.9148177505,
-0.53843081,
0.2335275859,
0.5973374248,
0.3059940338,
0.0327891372,
-0.7403309941,
0.2470853478,
-0.4882429838,
0.1518825442,
0.0739039257,
-0.5477331877,
0.8835915923,
-0.1180598959,
-0.3574689925,
-0.123236239,
0.5527222753,
-0.3845772147,
-0.284149617,
0.6955041289,
0.0981993303,
0.462756753,
-0.0996299759,
1.0753813982,
-0.1188060567,
0.2346938252,
0.8249061704,
-0.1363278627,
0.9471737146,
0.3843158484,
0.04885206,
0.8785415888,
0.1130696088,
-0.1287912875,
0.8359974623,
-0.0492185876,
0.1025917679,
-0.0424671248,
0.0208116677,
-0.0874109194,
0.4100938141,
0.6117984653,
-0.3266397417,
-0.0313339606,
0.1923331618,
0.0749155432,
-0.0671000853,
-0.0102018137,
0.7217228413,
0.1537371278,
-0.5298945904,
0.6174858809,
0.0171033703,
0.0906504467,
-0.4018928409,
0.0117894365,
-0.2179354876,
0.2786502838,
-0.0908099636,
-0.8168219924,
0.3533102572,
-0.3353628814,
-0.3114160597,
-0.2841974795,
0.8574930429,
-0.3684978485,
-0.5326517224,
0.6630589366,
0.5053457022,
0.1496714801,
0.3072125912,
-0.482871443,
0.1943119615,
0.0357537717,
-0.1947967708,
0.3185026348,
0.566623807,
-0.0796513781,
0.6476324201,
0.3422086835,
0.2465724349,
0.4273326397,
0.0500260852,
1.1151586771,
-0.4779756367,
-0.5947893262,
-0.6971808672,
0.6419397593,
0.1368670315,
-0.0816885456,
0.7469262481,
0.36247769,
0.8588997722,
-0.4500837922,
0.7070357203,
0.0844995454,
0.1339654773,
-0.5600956678,
0.8185100555,
-0.2613731623,
0.4608575404,
-0.40185377,
-1.0901944637,
-0.359004885,
0.4326709807,
-0.3230486512,
-0.1334589422,
0.8081309199,
0.5440881252,
-0.3833165765,
-0.242627874,
0.7754408717,
0.5534861088,
0.2443051189,
0.4551535845,
1.0451551676,
-0.7213067412,
0.3269413412,
-0.3206400871,
-0.2249438763,
-0.0938721821,
-0.6669752598,
-0.898036778,
-0.76325804,
-0.2433164567,
-0.0496567301,
-0.2094326615,
0.3988636136,
0.9158326983,
-1.0353872776,
-0.5857569575,
-0.0922594443,
0.178480655,
-0.3311011493,
-0.247292757,
0.2218549848,
0.1322144568,
-0.8077098131,
0.8354868889,
0.3057747483,
-0.0208280385,
-0.0698200464,
-0.015141313,
0.2232226729,
0.00015869,
0.350279361,
0.1569573283,
-0.5248584151,
-0.6635150313,
0.3579321802,
0.3446699381,
0.3050489724,
1.1095404625,
-0.831582129,
0.5296196342,
0.2624436319,
0.4919344783,
0.7964927554,
-0.6353819966,
0.8706718087,
-0.8131164312,
0.4692437649,
0.0511533283,
0.3913142681,
0.2700414658,
-0.3395080864,
0.0155783137,
0.0094844373,
-0.255043596,
-0.8533961773,
0.2767351866,
-0.6869956255,
-0.3915969431,
0.8891752362,
-0.1634956747,
-0.2996813953,
-0.1973843575,
-0.0203223769,
0.3996224403,
-0.3138128221,
0.8133401871,
0.5008093715,
-0.1347975433,
-0.6022710204,
-0.6076547503,
0.6135267615,
0.1912568659,
-0.4541776776,
0.2175068855,
-0.0637433007,
0.4231168926,
0.6158056855,
0.2555716038,
0.0305107851,
0.0105422493,
0.2289750278,
-0.1002717391,
0.3057006001,
-0.565726757,
-0.9332514405,
0.2814062536,
0.3857499361,
-0.1480354816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13130v1
|
Are ELECTRA's Sentence Embeddings Beyond Repair? The Case of Semantic Textual Similarity
| 2024-02-20T16:43:20 | 2024-02-20T16:43:20 |
Ivan Rep, David Dukić, Jan Šnajder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While BERT produces high-quality sentence embeddings, its pre-training
computational cost is a significant drawback. In contrast, ELECTRA delivers a
cost-effective pre-training objective and downstream task performance
improvements, but not as performant sentence embeddings. The community tacitly
stopped utilizing ELECTRA's sentence embeddings for semantic textual similarity
(STS). We notice a significant drop in performance when using the ELECTRA
discriminator's last layer in comparison to earlier layers. We explore this
drop and devise a way to repair ELECTRA's embeddings, proposing a novel
truncated model fine-tuning (TMFT) method. TMFT improves the Spearman
correlation coefficient by over 8 points while increasing parameter efficiency
on the STS benchmark dataset. We extend our analysis to various model sizes and
languages. Further, we discover the surprising efficacy of ELECTRA's generator
model, which performs on par with BERT, using significantly fewer parameters
and a substantially smaller embedding size. Finally, we observe further boosts
by combining TMFT with a word similarity task or domain adaptive pre-training.
|
[
-0.1304235458,
-0.7606054544,
0.7999659777,
-0.3656332493,
-0.343727231,
0.2580316663,
-0.2935691178,
-0.4162299931,
0.2637351155,
0.6869443655,
-0.4612511992,
-0.2043750733,
-0.4461691976,
0.1633363068,
-0.5443201661,
0.8676190376,
-0.0020784219,
-0.3788198233,
-0.260011673,
-0.0979683399,
-0.4625068307,
-0.2293590605,
-0.3327396512,
-0.3859549463,
0.5857807398,
0.7157160044,
0.6754058599,
0.4699368477,
0.42002967,
0.3123833239,
0.0026306612,
0.5033105612,
-0.7722217441,
0.0633353069,
-0.1375530213,
-0.5525935888,
-0.1471744478,
-0.1779726297,
0.3873088956,
0.6118038297,
-0.1948464811,
-0.0159027465,
0.2097794861,
0.7616530657,
-0.5738043785,
-0.2757157385,
-1.1857256889,
-0.1457376182,
-0.1363623738,
-0.1762255281,
-0.5798280239,
-0.4636988342,
0.2866896391,
-0.535148859,
0.465300858,
0.326782912,
1.3727859259,
0.4316809773,
-0.1784248203,
-0.0436441004,
-0.6730926037,
0.8960641623,
-0.5158803463,
0.1433641016,
0.2851887941,
-0.1690706015,
-0.0009120144,
-0.7126479745,
-0.5032472014,
-0.2568526864,
0.1650865972,
-0.0419697836,
-0.5990458727,
0.0925072059,
0.1788669825,
0.0189965013,
-0.3943042755,
0.2899856865,
-0.4773376584,
-0.0302951783,
0.3276902139,
0.1724709272,
0.260964334,
-0.2456958741,
-0.3832299113,
-0.2514621615,
-1.0463006496,
-0.4097135663,
0.5445162058,
0.4209237099,
0.3262053132,
0.5689526796,
0.2293892205,
0.52927351,
-0.1636189073,
0.4639029503,
0.4090842605,
0.1177700236,
-0.3891963363,
0.2490423918,
0.4174568057,
0.5243074894,
0.5384269953,
-0.392852664,
-0.0155831035,
0.2398310304,
0.6327002048,
-0.6234617233,
-0.4291672707,
0.1343911588,
-0.4721391201,
-0.0997383073,
0.0211691689,
-0.2906704545,
-0.1908818483,
-0.3228580356,
0.6644549966,
-0.9386176467,
-0.18241629,
0.2348161489,
-0.2021726072,
0.0648803562,
0.1128503382,
-0.7316021323,
0.3037317395,
0.726754427,
0.9453546405,
0.2438007295,
-0.3244221807,
-0.3354489207,
0.1301940978,
-0.1909871399,
1.0678737164,
-0.5820072293,
-0.0807327032,
0.1472378969,
-0.1036198214,
-0.40600577,
-0.717215538,
0.6148673296,
-0.4063703418,
-0.1609949917,
-0.3722394407,
-1.0663506985,
0.0539724976,
-0.0033164648,
-0.7719177604,
0.9263968468,
0.0918678641,
-0.8894532919,
0.4881888628,
-0.3037720919,
-0.3538922966,
0.0323026888,
0.2999149859,
-0.8938547373,
0.4457684159,
0.0260374434,
0.4971914291,
-0.0518689305,
-0.0678180903,
-0.5105448961,
-0.568723917,
0.1382147521,
0.0334336311,
0.2545796037,
0.0871293992,
-0.1163515151,
-0.1926870048,
-0.8583580852,
0.0786155164,
-0.0760970116,
0.2775115371,
-0.8364987969,
0.2842612267,
0.2032327503,
0.0764693767,
0.1760351062,
-0.8238678575,
-0.0474735387,
-0.7982053757,
0.9919850826,
0.8281610012,
-0.236383453,
0.2975939512,
-0.6490930319,
0.2078268528,
-0.0626128539,
-0.1906260252,
-0.0229354165,
-0.1702817082,
-1.0572156906,
-0.1856729686,
0.4412768185,
0.2347156256,
-0.6933975816,
0.5641310215,
-0.6163713932,
-0.6983633041,
-0.7357894182,
-0.0732939094,
0.2532445788,
0.3295192122,
0.5575993061,
-0.2079498768,
-0.7332351208,
-1.0452520847,
-0.6797519922,
-0.2360481918,
-0.0228343401,
0.1140096337,
0.5457493663,
-0.0017956998,
1.0085847378,
-0.5382168293,
-0.4198007584,
-0.2728341818,
0.0642552525,
0.1381810904,
0.3517391086,
0.5230260491,
-0.3100419641,
-0.3667242825,
-0.151853919,
-0.138832882,
-0.0531743653,
-0.0817352906,
-0.0048954035,
0.1387490928,
0.4377195239,
-0.6199584007,
0.2539667785,
0.3388475478,
-0.5330662131,
0.2958723307,
-0.5713865161,
0.0886111856,
-1.0557547808,
-0.1022673994,
-0.0772031546,
-0.3411580026,
-0.4799577594,
-0.0236329846,
0.2134313285,
0.1651138067,
-0.3123600781,
0.0299383402,
-0.1971697211,
0.0735434592,
-0.3203630447,
0.2054012269,
-0.0013231309,
0.1779786944,
-0.2952112854,
0.7000299096,
0.1453674436,
-0.4530165792,
-0.1219550595,
0.3883545399,
-0.5692859888,
0.4796001017,
-1.0390919447,
0.2847627103,
-0.1658902019,
-0.1506659091,
-0.8785642982,
0.0862300247,
-0.3632779717,
-0.0672232434,
0.1304461956,
0.1554210782,
-0.6026113033,
-0.2049212903,
-0.6737310886,
0.027070675,
0.7667253017,
-0.5595899224,
0.4339273572,
0.1597116441,
-0.1184336394,
-0.2609327435,
-0.6866867542,
0.111014165,
-0.3822125196,
-0.7017938495,
0.8014550805,
0.3370726705,
-0.1030241847,
0.1374991834,
0.1829808354,
0.0377771109,
0.127837047,
0.1365723163,
0.1137840301,
-0.015227248,
0.5968330503,
0.4075722694,
0.0543975309,
-0.2196712494,
-0.1530243158,
0.6440931559,
-0.192550078,
-0.1071543396,
-0.0034032492,
0.2184394151,
0.2382404953,
-0.169744879,
1.0337600708,
0.3893392682,
-0.2614582479,
-0.2918986678,
-0.7340791225,
-0.0521362424,
-0.4886022806,
0.4045036435,
-0.310520947,
-1.1455661058,
0.3640729487,
-0.0980707034,
0.0055652959,
0.681030035,
0.3139343858,
-0.4635418057,
0.6476553679,
0.9151519537,
0.1753866524,
0.5713783503,
-0.1549182385,
0.2380894274,
-0.6849378347,
-0.2008211017,
-0.7745684981,
-0.2954888344,
-0.5301399231,
-0.1677420735,
0.2754713893,
-0.0190044791,
-0.5560733676,
0.7428159714,
-0.5864279866,
0.4575468898,
0.47606498,
0.6375138164,
0.1532807052,
0.1454278231,
0.0382175781,
-0.3318566084,
-0.6710062623,
-0.7526088953,
0.9315109253,
0.1676498652,
0.7618135214,
-0.0578012317,
0.8027837276,
0.3635158539,
-0.1549642682,
-0.4192788601,
0.3553797305,
-0.4925896525,
-0.0329608321,
-0.2028408498,
-0.2468330562,
-1.2658407688,
0.0493053198,
-0.1506045759,
-0.649877727,
0.0673822761,
0.1355685741,
-0.3234689534,
0.4749557972,
-0.8543942571,
0.6758705974,
0.345672369,
-0.1390045881,
-0.6646546721,
-0.5292127728,
-0.1633270383,
-0.0470383242,
-0.0116106234,
-0.2602524161,
-0.0575515181,
0.8091725707,
-0.8357619047,
0.6714478135,
0.1411166191,
-0.0479196161,
-0.0471383147,
-0.0979100615,
0.3296642005,
-0.386266768,
-0.0261257142,
-0.0592233576,
-0.0213091169,
-0.4764744639,
-0.3375383019,
0.7857432365,
-0.8404067755,
-0.2622913122,
-0.1258479357,
-0.2157163024,
-0.2028855383,
-0.0208778046,
0.3233709335,
0.4896411002,
-0.3697778583,
0.1972317845,
0.8056923747,
-0.1637787521,
0.5702847838,
0.2412118912,
0.4764392674,
-0.1056133285,
0.8444867134,
0.1609817743,
0.1524380296,
0.492241621,
-0.0820323527,
-0.0862062946,
-0.2633132041,
-0.0693395957,
0.2172078788,
-0.3376866877,
-0.5056822896,
-0.8176796436,
0.0360032208,
-0.025482282,
-0.3045917451,
-0.4687783122,
-0.5972099304,
-0.4407457709,
-0.2998967767,
0.8108420968,
0.6863712072,
0.2170647234,
0.1710870266,
-0.8763464689,
0.0597612485,
0.1258709133,
0.3139536977,
0.1182554066,
-0.5288767815,
-0.3303306997,
-0.1535431147,
-0.3838768005,
-0.7531723976,
0.3569151163,
0.6810716391,
0.0468897521,
-0.034043014,
0.2001182735,
0.7431506515,
-1.0808506012,
0.8598780632,
0.0885347128,
-1.1827249527,
0.5963474512,
0.0205415003,
0.2124169171,
0.5702033639,
0.0107614137,
-0.1264035553,
-0.6798869371,
-0.7649850845,
-1.0197365284,
0.3017926812,
0.3120324016,
0.5851050019,
-0.1898877025,
0.3039935827,
0.3400971889,
-0.057219848,
-0.2948457003,
-0.1531936377,
-0.2327639014,
-0.3662652671,
-0.1078911275,
-0.4421133995,
0.2246475518,
-0.2567107677,
0.7117173672,
0.0247434992,
0.3789703548,
0.2856514454,
-0.4675976038,
-0.1631304324,
0.532186389,
0.3011767268,
0.6010630131,
-0.1125553399,
0.014344411,
0.302490294,
-0.3887688518,
-0.0490686968,
0.294729948,
-0.1576997936,
0.1340426207,
0.5103988647,
0.9017941952,
0.5656328201,
-0.8227716684,
0.4171301126,
0.0968536958,
-0.2341494411,
-0.3498421311,
0.010462543,
-0.1748874038,
0.2515873909,
0.399897486,
0.1106176078,
0.1798892319,
-0.4461686611,
0.2755492032,
0.290461421,
-0.4872229993,
-0.2228299677,
0.7322792411,
0.0708822012,
-0.180606693,
0.7003960609,
0.3404896259,
-0.7140234709,
0.5254180431,
0.3660326004,
0.8092657924,
0.0516394675,
0.4809311628,
0.2207437456,
0.4798471928,
-0.0914836526,
0.4080035985,
0.2430057973,
-0.7241093516,
-0.4556823075,
-0.416631639,
-0.3282647133,
-0.4306773543,
-0.6733822823,
0.2549183965,
-0.1498192996,
-0.1138605475,
-0.0451550148,
0.0725792795,
-0.8899262547,
0.153626442,
-0.1276468635,
0.8685331941,
-0.9035147429,
0.6882882118,
0.6332450509,
-0.4126409292,
-0.9732408524,
-0.0929466337,
-0.7540929317,
-0.5143209696,
0.3519643247,
0.3210584521,
-0.0892790556,
0.1539783925,
-0.519466579,
-0.6300951242,
1.0614280701,
0.7801876664,
-0.8019614816,
-0.1487116814,
0.0867654979,
0.7291099429,
-0.032858748,
0.3965605795,
0.6795223355,
0.0971045792,
-0.274787426,
-1.0949312449,
0.1778198183,
0.0073061185,
0.2142556906,
0.566183269,
-0.6899347305,
0.8130328059,
-0.2116194069,
-0.0702726543,
0.4719958305,
0.6593050957,
0.032647185,
0.03368067,
0.5713713169,
1.0332665443,
0.853826344,
-0.1914087236,
0.9781419635,
-0.1562355757,
0.8546866775,
0.7908610106,
-0.409651041,
1.161872983,
0.4815559983,
-0.2852314115,
1.0051541328,
0.3770404458,
-0.0977071226,
0.751249671,
0.1900963336,
0.0625544339,
-0.4481350482,
-0.0788387656,
-0.4548973441,
0.330640316,
0.2361141443,
-0.6226915121,
-0.2055978775,
0.1951564848,
-0.0686270222,
0.4402599633,
-0.3425763547,
0.5928813815,
0.2196427137,
-0.3246289492,
0.4895735979,
-0.1025056243,
0.6709473133,
-0.3643578887,
-0.0498131737,
0.0325613096,
0.4276915789,
-0.1151849106,
-0.4894073606,
0.3440240026,
-0.1056735888,
-0.0217541363,
-0.1655950993,
0.9379214048,
-0.4408019483,
-0.4055715501,
0.2210906595,
0.421149075,
-0.0892435908,
-0.0709115416,
-0.4423263073,
0.1126300693,
-0.2919373512,
0.0265655071,
0.0726038888,
0.2903605103,
0.3479136825,
0.6291390657,
0.271807164,
-0.0326000638,
-0.0368787423,
0.3540281355,
1.0287680626,
-0.5851653814,
-0.501632452,
-1.0211621523,
0.2948821485,
-0.3116629124,
-0.4047225416,
0.6650063992,
0.4811654091,
0.8833853006,
-0.1018177643,
0.5550292134,
-0.1122039706,
0.7115588784,
-0.8025950193,
0.6579588652,
-0.6102755666,
0.2069450617,
-0.6514547467,
-1.0834856033,
-0.1960621029,
0.5308288336,
-0.1699192226,
-0.1007068828,
0.8865782022,
0.661331296,
-0.0842472613,
0.1225778386,
0.4090295434,
0.418397367,
0.0565564409,
0.8644247651,
0.9344835877,
-0.6586990356,
0.6037944555,
-0.0556749552,
0.0810656846,
-0.0738377273,
-0.7827116251,
-1.0734074116,
-0.6021628976,
-0.430852294,
-0.3493424058,
0.3339855075,
1.0091927052,
0.4034974575,
-0.7069024444,
0.380579412,
-0.2354385555,
-0.022658091,
-0.1983986795,
-0.2026008368,
0.5749459267,
-0.3372445703,
-0.5291929245,
0.0867926925,
0.1997985393,
-0.3924383223,
0.0842614472,
0.2005577385,
-0.0383788534,
0.1551201642,
0.6326723695,
0.0219509751,
-0.7210608721,
-0.8645368814,
-0.0345941633,
0.0284594353,
-0.0020103911,
0.7952796221,
-0.8823014498,
0.2024326175,
0.3501701057,
0.7625308633,
0.4776426554,
-0.1969435811,
0.6525375843,
-0.730096221,
-0.1107244939,
0.2681045532,
0.6324206591,
0.4342831373,
-0.1910536289,
0.3591022789,
-0.0861003101,
-0.6858623028,
-0.7714037895,
0.1802045256,
-0.903400898,
-0.252910018,
0.8494147062,
-0.1258750558,
-0.061114274,
-0.2004477978,
-0.1916892529,
0.2196077108,
-0.3482281566,
0.8999358416,
0.706885457,
0.1377910376,
-0.2029552162,
0.0438215062,
0.2635473609,
0.7619446516,
-0.4856094122,
-0.1535052359,
0.3423579037,
0.3687971234,
0.037412554,
0.218616873,
0.1426783502,
0.165035367,
-0.1945028007,
-0.1386879385,
0.0603525005,
-0.1374927014,
-0.1963668764,
0.2165492028,
0.1304438412,
-0.0821893513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13125v1
|
TreeEval: Benchmark-Free Evaluation of Large Language Models through Tree Planning
| 2024-02-20T16:38:33 | 2024-02-20T16:38:33 |
Xiang Li, Yunshi Lan, Chao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, numerous new benchmarks have been established to evaluate the
performance of large language models (LLMs) via either computing a holistic
score or employing another LLM as a judge. However, these approaches suffer
from data leakage due to the open access of the benchmark and inflexible
evaluation process. To address this issue, we introduce $\textbf{TreeEval}$, a
benchmark-free evaluation method for LLMs that let a high-performance LLM host
an irreproducible evaluation session and essentially avoids the data leakage.
Moreover, this LLM performs as an examiner to raise up a series of questions
under a topic with a tree planing strategy, which considers the current
evaluation status to decide the next question generation and ensures the
completeness and efficiency of the evaluation process. We evaluate $6$ models
of different parameter sizes, including $7$B, $13$B, and $33$B, and ultimately
achieved the highest correlation coefficient with AlpacaEval2.0 using only
around $45$ questions. We also conduct more analysis to show the robustness and
reliability of TreeEval. Our code can be accessed via the provided
https://github.com/Ashura5/TreeEval.
|
[
-0.0715618506,
-0.7961165309,
0.3645659685,
0.3644737899,
-0.37961182,
0.1352428943,
-0.4325397015,
-0.5048613548,
-0.0829612836,
0.4664234817,
-0.2827877998,
-0.7468126416,
-0.4297642708,
-0.3967572749,
-0.5314347148,
0.8459814191,
-0.121468626,
-0.1158309132,
-0.3137976229,
-0.4977149963,
-0.2630416155,
-0.3203183413,
-0.5250961185,
0.002479601,
0.1987530589,
0.5023444891,
0.7062883377,
0.8580120206,
0.5721331835,
0.214602083,
-0.2911728323,
-0.1330877692,
-0.5336971879,
0.4585856795,
-0.1742435247,
-0.3717972338,
-0.5808370113,
-0.2488180399,
0.7979701757,
0.5041754842,
-0.4046883583,
0.6135615706,
0.2920766473,
0.7191234231,
-0.8373205662,
0.4284549356,
-1.0034916401,
-0.2253424674,
-0.4873419106,
-0.1122564077,
-0.5414381027,
-0.6124286652,
-0.0808593035,
-0.2470149398,
-0.1116415337,
0.0619488731,
0.51790905,
0.3014004827,
-0.0901070833,
-0.1239360943,
-0.6094073057,
0.6855996847,
-0.5782728195,
0.350245744,
0.4947638512,
0.6771504283,
0.0168026388,
-0.6115137935,
-0.0779828802,
-0.4127958715,
0.3116748631,
0.0013173887,
-0.3639550805,
-0.0804366916,
0.2320616096,
0.2768918574,
-0.5866928101,
0.0567754619,
0.1427930146,
0.0976410285,
0.6453290582,
0.0698536262,
-0.0846845731,
-0.1283649653,
-0.2607750595,
-0.3468514979,
-0.8756927848,
0.0102853654,
0.0762263015,
0.3559981287,
0.0220053028,
0.4768305123,
-0.2100967169,
0.3581237197,
-0.2377998382,
0.0632490963,
0.2594112158,
-0.2979802191,
-0.3214599192,
0.015781736,
0.6924814582,
0.2519752085,
0.2542347908,
-0.1555889398,
-0.2279439718,
-0.1297259778,
-0.026185723,
-1.1818300486,
-0.0640746281,
0.3295087516,
-0.5306918025,
-0.4124653041,
-0.2097960263,
-0.975173831,
-0.2403826565,
0.1686638296,
0.179498747,
-0.3955525756,
-0.3934732676,
-0.1048529223,
0.4564776421,
0.0660789981,
0.2596972585,
-0.7269265056,
0.4786857665,
0.889202714,
0.7192137837,
-0.0828001127,
-0.2684943676,
-0.9159818292,
0.1183811426,
-0.5177624226,
0.6769730449,
-0.6602195501,
-0.5026597977,
0.119041428,
-0.0921567529,
0.0672845617,
-0.5652133226,
0.7552532554,
-0.6209756732,
-0.0998455435,
-0.0042546894,
-0.365431875,
-0.0497330539,
0.2529252172,
-0.6860685945,
1.0778521299,
0.0851244777,
-0.7409543991,
0.3152686954,
-0.6526697278,
-0.1690666229,
0.3738403022,
-0.1857340485,
-0.5032941699,
-0.0439598486,
0.3897648752,
0.0830843821,
-0.4580631256,
0.5359582901,
-0.415984422,
-0.2430997789,
-0.0728124455,
-0.7213355303,
0.8935506344,
0.2251568586,
-0.3937687874,
0.3976156414,
-0.6447278857,
0.511872828,
0.0768249035,
-0.3285030425,
-0.2686637938,
0.2465279698,
-0.0266066138,
-0.1291663796,
0.1948847026,
-0.4884607494,
0.1862120032,
-0.3313590586,
0.0933769122,
0.6800883412,
-0.1194216311,
-0.0312503129,
-0.3006052971,
0.6970002055,
-0.1972194165,
0.2398776263,
-0.1332621127,
-0.2712542713,
-0.6440775394,
-0.069090642,
0.5735940933,
0.4342655241,
-0.3158996999,
0.4071457982,
-0.4257189929,
-0.8538526297,
-0.60705477,
0.0639354959,
0.6215984821,
0.1744801998,
0.4075981081,
-0.1863464117,
-0.4228952825,
-0.7578738332,
-0.3587622643,
-0.4846504629,
0.0192983393,
0.2593314052,
0.3645595014,
0.1077984348,
0.693074882,
-0.340583533,
-0.2121665329,
-0.2250339836,
0.0954962745,
0.221437335,
0.3943631649,
0.3579235971,
-0.1411968619,
-0.6284090281,
-0.030605739,
-0.5078321099,
-0.2936730385,
0.1076266542,
-0.0115589751,
0.2935576737,
0.6112539172,
-0.5540525317,
0.2945322692,
0.7635426521,
-0.1852288395,
0.5915668011,
-0.1153925657,
-0.1656047702,
-1.0270146132,
0.3146951795,
-0.2552971542,
-0.3161236048,
-0.1897879392,
0.4223113954,
0.2682165802,
0.003044033,
-0.3549185097,
0.4777363241,
-0.5559624434,
-0.1978716403,
-0.0503072664,
0.0593460761,
-0.2080420703,
0.2599404454,
-0.1719183773,
0.7493088245,
0.6656437516,
-0.1014971361,
0.0631516278,
0.197410062,
-0.7161577344,
0.3128092587,
-0.4410884976,
0.2046466768,
0.0528391972,
0.2489230037,
-0.7614751458,
0.1098439023,
-0.0675727949,
-0.2537332177,
0.2269541323,
-0.3408690393,
-0.4660268426,
-0.1323391199,
-0.5083383918,
0.4489073455,
0.3497330844,
-0.7906675339,
0.2135048062,
0.4328223765,
-0.223326236,
-0.5427826643,
-0.5138834119,
0.1896393299,
-0.2858012617,
-0.5183221102,
0.2202293575,
-0.1926473826,
-0.3888650537,
0.1686646938,
-0.1040379405,
0.0365090258,
0.1381708086,
0.3149172962,
0.2254130244,
-0.4573306441,
0.2661292553,
-0.1105958223,
-0.1529543549,
0.163019225,
0.0045532412,
0.5146073699,
-0.5099537373,
-0.6265093684,
-0.2290763855,
0.2314992845,
0.7720045447,
-0.5519528985,
0.3960001171,
-0.1892868578,
-0.4314772487,
-0.2810413837,
-0.530721426,
0.3079592288,
-0.4380832016,
0.5374517441,
-0.5201588869,
-0.6606993675,
0.225597471,
-0.1495957524,
0.2397396564,
0.4265757799,
0.5417541265,
0.3623821735,
1.1282119751,
0.49520275,
-0.1943360418,
0.3028871119,
-0.1604611278,
-0.0808781758,
-0.7583500743,
-0.1352363527,
-0.7602317333,
-0.1026629508,
-0.6073631048,
-0.6419844627,
0.2633192241,
0.3404312432,
-0.1539590359,
0.3454110026,
-0.3319847882,
0.803337872,
0.3749358654,
-0.4570274055,
0.657225728,
-0.0298771895,
-0.371642679,
0.1519224197,
-0.4522233903,
-0.7123022676,
1.2599807978,
0.5209652781,
0.6703349352,
0.189765662,
0.655905962,
-0.1241540909,
0.6022467613,
-0.7198114395,
0.7018755674,
-0.0171697233,
-0.4315089583,
-0.4742134213,
-0.3126725256,
-1.1000982523,
0.4485431015,
0.0096715838,
-1.0455867052,
0.0256313179,
-0.1132934466,
-0.1226597205,
0.5096911192,
-0.4983264506,
0.8166373968,
-0.4709099233,
-0.5210535526,
-0.4949910343,
-0.4028441906,
0.4335398972,
-0.3027157485,
0.1627031267,
-0.1964393109,
0.0144881997,
0.8010956645,
-0.515219748,
0.3902392387,
-0.2395213544,
0.1783812046,
0.3388890326,
0.459485352,
0.5919501185,
0.1389821917,
-0.4120665491,
0.1438256502,
0.3492000103,
-0.1748431623,
-0.3757193089,
0.8903483748,
-0.6340143681,
-0.5861672759,
-0.5237989426,
-0.5756116509,
-0.5792357326,
0.1547744721,
-0.2508687675,
0.2904422581,
-0.4928165972,
0.5568515062,
0.0951194093,
-0.0579126142,
0.7339946628,
0.6728417277,
-0.6960669756,
-0.3758096993,
0.5478892326,
0.0063998974,
0.358187288,
0.319701165,
0.4807229042,
-0.3850126863,
-0.7870283723,
-0.4113019705,
0.0832457319,
-0.4588771164,
-0.3764726818,
-0.2873114944,
-0.480311811,
-0.0045854431,
0.3034990728,
-0.5106195807,
-0.5267490745,
0.2837067246,
-0.2233940661,
0.3135148585,
0.5258065462,
0.0936479419,
0.1894771755,
-0.7036848664,
-0.1086153165,
0.1195250079,
0.595080018,
0.3307946622,
-0.1464093328,
-0.1213704273,
-0.0622983947,
-0.5113901496,
-0.5641474128,
0.2719720006,
0.1300041229,
0.4791239202,
0.5752418637,
0.1068456545,
0.8879752755,
-0.4385751486,
0.3516739011,
-0.0502230376,
-0.9555581212,
0.5789960623,
-0.1395473182,
0.4141256511,
1.0785610676,
0.1826360226,
-0.4747486711,
-0.5462440252,
-0.7133049965,
-0.8197265863,
0.5816919804,
0.0622681007,
-0.1140083745,
0.0545482598,
-0.1059852839,
0.0913744345,
0.0748281255,
-0.5977671146,
0.1820141971,
-0.0690084025,
0.0743009746,
0.0196791533,
-0.3314900994,
-0.1396545619,
-0.2727498114,
0.6106977463,
-0.1412341595,
-0.2824842036,
-0.0434421487,
-0.1715857983,
-0.4156655967,
0.4344646037,
0.05260529,
0.8806185126,
-0.5218148232,
0.3640437126,
0.3181089461,
-0.2935818136,
-0.0762750432,
0.1736049056,
-0.1608058363,
-0.054644987,
0.595264852,
0.4908440709,
0.0409892984,
-0.7157206535,
0.6444394588,
-0.0629887208,
-0.1726637185,
-0.0131483283,
-0.2217856795,
0.3165478408,
0.2241649032,
0.1250428557,
-0.1769032627,
-0.2554368079,
-0.5813415647,
0.3364779353,
0.6283827424,
-0.5001236796,
-0.1397213936,
0.6211102009,
0.0432527736,
-0.4247410297,
0.5791301727,
-0.0855992883,
-0.2738996148,
0.3710319996,
0.6034115553,
1.0884486437,
-0.5859211683,
0.1848507077,
0.4172578454,
0.3182731569,
0.150810495,
0.2584849596,
-0.1195229366,
-0.3067824841,
-0.4226076603,
-0.7849906087,
-0.5287919641,
0.436914891,
-0.4486419261,
0.282373637,
-0.402816534,
0.2327776998,
-0.2960400879,
0.1551535726,
-0.2872405648,
-0.0644254833,
-0.2205523849,
1.4073797464,
-0.5518859029,
1.1100050211,
0.1176254824,
-0.1888513118,
-0.7594441175,
0.3166512549,
-0.06989225,
-0.9682022333,
0.5031185746,
0.2485321015,
-0.1675230563,
-0.2414040118,
-0.1747942716,
-0.9801305532,
0.9868305922,
0.4018940628,
-0.8068322539,
0.0448857695,
0.2835044563,
0.592443943,
-0.2453107536,
0.5925248265,
0.5937924385,
0.4838852882,
0.2745126784,
-0.9642435312,
0.1928410679,
-0.3318040669,
-0.0329066291,
0.3778759837,
-0.5700047016,
0.5337234735,
-0.0756768212,
-0.4230274856,
0.199189648,
0.3051628172,
0.3330219984,
0.0847956315,
0.7795449495,
0.5978040695,
0.8783426881,
0.0999711007,
0.9550557733,
-0.7205346227,
0.3447890282,
1.373455286,
-0.4887222946,
1.4722677469,
0.3348868787,
-0.2596167326,
0.3515284657,
0.4807598591,
0.1003038809,
0.5274159312,
0.5110701323,
-0.3323122859,
-0.0969297364,
-0.155355379,
-0.4793945253,
0.563649416,
0.1268328875,
-0.1522504985,
-0.6925901771,
-0.585947752,
0.114071466,
0.0310636349,
-0.1760025024,
0.5915116668,
0.0536251441,
-0.8721591234,
0.6573888063,
-0.105375357,
0.0927377045,
-0.6986852288,
0.0781713501,
-0.1600275785,
0.4282085001,
-0.1763204038,
-0.7917329073,
0.5170433521,
0.1483949721,
0.3277232647,
-0.3253732324,
0.4874577224,
-0.357642144,
-0.662443459,
0.6080269814,
0.6980756521,
0.2771324217,
-0.1986567378,
-0.5810447931,
0.0973138437,
-0.2264195532,
-0.2659907341,
0.3775960207,
0.1367207319,
-0.6464145184,
0.779301703,
0.6751021743,
0.4368001223,
-0.2005304992,
0.2493081242,
0.7896157503,
-0.5051913857,
-0.3077746332,
-1.0082497597,
0.2594617605,
0.0184101108,
-0.2333005667,
0.7187529206,
1.1635857821,
0.5727157593,
0.3467361331,
0.5436475277,
0.2520281374,
0.6319685578,
-0.4261412621,
0.833568275,
-0.2813489139,
0.5070909858,
-0.3216929138,
-1.2163953781,
-0.3660568297,
0.3270097971,
-0.2862198353,
-0.15167135,
0.9918043017,
0.7999503613,
-0.097123079,
0.2272003144,
0.2004789859,
0.3160138428,
0.5260441303,
0.8264166117,
0.8904329538,
-0.0756616369,
0.8844456077,
-0.0922488123,
-0.5570446849,
-0.1330168247,
-1.0642558336,
-0.6178649664,
-0.3457218111,
-0.3084635735,
-0.2240757793,
0.1606601626,
0.6803015471,
0.7385495305,
-0.7964779735,
-0.8005574942,
-0.2834362686,
0.181032151,
-0.1885963976,
-0.1920001954,
0.7395169735,
-0.21124354,
-0.483839184,
0.6210824251,
0.2623220086,
-0.2220910192,
-0.3922848403,
0.0215384625,
-0.0615835749,
-0.0250866003,
0.4555675387,
0.1004200578,
-0.6246215701,
-0.4072476923,
-0.3064694107,
0.0945739672,
0.2942258418,
0.5221647024,
-0.8581362963,
0.3972607553,
0.4192563593,
0.7808073759,
0.980474174,
0.1555504501,
0.2512032688,
-0.6342082024,
-0.1416000575,
0.3324351907,
0.3362096548,
0.2198626399,
0.1061497107,
0.66894871,
-0.3121066988,
-0.6193088889,
-0.906041801,
0.1977986842,
-0.9404306412,
-0.1746675074,
1.0418869257,
-0.072504133,
-0.2375243604,
0.2748757601,
-0.1781093031,
0.0270105302,
-0.2629202902,
0.6805998683,
0.7921507955,
-0.0874865502,
-0.1468414068,
-0.5766547918,
0.3537674248,
0.4454694986,
-1.1640713215,
0.6951934695,
0.316916734,
0.2490899563,
0.08455313,
0.6406601071,
-0.3582763076,
0.0207935981,
-0.076380156,
-0.1659310162,
-0.0227408111,
-0.319313854,
-0.409214884,
0.4516224265,
0.5610417128,
-0.3818005919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13116v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13116v3
|
A Survey on Knowledge Distillation of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T16:17:37 | 2024-03-08T13:29:03 |
Xiaohan Xu, Ming Li, Chongyang Tao, Tao Shen, Reynold Cheng, Jinyang Li, Can Xu, Dacheng Tao, Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of Large Language Models (LLMs), Knowledge Distillation (KD)
emerges as a pivotal methodology for transferring advanced capabilities from
leading proprietary LLMs, such as GPT-4, to their open-source counterparts like
LLaMA and Mistral. Additionally, as open-source LLMs flourish, KD plays a
crucial role in both compressing these models, and facilitating their
self-improvement by employing themselves as teachers. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey of KD's role within the realm of LLM, highlighting its
critical function in imparting advanced knowledge to smaller models and its
utility in model compression and self-improvement. Our survey is meticulously
structured around three foundational pillars: \textit{algorithm},
\textit{skill}, and \textit{verticalization} -- providing a comprehensive
examination of KD mechanisms, the enhancement of specific cognitive abilities,
and their practical implications across diverse fields. Crucially, the survey
navigates the intricate interplay between data augmentation (DA) and KD,
illustrating how DA emerges as a powerful paradigm within the KD framework to
bolster LLMs' performance. By leveraging DA to generate context-rich,
skill-specific training data, KD transcends traditional boundaries, enabling
open-source models to approximate the contextual adeptness, ethical alignment,
and deep semantic insights characteristic of their proprietary counterparts.
This work aims to provide an insightful guide for researchers and
practitioners, offering a detailed overview of current methodologies in KD and
proposing future research directions. Importantly, we firmly advocate for
compliance with the legal terms that regulate the use of LLMs, ensuring ethical
and lawful application of KD of LLMs. An associated Github repository is
available at https://github.com/Tebmer/Awesome-Knowledge-Distillation-of-LLMs.
|
[
-0.4128374457,
-0.7614111304,
0.8253430128,
-0.2056698203,
-0.1242975444,
0.3439386785,
-0.4265664816,
-0.208608225,
-0.1448130757,
0.4340694547,
-0.3457174003,
-0.5027393103,
-0.9292579889,
-0.1821329743,
-0.3218294382,
1.0448784828,
0.0148670552,
0.1659536809,
-0.5144043565,
-0.0673933029,
-0.4812048972,
-0.7407425642,
-0.2631750405,
-0.5870440602,
0.5185064077,
0.3911180198,
0.4269125462,
0.5842561126,
0.3392162025,
0.2837891281,
-0.313266784,
-0.0161246974,
-0.8179002404,
0.3469775021,
-0.1386231333,
-0.5460858941,
-0.4308004677,
0.1035062894,
0.456035018,
0.7525514364,
-0.3710275292,
0.1952038556,
0.331858784,
0.989741683,
-0.7177847028,
0.2219698578,
-0.6486413479,
-0.0453746878,
-0.245298326,
0.1200876012,
-0.0728278086,
-0.5749989152,
0.2761943936,
-0.4849233329,
-0.0074737589,
-0.3359976709,
0.4171434045,
0.6446124911,
-0.6180387735,
-0.4618366361,
-0.9829607606,
0.7043901682,
-0.7899823189,
0.4888271987,
0.398614496,
0.5211620331,
-0.1652870178,
-0.8963091969,
-0.5691431165,
-0.1499507278,
0.1189391166,
-0.0470886603,
-0.0597120002,
0.0898867249,
0.2762299776,
0.8476297855,
-0.0358121842,
0.2912241817,
-0.6443389654,
-0.0616712905,
0.4605876207,
-0.0906383917,
0.169767037,
0.2048752904,
-0.0457382202,
-0.2170666754,
-0.8333064318,
-0.2042971551,
0.3664105237,
-0.0983260721,
0.0929786786,
0.6503587365,
-0.3348526657,
0.5158283114,
0.1623384058,
-0.5425323248,
0.2087897509,
-0.3202706277,
-0.1694136411,
0.1496464759,
0.6632980108,
0.3112995625,
0.2675617039,
-0.1245317683,
-0.0970158353,
-0.1829908043,
-0.0082300957,
-0.7480937243,
-0.5789980888,
0.0272431821,
-0.2513394058,
-0.3800302148,
-0.2998584509,
-0.6986066699,
-0.7386277914,
-0.5890185833,
0.1641299576,
-0.3227600753,
-0.5382676721,
0.169139877,
-0.3329132795,
-0.1016772538,
0.1370618343,
-0.924308002,
0.1161486655,
0.6100406647,
0.6787425876,
-0.0715994015,
-0.2035665512,
-0.1096236259,
0.2029666901,
-0.3617056906,
0.3781870604,
-0.363376379,
-0.4799115658,
-0.1128860265,
-0.2179422826,
0.3920101821,
-0.7062884569,
0.6334046125,
-0.7337892652,
-0.0893617645,
-0.4492987096,
-0.754719317,
-0.2706394494,
0.2457226813,
-0.6804447174,
0.9895114303,
0.0607681461,
-0.6848608255,
0.6430264115,
-0.6122869849,
-0.041470632,
0.092373006,
-0.3306006491,
-0.1554684043,
0.2625260651,
0.2853986025,
0.5536987185,
-0.4542007744,
0.45135957,
-0.5539973378,
0.2712541819,
0.0840854347,
-0.4800215662,
0.7850137353,
0.3641586304,
0.0121276435,
-0.1953511387,
-0.7580732703,
-0.0290849321,
0.1502696723,
-0.3808505237,
-0.7738817334,
-0.1180502698,
-0.331628412,
0.2378027737,
0.4107603729,
-0.4321329594,
0.3822957277,
-0.1777262092,
0.6196043491,
0.851860404,
0.1078113243,
0.6746426225,
-0.1001995057,
0.5497947931,
0.0313727222,
0.126152724,
-0.1065532863,
-0.2570848763,
-0.4530549645,
-0.4198067486,
0.4945343733,
0.1032701954,
-0.9016445875,
0.3830368817,
-0.3688818216,
-0.9308788776,
-0.7710393667,
0.4591180086,
0.1582150757,
0.5473219156,
0.2435366213,
0.2147625983,
-0.3241859376,
-0.871940434,
-0.017748272,
-0.1555713415,
0.0811798945,
0.2225879878,
0.3218908608,
-0.0733318552,
1.0503207445,
-0.737518549,
-0.4250656962,
-0.1613748521,
-0.0301138014,
0.1967172623,
0.3637045324,
0.676551342,
-0.6066153049,
-0.6425530314,
0.116748631,
-0.8260400295,
-0.2948539853,
0.3301726282,
-0.0792403519,
0.0167827066,
0.6045085788,
-0.5856334567,
0.0442413576,
0.6320131421,
-0.1067519784,
0.5579228401,
-0.4656584859,
0.1941057593,
-1.1674892902,
0.0487641916,
-0.1616124511,
-0.0339924805,
-0.6455073357,
0.1491087973,
0.0482555255,
0.262529403,
-0.2269164324,
0.2897576392,
-0.633713007,
-0.0152838789,
-0.4355596304,
0.1717089266,
-0.1345753372,
0.1052870005,
-0.1326798499,
0.4934648275,
0.6270501018,
-0.5885105133,
0.6234030128,
0.0144371558,
-0.7073335052,
0.4926426709,
-0.5358144641,
0.1577473134,
-0.2186015695,
0.2516663671,
-0.88652879,
-0.205763638,
0.0366579443,
-0.235270068,
0.2307141423,
-0.4163634479,
-0.733166337,
-0.3252048492,
-0.0599065498,
0.5372954011,
0.842899859,
-0.5687268972,
0.4178973734,
0.6098966002,
-0.3304976523,
-0.6295696497,
-0.6760736108,
-0.0033580298,
-0.3883734047,
-0.5367949605,
0.1328317672,
-0.2381258756,
-0.4177184999,
0.1338760257,
-0.2214382142,
-0.1639872044,
0.1482046098,
0.099894695,
0.2952870727,
-0.0871274397,
0.1236639097,
0.2865722775,
0.1994047165,
0.1451221406,
-0.3471971452,
0.561550498,
0.3072916865,
-0.5543962717,
-0.2014901936,
-0.0995269418,
0.8032005429,
0.0422014035,
0.6449132562,
0.465038687,
-0.1396996528,
-0.3057487607,
-0.8207985163,
-0.2192095518,
-0.4642733634,
0.2964648902,
-0.3169718981,
-1.2199189663,
0.4047642648,
-0.2689831257,
-0.0176472738,
0.4208220243,
0.78143996,
0.1555279493,
0.7164775729,
0.7239261866,
-0.4254281521,
0.297093153,
-0.2557307482,
0.294876039,
-0.6990758777,
-0.2628803849,
-0.4376526177,
-0.4479600489,
-0.3727451563,
-0.4595790207,
0.5508021116,
0.4398566484,
0.0385748595,
-0.1517581195,
-0.5336792469,
0.6560139656,
0.4625439048,
-0.2529540658,
0.6538107395,
-0.1387639493,
-0.0746960491,
-0.079183042,
-0.6132941842,
-0.3256623745,
1.4712045193,
0.5411308408,
0.9342547059,
-0.0369488969,
0.7962796092,
0.3903229535,
-0.0125705982,
-0.8602728248,
0.3696289361,
0.1463757753,
-0.6081891656,
-0.3244768977,
-0.4161499739,
-0.5610405803,
0.1664175093,
0.093739368,
-0.4820933044,
0.2618564665,
0.2778612971,
-0.2619558573,
0.3203259408,
-0.8840178847,
0.6815479994,
-0.120222576,
-0.0490288921,
-0.4336362481,
-0.3702600002,
0.8708210588,
-0.4563149214,
0.1837563664,
-0.158973217,
-0.0083686402,
0.5417588353,
-0.4883910418,
0.7676756382,
-0.5380658507,
-0.7224524021,
0.2304158062,
0.0555354171,
0.5174495578,
-0.151177153,
0.1720401347,
0.3419826031,
0.3202570379,
-0.0674650073,
-0.6846498251,
0.9267439246,
-0.8222737312,
-0.6670034528,
-0.1228636205,
-0.5944151878,
-0.1806105077,
0.1683609337,
-0.045780696,
0.1278074086,
-0.037447013,
0.4456410706,
0.7640022039,
-0.0078377323,
0.31091699,
0.5401545167,
-0.4696339369,
-0.379522413,
0.8447357416,
0.4492673576,
0.4973883033,
0.0925532654,
0.2015552521,
-0.5916388631,
-0.7402703762,
-0.2686488032,
0.1048984155,
-0.9970867634,
-0.1096484587,
-0.6112055779,
-0.3006152213,
-0.6162549853,
0.1002216712,
-0.5020526648,
-0.5527288914,
-0.1372985095,
-0.3443834186,
0.5149019361,
0.9207874537,
-0.1363739371,
0.1464722753,
-0.6776078939,
0.314060837,
0.4384566545,
0.2291480601,
0.2185918242,
-0.3892965615,
-0.2276556641,
0.2301805913,
-0.2172538042,
-0.5000695586,
0.258823216,
0.1315481812,
0.6563987136,
0.3980790079,
0.3435887098,
0.6597919464,
-0.5101419687,
0.8650367856,
0.1851709038,
-0.6743181348,
0.3950496018,
-0.1488986164,
0.2703023255,
0.5754847527,
0.6025019288,
-0.6855397224,
-0.3802575767,
-0.332539469,
-0.8052044511,
0.7650337219,
-0.0432621911,
0.0296959691,
0.2186104059,
0.4008870721,
0.3526509404,
0.3073711097,
-0.5308491588,
-0.3847082853,
0.0666465685,
-0.2140462846,
-0.0473236144,
-0.3268648982,
-0.1786335707,
-0.3420777917,
0.8434074521,
0.018917961,
-0.3182848394,
0.0560579933,
-0.2250001281,
0.1878200322,
0.2659388483,
0.1995587498,
0.7205913067,
0.1365825683,
0.265083313,
0.040680103,
-0.6105984449,
0.2774292529,
-0.0113492254,
-0.0458478257,
-0.4272778034,
-0.0042959796,
0.5528588891,
-0.1419112533,
-0.6344242692,
0.4073319733,
0.161743626,
-0.371086359,
-0.1969586015,
0.1500566155,
0.2386524975,
0.5253642797,
0.3904159665,
-0.2331496775,
0.2206816226,
-0.4410273731,
-0.0695126653,
0.2936302125,
-0.1206192225,
-0.2620462179,
0.5995849371,
0.0293431431,
0.2729679048,
0.4956854582,
-0.1847828329,
-0.1782691777,
0.2673887014,
0.2225566804,
0.8492078185,
-0.2642019689,
0.0701864213,
0.1655466855,
0.0593238734,
-0.1970163286,
0.0161709189,
-0.3415274024,
-0.7932662964,
-0.6347280741,
-0.7680929303,
-0.0183667522,
0.3838145435,
-0.5147832632,
0.1736792028,
-0.2786394358,
-0.1058288589,
0.0377752483,
-0.1427013129,
-0.3431889415,
-0.2586550415,
0.1883100867,
0.777759254,
-0.7088154554,
1.09497118,
0.560105145,
-0.3511029184,
-0.6234215498,
0.0127090029,
0.2053894401,
-0.7627321482,
0.9374975562,
-0.41955176,
-0.013438818,
0.3023233712,
-0.5183793902,
-0.7406045794,
1.4358121157,
0.5533405542,
-0.7194860578,
-0.0913989767,
0.3577823639,
0.5837376118,
-0.0568393581,
0.0134150684,
0.8953626156,
0.4512362778,
0.3077582121,
-1.0662323236,
-0.0281292349,
-0.0779282674,
0.1574626565,
0.1238102689,
-0.4137228727,
0.5387889147,
0.0384209305,
-0.1260350496,
-0.1255331188,
0.4207231402,
0.2299969792,
0.0919696838,
0.3728998899,
0.7675533891,
0.8043589592,
-0.0493076928,
0.6767011881,
-0.5399308801,
0.2233893573,
1.1719566584,
-0.326495856,
0.5331484079,
0.6509193182,
-0.2361391187,
0.2179480493,
0.3445170224,
-0.0067316187,
0.7508621216,
0.2309378386,
-0.350692302,
0.0449249446,
-0.1392404884,
-0.4683370888,
0.3254258037,
0.3171328604,
-0.4036729932,
-0.4052780271,
0.1641465724,
0.0007537436,
0.1443301439,
-0.3492211103,
1.1317681074,
0.117144756,
-0.6424399018,
0.5462026,
-0.1826884598,
0.6997330189,
-0.5906258225,
-0.0503125563,
-0.0887652785,
0.287374109,
-0.1319948584,
-0.9062545896,
0.1923379451,
0.015652461,
-0.4005321264,
-0.3841886818,
0.8954190612,
-0.6583154202,
-0.1475193799,
0.3148802221,
0.7668885589,
0.1517151594,
-0.1750597805,
-0.441323936,
0.1478375494,
-0.0204470102,
-0.0112725925,
0.514775753,
0.8819816709,
0.1730009466,
0.7259604931,
0.5526316166,
0.3561924994,
0.1968057305,
0.1482437253,
1.1319497824,
-0.3269824088,
-0.3146722317,
-1.1010890007,
0.4743800461,
-0.1334349215,
-0.059163332,
0.9208657146,
0.5645032525,
1.0457758904,
-0.1638080925,
1.0763654709,
-0.2920698822,
0.4632829428,
-0.5691105127,
1.1175906658,
-0.333738327,
0.3746534586,
-0.1736373156,
-1.0511599779,
0.1684023738,
0.0468741655,
-0.4896312356,
0.0117508015,
0.4704425931,
0.69040519,
-0.0713146254,
-0.0697842911,
0.464638412,
0.3831481636,
0.4327057302,
0.166312784,
1.0627833605,
-0.0834508687,
0.5473951101,
-0.4182517231,
-0.2024511397,
-0.0120197488,
-0.9063365459,
-0.8143928647,
-0.8617994189,
-0.3441482186,
-0.0283425041,
-0.2075791359,
0.9256142974,
0.5783148408,
-0.4054957628,
-0.126792863,
-0.2026014328,
0.1018767953,
0.0752262771,
-0.2305569798,
0.193556577,
-0.5201324224,
-0.9072568417,
0.3915371597,
0.0929071903,
0.0940988362,
-0.6453660727,
-0.1270456761,
-0.0043709669,
-0.2972100377,
0.7213453054,
0.0873457342,
-0.7119818926,
0.0579255782,
-0.2376148403,
0.0497606285,
-0.1948204786,
0.8201730251,
-0.8094928265,
0.5449227691,
0.5274695754,
0.8167147636,
0.4385875762,
-0.2366471887,
0.6738998294,
-0.7437277436,
-0.1062620357,
0.1513564438,
0.1974824071,
0.1625935435,
-0.3067337871,
0.4721586108,
0.2904886007,
-0.8255403042,
-0.9643966556,
0.1106291935,
-0.5800955296,
-0.3669858575,
1.2153732777,
-0.2319586724,
-0.0873737559,
-0.1243215203,
-0.4152216613,
0.1393266916,
-0.4311195016,
0.8766596913,
1.1402635574,
0.1886329204,
-0.1489124298,
-0.704937458,
0.7571969628,
-0.1179800034,
-0.6305398345,
0.4264436364,
0.9506218433,
0.3980771899,
0.058751747,
0.6587565541,
-0.2909614444,
-0.1498413682,
-0.1504153758,
0.2330399305,
-0.2646563053,
-0.2070112675,
-0.4456871152,
0.134985432,
0.4457504153,
0.0760101154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13113v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13113v2
|
When Only Time Will Tell: Interpreting How Transformers Process Local Ambiguities Through the Lens of Restart-Incrementality
| 2024-02-20T16:09:49 | 2024-06-02T14:48:13 |
Brielen Madureira, Patrick Kahardipraja, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Incremental models that process sentences one token at a time will sometimes
encounter points where more than one interpretation is possible. Causal models
are forced to output one interpretation and continue, whereas models that can
revise may edit their previous output as the ambiguity is resolved. In this
work, we look at how restart-incremental Transformers build and update internal
states, in an effort to shed light on what processes cause revisions not viable
in autoregressive models. We propose an interpretable way to analyse the
incremental states, showing that their sequential structure encodes information
on the garden path effect and its resolution. Our method brings insights on
various bidirectional encoders for contextualised meaning representation and
dependency parsing, contributing to show their advantage over causal models
when it comes to revisions.
|
[
-0.1074756831,
-0.5231687427,
0.7647420764,
0.4929981828,
0.0564814508,
0.0298353955,
-0.0553536154,
-0.5671365261,
0.1967879683,
0.5258339047,
-1.1129695177,
0.1392368525,
-0.7208861709,
0.4711357653,
-0.5974274278,
0.7453967929,
-0.4257593751,
-0.1696975678,
0.013003896,
-0.2445389479,
-0.7716321945,
-0.2023167014,
-0.7852424383,
-0.7163761854,
0.3310073912,
0.3561743796,
0.8580718637,
0.8302158713,
0.2822312713,
0.3239484727,
-0.2945577502,
-0.4050549269,
-0.2438747883,
0.6273095608,
-0.1638339609,
-0.7225582004,
0.1396585703,
-0.0511208512,
0.8624857664,
0.791710794,
-0.071367301,
0.2375563979,
0.0059234854,
0.5031924248,
-0.333671838,
0.309656918,
-0.8015242815,
0.3677347302,
-0.1065982506,
-0.6405521631,
-0.6247751713,
-0.0639917776,
-0.0574683845,
-0.309153825,
0.4597340822,
-0.2331906855,
0.9797187448,
0.794400692,
-0.5918576121,
-0.0403033979,
-1.073014617,
0.6877646446,
-0.5891894698,
0.3661720455,
-0.2905289829,
0.5911715627,
-0.2974730432,
-0.8887899518,
-0.7042211294,
-0.1440493912,
-0.4698132277,
0.2357053161,
-0.1145338714,
-0.381051898,
0.436403513,
0.3108186424,
-0.2375733554,
-0.0789464712,
-0.0819172859,
0.0409947298,
0.1215891913,
0.4300602674,
0.1198889613,
-0.6517599821,
-0.8086733222,
-0.2494028509,
-0.5073599815,
0.2913079858,
0.2663137317,
0.0832385272,
-0.1318435073,
0.5118847489,
0.0439359024,
0.5239066482,
0.4063828588,
0.1746218055,
-0.0563923791,
-0.2043219805,
-0.2652725577,
0.2653707564,
0.6688963175,
0.1348421127,
0.0052843187,
-0.2368225008,
-0.1145414785,
0.2972871363,
0.4326834679,
-0.5487683415,
-0.0216741171,
0.2986633182,
-0.3533234894,
-0.304027915,
0.2261587381,
-0.7269821763,
-0.4043770134,
-0.5181772113,
0.4087173641,
-0.2516227067,
-0.189201355,
0.2556750178,
-0.3525889516,
0.2484048158,
0.4248574078,
-0.5255342126,
-0.0529316589,
0.4880363941,
0.8322336078,
0.1659727842,
-0.5050623417,
-0.1737982929,
0.2556039393,
-0.3670296669,
0.8673419952,
-0.2863863409,
-0.4389776289,
-0.2593947947,
0.798641026,
-0.0060137589,
-0.2273402363,
0.1281975657,
-0.5609106421,
-0.0615438446,
-0.3910855651,
0.0543103181,
0.0205596182,
0.1360275745,
-0.6619715095,
0.5895262957,
0.1752162725,
-0.8192810416,
0.6553142667,
-0.491007179,
-0.4971056283,
-0.3371299207,
-0.1514166445,
-0.2819623649,
0.0066257464,
0.0710239187,
-0.0487305596,
0.0337234996,
0.3973631263,
-0.115099065,
-0.0557896681,
0.2721320689,
-0.9142278433,
0.9398562312,
0.0721084699,
-0.5351216197,
0.3526376188,
-0.4986459911,
-0.4162418246,
0.1649804711,
0.0460004918,
0.2397108823,
0.2638327777,
-0.3998812437,
0.2863011062,
0.1732507348,
-0.7721229792,
0.3349095583,
-0.225773111,
0.4750975072,
1.1266839504,
0.5581197143,
0.5149399638,
-0.4536688924,
0.5330674052,
0.6458978057,
0.4992502034,
-0.7578559518,
-0.6601938009,
-1.0563348532,
0.2979027033,
-0.1406198144,
0.5100457668,
-0.7277784348,
-0.0716238692,
-0.4262755215,
-0.4737243354,
-0.560880959,
-0.2999249101,
-0.0522550605,
0.5720991492,
0.4030236006,
-0.5070511699,
-0.589363575,
-1.0481158495,
-0.5966150761,
-0.117553331,
-0.0140856896,
0.1336693466,
0.5465477705,
-0.4250194728,
1.0815707445,
-0.4879691601,
-0.1060374603,
0.2189403027,
0.531961143,
0.5031968355,
0.361364007,
0.1858043522,
-0.5722844005,
-0.4477864206,
-0.0697446615,
-0.9282264709,
-0.0103207733,
-0.8046614528,
-0.0094401687,
-0.0506238602,
0.5204636455,
-0.6910484433,
0.5718644261,
0.1785907298,
-0.8717426658,
0.4381102324,
-0.3392296433,
0.5666473508,
-0.5962203741,
-0.3083431721,
-0.2159033418,
-0.273552984,
-0.1329333484,
-0.2053903341,
-0.0246739853,
-0.0928718373,
-0.173095122,
0.4382182062,
-0.4997025728,
-0.2800454795,
-0.0913195163,
0.0126977982,
0.114175804,
0.2738471627,
-0.1809641421,
0.6967715025,
0.0987083539,
-0.5459868908,
0.1243870929,
0.3520966768,
-0.2627795041,
0.3978479207,
-0.4384836853,
0.0664794073,
-0.5474715233,
0.3940600753,
-1.0744092464,
-0.1267437488,
0.2341809571,
-0.5517240167,
0.3989312053,
-0.2524121702,
-0.6197955012,
-0.2788589597,
0.0582143217,
0.2903492153,
0.2919971347,
-0.8807238936,
0.7094627619,
0.151351735,
0.2858297229,
-0.3594928384,
-0.7139803767,
0.1414134651,
-0.136115849,
-0.7655134201,
0.2729873955,
0.1615611762,
-0.507036984,
0.2056708634,
-0.1639570743,
0.1744025052,
0.236022234,
0.5156273842,
-0.045420967,
0.0513261408,
0.1027516946,
0.0439820923,
-0.5071003437,
0.2923024297,
-0.2584486306,
0.3647445738,
0.032320831,
-0.5123053789,
-0.3658230007,
0.4608671665,
0.8632053733,
-0.077183038,
0.8834825158,
0.4415578246,
-0.2844767272,
-0.0587493293,
-0.3375297785,
-0.2509836853,
-0.4844563305,
-0.1431297511,
-0.4706253111,
-0.4391071796,
0.5266248584,
0.0709816068,
0.1829134375,
0.732298851,
0.3927372694,
-0.1223756149,
0.9990954399,
0.6924211383,
0.0785600021,
0.3680001795,
-0.2615947127,
0.3371347189,
-0.7102906108,
-0.3659536242,
-0.4445021152,
-0.2944941521,
-0.6031162739,
-0.393397063,
0.5150386095,
0.0582192913,
-0.4945743382,
0.5340585709,
-0.6682854891,
0.2629709244,
0.3696306944,
0.071260199,
0.5418248773,
-0.2625133395,
0.1427799463,
-0.2359751612,
-0.5777495503,
-0.4688604176,
0.6077923179,
0.2400697172,
0.5801891088,
0.2185684144,
0.138292715,
0.376137048,
0.6328597665,
-0.7315301299,
0.2918959856,
0.1478315443,
-0.5502578616,
-0.0985801369,
-0.189952597,
-1.090088129,
0.2957023084,
-0.0680274144,
-0.7607065439,
0.5105755925,
0.0267502554,
-0.0974121094,
0.6710122228,
-0.6262016892,
0.9950268865,
-0.1008078754,
-0.2544000745,
-0.2670449018,
-0.550408721,
0.2610047758,
0.0444864258,
0.1529851854,
0.1303445101,
0.1836223453,
0.4351116717,
-0.2667700946,
0.7981693745,
-0.2127921283,
0.0366533138,
0.3391472101,
0.3884433806,
0.6626351476,
0.067773357,
0.1231792346,
0.3095869124,
0.2772923112,
-0.2122603804,
-0.7210456729,
0.7288580537,
-0.5926569104,
-0.7764193416,
-0.6543365717,
-0.3995587528,
-0.0498613082,
-0.1633260697,
0.4160509408,
0.4273317456,
0.3305861652,
-0.1583400816,
0.3837034106,
-0.2623711526,
0.8006230593,
0.4256117344,
-0.2708304524,
0.061505042,
0.1542026997,
0.1189031377,
0.2525261939,
0.2125293314,
-0.0530859604,
-0.0836215988,
0.2162858248,
-0.4473175108,
0.2251805365,
-1.1349396706,
-0.0698855072,
-0.6233827472,
-0.1057434678,
-0.2900646925,
-0.3618486822,
-0.397808522,
-0.2379773259,
-0.1289956421,
-0.0220643971,
0.4682716131,
1.1167324781,
-0.2670466006,
0.2795365453,
-0.7989492416,
0.3095577955,
0.2206234783,
0.1385961473,
0.2109983116,
-0.5448629856,
-0.1501632631,
-0.0867377445,
-0.4437410831,
-1.1711119413,
0.2693006098,
-0.174739331,
0.0994520411,
0.3413406312,
-0.204970479,
0.9637007117,
-0.8730480075,
0.8575881124,
0.1476134807,
-0.9489603639,
0.6751856208,
-0.1877227277,
0.8388897777,
0.1800354719,
0.2370927036,
-0.9771117568,
-0.5448145866,
-0.8602304459,
-1.0241264105,
0.3209412396,
0.1115961149,
0.055964835,
-0.167703554,
0.5128725171,
0.2769142985,
0.0601719469,
-0.6616473794,
-0.4728549421,
-0.3523808122,
0.1650625467,
-0.0929506123,
-0.3786761761,
-0.0578301325,
-0.2461347282,
0.458596468,
0.3034712374,
0.6183208823,
0.4464160204,
-0.1180266961,
-0.658313632,
0.4614253938,
0.0767862126,
0.7374249101,
-0.0847852603,
0.0494352095,
0.1003986746,
-0.0869186744,
0.4144612253,
-0.1043727547,
-0.3963301182,
0.3733910322,
0.7852799296,
0.7933117151,
0.5201672316,
-0.2292634696,
0.2853904963,
-0.1267352253,
0.3199495971,
-0.8215635419,
-0.0932057351,
-0.3649168313,
0.6272621155,
0.3680108488,
0.5099692345,
0.0284952801,
-0.7233777046,
0.4999964833,
0.2353830636,
-0.7428640127,
-0.5170801282,
0.9193885922,
-0.4091480076,
-0.39076823,
0.6704923511,
-0.0119151874,
-0.4748401046,
0.6471863389,
0.4008134007,
1.0776578188,
-0.1710048169,
0.0723993704,
0.7122120261,
0.4465579391,
0.1651293188,
0.0650988594,
-0.1452881843,
-0.7392897606,
-0.6824167967,
-0.6682445407,
-0.3249741793,
-0.0807676464,
-0.8852801919,
0.0250540152,
-0.3422635794,
-0.313260287,
-0.1583948582,
-0.6429054141,
-0.7219046354,
0.2434527427,
-0.2312987894,
0.7800955176,
-0.9541413188,
0.5917104483,
0.4231289327,
-0.4059742093,
-0.6620835066,
0.3164504766,
0.0316752531,
-0.4835431278,
0.8128216267,
0.2054517269,
-0.2033378035,
-0.0206884034,
-0.4904107749,
-0.9979914427,
1.0932514668,
0.0392745845,
-0.4094772637,
-0.0262190811,
-0.0319399051,
0.4449073076,
0.0113376649,
0.1839041561,
0.7476586103,
0.6970606446,
0.1301973909,
-0.830289185,
0.1048944294,
0.0168491211,
-0.0794366524,
0.5744741559,
-0.4284403026,
1.1158450842,
-0.2661980689,
-0.7653458118,
-0.0177165382,
0.6109070182,
-0.2419208735,
-0.1097178236,
0.7008732557,
0.7838537693,
0.3774419725,
-0.4422973692,
1.3614759445,
-0.4310038388,
0.4558581114,
1.3687058687,
0.1506848931,
0.5739535093,
0.6082101464,
-0.3469866514,
0.8405533433,
0.6662091613,
0.0154579794,
0.5384377837,
-0.0900054425,
-0.3801338971,
-0.1243829578,
-0.0337526426,
-0.2011407167,
0.3240655363,
-0.025006853,
-0.2006942034,
-0.5403102636,
0.0732134134,
0.1562287956,
-0.0789913461,
-0.183470875,
0.4253509939,
0.1744084358,
-0.9506816864,
0.0598076023,
-0.0754586533,
0.1868671328,
-0.5055334568,
-0.2469980866,
-0.1895779967,
0.5141441226,
-0.15479289,
-1.0295397043,
0.5782865882,
-0.1698317975,
-0.3566398025,
-0.792290628,
0.3178192675,
-0.1936701685,
-0.2613956928,
0.59810853,
-0.0055692471,
-0.2979591489,
-0.0141655374,
-0.5658404231,
-0.1685588509,
-0.000519916,
-0.2399413884,
-0.0625283495,
0.7233009338,
0.174262166,
0.8597264886,
0.3907448053,
0.2226891667,
0.1831847578,
0.0580955334,
0.4468981326,
-0.9497645497,
-0.2660450339,
-0.8660672903,
1.0363097191,
0.1560329646,
-0.2022623122,
0.9644970298,
0.0879663005,
0.9091538191,
0.0235706232,
0.4884455502,
0.115708217,
0.2443529516,
-0.5680924654,
0.4849284589,
-0.4059838057,
0.3384785354,
0.0711382553,
-0.5043693781,
0.095032461,
0.5508703589,
-0.4525685012,
-0.3748566806,
0.9496207237,
0.4915607274,
0.0937902257,
0.2241650671,
-0.0503882058,
0.8886861205,
0.403459996,
0.3570156693,
1.050514698,
-0.5711474419,
0.1461916566,
-0.3974612951,
-0.1066055074,
0.2468678355,
-0.7810234427,
-0.1837685406,
-0.8356655836,
-0.1834783107,
-0.7767701745,
-0.397254914,
0.4770559072,
0.1972372681,
-0.702257514,
-0.1943641752,
-0.2656103969,
0.1211620942,
-0.2615508139,
-0.3544635177,
0.1804394573,
-0.5426847339,
-0.2909594774,
0.5481988192,
0.6365174055,
0.0062640551,
-0.4458938539,
0.3306764364,
-0.1417847425,
0.0787433684,
0.5001280904,
0.1604426801,
-0.6868612766,
-0.589582324,
-0.3742043078,
0.2420889139,
0.5031356215,
0.9869164228,
-1.1030287743,
0.8436197639,
0.1945033669,
0.1307441592,
0.8050744534,
-0.1728016734,
0.7251674533,
-0.2916605175,
0.2939680517,
0.1424637586,
0.7545083165,
0.3832679391,
-0.5460352898,
0.5114380717,
0.3893054724,
-0.6089602113,
-0.6132455468,
0.6564090848,
-0.4303858876,
-0.461879164,
0.9476390481,
-0.0449525006,
-0.3256275356,
-0.1178238317,
0.1613971293,
0.5150407553,
0.1560667157,
0.7960172892,
0.6199325919,
-0.2793653309,
-0.0100307493,
-0.5533755422,
0.3253252506,
0.0602022372,
-0.5131020546,
-0.0958736315,
0.3523575664,
0.3085319102,
0.2799147666,
0.597335279,
-0.1939195991,
-0.0950509831,
0.2453124374,
-0.4218913913,
0.2092675567,
-0.6282466054,
-0.4522571266,
0.0648980588,
0.0416961052,
-0.0368383415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13109v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13109v2
|
CIF-Bench: A Chinese Instruction-Following Benchmark for Evaluating the Generalizability of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T16:02:12 | 2024-06-04T14:26:30 |
Yizhi LI, Ge Zhang, Xingwei Qu, Jiali Li, Zhaoqun Li, Zekun Wang, Hao Li, Ruibin Yuan, Yinghao Ma, Kai Zhang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Yiming Liang, Lei Zhang, Lei Ma, Jiajun Zhang, Zuowen Li, Stephen W. Huang, Chenghua Lin, Jie Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has enhanced the ability to
generalize across a wide range of unseen natural language processing (NLP)
tasks through instruction-following. Yet, their effectiveness often diminishes
in low-resource languages like Chinese, exacerbated by biased evaluations from
data leakage, casting doubt on their true generalizability to new linguistic
territories. In response, we introduce the Chinese Instruction-Following
Benchmark (CIF-Bench), designed to evaluate the zero-shot generalizability of
LLMs to the Chinese language. CIF-Bench comprises 150 tasks and 15,000
input-output pairs, developed by native speakers to test complex reasoning and
Chinese cultural nuances across 20 categories. To mitigate data contamination,
we release only half of the dataset publicly, with the remainder kept private,
and introduce diversified instructions to minimize score variance, totaling
45,000 data instances. Our evaluation of 28 selected LLMs reveals a noticeable
performance gap, with the best model scoring only 52.9%, highlighting the
limitations of LLMs in less familiar language and task contexts. This work not
only uncovers the current limitations of LLMs in handling Chinese language
tasks but also sets a new standard for future LLM generalizability research,
pushing towards the development of more adaptable, culturally informed, and
linguistically diverse models.
|
[
-0.1543329954,
-0.496010989,
0.4637867808,
0.5148791671,
-0.0744206905,
-0.1429591626,
-0.6022154093,
-0.3388557732,
-0.3303782046,
0.4127264321,
-0.3620341122,
-0.8045930266,
-0.4380362332,
-0.1536921114,
-0.5198617578,
0.7664891481,
-0.155667901,
0.1693511307,
-0.2121122181,
-0.2139184326,
-0.1722066253,
-0.5659999251,
-0.4032999277,
-0.3772526681,
0.4166581333,
0.4634963572,
0.5231058002,
1.0167262554,
0.5211808085,
0.1155819446,
0.134904474,
-0.0235659182,
-0.4693517089,
-0.2066246718,
-0.1549637318,
-0.4981528223,
-0.364192754,
-0.1936796755,
0.8222126365,
0.8966244459,
-0.1991135627,
0.2761540115,
0.2382180244,
0.7397084832,
-0.9050168991,
0.340128988,
-0.4596749842,
0.0956385583,
-0.406295687,
0.1254781336,
-0.4773486257,
-0.3261472583,
-0.0434707403,
-0.4531283677,
0.3343744278,
-0.2660537064,
0.6666150093,
0.1487646401,
-0.1681238115,
0.0654437989,
-0.7653534412,
0.7289167047,
-0.7888920307,
0.290578872,
0.4577851892,
0.4797902405,
-0.1327141374,
-0.6633136272,
-0.3192235231,
-0.4199694693,
0.1405458003,
-0.0337878801,
0.1750942022,
0.1472594142,
0.2437551916,
0.456328541,
-0.8047180176,
0.2489400804,
-0.007055555,
0.1270833611,
0.7545865774,
0.1701627821,
0.4445200562,
0.1399487555,
-0.4100926518,
-0.3020215034,
-0.9017782807,
0.2071676552,
0.0880247653,
0.3936512172,
-0.3546821475,
0.2365826964,
-0.6091174483,
0.6998252273,
-0.1056778356,
0.1302993745,
0.1497518271,
-0.3511510193,
-0.3775678873,
-0.2009967715,
0.8802028298,
0.3481775522,
0.3284444511,
-0.3920148313,
-0.147544682,
-0.2849672437,
-0.212513566,
-0.7755305767,
-0.2286366224,
0.1056605354,
-0.3065383732,
0.0932957977,
0.1992933601,
-0.5743854046,
-0.3752419949,
-0.081837818,
-0.0742819607,
-0.4154575169,
-0.218918249,
-0.0513310954,
0.1262383461,
0.6929157376,
0.1158709824,
-1.1591960192,
0.4014666677,
0.943331778,
0.6912784576,
-0.3403170407,
-0.3377249241,
-0.7015146613,
0.3013261259,
-0.5700071454,
0.6466037035,
-0.7539499402,
-0.473028779,
0.1588013768,
0.1091300473,
-0.1555286944,
-0.7574328184,
0.7156290412,
-0.123219654,
-0.1260222197,
-0.6146478653,
-0.5034762621,
-0.1047619358,
0.3242841363,
-0.6047517061,
0.9655226469,
0.0277940501,
-0.2776075304,
0.1729157716,
-0.5364851952,
-0.3821222782,
0.1959168315,
-0.4252873659,
0.0432151444,
0.0822258964,
0.2206277251,
0.443095237,
-0.6289141774,
0.2997609973,
-0.6630246639,
-0.9056742191,
0.0109701399,
-0.5616762638,
0.7153505683,
0.0128910867,
-0.5734048486,
-0.1380686164,
-0.676271677,
0.2421644628,
0.0873387158,
-0.2902919054,
-0.267075479,
0.1226506829,
-0.1172168702,
0.1271938384,
0.2641364634,
-0.4685653746,
0.1236216351,
-0.3000962734,
0.1168016791,
0.7177455425,
-0.2599420846,
0.3526277244,
-0.2865227759,
0.3717390895,
-0.1349894404,
0.1872965693,
-0.2869158983,
-0.1049747542,
-0.9345635772,
-0.0838155895,
0.4200667441,
0.6154712439,
-0.6416558623,
0.1356408,
-0.2784509361,
-0.6635127068,
-0.3674995303,
0.4090070128,
0.5471369028,
0.2441496253,
0.1744021773,
-0.2439474761,
-0.1216002628,
-0.9894321561,
-0.3286161423,
-0.1673666835,
-0.2973147631,
0.2410394251,
0.2143180817,
-0.0304615311,
0.3943454027,
-0.277184993,
-0.0675500706,
-0.2104586214,
0.045561213,
0.2627382576,
0.5122888088,
0.6293874383,
-0.4990879893,
-0.7875128388,
0.160257265,
-0.7697486877,
-0.1849432886,
-0.1917279214,
-0.2889597714,
0.148807317,
0.5068033338,
-0.3732281625,
0.2560704648,
0.6779533029,
0.0430257693,
0.5671713352,
-0.1269530505,
0.1117179617,
-0.5441476703,
0.2563349009,
0.1333233714,
0.1130322292,
-0.655290544,
0.3983873427,
0.3937222362,
0.1387779564,
-0.4645119309,
0.5054997206,
-0.6217746139,
-0.1148097515,
-0.2780796289,
0.1345350891,
-0.1945830286,
0.7719493508,
0.0408871397,
0.6148627996,
0.435505271,
-0.7484635115,
0.248131305,
-0.2744118869,
-0.409876287,
0.3810723424,
-0.7141922116,
0.2327442914,
0.0631479099,
0.1179529354,
-0.8884448409,
-0.2354817688,
0.2787485421,
-0.1626073271,
0.3849102259,
0.0877133533,
-0.6673314571,
-0.1962810904,
-0.3873472214,
0.3842435777,
0.2884249985,
-0.6500355005,
0.2932355404,
0.025136577,
0.0358894728,
-0.7505461574,
-0.8814918995,
0.0063306135,
0.1548555344,
-0.4948176146,
0.4045168161,
-0.3281228542,
-0.2534323335,
-0.1572903395,
-0.0959965885,
-0.2812210619,
0.2028930634,
0.1993024498,
0.3381682336,
-0.3764414787,
0.18953906,
-0.1131618246,
0.1558549255,
0.2729784548,
-0.0380761325,
0.5313600898,
-0.1276676804,
-0.7921997309,
-0.3125075102,
0.1347292513,
0.2566650808,
-0.2886645794,
0.6395036578,
0.5345148444,
-0.4783510864,
-0.3558993936,
-0.4467380643,
0.2748916149,
-0.4534046352,
0.5304748416,
-0.2436545789,
-0.5896850824,
0.3637757301,
-0.0129262889,
0.4500685632,
0.4237359762,
0.4766529202,
0.075473927,
0.8784195781,
0.7256951332,
-0.385714829,
0.4248319268,
-0.0410499796,
-0.0313279927,
-0.7584781051,
-0.008932543,
-0.4736513197,
-0.3172538877,
-0.677559793,
-0.5893542767,
0.0663121864,
0.0622654334,
-0.2896697521,
0.1142936423,
-0.4056906104,
0.696382761,
0.4851299524,
-0.0567978807,
0.2552213073,
-0.2806779444,
-0.2010459155,
0.1141861603,
-0.4993351102,
-0.3401392698,
1.1926668882,
0.1839084178,
0.6101927161,
0.041816026,
0.6851804852,
0.2541932762,
0.4995414317,
-0.4283502698,
0.5484693646,
-0.672021389,
-0.4918465316,
-0.2539234161,
-0.2939447761,
-0.5694386363,
0.3271037638,
0.1018707305,
-0.7943218946,
0.0516151302,
-0.0403428376,
-0.286742568,
0.3748232126,
-0.7205649614,
0.8451780081,
-0.5075007081,
-0.4308507144,
0.020184109,
-0.3503507078,
0.8679095507,
-0.0826067552,
0.1537976265,
-0.2695991099,
-0.1734357625,
0.4721394777,
-0.1437881589,
0.842972517,
-0.1965289265,
0.0321743153,
0.1892650276,
-0.143668741,
0.3614929616,
-0.1996934116,
-0.2233865857,
0.1471239775,
0.1185025126,
-0.5957731605,
-0.5852040648,
0.8543274999,
-0.7825464606,
-0.8021724224,
-0.4107065201,
-0.5260229707,
-0.3684418797,
0.1572626233,
0.1407976151,
0.1341887861,
-0.6377381682,
0.4078713059,
0.7059948444,
-0.3826171458,
0.5772346854,
0.7786076069,
-0.1969448924,
-0.054237403,
0.9215669036,
0.2110940367,
0.3688217402,
0.6666375995,
-0.1139315441,
-0.0892868266,
-0.5385606885,
-0.4768018723,
0.2108517438,
-0.5800945759,
0.0681282207,
-0.2351359278,
-0.558411479,
-0.3225148618,
0.0515512079,
-0.3919073045,
-0.2020930797,
-0.1351486593,
-0.002203495,
-0.3194233477,
0.5726036429,
-0.0248720814,
0.1494080126,
-0.8000246286,
0.2637689114,
0.2012077421,
0.649800837,
0.1707894206,
-0.4999518692,
-0.4327638745,
0.1818632483,
-0.2625710964,
-0.5733109713,
0.1473697424,
0.2076120228,
0.8895200491,
0.5711033344,
0.3560203612,
0.6641344428,
-0.3160849512,
0.8050183654,
0.1263703257,
-0.8514667749,
0.2813969851,
-0.3367685974,
0.7281705737,
0.4735356569,
0.1730546504,
-0.7724083662,
-0.404032886,
-0.3794584572,
-0.6480630636,
0.7315921187,
-0.1990128905,
0.1594092846,
0.0779192001,
0.2806624174,
0.0752064884,
-0.0878137872,
-0.6270794868,
-0.3706732094,
-0.0691978857,
-0.101520732,
-0.1327166557,
-0.242258504,
-0.0279395953,
-0.0962964743,
0.4320147336,
-0.289239049,
0.0606017746,
-0.0783375204,
-0.1784865558,
-0.0883330926,
0.3803237975,
0.4480402172,
0.6183538437,
-0.2233386189,
-0.0422519557,
0.4166246951,
-0.4194951653,
-0.0456550643,
0.2476462573,
-0.268786937,
-0.0255262479,
0.397152096,
0.5290166736,
0.248622492,
-0.9424971342,
0.4854567349,
-0.2062969655,
-0.2226979882,
-0.4824017286,
0.5196815133,
0.3945618868,
0.1796226203,
0.3832825124,
-0.3058120012,
0.1108714789,
-0.5230045319,
0.1602458954,
0.3763906658,
-0.4740257263,
-0.3142641187,
0.6272802949,
0.1454928666,
-0.0286466479,
0.6214244366,
-0.1076984182,
-0.155631274,
0.7369504571,
0.2803800404,
1.0402616262,
-0.341750741,
0.3177953959,
0.4646600485,
0.447211504,
-0.2082354426,
0.0268724374,
-0.1941965967,
-0.5010255575,
-0.320419848,
-0.3551334143,
-0.6969799995,
0.3104772568,
-0.8874027729,
0.2089154124,
-0.8769106269,
0.1438799053,
-0.2303608656,
0.1377554685,
-0.7404456735,
0.1883204877,
0.5159463286,
1.1842703819,
-0.5394167304,
1.1331839561,
0.3674252033,
-0.2996460497,
-0.707444787,
0.1957329661,
0.0365680121,
-0.890612781,
0.4656965733,
0.3039087951,
0.1796232462,
-0.5959755182,
-0.7359459996,
-0.8113678694,
1.2463480234,
0.6534270048,
-0.837466836,
-0.0452834368,
0.4961446226,
0.6330432892,
-0.3647574782,
0.4218300283,
0.8891290426,
0.4838791788,
0.0083124349,
-0.6772580743,
0.1091359705,
-0.4651748538,
0.1155612171,
-0.1264699847,
-1.0223990679,
0.8887583613,
-0.0664340481,
-0.4482339025,
0.2943049669,
0.6916706562,
0.3123613894,
0.2937858999,
0.3916363418,
0.219658941,
0.8048103452,
-0.2116796374,
1.0698876381,
-0.4351399243,
-0.1374488622,
1.3671416044,
-0.4431613088,
1.0979429483,
0.0990692079,
-0.1298400313,
0.5263995528,
0.5832743049,
-0.1666736156,
0.366645813,
0.3750602603,
-0.2805769742,
-0.1944130659,
-0.3546895385,
-0.4172226191,
0.4411361814,
0.2695394456,
-0.4063333273,
-0.2573247254,
-0.5246723294,
0.0472616442,
0.2222349495,
-0.1950100064,
0.4861107469,
0.0610010959,
-0.7824670672,
0.7897420526,
0.0637712628,
0.557002604,
-0.7855049372,
-0.1289299428,
-0.5005056262,
0.2761470675,
-0.1709696949,
-0.6754220724,
0.0764850155,
0.2436161041,
-0.2008960694,
0.0183170475,
0.4199926257,
-0.5708136559,
-0.3544627428,
0.585472703,
0.4464330971,
0.0689911321,
-0.0943017155,
-0.6240308881,
0.1692202687,
0.2341442108,
-0.097953245,
0.7350764275,
0.3800769448,
-0.1358091533,
0.6587489843,
0.4809720814,
0.0616621859,
0.0332442597,
0.214524433,
0.7501132488,
-0.8779531717,
-0.2008673996,
-0.7629439235,
0.2225171477,
-0.0744911507,
-0.3359213769,
0.5731467009,
0.4476248026,
1.0997054577,
0.1838523597,
1.0094339848,
0.2008423805,
0.3824467957,
-0.3061175942,
0.7771937847,
-0.4781614542,
0.4492668808,
-0.0536879338,
-0.8976014256,
-0.2012088299,
0.0971475616,
-0.4095607698,
0.019338645,
0.5726021528,
0.7422545552,
0.1228590757,
0.1110499799,
0.4761927426,
0.132350266,
0.3604922295,
1.1136270761,
0.5790957808,
-0.2773477733,
0.8647390008,
-0.4883974195,
-0.3297388852,
-0.0813534707,
-0.6093146801,
-0.8779060841,
-0.3105322719,
-0.1126481891,
0.2562926114,
0.1260253191,
0.7118151784,
0.5353197455,
-1.0376344919,
-0.6821742654,
0.1007449701,
0.1049731299,
-0.5457317233,
-0.2073793858,
0.4740161598,
-0.4230391681,
-0.9341347218,
0.2467300147,
0.2030739039,
-0.2292915285,
-0.3296560049,
-0.2500684559,
-0.2489047199,
-0.0186448973,
0.3595548868,
0.6732208133,
-0.6967733502,
-0.27984339,
0.2643327415,
-0.3985169828,
-0.0942109674,
0.5139452219,
-0.4333751798,
0.5071426034,
0.4614530802,
0.9003568292,
0.4102113247,
-0.1475669295,
0.9295278788,
-0.5403354168,
-0.0963018835,
-0.0021288141,
0.3917880952,
0.4385403991,
-0.1399931163,
0.7720662951,
0.0269698594,
-0.3544405997,
-0.7638243437,
-0.1423477232,
-0.7247961164,
-0.2554270029,
1.081037879,
-0.5386086702,
-0.36488083,
0.2664190531,
0.2550582886,
0.2583587468,
-0.272995621,
0.692881465,
0.958888948,
-0.0537396744,
-0.363711834,
-0.6281477809,
0.2870936096,
0.4607577622,
-0.7595560551,
0.3725740612,
0.2806857228,
0.2463348061,
-0.1125176772,
0.6790227294,
-0.0711501613,
0.5977155566,
0.0981145725,
0.039875295,
0.0062988997,
-0.0526609607,
-0.2421147674,
0.1843524128,
0.1388981193,
-0.341153115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13098v1
|
ELAD: Explanation-Guided Large Language Models Active Distillation
| 2024-02-20T15:47:59 | 2024-02-20T15:47:59 |
Yifei Zhang, Bo Pan, Chen Ling, Yuntong Hu, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The deployment and application of Large Language Models (LLMs) is hindered by
their memory inefficiency, computational demands, and the high costs of API
inferences. Traditional distillation methods, which transfer the capabilities
of LLMs to smaller models, often fail to determine whether the knowledge has
been sufficiently transferred, potentially resulting in high costs or
incomplete distillation. In this paper, we propose an Explanation-Guided LLMs
Active Distillation (ELAD) framework that employs an active learning strategy
to optimize the balance between annotation costs and model performance. To
improve efficient sample selection, we introduce an explanation-guided sample
selection method that identifies samples challenging its reasoning by
exploiting uncertainties in explanation steps. Additionally, we present a
customized LLM-annotated explanation revision technique where the teacher model
detects and corrects flaws in the student model's reasoning. Our experiments
across various reasoning datasets demonstrate that our framework significantly
enhances the efficiency of LLM knowledge distillation.
|
[
-0.1308303922,
-1.1929597855,
0.8998304009,
0.0382811874,
-0.3358661532,
-0.0683998242,
-0.4823155403,
-0.1888659745,
-0.2027018666,
0.4385942221,
-0.5529416203,
-0.4717713296,
-0.5084800124,
0.168705076,
-0.4281769395,
0.8986911178,
-0.4930970073,
-0.1104035378,
-0.1159875467,
0.1489320993,
-0.2925731242,
-0.0580968969,
-0.9411825538,
-0.5863819122,
0.5367240906,
0.4635994434,
0.4716751873,
0.9360114336,
0.2896337807,
0.2556881309,
-0.56158638,
0.3658551574,
-0.2993224859,
0.577721715,
-0.0773960501,
-0.7149027586,
-0.3643326163,
-0.1366382241,
0.2687772512,
0.9115251303,
-0.3300418854,
0.1187497452,
-0.1900635809,
0.6357101798,
-0.7769531012,
0.0844163522,
-0.7513524294,
-0.1382689327,
0.0311177112,
0.0687248334,
-0.4199914336,
-0.2332837582,
0.4459745884,
-0.6652774215,
0.2771870494,
0.05491798,
0.5852514505,
0.6765847206,
-0.4475614429,
-0.6316509247,
-0.9533537626,
0.7509146929,
-0.6677250862,
0.0147128226,
0.5406359434,
0.5963457823,
-0.1553489864,
-0.8097593784,
-0.6426398754,
0.1629829258,
0.0011784772,
-0.0774512663,
-0.0569938831,
0.2727494538,
0.1832335144,
0.4701139629,
-0.3525111973,
0.1119172573,
-0.3666931391,
0.0191939361,
0.5791017413,
-0.2472492456,
-0.0221190471,
0.1756177247,
-0.3557741046,
0.1937879026,
-0.7926723361,
-0.2684830129,
0.4556310177,
0.17058146,
0.0352708586,
0.4802532494,
-0.0123390416,
0.9078648686,
0.1804890335,
-0.2388203293,
0.0877759308,
-0.0517157875,
-0.3490541279,
0.4038955867,
0.2973042428,
0.0187720302,
0.0868997127,
0.1197016612,
-0.5219424367,
-0.0600269698,
-0.071079433,
-0.8781095743,
-0.441559881,
0.6084545255,
-0.4119285941,
-0.3834061325,
-0.3374267817,
-0.8117959499,
-0.4754709005,
-0.3277663887,
0.4380885363,
-0.1549234241,
-0.3209214807,
0.2076502293,
-0.161337018,
-0.3096712828,
0.6804898381,
-1.0441185236,
0.0479450487,
0.3830550611,
0.7227239013,
-0.2398285121,
0.1098223552,
-0.37618047,
0.3897382021,
-0.1887487024,
0.6778695583,
-0.4993725121,
-0.2505469024,
-0.0574709252,
-0.1418302208,
0.1346916258,
-0.6743023992,
0.5947372913,
-0.4671346545,
0.1360341012,
-0.2049314678,
-0.634442091,
-0.5583029985,
0.1340249032,
-0.7451256514,
0.9648246169,
-0.2281564772,
-0.5027198195,
0.3802272975,
-0.6969195604,
-0.430965364,
0.0151416687,
0.0004724313,
-0.5443506241,
0.1859644651,
0.5057332516,
0.4509895146,
-0.1936824024,
0.4224733412,
-0.1494040638,
-0.351197809,
0.1408682019,
-0.6241185069,
0.8516665101,
0.5675144792,
-0.3852624595,
0.0009981097,
-0.8805826306,
-0.2926779091,
0.2555162311,
-0.5039123297,
-0.5289624333,
0.1809720844,
-0.3907062411,
-0.1709728986,
0.4158684909,
-0.2938955426,
0.1604224145,
-0.1005582884,
0.4261068404,
0.8666597009,
0.1393743902,
0.4678562284,
-0.0957973525,
0.6698065996,
0.0507095233,
0.1036677957,
-0.6390410066,
-0.3237971067,
-0.7773864269,
-0.5308095813,
0.2695418,
0.3313925266,
-0.6346103549,
0.2623281479,
0.1438743919,
-0.2824695706,
-0.7131423354,
0.4367000759,
0.2205431163,
0.614109993,
0.3878888488,
0.3956293166,
-0.4885624349,
-0.8290902376,
-0.058356978,
-0.4262727499,
0.0746653602,
0.0602940954,
0.4418489039,
-0.0328839347,
0.7828137875,
-0.4790416956,
0.0203704666,
-0.4218821228,
0.3071916103,
0.2391185015,
-0.0230033137,
0.5605230331,
-0.9984636307,
-0.4712382853,
-0.0832658559,
-0.5532326102,
-0.8167785406,
-0.2997520864,
0.0318210647,
0.0099767111,
0.5165399313,
-0.437256217,
0.2801325619,
0.6806237698,
-0.2870655954,
0.3572776318,
-0.3427093625,
-0.1392860562,
-0.770713985,
-0.1142032817,
0.0061653932,
-0.0558003634,
-0.3867838383,
-0.0088045653,
0.0618233867,
0.1654096991,
-0.3095167577,
0.5332052708,
-0.8893950582,
0.3022907972,
-0.6370871067,
0.3834878206,
0.356403023,
0.3461181521,
-0.1127610728,
0.522585094,
0.6140202284,
-0.5944566131,
0.6449317932,
-0.0582112782,
-0.2830599248,
0.3391615152,
-0.7275123,
-0.0914582312,
-0.3852569759,
0.3421931863,
-1.1993849277,
-0.0951401889,
-0.2432859093,
-0.0629301742,
0.3169566095,
-0.3770451844,
-0.2572936118,
-0.2970556617,
-0.0479636341,
0.1721340269,
0.5188905001,
-0.9507977366,
0.8136561513,
0.0403105654,
-0.1121456921,
-0.5465679765,
-0.8302155137,
-0.2019930929,
-0.5119557381,
-0.3790969551,
0.2920942903,
-0.0029036545,
-0.7149711251,
0.2544870377,
-0.4057533741,
0.0115598869,
0.4943108857,
0.0663170069,
0.1665486395,
-0.116998367,
0.29696244,
0.3714687228,
0.0972917601,
0.1836622357,
-0.0831186175,
0.0930188894,
0.3275907934,
-0.5956271291,
-0.4241041541,
0.0103119006,
0.542764008,
-0.173740685,
0.8492343426,
0.20875898,
-0.3396308124,
-0.8397308588,
-0.5684089661,
-0.2435932308,
-0.4892116785,
0.3925794661,
-0.3688598573,
-0.4300927222,
0.6996639371,
-0.4460431039,
0.4957608879,
0.3724784553,
0.6479977369,
0.0744893327,
1.0392249823,
0.1921022236,
0.3389800787,
0.4993062317,
-0.0677242354,
0.5116850734,
-0.4426485598,
-0.3106455803,
-0.6148496866,
-0.5253767967,
0.0053389999,
-0.4970864952,
0.1670442075,
0.3944917023,
-0.1339292824,
-0.2044029683,
-0.5593124032,
0.6480081081,
0.3566868901,
-0.1959893107,
0.5614416599,
0.0346742272,
-0.1874702871,
0.2177362442,
-0.5497424603,
-0.7563216686,
1.0495014191,
0.5005608797,
1.0422153473,
0.4017941952,
0.6652508974,
0.1367945969,
0.2524725497,
-0.785870254,
0.4037686884,
0.0023032185,
-0.8962525129,
-0.3250570893,
-0.4009168148,
-0.6144970655,
0.480209142,
-0.1498772502,
-0.3752199709,
0.0001748029,
0.3475902379,
-0.3289797902,
0.3827549219,
-1.1046146154,
0.5399864912,
-0.522474587,
-0.3306766152,
-0.1184050068,
-0.295740217,
0.3870502412,
-0.4455034137,
0.5268999934,
-0.1023843661,
-0.0129594626,
0.5961738825,
-0.5557043552,
0.7842066288,
-0.5358772874,
-0.2986828089,
0.5941292048,
0.0493234359,
0.7573264241,
-0.0653389692,
-0.4624087214,
-0.2243196517,
-0.3585648239,
-0.2112651467,
-0.9060336351,
0.7036509514,
-0.5501708984,
-0.8638830185,
-0.0192922186,
-0.5136415362,
0.1082489789,
0.0248998385,
-0.1295658201,
0.0530394949,
0.1391761154,
0.2172879726,
1.0279290676,
-0.280461818,
0.5071341991,
0.6179844141,
-0.3955853879,
-0.0706930906,
0.3090203702,
0.1444291621,
0.4298571348,
0.1812544018,
0.3252623677,
-0.345594734,
-1.0373136997,
-0.6061953306,
0.1460270435,
-0.8938770294,
-0.1051864102,
-0.5138972998,
0.095548898,
-0.062540099,
-0.2764465511,
-0.337208122,
-0.5707432628,
-0.2989322543,
-0.5803776979,
0.6793881059,
0.6797114015,
0.1510535181,
0.5280911326,
-0.3458786011,
0.3497973084,
0.4027917385,
0.0409165025,
0.3240771294,
-0.8258045316,
-0.2962727845,
0.2959097028,
-0.3257668018,
-0.9828203321,
0.220818907,
0.4132627547,
0.8233494163,
0.800350666,
0.2377696633,
0.7364428639,
-0.3607477248,
0.7305829525,
0.0139466738,
-0.9146659374,
0.8774756789,
-0.0845902488,
0.2003513873,
0.4343422353,
0.3248746097,
-0.1519645751,
-0.5246000886,
-0.3874874413,
-1.2339366674,
0.5407420993,
0.0316023827,
0.0034727026,
-0.0374228582,
0.7370553017,
0.2057753354,
0.0032539626,
-0.7001948953,
-0.5510666966,
0.2643901706,
-0.5278883576,
0.2083341777,
-0.2718887031,
-0.2054238319,
-0.1978012323,
1.1537209749,
0.0182116535,
-0.2966367304,
0.0438530333,
-0.2136497945,
-0.3395904303,
0.231702432,
0.3967856765,
0.7794251442,
-0.1972737312,
0.5606851578,
0.2478562146,
-0.4870515764,
0.1299845427,
0.2201756388,
-0.2569057345,
0.2482719719,
0.4123919606,
1.0829312801,
-0.1910893321,
-0.8327465653,
0.4818754494,
-0.0416630544,
-0.3226567209,
-0.2450228184,
0.2557938397,
0.3581449091,
0.4279542863,
0.863486886,
-0.4141043127,
-0.125299722,
-0.4908874333,
-0.0933114514,
0.1137595922,
-0.1485836208,
-0.2718158662,
0.8360720873,
0.2539519668,
-0.1326922476,
0.3855340779,
-0.0600213446,
-0.4927305281,
0.6874781847,
0.436586827,
0.7358736992,
-0.4268071353,
0.1108520478,
0.1720863581,
0.2351119667,
-0.3790887296,
0.2407612801,
0.005270368,
-0.5872623324,
-0.7366057038,
-0.7221146822,
-0.4511890113,
0.1894216388,
-0.5501435995,
0.4467814267,
-0.3096614778,
0.0796037465,
0.2746078074,
-0.1398727149,
-0.2210687101,
0.1116418764,
0.1531745642,
0.7920240164,
-1.1397621632,
0.7477685809,
0.8447067738,
-0.3043795526,
-0.8320704103,
-0.1863854676,
0.0558898337,
-0.6240648627,
0.7529995441,
-0.1133519188,
0.0664012581,
-0.1918122321,
-0.5418053269,
-0.6072052121,
1.1995424032,
0.4133173525,
-0.8555498123,
0.1333497316,
-0.3384597003,
0.5890507102,
-0.3152430952,
0.1904545128,
0.5183056593,
0.6401705742,
0.4811624289,
-0.761248529,
0.073448658,
-0.0235264357,
-0.3471745253,
0.3029960394,
-0.2372819781,
0.8242266178,
-0.4970563054,
0.0540462136,
-0.3524458408,
0.5944471955,
0.453358084,
0.4138182998,
0.643247366,
0.6302675009,
1.0085566044,
-0.1555848122,
0.5552864671,
-0.0031125755,
0.3070631623,
1.1712414026,
-0.4279202819,
0.6312984824,
0.8804152608,
-0.1550342292,
0.4768646657,
0.7727686167,
-0.0208466351,
0.7662106156,
0.4316442907,
-0.6004163027,
-0.192770943,
0.0886659771,
0.0004885639,
0.3468935192,
0.4487720728,
-0.7626465559,
-0.3243710697,
0.1323923022,
0.0977722257,
0.1948322058,
-0.3433433771,
0.7575506568,
0.0645599514,
-0.7876752615,
0.7401266694,
0.118694894,
0.4489021003,
-0.4121072888,
-0.2314839065,
-0.1752405614,
0.3305763006,
-0.2831459343,
-0.4679240584,
0.2273171842,
0.2530141771,
-0.2614339888,
-0.5492594242,
0.4699697495,
-0.7421912551,
-0.3736822307,
0.1502983272,
0.5219191909,
0.2803758383,
0.1148851216,
-0.6242222786,
0.0815150738,
0.3343040645,
-0.5628218055,
-0.0647195876,
0.9328234792,
-0.1824065447,
0.6561409831,
0.4965935647,
0.3831162155,
0.0559796579,
0.1456985772,
0.8884712458,
-0.1548589617,
-0.3008885682,
-1.0866155624,
0.4920482039,
-0.0232570525,
0.0255142264,
0.6453481913,
0.4104135036,
0.5483695865,
0.2638407946,
0.9654042721,
0.0389452055,
0.5972526073,
-0.6102747321,
0.5670765638,
-0.5659627914,
0.9595231414,
0.0430003293,
-1.0654107332,
-0.1517580301,
0.9726729393,
-0.3849215508,
0.024747625,
0.7601885796,
0.5596064925,
-0.1285624206,
0.1682272106,
0.0576343723,
0.5130925775,
0.4363006949,
0.3095848262,
0.7111504078,
-0.1855508983,
0.4571605623,
-0.2804878056,
-0.3032163084,
-0.1733630747,
-1.1112686396,
-0.9981205463,
-0.3519714475,
-0.6742295623,
-0.1970350891,
0.1399374008,
0.8470471501,
0.4907241464,
-0.6043398976,
0.1098114625,
-0.188084498,
0.3429846466,
-0.2012234181,
-0.1701842844,
0.5560545325,
-0.2124218494,
-0.9464002252,
0.4255270958,
-0.0267741289,
0.2102240324,
-0.4765910208,
0.0386963487,
-0.3223205209,
0.1959615499,
0.3845970631,
-0.0879439935,
-0.7227929831,
0.0172024444,
-0.2176959515,
0.2281077355,
-0.3321485519,
0.6160280108,
-0.5200890303,
0.6390098929,
0.4266557097,
0.6286801696,
0.7806297541,
0.0418662429,
0.587037921,
-0.7416550517,
0.281909734,
0.2017826438,
0.4221895039,
0.3475120962,
-0.3288623095,
0.4464473128,
-0.0173440091,
-0.5355005264,
-1.0805864334,
0.0711122677,
-0.7382617593,
-0.7131499648,
1.4621732235,
-0.6330186725,
-0.3660918772,
-0.3945172131,
-0.1854055077,
0.3246921301,
-0.3401322961,
0.9229670763,
0.9341531992,
0.063780494,
-0.1951051652,
-0.7003110051,
0.4236955047,
0.31774351,
-0.5686940551,
0.4164114594,
0.6790279746,
0.262583971,
-0.1185135767,
0.1762621552,
-0.0135810012,
-0.0088895736,
-0.2190534174,
0.1404136419,
-0.4234229028,
-0.2360811532,
-0.4077784419,
0.0596630797,
0.325529635,
-0.0975348204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13094v1
|
Digital Comprehensibility Assessment of Simplified Texts among Persons with Intellectual Disabilities
| 2024-02-20T15:37:08 | 2024-02-20T15:37:08 |
Andreas Säuberli, Franz Holzknecht, Patrick Haller, Silvana Deilen, Laura Schiffl, Silvia Hansen-Schirra, Sarah Ebling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Text simplification refers to the process of increasing the comprehensibility
of texts. Automatic text simplification models are most commonly evaluated by
experts or crowdworkers instead of the primary target groups of simplified
texts, such as persons with intellectual disabilities. We conducted an
evaluation study of text comprehensibility including participants with and
without intellectual disabilities reading unsimplified, automatically and
manually simplified German texts on a tablet computer. We explored four
different approaches to measuring comprehensibility: multiple-choice
comprehension questions, perceived difficulty ratings, response time, and
reading speed. The results revealed significant variations in these
measurements, depending on the reader group and whether the text had undergone
automatic or manual simplification. For the target group of persons with
intellectual disabilities, comprehension questions emerged as the most reliable
measure, while analyzing reading speed provided valuable insights into
participants' reading behavior.
|
[
-0.7366164327,
-0.5933091044,
0.6042231917,
0.4089614451,
-0.5021186471,
-0.1595863104,
-0.2454416752,
-0.482960552,
-0.0240094215,
0.0403668024,
-0.7191144824,
-0.1558250487,
-0.7870399952,
0.8223543167,
-0.444247812,
0.8454722762,
-0.5465244055,
0.088103272,
-0.2936815321,
-0.131797567,
-0.5118835568,
-0.1990290284,
-0.4785710275,
-0.4670089781,
0.3942923546,
0.4599335194,
0.6114435196,
0.6252020001,
0.7540583014,
0.3767705858,
-0.2287291735,
-0.1084034443,
-0.003915552,
0.1513907164,
-0.0061498359,
-0.2504933476,
-0.5289693475,
-0.0741431564,
0.5324399471,
0.9924659133,
0.0741670653,
0.3298020661,
0.4489580095,
1.0645970106,
-0.7039117217,
-0.0127562629,
0.2055476159,
0.1015803516,
-0.0616520457,
-0.4278085232,
-0.3672515452,
-0.5606772304,
0.2263760567,
-0.7621768117,
0.4117431939,
0.080234535,
0.3193778396,
0.4261244237,
-0.9341157079,
-0.6321461201,
-0.9082253575,
0.6132270694,
-0.324059248,
0.6039832234,
0.5060774684,
0.1060190201,
0.1220489964,
-0.8271272779,
-0.9823791385,
-0.1648281813,
-0.3029803932,
0.0192945022,
-0.1054528952,
0.2319079638,
0.6382980943,
0.1843032241,
-0.6108263731,
-0.4361879528,
-0.5960774422,
-0.0293798391,
0.8643371463,
0.1366098672,
0.6087050438,
-0.2661076188,
-0.1606944352,
-0.102273941,
-0.1022410765,
0.0970997885,
0.4758439958,
-0.2460786253,
0.0783478767,
0.7639727592,
-0.4292736948,
0.8224725723,
-0.0431129932,
-0.2126715183,
0.2899564505,
-0.6739619374,
-0.2002124786,
0.0302180555,
0.3300693631,
0.4372809827,
0.6510338783,
-0.122026749,
-0.2217900157,
-0.229074955,
0.1369006634,
-0.4925247729,
-0.2298607826,
0.2533325255,
-0.5906812549,
0.1718933582,
0.1428025216,
-0.5791506767,
-0.4726765156,
-0.5247491002,
0.4443080723,
-0.3811425269,
-0.028281277,
0.3173591793,
-0.4924353063,
-0.112520583,
0.6658065319,
-0.8611382842,
0.4741795957,
0.2775980532,
0.7186291814,
-0.4097928703,
-0.3377029896,
-0.0925913677,
0.2847532034,
-0.004677305,
1.0953880548,
-0.0260238796,
-0.5229461789,
-0.4605995715,
-0.0026297253,
-0.476321131,
-0.1266422421,
0.9609642029,
-0.5156856179,
0.0903164372,
-0.249064818,
-0.6677710414,
-0.4147259295,
0.1329549998,
-0.9003232121,
0.5962302089,
-0.0453695767,
-1.0134112835,
0.7180005908,
-0.6632876992,
-0.6189443469,
0.0127742263,
0.2107800692,
-0.155458957,
0.171752885,
0.1038008928,
0.1694306582,
-0.0386177003,
-0.0148750255,
-0.0495306849,
-0.7571954727,
0.2583804429,
-0.7535672188,
0.9840833545,
-0.101824142,
-0.5431905389,
-0.1047382057,
-0.7584031224,
0.3367832899,
-0.1857493371,
-0.7784519792,
-0.6046056151,
0.1252808422,
0.2137077302,
0.1445030272,
0.078121528,
-0.5135832429,
0.0626792684,
-0.2968238294,
0.0608246513,
0.5807994008,
0.1146504581,
0.2307879925,
-0.5619878769,
0.3125010431,
-0.2755384445,
0.2010359019,
-0.0714547411,
-0.4126367867,
-0.8426297307,
-0.4075524807,
0.5790143609,
0.7623394132,
-0.5974741578,
0.3941003382,
-0.4282184541,
-0.3393397033,
-0.270011276,
0.2989914715,
0.2539000511,
0.2960992754,
0.2617669702,
-0.2193061858,
0.0296589062,
-0.5505467057,
-0.5377827287,
-0.3151009083,
-0.2880445719,
0.2720042169,
0.5991845727,
-0.2255257368,
0.426120609,
-0.5005746484,
-0.1474842876,
-0.2038734704,
0.5287624002,
-0.2910468876,
0.4900950491,
-0.1001818255,
-1.1276401281,
-0.7983334661,
-0.2540449798,
-0.6473006606,
-0.3281997442,
-0.0859746933,
0.5830116868,
0.5439032912,
0.7303876877,
-0.4354836941,
0.7297458649,
0.2995633781,
-0.6249070168,
0.4499658644,
-0.728043735,
0.5898435712,
-0.4874846935,
0.1427760869,
0.0515246503,
-0.172231257,
-0.6758297086,
0.0357737429,
0.2523540556,
0.2327016592,
-0.4033340216,
0.5436940193,
-0.6735401154,
-0.1342087239,
-0.0003406545,
0.3555501997,
0.2217022628,
0.1012314633,
-0.2704262435,
0.7750530243,
-0.0171210002,
-0.6856641769,
0.4371796548,
0.1296157986,
-0.3602898121,
0.8412075043,
-0.9025344849,
0.1817318648,
-0.5143621564,
0.2029031068,
-1.5206500292,
-0.3170196414,
0.1293703169,
-0.2747258842,
0.1062340364,
0.6286501288,
-0.6319243908,
-0.3383862972,
-0.3621801138,
0.5974189639,
-0.0355772339,
-0.1525213122,
0.7485063672,
0.0578999035,
-0.4050934315,
-0.2150015235,
-0.7854812741,
-0.0733636394,
-0.1253077835,
-0.9121453762,
0.2944048643,
-0.5424875617,
-0.6253039241,
-0.1654784828,
-0.0758729875,
-0.3560105264,
0.2141125947,
0.1987028718,
0.0597696491,
0.2245149016,
0.3109515011,
0.2365231961,
-0.1531015486,
-0.1821378022,
0.4191501141,
0.2938791215,
0.1077365503,
-0.4919053614,
-0.7442794442,
0.6403440833,
0.2344563007,
0.0549402237,
0.3400740921,
0.1983802766,
-0.2572578788,
0.0795943812,
-0.440921694,
-0.2340120673,
-0.4736058712,
-0.1379082948,
-0.5538570285,
-0.599652946,
0.3628097475,
-0.2661595643,
-0.1517157257,
0.4703542292,
0.2572590709,
-0.4544677436,
1.1527768373,
0.8351550102,
0.6881667972,
0.1858433038,
0.3782360554,
0.095355086,
-0.4338995516,
-0.3326827586,
-0.8015603423,
-0.3330805004,
-0.5777138472,
-0.1047553718,
0.2829738557,
0.2104815692,
-0.0886971056,
0.1679970026,
-0.4672394991,
0.4516843855,
0.520991683,
0.3028691411,
1.0277018547,
-0.1002898514,
-0.1482648551,
-0.2752634585,
-0.1999074668,
-0.6926781535,
0.9825603366,
0.1030632779,
0.5350051522,
0.2831102312,
0.6336001754,
0.7069662213,
0.2644597292,
-1.0210915804,
0.5156009793,
-0.1447552294,
-0.6727601886,
-0.6832568645,
-0.3965767324,
-0.8640810847,
-0.1129867807,
-0.1414089352,
-0.6846917272,
0.3846803904,
-0.0072593293,
-0.2172575742,
-0.1172381043,
-1.0216342211,
0.7297401428,
-0.1109206751,
0.2853160799,
-0.2465244532,
-0.482301712,
0.2391038537,
-0.682801187,
0.1036911085,
0.0706026182,
-0.4663683176,
0.8007118106,
-0.0953614041,
0.5142905712,
0.1138627604,
0.2917941809,
0.1544536948,
-0.0169974435,
0.4359202385,
-0.3571465313,
-0.2762979269,
0.0013653325,
0.3874045312,
-0.4012039006,
-0.6900542378,
0.4095544815,
-0.7388502955,
-0.7611953616,
-0.6202889085,
-0.4611160755,
-0.1332692951,
0.6157255769,
0.2498310804,
0.1410483867,
-0.3718216121,
0.0666195527,
0.7136619687,
-0.0751697421,
0.683239758,
0.5996592641,
0.3089424372,
-0.2096787691,
0.4326411486,
0.6252536774,
0.2579320669,
-0.0239072125,
-0.0826461911,
-0.4868496954,
-0.5921018124,
-0.5226333737,
0.1790441275,
-0.9458386302,
0.4019485414,
-0.6738812327,
-0.0337485224,
-0.356667161,
-0.2336406112,
0.4696838856,
-0.6942632794,
-0.3711086512,
-0.0872967765,
-0.0441554599,
0.7947500348,
0.016905861,
0.4773871899,
-0.6081211567,
0.5362311602,
0.5562895536,
0.4085110724,
-0.2630536854,
-0.3975822926,
0.130465582,
-0.2847227752,
-0.3730254471,
-1.0082376003,
0.1343811899,
0.1565930396,
0.4495268166,
0.0286575854,
0.5178257227,
0.4197851717,
-0.3023376763,
0.4619759023,
0.2113090903,
-1.167888999,
0.2710355222,
-0.119316496,
0.377492547,
0.9051526189,
0.5819327831,
-0.5986304283,
-0.0108531369,
-0.4780657291,
-0.8490011096,
0.4568910301,
0.1371324658,
0.1853928119,
0.3194652796,
0.271832794,
0.0698142648,
0.1017529964,
-0.620121181,
-0.4381217062,
0.0008382617,
-0.2981141806,
-0.0408032425,
-0.3937047422,
-0.1700019985,
-0.3125659823,
0.3378596008,
-0.0753276646,
0.0975380316,
0.428285867,
-0.2270545512,
-0.2478125095,
0.3477474749,
0.6994638443,
0.9090282321,
-0.1523486823,
0.1555226445,
0.1726950407,
-0.7149373889,
0.5455152392,
0.3440279663,
-0.4528706074,
0.1338905543,
0.4184548855,
0.4886048734,
-0.2924300134,
-0.5992792845,
0.6444756985,
-0.6002272964,
-0.2809623778,
-0.3342988491,
0.1306450516,
-0.0474270619,
0.1059401706,
0.4597108662,
0.1286689788,
0.5339336991,
-0.1903092861,
0.4039114416,
-0.0483638048,
-0.4215177,
-0.0395218022,
0.2959890664,
0.3234888613,
-0.4696276486,
0.4870522022,
-0.0816962868,
0.0912737846,
0.6031234264,
0.3752309978,
0.8706143498,
-0.2354223132,
0.4132768214,
0.0923140943,
0.6203107238,
-0.2642248571,
0.5023673773,
-0.2174553126,
-0.4401634932,
-0.2470188588,
-0.2064942122,
-0.4509553909,
-0.3880997598,
-0.5404641628,
0.3107970059,
-0.3971300125,
-0.5051637292,
0.3287853003,
0.2302663773,
-0.5377116799,
0.6783499718,
-0.3124209344,
1.214738369,
-0.8364155293,
0.4878450334,
0.893393755,
-0.332844466,
-0.6815258861,
0.7439332008,
0.1275064498,
-0.2024649829,
0.7133229375,
0.0761465207,
-0.1016712412,
0.1681711674,
-0.0602205284,
-0.6309057474,
1.0716449022,
0.391150862,
-0.2770752013,
-0.0536826886,
0.3893407583,
0.6385205984,
0.0856851339,
0.4554177225,
0.6218951344,
0.7936436534,
-0.1832482219,
-1.0359044075,
0.1990011334,
-0.130941391,
0.0442424454,
0.0872256756,
-0.4969832599,
0.5908212066,
-0.1648545265,
-0.3890526295,
-0.1819266081,
0.4444699287,
0.1806904078,
0.7019138336,
0.6505371928,
0.3601217568,
0.935297668,
-0.0920455381,
1.0518081188,
-0.2363287956,
0.1501685232,
0.6032700539,
0.1170755997,
0.7542828918,
0.6590173841,
-0.0035484296,
0.3716721535,
0.5415681005,
0.3624465764,
0.3236207068,
0.1995535046,
-0.6433757544,
-0.0669344887,
-0.0759505332,
-0.0106000602,
0.2388105989,
0.0521915816,
-0.3452923298,
-0.2054651231,
0.2490255088,
-0.0760251582,
0.2952566445,
-0.3773533404,
0.8398073316,
0.0665127411,
-0.8343276381,
0.5460357666,
0.3116458654,
0.4306347668,
-0.2463062555,
0.240089789,
-0.2517902553,
0.2152292132,
-0.3573838174,
-1.1495084763,
0.6232854128,
0.1311214864,
-0.4332097769,
-0.2624856234,
0.7792566419,
0.0487281866,
-0.722524941,
0.3351167738,
0.5356065631,
0.3053892255,
-0.0040817037,
-0.7520151138,
0.1570022851,
0.0181118473,
-0.6773450971,
0.0424617529,
0.6326105595,
-0.1800307781,
0.9199778438,
0.3887543678,
0.0374745615,
0.0312036928,
-0.1414818317,
0.6919792295,
-0.6392145157,
-0.2589983344,
-0.8103082776,
0.5324040055,
-0.0322720259,
-0.4320430756,
0.9535835385,
0.2507844269,
0.8125998378,
0.0952291787,
0.8233587146,
-0.1099473312,
0.3881824911,
-0.1340138763,
0.6909812093,
-0.6650087237,
0.0278005153,
-0.4506275952,
-0.8967491984,
-0.501850903,
0.4614752531,
-0.4536777437,
0.2596220672,
0.8454274535,
0.4137938321,
-0.1111049876,
0.1797734052,
0.235133633,
-0.3316302896,
-0.1163125932,
0.2078678608,
0.2410731465,
-0.4657616317,
0.7637042999,
-0.2617098093,
-0.5164633989,
-0.1315598339,
-0.8892146945,
-0.7203114033,
-0.5297710299,
-0.4383494854,
-0.2679876685,
0.1163911596,
0.7218694687,
0.1566774994,
-0.5945195556,
-0.1532559842,
-0.0596539676,
0.3070985973,
-0.2277068645,
-0.2234718055,
0.4063619077,
0.0912128091,
-0.8153891563,
-0.1547649354,
0.1781947464,
0.4049552977,
-0.277717948,
0.0738391429,
-0.0074829087,
0.4491573274,
0.3304398358,
0.2016099691,
-0.1599918604,
-0.0563067943,
0.0679393113,
-0.6010260582,
-0.0918053612,
0.603484571,
-0.2538139522,
0.7748988271,
1.1248373985,
0.2114888877,
0.3839406073,
0.2883687317,
0.4370405972,
-0.3001326323,
0.0752907023,
0.098881565,
0.1360477507,
0.4312829077,
-0.3995603621,
0.2731263638,
0.4407476187,
-0.584937036,
-0.6311604381,
0.0301643908,
-0.8220158219,
-0.3401528895,
0.9755895734,
-0.3227365613,
-0.2721916735,
-0.6352526546,
-0.3202352226,
0.2484223843,
-0.1122369245,
0.861593008,
0.8904973865,
-0.2529291511,
-0.2967460155,
-0.6662560105,
0.6412708163,
0.1350221336,
-0.8975698352,
-0.0508441888,
0.6192949414,
0.2645185292,
0.174946025,
0.8881573677,
0.1586517096,
0.4366435111,
0.0213586185,
-0.0901543275,
0.048220709,
-0.2354751378,
-0.4235298634,
0.2281872034,
0.0281152781,
0.2931825817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13093v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13093v2
|
Event-level Knowledge Editing
| 2024-02-20T15:36:41 | 2024-04-21T06:13:45 |
Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Chunyang Li, Kaisheng Zeng, Jiangshan Duo, Yixin Cao, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge editing aims at updating knowledge of large language models (LLMs)
to prevent them from becoming outdated. Existing work edits LLMs at the level
of factual knowledge triplets. However, natural knowledge updates in the real
world come from the occurrences of new events rather than direct changes in
factual triplets. In this paper, we propose a new task setting: event-level
knowledge editing, which directly edits new events into LLMs and improves over
conventional triplet-level editing on (1) Efficiency. A single event edit leads
to updates in multiple entailed knowledge triplets. (2) Completeness. Beyond
updating factual knowledge, event-level editing also requires considering the
event influences and updating LLMs' knowledge about future trends. We construct
a high-quality event-level editing benchmark ELKEN, consisting of 1,515 event
edits, 6,449 questions about factual knowledge, and 10,150 questions about
future tendencies. We systematically evaluate the performance of various
knowledge editing methods and LLMs on this benchmark. We find that ELKEN poses
significant challenges to existing knowledge editing approaches. Our codes and
dataset are publicly released to facilitate further research.
|
[
-0.0720561221,
-0.6576682925,
0.6046407223,
0.0222900454,
-0.0113507779,
0.1753323525,
-0.2024411261,
-0.7903445363,
-0.083256647,
0.5374407768,
-0.322640717,
-0.9403823018,
-0.574605763,
0.2645880282,
-0.3856176734,
0.8956832886,
-0.3503243625,
-0.3354269266,
-0.2739450037,
-0.1759073436,
-0.3317117095,
-0.5572009683,
-0.9705167413,
-0.0182801336,
0.5921956897,
0.3881250024,
0.5434443951,
0.8145544529,
0.4825154543,
0.2339945734,
-0.6813272238,
0.1747495085,
-0.4870102704,
0.2281533331,
-0.2244569212,
-0.5999025702,
-0.8406661749,
-0.1864184588,
0.7817031145,
0.5247055888,
0.0620093122,
0.297640264,
0.0050612409,
0.5847952366,
-0.7054802775,
0.0939040557,
-0.8190702796,
-0.0125214839,
-0.3037383854,
-0.0788474157,
-0.1984611303,
-0.2252749056,
0.011667938,
-0.8406046033,
0.2779988945,
0.0423385538,
0.5276958346,
0.2592307031,
-0.192615509,
0.0339795835,
-0.5737959146,
0.5348291993,
-0.7541803122,
0.4607331157,
0.2279840857,
-0.194140017,
-0.2168547064,
-0.5038349628,
-0.634126842,
0.2304104567,
0.1821850538,
-0.1766810715,
-0.2977095544,
0.1672089547,
0.6243444681,
0.0232505761,
-0.2741754353,
0.0789742023,
-0.1654738784,
0.2539686859,
0.7137235999,
0.3222986162,
0.2793263793,
-0.2963470817,
0.1667937934,
0.1037734896,
-0.953343451,
-0.0744017288,
0.273152411,
-0.1667319387,
0.3483954668,
0.7317162752,
-0.5089656711,
0.7655434608,
0.0639235526,
-0.3807756603,
0.0250356756,
-0.540561676,
-0.1246105358,
0.2417678237,
0.4069328904,
0.6042276025,
-0.0731353164,
-0.1779178679,
-0.2322513014,
-0.4605842531,
-0.1280761659,
-0.5718067288,
0.1544213891,
0.318947345,
-0.3424056172,
-0.4512622356,
-0.2817805409,
-0.547845304,
-0.7235779166,
-0.2757763565,
0.4287485778,
-0.4473528564,
0.0971702412,
0.2697629035,
-0.2105358541,
-0.0351856165,
0.7845575809,
-0.5297251344,
0.0185124874,
0.7936883569,
0.5997123122,
-0.0264507532,
-0.5532125235,
-0.5707888603,
0.5504944324,
-0.4378505945,
0.7568850517,
-0.7523822188,
-0.1586772501,
-0.0200328212,
-0.2278413475,
0.1767007262,
-0.4595005512,
0.3104051948,
-0.9467121363,
-0.0165644325,
-0.5177560449,
-0.8487306237,
0.0738320872,
0.2797726691,
-0.4753435254,
1.1393009424,
-0.2855988145,
-0.7714595199,
0.7491478324,
-0.6294523478,
-0.5873841643,
0.0064786519,
0.2620755434,
-0.0644435808,
-0.0131123178,
0.4928222299,
0.2949459255,
0.1604667753,
0.2399957478,
-0.0824131519,
-0.1143309996,
0.0875598863,
0.0513264425,
0.3602091968,
-0.1855192035,
-0.2646725476,
0.1904129088,
-1.2109154463,
-0.3941138387,
-0.2273033261,
-0.5713858008,
-0.4586044848,
0.2434783727,
-0.4214758575,
0.2500019073,
0.5408319831,
-0.7735193372,
0.5756587386,
-0.1664389074,
-0.0103020649,
0.8361015916,
0.4786391854,
0.3719595671,
-0.4120329022,
0.4274804294,
-0.0956005082,
0.3284912705,
-0.0044119279,
-0.7290254235,
-0.745084703,
0.084946543,
0.3841169178,
0.6552556753,
-0.8508301377,
0.3551794291,
-0.2206559777,
-0.2808236778,
-0.6668798923,
0.3354410529,
0.1331166327,
0.3487428129,
0.3381573558,
0.1300157458,
-0.7058663964,
-0.4737075567,
-0.8156456947,
-0.1938823611,
0.1078484878,
-0.2140778452,
0.3722956181,
0.0275518671,
0.7951155901,
-0.3496161401,
-0.1700342894,
-0.1192424819,
0.4290407896,
0.0072197192,
0.2135456204,
0.2276745439,
-0.2982456982,
-0.3900522888,
0.2832039297,
-0.6485854387,
-0.1568830311,
-0.0836501867,
-0.0836270154,
0.5233608484,
0.5602833033,
-0.3707582355,
0.5189169645,
0.4028673172,
-0.4165737331,
0.4310369492,
-0.2186732739,
0.5869449377,
-0.9511909485,
-0.2699482143,
-0.1866470426,
-0.1754682958,
-0.7271711826,
-0.0629178435,
0.2010753453,
-0.0199875515,
-0.4786473513,
0.7406543493,
-0.32841447,
-0.0155295227,
-0.1337167174,
0.2765283883,
-0.0821732134,
0.3765643537,
-0.1419863701,
0.5097926259,
0.4549089372,
-0.391877383,
0.4810886383,
0.482868582,
-0.8541998267,
0.4874353111,
-0.3546311259,
0.1992939115,
-0.3061619401,
0.1448076814,
-0.4473085403,
-0.0233662259,
-0.1285572201,
-0.2141157538,
0.1075045243,
-0.2066318095,
-0.8083470464,
-0.0147152357,
-0.385098815,
0.2315595895,
0.3526254594,
-0.6414841413,
0.5012373328,
0.2959890664,
-0.4695592821,
-0.6584308743,
-0.5227663517,
0.4937455058,
0.1301111877,
-0.8623934984,
0.1752167642,
0.129578799,
-0.531483829,
0.3726335466,
-0.1878812611,
0.1885946989,
-0.3005580902,
-0.2226603776,
0.187126711,
-0.0821447745,
0.129425019,
0.1747641414,
0.0213960726,
-0.1589798331,
-0.3618987501,
-0.1297383159,
0.2106709182,
-0.3161001503,
-0.8074271679,
0.2044440359,
0.5245459676,
-0.3491775095,
0.8082172275,
0.4014279246,
-0.6331140995,
0.1571834981,
-1.0486242771,
0.1427855641,
-0.3779422045,
0.6130490303,
-0.506948173,
-1.1657168865,
0.6289924979,
0.2043817341,
0.4676358998,
0.5514574647,
0.2940929234,
-0.0584301911,
1.1749585867,
0.313924253,
0.0842226371,
0.5486094952,
-0.0359534584,
0.1677037477,
-1.0888432264,
-0.1955144852,
-0.5004220605,
-0.4012489915,
-0.3470446169,
-0.6612374187,
0.4723000228,
0.2008000165,
-0.0464385897,
0.2935314178,
-0.1188532189,
0.6633319259,
0.4155592322,
0.0274539925,
0.8251855969,
-0.3554321826,
0.3447953463,
0.0461304113,
-0.8931070566,
-0.4934522212,
1.1120753288,
0.1133485138,
0.7165779471,
0.1388366073,
0.7319166064,
0.2663888633,
0.2479545772,
-0.1345133185,
0.5064666271,
-0.0016264665,
-0.7710730433,
-0.8117753863,
-0.4048992991,
-0.5607466698,
0.1426600218,
-0.3797964752,
-0.8642338514,
0.6204609275,
0.2704057693,
-0.2558639646,
0.8526900411,
-0.4594849944,
0.8024705648,
0.1677642912,
-0.2504010499,
-0.4469152987,
-0.3431952596,
0.1640401334,
-0.1226335838,
0.665979445,
-0.3229241967,
-0.2021112442,
1.0261167288,
-0.2500683963,
0.701544106,
-0.1337936521,
-0.1664753258,
0.1719121039,
0.2416853756,
1.199008584,
0.3429552615,
-0.4244154096,
-0.1341909617,
0.2705149353,
-0.3816981018,
-0.713293612,
0.6247834563,
-0.7039151192,
-0.6127405763,
-0.1320572495,
-0.4912011623,
-0.3524588346,
-0.008368006,
0.0677321181,
0.8533754945,
-0.3305752277,
0.0322030298,
0.7595543265,
-0.3846558928,
0.1974689066,
0.4901139438,
-0.2156028301,
-0.3360897899,
0.743852973,
0.2448043227,
0.343249768,
0.6243100166,
-0.0428563729,
0.0052169985,
-0.7871995568,
-0.5326222777,
0.046691779,
-0.9447309375,
-0.1486375928,
-1.0602762699,
0.0175854005,
-0.5915950537,
-0.4586339891,
-0.2840939462,
-0.7192457318,
-0.0967335105,
-0.1523041874,
0.6191725731,
1.1220656633,
-0.4272232652,
0.0939084813,
-0.7579107881,
0.4762007594,
0.5074619651,
0.4681560695,
-0.091967091,
-0.4173872769,
-0.3321663141,
-0.2008648515,
-0.0411357619,
-0.7406083345,
-0.1113509387,
0.1399728358,
0.3706724048,
0.0231245942,
-0.0423608758,
0.6359888911,
-0.4897306859,
0.891664803,
0.0393811278,
-1.1629180908,
0.7475953698,
-0.408283174,
0.4888086021,
0.5411627293,
0.032901112,
-1.0627647638,
-0.8886598349,
-0.7336413264,
-0.5759317875,
0.9679020047,
0.062435668,
-0.1824890971,
0.0247047767,
0.5642299056,
0.0872870237,
0.2217687219,
-0.3405601084,
-0.1180974543,
0.2047014534,
0.0738286749,
0.0650456548,
-0.6381617188,
-0.0339777581,
-0.6067967415,
1.0673605204,
0.2372870296,
-0.2430334687,
0.1891282797,
-0.1711854041,
-0.3465816975,
0.5287855268,
0.567330718,
1.1281045675,
-0.3566995561,
-0.0005581907,
0.9862631559,
-0.1465986967,
-0.0691855028,
-0.0726612434,
-0.233643651,
-0.0456858911,
0.7002472281,
1.0508424044,
0.4859196544,
-0.4085372984,
0.3358704746,
-0.1074330136,
-0.4466341138,
0.2115659714,
0.1443922222,
0.0605278797,
0.2235626727,
0.2114725113,
0.0185531024,
-0.11694175,
-0.5376804471,
0.0051790378,
-0.0915814862,
-0.1959906518,
-0.1521327943,
0.6651569009,
0.2895419002,
-0.2559268475,
0.291162461,
-0.3586767018,
-0.4045172036,
0.2196656764,
0.1665442139,
0.5367393494,
-0.1778679788,
-0.0324602574,
0.5527720451,
0.5259229541,
0.0217715893,
0.3116850257,
0.2742163837,
-0.7954796553,
-0.9494507313,
-0.6735347509,
-0.5826322436,
0.2024214864,
-0.3632352352,
0.3293436766,
-0.2307127863,
0.1543263048,
0.0503025278,
-0.0691822544,
-0.7550842762,
0.0617727377,
-0.0568663068,
1.0266587734,
-0.392500788,
0.6420521736,
0.8875203729,
0.0117140356,
-0.3029636741,
-0.1625668555,
0.0691180974,
-0.5356987715,
0.2484873831,
-0.5201131701,
0.2092075944,
0.1347242594,
-0.4126747549,
-1.0623383522,
0.9014331102,
0.166244179,
-0.6580582261,
-0.3113757074,
0.1157670468,
0.3526590168,
-0.0233060233,
-0.2164690197,
0.8500329256,
0.8628087044,
0.1602891386,
-0.8201452494,
-0.1237353235,
-0.0434354953,
0.0522461571,
0.389621973,
-0.1781062782,
0.425478667,
-0.0917464346,
-0.0068213101,
-0.0963440388,
0.7743991613,
-0.0906939358,
-0.0638549253,
0.3832517564,
0.8149505258,
0.8171402216,
-0.1457010806,
0.8382324576,
-0.4412846863,
0.1245367751,
1.1453393698,
-0.3453841805,
0.6568211317,
0.182492435,
-0.1662345678,
0.3668624163,
0.5094337463,
0.2180429399,
0.2178894877,
0.0632367432,
-0.6985331178,
-0.3054746687,
0.1126261726,
-0.447488606,
0.2640978992,
0.1508573294,
0.2848255932,
-0.2298233956,
0.2643465102,
0.2245799303,
-0.2536285222,
-0.3548846543,
1.0559712648,
-0.2533451021,
-0.5757712126,
0.1365898401,
0.2731445432,
0.3870776594,
-0.3561679423,
-0.0775906444,
-0.0454029292,
-0.0234261919,
-0.21958296,
-1.0369766951,
0.319483906,
0.4129820764,
-0.1941538155,
-0.2038550377,
0.7214961052,
-0.4602456391,
-0.5290162563,
0.1275887042,
0.3593295813,
-0.0567013286,
-0.2796984613,
-0.368014127,
0.4464870691,
-0.1493633986,
-0.4168247581,
0.2540870309,
0.9086232781,
0.1370723993,
0.3734699488,
0.5485802889,
0.3296509385,
0.2678261995,
0.1522725374,
0.5180416703,
-0.8008464575,
-0.4301718473,
-0.5422822833,
0.5037177801,
-0.2475266308,
-0.4260105491,
0.3928445876,
0.596173048,
1.0550522804,
0.2050202638,
1.0676189661,
-0.1230386347,
0.4686670303,
-0.5749596357,
0.5262122154,
-0.5299413204,
0.0489692651,
-0.315539062,
-0.8162861466,
-0.4118093252,
0.1085923612,
-0.5425069928,
-0.4009638727,
0.8042655587,
0.7308828235,
0.2669438124,
0.4472138286,
0.4745263457,
0.4203299284,
0.3226081431,
0.3616030514,
1.0424836874,
-0.3377866745,
0.3431437016,
-0.4921518862,
-0.3579399884,
-0.1418834925,
-0.8813479543,
-0.9037503004,
-0.6965510249,
-0.5478780866,
-0.0338056199,
0.6594952941,
1.0056583881,
0.4500787258,
-0.7574412227,
-0.1537172496,
0.148012206,
0.4314613938,
-0.2475448698,
-0.1415390819,
0.3978521228,
-0.5206013322,
-0.6101762056,
0.4843557179,
0.40260607,
-0.2963780761,
0.3435764313,
0.2496367991,
-0.3913368583,
0.0074093235,
0.8622123599,
0.1742991507,
-0.5328967571,
-0.6674415469,
-0.2581085563,
0.0003632326,
0.0451871343,
0.6844937801,
-0.3979125619,
0.4054112732,
0.5690063834,
0.6979025602,
0.6351330876,
-0.3369696736,
0.4765332341,
-0.6713003516,
-0.1550188661,
-0.0405141376,
0.3710960746,
0.250015378,
-0.4044545591,
0.3509586751,
0.2875860333,
-0.6703506112,
-0.6023828983,
-0.0752516612,
-0.7044996619,
-0.0596136153,
1.3451617956,
0.239225477,
-0.3206450045,
-0.281285435,
-0.2543073893,
0.4198130369,
-0.0961835012,
0.6400398016,
1.0395665169,
-0.3517969847,
-0.0619260967,
-0.6533982158,
0.7387343049,
0.1790079921,
-0.8851645589,
0.3824556768,
0.428386569,
0.124488771,
-0.2515520453,
0.574934423,
-0.1612343043,
0.4538519979,
-0.1958304644,
0.6059685946,
-0.0893095806,
-0.4598385096,
-0.1852634996,
0.0851957723,
0.2774032652,
0.1508622319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13089v1
|
Towards an empirical understanding of MoE design choices
| 2024-02-20T15:31:44 | 2024-02-20T15:31:44 |
Dongyang Fan, Bettina Messmer, Martin Jaggi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this study, we systematically evaluate the impact of common design choices
in Mixture of Experts (MoEs) on validation performance, uncovering distinct
influences at token and sequence levels. We also present empirical evidence
showing comparable performance between a learned router and a frozen, randomly
initialized router, suggesting that learned routing may not be essential. Our
study further reveals that Sequence-level routing can result in topic-specific
weak expert specialization, in contrast to syntax specialization observed with
Token-level routing.
|
[
-0.6653398871,
-0.6835787296,
0.4385329783,
0.0530663095,
-0.2688856423,
-0.0397475325,
0.1217753813,
-0.4712259769,
0.0567238294,
0.1830534339,
-0.2563082278,
-0.1664264947,
-0.2928190827,
0.1753745079,
-0.1898474544,
0.7641658783,
0.0139397597,
0.2089746594,
-0.3137308061,
0.0084001338,
-0.9165952206,
-0.3023099601,
-0.6350498796,
-0.446339339,
0.5828688145,
0.4695239067,
0.489716351,
0.4096336365,
0.3713111579,
0.2740538716,
-0.3387913108,
0.1681492478,
-0.2606010437,
0.1459391713,
-0.5140486956,
-0.6853724718,
-0.5040047765,
-0.30021137,
0.4874216914,
0.8004615903,
-0.3404235244,
0.0053019449,
0.1868311316,
0.7018331289,
-0.7109424472,
-0.0870746449,
-0.7452945113,
0.2748637497,
-0.3333221674,
-0.1201061532,
-0.6735289693,
0.1091708764,
0.4224920273,
-0.5721392632,
0.3513537645,
0.6215360165,
0.6984273195,
0.240339607,
-0.6650321484,
-0.2635394335,
-0.7862395048,
0.892670393,
-0.4983998239,
0.5675504208,
0.1468910724,
0.2080536634,
-0.331327945,
-0.5486406684,
-0.1827442646,
0.3537118137,
-0.0816215277,
0.2660003901,
0.0435231924,
0.3239170015,
0.3153906167,
0.635856688,
-0.4434682429,
0.3984744549,
-0.8220757246,
-0.0654492006,
0.868896246,
0.3621478081,
0.2342367619,
-0.1998665035,
-0.3684976697,
0.1114693061,
-0.5892542005,
0.3821127713,
0.4234341383,
-0.0683769584,
-0.039623104,
0.3836736977,
-0.5825270414,
0.9446631074,
0.2096050084,
-0.1243377179,
0.394939661,
0.0699770004,
-0.2287682295,
0.0314105004,
0.6363167763,
0.3288953602,
0.2083162367,
-0.4264865816,
-0.4318648875,
-0.4584997892,
0.6164158583,
-0.4192261994,
-0.4110158384,
0.2189286649,
-0.6658312678,
-0.1682714075,
0.3909141123,
-0.9165016413,
-0.1897736937,
-0.5080667734,
0.5136947036,
-0.3073852658,
-0.4616124332,
0.2854375541,
-0.8140479326,
0.2168357968,
0.5229418874,
-0.9038484097,
0.1885244399,
1.0262259245,
0.609837234,
-0.2364097238,
-0.4204418957,
-0.0089597022,
-0.0365861617,
-0.4643783569,
0.7429131866,
-0.6160154343,
-0.8245382309,
-0.2192548811,
-0.6313191652,
-0.3184920251,
-0.7391895056,
0.5000075102,
-0.9749860168,
-0.0215175301,
-0.4937693775,
-0.5904585719,
-0.3774788082,
-0.1038846895,
-0.6368889809,
0.7255988121,
-0.1056398898,
-0.8398603201,
0.9828391075,
-0.546662569,
-0.7260856032,
-0.1718169451,
-0.4319042265,
-0.0939173326,
0.6199420094,
0.0256921723,
0.3336814046,
-0.0018075804,
0.2847798169,
-0.3608925641,
-0.47553882,
0.3676789701,
-0.5339902043,
0.708073318,
0.5286665559,
-0.3942564726,
-0.0392135642,
-1.2928547859,
-0.0414615981,
-0.2276655287,
-0.5262975097,
-0.4603520036,
0.3012547493,
-0.4514073431,
0.1840740293,
-0.1914694607,
-0.4525761008,
-0.0371674709,
-0.136353001,
0.3537258208,
1.1824097633,
0.4206890166,
0.597252965,
-0.5979353189,
0.3392628729,
0.2855884433,
0.2086256146,
-0.1162732393,
-1.0936561823,
-1.0801562071,
-0.3041111529,
0.5600735545,
0.2672256827,
-0.509578824,
0.3045239151,
-0.1589418799,
-0.4364027083,
-0.5079852343,
0.1460687816,
0.4613343775,
0.568035841,
0.3257036507,
-0.5546095371,
-0.3195589483,
-1.1365334988,
-0.4596171975,
-0.1567414552,
-0.1001104638,
0.5092887282,
0.3495103717,
-0.0676163435,
1.4589617252,
-0.4883575141,
0.2600671947,
-0.0862447247,
0.3998861015,
0.0935068727,
0.7286651134,
0.7577479482,
-0.6238950491,
-0.4209971428,
-0.0217962861,
-0.6854295731,
-0.031523142,
0.0241366588,
-0.3113505244,
-0.3511944115,
0.2329916507,
-0.5820645094,
0.6318435669,
0.2055735737,
-0.1636001915,
0.3620226085,
0.165065527,
0.1372775286,
-0.7565307617,
-0.3130047321,
-0.0529864207,
0.377761662,
-0.5073420405,
0.1537792981,
-0.1485794187,
0.0378010496,
-0.4116779566,
0.5869551301,
-0.2832578719,
-0.1114944294,
0.1395735592,
-0.5381733775,
0.2857240438,
0.5493730307,
-0.0653187782,
0.9263994694,
0.5608865619,
-0.93718189,
-0.0702500716,
-0.0420081578,
-0.4749007821,
0.7265324593,
-0.9619867206,
0.3335282505,
-0.133852452,
-0.0441948585,
-1.0598938465,
-0.3516777456,
0.2078748643,
-0.270136714,
0.2577849627,
-0.2230721712,
-0.4666897058,
-0.2811376154,
0.0974608511,
0.5732316971,
0.7043273449,
-0.2936829627,
0.805655539,
-0.0007613804,
0.0879784673,
-0.2457509637,
-0.7776882648,
-0.2425393462,
-0.3054065406,
-0.771238327,
0.1547667235,
-0.2049098909,
-0.6297318935,
-0.2791042626,
-0.183982864,
-0.2172669172,
0.5101140141,
0.4419978559,
-0.1809835285,
-0.5379365087,
-0.0272931885,
0.3982860446,
-0.0148053812,
0.2885380983,
-0.1495359987,
0.4163530469,
-0.0058190254,
-0.9509792328,
-0.649990797,
0.5409986973,
0.6622644067,
-0.3432496488,
0.7578088045,
0.1135060191,
-0.0892913863,
-0.3174780607,
-0.8575769663,
0.0497615151,
-0.5291545391,
0.0312654227,
-0.6309331656,
-0.6007671356,
0.7599802017,
0.0308010578,
0.2695035338,
0.6383647323,
0.1969913095,
-0.2368323356,
0.9515656829,
0.3230159283,
0.1080538705,
0.429772377,
0.0312442146,
0.0936954021,
-0.9640635848,
-0.4209679365,
-0.4435798526,
-0.591812253,
-0.4084306061,
-0.2232097685,
0.2944500148,
0.2890140414,
-0.3498394489,
-0.304579258,
-0.172837913,
0.4277853966,
0.9250801802,
0.3603630662,
0.2329878211,
0.1765043288,
-0.5893495083,
0.3328895271,
-1.10701406,
-0.422155112,
1.3148472309,
0.388777554,
0.7062096596,
0.0241623335,
0.8921107054,
0.2003350705,
0.1318911761,
-0.4795777798,
0.4625797868,
0.2920575738,
-0.9118062854,
-0.1318688989,
-0.2407402396,
-0.9082664251,
0.3006126285,
-0.037248835,
-0.5178339481,
0.6592499018,
0.261525929,
-0.5920774341,
0.3194091916,
-0.8609326482,
0.3824488819,
-0.2932428718,
-0.2920667529,
-0.301253289,
-0.4681223631,
0.2725917101,
-0.1429997236,
0.1867622286,
0.2813043594,
0.1776524782,
0.8936470747,
-0.3689107597,
0.8791187406,
0.0558932163,
0.0615081973,
0.5079231262,
-0.0565479435,
0.1735430062,
0.1849283576,
-0.5693482161,
0.374178201,
-0.9013617039,
-0.5054649711,
-0.523573637,
0.4814397395,
-1.0728418827,
-0.8061947823,
-0.0646249056,
-0.1682260484,
-0.4451892972,
0.2672041953,
0.5830110312,
0.6377690434,
-0.1718618125,
0.3578714132,
0.9966365099,
0.0144874528,
0.257371366,
0.3048359454,
0.1045752019,
-0.4850729108,
0.5830073953,
0.2633422017,
0.2760841846,
0.3466616869,
0.2126122266,
0.2850340307,
-0.9501042366,
-0.7246804833,
-0.3945639729,
-0.761338532,
0.0341086611,
-0.5891044736,
-0.2103127539,
-0.0368528366,
-0.4428911805,
-0.4951422513,
-0.332508266,
-0.5670941472,
-0.3611133099,
0.2343222052,
1.1498703957,
0.0563402697,
0.4283273816,
-0.6548342705,
0.0243681744,
0.63641119,
0.5720491409,
0.5919018388,
-0.4565626979,
-0.2482963651,
0.0500752255,
-0.5339192748,
-0.5882986784,
-0.36653018,
-0.018239215,
1.1712212563,
1.1244353056,
0.0699750707,
0.6774809361,
-0.7579811811,
1.0281201601,
0.1237113476,
-0.7398237586,
0.6643958092,
-0.2987582088,
-0.1063328162,
0.6701225042,
0.2129426301,
0.1075072438,
-0.2024083585,
-0.9214187264,
-0.7354393601,
0.3084896803,
0.2390792966,
0.126353085,
-0.1499862671,
0.3524546623,
0.4970995784,
0.3970136642,
-0.1954208761,
-0.4431304336,
-0.0545895286,
0.2898375094,
0.1460605562,
-0.5004399419,
-0.2518230677,
-0.2422772646,
0.1434578001,
0.5282082558,
0.2851895988,
0.1198050156,
0.0585629344,
-0.0648808181,
0.2672758102,
0.8286617398,
1.1039965153,
-0.1798046529,
-0.0371854864,
0.1769027412,
-0.0283233486,
-0.0130717857,
-0.443541497,
-0.3746989667,
0.2280645519,
0.6657919884,
0.9555325508,
0.4847068787,
-0.1396653801,
0.1817014515,
0.1319293827,
-0.3316909671,
0.174243018,
0.6258454919,
-0.4332982302,
0.1198354959,
0.56353724,
0.6946772337,
0.4207561016,
-0.2832578719,
0.2944793105,
0.2352380306,
-0.04996939,
-0.5429961085,
0.62278229,
0.8184146285,
-0.6313269138,
0.735773325,
-0.0461986437,
-0.4414674044,
0.6872317791,
0.1447073966,
0.9033235908,
-0.1538496763,
-0.1419665217,
0.1878299117,
0.085283041,
0.0270096716,
0.1279615164,
-0.1898329258,
-0.595341444,
-0.060238868,
-0.4251140654,
-0.3470063508,
-0.4326655269,
-1.1394989491,
0.2576444149,
-0.6223407984,
-0.3690718412,
-0.4167594612,
-0.5576572418,
-1.1236544847,
0.5044766068,
-0.0850955248,
1.0934624672,
-0.8390421867,
0.1772560626,
0.9645234346,
-0.1420127451,
-0.8530105352,
-0.0120565882,
0.0030392539,
-0.8860845566,
0.9095082879,
-0.1670888811,
0.0259339381,
-0.1650846303,
-0.120303303,
-0.7700576782,
1.1000323296,
-0.3494724035,
-0.5141881108,
0.0254096221,
0.0878578275,
0.4199461043,
-0.2258284539,
0.43743065,
-0.0465355366,
0.1010279879,
0.1373749971,
-1.188908577,
-0.4691214561,
-0.3271883428,
0.1195545197,
-0.0111388387,
-1.0920687914,
1.1673179865,
0.0231013838,
0.070886828,
-0.1732669473,
0.8211783767,
0.4901959598,
0.7073324919,
0.5101462603,
0.7641379833,
0.9039331675,
0.1888444424,
0.878495872,
-0.3232248724,
0.1414665878,
0.7558749318,
-0.0980414525,
0.8420625925,
0.5005110502,
-0.1960939914,
0.848508656,
0.8968693614,
0.4065223038,
0.8052285314,
0.2002402097,
-0.034633413,
-0.2964874506,
0.2643563747,
-0.9068566561,
0.3745243847,
0.3441469669,
-0.4491091967,
-0.0759134889,
-0.0941514671,
-0.0997578129,
-0.4730735421,
-0.5859696865,
0.8154115081,
0.0335819349,
-0.7573727369,
0.0895019844,
-0.0317233913,
0.6552909613,
-0.2244253904,
0.0528740324,
-0.3690059483,
-0.0508762859,
-0.2918587625,
-0.7769557238,
-0.0323740505,
-0.2642742395,
-0.4697882831,
-0.2340501547,
0.5669878125,
0.3961645365,
-0.4539923966,
-0.1038066596,
0.6067805886,
-0.1072884277,
0.1516126245,
-0.3639000654,
0.0632532537,
-0.193411395,
-0.5187932253,
0.4922778904,
1.0167630911,
0.1169507429,
0.7545546293,
0.5140585303,
-0.0886760056,
0.4713494778,
-0.1192913353,
0.9772978425,
-0.4315469265,
-0.7442920208,
-0.708853066,
0.9023399949,
-0.224252224,
-0.670075655,
0.8807557821,
0.7008894682,
1.1771137714,
-0.2618690431,
0.8620038033,
0.3191391826,
0.2593241036,
-0.9725007415,
0.5748822093,
-0.6056519747,
0.6394588947,
-0.3796057701,
-0.6438325047,
0.0815523341,
0.6616712809,
-0.5150488615,
0.2900007963,
0.3470858335,
0.390050739,
-0.3539644182,
0.1982934177,
0.1074056178,
-0.1851211339,
0.3039731979,
0.3609860241,
1.1541492939,
-0.1007184535,
-0.0044923639,
-0.3542894423,
-0.2444494367,
-0.6272956729,
-0.7837826014,
-1.1383234262,
-0.2539201975,
-0.3286727667,
-0.1044989973,
-0.017964201,
0.6570125818,
0.888710916,
-0.70950526,
-0.1036963686,
-0.2056600302,
0.5126335621,
-0.1920791715,
-0.2542078197,
0.0538665615,
-0.3509418964,
-0.3770414293,
0.1541458219,
0.2219022065,
-0.1294887811,
-0.0922809467,
-0.1419769675,
0.2411135733,
0.2730502784,
0.5738251209,
0.0123488382,
-1.0180270672,
-0.1533494443,
-0.0417346433,
0.1294569224,
0.2712066472,
1.177058816,
-0.6600376964,
0.5390300751,
0.8702144623,
0.6125439405,
-0.1831072122,
0.2756112516,
0.8139744401,
-0.4925306737,
-0.0438712239,
0.0096859848,
0.6936877966,
-0.3381250501,
-0.3803107142,
0.3131183982,
0.4604709446,
-0.6586685777,
-0.8700588346,
0.2809630036,
-0.8140435219,
-0.1952499598,
1.2821519375,
-0.1028395146,
0.1343357861,
-0.4530436099,
-0.1990173012,
-0.3650918007,
-0.4839034379,
0.751691699,
1.0423848629,
-0.430175215,
-0.0351382233,
-0.682153523,
0.1762251705,
0.4221878648,
-0.080100663,
-0.5475447178,
0.2036250383,
0.5063621998,
0.3217839301,
0.4785860777,
0.4015408456,
0.3276954293,
0.1804268807,
-0.3122913837,
-0.2138447762,
-0.5012460947,
-0.0674190819,
0.2676131427,
0.4197123349,
-0.2797547579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13064v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13064v1
|
Synthetic Data (Almost) from Scratch: Generalized Instruction Tuning for Language Models
| 2024-02-20T15:00:35 | 2024-02-20T15:00:35 |
Haoran Li, Qingxiu Dong, Zhengyang Tang, Chaojun Wang, Xingxing Zhang, Haoyang Huang, Shaohan Huang, Xiaolong Huang, Zeqiang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Yuxian Gu, Xin Cheng, Xun Wang, Si-Qing Chen, Li Dong, Wei Lu, Zhifang Sui, Benyou Wang, Wai Lam, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Generalized Instruction Tuning (called GLAN), a general and
scalable method for instruction tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike
prior work that relies on seed examples or existing datasets to construct
instruction tuning data, GLAN exclusively utilizes a pre-curated taxonomy of
human knowledge and capabilities as input and generates large-scale synthetic
instruction data across all disciplines. Specifically, inspired by the
systematic structure in human education system, we build the taxonomy by
decomposing human knowledge and capabilities to various fields, sub-fields and
ultimately, distinct disciplines semi-automatically, facilitated by LLMs.
Subsequently, we generate a comprehensive list of subjects for every discipline
and proceed to design a syllabus tailored to each subject, again utilizing
LLMs. With the fine-grained key concepts detailed in every class session of the
syllabus, we are able to generate diverse instructions with a broad coverage
across the entire spectrum of human knowledge and skills. Extensive experiments
on large language models (e.g., Mistral) demonstrate that GLAN excels in
multiple dimensions from mathematical reasoning, coding, academic exams,
logical reasoning to general instruction following without using task-specific
training data of these tasks. In addition, GLAN allows for easy customization
and new fields or skills can be added by simply incorporating a new node into
our taxonomy.
|
[
-0.2108832151,
-1.0970875025,
0.450953722,
-0.1592950821,
0.0945895165,
0.5328931212,
-0.311437279,
-0.3843405247,
0.312458396,
0.5637262464,
-0.5846480727,
-0.7571944594,
-0.0753757134,
-0.3184179664,
-0.4942414463,
1.164239049,
0.1804286987,
-0.0012000187,
-0.215104267,
0.2029735297,
-0.2510540783,
-0.4291622341,
-0.6934294701,
-0.2423106134,
0.4043020308,
0.6785957813,
0.5682063103,
1.1018455029,
0.2234930545,
0.3573444486,
0.1197390556,
0.6810027361,
-0.5019343495,
-0.2487849593,
-0.5271577835,
-0.3293462992,
-0.9376969934,
0.0890946314,
0.8336911798,
0.8834078312,
-0.3006551564,
0.5465806127,
0.0763418302,
0.624833107,
-0.5527426004,
-0.0588139221,
-0.800804317,
-0.141656369,
-0.2616018951,
-0.3566999137,
-0.5443045497,
-0.6578980684,
-0.0740876645,
-0.8461238146,
0.7782253027,
0.2835735083,
0.825502038,
0.0414098911,
-0.3522664309,
-0.5394362807,
-0.8951712847,
1.0132858753,
-0.3008548319,
0.2723919451,
0.4321622849,
0.4023632407,
-0.308829546,
-0.9022650123,
-0.5513502359,
-0.399128437,
-0.0358288623,
-0.0453514904,
-0.0142460065,
0.5608797669,
0.2999629974,
0.6962684989,
-0.5582313538,
0.1224821955,
-0.7985164523,
-0.2587170899,
0.7466522455,
0.4250881076,
0.4614415765,
0.3010630012,
-0.1682268977,
-0.2238976061,
-0.7842311263,
-0.0164257865,
0.64813447,
0.1829345077,
-0.1885091811,
0.4668685794,
-0.330052197,
1.2532064915,
0.0910306275,
-0.1460084915,
0.215503484,
-0.3878872097,
-0.4223311245,
-0.0931921303,
0.5838406682,
0.1606233269,
0.371622622,
-0.2661115527,
-0.0887351036,
0.1280441284,
0.6118326187,
-0.5044535995,
-0.4815375507,
0.0449294187,
-0.1776644289,
-0.2706935704,
0.0647721291,
-0.8533657193,
-0.0554609373,
-0.8982256651,
0.4351024926,
-0.3378744423,
0.1833853424,
0.035060484,
0.1636034995,
0.4154587984,
0.1536857039,
-1.4287666082,
0.5388860703,
0.7781636715,
0.8157492876,
-0.2277133912,
-0.2933674455,
-0.4387292564,
0.2590696216,
-0.654104948,
0.6667273641,
-0.774513185,
-0.469765842,
0.0765548944,
0.1013904884,
-0.2234922349,
-0.5688705444,
0.3113244176,
-0.5241547823,
0.3765330017,
-0.0474800542,
-0.8749092817,
-0.1290878654,
0.1295838207,
-0.6296020746,
1.0039669275,
0.3054591417,
-0.1929848641,
0.1108567491,
-0.9071364999,
-0.5871079564,
-0.1628301442,
-0.2279889286,
-0.2167759091,
0.2683394253,
-0.0117895408,
0.167157352,
-0.490812391,
0.1856775135,
-0.0491535775,
-0.5290826559,
-0.1793514639,
-0.0945077389,
0.6833273172,
0.1802826524,
-0.0331522487,
0.2900455892,
-0.9850867987,
0.7090752125,
-0.3540891707,
-0.3368441761,
-0.2345501631,
-0.0532674566,
-0.2434870005,
-0.1407633275,
0.282608062,
-0.4131068885,
0.6041346192,
-0.486004591,
0.4743557274,
0.801886797,
-0.147986412,
0.7135052085,
-0.3522758484,
0.6833385229,
-0.3704084456,
0.1361463517,
-0.1131424829,
-0.4366544187,
-0.7815995216,
-0.2707674205,
0.3143879473,
0.7388656735,
-0.6533838511,
0.4318368137,
-0.1033174172,
-0.4454616606,
-0.7861809134,
0.5102440715,
0.4817473888,
0.5677722096,
0.5739072561,
0.0016338124,
-0.708701849,
-0.9311506152,
0.0096276989,
-0.0474314317,
-0.1712902039,
0.0354639143,
0.3864055574,
-0.2756319344,
1.0759841204,
-0.845941484,
-0.274836868,
-0.320017904,
0.1226662323,
0.2877859771,
0.5015821457,
0.5075709224,
-0.411680311,
-0.5216622949,
0.3000729978,
-0.6269208193,
-0.2611779571,
-0.1713104844,
-0.4370221198,
0.1978199333,
0.7834128737,
-0.3584292829,
0.1448985785,
0.6116297245,
-0.155714184,
0.83408916,
-0.6436422467,
-0.004188051,
-1.23785007,
0.0561772175,
-0.2875214517,
0.1573376358,
-0.8492605686,
0.1224854738,
0.3375236392,
0.0781509131,
-0.2119970322,
0.7680097222,
-0.5484401584,
0.1082465723,
-0.3377574682,
-0.3222160041,
0.0506925583,
0.4245235026,
-0.1269221604,
1.0258716345,
0.4884037077,
-0.7601214051,
0.6045588851,
-0.0452027172,
-0.5246768594,
0.4094540775,
-0.9163074493,
0.3157913685,
-0.0653296933,
0.0412267148,
-0.6246352792,
-0.6127451658,
0.2511536777,
-0.0852467492,
0.5427238345,
-0.1405693144,
-0.1215536445,
-0.339890331,
-0.3181800544,
0.3761079013,
0.5047560334,
-0.5325400233,
0.6070158482,
0.2822429538,
-0.0100974375,
-0.4901897609,
-0.4236639738,
0.0468639694,
-0.1762373894,
-0.4101093113,
0.660202384,
-0.1970057935,
-0.1590060592,
0.1818450987,
0.12720263,
-0.1833161861,
-0.047261741,
0.0736840293,
0.4617175758,
-0.325994432,
0.3111818135,
0.3726220727,
0.0451198146,
0.004908754,
-0.6256356239,
0.488784641,
0.0434816927,
-0.3632256687,
-0.2297504097,
0.2664766014,
0.30443874,
-0.1233655885,
0.7107294202,
0.5712255239,
-0.1571917683,
-0.8991068602,
-0.3831476569,
0.0909599364,
-0.5646439195,
0.6306816339,
-0.0778532326,
-1.0166211128,
0.4033821821,
0.0016411493,
0.1223773658,
0.0834999084,
0.612563014,
-0.1461205184,
0.740183115,
0.9518558383,
-0.3478991091,
0.5704029202,
-0.5313740373,
0.1237612069,
-0.7819110155,
-0.3117367625,
-0.3481007218,
-0.4648601711,
-0.681669116,
-0.6639531255,
0.3849604726,
0.0311264526,
-0.3061415851,
0.0675487816,
-0.5948933959,
1.0995056629,
0.7493157983,
-0.0563524738,
0.0955986977,
0.1835366935,
0.0166658089,
0.2875829041,
-0.5608423352,
-0.4349095225,
1.4364331961,
-0.003947387,
0.9355645776,
-0.0966852531,
0.7972063422,
0.5039070249,
0.2952673733,
-0.8376324773,
0.5966815352,
-0.3279460669,
-0.6323313117,
-0.2170595527,
-0.5416705012,
-0.9556416273,
-0.0289510153,
0.0202055182,
-0.7854934931,
-0.2515026927,
0.6396752,
-0.5332373381,
0.4242045581,
-1.0763317347,
0.7144818306,
-0.2310519218,
-0.3258532286,
-0.2951010466,
-0.3919139504,
0.6476873755,
-0.0989714041,
0.191915825,
0.2829647362,
-0.0639798269,
0.7044010758,
-0.3757416606,
0.972679913,
-0.0586477034,
-0.2113258392,
0.4587340951,
-0.0686549768,
0.1581165344,
-0.087824814,
-0.0034977964,
-0.1463216841,
-0.0995953605,
-0.5024788976,
-0.8017728925,
0.8436134458,
-0.9861055613,
-0.7019879818,
-0.2122053951,
-0.8732465506,
-0.3915647268,
0.0974854603,
0.1349149346,
0.4946628809,
-0.386501193,
-0.0911743194,
0.8504493833,
-0.3954234123,
0.2197378427,
0.4023044705,
-0.2488139719,
-0.6276471615,
1.3818445206,
0.1626593471,
0.5766063929,
0.4118060172,
0.0280663855,
-0.2683159411,
-0.3966251016,
-0.5591109395,
0.2134055942,
-0.498462379,
-0.2267394662,
-0.1079282537,
-0.4402273893,
-0.2784315646,
-0.2293366045,
-0.1938827634,
-0.4000245035,
-0.2331643254,
-0.1185842827,
0.2954719961,
1.0605795383,
-0.1303687245,
0.5115388632,
-0.7346494794,
0.6322098374,
0.5144353509,
0.35885638,
-0.068502225,
-0.759399116,
-0.544865191,
0.3481287956,
-0.4208811522,
-0.5124206543,
0.197700575,
0.9146820307,
0.5632809997,
0.3773161173,
-0.2598156333,
0.7567279339,
-0.7898223996,
0.6371298432,
-0.1638521701,
-1.0018162727,
0.5662462115,
-0.2786402702,
0.2187244147,
0.1960597038,
0.3861630261,
-0.3322053254,
-0.2449938953,
-0.4376958907,
-0.8655210137,
0.8309479356,
-0.3456170261,
0.5010266304,
0.1042481437,
0.4006755054,
0.1050869152,
0.2308398634,
-0.115279153,
-0.2661820948,
0.004796356,
-0.3978560567,
-0.286513418,
-0.2304714173,
-0.2609258592,
-0.6884145737,
0.6342584491,
-0.2693017423,
0.1297021806,
-0.2328197211,
-0.0317889601,
-0.1332754642,
0.2467973083,
0.8711153269,
0.8034003973,
-0.0962642357,
0.0510532595,
0.2580800056,
-0.8474308848,
0.3415049314,
-0.3135855794,
-0.2652358711,
-0.2267487049,
0.5486348271,
0.7761929035,
0.1525063217,
-0.3817690909,
-0.2238383293,
0.3277810514,
-0.3812004626,
-0.1283979863,
0.6306763887,
0.0901687518,
-0.0574911498,
0.3302588165,
-0.1918255836,
-0.1516704708,
-0.7455525398,
0.2723435462,
0.3759145737,
0.2038391382,
-0.6579565406,
0.5173612833,
0.0013692843,
-0.2352979183,
0.5748399496,
-0.3761488795,
-0.2181746215,
0.6475244164,
0.8984851837,
0.782143712,
-0.3661651015,
0.7544307113,
0.3835650384,
0.3273794055,
-0.0953736231,
0.3349901736,
-0.0108108083,
-0.7617317438,
-0.652148664,
-0.9816117883,
-0.7135526538,
0.3397098482,
-0.7414406538,
0.0320790596,
-0.8636713624,
0.0915584341,
0.0070048962,
0.0824384391,
-0.4777580202,
0.38782987,
0.0372778736,
0.8153848648,
-0.9122017622,
1.2938777208,
1.0847634077,
-0.0892788768,
-0.8617810607,
-0.1575843841,
0.0314406417,
-0.9117107391,
0.4596608877,
-0.2061185986,
-0.1380319446,
0.1940066665,
-0.6413023472,
-0.8211135864,
0.9846246839,
0.6590009332,
-0.5503213406,
-0.2809739411,
0.5303668976,
0.7760782242,
-0.3541174531,
0.0151750129,
0.8781802654,
0.1321113408,
0.1819908768,
-0.7245922089,
-0.3643355072,
-0.342691958,
0.0503707007,
0.2438013852,
-0.542845428,
0.9151536822,
-0.2467347533,
-0.0473635048,
0.0677118972,
0.767611146,
0.1665156186,
0.2851487398,
0.0930411369,
0.6650859118,
1.173324585,
-0.0318778716,
0.9293907285,
-0.3543343842,
0.1925421208,
1.1672978401,
0.0014970332,
0.4438454211,
0.2785975635,
-0.1866978854,
0.5832598805,
0.4135221839,
0.0035831803,
0.4169035256,
0.4134535789,
-0.2532654107,
-0.2543206811,
0.0304482635,
-0.5347675085,
0.4358766973,
0.5012224913,
-0.2684235573,
-0.1567960382,
-0.1834749281,
-0.135262683,
0.1867274791,
-0.6479833722,
0.5175977945,
0.0097806072,
-0.5272048116,
0.8501623869,
0.0635530353,
0.4355796278,
-0.8771503568,
-0.1965206265,
-0.3856888413,
0.2467824817,
-0.3416019976,
-0.6628654599,
0.3675298393,
0.1038450599,
-0.3851993382,
-0.2589088678,
0.4946516454,
-0.7095116377,
-0.8467314243,
-0.0090219257,
0.3752115667,
-0.0943018943,
0.4533671141,
-0.3856278062,
0.1068255901,
0.126780346,
-0.2015849054,
0.4860203266,
0.4953291714,
-0.2922201753,
0.7733975053,
0.7178287506,
0.3864940405,
0.2483772933,
0.1251505613,
0.9824060798,
-0.7593462467,
-0.3480499387,
-0.7307721972,
0.4246105254,
-0.0998280421,
-0.4544596672,
0.6611797214,
0.5840045214,
1.2849498987,
-0.3743812144,
0.8798545599,
-0.1169042513,
0.4207662642,
-0.8194428682,
0.7373983264,
-0.4491567016,
0.2000604421,
-0.1461076736,
-1.0597933531,
-0.1751379222,
0.4422909319,
-0.3338609338,
0.0730081648,
0.4979032576,
1.0799921751,
-0.3159977198,
-0.0848602355,
0.3032960892,
-0.0527064018,
0.1870098561,
0.4289114773,
0.7754388452,
-0.0651645064,
0.1872326732,
-0.1777507216,
-0.3106934428,
0.1377646774,
-0.5796292424,
-0.9752841592,
-0.5065159202,
-0.171859324,
0.0971942842,
0.2883940339,
0.9452237487,
0.495316714,
-1.2226737738,
-0.5403265357,
0.0297948997,
0.1716383249,
-0.1426042616,
-0.2403726131,
0.4709936678,
-0.8126649857,
-0.8064640164,
0.7071865201,
-0.0233273115,
-0.2018308192,
-0.0977753475,
-0.1289772391,
0.0713938177,
0.0746379569,
0.5137287378,
0.5590241551,
-0.4380588531,
-0.4522665739,
0.1635368913,
-0.0859768465,
-0.3228216767,
0.7909035683,
-0.6630854011,
0.4398922026,
0.3055212796,
0.6237671971,
0.0491456464,
0.2042424381,
0.6557070613,
-1.004124403,
0.1801148504,
-0.0234929807,
-0.0601332746,
0.0302676149,
-0.1150535643,
0.4731049538,
0.1762757152,
-0.5449553728,
-0.8442858458,
0.2749993503,
-0.843982935,
0.0198675636,
0.9510563016,
-0.0042256806,
-0.3328347504,
0.1184890717,
-0.2697172463,
0.201238811,
-0.0313810073,
1.1695923805,
0.4439703226,
-0.0990058854,
0.2461380363,
-0.6257015467,
0.7388903499,
0.2897711396,
-0.895403266,
-0.0471751615,
0.5255259871,
0.2005211413,
-0.0071292473,
0.3673581779,
0.218258217,
0.2751187384,
-0.1429410875,
0.1654730886,
-0.3798149824,
-0.7097269297,
-0.0107391886,
0.2021008283,
-0.0646685883,
-0.4751131237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13055v1
|
Identifying Semantic Induction Heads to Understand In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-20T14:43:39 | 2024-02-20T14:43:39 |
Jie Ren, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Dongrui Liu, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance, the lack of transparency in their inference logic raises concerns
about their trustworthiness. To gain a better understanding of LLMs, we conduct
a detailed analysis of the operations of attention heads and aim to better
understand the in-context learning of LLMs. Specifically, we investigate
whether attention heads encode two types of relationships between tokens
present in natural languages: the syntactic dependency parsed from sentences
and the relation within knowledge graphs. We find that certain attention heads
exhibit a pattern where, when attending to head tokens, they recall tail tokens
and increase the output logits of those tail tokens. More crucially, the
formulation of such semantic induction heads has a close correlation with the
emergence of the in-context learning ability of language models. The study of
semantic attention heads advances our understanding of the intricate operations
of attention heads in transformers, and further provides new insights into the
in-context learning of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2309825271,
-0.6465805769,
0.7751932144,
0.0790559873,
-0.0668519437,
-0.2921051383,
-0.4037454128,
-0.6115780473,
0.0429387577,
0.7953191996,
-0.9228889942,
-0.325040251,
-0.832034409,
0.294139415,
-0.5688412786,
0.7487339973,
0.1253874749,
0.0245824587,
-0.4644052088,
-0.0952151865,
-0.5046420693,
-0.4515962601,
-0.6990872622,
-0.4785249531,
0.5904355049,
0.1723811775,
0.4861957133,
0.8533018827,
0.6688170433,
0.3095465302,
-0.2143884599,
0.0673801079,
-0.5070408583,
0.1303988695,
-0.4783446789,
-0.5238273144,
-0.1446841955,
-0.0756110996,
0.7491987348,
1.0816289186,
0.3819966316,
0.2164484859,
0.2715143263,
0.6547496915,
-0.6655667424,
0.6805073023,
-0.9638628364,
0.0447032154,
-0.1710619479,
-0.4621646404,
-0.6672075987,
0.0698264241,
0.4137220681,
-0.5017950535,
0.0885170475,
0.0324576013,
0.7394378781,
0.5284651518,
-0.4375192225,
-0.3633871078,
-0.467015028,
0.8595435023,
-0.4053892195,
0.5789076686,
0.1897125244,
0.2302185595,
-0.5624602437,
-0.9911409616,
-0.6420511603,
0.1994956881,
-0.5100833774,
-0.1634064466,
0.0553930439,
0.2055050135,
0.3579698801,
0.2924111485,
-0.2176707834,
-0.0898259878,
-0.1166900545,
-0.1420315504,
0.1347621828,
0.2722214162,
0.3095105886,
-0.0434900969,
-0.4358272851,
-0.0344708785,
-0.8581014872,
-0.0825927705,
-0.0468551852,
0.4464179277,
-0.2775576711,
0.6614348888,
-0.2967126369,
1.1174112558,
0.2741999626,
-0.4397802949,
0.1675691605,
-0.312394917,
-0.2767678797,
0.197383821,
0.5581594706,
0.2692904174,
0.6179401875,
-0.589166522,
-0.0340267606,
0.1201615185,
0.1240382269,
-0.6754900217,
0.285833925,
0.0553416088,
-0.3854960203,
-0.1470948905,
0.0496075712,
-0.1403304338,
-0.2037517428,
-0.6574704647,
0.450070411,
-0.2913558781,
-0.1722883582,
0.1134403795,
-0.3136457503,
0.6938021779,
0.0765988678,
-0.9958181977,
0.2899254858,
0.9736564159,
0.645627141,
-0.365675509,
-0.5262402892,
-0.5520023704,
0.4810207486,
-0.1249095649,
0.7217384577,
-0.7499109507,
0.1239551008,
0.2412528396,
0.2837988734,
-0.2895355225,
-0.615244627,
0.1795843393,
-0.8400621414,
0.0308374614,
-0.4633484483,
-0.8689556122,
-0.2870708704,
0.0678563043,
-0.5817134976,
0.6480730176,
0.4659330845,
-1.1259639263,
0.3993967772,
-0.6353346109,
-0.4389066696,
0.0727943182,
-0.390591234,
0.1016749144,
0.0952539966,
0.0280456617,
0.7314664721,
-0.1940725595,
0.0353596918,
-0.1093801335,
-0.3192102611,
0.2994763851,
0.2318594009,
1.0971541405,
-0.1755094528,
-0.3180930614,
0.2258448899,
-0.6156836152,
-0.3636782765,
0.1233368218,
0.1060763747,
-0.4535797536,
-0.0952216685,
-0.3966084719,
0.3483259082,
0.1869835854,
-0.3931866586,
-0.1781757623,
-0.6202101111,
0.6369318962,
0.6223338246,
0.2949411571,
0.4987974465,
0.0927123278,
0.1442731321,
0.3446005285,
-0.1416288316,
-0.4093952775,
-0.4692636728,
-0.8817725778,
-0.0939251333,
0.1879501343,
0.1207230538,
-0.5487605929,
0.6829750538,
-0.2449579239,
0.0455632992,
-0.2428762466,
0.1814688742,
0.3948355913,
0.9760532379,
0.0324953571,
-0.4484952092,
-0.4592024386,
-0.8895690441,
-0.5034173131,
0.0182856936,
0.0049143932,
0.2192523479,
0.4413086176,
-0.356511116,
1.3658473492,
-0.2947790623,
-0.3146768808,
-0.438664943,
-0.231597662,
0.0189532582,
0.2578634024,
0.5848792791,
-0.5247288346,
-0.3236397505,
-0.0122316526,
-0.9887884259,
0.012018295,
-0.0279967487,
-0.4852494299,
-0.0164286252,
0.7279133201,
-0.7706698775,
0.2546335161,
0.3457068205,
-0.4960939288,
0.3010863364,
0.2695049942,
-0.4034164846,
-0.7656328082,
-0.0815941542,
-0.048738569,
-0.3052083254,
-0.590893209,
0.2755831182,
0.2145641446,
0.1992679238,
-0.608232975,
0.5587491393,
-0.3901936412,
-0.5789732933,
-0.1719990224,
0.4009495676,
0.0359718986,
0.7791035771,
0.2622405589,
0.6584110856,
0.6993800402,
-0.8918597102,
0.1326771826,
0.4071539938,
-0.3310254812,
0.4550286233,
-0.4940359592,
0.1814258099,
-0.3406411707,
0.2064371407,
-0.9079566598,
-0.5142675042,
0.2414674461,
-0.4681288302,
0.4261493385,
0.0067372802,
-0.5756883621,
0.0205380358,
-0.0350960605,
0.3446983099,
0.1760822386,
-0.6627110243,
0.5806480646,
0.6584134102,
0.102966778,
-0.5919161439,
-0.6264508963,
-0.19690983,
-0.3369757533,
-0.5577155352,
0.3214161992,
0.4092639685,
-0.5494958758,
0.0993633121,
-0.0579708256,
0.0258407798,
0.1388417482,
0.1397836655,
0.0635340586,
-0.1614590734,
0.0976427421,
-0.1051978916,
-0.2522492707,
0.599709928,
-0.464009136,
0.5629907846,
0.1012696028,
-0.08143875,
-0.6090714931,
0.0875705704,
0.7417472601,
-0.2625154555,
0.9688310027,
0.4116317928,
-0.617734015,
-0.1722637564,
-0.4010831416,
-0.5518684387,
-0.4761525989,
0.4878884256,
-0.3540067375,
-0.8293603063,
0.6054544449,
0.1113284901,
-0.0390748717,
0.6713792086,
0.739452064,
0.163993299,
0.6131337285,
0.727478981,
0.0856579095,
0.5116896629,
-0.1924022287,
0.1422004253,
-1.0814496279,
-0.4169679582,
-0.3320627809,
-0.0804874152,
-0.554957509,
-0.2225596309,
0.2720328867,
-0.1606302857,
-0.2777518034,
0.4627458453,
-0.2787629962,
0.5854020715,
0.3971705139,
0.099626936,
0.2837270796,
-0.0913031325,
-0.0745667815,
-0.0137442965,
-0.5662109256,
-0.3486894965,
1.0731570721,
0.4894673228,
0.5005783439,
-0.1991861314,
0.4691533744,
-0.0513041355,
0.0129156094,
-1.0192160606,
0.4829105139,
0.1649328619,
-0.3493042588,
-0.2914262712,
-0.2146875858,
-0.9061875343,
0.2140285224,
0.0929476991,
-0.7576953769,
0.0352736153,
-0.0888631269,
-0.235906899,
-0.0001474263,
-0.7660567164,
1.1728475094,
0.0660455748,
-0.3458868861,
-0.2257430255,
-0.9369339943,
0.4144757092,
0.105254285,
-0.0829735324,
0.0249679796,
-0.0453168489,
0.8933888078,
-0.2035984397,
0.9117584229,
0.0069252378,
-0.3031393588,
0.3977676928,
-0.0757995546,
0.5772389174,
-0.1245659888,
0.3375858963,
0.197487995,
-0.3481971025,
-0.183927089,
-0.5733830333,
0.728782773,
-0.7080811262,
-0.5430759788,
-0.1907542497,
-0.7824459672,
-0.5280914903,
0.2934780717,
0.1095406786,
0.4702067673,
0.2350222617,
0.1381347775,
0.8496802449,
-0.0294329002,
0.4602265656,
0.1568485796,
-0.1490535885,
0.1910948604,
0.5786200166,
0.0405885689,
0.4495311081,
0.6045846939,
0.0897988901,
-0.3641794622,
-0.3722466826,
-0.2116518468,
0.4780793488,
-1.0019772053,
-0.0249639433,
-0.9279527068,
-0.357021749,
-0.2782766521,
0.1175859198,
-0.2098619193,
-0.4372085035,
-0.1662554145,
-0.0835708901,
0.4202445447,
0.8463837504,
0.4784156382,
0.492875278,
-0.4309650362,
0.3005638421,
0.442838341,
0.3598880172,
0.2891825736,
-0.5864554048,
-0.3648846447,
-0.289429754,
-0.2074637711,
-0.8284051418,
0.2476769388,
0.1438626647,
0.5604939461,
0.7373544574,
-0.0572479479,
0.6541234851,
-0.6010090709,
0.6129845977,
-0.0019729079,
-0.8749975562,
0.2589621544,
-0.3625473082,
0.335115999,
0.2134254277,
0.2787141502,
-0.467826128,
-0.7564738989,
-0.6145034432,
-0.6952841282,
0.9001313448,
0.1279853582,
0.0008800092,
-0.2865946889,
0.5203700662,
0.2751294672,
0.3149447441,
-0.5094166398,
-0.4005423486,
0.0764679089,
-0.1644360125,
0.1597578526,
-0.4230366945,
-0.0296512805,
-0.1933136731,
0.239796564,
-0.1481190771,
0.4941360652,
0.0003702559,
-0.4834243357,
-0.1056927294,
-0.1301014274,
0.5071725845,
1.0198447704,
-0.2323598117,
0.3638513088,
0.0790090635,
-0.4010131955,
-0.4309335053,
-0.4667540491,
0.0437946245,
0.1119726077,
0.6132551432,
0.8372988105,
0.4585207105,
-0.5173956156,
0.5031618476,
0.0472408794,
0.1866402179,
-0.6124088168,
0.0921023786,
0.2990838587,
0.1347304136,
0.3291299343,
-0.1029039174,
0.19702591,
-0.7046572566,
0.380215764,
0.6716224551,
-0.4573748112,
-0.3866428137,
0.4803130925,
0.1583226174,
-0.1906657666,
0.4790432453,
-0.0267747454,
-0.5868662596,
0.5543844104,
0.7035043836,
1.123116374,
0.1261127889,
-0.3161765635,
0.3563919067,
0.0982829034,
0.2425896525,
-0.0933253393,
-0.2311216444,
-0.8747460246,
-0.7423454523,
-0.6624189019,
-0.4654958248,
0.2170445174,
-0.8522580266,
0.3040803075,
-0.2958514392,
0.0691192225,
0.112982817,
-0.3607573807,
-0.8769314885,
0.0717821568,
0.3291710317,
0.7627959251,
-0.7186455727,
0.9008266926,
0.4372415543,
-0.1230674163,
-0.5428918004,
0.2115357518,
-0.1820718795,
-1.0159193277,
1.023175478,
0.5482293963,
-0.380284816,
0.1688854545,
-0.4134457111,
-0.9386929274,
0.8454907537,
0.4839264154,
-0.3535668254,
-0.2315443456,
0.2312529683,
0.2776557207,
-0.7781422734,
0.2849591076,
0.9595010281,
0.2740712464,
-0.1024470851,
-0.7840538621,
0.080220066,
0.3634927869,
0.022471616,
0.1644554883,
-0.5344551206,
0.7240108252,
-0.075209558,
-0.3573636711,
-0.3744551539,
0.8017979264,
0.0327946097,
-0.0360527635,
0.3849281073,
0.3676345944,
0.4359878898,
-0.1128629148,
1.0832613707,
-0.6972635984,
0.3362239897,
0.9583187699,
-0.2241996825,
0.7076893449,
0.9374864101,
-0.1009432375,
0.7184911966,
0.5144987106,
0.5096656084,
0.6337110996,
0.0142672593,
0.0486051291,
-0.2231848836,
-0.2557410002,
-0.1234615073,
0.5476440191,
0.648906827,
-0.4623859525,
-0.3098429441,
-0.0910908729,
-0.0066733086,
-0.0561744981,
-0.525940299,
0.9836636782,
0.1295485348,
-0.6461538672,
0.5343310237,
-0.1384314299,
0.4547854662,
-0.5363196135,
-0.0665962324,
0.0136062549,
0.3452575505,
-0.2417425364,
-0.6830604672,
0.5384193659,
-0.234713167,
-0.2045985907,
-0.0429883562,
0.5621128678,
-0.4227666855,
-0.2107505649,
0.4965532422,
0.29988271,
0.1000946313,
-0.0910756961,
-0.2689649165,
0.1230804846,
-0.2605588734,
-0.3235661685,
0.5000662208,
0.653652072,
-0.0845253021,
0.5103939772,
0.3345740139,
-0.0821890905,
0.1806954592,
0.0194279701,
0.7207868695,
-0.7336148024,
-0.4841953516,
-0.9654173851,
0.3617151678,
0.0027528375,
-0.1978058368,
0.8327440023,
0.3042521775,
1.1961010695,
-0.2842096686,
0.6632550359,
0.1498772353,
0.4570385516,
-0.6148502231,
0.526427567,
-0.2943374515,
0.0028715292,
-0.1445399076,
-0.9725667834,
-0.3484815359,
0.6892037988,
-0.2715974152,
-0.2256752551,
1.0496302843,
0.6706734896,
0.0589482002,
-0.1360295713,
0.2356660366,
0.2189635932,
-0.1405090094,
0.6386938691,
0.7515414953,
-0.3242709041,
0.2386586517,
-0.3678503633,
-0.0825943574,
-0.2158368677,
-0.8262575269,
-1.2107219696,
-0.5444064736,
-0.3005338311,
-0.3450156748,
-0.1144506261,
1.073374629,
0.3823381066,
-0.9004359841,
-0.3468717635,
-0.337857008,
0.3022583723,
-0.4140459895,
-0.2741613388,
0.5335046053,
-0.9916824698,
-0.8943876028,
0.1154272258,
0.4578622282,
-0.2603360415,
-0.4601834118,
-0.0952365026,
0.0409074761,
-0.0434083529,
0.7946954966,
-0.0133684408,
-1.0249493122,
-0.4332426488,
0.0128111457,
-0.1793474704,
0.1195143536,
0.909668684,
-0.9635351896,
0.2972396314,
0.4352062643,
0.8381661773,
0.2700982392,
-0.2041756809,
0.5923228264,
-0.7745135427,
0.5771036148,
-0.0042731608,
0.5216374397,
0.3632768989,
-0.3199031949,
0.4709745944,
0.3214856982,
-0.2987758219,
-0.8637291789,
0.3858067691,
-1.0236452818,
0.0591197759,
1.3524091244,
-0.1028853506,
-0.640642345,
-0.2054505795,
0.0721570402,
0.4260258377,
0.0027633782,
0.5048488379,
0.7362938523,
-0.2004816979,
-0.0854197964,
-0.5043544769,
0.6812825203,
0.2269265056,
-0.3203164041,
0.3357269764,
0.0953673795,
0.2532978654,
0.1470858455,
0.0766942874,
-0.2640850842,
0.2342661619,
-0.1381786466,
-0.0947122797,
0.1419358253,
-0.4084751904,
-0.164044708,
0.0801124722,
0.2396145612,
-0.3318388164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13048v1
|
Stable Knowledge Editing in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T14:36:23 | 2024-02-20T14:36:23 |
Zihao Wei, Liang Pang, Hanxing Ding, Jingcheng Deng, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efficient knowledge editing of large language models is crucial for replacing
obsolete information or incorporating specialized knowledge on a large scale.
However, previous methods implicitly assume that knowledge is localized and
isolated within the model, an assumption that oversimplifies the interconnected
nature of model knowledge. The premise of localization results in an incomplete
knowledge editing, whereas an isolated assumption may impair both other
knowledge and general abilities. It introduces instability to the performance
of the knowledge editing method. To transcend these assumptions, we introduce
StableKE, a method adopts a novel perspective based on knowledge augmentation
rather than knowledge localization. To overcome the expense of human labeling,
StableKE integrates two automated knowledge augmentation strategies: Semantic
Paraphrase Enhancement strategy, which diversifies knowledge descriptions to
facilitate the teaching of new information to the model, and Contextual
Description Enrichment strategy, expanding the surrounding knowledge to prevent
the forgetting of related information. StableKE surpasses other knowledge
editing methods, demonstrating stability both edited knowledge and multi-hop
knowledge, while also preserving unrelated knowledge and general abilities.
Moreover, StableKE can edit knowledge on ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.0902643725,
-1.0558240414,
0.5365557671,
-0.020862367,
-0.0056622722,
0.1681009978,
-0.6102508307,
-0.492844373,
0.2328881919,
0.5610937476,
-0.1125030369,
-0.6150797009,
-0.6044268012,
-0.1018080413,
-0.2552728057,
0.9171646833,
-0.0908188969,
-0.0452521779,
-0.3324142694,
-0.3603259027,
-0.5134477019,
-0.3701190054,
-0.6862123609,
-0.093932502,
0.3616798818,
0.458343029,
1.397900939,
0.8873024583,
0.328963995,
0.3974545598,
-0.5430611968,
0.1685650349,
-0.5487732887,
0.5180255175,
-0.3668814003,
-0.4168452322,
-0.7547308803,
-0.3764961362,
1.0395075083,
0.9016322494,
-0.1106152311,
-0.246162653,
-0.0364074633,
0.5001957417,
-0.7396073341,
0.1402915567,
-0.7150537372,
-0.3543157279,
-0.1838929802,
0.3538203537,
-0.3366176188,
-0.3124556541,
0.2205816656,
-0.7867631912,
-0.0392496213,
-0.431981355,
0.7568100691,
0.1767617613,
-0.3497385681,
0.1087044701,
-0.6749619246,
0.5665616989,
-0.9608191848,
0.4641304016,
0.4582012892,
0.085479103,
-0.2891178429,
-0.6294461489,
-0.4310986102,
-0.1777329296,
0.0139364367,
0.0051642093,
0.1951891333,
0.3170336783,
0.2601493001,
0.2023952603,
-0.0526771471,
0.0607604869,
-0.2996256053,
-0.2062823176,
0.3488818705,
-0.1498267949,
0.5717497468,
-0.1160438359,
-0.0743300691,
-0.0570358299,
-0.6827303171,
0.0100472439,
0.2780948281,
0.1282285452,
0.2728165388,
0.685294807,
-0.5191400647,
0.8355603218,
0.1255645305,
-0.2313378751,
0.1124589965,
-0.13833718,
-0.0283805076,
0.1563002765,
0.639033556,
0.3357418478,
-0.1545255035,
-0.3788075149,
-0.1996599436,
-0.1707016826,
0.0118817091,
-0.480130434,
-0.2260171473,
0.0149140339,
-0.2374092937,
-0.4530886114,
0.0742803141,
-0.679256916,
-0.5012326837,
-0.1443733573,
0.5583887696,
-0.4380461872,
-0.506699264,
0.1826500148,
-0.0961511433,
-0.1509632617,
0.5781851411,
-0.8923841715,
0.1482680589,
0.6993144155,
0.618140161,
0.0372633301,
-0.4700428843,
-0.3864412606,
0.6125090122,
-0.6012340188,
0.5581957102,
-0.7792899013,
-0.1876007169,
-0.1379998475,
0.0832930431,
0.2143889666,
-0.2668606937,
0.4117307961,
-0.8679939508,
0.1455372274,
-0.3877056241,
-0.7390875816,
-0.1903614253,
0.1683861315,
-0.7435595989,
1.0004332066,
0.1541552097,
-0.8928806782,
0.3873361349,
-0.5657669306,
-0.5450766683,
-0.0936746299,
0.3391278088,
-0.2778648138,
0.0699004382,
0.2235026211,
0.3648113906,
0.1689062864,
0.5693413615,
-0.5022671819,
0.0062230015,
-0.0063292962,
-0.1540539116,
0.5485783219,
-0.0180506501,
-0.1821333021,
0.2652677298,
-0.6832568049,
-0.1111806259,
-0.1279790699,
-0.4878658354,
-0.7052147985,
0.0865085572,
-0.313492924,
0.0529323705,
0.398591727,
-0.4517857134,
0.6175788641,
-0.5076673627,
0.4239057004,
0.5972377062,
0.3138425052,
0.8719576001,
-0.0835365653,
0.4264161289,
-0.1028777212,
0.1554899663,
-0.1260297596,
-0.5652407408,
-0.7020844817,
-0.0049359375,
0.6129872203,
0.5269002914,
-0.8460325599,
0.2097568959,
-0.4277550578,
-0.4102780819,
-0.3728850484,
0.3862145841,
0.1182168722,
0.7762055993,
0.3989692926,
0.0626982749,
-0.3402864635,
-0.9238429666,
-0.3548206687,
-0.1016343087,
0.1379705817,
-0.5154255033,
0.0901803747,
-0.4381865859,
0.8524971604,
-0.3450620174,
0.0831109583,
-0.2644365132,
0.0555571392,
0.0484105088,
0.6276949644,
0.3560583591,
-0.6565504074,
-0.4383692443,
0.3062362671,
-0.7523069382,
0.045959767,
-0.2025243938,
-0.3522440195,
0.1126617715,
0.5679289103,
-0.8857491016,
0.1613326967,
0.4321953654,
-0.3229285479,
0.2575987875,
-0.266466409,
0.3750045002,
-1.2656286955,
-0.1478938907,
-0.2960261106,
-0.5027582049,
-0.6814537644,
0.1613399982,
0.4076171517,
-0.1024162471,
-0.1995570362,
0.5002358556,
-0.5761262178,
0.3641325235,
-0.2012396157,
0.481553793,
0.040083088,
0.0594125427,
0.1530712843,
0.3905159533,
0.6364061236,
-0.154804036,
0.1988653094,
0.4059962034,
-0.3960390985,
0.0040042349,
-0.393256247,
0.1517502964,
-0.2576714754,
0.1069215015,
-0.7311699986,
-0.4970624745,
0.048393283,
-0.344424367,
0.4804083407,
-0.3087429404,
-0.4417839348,
0.1580978632,
-0.3161330521,
0.2818800509,
0.4304212928,
-0.2626826465,
0.5633332729,
0.6537619233,
-0.4777778387,
-0.730679512,
-0.5135065317,
0.4167224765,
-0.1597406119,
-0.9173998237,
0.171002984,
0.1774663329,
-0.4781713188,
0.223323822,
-0.1799784154,
-0.3054922521,
0.1166614145,
-0.2109082639,
0.2635427117,
-0.2026447207,
0.3815350831,
0.5882757306,
-0.1852688491,
-0.2754278481,
-0.3012420535,
-0.0072714887,
-0.1369434446,
-0.002162698,
-0.3546171784,
0.3656836748,
0.9364507198,
-0.3817206025,
1.0477433205,
0.3681497276,
-0.6306496859,
0.0186341498,
-0.7490357161,
-0.1170225888,
-0.4394051433,
0.5544369221,
-0.3514913917,
-0.928209424,
0.6846761107,
-0.1626616567,
0.332130909,
0.6990246773,
0.2978419363,
0.1418373138,
1.0424607992,
0.6249269247,
-0.0884578824,
0.4242171347,
0.0326624699,
0.2180812955,
-0.6263518333,
0.0288758297,
-0.2787385285,
-0.1881263554,
-0.2883825004,
-0.2537162304,
0.2370596379,
0.8354395032,
-0.0571256243,
0.3118282855,
-0.3669601679,
0.6682434082,
0.2794580758,
0.3062828779,
0.4326519966,
-0.2993066311,
-0.0931089744,
-0.2108357251,
-0.9772335887,
-0.4484417737,
0.9894697666,
0.3002502322,
0.6928916574,
0.2593216002,
0.5081562996,
0.1662450135,
0.2748313248,
-0.5198456049,
0.4538265467,
-0.0218334403,
-0.5404708385,
-0.6525166631,
-0.3763568103,
-0.5767816305,
0.0443333723,
-0.5470765829,
-0.6140332818,
0.2027034312,
0.4717812538,
-0.2952475846,
0.4766835868,
-0.8673920631,
1.1213937998,
-0.1353974938,
-0.5005089641,
-0.3075150549,
-0.8194901347,
0.3735359013,
-0.2366278023,
0.4724264443,
0.004386662,
-0.1593101025,
0.6535782814,
-0.5917910337,
0.7089393735,
-0.250079453,
-0.0210231952,
0.2260486782,
0.4476467669,
0.89487499,
0.276792258,
-0.3716388941,
-0.0377717428,
0.1081750989,
-0.4542639554,
-0.8964484334,
0.7305969596,
-0.7061038613,
-0.7239951491,
0.0363535397,
-0.643579185,
-0.4508048892,
0.3750363886,
-0.0172418747,
0.3924235702,
0.1818503737,
0.456279099,
0.6824986935,
-0.2115163952,
0.0220227037,
0.135908097,
-0.2534959614,
-0.6349271536,
0.6583006382,
0.3335559666,
0.6679432392,
0.4120957255,
0.4227135777,
-0.1445488185,
-0.5777615309,
-0.3103619814,
0.0377620831,
-1.2201150656,
-0.0588836223,
-0.7785593867,
-0.0383160412,
-0.4411154389,
-0.4618391693,
-0.6468052268,
-0.8514022827,
0.177045837,
-0.2660317123,
0.5848574042,
0.6443929672,
-0.2458658516,
0.2956262231,
-0.9915459156,
0.3925203085,
0.2932330072,
0.2201094925,
-0.1901457906,
-0.3237923682,
-0.5601075888,
0.139584884,
0.1644983292,
-1.0529806614,
-0.0385553055,
0.2298117876,
0.6739424467,
0.4262109399,
0.228192538,
0.8597497344,
-0.2447465509,
0.7027847171,
0.0396820642,
-1.1083474159,
0.6660407186,
-0.7253723741,
0.5106090903,
0.8025246859,
-0.0082725668,
-0.6300883889,
-0.8244361281,
-0.5773791075,
-1.0695691109,
0.5109581947,
-0.0929061472,
0.256948024,
-0.131299898,
0.7243927121,
0.1990417242,
0.2873330712,
-0.7691833973,
0.1627928615,
-0.1707919687,
-0.240773797,
0.2596823573,
-0.3858792484,
-0.0160496794,
-0.5613759756,
0.9450442791,
0.1206702068,
-0.1671698093,
0.0888064131,
-0.380394578,
-0.2158987224,
0.2545644939,
0.57612288,
1.0000917912,
-0.0391099639,
0.2904880941,
0.4849211276,
-0.3635857701,
-0.052370023,
-0.1764904857,
-0.5152983069,
-0.0888878927,
0.4949376881,
0.7179814577,
0.6092277765,
-0.3831274509,
0.2902373075,
0.1575855613,
-0.0850192383,
0.1887332499,
0.122392267,
0.2474079579,
0.2020405531,
-0.0705654323,
0.5400723815,
-0.1855981052,
-0.3010225594,
0.1880670339,
0.0797048658,
-0.131967932,
-0.1880146712,
0.8692345619,
0.0776100382,
-0.109883368,
0.5527621508,
0.1128893644,
-0.46592623,
0.1058069542,
0.3851835728,
0.8558444381,
-0.4435325265,
0.1211608946,
0.4002272487,
0.4127612412,
-0.4525582194,
-0.1288269758,
-0.0515836775,
-0.8066201806,
-0.7407705188,
-0.3937926888,
-0.4276337624,
0.0446151868,
-0.4023262262,
0.389508456,
-0.5595481396,
-0.137726143,
-0.2234779745,
-0.5000684261,
-0.0731620118,
-0.0204409286,
-0.2684538662,
0.7439187169,
-0.6921624541,
1.0235519409,
0.977533102,
-0.2284690291,
-0.7414164543,
0.1085647941,
-0.1766945124,
-0.2925122082,
0.329033345,
-0.1439883411,
-0.0707106441,
-0.0113290995,
-0.3944646418,
-1.0759184361,
0.7601163387,
0.6881219745,
-0.5359866619,
-0.0033580454,
-0.3153239191,
0.4277400076,
0.0835364908,
-0.1718651205,
0.3274886608,
0.6887482405,
0.0720039457,
-0.8402485847,
-0.0435859226,
-0.1935383677,
-0.0686747357,
0.3424297869,
-0.5061956048,
0.6385731101,
0.0268186498,
0.0343471356,
-0.0794956759,
0.6153640747,
-0.1899649352,
-0.3377515078,
0.5165461898,
0.7095184326,
0.7497909665,
0.0054447236,
0.7506949902,
-0.5304711461,
0.4342317283,
1.1734873056,
-0.0806207806,
0.9002706409,
0.2255762666,
0.1454666853,
0.3195121288,
0.6790736318,
0.2489623427,
0.469224453,
-0.4089853466,
-0.5090331435,
-0.5899293423,
0.4212681055,
-0.2420529127,
0.3310723901,
0.1957223117,
-0.0581487156,
-0.2666567564,
0.1514377147,
0.4958563745,
0.1558973044,
-0.3521623015,
0.8012800217,
-0.2719994485,
-0.7988034487,
0.545538187,
0.3314068019,
0.1640083939,
-0.7717030048,
-0.0862147659,
0.1174973175,
0.2597553432,
-0.238997072,
-0.7711917162,
0.5959079266,
-0.2335274965,
-0.2748483419,
-0.2792790234,
1.080344677,
-0.651876986,
-0.5637885928,
0.2356657088,
0.3185996413,
-0.172353372,
-0.0466057174,
-0.5501214862,
0.0669692978,
-0.0263658855,
-0.4129398763,
0.1626738161,
0.6309585571,
-0.3332698941,
0.5114850402,
0.5348242521,
0.2689667046,
0.2066818774,
-0.1258736253,
0.9060258269,
-0.3997890055,
-0.5707678199,
-0.8452060223,
0.9519468546,
-0.2741482556,
-0.1029952615,
0.8456471562,
0.4103983343,
0.6614155173,
-0.087508589,
0.9998109341,
-0.0987540558,
0.2766377628,
-0.590580821,
0.9806593657,
-0.3606840968,
0.2578064799,
-0.5169923306,
-1.1465184689,
-0.6396138072,
0.7395245433,
-0.645211041,
-0.1928835064,
0.5484175086,
0.5686954856,
-0.0099937795,
-0.1324769557,
0.4075721502,
0.602242291,
0.0045954948,
0.0483355448,
0.7795788646,
-0.2435174733,
0.3831272125,
-0.3393309712,
-0.3603690267,
0.1950720102,
-0.750882268,
-0.7237061858,
-0.4417326152,
-0.4873892963,
-0.298820436,
0.2353130728,
0.763127327,
0.6804932356,
-0.691203475,
0.0335153714,
-0.1516364664,
0.3731160462,
-0.1368550956,
-0.214863956,
0.431634903,
-0.5636997819,
-0.6421884894,
0.5715258121,
0.4505179226,
-0.1610728651,
-0.0873810053,
-0.0179704893,
-0.2984308898,
-0.2448035777,
0.5719183683,
0.1699232459,
-0.474306494,
-0.4616855085,
-0.1384635568,
0.2224586606,
0.0596691631,
0.4284941852,
-0.5188387036,
1.0035389662,
0.6222442389,
0.8757165074,
0.3453396261,
0.1207247153,
0.8347655535,
-0.5130387545,
0.3618877232,
0.0652195662,
0.4062809646,
0.3533053696,
-0.4509892464,
0.1235014275,
0.3241938651,
-0.6414441466,
-0.6196194291,
0.1670864522,
-0.827650547,
-0.2297145128,
1.1364374161,
-0.3152882159,
-0.1757339984,
-0.1338095069,
-0.3343455195,
0.3634558916,
-0.2044808269,
0.7204467058,
1.0109218359,
0.156175822,
-0.2896080613,
-0.8022404909,
0.4525875151,
0.2578380704,
-0.743866086,
0.1699404567,
0.6758130789,
0.3906559348,
-0.0066244816,
0.3767460883,
-0.25830549,
0.2265457809,
-0.0088586304,
0.1602346748,
-0.0403794348,
-0.1541332901,
-0.0520199686,
0.2817568481,
0.3637438118,
0.106567964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13043v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13043v3
|
Effective and Efficient Conversation Retrieval for Dialogue State Tracking with Implicit Text Summaries
| 2024-02-20T14:31:17 | 2024-04-02T20:06:52 |
Seanie Lee, Jianpeng Cheng, Joris Driesen, Alexandru Coca, Anders Johannsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot dialogue state tracking (DST) with Large Language Models (LLM)
relies on an effective and efficient conversation retriever to find similar
in-context examples for prompt learning. Previous works use raw dialogue
context as search keys and queries, and a retriever is fine-tuned with
annotated dialogues to achieve superior performance. However, the approach is
less suited for scaling to new domains or new annotation languages, where
fine-tuning data is unavailable. To address this problem, we handle the task of
conversation retrieval based on text summaries of the conversations. A
LLM-based conversation summarizer is adopted for query and key generation,
which enables effective maximum inner product search. To avoid the extra
inference cost brought by LLM-based conversation summarization, we further
distill a light-weight conversation encoder which produces query embeddings
without decoding summaries for test conversations. We validate our retrieval
approach on MultiWOZ datasets with GPT-Neo-2.7B and LLaMA-7B/30B. The
experimental results show a significant improvement over relevant baselines in
real few-shot DST settings.
|
[
-0.2443753332,
-0.8485226631,
0.6753792167,
-0.0870196447,
-0.631017983,
0.2082871497,
-0.132649228,
-0.3216429353,
0.2858571112,
0.5189470649,
-0.6988269687,
-0.7049731016,
-0.4627244174,
0.1395623833,
-0.3061254323,
1.1275172234,
0.2763184905,
-0.1279420853,
-0.0286625605,
-0.2675566375,
-0.0854332596,
-0.549085319,
-0.580750525,
-0.3038213849,
0.3474547863,
0.2686940432,
0.3022683263,
0.1596709043,
0.3937055171,
0.2274477482,
-0.603141129,
0.4371374547,
-0.8906542063,
0.4911355674,
0.3408922851,
-0.3594208956,
-0.2915385962,
-0.3070707321,
0.5155227184,
0.4513991177,
-0.198254779,
-0.0831620395,
0.0525855534,
0.4661821723,
-0.6167035699,
0.4636479616,
-0.8825370073,
0.0349217281,
-0.0044529773,
-0.4192601442,
-0.3461713493,
-0.5204859972,
0.4077734053,
-0.3549720347,
0.148877874,
-0.0427424312,
0.4155150652,
0.178185463,
-0.7351507545,
-0.3875265419,
-0.611107409,
0.6598157287,
-0.8444384336,
0.2193584293,
0.3713738918,
0.2661714852,
-0.308727473,
-0.6653463244,
-0.4607744515,
-0.1599777341,
-0.2190257758,
0.3016107976,
-0.2220962644,
0.4143791199,
0.3527458608,
0.4144048095,
-0.3609914482,
-0.1398322433,
-0.2012536973,
-0.2735311985,
0.4640256166,
0.5715382099,
-0.0178236719,
-0.2664313316,
-0.1432387233,
0.0705342591,
-0.8141806722,
-0.06218509,
0.2001523226,
0.4909211397,
-0.0247910861,
0.6156046987,
-0.6770424247,
0.6155747175,
-0.0943880603,
-0.4247306287,
-0.0395264067,
-0.8318231106,
0.0543749444,
0.050361231,
0.7458407879,
0.4854724109,
-0.0809195489,
-0.0996675193,
-0.1569660157,
-0.2412782311,
-0.0762490779,
-1.1399629116,
-0.0798312873,
-0.0836619958,
-0.2026211023,
0.0667572767,
-0.1426239163,
-0.5857721567,
-0.2062271386,
-0.0603656135,
0.1512198001,
-0.2275916487,
-0.028239103,
-0.1581498533,
-0.1864818782,
0.4419476092,
0.514710784,
-0.9387369752,
0.3781730831,
0.7036898136,
0.9790363908,
-0.0900105014,
0.4085876048,
-0.454459995,
0.0002547142,
-0.4038638473,
0.7085589767,
-0.4579281211,
-0.6531311274,
0.0535929166,
-0.1102136523,
-0.0187283568,
-0.3190998137,
0.4044044614,
-0.5803739429,
0.2160099,
-0.3172774017,
-0.7308517098,
-0.15049918,
0.5307980776,
-0.3006973565,
0.8636656404,
-0.250493139,
-0.5765562057,
0.1110594347,
-0.4529875815,
-0.4040445983,
0.0468778759,
-0.4469330013,
-0.2987784147,
0.1578735411,
0.3727105558,
0.3412481546,
-0.1913318038,
-0.0447936803,
-0.1077058017,
-0.7614223361,
-0.035563495,
-0.6202032566,
0.4629350603,
-0.0300999489,
-0.1224653125,
-0.1771887392,
-0.4751591384,
-0.0416178703,
0.133999154,
-0.2453956157,
-0.3697682321,
0.1390832514,
-0.2097886205,
0.0387493297,
0.1355389655,
-0.7210955024,
0.3142569363,
-0.4852464199,
0.2152582258,
0.4094549716,
0.4672229588,
0.3209906518,
-0.0245276615,
0.4039475024,
-0.0386432111,
-0.0204542521,
-0.6737533808,
-0.5107492208,
-0.6885405183,
-0.2801080942,
-0.1791640967,
0.4547445774,
-0.7040151358,
0.1985583901,
-0.3494375646,
-0.3781153858,
-0.4746311903,
0.0991670415,
0.5625325441,
0.6109179854,
0.2951806188,
-0.1737566888,
-0.2250551879,
-0.8402685523,
-0.1772394925,
-0.2162967324,
-0.1015139893,
0.6715044975,
0.4541486204,
0.0205478929,
1.0458676815,
-0.958145082,
-0.3538809419,
-0.5757898092,
0.2269579917,
0.2328089476,
0.1389292181,
0.3514167666,
-0.7145738602,
-0.5663767457,
-0.2498898208,
-0.570479691,
0.0771600008,
0.0263667926,
-0.0114018749,
0.1929852515,
0.4081285,
-0.7581179142,
0.5183842182,
0.1963993907,
-0.0849457234,
0.1234057322,
0.0573963486,
0.3077340126,
-1.2397888899,
-0.1002504602,
-0.1229263246,
-0.4398204982,
-0.6264460683,
-0.377967149,
0.0340924822,
-0.0293814149,
-0.4756295383,
0.4738710225,
-0.3423336148,
-0.1382587999,
-0.3090206981,
0.5228479505,
-0.0084679471,
0.7134562135,
0.0373857021,
1.0561034679,
0.1615501791,
-0.6641267538,
0.2011502385,
0.6976585984,
-0.32337749,
0.6164491177,
-0.698428452,
0.6346725225,
-0.2810676694,
0.6974611282,
-1.0604344606,
0.0799914524,
0.1569106579,
-0.2944709659,
0.1901409179,
-0.7160578966,
-0.5511981845,
0.042818699,
-0.4579059184,
0.0804151893,
0.4540518224,
-0.5594723225,
0.3857316673,
0.333863467,
-0.3694056571,
-0.5121334791,
-0.419937253,
0.1505923271,
-0.1399035454,
-0.3260129392,
0.2682287693,
-0.123872079,
-0.02007786,
-0.3695907295,
-0.6408945322,
-0.0755330175,
0.0816574246,
-0.0657948628,
0.2370644361,
-0.1774212271,
-0.0116987135,
0.0908474326,
-0.188783884,
-0.0816332623,
-0.0399579927,
0.5347784758,
-0.0702867731,
-0.3326290846,
-0.3939588964,
0.4281131625,
0.3515002728,
-0.0446836166,
0.5985668898,
0.4529859126,
-0.2140314877,
-0.0079202289,
-0.538667202,
-0.5211555958,
-0.4298899472,
0.473289758,
-0.4398154616,
-1.1240696907,
0.478692174,
-0.1043639928,
0.2771047652,
0.1726664752,
0.2499861419,
-0.2913970053,
1.2926357985,
0.5055659413,
-0.181815505,
0.6458300352,
-0.229290694,
0.2190958411,
-1.1031130552,
-0.3002979159,
-0.5055935979,
-0.0536017939,
-0.5466274619,
-0.0763959512,
0.6674025059,
-0.0816119835,
0.0701716244,
0.3916131556,
-0.0398592278,
0.6756572723,
0.4361208677,
0.1948820949,
0.7473186851,
-0.1285172999,
0.1387069523,
-0.2132962644,
-0.5378454328,
-0.4145640135,
1.00652349,
-0.1109124348,
0.9653867483,
0.3192657828,
0.7400661707,
-0.025268916,
-0.0107642151,
-0.8627589345,
0.6218361259,
-0.117354393,
-0.4494576156,
-0.1168188602,
-0.7419855595,
-0.8139154315,
0.6587823629,
-0.1647334695,
-1.0162837505,
-0.2290928215,
0.0862296373,
-0.3976907432,
0.0246653464,
-0.5168001652,
0.7326881886,
-0.0655837357,
-0.1023186743,
-0.4374240637,
-0.6457556486,
0.4338572323,
0.1111853644,
-0.4473067522,
-0.411043942,
0.0525695384,
0.5600584745,
-0.2789193094,
0.8641762137,
-0.080334805,
-0.0839445144,
0.2642687261,
-0.0044223643,
0.660450995,
0.1122667491,
0.1995423734,
-0.0685685277,
0.0108360844,
-0.1640814692,
-0.8807803392,
0.558092773,
-0.3766259849,
-0.6103088856,
-0.293040663,
-0.323369801,
-0.3302021027,
0.0633772016,
0.2749899924,
0.7228083014,
-0.3973855972,
0.4967001975,
0.8259652257,
-0.1339591295,
0.5024240017,
0.7957821488,
0.0231668316,
-0.2256760597,
0.5600303411,
-0.0249703713,
0.3828264177,
0.5327399373,
0.0608349554,
-0.52337116,
-0.4925629497,
-0.3930385113,
0.041521173,
-0.6743904352,
-0.5133020282,
-0.9271795154,
-0.1503687352,
-0.3935708702,
0.2109310627,
-0.4251850545,
-0.4051636457,
-0.2395495176,
-0.1851416677,
0.5494934916,
0.611213088,
0.5359216928,
0.518682301,
-0.7547559142,
0.4735602736,
0.321165055,
0.2285574973,
-0.3001232743,
-0.5683543682,
-0.2172165215,
0.1314114332,
-0.4255204499,
-0.8277831674,
0.2617388368,
0.4339941442,
0.5560528636,
0.2138021737,
0.3787721992,
0.8581690192,
-0.2752887309,
0.8426733017,
0.0166666508,
-0.7865456939,
0.8058913946,
-0.2280406505,
0.5711188316,
0.6895897985,
0.2088853866,
-0.658822,
-0.4709647596,
-0.4264136255,
-1.0244724751,
0.9973179698,
0.3720389903,
0.4489068687,
-0.0737863556,
0.2153259516,
-0.0508188047,
0.3454878032,
-0.2181969136,
-0.3072560132,
0.1210797802,
-0.3039499819,
-0.1019318774,
-0.2787162662,
-0.13680242,
0.0289170258,
0.5981041789,
-0.4579155743,
0.2389318645,
0.2464181632,
-0.3662618995,
0.2579582632,
0.4605261683,
0.4149644375,
0.3557052314,
-0.3992145061,
-0.0013535708,
0.3809083104,
-0.3702880144,
-0.0897022784,
0.2665704489,
-0.3777607977,
0.1397737563,
0.1487046331,
0.8402070403,
0.5009917021,
-0.691829145,
0.659568131,
-0.3350581527,
0.1274898499,
-0.2172185034,
0.144296661,
-0.0895989761,
0.406291455,
0.476575315,
-0.3417854309,
0.498454839,
-0.4687720239,
0.1498085707,
0.591465652,
-0.3334343731,
-0.2024139762,
0.4115975201,
0.3598731756,
-0.0282359216,
0.9055452347,
-0.129377082,
-0.5027880669,
0.3910212219,
0.6084486246,
0.9509381056,
0.2056112885,
0.1343816668,
0.3372244537,
0.1498311013,
-0.1325217038,
0.0941437483,
-0.6251422763,
-0.6155919433,
-0.4638677835,
-0.2104345709,
-0.8318798542,
-0.0737822801,
-0.5844544172,
-0.0168884248,
-0.1333526522,
-0.1894737929,
-0.3816540539,
0.2372996062,
-0.4544668496,
-0.2476166189,
0.2427306026,
0.679541707,
-0.5571547747,
0.5937567353,
0.225208059,
-0.391649574,
-0.2967148125,
0.0632450357,
0.3406226039,
-0.6206041574,
0.2525330186,
0.2357238382,
-0.4592285454,
0.1148901433,
-0.5446000695,
-0.7497205734,
1.2361419201,
0.4598892629,
-0.580211997,
0.0366737805,
-0.0587159656,
0.5991854668,
-0.1966822892,
0.7070482969,
0.6480534077,
-0.0736920834,
0.3861173987,
-0.8288931847,
-0.157976523,
-0.0401830077,
-0.0318312943,
0.3239537477,
-0.8022079468,
0.2986601889,
-0.0971949324,
-0.3558302224,
0.1538283676,
0.6574072242,
0.299298346,
0.3533902764,
0.2444173992,
0.2895280123,
0.5623686314,
-0.3256235123,
0.9775194526,
-0.1695019007,
0.3106380701,
1.3382685184,
-0.1548272222,
0.794120729,
0.3218590617,
0.0283266567,
0.162531659,
0.4755752981,
0.3922273219,
0.6536051631,
0.0024886359,
-0.462913245,
-0.1528701782,
-0.234767139,
-0.1473722756,
0.5020044446,
0.4351648688,
-0.1425158978,
-0.3030179739,
-0.3034400344,
0.2353418618,
-0.1712379605,
0.0010947834,
1.4352744818,
0.260753274,
-0.5629354715,
0.2587365508,
-0.3157407045,
0.7808561921,
-0.8155484796,
-0.2230191231,
-0.8355374932,
0.0693950877,
-0.0438990481,
-0.5133743286,
0.1185839251,
0.2135509849,
0.2391524017,
-0.2320465744,
0.5433351994,
-0.7563017011,
-0.1724881828,
0.1064667404,
0.5836690068,
0.2861300111,
-0.1863411814,
-0.4475987554,
0.0138239069,
-0.0062979609,
-0.4472969174,
0.2251042873,
0.344489187,
0.1143281087,
0.6121801138,
0.5161794424,
-0.1615003049,
-0.0471665226,
0.2771012485,
0.964792192,
-0.8058446646,
-0.4742151797,
-0.7436663508,
0.2707887292,
-0.1747687608,
-0.3960480094,
0.6560636163,
0.7667158246,
0.6105619073,
0.3647957146,
0.6402515173,
0.1668458879,
0.4791389406,
-0.6820729971,
0.395904243,
-0.342533797,
0.4987771809,
-0.3786766231,
-1.066922307,
-0.0436168872,
0.6676992774,
0.0258624274,
-0.1325593442,
0.4377406836,
0.885625422,
-0.0293919388,
0.2843259871,
0.2143085301,
0.1872616857,
0.573197484,
0.500531435,
0.9657872915,
-0.4997732937,
0.8541334271,
-0.0812221244,
0.0346939936,
-0.2539528012,
-0.6591879725,
-0.8128919601,
-0.4088027775,
-0.338344574,
-0.1222225353,
0.1549278051,
1.0960576534,
0.7284660339,
-0.5236107111,
-0.0856591165,
0.1251185685,
0.0990159288,
-0.0238318797,
-0.1724473238,
0.2072725594,
-0.5034719706,
-0.9532745481,
0.8262034059,
0.3128093481,
0.2112214118,
-0.0376812629,
-0.0628536791,
0.0026896151,
-0.0279307831,
0.7571231127,
0.2019330412,
-0.5944308639,
-0.1882566363,
0.0778589919,
-0.2299505621,
0.1078686491,
0.9092127681,
-0.7152203918,
0.4938072562,
0.4590446353,
0.6804380417,
1.1719197035,
0.125905484,
0.6068137288,
-1.066249609,
0.1338963956,
0.3818440735,
0.2232756615,
0.4299628735,
-0.2418847084,
0.5285329819,
0.1045202017,
-0.3496961594,
-0.5511266589,
0.1779359579,
-0.9508194327,
0.0641811267,
1.082636714,
-0.2052801698,
0.1964022517,
-0.1767904609,
-0.3506036997,
0.2001351565,
-0.7848860025,
0.6769667864,
0.3986083269,
-0.4012441635,
-0.3609949052,
-0.446847707,
0.5155493021,
0.2426399142,
-0.7676543593,
0.1534733623,
0.6326663494,
-0.0003862016,
-0.1362631619,
1.0486972332,
-0.0626381189,
-0.163931042,
-0.0800183341,
-0.4526267052,
0.101849176,
-0.0969922021,
-0.2763440311,
-0.1052173004,
-0.1922733337,
-0.2792104185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13040v1
|
Text-Guided Molecule Generation with Diffusion Language Model
| 2024-02-20T14:29:02 | 2024-02-20T14:29:02 |
Haisong Gong, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, q-bio.BM
|
Text-guided molecule generation is a task where molecules are generated to
match specific textual descriptions. Recently, most existing SMILES-based
molecule generation methods rely on an autoregressive architecture. In this
work, we propose the Text-Guided Molecule Generation with Diffusion Language
Model (TGM-DLM), a novel approach that leverages diffusion models to address
the limitations of autoregressive methods. TGM-DLM updates token embeddings
within the SMILES string collectively and iteratively, using a two-phase
diffusion generation process. The first phase optimizes embeddings from random
noise, guided by the text description, while the second phase corrects invalid
SMILES strings to form valid molecular representations. We demonstrate that
TGM-DLM outperforms MolT5-Base, an autoregressive model, without the need for
additional data resources. Our findings underscore the remarkable effectiveness
of TGM-DLM in generating coherent and precise molecules with specific
properties, opening new avenues in drug discovery and related scientific
domains. Code will be released at: https://github.com/Deno-V/tgm-dlm.
|
[
-0.0202661473,
-0.9124060273,
0.7215727568,
0.0395586789,
-0.438226819,
0.2084720284,
-0.1182911322,
-0.10335242,
0.0060014296,
0.4912033677,
-0.5174907446,
-0.9836903811,
-0.7658079863,
0.0544657558,
-0.4762273431,
0.9309064746,
-0.0711222664,
0.1384068578,
-0.2120858729,
0.126581192,
0.042699229,
-0.0203608721,
-0.6218588352,
-0.4366977215,
0.519519031,
0.0790969208,
0.317920208,
0.7852034569,
0.2997527719,
0.1507588476,
-0.310058713,
0.0901962817,
-0.2974356413,
0.2807464898,
-0.0003408588,
-0.2502010465,
-0.6860500574,
-0.1825614423,
0.5699201226,
0.5640446544,
-0.5363273025,
-0.1067098901,
-0.0844413042,
0.7271242142,
-0.276288718,
0.0975210667,
-0.4577914476,
0.2533079088,
-0.275840044,
-0.0747913569,
-0.306019038,
-0.5489468575,
0.4163222909,
-0.3831920922,
0.4268845618,
-0.1252965331,
0.5947445631,
0.1540627927,
-0.820939064,
-0.6419658661,
-0.5924651623,
0.6867394447,
-0.9735919833,
0.1452788562,
-0.0299562104,
0.1861056387,
-0.4567554295,
-0.6927030087,
-0.3408811986,
-0.4015298188,
0.3252678216,
0.1277109832,
-0.0019597595,
0.1759469211,
-0.1835685819,
0.2794937491,
-0.7679561377,
-0.2821418047,
-0.1914348751,
-0.0412071571,
0.4718096852,
0.0333551057,
0.2158303708,
-0.2402786762,
-0.5221957564,
-0.0124761704,
-0.5541759729,
-0.5816431642,
0.0763374045,
0.3544673026,
0.104796432,
0.6954092383,
0.2464678586,
0.7604561448,
0.3014140129,
-0.2846546769,
0.2340202332,
-0.4089443982,
-0.2208292782,
0.2417034805,
0.8961197138,
0.1945292205,
0.1519056857,
0.0135542043,
-0.2722128928,
-0.2918441892,
0.1769878715,
-1.1282963753,
-0.3445647061,
0.3668686748,
-0.5331055522,
-0.6522391438,
-0.2268202156,
-1.0769153833,
-0.2944822609,
0.307330966,
0.7060723305,
-0.6264073849,
-0.4151553214,
0.0014735432,
-0.4448492229,
-0.3341610432,
0.2638837993,
-0.7623742223,
0.0300061963,
0.2501524091,
1.0855518579,
-0.4673939943,
0.1329406351,
-0.3880014718,
0.6046664119,
-0.2453805059,
0.7120369077,
-0.5177437067,
-0.8597074151,
-0.0358209759,
-0.4730226994,
0.0377352722,
-0.6487932205,
-0.2310566604,
-0.3479160964,
0.4761237204,
-0.0267362632,
-0.9206098318,
-0.1092973277,
-0.0579780005,
-0.4099275768,
0.7377217412,
0.3460595906,
-0.3537046611,
0.463754952,
-0.7821164131,
-0.5830076933,
-0.0073120836,
-0.165388301,
-0.6774265766,
0.1584524214,
-0.0327001959,
0.3181113303,
-0.0575412624,
0.5432025194,
-0.1830460131,
0.1834293902,
0.116005443,
-0.2996316552,
0.6916630864,
0.3217480779,
-0.4804170132,
-0.0950934142,
-0.9777749181,
-0.2030192763,
0.1175009459,
-0.6372569799,
0.0072056418,
0.0032104319,
-0.095270656,
0.1745134741,
0.4744226038,
-0.4911883771,
0.3160634935,
-0.3013781011,
0.4332455397,
0.6956654787,
0.4737868905,
0.7002047896,
0.0075012473,
0.5700141191,
0.5624523163,
-0.1088839173,
-0.3591107428,
-0.7208249569,
-0.5541389585,
-0.1626479626,
0.2715642154,
0.3607307971,
-0.4533145428,
0.366795212,
0.166136831,
-0.3224610388,
-0.0581894517,
0.23954238,
0.2676088512,
0.7623450756,
0.5038583279,
-0.3147795796,
-0.2450737506,
-0.5413591862,
-0.1084526405,
-0.3343490362,
0.0984585956,
0.4467170238,
0.3847320974,
-0.6063841581,
0.8789122701,
-0.7740659714,
-0.2636529505,
-0.0560883582,
0.4463103414,
-0.3111945391,
0.4995598495,
0.4925267398,
-0.6132984757,
-0.4007759392,
-0.1820662469,
-0.5330542922,
-0.3020351231,
-0.0422490425,
-0.3358725905,
0.4484194517,
0.3061972857,
-0.5542400479,
0.2047810555,
0.4379718304,
-0.4560769498,
0.1136592031,
-0.3403000236,
-0.0442154333,
-1.4894649982,
0.0121049881,
0.3368241191,
-0.5140345693,
-0.6798498631,
-0.3026838899,
-0.0905943513,
-0.1709929705,
-0.4183031917,
0.6625438333,
-0.4602812529,
0.2001860142,
-0.4754438698,
0.2513572872,
0.0907337591,
0.3254256248,
0.0225828309,
0.5142518282,
0.4884886742,
-0.7767843604,
0.1104155928,
0.1675464362,
0.1282557845,
0.3608048856,
-0.5215802789,
-0.1458919197,
-0.1373005062,
0.3622208834,
-1.0130519867,
-0.266546905,
0.3512358069,
-0.3528150916,
0.5204096437,
-0.0500189103,
-0.4105747938,
-0.2781315446,
0.0460411459,
0.3308068216,
0.8741124272,
-0.4280894697,
0.7391853929,
0.4107906222,
-0.0563855283,
-0.0965182036,
-0.990019381,
0.0695511699,
-0.3113708198,
-0.7002349496,
0.4306410849,
-0.2092441022,
-0.0050068502,
-0.1252979189,
-0.1300837845,
-0.1368952096,
-0.1003571972,
0.0240580793,
-0.0146946702,
-0.1763571948,
0.1901935041,
0.3806397319,
0.0322475955,
0.0784407333,
-0.8814569712,
0.3386225402,
0.2232647091,
-0.0302555412,
-0.1759669036,
0.4080937803,
0.3207045496,
0.0097209197,
0.5794838071,
0.682816267,
-0.047616493,
-0.4500505626,
0.0291263517,
-0.1397381276,
-0.5201539993,
0.1947136074,
-0.0062519391,
-0.7561422586,
0.3255544901,
-0.2918582857,
-0.0593871102,
0.3904712796,
0.7261333466,
-0.0174509026,
1.1266094446,
0.6308960319,
0.5821287036,
0.6592395306,
-0.0350131467,
0.1449891329,
-0.4617039859,
-0.4671432078,
-0.1244911924,
0.0045900433,
-0.4963217378,
-0.6156876683,
0.4270422161,
0.041962143,
-0.100501053,
0.2634276748,
-0.6132412553,
-0.0723812953,
0.6264881492,
0.1485332251,
0.2198695689,
0.2132921666,
-0.4562009871,
0.1869226545,
-0.7226681113,
-0.6100772619,
1.0145486593,
0.1577252895,
0.7401894331,
0.283809036,
1.0919593573,
0.3644139469,
0.0114562213,
-0.4760901928,
0.7881949544,
-0.3659735322,
-0.3384036422,
0.0560787059,
-0.6596580148,
-0.8992254138,
-0.0986173302,
0.037637651,
-0.4631706774,
0.1595606804,
0.5201761127,
-0.1430829763,
0.2678109407,
-0.7522959113,
0.6735493541,
0.0030254093,
-0.0093196677,
-0.0971224308,
-0.5938840508,
0.24526003,
-0.1190862432,
-0.0799734294,
-0.1324834228,
-0.3075200617,
0.6262916923,
-0.5830296874,
0.5950679183,
-0.4328148961,
-0.7504311204,
0.4355530739,
0.213935554,
0.4867491722,
-0.0140544688,
0.0328854471,
0.0390108004,
-0.41735062,
-0.4431163073,
-0.3326322138,
0.7730491161,
-0.1472595036,
-0.5717316866,
-0.2659696937,
-0.3149739802,
-0.1046416759,
0.5260091424,
0.4956596792,
0.4135293365,
-0.2351876199,
-0.4346748292,
0.9464719296,
-0.2799146175,
0.621460259,
0.4785645306,
-0.4957353473,
-0.5863623023,
1.2640503645,
0.047700949,
0.6179718971,
0.3955052197,
0.2173936069,
-0.2575056851,
-0.7497285008,
-0.5415083766,
0.144756794,
-0.5196399689,
-0.0226080902,
-0.7898148894,
0.0224178117,
-0.4534062743,
-0.0500308126,
-0.4297048748,
-0.6799497604,
-0.6990852952,
0.0611499436,
0.4333843291,
0.85722965,
-0.2457705885,
0.2140414268,
-0.8791226745,
0.5113799572,
0.3139617145,
0.1908317059,
-0.0682408884,
-0.2122625858,
-0.376871556,
0.371208787,
-0.4667904377,
-0.9912874699,
0.4252739251,
0.2996271253,
0.3265254796,
0.3024038076,
-0.3148515522,
0.3606585264,
-0.6936599612,
1.0655115843,
0.2036439031,
-0.7876389027,
0.9973194003,
-0.6274366975,
0.5444347262,
0.0342569277,
-0.0779031292,
-0.0844104141,
-1.0292812586,
-0.7523533702,
-0.9160578847,
0.3258152902,
0.4947135448,
-0.0550822988,
-0.3553139269,
0.3964902461,
0.1100548357,
0.5162435174,
-0.4325628579,
-0.4383671284,
-0.4199029505,
-0.601823926,
0.2363486439,
-0.1770495325,
-0.1443369389,
0.3232405484,
0.7473074794,
-0.0351841412,
0.6010230184,
0.3314391673,
-0.1325312257,
-0.284953177,
0.077847831,
0.8670145273,
0.3260872364,
-0.3642818332,
0.0524467193,
-0.3479735553,
-0.6676622629,
0.2118503302,
0.2376277745,
-0.4478563368,
0.346704334,
-0.1312724352,
0.5560594797,
-0.371861428,
-0.572268486,
0.3659437597,
0.005640158,
-0.3463678658,
0.0936943963,
0.5220307112,
0.196086973,
0.2975887656,
0.626013577,
0.3322834373,
0.2891353667,
-0.2799455523,
0.3220048547,
0.4006878138,
-0.2930987775,
-0.2050774992,
0.9365502596,
0.2884564102,
-0.2733471394,
0.1538645923,
-0.2272796333,
-0.2056939751,
0.6752266288,
0.6411374211,
1.1146663427,
-0.3256579041,
0.4979660511,
0.32051754,
-0.1527040005,
-0.1982555091,
0.245072946,
-0.2340314984,
-0.3114357889,
0.1474841982,
-0.6233505607,
-0.1284451783,
-0.40941751,
-0.4251868427,
0.0893758461,
-0.4440352619,
-0.3544614911,
0.0164039489,
-0.0888544917,
-0.0328418091,
0.5069734454,
0.3662371933,
0.7436863184,
-0.3979691565,
0.8238024116,
0.4771928489,
-0.1639717817,
-0.2419647723,
0.4667627215,
0.2069802135,
-0.4798505306,
0.4297787547,
-0.0480807349,
-0.3122341037,
0.2012506127,
-0.5952644944,
-0.9274475574,
1.3351467848,
0.2205859125,
-0.5829391479,
-0.0610076487,
0.0225135777,
0.6972512603,
-0.6502044201,
-0.2078365684,
0.2763208747,
0.4112995267,
0.403057456,
-0.4511469305,
0.1117370501,
0.0003322344,
0.4667621553,
0.2239769101,
-0.7383331656,
0.6936423182,
-0.4333372414,
-0.3079529107,
0.2822596729,
0.828029871,
0.5259217024,
0.2478138804,
0.2108884752,
0.4643256366,
0.946980834,
-0.0050417436,
0.7658913732,
-0.3348397017,
0.4194940329,
0.9084298015,
-0.2828189135,
0.4797449112,
0.4816877246,
0.0022771659,
0.6942158341,
0.5751613975,
-0.2985731661,
0.803247869,
0.2562066615,
-0.549010396,
0.0602242686,
0.0266828872,
-0.2404366732,
-0.1356225461,
0.4552226961,
-0.6519778967,
-0.2977949679,
0.4075244665,
0.0459332503,
-0.2271704525,
-0.2141741216,
0.7828966379,
0.195265457,
-0.5982907414,
0.3007008433,
0.0709079877,
0.5676352382,
-0.5168277025,
-0.1283606142,
-0.1943022907,
0.1043757796,
0.0047672954,
-0.9284717441,
0.1455162168,
0.0909375995,
-0.2745456398,
-0.4203312099,
0.6799818873,
-0.9464724064,
-0.4757140875,
0.2058696896,
0.3149561584,
0.062023744,
0.4188046753,
-0.80641222,
-0.4395850301,
0.3736025691,
-0.4999128878,
0.250837177,
0.5820418596,
0.3627584577,
0.7198755741,
0.2024476081,
-0.0513610281,
0.2501360774,
0.0817612186,
0.5532351732,
-0.8277751207,
-0.2125908881,
-0.9147546887,
0.4771318436,
0.1875137836,
-0.2547551095,
0.7542920709,
0.6331499815,
0.30466941,
-0.0333618075,
0.8101136088,
-0.0846649408,
0.3054768741,
-0.6911405921,
0.6810786724,
-0.795234859,
0.3142417371,
-0.202937156,
-0.7579799294,
-0.3316911459,
0.5460471511,
0.3029779196,
0.3809157908,
0.6219264269,
0.8446210027,
0.1070688516,
-0.0745692849,
0.0054731937,
0.526350379,
0.6551285982,
0.5545165539,
0.2303119302,
-0.550146699,
0.671321094,
-0.0323941223,
0.0888352171,
-0.2698317468,
-0.847299397,
-1.0031034946,
-0.3474476635,
-0.6648474336,
-0.8257055879,
0.0630343109,
0.6729869843,
0.6378096342,
-0.6018887758,
-0.1162744537,
-0.8654831648,
0.0078579513,
0.25732705,
-0.2447681874,
0.2097733915,
-0.2311986089,
-0.8497338295,
0.3983602226,
0.537969768,
0.8555521369,
-0.5910722613,
-0.1290580779,
-0.1537888348,
0.2189835012,
0.351545006,
0.1202462539,
-0.5491764545,
0.2670499682,
-0.0242658742,
-0.5793648362,
0.3243663013,
0.618658483,
-0.6763131618,
0.5517013669,
0.5084610581,
-0.0089857671,
0.770418644,
-0.0410080664,
1.1686373949,
-0.8181804419,
-0.0947165787,
0.2626226842,
0.0975339413,
0.3757309914,
-0.4903446138,
0.1907634139,
0.3043883443,
-0.5792003274,
-0.6827630401,
0.3239462376,
-1.1710988283,
-0.6037603021,
1.3756370544,
-0.0406259485,
-0.5138608217,
0.222781077,
-0.1068305001,
0.4093750417,
-0.8310936689,
0.7348520756,
0.5367750525,
-0.2550857365,
-0.0599748977,
-0.1194910184,
0.7378057241,
0.3418402374,
-0.5951374769,
-0.0245053526,
0.6209267974,
0.3137608469,
0.1609624773,
0.7473289967,
-0.1632026285,
0.2292078882,
0.0689478144,
-0.2107337564,
-0.0360066481,
-0.1305515766,
-0.3500438333,
0.2170747519,
-0.210740611,
-0.0414370075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13036v1
|
SiLLM: Large Language Models for Simultaneous Machine Translation
| 2024-02-20T14:23:34 | 2024-02-20T14:23:34 |
Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) generates translations while reading
the source sentence, necessitating a policy to determine the optimal timing for
reading and generating words. Despite the remarkable performance achieved by
Large Language Models (LLM) across various NLP tasks, existing SiMT methods
predominantly focus on conventional transformers, employing a single model to
concurrently determine the policy and generate the translations. However, given
the complexity of SiMT, it is challenging to effectively address both tasks
with a single model. Therefore, there is a need to decouple the SiMT task into
policy-decision and translation sub-tasks. We propose SiLLM, which delegates
the two sub-tasks to separate agents, thereby incorporating LLM into SiMT. The
policy-decision agent is managed by a conventional SiMT model, responsible for
determining the translation policy. The translation agent, leveraging the
capabilities of LLM, generates translation using the partial source sentence.
The two agents collaborate to accomplish SiMT. To facilitate the application of
token-level policies determined by conventional SiMT models to LLM, we propose
a word-level policy adapted for LLM. Experiments on two datasets demonstrate
that, with a small amount of data for fine-tuning LLM, SiLLM attains
state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.2825550139,
-0.6736252904,
0.5803548694,
0.6697634459,
-0.3998129964,
0.0774298161,
-0.4573024809,
-0.1913790703,
0.0369523503,
0.7361986637,
-0.6460704803,
-0.2966808379,
-0.6811512709,
0.2767188847,
-0.2267442495,
1.0038403273,
-0.2309275419,
0.162697196,
-0.2837169468,
-0.0443464033,
-0.7318478823,
-0.2520326674,
-0.7139286399,
-0.5438879728,
0.4655404687,
0.1895373762,
1.0861207247,
0.6366288066,
0.6252512336,
0.2723771632,
-0.137880668,
0.5162571669,
-0.3932557702,
0.0747702792,
-0.3364673853,
-0.3562509716,
-0.5614660978,
-0.1569212824,
0.9828320742,
0.4530920088,
0.0763806105,
0.0463493466,
0.1551190317,
0.3527636826,
-0.1964906007,
0.3349587917,
-0.7455424666,
0.0616270788,
-0.0072800526,
-0.390781343,
-0.5139434338,
-0.1940197349,
-0.1443039924,
-0.3446549773,
-0.2336538881,
0.2337439209,
0.5624700189,
0.5939655304,
-0.6703609228,
-0.2554964125,
-0.894833982,
0.8964083791,
-0.7458450198,
0.2376228571,
0.062923111,
-0.0753220469,
-0.2395560741,
-0.4646036029,
-0.4339622557,
-0.5006178021,
-0.1887934804,
0.2256613076,
0.0633060932,
0.0726221576,
0.3131217659,
0.1472165138,
-0.675509274,
0.133400023,
-0.2827489972,
0.0119602215,
0.6077235937,
0.3406540155,
0.449326545,
0.0965618789,
-0.7724380493,
0.2425756007,
-0.6610268354,
-0.4367980361,
0.0894051343,
0.3635116518,
0.0728413463,
0.7776219249,
0.0110168569,
0.2293767035,
-0.3458634615,
-0.4187285304,
0.2047973573,
-0.5260113478,
-0.1963851005,
0.1676170826,
0.9019025564,
0.1544694752,
0.2587008178,
-0.3244330287,
-0.4757936895,
-0.1307622939,
0.1609017998,
-0.7604234815,
0.5322229862,
0.1140022725,
-0.1621039361,
-0.1348496377,
-0.0217078254,
-0.3504594862,
-0.1891965419,
-0.5774412155,
0.56932652,
-0.3451140225,
-0.3170349896,
0.2328897566,
0.1709383428,
0.2415832281,
0.2666865289,
-0.5394276977,
0.5004068017,
0.8138296008,
1.0864087343,
-0.6834907532,
-0.7185096145,
-0.5320221186,
0.430356741,
-0.2857064605,
0.3484980464,
-0.2008285373,
-0.3920618594,
-0.1850713938,
-0.0003026741,
-0.584989965,
-0.4879000485,
0.2296340317,
-0.3605086505,
-0.1618151814,
0.0345861912,
-0.4828261733,
0.0691762418,
0.2866233885,
-0.6821916103,
1.0066187382,
-0.0475617647,
-0.7146985531,
0.1716798693,
-0.8761982918,
-0.6828342676,
0.092110984,
-0.1529304683,
-0.2750087976,
0.2526844442,
0.2302199155,
0.4618930519,
-0.5606126785,
0.5310921073,
-0.1141054705,
-0.3461416662,
0.2027432472,
-0.5914404988,
0.7291128039,
0.3417752683,
-0.2347624153,
0.2027939856,
-0.0908224136,
-0.1942349374,
0.1263846904,
-0.5285275578,
-0.0618720539,
-0.0567951947,
0.0908878297,
0.3713108301,
0.5514255762,
-0.4332452714,
0.5166246295,
-0.2146492302,
0.3532938063,
0.5085712671,
-0.0769054219,
0.5612766147,
-0.3362837434,
0.6364185214,
-0.0445067622,
0.1213759556,
-0.1031984687,
-0.2742110789,
-0.7806782126,
-0.4024766982,
0.3085325062,
0.8556681275,
-0.6708418131,
0.0969384536,
-0.3241051435,
-0.2203172147,
-0.6476504803,
0.261621654,
0.2442369312,
-0.1538133174,
0.436527133,
-0.056028448,
-0.1954483986,
-0.8394553661,
-0.3486215472,
0.0158635322,
0.346614778,
0.1927241087,
0.4141892791,
-0.3330085278,
0.7730133533,
-0.4361431599,
-0.4789966047,
-0.6127290726,
0.3244930208,
0.0988724679,
0.4623850286,
0.3615969718,
-0.8679116368,
-0.5509269238,
0.2583738267,
-0.8071571589,
-0.3418197036,
-0.4881914556,
-0.1469063461,
0.2441692352,
0.8934841156,
-0.7203181386,
0.2903030813,
0.4817660153,
0.0332894102,
0.5244022608,
-0.464548409,
0.0166707318,
-1.3403687477,
-0.2082964927,
-0.4007256627,
-0.6166870594,
-0.3813906014,
0.2593278885,
0.0068606744,
-0.0507384576,
-0.6409199834,
0.5284206271,
-0.6058252454,
-0.3015507162,
-0.3902014196,
-0.089729093,
-0.2541787028,
0.3379257917,
0.0612620115,
1.0164499283,
0.3296402991,
-0.3480148911,
0.1857661456,
-0.0547222383,
-0.0823974311,
0.2514284253,
-0.6010637879,
-0.0411829799,
-0.0634777024,
0.3002891839,
-0.6275280714,
-0.1559115946,
-0.0129214246,
0.0162611846,
0.3248283863,
-0.0063435035,
-0.790587604,
-0.3208129704,
0.0495203063,
0.4089746773,
0.5354091525,
-0.2645268142,
0.7496486902,
0.3763414919,
-0.3577913344,
-0.4262290001,
-0.6136714816,
0.1083076969,
-0.2087227404,
-0.5424655676,
0.3163796067,
-0.0396861956,
-0.1509111524,
0.1151233837,
-0.111036092,
0.0974380672,
0.0999345779,
0.3794347644,
0.1847393066,
-0.3730671108,
0.0039543016,
0.2465029657,
-0.3293079436,
-0.2019343972,
-0.3835157454,
0.7054997683,
-0.1760098487,
-0.5123996735,
-0.4222583473,
0.5216139555,
0.9907527566,
-0.3961816728,
0.9838353992,
0.8110027313,
-0.1621432155,
-0.4566326737,
-0.3785911202,
-0.0392146744,
-0.3680951297,
0.3548881412,
-0.6889976859,
-0.8838225603,
0.2514789701,
-0.6030774117,
0.2171880454,
0.3671194315,
0.9191143513,
0.1219474673,
1.2448678017,
0.6510045528,
-0.0479642414,
0.4459658563,
-0.0787216127,
0.228166461,
-0.6521980166,
0.0000906984,
-0.2606303394,
-0.1335660815,
-0.3630718887,
-0.5699327588,
0.4707665443,
0.247695148,
0.0787521377,
0.5040405393,
-0.0877074078,
0.6561738253,
0.588016808,
-0.1268721223,
0.4923483133,
-0.0062294011,
-0.4980089366,
0.1750190258,
-0.6805340052,
-0.6219127774,
0.6428948045,
0.2419027537,
0.8569543958,
-0.0173209719,
0.8124027252,
0.2211517692,
0.0851203948,
-0.7754223347,
0.7918742895,
-0.3489261568,
-0.3075145781,
-0.2613264322,
-0.5572561026,
-0.7825165391,
0.5984130502,
-0.1292717755,
-0.5003595948,
-0.3692284822,
0.0261620432,
0.0103943255,
0.2824368775,
-0.5569262505,
0.9442340136,
-0.4181911349,
-0.1289629191,
-0.3636823893,
-0.5665363669,
0.4783875942,
-0.4779455662,
0.0924338475,
-0.4519975185,
-0.1676591635,
0.2655853033,
-0.3922818899,
0.5932794213,
0.147757411,
-0.0346155986,
0.109910138,
0.2495337725,
0.5796511769,
0.045524288,
-0.1903882772,
0.1789864749,
0.1836327612,
-0.2204675823,
-0.2891032398,
0.6746287942,
-0.7037924528,
-0.5603810549,
-0.549359858,
-1.1256793737,
-0.0274085682,
0.3675382733,
0.1091098562,
0.1181822941,
-0.3210388124,
0.3112059236,
0.3898732066,
-0.2744278312,
0.318417877,
0.6186878085,
-0.5295444727,
-0.0715290532,
0.9390177131,
0.2071476728,
0.6099205613,
0.3930830061,
0.209045127,
-0.3157044351,
-0.5857540965,
-0.4401778281,
0.3536519706,
-0.2627543509,
-0.0835027397,
-0.7194940448,
-0.5193477869,
-0.503491044,
-0.035772007,
-0.392416954,
-0.2416326553,
-0.1231293604,
0.315577805,
0.0817315057,
0.7641981244,
-0.1356539428,
0.470190078,
-0.7159263492,
0.5656448603,
0.0838553384,
-0.1327234656,
-0.3813526034,
-0.3591475487,
-0.1946546733,
0.0646023154,
-0.1305032223,
-0.6720087528,
0.4225625992,
0.0562894382,
0.4015834033,
-0.0680393279,
0.0111100897,
0.6305981874,
-0.7880938649,
0.5137912631,
0.1039303243,
-0.8441080451,
0.3359921277,
-0.1806924492,
0.6147375703,
0.3210541606,
0.2848757207,
-0.645930171,
-0.6799921989,
-0.1666570753,
-1.0244961977,
1.0750398636,
0.2614678442,
0.1479416937,
0.0141827092,
-0.129540652,
0.0877043083,
0.232432276,
-0.6043940187,
0.1075308621,
0.4069176018,
-0.3076680601,
0.0055054631,
-0.1369383484,
0.1443944424,
-0.0162066761,
0.9455808401,
-0.2423441261,
-0.042260956,
-0.1120546535,
-0.51107651,
0.0307871047,
0.4913787842,
0.5013497472,
0.6154613495,
-0.1169859394,
0.2482877523,
0.3625613749,
-0.420933485,
0.0788963065,
0.0430617742,
-0.6209442616,
0.0347142071,
0.2776217163,
0.8662151098,
0.2028621733,
-0.5611524582,
0.5772259235,
-0.0281650499,
-0.2072949708,
-0.1453983486,
0.1310902685,
0.313092947,
0.468156904,
0.0901600793,
0.0913367197,
-0.2820150256,
-0.3572605252,
0.2925297618,
0.3953571022,
-0.1667463481,
-0.045941297,
0.6811933517,
-0.0202820115,
-0.3661138117,
0.326002568,
-0.1933614463,
-0.5567008853,
0.6414479613,
0.9169241786,
0.9039489627,
-0.1497908533,
0.3628460467,
0.0473555997,
0.6701621413,
-0.5412249565,
0.2311237305,
0.2109805793,
-0.547522068,
-0.5546205044,
-0.9164035916,
-0.1874067634,
0.0888503119,
-0.5022213459,
0.3070846498,
-0.1747097224,
-0.1267852187,
-0.1421571523,
-0.1584825814,
-0.7074385881,
-0.1858276278,
0.1411564648,
0.7478724122,
-0.8603207469,
1.0224803686,
0.6226966977,
-0.5252482891,
-0.7798628807,
0.1801787168,
0.0354593061,
-0.7620793581,
0.5101530552,
0.0578344986,
-0.2652204633,
0.2184908986,
-0.3189942837,
-0.7327518463,
1.0544793606,
0.6931582093,
-0.6280577183,
-0.1813703179,
0.5999901295,
0.2598861158,
-0.4092191756,
-0.0774357691,
0.6773521304,
0.4957974255,
0.1090034842,
-1.2361445427,
0.025574252,
0.3725892901,
0.1734617352,
0.3596374989,
-0.6541247368,
0.909946382,
-0.0716396868,
-0.2590967715,
0.1704747975,
0.5852905512,
0.1496898532,
0.209621489,
0.5820862055,
0.3587066531,
0.4989686906,
-0.0579014421,
1.0544409752,
-0.2354956418,
0.4474532008,
1.3720369339,
-0.5687003732,
0.7939968109,
0.5850543976,
0.0560223162,
-0.283606261,
0.364535898,
0.1397833228,
0.265745014,
0.1053266898,
-0.3870042861,
-0.4247736037,
-0.6006699204,
-0.2603629529,
0.3902772367,
0.3364652693,
-0.4680054188,
-0.3619667888,
0.2472191453,
0.2213493288,
-0.1037339196,
-0.3617330492,
0.9381702542,
0.3694374263,
-0.7852443457,
0.2230918705,
0.2471825927,
0.3602282405,
-0.6199164987,
0.0765607208,
-0.1973878294,
0.3937113583,
0.0000931348,
-0.7064520717,
0.2611603737,
-0.0129629122,
-0.1552590579,
-0.6203437448,
0.7114133835,
-1.0055770874,
-0.6330497861,
0.3858343959,
0.7782797813,
0.4576891959,
0.0483525172,
-0.9452422857,
0.2733983994,
-0.12763758,
-0.2917711139,
0.2280880213,
0.5777527094,
-0.3734178543,
0.4859835804,
0.5729042888,
0.42942065,
0.3711461723,
0.2081903219,
0.5694465041,
-0.4328926802,
-0.3980284929,
-0.9699519277,
0.1086744815,
0.034574192,
0.007652129,
0.640609324,
0.6238719821,
0.7531955838,
-0.1203323603,
0.7489086986,
0.0273647457,
0.1861386895,
-0.7308750153,
0.573481977,
-0.8338037133,
0.2558915019,
-0.0309692957,
-1.2357661724,
-0.2998525202,
0.3245358467,
-0.2944143414,
-0.2092601955,
0.9467473626,
1.00111866,
-0.3577720523,
-0.1543850899,
0.477912724,
0.2222214043,
0.1697222143,
0.5287851095,
0.7685248852,
-0.1170937195,
0.6463025808,
0.1337680668,
0.025726473,
-0.2622557878,
-0.8579034209,
-0.883390367,
-0.3712470233,
-0.2436890304,
-0.0933533385,
0.0187169556,
1.2824631929,
0.6745397449,
-0.6073157191,
-0.2719827592,
-0.0660858676,
0.2657426894,
-0.347066462,
-0.1821931452,
0.1969753504,
-0.617816031,
-0.9428793788,
0.5041548014,
0.6558864713,
0.0094010467,
-0.3378754854,
-0.2497091442,
-0.3130923808,
0.3499954343,
0.6462163329,
-0.0227129404,
-0.8244290352,
0.1763984263,
-0.2210161537,
-0.5078929663,
-0.1734495312,
1.0378414392,
-0.2707807422,
0.2125444263,
0.6325623393,
0.9574222565,
0.7678933144,
-0.0326618254,
0.6365619898,
-0.6957084537,
0.1330269426,
0.1550237089,
0.3398832381,
0.0605880916,
-0.2426185906,
0.7106754184,
0.0838543847,
-0.4937751889,
-0.8750988841,
0.3580827117,
-0.8892099261,
-0.3729778826,
1.3780403137,
-0.161601603,
-0.3340796232,
0.0632018149,
-0.5701624155,
0.3029008806,
-0.2413480431,
0.0398619398,
0.6250775456,
0.1170354635,
-0.0998144597,
-0.813860774,
0.2215996385,
0.50291574,
-0.8711743355,
0.0279595368,
0.2555271089,
0.0675856546,
-0.0744105801,
0.8036949039,
-0.1655602157,
-0.0622220933,
-0.0617631078,
-0.2061493397,
-0.1955788881,
-0.7497261167,
-0.1847363263,
0.1557123959,
0.0580388904,
-0.1200352237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13035v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13035v3
|
Learning to Check: Unleashing Potentials for Self-Correction in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T14:23:23 | 2024-06-17T15:24:29 |
Che Zhang, Zhenyang Xiao, Chengcheng Han, Yixin Lian, Yuejian Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-correction has achieved impressive results in enhancing the style and
security of the generated output from large language models (LLMs). However,
recent studies suggest that self-correction might be limited or even
counterproductive in reasoning tasks due to LLMs' difficulties in identifying
logical mistakes.
In this paper, we aim to enhance the self-checking capabilities of LLMs by
constructing training data for checking tasks. Specifically, we apply the Chain
of Thought (CoT) methodology to self-checking tasks, utilizing fine-grained
step-level analyses and explanations to assess the correctness of reasoning
paths. We propose a specialized checking format called "Step CoT Check".
Following this format, we construct a checking-correction dataset that includes
detailed step-by-step analysis and checking. Then we fine-tune LLMs to enhance
their error detection and correction abilities.
Our experiments demonstrate that fine-tuning with the "Step CoT Check" format
significantly improves the self-checking and self-correction abilities of LLMs
across multiple benchmarks. This approach outperforms other formats, especially
in locating the incorrect position, with greater benefits observed in larger
models.
For reproducibility, all the datasets and code are provided in
https://github.com/bammt/Learn-to-check.
|
[
-0.0614448749,
-0.7220924497,
0.7668909431,
0.0691186339,
-0.1180442199,
0.2117974758,
-0.2407405972,
-0.3510484397,
-0.1062983647,
0.8940784931,
-0.6222752929,
-0.4853271842,
-0.5554256439,
0.3077377081,
-0.6112641096,
0.9755663872,
-0.463285476,
-0.0949602574,
-0.1164849252,
0.1540414542,
-0.5395972133,
-0.5122390389,
-0.7901546955,
-0.4590449929,
0.5796166062,
0.4793523848,
0.4296720326,
0.66666466,
0.3483349383,
0.3991525173,
0.0884878784,
0.6616441607,
-0.5357775688,
-0.0155593809,
-0.6400046349,
-0.5799435973,
-0.619535625,
-0.0081169251,
0.4744771421,
0.1950018555,
0.0108851343,
0.2221790105,
-0.0390040502,
0.9726865292,
-0.6690860987,
0.1827640533,
-0.6293612123,
-0.0092354845,
-0.1487714201,
-0.2944642901,
-0.5099052191,
-0.2543256283,
-0.4605728388,
-0.0172403138,
0.3115821481,
0.1466593146,
0.5824289322,
0.5034716725,
-0.5063095093,
-0.4049258232,
-0.7022589445,
0.4340596795,
-0.763063252,
0.4615388215,
0.7260203362,
0.1031827256,
-0.3678398728,
-0.4583499134,
-0.7404146194,
-0.0501539595,
-0.0870312974,
-0.1756374985,
0.0286482796,
0.0941097438,
0.4423521459,
0.4577350318,
-0.4869917631,
0.0434486009,
-0.3014698923,
-0.3201904595,
0.6667823195,
0.0538166203,
0.320957303,
0.0010596715,
-0.1408923864,
-0.3352784812,
-0.7128759623,
-0.0056314166,
0.4200057983,
0.221783936,
-0.0221880022,
0.5872796178,
-0.4908883572,
0.7697009444,
0.3170000911,
-0.3028361499,
0.0098942248,
-0.461522907,
-0.4731125236,
0.0719485581,
0.4897776842,
0.0884048641,
0.1901661009,
-0.0209661517,
-0.6728021502,
0.030327959,
0.3187483251,
-0.4358101487,
-0.5193924308,
0.4025458097,
-0.0808980465,
-0.3586103022,
-0.1582072079,
-0.3159133792,
-0.4748241901,
-0.5861169696,
0.591093123,
-0.4359413385,
0.0783872604,
0.537196517,
0.4349578917,
-0.067584388,
0.4982243478,
-0.7444556952,
0.1248309463,
0.6554813385,
0.4879141152,
0.0430079922,
-0.5535407066,
-0.7687782049,
0.0353924707,
-0.8638646007,
0.9198877215,
-0.1753354073,
0.1712833792,
-0.022432249,
0.0384411886,
-0.0035163751,
-0.4678805768,
0.3153864741,
-0.4441986382,
-0.1781373918,
-0.4451182187,
-0.5930063128,
0.0418794975,
0.5768641829,
-0.4796147943,
1.1372892857,
0.0151231745,
-0.5722584724,
0.2772034109,
-0.4266689718,
-0.5687342882,
-0.2718988359,
-0.200860709,
-0.4586367607,
-0.0472429693,
0.4095170498,
0.4441788495,
-0.0783359259,
0.1792676449,
-0.1460060924,
-0.1194000542,
0.2786657214,
-0.1105673313,
0.7295405269,
0.1254738569,
-0.6352720857,
0.3240928054,
-0.8465725183,
0.2303123772,
0.0558130182,
-0.3550487757,
-0.1898185313,
-0.0713686869,
-0.6078753471,
0.4294107556,
0.1277490556,
-0.4357257485,
0.3047379851,
-0.1717085093,
0.2948668003,
0.8418806791,
-0.160474807,
0.0214071441,
-0.2469573468,
0.3978349268,
0.2368100435,
0.2013128847,
-0.2366465926,
0.013778938,
-1.2282594442,
-0.0870090201,
0.5454104543,
0.4319766462,
-0.8561499119,
0.8159330487,
0.3099673688,
-0.4250197709,
-0.3868976235,
0.449247241,
0.5369712114,
0.4526337683,
0.4607312381,
-0.3403072953,
-0.6110519767,
-0.3787873387,
-0.2875535488,
-0.2521803975,
0.3436821401,
-0.122699976,
0.6575380564,
-0.5178693533,
0.7449043989,
-0.3449346721,
-0.2552080154,
-0.1254237443,
0.1145745665,
-0.0197170228,
0.5111150742,
0.0754542127,
-0.1442582011,
-0.21837686,
-0.0442418195,
-0.5174084306,
-0.1737903506,
-0.5092045069,
-0.3664524853,
0.1481649578,
0.8579594493,
-0.2881501317,
0.4632824063,
0.5797503591,
-0.6610559821,
0.6141702533,
-0.5738633275,
0.1462846696,
-0.6053283811,
-0.1749452353,
-0.2366090417,
-0.6699768901,
-0.3573171198,
0.058486037,
0.5050522685,
0.1991388798,
-0.1028501764,
0.3291490972,
-0.5131973624,
-0.1662455648,
-0.4813358188,
0.1281974763,
-0.011782215,
0.4192841649,
-0.304281652,
0.8117399812,
0.6398852468,
-0.712025702,
0.1846468151,
0.2184407711,
-0.4807950854,
0.4418763816,
-0.3871703744,
0.5469580889,
-0.1043857709,
0.4419795275,
-0.9332851171,
-0.0858700797,
0.075035952,
-0.1362794191,
0.3880912662,
-0.0809691623,
-0.6816384792,
-0.4700135291,
-0.0967230201,
0.3328689933,
0.1298603863,
-1.0052275658,
0.4302543998,
0.152913183,
0.2333755493,
-0.714846611,
-0.4280779064,
0.0338912532,
0.2801894546,
-0.3721671402,
-0.0060502551,
-0.0560552441,
-0.0809551775,
-0.4047999084,
-0.478339076,
0.1177500486,
-0.0589129031,
-0.010463343,
0.1530678421,
0.1571308821,
0.4355103076,
-0.0517566726,
-0.1057948247,
0.1433458477,
-0.4639820457,
0.6353678107,
-0.3059610724,
-0.5226634145,
-0.1910733432,
-0.1921815574,
0.539026916,
-0.5611027479,
0.3703194261,
0.4373845756,
-0.3347463608,
-0.6151888967,
-0.8446221352,
-0.2133754343,
-0.5028043389,
0.1751885712,
-0.3619070947,
-0.8459769487,
0.3440936506,
-0.1615710855,
-0.0789197013,
0.4519598484,
0.5837501287,
-0.2123717517,
0.8730604649,
0.7265175581,
-0.054547403,
0.211965695,
-0.2943059802,
0.6299772263,
-0.885969758,
-0.2486660331,
-0.5477682948,
-0.1288582832,
-0.6217371821,
-0.909478724,
0.0338958204,
0.1107111797,
-0.5229402184,
0.3663259745,
-0.3029704094,
0.8341225386,
0.306417495,
0.3620973527,
0.4888096154,
-0.2779111266,
-0.3625214398,
0.2402185798,
-0.5200421214,
-0.5089770555,
0.9179596305,
0.4498176575,
1.2128823996,
-0.2481724918,
0.9575279355,
0.3315778673,
0.0749507993,
-0.6215924025,
0.5636788011,
-0.1599332988,
-0.4337697029,
-0.4205197692,
-0.3728132546,
-0.6987380981,
-0.0762579367,
-0.1745909005,
-0.5237777233,
0.211526677,
0.5450373292,
-0.2405612767,
0.6194819212,
-0.3614035547,
0.6393021941,
-0.6877833605,
-0.2993423045,
-0.3756850958,
-0.3612927794,
0.4358861744,
-0.259383142,
0.1122440845,
-0.1321191639,
0.3068296313,
0.4021515846,
-0.5073270202,
1.0930339098,
0.3565076888,
-0.6152313948,
0.4551490545,
0.4563947916,
0.8779838681,
-0.0458666012,
0.2035681456,
0.1197957993,
0.0077475039,
-0.3281651139,
-0.6163898706,
0.5979070663,
-0.7016980052,
-0.6432552338,
-0.4973947704,
-0.4542754292,
-0.4577307403,
0.3494036198,
-0.0368287116,
0.3308405876,
0.2512006164,
0.0249904953,
0.8381624818,
-0.0520734563,
0.1387268156,
0.5359439254,
-0.5026091933,
-0.2117766738,
0.7711778283,
-0.0530940816,
0.3596345484,
0.3692024648,
0.2749196589,
-0.4104353786,
-0.3992761672,
-0.4269251227,
0.3527593613,
-0.9044782519,
-0.2999491394,
-0.5219535232,
-0.1370883435,
-0.3902631104,
0.0372300893,
-0.705834806,
-0.2234730273,
0.0854414999,
-0.1307016015,
0.2218044102,
1.0317877531,
-0.2459924221,
-0.0062060975,
-0.4776532948,
0.267107904,
0.4950210154,
0.7266004086,
0.1186365187,
-0.3668987751,
-0.2792012393,
-0.0444042869,
-0.4042026401,
-0.5418269634,
0.1242763326,
-0.2075270861,
0.2756999731,
0.232955724,
-0.0675919056,
0.8787801266,
-0.4802953303,
0.4451444745,
0.2273469865,
-1.2738344669,
0.8415171504,
-0.0646782741,
0.2810252309,
0.511154294,
0.0901064649,
-0.5166398883,
-0.3892021775,
-0.5637360811,
-0.5650257468,
0.485570997,
0.198273778,
-0.2937768102,
-0.0744373128,
0.564242959,
-0.0964890346,
0.0306523591,
-0.6712855101,
-0.0723310634,
-0.0824378505,
-0.0394038931,
-0.2344831228,
-0.172720328,
-0.2015976906,
-0.275578022,
0.7840337753,
-0.5306261778,
0.0758004859,
0.5956069231,
-0.1631541401,
-0.4928246737,
0.2877189815,
0.5506028533,
0.883338511,
0.0783094317,
0.4901056886,
0.4426242709,
-0.1566560268,
0.2007576227,
-0.5132209659,
0.0296634044,
-0.2466403246,
0.2887160182,
0.730358839,
0.077397719,
-0.6397655606,
0.1431952566,
-0.0191221517,
-0.024748873,
-0.0107695013,
0.3387524188,
-0.035039138,
0.3345468044,
-0.2745364904,
0.1144027337,
0.0324787647,
-0.8786660433,
0.2189371735,
0.2835316062,
-0.2186156362,
-0.0495176762,
0.3251209557,
0.0446279608,
-0.4327312708,
0.6238542795,
-0.2099644989,
-0.6634697914,
0.5269911885,
0.8290076852,
0.820920527,
-0.2495056987,
0.1426367909,
0.518471539,
0.6101383567,
-0.4137866497,
0.4637571573,
-0.1322642118,
-0.7515452504,
-0.5893986821,
-0.454939574,
-0.6408236027,
0.3577604592,
-0.4811744094,
0.3208555281,
-0.6120414138,
0.0137786809,
-0.2293411642,
-0.0550670587,
-0.7755001187,
0.7130816579,
0.1675977111,
0.7414283156,
-0.5957202315,
0.9367441535,
0.5044776201,
-0.2088012695,
-1.1182612181,
0.2113284469,
-0.2064864784,
-0.9025751948,
0.4717735052,
0.104767628,
-0.505731523,
-0.2876885235,
-0.7330924273,
-1.036998868,
0.8657369018,
0.310914278,
-1.1500658989,
0.1271855235,
0.0779763088,
0.723512888,
-0.3285330236,
0.0627747104,
0.8573943377,
0.2397011817,
0.0513448827,
-0.9072279334,
0.168817088,
0.1426590085,
-0.1571642905,
0.3860517442,
-0.6086321473,
0.8175691366,
-0.582816422,
0.1382682621,
-0.2797875702,
0.5040288568,
0.3138628006,
0.046614401,
0.7285666466,
0.5929265618,
1.1353759766,
0.0620274395,
1.006975174,
-0.312805444,
0.572858572,
1.4392777681,
-0.2538921833,
0.8241552711,
0.3524853885,
-0.0886747837,
0.7221180201,
0.5434260964,
-0.0036164129,
0.1423421055,
0.3427145183,
0.1448856294,
-0.6894440055,
0.3815744817,
0.0323571749,
0.450214982,
0.2865269184,
-0.2677518427,
-0.154655993,
-0.2987564504,
-0.077250503,
0.0920888707,
-0.3989657164,
0.6245498657,
-0.0416268706,
-0.8029586077,
0.6222017407,
-0.0127212908,
0.3356678188,
-0.3893015087,
-0.0426739119,
-0.16059798,
0.4762915969,
-0.3144859672,
-0.8922970295,
0.1702300757,
0.1426197439,
-0.0120345671,
-0.2579365373,
0.9435583949,
-0.5610427856,
-0.4292058647,
0.40995121,
0.474766463,
0.0317661501,
-0.0374931246,
-0.6616580486,
0.0699330196,
0.1573071033,
0.0504865088,
0.2298315316,
0.5108526349,
-0.1810239404,
0.8980776072,
0.6359184384,
0.1170737818,
-0.1500986665,
0.2533352673,
0.674354136,
-0.8329879045,
-0.5439590216,
-0.8121337891,
0.3924369812,
-0.0171637256,
-0.5058160424,
0.5438494682,
0.4505591094,
1.2342814207,
-0.2254377007,
0.6415425539,
0.206562385,
0.3637340069,
-0.6627783179,
0.5430534482,
-0.4267504513,
0.234640792,
-0.1517876238,
-0.5679886341,
-0.1700465828,
0.8515235782,
-0.3679197729,
0.071212247,
1.0537968874,
0.9033600688,
0.0808901191,
-0.1063523069,
0.5281259418,
0.427366972,
0.3763473928,
0.4157883525,
0.75968045,
-0.5529400706,
0.2361762375,
-0.5145068169,
-0.1868145466,
0.0233167745,
-1.0150264502,
-1.3195806742,
-0.4106724262,
-0.6174329519,
-0.6664104462,
0.1383379251,
1.0849381685,
0.604093194,
-1.0202336311,
-0.2696187198,
-0.2954087257,
0.3186517358,
-0.3563381135,
-0.0571677461,
0.3462631106,
-0.8627344966,
-0.3888146579,
0.5039058328,
0.5644678473,
-0.0292171147,
-0.4178849459,
-0.0321388319,
-0.1456092447,
0.3931906521,
0.7243432999,
0.1095731556,
-0.7779890299,
-0.4514040947,
-0.036638394,
-0.1998563409,
0.0596228242,
1.1605037451,
-0.6053054929,
0.8221265078,
0.3889235854,
0.6430001855,
0.4761887789,
-0.248465091,
0.4311911762,
-0.543171525,
-0.4658676982,
-0.0200225841,
0.707496047,
0.3710294962,
-0.6414357424,
0.6547176242,
-0.1218163967,
-0.7889079452,
-0.6891383529,
0.1692054868,
-0.8470598459,
-0.0759529173,
1.0761480331,
-0.1896024346,
-0.2944810987,
-0.0920220315,
-0.5315257907,
0.4155296981,
0.0710975602,
1.3184361458,
0.7661645412,
-0.1976177394,
0.0588431843,
-0.1329078823,
0.6864403486,
0.5574806929,
-1.1424763203,
0.4494459927,
0.1652118564,
0.5802545547,
0.037120156,
0.4559933245,
-0.1771486253,
0.357155472,
-0.2747264802,
0.0942605361,
0.1690841019,
-0.540316999,
-0.3853391409,
-0.347204268,
0.1073197275,
0.0487063378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13028v1
|
Heterogeneous Graph Reasoning for Fact Checking over Texts and Tables
| 2024-02-20T14:10:40 | 2024-02-20T14:10:40 |
Haisong Gong, Weizhi Xu, Shu wu, Qiang Liu, Liang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fact checking aims to predict claim veracity by reasoning over multiple
evidence pieces. It usually involves evidence retrieval and veracity reasoning.
In this paper, we focus on the latter, reasoning over unstructured text and
structured table information. Previous works have primarily relied on
fine-tuning pretrained language models or training homogeneous-graph-based
models. Despite their effectiveness, we argue that they fail to explore the
rich semantic information underlying the evidence with different structures. To
address this, we propose a novel word-level Heterogeneous-graph-based model for
Fact Checking over unstructured and structured information, namely HeterFC. Our
approach leverages a heterogeneous evidence graph, with words as nodes and
thoughtfully designed edges representing different evidence properties. We
perform information propagation via a relational graph neural network,
facilitating interactions between claims and evidence. An attention-based
method is utilized to integrate information, combined with a language model for
generating predictions. We introduce a multitask loss function to account for
potential inaccuracies in evidence retrieval. Comprehensive experiments on the
large fact checking dataset FEVEROUS demonstrate the effectiveness of HeterFC.
Code will be released at: https://github.com/Deno-V/HeterFC.
|
[
-0.0072573116,
-1.2973834276,
0.889754951,
0.0832397565,
-0.1491121948,
0.0655129999,
-0.0852257907,
-0.3342435062,
0.0028922153,
0.4649074674,
-0.2733682692,
-0.8915296197,
-0.6053891778,
0.0850690454,
-0.3034283817,
1.0242824554,
-0.2143783569,
-0.2979106307,
-0.4343191981,
-0.191032812,
-0.1444056481,
-0.4194003642,
0.0014440696,
-0.877892971,
0.5473980904,
0.5814520717,
0.7777174711,
0.8913526535,
0.1088553667,
0.3758180141,
0.0258472562,
0.5379485488,
-0.4116930068,
-0.2113039792,
-0.1790242791,
-0.1528972983,
-0.2858853638,
0.2244226784,
0.6739478111,
0.7121300697,
-0.0624976978,
-0.0815243348,
-0.1236106604,
0.1192455143,
-0.6749250889,
0.5842167139,
-0.8101305366,
0.2121368498,
-0.1104001179,
-0.184919253,
-0.6057586074,
-0.5697949529,
0.088149555,
-0.5212123394,
0.2508840561,
0.1814265847,
1.1008716822,
0.1288107187,
-0.5083961487,
-0.0012884352,
-0.5247037411,
0.1945280582,
-0.5748209357,
0.538577497,
0.6957876682,
-0.037125621,
-0.1267323196,
-1.1275467873,
-0.7440799475,
-0.2616395354,
-0.3780997396,
0.1175319999,
-0.0569065176,
0.0519125164,
0.2974300086,
0.2566681802,
-0.3974002898,
-0.1476502717,
0.1456380934,
-0.6670730114,
0.263040334,
-0.0634119213,
0.1890709996,
-0.4057042301,
-0.4507007003,
0.1067813188,
-0.6192783713,
-0.08324714,
0.5427664518,
0.4601235986,
-0.0605139993,
0.8111422062,
-0.3925211132,
0.734122932,
-0.0950078592,
-0.2013995349,
0.2494771034,
-0.4774172604,
-0.2122804224,
0.5174304247,
0.6854658127,
0.2228665352,
-0.1974125952,
-0.4800501466,
-0.0688773096,
0.3901579678,
-0.040334668,
-0.9223124385,
-0.2594433725,
0.276470542,
-0.4154126346,
-0.2854169607,
0.0773861781,
-0.6517363191,
-0.3029505908,
-0.0590271056,
0.3269242942,
-0.5822309852,
0.0274323486,
0.1746885777,
-0.2315240651,
-0.5233517289,
0.4942153394,
-0.4010639489,
-0.0342544243,
0.6170081496,
0.7911362052,
0.2301615328,
-0.4532146454,
-0.8817968965,
0.2086181492,
-0.1423491538,
1.217954874,
-0.7062780261,
-0.0723394305,
0.3149731159,
0.0666424781,
-0.065731734,
-0.0119150653,
0.8484169245,
-0.5623848438,
0.4848476946,
-0.3578647971,
-0.6649982929,
-0.205385983,
0.6615337133,
-0.664178133,
0.8799886107,
0.0821715072,
-1.3366197348,
0.4466612339,
-0.4978679419,
-0.7706145644,
0.1308748126,
-0.2980946302,
-0.5963269472,
-0.5834513903,
0.082839258,
0.2799315155,
-0.1978220344,
0.38571015,
-0.6253667474,
-0.1138451323,
0.0401177444,
-0.1751748323,
0.5079056025,
0.2306514531,
-0.303753078,
0.2341690958,
-0.7964093089,
0.1223696843,
-0.0107896309,
-0.8450171947,
-0.1962064058,
0.3274805844,
-0.0062132641,
0.0391229726,
-0.0000211133,
-1.0070935488,
0.0664364025,
-0.1431719065,
0.4187219143,
0.3206498623,
-0.0056516482,
0.128902629,
-0.1846723557,
-0.2178324908,
-0.0011640822,
-0.0643533692,
-0.0183229819,
-0.5285297632,
-0.2375429571,
-0.0903164819,
0.4507955909,
0.5648483634,
-1.0126817226,
0.4298920631,
-0.2420594394,
-0.0752098039,
0.0209593307,
-0.2348675728,
0.340798974,
1.1013376713,
0.5319268107,
0.0504385754,
-0.4725727141,
-0.5888829827,
-0.3056475222,
-0.3857626021,
0.1898524612,
0.3070798814,
0.4825962782,
-0.5231288075,
0.9535540342,
-0.6307179928,
-0.1941059828,
-0.0848318785,
0.4989953935,
0.1117889136,
0.2503252029,
0.3337667584,
-0.7347784638,
-0.2721484005,
0.266269803,
-0.8246594667,
0.050237108,
0.105939962,
0.0415833034,
0.1068214998,
0.5325577259,
-0.6018320322,
0.7163459659,
0.2213970125,
-0.7964957952,
0.329430908,
-0.2669183016,
0.2191825658,
-0.6419503689,
0.1069751158,
0.1616526246,
-0.4700862169,
-0.5512747169,
-0.2691123188,
0.101752378,
0.0777141675,
0.0104509601,
0.1148992628,
-0.3594602048,
-0.0002312572,
-0.3492477834,
0.045232065,
0.1400902122,
0.4449534714,
0.0227406863,
0.2839618325,
0.246308133,
-0.3259914219,
0.5229012966,
0.5077694654,
-0.4317072928,
0.4276416302,
-0.6031883359,
0.0686192438,
-0.1979770958,
0.3716321886,
-0.8632419109,
-0.3523241282,
0.2204062045,
-0.3394576311,
0.223197937,
-0.2839711607,
-0.6879064441,
-0.4800308645,
0.0068087885,
-0.0749748796,
-0.0669328868,
-0.6952106357,
0.9500632882,
0.4559608698,
0.1767073125,
-0.7657164931,
-0.4448551834,
0.0161198787,
0.2385620922,
-0.7099838853,
0.4974704981,
0.2306959629,
-0.4530403316,
0.4419786334,
-0.459769845,
-0.1818358302,
-0.0429762714,
0.4401281774,
0.4017423391,
-0.3308042288,
0.2518921793,
-0.0770032257,
0.1231392175,
0.0444336236,
-0.4574487209,
0.3631010354,
-0.4009798765,
-0.4209288955,
-0.0809030309,
0.1812222153,
0.3945364356,
-0.1665568501,
0.8406763673,
0.5729782581,
-0.5223429203,
-0.1181626767,
-0.588988781,
-0.1493251324,
-0.3566111922,
0.375335753,
-0.3226409554,
-0.8731346726,
0.6059225202,
-0.2979519367,
0.0273092575,
0.6854120493,
0.6485924721,
0.0766885877,
0.7893500328,
0.4987376928,
0.0744640231,
0.2133358121,
-0.1484419703,
0.174311012,
-0.1991456896,
-0.5679719448,
-0.7327245474,
0.0741321594,
-0.3517934978,
-0.4096682966,
0.3831684589,
-0.3092879653,
-0.2695147097,
0.0453794003,
-0.3457405269,
0.595898211,
0.1826908886,
0.283886224,
0.6138857603,
0.1302554607,
-0.4228909612,
0.5386815667,
-0.8855335116,
-0.3374294043,
0.7106373906,
0.399101615,
0.7583507299,
-0.1062269434,
0.2391914129,
0.3977923393,
0.5005992651,
-0.414840579,
0.2699423134,
-0.1145057902,
-0.7244170308,
-0.5632630587,
-0.8484426141,
-0.720571816,
0.3504172862,
-0.5599902868,
-0.8058034778,
0.2451007962,
0.135443911,
-0.2632930875,
0.5960049033,
-0.632091105,
0.9044176936,
0.1439809054,
-0.6842957139,
-0.2303825021,
-0.7895969152,
0.4187857807,
0.2191768736,
0.2902468145,
-0.2200331241,
0.5729624629,
0.4344583154,
-0.60240376,
0.7016322017,
-0.1094315276,
-0.0643206239,
0.4689966142,
-0.0097871693,
0.7489926815,
0.4689162672,
-0.2608212531,
0.0571739413,
0.0080844685,
-0.2464062124,
-0.2798473835,
0.6850641966,
-0.6846475601,
-0.393140167,
-0.4118593931,
-0.8406576514,
-0.307141155,
0.4715638161,
0.5739302635,
0.6103293896,
-0.3773047626,
0.2319791466,
0.6949550509,
0.1780024469,
0.1697860956,
0.4391244948,
-0.0502907708,
-0.0939583555,
0.7421911359,
0.1039086059,
-0.1143481657,
0.4894898534,
0.4655385315,
-0.5546818376,
-0.3585128188,
-0.4654711485,
0.0429341272,
-0.8989447951,
-0.3141653836,
-1.0558351278,
-0.0729171038,
-0.4502005577,
0.4081932902,
-0.3314719498,
-0.3247152269,
0.0922653452,
-0.0963150859,
0.429358542,
0.7163283229,
-0.0229548551,
0.0026305765,
-0.6225892901,
0.6142694354,
0.3924686313,
0.8110455871,
-0.394375205,
-0.2768725455,
-0.2229228765,
0.1415777504,
0.0464468747,
-0.9965777397,
-0.2157338411,
0.0614687316,
0.6201993823,
0.3211962581,
0.1979356259,
0.1322393119,
-0.5024157763,
0.23843503,
0.1660684794,
-0.7963302135,
0.2860841155,
-0.2825091779,
-0.0880563557,
0.5367668271,
0.3840846419,
-0.4236263931,
-0.1296169162,
-0.726692915,
-0.5255740881,
0.7554932237,
0.10397055,
-0.3706393838,
0.2197955698,
0.2384168059,
-0.0452512652,
0.2251103967,
-0.6749531031,
-0.1627583057,
-0.8432031274,
-0.119704552,
0.2096585333,
-0.1287697703,
-0.6180992126,
-0.2656723559,
0.5862647295,
-0.6162751317,
0.1944710463,
0.3291527331,
-0.0019155908,
-0.2632793188,
0.3422926664,
0.2749407291,
0.4452170432,
-0.4144956768,
0.7457433343,
0.1739634871,
-0.5961649418,
0.0009064003,
0.6636682749,
-0.1522817016,
0.200245589,
0.514040947,
0.762029767,
-0.0612802841,
-0.1944313496,
0.4124169648,
-0.1608291417,
-0.4872690737,
0.3888428211,
-0.110216856,
0.1937971115,
0.0938612372,
0.0485208109,
0.0147052109,
0.0968777761,
-0.9744290113,
0.2608357072,
0.2716857493,
-0.1720306873,
-0.0612444207,
0.5152471066,
0.0362628326,
0.0961195454,
0.7714443803,
-0.3072774112,
-0.7563447952,
0.5691190362,
0.5354856253,
0.3723092079,
0.0660108402,
0.3991252184,
0.3294838369,
0.2767927051,
-0.1404976547,
0.1637826264,
-0.0248337667,
-1.0953880548,
-0.4450446367,
-0.36183846,
-0.4167073965,
0.1612795442,
0.0250075366,
-0.2809353769,
-0.5521118045,
-0.1820638925,
0.6317867637,
0.0131781669,
-0.3870114386,
0.311621815,
-0.073949039,
0.6577042937,
-0.9924398065,
0.8353816271,
0.6327017546,
-0.438864857,
-1.0501008034,
0.0887340233,
0.0495335534,
-0.6221590042,
0.5334377885,
-0.0764240399,
-0.2065181881,
-0.2960579693,
-0.7577556372,
-0.64055264,
0.6672617793,
0.384027034,
-0.1957066208,
0.029258199,
0.0773747489,
0.3422648609,
-0.3698217571,
0.1243846864,
0.5259615183,
0.8350464702,
0.4071389735,
-0.4814701676,
0.2242701948,
-0.2627832592,
-0.3551529348,
-0.0732454732,
-0.2816826701,
1.1521232128,
-0.4186557531,
-0.3925636411,
-0.4427900016,
0.8096286058,
0.0321930945,
0.7077966928,
0.6971361041,
0.6738319993,
0.9994348884,
-0.2969499826,
1.1365711689,
-0.2509948015,
0.5522279143,
1.2936593294,
-0.7133255601,
0.1692242026,
0.2031713277,
-0.0330971628,
0.9841752648,
0.5343101621,
-0.1727599502,
0.3256345987,
0.0041363956,
-0.1313941032,
-0.366653055,
-0.5483433604,
-0.3058388233,
0.3842446208,
0.1570480764,
-0.0424049683,
-0.6270269156,
-0.2767809629,
0.1388688534,
0.2995927632,
-0.0252616163,
0.4448219538,
-0.3629082441,
-0.7830200195,
0.4056175351,
0.36950773,
0.1870090216,
-0.4615481198,
-0.1888282299,
0.0408508107,
0.1370714009,
-0.6047149897,
-1.0663086176,
0.2247749865,
0.0302216597,
-0.2505328953,
0.0306025259,
1.2377802134,
-0.4917410314,
-0.0616457611,
0.0793129504,
0.6212777495,
-0.2992807925,
-0.2243166566,
-0.4523153305,
-0.0867950469,
-0.0162887089,
-0.14017874,
-0.0158706196,
0.7407535911,
-0.0749362409,
0.4168058038,
0.8284532428,
-0.1828212142,
-0.4236792624,
0.3302262127,
1.0143071413,
-0.2089348435,
-0.8566599488,
-0.7295742631,
0.062712945,
-0.2823772728,
-0.0370699838,
0.8852886558,
0.6421086192,
0.4555575848,
0.2190351486,
0.7366034985,
-0.1691044271,
0.2737310827,
-0.5315553546,
0.711982131,
-0.2459798455,
-0.1008453518,
-0.3549527526,
-0.5193040371,
-0.1569368392,
0.6269908547,
-0.4425699413,
-0.0798763558,
0.8814124465,
0.4693301618,
-0.2132463008,
0.5318157077,
0.0181339271,
0.4275240898,
0.0794526115,
0.3608105183,
0.9181014299,
-0.0720177069,
0.3284483254,
-0.1219616607,
-0.0626731142,
-0.2972514927,
-0.9931147695,
-0.9752432108,
-0.4031220675,
-0.4753651917,
-1.0110602379,
-0.0879449323,
0.664047122,
0.7500601411,
-0.5950115919,
0.2400331497,
-0.2160549313,
0.7164895535,
0.0990993083,
-0.1781744063,
0.5832470059,
-0.0377930552,
-0.0247937553,
0.3010352254,
0.3123766184,
-0.0616088025,
0.229923889,
0.0368247516,
-0.739770174,
0.1223542839,
0.4596256912,
0.3149856329,
-0.4095652997,
-0.5812832117,
-0.2359400988,
-0.4287454784,
0.2878915071,
0.9739723206,
-0.6923354268,
0.2296934277,
0.7394878864,
0.5593454242,
0.7522369623,
0.0646917894,
0.1129529178,
-0.7267650962,
0.156814903,
0.2210820764,
0.6077998281,
0.3821140528,
-0.709338963,
0.4726940095,
0.6999209523,
-0.3317095637,
-0.7918998003,
0.2283006757,
-0.8008915186,
-0.6335374713,
0.9496497512,
-0.2208360732,
-0.4134870768,
-0.4501905739,
0.1761151403,
0.7121083736,
-0.2371460497,
0.7997332215,
0.6883991361,
-0.0536658391,
0.2545409501,
-0.1884071082,
0.5411471725,
0.1775266677,
-1.24233675,
0.3134400845,
0.7193498015,
0.3460732996,
0.4891653657,
0.5370137691,
-0.0978128985,
0.2907907665,
0.3966267407,
-0.0380641855,
-0.4222820103,
-0.5395915508,
0.2702591121,
0.487344712,
-0.3830815554,
0.1039014012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13025v1
|
CFEVER: A Chinese Fact Extraction and VERification Dataset
| 2024-02-20T14:08:24 | 2024-02-20T14:08:24 |
Ying-Jia Lin, Chun-Yi Lin, Chia-Jen Yeh, Yi-Ting Li, Yun-Yu Hu, Chih-Hao Hsu, Mei-Feng Lee, Hung-Yu Kao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present CFEVER, a Chinese dataset designed for Fact Extraction and
VERification. CFEVER comprises 30,012 manually created claims based on content
in Chinese Wikipedia. Each claim in CFEVER is labeled as "Supports", "Refutes",
or "Not Enough Info" to depict its degree of factualness. Similar to the FEVER
dataset, claims in the "Supports" and "Refutes" categories are also annotated
with corresponding evidence sentences sourced from single or multiple pages in
Chinese Wikipedia. Our labeled dataset holds a Fleiss' kappa value of 0.7934
for five-way inter-annotator agreement. In addition, through the experiments
with the state-of-the-art approaches developed on the FEVER dataset and a
simple baseline for CFEVER, we demonstrate that our dataset is a new rigorous
benchmark for factual extraction and verification, which can be further used
for developing automated systems to alleviate human fact-checking efforts.
CFEVER is available at https://ikmlab.github.io/CFEVER.
|
[
-0.4859157205,
-0.4982003272,
0.2941525578,
0.3312488198,
-0.2213116288,
-0.4226885438,
-0.2934994698,
-0.5167298913,
0.0600989349,
0.2738642991,
-0.2590953708,
-0.3558553457,
-0.3283061087,
0.4691269696,
-0.6066022515,
1.1182765961,
0.239419505,
-0.1008974463,
-0.0912622437,
0.0279600359,
0.0220472105,
-0.2084204555,
-0.3730318248,
-0.2178404331,
0.6622819304,
0.7811346054,
0.7186469436,
0.6418027878,
0.5051799417,
0.2780556083,
0.5161448717,
0.3851958811,
-0.463766247,
-0.2879599631,
-0.1308079362,
-0.0675631389,
-0.1208548248,
0.1529078633,
0.5369822979,
0.2453609407,
-0.1743498445,
0.3854211867,
-0.1581238061,
0.2581131756,
-0.5465810299,
0.0516770035,
-0.5759353042,
0.0928687081,
-0.4788156152,
0.0510066226,
-0.2763305008,
-0.4847355485,
0.3563271463,
-0.7770177722,
0.6239976287,
0.1543141454,
1.1816209555,
0.0573739745,
-0.3720331788,
-0.1206232309,
-0.3937093616,
0.2856588662,
-0.7168850303,
0.5800670981,
0.2054680735,
0.3276022673,
-0.0884660333,
-1.054693222,
-0.9181770086,
-0.2503603101,
-0.3627136946,
0.0308729187,
0.0412906148,
-0.2038838118,
0.2928746939,
0.5819733739,
-0.4672805071,
-0.263594538,
-0.5795262456,
-0.6498672366,
0.9771361351,
-0.1882064939,
0.5424236655,
-0.4909999967,
-0.5979047418,
0.0265969578,
-0.6780648232,
0.0579404645,
-0.12026871,
0.2554299533,
-0.0295886286,
0.5084388256,
-0.3349588215,
0.4373969734,
0.272751987,
-0.2030954659,
0.3251361847,
-0.3463012278,
-0.4812506735,
0.5426782966,
0.9606150389,
0.2709655762,
0.0454962179,
-0.3019003272,
-0.2330090106,
-0.6264941692,
0.0547221713,
-0.8170499802,
-0.6279035211,
0.2847745121,
-0.6058728695,
-0.4064077139,
0.7840955853,
-0.8381994963,
-0.7882546782,
-0.1533105224,
0.2610230744,
-0.526556015,
-0.7393448949,
-0.1064795926,
-0.3940697908,
0.5258983374,
0.1990254968,
-0.5747456551,
-0.0318942405,
0.8063287735,
0.7675155401,
-0.0064863279,
-0.4185138047,
-0.394559741,
-0.1917527467,
-0.5866597891,
1.0760176182,
-0.2494892627,
-0.2286812514,
-0.0506036542,
0.1660697162,
0.1995645911,
-0.5077496171,
1.0291153193,
-0.3863584399,
0.2471310794,
-0.9014529586,
-0.5866349936,
-0.2825915217,
0.3774605393,
-0.9267114401,
1.1536638737,
-0.035284508,
-1.0744944811,
0.4196688831,
-0.5329348445,
-0.5393486619,
0.1563345641,
-0.2765492499,
-0.1254020035,
-0.0328308344,
0.0241552573,
0.3900316656,
-0.4041216075,
0.4437430203,
-0.3966445923,
-0.2401598841,
0.4029776752,
-0.4722435474,
1.0097541809,
0.4298423231,
-0.4118186831,
-0.1946363449,
-1.0175893307,
-0.3162466288,
0.2412370294,
-0.4405083358,
-0.2709151506,
0.0504842289,
0.0858519301,
0.3245302439,
0.3704288602,
-0.9634227753,
0.0935105532,
-0.1873525232,
-0.0481102169,
0.6316248775,
-0.025463853,
-0.0946522951,
-0.2416509241,
-0.0465089679,
0.0995734632,
0.1401049048,
-0.1562247425,
-0.2323628068,
-0.929667592,
-0.1660826802,
0.4536510408,
0.6427653432,
-0.8498526216,
0.3582877517,
-0.2870182097,
-0.7469902635,
-0.2888530791,
0.130794391,
0.0118824886,
1.0054421425,
0.3902161419,
0.2798909545,
-0.6621319056,
-0.936632812,
0.0122682694,
-0.4475301206,
-0.2382493764,
-0.1469753385,
0.3303126991,
0.0178969484,
1.2075637579,
-0.4513419867,
-0.1944144517,
0.0541914515,
0.0447863378,
0.2561759353,
0.2964664698,
0.8062427044,
-1.1549506187,
-0.2983523607,
0.272973299,
-1.0466196537,
-0.0651421025,
-0.2645817697,
-0.3200745285,
0.2323531657,
0.3201373219,
-0.3781937361,
0.3030411005,
0.2086810172,
-0.3701100349,
0.7921256423,
0.069355242,
0.3289033175,
-0.7778346539,
0.4418793023,
0.2662325799,
-0.1658798605,
-0.6251116991,
-0.0940088332,
0.1747096181,
0.2184516937,
-0.4994272292,
0.3577793241,
-0.1781285554,
0.3216399848,
-0.2374216467,
0.0916793197,
0.005103407,
0.30601722,
0.2126910537,
0.4967613518,
0.5447679162,
-0.651161015,
0.890108645,
0.1040110737,
-0.3626327217,
0.7357190847,
-0.4752466381,
-0.2308910787,
0.0872841179,
0.323600024,
-0.8760784864,
-0.4446285963,
0.7077841759,
-0.3649166226,
-0.0721158683,
0.1289535761,
-0.6679019332,
-0.4273711145,
-0.4038461149,
-0.053995613,
0.0500750095,
-0.9340664744,
0.4767745435,
0.3293125629,
0.0449049659,
-0.7920950651,
-0.5227006674,
0.1195839718,
-0.2469180524,
-0.5223420858,
0.1881545782,
-0.0298033394,
-0.3313833177,
0.0771402121,
-0.3372710943,
-0.3372510076,
0.0799975842,
0.1596838981,
0.3888832033,
-0.627440989,
0.2037937492,
-0.141805619,
0.0469346605,
0.3730549216,
-0.4508901238,
-0.0889327377,
-0.128873229,
-0.2105936706,
-0.3395789862,
0.0697792843,
0.1202293262,
-0.0513952933,
0.4478657544,
0.8650351167,
-0.9153632522,
0.1423133612,
-0.6774238944,
0.0089396723,
-0.4943996966,
0.0691962317,
-0.1909444928,
-0.411552459,
0.3265140951,
0.1710482389,
0.7615605593,
1.0308488607,
0.2003865689,
-0.0725819841,
0.5869268179,
0.3699629605,
-0.2648038268,
0.0642445087,
0.0708314851,
-0.0545477718,
-0.115661718,
-0.4659225345,
-0.6022507548,
-0.1023218855,
-0.4203062356,
-0.2448880374,
0.0154447276,
-0.1588011384,
-0.340603739,
0.1251900643,
-0.3879760802,
0.4522134662,
0.4109736383,
0.2012365758,
0.2915199101,
-0.0550732277,
0.0138110267,
0.0256624464,
-0.749134779,
-0.3279186487,
0.7573831081,
0.1062661037,
0.2554037571,
0.1884890944,
0.5080654621,
0.6667119861,
0.8272537589,
-0.3695224822,
0.4279532135,
-0.1811991632,
-1.0304454565,
-0.3434182703,
-0.5118350387,
-0.6442024112,
0.2049577683,
-0.4960594475,
-0.4618362486,
0.2814878225,
0.0021080379,
-0.4344865084,
0.3781349361,
-0.5088364482,
0.762616396,
-0.4801084399,
-0.2326648831,
0.0067057121,
-0.50916785,
0.7961869836,
-0.1392731965,
0.3237935901,
-0.2463808805,
0.1069722623,
0.7784523368,
-0.6502984166,
0.6917952299,
-0.400582552,
-0.5191953182,
0.5378100276,
-0.1182730347,
0.0438432507,
0.5473619103,
-0.40341869,
0.3958351314,
0.2344503403,
-0.3478068113,
-0.2758671939,
0.687630713,
-0.6070010066,
-0.5793565512,
-0.742107749,
0.0897117779,
0.1106744334,
0.6430966854,
0.3918780982,
0.459971875,
-0.590020597,
0.1524111629,
0.8576014638,
-0.3648887873,
0.2208819389,
0.4985905588,
-0.2709088027,
-0.4911755621,
1.3315265179,
0.1866526008,
-0.3408066034,
0.3873342276,
0.3845098913,
-0.3673236072,
-0.1308083087,
-0.3926851749,
0.1970261633,
-0.9268382192,
-0.3949705362,
-0.313307941,
-0.4832847416,
-0.5758327842,
0.0793585256,
-0.3190339804,
-0.3725516796,
-0.1245188266,
-0.4080083668,
0.4363959432,
0.6811395288,
-0.4853610992,
-0.0484244302,
-0.8763759136,
0.675513804,
0.1196842268,
0.4184802175,
-0.1868458688,
-0.2751004696,
-0.4413067698,
0.1373803467,
-0.2579365671,
-0.8645712137,
-0.1154043749,
0.2443326712,
0.7726810575,
1.1447901726,
0.5232257843,
0.7779116631,
-0.2401605397,
0.9853700399,
0.1696247607,
-0.8479150534,
0.3856660128,
-0.1078064069,
-0.2100120783,
0.5274418592,
0.4161410332,
-0.7216438055,
-0.1672281772,
-0.8627998829,
-0.4354147911,
0.6965007186,
0.1201404035,
-0.1381427497,
-0.0275302939,
0.6042805314,
0.3837111592,
-0.1513593197,
-0.3953282535,
-0.5814321041,
-0.6592283845,
-0.2571957111,
0.0689982399,
-0.2033177018,
-0.116296187,
-0.2255147994,
0.7837648988,
-0.0772190243,
0.1019955277,
0.6647375822,
-0.1970798671,
0.077949211,
-0.1616636217,
0.5255725384,
0.7069719434,
-0.1641251445,
0.3371293545,
0.2977281213,
-0.4631749094,
-0.1803336889,
0.5293406844,
-0.1953365356,
0.3980181217,
0.471349597,
0.2054923326,
0.2651385665,
-0.627664566,
0.4189705253,
-0.3530906737,
-0.2628760338,
-0.4276898503,
0.1692440361,
-0.1868039221,
0.0847780779,
0.6639975309,
-0.068643339,
0.4056476057,
-0.0447302647,
0.7044798136,
-0.0462171622,
-0.1658844203,
-0.4522147179,
0.7160806656,
0.4263651371,
0.2221123725,
0.8028084636,
0.0521276258,
-0.370683223,
0.6418740749,
0.0964965299,
0.4537106752,
-0.0604918413,
0.5204903483,
0.7486191392,
0.4028241038,
-0.265979737,
0.04106462,
-0.1152224913,
-0.7217942476,
0.0643682629,
-0.2809062004,
-0.3547564745,
0.1730783433,
-0.4990249872,
0.6309637427,
-0.4745247662,
0.0501107462,
0.2752547562,
0.3315675557,
-0.5644850731,
0.4118134677,
0.5961250067,
1.5240187645,
-0.673856616,
0.8011879921,
0.4251558781,
-0.5527812243,
-0.7264535427,
0.1491111517,
0.3525926173,
-0.4784954488,
0.2864254415,
0.332803607,
0.0556022823,
-0.2934771478,
-0.8662016392,
-0.6899518967,
1.0872638226,
0.5016074777,
-0.1853067726,
0.1533804536,
0.1401753277,
0.2475411594,
-0.1927375793,
-0.1246278137,
0.6130225062,
0.8081252575,
0.0893580392,
-0.598562777,
0.3098585904,
-0.3729591966,
-0.6036149859,
-0.2974715233,
-0.8899042606,
0.5446645617,
-0.2980076075,
-0.4055811465,
-0.0816839784,
1.2618671656,
0.3969121873,
0.6269782782,
0.8001214266,
0.0314742662,
1.2529126406,
-0.1438768506,
0.7752962112,
-0.1599627286,
0.3330060542,
0.8366785645,
-0.2302947789,
0.5613210201,
0.1274323761,
0.0417471863,
0.5147817731,
1.0038846731,
-0.2732935548,
0.1617925465,
-0.0716327503,
-0.0661653057,
-0.3414402008,
-0.059081655,
-0.5561034679,
0.36905393,
0.4402927458,
-0.1801238805,
-0.2677240074,
-0.2460360676,
0.4012347758,
-0.3000332713,
-0.0998994112,
0.6135777831,
-0.1235538349,
-0.876398623,
0.4806806743,
0.1024221554,
0.4877910316,
-0.5880046487,
-0.1128618047,
-0.4181743562,
-0.1427759379,
-0.6656659842,
-0.7775791883,
0.1260393262,
0.2992085516,
-0.0749530122,
0.3353519738,
0.9469138384,
-0.3945418894,
-0.7252123356,
-0.287307322,
0.1006328762,
0.1869716048,
0.0170648005,
-0.643563807,
-0.2420176864,
0.1643671542,
-0.2255163342,
-0.1371079832,
0.9308101535,
0.0729757473,
0.376409471,
0.8185712099,
0.0548809841,
0.0674709529,
-0.2801902592,
0.7139760256,
-0.7123034,
-0.3110641241,
-0.9028199911,
0.3478169441,
-0.5168952346,
-0.2428478897,
0.895069778,
0.8508408666,
0.6593705416,
0.2059217989,
1.1701430082,
-0.6658298373,
0.1719363779,
-0.3016313612,
0.8684355617,
-0.4913026094,
-0.0379997715,
-0.1521161497,
-0.3495740891,
-0.3493157923,
0.4782353938,
0.2745299041,
-0.3677702248,
0.4725600183,
0.5662490129,
-0.178673476,
0.4835938215,
-0.0055468995,
0.2121668756,
0.505915761,
0.3103188574,
0.6814211607,
-0.3647004366,
0.7630777359,
-0.6148335338,
-0.2381190658,
-0.2887889445,
-1.0111713409,
-0.6583867669,
-0.6946564913,
-0.474247545,
-0.5392639041,
-0.278996557,
1.0066449642,
0.6310275197,
-1.010350585,
-0.0437882319,
0.4181300402,
0.3852076828,
-0.4469829202,
-0.2214058787,
0.5078426003,
-0.2246614099,
-0.4318206012,
0.1577124,
-0.0851767883,
-0.1324883699,
-0.2475572228,
-0.2472006381,
-0.2815101445,
0.2499280572,
0.3398759067,
0.7708444595,
-0.5418354273,
-0.4692822099,
0.0161599927,
-0.1895249933,
0.0889663547,
0.9163451791,
-0.5533397198,
0.3338842392,
0.5531560183,
0.7490051389,
-0.1691160351,
0.0743199214,
0.4654155076,
-0.7740457654,
-0.1085228026,
-0.4770793319,
0.4662209153,
0.3885698318,
-0.5320897698,
0.5271328688,
0.5122251511,
-0.2913273573,
-0.8166753054,
-0.3256731033,
-0.8928753138,
-0.1791876704,
0.9689075947,
-0.2439512908,
-0.19667992,
-0.1778517812,
-0.253521204,
0.4720982313,
-0.3613207042,
1.0251579285,
0.9582220316,
-0.0328468271,
0.007562459,
-0.2345293909,
0.6596231461,
-0.287489742,
-0.8466982841,
0.4149861932,
0.6564078927,
0.5488967299,
0.2161865234,
0.5580028892,
0.0860340595,
0.6504398584,
-0.0343806222,
-0.019964315,
-0.1126927584,
-0.2428836077,
0.1036161035,
0.2498666346,
-0.2253497541,
-0.1846818626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13022v1
|
SoMeLVLM: A Large Vision Language Model for Social Media Processing
| 2024-02-20T14:02:45 | 2024-02-20T14:02:45 |
Xinnong Zhang, Haoyu Kuang, Xinyi Mou, Hanjia Lyu, Kun Wu, Siming Chen, Jiebo Luo, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
The growth of social media, characterized by its multimodal nature, has led
to the emergence of diverse phenomena and challenges, which calls for an
effective approach to uniformly solve automated tasks. The powerful Large
Vision Language Models make it possible to handle a variety of tasks
simultaneously, but even with carefully designed prompting methods, the general
domain models often fall short in aligning with the unique speaking style and
context of social media tasks. In this paper, we introduce a Large Vision
Language Model for Social Media Processing (SoMeLVLM), which is a cognitive
framework equipped with five key capabilities including knowledge &
comprehension, application, analysis, evaluation, and creation. SoMeLVLM is
designed to understand and generate realistic social media behavior. We have
developed a 654k multimodal social media instruction-tuning dataset to support
our cognitive framework and fine-tune our model. Our experiments demonstrate
that SoMeLVLM achieves state-of-the-art performance in multiple social media
tasks. Further analysis shows its significant advantages over baselines in
terms of cognitive abilities.
|
[
-0.3891314268,
-1.2430022955,
0.5835048556,
0.2240397483,
-0.2759259343,
0.0812982246,
-0.4246889651,
-0.3518430889,
0.1547704935,
0.3332843184,
-0.8181917071,
-0.4206320047,
-0.7139710784,
-0.3915531933,
-0.4750370085,
0.674696207,
0.3787758648,
0.1839917749,
0.0376067534,
-0.1109371781,
-0.4757652879,
-0.2964960635,
-0.7981469631,
0.0348302759,
0.689471066,
0.3170700371,
0.5926838517,
0.5070964098,
0.5857384801,
0.3435659111,
0.1436287761,
0.4640259445,
-0.9796428084,
-0.0631434917,
-0.3025155067,
-0.176456511,
-0.4597596824,
-0.2393727899,
0.7522340417,
0.2724345326,
-0.0989762098,
0.4912730157,
-0.0510470979,
0.7338564396,
-0.5960186124,
0.1126895919,
-0.8166308999,
-0.2713232338,
-0.1034637764,
-0.1481523812,
-0.2841247618,
-0.1789970249,
0.0347820111,
-0.619741559,
-0.0419613011,
0.1485916376,
0.5146943927,
0.2978152037,
-0.1026644185,
-0.0527759604,
-0.7572804093,
0.9498642683,
-0.482278645,
0.6035910845,
0.4158940613,
0.8003503084,
0.3426995575,
-0.8459192514,
-0.7983493805,
0.0947518572,
0.3313621283,
-0.0885593891,
-0.1083901748,
-0.0605506748,
0.1340252459,
-0.1802554578,
-0.5336188078,
-0.1015027165,
-0.6295921206,
-0.0044563725,
0.5967279673,
0.2768111527,
0.1769756526,
-0.2817393243,
-0.2586793303,
0.1804386675,
-0.1376936436,
0.1896936297,
-0.2257124484,
0.2134194821,
-0.1228904575,
0.6289058924,
-0.4874365032,
0.8650922775,
-0.2710208595,
-0.2096887082,
0.0646341592,
-0.2687233388,
-0.4573692083,
-0.2528665066,
0.4842732251,
0.9015272856,
0.6585481167,
0.1627438962,
-0.1063086614,
0.3234646618,
0.5199959278,
-0.5804237127,
-0.0457910039,
0.2197354585,
-0.8253220916,
-0.1456850469,
-0.1711077541,
-0.3608876467,
-0.4314202964,
-0.5094089508,
0.3224663436,
-0.6650445461,
-0.2461424768,
0.0628336892,
-0.0867581069,
0.196318984,
0.5784612298,
-0.6738902926,
-0.1050498486,
0.6756128669,
0.7649888992,
-0.3112903833,
-0.3661302626,
-0.5554451346,
0.1253992021,
-0.2663884163,
0.6504454017,
-0.8069236279,
-0.0577528067,
0.3923275173,
0.0273498241,
-0.1429836601,
0.0280651599,
0.174804002,
-0.8554704189,
-0.3531555831,
-0.402908057,
-0.6583033204,
-0.2983088493,
0.6003153324,
-0.4967366755,
0.7223929167,
-0.0326287374,
-0.5237064958,
0.3554686904,
-0.5508543849,
-0.3707105815,
0.5267335176,
-0.1642102897,
-0.041508846,
-0.0580211766,
0.0792940482,
0.9036225677,
-0.3262919188,
0.059510015,
-0.571398139,
-0.3030492365,
0.4571321607,
-0.3767624199,
0.7566228509,
0.3279187977,
0.0598147772,
0.3482102454,
-0.7852185965,
0.1760183722,
0.0746137202,
-0.3522414565,
-0.4050374627,
0.0495868362,
0.4031358063,
0.4766770303,
0.4044406712,
-0.4654677808,
0.0841475353,
0.1043602079,
0.6474022269,
0.655934453,
0.0534174368,
0.4657961726,
-0.2791463435,
0.220416531,
-0.1690157801,
0.6603603959,
-0.15125148,
-0.5817031264,
-0.5984269977,
-0.3291718662,
-0.227468729,
0.4027384818,
-1.2528049946,
-0.1598258913,
-0.3592155874,
-0.5112149715,
-0.8367247581,
0.6688264012,
0.285956651,
0.1043729708,
0.2886497974,
0.0139214434,
-0.5574498177,
-0.7733383775,
0.0533832461,
0.0696010739,
0.1060020253,
0.3691776395,
0.2290467024,
-0.3675012887,
0.8495014906,
-0.3696829081,
-0.5909811258,
-0.4182423353,
-0.1187976152,
-0.1293224394,
0.0858583227,
0.5669273734,
-1.2215466499,
-0.448318392,
-0.0382830836,
-1.0426139832,
0.1962456852,
-0.063339971,
-0.2778634429,
0.1862855852,
0.5914019346,
-0.5205391049,
0.1529417187,
0.6666895747,
-0.1041012853,
0.1545244604,
-0.0518356077,
0.2131216228,
-0.9571686983,
-0.2632692754,
0.3530519009,
-0.2788968384,
-0.7220032215,
0.0346435085,
0.2168618888,
0.0206210017,
-1.1392928362,
0.4654480517,
-0.2786037922,
0.0008918975,
-0.3218142688,
0.2099082619,
-0.2177940309,
0.4436452389,
-0.067383267,
0.0806103572,
0.8982079029,
-0.741517365,
0.7954583168,
-0.0662233904,
-0.3511716127,
0.7188209891,
-0.4714538157,
0.005693981,
-0.4038448632,
-0.0952953473,
-1.243413806,
-0.3482552171,
-0.0672449693,
-0.3872765899,
0.0991367847,
0.0710750744,
-0.5878334641,
-0.4908834696,
-0.3050594032,
0.3188211918,
0.4661593139,
-0.3265911937,
0.7200026512,
0.4680104554,
0.187145099,
-0.2660807371,
-0.5791223645,
0.0475369133,
-0.0332732685,
-0.8566753268,
0.1650490463,
-0.1297186017,
-0.1809173077,
0.2395083755,
0.4471623898,
0.0911389813,
-0.2509093583,
0.180982843,
0.3463914394,
-0.216079995,
0.1661862582,
-0.2233697623,
0.1041263938,
-0.2949590385,
-0.2240512967,
0.6067737341,
-0.108746998,
-0.2994859815,
-0.3872695565,
0.2477217317,
0.7519951463,
-0.4004597664,
0.6945288777,
0.8444170356,
-0.4194837809,
-0.4387161136,
-0.7304540277,
-0.1238447502,
-0.5053441525,
0.4342363477,
-0.1914169639,
-1.074182868,
0.3741590083,
0.1340512037,
0.2298651189,
0.0277232584,
0.8413104415,
-0.3215783834,
1.2354969978,
0.7848978043,
0.014318848,
0.8954179287,
-0.1485658437,
0.0154308481,
-0.5291905999,
-0.0383998528,
0.1652595699,
-0.2923765779,
-0.4494585395,
-0.6249010563,
0.2301275134,
-0.2769510448,
-0.1089146212,
0.2371027023,
-0.425214082,
0.444714576,
0.5472364426,
0.1589585394,
0.1633003205,
0.0606524833,
0.2269096822,
-0.0788856149,
-0.7245821357,
-0.4232728779,
0.7195401788,
0.3400644064,
0.8877159953,
0.1524718702,
0.2007717341,
0.6830840111,
0.3026629984,
-0.7516824603,
0.8149346113,
-0.580727756,
-0.7763894796,
-0.5020104051,
-0.0305415448,
-0.5920497179,
0.3222200274,
-0.5468268394,
-0.8618038297,
-0.0804707557,
0.3401368558,
-0.3076455891,
0.0631032214,
-0.6550783515,
0.8210210204,
-0.2699300647,
-0.5721052289,
-0.430159986,
-0.6208447814,
0.5944285393,
-0.0917712301,
0.3685468137,
-0.1861592382,
0.2983929813,
0.4845949113,
0.1484636813,
1.2744727135,
-0.1568496823,
0.116973117,
0.4025277793,
-0.0740316659,
0.406154573,
-0.1289267093,
0.05055812,
0.0256123953,
0.1830232143,
-0.32613644,
-0.55585289,
0.7744032741,
-0.5297927856,
-0.3474761844,
0.0775963962,
-0.5612306595,
-0.090588145,
0.2266960591,
0.1881554425,
0.2455450147,
-0.3461913466,
0.4886478782,
0.4542084336,
-0.2368635237,
0.6514809132,
0.5632811189,
-0.3904394209,
-0.0207604878,
1.2887206078,
0.3954049051,
0.1704624742,
0.2320244461,
-0.1694408953,
-0.2955333292,
-0.2435173094,
-0.4451233149,
0.1131483689,
-1.1061675549,
0.0537788384,
-0.6541904807,
-0.3182241619,
-0.4946376979,
-0.2604378164,
-0.3197804987,
-0.1642996818,
-0.0351458006,
0.0903868377,
0.2677019835,
0.5877321959,
0.3845382631,
0.4365957081,
-0.8712415099,
0.674480319,
0.4776921272,
0.3060366213,
0.2606194019,
-0.3253841102,
-0.3421019912,
0.048046656,
-0.1371562481,
-0.8585996032,
0.3546537459,
0.3326092958,
0.7003688812,
0.5674996972,
0.0016551396,
0.602419138,
-0.6995610595,
0.6438177824,
0.1854958087,
-0.6390273571,
0.447601974,
-0.3408686221,
0.3477269709,
0.2839849591,
0.3601890802,
-0.6374474764,
-0.4602407813,
-0.4337364137,
-0.5962637067,
0.5828956962,
0.2186546177,
0.373568207,
-0.1548793465,
0.1462856084,
-0.4321144521,
0.2578804791,
-0.7015179396,
-0.1216472983,
-0.4539847374,
-0.219698444,
0.0362548158,
-0.2889759243,
-0.0733429641,
-0.3525395989,
0.4068447053,
-0.1497782469,
-0.0087371022,
-0.2387718856,
-0.4601762891,
-0.2269942909,
0.1103918627,
0.6015883684,
0.9066072106,
0.006632071,
0.1892282218,
0.1841878444,
-0.2116016895,
-0.2930258512,
-0.1247355416,
-0.2634714544,
-0.252019316,
0.4169001579,
0.8571720719,
0.1667311937,
-0.7195195556,
0.4320788085,
-0.1532099843,
-0.2750807703,
-0.2028874457,
0.2880102992,
0.3775249422,
0.646105051,
0.6667862535,
-0.0826806948,
0.1137528047,
-0.7102957964,
0.2046086043,
0.4926629663,
-0.4402161241,
-0.1120918542,
0.7334035039,
0.0876838192,
-0.5142667294,
0.2320569903,
-0.2445915341,
-0.4758552313,
0.4214116335,
0.4143398702,
0.5309886932,
-0.1332742721,
0.4063489139,
0.0758369118,
0.3725497425,
-0.0843728259,
0.4901807606,
-0.0112592839,
-0.944865942,
-0.5407229662,
-0.9728714228,
-0.0631650239,
0.1075390875,
-0.4536229074,
0.1892263144,
-0.5429104567,
-0.3269460499,
0.6354617476,
-0.4796335697,
-0.8442198634,
0.5036866069,
0.2804366648,
0.4087192118,
-0.8610338569,
1.1303944588,
0.8634443283,
-0.2320246845,
-0.4795351028,
-0.2797469199,
0.3161321282,
-1.0164705515,
0.8518815637,
0.1521190107,
-0.0694224238,
0.1845057309,
-0.6542420387,
-0.6828792691,
0.8194868565,
0.1315725297,
-0.7960236669,
0.0832247809,
0.1084975749,
0.7375354171,
-0.5901763439,
-0.3462602794,
0.3929623067,
0.3920252323,
0.2852512002,
-0.626240015,
0.1394586712,
-0.3144948483,
0.4812833965,
-0.2855883539,
-0.7171304226,
0.7363834381,
-0.1224268675,
-0.115152061,
-0.4856075644,
0.5399616957,
0.2735489011,
0.4458608925,
0.6091475487,
-0.0594839528,
0.513428688,
0.1520946324,
1.013499856,
-0.3071327209,
0.2316512614,
0.8335074186,
-0.2273958623,
1.0432878733,
0.4419300854,
0.132631138,
-0.0737147257,
0.5197612047,
-0.1342262775,
0.5881067514,
-0.1013512984,
-0.1614666134,
-0.6606509686,
-0.2724988759,
0.0334758162,
0.5658935308,
0.5648258328,
-0.4805000722,
-0.0379162729,
0.4447466731,
-0.5826157331,
0.0513472855,
-0.5209614635,
0.7441046834,
0.2923331261,
-0.6370321512,
0.593888104,
0.0098918872,
0.717711091,
-0.5182787776,
-0.051892437,
0.2527253628,
0.2838588357,
-0.2555523813,
-0.8952682018,
0.3891088963,
0.0348671451,
-0.3049493134,
-0.2267430574,
1.0379583836,
-0.4452339113,
-0.7630051374,
0.5279160738,
0.5014717579,
-0.0220103767,
-0.0593095608,
-0.8432126045,
0.28090927,
-0.0656445324,
-0.3786087632,
0.2204561681,
0.5559339523,
-0.4387428761,
0.7987554073,
0.8608061671,
0.1045749635,
0.3215124905,
0.5475563407,
0.847524941,
-0.4967140853,
-0.5771127343,
-1.0977860689,
0.4243172705,
-0.2378370762,
-0.2015470117,
0.7385211587,
0.1013700664,
0.7381519675,
0.0065426454,
0.9332089424,
-0.2535738051,
0.323866725,
-0.5485463142,
0.7941231132,
-0.855455637,
0.1438351572,
-0.3690562248,
-0.905708909,
-0.3306606114,
0.683041513,
-0.2379787564,
0.0573908128,
0.3913668692,
0.7433438301,
-0.1887105852,
-0.0987525433,
0.8491945863,
0.2278354913,
0.175899446,
0.2195065916,
0.7695889473,
0.1327727139,
0.607783556,
-0.1327858567,
-0.1370849907,
-0.5166127682,
-0.676617682,
-1.1798739433,
-0.822006762,
-0.0021984992,
-0.3098538518,
0.233935222,
0.856256783,
0.8911040425,
-0.4242593646,
0.0000416517,
0.2756725848,
-0.03685835,
-0.2967538834,
-0.1971099824,
0.1794667989,
-0.3066511452,
-0.6335510015,
0.1138946638,
0.3454202712,
-0.1808831245,
-0.3682841957,
-0.2256630957,
-0.3733659089,
0.0972025022,
1.1258693933,
0.1333542317,
-0.752132535,
-0.2912876904,
0.3467023075,
-0.2622851133,
-0.1824048609,
0.4539862871,
-0.0738255233,
0.65688622,
0.5879155993,
0.6632860303,
0.8613681197,
0.1208027452,
0.3360283375,
-0.9512857199,
0.0574223064,
-0.1007953212,
0.4402595758,
0.5002547503,
-0.2461753339,
0.2270070016,
0.1405278742,
-0.3027015924,
-0.5701773763,
0.141977787,
-1.1471995115,
-0.7105221152,
1.448269248,
0.2249238789,
-0.4698520899,
-0.1443883777,
-0.4317218959,
0.4919058084,
-0.4790243208,
0.8621417284,
0.7865406275,
0.1547119468,
-0.7324871421,
-0.9614289403,
0.4067777097,
0.2442104816,
-0.4983440638,
-0.0080065737,
0.4818690717,
0.2390393168,
0.1999345571,
0.9288181663,
0.3448852599,
0.4824897647,
-0.3447107375,
-0.0437467359,
-0.0375418924,
-0.3059316576,
-0.0221226811,
0.2962854207,
-0.1562410444,
-0.2859722674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13016v1
|
Understanding the effects of language-specific class imbalance in multilingual fine-tuning
| 2024-02-20T13:59:12 | 2024-02-20T13:59:12 |
Vincent Jung, Lonneke van der Plas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study the effect of one type of imbalance often present in real-life
multilingual classification datasets: an uneven distribution of labels across
languages. We show evidence that fine-tuning a transformer-based Large Language
Model (LLM) on a dataset with this imbalance leads to worse performance, a more
pronounced separation of languages in the latent space, and the promotion of
uninformative features. We modify the traditional class weighing approach to
imbalance by calculating class weights separately for each language and show
that this helps mitigate those detrimental effects. These results create
awareness of the negative effects of language-specific class imbalance in
multilingual fine-tuning and the way in which the model learns to rely on the
separation of languages to perform the task.
|
[
-0.5719133019,
-0.6059905887,
-0.1411507279,
0.1207531318,
-0.0826775655,
0.1813479662,
-0.3409198821,
-0.7047305703,
0.0471316501,
0.4943024516,
-0.296482414,
-0.0142577058,
-0.6153800488,
-0.0026734967,
-0.1746861041,
1.163525939,
0.1805790216,
0.4240027964,
-0.1674682647,
-0.4940205514,
-0.6708610058,
-0.6531364918,
-0.5135034919,
-0.8852313161,
0.6980215311,
0.7093208432,
0.8249838352,
0.5878778696,
0.549171567,
0.2914994359,
-0.14254421,
-0.1189488992,
-0.6831827164,
-0.1104728058,
-0.1821306348,
-0.8735867143,
-0.4706483781,
0.0367032997,
0.8619347811,
0.7591461539,
-0.1221116036,
0.2906608582,
0.2491853833,
0.43283391,
-0.7433514595,
0.1541218311,
-0.5178456903,
0.1200610027,
-0.4572327733,
-0.2816661298,
-0.4037101865,
0.0801914483,
0.0378345028,
-0.3496783376,
0.2713108659,
0.0084359171,
0.7954075933,
0.4402660728,
-0.3627494276,
0.0946210623,
-0.7268895507,
0.9229222536,
-0.553848207,
0.3524405658,
0.3074412942,
0.1658295095,
0.3531454802,
-0.1876288354,
-0.347019434,
0.1492038518,
-0.2269953042,
0.0365084112,
0.121648781,
0.0502100587,
0.2851218879,
0.6608623862,
-0.4774448276,
0.6495416164,
-0.4216362536,
-0.0353761502,
0.5365436673,
0.1757487208,
0.5001383424,
0.3057464659,
0.122520715,
-0.1839745343,
-0.8160738349,
0.0178047791,
0.7625627518,
0.6703742146,
-0.1402929872,
0.5643840432,
0.0431969538,
0.827713728,
-0.0348014235,
-0.3286384642,
0.4002676904,
0.007924852,
-0.1832199544,
0.218551144,
0.3520168066,
0.5342472196,
0.5121126771,
-0.20511356,
-0.1382605135,
0.2933848202,
0.1040917486,
-0.8698933125,
-0.1594926268,
-0.1873857081,
-0.2959232926,
-0.4497182369,
-0.2381716818,
-0.577014327,
-0.3727869093,
-0.5533849001,
0.4286094606,
0.0564258471,
-0.2439967841,
0.0528545864,
-0.0116143953,
0.1522905529,
0.0290947743,
-1.1382799149,
0.2665315866,
0.426205188,
0.3865496218,
-0.2352958471,
-0.4747874439,
-0.4090951979,
0.1172843874,
0.0232739579,
0.7462946177,
-0.8290755153,
-0.0690092668,
0.0064090835,
0.2697590888,
-0.1730957925,
-0.8703669906,
0.4385560155,
-0.3590975404,
0.2872439027,
-0.1744087785,
-0.5466592312,
-0.1339599043,
0.15363653,
-0.5456169844,
0.8304249644,
-0.1375098974,
-0.7869112492,
0.6587753892,
-0.2618601322,
-0.6327155232,
0.0829642415,
-0.0839301273,
-0.5878086686,
0.1076655835,
0.0603459664,
0.4620708227,
-0.2417463362,
0.2063840032,
-0.3298758268,
-0.6336712837,
0.0494227223,
-0.5535309315,
0.6542866826,
0.2151753902,
-0.1405302733,
-0.0691801459,
-0.781308651,
0.0504444838,
0.028905699,
-0.4807821214,
-0.621119976,
0.1519608945,
0.2462109923,
0.3158980906,
0.1326249838,
-0.3291304708,
0.2673786283,
-0.4639246166,
0.1348235607,
0.5691616535,
-0.1251629591,
0.5711042881,
-0.3998658657,
0.4928360283,
0.2018922716,
0.1537682116,
-0.0782168731,
-0.3265441954,
-0.8230942488,
-0.1164679006,
0.3799376488,
0.7765681148,
-0.3997451067,
0.1125838086,
-0.1455365717,
-0.3730788529,
-0.8972685337,
0.2816479802,
0.6392679811,
0.3508448005,
0.3956840336,
-0.3316456974,
-0.164818868,
-1.0857282877,
-0.4526976645,
0.284285903,
0.155531615,
-0.0171337537,
0.1914365292,
-0.3767312765,
0.4821033478,
-0.5292143822,
-0.3734483421,
-0.3468795121,
0.0183051918,
-0.1009955183,
0.5478209853,
0.6895909309,
-0.837233901,
-0.4493019879,
0.0967953876,
-0.4598271549,
-0.3323324025,
-0.0300621446,
0.0868592486,
0.3954571187,
0.5101607442,
0.0406829603,
0.1445149779,
0.6114254594,
-0.3853223622,
0.314152807,
-0.2923115492,
0.1300495565,
-0.7786720395,
-0.1257776767,
0.1251073778,
0.0711528137,
-0.6637975574,
0.2082002759,
0.2342731059,
0.0651430711,
-0.4662503898,
0.4928235114,
-0.1119642556,
0.1369200796,
-0.3096752465,
0.1614304632,
-0.0292978175,
0.4161636829,
-0.1282409579,
0.6053551435,
0.374412328,
-0.6818503737,
-0.0656269193,
0.0001735573,
-0.3895293772,
0.6566908956,
-0.4207926989,
-0.4141403437,
-0.422424823,
-0.2342731059,
-0.8221895695,
-0.1201223582,
-0.0841489211,
-0.0661904216,
0.9603942037,
-0.2287883461,
-0.498427093,
-0.287476927,
-0.0182774924,
0.4951949418,
0.1269309223,
-0.6559237242,
0.2279597074,
0.5616292953,
0.0288664307,
-0.7953991294,
-0.8878102303,
-0.1752074659,
-0.4797209799,
-0.4671358764,
0.2348464727,
-0.1870063692,
-0.4938414395,
-0.234768942,
-0.1982399821,
-0.0395664051,
0.3485064805,
0.1873627603,
-0.0898942798,
-0.060040921,
0.2770736217,
0.1650007367,
-0.2255691439,
-0.2027104944,
-0.0019791436,
0.6645672321,
-0.3052530289,
-0.4056428075,
-0.1708145738,
0.0902480036,
0.7076057196,
-0.2603523433,
0.9896572232,
0.5162494779,
-0.0965584889,
-0.1897844672,
-0.6189246774,
-0.149510473,
-0.4772542715,
0.4318436384,
-0.4524995685,
-0.7738551497,
0.7913387418,
0.0715606511,
0.1211922616,
0.5928317308,
0.5781458616,
0.038479507,
1.1763939857,
0.863458693,
-0.3544395864,
0.7011120915,
-0.1039029807,
0.1928738058,
-0.4811720252,
-0.2632488906,
-0.6481612921,
-0.6304786801,
-0.9604893923,
-0.1090879738,
0.1309147477,
0.099181436,
-0.3080005944,
0.0710897297,
-0.4835110307,
0.8474433422,
0.5185250044,
-0.034409076,
0.3920095265,
0.1284337491,
-0.0927438214,
-0.2819159031,
-0.6867935061,
-0.4242753386,
0.8112444878,
0.2129924744,
0.9138848186,
0.0761809647,
0.2972606122,
0.1712768674,
0.3306915462,
-0.6180663705,
0.0708117634,
-0.5883775949,
-0.5641691089,
-0.2971268594,
-0.4269703925,
-0.7938375473,
0.5925697088,
-0.3242658675,
-0.4681251645,
0.0355123319,
0.27222839,
0.2032037526,
0.4716458619,
-0.9909078479,
1.0586384535,
-0.4784480929,
-0.4501248002,
-0.3325054049,
-0.6064122915,
0.2755634189,
-0.3632795215,
0.5132116079,
-0.1878614724,
0.4237709641,
0.5219978094,
-0.2193107009,
1.0353126526,
-0.2829621732,
-0.4969384074,
-0.0812054127,
-0.0702005923,
0.3032965064,
-0.0918334052,
-0.1726795137,
0.2357619703,
-0.0318467021,
-0.5327359438,
-0.3432123661,
0.7852002978,
-1.1352155209,
-0.3580631912,
-0.0535037145,
-0.5843970776,
-0.2713631094,
0.1600769162,
0.6192823648,
0.3070945442,
-0.0544992238,
-0.0126942107,
0.6742978096,
-0.4436403215,
0.3712893426,
0.8907727003,
-0.2739530802,
-0.0434863716,
1.2154544592,
0.5818415284,
0.4900260568,
0.6051135659,
0.2544716895,
-0.0223668534,
-0.2179751694,
-0.4365265369,
0.1595226079,
-0.6604142785,
-0.124670215,
-0.4552481771,
0.0551907122,
-0.1529738158,
-0.2708261013,
-0.3884860873,
-0.6832894087,
-0.2232798338,
-0.0712099969,
0.0688189566,
0.5963788033,
0.1812664866,
0.7070625424,
-0.5333132744,
0.0839783475,
0.2373915017,
0.8155029416,
-0.0346559472,
-0.8464266062,
-0.5563831925,
0.0281474069,
-0.4208434224,
-0.2404080778,
0.2080329061,
0.3483768106,
0.7232417464,
0.608694613,
-0.1828418076,
0.7885981202,
-0.6184769869,
0.5996873975,
0.2287470102,
-0.8685926795,
0.2485251725,
-0.2484617084,
0.5338676572,
0.4593933523,
0.0358999074,
-0.8861197829,
-0.8985597491,
-0.3742782772,
-1.0297305584,
0.8972111344,
-0.1274711639,
0.1789885759,
0.0383024327,
0.3655655086,
0.1835547984,
0.1077693999,
-1.0854556561,
-0.7929181457,
-0.1774421483,
-0.0874433815,
-0.5704656839,
-0.4181595147,
0.0694303736,
-0.3614224494,
0.7502684593,
-0.0576918647,
-0.146718815,
-0.5569469929,
-0.4066728354,
-0.5289179087,
0.4139502048,
0.8039968014,
0.4122147262,
-0.043143373,
0.4042409658,
0.4541620016,
-0.3767341971,
0.1700497866,
-0.0854732767,
-0.1140704378,
-0.334315747,
0.320146203,
0.8494890332,
0.3813503385,
-0.5824361444,
0.2194535583,
0.0078187948,
-0.0384241454,
0.0735502318,
0.3192236423,
0.0585254505,
0.1084935218,
0.1984930038,
0.17249915,
-0.0396503583,
-0.3208287954,
0.1467319429,
0.3829054236,
-0.3790463805,
-0.2848341167,
0.5196348429,
0.0873364955,
-0.0812757313,
0.4833248556,
0.2188853025,
-0.3595125675,
0.7607688904,
0.7302464247,
0.4803644419,
-0.6652152538,
-0.0463466533,
0.1545452774,
0.6028622389,
-0.2776967883,
0.0353904553,
0.2254397273,
-0.7751320004,
-0.5923410654,
-0.7721921206,
-0.359238714,
0.1226530969,
-0.6867492795,
0.3834023476,
-0.0304990541,
0.000532126,
0.082936652,
-0.1061012447,
-0.6055065393,
0.2074940205,
0.3493427038,
0.5345665216,
-1.1807118654,
0.8047099113,
0.8329826593,
-0.1855456233,
-0.72215271,
-0.0584058613,
0.0011430774,
-0.7911334038,
0.6633416414,
0.2958514988,
-0.1468574852,
-0.1875635386,
-0.2305312008,
-0.9094352126,
0.5407523513,
0.574303925,
-0.8326265812,
0.2143964171,
0.6790463924,
0.772893548,
-0.095715262,
0.1693052053,
0.4275729954,
0.6241856813,
-0.1975902021,
-1.0635972023,
-0.3544814587,
-0.1855736375,
-0.1959284991,
0.6254617572,
-0.8286762238,
0.7576517463,
0.0303270537,
0.033011809,
-0.4494816959,
0.0895221531,
-0.42681849,
0.1722452641,
0.2546310723,
0.7382646203,
0.9206944108,
-0.1339800805,
0.8090712428,
-0.5180492997,
0.3454948664,
1.2776587009,
-0.096280247,
0.559021771,
0.3985577524,
-0.0291898642,
0.1533733457,
0.519159019,
-0.225275889,
0.4659751058,
0.4071428478,
-0.1914942861,
-0.2737328112,
-0.0020650444,
-0.4220634997,
0.6881132722,
0.4303439856,
-0.2600097656,
-0.3428201079,
0.390538305,
-0.0363756046,
-0.1192274988,
-0.6157597899,
0.6501896977,
-0.0433585346,
-0.6155862212,
0.6766028404,
0.1646607071,
0.8727718592,
-0.1920390576,
0.2460873723,
-0.3227025568,
0.6387540102,
-0.4261854887,
-0.6737240553,
0.455083251,
-0.1377020031,
-0.4720315933,
-0.335829705,
0.4072464406,
-0.7553566098,
-0.4715204537,
0.417979449,
0.54026407,
0.0596521832,
0.0779380873,
-0.5286912918,
-0.027849365,
-0.0091333827,
-0.1851047575,
0.5975239873,
0.5282484293,
-0.2209897935,
0.7093090415,
0.1334932894,
-0.1395158768,
0.0328193344,
0.4984741509,
0.5695419908,
-0.425034076,
-0.2488950789,
-0.9613938928,
0.3163136542,
0.3194343746,
-0.2006345987,
0.805155158,
0.7889962196,
1.217908144,
-0.1254501343,
0.6045364141,
0.2164711803,
0.4282014966,
-0.1873712987,
0.8903298378,
-0.9559048414,
0.4846588969,
-0.421072185,
-0.836043179,
-0.7886520028,
0.4232627749,
-0.2235662192,
-0.0520591736,
0.312972039,
0.5760493875,
-0.1185044944,
-0.1352812946,
0.5335147381,
0.2296429276,
0.2491403818,
0.0654610544,
0.7431090474,
-0.1662931442,
0.4938881695,
-0.3477509022,
0.0378243662,
-0.2651676834,
-0.5516300797,
-1.106436491,
-0.3473839164,
-0.4047952294,
-0.0926968828,
-0.1128415912,
0.67828089,
0.3474934101,
-0.8808116317,
-0.3853422999,
0.1652807444,
0.3778417408,
-0.1623719633,
-0.2727216482,
0.125919953,
-0.6808283925,
-0.8673368692,
-0.0889909789,
0.1666788906,
0.212491855,
0.0643301383,
0.0658632517,
0.0385397039,
-0.2355569899,
0.7205938101,
0.1966677308,
-0.5487962961,
-0.161111936,
-0.1424884349,
-0.1373979598,
0.262498945,
0.8106190562,
-0.5411120653,
0.4465901554,
0.133277446,
0.2365888655,
0.4415775537,
-0.3288606405,
0.509122014,
-1.0691049099,
0.4688125551,
-0.0383909419,
0.3408585191,
0.2130818367,
-0.3150375783,
0.4156397879,
0.14683339,
-0.5586045384,
-0.7915828824,
0.1186652333,
-0.5845050812,
-0.5704969764,
0.9360631108,
0.2498607785,
0.2134057134,
-0.1538000554,
-0.1804133505,
0.3975436091,
-0.1717920303,
0.9216153622,
0.8389083743,
-0.003788152,
-0.1251079738,
-0.3831590414,
0.476682663,
0.548283577,
-0.5880131125,
0.3143694103,
0.4364398122,
0.3155051768,
0.1896395236,
0.0667004362,
-0.0467045605,
-0.1930941194,
-0.32970348,
0.276568532,
0.2440713644,
-0.4194506705,
-0.5088037848,
0.2623996139,
0.2302841395,
0.2162049562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13013v1
|
Code Needs Comments: Enhancing Code LLMs with Comment Augmentation
| 2024-02-20T13:56:38 | 2024-02-20T13:56:38 |
Demin Song, Honglin Guo, Yunhua Zhou, Shuhao Xing, Yudong Wang, Zifan Song, Wenwei Zhang, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The programming skill is one crucial ability for Large Language Models
(LLMs), necessitating a deep understanding of programming languages (PLs) and
their correlation with natural languages (NLs). We examine the impact of
pre-training data on code-focused LLMs' performance by assessing the comment
density as a measure of PL-NL alignment. Given the scarcity of code-comment
aligned data in pre-training corpora, we introduce a novel data augmentation
method that generates comments for existing code, coupled with a data filtering
strategy that filters out code data poorly correlated with natural language. We
conducted experiments on three code-focused LLMs and observed consistent
improvements in performance on two widely-used programming skill benchmarks.
Notably, the model trained on the augmented data outperformed both the model
used for generating comments and the model further trained on the data without
augmentation.
|
[
-0.5746598244,
-0.3250283301,
0.3714565039,
0.2704921365,
-0.3813660145,
0.3232733607,
-0.4026747048,
-0.670743525,
0.1969026774,
0.7464901805,
-0.4406561852,
-0.5199260116,
-0.4365496039,
0.363386333,
-0.4270071983,
1.3186756372,
0.1407302916,
0.2393049002,
-0.6794002652,
0.2022209913,
-0.2800498903,
-0.6515312195,
0.0090600699,
-0.1187021285,
0.375105232,
0.4099141359,
0.7644973993,
0.565381825,
0.7844119072,
0.2422363311,
0.1789585203,
0.2200903445,
-0.4255173802,
-0.1631445736,
0.2106070817,
-0.6069199443,
-0.5684713721,
-0.1736229211,
0.4037831724,
0.8249647021,
0.1611715853,
0.0794386789,
0.1807816923,
0.6489302516,
-0.5160672665,
0.1609502882,
-0.3506407142,
0.077375792,
0.0146001549,
-0.4365418553,
-0.2397320718,
-0.7041660547,
0.050374154,
-0.5471752286,
0.1688450724,
-0.366040498,
0.5851730108,
0.7145667672,
-0.0389023945,
-0.3770233095,
-0.5861178637,
0.5524861813,
-0.9403697252,
0.2419272214,
0.4202621579,
-0.4142279625,
-0.0114628524,
-0.4415260553,
-0.3961897492,
-0.4330865443,
-0.1842956394,
-0.1100924686,
0.4993422925,
0.2132968605,
0.6738131046,
0.5595071912,
-0.3667726219,
-0.1267561764,
-0.4590166509,
-0.011824904,
0.7590177059,
-0.1092770323,
0.2219800949,
-0.0496291816,
-0.1086350083,
0.1809575856,
-0.6249989271,
0.0368639007,
0.5229292512,
0.2073064744,
-0.1315327287,
0.5848129392,
-0.1626905352,
0.9907363653,
-0.2817800939,
-0.117420502,
0.4744638205,
-0.437335521,
-0.051212173,
-0.2849873006,
0.3548655212,
0.2302434742,
0.6470057964,
-0.252030164,
-0.2217991501,
0.2601204216,
0.5096352696,
-0.6535515189,
-0.5690072775,
-0.1298446059,
-0.3263223767,
-0.4600275755,
0.3287715018,
-0.5950907469,
-0.6669760942,
-0.6891283989,
-0.0034281102,
-0.1307457983,
-0.3370851278,
-0.0594568588,
-0.0230342392,
0.1945023388,
0.2724364102,
-0.7794161439,
0.2562585175,
0.7313036919,
0.527279377,
-0.124255456,
-0.1525446326,
-0.5490738153,
-0.0632086694,
-0.6258718371,
0.845950067,
-1.012370348,
-0.3301350772,
0.1086208671,
-0.1977435052,
0.2244916856,
-0.6433387399,
0.3568460047,
-0.6842353344,
-0.1308482736,
-0.2179562151,
-0.590084374,
0.0807064548,
0.0961339623,
-0.4466048777,
1.2334327698,
0.4217073619,
-0.8143569827,
0.4422287345,
-0.6305218935,
-0.694206357,
0.2436607182,
-0.3997910321,
-0.10687612,
0.3607234061,
0.1795676649,
0.2694673836,
0.0244271848,
0.1553084701,
-0.6023497581,
-0.6220177412,
0.4658634365,
-0.0288207084,
0.2953831255,
0.1495053768,
-0.1469644457,
0.0071263621,
-0.9806390405,
0.3680101335,
-0.3725939691,
-0.5880521536,
-0.0949332044,
0.1245083362,
-0.2447579801,
0.2765592933,
0.4903080463,
-0.3240152895,
0.3447350264,
-0.58135885,
0.1648330837,
0.4933206141,
-0.0563564412,
0.4669778347,
-0.0588215105,
0.5538455248,
-0.1058220416,
0.1622207314,
-0.1865660101,
-0.1379330903,
-0.8812307715,
-0.156329155,
0.2126207799,
0.491294533,
-0.7586037517,
0.2852703333,
-0.2101563215,
-0.1605616361,
-0.6659218669,
0.821357131,
0.5133805275,
0.244782567,
0.3165012896,
-0.704185605,
-1.1074825525,
-0.7401257753,
-0.150068596,
0.0064980397,
-0.0121033108,
0.2341314703,
0.1300017387,
-0.3784190714,
0.9787041545,
-0.6688922644,
0.1291881204,
-0.1620137095,
-0.0562396012,
0.1963908225,
0.4754644036,
0.1178244948,
-0.4312443137,
-0.5782652497,
-0.1474271417,
-0.6717617512,
-0.4027010798,
0.0899314284,
0.0786624253,
0.1346850097,
0.7496988177,
-0.2922812104,
0.4998018742,
0.637033999,
0.1831320375,
0.3717296124,
-0.2680603862,
0.0738959312,
-0.6941056252,
0.1560938507,
0.0285744742,
-0.2292272151,
-0.6438942552,
0.0418381803,
0.2072173655,
-0.1910157353,
-0.0794209763,
-0.0688851029,
-0.5898769498,
-0.2997842133,
-0.6797859669,
0.0922409818,
0.0470446758,
0.4335987866,
0.2950795889,
1.0437465906,
0.4319167733,
-0.7112354636,
0.1210281178,
0.0913657174,
-0.5206564665,
0.1937307119,
-0.5373246074,
0.6205577254,
0.0720289201,
-0.0185365621,
-1.0387004614,
-0.238356337,
-0.1807425022,
-0.5010294318,
0.433768332,
-0.3945422173,
-0.3980256021,
-0.4637313187,
-0.3384280503,
0.1814952493,
0.304851681,
-0.2590745389,
0.1677352488,
0.4580067694,
-0.2010098398,
-0.7333744764,
-0.7952080369,
0.2446266711,
0.1445487142,
-0.5362058282,
0.0943786502,
-0.2232777923,
-0.0904745236,
-0.0201529898,
-0.0156544261,
-0.2276021391,
0.2156012505,
0.291875869,
0.477609992,
-0.1738379598,
0.0964477733,
-0.4722116292,
-0.0994051322,
0.3210189044,
-0.0921498835,
0.5440026522,
-0.0949064791,
-0.2165139765,
-0.1159798577,
0.1886307895,
0.3964055479,
-0.2366000414,
0.6594923735,
0.2547824383,
-0.0552076958,
-0.198927775,
-0.7344985604,
-0.1201493591,
-0.4634657502,
0.5530902147,
-0.1019560397,
-0.9581244588,
0.3122284114,
0.1667418331,
-0.0697290301,
0.0772107169,
0.2261332124,
-0.1779119819,
1.1244617701,
0.9563848972,
-0.3589037359,
0.693798542,
-0.1158894077,
0.5078911781,
-0.8856111765,
-0.0840703845,
-0.5095740557,
0.0538807027,
-0.5470471382,
-0.5569198132,
0.0099438103,
0.101886943,
-0.1163348556,
0.2771986723,
-0.6246019602,
0.6567310691,
0.3303323686,
0.2305932492,
0.1810103059,
0.0113261659,
0.2794385254,
-0.0952929482,
-0.4847640097,
-0.4424602091,
1.3432751894,
0.2204360962,
0.8631346226,
-0.1951780319,
0.6521974206,
0.3051914871,
0.5250151753,
-0.349075675,
0.4820328951,
-0.1785525233,
-0.3300211728,
0.0372333601,
-0.5491422415,
-0.3100102842,
-0.1674639434,
-0.1104227602,
-0.3166236281,
-0.0040981397,
0.3317968249,
-0.4926181138,
-0.0522759333,
-1.0147428513,
0.6408033967,
-0.3536026478,
-0.5967289209,
-0.2122917622,
-0.6088393927,
0.2870905101,
-0.0508518368,
0.2481170595,
0.1357415617,
-0.1818824559,
0.5197632313,
-0.6286075115,
0.9590067267,
-0.3870398104,
-0.1872288883,
0.3403024673,
-0.1973552853,
0.5164805055,
0.0859277174,
-0.0543092452,
-0.0558166504,
-0.2301775813,
-0.3741776049,
-0.5719130039,
0.7095837593,
-0.8339473009,
-0.7519245148,
-0.164824307,
-0.6780492663,
-0.5124397874,
0.0234786458,
0.013078467,
0.3474978805,
0.2245251387,
0.1748316884,
0.7486342192,
-0.0961848348,
0.3155732453,
0.4080919623,
-0.155554086,
-0.5755293369,
0.772690475,
0.0335848145,
0.3820152879,
0.1477447152,
-0.3314534426,
-0.1306248456,
-0.6973088384,
-0.0463542938,
0.2345687151,
-0.835588038,
-0.2871180475,
-0.6658743024,
-0.3754760325,
-0.4908865392,
-0.2100217342,
-0.1721000522,
-0.2361828983,
-0.3091620505,
-0.1313986331,
0.522161305,
0.9153478146,
0.0605759956,
0.1181848571,
-0.8842765689,
0.1549796313,
0.112816073,
0.8941870332,
-0.0272941962,
-0.5747814178,
-0.7888269424,
0.0289090034,
0.0725561604,
-0.7437753677,
0.284981221,
0.0423497409,
0.4377240837,
0.2662827075,
-0.1569772959,
0.9554487467,
-0.0695648044,
0.7570495605,
-0.0364807285,
-0.8866288662,
0.5910238624,
-0.058535751,
0.2757788897,
0.9185849428,
-0.0138956057,
-0.298050195,
-0.4225055277,
-0.2974414825,
-0.681430459,
0.7492718101,
-0.1192853451,
0.3825961351,
-0.1707418263,
0.5165785551,
-0.139945522,
0.5960247517,
-0.992317915,
0.056041237,
-0.1323708743,
-0.2192123681,
-0.0996729434,
-0.4672394991,
0.1121929884,
-0.4707656503,
0.5234918594,
-0.1792681962,
0.1245639473,
0.2029142678,
-0.3356110454,
-0.1543649733,
0.124726586,
0.7217354178,
0.5935345888,
-0.0889056176,
0.2324384451,
0.2291279584,
-0.4800777435,
-0.0882033482,
-0.0915734321,
0.0504075661,
-0.3006223142,
0.302819401,
0.5156536102,
0.4216896594,
-0.6636326909,
0.4816099405,
0.1912410706,
-0.0438548177,
-0.2042639554,
0.4783081412,
0.1645250022,
-0.1990550756,
0.1928023845,
0.4500877857,
0.0297694579,
-0.4767703414,
0.3455071747,
0.3100558221,
-0.5295055509,
-0.2060664594,
0.1898075193,
0.2683971226,
-0.1132656559,
0.4418689311,
-0.1347289979,
-0.6952846646,
0.6260178685,
0.497878015,
0.648660183,
-0.1145332307,
0.037051972,
0.329099983,
0.358002305,
0.0498732068,
0.4758946598,
-0.3172586262,
-0.4468121529,
-0.9529044628,
-0.3959316909,
-0.2309746146,
0.0214579292,
-0.4987450242,
0.4551081061,
-0.7442026138,
-0.0458462387,
-0.4050983191,
0.3380043507,
-0.718739748,
0.2486277223,
0.36812675,
0.7986896038,
-0.7689250708,
0.9684665799,
0.723488152,
-0.5625478029,
-0.8768213391,
0.0155827813,
-0.4908463657,
-0.7164923549,
0.6068845391,
0.225377813,
-0.1052205712,
-0.0232917257,
-0.693960309,
-1.1456898451,
0.3519661129,
0.4481391013,
-0.460270375,
0.2558528483,
0.485732764,
0.910505712,
-0.4850486517,
0.4484016597,
0.5693309307,
0.2594823539,
-0.1612981111,
-0.6206727624,
-0.257448256,
-0.7148364186,
0.1467266381,
0.2330177575,
-0.5005291104,
0.5402179956,
-0.243638292,
0.1215891391,
-0.1397686154,
0.5938304067,
0.0785526782,
0.1177849099,
0.4097339213,
0.604655087,
0.7060427666,
0.1105033755,
1.1411904097,
-0.7349103093,
0.0878549442,
1.2554197311,
-0.650162816,
0.7792804241,
0.4768472612,
-0.2926380336,
0.779332459,
0.4464343786,
-0.1013886109,
0.468423456,
0.3630829751,
-0.158753112,
-0.1736828387,
-0.1054665297,
-0.5839237571,
-0.0196881872,
0.3525258303,
-0.3318659961,
0.2149440497,
-0.1664539576,
-0.1081378832,
0.2999741435,
-0.1836181879,
0.9846695065,
0.0282122288,
-1.0319590569,
0.5491330624,
-0.2953580022,
0.6771259904,
-0.6210808754,
-0.0602449141,
-0.3192728758,
0.1621111929,
-0.8576282859,
-0.7076589465,
0.4298374355,
0.4559800327,
-0.4151317775,
0.0242009722,
0.5670061111,
-0.5136070251,
-0.4442445338,
0.3939626515,
0.1018514782,
-0.0450588502,
0.0894609466,
-0.425450027,
0.1381400228,
0.2201857716,
-0.056013871,
0.3769531548,
0.2838570476,
0.2937144637,
0.4241774976,
0.7990977764,
0.1935527176,
0.2898955643,
0.3801369667,
1.1998274326,
-0.4602976143,
-0.3786002994,
-0.6516401768,
0.4365598261,
-0.4621649981,
-0.1839951575,
0.847450614,
0.8053048253,
0.932541728,
-0.1715848744,
0.9884230494,
0.0116834911,
0.6058192253,
-0.3775885999,
0.2324433476,
-0.222507298,
0.687212646,
-0.5239388347,
-1.0134057999,
-0.4115533233,
0.7269013524,
-0.7582020164,
0.2437628657,
0.588054657,
1.1341913939,
0.1307234913,
0.1451224387,
0.2115087062,
-0.0347405039,
0.0826646984,
0.5698083043,
0.9843519926,
-0.2442718744,
0.584474206,
-0.4402071536,
-0.0944292769,
-0.2256412953,
-0.82433635,
-0.8039870262,
-0.1639701575,
-0.5405715704,
-0.3418204784,
-0.2241536826,
0.959608674,
0.7917060256,
-0.8833428025,
-0.2649814188,
-0.4463932812,
0.0460084677,
0.0966452211,
-0.2351493984,
0.0887923017,
-0.9110940099,
-0.4344636202,
0.4138780236,
0.3483932018,
-0.1433902383,
-0.3037090898,
-0.2436570376,
0.0066323453,
0.0140910707,
0.3722485304,
0.2236207277,
-0.3712016642,
-0.2722254097,
0.1300284564,
-0.3153280318,
0.3506819606,
1.1913580894,
-0.7972416282,
0.5432015657,
0.4553178549,
0.7471516132,
0.3426282406,
0.184267059,
0.5577259064,
-1.0150380135,
0.332878232,
0.2035299838,
0.2352742851,
0.5083488822,
-0.6379783154,
0.5650382638,
0.0736692026,
-0.5864545107,
-0.9937161803,
-0.0045507303,
-0.5787287354,
-0.0869605243,
1.0513038635,
-0.1331075579,
0.013693423,
-0.3349849284,
-0.1997198313,
0.1227317825,
-0.2204002738,
0.7018930912,
0.703440845,
-0.0678533018,
-0.2640860975,
-0.6060110331,
0.8122340441,
0.5854985118,
-0.8655270934,
0.2003998756,
0.5163370371,
0.1351478845,
0.1311073154,
0.7650702596,
-0.205941692,
0.4318627119,
-0.091779992,
0.2764547169,
-0.0780309215,
-0.3723494709,
-0.4370293915,
0.3403117657,
0.4766659439,
0.2187534571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13302v1
|
Enhancing Modern Supervised Word Sense Disambiguation Models by Semantic Lexical Resources
| 2024-02-20T13:47:51 | 2024-02-20T13:47:51 |
Stefano Melacci, Achille Globo, Leonardo Rigutini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Supervised models for Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) currently yield to
state-of-the-art results in the most popular benchmarks. Despite the recent
introduction of Word Embeddings and Recurrent Neural Networks to design
powerful context-related features, the interest in improving WSD models using
Semantic Lexical Resources (SLRs) is mostly restricted to knowledge-based
approaches. In this paper, we enhance "modern" supervised WSD models exploiting
two popular SLRs: WordNet and WordNet Domains. We propose an effective way to
introduce semantic features into the classifiers, and we consider using the SLR
structure to augment the training data. We study the effect of different types
of semantic features, investigating their interaction with local contexts
encoded by means of mixtures of Word Embeddings or Recurrent Neural Networks,
and we extend the proposed model into a novel multi-layer architecture for WSD.
A detailed experimental comparison in the recent Unified Evaluation Framework
(Raganato et al., 2017) shows that the proposed approach leads to supervised
models that compare favourably with the state-of-the art.
|
[
-0.5449157357,
-0.3773894906,
0.6081073284,
-0.3007177711,
-0.2222711295,
-0.1352457851,
-0.1615508646,
-0.7296520472,
0.1337167174,
0.3386811316,
-0.3919723034,
-0.4956131577,
-0.7091933489,
-0.0250863265,
-0.4100082517,
0.8373305202,
0.0109941633,
0.1122366488,
-0.3912043273,
-0.6075183153,
-0.5775271058,
-0.6432817578,
-0.1671875864,
-0.4388376772,
0.6191845536,
-0.2010478377,
0.7112120986,
0.3155913651,
0.3956536055,
0.338601768,
-0.6074185371,
0.4999402165,
-0.0225016717,
0.0218914598,
-0.3922722042,
-0.0657869428,
-0.4664995372,
-0.0962722227,
0.2253275365,
1.1391277313,
-0.2442303449,
-0.142119661,
0.178049013,
0.5275633931,
-0.9631050229,
0.0550522767,
-0.7661254406,
0.0329218917,
0.0405090228,
-0.0183237307,
-0.1618460566,
0.0378190912,
0.5508198142,
-0.8126373291,
0.2509817481,
-0.025530709,
0.6460965276,
0.1188872904,
-0.3794763982,
-0.3344430327,
-0.3163460195,
0.8866334558,
-0.6339613795,
0.7048780918,
0.2914918661,
0.1622333676,
-0.2124026269,
-0.7816067338,
-0.5930256248,
-0.2914806306,
-0.2643232942,
0.1553514004,
-0.024712028,
0.1844406724,
0.1419226527,
0.3208940029,
-0.1611035168,
-0.0977643728,
-0.2467794865,
-0.3699371219,
0.4322963357,
0.1217405796,
-0.0387494862,
-0.0532605015,
-0.6322851181,
-0.2372017652,
-0.1612615138,
-0.0857969597,
0.0619393811,
0.5451760292,
0.2363943756,
0.5790015459,
-0.4063929617,
1.2423882484,
-0.2040645033,
-0.4397544265,
0.3766257763,
-0.5294513702,
-0.0245530196,
0.1569734216,
0.1318702847,
0.4163432419,
0.1916043758,
-0.3603710234,
-0.3950654864,
0.462886095,
0.2705963552,
-0.5614414215,
-0.2204294503,
-0.0619502142,
-0.2521130443,
-0.2321502566,
0.2852749527,
-0.3110910654,
-0.5822940469,
-0.7575308084,
0.5701521635,
-0.653583765,
-0.3767144084,
0.4584880769,
-0.7007713318,
0.0706435516,
0.2874679863,
-0.5135290623,
0.3367559612,
0.6599010825,
0.7777321935,
-0.2725791633,
-0.4379884303,
-0.2180646956,
0.2077770084,
-0.0693133995,
0.6813808084,
-0.7767322659,
-0.2509693503,
0.0643600076,
0.0447344929,
0.0397857688,
-0.5910146236,
0.198193565,
-0.5796086788,
0.180435583,
-0.3806720376,
-0.6908354759,
-0.2351513505,
0.2587046921,
-0.4092835486,
0.9568092823,
0.4986456037,
-0.9441686869,
0.6609575152,
-0.8990860581,
-0.4938057959,
-0.0229959954,
0.1183126867,
0.1482857019,
0.4004744589,
0.1605186909,
0.3075003922,
0.1417576671,
0.4072989225,
-0.4445534348,
-0.2660274208,
0.3361487985,
-0.2273579985,
0.5869442821,
0.34136343,
0.1100255325,
0.133160919,
-0.9736153483,
0.0489520691,
0.0213106982,
0.0049475511,
-1.150996089,
-0.1514440626,
0.0731448531,
0.1282692701,
0.3734908104,
-0.5856255889,
-0.1305784732,
-0.4210118651,
0.6590847373,
0.3556185365,
-0.1233705133,
0.6096550226,
-0.1521442235,
0.1382224709,
0.5882968903,
0.1292886734,
-0.0944785178,
-0.2897925675,
-0.4518461823,
-0.2626546919,
0.2350485027,
0.3133916855,
-0.7723875046,
0.492390573,
-0.1609679759,
-0.3979813159,
-0.4558200538,
0.0746285766,
0.2727612257,
0.7314744592,
0.5776171088,
-0.5270913243,
-0.339266032,
-0.5778481364,
-0.1515972018,
0.0537440926,
-0.3259986341,
0.2378339022,
0.3208177388,
-0.2007030398,
1.4257427454,
-0.5096253753,
-0.4557538033,
-0.2047923505,
-0.3035304844,
-0.1448898464,
0.223811388,
0.3666886687,
-1.0137226582,
0.2916688025,
-0.1755693108,
-0.5968314409,
0.1060901061,
0.3649356365,
-0.0725592971,
-0.0570339747,
0.3214738369,
-0.3668606877,
0.4677967131,
0.2839041054,
-0.5239335299,
0.352188766,
-0.2724309862,
-0.2163656205,
-1.1923853159,
-0.1768758148,
0.2058694959,
-0.0634985417,
-0.6712603569,
0.3708229661,
0.2590110898,
-0.1331194937,
-0.6091972589,
0.7226661444,
-0.4097509384,
-0.2796807587,
-0.3301317394,
0.6069402099,
0.5685629845,
0.1925494969,
0.1790222824,
0.5186886191,
0.5496711135,
-0.7549779415,
0.3247950077,
0.2358413339,
-0.4952581823,
0.7116645575,
-0.6346964836,
-0.2938143313,
-0.3420906961,
0.0994610339,
-0.6972513795,
-0.1057812497,
-0.2055487633,
-0.2976004779,
0.1474943012,
0.0606207512,
-0.4028986692,
-0.3489249945,
-0.2259435952,
0.2699998915,
0.1291835606,
-0.7743657231,
0.4683714211,
0.442984432,
0.3678498864,
-0.4267677665,
-0.7254955769,
0.0929024443,
-0.3826466203,
-0.5676242709,
0.7119981647,
0.3276699185,
-0.316051811,
0.2282796651,
-0.2613975406,
-0.1201553792,
0.3153457344,
0.0665004626,
0.2959185243,
-0.0526922308,
0.4008862674,
0.0273533948,
-0.1243872494,
-0.2764257789,
-0.6683768034,
0.4498015344,
-0.1956679225,
-0.4260983169,
-0.027140433,
0.3387301862,
0.4817448854,
-0.6852322817,
0.7885628343,
0.7510893345,
-0.5882382393,
-0.2007611096,
-0.4771291912,
-0.5373106003,
-0.4819883704,
0.5842795968,
-0.5152272582,
-1.2138265371,
0.3813942969,
-0.2934502363,
-0.0842711776,
0.0557905734,
0.0025091525,
-0.0470586345,
0.9141641259,
0.6651533842,
-0.0666348189,
0.455396533,
-0.0501080342,
0.3448039591,
-1.1836322546,
-0.1756179184,
-0.2441123724,
-0.2494435161,
-0.4479086399,
-0.3182416558,
0.3546086252,
0.3170005977,
-0.1071291193,
0.3768499792,
-0.6634259224,
0.0874747932,
0.3762348592,
0.1859311163,
0.2283075601,
0.1614402831,
-0.4526354373,
0.025093561,
-0.8625435829,
-0.3500674367,
0.5729969144,
0.307105124,
0.7998638749,
0.0897896439,
0.5333420038,
0.2135626823,
-0.0066790259,
-0.8753064871,
0.5118339062,
-0.2219389528,
-0.2395064235,
-0.2233772129,
-0.1428065747,
-0.9021657705,
0.4819484353,
-0.1440214962,
-0.602733314,
0.2681479752,
-0.1321447641,
-0.308206439,
0.2066456676,
-0.7785468698,
0.798417449,
-0.0114874924,
-0.2236026376,
0.0484058857,
-0.3509907722,
0.2440606505,
0.1823028773,
0.1453240663,
0.0137522258,
-0.227392301,
0.4556583464,
-0.661243856,
0.8362239599,
-0.6455103159,
-0.3904403746,
0.2951422334,
-0.2288704365,
0.2707864642,
-0.1988460422,
-0.1050975174,
0.3013249338,
0.1850298792,
-0.2970462143,
-0.6258918643,
0.6463718414,
-0.3434100747,
-0.4200015366,
-0.3514360189,
-0.7616768479,
-0.5314633846,
0.0397094116,
-0.0412476398,
0.8293502331,
0.1288089603,
-0.0121233445,
0.5464040637,
-0.0552492514,
0.3602308929,
0.3066834211,
-0.0065608299,
-0.1952555031,
0.7470164299,
0.2047504932,
0.2634941936,
-0.0075195762,
0.2576929033,
-0.6009036303,
-0.5202972293,
-0.3004037142,
-0.1699723452,
-0.6087480783,
-0.3065654337,
-0.5959231853,
-0.2940130532,
-0.4913508892,
-0.0822733566,
-0.1032054275,
-0.2505342662,
-0.0160781108,
-0.144188419,
0.83533144,
0.4201180339,
0.2773350477,
0.346930325,
-0.7344443798,
0.1554720402,
0.2233207226,
0.5675638318,
0.2591867149,
-0.6002449393,
-0.1302490532,
0.043951761,
-0.0466058105,
-0.6572946906,
0.2598675489,
0.2990217507,
0.4812723994,
0.5225895047,
0.1784382761,
1.0733932257,
-0.5056414604,
0.6754590273,
0.2496080846,
-0.7521384358,
0.6409626007,
-0.0823141783,
0.4232136309,
0.4487654269,
0.1377723366,
-0.5218493938,
-0.4209887981,
-0.4427375495,
-0.7538651824,
0.3000727892,
-0.2529071271,
0.3272017539,
-0.2775553763,
0.4583623409,
0.1766209304,
0.2286395878,
-0.2472801208,
-0.02489339,
-0.3329909742,
-0.4302233458,
0.1542172134,
-0.2594881952,
-0.0173854399,
-0.1033916697,
0.3480442762,
-0.3145032823,
-0.2069760859,
0.4056889713,
-0.3758000731,
0.6042308807,
0.2735729218,
0.3362202942,
0.7671397328,
0.0596680231,
0.3477586806,
0.4085612595,
-0.5072649717,
0.065878503,
0.0784486532,
-0.3740622103,
0.0875137523,
0.2500542104,
0.9086431861,
0.5090769529,
-0.5619733334,
0.4632724822,
0.1413769275,
-0.1222509369,
-0.3420254588,
0.3061886132,
0.1511294097,
0.2944721878,
0.317918092,
0.1826573461,
0.2554318905,
-0.4245171249,
0.3449463844,
0.5294521451,
-0.546665132,
-0.0360361338,
0.338485539,
-0.130838424,
0.101851806,
0.096735023,
-0.4596259892,
-0.510725975,
0.2129306644,
0.8031185865,
0.345931083,
0.0578507297,
-0.0475707352,
0.3776681423,
0.0910939872,
-0.1350182593,
0.2986235023,
-0.2800014019,
-1.0429140329,
-0.1899810284,
-0.9230846763,
-0.2299067229,
-0.0390207618,
-0.946828723,
0.1380003095,
-0.1537836492,
-0.3277232945,
-0.1329264194,
-0.025670385,
-0.6390743256,
0.2521488965,
0.1858947575,
1.090990901,
-0.6440951824,
0.9605207443,
0.9640548229,
-0.1412986964,
-0.5574240088,
-0.1447057724,
-0.1088694856,
-0.5494126081,
0.3994780481,
0.2311834991,
-0.1552676111,
-0.0225922707,
-0.1508239359,
-0.801415503,
1.259532094,
-0.0734627843,
-0.619220674,
0.0551007167,
0.078330107,
0.4656675458,
-0.3449473083,
-0.006523428,
0.5250923038,
0.4215182364,
0.1367758065,
-0.5191496015,
0.0003629174,
-0.077765502,
0.5790792704,
0.1753233969,
-0.1537685096,
0.5391901135,
-0.2762598097,
-0.2383254915,
0.0058301189,
0.9594197273,
0.5353632569,
0.541136086,
0.8801124692,
0.9861080647,
0.923979342,
-0.0892134383,
0.8289444447,
-0.2870333195,
0.1006888151,
1.3139449358,
-0.6097645164,
0.8690565228,
0.7002231479,
-0.2312764674,
0.4038730562,
0.591555655,
-0.0680657253,
0.7486677766,
0.4488736391,
-0.4585205317,
0.0334837958,
-0.6009914875,
-0.2709520161,
0.5775120854,
0.5462633371,
-0.0410736725,
-0.367354244,
0.4352691472,
-0.1453521997,
0.2997392416,
-0.4457117915,
0.84690696,
0.0482232198,
-0.3964598775,
0.251154691,
0.1749217659,
1.213686347,
-0.6343528628,
0.0844996348,
-0.2463568598,
0.2122298181,
-0.1856068075,
-0.518607378,
0.3463329375,
0.0566473082,
-0.1488077492,
0.1151559353,
1.174151659,
-0.5255417228,
-0.5905659795,
0.5810050964,
0.5784496665,
-0.0402001292,
-0.1959175467,
-0.4325265884,
-0.0310442373,
-0.5103697181,
0.0711412057,
0.6346808076,
0.6304715276,
-0.2600995898,
0.387376219,
0.7625928521,
0.2313120216,
0.1166856885,
0.6394469738,
0.8265515566,
-0.6591950655,
-0.3509818614,
-0.6510750055,
0.2729426026,
-0.2090672553,
-0.3625295758,
0.5611637235,
0.2003129274,
1.2145696878,
0.0976897925,
0.6243332624,
-0.1155262217,
0.2563737333,
-0.4451656044,
0.7709077001,
-0.7628877163,
-0.0221155994,
-0.2398541868,
-0.841722846,
-0.2118450403,
0.7221522331,
0.0833693519,
0.1983401775,
0.3662337959,
0.9903851151,
-0.2384173423,
0.1186227128,
0.4313379526,
-0.1772381663,
-0.0428626649,
0.3205686808,
0.8541858196,
-0.2608150542,
0.0848192871,
-0.5421954393,
-0.2566899061,
0.1091909632,
-0.9691413641,
-0.6421381235,
-0.8666169643,
-0.2494378239,
-0.2265420556,
-0.0526425764,
0.780569911,
0.6886452436,
-0.6700303555,
0.3192221224,
-0.1397684067,
-0.0691641271,
-0.3380877078,
-0.2547102571,
0.3037219048,
-0.6675314903,
-0.5572226048,
0.5321406126,
0.2074324191,
-0.076452598,
-0.4702715874,
-0.0853419602,
0.0963819399,
-0.1487012804,
1.0763207674,
-0.3256004453,
-0.9562507272,
-0.5423643589,
0.106216386,
-0.0895042941,
-0.378415525,
0.5209342241,
-1.0125995874,
0.2771007717,
0.2798461914,
0.780303061,
-0.0019442585,
-0.0921170861,
0.1730778962,
-0.6980597973,
0.3395008147,
-0.038044773,
0.6945722103,
0.4345301688,
-0.0168097243,
0.4939104021,
0.3298760951,
0.2098266482,
-0.7779348493,
0.1561356783,
-0.9108902216,
-0.4102405906,
1.0450973511,
-0.1881662011,
-0.2913613021,
-0.1211749464,
-0.0298132412,
0.2182761431,
-0.0344471745,
0.8257367015,
0.6934030652,
0.1757819504,
0.0683438256,
-0.4853486717,
0.2247894108,
0.4372628927,
-0.4545408189,
0.0476393662,
0.5558146834,
0.2475541234,
0.2172211856,
0.0035266427,
-0.478967905,
0.0893062949,
-0.0808835924,
0.0202894025,
-0.4513852596,
-0.3796231151,
-0.3984571695,
0.1179995835,
0.0340736359,
-0.2580164075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13006v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13006v2
|
Investigating the Impact of Model Instability on Explanations and Uncertainty
| 2024-02-20T13:41:21 | 2024-06-04T11:18:03 |
Sara Vera Marjanović, Isabelle Augenstein, Christina Lioma
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Explainable AI methods facilitate the understanding of model behaviour, yet,
small, imperceptible perturbations to inputs can vastly distort explanations.
As these explanations are typically evaluated holistically, before model
deployment, it is difficult to assess when a particular explanation is
trustworthy. Some studies have tried to create confidence estimators for
explanations, but none have investigated an existing link between uncertainty
and explanation quality. We artificially simulate epistemic uncertainty in text
input by introducing noise at inference time. In this large-scale empirical
study, we insert different levels of noise perturbations and measure the effect
on the output of pre-trained language models and different uncertainty metrics.
Realistic perturbations have minimal effect on performance and explanations,
yet masking has a drastic effect. We find that high uncertainty doesn't
necessarily imply low explanation plausibility; the correlation between the two
metrics can be moderately positive when noise is exposed during the training
process. This suggests that noise-augmented models may be better at identifying
salient tokens when uncertain. Furthermore, when predictive and epistemic
uncertainty measures are over-confident, the robustness of a saliency map to
perturbation can indicate model stability issues. Integrated Gradients shows
the overall greatest robustness to perturbation, while still showing
model-specific patterns in performance; however, this phenomenon is limited to
smaller Transformer-based language models.
|
[
-0.3582098484,
-1.1428692341,
0.6315973401,
0.1112324595,
-0.0581456609,
-0.255531162,
-0.2691513598,
-0.4974632859,
-0.3840666711,
0.0221504886,
-0.4736013412,
-0.0627513677,
-0.8709000945,
-0.0605322421,
-0.5023993254,
0.8111400008,
-0.0348854959,
0.073115848,
-0.2340381294,
0.2981058955,
-0.2492816299,
-0.5167385936,
-0.6801722646,
-0.1637868881,
0.610272646,
0.1723261029,
1.1848357916,
0.6885976195,
0.4766564667,
0.3500187993,
-0.3843027055,
-0.1113797501,
-0.4191376567,
0.3359386623,
-0.0402670987,
-0.6547302604,
-0.2983935475,
0.0323912054,
0.7386231422,
0.7695174813,
-0.1390367597,
-0.0228675604,
0.1772611141,
0.0260496289,
-0.66316998,
0.0282536279,
-0.6187447906,
-0.2239543498,
0.0094458992,
-0.0288805552,
-0.3591336012,
0.0947397947,
0.4898665547,
-0.7588933706,
0.1568874121,
0.1038716733,
1.3562563658,
0.7467992306,
0.1567394584,
-0.2875286937,
-1.2636681795,
0.8229561448,
-0.7855523229,
0.3275949657,
0.5147650242,
0.1833219528,
-0.1098302305,
-0.6191580892,
-0.5604475737,
-0.0157790948,
-0.1359198093,
0.1612037867,
-0.1776334047,
0.2640908062,
0.2830407619,
0.2780549526,
-0.0444112457,
0.3515900671,
-0.0916080996,
-0.3028794527,
0.4488936365,
-0.0114139896,
0.096026361,
0.177311793,
-0.0218915846,
-0.2476435155,
-0.4787975252,
0.3319785595,
0.6535416245,
0.1072212905,
-0.2078557312,
0.3253467381,
0.1286355257,
0.5493485332,
0.3435948491,
-0.1576235741,
-0.2112594843,
-0.3150346875,
-0.1929504424,
0.0484199412,
0.8084800839,
0.1011240184,
-0.0482710078,
-0.0137978746,
-0.1706161499,
0.0390315764,
0.3300074935,
-0.6631582379,
-0.213743493,
0.3709909618,
-0.390230149,
-0.4626221955,
0.1677033752,
-0.8616349101,
-0.3461085856,
-0.0780686066,
0.59435004,
-0.3508476317,
-0.3025279343,
0.2629477382,
0.0805533156,
-0.0009723635,
0.6031131744,
-0.9098007083,
0.0985279456,
0.4403368235,
0.4019295275,
0.0461158678,
-0.4640682638,
-0.210638091,
0.0394173302,
-0.3938652277,
0.6265724301,
-0.5781756043,
-0.2100745291,
0.0533280261,
-0.0737427026,
-0.03079441,
-0.2407069504,
0.5933294296,
-0.3214546442,
0.4130847454,
-0.0335843116,
-0.3298208714,
-0.2591051459,
-0.0007114579,
-0.6301332712,
0.9515842795,
-0.0401400737,
-0.8940039277,
0.415773958,
-0.7074424624,
-0.2957323492,
-0.4565036297,
-0.1951135099,
-0.74037081,
0.3089482188,
0.3698566258,
0.2811889052,
-0.1354442984,
0.2219332457,
-0.158417508,
-0.5214024782,
0.7104851604,
-0.9555093646,
0.5599427223,
-0.0105491253,
-0.4793340862,
0.0863904729,
-0.647811532,
-0.2821891606,
-0.0012655831,
-0.0695956871,
-0.1683413833,
0.2825810313,
-0.3727397323,
0.128481403,
0.0047099325,
-0.150827378,
-0.2871542871,
-0.4822232127,
0.5085575581,
0.6927543283,
0.0832712427,
0.3618780077,
-0.2248616964,
0.6715688109,
0.3547400534,
0.3722854555,
-0.4432654083,
-0.58509624,
-0.6855570674,
-0.0947481692,
0.4744247496,
0.248301357,
-0.2516359985,
-0.2490686178,
-0.1448515803,
-0.2736294866,
-0.8309546709,
-0.230346784,
0.3806164265,
0.5822027326,
0.1858042479,
-0.0299032964,
-0.3964268565,
-0.7482187152,
-0.3400300443,
-0.6411983371,
-0.0397846773,
0.1129778028,
0.3002156615,
-0.2079062313,
0.779296279,
-0.034020938,
0.3997701705,
0.0902715027,
0.4140026569,
-0.0816710517,
0.4221866131,
0.3699772358,
-0.8694223166,
-0.0237245504,
-0.2313091904,
-0.4224205911,
0.1210685,
-0.2588695884,
-0.0093580578,
0.3959640563,
0.3617797792,
-0.7204393148,
0.7071390748,
0.5648657084,
-0.110228464,
0.8359494209,
-0.1488133371,
0.1370979548,
-0.76719594,
-0.1325220913,
0.0227893032,
0.0494421609,
-0.5319814086,
-0.058015991,
-0.3501835763,
0.0771618783,
-0.1576438248,
0.0760135129,
-0.4072729051,
0.110641554,
0.0001758368,
0.2471190542,
0.1208681315,
0.0770204142,
-0.1221727803,
0.576585412,
0.7088015676,
-0.5705265999,
-0.1843205392,
-0.030628955,
-0.2415228933,
0.1300494969,
-0.8332346082,
-0.0691764727,
-0.2199832052,
-0.0810139701,
-1.0978113413,
-0.6392866969,
0.1903523058,
-0.7854316831,
0.5198694468,
-0.1188858449,
-0.2922511995,
-0.1571636051,
-0.0148307271,
0.1950123757,
0.3725360334,
-0.463304311,
0.6206917167,
0.1822942644,
-0.0437088758,
-0.7376437783,
-0.8430507779,
-0.1514075249,
-0.3950950205,
-0.6006789804,
0.1908204705,
-0.047072228,
-0.6718378067,
-0.0716538802,
-0.3883802593,
-0.1966006011,
0.6897902489,
0.7021743655,
0.2343539149,
-0.4180316329,
0.2757570744,
0.1137992963,
0.0139179165,
0.3972337544,
-0.0546545871,
0.165714711,
-0.2991935909,
-0.3224746883,
-0.8335744143,
0.0432720073,
0.7472733855,
-0.0184859317,
1.0477360487,
0.5298070312,
-0.3564614654,
-0.1569911093,
-0.3375996649,
-0.362280786,
-0.4898261428,
0.496596992,
-0.5242011547,
-0.7949917316,
0.6668608785,
-0.1107632145,
0.025286302,
0.6267732382,
0.4860913754,
-0.3996141255,
1.1924695969,
0.5714088082,
0.21000202,
0.4094846249,
0.0601961538,
0.380438894,
-0.3136487603,
-0.1484857649,
-0.7012094259,
-0.0773067325,
-0.5988357663,
-0.4008707702,
0.0083551109,
0.4459314942,
-0.3055323958,
-0.3072022796,
-0.4471599162,
0.3105018735,
0.3755571842,
-0.0458022766,
0.2630896866,
0.1336494088,
0.2306877971,
-0.1241562888,
-0.9178086519,
-0.6757127643,
0.7236545682,
0.7097352743,
0.9402765036,
0.0329350978,
0.2360256165,
-0.1096253395,
0.1364861578,
-0.5787140131,
0.0435427539,
0.1115158722,
-0.6063733101,
-0.6553832889,
-0.178801015,
-0.7811066508,
0.0185941402,
-0.4515141547,
-0.9425801635,
0.3635123074,
0.570777595,
-0.7068938613,
0.1203299165,
-0.6293253899,
0.6513495445,
-0.198435396,
-0.4008626342,
-0.0166451875,
-0.8156970143,
0.2944831252,
-0.0932113603,
0.4850675762,
0.2571022213,
0.084695518,
0.4548570812,
-0.3751471639,
0.9056167603,
0.0487491004,
-0.228439033,
0.2376539856,
0.2683002055,
0.5250137448,
0.1870732605,
-0.3739649653,
0.3876035511,
-0.0532704517,
-0.3247689307,
-0.8741520047,
0.3913126886,
-1.0005960464,
-0.8805502057,
-0.0659457296,
-0.606328249,
-0.0597090088,
-0.149649322,
0.6928606629,
0.3291027546,
0.1535020322,
0.0802272484,
0.8725345135,
-0.2467309982,
0.4384572804,
0.2528784275,
-0.2773398757,
-0.0030474898,
0.6407955289,
0.2402058393,
0.5234589577,
0.1584119797,
0.3275385797,
0.0360105745,
-0.8577504158,
-0.2774054408,
-0.0885835066,
-0.5150424838,
0.2008904964,
-0.4038220048,
-0.2531907558,
-0.0825162604,
-0.1715397686,
-0.5411012769,
-0.5061020255,
-0.426279068,
-0.3051995933,
0.2944148183,
0.8712534904,
-0.0380987227,
0.670969367,
-0.2935270965,
-0.0792197958,
0.0488245636,
0.5036666989,
0.0078053223,
-0.8690837026,
-0.5951707959,
0.3939807713,
0.020846352,
-0.936740458,
0.0466483943,
0.3027560711,
0.5201102495,
0.8989269733,
0.0272333063,
0.7993897796,
-0.1322422475,
1.0801635981,
-0.0818936229,
-1.0789819956,
0.7080158591,
-0.4401269257,
0.2332066745,
0.3028895855,
0.3400829434,
0.1358580589,
-0.7958289981,
-0.7990997434,
-0.7681167722,
0.7791262865,
0.260456562,
-0.0104023675,
0.227852121,
0.8551329374,
0.1819041818,
0.0473026223,
-0.5127670169,
-0.3743074238,
-0.3328125179,
0.0308847427,
0.0525915809,
-0.5819305778,
-0.2209118754,
-0.1464713663,
0.6346594095,
0.0716203898,
0.4043932855,
0.2932752073,
0.0146841686,
-0.4589196742,
-0.0036366237,
0.8160043955,
0.7279579043,
-0.1222073063,
0.2517621219,
-0.126239568,
-0.4459617138,
-0.1167906746,
0.1214486957,
-0.2723944187,
0.2361329794,
0.6050107479,
1.0571460724,
0.201894179,
-0.537419796,
0.3236134052,
-0.3149466813,
-0.1970252842,
-0.2038248628,
0.0159901381,
-0.1154644117,
0.1481944174,
0.2269677073,
0.3578313589,
-0.0858532116,
-0.4449451864,
-0.0812900439,
0.2478110641,
-0.4420130253,
-0.6423290372,
0.9945578575,
-0.1714522392,
-0.3943367898,
0.4143922329,
0.0515582748,
-0.5064553618,
0.6557430625,
0.5243853331,
0.5207777619,
-0.5180159211,
0.3087445796,
0.2250394374,
0.6882036924,
-0.2547475994,
0.0371960551,
0.2568818331,
-0.8175903559,
-0.643011868,
-0.5319003463,
-0.5419541001,
0.0732402429,
-0.8003672361,
-0.0418180414,
-0.4270818532,
-0.3393694758,
0.1398590952,
-0.4274357259,
-0.461966753,
0.3714141548,
0.0365640223,
0.3663054109,
-0.8246508241,
0.4745042324,
0.7779929638,
-0.5044296384,
-1.1348236799,
0.5493275523,
-0.0085536037,
-0.4668214321,
0.3637082577,
0.0057671131,
-0.2062706202,
-0.2150485963,
-0.7764518857,
-1.1481192112,
0.7895711064,
0.8710190654,
-0.5467254519,
-0.0188908204,
0.063902311,
0.7289340496,
-0.168926537,
0.3618980348,
0.5527648926,
0.610953331,
0.0138400672,
-0.9100342989,
-0.0369979888,
-0.0312122423,
-0.0095019955,
-0.0039373464,
-0.6551795006,
0.8869485259,
-0.3301228583,
-0.3577037752,
0.0508309901,
0.5323230624,
-0.1136352122,
0.1999555677,
0.3419819176,
0.4697313905,
0.9727395773,
-0.4127542973,
1.2437957525,
-0.4802645743,
0.2596597672,
1.2591148615,
0.2296873629,
0.7828789353,
0.6542666554,
-0.2092747837,
0.6875655651,
0.9372391701,
0.1607614905,
0.2252976745,
0.1141350418,
0.028734602,
-0.3175735772,
-0.0782184973,
-0.1233933493,
0.4524023235,
0.6253688931,
-0.55966717,
0.2380986214,
0.043005906,
-0.061933957,
-0.0963937268,
-0.2644535601,
0.4420993328,
-0.0301028546,
-0.5967057943,
0.5182583928,
-0.1559333056,
0.2728197277,
-0.2498858571,
0.1253138036,
-0.0226408709,
0.1514394879,
-0.2607371807,
-0.549718082,
0.3005504012,
-0.3116085529,
-0.4188094437,
-0.1137292534,
0.5654504299,
-0.3191325963,
-0.4362201691,
0.1758135855,
0.4248766005,
0.285397321,
0.0462491848,
-0.3955755234,
0.4289808273,
-0.1344574988,
-0.469740808,
0.1874718666,
0.769743681,
0.0399030857,
0.6367170215,
0.1771014184,
0.0002369614,
0.3063217998,
-0.0511690006,
0.6612462401,
-0.0436059237,
-0.088083677,
-1.006141305,
0.8904611468,
0.0941169485,
-0.3824009597,
0.8210395575,
0.049591478,
0.6316544414,
0.0881679431,
0.7517133355,
0.2633573711,
0.198389858,
-0.4800338149,
0.8428774476,
-0.5666571856,
0.5803602338,
-0.2585282028,
-0.654224813,
-0.3436055481,
0.6000760198,
-0.2280929983,
0.0219665468,
0.6132716537,
0.8249531984,
0.1904886216,
0.1768368632,
0.4215248525,
0.9136192203,
-0.0010170152,
-0.1984549314,
0.9257202148,
-0.4516783357,
0.5567138195,
-0.3661272526,
-0.0453397036,
-0.1975796819,
-0.7659096718,
-0.6282496452,
-0.544303,
-0.5509325862,
-0.5556483865,
0.3086941242,
0.3194743097,
0.7818112969,
-0.8550314903,
0.1726203263,
-0.2128460258,
0.3135709167,
-0.2889566123,
-0.2258147448,
0.3985940516,
-0.2691604793,
-0.7502927184,
0.2617669106,
0.1682132781,
0.2226357758,
-0.3891261816,
-0.0822970271,
0.0542208403,
0.4166192412,
0.3212468326,
0.1059574336,
-1.0154032707,
-0.3645488322,
-0.1273634881,
0.1806144863,
0.0575378686,
0.3765554726,
-0.51108706,
0.7741014361,
0.0182375144,
0.6626293063,
0.3238213062,
0.197057873,
0.8989580274,
-0.6163986325,
0.1766935438,
0.1167530045,
0.2472266108,
0.1822651476,
-0.6377986073,
0.2237534821,
-0.0383251831,
-0.6353395581,
-1.0749031305,
0.0814424977,
-0.4992772043,
-0.2555131018,
1.0186128616,
-0.4121251404,
-0.2145317048,
-0.1062994972,
-0.0325873531,
0.3739178777,
-0.4728080332,
1.1125459671,
1.1795880795,
-0.2294701338,
-0.4423474669,
-0.5610089302,
0.5788918734,
0.5911887884,
-0.4727590978,
-0.0177232996,
0.3903653622,
-0.0223593339,
0.3933940232,
-0.140813604,
-0.0839461237,
0.3677085042,
0.3974384367,
-0.2880133688,
0.0864760652,
-0.3315581679,
-0.6711654663,
0.1801616997,
0.4023017883,
-0.0113102691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12998v1
|
Phonotactic Complexity across Dialects
| 2024-02-20T13:25:39 | 2024-02-20T13:25:39 |
Ryan Soh-Eun Shim, Kalvin Chang, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Received wisdom in linguistic typology holds that if the structure of a
language becomes more complex in one dimension, it will simplify in another,
building on the assumption that all languages are equally complex (Joseph and
Newmeyer, 2012). We study this claim on a micro-level, using a
tightly-controlled sample of Dutch dialects (across 366 collection sites) and
Min dialects (across 60 sites), which enables a more fair comparison across
varieties. Even at the dialect level, we find empirical evidence for a tradeoff
between word length and a computational measure of phonotactic complexity from
a LSTM-based phone-level language model-a result previously documented only at
the language level. A generalized additive model (GAM) shows that dialects with
low phonotactic complexity concentrate around the capital regions, which we
hypothesize to correspond to prior hypotheses that language varieties of
greater or more diverse populations show reduced phonotactic complexity. We
also experiment with incorporating the auxiliary task of predicting syllable
constituency, but do not find an increase in the negative correlation observed.
|
[
-0.6554019451,
-0.795686543,
0.834762156,
0.2065425813,
-0.1877779663,
-0.0503660031,
-0.4819177687,
-0.6365894675,
0.4039580524,
0.4480033815,
-0.2500256896,
-0.4432584345,
-0.6324250698,
0.1870954484,
-0.0232846085,
0.3745303154,
0.331841141,
-0.1137851998,
-0.0655340701,
-0.2418341935,
-0.1809805334,
-0.7439525127,
-0.4541488588,
-0.6748631001,
0.3642878532,
0.4845017791,
0.6629997492,
0.5780004263,
0.3837130368,
0.3174634576,
-0.6488723159,
0.1896290034,
-0.1300706863,
0.1078795418,
0.0702390447,
-0.564062953,
-0.4700852931,
-0.3363084793,
0.4865206182,
1.3886618614,
-0.3179630935,
-0.0019076909,
-0.0828889981,
0.7335592508,
-0.4371453822,
0.2746425867,
-0.5473296642,
-0.0188899077,
-0.3564940393,
-0.1354335845,
-0.2514913082,
-0.3144946396,
0.5765504837,
-0.3553332686,
0.0932562202,
-0.062034633,
0.8076469898,
-0.1355376691,
-0.4091908336,
-0.2975420952,
-0.9621321559,
0.701541841,
-0.688225925,
0.1710083336,
0.5861750841,
0.1396865696,
0.0444524214,
-0.2237794995,
-0.5163010955,
-0.4350300133,
-0.0553186685,
0.04678379,
-0.2169094533,
0.4770180285,
0.2180721611,
0.6395295262,
-0.5744922161,
0.1660077274,
-0.4531844258,
-0.1506406963,
0.278003931,
0.2394758612,
0.3171691895,
-0.5084225535,
0.1184497327,
0.0595627651,
-0.3999387622,
0.3171246648,
0.5700688362,
0.5428899527,
-0.15450418,
0.7071216106,
-0.267005682,
0.7304548621,
-0.1251297295,
-0.3557675183,
0.2403095812,
-0.4051660895,
-0.154359743,
0.0654645637,
0.5463727713,
0.1149696484,
0.5318754315,
0.0959365889,
-0.1013325229,
-0.2103513777,
-0.1366419494,
-0.4374944568,
-0.3850128055,
0.346075058,
-0.3876982629,
0.038977541,
0.1319916397,
-0.4461879432,
-0.3524359465,
-0.2562669218,
0.3515144289,
-0.6640927792,
-0.6008487344,
0.5026031137,
-0.1386229843,
0.0591663159,
0.3116249442,
-0.9029631019,
0.4492605925,
0.8184091449,
1.1262531281,
-0.1312015951,
-0.3083148897,
-0.0067273099,
-0.1320415884,
-0.4806367159,
0.5385412574,
-0.4920786023,
-0.5260465741,
0.0576899946,
-0.2447169721,
-0.1211314574,
-0.7904821634,
0.2503196597,
-0.193412587,
0.0483709499,
-0.3939521313,
-0.4617429972,
-0.4001434147,
0.113655813,
-0.8688679338,
0.8912321925,
0.4347530007,
-0.4843534231,
0.5817015171,
-0.0163525604,
-0.6302688718,
-0.1493987888,
0.0381419696,
-0.5258724689,
0.6289544106,
-0.1072814837,
0.1916264892,
-0.1948531866,
0.0144645143,
-0.3331720531,
-0.2561978102,
0.1204240471,
-0.1240009069,
0.8724455237,
0.0901656821,
-0.1928129345,
-0.076263085,
-1.0026205778,
0.0199094117,
-0.0596928634,
-0.5231770277,
-0.6317136884,
-0.2563437819,
-0.2478050143,
0.0904352441,
0.0829701722,
-0.4555650949,
0.4047227502,
-0.5370943546,
0.343295306,
0.3788292408,
0.0854632258,
0.8313196898,
-0.4697256088,
0.6233267784,
0.1319262385,
0.0104358988,
0.0808871612,
-0.6462301612,
-0.9899746776,
-0.1991394758,
0.3343332708,
0.5563665628,
-0.3162040114,
0.4946824014,
-0.4663252234,
-0.4310750365,
-0.3116950691,
-0.0642564669,
0.3373528123,
0.1311751902,
0.3284473717,
-0.6496270895,
-0.436439991,
-1.0584566593,
0.0424972028,
-0.4499578774,
-0.0476834327,
0.2656900287,
0.2117252052,
0.1233144775,
0.7818165421,
-0.0649165213,
-0.1198063195,
-0.5234937668,
0.2214346677,
0.3428179622,
0.272361815,
0.5458202362,
-0.3496740162,
-0.3003418148,
0.3026600778,
-0.2400989085,
-0.3383700252,
0.1771636158,
0.3876115978,
0.2673713565,
0.2055787146,
-0.7428404093,
0.3779633343,
0.4314059615,
-0.0383617729,
0.6474334598,
-0.296241194,
0.0073610037,
-0.6439371109,
-0.2638710737,
-0.1576421559,
0.0112206042,
-0.8347767591,
-0.2378505617,
-0.3214250803,
0.0040534963,
-0.0679413676,
0.2211588919,
-0.5795204043,
-0.4028615057,
-0.0734302327,
-0.1434911042,
-0.0890016109,
0.599224031,
0.0488165431,
0.5093483329,
0.3567555845,
-0.6700484157,
0.1534020454,
-0.1713496298,
-0.7924265862,
0.1266730428,
-0.5926892757,
-0.2201457918,
0.0381388217,
-0.0420194641,
-1.095334053,
-0.2488452792,
-0.126210168,
-0.2175927162,
0.1644124389,
-0.2580670416,
-0.2831450999,
-0.230073303,
0.0823636949,
0.5350918174,
0.4340354502,
0.1029096842,
0.7647445202,
0.3948219419,
-0.3615261912,
-0.1483572572,
-1.0204510689,
-0.105826512,
-0.212016955,
-0.7564387321,
0.0302290022,
0.1160859689,
-0.8967924118,
-0.1848465353,
-0.3291962147,
-0.2438413203,
0.0026387125,
0.0501463078,
-0.4397085011,
-0.348330766,
0.2948791087,
-0.1580588371,
0.0827272758,
-0.0594135746,
-0.4782020152,
0.9159308672,
-0.227293402,
-0.3912785649,
-0.2699536979,
0.4535783231,
0.6394189596,
-0.1720300019,
0.4513136446,
0.1278680414,
-0.1954331696,
-0.394964844,
-0.5274516344,
0.0656547695,
-0.4020962119,
0.2950087488,
-0.7655047774,
-0.9850602746,
1.1094471216,
0.1171393842,
-0.3810245991,
0.3470796943,
0.7507881522,
0.1885429621,
0.5503230095,
0.6131694317,
-0.0260397457,
0.3896162212,
-0.1900160164,
0.121809572,
-0.1649754941,
-0.2634606957,
-0.5917458534,
-0.1101589724,
-0.8821213245,
-0.3595314622,
0.4191960096,
0.0483260341,
-0.1936121881,
0.3820136487,
-0.2165248394,
0.4436532855,
0.7202295661,
0.1319489479,
0.4080925286,
0.1495483071,
-0.249591127,
-0.0440767631,
-0.8170166612,
-0.1813300401,
0.731995225,
0.194716692,
0.3519996107,
0.3803203106,
0.8623481989,
0.2449739873,
-0.406762749,
-0.9732965827,
0.4277910292,
-0.2585343719,
-0.3440613449,
-0.5850778818,
-0.5261777043,
-0.8110218048,
0.2737593353,
0.0696871057,
-0.6486400962,
0.6106449366,
-0.0307622142,
-0.385045886,
0.3438419104,
-0.6633419394,
0.4012238383,
0.05992008,
-0.0478618294,
-0.2320026159,
-0.6912004352,
0.3600639403,
0.0688911974,
0.3843943179,
-0.1466216743,
0.1665227413,
0.3720041811,
-0.8920456767,
0.5712448359,
0.0361946411,
-0.4275032878,
0.4927642047,
0.5614955425,
0.124244459,
-0.2391470671,
-0.2692557573,
0.2588168383,
-0.1914847195,
-0.4857446253,
-0.4330248535,
0.3668129444,
-0.8129893541,
-0.6071894169,
-0.2916345596,
-0.541423738,
-0.2320367545,
0.1236226261,
0.5426004529,
0.4978339672,
0.0587192178,
0.2923703194,
0.6078612208,
-0.198621884,
0.2163817883,
0.2703961432,
-0.1186168417,
-0.2355405241,
0.7117031217,
0.6129065752,
0.6538599133,
0.6268014312,
0.466930747,
0.1267800927,
-0.8542435169,
0.0080966251,
-0.0454607457,
-0.7251569033,
0.3131498396,
-0.5541788936,
0.0091490149,
-0.2373314202,
0.0927198827,
-0.3383020163,
-0.9510473013,
0.2316130847,
-0.2742909491,
0.3130582571,
0.7596610188,
-0.3492829204,
0.4238163233,
-0.5568070412,
0.1428006291,
0.4920597374,
0.1709354222,
0.1086569205,
-0.5490570068,
-0.2122809142,
-0.0804050267,
0.2414681315,
-0.7626513839,
0.1789207608,
0.3528759778,
0.2420655936,
0.2416592985,
-0.2410677671,
0.5879043937,
-0.4442898333,
0.9315676093,
0.1545871198,
-1.0793033838,
0.1222364753,
-0.6249164343,
0.4382499754,
0.4814766943,
-0.0570074879,
-0.5138891935,
-0.6181055307,
-0.6246007085,
-1.1158008575,
0.3426912427,
0.132939443,
-0.0702122524,
0.0531816483,
0.3523445725,
0.1087695584,
0.1500980258,
-0.6658802629,
-0.3290344477,
-0.1534236819,
0.1712293029,
0.0454813652,
-0.5062362552,
0.0803930983,
-0.3965818584,
0.2802772224,
0.1772922277,
0.2040304095,
0.1527210772,
-0.1065323502,
-0.1846042573,
0.4968208671,
0.900336504,
0.9359078407,
-0.2933274209,
0.3962290287,
0.2378695458,
-0.5073313713,
0.2632599771,
-0.2091632932,
-0.0154123735,
0.2886657119,
0.9308775067,
0.768458426,
0.080468826,
-0.260330528,
0.3797276318,
0.364913851,
-0.4870228767,
-0.3586660922,
0.0774862319,
0.1276974231,
0.0751322582,
0.3559122384,
-0.0433033109,
0.1736848354,
-0.6368085146,
0.2417073399,
0.1184733137,
-0.1687093228,
-0.3345937431,
0.1842674017,
0.1008628085,
-0.2248655707,
0.38223809,
-0.2793549597,
-0.7070267797,
1.0032064915,
0.016050145,
0.8755831122,
-0.1751496941,
-0.0781520456,
0.3321817517,
0.6018873453,
-0.1153259277,
0.3525496721,
-0.0837648809,
-0.6271494031,
-0.5155243278,
-0.7663232088,
-0.6247326732,
0.300745368,
-0.6625944972,
0.0413273685,
-0.4091534615,
-0.1403087825,
0.1467883736,
0.165203169,
-0.3585142195,
0.0653746873,
0.14271079,
0.7381477952,
-0.7603108883,
0.7962295413,
0.3296262622,
-0.439994067,
-0.8954364061,
0.1965964288,
0.0623756535,
-0.7211407423,
0.6429219246,
0.0599209517,
-0.4103198946,
-0.2866318226,
-0.2184992731,
-0.5659015179,
0.6112880707,
0.1710975915,
-0.7144410014,
0.0139365885,
0.5758107305,
0.803401053,
-0.116917409,
0.1026718393,
0.6803709269,
0.617510736,
-0.0311321747,
-1.3519803286,
-0.3160176277,
-0.0968709961,
0.1302864999,
0.3100613952,
-0.4929175675,
1.4510837793,
-0.1698494107,
-0.2458226383,
0.195628345,
0.5835760832,
-0.0107180439,
0.1473489851,
0.6586006284,
0.7044630051,
0.6927453279,
-0.2594074905,
0.9713900685,
-0.44071123,
0.3101554513,
0.8089212179,
-0.1383362412,
0.3731932342,
0.2477116138,
-0.4067381918,
0.6047037244,
0.6575568318,
0.2570181191,
0.2818576694,
0.491597265,
-0.3150918186,
-0.5590686798,
-0.1059338301,
-0.317323029,
0.7616711855,
0.4098613262,
-0.0236484502,
-0.111639902,
-0.1219490618,
0.147961989,
0.2251765728,
-0.4183495045,
0.7772342563,
0.2466541976,
-0.6073108912,
0.7202808857,
-0.1071808264,
0.5321417451,
-0.7859598398,
0.1933638006,
-0.3785224259,
0.1736654788,
-0.1573752612,
-0.8434964418,
0.2556806207,
-0.5124698281,
-0.4204719961,
0.0709157363,
0.6011834741,
-0.7280746102,
-0.1023830026,
0.5053444505,
0.886957407,
0.0014412035,
-0.0040756539,
-0.1898425221,
-0.0439854078,
-0.1873995066,
-0.4579205811,
0.1328541785,
0.9733768106,
-0.0904978961,
0.6991406679,
0.4398027062,
0.5839252472,
0.1977283955,
0.3443342745,
0.4971803427,
-0.4872048199,
-0.7701938748,
-0.8004778028,
0.1223026812,
-0.0345285833,
-0.2967490554,
0.8237116337,
0.3956341445,
0.9655177593,
-0.1320621967,
0.9072383642,
-0.0458624102,
0.452729553,
-0.597715199,
0.301615566,
-0.6290622354,
0.2106178701,
-0.2346755266,
-0.7331783772,
-0.4423967302,
0.6309673786,
-0.3316308558,
0.2068062276,
0.6608243585,
0.5761677027,
-0.0943149179,
-0.225271076,
0.4252091944,
0.272698015,
0.0281907842,
0.4857431948,
0.5964542031,
0.1552868187,
0.5557480454,
-0.6106177568,
-0.0300386809,
-0.2940604985,
-0.6515676975,
-0.6486836076,
-0.6336830854,
0.0888079256,
-0.4802018106,
-0.0372579135,
0.8759118319,
0.4922255278,
-0.9575850368,
-0.674131453,
-0.2260655761,
0.1726713479,
-0.5083044171,
-0.2479730994,
0.3825398684,
-0.0510128848,
-0.8089520931,
0.1634440571,
0.4396082461,
0.0321451873,
-0.191703245,
0.0944070444,
-0.019551672,
0.1782391667,
0.7116575241,
0.337980181,
-0.7649089694,
-0.4976415932,
0.1007620543,
-0.344928205,
0.1243001446,
1.1347047091,
-0.1033465415,
0.625621736,
0.8574129939,
0.2637205422,
0.2420440763,
-0.1566549093,
0.6270178556,
-0.9321841002,
0.4040446281,
0.2211595178,
0.5892773867,
0.1971169263,
0.0285818856,
0.4298100173,
0.364590615,
-0.3536602855,
-0.4908312261,
0.6334289312,
-1.2128090858,
-0.469532609,
1.3114626408,
0.1087503508,
-0.0253198519,
-0.5305754542,
-0.0242743213,
0.0542733744,
-0.3236703575,
0.8112222552,
1.173640132,
-0.0815066621,
-0.2860024869,
-0.4273522496,
0.733604908,
0.411837846,
-0.4193605781,
0.1738360673,
0.4865383506,
0.0380296558,
0.613075614,
0.6983290315,
0.1162380725,
0.1568569392,
0.1007227078,
0.0911912397,
-0.1047559679,
-0.3889135122,
-0.4464479983,
0.4007200599,
0.2062948942,
0.220666945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12997v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12997v4
|
Towards Trustworthy Reranking: A Simple yet Effective Abstention Mechanism
| 2024-02-20T13:25:16 | 2024-04-02T12:56:53 |
Hippolyte Gisserot-Boukhlef, Manuel Faysse, Emmanuel Malherbe, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Neural Information Retrieval (NIR) has significantly improved upon
heuristic-based IR systems. Yet, failures remain frequent, the models used
often being unable to retrieve documents relevant to the user's query. We
address this challenge by proposing a lightweight abstention mechanism tailored
for real-world constraints, with particular emphasis placed on the reranking
phase. We introduce a protocol for evaluating abstention strategies in a
black-box scenario, demonstrating their efficacy, and propose a simple yet
effective data-driven mechanism. We provide open-source code for experiment
replication and abstention implementation, fostering wider adoption and
application in diverse contexts.
|
[
-0.1338165402,
-0.4795772135,
0.5107207298,
0.0167001802,
-0.2008217871,
0.3006224334,
-0.1606746316,
-0.4085426331,
0.3329724073,
-0.1012337506,
-0.3132872283,
-0.2520466447,
-0.4073721766,
-0.0134363854,
-0.7175894976,
1.0277875662,
0.0263566598,
-0.1397085935,
-0.4665302038,
-0.2028869539,
-0.313790381,
-0.3426086009,
-0.6050727367,
-0.8980875015,
0.8941501975,
0.667565167,
0.6269547939,
0.7180508971,
0.9905337095,
0.2060941458,
-0.1350808889,
-0.05742817,
-0.7618759274,
0.3513017595,
-0.3354569077,
-0.7749089003,
-0.0143557889,
0.0194339845,
0.5102549195,
0.5739061236,
-0.4312572479,
-0.005807545,
0.1474491209,
0.5760672688,
-1.0543111563,
-0.2162412107,
-0.8480919003,
0.1230619922,
-0.1046773493,
-0.3378413916,
-0.6551886201,
-0.6727868915,
0.2246368825,
-0.5143020749,
0.1966769397,
0.193563506,
1.0118026733,
0.244050011,
-0.0655466914,
-0.0202505644,
-0.6614598632,
0.6257247329,
-0.4258135855,
0.2892388999,
0.4780802429,
0.4744954109,
0.195522964,
-0.915884912,
-0.4335494936,
-0.3115361035,
-0.1198280901,
-0.0163264982,
-0.2086569518,
-0.207712695,
-0.1268090159,
0.2825892866,
-0.2264891118,
-0.0447528213,
-0.3682656288,
-0.173536703,
0.1338617504,
0.0176234208,
0.0133291418,
-0.1498777717,
-0.3663864136,
-0.1817485988,
-0.8258401155,
-0.4453160167,
0.473665446,
0.2600495815,
0.0155240204,
0.6418890357,
-0.4004200101,
0.3411421478,
0.0857279375,
0.3052284122,
0.1790557206,
-0.2881914079,
0.147693485,
0.1320073456,
0.3645734787,
0.4798714817,
0.141798839,
-0.7088534236,
-0.7151494622,
-0.0164876468,
0.7191437483,
-0.8450833559,
-0.1485311836,
-0.0100229923,
-0.5630603433,
-0.697591424,
0.2524582148,
-0.4254972041,
-0.0529262647,
0.0028005263,
0.9509281516,
-0.5871495008,
-0.1472277194,
-0.2382701486,
-0.3210901022,
0.3556165099,
0.2394402474,
-0.6493233442,
0.465577513,
1.094822526,
1.2100265026,
-0.1001389623,
-0.1848203391,
-0.3825652897,
0.0700015798,
-0.1991375536,
0.4328932762,
-0.3696903884,
-0.2811885476,
-0.2938956618,
-0.2260650843,
0.1482672393,
-0.6205981374,
0.4655636251,
-0.6344736218,
-0.287696749,
-0.0934114158,
-0.4793571532,
-0.091076225,
0.5707694292,
-0.6419197321,
0.4649063349,
-0.043531131,
-0.7791829109,
0.3230161369,
-0.5120296478,
-0.3188273907,
0.0256629791,
0.0864063203,
-0.7059766054,
0.3250171244,
-0.207176879,
0.0589663126,
-0.2118082941,
0.1019423977,
-0.3867457509,
-0.7771032453,
0.1437498629,
-0.5228096843,
0.5134551525,
0.3940076828,
-0.4580608606,
-0.0429581404,
-0.2822615504,
0.3261902332,
0.2220805138,
0.0120394295,
-0.7042789459,
0.0325009488,
-0.0178790353,
-0.3970208764,
0.001526119,
-0.678296566,
0.2102352381,
-0.4481961131,
0.544575572,
0.721304059,
0.0716404989,
0.4058060646,
-0.6104911566,
0.1550419033,
-0.4428876936,
0.3874203861,
0.1479043216,
-0.2448875755,
-0.5473408699,
-0.0615335144,
0.7215203643,
0.555552423,
-0.8792048097,
0.1576544493,
-0.4457822144,
-0.6468555927,
-0.6818119884,
0.004095152,
1.0122298002,
0.5084637403,
0.3560580313,
-0.4037134647,
-0.1631778777,
-1.1956896782,
-0.1340773255,
-0.2384129465,
-0.0669187978,
0.1691650152,
0.8096410632,
-0.0825365037,
0.8590814471,
-0.6511417031,
-0.4417075813,
-0.0303467698,
0.5551165938,
-0.2247885913,
0.8112925887,
0.3617430031,
-1.1593768597,
-0.1363390088,
-0.2343184799,
-0.8913185,
0.2738007903,
0.1744986176,
-0.1927880496,
-0.0664529055,
0.6156994104,
-0.3078016639,
0.8478909731,
0.1963496208,
-0.1005998701,
0.48046574,
-0.0953866839,
0.2131567001,
-0.760459125,
0.412291944,
-0.0938671529,
-0.3701199889,
-0.3321551383,
0.5259240866,
0.2573285997,
-0.0404721014,
-0.3602099121,
0.3295144439,
-0.2675783038,
0.0819608197,
-0.1563142687,
0.0572477058,
0.0315018594,
0.1123739779,
0.0177635271,
0.6394101381,
0.0946438611,
-0.4906801879,
-0.0738472715,
0.334593147,
-0.5558395982,
0.8002628684,
-1.0097546577,
0.0728481188,
-0.2457354069,
0.03009139,
-0.8828696012,
-0.1276215315,
0.3103071451,
-0.6415030956,
0.2963021696,
-0.5472743511,
-0.3340179622,
-0.0207455605,
-0.4550523758,
0.6851930022,
0.2294779718,
-0.7418179512,
0.1433154196,
0.0274915043,
-0.1601838022,
-0.8084792495,
-0.7672793865,
0.3188157678,
-0.0088534355,
-0.3797836602,
0.6687542796,
-0.1249270439,
-0.488824755,
0.4647886455,
-0.376024574,
-0.1459645927,
0.3717266321,
0.250457406,
0.0213969871,
0.1110961437,
0.0109749064,
-0.1414202154,
-0.3298150003,
-0.0854708701,
-0.1184164137,
0.2123354822,
-0.1265277714,
-0.7357245088,
-0.4070230722,
0.3426735401,
0.6250164509,
-0.1877728999,
0.8781392574,
0.2822413445,
-0.4864795804,
-0.31353122,
-0.5241327882,
-0.859364748,
-0.5253326297,
0.0465891883,
-0.3113882244,
-0.618974328,
0.4906766117,
-0.005230281,
0.1594572812,
-0.1475233436,
0.0962641463,
-0.0804023072,
0.7203611135,
0.6835775971,
0.0326554216,
0.5824667811,
-0.2565721273,
0.3127640784,
-0.8495607972,
-0.4329025745,
-0.7187405825,
-0.6630772948,
-0.253074795,
-0.1649640203,
0.4227274954,
-0.0104198847,
0.1789756119,
0.1287657768,
-0.7775131464,
0.7267997861,
0.8375116587,
0.4546641707,
0.1597603261,
0.0066755693,
-0.2707148492,
-0.171887055,
-0.5529049039,
-0.1233705282,
0.8548781276,
0.1018232778,
1.1397699118,
0.4666986763,
1.0076836348,
0.4086156487,
0.7598682046,
-0.7884494662,
0.3140125871,
0.031541694,
-0.7638202906,
-0.3318378925,
-0.7744630575,
-0.8591329455,
0.1917893738,
-0.3378899097,
-0.676692009,
0.4212566614,
0.0744559765,
-0.2633402944,
0.3577499986,
-0.7991681099,
0.4903472066,
-0.204744488,
-0.7474098206,
-0.1646135598,
-0.6227579117,
0.2986619473,
-0.0251700021,
-0.1827645898,
0.1687324494,
-0.0054909606,
0.6944786906,
-0.5257456899,
0.5928379893,
-0.3892779052,
0.4034855068,
0.0241316129,
0.499075532,
0.5793745518,
0.2399092764,
-0.416944325,
0.0356823541,
-0.3015099168,
-0.247364074,
-0.8130825162,
0.7751530409,
-0.4944284558,
-0.5244789124,
-0.4416965842,
-0.4032031,
0.0872219205,
0.5002884865,
0.2290564775,
0.3756859601,
-0.1946033239,
0.9051150084,
0.7546488047,
0.1616785675,
0.2914048731,
0.6328854561,
0.0303455833,
-0.6167669892,
1.1196199656,
0.2322750539,
0.3323508501,
0.4810112119,
0.2450555861,
-0.1930769831,
-0.9422209859,
0.094381392,
-0.0018311706,
-0.4734805226,
-0.524923563,
-0.2563414872,
-0.1805255562,
-0.2696577907,
-0.4541683495,
-0.5395377278,
-0.5846867561,
0.2419647425,
-0.4582117796,
0.368147552,
0.6569190025,
-0.3210447729,
0.2667542398,
-0.2084427923,
0.416991502,
0.2376945168,
0.7854310274,
0.1813328117,
-0.3868408203,
-0.1542583704,
-0.160817489,
-0.1283437759,
-0.538506031,
0.4815948009,
0.080513157,
0.8379341364,
0.3149148226,
0.4375538826,
0.5626490712,
-0.3626073003,
0.1217817739,
0.0414060727,
-0.8522465229,
0.4581065774,
-0.1426285207,
0.0908858925,
1.206887126,
0.3444363475,
-0.4648210108,
-0.4647283852,
-0.4126766324,
-1.3895977736,
0.5156924725,
0.5463123918,
-0.0442701615,
0.0941741094,
0.778573513,
-0.0118476907,
0.3170323372,
-0.6680760384,
-0.4103836119,
-0.2504618168,
-0.2417185754,
0.0017269721,
-0.321669817,
-0.2798108459,
-0.0487992354,
0.7179430723,
-0.0976509079,
0.243508786,
0.5635391474,
-0.3240763545,
0.0012769327,
0.1090071574,
0.3913607597,
0.5506668091,
-0.7678253651,
0.2537374496,
-0.3824383914,
-0.4901237786,
0.362057209,
-0.0694935992,
-1.021417141,
-0.2662827671,
0.1190911382,
0.2086325735,
0.5665201545,
-0.1930544078,
0.4190484583,
-0.5210000277,
-0.5805789828,
-0.1970964819,
-0.1030328199,
0.0007234284,
-0.135882929,
0.5881003141,
0.0615980439,
0.2454012334,
-0.3494732976,
0.9853702188,
0.5060268044,
-0.7420731187,
0.0675779209,
0.7872079611,
0.3648605943,
-0.5457544327,
0.908839643,
-0.3392234445,
-0.3760378659,
0.5741885304,
0.5785066485,
0.7030488849,
-0.0318049937,
0.3071853817,
0.2105219066,
0.7067284584,
-0.4260361195,
0.1221622527,
0.0206868518,
-0.6726876497,
-0.1595003754,
-0.2754307985,
-0.797565043,
-0.2974312603,
-1.1457853317,
-0.2423394322,
-0.7143524289,
-0.2256645113,
0.0918375328,
0.0051308959,
-0.2558665872,
-0.1169921756,
-0.1545304805,
1.1865984201,
-0.489534229,
0.5387957096,
0.4830226302,
-0.5617906451,
-0.3655297458,
0.1747276336,
0.3126448691,
-0.5742265582,
0.5744057894,
0.1769600809,
-0.2640579045,
-0.0145018259,
-0.8394516706,
-0.7740308642,
1.1086534262,
0.4523134232,
-0.4516402781,
0.2232691199,
-0.439348191,
0.2030005455,
0.0513495766,
0.2622735798,
0.0278335065,
0.7572000027,
-0.04529652,
-0.6917484999,
0.207823813,
-0.4401070774,
-0.427043885,
0.2088427842,
-0.8708071709,
0.7101915479,
-0.2627111375,
-0.1263984442,
0.3050124645,
0.5972836018,
0.1588092744,
0.6387230158,
0.6953015327,
0.7882913351,
0.737459898,
-0.19355838,
1.0177865028,
-0.1713096648,
0.1485552937,
1.1373054981,
-0.5080777407,
0.9169459939,
0.6994768977,
0.3923103809,
0.4690671265,
0.0735384822,
0.0745077729,
0.8866578937,
0.4229815602,
-0.3084637225,
-0.2403376549,
-0.418607384,
-0.0281924028,
0.4960843623,
0.2818393111,
-0.0666003749,
-0.3472022712,
-0.1321736276,
0.0125275068,
0.3147245646,
-0.1484367251,
0.6541749239,
0.2011820227,
-0.6910869479,
0.3608698845,
0.1333293468,
0.8369420767,
-0.7621487975,
-0.3377475441,
-0.2970679998,
0.435849607,
-0.165296331,
-0.4920657277,
0.3971048594,
-0.1076019481,
-0.3182037473,
-0.3818316758,
0.7872482538,
-0.1082433164,
-0.295055598,
0.4123877287,
0.5998385549,
-0.0008067355,
0.0470663235,
-0.7053341269,
0.1569755673,
-0.0924502686,
-0.1998474449,
0.6014180183,
0.2473958582,
-0.0924688727,
1.2466547489,
0.695885241,
-0.0095113292,
-0.4186250269,
0.0362077877,
0.676930666,
-0.5893164277,
-0.4931851327,
-0.5508687496,
0.147266984,
-0.1210721582,
0.1378516406,
0.8879473209,
0.512579143,
0.7296571136,
0.4166554511,
0.7664371133,
-0.1192431971,
0.3657023013,
-0.1203971654,
1.2205872536,
-0.7133100033,
0.3245069683,
-0.1215017289,
-0.5070417523,
-0.5928869843,
0.7368274331,
-0.1534972638,
-0.1209493354,
0.3769389093,
1.020641923,
-0.1077489927,
-0.3228020966,
0.2633308768,
0.0326261893,
0.314027518,
0.2320283353,
0.6753377318,
-0.295140624,
0.941083014,
-0.632455349,
-0.1722447425,
-0.5528466105,
-0.8644965887,
-0.4824908078,
-0.1623294801,
-0.2649246156,
-0.3789969683,
0.7744367123,
0.5891293883,
1.0740118027,
-0.6078822613,
0.1004427895,
0.0869070143,
0.7746667862,
-0.6170258522,
-0.247269839,
0.0399391092,
0.0018923162,
-0.3461776972,
0.5281301737,
0.0419482067,
-0.1155580506,
-0.0759461895,
-0.0923913419,
-0.2392194569,
0.0095871286,
0.1696267724,
0.539471209,
-0.2200230211,
-0.6522259116,
0.0159528628,
-0.10198991,
-0.208719939,
0.9002303481,
-0.8333055377,
0.2781662643,
0.515640676,
0.6032981873,
0.1986822337,
0.5061845183,
0.7277581692,
-1.0295813084,
-0.0726978406,
0.4994676411,
0.1192235127,
0.262860477,
-0.3269355297,
0.893727839,
0.2307979614,
-0.4861647487,
-1.3832015991,
-0.052061379,
-0.7701255083,
-0.3687644601,
0.7452085018,
-0.0941077024,
-0.4511801898,
-0.2974244058,
0.2687985003,
-0.0484089479,
-0.7085676193,
1.0511018038,
0.4007344246,
0.2364650965,
-0.1606716961,
-0.230803296,
0.0344435424,
0.6109057665,
-0.4261900187,
0.1124584451,
0.2345047444,
0.425621599,
0.4310792089,
0.5805667043,
-0.2156888098,
0.2473468333,
0.307397157,
0.2046471685,
-0.4263574779,
-0.6532152891,
-0.218370527,
0.4635326862,
0.2210052609,
-0.0811590329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12991v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12991v2
|
TRAP: Targeted Random Adversarial Prompt Honeypot for Black-Box Identification
| 2024-02-20T13:20:39 | 2024-06-06T17:46:48 |
Martin Gubri, Dennis Ulmer, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Seong Joon Oh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language Model (LLM) services and models often come with legal rules on
who can use them and how they must use them. Assessing the compliance of the
released LLMs is crucial, as these rules protect the interests of the LLM
contributor and prevent misuse. In this context, we describe the novel
fingerprinting problem of Black-box Identity Verification (BBIV). The goal is
to determine whether a third-party application uses a certain LLM through its
chat function. We propose a method called Targeted Random Adversarial Prompt
(TRAP) that identifies the specific LLM in use. We repurpose adversarial
suffixes, originally proposed for jailbreaking, to get a pre-defined answer
from the target LLM, while other models give random answers. TRAP detects the
target LLMs with over 95% true positive rate at under 0.2% false positive rate
even after a single interaction. TRAP remains effective even if the LLM has
minor changes that do not significantly alter the original function.
|
[
-0.1837536991,
-1.1706223488,
0.472291857,
0.0777102038,
-0.2262854278,
0.3081717789,
-0.0662545413,
-0.4420468509,
0.1372932047,
0.7931813002,
-0.6608449221,
-0.4807011783,
-0.611962676,
0.0864843428,
-0.6512277126,
0.8987990022,
0.3986696899,
-0.1620348394,
0.0741897896,
0.1843899637,
-0.8672665954,
-0.5586045384,
-0.6250342727,
-0.0257121716,
0.5683298111,
0.1905815452,
0.5159263015,
0.4681457281,
0.2446166277,
0.3047289252,
-0.0909492671,
0.135225594,
-0.399004519,
-0.0724679455,
0.050897222,
-0.9576233029,
-0.0162259378,
0.0426720828,
0.2835756838,
0.2493742555,
-0.0666827559,
0.3765843809,
-0.0508535691,
0.0726096109,
-0.6992024183,
-0.2280922234,
-0.8333773613,
-0.1443449557,
-0.6536729932,
-0.254643321,
-0.7690264583,
-0.4010993242,
-0.2818539143,
-0.1401647627,
0.392705977,
0.2935265005,
0.8742474914,
0.3572227657,
-0.2877531946,
-0.1772876531,
-0.8998738527,
0.4430809617,
-0.6956499219,
-0.1395948827,
0.1376101822,
0.47406587,
-0.654029429,
-0.1588498354,
-0.5732262731,
-0.4640729725,
0.0160424151,
-0.3850147724,
-0.4567662477,
-0.247920081,
0.3364937007,
0.1527911127,
-0.6785978079,
0.1990446448,
-0.5789614916,
-0.5740284324,
0.4968535304,
0.1483731866,
0.4566505849,
0.0030693684,
-0.5888957381,
0.2100597471,
-0.919547379,
0.263384521,
0.7293372154,
0.5271311998,
-0.1197636873,
0.7364350557,
0.1560153961,
0.7495243549,
0.2326429635,
-0.113036342,
0.0799116939,
0.0186410584,
-0.1026944965,
0.1430889666,
0.8093647361,
0.0651689693,
0.3526630104,
-0.3008812964,
-0.1113302484,
0.15211761,
0.3311463594,
-0.7452750206,
-0.1556862593,
0.3560127318,
-0.2260194421,
-0.5394532681,
0.2090163529,
-0.7535722852,
-0.9297320843,
0.1886074692,
0.3508117795,
-0.212090537,
-0.239319399,
-0.2412442267,
-0.2963837087,
0.4462436438,
0.1050684378,
-0.6221557856,
0.1020165831,
0.8809382319,
0.7564268708,
-0.0727408305,
-0.0809332728,
-0.9890585542,
0.0179528296,
-0.4387691319,
0.6457378268,
-0.4742806554,
-0.286372155,
0.0848724619,
0.1506023109,
0.0973396823,
-0.655734241,
0.0290413126,
-0.9316461086,
-0.003386165,
-0.0043733348,
-0.4402359128,
0.039845977,
0.3209474385,
-0.6270327568,
0.7643623948,
0.0830919817,
-0.4933733046,
0.3481150568,
-0.3701689243,
-0.3562630713,
0.7161111832,
-0.1786265522,
-0.5583007932,
0.097596094,
0.011900885,
0.4748882353,
-0.069917582,
0.1570941508,
-0.7715877295,
-0.6539266706,
0.6206305623,
-0.4146024883,
1.2772376537,
0.2167068273,
-0.3830460012,
0.0159375444,
-0.8087151647,
-0.2602038682,
0.3127002716,
-0.1000081748,
-0.5021296144,
-0.2437023073,
-0.1826742738,
-0.0959187746,
0.4771334231,
-0.8539210558,
0.2481053025,
-0.3357268572,
0.0645552203,
0.7451177239,
0.1626179069,
0.1109666303,
-0.0761927888,
0.8691046834,
-0.0260212962,
0.1682444811,
-0.2429757267,
-0.8040193915,
-0.2000905871,
-0.7188473344,
0.3497442305,
1.0401754379,
-0.6189002395,
0.5263386965,
0.1467426568,
-0.5214255452,
-0.5784047842,
0.427954644,
0.587900281,
0.0937016234,
-0.0227331258,
0.0435864143,
-0.2720680237,
-0.9463374615,
-0.2405956388,
-0.040705353,
-0.1900396198,
0.5937362313,
0.438054204,
-0.3150799274,
0.9449532628,
-0.4184997082,
-0.2920313478,
-0.1746253818,
0.0985548198,
0.4443757534,
0.1399810463,
0.7613774538,
-0.7004549503,
-0.4387351573,
-0.1718335003,
-0.5052019358,
-0.4077499211,
-0.1553969085,
-0.0016319773,
0.1066349074,
0.5225930214,
-0.6553463936,
0.4552744925,
0.6368778944,
-0.5527303815,
0.6277416348,
0.0553285629,
0.1379327178,
-1.1433221102,
0.2252192944,
0.1269811988,
-0.1336556375,
-0.6247132421,
0.2747435868,
0.2393618077,
-0.4089275301,
-0.6077706218,
0.8303838372,
-0.423802346,
0.1228458732,
-0.3577945828,
0.0947459862,
-0.5103281736,
0.3264858127,
-0.5444976091,
1.1153475046,
0.3703258038,
-0.4618092179,
0.8450086117,
0.1090843827,
-0.2579895854,
0.6820317507,
-0.631550014,
0.2153386474,
-0.0691126138,
0.1298295856,
-1.2072156668,
-0.2150301635,
0.6754254699,
-0.7829357386,
0.2957519591,
-0.5235644579,
-0.4892827868,
-0.5994954705,
-0.1810676903,
0.1118729562,
0.5121802092,
-0.6608692408,
0.7059512138,
0.2672029734,
0.1723740697,
-1.0358430147,
-0.5708063841,
0.2425392419,
-0.4351481497,
-0.4279824495,
0.0951348543,
-0.0557038002,
-0.1855661422,
0.0473773144,
0.1087194607,
0.023717856,
0.5868883133,
0.4424605668,
0.5009083748,
-0.1640361995,
-0.4066350162,
-0.4585231245,
-0.0451961607,
0.408326,
0.0306384601,
0.5492556691,
0.1744307131,
-0.1541469693,
-0.3691649437,
0.5484266877,
0.5506126881,
-0.2507427037,
0.7782056928,
0.6181896329,
-0.4077434838,
-0.5770839453,
-0.5495365262,
-0.2385271937,
-0.5513914227,
0.0607992634,
-0.5253450274,
-0.791667819,
0.8044535518,
0.20659554,
-0.1028486416,
-0.0953372642,
0.5704233646,
0.1976608783,
0.8535152078,
0.8445903659,
-0.3268391788,
0.4595187604,
0.175948441,
0.4289047718,
-0.6724662781,
-0.1525675505,
-0.5273362398,
-0.1010028422,
-0.5452458858,
-0.1367883086,
0.1806279272,
-0.0206774641,
0.1887618452,
0.6068052053,
-0.4173820019,
0.5849271417,
0.87369591,
0.3307483494,
-0.0552737303,
-0.3235995173,
-0.2806156576,
0.3086271584,
-0.2146591991,
-0.4858400226,
1.2760282755,
0.2740367651,
0.779215157,
0.2939296663,
0.7796348333,
0.4947921932,
0.6926804185,
-0.5465856791,
0.8881052732,
-0.010780842,
-1.077677846,
-0.1880218089,
-0.4194760621,
-1.2246361971,
-0.151043579,
-0.1218016446,
-1.203825593,
-0.1623111814,
0.4026848674,
-0.5752118826,
0.2889109254,
-0.7643636465,
0.9619929194,
-0.0681623593,
-0.1545612663,
0.1635514945,
-0.4321806729,
0.7670170069,
-0.2335947603,
0.0185859129,
-0.3900153935,
0.1950169206,
0.3547647595,
-0.321770519,
1.1271300316,
-0.4974583089,
-0.0840044245,
0.2616189718,
0.2360573113,
0.7290605307,
0.0827649608,
0.2688087225,
0.0674614832,
-0.016265329,
-0.3444406688,
-0.6990311146,
0.6309059262,
-0.6248685718,
-1.0527199507,
-0.3736881316,
-0.1384252608,
0.0014206343,
0.2275968194,
0.2321977466,
0.3516988158,
-0.1252668649,
0.2015175968,
0.7953805923,
-0.3244974315,
0.1984296739,
0.8491362333,
-0.1629332006,
-0.1428399384,
0.8470340967,
-0.2875041664,
-0.0037400178,
0.4608377218,
0.1838652641,
-0.217320621,
-0.70289886,
-0.6767104268,
0.3669408262,
-0.4546955824,
-0.3428699374,
-0.3833558559,
-0.3263071775,
-0.1953581423,
-0.0456754789,
-0.1148933619,
0.2608871162,
-0.2969835401,
0.2369330823,
0.4616833925,
0.4557379484,
0.2229842842,
0.2896278799,
-0.6772022843,
0.4205760658,
0.4698186517,
0.3048329353,
-0.2811946273,
-0.572065413,
0.0163429305,
-0.0643643513,
-0.0081822202,
-1.460903883,
0.1928342283,
-0.2864208221,
0.7414577603,
0.3555589616,
0.1849192977,
0.2993997335,
-0.5665522814,
0.8162670732,
-0.0439230017,
-0.6610907912,
0.6377690434,
-0.3792951405,
0.2064196765,
0.2636886239,
0.2557795644,
-0.3602386713,
-0.9830967188,
-0.4774208069,
-0.6640568972,
0.3849401176,
-0.0422423668,
0.4059017599,
0.0068184682,
0.380009979,
-0.1672385633,
0.3106947243,
-0.834415257,
-0.651383698,
0.2579741776,
-0.2317925394,
-0.1425861269,
-0.3907980621,
-0.24580805,
0.4225232303,
0.5490780473,
0.0801001787,
0.3267716765,
-0.2182300687,
-0.0511043705,
-0.0006636358,
0.3066933751,
0.5927972794,
0.2649109364,
-0.2733135819,
0.0953812003,
-0.018027531,
-0.5659621954,
0.3717206419,
0.2856273949,
-0.4532622695,
-0.0281858444,
0.167323947,
0.3197027743,
-0.0658341274,
-0.6831341982,
0.9078754187,
-0.2787830234,
0.011340349,
-0.5100365281,
0.4106232226,
-0.2043943554,
0.4189890027,
0.8199076653,
0.0311747286,
0.1669262946,
-0.333604306,
0.2724883854,
1.0931609869,
-0.1605083197,
-0.1593216658,
0.6963947415,
0.2900390029,
-0.8363571167,
0.4187019765,
-0.4364768863,
-0.6434771419,
0.8307614326,
0.6794583797,
1.0106981993,
-0.5872911811,
0.1174630001,
0.2135336399,
0.6292218566,
0.3547464907,
0.1468007267,
0.0426740982,
-0.8635204434,
-0.3360047936,
-0.297347039,
-0.4540796876,
0.5646102428,
-0.5581277609,
0.6028855443,
-0.5928225517,
-0.1709642857,
0.2392069548,
0.0169942658,
-0.5862470865,
-0.1177663133,
0.6025563478,
0.7721161246,
-1.1076977253,
0.5937296748,
0.3642928004,
0.0481977724,
-0.6513742805,
-0.0851800144,
0.5284129977,
-0.9476322532,
0.2603310645,
0.4361274838,
-0.1989837438,
0.0400389805,
-0.7878655791,
-0.8097052574,
0.7903164029,
0.3585548103,
-0.5713456273,
0.3357768059,
-0.1455497593,
0.2571800053,
-0.2119349092,
0.0500186123,
0.5861440301,
0.3751302361,
-0.0079407394,
-0.6710227728,
0.4280691743,
-0.435654819,
0.0147505878,
0.4253991246,
-0.4532382488,
0.4058767855,
-0.4518660903,
-0.381519258,
0.2388567328,
0.5320036411,
0.6557317376,
0.2755692005,
0.4619419277,
0.2596463859,
0.6998457909,
-0.0690107793,
0.8789178729,
-0.4278044701,
0.0586816482,
0.863828063,
-0.336346209,
0.7411843538,
0.4434889555,
-0.2008097768,
0.2918055058,
0.5090168118,
-0.7458746433,
0.409427017,
0.5568038225,
-0.3265699446,
0.0595574118,
0.1138356626,
-0.1675986648,
0.3440022469,
0.398633182,
-0.1678983122,
0.0200578049,
0.3128145337,
0.2788915634,
0.1690310389,
-0.2140465826,
0.6175920367,
-0.2521167994,
-0.7410176992,
0.5829379559,
0.1143471301,
0.7712262869,
-0.5995126963,
0.1028936878,
-0.136707589,
0.2845074236,
-0.0040073954,
-0.5303740501,
-0.0038217034,
0.0515333153,
-0.1310817748,
0.1011254862,
0.5583249331,
-0.4756114483,
-0.3155969381,
0.263261795,
0.1447021067,
0.1305674464,
-0.0213391557,
-0.6827740073,
0.2272900641,
0.033270169,
-0.1533749104,
0.0630855486,
0.2741972208,
0.148049742,
0.9565879703,
0.8571861386,
0.2846274078,
0.2143980265,
-0.0913762897,
0.6139034033,
-0.6177085638,
-0.5875462294,
-1.0982456207,
0.2919426858,
-0.2188063562,
-0.2724170387,
0.993545413,
0.4996390045,
0.6150920987,
-0.1786148101,
0.7883150578,
-0.062357109,
0.6047079563,
-0.3940527439,
0.4732131958,
-0.2327610254,
0.5773291588,
-0.1483720988,
-0.6614993811,
-0.2372222394,
0.0858245641,
-0.2630979121,
-0.0168824233,
0.5878029466,
1.2590645552,
-0.0047013699,
-0.3836344779,
0.4118338823,
-0.0104489895,
0.452940464,
0.7920993567,
0.9609867334,
-0.3515793681,
0.8812261224,
-0.0414862894,
-0.586109221,
-0.7161996365,
-0.853706181,
-1.3433738947,
-0.2599310875,
-0.5429083705,
-0.6460865736,
0.1573799253,
0.7010790706,
0.7594905496,
-0.7706408501,
0.0356194749,
0.2890752256,
0.2570813596,
-0.3433039784,
-0.2802755833,
-0.0886776894,
0.0252053943,
-0.5546433926,
0.4532254338,
0.1949252188,
0.3296906948,
-0.485404402,
0.3954127431,
0.0951697677,
0.3231149018,
-0.0081334151,
0.6858173609,
-0.9903998375,
-0.3520249426,
0.0181005038,
-0.403421104,
-0.2480329573,
0.7969499826,
-0.5335977674,
0.2679559886,
-0.0455486178,
0.8154414892,
0.2839396298,
0.1599898487,
0.6272685528,
-0.9569255114,
0.3143093288,
0.163273856,
0.1940139979,
0.1744188368,
-0.8853929639,
-0.0615220964,
0.2425422668,
-0.3705377281,
-1.0275181532,
0.3770451844,
-0.9880498052,
-0.4168741703,
1.3237370253,
-0.2775670886,
-0.5657233596,
-0.3574385941,
-0.1345557719,
-0.191623494,
-0.3529781401,
0.8433473706,
0.62751019,
0.386459738,
-0.4482936263,
-0.3844436109,
0.5307283998,
-0.0469238348,
-0.544285655,
0.0311511979,
0.2846063375,
0.4838776886,
0.2487289757,
0.5496310592,
-0.0067249779,
0.5248690248,
-0.0876204669,
-0.0715863183,
-0.3318785429,
-0.4179800749,
-0.414802283,
0.3336366117,
-0.1706472486,
-0.6131949425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12984v1
|
Can GNN be Good Adapter for LLMs?
| 2024-02-20T13:13:13 | 2024-02-20T13:13:13 |
Xuanwen Huang, Kaiqiao Han, Yang Yang, Dezheng Bao, Quanjin Tao, Ziwei Chai, Qi Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior
capabilities in understanding and zero-shot learning on textual data, promising
significant advances for many text-related domains. In the graph domain,
various real-world scenarios also involve textual data, where tasks and node
features can be described by text. These text-attributed graphs (TAGs) have
broad applications in social media, recommendation systems, etc. Thus, this
paper explores how to utilize LLMs to model TAGs. Previous methods for TAG
modeling are based on million-scale LMs. When scaled up to billion-scale LLMs,
they face huge challenges in computational costs. Additionally, they also
ignore the zero-shot inference capabilities of LLMs. Therefore, we propose
GraphAdapter, which uses a graph neural network (GNN) as an efficient adapter
in collaboration with LLMs to tackle TAGs. In terms of efficiency, the GNN
adapter introduces only a few trainable parameters and can be trained with low
computation costs. The entire framework is trained using auto-regression on
node text (next token prediction). Once trained, GraphAdapter can be seamlessly
fine-tuned with task-specific prompts for various downstream tasks. Through
extensive experiments across multiple real-world TAGs, GraphAdapter based on
Llama 2 gains an average improvement of approximately 5\% in terms of node
classification. Furthermore, GraphAdapter can also adapt to other language
models, including RoBERTa, GPT-2. The promising results demonstrate that GNNs
can serve as effective adapters for LLMs in TAG modeling.
|
[
-0.0100078201,
-0.6195036769,
0.4812465012,
-0.0946592316,
-0.4431988299,
0.1128199473,
-0.1100308523,
-0.6403180957,
0.2535598874,
0.2617794871,
-0.3506231904,
-0.4838066697,
-0.5797057748,
-0.1368002743,
-0.2678970993,
0.9541472197,
-0.1230278462,
-0.2403549552,
-0.0462286882,
-0.0949107781,
-0.5881429911,
-0.2125901133,
-0.9556224942,
-0.5409998298,
0.7863342166,
0.1363586783,
0.4224086404,
0.8223274946,
0.4089885354,
0.3371822536,
0.0442852788,
0.2742934227,
-0.58276999,
0.0819183886,
-0.2720799446,
-0.307885915,
-0.7191599011,
-0.0936608464,
0.5511021018,
0.4174535573,
0.062786676,
0.284209758,
0.0470041633,
0.4361387789,
-0.1655427366,
0.2375832796,
-1.0619915724,
-0.2759033144,
0.1591569334,
-0.0932082832,
-0.3673347831,
-0.2206265628,
-0.0610876381,
-0.7637138367,
-0.0233469419,
0.2471897155,
0.9243226051,
0.3125680089,
-0.4127904475,
-0.3282288909,
-0.5728063583,
0.549902916,
-0.6647667289,
0.0876228735,
0.1254557073,
0.3495296538,
-0.3617242575,
-1.0472757816,
-0.5244639516,
0.0325888954,
0.0261128247,
0.1003439873,
-0.3652338386,
0.0435343944,
-0.1116491109,
0.0091785146,
-0.5686724186,
0.4967335165,
0.2711030543,
-0.1434679031,
0.362229377,
0.1062244475,
0.5696055293,
-0.3902491033,
-0.4280410111,
0.2120323628,
-0.5317784548,
-0.290176928,
0.3517861366,
0.5836904645,
0.0916816369,
0.3699867427,
-0.0107889632,
1.1051986217,
-0.3018297553,
-0.1464438736,
0.1187621281,
-0.4977956116,
-0.2622926831,
-0.1937377155,
0.8226954341,
0.6652538776,
0.7005001307,
-0.3672114909,
0.0320177525,
0.1594194174,
0.1417933553,
-0.945835948,
-0.4755781591,
-0.0599167123,
-0.299048543,
-0.1951803565,
-0.3921363652,
-0.4700489044,
-0.4749898911,
-0.1082428768,
0.2719971836,
-0.2770384252,
-0.2571821511,
0.0448977202,
-0.2847748995,
0.056813743,
0.5709857941,
-0.7434688807,
0.2410054058,
0.631767869,
1.2842537165,
-0.1023952812,
-0.200787738,
-0.3692525625,
0.3083047569,
-0.1285067648,
0.8877901435,
-0.4057404399,
-0.269295603,
-0.1795220226,
0.1729036868,
-0.4277446866,
-0.2564508915,
0.421943754,
-0.6280796528,
-0.2831031084,
0.0857356265,
-0.6470810175,
-0.2291935235,
0.4412196577,
-0.6397022009,
0.8014044166,
0.1621486843,
-0.8009679914,
0.2595283687,
-0.500813663,
-0.4377911985,
0.3328349292,
0.0736989677,
-0.4059328437,
-0.1626781374,
0.2300581336,
0.6322085261,
-0.2501189709,
0.2142472416,
-0.4060773253,
-0.5466217399,
0.1997712255,
-0.3573130667,
0.50176543,
-0.042050872,
0.0836553946,
0.1568327397,
-0.7788698077,
-0.0095151598,
0.3235830069,
-0.4636666775,
-0.5110119581,
0.2968747318,
0.11222177,
0.2536911666,
-0.0315089673,
-0.5807185173,
0.3074266911,
-0.3561931849,
0.737052083,
0.8846162558,
0.1006551534,
0.4537138939,
-0.238413915,
0.4185370803,
-0.3903412819,
-0.3434687257,
-0.1009314507,
-0.6038697958,
-0.5520749092,
-0.4452502728,
0.4823660553,
0.5694164634,
-1.0830239058,
0.3907305002,
-0.6077296734,
-0.5799440145,
-0.3510792553,
0.2496707886,
0.1041111499,
0.7974758744,
0.1582719535,
-0.1720302105,
-0.4821853042,
-0.3670499027,
-0.4609630704,
-0.4079077244,
-0.0768912733,
0.640725255,
0.3364759088,
-0.2326547801,
0.8763365746,
-0.38525787,
-0.4994061887,
-0.48340711,
-0.229448095,
0.4726378918,
0.2156301737,
0.7172386646,
-0.4499350488,
-0.6004098654,
0.2211683989,
-0.6766207814,
-0.0751565099,
0.0125112943,
-0.0856896713,
0.0994039774,
0.4336902499,
-0.3328435719,
0.2409912199,
0.8302407861,
-0.2406305075,
0.2696568966,
-0.1389436275,
-0.5558931828,
-1.3018038273,
-0.0805060416,
0.4191811383,
-0.7378697395,
-0.7438363433,
-0.2728420496,
-0.062609762,
0.1993978322,
-0.2655437291,
0.7543694973,
-0.363199681,
-0.19257994,
-0.5329517126,
0.3846679926,
0.0389998704,
0.2667466998,
-0.2147957832,
0.8078056574,
0.3796307147,
-0.4974884093,
0.4587721229,
0.1039910465,
-0.4376853406,
0.424399823,
-0.753957808,
0.2005070448,
-0.1541406065,
0.5345792174,
-1.4779802561,
-0.0724288896,
0.3676228821,
-0.4438585341,
0.2953976095,
-0.6267864704,
-0.5761368275,
-0.5244503617,
-0.2844662964,
0.1283120811,
0.2563670278,
-0.787797749,
0.8980183005,
0.3256349266,
-0.0430337973,
-0.3701556623,
-0.7125823498,
0.2872830629,
-0.1123516485,
-0.3649139404,
0.1851493865,
-0.1264278889,
0.3316613436,
0.1991147548,
0.0327659585,
0.2326796055,
0.3903470635,
0.4617649615,
0.5152993798,
-0.1318553835,
0.3042247891,
-0.2921469808,
-0.3576890528,
-0.1235002279,
-0.7291201353,
0.7500120401,
0.0236532111,
0.0107484534,
-0.3683691919,
-0.2260681838,
0.1337410063,
0.1031837463,
0.5253418684,
0.5474422574,
-0.2798166871,
-0.2828022838,
-0.1536186785,
0.310526967,
-0.5296680331,
0.7693930268,
-0.2461227179,
-0.916757524,
0.5317898989,
-0.4872663915,
-0.2904903293,
0.3816294372,
0.5593946576,
-0.1909607798,
0.7645109296,
0.5092740655,
-0.6430455446,
0.7835291624,
-0.2866096497,
0.1647206843,
-1.1751252413,
0.2380684912,
-0.3967206478,
-0.574521184,
-0.7433476448,
-0.3872262239,
0.00807539,
-0.0382703803,
-0.2762692571,
0.3892203271,
-0.551525414,
0.6085503697,
0.2970454097,
0.087687254,
0.3058949709,
0.1473332047,
0.0077433451,
0.2405681312,
-0.7783058882,
-0.3902783394,
1.0420604944,
0.4176594317,
0.9984513521,
-0.0053606089,
0.458196938,
0.0892314613,
0.5923457146,
-1.071603775,
0.5066937804,
-0.3994457126,
-0.3783859313,
-0.2312187552,
-0.4788001478,
-0.8183169961,
0.287032485,
0.0044570933,
-1.0654760599,
0.0309161823,
0.2564943135,
0.1047476381,
0.5513984561,
-0.7186740041,
0.6658632159,
-0.1697499454,
-0.1385467947,
0.4418450892,
-0.537997961,
0.0383648388,
-0.0800822228,
0.3229582012,
-0.4735624194,
-0.2284307033,
0.7881359458,
-0.1710939407,
1.1288176775,
-0.2564116716,
-0.0008271654,
0.3319050074,
0.0628759563,
0.7730078697,
0.0750057623,
-0.2482390106,
0.0490631871,
-0.5232141018,
-0.0851087868,
-0.6178613305,
0.9948922396,
-0.9521256685,
-0.2728331387,
-0.2593751848,
-0.8587317467,
-0.1172483787,
0.4455002546,
-0.0157146398,
0.3304837048,
-0.0609191619,
-0.185699299,
0.1529222578,
0.130780533,
0.8832641244,
0.261579603,
-0.4439592063,
-0.5701661706,
1.2805382013,
0.3524663746,
0.4546473026,
0.2337365001,
0.2064492404,
-0.0773419663,
-0.7315083742,
-0.7616491914,
0.4217441976,
-0.8572329879,
-0.611594677,
-0.6677567959,
-0.2591181695,
-0.0866015106,
-0.1960491985,
0.0580576248,
-0.4723404348,
-0.6965706944,
-0.2343567759,
0.7001183629,
0.6779048443,
0.3006570041,
0.7193929553,
-0.2800796032,
0.3010855615,
0.2847643197,
0.5121957064,
0.283272922,
-0.622441113,
-0.1542693526,
-0.1140700951,
0.0570391677,
-0.5944057703,
0.3137313724,
0.5353506804,
0.3962957561,
0.0096874945,
-0.2331950963,
0.5341596603,
-0.6700051427,
0.6000193357,
0.1256770045,
-0.7311514616,
0.2452966869,
-0.4884175658,
0.3392832279,
0.3931601644,
0.420694828,
-0.5792829394,
-0.0328567773,
-0.1869555563,
-0.9474182129,
0.6259118915,
-0.111578092,
0.3938177526,
0.0281978343,
0.7699711919,
-0.2572487891,
0.0967506617,
-0.8491864204,
-0.2682632208,
-0.3206113279,
-0.4851124585,
-0.349771589,
-0.0893766433,
0.1861723661,
-0.2913263738,
0.6832792163,
-0.7113859057,
0.2777656913,
-0.0266388655,
-0.2218569517,
-0.0638349429,
-0.0069891228,
0.17160815,
0.4766224325,
-0.20041807,
0.2608819306,
0.2642014623,
-0.5528974533,
0.2229323685,
0.2053759396,
-0.2064087391,
0.0272945669,
0.4103015661,
0.8904783726,
0.0146474121,
-0.1295299381,
0.4429006875,
-0.1271679401,
-0.1525115669,
0.1069950834,
0.0890602395,
0.6124728322,
0.1537169665,
0.1061705425,
-0.0877566338,
-0.0169337448,
-0.4200888574,
0.0128956437,
0.6092149019,
-0.5814912319,
-0.2621147931,
0.6318717599,
0.042056337,
-0.486808449,
0.4187589288,
-0.100627169,
-0.6228229403,
0.6296890378,
1.160015583,
0.6836169362,
-0.2613162994,
0.2290722579,
0.0943024084,
0.2480047494,
0.2228405923,
0.1568658054,
0.2305244803,
-1.0346882343,
-0.6068854332,
-0.6053217649,
-0.2308891714,
-0.2910688221,
-0.1897095144,
0.1483620554,
-0.6244378686,
-0.3277710676,
0.3441959321,
-0.0741418824,
-0.6545420289,
0.1906104684,
0.0233197846,
0.8980072141,
-0.831207633,
1.0460332632,
0.7532067895,
-0.1807452738,
-0.8526002765,
-0.2365191579,
-0.0798629895,
-1.2929471731,
0.5065469146,
0.1780943573,
-0.2229708433,
0.5416323543,
-0.5488899946,
-0.8194291592,
1.2934744358,
0.2144729495,
-0.5215324759,
-0.1378671974,
0.1254656166,
0.5913196206,
-0.5670434833,
0.3682853878,
0.3160101771,
0.2904896438,
0.4528189898,
-0.6212593317,
0.2299600542,
-0.1460954547,
0.446172744,
0.2345411032,
-0.6288605928,
0.7878308296,
0.0246814229,
0.0300146211,
0.1264465302,
0.4444613755,
0.0361001007,
0.1808431149,
0.5337663293,
0.4637598395,
0.7621991038,
-0.0175473001,
1.1747808456,
-0.1450109184,
0.5193734169,
1.2933826447,
-0.5572355986,
0.7887229919,
0.2461462468,
-0.0217265207,
0.6953217983,
0.5168800354,
-0.090145126,
0.3647453189,
0.4711030424,
-0.0169273205,
-0.192268461,
-0.4898665249,
-0.0856949687,
0.2558124065,
0.4775974452,
-0.3824514151,
-0.3786092401,
-0.1656304151,
0.2377174944,
-0.1919166148,
-0.4397108853,
1.0102014542,
0.225558117,
-0.0284966454,
0.3108102083,
-0.0476426668,
0.6520392299,
-0.5468936563,
0.0289271343,
0.0911180675,
0.3166750669,
-0.2364743203,
-0.7322525382,
-0.0108829113,
-0.1485373974,
-0.173506096,
-0.0545467921,
1.4575015306,
-0.1407376379,
-0.7325439453,
0.6174923182,
0.4141211212,
-0.0371018015,
0.00423409,
-0.5067968369,
0.1174351126,
-0.2701739371,
-0.1661103517,
0.3946353197,
0.3258783519,
0.0575772002,
0.7007980943,
0.709220767,
0.2183557451,
-0.0537074544,
0.2184515446,
1.2763098478,
-0.4959011078,
-0.3462452292,
-0.9531867504,
0.325060457,
-0.0605047978,
0.0170052703,
0.8126679659,
0.3637627065,
0.5380923748,
0.311629355,
0.9582932591,
0.2196100652,
0.4326653481,
-0.3788801134,
0.7655618191,
-0.4095179439,
0.0597245507,
-0.4540388286,
-0.9593520761,
-0.596214354,
0.5358797908,
-0.3234283626,
0.1484647244,
0.3376014531,
0.461429745,
0.0289791524,
-0.1089975536,
0.1968132108,
0.1446341276,
0.6409649253,
0.5656657815,
0.645468235,
-0.6384758949,
0.4695121944,
0.3327307701,
-0.1319635063,
-0.244735539,
-1.2555472851,
-1.1605985165,
-0.1621461511,
-0.1734215319,
-0.4300972521,
0.1631784886,
0.669329226,
0.5564280152,
-0.4270833731,
-0.1826018244,
-0.2127771676,
0.3669873178,
0.0652548596,
-0.1488549113,
0.2975420058,
-0.1112059951,
-0.4854014814,
0.2325858325,
0.3103465736,
0.2413814366,
0.0398461893,
0.0539789274,
-0.4946241081,
0.0067707151,
0.4667268991,
0.0888541192,
-0.5126218796,
-0.70305264,
-0.0541396439,
0.1019490287,
0.1619142592,
0.5725114346,
-0.8439347744,
0.535538435,
0.3728032708,
0.8514896631,
0.6242918372,
0.1210815534,
0.3039056361,
-0.8213972449,
0.0068405573,
-0.1234386936,
0.4591595829,
0.4382419288,
-0.2558015883,
0.5498472452,
0.2474003881,
-0.7339497805,
-0.62131989,
0.2499712706,
-1.0787035227,
-0.1505958587,
1.34918046,
-0.2197348475,
-0.4733700454,
-0.0858918279,
-0.2263749689,
0.3582969308,
-0.2634865642,
0.1954057366,
0.5222591758,
0.0716867149,
-0.1888822913,
-0.6368286014,
0.0617802888,
-0.0970750675,
-0.7545488477,
0.0022510833,
0.1849406511,
0.5311001539,
0.0430107303,
0.7851164937,
0.4118112922,
-0.1677297652,
-0.2000128925,
-0.0101336529,
-0.3381389081,
-0.1950023472,
-0.370397985,
-0.0475126728,
0.3201071322,
-0.2788535058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14856v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14856v2
|
Comparing Inferential Strategies of Humans and Large Language Models in Deductive Reasoning
| 2024-02-20T12:58:14 | 2024-06-03T13:53:01 |
Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deductive reasoning plays a pivotal role in the formulation of sound and
cohesive arguments. It allows individuals to draw conclusions that logically
follow, given the truth value of the information provided. Recent progress in
the domain of large language models (LLMs) has showcased their capability in
executing deductive reasoning tasks. Nonetheless, a significant portion of
research primarily assesses the accuracy of LLMs in solving such tasks, often
overlooking a deeper analysis of their reasoning behavior. In this study, we
draw upon principles from cognitive psychology to examine inferential
strategies employed by LLMs, through a detailed evaluation of their responses
to propositional logic problems. Our findings indicate that LLMs display
reasoning patterns akin to those observed in humans, including strategies like
$\textit{supposition following}$ or $\textit{chain construction}$. Moreover,
our research demonstrates that the architecture and scale of the model
significantly affect its preferred method of reasoning, with more advanced
models tending to adopt strategies more frequently than less sophisticated
ones. Importantly, we assert that a model's accuracy, that is the correctness
of its final conclusion, does not necessarily reflect the validity of its
reasoning process. This distinction underscores the necessity for more nuanced
evaluation procedures in the field.
|
[
-0.140560329,
-0.9600804448,
1.0407094955,
0.2500966191,
-0.155101195,
0.1764623523,
-0.4364330173,
-0.3632819355,
-0.2244937271,
0.4393960536,
-0.3308468163,
-0.2469048649,
-0.4710451066,
0.359600842,
-0.1232854426,
0.3825819194,
0.1303264648,
0.3335528076,
-0.5964234471,
0.1359253824,
-0.5016028881,
-0.8833582401,
-0.5840815306,
-0.8406438231,
0.2077584118,
0.3875869811,
0.8389849067,
0.4278495014,
0.6305940747,
0.3077400625,
-0.4016124904,
0.165777728,
-0.184389174,
0.198322311,
-0.4570723474,
-0.5732756257,
-0.2277074009,
0.0592547692,
0.3657677472,
0.9391006231,
-0.2170336246,
0.1032839864,
0.0756205767,
0.5963122249,
-0.6428213716,
-0.0729789585,
-0.6734750271,
-0.1447670311,
-0.2007122785,
-0.1534418315,
-0.6391571164,
-0.4357998371,
0.4185460508,
-0.2358353734,
-0.02445825,
-0.1162797436,
0.5094056129,
0.1725949049,
-0.398673594,
-0.6514118314,
-0.700656116,
0.7504828572,
-1.0436451435,
0.1776960343,
0.4604005814,
-0.0276414063,
-0.5056807995,
-0.3972689211,
-0.4952606559,
-0.6644335389,
-0.1277357489,
-0.1630668789,
-0.1459564567,
0.0110372966,
0.7464045286,
0.0411762297,
-0.4836804569,
0.3848911822,
-0.0391599871,
0.0772877783,
0.7095995545,
0.1540959924,
-0.0852890685,
-0.2329950929,
-0.3214255869,
-0.1749984622,
-0.7109461427,
0.0995079428,
0.2327467352,
0.1188889816,
0.0834115148,
0.532579124,
-0.3675448,
0.9205005765,
0.2855524719,
-0.2163165957,
-0.0150931943,
-0.0832423642,
-0.356305182,
0.1254428476,
0.5537329912,
0.4463110268,
0.4549823701,
-0.0767550319,
-0.3751872182,
0.445004642,
0.1761698127,
-0.5303050876,
-0.0452086106,
0.0753423423,
-0.5705530643,
-0.2039269656,
-0.1898964345,
-0.5396255255,
-0.7158870697,
-0.387581259,
0.4262905419,
-0.334785372,
-0.0788804218,
0.5628607273,
-0.2050679624,
0.4260763526,
0.333843559,
-0.7919458747,
0.488940239,
0.7944656014,
0.5630945563,
-0.1439955533,
0.014585658,
-0.4258933961,
0.1002389789,
-0.6105611324,
0.923786819,
-0.7963522673,
-0.4409431219,
-0.0800621882,
-0.341035068,
-0.0450251959,
-0.9248273373,
0.9535112381,
-0.5300741792,
0.056298662,
-0.554828465,
-0.8181558847,
-0.3796679974,
0.3546435833,
-0.4195578694,
0.6205677986,
-0.1997329146,
-0.5729894638,
0.4229790568,
-0.702270627,
-0.511867404,
0.0033413034,
-0.3339097798,
0.0518842004,
0.3545732796,
0.1577284485,
0.6783248782,
-0.7405262589,
0.1747752428,
-0.5257583857,
-0.3550695479,
0.8635756373,
-0.4875998497,
0.8680238724,
0.1729756147,
-0.5558344722,
-0.2094808221,
-0.6403111219,
-0.0346843265,
0.4038603604,
-0.2788108885,
-0.5682034492,
0.3369149864,
-0.7511894107,
0.2419707179,
0.0394641869,
-0.4140021503,
0.2028011978,
-0.4549150169,
0.7351599336,
0.6622797847,
-0.0084680812,
0.4361926913,
-0.2654840648,
0.3221639097,
-0.2474210411,
0.139318049,
0.1609451473,
-0.2672346532,
-0.5494619608,
-0.2076202333,
0.1043009758,
0.4910744429,
-0.2741985619,
0.180834502,
-0.2321169227,
-0.5502129793,
0.0044628056,
0.1186660528,
0.4254770875,
0.459005475,
0.1620021164,
-0.088475816,
-0.372020632,
-0.8309996128,
-0.3376554847,
-0.2031140476,
0.0357197747,
0.089874804,
0.6008734703,
-0.0196870267,
0.7231621742,
-0.4644672573,
0.258210808,
-0.2969237268,
0.0283460598,
0.3534069955,
0.2422431558,
0.4641940296,
-0.6549313068,
-0.1332390159,
-0.1408537328,
-1.0134171247,
-0.0186877623,
-0.0773032531,
-0.0886796266,
0.3562054634,
0.5666022897,
-0.7516760826,
0.3575058877,
0.2145113051,
-0.5138164163,
0.5016941428,
-0.1979113668,
-0.0185089633,
-0.3558618128,
-0.3516715765,
0.1270511746,
0.0255432278,
-0.4142739773,
0.0472277924,
-0.1255414635,
0.4112727344,
-0.1735634804,
0.373539418,
-0.4125007987,
-0.0082311453,
-0.1324663907,
0.1680823714,
0.1845036447,
0.2771136165,
0.184384793,
0.4706382751,
0.3787579834,
-0.7317143679,
0.5254862309,
0.0584773235,
-0.6034829021,
0.6702076793,
-0.8936530948,
0.3015872836,
-0.1221094728,
0.3356810212,
-1.189622283,
-0.0456380509,
0.146730125,
-0.305039078,
0.0730874613,
0.1162840351,
-0.7386591434,
-0.4963079393,
-0.2485805154,
0.2392722517,
0.5047085881,
-0.5130776167,
0.440174073,
0.0403707922,
0.0783725008,
-0.3555381894,
-0.7809646726,
0.0957493111,
-0.6178889275,
-0.6345592737,
0.251588881,
-0.0664290711,
-1.065735817,
-0.3562635481,
-0.1703354716,
0.1140202656,
0.2892913222,
0.0166711546,
0.2591890693,
-0.0792699605,
0.2050335854,
-0.3920801282,
0.08305078,
0.4422704577,
-0.0896291807,
0.5120685101,
-0.0598897114,
-0.4741490781,
-0.1634746194,
0.1726026833,
0.6446871161,
-0.2455219626,
0.689822495,
-0.1431768835,
-0.2838773429,
-0.1162418053,
-0.8446416259,
-0.4207487404,
-0.4120063484,
0.0953254625,
-0.5048303604,
-0.5264712572,
0.3444586694,
-0.2012100518,
-0.2337656319,
0.3199168146,
0.5928521752,
-0.2569348514,
1.0451136827,
0.1279399395,
0.2382996827,
0.0852131173,
-0.3182254136,
0.2008778602,
-0.8421441913,
-0.326297909,
-0.5701767802,
-0.2203194201,
-0.3424352705,
-0.400847733,
0.1128340662,
0.2010489255,
-0.5421468019,
0.1850208342,
-0.4755958021,
0.4010786116,
0.4153089225,
0.1678309143,
0.5096681118,
-0.0056771105,
-0.2078949511,
-0.0480826683,
-0.6953510046,
-0.933976531,
0.9336259961,
0.3875686228,
0.8731939793,
0.3359690309,
0.4045360684,
0.3153603673,
0.0884068459,
-0.7584121823,
0.8093231916,
-0.0671765953,
-0.5076518059,
-0.240160957,
-0.3204723001,
-0.8926488161,
0.422754705,
-0.2842532098,
-0.8087767363,
0.2703071535,
-0.0476293825,
-0.3520942628,
0.1989833117,
-0.6422634125,
0.8086481094,
-0.6411277056,
-0.4040414691,
-0.4739103317,
-0.6121279597,
0.1779571325,
0.0831463784,
0.1247849166,
-0.081054084,
0.043277204,
0.6660584211,
-0.212244153,
0.8804706335,
-0.0338066481,
-0.4373094141,
0.4579009414,
0.2616565228,
0.5439942479,
-0.1496356279,
-0.3614984453,
0.0175493378,
0.0067027039,
-0.2056251615,
-0.8054875731,
0.4821873009,
-0.4981047511,
-0.8982890844,
-0.3443232179,
-0.3677282631,
-0.2103604823,
-0.2732962966,
0.2903576791,
0.6322613955,
-0.3079779148,
0.1485697776,
0.7886004448,
-0.1096534654,
0.4742198586,
0.541533947,
-0.0058474662,
-0.1078441367,
0.3983758986,
0.1349528283,
0.5815265179,
0.6018745303,
0.4819396734,
-0.5852302909,
-0.4948060513,
-0.2881014645,
0.3864621818,
-0.9206795096,
-0.1154309809,
-0.2965479791,
0.1845552176,
-0.2962755263,
-0.135528475,
-0.1284009963,
-0.261176914,
0.053351745,
-0.0904674456,
0.3079373538,
0.8154430389,
0.175556615,
-0.0102887265,
-0.4221964478,
0.1212308928,
0.4768128395,
-0.012579591,
0.3291165531,
-0.6311079264,
0.065140672,
0.2093934417,
-0.4479793012,
-0.9239450097,
-0.0319188796,
-0.2417982072,
0.7811304927,
0.4015830457,
0.0576871522,
0.609274745,
-0.2816088796,
0.6054676175,
-0.0210972074,
-0.9311221838,
0.5439349413,
-0.2376140803,
0.1292351484,
0.2557704747,
0.3695930541,
-0.235874474,
-0.0739199668,
-0.5714563727,
-0.4311800897,
0.2496201098,
0.0603865795,
-0.0551090091,
-0.374507457,
0.4237793684,
-0.0304701589,
0.1234296933,
-0.5471130013,
0.1118909717,
0.2195409834,
0.1417388916,
0.0433893576,
-0.3723124862,
-0.0994362161,
-0.3338411152,
0.3168787062,
-0.0767688826,
0.0639133379,
0.4005957544,
-0.112344034,
0.0532262735,
0.3515895903,
0.7245262265,
1.0407608747,
-0.2286201566,
0.2396434247,
0.3633389473,
-0.0141870985,
0.2773267925,
-0.1669249833,
-0.0814733505,
-0.1523626745,
0.7162784338,
0.50032866,
0.0782222077,
-0.9389343262,
0.5071436763,
0.1390011907,
-0.2574554086,
-0.3410960436,
-0.0022499429,
0.1242581159,
0.6197067499,
0.202817589,
0.0193823949,
0.1751196831,
-0.7939043045,
-0.3240728676,
0.6729508042,
-0.0280118901,
-0.1434005201,
0.3979917169,
0.0099634053,
-0.3897392452,
0.8129736185,
-0.1858123243,
-0.5705720782,
0.5339237452,
0.7106596828,
0.7406457663,
0.0017477177,
0.1584719867,
0.2220494151,
0.1973083168,
-0.3634927273,
0.1579473019,
0.0095595121,
-0.940487206,
-0.7087109685,
-0.4453739822,
-0.2872145474,
0.0747498199,
-0.4478190243,
0.0915281996,
-0.4440312684,
-0.2324507385,
0.0212417524,
0.0072248043,
-0.5795273781,
0.1831984073,
0.3547429442,
0.9962307811,
-0.5539947152,
0.5482417345,
1.0275040865,
-0.4113329649,
-0.6732375026,
0.0524109714,
-0.0906017944,
-0.6185103655,
0.9539557099,
0.037896648,
-0.5051678419,
-0.4542527497,
-0.6784661412,
-0.7804769278,
0.7804344893,
0.5932431221,
-0.4427925944,
0.0753668472,
0.0250370409,
0.6059958339,
-0.5357390046,
0.2782324255,
0.7137026191,
0.5282574296,
0.276886642,
-0.8539314866,
0.2923401892,
0.1687666029,
0.0707260892,
-0.0583510362,
-0.5422871709,
0.8244740367,
-0.5075833201,
-0.044176735,
0.0816202536,
0.4580846429,
0.4924997687,
0.2451664507,
0.6463661194,
0.522217989,
0.8256020546,
0.1775140762,
1.072447896,
0.1087102145,
0.0128621068,
1.0673488379,
-0.5953798294,
0.9513379931,
0.4108387828,
-0.2497271448,
0.8357161283,
0.5378263593,
0.0730555058,
0.4369088411,
0.6638126373,
0.0364404358,
-0.5779487491,
-0.0976647958,
-0.063196376,
0.7858290076,
0.5290954113,
-0.303150475,
-0.0014447137,
-0.177131936,
0.228260085,
0.5709199309,
-0.3718586862,
0.7632956505,
0.0791734532,
-0.8750191331,
0.7610583901,
-0.023021413,
0.6279316545,
-0.3343862891,
-0.1511322558,
-0.1017656028,
0.4799824953,
-0.2415712923,
-0.8510559797,
0.1589162201,
-0.0155691234,
-0.2470478415,
-0.0218435451,
0.6681018472,
0.0875990912,
-0.3583089709,
0.4274189174,
0.5370811224,
0.1545832753,
-0.2634382546,
-0.5634806156,
0.1298247278,
-0.0913680866,
-0.1199773252,
0.1027751863,
0.5863752365,
-0.3891835809,
0.825764358,
0.4804852009,
0.0193389878,
-0.2327715605,
0.2549631,
0.6134348512,
-0.7587203979,
-0.0502269119,
-1.4677809477,
0.2396043986,
-0.1762039065,
-0.1811122596,
0.9065524936,
0.317299664,
0.8421218991,
-0.0807679743,
0.5730992556,
0.136054799,
0.4591545165,
-0.5641570687,
-0.0550750308,
-0.3625318408,
0.4670907259,
-0.4201796949,
-0.8836812377,
-0.1913010925,
1.0034641027,
-0.6380497217,
0.0333851054,
0.6644787192,
0.606900692,
0.1928067207,
0.1165975332,
0.2178394347,
0.373031348,
0.239329204,
0.6876907945,
1.3957539797,
0.0328033827,
0.2398577482,
-0.1236693859,
-0.2602948546,
-0.1440354735,
-1.0910048485,
-1.1133079529,
-0.239911288,
-0.3045340478,
-0.3292554915,
-0.1706883609,
1.1410735846,
0.458550632,
-0.4305535257,
-0.5682834983,
-0.0701119527,
0.2658004463,
-0.4760321677,
-0.1718965024,
0.2052790821,
-0.2093566954,
-0.3367109001,
0.392495811,
0.2432779968,
-0.113895148,
-0.2841328979,
-0.1084862575,
-0.3084082305,
0.3429130316,
0.8529081941,
-0.1213474795,
-1.045270443,
-0.2708443999,
0.0838794634,
-0.1731298864,
0.0087293861,
0.7323016524,
-0.8704218864,
0.2549405098,
0.5660429597,
0.3758110702,
0.1750478745,
-0.0732918531,
0.6432383657,
-0.0652067587,
-0.0060643875,
0.2447496206,
0.4023234248,
0.5434431434,
-0.3316083252,
0.675614059,
0.1326133013,
-0.6931334734,
-0.6312187314,
0.351757586,
-0.76562047,
-0.5084196329,
1.1822519302,
0.0619076304,
-0.0825243145,
0.0071604894,
-0.3142462671,
-0.0653269589,
-0.2709847093,
0.6776349545,
0.9053730369,
-0.3711565435,
0.2064958811,
-0.4740717709,
0.4225755036,
0.4425214529,
-0.4233663678,
0.0898565203,
0.4063699543,
0.1585728526,
0.2535297275,
0.5162623525,
0.038565699,
0.0755625516,
-0.1487246007,
-0.3078829348,
0.2921938598,
-0.0903236941,
-0.3199465275,
0.0066565815,
0.3735463023,
-0.1063272953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12976v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12976v2
|
The Impact of Demonstrations on Multilingual In-Context Learning: A Multidimensional Analysis
| 2024-02-20T12:53:31 | 2024-06-07T13:44:07 |
Miaoran Zhang, Vagrant Gautam, Mingyang Wang, Jesujoba O. Alabi, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow, Marius Mosbach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning is a popular inference strategy where large language
models solve a task using only a few labeled demonstrations without needing any
parameter updates. Although there have been extensive studies on English
in-context learning, multilingual in-context learning remains under-explored,
and we lack an in-depth understanding of the role of demonstrations in this
context. To address this gap, we conduct a multidimensional analysis of
multilingual in-context learning, experimenting with 5 models from different
model families, 9 datasets covering classification and generation tasks, and 56
typologically diverse languages. Our results reveal that the effectiveness of
demonstrations varies significantly across models, tasks, and languages. We
also find that strong instruction-following models including Llama 2-Chat,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 are largely insensitive to the quality of demonstrations.
Instead, a carefully crafted template often eliminates the benefits of
demonstrations for some tasks and languages altogether. These findings show
that the importance of demonstrations might be overestimated. Our work
highlights the need for granular evaluation across multiple axes towards a
better understanding of in-context learning.
|
[
-0.4046861231,
-0.6687507033,
0.2894586027,
0.5384881496,
-0.0865674317,
-0.1115844101,
-0.2082611918,
-0.2190065831,
-0.241487965,
-0.1200651973,
-0.2406347394,
-0.3675162196,
-0.5479576588,
0.0009187343,
-0.3705762625,
0.98102355,
-0.1488820463,
0.2157535702,
-0.6991642714,
-0.1807173193,
-0.4803819954,
-0.6113119125,
-0.583070457,
-0.5274018645,
0.4684514701,
0.7024739981,
0.1530670822,
0.1876811087,
-0.2293388098,
0.2800421119,
0.0431543328,
0.2187398225,
-0.4053512812,
-0.0377750397,
-0.0864073932,
-0.3514281809,
-0.0936979726,
0.1143166348,
0.8448716402,
0.8806456327,
0.0556622408,
-0.0017987364,
0.4301746488,
0.3143381476,
-0.5554059148,
0.2523782849,
-0.1570479423,
0.1280886382,
-0.0567643009,
-0.0467406847,
-0.5432146192,
-0.1111935154,
0.2871483266,
-0.4828680754,
-0.1357627064,
-0.3029316366,
0.4543487132,
-0.1238821298,
-0.9890455008,
-0.3867102265,
-0.6812084913,
0.9209986329,
-0.4879781604,
0.3343552649,
0.2652173638,
0.3808654845,
-0.1179568395,
-0.7792047262,
-0.4176711738,
-0.3254156411,
-0.1687166691,
0.4261291921,
-0.1653333753,
-0.1604798436,
0.3783100247,
-0.0517856367,
-0.2646535635,
0.411614418,
-0.2595946491,
-0.0965272933,
0.2266883999,
0.0308032446,
0.2782416344,
-0.2872045338,
-0.5534998178,
-0.3169622421,
-0.8052382469,
0.4746896923,
0.5627303123,
0.2449096143,
-0.4676040709,
0.2720030844,
-0.0410969108,
0.5473991632,
-0.035870336,
-0.443118155,
0.1756840497,
-0.3224276602,
-0.1306532919,
-0.2374584079,
0.6646696925,
0.195719853,
-0.0766311884,
-0.1137401983,
-0.0939810053,
-0.2694171369,
0.0243408568,
-0.9807317853,
0.1328673959,
0.1019596457,
-0.5214741826,
0.0650243163,
0.1140045002,
-0.9965974689,
-0.231420666,
-0.281286478,
0.864038825,
-0.3708646297,
-0.4095548093,
0.0022650242,
-0.3132961988,
0.0402258635,
0.3713037372,
-0.6999611259,
0.2852296531,
0.5546878576,
0.5888699889,
-0.0925809368,
-0.9375502467,
-0.5506328344,
0.1579878479,
-0.271648258,
0.7842260003,
-0.4782413542,
-0.5030995011,
0.2027495354,
0.1198904663,
-0.4683078229,
-0.419036597,
0.0802397951,
0.0206473861,
0.4854168296,
-0.4965415299,
-0.6852306724,
-0.4492708445,
0.2584739923,
-0.472260654,
0.6250355244,
-0.1171266735,
-0.5317730904,
0.7125115395,
-0.7238760591,
-0.6595934033,
-0.1335528493,
-0.3774727583,
-0.3459935188,
0.0113510471,
0.2571238577,
0.6599577069,
0.146597445,
0.1095263287,
0.0574171543,
-0.4899812639,
0.1889828593,
-0.7418823242,
0.4728637636,
-0.1506595314,
-0.8046341538,
0.0675953701,
-0.5494903922,
-0.3027967215,
0.0240462516,
-0.3983263671,
-0.3371823132,
0.1679093242,
-0.1630331576,
0.3967699111,
-0.1116819307,
-0.3518761992,
0.1739575714,
-0.3136647642,
0.1813240498,
0.4338281155,
0.1734032482,
0.4207569957,
-0.2498584688,
0.7484996319,
0.1425757706,
0.1937998682,
-0.5527654886,
-0.5054980516,
-0.3613521755,
-0.3004851639,
0.0629957616,
0.1145822853,
-0.7962668538,
-0.6135721207,
-0.1527896672,
-0.4217799902,
-0.1112857834,
0.1303428859,
0.7753022909,
0.4191257358,
0.1076091528,
-0.096674554,
-0.1225211397,
-0.9264013171,
-0.0861016661,
-0.0141970562,
0.2005644143,
0.2603107691,
0.6542029381,
-0.0409832411,
0.3493892848,
0.244291842,
-0.0444292538,
-0.5750735998,
0.2788872123,
-0.1352960616,
0.3058254421,
0.8981969357,
-0.741427958,
-0.660643816,
0.3334288895,
-0.5795724392,
0.0944671929,
-0.4399223924,
0.1242750883,
0.1353906691,
0.5028788447,
-0.3934540153,
0.425106287,
0.550168097,
0.0653573871,
0.6202799678,
-0.5084226727,
0.3806314468,
-0.8839056492,
-0.4042628407,
0.0742351189,
0.042345129,
-0.8439270258,
0.240748167,
0.4535452425,
0.0269884225,
-0.7807529569,
0.671898663,
-0.2875530422,
-0.1493190229,
-0.1873350292,
0.1693721116,
0.2974141538,
0.5242302418,
0.0639422387,
0.9371600151,
0.6615278721,
-0.6274453402,
-0.1636502147,
0.0449267663,
-0.4490481615,
0.6231712103,
-0.3659334183,
-0.0303038768,
-0.0555680469,
0.3166700602,
-1.0724101067,
-0.3736632764,
-0.0106686875,
-0.0317458212,
0.4387598932,
-0.1412960738,
-0.5295058489,
-0.0364247262,
-0.4434185028,
0.1918199956,
0.1023733094,
-0.9875851274,
0.5249063969,
0.1496338993,
0.1781710982,
-0.6425949335,
-0.3944304287,
-0.1483043283,
-0.6864695549,
-0.2819850743,
0.2503177822,
0.0757356808,
-0.4272639751,
-0.6979284286,
0.0370691605,
0.1813080907,
0.1709004194,
0.310818851,
-0.3503952324,
0.020068936,
0.3927389085,
0.3863518834,
0.2067973763,
0.1223553047,
0.0406943522,
0.4420036674,
-0.2336672992,
-0.8236580491,
-0.5347064137,
0.6171243191,
0.6148298979,
-0.1517386585,
0.6678289175,
0.5680508614,
-0.2182812989,
-0.1119473949,
-0.1913605481,
0.0261896625,
-0.4027968347,
0.5353106856,
-0.4378163815,
-0.3287706673,
0.4996984899,
-0.2875417769,
0.1601098031,
0.2042978555,
0.4756970704,
-0.1181975603,
1.2333110571,
0.4446232021,
0.2180930972,
0.5094661713,
-0.4310832918,
0.0675907359,
-0.6745414734,
-0.5205544829,
-0.4244841933,
-0.183658883,
-0.3387926817,
-0.1823457628,
0.5284798145,
-0.0104470523,
-0.1423332989,
0.1660504192,
0.1115049049,
0.3533593714,
0.562395215,
0.1820947677,
0.0058091418,
0.0488498323,
-0.276884526,
-0.1302715093,
-0.777344346,
-0.5279691815,
0.9525707364,
0.2345394045,
0.5274792314,
0.4113557041,
0.632225275,
-0.124838382,
0.3716350496,
-0.6844784021,
0.1960436404,
-0.1748298258,
-0.0566764288,
-0.1358662099,
-0.1152177081,
-1.0642703772,
0.5075276494,
0.0729831606,
-0.6261540651,
0.2265718728,
0.1668221205,
-0.1218696907,
0.2294226587,
-1.2581883669,
1.1345179081,
-0.3144736588,
-0.4726787508,
-0.3452107012,
-0.4725483358,
0.1978737116,
0.0149230137,
0.634172976,
0.5926092267,
0.2125008851,
0.6029374599,
-0.0487860441,
1.2907947302,
-0.4270482957,
-0.4194004834,
0.0120911207,
0.1050300822,
0.4224660397,
-0.0181251727,
0.1635442823,
-0.0743334517,
-0.0337870307,
-0.4129830897,
-0.6648068428,
0.735668838,
-0.6124825478,
-0.5717945695,
0.1226964444,
-0.5264477134,
-0.2529625893,
-0.3096680641,
0.2684506476,
0.9937664866,
-0.098253347,
0.1455850899,
0.5206532478,
-0.5224456191,
0.5746019483,
0.2940724194,
-0.1816782653,
0.0259273481,
1.0907574892,
0.2427229285,
0.784750402,
0.386036247,
0.4165154696,
-0.3311773539,
-0.4341094494,
-0.5671877265,
0.0889821798,
-1.2033089399,
0.1946889162,
-0.6499814987,
0.3597202599,
-0.2161149532,
-0.0929152668,
-0.0861459374,
-0.3031154871,
-0.2337225378,
-0.1490501016,
-0.0769360289,
1.1302186251,
-0.0036387164,
0.5726534724,
-0.3057369292,
-0.0325031243,
0.7727760077,
0.0092012417,
0.4584441483,
-0.3463205695,
-0.3373731375,
0.0642645508,
-0.5985850692,
-0.8519132733,
0.212737456,
0.5489642024,
1.0062021017,
0.784337759,
-0.4274312258,
0.9893752337,
-0.5467864275,
1.0490938425,
-0.0868636668,
-0.9721692801,
0.4139763415,
-0.2133025974,
0.2976086736,
-0.0449565947,
0.50792557,
-0.5619607568,
-0.5414958596,
-0.5090422034,
-0.7373462915,
0.5540108681,
-0.2125000507,
0.467197001,
-0.2636166215,
0.0384949334,
0.5890609026,
0.2582668662,
-0.8328179121,
-0.1696920991,
-0.5357036591,
0.2807317972,
-0.0998642296,
-0.1869879365,
-0.1925171465,
-0.3061035275,
0.4132942557,
-0.2787975669,
0.1404957473,
-0.1621651202,
-0.4341282547,
0.2407999635,
0.2703847289,
1.0582182407,
0.8638306856,
0.1930079162,
0.1225312427,
0.2858467996,
-0.2015574574,
-0.0493922494,
-0.0562570095,
0.1954981834,
-0.0574042723,
0.6916260719,
1.0344808102,
0.709222436,
-0.6220456362,
0.7823024988,
0.0282428451,
-0.2281677276,
-0.1708191186,
-0.1931034476,
-0.0419847593,
0.4591154158,
0.3319938183,
-0.044212386,
0.1573175043,
-0.6179264784,
0.08619418,
0.4713901877,
-0.3017004728,
-0.4712219834,
0.5373343825,
-0.1940163076,
-0.2836435437,
0.1513893604,
-0.2761730254,
-0.5243152976,
0.8027404547,
0.6706182957,
0.3593687415,
-0.2046549171,
0.4448401928,
0.2852246463,
0.1299214959,
-0.0598730706,
-0.0346248448,
-0.2974018753,
-0.4667360485,
-0.6123021841,
-0.0568840764,
-0.6126061082,
0.0919272602,
-0.7203668356,
0.1785529107,
0.1066935435,
0.2587068975,
0.0271684844,
-0.2154372334,
-0.651711762,
-0.1688189656,
0.0971240476,
0.7925316691,
-1.1524068117,
0.6473222971,
0.7414430976,
-0.2897144258,
-0.5967000127,
0.1765171438,
0.0333122425,
-0.4005765319,
0.8545759916,
0.4761842787,
-0.0424699076,
-0.1439798027,
-0.3140400648,
-0.4481418431,
0.8348461986,
0.4604777396,
0.0259131454,
0.2953926325,
-0.017282553,
0.5482738614,
-0.627299428,
0.5183273554,
0.1531732082,
0.4136623144,
-0.2312061936,
-0.893566668,
-0.4298229814,
-0.0040922784,
-0.0799853429,
-0.2075809836,
-0.6634098291,
0.7976716161,
-0.1435542852,
-0.221039474,
-0.0306721646,
0.4711822569,
0.1811567098,
0.4052261114,
0.5040866137,
-0.0223439392,
0.5047436953,
-0.0725782812,
1.4122974873,
0.2305527627,
0.1289515197,
0.9042987823,
-0.2924540341,
0.8282354474,
0.7463834882,
-0.1462041587,
0.706964016,
0.6037861109,
0.4481719434,
0.5285197496,
-0.0682425797,
-0.22044231,
-0.2585887313,
0.0148949949,
-0.1809666306,
0.5653963089,
0.5764579177,
-0.0434140451,
-0.5422255993,
0.7526544333,
0.0292468313,
0.2618403435,
-0.2470423728,
0.6897236109,
-0.3254550099,
-0.5618199706,
0.5105968714,
-0.4268117249,
0.5082835555,
-0.4901974499,
-0.3957718313,
-0.288793385,
0.060698729,
-0.0543306619,
-0.5010405779,
-0.0380873755,
-0.2617206573,
0.04440758,
-0.5153501034,
0.1115113944,
-0.4936822653,
-0.1654765457,
0.5543153286,
0.6808667183,
0.3837943375,
0.0493405312,
-0.2662769258,
-0.3317990303,
-0.1061417237,
-0.3413904309,
0.8328789473,
0.5639071465,
-0.3233540654,
0.5550929904,
0.2312449664,
-0.3786407113,
0.1939906627,
0.5584948063,
0.6608656645,
0.0484310016,
-0.1816868186,
-0.7759126425,
0.6905996203,
0.0281062815,
-0.1960942894,
1.0556259155,
0.4568715394,
1.1331150532,
-0.311956197,
0.6358115673,
0.2189143449,
0.3101184666,
-0.5535455346,
0.4969159961,
-0.9192197919,
0.1615959406,
-0.3895668387,
-0.3792547584,
-0.0311653707,
0.3659075201,
-0.2348093241,
0.0113297403,
0.7432991862,
0.482593596,
-0.3055421114,
-0.0310400855,
0.5698871613,
0.0289733745,
0.4568585455,
0.2045110613,
1.1005572081,
-0.298260361,
0.4278581142,
-0.6001278162,
-0.2538430095,
0.0662122518,
-0.9862113595,
-1.0747015476,
-0.8304926157,
-0.2379079461,
0.0583244488,
-0.1664225757,
0.91003865,
0.6813895702,
-0.5484090447,
-0.5929989219,
0.3421396613,
0.170807153,
-0.8911949396,
-0.1966727525,
0.5132887363,
-0.5592646003,
-1.1065545082,
0.6965466738,
0.0819121003,
0.1380331367,
-0.2428168207,
-0.0289995689,
-0.2472533882,
-0.3307051063,
0.9547535777,
0.1891050637,
-0.7654817104,
-0.2624461949,
-0.0557889603,
0.2755355835,
0.0188571624,
0.6939332485,
-0.7275514007,
0.5619907975,
0.0882467255,
0.4710268378,
0.4938361943,
-0.3247841597,
0.5787246227,
-1.1730422974,
0.4879435599,
-0.3160436749,
0.6551264524,
0.4216834009,
-0.0700793117,
-0.0147510078,
0.0495252311,
-0.4182691574,
-0.7231248617,
0.2930363715,
-0.4360866547,
-0.3322621882,
1.2916256189,
-0.3565740585,
-0.0251290742,
-0.130712539,
-0.2563288808,
0.0687209964,
-0.0979964584,
0.7901242375,
0.7491048574,
-0.1218864247,
-0.3137209415,
-1.0274993181,
0.3048675358,
0.2796704471,
-0.746414721,
0.0178795885,
0.265360117,
0.0602806099,
0.1059098616,
0.1278220415,
0.0273764525,
0.3900711238,
-0.2711140811,
-0.0402949788,
0.0515599772,
-0.5478878617,
-0.732170701,
0.2999197841,
-0.0231939536,
-0.1568075269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12969v1
|
GlórIA -- A Generative and Open Large Language Model for Portuguese
| 2024-02-20T12:36:40 | 2024-02-20T12:36:40 |
Ricardo Lopes, João Magalhães, David Semedo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Significant strides have been made in natural language tasks, largely
attributed to the emergence of powerful large language models (LLMs). These
models, pre-trained on extensive and diverse corpora, have become increasingly
capable of comprehending the intricacies of language. Despite the abundance of
LLMs for many high-resource languages, the availability of such models remains
limited for European Portuguese. We introduce Gl\'orIA, a robust European
Portuguese decoder LLM. To pre-train Gl\'orIA, we assembled a comprehensive
PT-PT text corpus comprising 35 billion tokens from various sources. We present
our pre-training methodology, followed by an assessment of the model's
effectiveness on multiple downstream tasks. Additionally, to evaluate our
models' language modeling capabilities, we introduce CALAME-PT (Context-Aware
LAnguage Modeling Evaluation for Portuguese), the first Portuguese zero-shot
language-modeling benchmark. Evaluation shows that Gl\'orIA significantly
outperforms existing open PT decoder models in language modeling and that it
can generate sound, knowledge-rich, and coherent PT-PT text. The model also
exhibits strong potential for various downstream tasks.
|
[
0.1325077713,
-0.652931273,
0.2466151416,
0.1923592091,
-0.430755496,
-0.2303138673,
-0.3485902846,
-0.6323366165,
0.0028820899,
0.7262796164,
-0.2553398609,
-0.749524951,
-0.6463618279,
0.2146069109,
-0.6763619184,
0.8859757185,
-0.000520492,
0.40179196,
0.400254786,
-0.0652992427,
-0.2418193966,
-0.6113434434,
-0.9162285328,
-0.1219156981,
0.3500944376,
0.0558021739,
0.5401067138,
0.8344528079,
0.2844068706,
0.3205471635,
-0.0888471976,
-0.0356243588,
-0.9036982059,
0.0855911598,
-0.2169586867,
-0.6933658719,
-0.6304725409,
-0.1353561282,
0.7752726674,
0.7478343248,
0.0317500345,
-0.0181385279,
0.1481761187,
0.2857793272,
-0.5080986023,
0.4589814842,
-0.727183342,
-0.0435233824,
-0.2236748189,
-0.1775462925,
-0.396563679,
-0.3944023252,
0.2291469872,
-0.6226969957,
0.0406043082,
-0.1966476738,
0.8266549706,
0.2591343522,
-0.3498485684,
-0.5488019586,
-1.00827384,
0.8621103764,
-0.3073679805,
0.6105770469,
0.0156117594,
0.2463668734,
-0.1263204068,
-0.4326214194,
-0.3471732438,
-0.6055124998,
0.3650507629,
0.1211828589,
-0.2520618737,
-0.0058998908,
-0.0479441695,
0.3952560127,
-0.5115403533,
0.2233398557,
-0.4835344553,
-0.0491876528,
0.1175630316,
-0.0717149973,
0.2179948092,
0.0888480172,
-0.4261240363,
-0.011378712,
-1.264133215,
-0.212872535,
0.6765629053,
0.606859684,
-0.1906053424,
0.6395972371,
0.088703908,
0.9233112335,
-0.3846493959,
-0.5553787947,
0.0375564694,
-0.21731776,
-0.4614329636,
0.1416074187,
0.7547197342,
-0.2507036924,
0.5014767051,
-0.2221138775,
-0.1455494463,
0.353933692,
0.1659367383,
-0.8481266499,
0.1806771755,
0.1264874637,
-0.3949581385,
-0.2386458963,
-0.0178497583,
-0.3705663979,
-0.230073154,
-0.4239292145,
0.2350799143,
-0.6971504092,
-0.1291718334,
0.5278137326,
0.2579311132,
0.3037759066,
0.3679205775,
-0.749252975,
0.0915302262,
0.7527377605,
0.4891863465,
-0.0762265027,
-0.2896883786,
-0.5781534314,
0.0334975943,
-0.533546567,
0.5744746327,
-0.528742373,
-0.6145272255,
0.4608815312,
0.064301759,
-0.0397543535,
-0.4352053404,
1.0108667612,
-0.5144793391,
0.4715178013,
-0.1181845665,
-0.2967064977,
-0.1904724687,
0.2641651928,
-0.4900660813,
0.7857060432,
0.271037817,
-0.7841181755,
0.4219768345,
-0.5066635609,
-0.2206569314,
0.1177087352,
-0.1647865325,
-0.0105081713,
0.2042556256,
0.0495614745,
0.2578502893,
-0.493018955,
0.2344651371,
-0.2115326822,
-0.3886492848,
0.1070436314,
-0.6438746452,
0.8185194135,
0.4346596897,
0.0317261517,
0.0534146875,
-0.8140646219,
-0.5207617879,
0.0464807302,
-0.7202829123,
-0.3892115355,
-0.0313205458,
0.0906113014,
0.0415255502,
0.4736729562,
-0.6124210954,
0.3508053422,
-0.7830613852,
0.5410495996,
0.3445745707,
-0.4799263179,
0.5194529891,
0.0273590405,
0.715230763,
-0.0023745624,
0.1314570904,
-0.3413053453,
-0.4095075727,
-0.9397872686,
-0.3342318833,
0.4409417808,
0.66083318,
-0.894387126,
0.3114566207,
-0.4695236385,
-0.4798644185,
-0.7470781803,
0.1146917492,
0.6495350599,
0.5005732775,
0.1105693728,
-0.6154683232,
-0.5170436502,
-0.6830837727,
0.2148795873,
-0.3043589294,
-0.2655449212,
0.1685369015,
0.4641087949,
-0.1773712635,
0.8510374427,
-0.0920024216,
-0.4636768401,
-0.5364835858,
0.1205682382,
0.4112087488,
0.1889200211,
0.6872234941,
-0.5318362713,
-0.2500477731,
0.031863749,
-0.7532504201,
-0.3146901429,
0.2567653954,
0.0524370112,
0.4625281394,
0.4213846624,
-0.2586714625,
0.0820024237,
0.8703759313,
-0.1521869898,
0.6138158441,
-0.7052701712,
0.0572356693,
-1.1318542957,
0.2399937361,
-0.0606047809,
-0.2320451736,
-0.6054670215,
0.0719088838,
-0.0464737639,
-0.2845935225,
-0.8602703214,
0.4381705821,
-0.4160633683,
-0.3012165725,
-0.3245702088,
0.0754689425,
-0.1491333544,
0.181359902,
0.4957026541,
0.7511532903,
0.8941873908,
-0.4633692205,
0.2258628905,
0.1086647883,
-0.3180575669,
0.6812278628,
-0.8269064426,
-0.0788512081,
-0.4023543596,
0.2492687553,
-0.8466712236,
-0.1712989807,
0.2773688138,
-0.272469908,
0.4903945625,
-0.5449364781,
-0.463080585,
-0.3534689844,
-0.1048429161,
0.4090863466,
0.1836916059,
-0.5313717127,
0.6210926175,
0.4366826415,
-0.2705471814,
-0.5021559596,
-0.4595749974,
0.3083160222,
-0.3777033091,
-0.6785719395,
0.3546523452,
0.0621695332,
-0.0223436058,
-0.1692306846,
0.426737994,
-0.1980072856,
-0.0289363377,
0.197328642,
0.4134621322,
-0.537052691,
0.1423088014,
-0.1875939369,
-0.4052245021,
-0.0552913807,
-0.6812830567,
0.7676569223,
-0.2828845978,
-0.2652805746,
-0.1822216958,
0.2579375803,
0.6645683646,
-0.4487770796,
0.6811841726,
0.4309317768,
-0.1699444205,
-0.051734902,
-0.3541371524,
0.2612868547,
-0.3939658403,
0.3873134851,
-0.3283725679,
-1.1763267517,
0.4243703783,
0.093569316,
0.0694592148,
0.2802310288,
0.7916256189,
0.3212617934,
0.8805520535,
1.1460022926,
-0.5154883265,
0.547023952,
-0.1768836528,
0.0611843802,
-0.2937889993,
0.1012506559,
-0.9603527188,
0.2616446912,
-0.5919143558,
-0.5526126027,
0.5093921423,
0.1059229672,
-0.2051493078,
0.5844253898,
-0.3774635196,
0.4015404582,
0.594592452,
-0.3845701516,
0.5464504361,
0.0149948848,
-0.0377406627,
0.2475287467,
-0.6324005127,
-0.8123940825,
1.2002104521,
0.4450880885,
1.0200124979,
-0.0748142377,
0.6222666502,
-0.1037850678,
0.3980523944,
-0.6028374434,
0.3430533409,
-0.3845892847,
-0.575717628,
-0.0476988703,
-0.3803683221,
-1.2625370026,
0.2636400461,
-0.1611673981,
-0.8336969018,
-0.0991470516,
0.160356909,
-0.4974155426,
0.0888434798,
-0.6618408561,
0.9943991303,
-0.224655062,
-0.0862298086,
0.0346652754,
-0.4702174962,
0.4471998215,
-0.0670934618,
0.2000896931,
0.1145739257,
-0.2124815285,
0.4733729661,
-0.1675135344,
0.7644433975,
0.1236735135,
-0.5908522606,
0.4937674701,
0.1006230414,
0.267611742,
-0.0790285841,
-0.032674741,
0.2345749736,
0.0751005933,
-0.2113239318,
-0.0529183783,
0.6085631847,
-0.9219669104,
-0.0225040838,
-0.38045156,
-0.4163309336,
-0.0098865684,
0.095863007,
0.3957571983,
0.5638189316,
-0.5625413656,
-0.0087082526,
0.6946175694,
-0.5821175575,
0.2800489962,
0.8877736926,
-0.4144428372,
-0.3816913962,
0.9681500196,
-0.0844859257,
0.1199925542,
0.6071796417,
0.0197953768,
-0.4246233404,
-0.590609014,
-0.5737660527,
0.4101270437,
-0.3569654524,
0.0624580868,
-0.537232399,
-0.0587345958,
-0.4768767059,
-0.0846739188,
-0.5518107414,
-0.0623213276,
-0.3898379207,
0.0887250528,
-0.0586623773,
0.9891603589,
-0.1169999614,
0.3975311816,
-0.9099788666,
0.1822959483,
0.209065944,
0.1022274643,
-0.2873580158,
-0.4758686721,
-0.0608130731,
-0.0241403356,
-0.185491994,
-0.9908556938,
0.8420716524,
0.0259991884,
0.3124184608,
0.8164975643,
-0.3607269228,
0.1550710946,
-0.4558701217,
0.6919093132,
0.0410659015,
-0.7335489988,
0.4757635891,
-0.8540605903,
0.1973078698,
0.3312188089,
0.4481303096,
-0.354709357,
-0.4609025419,
-0.4893852472,
-0.768974781,
0.6425166726,
0.1334550828,
0.1693550944,
-0.1950255483,
0.0351101793,
0.1820929945,
0.3918082416,
-0.8860617876,
0.1952243298,
-0.0778227374,
0.0853097811,
-0.1811896414,
-0.3900284767,
0.2471245974,
0.0846577659,
0.7619798779,
-0.1433937699,
0.273670733,
-0.1187133789,
-0.1273293346,
-0.1358413994,
0.4477795362,
0.5949290991,
0.5663512945,
-0.2626832426,
-0.0099449651,
0.2200960666,
-0.4124460816,
-0.2143545598,
0.3575429916,
-0.3389895558,
0.0393734425,
0.2629275024,
0.4681966305,
0.3567943275,
-0.7088833451,
0.3951131701,
-0.1842509508,
0.0970364064,
-0.3256146014,
-0.0600119196,
0.1743329614,
0.014720561,
0.0665265098,
-0.3668254614,
-0.0436320715,
-0.7785553932,
-0.3040110469,
0.3460775912,
-0.7293528914,
-0.3642857373,
0.728132844,
0.2621951103,
-0.1839987189,
0.4376856983,
-0.2279776782,
-0.6283910871,
0.3030806184,
0.4084929526,
0.7448937297,
-0.3535544574,
0.1948174834,
0.2396703064,
0.2992604971,
-0.0692452118,
0.5507441759,
0.1437895447,
-0.7138639688,
-0.5873786807,
-1.1638230085,
-0.3450703323,
0.2786039114,
-0.360535115,
0.2812021077,
0.0545860715,
-0.0141315125,
-0.2854146957,
-0.0316366851,
-0.6590573192,
0.1713346839,
0.4110555947,
1.0913871527,
-0.8899139166,
1.2985783815,
0.4041617811,
-0.4031933546,
-0.6160601377,
-0.5209062099,
-0.2349311858,
-0.9268140793,
0.644223094,
0.1782364994,
-0.1475501955,
-0.1597552747,
-0.5471072793,
-0.7438607812,
0.6920703053,
0.8719495535,
-0.3599700332,
-0.1623500586,
0.5453791618,
0.7741521597,
-0.7114803791,
0.3559426963,
0.8129333258,
0.2498555183,
0.3190890849,
-0.997885406,
-0.5323424935,
-0.068065688,
0.1522012949,
0.1615466028,
-0.2875556648,
0.9242761731,
-0.0137891201,
-0.1856501251,
0.6069474816,
0.8163955212,
0.1485802531,
-0.2302616686,
0.3858757317,
0.6228973269,
0.4715053737,
-0.2610995471,
1.2377425432,
-0.5698878765,
0.0975030735,
1.0486396551,
-0.3065667748,
0.9089699984,
0.0593164861,
-0.0651850253,
0.2715749741,
0.3717574477,
0.2180553973,
0.2785156667,
0.3230647445,
-0.4024995565,
-0.3072221875,
-0.5227134824,
-0.5430876613,
0.865471065,
0.4407279789,
-0.6085000038,
-0.6671930552,
-0.0872056708,
0.3295493722,
-0.0568124615,
-0.4099831581,
0.4449028671,
0.0950606093,
-0.9199206829,
0.4100028872,
0.2736607492,
0.6068294644,
-0.9146737456,
-0.0155682256,
-0.1915543079,
0.407587111,
0.310130477,
-0.3832448125,
0.1817019135,
0.3902203143,
0.1826565117,
-0.6055200696,
0.7257453799,
-0.6605585217,
-0.6542679667,
0.3436865509,
0.5551018119,
0.4744541943,
-0.1979014874,
-0.571669817,
0.3686043918,
-0.2200784981,
0.0255580973,
0.380099088,
0.5913208723,
0.1400550604,
0.4834583998,
0.5513857007,
0.2752021551,
0.012382566,
0.2518709302,
0.8711577058,
-0.2462486625,
-0.5563923717,
-0.5786051154,
0.1986573786,
0.2551623285,
-0.5407891273,
0.6906552315,
0.6631395221,
0.8582097888,
-0.1429623961,
0.6823993325,
0.1536853909,
0.5340189934,
-0.4030783474,
0.8060851693,
-0.3167337477,
0.0578766614,
-0.1812327653,
-1.1374659538,
-0.1025838405,
0.6560530066,
-0.4364850819,
-0.0031790941,
0.3691247404,
0.9394215345,
-0.0230543911,
0.059521284,
0.4980943203,
0.5338392258,
0.3654055297,
1.0080704689,
0.8116030693,
-0.2056936324,
0.8927233219,
0.1667169183,
-0.4469786286,
-0.0862438902,
-1.1992578506,
-0.8351306319,
-0.299190402,
-0.0579233877,
-0.3615480065,
0.2636543214,
0.6476907134,
0.6621092558,
-0.8166869283,
-0.552375257,
-0.1391812414,
-0.0131576657,
0.1415062994,
-0.0994744599,
0.2791659534,
-0.406267792,
-1.1355813742,
0.6456590891,
0.5401049852,
0.1818770766,
-0.72582829,
-0.0114614498,
0.2967048585,
0.1210121512,
0.6294186711,
0.5040790439,
-0.4174380898,
-0.1606992632,
-0.086713478,
-0.2684467733,
-0.0645506829,
0.5858649015,
-1.045928359,
0.5009875298,
0.5223437548,
0.2144178003,
0.2861351967,
-0.2875297964,
0.8416987658,
-0.4815390408,
0.3082459867,
0.2002165169,
0.828686893,
0.3701716959,
0.2489009053,
0.530371964,
0.0646132827,
-0.3604240119,
-0.4545913339,
0.2723546028,
-1.1911283731,
-0.1073766574,
1.3299759626,
-0.3901373744,
-0.4463250041,
-0.1113375649,
-0.4612588882,
0.2156809568,
-0.3356668949,
0.7716701627,
0.4130932093,
0.5356295109,
0.4326794446,
-0.4745078385,
0.2120028883,
0.0338991098,
-0.7065224051,
-0.0773530453,
0.5912888646,
0.1225696579,
0.2711515129,
0.6566608548,
-0.254311353,
0.1328746229,
-0.0687746704,
-0.0661422238,
-0.0891149044,
-0.7358614802,
-0.3068902194,
0.5439291596,
0.1447872818,
0.0118654184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12959v1
|
Prompt Stealing Attacks Against Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T12:25:26 | 2024-02-20T12:25:26 |
Zeyang Sha, Yang Zhang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
The increasing reliance on large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT in
various fields emphasizes the importance of ``prompt engineering,'' a
technology to improve the quality of model outputs. With companies investing
significantly in expert prompt engineers and educational resources rising to
meet market demand, designing high-quality prompts has become an intriguing
challenge. In this paper, we propose a novel attack against LLMs, named prompt
stealing attacks. Our proposed prompt stealing attack aims to steal these
well-designed prompts based on the generated answers. The prompt stealing
attack contains two primary modules: the parameter extractor and the prompt
reconstruction. The goal of the parameter extractor is to figure out the
properties of the original prompts. We first observe that most prompts fall
into one of three categories: direct prompt, role-based prompt, and in-context
prompt. Our parameter extractor first tries to distinguish the type of prompts
based on the generated answers. Then, it can further predict which role or how
many contexts are used based on the types of prompts. Following the parameter
extractor, the prompt reconstructor can be used to reconstruct the original
prompts based on the generated answers and the extracted features. The final
goal of the prompt reconstructor is to generate the reversed prompts, which are
similar to the original prompts. Our experimental results show the remarkable
performance of our proposed attacks. Our proposed attacks add a new dimension
to the study of prompt engineering and call for more attention to the security
issues on LLMs.
|
[
-0.3057749867,
-1.1091639996,
0.4250951707,
0.1242081821,
-0.2485162914,
0.1770277619,
0.326295495,
-0.3350331485,
0.0570260882,
0.9842424989,
-0.7574307919,
0.1601975709,
-0.6177518368,
0.2312186658,
-0.4297671616,
0.7364698648,
0.2226660401,
0.0963450819,
0.1493908465,
0.2756159008,
-0.824406445,
-0.5870409608,
-1.0839414597,
0.2486849874,
0.7219937444,
0.1471574008,
0.4851745367,
0.2515347004,
0.1749216467,
0.3594906628,
-0.1777483523,
-0.2337240577,
-0.4143529534,
0.4119238853,
0.0694502667,
-0.3364008367,
-0.3633385599,
0.0895045921,
0.4086744785,
0.1238141879,
0.2195361108,
0.0138160298,
0.1967225969,
0.3723556697,
-0.4544243217,
0.1253646016,
-0.784781456,
-0.1392125487,
-0.276347965,
-0.6529567838,
-0.724892199,
-0.3736746609,
-0.3010800481,
-0.20486857,
0.1627240926,
0.2448305339,
0.720554173,
-0.0091356775,
-0.1947249919,
-0.4674356878,
-0.3117711544,
0.6936058402,
-0.6984732151,
0.0261263773,
0.2670606077,
0.5899193287,
-0.5550216436,
-0.475502938,
-0.4269955754,
-0.310134232,
-0.0887968391,
-0.1551091522,
-0.4015606046,
-0.1203554571,
0.5483888984,
0.0992241502,
-0.5895614028,
0.4628962874,
-0.470295459,
-0.3866017759,
0.4916512966,
0.152082473,
0.7962860465,
-0.476130873,
-0.8241869807,
0.0784376711,
-1.006736517,
0.2519820035,
0.3528121114,
0.3524944782,
0.1148847863,
0.4956801832,
0.0656117648,
0.6359474063,
0.0017461788,
-0.2872711718,
-0.2114838213,
-0.0580880009,
-0.1749737859,
0.1655073613,
0.7793384194,
0.1195571497,
0.3562875688,
-0.1404915303,
-0.4690725803,
-0.400672406,
0.0836801827,
-0.8129088879,
-0.0356806926,
0.152360335,
-0.4158521891,
-0.4849812686,
-0.1332246959,
-1.0726909637,
-0.7977747321,
-0.0358942971,
0.2139064223,
-0.3618954718,
-0.0483605564,
-0.1302295029,
-0.1216526702,
0.7022563815,
0.229493469,
-0.9036489725,
-0.0595200546,
1.0396021605,
0.78961128,
-0.1399502903,
-0.3380430341,
-0.9372649789,
0.0245171078,
-0.0454705209,
0.7202228308,
-0.5128484964,
-0.7375247478,
-0.1043453738,
0.0825016797,
0.0423580557,
-0.3734284639,
0.4744932055,
-1.1909980774,
0.3180235922,
-0.417688489,
-0.5188054442,
0.0220748819,
0.3949904144,
-0.9811420441,
0.5521323085,
-0.2873343527,
-0.8018606901,
0.0391525775,
-0.2977928519,
-0.1621063054,
0.1557251811,
-0.1793467253,
-0.0923157632,
0.0404343605,
0.4620040059,
0.4626586437,
-0.3024843037,
0.0145701291,
-0.3143761456,
-0.1895941794,
0.652032733,
-0.8209417462,
1.3009717464,
0.3235808611,
0.0932966843,
0.0687176883,
-0.7263391614,
-0.2296702564,
0.2867652774,
-0.0706490949,
-0.3125691414,
-0.145246923,
-0.1765643954,
0.202676177,
0.4401587248,
-0.6844325662,
0.3118581772,
-0.3773602247,
0.4666346908,
1.0625269413,
0.5675700307,
0.3899134398,
-0.3497005403,
0.9290434718,
-0.3198081851,
0.1130000576,
-0.421114713,
-0.4631924629,
-0.0368995294,
-0.7735138535,
-0.0715902597,
0.6850145459,
-0.8409695625,
0.1455188841,
0.1012062505,
-0.4561961591,
-0.2673763335,
-0.0496639758,
0.2124088109,
0.4778911173,
0.2424657047,
0.2344666421,
-0.3805670738,
-0.6784458756,
-0.6584159136,
-0.044417128,
-0.1808266342,
0.086081095,
0.1895565838,
-0.1136639789,
1.1095840931,
-0.5413406491,
-0.1310266554,
-0.4626380205,
-0.2393033504,
0.337030232,
0.5977727175,
0.7841296196,
-0.5628407001,
-0.3472338617,
-0.4001773894,
-0.5098441243,
-0.4032301903,
-0.4977405965,
-0.0846224725,
0.1066707969,
0.7787847519,
-1.0702713728,
0.1317998171,
0.1159375161,
-0.4928722084,
0.8693507314,
0.179787457,
0.0057781064,
-1.2591623068,
0.0307504255,
-0.2929570675,
-0.0442649387,
-0.5579659343,
0.3508454263,
-0.1007643268,
-0.5458639264,
-0.6195287108,
0.8248688579,
-0.6272926331,
0.1456212997,
-0.2677843273,
-0.0378923453,
-0.1263803989,
0.4141284823,
-0.4962477088,
0.8885023594,
0.5952002406,
-0.3190584183,
0.597009182,
0.2271239311,
-0.2379949242,
0.5335522294,
-0.8080756068,
0.3663752675,
-0.1208308786,
0.1785050631,
-1.2736631632,
-0.1549116969,
0.4521705806,
-0.6950455308,
0.4904125333,
-0.3261245787,
-0.5572847128,
0.0254517812,
-0.4084364176,
-0.021724686,
0.4859377742,
-0.6895483732,
0.6522951126,
0.2715961635,
-0.6984604001,
-0.7642886639,
-0.4217502773,
0.2466347516,
-0.4115566313,
-0.5604364872,
-0.0663851574,
-0.0148048699,
-0.3456021547,
-0.3149855137,
-0.158684209,
0.0237247571,
0.525590837,
0.0682569817,
0.5165383816,
-0.0870441422,
-0.3917942643,
-0.0350217074,
-0.2041332722,
0.5776368976,
0.1828005016,
0.8219521046,
0.4470897317,
-0.386270225,
-0.6198548079,
0.6847094297,
0.8645867705,
-0.3237736225,
0.4283470511,
0.2518424094,
-0.2540947199,
-0.2661682665,
-0.5079550743,
-0.3416486979,
-0.6012094021,
0.4722735882,
-0.4683010876,
-0.8542703986,
0.5433977842,
0.032092452,
0.5226886272,
0.0604218617,
0.1671483517,
0.0497093275,
1.0741537809,
0.2489361614,
-0.366476953,
0.5491634011,
0.2264224589,
0.0400951467,
-0.5605829954,
-0.1201868728,
-0.6428274512,
-0.180899024,
-0.3045806885,
-0.1099531725,
0.0277543534,
0.1262212545,
-0.2490407825,
0.3224579096,
-0.0362176821,
0.683729291,
0.5063652396,
-0.146042183,
0.0709499568,
0.1894894838,
0.0706154928,
0.1542218775,
-0.3091681302,
-0.7429947853,
0.6982047558,
0.31141904,
0.8045701981,
0.0912239701,
0.8094889522,
0.389757663,
-0.2605277598,
-0.6198250651,
1.0019224882,
0.3210193813,
-0.3914974034,
-0.1554680467,
-0.494146049,
-1.0905103683,
0.47838974,
0.0201502405,
-0.9368092418,
-0.0067040049,
-0.1592681557,
-0.3892526031,
0.5375697017,
-0.6992613673,
0.5890760422,
-0.0782524049,
-0.0809615031,
-0.02639376,
-0.5015923381,
0.3605886102,
-0.1107291803,
0.1878024042,
-0.0380440056,
0.1485705674,
0.659086585,
-0.3483419418,
1.1421530247,
-0.3961676061,
-0.2844082415,
0.3062710464,
0.6545951366,
0.8091750145,
0.3124312162,
0.003960616,
-0.1364224553,
0.0851931497,
-0.5268709064,
-0.701362133,
0.7449780703,
-0.6667504907,
-1.0655909777,
-0.3724381924,
-0.1960347444,
-0.0415639915,
0.1274710745,
0.2905271947,
0.6123694181,
-0.2974044681,
-0.1906247437,
0.381634742,
-0.4321120381,
0.8606987596,
0.3946835995,
-0.0995117947,
-0.4653059244,
0.9445179105,
-0.1038235128,
0.4402747154,
0.3169294298,
0.1032852679,
0.038366504,
-0.4259645939,
-0.4495915174,
0.2760717571,
-0.5099001527,
-0.2413275391,
-0.6412541866,
-0.3298530877,
-0.3153506815,
-0.2568604052,
-0.0151158245,
-0.440313518,
-0.555298686,
0.0138198212,
0.2046861947,
0.3612216413,
0.3661995232,
0.415599227,
-1.0674571991,
0.1682451218,
0.6382792592,
-0.2460618317,
0.3163021207,
-0.5416040421,
0.3636796474,
-0.241860643,
-0.2745699286,
-1.2071535587,
0.6600525379,
-0.3211293817,
0.6005941033,
0.4561749101,
0.1687069237,
0.1533797383,
-0.694650352,
0.9173280001,
0.1188623533,
-0.800778985,
0.3556885421,
-0.1469929814,
0.313708812,
0.2741879821,
0.2379297763,
-0.5562301874,
-0.3544422686,
-0.5951592922,
-0.7552832365,
0.7837677002,
-0.0196298379,
0.3014827073,
-0.0337893963,
0.3273454607,
0.2838852108,
-0.090956144,
-0.5402988195,
-0.1565711349,
0.0766807124,
0.0308281071,
0.2181510627,
-0.7188333869,
0.1203542724,
0.3454395533,
0.5493233204,
0.2146168202,
0.1493855119,
-0.0444451459,
-0.228840366,
0.338632226,
0.4852623045,
0.381272465,
0.3629202545,
0.2570871115,
0.1472029537,
0.2367485911,
-0.5840343237,
0.0478858165,
0.0960307419,
-0.268238306,
-0.1893872768,
0.6016104221,
0.6710686088,
-0.0122357206,
-0.579005897,
0.517916739,
-0.0840380043,
0.3698681295,
-0.4576347172,
0.0529060736,
-0.1274695098,
0.4040727913,
0.3947511613,
0.2261312157,
0.0000885083,
-0.2806339562,
0.2032765895,
0.5781082511,
-0.4427673221,
-0.6286591887,
0.4324591756,
0.1715908349,
-0.7307418585,
0.5839087963,
0.0285565201,
-0.5449608564,
0.6901206374,
0.8393634558,
0.9259121418,
-0.4986099303,
0.0702386424,
0.1985097826,
0.3445415497,
0.1517471373,
0.2736804187,
0.0352855474,
-0.455413878,
-0.3169605136,
-0.3952262998,
-0.3147638142,
0.2445603311,
-0.3996014893,
0.4582214355,
-0.6875984669,
0.1865196526,
-0.2937597632,
-0.4184623659,
-0.2682085335,
-0.2848521471,
0.1613969803,
0.6484802961,
-0.3596056998,
0.5725800991,
0.3171325624,
-0.2341885269,
-0.6310225725,
0.0364866331,
0.2402767241,
-0.8855361938,
0.7646477222,
0.265181452,
0.0139599675,
-0.0059150918,
-0.7956680059,
-0.8918426633,
0.7608270049,
0.3795606196,
-0.470710963,
-0.3413484395,
-0.003327138,
-0.0244736578,
-0.0457069241,
0.1243302524,
0.5244991183,
0.1510060579,
0.0566737279,
-0.6136229038,
0.4785814285,
-0.1351956278,
-0.2957958281,
0.2067506313,
-0.4548712969,
1.0392124653,
-0.1605098397,
-0.6385041475,
0.2913164198,
0.5219688416,
0.6542553306,
-0.0214656051,
0.4752686918,
0.0488995984,
0.6499440074,
0.291351527,
0.8435740471,
-0.107053481,
0.1194805279,
1.069638133,
-0.3742864132,
0.6947057843,
0.5631171465,
0.178786844,
0.1407487839,
0.3376864195,
-0.1244160533,
0.4611724615,
0.2511346638,
-0.2569031417,
0.0234501958,
0.2284459919,
-0.2766709328,
0.3610746264,
0.3298619688,
-0.2731078565,
-0.3262127936,
0.2006542683,
0.5121032,
-0.2303004265,
-0.2640836835,
0.8271402717,
0.2481007129,
-0.4999855459,
0.5505766869,
-0.0740829632,
0.5573269129,
-0.6908974051,
0.0232553743,
-0.1824173778,
0.0027910988,
0.0928175822,
-0.4638403356,
-0.0146164466,
0.1777458042,
0.0788992643,
-0.3593815863,
0.8325375915,
-0.0839921087,
-0.160059154,
0.2079865634,
0.3997600377,
-0.0632579699,
-0.2989854813,
-0.5353993177,
-0.0597880185,
0.1695485264,
-0.5119439363,
0.3884381354,
0.4853150547,
0.0730335414,
0.6673754454,
0.6935066581,
0.2570666671,
0.1686956584,
-0.243073836,
0.9156238437,
-0.8479741812,
-0.6719176173,
-1.4380831718,
0.1201017126,
-0.2420590371,
-0.2030342072,
0.9572244287,
0.4110238552,
0.4654790163,
-0.2258419842,
0.7234816551,
0.1287250221,
0.5766692758,
-0.7829350233,
0.9624605179,
-0.0932905599,
0.7167286873,
-0.5101397038,
-0.9348793626,
-0.1461920142,
-0.0438001119,
-0.2707415819,
-0.1168995798,
0.521084249,
0.95566082,
0.1077212766,
0.3131124973,
0.1298244894,
0.2838941514,
0.9466556311,
0.4229895473,
1.3643256426,
-0.0601973981,
0.6099043489,
0.2300827652,
-0.3947629929,
-0.0343700461,
-0.5671460629,
-1.1746295691,
-0.3696507215,
-0.0564346388,
-0.282656014,
-0.1266017854,
1.0703299046,
0.1802045703,
-0.6639896631,
-0.0965280309,
0.1120049804,
0.1596589684,
-0.0489662103,
-0.2914125621,
0.5600836873,
-0.4465870559,
-0.5613831878,
0.6894674301,
0.0370477699,
0.0752635673,
-0.3225330114,
0.4510546923,
-0.0132365059,
0.3117105663,
0.5320217013,
0.4777135551,
-0.8270340562,
-0.263875097,
0.0856205449,
-0.1659198999,
-0.1918610781,
0.940803051,
-0.7264007926,
0.0708380863,
0.8454983234,
0.8828954697,
-0.0657939985,
-0.0468452759,
0.4744947255,
-0.7626615167,
-0.0037253022,
0.2736788988,
0.6043306589,
0.2663735449,
-0.5177093744,
-0.0642780289,
0.3113842607,
-0.4983480573,
-0.9540762901,
0.6032915711,
-1.0437858105,
-0.6640161872,
1.389288187,
-0.1938152164,
-0.3542951345,
-0.1525470763,
-0.9145787358,
-0.113129735,
-0.5371464491,
0.6986005902,
0.5057299733,
0.1479655951,
-0.0636481419,
-0.5695311427,
0.4675603807,
0.1458556205,
-0.5839926004,
0.3457758129,
0.5169894695,
0.3903526664,
0.0928899422,
0.2355977446,
-0.4854144454,
0.1385207474,
-0.1096931547,
-0.1911546439,
-0.2677561939,
-0.1365348697,
-0.4466438591,
0.6955384612,
0.0487384386,
-0.2854655981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12948v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12948v3
|
GumbelSoft: Diversified Language Model Watermarking via the GumbelMax-trick
| 2024-02-20T12:05:47 | 2024-05-28T04:58:41 |
Jiayi Fu, Xuandong Zhao, Ruihan Yang, Yuansen Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) excellently generate human-like text, but also
raise concerns about misuse in fake news and academic dishonesty.
Decoding-based watermark, particularly the GumbelMax-trick-based watermark(GM
watermark), is a standout solution for safeguarding machine-generated texts due
to its notable detectability. However, GM watermark encounters a major
challenge with generation diversity, always yielding identical outputs for the
same prompt, negatively impacting generation diversity and user experience. To
overcome this limitation, we propose a new type of GM watermark, the
Logits-Addition watermark, and its three variants, specifically designed to
enhance diversity. Among these, the GumbelSoft watermark (a softmax variant of
the Logits-Addition watermark) demonstrates superior performance in high
diversity settings, with its AUROC score outperforming those of the two
alternative variants by 0.1 to 0.3 and surpassing other decoding-based
watermarking methods by a minimum of 0.1.
|
[
-0.49698928,
-0.5855128765,
0.0613621175,
0.4547146559,
-0.6223296523,
0.6447994113,
0.0212028269,
-0.6182128787,
0.2922602892,
0.5491684079,
-0.461787343,
-0.4745334089,
-0.8178442121,
0.128523007,
-0.5681110024,
1.0539677143,
0.1162144914,
-0.0608001128,
0.1370050162,
-0.5309276581,
-0.3624028563,
-0.7094236612,
-0.563126564,
-0.2797668874,
0.4086118639,
0.1449588388,
0.9095677137,
0.5598926544,
0.140078336,
0.2640719712,
-0.4220334291,
0.189791441,
-0.6344236732,
0.2780021131,
-0.0671875477,
-0.4254907668,
-0.4373199344,
-0.1989472955,
0.5781292915,
0.4929849505,
-0.1399668455,
-0.0225669574,
0.1765515357,
0.662095964,
-0.6539915204,
0.0979646891,
-0.7734129429,
0.1380216181,
-0.1903514266,
-0.0615115389,
-0.3440262079,
-0.4778296053,
-0.258772254,
-0.4056582749,
0.3052049279,
0.1364455074,
1.0333149433,
-0.2203688323,
-0.5603084564,
-0.2492120266,
-0.7223849893,
0.9476636052,
-0.855676651,
0.1337977499,
0.0658365488,
0.3426707387,
-0.0814168081,
-0.5468565822,
-0.2751223743,
0.2434735447,
0.0974122733,
0.1731598228,
-0.5285233259,
-0.1879666001,
0.2109681368,
0.5353645682,
-0.5386908054,
-0.1392427534,
-0.1289873719,
-0.366963774,
0.7527051568,
0.1932711005,
0.1305329949,
0.1224109828,
-0.2318684012,
-0.2467431277,
-0.8356533647,
0.0559202284,
0.4866507351,
0.35006091,
0.2856180966,
0.3746335804,
-0.1693257391,
0.727414012,
-0.2283281237,
-0.3276559711,
0.3977487087,
-0.0791586712,
-0.1748156101,
0.1811446995,
0.4841743112,
0.2147983611,
0.4331476688,
-0.1243249401,
-0.5205723047,
0.0829116032,
-0.2534691691,
-0.9722045064,
0.0726007,
-0.1002057344,
-0.3551186621,
-0.3472855389,
0.3085021377,
-0.6368861198,
-0.4746717811,
0.0517354831,
0.3198963702,
-0.45829162,
-0.3899790645,
0.3919522762,
-0.3811514378,
0.1317124367,
0.2447707951,
-0.8248534799,
0.3503698111,
0.7843132019,
0.7605877519,
-0.2750090659,
0.0290557053,
-0.7321308255,
0.472348392,
-0.1890117079,
1.0460723639,
-0.7758638263,
-0.8052402139,
-0.0556620136,
0.0249215513,
0.2118917555,
-0.7783887982,
0.3708150685,
-0.6142047048,
0.2367066741,
-0.1127711609,
-0.8396618366,
-0.263739109,
0.0377478562,
-0.9234847426,
0.8957531452,
0.3616439402,
-0.6103098392,
0.4086267948,
-0.4736291468,
-0.5977959037,
0.517585814,
-0.1700782627,
-0.6111707091,
0.1211889908,
0.1678514183,
0.1301161796,
-0.1354890168,
0.4174085259,
-0.3110569119,
-0.2601112425,
0.4612022936,
-0.7037338018,
0.9097923636,
0.1132494658,
-0.4568889141,
0.0433238484,
-0.8493334651,
0.1856679171,
0.2974578142,
-0.631921649,
-0.3571098149,
-0.3403654695,
0.0796361864,
-0.0515542142,
0.1571309417,
-0.345969677,
0.0341783799,
-0.027350571,
0.0969443768,
0.8163453341,
-0.0294467844,
0.185705319,
-0.552312851,
0.973995924,
0.1046654135,
0.241603449,
-0.281471014,
-1.0720566511,
-0.3418736458,
-0.6717826128,
0.6162574291,
0.6454700828,
-0.5485876203,
0.3921709955,
-0.3493899703,
-0.4304078817,
-0.5224705935,
0.5185654759,
0.2445609272,
0.2837419212,
0.3023410141,
-0.5398644209,
-0.3609746099,
-0.8983265758,
-0.8027390242,
-0.0998809487,
-0.2191988677,
0.5266337991,
0.2086877376,
-0.4256317914,
1.1912939548,
-0.4264740646,
-0.0545228124,
-0.3559925556,
0.1776929945,
0.1646467447,
0.2903002203,
0.8482186198,
-0.8028563261,
-0.6833316684,
-0.2276584208,
-0.3296565711,
-0.3932319283,
0.0350498296,
0.0372406617,
0.2352333367,
0.1574946791,
-0.4566639364,
0.3813378513,
1.0692453384,
-0.728200376,
0.639996469,
0.1129822284,
0.0871581063,
-0.8521670103,
-0.0494512096,
-0.3152787685,
-0.4646172822,
-0.5679394007,
-0.1058921441,
0.1413924545,
0.0016579818,
-0.2488831282,
0.6441781521,
-0.428142488,
0.0822902471,
-0.493201375,
-0.0556917302,
0.3010267913,
0.0269871,
-0.3321343064,
0.6604843736,
0.6877315044,
-0.2190788984,
0.5527852774,
-0.0151234567,
-0.3082563579,
0.3685893714,
-0.595885098,
-0.0314242765,
-0.3221823275,
0.320787102,
-0.7400307655,
0.0141044958,
0.110691376,
-0.2036451697,
0.4007611871,
-0.1384194195,
-0.5567006469,
-0.0415121056,
-0.4908195734,
0.3923680782,
0.8024677634,
-0.6446130872,
0.739477694,
0.1680398881,
-0.3347608447,
-0.6024051905,
-0.8633685708,
0.4066332579,
-0.3918971419,
-0.8113678098,
0.4314174652,
-0.2636072636,
-0.1234785914,
0.2596004307,
-0.2389840633,
0.0474607423,
0.233638227,
0.2068981081,
0.2525891066,
-0.4081245959,
-0.2901071012,
0.3920808733,
-0.2042707354,
-0.3899353445,
-0.3415929973,
0.3976095021,
-0.3679305613,
-0.3719235063,
0.1765333712,
0.7739007473,
0.2075701803,
-0.1764877588,
0.7934701443,
0.5803806186,
-0.3623369336,
-0.3276035786,
-0.5255877376,
-0.1096901894,
-0.5682265162,
0.1505976617,
-0.0992850289,
-1.3928645849,
0.3987710476,
-0.0872490853,
0.389193505,
0.2523433566,
0.1779505908,
0.2600028217,
1.0565416813,
0.6456121206,
-0.1580110192,
0.5483090878,
0.1068245769,
0.24575454,
-0.4419394433,
-0.0812090561,
-0.3500157893,
-0.2268887609,
-0.482091397,
-0.2825484872,
-0.0983631238,
0.4893906415,
0.0548036546,
0.4255256057,
-0.4520156682,
0.4445556998,
0.4996605814,
-0.2707983553,
0.6840937138,
0.5141818523,
-0.0994472131,
-0.0168502945,
-0.8635668755,
-0.6823259592,
0.9045343995,
0.1734186113,
0.8737196922,
0.209017992,
0.9545449018,
0.2639077902,
0.9466532469,
-0.4757742882,
0.6253361106,
-0.1577829868,
-0.9389610291,
-0.2723186612,
-0.6015678048,
-1.2086404562,
0.483517319,
-0.1011406183,
-0.6138477325,
0.0901766345,
0.203783825,
-0.1737242341,
0.3439463377,
-0.6678134203,
0.6156778932,
-0.339854598,
-0.19773449,
-0.2393696606,
-0.2471576929,
0.1915581822,
-0.1921009868,
0.6370022893,
-0.4540806413,
-0.2397446632,
0.6136113405,
-0.1198345274,
0.67460078,
-0.1836856604,
-0.3789452016,
0.3905640841,
0.3308192492,
0.5831082463,
0.2635546625,
-0.0800096765,
0.178020969,
-0.3910963535,
-0.5320920348,
-0.4282026589,
0.6222491264,
-0.3045422137,
-0.8438713551,
-0.3991775215,
-0.4248121977,
-0.2128313482,
0.2810927033,
0.150722146,
0.4254007041,
-0.1502652764,
0.2902213931,
0.6800518632,
-0.3477229774,
0.6092666984,
0.5598857403,
-0.5329110622,
-0.5697863102,
1.0853532553,
-0.1226857007,
0.2712478638,
0.0579697043,
0.3150482774,
-0.098732017,
-0.5649321079,
-0.3203534186,
0.270929873,
-0.9975666404,
-0.2949353755,
-0.5817122459,
-0.3636297584,
-0.2693997622,
-0.2618972659,
-0.2505929768,
-0.5561071634,
-0.3351356685,
-0.1107124984,
0.4923441708,
0.5598211884,
-0.1696266234,
0.2411244661,
-1.0292692184,
0.4463050961,
0.7609753609,
0.5405628085,
-0.4096004367,
-0.6822960377,
0.0030543795,
-0.0239421725,
-0.3868056536,
-0.8585795164,
0.422083497,
0.3523919284,
0.6543633938,
0.5772470832,
-0.2609537542,
0.4287951291,
-0.3931147754,
0.6415781379,
0.5225195885,
-0.9117487073,
0.1646187901,
-0.1997767091,
0.4992062151,
0.3364890218,
0.0086071482,
-0.5133437514,
-0.6528480053,
-0.7821059823,
-1.0301764011,
0.4139451087,
0.4491705596,
0.3521877229,
0.1913179904,
-0.0524584837,
0.4811011255,
0.3961719275,
-0.9964905977,
-0.4196316004,
-0.6629211903,
-0.2033835053,
-0.0668953583,
-0.458299458,
-0.1788955331,
-0.0168280173,
0.7877340913,
-0.207497552,
-0.0977606624,
-0.1478214562,
-0.1681195199,
-0.0918708965,
0.5711126924,
0.5526233912,
0.4852535129,
0.079530932,
0.1826788336,
0.1008745208,
-0.4597283006,
0.1347006559,
0.1410352886,
-0.3489656448,
0.5186066031,
0.3917941451,
0.9639085531,
-0.1049390435,
-0.8208096027,
0.3175834417,
-0.197124958,
-0.2095538825,
0.1400076896,
0.4750051796,
0.4918377101,
0.149206087,
0.7045654655,
0.0656820759,
0.0559313297,
-0.3824023306,
0.1210575178,
0.5653861165,
-0.0809232444,
-0.224884063,
0.4677658379,
0.2761601806,
-0.5126065016,
0.1398884654,
-0.3106111586,
-0.6400488019,
0.5795537233,
0.675006032,
0.9474463463,
-0.4720870852,
0.215989098,
0.224368155,
0.466314882,
-0.1415010095,
0.4912424386,
0.0726569146,
-0.6845077276,
-0.2055299431,
-0.6278693676,
-0.3431867659,
0.0420090109,
-0.5211673975,
0.1200466901,
-0.5337975025,
-0.3763882816,
-0.1846286207,
-0.3580532074,
-0.5166119337,
0.2212370187,
0.4906528592,
0.7944248915,
-0.6255218983,
0.8044831157,
0.5420402884,
0.3589774966,
-0.3861939311,
-0.0712343231,
-0.1604504883,
-0.7464246154,
0.0911528096,
0.3776117861,
-0.2995016575,
0.0115303202,
-0.6722242236,
-0.9538523555,
1.0797829628,
0.7088656425,
-0.8048011065,
0.2773430943,
0.3797143698,
0.2877216935,
-0.4945006371,
-0.2128588706,
0.5282604694,
0.6069974899,
-0.238447696,
-0.5199417472,
0.3516034782,
-0.4113046825,
0.294124037,
-0.0128447684,
-0.6457086205,
0.5833419561,
0.1260929853,
-0.516792655,
-0.1652357131,
0.4917125404,
0.6168358326,
-0.0134751135,
0.7718914151,
0.2494360059,
0.7091804147,
-0.1197676584,
1.0101084709,
-0.3495580256,
0.3207567036,
0.8758168221,
-0.3220157623,
0.3159310818,
0.5283010602,
-0.0761451349,
0.7104436755,
0.3260470629,
-0.3426956832,
0.4784306884,
0.2172043473,
-0.5493963957,
-0.3721337616,
-0.0966029912,
-0.4856544733,
-0.0651866049,
0.5323165059,
-0.1712303758,
-0.1741412878,
-0.1556120664,
-0.1048604473,
-0.1230062619,
-0.0308661629,
0.5587486625,
0.4203349054,
-0.4827386439,
0.5546761751,
0.3481645882,
0.9577605128,
-0.8431919813,
0.23450616,
-0.5248971581,
-0.0189824607,
-0.2520895898,
-0.7786393762,
0.1244433299,
0.0849395171,
0.0430057906,
-0.324775219,
0.8055233955,
-0.4747284949,
-0.662166357,
0.5917479396,
0.3014630973,
-0.194751814,
0.0321524478,
-0.869007647,
0.1514675915,
0.1004574969,
-0.549515903,
0.1585262865,
0.3685993254,
-0.086523585,
0.7462239861,
0.5235587358,
0.0583932847,
0.4352381825,
0.3743333519,
0.7905148268,
-0.7051622868,
-0.7625633478,
-0.9858592153,
0.4161169827,
-0.3385063112,
-0.2747078538,
0.8709246516,
0.6825152636,
0.6352000237,
-0.0983508974,
1.1462551355,
0.1787834764,
0.1682693213,
-0.2136514187,
0.4866431057,
-0.5880370736,
0.2516960502,
-0.4564808905,
-1.0419888496,
-0.4300282598,
0.2884459496,
0.3142476082,
0.2263964117,
0.6217622757,
0.8522880673,
-0.1683735847,
0.2711437941,
0.4072684348,
-0.1558231413,
0.4755642414,
0.5397654176,
0.9123337865,
-0.2200999856,
1.0657378435,
0.0449758433,
-0.4049331844,
-0.4208417833,
-1.0164042711,
-0.8742858171,
-0.0800708383,
-0.5602846742,
-0.319609493,
-0.0721229911,
0.450008601,
0.5321572423,
-1.1899131536,
-0.3020731807,
-0.0613211617,
0.1058919206,
-0.3126905859,
-0.1860412806,
-0.0577223897,
0.0465879887,
-0.4766936302,
0.399700135,
0.5619391799,
0.6543614268,
-0.1446692944,
-0.3477254808,
0.2241992652,
0.5400878787,
0.4657459557,
0.20862405,
-0.4386148155,
0.0471150577,
-0.0889243782,
-0.1760464609,
0.2625578642,
1.1663393974,
-0.5872577429,
0.163995266,
0.3780774772,
0.6240793467,
0.6954733133,
0.0134169981,
0.4486009181,
-0.7181745768,
0.3189845681,
0.4054990113,
0.5447173715,
0.7298631668,
-0.1719442159,
0.1891070157,
0.5837575197,
0.0273156743,
-0.8647305369,
0.3877987564,
-0.6618652344,
-0.6570027471,
1.3336215019,
-0.2200565934,
-0.078022182,
-0.2188162655,
-0.1840264201,
-0.0047733258,
-0.480574131,
0.8111432195,
0.7607118487,
0.2498366982,
0.0528999642,
-0.2431375384,
0.4032471776,
0.8067682981,
-0.7786343694,
0.0552843325,
0.3764431477,
0.5745537281,
-0.0150489239,
0.3712108731,
-0.3094941378,
0.220199272,
0.1093212366,
-0.0184984133,
-0.1368465871,
-0.1411673725,
-0.4436605871,
0.3917015791,
0.0521371961,
0.2070047855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12940v2
|
Normalized Orthography for Tunisian Arabic
| 2024-02-20T11:52:29 | 2024-06-11T20:28:35 |
Houcemeddine Turki, Kawthar Ellouze, Hager Ben Ammar, Mohamed Ali Hadj Taieb, Imed Adel, Mohamed Ben Aouicha, Pier Luigi Farri, Abderrezak Bennour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tunisian Arabic (ISO 693-3: aeb) isa distinct variety native to Tunisia,
derived from Arabic and enriched by various historical influences. This
research introduces the "Normalized Orthography for Tunisian Arabic" (NOTA), an
adaptation of CODA* guidelines for transcribing Tunisian Arabic using Arabic
script. The aim is to enhance language resource development by ensuring
user-friendliness and consistency. The updated standard addresses challenges in
accurately representing Tunisian phonology and morphology, correcting issues
from transcriptions based on Modern Standard Arabic.
|
[
-0.3054130077,
-0.5681316257,
0.2530175149,
0.2734687626,
-0.4016311765,
-0.1504073143,
-0.0427181311,
-0.6007866263,
0.5822085738,
0.5380620956,
-0.215496555,
-0.9818618298,
-0.5320591927,
0.3058697283,
-0.1643403918,
0.8657023311,
-0.0816740245,
0.2728559673,
0.5934491158,
-0.6308726072,
-0.4629183114,
-0.3675236404,
-0.5032553077,
0.0749246925,
0.4740764201,
0.634370029,
1.0602066517,
0.534537673,
0.4495089948,
0.1992965192,
0.1280168146,
0.0393216237,
-0.1899006069,
0.1896166503,
0.0403785631,
-0.4510518312,
-0.6056973934,
-0.4291883111,
0.617292285,
0.8106283545,
0.0043567526,
0.2489702106,
-0.5408765674,
0.9837844372,
-0.9144392014,
0.0632111505,
-0.1742909104,
-0.4602906704,
-0.7355948091,
-0.1051100269,
0.036445871,
-1.0761318207,
0.0537982583,
-0.0334759541,
0.1319117248,
-0.3082437515,
0.690441668,
-0.2694270313,
-0.5398673415,
-0.4487275779,
-0.6137682796,
0.6600791216,
-0.6268286705,
0.4601968229,
0.2097120136,
0.4255216122,
-0.3429907858,
-0.553145051,
-0.3199845552,
-0.0078104222,
0.2579689026,
-0.0401691683,
-0.0408649333,
0.1451556087,
0.1911406517,
0.593883276,
-0.6296620369,
-0.0980793536,
-0.5491277575,
-0.1904512793,
0.9375849962,
-0.2751164138,
0.9398908615,
0.024023965,
-0.0903728753,
0.0366025008,
-1.015468955,
0.1816471219,
0.5647372007,
0.2860641479,
-0.5215047002,
0.3318687975,
-0.1196126714,
0.9948378801,
-0.348502785,
-0.4020376801,
0.66931355,
-0.0144690378,
-0.1915098876,
0.2315272838,
0.2629615664,
0.4165563881,
0.4260292947,
-0.2374228239,
-0.5387863517,
-0.2732518315,
-0.026194226,
-0.6344013214,
-0.1290636212,
0.0166447833,
-0.6460348964,
0.2714251876,
0.3573282063,
-0.6310908794,
-0.2517181337,
-0.027470028,
0.2549068034,
-0.4954999089,
-0.1801074594,
0.1914522797,
-0.354880929,
0.3242858648,
0.4581384659,
-1.0239189863,
0.1002634019,
-0.0654314011,
0.8703430891,
-0.1810390949,
0.3276616037,
0.2004751116,
0.2283565104,
-0.6360943913,
0.7954102159,
-0.5433532596,
-0.726293385,
0.4267815351,
-0.2231266946,
-0.0958861038,
-0.5633072257,
0.8518229127,
-0.7846978307,
-0.1443993747,
0.0526680686,
-0.1864917576,
-0.9455509782,
0.0097281933,
-1.0513894558,
0.7857831717,
0.6198683977,
-0.1619056165,
0.2070633173,
-0.8123893142,
-0.6227740049,
0.1457808912,
-0.4034908116,
0.0457273833,
0.4964291155,
0.2906371057,
-0.1397124231,
-0.4217156768,
0.0460176952,
-0.0313033201,
-0.3462471068,
0.0899103135,
-0.269659251,
1.1855466366,
0.5970137119,
-0.2769708037,
-0.0386280753,
-1.3072829247,
0.3011454642,
-0.3042619526,
-0.2180512547,
-0.3219424784,
-0.2151271999,
0.5736041069,
0.1734524071,
0.4568628371,
-0.6685220003,
0.2016092092,
-0.3761979043,
0.4811318219,
0.4898328185,
0.3512699604,
0.3208541274,
-0.7841128707,
0.6344538927,
-0.2462644279,
0.0211669914,
0.0770155266,
-0.6842238903,
-0.7570998669,
-0.8395277262,
0.4800824225,
0.1917987466,
-0.3086362481,
0.3988472819,
-0.1440299898,
-0.7948545218,
-0.6766213775,
0.0756378993,
-0.073310405,
0.0758540258,
0.3377768695,
-0.5856209993,
-0.7264207602,
-1.1400815248,
-0.2340900153,
-0.1007489935,
-0.0083512906,
-0.0177485924,
0.1739203334,
-0.4154512882,
0.7971853614,
-0.0709982812,
-0.7384472489,
-0.3026055098,
0.3686071038,
0.6783145666,
0.5326877832,
1.0071573257,
-0.5869039893,
-0.8371120095,
-0.1570389122,
-0.3046745062,
-0.4127320349,
-0.1838816553,
-0.1112673953,
0.4422679245,
0.3321914971,
0.0327440202,
0.9324988723,
0.7282156348,
-0.1927084923,
-0.1476639807,
-0.0597094707,
0.2997682393,
-0.942109704,
0.0433051288,
-0.3114926815,
-0.35641101,
-0.6683195829,
0.031805262,
0.2255343646,
0.1874525845,
-0.4302872717,
0.3198911846,
-0.7547081113,
0.0428327993,
-0.2251331806,
-0.3647726476,
0.033477556,
0.0246338062,
0.2735560834,
1.166672349,
0.3929105103,
-0.4573608339,
0.0880635232,
0.1832958609,
-0.4642755687,
0.4374275208,
-0.5577492118,
0.3570446372,
-0.0610280856,
0.075698629,
-0.9286358356,
-0.0559602864,
-0.2009530216,
-0.478451699,
0.1180456802,
0.1163024753,
-0.4581743777,
0.3614269793,
-0.4800997078,
0.7832551599,
0.7684819102,
-0.2870036364,
0.8307279944,
0.3750160038,
-0.2699312568,
-0.0314562544,
-0.6953825355,
-0.1030382589,
0.2323206663,
-0.884567678,
0.5340936184,
0.2471438944,
-0.3199005127,
-0.4450380504,
-0.3055289984,
-0.3476701081,
-0.0063746842,
0.2766511142,
0.2420590073,
-0.3920342326,
-0.1492813975,
0.1254866272,
0.2259185761,
0.0367385522,
0.0422373116,
0.5524950027,
0.1110672355,
-0.2236280888,
-0.8147572875,
0.5094262958,
0.5375449061,
-0.0689589456,
0.8004692793,
0.3250689507,
-0.4951166213,
0.2674677968,
-0.8460727334,
-0.1315752417,
-0.4515384138,
-0.0114065893,
-0.5802896023,
-0.5075592995,
0.6657080054,
0.1685149819,
0.2148817927,
0.591391623,
0.7389090061,
-0.230488345,
0.8663679361,
0.782397449,
0.0409748852,
0.4085744321,
0.1000588536,
0.1456654817,
-0.6397833824,
-0.512200892,
-0.9356242418,
-0.7284713387,
-0.7434777617,
-0.2778165936,
0.334354192,
-0.0265659485,
-0.1972803771,
0.179315865,
0.0427613221,
0.3289917707,
0.6458229423,
-0.1161015481,
0.3327097595,
0.2391569465,
0.1853666008,
-0.0786398426,
-0.3157570064,
-0.8627868295,
1.50472188,
0.1454672068,
0.9389368296,
0.7842357755,
1.0266077518,
0.6217489243,
0.2313180119,
-0.4311451018,
-0.0853849277,
0.2174927592,
-0.9483836889,
-0.049768921,
0.1023673266,
-0.9262773991,
-0.1035254002,
-0.1348395199,
-1.0364304781,
0.7407320142,
-0.0391541757,
-0.3751431108,
-0.0396366864,
-0.7284585238,
0.4935689867,
0.0651344657,
0.2500882447,
0.065991804,
-0.6861823797,
-0.1193418503,
0.1696002483,
0.3148021102,
-0.0145885982,
-0.2109821737,
0.9603031278,
-0.2925933897,
0.5880375504,
0.0568059497,
0.0057056183,
0.418525368,
0.3808616102,
0.3723619282,
0.2515434623,
-0.2144862413,
0.4246835113,
0.2657388151,
-0.7783188224,
-0.4261461496,
0.6129877567,
-1.2455080748,
-0.5425872803,
-0.8236755133,
-0.6928660274,
-0.2725252807,
0.406164676,
0.2420900315,
0.2737694979,
-0.3993229568,
0.4806979895,
0.421515733,
0.0393925309,
0.1905725896,
0.6485095024,
-0.0821969584,
-0.5036173463,
0.7824037671,
0.469160378,
0.0695631579,
0.370797962,
-0.3701510727,
-0.5290116072,
-0.9652372599,
-0.4203893542,
0.147997871,
-0.7399235368,
-0.146448791,
-0.3471408188,
-0.4229321182,
-0.8748593926,
-0.3528617024,
-0.0397475548,
-0.6567600965,
-0.4307761192,
-0.2304636091,
0.4239122272,
0.7659729123,
-0.3494660556,
0.2473097295,
-1.0208500624,
0.4766146839,
0.0277757514,
-0.0594228394,
-0.5210778117,
-0.8569262624,
0.0793159828,
-0.0724476427,
-0.2481551617,
-1.4488742352,
0.3248425126,
0.3859061897,
0.3944812119,
0.7165466547,
-0.0354638137,
0.5839688778,
-0.273447752,
0.7614676952,
0.183733061,
-1.0151026249,
0.2691218853,
-0.384711653,
0.3769692481,
0.8175777197,
0.3653574586,
-0.6744728684,
-0.2228052765,
-0.63839221,
-0.9723774195,
0.6120505929,
0.5813868642,
0.3563737571,
-0.0902830437,
0.1674400717,
0.4501881301,
0.1636715531,
-0.2658437788,
-0.4688441157,
-0.2657488883,
-0.3802398145,
-0.0036073932,
-0.6917405725,
-0.2131841928,
-0.0586976334,
0.5502029657,
0.1390088052,
0.3496078551,
0.1868939996,
-0.6709282994,
-0.0035626884,
0.4018710554,
0.8003554344,
1.1168364286,
-0.696264863,
0.0222965032,
-0.1794864535,
-0.8044524789,
0.3238872886,
-0.1243803501,
-0.6635676026,
0.3617255986,
0.6047161222,
0.4053471088,
-0.5080224872,
-0.5347912908,
0.2923564315,
0.1970051825,
-0.2528720498,
-0.5772951245,
0.0624259748,
-0.1242113411,
-0.0198559556,
0.4742607474,
-0.0445940904,
0.4822604656,
-0.6123859882,
-0.1268128455,
0.1777571142,
-0.4837963283,
-0.3744936883,
0.0669551715,
0.513382256,
-0.4405380785,
0.7221217155,
0.2105963081,
-0.0487421155,
0.7832485437,
0.7270978093,
0.7115602493,
-0.0819820538,
0.1747624427,
0.2562648654,
0.6316006184,
0.5161368847,
1.2917159796,
0.2408289909,
-0.7361528277,
0.1742739081,
-0.4250500798,
-0.0913307443,
0.1398085654,
-1.0204234123,
0.1912706196,
-0.9816058278,
-0.2371682525,
-0.1107508913,
-0.4394648671,
-0.7804731727,
0.5347930193,
0.1430197656,
1.3513931036,
-0.9638553262,
1.0387448072,
1.0247347355,
-0.6830218434,
-0.8193740249,
-0.0848914385,
0.0206732675,
-1.0717275143,
0.7328855395,
0.1484102905,
-0.2488970309,
-0.0168701671,
-0.1931007206,
-1.0404690504,
1.0032367706,
0.3452207744,
-0.4301724434,
0.3475069106,
-0.0240505114,
0.4292558134,
-0.4200522602,
0.6746227145,
0.8268638253,
0.6055310369,
-0.1484218687,
-0.4968307614,
0.066314958,
-0.1881461143,
0.6625314951,
0.1743822992,
-0.4810415208,
0.9374619126,
0.0840130076,
-0.3081301749,
0.3786505461,
1.0567171574,
-0.0520654544,
-0.2300696671,
0.1371091157,
0.2391846329,
0.570792973,
-0.1287254393,
0.6960453987,
-0.4696262181,
-0.1792721301,
0.6618816257,
-0.2729673982,
0.460355252,
1.0493822098,
-0.1173556596,
1.0095851421,
0.8189683557,
0.4224476516,
0.6291954517,
0.0793073773,
-0.3485160768,
-0.0932778269,
-0.1236611903,
-0.8668052554,
0.4710951149,
0.3066793978,
-0.4434669316,
-0.3943994641,
-0.4004178047,
0.0315038003,
0.389321059,
-0.3369908631,
0.7215194106,
-0.0726027042,
-0.4647975266,
0.8601908684,
0.4665343761,
0.2195807546,
-0.6809232235,
-0.2456543595,
-0.4441545308,
-0.116414167,
-0.4163922369,
-0.2587035,
0.3728353679,
-0.073500067,
-0.3051095009,
0.0909346342,
0.1851140857,
-0.2684544921,
-0.3790375292,
0.16456981,
0.3907708526,
0.1653968245,
0.032282725,
-0.5118426085,
-0.0132200317,
0.3024595678,
0.0443105474,
0.199910149,
0.1753689498,
-0.4445230663,
0.1650609821,
0.579575479,
0.2677519023,
0.1671674997,
0.3195822835,
0.6538108587,
-0.7551926374,
-0.5093906522,
-0.637033999,
0.2493299097,
0.1834155768,
-0.4124338329,
0.7381269932,
0.4012783766,
0.7443634272,
-0.389783293,
0.8746632934,
-0.2857145071,
0.2446541637,
-0.7343153358,
0.7451949716,
-0.4343011975,
-0.1331099719,
0.1048124358,
-1.3763736486,
-0.6627218127,
1.0584121943,
-0.1628965288,
0.1250945181,
1.1226122379,
0.8238121867,
0.1139200553,
0.145734936,
0.353522867,
-0.0928204432,
0.1424930394,
0.5672118068,
0.3315246403,
-0.3774992228,
0.1656453162,
-0.0543020517,
-0.495819062,
-0.4725558758,
-0.7660934925,
-0.9239032865,
-0.1376249492,
-0.2007922828,
-0.4542494714,
0.3770801127,
1.4016103745,
0.3248438537,
-1.3720569611,
-0.6222397089,
-0.0079282904,
0.091025196,
-0.3485827744,
-0.1063019112,
0.3937197626,
-0.1471670866,
-0.7961547971,
0.2782859504,
0.4236322939,
0.3217396438,
-0.0560299344,
0.0242057461,
-0.5448029041,
0.3674589992,
-0.1270349324,
0.6006622314,
-0.4345609844,
-0.4137509465,
-0.3353343308,
-0.5594910979,
0.3303678632,
0.7384665012,
-0.2196426392,
0.7365431786,
0.9224722981,
0.4557584822,
0.2248660624,
-0.2594064474,
1.0157102346,
-0.6389122605,
0.686886847,
0.3270786405,
0.3844769299,
0.1372696459,
-0.1174076647,
0.3839629591,
0.1068713143,
-0.0285255723,
-0.4131320715,
0.4915179014,
-0.8412258029,
0.2086225897,
1.0829815865,
-0.4951460063,
-0.3278505802,
-0.4339511693,
-0.4260317981,
0.1179090962,
-0.9259438515,
0.9302431345,
0.7252583504,
0.1762692481,
-0.0210702028,
-0.1727986932,
0.7402456999,
0.3112000525,
-0.5439509749,
-0.8709818125,
0.3762243688,
0.1584543884,
0.1924943179,
0.8433257341,
-0.4554278851,
0.8024713397,
-0.338460207,
0.5310059786,
0.0694351345,
-0.3117868602,
-0.3754713237,
0.1846669614,
0.6906232238,
-0.43707937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12914v1
|
Large Language Model-based Human-Agent Collaboration for Complex Task Solving
| 2024-02-20T11:03:36 | 2024-02-20T11:03:36 |
Xueyang Feng, Zhi-Yuan Chen, Yujia Qin, Yankai Lin, Xu Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In recent developments within the research community, the integration of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in creating fully autonomous agents has garnered
significant interest. Despite this, LLM-based agents frequently demonstrate
notable shortcomings in adjusting to dynamic environments and fully grasping
human needs. In this work, we introduce the problem of LLM-based human-agent
collaboration for complex task-solving, exploring their synergistic potential.
In addition, we propose a Reinforcement Learning-based Human-Agent
Collaboration method, ReHAC. This approach includes a policy model designed to
determine the most opportune stages for human intervention within the
task-solving process. We construct a human-agent collaboration dataset to train
this policy model in an offline reinforcement learning environment. Our
validation tests confirm the model's effectiveness. The results demonstrate
that the synergistic efforts of humans and LLM-based agents significantly
improve performance in complex tasks, primarily through well-planned, limited
human intervention. Datasets and code are available at:
https://github.com/XueyangFeng/ReHAC.
|
[
-0.3925353885,
-0.9595355988,
0.7703819275,
0.1892024726,
0.1667778194,
0.6367896795,
-0.5290762186,
-0.7537838221,
0.3276516497,
0.338971734,
-0.7525875568,
-0.337616533,
-0.3938273191,
0.1210218892,
0.1925924867,
0.6652979255,
-0.3174655139,
0.0097129708,
-0.4727638066,
-0.0579311848,
-0.5303161144,
-0.5725001693,
-0.7179261446,
-0.7920042276,
0.7075412869,
0.6347250342,
0.7361570597,
0.3364252746,
0.5165376067,
0.4458938241,
0.0482620932,
0.4307629168,
-0.4526593387,
0.482963562,
-0.4327620864,
-0.4386194646,
-0.6363327503,
-0.1307284236,
0.4505906701,
0.7420463562,
-0.5591388941,
-0.2510955632,
0.0950895771,
0.2841275632,
-0.6002590656,
0.5217444301,
-0.2847097516,
-0.015211137,
0.0224717911,
0.0528786592,
-0.2162145972,
0.0845959038,
0.2713040113,
-0.7689168453,
0.0099679949,
0.1700172126,
0.3692955673,
0.4262061417,
-0.3757331967,
-0.0519635007,
-1.0596321821,
0.90125072,
-0.7100532055,
0.144553408,
0.503102839,
0.240173474,
-0.9257109761,
-0.4582642317,
-0.6660746932,
-0.4123743176,
0.2737539411,
0.0619350895,
0.0305786896,
0.3924386203,
0.2090017051,
-0.0650085881,
-0.3626546264,
0.3097914755,
-0.0346237682,
-0.0497173779,
0.6938111186,
0.4955682456,
0.3018963635,
0.1896613687,
-0.2442480773,
-0.0539484024,
-0.4246005714,
0.1777621955,
0.0644346699,
0.3869175613,
-0.1292671263,
0.4555049539,
-0.3372889757,
0.5702374578,
-0.1836247742,
-0.23303397,
0.1910110414,
-0.3271751404,
-0.0458675213,
-0.2494211942,
0.5361242294,
-0.0356974155,
0.1162095219,
-0.3421228826,
-0.4932389855,
-0.0369285978,
0.3901739717,
-0.3410238624,
0.0759013891,
0.2276449353,
-0.2147966772,
-0.2973799109,
0.0205021817,
-0.2297035009,
-0.381195128,
-0.4744926691,
0.5272028446,
0.1100592166,
-0.3775992692,
-0.0432637073,
0.15286538,
0.0999938771,
0.4960485101,
-0.5696157217,
0.4181397557,
0.7561285496,
0.5857397914,
-0.1773477942,
-0.8705959916,
-0.8046395779,
0.2273984104,
-0.2405352443,
0.6997715235,
-0.4161682427,
-0.276150018,
0.1089791432,
0.1871661842,
0.0608712621,
-0.6528429389,
0.4305615723,
-0.3643867075,
-0.1317533851,
-0.3064798415,
-0.4302410781,
-0.0041517755,
0.5551150441,
-0.9432677031,
0.7920734882,
0.13157776,
-0.4611452222,
-0.0227205716,
-0.8287279606,
-0.5974517465,
0.0829560757,
-0.1937213689,
-0.614934504,
-0.2869610488,
-0.1297176629,
0.3690867722,
-0.669393301,
0.5108231306,
-0.4380503297,
-0.3340520263,
0.382214874,
0.02928859,
0.3607638776,
0.1233891174,
-0.4361491203,
0.5739330649,
-0.2967841923,
0.0599784069,
0.3062371612,
-0.4891017079,
-0.0092445211,
0.0479622856,
0.0908502415,
0.4414928854,
0.544447124,
-0.5057166219,
0.1788670868,
-0.2128681242,
0.4141536653,
0.5032042265,
-0.1177319512,
0.4154408276,
-0.6787545681,
0.7814143896,
-0.3235998154,
0.0875681266,
0.2736130655,
-0.3640913069,
-0.4096133411,
-0.1957594752,
0.1386186332,
0.5367315412,
-1.120577693,
0.4679779708,
-0.0218761936,
-0.3660437763,
-0.1129473671,
0.1249569729,
0.6796917319,
0.1275330782,
0.1783927232,
-0.3474515975,
-0.5117464066,
-0.7346300483,
-0.1300615519,
-0.1880683154,
0.0978868976,
0.3696374297,
0.5938993692,
-0.3571923673,
1.0227502584,
-0.4941773117,
-0.4957155883,
-0.6005602479,
0.4181243181,
-0.2192713171,
0.4414583147,
-0.0217412356,
-0.7978744507,
-0.5728864074,
-0.0997184739,
-0.7130815983,
-0.0675181299,
0.1127090305,
-0.102735281,
0.3696740866,
0.4979600608,
-0.590395391,
0.3505114913,
0.6379584074,
-0.2339844853,
0.6496592164,
-0.6399511695,
0.0369288288,
-0.9841111302,
0.200623408,
0.0007354309,
-0.5179590583,
-0.7786905766,
-0.0403528288,
-0.4226569533,
-0.2480193079,
-0.4660042226,
0.4467994869,
-0.5061703324,
-0.1211984605,
-0.6028363705,
0.210508436,
-0.2972732782,
0.8862224817,
0.2425457984,
0.4022179544,
0.2846980095,
-0.0455578379,
0.6564705968,
0.1788787246,
-0.0874323696,
0.4784829915,
-0.6769962907,
0.2617351413,
0.2312460691,
0.522564292,
-0.4875372052,
-0.4204527438,
0.2601995766,
-0.0780454129,
0.1524043232,
0.2029037029,
-0.8582090735,
-0.1659628004,
-0.219658941,
0.6533435583,
0.0913616046,
-0.2795897424,
0.864634335,
0.662428081,
-0.1358873695,
-0.4238162637,
-0.4340242147,
0.2760885954,
0.1500815004,
-0.7137795091,
0.6905103922,
0.0344312713,
-0.2799891829,
0.0587781668,
0.0263879132,
-0.2797903717,
0.0581320748,
0.4772786498,
0.3339605033,
0.3666406572,
-0.0436306186,
-0.3079551756,
-0.1850086153,
0.0729072541,
-0.0385067053,
0.4289577603,
-0.1859797835,
-0.4221766293,
-0.3214081526,
0.5071058869,
0.6347900033,
-0.3786735535,
0.9210931659,
0.4369407296,
-0.490807265,
-0.2920237482,
-0.4796076417,
-0.2569228709,
-0.4336761236,
0.5670230389,
-0.1966362894,
-1.0277479887,
0.5863574743,
-0.3782744706,
0.0095960591,
-0.2351763397,
0.7568206191,
-0.1735217273,
0.8559682369,
0.7802333832,
-0.1541535854,
0.590175271,
-0.2285794765,
0.1436929107,
-0.5229077935,
-0.4984731376,
-0.2518338561,
-0.2998798788,
-0.4245850146,
-0.6830870509,
0.4466584921,
-0.2293203771,
-0.1909179986,
0.3312412202,
-0.1709939688,
0.3442771137,
0.5308701396,
0.1468214989,
0.3235181272,
-0.3055288494,
0.1587028503,
0.1971151084,
-0.7741208673,
-0.1720801294,
0.7364124656,
0.3226084411,
0.7578929663,
0.2348957658,
0.6553602815,
0.4011470079,
-0.0457800478,
-0.5651569366,
0.6693783998,
0.1441129297,
-0.429338783,
-0.6907850504,
-0.5221219659,
-1.4029581547,
0.160449326,
-0.6142657399,
-0.463362813,
-0.0693907216,
0.0706263557,
-0.2504214644,
0.262729764,
-0.4047099054,
0.9525542855,
-0.3091213107,
-0.4604995847,
-0.8071320057,
-0.7516948581,
-0.078016825,
-0.093285054,
0.2012608945,
-0.0811748952,
-0.108038947,
0.7938129306,
-0.5323398709,
0.9475281239,
-0.1473148614,
-0.2734438181,
0.2804195285,
0.0445226282,
1.1029579639,
-0.3611623347,
0.272975415,
-0.0724287406,
-0.4264732003,
-0.5318356156,
-0.6255091429,
0.6716387868,
-0.8348464966,
-0.5641297102,
-0.3280502856,
-0.9340676069,
-0.420712918,
0.1561193764,
-0.3092645705,
0.3091000617,
-0.4318728447,
0.0889407918,
0.3066041172,
-0.0100325281,
0.2901640534,
0.6216927767,
-0.2131123096,
-0.2306640297,
0.9236000776,
0.048901327,
0.3572778702,
0.3408186734,
0.0180311166,
-0.1124034598,
-0.3703201711,
0.0482401997,
0.2494190186,
-0.5260365605,
0.0434495062,
-0.2599087656,
-0.0854199901,
-0.0736771822,
-0.2629874647,
-0.3515342176,
-0.0215539504,
-0.136382401,
0.3846077025,
0.0195394214,
0.8861960173,
-0.0422277525,
0.0076478352,
-0.7117576003,
0.2441393435,
0.3695170581,
0.1638185829,
0.2215964496,
-0.0748261511,
-0.67313236,
0.108351633,
-0.2940839231,
-0.6329096556,
0.311935097,
-0.1704410017,
0.7174691558,
-0.0437864251,
0.2530131638,
0.2503205538,
-0.1174394637,
0.3354737461,
0.1215688959,
-0.8008975387,
0.1580663621,
-0.5148565769,
0.226917237,
0.2534371018,
0.1225781739,
-0.5557678342,
-0.5528124571,
-0.4861740172,
-0.865801096,
0.9130033851,
0.4173411727,
-0.755107522,
0.4296107292,
0.0325192399,
-0.2885001898,
0.195000425,
-0.3671384752,
-0.1094972789,
0.286896646,
-0.0741078332,
-0.0514186807,
0.0513425656,
-0.173358649,
0.0440934487,
0.5216175914,
-0.0998326093,
0.0888176709,
0.0807775706,
-0.1787798405,
-0.404743135,
0.2922186553,
0.6048289537,
0.5406315923,
0.0631302968,
0.0342253782,
0.3977887928,
-0.1697750837,
0.3388223648,
0.1018866822,
0.3405051529,
-0.5890001655,
0.5780692697,
0.4706659913,
0.4315881133,
-1.1085829735,
0.4022603333,
-0.0493777916,
-0.273039639,
-0.489484787,
0.1555555016,
0.389010787,
0.755710721,
0.2715731263,
-0.0673229992,
-0.1923105121,
-0.6206018925,
-0.0220225025,
0.5207155943,
-0.1148547828,
-0.2615860403,
0.3232705295,
0.6286103129,
-0.7204995751,
0.6022948623,
-0.4688979387,
-0.8552322388,
0.9037311077,
0.4307816923,
0.7831869721,
-0.0587181002,
0.2028236985,
-0.0507906675,
-0.0241062399,
-0.2786598206,
0.3079322577,
-0.1406542361,
-0.7086416483,
-0.7966311574,
-0.0306096431,
-0.8038676977,
-0.1572207958,
-0.3103501499,
0.0877807587,
-0.1818171442,
-0.2323057353,
-0.2789294124,
0.4662084281,
-0.5295952559,
-0.1328956336,
0.1673479974,
0.2623301148,
-0.8179651499,
1.1133817434,
0.9284626842,
-0.3264389038,
-0.9593344331,
0.1491467655,
0.0280878358,
-0.3256693184,
0.7070052028,
-0.1652517915,
-0.4047438204,
-0.014689656,
-0.4375246167,
-0.7178693414,
1.3070465326,
0.3736186028,
-0.6772987247,
-0.1762278825,
0.3499616086,
0.6796176434,
-0.4455839396,
-0.0114791961,
0.3753538132,
0.5689573884,
0.0343514159,
-1.4198505878,
0.3001199365,
-0.0940963104,
-0.0380288139,
0.3373153806,
-0.7180510163,
0.7831823826,
-0.3388494849,
-0.0533926822,
0.0449906737,
0.6886503696,
0.3975120485,
0.2700594962,
0.971241653,
0.433163017,
0.6601920724,
0.3321025968,
0.6333829165,
-0.145393908,
0.558837235,
1.0942492485,
-0.5808570981,
0.784219563,
0.4813923538,
-0.223096773,
0.4903331101,
0.2411909401,
0.1048545688,
0.3246994019,
0.2783432007,
-0.5065813065,
-0.6159906387,
-0.4998642504,
0.1674874127,
0.3076351285,
0.000330089,
0.2577350736,
-0.235540852,
0.1966571808,
-0.049062632,
0.1670970619,
-0.2182981968,
0.8075284362,
0.1685737073,
-0.9772631526,
0.3142314851,
0.1445809007,
0.6647182107,
-0.3701863885,
-0.2568297684,
0.3695062101,
0.3117877245,
-0.3048990667,
-0.8381483555,
0.1456295997,
-0.2984077632,
-0.3852163851,
0.0876749679,
0.751309216,
-0.8842922449,
0.0679582432,
0.6475126147,
0.6997304559,
-0.0454073548,
-0.1710041612,
-0.721162796,
0.047480043,
-0.1281774789,
0.0078132665,
0.6575687528,
0.1716406941,
-0.3454533219,
1.012542963,
0.7425279617,
0.0662236661,
-0.4364234209,
-0.0290629268,
0.7870032191,
-0.6549024582,
-0.5558927059,
-0.5079773664,
0.2158621997,
0.1201351732,
0.2161301225,
0.3404525816,
0.1974867135,
0.6969692111,
0.1068165153,
0.7556520104,
-0.1166651621,
0.3412526548,
-0.1206005141,
0.5032795668,
-0.5374270678,
0.1577742398,
-0.1028945148,
-0.789198935,
-0.1041613817,
0.4483450055,
-0.1842398942,
0.139687255,
0.7201454043,
0.8970280886,
0.212423861,
-0.1902784705,
0.4407143295,
0.1010281593,
0.5797008872,
0.8574055433,
0.8854368925,
0.2374141514,
0.6616728902,
-0.3767409027,
-0.2378033847,
-0.4551837146,
-0.7138594389,
-0.9269661307,
-0.8313550949,
-0.210757941,
-0.3931986392,
0.1959816515,
1.6068812609,
0.5860869884,
-0.3601414859,
-0.4625202119,
-0.194143638,
0.1476482749,
-0.2787481844,
-0.120287776,
0.1715514958,
-0.183449015,
-0.6473816037,
0.4827547371,
0.0457488857,
-0.1164965779,
-0.7128295898,
-0.6388424635,
-0.2999365032,
-0.0665493459,
0.3821318448,
0.5779467821,
-0.7821286321,
-0.0582939275,
-0.1025526971,
-0.2973537147,
-0.0951891467,
1.1654449701,
-0.6440372467,
0.2497059405,
0.5208166242,
0.6595993042,
0.4668531418,
0.0946682394,
0.7905595303,
-0.551486969,
0.111371018,
0.3097386062,
0.3683561683,
0.1866213381,
-0.2158973068,
0.3878271878,
0.1805728972,
-1.0022078753,
-0.7066017985,
0.1554989815,
-0.9652706385,
-0.3754433393,
0.9320503473,
-0.3902402222,
-0.3172599673,
-0.6254681945,
-0.2854279876,
0.4784800708,
-0.6566713452,
0.8344926238,
0.4661046863,
-0.1869306564,
0.1348811537,
-0.2298337668,
0.2759042084,
0.640039444,
-1.0877040625,
0.1991017461,
0.2549715936,
0.0022927199,
0.1682842076,
0.587110579,
0.4824438095,
0.4050186872,
-0.1453202665,
0.5153011084,
-0.4183380008,
-0.5559969544,
-0.1414585561,
-0.0434139222,
0.3749333322,
-0.0241036527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12913v1
|
OPDAI at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Small LLMs can Accelerate Hallucination Detection with Weakly Supervised Data
| 2024-02-20T11:01:39 | 2024-02-20T11:01:39 |
Chengcheng Wei, Ze Chen, Songtan Fang, Jiarong He, Max Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper mainly describes a unified system for hallucination detection of
LLMs, which wins the second prize in the model-agnostic track of the
SemEval-2024 Task 6, and also achieves considerable results in the model-aware
track. This task aims to detect hallucination with LLMs for three different
text-generation tasks without labeled training data. We utilize prompt
engineering and few-shot learning to verify the performance of different LLMs
on the validation data. Then we select the LLMs with better performance to
generate high-quality weakly supervised training data, which not only satisfies
the consistency of different LLMs, but also satisfies the consistency of the
optimal LLM with different sampling parameters. Furthermore, we finetune
different LLMs by using the constructed training data, and finding that a
relatively small LLM can achieve a competitive level of performance in
hallucination detection, when compared to the large LLMs and the prompt-based
approaches using GPT-4.
|
[
-0.4909701049,
-0.850410521,
0.9968397617,
0.0127805313,
-0.4180600047,
-0.502327919,
-0.212652564,
-0.4900756776,
0.3337196112,
0.4114823043,
-0.6423402429,
-0.7335413098,
-0.5124946833,
0.6166298389,
-0.2313632071,
0.6409115791,
0.0107788593,
0.168207109,
-0.3985747099,
-0.0110833868,
-0.4184569716,
-0.3209741712,
-0.4846378267,
-0.4488573968,
0.492595017,
0.5709240437,
0.2680415809,
0.3970932961,
0.4633550644,
0.2769748569,
-0.1501540244,
0.4991735518,
-0.3184985518,
0.098236613,
0.0750946179,
-0.3404567242,
-0.6420112848,
-0.187929064,
0.3289421499,
0.5511866808,
0.211859867,
0.0293111131,
0.323169142,
0.2720356286,
-0.5141640306,
-0.0770787001,
-0.7235040665,
0.3154545128,
-0.2678192854,
-0.3707362413,
-0.5351433754,
-0.245558396,
-0.3245870173,
-0.161390692,
0.3969524801,
0.2059056461,
0.695009768,
0.7240190506,
-0.1950406581,
-0.3713209033,
-0.2874919176,
0.7442519069,
-0.7129685283,
0.2482461184,
0.4267386496,
-0.0002891442,
-0.2688436806,
-0.6565471292,
-0.4542498291,
0.0060693198,
-0.1807868183,
0.0402570628,
0.0708451197,
0.1003777012,
0.4023824036,
0.2402438223,
-0.626681149,
0.4988689721,
-0.3489907384,
-0.4528187811,
0.4296729565,
0.3477323353,
0.0262535419,
-0.4216216803,
-0.2967745662,
0.2793313861,
-0.7155147195,
-0.3206509054,
0.3422691822,
0.4390116632,
-0.0544324555,
0.6250128746,
-0.2617981136,
0.3969379961,
-0.0536605641,
-0.1883101463,
0.5174896717,
-0.4064131379,
-0.1786055565,
0.2361637801,
0.8822804093,
-0.061741244,
-0.2089003921,
-0.1784257293,
-0.4687930346,
0.324334234,
0.0914717317,
-0.8934912682,
-0.251794368,
0.0706973895,
-0.6624075174,
-0.5416510105,
-0.1631617844,
-0.8269344568,
-0.5837908387,
-0.4837362468,
0.7434610128,
-0.2106648535,
0.0463220999,
0.057688199,
0.168803677,
0.2870501876,
0.4797764719,
-0.9054666162,
0.2359020114,
0.5106899142,
0.8560194969,
-0.6809283495,
-0.335047394,
-0.9769948125,
-0.2331157625,
-0.2780503333,
1.0031335354,
-0.1632560939,
-0.2485622168,
-0.1635894775,
0.2322308123,
0.1124990284,
-0.701559186,
0.9792052507,
0.0806990489,
0.0506092086,
-0.3150315583,
-0.4718686044,
-0.0386802182,
0.1024254039,
-0.5039849877,
1.0216072798,
-0.2186638415,
-0.5980857015,
0.3570743799,
-0.1716122776,
-0.4274379909,
0.1222884655,
-0.7092766166,
-0.7668474913,
0.3583958447,
0.3410178721,
0.7356485128,
-0.1968415231,
0.1413522214,
-0.2947084606,
-0.8532981277,
-0.0745483041,
-0.4415852726,
0.3336462975,
0.0518724248,
-0.732245028,
0.1428061426,
-0.8601255417,
-0.2163131535,
0.0890746936,
-0.1103410944,
-0.0370963812,
-0.0664587021,
-0.2144646347,
0.067227222,
0.3236171007,
-0.3873408735,
0.3026358485,
-0.3249251544,
0.0517390035,
0.8555721641,
0.1225135773,
0.4410100579,
-0.2315465063,
0.3581216633,
0.0812113956,
-0.0204994306,
0.0386764333,
-0.6091175079,
-1.0348601341,
-0.313996017,
0.1685818881,
0.2056457251,
-0.7274551392,
0.5618059039,
0.0886663571,
-0.1493955553,
-0.3766264021,
0.3430484235,
0.1116717234,
0.5300672054,
0.5044237971,
0.0772193223,
-0.7506340146,
-0.9027258754,
-0.0220205337,
0.0086694136,
-0.015091287,
0.2147975266,
0.7728092074,
-0.5580545068,
0.4462726116,
-0.3775143027,
-0.823105514,
-0.1175795346,
0.4674112797,
0.3468932807,
0.2729392648,
0.2878945768,
-0.4828155041,
-0.073348999,
-0.179227218,
-1.1572363377,
-0.451803416,
0.0638238192,
0.0671352968,
0.516143918,
0.7431587577,
-0.2148452252,
0.5172160268,
0.2437116355,
-0.1589488536,
0.3154671192,
-0.107296668,
0.165934369,
-0.854752779,
-0.3774065077,
-0.3563623726,
-0.2899712622,
-0.4833395183,
-0.4420167208,
-0.0216410924,
0.1345227808,
-0.5103793144,
0.2766126096,
-0.5464470387,
-0.306386441,
-0.5755848885,
0.1821808964,
-0.3882172406,
0.5595273376,
0.2986736894,
0.4651650488,
0.5419803858,
-0.5413318872,
0.09814284,
0.1490252167,
-0.1716972739,
0.390897572,
-0.5217263699,
0.3990240395,
-0.0851442218,
-0.2094411105,
-0.964130044,
-0.5108733773,
0.2862914503,
-0.4575558305,
-0.0051027723,
0.1823456734,
-0.6494097114,
-0.2861301005,
-0.4314019382,
0.2178783268,
0.6925569773,
-0.8877685666,
0.514528513,
0.0856703073,
0.0224326532,
-0.1868002862,
-0.7270355821,
-0.1766403466,
-0.3311947584,
-0.5959788561,
0.2557337284,
-0.0340160504,
-0.0367485471,
-0.1802153587,
-0.1391957104,
0.3392447531,
0.1343790442,
0.4801965654,
0.1035305336,
-0.1631434411,
0.2256260365,
0.1837193072,
-0.2812951207,
0.0736118183,
-0.0043885666,
0.4650522768,
-0.3383284211,
-0.5503792763,
-0.524056673,
0.017736908,
0.1257843226,
0.4956319034,
0.3871447444,
0.8028900623,
-0.7756729722,
-0.5248746276,
-0.4235077202,
-0.6646999717,
-0.4564037919,
0.0090581095,
-0.5781234503,
-0.9374078512,
0.3931764364,
-0.1489224434,
-0.3420577347,
0.4361376464,
0.7313754559,
-0.0398172252,
1.2003442049,
0.3858786523,
0.039682135,
-0.1472954303,
-0.0363999829,
0.1049583182,
-0.6432753801,
-0.3032684326,
-0.5448254347,
-0.4577454925,
-0.4656592906,
-0.3148800135,
0.44898808,
0.0845000744,
0.0166999064,
0.1367758214,
-0.8320019245,
0.3314525783,
0.3493134081,
0.1728466749,
0.5274294615,
-0.0011488339,
-0.1364350468,
-0.2929957509,
-0.4571779966,
-0.6662698388,
0.9176854491,
0.1987858266,
0.9616391659,
-0.038279999,
1.1816806793,
0.4183945954,
-0.0290322918,
-0.8453059196,
0.811801672,
0.027115766,
-0.091497004,
-0.3629012108,
-0.2602053583,
-0.7961614132,
0.3128847778,
-0.1087140292,
-0.818544805,
0.2560988665,
-0.0569687299,
-0.3388923705,
-0.003005004,
-0.3756640255,
0.6930718422,
-0.2091940045,
-0.5026965141,
0.243959263,
-0.3872791529,
0.5733202696,
-0.2629660666,
-0.006784779,
-0.1247080937,
-0.1637723446,
0.7632986903,
-0.5113039613,
0.8206962347,
-0.1976932734,
-0.1510645002,
0.2187592238,
-0.2385042161,
0.7885408401,
0.234243229,
0.0874173269,
-0.0411072001,
-0.4454493523,
-0.0250022467,
-0.2971068025,
0.8644077182,
-0.5300170779,
-0.4864179194,
-0.532546699,
-0.1881991476,
-0.1365127712,
0.1684024334,
0.8276910782,
0.1258316487,
0.0288183931,
0.3818334937,
0.826356709,
-0.0077251154,
0.3675188124,
0.0626598522,
-0.2182628661,
-0.2404650301,
0.9469402432,
-0.0464346856,
-0.1860619932,
0.125365451,
0.1277658641,
-0.3619679511,
-0.9376779795,
-0.1556629688,
0.3235664666,
-0.8030110002,
-0.3783055246,
-0.8105025291,
-0.2467004806,
-0.4201891124,
-0.2558996677,
-0.4118468165,
-0.0535836332,
-0.7340481877,
-0.0893809423,
0.178335622,
0.681737721,
-0.1444275826,
0.1801868677,
-0.3444005549,
0.6968780756,
0.3448835909,
-0.1561566442,
-0.4142524004,
-0.6926343441,
0.0578880571,
-0.2426629215,
-0.3324858844,
-0.5448513627,
0.3837759197,
-0.027739834,
0.5502557755,
0.5202253461,
0.1323260367,
0.6385704875,
-0.3381857872,
0.8125104308,
0.1447514594,
-0.8211912513,
0.8503174782,
-0.1819213927,
0.1958460957,
0.8281561732,
0.2020440102,
0.1828624606,
-0.4520394802,
-0.6319810152,
-0.560085535,
0.8036922216,
0.4055478275,
-0.2322814614,
0.1029822305,
0.2637698352,
0.3942572474,
0.1401736438,
-0.9140154123,
-0.106131494,
0.1533543169,
-0.3129285872,
0.1213278398,
-0.3345631063,
0.1423662752,
-0.1571833044,
0.8023281693,
-0.4299410582,
0.4441711307,
0.2125130296,
-0.2106366605,
-0.0162626188,
0.1835595965,
0.688414216,
0.2284141481,
-0.3063947558,
0.428209722,
0.5393516421,
-0.3747443855,
0.321579963,
-0.0756774843,
-0.3973036706,
0.2748714089,
0.4161237776,
0.8544306755,
0.2733297944,
-0.385889411,
0.648874104,
-0.1059086099,
-0.5678474903,
-0.4459783137,
0.2267354578,
-0.0136692151,
0.3925574124,
0.2215827703,
-0.0000106407,
0.3773995042,
-0.2559812665,
0.2751049399,
0.260057956,
-0.3075467944,
-0.4507644773,
0.9203704596,
0.0431414656,
-0.1948050261,
0.2641446888,
-0.6108182073,
-0.3031673133,
0.460257262,
0.4050966203,
0.9428380132,
-0.0374713689,
-0.0306472126,
0.3741430938,
0.3381487429,
-0.3425124586,
0.6682334542,
-0.1728791595,
-0.6250828505,
-0.0135574704,
-0.7302646637,
-0.2374763489,
0.6764754653,
-0.4672793746,
0.8668800592,
-0.1790349185,
-0.069706127,
-0.0913227424,
-0.0793313757,
-0.6926733851,
0.0526972488,
0.2520392835,
0.3923097551,
-0.8274633884,
0.6444134712,
0.4744426012,
-0.2611497939,
-0.5640422106,
-0.0001095316,
0.3694250882,
-0.5162855983,
0.7092077732,
0.4044714272,
-0.3610084951,
-0.0239361972,
-0.611092329,
-0.3042005897,
1.3541859388,
0.1791561693,
-0.5644395351,
-0.1678313911,
0.0685442537,
0.3525024951,
-0.3478814363,
-0.0303620193,
0.5858912468,
0.4018328488,
0.2227668762,
-0.5339214206,
0.0459504165,
0.0362594612,
-0.1267444044,
0.0778034702,
-0.4693598151,
0.6803027391,
-0.0747741684,
-0.1745617092,
0.5366891026,
0.9202128649,
0.6309040189,
0.6370149255,
0.4227075279,
0.6827452183,
0.9160664678,
-0.3367352784,
0.6088173985,
0.1371686012,
0.2960336208,
1.1829481125,
-0.3455170393,
0.6693145633,
0.6488774419,
0.0564971417,
-0.0174886491,
0.7851573229,
-0.100127086,
0.6362977624,
0.1308225393,
-0.2421244979,
-0.4298696518,
-0.2264204323,
-0.4668841362,
0.5490751863,
0.2624262571,
-0.387784183,
-0.1718748063,
0.499007225,
-0.1970419139,
-0.0759383962,
-0.3407625854,
0.7835923433,
0.3827785254,
-0.5929095149,
0.7159321904,
-0.2229058594,
1.0737379789,
-0.1775507778,
-0.0097989421,
-0.3845719099,
0.2593849599,
-0.3489831388,
-0.2726204395,
0.0784496367,
0.0824663043,
0.0242222995,
-0.1673841327,
1.2580703497,
-0.1981229633,
-0.400000602,
0.3453359604,
0.6511377692,
0.6075314879,
-0.0209519509,
-0.1089657992,
0.3001027107,
-0.032056503,
-0.2149518281,
0.2365153432,
0.7023202777,
0.0503533371,
0.205444172,
0.2294819355,
0.1282657087,
-0.0092655523,
0.3987355828,
0.5708153844,
-0.5998196602,
-0.2475617975,
-0.892957449,
0.1180816293,
-0.0804766938,
-0.2256518006,
0.9170113206,
0.6121146679,
0.7141079307,
-0.252832979,
0.631726563,
0.2257527262,
0.4711201191,
-0.9195108414,
0.4510537982,
-0.7617256641,
0.4174610972,
-0.3287145793,
-0.977232933,
-0.1850995272,
0.7215248346,
-0.1960563958,
0.0221643653,
0.8926885128,
0.96075809,
-0.0115821296,
0.2909859121,
0.6251738071,
0.1896762848,
0.0047521363,
0.6367581487,
1.1432622671,
-0.5567466617,
0.4186028838,
-0.1878432333,
0.0274951495,
-0.4043205678,
-0.7941303849,
-1.1804969311,
-0.5449912548,
-0.4014675319,
-0.0951595232,
-0.2130398303,
0.6884083748,
0.5375037193,
-0.8567042351,
0.1319412291,
-0.4854873121,
0.1748871356,
0.0437592007,
-0.2388270497,
0.3833845854,
-0.6429280043,
-0.955586791,
0.6987860799,
0.4335512817,
0.2691643834,
-0.1363392472,
-0.3102060258,
0.0012602168,
-0.2572721839,
0.5620808601,
-0.1586543173,
-0.7282420397,
-0.3581239581,
0.0347503386,
-0.2326338738,
0.0506856926,
0.5590843558,
-0.729272306,
0.1063020676,
0.7644213438,
0.7162939906,
0.5364609957,
-0.1348722279,
-0.0300101079,
-0.6757667661,
0.2835403681,
0.4391967654,
0.5606197715,
0.1334866583,
-0.5279276371,
0.908306241,
0.5171391964,
-0.8509569764,
-1.054944396,
-0.1074083075,
-0.9650487304,
-0.2643547356,
1.2602660656,
0.361795783,
-0.2281770855,
-0.1133102328,
-0.2025466561,
0.0155849792,
-0.2450786531,
0.6397404075,
0.7613089681,
-0.6005805731,
-0.2303166837,
-0.6379398704,
0.7485896945,
0.5563336611,
-1.1859738827,
-0.4800013602,
0.6232933402,
-0.1899566054,
0.2167390585,
0.8153349757,
-0.0213014763,
0.3633464575,
0.0029381523,
-0.0981410146,
-0.0460568219,
-0.5885193944,
-0.5189865828,
0.2294193953,
0.0280360803,
-0.306342423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12890v1
|
More Discriminative Sentence Embeddings via Semantic Graph Smoothing
| 2024-02-20T10:34:19 | 2024-02-20T10:34:19 |
Chakib Fettal, Lazhar Labiod, Mohamed Nadif
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper explores an empirical approach to learn more discriminantive
sentence representations in an unsupervised fashion. Leveraging semantic graph
smoothing, we enhance sentence embeddings obtained from pretrained models to
improve results for the text clustering and classification tasks. Our method,
validated on eight benchmarks, demonstrates consistent improvements, showcasing
the potential of semantic graph smoothing in improving sentence embeddings for
the supervised and unsupervised document categorization tasks.
|
[
-0.2679600418,
-0.9898727536,
0.8934005499,
-0.0701434836,
-0.3955770433,
0.2214870453,
-0.3790813386,
-0.2482596934,
0.2868367434,
0.6860954165,
-0.4696169794,
-1.1259888411,
-0.9657624364,
-0.0270181559,
-0.5817923546,
0.8047358394,
-0.0289894994,
0.0937117562,
-0.5517847538,
0.0678060502,
-0.4953808486,
-0.4782178104,
-0.3345235586,
-0.4672698081,
0.4003891647,
0.3650337756,
0.5893915296,
0.5328239202,
0.3445230424,
0.3108698726,
0.1903731078,
0.3778896928,
-0.5988304019,
0.0675758049,
0.2646258175,
-0.4893791378,
-0.1318403929,
0.2351865917,
0.5643216968,
1.0811578035,
-0.2678351402,
-0.2111416757,
0.0157847572,
0.4147375226,
-0.3630744815,
0.4972731173,
-0.5262729526,
0.1026050225,
-0.2595399618,
-0.2466286123,
-0.7201642394,
-0.471875608,
0.0410037413,
-0.950232625,
0.4511051476,
0.2314026207,
0.7973819375,
0.2625727952,
-0.9205389619,
0.038039159,
-0.4671297967,
0.5572109818,
-0.5503247976,
0.5598199964,
0.4049580693,
-0.0199424643,
-0.5129812956,
-1.2176014185,
-0.3170695901,
-0.1907928735,
-0.1273210496,
0.1851558089,
-0.1098751798,
0.2694943249,
0.1705061197,
0.1742326617,
-0.4692608714,
0.5219701529,
-0.0619141236,
-0.2251567841,
0.640589118,
-0.020361403,
0.3127358854,
-0.0159773976,
-0.1712331325,
-0.4857203364,
-0.3129180968,
0.0058645708,
0.5478774905,
0.3877080679,
0.2658975422,
0.5999678373,
-0.3007537723,
0.7532761693,
-0.0791697279,
0.1218797714,
0.7664021254,
-0.0184922051,
0.0379768722,
0.3230844438,
0.5071062446,
0.6483584642,
0.4240235984,
-0.3510748744,
0.1001702845,
0.6421122551,
0.3737462759,
-0.7626473904,
-0.446669668,
0.0193239432,
-0.5719386339,
-0.0389150158,
0.4276157916,
-0.8355981708,
-0.3141904473,
-0.1956058443,
-0.1485981345,
-0.508487463,
0.0085579269,
0.447732538,
-0.6639685035,
-0.2506768703,
0.3013226688,
-0.6625442505,
0.4066514075,
0.803309381,
0.6186656356,
0.0031396449,
-0.2127106488,
-0.4980207682,
0.124649711,
-0.4173370302,
1.1283802986,
-0.9465720057,
-0.460459739,
0.3419544697,
0.2267241776,
-0.2722633481,
-0.1732771546,
0.8900747895,
-0.3542404175,
0.2292573899,
-0.06951534,
-1.0145839453,
-0.4569758773,
0.1055960655,
-0.4994656444,
1.2952473164,
0.2649923563,
-0.7898272872,
0.860624969,
-0.4696852565,
-0.5308821201,
0.004280326,
-0.0554364063,
-0.5418152213,
0.1744085848,
0.4991530478,
0.6801280379,
0.2466530353,
0.3420256674,
-0.5735810995,
-0.3748121262,
0.0416427776,
-0.2014255673,
0.4235579073,
-0.0180503484,
-0.0400790684,
0.3109521568,
-0.8251413703,
0.031223176,
-0.0212986339,
0.0233455282,
-0.7549221516,
-0.0386700258,
0.2682368159,
0.0013121952,
-0.0605047867,
-0.9603537321,
0.0455735587,
-0.5847328305,
0.4099275768,
0.6110659838,
0.1425953507,
0.5132154226,
-0.0617875829,
0.2644320428,
0.1656199098,
-0.1813566089,
-0.0588143095,
-0.6377326846,
-0.6494473219,
-0.2618051469,
0.409934938,
0.3312556744,
-0.6436753273,
0.7159520984,
-0.3642897308,
-0.3676990569,
-0.6125907302,
0.1604089737,
0.3271042705,
0.306933701,
0.3680119812,
-0.4383310378,
-0.3992862105,
-0.5649564266,
-0.1906960458,
0.1058184505,
0.0300816782,
-0.0714650452,
0.4407261014,
-0.1809069216,
0.807533145,
-0.9955214262,
-0.4885474145,
-0.1552497596,
0.4297516346,
-0.192950055,
0.3973371685,
0.4356189966,
-0.7076281905,
-0.4405289292,
-0.0210568756,
-0.5648002625,
0.0845253244,
0.2214740366,
-0.1792212129,
0.1217137799,
1.003890276,
-0.6283974648,
0.682608664,
0.1294315904,
-0.6305106878,
-0.0919332281,
-0.6682575941,
-0.001516223,
-0.8557153344,
-0.4143396318,
0.1230854318,
-0.7566479445,
-0.4085382223,
0.030626433,
-0.0801413953,
-0.0606224872,
-0.1604690999,
0.0864545405,
-0.659318924,
-0.156540364,
-0.2569493353,
0.7289166451,
0.1583260596,
0.4288190007,
-0.0267552268,
0.3079889417,
0.5041249394,
-0.3770749867,
0.1915524155,
0.5694372058,
-0.3994343281,
0.2748470306,
-0.6123587489,
0.0456986725,
-0.5407419801,
0.6510449052,
-1.0844391584,
0.0723604262,
-0.1903782487,
-0.2438065112,
0.2819488645,
0.2015592605,
-0.805126965,
-0.601180613,
-0.3728376627,
-0.2072259933,
0.6645470858,
-0.5273281336,
0.3610047996,
0.4637057185,
0.1146635339,
-0.0795054212,
-0.5520896316,
-0.1230560169,
-0.327203542,
-0.495875597,
0.6764963865,
0.4263948202,
-0.0156442113,
0.1352354735,
0.1901788116,
0.0902751759,
0.1487804055,
0.3826223016,
0.0836373344,
-0.0741362572,
0.3498158157,
0.3609027863,
-0.528218925,
-0.1178852394,
-0.5271819234,
0.7395960093,
0.2711759806,
-0.2536958456,
-0.3995048404,
0.5304251313,
-0.1392693073,
-0.2977168262,
0.6054539084,
1.133148551,
-0.2055998296,
-0.2247537673,
-0.2803348005,
-0.2445396185,
-0.4203263521,
0.5031215549,
-0.1432796419,
-1.4560793638,
0.3135305643,
-0.5138238668,
-0.1979426146,
0.4604955316,
0.2507156432,
0.0140873175,
1.3156657219,
0.9307665825,
0.270411253,
0.4609318972,
-0.1322149038,
0.3316770494,
-0.661662519,
-0.2661800981,
-0.6773317456,
-0.0351494625,
-0.9786377549,
-0.315975219,
0.0390220731,
0.0081096087,
-0.2295934409,
0.1895426065,
-0.6629425287,
0.2636267245,
0.6178691983,
0.3622157276,
0.1466571689,
0.1197571233,
-0.3151828945,
-0.0706617683,
-0.5305120349,
-0.3876146376,
0.9040461779,
0.2349597365,
0.500931859,
-0.2021453828,
0.634570837,
0.3133348823,
-0.2540556192,
-0.4031560719,
0.4230922759,
-0.7084299326,
-0.0852736682,
-0.2160076201,
-0.231071189,
-1.1451637745,
0.158633545,
-0.4004180431,
-1.1234214306,
0.3630494773,
-0.1754129082,
0.019282544,
0.0126272533,
-0.8405852318,
1.0175356865,
0.2798866928,
0.259758234,
-0.2214425504,
-0.5738901496,
-0.1727242172,
0.0534672588,
0.0558033399,
-0.1959793866,
0.1040702164,
0.9274258018,
-0.6170930266,
1.1067868471,
-0.3240591288,
0.1844717562,
0.1611058861,
-0.3593713045,
0.6204173565,
-0.0803764686,
0.0775607377,
-0.103320092,
-0.1777426898,
-0.6174167991,
-0.7415554523,
0.6979998946,
-0.7178221345,
-0.5186597109,
-0.3193812966,
-0.5818553567,
-0.4760385752,
0.3268393278,
0.3200450242,
0.5441864133,
-0.3221439421,
0.0535148941,
0.574406445,
-0.0340789333,
0.6262764931,
0.1981147528,
-0.3879315555,
-0.0026338079,
0.5744786263,
0.0508292876,
-0.0727386177,
0.5622170568,
0.1149030253,
-0.6477372646,
-0.7580244541,
0.0893345848,
0.0823966414,
-0.8711975813,
0.0226756707,
-1.1566439867,
-0.0014410091,
-0.9361431599,
-0.2736327052,
0.0345595144,
-0.6099413037,
-0.3721045256,
-0.8095622063,
0.9446347356,
0.8133598566,
0.1688977331,
0.8466624618,
-0.4998458028,
0.1247221157,
-0.0956500471,
0.1528529823,
-0.1652367562,
-0.3609003425,
-0.0552970432,
-0.1104033589,
-0.0934129357,
-0.478664279,
0.4562781751,
0.3029717505,
0.6898058057,
0.3968727887,
0.2624313831,
0.7904242277,
-0.6759597659,
0.645126462,
0.2484508008,
-0.7103814483,
0.6120451093,
-0.2042396814,
0.1076685637,
0.6666495204,
0.4503601193,
-0.1274917424,
-0.5998561382,
-0.6398535371,
-1.0289919376,
0.2930692732,
-0.0398547761,
0.3769142628,
-0.259660542,
0.5029707551,
0.1517424434,
0.1536893249,
-0.2725678086,
-0.1176677048,
-0.4772732258,
-0.452842772,
-0.6684247851,
-0.3275049329,
0.1894036382,
-0.3089004159,
0.5078880191,
-0.1224437431,
0.316411972,
0.2105974704,
-0.2455788255,
0.3675041795,
0.0456634015,
0.0957929194,
0.3411490619,
-0.1675397605,
0.2498639524,
-0.0672882199,
-0.5952843428,
0.0005288309,
0.5477420688,
-0.2255692333,
0.2250210345,
0.5596989393,
1.0456645489,
0.2956583798,
-0.4011608064,
0.6278373599,
-0.1765573174,
-0.1235790029,
-0.218220219,
-0.0223871488,
0.0247730203,
0.0428200215,
0.0007439872,
-0.2304266244,
0.403791517,
-0.4589780569,
0.5548056364,
0.2362373322,
-0.8363128901,
0.2072531879,
0.5417151451,
0.119644694,
-0.1246452555,
0.8333268166,
-0.1683973819,
-0.6015660763,
0.422617048,
0.8426596522,
0.6045932174,
-0.0569923855,
0.751914084,
0.0324248746,
0.0501437597,
-0.1646278501,
-0.0536248013,
0.1490702033,
-0.747220099,
-0.4624736905,
-0.4515441358,
0.0289534535,
-0.7038130164,
-0.7889463305,
0.1583003104,
-0.1765643358,
-0.3307865858,
0.3114424646,
0.1998904645,
-0.5034074187,
0.1975023597,
-0.2868858278,
0.6380423903,
-0.9818380475,
0.9144899845,
0.6696758866,
-0.4636678994,
-0.6361016035,
-0.1734405011,
-0.266913563,
-0.9202228785,
0.6404742002,
0.4305827618,
0.0513489507,
0.2856350839,
-0.3237824142,
-0.5645300746,
1.0418856144,
0.3748272955,
-0.432859093,
-0.1089663804,
0.2029092759,
0.6965967417,
-0.6760100126,
0.2667853534,
0.5055370331,
0.3389870226,
0.1296092719,
-0.5201984644,
0.2315900028,
-0.3205538094,
0.3837807775,
0.2920703888,
-0.3100602329,
0.7241562009,
0.0624037124,
-0.2829158902,
-0.1386788487,
0.7553845048,
-0.1768685728,
0.3900071383,
0.4330909848,
0.8846714497,
1.2760332823,
-0.3448308706,
1.4190460443,
-0.176232487,
0.2498024851,
1.2200103998,
-0.4496999085,
0.771710813,
0.1609900892,
-0.0014887889,
1.0629131794,
0.977116406,
-0.0539131239,
0.5554379821,
0.2013894767,
-0.0949911028,
-0.4243350327,
-0.5372475982,
-0.1625073999,
0.4616069794,
0.191053167,
-0.2870076001,
-0.3097610176,
0.5764276981,
0.3993999958,
0.7410500646,
-0.2484979481,
0.7638223171,
0.1278754622,
-0.4235643744,
-0.0488300323,
0.0996501595,
0.586896956,
-0.4731940627,
-0.2066472024,
0.1126318797,
0.3671242297,
-0.2235784233,
-0.7339176536,
0.0817508548,
-0.355211705,
-0.0473650023,
-0.3573317826,
0.9764052629,
-0.4713181853,
-0.6639363766,
0.6617451906,
0.21760571,
0.0231404565,
-0.0245771557,
-0.4296228886,
-0.0344519727,
-0.1642422974,
0.052449055,
0.3827596307,
0.6426013708,
-0.1482528746,
0.5026592612,
0.8476169705,
-0.2782227099,
0.1519328505,
0.5305346847,
0.9840295911,
-0.530249238,
-0.9426801205,
-0.5961866975,
0.2633126676,
-0.4192797244,
-0.2263533771,
1.1371846199,
0.529753983,
0.9330537319,
0.1697594076,
0.3912093937,
0.2621711791,
0.4818893373,
-0.8613587618,
0.4660397768,
-0.1638136059,
-0.1236216947,
-0.4695352316,
-0.791664958,
-0.5320062041,
0.6824095249,
-0.4754003882,
0.1183380932,
1.0883150101,
0.5225552917,
0.2377741635,
0.1595734209,
0.2975209951,
0.0745679364,
0.1898435652,
0.2554036081,
0.6049620509,
-0.3438047767,
0.1126990095,
-0.1833430827,
-0.0514939912,
0.0500401966,
-0.921048522,
-1.0972673893,
-0.6876311302,
-0.5930590034,
-0.3413079381,
0.2766587436,
0.4582996964,
0.6049551964,
-0.4432461858,
0.1959483922,
-0.4108556807,
0.145570457,
-0.2051516473,
-0.2661775947,
0.7147071958,
-0.4870440066,
-0.7219997048,
0.0907016322,
0.1086581498,
0.1012273133,
0.0693819672,
0.1845101416,
-0.3913348615,
-0.1050066128,
0.7056190968,
-0.3476768434,
-0.2758843005,
-0.5385616422,
-0.2030474246,
0.0884737819,
0.0926460996,
0.9537928104,
-0.798073709,
0.3649820089,
0.3461731076,
0.4586875439,
0.9352861643,
0.0905856341,
0.4309861958,
-0.8357110023,
0.5805969238,
-0.1712605506,
0.4736820459,
0.4125471413,
-0.648586154,
0.3684961498,
0.1860654056,
-0.4053506255,
-0.6052840948,
0.0176957063,
-1.137571454,
-0.4542622268,
0.8427253962,
-0.5727437735,
-0.3201690614,
-0.3973477781,
0.027037587,
0.4548139274,
-0.566914618,
0.3045235276,
0.5254622698,
-0.2087499052,
-0.1723541021,
-0.3294867873,
0.3367574811,
0.0095508369,
-0.8659725189,
-0.10146299,
0.5984731317,
0.0033504495,
0.2001875937,
0.7638818622,
-0.2984337509,
-0.1324692965,
0.3897139132,
-0.1400027573,
-0.1625188887,
-0.3002968431,
-0.0683524385,
0.2343627363,
-0.0227306373,
-0.0956148952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12881v1
|
GRAFFORD: A Benchmark Dataset for Testing the Knowledge of Object Affordances of Language and Vision Models
| 2024-02-20T10:23:00 | 2024-02-20T10:23:00 |
Sayantan Adak, Daivik Agrawal, Animesh Mukherjee, Somak Aditya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate the knowledge of object affordances in pre-trained language
models (LMs) and pre-trained Vision-Language models (VLMs). Transformers-based
large pre-trained language models (PTLM) learn contextual representation from
massive amounts of unlabeled text and are shown to perform impressively in
downstream NLU tasks. In parallel, a growing body of literature shows that
PTLMs fail inconsistently and non-intuitively, showing a lack of reasoning and
grounding. To take a first step toward quantifying the effect of grounding (or
lack thereof), we curate a novel and comprehensive dataset of object
affordances -- GrAFFORD, characterized by 15 affordance classes. Unlike
affordance datasets collected in vision and language domains, we annotate
in-the-wild sentences with objects and affordances. Experimental results reveal
that PTLMs exhibit limited reasoning abilities when it comes to uncommon object
affordances. We also observe that pre-trained VLMs do not necessarily capture
object affordances effectively. Through few-shot fine-tuning, we demonstrate
improvement in affordance knowledge in PTLMs and VLMs. Our research contributes
a novel dataset for language grounding tasks, and presents insights into LM
capabilities, advancing the understanding of object affordances. Codes and data
are available at https://github.com/sayantan11995/Affordance
|
[
-0.1345437914,
-0.3986809552,
0.5133653879,
-0.0766410008,
-0.1110922247,
-0.2488216609,
-0.1857806146,
-0.3055876195,
-0.3690065145,
0.4860477746,
-0.3586204946,
-0.5576129556,
-0.5196743011,
-0.1063442752,
-0.5730171204,
0.5233598948,
-0.1670776904,
0.0427799821,
-0.6957107186,
-0.6175306439,
-0.4017124176,
-0.6098014712,
-0.1365557462,
0.090555042,
0.2359860837,
0.5113058686,
0.7966336608,
0.8328730464,
0.6641994715,
0.2112901062,
-0.0257743541,
-0.1949227303,
-0.6070018411,
-0.341622591,
-0.3049363792,
-0.3936626017,
-0.1082592085,
0.1003238186,
0.3963252306,
0.7554690838,
-0.0240169317,
0.2106209099,
0.0705663115,
0.5838042498,
-0.8341523409,
0.1469955891,
-0.9721285105,
-0.1540752649,
-0.1089311019,
-0.0086908704,
-0.4449487925,
0.1147117764,
0.197214067,
-0.9551840425,
0.3711867929,
0.3794376552,
1.2218381166,
0.6012086272,
-0.1296166331,
-0.1544077694,
-0.3472611606,
0.9996650815,
-0.3548481464,
0.7014757395,
0.6520108581,
0.198646754,
0.348654896,
-0.8710796833,
-0.2931210399,
-0.4078497589,
-0.6184036732,
0.1975405663,
-0.0280993674,
0.0155021688,
0.4736837745,
0.2624535859,
-0.4538816214,
-0.3426311612,
-0.4759963751,
-0.064844422,
0.155638352,
0.0354101844,
0.2637038231,
-0.4715621471,
-0.5355966091,
-0.3353150785,
-0.7673673034,
0.2350221723,
0.1360792816,
0.182873264,
0.0249425732,
0.8255371451,
-0.307836175,
1.0168676376,
-0.3184286952,
0.0498642251,
0.2345911711,
-0.3241773844,
-0.2143124789,
-0.2400799841,
0.4205648005,
0.4828430414,
0.4626319408,
-0.2846393585,
-0.1048737019,
0.0808302015,
0.5680011511,
-0.6793422103,
-0.3103222847,
0.0489535108,
-0.5720351338,
-0.5252782702,
0.1970800012,
-0.2157718092,
-0.201363042,
-0.5848760009,
0.5003092289,
-0.6667281389,
0.0109932898,
0.253133297,
-0.357956171,
0.8010541797,
0.2262304872,
-0.6291949749,
0.1155875772,
0.7569308281,
0.7519471049,
-0.2193900943,
-0.8436871171,
-0.4041142464,
0.248873204,
-0.3189223707,
0.8161514997,
-0.4161082506,
-0.2909962237,
-0.2030832469,
0.2912928462,
0.0903754085,
-0.7204136252,
0.7653964758,
-0.0478469469,
-0.1250040382,
-0.4953506887,
-0.2936856151,
-0.244529292,
0.4251129031,
-0.547837019,
0.9936590791,
0.5327124596,
-0.8673593402,
0.775521338,
-0.4357163608,
-0.6316072941,
0.0218103752,
-0.125592351,
-0.2913450301,
0.3876811564,
0.1740799397,
0.4927358627,
0.0038004625,
0.4708655179,
-0.605068326,
-0.361864686,
0.1221370995,
-0.275587976,
0.8164482117,
-0.044998385,
-0.1475760639,
0.2339673489,
-0.8619995117,
-0.2126350105,
0.1668917537,
-0.0210780557,
-0.3993912935,
0.3777066171,
0.1792348325,
0.2363551706,
0.0709899068,
-0.328191787,
-0.1451497078,
-0.4516916275,
0.3749533594,
0.8779622316,
-0.576793611,
0.5338623524,
-0.4948604405,
0.1788771749,
0.1165838167,
0.3470630348,
-0.3134856224,
0.154323861,
-1.0379030704,
-0.1559807807,
-0.1942275912,
0.6234912276,
-0.677164197,
0.1699963063,
-0.2223232985,
-0.0748751909,
-0.4901960492,
0.1576019675,
0.3329379261,
0.8499259353,
0.370174557,
-0.002852282,
-0.6354379058,
-1.0973635912,
-0.4202889502,
-0.0295454375,
-0.105925709,
0.7099658251,
0.3734929562,
-0.2115579098,
1.2642177343,
-0.5274869204,
-0.435723722,
-0.0199292861,
-0.2976468503,
-0.046021089,
0.3699288368,
0.8068686128,
-0.7789085507,
-0.1151729822,
-0.0692123473,
-1.1039290428,
0.0865760595,
0.2330377102,
-0.2269783914,
0.031652689,
0.6143971682,
-0.4513654709,
0.5927142501,
0.318043083,
-0.2141163349,
0.465991199,
-0.1913733184,
-0.1057599634,
-0.8085222244,
0.292101115,
-0.2569858432,
-0.5170713663,
-0.4172147512,
0.1953935772,
0.1158835813,
-0.2776649296,
-0.7912905812,
0.5676888227,
-0.6492833495,
-0.340203613,
-0.2844901383,
0.2145608068,
0.1779527664,
0.4571803808,
0.3153951168,
0.8580599427,
0.8330419064,
-0.3769862354,
0.0766943172,
0.377301544,
-0.5666486025,
0.7195294499,
-0.9434261918,
0.1043723822,
-0.4049710035,
-0.0704426467,
-0.7356853485,
-0.2401412874,
0.152116552,
-0.1378666013,
-0.144828558,
-0.2395700663,
-0.3848453164,
-0.3080124557,
-0.1248789132,
0.4304776788,
0.5666455626,
-0.7772603035,
0.8108592629,
0.3140054643,
0.2509336174,
-0.5995886922,
-0.502715826,
-0.1956264675,
-0.2325188667,
-0.4102987349,
-0.1654825509,
-0.1212625504,
-0.3980407715,
0.0740832388,
-0.177546367,
-0.0718477294,
0.4591206014,
0.6068544984,
0.3493667841,
-0.1407255828,
0.0676018521,
-0.41821751,
-0.3990105689,
0.1765118837,
-0.4816573858,
0.3227551579,
-0.4388886988,
-0.4263333082,
-0.0218307041,
-0.0692423284,
0.372675091,
-0.2152529955,
0.6334823966,
0.3827269971,
-0.3091159761,
-0.1079135761,
-0.3679038584,
-0.1310384423,
-0.5071721077,
0.3345026076,
-0.5513011217,
-0.7041715384,
0.2030948251,
-0.028153874,
0.0947245136,
0.317858696,
0.1642049849,
-0.3210381269,
0.5489126444,
0.4866729677,
-0.0274985041,
0.4215002358,
-0.4450028837,
-0.10962338,
-0.7095974088,
0.0321866721,
-0.4751720726,
-0.3188473582,
0.0689441636,
-0.6883397698,
-0.0506592505,
0.4129025936,
0.0108997021,
0.4955786467,
-0.3647721112,
0.8062540293,
0.5924326181,
0.2922764122,
0.4281286001,
-0.1277019829,
0.1448654681,
-0.021054199,
-0.4989750981,
-0.538782239,
1.2754197121,
-0.0850013867,
0.6849068999,
-0.2507764697,
0.2496509701,
0.1225451156,
0.4996072054,
-1.0408811569,
0.3735376596,
-0.4359073043,
-0.4852494299,
-0.074318327,
-0.4060091376,
-0.6147213578,
0.1745617688,
0.0989249051,
-0.5913707018,
0.0585729629,
0.5263928175,
-0.0688137412,
0.2485330403,
-0.6775972843,
1.1204508543,
-0.5122848153,
-0.3502404392,
-0.0764956921,
-0.7395123243,
0.3190780282,
-0.0598578118,
0.227651462,
-0.3178086281,
0.1472069025,
0.4423519671,
-0.237064451,
0.6395809054,
-0.0987071544,
0.0746606961,
0.203188464,
0.158315599,
0.5074195266,
0.1059387401,
0.035150338,
0.2980296612,
0.0034953938,
-0.589610815,
-0.5298749804,
0.5075569749,
-0.6325719357,
-0.4855772257,
-0.214853093,
-0.7043459415,
-0.4017632306,
0.3729003668,
0.2864401937,
0.6683857441,
-0.513825655,
0.5124931335,
0.5310717821,
-0.1834819764,
0.3784688413,
0.4665017128,
-0.3437057137,
-0.2495037764,
1.133153677,
-0.1090826541,
0.3802996576,
0.5319601893,
0.3449611068,
-0.131499365,
-0.4831280112,
-0.3056448996,
0.027109934,
-0.7437800765,
-0.0903961807,
-0.6973675489,
0.0458400734,
-0.1920223087,
-0.5565854311,
-0.3353763521,
-0.2977090776,
-0.2854863107,
-0.5030545592,
0.3330695331,
0.7361348867,
0.036678113,
0.4206089675,
-0.5387009382,
0.6353380084,
0.4764935672,
0.5151126981,
-0.230941236,
-0.5897855759,
-0.0855630338,
0.213052839,
0.0577606186,
-0.3565146923,
0.0965621322,
0.1181937531,
0.574547112,
0.5110250115,
0.1739389598,
0.7011467814,
-0.5093887448,
0.5579193234,
-0.1155962572,
-1.0786467791,
0.6741042733,
-0.4858555496,
0.0983441323,
0.8117229342,
0.1459218711,
-0.336629957,
-0.1780038774,
-0.8244600892,
-0.6392920613,
1.0926836729,
0.1949714273,
-0.0083018206,
0.2477925122,
0.1228577197,
0.1436602771,
0.2759620249,
-0.7372393012,
-0.1665650308,
-0.5900489688,
-0.3718747795,
-0.4043602645,
-0.1669272482,
-0.1920654178,
-0.5660594702,
0.4124875665,
-0.2552405298,
-0.0885216892,
-0.0170466378,
-0.6690294743,
0.2735103369,
-0.0448197313,
0.7370741963,
0.801568687,
-0.4611253142,
0.2027992159,
0.3513863385,
-0.3960121274,
0.0498084947,
-0.154983744,
-0.2685412169,
-0.0057390784,
0.37838763,
1.0287187099,
0.4169771075,
-1.0282338858,
0.786619246,
0.0307677593,
-0.3114663363,
-0.4189116061,
-0.1010883376,
-0.042390503,
-0.2078632861,
-0.0095262406,
0.4328448176,
-0.0379220694,
-0.3566291034,
0.4515902996,
0.4641927779,
-0.7562325001,
-0.323672235,
0.5817070007,
0.170822978,
-0.1936055571,
0.5415037274,
0.0221802145,
-0.2586705685,
0.541482389,
0.2745298147,
0.826032877,
0.2462393343,
0.181232512,
0.261416018,
0.6125760674,
-0.2478138506,
0.0925281644,
-0.1961894482,
-0.99842906,
0.016634563,
-0.5719194412,
-0.3287045956,
-0.0162893962,
-0.7024473548,
0.3784835637,
-0.5174040198,
0.3472827077,
-0.5148739219,
-0.5193116665,
-0.8785702586,
0.1256427169,
-0.3738527894,
0.8807301521,
-0.8014138937,
0.7178742886,
0.6659371853,
-0.2643623054,
-0.9805545211,
0.0417454727,
-0.0632440373,
-1.1611998081,
0.8620008826,
0.513266921,
-0.2631396353,
0.2133010477,
-0.6408967376,
-0.8205949664,
0.9664943814,
0.5769979954,
-0.4243296385,
-0.0381725617,
0.1251826137,
0.1838903278,
-0.0313183963,
0.1235934272,
0.6021130681,
0.4579316676,
0.0430219024,
-0.4702013731,
-0.3036204576,
-0.0801560208,
-0.1453601569,
0.1503905356,
-0.6664885879,
0.5554385185,
-0.0967120379,
-0.2575926781,
0.1132771596,
0.4528607428,
0.294061482,
0.3503268361,
0.7597131729,
1.0867156982,
0.3417002559,
-0.2889727652,
1.1183193922,
-0.2917024493,
0.5770537853,
1.2044044733,
-0.447987169,
1.0041056871,
0.5010352731,
-0.221411258,
0.1536080837,
-0.0120576927,
0.1345537305,
0.4348345697,
0.3807521164,
0.0733290389,
-0.4343717694,
-0.1555150896,
-0.1429056078,
0.7076466084,
0.1492735595,
-0.3646267653,
-0.2272527516,
0.5101903081,
-0.1117197275,
-0.0307731126,
-0.0226050559,
0.8359171152,
0.1267335862,
-0.3865761757,
0.551353693,
-0.3932284713,
0.464961201,
-0.5997684002,
0.0612503923,
-0.2285446972,
0.3555588126,
-0.0482171401,
-0.7008723021,
0.5034311414,
-0.0941988677,
-0.3660856485,
-0.6851580739,
0.9729958773,
-0.1266307235,
-0.8111025691,
0.4220228791,
0.432054311,
0.2181248963,
-0.260406822,
-0.5220040679,
0.1002461389,
-0.1351217031,
-0.0940836743,
0.160983339,
0.3341199756,
0.2648568153,
0.7751096487,
0.7287201881,
-0.0444827266,
0.0426102094,
0.2294989228,
0.8147999644,
-0.6808504462,
-0.1820648611,
-0.6593386531,
0.5212196708,
-0.0657152534,
-0.3650998473,
0.7015983462,
0.7793705463,
1.1667143106,
-0.3633985519,
0.7060031891,
-0.1395109445,
0.5378358364,
-0.5415332913,
0.6968353987,
-0.7118201852,
-0.0577985495,
-0.3163544238,
-0.7632645369,
-0.1206789464,
0.789919138,
-0.2784325778,
-0.1216005608,
0.7011671066,
0.8703686595,
-0.4546249211,
-0.2169911712,
0.557004571,
0.156514436,
-0.0671863407,
0.5385327935,
1.1745245457,
-0.509256959,
0.8157420158,
-0.5680251122,
-0.0892692059,
-0.0929712132,
-0.8345860839,
-1.077855587,
-0.5892077684,
-0.0287752599,
-0.1673521399,
0.1525101215,
0.488327086,
0.9304757714,
-0.7683041692,
-0.2797287107,
-0.4627518058,
0.0386771075,
-0.2936562598,
-0.2411998659,
0.3305365741,
-0.269716233,
-0.5221709609,
0.3850633502,
0.3116973042,
0.0849372745,
-0.0285989903,
-0.0804566592,
0.0403297991,
-0.3398120403,
0.6935478449,
0.1475899816,
-0.9191811681,
-0.4910753071,
0.3548583984,
-0.0053921714,
0.1949135065,
1.1994874477,
-1.0798287392,
0.2538030148,
0.4580895901,
0.6263149381,
0.050443165,
0.4412974119,
0.5000762343,
-0.8305763006,
0.5521339178,
0.0832189843,
0.6154741645,
0.3395727873,
-0.1718129218,
0.4856134057,
0.6197479963,
-0.2859221995,
-0.8230111599,
0.4195506573,
-1.2014647722,
-0.41056481,
0.9593241215,
-0.0672888979,
-0.2721577883,
-0.0681934208,
-0.6117981076,
-0.1438061446,
-0.0358372629,
0.5280725956,
0.7384631038,
0.3949891925,
-0.5768392086,
-0.3733538687,
0.531639874,
0.6497206092,
-1.0973311663,
0.4047090113,
0.5033249855,
0.3415802419,
-0.0273521617,
0.3756385446,
0.138134405,
0.1739653796,
-0.0373307541,
-0.1605753899,
-0.334584713,
-0.5327991843,
-0.1747879684,
0.1793671697,
0.1254519224,
-0.2529660165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12880v1
|
Autism Detection in Speech -- A Survey
| 2024-02-20T10:18:18 | 2024-02-20T10:18:18 |
Nadine Probol, Margot Mieskes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There has been a range of studies of how autism is displayed in voice,
speech, and language. We analyse studies from the biomedical, as well as the
psychological domain, but also from the NLP domain in order to find linguistic,
prosodic and acoustic cues that could indicate autism. Our survey looks at all
three domains. We define autism and which comorbidities might influence the
correct detection of the disorder. We especially look at observations such as
verbal and semantic fluency, prosodic features, but also disfluencies and
speaking rate. We also show word-based approaches and describe machine learning
and transformer-based approaches both on the audio data as well as the
transcripts. Lastly, we conclude, while there already is a lot of research,
female patients seem to be severely under-researched. Also, most NLP research
focuses on traditional machine learning methods instead of transformers which
could be beneficial in this context. Additionally, we were unable to find
research combining both features from audio and transcripts.
|
[
-0.4556349218,
-0.9337724447,
0.1523468494,
0.1519979537,
0.2286103815,
0.1887949258,
0.0725874156,
-0.8547698259,
0.604550004,
0.469160229,
-0.6134750247,
-0.3173520863,
-0.9046716094,
0.2939457893,
-0.7543005943,
0.664454937,
0.3730232418,
0.3682741225,
0.0369306058,
-0.0984186456,
-0.3865489364,
-0.5981358886,
-1.3854504824,
-0.2969663441,
0.2469316125,
0.4163638651,
0.4776727259,
0.0508080311,
0.3683259785,
0.1934467405,
-0.577334106,
0.10141325,
0.0679981336,
0.1406179219,
-0.1181228757,
-0.2711327076,
-0.9202519655,
0.136920467,
0.4678753316,
1.0044152737,
0.0129511319,
0.0952177271,
0.1010659561,
0.4303747714,
-0.192632392,
0.080430381,
0.0552149303,
0.4646375179,
-0.5415174365,
0.0848228261,
-0.1157513261,
0.1648699045,
0.0777259097,
-0.403051585,
0.3114288747,
0.3070137203,
0.3509247303,
0.118864648,
-0.8356653452,
-0.5713329315,
-0.7909733057,
0.656044662,
-0.7672638297,
0.541577518,
0.9027994275,
0.0806035101,
0.0990606025,
-0.5504347682,
-0.5818942785,
-0.4263587892,
-0.0801589191,
-0.0559533425,
-0.8571474552,
-0.1641662121,
0.2308484018,
0.2209006846,
-0.8754205704,
0.2714612186,
-0.2135598212,
-0.4633228779,
0.677416265,
0.0810208023,
0.7836167216,
-0.0758811459,
0.2556557953,
0.1703162789,
-0.2852620184,
0.1067705527,
0.4517267346,
0.3359565139,
-0.0938132331,
0.4829674959,
-0.0196563751,
0.3645327985,
0.1338681877,
0.1583675146,
0.4119121432,
-0.3823109269,
0.307626605,
0.190641284,
0.5997264981,
0.0982983485,
0.1115670949,
-0.0928713456,
-0.0647038668,
0.2441495061,
0.3229747713,
-0.2905631065,
-0.0441356003,
0.0975474715,
-0.5248139501,
-0.0732856989,
-0.2695063651,
-0.5239225626,
-0.1715924591,
-0.0673608407,
-0.2446344942,
-0.5127344131,
-0.6708655357,
-0.0328355357,
-0.2838970721,
0.1386039853,
-0.0941503868,
-1.2359530926,
0.7987502217,
0.653503418,
0.782805264,
-0.1732856333,
-0.0291248467,
-0.450289458,
-0.2642543018,
-0.3894509971,
0.8787096143,
-0.5738819242,
-0.5335828066,
-0.178591013,
0.0921928808,
-0.1321952045,
-0.8054508567,
0.8273211122,
-0.0519258045,
0.2591413558,
-0.3331512511,
-0.5167040229,
-0.1781722754,
-0.0706802309,
-0.855638504,
0.6594640017,
0.4157341421,
-0.781486392,
0.1658257842,
-0.8534491062,
-0.5552234054,
0.1202826276,
-0.2888388336,
-0.5524066687,
-0.1406125128,
0.1713391095,
0.0645182133,
-0.0379413441,
0.1817444414,
-0.0044370699,
-0.1155662164,
0.352868557,
-0.4205657244,
0.9547611475,
0.2827071548,
-0.3905653954,
0.0150428452,
-0.5931661129,
-0.3479718566,
0.0909524038,
0.1659439355,
-0.2703719139,
0.2254826725,
0.347666949,
-0.1780771166,
-0.2431331426,
-0.6231586933,
-0.0866750777,
-0.7091972828,
0.3452551365,
0.0172344949,
0.1170463413,
0.1929240972,
-0.3792534471,
0.8959126472,
0.350410074,
0.2155167162,
0.2033422142,
-1.098772645,
-0.148631677,
-0.210324809,
0.58427912,
0.5183105469,
-0.2600949407,
0.6171883345,
0.2960382998,
0.0623485893,
-0.562094748,
-0.1424458623,
0.478692621,
0.791218996,
0.3975178897,
-0.7543212771,
-0.5403696299,
-0.8190813065,
-0.1336060315,
-0.0657401085,
0.0484524295,
0.2492505312,
0.5418100953,
-0.2063178122,
0.710200727,
-0.3064023554,
-0.5361238718,
-0.260179311,
0.3818675578,
-0.1362570673,
0.345713824,
0.8902382851,
-0.8782439828,
-0.2255061418,
-0.1259915382,
-0.4374055862,
-0.2247734219,
0.5866674781,
0.4178445637,
0.0270545781,
0.6101255417,
-0.5383797884,
0.512457788,
0.4874902964,
-0.6383887529,
0.3547397852,
0.2937117517,
0.2324338257,
-0.7058081627,
-0.002289902,
-0.0301569831,
-0.3041186333,
-0.8356767893,
-0.4280067086,
-0.3309544027,
-0.1679302156,
-0.2166284174,
0.4569101036,
-0.1693131477,
-0.3129558563,
-0.4136017263,
0.2702125609,
-0.076854445,
-0.0808098242,
-0.1024099067,
0.5831630826,
0.8595278859,
-0.5440150499,
0.3809571862,
0.5044836402,
-0.2037049085,
0.7702436447,
-0.4731359482,
-0.064471744,
0.0563835092,
0.3279955387,
-1.1609838009,
-0.2549068034,
0.6940552592,
-0.9305622578,
0.3208498359,
0.2940721512,
-0.034781646,
-0.4681968987,
0.0477334559,
0.729044199,
0.2554407716,
-0.0241991915,
0.4234389663,
0.7974691987,
-0.4298225641,
-0.6839361787,
-0.8378298283,
0.0333728716,
-0.2377833724,
-0.2508480251,
0.3402146399,
0.0260396507,
-0.3978153467,
0.1648813039,
-0.2040532231,
-0.2516318858,
0.4157499969,
0.0091652935,
-0.2868165076,
-0.4481195509,
0.0362767167,
0.0795254335,
-0.1652478725,
0.2277315706,
0.330393225,
0.5785500407,
0.0494338498,
-0.480194211,
-0.5497840643,
0.8776515722,
0.162354812,
-0.2707758248,
0.2890326679,
0.6779856682,
-0.5411629677,
-0.1809791476,
0.0632963032,
-0.3614724874,
-0.3163073063,
0.3944617808,
-0.0165463202,
-0.7870188355,
0.6895709634,
-0.1557525843,
-0.5070849061,
0.5555654764,
0.3773184121,
-0.4554000497,
1.3792778254,
0.680131197,
-0.3207141459,
0.4519274235,
-0.2298159301,
0.4066013992,
-0.8190838099,
0.1301285028,
-0.9446333647,
-0.2611303329,
-0.5070002675,
0.2039889544,
0.2944909632,
-0.2832424939,
-0.0400463976,
0.040846318,
-0.5111939907,
0.1888529211,
0.4275690615,
0.0075377868,
0.156973511,
-0.4023339748,
0.2017204762,
0.0657478645,
-0.719978869,
-0.3622538745,
1.1847544909,
0.2790518105,
0.0372699127,
0.4114124775,
0.4113042057,
0.7831259966,
0.166364193,
-0.7980131507,
0.2671515942,
-0.3077429533,
-0.8364724517,
-0.292093575,
-0.2715550065,
-1.3932526112,
0.0197945125,
-0.162332207,
-0.8554425836,
0.3197244406,
0.0192940142,
-0.4599202573,
0.0187169313,
-0.4559663236,
0.8384740949,
-0.2351762056,
0.4480670393,
-0.0183343291,
-0.6053267717,
0.5737961531,
-0.1422448456,
0.5802568197,
-0.2549708188,
0.2033413351,
1.0891777277,
-0.0855956897,
0.7802659869,
-0.1616899669,
-0.1114279926,
0.2058413476,
-0.364767462,
-0.3311573863,
-0.0878487602,
0.0627291948,
0.2654711604,
0.1366936564,
-0.1364533603,
-0.3638552427,
0.3336792588,
-0.6658740044,
-0.3792582452,
-0.785359025,
-0.4645195305,
-0.5579918623,
-0.041605223,
0.1699861586,
0.5244269967,
-0.5085522532,
-0.0731753185,
0.5006966591,
-0.1218988448,
0.4222864211,
0.4301388562,
-0.4324780405,
0.053830415,
0.6218572259,
0.0250678658,
-0.0477683321,
0.1168082803,
0.2461879849,
-0.3589649796,
-0.6448638439,
-0.1044644117,
0.3722444773,
-0.4354126751,
0.0696995631,
-0.2774025798,
-0.4363486171,
-0.7698900104,
0.2971865833,
-0.2770182192,
-0.5150619745,
-0.5505810976,
-0.097847335,
0.4253068268,
0.644108057,
-0.2174053341,
0.4951103032,
-0.4033349454,
0.8669862747,
0.1238679662,
0.2224313766,
-0.0919066891,
-0.6430777907,
-0.1011378914,
0.1735479087,
-0.4596818388,
-0.9854671359,
0.6779108644,
0.4026932716,
0.5969603658,
0.4245513976,
-0.1460648626,
0.1012414917,
-0.2447657436,
1.1022480726,
-0.0247143805,
-0.9114208221,
0.6455305815,
-0.0434147827,
-0.1003013328,
0.1540189087,
0.8185617328,
-0.6507764459,
-0.5580931902,
-0.9598315954,
-0.6642910242,
0.7201864123,
0.3097497523,
-0.1458963156,
-0.0925958529,
0.1941745281,
-0.1006051004,
0.009717416,
-0.2398985028,
-0.6303656101,
-0.0901695266,
-0.1903046519,
-0.3507468104,
-0.1667779982,
-0.5430300236,
-0.4379745126,
0.4225842953,
0.0263129026,
0.4798035026,
0.0943229571,
0.2574836314,
-0.1419494897,
0.2996682823,
0.6120215654,
0.6484473944,
-0.1170689464,
0.1100954488,
-0.045958057,
-0.7632163167,
0.107813023,
0.1927509606,
-0.1212470382,
0.4063634276,
0.7103232145,
0.610075891,
0.0677356571,
-0.7282149792,
0.7776780128,
-0.2890989184,
-0.4716789126,
-0.3024289608,
0.0504389368,
0.2281277329,
0.4754143059,
0.2955872715,
0.2210358828,
0.6772614121,
-0.6997222304,
0.3534342051,
0.7021803856,
-0.2689960897,
-0.4817285538,
0.640376687,
0.0973441824,
-0.903413415,
0.5423036218,
-0.0714171678,
-0.3821614385,
0.7996941209,
0.6181120872,
0.7711270452,
-0.63877213,
0.2996976674,
-0.1762222797,
0.0595727488,
0.1869459003,
0.5136029124,
-0.0870750174,
-0.8796886802,
0.0169601906,
-0.3203363419,
-0.712366879,
0.228708297,
-0.8131447434,
-0.0828799233,
-0.1011546552,
-0.76761657,
0.6716555357,
-0.099309206,
-0.3364951015,
0.3319164217,
0.4275827706,
0.5521253943,
-1.0030242205,
0.7149330378,
0.4507833123,
-0.3756775856,
-0.451718688,
0.0043713711,
0.4198598862,
-0.4415347874,
0.4991950095,
-0.2106205821,
-0.4576860368,
0.0308765154,
-0.5703573823,
-0.7825297713,
0.6075258255,
0.2092159241,
-0.4312690496,
0.044539921,
0.2298023254,
0.7127785683,
-0.4826904833,
0.4279154539,
0.750864923,
0.4248512983,
-0.1625234038,
-1.3118600845,
-0.4834682047,
-0.3229383826,
-0.3918488026,
-0.1408376247,
-0.2848419249,
0.6614940763,
0.2183180749,
-0.1894193739,
-0.0979233682,
0.581793189,
0.2390093952,
0.8706777692,
0.3696035147,
0.3153567612,
0.9359153509,
-0.0396878272,
0.8877610564,
-0.1201243773,
-0.0029567117,
0.6782042384,
-0.2982546687,
0.7975197434,
0.2036503553,
-0.2602999508,
0.2441854626,
0.5811397433,
0.4533274174,
0.311098367,
0.0383756049,
-0.238024652,
0.2999526262,
-0.3865925074,
-0.6039162874,
0.7551227212,
0.8577024341,
-0.1901669055,
-0.0180081222,
0.3742729127,
-0.0761319548,
0.1270809025,
-0.2762046456,
0.6627975702,
0.3260029852,
-0.2665665746,
0.4640359581,
0.0173137486,
0.5663436651,
-0.579323113,
-0.0185078792,
-0.2252328694,
-0.0237984341,
-0.2511119545,
-0.6022880077,
0.9234256148,
0.0491408855,
-0.0674927458,
-0.2952732444,
0.6130637527,
-0.3463381529,
-0.3249499798,
0.2676609159,
0.6866407394,
0.3529260457,
0.036419712,
-0.6996067166,
-0.0033100666,
-0.3334490657,
-0.1803779751,
0.3420686424,
0.2309705019,
-0.3075030744,
0.6670610905,
0.3056518137,
0.2836851776,
-0.011963929,
0.3726018965,
0.4122848213,
-0.6419345737,
-0.334792465,
-0.4949061275,
0.1009304523,
0.0911190361,
-0.3402819932,
0.6795645952,
0.452631712,
0.6299879551,
0.0900920853,
0.5408744812,
0.1008144468,
0.9250410795,
-0.3419877589,
0.6853488088,
-0.5544000268,
0.0056504207,
-0.4201794863,
-0.4597390294,
-0.5020933151,
0.6950964928,
-0.1516675949,
0.0987899452,
0.8485104442,
0.5378898978,
-0.2272888422,
0.5958807468,
0.1047844216,
0.1198210716,
0.0735022575,
0.2812008262,
0.8616922498,
-0.3104764819,
-0.1918888539,
0.0446640439,
-0.303409487,
-0.0619627349,
-0.4079869092,
-0.3791592419,
-0.8872525692,
-0.592610538,
0.0622953437,
0.1504459083,
0.4923613966,
0.7236989141,
-0.8756983876,
-0.2207048088,
0.0742207915,
0.320756048,
-0.8454347849,
-0.1713341027,
0.2887437642,
0.0512577631,
-0.6353028417,
0.8423732519,
-0.1337662339,
-0.1203208938,
-0.0732666329,
0.156360656,
-0.2637147903,
0.0179214142,
0.4981169701,
0.5102624297,
-0.6974813342,
-0.2275123298,
-0.1300476938,
0.1472641081,
0.1503823251,
0.6997808814,
-0.5758452415,
0.0599161275,
0.2439882606,
0.4138608277,
0.3554976583,
0.183333084,
0.2974512577,
-0.6918398738,
-0.1010679752,
0.7697362304,
0.3570900559,
0.1795602441,
-0.3862353861,
0.2602261901,
0.4002986252,
-0.6156439185,
-0.7703852057,
0.3169469535,
-1.3187551498,
-0.2941431701,
0.8877378106,
0.2293532044,
-0.2028983682,
-0.6725134254,
-0.3427131772,
0.318728745,
-0.3138645291,
0.4585882127,
0.6448144913,
-1.0040557384,
-0.2773385942,
-0.6371921301,
0.7553658485,
0.3455427885,
-0.5376862288,
-0.1666790694,
0.4095875919,
0.1262583137,
0.2875039876,
0.9045391679,
0.0427720919,
0.3195239902,
0.1242491901,
-0.046660956,
0.1820579171,
-0.3404633403,
-0.7203124166,
0.1863131672,
0.0251196939,
-0.145661369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12869v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12869v2
|
Exploring the Impact of Table-to-Text Methods on Augmenting LLM-based Question Answering with Domain Hybrid Data
| 2024-02-20T10:00:58 | 2024-04-09T09:00:57 |
Dehai Min, Nan Hu, Rihui Jin, Nuo Lin, Jiaoyan Chen, Yongrui Chen, Yu Li, Guilin Qi, Yun Li, Nijun Li, Qianren Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) for Question Answering (QA) with
domain specific data has attracted wide attention. However, domain data often
exists in a hybrid format, including text and semi-structured tables, posing
challenges for the seamless integration of information. Table-to-Text
Generation is a promising solution by facilitating the transformation of hybrid
data into a uniformly text-formatted corpus. Although this technique has been
widely studied by the NLP community, there is currently no comparative analysis
on how corpora generated by different table-to-text methods affect the
performance of QA systems. In this paper, we address this research gap in two
steps. First, we innovatively integrate table-to-text generation into the
framework of enhancing LLM-based QA systems with domain hybrid data. Then, we
utilize this framework in real-world industrial data to conduct extensive
experiments on two types of QA systems (DSFT and RAG frameworks) with four
representative methods: Markdown format, Template serialization, TPLM-based
method, and LLM-based method. Based on the experimental results, we draw some
empirical findings and explore the underlying reasons behind the success of
some methods. We hope the findings of this work will provide a valuable
reference for the academic and industrial communities in developing robust QA
systems.
|
[
-0.4419609308,
-0.9168148637,
0.724322319,
-0.0615750141,
-0.2962440848,
0.4388330877,
0.1598634869,
-0.6639445424,
0.013293921,
0.4258905649,
-0.4192599356,
-0.612432003,
-0.0025991849,
0.3853884935,
-0.540135026,
1.0126903057,
-0.1299382299,
-0.0416367799,
-0.6776357293,
0.0151041597,
-0.5621517897,
-0.9124812484,
-0.2407794595,
-0.1038463861,
0.3260519803,
0.3714621365,
0.8109271526,
0.4892863631,
0.3455311656,
0.158926934,
-0.013987991,
0.3831078708,
-0.3690529466,
0.0376161933,
-0.0305484794,
-0.5664163232,
-0.3901397884,
-0.2747478783,
0.5183259845,
0.6588517427,
-0.129886955,
0.2653897703,
-0.0028123774,
0.6486310363,
-0.4944771528,
0.0210395269,
-0.585580349,
0.1538235247,
-0.1380286962,
-0.5561395884,
-0.5230429769,
-0.3951557875,
0.0074288887,
-0.4636215568,
0.0961408392,
0.28759709,
0.5812314153,
0.0332262404,
-0.5508441329,
-0.2281522304,
-1.1953532696,
0.5641041398,
-1.023327589,
0.383741051,
-0.044715561,
0.2368996143,
-0.2559252679,
-0.7910977006,
-0.8519927263,
-0.0649469495,
-0.2929790616,
0.2407693118,
0.0767553523,
-0.0750322714,
0.3877341151,
0.4896551669,
-0.8271958828,
0.1725230366,
-0.2305811793,
0.1019271612,
0.5345217586,
0.2848059535,
0.5369822383,
-0.057793051,
-0.4499946833,
-0.1791260242,
-0.6050937772,
0.0106181409,
0.0884877816,
0.1672481596,
0.1315027475,
0.7951241136,
-0.2108261585,
0.7741444707,
-0.1974601597,
-0.1818365157,
0.041722022,
-0.4932580292,
-0.2152274549,
-0.237098068,
0.6236429811,
0.2933760583,
-0.096679844,
-0.6422609687,
-0.3699917197,
0.1274230033,
0.2006957084,
-0.411452949,
0.2032686919,
0.395427376,
-0.2325225025,
-0.2051575184,
0.0538525395,
-0.9294368625,
-0.2338926941,
-0.2484028786,
0.6343359947,
-0.1476560533,
-0.2549270988,
-0.0099850716,
-0.2809303999,
0.7137705684,
0.2302097082,
-0.5827658176,
0.4624187946,
0.7903469205,
0.5491304398,
-0.674249053,
0.0677969903,
-0.4787072837,
0.3520545363,
-0.4628479481,
0.9805396795,
-0.3329098821,
-0.5470835567,
0.3621953428,
-0.2925037444,
-0.0944484472,
-1.068082571,
0.455694139,
-0.9805625677,
0.3683241308,
-0.3146611154,
-0.5096547604,
0.0775037482,
0.2925908267,
-0.6297754645,
1.2559232712,
0.1469288319,
-0.6984559894,
0.3472957015,
-0.641977787,
-0.6121680737,
0.0943185389,
-0.3808051646,
-0.5293302536,
-0.0027297833,
0.1101560369,
0.4278951883,
-0.5018951893,
0.2167127132,
-0.1909643263,
-0.2836659849,
0.6610823274,
-0.1693348736,
0.266818434,
-0.0323856883,
-0.3694504499,
-0.0154692261,
-0.7872258425,
0.1713056713,
0.2086969614,
-0.4018934071,
-0.2129613757,
0.0523057207,
0.168585062,
0.4869762063,
0.0096863387,
-0.4921755791,
-0.2355260104,
-0.2461388111,
0.2464278936,
0.2975409627,
0.3783901334,
0.1781302094,
-0.683172226,
0.6988924146,
-0.0461275317,
-0.0729735866,
0.18410182,
-0.3355020285,
-0.5453716516,
0.0213072151,
0.5119436383,
0.6497682929,
-1.0542017221,
0.2021596432,
-0.2104382962,
-0.3408474326,
-0.3677642643,
-0.2436032742,
0.2632288635,
0.7655723095,
0.4858853221,
-0.2484743595,
-0.3382056952,
-0.9891870618,
-0.0934904218,
-0.1970679015,
-0.2019295841,
0.2693802118,
0.2636299133,
-0.0422895141,
1.135263443,
-0.4532611966,
0.0945731625,
-0.4116208553,
-0.1244489178,
-0.0131209884,
0.3783739507,
0.3200674653,
-0.7185922861,
-0.5745720863,
-0.0229627769,
-0.6222818494,
-0.0284592845,
-0.0766625032,
-0.3588403165,
0.3746244013,
0.3299286962,
-0.3841361403,
0.4424391091,
0.3870714009,
-0.1954354793,
0.7767468095,
0.0999741703,
0.2973139584,
-1.1411327124,
0.245770067,
0.0713946521,
-0.1437375844,
-1.0491276979,
0.0604141839,
0.1509303004,
-0.271052599,
-0.5579221845,
0.2398937792,
-0.3942385912,
-0.4560497403,
-0.1130108312,
0.2407887429,
0.3029190004,
0.5783163309,
0.1569430381,
1.3541790247,
-0.0647064671,
-0.5938768387,
-0.0677011833,
0.6482007504,
-0.2139205784,
0.3867509663,
-0.6885194778,
0.2916201055,
0.0269659143,
0.1572970897,
-1.1207482815,
0.116372712,
0.0925795287,
-0.3244537115,
0.3296418488,
0.2032123059,
-0.848567009,
-0.2752165794,
-0.4250298738,
0.224113673,
0.4777487218,
-0.5137404203,
0.5420895815,
0.4195513427,
-0.2231624722,
-0.406393528,
-0.7278112173,
0.1788856387,
-0.3219003081,
-0.7777260542,
0.6022363901,
-0.0952477157,
-0.2945638895,
-0.3003743589,
-0.4161113799,
-0.0971418321,
0.0658267736,
-0.1912361085,
0.6468444467,
-0.2704524696,
0.1429930925,
0.2704100311,
0.0410018526,
0.3050938547,
-0.0919526368,
0.671030283,
0.1681105345,
-0.1021395922,
-0.496658802,
0.5707256198,
0.3956254423,
-0.4304741025,
0.937533021,
0.2071340978,
-0.1392008066,
-0.5701003075,
-0.5559376478,
-0.2555590868,
-0.4730222523,
0.3042885363,
-0.2037911266,
-0.7947472334,
0.63609308,
-0.1612041146,
0.2380689085,
0.4657109678,
0.4753299952,
-0.3719004691,
0.6019740701,
0.4868110418,
0.3631606698,
0.2103192955,
-0.1462011337,
0.2730754614,
-0.8552026749,
-0.3847742379,
-0.7583434582,
-0.1953340918,
-0.5297389627,
-0.549466908,
0.6995512247,
-0.1627982557,
0.209745273,
0.077539891,
-0.2584680021,
0.0832397714,
0.3029021323,
0.1618314683,
0.7392840385,
0.0566523187,
0.0465453342,
0.0794849843,
-0.9301421642,
-0.638323307,
1.0468654633,
0.2774691582,
0.501321733,
0.0411425531,
0.4979370832,
0.3797257841,
0.307980746,
-0.4848992527,
0.6691665053,
-0.066292055,
-0.4338511825,
-0.3588802218,
-0.4384716153,
-0.728679657,
0.179585129,
-0.3988104761,
-0.2626337707,
0.1841434538,
0.0267258398,
-0.3185885549,
0.2103189826,
-0.7210155129,
0.7933436036,
-0.2086700499,
-0.4391296506,
0.0790290982,
-0.4998809695,
0.2953867912,
-0.2699923813,
0.2048118412,
0.1796804518,
-0.2676164806,
0.9424965382,
-0.495475471,
0.6607457399,
0.0410662666,
-0.4309312403,
0.3351023495,
-0.0037043779,
0.6832508445,
0.173607707,
-0.1373450756,
-0.0321168639,
0.2733400166,
-0.3026410341,
-0.750300765,
0.4295303524,
-0.6392719746,
-0.6094205976,
-0.329646647,
-0.768666625,
-0.9978930354,
-0.1733230501,
-0.0623003356,
0.501009047,
0.0210298952,
0.0654838309,
0.8716669679,
-0.5395000577,
0.2827654183,
0.5852289796,
-0.1472891867,
-0.2465641499,
0.7386709452,
0.2604491115,
0.5235488415,
0.6819273829,
-0.1484455615,
-0.5179799795,
-0.807770133,
-0.5328920484,
0.3591404855,
-0.4612809122,
-0.2660736144,
-0.7951952815,
-0.2508364618,
-0.3323432803,
-0.0658596382,
0.076936461,
-0.5585762858,
-0.2776594162,
-0.1809535623,
0.4290502965,
0.3867632449,
0.4104903936,
0.1744466871,
-0.8776838183,
0.4290721118,
0.3593213856,
0.4281443655,
0.1332315505,
-0.3319379985,
-0.1005286276,
-0.16335392,
-0.0321366601,
-1.0375306606,
0.2158536464,
-0.0361506566,
0.4587332606,
-0.1911806911,
0.3037728369,
0.5241479278,
-0.3549477458,
0.7772157788,
-0.1521548927,
-0.7090185285,
0.2188550383,
-0.4918828905,
0.1632627845,
0.5175801516,
0.3107633293,
-0.6448680758,
-0.3907867968,
-0.3555045426,
-0.9761871099,
0.46119681,
0.2445974648,
-0.0856890306,
0.2672797441,
0.5255054832,
0.51066643,
0.4009235799,
-0.5930408835,
-0.3328715265,
0.3440304697,
-0.0397493243,
0.1062712073,
-0.241174072,
-0.0891331881,
0.1731403172,
0.5886399746,
0.0351114199,
0.365718931,
0.2246276438,
-0.1392316818,
-0.0819889084,
0.6100687385,
0.5243099332,
0.8831782937,
-0.1069387719,
-0.1479323655,
0.2538296282,
-0.2017167062,
0.0384631082,
0.1471677572,
-0.4834730923,
0.0709654465,
0.1040550247,
0.5075170398,
-0.2660066187,
-0.8076681495,
0.044944752,
0.0686372444,
-0.315096885,
-0.1161212921,
-0.002935915,
0.0681258142,
0.0771897584,
0.6515371203,
-0.4034810066,
0.3254624307,
-0.6544597745,
0.3838874698,
0.4849124551,
-0.0589855537,
-0.0937261432,
0.5219334364,
0.1818626821,
-0.2725322843,
0.249989748,
0.0902891904,
-0.3954868913,
0.5711920857,
0.8012219071,
0.5327134728,
0.0981467962,
0.5298067331,
-0.0685735196,
0.1839156896,
0.2214185596,
0.4548422694,
-0.002051068,
-0.4588736594,
-0.6284084916,
-0.4558068812,
-0.6160001755,
0.2885853648,
-0.5884415507,
-0.1129440218,
-0.2371963561,
-0.1069430187,
-0.0994525179,
0.1587042958,
-0.4301053584,
0.2025354505,
-0.0903473124,
0.8809922934,
-0.8251601458,
0.4165593684,
0.7424491048,
-0.2746380568,
-0.9261922836,
0.2232226878,
-0.3644195497,
-0.5951088071,
0.0651329383,
-0.2060074061,
0.1520018429,
0.0592935197,
-0.1419678479,
-0.7263780832,
1.0777579546,
-0.0095657846,
-0.4819375575,
-0.1517371684,
0.8955694437,
0.8101090789,
-0.1601419598,
-0.056445986,
0.7662010193,
0.3588093817,
-0.0508377366,
-0.8466072083,
0.2204312533,
-0.2107607424,
0.2608758807,
0.4263729453,
-0.5414319634,
0.150452584,
0.2388730943,
-0.3280210197,
-0.207545191,
0.8552910089,
0.4006327689,
0.5758661032,
0.3635593057,
0.3105299175,
0.4170737863,
-0.0265815053,
0.9349157214,
-0.1575519443,
-0.0490453541,
0.8864762783,
-0.6246076822,
0.953055501,
0.7261472344,
-0.4617589116,
0.4773961604,
0.5684556365,
0.0588776879,
0.2622077763,
0.224116534,
-0.1881261021,
0.1389046758,
-0.261785984,
-0.5084812641,
-0.0156104052,
0.2925497293,
-0.0746467188,
-0.1778185368,
0.0335492082,
-0.0999006256,
0.312274158,
-0.1078464463,
0.9409024119,
-0.0517575294,
-0.5378015637,
0.4881126881,
-0.029880913,
0.5991889834,
-0.3946684897,
-0.0207854547,
-0.3296957314,
-0.3740683496,
-0.2900391221,
-0.7654803395,
0.4340989292,
0.0711499006,
-0.0856411234,
-0.2022750229,
0.6069552898,
-0.4643101692,
-0.1744219661,
0.0779348165,
1.0297604799,
-0.1961752921,
0.1847034991,
-0.3644424677,
0.0584805794,
-0.0362751037,
-0.0839778706,
0.540846467,
0.3327368796,
-0.1125211194,
0.3352684379,
0.6720384359,
-0.1171630621,
0.1498195678,
-0.1520136595,
0.9466944337,
-0.4798634052,
-0.3830019534,
-0.4113478661,
0.6891102791,
0.0325980969,
-0.088233307,
0.6890074015,
0.8158162832,
0.7700994611,
-0.219889611,
0.8005315661,
-0.0640250817,
0.8394204378,
-0.5645192862,
0.5397388339,
-0.5300468206,
0.4765892625,
-0.2922502458,
-0.9760294557,
-0.2562059462,
-0.1690525413,
-0.3404101729,
0.0588820763,
0.7308235765,
0.8070722222,
0.2372192144,
-0.0732770637,
0.3209475577,
0.0038397869,
0.3001906276,
0.2041318417,
0.8922232389,
-0.398624897,
0.7546406388,
-0.3048553467,
-0.0968539789,
-0.0439375862,
-0.4571642876,
-0.5753756762,
-0.5861476064,
-0.3907282352,
-0.5610445142,
0.1263801157,
0.6452609301,
0.1947613358,
-0.7730798125,
-0.3672911227,
0.1616399288,
-0.1521724015,
-0.2366491854,
-0.2824906409,
0.5466794968,
-0.2001448125,
-0.5925614834,
0.2274038941,
0.3001804352,
0.0693688244,
-0.0768321678,
0.2389186621,
-0.2348835617,
0.2298669517,
0.7157877088,
0.3632383943,
-0.2734721899,
0.0487809926,
0.4578357339,
-0.0789510384,
0.3251410723,
0.7943906188,
-0.8044658899,
-0.020113688,
0.5848353505,
0.9858701825,
0.5128793716,
0.3496262133,
0.9095975757,
-0.5329152942,
-0.3229211569,
0.4792233109,
-0.1336590648,
0.2083009779,
-0.5045841336,
0.5273654461,
0.0694323331,
-0.5290606022,
-1.0712780952,
0.0413598903,
-1.0575829744,
-0.2426029742,
1.1550451517,
0.29346627,
-0.1477601528,
-0.3454388082,
-0.0835872516,
0.2647316456,
-0.3349814117,
1.0542382002,
0.3025018871,
-0.3406851888,
-0.0565046109,
-0.6683889031,
0.5730816722,
0.6262292862,
-1.4482325315,
-0.0188540276,
0.4494368136,
0.0574497208,
0.0738657266,
0.3490155339,
-0.3306189477,
0.4856356084,
-0.321086973,
-0.0499949902,
0.0230010655,
-0.0582852624,
-0.2649669051,
0.3984206617,
0.1274772882,
0.0266298819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12865v1
|
Backward Lens: Projecting Language Model Gradients into the Vocabulary Space
| 2024-02-20T09:57:08 | 2024-02-20T09:57:08 |
Shahar Katz, Yonatan Belinkov, Mor Geva, Lior Wolf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Understanding how Transformer-based Language Models (LMs) learn and recall
information is a key goal of the deep learning community. Recent
interpretability methods project weights and hidden states obtained from the
forward pass to the models' vocabularies, helping to uncover how information
flows within LMs. In this work, we extend this methodology to LMs' backward
pass and gradients. We first prove that a gradient matrix can be cast as a
low-rank linear combination of its forward and backward passes' inputs. We then
develop methods to project these gradients into vocabulary items and explore
the mechanics of how new information is stored in the LMs' neurons.
|
[
-0.2424985915,
-0.4106731415,
0.3694756031,
0.0334296264,
0.1870709062,
0.1283948869,
-0.1752427518,
-0.1462525278,
0.1964177042,
0.6998699307,
-0.5640730858,
-0.555075407,
-0.720399797,
-0.369020164,
-0.7434746623,
0.925336659,
0.0201971773,
0.2923317254,
0.1851336062,
-0.0723552927,
-0.5073034763,
-0.2778459191,
-0.595051527,
-0.6589294076,
0.7220022082,
0.2481691241,
0.9032993317,
0.5125252604,
0.3736071885,
0.2206326425,
-0.1617857963,
-0.2937680781,
-0.5500334501,
0.1206888855,
-0.5022157431,
-1.0170041323,
-0.2082438469,
0.1113255545,
0.9812158346,
1.0047010183,
-0.3826106191,
0.1231426969,
0.1985887289,
0.5578651428,
-0.5880519152,
0.1133543774,
-0.667316556,
0.2826895714,
-0.0793350786,
-0.2816663086,
-0.4722746313,
-0.2395959944,
0.0599965341,
-0.5346571207,
0.294806689,
-0.1551724672,
0.8436270952,
-0.0442725532,
-0.0946747363,
-0.40631634,
-0.8460354209,
0.8670344949,
-0.466991663,
0.7601011395,
0.2177503109,
0.3310738802,
0.0668010041,
-0.9446034431,
-0.6447424293,
-0.0683362707,
-0.1997544467,
0.1133163199,
-0.3558275998,
-0.0673067048,
0.0158631001,
0.5288479328,
-0.3665290773,
0.2892037332,
-0.5668081641,
-0.1359380335,
0.3547193408,
0.2519728541,
0.1435976326,
-0.078128472,
-0.3217103481,
-0.2749719322,
-0.8349829316,
-0.0532826483,
0.1514167786,
0.4741252363,
0.0427353457,
0.6020514965,
0.1018394753,
0.5717408061,
0.057517115,
0.1649540216,
0.2309915125,
-0.2747916877,
-0.3402934074,
-0.3309198618,
0.1748234779,
0.2269426137,
0.2581369281,
-0.3705421388,
-0.3450573981,
-0.0369098298,
0.5707390308,
-0.6088211536,
-0.2575055361,
-0.0577485077,
-0.7492136955,
-0.3172582388,
-0.0787601694,
-0.8483480811,
-0.5516429543,
-0.3204733133,
0.680322051,
-0.2244905531,
-0.3469396532,
0.0682882369,
-0.1017557755,
0.4831967652,
0.3933751583,
-0.8664847612,
0.6508232951,
0.6904844642,
0.8966837525,
-0.173786819,
-0.3688220978,
-0.4922001064,
-0.1435716003,
-0.4187427461,
0.4227567315,
-0.6084809303,
-0.5665501952,
0.448437959,
0.2125595212,
-0.260001421,
-0.6541214585,
0.2968947887,
-0.8377286196,
0.244720906,
-0.0058069052,
-0.5473772287,
-0.3272357881,
0.1760811806,
-0.6729894876,
0.8503152132,
0.0296767298,
-0.3909508884,
0.1066135764,
-0.5449037552,
-0.3472783566,
0.054059878,
-0.1902412772,
-0.0639822036,
0.430814296,
-0.0765618011,
0.5703981519,
-0.0664669871,
0.1504182816,
0.0747375712,
-0.3540391028,
0.1904518902,
-0.4453797638,
0.5044503808,
0.1647679359,
-0.0579297654,
0.0518934987,
-0.7467244864,
-0.3476617634,
0.0649653301,
-0.5695647597,
-0.2596763968,
0.2878016233,
-0.0223837048,
0.2412497848,
0.0468362533,
-0.391109705,
0.2502915263,
-0.4267184138,
0.2985557914,
0.7338812351,
-0.3920784295,
1.0081342459,
0.0410479717,
0.5921874046,
0.3290518522,
0.0954484344,
-0.2312226593,
-0.5071727037,
-1.0428506136,
0.2256425023,
0.0291465409,
0.6546907425,
-0.77799052,
0.1274445653,
-0.2650589943,
-0.4911462665,
-0.5647424459,
0.2330836803,
0.143301934,
0.7632946968,
0.4877780676,
-0.3633281589,
-0.2441776842,
-0.8835681677,
-0.3990545869,
-0.0544958636,
0.0103948396,
0.2279841155,
0.5371712446,
-0.2332140803,
0.6380886436,
-0.6924304366,
-0.3885082304,
-0.2714550495,
0.1151416302,
0.4856368005,
0.5639343262,
0.2776466906,
-0.8037405014,
0.1549504399,
-0.4027896821,
-0.4459551275,
0.1207970828,
0.0044192947,
-0.1715661287,
-0.0947883651,
0.7254827619,
-0.6179001331,
0.6206480265,
0.663484633,
-0.4347986877,
0.0857100338,
-0.0888687149,
-0.458189249,
-0.9384660721,
0.1446172744,
0.0675509572,
-0.1199264005,
-0.8213461637,
0.0444982238,
-0.0401705913,
0.0170910805,
-0.3680464327,
0.7772715092,
-0.4854970276,
-0.2753568888,
-0.2135706991,
0.3322659731,
0.0897464007,
0.4282483757,
0.0913360268,
0.4076491594,
0.7382864952,
-0.6155196428,
0.2119435221,
-0.0123054432,
-0.3060182333,
0.5582922101,
-0.4365870655,
-0.095940724,
-0.5609838367,
0.2404247224,
-1.1386632919,
0.3653510511,
0.3261736035,
-0.4492863715,
0.6921710968,
-0.2091266662,
-0.1787332594,
-0.1012163833,
-0.1593514532,
0.2865713239,
0.6583474874,
-0.5878776312,
0.8969101906,
0.4607948661,
-0.0618019886,
-0.973465085,
-1.1040799618,
0.0023292198,
0.0099715572,
-0.1828119904,
0.4202798903,
0.1516116112,
-0.2577356994,
0.1062703058,
0.243853718,
-0.008310915,
0.180759877,
0.2496595383,
0.2120836675,
-0.5174624324,
0.3732345998,
-0.1142544523,
0.057548359,
0.0936922356,
-0.6233717203,
0.6522091031,
-0.1812145412,
-0.1301545799,
-0.3017159104,
0.2645250559,
0.2055057138,
-0.0915804654,
1.0327941179,
0.7509427071,
-0.4767445624,
-0.3466697335,
-0.3179564178,
-0.3993728161,
-0.4498553574,
0.6064527035,
-0.3810088336,
-0.6724461913,
0.6346589327,
-0.1101603359,
0.1241493076,
0.5441533923,
0.6908984184,
-0.097718358,
0.7234120369,
0.8150225282,
-0.0821682811,
0.6371001005,
-0.585706532,
0.037290372,
-0.7765508294,
-0.5295087099,
-0.3952665031,
-0.6334678531,
-0.4075367749,
-0.6983810663,
-0.0961887017,
0.5458884835,
-0.0794942826,
0.114033848,
-0.2510291338,
0.3465252221,
0.6235176921,
0.0469181426,
0.3607856035,
-0.0404823385,
-0.2374361008,
-0.0109289363,
-0.7086873055,
-0.3390133977,
0.8011959195,
0.8015524745,
1.1254328489,
0.1262080818,
0.5757091641,
-0.0066069146,
0.7215589881,
-1.0492805243,
0.5391376615,
-0.3305723667,
-0.5566239357,
-0.1807843447,
-0.0222759284,
-0.9262536764,
0.3194551766,
-0.0296450015,
-0.8748885393,
0.5534781218,
0.3132394254,
-0.0632594228,
0.4063618481,
-0.4419384301,
0.5629258752,
0.0816977471,
-0.2480175048,
-0.4416620731,
-0.7080843449,
0.0896448493,
0.1866655052,
0.2053442448,
0.2290551066,
-0.2395729721,
0.7985229492,
-0.2520392537,
1.2063281536,
-0.4924997389,
-0.3776360452,
0.0425134823,
0.3616369069,
0.2916883528,
-0.067088604,
0.1177687719,
0.4179330468,
-0.3410321772,
-0.2251176685,
-0.7707836032,
0.6009928584,
-0.5015302896,
-0.5357109904,
-0.1051981524,
-0.5469036102,
-0.1013329178,
0.1650091857,
0.249425143,
0.5223366022,
-0.0747287571,
-0.0446245968,
0.5594289303,
-0.3060292304,
0.4588650167,
0.5524020195,
-0.685521543,
0.1172927395,
0.9178931713,
0.1862550229,
0.2005070299,
0.7495545745,
0.1102589443,
-0.316252768,
-0.6569562554,
-0.3554165661,
0.2156108916,
-1.1139658689,
-0.0162485,
-0.2550814152,
-0.4429427087,
-0.017525604,
0.0428733416,
-0.5257673264,
-0.5494288206,
-0.4313719571,
-0.1501622647,
-0.0504321195,
1.0179673433,
-0.2083344758,
0.3878786266,
-0.563673079,
0.0066456082,
0.1543304175,
0.3921877146,
0.2611242235,
-0.6078088284,
-0.4483535588,
-0.0695348829,
-0.2562720478,
-0.772642076,
0.5068333745,
0.2624302804,
0.5534348488,
0.2403629273,
-0.6738452911,
0.3383243084,
-0.7719785571,
0.9704942703,
0.1207925677,
-1.0337719917,
0.5654796958,
0.0333232172,
0.099970378,
0.2166320831,
0.3446933627,
-0.6462757587,
-0.2156658173,
-0.3586838245,
-0.7247338295,
0.5499581099,
-0.0153790172,
0.4434279799,
0.1924205422,
0.501100421,
0.1753528565,
0.2149108648,
-0.6654990315,
-0.4761953652,
-0.302482754,
-0.330698669,
-0.5869432688,
-0.1631009579,
-0.123324573,
-0.1007022709,
0.2499490827,
-0.1707909703,
0.5175879002,
0.0732621178,
-0.2464108914,
0.1013271958,
0.1485816985,
0.7390915155,
0.5748425126,
-0.062176615,
0.3917078674,
0.0983541161,
-0.725756824,
-0.1439230144,
0.0134879826,
-0.0843388289,
0.1720592976,
0.3517775834,
0.913417697,
0.1204774007,
-0.3181072474,
0.6211320162,
0.0625536591,
0.0396686345,
-0.3247566521,
-0.0073977001,
0.1510155499,
0.5419914722,
0.4999543726,
0.2917834818,
0.1871629059,
-0.6215277314,
0.0858398229,
0.3722587526,
-0.7350950837,
-0.6113519073,
0.3957315981,
-0.0616442412,
-0.3624170423,
0.6821319461,
0.3815816343,
-0.4930479228,
0.3035346866,
0.5646118522,
0.7106394768,
-0.3642004132,
0.194474414,
0.0420804694,
0.2145503759,
-0.1688816398,
0.505189836,
-0.0923658386,
-1.1500810385,
-0.3759615719,
-0.6019207239,
-0.2276779413,
0.0222927462,
-0.9268429279,
0.0575692654,
-0.2290566862,
-0.1463272125,
0.0607490912,
-0.422016412,
-0.7884925008,
0.466602236,
0.3393975794,
1.2482988834,
-0.7728759646,
1.0025229454,
0.4531665146,
-0.4919737875,
-0.7636262774,
0.0736634806,
-0.2668559849,
-1.5478454828,
1.4756712914,
-0.129654631,
-0.3713933229,
0.0592110828,
-0.4897279143,
-0.7832058072,
1.0746449232,
0.2762165666,
-0.4704558849,
-0.5608670115,
0.0435222946,
0.5051121712,
-0.3214586675,
0.1813714355,
0.3307284713,
0.274066031,
0.0726125985,
-0.6450694799,
-0.0419313461,
-0.2273824513,
0.096301131,
0.2007045299,
-0.3056889772,
1.0879020691,
-0.2013530582,
-0.2981909513,
0.0661464334,
0.6577109098,
-0.1782583147,
0.145532459,
0.3259438276,
0.5153290629,
0.7437414527,
-0.0854038596,
1.20523417,
-0.171763435,
0.5273748636,
0.9045559764,
0.1104808226,
1.2484755516,
0.7524385452,
0.0529657714,
0.8611423373,
0.1342644244,
-0.0530706383,
0.7197220922,
0.5448587537,
0.1135351732,
0.1255141497,
-0.21939601,
-0.1686373353,
0.4428106248,
0.6572508812,
-0.8721586466,
0.0442773066,
0.1437656134,
0.0163370147,
-0.0931066573,
-0.7396982312,
0.4380031228,
0.4324576557,
-0.6158738136,
0.4710963666,
0.0529505722,
0.7094320059,
-0.3968803883,
-0.0983612686,
-0.3008598387,
0.5966715813,
-0.2890236676,
-1.0929043293,
0.4119756222,
-0.4570305347,
-0.2039960772,
-0.2329835743,
0.7912850976,
-0.6138089299,
-0.4970971942,
0.4954598248,
0.6083101034,
0.0680285841,
0.2215728015,
-0.5462217927,
-0.1180113554,
-0.3717344105,
-0.4059290588,
0.0927602425,
-0.1246451959,
0.19954817,
0.7258644104,
0.0447100699,
0.5043237209,
0.2829964757,
0.3126775324,
0.7303268313,
-0.7418976426,
-0.3869989812,
-0.9376515746,
0.4841043949,
0.0408243723,
-0.3096473813,
0.7163749337,
0.2524631619,
0.9014123678,
-0.1615792662,
0.4007210433,
0.4704414308,
0.5433165431,
-0.8667390943,
0.7609097362,
-0.6126155853,
0.2699820995,
-0.1912170649,
-0.7541305423,
-0.4625979066,
0.6685778499,
-0.2717517018,
0.0762555078,
0.4991212785,
0.8692676425,
-0.0104686804,
0.0541571602,
0.208842814,
0.303014636,
0.0922995731,
0.7021867633,
1.2895791531,
-0.5149894357,
0.3104766905,
-0.1007823944,
0.0967771858,
0.0061032227,
-0.6387901306,
-0.7544776797,
-0.7149929404,
-0.2324764431,
-0.5448604822,
-0.0138627058,
0.2924878895,
0.9397526979,
-0.7467007637,
-0.4265601337,
-0.304253608,
0.1182144731,
-0.0019613674,
-0.2863939404,
0.3522202969,
-0.1469786316,
-0.6697698832,
0.3443621695,
0.2325937748,
-0.0394605473,
-0.7606560588,
-0.2321527153,
-0.0239892565,
0.1088329032,
0.5880753994,
0.1590616703,
-0.702519834,
-0.1225651875,
0.0238199774,
-0.032081414,
0.1551356912,
1.0068978071,
-1.0589565039,
0.2573038936,
0.4408881664,
0.7089909911,
0.5176240802,
-0.3730849028,
0.8734167218,
-0.7878219485,
0.0604890324,
0.2949026227,
0.3680407405,
0.3396652043,
-0.1732882261,
0.3256491423,
0.1924227476,
-0.1874592751,
-0.6997876763,
0.4514696896,
-0.755171001,
-0.4225488603,
0.998634994,
-0.1638944149,
-0.0921191499,
0.0874076784,
0.0601969138,
0.1998545676,
-0.0096703256,
0.1912468821,
0.5331652761,
-0.0426428318,
-0.3851644695,
-0.4335308075,
0.4613462687,
0.3377534449,
-0.3653210998,
-0.2277074307,
0.1483134776,
0.237131387,
0.4460038543,
0.3252476752,
-0.1963481307,
-0.1472120881,
0.038648881,
-0.2590847015,
0.3454116881,
-0.3300304115,
-0.891079843,
0.281108588,
0.0468083024,
-0.3237437308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12862v1
|
Handling Ambiguity in Emotion: From Out-of-Domain Detection to Distribution Estimation
| 2024-02-20T09:53:38 | 2024-02-20T09:53:38 |
Wen Wu, Bo Li, Chao Zhang, Chung-Cheng Chiu, Qiujia Li, Junwen Bai, Tara N. Sainath, Philip C. Woodland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The subjective perception of emotion leads to inconsistent labels from human
annotators. Typically, utterances lacking majority-agreed labels are excluded
when training an emotion classifier, which cause problems when encountering
ambiguous emotional expressions during testing. This paper investigates three
methods to handle ambiguous emotion. First, we show that incorporating
utterances without majority-agreed labels as an additional class in the
classifier reduces the classification performance of the other emotion classes.
Then, we propose detecting utterances with ambiguous emotions as out-of-domain
samples by quantifying the uncertainty in emotion classification using
evidential deep learning. This approach retains the classification accuracy
while effectively detects ambiguous emotion expressions. Furthermore, to obtain
fine-grained distinctions among ambiguous emotions, we propose representing
emotion as a distribution instead of a single class label. The task is thus
re-framed from classification to distribution estimation where every individual
annotation is taken into account, not just the majority opinion. The evidential
uncertainty measure is extended to quantify the uncertainty in emotion
distribution estimation. Experimental results on the IEMOCAP and CREMA-D
datasets demonstrate the superior capability of the proposed method in terms of
majority class prediction, emotion distribution estimation, and uncertainty
estimation.
|
[
-0.7133287787,
-0.4612643123,
0.4699943364,
0.1285067797,
-0.3779590428,
0.1011797711,
-0.3948908448,
-0.7123235464,
-0.0377632342,
-0.0283028614,
-0.5298746228,
-0.2499412745,
-1.0456295013,
0.031147927,
0.022981707,
0.7254319191,
-0.3501057923,
-0.0614568181,
-0.0461405814,
-0.5252523422,
-0.2468877286,
-0.7658563256,
-0.2861076593,
-0.50366503,
0.4021753669,
0.4856938124,
0.6992165446,
-0.0733671337,
0.3610800207,
0.3289295137,
-0.0849225596,
0.2859956026,
-0.3024152815,
0.2814244628,
0.0632748827,
-0.4709598124,
-0.3179780245,
0.0386123769,
0.1153139174,
0.582680881,
-0.2716195285,
-0.0352534652,
-0.3390080929,
0.7646581531,
-1.1617590189,
0.1028646007,
-0.3412669003,
0.6341770291,
-0.0745785534,
-0.0753094181,
-0.4719881117,
-0.1215479001,
0.3391438723,
-0.4381200671,
0.0439979285,
0.0471469015,
0.703287065,
0.4427363873,
-0.663561821,
-0.506772995,
-0.7097786665,
0.9277989268,
-0.5032092333,
0.5406713486,
0.5248188376,
0.3292018175,
0.0760566145,
-0.4522842169,
-0.7900528312,
0.2434566468,
0.0846297145,
0.4522418082,
-0.4868320525,
0.3652789593,
0.014964628,
0.3252848387,
-0.234466359,
0.2813560367,
0.152349636,
0.0450635105,
0.8200855255,
-0.0025526024,
0.1164756194,
0.0458686128,
-0.3627714217,
-0.1908293068,
-0.3421173692,
0.1831785142,
0.5997528434,
0.0994178057,
0.0936833397,
0.4085409939,
-0.1103687957,
0.2482887954,
0.3235437274,
0.2709384561,
0.5493130088,
0.5746079087,
-0.7580042481,
0.1891548038,
0.6862341762,
0.2953469455,
0.1032343432,
0.1047825143,
-0.3147082031,
0.1309513897,
0.2307451665,
-0.5759086609,
-0.0587133318,
0.5707039833,
-0.3680884242,
-0.0577539206,
-0.1035638824,
-1.1910300255,
-0.8393871188,
-0.2551814616,
0.428004086,
-0.1423878223,
-0.4657937288,
0.2888147533,
-0.0596433207,
-0.2636027038,
0.4242791533,
-0.9556832314,
0.2714054585,
0.3775789142,
0.2700603902,
-0.0852867365,
0.2874186337,
-0.0847944692,
-0.182282865,
-0.3088337481,
0.4956037104,
-0.7415046096,
-0.1320653111,
0.1335458606,
-0.1101361066,
-0.0518868491,
-0.631906867,
0.8450731039,
-0.5669631362,
0.2249998152,
-0.0596499443,
-0.9476905465,
-0.5236752033,
0.1269279718,
-0.385456115,
0.8992395997,
0.3900461793,
-0.7158216834,
0.4943166077,
-0.5863813758,
-0.1177451462,
0.0336625837,
0.0099193342,
-0.5740311146,
0.361212939,
0.226747185,
0.6004582047,
-0.0204455554,
0.2445823997,
-0.5528284311,
-0.3431629539,
0.4048067033,
-0.4421223104,
0.3301890194,
0.4327920377,
-0.4947664142,
-0.184272632,
-0.4551500976,
0.0724525154,
-0.2151293457,
0.0462675206,
-0.3666619956,
-0.0329781063,
-0.011539516,
0.112382628,
0.0214826018,
-0.4697074592,
0.0314736851,
-0.1814194918,
0.1790921986,
0.8610208631,
-0.0233601127,
0.572530508,
0.2242046893,
0.6278010011,
0.496666044,
0.3587418497,
0.2484893203,
-0.4650045335,
-1.0175504684,
-0.1781861186,
0.1676643938,
0.5763299465,
-0.3471888304,
0.6682409644,
0.1799034327,
-0.3872177601,
-0.6160010695,
-0.3275070786,
0.1639751196,
0.5197328925,
0.4715818763,
-0.0159262884,
-0.590388,
-0.5857415199,
-0.2085055858,
-0.4195509255,
0.1750054508,
0.3481374681,
0.4194145203,
-0.5007737875,
0.8148379326,
-0.5251541138,
-0.0407634079,
0.2049236298,
0.8090679049,
-0.2657670379,
0.4623390734,
0.3430519104,
-1.1873214245,
-0.3350384533,
0.1373166442,
-0.6317911148,
0.0307711028,
-0.211278826,
0.0791441649,
0.2969101965,
-0.2127312124,
-0.5195651054,
0.6959093809,
0.2867644429,
0.0554864444,
0.2090507299,
0.0503352731,
0.3374698162,
-0.4999350607,
-0.5320034027,
0.1859579235,
-0.031820029,
-0.8533599377,
-0.1295046806,
0.2594603002,
0.1982147843,
-0.5938532948,
0.3861157894,
-0.4554767609,
0.1685332358,
-0.2339387089,
0.0362892002,
0.1875597835,
0.445178628,
0.3913902938,
0.3151344359,
0.7871251106,
-0.4119444489,
0.4569974542,
0.3005589843,
-0.4061522484,
0.8087694645,
-0.1121534333,
0.1864029169,
-0.6380255818,
0.2135054618,
-0.9680814147,
-0.2684025168,
0.7236554623,
-0.3396360576,
0.5769718289,
-0.1880682856,
-0.0972623378,
-0.412840426,
0.1700483561,
0.4659600854,
0.6735015512,
-0.539132297,
0.7294015884,
0.2037139535,
-0.0367221013,
-0.9251127839,
-0.8367242217,
-0.0030992022,
-0.6696617007,
-0.4114447832,
-0.0490025133,
-0.1639100909,
-0.3266619742,
-0.1248481125,
-0.3701295257,
-0.6376100183,
0.0789062381,
0.6234380007,
-0.2405785173,
0.0237790123,
0.6037721634,
0.3392289877,
0.0930050313,
0.1081642061,
0.0301494878,
-0.0096093342,
-0.2358528078,
-0.5380479097,
-0.435094595,
0.7731728554,
0.2130947262,
-0.0050109103,
0.2835361362,
0.8295926452,
-0.6412582397,
-0.177576676,
-0.4849968255,
0.00404596,
-0.4970338345,
0.1956255436,
-0.2962124646,
-0.7420991063,
0.6101600528,
-0.3476313055,
-0.408026427,
0.2619999945,
0.4245458543,
-0.4693650305,
1.1487178802,
0.5955960751,
0.0160219651,
0.4239872694,
-0.0488308147,
0.5819455981,
-0.7869657278,
-0.0874315575,
-0.2988444269,
-0.5543640256,
-0.3596153855,
-0.2499536723,
0.2049713433,
0.2371601164,
-0.138934195,
-0.0152344573,
-0.491956979,
0.2324050963,
0.2629625499,
0.3485678434,
-0.1431401819,
-0.0721928403,
0.3761977255,
-0.2451932132,
-0.2236753255,
-0.2258516848,
0.641242981,
0.4295616448,
0.7280395627,
0.2416923493,
0.9153367877,
0.4658460915,
0.6743950248,
-0.9523373842,
0.0276248381,
0.057921838,
-0.6303307414,
-0.2386533618,
-0.4100736678,
-0.89188236,
0.381485492,
-0.1777801067,
-0.958594799,
0.9492704272,
0.0152117815,
-0.4647569358,
0.287332058,
-1.0437566042,
0.8540312052,
-0.1621803343,
0.1487409472,
0.0996088609,
-0.8436295986,
0.3820972741,
-0.175027892,
0.1443263441,
-0.4240210354,
-0.0090643307,
0.4601673782,
-0.4297926724,
0.9871767759,
-0.3502315581,
-0.0680496469,
0.5257158279,
0.0270104762,
0.5727069378,
-0.0440469049,
-0.4487402141,
0.1956893802,
-0.3266684115,
-0.2861475945,
-0.9693585634,
-0.0086050946,
-0.8955366015,
-0.5121218562,
-0.4820562005,
-0.5827343464,
-0.3506127,
-0.1591137946,
0.5481660366,
0.087863557,
0.0674455166,
-0.212401256,
0.8485472202,
-0.0884174779,
0.4830030799,
0.2577444017,
0.5596769452,
-0.2344523221,
0.6584670544,
-0.0331891812,
0.2305324078,
0.4147700369,
0.322180599,
-0.562961638,
-0.4996260703,
-0.4250130653,
-0.4284323156,
-1.0224987268,
-0.3024451733,
-0.7735354304,
0.2372285575,
-0.4542772472,
-0.2615797818,
-0.112425074,
-0.0665862486,
-0.5519239306,
-0.4065819979,
0.4965202808,
0.5587930083,
-0.2421458364,
0.5761662722,
-0.5994673967,
0.1990014166,
0.2137059569,
0.2244102508,
-0.1624206901,
-0.6818358898,
0.102570042,
0.2615941167,
-0.0902917013,
-1.176946044,
0.6766684055,
0.426735431,
0.3467882872,
0.6607747078,
0.717345655,
0.8550689816,
-0.0878900811,
0.6996043921,
0.3593662381,
-1.2270395756,
0.4022011161,
0.0947453231,
-0.2844216526,
0.4559242129,
0.7000878453,
-0.6563904285,
-0.335054487,
-0.5974687934,
-1.0239610672,
0.5395697951,
0.1837144196,
0.1385246068,
-0.0615347512,
0.2962934077,
0.1873781085,
0.4690362215,
-0.4263184667,
-0.5614410043,
-0.2596439123,
-0.4743661284,
0.0268872716,
-0.1524406523,
-0.2764136791,
-0.1146720201,
0.3228151202,
-0.0617486872,
0.3038460314,
0.3073108196,
-0.2038428634,
-0.3459321856,
0.3813267648,
0.5967136621,
0.2441452444,
-0.4600563049,
0.3735356629,
0.1625128835,
-0.2745277882,
0.549802959,
0.1672040075,
0.2776628435,
0.0221232586,
0.0618070997,
0.9644189477,
-0.1492581964,
-0.7352605462,
0.7707898021,
-0.0717228204,
-0.0572650135,
-0.271667093,
-0.3210785091,
-0.1882398129,
0.3674879074,
0.2167972028,
0.5295699239,
0.5885038972,
-0.3665756881,
0.2923707366,
0.0241282675,
-0.8296767473,
-0.0293492116,
0.3244543672,
0.2122229785,
0.0867563859,
0.5797542334,
-0.4400518835,
-0.7406261563,
0.7237689495,
0.174016729,
1.0863385201,
-0.3126146495,
0.3507507443,
-0.2544595301,
0.1406982839,
-0.0164118037,
0.4549695551,
-0.1023188084,
-0.9707235694,
-0.1999269426,
-0.0702303797,
-0.7508781552,
-0.4323112369,
-0.9816444516,
-0.2370084226,
-0.1787756234,
-0.3803497553,
0.0090091433,
-0.0327772647,
-0.8478654027,
0.6911827326,
0.6422249675,
0.6580818892,
-1.1282937527,
0.4901790023,
0.638602078,
-0.2186541408,
-0.6153421402,
-0.2306030393,
0.1561197639,
-0.6508133411,
0.6949763298,
0.1814291924,
0.0301382784,
-0.4524976909,
-0.5151587129,
-0.417704314,
0.5844077468,
0.1544991285,
-0.4435829818,
0.7992699742,
0.2243957818,
0.6409323215,
-0.301610589,
0.6301854253,
0.4383502305,
0.7557069063,
0.1755152196,
-0.2904388309,
-0.1161381379,
-0.1474362612,
-0.4011776745,
0.4470055103,
-0.6601424813,
0.80292207,
-0.175934568,
-0.3933693469,
-0.0611163229,
0.8476362824,
-0.007929028,
0.6720767617,
0.7286773324,
0.5470858812,
1.3717024326,
-0.3685262501,
0.7572315931,
0.2852842212,
0.5266967416,
1.0805951357,
-0.5587102175,
0.7642766237,
0.3249028921,
-0.2016377598,
0.3499616683,
1.4268360138,
0.0365395956,
0.3128199577,
0.3814522922,
-0.8507700562,
-0.4379515052,
-0.213405624,
-0.4202365577,
0.176672861,
0.7086926699,
-0.013883681,
-0.1334601939,
0.1401482373,
-0.1413203776,
-0.2375157923,
-0.2348838449,
0.4371687472,
0.146828562,
-0.313590318,
0.3756263554,
-0.1737918109,
0.6436164975,
-0.1927698106,
0.1027997658,
-0.4183622599,
-0.0247373618,
-0.3679136038,
-0.9759950638,
0.0136882048,
-0.1455839276,
-0.1462284774,
-0.2750896513,
0.6263644695,
-0.6596229672,
-0.2473946363,
0.1667894721,
0.21393466,
0.4524463117,
-0.4166763127,
-0.6810904741,
0.1356872469,
-0.2671148777,
-0.4508138001,
0.1230402067,
0.9714829922,
0.0434963815,
0.6147665381,
0.0839761868,
-0.3568080068,
0.2163699567,
0.1582688093,
0.5553170443,
-0.4403375089,
-0.1891536415,
-0.6499422789,
0.561961174,
0.127812773,
-0.6144153476,
0.1877986044,
-0.0866238847,
0.6087640524,
-0.1434395313,
0.8158827424,
-0.152128756,
-0.0370748602,
-0.0206342097,
0.1479687095,
-0.6723381281,
-0.340573132,
-0.3591271341,
-0.5287581682,
-0.4472674429,
0.6465934515,
-0.1807285994,
0.0851563513,
0.4234661162,
0.1823903471,
0.1189182848,
0.5000714064,
0.3268282413,
0.05865537,
0.1893006116,
0.8998913169,
1.0569804907,
-0.6151632071,
0.1759522706,
-0.6082510948,
-0.2018096149,
-0.2865185738,
-1.018776536,
-0.5186672807,
-0.2915538847,
-0.6774535179,
-0.144768849,
-0.0633392781,
0.9170382619,
1.0876053572,
-0.9149370193,
0.2007188797,
0.175099194,
0.3980283737,
-0.5115001202,
-0.272572726,
0.2915935814,
-0.2262478173,
-1.1317412853,
0.2223222405,
0.1840195209,
0.3417646289,
0.1592856795,
-0.1373987645,
0.2061797976,
0.0445333309,
0.5524173975,
0.3082887828,
-0.6779397726,
-0.5819741488,
-0.2363889068,
0.0100420732,
0.2291148305,
0.5292428136,
-0.3387753665,
0.698759377,
0.4366704524,
0.7507976294,
0.3396703005,
0.1785211414,
0.3945564032,
-0.9921865463,
0.2724714577,
0.4181229174,
0.3931396902,
0.1494893134,
-0.8578006029,
0.5469868779,
0.0931704342,
-0.6412906647,
-0.6993607283,
0.5371894836,
-1.1628848314,
-0.1311439425,
0.7192065716,
-0.5852672458,
-0.0197927747,
-0.1134602204,
0.0386399589,
0.3502942622,
-0.5646334291,
0.8752805591,
0.7926160693,
-0.5513336062,
-0.3983091116,
-0.3115411997,
0.376552701,
0.5413134694,
-0.7274312377,
0.1646839529,
0.383587569,
-0.169152841,
0.1370181739,
0.195277974,
0.2719518542,
-0.0372836962,
-0.1225870103,
0.41503793,
0.4009480178,
-0.2062577903,
-0.4705658257,
0.0847275481,
-0.4071443379,
-0.3275276721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12851v1
|
MoELoRA: Contrastive Learning Guided Mixture of Experts on Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T09:30:48 | 2024-02-20T09:30:48 |
Tongxu Luo, Jiahe Lei, Fangyu Lei, Weihao Liu, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning is often necessary to enhance the adaptability of Large Language
Models (LLM) to downstream tasks. Nonetheless, the process of updating billions
of parameters demands significant computational resources and training time,
which poses a substantial obstacle to the widespread application of large-scale
models in various scenarios. To address this issue, Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning (PEFT) has emerged as a prominent paradigm in recent research.
However, current PEFT approaches that employ a limited set of global parameters
(such as LoRA, which adds low-rank approximation matrices to all weights) face
challenges in flexibly combining different computational modules in downstream
tasks. In this work, we introduce a novel PEFT method: MoELoRA. We consider
LoRA as Mixture of Experts (MoE), and to mitigate the random routing phenomenon
observed in MoE, we propose the utilization of contrastive learning to
encourage experts to learn distinct features. We conducted experiments on 11
tasks in math reasoning and common-sense reasoning benchmarks. With the same
number of parameters, our approach outperforms LoRA significantly. In math
reasoning, MoELoRA achieved an average performance that was 4.2% higher than
LoRA, and demonstrated competitive performance compared to the 175B GPT-3.5 on
several benchmarks.
|
[
-0.636526823,
-0.906236887,
0.4015506506,
0.1657163352,
-0.5215424895,
-0.0145495273,
-0.5362058282,
-0.3180726767,
-0.0075413743,
0.49406147,
-0.45166412,
-0.4591066539,
-0.4904400408,
-0.1985293627,
-0.158330664,
0.8961193562,
0.1548284739,
0.0411435254,
0.2578497231,
-0.3186557889,
-0.4542259872,
-0.2397441566,
-0.9290755391,
-0.5223594904,
0.8230329752,
0.4351302683,
0.6255581379,
0.471612215,
0.2840976417,
0.3373698592,
-0.1293557882,
0.604244709,
-0.6728467941,
0.2529230714,
-0.6262040138,
-0.4972943664,
-0.4105010629,
-0.202465266,
0.5138258338,
0.8842094541,
-0.2809675038,
-0.0804512501,
0.3335313499,
0.7703330517,
-0.8567833304,
0.0783892646,
-1.0532244444,
-0.0896437466,
-0.3013709188,
-0.2850818038,
-0.2539726496,
-0.1389647275,
0.1313304156,
-0.7129409909,
0.2256646752,
-0.0738058761,
0.7429171205,
0.4499564767,
-0.284666419,
-0.0095382845,
-0.5717810988,
1.0854781866,
-0.7129850388,
0.2064831406,
0.2694516182,
0.369058609,
-0.1347352415,
-0.2820412219,
-0.3370197713,
0.1249784157,
0.1859330386,
0.0817124993,
-0.0984664485,
-0.0812379569,
-0.1649249345,
0.2820089459,
-0.3965687156,
0.368529737,
-0.2800365984,
0.0362525359,
0.6509996057,
0.07795652,
-0.0948792845,
0.4627144039,
-0.118999213,
-0.0764070377,
-0.7050756812,
-0.2606959045,
0.4824103713,
0.5296425819,
-0.0881455019,
0.0821168721,
-0.4219285548,
0.7543392777,
0.3111816645,
0.0463142581,
0.1506969184,
0.0834609345,
-0.2690747678,
-0.0520040579,
0.5821655989,
0.1089940816,
0.4250608981,
-0.0585971698,
-0.2027754188,
-0.1913475245,
-0.005686528,
-0.7015767694,
-0.7675018311,
-0.0105235111,
-0.2384019196,
-0.2476177514,
-0.0497199222,
-0.8830016255,
-0.4129910767,
-0.4846540093,
0.4232751131,
-0.5600143671,
-0.2526279986,
0.0303597711,
0.2317749411,
0.1401896179,
0.7942558527,
-0.9480105042,
0.2721340656,
0.774686873,
0.4894402623,
-0.2475240976,
-0.3141349554,
-0.8436730504,
0.1075821891,
-0.2349670082,
0.9163906574,
-0.7171527743,
-0.380281359,
-0.2993181646,
-0.5595109463,
-0.3191561699,
-0.8989975452,
0.4306530952,
-0.6453644037,
0.1667196155,
-0.1885176003,
-0.3135558367,
-0.540361762,
0.2042070031,
-0.4661327004,
0.9720022678,
0.1912718415,
-0.6152957082,
0.2195141017,
-0.4171785116,
-0.3085924387,
-0.0651374385,
-0.3238434792,
-0.3671382964,
0.1972832531,
0.4546326697,
0.5085632801,
-0.2758545578,
0.2499194592,
-0.393219322,
-0.5277982354,
0.1123789772,
-0.7022413015,
0.5540841222,
0.4360040426,
-0.3539623916,
0.1489332765,
-0.8890830874,
0.0094750132,
0.0337463282,
-0.5867001414,
-0.4636667371,
-0.0023520531,
0.0478348732,
0.0594482683,
0.2617237866,
-0.0739731938,
0.1229890659,
-0.4375039637,
0.2139803171,
1.0718764067,
-0.0474837795,
0.3081802726,
-0.2450277358,
0.2266648263,
0.2587262988,
-0.0335686207,
0.0471878685,
-0.6521198153,
-0.9871667027,
-0.4284296036,
0.5106149316,
0.502530694,
-0.7563978434,
0.5068884492,
-0.076602295,
-0.5676490664,
-0.4418622553,
0.7416988015,
0.5128656626,
0.5876682997,
0.5433547497,
-0.087431021,
-0.1870101541,
-0.9525897503,
-0.4421587586,
0.125655666,
-0.1599059254,
0.3108837008,
0.1628971249,
-0.1366355121,
0.8203879595,
-0.7615333796,
-0.2377093136,
-0.0649624914,
0.2441563606,
0.4437965453,
0.6694576144,
0.5935263634,
-0.8135487437,
-0.8253691792,
0.3793651462,
-0.2826467156,
-0.3203306496,
0.0870991573,
-0.2403168976,
-0.0144816926,
0.422822535,
-0.172265172,
-0.0969538912,
0.6612769961,
-0.2832864225,
0.222207576,
-0.3795991838,
-0.0716246963,
-0.9641506672,
-0.0455225222,
0.1364983618,
-0.2250877768,
-0.3781151175,
0.2853389382,
-0.0425433367,
0.1329534501,
-0.3845188022,
0.6084744334,
-0.2240069062,
0.4103363454,
-0.3007366657,
0.0689455494,
-0.2042137533,
0.8294844031,
-0.1270276308,
0.7562134266,
0.7084857821,
-0.6831819415,
0.1569934338,
-0.2287111431,
-0.0743487701,
0.8340690136,
-0.4824080169,
0.1722784936,
0.1466261894,
-0.1188653782,
-0.8102853298,
-0.1941256225,
0.3339895308,
-0.0765086859,
0.2320686728,
-0.0152621875,
-0.5090810061,
0.2764873803,
-0.1992276758,
0.5342519879,
0.7215253711,
-0.6579485536,
0.9134439826,
0.0658518821,
-0.3991193771,
-0.2728072703,
-0.4584964812,
-0.2582972944,
-0.4203700721,
-0.388332814,
0.4091587365,
-0.1302567273,
-0.3428985775,
-0.1759706438,
-0.0210510641,
-0.3007279932,
0.3565511703,
-0.0399860144,
-0.1125845537,
-0.3160807788,
0.0457772948,
0.5074785352,
-0.2240295112,
-0.2634514868,
-0.0576649122,
0.6531077027,
-0.1670022607,
-0.4831356406,
-0.3166173697,
0.4238596857,
0.2884419262,
-0.2933078706,
0.6994807124,
0.8303052783,
-0.1123282909,
-0.5305327177,
-0.7337680459,
-0.1247024536,
-0.5478081703,
0.4034204483,
-0.3658544123,
-0.7200191021,
0.6913083792,
-0.2757111788,
-0.0220769029,
0.5017250776,
0.5038718581,
0.0366076231,
0.9345257282,
0.4978904128,
-0.1892337501,
0.698487699,
-0.068340756,
-0.0052618533,
-0.5726310015,
-0.0654225796,
-0.517604053,
-0.4994316101,
-0.5094878674,
-0.6182672977,
0.5040912032,
0.3902121782,
-0.3859465718,
-0.1026251912,
-0.3045551181,
0.6759831309,
0.8087233305,
0.485471487,
0.4525927603,
0.1620386541,
-0.2779472768,
0.2017343938,
-0.7987189889,
-0.1314933598,
1.0542281866,
0.0664527416,
0.7784833312,
0.0932601541,
0.7824451327,
0.0312628224,
0.2425793707,
-0.4828164577,
0.6845906377,
-0.4513401389,
-0.2190526724,
-0.1746661365,
-0.5060608387,
-0.8009471893,
0.5562662482,
-0.2003549784,
-0.5788509846,
0.3178555071,
0.4656894207,
-0.4181995094,
0.366458416,
-0.7783097029,
0.3773561418,
-0.0732984766,
-0.5330989361,
-0.5577476025,
-0.5094774365,
0.1611283273,
-0.4026376009,
0.0572796687,
-0.0901146904,
-0.1244019791,
0.5694451332,
-0.33670941,
0.9727153778,
-0.1436478496,
-0.3815130293,
-0.0013409273,
0.0757677853,
0.4687404931,
-0.0120136831,
-0.274648428,
0.2037740052,
-0.3822734058,
-0.6987453103,
-0.6580039263,
0.9927460551,
-0.7929502726,
-0.5322771072,
-0.101806052,
-0.6160202026,
-0.5579087138,
0.2842686474,
0.2029545903,
0.2515601516,
0.1087533757,
0.35668993,
1.0376423597,
-0.0668568537,
0.2982189953,
0.4631801248,
-0.0100473445,
-0.4751038849,
1.1119771004,
0.110318765,
0.0837156847,
0.5924574733,
0.3957308531,
0.1563266516,
-0.8767687678,
-0.1195956245,
0.2476650029,
-0.6524353027,
-0.1056229696,
-0.3414857388,
-0.0491853021,
0.0052499715,
-0.3395687044,
-0.5991364717,
-0.2271470577,
-0.4956071973,
0.3239091039,
0.2794442773,
0.3879523873,
0.111761719,
0.4587444365,
-0.7056424022,
0.2497234344,
0.6541095376,
0.4248751104,
0.2642927468,
-0.3912706375,
-0.3221082687,
-0.0657246038,
-0.5140852332,
-0.5412512422,
0.2543060482,
0.3578210771,
0.7741159797,
0.8810741901,
0.0617712438,
0.7455391884,
-0.426513195,
0.5606274605,
0.0496346056,
-0.913092792,
0.4562692344,
-0.6125848293,
0.2986631691,
0.6440226436,
0.1381164044,
0.0772528425,
-0.3275851309,
-0.4504041672,
-0.9325290918,
0.3424077034,
0.2645817101,
0.130980283,
0.2438763827,
0.1545257121,
0.4198548794,
0.1984215081,
-0.3341937065,
-0.1725117862,
0.1343301386,
-0.3703407943,
-0.2616226971,
-0.1424326897,
-0.2676269412,
-0.390262872,
0.6630839109,
-0.2885632515,
-0.1072217673,
-0.1517994106,
-0.0130128525,
0.0855649114,
0.3435302377,
0.6184391379,
0.7727138996,
-0.2392809987,
0.1985832602,
0.337624222,
-0.2710662782,
-0.2805472314,
0.2979870439,
0.0012893685,
-0.0898908302,
0.3084471226,
0.5089490414,
0.5456331968,
-0.6965752244,
0.0656813607,
0.3359628618,
-0.2796077132,
0.063565582,
0.613756597,
0.0796801895,
0.5076623559,
0.5400600433,
0.2636255026,
-0.0036335734,
-0.2841381729,
-0.1180763543,
0.2983094752,
-0.1394534856,
-0.2371995449,
0.4440468252,
0.5054657459,
-0.1457719356,
0.4917963445,
0.0009336295,
-0.3687608242,
0.4229463041,
0.2081350684,
0.7444906831,
-0.4061201513,
-0.1912547499,
-0.0276814271,
-0.1007184908,
-0.0429547131,
0.3294230103,
-0.2069360167,
-0.7360394597,
-0.1762425154,
-0.4809534848,
-0.5136162043,
0.0050841691,
-0.6077015996,
0.108639136,
-0.4875642061,
0.0605701581,
-0.1825735718,
-0.0017879765,
-0.6169191599,
0.1295960099,
0.028712377,
0.8529531956,
-0.8006142378,
0.9811685085,
0.6262426972,
-0.1132619381,
-0.7987629771,
0.1331255138,
-0.2459342778,
-0.7127046585,
0.6245838404,
-0.1000900418,
-0.2236977369,
-0.0261539575,
-0.4526748657,
-0.5210033059,
0.9921492338,
0.6956257224,
-0.7165843248,
0.0211464111,
-0.1207163334,
0.5510710478,
-0.2268852144,
0.0179759879,
0.4049507976,
0.3769778311,
0.0700595826,
-0.9152389169,
-0.1264103353,
-0.2908400297,
-0.0316369012,
0.0741577297,
-0.862588346,
1.2243260145,
0.1309159547,
0.2631810606,
0.0808575451,
0.6422681212,
0.6040471196,
0.3092900217,
0.6052308679,
0.5064498782,
0.9436222315,
0.063434571,
0.7544692159,
-0.2826623917,
0.4106147289,
1.2998199463,
-0.2205619663,
1.1119651794,
0.6812588573,
-0.2496580184,
0.5525728464,
0.5810754895,
0.0639011189,
0.6836699247,
0.082994394,
-0.3275537789,
-0.6595326662,
0.1831628978,
-0.5167455673,
0.3265621066,
0.360114634,
-0.4584936202,
-0.5661280751,
-0.041424565,
0.0410430953,
0.320655793,
-0.6660979986,
0.5632717609,
0.1512381285,
-0.6318705678,
0.608856082,
0.04768195,
0.8947573304,
-0.6110467315,
-0.2266209275,
-0.4593336582,
0.5510125756,
-0.0690893754,
-0.4645032883,
-0.1139126346,
-0.1699453741,
-0.1689492166,
-0.0186659023,
0.4140559435,
-0.5236898065,
-0.5461832285,
0.1866484135,
0.4646784365,
-0.1204640567,
-0.4357094467,
-0.7516406178,
-0.1052986607,
-0.144177407,
-0.2198036313,
0.5699911118,
0.4981498718,
0.0053887093,
0.8874108791,
0.5676379204,
0.1180219799,
0.0025397253,
0.017920034,
1.2616424561,
-0.3609931767,
-0.7987738252,
-0.7901801467,
0.2641971707,
-0.0207514707,
-0.3374785185,
0.7066538334,
0.4169095457,
0.9750097394,
-0.1951312423,
0.5485128164,
0.4835539162,
0.5008815527,
-0.9358232617,
0.6427375078,
-0.6141322255,
0.4374782145,
-0.2791040838,
-0.9778407812,
-0.30713287,
0.5635675788,
-0.4685814679,
0.3135148287,
0.5416842103,
0.6968671083,
-0.5428684354,
-0.1495193839,
0.3431724012,
0.1970902234,
0.3290320933,
0.8080815077,
0.4676348269,
-0.0726184621,
0.4395028949,
-0.3139652908,
-0.0833399817,
-0.5441809893,
-0.8826596141,
-1.0314301252,
-0.2642987967,
-0.4863156676,
0.0514267199,
0.1377413422,
1.0389851332,
0.9247086048,
-1.1020634174,
-0.0554541424,
-0.1543624401,
0.1861173809,
-0.4730824232,
-0.1939843148,
0.5385271311,
-0.3098352849,
-0.9818439484,
0.3392512798,
0.186687395,
-0.240434438,
-0.2621997297,
-0.1618798971,
-0.1203877628,
0.1879108846,
0.3703315556,
0.1835895628,
-0.7074215412,
-0.020640891,
-0.5528019667,
0.1340266466,
0.0774306729,
0.6494205594,
-0.7927722335,
0.2979030311,
0.5578711629,
0.6930034161,
0.2029515356,
0.1023161784,
0.695066452,
-0.6007304788,
0.1916327477,
0.1631609052,
0.4349497855,
0.1563339382,
-0.3331053853,
0.4410006404,
0.2357345968,
-0.3411119878,
-0.6527349353,
0.1475183517,
-1.2413755655,
-0.5355904698,
0.9983447194,
-0.2161080539,
-0.0239340719,
-0.0695269704,
-0.4705048203,
-0.0123468768,
-0.6492837071,
0.8729665875,
0.4683708549,
-0.1383728236,
-0.2522755265,
-0.246427238,
0.1807417125,
0.6627318859,
-0.714853704,
-0.2305182368,
0.2076780796,
0.4648404121,
-0.0006064932,
0.3275353909,
0.1799469739,
0.1939762831,
-0.1139199287,
-0.4760424197,
-0.3431357741,
-0.3169438839,
-0.3724596798,
0.5215923786,
0.1985081881,
-0.0500757582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12847v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12847v2
|
Instruction-tuned Language Models are Better Knowledge Learners
| 2024-02-20T09:20:32 | 2024-05-26T03:19:48 |
Zhengbao Jiang, Zhiqing Sun, Weijia Shi, Pedro Rodriguez, Chunting Zhou, Graham Neubig, Xi Victoria Lin, Wen-tau Yih, Srinivasan Iyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In order for large language model (LLM)-based assistants to effectively adapt
to evolving information needs, it must be possible to update their factual
knowledge through continued training on new data. The standard recipe for doing
so involves continued pre-training on new documents followed by
instruction-tuning on question-answer (QA) pairs. However, we find that LLMs
trained with this recipe struggle to answer questions, even though the
perplexity of documents is minimized. We found that QA pairs are generally
straightforward, while documents are more complex, weaving many factual
statements together in an intricate manner. Therefore, we hypothesize that it
is beneficial to expose LLMs to QA pairs before continued pre-training on
documents so that the process of encoding knowledge from complex documents
takes into account how this knowledge is accessed through questions. Based on
this, we propose pre-instruction-tuning (PIT), a method that instruction-tunes
on questions prior to training on documents. This contrasts with standard
instruction-tuning, which learns how to extract knowledge after training on
documents. Extensive experiments and ablation studies demonstrate that
pre-instruction-tuning significantly enhances the ability of LLMs to absorb
knowledge from new documents, outperforming standard instruction-tuning by
17.8%.
|
[
-0.3680344224,
-0.8339539766,
0.7616886497,
-0.3338663876,
-0.274918288,
0.1270370036,
-0.3758279383,
-0.2174960077,
0.0213818699,
0.55798769,
-0.5203424692,
-0.3897666633,
-0.6860203743,
0.0302915014,
-0.3377626836,
0.9133330584,
0.1466647685,
0.0453763753,
-0.4119519293,
0.2674508989,
-0.4476342797,
-0.3568293452,
-0.6845607162,
-0.2254402637,
0.4552561343,
0.4766472578,
0.5488228798,
0.8827781677,
0.390752703,
0.3920088708,
0.0437011495,
0.4002266824,
-0.4427049458,
0.0924322233,
-0.0471191183,
-1.0397427082,
-0.468469739,
0.230120033,
0.5255458355,
0.679253161,
-0.2043097466,
0.0496810153,
-0.0972453505,
0.6554507017,
-0.6936127543,
0.0134418262,
-0.87999928,
-0.2809557319,
-0.028860746,
-0.7412739992,
-0.4125649929,
-0.4451249242,
0.0968136266,
-0.8991732001,
0.3355503082,
0.1654625833,
0.9985632896,
0.4769251049,
-0.2918168902,
-0.542409718,
-0.5622924566,
0.5525003076,
-0.6849454641,
0.6132108569,
0.6672574878,
0.0985490978,
-0.2154747546,
-0.4858901501,
-0.6659501791,
-0.132981658,
-0.1380924582,
0.1581698656,
0.1681323498,
0.1473387927,
0.4404121041,
0.4136061072,
-0.3167879879,
0.0966168121,
-0.3789325655,
0.0299262442,
0.4492826164,
-0.0926657468,
0.3421794772,
0.2453927994,
-0.0111972829,
-0.2854725122,
-0.8686714172,
0.0408729985,
0.3373797238,
0.0375075191,
-0.0225555412,
0.2647056282,
-0.1668896377,
0.956864059,
0.4362838864,
-0.2937185764,
0.2153216302,
-0.0376081392,
-0.3128991723,
0.0380560346,
0.3660572767,
0.0323577449,
0.3966391981,
-0.3745515943,
-0.140423879,
-0.2160675973,
0.4519534111,
-0.6251205802,
-0.2660929859,
-0.1205920205,
-0.0066077411,
-0.0250351783,
0.0934545621,
-0.4638116956,
-0.3159396052,
-0.7492898703,
0.662756443,
-0.4460757077,
-0.0252496284,
0.2515487075,
-0.0683659315,
0.6777242422,
0.4862164557,
-1.1583518982,
0.1698929965,
0.8270540237,
0.4266807437,
0.0971566588,
-0.2836431861,
-0.8196354508,
0.1995428205,
-0.5885185003,
0.934958756,
-0.677290976,
-0.3914241195,
-0.0132153388,
0.1141678989,
-0.3500603735,
-0.6094647646,
0.3072324991,
-0.945324719,
0.397441566,
-0.5454798937,
-0.7713449597,
0.0363619477,
0.311367631,
-0.4473145008,
0.6765730381,
0.2110916078,
-0.5338997245,
0.3401454985,
-0.473146975,
-0.5180796385,
-0.1468180865,
-0.1849978566,
-0.2309482694,
0.1965064853,
0.3787614405,
0.3697716892,
-0.2868727148,
0.0411159992,
-0.0458982512,
-0.4659562111,
0.1663503647,
-0.2869666219,
0.4068561792,
0.0193386003,
-0.1676166505,
0.0133281397,
-0.648121655,
0.0554589443,
-0.1181265116,
-0.7796666026,
-0.4406626523,
-0.0649898425,
-0.7978541255,
-0.0498610213,
0.3250850141,
-0.3317879438,
0.2119197994,
-0.6350160837,
0.0450396501,
0.9756587148,
-0.1511646956,
0.5118047595,
-0.5463644266,
0.7003018856,
-0.1079291329,
0.0320970118,
-0.3878767788,
-0.1004469693,
-1.2512587309,
0.2225896269,
0.2366253287,
0.5287673473,
-0.7818456888,
0.4628201723,
-0.1875826269,
-0.2965673804,
-0.9177544713,
0.4655300975,
0.6500073671,
0.8790604472,
0.4755204916,
-0.1447114795,
-0.3240860999,
-0.6061076522,
-0.2532574236,
-0.0990671143,
-0.0189248901,
0.46843943,
0.1007718518,
0.0511956662,
0.6174778938,
-0.565359354,
0.1307936758,
-0.0063850526,
0.1444140077,
0.0787571669,
0.4033732712,
0.1630904377,
-0.696577847,
-0.6106939316,
0.0352589898,
-0.7299458981,
-0.1040773243,
-0.1299155802,
-0.4079699814,
0.2138866335,
0.788842082,
-0.5075265765,
-0.0451266095,
0.3345357776,
-0.2607803941,
0.4711428285,
-0.3977055252,
0.2201953232,
-1.1223773956,
-0.1021344438,
-0.3286864161,
-0.1656911671,
-0.6264787316,
0.0274838936,
0.237945497,
0.0643491,
-0.3013017476,
0.5097712874,
-0.6961807609,
-0.0760023743,
-0.3381567299,
0.2878045142,
0.221004799,
0.5525817871,
0.1259344965,
1.0597211123,
0.510433197,
-0.7199022174,
0.2486248165,
0.301635474,
-0.5689871311,
0.4223908186,
-0.5726816654,
0.5859845877,
-0.2762745619,
-0.1498133242,
-0.4954924881,
-0.1289484352,
-0.1503191739,
-0.3857823014,
0.8259741664,
-0.0152890207,
-0.2526653111,
-0.1216598824,
-0.1230352893,
0.0796717927,
0.5097818971,
-0.6271998882,
0.679707408,
0.3370418847,
-0.2076259404,
-0.5665502548,
-0.2421212643,
-0.3188612759,
-0.0418944694,
-0.5318012238,
0.2558995485,
-0.1774709225,
-0.0720805004,
0.0102110235,
-0.3794073164,
-0.0544153266,
0.2399498522,
-0.084541209,
0.2874074876,
-0.4620717466,
0.4049723744,
0.2404366881,
-0.1639966667,
0.09070158,
-0.1616371572,
0.6057962775,
-0.1337788105,
-0.4462559521,
-0.3544868827,
0.2145130932,
0.3969275057,
-0.4772789776,
0.8888809085,
0.4393197596,
0.0734880641,
-0.1294821054,
-0.9157989621,
-0.3513106406,
-0.5288829803,
0.3425014913,
-0.493576169,
-0.9879387617,
0.0965396985,
-0.2597212195,
0.1069485098,
0.1852529198,
0.4100545943,
-0.5462338924,
0.8688020706,
0.8149898052,
-0.027428031,
0.6555244327,
-0.2226672024,
0.0163227394,
-1.039270997,
-0.2749810219,
-0.6481651664,
-0.1391080022,
-0.263897419,
-0.3845065534,
0.4811069071,
0.4001117349,
-0.2029721141,
-0.0237540919,
-0.210442692,
0.7779259682,
0.8328496814,
0.1955216229,
0.189574793,
-0.153318584,
0.0923257992,
0.3720784187,
-0.8341892958,
-0.4719513059,
1.3113000393,
0.0637578592,
0.8362985253,
-0.0730150193,
0.7869724035,
-0.1429674178,
0.2553118169,
-0.5676627755,
0.3429945707,
-0.2357536554,
-0.4203481078,
-0.4030443728,
-0.3535977304,
-0.9627884626,
0.0519119613,
-0.4083240032,
-0.411000222,
0.0023299111,
0.5195416212,
-0.4775802195,
0.099400796,
-1.0091096163,
0.7845298648,
-0.5152257681,
-0.3211076558,
-0.1536684334,
-0.5964734554,
0.1819762737,
-0.1403632313,
0.202326417,
0.2091093808,
0.0948992968,
0.7480509281,
-0.374989599,
0.6343610883,
-0.0936719254,
-0.2171206772,
0.1500444412,
-0.1908363402,
0.5940775275,
-0.0298759639,
-0.0696937591,
-0.3907997012,
-0.0222792979,
-0.3934420049,
-1.0410386324,
0.5234922171,
-1.0706862211,
-1.2866610289,
-0.0827891454,
-0.5188459158,
-0.4960584939,
0.2344574034,
0.1678213626,
0.405774653,
0.1207606867,
0.2928001583,
1.2741293907,
-0.2806462049,
0.03404098,
0.9632095695,
0.0693661124,
0.05435149,
0.8452931643,
-0.0408763625,
0.4230599403,
0.7560181618,
0.2405543327,
-0.3060918748,
-0.5700299144,
-0.316693902,
0.3959291279,
-0.6204619408,
-0.1203651726,
-0.6795645356,
-0.2805185318,
-0.4985716045,
-0.2307823896,
-0.1854329705,
-0.1256615072,
-0.502217114,
-0.0897987187,
0.2620947659,
0.4217011631,
0.1263765693,
0.4970180988,
-0.8854801655,
0.4719699323,
0.7879847288,
0.3616270721,
-0.3104542494,
-0.8370545506,
-0.4275860488,
0.0905291513,
-0.178383559,
-0.8978262544,
0.0699784309,
0.347117722,
0.6278730631,
0.3336261511,
-0.082619518,
0.7318345904,
-0.5009320974,
0.324842453,
-0.1953182369,
-0.7666617632,
0.8111983538,
-0.2132668346,
0.3889573812,
0.6831496358,
0.5192614198,
-0.3153639734,
-0.2821693718,
-0.3861471117,
-0.5791885853,
0.9642962217,
-0.3543749154,
0.3385459483,
0.0034360073,
0.5645598173,
0.0694644079,
0.3545536697,
-0.4073478878,
0.0094664544,
-0.132351324,
-0.1830770075,
-0.1977326572,
-0.303445369,
-0.1703566164,
-0.1956622005,
0.9102031589,
-0.1491999626,
0.1204756573,
-0.1040375009,
-0.3089563847,
-0.1683535874,
0.4179059565,
0.4824243486,
0.6399436593,
-0.2748636603,
0.1334855258,
0.1738337725,
-0.4228544533,
0.003100324,
0.0226433333,
-0.3210101128,
-0.3945076764,
0.5878610015,
1.1672209501,
0.181839928,
-0.6105878949,
0.3917913437,
-0.1235142723,
-0.1969785392,
-0.143268168,
0.7552457452,
0.2074329257,
0.1953438967,
-0.0570188276,
-0.1529565603,
-0.2711064517,
-0.7164149284,
0.0191644952,
0.4548378885,
-0.093144834,
-0.1161895245,
0.3295683265,
0.3223441839,
-0.5395922661,
0.7713544965,
-0.0770410895,
-0.4295467138,
0.5497270823,
0.6883565784,
0.5711872578,
-0.3848442137,
0.0841206834,
0.2575711906,
0.2716167271,
-0.0469911955,
0.3288666904,
-0.3726263344,
-0.8310603499,
-0.3699045479,
-0.8957100511,
-0.2976486087,
0.1997938603,
-0.7081725597,
0.2753885388,
-0.4043759406,
0.2655413449,
-0.2336368561,
0.0236418936,
-0.7723738551,
0.3855848908,
-0.2002429217,
0.894159615,
-0.7403250337,
1.133038044,
0.7117478251,
-0.2969391346,
-1.2318539619,
0.0713808537,
-0.3615500629,
-0.9737754464,
0.3847490251,
-0.0461761281,
-0.0701480433,
0.2988956273,
-0.2902897596,
-0.9947177172,
1.1100310087,
0.7001196146,
-0.9280870557,
-0.3120890558,
-0.0557931848,
0.4823544025,
-0.1444009691,
0.2742035091,
0.7673928738,
0.3902409375,
0.0972436443,
-0.6323275566,
-0.2139685899,
-0.3957085311,
-0.3552986979,
0.2470174432,
-0.6108126044,
0.7538865805,
-0.2161253989,
-0.1982132494,
-0.2317428142,
0.5102415681,
0.0519207567,
0.153376013,
0.4925028384,
0.6268848181,
1.0343806744,
-0.1024470702,
1.0556941032,
-0.4129641354,
-0.2167788446,
1.468960762,
0.0472959913,
0.8035408854,
0.429864347,
-0.1282185018,
0.594997704,
0.4309881032,
0.1712688655,
0.4452034831,
0.067485787,
-0.1518949121,
-0.5597598553,
0.1081542,
-0.523778379,
0.4757854342,
0.381426543,
-0.2899238467,
0.069457978,
-0.1372694671,
0.0051748115,
0.3421784341,
-0.3722995222,
1.173600316,
-0.009270709,
-1.1046253443,
0.7472940087,
-0.1049859449,
0.5150856376,
-0.710349977,
0.0290573835,
-0.4685103893,
-0.1651154757,
-0.0811403915,
-0.403757304,
0.1683889031,
0.1120313555,
-0.3636918068,
-0.0481420569,
0.5535713434,
-0.6002955437,
-0.3919197619,
0.0023400695,
0.4946325123,
0.1080546454,
0.087996915,
-0.5015436411,
-0.1114695072,
-0.1038732603,
-0.2567457855,
0.4657039642,
0.4301811457,
0.1817348301,
0.5594677925,
0.6789939404,
0.1591740102,
0.4385151863,
0.137863636,
1.0470117331,
-0.434897989,
-0.384560883,
-0.6175479889,
0.4029360414,
-0.0439234897,
-0.2172029912,
0.5306405425,
0.3834477365,
0.9827170968,
-0.0342234336,
0.6654815078,
0.2184588611,
0.6557317972,
-1.1434009075,
0.659437418,
-0.7252470255,
0.5070827603,
0.043024946,
-0.8238930702,
0.1212645322,
0.6329020262,
-0.5129184127,
0.1341570318,
0.6914533973,
1.0454063416,
-0.0841173455,
0.0077656992,
0.3425830007,
0.2208922654,
0.2064525187,
0.7350122929,
0.7035675049,
-0.1997347474,
0.4571829438,
-0.2157470733,
-0.2870458066,
-0.0010054023,
-0.5998632312,
-1.0907502174,
-0.497367233,
-0.0712959245,
0.0108130192,
0.3238672018,
0.7731310129,
0.7224607468,
-0.6700273752,
-0.0359735303,
-0.1643039733,
0.2787202597,
0.0697005391,
-0.1166952029,
0.6016464829,
-0.8984886408,
-0.7178628445,
0.6494083405,
0.136708349,
-0.0016819318,
-0.0435416028,
-0.2985102534,
-0.2905380428,
0.2629615664,
0.3865523636,
0.3542991281,
-0.4397123158,
-0.2063247114,
0.2126238942,
-0.0538905971,
0.028460931,
0.8412106037,
-0.7570868731,
0.7286829352,
0.3399061561,
1.1019135714,
0.5652018189,
0.1515396088,
0.6909290552,
-0.7384186983,
-0.005320543,
0.0863115117,
0.1598182321,
0.3207918406,
-0.4374506772,
0.235974893,
-0.0414008237,
-0.5323340893,
-0.6219215393,
0.2235298455,
-0.654489994,
-0.2576841116,
0.9820667505,
-0.3668319881,
-0.2693507969,
-0.0266534667,
-0.1163863465,
0.5370751023,
-0.1809470654,
1.2272309065,
0.5976949334,
-0.0523894764,
-0.3890264928,
-0.2995254397,
0.7097794414,
0.6624670029,
-1.1669276953,
-0.0911227614,
0.3253619969,
0.2024377584,
0.0069142454,
0.8402748108,
0.0504812486,
0.5217977166,
-0.1595896333,
-0.2997964323,
-0.4236848056,
-0.5448351502,
-0.1560836583,
0.0407924913,
0.5157303214,
-0.127129823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12844v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12844v1
|
ICON: Improving Inter-Report Consistency of Radiology Report Generation via Lesion-aware Mix-up Augmentation
| 2024-02-20T09:13:15 | 2024-02-20T09:13:15 |
Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Kaishuai Xu, Yan Hu, Wenjie Li, Jiang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Previous research on radiology report generation has made significant
progress in terms of increasing the clinical accuracy of generated reports. In
this paper, we emphasize another crucial quality that it should possess, i.e.,
inter-report consistency, which refers to the capability of generating
consistent reports for semantically equivalent radiographs. This quality is
even of greater significance than the overall report accuracy in terms of
ensuring the system's credibility, as a system prone to providing conflicting
results would severely erode users' trust. Regrettably, existing approaches
struggle to maintain inter-report consistency, exhibiting biases towards common
patterns and susceptibility to lesion variants. To address this issue, we
propose ICON, which improves the inter-report consistency of radiology report
generation. Aiming at enhancing the system's ability to capture the
similarities in semantically equivalent lesions, our approach involves first
extracting lesions from input images and examining their characteristics. Then,
we introduce a lesion-aware mix-up augmentation technique to ensure that the
representations of the semantically equivalent lesions align with the same
attributes, by linearly interpolating them during the training phase. Extensive
experiments on three publicly available chest X-ray datasets verify the
effectiveness of our approach, both in terms of improving the consistency and
accuracy of the generated reports.
|
[
-0.3443015218,
-0.008004413,
0.5496946573,
0.6412475109,
-0.5047320724,
0.4548726976,
0.3977401555,
-1.0401017666,
0.7024071813,
0.461948365,
-0.1111094505,
-0.2690772116,
-0.9925989509,
0.0835139826,
-0.3254151046,
0.6986120343,
-0.1135763377,
0.2846597433,
-0.2731428444,
-0.725084424,
-0.9358344674,
-0.1247157231,
-0.59179461,
-0.4468370676,
0.4026007652,
0.3205198646,
1.3121914864,
0.8841005564,
0.6847391725,
0.1094009578,
0.48729375,
0.5926343799,
-0.1492506415,
0.1984975189,
-0.0939496234,
0.1760440767,
-0.6567363143,
-0.1938425004,
0.4983125925,
0.4665778875,
0.1026089117,
-0.4395742416,
-0.1062590256,
0.5526609421,
-0.6012331247,
-0.0251639169,
-0.485499531,
-0.2117452025,
0.035618905,
-0.8289419413,
-0.2221636027,
-0.394546926,
-0.0560553856,
-0.8080488443,
-0.0541304834,
-0.2178016156,
1.0591804981,
-0.055623468,
-0.24793607,
-0.328874737,
-0.5212788582,
0.2648451328,
-0.6304314137,
0.4065735936,
0.3722802401,
0.4407086968,
0.048685763,
-0.9989408255,
-0.2387873083,
-0.2771554291,
-0.6307207942,
0.4061198235,
-0.2476962954,
0.1131450906,
0.0018551135,
0.2832939923,
-0.4028452039,
0.0213117134,
-0.0100610219,
-0.3284179568,
0.6912001371,
0.2754489183,
0.5502243638,
0.1559114009,
-0.636577189,
-0.3268355131,
-1.1280683279,
-0.3518173695,
-0.0459528044,
0.2261523008,
0.1273102909,
0.4480257332,
-0.2112280279,
0.493599087,
0.2176269591,
-0.164604038,
0.5429663658,
-0.4217201471,
-0.0454157069,
0.4888762832,
0.4699904919,
0.6797652841,
-0.4564422071,
-0.1325168014,
-0.267096132,
0.0746203139,
0.4235010147,
-0.871739924,
-0.2514766753,
0.283248961,
-0.3296152055,
-0.4395713806,
0.0613936074,
-0.0734867081,
-0.656062007,
-0.1856799424,
0.9889978766,
-0.7611370683,
-0.2084786445,
0.1069473922,
-0.0559471399,
-0.1259218603,
0.6111013293,
-0.507807374,
0.1791893542,
0.3964359164,
0.5461193323,
0.3392238319,
-0.1523067057,
-1.0038590431,
0.6109162569,
-0.3857180476,
0.9256879091,
-0.6601731777,
-0.5117266774,
-0.0888997838,
-0.2289092243,
0.1163613126,
-0.9719379544,
0.0525703132,
-0.3152102828,
0.0090141036,
-0.5675154328,
-0.3522111475,
-0.0760015845,
0.4386804104,
-0.53496176,
1.3043968678,
0.4880606234,
-0.5791134238,
0.8172066212,
-0.371938318,
-0.3537278771,
0.3295330405,
-0.6880064607,
-0.5329669714,
0.0026052343,
0.5943829417,
0.3572301269,
-0.1717894971,
0.1111214757,
0.0882464498,
-0.3270925879,
0.1071221232,
0.0325553827,
0.3585038781,
-0.0785472989,
-0.2372069508,
0.150093019,
-0.6044113636,
0.1746055037,
-0.0035205767,
0.0239255074,
-0.4481311142,
-0.2708711326,
-0.2581246793,
0.3062033057,
0.3252073228,
-0.7847152352,
0.3772629797,
-0.0167929418,
-0.1939638257,
0.5176748037,
0.1796969026,
-0.0840188265,
-1.0618774891,
0.3152054548,
0.5182645321,
0.2937259972,
-0.2390265316,
-0.5696747899,
-0.5443681479,
-0.6746613979,
0.2789110243,
0.261825949,
-0.6444118023,
0.2361463904,
-0.3694321811,
-0.5623341799,
-0.6566310525,
-0.2556158602,
0.54314816,
0.6625326276,
0.5010402203,
-0.9522399902,
-0.7894155979,
-0.9352037311,
-0.2893290222,
-0.1074872613,
0.1020944268,
0.4184785187,
-0.1353733689,
-0.3989318907,
0.7292371988,
-0.3406088948,
-0.5178499222,
0.029067928,
0.3165183365,
-0.1371504217,
0.5668568015,
0.7048830986,
-0.6236525178,
-0.7722335458,
0.3047040105,
-0.8035883307,
-0.2422603667,
-0.3010694981,
-0.1482032984,
-0.1507357955,
0.9426056147,
-0.110988684,
0.6896693707,
0.376719892,
-0.1518646777,
0.2638727725,
-0.6737517118,
0.6890799403,
-0.8641768098,
0.0912453383,
-0.2917813659,
-0.6556253433,
-0.5006867647,
-0.0888596103,
0.1663445234,
0.1062812805,
-0.2606639862,
0.3995921314,
-0.458350122,
-0.1302251667,
-0.0623014532,
-0.2761813998,
0.4073068202,
-0.1772376001,
-0.0430033505,
0.6932870746,
0.6134585738,
-0.3432369828,
-0.2253331691,
0.2200256437,
-0.2153507471,
0.7667298913,
-0.4635618031,
0.1972399205,
-0.1556944698,
0.0932421684,
-0.9331285357,
-0.2669296861,
0.3167908192,
-0.2912412882,
0.6824516058,
-0.1671435088,
-0.4634637237,
0.0968896449,
-0.2677973807,
0.5577321053,
0.4845449924,
-0.4773805141,
0.8204088211,
0.2888749838,
-0.0979122818,
-0.7850571275,
-0.5110770464,
0.2058264613,
0.1541006118,
-0.529206574,
0.5112636089,
-0.3343767822,
0.0070682303,
0.1200264469,
-0.1317278147,
-0.1915064603,
-0.4239965975,
0.393301487,
0.2542253733,
-0.1681370437,
-0.025857389,
0.1017729267,
-0.0178113114,
-0.2878853083,
0.0127407629,
0.3912675381,
0.1309529096,
-0.761729002,
-0.333042115,
0.4699353576,
0.7394941449,
0.1167257354,
0.2886731923,
0.2972796261,
-0.4214301705,
0.3824477494,
-0.6272775531,
-0.2022465616,
-0.3953720629,
0.3203922808,
-0.3712760806,
-0.4430148304,
0.8029240966,
-0.1980824769,
0.2473087758,
0.2581018507,
0.334946692,
-0.3118857145,
1.2507940531,
0.4292164147,
0.2354549021,
0.2706938982,
0.0913283527,
0.080196254,
-0.8980660439,
-0.4809037745,
-0.2599589527,
-0.199964419,
-0.0696725398,
-0.3110334277,
0.706012249,
0.0216027182,
0.0953600258,
-0.0048010144,
-0.7091280818,
0.5344037414,
0.0092476886,
0.397118628,
0.5325562358,
0.3529937863,
0.1455351263,
-0.3260459602,
-0.8879019618,
-0.2008337379,
0.9136727452,
0.077804096,
0.5244227052,
0.0165886935,
0.9612523317,
0.6480079889,
0.6861374378,
-0.4122109115,
0.2791334391,
-0.3289221525,
-0.4012574255,
-0.0608220249,
-0.0577990897,
-1.2064349651,
0.3018602133,
-0.3458735943,
-0.3543536067,
0.2975071967,
0.4979533851,
-0.1348729432,
0.1882088929,
-0.2635860145,
0.4623490572,
0.0466866456,
0.0512627736,
-0.231066823,
-0.6623613238,
0.0104883574,
0.0091644228,
0.2879335582,
-0.1988151073,
0.0179536827,
0.4547953606,
-0.9411267638,
0.6596108079,
0.074725315,
-0.0299660321,
0.2292729616,
0.3077545762,
0.590525806,
0.1205971017,
0.2998024225,
0.2962270677,
-0.1582881808,
-0.4726885557,
-0.7038715482,
0.6208128929,
-0.8611895442,
-0.22050713,
-0.3952736855,
-0.9428677559,
-0.3450107872,
0.2492582649,
0.5101368427,
0.9752342701,
-0.2153581828,
-0.3804868758,
0.6134111881,
0.1527370811,
-0.1783503592,
0.5094901323,
-0.2095008641,
-0.7183574438,
1.2097423077,
0.2721787095,
0.3727074862,
0.5167144537,
0.0247569904,
-0.0707545951,
-0.7147711515,
-0.6161946654,
0.3531942368,
-0.8932398558,
-0.4512446523,
-0.6197400093,
-0.3321969807,
-0.3391764164,
-0.6364491582,
-0.6039360762,
-0.2818598151,
0.1101078391,
0.4446085989,
0.4590800703,
0.8956288099,
-0.5229720473,
0.324273169,
-0.8463797569,
0.1744387448,
0.1270677298,
0.2579418123,
-0.257951051,
-0.6045846939,
-0.3127387166,
-0.0205089431,
-0.06262739,
-0.6370295286,
0.1329269409,
0.0042150924,
0.4085575342,
0.1934291124,
-0.001197144,
0.8330391645,
-0.0142817432,
0.2576833367,
0.6521719098,
-0.7937496901,
0.4849368334,
-0.3574058712,
0.2041659057,
0.6914253235,
0.1242286712,
-0.4622522891,
-0.7919538021,
-0.9704295397,
-0.9499682188,
0.5755532384,
0.2900901437,
-0.3357318342,
-0.0121527659,
0.0722498298,
0.4818443656,
0.0519801565,
-0.3612293005,
-0.1790810227,
-0.3232658207,
-0.1551418602,
0.192093581,
-0.1504498869,
-0.6624604464,
-0.2475901842,
0.7496660352,
-0.0911428779,
0.0994298235,
0.4351232648,
-0.2083860785,
-0.2436093241,
0.0043362188,
0.6536550522,
1.0636547804,
-0.5004606843,
0.3952485323,
-0.0663611516,
-0.9467203021,
0.2007747293,
-0.1259620786,
-0.0173998717,
0.3623627126,
0.3432203233,
0.3967629969,
0.0874500647,
-0.518959105,
0.7262904644,
-0.026248876,
-0.299933821,
-0.0118998345,
-0.0230704006,
-0.1439478844,
0.1602347642,
0.2666790783,
0.5909358263,
0.0325240009,
-0.4024744332,
0.3956633508,
0.2444314361,
-0.9411915541,
0.0495110266,
0.3089153767,
0.1407353729,
0.2128561735,
0.5777275562,
-0.056322027,
-0.0131614096,
0.6104982495,
0.5699965358,
0.574249208,
-0.2650080323,
0.2284203321,
0.1981895119,
0.4878992438,
0.051443927,
0.5029983521,
0.4693683088,
-0.6470651627,
-0.3930657804,
0.0667576417,
-0.4369514585,
0.2554683387,
-0.8345893025,
0.2949664593,
-0.6246473789,
-0.0039569847,
0.1248481497,
-0.4626180232,
-0.3158659339,
0.5196965337,
-0.1327374279,
0.7574366331,
-0.8518892527,
0.6950902343,
0.9808063507,
-0.5708094239,
-0.9857848883,
-0.1230582893,
-0.3520558178,
-1.2008491755,
0.4748307765,
0.1046738699,
-0.072721228,
-0.2544974983,
-0.1091325954,
-0.7076817155,
1.1546872854,
0.4337943792,
-0.2512781024,
0.4861710668,
0.3538931608,
0.3092291951,
-0.8109045625,
0.4329993129,
0.324182272,
0.359249711,
0.3427656889,
-0.9851979017,
0.6460853219,
-0.01645617,
-0.0912999734,
0.3634693325,
-0.3185514212,
0.6016096473,
-0.3428275287,
-0.0699675307,
0.0378055423,
0.5691735148,
0.3311170638,
0.6220709682,
0.5728712082,
0.8135646582,
0.5898907781,
0.0392570831,
1.046074152,
-0.2900748551,
-0.0955625772,
0.9722542763,
-0.2512791455,
0.2470218837,
0.3127779067,
0.1682553142,
0.6072478294,
0.3487681448,
0.0898480564,
0.5727549791,
-0.4815634489,
-0.3675872684,
-0.3868867457,
-0.3228471875,
-0.7904880047,
0.3077303469,
0.2954851389,
-0.4018279016,
-0.4179345369,
-0.1525214314,
0.0620367639,
-0.2144068182,
-0.3120257556,
0.7821372151,
-0.3157354295,
-0.4176886082,
0.7535936832,
-0.4867249131,
0.1776746809,
-0.8393031955,
-0.4196795523,
-0.1910562217,
0.0147909597,
-0.5415404439,
-0.9054344296,
0.2930258512,
-0.6442701817,
-0.3911763728,
0.1246540472,
0.7465284467,
-0.51184237,
-0.134845227,
0.0889031738,
0.3343566954,
0.2491900772,
0.0281491205,
-0.5577940941,
0.5343583822,
0.0466503017,
0.5204228759,
0.780144155,
0.2330340147,
-0.10867659,
0.1880925745,
0.3090665936,
0.2126125395,
-0.2056469023,
0.2335902303,
1.0583806038,
-0.0391061008,
-0.5685002804,
-0.2279190123,
0.5941384435,
-0.4382913113,
-0.4027929902,
0.5359987617,
0.7141423225,
0.6137951612,
0.1465512365,
0.7961172462,
0.0871591568,
0.2455430627,
-0.3561153114,
0.6623367071,
-0.6185384989,
0.3787865341,
-0.2548298836,
-0.6748505831,
-0.3986902833,
0.2150991559,
0.1127509773,
0.0428162254,
0.6295832396,
1.0721071959,
-0.442950815,
-0.291479528,
0.4566448927,
0.24954018,
0.3210145235,
0.1538748741,
0.723986268,
-0.7020442486,
0.4911078215,
-0.1729512662,
-0.4801424146,
-0.6932219267,
-0.834923923,
-0.3582456112,
-0.4685254395,
-0.8181229234,
-0.8441607952,
0.2835882902,
0.3840908706,
0.8977244496,
-0.4369345605,
0.012032073,
0.0387515277,
-0.2356416583,
-0.4218655229,
-0.1479442716,
0.5147262216,
-0.2359910607,
-0.2190342844,
0.3794308901,
0.9399616122,
0.1432521492,
0.1534334123,
-0.2173353285,
0.0716077834,
0.3054841757,
0.484013319,
0.5964936614,
-0.4335598052,
-0.5726175308,
-0.4085129201,
-0.4502799809,
0.6515792608,
1.0100001097,
-0.9350780845,
1.0299005508,
0.2663119733,
0.5100411773,
0.3734067082,
-0.2182389945,
0.234314546,
-1.0278578997,
0.1027262583,
0.305979073,
0.1789966673,
0.5242609978,
-0.5472459793,
0.3983941972,
0.0675920844,
-0.3862612247,
-0.8381215334,
0.3484895229,
-1.3370089531,
-0.2416214794,
0.5805268288,
-0.1612568349,
0.4394942224,
-0.4056646526,
-0.2801181674,
0.1750728935,
-0.3189048171,
0.8590185642,
-0.0083826194,
-0.7214992046,
0.1454516053,
0.0656731501,
0.5890631676,
0.6020026207,
-0.7802705765,
-0.232185632,
0.3578142226,
0.4331485033,
0.202884391,
1.2117109299,
-0.4692118168,
0.7508707643,
0.2124089748,
0.0817393959,
-0.3236506879,
-0.2228988707,
0.0851231143,
0.0163027868,
0.1928069741,
-0.1649351716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12842v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12842v2
|
PromptKD: Distilling Student-Friendly Knowledge for Generative Language Models via Prompt Tuning
| 2024-02-20T09:10:08 | 2024-06-24T05:40:38 |
Gyeongman Kim, Doohyuk Jang, Eunho Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have raised concerns
about inference costs, increasing the need for research into model compression.
While knowledge distillation (KD) is a prominent method for this, research on
KD for generative language models like LLMs is relatively sparse, and the
approach of distilling student-friendly knowledge, which has shown promising
performance in KD for classification models, remains unexplored in generative
language models. To explore this approach, we propose PromptKD, a simple yet
effective method that utilizes prompt tuning - for the first time in KD - to
enable generative language models to transfer student-friendly knowledge.
Unlike previous works in classification that require fine-tuning the entire
teacher model for extracting student-friendly knowledge, PromptKD achieves
similar effects by adding a small number of prompt tokens and tuning only the
prompt with student guidance. Extensive experiments on instruction-following
datasets show that PromptKD achieves state-of-the-art performance while adding
only 0.0007% of the teacher's parameters as prompts. Further analysis suggests
that distilling student-friendly knowledge alleviates exposure bias effectively
throughout the entire training process, leading to performance enhancements.
|
[
-0.3488978744,
-0.7401683331,
0.5224627256,
0.2257123291,
-0.4544427395,
0.1060719192,
-0.4022140205,
0.2399297208,
-0.3465198278,
0.3504748642,
-0.6209742427,
-0.5860074162,
-0.3822910488,
0.0816598684,
-0.1765467077,
1.038849473,
0.3996741176,
0.2166043818,
-0.438105762,
0.1549672633,
-0.6908115149,
-0.2491616756,
-0.9384102821,
-0.2551106513,
0.6641263962,
0.7628811002,
0.4235050976,
0.8281309009,
-0.0386517681,
0.2247144729,
-0.357938081,
-0.0810337737,
-0.2795468569,
0.5120888352,
-0.0636195093,
-0.6294152737,
-0.0609658621,
0.1193781868,
0.3944781125,
0.8903968334,
-0.2518091202,
0.0160084981,
0.4243311584,
0.6528308392,
-0.4745041728,
0.2509531975,
-0.5870264173,
-0.1110671386,
-0.2790950239,
-0.1971134692,
-0.6352436543,
-0.6450237632,
0.1032043546,
-0.7921116352,
0.5387506485,
-0.037475843,
0.384105444,
0.56938833,
-0.4102747142,
-0.371715039,
-0.3984442055,
0.6022877097,
-0.5667576194,
0.3721286952,
0.4456711411,
0.5240143538,
-0.1904769689,
-0.632017374,
-0.7086957097,
-0.0881161392,
0.0020385222,
0.0173484702,
0.101002343,
0.3184941113,
0.5864779353,
0.3107504547,
-0.3256523013,
0.2558189034,
-0.0866306797,
-0.1613368988,
0.2570668161,
0.0797789395,
0.3083328307,
-0.3829813898,
-0.3215818107,
-0.3141682446,
-0.5896171331,
0.31577003,
0.3890113533,
0.6291635633,
-0.0395218618,
0.3286195397,
-0.4585089684,
0.8666554689,
0.2275631577,
-0.3073953986,
-0.1243105829,
-0.2975746393,
0.084881179,
0.1420162171,
0.5415258408,
0.4132969379,
0.2969910502,
-0.1492869109,
-0.085744597,
0.178826645,
-0.0228915326,
-1.0245763063,
-0.7650847435,
-0.3145629764,
-0.2368229479,
-0.5159311295,
-0.4228579104,
-0.9690671563,
-0.5540329814,
-0.5733578801,
0.3047372699,
-0.4351734221,
-0.2281676531,
-0.0314858742,
-0.1941985488,
0.1267952621,
0.4453858435,
-1.0820487738,
-0.0804605484,
0.5523461699,
0.8035869598,
-0.0608029328,
-0.1278032064,
-0.621473074,
-0.1491091996,
-0.2546018362,
0.6746380329,
-0.6144907475,
-0.6804947257,
-0.106334731,
-0.0740091354,
0.1427538544,
-0.5485953093,
0.6649773717,
-0.6365969181,
0.1381056607,
-0.5150441527,
-0.7351999879,
0.0522921979,
-0.073191613,
-0.4964146912,
1.1674150229,
0.3784188628,
-0.6319061518,
0.7286720276,
-0.3331767619,
-0.5521062016,
0.3286805749,
0.0056198235,
-0.2139662057,
0.1499221772,
0.3200371861,
0.4932104051,
-0.1380621791,
0.3702968359,
-0.259924382,
0.0497217178,
-0.0143866921,
-0.4971016049,
0.8937654495,
0.5617701411,
0.1955176443,
0.0406120121,
-0.9037391543,
-0.0338409916,
-0.1777194738,
-0.4092940986,
-0.8056100011,
-0.4100190997,
-0.1463405341,
0.1302274466,
0.1461199075,
-0.3919707835,
0.6664776206,
-0.2831076086,
0.1534745097,
1.0388879776,
0.0734304786,
0.6990917921,
-0.0445972569,
0.7593128681,
0.0012935189,
0.0771287456,
-0.5152732134,
-0.4694761038,
-0.7814348936,
-0.2971558273,
0.3817462325,
0.197965458,
-1.21232903,
0.2948971987,
0.0011007487,
-0.4566037655,
-0.8078867197,
0.3625798225,
0.0942833945,
1.125977397,
0.2361861318,
0.1594584286,
-0.2894049287,
-0.5258979797,
-0.2337978333,
-0.2082361281,
-0.1593716741,
0.2247280329,
-0.1909935027,
0.2644382417,
1.1967300177,
-0.8012706637,
0.0041249222,
-0.2762363553,
0.2513214946,
0.1941185743,
0.5619452596,
0.6111328006,
-0.5116252899,
-0.9373699427,
-0.2048882991,
-0.4567308724,
-0.52835536,
-0.0734038725,
-0.2849150598,
-0.0555464327,
0.6328750849,
-0.5785894394,
0.0405999944,
0.1117441058,
-0.6186309457,
0.5129321814,
-0.2242397219,
0.1364158541,
-1.2335116863,
-0.1057004854,
-0.1013213694,
-0.3155472279,
-0.6172245741,
-0.0566924885,
0.2213073224,
-0.2114659548,
-0.2267614007,
0.615714848,
-0.2387618124,
0.3937858343,
-0.4952655137,
0.0021543331,
0.0612323135,
0.3911759257,
-0.0248211771,
0.8803132176,
0.9118223786,
-0.930947125,
0.5090205073,
0.3242759109,
-0.5772890449,
0.7948082089,
-0.5439454317,
0.1847982109,
-0.2458146811,
-0.056237001,
-0.9569728971,
-0.097654514,
0.1524756402,
-0.3753443956,
0.4790503383,
-0.6036356688,
-0.3325769305,
-0.2273823619,
0.0119030904,
0.4256158471,
0.8725000024,
-0.9761614203,
0.334314853,
-0.0948361829,
-0.4683804512,
-0.2211627066,
-0.0635957345,
-0.0837981775,
-0.445645988,
-0.4343961477,
0.1122509092,
-0.3351120651,
0.0530648082,
-0.0332095064,
-0.1217990518,
0.1008915305,
0.4735800922,
0.0032123565,
0.3668941855,
-0.0911925584,
0.3534699082,
0.3679097593,
-0.2939133644,
0.0302410163,
-0.3098063469,
0.5242910981,
0.4436898828,
-0.1161398143,
-0.442293644,
0.0771640986,
0.4376345575,
0.0765600428,
0.653175354,
0.4235369861,
-0.1298496872,
-0.6610028744,
-0.4287905097,
-0.5925699472,
-0.5425390005,
0.2722017765,
-0.5031712651,
-0.8859750628,
0.2501322329,
-0.4818641245,
-0.1419352442,
0.2242388874,
0.3040747046,
-0.1779356748,
1.0985094309,
0.8497445583,
-0.1080766544,
0.7013952732,
0.1308072954,
0.0075968849,
-0.620988369,
-0.4051928222,
-0.9151529074,
-0.1494485736,
-0.4131499827,
-0.1960213333,
0.3518986702,
0.6201985478,
-0.0389914364,
0.0626735911,
-0.3760977685,
0.7543655634,
0.690274775,
-0.0216749329,
0.3263719678,
-0.0127795683,
-0.1598080099,
-0.0992198735,
-0.846517086,
-0.3800275624,
1.0187449455,
0.0142187634,
0.8940036893,
-0.1355236918,
0.61999017,
0.2145466954,
0.2204991728,
-0.7875514627,
0.5674671531,
-0.1599808037,
-0.193278268,
-0.3180153668,
-0.6972427368,
-0.6855576634,
-0.0529417247,
-0.0271386635,
-0.3337036073,
0.0585472248,
0.390840441,
-0.4829485416,
0.0023494079,
-0.9822363257,
0.9278768897,
0.0375054255,
-0.1464230865,
-0.0382799059,
-0.5411211848,
0.2726223767,
-0.0379729345,
0.0115688518,
-0.1079747528,
0.2627633512,
0.76927948,
-0.5493713617,
0.7967300415,
-0.6511591673,
-0.2844395936,
0.2075905502,
0.162025705,
0.6593333483,
0.2414314449,
0.0784505382,
-0.3202301562,
-0.0007275165,
-0.3713551462,
-0.9839938283,
0.8118723035,
-0.6884531379,
-0.7347010374,
-0.0781227648,
-0.5006787181,
-0.3204726279,
0.2076486647,
0.2703530192,
0.3049091697,
0.0858607888,
0.0312069673,
1.0319886208,
-0.2111869901,
0.4551139176,
0.7456644177,
-0.375300765,
-0.1412429214,
1.098882556,
-0.0219911672,
0.369941771,
0.0310819596,
0.4600360692,
-0.6484713554,
-0.3298458159,
-0.6552907228,
-0.1007792577,
-0.790861249,
-0.3582919538,
-0.5989899039,
0.0875900164,
-0.6135412455,
-0.168591857,
-0.3390696049,
-0.5310727358,
-0.6690874696,
-0.2300005853,
0.7474542856,
0.4231424332,
0.0840228796,
0.5459846258,
-0.5287179351,
0.353635937,
0.5816712379,
0.531067431,
0.0498194695,
-0.7653090954,
-0.1147857532,
-0.1004937887,
-0.1661016792,
-0.7063060403,
0.2353366017,
0.4657315314,
0.4159266949,
0.6631386876,
0.6326945424,
0.5033763647,
-0.3311813176,
0.7736517191,
0.2744066715,
-0.7640842795,
0.8243359327,
-0.0938213021,
0.4867014885,
0.6713083982,
0.3471139371,
-0.8828466535,
-0.3109573424,
-0.2555522919,
-0.7674317956,
1.0316010714,
-0.3192144632,
0.276091516,
-0.0997552946,
0.5413559675,
0.5089100003,
0.1119481027,
-0.3526865542,
-0.4210551679,
-0.3550946712,
-0.5632326603,
-0.2352637798,
-0.3107441664,
0.1685900539,
-0.3682808578,
0.7880071402,
-0.2484808117,
-0.4093177915,
-0.1943551153,
-0.090211615,
0.089609459,
0.4165455103,
0.1816987246,
0.151364997,
0.1053937376,
0.4897681773,
0.0064183287,
-0.4509223402,
0.4292370677,
0.0197004452,
-0.6477568746,
-0.078278169,
-0.0153817572,
0.9114096761,
0.1933600754,
-0.348020643,
0.3289863765,
-0.183260113,
0.1308677495,
0.2499851882,
0.4591625035,
0.0641555786,
0.2127637267,
0.2310285866,
0.1246480644,
0.0470689535,
-0.0965862274,
0.1320984513,
0.2661985755,
-0.2193802297,
-0.469154954,
0.6940771341,
0.4091697335,
-0.1996971518,
0.8760913014,
-0.2968215048,
-0.4290662706,
0.4100065529,
0.5868879557,
0.9205043912,
-0.451143831,
0.451050967,
0.608484745,
-0.0774483755,
-0.1414942592,
0.1531750858,
-0.4519177377,
-0.649535358,
-0.3598482907,
-0.9193472862,
-0.0164644979,
0.0252545644,
-0.8426652551,
0.3838492632,
-0.3231379688,
-0.0052554891,
-0.0071997815,
-0.1074014828,
-0.6431298256,
-0.0228911415,
-0.1306196898,
1.0218678713,
-0.9759431481,
1.009572506,
0.5452036262,
-0.1646924317,
-0.9046231508,
-0.214176327,
-0.2463218868,
-0.559157908,
0.6645738482,
-0.0249715913,
0.2409904599,
0.5667892098,
-0.6438385844,
-0.3598176241,
0.8797813654,
0.6235942841,
-0.8087255955,
0.0543250032,
0.1651942581,
0.2414141595,
0.0405288562,
0.0600249842,
0.6236413717,
0.33011657,
0.4474322498,
-0.447260499,
0.0290770028,
-0.2007543892,
0.1188913658,
0.0404302776,
-0.4436569512,
0.6847526431,
-0.3260847628,
-0.5124216676,
0.0259478148,
0.7053471208,
-0.0064707273,
0.4285555184,
0.5903515816,
0.6778745651,
1.0430952311,
-0.2606517971,
0.7617079616,
-0.5216297507,
0.2651999593,
0.9950616956,
-0.0828394815,
0.2782632411,
0.587588191,
-0.3151367605,
0.1002548337,
0.6578200459,
0.10085807,
0.9003637433,
0.087363489,
-0.7296031713,
-0.5672861338,
-0.4326880574,
-0.4392103553,
0.0714199245,
-0.0510625578,
-0.0371575579,
-0.3470484614,
0.4022435248,
-0.1486174762,
0.2086711079,
-0.4247160256,
1.1318967342,
0.0068746689,
-0.8221620321,
0.4217861593,
-0.1009378284,
0.7181352973,
-0.5344164968,
-0.0798114538,
-0.6111630201,
-0.1203570291,
0.0760092735,
-0.5163350105,
-0.0838472396,
0.1879129857,
-0.4532319605,
-0.4788644016,
0.6747732759,
-0.8448740244,
-0.4476389587,
-0.1835286021,
0.3149946928,
-0.0614946038,
0.0194119085,
-0.1746642143,
-0.2087197006,
0.1310290098,
-0.0424097329,
0.4084655344,
0.7971280813,
0.3180449903,
0.7809589505,
0.7010031343,
0.1522268057,
0.1982031912,
0.2715165615,
1.0761650801,
-0.5114693642,
-0.6476169825,
-0.8867540956,
0.3603906333,
0.1347396225,
-0.3658856452,
0.9239859581,
0.3687931299,
0.9295585752,
-0.2680281103,
0.9133043289,
0.04755193,
0.5705122352,
-0.7387399077,
0.8892425895,
-0.2411517948,
0.3372863829,
-0.1757718027,
-0.7828977704,
0.1584827155,
0.421790868,
-0.0014183192,
-0.0387958735,
0.1690366119,
0.7688852549,
0.1500557363,
0.1624656469,
0.4217822254,
0.184528634,
0.4048080146,
0.2954657674,
1.0571700335,
0.06928958,
0.3926836252,
-0.5824804902,
-0.2910150588,
-0.0696374625,
-0.8874800205,
-0.8597313762,
-0.6641087532,
-0.5849350095,
-0.0708075985,
-0.0616021231,
0.8663150668,
0.5165860057,
-0.6577192545,
0.2921791077,
-0.3508867323,
0.313669771,
-0.0945197493,
-0.2833435833,
0.3980286121,
-0.8806867599,
-0.8134302497,
0.4112279415,
-0.3017049432,
0.2182220221,
-0.1406829208,
-0.2136301547,
0.3372112513,
-0.2369297594,
0.4962179363,
0.0992522761,
-0.4669080675,
-0.1915264577,
0.1147014275,
-0.0291510839,
-0.252504766,
0.9108809829,
-1.021766901,
0.8349040747,
0.3629718423,
0.6173094511,
0.210972175,
0.1079493463,
0.4841244221,
-1.180077076,
0.0638072342,
0.103116408,
-0.0267156847,
0.2646364868,
-0.4033104777,
0.0915227458,
0.3755140305,
-0.5069393516,
-0.9056982994,
0.1710395366,
-0.8265029192,
-0.2410918623,
1.0308088064,
-0.2456378192,
0.1690949053,
-0.0874887183,
-0.4446274042,
0.5873438716,
-0.5435256958,
0.9592689276,
0.729519248,
0.3066163063,
-0.3615854084,
-0.374415338,
1.0146507025,
0.3144515157,
-0.5847230554,
0.4001349211,
0.6169375777,
0.3580518663,
-0.3340015411,
0.3693905771,
0.3717814684,
0.1748902649,
-0.0587661937,
0.0538948588,
-0.3418685198,
-0.4695813954,
-0.4505626857,
0.1397194564,
0.3749023378,
-0.1679971218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12840v1
|
ArabicMMLU: Assessing Massive Multitask Language Understanding in Arabic
| 2024-02-20T09:07:41 | 2024-02-20T09:07:41 |
Fajri Koto, Haonan Li, Sara Shatnawi, Jad Doughman, Abdelrahman Boda Sadallah, Aisha Alraeesi, Khalid Almubarak, Zaid Alyafeai, Neha Sengupta, Shady Shehata, Nizar Habash, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The focus of language model evaluation has transitioned towards reasoning and
knowledge-intensive tasks, driven by advancements in pretraining large models.
While state-of-the-art models are partially trained on large Arabic texts,
evaluating their performance in Arabic remains challenging due to the limited
availability of relevant datasets. To bridge this gap, we present ArabicMMLU,
the first multi-task language understanding benchmark for Arabic language,
sourced from school exams across diverse educational levels in different
countries spanning North Africa, the Levant, and the Gulf regions. Our data
comprises 40 tasks and 14,575 multiple-choice questions in Modern Standard
Arabic (MSA), and is carefully constructed by collaborating with native
speakers in the region. Our comprehensive evaluations of 35 models reveal
substantial room for improvement, particularly among the best open-source
models. Notably, BLOOMZ, mT0, LLama2, and Falcon struggle to achieve a score of
50%, while even the top-performing Arabic-centric model only achieves a score
of 62.3%.
|
[
-0.4875730574,
-0.6488085389,
0.5194092989,
0.2447156906,
-0.1872985512,
0.2057090849,
-0.207482785,
-0.3321365416,
-0.2794272304,
0.2303403169,
-0.6072673202,
-0.6855965257,
-1.0274518728,
0.0674544349,
-0.3065854907,
1.0445818901,
-0.387953043,
-0.0041160835,
-0.1393686831,
-0.6341346502,
-0.3570123017,
-0.441876322,
-0.5052557588,
-0.3807207644,
0.5929768682,
0.5503927469,
0.7429982424,
0.3122072518,
0.2152981162,
0.2056479156,
0.0121058188,
0.2807917297,
-0.3659637868,
-0.1124646887,
0.0208519977,
-0.1808010638,
-0.3528425395,
0.035793785,
0.5742059946,
0.7490165234,
-0.1621029824,
0.5702034831,
-0.0277428292,
0.902651608,
-1.0769652128,
0.2869937718,
-0.4774079621,
-0.0508100577,
-0.3600376844,
0.2869238257,
-0.2906919718,
-0.0512266569,
-0.0315774903,
-0.3783126771,
-0.2365909368,
-0.2862338722,
0.5926818848,
0.0882835388,
-0.8088409901,
-0.3848394454,
-0.4349761307,
0.8669400215,
-0.5192069411,
0.5629906654,
0.6861264706,
0.5367522836,
0.0003913787,
-0.4045409262,
-0.4341579974,
-0.3516452909,
0.1659919769,
0.1883219332,
-0.0984501317,
-0.0680944175,
0.0013751847,
0.3145265877,
-0.8231609464,
-0.1859364808,
-0.1041254252,
-0.181679979,
0.4703573883,
0.116336979,
0.2550358772,
0.2044564635,
-0.1539956927,
-0.0224593058,
-0.6950775981,
0.2695239484,
0.3972261548,
0.1162651107,
-0.2202141732,
0.5082044601,
-0.2657555938,
0.8647659421,
-0.5500627756,
-0.2585602701,
0.2654714882,
-0.5680200458,
-0.2546162307,
-0.1529563367,
0.5551211834,
0.120227389,
0.2924605012,
-0.0526095033,
-0.2348669171,
0.1643500775,
0.2482540458,
-0.9302966595,
-0.2006862909,
0.3660472035,
-0.2241238058,
0.2523820102,
-0.2275519818,
-0.3140856624,
-0.3103438914,
-0.2489576489,
0.364025861,
-0.3555979133,
-0.3596127033,
0.2057837844,
0.2808287442,
-0.0158359352,
0.3937720954,
-0.6120522022,
0.1540786624,
0.587883234,
0.9342235327,
-0.0003034833,
-0.6124991775,
-0.4055854976,
-0.1083265916,
-0.2946918011,
0.6096014977,
-0.7311714292,
-0.2852867246,
0.0654442683,
-0.3186586499,
-0.440502435,
-0.5612775683,
0.7662419677,
-0.6019358039,
-0.2912684977,
-0.2703276575,
-0.3488755524,
-0.6498728395,
0.4234559834,
-0.6094326377,
0.9968913794,
0.298108995,
-0.5322360396,
0.2825909853,
-0.7940520048,
-0.3596367836,
-0.1017361209,
0.0252435692,
-0.1420728415,
-0.0372252204,
0.3869879246,
0.2809447348,
-0.2983789146,
0.2572544217,
-0.132570833,
-0.2792934179,
0.2285044193,
-0.4292138219,
0.5933872461,
0.49224177,
-0.2471740842,
0.3246906698,
-0.59066993,
0.1784293354,
0.0060425131,
-0.2838970125,
-0.2858612239,
-0.2440647781,
0.4805922806,
0.6135591269,
0.3140583336,
-0.4654665589,
0.1027356386,
-0.2298751622,
0.2089603692,
0.3988673687,
-0.5130227208,
0.0950291082,
-0.4037717879,
0.6757948995,
0.2071638703,
0.0335054025,
-0.2651780546,
-0.6083590984,
-0.6722726822,
-0.3028368354,
0.2902271748,
0.337305367,
-0.4633055627,
0.0378610156,
-0.0930164754,
-0.909934938,
-0.8764585257,
0.4587797821,
0.5244389176,
0.0731640384,
0.27657938,
-0.3019254506,
-0.1589539796,
-0.9167969227,
-0.3495061994,
0.0778766945,
0.150035426,
0.4142055809,
0.7807575464,
-0.3703496754,
0.375900209,
-0.3174292147,
-0.3630008101,
-0.438681215,
0.458752811,
0.321026504,
0.2744072378,
0.6630254388,
-0.5593132377,
-0.5577379465,
0.1231554076,
-0.5224168897,
0.0627545565,
0.085383743,
-0.1301400065,
0.0767234489,
0.1569136977,
-0.7401947379,
0.3153566718,
0.9502546191,
-0.5236896873,
0.8558340669,
-0.1045693681,
0.3642610312,
-0.7425386906,
0.4142674208,
-0.0944848806,
-0.1875095665,
-0.8028944731,
0.473056823,
0.3189938068,
-0.0917485058,
-0.5495420694,
0.7012323141,
-0.4281858802,
-0.0915030614,
-0.4181861281,
0.1601125449,
-0.1467666626,
0.4395022392,
-0.3403396308,
1.1623187065,
0.5124248266,
-0.442388624,
0.0414932482,
0.0555035807,
-0.9553471804,
0.209133774,
-0.4722496271,
0.4114777446,
-0.1776957065,
0.168994233,
-1.1436722279,
0.0428652912,
0.0361717641,
-0.1837753505,
-0.0304876082,
-0.034107402,
-0.5150082111,
-0.1730157882,
0.0678517744,
0.7948433161,
-0.011198136,
-0.3875598609,
0.7711997628,
0.3927660286,
-0.2218423337,
-1.083440423,
-0.1470861286,
0.1109863445,
0.109696582,
-0.580693543,
0.0052449279,
-0.2191121727,
-0.3914334476,
-0.2416253537,
-0.2924820781,
-0.2841304541,
0.4700367451,
0.4001557231,
-0.0323215574,
-0.3280523121,
0.0320344046,
0.0818221718,
0.0639777556,
0.1230969355,
-0.0378435031,
0.7402223349,
-0.2387010604,
-0.5310203433,
-0.3018561304,
0.2753812075,
1.0639208555,
-0.7035368681,
0.976115942,
0.7023231983,
-0.4112206399,
-0.0071034441,
-0.3406206667,
0.1163836792,
-0.3782690763,
0.7276990414,
-0.7863118649,
-0.7193282843,
0.4760175347,
0.0334722772,
0.523625195,
0.4829576015,
0.7137625217,
0.1662635356,
1.2071965933,
0.4418593943,
-0.4412710071,
-0.0836438462,
-0.0684795156,
0.0077313511,
-0.5285865068,
-0.1259978712,
-0.5472892523,
-0.3101605177,
0.0551756136,
-0.5172420144,
0.3436497152,
0.0532483384,
-0.1359657645,
0.1711883396,
0.2584836483,
0.4447679222,
0.2323079705,
-0.0957822651,
0.3028978109,
-0.2191837579,
-0.3038664758,
0.1765486747,
-0.4969313741,
-0.5804565549,
1.2776838541,
0.26301983,
0.3329132497,
0.5106061101,
0.3451677263,
0.2655233145,
0.6062527299,
-0.839361608,
0.263304323,
-0.0447439514,
-0.7206292152,
-0.211811766,
-0.3562215865,
-1.0065870285,
0.6964927912,
0.0669719204,
-0.6315112114,
-0.5306882262,
-0.0863035619,
-0.338044256,
0.0942220762,
-0.6703756452,
1.2214452028,
-0.1091949195,
-0.0938185826,
-0.7170047164,
-0.293105334,
0.6837168932,
-0.3467328548,
0.6009413004,
-0.4872168303,
-0.0080708275,
0.9269485474,
-0.2478922457,
0.3087208271,
-0.2165071815,
-0.1639114916,
0.2148158401,
0.1557489038,
0.2040971667,
-0.0722889304,
-0.1416051984,
0.2080456465,
0.253910929,
-0.7483060956,
-0.5786448121,
0.7492004037,
-1.0169614553,
-0.4273723662,
-0.4385429919,
-1.0878590345,
-0.3430052102,
0.0609684549,
-0.2573616207,
0.4875986874,
-0.2358327806,
-0.0802422911,
-0.041040998,
0.0026523983,
0.3120580316,
0.7626999021,
-0.4583661854,
-0.1067806035,
0.806543231,
0.0914955661,
0.1094109118,
0.035925366,
0.0735530183,
-0.411932826,
-0.6607022285,
-0.928958118,
0.3093341291,
-0.8093169332,
0.0436184071,
-0.7735668421,
-0.1119633541,
-0.165617317,
0.1312805265,
-0.4718708992,
-0.0536889657,
-0.0078115663,
-0.0058810199,
0.0657223687,
1.0094275475,
0.2492685616,
0.3562395871,
-1.0596643686,
0.168833375,
0.1726849377,
0.2028877139,
0.3007379472,
-0.752436161,
-0.559494257,
0.0267921239,
-0.33795771,
-0.8157464266,
0.410135299,
0.4220224023,
0.4697445631,
0.6400805712,
-0.1090070307,
0.7983105183,
-0.559607327,
0.5717571378,
-0.0661014989,
-1.0217417479,
0.2092102766,
-0.063114211,
0.9025269151,
0.7252597213,
0.6812070608,
-0.8166065812,
-0.4547701478,
-0.1876988262,
-0.5783060789,
0.5985460877,
0.3062883019,
0.0866365582,
0.3496818841,
0.1358426809,
0.4857734442,
0.2163890749,
-0.360208571,
-0.7088825107,
-0.025141485,
-0.3808361292,
-0.5706120133,
-0.3082150817,
-0.158636719,
-0.27515468,
0.6031478047,
-0.1793281883,
-0.0872930586,
-0.3806630969,
-0.641741097,
0.0511913784,
0.4302494526,
0.9905021787,
1.2685211897,
-0.155203715,
0.3031760752,
0.1006643474,
-0.8592483997,
0.2618019879,
0.3137789369,
0.1056897193,
0.0312641375,
0.3012074828,
0.5683856606,
0.2420756072,
-1.0651249886,
0.3987444937,
-0.18971093,
-0.1943764091,
-0.1395168304,
-0.0298055522,
0.2033871114,
0.065492101,
0.4956934154,
0.0365288556,
0.0635704622,
-0.5530822873,
0.2695197165,
0.3783647716,
-0.3981424868,
-0.4273338616,
0.4266480207,
-0.0042966017,
-0.018943578,
0.4893224537,
-0.2323034257,
-0.5702474117,
0.6566492319,
0.3838259578,
0.432495594,
-0.3766702712,
0.2924838364,
0.5967808962,
0.4467439353,
0.1659969687,
0.6685757637,
-0.2238052785,
-0.8187614083,
-0.5811980963,
-0.6227120757,
-0.5886597037,
0.4554716945,
-0.4765894711,
-0.1931567639,
-0.3563844562,
-0.0749956295,
0.0946089178,
0.245047614,
-0.800519228,
0.2873343229,
0.073605068,
1.0121092796,
-0.9874240756,
1.1574935913,
0.8494305611,
-0.203616187,
-0.4866171181,
-0.2664488554,
0.232161954,
-0.9799996018,
0.6665110588,
0.6662424803,
-0.2218986601,
-0.0187551808,
-0.0617212802,
-0.954215467,
0.6862084866,
0.2575847208,
-0.4938116372,
0.3028220832,
0.153915599,
0.1669348478,
-0.2451348603,
0.8582409024,
0.8246238828,
0.5556579828,
-0.188372314,
-0.9039744139,
-0.1735696346,
-0.4069862366,
-0.5855795741,
0.2707502246,
-0.4488794506,
0.8543671966,
-0.2581203282,
-0.3653322756,
0.1488252878,
0.7569413185,
0.3805088103,
0.4282318652,
0.6324471831,
0.659414649,
0.772775054,
-0.0261059534,
0.8505836725,
-0.5390100479,
0.191466704,
1.1297305822,
-0.3083558083,
1.0014169216,
0.3008229136,
-0.4324322641,
0.3578378856,
0.5590722561,
0.4758790135,
0.3380596042,
0.1891758293,
-0.4906913042,
-0.3947492838,
-0.3784318268,
-0.3757757843,
0.7797008753,
0.5134088993,
-0.0112342816,
-0.4700053036,
0.1374165118,
0.1768546551,
0.0330107585,
-0.3616809547,
0.3014726341,
0.1147736087,
-0.6737855673,
0.7674615383,
0.2448453754,
0.4577951729,
-0.6327319741,
0.0320098251,
-0.2846391499,
0.1383870393,
0.0017650791,
-0.744615376,
0.2803992927,
0.1468651146,
0.0079986639,
0.0820363164,
0.3393602073,
-0.5929407477,
-0.5124370456,
0.3827396631,
0.7538366318,
0.4494999647,
-0.4518937469,
-0.79629004,
0.1281293482,
-0.2834910452,
-0.0156826321,
0.4505962431,
0.0306162797,
0.2532807589,
0.7532553673,
0.6821107268,
-0.1400733888,
0.0166089516,
0.2777235806,
0.5563718677,
-0.4812607765,
-0.3137744069,
-0.8131782413,
0.296990037,
0.3218843639,
-0.6720432639,
0.9170321822,
0.6202679276,
0.858802855,
-0.0907734185,
0.703615129,
0.3645801246,
0.2026864141,
-0.4228287339,
1.1729807854,
-0.8246328831,
-0.3403419554,
-0.067271471,
-0.9135800004,
-0.0640573055,
0.4206679463,
-0.249017179,
0.0482968278,
0.7388238311,
0.7162877321,
-0.0418920517,
0.1475759745,
0.6898602843,
0.0280898307,
0.0883773342,
0.9466161728,
0.918556869,
-0.4841002822,
0.4548267424,
-0.2349391729,
-0.149736762,
-0.16040425,
-0.4796324372,
-1.0153061152,
-0.6733035445,
-0.2583651841,
-0.0408718847,
0.0238355603,
1.0025043488,
0.6657208204,
-1.063847661,
-0.6058835387,
0.3183598518,
0.1601921022,
-0.5643354654,
-0.0704320967,
0.4903930128,
-0.2689844966,
-0.6740631461,
0.6752070785,
0.1059443206,
-0.257204771,
-0.2319829464,
-0.1886642724,
-0.509224236,
-0.0630092844,
0.7662274837,
0.2294969112,
-0.8308677077,
-0.0217051636,
-0.1203889027,
-0.3132094145,
-0.0031367049,
0.6457356811,
-0.5611156821,
0.5054394007,
0.1246203035,
0.8805769682,
0.4331763387,
-0.26437819,
0.3241845369,
-0.3123596311,
0.0381709747,
-0.1001635119,
0.447435081,
0.2515091598,
0.1075317487,
0.3245909214,
-0.108119458,
-0.4778235555,
-0.5728641748,
0.2162111551,
-0.6936811209,
-0.2123993039,
0.9873030782,
-0.4573152065,
-0.0939398706,
-0.4455338418,
-0.2578531206,
0.2030239701,
-0.329537034,
0.7016189098,
1.0395973921,
0.2085424364,
-0.2748393416,
-0.9097850919,
0.2580415905,
0.8894520402,
-0.8596096635,
0.0237914734,
0.3058454394,
0.0682178214,
-0.0124312155,
0.5299330354,
0.2379065752,
0.5244695544,
-0.118033506,
-0.0778256208,
-0.0496725291,
-0.5955227017,
-0.4124224782,
0.3498570919,
0.4049025476,
-0.2586349547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12835v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12835v2
|
PANDA: Preference Adaptation for Enhancing Domain-Specific Abilities of LLMs
| 2024-02-20T09:02:55 | 2024-06-18T03:08:37 |
An Liu, Zonghan Yang, Zhenhe Zhang, Qingyuan Hu, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable
capabilities across various natural language tasks, they often fall short of
the performance achieved by domain-specific state-of-the-art models. One
potential approach to enhance domain-specific capabilities of LLMs involves
fine-tuning them using corresponding datasets. However, this method can be both
resource and time-intensive, and not applicable to closed-source commercial
LLMs. In this paper, we propose Preference Adaptation for Enhancing
Domain-specific Abilities of LLMs (PANDA), a method designed to augment the
domain-specific capabilities of LLMs by leveraging insights from the response
preference of expert models without requiring fine-tuning. Our experimental
results reveal that PANDA significantly enhances the domain-specific ability of
LLMs on text classification and interactive decision tasks. Moreover, LLM with
PANDA even outperforms the expert model that being learned on 4 tasks of
ScienceWorld. This finding highlights the potential of exploring tuning-free
approaches to achieve weak-to-strong generalization.
|
[
-0.3181169331,
-0.735117197,
0.2966303229,
0.4180537462,
-0.3956876993,
0.1166958511,
-0.6483773589,
-0.2839055061,
0.2522698939,
0.7123069763,
-0.4460184276,
-0.3866590559,
-0.6689206362,
0.3267787993,
0.0810131207,
1.320135951,
-0.117367439,
-0.1298249215,
-0.5832507014,
0.0176991411,
-0.4061121345,
-0.5293246508,
-0.5778241754,
-0.1838578582,
0.3762225807,
0.4273692667,
0.6268849969,
0.5170378685,
0.6607276201,
0.2312910408,
-0.1067436635,
0.4924746752,
-0.6164671183,
0.1603139639,
-0.571667552,
-0.8105527759,
-0.9381437898,
-0.1234226897,
0.4888490736,
0.6912947297,
0.0434103981,
0.1028115824,
0.3728245199,
0.8633533716,
-0.5232415795,
0.4726892412,
-0.9039083719,
0.0189637411,
-0.0474737696,
-0.6270181537,
-0.3115192354,
-0.1741727144,
0.3986903429,
-1.148216486,
0.3943579495,
0.1839001179,
0.5147259235,
0.5876895189,
-0.240476355,
0.0519858673,
-0.5130890012,
0.903488338,
-0.6108269095,
0.1504231542,
0.4842651784,
0.1140342429,
-0.3614329398,
-0.2418017238,
-0.4973903,
-0.2074404955,
0.0995816812,
0.0746044293,
0.0071478444,
0.0984379053,
0.2153567523,
0.2214792669,
-0.3634987473,
0.2576245666,
0.0133472336,
0.008002446,
0.5517036319,
0.238772437,
0.0320942029,
-0.1839260906,
-0.0604788437,
-0.0067420113,
-0.4777009487,
0.3060445189,
0.1523412168,
0.5959035158,
-0.0807043239,
0.6038569808,
-0.4330210388,
0.7623240352,
0.3984814882,
-0.1997873783,
0.2304747999,
-0.2608949542,
-0.2501655221,
-0.1611406654,
0.3635510504,
0.4200282395,
0.3978089392,
-0.2026144862,
-0.034954153,
-0.0796311945,
0.2034621835,
-0.8898271918,
-0.374398917,
0.1715831012,
-0.4690426588,
-0.2408905178,
-0.4301945865,
-0.7258905768,
-0.6602429152,
-0.4766145051,
0.2115775794,
-0.2361649126,
-0.4591608644,
0.3800645471,
-0.1435499638,
-0.0598185062,
0.6110136509,
-1.2927939892,
0.3749054372,
0.7158161998,
0.7274551988,
-0.8316091895,
-0.3100628555,
-0.683470726,
0.2940594256,
-0.3059849739,
1.1241308451,
-0.916261673,
-0.5122507215,
-0.2144388556,
0.1648002863,
-0.169092387,
-0.793864429,
0.6389403343,
-0.6524983644,
-0.1884327978,
-0.2639834285,
-0.4802502692,
-0.1071313992,
-0.0237963572,
-0.5642222166,
0.8346745372,
0.3061246276,
-0.6715680957,
0.6608729362,
-0.9495835304,
-0.5393408537,
0.0070416895,
0.1758616269,
-0.4173660874,
0.1325527877,
0.4359355271,
0.8001478314,
-0.1151290834,
0.0760412738,
-0.8055728078,
-0.0747316629,
0.3761573434,
-0.1061550677,
0.5870537758,
-0.0269348938,
0.0990005657,
0.4131646752,
-0.8523060083,
-0.0899730474,
0.2213957161,
-0.5299982429,
-0.606477201,
0.1849165112,
-0.1789460778,
-0.2978208065,
0.4175015092,
-0.1382821798,
0.4839679003,
-0.3372636735,
0.2599126101,
1.043643713,
-0.1297471672,
0.7697254419,
-0.3899365067,
0.4017515182,
0.0750647336,
-0.1197062433,
0.2448541671,
-0.3658490479,
-0.9857622385,
-0.4491770566,
0.4821418822,
0.5181688666,
-0.8285046816,
0.5802932382,
-0.5368254781,
-0.2807950675,
-0.5476962328,
0.6234033108,
-0.0320046246,
0.4300192297,
0.4837542176,
-0.5652889609,
-0.344114691,
-0.6403033137,
-0.27525267,
-0.0899737924,
-0.2061084062,
0.7547423244,
0.2008135021,
-0.1456378549,
1.0536555052,
-0.7622045875,
-0.3896160722,
-0.3200449347,
-0.1768346131,
0.3248439431,
0.1572462916,
0.7062884569,
-0.8110676408,
-0.6522009373,
0.0073378244,
-0.5380014777,
-0.2322830558,
0.0170716867,
-0.135033071,
0.35007447,
0.0350728594,
-0.3729476631,
0.1080439761,
0.4309543967,
-0.2447040677,
0.5541796684,
-0.3044629395,
0.0009203636,
-0.8111163974,
-0.1599312276,
0.2577703297,
-0.1793447733,
-0.7042538524,
-0.2468657494,
0.1855534464,
0.1705026329,
-0.2606866956,
0.6570736766,
-0.2873416841,
-0.1351307631,
-0.5077157021,
0.0619408265,
-0.0413662903,
0.5305126905,
0.5659974813,
0.9365680218,
0.8402699828,
-1.084474802,
0.3706640303,
0.419544369,
-0.3702378869,
0.617084682,
-0.3749890625,
0.050172206,
0.0336420573,
0.1914590448,
-0.5059373379,
-0.3014748394,
0.1912689507,
-0.2782334685,
0.3868898153,
-0.0735890493,
-0.2555472851,
0.0062805782,
-0.3742479384,
0.1413623095,
0.2755333483,
-0.8203773499,
0.5426725149,
0.361569196,
-0.6430562735,
-0.4496804774,
-0.2624343336,
0.1421104372,
-0.381947875,
-0.4708558023,
0.4008767307,
-0.4860560596,
-0.0479852892,
-0.0385997929,
-0.0205475837,
0.1007754952,
0.3503870964,
0.0839746222,
0.2233966589,
-0.2830525339,
0.0648689717,
0.2736855149,
-0.1813943833,
-0.1321684867,
-0.1283995807,
0.1363050938,
0.0172149297,
0.0312183965,
-0.1606562287,
0.1165409088,
0.3984666765,
-0.2595564127,
0.5458269715,
0.4368502796,
-0.1191424876,
-0.6995258331,
-0.2096237838,
-0.2039177269,
-0.5323281884,
0.5314387083,
-0.5661956668,
-1.0021959543,
0.0512768179,
-0.4997697771,
-0.1457604617,
0.2204508483,
0.579847455,
0.0467355363,
0.9304333329,
0.9509680271,
-0.4049164355,
0.5806723237,
-0.0009991407,
0.1673600823,
-1.0968466997,
0.0118467389,
-0.4719466567,
-0.0676013902,
-0.352788806,
-0.353687793,
0.3640173674,
-0.0183858443,
-0.1221589819,
0.2516905665,
-0.5353637338,
0.3795689046,
0.4079536796,
0.2283498943,
0.3409086764,
0.3781572282,
0.0976663604,
-0.1169336066,
-0.7097442746,
-0.3938051164,
1.2963680029,
0.2079926282,
0.9069880843,
0.1154869348,
0.1441212445,
0.5886386037,
0.3294159174,
-0.8493443727,
0.5675372481,
-0.460252285,
-0.2340370119,
-0.4528310597,
-0.3704012334,
-0.7711422443,
0.1517065763,
-0.555060029,
-0.3979758322,
0.1634325832,
-0.0173146389,
-0.3840762973,
0.098373495,
-0.566349268,
0.4741089046,
-0.3364154696,
-0.3910168409,
-0.3539571762,
-0.163819328,
0.0859328434,
-0.5158724785,
0.007611447,
-0.3711062968,
-0.3285878599,
0.8471907973,
0.1937203705,
1.1056343317,
-0.1043335795,
-0.1552757174,
-0.1026252434,
0.0801501423,
0.4236745536,
0.1183274835,
-0.3788101673,
0.2188799381,
-0.1597002,
-0.4016452134,
-0.7271977067,
0.8147918582,
-1.0487372875,
-1.0585693121,
-0.2852300107,
-0.6328188181,
-0.5808568001,
0.2099856734,
-0.2960371375,
0.0232890341,
-0.2309498191,
0.0380241573,
0.7008266449,
-0.1188846976,
0.2910427451,
0.8312832117,
-0.1268140227,
-0.3845429718,
1.1559897661,
-0.1034356207,
0.2097072154,
0.5060757399,
0.1136411801,
-0.2885178924,
-0.9223086834,
-0.4821796417,
0.1688935608,
-0.6730147004,
-0.2611678541,
-0.6665484905,
0.0039997851,
-0.4724678397,
-0.3477213085,
0.1302837133,
-0.6956944466,
-0.9523916245,
-0.094635427,
0.6758099794,
0.3401524723,
0.1351695359,
0.2820559442,
-0.5121631622,
0.5943886042,
0.5304862261,
0.6253330708,
-0.2242950201,
-0.7969272137,
-0.2175709009,
-0.088603802,
-0.3392549455,
-0.2781473696,
0.4447773397,
0.5452455282,
0.634899199,
0.439855814,
0.2500887513,
0.5134443045,
-0.4616165459,
0.7600835562,
-0.1066579074,
-0.9300346971,
0.555758059,
-0.2963836491,
-0.1497113109,
0.2770929039,
0.3970482945,
-0.1746798456,
-0.1243648902,
-0.2211811393,
-0.4524128735,
0.8631077409,
-0.0757237449,
0.2193472236,
0.3152343333,
0.5234365463,
0.5093448162,
0.1238846183,
-0.4747667611,
-0.0628698021,
-0.4075904489,
-0.0190117247,
-0.411149025,
-0.0949245319,
-0.0834679604,
-0.3503654301,
0.7927021384,
-0.6687877774,
0.062853761,
0.0077648698,
-0.1598765999,
-0.3167280853,
0.4035812318,
0.3267579675,
0.6278625131,
-0.3158739805,
-0.0035500836,
0.505766511,
-0.2865050137,
-0.0479623601,
0.1822281182,
-0.0268942825,
-0.3659414649,
0.109193407,
0.9249095917,
0.036090862,
-0.4971681535,
0.2961236238,
-0.1985233426,
-0.021178402,
0.2062940747,
0.7368012667,
0.065788582,
0.2993623316,
0.3415720165,
0.1985558718,
0.0594346859,
-0.2744725049,
-0.1772478968,
0.4970216751,
-0.1343755871,
-0.3456847072,
0.5793255568,
0.4546830058,
-0.2504164577,
0.0130521888,
0.1456900388,
-0.3742157817,
0.6279905438,
0.7434129715,
0.8247472644,
-0.1914215982,
0.1435017586,
-0.0023777881,
-0.0220478214,
0.0898028687,
0.1372155398,
-0.1314362735,
-0.9790520072,
-0.2920020521,
-0.678527236,
-0.7931480408,
0.0681822747,
-0.5201532245,
0.3589550853,
-0.5509518385,
-0.2409381121,
0.168446213,
0.2655420303,
-0.6150102019,
0.1799564511,
-0.1582491398,
1.0246034861,
-0.5867577791,
0.9262576699,
0.8718389869,
-0.0633252338,
-0.0343293883,
0.0336759537,
-0.2898648083,
-0.8180750012,
0.5451708436,
-0.1801654696,
-0.1251812577,
-0.0425206982,
-0.6578017473,
-0.6645175219,
1.019538641,
0.4674412012,
-0.3145278394,
0.3320307732,
0.2731220722,
0.7078601718,
-0.638913393,
0.0165923592,
0.6469552517,
0.438013047,
-0.4442270994,
-1.0688719749,
0.1598700732,
-0.2337134778,
0.1903329641,
-0.1365157515,
-0.85829705,
0.4200919867,
-0.5062033534,
0.0472260565,
-0.0067057577,
0.9616911411,
0.1238798797,
0.2634171546,
0.7323028445,
0.1264852881,
0.9996968508,
0.2523263395,
0.7997843027,
-0.3337643147,
0.1044096053,
0.6944641471,
-0.5990245938,
0.9699305296,
0.2272002548,
-0.3738702238,
0.3347319961,
0.7846062779,
0.022467088,
0.7849045396,
0.0150943613,
-0.3690603673,
-0.6250026226,
-0.4014157653,
-0.3587057889,
0.2350659966,
0.773257792,
-0.0352289937,
0.2240612507,
-0.0570236817,
-0.2045624554,
0.0294373687,
-0.4700419903,
0.9608952403,
0.1555474102,
-0.6455171108,
0.7832632065,
0.001007296,
0.8708354235,
-0.496186614,
0.0126930997,
-0.148774907,
0.2624574304,
-0.2898483574,
-0.8783897758,
-0.0816438422,
0.04083566,
-0.6011371017,
-0.0929570496,
0.9563168883,
-0.3095139861,
-0.3653320968,
0.3285507262,
0.3611419499,
-0.0532826968,
-0.0020397769,
-0.6810691953,
-0.149399817,
0.0127683766,
-0.1360786706,
0.7365284562,
0.4037442803,
-0.0196161326,
0.9300383925,
0.7936762571,
0.3369220197,
-0.2681676149,
-0.1137940511,
1.0379543304,
-0.5260373354,
-0.3841708302,
-0.447155267,
0.0075698476,
-0.0507087223,
-0.1801611185,
0.6139018536,
0.4150438309,
0.8644054532,
-0.2797355056,
1.3960294724,
0.3819641769,
0.6529453993,
-0.6040222049,
0.6501665115,
-0.6559830904,
0.3395786583,
-0.1955864429,
-0.9534966946,
-0.3703254759,
0.4015088975,
-0.5132518411,
-0.0758522823,
0.5776667595,
0.8004084826,
-0.2557422221,
0.098063387,
0.2600358725,
0.1795022339,
0.2954182327,
0.4604337215,
0.5593048334,
0.345043987,
0.4968484044,
-0.1347863525,
-0.5722074509,
-0.3723459244,
-1.0872479677,
-1.2206503153,
-0.5014587641,
-0.3324857354,
-0.1980826706,
0.1456863731,
0.9869120717,
0.5035484433,
-0.9484749436,
-0.02637312,
0.4372807741,
0.2040415555,
-0.2621527314,
-0.1930964291,
0.6503326893,
-0.4933117926,
-0.8084237576,
0.5299156308,
0.3147506714,
-0.026771225,
-0.0220894627,
-0.1692412347,
0.4733553231,
0.216507569,
0.7038387656,
0.2001782805,
-0.481321156,
-0.3174049556,
0.0854731947,
0.1426368356,
0.2255492061,
0.7730705142,
-0.6864272356,
0.4608594179,
0.3749074936,
0.8039845228,
0.3318194151,
-0.0796090886,
0.5000232458,
-0.3416304588,
-0.1465497911,
-0.0566379279,
0.3197428882,
0.440106988,
-0.5760436058,
0.4204399884,
0.3009011447,
-0.6252824664,
-0.5594070554,
0.065410383,
-1.261113286,
-0.3368116915,
1.5983936787,
-0.1044934615,
-0.1517362744,
-0.3621611595,
-0.4433319569,
0.0790533721,
-0.7427484393,
1.0880880356,
0.5748921633,
-0.3242505789,
0.1672433615,
-0.3073878288,
0.7574232817,
0.6030803323,
-0.8402941227,
0.3880841136,
0.1170219257,
0.5246260762,
-0.0961546227,
0.5912476182,
0.3006706834,
0.1631816626,
-0.5150154829,
-0.1645758897,
-0.1664887369,
-0.3070281744,
-0.4674696922,
0.0166372024,
0.34756127,
0.1137032956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12821v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12821v2
|
Identifying Factual Inconsistencies in Summaries: Grounding Model Inference via Task Taxonomy
| 2024-02-20T08:41:23 | 2024-06-20T03:45:51 |
Liyan Xu, Zhenlin Su, Mo Yu, Jin Xu, Jinho D. Choi, Jie Zhou, Fei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Factual inconsistencies pose a significant hurdle for the faithful
summarization by generative models. While a major direction to enhance
inconsistency detection is to derive stronger Natural Language Inference (NLI)
models, we propose an orthogonal aspect that underscores the importance of
incorporating task-specific taxonomy into the inference. To this end, we
consolidate key error types of inconsistent facts in summaries, and incorporate
them to facilitate both the zero-shot and supervised paradigms of LLMs.
Extensive experiments on ten datasets of five distinct domains suggest that,
zero-shot LLM inference could benefit from the explicit solution space depicted
by the error type taxonomy, and achieves state-of-the-art performance overall,
surpassing specialized non-LLM baselines, as well as recent LLM baselines. We
further distill models that fuse the taxonomy into parameters through our
designed prompt completions and supervised training strategies, efficiently
substituting state-of-the-art zero-shot inference with much larger LLMs.
|
[
0.0418766737,
-0.7829493284,
0.7805226445,
0.1755187511,
0.0087291356,
0.1225566939,
-0.0082445713,
-0.282351464,
0.2043667883,
0.4389512837,
-0.5204067826,
-0.6394201517,
-0.9240846634,
0.246905759,
-0.4114777744,
1.1011164188,
-0.1322800219,
-0.2614939809,
-0.6073276997,
-0.3483581841,
-0.3820596635,
-0.5101402998,
-0.400041014,
-0.4074771702,
0.5956583023,
0.4567487836,
0.5291340947,
0.6893860698,
0.3982699215,
0.1554827988,
-0.1417824626,
0.5814054608,
-0.2147976458,
0.1743760258,
-0.0917076841,
-0.8489649296,
-0.6691864133,
-0.0284878667,
0.3690825999,
1.1193833351,
-0.122851491,
0.0764841288,
-0.0664160028,
0.4160343409,
-0.9317264557,
0.3656610847,
-0.5709056854,
0.2517744303,
-0.1213916466,
-0.3794672489,
-0.4819027483,
-0.0650212839,
-0.0286466125,
-0.5574938655,
0.673615694,
-0.1167152971,
1.0136333704,
0.373159349,
-0.6631727219,
-0.1576792151,
-0.7509761453,
0.9262848496,
-1.1813082695,
0.1302950382,
0.2305343896,
-0.1849968582,
-0.1116472855,
-0.3701552749,
-0.5505840182,
-0.1892332733,
-0.283043921,
0.436955303,
-0.309766084,
0.2992298603,
0.3766207695,
0.3681737185,
-0.5476325154,
0.2455879748,
-0.00643592,
-0.0209635124,
0.6184533238,
0.4074177444,
0.1915618032,
-0.3194327652,
-0.1503646374,
0.1909628659,
-0.8964865208,
-0.0759754926,
0.1650169343,
0.4280247688,
-0.4653797448,
0.8058277369,
-0.439319849,
0.9082934856,
0.1779739559,
-0.5451050997,
0.2088115662,
-0.3742783666,
-0.4683246911,
-0.0509205721,
0.4102720618,
0.4571911991,
-0.1237672716,
-0.4736088812,
-0.1998035461,
0.1363479048,
0.1743990481,
-0.34387514,
-0.0817844719,
0.5742784739,
-0.2205440998,
-0.3011623323,
-0.0058553494,
-0.4423321784,
-0.3911726475,
-0.6751702428,
0.4234108329,
-0.1840527505,
-0.2751168311,
-0.0195703916,
-0.4648883343,
0.2326019108,
0.6526634693,
-0.9099904895,
0.062929146,
0.8381800652,
0.8430923223,
-0.2521904409,
-0.1811156422,
-0.3280637562,
0.3308185637,
-0.5712332129,
1.1192605495,
-0.119302839,
-0.3041089177,
0.0610882863,
-0.1874102652,
-0.2544461191,
-0.5743788481,
0.5257176161,
-0.347029984,
0.256397903,
-0.2707622945,
-0.942243576,
-0.346463412,
0.5732518435,
-0.3530554771,
0.890075922,
0.1161179543,
-0.9140259027,
0.4851216078,
-0.4665410817,
-0.4572240412,
0.0256153382,
-0.408619374,
-0.3468102217,
0.4028731883,
-0.0130676869,
0.5664139986,
-0.2148731053,
0.7645739317,
-0.3089500666,
-0.1950702965,
0.0120084193,
-0.3386880159,
0.8257959485,
-0.0492644161,
-0.23540847,
0.1473501921,
-0.8773650527,
-0.3718757331,
0.077401422,
-0.178736791,
-0.3045601845,
0.2124048322,
-0.3118178546,
-0.163927719,
0.0672978237,
-0.3806389272,
0.1068641096,
-0.2279310971,
0.0918177143,
0.3691046238,
0.1885661185,
0.4493126869,
-0.6763125658,
0.4155440032,
0.2483830303,
-0.1658331305,
-0.5073636174,
-0.5104605556,
-0.9962549806,
-0.346642971,
0.0726760477,
0.8219128251,
-0.8403723836,
0.494761467,
-0.4531981051,
-0.4584052861,
-0.1175294071,
0.0112244375,
0.3785144389,
1.0095660686,
0.3291523457,
0.0330501907,
-0.6691641212,
-0.8176117539,
-0.3498831093,
-0.3297275603,
-0.2868317962,
0.0892406926,
0.5526613593,
-0.0865820125,
1.2512569427,
-0.4408821762,
-0.1731638461,
-0.5132305622,
0.6066205502,
0.4611598253,
0.3309406042,
0.5676766634,
-0.6271000504,
-0.1963183433,
-0.4124371707,
-1.2857249975,
-0.1972010285,
-0.3121523857,
0.3039530218,
0.1749179065,
0.4017404914,
-0.7811860442,
0.5330091715,
0.2106384486,
-0.1507443786,
0.5376079082,
-0.1905954182,
0.0597353689,
-0.8208291531,
-0.1635018289,
0.2410946041,
-0.2414489239,
-0.8512641191,
0.1171531677,
0.0120740086,
0.4662031531,
-0.1899245828,
0.2641967833,
-0.3617275953,
0.0657822341,
-0.2080141902,
0.1865357012,
0.188475728,
0.4783137441,
0.1675557643,
0.6664012074,
0.4714894593,
-0.7353811264,
0.1811533123,
0.3104987741,
-0.0051972563,
0.743538022,
-0.6405599713,
-0.3736557066,
-0.5080242753,
0.3015706837,
-1.134898901,
-0.6445096135,
0.2819098532,
-0.4148734212,
0.5144568682,
-0.1353880167,
-0.4728276134,
0.0823891684,
-0.3948226869,
0.1983226091,
0.3071890473,
-0.3922762871,
0.8432169557,
0.329204917,
-0.1624272764,
-0.7049487233,
-0.8369314075,
0.4200560749,
-0.2411782593,
-0.393546313,
0.3661405742,
0.2293567806,
-0.4933827221,
-0.0241271481,
-0.3235075772,
-0.1142241433,
0.278863132,
0.3116793334,
0.4508946538,
-0.3998361826,
0.0881124213,
-0.0587690584,
-0.0265230481,
0.0941486657,
-0.0374212377,
-0.0693954453,
0.2318790406,
-0.4052836299,
-0.2395810783,
0.3943104446,
0.3597078323,
0.1716631353,
0.5865029693,
0.0281268433,
-0.4010911882,
-0.1276835948,
-0.7578008175,
0.0867956355,
-0.2927893102,
0.2510242164,
-0.0892091915,
-0.920432806,
0.4597756267,
0.1201511696,
0.2698636651,
0.5218933821,
0.2809836268,
-0.291234374,
0.6686400175,
0.8027873635,
0.2154498696,
0.0856974274,
-0.2864311337,
0.2524106801,
-0.8040953875,
-0.2050343156,
-0.3850553334,
0.0218420681,
-0.3574936092,
-0.4160189033,
0.4910317063,
0.0641811788,
-0.2333646566,
0.2226638645,
0.0285126362,
0.2398600578,
0.4620163441,
-0.0746093988,
0.5522456169,
0.0217779651,
0.0699126422,
-0.0761429891,
-0.9096665978,
-0.5397345424,
1.0409948826,
0.3034229577,
0.645111084,
0.2523511052,
0.6012770534,
0.4017961025,
0.6551536322,
-0.8378234506,
0.3315237463,
-0.2443931103,
-0.6048022509,
-0.0194574576,
-0.4065968096,
-0.6538299322,
0.4314705133,
-0.1855409741,
-0.6217624545,
0.2722138464,
0.2741888762,
-0.6091040969,
0.3689951301,
-0.5960200429,
0.794778347,
0.060023699,
-0.0724525601,
0.1444420666,
-0.7173479199,
0.9422476292,
0.1860782951,
0.2060483843,
-0.3407875896,
-0.2542791367,
0.5339161754,
-0.4356816411,
1.1655750275,
-0.0655410737,
-0.282794565,
0.2365532517,
-0.0232570563,
0.3920678496,
-0.0916039571,
0.1864102334,
0.3149996996,
-0.2837461829,
-0.3898553848,
-0.682679832,
0.1728488952,
-0.5304504037,
-0.758880496,
-0.5291621685,
-0.7953279614,
-0.5521620512,
-0.2295811474,
0.5102354288,
0.6268563867,
0.0032942612,
-0.0507400781,
0.8864308596,
-0.043664787,
0.4268388748,
0.7040714622,
-0.0185283013,
-0.0617908463,
0.7041088343,
0.2038460225,
0.3671846986,
0.6306959987,
-0.2383437157,
-0.2130737603,
-0.9345539808,
-0.3070761263,
0.2314020991,
-0.8126573563,
-0.5640990138,
-1.0026106834,
-0.3611643314,
-0.46972543,
-0.125846386,
-0.1371091604,
-0.5002039671,
-0.5138587356,
-0.380907923,
0.4318124354,
0.6534662247,
-0.2094622105,
0.4654801488,
-0.9571465254,
0.5944074988,
0.1342915297,
-0.0229710601,
0.0565342754,
-0.938901484,
-0.0030166572,
-0.0204209741,
-0.2421278507,
-0.8249747753,
0.3500782549,
0.3042694628,
0.5130428672,
0.425106287,
0.0520575792,
0.8203800917,
-0.3280518353,
0.9509847164,
0.3156272173,
-0.8672175407,
0.5169718266,
-0.4565584958,
0.2326138616,
0.3422574997,
0.3505053222,
-0.6163945794,
-0.8334891796,
-0.7204834819,
-0.9305540919,
0.617524147,
0.0903416574,
0.0818559751,
-0.3526921272,
0.4476451278,
0.0881893262,
0.307343483,
-0.6709474325,
-0.5927712917,
-0.0131183732,
-0.2869985402,
-0.038233906,
-0.5858244896,
-0.2398182452,
-0.0608041584,
0.687196672,
-0.3390496373,
0.0167284645,
0.4940065742,
-0.3280187249,
-0.0875807852,
0.280308485,
0.749345243,
1.012745142,
-0.3241970241,
0.4211125374,
0.3549849987,
-0.083951965,
0.2322770953,
-0.069904089,
-0.5092083812,
0.4239865839,
1.0901784897,
0.6996549368,
0.4354606569,
-0.7162666321,
0.7452787757,
0.2193131447,
-0.2183833569,
-0.3076000512,
0.1653298438,
0.0533365309,
0.0056491918,
0.5829906464,
0.2842431068,
0.2095035464,
-0.4737933874,
0.226427868,
0.4229038358,
-0.1875219941,
-0.2862229049,
0.6874761581,
0.0488136336,
0.1534857899,
0.2080576271,
-0.5181907415,
-0.2454037368,
0.8004447818,
0.2836918831,
0.8455030322,
0.0480938554,
0.4614880085,
0.3166911006,
0.3344258666,
-0.1291070729,
0.1000907421,
-0.0237625558,
-0.9945925474,
-0.9059323668,
-0.3350156546,
-0.6553012729,
0.0936116055,
-0.7283574343,
-0.0219983049,
-0.3441613317,
0.0852461383,
0.1492646337,
-0.4728683531,
-0.2665141523,
0.1882533431,
0.3191818595,
0.9841436744,
-0.9935330749,
0.4298002124,
0.5337125659,
-0.5175377727,
-0.5824780464,
0.0066095991,
0.417660445,
-0.7010932565,
0.9537133574,
-0.0810992345,
-0.0505249947,
-0.3397576809,
-0.5557821393,
-0.7452052236,
1.0877034664,
0.4414075017,
-0.5188469887,
-0.1327921301,
0.0812995657,
0.3394169807,
-0.4576966465,
0.32193169,
0.6178149581,
0.2869231999,
0.2446394116,
-0.6892151237,
-0.0471256785,
0.1483994573,
0.196965009,
-0.0094878124,
-0.2927868664,
0.892765224,
-0.3602073491,
-0.3610762954,
0.0688116923,
0.9106758237,
0.3821166456,
0.5299027562,
0.3238167763,
0.9175817966,
0.804423511,
-0.1989309192,
1.1354979277,
-0.0507166535,
0.4436076581,
1.5066426992,
-0.4159665108,
0.6689634323,
0.3664268851,
-0.3407603502,
0.3656489849,
0.5094847083,
-0.1408593804,
0.3228529692,
-0.2086035758,
-0.535772264,
-0.4150370061,
-0.351277113,
-0.1976614892,
0.4352725148,
0.4211770892,
-0.0501833223,
-0.8413593769,
-0.2440080643,
0.2360970825,
0.042949561,
-0.3348482847,
0.8566426039,
0.0277054925,
-0.7246245742,
0.4713133872,
0.1196836457,
0.9103405476,
-0.5279205441,
-0.1469062567,
-0.5109268427,
-0.0617205054,
-0.4128044844,
-0.5666383505,
0.6218605638,
0.1972560585,
-0.3940664828,
-0.1882739514,
0.5977687836,
-0.4281443059,
-0.4297991097,
0.1082321629,
0.7631449699,
-0.0070867622,
-0.0993524641,
-0.4476432502,
-0.2066845894,
-0.0715739504,
0.1788431704,
0.0812955275,
0.4849011898,
0.0811380893,
0.4749342799,
0.5384933352,
-0.0078239823,
-0.0420415252,
0.0317124017,
0.4613839388,
-0.6146890521,
-0.1629484743,
-0.9898596406,
0.5882894993,
-0.1119107008,
-0.3014856875,
0.9608919024,
0.5504895449,
0.6166671515,
-0.2714439929,
0.9032939076,
-0.0313333906,
0.7165842652,
-0.5780391693,
0.3226332366,
-0.483386606,
0.3051270843,
0.1398974955,
-0.5696132779,
-0.664424777,
0.3150296807,
-0.1502018571,
-0.1611706316,
0.5875819325,
0.6209279895,
-0.0074068615,
-0.131217733,
0.3712067902,
0.4103240967,
0.272400111,
0.3797885478,
0.9173331857,
-0.3752221167,
0.1526377648,
-0.1798729897,
-0.2206192464,
-0.3313615322,
-1.2217488289,
-0.6894631982,
-0.1844123006,
-0.9176454544,
-0.2174771577,
-0.0442163385,
0.7887298465,
0.6648707986,
-1.1131541729,
-0.1727060676,
-0.3789947331,
0.5270688534,
-0.1869330406,
-0.3075545132,
0.1305932552,
-0.8334789872,
-0.4383862615,
0.317686826,
0.739712894,
0.063969709,
0.0513083935,
0.2570634484,
-0.229479298,
0.3415843844,
0.6510931849,
0.4263318181,
-1.1208361387,
-0.2133033574,
-0.1132567152,
-0.068396084,
0.2601911426,
0.800445199,
-0.6282755136,
0.184196189,
0.2766095698,
0.7132112384,
0.0807251409,
-0.0088351443,
0.4578638077,
-1.1031486988,
0.1066814214,
0.1614156216,
0.5913627148,
0.4585389495,
-0.2898720205,
0.6319542527,
0.6473122239,
-0.1256410331,
-0.9175572395,
0.184250012,
-1.1849911213,
-0.2348238379,
0.9533278346,
-0.4569616616,
-0.1598388404,
-0.3066281974,
0.2587283254,
0.1464846134,
0.036309462,
0.7471691966,
0.7858977914,
-0.3213239014,
-0.1915568709,
-0.70073843,
0.4334864616,
0.442369014,
-0.9996880293,
0.1057871878,
0.5594526529,
0.3700098097,
0.4111404121,
0.5866621733,
0.0840280131,
0.3144656122,
0.0222189799,
-0.0025818904,
0.0543986224,
-0.1820153594,
-0.3618288636,
0.1898541003,
-0.0666208416,
0.0280009191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12819v2
|
Comparing Specialised Small and General Large Language Models on Text Classification: 100 Labelled Samples to Achieve Break-Even Performance
| 2024-02-20T08:38:24 | 2024-04-26T08:20:40 |
Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
When solving NLP tasks with limited labelled data, researchers can either use
a general large language model without further update, or use a small number of
labelled examples to tune a specialised smaller model. In this work, we address
the research gap of how many labelled samples are required for the specialised
small models to outperform general large models, while taking the performance
variance into consideration. By observing the behaviour of fine-tuning,
instruction-tuning, prompting and in-context learning on 7 language models, we
identify such performance break-even points across 8 representative text
classification tasks of varying characteristics. We show that the specialised
models often need only few samples (on average $10 - 1000$) to be on par or
better than the general ones. At the same time, the number of required labels
strongly depends on the dataset or task characteristics, with this number being
significantly lower on multi-class datasets (up to $100$) than on binary
datasets (up to $5000$). When performance variance is taken into consideration,
the number of required labels increases on average by $100 - 200\%$ and even up
to $1500\%$ in specific cases.
|
[
-0.553843677,
-0.7004469037,
0.3262887895,
0.1977173835,
0.1185595915,
-0.2454890907,
-0.205058828,
-0.8230016828,
-0.0988784581,
0.5753031969,
-0.4028967917,
-0.2615000904,
-0.8139747977,
0.300124824,
-0.4320480227,
0.872559309,
0.232755363,
-0.1412988901,
-0.2943216264,
-0.0953018889,
-0.6196894646,
-0.4469049275,
-0.808198154,
-0.5037428737,
0.6172968149,
0.4428872168,
0.702476263,
0.5485721231,
0.5528697371,
0.2406963408,
-0.514210701,
0.4058102071,
-0.1900768727,
-0.150037095,
-0.4237317145,
-0.5989903212,
-0.4712267518,
-0.0080840625,
0.5050290227,
0.6682876945,
0.1373109221,
0.1965979189,
0.2871643603,
0.5957756639,
-0.4478200972,
0.1642366648,
-0.259750396,
-0.0082419431,
-0.3296338916,
0.1749191731,
-0.6090033054,
-0.0912979469,
0.1150991842,
-0.3605188727,
0.3770653605,
0.0175233893,
0.8915022612,
0.4253155291,
-0.2539097965,
-0.5269965529,
-0.5728645921,
0.8867779374,
-0.8543601036,
0.0990420505,
0.6094517708,
-0.0073498152,
0.0166036077,
-0.7313231826,
-0.2493996322,
-0.1402478367,
-0.2119159997,
-0.2757349312,
-0.3026323318,
-0.0397929363,
0.4234294891,
0.2464220822,
-0.3439667523,
0.7426849604,
-0.5272524953,
0.1522954851,
0.5926339626,
0.2299403846,
0.2408096045,
-0.1514425576,
0.111328885,
-0.2713233232,
-0.4827318788,
0.2178761959,
0.2751481235,
0.5865942836,
0.0898482352,
0.5647873282,
-0.0621706583,
0.9993273616,
0.1129841805,
-0.1933939308,
0.26837942,
-0.3815294802,
-0.4004758298,
-0.3014520705,
0.8682812452,
0.0632719323,
0.3500840366,
-0.0511823222,
-0.411690414,
-0.0755671933,
0.3735150695,
-0.8310363293,
-0.2899660468,
0.1007150859,
-0.2803262472,
-0.2230461687,
-0.1926127225,
-0.8148487806,
-0.1057283282,
-0.4357633889,
0.4754881263,
-0.2357126921,
-0.0278251301,
0.2946994007,
-0.0937782675,
-0.0540026464,
0.3067360818,
-1.1783051491,
0.4803906381,
0.6650049686,
0.9663941264,
-0.3595294654,
-0.2486010343,
-0.4613130689,
-0.2936522961,
-0.3964648843,
0.8151385188,
-0.6714513898,
-0.4458016455,
-0.1298434436,
0.0359228402,
-0.1636370569,
-0.8076404929,
0.6395848393,
-0.4073674381,
0.2067570537,
-0.1540950984,
-0.7480809689,
-0.0339828916,
0.174141854,
-0.9786180854,
1.2520047426,
0.177251488,
-0.7824367881,
0.6332239509,
-0.6224378347,
-0.3791277111,
0.1746017635,
-0.1975242347,
-0.4949585795,
0.1088756695,
0.0520976521,
0.6706059575,
-0.4741766751,
0.2214780152,
-0.2304472774,
-0.398087889,
0.3386996984,
-0.3182312846,
0.601465404,
0.0133001618,
-0.5699202418,
-0.126330629,
-0.9530493617,
0.2783999741,
-0.3494649529,
-0.6347215176,
-0.6606724858,
0.0032243258,
0.136690706,
0.4691779017,
-0.0747997016,
-0.2208787501,
0.4168117046,
-0.4950298667,
0.3880843818,
0.3593541086,
-0.2309329361,
0.4097388089,
-0.3021140397,
0.5358729362,
-0.2612701058,
-0.0462776609,
-0.0140061388,
-0.7331257463,
-0.7723178864,
-0.5991207361,
0.9178701043,
0.3683445454,
-0.5408865809,
0.3970748782,
-0.0288333744,
-0.4407810271,
-0.8627246618,
0.1047833115,
0.5072274208,
0.1240596399,
0.5605315566,
-0.3130135536,
-0.2961523831,
-1.0067611933,
-0.2256057262,
0.1465556324,
-0.4744707942,
0.5082091093,
0.8384290338,
-0.3985776305,
1.0583148003,
-0.3351523578,
-0.2957285941,
-0.1245825291,
0.4325996637,
0.2656475604,
0.3353484869,
0.6235308051,
-0.7439166307,
-0.4743709862,
0.0643706322,
-0.4082748592,
-0.1690724343,
-0.0670255199,
0.2506625652,
0.4930743575,
0.4616763592,
-0.4154703021,
0.4508643746,
0.7033284903,
-0.469024092,
0.5691731572,
-0.3463686407,
-0.0745631903,
-0.6141409874,
0.0464668199,
0.2659535706,
-0.1900449246,
-0.6947770119,
-0.0046467348,
0.2269825488,
0.0722127035,
-0.2748660743,
0.5607225895,
-0.2504852712,
0.1940112412,
-0.4814809859,
0.0106782624,
0.0159074236,
0.2000110894,
0.033305198,
0.6635888219,
0.4152769446,
-0.7996200323,
-0.1139576808,
0.0494694225,
-0.7302894592,
0.1171717048,
-0.7997086048,
0.0831079111,
0.3025756478,
0.0094891172,
-0.9230386019,
-0.3458362222,
-0.0107319327,
-0.2209894657,
0.5311893225,
0.0869973674,
-0.6291787028,
-0.2053818852,
0.063824743,
0.3301483989,
0.484095782,
-0.6068359613,
0.4771667123,
0.3530688882,
-0.29560256,
-0.4985844791,
-0.9347234964,
-0.0773014426,
-0.1041253507,
-0.4367617369,
0.3388985693,
0.138550207,
-0.2530447543,
-0.0488940626,
-0.0499174893,
-0.1791455299,
0.0107732359,
0.1451566964,
-0.1016156748,
-0.0820479766,
0.4150784314,
0.0288468022,
-0.0507607423,
0.0550075658,
-0.1665061414,
0.3235801458,
-0.0621407293,
-0.1352096945,
-0.2005304247,
0.3209569454,
0.4584661722,
-0.0498143584,
0.8765377402,
0.4274276495,
-0.237455368,
-0.5911313891,
-0.419603169,
0.022700537,
-0.4739471674,
0.3312051296,
-0.5765269995,
-0.9666260481,
0.1865753382,
0.0915212706,
-0.0014141566,
0.7242355347,
0.5482855439,
-0.0069897249,
0.9691017866,
0.948278904,
-0.17442891,
0.2085374296,
-0.0387256518,
0.157806024,
-0.2518652976,
-0.1878726482,
-1.0500866175,
-0.2793886364,
-0.7679858804,
-0.6471953392,
0.1300061941,
0.1991687715,
-0.0194719303,
0.1084917858,
-0.6694120169,
0.5829892755,
0.73914361,
0.0062681912,
0.3173963428,
-0.0589444041,
-0.0972146988,
-0.1474892497,
-0.9726836681,
-0.5422826409,
0.8782683015,
0.3802161813,
0.7171376944,
0.0284529962,
0.4989433289,
0.4063229859,
0.3130922019,
-0.8621546626,
0.3179122806,
-0.5374765992,
-0.6704105139,
-0.5615295172,
-0.4086324573,
-0.9941841364,
0.3480914831,
-0.1672674567,
-0.6182433367,
0.4755969346,
0.0171537921,
-0.0599583462,
0.1319933534,
-0.5955668688,
0.7361901402,
-0.1031147093,
-0.1043420061,
-0.012235418,
-0.4014422894,
0.4288552403,
-0.5332860947,
0.4741283655,
0.1032700092,
-0.0997085348,
0.9471592307,
-0.2555426061,
1.1729938984,
0.0972301811,
-0.2192004472,
0.1628305465,
-0.1554361135,
0.3874381185,
-0.2640884817,
-0.2043415904,
0.1500500292,
0.1748067439,
-0.5064873695,
-0.3992121816,
0.2218234539,
-0.710976243,
-0.2464021742,
-0.3712871075,
-0.3518256843,
-0.2618145347,
0.0877299979,
0.6671901345,
0.3409121633,
-0.0017901559,
0.4900523722,
0.8466001749,
-0.2966809869,
0.3574424386,
0.3998919427,
-0.2079319805,
-0.0937567279,
0.7682535052,
0.3920817673,
0.347617507,
0.3986447752,
0.308029145,
-0.087961182,
-0.5876591206,
-0.2609067261,
0.1655674577,
-0.5319900513,
-0.1792303473,
-0.7093119025,
-0.1033695117,
-0.2162213326,
-0.065672107,
-0.5191419721,
-0.4322199225,
-0.486866653,
0.061472699,
0.2526406348,
0.8444864154,
-0.0729940832,
0.315149039,
-0.7472572327,
0.345191896,
0.3760889471,
0.3060163558,
0.0969619304,
-0.824547708,
-0.5022186041,
-0.168902576,
-0.2387298793,
-0.701225698,
0.4660975039,
0.363799721,
0.5095965862,
0.3322799206,
0.0200862847,
0.5520936847,
-0.6025775671,
0.7863506079,
0.1539687514,
-1.0698245764,
0.4245728552,
-0.2569032013,
0.3369105756,
0.5222473145,
0.5979178548,
-0.5132863522,
-0.5008733869,
-0.6820710301,
-1.2309192419,
0.7725476027,
0.0389814787,
-0.0927054659,
0.1425501257,
0.3030284941,
0.249869898,
0.0621042214,
-0.6979214549,
-0.2223392427,
0.3255863786,
-0.0272160135,
-0.356233716,
-0.3846954703,
-0.1695240289,
-0.3645563722,
0.5528128743,
-0.142645523,
0.0171991251,
-0.1859735101,
-0.0100762798,
0.3417309523,
0.5301841497,
0.5888934135,
0.7367686033,
-0.1490714997,
-0.0073589808,
0.1909527481,
-0.3640236557,
0.1454304755,
-0.0902243406,
-0.350087285,
0.3873535991,
0.5052658319,
0.8638030291,
0.4229305685,
-0.7265663147,
0.1654008627,
-0.0725857541,
-0.4164357185,
0.3615397215,
0.4169328809,
0.0510463342,
0.1384775043,
0.2695447206,
0.0384695642,
0.2035864145,
-0.4244686067,
0.2786189318,
0.0484422594,
-0.2156067193,
-0.0700594857,
0.3347916305,
0.1142373383,
-0.6376729012,
0.3754795492,
-0.2364969105,
-0.2025800943,
0.643779397,
0.3954487443,
0.5876443982,
-0.2465183288,
0.4321113229,
0.2632005811,
0.4776974618,
-0.787152648,
-0.0975752398,
-0.0036634002,
-0.488802731,
-0.688904047,
-0.7435762882,
-0.9376725554,
0.3331990838,
-0.9975230694,
0.1539979279,
-0.1165122539,
-0.1970288008,
0.4243599176,
0.0756246671,
-0.7117334008,
0.5926021934,
-0.1242238209,
1.0724232197,
-0.8497520685,
0.8647008538,
0.5560929179,
-0.1187379733,
-0.7121613622,
-0.1789837927,
-0.182116434,
-0.1970954239,
0.8204810023,
0.2985369265,
-0.1328705996,
-0.3384274542,
-0.4349943697,
-0.7675386071,
0.4308596551,
0.0383055136,
-0.9537578821,
-0.1009174362,
0.164827615,
0.8627537489,
-0.3714527786,
0.148530826,
1.0843229294,
0.4742344022,
-0.1847532541,
-1.1168388128,
-0.1910089552,
-0.1916097552,
-0.0817645118,
0.1281630397,
-0.5233181119,
0.8929227591,
0.1009800434,
-0.0221536811,
-0.013432161,
0.2308390588,
0.1807915717,
0.5298178792,
0.4023804665,
0.3726961017,
1.091567874,
-0.1742784977,
1.0995107889,
0.1050273925,
0.4103351235,
1.2064243555,
-0.0065772324,
1.0372307301,
0.1889302582,
-0.3547150791,
0.1164517626,
0.7949685454,
-0.2680664957,
0.4239244461,
0.1788480282,
-0.0923590958,
-0.2620744109,
0.1883452982,
-0.3935953379,
0.4777496159,
0.4514557421,
-0.4671237469,
0.1167825088,
0.2758264542,
-0.1125731543,
-0.0966975316,
-0.4260389805,
0.782797277,
0.1457450539,
-0.7230322957,
0.7583909631,
0.2749790847,
0.8897510767,
-0.4809693396,
0.3765429854,
-0.0763931274,
0.3347679377,
-0.2879225612,
-0.714020133,
0.2760693133,
0.248662591,
-0.5087277889,
-0.3476386666,
0.7827673554,
-0.3165853024,
-0.6110400558,
0.4282553196,
0.3239659667,
0.2837272584,
0.0063917721,
-0.4959485829,
0.0013641382,
0.0179205928,
-0.491995275,
0.6706662774,
0.6312161684,
0.1663395166,
0.5323085785,
0.2461214215,
0.2058865577,
0.0330740288,
0.0319243707,
0.799577415,
-0.7962737083,
-0.5166134834,
-0.8699492812,
0.5189413428,
-0.0986747593,
-0.6105313301,
0.6888443828,
0.4037923217,
0.9584572315,
-0.1318376958,
0.8101462722,
0.0625992492,
0.597656846,
-0.6171396971,
0.4084554613,
-0.7127587199,
0.299856931,
-0.2671546042,
-0.665461421,
-0.3795236349,
0.5951818228,
-0.4110443592,
-0.0397483855,
0.6153728962,
0.535153985,
-0.0068558883,
0.074973464,
0.4212881327,
-0.0191776119,
0.328869015,
0.3465289772,
0.5826259851,
-0.2555377781,
0.4170219004,
-0.0642280728,
-0.2483861148,
-0.2191372514,
-0.7561019659,
-0.9674379826,
-0.2812847495,
-0.3921247721,
-0.407220155,
-0.0802269131,
0.5536818504,
0.6896166801,
-0.9212516546,
-0.17438142,
0.1765762269,
0.108316958,
-0.3614561856,
-0.2074034363,
0.411452949,
-0.6785468459,
-1.0247251987,
0.3068736792,
0.199833706,
-0.0883645937,
-0.0217772778,
0.1853899509,
-0.0908444524,
0.2014690191,
0.6590905786,
0.4490245879,
-0.4872472584,
-0.0159309059,
-0.1859027445,
-0.2539800406,
-0.027944956,
0.7853708863,
-0.50517416,
0.2943110764,
0.3404544592,
0.963403821,
0.8132730126,
-0.1298987418,
0.3112713099,
-0.9949623942,
0.0221106745,
0.3557345867,
-0.1192551032,
0.1519698799,
-0.1110347658,
0.6219400167,
0.017321106,
-0.8168180585,
-1.0029718876,
0.0843245462,
-0.7552340627,
-0.6800979972,
1.1969320774,
-0.1152072102,
-0.0094149252,
-0.1703013927,
-0.035955213,
-0.1800469458,
-0.0842701569,
0.8670064807,
1.0506165028,
-0.3387581706,
0.0212593768,
-0.7896383405,
0.6817398071,
0.4530135095,
-0.7643262744,
-0.044822365,
0.3133981824,
0.1199011877,
0.3179194331,
0.4808374941,
0.1909036785,
0.1552994549,
0.2313396186,
0.0363098122,
0.0804845467,
-0.5484336019,
-0.5018785,
0.5178540945,
-0.0262052491,
-0.0815538168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12817v1
|
On Sensitivity of Learning with Limited Labelled Data to the Effects of Randomness: Impact of Interactions and Systematic Choices
| 2024-02-20T08:38:19 | 2024-02-20T08:38:19 |
Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
While learning with limited labelled data can improve performance when the
labels are lacking, it is also sensitive to the effects of uncontrolled
randomness introduced by so-called randomness factors (e.g., varying order of
data). We propose a method to systematically investigate the effects of
randomness factors while taking the interactions between them into
consideration. To measure the true effects of an individual randomness factor,
our method mitigates the effects of other factors and observes how the
performance varies across multiple runs. Applying our method to multiple
randomness factors across in-context learning and fine-tuning approaches on 7
representative text classification tasks and meta-learning on 3 tasks, we show
that: 1) disregarding interactions between randomness factors in existing works
caused inconsistent findings due to incorrect attribution of the effects of
randomness factors, such as disproving the consistent sensitivity of in-context
learning to sample order even with random sample selection; and 2) besides
mutual interactions, the effects of randomness factors, especially sample
order, are also dependent on more systematic choices unexplored in existing
works, such as number of classes, samples per class or choice of prompt format.
|
[
-0.5504191518,
-0.7314168215,
0.2635674775,
0.0088189049,
-0.1574323773,
-0.2828027308,
-0.26899755,
-0.7685709,
0.0905084908,
0.4001255035,
-0.4923829436,
-0.0622751787,
-0.6758343577,
0.3893064559,
0.0045601623,
1.1939485073,
0.0514496975,
0.2459735721,
-0.3290296793,
-0.5737294555,
-0.3638476431,
-0.6357291341,
-0.3869203031,
-0.5376364589,
0.8956953287,
0.6247162819,
0.5645693541,
0.442242682,
0.8893579245,
0.2439057827,
-0.0682070628,
0.0375628807,
-0.635215044,
0.1782623231,
-0.4201585352,
-0.5645225644,
-0.2189777046,
0.2309642583,
0.7171458602,
0.6158672571,
0.1786752641,
0.3037652075,
0.4777309299,
0.401425302,
-0.616907239,
-0.0854080692,
-0.2825047374,
0.0138769224,
-0.2307849973,
-0.5470256209,
-0.5905082822,
-0.0641523898,
0.4047527313,
-0.5650411844,
0.4335420728,
0.1042872593,
0.5925636888,
0.4146336317,
-0.467559725,
-0.3449048996,
-0.8359279633,
0.8930948377,
-0.3385021389,
0.0711961314,
0.2651236951,
0.0873763859,
-0.1211463287,
-0.796913445,
-0.2363755405,
0.1282332987,
-0.1707471311,
0.1878694445,
0.3803009689,
0.1947565675,
0.8124573827,
0.1012245193,
-0.0044521331,
0.0684546456,
-0.4647209048,
-0.1589666754,
0.55971241,
0.2483461052,
0.3068167269,
0.1508480012,
-0.2889364064,
-0.3623634577,
-0.4511184096,
0.3865874112,
0.5520308614,
0.6461143494,
0.1808337718,
0.6569938064,
-0.3035318553,
0.6750213504,
0.0749116242,
-0.367020756,
0.4032406509,
-0.5686540604,
-0.0987257436,
-0.1134503409,
0.6864385605,
0.1176269501,
0.0208226815,
0.0759216771,
-0.1239851713,
-0.2617387772,
0.0387219079,
-0.7044277191,
-0.1440043002,
-0.0885829628,
-0.547152102,
-0.4535084963,
0.2880868018,
-0.7109932899,
-0.4157710373,
-0.3786363602,
0.5462322831,
-0.1856062859,
0.0282889735,
-0.1890669316,
-0.279673934,
-0.1116534099,
0.3110717535,
-0.7924969792,
0.4838998318,
0.2063067555,
0.4446189404,
-0.3063201308,
-0.4462042153,
-0.5133507252,
0.0568801798,
0.0429795124,
0.6260428429,
-0.9267100096,
-0.3691616654,
-0.1819743812,
-0.155221194,
-0.1907798201,
-0.4593279362,
0.4208138585,
-0.3628848791,
0.1590969265,
-0.5270752907,
-0.6365082264,
-0.30303666,
-0.2581528425,
-0.8400992751,
0.9910094142,
0.1412517279,
-1.0023519993,
0.8324351907,
-0.3927211165,
-0.5437934995,
-0.1398884505,
-0.2588838339,
-0.4557482898,
0.0683760196,
-0.2287284583,
0.3268666267,
0.1787542999,
0.1670404822,
-0.4995362461,
-0.3857579231,
0.6896370053,
-0.3768756688,
0.8398868442,
0.0022915984,
-0.3337603807,
0.0693331361,
-0.9781268239,
0.0869707316,
-0.3404271901,
-0.605935216,
-0.4926372766,
0.1703860164,
0.0210924279,
0.3903160095,
-0.1307566762,
-0.3080371916,
0.2384593338,
-0.0193724595,
0.1017534807,
0.7004329562,
0.3936579227,
0.6745973825,
-0.529227674,
0.3466024697,
0.2216655612,
0.1776019633,
0.1731960326,
-0.6282867789,
-0.6250014901,
-0.1886782646,
0.5598469377,
0.3434740305,
-0.5644345284,
-0.1735244691,
0.0532850325,
-0.1943607777,
-0.371058166,
0.3239428699,
0.5552569628,
0.4151311815,
0.2983708978,
-0.7392343879,
-0.4305818975,
-0.714530468,
-0.4102942348,
0.0419933274,
-0.0721851215,
0.592743516,
0.5229455233,
-0.1761324704,
0.9666349292,
-0.3915073574,
-0.1241585836,
0.0282908231,
0.4654242694,
-0.0999237373,
0.5132655501,
0.4885627329,
-0.7137614489,
-0.4617874622,
-0.2434990257,
-0.3023194969,
-0.1530128121,
-0.2890276909,
0.038659364,
0.189874202,
0.491453439,
-0.2146182209,
0.3345687389,
0.0246496461,
-0.155015558,
0.267890811,
-0.0382689945,
-0.0543618165,
-0.4710590839,
-0.0287517589,
0.0768648833,
0.1037439704,
-0.7632570863,
-0.009015711,
0.1612032503,
0.121698156,
-0.5923302174,
0.5632371902,
-0.2997592688,
0.2288164943,
-0.0615693294,
-0.1621453613,
-0.0878754631,
0.5205257535,
-0.0701008886,
0.558829248,
0.3066447973,
-0.6579332352,
-0.2477488667,
0.0001326727,
-0.2065685838,
0.4016713202,
-0.3643096983,
0.0660681576,
-0.283616215,
0.139573887,
-0.9475746155,
-0.4031980932,
0.5635359883,
-0.4259215891,
0.4999662936,
0.2579323053,
-0.5620443821,
-0.1316661984,
-0.3510149419,
0.4294073582,
-0.0164942592,
-0.3696116209,
0.5549142361,
0.0337746628,
0.1407088637,
-0.6640315056,
-0.5784705281,
-0.5884687304,
-0.2590382695,
-0.1878548861,
0.0052773906,
-0.4577599168,
-0.3721761405,
-0.1601451486,
-0.3762498498,
-0.262576282,
0.264257431,
0.3086028695,
0.0202709846,
0.1842541695,
0.3050467372,
0.0847358704,
0.0161001999,
0.1558030248,
0.1118234247,
-0.0154217323,
0.1741846353,
0.0373241864,
-0.0687565133,
0.0516228601,
0.2030908465,
-0.0423191227,
0.7357035875,
0.5076440573,
-0.1566974819,
-0.445994854,
-0.2879529893,
-0.410793066,
-0.4870440364,
0.2875443697,
-0.4060353339,
-0.9131042957,
0.5647706389,
0.1123125553,
-0.0355305113,
0.5178533792,
0.3990793228,
-0.2989225984,
0.8833753467,
0.8765261769,
-0.0179955047,
0.7062464952,
0.1117655933,
0.0459590144,
-0.7470843792,
-0.1319416612,
-0.5548444986,
-0.5499967933,
-0.8944689035,
-0.1326385736,
0.1578357816,
0.1249047518,
-0.1595284194,
0.0070615532,
-0.4271507561,
0.5942892432,
0.635917604,
0.5632575154,
0.4129006863,
0.0281366277,
-0.2622487247,
-0.0171493441,
-0.8683636785,
-0.0351424962,
1.3479768038,
0.3047337532,
0.7472769618,
-0.018279165,
0.7719879746,
-0.1332136691,
0.6041304469,
-0.4526320696,
0.2558762133,
0.1105335876,
-0.9681566358,
-0.6263117194,
-0.5057303309,
-0.8318208456,
0.1777334362,
-0.448733598,
-0.81225425,
0.4607665837,
-0.0267565195,
-0.4025396705,
0.0297327414,
-0.8031180501,
0.4152662754,
-0.0829251483,
-0.6260309815,
0.0551154986,
-0.8534641266,
0.4164499044,
-0.2180578858,
0.3257781565,
0.0709820688,
-0.0381101519,
0.9930360317,
-0.0148807848,
1.3091467619,
-0.0215384141,
0.0561479926,
0.4875316024,
-0.1012325138,
0.4561024308,
0.1842357367,
0.0504964665,
-0.0182400402,
-0.1697984487,
-0.4907506108,
-0.4485544562,
0.4697683752,
-0.8328897953,
-0.3217810094,
-0.5258648992,
-0.8625338078,
-0.2486562878,
0.4507274032,
0.6067382693,
0.4124281108,
0.0567081682,
0.1928458661,
1.0115624666,
-0.1400554627,
0.4170411825,
0.5302754641,
0.1089486852,
-0.3303080499,
1.0689644814,
0.6996980906,
0.4270156622,
0.4073518813,
0.2168356627,
0.0440312363,
-0.4604833424,
0.1328414828,
0.1223830432,
-0.7239322066,
-0.2384791821,
-0.444470942,
0.0456675403,
-0.1404394507,
-0.0839035287,
0.1357395947,
-0.4442850947,
-0.5820171237,
-0.1236945167,
0.2473790944,
0.6404387355,
-0.1773380786,
0.2766168714,
-0.4788564444,
0.1705632359,
0.5077063441,
0.639924705,
0.0132823009,
-0.5223745108,
-0.32424438,
-0.2372993678,
-0.4424363673,
-0.6563310623,
-0.1319898367,
0.2107937038,
0.6107389331,
0.5056596994,
0.1496320218,
0.3681664765,
-0.2818210423,
0.2464340776,
0.1172978207,
-0.5544657111,
0.3150833845,
-0.5178868175,
0.2156527787,
0.8968707323,
0.5156931877,
0.045884259,
-0.6162279844,
-0.9464207888,
-0.8476765156,
0.8561783433,
0.2731580436,
-0.2316748053,
0.0483211912,
0.4185426831,
0.2524634302,
0.1743481755,
-0.7223140597,
-0.5852661133,
0.1480334401,
0.0865992084,
-0.2872498035,
-0.503385663,
-0.452339679,
-0.4831447601,
0.4604821503,
0.0036098629,
0.0220206268,
0.2638475001,
-0.107668452,
-0.4091707468,
0.1637761891,
0.7667934895,
0.6954283714,
-0.3819646239,
0.083332248,
0.3183451295,
-0.5353578925,
0.0784821212,
-0.0285262596,
-0.4530244172,
-0.0896678045,
0.4826235175,
0.5283473134,
0.3658338785,
-0.3197691441,
0.2308809757,
-0.1510397345,
-0.2335199565,
0.3168734014,
0.4149034023,
-0.3131574988,
0.1940528601,
0.3137791753,
0.4158435464,
0.3375746906,
-0.3611551523,
0.4318287969,
0.2520456016,
-0.4198248982,
0.045133505,
0.3951216042,
0.1955537945,
-0.1536075473,
0.2526921332,
0.0196312498,
-0.1495587826,
0.9064278603,
0.4882991314,
0.4688307345,
-0.3237168789,
0.2575177252,
0.5012114644,
0.4674708545,
-0.225373745,
0.1714796275,
-0.0187377464,
-0.537145555,
-0.201134339,
-0.2368717492,
-0.6745327115,
0.0423074923,
-0.9658103585,
0.1124377772,
-0.4005002379,
-0.341396749,
0.116886653,
0.2755592763,
-0.8035604358,
0.4995419979,
-0.2269805819,
0.8368576765,
-0.9488264322,
0.5898741484,
0.7446084619,
-0.3753714859,
-0.7800911665,
0.0891835243,
-0.0676883385,
-0.3322120905,
0.4529323876,
0.1408786923,
0.2501618564,
0.0593868643,
-0.6515669227,
-1.1144882441,
0.8680682778,
-0.1043811813,
-0.6368818879,
0.5481715202,
0.2680922747,
0.5960209966,
-0.0395691395,
0.434104681,
0.4530456066,
0.5232919455,
-0.2881013453,
-0.5215070844,
0.1299108863,
-0.1164749935,
-0.1251083314,
0.167204529,
-0.8176627755,
0.5445500612,
-0.1563077122,
-0.3244345784,
-0.1383145452,
0.5541268587,
-0.0255986676,
0.4895621836,
0.1924726665,
0.3585655391,
1.0519963503,
-0.034459848,
0.9184146523,
-0.1146795005,
0.4066240191,
1.1691359282,
-0.1067250818,
0.5636432767,
0.6669788957,
-0.2354668677,
0.1343366206,
0.7560703754,
-0.1201335937,
0.7015985847,
0.3640840352,
-0.300737232,
0.1492617279,
-0.0937104225,
-0.3402904272,
-0.0177921783,
0.2041997612,
-0.3041849136,
-0.122206606,
0.3197996318,
-0.2459895015,
-0.1109441444,
-0.2764875591,
0.6407853365,
0.0621802583,
-0.5246264338,
0.2214246243,
-0.0781928897,
0.6878162026,
-0.4139542878,
0.1142682508,
-0.2321169525,
0.1246725917,
-0.4957190454,
-0.6786246896,
0.0140268886,
-0.3523748219,
-0.6393620372,
-0.0949933827,
0.8961957693,
-0.337272346,
-0.4200488031,
0.3049889803,
0.3149135709,
-0.1627277583,
0.4183080494,
-0.3648408353,
0.0325498395,
-0.0816618279,
-0.6370343566,
0.919529736,
0.6826841831,
0.0244112164,
0.4704465866,
0.4467348754,
-0.3829501569,
0.1073999703,
-0.0815789476,
0.8111298084,
-0.3826853037,
-0.1669209003,
-0.5555207729,
0.4682589471,
0.1200870275,
-0.6080488563,
0.8561204672,
0.3269597292,
1.1050854921,
-0.1357200593,
0.8028339148,
0.0180756394,
0.3810881376,
-0.274723053,
0.455050528,
-0.2825260162,
0.2972804308,
-0.4255660176,
-0.8164158463,
-0.4340512753,
0.2598145902,
-0.4023725688,
0.0435672514,
1.0055471659,
0.5467470288,
-0.0058314563,
-0.0299186632,
0.0924968123,
0.0453815386,
-0.1658740342,
0.3358951211,
0.4078705907,
-0.3594030738,
0.5549582839,
-0.7806369662,
-0.4756918252,
-0.1309138089,
-0.6443894506,
-1.1720175743,
-0.5075933337,
-0.3866561949,
-0.4181964099,
0.0132945906,
0.4861611426,
0.1003887802,
-0.7966098189,
-0.1018099338,
-0.1035473272,
0.4222073853,
-0.4429267645,
-0.2786059082,
0.2946258187,
-0.5178784132,
-0.5486394167,
-0.046561826,
-0.2451782227,
0.0651417822,
0.261090219,
-0.040585503,
-0.1381713599,
0.1592171043,
0.4707953632,
0.6013013124,
-0.1538276523,
-0.3459257483,
-0.1484648287,
-0.3557911515,
0.0476162285,
0.7890395522,
-0.5345214605,
0.4419594109,
0.578112781,
0.3747481704,
0.3156484365,
-0.0801794305,
0.2598907351,
-0.8768393993,
0.0565062873,
0.1088639572,
0.0470586456,
-0.2016384602,
-0.5724802613,
0.6850733161,
0.3306315839,
-0.6654005051,
-0.913612783,
0.2108146101,
-0.7426386476,
-0.4124973714,
1.1352837086,
0.0679215267,
0.0203313455,
-0.0652912483,
-0.0329710394,
0.2764841914,
-0.2901833355,
1.0059741735,
1.0795006752,
-0.478623867,
0.0444255881,
-0.7542815208,
0.6665506363,
0.5944057107,
-0.3920285404,
-0.1877688318,
0.2838039398,
0.2597078085,
0.1502240151,
0.6126109362,
0.1377831995,
0.2355154753,
-0.0502369367,
-0.1605530083,
0.0906819627,
-0.6118940115,
-0.4344440997,
0.1567571461,
-0.1185164973,
0.0667400211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12806v1
|
SymBa: Symbolic Backward Chaining for Multi-step Natural Language Reasoning
| 2024-02-20T08:27:05 | 2024-02-20T08:27:05 |
Jinu Lee, Wonseok Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable reasoning
ability as in Chain-of-thought prompting, but faithful multi-step reasoning
remains a challenge. We specifically focus on backward chaining, where the
query is recursively decomposed using logical rules until proven. To address
the limitations of current backward chaining implementations, we propose SymBa
(Symbolic Backward Chaining). In SymBa, the symbolic top-down solver controls
the entire proof process and the LLM is called to generate a single reasoning
step only when the solver encounters a dead end. By this novel solver-LLM
integration, while being able to produce an interpretable, structured proof,
SymBa achieves significant improvement in performance, proof faithfulness, and
efficiency in diverse multi-step reasoning benchmarks (ProofWriter,
Birds-Electricity, GSM8k, CLUTRR-TF, ECtHR Article 6) compared to backward
chaining baselines.
|
[
-0.1836258322,
-0.7678257227,
0.7128554583,
0.5894857645,
-0.4549590051,
0.2203423977,
-0.0280940831,
-0.3420784473,
0.0670378804,
0.8092298508,
-0.6819708347,
-0.6225172877,
-0.6753339767,
0.4476133287,
-0.4294379652,
0.8052566648,
-0.1164628342,
0.0593383089,
-0.0775574744,
-0.1690556258,
-0.6840158701,
-0.5922448635,
-0.8390553594,
-0.5056756735,
0.4425216317,
0.1383242607,
0.6605523825,
0.5446098447,
0.2903968394,
0.2903522253,
-0.2360902578,
0.4450028837,
-0.3632232249,
0.6906777024,
-0.2121565789,
-0.7834664583,
-0.3676978648,
-0.1993967742,
0.7467157841,
0.4189974666,
-0.4267806709,
-0.054074198,
-0.3345475495,
0.8760226369,
-0.8512284756,
0.3357410133,
-0.6263233423,
-0.1022859812,
-0.165657416,
-0.1608378142,
-0.7527106404,
-0.8651741743,
-0.5035451651,
-0.4914168715,
-0.292255044,
-0.1308560967,
0.5151193142,
0.337687254,
-0.4079339802,
-0.4112665355,
-0.8414222002,
0.7054780722,
-0.6688500047,
0.7049380541,
0.2837279737,
0.56176126,
-0.4881227314,
-0.655661881,
-0.5797524452,
-0.1899456829,
-0.0081933588,
-0.1094227731,
-0.3410136402,
0.1566009521,
0.3536448479,
0.1688598543,
-0.4406086802,
-0.185150519,
-0.2068826705,
-0.0833761618,
0.5669167638,
0.3155614436,
0.2544046044,
-0.0091234958,
-0.0120176002,
0.0407881811,
-0.9437889457,
-0.1809486896,
0.1052471995,
0.4258859754,
-0.0228884183,
0.6423156857,
-0.191520229,
0.937122941,
0.0172516406,
-0.4158936143,
-0.051582884,
-0.5358227491,
-0.299387604,
0.3700362146,
0.6173195243,
0.1174842566,
0.3875718713,
0.0010098702,
-0.2373509556,
0.3032791913,
0.1013248712,
-0.8638666272,
-0.1581357419,
0.1580213755,
-0.2940007448,
-0.1571147442,
-0.0970002115,
-0.5448640585,
-0.3800533116,
-0.3686170876,
0.3820731938,
-0.4237072468,
0.0126574477,
0.241504699,
-0.0367936864,
0.0677635819,
0.4347030222,
-0.5186454058,
0.5823720098,
0.8540815711,
0.8899793029,
0.4253733754,
-0.1570009589,
-0.8510304689,
0.4176298082,
-0.5995751023,
0.8794181943,
-0.797531426,
-0.3492688835,
-0.2641516328,
-0.0011525637,
0.0957798362,
-0.4218466878,
0.3143534362,
-0.3293451369,
-0.0294724405,
-0.1782394201,
-0.2409180403,
-0.2465196997,
0.3900429606,
-0.4914526343,
1.0745015144,
-0.346419543,
-0.5301516056,
0.1526039094,
-0.3589664698,
-0.7882294059,
-0.2916088104,
-0.2213876098,
-0.2943620384,
0.0388108902,
0.3953609765,
0.3076795042,
-0.5519866347,
0.3003900349,
-0.4986258447,
-0.4346120954,
-0.05461872,
-0.1729497761,
1.027938962,
0.1566138715,
-0.1793013215,
0.231172815,
-0.8746791482,
-0.1737616211,
0.2991813421,
-0.2851375043,
-0.5650766492,
0.0333545618,
-0.6849095821,
0.4804760516,
-0.0171942636,
-0.513856411,
0.4381302297,
-0.507445693,
0.369204551,
0.8855520487,
-0.00365684,
0.1351217777,
-0.0440668166,
0.5238880515,
0.0333669595,
0.0840940177,
-0.4595338404,
-0.6836223006,
-0.6663870215,
-0.0465757437,
0.0349536538,
0.4642345607,
-0.5594605803,
0.3358558416,
0.0560276993,
-0.6577048898,
-0.5415394902,
0.1101101562,
0.4929199219,
0.3936560154,
0.6061329246,
0.0172669757,
-0.7004759908,
-0.6807428002,
-0.3374246657,
-0.4346467555,
0.0909503326,
-0.0343557522,
0.4413767159,
-0.2978194952,
0.5592132807,
-0.5815369487,
-0.2357667834,
-0.5244351029,
0.1976787597,
0.5620672703,
0.3492868543,
0.0473427773,
-0.4961549342,
0.0124085099,
0.0341707952,
-0.8342181444,
-0.1788243055,
-0.3018912673,
-0.2957733572,
0.3356427848,
0.4717868268,
-0.9003580213,
0.4009751976,
0.3364573121,
-0.1669588089,
0.6216131449,
-0.3908278048,
0.0391111523,
-0.960934639,
0.0298794303,
-0.0425865613,
-0.1003155634,
-0.3871216774,
0.2537204325,
0.0492783114,
-0.0978257358,
-0.0497398451,
0.3221368492,
-0.5139106512,
-0.245383352,
-0.2270922065,
0.237859264,
0.0045204903,
0.2251247019,
-0.0705251023,
0.5427694321,
0.5151448846,
-0.7447453737,
0.6262809634,
0.2305551767,
0.1562172472,
0.6240899563,
-0.5823002458,
0.3153572381,
-0.1976426393,
0.7899728417,
-1.0517843962,
0.1147293076,
0.4341188967,
-0.2275316417,
0.1589324176,
-0.1942655593,
-0.7261069417,
-0.5250028372,
-0.2546593249,
0.4840009511,
0.2708355486,
-0.4858981371,
0.9596702456,
0.2886802256,
-0.1247044653,
-0.5858800411,
-0.7235645056,
0.3403585255,
0.0791590884,
-0.4900832176,
0.2427901924,
0.0497383177,
-0.255597502,
-0.2811565399,
-0.5233150125,
0.0677898675,
0.0295160711,
0.1949066818,
-0.0037957942,
-0.2407509387,
0.122912325,
0.5292477012,
-0.4552444518,
0.3831320405,
-0.4881043732,
0.5879749656,
-0.1397300959,
-0.4731381536,
-0.5104836226,
0.3218457103,
0.614133358,
-0.3167842627,
0.6383615136,
-0.0493871532,
-0.7559013367,
-0.2012401819,
-0.4480177462,
-0.1022187546,
-0.3868831396,
-0.147736147,
-0.6299381852,
-0.6425541043,
0.2832205892,
-0.2855401635,
0.1728749573,
0.1460947245,
0.5613096952,
0.1089762449,
1.1514679193,
0.467410624,
0.026161423,
-0.2339369506,
0.0157395229,
0.4587805867,
-0.4230344892,
-0.6844394803,
-0.8067088127,
-0.1565357745,
-0.5665823221,
-0.2570464611,
0.2080849856,
0.4689852893,
-0.414054215,
0.4628258049,
-0.3679729104,
0.5295484066,
0.3027078807,
0.1897734553,
0.6659258008,
-0.3571549952,
-0.4144888222,
0.2779211104,
-0.5090852976,
-0.3340874314,
0.7123846412,
0.1209400743,
1.1126229763,
0.2015531361,
0.8872260451,
0.0306926277,
0.2960208654,
-0.7042623758,
0.9335184693,
-0.2121001929,
-0.4321757853,
-0.1166932359,
-0.4201004207,
-0.8327401876,
0.2948078513,
0.0751399845,
-0.8718413115,
-0.004313516,
0.2045743316,
-0.1647481769,
0.3044131994,
-0.2993223071,
0.7065182924,
-0.1794147193,
0.0212731455,
-0.4971538186,
-0.8788603544,
0.5687552691,
-0.1313842982,
0.2406259179,
-0.0205960628,
0.1566613466,
0.6151248217,
-0.6840467453,
0.6223238111,
-0.0578920841,
-0.3828460872,
0.2002050579,
0.5412563086,
0.7599921823,
0.0018502474,
-0.0337577127,
0.1314618737,
-0.053596396,
-0.2685247064,
-0.7338415384,
0.6332909465,
-0.1901372522,
-0.7934204936,
-0.4737288356,
-0.4430706203,
-0.2514900565,
0.4086581171,
-0.1488681883,
0.2745769918,
0.3335956335,
-0.0739615187,
0.3286297619,
-0.2196830511,
0.1586909741,
0.1643060297,
-0.6835959554,
-0.6161241531,
0.6595109105,
-0.0372253805,
0.2495553046,
0.5548477769,
0.2689024508,
-0.5234826803,
-0.3597633541,
-0.3848949671,
0.4641212523,
-0.9650344849,
-0.3721529543,
-0.5140852332,
-0.1616981775,
-0.3262490034,
-0.0861227289,
-0.5505642891,
-0.4306297302,
0.1601687223,
-0.1478793621,
0.1880793422,
0.9182367921,
-0.0916189551,
0.0284908675,
-0.8913280368,
0.7756406665,
0.0993123651,
0.3203306496,
0.0158679187,
0.0080146836,
0.0024301112,
0.0613414943,
-0.3694623411,
-1.1118555069,
0.1616033167,
-0.1106109247,
0.466902107,
0.4821926057,
0.0730792806,
1.1375768185,
-0.3700414598,
0.5472586155,
0.4018578529,
-1.1829628944,
1.0255788565,
0.0131976604,
0.3542439342,
0.1950351745,
0.4473091066,
-0.5262114406,
-0.8185472488,
-0.1839934886,
-0.7298591733,
0.5686571598,
0.4010167718,
-0.2965002656,
-0.120799914,
0.1916350275,
0.2314078063,
0.0468099713,
-0.6372818947,
-0.290741533,
-0.1142876074,
0.0772573352,
0.2287575752,
-0.0213936865,
-0.0120974034,
-0.3052392006,
0.7110082507,
-0.0899816528,
0.2060641944,
0.0384413712,
-0.0710639507,
-0.2442857474,
0.355570823,
0.4836191833,
0.8463065624,
-0.1750055701,
0.4260342717,
0.080649212,
-0.333035022,
0.4138660133,
0.2970450521,
-0.1473328471,
0.0504212081,
0.3111822009,
0.4637307227,
0.3371016383,
-0.4576875269,
-0.0132170757,
-0.0089593157,
0.0870978013,
0.0080249915,
-0.001556004,
0.1595839858,
0.38419047,
0.3799290061,
0.0300529115,
-0.0536799692,
-0.4881638587,
0.103442587,
0.2674984038,
-0.0910507217,
-0.1643372625,
0.6456577182,
-0.021416612,
-0.267159611,
0.7425501943,
0.0132377595,
-0.527192235,
0.5160995722,
0.9424572587,
0.8707358837,
-0.2646916211,
0.1645079553,
0.3778845668,
0.50517416,
-0.2339340746,
0.5003885031,
-0.2615380287,
-0.46779719,
-0.7851474881,
-0.6620654464,
-0.4670954645,
-0.223679021,
-0.6157721877,
0.3822263181,
-0.5757064223,
0.0173275806,
-0.1044844761,
-0.4045673907,
-0.0688865334,
0.2205885947,
0.2290485352,
1.0417131186,
-0.512445271,
0.9040073752,
0.6114014387,
-0.4175773561,
-0.6854382157,
0.1800293475,
0.176812008,
-0.6349095702,
0.8659772277,
0.4569917619,
-0.6489249468,
0.0062706256,
-0.3435655236,
-0.5908743739,
0.9820349813,
0.7284011841,
-0.6634818316,
-0.1100617871,
0.1277863234,
0.3378134966,
-0.1680402905,
0.1754083037,
0.6545200944,
0.5886855721,
0.2871337533,
-0.7847212553,
0.507832706,
-0.0134474421,
-0.0486919954,
0.7194476724,
-0.4645011723,
0.5680781603,
-0.5830514431,
-0.4441134334,
0.2221450061,
0.7008073926,
0.9018636942,
0.5970879197,
0.3823208809,
0.9615600705,
0.8760973811,
-0.1946268231,
1.0688350201,
-0.1497656554,
0.1792369336,
0.9100167751,
-0.3037307262,
0.7205738425,
0.4718401134,
-0.3813911974,
0.7909647226,
0.5591828227,
0.2812599242,
0.3889145851,
0.3228545189,
-0.1877129823,
-0.7396785617,
-0.1302233785,
-0.530346036,
0.2369743586,
0.2631062865,
-0.1119196489,
-0.500692904,
-0.3209110498,
0.1889113635,
0.0004845804,
-0.447470367,
0.4579740465,
0.4487030804,
-0.6157035232,
0.7366469502,
0.0795745105,
0.2476740032,
-0.6378110647,
-0.3802482784,
-0.4277465045,
0.2370371521,
-0.1389043778,
-1.0315500498,
0.4523621798,
0.0171209648,
0.18258591,
-0.1289035827,
0.8174503446,
-0.0831061229,
-0.554689467,
0.5613005161,
0.2871260047,
0.0200627781,
0.0053195246,
-0.6182581782,
0.209195599,
-0.3252695799,
-0.0307434667,
0.0087839765,
0.5621910691,
-0.144343704,
1.2111310959,
0.8409548998,
0.0890742242,
-0.0607285239,
0.2086381912,
1.0317704678,
-1.0206258297,
-0.7271642089,
-1.2370778322,
0.2704183459,
0.1090883389,
-0.0421881638,
0.6265896559,
0.5810850859,
0.7677272558,
0.0963409469,
0.4887615442,
0.2107498348,
-0.051846154,
-0.7623080611,
0.4131156206,
-0.4401470125,
0.4777123332,
-0.4984387755,
-0.8863977194,
-0.6346490979,
0.5836278796,
-0.0748783424,
-0.052861914,
0.8274647593,
0.630028367,
0.0818686932,
0.4058900476,
0.0986337215,
0.5092137456,
0.3505173922,
0.8770041466,
0.9373257756,
-0.3480243683,
0.7352981567,
-0.2715480626,
0.067317389,
0.2371440083,
-1.0196783543,
-0.8040243983,
-0.3110478222,
-0.2301377654,
-0.6173413396,
0.4297632873,
0.904335022,
0.5027813911,
-0.8669570088,
-0.4223603904,
-0.5676913857,
0.6504932642,
-0.4796828628,
-0.1566352099,
0.1123789102,
-0.2601958811,
-0.2640826404,
0.4008069634,
0.7405389547,
-0.3004950285,
-0.2885111272,
-0.3706781268,
-0.4575821757,
0.093788676,
0.79971838,
0.1939046234,
-1.0015025139,
0.011888938,
-0.2479268163,
0.1432439536,
0.0814214051,
1.0147073269,
-0.9511534572,
0.3297536373,
0.5533582568,
0.7912560701,
0.6228689551,
-0.0894385651,
0.6308659315,
-0.4543819427,
-0.194721505,
0.1347928196,
0.4598377049,
-0.0120372009,
-0.1026433632,
0.4689233899,
0.593970418,
-0.2244878858,
-0.9423182011,
0.3086498976,
-1.0843352079,
-0.4706626534,
0.9778052568,
-0.1026389673,
-0.0443923622,
-0.1103895456,
-0.2220965475,
0.3682462573,
-0.4423456788,
0.5943079591,
0.5351142287,
-0.4317230284,
-0.410289079,
-0.0632445663,
-0.101298295,
0.1596931666,
-1.0482447147,
0.2360209823,
0.5975442529,
0.0188195445,
0.2162431329,
0.5258843899,
-0.2771002948,
0.2138036191,
-0.0687410533,
-0.3444028795,
-0.2605021596,
-0.6475830078,
-0.2053200752,
0.279345274,
-0.1629582644,
-0.0479175821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12801v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12801v1
|
Few shot clinical entity recognition in three languages: Masked language models outperform LLM prompting
| 2024-02-20T08:20:49 | 2024-02-20T08:20:49 |
Marco Naguib, Xavier Tannier, Aurélie Névéol
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models are becoming the go-to solution for many natural
language processing tasks, including in specialized domains where their
few-shot capacities are expected to yield high performance in low-resource
settings. Herein, we aim to assess the performance of Large Language Models for
few shot clinical entity recognition in multiple languages. We evaluate named
entity recognition in English, French and Spanish using 8 in-domain (clinical)
and 6 out-domain gold standard corpora. We assess the performance of 10
auto-regressive language models using prompting and 16 masked language models
used for text encoding in a biLSTM-CRF supervised tagger. We create a few-shot
set-up by limiting the amount of annotated data available to 100 sentences. Our
experiments show that although larger prompt-based models tend to achieve
competitive F-measure for named entity recognition outside the clinical domain,
this level of performance does not carry over to the clinical domain where
lighter supervised taggers relying on masked language models perform better,
even with the performance drop incurred from the few-shot set-up. In all
experiments, the CO2 impact of masked language models is inferior to that of
auto-regressive models. Results are consistent over the three languages and
suggest that few-shot learning using Large language models is not production
ready for named entity recognition in the clinical domain. Instead, models
could be used for speeding-up the production of gold standard annotated data.
|
[
-0.1518658102,
-0.7265661359,
0.8325741291,
0.1503020525,
-0.2065758854,
-0.0572594367,
-0.3722107112,
-0.8577775359,
0.0794730037,
0.5593842268,
-0.3769395351,
-0.6248768568,
-0.7119137645,
0.7451101542,
-0.1479839385,
0.7717269659,
-0.151011318,
0.482095629,
0.0762103349,
-0.1012341827,
-0.60133636,
-0.5144155622,
-0.9077680707,
-0.4476033747,
0.5724716187,
0.3081476688,
0.3775503039,
0.5016803741,
0.8682540655,
0.1918879896,
0.21265544,
0.1871965677,
-0.2271187603,
-0.0273479354,
0.1264749169,
-0.3882570863,
-0.4931957126,
-0.1488231719,
0.7848362923,
0.7124739289,
-0.0083571486,
-0.1149855629,
-0.2259306312,
0.2929833531,
-0.5671029687,
0.2389773279,
-0.7009390593,
-0.1042372733,
-0.2995175421,
-0.0618399978,
-0.6207734942,
-0.039887242,
0.3173541129,
-0.5095311403,
0.3339146078,
0.1335939318,
0.8943424821,
0.1396426111,
-0.1781851947,
-0.5065040588,
-0.6441479921,
0.603704989,
-0.6190197468,
0.5355799794,
0.6581870317,
0.2352665663,
-0.0753141418,
-0.6551768184,
-0.4963755608,
-0.3918193281,
-0.1729610711,
-0.0881942883,
-0.6826669574,
0.1770335585,
0.5561718345,
-0.1705200523,
-0.7956029177,
0.5687835217,
-0.3392825425,
-0.3820299208,
0.5557082295,
0.2625176013,
0.1812340915,
-0.11300423,
-0.499645561,
0.2056200057,
-0.924041152,
-0.1503556371,
0.0499471016,
0.579092443,
-0.0092964508,
0.4567060173,
-0.150247857,
0.6690487266,
-0.041503869,
-0.637839973,
0.0101081245,
0.0086410865,
-0.4784255922,
0.1807044297,
0.929015696,
0.1085873991,
0.2044298202,
-0.1788267493,
-0.1543782502,
0.1808607876,
-0.0530016795,
-0.7876672149,
-0.4461611211,
0.1407497674,
-0.2820889354,
0.1029603556,
-0.3515659273,
-0.466556251,
-0.468591243,
-0.006775137,
0.2929261625,
-0.5511310697,
0.1429221332,
0.3625251949,
0.0632737279,
0.0703325346,
0.613191545,
-0.7889587283,
0.5034864545,
0.4600524306,
0.8511406183,
-0.3931334913,
-0.0824120194,
-0.693827033,
0.0021747623,
-0.3796209097,
1.0375571251,
-0.544567287,
-0.3311558366,
0.1669802815,
0.1336494386,
-0.262983799,
-0.684864223,
0.310457021,
-0.6494752765,
0.0136574907,
-0.1544286311,
-0.658567667,
-0.0430561565,
0.1933327466,
-0.6987733841,
0.6138366461,
-0.1206087694,
-0.4438001215,
0.6852110624,
-0.346755445,
-0.3447342813,
0.5817418098,
-0.3335656822,
-0.4748755097,
-0.0373810306,
0.1941886991,
0.7343229651,
-0.208265081,
0.2466772944,
-0.1382517368,
-0.1726623327,
0.1491122395,
-0.3702445328,
0.5567317009,
0.0365743227,
-0.0061158473,
-0.3120005727,
-0.8176728487,
-0.1626496464,
0.2681111097,
-0.1952651888,
-0.3273160756,
-0.4149453044,
0.0706729367,
0.1326756328,
-0.159352228,
-0.4097831845,
0.3329156637,
-0.2855617702,
0.3695420623,
0.0355066769,
0.4405825734,
0.2831221223,
-0.1559351534,
0.736133635,
0.1297999471,
-0.2796877325,
-0.3126119375,
-0.591999054,
-0.6390601993,
-0.8213825822,
0.562318027,
0.5563922524,
-0.6546674967,
-0.1110038012,
-0.1892666966,
-0.2647098899,
-0.646051228,
0.0963831469,
0.5097115636,
0.6213167906,
0.4408676922,
-0.5109822154,
-0.4755254984,
-1.0277252197,
-0.0984181836,
-0.259044379,
0.0911664814,
0.3968009353,
0.7865424156,
-0.3024438322,
0.5597054362,
-0.3918521404,
-0.6231732368,
-0.3517969549,
0.3275806904,
0.0514645204,
0.2781989872,
0.5247693062,
-0.3088467121,
-0.4608179629,
-0.1171172932,
-0.5736287236,
-0.0726071969,
-0.1848777682,
0.2375483364,
0.3468878865,
0.2458548397,
-0.6586633325,
0.3541384041,
0.4356960356,
0.2199430168,
0.2985073328,
-0.1553147882,
-0.003075453,
-0.6129361391,
0.02192083,
0.0524747781,
-0.6082291007,
-0.7519872785,
-0.2736085653,
0.1927149147,
-0.1446311027,
-0.7115144134,
0.8111083508,
-0.6729222536,
0.0350878723,
-0.2947763503,
0.2928918302,
0.1911276728,
0.2450134605,
0.6645457149,
0.5986450315,
0.6897134185,
-0.700979948,
0.2114824355,
0.4233772159,
-0.3696303666,
0.5289152861,
-0.5402450562,
0.2628273666,
-0.0571186468,
0.3569531441,
-0.7745106816,
-0.6307285428,
0.2163845748,
-0.2603298724,
0.618878901,
-0.3137637079,
-0.6428362727,
-0.2890842557,
0.145810917,
0.2734947801,
0.2151763141,
-0.3948025703,
0.0630041882,
0.2349651009,
-0.1444678903,
-0.3947530985,
-0.9752985835,
0.2598181069,
-0.1713040471,
-0.3193527758,
0.3082284629,
0.1919281632,
-0.1468398422,
-0.2239138335,
0.0863718763,
-0.2920577228,
-0.0006463008,
0.0956886932,
0.5131059289,
-0.3718645275,
0.4623609781,
-0.2475471944,
-0.2253641486,
-0.1545619667,
-0.1473938376,
0.4634026289,
-0.0858669654,
-0.3184705675,
-0.6822069883,
0.5012797713,
0.0480289869,
-0.1788952351,
0.8899052739,
0.4728109837,
-0.9704609513,
-0.0195818581,
-0.6532387137,
-0.102405645,
-0.2998906672,
0.2109897882,
-0.514136076,
-0.9444210529,
0.5877067447,
0.109052293,
-0.1332560629,
0.606308639,
0.8027677536,
-0.0637167692,
1.0253413916,
0.5125424266,
0.1771135628,
0.2295065969,
-0.1566617191,
0.2577885687,
-0.6182716489,
-0.0850063339,
-0.5088580847,
0.1170630231,
-0.7179730535,
-0.2365522683,
0.5751507878,
0.1813554466,
0.2141209096,
0.4992890954,
-0.2091189623,
0.386528492,
0.2245429158,
0.0866217613,
0.5626403093,
-0.1035853252,
-0.0115544768,
-0.1150414273,
-0.7939255834,
-0.9112292528,
0.7524318695,
0.5336668491,
0.7704710364,
-0.047157418,
0.9596852064,
0.0933202356,
0.3550060093,
-1.0264998674,
0.3202013373,
-0.111824058,
-0.6746447682,
-0.0188686382,
-0.1310727,
-1.0683350563,
0.018187318,
-0.330896616,
-0.755063653,
0.3645203412,
0.0189122632,
-0.9551925659,
-0.0322074741,
-0.6668075919,
0.7455177903,
-0.1030518338,
-0.2124772966,
0.1548348516,
-0.5380066037,
0.4080636501,
-0.1725006104,
-0.0373461619,
-0.1776160449,
-0.2203863114,
0.6026676893,
-0.1348095685,
0.8393847942,
0.0764991939,
-0.013033621,
0.231785655,
0.1216850057,
0.5718708634,
0.2339831889,
0.2204309553,
0.3397938311,
0.1653526723,
-0.2602479756,
-0.3419695497,
0.5005583167,
-0.4519467056,
-0.4446737766,
-0.594389379,
-0.190950498,
-0.3458148837,
0.3700671196,
0.6587043405,
0.4506826997,
-0.3846188188,
-0.1734473109,
0.6747633815,
-0.2283506691,
0.4292562902,
0.7691068053,
-0.0210362859,
-0.3448639214,
0.466815114,
0.1779372543,
0.3579976559,
0.352091223,
-0.1386593133,
-0.1449330598,
-0.7069068551,
-0.4931435287,
0.5533533096,
-0.6745274663,
-0.6634935737,
-0.9899270535,
-0.1052477658,
-0.6246522069,
-0.1456176192,
-0.30878371,
-0.2771429121,
-0.4002196193,
-0.0196475741,
0.3183757663,
0.6800042391,
0.0989853516,
0.5363084078,
-1.0192316771,
0.2451594472,
0.0673632994,
0.2181204259,
-0.3745978773,
-0.3940434456,
-0.2510807514,
-0.3823430836,
0.021951247,
-1.2119964361,
0.6440185905,
0.2980187833,
0.5064525008,
0.4800020754,
-0.139618963,
0.7662122846,
-0.831289649,
0.6254300475,
0.2652396262,
-0.6868222356,
0.4912452698,
-0.1207783893,
0.1435214728,
0.6932688951,
0.6663304567,
-0.5261341333,
-0.2444551736,
-0.7179650068,
-0.3408265114,
0.7016569376,
0.1112350598,
-0.0371522233,
-0.4305786788,
0.247986421,
0.2534452677,
0.1570090055,
-0.6427439451,
-0.1024860218,
0.5244958401,
-0.0533085652,
0.1136842892,
-0.2213376611,
-0.1522304863,
0.2067782134,
0.6709815264,
-0.2744798958,
0.536922574,
0.5192516446,
-0.3840753138,
-0.308673054,
0.4137296379,
0.6872298121,
0.1945422739,
-0.1123097613,
0.1574904919,
0.4015212059,
-0.5068359375,
0.0081195841,
0.2307825089,
-0.1057367548,
0.349006176,
0.7918234468,
1.0281112194,
0.2134282738,
-0.6994907856,
0.4450237453,
-0.0796506107,
-0.0327689238,
-0.2458925247,
0.0316568688,
-0.2995482683,
0.3953422606,
-0.0338467136,
-0.0041378476,
0.2442744374,
-0.4497457743,
0.1064985618,
0.5819942951,
-0.2929223478,
-0.3091002107,
0.6161371469,
-0.1241027042,
-0.298145622,
0.5886260867,
-0.4009248316,
-0.4454466999,
0.4017791748,
0.6873913407,
0.8083440661,
-0.0685130358,
0.1794303805,
0.5430565476,
0.2657920122,
-0.3655106127,
0.0430074856,
0.1494033039,
-0.738545239,
-0.2610727847,
-0.3887662292,
-0.5133111477,
0.3488055766,
-0.5708058476,
0.6216633916,
-0.4577306211,
-0.4977894723,
0.4363902211,
0.1732527912,
-1.1675328016,
0.2650664747,
0.5579699874,
0.8545234799,
-0.8540207148,
0.7709697485,
0.7485864162,
-0.5763446093,
-0.6574611068,
-0.3224799633,
0.2272231728,
-1.0783236027,
0.7038425803,
0.2967998683,
0.0470975041,
0.0141600752,
-0.6107082963,
-0.7823982239,
0.9397858977,
0.2069914192,
-0.7676329017,
-0.1472396851,
0.1614355296,
0.8637260199,
-0.8174194098,
0.2912187278,
0.7311461568,
0.1751870364,
0.0843252987,
-1.1563382149,
-0.1717737019,
0.2906500697,
-0.1000501066,
-0.0743724927,
-0.4801810682,
0.414511025,
-0.4969182014,
-0.4795688093,
0.0795722529,
0.414585501,
0.5488954186,
0.5721310377,
0.2597223818,
0.2660009563,
0.9233672023,
0.0015756036,
1.1114569902,
-0.0990313739,
0.2739988565,
1.0297474861,
-0.6642934084,
1.0586413145,
0.225739941,
-0.1895124018,
0.3240083158,
0.6948745251,
-0.0770217702,
0.4242230952,
-0.1794203222,
-0.1501353532,
-0.3505848944,
-0.3891965151,
-0.0613217838,
0.6127337217,
0.4194204807,
-0.5298213363,
-0.1532195807,
0.3748230934,
0.2438339293,
-0.3215079606,
-0.1783474386,
0.9019300938,
0.3926995695,
-0.6848620772,
0.577685535,
0.0288585462,
0.2607268691,
-0.5195586681,
-0.0602532178,
-0.1012112945,
-0.0342262201,
-0.2486250699,
-0.4105314612,
0.0588779151,
0.335695684,
-0.1054479182,
-0.1251761168,
0.8692319989,
-0.6584467888,
-0.4397298396,
0.1337526888,
0.5807147622,
0.3979425132,
0.1009836942,
-0.5753531456,
-0.0258236881,
-0.3998787701,
0.0417262092,
0.3200467527,
0.3795888424,
-0.2472293526,
0.4487810433,
0.4080686867,
0.337634325,
0.0954146534,
0.3232733309,
0.44352898,
-0.5294090509,
-0.219619453,
-0.7621663809,
0.1714354455,
0.2553081214,
-0.2020319402,
0.4571261704,
0.459584564,
0.7382789254,
-0.1760287583,
0.4300306141,
0.3303962052,
0.5726277232,
-0.6897433996,
0.4008934796,
-0.3208081424,
0.194957763,
-0.2453682721,
-0.6197877526,
-0.760222137,
0.5411064029,
-0.4338536859,
-0.1496708244,
0.7377828956,
0.6516285539,
0.1402148902,
-0.1554108411,
0.6384890676,
0.1381639093,
0.1793960035,
0.6480922103,
0.6694799066,
-0.5339124799,
0.1099331453,
-0.2480400354,
0.0400339961,
-0.3149886429,
-0.8885372877,
-0.9492000937,
-0.315931648,
-0.6672621369,
-0.313577354,
-0.1179695874,
1.2150328159,
0.6769630313,
-0.9271389842,
0.3160430193,
0.2108807713,
-0.1719362885,
-0.0374660268,
-0.1754076779,
0.3897847533,
-0.33642748,
-0.7583140135,
0.4617261589,
0.5798757076,
0.1896434873,
-0.2471645027,
0.1107269153,
-0.1090445295,
-0.0180759579,
0.5120810866,
0.382666409,
-0.8704004288,
-0.0568790808,
0.2945300937,
-0.6506958604,
0.2385231107,
0.7344791293,
-0.8827249408,
0.6105542779,
0.3118403852,
0.5079877377,
0.4009954333,
-0.2540519536,
0.1258364767,
-0.7200210094,
0.0731871054,
0.4474841356,
0.6134089828,
0.4370428324,
-0.4090953171,
0.4607279301,
0.3065732419,
-0.4421659708,
-0.8662427068,
0.1394813061,
-0.8620967269,
0.2977948189,
1.2565534115,
-0.2893322706,
-0.0625938997,
-0.1852862835,
-0.1204010919,
0.1189436093,
-0.3756222725,
0.4978217483,
0.8695743084,
-0.4711356461,
-0.353220135,
-0.85522753,
0.6411733627,
0.1492078304,
-0.7889038324,
-0.2422721088,
0.6586613059,
0.2256518602,
0.157068029,
1.0023844242,
-0.1216784865,
0.2781439722,
-0.139676407,
-0.1908059269,
0.2266968042,
-0.4739736915,
-0.77222085,
-0.1086414531,
0.1807986349,
-0.0120998221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12786v2
|
Advancing Large Language Models to Capture Varied Speaking Styles and Respond Properly in Spoken Conversations
| 2024-02-20T07:51:43 | 2024-05-30T09:06:34 |
Guan-Ting Lin, Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In spoken dialogue, even if two current turns are the same sentence, their
responses might still differ when they are spoken in different styles. The
spoken styles, containing paralinguistic and prosodic information, mark the
most significant difference between text and speech modality. When using
text-only LLMs to model spoken dialogue, text-only LLMs cannot give different
responses based on the speaking style of the current turn. In this paper, we
focus on enabling LLMs to listen to the speaking styles and respond properly.
Our goal is to teach the LLM that "even if the sentences are identical if they
are spoken in different styles, their corresponding responses might be
different". Since there is no suitable dataset for achieving this goal, we
collect a speech-to-speech dataset, StyleTalk, with the following desired
characteristics: when two current speeches have the same content but are spoken
in different styles, their responses will be different. To teach LLMs to
understand and respond properly to the speaking styles, we propose the
Spoken-LLM framework that can model the linguistic content and the speaking
styles. We train Spoken-LLM using the StyleTalk dataset and devise a two-stage
training pipeline to help the Spoken-LLM better learn the speaking styles.
Based on extensive experiments, we show that Spoken-LLM outperforms text-only
baselines and prior speech LLMs methods.
|
[
-0.192252636,
-0.8839337826,
0.5072934031,
0.4304205775,
-0.3396039009,
0.1800221354,
-0.5268456936,
-0.3993447125,
0.2550850809,
0.7213020921,
-0.6408910751,
-0.5120144486,
-0.5108123422,
0.3084805608,
-0.3708239496,
0.7361819744,
0.1611992866,
0.4998061955,
-0.3107577264,
-0.0857172832,
-0.4324837029,
-0.5232969522,
-0.7949640751,
-0.5316458941,
0.235021472,
0.6130346656,
0.4828858972,
0.3472426832,
0.2774556875,
0.2356144935,
-0.2218579203,
0.2329179943,
-0.6122806668,
0.3559217751,
-0.1062415019,
-0.5117132068,
-0.4464739859,
-0.0897767991,
0.638011992,
0.4304645956,
-0.268471539,
-0.1392566413,
0.1295617372,
0.330732286,
-0.0231398549,
0.2930651009,
-0.7775307298,
-0.0096044764,
-0.0358247124,
-0.5302618742,
-0.5464765429,
-0.1975813806,
0.1690426022,
-0.4841141999,
-0.1355510503,
0.1077708304,
0.5715121627,
0.0687980056,
-0.5298960209,
-0.3914048672,
-0.798186779,
0.559307456,
-0.9544950724,
0.525945425,
0.3837415278,
0.2516437471,
-0.0481949113,
-0.559432745,
-0.5887376666,
-0.2704867721,
0.0326692238,
0.118771255,
0.2622214854,
0.1205576435,
0.0200360157,
0.0968555287,
-0.5330919623,
0.4417842925,
-0.1049734578,
-0.1377091557,
0.6887872219,
0.1990821213,
0.0016822483,
-0.2920700908,
-0.4736129045,
-0.2415220737,
-0.7780193686,
0.0466398746,
0.2376837134,
0.5267660618,
-0.4127306938,
0.2589352727,
-0.00985636,
0.7713989615,
0.0321119241,
-0.789075613,
0.0735868365,
-0.2461249232,
-0.3211365342,
0.1469979882,
0.8071535826,
0.4459264874,
0.5366106629,
-0.1727502495,
-0.2223173678,
-0.4017001092,
0.0886172727,
-0.7528817058,
-0.0631233752,
0.0891180038,
-0.2993805707,
-0.1714200377,
-0.2732707262,
-0.7752411962,
-0.4538551569,
-0.6636186242,
0.5144282579,
-0.3114823103,
-0.3469013572,
0.2325406671,
0.0484319441,
0.574111104,
0.3737920225,
-1.0482895374,
0.5037395358,
0.6647735238,
0.8332229853,
-0.2992293537,
-0.0910386965,
-0.5036233068,
0.0245166365,
-0.3783793449,
0.6154324412,
-0.7506255507,
-0.6251716614,
0.1819140166,
-0.0720650405,
-0.0875980332,
-0.6102223396,
0.4175902307,
-0.3905873001,
0.2332047671,
-0.1458627433,
-0.6520249248,
0.0397913791,
0.0379942209,
-0.215668276,
0.7455432415,
-0.0415757932,
-0.5535395741,
0.1028371528,
-0.2233280092,
-0.5031296611,
-0.0002619005,
-0.4078326523,
-0.4319606423,
0.0306817964,
0.0419116504,
0.6378617287,
-0.2234312594,
0.3762114346,
-0.2442879826,
-0.2912847102,
0.3360650241,
-0.3684107661,
0.4299711585,
0.0267171767,
-0.037411809,
0.3317841589,
-0.761490345,
0.0840009302,
0.3106736541,
-0.3997892737,
0.0118466895,
0.1594798118,
0.2360586971,
0.2332663089,
0.0921625495,
-0.4347610474,
0.1976919025,
-0.2309291363,
0.6411365867,
0.8654595017,
-0.1128431261,
0.4079391658,
-0.5330250859,
0.4603941441,
-0.165613994,
-0.2313467413,
-0.2994421721,
-0.3101368248,
-0.8754966855,
-0.2023745179,
-0.055239521,
0.7861678004,
-0.6244593859,
0.2667155862,
-0.1272212118,
-0.378080368,
-0.2883148491,
0.1031552851,
0.4033097625,
0.6589283347,
0.3454355001,
-0.2922632694,
-0.7831097245,
-0.7612817287,
-0.2418417037,
-0.4196097851,
-0.1459895521,
0.4406494796,
0.0688378811,
0.0829353258,
0.9757588506,
-0.2436715364,
0.1196226925,
-0.5760044456,
-0.0556408949,
0.0117176743,
0.1069066897,
0.2600829899,
-0.6847091317,
-0.4388905764,
-0.1647262871,
-0.5615700483,
-0.4076809585,
-0.3308112621,
0.1101348922,
0.105643183,
0.7012469769,
-0.1879434139,
-0.0549094863,
0.7435837388,
-0.0008453036,
0.5060103536,
0.0893033147,
0.0422847681,
-1.343655467,
-0.4142499566,
0.0761789382,
-0.5436509252,
-0.8716424704,
-0.3846799433,
-0.0497725569,
-0.3555079401,
-0.6224728823,
0.6623459458,
-0.2704843283,
-0.3272329867,
-0.3382777572,
0.2495376915,
0.1077373996,
0.60188061,
0.4692393839,
0.9980345368,
0.7337988019,
-0.7041850686,
0.5164729357,
0.490953058,
-0.5225160122,
0.6706556082,
-0.7028325796,
0.4440059066,
-0.1528370529,
0.4022206366,
-0.9977972507,
-0.3306443691,
0.0328734368,
-0.1597457975,
0.668859899,
-0.1324124038,
-0.3642122447,
-0.005638361,
-0.0644643307,
-0.1870983988,
0.3760288358,
-0.5354191661,
0.7479909062,
0.2516550422,
-0.6951746345,
-0.2902674079,
-0.5995775461,
0.1890341938,
-0.4250438809,
-0.8259996772,
0.3175472915,
-0.3031521738,
-0.3470407724,
-0.672996521,
-0.2822233438,
-0.1053468361,
0.1084995791,
0.0425280966,
0.1955689639,
-0.1529390514,
0.2734778821,
-0.0987496302,
0.0385860205,
-0.0614824593,
-0.1657852232,
0.9416350126,
0.1117719188,
-0.4628247917,
-0.6482620835,
0.4596963823,
0.4508711398,
-0.1396422535,
0.5031859875,
0.459543705,
0.158589825,
-0.0766616538,
-0.4404061437,
-0.4116129875,
-0.4769364893,
0.5227969289,
-0.2802988291,
-1.1398288012,
0.2694791257,
-0.0451248996,
0.3266072571,
-0.231468752,
0.6789026856,
-0.1746425182,
0.7758588791,
0.697298646,
-0.000794897,
0.7982264757,
0.1477154344,
0.1926515996,
-0.7448888421,
-0.5116855502,
-0.453635931,
-0.2582263947,
-0.5336370468,
-0.2579225898,
0.3190701604,
-0.0339485258,
-0.1138089448,
0.2214091718,
-0.1331785917,
0.2576250434,
0.4409866929,
0.2281390131,
0.2567115128,
0.1321514249,
0.0997103155,
-0.0870217234,
-0.4742494226,
-0.7682160735,
0.9266787767,
0.4599937797,
1.0432704687,
0.1517416388,
0.7259880304,
-0.087522164,
-0.0578399859,
-1.1074146032,
0.7124552727,
-0.0987412184,
-0.1906966716,
-0.2069824487,
-0.3877978921,
-0.5317858458,
0.3154052496,
-0.1250247657,
-0.7482831478,
0.0527847521,
0.1822848618,
-0.1614089906,
0.1002264395,
-0.6031901836,
0.4610284567,
-0.2777960598,
-0.1377657354,
-0.1183942184,
-0.7531157136,
0.0639639869,
-0.1058889031,
0.2033226639,
-0.2103048861,
0.0554113686,
0.7554395199,
-0.1803164631,
1.1057245731,
0.2543730438,
-0.358310312,
0.2330790162,
0.2068402171,
0.3556295335,
0.1168933138,
-0.143659398,
0.0632571951,
-0.0795293227,
-0.2818703651,
-0.6228119135,
0.4533440173,
-0.7955312133,
-0.9324606657,
-0.1248500049,
-0.6061820984,
-0.7049795389,
-0.2093970776,
0.253987819,
0.734649837,
-0.2653209269,
0.2219221145,
0.893733561,
-0.0549908839,
0.538739562,
0.8453454375,
-0.3355918825,
-0.3245790005,
0.6104006767,
-0.0510397777,
0.9294353724,
0.5427280664,
0.312595129,
-0.4489202499,
-0.5116147399,
-0.3368690014,
0.2030000091,
-0.7795298696,
-0.0103347115,
-0.6365044117,
-0.1624281704,
-0.523003757,
-0.0975184962,
-0.0453843586,
-0.4184243381,
-0.3762124777,
-0.1094540507,
0.5939030051,
0.541211307,
-0.1524198204,
0.5444813967,
-0.6070346832,
0.1765761524,
0.7219665051,
-0.0923074409,
-0.2903036773,
-0.9662281275,
0.1946185827,
0.0765545592,
-0.3445326388,
-0.9939425588,
0.3843152523,
0.5968419313,
0.4181877077,
0.3000323176,
-0.2422297597,
0.479073137,
-0.5907188058,
0.8539690375,
0.1674486846,
-0.9141890407,
0.6330750585,
-0.3139849603,
0.3319921792,
0.3611260653,
0.4189103246,
-1.0737963915,
-0.3615947664,
-0.4170667231,
-0.6222996712,
0.7621588707,
-0.0058391616,
0.4114791155,
-0.0095327673,
0.2120100558,
0.0514418259,
0.3372495472,
-0.697846055,
-0.2061856687,
-0.4539556503,
-0.1426171958,
-0.1918618232,
-0.2722489238,
-0.4364764988,
0.0577971227,
0.5455088019,
-0.2884618044,
0.3559296727,
-0.0298495162,
0.0177989937,
0.070410721,
0.6031777263,
0.6662958264,
0.7028494477,
-0.0495193303,
0.2351324856,
0.2487076968,
-0.2557165027,
0.1126205996,
-0.0334768184,
0.0362774804,
0.0416734405,
0.6009688973,
1.2144403458,
0.4019192457,
-0.7175920606,
0.3393943608,
-0.0746196434,
0.0318449475,
-0.0150482496,
0.2550611794,
0.4007499218,
0.2461733818,
0.1400826871,
-0.2317472845,
-0.1147371233,
-0.7940483093,
0.226402238,
0.3980410695,
-0.2720460296,
-0.1437576711,
0.2943046391,
0.3900684714,
-0.7775319815,
0.3589253724,
0.1071615666,
-0.6092648506,
0.625877142,
0.9513579011,
0.6378443837,
-0.3893572986,
0.2545987368,
-0.0230580755,
-0.1695362926,
0.0086751683,
0.3786727786,
-0.2639205754,
-0.7832891345,
-0.4186202884,
-0.6643826962,
-0.7999155521,
0.151036337,
-0.7400368452,
0.3630754948,
-0.5093514323,
0.0005770259,
-0.1452029794,
-0.2160504311,
-0.4062496424,
0.1398966908,
0.2522922158,
0.8137211204,
-0.9313158393,
0.6219280362,
0.6456602216,
-0.1015971452,
-0.9343927503,
0.1315233707,
0.3243796825,
-1.1246994734,
0.5361213088,
0.1010355428,
-0.2534892559,
0.0524776503,
-0.6515249014,
-0.7032192945,
0.9633075595,
0.4296545982,
-1.0135043859,
-0.0792089701,
0.1539177895,
0.3294354975,
-0.4672089219,
0.2084947526,
0.6124206781,
0.0663824528,
0.6472323537,
-1.3583076,
-0.4977104664,
0.3168214858,
0.0849218145,
0.0446719266,
-0.820057869,
0.6945675611,
0.0309773982,
-0.210437879,
0.1069872528,
0.6990026832,
0.3489890993,
0.1585404575,
0.3765315711,
0.2046651542,
0.8237137198,
-0.2439733893,
0.7654333115,
-0.2424896508,
0.1429574043,
1.3061279058,
-0.4118582904,
1.0128983259,
0.2430190742,
-0.0606275387,
0.2815343738,
0.7075926661,
0.3597487807,
0.5112262964,
0.1599245816,
-0.5800357461,
-0.5059460402,
-0.2415329367,
-0.2757309377,
0.7761833668,
0.3704254925,
-0.1915968359,
-0.0973287523,
0.1524486244,
0.4261607528,
0.2795245349,
-0.3323682547,
0.907035172,
0.4285786748,
-0.410897851,
0.6785095334,
-0.1479136348,
0.8047517538,
-0.8049043417,
0.251075983,
-0.2315217108,
-0.2234639525,
-0.2878557146,
-0.93486619,
0.1134580672,
-0.0192031264,
-0.1138752848,
-0.5620034337,
0.606995225,
-0.6836825013,
-0.3183985353,
0.2148198485,
0.3520286083,
0.1702335328,
0.3596290052,
-0.5045392513,
0.4025625885,
-0.018908754,
-0.0788088739,
0.4214119017,
0.3346630931,
0.2039176524,
0.8355867267,
0.2477594316,
0.0795327872,
-0.0681896433,
0.4932403564,
0.7241950035,
-0.2325017601,
-0.3854450881,
-0.7540584207,
0.2565374672,
-0.0415093563,
-0.3752785921,
0.5597396493,
0.2500748336,
0.7259184718,
0.1252965629,
0.5222947001,
0.2171044499,
0.5098341107,
-0.938970983,
0.2282228023,
-0.3891859353,
0.1374903768,
-0.2456044108,
-0.8696873188,
0.1286723912,
0.9307020307,
-0.2364373058,
0.1650464386,
0.5610696673,
0.9333909154,
0.1604625583,
0.3182875216,
0.4889594018,
0.2078817785,
0.5337024331,
0.4678373635,
0.7546753287,
0.0775392056,
0.4305743277,
0.1006751433,
-0.1592529565,
-0.1131596118,
-0.9338695407,
-0.906701982,
-0.5698087811,
-0.2721758485,
-0.3496809006,
0.1835213602,
1.0344913006,
0.9034531116,
-0.5000280142,
-0.4878655672,
0.1148012951,
-0.0994798765,
0.0364069305,
-0.1859640032,
-0.0912744254,
-0.319203198,
-0.8183633089,
0.8917925358,
0.5285845399,
0.2387333512,
-0.3483083844,
-0.1098327637,
0.0412382744,
0.4219174385,
0.663554132,
0.2161925286,
-0.6576395631,
-0.4062255323,
-0.0360779278,
-0.1674972922,
0.3172433972,
0.9232673049,
-0.4805275202,
0.3867972195,
0.2836441398,
0.5657944679,
0.5755429864,
-0.1598772258,
0.6236211658,
-0.8963999152,
0.225996539,
0.3809890151,
0.3007820547,
0.698009789,
-0.170743525,
0.1409230083,
0.1292228401,
-0.5988047719,
-0.4678654373,
0.7164043188,
-1.1407620907,
-0.1035409123,
1.5299688578,
-0.0092423027,
0.1561933011,
-0.0434068292,
-0.3623442948,
0.2596120834,
-0.3774850368,
0.4116283059,
0.8154066205,
-0.3042568266,
-0.2993533313,
-0.4035756588,
0.4336459935,
0.4810129106,
-0.8785449862,
0.0717841238,
0.3152751923,
0.5084590912,
-0.1580625325,
0.7671228647,
0.1484779119,
-0.06274914,
-0.2827811241,
-0.3145553768,
0.054144904,
-0.432826817,
-0.3213423789,
-0.035545744,
0.2093741745,
0.0140980976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12784v1
|
Understanding and Mitigating the Threat of Vec2Text to Dense Retrieval Systems
| 2024-02-20T07:49:30 | 2024-02-20T07:49:30 |
Shengyao Zhuang, Bevan Koopman, Xiaoran Chu, Guido Zuccon
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The introduction of Vec2Text, a technique for inverting text embeddings, has
raised serious privacy concerns within dense retrieval systems utilizing text
embeddings, including those provided by OpenAI and Cohere. This threat comes
from the ability for a malicious attacker with access to text embeddings to
reconstruct the original text.
In this paper, we investigate various aspects of embedding models that could
influence the recoverability of text using Vec2Text. Our exploration involves
factors such as distance metrics, pooling functions, bottleneck pre-training,
training with noise addition, embedding quantization, and embedding dimensions
-- aspects not previously addressed in the original Vec2Text paper. Through a
thorough analysis of these factors, our aim is to gain a deeper understanding
of the critical elements impacting the trade-offs between text recoverability
and retrieval effectiveness in dense retrieval systems. This analysis provides
valuable insights for practitioners involved in designing privacy-aware dense
retrieval systems. Additionally, we propose a straightforward fix for embedding
transformation that ensures equal ranking effectiveness while mitigating the
risk of text recoverability.
Furthermore, we extend the application of Vec2Text to the separate task of
corpus poisoning, where, theoretically, Vec2Text presents a more potent threat
compared to previous attack methods. Notably, Vec2Text does not require access
to the dense retriever's model parameters and can efficiently generate numerous
adversarial passages.
In summary, this study highlights the potential threat posed by Vec2Text to
existing dense retrieval systems, while also presenting effective methods to
patch and strengthen such systems against such risks.
|
[
-0.0251929909,
-0.8352446556,
0.6307910681,
0.0578137524,
0.0109970141,
0.0153161772,
-0.0449142084,
-0.6897121668,
-0.0438402966,
0.7847818732,
0.0102030765,
-0.1268081665,
-0.7177432775,
-0.0902872458,
-0.6294445992,
0.9188957214,
-0.1078653634,
-0.2227936685,
-0.4447049499,
-0.1236804128,
-0.5188989639,
-0.8606300354,
-0.5871841311,
0.2057257891,
0.4968406558,
0.4157384932,
0.653619051,
0.4013857841,
0.6165723801,
0.2783084512,
-0.0377024375,
-0.1905965507,
-0.9889439344,
0.4833717048,
-0.1544619948,
-0.537991941,
0.0917848349,
-0.1574445814,
0.6770352125,
0.2341177315,
-0.123512499,
-0.3095420301,
0.3295821249,
0.7076846957,
-1.0438061953,
-0.4946304262,
-0.8018781543,
0.1912921965,
-0.160878554,
-0.2350084484,
-0.619825542,
-0.3228372633,
0.4305074811,
-0.4518314898,
0.0904895067,
0.0915761143,
0.8101474047,
0.2436487228,
-0.414516598,
-0.3186860979,
-0.8783900738,
0.6922023296,
-0.0722081363,
0.2243293822,
0.6297985911,
0.3553685546,
0.1272318065,
-0.9673764706,
-0.1560403407,
0.0519500375,
-0.2886407375,
0.1230134293,
-0.2037991583,
-0.2668502331,
0.2426703274,
0.4162675142,
-0.4464782774,
0.2392321527,
-0.300852865,
-0.2624014616,
0.4040539265,
0.2753701806,
0.4141192734,
-0.1033816189,
-0.8784660697,
-0.1584468335,
-0.8105118275,
-0.0724035949,
0.4261885583,
-0.1451954991,
0.1333187968,
0.5324501395,
0.1407612264,
0.1101311818,
-0.2825640142,
0.4845386744,
-0.0882760584,
-0.7298132181,
-0.0262134429,
0.154058367,
0.4945379198,
0.0677116811,
0.0768956766,
-0.3097274601,
-0.2305022925,
-0.4627999365,
0.8531395197,
-1.0314141512,
-0.0197836943,
0.178971231,
-0.5217661262,
-0.4593608081,
0.2464979589,
-0.7097030282,
-0.4896230102,
0.0465449505,
0.6206853986,
-0.5820834041,
-0.202195406,
0.0459954664,
-0.3531443775,
0.1457735151,
0.3250806332,
-0.9195591807,
0.6115293503,
0.7815006375,
0.8652252555,
-0.1293712556,
-0.0299879219,
-0.2715187669,
0.3663904667,
0.0670797303,
0.4577655494,
-0.5074782372,
-0.7063704133,
0.2186073065,
-0.0309311487,
-0.0179414824,
-0.3767912388,
0.6109696031,
-0.6707704663,
0.2065462321,
-0.6064024568,
-0.5939937234,
-0.2015890777,
0.2934493124,
-0.8580246568,
0.7465043664,
0.1928955168,
-1.1229401827,
-0.0401606373,
0.124980554,
-0.3940003514,
-0.1322602183,
-0.0460884012,
-0.5515435338,
0.2589719594,
-0.1914044619,
0.2497017235,
-0.1020451337,
-0.5184834003,
-0.3891970217,
-0.4973944426,
0.3663624227,
-0.5112071633,
0.6736863256,
0.2179138809,
-0.020172406,
-0.36732921,
-0.4552104771,
0.2240166515,
0.0040525859,
-0.2689331174,
-0.8656237721,
0.0654527843,
0.163272649,
-0.1137879342,
0.3294158876,
-0.4748153985,
-0.1050753891,
-0.6349323392,
0.6380478144,
0.6246287823,
0.2535792589,
0.7834539413,
-0.0406133644,
0.2542356849,
-0.1401338577,
0.1442144364,
-0.0773380399,
-0.0925173536,
-0.0718339235,
-0.4683486819,
0.3488304019,
0.8133196235,
-0.5683218837,
0.0341488868,
-0.1932829916,
-0.4120006859,
-0.1488366127,
-0.0163235907,
0.5968827605,
0.1690069139,
0.1395189911,
-0.1786399484,
-0.535212338,
-0.8513385057,
-0.515573144,
0.0755533576,
0.0331011303,
0.569283247,
0.5523016453,
-0.301715225,
0.7091295719,
-0.5411365032,
-0.3629025817,
0.2742183805,
-0.4475027323,
-0.2433336377,
0.7208325863,
0.6415096521,
-1.0747693777,
-0.3705154061,
-0.0299510267,
-0.8345761299,
0.2971081734,
-0.0552863814,
-0.2725329995,
0.1699076891,
0.607504487,
-0.3876252472,
0.8313071728,
0.1875225902,
-0.2837800086,
0.3508225381,
-0.5403231978,
-0.0077788895,
-0.9548541903,
0.1079356894,
-0.3456509411,
-0.276972115,
-0.5992217064,
0.3854812682,
0.1264197528,
-0.2028814703,
-0.4896960855,
0.3790671527,
-0.3464500308,
-0.1372198015,
-0.2231994271,
0.1885897815,
0.2490229905,
-0.1145554557,
-0.2831661403,
0.5941302776,
0.2399499565,
-0.6726953387,
-0.3373249173,
0.3132226467,
-0.0844763741,
0.5474549532,
-1.0442355871,
0.3729388714,
-0.0142084286,
0.0106839631,
-1.0271123648,
-0.0360811874,
0.3088413477,
-0.5369475484,
0.6379884481,
0.0199725032,
-0.5991387963,
0.0876183137,
-0.6615666151,
0.7237873673,
0.1923627406,
-0.5713782907,
0.4446392357,
0.485438168,
-0.1723534167,
-0.7483714819,
-0.6718367338,
0.3401336372,
-0.1183207631,
-0.8004153967,
0.7659341097,
-0.0494692512,
-0.1083518267,
0.2198123634,
0.0543608963,
-0.1362030059,
0.6046625376,
0.4472629428,
0.0535936579,
0.358446002,
0.0019270789,
0.2847126126,
-0.48403427,
0.1021836996,
-0.3466388583,
0.2117860317,
0.0629492477,
-0.1886139363,
-0.1672915965,
0.6445791721,
-0.0236857962,
-0.2601600289,
0.9592776299,
0.6342585683,
-0.5805914402,
-0.0258693807,
-0.2876579165,
-0.2878833413,
-0.4241560102,
0.5538779497,
-0.1989599019,
-1.0231918097,
0.4297021925,
0.2276086062,
-0.1401974559,
0.2241054922,
0.6411508322,
-0.0685922727,
0.8820832968,
0.7449188828,
-0.0129831107,
0.5237854123,
-0.1273292303,
0.0835717693,
-0.7867211699,
-0.5118046403,
-0.8158091903,
-0.2015429735,
-0.7944649458,
-0.1614230573,
0.2844645679,
-0.0644812584,
-0.1408180743,
0.4711705148,
-0.555750072,
0.4612154067,
0.3851839304,
0.2615771294,
0.0294509754,
0.5551359653,
0.1371517032,
-0.1375231147,
-0.3590240479,
-0.4181788862,
0.9639841318,
0.4245680571,
0.7376965284,
0.5172057748,
0.8115944266,
0.2676512599,
-0.2400516123,
-0.4301404953,
0.1465213895,
-0.3409338295,
-0.7860426307,
-0.2757003605,
-0.4716745615,
-1.0234715939,
0.4311768115,
-0.3069064617,
-1.044888258,
0.2796086669,
-0.2546457052,
-0.2258661836,
0.0567027144,
-0.7238294482,
0.5228163004,
0.1087350026,
-0.7998082638,
-0.4386516511,
-0.5639771223,
0.178879872,
-0.1139257923,
0.0078041456,
0.452257514,
-0.3089037836,
0.5354319811,
-0.4295849502,
0.7088894844,
-0.028885385,
-0.1302022189,
0.3126092851,
0.346426338,
0.5024636388,
0.4645188749,
-0.0998472795,
0.2062643468,
0.4129062295,
-0.5083791018,
-0.4943482876,
1.038949132,
-0.8649116158,
-0.6623700261,
-0.3194830716,
-0.2422608286,
0.2230537832,
0.2949284017,
0.4752601683,
0.5154330134,
-0.3373365998,
0.6372612715,
1.1320654154,
-0.470502764,
0.3608183563,
0.3294916749,
0.036466632,
-0.6419130564,
1.0552299023,
0.3923494518,
0.2701151371,
0.5886003375,
-0.0119224126,
-0.3375397623,
-0.4902662933,
0.0265662596,
0.0130713955,
-0.587423563,
-0.1347015798,
-0.8296144605,
-0.2262614965,
-0.3953580856,
-0.1714140177,
-0.2426083088,
-0.4861611426,
-0.6372619271,
-0.1877372116,
-0.0415932201,
0.5282970667,
-0.0294878464,
0.1648952067,
-0.8007698059,
-0.0702695623,
0.1336707324,
0.291879952,
-0.0854333565,
-0.6757569313,
-0.4001392424,
-0.1024062186,
-0.2468532324,
-0.8065325618,
0.2704565823,
0.0008609442,
0.3538752198,
0.1106901765,
0.088691853,
0.1133774668,
-0.4658212364,
0.5893926024,
-0.1255646348,
-0.642019093,
0.3824715316,
0.1049182862,
-0.255782187,
0.6047711372,
0.3507611156,
-0.1425015777,
0.066370599,
-0.5219744444,
-1.0875822306,
0.3610100746,
0.6201638579,
0.4509280026,
0.0629021972,
0.6731239557,
0.1736796349,
0.0899455249,
-0.2262657136,
-0.0627525598,
-0.3079177737,
-0.0752873942,
0.2167771608,
-0.9516707063,
-0.1087774783,
0.1898828149,
0.4451583922,
0.295878619,
0.3283002377,
0.3758452535,
-0.3304338157,
0.3292669654,
-0.0311218239,
0.424803406,
0.0384681523,
-0.1831584424,
0.2600520849,
0.0601464659,
-0.8436175585,
-0.0145745585,
0.1561529636,
-0.5005061626,
-0.3198905885,
0.3065495789,
0.5794322491,
0.4435587227,
-0.2953947186,
0.6614117622,
-0.3858010769,
0.0193833262,
-0.6928232908,
-0.0395531692,
-0.4089902639,
0.0334189609,
0.2013848424,
0.1087832078,
0.4902861118,
-0.3160029352,
0.3073956668,
0.464877665,
-0.6330984235,
-0.3316985369,
0.6948313117,
0.0005486451,
-0.2978764772,
0.5462524295,
0.3226234615,
-0.3468492329,
0.5204411745,
0.530031085,
0.8754088283,
-0.1601412296,
0.071620129,
0.3483933508,
0.4307817519,
0.0683027133,
0.1297426671,
0.0762045234,
-0.4496622384,
0.2100885063,
-0.236355707,
0.0188380517,
-0.5478583574,
-0.830860436,
0.028990021,
-0.6732991934,
-0.2107244134,
-0.2411022335,
0.1050328314,
-0.6052120924,
-0.0537621677,
-0.0074938927,
0.892193079,
-0.3059347272,
0.4511423707,
0.307531774,
-0.5889486074,
-0.5047432184,
-0.0328919701,
0.0772814378,
-0.6415100098,
0.2740460634,
0.1837708056,
-0.0890454426,
0.0246793739,
-0.592020154,
-0.8851513863,
1.1229838133,
0.3291270435,
-0.3535728455,
0.046383854,
0.11064592,
0.4719666243,
-0.0360906012,
0.4450865686,
0.3292531967,
0.3032883704,
-0.2447505891,
-0.2450508624,
0.4561739564,
-0.02264769,
0.3100637794,
0.0537478812,
-0.498621285,
0.6196370721,
-0.1623619348,
-0.4315859377,
0.4196842015,
0.4810396731,
-0.1483090222,
0.3511436582,
0.2951526642,
0.7020281553,
0.6679483056,
-0.0154318465,
1.5836410522,
0.0009515533,
0.376773119,
0.8456637263,
-0.2985725701,
1.0644404888,
0.4549902678,
0.0061448948,
0.496728152,
0.2713937163,
-0.0152394651,
0.686720252,
0.1489394009,
-0.160540089,
-0.0719810277,
-0.070141457,
-0.5378786922,
0.2930295169,
0.528768301,
-0.559731245,
0.0411963053,
0.0886407867,
0.1888591349,
0.3332923949,
0.1753005385,
0.832454741,
0.2567282617,
-0.2611814439,
0.3626818955,
0.0096697565,
0.1407497972,
-0.2807711661,
0.1549862027,
-0.0549194776,
0.3916690648,
-0.3623978198,
-0.8348840475,
0.3722076416,
-0.3640140891,
-0.493440032,
0.022626467,
1.0166456699,
-0.1853970289,
-0.1444326788,
0.4746247232,
0.2098069042,
-0.0576240271,
-0.3355873525,
-0.474009335,
0.3377909958,
-0.0343165547,
-0.3103213906,
0.759136796,
0.4926639795,
0.0774845108,
0.4860298634,
0.46640113,
-0.3092215657,
-0.1470038742,
-0.0243482292,
0.850887537,
-0.5211336613,
-0.2856313586,
-0.9264752865,
0.3964903057,
-0.2201830894,
0.0865335763,
0.9398687482,
0.5396649837,
0.6240106225,
0.0992640629,
0.7402706742,
0.0316235013,
0.3432914317,
-0.6083705425,
0.9528564811,
-0.4666182101,
0.5141500831,
-0.2809028327,
-0.8027775884,
0.0015351332,
0.0893535241,
-0.2012011409,
-0.0699067861,
0.7794077992,
0.9245435596,
0.2351901978,
0.0722719431,
0.2380873561,
0.2335138619,
0.4647866786,
0.6129978895,
0.7422197461,
-0.7332130075,
0.8612683415,
-0.0345140211,
-0.1469130218,
-0.3275050819,
-0.5771700144,
-0.5927154422,
-0.583779037,
-0.241219759,
-0.7280015349,
0.1985197067,
0.0141234212,
0.4031123221,
-0.5049268007,
0.3224961162,
0.0898034722,
0.2789157927,
0.0920740888,
-0.2214078009,
0.3122268021,
-0.1430038512,
-0.50604105,
0.0149135366,
0.2600430846,
0.0999886319,
-0.2816854417,
-0.0280947015,
0.004872689,
-0.0400512554,
0.5588371158,
0.3359126449,
-0.3243454099,
-0.6897913814,
0.0105302092,
-0.4079449475,
-0.3709128499,
0.820587337,
-0.7556195855,
0.3856825233,
0.6812716722,
1.0544866323,
0.4934515953,
-0.1106419191,
0.4572814405,
-0.8065738082,
0.0660078749,
0.0539488234,
0.2808015347,
0.2269406021,
-0.8125232458,
0.556347549,
0.3149494827,
-0.6370803118,
-1.0360758305,
0.2780814469,
-0.8107188344,
-0.3644680381,
1.1451867819,
-0.3275396824,
-0.3420677781,
-0.0008352009,
-0.4195406735,
0.0194465276,
-0.0607247874,
0.6858718991,
0.4711199701,
0.6696631312,
0.0405038893,
-0.517278254,
0.3402990699,
0.3106315136,
-0.3892029822,
-0.1005616188,
0.1755827963,
0.325042814,
0.0950651988,
0.3781685829,
-0.5364038348,
0.1784894764,
0.1562730819,
-0.4157971144,
-0.0293274429,
-0.3122404218,
-0.2197616398,
0.3696358204,
-0.1589546353,
-0.0822787508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12770v1
|
Acknowledgment of Emotional States: Generating Validating Responses for Empathetic Dialogue
| 2024-02-20T07:20:03 | 2024-02-20T07:20:03 |
Zi Haur Pang, Yahui Fu, Divesh Lala, Keiko Ochi, Koji Inoue, Tatsuya Kawahara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of human-AI dialogue, the facilitation of empathetic responses
is important. Validation is one of the key communication techniques in
psychology, which entails recognizing, understanding, and acknowledging others'
emotional states, thoughts, and actions. This study introduces the first
framework designed to engender empathetic dialogue with validating responses.
Our approach incorporates a tripartite module system: 1) validation timing
detection, 2) users' emotional state identification, and 3) validating response
generation. Utilizing Japanese EmpatheticDialogues dataset - a textual-based
dialogue dataset consisting of 8 emotional categories from Plutchik's wheel of
emotions - the Task Adaptive Pre-Training (TAPT) BERT-based model outperforms
both random baseline and the ChatGPT performance, in term of F1-score, in all
modules. Further validation of our model's efficacy is confirmed in its
application to the TUT Emotional Storytelling Corpus (TESC), a speech-based
dialogue dataset, by surpassing both random baseline and the ChatGPT. This
consistent performance across both textual and speech-based dialogues
underscores the effectiveness of our framework in fostering empathetic human-AI
communication.
|
[
-0.4054503441,
-0.6954908967,
0.6693709493,
0.4638952911,
-0.2040513158,
0.0678390786,
-0.2021218538,
-0.2428670228,
0.3075964451,
-0.0058254614,
-0.9034664035,
-0.2572616637,
-0.1658671945,
0.4575635493,
-0.1859310865,
0.8612111211,
-0.2860516012,
-0.0163169317,
-0.1377504319,
-0.1863884479,
-0.3936145008,
-0.6357319951,
-0.6572045684,
-0.6067492366,
0.4464470148,
0.3341532946,
0.080281496,
0.2109090835,
0.2531219125,
0.2198885679,
0.1605148315,
0.2293420434,
-0.1956557333,
0.4527654648,
0.0994216278,
-0.517475605,
-0.4846321642,
-0.1886135489,
0.2532942593,
0.0543984175,
-0.4766925275,
0.0463347621,
0.1330077052,
0.5366930962,
-0.5225565434,
0.124374561,
-0.2373700142,
0.490444243,
0.2813236713,
-0.1237102151,
-0.5274665952,
-0.5031046867,
0.1767490357,
-0.6918001175,
-0.1305932999,
0.1846413314,
0.8477700353,
0.3709539175,
-0.251465261,
-0.3537443876,
-0.662575841,
0.2589003146,
-0.5059677362,
0.3048891723,
0.5805441737,
0.1930107772,
0.2825346589,
-0.2644434869,
-0.7767083645,
-0.3615784347,
0.0399647392,
0.4936935306,
-0.1413151026,
0.2401155233,
0.4788763821,
0.1960053146,
-0.4297099411,
-0.0645668507,
0.1990253776,
-0.3216721416,
0.2764023542,
0.3225909472,
0.1476288885,
-0.1581961662,
-0.2746495605,
-0.1561764777,
-0.3392370045,
0.1508609802,
0.0807798728,
0.0463408381,
-0.4997311831,
0.5190212131,
-0.2408538759,
0.2591043115,
0.4710794985,
0.2363499403,
0.257782042,
-0.0929496586,
-0.2797653675,
0.1457518339,
0.5504752398,
0.6624333262,
0.1769277006,
-0.0908695385,
-0.1275817305,
0.37744838,
0.3380563259,
-0.7180873156,
-0.056677036,
0.3678353727,
-0.3791661859,
-0.1101052016,
-0.0610219166,
-0.7533165216,
-0.5174017549,
-0.2828070223,
0.4402406514,
-0.4644074738,
-0.3409767747,
-0.2354219407,
-0.0299178995,
0.2275910527,
0.6589078307,
-0.5756136775,
0.078781642,
0.5346165895,
0.7962234616,
0.2911260724,
-0.382789433,
-0.2342561483,
0.0917109475,
-0.1601727903,
0.675472796,
-0.4600055516,
-0.3253869712,
0.0985820889,
-0.1397277117,
0.0694473237,
-0.2139893919,
0.737007916,
-0.0776640847,
0.0888984427,
-0.409014076,
-0.484225899,
-0.0925946161,
0.7758922577,
-0.3240113556,
0.6947200894,
0.0903221741,
-0.6242245436,
0.3823119402,
-0.9879260063,
-0.4507706165,
-0.1190415993,
0.0199315101,
-0.1257327646,
0.2784740627,
0.3109526932,
0.2922941446,
-0.1525235325,
0.0328091644,
-0.2387221009,
-0.194153145,
0.3272837698,
-0.3829808533,
0.3424676657,
0.4495170116,
-0.2930304706,
-0.0645758808,
-0.7237843871,
0.1013008282,
0.0044446099,
-0.3973473012,
-0.0940803662,
-0.3400156498,
0.0726328865,
0.371797055,
-0.0752083585,
-1.0153976679,
-0.0626925901,
-0.2898008823,
0.4859022796,
0.7460910678,
0.1874216199,
0.1466645002,
-0.3972737491,
0.5920827985,
0.3690371811,
0.1295977235,
-0.7689077854,
-0.22433649,
-0.7379699945,
-0.011931492,
0.0673656911,
0.5715835094,
-0.6648440361,
0.6594979167,
-0.0328666344,
-0.6950662136,
-0.8001852632,
-0.4517900944,
0.3492073119,
0.7304396033,
0.1871552169,
-0.4327567518,
-0.6751228571,
-0.5887727141,
-0.117165409,
-0.5692968369,
-0.1921316385,
0.6033479571,
0.1723878235,
-0.1573414803,
0.939011097,
-0.1001860499,
-0.0246710349,
-0.0368591696,
0.5634277463,
-0.2326494008,
0.4251142442,
0.2315515876,
-0.4993547499,
-0.4016509652,
-0.035932526,
-0.6927223206,
-0.2508479059,
-0.1157501563,
-0.1864681393,
0.2848194838,
0.0412257463,
-0.421590358,
0.5833982229,
0.4524603784,
-0.5860664248,
0.1994956881,
-0.1144225076,
0.825116992,
-1.1173592806,
0.0813241377,
-0.0362989344,
-0.5044285059,
-0.4671761692,
-0.4397374988,
-0.1247350723,
-0.1736875474,
-0.2245385796,
0.4328610897,
0.1022660062,
0.1590244919,
-0.1925616264,
0.27167961,
0.0462374575,
0.6234275699,
0.2854675949,
0.0943847299,
0.4129642546,
-0.5618727207,
0.6069869399,
0.7161570191,
0.0094108935,
1.271458745,
-0.6269059181,
0.3976455331,
-0.2007631361,
0.6603699327,
-0.9129974246,
-0.1675826311,
0.3705313206,
-0.6196196675,
0.0555946603,
0.0418304279,
-0.3297827244,
-0.3662558496,
0.0062472969,
0.3195083439,
0.4840476513,
-0.6161981225,
1.09852314,
0.1313841641,
-0.1759674102,
-0.2115830779,
-0.7037329674,
0.1010773331,
-0.0938572064,
-0.5586700439,
-0.2040439248,
-0.3375571668,
-0.1096149087,
-0.216231212,
0.114346087,
0.0729166493,
0.1036669612,
0.5076291561,
-0.0161440596,
-0.0080670798,
0.2002354413,
0.1298105568,
-0.1592089385,
0.2390506715,
0.2341667414,
0.7010725737,
-0.192064479,
-0.5143980384,
-0.8437368274,
0.3755413592,
0.5002699494,
-0.0878560022,
0.397413969,
0.7170286775,
-0.641923666,
0.1037146598,
-0.5312365294,
-0.4472520053,
-0.3476685882,
0.1684711576,
-0.259257555,
-0.7981114984,
0.5133158565,
-0.1242056191,
0.0940202624,
0.2371773422,
0.9241791964,
-0.1731303781,
1.3355873823,
0.385086,
-0.0765654743,
0.4144576192,
0.3702094555,
0.3704095781,
-0.9433987737,
-0.1743796319,
-0.663331449,
-0.2390689552,
-0.4899083972,
0.0196852479,
0.2934792936,
-0.5490604639,
-0.6105434299,
-0.1141762584,
-0.2147546411,
-0.0221860893,
0.3889312744,
0.4187816083,
0.0789833665,
-0.0969069749,
-0.1953521371,
-0.113668412,
-0.4481377304,
-0.4688112736,
0.7087348104,
0.6284769773,
0.770601511,
-0.0050263284,
0.9830786586,
0.4278147221,
0.744692862,
-0.8046283126,
0.4057703018,
0.4041779339,
-0.4953230619,
-0.0895501822,
-0.3057501316,
-0.4680869281,
-0.1721131951,
-0.1546401978,
-1.0379840136,
-0.027322825,
0.3409543931,
-0.6136600971,
-0.0774739906,
-0.7257884145,
0.4301298261,
-0.1932966858,
-0.2516666353,
-0.320122242,
-0.7011591792,
-0.0845236182,
0.0822308809,
-0.0019511874,
-0.2049142569,
0.2732195556,
0.7767615318,
-0.3114730716,
0.8542539477,
-0.4268052578,
0.0138963284,
0.2038722038,
0.3107562363,
0.45703125,
0.0189505294,
0.0561100543,
-0.1263628006,
-0.1012713313,
0.0050444817,
-0.6016710401,
0.391859889,
-0.8099663854,
-0.3544824123,
-0.2801401615,
-0.3336551785,
-0.498132199,
0.0023842296,
0.1593375206,
0.1941927075,
-0.3559467793,
0.1039562672,
0.467653662,
-0.1859761924,
0.1785161942,
0.5425687432,
-0.2188609242,
-0.3493729234,
0.6724714041,
-0.493663013,
0.1268144846,
0.3152913153,
0.3105573654,
-0.1979857534,
0.2625813782,
-0.3073934913,
0.105702132,
-0.7100192904,
-0.3821459413,
-0.6383606195,
0.0309759062,
-0.2761809826,
-0.2633114755,
-0.3802691698,
-0.3579137325,
-0.0358478054,
-0.3811092675,
0.4124910235,
0.9104304314,
-0.3205249012,
0.2229553461,
-0.9414331913,
0.119919017,
0.0130273663,
0.3328341246,
0.2554193735,
-0.5436865687,
-0.2774557769,
0.3604600132,
-0.3994308412,
-0.8139288425,
0.2385302782,
0.1894625574,
0.2366628051,
0.5181979537,
-0.0539415926,
0.6416686773,
-0.3621783257,
1.0799126625,
0.3432768881,
-1.1815513372,
1.0237736702,
-0.2904914916,
0.1598097831,
0.5097595453,
0.2148446441,
-0.9030556679,
-0.5219445825,
-0.8615168333,
-0.8217690587,
0.7902201414,
0.1786792427,
0.2252408713,
0.0787033215,
0.4599850774,
-0.09028624,
0.3062501252,
-0.5759093761,
-0.2324287891,
-0.4387886524,
-0.6568827629,
0.0586591586,
-0.122295998,
-0.4867282212,
-0.0135755381,
0.698577106,
-0.2355187684,
0.7701877952,
0.4665780365,
-0.1090225205,
-0.393553704,
0.2250415087,
0.459466368,
0.0947320163,
-0.1218023971,
-0.1402288526,
0.0037817946,
-0.3030759692,
0.3414457142,
0.0506068803,
0.1428368092,
-0.2534824312,
0.068744719,
0.7655405402,
-0.097357206,
-0.5889204741,
0.3901450634,
-0.4994119108,
0.0244326666,
0.0611389652,
-0.1072358936,
-0.1835242063,
0.3576955199,
0.0875224769,
0.0094981976,
0.1577820778,
-0.3349807858,
0.2393398285,
-0.1752384454,
-0.4292984307,
-0.5691606998,
0.3491089642,
0.5033754706,
-0.4009301364,
0.7602183819,
-0.0405106582,
-0.8848074675,
0.4037874341,
0.5691762567,
1.0457628965,
-0.4233443141,
0.2866590023,
0.559047997,
0.0375283808,
0.0419301167,
0.5195126534,
-0.4909534454,
-0.9815947413,
0.2446209192,
-0.5046008825,
-0.7795267701,
-0.3877365291,
-0.9896915555,
-0.0744077712,
-0.5230922103,
-0.2942917645,
-0.4293075204,
-0.2213965207,
-0.9875136018,
0.4011735916,
0.5884878635,
0.9414520264,
-1.179122448,
0.2297175974,
0.8758098483,
-0.4515321851,
-1.1155542135,
0.1181942597,
0.193338275,
-0.9221644402,
0.3681413531,
0.2452716827,
-0.1334442794,
0.0117716193,
-0.3335026801,
-0.2691525817,
1.0180540085,
0.1069713235,
-0.4525431991,
0.1319816411,
0.0998143479,
0.7503741384,
-0.6050605178,
0.7131040692,
0.532569766,
0.5805119276,
0.0331053734,
-1.112459898,
0.1041005626,
-0.3889800608,
-0.0908919647,
-0.2373849154,
-0.87811023,
0.3108904362,
-0.0675844476,
-0.1023150086,
0.281965971,
0.5971564054,
0.5098636746,
0.4160256088,
0.6776999831,
0.6489785314,
0.9603062868,
-0.5371828079,
0.8657200336,
-0.4051958323,
0.2958244383,
0.8419231772,
-0.5134785771,
0.91497612,
0.4837501645,
-0.1002048329,
0.6204015017,
0.8017758727,
0.1634839028,
0.3133218288,
-0.0411699116,
-0.3924026489,
-0.1904807687,
-0.670627594,
-0.1678551733,
0.5184441209,
0.4306185246,
-0.3785640299,
-0.0607685968,
0.3095035255,
-0.03460785,
-0.1072863489,
-0.4685035944,
0.9569700956,
0.0665504932,
-0.7947817445,
0.0712957978,
-0.1685010195,
0.445933789,
-0.4772327542,
0.0425751507,
-0.3236087561,
0.1587027013,
-0.1831396669,
-0.7692320347,
-0.1161131188,
0.3519812822,
-0.0969373882,
-0.2840511799,
0.5047426224,
-0.5583899617,
-0.1186233386,
0.0052789915,
0.4568397105,
-0.0452048294,
0.1291581541,
-0.6285835505,
0.2259058058,
-0.0291110557,
-0.4421954155,
0.0477682017,
0.6556415558,
0.47699368,
0.5446859002,
0.2343588918,
-0.0849700645,
-0.2689258456,
0.4807706773,
0.7364597321,
-0.5257593989,
-0.9851467013,
-0.6241469979,
0.6831818819,
0.0831775516,
-0.1920736581,
0.5015493035,
0.0820659623,
0.5055014491,
0.0865184218,
1.019459486,
-0.2954079211,
0.5536484122,
-0.4385945797,
0.4569172561,
-0.3658926785,
-0.1020054147,
-0.3817026913,
-0.6411140561,
-0.0579679385,
1.0041172504,
-0.0102271456,
0.500108242,
0.5870804787,
0.5698327422,
0.4374282062,
0.4951997101,
0.2248579264,
0.4881989062,
0.511251092,
0.8238587379,
1.2632858753,
-0.2204413116,
0.0888625011,
-0.183857128,
-0.459885478,
-0.1611662507,
-1.0733629465,
-0.6118704677,
-0.6198803186,
-0.2455124557,
-0.6499211788,
-0.0500643887,
1.4815599918,
0.4500005841,
-0.6011051536,
-0.0125548141,
0.0845847577,
-0.3283408284,
-0.1201014221,
-0.2487367243,
-0.1004129201,
-0.1492197216,
-0.5666264892,
0.0132439705,
0.4366974235,
0.0931959525,
-0.1494626552,
-0.4120405316,
0.1502406448,
0.0989121795,
0.4625427723,
0.2691139281,
-0.5136033297,
-0.4481598437,
-0.1034702659,
0.1050704867,
0.2944012582,
1.1406604052,
-0.5668469667,
0.4852724075,
0.1661140472,
0.6592971683,
0.0741965622,
0.2308367491,
0.9025835991,
-0.7609799504,
0.0433064625,
0.4240043163,
0.5145990849,
0.474003613,
-0.575568378,
0.253423661,
0.1155690476,
-0.7205982804,
-0.8360674381,
0.2723382115,
-1.0184705257,
0.6129204035,
0.9459996223,
-0.6126245856,
-0.1475777626,
0.0889963284,
-0.5203729272,
0.3863247335,
-0.7343598604,
0.8263978362,
1.1323546171,
-0.4883789122,
-0.2398181856,
0.1826117188,
0.4600116313,
0.3680669069,
-1.1166408062,
0.4325763881,
0.4952935576,
-0.0011205608,
0.2636257708,
0.5937572122,
0.1265936196,
0.581626296,
-0.048363179,
-0.0336274318,
0.0430641733,
-0.2672045529,
-0.4582198262,
-0.1012425795,
0.2123178542,
0.0441689342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12750v1
|
Model Composition for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T06:38:10 | 2024-02-20T06:38:10 |
Chi Chen, Yiyang Du, Zheng Fang, Ziyue Wang, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent developments in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have shown
rapid progress, moving towards the goal of creating versatile MLLMs that
understand inputs from various modalities. However, existing methods typically
rely on joint training with paired multimodal instruction data, which is
resource-intensive and challenging to extend to new modalities. In this paper,
we propose a new paradigm through the model composition of existing MLLMs to
create a new model that retains the modal understanding capabilities of each
original model. Our basic implementation, NaiveMC, demonstrates the
effectiveness of this paradigm by reusing modality encoders and merging LLM
parameters. Furthermore, we introduce DAMC to address parameter interference
and mismatch issues during the merging process, thereby enhancing the model
performance. To facilitate research in this area, we propose MCUB, a benchmark
for assessing ability of MLLMs to understand inputs from diverse modalities.
Experiments on this benchmark and four other multimodal understanding tasks
show significant improvements over baselines, proving that model composition
can create a versatile model capable of processing inputs from multiple
modalities.
|
[
-0.5011912584,
-0.8132770658,
0.5231712461,
0.2694528699,
-0.145517379,
0.2666227818,
-0.3967285752,
-0.2896728218,
-0.1850839406,
0.3847189248,
-0.4488122165,
-0.3151669502,
-0.4992179871,
-0.0037637809,
-0.0503297821,
0.9718410969,
-0.1427561641,
0.3388754725,
-0.482201755,
-0.2404780686,
-0.6432508826,
-0.2861440778,
-0.2712217867,
-0.1171115711,
0.7810787559,
0.3275264204,
0.5561062098,
0.4679283202,
0.4177865982,
0.3448490202,
0.031074632,
0.6037225127,
-0.2718678713,
0.2726727426,
-0.1147284657,
-0.3208147585,
-0.6421844363,
0.0210284572,
1.149454236,
0.9838477969,
-0.0714377835,
0.0031610408,
0.1627780944,
0.2646741271,
-1.0145887136,
0.1364511847,
-0.5785860419,
-0.1097794473,
0.1193058044,
-0.0480004102,
-0.7483016849,
0.2185738236,
-0.1334736943,
-0.3747142851,
0.0086950446,
0.004970572,
0.2907086015,
-0.0074815946,
-0.879991889,
-0.1039270014,
-0.651725769,
0.9365224242,
-0.7502126694,
0.9572612643,
0.2602484822,
0.353009671,
0.001957861,
-0.5457246304,
-0.6029007435,
-0.6641251445,
-0.0580506399,
0.0445777327,
0.0759202018,
0.0008972069,
0.0553712212,
0.1105767712,
-0.6267716289,
0.1167078912,
-0.2634483576,
-0.3206174076,
0.3088147938,
0.451911658,
0.2443251014,
-0.2608937025,
-0.5390024781,
-0.0377021097,
-0.3570774794,
0.0253086686,
0.2358357161,
0.3582406342,
-0.4015907347,
0.6118681431,
-0.0578668676,
1.088814497,
-0.2019506842,
-0.6044633389,
0.1655076444,
-0.6228874922,
-0.3569687605,
-0.253179729,
0.7498260736,
0.2747047544,
-0.1047157571,
-0.2143090218,
-0.3285137415,
-0.1930837184,
0.2895852923,
-0.7192595005,
-0.2018021643,
-0.0342497304,
-0.448569417,
-0.2503871918,
-0.1887118965,
-0.4861290753,
-0.3964962065,
-0.7617720962,
0.4007765651,
-0.4322504103,
-0.4816875458,
-0.0991531983,
0.2181813121,
0.049749542,
0.3590491712,
-0.9457506537,
0.0887589976,
0.6331466436,
0.8123647571,
-0.1499094665,
-0.4408263862,
-0.6099652052,
0.4677315354,
-0.1741653532,
0.5283887982,
-0.8016100526,
-0.2941043973,
-0.2023436427,
0.0241075382,
-0.317379117,
-0.2475475669,
0.2594919801,
-0.5109702349,
0.1737732291,
-0.097109586,
-0.4436131716,
-0.3328051269,
0.5814803839,
-0.7256282568,
0.7907783985,
0.1753373742,
-0.62686342,
0.252536267,
-0.3744620681,
-0.515252769,
-0.111053668,
-0.0481303893,
-0.1100955009,
0.3251567185,
0.2894872725,
0.7316989303,
-0.2533566058,
0.4151570499,
-0.6065965295,
-0.0250971317,
0.790543735,
-0.8330720067,
0.6219220757,
0.3846801817,
0.2362100929,
0.30155316,
-0.9027956128,
-0.0331289507,
-0.2901754975,
-0.4951547682,
-0.2178485841,
-0.121991381,
0.3490111232,
0.2002746314,
0.3192291558,
-0.2351389527,
0.2036640197,
0.1477366835,
0.338360846,
0.6743732095,
-0.1421071887,
0.6827751398,
-0.4414775074,
0.4142456055,
0.2451108992,
0.1560023874,
-0.3176336586,
-0.159571752,
-0.8380800486,
-0.686072886,
0.4909670651,
0.2339598089,
-0.7763673067,
0.0975804031,
-0.3423312604,
-0.3977607191,
-0.4618462324,
0.3129005134,
0.2998176813,
0.3789535463,
0.2830247283,
-0.2656985819,
-0.6206346154,
-0.9693400264,
0.0380038619,
0.0582366548,
-0.009361851,
0.2971439064,
0.2130094171,
-0.3046245873,
0.7005113363,
-0.1063820496,
0.0292671211,
-0.5057306886,
0.2039185911,
-0.0872695148,
0.6569814086,
0.3296901286,
-0.7998834848,
-0.3908048868,
0.1310433447,
-0.624209702,
0.0743092,
-0.1306299865,
0.0210965443,
0.0526018143,
0.5096403956,
-0.3854420781,
-0.2508464754,
0.8532269597,
-0.0651186481,
0.5214347243,
-0.2213573009,
0.5216335058,
-1.2185325623,
0.114907071,
-0.1585988402,
-0.3297127485,
-0.7144572139,
0.2200447619,
0.3299126327,
0.004213809,
-0.718578577,
0.3685193956,
-0.6723404527,
0.0813909099,
-0.2613901496,
0.1057577878,
0.0764835179,
0.4757883847,
-0.1319777817,
0.4454128444,
0.5095785856,
-0.6667785645,
0.4914796948,
-0.1437091082,
-0.3932012022,
0.6547242403,
-0.4090111554,
-0.0437147506,
-0.2395427525,
0.2533982098,
-1.0174251795,
-0.4715005159,
0.2612917125,
-0.194869101,
0.5728272796,
-0.3727043271,
-0.5396271944,
0.0700971782,
0.026054943,
0.6179044247,
0.2416713834,
-0.042441003,
1.1996370554,
0.1568840295,
-0.1377564818,
-0.5937225223,
-0.6343481541,
-0.0110034524,
0.0045348704,
-0.5801125765,
0.1612375528,
-0.2882620692,
-0.0342995748,
0.0103281792,
0.1800594777,
-0.0896378383,
0.0885158554,
0.2072713226,
0.4053553939,
-0.505392015,
0.2752613127,
0.1096171662,
0.1055177972,
-0.2388203442,
0.1979410499,
0.7424146533,
-0.0190475248,
-0.5727260709,
-0.3075167537,
0.5111662745,
0.9411424398,
-0.5372957587,
1.0505769253,
0.9969596863,
-0.1984722763,
0.0322309993,
-0.7475925684,
-0.050855916,
-0.3988064528,
0.511028111,
-0.6672340035,
-0.8584140539,
0.3956327438,
0.0396538712,
0.0584872961,
0.1127816364,
0.691824615,
-0.2676793039,
1.0406213999,
0.6700098515,
0.0159273092,
0.5184547305,
-0.0658388287,
-0.0422022194,
-1.101776123,
-0.4303085208,
-0.1358445734,
-0.5783544779,
-0.4387868941,
-0.7135862708,
0.2441543043,
0.0745054558,
-0.084706068,
0.2032564729,
0.0399831533,
0.4089899659,
0.3335948288,
0.2892494202,
0.4608730674,
-0.0511308685,
-0.2030439973,
-0.0589008778,
-0.6955804229,
-0.4475570023,
1.1346848011,
0.3078847528,
0.8243395686,
0.3633054793,
0.3608225882,
-0.0428000316,
0.5217183232,
-0.7167389989,
0.5855284929,
-0.1402422935,
-0.6874032617,
0.0189598035,
-0.5332724452,
-0.6024585962,
0.7169607878,
-0.4067496657,
-0.4900711775,
0.0406490378,
0.0553623438,
-0.1945459098,
0.3000822067,
-0.5984178185,
1.028206706,
-0.3047051728,
-0.3973865807,
-0.2816213667,
-0.5716128945,
0.7983864546,
-0.0939355716,
0.3160869479,
-0.2103354186,
-0.2930826843,
0.4355519712,
0.1116772965,
0.7201812267,
0.1187782809,
-0.1735953391,
0.1206851453,
0.2032925785,
0.2828353345,
-0.0124997227,
0.1194924191,
-0.0676642433,
-0.0303353146,
-0.2547405958,
-0.6932247281,
0.7922760248,
-0.5629679561,
-0.2805843651,
-0.0427710786,
-1.0718262196,
-0.445831567,
0.0026919111,
-0.1469683945,
0.8173944354,
-0.0996379554,
0.6856068969,
0.5696954727,
0.0058302404,
0.4811052084,
0.6958779097,
-0.173082009,
-0.552205205,
0.8187638521,
-0.1602384895,
0.5396395326,
0.4800598919,
-0.0318147726,
-0.2205046564,
-0.5108686686,
-0.3946452439,
0.172045514,
-0.8282385468,
-0.1504745632,
-0.9471502304,
-0.0515057705,
-0.4361485243,
-0.0251626298,
-0.4222605526,
0.0281162541,
-0.3339722455,
0.2866330147,
-0.0721961558,
0.606574893,
-0.1055205166,
0.3483703732,
-1.1020588875,
0.375905931,
0.3921424747,
0.2462648004,
0.1597154588,
-0.6371867657,
-0.3743988276,
0.3371582031,
-0.2968830466,
-0.7914327383,
0.1785343587,
0.1186562553,
0.8148537874,
0.3689813912,
-0.1830336303,
0.764346242,
-0.4609478712,
0.6299200058,
0.449763,
-0.9627643824,
0.171211943,
-0.2259966433,
0.4349701703,
0.4672593176,
0.4434393644,
-0.6374463439,
-0.3537454009,
-0.1775356233,
-0.3287624121,
0.5522062182,
-0.1237161905,
0.2187468857,
0.2549752891,
-0.2003899515,
0.2216055542,
0.181203559,
-0.9268090725,
0.0547612794,
0.0207314268,
-0.5249595046,
-0.2536136806,
-0.4313522577,
-0.1784373224,
-0.284947902,
0.4064739943,
0.0018922796,
-0.0009269902,
-0.4035624564,
-0.5544029474,
0.0770742893,
0.4141909182,
0.8504167199,
0.800609231,
0.047596328,
0.5371322632,
0.1398309618,
-0.3388322294,
0.2197731882,
-0.064616017,
0.1659369022,
-0.1635982245,
0.6621658206,
0.7740054727,
0.6832637191,
-0.7279158235,
0.4483022094,
0.0583137907,
-0.1008592173,
0.3230679929,
0.182697013,
0.1479811668,
0.4266155362,
0.0641475692,
0.2982132733,
0.0426667519,
-0.7064046264,
0.0694317967,
0.4828085005,
-0.2207053751,
-0.2724941671,
0.3842498064,
0.1731146425,
0.1067558452,
0.5518246889,
-0.0198212136,
-0.474434346,
0.2614693344,
0.513312161,
0.6091889739,
-0.2189083993,
0.0969550163,
0.1364702433,
0.4602186978,
0.1284960359,
0.0630714297,
-0.3534919024,
-0.6651027799,
-0.7349134088,
-0.7162969708,
-0.2773155272,
0.1270232052,
-0.4561616182,
0.225469932,
-0.2877558768,
-0.0939613208,
-0.0753029957,
-0.3368146122,
-0.7596332431,
0.0857089683,
0.19287844,
0.4238628447,
-1.0076985359,
0.8275262713,
0.7351885438,
-0.4704069793,
-0.8122680783,
-0.2482239306,
-0.1623083651,
-0.5159614086,
0.8798142672,
0.1184045374,
-0.0336614139,
-0.2119918466,
-0.3499058187,
-0.7494028807,
0.7652775049,
0.4699355364,
-0.4611030817,
0.0783050284,
0.132272169,
0.1649898738,
-0.587479651,
0.271468997,
0.3658268154,
0.5868293643,
0.2979234159,
-1.0746628046,
-0.0420685783,
-0.0755371004,
0.104092136,
0.0993226394,
-0.2189684063,
1.0806879997,
-0.1234763041,
-0.1538544148,
0.044128608,
0.7343246937,
0.1221856847,
0.1963525414,
0.4844582379,
0.4551233649,
0.4135327041,
0.0103588132,
0.7611142993,
-0.1068054661,
0.1901222914,
1.3026235104,
-0.0638512895,
0.8858857751,
0.4567990303,
-0.0974790752,
0.4634571075,
0.427651912,
0.1241743863,
0.5366569161,
-0.1489197761,
-0.4702094495,
-0.6220151186,
-0.1238210574,
-0.4214164019,
0.8588674068,
0.2788843513,
-0.4495014846,
-0.1926810294,
0.459289372,
-0.305154115,
-0.0173388328,
-0.2887193561,
0.7441136837,
-0.1134462655,
-0.5545642972,
0.5470554233,
0.1839432567,
0.5910413861,
-0.6690503359,
0.1036256179,
-0.1923831999,
0.1692620963,
-0.0275322758,
-0.6117902994,
0.0543518774,
-0.2366055846,
-0.4125108123,
-0.1308927089,
0.4017152786,
-0.9430199862,
-0.6611139774,
-0.1984336227,
0.5381818414,
-0.0573294871,
0.0277242102,
-0.4998845458,
0.6165543795,
-0.2314684242,
0.1711900979,
0.2409306169,
0.4036275446,
0.2031395435,
0.7230122685,
0.6186764836,
-0.1274756938,
0.210076943,
0.2974884808,
0.7501379848,
-0.3621011078,
-0.3008457124,
-0.8890209198,
0.8007072806,
-0.0363086015,
-0.1070635468,
0.7649081945,
0.5186465383,
0.6343047023,
-0.381675899,
0.4676880836,
-0.015284962,
0.0811511278,
-0.7504976988,
0.6399000883,
-0.8139169812,
0.0731254742,
-0.1548961699,
-1.2112525702,
-0.1756016165,
0.3884744644,
-0.0214804318,
0.2851743698,
0.6179193258,
0.787986815,
-0.4877128303,
-0.1157916561,
0.6194902062,
0.0139840441,
0.3383100331,
0.5580675602,
1.0361540318,
-0.216091603,
0.4233567417,
-0.2034094483,
-0.2077045143,
-0.4217985272,
-0.9199694395,
-1.0302671194,
-0.6565753818,
-0.2878286242,
-0.0289667863,
-0.3321993649,
0.896767199,
0.863173902,
-0.6717149019,
-0.1641994566,
0.3383442461,
0.0223298725,
-0.1833507866,
-0.1626027972,
-0.0155384811,
-0.4415376782,
-0.871278882,
0.5513442159,
0.3967170417,
0.1530370116,
-0.6546933651,
-0.0867430344,
-0.2749164402,
0.0249208137,
0.903467834,
-0.2096150666,
-0.9265044928,
-0.1349109709,
0.0282830987,
-0.307566762,
-0.2391021103,
1.0598102808,
-0.5071896911,
0.7898262739,
0.4333727658,
0.7313632965,
0.2853758633,
-0.3899066746,
0.5775575042,
-0.8107343316,
0.1994215399,
0.1691581607,
0.5621298552,
0.5883638263,
0.2164223641,
0.0823872238,
0.1179872006,
-0.1356550157,
-0.9241418242,
0.2440231889,
-1.3435651064,
-0.3919833302,
1.0614960194,
0.138456732,
-0.0117914164,
0.1101358235,
-0.2826531827,
0.2970476747,
-0.0862373263,
0.1864893883,
0.7652742863,
0.2593599856,
-0.5715558529,
-0.4920950234,
-0.1219231635,
0.2685232759,
-0.6504507065,
0.0088261431,
0.7510242462,
0.333506912,
-0.0145170745,
0.1364623457,
0.0253870692,
0.1948480308,
0.1035564914,
-0.0692503452,
-0.4917452633,
-0.4574784338,
-0.0391321369,
0.3714102507,
-0.069144994,
-0.2114791125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12749v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12749v4
|
Me LLaMA: Foundation Large Language Models for Medical Applications
| 2024-02-20T06:37:31 | 2024-04-11T16:42:55 |
Qianqian Xie, Qingyu Chen, Aokun Chen, Cheng Peng, Yan Hu, Fongci Lin, Xueqing Peng, Jimin Huang, Jeffrey Zhang, Vipina Keloth, Xinyu Zhou, Huan He, Lucila Ohno-Machado, Yonghui Wu, Hua Xu, Jiang Bian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and LLaMA
have hinted at their potential to revolutionize medical applications, yet their
application in clinical settings often reveals limitations due to a lack of
specialized training on medical-specific data. In response to this challenge,
this study introduces Me-LLaMA, a novel medical LLM family that includes
foundation models - Me-LLaMA 13/70B, along with their chat-enhanced versions -
Me-LLaMA 13/70B-chat, developed through continual pre-training and instruction
tuning of LLaMA2 using large medical datasets. Our methodology leverages a
comprehensive domain-specific data suite, including a large-scale, continual
pre-training dataset with 129B tokens, an instruction tuning dataset with 214k
samples, and a new medical evaluation benchmark (MIBE) across six critical
medical tasks with 12 datasets. Our extensive evaluation using the MIBE shows
that Me-LLaMA models achieve overall better performance than existing
open-source medical LLMs in zero-shot, few-shot and supervised learning
abilities. With task-specific instruction tuning, Me-LLaMA models outperform
ChatGPT on 7 out of 8 datasets and GPT-4 on 5 out of 8 datasets. In addition,
we investigated the catastrophic forgetting problem, and our results show that
Me-LLaMA models outperform other open-source medical LLMs in mitigating this
issue. Me-LLaMA is one of the largest open-source medical foundation LLMs that
use both biomedical and clinical data. It exhibits superior performance across
both general and medical tasks compared to other open-source medical LLMs,
rendering it an attractive choice for medical AI applications. We release our
models, datasets, and evaluation scripts at:
https://github.com/BIDS-Xu-Lab/Me-LLaMA.
|
[
0.0393710621,
-0.7786812782,
0.5451213121,
0.2352128029,
-0.3211968243,
0.2848913372,
-0.208305046,
-0.5120010972,
0.3581632078,
0.5162385106,
-0.5663642883,
-0.601236403,
-0.8556617498,
0.1065041497,
-0.3418448269,
0.9569598436,
-0.2000657767,
0.3547888696,
-0.1698906422,
-0.2132674903,
-0.4508997798,
-0.6907693148,
-0.5971944928,
-0.5953657031,
0.4629365802,
0.4742517769,
0.4938103557,
0.6154817343,
0.7248483896,
0.2238883823,
0.0595245361,
-0.0127565227,
-0.6238137484,
0.0047490168,
-0.0593938604,
-0.4274316132,
-0.6310380697,
-0.1895907521,
0.3565364778,
0.7547581792,
-0.3287402391,
0.2082859725,
-0.3529221416,
0.664380908,
-0.4469441473,
0.1057431102,
-0.5228073001,
0.0467057005,
-0.3034123778,
-0.2709038556,
-0.183603853,
-0.1302705407,
0.2088830322,
-0.3720904589,
-0.0471904874,
-0.1175622791,
0.6185876727,
0.5583760142,
-0.3024683893,
-0.4485956132,
-0.4977926016,
0.6910855174,
-0.8192610741,
0.2443580031,
0.2835983336,
0.406373024,
-0.4034363627,
-0.7725282907,
-0.2703639865,
-0.5712709427,
0.3641501665,
0.167365253,
-0.2393160313,
0.1254917979,
-0.1003758758,
0.5100311637,
-0.6935490966,
0.4393405914,
-0.4550057352,
-0.100165382,
0.3648730218,
0.4471640885,
0.3105612695,
0.3147950172,
-0.2740770578,
0.1517503709,
-1.1207604408,
-0.2828461826,
-0.2598592341,
-0.0999260321,
-0.3014279306,
0.7945075035,
-0.4591425359,
0.6118224859,
-0.2872225344,
-0.5954763889,
0.3842898607,
-0.0596550517,
-0.3593542874,
-0.03282547,
0.7218428254,
0.3012274504,
0.4357072115,
-0.2017555833,
-0.0243615732,
0.2629494965,
0.0546790436,
-0.9090257287,
-0.2533027828,
0.2303208858,
-0.6025265455,
-0.3752775788,
-0.6097187996,
-0.4069493413,
-0.3658907712,
-0.2206870019,
0.2140859663,
-0.3673275709,
-0.1555385143,
0.4936244488,
0.4493194818,
0.1359603554,
0.4284692109,
-0.9201117158,
0.3319596052,
0.5729554296,
0.78211236,
-0.2208629251,
-0.2104859948,
-0.3958103657,
0.070502542,
-0.36306566,
0.7863357663,
-0.7574650645,
-0.4293815792,
-0.2076583207,
-0.1835761219,
-0.1616278142,
-0.8108476996,
0.340980947,
-0.2291815281,
-0.0801605731,
0.0971023664,
-0.4625217319,
-0.020213794,
0.3515133858,
-0.4626792669,
0.6347900033,
0.1492049694,
-0.2509275377,
0.0833595544,
-0.7319998145,
-0.5497402549,
0.0355507173,
-0.4107687771,
-0.4765918851,
0.116940774,
0.240732953,
0.7580885887,
-0.881788075,
0.5010277033,
-0.2280859202,
-0.4824923873,
0.2513931096,
-0.3580659628,
0.5133154392,
0.1808751523,
-0.0880008191,
0.0277931318,
-0.7274129391,
-0.3452526927,
0.4222038984,
-0.5621427298,
-0.0937676355,
-0.0221876893,
-0.1620626152,
0.0826053321,
0.3823530972,
-0.504098475,
0.174287349,
-0.4207620919,
0.6249479055,
0.605083704,
0.0170681104,
0.0658144578,
-0.4258745313,
0.6464272738,
-0.0065284488,
0.3152330816,
-0.2776134312,
-0.56240201,
-0.5884390473,
-0.4653679729,
0.2099153548,
0.6751992106,
-0.4485578835,
0.1698221862,
-0.3152690828,
-0.4786709547,
-0.5980862379,
0.2406988889,
0.5324407816,
0.7597879767,
0.4469291866,
-0.1881999373,
-0.3620714843,
-0.9599801302,
0.1570632756,
-0.1964188069,
-0.0708538145,
0.6449084878,
0.4834043682,
-0.8401039839,
0.4091339111,
-0.4503879249,
-0.4259673953,
-0.1454301775,
-0.1162816659,
0.3664968014,
0.4084257185,
0.6155098081,
-0.3730902374,
-0.1489457339,
0.1947114468,
-0.8145571351,
-0.2384748459,
-0.099511385,
0.0863782912,
-0.0350603387,
0.3219408393,
-0.4252948761,
0.2763772905,
0.8170142174,
-0.2300601453,
0.6276545525,
-0.2189212143,
0.1535367966,
-1.1922320127,
0.1987941414,
-0.2807091475,
-0.1874901205,
-0.4008936882,
-0.0810789093,
-0.0727242157,
0.0140357586,
-0.3547730744,
0.5433288217,
-0.3047926128,
0.0433317162,
-0.2835832834,
-0.2056943774,
-0.1952138096,
0.3390877247,
-0.2063833475,
0.7628726959,
0.4884743392,
-0.5672132969,
0.2471457869,
0.4118139744,
-0.3083628714,
0.4709016085,
-0.825373292,
0.0630107671,
0.2029566616,
0.2156710327,
-0.7271408439,
-0.3889943361,
0.2513619363,
-0.3287664652,
0.3894858956,
0.1346599609,
-0.4859699607,
-0.4490752518,
-0.0526848584,
0.326619029,
0.4742850065,
-0.4782075286,
0.3521596491,
0.5835972428,
-0.2790598869,
-0.8004368544,
-0.6669191718,
0.3114565909,
-0.0743198171,
-0.4420731366,
0.4036175311,
-0.2505244315,
-0.00768132,
-0.1364445686,
-0.1955973804,
-0.1504069716,
0.2895532846,
0.3698733449,
0.3361749649,
-0.4618193209,
0.3091906011,
0.4460851252,
-0.3541092277,
-0.1748799682,
0.1092277095,
0.6000490189,
-0.2708774507,
-0.531342566,
-0.3078764081,
0.1695660353,
0.6511595845,
-0.1445389986,
0.6639887094,
0.15995498,
-0.4904269278,
0.1841194332,
-0.7180754542,
-0.1160251796,
-0.4137801826,
0.6498525739,
-0.3588526547,
-1.299258709,
0.3480189741,
-0.4808043242,
0.1208591014,
0.1633324325,
0.987518847,
-0.2602615058,
0.6670802832,
0.4806444645,
-0.3819931746,
0.2196301371,
-0.0562162399,
-0.1469760835,
-0.7577344775,
-0.1934344918,
-0.2301943749,
-0.3191350102,
-0.091574423,
-0.5924187899,
0.5790362954,
-0.0935111046,
-0.2144313306,
-0.0991032422,
-0.4046623409,
0.5040421486,
0.2121191025,
0.2385388762,
0.3942920268,
-0.1337072104,
-0.0895852372,
0.1188311949,
-0.5171684623,
-0.5587416887,
1.5397702456,
0.4763127565,
0.9795560241,
-0.0953483805,
0.5300965905,
0.2373694032,
0.6179129481,
-0.6233052611,
0.4307691455,
-0.4303988814,
-0.4634762704,
-0.0086945649,
-0.2135990262,
-1.0202240944,
-0.0102831228,
-0.2846345901,
-0.5266298652,
-0.3551742733,
0.2233086377,
-0.2929017842,
0.1047620624,
-0.5423781276,
0.6610696912,
-0.4840548337,
-0.0346102864,
-0.5428656936,
-0.6848274469,
0.5200403333,
-0.3874539435,
-0.1804248989,
-0.5029811263,
-0.2009582967,
0.5108700991,
-0.3113992512,
0.9996724129,
0.0340821221,
0.0461837836,
0.1255595386,
-0.1069990098,
0.2213692814,
0.0555997305,
0.0343780629,
0.5415988564,
-0.0645731241,
-0.3277681768,
-0.2468536794,
0.8984465003,
-0.750520885,
-0.5249483585,
-0.2165503502,
-0.5452859998,
-0.3852195442,
0.0880363509,
0.0594511181,
0.3498064578,
-0.3573700786,
0.4311676919,
0.5861890316,
-0.5095617175,
-0.0187616404,
0.722612977,
-0.1023352221,
-0.3967399299,
0.7644354105,
0.0101739783,
0.1351360381,
0.6087329984,
0.2636238337,
-0.0398791023,
-0.8322911859,
-0.7127699256,
0.5251722932,
-0.4891278446,
-0.398019582,
-0.5618146062,
-0.1739142239,
0.0557635501,
-0.1722738743,
-0.4348224699,
-0.4110134244,
-0.3980714381,
-0.0940914974,
0.4951138794,
0.7374610305,
0.3242031038,
0.6260562539,
-0.7016866207,
0.3882625103,
0.0594224259,
0.5636493564,
-0.1228559166,
-0.2924216688,
-0.2025428712,
-0.0546902902,
-0.237896204,
-0.8175982237,
0.1184534281,
0.2899650633,
0.6731304526,
0.4871020615,
-0.3501477838,
0.6773769855,
-0.6673983335,
0.4460947216,
0.2849514782,
-0.6564039588,
0.4968493879,
-0.2692575455,
0.1625690311,
0.5196272135,
0.1572010368,
-0.2979499996,
-0.2047247738,
-0.235262543,
-0.6519793272,
0.3977225125,
0.0583156049,
0.1274031699,
-0.0269911438,
0.757938683,
0.252802968,
0.2707559466,
-0.5729620457,
-0.312858969,
0.0843074992,
-0.6000375152,
-0.1358893663,
-0.3662044704,
-0.1040595397,
-0.0471508428,
0.4909734726,
-0.2463087589,
0.3017392457,
0.160554558,
-0.2373938411,
-0.0860967338,
0.0654878169,
0.6968176365,
0.5496344566,
-0.0460006222,
-0.1814565063,
0.3962019682,
-0.8198413849,
0.2060628384,
0.0710412711,
0.1389520615,
-0.269328177,
0.3476788402,
0.5537110567,
0.4683433473,
-1.3003050089,
0.477129519,
0.0535411723,
-0.0335772932,
-0.1954358667,
0.2136031985,
0.3302191496,
0.3789760172,
0.0605503134,
-0.0218583625,
0.2737603486,
-0.0973307788,
0.1616511345,
0.4537045062,
-0.1591024548,
-0.3132945001,
0.7536705136,
0.1409695596,
0.0108713536,
0.4478216171,
0.4177682102,
-0.0943882391,
0.6780567765,
0.774443388,
0.5698828697,
-0.4449761212,
0.0113312481,
0.2139225304,
0.3759117424,
-0.0477972552,
0.224093318,
0.0740057454,
-0.4770435691,
-0.5220060349,
-0.6356083751,
-0.6422448158,
0.3823612034,
-0.3063835204,
0.3497349918,
-0.6765884161,
-0.0914170593,
-0.2335530221,
-0.1148184985,
-0.5769721866,
0.3642932177,
0.2193967253,
0.9355243444,
-0.5590277314,
1.0332570076,
0.5616952777,
-0.2075379491,
-0.4786617458,
-0.2968172431,
-0.037058197,
-1.2428988218,
0.1661670655,
0.2310778201,
-0.0773856342,
-0.0994701684,
-0.5716817975,
-0.8375604153,
1.4132339954,
0.6964296103,
-0.819316268,
0.024444975,
0.2601509988,
0.6397989392,
-0.6196593642,
-0.0127394954,
0.6913365126,
0.0036636123,
0.1840521097,
-0.9643260837,
-0.0335307792,
-0.3201195598,
-0.3257790506,
0.1254421175,
-0.8011002541,
0.7544690371,
-0.5576351285,
0.1812244654,
0.38223809,
0.2942094803,
0.6185995936,
0.4405401051,
0.1692347974,
0.5689317584,
0.8751530647,
0.0338277183,
0.998306036,
-0.3707848787,
-0.0231391788,
1.008617878,
-0.4317381084,
0.8628769517,
0.3333422244,
-0.172652185,
0.367836982,
0.6306146383,
0.0694988221,
0.4541647434,
0.2489568442,
-0.3190104663,
-0.0907039195,
-0.0444264449,
-0.5548408628,
0.393221885,
0.7781000733,
-0.5192799568,
-0.0043688938,
-0.0076903854,
0.1596817672,
-0.1819207668,
-0.3096487522,
0.6902610064,
0.3438317478,
-0.2595842183,
0.7384572625,
-0.0752966404,
0.4856590629,
-0.8075665832,
-0.065447405,
-0.1971058846,
0.2666900754,
-0.0707108006,
-0.3860654831,
0.1242193803,
0.1057630852,
-0.1234261543,
0.2409261316,
0.6536573768,
-0.1562901288,
-0.4819456935,
0.3480781317,
0.5432961583,
0.2445155531,
0.1136037782,
-0.7789536715,
0.0995181128,
-0.0600943491,
-0.278193891,
0.3631952703,
0.1047185212,
-0.3830223382,
1.0343461037,
0.7222214937,
0.1421983242,
0.0479626022,
0.1724345982,
1.0506958961,
-0.6116979718,
-0.1290622056,
-0.9234864712,
0.1493786424,
0.2997248471,
-0.4493569732,
0.1398829222,
0.5363951325,
0.3403807282,
-0.1655494869,
0.6820648909,
0.2698994577,
0.5728427172,
-0.4667795002,
0.7451696396,
-0.5349037647,
0.2736503482,
-0.0805985332,
-0.5326620936,
-0.579813242,
0.6027801037,
-0.3156450093,
-0.054371316,
0.3632328808,
0.6213245988,
0.019633539,
-0.0279382505,
0.4896189868,
0.4098589718,
0.4329185188,
1.0668766499,
0.8213118315,
-0.2458165288,
0.4022988081,
-0.0184326917,
-0.4989650249,
-0.5652973652,
-0.7237909436,
-1.055177331,
-0.2356592417,
-0.1774207503,
-0.0186755434,
0.1687734276,
0.9962005019,
0.671739161,
-0.80877918,
-0.1756542176,
0.1076416969,
-0.2178168148,
-0.0312811285,
-0.0187272094,
0.2843300104,
-0.0496308096,
-0.5184602141,
0.7160767913,
0.6513803601,
0.2941743135,
-0.1860244423,
-0.2994108796,
-0.0892104506,
0.0409949273,
0.4929915667,
0.3079566061,
-0.7926813364,
0.0778103545,
0.10446807,
-0.2173823863,
0.1957344711,
0.5680491924,
-0.8037974834,
0.3796903789,
-0.1186107397,
0.8882561922,
0.5039274096,
-0.2021120638,
0.577943325,
-0.3251251876,
0.1966675669,
0.3194004297,
0.5988714695,
0.3152875602,
-0.3751528859,
0.8481920362,
0.0168344937,
-0.5552228093,
-0.7931455374,
-0.0157442689,
-0.961152792,
-0.1219375506,
0.8991611004,
-0.0521545708,
-0.0838987306,
-0.0849847198,
-0.3811556697,
0.1559482664,
-0.1415845007,
0.9241808057,
0.5434984565,
-0.2712124288,
0.0749902278,
-0.808152616,
0.144204095,
0.5463401079,
-0.9535207748,
-0.2705266476,
0.4490588009,
0.4707555175,
-0.2015159875,
0.9979122281,
-0.2724277079,
0.4851793647,
-0.2742000222,
-0.0137249799,
-0.1519526094,
-0.4297529757,
-0.269007951,
-0.0344093591,
0.1358069479,
-0.2268630862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14855v1
|
An LLM Maturity Model for Reliable and Transparent Text-to-Query
| 2024-02-20T06:20:09 | 2024-02-20T06:20:09 |
Lei Yu, Abir Ray
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recognizing the imperative to address the reliability and transparency issues
of Large Language Models (LLM), this work proposes an LLM maturity model
tailored for text-to-query applications. This maturity model seeks to fill the
existing void in evaluating LLMs in such applications by incorporating
dimensions beyond mere correctness or accuracy. Moreover, this work introduces
a real-world use case from the law enforcement domain and showcases QueryIQ, an
LLM-powered, domain-specific text-to-query assistant to expedite user workflows
and reveal hidden relationship in data.
|
[
0.0457126014,
-0.5727747679,
0.9310382605,
0.4412382245,
0.0068843877,
0.2745753229,
0.144789502,
-0.6468749046,
-0.2854135036,
0.927799046,
-0.5275527239,
-0.8481095433,
-0.5046716928,
-0.240516603,
-0.7234519124,
0.7259594798,
0.0115696304,
-0.0108609628,
-0.5860825777,
-0.3019127548,
-0.515802145,
-0.4695545435,
-0.6866058111,
-0.4056152105,
0.3292163014,
0.4932531416,
0.513455689,
0.5854430795,
0.5054638982,
0.2600650191,
-0.0856266692,
0.0992003977,
-0.6195012927,
0.4494661093,
-0.5433216095,
-0.6085437536,
-0.7105666995,
0.0749082714,
0.4726372957,
0.571295321,
-0.2274878323,
-0.0435079075,
-0.2616155148,
0.9819000363,
-0.8733623624,
-0.0517216548,
-0.922089994,
-0.1881793141,
-0.079733327,
-0.1044653356,
-0.5853710771,
-0.4233655035,
0.026829591,
-0.3948498666,
-0.168035388,
0.3650608361,
0.6265795827,
-0.0053706141,
-0.528046608,
-0.3498571515,
-0.8772739768,
0.6531190276,
-0.6998249888,
0.537168026,
0.7031104565,
0.5925503373,
-0.0382392444,
-0.9856030941,
-0.3832764924,
-0.6909442544,
-0.0122372117,
0.0477546975,
0.0228500776,
0.0048738276,
-0.2425005287,
0.5510979295,
-0.6027210355,
0.2164418399,
-0.1724053174,
-0.1987382174,
0.6708468199,
0.3605744243,
0.0153597221,
-0.0075297556,
-0.4764293432,
0.3082847893,
-0.8395497799,
-0.2252142131,
0.485833168,
0.1736772209,
-0.0550693907,
0.8449923992,
-0.4496655166,
0.5378924012,
0.0638823882,
-0.0837632418,
-0.0335858949,
-0.4089065492,
-0.2909466624,
-0.2479607165,
0.7985849977,
0.2742684484,
0.3008588254,
-0.4519380331,
-0.5041241646,
-0.5799847841,
0.3887833059,
-0.8039655089,
0.1614653617,
0.6251112819,
-0.3205624223,
-0.4327540398,
0.2015186846,
-0.4899851382,
-0.5052172542,
-0.1281791329,
0.4269642234,
-0.3562844396,
0.0485227033,
0.0280097593,
0.0063020857,
0.1250122637,
0.4530870914,
-0.5080862045,
0.3804950714,
0.7113844156,
0.7847275138,
-0.4111872911,
-0.0268556662,
-0.3532927632,
0.4741782546,
-0.3166605532,
0.3842166066,
-0.7037924528,
-0.4560136795,
0.1795612425,
0.1395731121,
0.0942490846,
-0.7894764543,
0.7038367391,
-1.0867296457,
0.1953368187,
0.3390215337,
-0.6885691285,
0.0538470708,
0.7007843852,
-0.7635404468,
1.0590002537,
0.1638364196,
-0.5064361691,
0.3978555799,
-0.5678908229,
-0.1104516387,
0.2658452392,
0.0421737432,
-0.7498983741,
-0.0660187528,
0.168378219,
0.3568490446,
-0.3440925479,
0.3658901453,
-0.2073612958,
-0.3241466284,
0.1607952416,
-0.422429949,
0.6973660588,
0.2632447481,
0.0544822626,
0.1701861918,
-0.7929342389,
-0.1295713037,
0.2900408208,
-0.4523099959,
-0.3486838043,
0.1245634258,
-0.0934265405,
-0.2274581045,
0.7439587712,
-0.5742881894,
0.0559086129,
-0.3342037499,
0.4638007879,
0.2726505697,
0.0576950647,
0.6226099133,
-0.325293541,
0.5177195668,
-0.0119498661,
0.395856142,
-0.4093946517,
-0.4438292682,
-0.4096670449,
-0.0741462633,
0.2022728622,
0.7864314318,
-0.4956302345,
0.4292573929,
-0.3549481928,
-0.7245092392,
0.0643772855,
0.0848068818,
0.107237637,
0.473204881,
0.1056872606,
-0.2044077218,
-0.2149947584,
-0.7945528626,
-0.4160935879,
-0.6868276596,
-0.1656641066,
0.761376977,
0.4797109067,
-0.4204801619,
0.9155086875,
-0.3385102451,
-0.429680109,
-0.1049809605,
0.2199450582,
0.0783354416,
0.4034376144,
0.2989472151,
-0.8781110048,
-0.2596710324,
-0.0341122672,
-0.6021423936,
-0.0901091993,
0.03439226,
-0.1202228144,
-0.0055325599,
0.8613628745,
-0.3119270802,
0.4191198051,
0.6048843861,
-0.4440639317,
0.5080580711,
-0.1108518541,
0.3531531394,
-0.7248731256,
0.150803864,
-0.0670342371,
-0.7117896676,
-0.5093148351,
0.1842603087,
0.5039409399,
-0.3249107003,
-0.703184247,
0.5042001605,
-0.4136461318,
-0.2394558936,
0.0069149807,
0.1676601917,
0.2799142897,
0.0593565218,
-0.2620968223,
1.1690826416,
0.319362402,
-0.6865500808,
0.3365112841,
0.068724893,
-0.2770910859,
0.7701157928,
-0.6959818006,
0.1784143001,
-0.0470416546,
-0.0487564169,
-0.8887107968,
-0.235130012,
-0.0867352933,
-0.6966702938,
0.3996973038,
-0.3206298947,
-0.676662147,
-0.1881566495,
-0.5586411953,
0.6137545109,
0.0606511422,
-0.35206002,
0.6503513455,
0.2487159073,
0.0187563784,
-0.4456622899,
-0.9586110115,
0.4298028946,
-0.0761410221,
-0.8849838972,
0.6358242631,
0.0152294748,
-0.0964089185,
-0.0266393889,
0.0458942279,
-0.4090255797,
0.163852483,
0.1727838963,
0.1328821629,
-0.3302498162,
0.1443518102,
-0.0623946264,
0.2202389687,
0.0958618075,
-0.2163344473,
0.507530272,
0.0122175775,
-0.6494938135,
0.0448715314,
0.3820276558,
0.8123518229,
-0.3896245658,
1.0085164309,
0.14958179,
-0.3125870526,
-0.1094983965,
-0.5740833282,
0.0579243302,
-0.510114491,
0.3596014678,
-0.0892654583,
-1.2378709316,
0.6223946214,
-0.2754597068,
-0.0951158255,
0.3825033307,
0.5332553387,
-0.0093188975,
0.8162844181,
0.8507416844,
0.0694722086,
0.577304244,
0.083864592,
0.0582733899,
-0.8143661618,
-0.8654454947,
-0.6881292462,
0.1615748703,
-0.4733157158,
-0.2844974399,
0.4242765605,
0.3716512918,
-0.4552209675,
0.1906827241,
-0.3644331992,
0.4500004947,
0.2678693831,
0.0883275568,
0.6727375984,
-0.0431834422,
0.0290318131,
0.0503761247,
-0.280444622,
-0.6863186955,
1.1908810139,
0.5377423763,
1.0102678537,
0.4223586321,
0.5403595567,
0.4232934117,
0.2606295347,
-0.9627674818,
0.5667052865,
-0.2064555287,
-0.9017874002,
-0.5612572432,
-0.5263302326,
-1.0231745243,
-0.1225246638,
0.120065175,
-0.8616410494,
0.218334496,
-0.1818266064,
0.1173384413,
0.2343341559,
-0.5382609963,
0.7807790637,
-0.2049883753,
-0.6612400413,
0.0645312145,
-0.3910891712,
0.6803706288,
-0.1786690354,
0.0481853485,
-0.3444361091,
-0.6603184342,
0.4291704595,
-0.5516865849,
0.4732224345,
0.0535117425,
-0.2838798761,
0.2876235843,
0.2782549262,
0.7421722412,
0.2844725251,
-0.419682771,
-0.1327625513,
-0.1987062544,
-0.1957190782,
-0.5445436835,
0.6887321472,
-0.3159713745,
-0.7510030866,
-0.2852889895,
-0.6342266202,
-0.5745279193,
0.3105196655,
-0.0303537268,
0.0526265875,
-0.3856827319,
0.3030638397,
0.7538735867,
-0.2831316292,
0.2463150918,
0.7714599371,
-0.4952875078,
-0.2097317725,
0.4898773134,
-0.0572408959,
0.4714511037,
0.5723137259,
-0.007016818,
-0.5904837847,
-0.9795380831,
-0.5794244409,
0.2486219555,
-0.6361936927,
-0.3261215687,
-0.5023275614,
-0.387082845,
-0.4565550089,
0.1127371639,
-0.3680004478,
-0.4120358229,
-0.4162684977,
0.1024775282,
0.6251602173,
0.4695439935,
0.2601284385,
0.3325126767,
-0.9074627161,
0.3314463198,
0.3256312013,
0.7275127172,
-0.2112485319,
-0.8684878349,
-0.0990652218,
-0.1936068088,
-0.3942090571,
-0.9657585621,
0.2375110239,
0.3979403675,
0.5819020271,
0.2643012702,
0.1004910097,
0.06315317,
-0.4226447344,
0.9216378927,
-0.0234343912,
-0.9282695651,
0.8522382379,
-0.4707577527,
0.2915090322,
0.777808547,
0.4278557897,
-0.2635478079,
-0.607724607,
-0.1721553504,
-0.9642557502,
0.4825971425,
0.3543857932,
0.3938732445,
0.2612379193,
0.5497503877,
-0.1653281003,
0.3834595084,
-0.7485781908,
-0.3828972578,
-0.0981293321,
-0.3015518188,
0.3364008963,
-0.5388714075,
0.0389426164,
0.0275321212,
0.445096761,
-0.0673746318,
0.1979676485,
0.0096631022,
-0.0399784409,
0.1318880767,
0.510428369,
0.3706679642,
0.9430837035,
-0.4925189614,
-0.0236446522,
0.1055150852,
-0.7524468303,
0.2706243694,
-0.0194680355,
-0.2700406015,
-0.3377373815,
0.3783785403,
0.3705318272,
-0.1885479838,
-0.7955527902,
0.7983983159,
-0.1135145351,
-0.2540079653,
-0.2408445626,
0.0603063665,
0.2281195968,
0.2160434276,
0.5356602669,
-0.3101960421,
0.3778189123,
-0.8693802357,
0.3172723055,
0.3765005469,
-0.7215080857,
0.2676497698,
0.8455072045,
0.084552899,
-0.2057065368,
0.4284682274,
-0.2516295612,
-0.4609353542,
0.497874558,
0.4764760435,
0.8220915794,
-0.2672079206,
0.1899821907,
0.005951751,
0.6446612477,
-0.126712963,
0.3210470676,
0.1387797445,
-0.4161676466,
-0.3991800547,
-0.4988179207,
-0.5319876075,
0.2619165778,
-0.594671905,
0.1706261635,
-0.5951778889,
-0.1870261282,
-0.3179327846,
0.0247925874,
-0.1924521774,
0.5130665898,
-0.2142366916,
1.1757861376,
-0.4392454326,
0.8696601391,
0.4695828259,
-0.3363408744,
-0.4489770234,
-0.1223524362,
-0.1398356259,
-0.9808045626,
0.5408722758,
-0.0545480251,
-0.2162892073,
-0.2758555412,
-0.835303545,
-0.5006650686,
1.384478569,
0.3758024275,
-0.8019824624,
0.1627064943,
0.529558897,
0.5140423179,
-0.4767574668,
0.0136452932,
0.7325088382,
0.4213024378,
0.4285117984,
-0.6598934531,
0.0976341963,
0.0994634703,
0.1406939626,
0.0939716324,
-0.405372858,
0.8132688999,
-0.0989022851,
-0.3006967008,
0.2331560403,
0.7177516818,
0.4312721789,
0.8474254608,
0.2793324888,
0.5760701895,
0.629229486,
-0.052233424,
1.0088045597,
-0.1910556555,
0.1458091438,
1.1940441132,
-0.2641757727,
0.9517726302,
0.3994030952,
-0.1679094583,
0.3699394464,
0.3962394595,
-0.1688719541,
0.4217143357,
0.1353936791,
-0.3431265056,
-0.0890343711,
-0.2455546111,
-0.0016047689,
0.0887743607,
0.476034075,
-0.5960772038,
0.0486762561,
-0.223472625,
-0.0808956772,
0.4518910646,
-0.6120370626,
0.7556036115,
0.1641244441,
-0.2986092865,
0.1754012704,
0.4303648174,
0.6428655386,
-0.3743060827,
0.1924413294,
-0.411485523,
-0.1233161166,
-0.3643984497,
-1.2234331369,
0.587061584,
0.1178925931,
-0.206690833,
0.1436668783,
0.9564426541,
-0.2936492562,
-0.5353556871,
0.4863919318,
0.5219199061,
0.0578941517,
-0.4087598622,
-0.8171687126,
0.1263064146,
-0.2253676504,
-0.1756380498,
0.0365886502,
0.7888746858,
-0.0705545023,
1.0581167936,
0.4848358631,
0.2419226468,
0.1397499144,
0.2857317328,
0.7003224492,
-0.5601682067,
-0.1912314147,
-0.7454108,
0.4466558695,
-0.1909035891,
-0.0792448521,
0.6801496148,
0.7551165223,
0.5356888771,
0.2686090767,
0.5973437428,
0.2730145454,
0.5547432303,
-0.7122728825,
0.8631429672,
-0.8108065724,
0.8142020702,
0.146068722,
-0.9526313543,
-0.2994719148,
0.077691257,
-0.2694053352,
0.3996239305,
0.3599618375,
1.0088154078,
-0.1806430966,
-0.2828876674,
0.6639331579,
-0.0436403044,
0.323251754,
0.4249022305,
0.9897395372,
-0.6095470786,
0.768453598,
0.1277853101,
0.0080091488,
-0.3763493896,
-0.9929990172,
-0.861871779,
-0.340251863,
-0.1647920161,
-0.2712438107,
0.1481488496,
0.098625347,
0.7622606158,
-0.6512088776,
-0.1274001896,
-0.3246390224,
0.2492146194,
0.3481016159,
-0.2081067413,
0.011382062,
-0.2328498363,
-0.6015256643,
0.3471298218,
0.4947091341,
0.3321958184,
-0.5027968884,
-0.1720316708,
0.0186365508,
0.4793076813,
0.5478751063,
0.1682385504,
-0.4410346448,
-0.0012337648,
0.0735867023,
-0.4926167428,
0.1184562519,
0.8085247874,
-0.5229934454,
0.2699028552,
0.464959234,
0.6409680247,
0.9119734764,
0.0174934324,
0.6611152291,
-0.9298534393,
-0.0702006742,
0.49560076,
0.0631387904,
0.5278356075,
-0.500559926,
0.5236462951,
-0.0876277015,
-0.6567956805,
-0.7562069297,
0.391420871,
-0.9326802492,
-0.2953879237,
1.0079073906,
-0.2330934107,
-0.0968996212,
-0.3982619345,
0.0619817823,
-0.0868501663,
-0.5115345716,
0.350592196,
0.634763062,
0.1830929369,
-0.4097038805,
-0.5959047079,
0.3505954444,
0.1701382995,
-1.0745300055,
0.0730662718,
0.2859970629,
0.1128006801,
-0.0140433237,
0.4742985666,
-0.6210281253,
0.025024455,
-0.0641786531,
-0.3701248169,
-0.2348481566,
-0.3224980235,
-0.0760516673,
0.3291064799,
0.4554100931,
0.0447587594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14854v1
|
A Dual-Prompting for Interpretable Mental Health Language Models
| 2024-02-20T06:18:02 | 2024-02-20T06:18:02 |
Hyolim Jeon, Dongje Yoo, Daeun Lee, Sejung Son, Seungbae Kim, Jinyoung Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the increasing demand for AI-based mental health monitoring tools,
their practical utility for clinicians is limited by the lack of
interpretability.The CLPsych 2024 Shared Task (Chim et al., 2024) aims to
enhance the interpretability of Large Language Models (LLMs), particularly in
mental health analysis, by providing evidence of suicidality through linguistic
content. We propose a dual-prompting approach: (i) Knowledge-aware evidence
extraction by leveraging the expert identity and a suicide dictionary with a
mental health-specific LLM; and (ii) Evidence summarization by employing an
LLM-based consistency evaluator. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of combining domain-specific information, revealing performance
improvements and the approach's potential to aid clinicians in assessing mental
state progression.
|
[
-0.2917257547,
-0.5715055466,
1.1097933054,
0.2552737594,
-0.1004958302,
-0.2378562838,
-0.550295651,
-0.269185245,
0.0679159313,
0.3960149288,
-0.9581190348,
-0.6181035638,
-0.8319962621,
0.215638414,
-0.213736102,
1.1196733713,
-0.1154250205,
0.1973188519,
-0.1585542709,
0.0182412211,
-0.849996984,
-0.2403244674,
-1.0948586464,
-0.3800244927,
0.8130886555,
0.3960317075,
0.7904387116,
-0.0079038478,
0.1801731586,
0.1431009918,
0.2154034525,
0.1896450222,
-0.2618153095,
0.0830752254,
-0.2121853381,
-0.280169487,
-0.6911528111,
0.0960119888,
0.3189666271,
0.6703885794,
-0.2469005287,
0.0410236977,
0.1934416592,
0.4304796159,
-0.4678580463,
0.2837115824,
-0.3644828498,
-0.061008662,
-0.1019410416,
-0.0360780619,
-0.4698317349,
-0.2217708528,
0.1317760944,
-0.4472042918,
0.1852152944,
-0.5230208635,
0.395680517,
0.5724413991,
-0.6247726083,
-0.3346007168,
-0.3927044272,
0.7072572112,
-0.9075338244,
0.4990787804,
0.4680719674,
0.1699357778,
-0.1806321144,
-0.6326615214,
-0.6585562229,
-0.0471476167,
-0.2242310345,
0.3002697825,
-0.2356007844,
0.4353458285,
0.2462666333,
0.0638395548,
-0.508977592,
0.1168618798,
-0.1944618672,
-0.4005641937,
0.8483583331,
0.268220067,
0.6939587593,
-0.0298027936,
-0.2801273167,
0.3654957712,
-0.4211767614,
-0.0412623398,
0.1619576514,
0.043360237,
-0.2345494032,
0.3992013335,
-0.0495938398,
0.6302350163,
0.0636653751,
-0.2012914866,
0.027405858,
-0.3679166436,
0.0086487392,
0.0517243519,
0.9139197469,
0.7990983129,
-0.0184268244,
0.023388572,
-0.0002320897,
0.1114345938,
0.4947908521,
-0.5781487823,
-0.6290051341,
0.7604483962,
-0.4337913394,
0.1218686178,
-0.3129753172,
-1.0499950647,
-0.6733462811,
-0.4492121637,
0.5458404422,
-0.5440015197,
-0.5248475075,
0.4902428985,
-0.3395919502,
-0.3783911467,
0.4471063912,
-0.7423945665,
0.1632410139,
0.6953327656,
0.9619159698,
-0.3892295659,
-0.3079865575,
-0.3233822286,
0.1829045117,
-0.0937588811,
0.7767252922,
-0.2634746134,
-0.2107613385,
0.0748609975,
0.0786623955,
-0.2398248017,
-0.3732495904,
0.6879037619,
-0.1894522905,
0.3027613461,
-0.6478078961,
-0.519010663,
-0.2437766194,
0.0280441698,
-0.6501879692,
0.9384031296,
-0.1135339215,
-1.0183598995,
0.5448582172,
-0.7662600875,
-0.1745251119,
0.3003071249,
-0.319924444,
-0.2252681106,
0.0576679967,
0.1733193249,
0.6105055809,
-0.0882943943,
0.8069956899,
-0.483441025,
-0.1396981627,
-0.0472739898,
-0.5243044496,
0.8312940001,
0.0091598518,
-0.2503148019,
0.1812199503,
-0.5734672546,
-0.0320588499,
0.1100385189,
-0.3102170825,
-0.3425594568,
0.2378748208,
-0.1080749184,
0.146224454,
0.7754319906,
-0.4790565073,
-0.1315148324,
-0.195561707,
0.1471725255,
0.6004644036,
0.2862424254,
-0.0633264109,
-0.4850957692,
0.6482721567,
-0.23449108,
0.1335401386,
0.0954604745,
-0.6957753897,
-0.2860713005,
-0.8998907804,
-0.247727111,
0.6973830462,
-0.2815215886,
0.789988637,
-0.0364786498,
-0.2997053266,
-0.4768534601,
-0.0797232613,
0.2299245596,
0.6090034246,
0.4645436704,
-0.1597995013,
-0.8434939384,
-0.9091354609,
-0.4677284658,
-0.0583907738,
-0.0166685935,
-0.0634057894,
0.2165776044,
-0.494402945,
0.8947079778,
-0.4522314668,
-0.0586587712,
-0.6088341475,
0.3129118979,
0.32970047,
0.0819946975,
0.1758111417,
-0.6400606632,
-0.5588544607,
-0.2863678038,
-0.978656292,
-0.5454711914,
-0.1284061521,
-0.1330865473,
-0.2712439299,
0.2239658386,
-0.6531118155,
0.4993368387,
0.5616003275,
-0.2831722498,
0.8461577892,
-0.2249825001,
0.1265768111,
-0.9244431257,
0.1634874642,
-0.264677614,
-0.1420481354,
-1.0056318045,
-0.3020965159,
0.0186306797,
0.0723906085,
-0.0506533831,
0.6272745728,
-0.3559775352,
0.3134684861,
-0.4968233407,
0.2055704594,
-0.0402902141,
0.1118830666,
0.1689730436,
0.8479554057,
0.4884328842,
-0.3185918033,
0.2868220806,
0.2841367424,
-0.0825879425,
0.7788341045,
-0.4865554571,
-0.2064152062,
-0.1947111189,
0.3455469906,
-0.8876151443,
-0.4885516465,
0.1961969286,
-0.1872240901,
0.1242612302,
0.1535232067,
-0.23805812,
-0.4601580501,
-0.2707211375,
0.338163048,
0.3905310035,
-0.4322288334,
0.3237629533,
0.3883895874,
-0.4991018474,
-0.5836513638,
-0.3207897842,
0.2224771529,
-0.4349553585,
-0.5192334056,
0.0920329541,
-0.4365017414,
-0.2862085402,
-0.1772046536,
-0.1468102038,
0.0582209229,
0.2437497973,
0.4342209101,
0.3587509096,
-0.0384760238,
0.2732099891,
0.289611876,
-0.1079503372,
0.4664710164,
-0.1512439549,
0.4682635367,
0.0424990915,
-0.2558103204,
-0.9803251028,
0.7167230844,
0.3534188569,
0.0001163644,
0.8805577159,
0.3731137812,
-0.5861302018,
-0.1582340598,
-0.4793610275,
-0.2474670857,
-0.3765738904,
0.1608318239,
-0.1599407196,
-0.8939340115,
0.3223362267,
-0.309030652,
0.1492934376,
0.3867776394,
0.7359321713,
-0.0733289644,
1.3703739643,
0.6174070239,
0.1534584761,
0.1619605273,
0.146172002,
0.5699014068,
-0.5853381157,
-0.09601634,
-0.131512478,
0.028323777,
0.0439620949,
-0.2042188644,
0.8513461351,
0.2857187986,
-0.1650126576,
0.1583385319,
-0.5306255817,
0.1325410604,
0.2463443577,
0.3026427627,
0.3734487295,
-0.1243678406,
-0.1786380857,
-0.4422339201,
-0.4175294042,
-0.582752049,
0.8613522649,
0.3279387355,
0.3129908144,
-0.0011782356,
0.7811223865,
0.430988729,
0.3943082392,
-0.6373064518,
0.461240083,
-0.0084201591,
-0.6557961702,
-0.277399987,
-0.2541195154,
-0.7834808826,
0.1167335287,
-0.0313790739,
-1.1231271029,
0.0010980354,
0.2220135778,
-0.528957665,
0.02078408,
-0.5231194496,
1.080222249,
-0.3858140707,
0.2655276954,
-0.5738194585,
-0.5079084635,
0.6136112809,
-0.5134469271,
0.587792635,
-0.4167114496,
-0.2112322003,
0.8479118347,
-0.4070701003,
0.9715821147,
-0.3847104609,
-0.2929342687,
0.0109887281,
-0.0398981869,
0.3058845103,
0.2949889898,
-0.2836046517,
0.2029292285,
0.4124878347,
-0.2122139335,
-0.7070535421,
0.5057852268,
-0.5971884131,
-0.8751699924,
-0.2289555669,
-0.8256731629,
-0.5501175523,
0.518019259,
0.3412561417,
0.3418655396,
-0.1452686787,
-0.4673056602,
0.545222044,
-0.3211602271,
0.0318785943,
0.6449332833,
-0.1201824024,
-0.4501638412,
0.6504618526,
-0.1415221691,
0.2717649043,
-0.0141471615,
0.4314284623,
-0.2676107585,
-0.6828851104,
-0.201181829,
0.5905289054,
-0.6288151145,
-0.0573941693,
-0.9625653028,
-0.1785753816,
-0.4965551198,
-0.1777207702,
-0.1845550686,
-0.1326748729,
-0.0603108816,
-0.2863793373,
0.4939433038,
0.9976050854,
-0.5519347787,
0.2463468164,
-0.871350646,
0.3428216875,
0.195695132,
0.0741594955,
0.0291708875,
-0.2343077958,
-0.2701568902,
0.2401833385,
0.000645752,
-1.3474746943,
0.2384938002,
0.1833090037,
0.6090587974,
0.6352199316,
0.2627275884,
0.7126075029,
-0.4716472328,
0.8468666077,
0.5082774162,
-0.9549999237,
0.8423817158,
-0.4396407008,
0.2149373293,
0.8063313961,
0.8677845001,
-0.9890486002,
-0.646930933,
-0.5378685594,
-0.5550251603,
0.5913122892,
-0.2783454657,
-0.2769630253,
-0.1246481016,
0.2034775466,
0.4235402346,
0.2191723734,
-0.2892249227,
-0.1190655157,
0.0285485834,
-0.7957163453,
0.0393996462,
-0.3372949064,
-0.6092317104,
-0.1173412949,
0.6218081713,
-0.3316911161,
0.3066465259,
0.2636038959,
0.2429297864,
-0.1532957405,
0.3478865623,
0.256431222,
0.7821723223,
-0.1716303378,
0.4225731194,
0.2968587577,
-0.4597361088,
0.0897639245,
0.2160230577,
-0.2068043947,
0.055709634,
0.5535522103,
0.5030543208,
0.1983717531,
-1.0927827358,
0.8326296806,
-0.1468415111,
-0.0983746201,
-0.367674917,
0.034880165,
0.1709097475,
0.3122161031,
0.0931035951,
-0.110418506,
0.3372491896,
-0.3513736725,
0.4155953526,
0.5518997312,
-0.3127200305,
-0.5755813122,
0.6052240133,
-0.1396634579,
-0.1766570508,
0.3296099901,
-0.0536283553,
-0.5963030457,
0.2806077003,
0.3358664513,
0.6145700812,
-0.1789119691,
0.4260854721,
0.4523431063,
-0.0169802625,
-0.2872182429,
0.7239974737,
-0.0740550384,
-0.6398224831,
-0.3125753105,
-0.452991128,
-0.2635037601,
0.2370805889,
-0.9873776436,
0.2660186291,
-0.3918124139,
-0.2277080268,
0.0488686226,
-0.0680405945,
-0.4691515565,
0.2812440097,
0.3202967644,
0.8925068974,
-0.8532817364,
0.7283095121,
0.6092526913,
-0.1143660471,
-0.8499324918,
0.1969447583,
0.518430531,
-0.7224496603,
0.2204806209,
0.3395445347,
-0.0396818183,
-0.3007974625,
-0.6162688136,
-0.7488293648,
1.0203487873,
0.3182596862,
-0.3973530829,
-0.3171261847,
0.0117552495,
0.5563635826,
-0.1887455285,
0.1635870934,
0.6574617624,
0.8283091187,
-0.2963039875,
-1.0026336908,
0.2624930739,
0.0689507574,
-0.4649991691,
0.276106149,
-0.3822318912,
0.408298254,
-0.2978846431,
-0.5923044682,
0.0044679828,
0.5955593586,
0.3485922813,
0.599673748,
0.6626072526,
0.4828657508,
1.2829518318,
0.4384694397,
0.6219362617,
-0.3569199443,
0.3175165355,
1.2661523819,
-0.3627589047,
0.8644436002,
0.2938482761,
-0.2572324574,
0.6048454046,
0.4678683579,
0.1547974199,
0.5120329857,
-0.2759805918,
-0.678720057,
-0.5651048422,
-0.3636842668,
-0.1615842134,
0.0834627748,
0.7107339501,
-0.1825152189,
-0.3672021627,
0.1478261054,
0.4242862761,
0.0347194858,
0.0400815457,
0.6511029005,
0.3763015568,
-0.9422238469,
0.4988834262,
-0.1555630714,
0.5407838821,
-0.5945673585,
-0.0218838993,
0.1336168796,
0.0711351186,
-0.3334537745,
-0.9034072757,
0.6490446329,
0.0037596014,
-0.3163937628,
-0.3529133797,
0.6449814439,
-0.6117733717,
-0.2499759048,
0.7021512985,
0.6125782132,
0.2763203681,
-0.1725467294,
-0.7834399343,
-0.0911505744,
0.0464453362,
0.1295308918,
0.237662062,
0.3345736563,
-0.077519469,
0.4376998246,
0.45746997,
0.4051618278,
-0.0187913179,
-0.0023900594,
0.5149242282,
-0.5287233591,
-0.3272084296,
-0.7255561352,
0.4682253897,
-0.0919624567,
-0.1202568039,
0.7528145909,
0.2859334648,
0.3185711503,
0.1976676583,
1.1416246891,
-0.185042128,
0.8502411246,
-0.3865896165,
0.8104591966,
-0.6627245545,
0.0142567791,
0.2706453502,
-0.3045809567,
-0.0967064127,
0.1816595197,
-0.4788195193,
-0.2200830281,
0.9794003963,
0.7214764357,
0.1719038188,
0.3047369719,
0.2850210667,
0.4221287966,
0.3064584136,
0.7959709167,
0.8464446068,
-0.050262861,
0.017374007,
-0.1818694174,
-0.5006087422,
0.09257669,
-0.6872282028,
-1.0804026127,
-0.7217106223,
-0.3614153862,
-0.2246293724,
0.156379059,
0.7728105783,
0.4521205127,
-0.8476845026,
0.0807161406,
-0.0338544026,
0.0014164825,
-0.4265642762,
-0.1842706501,
0.2950899303,
-0.2556749582,
-0.3288758993,
0.6604138613,
0.3757734895,
-0.420393616,
-0.2903516293,
0.0373553485,
-0.1540851146,
0.1528719664,
0.2175754607,
0.1278774887,
-1.0129579306,
-0.3409237862,
-0.4747038484,
-0.0980108976,
-0.0180837959,
0.9096650481,
-0.5319583416,
0.3500021696,
0.4736803174,
0.4347878695,
-0.095809862,
-0.0046587973,
0.8338415027,
-0.3085003495,
-0.2194413394,
0.1578885764,
0.3457357287,
0.2430889159,
-0.8676431775,
0.2591785789,
0.2304850817,
-0.6544781923,
-0.6104064584,
0.2800504267,
-0.9592557549,
-0.2110322416,
0.9605014324,
-0.4539311826,
-0.1057873815,
-0.4886134863,
-0.329680115,
0.3283610642,
-0.4850616157,
0.6153792739,
0.7439165115,
-0.348790586,
-0.3161364496,
-0.8690088391,
0.8217573166,
0.4812541604,
-0.864386797,
0.2887766659,
0.4383509457,
0.5430262685,
-0.0514642112,
0.7895724177,
0.0699862987,
0.5079974532,
-0.2532440424,
0.0925052911,
0.233403787,
-0.28503263,
-0.5267948508,
-0.0688126832,
-0.1040323451,
0.4002330899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12738v1
|
Can Large Language Models be Used to Provide Psychological Counselling? An Analysis of GPT-4-Generated Responses Using Role-play Dialogues
| 2024-02-20T06:05:36 | 2024-02-20T06:05:36 |
Michimasa Inaba, Mariko Ukiyo, Keiko Takamizo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Mental health care poses an increasingly serious challenge to modern
societies. In this context, there has been a surge in research that utilizes
information technologies to address mental health problems, including those
aiming to develop counseling dialogue systems. However, there is a need for
more evaluations of the performance of counseling dialogue systems that use
large language models. For this study, we collected counseling dialogue data
via role-playing scenarios involving expert counselors, and the utterances were
annotated with the intentions of the counselors. To determine the feasibility
of a dialogue system in real-world counseling scenarios, third-party counselors
evaluated the appropriateness of responses from human counselors and those
generated by GPT-4 in identical contexts in role-play dialogue data. Analysis
of the evaluation results showed that the responses generated by GPT-4 were
competitive with those of human counselors.
|
[
-0.4649802446,
-0.734631896,
0.9939047694,
0.3664133847,
-0.1390185803,
-0.3016375303,
-0.368673414,
-0.6439713836,
-0.0882979855,
0.3080953956,
-0.6172905564,
-0.2710906565,
-0.4219042361,
0.3854614794,
-0.1501847655,
0.8966203928,
0.0930767879,
0.5267672539,
0.161585018,
0.3832059503,
-0.9537269473,
-0.7561928034,
-1.045706749,
-0.2640410662,
0.3646497726,
0.1941658109,
0.8123201132,
-0.1306019574,
0.4572598636,
0.3793194592,
0.201857388,
-0.203813836,
-0.4206576943,
0.2250491828,
-0.3039926887,
-0.402856499,
-0.8100579381,
0.3810424507,
0.4522003829,
0.2933261991,
-0.3899749517,
0.0730843991,
0.0432414263,
0.1637261659,
-0.1025217772,
0.396684736,
-0.4268589914,
0.3255513906,
0.0535216108,
-0.1451084912,
-0.4130593538,
-0.3317244947,
0.4952771664,
-0.6930844784,
0.1358845979,
-0.1307206601,
0.4956210554,
-0.0682277605,
-0.4283826053,
-0.4338417351,
-1.076245904,
0.3777161539,
-1.0846232176,
0.1581374109,
0.7689352632,
0.5459495783,
-0.3689933121,
-0.3252876997,
-0.5074581504,
-0.251915127,
-0.1410423368,
0.3070808649,
-0.1696341038,
0.2431099713,
0.6609406471,
0.149530068,
-0.4034980237,
-0.0148077775,
-0.4694932997,
-0.1131226793,
0.7300507426,
0.3623005748,
0.3599018157,
0.0842433497,
0.2194211036,
0.1764148325,
-0.2843132317,
-0.1696128249,
0.2723255455,
0.236111179,
0.0441176966,
0.524104178,
0.1882808954,
0.4837741256,
0.2326232642,
-0.6577959657,
-0.2972873151,
-0.0738338828,
-0.2284813672,
0.0961404145,
0.8490843773,
0.9295707345,
0.4422008693,
-0.0510090888,
-0.0946869031,
0.0300983489,
0.5042058825,
-0.8471096754,
-0.1313357055,
-0.0266538206,
-0.4207681417,
-0.0699020177,
-0.4348348379,
-0.9515625834,
-0.4435343146,
-0.2868707776,
0.2846781909,
-0.4089328945,
-0.5074017048,
0.013913447,
0.0415060483,
0.1841168106,
0.2547970116,
-0.8484177589,
0.5938048959,
0.5307172537,
0.9426210523,
0.0667444468,
-0.0360047892,
-0.3862264752,
0.0955045372,
-0.4286480546,
0.5157682896,
-0.5649928451,
-0.776740253,
0.1782460213,
-0.1113076657,
-0.0496451966,
-0.4527877271,
0.6220855117,
-0.3864995837,
0.4249572456,
-0.5716354847,
-0.4790046215,
0.4111110568,
0.458052218,
-0.5075052381,
0.5171171427,
0.214446336,
-0.8511901498,
0.3115312457,
-0.7195708752,
-0.2767387033,
0.1936679482,
-0.3660582006,
-0.0606341958,
0.0483625159,
0.1790005714,
0.4347838461,
-0.6336488128,
0.584020257,
-0.4037157893,
-0.6506851315,
0.5700852275,
-0.6863739491,
0.2603679001,
0.2177897692,
-0.4899975657,
-0.1988714784,
-0.2498159856,
0.0396756642,
0.0838581696,
-0.3889910877,
-0.1518128663,
-0.1007667929,
-0.0639849007,
0.5552514791,
-0.1553163975,
-0.7116346955,
0.2972795665,
-0.2884538174,
0.4162638783,
0.6467544436,
0.09218961,
-0.0372559689,
-0.2087471485,
1.0443439484,
-0.2382345647,
0.0793118402,
0.0265198406,
-0.7681748867,
-0.153884694,
-0.4161921442,
-0.0824044496,
0.4196332097,
-0.8877536058,
0.2225756496,
0.0066095768,
-0.3956318498,
-0.2241931707,
-0.5200807452,
0.4724634886,
0.535559833,
0.1613786966,
-0.096588172,
-0.4353850782,
-0.9723343253,
-0.5154059529,
-0.3199292123,
-0.0780631304,
0.519923687,
0.1336867809,
-0.073260054,
0.9794927239,
-0.5864537358,
-0.1967462152,
-0.1960652024,
0.1230412275,
-0.0294321366,
0.3633780777,
0.690191865,
-0.2867374718,
-0.4355559349,
-0.1416305453,
-0.8197745085,
-0.2905091047,
0.13814345,
-0.1054333821,
0.0279714521,
0.2287544012,
-0.6168009639,
0.386669904,
0.7786223888,
-0.5215369463,
0.9266614318,
-0.4546186328,
0.3031653464,
-0.9312064052,
0.0541020818,
0.1502892077,
-0.1278943717,
-0.6764349341,
-0.3360518217,
-0.3163296282,
-0.498134762,
0.0253031533,
0.3846746087,
-0.1017052457,
-0.0903623402,
-0.2275423557,
0.1585905999,
-0.5054754615,
0.4481792152,
0.037786711,
0.8860514164,
0.4562836587,
-0.2286161333,
0.4273745418,
0.299518019,
-0.2242531329,
0.9816676974,
-0.4993075728,
0.1565045714,
0.1724101156,
0.9317378998,
-0.7576209903,
-0.6853544116,
0.0576118305,
-0.0587489977,
0.0359201431,
-0.1027811915,
-0.3887477219,
-0.7279033065,
0.1157231778,
0.5699924231,
0.2769763768,
-0.0251565538,
0.2333604395,
0.2997935414,
-0.6236804724,
-0.2710732818,
-0.4600330293,
0.3461951315,
-0.4773269594,
-0.4366585612,
-0.0011274298,
-0.0873577222,
-0.1391116679,
-0.2334812135,
0.0766345933,
-0.017168764,
-0.1420613825,
0.2151739299,
0.3005643487,
-0.1249127164,
0.2337671369,
-0.0554012321,
-0.2242385149,
0.3235737979,
-0.2779923379,
0.5104864836,
-0.2805799246,
-0.6605386138,
-0.5425060987,
0.7067239881,
0.63085711,
-0.2134209126,
0.6387948394,
0.5734286308,
-0.5240564346,
0.2756461203,
-0.7679088116,
-0.26441136,
-0.4704549909,
0.2977012694,
-0.3239879012,
-1.1316490173,
0.3507140577,
-0.0781170949,
0.0107039036,
0.0339693278,
0.6630057096,
0.0478215255,
1.6378028393,
0.1594755501,
0.2435277998,
0.4171326756,
-0.1026503965,
0.6891905069,
-0.6664807796,
0.0033973975,
-0.1822489798,
-0.274546057,
-0.8065620661,
-0.1348930448,
0.6405891776,
-0.0156897865,
-0.5048074722,
0.1083266959,
-0.3817534447,
0.1122777238,
0.2482653856,
0.1724251062,
0.3053173423,
-0.2267525494,
-0.3218254745,
-0.4442082644,
-0.3645522594,
-0.727812767,
0.761138618,
0.435334295,
0.5554394126,
0.3334281743,
0.389272362,
-0.0588478297,
0.8046190143,
-0.8003299832,
0.6347835064,
0.296143651,
-0.859005332,
-0.4682101905,
-0.4458981752,
-0.9408585429,
0.3738213778,
-0.2062484324,
-1.2240276337,
0.0406920463,
0.12206617,
-0.5966898203,
0.0823848546,
-0.8236171603,
0.828066051,
-0.18274647,
0.021362491,
-0.2129604816,
-0.4344783425,
0.5840808153,
-0.425191015,
0.3675316572,
-0.1596690714,
0.4205884337,
0.7540896535,
-0.4718691409,
0.589676857,
-0.4659938514,
-0.5335520506,
0.1573676616,
0.251008302,
0.3361807466,
0.2625046968,
-0.250285089,
-0.4941125512,
0.5564699769,
-0.1387667656,
-0.8620259762,
0.8102704287,
-0.8902413249,
-0.9412223697,
-0.3984137774,
-0.5493388176,
-0.8925901651,
0.1669652164,
0.1199363917,
0.7784386277,
-0.3357368708,
-0.1501834691,
0.044902999,
-0.326300472,
0.2142792493,
0.6822420359,
-0.4514192641,
-0.3294892311,
0.6784651875,
0.2401250452,
0.1927332878,
-0.588693738,
0.392051518,
-0.1266617775,
-0.2197317183,
-0.0831527933,
0.5158135295,
-0.4823535383,
-0.0731112584,
-0.5202736259,
-0.0282479208,
-0.3635169268,
-0.1499400884,
-0.1582151502,
0.0303244144,
0.3202235103,
-0.3510068059,
0.235951528,
1.0624334812,
-0.1252894402,
0.3792973757,
-0.8732587099,
0.0709053278,
0.4808285534,
0.5936859846,
0.248553589,
-0.056329798,
-0.3294609785,
0.1974701881,
-0.3159266412,
-1.1753497124,
0.307018131,
-0.1243333593,
0.3527519703,
0.3888077438,
0.0541999638,
0.8146150708,
-0.6467652321,
1.0556349754,
0.207281664,
-0.7692993283,
0.4152099192,
-1.0131592751,
0.3267689347,
0.4049678445,
0.3166369796,
-0.7844229937,
-0.4369017482,
-0.635063231,
-0.5710217357,
1.215252161,
0.3263657689,
0.1036999747,
-0.197967127,
0.5060830712,
-0.230868727,
0.1774463803,
-0.5385536551,
0.198490724,
-0.0860348418,
-0.2038575709,
0.0620738193,
-0.1545485854,
-0.4880259931,
0.0417657122,
0.4949841499,
-0.037731234,
0.799405396,
0.2541324496,
0.3732362986,
-0.3648499548,
0.3700791299,
0.501532495,
0.4949482381,
-0.1522910595,
-0.0277649723,
0.2365239412,
-0.5720559359,
0.3333025873,
0.125823006,
0.3963204622,
-0.3699292541,
0.3591914475,
0.6681882143,
0.2577929497,
-0.6680322289,
0.6649130583,
-0.4984526038,
-0.2823159695,
-0.2761963904,
0.0679074451,
0.174695164,
0.4745419323,
0.0869432837,
-0.2400533408,
0.2521603405,
-0.8504364491,
-0.0139810331,
0.4120886028,
-0.4730938971,
-0.3727733493,
0.4690485299,
0.2435204983,
-0.6405517459,
0.6439974904,
-0.037970949,
-0.4822134674,
0.253099829,
1.0506732464,
0.5933488607,
-0.4344546497,
0.3675462604,
0.2917196453,
-0.0641728491,
-0.4093260169,
0.1587719619,
0.2137685716,
-0.5489573479,
-0.6068956852,
-0.3185144663,
-0.4396190047,
0.4311090112,
-0.7673864365,
0.0238591284,
-0.2817064822,
-0.7728816867,
-0.2871010602,
-0.1612292528,
-0.9278333187,
0.2812327743,
0.2494060844,
0.5090304613,
-0.8335943222,
0.5605059862,
0.7858737111,
-0.2387381047,
-1.2554905415,
0.1572608948,
0.1938391924,
-0.2163949311,
0.4551103115,
0.1807657033,
-0.248146385,
-0.1671182066,
-0.4277079701,
-0.8122478724,
1.144156456,
0.6898462772,
-0.2090723366,
-0.5194071531,
0.1966057718,
0.9643648267,
-0.5041134357,
0.7190234661,
0.8524836302,
0.6364420056,
0.0233259723,
-1.5402290821,
0.1825233102,
-0.3474365473,
0.1307357252,
-0.2262843996,
-0.524119556,
0.6144067049,
0.2542738318,
-0.1625210196,
0.2224410921,
0.2678095996,
0.4395952523,
-0.0712148398,
0.5181344748,
0.0408679582,
0.6827682853,
0.0013921697,
1.0481976271,
-0.3030748367,
0.4081697464,
1.1291577816,
-0.6092839241,
0.5254846215,
-0.0585915744,
-0.2275835127,
0.2626709044,
0.5010472536,
0.2281385362,
0.1657759398,
0.3128041923,
-0.3222893476,
-0.2584505379,
-0.1123823375,
-0.3145153821,
0.3566508591,
0.6929677725,
-0.1712471247,
-0.0911170468,
0.2174572498,
0.1678030938,
-0.1371297836,
0.0318920389,
0.6968841553,
0.2707997262,
-1.0029737949,
0.3204160631,
0.1306820363,
0.3326268792,
-0.5519461036,
-0.2537012994,
0.0339968316,
0.3129309416,
-0.2063017786,
-0.6896492243,
0.0234849211,
0.3639805615,
0.2629961967,
-0.1493411362,
0.6121264696,
-0.3594664633,
-0.4430238605,
0.2680952847,
0.5988500118,
0.2958304286,
0.0138098262,
-0.4411574304,
-0.2637456059,
-0.3547434211,
-0.2533866167,
0.5730584264,
0.5813781619,
-0.2244202644,
0.5340889096,
0.3911304772,
0.0605539195,
-0.2230120599,
0.1558723599,
0.8017517924,
-0.5212543011,
-0.6369662285,
-0.6073235869,
0.1467096657,
-0.2380404323,
-0.2205490768,
0.7443638444,
0.1503245085,
0.2432581782,
0.1187966764,
1.0265375376,
0.0538699552,
0.4670289755,
-0.2371487767,
0.3606642783,
-0.1153825969,
0.0796821117,
-0.803375721,
-1.0115535259,
-0.0944972634,
0.8885499835,
-0.8016206622,
0.4119997025,
0.8276197314,
0.6283197999,
0.0302675776,
0.4635104537,
0.4200259745,
0.355281353,
0.9216046333,
0.3973447978,
0.9519357085,
0.0655807927,
0.3553191721,
0.3179275095,
-0.3991011083,
-0.0517250858,
-0.647053957,
-1.0349742174,
-0.4444192946,
0.1959383786,
-0.2750378847,
-0.0215259027,
1.1809098721,
0.4241578877,
-0.4807529151,
-0.2033093572,
0.2302131653,
-0.7301201224,
-0.0634462088,
-0.2227304727,
0.2350696772,
-0.0462261438,
-0.4938053787,
0.4407165945,
0.051233802,
-0.0479214154,
-0.5646902323,
0.041341681,
0.0692283139,
0.2646654546,
0.6695095301,
-0.0611226968,
-0.8092525005,
-0.4823009372,
-0.1069074422,
-0.0664110929,
-0.1665359885,
1.2444332838,
-0.5211990476,
0.4207687378,
0.0588158034,
0.3000720143,
0.478515476,
0.1013086364,
1.3325953484,
-0.3758788109,
-0.0444613807,
0.1400346011,
0.3760008216,
0.2837761939,
-0.5721683502,
0.5007306337,
-0.1006846279,
-0.7958612442,
-0.5939574242,
0.2135153115,
-0.4408278167,
0.0392446928,
1.2125405073,
-0.6285777688,
0.4291110933,
-0.3691934645,
-0.9010671377,
0.3618809283,
-0.6489843726,
0.6382588148,
1.1103155613,
-0.5126643777,
0.0433381796,
-0.8996337056,
0.7048672438,
0.1362553239,
-0.7220490575,
0.0098355226,
0.6487789154,
0.1798528731,
0.1634044796,
1.0587493181,
-0.1361271143,
0.1017995998,
-0.2960893512,
-0.4015974402,
0.2459245026,
0.1421607584,
-0.0749955624,
-0.011197296,
0.2786618471,
0.7239979506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14853v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14853v1
|
NL2Formula: Generating Spreadsheet Formulas from Natural Language Queries
| 2024-02-20T05:58:05 | 2024-02-20T05:58:05 |
Wei Zhao, Zhitao Hou, Siyuan Wu, Yan Gao, Haoyu Dong, Yao Wan, Hongyu Zhang, Yulei Sui, Haidong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Writing formulas on spreadsheets, such as Microsoft Excel and Google Sheets,
is a widespread practice among users performing data analysis. However,
crafting formulas on spreadsheets remains a tedious and error-prone task for
many end-users, particularly when dealing with complex operations. To alleviate
the burden associated with writing spreadsheet formulas, this paper introduces
a novel benchmark task called NL2Formula, with the aim to generate executable
formulas that are grounded on a spreadsheet table, given a Natural Language
(NL) query as input. To accomplish this, we construct a comprehensive dataset
consisting of 70,799 paired NL queries and corresponding spreadsheet formulas,
covering 21,670 tables and 37 types of formula functions. We realize the
NL2Formula task by providing a sequence-to-sequence baseline implementation
called fCoder. Experimental results validate the effectiveness of fCoder,
demonstrating its superior performance compared to the baseline models.
Furthermore, we also compare fCoder with an initial GPT-3.5 model (i.e.,
text-davinci-003). Lastly, through in-depth error analysis, we identify
potential challenges in the NL2Formula task and advocate for further
investigation.
|
[
0.1542265415,
-0.8826325536,
0.1942640245,
0.3689761162,
0.1322118193,
-0.0532018505,
-0.3019961417,
-0.4743131399,
-0.1372146308,
0.5401880145,
-0.5523968935,
-0.5762236714,
-0.2718744278,
0.3398063481,
-0.6064735651,
1.0188906193,
-0.2815162838,
-0.0949526653,
-0.4109368324,
-0.0463986583,
-0.3292874992,
-0.3302803934,
-0.2489247322,
0.2300615609,
0.2765256464,
0.6380442381,
0.4148672819,
0.4253190458,
0.5187871456,
0.1906917989,
0.1311015785,
0.2460578978,
-0.5720729232,
0.5102764964,
0.3018452823,
-0.578332901,
-0.4144012034,
0.0315114781,
0.6856582761,
0.7054721713,
-0.349178344,
0.4139291346,
-0.0471853763,
0.9978882074,
-0.411059171,
0.2399071604,
-0.8020614982,
0.240644604,
-0.513294518,
0.1842717528,
-0.454821825,
-0.8103470802,
0.039872013,
-0.7524584532,
0.3607913256,
0.0557429343,
0.583912015,
0.4055036306,
-0.0445941053,
-0.7421367764,
-0.4867207706,
0.4635129571,
-0.7692379355,
0.1803955287,
0.3059803247,
0.5916540027,
-0.4915647805,
-0.8469418287,
-0.6206342578,
-0.3914951384,
-0.3319412768,
0.19812195,
-0.3016310036,
-0.6043143868,
0.649295032,
-0.0341516696,
-0.8154417276,
-0.0564425439,
-0.5174217224,
0.0653480664,
0.4507040083,
0.1551974416,
0.2388407439,
-0.2163603902,
-0.2213217467,
-0.1625780463,
-0.6432377696,
0.2406416982,
0.3704586625,
0.4246384203,
-0.1316474676,
0.5728775859,
-0.1880989671,
0.5930575728,
-0.2770789862,
0.2300364226,
0.0017527603,
-0.2004508078,
-0.3159926236,
0.1027864441,
0.6981322169,
0.3249552548,
0.1829180866,
-0.4582552314,
0.0952346921,
0.1124150902,
0.408110261,
-0.8086798787,
-0.3469258547,
0.2496240139,
0.1165095568,
-0.3331563175,
0.2062731087,
-0.8211767673,
0.0245414115,
-0.4882094264,
0.1326621175,
-0.4691695869,
0.1443142146,
-0.5296726823,
0.0515649095,
0.0880840644,
0.3217695057,
-0.7471104264,
0.6383231282,
0.7723559141,
0.8251207471,
-0.1589128822,
-0.0785853341,
-1.0122601986,
0.2238472551,
-0.3464893997,
0.937279284,
-0.3076971173,
-0.4895325303,
-0.1638698429,
-0.253374517,
-0.1833314002,
-0.5637462735,
0.6301621795,
-0.2212777287,
0.3556925654,
-0.6183294654,
-0.7204809189,
0.0782850161,
0.0265100859,
-0.9847248197,
1.3917220831,
0.4080961943,
-0.5176656842,
0.263566941,
-0.9474433064,
-0.5317665339,
0.2350401878,
-0.2852731049,
-0.509039104,
-0.0559813231,
-0.0041921246,
0.1879341751,
-0.573715806,
0.2139863074,
0.0966378823,
-0.2025348842,
0.0444491133,
-0.0440803543,
0.5069971085,
-0.0682467818,
-0.5828925371,
0.1184597611,
-0.7784401178,
0.2408045381,
0.0911420062,
-0.129850328,
-0.1129629761,
-0.0565111749,
0.219055295,
0.0441267081,
-0.0356926322,
-0.3774313927,
0.2145525068,
-0.2789390385,
0.3955646157,
0.2247702777,
-0.4365983605,
0.3556173444,
-0.2039680183,
0.3992662132,
-0.3562776446,
-0.200026989,
0.0458591133,
-0.5665281415,
-0.3692393005,
0.0923500359,
0.2609711289,
0.746717751,
-0.4073493779,
0.1900347173,
-0.1317578107,
-0.764926672,
-0.0636922196,
0.4773318768,
0.6309807897,
1.1260938644,
0.5147437453,
0.2766264975,
-0.6563126445,
-0.8596960902,
-0.2927452326,
0.0624471866,
-0.0239769891,
0.2869124115,
0.479023695,
-0.0261487309,
1.0456598997,
-0.5923663378,
-0.4062327147,
-0.1600050777,
0.4665766954,
0.3975386322,
0.3168467283,
0.7066040039,
-0.7444410324,
-0.8170903325,
-0.0364466012,
-0.7147735357,
-0.3310725987,
0.0877217129,
-0.5096811652,
0.6667969823,
0.4403039217,
-0.3384369016,
0.3208311796,
0.4054815173,
-0.2131335288,
0.7132507563,
-0.1589310616,
-0.1692210436,
-1.0578131676,
0.7138679624,
0.0213402249,
0.0225886069,
-0.7154785991,
-0.1962076575,
0.4801153243,
0.058580298,
-0.1641410589,
0.3949753642,
-0.22682105,
-0.1576609761,
0.191474095,
-0.0856034681,
-0.012807074,
0.2393574417,
-0.1370186955,
1.0577373505,
-0.138718918,
-0.3889986277,
-0.0455509685,
0.6593379378,
-0.2242780328,
0.4915599227,
-0.7501668334,
0.1209826991,
0.0881433263,
0.2898573577,
-1.0202460289,
-0.3679637611,
-0.1998483986,
-0.3031024337,
0.2083131075,
-0.09822689,
-0.4486457407,
-0.5222983956,
-0.1903001964,
0.0600780919,
0.5172290802,
-0.3332018852,
0.3542072177,
0.3436493576,
-0.2737351954,
-0.5114917755,
-0.5127635598,
0.2260587066,
-0.0821666941,
-0.7097011209,
0.6639587283,
0.1121047586,
-0.2904253006,
-0.0191962849,
-0.1902442873,
0.0350220725,
0.0133093204,
0.3010970652,
0.2939638495,
-0.1922970563,
-0.1126977131,
0.2802214324,
-0.0936824828,
0.1926691979,
-0.0547790676,
0.4263332784,
-0.1575275064,
0.0997368172,
-0.1711235642,
0.6239573359,
0.3558461368,
-0.073173821,
0.2286833376,
0.5838446617,
-0.4484362006,
-0.3931304514,
-0.4150756299,
-0.0018146762,
-0.3787624836,
0.0974499434,
-0.1906993389,
-0.5235893726,
0.4962201118,
0.3368439376,
0.3926771283,
0.754955709,
0.7158746123,
-0.2024514973,
0.4346383512,
0.3283590376,
0.3174620569,
0.1128715128,
-0.3780171573,
-0.0112336036,
-0.7656593323,
-0.4461096823,
-0.6581763625,
-0.2860464156,
-0.3619219661,
-0.5410556793,
0.5632133484,
0.1924324632,
-0.1030591652,
0.9901437163,
-0.3494559526,
0.3078990579,
0.7618071437,
-0.2285345644,
0.1130335629,
0.0324858353,
-0.4765750468,
-0.1862275749,
-0.4754531384,
-0.636377275,
1.2017151117,
-0.1938392371,
0.2625003457,
0.4654784799,
0.6788982749,
0.284170568,
0.8854846954,
-0.4119279087,
0.2632322609,
-0.454035908,
-0.3778587878,
-0.3209818006,
-0.6053059101,
-0.6337488294,
-0.0832928643,
-0.157473743,
-0.7200632691,
-0.32842502,
0.2842644453,
-0.3326561153,
-0.0578958169,
-0.8911214471,
1.0751143694,
-0.3027880788,
-0.7507809401,
0.4250075817,
-0.6062309146,
0.5118129849,
-0.2483614087,
0.283256799,
-0.37853387,
0.2615399063,
0.8858988285,
-0.9244210124,
0.4287699163,
-0.2762217224,
-0.2108034492,
0.1835052371,
0.1917807013,
0.5640746951,
0.2021390349,
-0.4099195004,
-0.1286548525,
0.1832527667,
-0.2655504346,
-0.4910903871,
0.6835761666,
-0.2132459283,
-0.0744261965,
-0.2290455848,
-0.5881474018,
-0.3244116902,
0.2545762658,
0.3103567362,
0.5756923556,
-0.4034253061,
0.1197536066,
-0.006849044,
-0.0639944002,
0.598846972,
0.4270763993,
0.076210618,
-0.4738271236,
0.4205142856,
0.211438179,
0.0809731632,
0.4911772609,
0.2651848197,
-0.6120803952,
-0.3176394999,
-0.7196058631,
-0.2315864265,
-0.303240031,
-0.5319219232,
-0.6255882978,
0.1333871186,
-0.4759446979,
-0.0757613853,
-0.1426158994,
-0.607232213,
-0.1044225693,
0.1418667585,
0.7129687071,
0.4661487639,
-0.1021424159,
0.0828707516,
-0.6495459676,
0.4945482016,
0.3166809678,
0.3378323615,
-0.1148737296,
-0.0681729391,
0.0160056595,
0.0391002111,
-0.3036904931,
-0.7594243884,
0.6577851176,
0.3908767104,
0.4691046774,
-0.1169566587,
0.0779151767,
0.7800833583,
-0.8751441836,
0.4410595,
0.1513530165,
-0.9133756161,
0.5545950532,
-0.4071652889,
0.0743126497,
0.9404525757,
0.3221732974,
-0.406770438,
-0.3001234531,
-0.3588709533,
-1.2523523569,
0.6528645158,
0.7798629403,
-0.0683425367,
-0.112422891,
0.382399708,
0.4170474112,
0.1380358338,
-0.1937461644,
-0.1927217096,
-0.2436730862,
-0.3429248333,
0.0502378382,
-0.1134315208,
-0.0735072121,
-0.2709973454,
0.4722004533,
-0.3566536009,
0.2703960538,
0.2899551392,
-0.3804391325,
-0.1841320097,
0.1732879132,
0.9108636975,
0.5598272681,
-0.7276648879,
-0.2796331942,
0.0715512708,
-0.6841362119,
-0.2794522941,
0.5795724392,
-0.2912704051,
0.111122027,
0.1882849783,
0.379401356,
0.5397767425,
-0.8009451032,
0.1903686821,
-0.2108965814,
-0.27185902,
-0.5416731834,
0.01971763,
0.2305171639,
-0.331199646,
0.6822960377,
-0.1891552955,
0.2673767805,
-0.413589716,
0.6478591561,
0.3815397024,
-0.2214797735,
-0.0870516971,
1.0811473131,
-0.0046682307,
-0.2696388364,
0.598434329,
-0.2487568855,
-0.5340685248,
0.8249341846,
0.6409903169,
0.6154027581,
0.1595265716,
0.1308382899,
0.6644126773,
0.0003605473,
-0.0787997469,
0.5747217536,
-0.0237918422,
-0.2632615566,
-0.2500278652,
-0.9204266071,
-0.9760209918,
-0.0301313084,
-0.9323520064,
0.1618279815,
-0.3499228656,
-0.0144337937,
0.5010977983,
0.0812673345,
-0.807294488,
0.0154179288,
-0.0451607369,
0.8723012209,
-0.5021412969,
0.6250727773,
0.4653281868,
-0.2839619517,
-0.9361857176,
-0.2850891948,
0.183520928,
-0.5457823873,
0.6900075078,
0.5732320547,
0.2904786766,
-0.0845342129,
-0.2788669467,
-0.654979229,
1.2339798212,
0.2014382929,
-0.8426777124,
-0.1923134327,
0.3062698841,
0.409368068,
-0.2932335138,
0.3582155108,
0.9570683241,
0.5570325851,
0.1318472475,
-0.8360825181,
0.2838696539,
-0.7744058371,
-0.080320783,
0.3644614816,
-0.0951738283,
0.7663610578,
-0.21559982,
0.0325731635,
0.4202145636,
0.421752125,
0.3055485785,
0.3870112002,
0.1840644032,
0.5033490062,
1.0061395168,
-0.4341601431,
1.0389555693,
-0.2533520162,
0.1697681099,
1.4074758291,
-0.6876514554,
1.093798995,
0.3105610311,
-0.3832136095,
0.5752289891,
0.01468476,
-0.348552525,
0.2222082168,
0.395794183,
0.1640417576,
0.2713999152,
0.3378857672,
-0.3922968507,
0.38483724,
0.4520590007,
-0.2240365595,
-0.6165719628,
-0.5356106162,
0.1981869787,
0.4465888739,
0.1721799076,
0.7076814771,
-0.1703838706,
-0.723780036,
0.4643941224,
-0.1311357617,
0.3120372593,
-0.5400925279,
-0.0595068671,
-0.3178568482,
-0.0970434025,
-0.1834843308,
-0.5273225904,
0.6611962318,
0.5139958262,
-0.1279103458,
-0.0879430026,
0.1152723357,
-0.4078801572,
-0.8596362472,
-0.1297206134,
0.3744255602,
-0.1007215381,
-0.2105592042,
-0.5976129174,
-0.1821396649,
-0.1614609063,
-0.1413369328,
-0.1045983359,
0.1786324084,
-0.1881890148,
0.198307097,
1.1615810394,
-0.2628803849,
-0.0153428428,
0.1482131183,
0.7175957561,
-0.8297752142,
-0.4605102539,
-0.6519110799,
0.4808543921,
-0.4309526086,
-0.4396114945,
0.6429727077,
1.0062888861,
0.3077212274,
-0.0380097292,
0.6942471862,
-0.3256295025,
0.6663674712,
-0.7298762798,
0.9637417197,
-0.2663042843,
0.1216684282,
-0.5314370394,
-0.9070695639,
-0.5999407172,
0.4945570827,
-0.316752106,
-0.3670577407,
0.6052357554,
0.6201632023,
0.1778522432,
0.277115941,
-0.0718440861,
0.155271396,
0.5371443629,
0.5668459535,
0.2438629419,
-0.587213099,
0.4873231053,
-0.4017297924,
-0.0015724147,
-0.3695706129,
-1.077488184,
-0.6239224076,
-0.4457133412,
-0.1692500114,
-0.3693717718,
-0.1120810658,
0.9000325799,
0.4482456446,
-1.0950382948,
-0.2873559892,
-0.5056307316,
-0.1417223811,
-0.0710726306,
-0.2547849417,
0.6118083,
-0.5055705905,
-0.641890347,
0.3843934834,
0.1901039928,
0.1238586456,
0.1790501624,
0.0903424695,
-0.0210974086,
-0.1615947932,
0.6247233748,
0.528177917,
-0.442702949,
0.2367245108,
0.2675391436,
-0.1865480244,
0.1835594177,
0.7945691943,
-0.6701400876,
0.1213951707,
0.2866604924,
0.4066812098,
0.5562678576,
0.2207213789,
0.7916548252,
-0.5818949342,
-0.1087052673,
0.3604750931,
0.2692813873,
0.4443484247,
-0.2957254946,
0.7163696289,
-0.0485951006,
-0.1341564655,
-1.0194417238,
0.0139776524,
-1.5055804253,
0.1088050827,
1.161131978,
0.1490492374,
-0.4052671492,
0.1653609723,
-0.1727690995,
0.1903952211,
-0.4949173629,
0.7705830336,
0.2287629247,
-0.1405584961,
0.4220132828,
-0.7754334807,
0.8769449592,
0.3584698737,
-1.2079865932,
0.1475805193,
0.3802776635,
0.3685016334,
0.1084024087,
0.3262760043,
-0.2574044168,
0.428602457,
-0.0629706234,
-0.3148982823,
-0.2625762522,
-0.0210607853,
0.3515661657,
0.3598807454,
-0.5058287978,
0.4215196073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12730v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12730v2
|
UMBCLU at SemEval-2024 Task 1A and 1C: Semantic Textual Relatedness with and without machine translation
| 2024-02-20T05:46:29 | 2024-04-12T00:53:29 |
Shubhashis Roy Dipta, Sai Vallurupalli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The aim of SemEval-2024 Task 1, "Semantic Textual Relatedness for African and
Asian Languages" is to develop models for identifying semantic textual
relatedness (STR) between two sentences using multiple languages (14 African
and Asian languages) and settings (supervised, unsupervised, and
cross-lingual). Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance
on several natural language understanding tasks such as multilingual machine
translation (MMT), semantic similarity (STS), and encoding sentence embeddings.
Using a combination of LLMs that perform well on these tasks, we developed two
STR models, $\textit{TranSem}$ and $\textit{FineSem}$, for the supervised and
cross-lingual settings. We explore the effectiveness of several training
methods and the usefulness of machine translation. We find that direct
fine-tuning on the task is comparable to using sentence embeddings and
translating to English leads to better performance for some languages. In the
supervised setting, our model performance is better than the official baseline
for 3 languages with the remaining 4 performing on par. In the cross-lingual
setting, our model performance is better than the baseline for 3 languages
(leading to $1^{st}$ place for Africaans and $2^{nd}$ place for Indonesian), is
on par for 2 languages and performs poorly on the remaining 7 languages. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/dipta007/SemEval24-Task8.
|
[
-0.4291309416,
-0.852257669,
0.5511190891,
0.3346664608,
-0.5154160857,
-0.3356676996,
-0.3984425366,
-0.6713531017,
0.2141466588,
0.9019910693,
-0.6482487321,
-0.5504695773,
-0.5823282003,
0.478181839,
-0.281365484,
0.8420634866,
-0.3529055417,
0.1650433242,
-0.3636420965,
-0.5531311035,
-0.5716394782,
-0.6864511371,
-0.5598084927,
-0.2983371913,
0.5511251092,
0.3713277876,
0.5540043116,
0.6543416381,
0.7339227796,
0.307490319,
0.052576229,
0.2129694521,
-0.3509016335,
0.0888911709,
-0.4043015242,
-0.3718750775,
-0.2464342117,
-0.1660112292,
0.4294892251,
0.9046232104,
0.4106679261,
0.1287474334,
0.3506136835,
0.6562572718,
-0.4024790823,
0.0359385312,
-0.4975760281,
-0.019794872,
-0.3322778046,
-0.4297290146,
-0.2993746102,
-0.103550382,
0.0452942252,
-0.6116159558,
0.1210955307,
-0.0429171473,
1.0368075371,
0.4531506598,
-0.9925835133,
-0.4524431229,
-0.3227119744,
0.718634665,
-0.7047580481,
0.3412555754,
0.8944971561,
0.0661378205,
-0.0054409988,
-0.6650043726,
-0.3071604967,
0.092496179,
-0.0983981192,
0.2429792732,
0.0649694279,
-0.0102767088,
0.1762402207,
0.162787348,
-0.678303957,
0.1594703346,
-0.261751622,
-0.2392494828,
0.5680644512,
0.1296991408,
0.2706837058,
-0.3608958125,
-0.4912689924,
0.1684847325,
-0.8946782947,
-0.0478999391,
0.3730470538,
0.3694831729,
-0.1420606077,
0.6995669007,
-0.1654401422,
0.4794236124,
-0.3305497766,
0.1641409248,
0.3361535668,
-0.7988833785,
-0.0694555491,
0.0106690433,
0.5754268765,
0.211506173,
0.2069876343,
-0.0310348645,
-0.106981039,
0.2330132425,
0.1776523143,
-0.7299672961,
0.0025949492,
-0.1268945783,
-0.6551017165,
-0.1333734691,
-0.1696023792,
-0.4715313613,
-0.0280514527,
-0.7137990594,
0.6892830729,
-0.6032588482,
-0.0786807835,
-0.2004357278,
0.2346524298,
0.3275832534,
0.3095729351,
-0.886701405,
0.2682484686,
0.6840580702,
0.7054582238,
-0.3361698389,
-0.562153995,
-0.3108722866,
0.0680512488,
-0.1636481285,
0.7234678864,
-0.5841048956,
-0.2466135025,
0.0660856962,
0.4505591691,
-0.257674098,
-0.3558965325,
0.8505781293,
-0.3730565906,
-0.0483606085,
-0.5034331679,
-0.6477121711,
-0.5407890081,
0.2372650504,
-0.7401230335,
1.1146378517,
-0.0823056623,
-0.8076446056,
0.3663924038,
-0.6658030152,
-0.7325013876,
-0.0858779699,
0.0159647148,
-0.357999593,
0.1232007444,
0.1628587246,
0.5267292261,
-0.0944328383,
0.1682656258,
-0.3092162907,
-0.514985323,
0.1143247783,
-0.4574010074,
0.9427748322,
0.3997941911,
-0.3552785814,
-0.0325774848,
-0.6631811261,
-0.0959787145,
0.1690658182,
-0.3088560998,
-0.7389273047,
-0.3232296705,
0.1961730421,
0.2605223358,
0.3112635314,
-0.3280183971,
-0.0567592531,
-0.4303177595,
0.3874254227,
0.5189668536,
0.1029063538,
0.3643138111,
-0.0841802582,
0.4286545515,
0.1583412886,
-0.2229346186,
-0.4380116463,
-0.3999514878,
-0.9236171246,
-0.0467362292,
0.6454823613,
0.5245062113,
-0.9282547235,
0.2136293799,
-0.2836641073,
-0.269824028,
-0.5432787538,
0.1978295892,
0.3025099039,
0.2412982583,
0.3310106099,
-0.2834042013,
-0.7521930933,
-0.9673035145,
-0.3705925047,
0.1183925346,
0.0986920893,
0.0785026774,
0.8423933387,
-0.4995160401,
0.3973826468,
0.1010399759,
-0.2697311938,
-0.0442098603,
0.2502445877,
-0.005383071,
0.4691298306,
0.5907592177,
-0.8679602146,
-0.3827307522,
0.339823693,
-0.8953204751,
-0.3154002428,
0.2487367243,
-0.2384228855,
0.6991720796,
0.5476707816,
-0.0325717367,
0.7530218363,
0.7019675374,
-0.557987988,
0.1839442253,
-0.3632668257,
0.5170218945,
-1.3249008656,
0.1467763335,
-0.1825541407,
-0.438570112,
-0.6430416107,
0.1475683004,
0.1846360117,
-0.2002833486,
-0.510735929,
0.3858499825,
-0.3832705617,
-0.2169872373,
-0.4441452026,
0.1482391953,
-0.1269696653,
0.5982538462,
0.1594435722,
0.7249480486,
0.1211320087,
-0.7997859716,
-0.0074403821,
0.3263466358,
-0.2193922997,
0.6348509789,
-0.6160054803,
0.0059755351,
0.0397787318,
-0.0561496727,
-0.875218153,
-0.0470416062,
-0.0326820053,
-0.4428862631,
0.203877151,
-0.0139211873,
-0.5137162805,
-0.1006841436,
-0.0989245921,
0.6313244104,
0.1882905066,
-0.4378326535,
0.5258022547,
0.4276649356,
-0.4943518341,
-0.4498910904,
-1.0440819263,
0.2045066953,
-0.294493556,
-0.7863336802,
0.2186808437,
0.186552912,
0.0303174853,
0.1307005286,
0.0605851449,
-0.0887133107,
0.3145919144,
0.2363989949,
0.2984203696,
-0.1469288766,
0.1737971455,
0.3141478598,
-0.2977867424,
0.0533493981,
-0.343917191,
0.3589615226,
-0.0118081598,
-0.4303730726,
-0.0029786513,
0.4167568982,
0.1784450561,
-0.3164409399,
0.8157091737,
0.763741672,
-0.5765948296,
0.1706017554,
-0.4679887891,
-0.002498053,
-0.3837657273,
0.3701510131,
-0.7992301583,
-1.1678227186,
0.5828840137,
-0.1811742932,
0.0647261664,
0.5379551053,
0.74388659,
-0.0676968992,
1.0002286434,
0.8011820316,
0.155239284,
0.2990862429,
-0.12527363,
0.0469427854,
-0.7254196405,
-0.2054920197,
-0.7781585455,
-0.2045804411,
-1.0989772081,
-0.5144298077,
0.1641036719,
-0.1791823506,
-0.2126715332,
0.8228322864,
0.0048102736,
0.2766047716,
0.54077667,
-0.0845935792,
0.4562543035,
0.1212133095,
-0.5404523015,
-0.3231798708,
-0.6348474622,
-0.7896133661,
1.0462317467,
0.2977274358,
0.5876286626,
0.1009315997,
0.6901468635,
0.1862600893,
-0.0862131119,
-0.4640066922,
0.4099035263,
-0.3530981839,
-0.5127769113,
-0.3179923296,
-0.5344626904,
-1.1527446508,
0.4806802869,
-0.1054081246,
-0.4952734113,
0.0729231611,
-0.2582195401,
0.3386738002,
-0.0233556256,
-0.4450258315,
1.0895323753,
-0.2865737677,
-0.4014218152,
-0.2125029564,
-0.8544051647,
0.1111501977,
-0.2415437251,
0.2570646107,
-0.184449181,
-0.292183578,
0.790715158,
-0.4930005372,
0.6189303994,
0.0874890462,
-0.2670925856,
0.1582911611,
0.0285203177,
0.3802010715,
-0.0688856766,
-0.2210476995,
0.3896212876,
0.3114917576,
-0.6770815253,
-0.3571198583,
0.771196723,
-0.7827779651,
-0.2564512491,
-0.3808320165,
-0.4978842437,
-0.119517751,
0.396022886,
0.4591552615,
0.4063541293,
-0.3933760822,
0.2868355811,
0.6069091558,
-0.205192849,
0.3166438341,
0.4971267581,
-0.2020951211,
-0.3162631989,
0.8188200593,
0.1592735201,
0.1905248612,
0.594671607,
-0.1856428981,
-0.4327483177,
-0.3663358986,
-0.4438804388,
0.237040475,
-0.7277196646,
-0.207285583,
-0.8201965094,
-0.1858611107,
-0.4303412735,
-0.1577240229,
-0.1359345764,
-0.5943165421,
-0.2846048474,
-0.1114753932,
0.0914568901,
0.496017009,
0.0338420346,
-0.0004177805,
-0.77151227,
0.154810369,
0.0095600095,
-0.0048029046,
-0.3697632551,
-0.9867614508,
-0.4115439355,
0.208728537,
-0.2776772678,
-0.5735199451,
0.3049558401,
0.1688634306,
0.4334784448,
0.3271613121,
0.0651766583,
0.8015863895,
-0.626088202,
0.56642735,
-0.0986522138,
-0.9863141775,
0.7248627543,
-0.3060655296,
0.4615579844,
0.9232574701,
0.5029889345,
-0.5576217771,
-0.5660448074,
-0.3715405166,
-0.7183892727,
0.6361691952,
0.5978729129,
0.1673843414,
-0.0233763214,
-0.0168159138,
0.2974463999,
0.101650022,
-0.6743930578,
-0.2595991194,
-0.2151417732,
-0.2928136885,
-0.1556860358,
-0.2649049759,
0.2370644957,
-0.0541416444,
0.973947525,
-0.2530344427,
0.2695924044,
0.1456382275,
-0.4270363748,
-0.1212727129,
0.4015426338,
0.4339828789,
0.7118548751,
0.1062009111,
0.2390317023,
0.6173337698,
-0.3454414308,
0.1421189308,
0.3340236843,
-0.2761002779,
0.113178879,
0.5198474526,
0.8805406094,
0.5331707597,
-0.5504457951,
0.4595496356,
-0.0612670407,
-0.3355343342,
-0.3789084256,
-0.3474743664,
0.1683590859,
0.0429522954,
0.1101418659,
-0.0252207797,
0.3871211112,
-0.654980123,
0.0950626656,
0.1863597929,
-0.6620428562,
-0.3651725948,
0.6621890664,
0.3651637733,
0.1029880792,
0.3587513268,
-0.0896420404,
-0.759863615,
0.6209401488,
0.7072190642,
0.53561306,
-0.2085193545,
0.066803962,
0.4743309319,
0.5135899186,
0.1786504388,
0.2844400406,
0.0070408927,
-0.6119525433,
-0.5580248237,
-0.6447802186,
-0.2030888945,
-0.1614522785,
-0.6916962862,
0.6282522082,
0.1719647944,
-0.0208398923,
-0.0321055911,
0.3350689113,
-0.9389180541,
0.1101721749,
0.1177665219,
0.9060228467,
-0.8438391089,
0.8901653886,
1.1170026064,
-0.4552305341,
-0.7757585645,
-0.3853406608,
0.1406493336,
-0.5553691387,
0.4608533084,
0.3306874037,
0.1456100345,
-0.1599474996,
-0.1871011257,
-0.6287664771,
1.2328810692,
0.4193199873,
-0.492244035,
0.133010298,
0.4644268155,
0.5262170434,
-0.3198625743,
0.1899978071,
0.6599341035,
0.5081519485,
0.0638231263,
-0.9206594825,
0.042490337,
-0.36528036,
0.1788817942,
0.4699096978,
-0.6307142377,
0.4407529831,
0.0443566889,
-0.33036533,
0.3600144684,
0.7488698959,
0.1114416793,
0.6424812078,
0.2922923565,
0.7350203991,
0.7076326609,
-0.2401984334,
0.8536787629,
-0.2510079145,
0.2772411704,
1.0831207037,
-0.3917070627,
0.6890568137,
0.4933709204,
-0.1305109859,
0.3363268375,
0.8029933572,
0.2341887802,
0.4058357179,
-0.1409318447,
-0.0557181835,
-0.1959880441,
-0.4084589779,
-0.5024366975,
0.5530369282,
0.2377915829,
-0.4646579027,
-0.0602230914,
0.3028829694,
0.0787794366,
0.286403358,
-0.346234709,
0.9124336243,
0.3349699974,
-0.6805692315,
0.3483896255,
0.1310461164,
0.5972111225,
-0.7079594731,
-0.0159973521,
-0.2310770899,
0.0891483054,
-0.1453597695,
-0.5786398053,
0.5573982,
0.1044900194,
-0.0158574004,
-0.0575572997,
1.0212370157,
-0.7423686981,
-0.6504929066,
0.4172387421,
0.6072235107,
0.3245523274,
0.1189843118,
-0.579865396,
0.0782852247,
0.0801365227,
-0.0245956592,
0.3930283487,
0.9119662642,
-0.2759810388,
0.4290835559,
0.5223659873,
0.0238584001,
-0.0722449794,
0.241493091,
0.5432768464,
-0.7844477296,
-0.5368720889,
-0.7264066935,
0.0621804558,
0.0483900197,
-0.2697167993,
1.0408564806,
0.6428913474,
1.1683357954,
-0.0728669241,
0.7341794968,
0.0014640621,
0.5056725144,
-0.6815649867,
0.5569093227,
-0.6932259202,
0.1680592895,
-0.4410968125,
-1.2429946661,
-0.1086832285,
0.6071866155,
-0.2952555418,
-0.0528120361,
1.0981062651,
0.6715910435,
-0.1399652809,
0.3085800707,
0.5700740218,
-0.1310571283,
-0.0914041102,
0.6533073783,
0.8328217864,
-0.7551444769,
0.7021222711,
-0.2214346528,
0.0524612404,
-0.1901490837,
-0.7613717914,
-1.110309124,
-0.7580122352,
-0.2392001599,
-0.1885597855,
0.1070764139,
1.0326180458,
0.4794218242,
-0.9552155137,
-0.1058215573,
0.0091449907,
-0.1073778123,
-0.1835995167,
-0.1704444885,
0.3419198394,
-0.3042904139,
-0.7553394437,
0.0973592699,
0.3405772448,
0.0804626197,
0.0025062335,
-0.3193662763,
-0.5558696985,
0.1211652756,
0.7754604816,
0.00050721,
-0.6408131719,
-0.3321843147,
-0.0680830926,
-0.3044502735,
-0.3187884092,
0.7798545361,
-0.5094846487,
0.4295425117,
0.5763019323,
1.0796973705,
0.6851019263,
0.0277582221,
0.4583729804,
-0.4413592517,
0.2625221312,
0.0599738993,
0.5860434175,
0.4205287695,
-0.1702179015,
1.1898722649,
0.1203116477,
-0.791526258,
-0.4860048294,
0.0897653773,
-0.775154531,
-0.1424287409,
0.9883201122,
-0.3750760257,
-0.3159692585,
-0.3268224895,
-0.2697566748,
0.4195607901,
0.009463069,
0.3723449707,
0.8514125347,
0.2478024364,
0.0677373707,
-0.7198173404,
0.1213848069,
0.7580003738,
-0.9805015326,
-0.3027745485,
0.3642683923,
0.1152914762,
-0.0688627213,
0.4724578857,
-0.247931391,
0.423314929,
-0.1270942986,
-0.169623509,
-0.0148300864,
-0.1641997099,
-0.4335233569,
-0.2568113804,
-0.0920934007,
-0.0612203032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12728v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12728v2
|
Modality-Aware Integration with Large Language Models for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering
| 2024-02-20T05:32:24 | 2024-03-03T04:51:28 |
Junnan Dong, Qinggang Zhang, Huachi Zhou, Daochen Zha, Pai Zheng, Xiao Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Knowledge-based visual question answering (KVQA) has been extensively studied
to answer visual questions with external knowledge, e.g., knowledge graphs
(KGs). While several attempts have been proposed to leverage large language
models (LLMs) as an implicit knowledge source, it remains challenging since
LLMs may generate hallucinations. Moreover, multiple knowledge sources, e.g.,
images, KGs and LLMs, cannot be readily aligned for complex scenarios. To
tackle these, we present a novel modality-aware integration with LLMs for KVQA
(MAIL). It carefully leverages multimodal knowledge for both image
understanding and knowledge reasoning. Specifically, (i) we propose a two-stage
prompting strategy with LLMs to densely embody the image into a scene graph
with detailed visual features; (ii) We construct a coupled concept graph by
linking the mentioned entities with external facts. (iii) A tailored
pseudo-siamese graph medium fusion is designed for sufficient multimodal
fusion. We utilize the shared mentioned entities in two graphs as mediums to
bridge a tight inter-modal exchange, while maximally preserving insightful
intra-modal learning by constraining the fusion within mediums. Extensive
experiments on two benchmark datasets show the superiority of MAIL with 24x
less resources.
|
[
-0.5709979534,
-0.94239676,
0.8157445788,
0.018215023,
-0.5374693871,
-0.1424484104,
-0.2109683156,
-0.4178308845,
0.0905297101,
0.4343268573,
-0.6888554096,
-0.3971464336,
-0.2703565359,
-0.063008748,
0.0583180934,
0.3570308983,
-0.2546590567,
0.3158184886,
-0.5645372868,
-0.2483638823,
-0.7375786901,
-0.115320161,
-0.115674071,
0.1441816837,
0.6602424979,
0.4267735481,
0.4755987227,
0.1466465294,
0.4593943954,
0.3181976378,
0.3164964914,
0.4888621569,
-0.3900289834,
0.3137083948,
-0.1811836958,
-0.4727516472,
-0.2176785171,
-0.1877084076,
0.6780077219,
0.5761857629,
0.2118502557,
0.0202088505,
-0.2118086815,
0.4049333632,
-0.6488085389,
0.3230116069,
-0.5546284914,
0.0020180161,
0.1339976192,
-0.3083250225,
-0.4473012388,
-0.2734930813,
0.1393942684,
-0.7982975245,
-0.3816632628,
0.1050342396,
0.571226716,
0.3173367977,
-0.811318934,
-0.0755034834,
-0.4212144911,
0.438817203,
-0.2431578785,
0.7436368465,
0.3088054955,
0.6545891762,
0.0215783399,
-0.6873722672,
-0.9528121352,
-0.0762631446,
-0.1560717672,
0.3150855303,
-0.1501379758,
0.2519360483,
0.1456992328,
0.1625676453,
-0.7705483437,
-0.1898193657,
-0.2634296119,
-0.354658246,
0.1811891049,
0.1507661194,
0.3402580321,
-0.3623385727,
-0.4577985704,
-0.0516199134,
-0.4341687262,
0.2536492348,
-0.0393018611,
0.0459150299,
-0.0646135062,
0.802344501,
-0.2005594671,
0.8162235022,
-0.0502747111,
-0.1776230037,
0.0604388863,
-0.4979693592,
-0.3344423473,
-0.3220151961,
0.8134046197,
0.4497230947,
0.029355932,
-0.1775168329,
-0.103693381,
0.1643225402,
0.0307886563,
-0.7510651946,
-0.1736876965,
0.0048031071,
-0.4122674763,
-0.0743951648,
-0.2558759749,
-0.6118634939,
-0.3992964923,
-0.3375011683,
0.8945793509,
-0.4646511674,
-0.2837710083,
-0.0301707424,
-0.0808698833,
0.3471728265,
0.7080851793,
-0.43297562,
-0.136486724,
0.3041945994,
0.5122419596,
0.1872620434,
-0.176118359,
-0.7561413646,
0.3169425428,
-0.2608668208,
0.8358182311,
-0.7695429325,
-0.1911287308,
0.0342496745,
0.1366966665,
-0.1912266314,
-0.2887440026,
0.0731764734,
-1.0499567986,
0.500002563,
-0.5775476694,
-0.3469097614,
-0.5715301037,
0.6320335865,
-0.5427609086,
0.8365604877,
0.309237659,
-0.7379860878,
0.35491997,
-0.6093477011,
-0.1828095764,
0.0922070295,
-0.3221235871,
0.0247779619,
-0.0449756272,
0.2925029695,
0.5845513344,
-0.4801526666,
0.2689176798,
-0.4748807251,
-0.1549601704,
0.3351538777,
-0.390032202,
0.3334749043,
0.1829548925,
-0.1051196083,
0.2257817537,
-0.4992310703,
0.0225912929,
0.0012981107,
-0.1306960732,
-0.3256461024,
-0.5849261284,
-0.0527797751,
0.4912774265,
0.190061301,
-0.4255805314,
0.5135125518,
0.1682863832,
0.3571747243,
0.7173498869,
0.0974461436,
0.5333043337,
-0.1632864773,
0.6427320838,
0.4606171846,
0.2888791263,
-0.3267363608,
-0.4115658402,
-0.7174711227,
-0.6186383963,
0.1030828729,
0.4510668218,
-1.5642220974,
-0.1500617862,
-0.4456391931,
-0.2392996848,
-0.4005250037,
0.1719427556,
0.2599522173,
0.6694015265,
0.3080258667,
-0.2849636972,
-0.1757608205,
-1.0805207491,
0.2076519579,
-0.2787904143,
0.2530955076,
0.7530297041,
0.4199946225,
-0.2149324715,
0.8210222125,
-0.473069191,
-0.1546516716,
-0.1458334178,
0.134662196,
-0.1158728898,
0.2716186643,
0.4315731823,
-0.9281114936,
-0.3462257981,
-0.10528595,
-0.7921108603,
0.1200230643,
-0.13568452,
-0.43019858,
0.062067695,
0.5682874322,
-0.7390909195,
0.132065922,
0.4962318838,
-0.4561594129,
0.3719346225,
-0.0565051883,
0.5005643368,
-1.2674278021,
0.0569573939,
0.1091487333,
-0.3066591024,
-0.4821558297,
-0.2032231688,
0.2403610498,
-0.1669216007,
-0.5446059704,
0.5739757419,
-0.4909946918,
-0.0372189172,
0.0210410934,
0.0812467486,
0.1547772139,
0.7372940779,
0.1595979333,
0.7293617129,
0.6658401489,
-0.1621295065,
0.5744052529,
0.289267838,
-0.3402550817,
0.8738524318,
-0.4292637706,
0.0668910518,
-0.5020491481,
0.3800263703,
-1.2822738886,
-0.330999434,
0.4814375043,
-0.2136788517,
0.3336915374,
-0.2306491733,
-0.7099006772,
-0.3012214005,
-0.0268931538,
0.7757790089,
0.3965809643,
-0.4769793153,
1.0109449625,
0.0284870006,
-0.0014507177,
-0.4443086386,
-0.590278089,
0.1994843334,
-0.1526580155,
-0.985237658,
-0.0685399473,
-0.256691277,
0.0472295024,
0.1694963723,
0.0664066821,
-0.2037792951,
-0.3188019693,
0.0969819874,
0.4249284267,
-0.3837096095,
0.3190183342,
0.1300887316,
0.0942653045,
-0.0075716372,
-0.3902584016,
0.3261051178,
-0.1310632378,
-0.696347177,
-0.470983237,
0.5418871641,
1.1027024984,
-0.3267433047,
0.6825564504,
0.829192698,
-0.1649148017,
0.0778251737,
-0.8547281623,
-0.3884672821,
-0.4280157387,
0.2590722442,
-0.5639714003,
-1.0029579401,
0.4094360471,
-0.1788295209,
-0.3274763525,
-0.091046311,
0.3939405382,
-0.1943840683,
1.0792677402,
0.6563140154,
0.2063634843,
0.4861396253,
-0.3594311774,
0.2119632661,
-0.8939253092,
-0.5191683769,
0.1233754084,
-0.3584436178,
-0.1305830032,
-0.8774093986,
0.6872411966,
0.1063488424,
-0.1269439757,
-0.0350263827,
-0.2453417331,
0.3294335306,
0.4711894691,
0.3170038462,
0.3717019558,
-0.0623603277,
-0.2842277586,
-0.038520582,
-0.9836318493,
-0.0039759655,
0.7851141095,
0.1418094486,
0.909648478,
0.2266883701,
0.159452036,
-0.1500198692,
0.2260714024,
-0.7664213777,
0.73365134,
0.21404396,
-0.3363226056,
-0.0951125398,
-0.288533181,
-0.5209745765,
0.3683294952,
-0.5148607492,
-0.6577962041,
0.4048886895,
0.1339288801,
-0.0656758472,
0.1548607498,
-0.6923738122,
0.9570590854,
-0.106558308,
-0.4460215569,
-0.0853583142,
-0.7421728969,
0.6913040876,
0.1077927798,
0.2448551357,
0.0524469055,
-0.1429596543,
0.3217951059,
-0.2074680328,
0.9704612494,
-0.1381198019,
-0.1335252225,
0.1469816566,
0.2738490105,
0.5531409979,
0.1065275595,
0.4478926957,
-0.1390170455,
-0.0291377883,
-0.2711524963,
-0.9523140788,
0.6615508795,
-0.5758932829,
-0.6193708777,
-0.0865305364,
-0.9995524287,
-0.5711072087,
0.1189631149,
0.0125677045,
0.756634295,
0.327352941,
0.3549259007,
0.8934851885,
-0.0101993224,
0.2479458749,
0.4712004066,
-0.1956360936,
-0.6784567237,
1.0166488886,
-0.0161939897,
0.42159307,
0.4620224237,
0.099838607,
-0.5283759832,
-0.1743885279,
-0.7182278633,
0.4317281842,
-1.0263170004,
-0.2556746304,
-0.8927401304,
0.0263285246,
-0.3031369746,
-0.3465351164,
-0.0399037898,
-0.2207898498,
-0.2589708865,
0.3031400442,
0.4279897511,
0.3142128885,
0.1163449585,
-0.0037647907,
-0.9375330806,
0.4821033776,
0.8788815141,
0.3897030056,
0.031671688,
-0.3531912565,
-0.017881874,
0.0801086426,
0.0477816761,
-1.1015714407,
-0.0593194142,
0.0393903702,
0.5986372828,
0.4205315411,
0.0365807973,
0.7948337197,
-0.1529950798,
0.8377053738,
0.5035442114,
-0.7422149181,
0.4185027182,
-0.5240874887,
0.4862407446,
0.3980182707,
0.411542803,
-0.7721394897,
-0.3422068059,
-0.2693352997,
-0.5015072823,
0.4377358556,
-0.1674307287,
0.0495243371,
0.0564469174,
0.0208271015,
-0.0037676126,
0.2993981838,
-0.7697810531,
0.0440332368,
-0.3600770235,
-0.2959266007,
0.1452332288,
-0.1742408723,
-0.435801357,
-0.4500764608,
0.3810015023,
-0.5010073185,
0.1630471498,
0.2191884965,
-0.5327698588,
-0.04234685,
0.1433412135,
0.6198575497,
0.5970396399,
0.3089779913,
0.3503844142,
0.1667486578,
-0.2699076831,
0.078518033,
-0.0117556918,
0.0076775416,
-0.2096017152,
0.2856517732,
0.8307910562,
0.2413225621,
-0.8426641226,
0.7453365922,
-0.1804390103,
-0.3032649755,
0.126904279,
-0.1844920367,
0.2458015531,
0.6951105595,
0.2001542002,
-0.0709574372,
-0.0019681177,
-0.6056708694,
0.0283571016,
0.7662698627,
-0.5955910087,
-0.2002919465,
0.5798880458,
0.1321907192,
0.2545078397,
0.4190987647,
-0.0331507698,
-0.6577661037,
0.3320681453,
0.3930090666,
0.5298007727,
0.1919255555,
0.3785350919,
0.1694435179,
0.275704205,
0.257673949,
0.60790658,
-0.3971744478,
-0.6242293715,
-0.617934823,
-0.3182493448,
-0.1243033856,
-0.0113819521,
-0.235473156,
0.233003214,
-0.169347927,
0.1166483164,
-0.2072096169,
-0.3209468722,
-0.7966693044,
0.1242766678,
0.252576232,
0.8769627213,
-1.0279402733,
0.7190198302,
0.9058345556,
-0.5907353759,
-0.9280645847,
-0.1692279428,
-0.0339175202,
-0.8758189678,
0.8549983501,
-0.0450621024,
-0.0251390431,
0.0411731265,
-0.4614963531,
-0.7097986341,
1.2483794689,
0.3198701739,
-0.1795279831,
0.1390268654,
0.060499385,
0.2368464172,
-0.3914816678,
0.3148171306,
0.0697675496,
0.7409818172,
0.725790441,
-0.7520638108,
0.3282472789,
-0.370616138,
0.0935058445,
0.2991529405,
-0.649240613,
0.5769797564,
-0.127140224,
-0.1233714297,
-0.1771751493,
0.6304050684,
-0.0217555799,
0.1842029989,
0.7881972194,
0.5826014876,
0.5377358794,
0.083950229,
0.6497173905,
-0.2837429345,
-0.1252134442,
0.6808002591,
0.0820642188,
0.4523885548,
0.6460899711,
0.316275537,
0.4473660886,
0.544801712,
0.1866538078,
0.5482551455,
-0.1771921217,
-0.485937506,
-0.7146118283,
-0.4533776939,
-0.5005648136,
0.5268157721,
0.1889318228,
-0.1283608675,
-0.3068414927,
0.3644599915,
-0.256474793,
-0.2247360498,
-0.2052531689,
0.9578452706,
-0.1596660465,
-0.7410017848,
0.5773837566,
-0.554009378,
0.4222026765,
-0.598746419,
-0.225233376,
-0.0339538567,
-0.3930808604,
0.0014498384,
-0.8101002574,
-0.1534697413,
-0.3777551949,
-0.2312135696,
-0.159286648,
0.6899274588,
-0.9614219069,
-0.3503881991,
-0.1211830005,
0.8279000521,
-0.1965511441,
0.0463343002,
-0.4228920341,
0.1623394638,
-0.2841153741,
-0.247928232,
0.3095423281,
0.622110486,
-0.1221472993,
0.7265705466,
0.7411670089,
-0.2977648377,
-0.1347576678,
0.0942004845,
1.2634097338,
-0.3961670697,
-0.4850285053,
-0.4472666085,
0.7972687483,
-0.000428081,
-0.1048194468,
0.6183555126,
0.2904344201,
0.3697611094,
-0.0586231016,
0.6241934896,
0.0554651655,
-0.1949621588,
-0.6964519024,
0.5605620146,
-1.0108819008,
0.0104152383,
-0.2859714031,
-0.9945701361,
-0.1545005739,
0.1808265001,
-0.2797074616,
-0.0899834558,
0.8085991144,
1.0268256664,
-0.2314083427,
-0.0374568142,
0.5666988492,
0.131725356,
0.2632342875,
0.7351900339,
1.0341998339,
-0.1422059536,
0.6773171425,
-0.2977136374,
-0.1422880143,
-0.3441416919,
-0.8314257264,
-0.8206741214,
-1.0370937586,
-0.2039840966,
-0.2625546753,
-0.2229160666,
0.7475936413,
0.7557875514,
-0.1390630305,
0.3292828202,
0.2464008778,
0.1090635732,
0.112837404,
-0.2017425448,
0.2659358084,
-0.1145494431,
-0.5190122128,
0.2473004311,
0.5401673913,
0.1663092077,
-0.4993002415,
0.1179202944,
-0.1658278555,
0.0744348094,
0.775185585,
0.0903636739,
-0.7185771465,
-0.5098335147,
0.4033510387,
-0.2201614827,
-0.0163241755,
0.9519111514,
-0.8186103702,
0.8263075352,
0.7344616652,
0.62797755,
0.4057001472,
-0.1682175249,
0.4108580053,
-0.4853004813,
0.2810238898,
0.2854360342,
0.4414590597,
0.2826726139,
-0.3062869012,
0.1121546105,
0.4321911335,
-0.187811926,
-0.6922929883,
0.4683696032,
-1.2727671862,
-0.3948939741,
1.1650304794,
0.1776288599,
-0.2827496231,
-0.0825016052,
-0.4347887635,
-0.0064163725,
-0.1202810705,
0.4358221292,
0.6796221733,
0.026875671,
-0.6826011539,
-0.4485062957,
0.196112752,
0.367320329,
-0.7826036811,
-0.2858587503,
0.9992020726,
0.0700118467,
-0.1286678165,
0.6986975074,
0.0981221125,
0.6767004132,
-0.0412770398,
-0.0609380342,
-0.396784842,
-0.4550543427,
-0.1006667241,
0.1530179977,
-0.0895970985,
-0.0980180725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00788v1
|
PRECISE Framework: GPT-based Text For Improved Readability, Reliability, and Understandability of Radiology Reports For Patient-Centered Care
| 2024-02-20T04:26:31 | 2024-02-20T04:26:31 |
Satvik Tripathi, Liam Mutter, Meghana Muppuri, Suhani Dheer, Emiliano Garza-Frias, Komal Awan, Aakash Jha, Michael Dezube, Azadeh Tabari, Christopher P. Bridge, Dania Daye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
This study introduces and evaluates the PRECISE framework, utilizing OpenAI's
GPT-4 to enhance patient engagement by providing clearer and more accessible
chest X-ray reports at a sixth-grade reading level. The framework was tested on
500 reports, demonstrating significant improvements in readability,
reliability, and understandability. Statistical analyses confirmed the
effectiveness of the PRECISE approach, highlighting its potential to foster
patient-centric care delivery in healthcare decision-making.
|
[
0.0117436089,
-0.4371144176,
0.8181729913,
-0.0438537039,
-0.2528099418,
-0.342685312,
0.2942670882,
-0.5206797719,
-0.0003119687,
0.2797056139,
-0.4782348275,
-0.6395557523,
-0.5020166039,
0.0776288733,
-0.3267906606,
0.9992697239,
-0.2645064294,
0.0470452309,
0.1507435143,
-0.0828073099,
-0.4015411139,
-0.2395719886,
-0.3076849878,
-0.5322204232,
0.5018523335,
0.5018468499,
1.2106598616,
0.908870995,
1.0740189552,
0.1365132928,
0.2319416106,
-0.3956840634,
-0.3132056296,
-0.1688440293,
-0.2420661896,
-0.3533012569,
-0.8047899604,
-0.0688500106,
0.6202743649,
0.6237288117,
-0.2145837843,
-0.0765422657,
-0.3663800955,
0.9495077729,
-0.4453227222,
0.1625763625,
0.1278005391,
0.3760399818,
-0.2381113023,
-0.514434576,
-0.2833238244,
-0.3337084353,
0.6181450486,
-0.9275796413,
0.3087682724,
-0.2858368456,
0.9656862617,
-0.0776478872,
-0.5076290369,
-0.4631387889,
-0.7022752762,
0.5564596057,
-0.4717868865,
0.4385044873,
0.5248718858,
0.5510604978,
0.2115747184,
-1.3602294922,
-0.0714913532,
0.1069049165,
-0.3182989359,
0.3258580565,
-0.1013192981,
0.4356998503,
0.2861191332,
0.7900973558,
-0.971583426,
-0.2664941847,
-0.2348821461,
0.053340327,
0.5131878853,
0.0047552814,
0.4499543011,
-0.25735116,
-0.406809479,
0.0592289045,
-0.6316902041,
-0.2252916545,
-0.2633650899,
0.0175565723,
-0.1242024601,
0.3753644228,
-0.5027626157,
0.6481425166,
0.3038296402,
-0.4897303581,
0.7126514316,
-0.3022587001,
-0.6271326542,
0.3576728106,
0.2244483978,
0.4115799069,
-0.0313019864,
-0.2218447328,
-0.1684889197,
0.0869270638,
0.3779837489,
-0.925496161,
-0.3251643777,
0.415830791,
-0.8312367201,
-0.6537109613,
0.3254338205,
-0.3231309354,
-0.0311377849,
-0.4427551329,
0.3995896578,
-0.4810610414,
-0.335706234,
0.3317656815,
0.0579596199,
0.3888464868,
0.4226707816,
-0.8020070195,
0.166257754,
0.5044833422,
1.0102082491,
0.1785227358,
0.2597106695,
-0.58488518,
0.5788160563,
-0.3010852635,
0.8451148868,
-0.4030613005,
-0.4831736386,
0.0097466419,
-0.0962228626,
-0.1721048653,
-0.2046658248,
0.7629701495,
-0.3811807334,
0.3245610595,
-0.4174703658,
-0.5719105005,
-0.3894724548,
0.5677955151,
-0.6245400906,
0.5472249389,
0.5694015622,
-0.6461448073,
0.5313160419,
-0.8447234035,
-0.483022958,
0.3976406157,
-0.576782763,
-0.3399840295,
0.0982455686,
0.2155456543,
0.4859995544,
-0.0584078021,
0.3601081967,
0.3009538949,
-0.374727875,
0.0489080809,
-0.4728999734,
0.4763298035,
0.3853622973,
-0.7359997034,
0.3488531113,
-0.7699639201,
0.5228336453,
-0.000645864,
-0.0445282348,
0.0634632036,
-0.2768229246,
-0.0242561735,
0.0272632167,
-0.1307546794,
-0.4532921612,
0.2047670186,
-0.2478027791,
0.4331130087,
0.5049929023,
0.0859688818,
0.3551470339,
-0.7931523919,
0.7209434509,
-0.2123901993,
0.5242016315,
-0.4424438477,
-0.6183826923,
-0.0608409531,
-0.4256499708,
0.0212384146,
0.5188168883,
-0.4746916592,
0.1798964888,
-0.1053205654,
-0.5740849376,
-0.3440055251,
-0.2865706086,
0.747877121,
0.9445781708,
0.0456521623,
-0.7045698166,
-0.3839572966,
-0.7558766007,
0.1493404061,
-0.3070108593,
0.0665478781,
0.1946902573,
0.2402980477,
-0.4307904541,
0.7132255435,
-0.7905901074,
-0.5046101213,
-0.0613099523,
0.1290628016,
0.3711258769,
0.3749108911,
0.5978662372,
-1.1992558241,
-0.849578321,
0.3199213147,
-1.0221799612,
0.0466643311,
0.0569680743,
-0.1948971897,
0.0219416972,
0.4866214693,
-0.2055715919,
0.8730857968,
0.4316305816,
-0.4156433046,
0.4129312932,
-0.2951257527,
0.5060738921,
-0.7845163345,
0.5655305386,
-0.0028552541,
-0.6143140197,
-0.8530194759,
0.0671859235,
0.2943395674,
-0.0781251416,
-0.2739931047,
0.1170542166,
-0.4871297181,
0.1603546441,
0.0690495223,
-0.0018759907,
0.2670082748,
-0.0652801469,
0.2068047673,
0.6711627841,
0.1522992402,
-0.2745169103,
-0.0664103478,
0.4508934319,
-0.3511964381,
1.0818961859,
-0.9122647643,
0.2433760911,
-0.0694243908,
0.2131067216,
-0.7902882695,
-0.4764409661,
0.2163467109,
-0.4936656058,
0.6635640264,
0.0299091097,
-0.1438187957,
-0.1936913431,
-0.2991909683,
0.3626626134,
0.2694732547,
-0.1508239657,
0.5163267851,
0.1810614914,
-0.1695843637,
-0.4404188395,
-1.0005196333,
-0.1309076995,
0.1666143388,
-0.8207623959,
0.5520094037,
-0.4264652431,
-0.1770833433,
-0.0135914842,
-0.2234182954,
-0.5277646184,
-0.1508972496,
0.3802517056,
-0.0225045159,
-0.5978156924,
-0.0222644471,
-0.2961792052,
-0.4116691053,
-0.1815599799,
-0.2655685842,
0.3883880973,
-0.7355823517,
-0.4696874022,
-0.9236878753,
0.5250557065,
0.4582253098,
0.0239285305,
0.3324480653,
0.5498096347,
-0.4740620255,
0.6416993737,
-0.4441442788,
-0.0958301723,
-0.4451881051,
0.2349763066,
-0.6441140771,
-0.755772531,
0.4463984668,
0.0929114521,
-0.0203087348,
0.4826520085,
0.4952048957,
0.0100668157,
1.0814425945,
0.8330634236,
0.228826955,
0.2391209602,
-0.102939114,
0.2588397861,
-0.7442668676,
-0.5163316727,
-0.6421186924,
-0.0093527297,
-0.1746502221,
0.1389272213,
0.4033074677,
-0.0195486564,
-0.3950152099,
-0.2780022621,
-0.9834486842,
0.4663618803,
0.3334496915,
0.4825078845,
0.6814988256,
-0.0358726606,
0.0061985017,
-0.3898673952,
-0.6611683965,
-0.4886049926,
1.0215679407,
0.4296483994,
0.3957942128,
0.5185936093,
0.5805941224,
0.2575431168,
0.5531466007,
-0.7425448298,
-0.100932315,
-0.1591198742,
-1.0441892147,
-0.2607932985,
-0.2309634089,
-1.0046373606,
0.0323841311,
0.29478544,
-0.5292012095,
0.171912536,
0.0608953051,
-0.4675686657,
0.1812140942,
-0.7865709662,
0.8672857881,
-0.3601232767,
0.0492237732,
0.1986338049,
-0.9850203991,
0.1268693656,
-0.2241475433,
0.2756171525,
0.0123111149,
-0.2081024796,
0.4327447116,
-0.5285637975,
0.838176012,
-0.0986874253,
0.0316377766,
0.1201943606,
0.028439723,
0.0825624317,
0.3407229781,
-0.0602085665,
-0.0451952368,
0.2158175111,
-0.5085016489,
-0.5650086999,
0.4741892815,
-1.0330681801,
-0.2552845478,
-0.8459876776,
-0.6727681756,
0.0702029243,
0.7920717001,
0.4938527644,
0.9048147798,
-0.3944378197,
0.1218991056,
1.0356045961,
0.200044319,
-0.1092494056,
0.655359149,
-0.1525466293,
-0.6899562478,
0.5086984038,
0.2549362779,
0.2944970429,
0.7379533052,
0.329357326,
-0.0706790239,
-0.6969370246,
-0.5189548731,
0.1914986521,
-0.7359072566,
-0.1753219515,
-0.417067647,
-0.2343679368,
-0.509208262,
-0.7684066892,
-0.1790747941,
-0.130000487,
-0.1901755631,
-0.0968127698,
0.1944232881,
0.9351460934,
-0.0926922783,
0.6215052009,
-0.8112896085,
0.0732127056,
-0.1537089646,
0.5386391878,
-0.3356328011,
-0.5829228163,
-0.2199952751,
-0.2571014762,
-0.2151471078,
-0.8515660763,
0.3321118951,
0.1248815805,
0.5598306656,
0.6393637061,
0.0722456872,
0.6398560405,
-0.1096252725,
0.6732375622,
0.6049804688,
-1.1272997856,
0.7443370819,
-0.7745357752,
0.7199240327,
0.8068389297,
0.3504705727,
-0.4306327999,
0.3350275159,
-0.9319232106,
-0.8432167172,
0.522226274,
0.2373342514,
-0.3353822827,
0.1454201341,
0.7366436124,
0.051947508,
0.1189905331,
-0.4205955565,
-0.0721397698,
-0.3913730681,
-0.4557982087,
-0.1416319162,
-0.4895968735,
-0.4759022295,
-0.1889425218,
0.6969126463,
-0.4372496605,
0.4861600995,
0.8392665982,
-0.0495799109,
-0.2792602777,
0.1476229727,
0.737985611,
1.2483897209,
-0.5460214019,
0.1368398964,
-0.3699314892,
-0.981775403,
0.0643012151,
-0.0075654001,
-0.2386045009,
0.0772934183,
0.4718530774,
0.3939020336,
0.22432971,
-0.3167930841,
0.7682324648,
-0.4777798355,
-0.4853602052,
-0.4509054124,
-0.240216434,
-0.1651937217,
0.1604209244,
0.2126459479,
0.0931637958,
0.3805586994,
-0.368617475,
0.7523616552,
-0.2795811594,
-1.1104855537,
-0.2491423339,
0.4407165647,
0.1844909936,
0.1361590773,
0.7608146667,
0.2710417807,
-0.2223688215,
0.6044431329,
0.7347707152,
0.7522040009,
-0.3450019062,
0.6233178377,
0.1520579308,
0.3456898928,
-0.3027482033,
0.4407873452,
0.1755815893,
-0.4580479264,
-0.5727447271,
0.2037221342,
-0.4717653394,
-0.1149683446,
-1.2360569239,
0.1120248958,
-0.8585706949,
-0.0890256986,
0.0536333658,
0.3816476166,
-0.4655031264,
0.7800332904,
-0.2045810521,
0.9543540478,
-0.5212596655,
0.7787760496,
0.959248364,
-0.7252465487,
-1.2614568472,
-0.0708187297,
0.3757070303,
-0.8277701735,
0.2336713821,
0.4265318513,
0.0730989426,
-0.012255121,
-0.3136596084,
-0.9329347014,
1.4902877808,
0.3194835782,
-0.6119305491,
0.1296433508,
-0.0674943998,
0.4014644623,
-0.367760241,
0.4984920621,
0.5707538724,
0.5510023236,
0.4011808336,
-1.1601732969,
0.1407105774,
-0.326076895,
-0.1804415435,
0.2293975353,
-0.5505417585,
0.584436357,
-0.2632878721,
0.0264014844,
0.1269416511,
0.5719953179,
0.0105656628,
0.7634624839,
0.1536191255,
0.6870272756,
1.2592792511,
-0.1739147455,
1.5062943697,
0.0528809391,
0.2265915275,
0.9059391022,
-0.1558699012,
0.4336000681,
0.111653395,
0.0958708599,
0.4143357575,
0.4823535681,
0.2317590564,
0.7049770355,
-0.3882611692,
-0.4030531645,
0.1214668527,
-0.0273785591,
-0.8348771334,
0.0994648635,
0.3503445983,
-0.5210675001,
0.0632477775,
-0.0887082145,
0.6119855046,
-0.0044368724,
-0.4749565125,
0.6773874164,
0.1196412668,
-0.30473423,
0.5660737753,
-0.0747829825,
0.3517675996,
-0.8547828794,
0.1502927989,
0.015190782,
0.5737755895,
-0.8743001819,
-0.9981859326,
0.6607935429,
-0.0920123234,
-0.7013243437,
-0.2727317214,
0.7923404574,
-0.0315645151,
-0.1389541626,
-0.0479089878,
0.2001882493,
0.195434913,
-0.149937436,
-0.710558176,
0.3884016573,
0.4898338318,
-0.3340852857,
0.3362737298,
0.4678030908,
-0.0234865379,
0.3468683958,
0.4715441465,
-0.1740856618,
-0.4663094878,
0.1687889099,
0.7426831722,
-0.4469326437,
-0.4772515297,
-0.3789230287,
0.4783601165,
-0.1081835777,
-0.5899348855,
0.4363368452,
0.5438035727,
0.6452847719,
0.1846718788,
1.1228301525,
-0.1717649102,
0.4083483517,
-0.4776522517,
0.6593138576,
-0.2719976306,
0.0445866436,
-0.4492152333,
-0.5357263684,
-1.1464431286,
1.0419853926,
-0.4215132296,
0.1479922682,
0.8895629644,
0.5328086019,
0.0966571942,
0.345130533,
0.4563014209,
0.2105654627,
0.8068925142,
0.4115948975,
0.1384105384,
-0.5673382282,
0.4061436355,
-0.3682321012,
-0.8637747169,
-0.1622047275,
-0.897393465,
-0.5837486982,
-0.2906390429,
-0.5933381319,
-0.5432106853,
0.4246412218,
0.4488082826,
0.9492141604,
-0.6025050282,
0.1175185591,
-0.0923812091,
-0.4069071412,
-0.1940558255,
-0.2262502462,
0.8025997877,
-0.1434534043,
-0.1825383753,
0.0227404609,
0.5189685225,
-0.1326509416,
0.0429993309,
-0.290827632,
0.072408326,
-0.2012259811,
0.5682117939,
0.4596147239,
-0.136358887,
-0.3010754287,
0.0471625067,
-0.4517899752,
0.3460861146,
0.7393526435,
-0.5477254391,
0.7774013281,
0.4563532472,
0.4244119525,
0.5758126378,
0.0044779121,
0.7247285247,
-0.2709506452,
0.170668453,
0.4425736666,
0.055868458,
0.3212835491,
-0.7524436712,
0.7813879848,
0.3808010817,
-0.9369261861,
-0.5328205228,
0.1833274215,
-1.3118110895,
-0.0804595128,
0.9056147337,
-0.492041409,
-0.2720908523,
-0.4311553538,
-0.3568069041,
-0.0149567286,
-0.4154490232,
0.3048523068,
0.2032079995,
-0.400349319,
-0.1841917634,
-0.7282097936,
0.4297146201,
0.2862678468,
-0.6247771978,
-0.6515542269,
0.3737208247,
0.4678079486,
0.1178902015,
1.1803838015,
-0.8651559949,
0.5268669128,
-0.1067814082,
-0.0199874565,
-0.085402526,
-0.1945659965,
-0.2852107882,
0.3979229033,
0.2827473283,
0.042027846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12713v2
|
Are LLMs Rational Investors? A Study on Detecting and Reducing the Financial Bias in LLMs
| 2024-02-20T04:26:08 | 2024-07-01T15:42:15 |
Yuhang Zhou, Yuchen Ni, Yunhui Gan, Zhangyue Yin, Xiang Liu, Jian Zhang, Sen Liu, Xipeng Qiu, Guangnan Ye, Hongfeng Chai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly adopted in financial analysis
for interpreting complex market data and trends. However, their use is
challenged by intrinsic biases (e.g., risk-preference bias) and a superficial
understanding of market intricacies, necessitating a thorough assessment of
their financial insight. To address these issues, we introduce Financial Bias
Indicators (FBI), a framework with components like Bias Unveiler, Bias
Detective, Bias Tracker, and Bias Antidote to identify, detect, analyze, and
eliminate irrational biases in LLMs. By combining behavioral finance principles
with bias examination, we evaluate 23 leading LLMs and propose a de-biasing
method based on financial causal knowledge. Results show varying degrees of
financial irrationality among models, influenced by their design and training.
Models trained specifically on financial datasets may exhibit more
irrationality, and even larger financial language models (FinLLMs) can show
more bias than smaller, general models. We utilize four prompt-based methods
incorporating causal debiasing, effectively reducing financial biases in these
models. This work enhances the understanding of LLMs' bias in financial
applications, laying the foundation for developing more reliable and rational
financial analysis tools.
|
[
-0.3987665772,
-0.8842875361,
0.4011331499,
0.1998778433,
0.0705183223,
0.2617764175,
-0.0360823162,
-0.1445619166,
0.1425813586,
0.6060737371,
-0.7071179748,
-0.3735890388,
-0.5244169235,
0.0421842076,
-0.2258083969,
0.8388082385,
-0.0101059508,
0.6898316741,
0.0584162585,
0.1300690323,
-0.3733384609,
-0.3561507761,
-0.9663586617,
-0.349042058,
0.390237987,
0.0120171178,
0.5417500138,
0.5999110937,
0.5251122117,
0.3324738741,
-0.0092406506,
-0.0833069384,
-0.6265823841,
-0.1609600782,
-0.1879490465,
-0.4874635041,
-0.4805211425,
0.4034370184,
0.3343003094,
0.6693044305,
0.1123577654,
0.2596093118,
-0.1355326623,
0.9922072887,
-0.6371902823,
0.4046100974,
-0.5644627213,
0.1966097206,
-0.4334290028,
-0.6120471954,
-0.5988816619,
-0.4374981821,
0.3419627845,
-0.4391579926,
-0.1068902463,
0.4067518115,
0.5702604055,
0.3052112758,
-0.7809280157,
-0.3181309998,
-0.5292754769,
1.0519641638,
-0.7185299397,
0.3323464692,
0.5022146106,
0.3628905118,
-0.2745856643,
0.1580390781,
-0.3154796362,
-0.1356630474,
0.1699890643,
-0.1445319951,
-0.3203430474,
0.0311303344,
0.3086863458,
0.1088227406,
-0.1250993311,
0.1950582415,
-0.221658811,
-0.3947796226,
0.5967556834,
0.2021338642,
0.0934181362,
0.1857734323,
-0.5470189452,
0.0100846747,
-0.9662107825,
-0.0050322511,
0.7767297626,
-0.0042398912,
0.0644396469,
0.6051581502,
0.0461758263,
0.2539483905,
0.4653081894,
-0.6146323681,
0.0891855061,
0.1282339245,
-0.4410170019,
0.1216849536,
0.0878494233,
0.5778085589,
0.7491274476,
-0.0407034531,
-0.5830000639,
0.0348891728,
-0.0881037191,
-0.6679247618,
0.0610553361,
0.2346431762,
-0.7749710083,
-0.4736032784,
-0.1260631382,
-0.7112947106,
-0.6918867826,
-0.5489084721,
0.0480101444,
-0.1501788944,
-0.2071562558,
0.096812807,
-0.3026863039,
0.5709343553,
0.2364722788,
-0.8327895403,
0.2109789252,
0.8140848279,
0.3160112202,
0.1317214668,
0.0272562113,
-0.6304032803,
0.4208474457,
-0.3609038591,
0.8711745143,
-0.5285704136,
-0.2809242308,
0.0776552558,
-0.3084047735,
-0.0270654,
-0.6441953182,
0.1181951389,
-0.6008254886,
0.0931278169,
-0.6029607058,
-0.7824647427,
-0.476177603,
0.2511831522,
-0.4183758497,
0.5394865274,
0.1293749064,
-0.9790083766,
0.7279815078,
-0.8107052445,
-0.0628187358,
-0.1914561987,
-0.237725243,
-0.1805725694,
-0.0656580403,
0.3264198005,
0.3074501455,
-0.6117252707,
0.5829764605,
-0.7416164875,
-0.3264520764,
0.9511081576,
-0.8363678455,
0.6151413321,
-0.0347995013,
-0.5500383973,
0.3004145026,
-0.6454057693,
-0.5851095915,
0.0665368512,
0.0681521297,
-0.5867482424,
0.3030209839,
0.1152023524,
0.0293928981,
0.2151062787,
-0.2750959098,
0.3042083681,
-0.3308733106,
0.3133499622,
1.5122730732,
0.078299433,
0.525631547,
-0.4417228997,
0.5620669723,
0.2208803743,
0.3632469177,
0.1321444064,
-0.0722903386,
-0.8731079698,
-0.7700487971,
-0.0941717848,
0.6588408947,
-0.1033140719,
0.3442585766,
0.1194395199,
-0.0399960205,
-0.2377478182,
0.3717269003,
0.1861162186,
0.5631181598,
0.024435319,
0.258897692,
-0.4873273075,
-1.2393844128,
-0.5550147295,
-0.1229770258,
-0.0111061232,
0.1094387248,
0.5097586513,
-0.5398018956,
0.8898842335,
-0.5290686488,
-0.1495461017,
0.0254940391,
-0.0369846039,
0.3547258079,
0.2685827911,
0.8502370715,
-0.633872509,
-0.1757657081,
-0.0367052741,
-0.5849704146,
-0.1158449948,
-0.4499948025,
-0.1107829884,
0.3486257792,
0.4259484112,
-0.3698507249,
0.5146397352,
-0.0443562083,
-0.60294348,
0.2761486769,
0.2365608662,
-0.1400213987,
-0.4178851843,
0.0726591796,
0.5188480616,
-0.1343575269,
-0.3893525898,
-0.491707623,
-0.1630137265,
0.5072268248,
-0.0069492711,
0.8085494041,
-0.2559488714,
-0.2545073628,
-0.2516143918,
0.2890125513,
-0.0915248841,
0.4764434695,
-0.2833898962,
0.7702921033,
0.6305800676,
-0.1935519129,
0.2268250734,
-0.0907013118,
-0.4912019074,
0.5207772255,
-0.298438549,
-0.09912581,
-0.0889686272,
0.1633813977,
-1.0009548664,
-0.108039245,
0.659635365,
-0.0805241764,
0.2202069312,
0.1213186011,
-0.2326899469,
-0.271247685,
-0.4988497496,
0.2357572913,
0.2072928399,
-0.4707384408,
0.5652405024,
0.2891801596,
-0.4393721223,
-0.9953410029,
-0.4369285107,
-0.2968073785,
-0.58972615,
-0.7224230766,
-0.2245121896,
0.0169287957,
-0.9737975001,
-0.1537469923,
-0.3552298248,
0.0130821522,
0.3305197358,
0.0141027085,
0.8636315465,
-0.1958780289,
0.0757900476,
0.0713698119,
-0.4076938629,
0.4253843427,
-0.3238749504,
0.389442116,
-0.1725225896,
-0.3649643958,
-0.3697868884,
0.1117468327,
0.6381716132,
-0.1202007979,
0.6162509918,
0.2623936832,
-0.3219025433,
-0.1507644355,
-1.0455471277,
-0.1842126399,
-0.5367450118,
0.1262954772,
-0.1049956828,
-0.9530978203,
0.8977094293,
-0.1344334483,
-0.0453265533,
0.508815825,
0.8576430678,
0.1784209609,
0.9909301996,
0.6593751907,
-0.4426182806,
0.358006984,
-0.1562508494,
0.4398572445,
-0.5427761674,
-0.3544549048,
-0.2217836082,
-0.3461321294,
-0.2325033247,
-0.2305891067,
0.0423720703,
0.1530118585,
-0.5695191026,
-0.3727010787,
-0.184872821,
0.5710395575,
0.1622466296,
-0.1241060868,
0.1650062054,
-0.1547863781,
-0.1170317233,
-0.201858297,
-0.1866720319,
-0.6995519996,
1.3209831715,
0.9282150269,
0.8689975142,
-0.0606635585,
0.2578638196,
0.6426281333,
0.7745673656,
-0.7892770767,
0.3062011003,
0.3844609261,
-0.6278737783,
-0.2256332934,
-0.6610433459,
-0.2252753377,
0.1019105092,
-0.1694469452,
-0.495308876,
0.6048318744,
0.0271527302,
-0.3265232742,
0.2405159473,
-0.4678827822,
0.627155304,
-0.3902508616,
-0.3140749931,
-0.2336919308,
-0.0114680789,
0.7911984921,
-0.5184539557,
0.5116491318,
-0.4223420322,
-0.2022294402,
0.4665260315,
-0.4512183964,
0.9370679259,
-0.3616358042,
-0.570407927,
0.1577946246,
-0.0816846788,
0.627022624,
0.4645651281,
-0.1619834155,
-0.1461717635,
-0.2966985703,
-0.572350502,
-0.4455848932,
0.6588779688,
-0.7192617059,
-0.6772585511,
-0.4890362918,
-0.6723739505,
-0.2327421159,
-0.0478536487,
-0.3051556945,
0.1021282524,
-0.1849692911,
-0.1348760873,
0.4804459512,
-0.1262834817,
0.2489293665,
0.5148968101,
-0.4525290728,
-0.5444396138,
0.6941977143,
-0.00205099,
0.0945709348,
0.0989012271,
0.3004150093,
-0.5332057476,
-0.5461803079,
0.0107877403,
0.2302738428,
-0.7126413584,
-0.107708849,
-0.2544607222,
0.2080988586,
-0.6287595034,
-0.5101727843,
-0.1516835988,
-0.1134036481,
-0.2574903071,
-0.4599993825,
0.6498380303,
0.5982010961,
-0.0798673034,
0.3449730873,
-0.4840900004,
0.2582581043,
0.4334227443,
0.2713350058,
0.2835290134,
-0.4809280038,
-0.2294678688,
-0.040968392,
-0.0111757787,
-0.7087245584,
0.6026204824,
-0.208959952,
0.6270837784,
1.366674304,
0.0839319527,
0.53060776,
0.1048121676,
0.1281119585,
0.20078592,
-1.2722253799,
0.2890623808,
-0.6437670588,
-0.2669446766,
0.4246553183,
0.3916787207,
-0.3058670163,
-0.3733564913,
-0.1457151473,
-0.6729304194,
0.5457074046,
-0.1037336066,
-0.2553754449,
-0.1813709736,
0.5244939923,
0.0876217708,
0.5179926753,
-0.9058268666,
-0.3161144555,
-0.1111684069,
-0.0344826058,
0.2419454455,
-0.4689019918,
-0.3028054535,
-0.2052379102,
0.7637047768,
-0.2239306122,
-0.27004987,
0.0870629251,
0.0881097168,
-0.2938830853,
0.173806563,
0.4726762772,
0.8609891534,
-0.5587280393,
-0.1256671846,
0.1439100057,
-0.2228579074,
0.2003377229,
-0.1689437628,
-0.3272120655,
-0.2797487974,
0.2292690873,
0.4095187485,
0.2991220951,
-1.1231271029,
0.6767465472,
0.0245056823,
-0.0717708096,
-0.6891878247,
-0.2294126451,
-0.0199865438,
0.5922233462,
0.6511540413,
0.304345578,
0.2408180386,
-0.6659888625,
0.0450654477,
0.6559756994,
-0.3775543869,
-0.1400872171,
0.3460792303,
0.5490649343,
0.1643645316,
0.5689302087,
0.0968295187,
-0.5454581976,
0.7696998715,
0.3295276165,
1.1711722612,
0.0070337602,
0.0534021035,
-0.1226881519,
0.5396039486,
-0.1477756202,
0.2266621143,
0.1189687625,
-0.9484711289,
-0.5775201321,
-0.4651159942,
-0.3349299133,
0.1043248549,
-0.7942844033,
0.3759273589,
-0.8569997549,
-0.3439675868,
0.1995615363,
-0.0059514735,
-0.3894850314,
-0.0049843653,
0.2719894946,
0.9614264965,
-0.6990554333,
0.8195464611,
0.283349067,
-0.1910735071,
-0.3176781535,
-0.1737235934,
0.4571598768,
-0.8087692261,
1.0097790956,
0.3884419203,
-0.0790858567,
-0.4897321463,
-0.6138752699,
-0.5670309067,
0.912471056,
0.4289023578,
-0.8477682471,
0.0403246433,
0.0972524807,
0.1111189574,
-0.6679860353,
0.286942333,
0.749340713,
1.0589163303,
-0.0539489761,
-0.3013032973,
-0.2650780678,
-0.3314064741,
-0.2258040905,
0.347394079,
-0.7251454592,
0.8295640945,
-0.1771332026,
0.0104562137,
-0.154402867,
0.5066432953,
0.4327234924,
0.7027639151,
0.5919685364,
0.0999231115,
0.9482164979,
-0.0910916254,
0.7059029937,
-0.5051394105,
0.3862475753,
0.6973031163,
-0.7394817472,
0.5312914848,
0.719861865,
-0.0726877525,
0.100885585,
0.6538324952,
-0.3811684251,
0.2692291141,
0.6914904714,
-0.3085919023,
-0.6973522305,
-0.0995481163,
-0.2092985958,
0.2680728734,
0.4336037934,
-0.4083156586,
0.2217023522,
-0.0293675009,
0.315559268,
0.0890980661,
-0.3936093748,
0.3737227619,
0.2887876332,
-0.1610157043,
0.0298484378,
0.1192853823,
0.9473507404,
-0.744717598,
0.3383763433,
-0.5374184847,
0.4876298606,
0.0289333183,
-0.3038987219,
0.3422022462,
0.2164134681,
-0.3851148486,
-0.3301345706,
0.7481926084,
-0.0256346874,
-0.5978479385,
0.6402249336,
0.3430065811,
-0.1803053021,
-0.1596712619,
-0.4764412344,
-0.1787739992,
0.2802265882,
-0.4469785988,
0.3210081756,
0.5711131096,
-0.0221998524,
1.1334964037,
1.0347985029,
-0.1792771965,
-0.1492266953,
0.124504678,
0.755386591,
-1.0760142803,
-0.0821033269,
-1.0814228058,
0.0959049463,
-0.0332062617,
-0.3460659385,
0.8692960143,
0.7351360917,
0.6722338796,
-0.2002693713,
0.6265587211,
0.7832046151,
0.3555334508,
-0.578994453,
0.8506180644,
-0.3044034243,
0.6996735334,
-0.3198869824,
-0.9536092281,
-0.1190739498,
0.6697790027,
-0.5124926567,
-0.1118240133,
0.173429653,
0.7139363289,
0.2361630797,
0.3062176108,
0.1759828031,
0.3842156231,
0.244975999,
0.021878764,
1.1491068602,
-0.0918178633,
0.1981617808,
-0.1134571806,
-0.341396898,
-0.4335448444,
-0.8568857312,
-1.2573200464,
0.2455418557,
-0.5637322664,
-0.0553872138,
-0.1466232389,
1.0882645845,
0.1149162129,
-0.8485729098,
-0.4116013348,
0.2507436872,
0.3671478629,
-0.0556629784,
-0.2603798509,
0.2188226283,
-0.2163443714,
-0.4825643599,
0.344527334,
0.8215770721,
0.1774742305,
-0.6535790563,
-0.0383763611,
0.010005095,
0.7333905697,
0.58251369,
-0.0265991092,
-0.7045586109,
-0.2704556882,
0.277387917,
-0.0651273504,
-0.2955719233,
0.8063771129,
-0.3346031308,
-0.0091640009,
0.4086658061,
0.39455387,
-0.0312335975,
-0.1731875241,
0.617100656,
0.0150151486,
0.4380894601,
0.1284137368,
0.552007854,
-0.2425313145,
-0.3779661953,
0.3730645776,
0.2705853879,
-0.5489349365,
-0.7300032377,
-0.2500554919,
-0.9861527681,
-0.2042258084,
0.9777120948,
0.0126759512,
-0.355997324,
-0.2131639868,
-0.2868977189,
-0.3177247345,
-0.6168305874,
0.792157352,
0.6499091983,
0.191896081,
0.078977637,
-0.5256294608,
0.409278959,
0.4324705899,
-0.5100339651,
0.3962339461,
0.5765593648,
0.2614911795,
-0.0970141813,
0.6074531674,
-0.0657317638,
0.1430786997,
-0.037267033,
0.0404780619,
-0.0670757219,
-0.0945863724,
-0.1645243764,
-0.1713743955,
-0.0325364321,
0.228129521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14852v1
|
HumanEval on Latest GPT Models -- 2024
| 2024-02-20T04:17:21 | 2024-02-20T04:17:21 |
Daniel Li, Lincoln Murr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In 2023, we are using the latest models of GPT-4 to advance program
synthesis. The large language models have significantly improved the
state-of-the-art for this purpose. To make these advancements more accessible,
we have created a repository that connects these models to Huamn Eval. This
dataset was initally developed to be used with a language model called CODEGEN
on natural and programming language data. The utility of these trained models
is showcased by demonstrating their competitive performance in zero-shot Python
code generation on HumanEval tasks compared to previous state-of-the-art
solutions. Additionally, this gives way to developing more multi-step paradigm
synthesis. This benchmark features 160 diverse problem sets factorized into
multistep prompts that our analysis shows significantly improves program
synthesis over single-turn inputs. All code is open source at
https://github.com/daniel442li/gpt-human-eval .
|
[
-0.3615501225,
-0.5779513717,
0.4016126394,
0.0705187768,
0.0892731398,
0.0499291234,
-0.0032133819,
-0.3864865005,
-0.3649268746,
0.5347112417,
-0.4150444269,
-0.6263218522,
-0.1159331426,
0.3902491629,
0.0076081599,
1.2805505991,
-0.0137527911,
0.2511776388,
0.0567666627,
-0.3001473546,
-0.2329011559,
-0.837464273,
-0.4523294568,
-0.3200018406,
0.4645117819,
0.1828532964,
0.661657393,
0.668594718,
0.7058593631,
0.2689697146,
0.2771717012,
-0.461060077,
-0.1163257211,
0.005116099,
0.0866413563,
-0.0217219461,
-0.9087684751,
0.4606844187,
0.6256448627,
0.4375967681,
-0.1330830753,
0.0947198495,
-0.256008178,
0.4966898263,
-0.2831566036,
0.2165187746,
-0.5888346434,
0.0131969675,
-0.0676649362,
-0.1416305453,
-0.1956894547,
-0.738298893,
-0.0439781956,
-0.4777769744,
0.341743499,
-0.2562153041,
0.7100790739,
0.4450806677,
-0.3374682367,
0.0105158798,
-0.4668304324,
0.7325667739,
-0.8617681265,
0.4219799936,
0.3727443516,
0.3871587217,
-0.4080420732,
-0.9731808901,
-0.2599356174,
-0.6964839101,
0.6469153762,
-0.0192074757,
-0.1513756067,
0.3785449564,
0.3908019364,
0.488252461,
-0.6800661683,
-0.1283232421,
-0.5443598032,
-0.5447941422,
0.6221965551,
0.3726595044,
0.3995283246,
-0.1597828269,
-0.4473824799,
-0.2915215194,
-0.9178496003,
0.0282357652,
0.4558973014,
0.0148600563,
-0.0240521114,
0.4729909897,
-0.3732103705,
0.7352709174,
-0.3799258471,
0.0747665241,
0.2931442857,
-0.7888655066,
-0.2065581232,
-0.1239990667,
0.7480376959,
0.4345775843,
0.0213484745,
0.0626596287,
-0.4133419693,
0.242953375,
0.3898666799,
-0.9541721344,
-0.6954982281,
0.1451634914,
-0.2539659441,
-0.7074323297,
-0.2708854079,
-0.6076952219,
-0.2977139652,
-0.2582113743,
0.3964418173,
-0.2367512286,
-0.0909352154,
0.4288893044,
-0.0443417169,
0.4802118242,
0.2650648654,
-0.6503878236,
0.1334198713,
0.5651139617,
0.6306505203,
0.0753340125,
-0.4502660334,
-0.936642468,
-0.3304392099,
-0.6243728995,
0.6632966399,
-0.4871282279,
-0.1673714519,
-0.1063070074,
0.0003665267,
0.4157960713,
-0.4655199945,
0.6240393519,
-0.4063788652,
0.2390373945,
-0.3861643076,
-0.2347788513,
-0.137943238,
0.2918719351,
-0.7512565851,
1.170676589,
0.3614527881,
-0.8231450915,
0.2547396123,
-0.9662628174,
-0.1462560147,
0.2026773095,
-0.1322101057,
-0.5156954527,
-0.1475839317,
0.15804331,
0.3307656348,
-0.4223103523,
0.5192821026,
-0.4262939692,
-0.3897653818,
0.040972095,
-0.4365822673,
0.8417530656,
0.3360560536,
-0.2978973985,
0.5457459688,
-0.7487506866,
0.04730618,
0.1156063899,
-0.6171067953,
-0.0619320907,
-0.3024125695,
0.0320238583,
0.4564422071,
0.2037191689,
-0.5605261326,
0.5754846334,
-0.3792302012,
0.7228368521,
0.7277064323,
0.1908399463,
0.4404150844,
-0.3081623316,
0.8365776539,
-0.5750377774,
0.4774294198,
-0.1425169706,
-0.8417758942,
-0.3692914844,
0.038236741,
0.272008121,
0.4944228828,
-0.7561228871,
0.2141797692,
0.0786589608,
-0.3692687452,
-0.3564747572,
-0.2444569319,
0.1916493028,
0.4695244133,
0.2906981111,
-0.4000160396,
-0.6860756278,
-0.8516801,
-0.107191965,
-0.2089344114,
-0.2799123526,
-0.0750147104,
0.6581315398,
-0.4252707064,
0.6209665537,
-0.1799859554,
0.3072860837,
-0.2354611754,
0.3852601349,
0.219308883,
0.4804169834,
0.3789590895,
-0.6133901477,
-0.1932614893,
0.0087184226,
-0.6489623189,
-0.1360795647,
-0.0318532102,
-0.3670787215,
0.1641511619,
0.2899658084,
-0.2870296836,
0.3003947139,
0.5668446422,
-0.084171854,
0.8277654648,
-0.3286481798,
0.3779396713,
-0.9455307722,
0.2070397884,
-0.0859838575,
-0.1369796544,
-0.7459324598,
0.1515626013,
0.1642557681,
-0.304248333,
-0.5424237251,
0.5123504996,
-0.3321706653,
-0.2519189119,
-0.0790087655,
-0.3082193732,
-0.1136398837,
0.5282507539,
0.0792970359,
1.1589362621,
0.5281160474,
-0.4535442293,
0.7208066583,
0.1190199107,
-0.2197770029,
0.0093931127,
-0.8327626586,
0.4187393486,
0.4295812547,
0.3791778982,
-0.4985600114,
-0.4548257291,
0.2752425969,
-0.5629978776,
-0.0790679157,
-0.2400676459,
-0.327368021,
-0.5977652073,
-0.7690859437,
0.3748754561,
0.7447394729,
-0.2451977879,
0.1086931825,
0.4607487619,
-0.4142490029,
-0.3307876885,
-0.4694612324,
0.3842645884,
-0.2964085937,
-0.446685493,
0.0497089662,
-0.4550279677,
-0.1498099118,
-0.2476830035,
0.0916698873,
-0.171572566,
-0.1440407038,
-0.0500546061,
0.5964792967,
-0.2490290105,
-0.158301726,
-0.121101886,
-0.295537293,
0.2419448346,
-0.4614672065,
0.3134423196,
-0.5667708516,
-0.1426580846,
-0.2874071598,
0.2719592452,
0.7743448615,
-0.5052765012,
0.1672504991,
0.7020576596,
-0.4754945338,
0.0821492895,
-0.3674294055,
-0.1522295624,
-0.4867415726,
0.4079740942,
-0.2823068202,
-0.8775838614,
0.4044958055,
-0.051622685,
0.2238311023,
0.2585345507,
0.8100622296,
0.4961664677,
1.2736251354,
0.5601015687,
-0.071084857,
0.3966321945,
-0.1761774719,
0.0040183691,
-0.8498188257,
-0.0302575119,
-0.5708534718,
0.2550105155,
-0.6983764768,
-0.6294438243,
0.6767353415,
-0.0192127507,
-0.6934759617,
0.4873746037,
-0.8671118617,
0.3176166117,
0.6789677143,
-0.0470244102,
0.1921065301,
-0.0649158284,
-0.3425203264,
0.0021554588,
-0.6852540374,
-0.4947301447,
1.3586804867,
0.3446384072,
0.7104503512,
-0.3067976236,
0.7735096216,
0.4046129584,
0.3247834742,
-0.6203745008,
0.4634082317,
0.3302201331,
-0.586830318,
-0.4111430049,
-0.4183860123,
-0.8802022934,
0.1150665432,
0.1866904199,
-0.3942042291,
-0.2538363338,
0.033869721,
-0.4404931068,
0.2440623045,
-0.4211232364,
1.035332799,
-0.1541201919,
-0.4965378046,
0.0207113121,
-0.924501121,
0.4656146467,
-0.2252250016,
0.006446593,
-0.2027211487,
0.1783328503,
0.6680725217,
-0.5513831377,
0.4179129303,
-0.0735822022,
-0.2476582825,
0.4494846463,
0.081340462,
0.5988429189,
0.0897589624,
-0.393479377,
0.1280975342,
-0.0609195009,
-0.4558724463,
-0.0806209296,
0.6111696362,
-0.4030790329,
-0.3750905991,
-0.4680362642,
-0.5729950666,
-0.1355931461,
0.1822565198,
0.3042281568,
0.9125250578,
-0.3157117367,
0.0184647944,
0.4750034213,
-0.6608672142,
0.3671605289,
0.2274304479,
-0.1153467745,
-0.6832912564,
0.8869940042,
-0.2557057738,
0.2033119053,
0.0846037939,
0.3473753631,
-0.4599400759,
-0.4613398015,
-0.7243541479,
0.0817754492,
-0.6317021251,
-0.3491318822,
-0.4371239245,
-0.1941363215,
-0.4876122177,
-0.2547791004,
-0.4044460058,
-0.242820859,
0.275981009,
-0.0448263437,
0.4621586502,
1.1089401245,
-0.2725307345,
-0.414655596,
-1.1603605747,
0.5056217313,
0.3486889899,
0.3824894726,
-0.3827247024,
-0.3014549017,
-0.2540136874,
0.1318570375,
-0.4114417434,
-0.8568331599,
0.4058515429,
-0.0111177722,
0.5228833556,
-0.1493972689,
0.2591715753,
0.1538732201,
-0.6098717451,
1.0595779419,
0.1856393367,
-0.8999841809,
0.7370895743,
-0.8932019472,
0.4371771514,
0.3118179739,
0.2829559743,
-0.5926474333,
-0.4341034293,
-0.5619242787,
-0.4477541149,
0.6573749781,
0.1952691823,
-0.0087921955,
0.039025493,
0.1884969771,
0.1702816188,
0.2154829502,
-0.5315308571,
0.1884979457,
-0.2729653716,
-0.0524920709,
0.2277936488,
-0.0181293637,
0.0203043837,
-0.631747365,
0.5710058212,
-0.2332737595,
0.6102799177,
-0.0809410065,
0.2834262848,
-0.1266325116,
0.3232263625,
0.6683223844,
0.5797438025,
-0.2628310919,
-0.0824970379,
0.14872998,
-0.4624360204,
0.2243604958,
0.1898771673,
0.0331950076,
-0.2773665488,
0.2668000162,
0.8048186898,
-0.0020571833,
-0.5378783941,
0.5847548246,
-0.0878501609,
-0.3882674873,
-0.1624519676,
0.0713263527,
-0.0999225974,
0.269012481,
0.0536899194,
0.2093841285,
0.5154119134,
-0.4313883781,
0.432061404,
0.0888764858,
-0.2560519576,
-0.6397192478,
1.1375790834,
0.2083213925,
-0.1528015137,
0.8395178914,
-0.4546878934,
-0.8182882071,
0.6309166551,
0.3840089738,
1.0081326962,
-0.3919387758,
0.3044798672,
0.6645166278,
0.1324859411,
-0.1354203373,
0.4073175788,
-0.0737302676,
-0.4143752456,
-0.6641863585,
-0.6126977801,
-0.6304582953,
0.3282827437,
-0.5785030127,
0.3393553197,
-0.272183001,
-0.0983993188,
-0.3086377978,
0.0374068469,
-0.5197127461,
0.0370493941,
0.0657882616,
0.5549694896,
-0.7835361958,
1.2663391829,
0.9517148733,
-0.6772120595,
-0.9790545106,
-0.1479559094,
0.1276549101,
-0.4545729458,
0.2995221913,
-0.0186285581,
-0.099549748,
0.1436798126,
-0.8544680476,
-0.4618451595,
0.7898164988,
0.358959347,
-0.2131408155,
-0.0886484906,
-0.0544249378,
0.5547426343,
-0.0342194736,
0.0287891999,
0.5417768955,
0.5341653228,
0.1301533729,
-0.9662191868,
-0.0913512632,
-0.5183740258,
0.1267479509,
0.227311939,
-0.2519786358,
1.0542018414,
-0.3605165184,
0.0574983209,
0.2277897596,
0.4276311696,
0.4696899652,
0.203879714,
0.0125881871,
0.2398014814,
0.6286319494,
-0.1215194538,
1.2003276348,
-0.3157073855,
0.5382014513,
0.8551618457,
-0.3983644247,
0.6326190829,
0.0613757223,
-0.5595389009,
0.0973466709,
0.840728879,
-0.1432713717,
0.5128204226,
0.2797576785,
-0.4273118079,
-0.3228651881,
0.0317509361,
-0.5768686533,
0.2501247823,
0.0638169795,
0.14325279,
-0.2830688357,
0.2631177306,
0.0060084816,
-0.3032230437,
-0.0139023727,
0.6171271801,
-0.1290093511,
-0.5582324862,
1.0162004232,
0.1304172873,
0.6657322645,
-0.490732044,
-0.5625394583,
-0.2934800684,
0.0985344872,
0.1571864933,
-0.7287800312,
0.0744794905,
0.1211372912,
0.2425854653,
-0.2017085701,
0.8550085425,
-0.3664260805,
-0.2457571477,
0.0443782806,
0.3234474957,
0.4047198594,
-0.3238007128,
-0.8998219371,
0.1681424975,
0.1970552951,
-0.1720062941,
0.3105969131,
0.3264266551,
-0.4848800302,
0.596013844,
0.810284853,
0.0952431932,
0.3619936407,
0.1245683208,
0.9546845555,
-0.7324365377,
-0.3160915971,
-0.5049116015,
0.4126543403,
0.2862926424,
-0.3673361242,
0.5004897714,
0.4943765998,
0.7854648829,
-0.2955608964,
0.9881957769,
-0.0092793871,
0.1140686944,
-0.3915703893,
0.6974551082,
-0.441411972,
0.0570429936,
-0.3858299851,
-0.9532989264,
-0.4394172132,
0.6463466883,
-0.1481068283,
0.1522542238,
0.653034091,
0.8860964179,
0.2120964378,
0.0291658714,
0.4256458879,
-0.0963257104,
0.6660004258,
0.7280070782,
1.0852792263,
-0.521885097,
0.3854831457,
-0.2772113383,
-0.2972382903,
-0.1946970373,
-0.9260349274,
-0.5547127724,
-0.6880506277,
-0.3458908498,
-0.2554783821,
0.1521513462,
1.0403416157,
0.4969134331,
-0.7112389207,
-0.0524626039,
-0.4222086072,
-0.178883791,
0.0081633506,
-0.1455397457,
0.2559179366,
-0.295053333,
-0.7668147683,
0.526155591,
0.4742544591,
-0.1009616032,
-0.2396781892,
-0.5209950805,
-0.0953345448,
0.089393869,
0.5088322759,
0.4090672433,
-0.6503300071,
-0.4382974207,
0.1826424301,
-0.3811405897,
0.2378691137,
0.8878145814,
-0.7653169036,
0.5371589065,
0.6738812327,
0.682249248,
0.2383652776,
0.0822039768,
0.7767426372,
-0.2514712512,
0.0667474046,
0.4181346297,
0.2174513638,
0.352748841,
-0.1932688355,
0.6555706859,
0.1685525179,
-0.9437037706,
-0.6981332302,
0.1252219528,
-0.808152318,
0.095056057,
1.1908903122,
-0.0575104579,
-0.1010441408,
-0.2467455715,
-0.3228617013,
0.446002692,
-0.3932842314,
0.4383437932,
0.6251071692,
-0.4246298373,
-0.0329405777,
-1.0320653915,
0.597433269,
0.2491630465,
-1.0329662561,
-0.0024429928,
0.890009284,
0.3925244212,
-0.3381823599,
0.9093211293,
-0.5928165317,
0.6180312634,
0.2536004484,
0.6383429766,
-0.1247087568,
-0.438590616,
-0.537073195,
-0.179930523,
0.2587768734,
-0.2309467047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08819v2
|
Thermometer: Towards Universal Calibration for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T04:13:48 | 2024-06-27T16:30:32 |
Maohao Shen, Subhro Das, Kristjan Greenewald, Prasanna Sattigeri, Gregory Wornell, Soumya Ghosh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We consider the issue of calibration in large language models (LLM). Recent
studies have found that common interventions such as instruction tuning often
result in poorly calibrated LLMs. Although calibration is well-explored in
traditional applications, calibrating LLMs is uniquely challenging. These
challenges stem as much from the severe computational requirements of LLMs as
from their versatility, which allows them to be applied to diverse tasks.
Addressing these challenges, we propose THERMOMETER, a calibration approach
tailored to LLMs. THERMOMETER learns an auxiliary model, given data from
multiple tasks, for calibrating a LLM. It is computationally efficient,
preserves the accuracy of the LLM, and produces better-calibrated responses for
new tasks. Extensive empirical evaluations across various benchmarks
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
|
[
0.0343806185,
-0.3338731825,
0.709638536,
-0.0847872049,
-0.1254252642,
-0.1108124182,
-0.577046752,
-0.1656120121,
-0.0214352906,
0.5216523409,
-0.3382909596,
-0.5036123395,
-0.3399833739,
-0.0870679766,
-0.1847056597,
0.7406730056,
-0.0340087153,
0.2012071013,
-0.4728553891,
-0.0193434823,
-0.4495684803,
-0.5091965795,
-0.735253036,
-0.8992212415,
0.645950079,
0.6445388198,
0.5841549635,
0.6683115959,
0.1565597653,
0.3909000158,
0.2029915303,
0.2638363242,
-0.6790390611,
0.3493559957,
-0.1019309536,
-0.4262568653,
-0.2234742194,
-0.260474354,
0.5775668025,
0.8280195594,
-0.2445966005,
0.4502937496,
0.0494802743,
0.6854214668,
-0.6622969508,
0.2262682766,
-0.5684215426,
-0.2644287348,
-0.1398315281,
-0.3034451604,
-0.4122342467,
-0.3059757352,
0.0695720017,
-0.5898444057,
0.0429338589,
0.0257986449,
0.1262619942,
0.394420594,
-0.8607195616,
-0.2245941907,
-0.9465111494,
1.1636447906,
-0.7151754498,
0.4966705143,
0.3056697845,
0.2229796946,
0.0133085363,
-0.4577510953,
-0.2666046321,
-0.4593072534,
0.449831605,
0.0111136306,
0.2132311612,
-0.1204461008,
-0.1813890934,
0.2907211185,
-0.6136655807,
0.4440129995,
-0.1984133273,
-0.3104684651,
0.5316118002,
0.4532735348,
0.2031288892,
0.1177424192,
0.0363354571,
-0.2728983164,
-0.8290829659,
-0.1734391749,
0.2467375547,
0.4456321299,
-0.1014888138,
0.3389433622,
0.2844314873,
0.9864510298,
-0.1671535969,
-0.4145691097,
-0.1735725254,
-0.0767286792,
-0.0552444868,
0.2079101354,
0.4657386541,
0.2299085408,
0.5058521032,
-0.3452057838,
0.0600062348,
-0.1214154214,
0.2859874368,
-0.7856840491,
-0.5854486227,
0.0273908284,
0.5418990254,
-0.1193724498,
-0.0460650548,
-0.3582316339,
-0.4501665831,
-0.5829516649,
0.3910325766,
-0.0810828879,
-0.2571237385,
0.0474062972,
0.220643878,
0.1319194734,
0.4392214715,
-1.1057523489,
0.2141550183,
0.9589533806,
0.5535944104,
0.1212182939,
-0.39722085,
-0.5537029505,
0.3897470534,
-0.4504666328,
0.6215153337,
-0.7514486313,
-0.522649169,
-0.282761842,
-0.2184993923,
-0.135066092,
-0.2952694595,
0.4899041951,
-0.6077196002,
0.0393018611,
-0.4709448218,
-0.900546968,
-0.3368162811,
0.4183300138,
-0.7302179337,
1.1288145781,
0.0435995944,
-0.376917541,
-0.0846518353,
-0.4265357554,
-0.2663550377,
0.0319458619,
-0.2190130949,
-0.0692771673,
0.2506445348,
0.1343828291,
0.1851802915,
-0.8408847451,
0.1634439677,
-0.4205951691,
-0.4602285326,
0.1722383648,
-0.6419412494,
0.6074619889,
-0.0236857925,
0.1452921629,
0.1716871262,
-0.5270011425,
0.328276515,
-0.0108282715,
-0.3728220165,
-0.3284430802,
0.011074896,
0.0944775715,
-0.4654861689,
0.4030474424,
-0.6789125204,
0.0118352026,
-0.4524555504,
0.3449762166,
0.7725753784,
-0.2052464336,
0.6958591938,
-0.551700592,
0.4246719778,
-0.4059580564,
-0.2554687858,
-0.1223418489,
-0.1913258135,
-0.7158874869,
-0.354180932,
0.4409672022,
0.810449183,
-0.3747413456,
0.5370380878,
-0.3050845563,
-1.0474640131,
-0.195354417,
0.565240562,
0.2015272528,
0.6733864546,
0.0996299163,
0.1792356223,
-0.5250626206,
-0.2405091077,
-0.3347366154,
-0.2149086744,
-0.413829565,
0.3681507409,
0.2141637951,
0.0381991193,
0.6084430814,
-0.2539462149,
-0.0696378648,
0.1187446862,
0.0470069163,
0.5700469613,
0.520468235,
0.2645645142,
-0.3989264369,
-0.3897608817,
0.2324668467,
-0.7379887104,
-0.2541813254,
0.1842025816,
0.15945144,
0.0415543728,
0.5963369608,
-0.2779702544,
-0.1922571361,
0.9767957926,
-0.0213585552,
0.5021740198,
-0.5397834182,
0.1618266255,
-1.0310126543,
0.055376824,
0.0418949723,
-0.4147370458,
-0.6286557317,
0.1851240247,
0.1519149542,
-0.0567852706,
-0.4967042506,
0.9032850862,
-0.5145180821,
0.2435100973,
-0.2800723612,
0.0858107656,
0.1839693338,
-0.1417209357,
-0.1169342995,
0.6334235072,
0.6830691695,
-0.7059404254,
1.1428827047,
-0.0072245928,
-0.5020400882,
0.6328176856,
-0.6825707555,
0.5320464373,
0.0603666976,
0.2958067358,
-0.9288732409,
-0.3794251382,
-0.1392420679,
-0.1654426306,
0.2747255266,
0.0708815157,
-0.6330708265,
-0.4350563884,
-0.2722268403,
0.7366120219,
0.3359878659,
-0.706313014,
0.729370296,
0.2683372498,
-0.1512692273,
-0.2966982722,
-0.3289431632,
0.093684867,
-0.0940900669,
-0.6059366465,
0.0604772009,
-0.276001066,
-0.0725726038,
-0.3647568524,
-0.3760898709,
0.0575915612,
0.0548896492,
0.2868759632,
0.2693050206,
-0.3402072191,
0.3646912575,
-0.3893769383,
-0.0297498647,
0.006336343,
-0.1586936116,
0.7214449048,
-0.1690020114,
-0.5592367053,
-0.2852483988,
0.2366390824,
0.7322511077,
0.0364863612,
0.5654508471,
0.4127367437,
-0.5247499347,
-0.315992415,
-0.7329156995,
-0.1597761959,
-0.5984126925,
0.4232439399,
-0.4817306399,
-0.7710412145,
0.4719446898,
-0.0835981444,
0.031036716,
0.2838831246,
0.6565337777,
0.0048034997,
1.0308593512,
0.7597039342,
-0.1723372489,
0.3720806539,
0.2865783572,
0.2653307915,
-0.82805866,
-0.2009988129,
-0.7859346271,
-0.2561465502,
-0.4351896048,
-0.3755896986,
0.7411985397,
-0.2258591354,
-0.7105634809,
0.2441918552,
-0.3470130563,
0.7843293548,
0.7831529379,
0.3827546835,
0.2399801761,
-0.0652494356,
-0.0030294782,
-0.334010303,
-0.4873085022,
-0.7144238353,
1.1464494467,
0.1465215534,
1.230348587,
0.1127418056,
0.4478069842,
-0.1215973943,
0.6823756695,
-0.780467093,
0.524338603,
-0.4431041181,
-0.7257713079,
-0.4738017619,
-0.6354112625,
-0.4957787991,
0.0115601942,
0.0989065766,
-1.0648629665,
-0.4384696782,
0.3372680247,
-0.3641436696,
0.4443457723,
-0.6894974113,
0.8945732713,
-0.4585359395,
-0.3618740439,
-0.1161928773,
-0.0386337377,
0.1517049968,
-0.3537184,
0.0832218155,
-0.4064561427,
-0.2090190798,
0.5839384794,
-0.2682941258,
0.9947940111,
-0.0988860428,
-0.4199083745,
0.0136518171,
0.3253836632,
0.4204300344,
0.1766064018,
-0.9682101011,
-0.0879812539,
0.6396560073,
-0.3913231194,
-0.402394712,
1.0819443464,
-0.698400557,
-0.6841407418,
-0.4129686952,
-1.0181304216,
-0.6103516221,
0.1165041998,
0.0464805961,
0.4980204999,
-0.545440197,
0.1478750706,
0.4221645892,
-0.2402839214,
0.0786384642,
0.8052641749,
-0.0878976732,
-0.0406398773,
1.158747077,
-0.1782448143,
0.124141939,
0.4978121519,
0.3741036355,
-0.2801432908,
-0.1230740324,
-0.6415448785,
0.0613591522,
-0.7801336646,
-0.3311383724,
-0.0495481677,
-0.0448641069,
-0.3913886249,
-0.3729257882,
-0.4140762091,
-0.1688061506,
-0.767588377,
0.1643470973,
0.634159565,
0.6991393566,
-0.1904442906,
0.3876505792,
-0.9391477108,
0.03049458,
0.5713679194,
0.2704408169,
-0.0573714226,
-0.8893300891,
0.0652817413,
0.3419709802,
-0.1777180433,
-0.5500234365,
0.3191867471,
0.6108247638,
0.2867070436,
0.4573588967,
0.0909075141,
0.6541089416,
-0.6343724728,
0.6947405338,
0.2925986946,
-1.2623461485,
0.1377572864,
-0.2139488608,
0.9662740231,
0.7106488943,
0.3029971421,
-0.8385773301,
-0.3221321404,
0.0649388433,
-0.7177974582,
0.3050860167,
-0.6748886704,
0.6570414305,
0.2845448852,
0.385823518,
0.1791469753,
0.0057504722,
-0.4739759862,
-0.0291091334,
0.2754575014,
-0.6035750508,
-0.4814149439,
-0.0274161175,
-0.278691709,
-0.6232030988,
0.6391820312,
-0.254227668,
0.0350875072,
-0.3454660475,
-0.3147763312,
-0.5556365252,
0.2526658475,
0.3367966413,
1.0008847713,
-0.3334797919,
0.4071375132,
0.4236799479,
-0.3581195474,
0.112996906,
-0.1179845855,
-0.0944378003,
-0.1247540861,
0.3861241937,
0.627802968,
0.6440026164,
-0.7178795934,
0.290794462,
0.0561710484,
-0.0384905525,
-0.626224339,
0.3089869022,
0.3453820348,
0.1925919503,
0.2409480661,
-0.2192738354,
-0.1446440816,
-0.5206383467,
0.1129609793,
0.5931302905,
-0.2726453543,
-0.4011821747,
0.7022768259,
0.2747157216,
-0.3652332127,
0.6878147721,
0.2239071429,
-0.6805861592,
0.7824210525,
0.7825292945,
0.6298414469,
-0.5061898232,
0.1189901456,
0.4563681483,
0.5636196733,
-0.1201568842,
0.311899811,
-0.0224837344,
-0.8251472712,
-0.4627738297,
-0.8062254786,
-1.0657663345,
0.0165565386,
-0.6330077648,
-0.1254725009,
-0.4312755167,
0.1326722354,
0.1616917104,
-0.0424215607,
-0.9922823906,
0.2300545573,
0.5118992329,
0.91942662,
-0.8087757826,
0.8844620585,
0.8499186635,
0.4080654383,
-0.7917238474,
-0.4311278462,
0.2227438688,
-1.1966203451,
0.2660248876,
0.2703029811,
-0.2740668952,
0.1042464226,
-0.5578354597,
-0.8537720442,
0.9748328328,
0.9273978472,
-0.8384422064,
-0.085149847,
0.3013414145,
0.5731954575,
-0.279242903,
0.269697845,
0.6719294786,
0.6879683733,
0.2970347404,
-1.2137598991,
0.0760034397,
-0.0760310888,
-0.0266021267,
0.3256022334,
-0.4295604825,
0.5494986773,
-0.3230486214,
-0.0708770454,
0.3535196781,
0.442409724,
0.013289501,
0.1388479322,
0.4565576315,
0.4928718805,
0.953492403,
-0.2795808613,
0.9989151359,
-0.4778358042,
0.2402230948,
1.2153562307,
-0.5596491098,
0.9263266921,
0.5322912335,
-0.0507354364,
0.1426730603,
0.6764440536,
-0.0373812132,
0.3121519983,
0.6274252534,
-0.9142100811,
-0.5429382324,
-0.065133363,
-0.3010881245,
0.4684186876,
0.5738148093,
0.0513834693,
-0.3479712605,
-0.059399005,
-0.0486469567,
0.031781368,
-0.5956637263,
0.5556579232,
0.2828136384,
-0.5865662694,
0.5514566302,
0.1686848849,
0.4378676414,
-0.5254769921,
0.2321918607,
0.0155002195,
0.5674999952,
0.0303325634,
-0.5492928028,
0.2352363318,
-0.0286907814,
-0.0337803885,
-0.1892183125,
0.2638829947,
-0.6672627926,
-0.8907189965,
0.1195103377,
0.5093014836,
0.0080988277,
-0.1999925226,
-0.3090257645,
0.4179183841,
-0.2027334869,
-0.3563866019,
0.0409177989,
0.1858269721,
0.434772253,
0.5137717128,
0.3891420662,
0.1266665459,
0.0966976136,
-0.0076186392,
0.5606092811,
-0.5561086535,
-0.2534475029,
-0.7793262601,
0.0727129281,
0.3235206902,
-0.2747857571,
0.7173267007,
0.3769258559,
0.6247995496,
-0.0640952364,
0.5762605667,
0.3147232831,
0.5957878232,
-0.5720428228,
0.4829053581,
-0.674841404,
0.3941302896,
0.0611768141,
-1.168538332,
-0.6269910932,
0.5426674485,
-0.4179548621,
0.0784490779,
0.606208086,
0.9114855528,
-0.19257164,
0.2896314859,
0.4953107536,
0.1420439333,
0.1580184549,
0.879739821,
0.5014181137,
-0.3122635186,
0.4013012052,
-0.1591012478,
-0.399854362,
0.0536858104,
-1.1983010769,
-0.8702594042,
-0.4337404668,
-0.1655272245,
-0.1320921779,
0.0847707316,
1.0457965136,
0.7180938125,
-1.1302770376,
-0.6884925365,
0.2315450609,
-0.0521757342,
0.0888818204,
-0.1428944618,
0.0996196046,
-0.0402217656,
-0.9239501953,
0.573887825,
0.219594121,
-0.3027027249,
-0.4163641036,
-0.0248618033,
0.1595581025,
0.4576844871,
0.5624124408,
0.5878807902,
-0.4661043584,
-0.3665361106,
-0.0684228688,
-0.2422468364,
-0.178744778,
0.6470501423,
-0.3272899389,
0.6427052617,
0.2880932093,
0.9736773968,
0.7423374653,
-0.4968213439,
0.8400030136,
-0.7525857091,
0.0721071959,
0.2658765614,
0.2232712954,
0.6803959608,
-0.092217423,
0.2827363014,
-0.3571075201,
-0.7681887746,
-1.0357263088,
0.2982690334,
-0.8016495109,
0.1154980883,
1.0646257401,
0.0932545736,
-0.4333672225,
0.1748156101,
-0.0339848064,
0.2819402516,
-0.3797078133,
0.7524923682,
0.8162741065,
0.2071291804,
-0.2252767384,
-0.7320554256,
-0.0000622323,
0.6631167531,
-0.802628696,
0.0794088915,
0.4894751608,
0.5988622904,
0.0307733659,
0.3511121273,
0.2765753567,
0.3033998609,
-0.2276140749,
0.0202879086,
-0.0344199203,
-0.1775803715,
-0.2756250799,
0.0236401651,
0.380713433,
0.171136573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14851v1
|
SQL-CRAFT: Text-to-SQL through Interactive Refinement and Enhanced Reasoning
| 2024-02-20T03:57:55 | 2024-02-20T03:57:55 |
Hanchen Xia, Feng Jiang, Naihao Deng, Cunxiang Wang, Guojiang Zhao, Rada Mihalcea, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
Modern LLMs have become increasingly powerful, but they are still facing
challenges in specialized tasks such as Text-to-SQL. We propose SQL-CRAFT, a
framework to advance LLMs' SQL generation Capabilities through inteRActive
reFinemenT and enhanced reasoning. We leverage an Interactive Correction Loop
(IC-Loop) for LLMs to interact with databases automatically, as well as
Python-enhanced reasoning. We conduct experiments on two Text-to-SQL datasets,
Spider and Bird, with performance improvements of up to 5.7% compared to the
naive prompting method. Moreover, our method surpasses the current
state-of-the-art on the Spider Leaderboard, demonstrating the effectiveness of
our framework.
|
[
-0.0934762806,
-1.2024601698,
0.7385879159,
0.2411118895,
-0.3122753799,
0.2083441168,
-0.2184112519,
-0.3091155291,
0.1954826564,
0.6473813653,
-1.0016481876,
-0.5945794582,
-0.0104676653,
0.5024121404,
-0.4638924301,
0.6850566864,
0.0670470372,
-0.0889133736,
-0.624617219,
0.1867356896,
-0.5578075647,
-0.462695241,
-0.4249349535,
-0.3383692801,
0.6419714689,
0.5699617267,
0.7222777605,
0.8098084331,
0.5512940884,
0.3309182525,
-0.0001296394,
1.011885047,
-0.3631342947,
0.712218523,
-0.6674938798,
-0.8272439241,
-0.6623957157,
-0.3438742757,
0.3129921257,
0.5885733962,
-0.178905338,
0.0823444724,
-0.1055357084,
0.9535128474,
-0.4185566008,
-0.0900980234,
-1.1480607986,
-0.0295658354,
-0.4660015404,
-0.5121474862,
-0.5527589321,
-0.3913754821,
-0.0080526769,
-0.913282156,
0.0888408646,
0.5667458177,
0.4507354498,
0.3390473127,
-0.3317256868,
-0.3957831264,
-0.5299338102,
0.469974786,
-0.5409296155,
0.1213466004,
0.0586568825,
0.1810444295,
-0.6643624902,
-1.0204888582,
-0.7288961411,
-0.4282383919,
-0.0860045776,
-0.0524526462,
0.1963041127,
0.0223016497,
0.538376987,
0.4020307064,
-0.3332159221,
-0.0584487319,
-0.1425376683,
0.1954385042,
0.8105936646,
0.4405124784,
0.1035530865,
0.0923389718,
-0.1339597255,
0.3203691542,
-0.9294524193,
-0.3511264026,
0.4316515028,
0.5374394059,
0.2397083193,
1.154945612,
-0.2995889783,
0.90920645,
0.2717888355,
0.1694275141,
-0.1160861626,
-0.4525333345,
-0.3127070367,
0.0687281489,
0.505271852,
0.5454316139,
0.3036374748,
-0.2400335371,
-0.1252801865,
-0.1531904042,
0.2643596828,
-0.4275446832,
-0.3758460283,
0.7026309967,
-0.2199309617,
-0.3293525577,
0.0375457294,
-0.6552881598,
-0.8395670056,
-0.5828722715,
0.4104653001,
-0.3459880054,
-0.3199854195,
-0.084931314,
-0.4892135859,
0.002371189,
0.6515211463,
-0.6780475974,
0.2262188941,
0.7196634412,
0.7173249722,
-0.8228756785,
-0.2155836076,
-0.5865811706,
0.7025452852,
-0.496725291,
1.1671905518,
-0.6473354697,
-0.4483964741,
-0.1168723628,
-0.030004343,
0.1879149526,
-0.8137903214,
-0.0410075001,
-0.3386453092,
0.1767028719,
-0.3450987041,
-0.6594632268,
0.1919308454,
0.4284783006,
-0.626209259,
1.3443542719,
0.0443110391,
-0.556181252,
0.6122609973,
-0.7864044309,
-0.5648693442,
0.0766248256,
-0.1029741168,
-0.4735730588,
0.1559738517,
0.2329808027,
0.1485882103,
-0.4036466777,
0.1877656579,
-0.541733861,
-0.728518188,
0.3670256436,
-0.0642055795,
0.4366779923,
0.167555958,
-0.3174875379,
0.2750570476,
-0.9236723185,
0.4035048187,
0.0081605157,
-0.3729606569,
0.0904590935,
0.1799467653,
-0.3405096233,
-0.2367808968,
0.1745072752,
-0.2454208583,
0.7305754423,
-0.5659440756,
0.3484145701,
0.6599773169,
0.1187717542,
0.4385213852,
-0.4396930635,
0.3440214097,
0.1036083102,
-0.0010114157,
-0.4631459713,
-0.284625411,
-1.0156903267,
-0.1625241339,
0.1787586808,
0.8644863367,
-0.9015294909,
0.4194468856,
0.1509643197,
-0.4482691288,
-0.4093458354,
0.0749189481,
-0.054502558,
0.1667939872,
0.5651552677,
-0.1216467246,
-0.6726329923,
-0.47439906,
-0.7884228826,
-0.161630556,
0.0919697955,
0.354285121,
0.2936035097,
-0.0090679862,
1.0709630251,
-0.4165621102,
-0.2038523406,
-0.0524220355,
-0.188768521,
0.2505717874,
0.6384858489,
0.0960333273,
-0.3902222514,
-0.4801534116,
0.0301935226,
-0.7650860548,
-0.2027367055,
-0.478248924,
-0.2663431764,
0.5859910846,
0.5606773496,
-0.7089187503,
0.5300844908,
-0.172464788,
-0.3318893015,
0.7435261607,
-0.2662257552,
0.217093572,
-0.842772007,
-0.0220982227,
-0.2848043144,
-0.0213447772,
-0.4020319879,
-0.0393656567,
-0.1727226824,
-0.1797961742,
-0.3029811382,
0.3872888684,
-0.8390838504,
-0.1295590699,
-0.1156902537,
0.2382190078,
0.1025703922,
0.0739786103,
0.2030565739,
0.974234879,
0.6478665471,
-0.7269990444,
0.8884993196,
0.1278049201,
-0.1601537019,
0.9051286578,
-0.5413013697,
0.3572987616,
0.0606254749,
0.0821927637,
-0.9351830482,
-0.3537464738,
0.0430814438,
-0.300593704,
0.2067839056,
-0.1976526231,
-0.7514352202,
-0.270576179,
-0.4369657636,
-0.2172570676,
0.2389919162,
-0.7914703488,
0.7084915042,
-0.1147412658,
-0.0936487466,
-0.3114620149,
-0.8166799545,
0.4552898109,
-0.2983055115,
-0.6824297905,
0.5760055184,
-0.0843746364,
-0.5504707694,
-0.1365470439,
-0.0155233527,
-0.1396982968,
-0.1941460669,
0.0716537759,
0.2428815365,
-0.1268116534,
0.3945603669,
0.3989875317,
-0.0498220138,
-0.00662009,
-0.2848412693,
0.2483988702,
0.0610685758,
-0.633225441,
-0.2828342915,
0.4194354415,
0.4227220416,
-0.283126682,
0.6597382426,
0.2092478275,
-0.1650666893,
-0.5103971958,
-0.6460526586,
-0.294831574,
-0.5735601783,
0.0288488362,
-0.5943585634,
-0.6929280162,
0.141986534,
-0.7948817611,
0.2063552886,
0.3075714409,
0.4876811504,
-0.3976534009,
1.2078853846,
0.3796705902,
0.7251614928,
0.2074818611,
-0.05737314,
0.00861964,
-0.6678575873,
-0.5947687626,
-0.4845660031,
-0.0832178816,
-0.37643224,
-0.5652444363,
0.2384130955,
0.3235547245,
-0.4579721987,
0.1855977625,
-1.0621914864,
0.744386673,
0.4609051347,
0.2299728096,
0.6453692317,
0.1532303542,
-0.3752656281,
-0.0786509439,
-0.5780174136,
-0.5230548978,
0.8702072501,
-0.2607686222,
1.0106662512,
0.0739160553,
0.6660397053,
0.4191820025,
0.2780296504,
-0.568662107,
0.7490816116,
0.099342674,
-0.5018612146,
-0.2106504589,
-0.0882743672,
-0.5177583098,
0.1155646965,
-0.5818549991,
-0.5792309642,
-0.0044286428,
0.4399149716,
-0.0278074332,
0.3267982006,
-0.8499341607,
0.4766128957,
-0.4124062955,
-0.9063645601,
-0.1440633684,
-0.3256782293,
0.3288789392,
-0.0716114715,
-0.0929776579,
-0.1259807497,
-0.4743815362,
0.0307878219,
-0.8971307874,
0.7279099226,
-0.1348911971,
0.0043082731,
0.4432668686,
0.2085196376,
0.8118414283,
0.0955902264,
-0.8249157667,
-0.3151050806,
0.1498493105,
-0.0179797374,
-0.713455081,
0.7119494677,
-0.1540023386,
-0.8306683302,
-0.5197431445,
-0.525313735,
-0.201061815,
0.1992770582,
0.0566805489,
0.1592493951,
0.0434710942,
0.1520572752,
0.5368489623,
-0.1646710485,
0.1673202068,
0.5829047561,
-0.3757695258,
-0.476418674,
0.6838994026,
0.1617478281,
0.0740359575,
0.3118937314,
0.02587297,
-0.6628642678,
-0.6441197991,
-0.722237289,
0.0797937959,
-0.5807810426,
-0.246334359,
-0.3622019291,
0.1632121801,
-0.1283501536,
-0.416339606,
0.0385603309,
-0.751090169,
-0.5162813663,
-0.0332789533,
0.8971472979,
0.6873379946,
0.1454248875,
0.1980686188,
-0.6221516132,
0.1266863793,
0.0820353329,
0.5897305608,
-0.1353234351,
-0.1449770033,
0.1441871822,
-0.166538313,
-0.3247950375,
-1.0308274031,
-0.0441591889,
0.4719204903,
0.5382810235,
-0.0928573608,
0.2621468604,
1.145467639,
-0.5367596745,
1.0437729359,
0.0970716029,
-0.9933620691,
1.1168085337,
-0.2536775172,
0.2754268348,
0.5636553764,
0.1376085132,
-0.1505724639,
-0.4174978435,
-0.4648325741,
-0.7151997089,
0.5768079162,
0.1339625418,
-0.1160020605,
-0.16604954,
0.8474194407,
0.2330782861,
0.3949582279,
-0.558784306,
-0.2106986344,
-0.0576025657,
-0.0749856085,
0.5712683797,
0.0292450059,
0.1468323469,
-0.441347003,
0.5781853795,
-0.4726706147,
0.0249729268,
0.2640655041,
-0.0886262059,
-0.1799828857,
0.1756701469,
0.2641364336,
0.9374549985,
0.0561269484,
0.0363611504,
0.7792494297,
-0.1459353715,
-0.0837137103,
-0.0559286065,
-0.0511889756,
-0.0406472422,
0.2702329755,
0.5475170612,
-0.2539389431,
-0.8037774563,
0.1396435201,
0.1756837517,
-0.1504527628,
-0.2809225023,
0.4554629922,
0.3265825808,
0.3012180924,
0.2137611955,
-0.042824991,
0.1399717182,
-0.652908802,
0.2435381413,
0.413000375,
-0.2025582641,
0.1844436973,
0.7925387621,
0.3214063942,
-0.6033856273,
0.7559188604,
0.0127264541,
-0.2344073057,
0.6149870157,
0.7588789463,
0.6265817285,
-0.0009709965,
-0.1570251435,
0.4281402528,
0.2456322163,
0.0792504773,
0.9006978869,
-0.2529385984,
-0.2634547055,
-0.4827345014,
-0.3794730008,
-0.9083468318,
-0.3278974891,
-0.4948736131,
0.6272280812,
-0.4049118459,
-0.2083327174,
-0.1427365541,
0.0303092711,
-0.156331107,
0.1875994056,
-0.3233224154,
1.2609838247,
-0.2595264912,
0.851205349,
0.8750872016,
-0.3434463441,
-0.4801076353,
-0.3014903665,
0.0737216622,
-0.6222830415,
0.3580132127,
0.2691849172,
-0.1792511642,
0.1262355447,
-0.7849294543,
-0.4454811811,
1.2884052992,
0.3469668329,
-0.6298311949,
0.0198744256,
0.3811491132,
0.5648820996,
-0.4924146831,
0.3753682971,
0.8618682027,
0.6918706298,
0.2818467021,
-0.5786107779,
-0.0164139662,
-0.3011340499,
0.0922353417,
0.2293606997,
-0.3687928617,
0.4877792299,
-0.6908525229,
-0.1072445139,
0.2992223501,
0.7514539957,
0.9396823645,
0.3581843376,
0.5310209394,
0.306196183,
0.9464150667,
-0.4733238816,
0.7453556657,
-0.1234417185,
-0.0935909376,
1.1635235548,
-0.6952383518,
0.9360500574,
0.6153971553,
-0.3322666585,
0.803544879,
0.6861149073,
-0.2732485533,
0.2635288537,
0.6165315509,
-0.4402616024,
-0.4543394744,
-0.1825484186,
-0.2499150336,
0.1050918624,
0.6053932905,
-0.0613081008,
0.0091506522,
-0.1828814894,
-0.1595498919,
0.3959325254,
-0.2965524197,
1.0974988937,
-0.0436300747,
-0.839168787,
0.3957197964,
-0.2087892145,
0.665029645,
-0.5727546811,
-0.5595877171,
-0.1048002094,
0.2194917649,
-0.6906919479,
-1.2015670538,
0.5027039051,
0.1102583408,
-0.1198515147,
-0.1072226986,
1.0735888481,
-0.7279125452,
-0.2307100147,
-0.041709967,
0.3539038301,
0.2265734673,
-0.2284085006,
-0.8283039331,
0.3222718537,
0.0459343567,
-0.1358192563,
0.019163508,
0.7181123495,
-0.0536480658,
0.7991884947,
0.9299116731,
0.2170378566,
0.0801136121,
0.0765020326,
0.8924950361,
-0.7335378528,
-0.358368963,
-0.9239991903,
0.7170447111,
-0.566345036,
-0.0707328916,
0.7601732016,
0.8246073127,
0.4041693509,
-0.154377237,
0.6508613825,
-0.0255781803,
0.7164610028,
-0.6183854342,
0.5939996243,
-0.6949470043,
0.6698009968,
0.0240968093,
-1.0573997498,
-0.2903891504,
0.4535043538,
0.0423687398,
-0.0131651163,
0.7551212311,
1.1273106337,
0.2946552038,
0.1629005969,
-0.0431434922,
0.02429986,
0.3549456,
0.238594085,
1.0251256227,
-0.1199132875,
0.5771781206,
-0.1234710738,
-0.1117902473,
-0.0585021749,
-1.3376539946,
-1.0828832388,
-0.365237236,
-0.4090187252,
-0.5485372543,
0.2567206621,
1.0314751863,
0.5317025781,
-0.6904543638,
-0.2528018653,
-0.3265073001,
0.3443998396,
-0.3238364756,
-0.2761579454,
0.3528033197,
-0.5186250806,
-0.5701873899,
0.6278277636,
0.6385061145,
0.0181611907,
-0.2772161067,
0.1885229051,
-0.1065448746,
0.2791677415,
0.7836444974,
-0.0073545435,
-0.7761098742,
-0.0606917031,
0.0249645002,
0.0622084923,
0.0304943211,
0.8389504552,
-1.0444254875,
0.6306678653,
0.6069767475,
0.3722220361,
0.6521630287,
0.0913868397,
0.7857298851,
-0.7592995167,
-0.1691998541,
0.1432529241,
-0.0238753222,
0.2944211066,
-0.5972816348,
0.7042398453,
0.3686995506,
-0.3932724595,
-0.9465483427,
0.1996326149,
-0.930485189,
-0.2506659627,
0.9764748812,
0.1873833388,
-0.1534629613,
-0.3993060291,
-0.6246143579,
0.0359558836,
-0.1478278786,
0.5416980386,
0.4829602242,
-0.4729238451,
-0.2336778045,
0.066891484,
0.690852344,
0.1525077373,
-1.4140359163,
0.3161154389,
0.4969244599,
0.2423677593,
-0.1444075555,
0.6317270398,
-0.235176295,
0.3776240349,
0.1228091121,
-0.2129924744,
-0.430521518,
-0.3288960457,
0.0390519798,
0.0152699333,
0.1487921625,
0.434759438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12692v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12692v3
|
FormulaReasoning: A Dataset for Formula-Based Numerical Reasoning
| 2024-02-20T03:39:49 | 2024-06-12T13:19:55 |
Xiao Li, Bolin Zhu, Sichen Liu, Yin Zhu, Yiwei Liu, Gong Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The application of formulas is a fundamental ability of humans when
addressing numerical reasoning problems. However, existing numerical reasoning
datasets seldom explicitly indicate the formulas employed during the reasoning
steps. To bridge this gap, we construct a dataset for formula-based numerical
reasoning called FormulaReasoning, which consists of 5,420 reasoning-based
questions. We employ it to conduct evaluations of LLMs with size ranging from
7B to over 100B parameters utilizing zero-shot and few-shot chain-of-thought
methods, and we further explore using retrieval-augmented LLMs provided with an
external formula database associated with our dataset. We also experiment with
supervised methods where we divide the reasoning process into formula
generation, parameter extraction, and numerical calculation, and perform data
augmentation. Our empirical findings underscore the significant potential for
improvement in existing models when applied to our complex, formula-driven
FormulaReasoning.
|
[
-0.2282660306,
-0.6488300562,
0.6940354705,
0.6126806736,
-0.0332097635,
0.2603290677,
-0.0255922116,
-0.2160252035,
0.0298635717,
0.5350737572,
-0.8014130592,
-0.4782883227,
-0.2711810172,
0.4436987936,
-0.3276565671,
0.8370084763,
-0.4544280469,
0.3979539275,
-0.7049052119,
0.0809520632,
-0.4598406255,
-0.4754786193,
-0.1326379925,
-0.3799450994,
0.6123015881,
0.6144581437,
0.2289330363,
0.7386648655,
0.8344984651,
0.1342573911,
-0.1705517769,
0.4332282543,
-0.6319780946,
0.1294795424,
0.1615286916,
-0.8422228098,
-0.2941806018,
0.2805950046,
0.704087317,
0.9174971581,
-0.1801389605,
0.3659670949,
-0.5569577813,
0.8169585466,
-0.8366842866,
0.3406920135,
-0.454318881,
0.2610220611,
-0.1169564947,
-0.2957521081,
-0.3962932229,
-0.6491875052,
-0.0756222531,
-0.7001966834,
0.2941764593,
0.2618790865,
0.2534846663,
0.3264144957,
-0.1742739379,
-0.5143417716,
-0.5960748196,
0.7800403833,
-0.5097429156,
0.2975823283,
0.4962422848,
0.2608048022,
-0.2843563259,
-0.69456321,
-0.2638968527,
-0.4055608511,
-0.2098661512,
0.1779378951,
0.051371526,
-0.0804452822,
0.9405284524,
0.2022313029,
-0.5132321119,
-0.360597223,
-0.7157484293,
-0.1963466406,
0.7961558104,
0.5053932071,
0.2073776871,
-0.0849365145,
-0.3112131059,
0.1051441804,
-1.0520117283,
0.0107719693,
0.2162922323,
0.3596098721,
0.0007884544,
0.7594942451,
-0.4486164451,
0.8344596028,
-0.207906127,
-0.0886589736,
-0.0351647995,
-0.5437820554,
-0.2378215194,
0.3178775609,
0.5018756986,
0.2338721454,
0.3332213461,
-0.2614062428,
0.0251865182,
-0.1609357893,
0.1628156453,
-1.1287549734,
-0.1333599985,
0.0959225446,
0.0881488398,
-0.4281276464,
0.1017774716,
-0.4586252272,
-0.2263151109,
-0.5092625618,
0.0999562293,
-0.1943691522,
0.34123227,
0.1863627285,
-0.3551925123,
-0.0929443762,
0.5886554718,
-0.8111405373,
0.3270713985,
0.8142964244,
0.8699368238,
-0.1298689991,
-0.036083743,
-0.4528609216,
0.1108190268,
-0.5905942321,
1.1014704704,
-0.6816136837,
-0.5435205698,
-0.3732376397,
-0.2136780024,
-0.0849627033,
-0.7889285684,
0.5300317407,
-0.5651814342,
-0.1211818084,
-0.6343380809,
-0.7899916768,
-0.0611294769,
0.301560998,
-0.8921024203,
0.905154109,
-0.0414887331,
-0.4442507625,
0.3954034448,
-0.8976715207,
-0.4086068869,
0.1189457923,
-0.0952678323,
-0.4536280334,
0.2922129035,
0.3327188194,
0.1515674293,
-0.5002291799,
0.0388390236,
-0.5108354688,
-0.531386435,
0.3536549211,
-0.4307883382,
0.7538061738,
0.2360994369,
0.1780619621,
-0.1881023496,
-0.6903198361,
0.3050534725,
-0.0433600992,
-0.1115180925,
-0.0095322952,
-0.2196646184,
-0.5807235241,
0.1179633811,
0.2213025391,
-0.5842989087,
0.2437784225,
-0.1022896245,
0.2480154037,
0.4298289418,
0.2142873406,
0.5110920668,
-0.4621998072,
0.8889621496,
0.0654117987,
-0.1222674847,
-0.1984308213,
-0.303152144,
-0.5559324026,
-0.199782759,
0.3394410908,
0.608365953,
-0.3216756284,
-0.135050714,
0.1273580492,
-0.3797586858,
-0.206805855,
0.3147600889,
0.3898182511,
0.7841235399,
0.3999664485,
0.6606963277,
-0.7283061147,
-0.7714233398,
-0.2136538327,
-0.1127314568,
-0.0522994623,
0.4523778558,
0.6111952066,
0.2746400237,
0.8872591257,
-0.9472689629,
-0.0870716348,
-0.1933478415,
0.264811188,
0.2554209232,
0.1011440977,
0.2884058654,
-0.5469169617,
-0.5240264535,
-0.1241555586,
-1.0732997656,
-0.3393006325,
-0.0900800526,
-0.4184237719,
-0.1272770464,
0.6266065836,
-0.4511293769,
0.447660923,
0.0900663212,
0.0046352465,
0.7475460172,
-0.0438983105,
0.0779163167,
-0.7752774954,
-0.0334059894,
0.3318718374,
-0.0389527343,
-0.492341727,
0.0719830021,
0.0936416686,
0.1775538176,
-0.6076484323,
0.5819197893,
-0.5277559161,
-0.0506916903,
0.0533995181,
-0.1234627143,
0.1722856909,
0.1530970186,
0.1074632108,
1.2112666368,
0.2399468124,
-0.3507483304,
0.6839725375,
0.2150175571,
-0.2985340655,
0.4929906726,
-0.7380118966,
-0.008616291,
-0.2596746087,
0.3493186533,
-0.6702475548,
-0.3851416707,
0.0530166328,
-0.1343068331,
-0.1205155402,
-0.2269961238,
-0.569953382,
-0.4543653727,
-0.3493861854,
0.5583093166,
0.2935073376,
-0.5344726443,
0.382135272,
0.1194082424,
-0.3485394716,
-0.3929598629,
-0.4038178623,
-0.1799194068,
-0.3665706217,
-0.6221088767,
0.1950854063,
-0.2325554788,
-0.4869301319,
-0.1609660983,
-0.2659421563,
-0.1929308027,
-0.1938617826,
0.176823929,
0.404215306,
-0.1812779754,
0.1749532074,
0.1574068367,
-0.0949858651,
0.4511651993,
0.0946658701,
0.0314635746,
-0.1675852686,
-0.2593901157,
-0.3002506495,
0.3273004293,
0.3093823493,
-0.0315858983,
0.5244060755,
0.0491803065,
-0.5728751421,
-0.4064279199,
-0.3115465045,
-0.2074383199,
-0.4109270573,
0.1403446645,
-0.5364466906,
-0.7184798717,
0.6277889013,
-0.0500411056,
-0.00190463,
0.4043901861,
0.6921001077,
-0.449871093,
1.234931469,
0.127100125,
0.2659224272,
0.154606998,
-0.36559394,
-0.0612610616,
-0.7918983698,
-0.6592965126,
-0.3895328343,
-0.200812608,
-0.1337391734,
-0.5458341241,
0.4152195752,
0.3585905135,
-0.2727009952,
0.180773735,
-0.3992570639,
0.8103989363,
0.3246860802,
0.3370704353,
0.5848509669,
0.1539306492,
-0.1638268232,
-0.2168883532,
-0.5962931514,
-0.2820369601,
1.1311609745,
0.14960967,
0.9242181778,
0.0605347939,
0.5038456917,
0.2697975039,
0.9262412786,
-0.9051447511,
0.518320024,
-0.0159639325,
-0.6987152696,
-0.2636541724,
-0.9407773614,
-0.3874667287,
0.1063134372,
0.0517617166,
-0.477362901,
-0.197302863,
0.0469864272,
-0.412592113,
-0.0036040053,
-0.6780902743,
0.5991748571,
-0.3846566975,
-0.3343354166,
0.0655724034,
-0.2732783556,
0.5501018763,
-0.3334052265,
-0.0649916083,
-0.2079933137,
0.2046828568,
0.7183389068,
-0.9663204551,
0.6352633834,
0.0224161763,
-0.1712548137,
0.5908537507,
-0.0066850837,
0.3062678277,
0.2812071741,
-0.2556149662,
-0.1929065436,
0.2155331224,
-0.3894340694,
-1.133685708,
0.5789946914,
-0.2772783041,
-0.5670872927,
-0.500941813,
-0.9148420691,
-0.3140359223,
0.0412608013,
0.0545595922,
0.3486398757,
-0.0330339372,
0.15011172,
0.4696316719,
0.4061329067,
0.1379673779,
0.5057758689,
-0.097689569,
-0.4789395928,
0.8771178722,
0.2601681054,
0.1892065555,
0.3862397671,
0.2481265515,
-0.7289017439,
-0.3378050029,
-0.4561589062,
0.4176809192,
-0.5145285726,
-0.4406391382,
-0.2130635977,
-0.3191747069,
-0.0187182147,
-0.0875691846,
-0.0616139285,
-0.5528358817,
-0.3949213624,
-0.3506720364,
0.7185301781,
0.6738430858,
-0.0464327708,
0.0343968719,
-0.6104707718,
0.3221188784,
0.317140311,
0.4597438574,
-0.144186303,
-0.4066545367,
-0.1770015806,
0.4423043132,
-0.1602164507,
-0.6557571888,
0.3131281435,
0.0433997251,
0.4443668425,
0.2357041538,
-0.0258905161,
1.0826416016,
-0.5689367056,
0.2569449842,
0.1156315804,
-0.6843745112,
0.5031716228,
-0.2470066398,
0.067940779,
0.4702424705,
0.458296895,
-0.2510535717,
-0.0163303223,
-0.4420791566,
-0.1822887808,
0.5925242305,
0.319422543,
-0.0811757073,
-0.061202459,
0.8401670456,
-0.151557073,
0.1158966124,
-0.1197928786,
-0.1226860955,
0.0592158958,
-0.2111086547,
0.2159653902,
0.0137511268,
-0.2809399366,
-0.6026650071,
0.4514980316,
-0.3163960576,
0.0253982227,
-0.0125250649,
-0.1134526283,
-0.176594466,
-0.0468915999,
0.9165725112,
0.6392444372,
-0.4858797491,
-0.0280881766,
0.3920286596,
-0.5650062561,
0.1926899403,
0.1995177418,
-0.2956608534,
-0.1103761122,
0.2664160132,
0.5973803997,
0.1592280567,
-0.917301774,
0.2364896685,
-0.0375732481,
-0.5466294289,
-0.3671202362,
0.263430953,
0.1735704094,
0.0665271729,
0.3752169609,
-0.2280159891,
0.1847129911,
-0.3504474461,
0.3920945525,
0.3948245943,
-0.3409326673,
-0.1873940974,
0.7192376852,
-0.2450091392,
-0.1464734823,
0.7268684506,
-0.1692977399,
-0.3476421237,
1.0172380209,
0.7037057281,
0.3493507802,
0.2814641595,
0.3503307998,
0.3861714005,
-0.0541522317,
-0.3599925637,
0.5521873832,
-0.047899954,
-0.606174171,
-0.6735745072,
-0.6307020187,
-0.8430240154,
-0.1384342015,
-0.8371121883,
0.2466504425,
-0.5746417642,
-0.114369154,
0.2112104744,
0.1502988338,
-0.5254766941,
0.1705214232,
-0.1251234114,
1.1285723448,
-0.7134146094,
0.1460239142,
0.6323673129,
-0.7014274001,
-0.7686739564,
-0.317438364,
-0.0639695227,
-0.7770165801,
1.017577529,
0.0829322562,
-0.126188755,
-0.0735947341,
-0.8711081743,
-0.6642789841,
1.0472365618,
0.3958834708,
-0.3323828578,
-0.0817336962,
0.553175211,
0.5438166857,
-0.5384632945,
0.3422782719,
0.7591949701,
0.436116308,
0.7508057356,
-0.4919312596,
0.0466841385,
-0.2916094363,
-0.1927614361,
0.1881644726,
-0.4925139844,
0.6132278442,
-0.648031652,
0.0824766755,
0.2367514968,
0.5008947849,
0.9072317481,
0.4990064204,
0.0557525307,
0.6840592623,
0.8253936172,
-0.2126167417,
0.9925034642,
-0.0461768173,
0.3544729352,
0.9618313909,
-0.3527332246,
0.7802800536,
0.2602953911,
-0.5155332088,
0.4072861075,
0.5329667926,
-0.054885935,
0.3062667847,
0.5851696134,
-0.5194392204,
-0.4806852639,
-0.1736776829,
-0.2016747296,
0.2260188162,
0.6712779999,
-0.3110335171,
-0.4436388016,
-0.4348303974,
-0.0019932825,
-0.1156966388,
-0.4148221612,
0.6705247164,
0.3350375295,
-0.4945423603,
0.4943799078,
-0.1577858627,
-0.0291670561,
-0.2712181807,
-0.4573462307,
-0.375202775,
-0.0945267081,
-0.3785698414,
-0.9207763672,
0.3580776155,
0.2409288585,
-0.3942153752,
-0.1657894254,
0.4250980318,
-0.2554498315,
-1.0957289934,
-0.346398145,
0.618640244,
0.3155158758,
-0.0619204901,
-0.4729163945,
-0.1071046889,
-0.085233435,
0.0621118918,
0.0834380388,
0.5000894666,
-0.3004481494,
0.9078686237,
0.9910088778,
0.169711858,
0.1434487253,
0.376622051,
0.8938359022,
-0.8962253332,
-0.1511722356,
-0.8922501802,
0.2497777939,
-0.1589437276,
-0.2055844367,
0.7176793814,
0.8373800516,
0.4277959764,
0.0593557209,
0.7466616631,
0.6142048836,
0.6705214381,
-0.6912799478,
0.342045635,
-0.3866295815,
0.5398885012,
-0.1347469091,
-0.7767646909,
-0.7355670333,
0.7363422513,
-0.5500519872,
0.0709649101,
0.4720617533,
0.6778581142,
0.0943744332,
0.4591909647,
0.166631937,
0.0225253124,
0.2909385264,
0.3174030781,
0.9224798083,
-0.1559675485,
0.3299694061,
-0.2642205358,
-0.1054766476,
-0.2050092518,
-1.0113914013,
-0.8540449142,
0.0367964096,
-0.1619634628,
-0.3418464363,
0.0437882878,
0.7888323069,
0.583101809,
-0.8060194254,
-0.1217366382,
-0.5228389502,
0.2964980602,
0.0708656535,
-0.2611756325,
0.1651830375,
-0.3236845434,
-0.4561568797,
0.4163166285,
0.2385450155,
0.1099649668,
-0.3971277475,
0.0363255069,
0.2028049827,
0.1947571337,
0.7125953436,
0.5156143308,
-0.3681500852,
0.092862241,
0.4966967404,
0.039103251,
0.1122084409,
0.9112424254,
-0.8089315891,
0.3388463259,
0.5199056864,
0.4965053201,
0.6904879808,
0.4837802947,
0.6503184438,
-0.662579,
-0.0938264057,
0.2654911876,
0.2827887535,
0.0828446224,
-0.3139775097,
0.5196316838,
0.3729785979,
-0.2466296256,
-0.9473641515,
0.1458501667,
-0.8499054313,
0.0740353093,
0.9412081242,
0.1451343447,
-0.2636542618,
0.1620328873,
-0.0638407245,
-0.1593013853,
-0.5040653944,
0.6200640202,
0.7842284441,
-0.7161467671,
-0.2319775671,
-0.5720687509,
0.4880008996,
0.2075551897,
-1.2478108406,
0.0924783647,
0.6168437004,
0.2800861597,
0.0312794894,
0.4930965006,
-0.2363927215,
0.3446476758,
0.0411799476,
-0.479246974,
-0.2269320637,
-0.4959596992,
0.0139456391,
0.1457442641,
-0.2948744595,
0.2643184066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12691v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12691v2
|
Tree-Planted Transformers: Unidirectional Transformer Language Models with Implicit Syntactic Supervision
| 2024-02-20T03:37:24 | 2024-06-06T13:16:16 |
Ryo Yoshida, Taiga Someya, Yohei Oseki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Syntactic Language Models (SLMs) can be trained efficiently to reach
relatively high performance; however, they have trouble with inference
efficiency due to the explicit generation of syntactic structures. In this
paper, we propose a new method dubbed tree-planting: instead of explicitly
generating syntactic structures, we "plant" trees into attention weights of
unidirectional Transformer LMs to implicitly reflect syntactic structures of
natural language. Specifically, unidirectional Transformer LMs trained with
tree-planting will be called Tree-Planted Transformers (TPT), which inherit the
training efficiency from SLMs without changing the inference efficiency of
their underlying Transformer LMs. Targeted syntactic evaluations on the
SyntaxGym benchmark demonstrated that TPTs, despite the lack of explicit
generation of syntactic structures, significantly outperformed not only vanilla
Transformer LMs but also various SLMs that generate hundreds of syntactic
structures in parallel. This result suggests that TPTs can learn human-like
syntactic knowledge as data-efficiently as SLMs while maintaining the modeling
space of Transformer LMs unchanged.
|
[
0.0264244415,
-0.6394069791,
0.4938908815,
0.384074986,
-0.173332423,
0.3899047077,
-0.3690878749,
-0.3319696486,
-0.0021785581,
0.4885449409,
-0.5122644901,
-0.5720900893,
-0.5740128756,
0.0758963227,
-0.5858150125,
0.9524793029,
-0.1204448044,
-0.0734318569,
0.0600472838,
0.0665781349,
-0.0724685416,
-0.079702273,
-0.2202011496,
-0.3327788115,
0.5024171472,
0.1937595159,
0.8208680153,
0.711410284,
0.1182048842,
0.4036155045,
-0.1704375148,
-0.1561824977,
-0.0638439879,
0.000630925,
-0.0975442454,
-0.6257483959,
0.0144374566,
-0.266124934,
0.7882837057,
1.0355157852,
-0.2373265773,
0.1871556193,
0.1757789105,
0.4420790672,
-0.4224938452,
0.4978994429,
-0.7920946479,
0.1381860971,
-0.1079635248,
-0.3361961842,
-0.7635951042,
-0.4688346982,
0.2373303771,
-0.4828096628,
0.4377095103,
-0.0264775883,
0.7276858687,
0.4649241269,
-0.5024384856,
0.2243193388,
-0.8540165424,
0.7789813876,
-0.56859833,
0.2783565819,
-0.1096340194,
0.4849315882,
-0.0990262106,
-0.7880253792,
-0.2620354891,
-0.2017256618,
-0.4734671414,
-0.0357479192,
-0.2881116569,
0.2899924517,
0.3965431452,
0.1137711406,
-0.2333808392,
-0.0613130517,
-0.1247327179,
0.1101530641,
0.1761606485,
-0.2348658293,
0.2782379091,
-0.232180953,
-0.3947860301,
-0.2761461437,
-0.695117712,
0.0036191114,
-0.0427385941,
0.5379312038,
0.166816324,
0.5855192542,
0.0233194511,
0.4654273689,
0.1123052537,
-0.2364631146,
0.1633212715,
-0.4276106656,
-0.3924555779,
0.0696315169,
0.6048237681,
0.1805792451,
0.6965435147,
-0.6919516921,
-0.2241951227,
0.3867456019,
0.4424949586,
-0.5239458084,
-0.1872690469,
-0.1850454807,
-0.1476864517,
-0.4347473085,
-0.1965618581,
-0.7000695467,
-0.0238310676,
-0.136635989,
0.1405082941,
-0.2994027436,
-0.4087412357,
-0.2266743481,
-0.0080671292,
0.1660614461,
0.2603150904,
-1.004566431,
0.491766572,
0.5647627711,
0.7646412253,
0.0717942044,
-0.226884231,
-0.1430204064,
0.5515505075,
-0.2917342782,
0.783656776,
-0.3949922025,
-0.1336822808,
0.3042521477,
0.1019985303,
-0.2869724631,
-0.3003502488,
0.5495371222,
-0.2083231658,
0.3684692383,
0.0162756424,
-0.2041167766,
-0.2611013055,
-0.0075592347,
-0.2927551568,
1.1454812288,
0.488104105,
-0.8925917745,
0.6290038824,
-0.5866759419,
-0.5178329945,
0.2197112888,
-0.3243640661,
-0.4028017223,
0.1258376688,
0.2332323492,
0.2563388348,
-0.159023121,
0.6085836291,
0.0249071326,
-0.039084807,
-0.2067444026,
-0.2402199805,
0.8431272507,
-0.1941388696,
-0.7156479955,
0.2960795462,
-0.3946062326,
0.249848783,
0.1521576494,
-0.1284597069,
-0.3359109461,
0.1481678635,
0.1239136532,
0.155674994,
-0.0324423797,
-0.7046198249,
0.2900393903,
-0.7529870272,
0.5530648232,
0.5777719617,
-0.0547994897,
0.7310669422,
-0.152809307,
0.5755749345,
-0.0250702202,
0.1171029806,
-0.3692694902,
-0.1077372953,
-0.9910721183,
0.0210321937,
0.2010611743,
0.2108253539,
-0.6952729821,
0.4042125344,
-0.2947706282,
-0.3632840812,
-0.42943573,
0.0743105561,
0.6130689383,
0.462621659,
0.3554178178,
-0.1085853651,
-0.618232131,
-0.9223268628,
-0.4277070761,
-0.2451044768,
0.0915611982,
0.1990968734,
0.1228465587,
0.0748381764,
1.0569713116,
-0.4927949607,
-0.3614337444,
-0.4617125094,
0.1899830401,
0.0797003433,
0.4113508761,
0.5849070549,
-0.4490112066,
-0.7912775278,
-0.2189090997,
-0.4789202809,
-0.3325365782,
-0.0235731117,
0.0462829731,
0.4844057262,
0.5208096504,
-1.152171731,
0.0784002542,
0.3129333258,
-0.2847711742,
0.3784254789,
-0.096489884,
-0.561363399,
-1.0932074785,
-0.0282975286,
-0.1962549537,
-0.4451393783,
-0.6433914304,
0.0300087072,
0.1384971589,
0.1059078351,
-0.4435353875,
0.1111366302,
-0.8591938019,
-0.3081046939,
-0.0811749175,
-0.0371810347,
-0.0131338509,
0.931073904,
-0.0438913144,
0.6295024753,
0.6385841966,
-0.2503851652,
0.0022603991,
0.0083725238,
-0.2784001529,
0.1790348589,
-0.5073271394,
0.0216005594,
-0.2471421957,
0.3727271855,
-0.8758835793,
0.0582144894,
0.2571986616,
-0.1283339262,
0.5618153811,
-0.3154452443,
-0.6320472956,
-0.4001272619,
-0.1909179688,
0.1670899987,
0.6521977782,
-0.6719949245,
0.7343993187,
0.2675129473,
0.0257106591,
-0.4086462259,
-0.6354050636,
-0.002774551,
-0.4216612577,
-0.4290315509,
0.3089906275,
0.4006722271,
-0.1526934057,
0.1093309224,
-0.2463586479,
0.2528695762,
0.0502978303,
0.4036909044,
-0.0372186862,
-0.4665432274,
0.3034888804,
-0.0800350159,
-0.1396616548,
0.4083763957,
-0.7956117392,
0.4214850068,
-0.1253885478,
-0.2660794854,
-0.2659313381,
0.1954702586,
0.3431799114,
-0.2460722178,
0.4170340002,
0.0993309617,
-0.2539069653,
-0.4448398352,
-0.3484033942,
-0.1685497463,
-0.4848044813,
0.2322702557,
-0.1343828589,
-0.6533823013,
-0.3874165118,
-0.2990608513,
0.3692194521,
0.582650125,
0.3041258454,
-0.2155066133,
1.238463521,
0.8249027729,
0.003333946,
0.5633271933,
-0.3439612687,
0.0845290348,
-0.5639208555,
-0.2912264168,
-0.6750947237,
-0.298333168,
-0.5735481977,
-0.5011174679,
0.065282777,
0.0635567829,
-0.2856656015,
0.6213344336,
-0.6437059641,
0.3565611839,
0.6169732809,
-0.1354790479,
0.5146420598,
0.1590861529,
-0.231144309,
-0.0078716502,
-0.6790283918,
-0.6704610586,
0.8584878445,
0.3771689832,
0.6864811182,
-0.0177158639,
0.3859853745,
-0.0670866296,
0.6077200174,
-0.7525793314,
0.5329450965,
-0.0919818282,
-0.1773535609,
-0.3587030768,
-0.141932413,
-0.8457459807,
0.1126591638,
0.1316960156,
-0.9347085357,
-0.1278615892,
0.3339426816,
-0.1838793904,
0.379160136,
-1.0050610304,
0.8633180261,
-0.4470612407,
-0.1280245334,
-0.0955844522,
-0.7351518273,
0.2337588817,
-0.0134005584,
-0.1373140663,
-0.091741845,
-0.0128581645,
0.5366525054,
-0.3558908403,
1.0697927475,
-0.5905954838,
-0.0809397399,
0.3043105304,
0.1059251055,
0.6641896963,
-0.2247654498,
0.4178458154,
-0.0701289773,
-0.2013532966,
-0.2162539512,
-0.8280126452,
0.4321784079,
-0.6173735261,
-0.8448914289,
-0.426068753,
-0.7714990973,
-0.3240798116,
0.3991762996,
-0.038560912,
0.0749311745,
-0.1333819777,
0.1593380123,
0.3013235629,
0.1849867851,
0.7411221266,
0.5093716383,
-0.3361749351,
-0.0549846813,
0.4326803386,
0.0713262782,
0.3489351571,
0.6270619035,
0.1943408698,
-0.490706563,
-0.4605782628,
-0.3463130891,
0.2241293788,
-0.2703963816,
-0.3448524177,
-1.0145112276,
-0.2925826013,
-0.0798768699,
0.0880316421,
-0.3509451151,
-0.5683227181,
0.0732926503,
-0.1851653457,
0.4735534787,
0.8607023954,
0.385261178,
0.850812614,
-0.4539532363,
0.091010429,
0.1656409502,
0.3348076344,
-0.0430090092,
-0.2803725898,
-0.0639248341,
0.2186939716,
-0.6248577237,
-0.766851306,
0.4171564579,
0.258240521,
0.2712016702,
0.4711198509,
-0.2256997228,
0.5281873941,
-0.5930228233,
0.3082208335,
0.2360331267,
-0.7368027568,
0.4137561321,
-0.4225678444,
0.4865957499,
0.4577052295,
0.1938235909,
-0.3926211298,
-0.7812085152,
-0.8799988031,
-0.7204546332,
1.0538107157,
0.2080330104,
0.0605642535,
0.0780152604,
-0.0605698042,
-0.0752022639,
0.3130760789,
-0.901663363,
0.0540411398,
-0.3602262735,
-0.2085671723,
-0.3583233356,
-0.2158371657,
-0.0724852085,
-0.2317227721,
0.5310997963,
-0.2311562151,
-0.0213887896,
0.0497027561,
-0.2148384005,
-0.5787472725,
0.4671177268,
0.1066559628,
0.3982219994,
-0.2321400642,
0.6908849478,
0.1205836162,
-0.0701672286,
0.2520626485,
-0.0812766552,
-0.7150529027,
0.1435864419,
0.271753788,
0.8434199691,
0.6057959199,
-0.4070286155,
0.3648605943,
0.192645058,
-0.0786944702,
-0.3938369751,
0.0979122967,
0.4884039164,
0.3054406941,
0.2867268026,
0.2021075487,
-0.2366274148,
-0.4990396202,
0.2459778935,
0.5739089847,
-0.3696094453,
-0.4736521542,
0.5888649225,
0.1383499056,
-0.557824254,
0.559589982,
0.1790709049,
-0.7007061243,
0.5533226132,
0.9064149857,
1.0570441484,
-0.24038966,
0.4281116724,
0.3024499714,
0.4049586356,
-0.1313227266,
-0.000464811,
-0.4333630204,
-0.5614606738,
-0.5254427791,
-0.7032800913,
-0.1629721075,
-0.0907823369,
-0.3383524716,
0.2011265457,
-0.4314607978,
-0.1130100042,
0.0797427744,
-0.16345945,
-0.4309975207,
0.0030244538,
-0.1986248344,
1.0368855,
-1.0287156105,
1.0294085741,
0.6569030881,
-0.2893788517,
-1.032487154,
0.3741686344,
-0.4458491802,
-0.6868094802,
0.6855111718,
0.3823818862,
-0.0948793367,
0.4005385935,
-0.3667801619,
-0.8526269794,
1.0962942839,
0.695648253,
-0.4625520408,
-0.4238216877,
0.474460274,
0.7608317137,
-0.2828335762,
0.4741265774,
0.6296250224,
0.451836884,
0.0966111422,
-0.694496274,
0.0494204722,
-0.1293548197,
0.2093266994,
0.6581034064,
-0.5445294976,
0.4126326442,
-0.2928086221,
-0.7116493583,
-0.1247832105,
0.6211292744,
0.0206238832,
-0.1175126508,
0.9087235332,
0.6489160061,
0.2585493028,
-0.2923022211,
0.945992589,
-0.4058187902,
0.2696172297,
1.1943817139,
-0.0285043512,
0.5879580975,
0.7709710002,
-0.39988029,
0.5129584074,
0.379221946,
-0.0964706466,
0.4816232026,
0.2327929884,
-0.1143098101,
-0.061707966,
-0.8069078326,
-0.034579698,
0.3103763461,
-0.0547000691,
-0.4068727791,
-0.6841088533,
-0.3190205395,
0.0509150364,
0.2744743228,
0.0340679288,
0.7258595228,
0.1881013215,
-1.0314958096,
0.580272913,
0.0258081723,
0.4400970042,
-0.6468072534,
-0.0466306545,
-0.2746577263,
0.211465463,
-0.2684749067,
-0.624098599,
0.516923666,
0.068393454,
-0.0400097296,
-0.8790023327,
0.5315595269,
-0.666680932,
-0.5297908187,
0.6636477709,
0.3572745025,
0.0267892405,
-0.1232778355,
-0.4308022261,
-0.5083379149,
-0.0635214373,
-0.2924668789,
0.0883732289,
0.4338852763,
-0.3110691309,
0.5284646749,
0.4754221141,
0.1842028499,
0.1873045117,
0.4482801855,
0.8451808095,
-0.6434357166,
-0.2433210015,
-0.8632173538,
0.2750319242,
0.1081456169,
0.0397731774,
0.8618645072,
0.6147409081,
0.8194182515,
-0.1047373712,
0.5553043485,
-0.0404898636,
0.4747292995,
-0.249490425,
0.4442875087,
-0.3384139836,
0.0440101959,
-0.2688944936,
-1.1925202608,
-0.0964628235,
0.2784719765,
-0.1384820193,
0.1134177968,
0.9251598716,
0.7728748918,
-0.2321275324,
-0.09221185,
0.0808585286,
0.6419455409,
0.0411733277,
0.7588272095,
0.7724326849,
-0.1619968116,
0.6735521555,
-0.4749563932,
-0.1174861267,
0.2414483279,
-0.8824064136,
-0.8592996597,
-0.3681938648,
-0.1189477444,
0.0933830291,
0.1194654331,
0.8482698202,
0.5226445198,
-0.8084127307,
-0.1765081137,
-0.9351699352,
0.0566101,
-0.1581369489,
-0.2689645588,
0.55209589,
-0.4739387035,
-0.8870851994,
0.5177848935,
0.3383912146,
0.1788950115,
-0.5841980577,
0.0299875084,
-0.3399757147,
-0.3667615354,
0.299177587,
0.1864141673,
-0.8780733943,
-0.2598700225,
-0.0340713002,
-0.2572039664,
0.2978412211,
0.9213836789,
-1.0339916945,
0.2380213737,
0.3885779977,
0.4611744583,
0.5398929715,
0.2360497117,
0.7852370739,
-1.0913830996,
0.2679341733,
0.2842358053,
0.36055848,
0.4365804195,
-0.1792270541,
0.4872637391,
0.1900203824,
-0.1657774299,
-0.8100448251,
0.1447359771,
-0.840931356,
-0.0527199581,
1.2602126598,
-0.077276364,
-0.3139404058,
-0.0910016447,
-0.2106077671,
0.7532278299,
-0.3366203606,
0.7747342587,
0.1937816888,
0.2632771432,
-0.2809253037,
-0.3022819161,
0.6520649791,
0.9777738452,
-0.9060121179,
0.3199145496,
0.1011960506,
0.1851483285,
0.3202239573,
0.5308164954,
-0.0324735492,
-0.0305969883,
-0.1530482918,
0.4038718641,
-0.0103497282,
-0.5288611054,
-0.1383595169,
0.1361107826,
0.2648670971,
-0.0839822292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12690v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12690v2
|
Simpson's Paradox and the Accuracy-Fluency Tradeoff in Translation
| 2024-02-20T03:37:16 | 2024-06-10T05:59:26 |
Zheng Wei Lim, Ekaterina Vylomova, Trevor Cohn, Charles Kemp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A good translation should be faithful to the source and should respect the
norms of the target language. We address a theoretical puzzle about the
relationship between these objectives. On one hand, intuition and some prior
work suggest that accuracy and fluency should trade off against each other, and
that capturing every detail of the source can only be achieved at the cost of
fluency. On the other hand, quality assessment researchers often suggest that
accuracy and fluency are highly correlated and difficult for human raters to
distinguish (Callison-Burch et al., 2007). We show that the tension between
these views is an instance of Simpson's paradox, and that accuracy and fluency
are positively correlated at the level of the corpus but trade off at the level
of individual source segments. We further suggest that the relationship between
accuracy and fluency is best evaluated at the segment (or sentence) level, and
that the trade off between these dimensions has implications both for assessing
translation quality and developing improved MT systems.
|
[
-0.3090044558,
-0.7037736773,
0.701197207,
0.1768484265,
-0.0240770113,
0.0529861152,
-0.0571722426,
-0.5000254512,
0.2585966289,
0.1719529331,
-0.2930296957,
0.3133532405,
-0.9430935383,
0.213293463,
-0.5058961511,
0.900408566,
-0.4281716943,
-0.1009017155,
-0.4970928133,
-0.2898976505,
-0.6523214579,
-0.5204048157,
-0.4260754883,
-0.3003602028,
0.540017724,
0.3050671816,
1.3830498457,
0.4960912764,
0.6869916916,
0.2605760098,
-0.1302375048,
-0.1173960343,
-0.5413247943,
0.2303574681,
-0.2972263396,
-0.5931800008,
-0.2496063709,
0.1506491005,
0.6447933912,
0.8650308251,
-0.1028997004,
0.1094922423,
0.202847451,
0.9429855943,
-0.5433588624,
0.0910304934,
-0.4379099309,
-0.0889562592,
-0.4805977046,
-0.3783414662,
-0.1288010329,
-0.3600764871,
-0.0134139415,
-0.8027659059,
0.2020576,
0.1354086399,
1.2742800713,
0.3963306546,
-0.5053775311,
-0.1913292706,
-0.5767664909,
0.7709533572,
-0.4857524931,
0.0937757418,
0.4981097281,
0.2231090218,
-0.292473644,
-0.5569804311,
-0.6344738603,
0.0480373017,
-0.0261318926,
0.4469003975,
-0.4577975869,
-0.3667252958,
0.372502327,
0.6420505047,
-0.499886632,
-0.3710786402,
-0.3446941972,
-0.1196328998,
0.5156838894,
0.3462174237,
0.41367203,
-0.1209037974,
-0.3675551414,
-0.151669696,
-0.2442681193,
0.4117844105,
0.4184199572,
0.2638775408,
0.2159836888,
0.6398505569,
-0.2169910818,
0.5341793299,
-0.0085367784,
-0.0105390912,
0.3595305085,
-0.6171123981,
0.1143372133,
-0.2477369457,
0.894569695,
0.3916450441,
0.5479473472,
-0.1672435254,
-0.2105861157,
0.1838716418,
0.4326672852,
-0.426515162,
0.1124504805,
0.125629425,
-0.4320499897,
-0.1441658735,
0.4145035744,
-0.5861204863,
0.5121008754,
-0.2697040141,
0.5950681567,
-0.4586110413,
-0.1805283278,
0.3747406602,
-0.2110663801,
-0.3650666773,
0.0928276032,
-0.8513802886,
0.3482426107,
0.6056299806,
0.8449473381,
-0.159042418,
-0.3998961747,
-0.5179338455,
0.2329427749,
-0.6358984113,
0.5836852789,
-0.5632833242,
-0.3959144056,
-0.1237164661,
-0.1292142421,
-0.3423395157,
-0.2803728282,
0.6294125319,
-0.2689358592,
0.2377741635,
-0.4913668931,
-0.7235297561,
-0.2494380474,
-0.0742377713,
-0.5903490782,
0.9760347009,
0.493159771,
-0.5969058871,
0.4106800258,
-0.2434513122,
-0.6213905215,
-0.0668836161,
0.0846885964,
-0.4785078764,
0.4471984804,
-0.0828846395,
0.1692875773,
-0.0656242892,
0.2456622422,
-0.0984793901,
-0.6671031713,
0.8614858389,
-0.4800462723,
0.6388424635,
0.5528233647,
0.0247774795,
-0.4570527971,
-0.4109191298,
0.1368414909,
0.0516130924,
-0.4073878825,
-0.5396809578,
-0.0118470648,
-0.0572862066,
0.1915775687,
0.1868178844,
-0.3187687695,
0.0059247739,
-0.1441997588,
0.2568337023,
0.329459548,
-0.0927068144,
0.4235495031,
-0.6539683938,
0.5323594213,
0.0040459177,
0.2596031129,
0.1756688654,
-0.678716898,
-0.453802526,
-0.1063925624,
0.5332075953,
0.5942149162,
-0.407110244,
0.4117181599,
-0.5320362449,
-0.1573566347,
-0.4843092859,
0.1558063179,
0.3867762089,
0.384971112,
0.2767986655,
-0.9597682953,
-0.0778948739,
-0.6735713482,
-0.7527207732,
-0.2830913663,
0.1612152755,
-0.1295707673,
0.3616356552,
0.1107889414,
0.9544504285,
-0.3537140489,
-0.3031674027,
-0.0770827904,
0.3066664636,
0.2993093431,
0.7469682097,
0.6246406436,
-0.7708392739,
-0.6843068004,
0.0973047316,
-0.4812640548,
-0.2627950609,
-0.225886628,
-0.3207531273,
-0.08886078,
0.3285179734,
-0.5554084778,
0.5289024115,
0.4658993483,
-0.281989634,
0.5112546086,
-0.1031470001,
0.5047835708,
-0.9125300646,
0.3684304953,
-0.3197170496,
-0.3208376765,
-0.6925786138,
0.2389601916,
0.3494326472,
0.2674874365,
-0.3589234948,
0.1913956106,
-0.1889342964,
-0.0341876298,
-0.2499113679,
0.0838010758,
0.4027301669,
0.1930370033,
-0.3002140522,
1.1438301802,
0.0548001304,
-0.4289984703,
0.0782309771,
0.6006419063,
-0.5555446148,
1.0631351471,
-0.381719768,
-0.234604001,
0.1470563561,
0.0615167469,
-0.9153673649,
-0.1256247461,
0.3214256763,
-0.7065611482,
0.4371830523,
-0.0350031815,
-0.5121051073,
-0.3365185261,
0.0567430891,
0.4585120678,
0.6730993986,
0.0639634579,
0.00516778,
0.0567450225,
-0.0981229618,
-0.7564094067,
-1.0817724466,
0.1709803045,
-0.0132535687,
-0.6197901368,
0.1006626561,
-0.0436247177,
-0.3384791911,
0.2403714359,
-0.3451346755,
-0.0932185352,
0.1985442638,
0.1792156249,
-0.0331561528,
-0.2009964883,
-0.1171114817,
0.0771025196,
-0.5077718496,
0.0308151115,
-0.1034675315,
0.0931417942,
0.0060531627,
-0.3658478558,
-0.5446770787,
0.4427236915,
0.3919447064,
0.0393218063,
0.6716330647,
0.4339262545,
0.1330226213,
0.5043464303,
-0.4810613692,
0.1848353595,
-0.4111033678,
0.1977861673,
-0.887871325,
-0.3733514249,
0.5623620152,
0.2182901353,
-0.3747531772,
0.7561990619,
0.2826206982,
-0.262991935,
1.0111768246,
0.3412080407,
-0.0674015656,
0.4613207877,
0.0086410008,
0.3523316979,
-0.87456429,
0.0509073138,
-0.70442307,
-0.2930937409,
-0.3495602906,
-0.0554667525,
0.2240527868,
0.2537628412,
-0.0630669594,
0.5782800913,
-0.128940329,
0.7351713181,
0.6598516703,
-0.1777112037,
0.5855993032,
0.0292343348,
-0.1982109994,
-0.3395692706,
-0.8641093373,
-0.5561745763,
0.9865197539,
0.2313248217,
0.4940374196,
0.2522143722,
0.2840589285,
0.1398522109,
-0.0775174946,
-0.7090851068,
0.1268749982,
-0.0852732807,
-0.8228853345,
-0.2759006321,
-0.6511297226,
-1.2483634949,
0.2632703185,
-0.2800240219,
-0.3870524466,
0.4314665794,
0.0874340162,
-0.1520177871,
0.2826828063,
-0.7064308524,
1.0050843954,
0.0804609731,
-0.3912097812,
-0.1630391032,
-0.8783100247,
0.2142574638,
-0.1132784486,
0.4534221888,
-0.2956875563,
-0.0397433452,
0.4032961428,
-0.3935930729,
0.2405567318,
0.46157673,
0.0754653588,
0.1549221724,
0.7729691863,
0.3442212045,
-0.1936270297,
-0.2045844197,
0.5347476602,
0.4529401064,
-0.8831494451,
-0.6257439256,
0.3155798018,
-0.8085752726,
-0.5194354057,
-0.781498611,
-0.8949741125,
-0.11331743,
0.1484324485,
0.4595418572,
0.3706365526,
-0.333466202,
-0.2086652517,
0.3386731744,
0.0757603198,
0.1433116943,
0.1551122218,
0.039512746,
-0.2143311799,
1.0204404593,
0.1997169256,
1.0055930614,
0.4411326647,
0.0621775798,
-0.0437752157,
-0.5230897665,
-0.4816224575,
0.2126419097,
-0.6579250693,
-0.1399313211,
-0.2740764618,
-0.1444993466,
-0.1567099988,
-0.3294381797,
-0.3382255733,
-0.5859802365,
-0.2605424821,
0.2867622674,
0.0300857276,
0.5382008553,
-0.3379028738,
0.2106584907,
-0.8070018888,
0.0617518462,
0.0763616189,
0.1093970016,
-0.1082784459,
-0.7941522598,
-0.4352867007,
0.2313771695,
-0.4914236665,
-0.586705327,
0.4329820573,
0.0062984945,
0.4982293546,
0.5203894973,
0.0576056987,
0.8768973947,
-0.570818305,
0.8017940521,
0.4512448609,
-1.2598638535,
0.1250964105,
-0.177048251,
0.246559605,
0.7318938971,
0.3006736636,
-0.9441378117,
-0.8411656022,
-0.7354168296,
-0.599126935,
0.5968705416,
0.6855292916,
0.174937427,
-0.0929789171,
0.1572151184,
0.361284256,
0.2232060581,
-0.4907377064,
-0.1109035388,
-0.2275833488,
-0.3462710381,
-0.3039676845,
-0.2415955514,
-0.4600646198,
-0.0748574212,
0.3747344315,
0.1750568449,
0.3401222825,
0.2829688191,
-0.3382073641,
-0.7097745538,
0.3022877574,
0.6913130879,
1.0577278137,
-0.340715766,
0.2242670506,
0.0844931826,
-0.6122456193,
0.1648038179,
-0.3487738669,
-0.2356187105,
0.1510909647,
0.4908672869,
0.5841212273,
0.0898750126,
-0.375870347,
0.8052691817,
0.1990821064,
-0.3169531226,
-0.1149171367,
0.059833277,
-0.1564580649,
0.0815800354,
0.3124701083,
0.7741535306,
0.1061085463,
-0.6333944201,
0.1057045683,
0.4041725099,
-0.1123031899,
-0.2481483221,
0.8099212646,
0.1639184505,
-0.3663039804,
0.4193870425,
-0.0714422762,
-0.6688901186,
0.4751041532,
0.3617523313,
0.4279591143,
-0.1500517428,
0.1560753733,
0.393630296,
0.314915508,
-0.3467031419,
0.0925919637,
0.2271519452,
-0.5373750329,
-0.5692567825,
-0.1369454563,
-0.4511260986,
-0.4023641646,
-1.09539783,
-0.1572422832,
0.2106723636,
-0.2598774433,
-0.2846075892,
-0.063366957,
-0.4662990868,
0.0544331074,
-0.1934240013,
0.5404298902,
-0.7014791965,
0.6391710639,
-0.0445663929,
-0.8040834069,
-0.5476811528,
0.1462765485,
-0.1287891716,
-0.7169914246,
0.4870176911,
-0.0582000017,
0.0527310073,
-0.0474426672,
-0.3531315923,
-0.9359737039,
0.7776425481,
0.3216049969,
-0.5503205061,
0.3790941536,
0.3851544857,
0.5138750672,
0.042837508,
0.1479322761,
0.5544973612,
0.4677327275,
-0.0325071849,
-1.1882385015,
-0.0245148707,
-0.0097346082,
0.1966151893,
0.3538814783,
-0.7438111901,
0.7339818478,
-0.0292587411,
-0.4001538754,
0.3423241079,
0.4347996414,
-0.4029482603,
0.3485562205,
0.3022111356,
0.6245574951,
0.38011989,
-0.2763444781,
1.4458401203,
-0.3210327923,
0.469938904,
0.4916093349,
-0.0366641432,
0.9465313554,
0.8360967636,
-0.5661131144,
0.5497152805,
0.685190618,
0.2069377154,
0.4729290009,
-0.0321180113,
0.051316116,
-0.2831195593,
0.2283713073,
-0.5874953866,
-0.1258894503,
0.2951825559,
-0.1171494573,
0.1709487736,
-0.3284919262,
0.1757011414,
0.4253791571,
0.054300677,
0.3827836812,
0.1860720217,
-0.8291087747,
0.625528574,
-0.1789544225,
0.2399307936,
-0.5332477689,
0.3180672228,
-0.3841781914,
-0.0717408583,
-0.1031367108,
-1.1086447239,
0.5776795745,
-0.470105052,
-0.1466671675,
-0.3050570488,
0.2162342221,
-0.5464943051,
-0.3616554439,
0.0985293686,
0.7181193233,
0.431769371,
0.0241486616,
-0.7040464878,
0.0506844707,
-0.2034643143,
-0.1849613935,
0.2162684351,
0.59200418,
0.3282397687,
0.4916130006,
0.8123562336,
0.3748573363,
0.0216678753,
-0.1745278239,
0.3592592478,
-0.5047622919,
-0.5562614799,
-0.5979926586,
0.3057123721,
-0.1492052823,
-0.4730816782,
0.685116291,
0.3705736101,
1.1310197115,
-0.1497979462,
0.5755006671,
0.0413753688,
0.4937876761,
-0.5412299037,
0.4557082057,
-0.8033043146,
-0.0467545725,
-0.4530155659,
-1.0136129856,
-0.4903035462,
0.9867687821,
-0.3575735688,
-0.1847054362,
1.4155851603,
0.6357449293,
-0.3940457404,
-0.2027673125,
0.5394775271,
-0.0260993224,
-0.046508655,
0.853032887,
0.8625406623,
-0.7687891722,
0.76757586,
0.1372525841,
0.0016202905,
-0.4391311705,
-0.6391924024,
-0.5143844485,
-0.5964605808,
-0.3571963012,
-0.6019765735,
0.1659689546,
0.574452579,
0.3980340362,
-0.5957036018,
-0.464037329,
-0.1131933779,
0.136448428,
-0.9041487575,
-0.1932474822,
0.1505894512,
-0.5484451056,
-0.9156805277,
0.0541283265,
0.2274390608,
0.2605439723,
0.0855423361,
-0.3337679803,
-0.039156802,
0.2830871642,
0.2119499743,
0.4003097117,
-0.7557371855,
-0.3712718189,
-0.218009308,
-0.5027920008,
0.4092905521,
0.8437981606,
-0.4065205753,
0.5924691558,
0.5350949168,
0.69032377,
0.4753567278,
0.1278922558,
0.7925897837,
-0.4916065335,
0.0685817152,
-0.1660789698,
0.2212950885,
0.3095018864,
-0.260548681,
0.6563609838,
0.6809725165,
-0.6731906533,
-0.7469028234,
0.3940036595,
-1.1379592419,
-0.4136479497,
0.9783614874,
-0.196888119,
0.0526258871,
-0.3493851125,
-0.2500228882,
0.2941028476,
-0.3014997542,
0.9453326464,
1.120950222,
0.0560815223,
0.2766696215,
-0.847735405,
0.3126716912,
0.8976091743,
-0.3037697673,
-0.3108027279,
0.1900096089,
0.260237515,
0.3849574029,
0.2980633378,
0.01999918,
0.2718923092,
0.2660399675,
-0.1159358174,
0.0227055699,
0.0229053628,
-0.1173055843,
-0.1296198517,
-0.0090359254,
-0.2827540636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12663v1
|
SoftQE: Learned Representations of Queries Expanded by LLMs
| 2024-02-20T02:23:15 | 2024-02-20T02:23:15 |
Varad Pimpalkhute, John Heyer, Xusen Yin, Sameer Gupta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We investigate the integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into query
encoders to improve dense retrieval without increasing latency and cost, by
circumventing the dependency on LLMs at inference time. SoftQE incorporates
knowledge from LLMs by mapping embeddings of input queries to those of the
LLM-expanded queries. While improvements over various strong baselines on
in-domain MS-MARCO metrics are marginal, SoftQE improves performance by 2.83
absolute percentage points on average on five out-of-domain BEIR tasks.
|
[
-0.3003893495,
-0.7503841519,
0.7126801014,
-0.1202545837,
-0.0014918942,
0.1652022749,
-0.3649893999,
-0.3381794393,
0.1454100311,
0.8464307785,
-0.3460389972,
-0.4879669547,
-0.5166102052,
-0.1046371907,
-0.2888948917,
0.6479126215,
0.1667928398,
0.3588142693,
-0.1391745061,
-0.124493897,
-0.1823541969,
-0.6400621533,
-0.5511929393,
-0.1855086982,
0.5431723595,
0.2938078642,
0.8928601146,
0.0971577317,
0.5808261633,
0.3348125517,
-0.0515744314,
0.4232354164,
-0.7609367967,
0.5145460367,
-0.2630494237,
-1.0659753084,
-0.4272827804,
-0.2558812797,
0.7854067683,
1.1193223,
-0.3767623305,
-0.1523048729,
0.28955549,
0.9110642076,
-0.7239117026,
0.0861422569,
-0.6300638318,
0.0949212313,
-0.1150708199,
-0.0788950175,
-0.3225216568,
-0.5247194767,
0.1361465454,
-0.4073494971,
0.1384041309,
-0.1796952039,
0.3904925585,
0.0752262026,
-0.7177724838,
-0.2701601684,
-0.8345533609,
0.8813625574,
-0.6688312292,
0.8344657421,
-0.0063126581,
0.3449349701,
-0.5062347651,
-0.9891040325,
-0.4129656255,
-0.08738783,
-0.0172271915,
0.1597409397,
0.2369743586,
0.3697296083,
0.3781187236,
0.4695610404,
-0.2767508626,
-0.0314151645,
-0.2340402007,
0.0571978539,
0.8298360109,
0.3246704638,
0.0880171731,
0.1667960584,
-0.0856366903,
0.2342698574,
-0.8554481864,
-0.1169424802,
-0.0906941071,
0.1947327852,
0.4421825409,
0.649992764,
-0.3067080677,
0.6998165846,
-0.0448328331,
-0.2058869302,
0.2227960229,
-0.2422883809,
-0.1692283601,
-0.3582670987,
0.5711117983,
0.0655071363,
0.4187312126,
-0.6518117785,
-0.5492984653,
-0.5317900777,
-0.0789682046,
-0.8956376314,
0.1987518221,
0.2359124869,
-0.4981938004,
0.2853891551,
0.3138114512,
-0.5192044973,
-0.5045828819,
-0.3209424317,
0.4683084786,
-0.4288870394,
-0.3118498325,
0.1986595839,
-0.2610249519,
0.4350241125,
0.2693457007,
-0.6551832557,
0.6738971472,
0.672323823,
0.5849316716,
-0.2369464487,
0.1204953641,
-0.635127902,
0.2635332048,
-0.39767465,
0.8469042778,
-0.5809699297,
-0.5707398057,
0.4008086026,
0.2865817249,
-0.2481837422,
-0.8272689581,
0.5757846236,
-1.0364396572,
0.2193045914,
-0.3072091639,
-1.04912889,
-0.3855721354,
0.0317404568,
-0.7795321345,
1.1507328749,
0.365372777,
-0.1918624938,
0.3948389292,
-0.7638252974,
-0.2107986808,
0.3145626187,
-0.0910709649,
0.0348186009,
0.3287008405,
0.1672979295,
0.5335116386,
-0.3941147029,
0.2456591874,
-0.3333975077,
-0.7114162445,
0.4988156259,
-0.1560756266,
0.7486075759,
0.1974929869,
-0.2134799808,
-0.0529819615,
-0.5809831619,
0.2696818709,
0.2006430477,
-0.7281211019,
-0.5006747246,
0.0938719809,
-0.1498422474,
-0.133987993,
0.3669432998,
-0.3565907478,
0.52835536,
-0.7874786258,
0.3515954018,
0.2891286016,
0.0284237135,
0.8214948773,
-0.1437151283,
0.494859308,
0.1907992512,
0.1496057361,
0.1291050166,
-0.344206363,
-0.7738236785,
-0.1222006977,
0.587385118,
0.7367559671,
-0.9657570124,
0.0517830402,
-0.3178136647,
-0.2772632241,
-0.4849258363,
0.7763371468,
-0.0080516459,
0.0074203084,
0.267803967,
-0.2068185359,
-0.2634700537,
-0.7836774588,
-0.2785199583,
0.155008629,
-0.4135079384,
0.572524488,
0.340436101,
-0.1717997789,
0.5147703886,
-0.5213435888,
-0.1769316047,
-0.2906749249,
-0.157107234,
0.5527850389,
0.3574176133,
0.488240242,
-0.8499851227,
-0.580889523,
-0.3014680743,
-0.7092064023,
-0.0746479705,
0.1806424856,
-0.2405342758,
0.1738692522,
0.6380183101,
-0.7975713015,
0.1587928832,
0.1355759352,
-0.2609746158,
0.309463501,
-0.1114154235,
0.360937506,
-0.9326407313,
-0.4747865498,
-0.1609894335,
-0.213906616,
-0.5177692175,
0.2194999158,
0.2998653054,
-0.0670175552,
-0.5103305578,
0.2901321352,
-0.8861124516,
-0.2590244114,
-0.0410786048,
0.5275141597,
0.2465271354,
0.3964726329,
-0.075094007,
1.0354880095,
0.5813125372,
-0.6890099049,
0.4485467672,
-0.0062315399,
-0.3100647628,
0.5050706863,
-0.8100841045,
0.3539428711,
-0.1793045998,
-0.0560851432,
-1.0721007586,
0.0660037398,
-0.1527235061,
-0.2651075721,
0.5803121924,
-0.3849501312,
-0.7092749476,
-0.2508333921,
-0.4568331838,
0.3056281507,
0.4551292658,
-0.6021447182,
0.8016862869,
0.3208713531,
-0.0851666257,
-0.5564013124,
-0.6349754333,
0.0862560123,
-0.1099805012,
-0.7682094574,
0.6153698564,
-0.020863913,
-0.3567554951,
0.1712605208,
0.4025827348,
-0.3275637925,
-0.0690006316,
-0.0692840293,
0.0011195736,
-0.9057881236,
0.4045433402,
0.1293372214,
0.3708167672,
0.0629973039,
-0.4300529659,
0.4871454537,
-0.1240805984,
-0.4542056918,
-0.0535385609,
0.5809488297,
0.5800634623,
-0.1014936939,
0.9955262542,
0.4045141935,
-0.3517196476,
-0.2455878258,
-0.885708034,
-0.3517169356,
-0.5306579471,
0.373259902,
-0.471501559,
-1.0343663692,
0.5315013528,
-0.3599925637,
-0.1172778234,
0.4195400774,
0.159090668,
-0.166580379,
1.3299823999,
0.6629454494,
0.055825334,
0.5773677826,
-0.3849311173,
-0.2294405699,
-0.981746316,
-0.4386534691,
-0.3887533545,
-0.3159098029,
-0.8079781532,
-0.7801464796,
0.3572197855,
0.2394745648,
-0.3942719102,
-0.0333757773,
-0.2489273399,
0.4840984344,
0.5362751484,
0.4417790174,
0.3258071244,
-0.0236723647,
0.0366380624,
-0.2559362054,
-1.0124477148,
-0.2473507375,
1.3529485464,
0.1377481967,
0.9114995003,
0.4346653521,
0.6074608564,
0.2668489516,
0.2385102808,
-1.1848074198,
0.6500040293,
-0.3666184545,
-0.5589005351,
-0.1885318607,
-0.4471440017,
-1.0689054728,
0.4078347087,
-0.4120569825,
-0.5282984376,
0.3902169764,
-0.3825057447,
-0.248532474,
0.1819537431,
-0.7011210918,
0.423558116,
-0.5461786985,
-0.8064273596,
-0.3285441697,
-0.1098286957,
0.3706010282,
0.116574645,
-0.0734862015,
0.1257220507,
-0.5547056794,
1.017282486,
-0.3881078064,
0.7094754577,
-0.4081804454,
0.0468367487,
0.4746330082,
0.0474931374,
0.6273120046,
0.1084054857,
-0.4459295273,
0.0912396759,
-0.0742236078,
-0.5535101891,
-1.1172311306,
0.5942175388,
-0.5228481293,
-0.9054927826,
-0.1218489707,
-0.4828160107,
-0.5270363092,
0.1566735208,
-0.2241328061,
0.5499045253,
-0.1333506107,
0.5899307728,
1.0471915007,
-0.3182537556,
0.1913658082,
0.9133275151,
-0.189412415,
-0.3297262788,
0.3990998864,
0.4652057588,
0.1686594188,
0.5104316473,
-0.0735436156,
-0.6402663589,
-0.7047559619,
-0.1518152207,
0.4865769446,
-0.787107408,
-0.5117978454,
-0.6410306096,
-0.3988103271,
-0.4797287881,
-0.1170265749,
-0.3675479591,
-0.5824133158,
-0.2431856394,
-0.0718677714,
0.4452495575,
0.8466222286,
0.1499011368,
0.6366686821,
-0.942828238,
0.0508346483,
0.2748729885,
0.515176475,
-0.2607609332,
-0.7675263286,
-0.2955321074,
-0.0468937866,
-0.2863745093,
-1.0291849375,
0.3960415125,
0.422215879,
0.9252224565,
0.4743653536,
-0.0706192181,
0.5878504515,
-0.3699243069,
0.8890589476,
0.0570289083,
-0.7909148932,
0.5897663832,
-0.0995374471,
0.25962767,
0.4833428562,
0.6754474044,
-0.0961629972,
-0.2297560573,
-0.4089939594,
-0.8411496282,
0.2439638674,
-0.2159697115,
0.344132632,
-0.0432000794,
0.8127246499,
-0.0480601043,
0.120845601,
-0.3359610736,
-0.1401319802,
0.3394657671,
-0.1321867704,
0.1148724332,
-0.822268784,
0.1607426554,
-0.3514692783,
0.5446523428,
-0.1732206196,
0.3834171891,
0.1695816219,
-0.3411032856,
0.0617596582,
0.2272856086,
0.0738430023,
0.6508031487,
-0.1737300754,
0.0681084618,
0.5710809231,
-0.2738760114,
-0.2248593718,
0.0164327491,
0.0057517709,
-0.0831678286,
0.2552072406,
0.4357130826,
0.4582139552,
-0.6576890945,
0.4794911146,
-0.0536428057,
-0.1610735208,
-0.3083342314,
0.3110208511,
0.2784866393,
0.5707692504,
0.5660415292,
-0.5688989758,
0.6907434464,
-0.5244265199,
0.284126848,
0.7568730712,
-0.3961176872,
-0.0583578162,
0.626822114,
0.2824194133,
-0.2064308673,
0.8386455178,
0.1761182845,
-0.57289505,
0.4606630206,
0.6195487976,
0.5109531283,
-0.3653897047,
-0.07600528,
0.3937160969,
0.3092710376,
0.0332513936,
0.6485577822,
-0.0511239991,
-0.7886898518,
-0.7403666973,
-0.5491507649,
-0.4704845548,
0.0889053941,
-0.5737463832,
0.3703858256,
-0.1676736921,
-0.3711619675,
-0.3923901021,
0.4223748147,
-0.8546205163,
0.1540119648,
-0.0456740893,
1.1406453848,
-0.366469264,
0.807864368,
0.6046674848,
-0.5714722872,
-0.7188529968,
-0.256131351,
-0.3314645886,
-1.0173120499,
0.8093669415,
-0.1879993826,
-0.1864223033,
-0.0367331654,
-0.6663687229,
-1.0636230707,
1.0889006853,
0.4640245438,
-0.6096305847,
0.191894412,
0.2902075946,
0.4282982647,
-0.4786463082,
0.5972511172,
0.6001370549,
0.3161667883,
-0.0533189364,
-0.6039655209,
0.1724844426,
-0.0682127252,
-0.0283249579,
0.2260807455,
-0.5596381426,
0.4864085019,
-0.3292647898,
-0.142778635,
-0.2315505147,
1.0014407635,
-0.1580038071,
0.2629232705,
0.3876079321,
0.0308596231,
0.9817444086,
-0.0561274961,
1.0694950819,
-0.4047700763,
0.0538550466,
0.9916912913,
-0.2065010071,
1.0009182692,
0.3852844238,
-0.4617282748,
0.6095456481,
0.4230772555,
0.2079175115,
0.2621440291,
0.0263009034,
-0.4395582676,
-0.2964381576,
-0.1552099586,
-0.4705877602,
0.4386178553,
0.9085887671,
-0.4878924191,
0.1465388834,
-0.210577786,
-0.1248809695,
0.1254986972,
-0.2637285292,
1.0462772846,
0.2936620116,
-0.5997686982,
0.7020176649,
-0.170061335,
0.8649430871,
-0.6668459773,
-0.0555915684,
-0.6344999671,
0.1616030037,
-0.2702001333,
-0.8984819055,
0.3282282352,
-0.421805799,
-0.0815439075,
0.0736263096,
1.0892988443,
-0.6221897006,
-0.4816223681,
0.6257249117,
0.9653200507,
0.1780161262,
-0.3002146482,
-0.8256554008,
-0.2056689411,
-0.2981841266,
-0.6690171361,
0.3958333433,
0.8921790719,
0.184005782,
0.6783361435,
0.4176641405,
0.0497065671,
0.211136803,
0.2524026632,
0.9791520834,
-0.9659277797,
0.0981718227,
-0.6073929071,
0.302466929,
-0.1994736344,
0.2637701333,
0.6547186375,
0.7039568424,
0.4478243887,
-0.0429265797,
0.6573569179,
0.2837643325,
0.463106066,
-0.7102284431,
0.6854231954,
-0.8141444921,
0.4768868983,
0.1396080554,
-1.122474432,
-0.2892542779,
0.3610448539,
-0.3724316359,
0.2101158202,
0.6283680201,
0.9936790466,
-0.1282688826,
-0.2173795104,
0.621037364,
0.2424268275,
0.0642423928,
0.7007264495,
0.953202486,
-0.4642496407,
0.5882151127,
-0.1437713355,
-0.229146257,
-0.2535597384,
-0.6084247231,
-0.7081258297,
-0.3638664484,
-0.4366174042,
-0.4345349967,
0.1868624538,
0.7539649606,
0.6063356996,
-0.9126233459,
-0.4319422543,
0.3493043184,
0.4784941375,
-0.1475444883,
-0.3303053677,
0.1642325372,
-0.6904513836,
-0.9308516979,
0.5701932311,
0.1327208281,
-0.1783934385,
-0.2269902974,
-0.0748669058,
-0.1251078844,
0.4216145277,
0.9644112587,
-0.0786717385,
-0.3015551269,
-0.0265796874,
0.3062959313,
-0.0755801052,
0.0568235889,
0.8572461009,
-0.7778155208,
0.0133756427,
0.5669554472,
0.6304538846,
0.6793851852,
-0.2066696584,
0.7480008602,
-0.5163328052,
0.0782917589,
0.306491822,
0.6140536666,
0.3438872695,
-0.6057214737,
0.7722792029,
0.2920440137,
-0.5337917209,
-0.6271091104,
0.0881013721,
-0.8949158192,
-0.3338963985,
1.2904815674,
-0.0713517144,
-0.3877712488,
-0.3047254682,
0.0341318585,
0.1186763421,
-0.3578295708,
0.4037410021,
0.3368328214,
-0.2743453681,
-0.231784001,
-0.8866150975,
0.2324444056,
0.4155131876,
-0.4975573123,
-0.2631354928,
0.5970865488,
0.4574917257,
-0.158706516,
0.7007191181,
-0.3883783817,
-0.0314366817,
-0.1101825386,
-0.123900041,
0.1807332784,
0.0574692748,
0.0088609895,
0.617437005,
0.3849184513,
0.1227003038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12659v2
|
FinBen: A Holistic Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T02:16:16 | 2024-06-19T03:38:56 |
Qianqian Xie, Weiguang Han, Zhengyu Chen, Ruoyu Xiang, Xiao Zhang, Yueru He, Mengxi Xiao, Dong Li, Yongfu Dai, Duanyu Feng, Yijing Xu, Haoqiang Kang, Ziyan Kuang, Chenhan Yuan, Kailai Yang, Zheheng Luo, Tianlin Zhang, Zhiwei Liu, Guojun Xiong, Zhiyang Deng, Yuechen Jiang, Zhiyuan Yao, Haohang Li, Yangyang Yu, Gang Hu, Jiajia Huang, Xiao-Yang Liu, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Benyou Wang, Yanzhao Lai, Hao Wang, Min Peng, Sophia Ananiadou, Jimin Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
LLMs have transformed NLP and shown promise in various fields, yet their
potential in finance is underexplored due to a lack of comprehensive evaluation
benchmarks, the rapid development of LLMs, and the complexity of financial
tasks. In this paper, we introduce FinBen, the first extensive open-source
evaluation benchmark, including 36 datasets spanning 24 financial tasks,
covering seven critical aspects: information extraction (IE), textual analysis,
question answering (QA), text generation, risk management, forecasting, and
decision-making. FinBen offers several key innovations: a broader range of
tasks and datasets, the first evaluation of stock trading, novel agent and
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) evaluation, and three novel open-source
evaluation datasets for text summarization, question answering, and stock
trading. Our evaluation of 15 representative LLMs, including GPT-4, ChatGPT,
and the latest Gemini, reveals several key findings: While LLMs excel in IE and
textual analysis, they struggle with advanced reasoning and complex tasks like
text generation and forecasting. GPT-4 excels in IE and stock trading, while
Gemini is better at text generation and forecasting. Instruction-tuned LLMs
improve textual analysis but offer limited benefits for complex tasks such as
QA. FinBen has been used to host the first financial LLMs shared task at the
FinNLP-AgentScen workshop during IJCAI-2024, attracting 12 teams. Their novel
solutions outperformed GPT-4, showcasing FinBen's potential to drive innovation
in financial LLMs. All datasets, results, and codes are released for the
research community: https://github.com/The-FinAI/PIXIU.
|
[
-0.3384177685,
-0.5210992694,
0.2748818398,
0.4194821119,
-0.0869213715,
0.3955440819,
-0.4550433159,
-0.4764482081,
-0.116573751,
0.5977845788,
-0.3522554338,
-0.7915351391,
-0.3580836356,
-0.1085748672,
-0.5694685578,
1.0017673969,
-0.0527462959,
0.1530471891,
-0.1496861577,
0.0669107288,
-0.0636162981,
-0.3917489648,
-0.9639970064,
-0.3723944724,
0.4611115456,
0.2901778817,
0.435122937,
0.4107129276,
1.0483052731,
0.3079429567,
0.2470929176,
-0.1422509551,
-0.4122690856,
0.026927812,
-0.4555657506,
-0.2576192319,
-0.5929389,
0.1463870704,
0.6344755292,
0.8012464046,
-0.2383447886,
0.4561296403,
-0.0111544505,
0.8907154799,
-0.6803883314,
0.5737522244,
-0.391546756,
-0.1130595356,
-0.631542623,
0.0316108428,
-0.0889793187,
-0.3519806862,
0.0740226954,
-0.4179804921,
-0.0991227031,
0.4480222464,
0.7041182518,
0.1698905081,
-0.2101939917,
-0.2133323252,
-0.4326242805,
0.6043505073,
-0.756532371,
0.3677630424,
0.0404766649,
0.5350333452,
-0.289963603,
-0.8141743541,
-0.238890633,
-0.0746782869,
0.2143346667,
0.2609743178,
-0.4483324885,
0.0303085111,
0.0590515509,
0.4761760533,
-0.3149616718,
0.1898745,
-0.4596084952,
-0.0754376128,
0.6772634387,
0.1022065878,
-0.2304580063,
0.0292482711,
-0.7996706367,
-0.5588470101,
-0.5482560396,
0.0633409545,
0.5702790618,
0.3998828828,
-0.0372677222,
0.478495717,
-0.1519553661,
0.5785787106,
-0.0694224313,
-0.1426783651,
0.3313088715,
-0.1917837262,
-0.348092407,
0.1264729053,
0.8107194304,
0.4907001257,
0.3232989013,
-0.1895494163,
-0.4628031254,
-0.0976086035,
0.0313714035,
-0.4525928497,
-0.0047469088,
0.2118033916,
-0.4088363051,
-0.2501096129,
0.2247155458,
-0.9185847044,
-0.3782688081,
-0.1954026371,
0.1055430397,
-0.2256926298,
-0.2280237824,
0.3809504509,
-0.3391134739,
0.5632371902,
0.0219887141,
-0.8459669352,
0.974345088,
1.2992647886,
0.5695796609,
-0.4493383169,
-0.1846507341,
-0.6757635474,
-0.0645643994,
-0.5046027899,
1.0525596142,
-0.1859275103,
-0.2269544452,
-0.2988314331,
-0.288150847,
-0.0164408814,
-0.6667585373,
0.4396599531,
-0.2307798117,
0.0785178915,
-0.1999892592,
-0.7654678226,
-0.1734439284,
0.1228942052,
-0.6619482636,
1.2566099167,
0.3054126501,
-0.7482069731,
0.2825727761,
-0.9695214629,
-0.1461825818,
0.0945362821,
-0.2245318443,
-0.2523959875,
-0.0985938981,
-0.1766019464,
0.5477016568,
-1.0011589527,
0.5050040483,
-0.4420111775,
-0.4657661617,
0.3766173124,
-0.4322185516,
0.2420217544,
0.0398115069,
-0.5620055795,
0.3135649264,
-0.8565628529,
0.0832698718,
0.208710283,
0.0211859122,
-0.350138545,
-0.2167761922,
0.410816431,
0.0572294854,
0.5526815057,
-0.552277267,
-0.2444924265,
-0.7482488155,
0.254850477,
0.968223691,
-0.1418348104,
0.096073851,
-0.4804760218,
0.4220517874,
-0.3339474499,
0.1147416383,
0.0005270455,
-0.0846731588,
-0.4969767034,
-0.1761273444,
0.4322372675,
0.5709987283,
-0.3197245598,
0.2620022297,
-0.1988769025,
-0.6608793736,
-0.188093394,
0.5179289579,
0.4706954658,
0.1777802557,
-0.0060455194,
-0.2394201159,
-0.2633740306,
-1.2717324495,
-0.4118809104,
-0.1729598641,
-0.0599747412,
-0.0601424798,
0.4008091986,
0.1221702024,
0.727170825,
-0.3494756222,
-0.0983230099,
-0.2837315202,
0.1566420496,
0.5510056615,
0.2684607506,
0.7434194684,
-0.7275327444,
-0.2747960091,
0.1550682932,
-0.4450614452,
-0.2028827071,
-0.1532594711,
-0.4437654018,
0.0842321962,
0.5274217129,
-0.2139426917,
0.0784545839,
0.5321955681,
-0.4356938303,
0.2813690901,
-0.0475142188,
-0.1788138598,
-0.9209942818,
0.5712832808,
0.0367092453,
-0.4142439067,
-0.1983399093,
-0.0645608976,
-0.0000809422,
0.1349972785,
-0.2025046051,
1.0322231054,
-0.1670386791,
-0.769528687,
-0.3061222136,
0.6104650497,
-0.121083267,
0.5394847989,
-0.3532431126,
0.8429752588,
0.2104922086,
-0.2108734101,
0.6400344968,
0.1190623865,
-0.5326356888,
0.6201059222,
-0.6090934873,
-0.0919724107,
0.2023311108,
-0.1234342977,
-0.9082073569,
0.0000889687,
0.3759721816,
0.0424976051,
0.0970019624,
0.5948311687,
-0.6601426601,
-0.383715719,
-0.3657370508,
-0.114125967,
0.1822018623,
-0.4257380366,
0.5204992294,
0.2264178842,
-0.6465645432,
-0.8011670709,
-0.367340982,
0.185292393,
-0.1271795928,
-0.3820706904,
0.4174921215,
-0.0407858938,
-0.7309812903,
0.1255110204,
-0.6190584898,
0.2421014458,
0.4490211606,
0.1682836115,
0.7476252913,
-0.268044591,
0.2055228502,
0.0532903485,
-0.5105185509,
0.0325170755,
-0.322976321,
0.4176760316,
-0.7983294725,
-0.4098492563,
0.1701727211,
0.0280039683,
0.3452135623,
-0.2706564665,
0.3216581047,
0.5307405591,
-0.2366949618,
-0.0759734362,
-0.727342546,
0.2348856032,
-0.4716661572,
0.0786594898,
-0.1711019874,
-0.9960650802,
0.5303826928,
-0.5946851373,
0.6324462295,
0.8298716545,
0.5598799586,
0.0619662814,
0.1474950463,
0.7636289001,
-0.0199524797,
0.4216893017,
-0.0209905189,
-0.0321495645,
-0.4564138949,
-0.1110593453,
-0.3467374444,
-0.4316269755,
-0.3299658298,
-0.3803238869,
0.3353537917,
0.2319438308,
-0.3594642878,
0.1875411272,
0.0365251116,
0.4627794325,
0.6047925353,
-0.1852919459,
0.384001404,
-0.2066594958,
-0.4601401985,
0.1699861437,
-0.4908716679,
-0.5645750165,
1.4189091921,
0.3902778924,
0.6687041521,
-0.2347578406,
0.5518189073,
0.485113889,
0.7336778641,
-0.4751342535,
0.5385298133,
-0.3624708354,
-0.5883380771,
-0.3351136446,
-0.4300200343,
-0.5925855041,
0.1547842622,
-0.1695226431,
-0.6479892135,
0.0387554206,
-0.3084330261,
-0.5310877562,
0.1478145868,
-0.3196389973,
0.9360157847,
-0.7534937263,
-0.5756205916,
-0.14665097,
-0.5679472685,
0.42411834,
-0.6432484388,
0.4475527406,
-0.6316916943,
-0.2976764143,
0.8700501919,
-0.2481479943,
0.7071508765,
0.0241918303,
-0.3344474137,
0.0934625119,
-0.2318794429,
0.2978201807,
-0.0926581249,
-0.3075383008,
0.2683783472,
0.2523759902,
-0.3285852671,
-0.5932651758,
0.6550292969,
-0.3436212838,
-0.4448846579,
-0.3978491724,
-0.2885577381,
-0.4302197397,
0.2644096017,
-0.2947998047,
0.1546373069,
-0.5531736016,
0.3398369849,
0.2088863105,
-0.1591280699,
0.4598186612,
0.630102396,
-0.6883049607,
-0.6793376207,
0.7744748592,
-0.3102037311,
0.1024731696,
0.295871824,
0.2154249549,
-0.3997327983,
-0.2338689268,
-0.2728095353,
0.2118988782,
-0.9853743315,
-0.3964748979,
-0.2392334938,
-0.1384655386,
-0.1283115149,
-0.2143972814,
-0.7616344094,
-0.4045269191,
0.3161747158,
-0.4416595399,
0.5343198776,
0.7682614923,
-0.3830029666,
0.1847969294,
-0.6921954155,
0.2716666758,
0.0389944725,
0.8728483915,
-0.044090312,
0.2525602281,
-0.3393799663,
-0.3552069962,
0.0394176878,
-0.2587595582,
0.1393200606,
0.0508158952,
0.7308276892,
0.615504384,
0.1324137449,
0.3321878016,
-0.0022598426,
0.2823982537,
0.2423270494,
-0.9795087576,
0.1871820986,
-0.327840507,
0.1275649965,
0.7549436688,
0.1060462371,
-0.6566418409,
-0.346968323,
-0.4600966871,
-0.9864526987,
0.4220638573,
0.1815240979,
-0.2124287784,
0.1031570211,
0.4554075897,
0.6354916096,
0.6848818064,
-0.4360763729,
-0.2778810263,
0.03381918,
-0.26421386,
-0.2658044696,
-0.0351799168,
-0.0642291456,
-0.0914931893,
0.5780882835,
-0.2065546215,
-0.1218633354,
-0.1158623546,
0.3493149281,
0.0033564565,
0.2766235471,
0.2204364389,
0.6626297832,
-0.342756182,
-0.0503108874,
0.1583494097,
-0.1625026166,
-0.0369047485,
0.5181667209,
0.2295820266,
-0.0436035767,
0.3881091475,
0.6911933422,
1.0428594351,
-1.1152935028,
0.4507857561,
-0.0363045409,
-0.31792593,
-0.5853002667,
0.1725934595,
0.1420773715,
0.7416059375,
0.504209578,
0.0008987846,
0.0991300419,
-0.4992018342,
0.283095777,
0.2665909827,
-0.2050817609,
0.1564972848,
0.6837506294,
0.1625383794,
0.1908353269,
0.3775608838,
0.1799683869,
-0.3087588251,
0.4181850553,
0.1847482771,
0.963758707,
0.070384562,
0.1412146986,
-0.0128407897,
0.2338087112,
-0.3925142586,
0.5489178896,
-0.1529451162,
-0.5719951987,
-0.2515561879,
-1.0642212629,
-0.8306335807,
-0.038244918,
-0.7807244062,
0.2421534657,
-0.6978345513,
-0.4286575913,
0.212764591,
0.2979516387,
-0.6980203986,
-0.1101093143,
0.1190158427,
1.2157533169,
-0.2608859539,
0.3840478957,
0.4855880439,
-0.0392470099,
-0.1942293644,
-0.3099084795,
-0.0116920825,
-0.7030745149,
0.5178000927,
0.0225834437,
-0.261388123,
-0.0289789289,
-0.4023590386,
-0.8730770946,
1.0753775835,
0.5565456152,
-0.9179865718,
-0.1362189054,
0.2159181237,
0.4253333509,
-0.3339335918,
0.0260543525,
0.7639108896,
0.9461792707,
0.062231306,
-0.934281826,
-0.1927227825,
-0.6002779007,
-0.1087760031,
0.209349975,
-0.814843595,
0.8267351389,
0.0630793348,
-0.2201928496,
0.1267892271,
0.4772500098,
0.1104692817,
0.5050486922,
0.4352097213,
0.1097803563,
0.9008601904,
-0.3058274984,
1.1572641134,
-0.8225083351,
0.2447434515,
1.1678338051,
-0.5769572258,
1.1422848701,
0.2191203833,
-0.2562014759,
0.3610043228,
0.6504253149,
-0.2995374501,
0.1124864742,
0.5346562862,
-0.1424693167,
-0.423925519,
0.0966786668,
-0.2647310197,
0.5622444749,
0.4363744259,
-0.1479589939,
-0.3619959354,
0.0777212381,
-0.0221572593,
0.1812567115,
-0.2600013614,
0.706143558,
0.3533694744,
-0.2730505764,
0.0631076172,
0.4341808558,
0.6519422531,
-0.9922457933,
0.2055541277,
-0.2079930454,
0.3835398257,
0.211384207,
-0.6142472625,
0.3134484589,
0.1177659556,
0.2236395329,
-0.4521738589,
0.8469443917,
-0.1006110534,
-0.738517642,
0.5614730716,
0.7505761385,
0.1233791113,
-0.2446065843,
-0.5636282563,
-0.0265221559,
-0.4926300049,
-0.4465921223,
0.2580038011,
0.3833264709,
0.0303051416,
0.6827617884,
0.9276814461,
-0.167186141,
-0.3291379809,
-0.0635920838,
0.8765668273,
-1.0812921524,
-0.3937474191,
-0.8287988305,
-0.1006060243,
-0.2143644542,
-0.3930906951,
0.8117589355,
0.9019721746,
0.8281476498,
0.1964005679,
0.7685895562,
0.4698408544,
0.5067010522,
-0.481456399,
0.7016305327,
-0.4103010297,
0.2844755054,
-0.4299108088,
-1.0064564943,
-0.199194625,
0.4303962588,
-0.4153098464,
-0.1738017797,
0.5910368562,
0.179846406,
0.1953025013,
0.3365712166,
0.3929338157,
-0.0602226853,
-0.0544046946,
0.4091791213,
0.5413483381,
-0.2575493455,
0.4259549677,
-0.1780606359,
-0.1075160354,
-0.2527679503,
-0.8407584429,
-0.9007059932,
-0.3647630811,
-0.1865351349,
0.0642084405,
0.180020839,
1.1975427866,
0.0760672316,
-0.6907954216,
-0.720282495,
0.1644161642,
0.066482313,
-0.4993358552,
-0.1583722085,
0.286444664,
-0.2082292289,
-0.5750222802,
0.4488841593,
0.8528729081,
0.1330584884,
-0.5802408457,
0.1934029311,
0.1681736261,
0.1564273983,
0.4038562775,
0.0931581035,
-0.4047234654,
0.0364430062,
0.0408501476,
-0.1670942456,
-0.0321620926,
0.7668787241,
-0.3539831042,
0.0828665048,
0.1552913636,
0.7590779066,
0.5897337198,
-0.0956060067,
0.8666989803,
-0.2697956562,
-0.0221641902,
-0.0058140196,
0.3259902596,
0.020733228,
0.0120785125,
0.9215404987,
0.0956627503,
-0.0214024,
-0.5102002025,
-0.4621115625,
-0.8903706074,
-0.3001400828,
0.7795387506,
-0.2319214493,
-0.5755236149,
0.0401849523,
-0.0379989594,
-0.0954308361,
-0.4330330193,
0.4977689385,
0.9333776832,
0.166878134,
0.0073501389,
-0.8849523664,
0.3356238604,
0.169517681,
-0.9044123888,
0.3039777577,
0.2335881442,
0.1773594022,
-0.0546714626,
0.6461247802,
-0.1178426594,
0.3285080791,
0.2180354446,
0.2276409417,
-0.2566292882,
-0.1900561154,
-0.0552531369,
0.2280159742,
-0.0308308378,
0.2232098132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12654v2
|
OWSM-CTC: An Open Encoder-Only Speech Foundation Model for Speech Recognition, Translation, and Language Identification
| 2024-02-20T02:04:38 | 2024-06-16T20:58:43 |
Yifan Peng, Yui Sudo, Muhammad Shakeel, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
There has been an increasing interest in large speech models that can perform
multiple tasks in a single model. Such models usually adopt an encoder-decoder
or decoder-only architecture due to their popularity and good performance in
many domains. However, autoregressive models can be slower during inference
compared to non-autoregressive models and also have potential risks of
hallucination. Though prior studies observed promising results of
non-autoregressive models for certain tasks at small scales, it remains unclear
if they can be scaled to speech-to-text generation in diverse languages and
tasks. Inspired by the Open Whisper-style Speech Model (OWSM) project, we
propose OWSM-CTC, a novel encoder-only speech foundation model based on
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC). It is trained on 180k hours of
public audio data for multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR), speech
translation (ST), and language identification (LID). Compared to
encoder-decoder OWSM, our OWSM-CTC achieves competitive results on ASR and up
to 24% relative improvement on ST, while it is more robust and 3 to 4 times
faster for inference. OWSM-CTC also improves the long-form ASR result with 20x
speed-up. We will publicly release our code, pre-trained model, and training
logs to promote open science in speech foundation models.
|
[
-0.232663393,
-0.7184978127,
0.2004162073,
0.1438323706,
-0.2557226121,
-0.1860810667,
-0.2701726556,
-0.6268623471,
-0.0372383893,
0.3873989284,
-0.4700109065,
-0.4754578173,
-0.7025381923,
0.2595658898,
-0.7394399047,
0.6242159605,
0.2428551316,
-0.0165085737,
0.0500090718,
-0.2101169825,
0.0316156037,
-0.5683470964,
-0.7287347913,
-0.0372084379,
0.2140671909,
-0.002072999,
0.5467792749,
0.900079608,
0.3295478523,
0.3224321306,
-0.2102109641,
-0.0308485702,
-0.3505396247,
-0.0239199512,
0.1883139461,
-0.4063705802,
-0.2072828114,
-0.1200954765,
0.7195367217,
0.8652360439,
-0.4804374278,
0.0545873977,
0.131139338,
0.441075474,
-0.7534719706,
0.252799809,
-0.6222555637,
0.0028344565,
-0.2374170423,
-0.0690522566,
-0.5422826409,
-0.3952185512,
0.3378672004,
-0.2336578071,
0.2616117597,
-0.1356363147,
0.4465373456,
0.1671391129,
-0.558146894,
-0.218288064,
-0.800008893,
0.728969276,
-0.7230123281,
0.8078962564,
0.2082990855,
0.3038884997,
0.0409394354,
-0.6251126528,
-0.4345473051,
-0.1721431166,
0.1797780842,
0.0059063677,
-0.2651899457,
0.1867462397,
0.1261437982,
0.2373251617,
-0.7090910673,
0.1418627053,
-0.3358511925,
-0.2509897053,
0.3761058748,
0.0844881684,
0.0888880938,
0.2307983935,
-0.4271386862,
0.00991836,
-0.599065423,
0.1236049682,
0.1138112918,
0.5715797544,
-0.4611515105,
0.4689871371,
-0.2871889472,
0.7439826131,
-0.079333283,
-0.0730105266,
0.2620224357,
-0.124636136,
-0.2253727317,
0.4500273168,
0.9295563102,
-0.2542744875,
-0.050607793,
-0.3801746666,
-0.2132009119,
0.4155596495,
-0.0279485788,
-0.8450658917,
-0.0573784038,
0.1175406799,
-0.7087743878,
-0.2481529117,
0.1618513763,
-0.5121319294,
0.1175368652,
-0.2899417281,
0.5391556025,
-0.1364916116,
-0.3807660043,
0.2038744241,
0.0585945137,
0.1127090007,
0.3164706528,
-0.5901290774,
0.3425069749,
0.3698720038,
1.1204464436,
-0.3467736542,
-0.2304926515,
-0.6052706242,
0.1251168549,
-0.3736052513,
0.5894304514,
-0.5448388457,
-0.5885241628,
0.0416960604,
0.0428578071,
-0.1683552265,
-0.2173061371,
0.3147825301,
-0.3917689323,
0.0403043441,
0.1110757217,
-0.2710030377,
0.1499281675,
-0.1836390048,
-0.7335717678,
0.7045100927,
-0.1567672491,
-0.7015259862,
0.026488876,
-0.8652917743,
-0.5280441642,
-0.1472831666,
-0.108776316,
-0.2540283799,
0.0760370493,
0.1910526156,
0.2033726573,
-0.4699128568,
0.310223937,
-0.2939834893,
-0.2526655495,
0.2682262957,
-0.6585495472,
0.9887530804,
0.6600117087,
-0.3471858501,
0.04462732,
-0.8605371118,
-0.0074280798,
0.0583902262,
-0.4786229432,
-0.1547807008,
-0.0356010273,
0.1199992821,
0.2851959169,
0.2308168113,
-0.8792783618,
-0.2255302519,
-0.5410708189,
0.7526451349,
0.6141361594,
-0.2245256603,
0.3321432769,
-0.2590003312,
0.2741184235,
0.0741989687,
0.1109448746,
-0.1766429245,
-0.5272428393,
-0.7293023467,
-0.3496949673,
0.2785585821,
0.434265554,
-0.6342045069,
0.5632148981,
-0.3205898702,
-0.6377508044,
-0.7152236104,
-0.4658704996,
0.4882673621,
0.5134205818,
0.4098315537,
-0.1889612526,
-0.5050293207,
-0.6851145029,
-0.1853024811,
-0.2252007574,
-0.19747518,
0.0282729696,
0.4356374741,
-0.0944734737,
0.9610006809,
-0.2636226714,
-0.3137675524,
-0.1426303983,
0.2906826437,
0.056178499,
0.5094078779,
0.3791325688,
-0.6811159849,
-0.3152004182,
-0.0250392705,
-0.4386092424,
-0.3468559682,
0.2503153682,
0.0836908966,
0.3335413933,
0.4290379882,
-0.5012740493,
0.5087489486,
0.7542212605,
-0.1550025344,
0.3780502677,
-0.086427711,
0.258680433,
-1.0177158117,
0.2593587637,
-0.2311306745,
-0.0894479007,
-0.622068882,
-0.0037522537,
-0.0654504746,
-0.5249639153,
-0.5522787571,
0.4631365538,
-0.3664208353,
0.0737162083,
-0.1600310951,
0.0891989395,
-0.3000608981,
0.5288777947,
0.481293112,
0.7196367979,
0.6524603963,
-0.8413969278,
0.0650521815,
0.34354949,
-0.2654324472,
0.306258738,
-0.6506846547,
0.3026748896,
0.0045497203,
0.2493649125,
-0.6837443113,
0.135928914,
-0.2841452658,
-0.670873642,
0.1212503538,
-0.0405224077,
-0.4274501503,
-0.3434330225,
0.1049816161,
0.2286709547,
0.4960211515,
-0.8686072826,
0.7884252071,
0.5500496626,
0.0357955098,
-0.3751598895,
-0.955373466,
-0.2489358038,
0.0711980164,
-0.5799281597,
0.4385287762,
-0.1942671537,
0.0343110301,
-0.0341457501,
-0.2517570257,
-0.2929454744,
-0.1037989482,
0.2527228594,
-0.0006064342,
-0.4126904309,
0.0905312374,
-0.0107749291,
-0.1240729019,
-0.0296746362,
-0.3727595508,
0.3776437044,
-0.1509345472,
-0.4114253521,
-0.6760265231,
0.7121204138,
0.5856162906,
-0.5044303536,
0.6960965991,
0.4078323543,
-0.5296632051,
-0.0765412822,
-0.5762912035,
-0.2629659772,
-0.455927968,
0.2571008503,
-0.5110827088,
-1.0282918215,
0.3072257936,
-0.008454321,
0.3332533538,
0.4622285366,
0.5409358144,
0.1474520266,
1.3064986467,
0.6669232845,
-0.3454045951,
0.5102473497,
-0.1219963059,
0.0893368796,
-0.4162388146,
-0.257327497,
-1.1322802305,
0.0409305058,
-0.4669614732,
-0.3876891136,
0.3544791341,
-0.0788347721,
-0.2710083425,
0.5482231975,
-0.4336999059,
-0.0142661417,
0.3052950501,
-0.0384500138,
0.3926180601,
0.0054492899,
-0.2127108127,
0.2215633988,
-0.6883916855,
-0.3743538857,
1.0337131023,
0.2664507926,
0.8083834052,
0.248234868,
0.5909919143,
0.2562201321,
0.0838264599,
-0.5749723315,
0.4701693058,
-0.4220387638,
-0.5320774317,
-0.28170228,
-0.6424661279,
-0.8539123535,
0.3786840737,
-0.1604309529,
-0.7225803137,
0.2945046425,
0.3084714115,
-0.1902016401,
0.3889641762,
-0.4985999465,
0.6768550277,
-0.0635742545,
0.0205177106,
-0.2417990863,
-0.7172496915,
-0.090050973,
0.0776705146,
0.2982367873,
-0.0210917424,
-0.1023249924,
0.7610800266,
-0.4835732877,
0.7536147833,
-0.3064877093,
0.0273784604,
0.567435205,
0.0994441584,
0.6052804589,
-0.2836269438,
-0.1430422217,
0.5502648354,
0.0870470852,
-0.0823953152,
-0.4206068814,
0.6064878106,
-0.764574945,
-0.3742043078,
-0.1369500905,
-0.1632421166,
-0.3217838109,
0.0414645486,
0.3761748374,
0.7272959352,
-0.4269957542,
0.6047458649,
0.6607729197,
0.2771622837,
0.5635664463,
0.8052999973,
0.1872325987,
-0.4415779412,
0.7630512714,
-0.0478754714,
0.4100392461,
0.7321752906,
0.2830603719,
-0.3962110877,
-0.6069095731,
-0.2685805857,
0.0963289738,
-0.481197685,
-0.1150002107,
-1.0599588156,
-0.3958559334,
-0.646492064,
-0.1327441931,
-0.6782979369,
-0.4440176487,
-0.4659835994,
0.1432501525,
0.2159507573,
0.3658670783,
-0.1957224011,
0.4069115222,
-0.8741479516,
0.3836720586,
0.3087633848,
0.0892220587,
-0.0963029861,
-0.6718247533,
-0.1488373578,
0.2214062512,
-0.1450642347,
-0.7645552754,
0.3380959928,
0.439365983,
0.5131736398,
0.6069399714,
0.2270805687,
0.7338974476,
-0.383271724,
0.6873386502,
0.4342458844,
-1.0710560083,
0.5051786304,
-0.1185608283,
0.538110137,
0.2695228755,
0.2259721905,
-0.5187109113,
-0.4667780995,
-0.3680076599,
-0.5347552299,
0.7744800448,
0.3876340091,
-0.1189882755,
-0.1639690697,
-0.1252540648,
0.1601561308,
0.3051228821,
-0.4779748023,
-0.0351435281,
-0.4325951338,
-0.3815875351,
0.0488185659,
-0.0796261951,
0.0777549893,
0.0492860638,
0.6892384887,
-0.3362318873,
0.5441240072,
0.4062052667,
-0.1484026313,
-0.1295993775,
0.4563183188,
0.3589704633,
0.1582794487,
-0.0355072133,
0.0572799556,
0.161328882,
-0.4671381116,
-0.0329886228,
0.2124018967,
0.0772625878,
0.0168677103,
0.3878710568,
0.9109294415,
0.2441132069,
-0.6756104231,
0.5575606823,
0.0204358846,
-0.2126794606,
-0.3432817161,
-0.0299302619,
0.0243432987,
0.1247397065,
0.3602821827,
0.1806902438,
0.2584934533,
-0.4153332412,
0.0650992319,
0.3994562328,
-0.6015618443,
-0.4427326322,
0.8569799662,
0.4784785807,
-0.2049873173,
0.59634763,
0.2261319458,
-0.2953634262,
0.7404333353,
0.7415543795,
1.0678714514,
-0.6691506505,
-0.2493231744,
0.4236197472,
0.3403937817,
-0.1613863558,
0.3146978915,
-0.4448809326,
-0.5302543044,
-0.0457445048,
-0.7951590419,
-0.0692392439,
0.0570825078,
-0.8728707433,
0.2426066697,
-0.0568842366,
-0.2935734093,
-0.2277412266,
-0.3505899906,
-0.6298915744,
0.1912715733,
0.0761858672,
1.0980417728,
-0.7427925467,
1.1689804792,
0.2641818523,
0.0399934798,
-0.5124640465,
-0.1265808344,
0.1595113575,
-0.568644166,
0.3931123614,
0.3152130544,
-0.6159781814,
0.2979021966,
-0.3419318795,
-0.9606173038,
1.0365487337,
0.3420316875,
-0.8560412526,
-0.3565048873,
0.1252031475,
0.4882584214,
-0.6756311655,
-0.0467242226,
0.3400851786,
0.164455995,
0.1747478545,
-1.3236500025,
-0.1940943003,
-0.0725188479,
0.238007322,
0.2680463493,
-0.4696072042,
0.8404833078,
-0.5157577991,
-0.5160717368,
0.4453212321,
0.6676040292,
0.1657897532,
0.0312006958,
0.6755168438,
0.4708791971,
0.2883817852,
-0.1362121105,
0.6130689979,
-0.3063004613,
0.234236151,
1.1377570629,
-0.1481810063,
1.0853797197,
0.3506139517,
-0.1793987155,
0.2409102917,
0.3471443951,
0.1552484781,
0.876437068,
-0.1066503674,
-0.2454494238,
-0.3449269831,
-0.2449546009,
-0.5265801549,
0.6265437007,
0.4230206907,
-0.504473567,
-0.1198123395,
0.2493866384,
-0.1934795082,
0.0478340872,
-0.3489652574,
0.8237939477,
0.1964610368,
-0.2853232622,
0.440972954,
0.0176965762,
0.6997365355,
-0.9747523069,
-0.0507424213,
0.2807024419,
0.0631343499,
0.009920028,
-0.3036468029,
0.3399173915,
-0.0547752269,
-0.0616782568,
-0.086542733,
0.5033992529,
-0.7007138133,
-0.2148033231,
0.4854516685,
0.2781452537,
0.096076861,
-0.1658551097,
-0.5081213713,
0.1857888252,
-0.1511950791,
-0.0704819784,
0.09615428,
0.2733842731,
0.1048708186,
0.6416172981,
0.8401311636,
0.0036747023,
0.1429038942,
0.146765843,
0.5752798915,
-0.5256407857,
-0.9432483912,
-0.5482723117,
0.2820543349,
0.202588588,
-0.2492710948,
0.2582027018,
0.6700012088,
0.7881330848,
-0.1878183931,
0.7249907851,
-0.101328738,
0.5537165999,
-0.5281396508,
0.8788709641,
-0.5848106742,
-0.1850927919,
-0.0192814041,
-0.4878346622,
-0.0060093617,
0.4953761697,
0.1613537371,
-0.0420441628,
0.8383005857,
0.7351391315,
0.2496403158,
0.5206597447,
0.5164443254,
0.258515954,
0.2630809546,
0.5834340453,
0.55823493,
-0.3168140352,
0.9448525906,
-0.4065481424,
-0.2042865902,
-0.169407472,
-0.6125734448,
-0.936658442,
-0.9511575103,
-0.3696064651,
-0.1128266901,
0.1389467269,
1.0300523043,
0.9041397572,
-0.8671225309,
-0.3114287257,
-0.0964456201,
-0.34006235,
-0.4972603321,
-0.2058235109,
0.3022376001,
-0.0498420671,
-0.7199652791,
0.6960853934,
0.2925573885,
0.1403198838,
-0.2038120627,
0.0130567187,
0.0672062114,
0.1400554776,
0.5691004395,
0.2736735046,
-0.9247793555,
-0.1693980247,
-0.066222325,
-0.1828237921,
0.0732141882,
1.0908505917,
-0.7099946737,
0.6851628423,
0.4033438861,
0.4377723634,
0.4613998532,
-0.4406943917,
0.5184797645,
-0.404650867,
0.3071290851,
0.3867263198,
0.4380565584,
0.0980974361,
-0.2323428541,
0.301194489,
0.2467097342,
-0.3138673007,
-0.7824395299,
0.2409367561,
-0.8849968314,
-0.1590366215,
0.7850116491,
-0.1992241442,
-0.372890383,
-0.2270362973,
0.0410825424,
0.4603773952,
-0.7410115004,
0.5938427448,
0.2973606884,
-0.0024231698,
0.0507227927,
-0.3304427266,
0.318015784,
-0.1811530888,
-0.8001953363,
0.2499906272,
0.3022005856,
0.2800019681,
0.0858270675,
0.6978235841,
-0.5035879016,
0.30559057,
0.1868991554,
0.1005521566,
-0.223622486,
-0.4989425838,
-0.338278383,
0.3936517239,
-0.1269107759,
-0.4036288559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14850v1
|
CHATATC: Large Language Model-Driven Conversational Agents for Supporting Strategic Air Traffic Flow Management
| 2024-02-20T01:59:11 | 2024-02-20T01:59:11 |
Sinan Abdulhak, Wayne Hubbard, Karthik Gopalakrishnan, Max Z. Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) and large language models (LLMs) have
gained rapid popularity through publicly available tools such as ChatGPT. The
adoption of LLMs for personal and professional use is fueled by the natural
interactions between human users and computer applications such as ChatGPT,
along with powerful summarization and text generation capabilities. Given the
widespread use of such generative AI tools, in this work we investigate how
these tools can be deployed in a non-safety critical, strategic traffic flow
management setting. Specifically, we train an LLM, CHATATC, based on a large
historical data set of Ground Delay Program (GDP) issuances, spanning 2000-2023
and consisting of over 80,000 GDP implementations, revisions, and
cancellations. We test the query and response capabilities of CHATATC,
documenting successes (e.g., providing correct GDP rates, durations, and
reason) and shortcomings (e.g,. superlative questions). We also detail the
design of a graphical user interface for future users to interact and
collaborate with the CHATATC conversational agent.
|
[
-0.4515866041,
-1.0591572523,
0.5356470942,
0.5203266144,
-0.1184095517,
0.5507884026,
-0.2376339734,
-0.236188367,
0.1317342371,
0.5634145141,
-0.5859128833,
-0.4478515983,
-0.4125936627,
-0.1467934698,
-0.685328722,
0.947511971,
0.0171487443,
-0.3119730055,
-0.1198072881,
-0.0055245915,
-0.5366420746,
-0.8641459346,
-0.9640133977,
-0.3322235942,
0.410828948,
0.5197632313,
1.2060339451,
0.0904234499,
0.7117865682,
0.353759557,
-0.0455237813,
0.2623320222,
-0.570694983,
0.1228408664,
-0.0360522568,
-0.1543275267,
-0.3890630603,
-0.0316478908,
0.6865775585,
0.5535935163,
-0.6321545243,
-0.3828550875,
-0.0851428285,
0.4819304049,
-0.2049210817,
0.500415206,
-0.7084603906,
-0.2643117309,
-0.1000602916,
-0.4029628932,
-0.3040857315,
-0.3316173851,
0.3124300539,
-0.6031112671,
-0.1056523547,
0.1024607345,
0.8654437065,
0.3402450383,
-0.6007971168,
-0.5037083626,
-0.770124495,
0.4669159055,
-0.5351422429,
0.152997151,
0.1160105765,
0.5734342933,
-0.5348579884,
-0.6726257801,
-0.4781593978,
-0.4864074588,
0.1851981133,
0.4535399377,
0.0023353205,
0.3106071651,
0.0909020528,
0.1573300213,
-0.9440663457,
0.1125731692,
-0.262219429,
-0.0260845199,
0.6752656102,
0.6301014423,
0.1308516264,
0.2563174665,
-0.3237220943,
-0.0168238394,
-0.7686009407,
-0.2061136663,
0.2609561682,
0.2144898027,
-0.3797576725,
0.5254459977,
-0.321742028,
0.6041838527,
-0.4511058033,
0.0850797594,
0.1303458065,
0.014853782,
-0.3655940592,
-0.2351551652,
0.7985355258,
0.0538337156,
0.5506443977,
-0.3532985151,
-0.141052559,
-0.163506344,
0.3869136274,
-0.7955527902,
-0.3339065015,
0.2146900296,
-0.2387205511,
-0.4247397184,
0.0913926736,
-0.7035956383,
-0.289988935,
-0.5396588445,
0.0665369332,
-0.3987045884,
-0.3912484646,
0.0090203658,
0.0635815337,
0.6543629766,
0.6087106466,
-0.6920565963,
0.0654020458,
0.7520897388,
1.110408783,
-0.1040608287,
-0.3753956854,
-0.3928068876,
0.0047802147,
-0.5714084506,
0.9544681907,
-0.6760471463,
-0.7674499154,
0.0990982801,
0.0009177298,
-0.2230195552,
-0.5147429705,
0.3224587739,
-0.7884234786,
-0.1168398261,
0.2054683566,
-0.337161392,
-0.1014938205,
0.3569846749,
-0.3835544586,
0.7079414129,
0.1438110471,
-0.3432085514,
0.0494190343,
-0.7855459452,
-0.5593267679,
0.2896641493,
-0.3088032007,
-0.4366072714,
-0.2636659145,
0.1141066179,
0.3554208279,
-0.33022964,
0.3359389603,
-0.0071275146,
-0.2056254148,
0.3173559904,
-0.6300587058,
0.6174302101,
0.537042439,
-0.1362611204,
0.3906543553,
-0.3622119725,
0.1011116579,
0.0978114456,
-0.4994455874,
0.4282114506,
0.213610962,
0.2666197717,
0.195749402,
-0.0512329862,
0.037205644,
0.0824136063,
-0.1993536949,
0.6354491115,
0.8514485359,
0.2019166648,
-0.0245929025,
-0.5367409587,
0.7203866839,
-0.0427077599,
0.0013442261,
-0.1272152662,
-0.8229926229,
-0.7918738127,
0.0348910429,
-0.0277418736,
0.6793956161,
-0.8165450692,
0.1695330292,
-0.4359832406,
-0.7300588489,
0.111058943,
-0.0648683831,
-0.2716213763,
0.4731027484,
-0.0735870823,
0.1051835194,
-0.3452096283,
-0.5266487598,
0.1344924122,
-0.7503204346,
0.0079587875,
0.4208179712,
0.2936656177,
-0.2445231378,
0.7591056228,
-0.4671983719,
-0.0113904364,
-0.5270718932,
0.581710577,
-0.0548433214,
0.316519767,
0.4572871327,
-0.751670301,
-0.3478376865,
0.000263789,
-0.5951054692,
-0.1274768561,
-0.3690088093,
-0.4236498773,
0.2778181732,
0.657091558,
-0.6392667294,
0.3565587401,
0.6415170431,
-0.3066504598,
0.5403315425,
-0.1937735826,
0.2609955668,
-0.7655206919,
0.1154487655,
-0.2543893754,
-0.3744746149,
-0.687910378,
-0.019599637,
-0.3300296366,
-0.6250631809,
-0.622847259,
0.3027675748,
-0.0396155603,
0.1200518161,
-0.3174665868,
0.1183584705,
-0.3328101635,
0.5408455729,
0.3672867417,
1.1448225975,
0.7147907615,
-0.6693021655,
0.3145039082,
0.3815732896,
-0.1362697035,
0.6641317606,
-0.6091558337,
0.2834449112,
-0.2054313272,
0.1886036098,
-0.9703227878,
-0.392965436,
0.0820344016,
-0.284270376,
-0.2104825675,
-0.2512846589,
-0.4708760679,
-0.1897500753,
0.2981739938,
0.0507015251,
0.8377987146,
-0.4445616603,
0.8684664369,
0.5231506228,
-0.1462729722,
0.1698813587,
-0.60661906,
0.6156425476,
-0.3372794986,
-0.8856137991,
-0.1091741249,
-0.0759779885,
-0.2487389892,
-0.3400480151,
0.2230745405,
-0.173833847,
0.4044099748,
0.5910804272,
0.274391979,
-0.1769540161,
0.1583895832,
-0.6160862446,
-0.0896578655,
0.2321144491,
-0.2449236214,
0.704577744,
-0.4781561792,
-0.580552876,
-0.38033548,
0.4099451602,
0.7492385507,
-0.3099434078,
0.8390427828,
0.5302550793,
-0.0211064927,
0.0846844986,
-0.5281062126,
0.0593653396,
-0.5030073524,
0.3083737791,
-0.2693665922,
-0.7941536307,
0.4556937814,
-0.3086104989,
0.2427816391,
0.1956636608,
0.8382400274,
-0.0750884861,
1.0422927141,
0.4083549082,
-0.2937504053,
0.5529914498,
-0.3824632168,
0.1956859231,
-0.2803313434,
-0.5546087623,
-0.3728307784,
-0.1393664777,
-0.6528856754,
-0.4142337143,
0.4781837463,
-0.3186357915,
-0.3577570617,
-0.1306435764,
0.0322758257,
0.2890087962,
0.4789908528,
-0.0699316189,
0.2238339186,
-0.0067520435,
0.4284263253,
0.5098467469,
-0.6636983156,
-0.628510654,
0.8318439722,
0.229231894,
1.1041969061,
0.3107440174,
0.2500120699,
0.3133146763,
0.3531219661,
-0.912039876,
0.8268733621,
-0.010191842,
-0.3514419198,
-0.1750074476,
-0.6302119493,
-1.0742279291,
0.0395599753,
0.036123544,
-0.5208835602,
-0.3328799605,
0.1878490895,
-0.3152919114,
0.3059474528,
-0.8721378446,
0.7499905229,
-0.4569938779,
-0.0349495672,
-0.4650032222,
-0.519779563,
-0.0216081776,
0.0116222082,
-0.1491122544,
-0.3780098259,
0.006935332,
0.5287510753,
-0.6587085724,
0.5422774553,
-0.004643837,
0.102002129,
0.7072603106,
0.1614888459,
0.7337250113,
0.0255563706,
-0.0016781666,
0.4407666028,
-0.3404266834,
-0.3878760934,
-0.5274336934,
0.5938318372,
-0.8553869724,
-0.7539772987,
-0.3146314025,
-0.487436831,
-0.4211216569,
-0.0280874353,
-0.2913743258,
0.4301296473,
-0.3867196143,
0.1660004854,
0.2606455386,
-0.0847666189,
0.4442097545,
0.6034940481,
-0.1361475289,
-0.0263855532,
0.7874863148,
-0.1528622806,
0.4314205348,
0.2638991475,
0.1186233163,
-0.3039874434,
-0.6932905912,
-0.3712983429,
-0.112819396,
-0.3506606221,
-0.0207436476,
-0.650537014,
-0.7040576339,
-0.2374849319,
-0.2335199267,
-0.1259865314,
-0.06290555,
-0.2343503833,
-0.0655849501,
0.5786144137,
0.5866504312,
0.0847824439,
0.8530993462,
-0.3723632395,
0.1470510662,
0.3415549695,
0.1936843246,
-0.0492637679,
-0.3199888766,
-0.2577992976,
0.0120007228,
-0.5774297118,
-0.5934032798,
0.4238525629,
0.1994811743,
0.4943727553,
0.4309572577,
-0.1710681915,
0.7547895312,
-0.3014693856,
0.9182327986,
-0.1662955284,
-0.5735390186,
0.5917944312,
-0.4541001618,
0.3085836768,
0.2474557608,
0.0251048394,
-0.8786770701,
-0.7156512141,
-0.5370015502,
-0.7203081846,
0.7321266532,
0.623521924,
0.1700446308,
-0.0796546191,
-0.084995091,
-0.4330364466,
0.3001910448,
-0.0751732215,
0.0224940963,
-0.3567271829,
-0.1617084891,
-0.019019939,
0.0194763597,
-0.0048651649,
0.5293878317,
0.7924447656,
-0.2469905168,
0.144248873,
-0.0402335897,
0.0924284533,
0.2520698607,
0.404066205,
0.4814173281,
0.842633605,
-0.1396225989,
0.0265909545,
0.0283693224,
-0.4314412773,
0.0932891518,
0.0799063966,
-0.0840962604,
-0.184659034,
0.186199531,
0.6762247682,
-0.2100096792,
-1.0999640226,
0.3236608803,
0.0156494156,
-0.1721760184,
-0.4930116534,
0.0664747134,
-0.1056545302,
0.2169401348,
0.116445452,
-0.0816248581,
0.0311794598,
-0.34454,
0.0976203084,
0.6217814684,
-0.1868426055,
-0.0546371974,
0.8705996871,
0.5057515502,
-0.2649303973,
0.9966616631,
-0.2198146135,
-0.6243981123,
0.7316684127,
0.0443780534,
0.8519569039,
0.0440643802,
0.4144461751,
-0.0071804887,
0.2663569152,
-0.0382035263,
0.3371816874,
0.2122644633,
-0.5156701207,
-0.4187404215,
-0.093306981,
-0.6341189146,
0.3564550281,
-0.1592764407,
0.2499174923,
-0.5015045404,
-0.2736736536,
-0.3666763902,
-0.0202453453,
-0.8828547597,
-0.117580615,
0.2586380541,
0.86776191,
-0.6907438636,
0.3879035115,
0.6749363542,
-0.458545953,
-1.0929303169,
0.1302691102,
0.2900189757,
-1.0194647312,
0.5636313558,
0.0382308774,
-0.1364455223,
0.0485274084,
-0.3468264937,
-0.6595125794,
0.9851003885,
0.0408753268,
-0.3764288723,
0.018464312,
0.575538516,
0.5755620003,
0.0262435526,
0.4777761698,
0.4928506911,
0.3110282421,
0.5818593502,
-0.8694071174,
-0.2165233791,
0.1488047093,
0.1282971501,
0.1322063953,
-1.0939543247,
0.5762585998,
-0.0566144213,
-0.3948841393,
0.2763542533,
0.5693252087,
0.1857307553,
0.1676559448,
0.545216918,
0.401322037,
0.6689124107,
-0.3063623309,
0.8869271278,
-0.3215636015,
0.0206583254,
0.8848432899,
-0.3661317825,
0.5993978381,
0.4491717219,
-0.1186597049,
0.5892950296,
0.5622457862,
0.0752937645,
0.4332485795,
0.2380818129,
-0.3345413804,
-0.348279655,
-0.2657779455,
-0.1340392679,
0.5244624019,
0.2998051047,
0.0855492949,
-0.4186862409,
-0.0041416856,
0.1509221047,
-0.2968179584,
-0.3822799325,
0.9094283581,
-0.0035153897,
-0.8191837072,
0.3316439092,
-0.1257689446,
0.1581831723,
-0.7859302759,
-0.0342892073,
-0.3756025136,
0.0938782543,
-0.0197491609,
-1.1530115604,
0.3624906838,
0.0497203618,
0.385887295,
-0.3234195411,
0.3652676642,
-0.2074219137,
-0.4290346205,
-0.1455416828,
0.6442707181,
0.4099733829,
-0.3543721437,
-0.6357489824,
0.0663760006,
-0.2070784122,
-0.0693762824,
-0.0233820025,
0.5941057801,
-0.2163851112,
1.2330235243,
0.6622404456,
0.331841141,
-0.1079973727,
0.5440083146,
0.8453118205,
-0.57402426,
-0.8074609041,
-0.8323116302,
0.4425877631,
-0.0220069326,
-0.12593171,
0.5026301742,
0.5421806574,
0.3646770716,
0.0729237199,
0.9330753684,
-0.0738207921,
0.190856874,
-0.6676357985,
0.5277658701,
-0.1978777647,
0.4503733814,
0.069528237,
-0.3700815141,
-0.0594834723,
0.3805275857,
-0.280016005,
0.0536799356,
0.2960749567,
1.1518619061,
0.142806977,
0.1260661632,
0.3022538126,
-0.0287601408,
1.0644763708,
0.786634624,
1.3890998363,
0.0835579261,
1.068092823,
0.0370374769,
-0.1626984477,
-0.4837011397,
-0.7385601997,
-1.1487914324,
-0.3695631921,
-0.4934795797,
-0.2218873054,
0.3067165911,
0.9022085667,
1.0190036297,
-0.6389380693,
-0.3366928697,
-0.528439939,
0.1448347867,
-0.0103472425,
-0.3061382473,
0.10327553,
-0.4097799957,
-0.4427282512,
0.2103735656,
0.2308771461,
0.557880342,
-0.4286696017,
-0.2636535168,
0.2312396616,
0.1468059272,
0.3156265616,
0.249904424,
-0.4143249094,
-0.2363601476,
-0.0408968404,
0.0738211125,
0.1164575666,
1.1258744001,
-0.7286795974,
0.0962521806,
0.2745991945,
0.7556247115,
0.2239770591,
0.3862669468,
0.5417224765,
-0.5806849003,
0.3306215703,
0.2625109851,
0.1716868132,
0.2358430326,
-0.1558107734,
0.4999440014,
0.0762821659,
-0.8600617647,
-0.3492964506,
0.046369426,
-0.9827978611,
0.0080050463,
1.3006515503,
0.0214178208,
0.1667984128,
-0.2881366909,
-0.4852343202,
-0.1301245689,
-0.7140402198,
0.6893900633,
0.5544869304,
-0.246461615,
-0.0797320828,
-0.6937461495,
0.2775847614,
0.1067892388,
-1.2573487759,
0.1951443255,
0.5457640886,
0.0453130566,
-0.1514633447,
0.7370397449,
0.0806171671,
-0.1018482819,
0.0003802959,
-0.4025093913,
-0.0571785718,
-0.3046137393,
0.0099327127,
-0.0280501023,
0.223856926,
-0.2414269745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12649v1
|
Bias in Language Models: Beyond Trick Tests and Toward RUTEd Evaluation
| 2024-02-20T01:49:15 | 2024-02-20T01:49:15 |
Kristian Lum, Jacy Reese Anthis, Chirag Nagpal, Alexander D'Amour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.AP
|
Bias benchmarks are a popular method for studying the negative impacts of
bias in LLMs, yet there has been little empirical investigation of whether
these benchmarks are actually indicative of how real world harm may manifest in
the real world. In this work, we study the correspondence between such
decontextualized "trick tests" and evaluations that are more grounded in
Realistic Use and Tangible {Effects (i.e. RUTEd evaluations). We explore this
correlation in the context of gender-occupation bias--a popular genre of bias
evaluation. We compare three de-contextualized evaluations adapted from the
current literature to three analogous RUTEd evaluations applied to long-form
content generation. We conduct each evaluation for seven instruction-tuned
LLMs. For the RUTEd evaluations, we conduct repeated trials of three text
generation tasks: children's bedtime stories, user personas, and English
language learning exercises. We found no correspondence between trick tests and
RUTEd evaluations. Specifically, selecting the least biased model based on the
de-contextualized results coincides with selecting the model with the best
performance on RUTEd evaluations only as often as random chance. We conclude
that evaluations that are not based in realistic use are likely insufficient to
mitigate and assess bias and real-world harms.
|
[
-0.0347257629,
-0.856988728,
0.2717158496,
0.3844085634,
0.042112451,
-0.1005080342,
-0.1682270616,
-0.4040268958,
-0.067685619,
0.2592841089,
-0.7269260287,
-0.1823950559,
-0.5044395924,
-0.0450294688,
-0.5992079377,
1.11802876,
0.0905202106,
0.4964121878,
-0.5357278585,
0.160224244,
-0.7579884529,
-0.4441733658,
0.0235544946,
-0.620593071,
0.5174955726,
0.207806766,
0.5116357803,
0.4718066454,
0.3509225547,
0.1592125148,
-0.0266680904,
-0.3755961359,
-0.5163335204,
0.2547740936,
-0.2866688669,
-0.5174723268,
-0.1101905853,
0.4695546925,
0.3409946859,
0.9069976211,
0.0324350297,
0.3238706887,
0.1811366975,
0.6600353718,
-0.824401319,
-0.1707602441,
-0.4764613807,
0.2572923005,
-0.1048291102,
-0.1123804823,
-0.4935113192,
-0.4111076295,
0.1918828785,
-0.1722592711,
0.2469768077,
-0.0435635261,
1.0056504011,
0.2265345156,
-0.5950847268,
-0.4680146575,
-0.6935175061,
1.2091220617,
-0.3927089274,
0.6256048679,
0.3788041472,
0.2091584802,
-0.2113258988,
-0.4062355757,
-0.2087996304,
-0.4902296364,
0.0156279691,
0.1758873314,
-0.1662794799,
-0.1235594153,
0.5227612257,
0.0450248979,
-0.2014403641,
0.1544254273,
-0.2233279198,
-0.0899359137,
0.6572482586,
0.1866492033,
0.319109261,
-0.2211192101,
-0.521690309,
-0.2944751978,
-0.9990777373,
-0.1180807874,
0.7196553349,
0.1765919775,
-0.073651135,
0.5369088054,
0.0918805301,
0.5419519544,
-0.0245285966,
-0.3961209357,
0.0968255997,
-0.1412561238,
-0.2236650735,
-0.1940015256,
0.5797982812,
0.4269346297,
0.5321123004,
-0.3651798069,
-0.1941449046,
0.4084889591,
0.2934317291,
-0.6059488058,
0.0605334826,
-0.2036298364,
-0.3668833077,
-0.6326272488,
0.0435906015,
-1.1162973642,
-0.5247757435,
-0.1551237702,
0.3089617789,
-0.1583127528,
-0.0755623057,
-0.0103603527,
-0.3411058784,
0.147848323,
0.0030177946,
-0.6805081964,
0.3138477504,
0.6491513252,
0.3510720134,
-0.3451493084,
-0.2314659953,
-0.5050601959,
-0.0278823655,
-0.3890687227,
0.742744863,
-0.5624399781,
-0.4498246908,
0.1367584765,
-0.2921250165,
-0.0946359113,
-0.6713590026,
0.7485330701,
-0.1757991761,
0.5373126864,
-0.5428749919,
-0.2525112629,
0.1035942659,
0.2137444317,
-0.5446072817,
1.1316864491,
0.1914442629,
-0.8725310564,
1.0269525051,
-0.3954941332,
-0.7264906168,
-0.3255505264,
-0.3527437747,
-0.3560633361,
0.0548980534,
-0.0535730533,
0.1877589971,
-0.5091642141,
0.5279502869,
-0.1977630258,
-0.5511111617,
0.5545011163,
-0.8662616611,
0.7717454433,
0.0593750179,
-0.8676925302,
-0.1956617087,
-0.5092158914,
-0.1116492003,
0.1332198381,
-0.4314489961,
-0.6692598462,
0.0604050122,
0.0703796819,
0.3058522046,
-0.2293534428,
-0.4592097402,
-0.1133081466,
-0.2972175777,
0.087119624,
0.7295169234,
-0.1026184335,
0.4552441239,
-0.5965986848,
0.7686260343,
-0.106682986,
0.0835061297,
-0.0651162043,
-0.1888412833,
-0.8673263788,
-0.1930096447,
0.6349179149,
0.3496706784,
-0.4792448282,
0.1714066416,
-0.4714871347,
-0.2683124542,
-0.4257079959,
-0.0556994975,
0.7698669434,
0.5590443611,
0.0178684629,
-0.3473353684,
-0.4309223294,
-1.0814727545,
-0.909781456,
0.1185008287,
-0.0446492136,
0.4087384343,
0.649112165,
-0.1239648461,
0.8852354288,
-0.36525473,
-0.3318128884,
-0.1421099603,
0.1885190308,
-0.2393209934,
0.3526152074,
0.5800124407,
-0.5001806617,
-0.3121876121,
-0.4451394379,
-0.4216792881,
-0.5718585849,
-0.1343293935,
-0.135087207,
0.3115165234,
0.2310066372,
-0.4833779037,
0.6473534703,
0.4147617519,
-0.4671967626,
0.7667081952,
0.3714959621,
0.1977204531,
-0.4965732396,
-0.0545002669,
0.1236555725,
-0.152099967,
-0.4720157683,
0.1673627645,
0.0480344146,
0.2624530792,
-0.4686932564,
0.6318287253,
-0.53093642,
-0.2610297799,
-0.1022383645,
0.2741903961,
0.2720317245,
-0.0114310794,
-0.0589132607,
0.7113317251,
0.1566623002,
-0.5530774593,
-0.0973090678,
-0.1975506842,
-0.4550688267,
0.5018993616,
-0.4588491619,
0.1942630559,
-0.1122564673,
0.2261139899,
-0.8269529343,
-0.0011148411,
0.1856316924,
-0.187187925,
0.3504821062,
-0.1437267661,
-0.4334608614,
-0.3399710357,
-0.6725363135,
0.381085515,
0.7290267944,
-0.559299171,
0.0826060846,
0.2695958912,
0.2479869872,
-0.9903942347,
-1.0287613869,
-0.0810146257,
-0.510481894,
-0.3991998732,
0.2436558157,
-0.0432954691,
-0.7136412263,
-0.2271358818,
-0.3401200771,
0.1843084842,
0.0971007571,
0.3137849569,
0.0741432011,
0.1085212231,
0.0001844766,
0.2030137628,
0.0392347239,
0.2110413313,
0.3535362482,
0.5044708848,
0.2168667912,
-0.4762615561,
0.273075819,
0.1061088741,
0.1765042543,
0.2564477324,
0.4213360548,
0.284248203,
-0.2784869075,
-0.5517160296,
-0.7692605257,
-0.4404215515,
-0.4291058183,
0.2888241708,
-0.395979166,
-0.5992406607,
0.2528689206,
-0.0285023283,
-0.0190808885,
0.0492314361,
0.4232738614,
-0.1767203659,
0.8028540015,
0.3887965977,
0.0920558646,
0.5241274238,
-0.2166270763,
0.0649010837,
-0.8843607306,
-0.0507991239,
-0.5370150208,
-0.4329434931,
-0.4655043185,
-0.398459971,
0.109088555,
-0.0965250507,
-0.0478030518,
0.0589436777,
-0.3126717508,
0.5245303512,
0.5340949297,
-0.0680992678,
0.2715834975,
0.0818665102,
-0.2826994359,
-0.6285998225,
-0.9148501158,
-0.6117941141,
1.2968050241,
0.3846446276,
0.9518040419,
-0.1685084403,
0.4758964479,
0.3407519758,
0.7681988478,
-0.6758903265,
0.5945418477,
0.2212077528,
-0.9414746761,
-0.0814665109,
-0.2066559196,
-1.1626999378,
0.4961497784,
-0.3557379842,
-0.7131532431,
0.1653224975,
0.0351214856,
0.1973367035,
0.0195900518,
-0.6372606158,
0.6108924747,
-0.3371906281,
-0.9122286439,
-0.1481040567,
-0.293727994,
0.8152651191,
0.0805474147,
0.5325949192,
0.0463139303,
0.0302508883,
0.7479211092,
-0.0787266642,
0.9764022231,
-0.1071685478,
-0.4147368371,
0.1340581477,
0.53526932,
0.2527537644,
-0.0060347053,
-0.1194417551,
0.0744017735,
-0.0445463359,
-0.2443345338,
-0.488824755,
0.9483622909,
-0.5242574215,
-0.7027727962,
-0.7806257606,
-0.672001183,
-0.1564133167,
0.1690267771,
0.125978902,
0.4969534576,
-0.5061179399,
-0.1125707775,
0.6041895151,
-0.4046101868,
0.4144664109,
0.5548042655,
-0.2494675964,
-0.07244616,
0.661408484,
0.1413684785,
0.3306347132,
0.216674,
0.3960975707,
-0.1991767734,
-0.2304904759,
-0.3317827582,
0.2079995126,
-0.7723116279,
-0.1274704784,
-0.2655068636,
0.113455683,
-0.4136631191,
-0.1315805763,
-0.3207499087,
-0.2389002144,
0.0783584937,
-0.2299520075,
-0.0749826655,
0.7081826925,
0.0809883848,
0.0922807604,
-0.183543101,
0.3425287902,
0.2612439394,
0.2714250088,
0.005003863,
-0.4440019131,
-0.0842698142,
0.1641119421,
-0.5162838697,
-1.0444215536,
0.1534020305,
-0.1298130602,
0.5117324591,
0.3064357936,
0.0636914521,
0.6692150235,
-0.4785448909,
0.80101192,
-0.0181865096,
-0.795612514,
0.2375329137,
-0.4491610527,
0.0989711806,
0.5094187856,
0.1540829986,
-0.4382057786,
-0.286836952,
-0.6381928325,
-0.7964977026,
0.7389113307,
0.0421634465,
0.4007433951,
-0.1418662369,
0.2714997828,
0.4599644244,
0.4941192865,
-1.2017928362,
-0.4137892127,
0.0568160601,
-0.0723249242,
0.1997683793,
-0.4800450802,
-0.3006984591,
-0.2269085348,
0.6724962592,
0.1642321348,
0.2789200246,
0.0829129443,
-0.4984101057,
-0.2982083857,
0.4462172687,
0.5824211836,
0.7846781015,
-0.0204415806,
0.207259506,
0.2228126675,
-0.5582946539,
0.1073397473,
-0.1009281352,
-0.711029768,
-0.0417618826,
0.5982254148,
0.7045115232,
0.4492140114,
-0.8566266894,
0.6729504466,
0.2162410319,
-0.2258888632,
-0.3636219501,
0.1061708853,
-0.0459106229,
-0.0555788577,
0.2484174073,
-0.2162537277,
0.2356822938,
-0.7094393373,
0.0535969585,
0.7520576119,
-0.5119177103,
-0.2553273141,
0.5971891284,
0.3107548952,
-0.4470122457,
0.2628086805,
-0.0462234095,
-0.4711328149,
0.5410084724,
0.6999849677,
1.0039616823,
-0.0999286249,
0.2223608643,
0.1155492738,
0.6494820714,
0.1790321916,
0.1400865018,
0.0772314593,
-0.6101697683,
-0.4439317584,
-0.3864136934,
-0.1309000254,
0.4740926921,
-0.5938793421,
0.3872798979,
-0.1641080528,
-0.1414441466,
-0.3709426224,
-0.1049641818,
-0.677053988,
0.2948341668,
0.0830102414,
0.7606947422,
-1.0696771145,
0.3940515518,
0.7476382256,
-0.2581777871,
-0.3780165315,
0.4280222654,
-0.0947343856,
-0.5473174453,
0.7689049244,
0.1832183301,
-0.0702648833,
-0.3519173563,
-0.2520999908,
-0.7121309638,
0.8586046696,
0.4358396828,
-0.5034630299,
0.1614369601,
0.4319792986,
0.5727210045,
-0.2271454185,
0.6524161696,
0.8666112423,
0.6004734039,
-0.43517676,
-0.8429144025,
0.1203377321,
0.0967037901,
-0.0187195558,
0.11059127,
-0.6651414633,
0.539408803,
-0.0820431337,
-0.2931268215,
-0.2544567287,
0.2628980875,
0.4395523965,
0.3445045352,
0.5193784833,
0.4046081305,
0.247839883,
-0.2686779499,
1.1485528946,
-0.0171136409,
0.1122344211,
1.0061610937,
-0.2898023129,
0.415435046,
0.7808200121,
-0.3322850168,
0.655423224,
0.2704467773,
0.2600003481,
0.511032939,
0.6821725368,
0.0274750311,
0.0586140715,
-0.1134516001,
-0.1462869048,
0.1693363637,
0.170024693,
-0.4000208378,
-0.1975272149,
0.0640713573,
0.4497280419,
0.5398700237,
0.151984185,
0.5015795231,
0.2347494066,
-0.8844978213,
0.4953348339,
0.2664673328,
0.9988378286,
-0.4617482126,
-0.0259491038,
-0.4002177417,
0.0482636243,
-0.1299569458,
-0.4601995945,
0.0223395936,
0.1767793447,
-0.1371150166,
-0.3110703528,
1.0847704411,
-0.511466682,
-0.4798786938,
0.3149628639,
0.6727313399,
0.0597243048,
0.2856962681,
-0.7009581327,
0.1941910088,
-0.0683429688,
-0.6638829708,
0.6181154251,
0.0748716593,
-0.3140547276,
0.8917822838,
0.4068290889,
0.1175930649,
0.1736476272,
0.3654733896,
0.6498401165,
-0.6030800939,
-0.1656423509,
-0.7816684246,
0.4324643016,
0.1647980511,
-0.3492677212,
0.9472958446,
0.562795341,
0.7330428958,
-0.2316753417,
0.9268600941,
-0.0128122075,
0.4297634661,
-0.4278194606,
0.5321250558,
-0.3452924788,
0.362670362,
-0.8243890405,
-1.1575174332,
-0.0581273511,
0.6924194098,
-0.5579432249,
0.5421672463,
0.8605066538,
0.5124347806,
-0.2124630809,
-0.1872505546,
0.2852562964,
0.1049388647,
0.1590981334,
0.2912626863,
1.1581573486,
-0.6745153666,
0.3019568026,
-0.3946668506,
-0.2133548111,
-0.1398055553,
-1.1377441883,
-1.2892376184,
-0.2924348116,
-0.3445708156,
-0.2506497204,
0.2647596002,
0.6439936757,
0.4086365104,
-0.2975201607,
-0.2937949002,
-0.0781282559,
0.3670755923,
-0.1769812703,
-0.361386925,
0.2567537725,
-0.2219694853,
-1.0649871826,
0.4041587114,
-0.218831718,
-0.1062562168,
-0.6087616086,
-0.0530285612,
0.0422378704,
0.2259276211,
0.5836651921,
-0.2051429302,
-0.6720457077,
-0.4960340261,
-0.0665909871,
0.0095208567,
-0.2027416974,
0.7955523729,
-1.0139421225,
0.1917317212,
0.4443692267,
0.0731333271,
0.4522221386,
0.0662382096,
0.7206020951,
-0.8034605384,
0.2758329809,
0.2029369175,
0.0260891598,
0.4366078079,
-0.2603079379,
0.7011606097,
0.2869096696,
-0.3198265135,
-1.3782120943,
0.3183386028,
-0.4395804703,
-0.264898181,
1.5985053778,
0.0344291553,
-0.1646041125,
0.0366454087,
-0.1655494273,
0.1502330899,
-0.1254388243,
0.8936377168,
0.8875843287,
0.0894353613,
0.1049029231,
-0.8307916522,
0.6018047929,
0.7422000766,
-0.5436896086,
0.1931647509,
0.6650409102,
0.6777530909,
-0.0223409906,
0.2922988832,
-0.334736377,
0.2306344509,
0.0821061209,
0.2591199279,
0.0234461389,
-0.337020725,
-0.3545121849,
-0.2878546715,
0.1535910964,
0.2478508204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12636v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12636v3
|
StyleDubber: Towards Multi-Scale Style Learning for Movie Dubbing
| 2024-02-20T01:28:34 | 2024-07-02T03:42:36 |
Gaoxiang Cong, Yuankai Qi, Liang Li, Amin Beheshti, Zhedong Zhang, Anton van den Hengel, Ming-Hsuan Yang, Chenggang Yan, Qingming Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given a script, the challenge in Movie Dubbing (Visual Voice Cloning, V2C) is
to generate speech that aligns well with the video in both time and emotion,
based on the tone of a reference audio track. Existing state-of-the-art V2C
models break the phonemes in the script according to the divisions between
video frames, which solves the temporal alignment problem but leads to
incomplete phoneme pronunciation and poor identity stability. To address this
problem, we propose StyleDubber, which switches dubbing learning from the frame
level to phoneme level. It contains three main components: (1) A multimodal
style adaptor operating at the phoneme level to learn pronunciation style from
the reference audio, and generate intermediate representations informed by the
facial emotion presented in the video; (2) An utterance-level style learning
module, which guides both the mel-spectrogram decoding and the refining
processes from the intermediate embeddings to improve the overall style
expression; And (3) a phoneme-guided lip aligner to maintain lip sync.
Extensive experiments on two of the primary benchmarks, V2C and Grid,
demonstrate the favorable performance of the proposed method as compared to the
current stateof-the-art. The code will be made available at
https://github.com/GalaxyCong/StyleDubber.
|
[
-0.2490501851,
-0.4176908433,
-0.0501896031,
0.1630653292,
-0.164388746,
0.4462387562,
-0.0976716802,
0.0911279097,
0.58204633,
0.3781634271,
-0.5315626264,
-0.3990793526,
-0.3725916743,
-0.2464451939,
-0.0289880112,
1.1395970583,
0.0530512929,
0.2685726881,
-0.2165593952,
-0.1971020699,
-0.4587717652,
-0.3712668121,
-0.4715973735,
-0.2325689048,
0.4052887857,
0.8027815223,
0.6030411124,
0.5785929561,
0.5905410647,
0.1668705642,
0.0164479762,
0.1696503758,
-0.4504779875,
0.4168685973,
0.2311047763,
-0.4912441969,
-0.7889655232,
0.1040559188,
0.51255548,
0.0459050313,
-0.3078179955,
0.2687073946,
-0.2840959728,
0.8290353417,
-0.7104281187,
0.1998214722,
-0.5071859956,
0.0979347005,
-0.1882692873,
-0.3371290863,
-0.4677822292,
-0.1929236054,
-0.2079562247,
-0.2024186999,
0.3475226164,
-0.0911351368,
0.7796642184,
0.6172599792,
-0.3148530722,
-0.128352955,
-0.7312547565,
0.4306327403,
-0.5701363087,
0.7042749524,
0.2480981052,
0.5191575885,
0.2711569071,
-0.6312443614,
-0.5208446383,
-0.0165518932,
0.1675090194,
0.4756443202,
0.0464087352,
-0.0557834655,
0.2580905855,
0.347909838,
-0.5138416886,
0.0018567481,
-0.4263590574,
-0.1537062973,
0.4265502095,
-0.0740177333,
0.400842756,
-0.6124594212,
-0.4318407178,
-0.4004057348,
-0.1881113648,
0.5960580111,
0.5077438354,
0.2187791467,
-0.2712877095,
0.2223707289,
0.0672496855,
0.1556648016,
0.276083082,
-0.5810158253,
0.5378747582,
-0.2985011041,
0.1742455363,
0.4573013186,
0.4589491487,
0.865414083,
0.2275225073,
0.1706093401,
-0.0903371647,
-0.1050290465,
0.7408592701,
-1.1397080421,
-0.4754263461,
0.205761686,
-0.1065899804,
-0.1007008553,
0.0211617574,
-1.2244836092,
-0.3964688778,
-0.5616029501,
0.5180869699,
-0.5263445973,
-0.4345152974,
-0.5167223215,
-0.2786138356,
0.5339437127,
0.087830767,
-0.8842968345,
0.12899068,
0.1826524138,
0.9552527666,
-0.0926707834,
0.073225446,
-0.6262666583,
-0.0122718923,
-0.6250312924,
0.4572487473,
-0.5794636011,
-0.5374228954,
0.0545651801,
-0.1202222407,
0.1751675755,
-0.5510274172,
0.2068992555,
-0.3205322027,
-0.1516351402,
0.0059677814,
-0.0532851294,
0.2058236897,
-0.2822761238,
-0.5428876877,
0.9391661286,
0.0780937821,
-0.3794337809,
0.3435944915,
-0.3015372157,
-0.2698574364,
-0.0207638536,
0.1958713531,
-0.8300572634,
0.0336206928,
0.1914699078,
0.3444852233,
0.1669840664,
0.0518497415,
-0.5041377544,
-0.2157366723,
-0.0081685493,
0.0479333177,
0.155044198,
0.3763537407,
-0.0523879938,
0.2882452011,
-0.8234639764,
0.213646099,
-0.0816159844,
0.1403594464,
-0.1907248795,
-0.292598933,
0.279335767,
0.2579309046,
-0.0475974381,
-0.3232041001,
0.3910132945,
0.1132387146,
0.4904498458,
0.6087094545,
0.0053992015,
0.6761720181,
-0.1290242821,
0.6360915303,
-0.1378422678,
0.0585954674,
-0.338493973,
0.0517955944,
-0.9017591476,
-0.5946314931,
0.0261755083,
0.4912869632,
-0.6279348731,
-0.0150879445,
-0.1514891237,
-0.6647092104,
-0.7167066336,
0.1534165889,
0.4069646299,
0.1566884965,
0.7272199988,
-0.4685067236,
-0.6367972493,
-0.9174824953,
-0.0395942628,
-0.0470929779,
0.0012746288,
0.3526110649,
0.1102820337,
-0.2681163549,
1.0373674631,
-0.2828210294,
-0.3062723875,
-0.3299541771,
0.09290573,
-0.100369215,
0.5583295226,
0.5170155764,
-0.8589182496,
-0.3299053311,
-0.1027607992,
-0.4614648819,
-0.3249824941,
-0.1030483544,
-0.0507002659,
0.1330634058,
0.9431130886,
-0.0437965281,
0.1659439951,
0.6527248025,
0.0330743641,
0.621075809,
-0.2215749621,
0.4162493944,
-1.4143458605,
-0.1834402978,
0.3918176889,
-0.092826657,
-0.6389942169,
-0.3230461478,
0.1890333295,
-0.4301222861,
-0.3675818145,
0.4600718915,
-0.1993924528,
-0.1274643689,
-0.1829042435,
0.2177209705,
0.0646958649,
0.7549021244,
-0.0341966487,
0.7896543741,
0.3403888941,
-0.3095381558,
0.4941808283,
0.0322630182,
-0.1510960013,
0.9003757238,
-0.5487362742,
0.5215144753,
-0.1779985279,
0.3698962033,
-1.3989528418,
-0.529283464,
0.0125177167,
-0.4605504274,
0.6325912476,
-0.6976821423,
-0.3319522738,
-0.1884842664,
-0.2286436707,
0.4123018682,
0.818205893,
-0.633361578,
0.8646215796,
0.3322513402,
-0.4900660813,
-0.461573869,
-0.2741926908,
-0.0743642598,
-0.3985213339,
-0.3987163305,
0.469566226,
-0.0817332789,
-0.0665038228,
-0.4575452507,
-0.7039934993,
-0.3187423646,
-0.3855620921,
0.5448048115,
0.4909389317,
-0.0042268825,
-0.1666690409,
0.1700520664,
0.1502309442,
-0.161501646,
0.0144105293,
0.459623307,
-0.2398822308,
0.1824891716,
-0.6507251263,
0.0626855791,
0.8724063039,
-0.5372264385,
0.1969047189,
1.1379393339,
0.0732607022,
-0.3746496737,
-0.5721200705,
-0.2063668072,
-0.4391320348,
0.6203762889,
-0.4235854745,
-0.5183924437,
0.4738208652,
-0.3787970841,
-0.077912733,
-0.2287092656,
0.4322427213,
-0.3197316527,
0.7429309487,
0.6678156853,
0.1876848936,
1.0094145536,
-0.3605689108,
0.322152704,
-0.8893377781,
-0.432384491,
-0.2531635165,
-0.5011124611,
-0.7926861644,
-0.5950761437,
0.5822716355,
0.4053920507,
-0.1044755653,
0.577183485,
-0.1502596736,
0.6072909236,
0.4759179056,
0.1223654822,
-0.074621655,
0.0513394251,
0.0411689468,
-0.2380188853,
-0.3644591868,
-0.214234516,
0.6959808469,
0.2240917236,
0.9254673719,
0.3013074696,
0.7578609586,
0.2408590615,
-0.1044099554,
-1.0407626629,
0.3988323808,
-0.1305466145,
-0.4075707793,
-0.174661994,
-0.2327147275,
-0.1411815137,
0.1775545478,
-0.139535889,
-0.7960268259,
0.1707531661,
0.4681949615,
-0.2026458085,
0.2262792438,
-0.7478740811,
0.6851529479,
0.02007767,
-0.6710292101,
-0.3086140752,
-0.9763434529,
0.1365146041,
-0.050287433,
0.3084494174,
0.0057240268,
0.2009078115,
0.7404147387,
-0.0736609101,
0.7722990513,
-0.0428890623,
0.0551067293,
0.3341432214,
0.3982044756,
0.0951865017,
0.2105792612,
0.1853117198,
0.2099686265,
0.1149642318,
-0.2897487879,
-0.8834400773,
0.6441401243,
-0.6344296336,
-0.4350576699,
-0.1095006913,
-0.5220687985,
-0.3974063694,
-0.0249708649,
0.0317215919,
0.8729243875,
0.0192823596,
0.3139081597,
0.5207173824,
-0.1136424467,
0.5520547032,
0.1732775271,
-0.4207704961,
-0.9981505871,
1.1259334087,
0.0703987852,
0.6565571427,
0.1692887992,
0.1246819422,
-0.062518321,
0.0297117401,
-0.5287185907,
0.0835535973,
-0.4970181584,
0.0162755586,
-0.3710324466,
-0.0926596075,
-0.4916222692,
-0.4010418952,
-0.8009982705,
-0.1309242696,
0.1280528307,
0.0560518615,
0.3376092911,
0.5097838044,
-0.2361911982,
0.3518216312,
-0.5374570489,
0.4906801879,
0.4657341838,
0.3327170014,
-0.4205454588,
-0.9529883265,
-0.2426469177,
-0.3502942026,
-0.323540777,
-0.6024931073,
0.3580058813,
0.2256125808,
-0.0213086493,
0.4698885977,
-0.0728915781,
0.8384693265,
-0.6945238113,
0.6841551661,
0.3939590454,
-0.8904437423,
0.5135561228,
-0.227166757,
0.2935985029,
0.4241861701,
0.4360524118,
-1.0351535082,
0.0359284729,
-0.5371999145,
-0.8770433664,
0.667980969,
0.0387707837,
0.1758413464,
0.3538959026,
0.3544951975,
0.0663778782,
0.2667396665,
-0.2312171459,
-0.3662243485,
-0.7924693227,
0.0119475806,
-0.3272668719,
-0.234553948,
0.1737499237,
-0.2466082573,
0.5837494135,
-0.2759792507,
0.1450712234,
-0.002383162,
0.16016756,
-0.0934075713,
0.3891560733,
0.5192304254,
0.0927665383,
-0.5510478616,
0.0733177438,
-0.1221248507,
-0.5788429379,
0.0910654068,
-0.2504459321,
0.2279235125,
0.0438239276,
0.3645531833,
1.1915556192,
0.2489378005,
-0.4540153146,
0.3396603167,
0.2174143195,
-0.0784266591,
-0.1737268567,
0.1145093292,
-0.1094147563,
0.1755300909,
0.146085456,
0.3854532242,
-0.0305812098,
-0.7682430744,
0.4754131436,
0.1814375371,
-0.6864527464,
-0.4187089503,
0.6415013075,
0.2823022306,
-0.6308279634,
0.4702941477,
0.0052910256,
-0.5184045434,
0.5905532241,
0.4383310676,
0.7973198891,
-0.5113332272,
0.2844703197,
0.6429981589,
-0.0692300573,
0.1878214478,
-0.1137207076,
-0.3475359678,
-0.5989221931,
-0.177905187,
-0.6908768415,
-0.6048741937,
-0.0486788414,
-0.9298865199,
0.6574132442,
-0.6272470951,
-0.2597581148,
-0.0257893987,
-0.4893378913,
-0.2963160276,
-0.0345491953,
0.5788494945,
0.5057014227,
-0.7622708082,
0.7781280279,
0.7149829865,
-0.5136854649,
-0.9356330037,
0.269208312,
0.4961262047,
-0.5020640492,
0.8588997722,
0.3405680358,
-0.5260950923,
0.1796272248,
-0.5618006587,
-0.7688708305,
0.8533627391,
-0.0355964713,
-0.6662262678,
-0.2696887255,
-0.3890548646,
0.5463072062,
-0.3236990571,
0.2976883054,
0.6363478303,
0.0233094655,
0.6299444437,
-1.163687706,
-0.6895871162,
-0.336751014,
0.0903711319,
0.2676619589,
-0.971129775,
0.4656919539,
-0.6570739746,
-0.0274830703,
-0.0517242216,
0.6353808641,
-0.0597112887,
0.1792210937,
0.4358900189,
0.4154759049,
0.3849929571,
-0.1222941577,
0.6130674481,
-0.1731125116,
0.36654526,
1.211669445,
-0.2025128156,
0.8234429955,
0.5539593697,
-0.1110251546,
0.7199782729,
0.4665595591,
0.0190024208,
0.6675792933,
0.0746833012,
-0.0662630424,
-0.484364748,
-0.3632063568,
-0.1001223102,
0.7408931255,
0.192899555,
0.0167565104,
0.0375176929,
0.2694038451,
0.2409798652,
-0.0430001467,
-0.3138291836,
0.9122747183,
0.110974215,
-0.4550962448,
0.7066989541,
-0.4854078591,
0.4523179829,
-0.7510927916,
-0.3552675843,
-0.2698911726,
0.1728663445,
-0.260525465,
-0.5584816933,
-0.2120177299,
0.0493770652,
-0.125938043,
-0.2209264934,
0.1600678414,
-0.7887521982,
-0.2179957926,
0.0470964573,
-0.0433089808,
0.12067651,
0.4644733667,
-0.4447460473,
0.2719388902,
0.0616427213,
-0.0296105538,
0.2116602063,
0.228904292,
0.1378244311,
0.7088630795,
0.3396511674,
-0.038494613,
-0.0345590822,
0.50063622,
0.3761346042,
-0.306466192,
-0.2918563783,
-0.6697694063,
0.5321899056,
0.0994983688,
-0.2183125913,
0.5456502438,
0.3637980521,
0.9023045301,
-0.2598629296,
0.3767569065,
-0.0309368316,
-0.0521953367,
-0.6774287224,
0.4156405926,
-0.6870955229,
-0.2416578829,
-0.8161880374,
-1.0608654022,
-0.1952872425,
0.4894239306,
-0.1723697186,
0.051030118,
0.7717610598,
0.9723978043,
0.0644287094,
-0.1281530261,
0.2877877355,
-0.0557890944,
0.3510201871,
0.0022180742,
0.3902331293,
-0.2317738086,
0.537594676,
-0.4323794842,
-0.4087257981,
-0.5021637678,
-0.6535452604,
-0.8531490564,
-0.8965705037,
-0.4790862799,
-0.5662528276,
0.0688049719,
1.2894946337,
1.0148338079,
-0.6126402617,
-0.3940009773,
0.6197597384,
-0.2228597701,
-0.3960341513,
-0.1942444593,
0.0865462795,
-0.4083380997,
-1.0674920082,
0.4572843611,
0.4332801104,
0.0433254987,
-0.0068321754,
0.1398579776,
0.2194866091,
0.1292194128,
0.5191705227,
0.1513134688,
-0.7541710138,
-0.2301580608,
-0.2322016656,
0.0135326367,
0.2390376627,
0.9891206622,
-0.3279730678,
0.8779225349,
0.2813149691,
0.5355459452,
0.4984358549,
0.3402690589,
0.342556864,
-0.7997241616,
-0.0302368402,
-0.1990744323,
0.351831764,
0.3363653719,
-0.0322868787,
0.272572279,
0.3481825888,
-0.4885998964,
-0.6472921371,
0.3704841137,
-1.4579175711,
0.1306816936,
1.3096494675,
0.3590911925,
-0.0353300981,
0.5011672974,
-0.525811255,
0.43880409,
-0.8495565653,
0.5030117631,
0.5989721417,
-0.2358217835,
-0.1928052604,
-0.5489474535,
0.6720209718,
0.2632439137,
-0.3554502726,
0.2885614038,
0.5473226309,
0.4095047414,
0.467897743,
0.0648206323,
-0.1791940182,
0.283064276,
0.0632081106,
0.6964400411,
-0.1202628613,
-0.9173676968,
-0.1895870566,
0.0927316025,
-0.1211440265,
-0.0806630626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12621v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12621v2
|
Reflect-RL: Two-Player Online RL Fine-Tuning for LMs
| 2024-02-20T01:04:21 | 2024-06-06T17:04:41 |
Runlong Zhou, Simon S. Du, Beibin Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
As language models (LMs) demonstrate their capabilities in various fields,
their application to tasks requiring multi-round interactions has become
increasingly popular. These tasks usually have complex dynamics, so supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) on a limited offline dataset does not yield good performance.
However, only a few works attempted to directly train the LMs within
interactive decision-making environments. We aim to create an effective
approach to fine-tune LMs with online reinforcement learning (RL) in these
environments. We propose Reflect-RL, a two-player system to fine-tune an LM
using SFT and online RL, where a frozen reflection model (player) assists the
policy model (player). To generate data for the warm-up SFT stage, we use
negative example generation to enhance the error-correction ability of the
reflection model. Furthermore, we designed single-prompt action enumeration and
applied curriculum learning to allow the policy model to learn more
efficiently. Empirically, we verify that Reflect-RL outperforms SFT and online
RL without reflection. Testing results indicate GPT-2 XL 1.56B fine-tuned with
Reflect-RL outperforms larger open-source LMs, such as Mistral 7B. The
benchmarks, dataset, and code involved in this work are publicly available:
https://github.com/zhourunlong/Reflect-RL.
|
[
-0.4353484511,
-0.9768901467,
0.4294307232,
0.3951584101,
0.0292351656,
0.2193890512,
-0.580293417,
-0.460940212,
0.0897425786,
0.6826219559,
-0.7007288933,
-0.2045604438,
-0.1003673449,
-0.0913352445,
0.1625268608,
1.2122597694,
-0.0628446937,
0.1406786442,
0.100938186,
-0.1898982078,
-0.4274469912,
0.2798925638,
-1.0396305323,
-0.4064512253,
0.4905563593,
0.5611851811,
0.6254900098,
0.4182114303,
0.3873079717,
0.2676751614,
0.124970682,
1.0434561968,
-0.8722484708,
0.2007449716,
-0.4106247425,
-0.1820784807,
-0.423828423,
-0.1221954897,
0.5076576471,
0.0292436332,
-0.5484859943,
0.1615501642,
0.1778230518,
0.6925206184,
-0.5220021605,
0.3737608194,
-0.4355831146,
0.2309218943,
0.351682663,
-0.3694700599,
-0.6757629514,
-0.6849521399,
0.0129980156,
-0.9529101849,
0.1405495852,
0.2814153433,
0.9628317356,
0.5300962329,
-0.1386235058,
-0.2409015894,
-1.004852891,
0.7558876276,
-0.8380945325,
0.2824384272,
0.2769365609,
0.5405814648,
-0.2169913054,
-0.5456058383,
-0.2207263559,
-0.3084205985,
-0.1066329107,
0.4356006086,
0.4417033494,
0.2141691148,
0.3268496394,
-0.0370216258,
-0.3958780169,
0.1100406274,
-0.3094413877,
0.1355474144,
0.6563161016,
0.2384918779,
-0.0530007966,
0.48295331,
-0.3049357831,
0.0064237057,
-0.7088766694,
0.1670299768,
0.1817463785,
0.7829073071,
-0.1100438088,
0.1276077032,
-0.151727125,
0.5553960204,
0.2366141528,
-0.0137970187,
-0.0775135234,
0.1014682278,
0.0844359249,
-0.0858397633,
0.4422014654,
0.5870392323,
0.3874775469,
-0.1668339372,
-0.5239505172,
-0.167842105,
0.3946523964,
-0.8234581351,
-0.4692839682,
-0.0563513748,
-0.1323916465,
-0.3623688221,
0.3937646747,
-0.8008185029,
-0.5629917383,
-0.4829321802,
0.8713946342,
-0.0598528683,
-0.4064114988,
0.0845102593,
0.0970566571,
0.0732867643,
0.6488329172,
-0.6659288406,
0.592633903,
0.6134796143,
0.8616818786,
-0.3206074536,
-0.3105185926,
-1.0135859251,
0.0113398209,
-0.3023681939,
0.6721069813,
-0.4288535118,
-0.1214231402,
0.3893122971,
-0.0467550419,
0.0136188138,
-0.6814029813,
0.1567061245,
-0.5614253283,
0.3881191909,
-0.3500138819,
-0.5660697818,
-0.0766720995,
0.3521578312,
-0.7456529737,
1.2565335035,
0.1607336551,
-0.3243881166,
0.5490868688,
-0.7928854823,
-0.3242469728,
0.1158134341,
-0.0418565981,
-0.7822803855,
-0.0752228796,
0.0802357346,
0.3296710849,
0.0031735168,
0.1181277856,
-0.3711962402,
-0.921461761,
0.0504653528,
-0.0982559994,
0.2004953325,
0.1791191399,
-0.5942960978,
0.4252578318,
-0.7049211264,
0.3964648247,
0.0156458635,
-0.8011715412,
0.1587322205,
0.5349588394,
0.3474703133,
0.4123982787,
0.0629316941,
-0.4004267454,
0.3360174894,
-0.4242942929,
0.4341116846,
0.614470005,
0.0434050523,
0.2414683402,
-0.4797583818,
0.4660620093,
-0.2890952528,
0.2528496087,
0.0935243592,
-0.2502772212,
-0.825735867,
-0.1356448531,
0.0997043625,
0.6078276634,
-0.9317185879,
-0.1290017217,
0.127099961,
-0.0987410545,
-0.872403264,
0.1291196495,
0.7693732977,
0.063887611,
0.7669939399,
-0.0997431725,
-0.4551627636,
-0.5429056883,
-0.484841913,
0.1724106073,
0.0633730367,
0.7911191583,
0.2400738597,
0.0184659567,
0.9680986404,
-0.5549944043,
-0.6956455708,
-0.2089791298,
0.2111840695,
-0.1183520257,
0.2017549127,
0.2361876816,
-0.606125772,
-0.8152390718,
-0.077126123,
-0.3891937733,
-0.0300117843,
-0.1977399141,
0.2438683063,
0.4321096241,
0.4615710378,
-0.1363374293,
0.1093987748,
0.3058238924,
-0.4503803253,
0.1924363375,
-0.9610233903,
0.2186024487,
-0.5497084856,
-0.1852737367,
0.0437377654,
-0.5598557591,
-0.6065382361,
0.5431700945,
0.1415923238,
0.2243366092,
-0.5492038727,
0.4380245209,
-0.4656822979,
-0.1226834133,
-0.4384657741,
0.3618915677,
-0.0116156768,
0.7183021307,
0.2066231519,
0.7703130841,
0.0973417312,
-0.6833526492,
0.1799108237,
-0.1393784732,
-0.3052929044,
0.2395703197,
-0.4122115076,
0.1839912385,
-0.0554815903,
0.1823865771,
-0.5507121682,
-0.103002958,
0.3358072639,
0.1751835644,
0.3661783636,
-0.0680381507,
-0.3159748018,
0.0949971974,
-0.3559789956,
0.1091286838,
0.4303963482,
-0.6098232269,
0.4860908389,
0.2747215629,
0.3864118457,
-0.251591444,
-0.4771034122,
-0.1977978796,
-0.1041843146,
-0.1964161396,
0.2051271051,
-0.2656711042,
-0.1457889825,
-0.0929975435,
0.2889533937,
-0.1022284478,
0.2132092863,
0.2411569059,
0.0062553426,
-0.2365142405,
0.0224105772,
0.0251611657,
0.0232458971,
-0.1327611804,
-0.0395273007,
0.2656902671,
-0.4350051284,
-0.207769841,
-0.186573565,
0.0637108833,
0.3140492141,
-0.1626534015,
0.8535698652,
0.615291059,
-0.0933394954,
-0.8690644503,
-0.5012708306,
-0.3381977081,
-0.5068292618,
0.3365766108,
-0.2232491076,
-1.0031170845,
0.5313361883,
-0.3200223446,
0.2695483565,
0.0941419825,
0.4331273437,
-0.1726989746,
1.2554718256,
0.5735903978,
0.3946730196,
0.5191683173,
-0.1289175004,
-0.0710524172,
-0.6316273808,
-0.3526642323,
-0.0827437267,
-0.3316016793,
-0.6127866507,
-0.3416441679,
0.2428562194,
0.1310399473,
-0.4879496396,
0.2929300964,
-0.6034815311,
0.8584327698,
0.4275842309,
0.7257542014,
0.2712927163,
-0.3859917819,
-0.0345698744,
-0.1379130483,
-0.5200901031,
-0.2508454025,
0.4728776515,
0.4365177453,
0.7011232972,
0.321793139,
0.5184753537,
0.3810677826,
0.2362262756,
-0.5269408226,
0.4249016941,
0.0252534635,
-0.4729583263,
-0.5027974248,
-0.4506666362,
-0.4634258449,
0.3033764064,
-0.4474689364,
-0.2191825956,
-0.2343382686,
0.5588538051,
-0.5271604657,
0.3367581666,
-0.4667041004,
0.7059695721,
-0.2872599661,
-0.7585969567,
-0.5120694041,
-0.5926038623,
0.2967717946,
0.0305188242,
0.3858351409,
-0.0381890051,
0.0253195055,
0.2667453587,
-0.2120976746,
0.809971571,
-0.6140009761,
-0.1920126379,
0.0892571881,
0.4743044376,
0.8504939675,
0.0979024544,
0.1438703537,
-0.3564274013,
0.2257546633,
-0.0844616964,
-0.6691741943,
0.7578005791,
-0.7204131484,
-0.2551422119,
-0.2948326468,
-0.2668854594,
-0.1920066327,
-0.0400969423,
-0.099498935,
0.3268013597,
-0.2002305388,
-0.1180690005,
0.9572660327,
-0.3213565052,
0.27503106,
1.1609252691,
-0.7109339237,
-0.1963637769,
1.4558436871,
0.1282803565,
0.4453572929,
0.3284855783,
0.3483653367,
-0.0253381263,
-0.3225646019,
-0.4927516878,
-0.0725070685,
-0.3984775543,
-0.1014205739,
-0.027415853,
-0.1945732236,
0.1382586211,
-0.0094883656,
-0.5710716844,
-0.2497205287,
-0.4734936953,
0.1554916203,
0.2720019519,
1.1368886232,
-0.1158799604,
0.1095185354,
-0.4997069836,
0.2066223174,
0.0640797019,
0.8475416899,
-0.0514230169,
-0.6170182228,
-0.5369428396,
0.1203583255,
-0.134101674,
-0.5083529949,
0.2141458988,
0.7640891075,
0.2169170678,
0.6092501283,
0.1882476062,
0.5699400902,
-0.80811584,
0.5332095623,
-0.3186473846,
-0.5607558489,
0.5373440385,
-0.4003037512,
0.1828554273,
0.7770264149,
0.0255778693,
-0.5320340395,
-0.5242089033,
-0.295671314,
-0.7344334126,
1.0288046598,
-0.2130768895,
-0.161200583,
0.0863163024,
0.3812360466,
0.1594972759,
0.0211067572,
-0.5639552474,
-0.2714066803,
-0.2241336256,
0.0412363186,
-0.0641712844,
-0.0243472401,
-0.0222061723,
-0.1822908372,
0.9070488811,
-0.2245215327,
-0.0214681253,
-0.0764469579,
-0.1523762941,
-0.4799522758,
0.1395197511,
1.0529408455,
0.4664209485,
-0.4000271857,
-0.0212008674,
0.5596593022,
-0.1260840893,
-0.1379115582,
-0.2650186419,
-0.3669201434,
-0.3944740593,
0.1616471261,
0.8927522898,
0.7987704277,
-0.7325871587,
0.3012022674,
-0.144832626,
-0.3008332551,
-0.2409196049,
0.4190995395,
-0.0367486887,
0.6132618189,
0.0053182044,
0.0024596415,
-0.0083022527,
-0.5726053715,
0.374704808,
0.4153070748,
-0.6642456055,
-0.1724434644,
0.6341961622,
0.1913509518,
-0.6014298797,
0.5327717066,
-0.4219391346,
-0.6357870102,
0.3667575717,
0.612101078,
0.6405008435,
-0.0725178868,
0.6262367368,
0.5051904917,
0.1254254282,
-0.5904884338,
0.4711290002,
-0.0220973138,
-0.5817283988,
-0.4464127421,
-0.5161780715,
-0.6417289972,
-0.1281424612,
-0.8137810826,
0.2559091449,
-0.6410065293,
0.1049309,
-0.564324677,
0.1707435101,
-0.4787824154,
0.0432978645,
-0.0086124912,
0.5784418583,
-0.8364714384,
0.73848176,
0.5183236599,
-0.4775539935,
-0.9480250478,
-0.2482255101,
-0.118761234,
-0.6029747725,
0.5188983679,
-0.0182353109,
-0.302642107,
0.225819096,
-0.4352076352,
-0.6475666761,
1.0169727802,
0.2376840264,
-0.6999356747,
0.0346261486,
0.0885169432,
0.7428379655,
-0.2180523276,
0.6458029747,
0.4389509559,
0.5520399809,
-0.0523144677,
-1.0716605186,
0.1396473497,
0.1999785155,
-0.1999255866,
0.4343422651,
-0.9854838252,
0.7298621535,
-0.3583278656,
-0.2315882742,
-0.2319874316,
0.5436873436,
0.1372679621,
0.1059692279,
0.431471318,
0.4409537315,
0.4980801642,
-0.1283247918,
0.4879993498,
-0.2273254842,
0.7377054691,
1.3773168325,
-0.4419679642,
1.0754461288,
0.2470388263,
-0.101800181,
0.3884039521,
0.470499903,
-0.2698245645,
0.7201581001,
0.3071974218,
-0.274261862,
-0.5887465477,
-0.0100978715,
-0.1771225482,
-0.0138607994,
0.2780010104,
-0.0085749049,
-0.4504241347,
0.0744086802,
-0.2814936936,
0.5060123205,
-0.3231212795,
1.1165732145,
-0.0383068994,
-0.8202759624,
0.0969540328,
0.3213121593,
0.6444782019,
-0.4260213077,
-0.5502178669,
-0.1634549946,
0.714589715,
-0.4068876505,
-0.7060213685,
-0.0097651361,
-0.2763985693,
0.0575519428,
-0.3698786795,
0.5825409293,
-0.8213380575,
-0.1484677047,
0.4812745452,
0.3312389553,
0.1142356545,
0.0799952671,
-0.7481786609,
-0.0205929484,
-0.0697638765,
-0.4349756539,
0.5896472335,
0.15676561,
0.0229148734,
0.8122193217,
0.2400455326,
0.2882287204,
0.0349669978,
0.2194102108,
0.7050733566,
-0.3464715481,
-0.3327192664,
-0.6788675189,
0.3795950711,
0.0949303061,
-0.4041732848,
0.5958629847,
0.6357012391,
0.9606323242,
-0.0933854505,
0.4274396896,
0.1421515793,
0.7905106544,
-0.64274472,
0.8712157011,
-0.5088090897,
0.2213332355,
-0.0270271339,
-0.9008940458,
-0.2720674276,
0.9023058414,
0.0195396394,
0.1640221328,
0.3450041711,
0.9992098212,
-0.1580377519,
-0.0125027634,
0.3892565072,
0.0244418308,
0.407750994,
0.4847548306,
0.7710912824,
-0.388556987,
0.3350447118,
-0.2369647175,
-0.1117203012,
-0.3288665116,
-0.9600857496,
-1.0797080994,
-0.3928942382,
-0.4085403383,
-0.4709436595,
0.450753659,
1.4058331251,
0.4567545652,
-1.0244990587,
-0.1822671592,
-0.1929172873,
-0.2054434866,
-0.6296967268,
-0.2866068482,
0.2704842091,
-0.489988476,
-0.3248863816,
0.6778358221,
0.0218050852,
-0.4458110929,
-0.6119998097,
-0.7751929164,
-0.2399098873,
0.0727176219,
0.5243102908,
0.4397149086,
-0.7855494022,
-0.6512804031,
-0.1904314309,
-0.1413633674,
0.0225567203,
0.8140944242,
-0.877857089,
0.4131535888,
0.2351724356,
0.393604517,
0.7739768028,
0.1057744101,
0.4578399658,
-0.6473603249,
-0.3997034431,
0.2488420606,
-0.0381686389,
-0.0012875233,
-0.2105589956,
0.4373266101,
-0.2571115196,
-0.9148120284,
-0.8396940827,
0.1694782227,
-0.6484658718,
-0.3919535875,
1.0625681877,
-0.1952858418,
0.3556288183,
-0.1334028393,
-0.4872232378,
0.3070452511,
-0.5337989926,
0.9416620731,
0.5033447146,
-0.111890614,
-0.4190123677,
-0.8258500099,
0.9699946046,
0.2777189612,
-0.6049996614,
0.1557867676,
0.3561890721,
0.2661801875,
-0.1752288193,
0.2952142358,
0.5509975553,
0.2356770039,
-0.2974199057,
-0.0247794501,
-0.6017531157,
-0.6138085723,
-0.3487131894,
0.2005630732,
0.2611439824,
0.1867237389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12617v1
|
Generative AI Security: Challenges and Countermeasures
| 2024-02-20T00:51:05 | 2024-02-20T00:51:05 |
Banghua Zhu, Norman Mu, Jiantao Jiao, David Wagner
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Generative AI's expanding footprint across numerous industries has led to
both excitement and increased scrutiny. This paper delves into the unique
security challenges posed by Generative AI, and outlines potential research
directions for managing these risks.
|
[
-0.4581916034,
-0.9007619619,
0.2428435683,
0.0749490559,
0.156278044,
0.3442313671,
0.4919794798,
-0.8277535439,
-0.1971180737,
0.6198321581,
-0.8723941445,
-0.0725988001,
-1.0780527592,
0.0972777382,
-0.4591197968,
0.8242036104,
0.0301895309,
-0.3060573041,
-0.4855858982,
-0.2200959772,
-0.7020494938,
-0.9221581221,
-0.6219299436,
-0.2686850429,
0.3189806342,
0.2798843384,
0.727402389,
0.0156940762,
0.8722305298,
0.5135816932,
0.2672823668,
-0.2521111369,
-0.0425841287,
0.6226970553,
0.0262725595,
-0.6851422787,
-0.1447374225,
-0.0896155089,
0.3074856997,
0.4504652917,
-0.1949422061,
0.0845751613,
-0.1983270049,
0.8148086071,
-0.6378919482,
0.0491301529,
-0.6227301955,
0.329577744,
-0.8334174156,
0.0186104458,
-0.3073214889,
-0.0429292955,
0.1234004647,
-0.6225745082,
0.1713611037,
-0.2503678501,
0.6820316911,
0.6285538077,
-0.5536180735,
-0.28750512,
-1.2041466236,
0.5743600726,
0.2334870249,
0.0185338221,
0.1359363943,
0.4619239867,
-0.0409101732,
-0.7819500566,
-0.1935252994,
-0.0474022068,
0.4647957981,
0.1103992462,
-0.7042629719,
-0.0163555015,
0.345203191,
0.5405861139,
-0.6094681025,
0.3837996125,
-0.4146843255,
0.021359222,
0.7667276859,
0.3501026332,
0.9419007301,
0.4046312869,
-0.4868716598,
-0.4350429773,
-0.8658339381,
-0.0601838082,
0.667501092,
-0.3178025484,
-0.1180407181,
0.6250596046,
-0.0791479945,
0.4326689541,
-0.1812740266,
0.5660524964,
0.1490477324,
-0.1372276843,
-0.1767084897,
-0.0383273251,
0.5657452345,
0.0405636579,
-0.0832720324,
-0.1577083766,
-0.1117911413,
0.0532096997,
0.7579466701,
-0.3594157994,
-0.0939542651,
0.6278591156,
-0.2391936928,
-0.4767545462,
0.2166998684,
-0.9137630463,
-0.5700085163,
0.2841853797,
0.2346959561,
-0.2916994393,
-0.4472222924,
-0.4193805754,
-0.7838987708,
0.7075979114,
0.2667307258,
-0.9187932611,
-0.3679355085,
0.8978851438,
0.8907444477,
0.1506350636,
-0.0083660809,
-0.1427587271,
0.3593037724,
-0.4488150179,
0.7836291194,
-0.4231701493,
-0.9403755069,
-0.207118988,
-0.4166325629,
-0.0586984232,
-0.5902418494,
-0.0484587587,
-0.6981711388,
-0.1957392246,
-0.0914844722,
-0.2026747316,
0.1811012626,
0.6784675717,
-0.7189189196,
0.398208499,
0.2490725964,
-0.7089341879,
0.1587027907,
-0.7891387939,
-0.4601331353,
0.5606326461,
-0.5008651018,
-0.4702238441,
0.2280488312,
0.1259871721,
-0.2672876716,
-0.1043546796,
-0.3217935264,
-0.2639506161,
0.0004151299,
0.441473335,
-0.6147140265,
1.1344121695,
0.4423628747,
-0.4408808649,
0.3055189848,
-0.510374248,
-0.2752149403,
0.1660947949,
0.2891578674,
-0.2013161033,
0.0183038786,
-0.2002905458,
-0.1294952333,
0.2810194194,
-0.2050776631,
0.0829520896,
-0.2503207326,
0.565304935,
0.8063960671,
0.4527030885,
0.4034655988,
-0.5207324028,
1.1236822605,
0.1814602464,
0.6014868021,
-0.0122272149,
-0.6753286123,
-0.379217267,
-0.3453153372,
0.074670963,
1.0177550316,
-0.9451223016,
0.4687558413,
0.19840841,
-0.7715886831,
-0.4982920587,
-0.1094469056,
0.1303511709,
0.0526009277,
0.0961063951,
-0.3354438245,
-0.2550252676,
-0.6229332685,
-0.0577891283,
-0.2525234818,
-0.112653248,
0.0276047587,
0.3389831483,
-0.7307144403,
0.4946579635,
-0.5784525275,
-0.5248817205,
-0.1813369691,
0.5636760592,
-0.2413266897,
0.9708232284,
0.6237157583,
-1.1513661146,
-0.3531506956,
-0.0517743789,
-1.0031245947,
0.2240151763,
-0.5981031656,
0.1021856517,
-0.0587886982,
0.8315126896,
-1.1358385086,
0.5126910806,
0.2131090015,
-0.0192233268,
0.6571345925,
0.0341640823,
0.0808914602,
-1.1018090248,
0.1610221267,
-0.3153426349,
0.3699611723,
-0.774620831,
0.7164016962,
-0.5871172547,
-0.5812737942,
-0.202317968,
0.121886842,
-0.3355126083,
0.0512000881,
-0.0696908608,
-0.2230997384,
-0.0910062119,
-0.3666324019,
-0.3145156503,
0.8411180973,
1.0014624596,
-0.6184862852,
0.8098105192,
0.2840740085,
-0.4479697645,
0.5488628745,
-0.7664701939,
0.4084861875,
-0.1032579392,
0.1308881938,
-0.9118571281,
-0.1050259471,
0.412825793,
-0.6869015694,
0.5475067496,
0.0964436531,
-0.2631696463,
-0.3882550895,
-0.3461968005,
0.6400216222,
0.5576414466,
-0.2894541621,
0.9387974739,
0.2534607053,
-0.2908365428,
-0.8835252523,
-0.8038952351,
0.6731159687,
-0.5344107151,
-0.4263345003,
0.4007482529,
0.0422551744,
-0.7542423606,
0.0358771719,
0.0977062136,
0.1464938968,
0.6893718243,
0.4009888768,
0.015963221,
-0.048041895,
-0.3703887761,
-0.1390337795,
-0.4187103808,
0.6095693111,
-0.1800855547,
0.2641581297,
0.1611269563,
-0.5870666504,
-0.4165924788,
0.825761199,
0.7224235535,
-0.3390626013,
0.7218676805,
0.6873208284,
-0.2907345891,
-0.1395586282,
-0.4375330806,
-0.0156341735,
-0.6259620786,
0.4924389422,
-0.4662185013,
-0.547495544,
0.6942929029,
-0.0507668294,
0.0369571373,
0.4663445055,
0.4897698164,
-0.229639411,
0.9584100246,
0.7296983004,
-0.2423571944,
0.4209161997,
-0.2024236172,
0.4602971375,
-0.5031300783,
-0.6845306158,
-0.6224138141,
-0.0755991936,
-1.0187325478,
-0.0800728798,
0.4870585501,
-0.192547828,
-0.1515581906,
0.2233489156,
-0.6135593057,
0.2980507016,
0.922678709,
-0.1746928543,
0.0643718764,
-0.211256519,
0.3589034379,
0.3606516719,
-0.3897295892,
-0.1531901956,
0.8043271899,
0.4008646309,
1.0812882185,
0.6490688324,
0.6017646194,
0.6437847614,
0.2224657089,
-0.4425106943,
0.3636859357,
-0.123046793,
-0.9115671515,
-0.3823753893,
-0.4719269872,
-0.9622352719,
-0.0542786531,
-0.1168505177,
-0.7193986177,
0.2150377035,
0.1731889397,
-0.4477971792,
0.3316023052,
-0.6466531157,
0.5959564447,
-0.3519226015,
0.09957093,
-0.2657902837,
-0.6364899874,
0.3221274316,
0.17011334,
-0.1121333688,
0.0439309813,
0.3117737472,
0.2567484975,
-0.2824905515,
0.9918227792,
0.0333276354,
-0.1991554201,
0.6192290783,
0.0643340424,
0.2145739198,
0.2155566216,
0.2725551724,
0.2939271629,
-0.051213,
-0.5471708775,
-0.2604360878,
0.6002146006,
-0.7947609425,
-1.3123438358,
-0.9791557193,
-0.376218766,
-0.4084977806,
0.113964662,
0.885864675,
0.1200287268,
-0.6461202502,
0.2869080603,
0.9976939559,
-0.4492467046,
0.4672121406,
-0.2299608737,
0.4356169105,
-0.4261250198,
0.9571260214,
0.070639655,
0.3473478854,
0.4158034921,
-0.259440124,
-0.2925320268,
-0.4936501086,
-0.852009058,
-0.6308339834,
-0.4632872939,
-0.3339656293,
-0.4230035543,
-0.646035552,
-0.693877399,
-0.3439424336,
-0.1513865888,
-0.2145326585,
-0.4365116656,
-0.2839226127,
0.3975031674,
0.834878087,
-0.0969112515,
0.1407238096,
-0.7549520135,
0.3627491593,
0.7081872225,
0.2240673304,
0.2063649595,
0.0283052381,
0.1914984882,
-0.3092800677,
-0.4855711758,
-0.7320773005,
0.0520546585,
-0.1401280165,
0.6322151423,
0.8929622173,
0.1389442533,
0.0921630338,
-0.3022110164,
1.0369963646,
0.3775507808,
-0.6187641621,
0.5586599708,
-0.3071147799,
0.3178856969,
0.4640710354,
0.5118333101,
-0.2011591494,
-0.3381519914,
-0.6945129633,
-0.9616532922,
0.182676658,
0.4767354429,
0.5681424737,
0.0615507811,
0.08664646,
-0.2477364242,
0.1735421866,
-0.618019104,
-0.4005195796,
-0.5524980426,
0.0344202034,
0.1865477711,
-0.1660760641,
-0.5764973164,
0.0742727444,
0.3944645524,
0.396810919,
0.3369689882,
0.0593864098,
0.0530396774,
0.121029444,
0.3482171297,
0.7409355044,
0.2833144069,
0.1175404489,
0.1468710452,
-0.0774325207,
-0.5106380582,
0.2494036108,
0.3013085723,
-0.3565902412,
-0.1877589375,
0.6253871322,
0.6352471709,
-0.6304333806,
-0.5005110502,
0.3178645372,
0.149859041,
-0.3762491047,
-0.753064096,
0.2538335323,
-0.193857193,
0.178613171,
0.6209619641,
0.2318070084,
0.1152696088,
-0.8264738917,
0.1553273052,
0.7291919589,
-0.4718137383,
-0.4313090146,
0.8721750379,
0.3584730029,
-0.222784549,
0.9246975183,
-0.1534319073,
-0.5685343146,
1.1656666994,
0.5965127349,
1.166446805,
-0.5482206941,
0.1592063457,
-0.1408674568,
0.8001593351,
0.2497757822,
0.1944827735,
-0.1356996298,
-0.7093807459,
0.257650882,
0.0018263542,
-0.8287236691,
0.2591817677,
-0.7052066922,
-0.2961031795,
-0.7952316999,
-0.4923934042,
-0.0515507571,
-0.2917638421,
-0.5486284494,
0.1361912191,
0.1385726035,
0.7111569047,
-0.5048882961,
0.2208963633,
0.608130753,
-0.6782352924,
0.0560363419,
0.0699399188,
0.2003529221,
-0.7260957956,
0.5152362585,
0.2604106665,
-0.1501700431,
-0.0558881611,
-0.4191356599,
-0.7563907504,
0.9378994703,
-0.0349343605,
-0.2087800205,
0.0598119833,
0.6668078303,
0.3502929211,
-0.1146046445,
-0.236587137,
0.3823598027,
0.478185147,
-0.1562654674,
0.0013378427,
-0.0879051164,
-0.4215944111,
0.0992447287,
0.1755144149,
-0.7419329882,
0.5369788408,
-0.1780967861,
-0.3532114327,
0.0803218335,
0.7287414074,
0.0686433017,
0.5406455398,
0.3758479059,
0.8253897429,
0.3321752846,
-0.2063680142,
0.8553811908,
0.0547259599,
-0.2368318588,
0.6895840168,
-0.4500147402,
0.2101492882,
0.2742395699,
-0.3009335697,
0.7145622373,
0.5391925573,
-0.6478182077,
0.254121691,
0.1534903198,
-0.8306646943,
0.0804964155,
-0.2898011804,
-0.7654069662,
0.6211461425,
0.8143681288,
0.0453132093,
0.0543777794,
0.2715198696,
-0.5479030609,
-0.0091989413,
-0.2093995959,
1.0641165972,
0.2228033692,
-0.3611678183,
-0.4036204219,
0.0238959957,
0.5107168555,
-0.6454364061,
0.0353328213,
-0.1184001639,
-0.0732803643,
0.0711049959,
-0.5237178206,
0.6517535448,
0.0944864526,
0.0196571928,
-0.1490073353,
0.465723604,
-0.0082549974,
-0.2973784208,
0.104634203,
0.1839674413,
-0.4957578778,
-0.1939661801,
-0.7161787748,
0.1659039408,
-0.3165222108,
-0.046914883,
0.4161157906,
0.3517091274,
-0.0647658333,
0.8845114112,
0.4573537111,
-0.2132084966,
0.0331255347,
0.0422736704,
0.5165985227,
-0.6357142925,
-0.5638903379,
-1.0197921991,
0.2677115798,
-0.3502559066,
-0.4973910451,
0.7749971747,
0.1945323348,
0.76358217,
-0.2509793043,
0.9323061109,
-0.2538146079,
-0.3748468161,
-0.3972679079,
1.0358030796,
-0.1515598297,
0.2552800775,
-0.0290840585,
-0.5038466454,
-0.3315104544,
0.1623460203,
0.0366123952,
0.2191287875,
0.2597562075,
0.4998423457,
0.2907135487,
-0.266148001,
0.1840030849,
-0.2285482138,
0.6257406473,
0.3648336232,
0.9737477899,
-0.4057829678,
0.3154977262,
-0.222768262,
-0.1407606751,
-0.20446679,
-0.6589647532,
-0.5375548601,
-0.6921748519,
-0.7260321379,
-0.3349104226,
-0.0999122187,
0.2633478642,
0.727942884,
-1.1317896843,
0.2199813575,
-0.3519774377,
0.478954494,
-0.5235629678,
-0.2749168277,
0.0666703954,
-0.3433411717,
-0.4680684805,
0.279428184,
0.3259106278,
0.5874502063,
-0.3766197264,
0.5167438984,
-0.0604253337,
0.1780166924,
0.5153847337,
0.8395912647,
-0.4168099463,
-0.2520616651,
-0.2630738318,
-0.021890156,
-0.4007752836,
0.8957425952,
-0.0757207051,
0.4751229882,
0.6503720284,
1.263022542,
-0.0023243427,
0.2591454387,
0.8619308472,
-1.0647610426,
0.2476519197,
0.2824926674,
0.0894051716,
0.1983758658,
-1.0115152597,
0.4244235754,
0.2451233417,
-0.2722599804,
-0.8026412725,
0.8233804107,
-0.6754479408,
-0.4657346904,
0.359233737,
-0.0251772031,
0.4241464436,
-0.3509229422,
0.345214963,
0.1284741908,
0.2295068651,
1.0907635689,
0.6852982044,
-0.2678630352,
-0.2172094733,
-0.2672696412,
0.8030524254,
0.4649779201,
-0.8456317782,
-0.0133299306,
0.1085068733,
-0.2215368897,
0.5400044918,
0.4011932313,
-0.2752378285,
0.4144899547,
0.5444626212,
-0.2119555026,
-0.0757286325,
-0.6318257451,
-0.3762180805,
0.4193251431,
0.3154248893,
-0.4515492618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12605v1
|
What is a word?
| 2024-02-19T23:58:20 | 2024-02-19T23:58:20 |
Elliot Murphy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In order to design strong paradigms for isolating lexical access and
semantics, we need to know what a word is. Surprisingly few linguists and
philosophers have a clear model of what a word is, even though words impact
basically every aspect of human life. Researchers that regularly publish
academic papers about language often rely on outdated, or inaccurate,
assumptions about wordhood. This short pedagogical document outlines what the
lexicon is most certainly not (though is often mistakenly taken to be), what it
might be (based on current good theories), and what some implications for
experimental design are.
|
[
-0.2950910032,
-1.1179153919,
0.6598842144,
0.2732506692,
-0.2274603099,
0.0985597074,
-0.1232784837,
-0.6667989492,
0.2408290803,
0.0477296337,
-0.2814105749,
-0.1061670482,
-0.8199914694,
-0.0237103812,
-0.5635234714,
0.6573927402,
0.0144623816,
0.1653841287,
-0.2297077477,
-0.353702426,
-0.4834929407,
-0.0948843956,
-0.3089307249,
-0.4666602612,
0.5656592846,
0.0842671543,
1.0380200148,
0.5927712917,
0.4647613168,
0.3526853323,
-0.642136693,
-0.2935826182,
-0.1644024253,
-0.2575567365,
-0.4564824104,
-0.6584504843,
-0.1453411281,
0.2525371611,
0.4389347732,
1.4275280237,
-0.0981955677,
0.2165452689,
0.1678629816,
0.5980873108,
-0.8066973686,
0.1707699299,
-0.3523094356,
0.0290231649,
-0.4154402614,
0.0556287393,
0.0004978068,
-0.4213623405,
0.1874164492,
-0.9221490622,
0.2122493237,
0.1479221284,
1.0205204487,
-0.0612859875,
-0.4027519226,
-0.4298135638,
-0.6286110878,
0.5569313765,
-0.4293631315,
0.7076853514,
0.5314240456,
-0.0272378232,
-0.2378267199,
-0.9163416624,
-0.6527482271,
-0.0837713182,
-0.0890158415,
0.032318484,
0.1089299172,
0.5054427981,
0.3455764651,
0.4712902009,
-0.2779151797,
-0.3360509276,
-0.7062183022,
-0.1391427666,
0.504522264,
-0.0324785635,
0.6678655744,
-0.195490703,
-0.3344280422,
0.3459380865,
-0.5656018853,
-0.1541944444,
0.331379652,
0.1132195517,
-0.0067320969,
0.624981761,
0.1383588761,
0.6635293961,
-0.4032609463,
-0.1198642552,
0.2126342356,
-0.2092419565,
0.1461983919,
0.0936607271,
0.6380361915,
0.2758115232,
0.11932078,
-0.5864171982,
-0.2481479347,
0.4408963621,
0.5765916109,
-0.4479818344,
-0.2823713422,
0.1000695974,
-0.0877821147,
-0.0664647967,
0.1561325192,
-0.5556194782,
-0.3306383193,
-0.3472521901,
0.7641148567,
-0.3239665031,
-0.3347822428,
0.2346030474,
-0.7794882059,
0.0337306485,
0.2622765303,
-0.9622632265,
0.6094399691,
0.6342413425,
0.6551681757,
-0.0723526478,
-0.4733742476,
0.3897649348,
0.0907167494,
-0.724055171,
0.7197468281,
-0.480112046,
-0.9397696257,
0.0786917657,
0.2397418916,
0.309135288,
-0.2044457793,
0.495193243,
-0.4250994921,
0.3292520046,
-0.6643131971,
-0.9354000688,
-0.3422811329,
0.0758468136,
-0.5019712448,
0.460865438,
0.1395245641,
-0.9083632231,
0.6072551012,
-0.5663467646,
-0.3406131864,
0.5142876506,
-0.3649362922,
0.3859170377,
0.6060609818,
-0.6293744445,
-0.2555336952,
-0.3620455265,
0.2101177275,
-0.2951121926,
-0.1711883843,
0.5752339363,
0.103329733,
0.5542705059,
0.3512511253,
-0.117634818,
-0.1028652862,
-0.6732228994,
0.0622481555,
0.1992317438,
-0.3968546987,
-0.7085283995,
0.5941059589,
0.0268274602,
-0.1904616654,
0.303720206,
-1.0571300983,
0.1960952282,
-0.2483180612,
0.6440285444,
0.2939554453,
-0.2693215013,
0.5318084955,
-0.4132101536,
0.4234499335,
-0.4850957692,
-0.0290084593,
0.3158216476,
-0.5253584385,
-0.5668551922,
0.0198295899,
0.5900036097,
0.3485718369,
-0.2749307752,
0.2211584449,
0.2015241981,
-0.3675931692,
-0.4201334715,
0.1973200589,
0.2408095896,
0.3161218166,
0.0366843455,
-0.4143653512,
-0.436637044,
-0.9091232419,
-0.5883071423,
-0.4167408645,
0.0527595058,
-0.05071095,
0.5264229774,
0.0260986015,
0.9588400126,
-0.7021782398,
-0.1118974388,
-0.3678011894,
0.314912498,
-0.0885561556,
-0.1521125436,
0.3901571631,
-0.6132158041,
0.3732056618,
-0.5202585459,
-0.7922683954,
-0.0248578899,
0.3159217238,
-0.1536944509,
-0.4080080092,
0.6188985705,
-0.3011535406,
0.4736033678,
0.4513446987,
-0.5078192949,
0.2664965689,
-0.4479529858,
-0.5146107674,
-0.7908299565,
0.0979260802,
0.0066733109,
0.2446597219,
-0.551495254,
0.4989992976,
0.2818334699,
-0.0596716702,
-0.6673714519,
0.75892061,
-0.4956467152,
0.2152462006,
-0.7873311043,
0.3171343207,
0.3261241317,
0.0086827194,
0.0130281132,
0.6384077072,
0.310257256,
-0.6998678446,
0.0630353317,
0.3239061534,
-0.3036943376,
0.4018912613,
-0.6474584341,
-0.0571109951,
-0.5351002216,
-0.0303667989,
-0.7676838636,
-0.2646641433,
-0.0958033577,
-0.2032934576,
0.154572174,
0.1973463446,
-0.4829289913,
-0.4303689003,
-0.0151168667,
0.4797686636,
0.1478150189,
-0.111930415,
0.1497590542,
1.0683720112,
0.1540411115,
-0.1457974464,
-0.766477704,
-0.03870482,
0.1161011904,
-0.4124941826,
0.1809817106,
-0.0397316888,
-0.841489315,
0.1369721591,
-0.0400439501,
-0.37605685,
0.4298743308,
0.4876276851,
-0.0426748171,
0.0285599716,
0.8181836605,
-0.2888203263,
0.2266636491,
0.3572393656,
0.0998445377,
0.2592661381,
-0.245963335,
-0.0225569513,
0.1869222522,
0.550817728,
0.4100729525,
0.0771511495,
0.4388034344,
0.0049628913,
-0.6827309728,
-0.3214396238,
-0.1324461251,
-0.0423716009,
-0.4591150582,
0.3228977621,
-0.2538145185,
-0.3012827039,
0.2264063656,
-0.0668359995,
-0.1312607378,
0.3432190418,
0.1357882768,
-0.0931678414,
0.4768369794,
0.9049196243,
0.1668980122,
0.0708457679,
-0.0843477249,
0.3124627769,
-0.7427965403,
-0.1743986607,
-0.5159583688,
-0.2252085209,
-0.5966572762,
-0.0906000733,
0.059254244,
0.2723305225,
0.1204219609,
0.2718780637,
-0.2848339081,
0.4277063012,
0.3370596766,
-0.1406715214,
0.0942268372,
-0.6427003145,
-0.2607071102,
0.0396333635,
-0.6159149408,
-0.6969627142,
0.660130024,
0.3023768067,
1.1012084484,
0.1303135455,
0.3384262919,
0.0562426373,
0.1502560675,
-1.0378317833,
0.6285289526,
0.1961461008,
-1.1759119034,
-0.106734775,
0.2206846029,
-1.1777818203,
0.2483104616,
-0.408644706,
-0.7024978399,
0.1811766922,
0.153976351,
-0.0848277509,
0.3184551597,
-0.7536478043,
0.6816635132,
-0.3519204259,
-0.3267939091,
0.0162722934,
-0.4237243533,
0.407979846,
-0.1043702364,
0.7675744295,
-0.4137679338,
-0.1560037434,
0.9197221994,
-0.2563558221,
0.5258268118,
0.1249821857,
-0.0549608953,
0.5997416973,
0.3595142663,
-0.0429353863,
-0.1848040819,
0.1610426605,
0.2828889489,
0.5174133778,
-0.1738971919,
-0.5102080107,
0.1614575982,
-0.6223889589,
-0.5599685907,
-0.4197717309,
-0.6305882335,
-0.3579339981,
0.1267189234,
0.4922770262,
0.4488380849,
-0.540387094,
0.0036969054,
0.4466058612,
-0.2054896206,
0.3270655274,
0.4420471787,
-0.5195138454,
0.1034147441,
0.9820628166,
0.4984822273,
0.1256520152,
0.2704135776,
0.7051689029,
-0.418687582,
-0.4358916581,
-0.1864503026,
0.2499699146,
-0.7196093202,
0.4910985529,
-0.413980782,
-0.4199125767,
-0.1591495275,
-0.1386774778,
-0.2784611583,
-0.422522068,
-0.0704476908,
-0.1333862543,
0.1997376531,
1.2361015081,
-0.2126909345,
0.3097507954,
-0.57452631,
0.4133753181,
0.5632811189,
0.3866572976,
-0.2783700824,
-0.2265748084,
0.1130456701,
-0.0983285606,
-0.3658010364,
-1.2370564938,
0.037184339,
0.4393027425,
0.6682437062,
0.5282039642,
0.0205186922,
0.1330072582,
-0.6781617999,
0.9433981776,
0.2798005939,
-0.9268980622,
0.5999851227,
-0.2241121233,
0.383320868,
0.5072903633,
0.3644354939,
-0.9810171127,
-0.5148133039,
-0.9953351021,
-1.1298558712,
-0.0124800391,
-0.284796387,
0.3002252281,
-0.4727373421,
0.2112589329,
0.137992844,
0.5187016129,
-0.2149977684,
-0.2183469236,
-0.1892827153,
-0.046078667,
-0.1172534376,
-0.4298907816,
-0.5335006714,
-0.0860493034,
0.2748631239,
0.063210398,
0.1214220151,
0.0694405138,
-0.2613602579,
-0.0948836207,
0.4533414543,
0.4471756816,
1.2146623135,
0.0186102577,
0.5793315768,
0.0948761404,
-0.7978029847,
0.1935770214,
-0.2542614341,
-0.266279757,
0.2415574491,
0.3382655382,
0.3909257054,
0.3778510094,
-0.6690065861,
0.5656171441,
-0.0033832425,
-0.5560898781,
-0.403103292,
0.1276739687,
0.2085468471,
-0.1813603789,
0.2829253674,
-0.4197820425,
0.1571631283,
-0.9173679352,
0.0401409939,
0.514575243,
-0.3179588616,
-0.6165683866,
0.7831453085,
0.2101663649,
-0.5630646944,
0.078035906,
-0.135033235,
-0.4534992278,
0.3152219653,
0.5171598792,
0.6881585121,
0.0238925256,
0.1787460297,
0.2208981365,
0.3132679462,
-0.373721838,
0.6215412021,
0.1504072994,
-1.0070911646,
-0.043393448,
-0.8532620668,
-0.5321746469,
0.3221037388,
-0.5522626042,
0.1070470065,
-0.6707006693,
-0.3387065232,
0.3218961954,
-0.0508533753,
-0.5174928904,
0.3314951956,
0.2921615243,
1.3151671886,
-0.8135570288,
0.4433343709,
0.831097126,
-0.3198494911,
-0.9114507437,
-0.1697825342,
0.3346653879,
-0.4927350283,
0.6402773857,
-0.1268097162,
-0.0682785884,
-0.327708602,
-0.7705756426,
-1.0299339294,
0.4932556748,
0.08235351,
-0.3492956758,
-0.161879003,
0.0683605373,
0.5108370781,
0.1178605929,
-0.0255923234,
0.3039680719,
0.6367816925,
-0.142198205,
-0.6460641623,
-0.1471429765,
-0.3524566293,
0.1791505367,
0.365242511,
-0.4215250611,
0.7509678602,
-0.13127698,
-0.4311848581,
-0.0956882015,
0.5599514246,
-0.2100979537,
0.0214473046,
0.3733930588,
0.6161109209,
0.7085362673,
-0.2748853564,
1.014881134,
-0.5388221741,
0.0398136377,
0.8246870637,
-0.0332905538,
0.4920804501,
0.5849802494,
-0.4164349437,
0.2022414207,
0.6567780972,
0.2917958498,
0.3758805394,
0.6468081474,
-0.3487573266,
-0.0973853767,
-0.2555140853,
-0.3174156547,
0.9162051678,
0.7854933739,
-0.3812208772,
-0.2809996009,
-0.1723389328,
0.1017851084,
0.169273138,
-0.1181793958,
0.6380230188,
0.1723272949,
-0.611644268,
0.0878620744,
-0.1649630368,
0.2898871303,
-0.7207829952,
0.0990407318,
0.062168479,
0.1553194821,
-0.0718130618,
-0.7923748493,
0.3447433114,
-0.5291336775,
0.0731598809,
0.095531404,
0.7283346057,
-0.2768941224,
-0.4474799037,
0.2052643299,
0.817587018,
0.3070136905,
0.3848927021,
-0.3146807849,
0.1195609719,
-0.7708999515,
-0.0807842016,
0.1355207562,
0.4890649915,
0.0179100614,
0.5685557127,
0.2159196287,
0.7071256638,
0.2178151906,
-0.1389244497,
0.412497282,
-0.7692239285,
-0.3487559557,
-0.4100330472,
0.0701540262,
0.0051882658,
-0.7915656567,
0.6639178991,
0.4224219918,
0.8424525261,
0.223364234,
0.9186312556,
-0.2567418218,
0.3750516176,
-0.1799703091,
0.8788009882,
-0.6418882012,
-0.1061356962,
-0.3358127475,
-0.5403102636,
-0.2898706794,
0.7053779364,
-0.1797538847,
-0.2774449587,
0.9118032455,
0.4115390182,
0.1606518924,
0.4544899464,
0.3363703787,
0.0594582483,
-0.0968218446,
-0.1490041614,
1.0575854778,
-0.1988558322,
0.0120978411,
-0.3554894328,
-0.1401016861,
-0.0723308176,
-0.8370119929,
-0.3618946075,
-0.8378805518,
-0.2773533165,
-0.3611064553,
0.4212802649,
0.6598112583,
0.5159335732,
-0.2530267835,
-0.4027312994,
-0.2385750413,
0.1580549777,
-0.0360989086,
-0.1641078591,
-0.0114842933,
-0.4706236124,
-0.4539041221,
0.1282627881,
0.0620551147,
0.0556681566,
-0.4327127934,
0.2616792917,
-0.0626198202,
0.5205154419,
0.5136104226,
0.5838645697,
-0.4927310348,
-0.615295887,
-0.2282599211,
-0.2248627543,
0.0469906852,
0.8979563713,
-0.4675408006,
0.6878022552,
0.6910566092,
0.3217837811,
-0.2267740816,
-0.2790372372,
0.6003667116,
-0.5618929863,
0.237865448,
0.1698194146,
0.6500896811,
0.1521239132,
-0.0844055414,
0.4302720129,
0.5857285261,
-0.4206027687,
-0.5575626493,
0.4997992814,
-0.7137610912,
-0.797668159,
1.2545509338,
0.293156743,
-0.9468260407,
-0.2455961108,
-0.0481904075,
0.1351152509,
-0.0349266306,
0.9095109105,
1.0028053522,
0.1638926268,
-0.1434866041,
-0.8262313604,
0.6856659055,
-0.0662766695,
-0.4786677063,
-0.1026235819,
0.2297804505,
0.4848371446,
0.4611386359,
0.4667367339,
-0.0865158066,
0.1199330539,
0.1898751259,
0.2994228601,
0.2831173539,
-0.1699198931,
0.1448156834,
0.234079808,
0.3867925704,
-0.3037548065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08818v1
|
Multimodal Fusion of EHR in Structures and Semantics: Integrating Clinical Records and Notes with Hypergraph and LLM
| 2024-02-19T23:48:40 | 2024-02-19T23:48:40 |
Hejie Cui, Xinyu Fang, Ran Xu, Xuan Kan, Joyce C. Ho, Carl Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Electronic Health Records (EHRs) have become increasingly popular to support
clinical decision-making and healthcare in recent decades. EHRs usually contain
heterogeneous information, such as structural data in tabular form and
unstructured data in textual notes. Different types of information in EHRs can
complement each other and provide a more complete picture of the health status
of a patient. While there has been a lot of research on representation learning
of structured EHR data, the fusion of different types of EHR data (multimodal
fusion) is not well studied. This is mostly because of the complex medical
coding systems used and the noise and redundancy present in the written notes.
In this work, we propose a new framework called MINGLE, which integrates both
structures and semantics in EHR effectively. Our framework uses a two-level
infusion strategy to combine medical concept semantics and clinical note
semantics into hypergraph neural networks, which learn the complex interactions
between different types of data to generate visit representations for
downstream prediction. Experiment results on two EHR datasets, the public
MIMIC-III and private CRADLE, show that MINGLE can effectively improve
predictive performance by 11.83% relatively, enhancing semantic integration as
well as multimodal fusion for structural and textual EHR data.
|
[
-0.0726289004,
-0.7742375731,
0.7109206319,
0.1443778872,
-0.2014128119,
-0.0071423464,
0.0793632045,
-0.6535227895,
0.5760604739,
0.536169827,
-0.2733921409,
-0.6946498156,
-0.3258794248,
-0.2698270977,
-0.0846398175,
1.1951229572,
0.0176271219,
0.2419133782,
-0.7188772559,
-0.2717602551,
-0.4920133054,
-0.6765798926,
-0.1854325384,
-0.5551016927,
0.4043062627,
0.3323541284,
0.5932709575,
0.7354229093,
0.714214623,
0.3476147354,
0.1144936085,
0.309998244,
-0.1741046906,
0.3332946599,
0.2712582648,
-0.3058916032,
-0.8321808577,
-0.5176374316,
0.7394042611,
0.5595664382,
-0.2447268516,
-0.019415563,
0.1258464456,
0.6198259592,
-0.3853212893,
0.5687605143,
-0.2323608994,
0.1374621093,
-0.2649190128,
-0.4467150271,
-0.4959582984,
-0.209667936,
0.2359169126,
-0.559663415,
-0.0586737096,
0.2828337252,
0.7526401877,
0.2879276276,
-0.6725831628,
0.0787063763,
-0.618932724,
0.5738989115,
-0.416103214,
0.6180130243,
0.383215785,
0.4036887884,
-0.1516624242,
-0.8605570197,
-0.5106142163,
-0.025860548,
-0.5518927574,
0.4840177596,
-0.0124514699,
0.4548433423,
0.0577181168,
0.2826479375,
-0.6181619167,
-0.0960781574,
-0.1688192636,
-0.3232495487,
0.5079827905,
0.4204854369,
0.4174978137,
-0.4741520882,
-0.6683954597,
-0.1528942436,
-0.3805772364,
-0.3808900416,
-0.3074711263,
0.2730467916,
-0.4795901775,
0.5740476847,
0.0031505807,
0.5891041756,
0.1563948393,
-0.5798735619,
0.7949518561,
-0.413163811,
-0.3150589168,
0.567905724,
0.8065130711,
0.4827827215,
-0.3486961126,
-0.1188585535,
0.0603689477,
0.3073466718,
-0.0529975407,
-0.5757007599,
-0.3360426128,
0.6529577374,
-0.8186472654,
-0.1176039055,
-0.0226069968,
-0.8881601691,
-0.5449010134,
-0.293274492,
0.2288950235,
-0.665145576,
-0.1478284597,
0.033215221,
-0.3162285686,
-0.1266766489,
0.4926440418,
-0.6489984989,
0.3978674412,
0.5336931348,
0.809458673,
0.0385935418,
-0.2929422855,
-0.74176085,
0.6589207053,
0.2820359766,
0.8096804023,
-0.3432114422,
-0.4398087561,
0.139392823,
-0.0965638086,
-0.399438262,
-0.577475965,
0.4810188711,
-0.3845689893,
0.2523223758,
0.1906041652,
-0.645617187,
-0.0774357542,
0.4766879976,
-0.994967401,
0.7982549071,
0.3530303538,
-0.8827174902,
0.4927515388,
-0.5731565356,
-0.7067631483,
0.3450750411,
-0.3726352751,
-0.6553775668,
-0.312479943,
-0.0029596677,
0.5370007753,
-0.186071828,
0.1993923932,
-0.2772709727,
0.0338474512,
0.2032274902,
0.1295896322,
0.459582746,
0.1691582948,
0.1600645036,
0.310944587,
-1.0101778507,
-0.0029609825,
-0.1935576797,
-0.5528002977,
-0.4438420832,
0.0754826218,
0.5459718108,
0.4955919385,
0.099740468,
-0.5503091812,
-0.1861853302,
-0.1971860081,
0.3130420744,
0.158300966,
0.1898463666,
0.3861765265,
-0.8617368937,
0.2715743482,
0.6324471235,
0.1325860322,
-0.3413277268,
-0.4490925074,
-0.283275485,
-0.6163063645,
0.1552936882,
0.6512179375,
-0.4844323397,
0.4185396135,
-0.3923563957,
-0.2223956436,
-0.7250963449,
0.0263222121,
0.3372219801,
0.8782101274,
0.6591597199,
-0.2977455854,
-0.5914183855,
-0.6529155374,
0.3101420403,
-0.4717895091,
0.018201733,
0.4512957036,
0.2130240053,
-0.4875798821,
0.6373556256,
-0.3105195463,
-0.823633194,
-0.4819218814,
0.0338337943,
-0.016874129,
0.6444530487,
0.1283708811,
-0.9790986776,
-0.4338158071,
0.2751860023,
-0.894161582,
0.4046275318,
-0.0944028273,
0.0140627492,
-0.1527975351,
0.4760262966,
-0.5466232896,
0.0274399575,
0.4924245477,
-0.1330673099,
0.214361921,
-0.4803537726,
0.1539965421,
-1.4082567692,
-0.1497865617,
0.0887088254,
-0.3489027023,
-0.722767055,
-0.233638525,
0.183976382,
-0.135019511,
-0.3795633316,
0.3795303702,
-0.4712219238,
0.2533194423,
0.2075987011,
0.1742570698,
0.1915548742,
0.3404242694,
0.0087896483,
-0.1613105237,
0.502882719,
-0.3035514057,
0.3794152737,
0.7713166475,
-0.2357557863,
0.8258123994,
-0.4625368714,
-0.1346661001,
-0.3236357868,
0.5595512986,
-0.9339333177,
-0.7394275069,
0.0910829902,
-0.3495130539,
0.520252049,
-0.1598921567,
-0.4699446857,
-0.1733808964,
-0.2443184853,
0.4264511764,
0.3985942006,
-0.1807001084,
1.1622567177,
0.5921584368,
0.056947507,
-0.3426906466,
-0.9471388459,
-0.0707816109,
-0.1389620155,
-0.9300380349,
0.8638127446,
0.2184241861,
-0.2032342255,
0.3400102556,
0.2845590711,
-0.1326102465,
-0.3552646637,
0.7000914216,
0.7215118408,
-0.3781568706,
0.3836530149,
0.0430990197,
-0.130240798,
-0.0056769559,
-0.2257063389,
0.4555316567,
0.086468786,
-0.5722904205,
-0.7267382741,
0.5660822988,
0.9117930532,
-0.3445132077,
0.7971668243,
0.4193808138,
-0.6004312038,
0.0741811246,
-0.6191285253,
-0.0172915086,
-0.3329090774,
0.3978869915,
-0.1501332372,
-0.7106127143,
0.4775015712,
-0.1050284654,
-0.177363798,
0.2872754335,
0.580074966,
-0.3872624636,
1.1015828848,
0.5098662972,
-0.0205229335,
0.3173954785,
-0.1127066836,
0.0180596858,
-0.9623755813,
-0.7870666981,
-0.3605367243,
-0.2395432442,
-0.9187774658,
-0.2576804757,
0.8053552508,
-0.420859009,
-0.0671497881,
-0.0503645577,
-0.1471301913,
0.0339788981,
0.2550032735,
0.6157289743,
0.3535908461,
-0.1026348695,
-0.1850111783,
0.2002634257,
-0.8137533665,
-0.1977318674,
0.8352728486,
0.303904593,
0.7457920909,
0.1045566201,
0.9197866917,
0.0892160013,
0.1571670026,
-0.8630341291,
0.3212705255,
-0.1856464893,
-0.462205708,
-0.1227479577,
-0.1902689189,
-0.8192793727,
0.2287541181,
-0.7838507295,
-0.5417396426,
0.2269222587,
0.5468464494,
-0.4972048402,
0.059768796,
-0.566649437,
0.8620060682,
-0.0120601803,
-0.3578897715,
-0.2030311078,
-1.1759017706,
0.2245568782,
-0.0102411965,
0.2749021947,
0.2132305354,
0.3415043652,
0.541673243,
-0.4368349612,
0.6902403235,
0.1924448758,
0.4018580616,
0.1840016544,
0.0514461622,
0.4732935727,
-0.2347842157,
0.0524176359,
-0.0083672712,
0.2095920891,
-0.1948913038,
-0.6318067908,
0.6304214001,
-0.5818365812,
-0.1011997536,
-0.4352931082,
-0.6554219127,
-0.5623654723,
0.1401694864,
0.1389056742,
0.9178023934,
-0.1900059879,
0.1275347918,
0.5792608261,
0.0767479986,
0.0333966129,
0.1364161223,
0.0624459758,
-0.5075888038,
0.8096506,
0.0131536424,
0.2225096226,
0.7022615075,
0.3644566536,
-0.3814182878,
-0.2452396303,
-0.433180809,
0.4821346998,
-0.6677575111,
-0.0482495055,
-1.0252847672,
-0.2690245807,
-0.2736364305,
-0.1740850359,
0.1288747638,
-0.1414943784,
-0.1492490619,
-0.1010019109,
0.2794166207,
0.5463177562,
0.1153172776,
0.3099895418,
-1.3676110506,
0.177109167,
0.041293148,
0.2377104461,
-0.0429420061,
-0.0067501077,
-0.3351158202,
-0.232453689,
-0.1241687462,
-0.9056248069,
0.0599795729,
0.0385175422,
0.6112700701,
0.5357544422,
-0.1535047591,
0.715370059,
-0.678655982,
0.578584969,
0.5481879711,
-0.4912101328,
0.5048961639,
-0.2480682582,
0.0623614416,
0.680881381,
0.4249209464,
-0.6929978132,
-0.1371458918,
-0.7177749276,
-0.7539702058,
0.3982140124,
-0.3573937416,
-0.1634864509,
-0.0917527527,
-0.0291834641,
-0.2479141951,
0.0770556629,
-0.352976203,
-0.2707937956,
-0.1829972267,
-0.7684952617,
-0.0020303491,
-0.2175179571,
-0.3629463911,
-0.0139178894,
0.268671453,
-0.0034283258,
0.1951870918,
0.3002877533,
-0.257995069,
-0.1993064284,
0.1674848199,
0.2029264122,
0.2478671074,
-0.3735828102,
0.3762743473,
-0.0809982195,
-0.5470966697,
-0.0497740284,
0.0789626166,
0.1278899461,
0.0505196936,
0.5638285875,
0.7785254717,
0.2794515789,
-0.6200273633,
0.5674769282,
0.2531738579,
-0.0907772779,
-0.18250525,
-0.0672590882,
0.2192120105,
0.2289304882,
-0.3200041652,
-0.0184860546,
0.3777219057,
-0.6565277576,
0.4408985972,
0.2524455786,
-0.6510267258,
-0.1778172702,
0.7463962436,
0.2905169427,
-0.0000817982,
0.6963757277,
0.2964264154,
-0.3407561779,
0.3812609911,
0.8561912775,
0.5516614914,
-0.2072504759,
0.1372391135,
0.3858867884,
-0.212660864,
-0.0156550128,
0.1643370688,
-0.1195101961,
-0.6882331967,
-0.4447842538,
-0.4254316092,
-0.4866405129,
-0.1306356937,
-0.6384235024,
0.3513841927,
-0.2527040243,
-0.2128060013,
0.1002226397,
-0.3207684457,
-0.5062671304,
0.3345271051,
0.2634825408,
0.6915826201,
-0.9686064124,
0.6937760711,
0.8856956363,
-0.6042486429,
-0.7690138221,
-0.1482208073,
0.5084623098,
-0.6407434344,
0.6954402924,
-0.0071320012,
-0.0706431195,
-0.1892592758,
0.0619618595,
-0.5245898366,
1.0427902937,
-0.0749332383,
-0.3875309825,
-0.1269297749,
0.0435247943,
0.4562242627,
-0.342320323,
0.2535342574,
0.4276094735,
0.4218688607,
0.4106305838,
-0.9370334148,
0.1479207426,
-0.2152861804,
-0.208853513,
0.5047799945,
-0.601379931,
0.7540558577,
-0.2912889123,
-0.1157426164,
-0.3240961432,
0.5911911726,
0.1984063238,
0.5155534744,
0.4241109192,
0.638903141,
0.8608595133,
0.1398343146,
1.0514601469,
-0.3000314236,
0.1578479856,
1.145731926,
-0.7204264402,
0.7542010546,
0.416974932,
-0.0328268968,
0.8123249412,
0.3513637781,
0.0920555741,
0.4448811412,
-0.0588696562,
-0.556117177,
-0.0819457993,
-0.3876242638,
-0.368286401,
0.508965373,
0.4649678767,
-0.3002374172,
-0.2989979982,
0.0024564303,
0.1942921281,
-0.0330647565,
-0.072408095,
1.0813440084,
0.0109656174,
-0.471550405,
0.0253476053,
-0.2545609176,
0.20318757,
-0.7254725695,
-0.4100865722,
0.100461185,
0.2001095265,
-0.6196519732,
-0.573399663,
0.1069396511,
-0.5524062514,
-0.2456742376,
-0.0821830332,
0.8701801896,
-0.7368556261,
-0.2239311934,
0.2880316079,
0.6167986989,
0.0344507881,
0.26444906,
-0.500344038,
-0.1422613412,
-0.3313187957,
0.224166438,
0.5649302006,
0.5212722421,
-0.0340744704,
0.5029633045,
0.6899542809,
0.3566522598,
-0.2995981276,
0.2727436423,
0.8297642469,
-0.4878760278,
-0.7945235372,
-0.8438024521,
0.6192176938,
-0.0832554623,
-0.1725573093,
0.5097603202,
0.6744012833,
0.6727523804,
0.1713658273,
0.7830025554,
-0.0133449435,
0.5512613058,
-0.6243772507,
0.6689943075,
-0.6267437935,
-0.3438344598,
-0.3562647402,
-0.5038045049,
-0.5221642256,
0.2857232094,
0.119466193,
-0.1468200386,
0.8659289479,
0.6489046812,
-0.0686277449,
-0.0459674709,
0.3262525201,
0.2395690829,
0.1803371012,
0.5362854004,
0.6409389973,
-0.2482189685,
0.218554318,
-0.2971724272,
-0.362291187,
-0.5378800631,
-0.7354056239,
-0.545591712,
-0.7658835649,
-0.408685267,
-0.7312936783,
-0.280212611,
1.2034081221,
0.7250766754,
-0.5857448578,
-0.179565236,
0.4493014514,
0.0211496949,
-0.2656440735,
-0.1323622912,
0.7490372062,
-0.1962848604,
-0.4040268064,
0.2380443066,
0.6125744581,
0.1841948032,
0.0764597282,
-0.0037885967,
-0.15765962,
-0.2389152348,
0.7807461619,
0.0120685622,
-0.3382903039,
-0.0845625848,
-0.0284453724,
-0.3061659932,
0.439954102,
0.8500386477,
-0.7354825735,
0.636520803,
0.6116152406,
0.5058020949,
0.5104268193,
0.2087883204,
0.0955361426,
-0.3070986867,
0.0303767975,
0.4057846963,
0.6712576747,
0.3007744253,
-0.4761246741,
0.0740941688,
0.1412307322,
-0.3907541335,
-0.5988559723,
0.1350482851,
-1.4501931667,
0.0350382142,
1.0078761578,
0.1286796778,
-0.3167226315,
-0.4100724757,
-0.1455716789,
0.2772300541,
-0.2230813354,
0.4835349619,
0.4677182138,
-0.7069182992,
0.1687491387,
-0.5357286334,
0.4120073318,
0.2374818325,
-0.9740774632,
-0.20971407,
0.9218914509,
0.0364808924,
0.3396546543,
0.7720551491,
-0.5105784535,
0.3730899096,
-0.0326128565,
-0.0125042945,
-0.1206648126,
-0.4957878888,
-0.1769324988,
0.3172883987,
-0.10771624,
-0.4678766429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12593v1
|
Standardize: Aligning Language Models with Expert-Defined Standards for Content Generation
| 2024-02-19T23:18:18 | 2024-02-19T23:18:18 |
Joseph Marvin Imperial, Gail Forey, Harish Tayyar Madabushi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Domain experts across engineering, healthcare, and education follow strict
standards for producing quality content such as technical manuals, medication
instructions, and children's reading materials. However, current works in
controllable text generation have yet to explore using these standards as
references for control. Towards this end, we introduce Standardize, a
retrieval-style in-context learning-based framework to guide large language
models to align with expert-defined standards. Focusing on English language
standards in the education domain as a use case, we consider the Common
European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) and Common Core Standards
(CCS) for the task of open-ended content generation. Our findings show that
models can gain 40% to 100% increase in precise accuracy for Llama2 and GPT-4,
respectively, demonstrating that the use of knowledge artifacts extracted from
standards and integrating them in the generation process can effectively guide
models to produce better standard-aligned content.
|
[
-0.1997089386,
-0.3325206935,
0.3872282803,
-0.2056993395,
-0.1668354571,
-0.1565883905,
-0.5530629754,
-0.3034108579,
-0.4036895037,
0.6981980801,
-0.2198126465,
-0.7180690169,
-0.5886440277,
0.0733636916,
-0.4268746674,
0.7118005157,
-0.519223094,
-0.046678029,
-0.4502014816,
-0.0645856857,
-0.4388042688,
-0.3301107585,
-0.5334162116,
-0.3307369649,
0.317702502,
0.6760952473,
0.869019568,
0.8366461396,
0.6790100336,
0.1728204191,
-0.1251218319,
0.3480450511,
-0.609030664,
0.2409342974,
-0.6029745936,
-0.0182120521,
-0.6525710225,
-0.0540259108,
0.4529024959,
0.7532524467,
-0.266779393,
0.1197243482,
0.3262964785,
0.4006220102,
-0.5607540011,
0.1938593537,
-0.5158318281,
-0.2352811992,
-0.0182212405,
-0.2548618317,
-0.4578338861,
-0.5141530633,
0.0817381442,
-0.6262902021,
0.3184813261,
-0.1091024727,
0.9945696592,
0.1308913231,
-0.6781631112,
-0.5531103015,
-0.5617630482,
1.0949862003,
-0.8321437836,
0.6758019328,
0.2810008824,
0.382357955,
-0.2383808047,
-0.8001767397,
-0.4885228276,
-0.0304486081,
-0.0947782993,
-0.1667202413,
0.0989394188,
0.0890558884,
-0.0205607545,
0.1859107763,
-0.4779904485,
0.2734977007,
-0.5199623108,
-0.0015751863,
0.8736512065,
-0.0526958965,
0.4305995703,
0.1211470813,
-0.2325082421,
-0.0140246134,
-1.0757838488,
-0.1399598271,
0.1422993094,
0.4140155017,
0.1818685681,
0.5025888681,
-0.2713532448,
0.6101775765,
0.1973277926,
-0.2489455342,
0.1561216712,
-0.3640392125,
-0.2395901978,
-0.0048618773,
0.4930796623,
0.659494698,
0.4028695822,
-0.1550875455,
-0.483273983,
-0.3074036539,
0.2897393107,
-0.838598907,
-0.0440597981,
-0.0638715178,
-0.2225918025,
-0.2669455707,
-0.0725293458,
-0.4813282192,
-0.031061748,
-0.7238642573,
0.3479335606,
-0.2090385556,
-0.1844165176,
0.3587522507,
0.0481319986,
0.1457556486,
0.2567619681,
-1.0850765705,
0.3459501565,
0.4736474156,
0.4285092652,
-0.3456448317,
0.0650842264,
-0.1134950668,
0.3955537379,
-0.6719834805,
0.6931456327,
-0.5786924958,
-0.5573956966,
0.426507771,
-0.1353740543,
0.254186362,
-0.6110271811,
0.6342428923,
-0.6174778342,
0.179782927,
-0.4296288192,
-0.4741187096,
0.0485588685,
0.12038178,
-0.4983976185,
0.9291397929,
0.1341371685,
-0.4097306132,
0.5718262196,
-0.3938348591,
-0.2171555459,
0.0853808671,
-0.4098132551,
-0.1753781736,
0.0925741568,
0.1414198279,
0.5242239237,
-0.4003009498,
0.6601528525,
0.185896188,
0.0048582531,
-0.2873271108,
-0.2045702636,
0.3324252665,
0.5337080359,
-0.2711356878,
-0.0501885973,
-0.4265675545,
0.1295967549,
0.1192600206,
-0.6572600007,
-0.2823288143,
0.2843576074,
0.1419027746,
0.1097498089,
0.5409681797,
-0.4193766713,
0.0363740996,
0.0509738848,
0.1800263524,
0.5008285046,
0.0902460366,
0.6557881236,
-0.3343976438,
0.2716905475,
-0.0002735105,
0.1138820499,
-0.1697579771,
-0.140272513,
-0.5729752779,
0.1149766818,
0.3202983439,
0.1282456368,
-0.4342944026,
0.4687148631,
-0.3333207369,
-0.5102627277,
-0.4767152369,
0.3309951127,
0.4270513356,
0.8289526701,
0.6849113107,
-0.3844246566,
-0.406018734,
-0.9235165715,
-0.1950933337,
0.190307349,
-0.212249577,
0.2614183128,
0.1566868871,
-0.2698348165,
1.0879513025,
-0.3582162857,
-0.032587301,
-0.1493410468,
0.075256303,
-0.0544391647,
0.7411112189,
0.4500759542,
-0.8751214743,
-0.786886096,
0.1786205471,
-0.7146037817,
-0.2986716628,
0.1738081127,
-0.251544416,
0.1516235918,
0.5987164378,
-0.0869795755,
0.1776056886,
0.5271711349,
-0.216255933,
0.3670105338,
-0.1014556587,
0.2606308162,
-1.1453711987,
0.1565174758,
0.1403616071,
-0.2486572862,
-0.714294374,
0.3989550471,
0.2987551391,
-0.1037609205,
-0.3861482739,
0.6718066335,
-0.4960796535,
0.1204506457,
-0.1703942418,
0.4513377547,
0.2819570899,
0.0459486656,
0.3672908545,
0.8954592347,
0.1835633665,
-0.4753466249,
0.0327711105,
0.3360212445,
-0.1760279983,
0.7346722484,
-0.7870078683,
0.0523402356,
-0.0066791172,
0.0052704336,
-0.4355860054,
-0.3087655604,
-0.340919137,
-0.3801514506,
0.5519375205,
0.2076995671,
-0.6585342884,
-0.1206239015,
0.1727278233,
0.2258806229,
0.7280810475,
-0.6180300117,
0.261033535,
0.4618668854,
-0.3505144715,
-0.6848859191,
-0.5304225683,
-0.1376811564,
0.2865352631,
-0.5626615286,
0.4430521429,
-0.4024011195,
-0.2998636961,
-0.1002435535,
-0.3145737052,
-0.220699966,
-0.0434966497,
-0.2491688877,
0.1458387077,
-0.4535961747,
0.2129027843,
0.5773854852,
0.2056220174,
-0.0951204449,
-0.2108760178,
0.2762429118,
0.1381745487,
-0.4131314158,
-0.2509020269,
0.5730650425,
0.3716406822,
-0.4589438736,
0.4388802946,
0.0155038144,
-0.4828829467,
-0.2960529923,
-0.5888831019,
-0.2173873335,
-0.525770545,
0.3116025627,
-0.2850503623,
-0.8347443938,
0.2195731848,
-0.110615775,
0.4946846664,
0.4603584111,
0.451174736,
0.0846595243,
1.2956365347,
0.973913312,
0.3706709146,
0.2194025367,
0.0385969803,
0.2348895073,
-0.6399792433,
-0.3363841772,
-0.6082009673,
-0.2630127072,
-0.3141701818,
-0.3530825973,
0.0621489733,
0.4427812397,
-0.317817688,
0.4404993057,
-0.7153227329,
0.6076034307,
0.3689402938,
0.0854503661,
0.4670341313,
-0.1765067726,
-0.3551538289,
-0.0781397969,
-0.5687589049,
-1.0112444162,
1.2141392231,
0.4048151374,
0.6344361901,
0.1529568285,
0.9058008194,
0.0325281955,
0.4791992605,
-0.5183667541,
0.399905324,
-0.3751676977,
-0.7429887056,
-0.3084457219,
-0.1086200923,
-0.6841787696,
-0.1946437657,
-0.0858331025,
-0.3709505796,
0.407350421,
0.0510361865,
-0.0974917412,
0.2254474908,
-0.5548622012,
0.7232030034,
0.188324064,
-0.1484837234,
-0.2333588004,
-0.2842846215,
0.1682770997,
-0.3561053574,
0.327891767,
0.0538079143,
-0.3024254739,
0.6595121622,
-0.1622044146,
0.7523229122,
0.0528092757,
-0.2804681957,
0.5238434076,
0.1771561503,
0.3880396485,
-0.1665290743,
-0.170113951,
0.0132765267,
-0.0509139746,
-0.5547950268,
-0.3236396015,
0.7738027573,
-0.932161212,
-0.6462838054,
0.1141823083,
-0.518235147,
-0.0154173989,
0.4402451217,
0.3024776876,
0.3894156218,
-0.3563452065,
0.3171237111,
1.2280939817,
0.0766980276,
0.3174805343,
0.8656768799,
0.182765007,
-0.2596309781,
0.7677069306,
0.483265698,
0.5031742454,
0.3128179908,
-0.0642445236,
-0.0705666244,
-0.6414250731,
-0.2304317057,
0.1515313387,
-0.9444665909,
-0.3093344867,
-0.4611344635,
-0.3644070625,
-0.7733857036,
-0.677690506,
-0.3046989143,
-0.1795189232,
-0.5735846758,
-0.2511208355,
-0.0374287404,
1.0566017628,
-0.0322424211,
0.3897786438,
-0.7399400473,
-0.160884589,
0.3879959285,
0.2843523324,
-0.3319867253,
-0.6463772655,
-0.4948052764,
-0.2573438287,
-0.6273344755,
-1.0377486944,
0.2202596515,
0.3063347042,
0.8466511965,
0.3663645089,
0.1028314978,
0.1713718623,
-0.695882678,
1.0065420866,
0.1054927409,
-1.0364546776,
0.6140104532,
-0.3699261546,
0.2318693697,
0.4799022675,
0.6815744638,
-0.7054166198,
-0.3633441627,
-0.7192784548,
-0.8420855403,
0.113232024,
-0.2729914486,
0.3908470571,
-0.2325501144,
0.3277759254,
0.2577241957,
0.3059816062,
-0.4156443179,
0.1842674166,
-0.0583860874,
-0.7949663401,
-0.1305871308,
-0.2977382243,
-0.3128965199,
0.2077918649,
0.5887179375,
-0.2900082171,
-0.0884521008,
0.1692017019,
-0.148361668,
-0.4072597921,
0.3999385834,
0.5360907316,
1.0588269234,
0.1306815892,
-0.0177896973,
0.0059951097,
-0.409398675,
-0.0555810966,
0.0506951176,
-0.3014123142,
0.0829518735,
0.2001817077,
0.1967870891,
0.4741823375,
-0.6833856106,
0.6606160402,
0.1627553403,
-0.4650482535,
-0.1146301329,
0.4208183289,
-0.0527280383,
0.1644615978,
0.3182463348,
-0.1182151958,
-0.1216632798,
-0.1602744311,
0.6203580499,
0.2207227498,
-0.5318804979,
-0.3537530899,
0.821885705,
0.5713291764,
-0.1786107868,
0.475028336,
-0.0569713451,
-0.0328821614,
0.5498368144,
0.5965899825,
0.6040003896,
-0.4245040119,
0.0952895805,
0.6409903169,
0.1732828021,
-0.4522619843,
0.4086742997,
-0.0259309672,
-0.8082824349,
-0.4628950357,
-0.5753713846,
-0.5254248381,
-0.1145488471,
-0.7886747718,
0.6588605642,
-0.5589530468,
-0.0269216765,
-0.3196346462,
0.0513093211,
-0.8394291401,
0.4729719758,
0.1830979288,
1.2824213505,
-0.9653063416,
0.9131557941,
0.6108754277,
-0.608863771,
-1.0452468395,
-0.1976448894,
-0.1387582421,
-0.4862987697,
0.6135434508,
-0.1587320268,
0.3012696207,
0.2859033942,
-0.7931511998,
-1.0406659842,
1.4127430916,
0.0346410275,
-0.7505096793,
-0.3980544806,
-0.0917739794,
0.5476835966,
-0.717585206,
0.1474064142,
0.6096622944,
0.3477920294,
0.1796195656,
-0.9392334819,
0.0897928476,
-0.0851282626,
-0.0376101956,
0.1855775267,
-0.4341625869,
0.8071772456,
-0.1949881017,
-0.2608865201,
-0.116506353,
0.8783641458,
0.3624071777,
0.0806855634,
0.1129097641,
0.4696058035,
0.7696588039,
0.0716076419,
0.4202659428,
-0.579054594,
0.1471477598,
1.1017324924,
-0.0645197183,
1.18447721,
0.4723932445,
0.2043016702,
0.5952062607,
0.717952311,
0.107094951,
0.498452127,
-0.1130774915,
-0.3158558011,
-0.0811334103,
-0.2312193662,
-0.4543872178,
-0.0808207095,
0.474498719,
-0.6982730627,
-0.3130225539,
-0.1324185878,
0.3791227043,
0.5893494487,
-0.3362951279,
0.7468292713,
-0.0276012141,
-0.7543298006,
0.6510041952,
-0.0005731594,
0.4087702334,
-0.3755117059,
-0.0187650621,
-0.2396568358,
-0.087828286,
-0.2013871521,
-0.7869535685,
0.2069640905,
0.129921481,
-0.2274372727,
-0.4106346369,
0.4872723222,
-0.8203469515,
-0.2649298608,
0.0694399551,
0.3257165551,
0.0288998,
0.3791807294,
-0.3572424352,
-0.1806681901,
-0.0140086822,
-0.3170273006,
0.3547315001,
0.4413686395,
-0.1112451553,
0.3595132232,
0.3387920558,
0.1081084684,
0.1012420356,
-0.0625736043,
0.9082546234,
-0.1844634414,
-0.1589579284,
-0.1777871996,
0.8345696926,
-0.092812255,
-0.3895964324,
0.2876695395,
0.5190188885,
1.2236258984,
0.1329997629,
0.8571591973,
-0.0919697657,
0.4238094985,
-0.3479701579,
0.7327025533,
-0.6753683686,
0.1072276533,
0.2054087222,
-0.8894299269,
-0.3445040286,
0.169052422,
-0.4065573812,
-0.0756244808,
0.7275656462,
0.8012676239,
-0.0706612542,
-0.2102844566,
0.4228084385,
-0.0006932685,
0.5762900114,
0.1956246793,
0.1911375374,
-0.3110075593,
0.5405015945,
-0.0634854287,
-0.5715642571,
-0.1937267631,
-0.8062022328,
-0.8085663915,
-0.6003479958,
-0.3227696121,
-0.1033687517,
0.1836262047,
0.9623731375,
0.6957572699,
-0.7641786933,
-0.254745245,
-0.0348189399,
-0.1245106533,
-0.1290954649,
-0.1508771479,
0.2327972949,
-0.9098246694,
-0.9536377788,
0.4380990565,
-0.1500037014,
0.1753793508,
-0.4600092173,
-0.1872679591,
0.1327809244,
0.5654999614,
0.331826061,
0.2863669097,
-0.5725251436,
-0.4229393601,
0.2192368805,
-0.6608747244,
0.0609806962,
0.7059348226,
-0.4262941778,
0.5603205562,
0.5860302448,
0.3933095634,
-0.0465520956,
-0.0518368483,
0.8788070679,
-0.7989265919,
-0.1620551944,
0.3747130036,
0.2055838257,
0.4111733139,
-0.4879430532,
0.364859581,
-0.1106989756,
-1.0607692003,
-0.6363831162,
0.4570164382,
-0.4831870794,
-0.2190411985,
1.0149835348,
-0.1380603462,
-0.2517350316,
0.0603694916,
-0.0601361431,
0.3232448995,
-0.4538658261,
0.5960506797,
0.511826098,
0.1749072373,
-0.1350840032,
-0.7655315995,
0.7095836997,
0.103727214,
-0.4620655179,
0.0399798751,
0.296371609,
0.3261772394,
0.1884863973,
0.4516043663,
-0.280354768,
0.2128687203,
-0.1704799235,
0.4941469431,
0.1169750541,
-0.369307816,
-0.0461784154,
0.0197917409,
0.3296602666,
0.2226118445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12590v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12590v2
|
Evolving AI Collectives to Enhance Human Diversity and Enable Self-Regulation
| 2024-02-19T22:59:43 | 2024-06-18T23:28:46 |
Shiyang Lai, Yujin Potter, Junsol Kim, Richard Zhuang, Dawn Song, James Evans
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large language model behavior is shaped by the language of those with whom
they interact. This capacity and their increasing prevalence online portend
that they will intentionally or unintentionally "program" one another and form
emergent AI subjectivities, relationships, and collectives. Here, we call upon
the research community to investigate these "societies" of interacting
artificial intelligences to increase their rewards and reduce their risks for
human society and the health of online environments. We use a small "community"
of models and their evolving outputs to illustrate how such emergent,
decentralized AI collectives can spontaneously expand the bounds of human
diversity and reduce the risk of toxic, anti-social behavior online. Finally,
we discuss opportunities for AI cross-moderation and address ethical issues and
design challenges associated with creating and maintaining free-formed AI
collectives.
|
[
-0.3386023939,
-0.4143355191,
0.224603191,
0.0273552556,
0.1710222363,
0.4396532178,
-0.1538735628,
-1.0333365202,
0.370814234,
0.4631612003,
-0.5222561359,
0.1438377351,
-0.5545670986,
0.0816499516,
-0.3990206718,
1.1506791115,
0.4415538907,
-0.0634264797,
-0.2771254778,
-0.3227406144,
-0.3069610298,
-0.5685261488,
-0.6568341255,
-0.1757088155,
0.6906347275,
0.3245016932,
0.6735278964,
0.6255340576,
0.5759499073,
0.4232044518,
0.070577547,
0.1297764927,
-0.7256312966,
0.2644527853,
-0.1831307262,
-0.4296682775,
-0.1617107242,
0.1985815912,
0.2732844055,
0.6424902678,
-0.1851395518,
0.2272173017,
0.0983233154,
0.4958126247,
-0.5133584738,
-0.0478874482,
-0.4142821431,
-0.0794948637,
-0.0642436519,
0.158150807,
-0.1326435357,
-0.4360453784,
0.1076099053,
-0.4917177856,
-0.2072843462,
0.0794989392,
0.3409576118,
0.2966878414,
-0.2447517663,
-0.077879861,
-1.1013536453,
0.5992495418,
-0.2333742678,
0.2634219527,
0.3483278751,
0.236287415,
-0.1327796429,
-0.7465502024,
-0.390211314,
-0.1342676133,
-0.00275695,
0.0170969609,
-0.5174043775,
-0.0223450437,
-0.3209090531,
0.3394552171,
-0.3038478196,
0.3000132442,
-0.8888269663,
-0.1126861796,
0.9184327126,
0.2270802259,
0.9049748778,
0.3417840898,
0.0887058228,
0.0122609604,
-0.616337955,
0.1368447393,
0.4243920445,
0.2951393425,
-0.2007490844,
0.3425959051,
-0.0219002906,
0.151421234,
0.1107352003,
0.4998987913,
0.172006309,
-0.5399098396,
-0.0569813401,
-0.0461170971,
0.7584982514,
0.1718454361,
0.2335077226,
-0.2019448429,
-0.0364932306,
0.0956245214,
0.4982428551,
-0.4493320882,
-0.4596770108,
0.1143888086,
-0.8313847184,
-0.5516713858,
0.2978258729,
-0.656046629,
-0.6506687999,
-0.1061149389,
0.3451710641,
0.094278276,
-0.584394455,
-0.2411476374,
-0.4592275321,
0.1126496419,
0.2348608524,
-0.9116824865,
0.5170815587,
0.6079767346,
0.7389259338,
-0.0682307258,
-0.3706112504,
-0.3316873312,
0.1688778251,
-0.2807531059,
0.536944747,
-0.464519769,
-0.615925312,
-0.2150887102,
-0.2502890229,
0.3450889885,
-0.6156231165,
-0.0700719282,
-0.4291502237,
0.410038054,
-0.1627025455,
-0.2931613624,
0.0137854423,
0.2392750531,
-0.7017452717,
0.5603716373,
0.2527321577,
-0.3566901088,
0.127027005,
-1.1941651106,
-0.5100234747,
0.4471720159,
-0.2735719979,
-0.127557531,
0.0540519804,
0.0578230582,
0.0502269529,
-0.1383462846,
0.0009419718,
-0.4548946023,
-0.1175937131,
0.2895610929,
-0.299826622,
1.2478456497,
0.3756688237,
-0.3981662095,
0.6636765599,
-0.1467655301,
-0.0902632847,
-0.0008750808,
-0.2725357413,
-0.6186862588,
0.2297377735,
-0.211663425,
0.3163955808,
0.1273674369,
-0.3126058578,
0.217685163,
-0.2758232057,
0.9725068808,
1.0430432558,
0.1638324708,
0.5415225625,
-0.9522975683,
0.504658401,
-0.1430082023,
0.804086566,
0.1639720798,
-0.6882124543,
-0.7661198974,
-0.2685728371,
0.006989697,
0.4130224288,
-0.5167093873,
0.7417666912,
-0.1036849543,
-0.7443572283,
-0.7786151767,
0.1767650247,
0.0035682751,
-0.1945718676,
0.3484405875,
-0.3114425838,
-0.2998736799,
-0.6895663142,
-0.203526631,
-0.3294406235,
-0.2440924793,
0.3468802869,
0.3365515769,
-0.6462077498,
1.0020523071,
-0.012980056,
-0.1965026408,
-0.426482439,
0.2944936752,
-0.3825704157,
0.6719676256,
0.5396767855,
-0.7874501944,
-0.3258253038,
-0.0529183559,
-0.5675439835,
0.0511360317,
-0.0665020272,
-0.1438108236,
-0.2388818264,
0.5588657856,
-0.4052434564,
0.1044172421,
0.5784668922,
-0.3820440471,
0.1363074481,
-0.1780047715,
0.2241440266,
-1.1122450829,
-0.1279715598,
-0.3236141205,
-0.0945313126,
-0.8057381511,
0.306692481,
-0.5316531062,
-0.0522352047,
-0.3176267743,
0.6361855268,
-0.418731153,
0.0117295627,
-0.3129939437,
0.095524393,
-0.3582834601,
-0.0816692039,
-0.3131779432,
0.5247979164,
0.6274405122,
-0.7846150398,
0.368332684,
0.2544608116,
-0.3310134113,
0.0881859437,
-0.5839856863,
0.0791522637,
-0.2193912417,
0.3891453147,
-0.5595734715,
-0.3559231758,
0.3565912545,
-0.4179927409,
-0.251000762,
0.3788089156,
-0.1997552067,
-0.4325661361,
-0.2795243263,
0.927144289,
0.6894599199,
-0.4839256108,
0.5773009062,
0.9817416072,
-0.2118414938,
-0.2685491145,
-0.8643453121,
0.2467067242,
-0.3474223316,
-0.5956792831,
-0.1175645068,
-0.4179533124,
-0.9061704874,
0.0900520757,
0.4529044926,
0.0855775177,
0.5107309222,
0.3235762119,
0.0675761029,
0.0098734312,
0.244139716,
0.0118707558,
0.1384561062,
0.0806045458,
-0.3282907903,
0.6707327366,
-0.2752235532,
-0.263277024,
-0.5377192497,
0.6062690616,
0.6259402037,
-0.4410374761,
0.8059049249,
0.259459734,
-0.4290787876,
-0.1658765227,
-0.2566952407,
-0.4208128154,
-0.5850135684,
0.2899737358,
0.1966988891,
-1.3833159208,
0.5771567225,
0.0233288631,
0.2478864044,
0.6039648652,
0.8404458761,
0.0074720639,
0.9190570116,
0.8527154326,
-0.2590357661,
0.6430359483,
0.1258049011,
0.1842393577,
-0.3535284996,
-0.1740404665,
-0.5231419206,
-0.547703445,
-0.9527007341,
-0.4676196575,
0.4992073774,
-0.2485132366,
-0.3965874612,
-0.0199254993,
-0.7899064422,
0.7382104993,
0.6821738482,
0.1956980079,
0.1063802764,
-0.4416974187,
0.4717050791,
0.3042660952,
-0.6915985942,
-0.1833826602,
0.8900014758,
0.2613051832,
0.8404129148,
0.4842219055,
0.8118482232,
0.9393482208,
0.6979342103,
-0.4403741062,
0.2719911635,
-0.0985283181,
-0.8011197448,
-0.4291127026,
-0.5381254554,
-1.2502051592,
-0.1368378252,
-0.3701782227,
-0.7599295974,
0.3276728392,
0.0579835549,
-0.6078707576,
0.3284790516,
-0.2421905249,
0.5529485345,
-0.5146560073,
-0.1229511499,
-0.6732714772,
-0.8091099262,
0.446610868,
-0.0857356191,
0.5323018432,
-0.0501513816,
0.1527200937,
0.516374886,
-0.1149424911,
1.1058448553,
0.3085578382,
0.0529529974,
0.6023932695,
0.1353245825,
0.114700444,
0.0383841433,
-0.1076763123,
0.2888662517,
-0.2648386657,
-0.383890599,
-0.3132904768,
0.5489630699,
-1.3568941355,
-0.8204492331,
-0.1954845339,
-0.3834586442,
0.203390196,
0.2911399007,
0.0653303415,
0.071352981,
-0.4379075766,
0.3256535828,
0.3960710168,
-0.0783211291,
0.4211981595,
0.1534612328,
-0.213040486,
-0.4496610761,
0.9372128248,
-0.125207603,
0.4984279275,
0.0139371855,
0.4982979298,
-0.0955610722,
-0.3285113275,
-0.1665725857,
-0.1689450443,
-0.5266467333,
-0.1195631102,
-0.4320660532,
-0.236321941,
-0.9317171574,
-0.29924348,
-0.1148984432,
-0.359403044,
-0.4804160595,
-0.0527751669,
0.3342609406,
1.3477822542,
-0.5376425385,
0.2734740973,
-1.1402779818,
-0.0812647194,
0.6499236822,
0.3197211325,
-0.0567035042,
-0.1888592094,
-0.04699843,
0.139289096,
-0.0116821034,
-0.8605501056,
0.2488162965,
0.2871727943,
0.7925758362,
0.7112898827,
0.3605948091,
0.3020998538,
-0.2280574292,
0.8062053919,
0.1398754269,
-0.9376846552,
0.373544693,
-0.4530027509,
0.0140849827,
0.6578728557,
0.2563249469,
-0.9500874281,
-0.7302404642,
-0.6364846826,
-0.7071152329,
0.4567666054,
0.3223421574,
0.6576458216,
-0.0770254657,
0.4655413628,
0.0196434837,
0.1135888249,
-1.0297768116,
-0.1655617654,
-0.3418497741,
-0.2129267156,
0.1817064881,
0.211813122,
-0.5706753731,
-0.2414515764,
0.4766599834,
-0.0474576503,
0.1108287945,
-0.0551916212,
0.2892112434,
-0.4257643819,
0.1261308938,
0.5675929785,
0.2474273294,
0.498641789,
0.1740616113,
-0.1339485794,
-0.1423327625,
0.1653372049,
-0.2316448987,
-0.1560032219,
-0.8217229843,
0.2092941254,
0.5283495188,
-0.2115751803,
-0.8728885055,
0.2378807664,
-0.4347503781,
-0.1410427392,
-0.2677713037,
0.6285091639,
0.0457471795,
0.538798511,
0.2551487386,
0.2636322081,
0.1608321071,
-0.9762429595,
0.3402199447,
0.4527153969,
-0.3244145811,
-0.1532243192,
0.6374396086,
0.6710098386,
-0.8175718784,
0.7739472985,
-0.3466628492,
-0.481143266,
0.828181684,
0.4326204062,
0.8622894883,
-0.2721575499,
0.1505556107,
0.1335157156,
0.61406672,
-0.0318282358,
-0.1915988773,
0.0594413653,
-1.0355268717,
0.0560735874,
-0.3729197681,
-0.4458741546,
-0.04036735,
-0.2171949446,
0.0846365392,
-0.6041072607,
-0.0942664593,
-0.1231456473,
-0.3089040518,
-0.2201947421,
-0.0266369581,
0.2614073455,
0.4186375737,
-0.7935045958,
0.6123530865,
0.6821506023,
-0.5549206138,
-0.5415783525,
0.156174317,
-0.0127653405,
-0.7053246498,
0.2432705909,
0.2280692011,
-0.0868123472,
0.1087114215,
-0.7678615451,
-1.0691469908,
0.9591844678,
-0.0834932998,
-0.3412442803,
0.0496962555,
0.1020927951,
0.7798749804,
-0.4735715389,
0.0348457545,
0.2785568535,
0.6445081234,
-0.2488865554,
-0.8209340572,
-0.0097922366,
-0.4830847979,
-0.341716975,
0.1235033199,
-0.996835053,
0.9917371869,
-0.3200233579,
-0.1598127335,
0.1766765863,
0.8089896441,
-0.0278428756,
0.0429825597,
0.769431591,
0.0679135025,
0.9037969112,
0.2483229786,
0.8091693521,
-0.2392001152,
0.0929657593,
0.9460945725,
-0.3033082485,
0.4918418229,
0.183230564,
-0.0160720516,
0.6252065897,
0.7578039169,
-0.3492230773,
0.2657179534,
0.3202866316,
-0.5237749815,
-0.4348536432,
-0.3777651489,
-0.1203267053,
0.851236403,
0.3971894085,
-0.3049847186,
0.0653357506,
0.0861730799,
-0.364060849,
0.236786589,
-0.4345930815,
0.9264947772,
-0.1852556765,
-0.7178630829,
-0.282707423,
-0.0939752832,
0.7626473904,
-0.2630933523,
0.1300141662,
-0.1394631863,
0.1042887196,
-0.1153461784,
-0.4785230756,
0.3033748269,
-0.3231967092,
-0.0193607956,
-0.1676239371,
0.6236984134,
-0.4236440659,
-0.4720375538,
0.5577005148,
0.8171620965,
0.1229594052,
0.272508353,
-0.7244843245,
-0.1553031355,
-0.2238155901,
0.1595986784,
0.4155041575,
0.2066288739,
-0.2861067355,
0.8463466167,
0.7625617981,
0.0229723938,
0.1708961725,
-0.0385433137,
1.015555501,
-0.2865197957,
-0.7505033612,
-0.8695934415,
0.3206389248,
-0.1495037973,
-0.4449372292,
0.354136914,
0.1550522,
0.7851431966,
0.3196791708,
1.1199483871,
-0.4144754708,
0.0331094489,
0.0832226127,
1.3397622108,
-0.6985011697,
-0.1006616056,
0.1453930289,
-0.3963980079,
-0.4408262074,
0.4423747361,
0.0406080671,
0.2737099826,
-0.0277053416,
0.4884503484,
0.2372479439,
0.0851132348,
0.3109223247,
0.3308001459,
0.6197941303,
0.0778819025,
1.0380060673,
0.2125554234,
0.5140859485,
-0.1272874027,
-0.3599962294,
-0.1317663193,
-0.5372849703,
-0.7185695171,
-0.3648240864,
-0.2495708168,
-0.2071062028,
-0.0490690917,
1.3127311468,
0.6570945382,
-0.8954684138,
-0.3735275567,
-0.2016313672,
0.252220273,
-0.2297034115,
-0.2496100068,
-0.2901103199,
-0.234909147,
-0.6768853664,
0.4736470878,
0.2486258,
0.1432012469,
-0.706174612,
-0.3109949529,
-0.1723325849,
0.2681055367,
0.4432552159,
0.7117642164,
-0.4499093592,
-0.5330402255,
0.0221288782,
-0.2645517588,
-0.0152092427,
0.9542537332,
-0.3984699547,
0.3963473737,
0.4625816047,
0.8048578501,
-0.2585867941,
0.0423210859,
0.775539279,
-0.5068700314,
-0.0927039385,
0.581076324,
0.1448353082,
0.0166588724,
-0.5388476253,
0.4550562799,
0.2761955857,
-0.9575061798,
-0.6250188947,
0.3265339732,
-0.5874605179,
-0.592782259,
0.7806338668,
0.0360943116,
-0.0414717272,
-0.3554106951,
0.0127947964,
0.4863613546,
-0.4890865088,
1.5437961817,
0.401966989,
-0.6822782755,
-0.1712974757,
-0.1207412705,
0.5657723546,
0.2800405324,
-1.4469995499,
0.1842586249,
0.5832290053,
0.1168062463,
0.3991717696,
0.7506083846,
0.1538683772,
0.3160478175,
-0.2086936384,
0.0818471685,
0.291754812,
-0.3560757935,
-0.3925285041,
0.0833461732,
0.1098992601,
0.0975581929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15525v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15525v1
|
Detecting misinformation through Framing Theory: the Frame Element-based Model
| 2024-02-19T21:50:42 | 2024-02-19T21:50:42 |
Guan Wang, Rebecca Frederick, Jinglong Duan, William Wong, Verica Rupar, Weihua Li, Quan Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In this paper, we delve into the rapidly evolving challenge of misinformation
detection, with a specific focus on the nuanced manipulation of narrative
frames - an under-explored area within the AI community. The potential for
Generative AI models to generate misleading narratives underscores the urgency
of this problem. Drawing from communication and framing theories, we posit that
the presentation or 'framing' of accurate information can dramatically alter
its interpretation, potentially leading to misinformation. We highlight this
issue through real-world examples, demonstrating how shifts in narrative frames
can transmute fact-based information into misinformation. To tackle this
challenge, we propose an innovative approach leveraging the power of
pre-trained Large Language Models and deep neural networks to detect
misinformation originating from accurate facts portrayed under different
frames. These advanced AI techniques offer unprecedented capabilities in
identifying complex patterns within unstructured data critical for examining
the subtleties of narrative frames. The objective of this paper is to bridge a
significant research gap in the AI domain, providing valuable insights and
methodologies for tackling framing-induced misinformation, thus contributing to
the advancement of responsible and trustworthy AI technologies. Several
experiments are intensively conducted and experimental results explicitly
demonstrate the various impact of elements of framing theory proving the
rationale of applying framing theory to increase the performance in
misinformation detection.
|
[
-0.4644921124,
-1.1229470968,
0.6833335161,
-0.1492830366,
-0.0179288257,
0.1313246936,
0.1937264055,
-0.7541649938,
0.0837594047,
0.2655988932,
-0.5354006886,
-0.1690974981,
-0.9067006111,
-0.2083581686,
-0.5543364882,
0.7959786057,
0.0787862614,
0.1646759212,
0.0475604683,
-0.0498351865,
-0.7874911427,
-0.4119475782,
-0.322694689,
-0.4874907434,
0.168462351,
0.2419990599,
0.913834095,
0.7583137155,
0.2869626284,
0.1767252535,
-0.0531642884,
0.2690818608,
-0.3224151731,
0.0510679595,
-0.0601611175,
-0.8647411466,
-0.1727999896,
0.2762714922,
0.658551693,
0.4520791173,
0.0681111217,
0.1961231828,
0.0136684934,
0.435143739,
-0.7229321003,
0.3698750138,
-0.4943780005,
0.3249818981,
-0.4892820716,
-0.3465819359,
-0.6227806211,
-0.1385360956,
-0.0481928177,
-0.5712701082,
0.4038290679,
0.5305974483,
0.8944938183,
0.3179944158,
-0.305380404,
-0.318623364,
-0.8818588853,
0.314309746,
-0.8261547089,
0.1922105104,
0.47730878,
0.0563330241,
0.0465429947,
-0.4915921986,
-0.7326135635,
-0.0879097208,
-0.2883433104,
-0.1121774837,
-0.5200819373,
-0.1318406314,
0.5808792114,
0.1048606634,
-0.7470783591,
0.0692706257,
-0.3555019498,
-0.3417874277,
0.602763474,
0.054086253,
0.6388358474,
-0.2602277994,
-0.4346930087,
-0.1671008915,
-0.7898948193,
-0.1891124696,
0.2779538929,
0.1150321588,
-0.1804148257,
0.4970622063,
-0.0229054354,
0.3683165014,
0.4849124253,
0.146692425,
0.2128570676,
-0.2933306694,
-0.273460865,
0.6227930784,
0.4360577166,
0.5522204638,
0.1958246231,
0.0158048049,
-0.2826808095,
0.461163938,
0.3891680837,
-0.6677560806,
-0.0010359773,
-0.3325340152,
-0.6289851665,
-0.4430199564,
0.2649351954,
-0.8601431847,
-0.5880185962,
-0.2079405189,
0.3990867734,
-0.5330930948,
-0.3669248521,
-0.0387147143,
-0.3183141649,
0.2714725435,
0.2040872425,
-0.5082066655,
-0.2571226358,
0.6740266681,
0.7087310553,
0.0958059058,
-0.2050504535,
-0.524969697,
0.2146428674,
-0.6146499515,
0.7992680669,
-0.7273403406,
0.0119057531,
0.0302177202,
-0.2257732004,
-0.0855355337,
-0.3566308916,
0.2427974045,
-0.7059497237,
0.4367158413,
0.0613299236,
-0.7229678631,
-0.4467561245,
0.5286998749,
-0.892374754,
0.6416702271,
-0.108891435,
-0.8245632648,
0.2344009131,
-0.7025697231,
-0.407199353,
0.0216373485,
-0.2308148593,
-0.4584300816,
0.3340670168,
0.4291834831,
0.2522337735,
-0.1731438488,
0.7528547645,
-0.2317347825,
-0.4581765831,
0.4536503255,
-1.181428194,
0.3903785944,
0.290459156,
-0.7380613089,
-0.0484452397,
-0.4258033037,
-0.1786948442,
0.0775822252,
-0.0122778211,
-0.2554368377,
-0.199042052,
-0.1280822009,
-0.1336337775,
-0.1233002245,
-0.2581370175,
-0.1080814227,
-0.377277106,
0.222555384,
0.4638672769,
-0.0167948119,
0.535032928,
-0.5419398546,
0.3977517486,
0.3166022897,
0.0767489001,
-0.6833466291,
-0.4719094634,
-0.4971475899,
0.3321077228,
0.316397965,
0.5972773433,
-1.1468937397,
0.2383264005,
-0.1532945335,
-0.1305579096,
-0.5933573842,
-0.3181067407,
0.4564066231,
0.6339375973,
0.3657393754,
-0.279614687,
-0.3802658916,
-0.7925436497,
-0.5664194822,
-0.2831952274,
0.1285450011,
-0.2658337355,
0.2929896116,
-0.1308103204,
1.1393992901,
-0.4388493896,
-0.0225583147,
-0.1807224005,
0.7111820579,
-0.1390545219,
0.5378860831,
0.691596508,
-1.2767738104,
-0.068234019,
-0.4429546893,
-0.918320477,
0.1917180419,
-0.3460468054,
0.4239623845,
0.2982620001,
0.6157939434,
-0.7578909993,
0.8652508259,
0.2665730119,
-0.5381224155,
0.5008038878,
-0.0238680989,
0.477976352,
-1.0166913271,
-0.1103586257,
0.1376723498,
-0.2789306641,
-0.6084997058,
-0.0615829937,
-0.0282541309,
-0.1553038508,
-0.2613710463,
0.2513134181,
-0.3904054761,
0.0002094843,
-0.5062770247,
0.149487108,
0.1805768609,
0.4688626528,
-0.2642865777,
0.6954223514,
0.2521406412,
-0.328119725,
0.3889957666,
0.2598407269,
-0.7257534862,
0.693836689,
-0.212867111,
-0.1929589361,
-0.5592250824,
0.5050587058,
-0.8591473699,
-0.357452482,
0.8317059875,
-0.7711046338,
0.5337303877,
-0.0582117103,
-0.358723253,
-0.002339409,
-0.1328184754,
0.5260383487,
0.0146493865,
-0.557251513,
0.4526923597,
0.3341167271,
0.0127570815,
-0.7380095124,
-1.0563719273,
0.2556029856,
-0.3297041655,
-0.5411244631,
0.3457395434,
-0.1100363135,
-0.4062617123,
0.4079229236,
-0.3139802217,
-0.2289426178,
0.2772558331,
0.3238545656,
0.2542223632,
-0.6139195561,
0.4198196828,
-0.1312003583,
-0.4389652014,
0.0404624566,
-0.1845108867,
0.3092053831,
-0.1866174936,
-0.5889512897,
-0.8121858239,
0.4624116421,
0.6124384403,
-0.2518313527,
0.6916748881,
0.6948118806,
-0.5164386034,
-0.1746960729,
-0.6571614146,
-0.2527150214,
-0.3471897244,
0.5546114445,
-0.1139103398,
-0.8449782133,
-0.0168948639,
-0.2454622239,
-0.4210082889,
0.5458861589,
0.1169816777,
-0.1010815278,
0.9542652369,
0.7210016847,
-0.4192624986,
0.5527825952,
-0.195931986,
0.6431319118,
-0.5719157457,
-0.0619918555,
-0.273442775,
-0.4521551728,
-0.1937451065,
-0.482570231,
0.3361156285,
0.2044250816,
-0.2605183423,
0.1077247411,
-0.3276938796,
0.6480526924,
0.394226402,
-0.0483049043,
0.4021818638,
-0.1926873177,
0.3129968047,
0.1745259315,
-0.8693688512,
-0.5597419739,
1.0094794035,
0.4676682353,
0.5909688473,
-0.088019602,
0.023787884,
1.0165143013,
0.5039726496,
-0.453861028,
0.1787454039,
0.3550941348,
-0.9305493236,
-0.1902129352,
-0.3028593063,
-0.4774192572,
0.0823297128,
-0.574695766,
-0.5110161304,
0.2849740386,
0.0837302804,
-0.463627845,
0.6645851731,
-0.6573267579,
0.7177565694,
-0.3875674009,
-0.000062928,
-0.5488170385,
-0.7108402252,
0.3841921091,
-0.0698100477,
0.4036129117,
-0.3446544707,
0.5004310608,
0.3671412766,
0.2409355044,
1.0864105225,
-0.1783750057,
0.1768908799,
0.115061976,
0.1750886887,
0.4331537783,
0.1712432206,
0.0109250341,
0.3300958276,
-0.3169899583,
-0.0954244286,
-0.7685464025,
0.1480214596,
-0.5039134622,
-0.6438587904,
-0.4429088533,
-0.6281612515,
-0.1011614501,
0.0093560126,
0.4997496605,
0.5169253349,
-0.4836451113,
0.14066948,
0.7003316879,
0.0339203253,
0.6689872146,
0.3588686585,
0.0331272818,
-0.0150255719,
0.7111814618,
0.1518581808,
-0.1051772237,
0.5089543462,
-0.082646735,
-0.0253452212,
-0.5806989074,
-0.700114131,
-0.0658310652,
-0.6532219648,
-0.4625335038,
-0.0863656402,
-0.4210710824,
-0.1834778935,
-0.0726342797,
-0.381832689,
-0.2741984427,
-0.3788568079,
-0.4894498289,
-0.1017062962,
0.875647366,
-0.0390637293,
0.5697396994,
-0.8233014941,
0.2661492229,
-0.0375414044,
0.2492685616,
-0.006069819,
-0.2393916547,
-0.3647321761,
0.5942364931,
-0.4068207741,
-0.845048964,
0.3264077902,
-0.2401015162,
0.752761364,
0.6927034855,
0.1122122332,
0.5051702857,
-0.2748468816,
0.8267162442,
0.2727906406,
-1.0076011419,
0.4088135064,
-0.0515859015,
-0.1196793094,
0.3413926065,
0.4453341067,
-0.6080240011,
-0.1555762142,
-0.8562252522,
-0.4471275806,
0.8109741807,
0.0379796438,
0.1439045519,
0.2330898941,
0.3168680966,
0.0597707182,
0.426982969,
-0.8070495725,
-0.2227795571,
-0.2201979011,
-0.3054849505,
-0.0291369557,
-0.4066905379,
-0.2806783915,
0.1019169018,
0.8234118223,
-0.3055269122,
0.2374102622,
0.2078268826,
-0.4688795805,
-0.0517956056,
0.1958574653,
0.6523666978,
0.8373155594,
0.2685722709,
0.2193361372,
0.0378003754,
-0.0812789425,
0.0884792358,
0.111326687,
-0.4535588026,
0.0763700083,
0.7841264009,
1.0749000311,
0.2831783295,
-0.3627938926,
0.8046949506,
0.0381305777,
0.0615127832,
-0.1935460418,
0.1375586838,
-0.1058334038,
0.7846896052,
0.488948077,
0.6708579659,
-0.0644148216,
-0.7462414503,
0.4186905026,
0.291798234,
-0.3496872783,
-0.3505504429,
0.6197528243,
0.2314426154,
-0.5943031907,
0.6695516109,
0.0742128417,
-0.4243092239,
0.5699617267,
0.4331181347,
0.7713805437,
-0.2545360029,
0.5263273716,
-0.1053448245,
0.4388929605,
-0.3588604033,
-0.7107081413,
-0.2182642817,
-1.3114804029,
-0.2403366566,
-0.2571441233,
-0.0979874656,
0.1188627332,
-0.5290811062,
-0.1573427022,
-0.2679209709,
-0.2083193362,
0.0703635514,
-0.4397951663,
-0.313193351,
0.086301811,
0.811866343,
0.8081362844,
-0.8992673755,
0.6839470863,
0.209537521,
-0.4829171896,
-0.60175246,
0.7111614943,
0.4672020376,
-0.7742076516,
0.4135331511,
0.366722554,
-0.1861241162,
-0.3255310953,
-0.9241525531,
-0.8972207308,
1.1463856697,
0.6177878976,
-0.453607887,
-0.3010167181,
0.2525524199,
0.2106183916,
-0.8517004848,
0.1528468728,
0.6274797916,
0.7482919693,
0.0622176938,
-0.6166090965,
-0.1132260561,
-0.300031662,
0.1218785942,
-0.0571268387,
-0.4332102239,
0.7375658154,
0.0381257832,
-0.2895349562,
-0.2078693658,
0.6141186953,
-0.0437683575,
0.8995790482,
0.4438336492,
0.5191778541,
0.8351647258,
-0.1462085992,
0.7884912491,
-0.4321207106,
0.2645536065,
0.9745550752,
-0.1581350565,
0.3803700805,
0.1649111658,
0.4139018655,
0.6142576337,
0.3563654721,
-0.1201528683,
0.2781613469,
-0.1229178384,
-0.037643455,
-0.2750707269,
-0.02020666,
-0.3674054742,
0.6336816549,
0.5574734211,
-0.3273158669,
-0.3594124615,
0.4262453616,
0.285594821,
0.2780496478,
-0.3552118838,
0.5736085773,
-0.1119269654,
-0.5840420723,
0.1240167618,
0.3361622989,
0.7410727143,
-0.4936647117,
-0.1888967305,
-0.0965653881,
0.1935801804,
-0.0773776472,
-0.6530071497,
0.7694291472,
-0.1040796265,
-0.4638287127,
-0.5636956692,
1.0091680288,
-0.4354300797,
-0.2725717127,
0.2206244022,
0.6143762469,
-0.3174845576,
-0.3365367651,
-0.566912353,
0.2828933597,
0.1369038522,
-0.1143101826,
0.1320408136,
0.3690850139,
0.0056059361,
0.491579473,
0.4877850413,
-0.242115289,
-0.2180111855,
-0.5353548527,
0.7563037872,
-0.6825171113,
-0.6953033209,
-0.8737254739,
0.3986306787,
-0.2245337218,
-0.135629192,
0.5572737455,
0.4915615916,
1.0020580292,
0.1578020453,
0.9237644076,
0.1407410055,
0.2349437177,
-0.6699424386,
1.1150882244,
-0.2988709211,
0.3662289083,
-0.036827419,
-0.69249928,
-0.2897059619,
0.5088513494,
-0.3299527466,
-0.193775028,
0.60819906,
0.7315988541,
-0.0365799777,
0.9036707878,
0.2695406377,
0.5904676318,
0.3226830959,
0.3216494322,
0.9142270684,
-0.353264153,
0.3877581954,
0.2518286705,
-0.1596634835,
-0.3933420479,
-0.6767446995,
-0.4569413662,
-0.7393347025,
-0.3136980534,
-0.142574057,
0.3867758512,
0.6373177767,
0.91320014,
-0.6128807664,
0.1887483001,
0.0381632075,
0.4447636008,
-0.1587974876,
-0.2828291953,
0.1708551794,
-0.1960504055,
-0.4651624858,
0.8434120417,
0.3872920573,
0.0796619207,
-0.1587361693,
0.0262552258,
-0.2692478597,
0.3129962981,
0.3718937635,
0.2091160268,
-0.4094180465,
-0.5850790739,
-0.6200023293,
-0.0694665387,
0.3761393428,
1.02754426,
-1.0237807035,
0.323431462,
0.168262437,
0.8751060367,
0.5773038864,
0.1668487787,
0.6287372708,
-0.8207688332,
0.1264401674,
0.2515076995,
0.1468364,
0.3856348693,
-0.6229128242,
0.3413248658,
0.6727246642,
-0.0956069827,
-0.7221517563,
0.2801180482,
-0.4618113935,
-0.7950787544,
0.5946640968,
-0.0072210133,
-0.2668860853,
-0.0652473569,
-0.0178023875,
0.223488003,
-0.1951038688,
0.9855339527,
0.9416049719,
-0.2124009728,
0.0088626072,
-0.4800284207,
0.5965231657,
0.2446992993,
-0.670096755,
0.0064523118,
0.7219666839,
0.2691088021,
0.5214168429,
0.5272491574,
0.0610366426,
0.1995751411,
0.2240129411,
-0.2018300146,
-0.5165333748,
-0.5987894535,
-0.3957917094,
0.5528533459,
-0.6260992289,
-0.3404998779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12566v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12566v2
|
GenAudit: Fixing Factual Errors in Language Model Outputs with Evidence
| 2024-02-19T21:45:55 | 2024-03-16T21:14:16 |
Kundan Krishna, Sanjana Ramprasad, Prakhar Gupta, Byron C. Wallace, Zachary C. Lipton, Jeffrey P. Bigham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
LLMs can generate factually incorrect statements even when provided access to
reference documents. Such errors can be dangerous in high-stakes applications
(e.g., document-grounded QA for healthcare or finance). We present GenAudit --
a tool intended to assist fact-checking LLM responses for document-grounded
tasks. GenAudit suggests edits to the LLM response by revising or removing
claims that are not supported by the reference document, and also presents
evidence from the reference for facts that do appear to have support. We train
models to execute these tasks, and design an interactive interface to present
suggested edits and evidence to users. Comprehensive evaluation by human raters
shows that GenAudit can detect errors in 8 different LLM outputs when
summarizing documents from diverse domains. To ensure that most errors are
flagged by the system, we propose a method that can increase the error recall
while minimizing impact on precision. We release our tool (GenAudit) and
fact-checking model for public use.
|
[
0.0438182913,
-0.624822855,
0.717908442,
0.1779856086,
-0.1220791489,
0.2477642894,
0.0396424532,
-0.2463656217,
0.0274915807,
0.5800272822,
-0.3166190684,
-0.7229838967,
-0.6513820291,
0.0031491052,
-0.6804312468,
0.8368589282,
-0.1940264404,
0.2076297849,
-0.6905517578,
-0.2521992028,
-0.2993628383,
-0.6638085246,
-0.6443042159,
-0.3637084365,
0.3460638225,
0.8406377435,
0.4762328863,
0.310819149,
0.6583673954,
0.3692299128,
0.0113974372,
0.3728051186,
-0.5360053778,
0.0213466547,
-0.2955792248,
-0.6244271994,
-0.9515061975,
0.2480748296,
0.4232834876,
0.4401681125,
-0.2302216887,
0.3145390153,
-0.0652462915,
0.6188726425,
-0.3489520252,
0.2283551544,
-0.3695433438,
-0.2436003089,
-0.057901945,
-0.503828764,
-0.5205855966,
-0.6987062097,
-0.1569033712,
-0.5409270525,
0.7018047571,
0.157336235,
1.0112150908,
0.460257709,
-0.3752644062,
-0.2881652415,
-0.7022901773,
0.4147523046,
-0.9966593385,
0.502260685,
0.303909719,
0.0773907974,
-0.2303911746,
-0.5939820409,
-0.4919409454,
-0.1061134934,
-0.1649063677,
0.2289418876,
-0.0145641761,
0.3172312677,
0.6112523675,
0.2670906186,
-0.4391555488,
-0.0372639894,
-0.3905136883,
-0.4773285687,
0.5709069967,
-0.1098010764,
0.4785752296,
-0.1120894253,
-0.058613874,
-0.2338747084,
-1.2058926821,
-0.2406858355,
0.3677201569,
-0.0128462249,
-0.0668612719,
0.8724814057,
-0.2948870063,
0.464553237,
0.1743499041,
-0.3085437715,
0.1231783107,
-0.291508168,
-0.3797528148,
0.3337931335,
0.3538343012,
0.551291585,
0.0265447237,
-0.1787094474,
-0.3261841536,
0.0158593599,
0.0291804615,
-0.7664305568,
-0.0959350839,
0.4522888958,
-0.1531974822,
-0.3618423045,
0.1709051132,
-0.7745194435,
-0.7569195032,
-0.4436412752,
0.1677959561,
-0.3190557957,
0.0631249472,
0.2197556198,
-0.342694968,
-0.0960092694,
0.712944746,
-0.6274966002,
0.0909096971,
0.54395473,
0.5188440681,
0.2743636072,
-0.1424349099,
-0.8738690615,
0.2234143168,
-0.2333139926,
1.0596147776,
-0.1619951278,
-0.5671058297,
-0.033203084,
-0.0103471437,
0.033553496,
-0.7076048851,
0.9364391565,
-0.4463949203,
0.2727206349,
-0.4664260447,
-0.817251265,
-0.1223799139,
0.1898223609,
-0.6204376817,
0.9407980442,
0.0702547804,
-0.8662346601,
0.4854261577,
-0.6654086709,
-0.1957713217,
-0.016926581,
-0.2443730235,
-0.5007750988,
0.1624790132,
0.2439595908,
0.2867065072,
-0.2478090823,
0.6062722206,
-0.2408148497,
-0.2213196158,
0.1660769284,
-0.4330787957,
0.7868432999,
-0.0871527642,
-0.3125373721,
0.3554348946,
-1.2380094528,
-0.5460797548,
0.1883021444,
-0.7741407156,
-0.4421919882,
0.2927440107,
-0.0702119321,
0.1277881414,
0.0974662155,
-0.7972558737,
0.1606378555,
-0.1265590787,
0.2052688301,
0.5934286714,
-0.0373218283,
0.1272075027,
-0.555952549,
0.3551793993,
0.0348757952,
0.0432772748,
-0.0835125446,
-0.4947645664,
-1.0052683353,
-0.2289227992,
0.5406505466,
0.7457049489,
-0.6478486061,
0.4132279754,
-0.4159787595,
-0.3131048381,
-0.6936320066,
0.2998024821,
-0.0547522977,
0.955355227,
0.1001125053,
-0.0208335537,
-0.6769499779,
-0.785074234,
-0.2821077406,
-0.592836082,
-0.1841360033,
0.0465441309,
0.3261753321,
-0.3628209233,
1.2411311865,
-0.3211232424,
-0.0587255135,
0.1093669012,
0.7070550323,
-0.0026538668,
0.2583773136,
0.5454893112,
-0.6148731709,
0.140797928,
-0.2649332583,
-0.9238217473,
-0.6046458483,
-0.3170718253,
0.2161503434,
0.1017943323,
0.5058526993,
-0.6375330091,
0.2662059069,
0.486517489,
-0.5316106677,
0.5345249772,
-0.3439259827,
0.3883741498,
-0.8546343446,
0.0438577458,
-0.1748263389,
-0.5470319986,
-0.43692559,
0.0479084626,
0.3628920913,
-0.0040332321,
-0.4016940594,
0.3527562916,
-0.1078485548,
-0.0358033217,
-0.1757422537,
0.270906508,
0.2952283621,
0.0438081659,
-0.0955843329,
1.0527057648,
-0.0002477821,
-0.2854000032,
0.5690776706,
0.4407701194,
-0.3525179327,
0.6022151113,
-0.5430081487,
0.0841532946,
-0.1777884662,
0.0121858893,
-1.0369091034,
-0.4268463254,
0.1740303189,
-0.3656841218,
0.2747641802,
-0.0953594819,
-0.6784031987,
-0.174887225,
-0.3124957383,
-0.0031795693,
0.1575677693,
-0.5898099542,
0.9144531488,
0.1568254977,
-0.5111957192,
-0.3655301929,
-0.5257822871,
0.3247334063,
0.0251640528,
-0.7962990999,
-0.0239752624,
-0.2133364826,
-0.494232595,
0.098240681,
0.0188268404,
0.0624854714,
0.4292471111,
0.4700325429,
0.4949363172,
-0.1005893722,
0.1768173873,
0.1232815757,
-0.0299960561,
0.4181865156,
0.1678700745,
0.0862912163,
-0.0499472171,
-0.8681237698,
0.0023331749,
0.0940293893,
0.9411455393,
-0.1919008046,
0.213575542,
0.4476202726,
-0.2784105837,
0.1466672421,
-0.9756307602,
-0.2324541956,
-0.4563209414,
0.2052865326,
0.0627618954,
-0.709557116,
0.4668556154,
-0.3927294314,
0.3292916417,
0.5042135119,
0.6119590998,
-0.1939953268,
0.706631422,
0.4942002296,
0.0472772345,
0.1201318875,
-0.0402710512,
0.2978828251,
-0.5736311078,
-0.16848436,
-0.621516645,
0.1645735204,
-0.2746473253,
-0.4792438447,
0.3589999974,
-0.1143001616,
0.1146722436,
-0.1541288346,
0.0058446969,
0.2764128447,
0.8478507996,
0.0516432188,
0.707013905,
-0.0750799254,
-0.1639108509,
0.0675531179,
-0.7545932531,
-0.7158216834,
1.0678483248,
0.452575773,
0.8391427398,
0.0988448262,
0.7166461349,
0.4563203156,
0.7794828415,
-0.593033433,
0.4602547288,
0.1015241891,
-0.7592863441,
-0.2246358842,
-0.3004859388,
-0.1890394539,
-0.0585528836,
-0.3880081475,
-0.1244805008,
0.4031526744,
0.3687013686,
-0.4537495673,
0.4469848573,
-0.6595134735,
0.6005535126,
-0.2450066507,
-0.289678812,
-0.2397917211,
-0.3438672423,
0.5754888058,
-0.2195102572,
0.3614232242,
-0.182910189,
0.4500648975,
0.6992375255,
-0.3494184911,
1.0929555893,
-0.0145851411,
-0.2849862874,
0.3011924326,
0.2214533687,
0.6996740699,
0.1510730386,
-0.0738230422,
0.1248543262,
-0.0538345948,
-0.1783616543,
-0.5586344004,
0.4162302613,
-0.6621729732,
-0.9175283313,
-0.5803313255,
-0.6785632372,
-0.2858626246,
0.0457748771,
0.0958451405,
0.5396535397,
-0.5631763935,
0.0100265229,
0.8657109141,
-0.2955582142,
0.0958027765,
0.8649835587,
-0.246512413,
-0.2159461081,
0.7982134223,
0.0067125261,
0.2503541708,
0.2434588224,
0.1298559308,
-0.2197153717,
-0.5803780556,
-0.5434545875,
0.2256715745,
-0.9522797465,
-0.1045967266,
-0.4711160958,
-0.0569630638,
-0.5860688686,
0.0229235124,
-0.1236705258,
-0.6432683468,
-0.2098415047,
-0.5522070527,
0.3283590972,
0.6897149086,
-0.3806217015,
0.1627221406,
-0.9267476201,
0.4695766568,
0.6306641698,
0.2139762491,
-0.5564368963,
-0.3925701976,
-0.1299952567,
0.0314075015,
-0.2332681268,
-0.846678555,
0.091930002,
0.1026301384,
0.3480817974,
0.5636957884,
0.02359006,
0.3087674081,
-0.6095673442,
0.6548404694,
-0.018367704,
-0.8819974065,
0.547970593,
-0.3413954675,
0.0216929559,
0.5904732347,
0.0026078855,
-0.6577594876,
-0.7079532743,
-0.7012578249,
-0.5060908198,
0.3447690606,
-0.0592399426,
-0.2541759908,
0.0439031906,
0.3002709746,
-0.0970441699,
0.2963990569,
-0.2207633108,
-0.0752452984,
-0.2881346345,
-0.3103647828,
0.0360856093,
-0.8554802537,
-0.6423784494,
-0.2558072805,
0.878682375,
-0.1976672411,
-0.0392591394,
0.6282885075,
-0.2407304943,
-0.5072934031,
0.588218987,
0.9669601917,
1.0446892977,
-0.7217494249,
0.25853616,
0.1245772094,
-0.4329924285,
0.2687195539,
0.1566117704,
-0.5801061392,
0.3271922469,
0.3945019841,
0.4080958366,
0.3565872312,
-0.9440746307,
0.6227421165,
-0.1799976379,
-0.2221847028,
-0.1385058314,
-0.1798699647,
0.3364048898,
-0.0074163284,
0.1545767188,
0.1888253838,
0.2066172957,
-0.4892112315,
0.2716984451,
0.0663142651,
-0.0853051394,
-0.2119835168,
0.8518604636,
0.5557345748,
-0.0882075503,
0.593203485,
-0.1900092214,
-0.5635264516,
0.5431928039,
0.2876709402,
0.9152237773,
-0.2123572677,
0.3982290924,
0.0878567249,
0.4855105281,
-0.1006589159,
0.3140957654,
0.5350210071,
-0.89165622,
-0.6610550284,
-0.2704230845,
-0.7863904238,
-0.0010495032,
-0.3802358806,
0.1676701903,
-0.608363688,
-0.2082395405,
-0.082507886,
-0.4065323174,
-0.58388412,
0.1994339973,
0.0981162935,
1.0366479158,
-1.0530167818,
0.7111824155,
0.7715409398,
-0.4852364063,
-0.628834486,
-0.3109929264,
0.339756608,
-0.6953306198,
0.9133947492,
-0.3922413588,
-0.2874956131,
-0.2034447789,
-0.7272622585,
-0.6086626649,
1.0013308525,
0.6298909783,
-0.78875494,
0.0030741205,
0.2615099549,
0.2083338648,
-0.0411095992,
0.2150543183,
0.5829594135,
0.6721274853,
-0.1738726944,
-0.6758535504,
0.093152754,
0.0207243431,
-0.5068812966,
-0.1170280278,
-0.4513086677,
0.7825789452,
-0.1218310893,
-0.1478627175,
-0.1538361758,
0.5760473609,
0.3423383236,
0.5376788378,
0.3866507411,
0.7048832178,
1.1622420549,
-0.2595145702,
1.0770465136,
-0.4235576689,
0.3508442044,
1.2583440542,
-0.5653532743,
0.4989225268,
0.5946295857,
-0.0304776635,
0.4233403504,
0.548797667,
-0.2098796517,
0.0805314481,
-0.0161127411,
-0.315208137,
-0.2974953949,
-0.2630637586,
0.0335828587,
0.0728717148,
0.297195673,
-0.1566916555,
-0.3449862897,
-0.213616848,
0.2118667811,
0.072120443,
-0.0127394078,
0.5424085259,
-0.0508010536,
-0.3568071127,
0.3324122429,
0.1625069231,
0.2818716764,
-0.3794079721,
-0.325987488,
-0.3692203462,
0.0314431563,
-0.3055891395,
-0.3764635623,
0.1857844889,
0.1238127127,
-0.4200873375,
-0.1117313355,
0.9631389976,
-0.4029882848,
-0.6319489479,
0.186815396,
0.6635058522,
-0.1416317075,
-0.1690280586,
-0.5887027979,
-0.0017986189,
-0.0535681136,
0.0918973461,
-0.0241082814,
0.363047868,
0.0439964421,
0.694020927,
0.6999585032,
0.4003153443,
0.1680547297,
0.3225314617,
0.7298496366,
-0.4437343776,
-0.1931899637,
-0.653911531,
0.3546224535,
-0.3489001691,
-0.0184312779,
0.7600976825,
0.6014119387,
0.6397497654,
-0.0772463009,
0.9622823,
0.152835682,
0.7198275328,
-0.5862265229,
0.6090393066,
-0.3145059645,
0.3961988688,
0.0242718682,
-0.6814935803,
-0.3537116051,
0.1341945529,
-0.2996580601,
-0.4647170305,
0.7033174634,
0.9324210882,
-0.1870438457,
-0.0194797404,
0.3048979342,
0.6075515151,
0.5505381227,
0.0925375298,
0.805926919,
-0.380994916,
0.1889315099,
-0.1690827757,
-0.2747307122,
-0.5133063197,
-0.9801562428,
-0.8450965881,
-0.1638496965,
-0.6243808866,
-0.5175516009,
0.1893730313,
1.039039135,
0.5070065856,
-1.1049875021,
-0.133874312,
0.1183986291,
0.3828425407,
-0.0621539392,
-0.1733214706,
0.4170871377,
-0.2751765251,
-0.5198000669,
0.6945641637,
0.3543503881,
0.1180662364,
-0.1621207297,
-0.0110870088,
-0.2514243126,
0.2924035192,
0.4359496832,
0.282784164,
-0.5847291946,
-0.6344957352,
-0.2442425489,
-0.1461481452,
0.1883456111,
1.0829143524,
-0.4202038944,
0.5319775343,
0.6931997538,
0.8452345133,
0.154500857,
0.2072878629,
0.7449111342,
-0.7593091726,
0.0282837674,
-0.064504303,
0.7582373619,
0.6404358149,
-0.493422091,
0.6715968251,
0.6375094056,
-0.5919588208,
-0.6792982817,
-0.0168940835,
-0.932895124,
-0.1655195802,
1.0462607145,
-0.147731185,
-0.2779445648,
-0.274618268,
-0.3730642796,
0.2921470702,
-0.3274677396,
1.0295479298,
1.0441600084,
0.2834615707,
-0.0347239524,
-0.8032541275,
0.6429647207,
0.3807671368,
-0.8460324407,
0.1919169724,
0.7478868365,
0.6896957755,
0.3138905466,
0.4893244803,
-0.1405402273,
0.5528979897,
-0.1604937911,
0.5052453279,
-0.2714874148,
-0.0728002116,
-0.3721948266,
0.0499400385,
0.4207259119,
0.0412118249
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.