id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12563v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12563v3
|
Confidence Matters: Revisiting Intrinsic Self-Correction Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T21:38:02 | 2024-05-13T11:01:17 |
Loka Li, Zhenhao Chen, Guangyi Chen, Yixuan Zhang, Yusheng Su, Eric Xing, Kun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has catalyzed an
increasing interest in their self-correction capabilities. This paper presents
a comprehensive investigation into the intrinsic self-correction of LLMs,
attempting to address the ongoing debate about its feasibility. Our research
has identified an important latent factor - the "confidence" of LLMs - during
the self-correction process. Overlooking this factor may cause the models to
over-criticize themselves, resulting in unreliable conclusions regarding the
efficacy of self-correction. We have experimentally observed that LLMs possess
the capability to understand the "confidence" in their own responses. It
motivates us to develop an "If-or-Else" (IoE) prompting framework, designed to
guide LLMs in assessing their own "confidence", facilitating intrinsic
self-corrections. We conduct extensive experiments and demonstrate that our
IoE-based Prompt can achieve a consistent improvement regarding the accuracy of
self-corrected responses over the initial answers. Our study not only sheds
light on the underlying factors affecting self-correction in LLMs, but also
introduces a practical framework that utilizes the IoE prompting principle to
efficiently improve self-correction capabilities with "confidence". The code is
available at https://github.com/MBZUAI-CLeaR/IoE-Prompting.git.
|
[
-0.1467899531,
-0.7218557596,
0.7342553735,
0.4636649191,
0.2482161075,
0.015671337,
-0.4055870473,
-0.3363778293,
0.0034263809,
0.1717083603,
-0.4325740933,
-0.2852653861,
-0.6178808808,
0.5152357221,
-0.5443376899,
0.6521828175,
-0.091731973,
0.2939848006,
-0.1813310236,
0.1453137994,
-0.6060688496,
-0.4320463538,
-0.7427746058,
-0.2338785529,
0.8366287947,
0.7014253736,
0.3478009701,
0.3604398966,
0.4946633577,
0.329451561,
-0.007791549,
-0.0548471548,
-0.5590396523,
0.2392349243,
-0.3559350073,
-0.8182731867,
-0.5747620463,
-0.0896980762,
0.8814039826,
0.4636011124,
-0.128512308,
0.044704292,
0.3827139437,
0.6754000783,
-0.6160228252,
0.1625257134,
-0.6702291965,
-0.1627588868,
-0.1330967546,
-0.3003672063,
-0.5500283241,
-0.0506170355,
-0.0661431849,
-0.2989762127,
0.168772772,
0.0165020712,
0.3709353507,
0.3198029995,
-0.3344682753,
-0.2161279023,
-0.711918056,
0.5331742167,
-0.8348929286,
0.1228263304,
0.4205625951,
-0.2516431808,
-0.312487632,
-0.4785975814,
-0.6933236718,
-0.2932695746,
0.0026514879,
0.0578229688,
-0.0910199434,
0.1579580158,
0.2747198641,
0.4063405991,
-0.2518901229,
0.2678969204,
-0.2729975581,
-0.0966846719,
0.4417411983,
-0.0890531093,
0.0778652132,
-0.0265348963,
0.0462572984,
-0.2045491338,
-0.9952366948,
0.2791718841,
0.2983863354,
0.2339533269,
0.1413168162,
0.7094863653,
-0.2905624509,
0.3551457524,
0.607034862,
-0.2187548429,
-0.160918951,
-0.1115297005,
0.0026224044,
0.2853352726,
0.4647937119,
0.4759244025,
0.2172034085,
0.1254606992,
-0.3547820449,
-0.0984927565,
0.2544591129,
-0.8163158894,
-0.0712447017,
0.601095438,
-0.043320477,
-0.1413397342,
0.1203403622,
-0.0303689353,
-0.4872986078,
-0.2805453241,
0.7352846861,
-0.227065593,
-0.0371644609,
0.2034709007,
0.2860916257,
0.0138775501,
0.5897159576,
-0.8237093687,
-0.005439945,
0.7554318309,
0.7018284798,
-0.156900093,
-0.4194520116,
-0.4528051019,
0.0109662097,
-0.7316054702,
0.7830127478,
-0.2726081014,
-0.6126762629,
0.0796724185,
0.0098811062,
0.0168219209,
-0.3586456776,
0.4619179666,
-0.255230993,
0.2025569379,
-0.5434125066,
-0.7380452752,
0.0062382314,
0.2986243665,
-0.2908425033,
0.91595608,
-0.198133409,
-0.6767875552,
0.1232023984,
-0.4161938131,
-0.3357711136,
0.0099831764,
-0.2545701265,
-0.2873442471,
0.4463202655,
0.0448518433,
0.5385414958,
-0.0133391209,
0.2835506499,
-0.3628203273,
-0.2630131245,
0.6842841506,
-0.4134109616,
0.3840764761,
-0.1835097671,
-0.4959978163,
0.233977899,
-0.3880240023,
0.1151380241,
-0.0646325201,
-0.1282320023,
-0.1095008478,
-0.0525656603,
-0.644595921,
0.0293081515,
0.4204743505,
-0.6368939877,
0.487688601,
-0.2520948052,
0.5263876319,
1.1535147429,
-0.110235855,
0.4151605964,
-0.2134042233,
0.4158378541,
-0.1922216564,
0.1679320484,
-0.536237359,
-0.4170125127,
-0.9514465332,
0.0190365426,
0.4850452244,
0.4714984,
-0.5340561867,
0.368788451,
-0.1783879101,
-0.2799638212,
-0.6143584251,
0.2140670121,
0.3301896155,
0.6236709952,
0.2431778312,
-0.1286997944,
-0.3542592525,
-0.8274640441,
-0.2803071141,
-0.6493064761,
0.198523432,
0.2024997771,
0.4559536874,
-0.1617387831,
1.1552493572,
-0.2389997542,
-0.1914276034,
0.0351768695,
0.3328651488,
0.1122177392,
0.5206475258,
0.2764309049,
-0.477807641,
-0.6468605995,
-0.2223618031,
-0.5453360677,
-0.3907112777,
-0.0403675325,
0.1871888787,
0.3360031247,
0.7890703082,
-0.4807531238,
0.482681483,
0.6963172555,
-0.1986015588,
0.6063802242,
-0.5566084981,
0.4255183637,
-0.6574984193,
-0.0504038893,
-0.2049601525,
-0.1515457481,
-0.4017865956,
-0.0249056574,
0.4364316463,
0.2143569291,
-0.1427337825,
0.673383832,
-0.4782072604,
0.1714070737,
-0.4946669936,
0.028323384,
-0.0722870976,
0.1603732407,
-0.0667394102,
1.1179329157,
0.7144263387,
-0.769116044,
-0.1487263441,
0.0120805707,
-0.2395727038,
0.8426977396,
-0.7681015134,
0.3347043395,
-0.1334698498,
0.2310980111,
-1.2010481358,
-0.3240836561,
0.118085824,
-0.5759305954,
0.5871765614,
-0.1771386415,
-0.480900526,
-0.4499098659,
-0.2429274917,
0.0510588735,
0.2917718291,
-0.5873776674,
0.595913589,
0.1131465212,
-0.650241971,
-0.696157515,
-0.6276037097,
0.389177233,
0.0672497526,
-0.5972886682,
0.303922683,
-0.6216063499,
-0.4289786816,
-0.1319478601,
-0.2093060166,
0.1222624183,
0.27528584,
0.2503862381,
0.1900379062,
-0.1410282999,
0.4862279892,
0.0364504866,
-0.2453610599,
0.2257192582,
-0.4622101188,
0.2941198349,
-0.4924656749,
-0.5628745556,
-0.5542451143,
0.1359145492,
0.3372679353,
0.0019273824,
0.7067171335,
0.2852659523,
-0.1236728951,
-0.0536865592,
-0.8560377955,
-0.669603765,
-0.4981705546,
0.2377480119,
-0.3218199611,
-1.1738371849,
0.4274072647,
0.1585865915,
0.0841559321,
0.4055861235,
0.6052287817,
-0.4670830071,
1.1541826725,
0.6382187009,
-0.0069514606,
0.3903156519,
0.0829076692,
0.2799334228,
-0.8105892539,
0.0566660203,
-0.7455983758,
-0.2350690663,
-0.470584631,
-0.4213368595,
0.4214681387,
0.0705624297,
-0.0637729168,
-0.1184934601,
-0.2114641219,
0.5435259342,
0.3675391376,
-0.0618563555,
0.4861166775,
-0.1746031791,
0.0807748288,
-0.1740822792,
-0.6942695975,
-0.5136807561,
0.9488565922,
0.4806309342,
1.0927181244,
0.2670968473,
0.5567272902,
0.3253120482,
0.4980384409,
-0.8695113063,
0.5122915506,
0.1179594174,
-0.7118782401,
-0.4216526151,
-0.4410939515,
-0.9010467529,
0.0904755592,
-0.2334722728,
-0.5733662844,
0.4304643571,
0.5583492517,
-0.522134304,
0.2641758025,
-0.641962409,
0.4640422761,
-0.4301570654,
-0.521841526,
-0.3522796333,
-0.5664366484,
0.1103896871,
-0.2416329533,
0.0856488496,
-0.1312173605,
-0.1400575042,
0.2932472527,
-0.2871198952,
1.1494956017,
0.0885475129,
-0.6254065037,
0.2609943449,
0.2976929545,
0.6668205857,
0.2068604678,
-0.1209589317,
0.1565621942,
-0.1870100796,
-0.2409447134,
-0.8088878393,
0.6787938476,
-0.5299170017,
-0.9373241663,
-0.4552645981,
-0.2177020758,
-0.2937383354,
0.1932905465,
0.3355968893,
0.4651631713,
-0.0608613491,
0.6595674157,
1.0148330927,
0.1083064228,
0.4434809983,
0.9250913262,
-0.441570878,
-0.1908688843,
0.6052536964,
0.4130721986,
0.4507018328,
0.2598863244,
0.4638202488,
-0.4149361849,
-0.5642212033,
-0.3601791263,
0.2990922332,
-0.7181136012,
-0.1280169785,
-0.492593497,
0.0305980444,
-0.632889092,
-0.1087386683,
-0.5962819457,
-0.2304851264,
-0.3175053,
-0.0511489809,
0.3290447295,
0.9725626707,
-0.2904279232,
0.4301174283,
-0.7148314714,
-0.1109398827,
0.5509549975,
0.2791896462,
-0.0270622689,
-0.8866642714,
-0.079032518,
-0.0039513344,
0.0346294492,
-0.6465527415,
0.1498741955,
0.0858589262,
0.53552562,
0.2041144818,
0.0725102425,
0.7484486699,
-0.3586887717,
0.5968078971,
0.0573457703,
-1.3304022551,
0.5157891512,
-0.3254619837,
0.2504060864,
0.6612164974,
0.157656312,
-0.6587272882,
-0.3750821054,
-0.8549166322,
-0.6837415099,
0.5105255842,
0.2846033275,
0.1660604477,
-0.1022470668,
0.7515040636,
-0.1678702235,
0.3469775319,
-0.8358950019,
-0.2142701894,
0.0840810314,
-0.0314464197,
-0.1374531984,
-0.5732320547,
-0.0395725407,
0.0020004194,
1.0226404667,
-0.4577980936,
0.0298676826,
0.7717999816,
-0.1769074053,
-0.3018640876,
0.485996902,
0.7201092839,
0.7313455939,
-0.1266145557,
0.0868610665,
0.2613279521,
-0.2094383538,
0.1619789749,
-0.3523188233,
-0.2945387959,
-0.2285400629,
0.2755821049,
0.6388964057,
0.1855415702,
-0.3955132067,
0.590094924,
-0.3004302382,
0.0473179705,
-0.2184520364,
0.0567725599,
0.0255337395,
-0.009630152,
0.412478745,
0.0121602612,
0.0123274392,
-0.6091154218,
0.084510535,
0.2465050668,
-0.4221838713,
-0.2262806892,
0.2639077604,
0.2635311186,
-0.4333481491,
0.4307186007,
-0.2892154753,
-0.5416331291,
0.2840218544,
0.6079886556,
0.7346562743,
-0.6429112554,
0.1279594004,
0.3613969088,
0.4951919317,
-0.3574451506,
0.1325538009,
0.2489352971,
-0.7131236196,
-0.7497544885,
-0.0706625059,
-0.8149099946,
0.0201980043,
-0.6329430938,
0.075385347,
-0.6629686356,
-0.2957165837,
-0.4759593904,
-0.0940803215,
-0.1506018937,
0.1986484379,
0.129329741,
0.8482895494,
-0.4275044203,
0.6006787419,
0.4719002545,
-0.1214093864,
-0.9681180716,
0.2333799303,
0.0194038227,
-0.8679974675,
0.6104920506,
0.1164595708,
-0.5554329753,
0.09149874,
-0.9557026625,
-0.890419066,
0.7267116904,
0.3766798973,
-0.8261653781,
0.3300949931,
-0.2144251466,
0.5127150416,
-0.25387609,
0.2927336991,
0.302780211,
0.6065816879,
0.0910225287,
-0.9364036918,
-0.2676624954,
-0.1415994763,
-0.1444336623,
-0.0090356972,
-0.6469604969,
1.0213531256,
-0.4428401887,
-0.076944679,
0.1759309024,
0.8518609405,
0.0952119753,
-0.1099034622,
0.5659524798,
0.2122707963,
1.0123317242,
-0.153625682,
1.0964552164,
-0.5002072453,
0.2920729518,
1.2995195389,
-0.4368411899,
1.0600761175,
0.4140166938,
-0.0858290568,
0.5439142585,
0.4617474973,
0.3246892095,
-0.1244170442,
0.0117911026,
-0.2218813002,
-0.4290570617,
-0.079029046,
-0.3774875104,
0.352401495,
0.48833251,
-0.1352478713,
0.1662609726,
-0.1982893795,
0.0852835178,
-0.0211126357,
-0.4482205212,
0.6853600144,
0.1535229385,
-0.9120530486,
0.229402557,
0.1000328287,
0.5480668545,
-0.7683202624,
0.0925376117,
-0.3488661349,
0.2133834511,
-0.2621197999,
-1.0913844109,
0.0072804722,
-0.0954076573,
-0.2799359262,
-0.4030920267,
0.7497521639,
-0.4682939947,
-0.3019532561,
0.1836183965,
0.3966197371,
-0.0994420648,
-0.3698519766,
-0.682507813,
0.0629862472,
0.105444625,
-0.0672804266,
0.1344438791,
0.5187389851,
0.1106270626,
0.8595334888,
0.7071042657,
0.1013655439,
-0.1294650882,
0.146566242,
0.4145085812,
-0.5444913507,
-0.4095889926,
-0.7986184359,
0.5607860088,
-0.078599073,
-0.2723462284,
1.0431940556,
0.1647259146,
0.6271302104,
-0.0938888341,
0.7307926416,
0.1465222687,
0.6054685712,
-0.7357535362,
0.4245667756,
-0.5270078182,
0.3836835921,
-0.0656187385,
-0.6536384225,
-0.18707636,
0.9761615992,
-0.4290938377,
0.1391202956,
0.7712816596,
0.9232654572,
0.5311287045,
-0.0561529621,
0.3857571185,
0.7117581367,
0.3113019168,
0.0414801762,
0.9968110323,
-0.219070226,
0.2366652638,
-0.2440611273,
-0.2564222515,
-0.3587566316,
-1.2654488087,
-0.6929547787,
-0.4235842824,
-0.5859271288,
-0.6056723595,
0.0817758217,
1.0175971985,
0.6083878279,
-0.8451487422,
-0.3332276344,
-0.0638763085,
0.1302317083,
0.15133515,
-0.1080638245,
0.0586012378,
-0.5189027786,
-0.8002057076,
0.4429906011,
0.6504080892,
0.3703594208,
-0.5599372983,
-0.0069244783,
0.1383173019,
0.2312102914,
0.4627161026,
0.3723856211,
-0.8325325251,
-0.3597904444,
0.1714031696,
-0.3782569766,
0.3171066642,
0.859903276,
-0.4372039735,
0.5355075002,
0.3613063693,
0.5682390928,
0.0283778794,
0.018400399,
0.7373600602,
-0.6883609891,
-0.30276981,
0.0260108337,
0.6047967672,
0.5531169176,
-0.5898771286,
0.46366328,
0.2049339712,
-0.7055980563,
-0.6420639753,
0.0941945836,
-0.8419311643,
-0.2287221551,
1.2023891211,
-0.2014829814,
-0.3218814731,
0.0327619947,
-0.5508421063,
-0.2969418168,
-0.4712776244,
0.8831441998,
1.0086530447,
0.030273594,
-0.1537149101,
-0.0664589629,
0.2792386115,
0.814262569,
-0.6173593402,
0.3101320863,
0.3038047254,
0.2837195694,
0.3054543436,
0.802480042,
0.099160336,
0.20175381,
-0.2042658925,
0.1847771704,
0.2705097198,
-0.6096597314,
-0.7391728759,
-0.0870387107,
0.5360137224,
0.588436842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12560v1
|
CausalGym: Benchmarking causal interpretability methods on linguistic tasks
| 2024-02-19T21:35:56 | 2024-02-19T21:35:56 |
Aryaman Arora, Dan Jurafsky, Christopher Potts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Language models (LMs) have proven to be powerful tools for psycholinguistic
research, but most prior work has focused on purely behavioural measures (e.g.,
surprisal comparisons). At the same time, research in model interpretability
has begun to illuminate the abstract causal mechanisms shaping LM behavior. To
help bring these strands of research closer together, we introduce CausalGym.
We adapt and expand the SyntaxGym suite of tasks to benchmark the ability of
interpretability methods to causally affect model behaviour. To illustrate how
CausalGym can be used, we study the pythia models (14M--6.9B) and assess the
causal efficacy of a wide range of interpretability methods, including linear
probing and distributed alignment search (DAS). We find that DAS outperforms
the other methods, and so we use it to study the learning trajectory of two
difficult linguistic phenomena in pythia-1b: negative polarity item licensing
and filler--gap dependencies. Our analysis shows that the mechanism
implementing both of these tasks is learned in discrete stages, not gradually.
|
[
-0.0014597805,
-0.8414305449,
0.6797726154,
0.4333229661,
0.0156006953,
-0.3421355188,
-0.3900015652,
-0.4230347276,
-0.0737884492,
0.3612979054,
-0.4592207968,
-0.2479701191,
-0.6744792461,
0.0403588749,
-0.4213738143,
0.8405544162,
-0.1165107414,
0.1797994226,
-0.2552389503,
-0.2648628652,
-0.8167913556,
-0.3770377338,
-0.6004080176,
-0.7494921684,
0.9119682908,
0.2115861177,
0.828892231,
0.674808383,
0.4307863116,
0.267973423,
-0.1740085185,
-0.2812963426,
-0.5041402578,
0.2116940469,
-0.5710726976,
-0.7648057938,
-0.173386246,
0.2599103153,
0.5973622203,
0.9857562184,
-0.4882631302,
0.1692121178,
-0.0390185229,
0.353177458,
-0.6532007456,
0.3992103338,
-0.5026073456,
-0.2526256442,
-0.2349267304,
-0.129328981,
-0.5966181755,
-0.5387067795,
0.1808915883,
-0.6063384414,
0.1403348595,
0.0756644011,
0.7549263239,
0.1876671314,
-0.5546181798,
-0.3775950968,
-0.7009301186,
0.6763829589,
-0.7032018304,
0.462472707,
0.4467774332,
0.1649947166,
-0.2947208583,
-0.8978638649,
-0.5365415215,
-0.4316067994,
-0.4279499054,
-0.0993902534,
-0.3338153958,
0.0624441169,
0.5022172332,
0.1048583612,
-0.6847205758,
0.2495977134,
-0.3086912334,
-0.0518107302,
0.5092499256,
0.2787679434,
0.7007402778,
-0.1780644953,
-0.2520640492,
0.031948477,
-0.7737012506,
-0.2087778598,
0.5480994582,
0.2398309708,
0.0118437996,
0.4880802333,
-0.2673971951,
0.8825697303,
-0.2132295072,
0.2120903283,
-0.1469192058,
-0.2607498467,
-0.1184335947,
0.000805459,
0.4195353985,
0.0635102391,
0.1844064146,
-0.3854800761,
0.0742079914,
0.3075534403,
0.3625648916,
-0.5826281309,
-0.5764131546,
0.0641568154,
-0.3211863637,
-0.1512914449,
-0.2243880928,
-0.5652468204,
-0.5772880912,
-0.5619879365,
0.6765619516,
-0.2045096159,
-0.5645380616,
0.2851622403,
-0.0019171074,
0.2364236414,
0.1165247634,
-0.7607437968,
0.4543709159,
0.8130188584,
0.8122432232,
-0.003420986,
-0.6920449138,
-0.5504674315,
-0.0699806064,
-0.3047075868,
0.5763122439,
-0.2465762943,
0.1560788304,
0.0033544656,
-0.048737552,
-0.5099314451,
-0.5908535719,
0.5905898809,
-0.6280264854,
0.1373990625,
-0.367911458,
-0.7510304451,
-0.6522283554,
0.0118900333,
-0.5250772834,
0.7470325828,
-0.0193252377,
-0.6888530254,
0.4926378429,
-0.0820764527,
-0.3773612082,
0.0674183592,
-0.0801451504,
-0.3291832805,
0.3328179717,
-0.2777014971,
0.3855479956,
-0.5245953202,
0.8307304978,
-0.3456762433,
-0.4229035079,
0.2997912467,
-0.4616116285,
0.8408738375,
-0.1691183746,
-0.6218959093,
0.2920957208,
-0.7412241697,
-0.138448,
0.1766674221,
0.0080329198,
-0.352032572,
0.5296476483,
0.1282227933,
0.4605146348,
-0.0372486897,
-0.0498576835,
0.0063542938,
-0.4794953465,
0.2674610019,
0.545845449,
-0.1962211281,
0.0914013684,
-0.2532317936,
0.3183535039,
-0.0289659686,
0.0508150831,
0.1274893582,
-0.3159221411,
-0.8033953905,
-0.1522608697,
-0.0499025807,
0.3857291639,
-0.5466237068,
0.2774933875,
-0.0688089281,
-0.7435464263,
-0.0975523144,
0.0144204916,
0.6083047986,
0.4476036131,
0.2591700852,
-0.3878208697,
-0.2830393612,
-0.7477442026,
-0.7825399041,
-0.4599896371,
0.2735083401,
0.1716779619,
0.3448047042,
0.0033135905,
0.4674839675,
-0.5972668529,
0.0158320852,
-0.2711675167,
0.4859407544,
0.5039493442,
0.2709693611,
0.2552960217,
-0.5978162885,
-0.1620364785,
-0.2740480006,
-0.7606906891,
-0.5236946344,
-0.1812133193,
-0.0138328802,
0.021684479,
0.709756732,
-0.7235062718,
0.2734991908,
0.4117500782,
-0.8572849035,
0.6754834652,
-0.1492947638,
-0.0264813341,
-0.5010302067,
0.2166609317,
0.0306941736,
-0.0818873718,
-0.8261058927,
0.2329525352,
0.1533542126,
0.0720392019,
-0.4447180331,
0.3891208172,
-0.4759205878,
-0.1699519902,
-0.3101972938,
0.3391834497,
-0.3227848709,
0.5346202254,
-0.0825993344,
0.4855080545,
0.5756340027,
-0.5858239532,
0.1683981866,
0.1028563306,
-0.3754072785,
0.6251900196,
-0.6258603334,
-0.15747419,
-0.2023798376,
-0.0199419614,
-1.120179534,
-0.0893901438,
0.3719362915,
-0.1640447825,
0.2744974196,
-0.0775102451,
-0.5334360003,
0.1206095889,
0.1373380572,
0.6423089504,
0.3766065538,
-0.6432039738,
0.4358226657,
-0.0497742705,
-0.0555899628,
-0.3592357635,
-0.2348204851,
0.0382103994,
-0.5853828788,
-0.3433364034,
-0.0308641251,
0.2158495337,
-0.4516819417,
-0.0441041626,
-0.2227976322,
0.3043496013,
0.5091300011,
0.2168623507,
0.0859416798,
-0.2058634311,
0.0850645676,
-0.2939708531,
-0.3353784084,
0.4024727643,
-0.4307925999,
0.5873753428,
0.2540952265,
-0.3429896533,
-0.2480876446,
-0.1441327035,
0.4731436074,
-0.0678140298,
0.9071373343,
0.6287850738,
-0.3824751377,
-0.1829013973,
-0.5350040793,
-0.0931072459,
-0.3861041665,
0.3601500094,
-0.1861754507,
-0.5982335806,
0.4265143573,
-0.1263884455,
-0.4378065467,
0.4524355829,
0.5765690207,
0.2561944127,
0.9967063069,
0.4111596048,
-0.174898535,
0.5861558318,
0.1315761656,
0.3686789572,
-0.6098020077,
-0.1408709586,
-0.5496213436,
-0.2043445408,
-0.885134697,
-0.3208350539,
0.3226099014,
0.5654950738,
-0.2016293705,
0.5345959663,
-0.0631256327,
0.3696392775,
0.3440236151,
0.132844463,
0.3546719253,
-0.3786312938,
0.008636211,
-0.1183747053,
-0.8235809207,
-0.2850322425,
0.9845687151,
0.1696389318,
0.7353668809,
0.3386657536,
0.3069455624,
-0.1032703444,
0.5628454685,
-0.6792554259,
0.5250694156,
0.0986212417,
-0.5449441671,
-0.2011749893,
-0.4649655223,
-1.0134357214,
0.4812113643,
0.0016631423,
-1.1252756119,
0.2172690183,
0.0698528886,
0.0967050344,
0.0535422936,
-0.6822346449,
1.0387568474,
-0.2330530733,
-0.6614670157,
-0.5422070622,
-0.6023621559,
0.4248507917,
0.1671059132,
0.1422349811,
-0.2922123075,
0.2268417627,
0.763874352,
-0.0431234837,
0.8570103645,
-0.1720211953,
-0.1388208866,
-0.1817334443,
0.2892748117,
0.5433914065,
0.1163049787,
0.168012768,
0.2926897705,
0.1415606737,
-0.4305325449,
-0.7249890566,
0.7029117346,
-0.6187742352,
-0.6777556539,
-0.6906838417,
-0.5942499042,
-0.2691387832,
0.3078740537,
0.084061496,
0.5664201975,
-0.2756515443,
-0.1997295618,
0.5714905262,
-0.2484701425,
0.3880977929,
0.7590197325,
-0.3779107332,
-0.2042698115,
0.9489070773,
0.0869111866,
0.3856863081,
0.3165944219,
0.336768806,
-0.1854589432,
-0.6261780858,
-0.1303917766,
0.3533348739,
-0.7437357306,
-0.0170219205,
-0.4242581129,
0.0448704846,
-0.0180515423,
0.0404933095,
-0.133306399,
-0.2934915125,
-0.1918824017,
-0.0308918469,
0.2305667102,
0.8465896249,
-0.0784877539,
0.3363232911,
-0.2752660811,
0.2355304807,
0.2120030671,
0.4009148777,
0.1753466725,
-0.3021743596,
-0.28567186,
-0.2331814468,
-0.2319198847,
-1.1009610891,
0.2641447783,
-0.0642516389,
0.5299422741,
0.2387261391,
-0.3856122196,
0.6119735837,
-0.4383476675,
0.6216997504,
0.1167517006,
-1.0676823854,
0.3687054813,
-0.5555412173,
0.1010193303,
0.3007026017,
0.4462796152,
-0.761872828,
-0.4766789973,
-0.6547985077,
-0.9950456023,
0.8389771581,
0.3663273156,
-0.2529287338,
0.0429731794,
0.418825835,
0.0555876978,
0.0555677116,
-0.5822164416,
-0.3303323984,
0.2774007916,
-0.2505990863,
-0.7042238116,
-0.2608885169,
-0.0695887282,
-0.2614890635,
0.6333928108,
0.0298084188,
-0.0531499051,
0.1677739471,
-0.5766109824,
-0.0886774212,
0.1272714138,
0.5324192643,
1.0261901617,
-0.036832802,
0.3511584103,
-0.0981521606,
-0.3003649712,
0.20456554,
0.3737568855,
-0.2729424834,
-0.0398364291,
0.6272287369,
0.9426852465,
0.6024425626,
-0.6059702635,
0.314692378,
0.0212520957,
0.1734185219,
-0.0964491814,
0.0084463404,
0.1298396736,
0.4354530871,
-0.0407563262,
-0.2692911327,
0.3570304215,
-0.6536829472,
0.1249506101,
0.170860067,
-0.4678947031,
-0.5165993571,
0.7233950496,
-0.1928070933,
-0.2500113547,
0.5691363215,
-0.1867423058,
-0.4694140553,
0.6082142591,
0.6453934908,
0.8835861087,
-0.2229172438,
0.2846122384,
0.3452385068,
0.4244608879,
-0.4072755873,
0.3289578557,
0.0481400415,
-0.6650001407,
-0.3064472675,
-0.3655764759,
-0.3055544198,
0.0072698388,
-0.9889689684,
0.3120328784,
0.0342562608,
0.1537114233,
0.251572907,
-0.101707615,
-0.703627944,
0.2301550955,
-0.1356081218,
0.5300549269,
-1.2027703524,
0.4995637536,
0.6482113004,
-0.5727367997,
-1.0282109976,
0.1524434537,
0.1402752548,
-0.7451733947,
0.4898552001,
0.0373890363,
0.1153054461,
0.1890645474,
-0.267890662,
-0.8156281114,
0.9566341639,
0.354205966,
-0.6065930128,
0.1776104271,
-0.0325959958,
0.6164011359,
0.2172077298,
0.4801329374,
0.976572752,
0.3723242879,
-0.3456310332,
-0.8743284345,
0.3515127003,
0.1020821109,
-0.0438627787,
0.5183352828,
-0.4683773518,
0.7242722511,
0.0879021958,
-0.2450887561,
0.1055476815,
0.3460465372,
0.2060588449,
0.4690626562,
0.35470137,
0.608446002,
0.7479726076,
-0.1722010523,
0.8599654436,
-0.1933905631,
0.6431841254,
1.0907078981,
-0.2994659841,
0.7038430572,
0.7151369452,
-0.2113461196,
0.4359187782,
0.4594203532,
0.2306916714,
0.4402197003,
0.6819072366,
-0.2034720033,
-0.2158276737,
-0.1403608322,
-0.0069789412,
0.4458229244,
0.3201231658,
-0.1572133452,
-0.2911410928,
-0.152132079,
0.1506594121,
0.2279983014,
-0.2382512093,
0.8149425983,
0.2434082776,
-0.7361731529,
0.3402314782,
0.0318597257,
0.353738755,
-0.5195704699,
0.0367699936,
-0.322344929,
0.2586159408,
-0.2262026966,
-0.430878818,
0.386585027,
-0.3635080457,
0.0266596861,
-0.1477274448,
0.7824500799,
-0.6275555491,
-0.3327593803,
0.5688228011,
0.7347874045,
-0.0344101302,
0.1035385951,
-0.2921784222,
0.0256905537,
-0.5462267399,
-0.2102783471,
0.3503153026,
0.3086766601,
-0.2252046913,
0.6294692755,
0.321034044,
0.4443530738,
-0.037492685,
0.1824249774,
0.507927537,
-0.7700322866,
-0.3488782644,
-1.0847936869,
0.2828176618,
0.2461428791,
-0.3251004815,
0.9636153579,
0.2643144727,
1.0286611319,
0.0486982092,
0.3159364462,
-0.1135479361,
0.1657327861,
-0.7160230279,
0.7758340836,
-0.3796133101,
0.1853842139,
-0.3048006892,
-0.8944911957,
-0.3219541609,
0.4045103192,
-0.5387092829,
-0.0450034589,
1.0033935308,
0.7676441073,
-0.1368385851,
0.0763051882,
0.3124645948,
0.4649368227,
0.0988695547,
0.5439119935,
1.1970793009,
-0.4620850086,
0.0877609253,
-0.0528536439,
-0.0624313429,
-0.0298932213,
-0.8377225399,
-0.8493695259,
-0.5437448025,
-0.5862878561,
-0.4160885811,
0.2067779005,
0.6780512333,
0.4837407172,
-0.6528649926,
-0.5110176802,
-0.535790205,
0.5584621429,
-0.6393063068,
-0.2282465845,
0.3118918836,
-0.4842835069,
-0.2879576981,
0.2766152918,
0.1801031679,
-0.5145094991,
-0.1538683623,
0.061835926,
-0.3425108194,
0.0825937614,
0.3420706987,
0.1762955189,
-0.8150742054,
-0.3965661526,
-0.2826423943,
0.1112168282,
-0.171731025,
1.2609386444,
-0.4303428531,
0.5173372626,
0.5876228809,
0.3893326819,
0.4207453132,
-0.2619663477,
0.7639658451,
-0.4134560525,
0.0763020143,
0.0457763113,
0.3060291111,
0.1277040839,
-0.1734783351,
0.4464500844,
0.4630477428,
-0.5346003771,
-0.8777673244,
0.3157186508,
-0.6697463393,
-0.1698246151,
1.1386022568,
-0.221042797,
0.1793952286,
-0.2092418224,
0.0237133764,
0.4882881641,
0.2671835721,
0.8740989566,
0.8209704161,
-0.050323166,
-0.0479042828,
-0.6754781604,
0.5790064335,
0.7967427969,
-0.705956161,
0.1790084541,
0.5124442577,
0.4722241759,
-0.0933962539,
0.4890035987,
0.0164759587,
0.3478603065,
0.0308491215,
-0.1549783796,
0.2633015513,
-0.4331410527,
-0.8269876838,
-0.050857164,
0.3962180912,
0.1831318736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12557v1
|
Creating a Fine Grained Entity Type Taxonomy Using LLMs
| 2024-02-19T21:32:19 | 2024-02-19T21:32:19 |
Michael Gunn, Dohyun Park, Nidhish Kamath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we investigate the potential of GPT-4 and its advanced
iteration, GPT-4 Turbo, in autonomously developing a detailed entity type
taxonomy. Our objective is to construct a comprehensive taxonomy, starting from
a broad classification of entity types - including objects, time, locations,
organizations, events, actions, and subjects - similar to existing manually
curated taxonomies. This classification is then progressively refined through
iterative prompting techniques, leveraging GPT-4's internal knowledge base. The
result is an extensive taxonomy comprising over 5000 nuanced entity types,
which demonstrates remarkable quality upon subjective evaluation.
We employed a straightforward yet effective prompting strategy, enabling the
taxonomy to be dynamically expanded. The practical applications of this
detailed taxonomy are diverse and significant. It facilitates the creation of
new, more intricate branches through pattern-based combinations and notably
enhances information extraction tasks, such as relation extraction and event
argument extraction. Our methodology not only introduces an innovative approach
to taxonomy creation but also opens new avenues for applying such taxonomies in
various computational linguistics and AI-related fields.
|
[
-0.6682050228,
-0.8111951351,
0.8000506759,
0.1014845446,
-0.3392134607,
0.4215124846,
-0.3418306708,
-0.3398710489,
0.2395705879,
0.2180048078,
-0.3787012696,
-0.558847487,
-0.2616879344,
0.2257809788,
-0.3465109766,
1.1462780237,
-0.1741628647,
-0.2892624438,
-0.0595979653,
0.2176651657,
-0.1896032393,
-0.4147335589,
-0.8345694542,
-0.1517146528,
0.6317212582,
0.4249537587,
0.4233112633,
0.7886098027,
0.6332195997,
0.308547467,
0.0923870653,
0.3030544221,
-0.3220234215,
0.1814842671,
-0.3292240798,
-0.3441499174,
-0.6403027773,
-0.1528808326,
0.5385421515,
0.4288417697,
-0.318536371,
0.2900107205,
0.081446752,
0.1650303155,
-0.3617832661,
0.4000936747,
-0.8831635714,
0.0883184224,
-0.7530096769,
-0.539799571,
-0.000060771,
-0.0611074753,
0.2252515852,
-0.6518992186,
0.1606513113,
-0.0989245549,
0.871283412,
0.2928293049,
-0.2992589176,
-0.5049024224,
-0.8238407373,
0.413567245,
-0.5184930563,
0.2596591711,
-0.0810547918,
0.3720268309,
0.0163852517,
-1.255190134,
-0.2378406078,
-0.1318387836,
0.2424990386,
0.137290135,
-0.0908603817,
0.248528257,
0.0351442844,
0.5176733732,
-0.3636844754,
0.2912886441,
-0.2045261413,
-0.1310404092,
0.3808562756,
0.4699321091,
0.1058207005,
-0.1253451109,
-0.2359479666,
0.6231322289,
-0.7668382525,
-0.1193324104,
0.2911446393,
0.2818265557,
0.2234694362,
0.6498513222,
-0.3402009606,
0.4313648045,
0.0846239626,
-0.2831083536,
0.0288500525,
-0.3854710162,
-0.2335048616,
-0.1186633781,
0.8092249036,
0.2196237743,
0.1661790907,
-0.4894827604,
-0.3903819025,
0.0963053256,
0.3392482698,
-0.7800210118,
-0.1744006276,
0.2849238515,
-0.2200477272,
-0.4443057775,
-0.2708328068,
-0.8215873837,
-0.0567162409,
-0.5176367164,
0.2751699388,
-0.5321965814,
-0.2499696314,
-0.0440746918,
0.0189110823,
0.4050010443,
0.4648292363,
-0.9902121425,
0.3523707688,
0.9109995365,
0.8957693577,
-0.4156163931,
-0.0936895907,
-0.211096406,
0.4963388145,
-0.2347933352,
1.0727989674,
-0.7402637005,
-0.4167265594,
-0.1418270916,
-0.4183188081,
0.4393204749,
-0.6364101768,
0.5130625367,
-0.6351492405,
-0.0059803603,
0.0060013901,
-0.7747834325,
-0.1879401058,
0.6122018099,
-0.4567276537,
0.9945521355,
0.207696259,
-0.6826037765,
0.5013366342,
-0.7932373285,
-0.1608932763,
0.7887060642,
-0.6800556779,
-0.1519787163,
0.1352498233,
0.0429285988,
0.5448146462,
-0.3679509461,
0.7174671888,
-0.2688686848,
-0.0714327842,
-0.1348006278,
-0.1156535968,
0.2351197302,
0.2157835811,
-0.3850033879,
0.1410701722,
-0.7055055499,
0.0240612179,
0.0261656195,
-0.3097703755,
-0.3263877928,
-0.0196542982,
-0.3364488482,
0.0486705974,
0.3688845038,
-0.1467252672,
0.6749097705,
-0.1880383044,
0.6630403996,
0.7012757659,
0.4369367957,
0.5631328821,
-0.0843795314,
0.5902085304,
0.0701682642,
0.0372191668,
-0.126348421,
-0.5724719763,
-0.6559631824,
-0.3848000169,
0.3527248502,
0.4233311713,
-0.8615428209,
0.4154855907,
-0.4540513158,
-0.5597940683,
-0.1533071101,
-0.1265845895,
0.0621225685,
0.6023362279,
0.2657857835,
-0.3438770175,
-0.4151040316,
-0.9163475633,
-0.1108352989,
-0.1324013025,
-0.0503017753,
0.2883279622,
0.4200042188,
-0.5295295119,
1.0992306471,
-0.4864447415,
-0.170256108,
0.0738203824,
0.2086948156,
-0.0520794801,
0.2834159732,
0.465519309,
-0.5297005177,
-0.190031901,
-0.042249795,
-0.6287783384,
0.1018101722,
-0.0599614792,
-0.268230319,
-0.0371394381,
0.2087204754,
-0.6520124078,
0.084930487,
-0.2255826443,
0.0246947259,
0.5674310327,
0.1456642002,
-0.1573274583,
-1.1180603504,
-0.2633493245,
0.011312684,
-0.0980317518,
-0.6415772438,
0.2640718818,
-0.0704500973,
0.2001201957,
-0.3510625362,
0.5381979942,
-0.5050355196,
-0.4332695007,
0.0903950483,
0.1402062178,
-0.1767135262,
0.3781598806,
0.072400853,
0.7163378,
0.8793972135,
-0.9512284398,
0.4009502232,
0.0946552232,
-0.1035898328,
0.5069910288,
-0.2704283595,
0.1047498286,
-0.0247743297,
0.1335763782,
-0.4226072431,
-0.4580447972,
0.2278918922,
-0.2214802355,
0.4894624949,
-0.2686354518,
-0.674305141,
-0.4235114753,
-0.3297097683,
0.2843833268,
0.3054595292,
-0.3609513938,
0.6822409034,
0.4399238527,
-0.42557621,
-0.0962591991,
-0.4305587113,
0.3377045691,
-0.6446899176,
-0.4973279834,
0.6665178537,
-0.0788001418,
-0.3878234327,
0.1558071077,
-0.2487087548,
-0.1544837803,
0.2279514223,
-0.1723394394,
0.2431968004,
-0.4207103252,
0.1021551117,
0.0948312357,
0.1550625265,
0.0857589692,
-0.5354568958,
0.6498731971,
-0.4159093499,
-0.1302711964,
-0.3194914162,
0.2110221088,
0.2164049298,
-0.3301883638,
-0.0801921189,
0.5806036592,
-0.6023147702,
-0.2086450309,
-0.4398328066,
-0.0875216126,
-0.5011938214,
0.2526388764,
-0.7839130759,
-1.2808887959,
0.5851022005,
-0.3793773055,
0.1661139131,
0.4674945176,
0.826828897,
0.2186183482,
0.5656279922,
0.4167394042,
0.0826775283,
0.2516057789,
-0.310950458,
0.1115401685,
-0.8157684207,
-0.3468900919,
-0.3856229782,
-0.1267135292,
-0.9315218329,
-0.5176641941,
0.2001937628,
0.145888716,
-0.514754653,
0.0616745837,
-0.7596938014,
0.2864537537,
0.4138203263,
-0.1437927186,
0.4863081872,
-0.100365527,
-0.1183994412,
0.1312409192,
-0.3560001254,
-0.8609039187,
1.0850167274,
0.3831693828,
0.6806278825,
0.1371911466,
1.2204377651,
0.0968305767,
0.6046284437,
-1.2090512514,
0.5505571961,
0.0157218687,
-0.4242940843,
-0.1848901212,
-0.4093934,
-0.7373504639,
-0.0810806006,
0.2309338748,
-0.8310432434,
0.0220227987,
0.051300671,
-0.6732898951,
0.2653978765,
-0.4386520088,
0.4622288346,
-0.4959462881,
-0.1336967647,
0.2527205348,
-0.402767837,
0.6780961156,
-0.4397378266,
0.1608442813,
-0.1641677767,
-0.6522071958,
0.6147941351,
-0.2166358232,
0.4642000496,
-0.0242732596,
-0.4272313416,
0.5425949693,
0.2593970597,
0.4637521505,
0.5953559279,
0.1113898307,
0.1093236953,
-0.3117068112,
-0.0658309981,
-0.6075476408,
0.7382329106,
-0.6074247956,
-0.6853452325,
-0.2038216144,
-0.3240349293,
-0.5026589036,
0.4108580351,
0.1434570253,
0.459196955,
-0.1096267179,
-0.2006048262,
0.5930724144,
0.0618074015,
0.5674744844,
0.4945735633,
-0.2888979316,
-0.463082999,
0.9514997005,
0.2118757665,
-0.0141602643,
0.423004806,
0.047611054,
-0.338113755,
-0.989477396,
-0.480309993,
0.0521385632,
-0.4667372108,
-0.5806850195,
-0.7055311799,
-0.1572516561,
-0.4764488339,
-0.1059920788,
-0.2073860168,
-0.45869416,
-0.5318366885,
-0.1601090729,
0.4466075301,
1.0180430412,
0.2392825186,
0.3304598927,
-0.8472659588,
0.3186322451,
0.3650008142,
0.6139400005,
-0.203978315,
-0.3009661436,
0.118019104,
-0.3069005907,
-0.4296805859,
-0.6864849329,
0.3659301996,
0.3218639195,
0.6800179482,
0.4877236187,
-0.2009171844,
0.851436615,
-0.8223388195,
1.0566027164,
-0.0356586799,
-0.8743593693,
0.5438717604,
-0.7245099545,
-0.0301839355,
0.4909318089,
0.5268375278,
-0.1437307447,
-0.410585314,
-0.9416663051,
-1.1150640249,
0.4596846402,
0.2587957978,
-0.0220687706,
-0.1586535573,
0.8482825756,
0.1309438646,
0.3997156322,
-0.4272682369,
-0.4194237888,
-0.245533675,
-0.1351448745,
0.0922177881,
-0.1843381375,
-0.0913832039,
-0.0789067522,
0.5629568696,
-0.3437963724,
0.4195587337,
0.0396095887,
0.0042943377,
0.2788780332,
0.4554340243,
0.7201415896,
0.676690042,
-0.1485282481,
0.3139097691,
0.0053741233,
-0.3998545706,
-0.0245271306,
0.324421972,
-0.1204799861,
-0.0148062482,
0.1431450546,
0.6447916627,
0.1875483543,
-0.2148170918,
0.1249574274,
-0.0056619286,
-0.2316099256,
-0.3027893603,
-0.0042267176,
0.2873240113,
0.2971453369,
0.3623650074,
-0.2501832247,
0.5151628852,
-0.5560492873,
0.498811841,
0.3875691593,
-0.0643524975,
-0.3686670661,
0.5629447699,
0.2589634955,
-0.1393381059,
0.2854233384,
-0.6107205153,
-0.4185185134,
0.4779787958,
0.412324965,
0.8986990452,
-0.0570605136,
0.0628689751,
0.2015074044,
0.1561934203,
-0.1298551857,
0.2447470129,
-0.1139454842,
-0.803140223,
-0.3034838438,
-0.8779853582,
-0.4604754746,
0.3423843384,
-0.5566800237,
0.4134144187,
-0.4977720082,
-0.2515942454,
0.3130095601,
0.1180652231,
-0.632537961,
0.0854764208,
0.3002671897,
1.0582911968,
-0.2178613991,
0.7072302103,
0.9875222445,
-0.6778784394,
-1.0551307201,
0.104279682,
0.1029293686,
-0.8422590494,
0.4972560406,
0.0366471447,
0.094394356,
0.3882881999,
-0.493573606,
-1.0695956945,
1.3795320988,
0.0038503453,
-0.6949509382,
-0.4742311835,
0.0672249049,
0.5082595944,
-0.6006278992,
0.3278045654,
0.9133776426,
0.5828859806,
0.1724144965,
-0.7428046465,
0.0014943912,
0.0238274522,
0.2176737189,
0.3401966393,
-0.637799561,
0.771641314,
0.026821129,
-0.2865434289,
0.0147235068,
0.7856152654,
0.2126459628,
0.0936157554,
0.2976612449,
0.6561942101,
0.9752647877,
-0.2395666987,
0.704351604,
-0.4001608789,
0.5639811754,
1.2888661623,
-0.376960516,
0.332434684,
0.1994765848,
-0.1495386064,
0.3733004332,
1.1955964565,
-0.1767386049,
0.3271900713,
0.3491573334,
-0.560844183,
-0.1267225295,
-0.0151971085,
-0.2247354537,
0.4888665974,
0.8948869109,
-0.0726018548,
-0.6063384414,
-0.1554248035,
0.0669158995,
-0.5179726481,
-0.78613168,
1.0475170612,
0.1409290582,
-0.6345145106,
0.2617908418,
0.0098237656,
0.9081088305,
-0.3384131789,
0.098244369,
-0.1379777193,
-0.2390667796,
-0.3593085706,
-1.1370259523,
0.2170633823,
0.1645640284,
0.2154781073,
-0.164258495,
0.7985799909,
-0.4756798148,
-0.1237775683,
-0.0121950712,
0.6141103506,
0.3120627701,
-0.0933593959,
-0.6553798318,
-0.2218829542,
-0.0929995254,
-0.4097132981,
0.128087312,
1.0612485409,
-0.4462917149,
0.5771908164,
0.3010651767,
0.0664418489,
0.1836278588,
0.2215030938,
1.0567954779,
-0.8047640324,
-0.205599457,
-0.904260397,
0.3288193941,
0.0993802771,
-0.195587635,
0.516587913,
0.9058719277,
0.7500379086,
0.0732199028,
0.9890198112,
-0.1703465581,
0.2103986442,
-0.2985170186,
0.1875244081,
-0.3275997341,
0.210477218,
-0.2102487385,
-0.8535867929,
-0.4242077172,
0.0628804639,
-0.0169939771,
0.0381981768,
0.6595333815,
0.4259685576,
-0.0077514788,
0.0542143472,
0.1751465648,
0.1985654235,
0.7047411799,
0.1930780709,
0.8911300898,
0.2175550759,
0.4827083051,
-0.1943386793,
-0.3818634152,
-0.0658135936,
-0.9412760735,
-0.4957331717,
-0.4473755658,
-0.3737304807,
-0.0957651287,
-0.15661183,
0.7829742432,
0.3123084903,
-0.4642266333,
0.0952295288,
-0.3660442233,
-0.0813488737,
0.3812618256,
-0.3186744153,
0.1061999202,
-0.8555011153,
-0.6834801435,
0.2326560915,
0.6518210173,
0.1978227645,
-0.3154112995,
0.2868833542,
0.0922125056,
-0.0920730978,
0.7690548897,
0.1464829296,
-0.8623642921,
-0.3063887954,
-0.0231504478,
0.0028419418,
0.1565669775,
0.9447045326,
-0.602052331,
0.1247286722,
0.1470203102,
0.7792224288,
0.5312706232,
0.0293924883,
0.476007998,
-0.6735693216,
-0.3353073895,
0.5047799945,
0.4593568444,
0.1858577132,
-0.5778619051,
0.6606958508,
0.3150399327,
-0.5518804193,
-0.5483666658,
0.3673802316,
-1.3331911564,
-0.0578928329,
1.3680925369,
0.0741813034,
-0.0980051234,
-0.1538963914,
-0.087356858,
0.2350108176,
-0.6613788009,
0.5630406737,
0.577075839,
-0.705008626,
-0.0709748194,
-0.4044910669,
0.7744359374,
-0.4135691524,
-1.2392506599,
-0.140835464,
0.4466766119,
0.4953939617,
0.3948492706,
0.8708171248,
-0.2707396448,
-0.1124592349,
-0.4081754386,
0.233905524,
0.0703787953,
-0.2206692249,
-0.2421762794,
0.1744749695,
0.1536448449,
0.1428010166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12556v1
|
IMBUE: Improving Interpersonal Effectiveness through Simulation and Just-in-time Feedback with Human-Language Model Interaction
| 2024-02-19T21:31:11 | 2024-02-19T21:31:11 |
Inna Wanyin Lin, Ashish Sharma, Christopher Michael Rytting, Adam S. Miner, Jina Suh, Tim Althoff
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Navigating certain communication situations can be challenging due to
individuals' lack of skills and the interference of strong emotions. However,
effective learning opportunities are rarely accessible. In this work, we
conduct a human-centered study that uses language models to simulate bespoke
communication training and provide just-in-time feedback to support the
practice and learning of interpersonal effectiveness skills. We apply the
interpersonal effectiveness framework from Dialectical Behavioral Therapy
(DBT), DEAR MAN, which focuses on both conversational and emotional skills. We
present IMBUE, an interactive training system that provides feedback 25% more
similar to experts' feedback, compared to that generated by GPT-4. IMBUE is the
first to focus on communication skills and emotion management simultaneously,
incorporate experts' domain knowledge in providing feedback, and be grounded in
psychology theory. Through a randomized trial of 86 participants, we find that
IMBUE's simulation-only variant significantly improves participants'
self-efficacy (up to 17%) and reduces negative emotions (up to 25%). With
IMBUE's additional just-in-time feedback, participants demonstrate 17%
improvement in skill mastery, along with greater enhancements in self-efficacy
(27% more) and reduction of negative emotions (16% more) compared to
simulation-only. The improvement in skill mastery is the only measure that is
transferred to new and more difficult situations; situation specific training
is necessary for improving self-efficacy and emotion reduction.
|
[
-0.4924282134,
-1.1612043381,
0.0644640625,
0.8693064451,
-0.0897368342,
0.5975334644,
-0.4047949314,
-0.4576344788,
0.4622193277,
-0.1874448657,
-0.4742359817,
0.0572572164,
-0.5798842907,
-0.0097595481,
-0.2512411475,
0.6672970653,
0.255531013,
0.4818794131,
0.1872901618,
0.061610505,
-0.4376614988,
-0.8446116447,
-0.6872106791,
-0.8867995143,
0.1696359515,
0.6452924609,
0.2654139102,
-0.1578590572,
0.5197649002,
0.2648185492,
0.0438455902,
-0.1783207059,
-0.7777989507,
-0.1327122301,
-0.4177156091,
-0.2281958461,
-0.3886519969,
0.2750575244,
0.4348866045,
0.4217534363,
-0.7360143661,
-0.0399256498,
0.5221655965,
0.3495511711,
-0.5694554448,
0.0056545082,
-0.3414306045,
0.0113523025,
0.0412635617,
-0.250867933,
-0.3624082208,
-0.4045520127,
0.1924757808,
-0.2310330868,
-0.2066020817,
0.0349126607,
0.8397412896,
-0.1332282722,
-0.4206353724,
-0.0775953382,
-0.8802841306,
0.3686842024,
-1.2087484598,
0.2658256888,
0.2256687135,
0.1976240426,
-0.3624203205,
-0.2708288431,
-0.5159897208,
-0.629704237,
0.0230868887,
0.5955747962,
-0.0194832608,
0.4212278426,
0.3873091936,
0.0688455552,
-0.0342004001,
0.0848200321,
-0.2599423826,
0.0942512825,
0.6638520956,
-0.0604783036,
0.1949081868,
0.0371402092,
-0.1906892508,
-0.1065145656,
-0.3876526356,
0.2377179116,
0.1100618541,
-0.2557340264,
-0.2357442975,
0.3933965266,
-0.2840921581,
0.1943293214,
0.3867864013,
-0.5008826852,
-0.2418801636,
-0.084106043,
0.0226729047,
0.0020361277,
0.5202714801,
0.348000288,
0.3941456378,
-0.4684999585,
0.0411892086,
0.0859759077,
0.6342230439,
-1.2342995405,
-0.2163722068,
0.0988223478,
-0.4173078835,
-0.3649492562,
0.1552826464,
-0.7767596245,
-0.0566422567,
-0.471175909,
0.4878309071,
-0.5603811145,
-0.7510921359,
-0.1547929794,
0.0780339018,
0.1863302886,
0.449698776,
-0.8253858089,
0.6746501327,
0.3062274158,
0.8430742025,
0.0813839734,
-0.2818723321,
-0.4800264239,
-0.0084394095,
-0.2415068597,
0.7013997436,
-0.5139698982,
-0.5603048205,
-0.1125259772,
-0.1703872383,
0.0202466343,
-0.7075187564,
0.2335342616,
0.0020370202,
0.1350489855,
-0.071123153,
-0.8264698982,
-0.0910272598,
0.4854456484,
0.0567881651,
0.8545188308,
0.3863355219,
-0.3129809201,
0.0987189636,
-0.8831783533,
-0.3734875023,
0.0197187811,
-0.0826174915,
-0.2675310075,
0.3213097453,
-0.139640823,
0.2178028524,
-0.1530936211,
0.0784063116,
-0.637513876,
-0.5757142901,
0.4014348388,
-0.0731363669,
0.3309601247,
0.1057492569,
-0.7158361673,
-0.1355126947,
-0.6955474019,
0.5183168054,
-0.0614241511,
-0.4995729327,
-0.0579887666,
-0.3888277113,
0.1523187459,
0.2347900867,
-0.2740023434,
-0.7462753654,
0.2116773129,
-0.3132006228,
0.0966028273,
0.6627164483,
0.2507841885,
0.37190938,
-0.2930676639,
0.8062952757,
0.0836551338,
0.2954067588,
0.0903620794,
-0.0800088421,
-0.5053576827,
-0.2516587675,
0.2661496699,
0.7477849126,
-0.6512433887,
0.1231917068,
-0.0658163801,
-0.5406007171,
-0.6310892105,
0.2051227093,
0.7103117704,
0.5533903241,
0.1030123681,
-0.8493441939,
-0.2235991657,
-0.6333095431,
-0.3427931666,
-0.3939251304,
0.3362519145,
-0.1050961316,
0.3589013815,
-0.2195887566,
0.8320094943,
0.0319263898,
-0.0380841419,
-0.316270113,
0.5910230875,
-0.1467260718,
0.5492893457,
0.4650686085,
-0.3115873933,
-0.861800909,
0.0195611753,
-0.8127654791,
-0.3940880299,
-0.0963355824,
-0.0974905267,
-0.0741743967,
0.3952273428,
-0.1030046046,
0.718934536,
0.3685317338,
-0.3024732769,
0.6037115455,
-0.4938040972,
0.7361755371,
-0.6481679678,
0.0148262726,
0.0810188428,
-0.3200438917,
-0.7282032371,
-0.3739112318,
0.2869036496,
-0.115950495,
-0.3731249571,
0.6157889366,
-0.3019363284,
0.2065188587,
-0.4417436421,
0.103792116,
-0.3235708475,
0.8091368675,
-0.194630459,
0.7581025362,
-0.0217311848,
-0.5598349571,
0.1830426306,
0.3614367843,
-0.5503274798,
1.3717006445,
-0.6187229753,
0.2184835374,
-0.2391174138,
-0.1756427288,
-0.6719833612,
-0.3460327983,
0.1439373046,
-0.3519732654,
0.5229693651,
0.0046902085,
-0.4016424119,
-0.3019809127,
0.0394341238,
-0.1069861576,
0.5758046508,
-0.2846689522,
0.4119326174,
0.1620778143,
-0.3986942172,
-0.5236631036,
-0.4430484772,
0.2848045826,
-0.0581603609,
-0.5700956583,
0.1105600223,
-0.628261745,
-0.5514506698,
-0.0215282515,
0.1175708696,
-0.2949832976,
0.4028304219,
0.1639371067,
-0.3030874431,
0.4033624828,
0.2397769094,
0.1904198676,
-0.148680672,
0.0586505011,
0.2828692198,
0.2848682702,
-0.4086017907,
-0.5667697787,
-0.6140106916,
0.6032009721,
0.3287024498,
-0.1020044163,
0.7833026648,
0.4696032107,
-0.2128800452,
-0.0047700689,
-0.8140779734,
-0.9107207656,
-0.379471153,
0.4748404622,
-0.4475093782,
-0.5398189425,
0.1967870146,
-0.5176315904,
0.0639133975,
-0.6250803471,
0.4782779515,
-0.6225633621,
1.0467185974,
0.7670187354,
0.067832239,
0.8837336898,
-0.2467927188,
0.4321660995,
-0.6923086047,
-0.1795672327,
0.0951406807,
-0.440379411,
0.1404473633,
0.0521236435,
0.7122043967,
0.3405787647,
-0.2278463542,
-0.1508027464,
-0.2551671267,
0.2757889926,
0.5727524161,
0.4765666425,
0.2885124087,
-0.1646470129,
0.1554915756,
-0.5699010491,
-0.7971448898,
-0.3922673762,
0.6169449687,
0.2241632044,
0.8753857613,
0.262803942,
0.7230485678,
0.371198684,
1.0578143597,
-0.5652837157,
0.3781120479,
0.4758882821,
-0.6966099143,
-0.0106235975,
-0.2621175647,
-0.7053971887,
0.4795197845,
-0.4766720831,
-0.6933358312,
-0.1199377924,
0.436044842,
-0.1007950157,
0.1343418509,
-1.1187345982,
0.7589297295,
-0.3964490592,
-0.5874084234,
-0.6528991461,
-0.673643589,
0.2048716396,
-0.1481326222,
0.2441541702,
-0.2580392659,
0.3908392191,
0.3587067723,
-0.6953487992,
0.8618656397,
-0.2299006134,
0.1615365595,
0.2368559092,
0.222448349,
0.5878725648,
-0.0479160361,
-0.2130277157,
-0.1618336141,
0.088341184,
-0.6521111727,
-1.0870531797,
0.2444295734,
-0.6836913824,
-0.5243862867,
-0.3169156909,
-0.281380862,
-0.3244920671,
0.0311264917,
0.305750221,
0.5951731205,
-0.6277101636,
0.3551320434,
0.797139585,
-0.0121608013,
0.2679750025,
0.9290061593,
-0.2280061245,
-0.5993848443,
0.5230167508,
0.3829194009,
0.6537250876,
0.1863216162,
0.2469559163,
-0.0637063533,
0.0020285891,
0.0961957723,
0.3725658357,
-0.6892724037,
0.0147505337,
-0.6046171784,
-0.1908540726,
-0.3220966458,
-0.3184730411,
-0.4923326671,
-0.0403938405,
0.1847894937,
-0.1901733577,
0.2507617772,
0.7602223754,
-0.6254048347,
0.9124085307,
-0.4888923168,
-0.1268773526,
0.2939578593,
0.3221445978,
0.2782753706,
-0.3459729552,
-0.7124658227,
0.2447437048,
-0.6644489169,
-1.0439002514,
0.4579836726,
0.1302898675,
0.383290261,
0.1489095092,
-0.0918192714,
0.83842659,
-0.0717568249,
0.3550738692,
0.367610842,
-1.2099124193,
0.4718866348,
-0.1185620129,
0.2536481917,
0.5363405347,
-0.0858446881,
-0.5989226103,
-0.5976213813,
-0.8750190735,
-0.4261888564,
0.6638415456,
0.3662807643,
-0.0784367099,
0.1000984088,
0.6288669705,
-0.1608507335,
0.5089920759,
-0.8646519184,
-0.2072653025,
-0.1542124748,
-0.2107770741,
0.1540687382,
-0.4195173383,
-0.2173644304,
-0.3262842,
1.0393214226,
-0.0570266731,
0.3476246893,
0.3011871278,
-0.1591055244,
-0.3082672954,
0.4814479947,
0.2463098168,
0.640930295,
-0.3569638729,
-0.1472724825,
0.3969471753,
-0.2556760907,
0.5481832027,
-0.2384680361,
0.342659831,
-0.17899701,
0.0873145908,
0.5521857142,
0.5383262038,
-0.5889725089,
0.6683765054,
-0.1153083071,
0.0219210088,
-0.2554065585,
-0.0081821717,
-0.0385956913,
0.431815058,
-0.1207134053,
-0.073490575,
0.0725681931,
-0.4914942384,
0.305195272,
0.4541402459,
-0.4640345275,
-0.3992608786,
0.648909986,
0.4920849204,
-0.450504154,
0.6008706689,
-0.319082588,
-0.3197581172,
0.4886085391,
0.6848950386,
0.6708485484,
-0.4732421041,
0.4129220843,
0.3207041919,
0.427834183,
-0.107034795,
0.3864990473,
-0.0940686911,
-0.4641521871,
-0.4651835859,
-0.0916216746,
-0.9393174648,
-0.0996203125,
-0.6876615286,
0.2143232673,
-0.5125201941,
-0.3649992049,
-0.5498103499,
0.0918890461,
-0.6593134999,
0.0496738665,
-0.1474445611,
0.7957089543,
-0.5199786425,
0.9214562774,
0.8256713748,
-0.5584671497,
-0.8878185153,
-0.151950404,
0.0126877213,
-0.6015942097,
0.4980596602,
-0.0016311381,
-0.2162055373,
0.3261849284,
-0.6491185427,
-0.6097156405,
0.9443300366,
0.6806776524,
-0.3076611757,
0.3433358967,
-0.1606199294,
0.6605980396,
-0.0848969892,
0.8810834289,
0.3838189244,
0.477063179,
-0.1365101784,
-1.1443682909,
-0.4684026241,
-0.565531075,
0.1026100293,
0.0147121223,
-1.1130671501,
0.3400196135,
-0.1956188679,
-0.1280417889,
0.1188733131,
0.7024248838,
0.1757494658,
0.1641920805,
0.5166751146,
0.5455006957,
0.7483404279,
-0.1155008301,
0.9622254372,
-0.4034710228,
0.2679464519,
1.05963099,
-0.2357515842,
0.5210249424,
0.3657310009,
-0.0109586371,
0.7485766411,
0.4472475052,
0.5747863054,
0.4491954744,
0.2010388225,
-0.4651910067,
-0.2754239142,
-0.1923424304,
-0.1380216479,
0.1177603826,
0.3115087748,
0.3226253092,
-0.1688546985,
0.5271348953,
0.3459572792,
0.2366523594,
0.1254872233,
0.735861361,
0.3399477005,
-0.631722331,
0.5351439714,
-0.3454547226,
0.5155709982,
-0.9406615496,
-0.0966954902,
-0.3599766791,
0.4878712893,
-0.1964540631,
-0.4381058514,
-0.0997035801,
-0.1723436266,
-0.0307929926,
-0.3969085217,
0.483222276,
-0.8817905188,
0.0011268117,
0.5736664534,
0.6812344193,
0.1512869298,
-0.1989425868,
-0.6828024387,
-0.0918797627,
-0.1614230871,
-0.3491777182,
0.4871433675,
0.4873480797,
0.288123548,
0.9243811965,
0.2904773951,
0.2146662325,
0.1308140755,
-0.0614602938,
0.6147308946,
-0.7487982512,
-0.5461369753,
-0.584726572,
0.7241077423,
-0.4964760542,
-0.1341154426,
0.6586107016,
0.0442051552,
0.5706450343,
-0.0351078548,
0.9638400674,
-0.2879329622,
0.6757197976,
-0.107679233,
0.3228828609,
-0.6491273046,
0.0464449488,
-0.4091088474,
-0.8985959888,
0.1384917796,
0.6152912974,
-0.0996195376,
-0.104276605,
0.6885082722,
0.7952378392,
0.0541382134,
-0.130157277,
0.4009500742,
0.4163713157,
0.8744902015,
0.3977412879,
1.0063580275,
-0.1509445161,
0.1656190306,
-0.7931599021,
-0.6984940171,
-0.3203149736,
-0.8760144711,
-0.8638083935,
-0.3615829051,
-0.3354997933,
-0.4519385099,
0.2717703581,
1.3606705666,
0.9388981462,
-0.346647948,
-0.6887430549,
0.1952689588,
-0.2476265728,
-0.3468208611,
-0.241430521,
-0.3252901733,
-0.5335799456,
-0.6913203597,
0.4302981794,
0.5321379304,
0.4220657051,
-0.1068199724,
-0.1992045641,
-0.049237147,
0.1538792998,
0.7043814659,
0.4456936419,
-0.40958938,
-0.2075176984,
-0.1615389585,
-0.114594765,
0.1588778049,
0.7101634145,
-0.6708185077,
0.8740931153,
0.0452678166,
0.4851581156,
0.5327363014,
0.2557528317,
0.8172578216,
-0.6434580684,
0.4938121736,
0.0320528485,
0.3420309424,
0.2808653414,
-0.3900322318,
0.8933283687,
0.3190008998,
-0.7094432712,
-0.6952268481,
0.1710830629,
-0.7620366216,
-0.0703837574,
1.0418046713,
-0.264249146,
0.1940619051,
-0.0421884619,
-0.6672087312,
0.2625070512,
-0.5047696829,
1.2467266321,
1.0423016548,
-0.4555102885,
-0.2145386636,
-0.4261551499,
0.2040118426,
0.9238328338,
-1.1241511106,
-0.4147593379,
0.1785380393,
0.2409450561,
-0.1441465914,
1.1537641287,
0.095109269,
0.0431350283,
-0.3142797947,
0.4210916758,
0.4111165702,
-0.1492705196,
-0.1547946483,
-0.1394824088,
0.2554619908,
0.3053979874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12554v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12554v2
|
Archer: A Human-Labeled Text-to-SQL Dataset with Arithmetic, Commonsense and Hypothetical Reasoning
| 2024-02-19T21:24:36 | 2024-02-25T00:12:38 |
Danna Zheng, Mirella Lapata, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Archer, a challenging bilingual text-to-SQL dataset specific to
complex reasoning, including arithmetic, commonsense and hypothetical
reasoning. It contains 1,042 English questions and 1,042 Chinese questions,
along with 521 unique SQL queries, covering 20 English databases across 20
domains. Notably, this dataset demonstrates a significantly higher level of
complexity compared to existing publicly available datasets. Our evaluation
shows that Archer challenges the capabilities of current state-of-the-art
models, with a high-ranked model on the Spider leaderboard achieving only 6.73%
execution accuracy on Archer test set. Thus, Archer presents a significant
challenge for future research in this field.
|
[
-0.1604204476,
-0.8452436924,
0.2941061258,
0.1703925878,
-0.0733862296,
0.1343681514,
0.3006337583,
-0.5305256248,
-0.0134828575,
0.4131958187,
-0.6136615872,
-0.5257633328,
-0.5775975585,
0.5784279108,
-0.3377504349,
0.9463150501,
0.1439944059,
0.1694385111,
-0.1457271278,
-0.4563775361,
-0.6780548096,
-0.7055591941,
-0.6371918917,
-0.045519162,
0.4889168441,
0.5757478476,
1.0293234587,
0.3873218596,
0.715364933,
0.2467971146,
0.0579781719,
0.5417667627,
-0.4272715151,
-0.072505787,
-0.586976707,
-0.6227201223,
-0.7257063389,
-0.2367080897,
0.4222719073,
0.9534373283,
0.0733576268,
0.3421758115,
-0.4574111104,
0.979942441,
-0.4391258955,
0.1806424856,
-0.73026371,
0.113638863,
-0.4068086445,
0.0492944382,
-0.6915556192,
-0.0918492079,
0.2759765983,
-0.7570415735,
0.1072972044,
0.8650246859,
0.9690628052,
0.1146746725,
-1.1861897707,
-0.1610190123,
-0.5530554652,
0.8811047673,
-0.3126877546,
0.128540948,
0.556024611,
0.6698871255,
-0.1998369247,
-0.6865081787,
-0.5697616935,
0.0614479147,
-0.2687385976,
-0.1755761504,
-0.4310031533,
-0.1312102079,
0.2211184502,
0.0105125597,
-0.8826451898,
-0.0405095406,
-0.3582395911,
0.030129727,
1.1815057993,
0.5409198999,
0.4847492278,
-0.2139021158,
0.1400254816,
0.1893815398,
-0.901702106,
-0.0234422535,
0.2920573652,
0.2887095809,
0.1848994792,
0.9527190328,
-0.3772921264,
1.0944782495,
0.0258478299,
0.2132617831,
-0.0977777466,
-0.0274329074,
-0.2596261203,
0.1409928352,
0.6222890019,
0.2969507277,
0.2828873694,
-0.0373850949,
-0.1732391119,
-0.1332815439,
-0.0116621731,
-0.6679480076,
-0.2949737906,
0.6572458744,
-0.2296491116,
-0.2258021533,
-0.1142249033,
-0.4740730524,
-0.4357815087,
-0.2741521597,
0.6230076551,
-0.3514860272,
-0.2220763266,
0.3236613274,
-0.0268303677,
0.324029088,
0.4167783856,
-0.838296771,
0.3554887772,
0.9629352689,
0.5158202052,
-0.2784595191,
-0.3270658553,
-0.3595331013,
0.0765830353,
-0.6101098061,
0.9490252137,
-0.7587721348,
-0.1131823882,
-0.3494866788,
0.1384354085,
-0.0417410918,
-0.5238939524,
0.5345489979,
-0.634133935,
0.2968663871,
-0.4070006907,
-0.7859076262,
-0.2673847079,
0.2556239963,
-0.9370217323,
0.6924290061,
-0.079917945,
-0.7708384395,
0.2644845843,
-0.5639292598,
-0.7826782465,
0.313646853,
-0.2293593735,
-0.3552564681,
-0.1815075725,
0.2833635807,
0.3927100897,
-0.7463967204,
0.584631443,
-0.160569489,
-0.3884562552,
0.2435096651,
-0.3122329712,
1.1058909893,
0.460573405,
-0.1850899011,
-0.1406932175,
-0.8494668007,
-0.0120137343,
0.3507196307,
0.0672557503,
-0.1992133409,
0.3353940845,
-0.3088998199,
-0.2792651355,
0.1578089297,
-0.5009900928,
0.3118621111,
-0.2170730829,
0.2855122387,
0.4010061622,
0.0411269739,
0.0860877782,
-0.4626152217,
0.6478876472,
0.0429225937,
-0.1482853889,
-0.1847130507,
-0.8564524651,
-0.6366919279,
-0.1163417175,
0.1293415874,
0.9190340638,
-0.7340664268,
0.2983189821,
-0.4373804331,
-0.6074391007,
-0.5217754245,
-0.4679622054,
0.4492355585,
0.678316474,
0.3449572325,
0.3617585301,
-0.2772460878,
-1.0834419727,
-0.5911051631,
-0.0231477376,
-0.0244416874,
0.4737987816,
0.8582328558,
0.2801248431,
0.8661743999,
-0.8378686905,
-0.3551584482,
-0.3094626665,
0.3773699999,
0.3585218489,
0.3456948996,
0.3118419051,
-1.134843111,
-0.6122174263,
0.2394454181,
-1.0367952585,
0.2948901355,
-0.2375166118,
0.014951841,
0.2806973159,
0.0631597638,
-0.6516661644,
0.4474519193,
0.2830019295,
-0.7617646456,
0.7326506376,
-0.0932181999,
0.6312234402,
-1.1378479004,
0.1520242393,
0.0561594628,
0.0096352119,
-0.7095195055,
0.1704048067,
0.0098016476,
-0.4825633466,
-0.5270046592,
0.5266360641,
-0.4515795708,
0.0190223567,
0.2772925496,
-0.0595065355,
0.1808756143,
0.4726553559,
0.0536594689,
1.0552467108,
0.6082721949,
-0.2495145947,
0.8676224947,
0.3171037138,
-0.4214370251,
0.9683490992,
-1.0108423233,
0.1045553163,
-0.3878154457,
0.1618154645,
-1.0258885622,
-0.6231865883,
-0.2600471079,
-0.6682177186,
-0.0201820526,
-0.1943400949,
-0.5020461679,
-0.142171666,
-0.038720943,
0.7080619931,
0.3229604661,
-0.4647895098,
0.627820909,
0.5612921119,
-0.0353378393,
-0.6895061731,
-0.7185251117,
0.398486197,
-0.2293577343,
-1.0530343056,
0.1175502241,
0.3592230678,
-0.5306216478,
0.1224516556,
0.1740789711,
-0.5105602741,
-0.1206437573,
-0.0912475288,
0.4485055506,
-0.2580346465,
0.3192629516,
0.1867697239,
0.1984254867,
0.1427948326,
-0.1371008158,
-0.0950098485,
-0.4746102691,
-0.5518260598,
-0.4706211686,
0.6281907558,
0.2395104319,
-0.318813175,
0.7334943414,
-0.2126555294,
-0.6435155272,
-0.2279445976,
-0.0536434725,
0.1300856322,
-0.4751774371,
0.6426348686,
-0.8111924529,
-0.6890975833,
0.3584863544,
0.1030910611,
0.1836316884,
0.671451211,
0.1901583225,
-0.1687003374,
1.5368475914,
-0.1842979491,
0.0770556703,
-0.6536508203,
-0.2565327883,
0.3352547586,
-0.2768782973,
-0.5328480601,
-0.6813584566,
-0.2690370679,
-0.438200593,
-0.2807920277,
0.3172483444,
-0.2498199493,
-0.6288660169,
0.333496511,
-0.7398509383,
0.912121594,
0.1850289702,
0.058335986,
0.5684591532,
-0.1493635476,
0.3791280091,
-0.2389993072,
-0.5167683959,
-0.4657535255,
1.1839003563,
-0.1405620128,
0.7221231461,
0.6069039106,
0.1017661765,
0.7544378638,
-0.0709002614,
-0.6680895686,
0.7166496515,
-0.3266076744,
-1.2714768648,
-0.5175107121,
-0.4658848941,
-1.2991024256,
0.2475351393,
-0.3069924116,
-0.7070008516,
-0.1154019833,
0.2687658072,
-0.1372893602,
0.3832021356,
-0.9961816072,
0.9697794914,
-0.4983308911,
-0.4478343427,
-0.1565517038,
-0.7586082816,
0.4953680038,
-0.1068100631,
0.2422574311,
-0.1509759575,
-0.0558778271,
0.7580714822,
-0.5659840703,
0.5486040711,
0.0515939742,
0.2839840055,
0.4618237317,
0.2972575426,
0.7643258572,
-0.1443098038,
-0.2149406672,
-0.0755705088,
0.3270212114,
-0.7460916638,
-0.6678984165,
0.4326368868,
-0.6292276382,
-0.7638145089,
-0.9665181637,
-0.4415960908,
-0.4230906069,
0.38895154,
0.0795267448,
0.7387257218,
-0.049959626,
0.2629393637,
0.7263197899,
-0.25683254,
-0.184100464,
0.3286156952,
-0.2923310697,
-0.248271212,
1.2216669321,
0.1835773438,
0.1233423725,
0.5414803624,
-0.001717114,
-0.3912190497,
-0.4677426815,
-0.7007635832,
0.2782233953,
-0.7090791464,
-0.1950464696,
-0.3501983881,
-0.0710627362,
-0.3485276103,
-0.1840207726,
-0.1943657547,
-0.7131641507,
-0.350698173,
-0.0713448822,
0.4307227433,
0.9110907316,
0.6305066347,
-0.080359444,
-0.6451377273,
0.3677169085,
0.4863123,
0.2982726395,
-0.0146375587,
-0.5420353413,
0.0838847831,
0.1585767716,
-0.0771986544,
-1.0784010887,
0.3798669577,
0.3687447011,
0.3080694377,
0.1686357707,
0.4328524768,
0.7565128803,
-0.4347397685,
0.8609234691,
-0.0612085722,
-0.8993993402,
0.5095439553,
-0.4834641218,
0.1764457971,
0.4887808859,
0.9637389183,
-0.2829494774,
0.0409052782,
-0.4587584138,
-0.484444797,
0.7670718431,
0.1902917624,
-0.1275182962,
0.2027395815,
0.1766099036,
-0.0778767765,
-0.0359766148,
-0.3782508373,
-0.3392968178,
0.040935047,
-0.2852956355,
0.2071348429,
-0.0439344496,
0.0282543264,
-0.5729458928,
0.5133219361,
-0.0270334519,
-0.0891763791,
-0.028715346,
-0.058946643,
0.2727966607,
0.2194775194,
0.383271873,
0.858289361,
-0.2130645961,
0.1529287696,
0.4334874451,
-0.3609277308,
0.230697304,
-0.0013251263,
-0.1703222096,
-0.2260350138,
0.5767617822,
0.6746576428,
-0.145739466,
-1.0582551956,
0.5423087478,
-0.0421574041,
-0.2577706873,
-0.3201534748,
-0.1034921706,
0.2333225161,
-0.2178715765,
0.7001995444,
-0.0768028051,
0.351549536,
-0.528375864,
0.2406424135,
0.342433542,
-0.1711484343,
-0.2553011775,
0.8339745998,
0.4659202397,
-0.6922547817,
0.7077603936,
-0.4921474159,
-0.4233162105,
0.8209983706,
0.4415512085,
0.562906146,
0.1281722933,
0.1944523007,
0.4472605288,
0.3473440409,
0.0302509312,
0.4434573352,
0.1265633553,
-0.4616329074,
-0.3752349615,
-0.2329821438,
-0.75191921,
-0.2654947042,
-0.541610539,
0.5601286292,
-0.3019625247,
0.0328667611,
0.4787849188,
0.1595100313,
-0.2537295818,
0.3124437034,
-0.485898912,
1.0255506039,
-0.8559602499,
0.827724874,
0.7460526824,
-0.3500638902,
-0.8818877339,
-0.4399922788,
0.269295305,
-0.7346388698,
0.7074828148,
0.1673864871,
-0.3359314799,
0.0352701917,
-0.6521865726,
-0.7065365911,
1.09109056,
0.3387796283,
-0.3216796219,
-0.0147950044,
0.5214170218,
0.5898041725,
-0.3644307554,
0.1878028512,
0.76404351,
0.4916992784,
0.4016716182,
-0.7305818796,
-0.0639234111,
-0.4709784389,
-0.3192753792,
0.2568089366,
-0.5963982344,
0.9017599821,
-0.4933699965,
-0.2922422886,
-0.2132597119,
0.7356938124,
0.3812401295,
0.5620544553,
0.2945275307,
0.486199379,
0.8812840581,
-0.1341499686,
0.8054251671,
0.125349924,
0.2752613425,
1.1783578396,
-0.6493033171,
0.8511663079,
0.073110722,
-0.6419241428,
0.3658475876,
0.6027174592,
-0.1176331863,
0.103113696,
0.1103012189,
-0.3652379215,
-0.3836587667,
-0.1236225516,
-0.2006888688,
0.3534033,
0.2892456055,
0.3413150012,
-0.134612605,
-0.2674253881,
0.2005815655,
0.4362428486,
-0.1209781319,
0.6536794305,
-0.2260228842,
-1.0061957836,
0.6218852401,
-0.0170782842,
0.2965472043,
-0.4576577544,
-0.4013411403,
-0.3893966079,
0.0601253286,
-0.4642911255,
-1.2105760574,
0.5855269432,
0.2316715121,
0.2693715394,
0.2093432099,
0.523671627,
-0.2266747802,
-0.7770339251,
-0.3501217365,
0.045050662,
0.4543967545,
-0.1303004771,
-0.675557375,
-0.1317230612,
0.2232516259,
-0.1957909167,
0.1940619946,
0.8084038496,
-0.2605527639,
1.1259937286,
0.4641484022,
0.0055819489,
0.0306922998,
-0.4622404277,
0.4965866506,
-0.7036134005,
-0.2450013757,
-0.7130570412,
0.447920531,
-0.3330961764,
-0.4194337726,
0.8365838528,
0.858484447,
0.5106273293,
-0.0339064486,
0.5506494045,
-0.2377942652,
0.6421487331,
-0.2121429443,
0.7755128145,
-0.8135675788,
0.3728109896,
0.0102848578,
-0.2589397132,
-0.638969779,
0.2239144892,
-0.2083849311,
-0.175826326,
0.7059889436,
0.8324929476,
0.1096112058,
0.3806443512,
0.3316079974,
-0.0171726719,
0.4611886144,
0.9269880056,
0.5281723142,
-0.3921728432,
0.7597971559,
-0.0545107238,
-0.2306201905,
-0.1144570485,
-0.8117986321,
-1.0124738216,
-0.8137562275,
-0.0824048817,
-0.2066651732,
0.1585867852,
1.0161399841,
0.6268484592,
-1.1188284159,
-0.3842706084,
-0.1030818298,
0.3387657702,
-0.0802683532,
-0.2204052508,
0.6933615208,
-0.0514762029,
-0.6348590851,
-0.0264855381,
0.0991616175,
-0.0757578015,
-0.1475477368,
0.0220020078,
-0.5193622112,
0.1998624653,
0.7156777978,
0.4374143779,
-0.4733364582,
-0.2345856577,
0.1819722056,
-0.0925882235,
-0.1412605494,
0.4458864033,
-0.6591453552,
0.5682598352,
0.5807316303,
0.8535519838,
0.4591308832,
0.1387904882,
0.5011795163,
-0.5390394926,
0.1359139234,
0.5515370965,
0.263263762,
0.2610321045,
-0.4520008862,
0.5520678163,
0.2498802394,
-0.6621643901,
-0.9871257544,
0.29768309,
-0.8905678988,
-0.4747262597,
0.8292125463,
-0.1296429038,
-0.2257929444,
-0.4170752764,
-0.3750311434,
-0.3298105597,
-0.1813542694,
0.6609636545,
0.8009695411,
-0.5226284862,
-0.006981486,
-0.1345168054,
0.4865374565,
0.5121357441,
-1.1374702454,
0.1831020117,
0.6822817922,
0.0281109568,
-0.1557503045,
0.4635771215,
0.1374509335,
0.4340859056,
0.1676350385,
-0.3645210266,
-0.2072257102,
-0.4757890105,
-0.0094736582,
0.2821983397,
0.1435940266,
0.023266295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12545v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12545v2
|
TrustScore: Reference-Free Evaluation of LLM Response Trustworthiness
| 2024-02-19T21:12:14 | 2024-05-06T22:02:10 |
Danna Zheng, Danyang Liu, Mirella Lapata, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
various domains, prompting a surge in their practical applications. However,
concerns have arisen regarding the trustworthiness of LLMs outputs,
particularly in closed-book question-answering tasks, where non-experts may
struggle to identify inaccuracies due to the absence of contextual or ground
truth information. This paper introduces TrustScore, a framework based on the
concept of Behavioral Consistency, which evaluates whether an LLMs response
aligns with its intrinsic knowledge. Additionally, TrustScore can seamlessly
integrate with fact-checking methods, which assesses alignment with external
knowledge sources. The experimental results show that TrustScore achieves
strong correlations with human judgments, surpassing existing reference-free
metrics, and achieving results on par with reference-based metrics.
|
[
-0.1126531214,
-0.6058505774,
0.8709999323,
0.0519432127,
-0.0697875917,
0.263632834,
-0.2864218056,
-0.4486066699,
-0.0836906433,
0.2854761183,
-0.3987267017,
-0.5275017619,
-0.801117599,
-0.0893877223,
-0.5387186408,
0.939876914,
-0.1576363444,
-0.0075847958,
-0.940834403,
-0.2882773876,
-0.2347641587,
-0.4836501181,
-0.5009341836,
-0.6826035976,
0.0946417898,
0.3436707258,
0.8545943499,
0.555351615,
0.7200453281,
0.2300908864,
-0.0032403045,
0.4272731245,
-0.5907236934,
0.2102147192,
-0.5372489095,
-0.3982398212,
-0.6697882414,
0.2440627366,
0.5609127283,
0.2354366928,
-0.3261071146,
0.4453754127,
0.2497339398,
0.6022347212,
-0.6076878309,
0.2568499446,
-0.6914899349,
-0.0402143188,
0.0979976729,
-0.1969504654,
-0.363235563,
-0.7913579345,
0.001831864,
-0.4147089124,
-0.0011870331,
0.3177874684,
0.8090756536,
0.3144806623,
-0.3342407048,
-0.3502848744,
-0.4698871672,
0.7529482245,
-0.6225107908,
0.6945676208,
0.5514632463,
0.1643363088,
-0.0339182205,
-0.4537570179,
-0.6028524637,
-0.5299692154,
-0.1030928418,
0.2763160169,
0.0156355165,
-0.2136562318,
0.0595741682,
0.4547062218,
-0.4576047361,
-0.2168014944,
0.0675417706,
-0.5005164742,
0.5342911482,
0.276014626,
0.1318187714,
0.0033335004,
-0.5484958887,
0.0542407781,
-0.612414062,
0.0812087506,
0.2269047201,
0.2502216697,
-0.2650526762,
0.7548109293,
-0.2454371601,
0.4666512012,
0.3116989434,
-0.446745038,
-0.017956648,
-0.4184976816,
-0.2817735672,
0.0667290613,
0.6831489205,
0.5538470745,
0.5003623962,
-0.4326112568,
-0.1790930927,
0.2320932001,
0.2330734432,
-0.6376715899,
0.2361693978,
0.5191106796,
-0.2757683694,
-0.3477037251,
0.0876753926,
-0.2869121432,
-0.5477606058,
-0.4254493415,
0.232579574,
-0.5609917641,
-0.4018196464,
0.0256070755,
0.1244264841,
0.3677048683,
0.3559743762,
-0.3318915963,
0.5167410374,
0.99567312,
0.8221638203,
-0.5414920449,
-0.1737928241,
-0.8635575771,
0.377423346,
-0.3100432456,
0.7327145338,
-0.4802062213,
-0.5238568187,
0.0072762663,
-0.2463777065,
0.0139645031,
-0.5669260621,
0.7112713456,
-0.724273622,
-0.1521621495,
-0.3008729219,
-0.8843636513,
0.1121942326,
0.8672770262,
-0.3189811409,
1.1796042919,
-0.0171917696,
-0.7158228755,
-0.0680712089,
-0.2883199453,
-0.2210626602,
-0.135615617,
-0.2019356191,
-0.1210979074,
0.158614099,
-0.1837585717,
0.2145060599,
-0.4082145989,
0.5033084154,
-0.5401700735,
-0.2836025655,
0.6812998056,
-0.1984805614,
0.5766249895,
0.2287549525,
-0.1474325508,
0.1159620211,
-0.6389232874,
0.4259879589,
-0.0572296567,
-0.1891077012,
-0.2963214517,
-0.0724980906,
-0.2602334023,
0.1592497975,
0.6264218688,
-0.7745269537,
-0.2255641073,
0.0450348072,
0.1225838661,
0.9109373093,
-0.0739130154,
0.177810967,
-0.6172910929,
0.2771116793,
0.4242622852,
0.270154506,
0.3315833509,
-0.2905813754,
-0.7126353979,
-0.0787387341,
0.1037796214,
0.5765864253,
-0.2687073052,
0.4269604087,
-0.515181601,
-0.5689737201,
-0.3492763937,
0.3198365569,
0.7021862268,
0.9391199946,
0.2585492134,
-0.4618130028,
-0.4090313911,
-1.0392003059,
-0.4992508888,
-0.5629892349,
0.1664302349,
0.3355564177,
0.310862422,
-0.1351069063,
1.0903809071,
-0.5732966661,
-0.1345311105,
0.2017214447,
-0.1145577431,
0.0283169262,
0.3629910648,
0.0893760473,
-0.4333310425,
-0.3744770586,
-0.0587860197,
-0.9658094645,
0.0393602289,
0.479277879,
-0.1579588801,
0.0358563177,
0.4264746308,
-0.7580422163,
-0.0042041978,
0.6798476577,
-0.2835676968,
0.6857368946,
0.0580595657,
0.3112607598,
-1.1098017693,
0.2209884077,
0.0753610805,
-0.5400037766,
-0.2604623437,
0.1866289377,
0.1875721216,
0.0618784539,
-0.35467875,
0.7466356754,
-0.2143247575,
-0.3119157255,
-0.0091751115,
0.5112563372,
-0.0135923438,
0.0660749301,
0.0327186696,
1.0824369192,
0.2286812961,
-0.5650563836,
0.3677895963,
0.549210608,
-0.4297614098,
1.1691285372,
-0.6539596319,
0.4787153006,
0.0511514768,
-0.0238490794,
-0.839812994,
-0.0667439029,
-0.0932519138,
-0.6564720869,
-0.0379329324,
-0.0071764556,
-0.5711912513,
-0.1766690463,
-0.3261549473,
0.0543505885,
0.4434607625,
-0.2250682265,
0.7348574996,
0.2656932473,
0.08678215,
-0.6901341081,
-0.5376952887,
-0.1495540142,
0.1415774822,
-0.5951682329,
-0.0593625829,
-0.5369150043,
-0.5475179553,
0.1572364271,
-0.3480354846,
-0.2026372105,
0.2726213336,
0.3600814939,
0.2437833548,
-0.3668229878,
0.0637264922,
-0.383785516,
-0.0478650294,
0.2437325865,
-0.1200837046,
0.2659893334,
-0.5625036359,
-0.6183686852,
-0.2934964001,
0.0400502719,
0.7236613035,
-0.2926132679,
0.6177259088,
0.3498866558,
-0.390829891,
0.0005181988,
-0.6328467727,
-0.1370024383,
-0.4894004762,
0.1729395539,
-0.2178108692,
-1.1082850695,
0.4504804313,
0.0248274617,
-0.1350975186,
0.2478860915,
0.5212571621,
-0.1785391122,
0.6204416752,
0.4333711267,
-0.0977945626,
-0.0282892846,
0.3885209858,
0.3461204767,
-0.9973608255,
-0.4136155844,
-0.5596454144,
0.0318461135,
-0.2599596083,
-0.4266676307,
0.368408531,
0.0129028028,
-0.4799488783,
0.0546083041,
-0.0108400276,
0.4390695393,
0.3949636817,
0.2219081074,
0.8319492936,
-0.1623708904,
-0.2977588773,
0.0246307719,
-0.1818742752,
-0.7502095699,
1.0720467567,
0.2587045133,
0.7756122351,
0.4178549051,
0.4369528592,
0.5416948795,
0.7433078289,
-0.8748281598,
0.6843609214,
0.118310228,
-0.7325718999,
-0.0510011464,
-0.310023576,
-0.2573667169,
-0.1325993687,
-0.3962572813,
-0.6497917771,
-0.3970584571,
0.1894143224,
-0.2879192829,
0.2541891336,
-0.520478785,
0.3440474272,
-0.3632977009,
-0.648109436,
-0.1719691008,
-0.3604125977,
0.5748137832,
-0.1047081426,
0.0163369998,
-0.360906899,
-0.0502754115,
0.6113791466,
-0.1723187715,
0.8684107661,
0.0709016174,
-0.2053721547,
0.4207439423,
0.4478293061,
0.6416228414,
0.2242574692,
-0.2290145904,
0.1825681478,
0.1595212966,
-0.2151423991,
-0.7325556278,
0.9636257887,
-0.9324948788,
-0.8963618875,
-0.5371502638,
-0.7152354121,
-0.988955915,
0.3400922418,
-0.3196833432,
0.2761612833,
-0.5337588191,
0.1860451996,
1.0065327883,
0.085104309,
0.0162069295,
1.0444363356,
-0.174542129,
-0.3040006757,
0.5136548877,
-0.2529753745,
0.216928184,
0.3064098656,
0.1550330073,
-0.5388110876,
-0.6031405926,
-0.1602574885,
0.3333515823,
-0.7247613072,
-0.5031369328,
-0.4952909648,
-0.4532915652,
-0.3910292685,
0.1302729398,
-0.5715532303,
-0.2075949758,
0.0463186353,
-0.4584878385,
0.3865143657,
0.7034850121,
0.2150937021,
0.1437272877,
-1.041035533,
0.0322540887,
0.3471198678,
0.8085076213,
-0.0410709903,
-0.4852720499,
-0.2412009388,
-0.0152416658,
-0.3332409263,
-0.5887028575,
-0.2393624634,
0.0573335588,
0.6191794872,
0.4162941873,
0.1620746553,
0.6238905787,
-0.3841155171,
0.8639532328,
0.2459582835,
-1.1645666361,
0.2589724958,
-0.3641354144,
0.0726876184,
0.7875352502,
0.4390381575,
-0.5755876899,
-0.4855831265,
-0.6769037247,
-0.2696347237,
0.1698541492,
0.174119547,
0.0018404193,
-0.1834119111,
0.4358754456,
-0.0028740009,
0.4533088207,
-0.336153537,
-0.1357820332,
-0.0874281973,
-0.4545722008,
-0.1478239745,
-0.3444308937,
-0.5146890879,
0.1651053727,
0.6285019517,
-0.2004258037,
0.1940129846,
0.3199739158,
-0.3339953125,
-0.2555505931,
0.4535954297,
0.6461797357,
0.9166426659,
-0.3809489012,
0.4636231363,
0.0486769564,
-0.4780989885,
0.2842379808,
-0.2760198712,
-0.1028335392,
-0.3491751254,
0.4513834715,
0.1937118471,
0.1263785958,
-0.7476984859,
0.7083055377,
-0.0609513484,
-0.056074027,
-0.3750370741,
0.1739610136,
0.3605986834,
0.2516562045,
0.1477853507,
0.0714226067,
-0.1586306393,
-0.4415003359,
0.5498079658,
0.6427310705,
-0.641851902,
-0.4196636677,
0.5359585881,
0.2271302789,
-0.1763432622,
0.8043401241,
0.1074784175,
-0.4338497221,
0.4024625123,
0.5748707056,
0.8106053472,
-0.2985141277,
0.164904952,
0.375761956,
0.3689887226,
-0.0595930964,
0.3429828584,
0.1114043891,
-1.1384660006,
-0.2212223411,
-0.6344235539,
-0.8374109268,
0.0992181003,
-0.9409121275,
-0.1622901559,
-0.7806366682,
-0.3072954118,
-0.5557078123,
0.1359351128,
-0.6690312624,
0.4243931174,
-0.0423755422,
1.3236504793,
-0.8452304602,
0.8302379847,
0.6678766608,
-0.2347114086,
-0.788380444,
0.1119254678,
0.121466279,
-1.2025830746,
0.6063871384,
-0.1179460138,
-0.6622981429,
-0.1229206845,
-0.5441939235,
-0.9771899581,
1.2283397913,
0.5038687587,
-0.4061194658,
0.2497933209,
0.0986699536,
0.5895185471,
-0.3401492536,
0.2312858105,
0.4975931942,
0.6145538688,
-0.0580276065,
-1.0101157427,
0.3151569664,
-0.1824581772,
-0.1106649786,
-0.0924060941,
-1.024204731,
0.4703720212,
-0.0945939347,
-0.0328996368,
0.07914114,
0.8840757608,
0.5027525425,
0.1280379891,
0.3778751791,
0.7016559243,
1.1284841299,
-0.0276652239,
1.1270591021,
-0.6318074465,
0.3874251544,
1.3882461786,
-0.6523886323,
1.0760874748,
0.5378006697,
-0.1451984346,
0.6091071367,
0.4127687216,
0.2971667051,
0.3905675113,
-0.0396230631,
-0.1760574728,
-0.5200403929,
-0.4694783092,
-0.2913151979,
0.382534951,
0.1151668429,
-0.146411553,
-0.1503924727,
-0.7697991133,
0.1576398015,
0.3797896504,
-0.2680181563,
0.500148356,
0.2909297049,
-0.7454785705,
0.2620154023,
-0.1129621938,
0.4353135824,
-0.7460886836,
0.1970745027,
-0.42654863,
0.3284741342,
-0.3749336302,
-1.0798823833,
0.512265265,
0.016413141,
-0.3974580467,
-0.024070045,
0.601591289,
-0.2842134237,
-0.1928194314,
0.3228873014,
0.878914535,
-0.1424820721,
0.0944398642,
-0.7114142776,
0.1773129553,
-0.401575774,
-0.0481573157,
0.4707601368,
0.123287648,
-0.0009796957,
0.8425123692,
0.5418271422,
-0.0180412084,
-0.3398604989,
-0.2593089342,
0.6241694093,
-0.4467283487,
-0.3416647315,
-0.690689981,
0.2273273021,
-0.2385614663,
-0.1545096189,
1.1015268564,
0.7178272009,
0.6748507023,
0.0386515707,
0.8764654398,
0.268404603,
0.5511267185,
-0.4960122108,
0.5448450446,
-0.3039999604,
0.0197903179,
-0.0182672497,
-0.7416638136,
0.0361694619,
0.3965910077,
-0.3146537244,
0.0839089453,
1.0392897129,
0.7532041669,
-0.2614938915,
0.1323761344,
0.3594529927,
0.3801411986,
0.1177981272,
0.4785514772,
0.881726265,
-0.2331070751,
0.3586305976,
0.1744064987,
-0.0726756081,
-0.0084070535,
-1.315841794,
-0.7777699828,
-0.3429132104,
-0.3853430748,
-0.8421289325,
0.1818756908,
0.8933897018,
0.582048893,
-1.023042202,
-0.3618680239,
0.3626636863,
0.1938914359,
-0.2516293526,
-0.1933680475,
0.2459552735,
-0.2068827897,
-0.4535769522,
0.2947621346,
0.3038783967,
-0.0360659324,
-0.283991158,
-0.2612676919,
0.0679443553,
0.4365199506,
0.5520169139,
0.0364606418,
-0.5947502851,
-0.646551013,
0.2418625653,
-0.4062788188,
0.1169533059,
0.8632954955,
-0.4785281718,
0.0620256364,
0.2412385345,
0.8137099147,
0.1417645812,
0.3163459301,
0.5211190581,
-0.6497894526,
-0.1859113127,
0.0901309326,
0.3040308654,
0.5749059319,
-0.4415692687,
0.5208442807,
0.1264704317,
-0.400811255,
-0.5899385214,
0.4309560657,
-1.1932729483,
0.1347309202,
1.3142410517,
-0.3658738732,
-0.3611989021,
-0.0631674156,
0.2603224516,
0.0370240062,
-0.3968564272,
0.7450860143,
1.0532882214,
-0.1871309876,
-0.0169840381,
-0.3283142447,
0.425165385,
0.3431404531,
-0.8120373487,
0.1492531449,
0.5383633375,
0.8365042806,
0.2422204167,
0.8485950232,
-0.2758949995,
0.0726607665,
-0.3432683647,
-0.1787458807,
-0.3218769133,
-0.0139371501,
0.0109927943,
0.3538896441,
0.6368519068,
0.2345796824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12530v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12530v1
|
Parallel Structures in Pre-training Data Yield In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-19T20:40:48 | 2024-02-19T20:40:48 |
Yanda Chen, Chen Zhao, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown, He He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained language models (LMs) are capable of in-context learning (ICL):
they can adapt to a task with only a few examples given in the prompt without
any parameter update. However, it is unclear where this capability comes from
as there is a stark distribution shift between pre-training text and ICL
prompts. In this work, we study what patterns of the pre-training data
contribute to ICL. We find that LMs' ICL ability depends on $\textit{parallel
structures}$ in the pre-training data -- pairs of phrases following similar
templates in the same context window. Specifically, we detect parallel
structures by checking whether training on one phrase improves prediction of
the other, and conduct ablation experiments to study their effect on ICL. We
show that removing parallel structures in the pre-training data reduces LMs'
ICL accuracy by 51% (vs 2% from random ablation). This drop persists even when
excluding common patterns such as n-gram repetitions and long-range dependency,
showing the diversity and generality of parallel structures. A closer look at
the detected parallel structures indicates that they cover diverse linguistic
tasks and span long distances in the data.
|
[
-0.4718392491,
-0.7507043481,
0.4730512798,
0.1912704706,
-0.4157842398,
-0.0409049131,
-0.2999521792,
-0.230081737,
-0.103473343,
0.2866472006,
-0.4651696682,
-0.7371957302,
-0.5888468623,
0.1793760955,
-0.5439519286,
1.0945769548,
-0.2408211976,
0.1487806588,
-0.4624319673,
-0.2194357216,
-0.2676829696,
-0.7281070352,
-0.2457052618,
-0.1627447605,
0.5465474129,
0.5071180463,
0.2994231582,
0.9351242781,
0.3071896732,
0.3174465597,
-0.1250471026,
-0.2410190701,
-0.4505009949,
-0.0354073234,
-0.0428297035,
-0.7747172713,
-0.166705668,
-0.0821763724,
1.1744296551,
1.153922081,
0.0631995723,
0.1214144975,
0.6231513619,
0.754440248,
-0.4118542075,
0.2153353542,
-0.7723335028,
-0.0963846818,
-0.8957635164,
-0.1491079628,
-0.3752999604,
0.0257078037,
0.1790527403,
-0.2045437098,
0.3900814354,
0.1697114706,
0.7815449834,
0.2467404753,
-0.2818088531,
-0.335409224,
-0.4083473384,
0.6068031192,
-0.359562695,
0.5087792277,
0.4326790571,
0.0397620611,
-0.2771863937,
-0.5782690048,
-0.3798303604,
-0.3041952848,
-0.3821689487,
-0.1457978636,
0.3728538454,
0.117609188,
0.4497888684,
0.2128076553,
-0.4384228289,
0.3442600369,
-0.4455860555,
0.076202184,
0.0395262018,
0.1629978567,
0.3384051323,
0.1415674537,
-0.3776379228,
-0.1843877882,
-1.1186506748,
0.3940680325,
0.2328523546,
0.409348309,
-0.4875362813,
0.3712198734,
-0.0385035798,
0.8016606569,
0.1035554111,
-0.0584493428,
0.4888812602,
-0.2221488059,
-0.2589160502,
0.273116678,
0.5839386582,
-0.1571716815,
0.2927315831,
-0.2411156744,
-0.0928487778,
-0.1386431009,
-0.017350655,
-0.7825548053,
-0.2162926346,
-0.0935393497,
-0.6324054599,
0.0229863022,
0.1416541338,
-0.2281146944,
0.0083948718,
-0.3873930871,
0.1208422109,
-0.3383299708,
0.0172867719,
0.1675746739,
-0.0724836811,
0.0911750644,
0.0298571642,
-0.6874048114,
0.3783280551,
0.4051019847,
0.8143313527,
-0.243203342,
-0.7651351094,
-0.4481639862,
0.2235874087,
-0.2108483464,
0.8974825144,
-0.6683260798,
-0.240904063,
-0.1562810987,
0.0662166625,
-0.409293592,
-0.7668938637,
0.2101615071,
-0.3484570682,
0.0993133411,
-0.520555079,
-0.702631712,
0.0286900271,
0.19008632,
-0.5518316627,
0.6399603486,
-0.1199419722,
-0.9236635566,
0.4847177565,
-0.5519316792,
-0.4923580289,
-0.0460827164,
-0.6529788375,
-0.4446145296,
0.2898392379,
0.1281229258,
0.3414614201,
-0.091566056,
0.0694570616,
-0.4438883066,
-0.5025525689,
0.3977960646,
-0.1865093261,
0.6073468924,
0.0132856537,
-0.4578188062,
0.1260077804,
-0.688839972,
-0.2660698295,
-0.0769210458,
-0.421602428,
-0.5750311017,
0.2690207362,
-0.2096376717,
0.3186225593,
-0.1395094693,
-0.5071519017,
0.0790820718,
-0.5523757339,
0.0300093312,
0.7864907384,
-0.1908375174,
0.3994037807,
-0.4472367167,
0.3829466701,
0.5747549534,
-0.0748665407,
-0.339269489,
-0.2141945064,
-0.6471299529,
-0.4371735454,
-0.0308304671,
0.2931624055,
-0.5159855485,
0.1734408438,
-0.1600984335,
-0.2347079664,
-0.2720078826,
0.1442402899,
0.7168867588,
0.8471547365,
0.4266014993,
-0.2697806656,
-0.5724868774,
-0.9514063001,
-0.5780534148,
0.121920146,
0.1420836598,
0.1772551686,
0.3222451806,
0.0980069935,
0.9646977186,
-0.3413802981,
-0.1984837204,
-0.1615659148,
0.0635276437,
0.1906148791,
0.531855464,
0.7412751317,
-0.8171756268,
-0.7985422015,
-0.2609716952,
-0.6213210821,
-0.1386828572,
-0.0240661371,
0.0498608649,
0.101895608,
0.8897304535,
-0.5111364722,
0.5036384463,
0.2847166955,
-0.1908767819,
0.4642336369,
-0.1442717761,
-0.085128583,
-1.0818303823,
-0.1110871583,
-0.12058983,
0.1255265176,
-0.7094534039,
-0.2365122139,
0.1737815887,
0.1917448789,
-0.5097963214,
0.4949543774,
-0.552803874,
-0.3480406106,
-0.2418777943,
-0.2234737277,
-0.27698493,
0.411513567,
0.0449375957,
0.77461797,
0.733692944,
-0.6909406185,
-0.4941148758,
0.2345311493,
-0.7835368514,
0.147248134,
-0.4731374383,
0.1296265423,
-0.5073410273,
0.2872096598,
-0.9531598091,
-0.1171954721,
0.1648183614,
-0.1105233282,
0.1375803947,
-0.0087623885,
-0.5071700215,
-0.026321901,
-0.0401801467,
0.7211669087,
0.2782198191,
-0.5649032593,
0.0083708512,
0.2180357426,
-0.1064455584,
-0.6939437985,
-0.6326088905,
-0.3393031061,
-0.3517401516,
-0.1942502707,
0.3945475519,
-0.2386221588,
-0.3287725449,
0.1526569575,
-0.0363853127,
-0.138544172,
0.3492630124,
0.3804380596,
0.031314306,
-0.3728270531,
0.2868163884,
0.0281427633,
0.2166573256,
0.1141165197,
-0.3436382711,
0.8840609789,
-0.308596015,
-0.4377500415,
-0.3710771203,
0.2935999632,
0.6024870872,
-0.3985860944,
1.006739378,
0.2563366592,
-0.1954310238,
-0.2988502979,
-0.3092807531,
-0.0844672024,
-0.4987891614,
0.5440195799,
-0.6646743417,
-0.8784052134,
0.6255398989,
0.050519336,
-0.0942942128,
0.1752831638,
0.4611504376,
-0.3154483438,
0.9504872561,
0.5146226883,
-0.0733161569,
0.751753211,
0.0132585345,
0.0588781498,
-0.659776926,
-0.3124899268,
-0.6483181119,
-0.376827687,
-0.3686130941,
-0.1238848791,
0.2418659478,
0.5301539302,
-0.2419679165,
0.0838013142,
-0.180450961,
0.643874228,
0.4608737528,
0.1454659104,
0.0361605249,
0.2696152031,
-0.2586224973,
0.1205199212,
-0.5154857635,
-0.1037943885,
1.0924094915,
0.1346249282,
0.4712532759,
-0.2139422596,
0.8877672553,
-0.068153955,
0.5238758922,
-0.3969432712,
0.4679939747,
-0.3704999387,
-0.2690761685,
-0.2121722102,
-0.3741241693,
-0.927808702,
0.1669637561,
-0.1102413684,
-0.4733883739,
0.1838934571,
0.3091403246,
-0.0661914274,
0.2895375788,
-0.5737576485,
0.763908565,
-0.2668727636,
-0.0374495201,
-0.1835265458,
-0.61620152,
0.1647325307,
-0.1765592992,
0.2144740373,
-0.0178239085,
0.1225411296,
0.4911161959,
-0.3708537817,
0.8309558034,
-0.1836847812,
0.2410872281,
0.1142793968,
-0.2398072034,
0.5555004478,
-0.1421264857,
0.0660673082,
0.1054568142,
-0.4060057402,
-0.5083498359,
-0.5091192126,
0.540661335,
-0.778619647,
-0.6781919599,
-0.1441297233,
-0.7283670902,
-0.1303779334,
0.2496266812,
0.5487760305,
0.6721566916,
-0.0152434576,
0.5005034804,
0.5398487449,
-0.1620899886,
0.5107606649,
0.3666886091,
0.0029962861,
-0.0192187726,
0.4974532425,
0.3493032753,
0.3071119189,
0.487867862,
0.1528998315,
-0.2509168088,
-1.1191323996,
-0.1351469308,
0.2378514409,
-0.7062283754,
0.2028593272,
-0.6329570413,
-0.1189658418,
-0.3860554993,
-0.2481074482,
-0.1134205982,
-0.059315294,
-0.2581503093,
-0.2366701216,
0.0084122391,
0.6934159994,
0.2630231082,
0.4970518053,
-0.7590761781,
0.0800326318,
0.0331241116,
0.3837653697,
-0.1723190099,
-0.295504123,
-0.4984696507,
-0.0418880358,
0.207955122,
-0.6761372089,
0.2947776914,
0.3312806785,
0.6273911595,
0.3595929742,
-0.1403876245,
0.9423297644,
-0.724087894,
0.4378290176,
0.1240107641,
-0.7913219333,
0.375613153,
-0.4088593423,
0.5608897209,
0.6510708332,
0.5668305755,
-0.2230140865,
-0.3720626533,
-0.4476120472,
-0.551482439,
0.8447031379,
-0.0444626249,
-0.1272488832,
-0.2307577431,
0.5188401341,
0.1225648746,
0.3409022987,
-0.705085218,
-0.3962202668,
-0.1457495689,
-0.4162757993,
-0.3176683784,
-0.2214016318,
-0.0371227488,
-0.2684290409,
-0.0027147827,
-0.0506688394,
-0.1069584265,
0.0446429215,
-0.5145597458,
0.1758861691,
0.2030596584,
0.6770057678,
0.6325055957,
-0.2882747948,
0.1980542392,
0.08681041,
-0.4572766125,
0.0672140121,
0.0425561927,
-0.0970459729,
-0.0560206771,
0.3852905631,
1.0236538649,
0.3526861668,
-0.5349752903,
0.4118759036,
0.0293832496,
-0.0549851619,
-0.2697457969,
-0.0456582271,
-0.1257074624,
0.1699859202,
0.2084123492,
0.2643703222,
0.052705504,
-0.6176695824,
0.4569123089,
0.2333165407,
-0.1352329552,
-0.5850781798,
0.3833163381,
-0.0475445352,
-0.2702113092,
0.7529150844,
0.0389641821,
-0.3765045404,
0.7596108317,
0.8484907746,
0.8812433481,
-0.2713244259,
-0.051518403,
0.1174776182,
0.0855141059,
-0.102657713,
0.1171643808,
-0.3572964966,
-0.7977250218,
-0.2996457219,
-0.6984285712,
0.0329650529,
0.1830711663,
-0.7358849645,
0.3315848708,
-0.5143803954,
0.3399686515,
-0.2736614048,
-0.4019706845,
-0.8776242733,
0.1892592013,
0.3549331725,
0.7500030994,
-0.9049855471,
1.3898761272,
0.7785215378,
-0.1697807312,
-0.913082242,
0.2896792293,
-0.0959345624,
-0.5773676038,
1.1468579769,
0.5465637445,
0.0141514894,
0.1376000345,
-0.3836038709,
-1.1013206244,
0.8343780637,
0.542974174,
-0.6380109191,
-0.2315671593,
0.5626600385,
0.4134045839,
-0.6672390699,
0.0977471471,
0.3538504839,
0.0744056329,
-0.2442709357,
-0.8432216644,
-0.0924037024,
-0.1136827096,
-0.1025901437,
0.3353680074,
-0.388745904,
1.4215105772,
0.0875909477,
-0.4393368661,
-0.1339513063,
0.46262905,
0.5051138401,
0.215966031,
0.8008157015,
0.4958955646,
0.6066598892,
0.1365323365,
1.0219826698,
-0.3394860625,
0.0723701492,
1.3330485821,
-0.1921545118,
0.8149167299,
0.5108048916,
0.2176211178,
0.7915813923,
0.5763747096,
0.2923058271,
0.7623969913,
0.2021367848,
-0.1482037157,
-0.1793607175,
0.006717951,
-0.4592764378,
0.4338611364,
0.6293002367,
-0.3574528694,
-0.4383605421,
0.3735875189,
-0.0104619162,
0.1120420098,
-0.3768633008,
0.4876494408,
0.1962419003,
-0.6470327973,
0.6011016965,
-0.3251709044,
0.478654027,
-0.6508319378,
0.0751469061,
-0.2607010603,
0.3765560389,
-0.1475143284,
-0.5323321223,
0.3949592412,
-0.2450115681,
-0.3706890047,
-0.4439691603,
0.4367281497,
-0.6877260208,
-0.1410998702,
0.3927176595,
0.3624965549,
0.2519774437,
-0.1061552241,
-0.6126785278,
0.0647593737,
-0.0997672603,
-0.3123236597,
0.7566713691,
0.2786830962,
-0.2671884894,
0.2844421566,
0.6419981718,
0.0699244514,
0.4083378911,
0.1265547723,
0.995775342,
-0.5805232525,
-0.6390662789,
-0.9929853678,
0.4474018514,
-0.0276354346,
-0.419826746,
0.9125132561,
0.5360432267,
1.4752405882,
-0.1260506809,
0.6200436354,
0.1710109711,
0.4197711945,
-0.7486062646,
0.6014221907,
-0.5314375758,
0.3392783701,
-0.1680518538,
-0.8398132324,
-0.3902486265,
0.2099170089,
-0.4516812265,
-0.3117922843,
0.9419456124,
0.7602030635,
-0.0821500793,
-0.1309176683,
0.1844592243,
0.3156223595,
0.243269667,
0.3451047242,
0.857282877,
-0.0046409816,
0.4084678888,
-0.2713421285,
-0.1106615439,
-0.0001314729,
-0.4828458726,
-1.2337018251,
-0.7731181383,
-0.0023039866,
-0.0123516042,
0.1104764044,
0.914761126,
0.6398641467,
-0.821561873,
-0.5095241666,
-0.4663909972,
0.0053020916,
-0.1036269814,
-0.1158640534,
0.6472818851,
-0.839417994,
-0.6571083069,
0.7796102762,
0.246628046,
0.1195036694,
0.2907550931,
0.0306886379,
-0.1532771438,
-0.204372555,
0.4842834473,
0.3857806027,
-0.53060323,
-0.311578989,
0.0112939402,
-0.0900312066,
0.2069537789,
1.0012122393,
-0.8205593228,
0.2757081687,
0.6693099141,
0.6547051072,
0.3281910419,
0.0419978574,
0.5831513405,
-0.9994852543,
0.7199543118,
-0.0256021358,
0.4386591017,
-0.0343420208,
-0.2388222665,
-0.0337308384,
0.2346513569,
-0.4037092924,
-0.973660171,
0.3452020884,
-0.4642695785,
-0.5079934001,
0.8055542707,
-0.2584563196,
-0.37567994,
-0.3228387237,
0.1776018292,
0.252414614,
0.1532583535,
0.7291427851,
0.6471395493,
-0.2341626287,
-0.1431177557,
-0.1078183278,
0.8463463187,
0.7566034198,
-0.8042890429,
-0.1902750134,
0.2668112516,
0.3669986427,
-0.0746181011,
0.7068648934,
-0.120277375,
0.0631178468,
-0.2824352682,
-0.1707503796,
-0.1740858406,
-0.694457531,
-0.4203569591,
0.4195325673,
0.1084179729,
-0.4628096223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12513v1
|
Induced Model Matching: How Restricted Models Can Help Larger Ones
| 2024-02-19T20:21:09 | 2024-02-19T20:21:09 |
Usama Muneeb, Mesrob I. Ohannessian
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We consider scenarios where a very accurate predictive model using restricted
features is available at the time of training of a larger, full-featured,
model. This restricted model may be thought of as "side-information", derived
either from an auxiliary exhaustive dataset or on the same dataset, by forcing
the restriction. How can the restricted model be useful to the full model? We
propose an approach for transferring the knowledge of the restricted model to
the full model, by aligning the full model's context-restricted performance
with that of the restricted model's. We call this methodology Induced Model
Matching (IMM) and first illustrate its general applicability by using logistic
regression as a toy example. We then explore IMM's use in language modeling,
the application that initially inspired it, and where it offers an explicit
foundation in contrast to the implicit use of restricted models in techniques
such as noising. We demonstrate the methodology on both LSTM and transformer
full models, using $N$-grams as restricted models. To further illustrate the
potential of the principle whenever it is much cheaper to collect restricted
rather than full information, we conclude with a simple RL example where POMDP
policies can improve learned MDP policies via IMM.
|
[
-0.3956028819,
-0.5806708336,
0.5442674756,
-0.0579854473,
-0.1672279835,
-0.3214433491,
-0.0510869585,
-0.8045333624,
0.0498676263,
0.9522709846,
-0.4091033638,
0.0060367025,
-0.4865831137,
-0.0367316678,
-0.6935803294,
0.7541096807,
-0.0953358933,
0.2642614841,
-0.596144259,
-0.0656261966,
-0.4651252925,
-0.7221705914,
-0.3622562885,
-0.4952190518,
0.4110885859,
0.1530409157,
0.6474638581,
0.8699797392,
0.5653810501,
0.202772975,
-0.0731893033,
0.1218442693,
-0.4080694616,
0.142020762,
-0.303004235,
-0.7077053785,
0.0053855958,
0.0894983485,
0.754504323,
0.5579676032,
0.1521936506,
-0.0457199179,
0.3163911402,
0.6021105647,
-0.7754763961,
0.0723203644,
-0.7466862202,
0.1338075399,
0.066884011,
-0.2490125746,
-0.4877424836,
-0.1103322357,
0.3198551238,
-0.435292989,
0.3987551033,
0.0950596035,
0.9003750682,
0.2736391723,
-0.6947365999,
-0.314884305,
-1.1003096104,
0.5869603157,
-0.7255314589,
0.2560786903,
0.4309312105,
0.4369207919,
-0.1994796842,
-0.5627548099,
-0.5026135445,
-0.3298180699,
-0.5914605856,
-0.0098685259,
-0.1279754341,
0.2630234361,
0.666769743,
0.2419530004,
-0.3440385759,
0.2532849014,
-0.4790067375,
-0.0128735518,
0.6344667673,
0.1617116481,
0.129808411,
0.1622005552,
-0.4145083725,
0.0410382375,
-1.0150359869,
-0.3746244311,
0.409786284,
0.6039005518,
0.0317528807,
0.9844834805,
-0.0988665596,
0.8712375164,
0.057385996,
0.0264246892,
-0.0561950058,
-0.3141526878,
-0.3218417764,
0.0146831525,
0.4112428129,
0.2629267573,
0.3421036005,
-0.0810703486,
-0.3028036058,
0.0351104029,
-0.1084608361,
-0.8428955078,
0.0813667625,
-0.123120673,
-0.3134402633,
-0.0772961751,
0.1748840213,
-0.7088266611,
-0.6637285948,
-0.510192275,
0.7629825473,
-0.0098044453,
-0.395632714,
0.0289705601,
-0.2575121522,
0.7588032484,
0.0901286826,
-1.0556352139,
0.4143023491,
0.8199048638,
0.8767905831,
0.0709002167,
-0.0584070608,
-0.4397837222,
0.0664205998,
-0.2858079672,
0.4866170287,
-0.5481336117,
-0.3208373487,
0.094743371,
-0.0039078463,
-0.2896635234,
-0.9227554798,
0.0275184382,
-0.4845007062,
0.2165810913,
-0.0309061911,
-0.7601237893,
-0.0733714923,
0.0299906544,
-0.7721111774,
0.6092161536,
0.0791788325,
-0.740352571,
0.4372812212,
-0.6500921249,
-0.4644412696,
-0.347341001,
-0.2774611115,
-0.3853064179,
0.2864218354,
0.0340196937,
0.4414306879,
-0.4511562586,
0.1702664196,
-0.5995296836,
-0.0866296515,
0.4414262176,
-0.1868014336,
0.6350053549,
0.2056230754,
0.0670360178,
0.340600282,
-0.5276143551,
-0.3588788211,
0.1405256391,
-0.069076933,
-0.5493155718,
-0.085357666,
-0.1135987788,
0.3690829277,
0.0443989448,
-0.3529833555,
0.2443119884,
-0.1781874001,
0.5110116005,
0.752276361,
0.1247580871,
0.6879746914,
-0.4986822903,
0.6491247416,
0.0505330563,
0.1721399873,
0.0799336582,
-0.4247416556,
-0.733283937,
-0.3702766895,
0.6720570922,
0.5762348175,
-0.5755825639,
0.237855494,
0.1636377275,
-0.2693597376,
-0.5263548493,
-0.0199452173,
0.2198026031,
0.4754783213,
0.2570289969,
-0.3194743991,
-0.7707067132,
-1.0019651651,
-0.3734006882,
0.1335977316,
-0.2637361884,
0.5506154895,
0.4067068994,
-0.1367883384,
0.9236060381,
-0.4417355061,
-0.3419176936,
-0.312122494,
-0.2864085436,
0.2074304968,
0.767784059,
0.6686523557,
-0.7701302171,
-0.5642338991,
-0.0442753471,
-0.6747758985,
-0.0657244921,
-0.1044571921,
-0.2716428638,
-0.1604947597,
0.5315912962,
-0.6781443954,
0.5321491957,
0.6062466502,
-0.4126831889,
0.5247513652,
-0.3672553897,
-0.0784467831,
-1.1452543736,
-0.0495658368,
0.2526667714,
-0.3564060628,
-0.6886740923,
0.1608149558,
0.1981410831,
-0.305970341,
-0.2913416922,
0.7711812258,
-0.5854494572,
-0.0971783623,
-0.5885623693,
0.0188547727,
-0.0548844188,
0.135205254,
0.0932431594,
0.6087539196,
0.6085367203,
-0.7102946639,
0.2728917003,
0.2750518024,
-0.5521861911,
0.406634748,
-0.3547258377,
0.0363253839,
-0.1651636213,
0.0851077512,
-0.5750710964,
-0.3449698985,
0.1335064322,
-0.1515284777,
0.505956769,
-0.3735440075,
-0.337341547,
-0.1376660317,
0.0856290311,
0.4076829553,
0.7764315605,
-0.7712697387,
0.7567670941,
0.2643544972,
0.15397273,
-0.5586702228,
-0.5589463711,
-0.1733687371,
-0.6368712187,
-0.3674447536,
0.4145950377,
-0.2480537444,
-0.4724535644,
0.1851786226,
-0.0849941522,
-0.2054227889,
0.2969617248,
0.1606810689,
0.2208771408,
-0.2968385816,
0.1925317347,
0.103128992,
0.0105616525,
-0.0646767169,
-0.1311827898,
0.4368522465,
0.4526966214,
-0.2985790074,
-0.3944690228,
0.4568805993,
0.3816896975,
-0.0910123289,
1.0439522266,
0.1298804879,
-0.5553928018,
-0.2215833515,
-0.4590554237,
-0.5468955636,
-0.4171705842,
0.3984279037,
-0.5567433238,
-0.7843545675,
0.457265228,
0.0520351306,
-0.1536309868,
0.4879768789,
0.3765856624,
0.3431521356,
1.4013164043,
1.1505594254,
-0.1263739765,
0.9204985499,
0.0601235554,
0.0758048818,
-0.8800900578,
-0.1405636966,
-0.6074208617,
-0.3141770065,
-0.662910521,
-0.1276833415,
-0.0728732124,
0.2110528499,
-0.0224033445,
0.4039152265,
-0.2537948191,
0.5836702585,
0.7069405913,
0.4158345759,
0.3229680955,
-0.240305081,
-0.0135704977,
0.1039957777,
-0.836162746,
0.0176876318,
1.2227818966,
0.2762799561,
1.0380988121,
-0.0340707079,
0.337171644,
0.1849911511,
0.6218293905,
-0.8948717117,
0.4125563204,
-0.0430776328,
-0.7919495702,
0.0223472621,
-0.6888076663,
-0.7937256694,
0.1518563777,
-0.5573402047,
-0.5725577474,
0.510668695,
0.2969802916,
-0.1003594771,
0.3003334701,
-0.7646459341,
0.5394235253,
-0.257358849,
-0.3156325817,
-0.1775030047,
-0.5231592655,
0.4791258574,
-0.3489161432,
-0.0185185075,
-0.2439124733,
0.1499445438,
0.7859984636,
-0.3594601154,
0.714761734,
-0.3345196247,
0.0051167002,
0.0330357887,
0.0528346486,
0.4553169012,
-0.1393971741,
-0.0840835869,
-0.0603932217,
0.0105266608,
-0.385859549,
-0.7243067026,
0.6393246055,
-0.655346036,
-1.0456500053,
-0.15172638,
-0.866671741,
-0.1734797359,
0.1900316328,
0.2400043905,
0.2136242092,
0.1639236659,
0.3755824864,
0.6189423203,
0.0422348306,
0.0046941675,
0.6126480103,
-0.5551730394,
-0.084275201,
0.4194015563,
0.1760447919,
0.5651643276,
0.6597567797,
0.3903664351,
-0.3121395409,
-0.4696443677,
0.0622931272,
0.4000200629,
-0.7169950604,
-0.2883894742,
-0.3950998485,
-0.3983019292,
-0.4174243808,
0.0769483894,
-0.1337870955,
-0.5711336136,
-0.3337309361,
-0.2073209137,
0.2821566761,
0.8137207031,
-0.3070449829,
0.2942249477,
-0.3820769489,
0.0178541541,
0.4124637246,
0.2898728251,
-0.1255303472,
-0.7599139214,
-0.3088057637,
0.0039634253,
0.0547495708,
-0.8910810351,
0.2974841595,
0.337606132,
0.5980466604,
0.4967086911,
0.2161686122,
0.5660709143,
-0.390363574,
0.1732704639,
0.0820852369,
-0.8211729527,
0.3689202368,
0.0504730903,
-0.0532596111,
0.1304255724,
0.5720078349,
-0.402461797,
-0.4251868427,
-0.4122888446,
-0.6582788229,
0.4412798285,
-0.0733850449,
0.2062249929,
0.1589373648,
0.7473074794,
0.1705908179,
0.2063490003,
-0.9314090014,
-0.0072177779,
0.0758220032,
-0.34961164,
-0.1526276767,
-0.4687125087,
-0.404825747,
-0.1180753186,
0.7241609693,
-0.1465339512,
0.334223479,
0.3112158179,
-0.2251650095,
0.0062057478,
0.0374058075,
0.6124064922,
0.7509655952,
-0.2207003534,
0.1259396523,
0.0490085296,
0.0111315232,
0.0529505946,
0.3011719584,
-0.2368359268,
-0.2135628611,
0.200154081,
0.8705563545,
-0.2418784648,
-0.6759054661,
0.3000656664,
-0.1116768494,
-0.2771933079,
-0.0404506661,
0.2497239262,
-0.1928904355,
0.695291698,
0.222450316,
-0.1478833854,
-0.1140760407,
-0.5329621434,
0.2567094266,
0.8212735057,
-0.6621156335,
-0.1978378296,
0.8277776241,
-0.0143859209,
-0.3673915565,
0.5874812603,
0.290517509,
-0.3409386575,
0.7740210891,
0.9840955734,
0.725887239,
-0.3089266121,
-0.1411665678,
0.3327522278,
0.410615176,
-0.1450453848,
-0.0996948555,
-0.0340683386,
-0.9605693817,
-0.4472061098,
-0.3065577745,
-0.4364666343,
0.3289429545,
-0.7844775915,
0.405133009,
-0.4895631075,
-0.0731225461,
-0.1106037423,
-0.3839317858,
-0.7918564081,
-0.0198526382,
0.0826725289,
1.077565074,
-1.139269352,
0.8317835927,
0.3452678919,
-0.4066541791,
-0.6883356571,
0.0144715961,
-0.3513934314,
-0.936146915,
0.3647181094,
0.3032046556,
0.3737327158,
0.0514124259,
-0.5656293631,
-0.7333669066,
1.021294117,
0.3894629776,
-0.6355780959,
-0.0832219347,
0.0799996927,
0.3222362995,
-0.588378191,
0.0995882452,
0.5550077558,
0.1001033559,
0.0028779258,
-0.8993855715,
0.3578667641,
0.0270002186,
-0.1260904968,
0.4120131731,
-0.3628430068,
0.8093033433,
-0.2494059801,
-0.27617836,
0.3590149283,
0.4572620094,
0.0115057891,
0.1745208353,
0.5739895701,
0.2543335557,
0.5563027859,
0.0279203504,
0.8742573857,
-0.3108524382,
0.5105593801,
1.0575129986,
-0.5447407365,
0.6541619897,
0.5405748487,
-0.0475831218,
0.116616711,
0.6281560063,
-0.0424125865,
0.73041749,
0.2663748264,
-0.3169053793,
-0.112148203,
-0.3417498469,
-0.5426517129,
0.2364633679,
0.3596070707,
-0.6298571229,
-0.1078376994,
0.3122213781,
-0.1956806481,
-0.0586911961,
-0.3416714668,
1.1204642057,
0.2401251793,
-0.4357211888,
0.2692898214,
-0.1306284666,
0.4849802554,
-0.8123794198,
-0.0190816056,
-0.3544973731,
0.2684589624,
-0.1210334823,
-0.4819709063,
0.3049086928,
-0.2706121802,
-0.2822525203,
-0.098177813,
1.0048707724,
-0.599493742,
-0.3553376794,
0.4896076918,
0.5284258127,
-0.1540110856,
-0.1038448662,
-0.5133223534,
-0.4166890681,
0.0196324121,
-0.0651962459,
0.6546823382,
0.254185617,
0.0585686713,
0.7261137962,
0.5075007677,
0.1305516809,
-0.0376710296,
-0.2025261074,
0.7672892809,
-0.6874035597,
-0.3423264623,
-0.9714482427,
0.1845722646,
0.0526010655,
0.1409025192,
0.7049439549,
0.5793053508,
0.8537460566,
-0.0657965094,
0.9703246355,
0.0358255357,
0.4885395765,
-0.8024505973,
0.4077720642,
-0.6674984097,
0.2215135843,
0.0559133776,
-1.0954803228,
-0.4778949618,
0.3916190267,
-0.518930614,
-0.0827869773,
0.4916670024,
0.8746319413,
-0.3120536804,
-0.1939434558,
0.5215331912,
0.1598165333,
0.3177575767,
0.4105214477,
1.0697689056,
0.0562467426,
0.3927898407,
-0.4142755568,
-0.4271970093,
-0.2825171053,
-0.8285627365,
-0.9670140147,
-0.4913584292,
-0.1979703158,
-0.6812187433,
-0.0570201017,
0.883066833,
0.6794480085,
-0.6984962821,
-0.2971461713,
-0.1272356361,
0.3082819283,
-0.1599985808,
-0.2122458369,
0.0996405855,
0.0368439108,
-0.5966902375,
0.2977645099,
-0.0579747185,
0.3993698657,
-0.2228720039,
0.1085580289,
-0.1830186099,
0.2404551953,
0.4519657195,
0.4032530487,
-0.1775856912,
-0.3412077725,
-0.1541702896,
0.1878250837,
0.1361057013,
1.2307243347,
-0.654818058,
0.4828609228,
0.451764971,
0.761698544,
0.7384766936,
-0.1163541898,
0.8649241924,
-0.7245790362,
0.4391461313,
0.1378133148,
0.5104585886,
0.2975630462,
-0.395775497,
0.5799077153,
0.1682137251,
-0.5308383107,
-0.9974967837,
0.6888009906,
-0.5317307711,
-0.250074923,
1.0876852274,
-0.0375520289,
-0.0496971086,
0.0360545814,
-0.18397066,
0.3245990276,
0.010250926,
0.8097382188,
0.5697998405,
-0.3371728063,
-0.256195128,
-0.5913924575,
0.4655741751,
0.278896749,
-0.7977939844,
0.0153981457,
0.1459629983,
0.2715191841,
-0.0884996727,
0.2685878277,
0.1250342876,
-0.1120877489,
-0.0550303459,
-0.1508733034,
0.0247433316,
-0.2531048357,
-0.5055935383,
-0.0850626826,
0.3961599171,
-0.0943544507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12501v1
|
Your Vision-Language Model Itself Is a Strong Filter: Towards High-Quality Instruction Tuning with Data Selection
| 2024-02-19T20:08:48 | 2024-02-19T20:08:48 |
Ruibo Chen, Yihan Wu, Lichang Chen, Guodong Liu, Qi He, Tianyi Xiong, Chenxi Liu, Junfeng Guo, Heng Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data selection in instruction tuning emerges as a pivotal process for
acquiring high-quality data and training instruction-following large language
models (LLMs), but it is still a new and unexplored research area for
vision-language models (VLMs). Existing data selection approaches on LLMs
either rely on single unreliable scores, or use downstream tasks for selection,
which is time-consuming and can lead to potential over-fitting on the chosen
evaluation datasets. To address this challenge, we introduce a novel dataset
selection method, Self-Filter, that utilizes the VLM itself as a filter. This
approach is inspired by the observation that VLMs benefit from training with
the most challenging instructions. Self-Filter operates in two stages. In the
first stage, we devise a scoring network to evaluate the difficulty of training
instructions, which is co-trained with the VLM. In the second stage, we use the
trained score net to measure the difficulty of each instruction, select the
most challenging samples, and penalize similar samples to encourage diversity.
Comprehensive experiments on LLaVA and MiniGPT-4 show that Self-Filter can
reach better results compared to full data settings with merely about 15%
samples, and can achieve superior performance against competitive baselines.
|
[
-0.6037441492,
-0.4053134024,
0.3926337361,
-0.0360633396,
-0.4520944953,
0.0236568935,
-0.1315808445,
-0.2725313306,
0.0938204676,
0.8472472429,
-0.7099845409,
-0.6159594059,
-0.3873710334,
-0.0095862094,
-0.4763509035,
1.0029343367,
0.1345985979,
0.2996606231,
-0.3175980151,
-0.060215611,
-0.5400552154,
-0.2681891918,
-0.54925704,
-0.4197408557,
0.4102413058,
0.3776665628,
0.2667064071,
1.0211181641,
0.6442822218,
0.2719088793,
0.1282197684,
0.3370471299,
-0.560845077,
0.3322939873,
-0.1071951091,
-0.4218716621,
-0.213652581,
0.0954324901,
0.5064048767,
0.40291664,
-0.1539046466,
0.497256577,
0.2932748497,
0.9355458021,
-0.8376264572,
-0.0550177917,
-0.6362284422,
0.3316352367,
-0.3309386671,
-0.0962561741,
-0.3727244735,
-0.0676643923,
-0.199184671,
-0.2710407674,
0.2902336121,
0.2414616942,
0.6619867682,
0.5446706414,
-0.1074943319,
0.0073459465,
-0.5950823426,
0.9040517211,
-0.345933944,
0.4752448797,
0.6543175578,
0.4828017652,
0.1348402947,
-0.5299778581,
-0.251618892,
-0.119717516,
0.1423048824,
0.3657234013,
0.1209673882,
0.1123826802,
0.057816714,
0.4071207345,
-0.7480866909,
0.306748122,
-0.6367756128,
-0.2084029019,
0.6143583059,
0.2493010461,
-0.1246046424,
-0.225932166,
-0.2537378669,
-0.1994811893,
-0.7246137261,
-0.0688983425,
0.4343146384,
0.3068905175,
0.2692169547,
0.4470487833,
-0.4639813304,
1.259929657,
0.0484419316,
0.0214004554,
0.1372208446,
-0.2238594741,
-0.4173549712,
-0.0953760594,
0.6457149386,
0.1992436051,
0.2092124671,
0.2220621109,
-0.4760498405,
-0.0312513784,
0.4549711347,
-0.6951981783,
-0.5925354362,
-0.1194483042,
-0.4719209969,
-0.3140668869,
-0.111241661,
-0.9317502379,
-0.0919255614,
-0.4891887903,
0.3272873759,
0.0257818904,
0.0905630663,
0.0434719063,
0.2509495318,
0.2796703577,
0.216754511,
-0.908643961,
0.243850708,
0.433113426,
0.6302981973,
-0.460911572,
-0.3758001328,
-0.8403184414,
-0.241557762,
-0.5289974213,
0.8521470428,
-0.8824991584,
-0.3337755799,
-0.2623872757,
-0.3177205026,
-0.0678326339,
-0.5717076659,
0.3922060728,
-0.6163944006,
0.2187381834,
-0.084194079,
-0.591154933,
-0.0194917098,
0.0485680252,
-0.6596954465,
1.2892929316,
0.3036019802,
-0.266479373,
0.5998088717,
-0.2552698851,
-0.4626706541,
0.20916152,
-0.2647219598,
-0.6208908558,
0.131679222,
0.5202099085,
0.4484349787,
-0.134705171,
-0.1038790196,
-0.5566097498,
-0.4349448979,
-0.2857602537,
-0.6403008103,
0.5260609388,
0.3008034527,
-0.3910562694,
0.0656773299,
-0.8807176948,
0.5495610833,
-0.1121132597,
-0.4085794091,
-0.2639449537,
0.037642736,
-0.3326412141,
0.352155894,
0.1194698885,
-0.4845791161,
0.1344430149,
-0.255464077,
0.1516798884,
1.0027858019,
-0.1635996848,
0.1145976707,
-0.1064028591,
0.5787351131,
-0.2707885802,
0.6446647048,
-0.0089606466,
-0.4896889925,
-1.0148215294,
-0.1676540375,
0.1693627387,
0.5263584256,
-0.940991044,
0.55388695,
0.0344685726,
-0.4155347943,
-0.990673244,
0.8913965821,
0.5829622149,
0.482596606,
0.6155681014,
-0.3378086686,
-0.364425987,
-0.7421677113,
-0.0506306216,
-0.0435565636,
0.2073829919,
0.4045150876,
0.2672974467,
0.1664623469,
0.8377702236,
-0.6343733668,
-0.5277039409,
-0.2558906078,
-0.2825866044,
0.3436570168,
0.3275203407,
0.433647722,
-0.8078041077,
-0.5604418516,
-0.1924958825,
-0.7540846467,
-0.2823694646,
0.0815592036,
-0.2487090528,
0.0152275879,
0.4611161351,
-0.0011034473,
0.5011280775,
0.7431407571,
-0.3409493268,
0.3554426134,
-0.3974023759,
0.114871636,
-0.5269722939,
-0.333674401,
0.1152810156,
-0.4305690229,
-0.2472156584,
-0.0461870506,
0.1714171618,
0.1628728062,
-0.4526184797,
0.45782727,
-0.6383817792,
-0.081904456,
-0.5104306936,
-0.0897863954,
0.1623514146,
0.514464438,
-0.0410291404,
0.6606644392,
0.8348607421,
-0.751734972,
0.6424195766,
0.1787747592,
-0.7299656868,
0.5592470765,
-0.4096799195,
0.2853962481,
-0.1292995214,
-0.16398637,
-0.8301024437,
0.0862714276,
0.1832035035,
-0.0321507864,
0.421608597,
-0.469958663,
-0.1440074146,
-0.6921855807,
-0.1191504002,
0.1636849195,
0.4962684214,
-0.8872976899,
0.3597027659,
0.2907834947,
0.2253397405,
-0.4783718288,
-0.6210657358,
0.0307031441,
-0.0830058604,
-0.2383472025,
-0.0186075885,
-0.2440952361,
0.1478879303,
-0.1277888268,
-0.2835997939,
-0.0835122243,
0.1110918596,
0.1109880283,
0.49859339,
-0.2423371375,
0.0825867206,
0.0024965045,
-0.2033700496,
-0.0584427193,
-0.4300702214,
0.393497318,
0.0058814106,
-0.6470935941,
-0.3417375982,
0.1720900089,
0.2924526036,
-0.6230362654,
0.4331885576,
0.5430973172,
0.1685010791,
-0.7398724556,
-0.5993670821,
-0.3536438346,
-0.5518712401,
0.491206795,
-0.4661664069,
-0.7970522046,
-0.1003703475,
0.3403809369,
0.012259691,
0.2058753371,
0.3409999609,
-0.3256258667,
1.0787320137,
0.3594315946,
-0.2188024074,
0.6896365881,
-0.3130531311,
0.104222998,
-0.9178522825,
-0.0854739025,
-0.2844254971,
-0.3108023405,
-0.462339133,
-0.2683471441,
0.5616753697,
-0.2226533145,
-0.0664780736,
0.0871308595,
-0.7700384259,
0.8142499924,
0.7522560954,
0.3913424313,
0.0120586986,
0.1816891879,
0.0744209588,
-0.0765478015,
-0.6597300768,
-0.1800593436,
1.2085504532,
0.029332649,
1.0258717537,
-0.2607649267,
0.8708532453,
0.261190176,
0.12450286,
-0.5553651452,
0.7082773447,
-0.7896611691,
-0.6132597327,
-0.5205409527,
-0.523796618,
-0.8789350986,
0.4545158744,
-0.1890336424,
-0.4939884245,
-0.0107139861,
0.4126583934,
-0.4357430339,
0.277736932,
-0.6536861062,
0.8338000774,
-0.549718082,
-0.4570586085,
-0.1946781874,
-0.4885618091,
0.2025140673,
-0.1595451832,
0.0678911805,
-0.269399792,
0.2831545472,
0.5782346129,
-0.1933099627,
0.9144223332,
-0.3131307662,
0.0992218778,
0.4170302451,
0.1520339698,
0.2635925114,
-0.1831974387,
-0.1761999875,
0.1746495366,
-0.224943161,
-0.3283199072,
-0.7544359565,
0.7290467024,
-0.6152956486,
-0.7766278982,
-0.2293449789,
-0.0036636151,
-0.1670191139,
0.1961418092,
0.2870736122,
0.5884676576,
0.1864588708,
0.321198374,
0.6146946549,
0.0156221632,
0.3794736862,
0.5540232658,
-0.3359394372,
-0.4107069075,
1.2754461765,
0.3112294376,
0.4793072641,
0.270360589,
0.3868011236,
-0.1726020277,
-0.7857377529,
-0.6170036197,
-0.0302855652,
-0.8794776797,
-0.298784405,
-0.2197257876,
-0.5049325824,
-0.1993575841,
0.2069310546,
-0.6591747403,
-0.0255600363,
-0.2722960711,
0.007162184,
0.1258015782,
0.7687026858,
-0.0937072039,
0.1622453034,
-0.554931879,
0.6021918654,
0.6465713382,
0.6822021008,
-0.373696506,
-0.740462482,
-0.342425704,
-0.1556987464,
-0.1363709718,
-0.4758476913,
0.3567050099,
0.6588448882,
0.752817452,
0.1244494393,
0.0441727303,
0.7884570956,
-0.5842012763,
0.5064211488,
-0.0929091126,
-0.6999313235,
0.9227308035,
0.1938334107,
0.3710130453,
0.7899320126,
0.0015923686,
-0.1525721848,
-0.3848813474,
-0.1291110069,
-0.8300690651,
0.8622041941,
0.1949767172,
0.1493469924,
0.1876796633,
0.4993206859,
0.0405964851,
0.1568793356,
-0.5655978918,
-0.5197040439,
-0.4114955068,
-0.3422932923,
-0.0717033297,
-0.1492079049,
0.1096083522,
-0.3917780221,
0.6963998079,
-0.2764735818,
-0.0683577508,
0.1358118206,
-0.03456714,
-0.2044059783,
-0.1796610057,
0.1222568899,
0.4938842356,
-0.0104052909,
0.0624697097,
0.1439103633,
-0.6278946996,
0.0216076002,
-0.299302429,
-0.3365023136,
-0.1849762648,
0.4070808589,
1.1672030687,
0.1562341601,
-0.2969230115,
0.5464374423,
-0.0646624416,
0.0258962885,
-0.0626445636,
0.8053127527,
-0.543971777,
0.1085434258,
0.1528841108,
0.0004498549,
0.3198308945,
-0.245919317,
0.3715024292,
0.3046359718,
-0.46910429,
0.036057163,
0.4247695208,
0.1987294555,
-0.2671480179,
0.7950706482,
-0.2516109347,
-0.4885263145,
0.5726773739,
0.3486395478,
0.8165465593,
-0.487431854,
0.3637648821,
0.3700663745,
0.2615091205,
-0.160823375,
0.2637413442,
-0.2011993229,
-0.6959388256,
-0.4843907654,
-0.9757415056,
-0.1878209859,
0.2022889405,
-0.8614761233,
0.3113671839,
-0.2777222097,
0.0115668727,
-0.1443386227,
0.0675389022,
-0.818182826,
0.685351491,
0.3935867548,
0.6821923256,
-0.7156052589,
1.0532215834,
0.3853828013,
0.0501340516,
-0.7156357765,
-0.1977041662,
-0.0372252315,
-1.1794002056,
0.7530395985,
0.1153696254,
-0.3072788417,
0.1360477954,
-0.5396127105,
-1.0209088326,
0.7467919588,
0.3706325591,
-0.840023756,
0.034085568,
-0.1723262519,
0.4871405065,
-0.3994681835,
0.1971942484,
0.8109772205,
0.3721783161,
0.4322310686,
-0.6977441311,
-0.4537667036,
-0.2664373219,
0.0323711745,
0.2034242302,
-0.8462231159,
0.5493246913,
-0.0530437343,
0.0825961232,
-0.2051923424,
0.6668348908,
0.1257550567,
0.2849490345,
0.738984704,
0.4169505239,
0.5283481479,
0.0689403713,
0.9614581466,
-0.3496806324,
0.369495213,
1.3454473019,
-0.2492699623,
0.7782380581,
0.3251815438,
-0.2627701461,
0.2331789583,
0.7427605391,
-0.6030144095,
0.7276553512,
0.189437449,
0.0524113439,
-0.7813096046,
0.2779104114,
-0.0719189048,
1.0653121471,
0.1363924742,
-0.2300290316,
-0.1711495221,
0.1736968607,
-0.521433115,
0.0273376331,
-0.4749753773,
0.7966384292,
0.0830617547,
-0.8617677093,
0.5878875852,
-0.4420109093,
0.33040604,
-0.6339821219,
-0.1004421487,
-0.2259897292,
0.0866727903,
-0.1425264627,
-1.0665340424,
0.1569771469,
0.0256153364,
-0.0278402418,
-0.2906260788,
0.6369599104,
-0.4942315221,
-0.7082387209,
0.4776986539,
0.5254196525,
0.2595059276,
-0.09539482,
-0.7069936991,
0.0776340142,
0.1942780465,
-0.603851676,
0.2543907166,
0.2237390131,
0.1830275357,
0.9104963541,
0.6241950393,
0.5199818015,
0.2022726387,
0.2416764349,
0.8625369072,
-0.5891424417,
-0.5567129254,
-0.9547560811,
0.204548955,
-0.2014503628,
-0.5161798,
0.5561725497,
0.5505560637,
0.9338836074,
0.0862705782,
0.6821509004,
0.2318419367,
0.4394533336,
-0.8699420691,
0.6684545279,
-0.7042734623,
0.3088643849,
0.0038204701,
-0.9647464156,
-0.1918300241,
0.8177190423,
-0.4440427423,
0.3139972091,
0.4025754631,
0.8294312954,
-0.1261931658,
-0.1557631046,
0.7679230571,
0.0445728265,
0.1838362515,
0.5774989128,
0.6320049167,
-0.2433850914,
0.6487880945,
-0.4137929678,
-0.1565574259,
-0.2361902148,
-0.6306253672,
-1.0913932323,
-0.5731704235,
-0.3419480324,
-0.0693596005,
0.1096351221,
0.7202319503,
1.2179430723,
-0.8095707297,
-0.2270544767,
0.0801058635,
0.2338590473,
-0.2581377029,
-0.1129082888,
0.2735851109,
-0.5898798108,
-0.6513864398,
0.743688643,
0.3926756084,
-0.0288622994,
-0.5296861529,
-0.0417703763,
0.1948564798,
-0.1173305437,
0.402100265,
0.0596347116,
-0.4356133044,
-0.2746335864,
-0.1806933731,
-0.1406111419,
0.3437505364,
0.5690389276,
-0.8736522794,
0.9531497359,
0.091354914,
0.576488018,
0.750451088,
-0.2979508042,
0.3012281358,
-0.6436424851,
-0.2117347568,
0.3168671131,
0.3419086337,
0.4015184939,
-0.4941602647,
0.5458019376,
0.1602977812,
-0.6015178561,
-0.7234066129,
0.3420833349,
-0.5633459091,
-0.2337324023,
1.0718631744,
-0.0395228602,
-0.4645639062,
-0.0213918816,
-0.1204163879,
0.0957654193,
-0.1904723495,
0.9939730763,
0.6086832881,
-0.1770440936,
-0.3738766015,
-0.7870399952,
0.5235412717,
0.4092459381,
-0.6223181486,
-0.0605896711,
0.4333352149,
0.2508302629,
-0.2522718012,
0.2691333592,
0.2676120996,
0.2961852849,
-0.1780069023,
-0.1498740613,
-0.2619651854,
-0.7202768922,
-0.3369134963,
0.2115548253,
-0.075278677,
-0.4179134667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12486v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12486v2
|
Do Pre-Trained Language Models Detect and Understand Semantic Underspecification? Ask the DUST!
| 2024-02-19T19:49:29 | 2024-06-12T09:09:47 |
Frank Wildenburg, Michael Hanna, Sandro Pezzelle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In everyday language use, speakers frequently utter and interpret sentences
that are semantically underspecified, namely, whose content is insufficient to
fully convey their message or interpret them univocally. For example, to
interpret the underspecified sentence "Don't spend too much", which leaves
implicit what (not) to spend, additional linguistic context or outside
knowledge is needed. In this work, we propose a novel Dataset of semantically
Underspecified Sentences grouped by Type (DUST) and use it to study whether
pre-trained language models (LMs) correctly identify and interpret
underspecified sentences. We find that newer LMs are reasonably able to
identify underspecified sentences when explicitly prompted. However,
interpreting them correctly is much harder for any LMs. Our experiments show
that when interpreting underspecified sentences, LMs exhibit little
uncertainty, contrary to what theoretical accounts of underspecification would
predict. Overall, our study reveals limitations in current models' processing
of sentence semantics and highlights the importance of using naturalistic data
and communicative scenarios when evaluating LMs' language capabilities.
|
[
-0.277001977,
-0.606003046,
1.0065876245,
-0.2740807235,
-0.5014153719,
-0.2967359424,
-0.2671676874,
-0.593375802,
0.0865955278,
0.692933619,
-0.9225350618,
-0.4298359454,
-0.7572503686,
-0.084831588,
-0.822943449,
1.0099138021,
0.0421943143,
-0.2723326087,
-0.6273980141,
0.3611944318,
-0.3032563031,
-0.4439609647,
0.2052843273,
-0.4270832241,
0.1197740957,
0.4751206338,
0.8428964615,
0.2294792831,
0.4117962122,
0.3471890986,
-0.1514111012,
0.1628329605,
-0.5474340916,
-0.2280411571,
-0.0039958735,
-0.3693292439,
0.0399351679,
0.0895732567,
0.4460046291,
1.0286576748,
-0.1355056167,
0.1979812235,
0.054517515,
0.1565520316,
-1.0252386332,
0.2511824667,
-1.1738497019,
0.0442929976,
-0.3533197641,
-0.3305633366,
-0.2340517491,
-0.113165006,
0.0340770595,
-0.5797948837,
0.2093484104,
-0.242978096,
0.9147878885,
0.5726520419,
-0.3712764382,
-0.3568131924,
-0.6254515052,
0.6594813466,
-0.6712610722,
0.2341679633,
0.6316843033,
0.0160022248,
-0.3050403595,
-0.7570747137,
-0.5870361924,
-0.2309007198,
-0.5847219229,
-0.0578795895,
-0.225844875,
0.0689182356,
0.0401293673,
0.3294540346,
-0.2934365869,
0.2671102583,
-0.412817657,
-0.1911669821,
0.3466516435,
0.1769991964,
0.4332330525,
-0.4413771033,
-0.5445138812,
0.4123684168,
-0.5360931158,
-0.0694462284,
0.1567077339,
0.4165151119,
0.1063253284,
0.541432023,
-0.3155672848,
0.649992764,
-0.2803429365,
0.4683294296,
0.1455360055,
-0.2609856427,
-0.4798839688,
0.008420255,
0.6596083045,
0.1096815988,
0.714856863,
-0.3222955167,
-0.2881729901,
0.3312256038,
0.5492112637,
-0.6651190519,
-0.3065576553,
0.2226614356,
-0.3099535406,
-0.5253226161,
0.0745101497,
-0.3118936419,
-0.4802061617,
-0.1831259727,
0.6216062903,
-0.1923358142,
-0.2285705954,
0.5676478148,
-0.0829501674,
-0.192568928,
0.3440959454,
-0.81031847,
0.6622707844,
0.7340489626,
0.4040461481,
0.2265859693,
-0.2998107076,
-0.3349848688,
-0.1537790298,
-0.3399819732,
1.0105196238,
-0.7771885991,
-0.235822767,
0.006619866,
-0.0962954164,
-0.5131364465,
-0.4212669134,
0.7891409397,
-0.4783055484,
0.3572857678,
0.1079065651,
-0.8102527857,
-0.0555667952,
-0.0328534767,
-0.2690289319,
0.7176661491,
-0.0245004836,
-1.1190484762,
0.6706625223,
-0.3450810611,
-0.0810838714,
0.1162723005,
-0.2627990544,
-0.1659392864,
0.3871398568,
0.2434946746,
0.6222951412,
-0.1026515216,
0.5553535819,
-0.3256938159,
-0.6208533049,
0.600776732,
-0.504909277,
0.4365068972,
0.1817888319,
-0.1346295029,
-0.1516063958,
-0.7204536796,
0.2514003813,
-0.0232540481,
0.2142215222,
-0.3332656324,
0.2848044932,
-0.1475144178,
0.2560240924,
0.4007132649,
-0.6330441833,
0.0821425468,
-0.4659668803,
0.3173002303,
0.6029406786,
-0.1041597277,
0.2188055813,
-0.0426956452,
0.2538782358,
0.0966387838,
0.1179175228,
0.0516102873,
-0.1607920974,
-0.9881090522,
0.0936836749,
0.1256032288,
0.4654675424,
-0.4150194526,
0.2878243029,
-0.5637535453,
-0.3808686137,
-0.4088902771,
0.2694161236,
0.3149394989,
0.3848904669,
0.4803967774,
-0.193079412,
-0.4622571766,
-0.8203033209,
-0.2861808836,
-0.110479109,
-0.0140592223,
0.2344714254,
0.6175014377,
-0.4823627174,
1.1663386822,
-0.6903352737,
-0.243366614,
-0.2830629945,
0.3749865294,
0.0700237751,
0.2850170732,
0.2044232786,
-0.7141389847,
0.1887764037,
-0.28374663,
-0.5171035528,
-0.3730593622,
-0.0480468236,
0.2033220381,
-0.1183205545,
0.723688364,
-0.8702397943,
0.5768700838,
0.5044222474,
-0.3630173206,
0.2587236762,
-0.4472585917,
-0.0123249423,
-0.5407930017,
0.0690085664,
-0.2839229405,
-0.190108493,
-0.6886168718,
-0.0176948011,
0.0048923739,
-0.0771817341,
-0.6448873281,
0.464881748,
-0.4079614878,
-0.0988209322,
-0.4877825677,
0.2029900551,
-0.2015303075,
0.4768231511,
0.4413351715,
0.4069529474,
0.4029050171,
-0.6371269822,
-0.145758912,
0.0845812112,
-0.733425498,
-0.0866043642,
-0.4852711856,
0.059707243,
-0.3532065451,
0.4255345166,
-0.8747560978,
-0.2333322912,
0.1759082228,
-0.329094559,
0.0061258888,
-0.1890271157,
-0.5975529552,
-0.3943680227,
0.0693802834,
0.4012825787,
0.3477049172,
-0.104876101,
0.2628648877,
0.3677964211,
0.2483863533,
-0.5425923467,
-0.8142767549,
-0.2531862557,
-0.1937055588,
-0.4826275408,
0.0462002903,
0.2901456356,
-0.3729774356,
0.1452838033,
-0.4063078463,
-0.4343076646,
0.5443434119,
0.5483843684,
0.114663288,
-0.29318133,
0.3529223502,
-0.1279415339,
-0.1631604284,
0.0668536127,
-0.2806868255,
0.4903578758,
0.076114729,
-0.3479715288,
-0.5612521768,
-0.0019535401,
0.2956032455,
-0.0908257291,
0.8105847239,
0.3799135685,
-0.4230896831,
-0.193571195,
-0.4339000881,
-0.3051848412,
-0.4660509229,
0.1630642116,
-0.4045524001,
-0.7494336367,
0.4110397398,
0.0693453997,
-0.2504600286,
0.6787436604,
0.2023950964,
-0.2089520246,
0.6734146476,
0.6204298139,
0.000525758,
0.18937473,
-0.0536655672,
0.0192777459,
-0.2294124216,
-0.0645148531,
-0.6091173887,
0.0457163043,
-0.6005657911,
-0.441020757,
-0.0071674082,
-0.0549696498,
-0.0156066278,
0.3464882374,
-0.2138752937,
0.7985893488,
0.2884082198,
0.1837016642,
0.1605507135,
-0.4526020288,
0.14891316,
0.1051361859,
-0.622728765,
-0.563108027,
0.7788687944,
0.3811923265,
0.8032414317,
-0.2727991343,
0.7553471923,
0.3443327844,
0.0351099111,
-0.5028789639,
0.5378034115,
-0.6564567685,
-0.6689964533,
-0.2079864293,
-0.4787278473,
-1.1559234858,
0.3797674477,
-0.4828931391,
-0.96590662,
0.1721916348,
0.114129141,
-0.5740865469,
0.2791398466,
-0.8038873076,
1.1777471304,
-0.0910631493,
0.3402700126,
-0.2936034203,
-0.8491405845,
0.3713847697,
-0.2871719301,
0.6208313704,
-0.3672684133,
0.0124043971,
0.5954140425,
-0.5812612176,
1.0673377514,
-0.1669435799,
-0.015681304,
0.3094686866,
0.1115408763,
0.2703372836,
-0.2854965925,
0.1226473302,
0.1074609235,
0.1007474139,
-0.3121193051,
-0.7753834724,
0.4535211027,
-0.8310087323,
-0.5473771095,
-0.2898690701,
-0.3256964684,
-0.2855522633,
0.1704985052,
0.2567023933,
0.5980815887,
-0.2172219604,
0.0217913389,
0.425465703,
-0.0730979368,
0.0985866413,
0.6254677176,
-0.0525257327,
0.2658602893,
0.7849611044,
0.0924478173,
0.4084317684,
0.5066818595,
0.4003994465,
-0.1757473648,
-0.6606861949,
-0.1873796433,
0.0286522899,
-0.8534983397,
-0.0003855659,
-0.9969794154,
-0.2904632986,
-0.4956845939,
0.0429939963,
-0.2062676102,
-0.5729836226,
-0.4737682343,
-0.0566395335,
0.2119391412,
0.9511065483,
0.2194325775,
0.5404067636,
-0.8910577893,
0.3735304177,
0.3267839253,
0.1627829075,
-0.2511771619,
-0.7087490559,
-0.0565414056,
0.2187711746,
0.1462502033,
-0.6345844269,
0.3060641587,
0.3013614416,
0.4984156489,
0.2872515321,
0.2041695863,
0.7386111021,
-0.5975669026,
0.6618290544,
-0.3634294271,
-1.0861623287,
0.5567564368,
-0.2723761797,
0.3600874841,
0.7598172426,
0.3920453489,
-0.4569762945,
-0.799087584,
-1.0422379971,
-0.7754048705,
0.9914063215,
0.254460156,
0.4561316967,
-0.0047841677,
0.1444200575,
0.1023206413,
0.3656178117,
-0.7923198938,
0.155657962,
-0.1702492982,
-0.2616509795,
-0.4385912716,
-0.4886270463,
0.2257435769,
0.1036366373,
0.4328274429,
0.0656516925,
0.0610660277,
-0.1671513766,
-0.5076605678,
-0.1289056093,
0.5040233731,
0.618489325,
0.4456265569,
-0.4866386056,
0.2740044296,
0.2915917337,
-0.2925587893,
-0.214619711,
0.12006744,
0.0447315276,
-0.0775323287,
0.7039293051,
0.9414851665,
0.6289404631,
-0.7375761867,
0.9555960298,
-0.0533545129,
0.0577110723,
-0.3956086934,
0.126918003,
-0.188499257,
-0.0996881202,
0.1758645624,
0.0923376456,
0.2625022233,
-0.6967622638,
0.4242380559,
0.3854674697,
-0.4269739985,
-0.0646834895,
0.3785663843,
0.1497873068,
0.3271512687,
0.6700644493,
0.1461220533,
-0.7347035408,
0.3952176571,
0.1727576256,
0.7307678461,
0.2796693444,
0.2534453869,
-0.2091324627,
0.4361536801,
-0.0401805751,
0.0720372498,
-0.3834867775,
-1.1357722282,
-0.4475538433,
-0.7063778639,
-0.2382048965,
0.0969034657,
-0.5231152773,
0.3826701045,
-0.0903690606,
0.0664066002,
0.1307881325,
-0.0363032855,
-0.5573692322,
0.6650939584,
0.4798387587,
0.7530453801,
-1.4309484959,
0.8704388142,
0.3945375085,
-0.3294495344,
-0.7686011195,
0.2368622124,
-0.0141600268,
-0.9797961116,
0.8955222964,
0.2981397212,
-0.3184875846,
-0.1373780966,
-0.4378225803,
-0.7851036191,
0.4113967419,
0.4320743084,
-0.1310008168,
-0.1905016601,
0.2201088667,
0.7362136245,
-0.0877452046,
0.5966671705,
0.517413795,
0.2618775368,
0.2474425435,
-1.0919530392,
-0.1061917394,
-0.0851098299,
-0.3599577248,
0.4299253821,
-0.2015286237,
0.9314258099,
-0.0779211745,
-0.5347824693,
0.1839307398,
0.5831776857,
-0.2959674001,
0.2473676056,
0.7120816708,
0.4978713095,
0.69490695,
-0.0654142275,
1.0804497004,
-0.0933278129,
0.3715810776,
1.2217648029,
-0.0484476909,
0.873917222,
0.1481678784,
0.0882153362,
0.7170448303,
0.6648635268,
0.3778662086,
0.5513341427,
0.3822647035,
-0.1147889346,
-0.8672329783,
-0.1584908813,
-0.2024462223,
0.7029676437,
0.4968186617,
-0.198877871,
-0.517963469,
0.1070503369,
-0.069265008,
0.2523509264,
-0.348937124,
0.9010835886,
0.1017425582,
-0.4993951023,
0.6193309426,
-0.275639981,
0.7011252642,
-0.5642136931,
0.3350729346,
-0.0104246661,
0.2456247807,
-0.4617670476,
-0.9121363163,
0.3485979438,
0.025373619,
0.1181969121,
-0.3144070506,
0.9143298268,
-0.5948038697,
-0.5875741839,
0.0068692318,
0.5305649042,
0.6276563406,
-0.1568633914,
-0.4338331223,
-0.034807127,
-0.1636967361,
0.1290166229,
0.0861292034,
0.6824833751,
-0.2099262476,
0.8031049967,
0.2828274667,
0.1648802757,
0.0544880778,
0.1656597406,
0.8220820427,
-0.4146438241,
-0.3840572834,
-0.7324017882,
0.5097010732,
0.1487194002,
-0.2283573002,
0.5831541419,
0.2418710142,
0.9168804288,
-0.0848200917,
0.3576621413,
0.193078503,
0.6672323942,
-0.8114994168,
0.4805380106,
-0.7874147892,
0.0625676885,
-0.5066869855,
-0.3221588135,
-0.3129419386,
0.625197351,
-0.766256392,
-0.0740055069,
0.6362994909,
0.5276938677,
-0.3925373256,
0.3179758787,
0.2676852643,
0.0638682768,
-0.1442602724,
0.5461631417,
1.0954111814,
-0.17383793,
0.4525459707,
-0.1822569817,
0.2379617393,
-0.1735409945,
-0.7761240005,
-0.7836308479,
-0.5239419341,
-0.2471955717,
0.1778503209,
0.042200163,
0.8733889461,
0.6607022285,
-0.8273727298,
-0.0272999611,
-0.4045833051,
-0.0599335618,
0.3195014596,
-0.1557544023,
0.2039047629,
-0.5939090848,
-0.437069267,
0.4357533753,
-0.2465531975,
0.2245534807,
-0.0309426803,
0.4006014466,
-0.0774746165,
0.2819070518,
0.2468627244,
-0.0951308161,
-0.6959494352,
-0.4397003949,
-0.2921195924,
-0.1443830729,
-0.1495550424,
0.9889902472,
-0.9123639464,
0.3246434927,
0.4349361956,
0.5405129194,
0.2844124436,
0.1537613869,
0.3986504376,
-0.9359048605,
0.4337360561,
0.3293631673,
0.3306681514,
0.1782335788,
-0.3154625893,
0.1569781303,
0.1513784677,
-0.4372103214,
-0.8346551657,
0.2028587461,
-0.592445612,
-0.6903768778,
1.1700541973,
-0.0305918567,
-0.0921198502,
-0.1625891328,
-0.07095965,
0.0829335302,
-0.0930950493,
0.5967305303,
0.7380908728,
0.0240760557,
-0.1336468607,
-0.3743384182,
0.6488674283,
0.533657372,
-0.7264437675,
0.2078031003,
0.7240643501,
0.1700514257,
0.1223895028,
0.6803478599,
0.2232359648,
0.2043109685,
-0.0782324821,
-0.3050064743,
0.0952011868,
-0.3296970129,
-0.2757250369,
0.0757361948,
0.1337081045,
-0.2741789222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14849v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14849v1
|
Asynchronous and Segmented Bidirectional Encoding for NMT
| 2024-02-19T19:48:02 | 2024-02-19T19:48:02 |
Jingpu Yang, Zehua Han, Mengyu Xiang, Helin Wang, Yuxiao Huang, Miao Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the rapid advancement of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), enhancing
translation efficiency and quality has become a focal point of research.
Despite the commendable performance of general models such as the Transformer
in various aspects, they still fall short in processing long sentences and
fully leveraging bidirectional contextual information. This paper introduces an
improved model based on the Transformer, implementing an asynchronous and
segmented bidirectional decoding strategy aimed at elevating translation
efficiency and accuracy. Compared to traditional unidirectional translations
from left-to-right or right-to-left, our method demonstrates heightened
efficiency and improved translation quality, particularly in handling long
sentences. Experimental results on the IWSLT2017 dataset confirm the
effectiveness of our approach in accelerating translation and increasing
accuracy, especially surpassing traditional unidirectional strategies in long
sentence translation. Furthermore, this study analyzes the impact of sentence
length on decoding outcomes and explores the model's performance in various
scenarios. The findings of this research not only provide an effective encoding
strategy for the NMT field but also pave new avenues and directions for future
studies.
|
[
0.0799973309,
-0.1686168313,
0.4014030397,
0.4655075669,
-0.7085180879,
0.1778814793,
-0.385745436,
-0.3100093901,
0.1461719573,
0.3887746036,
-0.5328088999,
-0.2832676172,
-0.9332315326,
0.3952008784,
-0.5322142839,
0.6703683138,
-0.1003710181,
0.3341603577,
-0.075938493,
0.0626549199,
-0.5491860509,
-0.4278767705,
-0.5276964307,
-0.5154704452,
0.2060877383,
0.3341167867,
0.7079512477,
0.8027228117,
0.8532966971,
0.2675135434,
-0.1919793338,
0.0973356962,
-0.1862155199,
0.1601849496,
-0.0461762175,
-0.178469941,
-0.4489732087,
-0.2540206611,
0.682346642,
0.6725426316,
-0.1662335247,
-0.1506287307,
0.1521669179,
0.7136012316,
-0.2919755578,
0.1267344058,
-0.3715558946,
-0.0203342382,
-0.0504549518,
-0.408459872,
-0.7310664654,
-0.1470061988,
0.1606770754,
-0.1884644479,
0.1304747462,
-0.193751201,
0.7234959602,
0.3944146335,
-0.6497284174,
-0.3271260262,
-0.5905616283,
0.4997865558,
-0.9438073635,
0.6755387783,
0.1470792592,
0.2935190797,
0.1305640787,
-0.9451243877,
-0.279623419,
-0.2374298871,
-0.1834679395,
0.4319275618,
-0.2727166116,
0.2379382253,
0.0647598431,
0.1792210937,
-0.4141733646,
0.0488853417,
-0.3134104908,
-0.0107725095,
0.5080324411,
0.1437110901,
0.1389145851,
-0.7012075782,
-0.6507440209,
-0.1803810149,
-0.4850513339,
-0.021356035,
0.2576609552,
0.2175426632,
0.0409911834,
0.7007617354,
-0.4393904507,
0.3427553475,
0.1275804788,
0.2125371546,
0.1020213515,
-0.4703166187,
0.0894173905,
0.2720437944,
0.660000205,
0.6856304407,
-0.1092870608,
-0.4012354612,
-0.4674857557,
-0.2022500932,
0.5003461838,
-1.1254560947,
0.0627710447,
0.0389024764,
-0.4344815314,
-0.0446409769,
0.0870607123,
-0.5760329962,
0.1382781565,
-0.3001220524,
0.356082201,
-0.7481775284,
0.0072862124,
0.5221779346,
-0.0716894045,
0.1086213961,
0.2187351286,
-0.7852854133,
0.0713141486,
0.6930876374,
0.9664514065,
-0.4596950114,
-0.3313118219,
-0.2469543368,
-0.0988324136,
-0.1190488115,
0.3424263597,
-0.2391198874,
-0.2928396761,
-0.0141357398,
0.0567121767,
-0.3639279604,
-0.1271893531,
0.740662396,
-1.0175668001,
0.2179630846,
-0.0993299037,
-0.3908001184,
-0.3574380279,
0.1537922472,
-0.5383948684,
0.4291853011,
0.0207332037,
-0.5971146226,
-0.1517473608,
-1.0725078583,
-0.7815263271,
0.0416429304,
0.2500857115,
-0.3695656955,
0.2869527042,
0.2589246035,
0.3582229912,
-0.4022531509,
0.5385380387,
0.5553538203,
-0.5068390369,
0.4053006768,
-0.9521339536,
0.6747897267,
0.1678243876,
-0.511082232,
0.2298376262,
-0.6542097926,
-0.15289554,
0.161572516,
-0.6514267325,
0.0521752946,
-0.0478581227,
0.2448914051,
-0.002645199,
0.1720686853,
-0.6176846027,
-0.0165753122,
-0.4393078089,
0.813241303,
0.5839492679,
-0.1301605105,
0.7316801548,
0.2247328609,
0.4363252521,
0.1394436508,
0.1338535696,
-0.2719747722,
-0.1303728968,
-0.9286460876,
-0.0022849131,
0.6832817793,
0.3596867919,
-1.2314627171,
0.3402866721,
-0.8074577451,
0.0317198411,
-0.5923558474,
-0.5700063705,
0.3705515563,
0.5967029333,
0.6876273751,
-0.3999914229,
-0.5253943801,
-0.7479748726,
-0.0278161969,
0.3527017236,
-0.110452719,
-0.0176348314,
0.3779568076,
-0.5656654239,
0.7405536771,
-0.3849359453,
0.3124630153,
-0.364428252,
0.1719289422,
0.4394678175,
0.6419236064,
-0.0214256737,
-0.8608155847,
-0.5217214227,
0.01331132,
-0.473574847,
0.2091708928,
-0.012770718,
-0.2303840965,
0.1402586997,
0.4197312593,
-0.7363512516,
0.2906399667,
0.5660190582,
-0.4997744858,
0.4084031284,
-0.3490594625,
0.4244864583,
-1.2307071686,
0.0013750796,
-0.4535902739,
-0.3897656202,
-0.8087719083,
0.0944545567,
0.6468408108,
-0.0675328672,
-0.3698241115,
-0.3411040902,
-0.6203863621,
0.1321421117,
-0.4349908531,
-0.1001254693,
0.2139477581,
0.4482339621,
0.1202813089,
0.9880886078,
0.0087556019,
-0.2452126741,
0.216479063,
0.310559243,
-0.2259995937,
0.3415867388,
-0.7498860359,
0.2772498131,
-0.3738864958,
0.2069831491,
-0.537983954,
-0.0273433346,
-0.0265313853,
-0.4976160824,
0.4914327562,
-0.1435577571,
-0.254009366,
-0.6043686867,
-0.1006863266,
0.4231153727,
0.6715285182,
-0.6300284863,
0.4644609392,
-0.2209197283,
0.2078689188,
-0.6914319396,
-0.7335118651,
0.3188467622,
-0.1306232363,
-0.7073822021,
0.5192605257,
0.0700339749,
0.3356179595,
-0.1788877696,
-0.1177556962,
0.0645179749,
-0.038340915,
0.108382538,
0.3609701395,
-0.4855522215,
-0.077314347,
0.1908408105,
-0.5591461062,
0.1115818098,
-0.5547763109,
0.7298015952,
-0.0145100802,
-0.3573346138,
-0.551001966,
0.4188733697,
0.7633394599,
-0.3249224126,
0.7144388556,
0.6158971786,
-0.1059787869,
0.0422238708,
-0.3177879155,
-0.4851312935,
-0.4797168374,
0.5551887155,
-0.414734602,
-0.9303197861,
0.2705617249,
-0.114155449,
-0.3474835157,
0.3592033684,
0.2039957494,
-0.1527328789,
0.9846168756,
0.6945230961,
0.1537892222,
0.4220590591,
-0.3570446968,
0.4297656417,
-1.1215332747,
-0.2443770021,
-0.2473214716,
-0.3068742752,
-0.3686367869,
-0.9002973437,
0.2863438427,
0.0832888931,
-0.0244984031,
0.8006709814,
-0.6323573589,
0.4710531235,
0.6169573665,
0.2770820856,
0.4338533282,
-0.1728954017,
0.04706534,
-0.2084704489,
-0.6812821031,
-0.3729189336,
0.931096971,
0.4985934794,
0.498667419,
0.176391989,
0.3747901022,
0.3149671555,
-0.1482404023,
-0.7819448113,
0.3922447562,
-0.2920599282,
-0.1576971263,
-0.3301976621,
-0.3724870086,
-0.8585069776,
0.2774839103,
0.2603971958,
-0.2556246817,
0.2578865588,
-0.1720066965,
-0.3749702573,
0.0940054283,
-0.5500147939,
0.7641201019,
-0.2157337219,
-0.2704690993,
-0.1144305915,
-0.9334724545,
0.0009110601,
0.1763226688,
-0.5078188777,
0.0080789402,
0.1075277701,
0.8388608098,
-0.4339015782,
0.5032632947,
-0.1885424852,
0.1721058041,
0.0457356945,
-0.1819367856,
0.8369727731,
0.0505398698,
-0.1855734587,
0.2716628611,
-0.2049924433,
-0.3170157373,
-0.5698278546,
0.3665316999,
-0.6759081483,
-0.5030217171,
-0.1573271602,
-0.8313989639,
-0.1201977655,
0.3299252689,
0.5036560893,
0.524661243,
-0.0934488773,
0.3791123927,
0.7020033598,
0.1770483404,
0.9164412022,
0.3629775345,
0.2983341515,
-0.5232155323,
0.5574822426,
-0.0386765152,
0.3250593245,
0.6451452374,
-0.0249800254,
-0.6555552483,
-0.9678515196,
-0.7027961612,
0.1221028194,
-0.6593183875,
-0.6609683037,
-0.8457751274,
-0.4553077221,
-0.3610261381,
-0.2593041658,
-0.8037241697,
-0.3574113846,
-0.1715511233,
-0.0088634575,
0.2626250386,
0.5373969674,
0.1112606525,
0.6641494632,
-0.7581034899,
0.0813651383,
0.1975059062,
0.2487226576,
0.0511528887,
-0.7159209251,
-0.3950253427,
0.1798405647,
0.0454841703,
-0.787209034,
0.5004279017,
-0.2714638114,
0.1422675401,
0.2281889766,
0.0390539877,
0.6313828826,
-0.8592420816,
0.4346235096,
0.4047700465,
-1.0996068716,
0.3220499754,
-0.2215145826,
0.5906835198,
0.6251128912,
0.2333608866,
-0.6670026183,
0.1728460789,
-0.2029609531,
-0.8426262736,
0.891651392,
0.4677276611,
0.2732427716,
0.125381723,
0.1243829504,
0.0113166897,
0.2645794153,
-0.5188360214,
0.1191047654,
-0.426189363,
-0.3183479905,
-0.2885038555,
-0.6792618036,
0.2106129825,
-0.3638325036,
0.5581851006,
-0.2099197954,
0.6095843315,
0.3329996765,
-0.4474488795,
0.1276022196,
0.4124392271,
0.7095925808,
0.3137027919,
-0.2752474248,
0.3824395835,
0.1617839187,
-0.612261951,
0.1464452446,
0.264544934,
-0.2862307429,
0.1421090513,
0.2576875091,
1.0850325823,
0.2305070162,
-0.3695245683,
0.7540918589,
-0.0798946172,
0.0562548339,
0.0765170455,
-0.4872098863,
0.3241655231,
0.5413309336,
0.2620489597,
0.2566179335,
0.4860637784,
-0.1472190022,
0.2506400347,
0.1372547746,
-0.5541526675,
-0.4094983637,
0.7286725044,
0.3936110735,
-0.4967843592,
0.9764367938,
-0.0464692302,
-0.8740685582,
0.4690873027,
1.006991148,
0.9730433822,
-0.2750449777,
0.2090870589,
0.3950769901,
0.3709114194,
-0.18289195,
-0.1941932142,
-0.3948257565,
-0.6026624441,
-0.5521307588,
-0.8909456134,
-0.1174896508,
-0.4017851353,
-0.8650332689,
-0.1032079011,
0.208957538,
-0.100752987,
-0.37065804,
-0.2414969802,
-0.3013624251,
0.0995288044,
-0.0062181377,
0.89475137,
-0.4449624121,
1.0708039999,
0.3408815265,
-0.1013453007,
-0.5179036856,
0.1835304052,
-0.4727337658,
-0.8172978759,
0.4261924028,
0.3265125751,
-0.4315027595,
0.2697847486,
0.0304393284,
-0.9537122846,
1.3330203295,
0.1164743453,
-0.6144750118,
-0.2605522573,
0.6281991005,
0.4775507748,
-0.3563822806,
0.1473182887,
0.7444829941,
0.3400385082,
0.2773627341,
-0.6684190631,
0.2416366488,
-0.3871690631,
0.6007217765,
0.1604781598,
-0.4916724265,
0.6277398467,
-0.1516254991,
-0.3936341107,
0.0206616186,
0.8592862487,
-0.4168304801,
0.1295000166,
0.1799508482,
0.1803562939,
0.3830187619,
-0.1500137746,
0.9010077119,
-0.318742305,
0.3639839292,
1.0312464237,
0.1931734383,
0.9119573832,
0.5527712703,
0.0073143644,
0.2453183532,
0.3422252536,
0.1499129683,
0.8149361014,
-0.23470442,
-0.0898346007,
-0.1600995511,
0.0175644197,
-0.3634900749,
0.5991022587,
0.009596047,
-0.6180227995,
-0.1307905018,
0.4915083051,
0.1648809314,
0.1199223697,
-0.0886882469,
0.524553895,
-0.1155535281,
-0.7251042724,
0.7441946864,
0.4169989526,
0.9470915794,
-0.3830593824,
0.2386751771,
-0.3123365045,
0.2420371473,
0.0876284093,
-0.7553758025,
0.4411537945,
-0.1721761525,
-0.3384497762,
-0.5404113531,
0.6882517338,
-0.6547685266,
-0.261431247,
0.2896176875,
0.3534368575,
-0.0840697512,
-0.2802514136,
-0.4634809494,
0.1331017166,
0.2848035991,
-0.1569976509,
-0.0351940095,
0.2346224934,
0.1816219538,
0.2699200809,
0.5657587051,
-0.3440875709,
0.1439089626,
0.2678414583,
0.7668663859,
-0.8399378061,
-0.5760853291,
-0.9275870919,
0.7954698205,
-0.2130603641,
0.0618700162,
0.9285977483,
0.5618148446,
0.5871704817,
-0.2640069425,
0.1883347332,
0.1270302236,
0.1739962995,
-0.5718250871,
0.8937283158,
-0.2552412152,
0.124759607,
0.3355489373,
-0.6914708614,
-0.3234891891,
0.3340577185,
-0.2933580279,
-0.2484039813,
0.9216487408,
0.5785988569,
-0.2173453122,
0.3367755115,
0.5032060742,
0.1892490089,
0.1143845767,
0.6088947058,
0.8135075569,
-0.8739435673,
0.3005702496,
-0.4961767793,
0.0374078713,
-0.5157092214,
-0.4967864454,
-0.8200372458,
-0.7630186081,
-0.0083213169,
-0.4124110043,
0.3399410248,
0.6994270682,
0.6931117773,
-0.6110759974,
-0.1720809042,
-0.2411776334,
-0.0269290488,
-0.2493795305,
-0.1511617005,
0.4167697728,
-0.2385484278,
-0.9123622179,
0.7100456357,
0.5442838073,
-0.0078437664,
0.1708590984,
-0.2822650671,
-0.2299957275,
0.1623612791,
1.0723054409,
-0.2714366019,
-0.4287034571,
-0.1725785732,
0.1711232066,
-0.2762282789,
0.5893132687,
0.8445695639,
-0.2721091807,
0.4109680951,
0.4553353488,
0.7346324325,
0.662838161,
0.1940119117,
0.5756069422,
-0.395908922,
-0.0127298273,
0.6069305539,
0.2427248806,
0.5123013854,
-0.5972549915,
0.4413811564,
0.1266546398,
-0.4858238101,
-0.6857742667,
0.012271909,
-1.0511026382,
-0.2106915861,
1.1071875095,
-0.005812909,
-0.4022543132,
0.1072859168,
-0.0403483324,
0.4835884869,
-0.3401255906,
0.5246445537,
0.2458594143,
-0.0724768862,
-0.188003853,
-0.3003141284,
0.3125012517,
0.5035099387,
-0.5720661879,
0.0344090387,
0.2647663355,
0.1381353736,
0.2215669155,
0.3406030238,
-0.0980070159,
0.338735193,
0.2098665088,
-0.0187912267,
-0.1968411505,
-0.4575861096,
-0.6797338724,
0.317930609,
-0.1236613691,
-0.5247398615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12483v2
|
Artifacts or Abduction: How Do LLMs Answer Multiple-Choice Questions Without the Question?
| 2024-02-19T19:38:58 | 2024-06-07T23:11:14 |
Nishant Balepur, Abhilasha Ravichander, Rachel Rudinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple-choice question answering (MCQA) is often used to evaluate large
language models (LLMs). To see if MCQA assesses LLMs as intended, we probe if
LLMs can perform MCQA with choices-only prompts, where models must select the
correct answer only from the choices. In three MCQA datasets and four LLMs,
this prompt bests a majority baseline in 11/12 cases, with up to 0.33 accuracy
gain. To help explain this behavior, we conduct an in-depth, black-box analysis
on memorization, choice dynamics, and question inference. Our key findings are
threefold. First, we find no evidence that the choices-only accuracy stems from
memorization alone. Second, priors over individual choices do not fully explain
choices-only accuracy, hinting that LLMs use the group dynamics of choices.
Third, LLMs have some ability to infer a relevant question from choices, and
surprisingly can sometimes even match the original question. Inferring the
original question is an impressive reasoning strategy, but it cannot fully
explain the high choices-only accuracy of LLMs in MCQA. Thus, while LLMs are
not fully incapable of reasoning in MCQA, we still advocate for the use of
stronger baselines in MCQA benchmarks, the design of robust MCQA datasets for
fair evaluations, and further efforts to explain LLM decision-making.
|
[
-0.5202037096,
-0.8757827878,
1.0904325247,
-0.2462632507,
-0.0248247068,
0.3260236681,
0.0838323087,
-0.1627441645,
0.0082431398,
0.6127232313,
-0.9174731374,
-0.1901335269,
-0.4217460752,
0.2038229555,
-0.218761161,
0.8501069546,
0.0256283768,
0.1563141048,
-0.6299437284,
-0.2528147399,
-0.2956139147,
-0.6369494796,
-0.7062766552,
-0.2186044753,
0.6316189766,
0.6225823164,
0.787784338,
0.7908771634,
0.1048592404,
0.2144704312,
-0.2959527671,
0.3116260767,
-0.408551991,
-0.0644940063,
-0.0072959433,
-0.7865236998,
-0.0998348147,
0.3111543655,
0.561514616,
0.7916666269,
-0.0398314632,
0.4749772549,
-0.0011837814,
0.5858214498,
-0.6557149887,
-0.311093837,
-0.7596408725,
-0.0879013911,
-0.0430400521,
-0.2496159822,
-0.426756829,
-0.3805859387,
0.1859228611,
-0.2936059237,
0.0516096763,
0.1836930066,
0.7042631507,
0.1983658373,
-0.6606059074,
-0.6351490021,
-0.45505023,
0.83336097,
-0.1852040291,
0.2360907048,
0.3498781025,
0.2737235129,
-0.2701732516,
-0.5919808149,
-0.5573777556,
-0.4994938374,
0.0338657461,
0.3225954771,
-0.0043544406,
0.0322872512,
0.6801487207,
0.46338889,
-0.4651919305,
0.1170920357,
-0.5960047245,
-0.255722791,
0.3042677641,
0.2016948909,
0.2416028976,
-0.1801435649,
-0.6434365511,
0.0736504942,
-0.9212518334,
0.4088696837,
0.3912672698,
0.1504190713,
0.2076929361,
1.0990521908,
-0.0741911456,
0.6819579005,
0.1338887662,
-0.0776973367,
0.1868057698,
-0.0440082625,
-0.2276553065,
-0.1301815659,
0.5541321635,
0.0905461386,
0.3119234145,
-0.0179500617,
-0.0440161228,
-0.1329222023,
0.2085687816,
-0.4453873634,
0.0704700276,
0.5886816382,
-0.367125541,
-0.0572177172,
-0.1996943206,
-0.6023975611,
-0.393823415,
-0.2567930222,
0.6301650405,
-0.1392844766,
-0.142366603,
0.0525429472,
-0.3612446785,
0.3201832771,
0.2991165221,
-0.5147386789,
0.3712313771,
0.4233478308,
0.6144150496,
-0.4365496635,
-0.5326844454,
-0.6786394715,
-0.0581963658,
-0.5684934855,
0.8396962285,
-0.4951400161,
-0.4967108071,
-0.1520973891,
0.0615953617,
-0.2045457661,
-0.6641310453,
0.7495914102,
-0.5782369971,
0.3110933006,
-0.8225868344,
-0.5600429773,
-0.3486857414,
0.1307157278,
-0.6390476227,
1.0718407631,
-0.1926009357,
-0.550675869,
0.4007445574,
-0.5985117555,
0.0477391109,
-0.227548793,
-0.3421218991,
0.0220780391,
0.2152200341,
0.3423367143,
0.1421575248,
-0.0701668784,
0.006695474,
-0.4526892602,
-0.48432374,
0.694535315,
-0.7449151278,
1.0733093023,
0.1588673145,
-0.1283691823,
-0.2692864537,
-0.56134969,
0.0036973683,
0.1442998499,
-0.4956384599,
-0.0533993542,
0.0842986181,
-0.6482813358,
0.4441611767,
-0.0212980714,
-0.5712041259,
0.2777136266,
-0.1015368775,
-0.0149290543,
0.7720842361,
0.1510662287,
0.4887803495,
-0.9212558866,
0.7576514482,
0.0119261416,
-0.0777814835,
-0.0797768831,
-0.6122525334,
-0.8912470341,
-0.222152859,
0.0702681094,
0.6232682467,
-0.8282664418,
-0.4760407805,
-0.122976318,
-0.2582192123,
-0.7550745606,
0.1604777724,
0.2246503681,
0.6365305781,
0.4272884727,
0.0153972805,
-0.5321503878,
-0.9867941737,
-0.27943784,
-0.3528748751,
-0.0087290099,
0.502892971,
0.4541721642,
0.2539061904,
0.856744051,
-0.2885141969,
0.2922415435,
-0.1399211735,
0.0264219921,
0.31685552,
0.143447265,
0.3409618735,
-0.8032790422,
0.1534414142,
-0.4612875283,
-0.7216205001,
-0.2447875738,
-0.3045708537,
-0.2075790614,
0.1826025397,
0.397700727,
-0.9382494092,
0.2296202034,
0.3951171637,
0.0020578385,
0.9003279805,
0.0399332605,
0.1926722676,
-0.5956715941,
-0.0764286965,
-0.5184488893,
-0.0478286222,
-0.6823564768,
0.1413954049,
0.1922187954,
0.2542377412,
-0.7995239496,
0.807493031,
-0.6892981529,
-0.2278337628,
-0.0579125546,
0.2101535201,
0.0124121392,
0.5012230277,
0.0881401822,
1.0027195215,
0.3902602792,
-0.9020577073,
0.0634147525,
0.2503768802,
-0.3849965036,
0.5245708823,
-0.22664316,
0.4448448718,
-0.3534154892,
-0.0905700698,
-1.1983624697,
-0.0291186515,
0.3477711976,
-0.5692272186,
0.0069838441,
-0.1812540144,
-0.1783924848,
-0.4465202689,
-0.3029797077,
0.2012424767,
0.4555364847,
-0.5968081951,
0.7120713592,
0.1217257828,
-0.1378857195,
-1.0625660419,
-0.7897844315,
0.0297862142,
-0.2756159902,
-0.0726231709,
-0.1982104033,
-0.6970847845,
-0.5071182847,
-0.2746018171,
-0.493663609,
-0.2298585922,
0.3441318572,
0.3857110441,
0.4083759487,
-0.375353694,
0.3165471256,
0.1078687608,
0.1539347768,
0.3044934869,
-0.0101302452,
0.2807134688,
-0.017169714,
-0.6177400947,
-0.0916625932,
0.2182613462,
0.6632883549,
-0.1160687581,
0.5880421996,
0.1166742817,
-0.2112179548,
-0.0392923169,
-0.8857610226,
0.0999626145,
-0.4487614334,
0.0512625948,
-0.7793366909,
-0.98021698,
0.6114374995,
0.0672426447,
0.2073676288,
0.39379403,
0.6997899413,
-0.4845944643,
0.8211904764,
-0.0205900501,
0.335578084,
0.0815303475,
0.0471277274,
-0.2769546509,
-0.9298927188,
-0.2432752699,
-0.6172357798,
-0.2323243171,
-0.3139403462,
-0.3133347929,
0.1319693327,
0.1135155633,
-0.3518564105,
-0.1706403941,
-0.0875879452,
0.7846497893,
0.5833906531,
0.1896040589,
0.4832888246,
-0.1965209544,
-0.4922972322,
0.0921848789,
-0.6851204634,
-0.681330204,
1.3661363125,
0.0999551415,
0.4594758749,
0.2073121369,
0.7163456678,
-0.002819964,
0.3445162773,
-0.9168789983,
0.6408894658,
0.4204816222,
-0.9434095621,
-0.2598523498,
-0.3312703967,
-0.9626182318,
0.5291900635,
-0.2984707057,
-0.7533352375,
0.2092950344,
0.0701554045,
-0.5638921857,
0.2096484601,
-0.5416873693,
0.6776230931,
-0.3783834875,
-0.1446875632,
0.3151512146,
-0.5017450452,
0.6865566969,
-0.133103475,
0.2920977175,
0.0446702838,
-0.3642186821,
0.6202503443,
0.0795250162,
0.5492901206,
-0.0320139341,
0.0270564295,
0.5914276838,
0.3665237129,
0.3055407703,
0.0765239,
-0.2852725089,
-0.0664237291,
0.1684894264,
-0.4637494683,
-0.8264919519,
0.473893404,
-0.4678139389,
-1.0704854727,
-0.3981316686,
-0.6419816613,
-0.2569013536,
0.104426533,
0.088808544,
0.3099580407,
-0.1184252501,
0.1197565719,
0.7629294991,
-0.1352694631,
0.6055749059,
0.5272784829,
-0.3464114368,
-0.300685674,
0.3859649003,
0.3966780901,
0.6707225442,
0.2364808619,
0.1208884194,
-0.5900446177,
-0.8641158938,
-0.6884811521,
0.2585625947,
-0.9878057837,
0.1755400896,
-0.8082975745,
-0.0955127999,
0.1218219027,
0.0936731175,
-0.0200444944,
-0.5886397362,
-0.4121814966,
-0.5668779612,
-0.2309730053,
0.6081110835,
0.0758784413,
0.0365741849,
-0.6259586811,
0.5541702509,
0.6060521603,
-0.0939263627,
-0.0582199581,
-0.5630595088,
0.2021119148,
0.3211358488,
-0.252135396,
-1.0585024357,
-0.0432769023,
-0.019766571,
0.9266260862,
0.1670793146,
0.0778448582,
0.9552462101,
-0.5608932972,
0.971078217,
-0.4272921085,
-0.834923625,
0.1231071725,
-0.1274516284,
0.4000920653,
0.6812111139,
0.4949441552,
-0.395830065,
-0.5500693917,
-0.7279819846,
-0.1507281065,
0.5986900926,
0.0794213936,
0.2383430749,
-0.2338233143,
0.5946282148,
0.1289735883,
0.3190277517,
-0.8561125994,
-0.5089634061,
0.1449203342,
0.0663267747,
-0.137313053,
-0.4724812508,
-0.2374499738,
0.0504808091,
0.359321326,
-0.1280409992,
0.2914660871,
0.3288485408,
-0.3596397936,
-0.1428389996,
0.3939748108,
0.7988230586,
0.9590066671,
-0.1245952994,
0.2678430676,
0.6835272908,
-0.2522108555,
0.3419454992,
-0.2804695666,
-0.0500408299,
-0.0728253573,
0.2491582036,
0.4577550888,
0.0121590523,
-0.8014329672,
0.5238112211,
-0.1083943769,
-0.3853530288,
-0.2738608718,
0.1456489414,
0.2146968096,
0.2722893953,
0.5704119205,
0.1980928034,
0.1379260719,
-0.6314179897,
0.2832026184,
0.7210344672,
-0.2536887228,
-0.0413540117,
0.5947535038,
-0.4614896774,
-0.3765974343,
0.629589498,
-0.0097589111,
-0.3744278848,
0.7889794111,
0.408115536,
0.5296981335,
-0.3419528604,
0.3970893323,
0.2036087662,
0.6018986702,
-0.1341845542,
0.5564031005,
-0.119149968,
-0.8308779001,
-0.4987164736,
-0.4034310877,
-0.6742001772,
0.3733454645,
-0.7984214425,
0.1172193363,
-0.3947995007,
0.0765480772,
-0.1218146011,
-0.1100463867,
-0.5700299144,
0.4158431888,
0.1815138608,
1.1030833721,
-0.646337688,
0.5994310379,
0.4255248606,
-0.2727597654,
-0.7258725166,
-0.0278945509,
0.3759742081,
-1.0447173119,
0.4039212465,
0.1839860082,
-0.0877073035,
-0.1576365978,
-0.7464197874,
-1.0525534153,
0.9152388573,
0.5690566897,
-0.0785217658,
0.131995067,
0.0200623237,
0.310940057,
-0.4175368249,
0.5446183085,
0.5988793373,
0.4230449498,
0.4632283449,
-0.7257625461,
-0.018409742,
0.0563300736,
-0.3889679015,
0.0607417747,
-0.397448808,
0.9242316484,
-0.5124399662,
-0.4211531579,
0.3316211998,
0.3964809477,
0.5569326878,
0.2804089487,
0.3278597593,
0.3171794713,
1.0197076797,
-0.1565247476,
1.1762549877,
0.2126702815,
-0.0059807464,
1.3198567629,
-0.1764674038,
0.8741844296,
0.6756821871,
-0.1410219222,
0.3666694462,
0.8854592443,
0.1435263008,
0.2168692201,
0.194599539,
-0.1120993868,
-0.447394073,
0.1097289175,
-0.0967360735,
0.4194960594,
0.3284485936,
-0.29790622,
0.0165141467,
-0.0269878656,
0.0783498213,
-0.3242576122,
-0.3636632562,
0.6787981391,
0.0899329931,
-0.9566856027,
0.7065359354,
-0.4887441397,
0.0581460781,
-0.5013507605,
-0.0494503677,
-0.2861284912,
-0.4124751985,
-0.1228566244,
-0.9877315164,
0.0818798691,
-0.1713137627,
-0.0888975412,
-0.1532008648,
0.3768805861,
-0.3802112341,
-0.3330141306,
-0.0264407247,
1.0986847878,
0.430057168,
0.0411945991,
-0.6753009558,
-0.3219343126,
-0.0119913789,
-0.5032884479,
0.2537567616,
0.3604001105,
-0.0471079871,
1.0145232677,
0.799151957,
0.1347953826,
0.2714159787,
-0.1917361468,
0.6290147901,
-0.5435045958,
-0.0201995466,
-1.0702755451,
0.706792593,
0.0156313945,
-0.2355598062,
0.8050967455,
0.6786100268,
0.7340218425,
-0.026065262,
0.7100222707,
0.3968299329,
0.6250798106,
-0.8830778003,
0.308799684,
-0.6397668123,
0.3427762389,
-0.2196481526,
-0.8143430352,
-0.2198602855,
0.2654582858,
-0.4251950979,
0.0744488165,
0.9523155689,
0.8596310019,
0.0876272693,
0.1387785077,
0.4262197018,
0.1669884622,
0.0369549096,
0.5232508183,
1.4861555099,
-0.1149332449,
0.8124504089,
0.0182626937,
-0.0583851151,
0.2748996317,
-0.771794498,
-1.0267535448,
-0.418656826,
-0.0611907803,
-0.2707705796,
-0.1719828248,
0.8993214369,
0.1617858559,
-0.6340014935,
-0.3650963902,
0.3927915394,
0.5316479206,
-0.3593311608,
-0.1431626081,
0.3057256639,
-0.2815974951,
-0.7507359385,
0.5652241707,
0.1414132416,
0.360165447,
0.1436881572,
-0.0241570193,
-0.2828074694,
0.3504752815,
0.3241111338,
0.2841201723,
-1.0480232239,
-0.4669145942,
0.2317175567,
0.0774184316,
0.4308349192,
0.6463935375,
-0.7726358175,
0.4305785894,
0.1235689297,
0.7547467947,
0.3800514042,
0.236407876,
0.2793264985,
-0.4705365002,
-0.216702804,
0.293065697,
0.3928085864,
-0.0043324511,
-0.1793030202,
0.2905538082,
0.0288783386,
-0.6020104885,
-0.8652495742,
0.3486328423,
-0.9438763261,
-0.4108206332,
1.1933137178,
0.0428714603,
-0.1371135712,
-0.3441842496,
-0.5493286848,
-0.062825717,
-0.0965641886,
0.4802347422,
1.261870265,
-0.3453479409,
-0.5692641139,
-0.9662678242,
0.5015280843,
0.4195223749,
-0.6384482384,
-0.0073219142,
0.6571555734,
0.3730902374,
0.1731935441,
0.7927386761,
0.0596199147,
0.4675130546,
-0.1176936552,
-0.3720054626,
-0.2383361608,
-0.2960699499,
-0.5847423673,
0.4864151478,
0.205314219,
-0.2538967729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12451v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12451v2
|
The Revolution of Multimodal Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-02-19T19:01:01 | 2024-06-06T16:13:43 |
Davide Caffagni, Federico Cocchi, Luca Barsellotti, Nicholas Moratelli, Sara Sarto, Lorenzo Baraldi, Lorenzo Baraldi, Marcella Cornia, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Connecting text and visual modalities plays an essential role in generative
intelligence. For this reason, inspired by the success of large language
models, significant research efforts are being devoted to the development of
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). These models can seamlessly integrate
visual and textual modalities, while providing a dialogue-based interface and
instruction-following capabilities. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive
review of recent visual-based MLLMs, analyzing their architectural choices,
multimodal alignment strategies, and training techniques. We also conduct a
detailed analysis of these models across a wide range of tasks, including
visual grounding, image generation and editing, visual understanding, and
domain-specific applications. Additionally, we compile and describe training
datasets and evaluation benchmarks, conducting comparisons among existing
models in terms of performance and computational requirements. Overall, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the current state of the art, laying
the groundwork for future MLLMs.
|
[
-0.6017911434,
-0.8586608171,
0.5084201694,
0.1386656314,
0.0940883383,
0.0517386757,
-0.3935602307,
-0.3670432866,
-0.1392486095,
0.5347275734,
-0.4678587914,
-0.5047014356,
-0.5679754615,
-0.1621044427,
-0.4221859872,
0.6377873421,
-0.0208635647,
0.2648686469,
-0.5842527747,
-0.387072891,
-0.6208087802,
-0.571713984,
-0.2414442152,
0.0076371287,
0.7425708175,
-0.0550116822,
0.7090246677,
0.3654725552,
0.5610932708,
0.4333827198,
-0.0161634143,
0.4077962935,
-0.4343447089,
0.3609457612,
0.0095181167,
-0.1778623015,
-0.4376602769,
-0.074526161,
0.6850184202,
0.7250932455,
0.1649118811,
0.0910366923,
-0.1116199046,
0.5815942883,
-0.6422834992,
0.2825696766,
-0.4123875201,
0.0621394031,
-0.1180981323,
-0.1257629544,
-0.6734671593,
-0.0236129221,
0.194016993,
-0.3785094023,
-0.0519365706,
0.0393306278,
0.4352165163,
0.1055347621,
-0.7728474736,
-0.340177387,
-0.8324320912,
0.9499598145,
-0.5646743178,
0.8744312525,
0.0844889879,
0.3494039178,
0.038210243,
-0.7895846367,
-0.5690765381,
-0.4562436938,
0.1736128032,
0.1658693403,
-0.0798296854,
0.044615604,
0.2087603509,
0.2980521321,
-0.7774236798,
0.1823055893,
-0.2738583982,
0.0870396122,
0.4437705874,
0.3490470052,
0.6041603088,
-0.1179560646,
-0.4984882772,
-0.1932023317,
-0.5371652842,
-0.0250915904,
0.1227185726,
0.107278347,
-0.2761442065,
0.8351962566,
-0.0894458592,
1.146023035,
-0.4530541301,
-0.4565830529,
0.2078840435,
-0.7917017937,
-0.3141329885,
-0.5141556859,
0.9196575284,
0.6360189915,
0.3436204493,
0.1128106415,
-0.3848209679,
-0.0457528457,
0.1998528838,
-0.7221574783,
-0.200730294,
0.0572479703,
-0.6927939057,
-0.2214220464,
-0.2211446762,
-0.8192682266,
-0.5465345979,
-0.7315695286,
0.2123404145,
-0.6531561017,
-0.3282577395,
-0.0598150268,
-0.1526401788,
0.1794314533,
0.6948646903,
-0.950556457,
-0.2649496496,
0.4851806164,
0.6625421047,
0.0038494065,
-0.4198779464,
-0.3115856051,
0.0695765615,
-0.4070883691,
0.7583353519,
-0.7150938511,
-0.1837895066,
0.4954650998,
-0.0974468961,
-0.138480559,
-0.1951848119,
0.1590268165,
-0.5709627271,
0.3642514348,
-0.1500573456,
-0.3251158595,
-0.4033320844,
0.6851305366,
-0.7589786053,
0.6961948872,
-0.0412481539,
-0.7027469873,
0.3000726998,
-0.4131028652,
-0.2120645493,
0.1048385948,
-0.411237061,
-0.252876699,
0.0693247914,
0.2638697028,
0.6654975414,
-0.4549268484,
0.3762306869,
-0.3436512053,
-0.063633807,
0.4742549956,
-0.8653920889,
0.6936846972,
0.1804789752,
-0.1058634967,
0.5613939166,
-0.8084512353,
0.0892144218,
0.0005942433,
-0.2278808057,
-0.2349690497,
0.1445100009,
0.4498057067,
0.435464561,
0.2106320113,
-0.1392535418,
0.3434809446,
0.1052357554,
0.4734613597,
0.6127086282,
-0.2460345477,
0.4767334759,
-0.0183772668,
0.4371694922,
0.0452891961,
0.4139312804,
-0.7727910876,
-0.4501971602,
-0.7953594327,
-0.5501053929,
0.2073616534,
0.4475362003,
-1.0100077391,
0.1508585215,
-0.3726078868,
-0.6075330377,
-0.303581357,
0.2568803728,
0.2948093414,
0.0032328102,
0.2464791387,
0.0039903698,
-0.4024206698,
-0.8903781176,
0.1839336306,
-0.0799838379,
0.2075791508,
0.2524755299,
0.4599798024,
-0.520766139,
0.6424576044,
-0.1903933436,
-0.0297212154,
-0.3495330811,
0.1959306598,
-0.1932544261,
0.3462887108,
0.7270671129,
-1.0054248571,
-0.3712053299,
0.3091836572,
-0.9465084076,
0.3910191655,
-0.1281087548,
0.1339367181,
0.1020982042,
0.6122508049,
-0.7119400501,
0.2101055235,
0.825723052,
-0.1511756331,
0.5226905942,
-0.0995482653,
0.3623282611,
-0.9535853267,
0.1673909426,
0.0958342329,
-0.0977873877,
-0.7716343999,
0.1740326136,
0.1233017147,
-0.3222379386,
-0.4038308859,
0.4732833803,
-0.8679530025,
0.0195694976,
-0.1189577356,
0.1087836325,
-0.0938817188,
0.5068795681,
-0.0643467009,
0.6609100103,
0.6260007024,
-0.3339396715,
0.8829658628,
0.3317531943,
-0.5636052489,
0.576132834,
-0.388343066,
-0.0914314464,
-0.4790476561,
0.1764896512,
-1.1412477493,
-0.3522335291,
0.0757755563,
-0.2169656903,
0.2624139488,
-0.0505675115,
-0.489458859,
-0.3313046098,
-0.3221314251,
0.5823555589,
0.4084086716,
-0.3895774782,
0.991612494,
0.2003132999,
-0.3964402378,
-0.6111912727,
-0.4900075197,
0.3818705976,
-0.0320129804,
-0.6757668853,
-0.0233069267,
-0.1000195518,
-0.323404789,
-0.2110956609,
0.6145042777,
0.0714934394,
-0.3517829776,
0.1249094605,
0.4866348505,
-0.3281883001,
0.288351506,
-0.4291264713,
0.174855575,
-0.2570028901,
-0.0107349688,
0.6765017509,
-0.140760228,
-0.5677750707,
-0.3270739913,
0.5624529719,
1.163383007,
-0.8706104159,
0.7353296876,
0.8138399124,
-0.1027728617,
-0.0130204968,
-0.7604112029,
0.2049987018,
-0.3401488662,
0.7023798227,
-0.2734305859,
-0.849031806,
0.0952536985,
-0.0577067807,
0.2221315652,
0.212436825,
0.8882763386,
-0.2216811478,
1.1977502108,
0.8437101841,
0.1659900248,
0.798299551,
-0.1431055665,
0.2445921749,
-0.7297157049,
-0.5175459385,
-0.2944375575,
-0.1108347699,
-0.5098803043,
-0.6783369184,
0.3763890862,
-0.1732119471,
-0.1080394313,
-0.0197490864,
-0.166212514,
0.0141928215,
0.4207251668,
-0.2452052683,
0.126864478,
0.0723349303,
-0.0056302464,
-0.0164612755,
-0.7708160877,
-0.4753616452,
0.934414804,
0.4212068021,
0.9280315042,
0.1226707846,
-0.0157564953,
-0.0456969775,
0.3811305165,
-0.7870275378,
0.573895216,
-0.2426009476,
-0.3884366155,
-0.3365325332,
-0.1741725802,
-0.6412168145,
0.4394384623,
-0.4849579632,
-0.3797834516,
0.1488042921,
0.0644472465,
0.0139175206,
0.3037832975,
-0.7022265196,
1.1239703894,
-0.4657470286,
-0.3154833317,
-0.1783157587,
-0.6260677576,
0.6015316248,
0.041512534,
0.1560637057,
0.0473314784,
0.0788432732,
0.3529685736,
-0.0060525429,
0.8891393542,
-0.0245940406,
-0.3874793351,
0.1661527902,
-0.2446518242,
0.3320097327,
-0.3984042406,
0.2628968656,
0.0449680984,
-0.0540095121,
-0.1670210212,
-0.5893337727,
0.6192383766,
-0.4626538754,
-0.3404023051,
-0.1192459315,
-0.7041909695,
-0.3931284845,
0.155052945,
0.0321451128,
0.9737781882,
-0.412047714,
0.5976703167,
0.7298478484,
-0.3455693424,
0.6227964759,
0.0268449467,
-0.615023613,
-0.6774845719,
1.0369133949,
0.0250020027,
0.3664188683,
0.5187110305,
-0.251134038,
-0.3495718241,
-0.5416289568,
-0.7633206844,
0.1366553307,
-0.7462999821,
-0.0695522726,
-0.7348796725,
-0.3262939453,
-0.3888640702,
-0.0765737519,
-0.3549006879,
0.0327553675,
-0.1549172699,
0.287499845,
0.0945312828,
0.8940094709,
0.5084105134,
0.0682306439,
-0.8583214879,
0.3518926501,
0.630413115,
0.303373009,
0.2465339601,
-0.049273219,
-0.2157929689,
0.0207845978,
-0.177360177,
-0.6968913078,
0.193346709,
0.0399653092,
0.5137748718,
0.5756152272,
-0.4699630141,
0.6392405033,
-0.828123033,
0.9589006901,
0.6492936015,
-0.535579145,
0.2242349386,
-0.4691339135,
0.4507130384,
0.1139714941,
0.3007103503,
-0.81024611,
-0.1559606194,
-0.0558197014,
-0.557694912,
0.1747879237,
-0.0481055342,
0.3039835989,
0.1156591848,
-0.2867160141,
-0.0239413995,
0.3907944858,
-0.6922989488,
-0.0153733566,
-0.4070388377,
-0.4549095631,
-0.0972808301,
-0.3308825195,
-0.2316096276,
-0.199458316,
0.3244831264,
-0.3298330009,
0.0986014009,
-0.3004046082,
-0.2865936756,
0.3113918006,
0.3578431606,
0.8967967629,
0.8883135915,
0.2282820642,
0.1907905042,
-0.1672691852,
-0.2461836189,
0.0985692367,
-0.0539073907,
-0.054050494,
-0.035823606,
0.6260339022,
1.2287211418,
0.1457703561,
-1.0370192528,
0.9011277556,
0.0034837979,
-0.1043824181,
-0.3051045239,
-0.1152435392,
0.1108853072,
0.4573093057,
0.1088837236,
0.1886721402,
-0.0434000865,
-0.7024521232,
-0.236627236,
0.9231339097,
-0.3928764164,
-0.3247948289,
0.5078255534,
0.3308593631,
-0.0916223377,
0.682539463,
0.2533933818,
-0.3797845244,
0.2220959365,
0.3262502253,
0.6903249621,
-0.1674099565,
0.1810656488,
0.1065149605,
0.3978693485,
0.1665638387,
0.1030207798,
-0.0409191437,
-0.6204191446,
-0.5483462811,
-0.600494504,
-0.1306895614,
0.2197939456,
-0.2490544468,
0.2080332935,
-0.3023163676,
-0.2089129388,
0.0206777342,
-0.5772657394,
-0.7375617027,
0.3980268538,
0.514523685,
0.8066177964,
-0.7696500421,
0.6399623156,
0.9023778439,
-0.5115491748,
-0.2226304114,
-0.2825877368,
-0.007168611,
-0.5507113934,
0.7926152349,
0.1405412555,
-0.1496720016,
-0.1047921106,
-0.6346225739,
-0.6630212069,
0.9072701931,
0.0820115879,
-0.5589915514,
-0.2269264013,
0.0676358044,
0.5340878367,
-0.3812909722,
0.2816781998,
0.2232482582,
0.5084526539,
0.0530802272,
-0.7465091944,
-0.3837475479,
-0.4892398715,
0.4657526314,
0.1993082017,
-0.6940139532,
0.8324949741,
0.0335980095,
-0.1914280057,
0.2871719599,
0.747651577,
0.0578584969,
0.0095324824,
0.4288918376,
0.4763351679,
0.3627116084,
-0.0644386038,
0.9190336466,
-0.2448399961,
0.0212002657,
0.7054048181,
-0.2581394315,
0.9122345448,
0.5040138364,
-0.0211474095,
0.3710518777,
0.1881821454,
-0.217294991,
0.3247198164,
-0.1323949993,
-0.4289012253,
-0.3391377926,
-0.2704696655,
-0.4099637866,
0.5554823279,
0.2890042067,
-0.4512338042,
-0.1440114975,
0.4010398686,
-0.2884064317,
-0.010291799,
-0.2864869833,
0.8545864224,
-0.228827849,
-0.5928974748,
0.4722420573,
-0.1019183323,
0.6148194671,
-0.6538543701,
-0.2237506211,
-0.0188203938,
0.0139695611,
0.0675143823,
-0.8007696867,
-0.2523424923,
-0.0532458797,
-0.3578714132,
-0.5026379824,
0.6353343129,
-0.6778689623,
-0.4331164062,
0.0578584597,
0.8106949329,
-0.2771774828,
0.1304452419,
-0.5141535401,
0.5648235083,
-0.0266804192,
-0.1345300227,
0.2346138507,
0.4612248838,
-0.1581263393,
0.7710137367,
0.6633681059,
-0.1912832707,
0.2837647498,
0.2932544649,
0.9339329004,
-0.7842209935,
-0.2210366577,
-0.6870965958,
0.8780358434,
-0.1115871519,
-0.3435160816,
0.6808259487,
0.5717154741,
0.587433815,
-0.3992028236,
0.7610719204,
0.1397532374,
0.0583306774,
-0.7659986615,
0.7357327342,
-0.7004299164,
-0.3418426514,
-0.2220043093,
-1.033505559,
-0.2592117786,
0.2380010784,
-0.0995433182,
0.1373088062,
0.6040230393,
0.6973045468,
-0.0777677074,
-0.0596549287,
0.6068025231,
0.1912873089,
0.4360446632,
0.2403361052,
1.3535888195,
-0.2182994336,
0.3398883641,
0.1098121107,
-0.2440643013,
-0.280220896,
-0.7349808812,
-1.0774638653,
-0.8791819811,
-0.0727744326,
0.2212407738,
-0.1436820626,
0.6826304793,
0.6938381195,
-0.4516480267,
-0.2003549784,
0.186429292,
-0.2743611038,
0.0290738568,
-0.1320147663,
0.1245706081,
-0.3686242104,
-0.9208266735,
0.3909151256,
0.6500746608,
0.2250858396,
-0.7229691148,
0.0721088871,
-0.3432104886,
0.031166343,
1.2158790827,
0.1487199366,
-1.0399682522,
-0.143650502,
0.0322237499,
-0.4432583153,
0.0069997464,
0.8370677829,
-0.5440378785,
0.7074224949,
0.6112298965,
0.7805522084,
0.2576797009,
-0.2185845077,
0.5209807754,
-0.3870778382,
0.2831088901,
0.1156651899,
0.4614142776,
0.6215897202,
0.2074510157,
0.1680659503,
0.1400403678,
-0.3860265017,
-0.7644292712,
0.3158475757,
-1.0087987185,
-0.24513188,
0.9846573472,
0.1911351383,
-0.1744326949,
0.0856582299,
-0.5163715482,
-0.0456805602,
0.1481135041,
0.319486618,
0.9335673451,
0.0536042824,
-0.5863237977,
-0.7656384706,
0.2652430832,
0.1535195857,
-0.9342494607,
0.142983973,
1.1021581888,
-0.0867639408,
0.293715477,
0.3444910347,
-0.1376199722,
0.1518961489,
0.0262812991,
0.2928833961,
-0.0049327267,
-0.6733067036,
-0.2770682275,
0.4243422747,
0.0609967001,
0.0543897226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12431v1
|
Understanding Fine-grained Distortions in Reports of Scientific Findings
| 2024-02-19T19:00:01 | 2024-02-19T19:00:01 |
Amelie Wührl, Dustin Wright, Roman Klinger, Isabelle Augenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Distorted science communication harms individuals and society as it can lead
to unhealthy behavior change and decrease trust in scientific institutions.
Given the rapidly increasing volume of science communication in recent years, a
fine-grained understanding of how findings from scientific publications are
reported to the general public, and methods to detect distortions from the
original work automatically, are crucial. Prior work focused on individual
aspects of distortions or worked with unpaired data. In this work, we make
three foundational contributions towards addressing this problem: (1)
annotating 1,600 instances of scientific findings from academic papers paired
with corresponding findings as reported in news articles and tweets wrt. four
characteristics: causality, certainty, generality and sensationalism; (2)
establishing baselines for automatically detecting these characteristics; and
(3) analyzing the prevalence of changes in these characteristics in both
human-annotated and large-scale unlabeled data. Our results show that
scientific findings frequently undergo subtle distortions when reported. Tweets
distort findings more often than science news reports. Detecting fine-grained
distortions automatically poses a challenging task. In our experiments,
fine-tuned task-specific models consistently outperform few-shot LLM prompting.
|
[
-0.2727402151,
-0.7346907854,
0.7004110813,
0.4365858436,
-0.3036692739,
-0.1302871853,
-0.0239308681,
-0.9665737748,
0.5375520587,
0.4732401967,
-0.0616272762,
-0.2523603141,
-0.9639664292,
0.2853645682,
-0.6373819113,
1.1399683952,
-0.092542693,
0.3192707896,
-0.1826959103,
0.1324699968,
-0.1444686353,
-0.0137226637,
-0.2643921375,
-0.4587132335,
0.4450878203,
0.30643785,
0.6058578491,
0.5887107849,
0.5529457331,
0.1926815361,
-0.2167844772,
0.3348485231,
-0.6500664353,
-0.1202622578,
-0.3111172318,
-0.622969389,
-0.2066306919,
0.1966992021,
0.5650926232,
0.8785336018,
0.3507389724,
0.4897269309,
0.5303642154,
0.5525549054,
-0.3327409029,
0.4034407437,
-0.4998445809,
-0.0421244428,
-0.4974671602,
-0.5906581283,
-0.3421442807,
-0.1501446217,
-0.0455782376,
-0.6816227436,
0.5969440341,
0.052902326,
0.7729058266,
0.3384829462,
-0.4230776727,
-0.432076931,
-0.9064941406,
0.5843857527,
-0.4397781491,
0.0659372136,
0.5249279737,
-0.1387311369,
-0.4119153917,
-0.6563383937,
-0.2488880306,
-0.2011385113,
-0.2632888854,
-0.0348643064,
-0.2304542065,
-0.0758727863,
0.2857877314,
0.1384089738,
-0.2110240012,
-0.0091368742,
-0.5632860661,
-0.4330443442,
0.6724104285,
0.0190278124,
0.0246156491,
-0.341884464,
0.0288689472,
-0.0992170647,
-0.4928744733,
-0.0786749795,
0.2494452596,
0.3408442438,
0.0061201043,
0.7525246143,
-0.3535962403,
0.4210503995,
0.4556114376,
-0.0195080247,
0.2325645983,
-0.4765971005,
-0.2136089206,
0.3670795858,
0.6883382797,
0.6696519852,
0.0396735668,
-0.2811994851,
0.0938032046,
0.2546508312,
0.1945246309,
-0.6369684339,
-0.277438879,
-0.1576977521,
-0.3332591951,
-0.5006747842,
0.1219788864,
-0.6866180897,
-0.877576232,
-0.4417697489,
0.4757941365,
-0.1599524319,
0.1381778121,
0.2089544535,
-0.1250640154,
-0.4613387585,
0.6060128808,
-0.6686090231,
0.1076274142,
0.4769654572,
0.8049576283,
-0.0228565186,
-0.1685038209,
-0.2911629379,
0.2264759541,
-0.2902258337,
1.0496966839,
-0.4133265615,
-0.3826451004,
-0.4038101733,
0.0813432336,
0.3350147307,
-0.3598892093,
0.6704381704,
-0.192590028,
0.0372823142,
-0.4819128513,
-0.3279387951,
0.0196280386,
-0.0207963865,
-0.470243603,
0.5938664079,
0.0169581901,
-1.0950769186,
0.4857839048,
-0.5260817409,
-0.39451316,
-0.2981340587,
0.0186897907,
-0.3123431802,
0.4976075292,
0.1768140048,
0.2880786955,
-0.0180011857,
0.3608806133,
-0.1893333942,
-0.1545576602,
0.3285421431,
-0.6506229639,
0.3287931681,
0.1499237567,
-0.2171980143,
0.1113966182,
-0.6639188528,
-0.2558805943,
-0.0480217263,
-0.2095310688,
-0.6090502143,
0.11840754,
0.198354274,
-0.096069932,
-0.0221435502,
-0.6838622093,
0.3721681237,
-0.3292750418,
0.4241867065,
0.5565707684,
0.2501885295,
0.3695154786,
-0.4405539632,
-0.2461053133,
0.3375046849,
0.3831052184,
-0.0762000456,
-0.4036171436,
-0.367323637,
0.1566865742,
0.2485834807,
0.1129728705,
-0.2359816283,
0.0068593496,
-0.2668911517,
-0.5290461779,
-0.6928114891,
-0.0218317527,
0.2228062451,
0.6631214023,
0.7509422302,
-0.4056082964,
-0.5182446837,
-0.9705795646,
-0.9489201307,
-0.0098427618,
-0.3079245389,
0.0781562105,
0.5925366879,
-0.2562988698,
0.8291864395,
-0.4523405731,
-0.3352094591,
0.4737234712,
0.9079087973,
-0.2553762197,
0.5029084682,
0.1464524418,
-0.7367803454,
-0.3381623924,
-0.2624033988,
-0.5340518951,
-0.3740197718,
-0.2641505599,
0.2454077005,
0.0509060062,
0.4463881254,
-0.3191529512,
0.6086492538,
0.3128859997,
-0.6770371199,
0.7515394688,
-0.0032735718,
0.4878927171,
-0.5711917281,
-0.0038574184,
0.3531628847,
-0.2209475189,
-0.5454384685,
-0.5067610145,
-0.1052862257,
0.5863280296,
-0.1988868713,
0.2867610157,
-0.416157186,
-0.0028199584,
-0.2640537918,
-0.0517720841,
0.136679247,
-0.2836685181,
-0.2643890083,
0.4139641523,
0.1548525244,
-0.4225153923,
0.1338899732,
0.2686718404,
-0.4232232571,
0.5140076876,
-0.6230892539,
-0.1767987311,
-0.5160865784,
0.4479091167,
-0.7465509772,
-0.6296816468,
0.3012652695,
-0.5318869948,
0.2025977522,
-0.0089606643,
-0.576191783,
-0.2794539928,
-0.2349235564,
0.2460782677,
0.0605456941,
-0.3062077761,
0.100983277,
0.342471391,
0.0674377307,
-0.2053195983,
-0.9823154211,
0.2154059559,
-0.0737680942,
-0.5257449746,
0.5343056917,
0.0576836467,
-0.5148264766,
0.1310928017,
-0.6295338273,
-0.0916655958,
-0.0269337296,
0.4966339171,
-0.0963456631,
-0.0250982661,
0.0776086748,
-0.0399906784,
0.0891015828,
0.3024742305,
0.1195808724,
0.3417315185,
-0.2084636539,
-0.2358180732,
-0.5836217999,
0.1731402576,
0.6504954696,
0.1913518906,
0.5613095164,
0.5370164514,
-0.2048784643,
0.1695698053,
-0.4788430631,
-0.5501943231,
-0.3787082136,
0.3823521733,
0.3018232882,
-0.6633525491,
0.4408898056,
-0.1820235997,
-0.1398534775,
0.3975934088,
0.2105122954,
-0.0477874242,
1.0544770956,
0.6570394039,
0.1001577452,
0.3256258667,
0.0392850265,
0.1118398532,
-0.6744498014,
-0.4526486099,
-0.522426486,
-0.1992388815,
-0.442943871,
-0.4710699618,
0.5598191619,
0.1674907207,
-0.2040312737,
-0.1540853083,
-0.8267921805,
0.6633158326,
0.4096402824,
0.2934838235,
0.6590451002,
0.0556034967,
0.3795233667,
-0.03109123,
-0.3360261619,
-0.7471872568,
0.9563077688,
0.4778657556,
1.0442156792,
-0.4190019965,
0.61332196,
0.477011621,
0.4987706542,
-0.7738490105,
0.0225009248,
0.1350398362,
-0.4612874389,
-0.2680940926,
-0.3531066477,
-0.8971936107,
0.0406859107,
-0.3438049853,
-0.8365215063,
0.302516222,
0.3595204651,
-0.2423616797,
0.1293832809,
-0.6680912971,
0.4140156806,
-0.176555261,
-0.3032947779,
-0.2690071166,
-0.6811106205,
0.5418063402,
-0.2726109922,
0.3708873987,
-0.1648825556,
0.3390391767,
0.9178657532,
0.1797307283,
1.1698005199,
-0.110621959,
-0.0201945771,
0.0008283659,
0.2270961553,
0.5863924623,
0.3963897824,
0.1747832894,
0.2231594473,
0.3417479098,
-0.3311783373,
-0.3266667724,
0.6127904058,
-0.7241201997,
-0.634055078,
-0.5224430561,
-0.8153560162,
-0.2438771874,
0.2065687627,
0.4787096977,
0.3289416134,
-0.2923341393,
-0.0059923031,
0.5613152385,
0.1417294294,
0.0966815278,
0.5811280608,
-0.0018736592,
0.1775613278,
0.6179360747,
0.3040012419,
0.1579453647,
-0.0437536314,
0.2955807149,
0.1107657552,
-0.647416532,
0.2284175158,
0.2555820644,
-0.4193059802,
-0.3980587423,
-0.365575403,
0.0258711949,
-0.518273294,
-0.0394581556,
-0.5463892221,
-0.340054065,
-0.7084158063,
0.0688009784,
0.1297062635,
0.9746196866,
-0.4243614972,
0.2066376358,
-0.6830605865,
0.4855125248,
-0.0633364245,
0.3554779887,
-0.0871304572,
-0.4307483733,
-0.2878590822,
0.6907324791,
-0.5192437172,
-0.8238015771,
0.4068528712,
0.019797001,
0.2503176033,
0.6379162669,
0.234734565,
0.7435492873,
-0.4208804667,
0.7002155185,
0.2313475311,
-0.8618107438,
0.5939998031,
-0.305108577,
0.0300057512,
0.452483654,
0.483243525,
-0.6192432642,
-0.5777561069,
-0.7490516901,
-0.6201320887,
0.56976825,
0.0264652781,
0.0116898334,
-0.0641405359,
0.2159000039,
0.3097155392,
-0.0714306161,
-0.5073450208,
-0.0793364793,
-0.4344181716,
0.0903038457,
-0.1655368656,
-0.2682093978,
-0.7388843298,
-0.4003998041,
0.3870615661,
-0.1353022009,
0.2464502156,
0.7512905002,
-0.1016094759,
-0.6627643704,
0.2919774354,
0.8175522685,
0.6143645048,
-0.1988820434,
0.5045384765,
-0.2560416758,
-0.6478865743,
-0.1026109606,
0.0260440968,
-0.2714048624,
0.0119170193,
0.3799361289,
0.5558412075,
0.2096586078,
-0.1976443678,
0.3156212568,
0.1123176143,
-0.215478152,
0.0342069305,
0.0170501359,
-0.1505846381,
0.2460732907,
0.5559609532,
0.6812848449,
0.3156946003,
-0.6152601242,
0.1986466348,
0.3585125506,
-0.2424377203,
-0.7756926417,
0.6337409019,
0.0669075027,
0.1041010097,
0.1554209441,
-0.0862704962,
-0.2600684762,
0.3822286427,
0.5935038328,
0.3683258891,
-0.199948743,
0.5443221331,
0.1362342834,
0.4858905971,
-0.6073890328,
-0.2893908024,
0.2333247215,
-0.6627739072,
-0.4760259986,
-0.6024778485,
-0.0662082359,
0.3585635424,
-0.7220806479,
0.0346953645,
-0.1914375871,
-0.2650731504,
0.6438871026,
-0.0683185831,
-0.4034531116,
-0.1386164576,
0.2116122246,
0.8337649703,
-1.3048766851,
0.5663915277,
0.5033275485,
-0.3507196605,
-0.5680220127,
0.2080861181,
0.4646844864,
-0.6461551189,
0.7190574408,
-0.0283346716,
-0.0234510638,
-0.1080208942,
-1.0553650856,
-0.9692341089,
0.7043834329,
0.3632784784,
-0.4949561357,
-0.0034396732,
0.3982795477,
0.6082732081,
-0.1717345417,
0.1295078248,
0.7453250289,
0.8771079779,
0.121071808,
-1.2961615324,
0.1482367367,
0.1461719126,
-0.3023035228,
0.2956216335,
-0.5206020474,
0.6776837707,
-0.2301219106,
-0.1411579698,
-0.2533465922,
0.474952966,
-0.0939862281,
0.7573122382,
0.170511812,
0.2062308937,
0.8520652652,
-0.12851803,
0.6416457891,
0.0195528734,
0.4067728817,
0.9512839913,
0.1377099454,
0.3587078452,
0.9094880223,
0.0445018336,
0.0494249202,
0.6309971809,
-0.4084612429,
0.4842895567,
0.2162933946,
-0.1173687428,
-0.0098837484,
-0.470554471,
-0.3527546525,
0.4001748562,
0.6614842415,
-0.4065442085,
-0.5133445263,
0.1745177358,
0.2866767049,
0.0531372465,
-0.5774002075,
0.3995480537,
0.1186268106,
-0.4646492302,
0.5519827604,
-0.0301848687,
0.8200244904,
-0.1820594817,
0.0147198047,
-0.0604597665,
0.0149734356,
-0.6926535368,
-0.8675785661,
0.799554646,
-0.0291032773,
-0.4140380323,
-0.167083621,
0.7283632755,
-0.355091691,
-0.1761295497,
-0.1125210822,
0.1987542361,
0.1739762127,
-0.3092311323,
-0.4324100018,
0.2439004928,
0.1004472375,
-0.3149011731,
0.3876995444,
0.3994783759,
-0.2133111209,
0.4776087999,
0.3887375295,
0.3536927998,
-0.0650287643,
-0.1607337445,
0.8259773254,
-0.4199417233,
-0.032059405,
-0.6182017326,
0.1852119118,
-0.1808987111,
-0.3039934933,
0.9685171843,
0.482881099,
0.7432389855,
-0.2285540253,
0.6441023946,
0.0256024748,
0.289611131,
-0.3002119362,
0.6897307634,
-0.2491174191,
0.2126581818,
-0.1403827369,
-0.5318866968,
-0.6266586781,
0.4061467946,
-0.4532979429,
-0.2492025942,
0.7611154914,
0.5203901529,
-0.1659031063,
0.1578605324,
-0.0077786082,
0.8052197695,
0.3546280265,
0.0730973855,
0.6031020284,
-0.2270337194,
0.2756452262,
-0.3699039221,
-0.2429692894,
-0.5105379224,
-0.913428843,
-0.689917326,
-0.5288459063,
-0.5216949582,
-0.502797246,
-0.0223189611,
0.5474197268,
0.4187947512,
-0.7875427604,
0.2741611004,
-0.4010724127,
0.0708199367,
-0.1122662425,
-0.2932763696,
0.4657754004,
-0.2890923917,
-0.5110918283,
0.1281203479,
0.0961944088,
0.2471205294,
-0.1137286276,
0.3139815629,
0.2081821263,
0.2308437675,
0.5645510554,
0.4571498632,
-0.7311740518,
-0.5552147627,
-0.3430874944,
-0.1557245553,
0.0580018945,
0.7408106923,
-0.699770093,
0.3426121473,
0.3546596467,
0.0840924382,
0.3978430033,
0.1009016484,
0.2306066751,
-0.7651335597,
0.0369261503,
0.4136278033,
0.0121056745,
0.3729572892,
-0.6626716852,
0.381464541,
0.3513519764,
-0.8107226491,
-1.1037230492,
-0.1310993582,
-1.0253111124,
-0.5111346841,
1.0341191292,
0.3061367571,
-0.2830395699,
-0.2475690544,
-0.24583444,
0.3709990978,
-0.4360921085,
1.426546216,
0.6661989093,
-0.5987306237,
0.2697256207,
-0.5923883319,
0.8017880917,
0.1088632196,
-0.6870414615,
0.3375248611,
0.5843898654,
0.4085233212,
0.5275468826,
0.2024463266,
-0.1610956043,
0.1636158377,
0.0111532882,
-0.1390639842,
-0.3129530549,
-0.2827418149,
-0.0960569829,
-0.0558677949,
-0.1340557784,
0.1726108193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12374v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12374v2
|
Sequoia: Scalable, Robust, and Hardware-aware Speculative Decoding
| 2024-02-19T18:58:32 | 2024-02-29T18:48:38 |
Zhuoming Chen, Avner May, Ruslan Svirschevski, Yuhsun Huang, Max Ryabinin, Zhihao Jia, Beidi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the usage of large language models (LLMs) grows, performing efficient
inference with these models becomes increasingly important. While speculative
decoding has recently emerged as a promising direction for speeding up
inference, existing methods are limited in their ability to scale to larger
speculation budgets, and adapt to different hyperparameters and hardware. This
paper introduces Sequoia, a scalable, robust, and hardware-aware algorithm for
speculative decoding. To attain better scalability, Sequoia introduces a
dynamic programming algorithm to find the optimal tree structure for the
speculated tokens. To achieve robust speculative performance, Sequoia uses a
novel sampling and verification method that outperforms prior work across
different decoding temperatures. Finally, Sequoia introduces a hardware-aware
tree optimizer that maximizes speculative performance by automatically
selecting the token tree size and depth for a given hardware platform.
Evaluation shows that Sequoia improves the decoding speed of Llama2-7B,
Llama2-13B, and Vicuna-33B on an A100 by up to $4.04\times$, $3.73\times$, and
$2.27\times$. For offloading setting on L40, Sequoia achieves as low as 0.56
s/token for exact Llama2-70B inference latency, which is $9.96\times$ on our
optimized offloading system (5.6 s/token), $9.7\times$ than
DeepSpeed-Zero-Inference, $19.5\times$ than Huggingface Accelerate.
|
[
0.0814639106,
-0.8822176456,
0.3787003756,
0.6274098754,
-0.4665598273,
0.5976526141,
0.2477685064,
-0.7991571426,
0.6887218952,
0.4380255044,
-0.5340492129,
-0.2916314304,
-0.4481338263,
-0.1119578332,
-0.5618426204,
0.4376614988,
0.0476383269,
-0.3941097856,
0.0839740857,
0.0184065793,
-0.0845137611,
-0.5224325657,
-0.5791168809,
0.3878538013,
0.1155287027,
0.2656507194,
0.6663629413,
0.9132062197,
0.2736742795,
0.3401694894,
-0.3829220831,
0.1669510007,
-0.5150185227,
0.6159681082,
0.3090973198,
-0.506267786,
-0.3251790702,
-0.802791059,
0.6362071633,
0.2555729747,
-0.2889609933,
0.3457353711,
-0.3248303235,
0.2230989486,
-0.7368801236,
-0.1230592877,
-1.0485229492,
0.1462111324,
-0.6138395667,
-0.7508432865,
-0.477291733,
-0.2234602869,
-0.2967714071,
-0.9030272365,
0.2929774523,
0.534548521,
0.658544898,
0.5298112631,
-0.4405705333,
0.0309498683,
-0.4759714603,
0.8340275884,
-0.7215250731,
0.2353859544,
0.4581136405,
0.152183488,
-0.1127121225,
-0.7213343978,
-0.3672947288,
0.1593040526,
0.2611283362,
-0.062557213,
-0.2754637897,
0.0886624306,
0.4132978916,
0.5047796369,
-0.3201413155,
0.3648063242,
0.0371541344,
-0.6730447412,
0.274207592,
0.299793452,
0.0801627785,
-0.2614912391,
-0.0322382934,
0.0684226528,
-0.6610480547,
0.0162075702,
0.3178333044,
-0.1427697241,
0.0939747989,
0.3146878779,
-0.2960436642,
0.1839249581,
0.0432627648,
-0.0161921382,
0.235117808,
-0.328530848,
-0.380669117,
0.3896639049,
0.4379730523,
0.1778234094,
-0.7186098099,
-0.3250400424,
-0.2281540036,
0.2571825385,
-0.1271356195,
-1.0733168125,
-0.0825762227,
0.4344117641,
-0.5812270045,
-0.5428515077,
-0.5749399662,
-0.7724025249,
-0.3820620477,
0.3309170306,
-0.0267943237,
-0.4090899825,
-0.38665241,
0.2746126354,
-0.2443547398,
0.2302921563,
0.3335517943,
-1.3402067423,
0.3985966146,
0.8056176901,
0.8133091331,
-0.1286816299,
0.0059644585,
-0.6838524342,
0.3387442827,
-0.5133278966,
0.663087368,
-0.4997668862,
-0.3838810623,
-0.2626559436,
-0.019277934,
0.2974251807,
-0.0674056411,
0.8679767251,
-0.8360034823,
-0.4665095508,
-0.4921681881,
-0.3622794449,
-0.2195816934,
0.167875737,
-0.6585009694,
1.2252585888,
-0.0792963654,
-1.2349683046,
0.4416106045,
-0.2088056356,
-0.6524906754,
0.2327668369,
-0.1543332189,
-0.0559287369,
0.470113337,
0.517478466,
0.31978634,
-0.4504096806,
0.2002491206,
-0.476439029,
-0.9168375731,
0.010575369,
-0.7878439426,
0.7744265795,
0.4926292598,
-0.4452468753,
0.009233404,
-0.6173014641,
0.1577979922,
0.1283807755,
-0.0793697387,
-0.2982058525,
0.0705773681,
0.0019527706,
-0.5675712228,
0.2996344268,
-0.6567081213,
0.1072925702,
-0.5672776103,
0.7590672374,
0.8628409505,
-0.0837474689,
0.1185831502,
0.1791111678,
0.6766974926,
-0.0872904733,
-0.0246688537,
-0.5104677677,
-0.0404945984,
-0.7572392225,
-0.2854382396,
0.1988825947,
0.3892072141,
-0.8314381838,
0.1711652577,
0.0812325627,
-0.4192245007,
-0.5826899409,
-0.2594462037,
0.1655141115,
0.3534685373,
0.1818504184,
-0.060137786,
-0.8593512774,
-0.5764244199,
-0.2924533784,
-0.2603645027,
0.577695787,
0.3667633533,
0.1533720642,
-0.3639412522,
0.3366699219,
-0.3860708773,
0.5462701917,
0.1682191938,
0.0690152943,
0.6069777012,
0.5200847387,
0.4569965303,
-0.2411092371,
-0.2177794278,
0.4439676106,
-0.5631872416,
0.1537682861,
-0.2098922729,
-0.1685905904,
0.4508933425,
0.612321794,
-0.6201403141,
0.356161654,
0.763194263,
-0.417042017,
0.6810703278,
-0.3976955116,
0.2150548548,
-1.100468874,
0.0773120448,
-0.5517188311,
-0.3090134561,
-0.0826792046,
0.2530459464,
-0.018041499,
0.2380381674,
-0.117414251,
0.0842286646,
-0.477035135,
-0.3446794748,
-0.1155327931,
-0.567809999,
0.0194060765,
0.1889469326,
0.0738245845,
1.0326880217,
0.7787255049,
-0.2191993147,
0.2064909041,
-0.245587036,
-0.4615489542,
-0.0804031268,
-0.7660719752,
0.2505227327,
-0.0703328922,
0.2961447537,
-0.7290626764,
-0.2317165732,
0.0900516957,
-0.1619142145,
0.0614556894,
-0.0860701129,
-0.5021314025,
-0.4004180431,
-0.4079374671,
0.7430458069,
0.4526285231,
-0.6728509665,
0.6314323545,
0.4565666616,
0.0535843484,
-1.0149163008,
-0.9009934664,
0.2625960112,
-0.2718968689,
-0.5307599902,
0.5921266079,
0.1215796024,
0.03060963,
0.1514409184,
-0.2896700203,
-0.1331086755,
0.3077457547,
0.4768885672,
0.2056394368,
-0.4522540271,
-0.1373291463,
0.6570500135,
-0.1598785669,
0.1110235676,
-0.552028358,
0.4385849535,
-0.3703503907,
-0.320689857,
-0.4103304148,
0.2619051337,
0.6570023894,
-0.0740758404,
0.3582378924,
0.5989325643,
-0.2561783195,
-0.3065305948,
-0.6211143136,
-0.1274631023,
-0.5737675428,
0.4911975861,
-0.7518599629,
-1.2103562355,
0.4941969514,
-0.1881349981,
0.1417012215,
0.4660581052,
0.3235222995,
-0.0127936881,
0.9439344406,
0.4638203382,
-0.1649398059,
0.2112718672,
-0.3127884269,
0.0917924419,
-0.6136085391,
-0.2505125403,
-0.5902432203,
-0.2572370172,
-0.3951233029,
-0.8540480137,
-0.0884674191,
0.0937146768,
-0.2290714532,
0.317273587,
-0.6498842239,
0.7079495192,
0.4327911139,
-0.204502508,
0.453548193,
0.4753662348,
-0.3272975981,
-0.1303654611,
-0.6870247722,
-0.108893171,
0.7745602131,
0.6668106914,
0.9987379909,
0.109287031,
0.6632745266,
0.4147205651,
-0.1881555915,
-0.647213161,
0.489890784,
-0.0565576926,
-0.5350299478,
-0.2456583381,
-0.400806576,
-0.651607573,
0.1920168698,
-0.093089506,
-0.8574302793,
0.2979548872,
0.3559024334,
-0.497662276,
0.407042563,
-0.4442685544,
0.4481467605,
-0.409666419,
-0.4211507738,
-0.7278111577,
-0.2963350415,
0.5505979657,
-0.0335832462,
-0.0884873271,
-0.1788696349,
-0.1239008084,
0.6708881855,
-0.5054970384,
0.7335451841,
-0.1347388327,
0.1926645339,
0.2678262591,
0.4531217813,
0.8183817863,
0.3670665026,
-0.4718907475,
0.0847768262,
0.8020685315,
-0.4405066073,
-0.2857900262,
0.7689922452,
-1.03469491,
-0.6050847769,
-0.7554889321,
-0.4138640463,
-0.118768394,
0.2977776527,
0.4170527458,
0.4615834951,
-0.2823033929,
0.4241771698,
0.6481618285,
-0.10246104,
0.5169599056,
0.3582600057,
-0.4450591803,
-0.255353272,
1.0714787245,
-0.165643841,
-0.2435906976,
0.5201103091,
-0.044840578,
-0.4224974215,
-0.9728487134,
-0.5507055521,
0.0411229394,
-0.4752078056,
-0.3189472854,
-0.8116342425,
-0.2227831334,
-0.2266194969,
-0.1428477168,
-0.4254432321,
-0.6432682276,
-0.3978813589,
-0.2297765911,
0.5764047503,
0.4944027662,
0.0466646552,
0.4500749707,
-0.575889647,
0.0305195991,
-0.0261019412,
0.0580587648,
0.3191921711,
-0.636743784,
-0.1127831787,
-0.2725329995,
0.1113221496,
-0.5900672674,
0.3918453157,
-0.1495524943,
0.3399802446,
0.6252864003,
0.2188440263,
1.0253932476,
-0.0497659892,
0.4714905918,
0.1557985842,
-1.2106394768,
0.2012215257,
-0.1932428628,
0.3107579947,
0.6320191026,
-0.0683460161,
-0.5727998614,
-0.1153772622,
-0.4307007492,
-0.8480007648,
0.9142502546,
-0.1447805315,
0.1844737381,
0.0621136576,
0.1874200255,
0.2424305528,
0.0681161284,
-0.2516697645,
0.079309091,
-0.3610791862,
0.0255254786,
0.1758275628,
-0.6673567891,
0.1746590286,
-0.2751327753,
0.5828265548,
-0.3168030977,
0.2095016539,
0.073615171,
0.0695164651,
-0.1403384954,
0.1491841376,
0.0473960489,
0.1481419653,
-0.4369448721,
0.4316029549,
0.4272675216,
-0.5432606936,
-0.0165445488,
0.0421446636,
-0.476939857,
-0.0720073581,
0.348821491,
1.1267031431,
0.1905221641,
-0.7492530942,
0.1366022676,
-0.420180887,
-0.2299429774,
-0.1635395437,
0.0445257388,
0.1470578313,
0.273332417,
0.2196010351,
0.4398833215,
0.4812635183,
-0.3705413342,
-0.1552287787,
0.4988610148,
-0.032366734,
-0.4819782376,
0.6768071651,
0.3606893718,
0.0683285221,
0.5920068026,
-0.231500566,
-0.3195732534,
0.7581259012,
0.9313295484,
0.894035399,
0.1320988685,
0.2845355868,
0.3061342239,
0.3397600353,
-0.1262551695,
0.6082942486,
-0.5643908978,
-0.6260670424,
-0.6048668623,
-0.9519045353,
-0.3232558966,
-0.3303902149,
-0.3912871182,
-0.1005076393,
-0.8482519388,
-0.1937498599,
-0.2043771893,
0.122678481,
-0.5274511576,
-0.1118194163,
-0.07972458,
1.2483603954,
-0.3706156909,
1.1405556202,
0.1838804036,
0.4063633382,
-1.0833191872,
0.0391957574,
-0.0180562139,
-1.0100456476,
0.271105051,
0.2296904624,
-0.5158485174,
0.1650095582,
-0.0890789628,
-1.2827492952,
1.2285490036,
0.5426595211,
-0.8433126807,
-0.1310670376,
-0.3101989329,
0.2693311572,
-0.1601755172,
0.5848695636,
0.6423113346,
0.248750478,
0.7406021953,
-0.4641560912,
0.3154433966,
-0.2449572533,
0.0908669233,
0.1648947597,
-0.6962649226,
0.5843816996,
-0.3427453041,
-0.357152164,
0.4464522898,
0.8236787915,
0.1891119629,
0.2805321217,
0.4409098625,
0.5309821963,
1.434238553,
0.0864995047,
0.9954376221,
-0.6344847083,
0.0295421313,
0.8298609853,
-0.177516669,
1.0858318806,
0.5441839695,
-0.2102181166,
0.4081021249,
0.8609095216,
0.2160803974,
0.4675444663,
-0.1878979653,
-0.3798015416,
-0.3811745048,
-0.4099688232,
-0.6592008471,
0.3423333466,
0.5792953372,
-0.2364712805,
0.2359523028,
-0.6463984847,
-0.1002722308,
-0.4654062092,
-0.2387482822,
0.1432048529,
0.0077039576,
-0.7230342031,
0.6304955482,
0.2954185903,
0.7997089028,
-0.5704673529,
0.384917587,
-0.1544974148,
0.121728234,
-0.4174531698,
-0.4747281671,
0.4287287593,
-0.1476722211,
-0.0763267204,
0.0159373526,
0.8395527005,
0.0026052026,
-0.6130650043,
0.0468184426,
0.0224233251,
0.2039396465,
0.1352329105,
-0.5000267029,
1.0027508736,
0.2295371294,
-0.1310659945,
-0.06955152,
0.5234742761,
-0.1207813397,
0.5928694606,
0.9149147272,
0.1446623206,
0.0848579705,
-0.0825793222,
0.9966127276,
-0.8196953535,
-0.8126966953,
-0.7024315,
0.0569961704,
-0.1599845439,
-0.2876928449,
0.9582955837,
0.5664778948,
0.1689072549,
0.2093017697,
0.5922884941,
-0.0848441795,
0.141791895,
-0.5234279633,
0.2357756048,
-0.3122557402,
0.6061102748,
-0.0593525618,
-0.7105832696,
-0.0192748047,
0.2859583795,
-0.1450089067,
-0.2965114415,
0.6276245117,
0.9889355302,
-0.0063641621,
0.5312682986,
0.1262854785,
0.5011912584,
0.173308,
0.6261561513,
0.9261353016,
-0.3016916811,
0.4478342235,
-0.0580204986,
-0.2280333042,
-0.4142026603,
-0.9328980446,
-0.6259613037,
-0.1097016558,
-0.0731736794,
-0.3899172246,
0.1326968372,
0.5924278498,
0.9477936029,
-0.6875142455,
-0.1439914107,
-0.3517516851,
0.0885811523,
-0.1807779074,
-0.1543243676,
0.4049523771,
-0.1090070009,
-0.3923838139,
0.6048650742,
0.6228738427,
-0.0580172017,
-0.3509790599,
-0.3535401821,
0.3918043375,
0.278943032,
0.5601852536,
0.5246049762,
-0.7969378233,
0.0851026997,
0.3276646137,
0.018770311,
-0.3055431843,
0.8894180655,
-0.892326653,
0.3631846309,
0.6657720804,
1.1023671627,
1.1473325491,
-0.0402007401,
0.3758168817,
-0.2892381847,
0.529735148,
0.4828795493,
0.3141691089,
0.0334940106,
-0.6569205523,
0.1422963291,
0.3404521644,
-0.4800288379,
-0.9988655448,
0.0251361299,
-0.9222024083,
-0.383025229,
0.834102571,
-0.00386114,
-0.6809609532,
0.0466374345,
-0.3559049964,
-0.2265230566,
-0.6398662925,
0.4963121712,
0.393822521,
0.006142138,
-0.3247210085,
-0.0520947836,
0.4142620564,
0.7625155449,
-0.6135463119,
0.1561490148,
0.3874117434,
-0.0609255396,
-0.1452530622,
0.9115267396,
0.1082173288,
0.3306913972,
0.7564693093,
-0.4882498085,
-0.033140514,
-0.2935069799,
0.0375195034,
0.31843853,
0.5102282166,
-0.071753405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12372v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12372v2
|
HunFlair2 in a cross-corpus evaluation of biomedical named entity recognition and normalization tools
| 2024-02-19T18:58:18 | 2024-02-20T13:10:27 |
Mario Sänger, Samuele Garda, Xing David Wang, Leon Weber-Genzel, Pia Droop, Benedikt Fuchs, Alan Akbik, Ulf Leser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the exponential growth of the life science literature, biomedical text
mining (BTM) has become an essential technology for accelerating the extraction
of insights from publications. Identifying named entities (e.g., diseases,
drugs, or genes) in texts and their linkage to reference knowledge bases are
crucial steps in BTM pipelines to enable information aggregation from different
documents. However, tools for these two steps are rarely applied in the same
context in which they were developed. Instead, they are applied in the wild,
i.e., on application-dependent text collections different from those used for
the tools' training, varying, e.g., in focus, genre, style, and text type. This
raises the question of whether the reported performance of BTM tools can be
trusted for downstream applications. Here, we report on the results of a
carefully designed cross-corpus benchmark for named entity extraction, where
tools were applied systematically to corpora not used during their training.
Based on a survey of 28 published systems, we selected five for an in-depth
analysis on three publicly available corpora encompassing four different entity
types. Comparison between tools results in a mixed picture and shows that, in a
cross-corpus setting, the performance is significantly lower than the one
reported in an in-corpus setting. HunFlair2 showed the best performance on
average, being closely followed by PubTator. Our results indicate that users of
BTM tools should expect diminishing performances when applying them in the wild
compared to original publications and show that further research is necessary
to make BTM tools more robust.
|
[
-0.1939612776,
-0.6126309037,
0.2012946159,
0.2069314867,
-0.2706214786,
0.193532005,
-0.1971871108,
-0.9746869206,
0.1859281659,
0.5188110471,
-0.105752632,
-0.6025756001,
-0.7259027958,
0.4844335616,
-0.5403795242,
1.1141250134,
0.0191567522,
-0.0577259026,
-0.4921318293,
-0.3497683406,
-0.1932095885,
-0.3558376133,
-0.4984957576,
-0.3229673207,
0.7773364782,
0.1921476722,
0.6943019629,
0.5024597049,
0.8954957724,
0.1500667185,
-0.2659816444,
0.0986075848,
-0.352856189,
0.2024466544,
-0.4042071998,
-0.2974799275,
-0.3079140186,
-0.1053143665,
0.6183291078,
0.7728618979,
0.2062230259,
0.1563208401,
0.190207988,
0.6031027436,
-0.7460915446,
0.0053930925,
-0.5442602634,
0.0836461335,
-0.5806734562,
-0.1763251126,
-0.1996364594,
-0.3285983205,
0.4280542433,
-0.559709549,
0.3257938325,
0.0877523571,
1.1325541735,
0.1529115885,
-0.4239703417,
-0.2993429899,
-0.6983535886,
0.6960073113,
-0.625240922,
0.5571337938,
0.2137865424,
0.1863297373,
-0.2703081369,
-0.9622604251,
-0.0994305313,
0.1277166456,
-0.2976464331,
0.1354653835,
-0.4044945836,
0.0500900261,
0.2595403492,
0.2261721194,
-0.5799889565,
0.2906731367,
-0.5233044028,
-0.6449013352,
0.4473661482,
-0.1842281669,
0.0068051317,
-0.2747681737,
-0.5898262858,
-0.0257747918,
-0.7193874121,
0.2605882287,
0.0210591443,
0.1647485644,
0.0614370257,
0.6310560703,
0.0068213143,
0.4428561032,
-0.1112662032,
-0.1985470951,
0.3396261036,
-0.2797064781,
-0.4204379618,
0.3347895741,
0.7305507064,
0.1947351545,
0.0840617195,
-0.5530168414,
-0.1582058966,
-0.0856555849,
0.2514986992,
-1.0788785219,
-0.2637005746,
0.3477561772,
-0.4652301967,
-0.388194859,
-0.0290866289,
-0.9807882905,
-0.4248876274,
0.0635613725,
0.3822907805,
-0.4401097894,
-0.2363568246,
-0.380667001,
-0.4757606089,
0.1280839443,
0.0793704987,
-0.631919682,
0.3580130339,
0.7636429667,
0.7713548541,
-0.5511469841,
-0.1017028019,
-0.692682147,
0.1996951252,
-0.387650162,
1.0390483141,
-0.5577394366,
-0.6972612143,
0.0270245243,
0.0702253655,
-0.0774921253,
-1.0015348196,
0.6585969925,
-0.6140829325,
0.061220251,
-0.3925602436,
-0.8620477915,
-0.1376623064,
-0.0831405073,
-0.7885752916,
1.2117881775,
0.3052799404,
-1.1431373358,
0.7668780684,
-0.5095716715,
-0.4982615709,
0.2446586192,
-0.2674946487,
-0.5743266344,
-0.0520909838,
-0.060095787,
0.4424867928,
-0.2412411869,
0.0871596634,
-0.6697639823,
-0.4966666698,
0.2006309181,
0.0203188788,
0.8376891613,
0.1187639683,
-0.5008493066,
-0.0599634051,
-0.6185527444,
0.0687867478,
-0.3318266273,
-0.39829427,
-0.719021976,
-0.1899227351,
0.411106199,
0.1295715868,
-0.1270709783,
-0.7128360868,
-0.1139497012,
-0.5276812315,
0.1966810077,
0.3401246965,
0.1906254143,
0.3238601387,
-0.2096652538,
0.3936374485,
0.1560337543,
-0.1225179955,
0.2283452302,
-0.6831836104,
-0.357724607,
-0.4958492517,
0.8328567147,
0.4952148497,
-0.383672148,
0.4347120225,
-0.2981694937,
-0.6389668584,
-0.4140478075,
0.271681577,
0.3586643636,
0.5764334798,
0.4960720241,
-0.1994713396,
-0.7720604539,
-1.0389758348,
-0.7260716558,
-0.0911645219,
-0.0761859044,
0.3789046407,
0.4944253862,
-0.7969619632,
1.0968216658,
-0.0863347277,
-0.1157656386,
0.0834798068,
0.3055798411,
-0.2281257212,
0.4032229185,
0.6374872923,
-0.7996715903,
-0.2577367723,
0.1206804961,
-0.7010378242,
-0.3032308519,
0.160839662,
-0.3676054776,
0.3078450859,
0.4485381246,
-0.4330678582,
0.6436833739,
0.5233637691,
-0.2431873083,
0.463173002,
-0.032632973,
-0.0712407231,
-0.8125700951,
0.6027824283,
0.0167045426,
-0.2957996726,
-0.4608563185,
-0.1927473545,
0.177234292,
0.1099093258,
-0.3909989297,
0.9164113998,
-0.5071538091,
-0.2025724053,
-0.3346000612,
0.026196491,
0.1920513809,
-0.0539036915,
0.1726893485,
0.603015244,
0.4413461983,
-0.6553768516,
0.1101501137,
0.1888622195,
-0.3162083328,
0.4828501046,
-0.5923309326,
-0.0288321227,
0.1495440006,
0.1615480036,
-0.6486612558,
-0.1806086004,
0.1148438156,
-0.4118946493,
0.3372815549,
0.0566543303,
-0.5412467122,
-0.2219818681,
-0.1998761147,
0.128045544,
0.4112924039,
-0.3798685372,
0.505430758,
0.6075296402,
-0.0273372624,
-0.515999198,
-0.8988402486,
0.0379877798,
-0.318387419,
-0.477499038,
0.7126640677,
0.2403306514,
-0.3085581362,
0.2624467015,
-0.5498094559,
-0.3661057949,
0.1207965612,
0.5328328609,
0.350120157,
-0.134779498,
0.2423190624,
0.5380974412,
0.0567706786,
0.2619530857,
-0.0598498732,
-0.1771417707,
0.1446844041,
0.0349178314,
-0.0738525465,
0.2255117744,
0.383879602,
-0.1611091197,
0.5774583817,
1.0091781616,
-0.8086847663,
0.0604467057,
-0.5174373388,
-0.1048901156,
-0.383469522,
0.1536955088,
-0.1023582667,
-0.8832111955,
0.4475306273,
-0.3691833317,
0.1436396688,
0.6156714559,
0.5538560748,
-0.2619019151,
0.4175297022,
0.6719974875,
0.2006504089,
0.2062421143,
-0.1201861873,
0.0647993311,
-0.7705798745,
-0.4897253811,
-0.7142145634,
-0.4498071969,
-0.7842870355,
-0.3460795283,
0.3513739407,
0.2120539397,
0.185238719,
0.5231781602,
-0.2922183871,
-0.0644119382,
0.5047322512,
-0.0720185265,
0.2149048001,
0.1636797041,
-0.3969035447,
0.0419113301,
-0.5820646882,
-0.5628488064,
1.1906273365,
0.2549931407,
0.3567688465,
-0.1878920048,
0.9388765693,
0.2886459529,
0.6582531333,
-0.7323659658,
0.1684298515,
-0.1250825524,
-1.0813103914,
-0.264959693,
-0.4473196864,
-1.3791177273,
-0.0068968688,
-0.398073405,
-0.6071785092,
0.5573924184,
-0.1823265404,
-0.5628553033,
0.1258276105,
-0.6304420233,
0.8963074088,
-0.0220048018,
-0.294360131,
-0.0612088926,
-0.7044565678,
0.14470312,
-0.4363483191,
0.2281215191,
-0.0855582282,
-0.2609596252,
1.2497104406,
-0.3184497356,
0.3667152822,
-0.1194404587,
0.1253622174,
0.4084929228,
0.0317544378,
0.2148274779,
0.2474432439,
-0.1541693658,
0.6590154767,
0.5600035191,
-0.4953747988,
-0.3204940259,
0.8671057224,
-0.5872796774,
-0.1783429533,
-0.4841626287,
-0.2444775403,
-0.3928358257,
0.5644904971,
0.5383846164,
0.3313710093,
-0.2517805398,
0.4550859332,
0.6265351772,
-0.0987952054,
0.3650437593,
0.3453247845,
-0.2409437299,
-0.4932637811,
0.5389732122,
0.217883572,
-0.0074826847,
0.6401830316,
0.1141176447,
-0.3444164991,
-0.5868545175,
-0.2594442666,
0.0970849767,
-0.3962545693,
-0.4005866945,
-0.8246975541,
-0.1572467387,
-0.6023876071,
0.1255735457,
-0.1556675732,
-0.3491124809,
-0.2156767249,
-0.1521143615,
0.3688398898,
0.3654281497,
-0.0944213793,
-0.0914922655,
-1.0801750422,
0.266928792,
0.1339962333,
0.3464844227,
-0.4539457858,
-0.2707898021,
-0.5821382999,
-0.0450871363,
-0.079736717,
-0.9110446572,
0.2374066263,
0.2594287694,
0.6958709359,
0.4717359245,
0.030221751,
0.6218886971,
-0.2023333162,
0.3824290037,
-0.2876270711,
-0.5462421775,
0.4083345234,
-0.0223801155,
-0.0537015572,
0.7433117628,
0.5020647049,
-0.4286508262,
-0.3021763563,
-0.726775527,
-0.7710193396,
0.4548024535,
0.5632042289,
-0.3949644864,
0.1040332913,
0.4766676724,
0.4060515463,
0.188384071,
-0.1166021675,
-0.3646478057,
-0.0676452368,
0.0167560559,
0.1425041407,
-0.1663591415,
-0.1645978391,
-0.1299758106,
0.5393763781,
0.0678122118,
0.3719982505,
0.5428753495,
-0.1918982565,
-0.1685004085,
0.0880316645,
0.1307062954,
0.3153869212,
-0.4965638816,
0.1180914193,
-0.0260380786,
-0.8099876046,
-0.2615881562,
0.4682462811,
-0.1754641384,
0.4041412771,
0.6298822165,
0.4800664186,
0.4965884089,
-0.8310875297,
0.3353427052,
0.1380371153,
-0.0831911638,
-0.0296049733,
0.0665827245,
-0.0448120683,
0.1529238373,
0.2253856212,
0.4287433624,
0.6005750895,
-0.3862683475,
0.4057034254,
0.3260411024,
-0.6363227367,
-0.3395292461,
0.5599361062,
0.2225977033,
-0.1059600934,
0.3631459773,
-0.1119011492,
-0.1380351335,
0.6064660549,
0.1994352937,
0.9961957932,
0.0597586744,
-0.0014771112,
0.22441037,
0.1475000978,
0.1876202673,
0.106260635,
-0.0089495387,
-0.539552629,
-0.2076213062,
-0.6751331687,
-0.4559782743,
0.10236644,
-0.815733552,
0.4404337704,
-0.1619653553,
-0.5439881682,
0.5154041648,
0.2174529433,
-0.8359749317,
0.2371278852,
0.1878980845,
1.2023351192,
-0.5810256004,
0.9224537611,
1.0666880608,
-0.1048339903,
-0.6193142533,
0.0899129137,
0.133103475,
-0.3051306307,
0.5528420806,
0.2631413937,
0.1169081703,
-0.1795280725,
-0.0735610127,
-0.8040630221,
1.1962747574,
0.204291895,
-0.5890543461,
-0.2448194176,
0.0446149707,
0.7448742986,
-0.1426479816,
0.3617102802,
0.5554760098,
0.6560122371,
-0.065715,
-1.0933896303,
0.0707306564,
-0.3468096852,
0.0598054267,
0.0392691083,
-0.3715034723,
0.3602744639,
-0.1679461002,
-0.3443467319,
0.0063912342,
0.5959975123,
0.24842453,
0.788530767,
0.3709739745,
0.4796793759,
0.8846618533,
0.0327746049,
0.7933731079,
-0.3059022725,
0.3492336273,
0.7208111286,
-0.4080624282,
0.7978083491,
0.5374004841,
-0.2582184672,
0.728843689,
0.7511692643,
0.063993156,
0.4940761328,
-0.0034887975,
0.0071881977,
-0.1653523743,
-0.0087275421,
-0.4846594036,
0.3831282258,
0.4013643861,
-0.4192948341,
-0.3127006292,
0.0598672479,
0.0885846019,
-0.1984787881,
-0.0932522267,
0.6857476234,
0.171812281,
-0.5524784327,
0.4788990319,
0.039785102,
0.6110827327,
-0.3891915679,
0.0978139043,
-0.1069891751,
0.1336426884,
-0.4947108924,
-0.5735808015,
0.6478070021,
0.0733954459,
-0.1637088358,
0.1821608841,
0.9629958272,
-0.1681345701,
-0.4752548635,
0.5106298923,
0.6169874072,
0.2978387773,
-0.1510234624,
-0.6197828054,
-0.0857889727,
-0.3225449622,
-0.2686066926,
0.3998956382,
0.6824341416,
-0.2926040888,
0.4269466102,
0.6628994346,
0.2482958436,
-0.0509328283,
-0.1423104256,
0.7065590024,
-0.7308101654,
-0.1293638498,
-0.6843044162,
0.1091521978,
-0.2077288777,
-0.3905685842,
0.7733951211,
1.0676919222,
0.7521870732,
0.1114798933,
0.7102197409,
0.0032122696,
0.8405163884,
-0.2173534632,
0.7841137052,
-0.4096260071,
0.1372063309,
-0.3165273666,
-0.8300661445,
-0.3790363967,
0.1932755858,
-0.0745069012,
-0.0165341944,
0.9826452732,
0.6693514585,
0.1225309595,
0.0176298376,
0.1035683006,
0.1878349781,
0.2727633715,
0.2825124562,
0.2516252697,
-0.5029842257,
0.683950007,
-0.5151859522,
-0.2159323096,
-0.4346528053,
-0.785715878,
-0.8702379465,
-0.2595913112,
-0.5074338913,
-0.5039141178,
0.2361821532,
0.703918457,
0.7452497482,
-0.9812687635,
0.1263113618,
0.012886961,
0.0798723996,
-0.5149767995,
-0.2236181796,
0.3398670256,
-0.0843002945,
-0.6032895446,
0.2778004408,
0.4670366645,
-0.0623733848,
-0.2053886205,
0.0152043113,
0.0087798899,
0.0926654637,
0.4683323801,
0.4157467186,
-0.6100756526,
-0.0772097632,
0.3520232439,
-0.4666324556,
-0.0302836001,
0.7881700993,
-1.0941735506,
0.3291123807,
0.565502584,
0.8099156618,
0.4466757774,
-0.0740617514,
0.1272895932,
-0.4313595891,
-0.1144739389,
0.4019213915,
0.2887406349,
0.2905756533,
-0.4917568862,
0.5163684487,
0.5999791622,
-0.5994176865,
-0.9498082399,
-0.3061944246,
-1.1697402,
-0.0672334954,
1.3394901752,
-0.1254747659,
-0.29548347,
-0.3343654275,
-0.047660172,
0.4020366371,
-0.494202286,
0.7606072426,
0.6135990024,
-0.3398190439,
0.4182449281,
-0.4111649394,
0.7166154385,
0.2749162614,
-0.8354522586,
-0.1771658808,
0.1861866415,
0.394647032,
0.1918051094,
0.4813858867,
-0.4134320915,
0.396073103,
-0.1485301554,
0.0666140467,
0.0152166178,
-0.2108640075,
-0.1624490768,
-0.0213575922,
-0.1427834779,
0.0352797173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12370v1
|
AnaloBench: Benchmarking the Identification of Abstract and Long-context Analogies
| 2024-02-19T18:56:44 | 2024-02-19T18:56:44 |
Xiao Ye, Andrew Wang, Jacob Choi, Yining Lu, Shreya Sharma, Lingfeng Shen, Vijay Tiyyala, Nicholas Andrews, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans regularly engage in analogical thinking, relating personal experiences
to current situations ($X$ is analogous to $Y$ because of $Z$). Analogical
thinking allows humans to solve problems in creative ways, grasp difficult
concepts, and articulate ideas more effectively. Can language models (LMs) do
the same? To answer this question, we propose ANALOBENCH, a benchmark to
determine analogical reasoning ability in LMs. Our benchmarking approach
focuses on aspects of this ability that are common among humans: (i) recalling
related experiences from a large amount of information, and (ii) applying
analogical reasoning to complex and lengthy scenarios. We test a broad
collection of proprietary models (e.g., GPT family, Claude V2) and open source
models such as LLaMA2. As in prior results, scaling up LMs results in some
performance boosts. Surprisingly, scale offers minimal gains when, (i)
analogies involve lengthy scenarios, or (ii) recalling relevant scenarios from
a large pool of information, a process analogous to finding a needle in a
haystack. We hope these observations encourage further research in this field.
|
[
-0.3370867372,
-0.576516211,
0.6610742807,
-0.1665432602,
-0.1664790809,
0.0791232213,
-0.2017462254,
-0.6387683153,
0.0406893715,
0.2287548482,
-0.3207108378,
-0.3205517232,
-0.1051834822,
0.1009428725,
-0.5838066339,
0.6081959009,
-0.0828964487,
-0.0551344678,
-0.098284319,
-0.4650483727,
-0.5193297863,
-0.4137195647,
-0.7821868062,
-0.4095010161,
0.3398244083,
-0.0666953772,
0.7839318514,
0.9488759637,
0.2162331343,
0.3484050035,
-0.1583272964,
-0.1751678288,
-0.4006345272,
0.1091753542,
-0.5761139989,
-0.6522280574,
-0.2422307432,
-0.0114414915,
0.5330659747,
1.0082046986,
-0.3322809935,
0.3249332905,
-0.1276930422,
0.5400215983,
-0.8910224438,
-0.0752943009,
-0.8598419428,
-0.1518849432,
0.0389288962,
0.0354764089,
-0.1484630853,
-0.6361023188,
-0.0093484158,
-0.7748642564,
-0.0429812744,
0.3511355519,
0.7109706998,
0.1355413198,
-0.2198959291,
-0.4933207631,
-0.8327015638,
0.5920749307,
-0.9387129545,
0.4406526089,
0.4050393105,
0.3510239124,
-0.0136104291,
-0.8456038237,
-0.6237564683,
-0.2636014521,
-0.2920113206,
-0.0628965497,
-0.4543930292,
-0.1372890472,
0.3691888452,
0.2269509584,
-0.7688769698,
0.1959499419,
-0.5709638,
0.1933850497,
0.4366553426,
0.3881991208,
0.0262320638,
0.0061778566,
-0.3546219468,
-0.1908973455,
-0.688477397,
0.1810273826,
0.320589602,
0.0162355229,
0.0900677592,
0.2096095979,
-0.2751372159,
0.6611827612,
-0.0821920335,
0.1911999881,
0.2817787528,
-0.1292011738,
0.0257356167,
-0.0860854164,
0.5403003693,
0.5893903971,
0.375279367,
-0.2778971195,
-0.340714395,
0.2210936546,
0.4333398938,
-0.6776625514,
-0.2581270635,
0.1991525739,
-0.4002751708,
-0.0329944938,
-0.1018709391,
-0.7358694077,
-0.6144995093,
-0.4317749441,
0.7161813974,
-0.5234878063,
-0.2472471893,
0.110310629,
-0.1771259159,
0.0584339611,
0.0079767462,
-0.8138042688,
0.879511416,
0.8951719403,
0.8213741779,
-0.0983689725,
-0.3737441897,
-0.2907659411,
-0.0750262216,
-0.649222374,
1.0815391541,
-0.6237334013,
-0.3131563663,
0.0192527734,
-0.3829908073,
-0.0107311876,
-1.2300390005,
0.5776070356,
-0.2146299481,
-0.1707808524,
-0.144756794,
-0.7463516593,
-0.1863358468,
0.3656468987,
-0.7229598761,
1.1678321362,
0.0321916826,
-0.6656063795,
0.1484720111,
-0.3250374794,
-0.098237142,
-0.0496818312,
-0.4219478369,
-0.1505306065,
0.339586556,
-0.0408109426,
0.1200703084,
-0.6864153147,
0.1779200286,
-0.4460392892,
-0.6627551913,
0.4805139303,
0.0318106264,
0.643824935,
0.1731657982,
-0.2485524565,
0.1157152951,
-0.6978054047,
0.2566712499,
0.1867062151,
0.0974057913,
-0.9150054455,
0.0423979759,
-0.2186077237,
0.1867092699,
-0.0512590483,
-0.4063810706,
0.1685923636,
-0.4738078117,
0.4392326474,
0.6771305203,
-0.104340829,
0.1090424061,
-0.6055229902,
0.6073479056,
-0.1579325199,
-0.3176267147,
-0.4358871877,
0.0148881432,
-0.6559802294,
-0.2997712791,
0.4086515605,
0.4055965543,
-0.3791400194,
0.387737751,
-0.3136396408,
-0.6341575384,
-0.6098842025,
-0.0141048273,
0.4110569358,
0.44173491,
0.1572365165,
-0.4506528676,
-0.5945719481,
-1.1945011616,
-0.5968279243,
-0.4162499309,
-0.576281786,
0.2580946088,
0.5807543993,
0.0763764977,
0.9596754313,
-0.5532458425,
-0.1762032956,
0.1004953086,
0.4635933936,
0.3009884953,
-0.0199548155,
0.5136141777,
-0.5407979488,
-0.2406772375,
0.0295097567,
-0.8136206269,
-0.5208634138,
-0.1245117784,
0.1079251915,
-0.1770909876,
0.860188365,
-0.5475617051,
0.3320104778,
0.3820468187,
-0.3039761484,
0.8012317419,
-0.2829697728,
0.0200333223,
-0.769875288,
0.6810264587,
-0.0567012504,
-0.0584846251,
-0.45471856,
0.3072930574,
0.2445114553,
-0.1375444531,
-0.3555945456,
0.9982968569,
-0.4554747045,
-0.1262757778,
-0.263890177,
0.2487453818,
-0.1123525798,
0.4301161766,
0.0704764351,
0.8654687405,
0.3232872486,
-0.438855201,
0.2689961195,
-0.2503625751,
-0.6860673428,
0.9205304384,
-0.8107433319,
0.1167715192,
-0.0488332808,
0.4693067968,
-1.0478153229,
0.1968975067,
-0.1002297774,
-0.109341979,
-0.1778000891,
0.188264519,
-0.7409548759,
-0.4083316326,
-0.4812783599,
0.7218676805,
0.6320863962,
-0.4404802024,
0.8812425137,
0.1572319567,
-0.4821290076,
-0.3284848928,
-0.1010928303,
-0.0827862099,
-0.5727561712,
0.1076177061,
0.2121496946,
-0.0613039061,
-0.5775778294,
0.1783132404,
-0.1338555664,
-0.1810956001,
0.048879981,
0.1998440772,
0.0192663018,
-0.2540964186,
0.3732892275,
-0.1534415632,
-0.1350465417,
0.3743054867,
0.0134253055,
0.340644896,
-0.2348594368,
-0.2312920243,
0.084338069,
0.4784297347,
0.4318370819,
-0.2269424498,
0.4208447337,
0.0832310095,
-0.5797051191,
-0.2200864106,
-0.5719739795,
-0.3052769303,
-0.4627069235,
0.4789343774,
-0.4573784471,
-0.3791654706,
0.7822012901,
-0.4560297728,
0.1675403267,
-0.0135617498,
0.433298707,
-0.1849351972,
0.5892800689,
0.280105561,
-0.024364952,
0.0915971994,
-0.0021348037,
0.3174274862,
-0.9415217638,
0.1721375883,
-0.4311521947,
-0.5103778839,
-0.2754768729,
-0.4191807508,
0.418051064,
0.143589735,
-0.2674939036,
0.4508160949,
-0.129434824,
0.663987875,
0.4234475493,
-0.1196550876,
0.4742370844,
-0.4781267047,
-0.4150049686,
-0.0329580568,
-0.4900040627,
-0.5316746235,
1.2284162045,
0.2328718901,
0.7308559418,
0.0448494777,
0.3773970902,
0.0892639682,
0.7038161755,
-0.5490962267,
0.7735976577,
0.0914907306,
-0.964171946,
-0.1107457355,
-0.2167863995,
-1.1050229073,
0.6648855209,
-0.2799825072,
-1.2700452805,
0.0108021544,
0.3884606361,
-0.2594335675,
0.402874589,
-0.5858458281,
0.7221313715,
-0.1544785798,
-0.3734990358,
-0.4159394503,
-0.6502269506,
0.2728392482,
-0.5367420912,
0.4374772608,
-0.2627686262,
-0.1601841748,
0.7026068568,
-0.0150218597,
0.7237623334,
0.3114610314,
0.1177949831,
0.2417615503,
0.4357215464,
0.3386673331,
-0.428080678,
-0.254147172,
0.202100873,
0.2352850437,
-0.1482854486,
-0.9327103496,
0.6785622835,
-0.3781103194,
-0.5551373363,
-0.3231456578,
-0.5822547674,
-0.2694786787,
0.18970415,
0.0668046772,
0.207079336,
-0.5200132728,
0.2296789885,
0.3687381744,
0.0574290901,
0.2377071977,
0.634709537,
-0.3895534575,
-0.1145931408,
0.5927144289,
0.0637555271,
0.203122139,
0.4336968064,
0.2922042608,
-0.387291342,
-0.2432039678,
-0.452707231,
0.405333817,
-0.781421423,
-0.2356476486,
-0.6185561419,
0.0481196642,
0.0673571974,
-0.0775413737,
-0.6960695982,
-0.4079481661,
0.3103639781,
-0.0649121404,
0.124341391,
0.6109421849,
-0.1124840826,
0.0901555866,
-0.1981314868,
0.5225017667,
0.3466438949,
0.6131202579,
0.4308526516,
-0.4458554387,
-0.2971739173,
-0.1203891709,
-0.6513695717,
-0.8842020631,
0.1635316014,
0.1243195236,
0.625483036,
0.5104855299,
0.2286460102,
0.5734275579,
-0.8054276705,
0.3246654868,
-0.0878046155,
-0.9553640485,
0.1847785711,
-0.2660184801,
0.5197324753,
0.5939211845,
0.6612188816,
-0.7206707597,
-0.4418832064,
-0.4824829102,
-1.0289242268,
0.1898877621,
0.3651274443,
-0.1496915817,
0.1006160378,
0.2306065261,
0.3384867907,
0.2925968766,
-0.6968393922,
-0.1170606017,
0.1446692795,
-0.1615971476,
-0.2744511366,
0.1175299063,
-0.1294233501,
-0.3101874292,
0.2422431707,
0.0321332514,
0.1535452008,
-0.244557932,
0.087733686,
-0.0768601596,
0.3965650201,
0.4187887311,
1.0080173016,
-0.4360526502,
0.4977577627,
0.4591065645,
0.0414473042,
0.2722316384,
0.295279175,
0.1506022662,
0.0056429231,
0.4829822183,
0.4376652241,
0.574649334,
-1.373155117,
0.2918244302,
0.0995113477,
-0.0538235493,
-0.410630554,
0.0410392806,
0.4833889008,
0.2424975634,
0.5351296067,
-0.3582774699,
0.4265936017,
-0.9086260796,
0.0404599719,
0.3740525842,
-0.0920030773,
-0.526422441,
0.7916744947,
0.0963097289,
-0.539986968,
0.3946655393,
0.1694305241,
-0.2740998864,
0.629199326,
0.5604938865,
0.8106502295,
-0.3852834702,
-0.3557316065,
0.5396460891,
0.1795873046,
-0.0589116439,
-0.0923200697,
0.0364642255,
-0.4703470469,
-0.0742747486,
-0.4468166828,
-0.4674558043,
0.5292828083,
-0.9042673707,
0.2417282462,
-0.3553837538,
-0.1406898201,
0.3090454638,
-0.316179812,
-0.7721780539,
0.1618982852,
-0.0355339609,
0.9139711857,
-1.3161509037,
0.5733132958,
0.8577829599,
0.0661621839,
-0.5354522467,
-0.0152993314,
0.1757722497,
-0.6426240206,
0.4372196496,
0.3020756841,
-0.3151838779,
-0.2534207702,
-0.0717440546,
-0.6871927977,
0.9000610113,
0.1808369756,
-0.5517196655,
-0.0802881718,
-0.1504386365,
0.9840144515,
-0.5792104602,
0.5159955025,
0.8915241957,
0.2097363323,
-0.1561321169,
-1.2660932541,
0.1812933087,
-0.5145388246,
0.1014416516,
0.2935415506,
-0.2307372689,
0.8656155467,
-0.281712234,
-0.3752084672,
0.3762649596,
0.3680189252,
0.4946275651,
0.4093463123,
0.6265280247,
0.5384092331,
0.396772325,
0.3745339513,
0.9182345867,
-0.1529314518,
0.0677826703,
1.5498731136,
-0.5186830163,
1.2759047747,
0.5560539961,
-0.1959848106,
0.5589996576,
0.3785442412,
0.3916871846,
0.5402944088,
0.4595363736,
-0.040202979,
-0.0091991611,
0.039973706,
-0.4013137221,
0.3649781644,
0.492736876,
-0.4135956168,
-0.3399059772,
-0.3046599627,
-0.0135659995,
0.5945738554,
0.0654537082,
0.816591382,
0.1178968102,
-0.7118750811,
0.8812888265,
-0.1709473729,
0.2814171314,
-0.5862398148,
-0.2340501845,
-0.3189596236,
0.4069559872,
0.3113897145,
-0.7484180331,
0.1700227857,
-0.0823887438,
0.063126415,
0.2126212418,
0.2112960219,
-0.2627575099,
-0.4616187215,
0.3841212094,
0.4998039007,
0.2944386601,
0.1157705784,
-0.4646956623,
0.2356926799,
-0.3200821877,
-0.1507937312,
0.2636753023,
0.494471848,
-0.3272994161,
1.0790264606,
0.1303469241,
0.3115861118,
-0.157541275,
-0.4400463104,
0.8995108008,
-0.8038157225,
-0.6316233873,
-0.6336504817,
0.2418778539,
-0.1233404726,
-0.5251272917,
0.4062433541,
0.8500803709,
1.1008732319,
-0.1172053218,
0.5517721176,
0.2497289032,
0.9819848537,
-0.3594364226,
0.4190358222,
-0.5823453665,
0.3268048763,
-0.301774621,
-1.1064581871,
-0.0552909672,
0.8436567783,
-0.5301799178,
-0.001080309,
0.9756439328,
0.8223255873,
-0.4818019271,
-0.1413380504,
0.3645514548,
0.3372398019,
0.0834362209,
0.6975684166,
0.8709928393,
-0.2448749691,
0.5077748299,
0.0157766063,
-0.238927722,
-0.3684337735,
-0.9909723401,
-0.9214091301,
-0.7074850798,
-0.0984600782,
0.0669296682,
0.334741503,
0.9917179346,
0.6912154555,
-0.3946285546,
-0.6731790304,
0.17629987,
-0.2332611382,
-0.6153971553,
-0.1328969747,
0.370018363,
0.2315136045,
-0.5286849141,
-0.0092132855,
0.1113745198,
-0.1470972598,
-0.209395662,
0.1504293978,
-0.0832340568,
0.5079345703,
0.3968818486,
0.6113264561,
-1.067455411,
-0.2556972802,
-0.2868508697,
-0.002065016,
0.0941202492,
1.0160697699,
-1.0508155823,
0.7841646671,
0.0631591827,
0.4275776744,
0.4632655382,
0.2484739125,
0.6090806127,
-0.4883788228,
0.3151329458,
0.349822402,
0.2202311307,
0.2252315283,
0.293145597,
0.6638560295,
-0.2832300067,
-0.3540673852,
-0.9996324778,
0.3409380317,
-0.7451758385,
-0.7051483393,
0.9603745341,
-0.2600915432,
-0.0514173508,
0.0034946352,
-0.2708161175,
-0.2848479748,
-0.1798994541,
1.1525537968,
0.6852531433,
-0.2197138369,
-0.1812109053,
-0.624040246,
0.2167099118,
0.546502471,
-0.7954685092,
0.3262952864,
0.2986201048,
0.2990843654,
0.0768974423,
0.5834809542,
0.0801352262,
0.367934227,
0.1550064683,
-0.0412786081,
0.152987361,
-0.1394843161,
-0.0917401612,
-0.0003845617,
0.1390829086,
0.0127604511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12368v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12368v2
|
A synthetic data approach for domain generalization of NLI models
| 2024-02-19T18:55:16 | 2024-06-28T10:36:27 |
Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Andrey Petrov, Alex Fabrikant, Annie Louis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Inference (NLI) remains an important benchmark task for
LLMs. NLI datasets are a springboard for transfer learning to other semantic
tasks, and NLI models are standard tools for identifying the faithfulness of
model-generated text. There are several large scale NLI datasets today, and
models have improved greatly by hill-climbing on these collections. Yet their
realistic performance on out-of-distribution/domain data is less
well-understood. We explore the opportunity for synthetic high-quality datasets
to adapt NLI models for zero-shot use in downstream applications across new and
unseen text domains. We demonstrate a new approach for generating NLI data in
diverse domains and lengths, so far not covered by existing training sets. The
resulting examples have meaningful premises, the hypotheses are formed in
creative ways rather than simple edits to a few premise tokens, and the labels
have high accuracy. We show that models trained on this data ($685$K synthetic
examples) have the best generalization to completely new downstream test
settings. On the TRUE benchmark, a T5-small model trained with our data
improves around $7\%$ on average compared to training on the best alternative
dataset. The improvements are more pronounced for smaller models, while still
meaningful on a T5 XXL model. We also demonstrate gains on test sets when
in-domain training data is augmented with our domain-general synthetic data.
|
[
-0.2604094446,
-0.6234543324,
0.6443450451,
0.0065727546,
-0.0505394638,
0.1309215575,
-0.2765831947,
-0.4874534607,
0.0690165088,
0.7272014022,
-0.7239658833,
-0.753881216,
-0.3900769949,
0.232253924,
-0.4861958027,
0.886631012,
-0.0135547938,
-0.239262715,
0.0682675317,
-0.2336113751,
-0.3686012328,
-0.5669525862,
-0.4343152344,
-0.366294682,
0.5168409944,
0.0353830755,
0.5534333587,
0.6434481144,
0.2322264016,
0.1412778646,
0.1623338461,
0.5111534595,
-0.5070222616,
-0.0195538905,
-0.385727942,
-0.4772109389,
-0.4092464745,
0.2113123387,
0.6751320362,
1.1916533709,
0.1464226395,
0.1890949607,
-0.0572645292,
0.5033229589,
-0.7790964246,
-0.1171548218,
-0.8724819422,
0.1294166893,
-0.0737813786,
-0.1450416297,
-0.7030434608,
-0.2930229604,
0.3011266291,
-0.9892833233,
0.6663077474,
0.1643948555,
0.934941411,
0.1138199791,
-0.5607984662,
-0.1496595442,
-1.0655050278,
1.2608389854,
-1.0290602446,
0.3851561248,
0.1278911531,
0.4552033246,
-0.2981012762,
-0.7562667131,
-0.6811992526,
-0.0785403475,
-0.0429392979,
0.1900730133,
-0.1813802868,
-0.104944922,
0.2061870098,
0.3121711314,
-0.6429306269,
0.0863792077,
-0.17955181,
0.1227985546,
0.9256054163,
0.1351857632,
0.2038887888,
0.1628343314,
-0.2058562934,
-0.1421048045,
-0.9614104033,
-0.4308906794,
0.3186262548,
0.624848187,
-0.0082483487,
0.6261823177,
-0.3519544303,
0.901186645,
-0.1101181805,
0.0059806402,
0.2536803186,
-0.5215929151,
-0.5127574205,
-0.0891099796,
0.5485609174,
0.3108883202,
0.5986148119,
-0.541751802,
-0.236981377,
0.1335024387,
0.3347453177,
-0.5578498244,
-0.0860536322,
0.2098042816,
-0.2948735356,
-0.2987638414,
0.0274681561,
-0.5833399296,
-0.2195691466,
-0.8753113747,
0.3882971406,
-0.5175312161,
-0.1787169427,
0.1949876249,
-0.3341553509,
0.4129618704,
0.1875037104,
-0.8275017142,
0.4626629651,
0.6559327841,
0.7126791477,
-0.4301152229,
-0.1313153505,
-0.4401850104,
0.4931459725,
-0.6346088052,
0.8028901815,
-0.3997301161,
-0.312498033,
0.1117922142,
-0.0187781695,
-0.3402843475,
-0.9903017879,
0.5535598993,
-0.4562356472,
0.0828947574,
0.231214419,
-0.8879412413,
-0.0327561833,
0.1565437615,
-0.6233774424,
0.8803772926,
0.1955188513,
-0.4340092242,
0.4037561417,
-0.6214399338,
-0.3383940756,
-0.1623144895,
0.1250163913,
-0.2465816587,
0.2775816023,
0.171203047,
0.2570238411,
-0.2576098442,
0.3205600679,
-0.5305792689,
-0.4477349818,
0.2505696714,
-0.4526655674,
0.4969068468,
0.0618031323,
-0.0712413415,
-0.2072779387,
-0.9983324409,
0.3089518547,
-0.0520654544,
-0.0493741222,
-0.574985683,
-0.1427376717,
0.0379753672,
-0.2198775262,
-0.3561485708,
-0.6746999025,
0.246413663,
-0.6847292781,
0.2388806045,
0.4868171811,
0.3727251291,
0.6663652658,
-0.3201705515,
0.3401112556,
-0.0735851154,
0.026811894,
0.2035975754,
-0.435120523,
-0.8234364986,
-0.1812045276,
0.6866068244,
0.4346311986,
-0.7931852937,
0.3332019448,
-0.5363897085,
-0.3010838628,
-0.4654531181,
0.012156182,
0.004601425,
0.3737534285,
0.4362893999,
0.04538133,
-0.6523809433,
-1.0535135269,
-0.480609864,
0.1960834563,
-0.5416782498,
0.1827045232,
0.4721016288,
-0.3890441358,
1.3751751184,
-0.6030265093,
-0.1338149756,
-0.5399492979,
0.351088196,
0.4797509015,
0.3867027462,
0.6000231504,
-0.6624099612,
-0.4709921181,
0.0420494936,
-0.7773388028,
-0.1824235916,
-0.3867128193,
-0.4959401786,
0.2062618881,
0.086051479,
-0.5490244031,
0.4397325814,
0.6046499014,
-0.0645445138,
0.4448425174,
-0.0676661581,
-0.2482001036,
-1.1759916544,
0.0609696433,
0.2204807997,
-0.1935662329,
-1.183226347,
-0.0664436519,
-0.1246117204,
-0.0572365522,
-0.5070189238,
0.8862599134,
-0.2998826504,
-0.004395741,
-0.280497402,
0.1331912279,
0.2027187347,
0.4410277605,
0.1696739197,
0.8136416078,
0.3302936256,
-0.7919799089,
0.1164965108,
0.2935188413,
-0.2285370976,
0.2257377207,
-0.7615372539,
0.1281109601,
-0.0587229952,
0.314624846,
-0.6454482675,
-0.2761152089,
0.0570145808,
-0.4115154743,
0.24410142,
-0.2554973364,
-0.3353761137,
0.0192288812,
-0.2094298303,
0.2181870937,
0.6965162158,
-0.7338369489,
0.7595098615,
0.1882095486,
0.1724302173,
-0.2861903012,
-0.8774761558,
0.1564934552,
-0.3174168468,
-0.4393462539,
0.7565032244,
-0.0155618945,
-0.2520112395,
0.0160038322,
-0.0734631792,
-0.4596613646,
-0.1904946417,
0.0446506329,
0.3371464312,
-0.3652755618,
0.0561996177,
0.094365932,
-0.002146851,
-0.0407584198,
-0.4517488182,
0.1348834932,
0.2915577888,
-0.1100509241,
-0.2884016335,
0.4299964905,
0.2064767778,
0.074978523,
0.7553452849,
0.3014040291,
-0.4891960025,
-0.9139668345,
-0.3353827596,
-0.1568061411,
-0.4375937581,
-0.0744140372,
-0.38880983,
-0.5457798839,
0.1000974625,
-0.3314256668,
0.1623464078,
0.4087167978,
0.2048583031,
-0.1054076403,
0.8703192472,
0.6892235279,
0.0899636447,
0.1073431298,
-0.6656380296,
0.534173429,
-0.8257962465,
0.2273851931,
-0.2368728966,
-0.0954258442,
-0.6409283876,
-0.5108206868,
0.1713410169,
0.0382611826,
-0.1269177794,
0.4165125489,
-0.1821075827,
0.4416850805,
0.536791563,
-0.0493730754,
0.3776890934,
0.2419436574,
0.0736922249,
-0.0286250375,
-0.6419438124,
-0.6519317031,
1.3538751602,
0.2096480131,
0.5377433896,
0.1953765303,
0.6969117522,
0.4779849648,
0.6850875616,
-0.6837266088,
0.3820647895,
-0.4400913417,
-0.4946019351,
-0.1991521418,
-0.4497797489,
-0.8714670539,
0.1795402318,
-0.2118751109,
-0.3915046751,
0.3028214276,
0.0787591562,
-0.3522312343,
0.2980771959,
-0.9997550845,
0.5808334351,
0.2219719142,
-0.2510674298,
0.1940378845,
-0.3050577939,
0.5430653095,
-0.336611867,
0.0717091709,
-0.3175428212,
0.1107835397,
0.3877361119,
-0.4125281274,
0.9744546413,
-0.1240247861,
-0.1528256088,
0.5274037719,
-0.1369612217,
0.4539999962,
-0.013657352,
-0.3930743039,
0.237395063,
-0.1511255056,
-0.4249531627,
-1.1037861109,
0.5512499809,
-0.6209067106,
-0.459433049,
-0.1654925793,
-0.5463562608,
-0.6289281845,
-0.0524094887,
0.1182650849,
0.5684543848,
-0.1660339534,
0.1066581011,
0.5905427933,
-0.2472838312,
0.3624786139,
0.3631201386,
0.1836296171,
-0.3204096854,
0.9423284531,
-0.0438071564,
0.5709421635,
0.3540717363,
-0.0188939851,
-0.500695765,
-0.6969248056,
-0.5333263278,
0.2963381112,
-0.5210897326,
-0.2478648424,
-0.526421845,
-0.5199677944,
-0.4377343357,
-0.0661552176,
-0.2763457596,
-0.4553981125,
-0.1868763715,
-0.0826876834,
0.2726561725,
0.5871962905,
0.1364000291,
0.2305006236,
-0.8015739322,
0.4621018171,
0.1628674567,
0.198747322,
-0.0861030743,
-0.6686053276,
-0.0075545041,
0.3075808287,
-0.1926751286,
-0.5179439783,
0.769164741,
0.6778694987,
0.4966546893,
-0.0379095376,
0.3435463905,
0.6692251563,
-0.6773727536,
0.7179436088,
-0.1498002857,
-0.7796948552,
0.493622601,
-0.4746880829,
0.1495009512,
0.4595810771,
0.4676623046,
-0.401635617,
-0.4808136821,
-0.5249181986,
-0.7614938617,
0.2706177533,
0.5645931363,
0.352365464,
0.0504594557,
0.5929799676,
0.2821981907,
0.125557214,
-0.5756685734,
-0.1660697609,
-0.0259194635,
-0.5546709299,
-0.0554980934,
0.1682884693,
0.0458809175,
-0.2147386819,
0.6944281459,
-0.5556474328,
0.3410121202,
0.288061887,
-0.1054190025,
0.2315160185,
0.2024905086,
0.4019491673,
0.7377220392,
-0.3346869051,
0.1661195904,
0.4269409776,
-0.2920302451,
0.2548888028,
-0.1710114032,
-0.3276687562,
0.2355612069,
0.5388116837,
0.8126999736,
-0.0806103945,
-0.7316568494,
0.2870643437,
0.0521699972,
-0.4137318134,
-0.3408686221,
0.2613293231,
-0.107358925,
0.0025923662,
0.3259761631,
0.0265121944,
0.2507692575,
-0.5909593701,
0.3073071241,
0.2687496543,
-0.0567960218,
-0.4558438957,
0.5071670413,
-0.0361745283,
-0.0931524187,
0.5365568399,
-0.1635484248,
-0.0537621863,
0.50074476,
0.6342231035,
0.8394755721,
0.1293649524,
0.4006414711,
0.4428377748,
-0.0573475473,
0.1012643501,
0.0048519685,
0.2395672351,
-1.0260468721,
-0.7299578786,
-0.6770393252,
-0.6182191372,
0.4008484483,
-0.5463659167,
0.2122908682,
-0.4441926777,
-0.1394969821,
0.1861712635,
-0.2311900407,
-0.513602972,
0.5455501676,
0.1882990748,
0.9265645742,
-0.8755259514,
0.9615458846,
0.3306828439,
-0.14116624,
-0.5062071085,
0.2879388332,
-0.2478370816,
-0.444444865,
0.6594244838,
0.0539459772,
-0.0158427786,
0.0798910782,
-0.6018392444,
-0.8910601139,
0.9805921912,
0.343526721,
-0.3924556971,
-0.0029797363,
0.687808454,
0.7517995834,
-0.6938412189,
0.0416116007,
0.8461760879,
0.2158679515,
0.1751176864,
-0.377505362,
-0.0510777831,
-0.1974103451,
0.4431265295,
0.0352437608,
-0.2175026089,
0.4767151773,
-0.0809073225,
-0.3892830014,
0.1477239728,
0.6231935024,
0.5923654437,
0.3702995777,
0.3866563439,
0.4858938158,
0.5379677415,
-0.0930318907,
1.2346947193,
-0.0815021247,
0.259349525,
1.2723674774,
-0.6230636835,
0.9744264483,
0.4380711913,
-0.0640833676,
0.4692314267,
0.5524612069,
-0.1610845774,
0.5846155286,
0.3783766925,
-0.4785019755,
-0.1549570858,
-0.4976519048,
0.0046909163,
0.1410467029,
0.2105682194,
-0.2275740951,
-0.2100426108,
-0.0793797523,
-0.3719891012,
0.0603406727,
0.1599418968,
0.6556556821,
0.0985367075,
-0.4944784641,
0.9003578424,
0.050181523,
0.5903126597,
-0.5514497161,
-0.2366077602,
-0.469040513,
0.3015373647,
0.0223587919,
-0.5510502458,
0.6727463603,
0.1048850641,
-0.2842964232,
-0.3931702971,
0.6180394888,
-0.4334460199,
-0.648244381,
0.2479108274,
0.3865836263,
0.0077306912,
-0.0964502767,
-0.2418927699,
-0.1657584459,
-0.0297687631,
-0.1470697373,
0.2674871981,
0.3353685737,
-0.0976006985,
0.5471244454,
0.9016596079,
0.2242922783,
0.2598704696,
0.4020871222,
0.7520356774,
-0.6917380095,
0.0145855015,
-0.5059410334,
0.5128160715,
-0.3367803693,
-0.344145,
0.6281709075,
0.5554904938,
0.8947916031,
-0.3823598027,
0.9878038764,
0.2950214744,
0.8344750404,
-0.7196468115,
0.4240500331,
-0.4522755146,
0.0257320106,
0.1555347294,
-1.047752738,
-0.4883421361,
0.2178998739,
-0.1970890015,
-0.0726445913,
0.6692525148,
0.7935334444,
-0.2982448936,
0.1538560838,
0.4170866907,
0.0427366868,
0.4324108362,
0.4980299473,
0.821770668,
-0.8325093985,
0.1398031563,
-0.2364307642,
-0.0142447986,
0.262771666,
-0.792729795,
-0.818557024,
-0.2287530005,
-0.4390977919,
0.0316405632,
0.1895951927,
0.7387242913,
0.9652939439,
-1.1437996626,
-0.1707865447,
-0.4223835468,
-0.1974881738,
-0.0885284618,
-0.2803860009,
0.144427523,
-0.4006468058,
-0.9674553871,
0.7842991948,
0.019544892,
0.4101084769,
-0.0164348874,
0.0807546303,
-0.1716923118,
0.4344979823,
0.7430052161,
0.1214616522,
-0.6660804152,
-0.3267580867,
0.1612755954,
0.2227319479,
-0.0806919336,
0.8448280096,
-0.7969537377,
0.0108456193,
0.1806713194,
0.8713951707,
0.5361021161,
0.1291722059,
0.9922642112,
-1.0859081745,
0.1045580953,
0.1512536854,
0.0645219535,
0.3672229052,
-0.193033576,
0.854285121,
0.3256604671,
-0.1623170823,
-0.8275647163,
0.1537683606,
-0.7508628368,
-0.2337337881,
1.2607841492,
-0.092882432,
-0.3802934885,
-0.1552054137,
0.1083496436,
0.1266451031,
-0.0941006094,
0.5695710182,
0.4746380746,
-0.1648796946,
0.066288732,
-0.7910398841,
0.458878994,
0.3251783848,
-1.0768002272,
0.1905700862,
0.2659410238,
0.3870670497,
0.0495772026,
0.14856264,
0.1425100416,
-0.2859567702,
-0.0775317103,
0.0064899577,
0.290402025,
-0.3533801734,
-0.2269355804,
0.0096619083,
-0.2552525103,
-0.1535102427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12366v1
|
A Critical Evaluation of AI Feedback for Aligning Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T18:53:54 | 2024-02-19T18:53:54 |
Archit Sharma, Sedrick Keh, Eric Mitchell, Chelsea Finn, Kushal Arora, Thomas Kollar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning with AI feedback (RLAIF) is a popular paradigm for
improving the instruction-following abilities of powerful pre-trained language
models. RLAIF first performs supervised fine-tuning (SFT) using demonstrations
from a teacher model and then further fine-tunes the model with reinforcement
learning (RL), using feedback from a critic model. While recent popular
open-source models have demonstrated substantial improvements in performance
from the RL step, in this paper we question whether the complexity of this RL
step is truly warranted for AI feedback. We show that the improvements of the
RL step are virtually entirely due to the widespread practice of using a weaker
teacher model (e.g. GPT-3.5) for SFT data collection than the critic (e.g.,
GPT-4) used for AI feedback generation. Specifically, we show that simple
supervised fine-tuning with GPT-4 as the teacher outperforms existing RLAIF
pipelines. More generally, we find that the gains from RLAIF vary substantially
across base model families, test-time evaluation protocols, and critic models.
Finally, we provide a mechanistic explanation for when SFT may outperform the
full two-step RLAIF pipeline as well as suggestions for making RLAIF maximally
useful in practice.
|
[
-0.3200256228,
-0.8359944224,
0.5000311732,
-0.0621761531,
0.0071687018,
0.0274581369,
-0.5644975901,
-0.4177482128,
-0.4010384083,
0.330436945,
-0.6385683417,
-0.4098864496,
-0.7608093023,
0.0305934437,
-0.3984247446,
1.4784852266,
-0.1659040451,
0.1662025899,
-0.0505130664,
-0.2168260217,
-0.5715788007,
-0.133229658,
-0.8148010373,
-0.6061814427,
0.6390491724,
0.5884826779,
0.8801630735,
0.8288168311,
0.5618106127,
0.2872197628,
0.3075845838,
0.4118928611,
-0.6006944776,
0.1197384894,
-0.3069103062,
-0.500069499,
-0.1634140015,
0.1946954578,
0.7195325494,
0.5088362694,
-0.2597684562,
0.1758178174,
0.1520436853,
0.9894663095,
-0.7355959415,
0.2646460831,
-0.0601565726,
0.1685602516,
0.1591858864,
-0.0152365267,
-0.7423530221,
-0.4598067403,
0.1609398872,
-0.5588333607,
0.0811292827,
0.0771762356,
0.7849905491,
0.8347101808,
-0.2453505099,
-0.2321285903,
-1.1234176159,
0.7095960379,
-0.579212904,
0.5095444918,
0.3266137838,
0.3472183347,
-0.0500858687,
-0.6513120532,
-0.3354370296,
-0.8109434843,
-0.2663570642,
0.2403298914,
0.0650482774,
0.3872770071,
0.5058167577,
0.239445284,
-0.3789622784,
0.283829391,
-0.5246068835,
0.0331186913,
0.6554256082,
0.158664763,
0.054026369,
0.1332761794,
-0.1416521817,
-0.4028114974,
-0.6488129497,
0.3165756464,
0.4553921819,
0.2458401322,
-0.0360621214,
0.2752428949,
-0.2269421965,
0.8610150814,
0.3134411871,
-0.185695827,
-0.0662775561,
-0.0305851046,
-0.0793989226,
-0.1555615664,
0.9258951545,
0.2761127353,
0.542866528,
-0.030564595,
-0.4263089895,
0.0779057145,
0.4865449071,
-0.8322631717,
-0.4607054591,
0.1186095104,
-0.3690261841,
-0.3429822922,
0.4426489174,
-0.3932500482,
-0.2851482332,
-0.3870281875,
0.3753217161,
-0.2791646421,
-0.1812984496,
-0.2479588538,
0.1981971264,
0.0312001053,
0.5022358298,
-0.8994885683,
0.2426048368,
1.0268148184,
0.5236547589,
-0.2134459019,
-0.7546300292,
-1.0397648811,
-0.2947046161,
-0.7059521079,
0.7741329074,
-0.6126866341,
-0.2720183134,
0.1104175597,
-0.1666778028,
-0.268460989,
-0.7041860223,
0.2662962079,
-0.3513512015,
0.1693657041,
-0.0933884755,
-0.5309007168,
-0.2236207128,
0.1952907145,
-0.6507000923,
1.0782331228,
0.1633609384,
-0.7006892562,
0.5984518528,
-0.5603380799,
-0.4619161487,
-0.0166795757,
-0.2787521183,
-0.5346718431,
-0.0791796446,
0.3881130815,
0.3354489803,
-0.2441231459,
0.3491435945,
-0.3009850383,
-0.8205527663,
0.2546215951,
-0.6291661859,
0.2503143847,
0.1953347325,
-0.7381083965,
0.4384857118,
-0.5802765489,
0.0344922468,
-0.325263828,
-0.6277619004,
0.0597583167,
0.1620344967,
-0.2061600238,
-0.0403366759,
-0.1226006225,
-0.2311655134,
0.1949987113,
-0.3284569681,
0.5256145597,
0.9980076551,
-0.0056354501,
0.3648684025,
-0.439812541,
0.8955058455,
-0.3507410884,
0.2401453853,
-0.1399634928,
-0.0858689025,
-0.838052392,
-0.2393501103,
0.6384578347,
0.473702848,
-0.4817308784,
-0.0015805429,
-0.1715578288,
-0.473660022,
-1.0121526718,
0.1411385536,
0.7007364035,
0.3960345685,
0.3224238455,
-0.2650328875,
-0.1512517631,
-0.9697142243,
-0.2964177132,
-0.558804512,
0.3324075341,
0.4845038652,
0.3848320544,
-0.1141447872,
0.6565318108,
-0.1818753928,
-0.1575456262,
-0.3320496678,
0.2450654656,
-0.0557164401,
0.5023376346,
0.2319075763,
-0.3810537457,
-0.5178067684,
0.1138439775,
-0.5563856959,
0.0121545773,
-0.1353023797,
0.1765160561,
0.4365257025,
0.7049928904,
-0.4231555462,
0.3559644818,
0.5655556321,
0.0692668036,
0.5346550941,
-0.3369646668,
0.3270909488,
-0.4264853895,
0.0072791651,
-0.1639710814,
-0.3290728033,
-0.3137282431,
0.4418458045,
0.0544012301,
0.1402557939,
-0.3420035243,
0.2903734744,
-0.052599363,
0.0191778354,
-0.3675804734,
0.2421525866,
-0.4381981492,
0.6348187923,
-0.0409009047,
0.9711751342,
0.2253837734,
-0.6037643552,
0.3674099445,
-0.1232719719,
-0.381419301,
0.5355234742,
-0.6910179853,
0.1763176471,
-0.034271922,
0.5499953032,
-0.7593522072,
-0.2272167057,
0.4225564897,
-0.3246987462,
0.3289504349,
-0.2069724053,
-0.320592016,
-0.3286785483,
-0.1799778193,
0.3659495115,
0.3579983115,
-0.7807852626,
0.6037136912,
-0.0287419036,
0.0794640779,
-0.8374490142,
-0.3576543331,
-0.2580076456,
-0.0011869296,
-0.5096755624,
-0.1175470203,
-0.105349578,
-0.2376419902,
0.1489670128,
-0.0481641553,
0.3319161534,
0.1661084443,
0.5110214949,
0.0561843067,
-0.1483028382,
0.2457236052,
-0.1427096725,
-0.3449445367,
0.0183383934,
-0.2216228545,
0.1861322969,
-0.3611243963,
-0.6231802702,
-0.6364091039,
0.149559617,
0.5200638771,
-0.3403892219,
0.4569286704,
0.7458435297,
0.0597290508,
-0.6272670031,
-0.3924390972,
-0.4514264166,
-0.3836045563,
0.5411600471,
-0.1683191061,
-1.178904295,
0.1281293929,
-0.0450672098,
0.2912876904,
0.4467487037,
0.4731591046,
0.058242362,
1.3188954592,
0.6944285631,
-0.1202075481,
0.4554190636,
-0.3056393862,
0.4003716409,
-0.6536698341,
-0.2150649279,
-0.531573236,
-0.2695406079,
-0.9295296669,
0.0746853501,
0.1096908227,
-0.0746435896,
-0.4840001166,
0.0304423757,
-0.4271097481,
0.5332951546,
0.8006973267,
0.148464188,
0.2988251746,
-0.2759258151,
-0.0035047485,
0.0294586923,
-0.8503078222,
-0.2901331186,
0.8660210967,
0.5546136498,
1.0262646675,
-0.0371171571,
0.7853400111,
0.3191134334,
0.6095888615,
-0.8440387249,
0.3211928308,
-0.1998298317,
-0.3077597022,
-0.3722274899,
-0.3900404572,
-0.6247520447,
0.2645704746,
-0.202308923,
-0.2771309614,
-0.3171275556,
0.4228982031,
-0.6174043417,
0.0677176937,
-0.7645019889,
0.8676729202,
-0.129120037,
-0.4559237361,
-0.5283072591,
-0.5520335436,
0.3912696242,
0.2342999876,
0.2894455791,
0.2878158689,
0.3787278831,
0.8221557736,
-0.7252857685,
0.7746956944,
-0.2794601321,
-0.1439932287,
0.3245853782,
0.1394201517,
0.6363146901,
0.2369083315,
0.414790988,
-0.3190228045,
0.1072401181,
-0.1588671505,
-0.8915314078,
0.751588285,
-1.1293327808,
-0.9284316897,
-0.5094860196,
-0.4684591293,
-0.2196232527,
-0.0517698377,
0.1024966091,
0.2837786376,
0.1411853433,
0.2105674744,
0.5627651215,
0.0829475969,
0.1619412899,
0.5321717262,
-0.4648106694,
-0.4298336208,
1.0568500757,
0.0797568858,
0.4044206142,
0.2457525134,
0.113838464,
-0.0278766323,
-0.3832029104,
-0.6790203452,
0.2769700587,
-0.6644326448,
-0.0708668754,
-0.3667960465,
-0.2883098423,
-0.213852942,
-0.0430702567,
-0.5755659342,
-0.272598803,
-0.1968599111,
-0.3790318668,
0.158864364,
1.3311856985,
-0.313721627,
0.1908246428,
-0.5431178212,
-0.0737720281,
0.479242146,
0.3207334876,
0.247326076,
-0.5275352001,
-0.4478120208,
-0.0846804753,
-0.2048461884,
-0.4730408192,
-0.2092967778,
0.1161044911,
0.3253828585,
0.398299247,
-0.0254717506,
0.7718018293,
-0.3990867734,
0.8817819953,
-0.2390165031,
-0.7115499973,
0.3512134552,
-0.1775261015,
0.1666524857,
0.6483098865,
0.1026330516,
-0.4017861485,
-0.5770725012,
-0.7227136493,
-0.7579290271,
0.8684040904,
-0.3069140911,
-0.0962717831,
0.2467329353,
0.494846493,
0.0576459505,
0.1217971668,
-0.7014060616,
-0.1029420123,
-0.1515586674,
-0.0346786231,
-0.1092880368,
-0.0010697348,
-0.2321435511,
-0.1554686278,
0.8681733012,
-0.1660864353,
-0.0658445135,
0.0664835721,
-0.0406914465,
-0.4198310077,
0.2794992626,
0.7056598067,
0.6304689646,
-0.0763217136,
0.0572800823,
0.1641317159,
-0.2040437162,
0.0391787216,
0.0650457069,
-0.3109667003,
-0.421718508,
0.8182452321,
1.0699036121,
0.1543881297,
-0.6536108851,
0.5368739367,
-0.1942348778,
-0.3574438691,
-0.1916316152,
0.6027417779,
-0.3291876018,
0.5014573336,
0.040590819,
0.2066555768,
-0.0869681388,
-0.4193448126,
0.3293550313,
0.3484155834,
-0.7703291178,
-0.1205129549,
0.4733159244,
0.037347015,
-0.3869948685,
0.968649745,
0.0571413599,
-0.6130836606,
0.4533892572,
0.424392432,
0.715798974,
-0.1767033637,
0.5272578597,
0.5308147669,
0.4155563712,
-0.2740423679,
-0.2362682372,
-0.3687865734,
-0.2754353285,
-0.759924233,
-0.4230270088,
-0.625,
0.0935640037,
-0.831817925,
0.0976547077,
-0.8134678602,
0.0447537228,
-0.3148562312,
0.0219088718,
-0.4993598163,
0.2981590629,
-0.2975930274,
0.6264772415,
-0.8041029572,
0.5961970687,
0.6249252558,
-0.5237073302,
-1.4424158335,
0.2681615651,
-0.1097558811,
-0.77582407,
0.6985134482,
0.1554802805,
-0.2798157334,
-0.0133974096,
-0.6291949153,
-0.6194471717,
0.8501222134,
0.2987425923,
-0.6745536923,
0.0140167819,
-0.1647105962,
0.7872356176,
-0.3733552694,
0.4949355721,
0.7503467202,
0.6079893112,
-0.0425767228,
-0.8673292398,
-0.0015661357,
-0.113617532,
0.0538517796,
0.2558454573,
-0.8498891592,
0.6899160743,
-0.5637730956,
-0.196745351,
0.0658161566,
0.9322852492,
0.201858446,
-0.0824158415,
0.5869759321,
0.7401109934,
0.5682054758,
-0.0591858253,
1.1876370907,
-0.2725868225,
0.4201310575,
1.1365288496,
0.0488520451,
0.9765689373,
0.2699292004,
-0.2433938533,
0.5666187406,
0.7227502465,
-0.0499402583,
0.51415205,
0.3131234348,
0.0642543957,
-0.4055372775,
-0.1240293533,
-0.3741691709,
0.1604088992,
0.0800678283,
-0.170363754,
-0.1501456052,
-0.0509289168,
0.0857560262,
0.2530660629,
-0.2410232276,
0.8264572024,
-0.0123017319,
-1.4245506525,
0.5973618627,
0.0709878355,
0.2931162119,
-0.2435221076,
-0.2946608067,
-0.182407707,
0.5104025602,
-0.4044651985,
-0.7091673613,
0.0378727205,
-0.0216263104,
-0.0215651654,
-0.0508137904,
0.2480946332,
-0.4777815044,
-0.1086928621,
0.4117677808,
0.1773579419,
-0.1718260944,
0.4217381477,
-0.6789943576,
0.192208305,
0.1508544385,
-0.1982408464,
0.2945931852,
0.0801017284,
0.0013146844,
0.6374950409,
0.6040178537,
0.1182949394,
-0.1186344177,
0.3531613052,
0.616938293,
-0.324611932,
-0.325884968,
-0.762594223,
0.4076417685,
0.4642303884,
-0.4787966013,
0.4370261729,
0.1266227663,
1.1938145161,
0.0479554683,
0.9247470498,
0.1364904642,
0.506510973,
-0.6430912614,
0.4621221125,
-0.430570364,
0.1903787404,
-0.2437728941,
-0.8345608711,
-0.1886550188,
0.8905811906,
-0.2999345064,
0.4744797945,
0.8381434679,
0.8518792391,
0.1088858545,
0.1506460309,
0.1507324725,
0.303509742,
0.511007309,
0.475998044,
0.9547733665,
-0.3411642611,
0.5027865171,
-0.3458829522,
-0.3998681903,
-0.2358751297,
-0.6208473444,
-0.9231299758,
-0.6118781567,
-0.3836859763,
-0.6231281757,
0.4390936792,
1.1165910959,
0.6758628488,
-0.8791595697,
-0.1977488101,
-0.2413973361,
0.0553580113,
-0.5451158285,
-0.226932466,
0.4988979399,
-0.5942890644,
-0.7563381195,
0.3770807087,
0.1564828157,
-0.2967806756,
-0.5939955711,
-0.5475876927,
0.1321822405,
-0.0938575119,
0.2848512828,
0.3991826475,
-0.8280906081,
-0.6761299968,
-0.1265577078,
-0.0685660467,
-0.246779412,
0.8124343753,
-0.7399259806,
0.2657802105,
0.3428165615,
0.8154182434,
0.3845562339,
0.0852424353,
0.6037791967,
-0.3286122084,
-0.1747472435,
0.0025325068,
0.1266576946,
0.281724453,
-0.1635895371,
0.5516973138,
0.0407026075,
-0.9444475174,
-0.845285356,
0.3186596334,
-0.5681343079,
0.0363303162,
1.0462121964,
-0.2025756985,
-0.1541986614,
0.3608030081,
-0.2838365436,
0.0228501838,
-0.6646713614,
0.9046322703,
0.8353657126,
-0.3176740706,
-0.3649869859,
-0.539234221,
0.6841512322,
0.7022765875,
-0.4056242406,
0.1899949163,
0.5310934782,
0.2278811783,
0.0972875804,
0.5556829572,
0.0592753552,
0.5907077789,
-0.3171954453,
-0.4776085615,
-0.2134364545,
-0.7607553005,
-0.4490561783,
0.1828982085,
0.7153184414,
0.1675332785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12363v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12363v2
|
Emergent Word Order Universals from Cognitively-Motivated Language Models
| 2024-02-19T18:49:57 | 2024-06-07T18:21:47 |
Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ryo Ueda, Ryo Yoshida, Yohei Oseki, Ted Briscoe, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The world's languages exhibit certain so-called typological or implicational
universals; for example, Subject-Object-Verb (SOV) languages typically use
postpositions. Explaining the source of such biases is a key goal of
linguistics. We study word-order universals through a computational simulation
with language models (LMs). Our experiments show that typologically-typical
word orders tend to have lower perplexity estimated by LMs with cognitively
plausible biases: syntactic biases, specific parsing strategies, and memory
limitations. This suggests that the interplay of cognitive biases and
predictability (perplexity) can explain many aspects of word-order universals.
It also showcases the advantage of cognitively-motivated LMs, typically
employed in cognitive modeling, in the simulation of language universals.
|
[
-0.3475166559,
-0.8800212741,
0.8587224483,
0.3059675097,
-0.123667568,
-0.1063079536,
-0.1561324,
-0.4527362287,
0.0343293287,
0.7256513834,
-0.6174553633,
-0.3647701144,
-0.5047965646,
-0.0161978826,
-0.4304344952,
0.861651659,
0.1416164488,
0.0119412197,
-0.2500032485,
-0.1672172993,
-0.2095029354,
-1.0088908672,
-0.1319248676,
-0.5341139436,
0.5039559007,
0.2393821776,
1.1210712194,
0.5467941761,
0.3439109921,
0.2738015056,
-0.1752962619,
-0.320720166,
-0.2950462699,
0.3269857168,
-0.4256719351,
-0.73612082,
-0.108353816,
0.2830894589,
0.3902699351,
0.893841207,
-0.2388323098,
0.0946325958,
-0.105370149,
0.4897198081,
-0.6026057005,
0.0162646826,
-0.9051697254,
0.0811177194,
-0.2235476971,
-0.1785350293,
-0.3155309856,
-0.1909478009,
0.6563688517,
-0.498682946,
0.2547357976,
0.0716219172,
0.6756221056,
-0.0793156028,
0.0078545064,
-0.416901499,
-0.9561641216,
0.7735211253,
-0.3824651241,
0.5365244746,
-0.0750268549,
0.0301401075,
-0.3535281718,
-0.585588634,
-0.711681962,
-0.2324195206,
0.235499084,
0.2272908986,
-0.0415619463,
0.3323070109,
0.3335132003,
0.0907874703,
-0.4672605991,
0.3190215826,
0.0242486969,
0.0560708717,
0.5472964048,
0.309433192,
0.6018798351,
-0.2853015363,
-0.2947199643,
-0.0684451684,
-0.8381578326,
0.2439255863,
0.1297310591,
0.3566528559,
0.1888586432,
0.6649234891,
-0.1718390286,
0.5698217154,
-0.1302647293,
0.1278963536,
-0.0431785323,
-0.2809602022,
-0.2010897547,
0.1954361349,
0.6580081582,
0.1026478931,
0.5022993684,
-0.1201728284,
-0.0696571767,
0.5388168693,
0.2609050572,
-0.4937562644,
0.0247206278,
0.4551272392,
-0.0794959292,
-0.4465959966,
0.0935829729,
-0.5769675374,
-0.2215484679,
-0.2194384784,
0.3288115561,
-0.4128443897,
-0.125727728,
0.2866245806,
-0.0285977349,
0.0755497515,
0.3983792961,
-0.7936156988,
0.1395075321,
0.6665171981,
0.3150138259,
-0.2206914723,
-0.4534444213,
-0.0617116019,
0.1520285904,
-0.4944058955,
1.0276055336,
-0.7354684472,
-0.4817278087,
0.1636715233,
-0.4208921194,
0.0313504338,
-0.6083574295,
0.5086185932,
-0.6992333531,
0.3047810793,
-0.3510971069,
-0.5293354988,
-0.1254664212,
0.0435003005,
-0.3056643903,
0.8132691979,
-0.3150183856,
-0.6763333082,
0.4157398343,
-0.4634658694,
-0.2575470209,
0.1966486424,
-0.5340310931,
0.1040644273,
0.51742661,
-0.101074867,
0.3621085882,
-0.5202813745,
0.4638591111,
-0.2852533162,
-0.1634048373,
0.4864729643,
-0.4259441793,
0.8888249397,
0.2210293561,
-0.3812698126,
0.1729703397,
-0.5048464537,
0.1323390156,
0.4096303582,
-0.4447360039,
-0.5856497884,
0.3629312217,
-0.2768747509,
0.427303642,
0.2070959508,
-0.4684952199,
0.2936322391,
-0.44369784,
0.1901284009,
0.6814057231,
-0.067736946,
0.5376075506,
-0.0125646768,
0.6033783555,
0.1422619671,
0.2448647469,
0.0883957073,
-0.7205157876,
-0.524179101,
-0.1195386797,
0.2714493871,
0.7979572415,
-0.5702515244,
0.1560944021,
-0.3730226755,
-0.1579066515,
-0.2407292128,
-0.0566251017,
0.5854899883,
-0.0626516715,
0.0383477956,
-0.1167912856,
-0.4045485556,
-0.7926521301,
-0.5925850868,
-0.1258900166,
-0.1886899471,
0.2344612777,
0.2577715814,
-0.2022798657,
0.9548561573,
-0.5626420975,
0.2063843161,
-0.3569374084,
0.2954252958,
0.2564329803,
0.165496245,
0.323698163,
-0.8535236716,
-0.0473080762,
-0.396137476,
-0.7401821613,
-0.2373160571,
0.0911175162,
-0.1175924689,
0.2081198543,
0.7349013686,
-0.717148006,
0.5645171404,
0.3348498642,
-0.2648700774,
0.9717857838,
-0.4747834802,
-0.3708160222,
-1.0197554827,
-0.3076321483,
-0.3342959285,
0.1876938194,
-0.8462079763,
0.4341607988,
-0.2726847231,
-0.0492652021,
-0.3436618149,
0.2999628484,
-0.6740150452,
-0.103588447,
-0.1166253686,
0.2576075494,
-0.1201890558,
0.2053882182,
0.2030358016,
0.4741375744,
0.4394226372,
-0.8604083657,
-0.0328153297,
-0.0031636632,
-0.4179082811,
0.131534338,
-0.5967430472,
-0.1022072658,
-0.4367702901,
0.0909335837,
-1.1043118238,
-0.1289461553,
-0.2647723556,
-0.3370147049,
0.1514548808,
0.1431718767,
-0.6739179492,
-0.4901145399,
-0.1310927421,
0.5822152495,
0.3711992502,
-0.3914756775,
0.3410859704,
0.3444165885,
-0.0352127105,
-0.3486095965,
-0.6226997375,
-0.1565312743,
0.0834478959,
-0.3499239683,
0.4027853608,
-0.4130277932,
-0.6429006457,
-0.2398973852,
-0.0740681514,
0.2928906381,
0.1464867741,
0.2777147591,
0.4483942986,
-0.2044304162,
0.0949827582,
-0.0310100242,
0.1592259556,
0.1976138949,
-0.7425546646,
0.8666446209,
0.0076407017,
-0.2201525271,
0.0451521426,
0.3420597315,
0.7113937736,
-0.1002454385,
0.6983301044,
-0.1862178147,
-0.2932738364,
-0.07901223,
-0.679861486,
-0.0219411515,
-0.4877389967,
0.2897430956,
-0.577844739,
-0.8052527308,
0.6018879414,
0.0131646162,
0.1853585392,
0.3492866755,
0.5604366064,
-0.1699824631,
1.3216724396,
0.3036038578,
0.1184022501,
0.6639797091,
-0.095231086,
0.0067172283,
-0.5750592947,
-0.1266363859,
-0.4050118029,
0.0688430592,
-0.8780955672,
-0.4375894368,
0.2195383459,
0.3399352729,
-0.1988184899,
0.1273275018,
-0.3885451853,
0.7544444203,
0.409448415,
-0.2674796283,
0.2203268111,
0.3399149776,
-0.9541588426,
0.0497540496,
-0.7280811667,
-0.4967616498,
1.1159341335,
-0.1458860487,
0.5816562176,
0.0170866195,
0.6679507494,
0.041614078,
0.2506379783,
-0.5501579046,
0.6886812449,
-0.388020426,
-0.8696284294,
-0.2427476048,
-0.0565836169,
-1.4057216644,
0.4216133952,
-0.4431319535,
-1.3599220514,
0.1237612367,
-0.080729574,
-0.435688585,
0.0544999912,
-0.5491707325,
0.6860493422,
-0.1417876035,
-0.2134192884,
-0.2331622541,
-0.5609084368,
0.3614838719,
0.1625957936,
0.4487168789,
-0.0279153995,
0.0990430638,
0.6246228814,
-0.5856642127,
0.4106047153,
0.1617776603,
-0.3534610868,
0.50424999,
0.5049161911,
0.3973189294,
-0.1459069103,
-0.0957692564,
0.2396766543,
-0.1489048749,
-0.4721712172,
-0.556370914,
0.6913577318,
-0.7986223698,
-1.0027320385,
-0.3408730626,
-0.7267571092,
-0.3118205369,
0.2932707369,
0.8351292014,
0.5053129196,
-0.3631682992,
-0.4171538949,
0.7121254802,
-0.2357500941,
0.4506919086,
0.6557348967,
-0.7756508589,
-0.1851428151,
0.8394008279,
0.6123558879,
0.4609931111,
0.5148314834,
0.3391368985,
-0.2224381566,
-0.6085063219,
-0.1577756703,
0.1257484257,
-0.4506081641,
0.4465443492,
-0.6332094073,
-0.3229972422,
-0.4449674785,
-0.2773446739,
-0.2813450098,
-0.5461148024,
-0.1261416972,
-0.0675843954,
-0.0298599787,
1.1045863628,
0.1640599668,
0.2581695318,
-0.6063710451,
0.3263491392,
0.4785528779,
0.2391894907,
-0.0815526024,
-0.575381577,
0.2655390501,
0.0339017548,
-0.2641252577,
-0.9443327785,
0.0668043569,
-0.2750189006,
0.5535936952,
0.8136640787,
-0.1127247438,
0.5085281134,
-0.7269871235,
0.6816384196,
0.2592250407,
-0.8621969223,
0.4785448909,
-0.7291707993,
0.5945088267,
0.3572264016,
0.2945495844,
-0.4863430858,
-0.6437270641,
-0.9444346428,
-0.8732090592,
0.8039387465,
0.178193137,
0.0217053276,
-0.1304980069,
0.5609700084,
0.0822735056,
0.2456691265,
-0.6588516831,
-0.3439085484,
0.0116832927,
-0.0292840153,
-0.2673226297,
-0.485822022,
0.1402465701,
-0.2031286955,
0.3299387693,
0.1263505667,
0.3505499065,
0.1677634269,
-0.23904939,
0.042269595,
0.3996435404,
0.804520309,
0.521786809,
-0.1914013326,
0.3315840065,
-0.0030006501,
-0.4664923847,
0.2615024447,
-0.038111221,
-0.4541992843,
-0.0939792693,
0.1998897642,
0.5729877949,
0.2566615045,
-0.6488518119,
0.2445274442,
0.0478525721,
0.0456493348,
-0.3627392054,
0.0494773127,
0.3989501297,
0.2914292216,
0.2702580988,
0.0625056401,
0.1076971591,
-0.7519389391,
-0.0795226991,
0.7077841163,
-0.1976280063,
-0.6044028401,
0.6215342283,
-0.2068518996,
-0.4824584723,
0.4655013382,
-0.2805214822,
-0.7708121538,
0.5016083121,
0.6978311539,
0.8110023141,
-0.51849401,
0.1380548924,
0.028071817,
0.2920448482,
-0.2293214649,
0.615524292,
0.0502855033,
-1.2030981779,
-0.0762852505,
-0.7572784424,
-0.3400182426,
0.1647620946,
-0.6686785817,
0.0892686248,
-0.7863888741,
-0.3721775711,
0.2243479937,
-0.3356088102,
-0.6842014194,
0.15953812,
0.5547082424,
0.7435492873,
-0.6807212234,
0.857580781,
0.9415218234,
-0.3688749373,
-0.7990807295,
0.3746758699,
0.0925488174,
-0.9787803888,
0.7654545307,
0.2249602526,
-0.1749788672,
-0.0053912019,
-0.6611891985,
-1.1268535852,
0.7234831452,
0.4220638573,
-0.300940901,
-0.2293330431,
0.3809208274,
0.7480929494,
-0.4951916933,
0.2876196802,
0.4702929258,
0.2252145708,
-0.0666552782,
-0.49198699,
0.1807557195,
-0.0549713559,
0.4972780049,
0.2289308608,
-0.4590352774,
0.869912684,
-0.3721255362,
-0.3885001838,
-0.0962991714,
0.6247380972,
0.5009206533,
-0.0122584235,
0.4512275457,
0.5488507152,
0.5461951494,
0.039165061,
1.2421176434,
-0.3618825674,
0.0952565596,
0.9209251404,
-0.3510761261,
0.8718274832,
0.5102415085,
-0.4303102791,
0.8793534636,
0.5123086572,
0.492690891,
0.2486696392,
0.5399162173,
-0.0906008929,
-0.403031379,
-0.2510916293,
-0.1104470119,
0.515594542,
0.6705592275,
-0.0258556046,
-0.1094553694,
-0.186989516,
0.1259902716,
-0.1358008981,
-0.3253554106,
0.6991161704,
0.159148097,
-1.0171227455,
0.7185205221,
-0.1754526645,
0.6555140018,
-0.5625211,
0.3810468614,
-0.0409558751,
0.1829120815,
0.0130416369,
-0.7510674596,
-0.0839310437,
-0.1303709745,
-0.4639146626,
-0.1940659434,
0.4948863685,
-0.4006029367,
-0.4721769691,
0.6932247877,
0.558631897,
0.1012901366,
-0.181778416,
-0.7155871987,
-0.2910878658,
-0.1421401203,
-0.6257265806,
0.5589148998,
0.4549772739,
-0.409943372,
0.616404295,
0.7163712382,
0.1058691293,
0.3502674401,
0.0418503098,
0.5554800034,
-0.6560846567,
-0.6436519027,
-0.9140998125,
0.0887168646,
0.1357185394,
-0.1288295686,
0.6270068288,
0.1435767859,
0.6979293227,
-0.0613861792,
0.7354388237,
0.2239587307,
0.1222003251,
-0.391561389,
0.5878094435,
-0.605137229,
0.326407522,
-0.4979937077,
-0.9546565413,
-0.3781893849,
0.0028016365,
-0.5888983011,
-0.1050480157,
0.8472590446,
0.5045844316,
0.0601353124,
0.3693000376,
0.4423361719,
0.5105984807,
-0.1491487622,
0.3735949695,
0.9296988845,
0.0575049296,
0.5000104904,
-0.1963798851,
-0.1969024241,
-0.229159981,
-0.5949636698,
-0.7782382369,
-0.3517413139,
-0.0432995819,
-0.5064249039,
0.0360009484,
1.1328117847,
0.2498941571,
-0.9701731205,
-0.4327569604,
-0.6377727985,
0.272177726,
0.0568694212,
-0.2911071777,
0.1748119295,
-0.3451350629,
-0.5267923474,
0.1539124101,
0.3075849116,
0.2095452845,
-0.1318588853,
0.1724466383,
-0.4076799452,
0.7454831004,
0.7258967757,
0.2294686139,
-1.0607873201,
-0.3186638057,
-0.0020440805,
-0.3236518502,
0.0329588205,
0.9884630442,
-0.737193644,
0.3871923685,
0.6471007466,
0.1757105142,
0.0211636461,
-0.1773032695,
0.7668052912,
-0.4388898611,
0.2039850354,
-0.1155280173,
0.443413347,
-0.1357466131,
-0.2869078517,
0.1951652467,
0.5223887563,
-0.3017563224,
-0.6547272205,
0.687528491,
-0.6401874423,
-0.6429498196,
1.1441918612,
-0.0703056753,
-0.2056942433,
-0.0947058275,
0.060805779,
0.2853971124,
-0.1472279131,
0.9071713686,
0.8014692068,
-0.231757313,
0.3281308115,
-0.3707640171,
0.5046843886,
0.9621124268,
-0.5940628648,
0.1713979989,
0.254255265,
0.3700118065,
0.5638486147,
0.6146084666,
-0.0579774529,
0.1202528253,
-0.1274636984,
0.1804740429,
0.5325824618,
-0.3734831214,
-0.3699860275,
0.2390834093,
0.1850980967,
0.0839195624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12354v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12354v1
|
LoRA+: Efficient Low Rank Adaptation of Large Models
| 2024-02-19T18:33:49 | 2024-02-19T18:33:49 |
Soufiane Hayou, Nikhil Ghosh, Bin Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
In this paper, we show that Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA) as originally
introduced in Hu et al. (2021) leads to suboptimal finetuning of models with
large width (embedding dimension). This is due to the fact that adapter
matrices A and B in LoRA are updated with the same learning rate. Using scaling
arguments for large width networks, we demonstrate that using the same learning
rate for A and B does not allow efficient feature learning. We then show that
this suboptimality of LoRA can be corrected simply by setting different
learning rates for the LoRA adapter matrices A and B with a well-chosen ratio.
We call this proposed algorithm LoRA$+$. In our extensive experiments, LoRA$+$
improves performance (1-2 $\%$ improvements) and finetuning speed (up to $\sim$
2X SpeedUp), at the same computational cost as LoRA.
|
[
-0.4143104255,
-0.7812550664,
0.4210977554,
-0.0430857874,
-0.2794541419,
-0.2562711835,
-0.0583969355,
-0.6993686557,
0.6679305434,
0.3562462926,
-0.3358478844,
-0.0963197425,
-0.5616990328,
-0.3098967373,
-0.270698756,
0.8245916963,
0.1524768621,
0.1760581285,
0.1237861812,
-0.5910822749,
-0.306575954,
-0.3674429357,
-0.9222548604,
-0.3811237514,
1.2332100868,
0.6790006161,
0.8516667485,
0.7074150443,
0.7065627575,
0.3369256854,
-0.2809295058,
0.1680624634,
-0.8448960185,
-0.0460158363,
-0.1062118113,
-0.6456111073,
-1.0556838512,
-0.4002186954,
0.7156538367,
0.8859159946,
0.0370969288,
0.372441113,
0.1790884882,
1.101510644,
-0.9449548721,
-0.3455215096,
-0.7462539077,
0.1063887253,
-0.1025241837,
-0.2739882767,
-0.3319384754,
-0.5685392618,
0.0622128621,
-0.8636690974,
-0.0727057159,
-0.1998903602,
0.5615364909,
0.4982346892,
-0.1607986093,
0.0043795109,
-0.7035628557,
0.7257512212,
-0.5954611897,
0.1984891295,
0.0218394659,
0.6226717234,
0.112735875,
-0.5352958441,
-0.1682019234,
0.0628846213,
0.4145618975,
-0.0504800417,
-0.3607881963,
-0.114185594,
0.618362546,
0.3944672942,
-0.0083098924,
0.6527751088,
-0.6035817266,
0.1822452843,
0.7164626122,
0.0287584942,
-0.2779997289,
0.1967806369,
-0.2357121855,
-0.2441552281,
-0.9625480771,
0.2001411021,
0.3770751953,
0.5231065154,
-0.1942739785,
0.5106956363,
-0.0720214248,
0.5976739526,
0.106660597,
-0.2679602802,
0.4530575573,
0.171971634,
-0.2894568443,
0.2321204096,
0.2109322995,
0.192116186,
0.2068211883,
0.3176656067,
-0.0979208648,
0.0254063476,
-0.0520134047,
-0.9431729317,
-0.0996561795,
-0.124800764,
-0.6252611279,
-0.2840699255,
-0.2325617075,
-0.6798025966,
-0.8303940296,
-0.2713597119,
1.1884227991,
-0.0091583449,
0.0193578489,
0.1779207438,
-0.1180343255,
0.4874420762,
0.8529333472,
-0.7226046324,
0.4071204066,
0.5444806218,
0.8605372906,
-0.0222545899,
-0.2391875535,
-0.9856446981,
-0.2183662355,
-0.2990851104,
0.8262482882,
-0.2360643297,
-0.135541603,
-0.3574661911,
-0.0577028655,
-0.0232963432,
-0.5121489167,
0.3491821587,
-0.5736812949,
-0.1354906857,
-0.4761576951,
-0.2256177068,
-0.3154036105,
-0.0620638616,
-0.9284201264,
0.6547029018,
0.2322335392,
-0.6928027272,
0.349788636,
-1.2979199886,
-0.442273885,
-0.3973195255,
0.4706467092,
-0.594682157,
0.299716264,
0.1714591086,
0.1936178654,
-0.157670334,
-0.4284656644,
-0.7275100946,
-0.7638784051,
0.2234620899,
-0.3618113101,
0.6884310842,
0.1414823383,
-0.0160708409,
0.3782790303,
-0.9138718247,
0.0980346128,
0.0830695629,
-0.4407728612,
-0.4705626667,
0.038438946,
0.0287303068,
0.0090836938,
0.2261281759,
-0.4028239548,
0.4437967837,
-0.4099281728,
0.6169685125,
0.9509453177,
-0.0119553683,
0.6410523057,
-0.4659723043,
0.3241790831,
-0.0807763785,
0.336843431,
0.2060005367,
-0.3655770421,
-1.1290271282,
-0.3052664697,
0.6936240196,
0.3308507502,
-0.4278096259,
0.3345583379,
-0.4295027554,
-0.5228487253,
-0.5272303224,
0.27481094,
0.1085333526,
0.154727757,
0.6547173858,
-0.4759899378,
-0.6522441506,
-0.8186758757,
0.1315349191,
0.2179676741,
0.1384060234,
0.2005125433,
0.4846603274,
-0.0804352388,
0.567152679,
-0.7187633514,
-0.4059702456,
-0.3236468434,
-0.4360157251,
0.4467252195,
0.5442771316,
0.6983245611,
-0.5998924375,
-0.5266077518,
-0.0222012773,
-0.5205863118,
0.2857592702,
0.3093754947,
-0.1564690322,
0.0507203229,
0.496385932,
-0.2230247557,
0.3762835562,
0.8826791048,
-0.2368218601,
0.0151929995,
-0.5121665001,
-0.2951633036,
-1.2427998781,
-0.0270738285,
0.1760469228,
-0.424134016,
-0.3097676635,
-0.0070815543,
-0.1070062965,
-0.3002147079,
-0.4878388941,
0.439345181,
-0.2297701836,
-0.543592453,
-0.2153303921,
0.2404978126,
0.0593124293,
0.627053082,
-0.4255503416,
0.5997927785,
0.5146521926,
-0.6565060616,
0.2050679177,
0.2033839226,
-0.3934708238,
0.6109675765,
-0.5759371519,
0.0669076443,
-0.0806752741,
0.3520591259,
-0.5551738143,
-0.1226008907,
-0.0467696376,
-0.0291621312,
0.0889727101,
-0.3054424524,
-0.0446588062,
-0.2033327222,
-0.6573048234,
0.3843929768,
0.729152739,
-0.81053859,
0.574339211,
0.4146595299,
0.2296154052,
-0.5717018247,
-0.6321895123,
-0.3912836015,
-0.4692512453,
-0.4367979765,
0.1264693737,
-0.2402029634,
-0.2100290954,
-0.0375072211,
0.1059428602,
0.0317835137,
0.5137766004,
0.3271963298,
-0.0706338137,
-0.6968752146,
-0.1096216366,
0.1805518866,
-0.1926013082,
-0.3792441189,
-0.0883897319,
0.5158436298,
0.0431702882,
-0.44124946,
-0.6229874492,
0.0929641724,
0.7940627337,
-0.1166754067,
0.7582703829,
0.7174075842,
-0.3611189425,
-0.2265063375,
-0.2904974222,
-0.1657978892,
-0.4794794619,
0.6713605523,
-0.5499240756,
-0.6204403639,
0.8303185701,
-0.1338757426,
-0.1609615386,
0.6408294439,
0.2283776402,
-0.0660556853,
0.9470165968,
1.109177351,
-0.2614676952,
0.8495865464,
-0.668331027,
0.0754378885,
-1.1115921736,
0.1878780127,
-0.500608027,
-1.0812748671,
-0.9110248089,
-0.3549186289,
0.6147709489,
0.3562446237,
-0.4823221862,
0.3565277159,
-0.2608127594,
0.4892129898,
0.5436798334,
0.5575066805,
0.4389331043,
0.1913855374,
0.4060500264,
0.187998265,
-0.9245877862,
0.2410138994,
1.0963103771,
0.5200407505,
1.1124756336,
0.4341736436,
0.5652509928,
0.4180291891,
0.4244245589,
-1.1467849016,
0.3584503233,
-0.6515151262,
-0.2593565881,
-0.6513742208,
-0.37677899,
-1.0146460533,
0.2037283778,
-0.5530412793,
-0.6497832537,
0.803823173,
0.3015118539,
-0.6157633662,
0.4105923474,
-0.8262875676,
0.6230561137,
-0.0939516872,
-0.353617847,
-0.5697287917,
-0.1959815025,
0.1663344949,
-0.3784050345,
0.1026862338,
-0.0862405896,
0.0276164208,
0.9116359353,
-0.482966572,
0.6776787043,
-0.6016325951,
-0.1671948582,
0.0657825768,
-0.0860233679,
0.6323795915,
0.077002272,
-0.4460638165,
-0.1552680135,
-0.2343612313,
-0.5676832795,
-0.6405122876,
0.9770169854,
-1.0393320322,
-0.4013730288,
-0.0411188565,
-0.6322573423,
-0.2814046144,
0.0335863493,
0.1672717929,
0.6957114339,
-0.0975329056,
0.5764222741,
0.6989176273,
-0.1215708479,
0.4098017514,
0.2842909694,
-0.2551298738,
-0.3936806917,
1.0752581358,
0.5426853895,
0.3975789845,
0.4540061355,
0.3043082952,
0.1277579665,
-0.6046251059,
-0.4117068946,
0.1426187307,
-0.7752283812,
-0.3910326362,
-0.3151072264,
-0.377738446,
0.2574372292,
-0.3951992989,
-0.5552057624,
-0.803578496,
-0.1254117936,
0.2315412313,
0.7372052073,
0.6239666343,
-0.2515707016,
0.6111633778,
-0.3302272856,
0.2408432066,
0.5482359529,
0.2806901932,
0.2403548509,
-0.9393931031,
-0.4913771749,
-0.0242830254,
-0.2654251158,
-0.3023481071,
-0.1129109263,
0.5068180561,
0.3695810139,
0.4339692593,
-0.0722216219,
0.8740152717,
-0.3247632682,
0.342990905,
0.2466241419,
-0.8697877526,
0.3215386868,
-0.2759492099,
0.3606005609,
0.4265191257,
0.2349416763,
-0.0917167291,
0.249761343,
-0.4135873318,
-0.6616106033,
0.5777071118,
-0.2636786997,
0.3385953903,
0.7924251556,
0.3668701947,
0.0992429852,
-0.2683245838,
-0.6701958179,
-0.1714128256,
-0.1696656495,
0.022551015,
-0.3192531466,
-0.4292469919,
-0.1900266856,
-0.4252748787,
0.7567946911,
-0.4653206468,
0.4184610248,
0.1084756777,
-0.343768239,
-0.3601601124,
0.2816328704,
0.5610113144,
1.0266939402,
-0.4735610187,
-0.1758841127,
0.6630043387,
-0.3343417943,
0.0277067777,
0.0876212344,
-0.1086609215,
-0.3801498115,
0.4193831682,
1.1467883587,
0.3986642063,
-0.1382237822,
0.4594246149,
0.0476619937,
-0.2737262845,
-0.0456202179,
0.4624701142,
0.0251007006,
0.5835161209,
0.5254430771,
0.4065259695,
-0.0239990167,
-0.5584264994,
-0.2013236582,
0.4030007422,
-0.4663659632,
-0.3067804277,
0.3374534249,
0.195622161,
-0.2362368703,
0.1144925952,
0.0713154897,
-0.2141914666,
0.6311728954,
0.5617194176,
0.5423979759,
-0.2334000766,
0.0297977068,
0.4512584209,
0.0216541067,
-0.2647253871,
0.2186527103,
0.1864563376,
-0.6701285243,
-0.6062886715,
-0.6939629912,
-0.5361458063,
0.2646446526,
-0.7506084442,
0.4675133228,
-0.6069731712,
-0.2154667675,
0.3795275092,
0.2037843466,
-0.5472336411,
0.0080589876,
0.0955930054,
1.1055719852,
-0.9222899079,
0.9458876848,
0.5648392439,
-0.183097437,
-0.7053011656,
-0.1692743003,
-0.2822889388,
-0.7404310703,
0.3744841218,
-0.0593325906,
-0.2386945933,
0.3271583319,
-0.326761663,
-1.1716942787,
1.2834836245,
0.5955672264,
-0.5570416451,
-0.0807707161,
-0.290084511,
0.4893971086,
-0.4787605703,
-0.1092837378,
0.2699165642,
0.3992210627,
-0.0269981232,
-0.9392515421,
-0.0618541725,
0.0378869623,
0.0199530199,
0.2450270951,
-0.7482694983,
1.0713917017,
-0.5544121861,
0.3611249328,
0.474696964,
0.5014185309,
-0.0576717742,
0.1247297227,
0.6859990358,
0.5775797367,
0.7763285041,
0.1319399625,
0.8261993527,
0.0961037129,
0.4638323784,
0.9170491695,
-0.2597749531,
1.1325463057,
0.3175269067,
-0.2776777744,
0.7057840824,
0.3877057731,
-0.0433343314,
0.5257198811,
0.0677477941,
0.1138934344,
-0.242005229,
-0.025522491,
-0.7315275073,
0.6488060355,
0.3181933463,
-0.4275496602,
-0.2680898905,
0.2701284587,
-0.2027857155,
-0.1069398448,
-0.8991569877,
0.7371429205,
0.1690847874,
-0.2231159806,
0.9523394704,
-0.0317623392,
0.6556302309,
-0.6140632033,
0.0056760721,
-0.4104659259,
0.7194186449,
-0.4404100776,
-0.3790129423,
-0.0419810303,
-0.1062795296,
-0.4370404184,
0.3996444046,
0.5766011477,
0.0865652934,
-0.6455838084,
0.4471158087,
0.5780626535,
-0.0936064422,
0.1407037973,
-0.6418893933,
0.249652639,
-0.12006668,
-0.2945912182,
0.6453273296,
0.2943896949,
-0.4052804708,
0.658770442,
0.800013721,
0.0333849229,
-0.1646995544,
0.2132052481,
1.1203688383,
-0.5285562277,
-0.5259480476,
-0.6337077618,
0.2890662551,
0.0585790053,
-0.1066535339,
0.5112073421,
0.4753729701,
0.5613737702,
0.030609386,
0.4742909372,
0.0152324159,
0.3402921259,
-0.7459664941,
0.72012043,
-0.7800869942,
0.212502718,
-0.3186834455,
-1.4045695066,
-0.2618667483,
0.6513662934,
-0.4964520335,
0.0328601189,
0.6963763833,
0.6581784487,
-0.5827897191,
-0.3875569999,
0.4009385705,
0.4032539129,
0.0516680032,
0.7390921712,
0.5032668114,
-0.8222091198,
0.3706443012,
-0.1691317111,
-0.1519141048,
-0.6553654075,
-0.8757314086,
-0.660341084,
-0.2993190289,
-0.283534497,
-0.4798237383,
0.2800684869,
0.8807599545,
0.9153423309,
-0.7410577536,
-0.1160357147,
0.3529102206,
0.3265107572,
-0.4615181386,
-0.104640089,
0.6604717374,
0.0893168524,
-0.582736671,
0.3510634005,
-0.0931521133,
-0.1370740235,
-0.3654128909,
-0.3749566078,
-0.1077867597,
0.1458332241,
0.7349607944,
0.4369709492,
-0.1959210783,
-0.4653024971,
-0.4134178162,
0.0148421256,
0.4409029782,
0.5988413692,
-0.785353303,
0.007441218,
0.3768486977,
0.535304606,
0.7344751358,
-0.0536105037,
0.1481160969,
-0.3821855187,
0.4963797033,
-0.2321290523,
0.4208436906,
0.4081054628,
-0.1639542729,
0.5265051126,
0.0197942685,
-0.4327734709,
-0.9719669819,
0.1849296987,
-1.2566194534,
-0.0877343118,
0.9016491175,
0.039474532,
-0.4305081964,
0.3315886855,
-0.2218021452,
0.0529962406,
-0.2860615551,
0.5607514977,
-0.1108841151,
-0.1996150017,
0.0254495069,
-0.5266817808,
0.4813641906,
0.1736985296,
-0.7955556512,
-0.2777762711,
0.1445996463,
0.4466821849,
0.363871187,
0.273303628,
0.0027483832,
0.4752797484,
-0.1625157148,
-0.2672292292,
-0.1691955179,
-0.3492003083,
-0.6236219406,
0.2209019214,
0.6673355103,
-0.0460094623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12352v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12352v1
|
Graph-Based Retriever Captures the Long Tail of Biomedical Knowledge
| 2024-02-19T18:31:11 | 2024-02-19T18:31:11 |
Julien Delile, Srayanta Mukherjee, Anton Van Pamel, Leonid Zhukov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) are transforming the way information is
retrieved with vast amounts of knowledge being summarized and presented via
natural language conversations. Yet, LLMs are prone to highlight the most
frequently seen pieces of information from the training set and to neglect the
rare ones. In the field of biomedical research, latest discoveries are key to
academic and industrial actors and are obscured by the abundance of an
ever-increasing literature corpus (the information overload problem). Surfacing
new associations between biomedical entities, e.g., drugs, genes, diseases,
with LLMs becomes a challenge of capturing the long-tail knowledge of the
biomedical scientific production. To overcome this challenge, Retrieval
Augmented Generation (RAG) has been proposed to alleviate some of the
shortcomings of LLMs by augmenting the prompts with context retrieved from
external datasets. RAG methods typically select the context via maximum
similarity search over text embeddings. In this study, we show that RAG methods
leave out a significant proportion of relevant information due to clusters of
over-represented concepts in the biomedical literature. We introduce a novel
information-retrieval method that leverages a knowledge graph to downsample
these clusters and mitigate the information overload problem. Its retrieval
performance is about twice better than embedding similarity alternatives on
both precision and recall. Finally, we demonstrate that both embedding
similarity and knowledge graph retrieval methods can be advantageously combined
into a hybrid model that outperforms both, enabling potential improvements to
biomedical question-answering models.
|
[
-0.3491476178,
-0.9236543775,
0.7432111502,
-0.4186711311,
-0.2829611301,
0.5386821628,
0.0991841406,
-0.6007186174,
0.670891881,
0.6591879129,
-0.1327014267,
-0.5374653935,
-0.6602145433,
0.1640276462,
-0.3574904799,
1.0676118135,
0.1561867446,
-0.1097893938,
-0.6965085268,
-0.3142949939,
-0.1194771901,
-0.4116224349,
-0.7261530161,
-0.7554050684,
0.7582011223,
-0.1388458163,
0.3639020324,
0.5830117464,
0.3978840709,
0.176250875,
-0.5198923945,
0.5242267251,
-0.9109222293,
0.0442683473,
-0.3716464043,
-0.2613662183,
-0.2411237061,
-0.3460017741,
0.7415508032,
0.9998221397,
0.1922135949,
0.1864054501,
0.0570527539,
0.9379905462,
-0.6129587889,
0.2127231807,
-0.6342622042,
-0.1257793009,
-0.3391422629,
-0.5160320997,
-0.4154979587,
-0.320872426,
-0.048806265,
-0.6255792975,
0.2095866203,
0.2065654248,
0.8163523674,
0.2471980602,
-0.6465932727,
-0.28470999,
-0.2998583019,
0.5779877305,
-0.4213109612,
0.3209905028,
0.2894133031,
0.2234360278,
-0.3979447484,
-0.8537498713,
-0.4368581772,
-0.0439227335,
-0.4226205349,
0.1149547324,
-0.2292831838,
0.0450375006,
0.3357299864,
0.211211592,
-0.5157403946,
-0.0880891755,
-0.5339607,
-0.175809294,
0.3147040009,
0.0681177825,
0.2322589904,
-0.437151581,
-0.3134931326,
0.0066392398,
-0.9611276388,
-0.1070780531,
-0.1206390858,
0.2514363825,
0.3260037303,
0.7597518563,
-0.052060388,
0.963968277,
0.0255987141,
-0.12485715,
0.5977879763,
-0.3008114696,
0.1097993851,
0.070469819,
0.7105907798,
0.3360443115,
-0.2080970258,
-0.3315233886,
0.1443322599,
-0.1896359324,
0.1050869972,
-0.9349780083,
0.1311073005,
0.2427363843,
-0.3994574547,
-0.0804326087,
-0.286493361,
-0.9547281265,
-0.7372068167,
0.0184199214,
0.3646604419,
-0.6214835048,
-0.0482882597,
-0.061025165,
-0.6662216783,
0.0891925693,
0.0849571675,
-0.3130731583,
0.1969409436,
0.7243884802,
0.9674941301,
-0.3119846284,
0.2079517841,
-0.7179621458,
0.6288218498,
-0.2545768619,
0.688237071,
-0.619908154,
-0.6603901386,
-0.2662290633,
-0.0381904021,
-0.0857481584,
-0.6548970342,
0.2277658731,
-0.8501213193,
-0.0026104003,
-0.4557528496,
-0.8935769796,
-0.1623478681,
0.3641316891,
-0.6369906664,
0.9685104489,
0.1811196506,
-1.330701232,
0.386962831,
-0.4548081458,
-0.5318724513,
0.1910683811,
-0.6552500129,
-0.4972246289,
-0.229988724,
0.2715055346,
0.2526059151,
-0.353684485,
0.2648506761,
-0.5231454968,
-0.333886534,
0.102207303,
0.2220153511,
0.6705813408,
0.056993477,
0.0914554372,
-0.0896875113,
-0.7776471972,
-0.0384001136,
0.2190515697,
-0.3180793822,
-0.8443924189,
-0.0135162352,
-0.4798428118,
0.1134891137,
0.299806416,
-1.0509634018,
0.2475857735,
-0.5237842798,
0.5100637674,
0.3081134856,
0.3469752371,
0.2647718787,
-0.5358191729,
0.2733023167,
0.0279967077,
-0.3324984908,
-0.0585947111,
-0.4871536791,
-0.3459948897,
-0.397177279,
0.2695714831,
0.3385972977,
-0.9243049622,
0.4315372407,
-0.5322066545,
-0.4107254148,
-0.6778655052,
0.0866679698,
0.309143126,
1.0528841019,
0.6688942909,
-0.1579000205,
-0.4553376138,
-0.7663909197,
-0.0438345261,
0.0632738546,
-0.0453447811,
0.6866098642,
0.4175384641,
-0.5117807388,
1.1468782425,
-0.796688199,
-0.2888984084,
-0.336735338,
0.1529448777,
0.4006130099,
0.2793540359,
0.5274523497,
-0.8769310713,
-0.2496479303,
0.1789449453,
-0.7238754034,
0.0254776888,
0.3168471754,
-0.3046775162,
-0.0042519448,
0.7120419741,
-0.7627031207,
0.3825959265,
0.3025208116,
-0.1713742167,
0.269031167,
-0.3286812901,
0.1433379054,
-1.1879348755,
0.6912404895,
-0.2820900083,
-0.3675791323,
-0.2792788446,
-0.0725399479,
0.1378976554,
-0.2255782336,
0.0169393569,
0.8980468512,
-0.4810552597,
-0.2256073505,
-0.386924088,
0.2445243895,
0.431558311,
0.0962217897,
-0.0192851424,
0.6529481411,
0.2691947818,
-0.5830239058,
0.1528143585,
0.4925686717,
-0.0351692848,
0.3424449563,
-0.5892960429,
0.2279031724,
-0.6652754545,
0.5852331519,
-0.8767989874,
-0.17460756,
-0.0308688581,
-0.5469381213,
0.699183166,
-0.2936298549,
-0.496414274,
-0.8244205713,
-0.2804026008,
0.4397172928,
0.606760323,
-0.5495755076,
0.6923725009,
0.7381139994,
-0.2319720685,
-0.7434134483,
-0.4276874661,
-0.125507921,
-0.1179139391,
-0.4796272814,
0.4521547258,
0.1358149946,
0.0366553068,
0.1005367786,
-0.0566403084,
0.0650107339,
-0.2692214847,
0.0423062742,
0.272123158,
0.0469851494,
0.544598937,
0.2293070108,
-0.1695258766,
-0.13188155,
-0.2769379616,
0.574364841,
0.3302274346,
-0.3246782124,
0.2276737243,
0.384775579,
0.3269607425,
-0.3016326427,
0.6658334732,
0.5628486872,
-0.3062130809,
0.0471221507,
-0.5006425977,
-0.3075073361,
-0.4310986102,
0.6877807379,
-0.1568361521,
-1.0256407261,
0.5367242098,
-0.4535476267,
-0.1612844169,
0.4344015718,
0.261285007,
-0.1453497708,
0.9587313533,
0.4409318864,
-0.1768283546,
0.1556859761,
-0.3883064687,
0.0668134913,
-1.0545704365,
-0.3198312819,
-0.5374415517,
-0.2171137631,
-0.4219376147,
-0.636659801,
0.8038066626,
0.2017352879,
-0.2385033667,
0.0305069201,
-0.5521268249,
0.2953788042,
0.5508989096,
0.4287222922,
0.4580215514,
0.0041861115,
-0.2897781134,
0.1739262044,
-0.9747948647,
-0.1197297797,
1.0853512287,
0.1147490516,
0.7456871271,
-0.1098580807,
0.9398183823,
0.0583259389,
0.2965377569,
-0.5778517723,
0.4665830731,
-0.2521789968,
-0.6360189319,
-0.2853243351,
-0.866599381,
-1.4386692047,
0.0227192547,
-0.2966755033,
-0.758880496,
0.1737173051,
0.180903703,
-0.2788360417,
0.4771662652,
-0.2332734764,
0.5495988131,
0.0117861116,
-0.3350769281,
-0.1669104993,
-0.8537644148,
0.1997580975,
-0.302257359,
0.4526863992,
0.0120138861,
0.0022204258,
0.7269502878,
-0.3815512657,
0.6725870371,
-0.1640857309,
0.1691072881,
0.4008114338,
0.0324106179,
0.6797229648,
-0.21236296,
-0.0701979175,
-0.107682541,
0.0712750927,
-0.4522298276,
-0.590793252,
0.7013958693,
-0.5172387958,
-0.5115861893,
-0.1761544794,
-0.6271746159,
-0.3705771267,
0.4362264574,
0.4116493165,
0.4974779189,
0.0467509292,
0.2148316354,
0.6702389121,
-0.6455834508,
-0.0844910517,
0.4404191077,
-0.5298948288,
-0.3927585781,
1.0673441887,
0.2789470255,
0.3129844964,
0.5192864537,
0.2639181912,
-0.4610280395,
-0.5115596056,
-0.339907825,
0.6088298559,
-0.5687842369,
-0.4625909925,
-1.0176733732,
-0.2950730324,
-0.4671342969,
0.0007568572,
-0.2109221667,
-0.3239422739,
-0.2279905528,
-0.1707626581,
0.7723339796,
0.7066655159,
-0.1109630615,
-0.1050595865,
-0.9891433716,
0.4967703819,
0.138088122,
0.3498595357,
-0.045316156,
-0.2482612133,
-0.2412820309,
-0.0139828995,
-0.1461578161,
-0.8914704323,
0.3658779562,
0.0699526519,
0.6278584599,
0.0865008608,
0.0853519812,
0.6249133348,
-0.5060632229,
0.2985135913,
0.2542876005,
-0.283387959,
0.4108445048,
-0.4674755931,
0.0384620912,
0.4517284334,
0.4749878049,
-0.3851210475,
-0.4299736917,
-0.6488453746,
-1.1186243296,
0.2474809438,
-0.0153840156,
-0.1955653131,
-0.3550917506,
0.4036731124,
0.0822479352,
0.2735976577,
-0.2562744021,
-0.2742093503,
0.1835981309,
-0.2935449779,
-0.0646878481,
-0.1671157181,
-0.3823912144,
-0.1865549386,
0.5661495328,
-0.2589365542,
0.3525291979,
0.3928391933,
0.0315186866,
-0.1480543762,
0.2075945884,
0.0272398293,
0.4913148284,
-0.3706310987,
0.1091094464,
0.1152948365,
-0.3663833737,
-0.1536429226,
0.5710705519,
-0.4160659313,
0.1115699783,
0.2329006195,
0.4911783338,
0.0464583449,
-0.8135641813,
0.4273906648,
0.4791330397,
0.1378198266,
-0.0047246502,
-0.0914939567,
0.2672592402,
0.2818263173,
0.6297808886,
-0.182118535,
0.4350865483,
-0.4258953929,
0.5130516291,
0.6932002306,
-0.3401688635,
0.1564033777,
0.5892956853,
-0.0155367199,
0.0975868553,
0.3274965286,
-0.1472932398,
-0.3952535391,
0.6609928012,
0.6718703508,
0.1473950893,
0.3480669856,
0.1344542205,
0.4892269075,
-0.2427669764,
0.0904106125,
0.1517332792,
0.2768125534,
-0.5469887853,
-0.6643688083,
-0.7001992464,
-0.1848687828,
0.0818745121,
-0.6107571721,
0.1087927595,
-0.1139760986,
-0.5804048181,
0.0819875821,
0.0816150159,
-0.4309769571,
-0.0279584415,
-0.003091085,
0.8386995196,
-0.5075281858,
0.7241660953,
0.5971651673,
-0.4827482104,
-0.5957545042,
-0.3503635526,
-0.2332247198,
-0.8979657888,
0.7320504189,
0.0135902911,
0.0185179226,
0.3282864392,
-0.3886820972,
-1.1034595966,
1.1390011311,
0.2492293119,
-0.5334483385,
-0.4101985097,
-0.1120664626,
0.6096932888,
-0.2007853538,
0.1170267835,
0.4290277362,
0.3135460317,
0.4657006264,
-0.8411421776,
0.111380972,
-0.1937259734,
-0.2997732162,
0.6460300684,
-0.5721434355,
0.7424230576,
-0.3784509301,
-0.1739753634,
0.1309047192,
0.2870106101,
0.8003185391,
0.6340171099,
0.1426853985,
0.6091121435,
1.0446392298,
0.1782462299,
1.2648977041,
-0.3646774888,
0.4525948465,
1.0743482113,
-0.2523209453,
0.6559106708,
0.6457716823,
-0.2014854699,
0.4406874776,
0.337959826,
0.1447365284,
0.426017195,
0.281878382,
-0.0485369675,
-0.1615441293,
-0.375366509,
-0.6923707724,
-0.0879700333,
0.6799510717,
-0.6695364714,
-0.3853469491,
0.062947467,
-0.0102886381,
0.0952164158,
-0.4401889741,
0.8873721361,
0.2455462962,
-0.4140943587,
0.6318663955,
-0.5149368048,
0.4915564656,
-0.5918482542,
-0.2337971628,
-0.0842750594,
0.0497797839,
-0.0386684425,
-0.8293840289,
0.0592636839,
-0.319034189,
-0.1459622383,
0.2340442687,
1.0165565014,
-0.5120218992,
-0.5970098376,
0.6667233109,
0.6633231044,
0.2024877965,
0.2604175508,
-0.5269671679,
-0.1827857792,
-0.1032724231,
-0.0328968689,
0.3549905419,
0.4580039084,
-0.0067963824,
0.8349894285,
0.5939386487,
0.4618884027,
-0.1193741933,
-0.0238894168,
1.2089636326,
-0.690813601,
-0.3574713767,
-0.5385346413,
0.0399122015,
-0.4856247902,
0.1847133338,
0.5301280022,
0.8020151854,
0.4675536752,
0.1623778641,
0.8910714984,
-0.0134523809,
1.3407388926,
-0.374024719,
0.7973723412,
-0.6813042164,
0.0550558083,
-0.3287053704,
-0.4759246707,
-0.23399809,
0.2965449691,
-0.411175549,
0.0756099671,
0.4686805606,
0.5933995843,
0.0048603662,
-0.2545003295,
0.1739828289,
0.4225947857,
0.2980957627,
0.522990346,
0.5101083517,
-0.0746577159,
0.5992325544,
0.1598588526,
-0.1680241227,
-0.2243122607,
-0.6514941454,
-0.8770759702,
-0.3026949465,
-0.079472661,
-0.6725450754,
0.3301248848,
0.719753027,
0.4348288178,
-0.5502905846,
0.2042028457,
0.0466025919,
0.0818397924,
0.1045637876,
-0.2023678273,
0.7051318288,
-0.3475671411,
-0.3087002635,
0.3462165892,
0.1790401787,
0.1440779418,
0.0858346224,
-0.0132907778,
-0.3323467374,
-0.0594126768,
0.5497477651,
0.5568343997,
-0.2625985742,
-0.1747832596,
0.0492476225,
-0.2418469489,
0.2511839867,
0.6955356002,
-1.2275611162,
0.5297112465,
0.5975854993,
0.9504354596,
0.9886901975,
0.2308747768,
0.5124486685,
-0.8179542422,
0.1725787222,
0.4132531583,
0.3528594375,
0.4509150982,
-0.4450962543,
0.5203564167,
0.3365681171,
-0.5444331765,
-0.668579936,
0.2099340856,
-0.8898622394,
-0.5267615318,
1.2035360336,
0.1010613889,
-0.3474300802,
-0.2833481729,
-0.2907628119,
0.5478251576,
-0.3314439654,
0.800763607,
0.230314225,
-0.2735022902,
0.3068486452,
-0.4292058945,
0.5351153016,
0.1632422656,
-0.6609178185,
0.0379249081,
0.5384374261,
0.2682460546,
0.4216301441,
0.8784834146,
-0.317666918,
0.0112021742,
-0.1474430561,
-0.0719013438,
-0.0803658664,
-0.029707808,
0.1342755258,
0.2937060297,
-0.1093219966,
0.0977778211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12348v2
|
GTBench: Uncovering the Strategic Reasoning Limitations of LLMs via Game-Theoretic Evaluations
| 2024-02-19T18:23:36 | 2024-06-10T17:14:09 |
Jinhao Duan, Renming Zhang, James Diffenderfer, Bhavya Kailkhura, Lichao Sun, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal, Tianlong Chen, Kaidi Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are integrated into critical real-world
applications, their strategic and logical reasoning abilities are increasingly
crucial. This paper evaluates LLMs' reasoning abilities in competitive
environments through game-theoretic tasks, e.g., board and card games that
require pure logic and strategic reasoning to compete with opponents. We first
propose GTBench, a language-driven environment composing 10 widely recognized
tasks, across a comprehensive game taxonomy: complete versus incomplete
information, dynamic versus static, and probabilistic versus deterministic
scenarios. Then, we (1) Characterize the game-theoretic reasoning of LLMs; and
(2) Perform LLM-vs.-LLM competitions as reasoning evaluation. We observe that
(1) LLMs have distinct behaviors regarding various gaming scenarios; for
example, LLMs fail in complete and deterministic games yet they are competitive
in probabilistic gaming scenarios; (2) Most open-source LLMs, e.g.,
CodeLlama-34b-Instruct and Llama-2-70b-chat, are less competitive than
commercial LLMs, e.g., GPT-4, in complex games, yet the recently released
Llama-3-70b-Instruct makes up for this shortcoming. In addition,
code-pretraining greatly benefits strategic reasoning, while advanced reasoning
methods such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and Tree-of-Thought (ToT) do not always
help. We further characterize the game-theoretic properties of LLMs, such as
equilibrium and Pareto Efficiency in repeated games. Detailed error profiles
are provided for a better understanding of LLMs' behavior. We hope our research
provides standardized protocols and serves as a foundation to spur further
explorations in the strategic reasoning of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3938389719,
-0.892954886,
1.0233308077,
0.3398109674,
-0.043759346,
0.4332174063,
-0.4660201967,
-0.3462177217,
-0.0270809978,
0.3178406954,
-0.6530382633,
-0.6837597489,
-0.3997332752,
-0.2113447934,
-0.0796230957,
0.7304521203,
-0.0783655867,
0.0031470405,
-0.4154209197,
-0.071994938,
-0.548156321,
-0.6784368753,
-0.6599341035,
-0.6249585748,
0.1488524079,
0.507006526,
0.7937532663,
0.543327868,
0.7180565,
0.3954815269,
-0.0705606714,
-0.0575964265,
-0.8241127729,
0.3706693649,
-0.5326254368,
-0.7364550829,
-0.3485817611,
0.1163032725,
0.3706823289,
0.3145830035,
-0.5286491513,
0.1769901663,
0.0439657681,
0.3874858618,
-0.4939748347,
0.3502499461,
-0.689576745,
0.2186136693,
-0.2825953662,
-0.2448846996,
-0.398082763,
-0.294916749,
0.0949066356,
-0.8565908074,
-0.1517239213,
0.1158439219,
0.8311810493,
0.1509399414,
0.0288955793,
-0.5462524891,
-0.8262092471,
0.7015301585,
-0.5196918249,
0.167740643,
-0.0242238324,
0.6078222394,
-0.5172116756,
-0.6230555773,
-0.3866957128,
-0.5034290552,
0.1747299135,
0.4976122379,
-0.4021926522,
0.3017181158,
0.4927770495,
0.0457664765,
-0.5223199129,
0.1561984271,
-0.0563539639,
0.1542129368,
0.619718492,
0.3504288495,
0.2491835803,
0.01456476,
-0.5244464874,
0.0519619621,
-0.6782346368,
0.0148852328,
0.3482605815,
-0.3255991638,
0.1433129162,
0.4899797142,
-0.0592725091,
0.3255747259,
0.0777415782,
-0.2663637102,
-0.2941244245,
-0.2202824205,
-0.1451952159,
-0.050739307,
0.6979508996,
0.4264488518,
0.3412437439,
-0.4323275685,
-0.1058373675,
0.3757187724,
0.0271719974,
-0.4230676889,
-0.3275815845,
0.2219256908,
-0.4237066209,
-0.2226406485,
-0.2595514059,
-0.917542696,
-0.4054944515,
-0.0636305362,
0.3610692918,
-0.311745882,
0.0259135943,
0.3080863953,
-0.5000974536,
0.3927985728,
0.1732556224,
-0.7061660886,
0.4171887338,
0.9029762149,
0.6478772163,
-0.2836621702,
-0.3349350095,
-0.3943737149,
0.4123096168,
-0.3288890123,
0.993994534,
-0.5781347156,
-0.5313363075,
-0.3518955112,
-0.4878507257,
0.1120479181,
-0.8279377818,
0.8003101945,
-0.4513252378,
-0.0913593769,
-0.509080112,
-0.5393078923,
0.1609763652,
0.6392897964,
-0.4633576274,
0.817199111,
-0.3613193035,
-0.4770461321,
0.373277545,
-0.6962934732,
-0.4305090308,
0.4003902376,
-0.4057564437,
0.0986639559,
0.1919217855,
-0.0482589714,
0.0818609223,
-0.6458351016,
0.4871875048,
-0.6275030375,
-0.538736403,
0.2960627079,
-0.3010757565,
0.8146455288,
0.0807659924,
-0.6591552496,
0.3255087137,
-0.3519809842,
0.4724029601,
0.3837729692,
-0.4277110696,
0.0642118752,
0.7405195832,
-0.6180612445,
0.3789893985,
0.1065333337,
-0.1974675804,
0.2201053202,
-0.1289266348,
0.5863282681,
0.910652101,
-0.2101595104,
0.2234482616,
-0.2873474061,
0.6188795567,
-0.4505924881,
0.3731741309,
0.5462172627,
-0.4355722666,
-0.753382802,
-0.2420862019,
0.2326964438,
1.0025422573,
-0.9165769815,
0.2977757156,
-0.4403462708,
-0.6085731387,
0.0271270219,
-0.0120387981,
0.2782773972,
0.179967016,
0.0566693321,
-0.1765879393,
-0.5597886443,
-0.7123933434,
-0.3012974262,
-0.3557899594,
0.2083996981,
0.5764265656,
0.5405284166,
-0.0667435005,
0.6041994691,
-0.3346621692,
-0.1033955961,
-0.6440167427,
-0.0869112015,
0.1417185664,
0.2047142833,
0.2836838663,
-0.0809531659,
-0.091715157,
-0.1309843808,
-0.9746749997,
-0.1658119559,
-0.2256485224,
-0.4386649728,
-0.1901426315,
0.5654056668,
-0.8165487051,
0.3475459218,
0.4718531668,
-0.2913978696,
0.7579260468,
-0.3042303026,
-0.071502924,
-0.2526466846,
-0.0138154151,
-0.2244661748,
0.0516003817,
-0.4000597,
0.5705635548,
-0.5670740008,
0.0935288742,
0.0212323051,
0.4558182657,
-0.4568114877,
-0.3150150776,
-0.0655357242,
0.6690963507,
-0.1342086941,
0.3377985358,
0.2834289968,
0.74076581,
0.3385416269,
-0.4624959826,
0.7909250855,
0.0250168983,
-0.5940710306,
0.6488255858,
-0.7284494042,
0.0333139785,
0.1405292004,
0.3454743922,
-0.8951253295,
0.145776704,
0.374035269,
-0.2158205807,
-0.1948603988,
0.0196892004,
-0.6519052386,
-0.4536217749,
-0.224869132,
0.0752705112,
0.4614073634,
-0.4517172277,
0.5952981114,
0.345595777,
-0.0042856829,
-0.5318686962,
-0.6799435616,
0.2421029657,
-0.3690467179,
-0.5932210684,
0.2474700958,
-0.1826627105,
-0.5566351414,
0.0440085381,
-0.2924983203,
0.0993732363,
0.3382759094,
0.0263634305,
0.2452039719,
-0.2431242913,
-0.0964926705,
-0.2755970955,
-0.0838801414,
0.5355911851,
-0.319934994,
0.3439145684,
-0.4678468704,
-0.5223112702,
0.2636469305,
0.1898583919,
0.1262512058,
-0.1230231747,
0.3941718042,
0.2242520303,
-0.0120827295,
-0.4202183485,
-0.6249022484,
0.0166728385,
-0.4818450511,
0.4358619452,
-0.4738958776,
-0.78931427,
0.727899313,
-0.3849749267,
-0.088778466,
0.4410013556,
0.5252817273,
-0.2570937872,
0.9225815535,
0.1563997269,
0.1600179076,
0.0520773605,
-0.0894983262,
0.1178237721,
-0.5008069277,
-0.4459610283,
-0.2884891927,
-0.6293255091,
-0.5554074049,
-0.5439896584,
0.3149071932,
0.2131486386,
-0.4894542694,
-0.0868986547,
-0.2371951342,
1.0639395714,
0.5878232718,
0.1773222387,
0.2864863276,
-0.160493806,
-0.5474099517,
-0.0358523577,
-1.0612914562,
-0.45577842,
0.9231778979,
0.1807710975,
0.656314373,
0.4246879518,
0.7059226036,
0.1525774002,
0.2801375985,
-0.7338591814,
0.9949902296,
0.1188082322,
-0.8839578032,
-0.2483725697,
-0.6349723935,
-0.7411368489,
0.1290377825,
-0.3057121038,
-0.8355227113,
0.05572588,
-0.0753889382,
-0.4335046709,
0.479876399,
-0.4584040046,
0.9882725477,
-0.8191467524,
-0.6563310027,
-0.4053973258,
-0.438078016,
0.674973011,
0.3072901964,
0.1369284689,
-0.0504610576,
-0.1264861077,
0.4776872694,
-0.0959974602,
0.5488157868,
0.0153640946,
0.0414647684,
0.4525679648,
0.5021253228,
0.4886199534,
0.1263490319,
0.1775111407,
0.077383779,
0.0509603992,
-0.2733431756,
-0.6463151574,
0.7563926578,
-0.670194149,
-1.0322176218,
-0.741697073,
-0.4484537542,
-0.5769242048,
0.060528025,
0.2333344221,
-0.0333381817,
-0.5824663639,
0.0778190494,
0.7191486359,
-0.3236981928,
0.132835567,
0.2508308589,
-0.1908476651,
-0.2561427653,
0.9533548951,
-0.0629839674,
0.2796697915,
0.1282176226,
0.1547207236,
-0.2846872807,
-0.7352990508,
-0.1187448129,
0.052486755,
-0.9886853695,
-0.0617988296,
0.0729305446,
-0.2427255213,
0.490493238,
-0.155318737,
0.0238103103,
-0.3161297739,
0.0966740623,
-0.222086072,
-0.1962771416,
0.9111065865,
-0.3237010241,
0.3314043283,
-0.3429197073,
0.1401498169,
0.2937179506,
0.6319116354,
0.0729403347,
-0.1739775687,
0.2067172825,
-0.2036499083,
-0.2296928018,
-0.9624674916,
-0.0882839039,
-0.1513019502,
0.9814532399,
0.3740194738,
-0.3407109082,
0.7956711054,
-0.5075015426,
0.6247800589,
-0.0259463023,
-1.1399302483,
0.2748644948,
-0.4462406933,
0.1248314083,
0.5541313291,
0.1200806797,
-0.316868186,
-0.1047685444,
-0.810620904,
-0.45710814,
0.6855100989,
0.1225827783,
-0.3332074881,
-0.2074583769,
0.2892529368,
-0.33792153,
0.187499091,
-0.6418546438,
-0.2060035765,
0.1532976478,
0.1499246657,
-0.028076062,
-0.3315967321,
-0.298411727,
-0.2431601733,
0.5375576615,
0.1980235726,
0.3753010631,
-0.0889584124,
0.04295123,
0.114927575,
0.4288421571,
0.6422203183,
0.7359948754,
-0.1429374665,
0.0813836604,
0.3774303198,
-0.1083377823,
0.3688621521,
0.1082206368,
-0.0844119936,
-0.2450314909,
0.4880074263,
0.5253126621,
0.375605315,
-1.0760240555,
0.3018320799,
0.0393645354,
-0.3728482127,
-0.0478297472,
0.118757993,
0.3084191382,
0.5814186335,
-0.0492724217,
0.0226470493,
0.1455816329,
-0.8144847751,
0.0101095811,
0.8593104482,
0.060119275,
-0.0464367568,
0.6106125116,
0.2758206129,
0.056767799,
0.5117907524,
-0.6696428061,
-0.7548609972,
0.5662506223,
0.4784503877,
0.6554794908,
0.1131827831,
0.3449101746,
0.1182684824,
0.532135725,
-0.253270179,
0.4255825281,
0.0266193002,
-0.6061394215,
-0.5867316127,
-0.107894212,
-0.6520248652,
0.093974784,
-0.2426375449,
-0.1575281918,
-0.9565690756,
-0.5289074183,
-0.2806340754,
0.201685071,
-0.6498837471,
-0.269007355,
0.4111286998,
0.8711942434,
-0.3140179813,
0.329436034,
0.4930652678,
-0.182422027,
-0.6762728691,
-0.1558636427,
0.1974996626,
-0.8296272159,
0.8752963543,
-0.3974478543,
-0.3006894886,
-0.126587376,
-0.6438850164,
-0.7973814607,
1.107878685,
0.6162875891,
-0.6898112297,
-0.3110108674,
0.2454374731,
0.450320065,
-0.1557514966,
0.4379367828,
0.8737834096,
0.6825354099,
0.2225557119,
-0.7184685469,
0.0252992529,
-0.0179877877,
-0.2384689003,
-0.0036099055,
-0.7397927642,
0.5271885395,
-0.422706753,
-0.4342764914,
0.1007767469,
0.4721466005,
0.6800216436,
-0.006451108,
0.2092982829,
0.7783423066,
0.8358388543,
-0.5620902777,
0.9624707699,
-0.2041179985,
0.171022743,
1.040109396,
-0.5880963802,
0.8310862184,
0.1146906465,
-0.2140654176,
0.7404409051,
0.3884901404,
-0.136651203,
0.2575113177,
0.7526062727,
-0.0875769258,
-0.6625820994,
0.0342298411,
-0.1541466564,
0.5491985083,
0.5870720148,
0.032278344,
-0.5275848508,
-0.4591375291,
0.1079356,
0.0213348866,
-0.2661072016,
0.6099901795,
-0.0603573434,
-0.6668900847,
0.290273279,
0.0466861241,
0.506071806,
-0.6941877604,
0.1392799616,
-0.2232194841,
0.4395104349,
-0.0411951207,
-1.068723917,
-0.0135770021,
0.2000853866,
0.2080294639,
0.0461591147,
0.7250790596,
-0.0234819166,
-0.2919257879,
0.4765157998,
0.9090981483,
0.0051028281,
-0.0308646653,
-1.159812212,
0.5030987263,
-0.1730041951,
-0.1420335919,
0.2929207087,
0.6709516644,
0.0342942849,
0.7957844734,
0.4822015464,
0.2865788937,
-0.0943820775,
-0.1438782662,
0.6686550379,
-0.7442762852,
-0.3827740848,
-1.0674712658,
-0.1738461554,
-0.2533952296,
-0.1704286188,
0.7626495957,
0.5631511211,
0.7509406209,
0.1265406013,
0.8298870921,
0.0132292798,
-0.1397165656,
-0.5360503197,
0.4797903299,
-0.0476939715,
0.4064382315,
-0.0328384228,
-0.8193916082,
-0.0636387765,
0.5397815704,
-0.7554673553,
0.0471827872,
0.6827152371,
0.3300577402,
-0.0137575427,
-0.0012457728,
0.1446723491,
0.1272086948,
0.3894849718,
1.2444081306,
1.2405557632,
0.1371995509,
0.8081281781,
-0.0234855264,
-0.3486847579,
0.0377774872,
-1.0498514175,
-1.1583344936,
-0.0073883771,
-0.0801806673,
-0.4162653983,
0.4112736583,
0.7288302779,
0.2909895182,
-0.4496988654,
-0.685223639,
-0.1364588886,
0.3072220981,
-0.3314338624,
-0.2297940254,
0.0732228383,
-0.2397657782,
-0.2012991011,
0.4070426524,
0.3564189076,
-0.1587815732,
-0.1770634055,
-0.081874676,
-0.1662444621,
0.5351279378,
0.6685802937,
0.4561330378,
-0.9241986871,
-0.2226725817,
0.1168206409,
-0.005902437,
0.0136625413,
0.7528915405,
-0.7121936083,
0.2271905392,
0.4376461804,
0.550047636,
0.2235070467,
0.0277675334,
0.4726465642,
-0.1663442105,
-0.0441808365,
0.3823021054,
0.3217468262,
-0.1065055281,
0.0510700718,
0.684442699,
0.3939397335,
-0.5179566145,
-0.576053679,
0.3152796924,
-0.7655112743,
-0.30395329,
1.1830263138,
-0.0783837438,
-0.0382069983,
0.2079666853,
-0.1428170651,
-0.1906987429,
-0.171148628,
0.5200718641,
1.2481302023,
-0.2011497468,
0.0473137349,
-0.7683268785,
0.6608794928,
0.3468787372,
-0.9830654263,
0.147360757,
0.6142672896,
0.1198248863,
0.1041479856,
0.4659177363,
0.1186945811,
0.4122622013,
0.3228841424,
-0.1765932441,
-0.1219459325,
-0.2389033437,
0.0166077875,
0.2269736826,
0.159158662,
0.2251574397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12343v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12343v4
|
Emulated Disalignment: Safety Alignment for Large Language Models May Backfire!
| 2024-02-19T18:16:51 | 2024-06-06T12:54:48 |
Zhanhui Zhou, Jie Liu, Zhichen Dong, Jiaheng Liu, Chao Yang, Wanli Ouyang, Yu Qiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) undergo safety alignment to ensure safe
conversations with humans. However, this paper introduces a training-free
attack method capable of reversing safety alignment, converting the outcomes of
stronger alignment into greater potential for harm by accessing only LLM output
token distributions. Specifically, our method achieves this reversal by
contrasting the output token distribution of a safety-aligned language model
(e.g., Llama-2-chat) against its pre-trained version (e.g., Llama-2), so that
the token predictions are shifted towards the opposite direction of safety
alignment. We name this method emulated disalignment (ED) because sampling from
this contrastive distribution provably emulates the result of fine-tuning to
minimize a safety reward. Our experiments with ED across three evaluation
datasets and four model families (Llama-1, Llama-2, Mistral, and Alpaca) show
that ED doubles the harmfulness of pre-trained models and outperforms strong
baselines, achieving the highest harmful rates in 43 out of 48 evaluation
subsets by a large margin. Eventually, given ED's reliance on language model
output token distributions, which particularly compromises open-source models,
our findings highlight the need to reassess the open accessibility of language
models, even if they have been safety-aligned. Code is available at
https://github.com/ZHZisZZ/emulated-disalignment.
|
[
0.0848922729,
-0.6678104997,
0.3539226949,
0.0481482558,
-0.4645960927,
0.3101539314,
-0.1546174586,
-0.3766222596,
0.1661561131,
0.4700078964,
-0.4819788933,
-0.6291589141,
-0.7960749865,
-0.2184441239,
-0.7182061076,
1.0995082855,
0.0266473219,
-0.1275183707,
0.0737206563,
-0.1107701957,
-0.3370978236,
-0.6288731694,
-0.5865660906,
-0.2680670321,
0.3756033778,
0.1354107857,
0.8019322753,
0.900744617,
0.7047487497,
0.3775369823,
-0.2429496944,
-0.5432180166,
-0.8097906113,
0.0040416657,
-0.1584732085,
-0.4448459446,
-0.6380792856,
0.0371405073,
0.5467101336,
0.642282784,
-0.4187401533,
0.1159301028,
0.3216248453,
0.3906931579,
-0.8153658509,
-0.158043161,
-0.9689843655,
-0.0538604222,
-0.147735998,
-0.0551409461,
-0.6877564788,
-0.4442205429,
-0.1420575231,
-0.4428744614,
-0.1973752975,
0.1038488522,
0.7441123128,
0.5512623787,
-0.3332729936,
-0.2104293555,
-0.5838646293,
1.007704854,
-0.7527438402,
0.4686921537,
0.2154235393,
0.406819135,
-0.2951300442,
-0.457346946,
-0.6232606769,
-0.0029725779,
-0.1043526083,
-0.0895919651,
-0.3798522353,
0.1783297509,
0.0509529635,
0.0422237553,
-0.2637836635,
0.6443265676,
-0.3495874405,
-0.1910843849,
0.5697478652,
0.189355731,
0.3585908413,
0.1497056782,
-0.6205854416,
-0.2363360524,
-1.0762604475,
-0.1298267692,
0.5937165022,
0.270948112,
-0.2956653237,
0.6322170496,
-0.0716138035,
0.5288763046,
0.3198693991,
-0.261585921,
0.4162320197,
-0.3090898693,
-0.4008395076,
0.2910914123,
0.7330447435,
0.7358726859,
0.041268412,
-0.043723762,
-0.283483088,
0.0613658018,
0.2946456671,
-0.7149681449,
-0.0183687452,
0.33379215,
-0.3123568892,
-0.7843389511,
-0.2847860456,
-0.9201323986,
-0.5450265408,
-0.1050962359,
0.3170116842,
-0.2669826448,
-0.3571830392,
0.0427620597,
0.0780512914,
0.2819379568,
0.2059045881,
-1.1107298136,
0.2068587989,
1.0308929682,
0.7045351267,
0.121293053,
-0.4538165331,
-0.6313827038,
0.3276242614,
-0.3478408158,
0.3061387539,
-0.749536097,
-0.1810084134,
-0.0250361655,
-0.1098172367,
0.0079891011,
-0.2832720578,
0.3491117954,
-0.526445508,
-0.0506127588,
0.0495392121,
-0.1682117432,
-0.0851557478,
0.3506225944,
-0.4593714178,
0.5984458327,
-0.2194882035,
-1.1241624355,
0.3032315969,
-0.3630085289,
-0.1202600002,
-0.6400236487,
-0.1814093441,
-0.5764039159,
0.061785724,
0.3325621486,
0.233984828,
-0.0380794518,
0.2546508312,
-0.544891715,
-0.482586056,
0.3051508367,
-0.6651020646,
1.0789834261,
0.2216671109,
-0.4890995026,
0.1642081589,
-0.6902536154,
-0.0819637701,
0.1719441116,
-0.1771792322,
-0.7583994865,
0.1225689426,
-0.3570746183,
0.1425122768,
0.201063484,
-0.7062240243,
0.1212576777,
-0.7124398351,
0.2711130977,
1.1003271341,
-0.1349288076,
0.5424086452,
-0.2532657981,
0.409542799,
0.1962859631,
0.5532339811,
0.1726666391,
-0.1866888851,
-0.5429525971,
-0.4998006821,
0.3288855553,
0.5116357207,
-0.5928379893,
0.4668370187,
-0.4038777053,
-0.4905383289,
-0.9121715426,
-0.0320133343,
0.7200374007,
0.3647406101,
0.201388523,
-0.2805051506,
-0.4943446815,
-0.8650307059,
-0.2017830014,
-0.4468674958,
0.1485292464,
-0.2834979296,
0.2592617869,
-0.3223551512,
0.6031594872,
-0.4153993726,
0.078489691,
0.073221907,
-0.0166656673,
-0.1118869111,
0.6249441504,
0.6327805519,
-0.4571968317,
-0.122213766,
-0.0748444796,
-0.5197095871,
-0.3295040429,
-0.1995395422,
-0.4274361134,
0.1571757048,
0.5717022419,
-0.1553016454,
0.5861052871,
0.8576403856,
-0.1489233226,
0.2016560286,
0.0914878994,
0.2259440273,
-1.1665568352,
0.0653456375,
-0.4086738527,
-0.0427295491,
-0.7346612215,
0.3128148615,
0.0895507485,
0.0649153814,
-0.6467330456,
0.3052360713,
-0.3836181164,
-0.0979026631,
-0.2363129556,
0.2153126001,
-0.1330148131,
0.2865371704,
-0.2316894084,
0.5670428276,
0.4276663363,
-0.4080583453,
0.005057822,
0.474668026,
-0.1876114309,
0.503285706,
-0.57186836,
0.3975164294,
-0.2598226964,
0.149951756,
-1.1586761475,
-0.019870529,
0.5227968097,
-0.2884249091,
0.4846257269,
-0.2227344513,
-0.1198977083,
-0.0322087333,
-0.6811766028,
0.5842630863,
0.636310637,
-0.9254943728,
0.2060105801,
0.5360066295,
-0.2643526196,
-1.2878857851,
-0.8372362256,
-0.024073936,
-0.4901014268,
-0.3594753444,
0.1442393214,
0.1065852344,
-0.5443164706,
-0.1454172879,
0.0800090358,
0.0908768848,
0.4929182827,
0.4192595482,
0.2535832226,
0.1280354857,
-0.0028485269,
0.4784431458,
-0.1751041859,
-0.0876549035,
0.1904910058,
0.6212361455,
0.2751301527,
-0.8657205701,
-0.4781045318,
0.3576896191,
0.5764140487,
-0.2127890438,
0.8601298928,
0.0692861602,
-0.5004455447,
0.1706870496,
-0.3223393261,
-0.3244158924,
-0.5724608898,
0.5452696681,
-0.0693779662,
-0.6330571771,
0.3065566421,
-0.032116767,
0.7332539558,
0.2468976527,
0.5072290301,
0.0414112546,
1.1534086466,
0.7088372111,
-0.2085386813,
0.4808072746,
0.2722587287,
0.3069097996,
-0.7684855461,
-0.0918650702,
-0.6393495798,
-0.506133914,
-0.5149123669,
-0.2989070415,
0.1235165149,
0.3363247514,
-0.4068327844,
0.2672078311,
-0.5046375394,
0.597854197,
0.1954626292,
-0.0061894609,
0.3652650118,
0.1517373472,
-0.1518314779,
-0.1037025303,
-0.3654978573,
-0.6256865263,
1.2676411867,
0.5449848175,
0.9903954864,
0.3228808343,
1.2591274977,
-0.1183002517,
0.7607310414,
-0.4939100444,
0.5084016919,
-0.0264299922,
-0.4543066323,
-0.2933627665,
-0.2980752587,
-0.8757199049,
0.1988641173,
-0.1169828176,
-0.8906023502,
0.1291116327,
0.2852331698,
-0.349045068,
0.4597147703,
-0.7590315342,
0.5822868347,
-0.3965923488,
-0.057655409,
-0.3543884158,
-0.596285522,
0.5566917658,
-0.423416853,
0.4951114058,
-0.0217170008,
-0.0722015426,
0.644885242,
-0.3562355042,
1.299100399,
-0.1775289625,
-0.3708012402,
0.1401517242,
0.2624054551,
0.6728407145,
-0.2938730419,
-0.1955898851,
0.3352724612,
0.0370451361,
-0.3828762472,
-0.5116410255,
0.8712289929,
-0.7779126167,
-1.0084012747,
-0.3250460029,
-0.2771494985,
0.074317053,
0.0904680789,
0.0543385558,
0.2362713218,
-0.3424170911,
-0.0485821031,
0.0573290326,
-0.5120367408,
0.4986888766,
0.3957327008,
-0.4864472747,
-0.482033968,
0.7635271549,
0.0001808086,
0.7327978611,
0.3152094781,
0.0639751032,
-0.3689344227,
-0.7932057381,
-0.5417225957,
0.0694093183,
-0.8414446712,
-0.2051381022,
-0.4070286751,
-0.05330256,
-0.4273575544,
-0.3912281096,
-0.4320926666,
-0.5384446383,
-0.0726397485,
-0.5162330866,
0.2889218032,
0.7484972477,
-0.2558449507,
0.2846244872,
-0.723228395,
-0.2114562094,
0.0831276998,
0.3875746429,
0.0448279157,
-0.5639311671,
0.1101626828,
0.2152564377,
-0.3962858617,
-0.9363455176,
0.232582584,
-0.0811278448,
0.4784849286,
0.6123614311,
0.3225278854,
0.6428095102,
-0.6215721965,
0.5403360128,
0.6130843163,
-0.8970848918,
0.2668783367,
-0.0422015861,
-0.1944556534,
0.6821690798,
0.2540732622,
-0.452865541,
-0.5851747394,
-0.4445488155,
-0.8678976893,
0.4668871164,
0.1321243346,
0.3450278044,
-0.2267059386,
0.1903822869,
0.2850458026,
0.1384345144,
-0.5890042782,
-0.1478080451,
-0.2479908615,
-0.5808497071,
-0.0249345433,
-0.3304274678,
-0.4424498677,
-0.0673685521,
0.5855121613,
0.0086849499,
0.2678801119,
-0.1096440628,
-0.109719716,
-0.1394482106,
0.4850354493,
0.558645308,
0.3777099252,
-0.0935510844,
0.4276880026,
0.2739378214,
-0.4967337847,
0.5348361135,
0.082364969,
-0.2216129452,
-0.3367374241,
0.1544855535,
0.5576005578,
0.4040321708,
-0.5532926321,
0.5572274327,
0.0772088617,
0.0458448045,
-0.0338079967,
0.051853966,
0.0125511289,
0.2723731697,
-0.1105494425,
-0.1402342319,
-0.1091758013,
-0.4504358768,
0.277251035,
0.4654096067,
-0.4038680792,
-0.4289475679,
0.7451171875,
0.3540517092,
-0.4056572616,
0.5356667042,
-0.0060701747,
-0.3965196908,
0.5564488769,
0.6989225745,
0.9262866974,
-0.3963509798,
0.083494395,
0.3458343148,
0.648876965,
0.1143342257,
0.0875783265,
0.367839843,
-0.770752728,
-0.3345503211,
-0.5598255992,
-0.2702673674,
-0.0720061585,
-0.7006040812,
0.1474914849,
-0.6532483697,
-0.1320636719,
-0.191655159,
-0.544090569,
-0.4057331681,
-0.1224594563,
0.1126227975,
0.742079258,
-0.9150696993,
0.7863819003,
0.4570349157,
-0.2078876197,
-0.5486309528,
0.4031690061,
0.2578600645,
-0.9103974104,
0.4457717538,
0.1429515928,
-0.1977849007,
0.0816749483,
-0.62334162,
-0.9142861962,
1.1746805906,
0.6482021213,
-1.0866905451,
0.0793914124,
0.228046,
0.4100998044,
-0.1033561975,
0.078595683,
0.6382804513,
0.2140706033,
-0.1863701493,
-1.0954592228,
0.2823421657,
0.1054687276,
-0.2406238317,
0.4822492898,
-0.7258787155,
0.6681814194,
-0.4409903586,
-0.5057525039,
0.0901646763,
0.4017877579,
0.4640400112,
0.250985235,
0.7277074456,
0.6573091149,
0.7836593986,
0.01138552,
0.9149829149,
-0.2049068213,
0.2863140404,
1.0918132067,
-0.4271495044,
1.1278189421,
0.9420284033,
-0.0114655988,
0.1805483848,
0.3471620381,
0.5292015076,
0.89832443,
0.2510423958,
-0.144602403,
0.0385941304,
0.095678784,
-0.4390170574,
0.4175301492,
0.1736575812,
-0.5078400373,
-0.3208540678,
-0.1805142462,
0.1460116804,
0.0824752226,
-0.2060595304,
0.7915197015,
0.0543091893,
-0.3740543425,
0.9429058433,
0.0465767384,
0.7460970879,
-0.2734358907,
0.0274152905,
-0.1921602637,
0.3109110296,
-0.1221704558,
-0.6995249987,
0.6209848523,
0.2097375244,
0.2351384163,
0.0059626428,
0.3835189939,
-0.4379528463,
-0.3817370534,
0.5380355716,
0.2065463513,
0.1054221541,
0.46014902,
-0.6370422244,
0.3558393121,
0.1945057958,
-0.3951310813,
0.644608736,
0.2295686454,
-0.1375091821,
0.4846892953,
0.4720782042,
-0.1991267204,
0.2419870645,
-0.0315597355,
1.0248773098,
-0.4428344369,
-0.4610898197,
-1.1192564964,
0.3935502768,
-0.062410865,
-0.1139691547,
0.4434490502,
0.2836175859,
0.9411694407,
0.1577987969,
0.728313148,
0.1504996866,
0.2738294005,
-0.5951091051,
0.9033892155,
-0.4616447687,
0.4590424895,
-0.5237655044,
-0.5661666393,
-0.3070436418,
0.4358874857,
-0.52360183,
-0.3541730344,
0.4860035181,
1.0673063993,
-0.1134913862,
-0.1251126975,
0.3840499818,
0.3370935023,
0.4765291512,
0.4766850471,
1.0300830603,
-0.3027460277,
0.6157151461,
-0.4601542354,
-0.3990909457,
-0.1887973398,
-1.0678267479,
-0.87912637,
-0.3758060932,
-0.3165431917,
-0.3536863923,
0.3499188125,
1.0290850401,
0.2678869069,
-0.8034442663,
0.1899270564,
0.207330063,
0.0634309575,
-0.2465431541,
-0.0663152933,
0.3378567398,
0.0684725717,
-0.7854914069,
0.3930299878,
0.1527397037,
0.3040040135,
-0.16215159,
-0.1111678034,
0.0786649287,
0.1714342535,
0.2345333695,
0.167051211,
-0.7291796207,
-0.8436021209,
-0.2109257132,
-0.2739116251,
-0.0182653293,
0.436812222,
-0.3100745678,
0.3602861166,
0.3731194139,
0.8381638527,
-0.1921996772,
0.1305266321,
0.6289052367,
-0.896032691,
0.6501711011,
0.0036050137,
0.4236888289,
0.2791078091,
-0.4752911329,
0.3498415053,
-0.2594742179,
-0.3440297842,
-1.2006380558,
0.4185900986,
-0.615255475,
-0.1214882135,
1.150105238,
-0.1735254824,
-0.4188215435,
-0.1160637736,
-0.3381846845,
0.3845679164,
-0.2484079152,
1.1240415573,
0.4765661955,
0.4446630776,
0.051585529,
-0.1832720041,
0.2789497972,
0.4564515054,
-0.6727948189,
0.4518686533,
0.3840268552,
0.4758313596,
0.0092276949,
0.6298464537,
-0.3730369806,
0.0754181147,
0.0525662638,
0.2808459699,
-0.0395508185,
-0.2346366346,
-0.6796168089,
0.0034416404,
0.3609523773,
-0.5277557969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12332v1
|
Triple-Encoders: Representations That Fire Together, Wire Together
| 2024-02-19T18:06:02 | 2024-02-19T18:06:02 |
Justus-Jonas Erker, Florian Mai, Nils Reimers, Gerasimos Spanakis, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Search-based dialog models typically re-encode the dialog history at every
turn, incurring high cost. Curved Contrastive Learning, a representation
learning method that encodes relative distances between utterances into the
embedding space via a bi-encoder, has recently shown promising results for
dialog modeling at far superior efficiency. While high efficiency is achieved
through independently encoding utterances, this ignores the importance of
contextualization. To overcome this issue, this study introduces
triple-encoders, which efficiently compute distributed utterance mixtures from
these independently encoded utterances through a novel hebbian inspired
co-occurrence learning objective without using any weights. Empirically, we
find that triple-encoders lead to a substantial improvement over bi-encoders,
and even to better zero-shot generalization than single-vector representation
models without requiring re-encoding. Our code/model is publicly available.
|
[
-0.187815845,
-0.3748242557,
0.5106514692,
-0.0431129374,
-0.0893583074,
0.2854308784,
0.0228164848,
-0.3254545629,
0.0482919142,
0.528690815,
-0.545458734,
-0.6955145597,
-0.3319503069,
0.0467084832,
-0.0473776944,
0.8343600035,
0.027932426,
0.2270541191,
0.0175745543,
-0.2351498157,
-0.3480708003,
-0.4557748735,
-0.5899900198,
-0.6104358435,
0.4361152351,
0.1505930275,
0.6044618487,
0.4609213471,
0.3912265897,
0.3172140121,
0.1045519412,
0.2067862898,
-0.6188961267,
0.0172657538,
0.4385885,
-0.5058656335,
0.0086259106,
-0.0733080655,
0.4316649735,
1.0813208818,
-0.5022185445,
-0.3565687239,
0.1776742041,
0.556322515,
-0.4496036768,
0.2745226324,
-0.5148295164,
0.17591995,
0.2410994023,
-0.3296084702,
-0.4666932821,
-0.5992600918,
0.4163747728,
-0.7707399726,
0.549071908,
0.1804036796,
0.7288522124,
0.0575923175,
-0.5044413805,
-0.6495147943,
-0.5825799704,
0.6858580112,
-0.5591986775,
0.5186997056,
-0.0009734807,
0.2619015276,
-0.1896913201,
-0.5044110417,
-0.5368626118,
0.1259938478,
-0.1238319501,
0.3006665409,
-0.1141909882,
0.3480777144,
-0.1310815066,
0.7040698528,
-0.427284956,
-0.0295955203,
-0.6637280583,
-0.007197632,
0.3270402849,
0.3035707772,
0.0945663676,
-0.1376917958,
-0.239548251,
-0.1488928795,
-0.5132440925,
-0.1240812764,
0.4544326961,
0.3876514137,
-0.3612653911,
0.2826549113,
-0.0073693367,
0.6626053452,
0.5083534718,
0.1616069227,
0.3503888845,
-0.1595987827,
-0.1691223681,
0.0968938023,
0.8220322132,
0.245461002,
-0.1964561194,
-0.1915851533,
0.0335433036,
-0.0975193903,
0.3002609313,
-0.9050502777,
-0.222869873,
0.1828952134,
-0.4013644755,
-0.0373942964,
0.1624143124,
-0.6945447326,
-0.3577566147,
-0.1394163221,
0.367295146,
-0.6418399811,
-0.1024701372,
0.388145864,
-0.2586198747,
0.0699234679,
0.2823216617,
-0.9610048532,
0.3250286579,
0.6317285299,
0.8252030015,
-0.0871238112,
-0.1300844699,
-0.4670343995,
0.2325751781,
-0.3676911891,
0.520057857,
-0.8393606544,
-0.5281469822,
0.0710340887,
-0.3615652621,
0.060096059,
-0.7273947597,
0.3169397116,
-0.7047180533,
0.4881910086,
-0.1569064707,
-0.6533182263,
-0.6250768304,
-0.1218594536,
-0.6970902681,
0.8548829556,
0.1146263629,
-0.5654684901,
0.5749077797,
-0.5780024529,
-0.2051458359,
0.2749357224,
-0.3927860856,
-0.534928441,
0.2435190231,
0.3424146771,
0.486669004,
-0.1308635324,
0.2377410233,
-0.4551510513,
-0.6917502284,
-0.1987927407,
-0.3827871084,
0.6930098534,
0.099963069,
-0.2645291388,
0.1798056662,
-0.6323689222,
-0.356017679,
-0.0051139751,
-0.4856423736,
-0.3659796417,
-0.2721706629,
-0.3199368119,
-0.0106124906,
-0.0088468464,
-0.5786452889,
-0.1193321645,
-0.5220676661,
0.1241207197,
0.6831406355,
0.053889636,
0.5305808783,
-0.2421817929,
0.1258426011,
0.388451308,
-0.2372825146,
-0.2965566814,
-0.200416714,
-0.8838008046,
-0.5799870491,
-0.1758602113,
0.3226751387,
-0.9832231998,
0.5775546432,
-0.1899210364,
-0.1332791448,
-0.5366761088,
0.0570530295,
0.213017419,
0.322843343,
0.2505601943,
-0.1129410118,
-0.5139498115,
-0.6642103791,
-0.2594468892,
-0.0135489739,
-0.2501225471,
0.4024109542,
0.3762715161,
-0.1616509855,
0.7598919272,
-0.5892091393,
-0.0295601916,
-0.3341577947,
0.4704041779,
0.2415650785,
0.3046042621,
0.3528787792,
-0.6727953553,
-0.6158178449,
0.1388877034,
-1.0623629093,
0.0751715675,
-0.050392583,
0.1039905772,
0.2355609238,
0.4844486713,
-0.3535065055,
0.4434094429,
0.6580570936,
-0.1481459737,
0.0276674125,
-0.2807103097,
0.1695570201,
-1.1596721411,
-0.4181675613,
-0.0038882277,
-0.1260809749,
-0.7439098358,
-0.2118420899,
-0.1021660268,
-0.3763036728,
-0.2738588154,
0.3278839886,
-0.7074429393,
-0.1176969036,
-0.0676073655,
0.1754655391,
0.1658262461,
1.0532772541,
0.1493793875,
0.8258303404,
0.7072773576,
-0.6851763129,
0.4782900512,
0.2623236775,
-0.2399218082,
0.7910532355,
-0.5742854476,
0.2570765018,
-0.4476929009,
0.4550740719,
-0.7865254879,
-0.4807194173,
0.2288480848,
-0.2558199167,
0.1004885808,
0.0273410119,
-0.0558431409,
-0.4717985988,
-0.3127626777,
0.3517843187,
0.4363335669,
-1.1139702797,
0.8106590509,
0.0873658657,
-0.0600686856,
-0.4113247991,
-0.4205155373,
-0.2693052292,
-0.2818836272,
-0.6288808584,
0.223103568,
0.0821913332,
-0.0045910329,
-0.0656375438,
-0.3648756742,
0.0075624827,
-0.1875169724,
0.328630358,
0.1413011551,
-0.0192590188,
0.1029682755,
-0.1603237838,
0.0562439822,
-0.1539605558,
-0.3742370605,
0.7493544817,
-0.3105635345,
-0.6551585793,
-0.8703876138,
0.7931700349,
0.252098918,
0.1904731691,
0.7175682187,
0.6737828851,
-0.2980814576,
0.0021498944,
-0.6737273335,
-0.2686561644,
-0.5716633797,
0.3899350762,
-0.5019840598,
-1.2594096661,
0.503082335,
-0.0833898112,
0.1103649512,
0.1222928986,
0.4010938108,
-0.1911773235,
0.8830080032,
0.5523316264,
0.3295289874,
0.6863886714,
-0.174060002,
0.3805253208,
-0.6292157173,
-0.5284815431,
-0.2849289775,
0.1071688011,
-0.6222949028,
-0.4112864137,
0.7326676846,
-0.0131916273,
-0.2708912492,
0.2436160743,
-0.2257246226,
0.4307853878,
0.7086409926,
0.449986577,
0.0903756917,
0.2634590864,
-0.1202364564,
0.0637623072,
-0.7180155516,
-0.286876291,
0.8768754005,
0.2513531148,
0.7962573767,
0.295099169,
1.2418237925,
0.1814555228,
-0.0647695363,
-0.8209307194,
0.3674112558,
-0.1215378866,
-0.2945806086,
-0.097086072,
-0.6235412955,
-0.9398723841,
0.458761245,
-0.0839770436,
-0.671828568,
0.4163100421,
-0.0031310073,
-0.6243162155,
0.4133203924,
-0.802203536,
0.6011285186,
-0.088009648,
-0.4797991216,
-0.2919074893,
-0.4279170632,
0.1317130774,
0.1923743188,
-0.019093845,
0.049723424,
0.3086698353,
0.683216393,
-0.4086452127,
0.8997828364,
-0.2959235907,
0.0419203751,
0.3604520261,
0.0174476746,
0.4420075119,
-0.0222739652,
-0.1499671638,
0.433940202,
-0.3779588938,
-0.6068173051,
-0.6537857652,
0.383649826,
-0.8447838426,
-0.627202332,
-0.2939968109,
-0.55055058,
-0.1962517798,
0.1076539457,
0.1930460036,
0.747036159,
-0.3679458797,
0.3210333586,
0.6466219425,
-0.2462095618,
0.6651024222,
0.0750103593,
0.0143185277,
-0.6871806979,
0.7729455829,
-0.3431951106,
0.3610029221,
0.259956181,
-0.0207761712,
-0.0196325369,
-0.4015036821,
-0.2806116343,
0.2575848401,
-0.7751302719,
-0.0753820762,
-0.9563702941,
-0.1633911282,
-0.2151702344,
-0.7453838587,
-0.3169772923,
0.0903574303,
-0.632013917,
-0.16754134,
0.0896999091,
0.9867070913,
-0.3484155834,
0.7044389248,
-0.7379499078,
0.5520472527,
0.7070353031,
0.4760731757,
-0.0662372932,
-0.3421884775,
-0.3436485529,
0.1083145142,
-0.2989526391,
-0.6294869781,
0.679479897,
0.1495611221,
0.5772342682,
0.3635422885,
-0.1094491407,
0.7536309958,
-0.4205011725,
0.828523159,
0.6712531447,
-1.0437499285,
0.0382979997,
-0.5143460631,
0.3313342333,
0.6242240071,
0.4481073618,
-0.498116225,
-0.0292896628,
-0.4230715632,
-0.6062142253,
0.9178479314,
0.16708152,
0.1713457853,
-0.0120757297,
0.237341702,
0.5853896737,
0.0480394214,
-0.5289491415,
-0.0041340753,
-0.5889416933,
-0.5281044841,
0.2521664202,
-0.3992090523,
-0.1856900901,
-0.0098026171,
0.4850987792,
-0.3292075396,
0.5077883005,
0.0503100231,
-0.0559302159,
0.1429693997,
0.4189642966,
0.3984488845,
0.1999134421,
-0.5138198137,
0.1490042359,
0.0912082121,
-0.4150440693,
0.022591453,
0.1213200018,
0.178900227,
0.0871323943,
0.1252734214,
1.362454772,
0.1673165709,
-0.1284623742,
0.5034989119,
-0.1183046773,
-0.1617890149,
-0.2642230392,
-0.111130774,
-0.0181187168,
0.4192952812,
0.531621635,
0.0758945942,
0.459993571,
-0.6440769434,
0.170737043,
0.380989641,
-0.5515596867,
-0.2892411649,
0.3928818703,
0.7545781732,
-0.2943644524,
0.6069629192,
-0.2253462672,
-0.5341135263,
0.2414286882,
0.5482576489,
1.0793869495,
-0.0751931071,
0.2207372487,
0.4081338942,
-0.0932884812,
-0.0501259975,
0.1610206217,
-0.3560698628,
-0.9103185534,
0.1080702245,
-0.4324882627,
-0.6428793073,
-0.2395416051,
-0.8667252064,
0.2678753436,
-0.4119905233,
0.1198951527,
-0.2250550687,
-0.1672897786,
-0.755389154,
-0.1711679101,
0.3009319305,
0.3099018037,
-0.6610091925,
0.3644256592,
0.1087128744,
-0.1800243258,
-0.4926490486,
0.2548256516,
0.1005982086,
-0.8024974465,
0.6029667854,
0.6582440138,
-0.4715977609,
-0.0563537739,
-0.5121798515,
-0.7129545212,
1.1203564405,
0.2018726021,
-0.7322503924,
-0.1894267052,
0.1385977268,
0.3822627068,
-0.5982573032,
0.4481739998,
0.5776254535,
-0.0856193602,
0.4611057639,
-0.7661258578,
-0.1823983341,
-0.0468556806,
0.2391782254,
-0.0485164747,
-0.7295008898,
0.853030622,
-0.1734652519,
-0.5084767938,
-0.2226604223,
0.9461087584,
0.4480154514,
0.2942469716,
0.1893322617,
0.3588996828,
0.8392445445,
-0.2354563475,
0.8920598626,
-0.0579269528,
0.3410814404,
1.2494874001,
-0.5943514705,
0.4290011525,
0.4169816375,
0.048847463,
0.8554252982,
0.3847339153,
0.1956124157,
0.7353864312,
0.0120750833,
-0.6793841124,
-0.3048526645,
0.0994510949,
-0.1167891771,
0.568998158,
0.5732505918,
-0.0896256194,
-0.3646034598,
0.0933142677,
-0.0135029396,
0.079949066,
-0.2447840869,
1.1384513378,
-0.0216572322,
-0.4074576497,
0.8241891265,
-0.3310882449,
1.1765058041,
-0.3578670919,
-0.2716151178,
-0.2674055696,
0.1619956493,
-0.2126164734,
-0.5185155272,
0.3023117483,
-0.2925632298,
0.0199183617,
-0.1619429588,
0.3975483477,
-0.6697395444,
-0.2990228832,
0.2652416229,
0.2180897593,
0.0130636506,
0.2220835239,
-0.3603132665,
0.1638732702,
0.0332952887,
-0.0801333562,
-0.2208015919,
0.4556786418,
0.1433244199,
0.5185691118,
0.3432341218,
-0.3583571017,
0.2772913277,
0.23532179,
0.7712566257,
-0.8953405023,
-0.6084856987,
-0.5532039404,
0.3949801922,
-0.3214835823,
0.3139858544,
0.5100703239,
0.4097728133,
0.8481781483,
0.0163701419,
1.0537676811,
0.2087247819,
0.4215379953,
-0.5083745718,
0.3669653833,
-0.3820796311,
0.2682502866,
0.0132792033,
-0.6622824669,
-0.5151140094,
0.6144635677,
-0.3047287464,
0.2683420181,
0.7203214765,
0.8332323432,
-0.0798259825,
0.5181669593,
0.5002608299,
-0.0901229009,
0.4310151637,
0.6283233166,
0.7672806978,
-0.552962184,
0.5340521336,
-0.149113223,
-0.0965811983,
-0.4823606908,
-0.5324779153,
-1.2837663889,
-0.5207701325,
-0.0832382366,
-0.1661869437,
0.126556024,
1.2043606043,
0.8230650425,
-0.8298403025,
-0.3985072672,
-0.3221160471,
0.0073853056,
-0.0662047118,
-0.2013792098,
0.2957681417,
-0.3216436207,
-0.8964432478,
0.4754240215,
0.443462044,
0.0709174648,
-0.1327315122,
-0.2433933169,
-0.1786398739,
0.3307598233,
0.5640792251,
0.1000743732,
-0.8238270283,
-0.5271093249,
-0.2035460472,
-0.2100167125,
0.425026685,
0.7491656542,
-0.7741376162,
0.5378040075,
0.4126652777,
0.6715384126,
0.8159893751,
-0.0977269411,
0.762993753,
-0.8278447986,
0.3020879924,
-0.01339118,
0.302988261,
0.781942904,
-0.3707236946,
0.3319746852,
0.2999824882,
-0.2622852921,
-0.547026217,
0.4301615059,
-1.0085811615,
-0.0849638954,
1.0010390282,
-0.2061485499,
-0.2268860787,
-0.3396142423,
-0.1739087403,
0.4222097993,
-0.7373344302,
0.5913066268,
0.3534729779,
-0.4422935843,
-0.2910439372,
-0.1009423882,
0.2652022839,
0.211725831,
-0.7701318264,
-0.0432068631,
0.9116663337,
0.292535156,
0.2633486986,
0.5143572688,
-0.0116456673,
0.0879415497,
0.5090726614,
0.3811529279,
-0.1311460286,
-0.3772366643,
-0.6268212199,
0.5092195868,
-0.4955723286,
-0.2461865097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12329v1
|
Query-Based Adversarial Prompt Generation
| 2024-02-19T18:01:36 | 2024-02-19T18:01:36 |
Jonathan Hayase, Ema Borevkovic, Nicholas Carlini, Florian Tramèr, Milad Nasr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown it is possible to construct adversarial examples that
cause an aligned language model to emit harmful strings or perform harmful
behavior. Existing attacks work either in the white-box setting (with full
access to the model weights), or through transferability: the phenomenon that
adversarial examples crafted on one model often remain effective on other
models. We improve on prior work with a query-based attack that leverages API
access to a remote language model to construct adversarial examples that cause
the model to emit harmful strings with (much) higher probability than with
transfer-only attacks. We validate our attack on GPT-3.5 and OpenAI's safety
classifier; we can cause GPT-3.5 to emit harmful strings that current transfer
attacks fail at, and we can evade the safety classifier with nearly 100%
probability.
|
[
-0.0680076927,
-1.1719964743,
0.3720464706,
-0.3105969131,
0.0368139744,
-0.165593788,
0.1278856695,
-0.5872184634,
-0.0817347765,
0.6907415986,
-0.5558369756,
-0.236176908,
-0.5421447158,
-0.1302151233,
-0.552470386,
1.187877059,
0.3239943087,
-0.1439674944,
0.188826099,
0.1032217667,
-0.4307987988,
-0.6539238691,
-1.0661077499,
0.2256541252,
0.6157256961,
0.0349628925,
0.9797823429,
0.2512388825,
0.5127747059,
0.2869773209,
0.0311351717,
-0.1545904279,
-0.4597175121,
0.354618907,
-0.2289181799,
-0.8687633872,
-0.2380208522,
-0.0274873674,
0.151064232,
0.3266194761,
-0.0055090995,
-0.1011511013,
-0.1993866712,
0.4531306922,
-0.6371119618,
-0.159641698,
-1.1274337769,
-0.1478158385,
-0.2053876668,
-0.1208783388,
-0.7026785016,
-0.6162019372,
0.0801900029,
-0.6628910899,
0.2494827062,
0.0527153052,
0.8828175664,
0.2155408114,
-0.5504704118,
-0.5229191184,
-0.4991409779,
0.4119082987,
-0.5287947655,
-0.2031049728,
0.4970002174,
0.6309092641,
-0.4223276079,
-0.7999372482,
-0.3421453238,
-0.4327050745,
-0.0383401252,
-0.0446677357,
-0.6661252975,
-0.0104862722,
0.4603748322,
0.0275880769,
-0.7662146091,
-0.0426606648,
-0.5201368332,
-0.2212543935,
0.5595723987,
-0.0408623703,
0.7095175385,
-0.2264519781,
-0.4866593778,
-0.2485228032,
-1.0950113535,
-0.0472882688,
0.6964530945,
0.4711743891,
0.1861354113,
0.3925444186,
0.0508358181,
0.9293422699,
0.0046860911,
0.4195001423,
-0.4231744111,
-0.3213635385,
-0.0644493923,
0.1776162833,
1.088127017,
0.2984592617,
0.2474110872,
-0.1233973727,
-0.0899480358,
-0.0773871094,
0.5692088008,
-0.7363984585,
-0.5032544732,
0.0808399245,
-0.18894279,
-0.6993927956,
0.1319365352,
-0.7598814964,
-0.7328846455,
0.2189506292,
0.4472647011,
-0.568947494,
-0.0367908925,
-0.1933480501,
-0.1498372853,
0.0410024412,
0.1677634567,
-0.7541604042,
0.0911811963,
0.5620390773,
0.5978543162,
-0.1045669317,
-0.1475551277,
-0.7552586198,
0.1642599255,
-0.1705970764,
0.6054664254,
-0.3458996713,
-0.567255795,
0.0816789791,
0.1086828634,
-0.1452165395,
-0.342648834,
0.4951380193,
-0.9272233844,
0.5442371964,
-0.3947443664,
-0.2548866272,
-0.3207614124,
0.1536488086,
-0.6877775192,
0.5374862552,
0.1447467357,
-0.7191807628,
0.1138154492,
-0.8024756908,
-0.6760237217,
0.0606636852,
0.1412173063,
-0.2441275567,
-0.0719255209,
0.238139689,
0.1396005154,
-0.0883223191,
-0.096345745,
-0.499260813,
-0.3121157587,
0.418153435,
-0.7075260282,
1.2977901697,
0.579405129,
-0.4106172025,
0.2379518747,
-0.5513408184,
0.0240533054,
0.344989866,
0.0481524579,
-0.5658364296,
-0.2903499901,
-0.367033869,
0.0874067768,
0.2264989167,
-0.4517265558,
0.35017398,
-0.4285399914,
0.381680876,
0.7670084834,
0.370315522,
0.1926711947,
-0.2350969166,
0.8360433578,
-0.2471735626,
0.3174029291,
0.0493282825,
-0.6157782674,
-0.2445107698,
0.0054300837,
0.1009461358,
0.8178443909,
-1.1573921442,
0.1851846427,
0.0202493537,
-0.5715441108,
-0.3346983492,
-0.1001612544,
0.4579699934,
0.6025029421,
0.2152313739,
0.2898496985,
-0.212203458,
-0.6134631038,
-0.467762202,
-0.4524844587,
-0.0204839054,
0.4610973895,
0.3469522893,
0.1895127296,
0.4349094629,
-0.8300088048,
0.1929493994,
0.0283123702,
0.1623559147,
0.1467288136,
0.4878258705,
0.8688080311,
-0.8744986653,
-0.4359815121,
-0.2050470561,
-0.747474432,
-0.0675079301,
-0.187116161,
-0.4417010546,
0.0272123311,
0.4982597828,
-0.6123790741,
0.3352650106,
0.254633069,
-0.5764021277,
0.5537042022,
-0.1074702144,
0.4267574251,
-1.2901581526,
-0.0426998921,
-0.0712244585,
-0.2148716897,
-0.7851057649,
0.5434042811,
0.1031537727,
-0.5636052489,
-0.9061644673,
0.3944622576,
-0.0383884721,
0.2213571519,
-0.2520396411,
0.128473565,
0.0356296636,
0.2824167013,
-0.4422087371,
1.1055027246,
0.6608387828,
-0.7091203332,
0.7338443398,
0.1484629959,
-0.0213558804,
0.7172825933,
-0.798086822,
0.1369477808,
0.0695321187,
0.1730835885,
-1.0009040833,
-0.2059487551,
0.6968269348,
-0.696326077,
0.5305725932,
-0.3250574172,
-0.2438719273,
-0.3065714538,
-0.346157223,
0.3615425527,
0.5820326209,
-0.7638888955,
0.0942966267,
0.1306604743,
-0.2394738048,
-0.6507163644,
-0.6434572339,
0.2274793535,
-0.4605690539,
-0.6878914833,
0.050817769,
0.0802807584,
-0.0655135438,
0.0731927752,
0.15366368,
0.1228455007,
0.5978413224,
0.063625969,
0.379149437,
-0.2637879848,
-0.2889791429,
-0.1433838606,
0.2620096505,
0.404736042,
-0.2689783871,
0.3388237953,
-0.0884738564,
-0.8174954057,
-0.5628299117,
0.4108852148,
0.689663887,
-0.1691538841,
0.7115769386,
0.4143461287,
-0.3759550154,
-0.1051880494,
-0.0101123052,
-0.193809703,
-0.4990763366,
0.4490590096,
-0.329030484,
-0.5874338746,
0.466036886,
0.2771115005,
-0.0335509889,
0.4395970106,
0.0999365821,
0.2218701094,
1.4261525869,
0.1101486012,
-0.1799727231,
0.7292957306,
-0.0647442862,
0.057074856,
-0.6511257291,
-0.0182515979,
-0.7444942594,
0.0694845989,
-0.8312676549,
0.0658042282,
0.308080405,
0.2170994729,
-0.3716316223,
0.5571276546,
-0.5586070418,
0.3996028602,
0.8145049214,
0.2029845566,
-0.2084532231,
0.1062685251,
-0.1105445623,
0.229217574,
-0.5642138124,
-0.3194271028,
1.1776520014,
0.0426588766,
0.9397118688,
0.5627872944,
0.3725108802,
0.5124294162,
0.349118948,
-0.3705037832,
0.5655292869,
-0.2482403368,
-0.7852947712,
-0.2015151978,
-0.6076823473,
-1.1962894201,
0.1493392438,
0.0931827053,
-1.00144279,
-0.1597851664,
0.1647898704,
-0.3485336006,
0.5913634896,
-1.0010918379,
0.8267624974,
-0.4350435734,
-0.4131965637,
0.2972603142,
-0.5604268909,
0.7191086411,
-0.0194491055,
0.0258173887,
0.2362896353,
0.327867955,
0.3910367489,
-0.4009425938,
0.8186604381,
-0.5192111731,
-0.1941811591,
0.4680542052,
0.3645971119,
0.821723938,
0.0853293315,
-0.2495897412,
-0.2381197214,
-0.132846877,
-0.4984679222,
-0.8310880065,
0.7375003695,
-0.5649914145,
-0.9663054943,
-0.408718586,
-0.3012537658,
-0.0507308543,
0.2092577219,
0.4155539572,
0.4252678156,
-0.1268056482,
0.0653815046,
0.6117175817,
-0.555963099,
0.2993731201,
0.4449454844,
-0.1439435631,
-0.3148524463,
1.2813034058,
-0.2199846655,
0.5659146309,
0.3141766787,
0.1386761814,
-0.4679253995,
-0.5795388222,
-0.6581978202,
-0.1315808743,
-0.6796591878,
-0.3900153637,
-0.2986890078,
-0.1855966449,
-0.6968297958,
-0.1175053418,
0.077416569,
-0.5167644024,
-0.290479064,
-0.0519394986,
0.5402772427,
0.8146114349,
0.1653407216,
0.4145447314,
-0.8257484436,
0.1390387416,
0.479776144,
0.0763806179,
-0.0998267904,
-0.4428630769,
0.2138483375,
0.2408875674,
-0.5800692439,
-1.2212394476,
0.2337056398,
-0.1306888312,
0.5451029539,
0.5123131871,
0.4976285994,
0.2629694641,
-0.1654908061,
1.2294661999,
0.1389958709,
-0.61964643,
0.8583628535,
-0.5970866084,
0.2083430886,
0.4618040621,
0.3915187418,
-0.2573385537,
-0.7526161075,
-0.8276881576,
-0.6515225768,
0.8442694545,
0.3149805069,
0.0340105817,
-0.2158599645,
0.2732023001,
0.0455044694,
0.0596357472,
-0.5709386468,
-0.5413369536,
-0.3530021012,
-0.0668850467,
0.1931770891,
-0.0179384612,
-0.2437948436,
0.3102072775,
0.8581960797,
-0.0527944379,
0.1917726547,
0.005245944,
-0.001788225,
0.120021224,
0.3037389815,
0.6792550683,
0.2364052981,
-0.1140345857,
0.195468083,
0.0164433084,
-0.4030102789,
0.1691042632,
0.5214141011,
-0.6581313014,
-0.3670066893,
0.1624792367,
0.7842609882,
-0.1890749782,
-0.3019950986,
0.6201993823,
-0.5064124465,
0.033893045,
0.0593108386,
0.3184396327,
-0.2154805809,
-0.1053680778,
0.2627305984,
0.326322943,
0.2656861842,
-0.5271074176,
0.291741699,
0.848133862,
-0.6121739745,
-0.3497162759,
0.9594112039,
0.2337685376,
-0.3385336399,
0.4269498885,
-0.3315565288,
-0.7236919403,
0.7521195412,
0.7868694663,
0.8225200176,
-0.4089840651,
0.2364720106,
0.2156880349,
0.365200758,
0.2009029388,
0.2353225201,
0.0391176343,
-0.2970798314,
-0.0655777529,
-0.2376645803,
-0.4811588526,
0.3758115768,
-0.7301653028,
0.0445378609,
-0.3658010066,
-0.095061101,
-0.0375870168,
-0.2260400206,
-0.3345769942,
0.1658327579,
-0.0311778113,
0.5619837642,
-0.7182195783,
0.4325859845,
0.8979179263,
-0.493722111,
-0.6859899163,
0.0905599296,
0.1076167896,
-0.8811731339,
0.4221540689,
-0.0202075746,
-0.0325243883,
-0.2547140718,
-0.5920518041,
-0.7671661377,
0.7976560593,
0.42395401,
-0.0550550967,
-0.0782136098,
-0.0161920656,
0.3623263836,
0.0213887636,
0.2249073535,
0.2549633086,
0.2380058616,
0.0888282061,
-0.4671102464,
0.5708110332,
-0.1247138008,
-0.2517526448,
0.3046991527,
-0.478730768,
0.7846708298,
-0.2006494999,
-0.4039382041,
0.1417406052,
0.6198452115,
0.1342108697,
0.2151314616,
0.398696661,
0.4039030075,
0.9961833954,
-0.1555318832,
1.4979300499,
-0.4577600062,
-0.0418789871,
0.9841792583,
-0.1793103814,
0.5521600842,
0.2126162499,
-0.2649747431,
0.1909828633,
0.5253332257,
-0.0841840729,
0.6326214075,
0.3362074196,
-0.487370491,
0.1751274467,
-0.2468523532,
-0.6146282554,
0.2426067144,
0.3644631207,
-0.2476265877,
-0.2798928022,
0.2521154583,
0.2800141275,
0.0813270211,
-0.3214247525,
0.6985349059,
-0.148111403,
-0.9719023108,
0.6662463546,
-0.1323055178,
0.6789932847,
-0.7490050793,
0.1117498279,
-0.0626554862,
0.0652167648,
-0.0085932603,
-0.6282880306,
0.2826023102,
0.0848530903,
0.0882167444,
-0.0390768833,
0.9041636586,
-0.1964135766,
-0.3314864933,
-0.0707612708,
0.3188730776,
0.1435120851,
-0.0782091692,
-0.752520144,
-0.4353512824,
0.3256180584,
-0.2276836187,
0.5411350727,
0.4791446626,
-0.0511610992,
0.5962757468,
0.8279518485,
0.3757708073,
0.1423437893,
0.1454192847,
0.7396469712,
-0.4544111788,
-0.4975245297,
-0.8420526385,
0.0105963051,
-0.2023248225,
-0.1266318709,
0.8833543658,
0.3406692743,
0.6929774284,
0.0264905561,
1.0748018026,
-0.1212502122,
0.3451680243,
-0.5922732949,
0.9866079688,
-0.4302698672,
0.5042418838,
-0.302993983,
-0.4096567333,
-0.1914365888,
0.1398560256,
-0.3903419077,
0.0583432131,
0.7650776505,
0.8767153621,
0.1119823456,
0.2328943014,
0.1564416885,
0.0421156622,
0.7670124173,
0.7233936191,
1.0005434752,
-0.553643167,
1.0179649591,
-0.1205164716,
-0.1260383725,
-0.0801066086,
-0.9043126106,
-0.8360833526,
-0.2992835343,
-0.2897259295,
-0.7799507976,
0.3570959568,
0.4288303852,
0.5514809489,
-0.8255566955,
0.254504472,
-0.2851080894,
0.3927911222,
0.0378224179,
-0.3429510891,
0.5828698277,
-0.2308071405,
-0.6088331938,
0.5058506131,
-0.3448127806,
0.4133907557,
-0.1267085671,
0.2570445836,
-0.0772837251,
-0.0209562182,
0.263530761,
0.6340840459,
-0.5593578219,
-0.4815503061,
-0.0925324336,
-0.2803238332,
-0.3782522678,
0.5869708657,
-0.4909468889,
0.3086745739,
0.5032635331,
0.9069180489,
-0.0829605386,
0.3158969581,
0.8112480044,
-0.8591061234,
-0.0351458304,
0.1596247107,
0.3518840373,
0.3720494211,
-0.8209972382,
0.282336086,
0.163539499,
-0.4745819271,
-0.783616066,
0.5214471221,
-0.747824192,
-0.5417983532,
1.2116388083,
-0.4417900145,
-0.4433451593,
0.0105252555,
-0.3535372317,
0.2153919488,
-0.6636709571,
0.6866795421,
0.5236071944,
-0.2740899622,
0.357237488,
-0.5320479274,
0.7578541636,
0.3581091464,
-0.9497515559,
0.1228666678,
0.3745673597,
0.2102723122,
0.2044045776,
0.1359973997,
-0.2219900638,
0.4827810228,
0.1530743688,
-0.477388531,
-0.4437750876,
-0.0455829985,
-0.3889392316,
0.5110707283,
0.0714563653,
-0.5013504624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12327v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12327v2
|
Shall We Team Up: Exploring Spontaneous Cooperation of Competing LLM Agents
| 2024-02-19T18:00:53 | 2024-07-02T17:56:09 |
Zengqing Wu, Run Peng, Shuyuan Zheng, Qianying Liu, Xu Han, Brian Inhyuk Kwon, Makoto Onizuka, Shaojie Tang, Chuan Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.MA, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have increasingly been utilized in social
simulations, where they are often guided by carefully crafted instructions to
stably exhibit human-like behaviors during simulations. Nevertheless, we doubt
the necessity of shaping agents' behaviors for accurate social simulations.
Instead, this paper emphasizes the importance of spontaneous phenomena, wherein
agents deeply engage in contexts and make adaptive decisions without explicit
directions. We explored spontaneous cooperation across three competitive
scenarios and successfully simulated the gradual emergence of cooperation,
findings that align closely with human behavioral data. This approach not only
aids the computational social science community in bridging the gap between
simulations and real-world dynamics but also offers the AI community a novel
method to assess LLMs' capability of deliberate reasoning.
|
[
-0.2912637293,
-0.8376968503,
0.78928864,
0.6115332842,
-0.0302244965,
0.5929058194,
-0.3466033936,
-0.5797411203,
0.4330462813,
0.2658650875,
-0.7791121006,
0.0383155756,
-0.2131798714,
0.2849628329,
-0.0712652579,
0.3648747802,
0.2197281867,
0.1356959641,
-0.36423406,
-0.0658059865,
-0.544151783,
-0.6368889809,
-0.9310245514,
-0.6568475962,
0.6654525399,
0.5258933306,
0.704022944,
0.1118759289,
0.2512356937,
0.5713340044,
0.1166626662,
0.3932390213,
-0.6236152649,
0.572709918,
-0.2316940576,
-0.5440684557,
-0.3225131631,
0.4361866415,
0.5734418035,
0.7816392779,
-0.3439519107,
-0.2754103541,
0.1258804351,
0.4268662333,
-0.0013328105,
0.1555460393,
-0.8154768944,
0.0944325104,
-0.0087198783,
-0.2001688033,
-0.2168012857,
-0.2670306861,
0.1860722899,
-0.6789321899,
0.1875398755,
0.3109919131,
0.5890196562,
0.0857235789,
-0.3534064293,
-0.2336025238,
-0.9367328882,
0.6166762114,
-0.3188304007,
-0.0464835949,
0.3171510696,
0.2858574986,
-0.9072636366,
-0.8347323537,
-0.8389304876,
-0.4541255832,
0.2780441642,
0.3280615807,
0.0501713529,
-0.0088366512,
-0.0410003886,
-0.0877587572,
-0.3419207036,
0.2773782313,
-0.2391732484,
-0.0938936397,
1.0114246607,
0.4602226615,
0.446703583,
0.4609616399,
-0.4518505037,
0.052308131,
-0.3367466331,
0.1148137003,
0.0608726554,
0.3381547034,
-0.3303747177,
0.5672756433,
0.0646814927,
0.3749266267,
0.2383343279,
0.2734318972,
-0.2170804739,
-0.4518449903,
-0.3762851655,
0.0659169108,
0.7773578763,
0.5481621027,
0.2997530103,
-0.4198862016,
-0.1848732084,
0.40204373,
0.2072960436,
-0.2006351501,
0.0247095264,
0.0233234931,
-0.2115254849,
-0.5669056177,
-0.0464156009,
-0.5552608967,
-0.446117878,
-0.4079038501,
0.3937904835,
0.0621332414,
-0.3065467477,
-0.0940401182,
-0.3538119793,
0.3426964283,
0.6206610799,
-0.5529840589,
0.5098801851,
0.8073717952,
0.8022810221,
-0.1912097186,
-0.8429239392,
-0.4359254837,
0.1097575054,
-0.5818327665,
0.7504776716,
-0.2316381037,
-0.5642266273,
-0.0896089673,
-0.0765070394,
-0.0661769137,
-0.2754138708,
0.271945715,
-0.5928764939,
-0.0476701297,
-0.654663384,
-0.5593826175,
0.2513973117,
0.4067098498,
-0.6412728429,
0.7728379965,
-0.0210354924,
-0.5392888784,
0.5279043317,
-0.4663469195,
-0.3583328128,
0.4636434913,
-0.3846928775,
0.0619415566,
-0.0009708271,
-0.3901274502,
0.5016842484,
-0.20518592,
0.2180952132,
-0.6823347807,
-0.3679046631,
0.8505685925,
-0.1101584658,
0.7888599634,
0.0838952288,
-0.1711999476,
0.3185867369,
0.0102677057,
-0.2798369229,
0.2844776511,
-0.0638190061,
-0.2971534431,
0.2326999158,
-0.3241600394,
0.3655552864,
0.1697835773,
-0.1712286025,
0.6187134385,
-0.1825885773,
0.4575913548,
1.090765357,
0.1832106858,
0.8779146075,
-0.8382632136,
0.5075907111,
-0.349786222,
0.2105351388,
0.4429799616,
-0.7453100681,
-0.5974273682,
-0.1708549559,
-0.076549612,
0.4946980476,
-0.8969194293,
0.1561634243,
0.0394858122,
-0.3732086718,
-0.0719468892,
0.0899987966,
0.0503582954,
0.1202141792,
-0.114063777,
-0.2161509544,
-0.6693766713,
-0.3748061061,
-0.1151108742,
-0.2456262112,
0.0702472478,
0.4729265273,
0.2447700948,
-0.2793818414,
1.0059922934,
-0.0101179481,
-0.2567638755,
-0.6862725019,
0.217988342,
-0.0050190934,
0.3565522134,
0.5020080805,
-0.7130814791,
-0.5372794867,
-0.0981159583,
-1.0101245642,
0.042204719,
-0.267210573,
-0.3523370624,
0.2987552583,
0.6753687859,
-0.5538942814,
0.1487448663,
0.7096444964,
-0.6199319959,
0.5572454333,
-0.3555436432,
0.2621353865,
-0.9848647118,
-0.41203022,
-0.0902773514,
-0.1558915526,
-0.7122744322,
-0.072096087,
-0.4540110528,
0.1815532744,
-0.2620847821,
0.6467298269,
-0.7457119226,
-0.1321975291,
-0.1564641744,
0.4026195407,
-0.3394194543,
0.1356429905,
0.0598476306,
0.7426126599,
0.662302196,
-0.5952016115,
0.6129714251,
-0.1106380969,
-0.0912380815,
0.4016073644,
-0.6272758245,
0.2696343064,
0.1522791535,
0.6082871556,
-0.8146983385,
-0.6953015327,
0.1707810909,
-0.482960552,
0.0411868468,
0.0614851341,
-0.7220534086,
-0.369291693,
-0.2764241099,
0.3696574867,
0.4657710195,
-0.1961763203,
0.6218062043,
0.5988843441,
-0.0163419787,
-0.1803250611,
-0.5777941942,
0.2836415768,
-0.2574697137,
-0.9440822601,
0.3364343941,
-0.3099330366,
-0.8688287735,
-0.064120613,
0.2006876916,
-0.1621992439,
0.2734680772,
0.4475750029,
0.4377760887,
0.0988983363,
-0.2606366575,
-0.1529618204,
0.3117496967,
0.0289231781,
-0.0740271062,
0.6343665719,
-0.0744141787,
-0.1470652372,
-0.2975958884,
0.2540885806,
0.5934789181,
0.2522703111,
0.9825032949,
0.1872508675,
-0.3752734065,
-0.358183682,
-0.5822036862,
-0.2327187061,
-0.5983200073,
-0.0538469329,
-0.0278856494,
-1.0804433823,
0.8128150702,
-0.0769801587,
-0.038550023,
-0.2677002549,
0.616977036,
-0.3151022792,
0.9143416286,
0.6765259504,
-0.2605972886,
0.1586747617,
0.2427929938,
-0.1191723123,
-0.336743772,
-0.4531282783,
-0.3517279625,
-0.3621015847,
-0.5998133421,
-0.8423714638,
0.4978372157,
0.1724957973,
0.0844024718,
0.1121419221,
-0.1118723154,
0.7264004946,
0.1542189121,
0.0631750003,
0.091359064,
-0.2721867859,
-0.2321244776,
-0.0283103194,
-0.8942065239,
-0.1875787675,
0.6290478706,
-0.0976133645,
0.421464622,
0.1666725427,
0.8282698393,
0.5499447584,
0.5789848566,
-0.5733953714,
0.8556121588,
0.5126598477,
-0.4870297015,
-0.4462484419,
-0.4274148345,
-1.3883218765,
0.0848046765,
-0.5464424491,
-0.7295222282,
-0.0896178111,
-0.1089625359,
-0.3773575425,
0.1541977674,
-0.4261864722,
0.4971639514,
-0.145321086,
-0.6031098962,
-0.3610759377,
-0.6086888909,
0.6270008683,
-0.0244031567,
0.5731235743,
-0.0775636584,
-0.2081634998,
0.4751006663,
-0.1743908674,
0.9804967046,
0.1667068005,
-0.0687936321,
0.4331070781,
0.4636646211,
0.6117494702,
0.2893328071,
-0.1232125312,
-0.06744124,
-0.4054523408,
-0.4946725965,
-0.5207734704,
0.7971894145,
-0.7757275701,
-0.6103244424,
-0.5567495227,
-0.5147520304,
-0.1510114819,
-0.0561582632,
0.0236603394,
0.1163007841,
-0.635353446,
-0.1388069838,
0.4974226058,
0.0642038733,
0.6148260236,
0.5712935328,
-0.2971943617,
-0.2489643991,
0.7407444715,
-0.133000657,
0.3065800965,
-0.1397161186,
0.1005916595,
-0.0348399058,
-0.3235979974,
0.0561774671,
0.2721168697,
-0.2800560892,
-0.0463414714,
-0.2343056202,
0.0670989677,
-0.4252022207,
-0.7295845151,
-0.1699598283,
-0.0891500488,
-0.080486238,
0.0308537371,
0.1239719242,
1.0707486868,
-0.4317228794,
-0.0869367197,
-0.9062457085,
0.0193927474,
0.6300177574,
-0.0094067259,
0.0728384629,
-0.1522572339,
0.0533789694,
-0.0253031105,
0.1457773149,
-1.1484673023,
0.4027805328,
-0.1607994139,
0.8760220408,
0.147325173,
0.1567053795,
0.4322900772,
-0.3134057522,
0.9173581004,
0.0427431203,
-0.8151401281,
0.3409994245,
-0.732852757,
0.0009278599,
0.4319531024,
0.4222022891,
-0.4893577695,
-0.3575798571,
-0.6797639132,
-0.7154726982,
0.6694398522,
0.5214015841,
0.054928083,
0.0106304558,
0.4052154422,
-0.3538768589,
-0.1540868133,
-0.5792930722,
-0.1485411823,
0.5072987676,
0.3242756426,
-0.1546664089,
0.080904372,
-0.5758846998,
-0.2256233692,
0.2186090648,
0.130790472,
0.1532375067,
0.2828457355,
0.0416335948,
-0.5033023953,
-0.1129498854,
0.7632666826,
0.3523606658,
0.1532401741,
0.0439496115,
0.4627548158,
-0.2046771944,
0.215734154,
-0.1995909512,
0.355264008,
-0.3815425336,
0.4328907132,
0.2002123147,
0.3124323487,
-0.6398008466,
0.507548213,
-0.6136780381,
-0.474206984,
-0.4475218654,
0.1865745038,
0.3831381798,
0.6972184181,
0.4368847013,
0.253752321,
-0.308911413,
-0.9227833748,
0.4021410346,
0.5291228294,
-0.0805300847,
-0.544243753,
0.2761789858,
0.6121738553,
-0.7684063315,
0.4738968015,
-0.7033227682,
-0.7825266123,
0.8613462448,
0.3093831539,
0.8001093864,
-0.2036786526,
0.1084513515,
0.0648288876,
0.3145537376,
-0.4511067867,
-0.0102988435,
-0.2602775097,
-1.1044089794,
-0.3859912455,
-0.4471036792,
-0.6298999786,
-0.1891236156,
-0.2820162773,
0.2208838463,
-0.4949949384,
-0.0301296078,
-0.2004400492,
0.2572489381,
-0.6370277405,
-0.3373515904,
0.380617559,
0.7319503427,
-0.800117135,
1.0361769199,
0.7064025402,
-0.2353098392,
-1.0612165928,
0.0770114213,
0.2199900597,
-0.6312661171,
0.7028314471,
-0.02660124,
-0.2802688181,
0.0629141927,
-1.0679552555,
-0.5316271782,
1.3577731848,
-0.0049710423,
-0.5684314966,
-0.1310736686,
-0.1414216757,
0.3961034715,
-0.3463954628,
-0.0385177322,
0.3684306443,
0.4496389329,
0.2216110528,
-1.0794165134,
0.3274593055,
-0.2231598347,
-0.237590313,
-0.164213419,
-1.0104782581,
0.8297931552,
-0.3276210427,
-0.1364159286,
0.1801805645,
0.8414515257,
0.6621085405,
0.5472617149,
0.642822504,
0.1185753122,
0.7297920585,
0.1229502186,
0.7106974125,
-0.0405455418,
0.2229004353,
0.7858757973,
-1.0484737158,
0.4230439067,
0.3454929888,
-0.2913112938,
0.3429155648,
0.4966689646,
0.0943003148,
0.0301809963,
0.2450947762,
-0.6745599508,
-0.7103349566,
-0.0790247172,
-0.1110032052,
0.4974165559,
0.5197201967,
0.2279301137,
0.0007926904,
-0.2719832063,
-0.1377780139,
0.2665856481,
-0.1960018575,
0.7250474095,
0.2000669986,
-0.9117724299,
0.0004309684,
-0.2901253104,
0.9774284363,
-0.3791518211,
-0.1097658649,
-0.3863343596,
-0.065867126,
-0.0772239417,
-0.6678358316,
0.0489302054,
-0.1639551222,
0.0528621599,
-0.0912865102,
0.7237557173,
-0.3191856742,
-0.1223229989,
0.5874253511,
0.599786818,
0.0413640812,
0.2665534616,
-0.7104994059,
0.232231617,
-0.3374880254,
-0.1309865266,
0.741814971,
0.7489868402,
-0.0866005048,
0.7462674975,
0.9414394498,
0.1580769569,
0.0021137432,
0.0316794515,
1.02627635,
-0.5448832512,
-0.3924462795,
-0.9433406591,
0.3217760026,
-0.3888070583,
0.0652968138,
0.8038859367,
0.1308597028,
0.624630928,
0.2703416049,
0.5524950624,
-0.1047044024,
0.0240890495,
-0.3413628638,
0.8547560573,
-0.4551251531,
0.2492429465,
-0.2470902503,
-0.6951754093,
-0.2632106245,
0.3963239789,
0.2185015976,
-0.0226768404,
0.4300820231,
0.8062769771,
0.2166779041,
-0.0018521942,
0.4878889024,
0.1682421863,
0.1292237937,
0.4352787137,
1.3315563202,
0.246489048,
0.3022011817,
-0.0143982228,
-0.5273707509,
-0.1468537748,
-0.9581249952,
-1.0435575247,
-0.3772959113,
-0.0882991999,
-0.534637332,
0.1180795878,
1.5554492474,
0.4865091741,
-0.1949843764,
-0.642475009,
-0.3615683019,
0.2288595736,
-0.0756512657,
-0.2802401781,
-0.5021110177,
-0.4572454095,
-0.6227934361,
0.8099196553,
0.1740988791,
0.2598724961,
-0.3247711062,
-0.4882172942,
-0.3204935789,
0.4862583578,
0.4493148327,
0.5469411016,
-0.4155143797,
0.08082892,
0.1317690313,
-0.3809605539,
-0.4125240445,
1.1154865026,
-0.7051599026,
0.1178779602,
0.5919674039,
0.2345628738,
0.2021082342,
-0.1270493567,
0.9832943678,
-0.6156837344,
0.4183629155,
0.3937951028,
0.1965475082,
0.0905199125,
-0.2409825325,
0.4042035937,
0.5306404829,
-1.0062336922,
-1.0754805803,
0.0377364531,
-1.1440637112,
-0.2886793613,
1.1504693031,
-0.3073976636,
-0.2362342775,
-0.2833511233,
-0.1264944822,
0.4533891678,
-0.5670818686,
0.932297051,
0.7381691933,
-0.5282570124,
0.1144878045,
-0.394733727,
0.5897729993,
0.3120064139,
-0.6408303976,
-0.1536545455,
0.380099237,
0.0179187451,
-0.0074131228,
0.9620545506,
0.5755442381,
0.185123235,
0.1053428203,
-0.400342077,
0.1819759011,
-0.2731257677,
-0.2877549529,
-0.1419966221,
0.4161816537,
0.3563329279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12326v1
|
LLM Agents for Psychology: A Study on Gamified Assessments
| 2024-02-19T18:00:30 | 2024-02-19T18:00:30 |
Qisen Yang, Zekun Wang, Honghui Chen, Shenzhi Wang, Yifan Pu, Xin Gao, Wenhao Huang, Shiji Song, Gao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Psychological measurement is essential for mental health, self-understanding,
and personal development. Traditional methods, such as self-report scales and
psychologist interviews, often face challenges with engagement and
accessibility. While game-based and LLM-based tools have been explored to
improve user interest and automate assessment, they struggle to balance
engagement with generalizability. In this work, we propose PsychoGAT
(Psychological Game AgenTs) to achieve a generic gamification of psychological
assessment. The main insight is that powerful LLMs can function both as adept
psychologists and innovative game designers. By incorporating LLM agents into
designated roles and carefully managing their interactions, PsychoGAT can
transform any standardized scales into personalized and engaging interactive
fiction games. To validate the proposed method, we conduct psychometric
evaluations to assess its effectiveness and employ human evaluators to examine
the generated content across various psychological constructs, including
depression, cognitive distortions, and personality traits. Results demonstrate
that PsychoGAT serves as an effective assessment tool, achieving statistically
significant excellence in psychometric metrics such as reliability, convergent
validity, and discriminant validity. Moreover, human evaluations confirm
PsychoGAT's enhancements in content coherence, interactivity, interest,
immersion, and satisfaction.
|
[
-0.6522185206,
-0.7586727738,
0.7607551813,
0.7389432192,
0.0264484342,
0.6078023911,
-0.2850395441,
-0.2691382766,
0.4048166871,
-0.0058859941,
-0.8116235137,
-0.3713051975,
-0.2677001953,
0.2037581801,
0.0705802366,
0.9643291831,
0.0119952932,
0.1608923227,
-0.5530766845,
0.090067625,
-0.4801107943,
-0.4845384061,
-0.5335697532,
-0.8355227709,
0.6452925205,
0.0046214988,
0.7525913715,
0.0315224603,
0.655793488,
0.2551308572,
0.2090221494,
0.3188420236,
-0.6480739117,
0.2338421643,
-0.3890753686,
-0.4918514192,
-0.6512200832,
0.4205076396,
-0.0710257366,
0.0303075779,
-0.4353748262,
0.5481609702,
0.0427844562,
0.1058847383,
-0.6219694018,
0.1350623071,
0.2198961824,
0.3022889793,
0.3102715909,
-0.3793163002,
-0.2216047347,
-0.7009525299,
-0.3314624727,
-0.5300386548,
0.1302458048,
-0.1796188056,
0.600857079,
0.1081768423,
-0.246309787,
-0.5174354315,
-0.9943903685,
0.4823512733,
-0.4827308655,
-0.1361628324,
0.4888328314,
0.3885194063,
-0.3764507771,
-0.253772974,
-0.4086995423,
-0.5344600677,
0.110265173,
0.5090685487,
-0.2104903907,
0.2731792927,
0.0565290041,
0.3846355975,
-0.556415379,
0.1691386402,
-0.0707955956,
-0.2584306598,
1.2183320522,
0.8903623819,
0.5413221717,
0.2304199785,
-0.264741689,
0.1732005924,
-0.2438570857,
0.2166961432,
0.4707913101,
-0.1714446247,
-0.2424286753,
0.4155717492,
-0.0643556714,
0.2118000835,
0.5052599311,
-0.5105635524,
0.1177616939,
-0.1297654659,
-0.0248426404,
-0.2837019265,
0.8318685293,
0.7319741249,
0.1535486877,
-0.3835596144,
-0.1384513378,
0.4406497478,
0.5302196145,
-0.6639087796,
-0.4827690721,
0.6808844209,
-0.3037395775,
-0.4760413766,
-0.1468781531,
-0.9889876842,
-0.8223161697,
-0.125794962,
0.4734400213,
-0.3071333468,
-0.2478901595,
0.1325690448,
-0.0826783106,
0.3339753151,
0.4659903049,
-0.9941657782,
0.2462348342,
0.6491934657,
0.8666406274,
-0.3439282775,
-0.2805330455,
-0.2086687088,
-0.1189534143,
-0.5943933129,
0.903979063,
-0.2692409456,
-0.629553616,
-0.0138882017,
-0.3351221681,
0.4388998151,
-0.440589577,
0.1351102293,
-0.0677487999,
0.26040259,
-0.1372280121,
-0.3626433909,
-0.1432320029,
0.734582901,
-0.1358367652,
1.0217752457,
0.3837209344,
0.0702511519,
0.4567885697,
-0.7945625186,
-0.1443241686,
0.547573626,
-0.220222041,
0.1075893566,
0.6048315763,
0.0951092392,
0.3252518177,
-0.3938370347,
0.0943754539,
-0.3974140286,
-0.8315427303,
0.6170839667,
-0.135067299,
0.7776041031,
0.2074054927,
-0.2375853956,
0.1807902604,
-0.4751897752,
0.3301647007,
-0.0209957175,
-0.2738395333,
-0.0601579398,
0.0244524535,
-0.0575986765,
0.334921211,
0.1025075614,
-0.5092865229,
0.3292343318,
0.1124951243,
0.0102946265,
0.7994098663,
0.2825769484,
0.2738901675,
-0.4654894173,
1.2897421122,
-0.5679953694,
0.4496020973,
0.4949327111,
-0.5698409081,
-0.3002715707,
-0.9622378945,
0.0777651072,
0.6244251132,
-0.3062188327,
0.9010255933,
0.033902768,
-1.0120705366,
-0.4010801315,
0.227975443,
0.1358283013,
0.2097621709,
-0.1813565493,
-0.6932218671,
-0.3078778088,
-0.2341499627,
-0.1734519005,
-0.3972339332,
-0.4840353131,
0.1867965758,
0.3803260624,
-0.5495631695,
1.0120186806,
-0.442209661,
-0.6461251974,
-0.1241992861,
0.4501902163,
0.1226104349,
0.0635232553,
0.5429146886,
-0.3122353554,
-0.2951218784,
-0.2411487103,
-1.2807819843,
-0.4813847244,
-0.2707096934,
0.0207513589,
-0.6000558138,
0.0227768142,
-0.5075447559,
0.384152174,
0.314458549,
-0.5706914067,
0.9658478498,
-0.3903276622,
0.3832413554,
-0.0930727199,
-0.2057710439,
-0.0288354214,
-0.2056037039,
-0.6750956178,
0.4852390587,
-0.0917347893,
-0.1362426281,
-0.3936867118,
0.5738254786,
-0.387304008,
0.2165312767,
-0.3353886306,
0.2672975957,
-0.1626654714,
0.5513191223,
-0.2819808722,
0.7748264074,
0.471018374,
-0.6042669415,
0.8377856612,
0.2088679969,
-0.208596617,
1.1391966343,
-0.411511898,
0.3711709976,
-0.0558615923,
0.1674309075,
-1.0494391918,
0.0222693812,
0.5589568019,
-0.6812661886,
-0.417289108,
0.6160197258,
-0.6098902822,
-0.3689877689,
-0.5685279965,
-0.058226265,
0.7078951001,
-0.1973106265,
0.9043656588,
0.2320618629,
-0.0477830321,
-0.1009862944,
-0.6613814235,
0.24314408,
-0.6499351859,
-0.3967253864,
-0.088366136,
-0.3890084922,
-0.3436737657,
-0.2192368507,
0.0944000185,
0.1009104252,
0.1768449396,
0.4522272944,
0.2817959189,
0.0058079297,
0.176562652,
-0.3290551007,
-0.1119277403,
0.6413062811,
0.4631759226,
0.6346919537,
-0.3168801665,
-0.2325114906,
-0.1884619892,
0.2296540588,
0.3262169957,
-0.3137827516,
0.2203383446,
1.1403436661,
-0.2875055969,
0.0680689067,
-0.7112250328,
0.0327223912,
-0.4805853665,
0.2922493517,
-0.4196049869,
-0.7715479732,
0.8097881675,
-0.2064870298,
-0.1158049703,
-0.1583046019,
1.0646282434,
-0.3676513135,
1.2433465719,
0.3733701706,
-0.020723328,
0.0920462757,
-0.0096578794,
0.3768047988,
-0.8744143248,
-0.3259097934,
-0.1083328351,
-0.7129732966,
-0.3504223526,
-0.3458100557,
0.3077355027,
-0.1782310754,
-0.412976265,
-0.3623605371,
-0.6310324073,
0.3952482939,
0.2165257782,
0.3483867943,
0.3661554754,
0.0119912643,
-0.0927767083,
-0.3091525733,
0.039849773,
-0.4805502295,
1.0141756535,
0.2558439672,
1.1271721125,
0.4166685343,
1.0574245453,
0.8863579035,
0.903788805,
-1.0290260315,
0.6150271297,
0.5581684113,
-0.8901515007,
-0.2568720281,
-0.1213811338,
-0.5828564763,
0.3975335658,
-0.2239545882,
-1.332277894,
0.3251697421,
-0.2980652153,
-0.6457636952,
-0.0841765851,
-0.5452805758,
0.3495023847,
-0.6464069486,
-0.5322377086,
-0.3158738315,
-0.1186422557,
0.4457196295,
-0.1666998863,
0.0633582324,
-0.3842386305,
-0.3148492873,
0.6109378338,
-0.1082641557,
0.4534601569,
-0.2851007879,
-0.2724256516,
0.3406080008,
0.6166529655,
0.0566686243,
0.4229601324,
0.0271271374,
-0.0459118262,
0.0917095393,
-0.3430964351,
-1.2325037718,
0.2692801952,
-0.8586530685,
-0.7760993838,
-0.8223298788,
-0.8225384355,
-0.5854262114,
-0.0772828609,
-0.0563917533,
-0.1842830926,
-0.6218962073,
-0.1197629794,
0.2861255705,
-0.0612036847,
-0.0329092182,
0.6398450732,
-0.6174277663,
-0.4504580796,
0.8643742204,
-0.4069775939,
0.0023136202,
-0.1193181351,
0.2578286827,
-0.3123740554,
-0.2011829019,
0.1370113194,
0.1705953628,
-0.4094103277,
0.0050931904,
-0.0120011419,
0.1421455592,
-0.2400544584,
-0.3621628582,
0.1225471199,
0.2560648322,
-0.1205596477,
-0.4426698983,
0.1880583763,
0.7620672584,
-0.6495968699,
0.5466022491,
-0.2100201398,
0.3502985239,
0.1980175823,
0.1525632739,
0.095966883,
-0.2034888715,
0.0109955147,
-0.0201634225,
-0.6374546885,
-0.9907383919,
0.4342059493,
0.0604886599,
0.3941725492,
0.8466591835,
-0.2303024232,
0.7872601748,
-0.0840870738,
0.9778234959,
0.483587116,
-0.7282339931,
0.2035631835,
-0.4210608304,
0.1238277927,
0.6655746698,
0.4796182513,
-0.6567263007,
-0.4650293589,
-0.3805737197,
-0.2450824231,
0.4263534546,
-0.0307954531,
0.3098107874,
-0.0483417027,
0.3676467538,
0.0202097539,
0.274725318,
-0.5011966825,
-0.3092952669,
0.1497755051,
-0.1860685498,
-0.6512265801,
-0.2338272035,
-0.3202986717,
-0.3352129459,
0.3762753308,
0.1436550617,
0.69162184,
0.1792132705,
0.0123493653,
-0.0355678946,
0.2691640854,
0.3653644919,
0.8476062417,
-0.6807366014,
0.0502018407,
0.0418368988,
-0.8095261455,
1.1787122488,
-0.1495185047,
0.0034128847,
-0.2869710326,
0.075436689,
-0.0748696402,
-0.2470434457,
-0.848714292,
0.3385961652,
-0.3146329522,
-0.2937587798,
-0.2277895361,
0.3233155012,
0.1448898911,
0.4936586022,
0.3282026052,
-0.3769218922,
0.2014983147,
-0.7734655738,
0.1311549991,
0.1850474328,
-0.4959429204,
-0.1477839053,
0.5465974808,
0.1208483726,
-0.8483661413,
0.6651750207,
-0.695797503,
-0.2290050238,
0.4889904857,
0.4535584748,
0.997610271,
-0.2966278195,
0.9885752797,
-0.0719505847,
0.4584788978,
0.1051186919,
0.5133249164,
-0.0387929529,
-0.6418600678,
-0.0618025847,
-0.2357459813,
-0.6625367403,
0.2274414897,
-0.5926112533,
-0.0649767742,
-0.7423127294,
-0.6791340709,
-0.5705010891,
0.4288833141,
-0.8219849467,
0.3519053757,
0.209640041,
0.5461025834,
-0.9389669299,
0.1024704278,
0.8141008019,
-0.7815984488,
-0.5745899081,
-0.2914311886,
0.1756581217,
-0.7071714401,
0.2237152904,
-0.1698503047,
-0.0851726681,
-0.2592020631,
-0.5198169351,
-0.4300836921,
1.0970598459,
0.3986988664,
0.0117666256,
-0.2654273212,
0.262296766,
1.1492030621,
-0.4810560942,
0.806825459,
0.4691568613,
0.5043359399,
-0.2875981629,
-0.3147811294,
0.1636850387,
-0.2313108593,
0.0332572386,
-0.316244632,
-0.724571228,
0.5201488733,
-0.1639401019,
-0.0503190458,
0.2790054381,
0.8724454045,
0.6780145168,
0.3201564848,
0.2437089384,
0.204742521,
0.9240955114,
-0.0426315628,
0.8575334549,
-0.0172620434,
0.5942863822,
0.9217290282,
-0.5300041437,
0.313459307,
0.4873450994,
-0.4943659306,
0.6054731011,
0.9928953052,
-0.5002574921,
0.4652096629,
0.835788548,
-0.3665137887,
-0.3806205392,
-0.146820724,
-0.0158459079,
0.510246098,
0.514115274,
-0.0307994597,
-0.3571077585,
0.2632987201,
-0.0344757624,
0.1830473393,
-0.2513741255,
0.1641892046,
0.0830063522,
-0.4831397831,
0.2199984938,
0.0194936525,
0.7989142537,
-0.7929760814,
0.2569732964,
-0.601783514,
0.302424252,
-0.2784223855,
-0.56852597,
-0.3417521715,
0.1029873043,
0.3597662449,
-0.122984089,
0.8328284621,
-0.0245917477,
-0.4331770837,
0.3384086788,
0.9482632279,
0.369202733,
-0.0941309854,
-0.6799655557,
-0.1002018824,
-0.3752539456,
-0.1787066907,
0.5284825563,
0.1477394104,
0.2614348531,
1.0341457129,
0.3333241045,
0.5163035393,
-0.1907788962,
-0.1228627414,
0.0574877076,
-0.5581883788,
-0.7683419585,
-0.8865251541,
0.1750009805,
0.1129395738,
-0.5223369598,
0.9457433224,
0.4100104272,
0.2754716575,
-0.3071819246,
0.666721642,
-0.1576254368,
-0.1452136636,
0.0292280484,
0.8847956657,
-0.4567304552,
-0.3573583364,
-0.2905470431,
-1.0188554525,
-0.2761462331,
0.7150018215,
-0.3737140894,
0.0752451345,
0.527923286,
0.6951838732,
0.221895054,
-0.1266075522,
0.5096549392,
-0.234922722,
0.6787189245,
0.7671836615,
1.3563374281,
-0.1024446413,
0.1396463662,
-0.1559069455,
-0.6368724108,
-0.0562023707,
-0.6198114753,
-1.169077754,
-0.290320009,
-0.4155083895,
-0.3814391494,
0.2039704323,
0.8528520465,
0.3512460291,
-0.2348582447,
-0.7517425418,
0.4946561158,
-0.1187659428,
-0.7005721331,
-0.3363720477,
0.0819063783,
-0.1289958656,
-0.3920420706,
0.0881342068,
0.2615452409,
-0.4207290411,
-0.8463758826,
-0.2500745356,
-0.1874931604,
0.4231718779,
0.5178390741,
0.2303769886,
-0.6949765682,
-0.4504300058,
-0.0076823481,
-0.2880609334,
-0.0173223969,
0.7203017473,
-0.6614271998,
0.6048725247,
0.4411860704,
0.4146627784,
0.2171843201,
0.2664498389,
0.7419743538,
-0.1029973552,
-0.0547317974,
0.2309393585,
-0.0311058816,
-0.0482655503,
-0.6468156576,
0.8746134043,
0.0014460878,
-0.563041389,
-0.8477007747,
-0.1296213418,
-0.9515553713,
0.3730642498,
0.9763659835,
-0.4121230841,
-0.1319729388,
0.0464450195,
-0.3591709435,
-0.125917241,
-0.3331207037,
1.0990983248,
1.1285771132,
-0.7877833843,
-0.1351837963,
-0.3723281324,
0.304104805,
0.302939117,
-0.832568109,
-0.5360757113,
0.437143296,
0.2896959186,
0.3391980529,
0.8791601658,
-0.0916185975,
0.4937300086,
-0.0230278764,
0.3982500136,
-0.1364242136,
0.1723945886,
-0.5011208653,
0.1469899714,
-0.0240726899,
-0.1223989427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15401v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15401v2
|
Large Language Model for Mental Health: A Systematic Review
| 2024-02-19T17:58:41 | 2024-05-29T21:55:17 |
Zhijun Guo, Alvina Lai, Johan Hilge Thygesen, Joseph Farrington, Thomas Keen, Kezhi Li
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for
potential applications in digital health, while their application in mental
health is subject to ongoing debate. This systematic review aims to evaluate
the usage of LLMs in mental health, focusing on their strengths and limitations
in early screening, digital interventions, and clinical applications. Adhering
to PRISMA guidelines, we searched PubMed, IEEE Xplore, Scopus, and the JMIR
using keywords: 'mental health OR mental illness OR mental disorder OR
psychiatry' AND 'large language models'. We included articles published between
January 1, 2017, and December 31, 2023, excluding non-English articles. 30
articles were evaluated, which included research on mental illness and suicidal
ideation detection through text (n=12), usage of LLMs for mental health
conversational agents (CAs) (n=5), and other applications and evaluations of
LLMs in mental health (n=13). LLMs exhibit substantial effectiveness in
detecting mental health issues and providing accessible, de-stigmatized eHealth
services. However, the current risks associated with the clinical use might
surpass their benefits. The study identifies several significant issues: the
lack of multilingual datasets annotated by experts, concerns about the accuracy
and reliability of the content generated, challenges in interpretability due to
the 'black box' nature of LLMs, and persistent ethical dilemmas. These include
the lack of a clear ethical framework, concerns about data privacy, and the
potential for over-reliance on LLMs by both therapists and patients, which
could compromise traditional medical practice. Despite these issues, the rapid
development of LLMs underscores their potential as new clinical aids,
emphasizing the need for continued research and development in this area.
|
[
-0.2539986968,
-0.6880477667,
1.0696567297,
0.320899725,
-0.2360748351,
-0.111193642,
-0.4247731864,
-0.6528951526,
0.3653385937,
0.5479626656,
-0.4731743932,
-0.6206048131,
-0.9829190373,
0.3461002707,
-0.5392552614,
0.7745956779,
-0.1742542237,
0.5905301571,
0.2165865451,
0.0709408149,
-0.3645842969,
-0.6149461865,
-0.7209430337,
-0.4262304902,
0.770470202,
0.1253065169,
0.6737776995,
-0.028771529,
0.8090147972,
0.2470092177,
-0.3746945858,
0.0681369379,
-0.5242733359,
0.2053213716,
-0.1251524836,
-0.3197091222,
-0.733802259,
-0.1496411562,
0.5068920255,
0.7338016033,
-0.366378814,
0.2667471766,
-0.0677890852,
0.6268506646,
-0.4366208017,
-0.0365492478,
-0.2213195413,
0.2556791902,
-0.2771698833,
0.0597112924,
-0.2040481567,
-0.2849786282,
0.0711781979,
-0.3510885835,
-0.3188796639,
-0.1216708794,
0.2416863143,
0.1343396455,
-0.6086214781,
-0.2915835083,
-0.9590021968,
0.556976378,
-0.9504237771,
0.4105028212,
0.3383959532,
0.2647046745,
-0.3325408101,
-0.4799941182,
-0.5489081144,
-0.1523116082,
0.0534079112,
0.0676452741,
-0.3268401325,
0.2804396152,
0.5925651193,
0.4205779135,
-0.6281832457,
0.2404821813,
-0.5221562386,
-0.1066864952,
0.7658964992,
0.5366388559,
0.4804235101,
-0.0725968108,
0.0946515501,
0.2380966842,
-0.7043529749,
-0.1898812801,
0.1355198175,
0.0297048613,
-0.1418307573,
1.0902104378,
-0.0456811637,
0.4070161283,
-0.1960416287,
-0.70981282,
0.120787628,
-0.2146198601,
-0.20953013,
0.0441088863,
0.8446964025,
0.6458947062,
0.1461839676,
-0.0598494746,
-0.1836420894,
0.0256495252,
0.3281920552,
-0.8511192799,
0.1188821197,
0.6209210157,
-0.5717276335,
0.2520397305,
-0.2060969621,
-0.4337156415,
-0.5959852338,
-0.3041494489,
-0.0365864672,
-0.341008544,
-0.3461242616,
0.5028315187,
0.0323149711,
0.0639467835,
0.3123934865,
-0.5346713662,
0.2678617537,
0.8001099229,
0.9283363819,
-0.2410409898,
-0.1204166189,
0.1537054628,
0.0294228531,
-0.5871403813,
0.6278738379,
-0.2463205755,
-0.4853155911,
0.3262461126,
0.2095379382,
0.0137333153,
-0.5354246497,
0.5660896897,
-0.1681614667,
0.1255145818,
-0.4085722268,
-0.3568173349,
0.0447944552,
0.1104549095,
-0.6170269847,
0.4721112251,
-0.0833871365,
-0.880425036,
0.1695571244,
-0.4083740711,
-0.4259447157,
0.1341743022,
-0.1245707124,
-0.2163806409,
0.244730413,
0.1012483314,
0.460435003,
-0.5852615833,
0.6006726027,
-0.6700166464,
-0.5158421993,
0.4784638584,
-0.2383211255,
0.8043056726,
0.3743366897,
-0.1933348924,
0.1985569745,
-0.4523624182,
-0.1875694096,
0.2569244802,
-0.0961085334,
-0.4672209024,
0.1006483734,
0.3006023467,
0.3762947619,
0.1200936064,
-0.5907122493,
-0.0514001958,
-0.3902545869,
0.4850021005,
0.4109653234,
0.2813083827,
-0.0046678931,
-0.5299029946,
0.5892854333,
-0.1935684383,
0.5085830092,
0.0023529851,
-0.58465904,
-0.2394685149,
-0.6147418022,
-0.0266534295,
0.5293850303,
-0.4794174135,
0.6356930137,
-0.1684407145,
-0.517092526,
-0.4945610166,
0.0192896407,
0.0889897868,
0.0201071613,
0.0376399383,
-0.3220993578,
-0.2855488062,
-1.0503379107,
0.0084243631,
-0.1460011899,
-0.1169105917,
0.3132751584,
0.6267775893,
-0.9937918186,
0.545540452,
-0.2656738758,
-0.4137497842,
-0.3214304447,
-0.0952279568,
0.048378557,
-0.1204084381,
0.1973905265,
-0.3903501034,
-0.341960758,
-0.1443921924,
-0.9516569376,
-0.3406670094,
0.1264298707,
0.1400519907,
-0.1331679374,
0.1024285108,
-0.8217254877,
0.019103393,
0.6750311852,
-0.076250881,
0.3680567145,
-0.0750096515,
0.0710621327,
-0.7936757803,
0.1344272494,
0.2943307459,
-0.0119721415,
-0.5087579489,
-0.073941052,
-0.0832253024,
-0.2882400155,
-0.2870410085,
0.3984750211,
-0.3224162459,
0.2425185591,
-0.4837934673,
0.3148373067,
-0.2386609316,
-0.1076334119,
-0.1691389233,
0.576589942,
0.3106581271,
-0.1970272511,
0.4903539717,
0.109210223,
-0.4522921443,
0.8220287561,
-0.564940989,
-0.0365900956,
-0.1451714486,
0.5903922319,
-0.720035851,
-0.2503309846,
0.2266939729,
-0.1259611547,
0.2966614664,
0.4833868146,
-0.6691147089,
-0.5665581226,
-0.3955875635,
0.381479919,
0.1628265679,
0.0463215597,
0.01017523,
0.929792583,
-0.6589943767,
-0.2648872137,
-0.5392429233,
0.4644931257,
-0.334561497,
-0.5221336484,
0.1889857501,
-0.0540189445,
-0.6100521088,
-0.193463698,
-0.0321430303,
0.0342528671,
0.1666314006,
0.1094860211,
0.1703179628,
0.0259478651,
0.3751958609,
-0.0795164481,
0.0019044634,
0.4073562622,
0.1883928925,
0.4464626908,
0.0646032393,
-0.5569153428,
-0.4849722385,
0.7976217866,
0.6044996381,
0.0591091476,
0.6158371568,
0.475233674,
-0.6077209711,
-0.1100165322,
-0.6878364086,
-0.2739209235,
-0.2914902866,
0.5382121801,
0.0600893945,
-1.0419306755,
0.2851523459,
-0.0738597736,
-0.082856603,
0.3896791339,
0.8325433135,
-0.2144782245,
1.1665035486,
0.5320672989,
-0.1284130812,
0.3443439603,
-0.0734712481,
0.7596628666,
-0.9644359946,
-0.2140560895,
-0.3100242317,
-0.2009677738,
-0.6756477356,
-0.3000792563,
0.487046808,
-0.1723029017,
-0.3849599063,
-0.2654968202,
-0.3750216067,
-0.1610608399,
-0.1403517425,
0.3990553617,
0.5400167704,
-0.1462009698,
-0.0566440597,
-0.4930574298,
-0.4447173774,
-0.7418900728,
1.3229932785,
0.690094769,
1.2085038424,
0.1478063911,
0.4929672182,
0.3705002367,
0.6199344397,
-0.9601788521,
0.5086887479,
-0.0054951101,
-0.7820737958,
-0.3593611419,
-0.3619976044,
-0.9411482811,
0.2151079774,
-0.1794659346,
-1.0270129442,
-0.0146560157,
-0.2816386819,
-0.2895291448,
0.2166587561,
-0.4059928656,
0.4281715155,
-0.7158183455,
-0.2355146706,
-0.4115919769,
-0.4318843484,
0.8456324339,
-0.5829418898,
0.4540760815,
-0.2917923629,
-0.0539934821,
0.8792870045,
-0.2676295638,
0.7314261794,
0.2549079657,
-0.5735673904,
-0.0388776623,
-0.2099463344,
0.2101399153,
0.3144050539,
0.1231788099,
0.324513942,
0.3610991538,
-0.0666986108,
-0.4673772156,
0.732385397,
-0.6321148872,
-0.9868804216,
-0.7421363592,
-0.4282138348,
-0.3751722574,
0.2793959379,
0.0296408106,
0.1470710486,
-0.327267319,
0.1288928241,
0.5386762619,
-0.4595372379,
-0.2253729701,
0.6291587949,
-0.582023561,
-0.5753517151,
0.5038907528,
0.2160243839,
0.0397274122,
-0.0884147659,
0.0496630482,
-0.286862582,
-0.8088340759,
0.0240041781,
0.6873826981,
-0.4361886978,
0.2315624803,
-0.5391325951,
-0.5048704743,
-0.4115270674,
0.1010158882,
-0.3503095508,
0.1279624701,
-0.002971916,
0.0167578664,
0.2086921483,
1.0070728064,
0.1851245314,
0.2488216907,
-0.6485216022,
0.3851860166,
-0.0255203899,
0.5536025763,
0.0705559328,
-0.2139825821,
-0.2258485556,
0.0336027034,
-0.3148780465,
-1.0485533476,
0.3587658107,
-0.2525134981,
0.6259864569,
0.5958964825,
0.1230572909,
0.6559532285,
-0.4527774751,
0.6163908839,
0.448030293,
-0.5700965524,
0.4388643503,
-0.4217506945,
0.4525036812,
0.4976801574,
0.8426116109,
-1.0741240978,
-0.3714378476,
-0.3318810463,
-0.9952639937,
0.4603292942,
0.1860812604,
0.0390264653,
-0.1421710849,
0.1887129694,
-0.1523038149,
0.2348389924,
-0.6143933535,
-0.4092969,
0.5105497837,
-0.1577916592,
-0.3274162412,
-0.5484958887,
-0.5096453428,
-0.110877268,
0.606575191,
0.0418356061,
0.4598837495,
0.4374657571,
-0.0509187542,
-0.3746035695,
0.4859743416,
0.3129337132,
0.7251172662,
-0.3626124561,
0.0282343403,
0.1345391124,
-0.6637663245,
0.3956283927,
0.2622605264,
-0.2201054692,
-0.0179545172,
0.2889745831,
0.3761999607,
0.3680363894,
-1.0398547649,
0.4531061053,
-0.0709139407,
-0.161802873,
-0.4777632058,
-0.2681205869,
0.1931315064,
0.5663776994,
0.0545613728,
-0.4711977243,
0.2622421384,
-0.5482704043,
-0.115808934,
0.6616522074,
-0.2152786702,
-0.2310786545,
0.0825348645,
0.0400627032,
-0.5216510892,
0.4251706898,
0.027688263,
-0.1532314867,
0.1316909343,
0.5429856777,
0.6595259905,
-0.1281105876,
0.1491158456,
0.0746244267,
0.6544891,
-0.3922430873,
0.3729760349,
0.4155048132,
-0.4892891645,
-0.2578985691,
-0.3460355103,
-0.6142380834,
0.6458759904,
-0.3520075083,
0.2670565248,
-0.4568385482,
-0.8443452716,
-0.1696722955,
0.0643383265,
-0.528046906,
-0.1081517637,
0.6433366537,
0.8314413428,
-0.6315476298,
0.5999338031,
0.7283812761,
-0.0755611509,
-0.3113553822,
0.0718175322,
0.4335404634,
-0.2542712688,
0.0409025997,
0.1922721267,
-0.0253622178,
-0.3963387012,
-0.356256187,
-1.0252053738,
1.1050316095,
0.5558293462,
-0.7469536662,
-0.3530961275,
0.2659209371,
0.7122197151,
-0.4175633192,
0.4079586565,
0.5077818036,
0.5568615198,
-0.0622976311,
-1.0008083582,
0.026724197,
-0.2357541621,
0.2526393533,
-0.0581441782,
-0.6689959764,
0.5461243987,
-0.1407785714,
-0.5135493875,
0.0558798462,
0.1022633761,
0.5165061355,
0.2481108606,
0.1513789445,
0.5484188795,
0.7734801173,
0.1845238358,
0.9924914241,
-0.2748279274,
0.3584387004,
0.8644257188,
-0.9049528241,
0.84794873,
0.3487298489,
-0.432959348,
0.0911881849,
0.7157393098,
0.0815216079,
0.1726648062,
0.3483054936,
-0.2760446966,
-0.1769148111,
-0.2206967771,
-0.4209661484,
0.0802097544,
0.6819374561,
-0.4446749985,
-0.1134886444,
0.1185618117,
0.1486798227,
0.0110053178,
-0.1013069898,
0.5643737912,
0.7120109797,
-0.2679948211,
0.4640051723,
0.2645445466,
0.5794154406,
-0.7571587563,
0.1986755729,
-0.0078878496,
0.0911394656,
-0.2954782844,
-0.6185098886,
0.4129578471,
0.200431332,
0.0533658639,
-0.1804030091,
0.7223562598,
-0.0586959384,
-0.7283905745,
0.6913124919,
0.7163925767,
0.1446428448,
-0.1194361895,
-0.696760416,
0.152674377,
-0.4616574645,
-0.4733086526,
0.5160356164,
0.3219071925,
-0.2546203732,
0.6817620993,
0.6312275529,
0.6385961771,
-0.2498874217,
0.1556552052,
0.6637961268,
-0.9364784956,
-0.0323508047,
-0.7834569812,
0.0775657892,
0.0169024691,
-0.2836988568,
0.7861379385,
0.3749092817,
0.6117219925,
0.2217566371,
0.7192806005,
0.3197749555,
0.2894394398,
-0.2674364746,
0.8306829333,
-0.5870660543,
0.2254840285,
-0.2373986691,
-0.9439789653,
-0.4791587889,
0.5882602334,
-0.680727303,
0.0489168428,
0.968940556,
0.6681715846,
0.2746054232,
0.1246524304,
0.3998809457,
0.4938032031,
0.2901878059,
0.5532773137,
0.9310187101,
-0.0965769365,
-0.1697535366,
-0.1977181137,
-0.2737310529,
-0.225283891,
-0.570957005,
-0.9167925119,
-0.3714581132,
-0.1450686455,
-0.1642774791,
0.1342240423,
1.118388772,
0.4759361148,
-0.55425632,
-0.4042509794,
0.507568419,
0.2556930482,
-0.1316005439,
-0.138664037,
-0.0712171122,
0.1041684523,
-0.3610226512,
0.1549070626,
0.5930836201,
-0.1396037787,
-0.7186274529,
0.0974446908,
-0.1749003083,
-0.0311580859,
0.8530740142,
-0.0047727227,
-1.0375059843,
0.1950607747,
-0.0612563454,
-0.6263254285,
-0.1812912822,
0.8928557634,
-0.1024720669,
0.1641289443,
0.3700804114,
0.4893064797,
0.3757426143,
-0.4589211643,
0.5526357889,
0.4250088632,
-0.1249814406,
0.3810074627,
0.7747117877,
0.2703897059,
-0.3900694847,
0.1824318916,
0.1675220281,
-0.3730725944,
-0.7532654405,
0.0775957629,
-0.9878515005,
-0.1847326756,
1.3496892452,
-0.0171066895,
-0.2999466062,
-0.3249190152,
-0.4990782142,
0.0282229483,
-0.3515041769,
1.0281114578,
0.7801929116,
0.0534948036,
-0.1045149118,
-0.9957168698,
0.1457518488,
0.0516307428,
-0.7378236651,
0.0154954689,
0.5203099251,
0.1709403545,
-0.0978103876,
0.9061285853,
-0.5401067734,
0.1410756707,
-0.5217366815,
0.1745727062,
0.2664901912,
-0.0949991196,
-0.7240175605,
-0.1084241942,
0.3146748245,
0.7810686827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12317v1
|
ARKS: Active Retrieval in Knowledge Soup for Code Generation
| 2024-02-19T17:37:28 | 2024-02-19T17:37:28 |
Hongjin Su, Shuyang Jiang, Yuhang Lai, Haoyuan Wu, Boao Shi, Che Liu, Qian Liu, Tao Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently the retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) paradigm has raised much
attention for its potential in incorporating external knowledge into large
language models (LLMs) without further training. While widely explored in
natural language applications, its utilization in code generation remains
under-explored. In this paper, we introduce Active Retrieval in Knowledge Soup
(ARKS), an advanced strategy for generalizing large language models for code.
In contrast to relying on a single source, we construct a knowledge soup
integrating web search, documentation, execution feedback, and evolved code
snippets. We employ an active retrieval strategy that iteratively refines the
query and updates the knowledge soup. To assess the performance of ARKS, we
compile a new benchmark comprising realistic coding problems associated with
frequently updated libraries and long-tail programming languages. Experimental
results on ChatGPT and CodeLlama demonstrate a substantial improvement in the
average execution accuracy of ARKS on LLMs. The analysis confirms the
effectiveness of our proposed knowledge soup and active retrieval strategies,
offering rich insights into the construction of effective retrieval-augmented
code generation (RACG) pipelines. Our model, code, and data are available at
https://arks-codegen.github.io.
|
[
-0.0687265396,
-0.8135967255,
0.2589718699,
0.152169615,
-0.2505273819,
0.250558883,
-0.5085142851,
-0.4366686046,
0.113448292,
0.5704046488,
0.069337897,
-0.6625877023,
-0.2928993106,
0.1645157039,
-0.6222959757,
0.6247256994,
-0.1139610931,
-0.0501696356,
-0.0417796299,
-0.1095076278,
-0.1735083908,
-0.1400801837,
-0.3309707344,
0.1121306196,
0.4413332939,
0.4243549407,
0.5543360114,
0.9138895273,
0.5722749829,
0.2840313911,
-0.0909643024,
0.2421818972,
-0.4219228029,
0.8224872351,
-0.0939032137,
-0.5361280441,
-0.075959295,
-0.3270030916,
0.7317806482,
0.4486242235,
-0.408578068,
0.3450019658,
-0.1746556312,
0.6810571551,
-0.9362851381,
0.1525946558,
-0.8269424438,
0.1337471753,
-0.2162200212,
-0.3263966143,
-0.4578041732,
-0.4086551368,
-0.0282809436,
-0.2069108337,
0.3332690001,
0.3700739145,
0.373026669,
0.2089223415,
-0.3268615603,
-0.5656684637,
-0.635797143,
0.8325457573,
-0.6979540586,
0.4115312696,
0.3926677704,
0.3063718975,
-0.2215265632,
-1.0720216036,
-0.5557216406,
-0.3739301264,
0.2389690876,
-0.1025358737,
-0.363754034,
-0.1733769476,
0.3315848708,
0.8303309083,
-0.2654592991,
-0.2485862374,
-0.3406620622,
-0.1147556454,
0.4946700931,
-0.076269187,
0.4640088081,
-0.1783133894,
-0.4472665489,
-0.0554204397,
-1.0562883615,
-0.0877161324,
0.3176493049,
0.4787575006,
0.1275152862,
0.8084139228,
-0.0978733003,
0.9135639071,
-0.3208476603,
0.2159962654,
0.2361470461,
-0.1873406023,
0.1292965561,
-0.0666378289,
0.7420102954,
0.0053608925,
-0.0405659489,
-0.3628578484,
-0.69272995,
-0.0973843634,
0.6122936606,
-0.5820460916,
-0.1582210809,
0.0099183228,
-0.3237839043,
-0.477576226,
-0.0763059705,
-0.609873116,
-0.4826377034,
0.0930799395,
0.3266486824,
-0.4196223319,
-0.3737050295,
-0.0850211456,
-0.4261132777,
0.3100351691,
0.0366259404,
-0.4300933182,
0.1732203811,
0.4822244942,
0.9019307494,
-0.1893561631,
-0.0426328965,
-0.7821238041,
0.3400269151,
-0.543086946,
0.8586882949,
-0.6698608398,
-0.1667415202,
0.1717818528,
-0.3652437329,
0.1836370677,
-0.6946260333,
0.1225203052,
-0.9003252983,
-0.1931812316,
-0.0652097017,
-0.5155249834,
-0.0157968681,
0.3422580659,
-0.8418796062,
0.9722488523,
0.3383739889,
-0.711261034,
0.0339050591,
-0.6059163809,
-0.6573226452,
0.2489681393,
-0.3255082667,
-0.317591846,
0.0293757655,
-0.0565385707,
0.3497934043,
-0.4674032629,
-0.0211169142,
-0.2050457895,
-0.481167227,
0.0325433873,
-0.0495076217,
0.3026971221,
0.5581408143,
-0.401568234,
-0.0231634807,
-0.5030511618,
0.2060352266,
0.2508790195,
-0.7830632329,
-0.3173962831,
0.2544148266,
-0.3257770538,
-0.2607240975,
0.2353620231,
-0.4143306613,
0.5411159992,
-0.1233357936,
0.3590566516,
0.5031727552,
0.1427901536,
0.626978755,
-0.2080324441,
0.619215548,
-0.1998385489,
-0.0728074536,
-0.3935816586,
-0.4688806832,
-0.5643101335,
-0.1259345561,
0.3664666712,
0.4095229208,
-1.0186796188,
0.0537791103,
-0.1895273328,
-0.3690977991,
-0.5872375965,
0.5297297239,
0.5916212201,
0.2580308616,
0.4945930541,
-0.3203959167,
-0.6081662774,
-0.7012723684,
-0.5186055899,
-0.0826161578,
-0.1700285971,
0.3854907453,
0.1073786989,
-0.2820445001,
0.8412091732,
-0.5328500271,
0.0323253497,
-0.5956828594,
0.161906898,
0.1286051571,
0.3972199857,
0.3747331798,
-0.9232773185,
-0.4379570186,
-0.0230312273,
-0.552878499,
0.004514175,
0.4148564935,
0.0189798921,
0.0791999772,
0.4286016226,
-0.434460938,
0.2180687785,
0.6104933619,
-0.3003033996,
0.5530474186,
0.038681481,
0.1299590915,
-0.9283134937,
0.4027079344,
-0.2092514336,
-0.2012773603,
-0.396993041,
0.7506865263,
0.2987272739,
-0.2545167804,
-0.329002887,
0.6182880998,
-0.9294932485,
-0.2808959782,
-0.1007183492,
-0.0173391402,
-0.1404568553,
0.3208468854,
-0.0693220273,
1.0699523687,
0.6444331408,
-0.7292185426,
0.7470802069,
-0.0064672884,
-0.6873607635,
-0.2637199163,
-0.5090630054,
0.4081596732,
0.1324823499,
0.1421294063,
-0.5858505964,
0.0067970962,
0.1043438315,
-0.3552915454,
0.5306870937,
-0.6731961966,
-0.5598633289,
-0.3038874269,
-0.2154727876,
0.409807831,
0.7113571763,
-0.3874319494,
0.5785323977,
0.509811759,
-0.1219551191,
-0.7778578401,
-0.4486495554,
0.1350196898,
0.0996432751,
-0.4298315942,
0.0841528624,
0.0917991623,
-0.4897333384,
0.1330258101,
-0.4704557955,
-0.0238152742,
-0.0743691176,
-0.2791675627,
-0.0544030331,
-0.4611875117,
-0.0805176571,
-0.182390511,
0.05132626,
-0.1084161326,
-0.2159368247,
0.6728326082,
-0.1780385077,
-0.4677573144,
0.2145050466,
0.2129240781,
0.4715089798,
-0.6198937893,
0.5735109448,
0.379060477,
-0.1026447341,
-0.6102176309,
-0.7378308177,
-0.116770044,
-0.4621068537,
0.285938412,
-0.1507933587,
-0.549837172,
0.634221673,
-0.2807306349,
0.2538256645,
0.1841474026,
0.2474758029,
0.0705623999,
1.0399492979,
0.4862023294,
0.0117029632,
0.5968908072,
-0.6704303622,
0.1029539928,
-0.9571956396,
-0.2082035393,
-0.6584964395,
-0.2270231098,
-0.27133286,
-0.9338757992,
0.1377909184,
0.3642871082,
-0.096847944,
0.4291712344,
-0.4114427865,
0.4919958115,
0.5980825424,
0.1519562155,
0.3527275026,
-0.1369371414,
-0.2554247975,
0.4594227374,
-1.0066725016,
-0.2539096773,
1.1494027376,
0.0869951025,
0.9741292,
0.3128681779,
0.6343735456,
0.5660426021,
0.2759753764,
-0.7005477548,
0.5003713965,
0.0598372482,
-0.4455041587,
-0.2957457006,
-0.9312522411,
-1.0423173904,
0.063985005,
-0.1241594329,
-0.1417344511,
-0.1230613664,
0.258233875,
-0.2293278873,
0.4684305191,
-0.7986688614,
0.6330041885,
-0.2521923482,
-0.4780808687,
-0.3378990889,
-0.4333362281,
0.1725407243,
0.1909859926,
0.294153899,
0.1817951798,
-0.1419082582,
0.5328623056,
-0.2199708521,
0.4669564366,
-0.2270926982,
-0.203321889,
0.6010494828,
0.3550195992,
0.8811920881,
0.0311186537,
-0.3620983362,
-0.0450723097,
-0.3518410325,
-0.4903976917,
-0.6496136785,
0.7979460359,
-0.4641059041,
-0.6114805937,
-0.3122573197,
-0.46641168,
-0.1319438964,
0.5458779335,
-0.0551912487,
0.7223502994,
0.1408201754,
0.4986786246,
0.8809963465,
-0.4139835536,
0.2134713233,
0.7146012187,
-0.3123297095,
-0.2075119317,
0.8312042356,
-0.0397108756,
0.1776646376,
0.3125163019,
0.1275337785,
-0.0937720463,
-0.8453290462,
-0.6138875484,
0.0523916259,
-0.5198423862,
-0.7966495752,
-0.4474402964,
-0.177547127,
-0.5441043377,
0.0659655184,
-0.5467212796,
-0.3174464703,
0.1436692625,
0.0457299389,
0.5264922976,
1.0509849787,
0.1000031009,
-0.274641335,
-0.9961988926,
0.6500535607,
0.2476896048,
0.8137798905,
0.1554613858,
-0.2285657823,
-0.3754412234,
0.2713447511,
-0.248171702,
-1.0009797812,
0.237552762,
0.1529421806,
0.7808177471,
0.3778388202,
0.4771514535,
0.610137105,
-0.4945116639,
0.6543587446,
0.0176158156,
-0.6784674525,
0.6589666009,
-0.413418144,
0.377679497,
0.2942204773,
0.0790314451,
-0.4751444757,
-0.6737321019,
-0.4456019998,
-1.3242197037,
0.6496474147,
0.3276000321,
0.2416161299,
-0.4357632697,
0.4308747947,
-0.1340730488,
0.2564216852,
-0.3708778024,
-0.2699130774,
0.0392609574,
0.0200554598,
0.37960729,
-0.2671218216,
-0.143463403,
-0.0265543573,
0.6428836584,
-0.0628975481,
0.3889033198,
-0.032195434,
-0.2943142056,
-0.506973207,
0.1191738769,
0.094813861,
0.6633212566,
-0.1312510371,
0.3007289767,
0.0510353968,
-0.5185894966,
-0.3492050767,
-0.1366188824,
-0.0537823103,
-0.0472155213,
0.4498795569,
0.5204369426,
0.655523479,
-0.9725815654,
0.6458970904,
-0.0632298514,
0.3114622235,
-0.3342009187,
0.4817263484,
-0.0369940065,
0.3165978789,
0.914259553,
0.1208988503,
0.0721697807,
-0.893563509,
0.4205772579,
0.424726963,
-0.1377579421,
-0.054575339,
0.2929058671,
0.3519476652,
-0.4927788079,
0.9914922118,
-0.2668916285,
-0.5555019379,
0.5222548842,
0.7878918648,
0.6608942151,
-0.2309909463,
-0.1536109298,
0.3085027337,
-0.0551279411,
-0.3631423414,
0.3400714695,
-0.4794089794,
-0.6879411936,
-0.4403649271,
-0.7653946877,
-0.329915911,
-0.108089678,
-0.8281806707,
0.3997520804,
-0.2329942882,
0.0955238268,
-0.5639429688,
0.0936339572,
-0.55971843,
-0.2399549037,
0.000581783,
1.2721560001,
-0.400642097,
0.6861055493,
0.9946561456,
-0.4524802566,
-0.7404411435,
-0.0305529442,
-0.4120312333,
-0.9157401323,
0.1935830712,
-0.1542206258,
-0.0195691586,
0.2783151567,
-0.744987607,
-1.0319061279,
1.1792112589,
0.2715491951,
-0.4454316199,
-0.2267026454,
-0.3250392377,
0.4012026191,
-0.150182575,
0.1366775334,
0.160738036,
0.3846896887,
0.3153208494,
-0.7724760771,
-0.0715943724,
-0.5950912237,
-0.0603475757,
0.4338535964,
-0.433678925,
0.4299349189,
-0.5580266118,
-0.3004434109,
0.0784035549,
0.6167734861,
0.4857803285,
0.128065154,
0.3701388836,
0.5804519653,
0.4896200299,
0.106707871,
1.1962594986,
-0.6794301867,
0.2595662773,
0.761924386,
0.0094222659,
1.032723546,
0.419677496,
-0.1092518121,
0.5885087252,
0.0719355196,
-0.0257934909,
0.5594662428,
0.2971570194,
-0.2315297127,
-0.1867217571,
0.284288168,
-0.5079027414,
0.3017721772,
0.3552312255,
-0.4449793994,
-0.2275581211,
-0.1911509335,
-0.0333078839,
0.066472277,
-0.2659288347,
0.9122209549,
0.0695752501,
-0.7131698132,
0.5982611775,
0.0130737489,
0.5396059155,
-0.827611208,
-0.4833970368,
-0.2986884117,
0.1195928007,
-0.0921073854,
-0.8077316284,
0.1905412227,
0.3227356076,
-0.0599566177,
-0.3781032264,
0.584941864,
-0.4482736588,
-0.1815594137,
0.1750020981,
0.4105878472,
0.052817069,
-0.0845242068,
-0.5850048065,
0.1416206807,
0.0009004123,
-0.5180737376,
0.3983981013,
0.6287611127,
0.1684285402,
0.9586977363,
0.7613243461,
0.4301770031,
0.2008490562,
-0.067833446,
1.0302869081,
-0.7023147345,
-0.4030307531,
-0.3886555731,
0.1848763525,
0.1023271084,
0.0260987021,
0.919918716,
0.8954119682,
0.665371716,
-0.0192671232,
0.834592402,
-0.4802292287,
0.5846020579,
-0.4430137277,
0.835709095,
-0.3835372925,
0.7403967977,
-0.2341219634,
-1.166613698,
-0.2174280584,
0.7763699293,
-0.1035012379,
-0.0266956221,
0.4960139096,
0.7322208881,
-0.0934867412,
-0.1851468086,
-0.0077570616,
0.3438835442,
0.1370670348,
0.0834216103,
0.9027675986,
-0.298768729,
0.7605128884,
-0.3125497699,
-0.1634948254,
-0.1717996895,
-0.7775162458,
-0.4569989443,
-0.5820841789,
-0.0735168904,
-0.3680993617,
0.3580832779,
0.8599953651,
0.40364182,
-0.6255748272,
-0.1881979406,
-0.112432532,
0.3585892618,
-0.3474075794,
-0.1963291168,
0.1940903515,
-0.7568652034,
-0.518104732,
0.6325601935,
0.0087129092,
-0.1963927746,
-0.2408335507,
-0.1475647837,
-0.1808479279,
-0.1799520403,
0.439666748,
0.4159463942,
-0.3195288479,
-0.0686169565,
0.2752870023,
-0.02820131,
-0.1267521083,
1.1543967724,
-0.9667025208,
0.4576147497,
0.5464375615,
0.4390130937,
0.3783224821,
0.1152412221,
0.8921803236,
-0.8324071169,
-0.0555699281,
0.6707669497,
0.3205771148,
0.3210713863,
-0.1722535938,
0.5076349378,
0.0376418605,
-0.4333058,
-1.1436434984,
0.247618705,
-0.536415875,
-0.3693569601,
1.7052571774,
-0.1842342615,
-0.3330847621,
-0.2686275542,
0.1093431115,
0.4193597436,
-0.4748713076,
1.0228173733,
0.117209211,
0.0811427459,
-0.1845648289,
-0.4054961801,
0.5776355267,
-0.0910528451,
-0.309395045,
0.3734032214,
0.5383873582,
0.3532367945,
0.1817892194,
0.4227781296,
-0.2553999424,
0.3862576187,
0.0484235585,
0.4003367722,
-0.3115718365,
-0.3440439701,
0.0671538413,
0.2465132475,
0.3010707498,
0.0927480385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12309v1
|
TILP: Differentiable Learning of Temporal Logical Rules on Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-02-19T17:30:44 | 2024-02-19T17:30:44 |
Siheng Xiong, Yuan Yang, Faramarz Fekri, James Clayton Kerce
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compared with static knowledge graphs, temporal knowledge graphs (tKG), which
can capture the evolution and change of information over time, are more
realistic and general. However, due to the complexity that the notion of time
introduces to the learning of the rules, an accurate graph reasoning, e.g.,
predicting new links between entities, is still a difficult problem. In this
paper, we propose TILP, a differentiable framework for temporal logical rules
learning. By designing a constrained random walk mechanism and the introduction
of temporal operators, we ensure the efficiency of our model. We present
temporal features modeling in tKG, e.g., recurrence, temporal order, interval
between pair of relations, and duration, and incorporate it into our learning
process. We compare TILP with state-of-the-art methods on two benchmark
datasets. We show that our proposed framework can improve upon the performance
of baseline methods while providing interpretable results. In particular, we
consider various scenarios in which training samples are limited, data is
biased, and the time range between training and inference are different. In all
these cases, TILP works much better than the state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
0.1345874518,
-0.6975089312,
0.7780687809,
-0.0200407933,
-0.3815330863,
-0.0090633295,
-0.049742125,
-0.6056253314,
-0.0143335462,
0.0907322094,
-0.8499733806,
-0.7478652,
-0.5363985896,
-0.0403000712,
-0.0293600094,
0.4860675931,
-0.0835632011,
-0.1500045359,
0.1711288393,
-0.2753155231,
-0.4873961806,
0.1043031141,
-0.7253767848,
-0.7676672339,
0.5074238777,
0.1010613516,
0.4862544537,
0.9717929959,
-0.066471532,
0.2365187407,
0.0851976275,
0.2119365782,
-0.1681385338,
0.032163728,
-0.3850514591,
-0.4911125302,
-0.4100383818,
0.1912338436,
0.4187538028,
0.9080218673,
-0.3669599593,
0.1211898774,
-0.3600969613,
0.676325202,
-0.3574746549,
0.8151125312,
-0.294098556,
0.7431551814,
-0.2252253741,
-0.640479207,
-0.4084153473,
-0.8187138438,
0.1916774064,
-0.9981133938,
-0.0240370817,
0.1888479441,
0.8447062373,
0.3443057835,
-0.5583778024,
0.0475636423,
-0.560380578,
0.6669737697,
-0.6644340158,
0.9516048431,
0.1103116795,
0.8639402986,
-0.1039106175,
-1.0551053286,
-0.4538138807,
-0.210529983,
0.0804536492,
-0.1853560209,
0.0243254323,
-0.2248819619,
0.5758752227,
-0.0777909756,
-0.232600823,
-0.0138984844,
-0.1145976856,
0.1053731069,
0.3634825349,
0.1895062029,
0.1128218323,
-0.2165771872,
-0.4293901622,
-0.0481501557,
-0.5478520393,
0.0586034395,
0.1743974686,
0.3417391181,
-0.2201561779,
0.4914924502,
-0.4713540971,
0.6894509792,
0.1847797483,
-0.5939511061,
0.4047825933,
0.1700065881,
-0.24887757,
-0.1442793012,
0.1923016012,
0.4484764636,
0.5464203954,
-0.5180203915,
-0.0799905583,
-0.0054361201,
-0.1758711487,
-0.6463425159,
-0.2144741714,
0.0693200454,
-0.610255897,
-0.3846558928,
-0.3529317081,
-0.4734682143,
-0.1381239295,
-0.7451847792,
0.0994287133,
-0.927256763,
-0.2611387074,
0.2370095402,
-0.305441618,
0.1286721081,
0.6758956313,
-0.4300680459,
0.3034161925,
0.6335014701,
0.6369040608,
0.15357925,
-0.3516663909,
-0.7214204669,
0.3211784959,
-0.4388405383,
0.5571075082,
-0.9112952948,
-0.0684256852,
-0.1665098369,
-0.3672176898,
-0.2968888283,
-0.2175231576,
0.2558784783,
-0.903388679,
0.4642795026,
-0.3863599598,
-0.7133916616,
-0.3170870841,
0.2674790919,
-0.3616752326,
0.6068233848,
0.3563845158,
-1.0092710257,
1.0584995747,
-0.5862793922,
-0.5054859519,
0.0475789085,
-0.1963787526,
-0.1344326586,
-0.3356305063,
0.1804580688,
0.397939235,
-0.1662847847,
0.2974798083,
-0.789090097,
0.2382604033,
0.0272504147,
-0.0438753851,
1.0312350988,
0.6223558784,
0.0026034312,
-0.1066065207,
-0.9290795326,
0.3102329373,
0.1833046526,
-0.4763230085,
-0.0986359715,
0.4863389432,
-0.2296872437,
0.4446840584,
-0.1368442178,
-0.5581461191,
0.4320554733,
0.046285525,
0.6127414107,
0.7662087679,
0.3990752101,
0.2207198143,
-0.6270284653,
0.272479713,
0.0499397367,
0.218803525,
0.4678364396,
-0.2424145341,
-0.1847347915,
-0.1439365149,
0.4266979098,
0.5839734674,
-0.78288275,
0.154771775,
-0.3715275228,
-0.181189701,
0.2864832282,
-0.126258418,
0.154006958,
0.9288783669,
0.4223122895,
-0.3515149057,
-0.5181317925,
-0.1881377101,
-0.2361447513,
-0.465905726,
-0.2551913261,
0.4423413873,
0.0539739095,
-0.280194968,
1.0134706497,
-0.6217836142,
-0.0932125673,
-0.2373656332,
0.1498361528,
0.0384793133,
0.1890794337,
0.6240078807,
-0.7722297907,
-0.1717128903,
-0.2229835242,
-0.9054617882,
-0.2998283207,
-0.0706755668,
0.2005510181,
0.025147099,
0.712217629,
-0.5962950587,
0.3778199255,
-0.1729772389,
-0.3954887986,
0.4298489094,
-0.063557297,
0.2140820622,
-0.7838537097,
-0.2153472304,
0.1120927334,
-0.5317915678,
-0.3063186705,
-0.1376752257,
-0.1263939887,
-0.1934206635,
-0.4142686427,
0.4855055511,
-0.0325209722,
0.0470792614,
0.2859397233,
0.1529018134,
-0.2522188127,
0.7000771761,
0.2611423135,
-0.1280883402,
0.3007189035,
-0.8240065575,
0.2507205009,
0.1964726001,
-0.3931032419,
0.5975567698,
-0.3828943968,
-0.0752490833,
-0.0545323752,
0.2363278866,
-0.3599150777,
-0.2171815336,
0.3409908414,
-0.3895412683,
0.6744375229,
-0.6469251513,
-0.5617813468,
-0.154277578,
0.0481963344,
0.105251886,
0.5758028626,
-0.5249053836,
0.9103483558,
0.1078833193,
0.3537635207,
-0.4686121345,
-0.4563099742,
-0.304735899,
-0.3514137566,
-0.7248245478,
0.2307553291,
0.27782619,
-0.484982729,
0.2414921969,
-0.6868397593,
-0.0166470595,
0.0785413757,
0.1683570892,
-0.1786940396,
-0.1433819085,
0.4570917785,
-0.1022080183,
-0.3648715615,
0.0155894253,
-0.9149761796,
0.4443015456,
-0.0365369581,
-0.4101136625,
-0.4015371501,
-0.1504791081,
0.2382512242,
-0.0255637988,
0.456728071,
0.5441253781,
-0.4427835941,
-0.5863044262,
-0.2527357936,
0.0145442318,
-0.4625311196,
0.0602785274,
-0.4621957839,
-0.524105072,
0.1928903311,
-0.3809371293,
0.2186005563,
0.5008163452,
0.0619153865,
-0.2685256004,
0.4606091082,
0.9148055911,
0.1582419723,
0.7486489415,
-0.0524753369,
-0.1574530751,
-0.2702670991,
-0.5485469103,
-0.193081215,
-0.2218403071,
-0.7614374161,
-0.344447881,
0.1952581108,
0.4403195381,
-0.6943212152,
0.2272674441,
0.0294879787,
0.2532995343,
0.3495078385,
0.4313190877,
0.381099999,
0.0126459338,
-0.6095010638,
-0.0425669104,
-1.0785444975,
-0.2372032255,
0.9873998761,
0.2969936728,
0.8490809202,
0.018770203,
0.7632519007,
0.6877867579,
0.0333382748,
-0.2225658447,
0.6094397902,
0.0104330853,
-0.2209001631,
-0.3028853834,
-0.750451386,
-0.6229020357,
-0.3044793308,
-0.224248752,
-0.9834231138,
0.3804449439,
0.2864561677,
0.1015070155,
0.8183190227,
-0.8281246424,
0.450083375,
-0.2089552581,
-0.2782454491,
-0.262383014,
-0.8139076829,
0.089175947,
0.182666555,
-0.0338927172,
-0.4228732884,
0.0860963985,
0.7029905915,
-0.5486229062,
0.916490376,
-0.4767291546,
0.4181264043,
0.235967651,
0.4043851495,
0.4608279765,
0.3060364723,
0.1222782955,
0.0297104474,
0.1626010984,
-0.475084722,
-0.5663508177,
0.2685052752,
-0.7072700262,
-0.4712528586,
-0.3683034778,
-0.5550191402,
-0.4855636358,
0.4032698274,
-0.0116394069,
0.4978396297,
0.098151952,
-0.0453149639,
0.6834305525,
-0.0854297802,
0.4836246371,
0.5082466602,
-0.2739796638,
-0.0579983927,
0.6502304673,
0.1912513822,
0.3382298648,
1.0563479662,
0.3833006024,
-0.4003929198,
-0.4120177925,
0.155073151,
0.1855113655,
-0.9294887185,
-0.0437043011,
-0.6078509092,
-0.1164499298,
-0.4194267988,
0.0185251832,
-0.1241486967,
-1.1970229149,
0.0043924907,
-0.1996374428,
0.6117340922,
0.4109376073,
-0.4711306691,
-0.2581731379,
-0.3994215131,
0.5211345553,
0.5773082972,
0.6082300544,
-0.0315297581,
-0.1667491943,
0.3039364815,
-0.213172853,
-0.1893160641,
-0.720662415,
0.0448404811,
0.1952955723,
0.6245616674,
0.7140862942,
0.2201313227,
0.502835989,
-0.6713926196,
0.1384851038,
0.043387115,
-0.7045092583,
0.4215258658,
-0.4402188063,
0.0126934526,
0.136815697,
0.4736974239,
-0.7944321632,
0.1655987799,
-0.9051832557,
-0.407065928,
0.561752677,
0.1754796505,
-0.6815310121,
0.073104687,
0.4042488039,
0.0495877229,
0.3594099879,
-0.5338590741,
-0.0504197665,
-0.3822358251,
0.0686278194,
0.2592974603,
0.0070735118,
-0.220172137,
0.0946179256,
0.3718117177,
-0.0108805215,
0.4142398238,
0.0949225947,
-0.1782306433,
-0.1282387227,
0.4748068452,
-0.0013120818,
1.07533741,
-0.5990847349,
-0.0180790778,
0.3471050858,
-0.1241060048,
-0.0704468265,
0.3089561462,
-0.1103551984,
-0.2339543253,
0.7953925729,
0.3317521513,
-0.0169233233,
-0.2845849395,
0.1021282598,
0.2179782093,
-0.1556368172,
-0.0800448358,
0.343029201,
0.0005056294,
0.7625671625,
0.1362190694,
0.1892663985,
-0.3273074627,
-0.4292158186,
0.4230579436,
-0.226095885,
-0.3740621507,
-0.1558278501,
0.7758191228,
-0.0306312218,
-0.5225507617,
0.7032122016,
-0.4008955061,
-0.4341300428,
0.4871102273,
0.2400393188,
0.7304040194,
0.1686048508,
0.2361064404,
0.1564026326,
0.3420488238,
0.1826506257,
0.3552421629,
-0.4757573009,
-0.7524574399,
-0.3712783754,
-0.4469831884,
-0.285618186,
-0.1240867376,
-0.4077544808,
0.1203714162,
-0.8068132997,
-0.0741073266,
0.0241424814,
0.3493084013,
-0.9685356021,
0.3232623637,
-0.1874546856,
1.4100706577,
-0.9269829392,
0.8949891925,
0.3342294395,
-0.5054901838,
-0.7904366255,
-0.1254681051,
0.2395894378,
-0.8155484796,
0.8433521986,
-0.193404302,
-0.0944740698,
-0.2813800275,
-0.5472960472,
-0.4407715499,
1.2893259525,
0.1992664635,
-0.5588236451,
-0.3703480363,
0.0070952573,
0.4942743778,
-0.4531813562,
-0.1241696998,
0.4067007005,
0.3649605811,
-0.0126151051,
-0.4470531344,
0.1687836051,
-0.0963072181,
-0.1618440747,
0.202306807,
-0.6487907767,
0.6914161444,
-0.5523545146,
-0.4336829782,
-0.4101197422,
0.5783032775,
0.3755727112,
0.6805490255,
0.6732382178,
0.8589220047,
0.9038595557,
-0.14917925,
1.1100863218,
-0.0354763418,
0.1818729937,
1.3398737907,
-0.2586139143,
0.3892586529,
0.2995251417,
-0.381950438,
0.6874062419,
0.803073287,
0.0829828903,
0.7177451849,
0.0896971524,
0.0313008353,
-0.6530050039,
0.1876979619,
-0.4335590303,
-0.2155637443,
0.2709542811,
-0.067788139,
-0.6916174293,
-0.2923634052,
-0.0212290678,
0.0400731154,
-0.207179442,
0.3800073266,
0.1553056985,
-0.0663735121,
0.0619817115,
0.2455222756,
-0.0437312946,
-0.7703210711,
-0.2669677734,
-0.1744336486,
0.1487275958,
-0.2491993755,
-0.6459215283,
-0.0043596118,
-0.2785021365,
-0.2304490358,
-0.3602084517,
0.4978606701,
0.0104963584,
-0.1228324324,
0.3431702256,
0.4706279337,
-0.1404425353,
0.6397069097,
-0.8050997853,
-0.5397872329,
0.0502794646,
-0.08438541,
0.0879229605,
1.0742710829,
-0.3958374858,
1.2441679239,
0.5552233458,
0.0791580901,
0.2515763044,
0.0613962747,
0.8111843467,
-0.6058605909,
-0.5160535574,
-0.3046196103,
0.1185937673,
-0.014533787,
-0.2655797899,
0.5283619165,
0.1899779439,
1.1644586325,
0.2592745423,
0.4471324682,
-0.5253313184,
0.7276949883,
-1.0826432705,
0.3600259125,
-0.3161222041,
0.7609499097,
-0.1383482516,
-0.6606687307,
-0.1136932448,
0.2783578336,
-0.6328437924,
0.2746719122,
0.8343812823,
0.2874226272,
-0.4026627839,
0.1228199676,
-0.0243515056,
0.1372320205,
0.499394685,
0.8198376894,
0.6450871229,
-0.0127603877,
0.4511054754,
-0.5123013854,
-0.0460340716,
0.1277070194,
-1.3415910006,
-0.8760756254,
-0.507799089,
-0.4184819162,
-0.3907271028,
0.2879729271,
1.2215034962,
0.8167594075,
-0.5357574821,
0.0164974835,
-0.1728297025,
0.5807639956,
-0.5488373637,
-0.2128604949,
0.5675832033,
-0.443721652,
-0.1287067682,
0.2514820993,
0.0543123707,
0.0277137961,
0.4723199308,
-0.1955861449,
-0.3474751711,
-0.2300133705,
0.3870069981,
0.6895672679,
-0.2150989473,
-0.6788293719,
-0.2838407755,
0.3551030159,
0.1212664396,
1.0015621185,
-0.7450041175,
0.5566612482,
0.6211392283,
0.3745349944,
1.0360320807,
-0.2842702568,
0.458352983,
-0.8695569634,
0.1063841134,
0.2265919447,
0.4802345037,
0.036568258,
0.0241080206,
0.7804562449,
0.744081676,
-0.2401686609,
-0.407969743,
0.5150406957,
-0.9950472713,
-0.4254674315,
1.0105928183,
-0.1688975394,
-0.1394168586,
-0.2727051675,
0.5834684968,
0.514288187,
-0.3638765514,
0.8682085872,
0.2718764842,
-0.3739334643,
0.0085167997,
-0.5225113034,
0.6017594934,
-0.2934407592,
-0.7139021158,
-0.1983961761,
0.5372408032,
0.903529346,
-0.0638035312,
0.5241235495,
-0.2422181368,
0.3422741592,
0.2809946835,
-0.4807355404,
-0.5563201904,
-0.6470078826,
0.2875382602,
0.2634701729,
-0.0189323556,
-0.0708630309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12298v1
|
Is Open-Source There Yet? A Comparative Study on Commercial and Open-Source LLMs in Their Ability to Label Chest X-Ray Reports
| 2024-02-19T17:23:10 | 2024-02-19T17:23:10 |
Felix J. Dorfner, Liv Jürgensen, Leonhard Donle, Fares Al Mohamad, Tobias R. Bodenmann, Mason C. Cleveland, Felix Busch, Lisa C. Adams, James Sato, Thomas Schultz, Albert E. Kim, Jameson Merkow, Keno K. Bressem, Christopher P. Bridge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Introduction: With the rapid advances in large language models (LLMs), there
have been numerous new open source as well as commercial models. While recent
publications have explored GPT-4 in its application to extracting information
of interest from radiology reports, there has not been a real-world comparison
of GPT-4 to different leading open-source models.
Materials and Methods: Two different and independent datasets were used. The
first dataset consists of 540 chest x-ray reports that were created at the
Massachusetts General Hospital between July 2019 and July 2021. The second
dataset consists of 500 chest x-ray reports from the ImaGenome dataset. We then
compared the commercial models GPT-3.5 Turbo and GPT-4 from OpenAI to the
open-source models Mistral-7B, Mixtral-8x7B, Llama2-13B, Llama2-70B,
QWEN1.5-72B and CheXbert and CheXpert-labeler in their ability to accurately
label the presence of multiple findings in x-ray text reports using different
prompting techniques.
Results: On the ImaGenome dataset, the best performing open-source model was
Llama2-70B with micro F1-scores of 0.972 and 0.970 for zero- and few-shot
prompts, respectively. GPT-4 achieved micro F1-scores of 0.975 and 0.984,
respectively. On the institutional dataset, the best performing open-source
model was QWEN1.5-72B with micro F1-scores of 0.952 and 0.965 for zero- and
few-shot prompting, respectively. GPT-4 achieved micro F1-scores of 0.975 and
0.973, respectively.
Conclusion: In this paper, we show that while GPT-4 is superior to
open-source models in zero-shot report labeling, the implementation of few-shot
prompting can bring open-source models on par with GPT-4. This shows that
open-source models could be a performant and privacy preserving alternative to
GPT-4 for the task of radiology report classification.
|
[
-0.0359481312,
-0.2073506564,
0.9663215876,
-0.1527880728,
-0.3340914249,
-0.2832713723,
-0.0378818735,
-0.8357364535,
-0.1118042693,
0.3632722795,
-0.1715633571,
-0.8400912881,
-0.7719964385,
0.1672958881,
-0.295267731,
1.021690011,
-0.2158792764,
0.207997337,
0.0195729788,
-0.2454097271,
-0.2354685217,
-0.4298492372,
-0.5203952789,
-0.3091736436,
0.5256028771,
0.0319610201,
0.8695992827,
0.6947110891,
0.7930673361,
0.2361858785,
-0.0563563034,
-0.4192616343,
-0.2454098463,
-0.2115438879,
-0.1621622741,
-0.4421830475,
-0.5149810314,
0.3632307351,
0.5560411811,
0.0857143328,
0.1603050381,
0.0610201657,
-0.2221554816,
0.5560320616,
-0.5057660341,
0.265458256,
-0.1005063504,
0.1323209405,
-0.2629257143,
-0.1503462344,
-0.4331740737,
-0.5875965357,
0.3782323301,
-0.613740027,
0.0754881799,
-0.0242192727,
0.9844797254,
0.0523745865,
-0.1519266516,
-0.6795799136,
-0.6051369309,
0.6771427393,
-0.7850024104,
0.4778399467,
0.2769129276,
0.4504169822,
0.5332070589,
-1.0223374367,
-0.0026876489,
-0.4257748425,
-0.0969818234,
0.3971922398,
-0.7929619551,
-0.0081266444,
0.0443030186,
0.5709242225,
-0.7995422482,
0.3738165498,
-0.6003130674,
-0.152026698,
0.2680402398,
0.0684498549,
0.1051320881,
-0.140405193,
-0.7776218057,
0.0363371037,
-0.9475795031,
-0.3995455205,
-0.1259784251,
0.1347772926,
-0.1620032936,
0.7037228942,
-0.2921292782,
0.5901655555,
-0.2184784114,
-0.2908321023,
0.4474194646,
-0.4307853878,
-0.4740153551,
0.3877325356,
0.9028378725,
0.266538322,
-0.0078010117,
-0.0111085977,
-0.146462366,
0.1328402907,
-0.138881579,
-0.6792129874,
-0.2395780385,
0.2099280059,
-0.6922125816,
-0.6388083696,
0.0691799447,
-0.3480062485,
-0.4149048924,
-0.0125379162,
0.6630313993,
-0.3159986138,
-0.129570514,
-0.0036248732,
-0.0255938154,
0.1812766045,
0.4249024689,
-0.2655145824,
0.1791518033,
0.4826980531,
1.3582854271,
0.0670754686,
-0.0102114873,
-0.556532681,
0.1067811623,
-0.3969682455,
1.0219094753,
-0.4506976604,
-0.4753345847,
-0.1558041275,
-0.0478436127,
0.1023969129,
-0.6756299138,
0.4708913267,
-0.4776874185,
0.3036983013,
-0.2930071056,
-0.4164736271,
-0.1029294133,
0.3535427451,
-0.8345861435,
0.6305021048,
0.4346749783,
-0.6895292997,
0.2818479836,
-0.4680741727,
0.1693341583,
0.1558003128,
-0.4904973805,
-0.5141028762,
0.019486133,
0.2215464264,
0.2784610391,
-0.5687345266,
0.0228631087,
-0.0835919529,
-0.1997000277,
0.432941258,
-0.2924664021,
0.7727159262,
0.3288790286,
-0.3755828738,
0.0938693509,
-0.6161487699,
0.1192179471,
0.1446572244,
-0.3351791501,
-0.2214893699,
-0.3952407837,
-0.4555710554,
0.4879050255,
-0.2050255686,
-0.902171731,
0.0188154299,
-0.1157664657,
0.1370524913,
0.6703903675,
-0.0276466906,
0.0008564823,
-0.6085327268,
0.9487962127,
0.053639546,
0.1506697237,
-0.2670238614,
-0.8337826133,
-0.1783205271,
-0.5838148594,
0.3758559525,
0.5682224035,
-0.4543955922,
-0.1629975736,
-0.0470469892,
-0.5693775415,
-0.7961151004,
-0.2174082994,
0.7046085,
0.7613928914,
0.2877500951,
-0.2835218906,
-0.3086830974,
-0.9125902057,
-0.2102280259,
-0.1142627001,
-0.1709958166,
0.3646689057,
0.1039716527,
0.0436736383,
0.6070796847,
-0.843724668,
-0.6538501978,
-0.0108461594,
0.2235295027,
0.2795213461,
-0.0213330165,
0.5723275542,
-0.218629539,
-0.6837812662,
0.1894494593,
-1.0809161663,
-0.2742084563,
0.3894149661,
0.1635037512,
0.424754113,
0.4872370064,
-0.3911765814,
0.62923944,
0.7447350025,
-0.0693935826,
0.5027074218,
-0.1787534654,
0.308676362,
-0.7382829189,
0.0665680617,
0.3020943999,
-0.287117064,
-0.6880388856,
-0.0873317942,
0.1982368231,
-0.3242935538,
-0.8760563135,
0.5951770544,
-0.7202728391,
-0.077991657,
-0.2401193082,
0.0595424026,
-0.0182062481,
0.017926462,
0.3153678775,
0.5175358653,
0.5650174022,
-0.227130726,
0.1296713054,
0.2292456776,
-0.6219930053,
0.3969920576,
-0.8172811866,
0.1742754281,
0.0151151009,
0.3617891371,
-0.9269422889,
-0.03148745,
0.5286573172,
-0.3345672488,
0.2209967971,
-0.2321814895,
-0.3963837028,
-0.5267632604,
-0.480399698,
0.3565543294,
0.6915785074,
-0.483428508,
0.1111477017,
-0.0481164418,
-0.3867414892,
-0.3246924579,
-0.9063593149,
-0.1766265333,
0.1913223863,
-0.5976158977,
0.1909201443,
-0.1866970211,
-0.2436712235,
0.3790279925,
-0.1969739497,
-0.2092988491,
-0.4477935135,
0.2420286685,
0.4239875078,
-0.4610877335,
-0.1097739488,
-0.3191072941,
-0.4367691576,
-0.0318996124,
-0.3553821743,
0.0378722623,
-0.3863498271,
-0.3891701102,
-0.5045335293,
0.2307584137,
0.2099873573,
-0.1102046669,
0.4732313454,
0.5035784245,
-0.2481921762,
0.2861714661,
-0.4441919029,
0.1043977663,
-0.420684427,
0.0898136571,
-0.2024794668,
-1.0494027138,
0.200495556,
0.1401569545,
-0.0978903845,
0.4130288064,
0.7733251452,
0.0801024586,
0.8071533442,
0.4071819484,
0.1007293984,
0.0804271698,
-0.1283012629,
0.2894067764,
-0.6456491351,
-0.1645156443,
-0.6605667472,
-0.0393496044,
-0.5983624458,
-0.3981139362,
0.8068289161,
-0.3790341318,
0.0268319771,
-0.271009028,
-0.8105005026,
0.6413049102,
0.3149630129,
0.2350671887,
0.6974751949,
0.0549464338,
0.2891577184,
-0.0005102073,
-0.6604118943,
-0.4299748838,
1.2821314335,
0.3884212971,
0.7310963869,
0.2329898477,
0.8469181061,
0.1178197488,
0.6498981714,
-0.7431207299,
0.3311484456,
-0.3388909101,
-0.8519287705,
-0.0836083591,
-0.2162984312,
-1.1342960596,
0.2679452896,
0.0690592751,
-0.5980473757,
0.1521837562,
0.0366460904,
-0.5064198375,
0.3917252123,
-0.6421465874,
0.5457426906,
-0.2457822412,
-0.2150608152,
0.3040377796,
-0.5871338248,
0.7383547425,
-0.3368323445,
0.4559993446,
-0.3105961084,
-0.2616632283,
0.6310222149,
-0.631552875,
0.879268527,
-0.1939132959,
-0.375385195,
0.5541231036,
-0.0453711413,
0.2853666544,
-0.1395642757,
-0.1074553952,
0.4469448626,
0.0993249193,
-0.0979915261,
-0.2692407966,
0.9976067543,
-0.9672526121,
-0.47613433,
-0.88921839,
-0.3394984603,
0.1631793529,
0.4443634748,
0.6435420513,
0.8626095057,
-0.0877612233,
0.0256078038,
0.6412485838,
-0.4425731897,
0.1630872935,
0.8290093541,
-0.1519994289,
-0.6973688006,
0.8056352735,
0.572122097,
0.3556710482,
0.4039629996,
0.691155076,
-0.2311428785,
-0.5392064452,
-0.2198812515,
0.5628269911,
-0.8724273443,
-0.4442987144,
-0.5151670575,
-0.2969727814,
-0.3862277567,
-0.3095070422,
-0.2453887463,
-0.3716365695,
-0.1078137159,
-0.1678549349,
0.3869146407,
1.2062023878,
-0.2211097777,
0.1162247732,
-0.9450051188,
0.1890127659,
0.0848896578,
0.6114993691,
-0.1420740485,
-0.3914651275,
-0.2701374888,
-0.3424272239,
-0.2712829113,
-1.0716561079,
0.3140640855,
-0.2008560449,
0.5100982189,
0.1849404573,
0.0494915284,
0.1850290895,
-0.2574563026,
0.9193036556,
0.3062393963,
-0.8489674926,
0.6590726376,
-0.5561747551,
0.6668962836,
0.2407733351,
0.8548766971,
-0.204299897,
-0.3910830021,
-0.6822650433,
-0.7498809695,
1.0450373888,
0.2009382695,
-0.5236249566,
-0.154286027,
0.1416557878,
0.3776804209,
0.1459227949,
-0.866691947,
-0.0235386528,
-0.2099912018,
-0.0758012012,
-0.1042852625,
-0.2885119319,
-0.2591350675,
-0.0066816127,
0.6202403307,
0.0237349849,
0.5915024281,
0.4631893337,
-0.0117333215,
-0.1230141968,
0.3730472624,
0.6204658747,
0.7548300028,
-0.5010020733,
0.2463511676,
-0.2888008356,
-0.3836269677,
0.3775129914,
0.0855203271,
-0.1720366925,
0.2193768919,
0.3671967983,
0.6682782173,
0.2265559137,
-0.2858217657,
0.656740427,
-0.0326351486,
-0.806922853,
-0.204324767,
-0.192225799,
0.0749332607,
0.3062555194,
-0.0939290076,
-0.1660414189,
0.0870288685,
-0.4205786586,
0.004713702,
0.0984183252,
-0.5874571204,
-0.3177142143,
0.8455594778,
-0.0758299008,
0.0550909936,
0.7125308514,
0.0265792105,
0.1720857173,
0.4448834956,
0.5838823915,
0.8785945773,
-0.4444710314,
0.4294861853,
0.4641484618,
0.4188476205,
-0.0594867989,
0.3160654604,
0.2169301957,
-0.3673422337,
-0.2681742013,
-0.0844041035,
-0.6020427346,
0.3723755479,
-0.7666612864,
0.2222063243,
-0.6609176993,
-0.186018154,
0.1681744605,
-0.239522472,
-0.6401938796,
0.298419416,
0.277598381,
0.9792279601,
-0.7970863581,
0.8280712366,
0.6616348624,
-0.6820844412,
-0.813677609,
-0.3120536804,
0.5537227392,
-0.8034959435,
0.5154893994,
0.2149102539,
0.0279830191,
-0.0527319871,
-0.4563898742,
-1.0964006186,
1.4226924181,
0.2140654922,
-0.4470161796,
0.0627511218,
0.1128572971,
0.4112799764,
-0.1530926675,
0.4874224365,
0.510094285,
0.4887441695,
0.1904725283,
-0.9900689125,
0.2645899057,
-0.0826996565,
-0.2569310069,
0.2979288101,
-0.7791137099,
0.837973237,
-0.1749900281,
-0.1685709357,
0.2157779336,
0.2838945091,
0.5018885732,
0.6826462746,
0.1004470289,
0.58259058,
0.7200247049,
-0.0882336795,
1.4312804937,
0.0505302288,
0.1452504247,
0.9722189307,
-0.5187684298,
0.6882497072,
-0.0270985793,
-0.0943532884,
0.4561946094,
0.4286190867,
-0.1136295944,
0.5244784355,
-0.0376143381,
-0.2994170189,
0.2679121196,
0.0104048569,
-0.6537094712,
0.1713607311,
0.1273819953,
-0.5302198529,
-0.3616571426,
0.0232166927,
0.3325588703,
-0.4676815867,
-0.2935977578,
0.8402645588,
0.2366125286,
-0.4763860106,
0.7967343926,
-0.1109614894,
0.4084389508,
-0.9603138566,
0.2710929513,
-0.1374190748,
0.2583779097,
-0.4806857407,
-0.9160101414,
0.3483941555,
0.2453090698,
-0.1595783681,
-0.0525484234,
0.7578490973,
-0.2257788479,
-0.2733200192,
0.2132859975,
0.500362277,
0.4454779327,
0.0429949239,
-0.5391108394,
0.4479868114,
0.1103397384,
-0.2816051543,
0.6442878842,
0.1889726818,
-0.1583443582,
0.3624605834,
0.3312630057,
0.1951694489,
0.0477921069,
0.0082142474,
0.9230017662,
-0.635463357,
-0.3613198996,
-0.5145215392,
0.3544586897,
0.2650167644,
-0.176765725,
0.7400918007,
0.568020165,
0.776995182,
-0.1265754104,
1.1060020924,
0.2132670432,
0.4826678634,
-0.7137038708,
0.3307282627,
-0.3314540684,
0.3247950673,
-0.3585758507,
-0.7657504678,
-0.5783398747,
0.3006542325,
-0.4347993135,
0.0747478157,
1.0470849276,
0.8682248592,
-0.1292532384,
0.1482527405,
0.3451772928,
0.3656681776,
0.4852899015,
0.4761274457,
0.844306767,
-0.2150514722,
0.8244042397,
-0.3517103791,
-0.7144292593,
-0.0471188016,
-0.8917770386,
-0.6110011935,
-0.2322936207,
-0.737385273,
-0.3965677023,
0.1595780551,
0.4469905794,
0.5669165254,
-0.4804934561,
-0.0259575322,
0.4028070271,
-0.2927804887,
-0.2282344997,
-0.1461884379,
0.4904314876,
-0.0545224361,
-0.3467960954,
0.5274210572,
0.5313477516,
0.1416212618,
-0.0433667712,
-0.0836607739,
-0.084209457,
0.1212006435,
0.6930263638,
0.4050989151,
-0.7591380477,
0.0115336571,
-0.0929314271,
-0.0897631496,
0.3412026763,
0.815369308,
-0.8047292829,
0.6867797971,
0.5206660628,
0.2541322708,
0.592109561,
-0.1491470933,
0.2529447675,
-0.5852395892,
-0.0789723992,
0.0744979829,
0.1870134473,
0.2169311941,
-0.4224021137,
0.6894710064,
0.1040898934,
-0.9030011892,
-0.6528728604,
0.0815994814,
-0.8980712891,
-0.4848590791,
1.057297349,
-0.2482067943,
-0.2623381615,
-0.0169052556,
-0.238960892,
0.0347395502,
-0.3031289577,
0.2757405043,
0.4634795785,
-0.4792782068,
-0.3755340278,
-0.6911829114,
0.2363784611,
0.0479995869,
-0.7274928689,
-0.2720104754,
0.5734112859,
0.4801649749,
0.0722936168,
1.3104819059,
-0.70939219,
0.4408366978,
-0.0011613994,
-0.0156659596,
-0.48521626,
-0.1469933093,
-0.7416319847,
0.2781064808,
0.345908612,
-0.3071770668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12291v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12291v1
|
KARL: Knowledge-Aware Retrieval and Representations aid Retention and Learning in Students
| 2024-02-19T17:05:29 | 2024-02-19T17:05:29 |
Matthew Shu, Nishant Balepur, Shi Feng, Jordan Boyd-Graber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Flashcard schedulers are tools that rely on 1) student models to predict the
flashcards a student knows; and 2) teaching policies to schedule cards based on
these predictions. Existing student models, however, only use flashcard-level
features, like the student's past responses, ignoring the semantic ties of
flashcards. Deep Knowledge Tracing (DKT) models can capture semantic relations
with language models, but are inefficient, lack content-rich datasets for
evaluation, and require robust teaching policies. To address these issues, we
design KARL, a DKT-inspired student model that uses retrieval and BERT
embeddings for efficient and accurate student recall predictions. To test KARL,
we collect a new dataset of diverse study history on trivia questions. KARL
bests existing student models in AUC and calibration error. Finally, we propose
a novel teaching policy that exploits the predictive power of DKT models to
deploy KARL online. Based on 27 learners and 32 6-day study trajectories, KARL
shows the ability to enhance medium-term educational learning, proving its
efficacy for scheduling.
|
[
-0.0776056871,
-0.6554771662,
0.777829051,
-0.1410105824,
-0.0443313457,
0.3233969808,
-0.0002985246,
-0.1754346192,
0.0941642895,
0.4672228992,
-0.3644089401,
-0.6682298779,
-0.1702272147,
-0.2254295498,
-0.4950653017,
1.0627418756,
0.0155637674,
0.009851207,
-0.3935093582,
0.1255719513,
-0.6142693758,
-0.2343590111,
-0.4399609566,
-0.5241530538,
0.572052896,
0.4124193788,
0.69989115,
0.7250515819,
0.1546075493,
0.0768788382,
-0.0892095789,
-0.1538357288,
-0.5461602807,
-0.0151713742,
-0.1586741507,
-0.5571600199,
-0.4394819736,
-0.2789029777,
0.8694191575,
0.9145428538,
-0.4344361722,
0.0909231678,
0.0207544062,
0.4877958298,
-0.5422141552,
0.1739779115,
-0.4088167846,
0.0557089671,
0.1102114096,
-0.0845412165,
-0.5007742643,
-0.9306890965,
0.7443104386,
-0.8798484206,
0.2425049394,
-0.1648739576,
0.3997868896,
0.0425070859,
-0.5505455136,
-0.2690859139,
-0.8130177855,
0.7846038938,
-0.5808683634,
0.5412487388,
0.4884956777,
0.6900649667,
0.1656392962,
-0.6481311917,
-0.5793972611,
-0.0712481737,
-0.1754389256,
0.12491256,
0.199011609,
0.0149884066,
0.2390402406,
-0.045968622,
-0.5219316483,
-0.034416683,
-0.5237374306,
-0.1778433323,
0.4358092546,
0.4917968214,
-0.0262764636,
0.0533007346,
-0.6372529864,
-0.1540863663,
-0.7865273356,
-0.1570139527,
0.4305395186,
0.2018366009,
0.2343139648,
0.2441705912,
0.0118084028,
0.841640532,
-0.2282227427,
-0.2213662267,
-0.2311219722,
-0.183533594,
0.0785872266,
0.2962320745,
-0.0998898074,
0.0638127998,
0.2537517846,
-0.258984834,
-0.0799819678,
-0.1064016819,
0.3020606339,
-0.7185291648,
-0.7184054852,
-0.0708717629,
-0.2200480998,
-0.0510523506,
-0.0320322886,
-0.886510849,
-0.3427635431,
-0.4851175845,
0.9412478209,
-0.6878020167,
-0.2560727894,
0.1915296018,
-0.1947156787,
0.1597622633,
0.6045188308,
-0.7606580257,
0.200145036,
0.631418705,
0.3378381431,
-0.0946506262,
-0.2650036812,
-0.1933256537,
0.4864254594,
-0.3443439007,
0.4874552786,
-0.7853049636,
-0.3271081448,
0.4725841284,
-0.295268029,
-0.0486334302,
-0.3104227483,
-0.0105142128,
-0.7357663512,
0.2554591298,
-0.553024888,
-1.1733572483,
-0.4705089629,
0.1118524298,
-0.6889591813,
0.9416655898,
0.2019980848,
-0.3070582747,
0.4754754901,
-0.279517293,
-0.4438922703,
0.3595678806,
-0.1549974084,
-0.2241072953,
-0.2100138664,
-0.1408527642,
0.6682588458,
0.0728763938,
0.6621220708,
-0.3176664412,
-0.6246646643,
-0.0214823801,
-0.0653171688,
0.7377319336,
0.085934341,
-0.1981163472,
-0.1154035926,
-0.845566988,
-0.0649773926,
0.0515512489,
-0.6704010367,
-0.7069288492,
0.1050479487,
0.0184671432,
-0.0701806918,
0.1068174988,
-0.5422006249,
0.3760070205,
0.0473164879,
0.0790389851,
0.9116007686,
-0.0058773723,
0.5209032297,
-0.4587103724,
0.5550909042,
-0.1310077161,
0.0182698667,
-0.3528698981,
-0.2221869975,
-0.7723122239,
0.1046212167,
0.0856252238,
0.3355233073,
-0.6829973459,
0.0479674414,
-0.3139363825,
-0.5441159606,
-0.468028903,
0.2674200833,
0.4923681021,
0.5292463899,
0.4536451101,
-0.0192566924,
-0.2358186543,
-0.604870379,
-0.1270976812,
0.1111705527,
0.1736304313,
0.4216874242,
0.5084822774,
0.0273159742,
1.083327055,
-0.6822159886,
-0.2623380125,
-0.5431067348,
0.0244439971,
0.0220658462,
0.5353265405,
0.6376600862,
-0.5869232416,
-0.6893668175,
-0.3634756505,
-0.5901305676,
0.3746756315,
-0.2411753386,
-0.016906688,
0.4529288113,
0.1994740218,
-0.1338883042,
0.5349075794,
-0.1792542785,
-0.7532074451,
0.32449615,
-0.2232385576,
-0.2229783684,
-0.7314396501,
0.0159886349,
-0.3887390792,
-0.1618945003,
-0.4819697738,
-0.5018954277,
0.2005459219,
-0.2558020055,
-0.4194486737,
0.7106928825,
-0.1638818979,
-0.1863236278,
-0.0070104538,
0.0669509917,
0.1809055209,
0.3664889038,
0.032330554,
0.5462270379,
0.5019113421,
-0.9411635995,
0.0454139933,
0.3474719524,
-0.4851526916,
0.883669734,
-0.4450392127,
0.0858313292,
-0.2738007903,
0.2704202533,
-0.9224739671,
0.0277517941,
-0.236311987,
-0.1657038778,
0.5845533609,
-0.1766902357,
-0.4766409397,
-0.2791540623,
-0.059895169,
0.3578995168,
0.7850112319,
-0.97229141,
0.8126961589,
0.2423451692,
0.1624047458,
-0.6287528276,
-0.1219075099,
-0.4729394317,
-0.2679546773,
-0.2731641531,
0.2270260155,
-0.1289631724,
-0.0559710078,
0.3683576286,
-0.2803719044,
-0.2050726414,
0.1891634017,
-0.0633391216,
0.4898247421,
-0.0771407336,
0.6442382336,
0.013169203,
-0.0251731481,
0.1073416099,
-0.6098008752,
0.4516708255,
0.1123169437,
-0.1516186148,
-0.4441659153,
0.2929368019,
0.2796031237,
0.1294618845,
0.4433780313,
0.8356178999,
-0.324202776,
-0.6171624064,
-0.8329553604,
-0.6475683451,
-0.452984482,
0.2798314095,
-0.0260416418,
-0.9260905385,
0.4831677377,
0.0575738698,
0.2019475251,
0.2509079576,
-0.0860258937,
-0.4342304468,
0.6171739101,
0.8823668361,
0.2211306095,
0.4583213031,
-0.4684502482,
-0.0301248245,
-0.5630294085,
-0.5169623494,
-0.0449877046,
-0.3259637356,
-0.1355477124,
0.0256065074,
0.1883942187,
-0.088583529,
-0.5078733563,
0.3191289604,
-0.4080713987,
0.5544580817,
0.8807917833,
0.1166211292,
0.0270887371,
-0.1698454916,
-0.1699311286,
-0.0485942066,
-0.9825857878,
-0.4042654932,
1.431755662,
0.1130254269,
0.8746362925,
0.0216446668,
0.9159591794,
0.3096573949,
0.0601735935,
-0.301159054,
0.7353378534,
0.0696171224,
-1.0438944101,
-0.3666085005,
-0.3244790733,
-0.8033921719,
-0.1054676101,
-0.2216160595,
-0.7030523419,
0.1087847427,
0.3593854606,
-0.7877403498,
0.55637151,
-0.5581297874,
0.8317759037,
-0.2901023924,
-0.7324211001,
-0.6075909138,
-0.699593544,
0.0743268579,
-0.0572262444,
-0.1856343597,
-0.2505476177,
0.2948330343,
1.144119978,
-0.1857580692,
1.2013543844,
-0.3965860307,
0.1618655771,
0.6743577123,
0.4594232738,
0.3973969221,
-0.0195199065,
0.1401353329,
-0.31820485,
0.42648983,
-0.4353073239,
-0.7212366462,
0.677529335,
-0.4785228074,
-0.5576809645,
-0.506400764,
-0.6291789412,
-0.0192528516,
0.1488573998,
-0.2870388031,
0.5391370058,
-0.0708703771,
0.1371304989,
1.0143244267,
-0.2789367735,
0.6558474302,
0.8281461596,
-0.2854227126,
-0.164106831,
1.3424476385,
0.499604702,
0.2755016387,
0.4277729094,
0.3574188948,
-0.366250664,
-0.1284303516,
-0.1353526264,
0.2456737608,
-1.0674695969,
-0.1701924354,
-0.5233031511,
0.0801837817,
-0.5228716135,
-0.5968809724,
-0.3445040882,
-0.6296080351,
-0.4170287549,
-0.3072822094,
0.5067705512,
1.0751743317,
-0.1000819132,
0.3910661936,
-0.4317285419,
-0.2301133722,
0.7237511277,
0.5467345715,
0.4237995446,
-0.3597696424,
-0.11813692,
-0.3664744198,
-0.38075158,
-0.7008476853,
0.3105447292,
0.2022427768,
0.6445755363,
0.4197603166,
0.2153510898,
0.4746646881,
-0.1984152645,
0.513258934,
-0.1177084744,
-0.7293244004,
0.7307602167,
-0.4773795009,
0.1382245719,
0.5276818871,
0.5483410954,
-0.3238580227,
-0.0256281421,
-0.8782845736,
-0.844576478,
0.6694898605,
-0.3508659005,
0.2388647944,
0.0895414799,
0.4830981791,
0.5126099586,
0.3400391936,
-0.3506838977,
-0.2215269804,
-0.2940704226,
-0.2828759253,
-0.1200341433,
-0.7586910129,
0.0085612163,
-0.4662682116,
0.5725076199,
0.023109138,
0.2311410308,
0.1274427325,
0.0161350276,
0.2934939265,
0.2660746574,
0.5416841507,
1.0138760805,
-0.5517214537,
0.191149205,
0.1892950088,
-0.5619618893,
-0.0802935213,
0.0227391366,
-0.4656727016,
0.1752928793,
0.2433509678,
0.3917171955,
0.7635260224,
-0.5823955536,
0.321680069,
0.3590097129,
0.0074033649,
-0.8527417183,
0.2252750695,
-0.0099127088,
0.2921479642,
0.4388377368,
-0.4659594297,
-0.0017023579,
-0.4771556556,
0.5491241217,
0.1457141787,
-0.5088851452,
-0.3828898668,
0.7308843136,
0.1699670851,
-0.2470555454,
0.8222730756,
-0.1089109257,
-0.6406753063,
0.6661744118,
0.8213591576,
0.4890299141,
-0.3565445244,
0.4827329814,
0.6832868457,
0.0201039687,
-0.2209025919,
0.5682372451,
-0.3063724935,
-0.3077328801,
0.0596238263,
-0.5311393738,
-0.4520611167,
-0.3851639628,
-0.7854853272,
0.1070615351,
-0.4866767526,
-0.0764783472,
-0.2533524632,
0.2286771983,
-0.9831247926,
-0.0046491502,
-0.0014998767,
0.8276590109,
-0.8255159855,
1.1134566069,
0.4849126339,
-0.3245013654,
-0.8122861385,
-0.444467485,
0.006682402,
-0.7989215255,
0.7072817087,
0.131316945,
0.4447196424,
0.3576216996,
-0.3991678953,
-0.9708794951,
1.5485162735,
0.2190866619,
-0.4091624618,
-0.1042079851,
-0.0869844407,
0.2885946631,
-0.3979840875,
0.1062760279,
0.5627522469,
0.379526943,
0.3771082163,
-0.6030231118,
0.0006753124,
0.355062753,
-0.2753471434,
0.1311017424,
-0.3125834465,
0.8195697665,
-0.6368874311,
-0.2359387428,
-0.4218841493,
0.5318729281,
-0.0180154908,
0.7036265731,
0.1164245829,
0.71741575,
0.9918009639,
-0.1495270729,
1.0961114168,
0.0025630756,
0.2568976283,
1.2870031595,
-0.1284156889,
0.7320204973,
0.4043243825,
-0.0365140587,
0.5474945903,
0.3397589326,
-0.2747505307,
0.8141520619,
0.1502816975,
-0.2122541517,
-0.5728675127,
-0.2194459438,
-0.3727579713,
0.2505822182,
0.3286980987,
-0.2721452415,
-0.4240604043,
0.1237118468,
0.2864483297,
0.1728994995,
-0.4747204185,
0.5981599092,
-0.115384765,
-0.7740278244,
0.2818819582,
-0.6978247166,
0.2978375852,
-0.566559732,
-0.3201503158,
-0.28477934,
0.5856116414,
0.0567341521,
-0.7906538844,
0.0236632861,
-0.6409451365,
0.1491936147,
-0.3046127558,
0.494743973,
-0.7827842832,
-0.5317792892,
0.2945260704,
0.3378502131,
0.0267329048,
0.5078445077,
-0.3230709434,
-0.0718016773,
-0.0754866153,
0.0273066312,
0.3068038523,
0.0685080364,
0.1777512133,
0.945884347,
0.3198415041,
-0.1959196925,
0.2747364342,
-0.1295491755,
0.6276734471,
-0.6081308722,
-0.367923826,
-0.716123879,
0.4147707522,
0.0772382915,
-0.2858096957,
0.847310245,
0.6548398137,
1.0230853558,
-0.0885258913,
0.6436042786,
0.2714921832,
0.5814017057,
-0.3250038624,
0.9267147183,
-0.374841243,
0.2626051307,
-0.2049992532,
-0.7264847755,
-0.0396752097,
0.7052950263,
-0.2335848659,
-0.0995222777,
0.5462652445,
0.1722990721,
0.1399883628,
0.1438827366,
0.2250643373,
-0.1551114768,
0.3606755733,
0.8287473321,
0.6397560835,
-0.1546984017,
0.5727127194,
-0.6171376705,
0.0078180414,
-0.3303075731,
-0.6296600103,
-1.2575956583,
-0.8363791704,
-0.4486044049,
-0.216448769,
0.3013312519,
0.6685259938,
0.4755874574,
-0.5650343895,
-0.2247485369,
0.1915536374,
0.5720344186,
-0.2610002458,
-0.2428026199,
0.8269646764,
-0.3735844791,
-0.2926527262,
0.1623185575,
-0.2002348602,
0.5083799958,
-0.1976929307,
0.0341506712,
-0.2184261382,
-0.0709398687,
0.5068603754,
0.270534128,
-0.5848674178,
-0.5022792816,
0.3679829538,
0.0234019663,
-0.3512561917,
0.7803798318,
-1.0794531107,
0.7596629858,
0.4169637859,
0.6352458,
0.5715673566,
-0.1422785223,
0.5814544559,
-0.3664841056,
-0.2528901994,
0.6612175107,
0.1357598007,
0.1278790832,
-0.2990085483,
0.5165759325,
0.279615432,
-0.4794646502,
-0.9426090121,
0.1164165512,
-0.8658955693,
-0.2246888429,
1.0285817385,
-0.2091683894,
-0.0501882657,
-0.4086047113,
0.2892069817,
0.0545487292,
-0.3706276417,
1.0894682407,
0.6581709385,
-0.011039882,
0.121569559,
-0.917290628,
0.6401587725,
0.3299567699,
-0.2124239206,
0.160762921,
0.3838199675,
0.4729706943,
0.1384041607,
0.6318618655,
0.2065369785,
0.2825887203,
-0.0573840253,
-0.0927149057,
-0.3028928041,
-0.8455798626,
0.0311383028,
0.2291999757,
-0.3763592839,
-0.1336896271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12282v1
|
Ontology Enhanced Claim Detection
| 2024-02-19T16:50:58 | 2024-02-19T16:50:58 |
Zehra Melce Hüsünbeyi, Tatjana Scheffler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose an ontology enhanced model for sentence based claim detection. We
fused ontology embeddings from a knowledge base with BERT sentence embeddings
to perform claim detection for the ClaimBuster and the NewsClaims datasets. Our
ontology enhanced approach showed the best results with these small-sized
unbalanced datasets, compared to other statistical and neural machine learning
models. The experiments demonstrate that adding domain specific features
(either trained word embeddings or knowledge graph metadata) can improve
traditional ML methods. In addition, adding domain knowledge in the form of
ontology embeddings helps avoid the bias encountered in neural network based
models, for example the pure BERT model bias towards larger classes in our
small corpus.
|
[
-0.0907219723,
-0.5721555948,
0.5178912878,
0.0612610579,
0.2653134167,
-0.0826992467,
-0.0096956585,
-0.5991982818,
0.4590288401,
0.9493171573,
-0.3520284891,
-0.2537041605,
-0.6883574724,
-0.0629098639,
-0.3410407007,
1.0242983103,
0.2760054171,
0.1043894589,
-0.3806214035,
0.0575972311,
-0.4499968588,
-0.3722401857,
-0.2219987512,
-0.5561078191,
0.2285755426,
0.341417253,
0.7856731415,
0.1828261018,
0.5610538721,
0.2152811885,
0.0102285221,
0.2615624666,
-0.0178497192,
-0.0071883788,
-0.1829842478,
-0.8080729246,
-0.613048315,
-0.1385627389,
0.5351307392,
0.6126463413,
-0.2128223926,
0.1197079495,
-0.0410356224,
0.3238666952,
-0.6886604428,
0.1757773012,
-0.9210186005,
0.3255014718,
-0.0917819142,
-0.2782729864,
-0.5016759634,
-0.3582480848,
0.6348295808,
-0.5224753022,
0.2571054399,
0.1841533035,
0.9913215041,
0.1087235585,
-0.5035318732,
-0.4195587039,
-0.1311053932,
0.8821288347,
-0.6959821582,
0.1937497407,
0.3213296831,
0.2237947732,
-0.0897732303,
-0.9554587007,
-0.8438655734,
-0.3470935225,
-0.3334810138,
0.2326171547,
-0.5379170179,
0.2062749565,
0.1782065034,
0.2432675362,
-0.4227062166,
0.2453852743,
0.158100903,
-0.692243576,
0.4945863187,
-0.0250176135,
0.3871769309,
-0.7004936337,
-0.671592772,
-0.0741045773,
-0.7146938443,
-0.1456268132,
0.3384762108,
0.5849846005,
0.2182885706,
0.7269089818,
0.0188082233,
0.8760157824,
-0.156762138,
-0.0977227464,
0.190305829,
-0.1169061884,
-0.2570658922,
0.4645568728,
0.3346578479,
0.2350657731,
0.1582398117,
-0.310097307,
-0.3180716336,
0.2384136766,
0.2481670678,
-0.5010463595,
-0.1630843282,
0.1822864264,
-0.776665628,
-0.5109031796,
0.1266970783,
-0.521494627,
-0.8114336133,
-0.0617717728,
0.7101027966,
-0.5450463891,
-0.2690455317,
0.2343245894,
-0.5657502413,
0.1499651074,
0.1500159204,
-0.5863887668,
0.3034027815,
0.5885974169,
0.5774140358,
0.2642115951,
0.1993303448,
-0.4574885368,
0.3384490311,
-0.0179189276,
1.1369122267,
-0.5945719481,
0.1441319436,
0.4837316275,
-0.1892574131,
-0.0238416884,
-0.5891703963,
0.95197016,
-0.8131274581,
0.4399873614,
-0.3624585271,
-1.1194449663,
-0.3042605817,
0.5796456933,
-0.7506905198,
0.8651200533,
0.1656593084,
-0.8805221319,
0.7910948992,
-1.0883010626,
-0.3725728989,
0.2156739235,
-0.0363885872,
-0.457954973,
0.0735494122,
-0.08864557,
0.4124266803,
-0.14374502,
0.2799679041,
-0.1979912072,
0.2799336314,
0.3220157325,
-0.1457723826,
1.0095177889,
0.3065735102,
-0.0714845434,
-0.1535747498,
-0.8883823156,
0.308465749,
0.1101599112,
-0.4736122489,
-0.6373790503,
0.0644277558,
0.1979987174,
0.0994967446,
0.3391807675,
-1.1164343357,
0.2548213601,
-0.4754659832,
0.3347862959,
0.4998742938,
-0.3123215735,
0.0410504639,
-0.3046432137,
0.2261235714,
0.0076930267,
-0.2615494132,
-0.0197766442,
-0.4328793287,
-0.8480643034,
-0.3105894029,
0.9075122476,
0.8118643165,
-0.6872175336,
0.9963440895,
-0.4358020127,
0.1455299556,
-0.624227643,
0.0777504593,
0.1803747714,
0.5265235305,
0.4291190505,
-0.3015223444,
-0.9017482996,
-0.8299522996,
-0.4910880029,
-0.1404997855,
-0.3450376391,
0.1378434002,
0.3666525781,
-0.2470066249,
1.5941901207,
-0.7441494465,
-0.9627201557,
-0.3496070504,
0.1887417138,
-0.1387449205,
0.14510037,
0.6750840545,
-1.0180262327,
-0.2980327904,
-0.1807194948,
-0.8378616571,
-0.34913221,
-0.0626009703,
0.094446741,
0.347034961,
0.0880179256,
-0.617444396,
0.4682407677,
0.246184364,
-0.8136925101,
0.1792931706,
-0.1452200413,
-0.2494336814,
-1.1092531681,
-0.3151471615,
-0.0586233735,
-0.6107933521,
-0.5737063289,
-0.2009997368,
0.1576419771,
0.1509554386,
-0.0929022431,
0.1373372674,
-0.429046452,
-0.120492354,
-0.617139101,
0.3761452436,
0.3164027631,
0.0107977604,
0.1224429831,
0.165353775,
0.5069585443,
-0.4877683818,
0.5067542195,
0.8330412507,
-0.4555827677,
0.473714143,
-0.5597102046,
-0.2016276419,
-0.0058973739,
0.3456299603,
-1.1643707752,
-0.0575105287,
-0.0721381381,
-0.6640074849,
0.1905288994,
0.1684178412,
-0.8774739504,
-0.5828335881,
-0.276094079,
-0.5070220828,
0.3884269595,
-0.9533956051,
0.8452528715,
0.449796468,
-0.1755345017,
-0.4454969466,
-1.1731936932,
0.5012233853,
-0.0593953691,
-0.8676259518,
0.6578076482,
0.6084963679,
-0.1761925519,
0.4268530309,
0.1741820574,
-0.1801328361,
-0.0546797365,
-0.0191695988,
0.3380818069,
-0.3465177715,
0.645993948,
0.0402968042,
-0.0212350916,
0.1081276685,
-0.5770563483,
0.4777887166,
-0.0281420927,
-0.1234714389,
-0.4165784717,
0.4152019322,
-0.0489788465,
-0.0386165008,
1.0911118984,
0.4926380217,
-0.423566848,
-0.1508110166,
-0.6215566993,
-0.1843192726,
-0.4388805926,
0.2289064825,
-0.1430587023,
-1.042842865,
0.4093599021,
-0.2053325474,
0.1273498535,
0.7579913735,
0.5086014867,
-0.1052112579,
0.8818811178,
0.9186615944,
0.0284777712,
0.4381960034,
-0.185210824,
0.4103199542,
-0.4251365066,
-0.109586671,
-0.3859319687,
-0.1618712395,
-0.5217680931,
-0.0814860016,
0.1342091858,
-0.165894568,
0.0650821403,
0.525452137,
-0.5085902214,
0.0579861999,
0.5389815569,
0.2730567157,
0.556271255,
0.1701687574,
-0.0847430304,
-0.0335153379,
-0.8531178236,
-0.6406908631,
1.2105202675,
0.3216313422,
0.6073007584,
0.399200052,
0.3403353393,
0.9880059958,
0.3551199734,
-0.7916064858,
0.4046385884,
-0.16250965,
-0.9291430116,
-0.1171554253,
-0.3981747329,
-0.8973055482,
0.2472390234,
-0.6300444007,
-0.6331858039,
0.235408619,
0.2780958116,
-0.5696913004,
0.3823554218,
-0.7520857453,
0.5346066356,
-0.0530752838,
0.1060568541,
-0.3060947955,
-0.7081977129,
0.1595454216,
0.0026873662,
-0.2607563734,
0.0647339001,
0.0128871202,
0.9476438165,
-0.834649384,
1.2364411354,
-0.3898299038,
-0.3340635598,
0.7013852,
-0.3960694969,
0.626858592,
-0.1767310202,
-0.0405518375,
-0.1111170128,
-0.0967792198,
-0.4293585122,
-0.5207984447,
0.3251760304,
-0.5007995963,
-0.389400661,
-0.3819701672,
-0.6422969103,
-0.326060921,
0.1300842017,
0.2913212776,
0.2467658818,
-0.195141539,
0.14520064,
0.7579458952,
-0.319667697,
0.3754376769,
0.8008052111,
-0.0666378811,
-0.1103283614,
0.7344077826,
0.336784035,
0.2075340897,
0.5577163696,
0.3049016893,
-0.3752245307,
-0.1738630086,
-0.0781330019,
-0.3493227065,
-0.6761420965,
-0.6465196013,
-1.2084341049,
-0.1486615986,
-0.9792363644,
0.2154775709,
-0.2853266299,
-0.8867704868,
0.2366755009,
-0.2440484911,
0.7816275358,
0.4778794348,
-0.1067427397,
0.6305105686,
-0.9356312752,
0.317756474,
0.2849539816,
0.1903668344,
-0.097332783,
-0.6990817785,
-0.0738121048,
-0.1465551555,
-0.5585591197,
-0.4754592776,
0.2555826604,
0.3811708093,
0.5616692901,
0.7488442063,
0.3196910322,
0.2075579613,
-0.4668640792,
0.6487088799,
0.291692704,
-0.9756483436,
0.8152515292,
-0.0236711707,
-0.440633446,
0.2000149041,
0.36841169,
-0.2718890309,
-0.153088212,
-0.8399812579,
-0.5113148689,
0.4467629492,
0.1505680382,
0.3038980663,
0.1205423921,
0.1763461083,
0.1237150505,
0.1700895429,
-0.8757573366,
-0.1184724495,
-0.0083075352,
-0.3400407732,
0.61412251,
-0.4881616831,
-0.2868018448,
0.0033204842,
0.4267653525,
-0.2110099345,
0.458355397,
0.2965176702,
-0.3877064586,
0.1578307748,
0.4157173634,
0.106603153,
0.4246107042,
-0.1665733904,
0.0073123975,
0.2418690622,
-0.3676191568,
-0.2265348732,
0.4071473777,
-0.1508706361,
0.2278202921,
0.6740453243,
0.7361460328,
-0.0615993999,
-0.827943325,
0.7549468875,
0.1967248321,
-0.1818728894,
-0.4533724189,
-0.0441153049,
-0.2196644396,
0.2801153064,
0.4281300902,
0.2035574317,
0.3921786547,
-0.6275125742,
0.4615985453,
0.3760152459,
-0.4900784194,
-0.0363881551,
0.4146560431,
0.1498156488,
0.0372543409,
0.282833159,
0.0084733935,
-0.966568768,
0.5375449061,
0.7378890514,
0.4257902205,
-0.0553563684,
0.2520013154,
-0.2351245135,
0.3603052497,
-0.018489616,
0.4109886289,
0.0301322881,
-1.3520594835,
-0.3425546587,
-0.3271374702,
-0.4235876501,
-0.2527584136,
-0.7654865384,
0.14327389,
-0.2075270712,
-0.3589513302,
0.2312186062,
0.1407810599,
-0.4412067235,
0.3153581321,
0.2295714319,
1.0729027987,
-1.027813673,
0.8346408606,
0.7923116088,
-0.4093049467,
-0.5942305326,
0.1449943185,
0.0198895298,
-0.9743432999,
1.0665159225,
0.1112107113,
0.1438814998,
-0.1147772372,
-0.5731767416,
-0.575949192,
0.9471748471,
0.4502982497,
-0.1853096187,
0.0507212281,
0.1930896491,
0.4524241686,
-0.5047171712,
0.0412067957,
0.4365429878,
0.5175857544,
-0.0397407301,
-0.7402639985,
0.1416795403,
0.1456649899,
0.0417886041,
0.1410485208,
-0.6242765784,
0.7722810507,
-0.2029150277,
-0.0509752817,
0.0802123994,
1.0756417513,
-0.0023282992,
0.2474955767,
0.6714616418,
0.9493676424,
1.104999423,
-0.0243555941,
1.2546131611,
0.0738919303,
0.633877933,
1.0874640942,
-0.5853936672,
0.790346086,
0.1615302563,
-0.2278194726,
0.7692885399,
0.4145171344,
-0.3587419093,
0.6451931596,
0.3579578996,
-0.3257116377,
-0.3635508716,
-0.6424622536,
-0.4248401821,
0.7312554717,
0.4093549252,
-0.625728488,
-0.2863363922,
0.3551659286,
-0.0356129259,
0.1411508769,
-0.3590629995,
0.6884061694,
0.0037156299,
-0.4192445576,
0.0416428,
0.068163,
0.9475914836,
-0.5841915011,
-0.0778133199,
0.3092722297,
0.5242766142,
-0.4489153028,
-0.7844645977,
0.3438418508,
0.0102767097,
-0.4129217267,
-0.274071455,
1.377732873,
-0.4397820532,
-0.5217467546,
0.5426988006,
0.3375942409,
-0.1040305346,
-0.0938885957,
-0.5195645094,
-0.5166561007,
-0.2042383552,
-0.2541337311,
0.1391535103,
0.6709278822,
-0.0027183695,
0.5949932337,
0.4354069531,
0.0085278079,
0.0417740345,
0.2379469126,
0.9744664431,
-0.5728216767,
-0.7323868871,
-0.6055833697,
0.1717624664,
-0.5798933506,
-0.0229194146,
0.8891274333,
0.6136607528,
0.4904274344,
-0.0245949253,
1.1184147596,
-0.5019170046,
0.9540638924,
-0.7196905017,
0.8691492081,
-0.4318937063,
0.0928112492,
-0.1889313608,
-0.5730555654,
-0.3738558888,
0.6158551574,
-0.22023426,
-0.0765867978,
0.5101469755,
0.5171189308,
0.1724762321,
0.3986386359,
0.3715569675,
0.1301023811,
0.0784608126,
0.4299860001,
0.8675325513,
-0.5836075544,
0.6646095514,
0.3598097861,
-0.3368636072,
-0.3554401994,
-1.0024276972,
-0.9211592078,
-0.0240546148,
-0.4922305644,
-0.7231253386,
-0.1828598678,
0.7427417636,
0.5804811716,
-1.1412045956,
0.3133616447,
0.0532222986,
-0.0972125456,
0.0483641848,
-0.313316673,
0.3126915097,
-0.4906519651,
-0.2857396901,
0.1100876257,
0.0548594147,
-0.1820310801,
0.0087721888,
0.2678898573,
-0.470351398,
0.1892788112,
0.8051844239,
-0.0213607289,
-0.5559720397,
-0.4846428931,
-0.1520261168,
-0.1627929062,
-0.0309637468,
0.9368842244,
-0.8157519698,
0.2586141229,
0.5195990205,
0.9204724431,
0.0738343969,
-0.1205590442,
0.6030397415,
-0.9773053527,
0.2206669599,
0.1320970803,
0.5983453393,
0.1940402985,
-0.6827599406,
0.5448446274,
0.27827546,
-0.1962282509,
-0.6996471286,
0.0970251709,
-0.8856492639,
-0.2898314297,
0.6981012821,
-0.4477108419,
-0.0163251776,
-0.2846899033,
-0.0254882984,
0.2281453758,
-0.2458901256,
0.8039458394,
0.8623649478,
-0.2153582573,
0.3155035079,
-0.5015593171,
0.3145063818,
0.6900647283,
-0.7390586734,
-0.0636120215,
0.3791450262,
0.2423953712,
0.6710224152,
0.3320285082,
-0.1398765743,
0.0651731864,
0.0912391096,
0.4178645313,
0.1023275778,
-0.0495847911,
-0.047399465,
0.2628488243,
-0.3439551592,
-0.3599212766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12280v1
|
Adaptive Skeleton Graph Decoding
| 2024-02-19T16:47:04 | 2024-02-19T16:47:04 |
Shuowei Jin, Yongji Wu, Haizhong Zheng, Qingzhao Zhang, Matthew Lentz, Z. Morley Mao, Atul Prakash, Feng Qian, Danyang Zhuo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have seen significant adoption for natural
language tasks, owing their success to massive numbers of model parameters
(e.g., 70B+); however, LLM inference incurs significant computation and memory
costs. Recent approaches propose parallel decoding strategies, such as
Skeleton-of-Thought (SoT), to improve performance by breaking prompts down into
sub-problems that can be decoded in parallel; however, they often suffer from
reduced response quality. Our key insight is that we can request additional
information, specifically dependencies and difficulty, when generating the
sub-problems to improve both response quality and performance. In this paper,
we propose Skeleton Graph Decoding (SGD), which uses dependencies exposed
between sub-problems to support information forwarding between dependent
sub-problems for improved quality while exposing parallelization opportunities
for decoding independent sub-problems. Additionally, we leverage difficulty
estimates for each sub-problem to select an appropriately-sized model,
improving performance without significantly reducing quality. Compared to
standard autoregressive generation and SoT, SGD achieves a 1.69x speedup while
improving quality by up to 51%.
|
[
-0.0840108693,
-0.492169559,
0.3842124343,
0.5525243878,
-0.6669807434,
0.3852595985,
-0.0579970442,
-0.5904058218,
0.4363546073,
0.5538292527,
-0.5026963353,
-0.5311275721,
-0.7022848725,
0.3707649708,
-0.0017006301,
0.8460778594,
-0.2039357275,
0.3122307658,
-0.1081580147,
-0.184125334,
-0.5995097756,
-0.437269032,
-1.0283476114,
-0.3386739194,
0.5051337481,
0.0856630281,
0.5875837207,
1.0904277563,
0.4217270911,
0.2674786448,
-0.075195007,
0.1468116194,
-0.6921434402,
0.1428930014,
-0.4241758287,
-0.5594522357,
-0.6599399447,
-0.4105480909,
0.569447577,
0.8541742563,
-0.102737166,
-0.0236987341,
0.1308374107,
0.9227358103,
-0.4121454358,
0.8822842836,
-0.5372858047,
-0.1899148375,
-0.0762321055,
-0.2216733694,
-0.3642703593,
-0.1596381962,
0.0884309039,
-0.5932022333,
0.2681108713,
0.0125291627,
0.5034322739,
0.496508956,
0.0221625529,
-0.598748982,
-0.3276529312,
0.4074922502,
-0.6732679605,
0.4957585633,
0.44864133,
0.006047307,
-0.4085401297,
-0.750466764,
-0.2608005106,
0.1560058892,
-0.0141611006,
0.1497423649,
-0.2874983847,
0.2585307062,
0.1413182616,
0.3024070859,
-0.515327394,
0.0415151827,
-0.1652353257,
-0.3650921583,
0.6423386931,
0.4198672175,
0.3649627268,
-0.3757855594,
0.1035805196,
-0.37285164,
-0.4539014101,
0.1454100162,
0.4765982628,
0.5523748398,
0.0037043018,
0.4464063048,
-0.4254715443,
0.721192956,
0.1571236849,
-0.2433608621,
0.2225011736,
-0.4017570019,
-0.0945444927,
0.1635193676,
0.3985088766,
0.2815220654,
0.2527048588,
-0.2970429361,
-0.1725313067,
0.3269811273,
0.0645400211,
-0.821496129,
-0.7486917973,
0.2317000329,
-0.5491598845,
0.2948658764,
-0.452927947,
-0.8348158598,
-0.3605936766,
-0.13880831,
0.168360576,
-0.6308894157,
-0.3240865469,
0.5879105926,
-0.1688926518,
-0.2302646339,
0.3936018944,
-0.9448019862,
0.3424390554,
0.4014189541,
0.8467771411,
-0.1987243593,
-0.1672292054,
-0.619915545,
0.1863470972,
-0.1863236278,
0.8179003596,
-0.5022719502,
-0.2051101774,
-0.5948367119,
-0.0135988481,
-0.2325208783,
-0.5156100392,
0.395391196,
-0.4453443289,
-0.4391906559,
-0.3314549625,
-0.4142661393,
-0.1546922177,
0.1534503251,
-0.7909418344,
0.722409904,
0.3222717047,
-1.1113839149,
0.0403878205,
-0.285295248,
-0.65675354,
-0.0254105441,
-0.1271342188,
0.0046290299,
0.3445669413,
0.7230318785,
0.5430468321,
-0.4339966774,
-0.0133263515,
-0.2767527997,
-0.0794318169,
-0.4399750531,
-0.2023714483,
0.5312740803,
0.0924923196,
-0.1786947548,
0.0760837495,
-1.0405356884,
0.0627855062,
0.4234721661,
-0.6502084136,
-0.3550947011,
0.1476018131,
-0.3567306101,
-0.1520388275,
0.0962876379,
-0.4360635281,
0.0886001438,
-0.68105793,
0.3941994011,
0.8911169767,
-0.1712892205,
0.2496353835,
-0.1770518124,
0.4976139367,
-0.0008725835,
-0.3340842724,
-0.2025417984,
-0.3781618774,
-0.7096160054,
-0.3634190857,
0.4426309764,
0.3731085658,
-1.2814911604,
0.0714813545,
-0.4154329598,
-0.2968484461,
-0.6895299554,
0.268956989,
0.5287200212,
0.4236231744,
0.5457807183,
-0.546857655,
-0.5645161271,
-0.4716327488,
-0.2484838665,
-0.4256259203,
-0.0141799422,
0.4616651535,
0.0499888584,
0.0381434076,
0.7833729982,
-0.5275576711,
-0.0716739446,
-0.4985323846,
0.1030222252,
0.3371267617,
0.4817737639,
0.4863683581,
-0.4328656495,
-0.6132245064,
-0.1536712945,
-0.6127477288,
-0.14361009,
0.1493955255,
-0.0282336995,
0.1828308702,
0.4009563029,
-0.8757587671,
0.277546823,
0.6404283047,
-0.0513227358,
0.3945138156,
-0.3577245474,
-0.1522072405,
-1.1153953075,
-0.2430188805,
-0.1259224117,
-0.2043290436,
-0.3182390332,
0.1679774672,
-0.0662409812,
0.1622418016,
0.0124383811,
0.3290428817,
-0.7742108107,
-0.2354120463,
-0.3337160349,
0.0584720634,
-0.0307145678,
0.3589915931,
0.0661126375,
0.6723820567,
0.7349778414,
-0.4752603769,
0.525180459,
0.0147780944,
-0.1636481285,
0.4293543994,
-0.5635758638,
0.360875994,
-0.5947710276,
0.7047147751,
-1.1636600494,
-0.4846321642,
0.2513454258,
-0.2529717386,
0.3653827906,
-0.4426654279,
-0.5502346754,
-0.4738259315,
-0.1763190925,
0.6379380226,
0.3838455975,
-0.8088669777,
0.8141281605,
0.293128401,
-0.3741410375,
-0.6242248416,
-0.4639048576,
0.0460707843,
0.1896051615,
-0.8895362616,
0.1744595766,
-0.1223540232,
0.114705883,
0.1390235126,
-0.4853836894,
0.1622640193,
-0.2101495415,
0.0713715255,
-0.2832911611,
-0.454441011,
0.0563836657,
0.0939166173,
-0.4842721224,
0.0781573057,
-0.6333917975,
0.9647212029,
0.3289839923,
-0.3322820663,
-0.4383075237,
0.3084751368,
0.5089957118,
-0.1966487914,
0.5266708732,
0.4734491408,
-0.4353644848,
-0.3198358715,
-0.3572194874,
-0.1421739459,
-0.4726072252,
0.5411406755,
-0.5730888844,
-0.7429407835,
0.7211927772,
-0.1065654382,
-0.2730592489,
0.216178596,
0.4692097902,
0.1054381505,
1.2745097876,
0.4703352153,
-0.3041087687,
0.1717680097,
-0.292997092,
0.1559105664,
-0.6811108589,
-0.2037281841,
-0.4951387346,
-0.3160400689,
-0.3062691391,
-0.5494722724,
0.101317808,
0.5068003535,
0.1525363028,
0.450863868,
-0.4001229405,
0.4546816349,
0.1903520077,
0.4829704463,
0.3387698233,
0.1092470586,
-0.2182510793,
-0.0133455712,
-1.0556050539,
-0.1081178933,
0.9496727586,
0.3264323175,
1.2637034655,
0.0957415998,
0.5660898089,
0.0234960336,
0.3152318001,
-0.6667337418,
0.5356001854,
-0.4852899313,
-0.1774590313,
-0.1887575239,
-0.6587876678,
-1.0060937405,
0.2193555385,
0.0566352382,
-0.89896065,
0.0795710608,
0.3759065568,
-0.3032134175,
0.2840414345,
-0.6024718285,
0.4820599258,
0.144206062,
-0.0645833835,
-0.2336419225,
-0.5852526426,
0.1456496567,
0.0434138179,
0.0261252765,
-0.1366103292,
0.2355426699,
0.6576472521,
-0.2935160995,
0.8838348985,
-0.226798445,
-0.1402609497,
0.113596499,
0.0527757108,
1.1340142488,
0.2478524148,
-0.3059355319,
-0.1808194667,
-0.088536121,
-0.5862699747,
-0.6529051065,
0.6803266406,
-0.6916643977,
-0.7630524635,
-0.0798849985,
-1.0660876036,
-0.3517686427,
0.2164120376,
0.3527754247,
0.5559591055,
0.2814092636,
0.1138886735,
0.5530789495,
-0.1161757037,
0.5451343656,
0.26748088,
-0.0200846083,
-0.5521885157,
1.0407390594,
0.3325635493,
0.3046269715,
0.2129600346,
0.0219881423,
-0.4852451086,
-1.1977481842,
-0.7197195292,
0.277248174,
-0.9544551373,
-0.4661984444,
-1.0545957088,
-0.1312805116,
-0.4853569865,
0.0837132931,
-0.4913412929,
-0.1556914002,
-0.4615335464,
-0.055308301,
0.4044322968,
0.6710074544,
0.0839225277,
0.3622104824,
-0.8326568604,
0.5271478891,
0.1645143181,
0.4639356434,
0.2472786009,
-0.2571641207,
-0.2032018453,
0.07487344,
0.2348070145,
-0.7189961076,
0.3451033235,
-0.1859307289,
0.5155800581,
-0.0289875362,
0.4490236044,
0.8264362812,
-0.4458518326,
0.4052212536,
0.220258221,
-0.8639413714,
0.1163918972,
-0.256849885,
0.3421038389,
0.3187063634,
0.3264913857,
-0.0604779981,
-0.315407455,
-0.2863811553,
-0.8950867057,
1.0220143795,
0.1776707917,
0.2710999548,
-0.1636975408,
0.6500915289,
-0.0091820844,
-0.1207058653,
-0.5534921288,
-0.0025923082,
-0.3275347352,
-0.4855272174,
-0.1203859746,
-0.2428197414,
0.1297561675,
-0.1880221963,
0.326921761,
-0.456784606,
0.1570252776,
0.2915208638,
-0.2604023814,
-0.3027651906,
-0.0303228721,
0.2969298065,
0.6614195704,
-0.1867954135,
0.3142522871,
0.3439507186,
-0.6093434691,
0.1803099215,
0.1441611499,
0.3467721045,
-0.1001610085,
0.4916494787,
0.8872640729,
-0.1245281845,
-0.5225064754,
0.1979507655,
-0.0444786362,
0.0538281053,
0.4321324825,
0.2264789045,
0.4758338034,
0.5737292171,
0.4224339128,
-0.0883238986,
-0.0511411801,
-0.3477106094,
0.0972294435,
0.2449917197,
-0.2403479367,
-0.4373485446,
0.5537472367,
0.1489203721,
-0.3549247384,
0.5024095178,
-0.1812634617,
-0.4477477074,
0.7070285082,
1.0096002817,
0.6018456817,
-0.2304039896,
0.1053714752,
0.2344200015,
0.2540900111,
-0.3267627656,
0.5470586419,
0.199438259,
-0.7114793062,
-0.7820292115,
-0.7756625414,
-0.1171859652,
0.1295083463,
-0.6599464417,
-0.1644287556,
-0.7666916251,
-0.0567045994,
-0.0015146201,
-0.1459007114,
-0.4467266798,
0.2898807228,
-0.374700278,
0.9792744517,
-0.4583717287,
0.8597955704,
0.6122125387,
-0.0939663649,
-0.9370964766,
0.2771319747,
-0.2868582606,
-0.75292027,
0.5908071995,
0.1005482972,
-0.4599381983,
0.5262869,
-0.2362368554,
-1.0973715782,
0.9911432266,
1.0249471664,
-0.3322739601,
-0.0516310856,
0.0672378838,
0.7119600773,
-0.6583430767,
0.0219154917,
0.5726829767,
0.256516397,
0.1073451191,
-0.8773822188,
0.439052701,
-0.1541647315,
0.243679747,
0.1835974008,
-0.5997621417,
1.0536586046,
-0.1949987411,
-0.6036586165,
0.1953841597,
0.5743822455,
0.1586689204,
0.3343039751,
0.5434593558,
0.4476451874,
0.5624082088,
0.0900058225,
1.0992655754,
-0.4100845754,
0.2582140565,
1.1113758087,
-0.0944079831,
0.6845239997,
0.3049637675,
-0.1984920353,
0.2322891802,
0.8543184996,
0.5335668921,
0.5483996272,
0.4814975858,
-0.0757377222,
-0.3854123652,
-0.1306844801,
-0.4688281417,
0.4088050723,
0.4798467755,
-0.3042506278,
-0.5768773556,
0.0813115388,
-0.1522852182,
0.1492137462,
-0.3077874482,
0.6556344628,
-0.1951788366,
-0.5227434039,
0.7589188218,
0.1071908325,
0.4654736221,
-0.4584346712,
-0.1608237028,
-0.421730876,
0.1287196726,
-0.1460634321,
-0.5863496065,
0.1228013784,
-0.2839128673,
-0.5739039183,
0.0343373753,
0.7196317911,
-0.2735021412,
-0.3807569146,
0.7515560985,
0.4141559303,
0.166903913,
-0.1060562804,
-0.6424453855,
0.333970964,
-0.0425002389,
-0.1824453324,
0.3959446549,
0.4640791118,
-0.0949277952,
0.7281532884,
0.7963247299,
-0.0678165331,
0.1312414557,
-0.1225964129,
1.3250733614,
-0.4088639319,
-0.6506743431,
-0.7419310808,
0.1238521338,
0.0781502351,
-0.0281517059,
0.6252596974,
0.2524356842,
0.9614486098,
0.0154589433,
0.6117123365,
0.1271984726,
0.3891579211,
-0.9386385679,
0.5097407699,
-0.2894994617,
0.5586295724,
-0.340696007,
-0.9977529645,
-0.2708894014,
0.5137896538,
-0.0230886918,
-0.0200590026,
0.6145936251,
0.7856390476,
-0.2065598816,
0.1134744361,
0.1029298455,
0.3215928078,
0.2619532347,
0.6285081506,
0.5461505055,
-0.2151922286,
0.6652309299,
-0.0742328614,
-0.1486504078,
-0.0834191367,
-0.7378783226,
-1.043004632,
-0.2900567651,
-0.14115569,
-0.7200395465,
0.282818228,
0.9434276223,
0.6917034388,
-0.812480092,
-0.1343901455,
-0.3210819662,
0.2423746884,
-0.1076500788,
-0.1547800601,
0.7102253437,
-0.4625250995,
-0.7804165483,
0.5274130106,
0.505135119,
0.039300032,
-0.0764138401,
-0.3403637707,
-0.0388232209,
0.2140297145,
0.4907797277,
0.2330626994,
-0.638350904,
-0.5756777525,
-0.0760632157,
-0.0712527707,
0.192485407,
0.9809328914,
-0.7066310048,
0.583843708,
0.7602448463,
0.9847869873,
0.7601415515,
0.0404983386,
0.5357086658,
-0.6694940329,
0.1437383443,
0.0839379951,
0.3149241805,
0.2927128077,
-0.4721279442,
0.5495987535,
0.539042592,
0.0556067228,
-0.8186649084,
0.399215579,
-0.7558760047,
-0.347612828,
0.9272085428,
-0.6278635859,
-0.2735388279,
-0.4984344542,
-0.2956018448,
0.2855689824,
-0.2677394748,
0.6121739149,
0.6506729722,
-0.4594570398,
-0.363042444,
-0.1741175056,
0.4562235475,
0.4790237248,
-0.7621427774,
0.3572661877,
0.367829144,
0.2723534703,
0.1857312173,
0.8698777556,
0.1170003116,
0.1341482997,
0.3881601393,
-0.3497292101,
-0.0702619702,
-0.4262982607,
-0.1194435507,
0.4223242998,
-0.1262997091,
-0.0341307074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12279v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12279v2
|
Key ingredients for effective zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer in generative tasks
| 2024-02-19T16:43:57 | 2024-04-22T17:32:00 |
Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer enables a multilingual pretrained
language model, finetuned on a task in one language, make predictions for this
task in other languages. While being broadly studied for natural language
understanding tasks, the described setting is understudied for generation.
Previous works notice a frequent problem of generation in a wrong language and
propose approaches to address it, usually using mT5 as a backbone model. In
this work we compare various approaches proposed from the literature in unified
settings, also including alternative backbone models, namely mBART and
NLLB-200. We first underline the importance of tuning learning rate used for
finetuning, which helps to substantially alleviate the problem of generation in
the wrong language. Then, we show that with careful learning rate tuning, the
simple full finetuning of the model acts as a very strong baseline and
alternative approaches bring only marginal improvements. Finally, we find that
mBART performs similarly to mT5 of the same size, and NLLB-200 can be
competitive in some cases. Our final zero-shot models reach the performance of
the approach based on data translation which is usually considered as an upper
baseline for zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in generation.
|
[
-0.4159438312,
-0.5638544559,
0.4249288738,
0.1334919184,
-0.2665116191,
0.0788577646,
-0.1364967823,
-0.5351928473,
-0.344599545,
0.4151248336,
-0.4946381748,
-0.2834641635,
-0.4440097809,
0.0692050681,
-0.3870549202,
1.113800168,
-0.1657432765,
0.1251260638,
-0.0590149462,
-0.2734092176,
-0.7109978199,
-0.4432398677,
-0.7455999851,
-0.7673715949,
0.5816630721,
0.5270674825,
0.351367861,
0.3861198425,
0.3865334094,
0.1114532799,
0.1550376713,
-0.1802612841,
-0.6694284081,
-0.1243539304,
-0.48855111,
-0.5770784616,
-0.4589128196,
-0.1321761459,
0.3222902715,
1.0756310225,
-0.0671214983,
0.2077873051,
0.1742997169,
0.562715888,
-0.6445502043,
0.0182156358,
-0.7608172894,
0.3930675387,
-0.168542996,
-0.350091368,
-0.5700005889,
-0.0148156891,
-0.0874204934,
-0.7807362676,
0.5741251707,
-0.0281167198,
0.9131544232,
-0.0539484918,
-0.5904952884,
-0.0194287375,
-0.8858668804,
0.9505271912,
-0.5759363174,
0.5521509647,
0.3380969167,
0.4294748604,
0.1239840612,
-0.4049328864,
-0.5480922461,
-0.1385627836,
0.0398996584,
0.3797022104,
-0.2811685205,
0.0002018703,
0.1454981863,
0.3037831187,
-0.6343251467,
0.3079566956,
-0.5111569762,
0.0057737534,
0.3887411356,
0.1123944148,
0.3098272979,
-0.4409132898,
-0.5243404508,
0.019789502,
-0.9171600342,
0.0038785739,
0.2428290844,
0.4863063991,
-0.1311149001,
0.4861625135,
-0.4925289154,
1.0407500267,
0.4016185105,
0.01322171,
0.0208552796,
-0.7059177756,
-0.4348785877,
0.0315534808,
0.5882861614,
0.280182153,
0.5491843224,
-0.5770664811,
0.0132075483,
0.0035615475,
0.3523198962,
-0.7690777183,
-0.1875881255,
-0.0374053195,
-0.0513663702,
-0.2891245782,
-0.1718417406,
-0.4480167925,
0.1077323779,
-0.5612350702,
0.7178317308,
-0.8176547289,
-0.2261891812,
0.1287001073,
-0.0705610588,
0.5420430899,
0.3878384829,
-1.140253067,
-0.0711441785,
0.3902802169,
0.5689679384,
-0.0630913004,
-0.4030651748,
-0.4336705804,
0.3183827996,
-0.5975505114,
0.8016837835,
-0.0435382165,
-0.2797622979,
-0.2763722241,
-0.0699314922,
-0.4243301749,
-0.3597518504,
0.4369933009,
-0.2843731046,
0.5362667441,
-0.4202573597,
-0.3500826359,
-0.3886130154,
0.2173939645,
-0.3437772095,
0.7399145961,
0.3420077562,
-0.7363607287,
0.6665312052,
-0.7638676763,
-0.7457645535,
0.0959637985,
0.1177922115,
-0.070740886,
0.2278757542,
0.3179189861,
0.7409906983,
-0.1458729655,
0.2675935626,
-0.1830173284,
-0.2808451056,
-0.0731038153,
-0.5368590355,
0.99587816,
0.3198530078,
-0.4706510603,
-0.2693143785,
-0.9225253463,
0.015424123,
0.2093632668,
-0.2885133624,
-0.3280111551,
-0.541654408,
-0.0178435482,
0.2876006663,
-0.1643107831,
-0.6205645204,
0.0315106176,
-0.3314577639,
0.0791193321,
0.4806004763,
0.0121183665,
0.6479259729,
-0.3516250849,
0.5898638368,
0.2259740978,
0.0034493096,
-0.2427552789,
-0.1533291489,
-0.9656872749,
0.0499525443,
0.5347795486,
0.5991357565,
-1.2834521532,
-0.0726798922,
-0.3420633078,
-0.3840687573,
-0.8804206848,
0.297041744,
0.6128829122,
0.7601794004,
0.5359255672,
-0.3905851245,
-0.4250872731,
-0.6598080993,
-0.2831491232,
0.0906881019,
-0.1416898221,
-0.0747636408,
0.2367785573,
0.214735657,
0.7832795978,
-0.1518332958,
-0.3103680611,
-0.6114755273,
0.6887577176,
-0.0151709011,
0.6042772532,
0.9297122955,
-0.4910044074,
-0.8175011873,
0.537322104,
-0.8915233612,
-0.0637460053,
-0.312428087,
-0.2134414017,
0.427762866,
0.1817760766,
-0.5031578541,
0.2442574054,
0.6287596822,
-0.0694704577,
0.3164178431,
-0.1099367142,
0.2748276591,
-1.2931867838,
0.2501968741,
-0.079860948,
-0.3373289704,
-1.1381731033,
0.1376789659,
0.1604286581,
-0.0091066882,
-0.7377102375,
0.5148990154,
-0.6517187357,
0.0436992161,
-0.1559973955,
0.2156792581,
0.0899730474,
0.6276901364,
0.0915161371,
0.6224302649,
0.5657164454,
-0.5239037275,
0.2240462005,
0.0375231914,
-0.3603697419,
1.0869519711,
-0.4511582553,
0.1443957686,
-0.2210168093,
-0.0995472521,
-0.8156996369,
0.1052699685,
0.2559696734,
-0.6107649803,
0.6497510672,
-0.1910282671,
-0.1968465447,
-0.111063838,
0.0002653126,
0.3405862749,
0.5259968638,
-0.4452444911,
0.2635757625,
-0.2704094946,
-0.1252859682,
-0.7584665418,
-0.8666610122,
0.1223195717,
-0.2176999301,
-0.4558410645,
0.2725322545,
0.057812158,
0.0960944071,
0.0192629248,
-0.0643739924,
0.0201180633,
0.0379912965,
-0.0846567377,
0.2237481773,
-0.4328815043,
-0.2192478031,
-0.0452696867,
-0.2955663502,
-0.3626311123,
-0.3033227324,
0.2954229116,
0.2242212147,
-0.3192963898,
-0.2296656519,
0.2252901345,
0.5674780011,
-0.1706410795,
0.7687727213,
0.9276428223,
-0.0173326638,
-0.1701555848,
-0.4829463959,
0.0361661501,
-0.3380138874,
0.1424749345,
-0.640055716,
-0.6806814671,
0.4077769518,
0.1038587913,
0.1920012832,
0.5699135661,
0.4801442623,
-0.1526543051,
0.8770419359,
1.0147942305,
-0.0651182011,
0.4413959682,
-0.2870880067,
0.2922320962,
-0.8710172772,
-0.1380895674,
-0.4058584869,
-0.1047272533,
-0.1992068142,
-0.3698241413,
0.0815735757,
0.4516519904,
-0.0036891829,
0.8054885268,
-0.0375146791,
0.2303434163,
0.5586292744,
-0.268456161,
0.506640017,
0.193267256,
-0.5327047706,
0.0435668379,
-1.2849664688,
-0.0428365692,
1.1457449198,
-0.0587024093,
0.7177722454,
0.1289197356,
0.5501516461,
-0.1701533943,
0.4522990286,
-0.5076166987,
0.3180659115,
-0.3069497347,
-0.7446448207,
-0.3073830009,
-0.6482588649,
-1.1244354248,
0.4360823631,
-0.2037875056,
-0.5270915031,
0.1663281024,
0.1160720438,
-0.4336154759,
0.4600066543,
-0.7442156672,
1.0068087578,
-0.259986788,
-0.3234869838,
0.0350400954,
-0.6744226813,
0.5422533154,
-0.2590575516,
0.1566525102,
-0.1416187584,
0.6575163007,
0.3280959129,
0.0222698878,
0.7240890861,
-0.1586590558,
-0.208316192,
0.0633586198,
0.219009161,
0.181138441,
-0.4678041041,
0.0040302393,
0.20841524,
-0.0152850635,
-0.4782763422,
-0.6058659554,
0.4191620052,
-0.68505162,
-0.4239361882,
-0.0620995909,
-0.7525159121,
-0.2025348693,
0.1474889964,
0.5962110758,
0.4672167599,
-0.2871593833,
0.3829373717,
0.4502096474,
-0.1393713206,
0.4141372442,
0.7299409509,
-0.1887622476,
-0.0048349923,
0.9808044434,
0.4339604378,
0.7731124163,
0.6280257106,
-0.1281475425,
-0.1034862101,
-0.4302980006,
-0.9404164553,
-0.000931897,
-0.5925571918,
-0.3845846355,
-0.5915336609,
-0.241251111,
-0.6386370659,
-0.4104140401,
-0.3790035844,
-0.5650699735,
-0.3318997324,
-0.3158991039,
0.1854475439,
0.3446691334,
-0.3846617043,
0.2486776859,
-0.7437057495,
0.6028003693,
0.2020241618,
0.0896534324,
0.1202595457,
-0.7426030636,
-0.3388301432,
0.1691090465,
-0.3009486794,
-0.7635533214,
0.3091431856,
0.2085542381,
0.7726375461,
0.3849974275,
0.146688357,
1.0082916021,
-0.411526829,
0.5593428016,
0.4827110469,
-0.92342484,
0.3523547947,
-0.3164757192,
0.6224771142,
0.5352761149,
0.594828248,
-0.7791255713,
-0.4685147107,
-0.5663813353,
-0.6944180131,
0.7405804992,
0.2745642364,
0.0398023315,
0.2805906832,
0.0248404294,
0.3726538122,
0.0812460929,
-0.9289035201,
0.0608711019,
-0.384021312,
-0.0535324812,
-0.2771463394,
0.1221843809,
0.0342684463,
-0.3470165431,
0.5492475033,
-0.2120798528,
0.1282770634,
0.0858804882,
-0.3899315596,
-0.4451905489,
0.5345740914,
0.5317972302,
0.6951363087,
-0.1927781254,
0.1486736834,
0.4691938758,
-0.1810189039,
0.2651461363,
-0.0399606749,
-0.463889271,
-0.0193073098,
0.4769554734,
1.1179398298,
0.4064895511,
-0.1146001667,
0.3159358501,
0.3155609071,
-0.4511424899,
0.1808234751,
0.1148832813,
0.0604604818,
-0.0522748791,
0.175472334,
0.0347411111,
-0.0705001056,
-0.7508807778,
0.0485000573,
0.4301167428,
-0.448518157,
-0.5641869307,
0.7133731246,
0.121238865,
0.1197030768,
0.6435724497,
-0.2295988649,
-0.3108198643,
0.4293804169,
0.7715258598,
0.7055696249,
-0.4399630725,
0.4596683085,
0.3448056579,
0.3420172632,
0.1487750411,
0.0159975588,
-0.4075407088,
-0.9226293564,
-0.7610250711,
-0.7879549265,
-0.2790560424,
-0.0283091404,
-0.806168139,
0.0446674004,
0.0262048021,
0.027102286,
0.0843722448,
-0.047307089,
-0.8923524022,
0.1581198275,
0.086749211,
0.60270226,
-0.8736618161,
1.1086703539,
0.6271140575,
-0.6676799059,
-0.8426116109,
-0.2706657648,
-0.1374561191,
-0.8912748694,
0.7415055037,
-0.2519191802,
-0.1352339685,
0.2239271551,
-0.154029429,
-0.6232617497,
1.2235537767,
0.5360187292,
-0.3755593598,
-0.1294701397,
0.4439962208,
0.5135223866,
-0.1622314006,
-0.0299507529,
0.4636832178,
0.4580303729,
0.555678606,
-1.1444004774,
-0.1067903489,
0.0846499577,
0.0633747801,
0.2300837934,
-0.4355448186,
0.8377501369,
-0.2509379983,
-0.4258660674,
0.0950542986,
0.4093153477,
0.0372584313,
0.3327841163,
0.1225109026,
0.710981071,
0.2483972013,
0.0369418487,
0.9903296828,
-0.2808350921,
0.3823227286,
0.9055335522,
-0.3312492669,
0.7927543521,
0.5364339352,
-0.0639110506,
0.3069682121,
0.3426978886,
0.0125191035,
0.578360796,
-0.051879812,
-0.1396833062,
-0.0977796465,
-0.1464616358,
-0.3926382363,
0.4622340202,
0.0579252131,
-0.0968858078,
-0.5786564946,
0.3725818396,
0.2728427052,
-0.2034915686,
-0.3723194599,
0.7824949622,
0.2282389253,
-0.7887022495,
0.8577340245,
0.098543331,
0.6175305843,
-0.5825895667,
0.0227964744,
-0.5226918459,
0.1350677162,
-0.0917900056,
-0.6726370454,
0.4070394635,
0.1193416342,
-0.0960486457,
-0.5620827079,
0.8993703127,
-0.6784222722,
-0.5748380423,
0.3071084023,
0.8194711208,
0.0715076402,
0.0501670726,
-0.5629399419,
-0.4713997841,
0.139160037,
-0.0371421985,
0.5875955224,
0.6696615219,
-0.0030681149,
0.3586013317,
0.7658784389,
0.1164796129,
0.2687325776,
0.1196984127,
0.3791151345,
-0.610608995,
-0.1357759088,
-0.5297221541,
0.4934492409,
0.2511250079,
-0.1607408077,
1.0067423582,
0.2369557172,
1.2481687069,
-0.2264565974,
0.6668993235,
-0.0400860459,
0.2756573856,
-0.6730186939,
0.7794837356,
-0.6328286529,
-0.2711033225,
-0.30290398,
-0.9426562786,
-0.4936247468,
0.5234606862,
-0.2171382606,
0.071366325,
0.6763786674,
0.5087124705,
-0.3770222664,
-0.2679093778,
0.8858730197,
0.1732372642,
-0.0179746542,
0.8198097944,
0.7147451043,
-0.4241954684,
0.6115620732,
-0.3939213455,
0.1244582012,
-0.1258473992,
-0.8802816868,
-0.7880702615,
-0.3943486214,
-0.1682964265,
0.1936739683,
0.265206337,
0.3937712312,
0.9129831195,
-0.7481911182,
-0.3892018795,
-0.1495810002,
-0.1149876118,
-0.4164579511,
-0.2353380322,
0.0949649885,
-0.5335204005,
-0.5956529975,
0.3349872231,
0.3369616568,
0.1839445829,
-0.261372745,
0.0262467638,
-0.2322889417,
0.0986193344,
0.8937827349,
0.5068482757,
-0.6640452743,
-0.4074498713,
0.0774795339,
-0.0746087059,
0.1073984653,
0.7542570233,
-0.7951215506,
0.396237433,
0.5187294483,
0.6028020382,
0.7063305974,
0.102261208,
0.836540103,
-0.8315982819,
0.1112961918,
-0.1702150255,
0.2020762265,
0.5245015621,
-0.2212441415,
0.656260848,
0.3339680135,
-0.264691323,
-0.6101038456,
0.2096157074,
-0.8874570727,
-0.3592509031,
0.9013056755,
-0.2587790191,
-0.0235547777,
-0.2132295668,
-0.1102675423,
0.5148225427,
0.1756313145,
0.5760837793,
0.6584070325,
-0.2407099754,
-0.347635448,
-0.8796898723,
0.2604451776,
0.8063878417,
-0.7327510715,
-0.0761916339,
0.2879593372,
0.3560240865,
0.1207336858,
0.5966620445,
-0.0849575773,
0.1826618165,
0.1055297256,
0.2714081407,
-0.0302860569,
-0.5554894209,
-0.3303319812,
0.2497513741,
0.0319384113,
-0.0974374115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12275v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12275v2
|
WorldCoder, a Model-Based LLM Agent: Building World Models by Writing Code and Interacting with the Environment
| 2024-02-19T16:39:18 | 2024-05-26T04:24:04 |
Hao Tang, Darren Key, Kevin Ellis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We give a model-based agent that builds a Python program representing its
knowledge of the world based on its interactions with the environment. The
world model tries to explain its interactions, while also being optimistic
about what reward it can achieve. We define this optimism as a logical
constraint between a program and a planner. We study our agent on gridworlds,
and on task planning, finding our approach is more sample-efficient compared to
deep RL, more compute-efficient compared to ReAct-style agents, and that it can
transfer its knowledge across environments by editing its code.
|
[
-0.3154580295,
-0.5987984538,
0.3998183608,
0.1262063384,
0.2382687181,
0.0574671328,
0.1646732837,
-0.5499131083,
-0.0509917885,
0.4989874065,
-0.6204947233,
-0.388517946,
-0.3345539272,
-0.0067942119,
0.0039912811,
0.8281958699,
-0.0060960646,
-0.2862400711,
-0.4396244586,
0.2562085092,
-0.0809829608,
-0.6961554289,
-0.4093322158,
-0.8917996287,
0.475132525,
0.2043155581,
0.9662724137,
0.6282582879,
0.5662989616,
0.3396461606,
-0.1497170925,
0.2007573843,
-0.4767594337,
0.3911929131,
-0.2880446911,
-0.6106374264,
-0.3345999718,
-0.1031226218,
-0.10657534,
0.0510794409,
-0.0808704495,
0.1739128977,
-0.1729389429,
0.3637908101,
-0.6996952891,
0.5396636724,
-0.4331474602,
0.5003679395,
0.5281348228,
-0.333891511,
-0.2362510115,
-0.2570836544,
-0.3705368042,
-0.7499701381,
0.035287898,
0.0375293531,
0.5766541958,
0.553824842,
-0.5209896564,
-0.2698525488,
-1.0892671347,
0.5855658054,
-0.5362080336,
0.2486944944,
0.1003475189,
0.3787933886,
-0.5671523809,
-0.6594758034,
-0.7198940516,
-0.0939160585,
0.1289470196,
0.071139425,
-0.0361608937,
0.1922155917,
0.5603384376,
0.1426561922,
-0.3433109224,
-0.1225914583,
-0.3933550715,
-0.3696425855,
0.8138585687,
0.5826807618,
0.4799403548,
-0.1841889024,
-0.2639189363,
0.0397801995,
-0.6242336631,
0.2756868005,
0.2727577686,
0.2584967315,
-0.0853241161,
0.8118599057,
-0.2278877199,
0.8066281676,
-0.2983576655,
-0.7052584887,
-0.1807755828,
0.0802372694,
0.0152038271,
-0.0119705917,
0.318351686,
0.7190846205,
0.1624279171,
-0.3066229224,
-0.7639422417,
0.3946702778,
0.4626413584,
-0.8388875723,
-0.1590958387,
0.3041656911,
-0.640822053,
-0.4279343784,
0.0784795582,
-0.3780210614,
-0.5590575337,
-0.2883448005,
0.2821507454,
-0.1323370785,
-0.1179871559,
-0.0762067661,
-0.398997575,
0.333109498,
0.3688807786,
-0.4988298714,
0.3415243328,
0.9951326847,
0.8660350442,
0.1132141128,
-0.5617948174,
-0.371371001,
0.2371010333,
-0.4290212691,
0.9551978111,
-0.4491173923,
-0.6022369266,
0.0401447788,
-0.1355067641,
0.2425186634,
-0.3043533862,
0.1265654117,
-0.7396459579,
-0.2871538997,
-0.1165688261,
-0.7147480845,
-0.181591168,
0.5709691644,
-0.7683572769,
0.956620574,
0.3080450296,
-0.5867497325,
0.3600645661,
-0.7089281082,
-0.1804146022,
0.0452901945,
0.1374784261,
0.008431416,
0.0407443233,
0.0637823194,
0.5277110934,
-0.077765137,
0.1930089742,
-0.2309596986,
-0.6722427011,
0.4846768379,
0.0752052143,
0.4522805214,
0.7043629289,
-0.0064241462,
0.1126768962,
-0.7436207533,
0.327406764,
-0.0272143371,
-0.6246552467,
-0.0804451108,
0.3629003167,
0.0603513569,
0.4504784644,
0.3111912906,
-0.7283110619,
0.5630031228,
-0.3086540997,
0.617818892,
0.5839955807,
0.1854499578,
0.4712405503,
-0.8498325348,
0.8312368989,
-0.2919851542,
0.0733879805,
-0.0763234273,
-0.4754044116,
-0.7390494347,
-0.0760561526,
-0.1754844934,
0.7427892685,
-0.6195610762,
0.1213007793,
-0.2987751365,
-0.6730993986,
-0.2332641333,
0.1696312129,
0.3116557002,
0.0460272096,
-0.0140725886,
0.2284701914,
-0.9495452642,
-0.7464500666,
-0.1136645898,
-0.1246078759,
0.4361406565,
0.1874746829,
0.9180033207,
-0.441598475,
1.2015782595,
-0.5896478891,
0.1101777181,
-0.7682390809,
-0.4226040244,
0.4676557183,
0.5179769397,
0.1062141433,
-0.8542791605,
-0.7061564326,
0.099364087,
-0.9151217937,
0.1757111698,
-0.0979427472,
-0.1324266642,
0.0939689204,
0.610218823,
-0.9135133028,
0.6190713048,
0.3729489446,
-0.3653253913,
0.5725098848,
-0.4189032316,
0.0512597263,
-0.9699906707,
-0.0966573954,
-0.1291614175,
-0.3422988653,
-0.7674122453,
0.4728960395,
-0.0528839305,
-0.3842385113,
-0.6004887223,
0.7268612385,
-0.5171524286,
-0.2241561562,
-0.475504905,
-0.2351084799,
-0.0003625376,
0.4842682481,
0.0643424019,
1.0411316156,
0.5134211779,
-0.9233973622,
0.7230209112,
0.3500085473,
-0.4107356369,
0.4035410881,
-0.6029999852,
0.4227719605,
-0.1855947077,
0.2037478536,
-0.4227358997,
-0.2445292324,
0.1102424785,
-0.2767495215,
-0.0731671378,
-0.3295042813,
-0.5473150015,
-0.6446794271,
-0.0168721937,
-0.0104794437,
0.6648448706,
-0.6524160504,
0.5307758451,
0.4372937381,
0.2611732483,
-0.4418800473,
-0.8436837196,
0.1790973246,
-0.1124013215,
-0.5910864472,
0.3689212799,
-0.0872725248,
-0.8330169916,
0.2476776391,
-0.0926219225,
-0.1825657636,
0.1499112397,
0.6230552197,
0.1794713885,
-0.0796819851,
-0.1255915612,
-0.3403454423,
-0.2133410275,
0.2600663006,
-0.3496880233,
0.4498594701,
-0.1360093653,
-0.2985792458,
-0.3408905566,
0.2239083201,
0.5795118809,
-0.0234785732,
0.6270198226,
-0.0467600673,
-0.3817494512,
-0.6577758789,
-0.1671743542,
0.3159207106,
-0.5481978059,
0.4379096925,
-0.8136620522,
-0.6658058167,
0.7624932528,
0.0121548055,
-0.0718829557,
0.180030033,
0.541206181,
0.1408138871,
0.9076556563,
0.8940420151,
-0.1217794418,
0.2483330816,
-0.4904047251,
0.1429872513,
-0.876155436,
-0.4476565719,
-0.238445282,
-0.3457642794,
-0.3254667819,
-0.6850392818,
0.1214064434,
-0.1007843837,
-0.6176857948,
0.3180352449,
-0.8500154614,
0.6977257133,
0.6706063151,
0.0375089161,
0.1789658517,
-0.3160664141,
0.0440826342,
0.1205887944,
-0.8777698278,
-0.6627690196,
1.1164442301,
0.0439848416,
1.2989499569,
0.1179882586,
0.9920786023,
0.6088910699,
0.2247434855,
-0.7509791255,
0.6729207635,
0.586961031,
-0.6590405703,
-0.0762653947,
-0.0688583478,
-0.9047852755,
0.5270255208,
-0.1553650498,
-0.8478768468,
-0.0630181804,
0.1746827662,
-0.2815329432,
0.6778652668,
-0.3723404109,
0.7605950236,
-0.1770151854,
-0.360842824,
-0.1417199522,
-0.3139290512,
0.1827442497,
0.3967452943,
0.2910845876,
-0.1198678687,
-0.2506600916,
0.2757649422,
-0.6720204353,
0.6843582988,
-0.3506470323,
-0.2034143955,
0.7225154042,
0.402374655,
0.8374434114,
-0.0135447932,
-0.3067516387,
-0.2712224126,
0.0208632629,
-0.2525958717,
-0.6223849058,
0.5906164646,
-1.0572372675,
-0.6951784492,
-0.5404780507,
-1.0582575798,
0.1133264974,
0.0450633019,
0.1533462107,
0.3724842966,
-0.656270802,
-0.2860879004,
0.4034953713,
-0.2912714183,
0.4915732145,
0.3984776735,
-0.6112556458,
-0.1610796601,
0.9554678798,
0.006973397,
0.1016211808,
0.5937868357,
-0.1106045917,
-0.0243775696,
-0.3258211017,
-0.081071876,
-0.2709836066,
-1.0460633039,
-0.3075569272,
-0.6527377367,
-0.5726035237,
-0.2917802036,
-0.5654649734,
-0.2754207253,
-0.2955433726,
0.0311535522,
-0.0445358008,
0.437924087,
1.2298994064,
-0.2014707476,
0.3480713665,
-0.7513456345,
0.2518191338,
0.3434273899,
0.0830975771,
-0.1425417364,
-0.0867736265,
-0.4740369022,
0.0026125081,
-0.3197895885,
-0.7182105184,
0.813916862,
0.268024683,
0.8668631315,
0.0934661999,
0.0911741704,
0.5926389694,
-0.2925602496,
0.8541846871,
-0.15220882,
-0.9397981763,
0.6488500834,
-0.1722165644,
0.3286866248,
0.0162945986,
-0.1525275558,
-0.776048243,
-0.5899884105,
-0.5732638836,
-0.3646555841,
0.8555631638,
0.0279413778,
0.1430893242,
0.1651190072,
0.6745810509,
0.0128307641,
0.1567851901,
-0.9229256511,
-0.1461144239,
-0.4492595196,
-0.001033814,
-0.2539740503,
-0.3503284454,
-0.1686874628,
-0.1187227517,
0.5412055254,
-0.3004710674,
0.5806675553,
0.3701671064,
-0.6059974432,
0.0069608679,
0.4726608396,
0.4387497008,
0.5953944325,
-0.2203035504,
0.4012740254,
0.0886562467,
-0.2768829763,
0.6647890806,
-0.0857296661,
-0.3026554286,
-0.4931795299,
0.5292513967,
0.7494981289,
-0.2015221119,
-0.8324275613,
0.3625827134,
0.0990734622,
-0.3902605474,
-0.3501663208,
0.6176957488,
0.2568026483,
0.6486431956,
0.1090877876,
0.2342490107,
0.1751680374,
-0.4024921358,
0.0955241621,
0.2439844906,
-0.4407482743,
-0.3309663832,
0.7925339937,
0.2313469797,
-0.7268757224,
0.8218064308,
-0.5361979604,
-0.878821671,
1.2719883919,
1.1313406229,
0.6697274446,
0.2701335847,
0.2167719156,
0.3111945093,
0.4114496708,
-0.055344861,
0.8397034407,
0.0406725146,
-1.0624437332,
-0.4725978374,
-0.4908330739,
-0.520915091,
-0.3191126287,
-0.5363671184,
-0.1587702036,
-0.659843564,
-0.1420923024,
-0.4134518504,
0.041403532,
-0.8240715265,
0.1413864642,
0.2886604965,
1.0332458019,
-0.5828965306,
0.9597300887,
1.1701396704,
-0.2225592136,
-0.7470242381,
-0.2078236192,
0.2307175249,
-0.9921036959,
1.0581837893,
0.4533135295,
-0.0425802432,
0.0084099974,
-0.7395262718,
-1.2571618557,
1.2377450466,
0.2060677111,
-0.3820797205,
0.1745291799,
-0.0591118,
0.6353112459,
-0.7276220322,
0.0059490679,
0.2100572884,
0.445809871,
-0.2155744582,
-0.5886563659,
0.166605711,
-0.795840919,
0.4892173111,
0.2301479876,
-0.6644912958,
0.9230211377,
-0.7526633143,
-0.090879634,
0.1477757245,
0.7825978994,
0.1646072119,
0.180139631,
0.3205855191,
0.5549575686,
0.6952636838,
0.1610693187,
1.356045723,
-0.8872935772,
0.4886172712,
0.860044837,
-0.4246997833,
0.493655175,
0.3317921758,
-0.323079139,
0.6494088173,
0.6532180905,
-0.1831745207,
0.6206296682,
0.2436473817,
-0.2617760599,
-0.513975203,
-0.0983717516,
-0.0869405344,
0.3503953516,
0.2178245336,
0.185349986,
-0.0352582037,
0.1146523729,
-0.3445043266,
0.0621215291,
-0.5206848383,
0.64943856,
0.111041598,
-0.7919817567,
0.222920239,
-0.0053827139,
0.6435279846,
-0.4210960567,
-0.1517422199,
-0.0971175209,
0.5192750692,
-0.3762384057,
-0.7448890805,
0.4142290354,
-0.1339023858,
-0.2258487493,
-0.2853746712,
0.987606585,
-0.1254595369,
-0.2889685631,
0.1891989708,
0.5791662931,
0.1953986883,
0.0503665321,
-0.8759158254,
0.1093308032,
-0.0177287087,
-0.4273471832,
0.2296853513,
0.3853436112,
0.1402089745,
1.3954969645,
0.5739785433,
0.1473790705,
-0.0069213724,
-0.3101460934,
0.8473792672,
-1.0734512806,
-0.789981544,
-0.778544724,
0.4062007368,
0.0881513879,
-0.1556377262,
0.7554965615,
0.8549719453,
0.5546163321,
-0.0668152347,
1.1899335384,
-0.4619373977,
0.0897721946,
-0.3759082556,
0.4086206555,
-0.4735779762,
0.2603339255,
0.0717803761,
-1.0638872385,
-0.1600492299,
0.8338377476,
0.0374445356,
-0.2321918458,
0.5939056277,
1.2513955832,
0.1456158608,
-0.1943519413,
0.3954601288,
-0.010171826,
0.4641567767,
0.714296937,
1.3883582354,
-0.1233926117,
0.4634597898,
-0.4312854111,
0.058414869,
0.0234674755,
-0.6311946511,
-0.8964404464,
-0.0948303789,
-0.2042911053,
-0.6525586843,
0.2334792018,
1.1802520752,
0.6158841252,
-0.4730510712,
-0.544549644,
-0.168180719,
0.438688457,
-0.4004480541,
-0.1467886716,
-0.0537037663,
-0.4362935722,
-0.7115157843,
0.4068071842,
0.2044700682,
0.0472513102,
-0.4821840525,
-0.6767632365,
0.1935594231,
0.090410687,
0.447175622,
0.4251564741,
-0.6252869368,
-0.2775018215,
-0.1297747195,
-0.4937853217,
0.0965991169,
0.8671839833,
-0.7531144023,
0.3925926387,
0.331343323,
0.2694418132,
0.5736777186,
-0.1884658337,
0.8461999893,
-0.2407557964,
0.5264031887,
0.0520769991,
0.3009842634,
0.2430320531,
-0.6829116344,
0.6720285416,
0.1136808321,
-0.910394609,
-0.495683074,
0.2128252983,
-0.7673063874,
-0.5261157155,
1.3693891764,
-0.197445631,
-0.4346654117,
-0.1975152194,
-0.2584010065,
-0.079352349,
-0.4562424719,
0.418258667,
0.379445225,
-0.5267454982,
-0.017146891,
-0.571131587,
0.449167639,
-0.3359414339,
-0.7494279742,
-0.2414152473,
0.5984568,
0.3596140146,
-0.0045662308,
0.9761624932,
0.469804287,
0.2670044899,
0.7551621795,
0.7870348096,
-0.4792295098,
-0.1394223571,
-0.0360379815,
0.2173805833,
0.3860472739,
0.0548591278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12424v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12424v4
|
Tables as Texts or Images: Evaluating the Table Reasoning Ability of LLMs and MLLMs
| 2024-02-19T16:34:50 | 2024-06-06T03:02:25 |
Naihao Deng, Zhenjie Sun, Ruiqi He, Aman Sikka, Yulong Chen, Lin Ma, Yue Zhang, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we investigate the effectiveness of various LLMs in
interpreting tabular data through different prompting strategies and data
formats. Our analyses extend across six benchmarks for table-related tasks such
as question-answering and fact-checking. We introduce for the first time the
assessment of LLMs' performance on image-based table representations.
Specifically, we compare five text-based and three image-based table
representations, demonstrating the role of representation and prompting on LLM
performance. Our study provides insights into the effective use of LLMs on
table-related tasks.
|
[
-0.2658611536,
-0.9977366328,
0.9287936687,
0.2060822845,
-0.3982545435,
-0.0070378534,
0.1400134116,
-0.4183819294,
-0.1584105492,
0.5840138793,
-0.4837322235,
-0.7788318396,
-0.4446210265,
0.3683643937,
-0.6981267333,
0.7020953298,
-0.3166573048,
0.4226658046,
-0.9255235195,
-0.094866097,
-0.7141224146,
-0.3114331663,
-0.5644481778,
-0.6558196545,
0.8534558415,
0.699221015,
0.8326752782,
0.7590031624,
0.7166380882,
0.2060676515,
0.1818436384,
0.2244238257,
-0.2004259378,
0.289596796,
0.0979908928,
-0.7632458806,
-0.262842387,
0.1256369799,
0.5306266546,
0.4573739171,
-0.0627123863,
0.3530155122,
0.129230693,
1.1868560314,
-0.3068175912,
0.4284409583,
-0.6759780645,
0.4799290001,
-0.0865605846,
-0.4219202399,
-0.7605707645,
-0.6733564734,
-0.0133312158,
-0.5091559887,
-0.1080050245,
0.4319366813,
0.5297188163,
0.2378533483,
-0.486762315,
-0.7702435851,
-0.6195127368,
0.4790415466,
-0.3319408894,
0.6353000998,
0.220414266,
0.3482549787,
-0.3050097823,
-1.0148973465,
-0.6274574995,
-0.6679853797,
-0.3314889371,
0.095220305,
-0.0242256671,
-0.1376115829,
0.6980580688,
0.2760241032,
-0.7239801884,
0.0407107659,
-0.1344391406,
-0.0302791987,
0.3826875091,
0.4058225751,
0.4420526326,
-0.0664879233,
-0.5098487139,
-0.0959480107,
-0.8157376051,
0.1275934279,
0.007860641,
0.0208302941,
-0.0374267176,
0.8794127703,
0.0567105412,
1.030502677,
-0.4256645739,
-0.2295601368,
-0.1799932718,
-0.142548427,
-0.3954640031,
-0.0862679407,
0.4662876129,
0.6439802647,
0.2510244548,
-0.1933299601,
-0.21634534,
0.280834347,
0.1310963482,
-0.2487283349,
0.0483065993,
0.0467207544,
-0.6506619453,
-0.0818542764,
-0.0387626998,
-0.9225358963,
-0.7694566846,
-0.4660562575,
0.678637743,
-0.2012475133,
0.3151073158,
-0.2247107029,
-0.3066676259,
0.4392796755,
0.6301885843,
-0.61955446,
0.4303977191,
0.3705789447,
0.7223123312,
-0.5819031,
-0.069776766,
-0.3829250336,
0.2780852318,
-0.6644816995,
1.1267633438,
-0.3711562753,
-0.5234687328,
0.2137075663,
-0.1420440525,
-0.0458419472,
-0.821206212,
0.7032904625,
-0.4735358059,
-0.00308955,
-0.8417731524,
-0.7025418282,
-0.257683605,
0.5223143101,
-1.1629351377,
1.0638229847,
-0.0500487946,
-0.427264154,
0.8410931826,
-0.8759852052,
-0.4502746463,
-0.0556328706,
-0.5620602965,
-0.4593786895,
-0.2018224746,
0.4135541916,
0.7366897464,
-0.3670849204,
-0.051875513,
-0.0165763497,
-0.5156957507,
0.7255393863,
-0.3582582772,
0.2098402083,
0.1540000439,
-0.2106634378,
0.1665701866,
-0.4365805984,
0.0217403248,
0.1702108383,
-0.6512182355,
0.2370889932,
0.3568080664,
-0.1908583194,
-0.077111721,
-0.0234794971,
-0.1292869598,
0.2749510407,
0.2788348794,
0.1408173591,
0.3262304366,
-0.0183809455,
0.2697348297,
-0.6111901999,
0.2529484332,
0.1964066327,
-0.1199846044,
-0.1067778021,
-0.5709959269,
-0.7731391191,
0.1248034835,
0.2492894977,
0.7209358215,
-1.1898293495,
-0.2270251811,
-0.0714764446,
-0.5811578035,
-0.0067283227,
0.1956627369,
0.3358432949,
0.8083692193,
0.4470922053,
-0.0278845411,
-0.3637003005,
-0.8615196347,
-0.5373752117,
-0.1998063624,
0.0760224983,
0.3816917837,
0.6048381925,
0.225357458,
0.6320711374,
-0.1905101091,
-0.2182238549,
-0.5133236647,
0.2507515252,
0.2529767752,
0.3672777414,
0.4215616286,
-0.5566284657,
-0.6585386992,
-0.089586325,
-1.0858899355,
0.0166776888,
-0.3050741255,
0.1025145128,
0.5920477509,
0.5718558431,
-0.5641068816,
0.8347984552,
0.009730963,
-0.5340266228,
0.587189734,
-0.0995892286,
0.4945026338,
-0.1769303977,
0.0804544538,
0.1227733493,
-0.275360465,
-0.7690654993,
-0.3246448934,
0.2156432569,
-0.1726276726,
-0.4681151509,
0.4933632314,
-0.8917945027,
-0.6471501589,
0.0839237347,
0.1785019487,
0.0321357511,
0.2758294046,
0.0789345279,
0.9804466963,
0.424879998,
-0.5285245776,
0.392069608,
0.1387772113,
-0.763061583,
0.7506161332,
-0.5725620389,
0.1796766073,
-0.2967203259,
0.0726510808,
-1.2421789169,
0.0614307374,
0.4481974542,
-0.0816196427,
0.4622230828,
0.1461629272,
-0.6490118504,
-0.5797769427,
-0.3608517945,
-0.3114287853,
0.5081980228,
-0.48797068,
0.6994659901,
0.0502245463,
0.0795755163,
-0.7933052182,
-0.8055157661,
0.2445419729,
-0.380137682,
-0.3826661706,
0.34796983,
0.1576086879,
-0.4856636226,
0.2256824076,
-0.2747886181,
0.0084752338,
-0.1127468273,
0.2937245965,
0.4044646025,
-0.1296927929,
0.0004274012,
-0.2277589142,
0.0532738864,
0.2245960236,
0.2513259053,
0.3166528046,
-0.1500625759,
-0.4936725497,
-0.552836895,
0.1359127313,
0.3276694715,
0.2979578376,
0.7134836316,
0.4973506033,
-0.1790899038,
0.0366100408,
-0.8251126409,
-0.1765602827,
-0.4228795767,
0.1102455705,
-0.4014405906,
-0.5044708252,
0.7627543807,
-0.0542165339,
0.222093761,
0.2289489508,
0.4811367393,
-0.6703312397,
0.7920479178,
-0.0207735393,
0.2372601628,
0.2655884027,
-0.3094873726,
-0.178565979,
-0.5465307832,
-0.6802526116,
-0.7059143782,
-0.6340423822,
-0.3058458567,
-0.5072531104,
0.4140749574,
-0.1208890453,
-0.1445017308,
-0.0515683107,
-0.492536962,
0.6651051044,
0.4677087665,
0.4527615309,
0.5740563869,
0.1408077329,
-0.1042630747,
-0.1183352098,
-0.756059885,
-0.8838374615,
0.8837679625,
0.3135982454,
1.0979589224,
-0.2848798037,
0.3059527278,
0.6246387362,
0.7071816325,
-0.8059210777,
0.9058219194,
-0.1356575787,
-0.593133688,
-0.5136252046,
-0.3416940868,
-0.9819467664,
0.2874234021,
-0.4416802824,
-0.8340011239,
-0.1016349345,
0.1150218844,
0.0662775561,
0.3849037886,
-0.7671555877,
0.9738898277,
-0.5129938126,
-0.3450836539,
-0.0296666678,
-0.2628239691,
0.2115654349,
0.3975684345,
0.1042095721,
-0.2005875707,
-0.3640315831,
0.9064139128,
0.0304993223,
0.7174419761,
-0.3080431223,
0.1981345415,
0.5226390958,
0.2438056767,
0.4586227834,
-0.113175422,
-0.3087155819,
-0.0444308519,
0.2040884942,
-0.142028302,
-1.0786472559,
0.355645597,
-0.3641335666,
-0.838822782,
-0.2827551961,
-0.7310191989,
-0.4220156968,
-0.0756125227,
0.0186692718,
0.4862327874,
-0.0047499845,
0.3046405911,
0.4575716257,
-0.1861919314,
0.381837219,
0.3303366899,
-0.3843304515,
-0.1738294363,
0.6582636833,
0.511911571,
-0.0801443085,
0.4487537444,
0.0367870368,
-0.8151326776,
-0.7988522053,
-0.6498531699,
0.0109965662,
-1.0854948759,
-0.2231131047,
-0.1592482328,
-0.0252265222,
0.1993613541,
-0.0895840675,
0.3538584113,
-0.4096022844,
-0.5367947817,
-0.1457821876,
0.3412645161,
0.9684815407,
0.3376159072,
0.1998114884,
-0.568829,
0.2779228389,
0.4955675006,
0.4446596801,
0.0873240307,
-0.1742285192,
0.1244968325,
-0.3953533769,
-0.3315283358,
-1.5007973909,
0.10060101,
-0.0966434777,
1.1028876305,
0.1919781417,
-0.3075873554,
0.547036469,
-0.5187218189,
0.9140343666,
0.247947976,
-0.77753371,
0.5514526963,
0.0115945647,
0.1058591902,
0.3936137855,
0.6284174919,
-0.2998501658,
-0.1952739358,
-0.1900494546,
-0.2959366143,
0.4642144442,
0.1294662952,
-0.1298624873,
0.2982513309,
0.6225209236,
0.1443793923,
0.2527053058,
-1.0455229282,
-0.39304775,
0.0249260999,
-0.1831835955,
0.2042691857,
-0.5867167711,
-0.0356101915,
-0.356221199,
0.2444788367,
0.013551604,
0.4524877965,
0.3995835483,
-0.2917520702,
0.0828027949,
0.3838374317,
0.6418504119,
0.8038660288,
0.011471956,
0.3780451119,
0.5749259591,
-0.3280712366,
0.2234148532,
-0.2086855024,
-0.0828777105,
0.2272095084,
0.4187238514,
0.7973194718,
0.1180596426,
-0.560257256,
-0.0291178115,
-0.1425750107,
-0.3656679988,
0.0627409145,
0.2648488581,
0.2560260892,
0.1231794432,
0.4522003531,
-0.6202016473,
0.1844961196,
-0.8975849152,
0.2500700951,
0.5654833317,
-0.3873092532,
0.3186977506,
0.4334422648,
-0.0318199247,
-0.435300678,
0.4847013354,
0.0288320128,
-0.2301300764,
0.8439501524,
0.5482044816,
0.135573104,
0.0029627653,
0.285161227,
0.2104276866,
0.4801616669,
0.110278599,
0.9053557515,
-0.096146062,
-0.5796135664,
-0.1632306427,
-0.1054345071,
-0.7211501598,
0.2762517035,
-0.5086550713,
0.1362764984,
-0.3764459193,
-0.3929494917,
0.3278352022,
0.0693299472,
-0.75821805,
0.1919130832,
-0.0377535857,
1.1083489656,
-0.5201297998,
0.3955374658,
0.862234652,
-0.2702072859,
-0.8679024577,
-0.5128730536,
0.0031657612,
-0.8799005747,
0.8762331009,
0.0981219411,
0.3643993437,
-0.1763083339,
-0.7590776086,
-0.5141421556,
1.2471901178,
0.4761636257,
-0.5364729762,
0.1153454632,
0.7006940246,
0.4479868412,
-0.3028258085,
0.3600128591,
0.8535089493,
0.9324404001,
0.2237909734,
-0.5627031326,
0.1787451208,
0.0831501931,
-0.1062513739,
-0.0274086501,
-0.0177898128,
0.5107569695,
-0.1801503152,
-0.3372462988,
-0.195590809,
0.5576508045,
0.4372699559,
0.7575265169,
0.6265407801,
0.4340553582,
0.7086928487,
-0.5995357037,
0.9550828338,
0.1563314348,
-0.1200324148,
0.7917633057,
-0.4586159289,
0.7618822455,
0.6510720253,
-0.4132702351,
0.6802965403,
0.6418786049,
-0.395722717,
0.1985690147,
0.3476280272,
0.0512602441,
-0.016281629,
-0.197149545,
-0.2806389332,
0.2095949948,
0.8137471676,
-0.4827238321,
-0.4644257724,
-0.1845842302,
-0.2603398263,
0.1760943979,
-0.556868732,
0.8240323067,
0.1216661111,
-0.5806849003,
0.2714285553,
-0.3749473989,
0.1737437099,
-0.1395684183,
-0.5128753185,
-0.1087962165,
-0.523716867,
-0.4178107083,
-1.5509580374,
0.3464195728,
0.1256494075,
0.0736435279,
-0.3381234109,
1.2402741909,
-0.3157469034,
-0.2854366004,
-0.0752187297,
0.931948781,
0.3839883804,
0.2421917468,
-0.9614708424,
0.3541790247,
-0.099254787,
-0.3758678138,
0.0423301607,
0.3090325296,
-0.0596348271,
0.8290078044,
0.502674818,
-0.0464183427,
-0.1080859452,
0.2190437019,
0.6660710573,
-0.8000062108,
-0.1008410454,
-1.1072137356,
0.4998137951,
-0.0916199014,
0.1306285262,
0.6622858644,
0.5718016028,
0.2231954485,
-0.4170151949,
0.3061705232,
0.1798954606,
0.3979275525,
-0.9371355176,
0.7448489666,
-0.3877874017,
0.0878865123,
-0.3087787926,
-0.8998743296,
-0.3277648091,
0.6741164923,
-0.6672826409,
-0.0008411076,
0.841453135,
0.611240983,
0.4034717977,
0.2236536741,
0.4684068263,
-0.1840549558,
0.0391297676,
0.2407520264,
1.3846877813,
-0.0871753469,
0.6597062945,
-0.0930103883,
0.1095531061,
-0.106830135,
-1.0830626488,
-1.1724791527,
-0.5148139596,
-0.2084619403,
-0.2301038206,
-0.051771,
0.4580247402,
0.4361326694,
-0.5098673701,
-0.4089178741,
-0.0008255396,
0.671082437,
-0.0524038002,
-0.2384361178,
0.4226722717,
-0.2108477205,
-0.2014292032,
0.0833968222,
0.3618543744,
0.4792102873,
-0.2507231832,
0.0664588958,
-0.0781589374,
-0.018544618,
0.6719001532,
0.0038865239,
-0.6786921024,
-0.0481432229,
0.1315134615,
-0.289177835,
0.3944362104,
0.9041728377,
-0.7422679663,
0.1363239735,
0.5180829763,
0.4611008167,
0.6105984449,
0.0304784738,
0.16842103,
-0.3969563544,
-0.0601283237,
0.3523789644,
0.4679741263,
0.3334291577,
-0.4095669091,
0.7931186557,
0.0167975966,
-0.5822950602,
-0.826474309,
-0.1660479158,
-1.0214591026,
-0.2075322121,
0.921148777,
-0.0038752232,
-0.4238912165,
-0.2041630298,
-0.3606039286,
0.2007376999,
-0.2854528427,
0.8148595095,
0.8166476488,
-0.5774495602,
-0.5323045254,
-0.8666998148,
0.6680036187,
0.2980639935,
-1.3677214384,
-0.1576113552,
0.5407921076,
-0.0697133616,
0.1584791094,
0.6328644753,
-0.2575345039,
0.3850486577,
-0.006502287,
-0.2111771703,
-0.1324109137,
-0.3837159872,
0.0069775977,
0.0937058479,
0.1705803424,
0.1142417863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12267v1
|
High-quality Data-to-Text Generation for Severely Under-Resourced Languages with Out-of-the-box Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T16:29:40 | 2024-02-19T16:29:40 |
Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of NLP methods for severely under-resourced languages cannot
currently hope to match the state of the art in NLP methods for well resourced
languages. We explore the extent to which pretrained large language models
(LLMs) can bridge this gap, via the example of data-to-text generation for
Irish, Welsh, Breton and Maltese. We test LLMs on these under-resourced
languages and English, in a range of scenarios. We find that LLMs easily set
the state of the art for the under-resourced languages by substantial margins,
as measured by both automatic and human evaluations. For all our languages,
human evaluation shows on-a-par performance with humans for our best systems,
but BLEU scores collapse compared to English, casting doubt on the metric's
suitability for evaluating non-task-specific systems. Overall, our results
demonstrate the great potential of LLMs to bridge the performance gap for
under-resourced languages.
|
[
-0.2970081568,
-0.3768377006,
0.5731295943,
0.2804968357,
-0.3196868896,
0.2532375455,
-0.6982864738,
-0.482365042,
0.029180266,
0.8251370788,
-0.4389406145,
-0.3248012662,
-0.5523486137,
0.4453648627,
-0.3944262564,
0.908875823,
-0.0520919599,
0.0182004478,
-0.3370556831,
0.0066944435,
-0.3688231111,
-0.762319386,
-0.5479639173,
-0.5384290218,
0.4149257541,
0.3322417736,
0.7051550746,
0.4832226038,
0.5592383146,
0.2811559141,
-0.0765123889,
0.4042969644,
-0.6682277918,
0.0383373909,
-0.3220313191,
-0.2420796156,
-0.5371596813,
-0.0272623021,
0.6250632405,
0.9443126321,
-0.1150886267,
0.1456001699,
0.3677608967,
0.7249457836,
-0.4721461535,
0.0286172479,
-0.8408737183,
-0.0631394982,
-0.4558397233,
-0.3115780354,
-0.4678365588,
-0.1943175942,
-0.1443074495,
-0.3817390203,
0.2483617812,
0.1162186414,
0.6612471342,
0.3270457685,
-0.2693461478,
-0.3880237639,
-0.9197186232,
0.8553860188,
-0.8024657965,
0.4777490795,
0.479660362,
-0.0390228964,
-0.3940581083,
-0.7110950351,
-0.4524056911,
-0.4436149001,
-0.1222863793,
0.0650768355,
-0.1671758294,
-0.0674888641,
0.3431099951,
0.4668977857,
-0.6175214648,
0.5103638172,
-0.3421741426,
0.1407610178,
0.8716884255,
0.0861089081,
0.1757014096,
-0.1918749213,
-0.1186566204,
0.005351739,
-0.9947857857,
-0.1609032601,
0.5350592732,
0.6713632345,
0.0176137704,
0.7104768753,
0.0797887743,
0.6586558223,
-0.0526068546,
-0.004907236,
0.0982356817,
-0.2841953337,
-0.2501939833,
-0.0260181911,
1.0246015787,
0.1988373846,
0.496686846,
-0.3472369015,
-0.5491834283,
0.1572908312,
0.1570481956,
-0.6591689587,
-0.0963208154,
-0.0835888907,
-0.192388773,
-0.0272471104,
-0.3529514074,
-0.6406461596,
-0.2043661028,
-0.0667680502,
0.319051832,
-0.0006855914,
-0.3706175089,
0.3363028169,
0.1866523325,
-0.1536460668,
0.0667357892,
-1.0492882729,
0.4565542936,
0.3496842384,
0.6003324389,
-0.3088900149,
-0.1838809848,
-0.3252146542,
0.0766605213,
-0.6447908282,
0.517896533,
-0.4277769327,
-0.4781358242,
0.1637940556,
-0.0604510047,
0.0363667794,
-0.7822612524,
0.5485442281,
-0.5124665499,
0.2106820047,
-0.1963317394,
-0.5471532345,
0.3387459815,
0.0633856431,
-0.7935776114,
1.1759052277,
0.2688838243,
-0.7127650976,
0.3326469362,
-0.5097133517,
-0.63994205,
0.313821733,
-0.0700917915,
-0.1091246009,
0.4098796844,
0.1775496006,
0.6884335876,
-0.7910137773,
0.3577788472,
-0.0530148819,
-0.27340734,
0.1715198159,
-0.6156556606,
0.5602867007,
0.1846413463,
-0.1949255764,
-0.3473519981,
-0.7607961297,
0.3380148709,
0.2063836604,
-0.6702887416,
-0.2252492309,
0.0109808557,
0.3499500453,
0.4254408181,
0.2449878156,
-0.5596734285,
0.0426433086,
-0.5492261648,
0.6322826147,
0.385899961,
-0.5489751101,
0.2317472994,
-0.1587778032,
0.6046074033,
-0.2335259318,
-0.2622691989,
-0.0762959868,
-0.2609335184,
-0.7847597599,
-0.0132363383,
0.5196941495,
0.6130875945,
-0.843275547,
0.6062438488,
-0.2192109823,
-0.4179388285,
-0.6909293532,
0.5830629468,
0.5847225785,
0.3154172301,
0.4034632742,
-0.5243980289,
-0.4053098559,
-0.7275216579,
-0.0454765968,
-0.346915096,
-0.2688324153,
0.2839982212,
0.3699220419,
-0.3673866093,
0.7253947854,
-0.1763148457,
-0.0500720255,
-0.5760114193,
-0.0442506559,
0.1508199424,
0.5132741332,
0.2549648881,
-0.5571017265,
-0.2302947938,
0.095743984,
-0.4373632073,
-0.3389625847,
0.1029129326,
0.0455446541,
0.4384760261,
0.6881358027,
-0.5202467442,
0.1208293885,
0.9078362584,
-0.1663299203,
0.5390717387,
-0.4399832487,
0.0937937722,
-1.1262633801,
0.1296167523,
0.0218759794,
-0.2724125981,
-0.3962365389,
-0.1834892333,
-0.0604266822,
-0.3390063941,
-0.4559963942,
0.7776102424,
-0.4409367144,
-0.2762351334,
-0.191123262,
0.0858325064,
-0.0092679318,
0.0866946205,
0.2537956834,
0.7501984835,
0.2621861696,
-0.4291348159,
0.435226649,
0.1423561871,
-0.4944835603,
0.3387138546,
-0.6319434047,
0.0000640928,
0.0751791894,
0.2325231582,
-0.7913048863,
-0.3571442068,
-0.3631001413,
-0.2091973573,
0.5274925232,
-0.1411786526,
-0.5857456326,
-0.4886262119,
0.1740764529,
0.5783936381,
0.570895493,
-0.6246002316,
0.1321240813,
0.2553571165,
-0.4232678413,
-0.4241556525,
-0.935143292,
0.3288428783,
-0.2461598068,
-0.6891314983,
0.2982332408,
0.0332348831,
-0.2058998048,
-0.1241102368,
0.2847729623,
-0.2316879183,
0.1299627721,
-0.022531556,
0.1021422371,
-0.4759607017,
0.2323880643,
-0.2810024321,
-0.116421476,
-0.0035112239,
-0.3499640226,
0.6922777295,
0.0171835888,
-0.4518473744,
-0.2770805657,
0.4599783421,
0.3982164264,
-0.3660224974,
0.5900988579,
0.285505116,
-0.3327032626,
-0.3655435741,
-0.6285997629,
-0.0365186632,
-0.4878549278,
0.4535948038,
-0.1397316605,
-0.9485424161,
0.3338347971,
-0.2957475781,
0.0343480706,
0.5600379109,
0.5888279676,
-0.3049067259,
0.8295885324,
0.8141402006,
0.0352327675,
0.2056298107,
-0.1540776193,
0.1559631377,
-0.5677800179,
0.0773151889,
-0.6962622404,
-0.0981904417,
-1.0036126375,
-0.3727267683,
0.1158770695,
0.3255017996,
-0.092737332,
0.1930943877,
-0.1321825832,
0.610063374,
0.5362544656,
-0.0804873332,
0.2395106256,
0.0134749999,
0.0555666052,
-0.0868710801,
-1.0544425249,
-0.8897269368,
1.2180709839,
0.0804583058,
0.9091905951,
-0.2157898992,
0.762016058,
0.2264242321,
0.1544223577,
-0.496239692,
0.3682561219,
-0.6994574666,
-0.4894351661,
-0.433729291,
-0.6304594874,
-1.1048877239,
-0.1595054716,
-0.3380488455,
-0.475767225,
-0.1263584346,
0.3210126162,
-0.4241264164,
0.3432894051,
-0.7080393434,
0.8064178824,
-0.492431134,
-0.4368749261,
-0.119086735,
-0.3877543211,
0.3607415259,
-0.5154321194,
0.3028607965,
0.0233295429,
0.1841230243,
0.786954999,
-0.3586570919,
0.6666429639,
0.1286162436,
-0.2869882286,
0.0743661672,
-0.0643314496,
0.3192082345,
-0.0436036624,
-0.2290446907,
0.2249611914,
-0.2678387761,
-0.5687598586,
-0.4190354943,
0.6965036392,
-0.5748580098,
-0.4708835185,
-0.0682231486,
-0.4933858514,
-0.3896199167,
0.0993053541,
0.3939775527,
0.5478265285,
-0.281917572,
0.1161468849,
0.6119216084,
-0.5427795053,
0.56504637,
0.412310183,
-0.0745711476,
-0.2441977113,
0.7192269564,
0.2597895563,
0.4684721529,
0.1285219938,
0.0878415257,
-0.4356879592,
-0.6959747672,
-0.7273541093,
0.2334934175,
-0.2518671155,
-0.1655951142,
-0.2737577558,
-0.3267170191,
-0.1935661435,
-0.4695350826,
-0.6641846895,
-0.3841032982,
-0.2436590493,
0.0499946922,
0.0199466106,
1.0482559204,
-0.1330652684,
0.4802118838,
-0.86103338,
0.2704950869,
0.3225748241,
0.3854999244,
-0.0841554403,
-0.4803891182,
-0.4186318517,
-0.006301017,
-0.2537454069,
-0.4371260405,
0.4218506813,
0.1317691505,
0.4040774405,
0.1075709462,
0.1308599263,
0.4740949273,
-0.7791844606,
0.7605860233,
0.2830570936,
-0.7397415638,
0.3695504069,
-0.2507357299,
0.2035075575,
0.3656408191,
0.3803547919,
-0.5857188702,
-0.5580701232,
-0.5768187642,
-1.030175209,
0.7323839068,
0.2213597,
0.3208448589,
-0.0722854957,
0.2693241239,
0.1772179902,
0.2723147869,
-0.769397974,
0.0886433497,
0.1008538976,
-0.2067366093,
-0.5999367237,
-0.3422445357,
0.0806757584,
0.0423749462,
0.6369597912,
0.0595173128,
-0.0243399758,
-0.0454903468,
-0.1382387429,
-0.3630531728,
0.3839122653,
0.3849647939,
0.9741795659,
-0.1309414506,
-0.0164056793,
0.2536161244,
-0.4594857693,
0.4089695513,
0.1403271407,
0.0220996458,
-0.1478598714,
0.7628216743,
0.7659419775,
0.0670896843,
-0.6202638745,
0.4578433335,
-0.1452193409,
0.0583766513,
-0.0606448688,
0.1765820384,
0.2130432427,
0.2230773419,
0.4019672275,
-0.1348379403,
-0.48854056,
-0.5505644083,
0.1539957523,
0.5016916394,
-0.1350185722,
-0.2700246572,
0.5287148952,
0.5928618312,
-0.4941771626,
0.6368560195,
-0.1889242977,
-0.4041050673,
0.466622442,
0.6751683354,
0.6237918139,
-0.2809987366,
0.1204007119,
0.106228143,
0.5735698342,
-0.3291705549,
0.3644830883,
0.1253591627,
-0.7796855569,
-0.9045818448,
-0.9072082639,
-0.2588043809,
0.4809874892,
-0.6125969887,
0.1698105782,
-0.2490879148,
-0.3374044299,
-0.1326658577,
0.3301791847,
-0.9372150898,
0.4354303479,
0.2699744105,
0.8632245064,
-1.1493861675,
0.7360603213,
0.6016051173,
0.010749802,
-0.6779187322,
-0.0415569991,
-0.491392374,
-0.651283443,
0.7013117671,
-0.0321606733,
-0.162449643,
0.2092158049,
-0.3374930322,
-0.7376607656,
0.6202445626,
0.8367000818,
-0.8296040297,
-0.1351895928,
0.4756720066,
0.738427639,
-0.1883442253,
0.306458801,
0.6635460258,
0.3492302895,
-0.1010033861,
-1.2292611599,
-0.2432869673,
0.0327656679,
-0.0088772839,
0.3116684556,
-0.5818226933,
0.5483543277,
-0.1390096545,
-0.2610497773,
-0.0212939773,
0.5103803277,
0.1103093475,
0.1262882203,
0.4119646251,
0.7259234786,
0.7651859522,
-0.0485807136,
1.0609714985,
-0.2277470976,
0.0599267632,
0.9195702672,
-0.4639798105,
0.9674850106,
0.3291272521,
-0.2549258471,
0.0637349337,
0.4576792121,
0.3393091857,
0.2462534308,
0.453527689,
-0.1489748359,
-0.5815735459,
-0.2241645306,
-0.3346472681,
0.5511003733,
0.3314038515,
-0.2291551083,
-0.2283829451,
0.0076615196,
-0.1125032529,
0.3189942241,
-0.4762824476,
0.7376614213,
0.1253015995,
-0.5257921219,
0.9367255569,
-0.0527011231,
0.8454648852,
-0.5252195597,
0.1916652024,
-0.2870668769,
-0.0375804864,
-0.3072447479,
-0.7604517341,
0.143039301,
0.4612569213,
-0.286688298,
-0.5498753786,
0.4641570449,
-0.6756856441,
-0.8081911206,
0.6060304046,
0.7866560221,
0.2993261814,
0.1882419288,
-0.4069457352,
-0.0457516983,
-0.0931366682,
-0.2813641727,
0.3749875724,
0.6419498324,
-0.0452591702,
0.5814939737,
0.5051131845,
0.5861184001,
0.1121209487,
-0.047182519,
0.8109837174,
-0.6723479033,
-0.1933363229,
-0.8510977626,
0.2360427231,
0.2229553908,
-0.4685441256,
0.4754442275,
0.6244240403,
1.2251423597,
0.0955950245,
0.770625174,
0.2192363888,
0.6229040623,
-0.7712264657,
0.8988904953,
-0.7036373615,
0.109231703,
-0.3713367581,
-1.1001068354,
-0.0910958126,
0.3449798822,
-0.0983473435,
-0.0058813659,
0.5856327415,
0.7042062283,
-0.1816547364,
-0.3078086972,
0.6358222961,
0.2277225405,
0.1523434222,
0.6587149501,
1.0139300823,
-0.0970166028,
0.4866970778,
-0.0005336989,
-0.0254241154,
0.0709532872,
-0.9621008635,
-0.9004025459,
-0.5129030943,
-0.053114336,
-0.1986659169,
0.1030026302,
0.8933417797,
0.6303613186,
-0.70766294,
-0.5244572163,
0.0739420205,
-0.1714335084,
0.2834314108,
-0.0913156345,
0.283147037,
-0.4470132589,
-0.6958274245,
0.6003030539,
0.118437387,
0.1501862258,
-0.4447491169,
-0.1838340163,
0.1109401956,
0.1005008593,
0.5683352947,
0.2223828584,
-0.536083281,
0.1639625281,
-0.2712664008,
-0.3041642904,
0.0214989297,
0.8253135085,
-0.8632674813,
0.0970829949,
0.2422535717,
0.8764699101,
0.4647412896,
-0.0478254259,
0.8034407496,
-0.9762123227,
0.2124286443,
0.4279069006,
0.2813669741,
0.6990613341,
-0.0961990654,
0.3274944723,
0.0023330585,
-0.6185006499,
-1.0488773584,
0.2197304815,
-0.4569672346,
-0.0366777889,
1.0945539474,
-0.1913171858,
-0.0553026982,
-0.0263387114,
0.0418807082,
0.231060937,
-0.1739444137,
0.7919999361,
0.8355749249,
0.1855209023,
0.1391243488,
-0.746496141,
0.7794325948,
0.4289689362,
-0.8883523941,
0.4605039358,
0.4180645943,
-0.1358174682,
0.0985979289,
0.6750270128,
0.0823381841,
0.1020561159,
-0.2859760821,
0.0674825832,
0.112349093,
-0.4357319772,
-0.2437086552,
-0.1287788153,
0.3366644979,
0.3026704192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12264v1
|
Uncertainty quantification in fine-tuned LLMs using LoRA ensembles
| 2024-02-19T16:26:00 | 2024-02-19T16:26:00 |
Oleksandr Balabanov, Hampus Linander
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Fine-tuning large language models can improve task specific performance,
although a general understanding of what the fine-tuned model has learned,
forgotten and how to trust its predictions is still missing. We derive
principled uncertainty quantification for fine-tuned LLMs with posterior
approximations using computationally efficient low-rank adaptation ensembles.
We analyze three common multiple-choice datasets using low-rank adaptation
ensembles based on Mistral-7b, and draw quantitative and qualitative
conclusions on their perceived complexity and model efficacy on the different
target domains during and after fine-tuning. In particular, backed by the
numerical experiments, we hypothesise about signals from entropic uncertainty
measures for data domains that are inherently difficult for a given
architecture to learn.
|
[
-0.4195265174,
-0.9683203697,
0.5663993359,
0.0796240717,
-0.0889664963,
0.0583054088,
-0.4024571478,
-0.4081275761,
-0.183414489,
0.2287654728,
-0.4930169582,
-0.4639118314,
-0.7309041023,
0.0706405118,
-0.3087542653,
0.6334114075,
-0.0578015372,
-0.0700897723,
-0.0897238255,
-0.1143552363,
-0.2392293513,
-0.1246061698,
-0.6294156313,
-0.2017821819,
0.5719206333,
0.4761071205,
0.694116652,
0.3597488999,
0.5384504795,
0.2443329543,
-0.1512370557,
0.4393634796,
-0.5784226656,
-0.0281837024,
-0.2935657501,
-0.7264726758,
-0.5493139625,
-0.3206146657,
0.6287602186,
0.8755587935,
-0.2512078881,
0.4925338924,
0.3695755601,
0.657969594,
-1.0900542736,
0.0081178574,
-0.980651021,
-0.0495528765,
-0.0055911755,
-0.2241952419,
-0.2668740153,
-0.2250734866,
0.0702530593,
-0.8710361123,
-0.020789111,
0.1479961425,
0.4834668636,
0.8156995773,
-0.2931084931,
-0.1217843816,
-0.897892952,
0.8575616479,
-0.7286858559,
0.3018210232,
0.6671230197,
0.1907429546,
-0.3399213552,
-0.4230929017,
-0.1633443832,
0.1954020858,
0.3308034241,
0.0954850987,
-0.2850114703,
0.2327197343,
0.1400895119,
0.2263592482,
-0.2131672204,
0.5875592828,
-0.3723713756,
-0.1663071364,
0.4811603725,
0.0384975038,
-0.2123571783,
0.147475332,
-0.1564746946,
-0.0485230796,
-0.6378213763,
0.1576054841,
0.4405969381,
0.3119598031,
-0.2955684066,
0.4543219507,
-0.3683102429,
0.9981374145,
0.366961807,
-0.1880841702,
-0.0396619216,
0.0693275034,
-0.508430779,
-0.1274037212,
0.4619822204,
0.0439801887,
0.3354753852,
-0.1368880421,
-0.194450289,
-0.1042801067,
0.1912374943,
-0.4601379335,
0.045322448,
0.3823350966,
-0.229306072,
-0.2249322832,
-0.1028576493,
-0.4058077633,
-0.430724144,
-0.4852903783,
0.8479086161,
-0.4696251452,
0.1174390838,
0.3607382774,
0.0008959792,
0.2997636199,
0.6721145511,
-0.78021276,
0.4401922226,
0.7030658722,
0.5757962465,
-0.4638317227,
-0.4039701819,
-0.3343212903,
0.1230469868,
-0.5576977134,
0.6087802052,
-0.4907501042,
-0.2925247252,
-0.2121431231,
-0.1195765957,
-0.4453462958,
-0.6529088616,
0.5860151649,
-0.5504978895,
-0.2845132649,
-0.0590906069,
-0.5262178779,
-0.0724386051,
0.069587402,
-0.5864211917,
0.9007150531,
0.2664194405,
-0.650714159,
0.3168387413,
-0.2052119821,
-0.3013854027,
-0.3227303028,
0.0772556067,
-0.2787136436,
0.718444705,
0.2581231892,
0.5393610001,
-0.4194922447,
-0.1348210126,
-0.6591768265,
-0.5124715567,
0.514243722,
-0.6610750556,
0.3040349782,
0.3669241965,
0.0916188732,
-0.0514714755,
-0.8542117476,
0.1678721756,
-0.3618198037,
-0.4469762146,
-0.3560014069,
0.0253141206,
-0.3110414743,
-0.1560111642,
0.4448826611,
-0.0862909183,
0.137141794,
-0.3391162157,
0.5874712467,
0.9573084712,
0.2035713643,
0.5539898872,
-0.4243325293,
0.4940333664,
0.0683358684,
0.0441358127,
0.3938204348,
-0.2939717174,
-0.8453996181,
-0.2580088675,
0.42369017,
0.4285336733,
-0.6392449141,
0.2931778133,
-0.3532764018,
-0.6267333627,
-0.5906235576,
0.1964240372,
0.1837275773,
0.1627928615,
0.2752566338,
-0.0321684927,
-0.034414947,
-0.7574974895,
-0.2582084835,
-0.1323716342,
-0.0292811785,
0.2700486779,
0.5643751621,
-0.1769373268,
0.6929644942,
-0.3765856922,
-0.0151541308,
0.2464934289,
0.1219389662,
0.1652590185,
0.4843521118,
0.3012102246,
-0.5877091885,
-0.298468411,
0.0615122914,
-0.4210369587,
0.0944769084,
0.0029612645,
-0.1315061301,
0.1078112051,
0.4906556904,
-0.5049863458,
0.1974700242,
0.7089572549,
0.1557673663,
0.3881418407,
-0.4766212404,
0.1742565781,
-0.8853107095,
-0.1962708533,
-0.0177351851,
-0.1005249694,
-0.454379797,
0.0379654802,
0.0511510931,
0.1816255748,
-0.3826280236,
0.4085944295,
-0.3139882386,
-0.2932083309,
-0.1461140364,
0.0752993971,
-0.2638540566,
0.5642811656,
-0.0463143028,
0.7358833551,
0.7599272728,
-0.8777047992,
-0.1026907563,
-0.1384310424,
-0.6564611793,
0.7831405997,
-0.6208059192,
-0.0230120961,
-0.0870339572,
-0.1341097802,
-0.883174479,
-0.5310055614,
0.010566473,
-0.3769367635,
0.2966736555,
-0.2578327954,
-0.2392157763,
-0.0260771103,
-0.0798837617,
0.4960613251,
0.3893579245,
-0.2815333307,
0.4082954228,
0.2460510582,
-0.0536768697,
-0.4704602063,
-0.6864287257,
-0.437009573,
-0.4636259675,
-0.2748898566,
0.3243867457,
-0.0477299653,
-0.3232148588,
-0.4154847264,
-0.4353627264,
-0.2108792514,
0.6031307578,
0.4673137069,
-0.2127058357,
-0.1469599307,
0.2174772918,
0.392813772,
0.1555028707,
-0.0927265435,
-0.2425200343,
0.3259190023,
-0.2622336745,
-0.8323304057,
-0.0762307271,
-0.2538561821,
0.6390501857,
-0.0409225561,
0.4698296189,
0.7259985805,
-0.6381693482,
-0.5210368633,
-0.3467487395,
-0.1360436827,
-0.4806886315,
0.2983350456,
-0.4592383504,
-0.945268631,
0.754347086,
-0.2833130956,
-0.2557491362,
0.5518239737,
0.5858284831,
-0.3231082857,
0.7340963483,
0.4324238598,
-0.1974142343,
0.2157781422,
-0.0402338505,
-0.1430729628,
-0.7469937205,
0.1203299165,
-0.6189098954,
-0.5992387533,
-0.9407666326,
-0.5201665759,
0.6150241494,
0.4463434219,
-0.5135963559,
0.0113903861,
-0.2925921082,
0.21108751,
0.6551264524,
0.480740577,
0.3990799785,
0.1633447856,
0.2989402115,
0.1444226652,
-0.7060232162,
-0.2024535835,
1.0317041874,
0.3628690243,
1.2727380991,
0.2644313872,
0.6261698604,
0.3201271892,
-0.1566723585,
-0.7449973822,
0.0761721209,
-0.1125197038,
-0.3406383395,
-0.6171335578,
-0.4003391862,
-1.0458438396,
0.2383557409,
-0.2884607017,
-0.9320403934,
0.5389866829,
0.3084165454,
-0.905764997,
0.0325109698,
-0.5280503035,
0.439845562,
-0.1588303596,
-0.2895210385,
-0.2688697278,
-0.5280279517,
0.2471820116,
-0.435544759,
0.4388816059,
-0.1919521242,
-0.0735919327,
0.7072402239,
-0.0841736272,
1.0011856556,
0.0308700465,
-0.3966325223,
0.2419312298,
0.2829848826,
0.6301817894,
0.2066679448,
-0.3521121144,
0.1204901263,
0.3105342984,
-0.3498257101,
-0.6045185924,
0.7560183406,
-0.9409788251,
-0.5446811318,
-0.0675352216,
-0.5029076934,
-0.6563169956,
0.0282566994,
0.5253340602,
0.1567519307,
-0.1297907531,
0.4038372934,
0.8067986965,
-0.1357732415,
0.2937622666,
0.3712634444,
0.2646654248,
-0.1773829907,
0.8684069514,
0.2614136636,
0.5006905794,
0.583142221,
-0.0488910563,
0.1445053071,
-0.8587626219,
-0.1955877542,
-0.1799129397,
-0.5082278848,
-0.2585792243,
-0.0538226329,
-0.1009033695,
-0.229211539,
-0.210914433,
-0.4261032343,
-0.608158052,
-0.7217388749,
-0.079990305,
0.4355006516,
0.5836524367,
-0.1112465113,
0.6437032819,
-0.463942647,
0.3300915062,
0.2649999559,
0.352217108,
-0.2239844054,
-1.0435085297,
-0.3254646361,
0.4595808983,
-0.0500315577,
-0.5698856711,
0.2380624712,
0.65177387,
0.6180510521,
0.3493616581,
0.2392434478,
0.7025284171,
-0.2007361352,
0.5224211812,
-0.3470924795,
-0.8557910919,
0.4754422605,
-0.3939772844,
0.258878231,
0.5639615655,
0.240863502,
0.0894041359,
-0.1356808841,
-0.4746266305,
-0.5277675986,
0.3254666328,
0.0849515721,
-0.0124392053,
0.3751639724,
0.6469521523,
0.0355833583,
0.2501605451,
-0.2617215216,
-0.2181942463,
0.2228455245,
-0.2923333049,
-0.3805291951,
-0.0875893831,
-0.1718610376,
-0.2408365905,
0.3696755171,
-0.4087683856,
0.3234303296,
-0.0182164535,
-0.2661358416,
-0.2607236505,
0.3819444776,
0.6823878288,
0.6980249882,
-0.386051476,
0.2310366631,
0.6461077332,
-0.2245505303,
0.0902276933,
-0.0280052479,
0.0073085744,
-0.4272339344,
0.5597112179,
0.9710161686,
0.4748636186,
-0.4565546513,
0.2513225675,
0.2430766225,
-0.2319840491,
-0.2546165287,
0.3810830116,
0.0212317631,
0.345648855,
0.3061247766,
0.4316552579,
0.207550168,
-0.279114753,
-0.142606318,
0.526145041,
-0.5642876625,
-0.3114565909,
0.4497624338,
-0.097023502,
0.0940700322,
0.1248415336,
0.1439874321,
-0.0447144322,
0.6312792301,
0.3304437101,
0.5179874897,
-0.0738231763,
0.0490700491,
0.067814365,
0.4307456613,
-0.3486503065,
0.3175393641,
-0.064384982,
-0.9486193657,
-0.3564031124,
-0.8586948514,
-0.554990828,
-0.0769387633,
-1.0079680681,
0.0908339098,
-0.4066133797,
-0.3841694891,
-0.0906191096,
-0.1853104979,
-0.7713975906,
0.2392700166,
-0.0305192918,
1.0039181709,
-0.7179068327,
0.7465471029,
0.4535606205,
0.0940602794,
-0.6349063516,
-0.1248586401,
-0.2167702913,
-1.0055158138,
0.3376977146,
-0.4779076576,
-0.4076205492,
0.2112488449,
-0.793844521,
-1.1750583649,
1.2116872072,
0.6517264247,
-0.5273778439,
0.0313819423,
0.1932035834,
0.5154582262,
-0.0652044639,
-0.1404749453,
0.7052078843,
0.4231064022,
-0.0626769066,
-1.041592598,
-0.310338825,
0.2367745191,
-0.1130276099,
-0.0413542315,
-0.6375730634,
0.9361361265,
-0.3155503273,
-0.0239762515,
0.1701102853,
0.5827000141,
0.1653694361,
0.177372098,
0.3666434288,
0.4558759332,
1.05186975,
-0.0815613791,
0.8556931615,
-0.4739018083,
0.4403301775,
1.3319290876,
-0.0592909195,
1.1164824963,
0.5890389681,
-0.333755672,
0.1702332348,
1.0586477518,
0.2486597598,
0.5039232969,
0.3923783898,
-0.0586620606,
-0.5975024104,
0.0760740042,
-0.3820368946,
0.5498130918,
0.9302733541,
-0.2080025971,
0.0903574973,
-0.0107860975,
-0.3954845965,
-0.1702292711,
-0.5958877802,
0.8461467028,
0.3167387545,
-0.5788289309,
0.874221921,
0.0836375058,
0.6490210295,
-0.3909227848,
0.3689511418,
-0.080489561,
0.1773477495,
-0.1771470308,
-0.5686175227,
-0.1115958393,
-0.4973776042,
-0.0564837717,
0.2083438784,
0.7593199015,
-0.3191018701,
-0.5735070705,
-0.0458571911,
0.7612310052,
0.0362249576,
-0.3342894912,
-0.3798971772,
0.1343001276,
-0.1883894205,
-0.3585054278,
0.3759061694,
0.6563078165,
-0.11140313,
0.9507600069,
0.2840681672,
0.1801548749,
0.11817386,
-0.1972775012,
0.4328220487,
-0.2344844192,
-0.0254637208,
-0.7519991994,
0.024752954,
0.3793537915,
-0.5449550152,
0.5683723688,
0.1704362333,
0.8947530985,
-0.2747501731,
0.8183291554,
0.3583481312,
0.3973812163,
-0.8912209868,
0.5350407958,
-0.5963235497,
0.3011306822,
-0.1304586232,
-0.806476891,
-0.2285982221,
0.6155995727,
-0.2262147665,
0.0951735005,
0.3407091498,
0.8355158567,
-0.2706522048,
-0.1478185803,
0.5594930053,
0.2785951495,
-0.3296204507,
0.6596617699,
0.6804252267,
-0.5117462277,
0.107380189,
-0.2649152577,
-0.0738696158,
-0.2775190175,
-0.7519086003,
-0.5964801311,
-0.5675881505,
-0.2954165637,
-0.1673828363,
0.0976918712,
0.8409737945,
0.7421198487,
-0.9269834757,
-0.1598988324,
-0.047517404,
0.3104412556,
-0.267893523,
-0.0707041547,
0.42880404,
-0.1554820389,
-0.7318113446,
0.288648814,
0.008836518,
0.2511112988,
-0.0983098671,
-0.2184675783,
0.1710259914,
0.2445292622,
0.5237607956,
0.2436893731,
-0.8140977025,
-0.4866909981,
-0.0962314159,
-0.1413422823,
-0.2821166515,
0.4435681701,
-0.43354249,
0.0452139154,
0.3241196275,
0.6039893031,
0.4289408326,
0.147659719,
0.4956274927,
-0.6714935303,
-0.0384583212,
-0.1080971658,
0.4376457334,
0.0489532501,
-0.220266059,
0.5298179984,
-0.0489604622,
-0.5521711707,
-0.7358427644,
0.1162116826,
-1.0965538025,
-0.4004221857,
1.3462247849,
-0.0725931451,
-0.2304854244,
-0.0163009372,
-0.04615568,
-0.0159014929,
-0.3206647336,
0.6796286702,
0.6276048422,
-0.050776042,
-0.0426677987,
-0.5433406234,
0.7000772357,
0.3525393009,
-0.7219603658,
-0.0003949232,
0.3708869815,
0.2113843709,
0.0164700132,
0.1798011363,
0.3478020132,
0.1674549729,
-0.2391353101,
-0.3022385538,
0.2707726657,
-0.2392764539,
-0.4328570366,
0.2520830035,
0.5944678783,
-0.0583612137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12423v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12423v2
|
On the Semantic Latent Space of Diffusion-Based Text-to-Speech Models
| 2024-02-19T16:22:21 | 2024-06-04T11:03:57 |
Miri Varshavsky-Hassid, Roy Hirsch, Regev Cohen, Tomer Golany, Daniel Freedman, Ehud Rivlin
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
The incorporation of Denoising Diffusion Models (DDMs) in the Text-to-Speech
(TTS) domain is rising, providing great value in synthesizing high quality
speech. Although they exhibit impressive audio quality, the extent of their
semantic capabilities is unknown, and controlling their synthesized speech's
vocal properties remains a challenge. Inspired by recent advances in image
synthesis, we explore the latent space of frozen TTS models, which is composed
of the latent bottleneck activations of the DDM's denoiser. We identify that
this space contains rich semantic information, and outline several novel
methods for finding semantic directions within it, both supervised and
unsupervised. We then demonstrate how these enable off-the-shelf audio editing,
without any further training, architectural changes or data requirements. We
present evidence of the semantic and acoustic qualities of the edited audio,
and provide supplemental samples:
https://latent-analysis-grad-tts.github.io/speech-samples/.
|
[
-0.4680166543,
-0.9953660369,
0.7164156437,
-0.0692089498,
-0.1631411165,
0.2168008834,
0.051790908,
-0.0228113588,
0.1681112796,
0.6365764737,
-0.6892769337,
-0.7390196919,
-0.7809872627,
-0.2864065468,
-0.6591229439,
0.7861985564,
0.1452846527,
-0.0109803798,
-0.1249911189,
0.0563586839,
-0.4052912593,
-0.2436592132,
-0.4313640594,
0.0994020775,
0.3350085616,
0.0441779755,
0.9916593432,
0.5926644206,
-0.0074782977,
0.3089872599,
-0.7096697092,
-0.2042252123,
-0.2849418819,
0.285646528,
-0.0824632123,
-0.1613522917,
-0.7467362881,
0.313177675,
0.8775446415,
1.070866704,
-0.2250780463,
-0.3399646878,
-0.1608334929,
0.5771633387,
-0.3603542447,
-0.1673849672,
-0.8628937602,
0.161944434,
-0.1174782887,
-0.0449923128,
-0.2505685091,
-0.1083000824,
0.5414670706,
-0.7417885065,
0.4825387001,
-0.4737048149,
0.5852711797,
0.6184004545,
-0.3756978512,
-0.2174815834,
-0.8572468162,
0.7213166952,
-0.5035785437,
0.7720164061,
0.3338167965,
0.0448351204,
-0.4517855644,
-0.8043746948,
-0.5559319854,
0.2315800041,
0.2633104026,
0.2706867754,
-0.4965952039,
0.0638512895,
-0.1199473888,
0.1901156455,
-0.3642904162,
0.1703228503,
-0.2508814037,
-0.2009914815,
0.3321711123,
0.0248332098,
0.5014623404,
-0.0342983976,
-0.1422097683,
0.0694786534,
-0.5609992146,
-0.3753336966,
0.249281764,
0.2333391607,
-0.1516803503,
0.7366817594,
-0.0115109142,
0.9156012535,
-0.1152268276,
-0.0572424605,
0.0990520418,
-0.2606986463,
-0.1108260378,
0.1022374481,
0.3954375684,
0.345939815,
-0.3689804971,
-0.5056040287,
-0.3530139029,
0.1991100609,
0.160123229,
-0.5835462809,
-0.2831515074,
0.2126131654,
-0.3042038381,
-0.0919364542,
-0.3089744151,
-0.665515244,
-0.2074161768,
-0.3370409608,
0.3754257262,
-0.2521943152,
-0.4261047542,
0.1045282036,
-0.7006025314,
-0.0336258858,
0.5053216815,
-0.6576008201,
0.4190371931,
0.4149941802,
0.9728900194,
-0.2928151488,
0.0118934317,
-0.4113712907,
0.3276306391,
-0.8605974317,
0.8226639628,
-0.5588282347,
-0.6576606631,
-0.2747250795,
-0.3073590696,
0.0959216654,
-0.6866355538,
0.1771946996,
-0.8324940801,
0.3143112063,
0.1256540418,
-0.7303398252,
-0.0082898485,
-0.4083298743,
-0.7305304408,
0.9182475805,
0.1966533363,
-0.5012527704,
0.3671609759,
-0.6958960891,
-0.2922891974,
-0.1979143918,
0.004727351,
-0.2848986983,
0.294878304,
0.0844201222,
0.502561152,
-0.1392414868,
0.3798920214,
-0.1150066629,
-0.0040737232,
0.4930583239,
-0.5199555755,
0.3862597346,
0.4192439914,
-0.0966534913,
0.0593469515,
-0.9359775782,
-0.1813106686,
-0.0123516927,
-0.1706843972,
-0.4554870725,
0.0306858327,
0.096970275,
0.0472334996,
-0.0247861333,
-0.3853464723,
-0.0679509193,
-0.5293459892,
0.7853003144,
0.465195626,
0.2044631541,
0.8072255254,
-0.1884595305,
0.3805591166,
0.1431440562,
-0.2043954283,
0.0308605935,
-0.7608790398,
-0.345444113,
-0.4877144694,
0.2905884981,
0.3811534345,
-0.7213163376,
0.4752393961,
-0.0369291641,
-0.6051931977,
-0.3730730712,
-0.0205703285,
-0.0695021227,
0.548843205,
0.3572300076,
-0.2220935524,
-0.0602803491,
-0.4988580048,
0.0156620275,
0.1011663601,
-0.2409517765,
0.1801351607,
0.1660293937,
-0.3487834632,
1.3613694906,
-0.6097506881,
-0.2417159826,
0.2023239136,
0.1629125029,
-0.0148559017,
0.6442463994,
0.4590776265,
-0.9817222953,
-0.0056942347,
-0.4792202115,
-0.4282741249,
-0.391559273,
0.0548209772,
-0.1075288057,
0.0209007561,
0.7702389359,
-0.7831436992,
0.6216134429,
0.6431750655,
-0.4854329526,
0.2633448541,
-0.3502140939,
0.0979733989,
-0.9235574007,
-0.1535778046,
-0.1693955511,
-0.0671529472,
-0.8175549507,
-0.3801407516,
-0.46189031,
-0.2655309141,
-0.5280615687,
0.50020504,
-0.4380718172,
-0.3613201678,
-0.3104627132,
0.7506605387,
0.1073265001,
0.1558614522,
0.3051250577,
0.8101990223,
0.5970543027,
-0.6257164478,
0.1479539722,
0.4680030942,
-0.3106182814,
0.5748807788,
-0.6693567634,
0.1562551707,
-0.1544389874,
0.2250803858,
-1.3997585773,
0.0168942269,
-0.0181256682,
-0.3949600458,
0.289134115,
-0.485807389,
-0.4551977813,
0.2597262859,
0.1050796211,
0.5415999889,
0.6432255507,
-0.4168308973,
0.5832176805,
0.8347549438,
-0.487298727,
-0.2389431149,
-0.7006858587,
0.2145702392,
-0.357090801,
-0.6919913292,
0.7543087602,
-0.1476108879,
-0.3726889491,
0.3552902639,
-0.0311351791,
-0.5931438208,
0.1284659356,
0.2416665107,
0.1886189133,
-0.1182021797,
0.1570982188,
0.5798438191,
-0.2384079248,
-0.1152868941,
-0.6761811376,
0.116966024,
0.3708425462,
0.0356174409,
-0.3500750363,
0.3694900572,
0.6639398336,
0.1401568651,
0.4223615527,
0.3536773026,
-0.3586268425,
-0.1654576361,
-0.3460459709,
-0.0926556364,
-0.4106976092,
0.3328699768,
-0.2968229949,
-1.0892100334,
0.5594998002,
-0.3226191998,
-0.1467223912,
0.5652248859,
0.4072523415,
0.0107999565,
0.8398894668,
0.5333490968,
0.5317475796,
0.5819416642,
-0.4450172186,
-0.1234388202,
-0.8694047332,
-0.1504763514,
-0.6779506803,
0.1531540006,
-0.5849080682,
-0.90053159,
0.500520885,
0.0409066789,
0.0740982294,
0.0118852034,
-0.5531238317,
0.2130945474,
0.2549333572,
-0.051841896,
0.1066378728,
0.1282689422,
-0.3237388432,
-0.3979398608,
-0.9093182683,
-0.4424708784,
0.6524499059,
0.3964759409,
0.6692885756,
0.1630919725,
0.3278046846,
0.3574908078,
-0.3498215377,
-0.6141585112,
0.5472972393,
-0.4938299954,
-0.4021432102,
-0.5107747912,
-0.3875092864,
-0.9412811399,
0.2585978508,
-0.2617604733,
-0.5521079898,
0.1692845821,
-0.0034651416,
-0.1957832277,
0.3411076963,
-0.6226790547,
0.750428021,
0.2975788414,
-0.3847643733,
-0.3642308414,
-0.5893663168,
-0.2061532736,
-0.1524334997,
0.3077926636,
-0.1918445081,
-0.3800805211,
1.0717998743,
-0.5854485631,
0.8183060884,
-0.4967390299,
-0.3930925727,
0.458547622,
0.2944681346,
0.0165389758,
0.0362320989,
0.1895601898,
0.3942891061,
0.0610814318,
-0.1798357069,
-0.7170491815,
0.7229082584,
-0.7345083356,
-0.5121467113,
-0.0187769309,
-0.4304599166,
-0.3969110847,
0.2223338634,
0.2110589445,
0.6137909293,
-0.3658833504,
-0.0630642846,
0.8844271302,
-0.5099764466,
0.36198017,
0.3739873767,
-0.0440216474,
-0.4808863699,
0.6051783562,
0.3185569644,
0.269028157,
0.4187112153,
0.4264130592,
-0.5847245455,
-0.7445914149,
-0.5944935083,
0.1258841753,
-0.8845692873,
0.1035826281,
-0.7648448348,
-0.2664419115,
-0.413833946,
-0.2896193862,
-0.8166960478,
-0.8399429321,
-0.7283221483,
0.0713552088,
0.5499681234,
0.8242068887,
-0.2035952061,
0.4964690208,
-0.7861964107,
0.4863203168,
0.2808746994,
0.4197178781,
-0.00397379,
-0.6860888004,
-0.0338049084,
0.0291229673,
0.0660146847,
-0.8426918983,
0.3611483574,
0.0155194262,
0.4543055594,
-0.0379112363,
-0.1427907497,
0.6465992332,
-0.547771275,
1.1730223894,
0.1530062407,
-1.0997829437,
0.5937345028,
-0.282528311,
0.3676051199,
-0.0878532305,
0.1342694163,
-0.2780745924,
-0.6964832544,
-0.7583291531,
-0.8944320679,
0.4053739011,
0.3609684408,
0.2681851089,
0.0874119326,
0.5200072527,
0.0771889091,
0.3157882094,
-0.2287029773,
-0.219291538,
-0.4346195757,
-0.0436168648,
0.0077741346,
-0.4126835167,
0.0499731153,
-0.0643994063,
0.4674336612,
0.2489081025,
0.3102692664,
0.3787272274,
0.1152302995,
-0.053339649,
0.3557658195,
0.5741980076,
0.4437321424,
-0.0432539955,
0.1755324453,
0.0059121219,
-0.5870896578,
0.2877461016,
-0.0420342162,
-0.27328372,
0.3101095855,
0.172317639,
0.817812562,
0.1212648451,
-0.3460126519,
0.4444113076,
-0.1441018581,
-0.1944321692,
-0.3004766405,
0.104264833,
0.0469463579,
0.1988265663,
0.2731977403,
0.1526020318,
0.298853159,
-0.0847860128,
0.2845077813,
0.5191289186,
-0.5853888988,
-0.3615024388,
0.9112896919,
0.0254014656,
-0.1270231456,
0.5498391986,
0.0936850831,
-0.1396562159,
0.2196277082,
0.2460209727,
0.9983449578,
-0.0651929528,
0.1133698225,
-0.127323851,
-0.0303214099,
0.2207762748,
0.0164007191,
-0.2256859839,
-0.7454339862,
-0.5730178952,
-0.4739429951,
-0.176000163,
-0.0209386367,
-0.3486827016,
0.2010128498,
-0.3399578035,
-0.4787253141,
0.3501038551,
-0.5044921637,
-0.2955753803,
0.4017497301,
-0.198857829,
0.6973608136,
-0.5853962302,
0.6702870727,
0.4197051823,
0.0254330132,
-0.5916141868,
0.0219159871,
-0.0484046377,
-0.3160003722,
0.7360818386,
-0.4449109435,
-0.4179902971,
0.1888554394,
-0.3730252683,
-0.8145878315,
0.7161899805,
0.3248206973,
-0.2594617903,
-0.083437711,
0.0524461046,
0.6892537475,
-0.2555923164,
-0.0055349483,
0.431671679,
0.1264234036,
0.5405853391,
-0.5904791951,
-0.2695365846,
-0.0188285895,
0.2752824128,
0.0630271807,
-0.1117528751,
0.7094578743,
-0.1813215315,
-0.1649131179,
0.1304265708,
0.4988662004,
-0.1183015779,
0.3024799526,
0.5906032324,
0.6016523838,
0.4033602774,
-0.1727881879,
0.601433754,
-0.162059322,
0.0194923002,
0.8647882938,
-0.1126040295,
0.7827617526,
0.5092139244,
-0.0144334016,
0.5406884551,
0.4982447624,
0.1752507389,
0.838131547,
0.0853728428,
-0.2986813486,
-0.1059934199,
-0.1415429413,
-0.222723648,
0.5538132191,
0.6634535789,
-0.1347062737,
-0.0166155417,
0.120390527,
0.0290854219,
0.1700424999,
0.0422646962,
1.1192946434,
-0.0788201764,
-0.335532248,
0.5329836607,
0.0202451553,
0.3984875381,
-0.4814409316,
-0.2394717038,
-0.0322661251,
-0.3195745945,
-0.0656323582,
-0.9354097843,
0.6736312509,
-0.0276381094,
-0.2571723759,
-0.265632242,
0.6119882464,
-0.3768560886,
-0.1167179272,
0.4009113014,
0.5947725773,
0.2184848636,
0.1483292431,
-0.47375983,
0.0792612135,
-0.3926089108,
-0.1678085923,
0.1263884306,
0.6675115824,
0.0915374979,
0.3581598401,
0.6580004096,
0.4237816334,
0.0503582172,
0.0999179706,
0.715511322,
-0.6432397366,
-0.8331665993,
-0.5854840279,
0.4567041993,
0.2643364072,
-0.1401768774,
0.5073035359,
0.4820354283,
0.7859017849,
-0.0640548542,
0.7438881993,
0.1397163719,
0.6595878005,
-0.9761781693,
0.7744845748,
-0.6850050092,
0.4061695039,
-0.7535836697,
-0.7137894034,
-0.3767389655,
0.5291367769,
-0.1555445343,
0.0383083597,
0.3405104876,
0.9777655602,
0.0088741509,
-0.0778897107,
0.6615952849,
0.2852379084,
0.2241597772,
0.1005544513,
1.197665453,
-0.3264482319,
0.3649940491,
-0.048567716,
-0.31372118,
0.2530705333,
-0.957726717,
-0.5939244032,
-0.9811335802,
-0.7735860944,
-0.3853268921,
-0.0541704148,
0.3679576814,
0.8581248522,
-0.3023084998,
-0.2055139095,
-0.3065166175,
0.3679668903,
-0.0371278338,
-0.1518158615,
0.4291918576,
-0.0229339562,
-0.7005231977,
0.593231976,
0.5297343731,
0.7292640805,
-0.1536192298,
0.042656824,
0.1345238835,
0.2016792148,
0.6159963608,
-0.2379293889,
-0.8430008888,
0.0143571235,
-0.0172445402,
-0.0061573554,
0.0164669994,
0.7942203879,
-0.7393767834,
0.6975860596,
0.376259774,
0.4499691725,
0.5270437002,
-0.3785690367,
0.4290228188,
-0.7720130682,
0.4947468936,
0.1782204211,
0.1043546051,
0.4049327374,
-0.1195879206,
0.2058976144,
0.5433381796,
-0.4100416899,
-0.6352502704,
-0.0291378908,
-0.9407234192,
-0.6180761456,
1.0674234629,
0.0556295961,
-0.096358344,
-0.2508693635,
-0.1753121018,
0.523479104,
-0.3298371434,
0.6140027046,
0.5758320093,
-0.0502987802,
-0.014242433,
-0.5169371367,
0.7226392627,
0.2452085465,
-0.453777492,
0.1778398752,
0.9181892276,
0.3500183523,
0.2073953599,
0.6265158653,
-0.3454874158,
0.2069903016,
0.3022694588,
-0.288292855,
0.2536526918,
-0.3732312918,
-0.4743744433,
0.0703993738,
0.1272440255,
-0.0204285402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12261v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12261v3
|
NEO-BENCH: Evaluating Robustness of Large Language Models with Neologisms
| 2024-02-19T16:19:15 | 2024-06-05T17:12:23 |
Jonathan Zheng, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) degrades from the temporal
drift between data used for model training and newer text seen during
inference. One understudied avenue of language change causing data drift is the
emergence of neologisms -- new word forms -- over time. We create a diverse
resource of recent English neologisms by using several popular collection
methods. We analyze temporal drift using neologisms by comparing sentences
containing new words with near-identical sentences that replace neologisms with
existing substitute words. Model performance is nearly halved in machine
translation when a single neologism is introduced in a sentence. Motivated by
these results, we construct a benchmark to evaluate LLMs' ability to generalize
to neologisms with various natural language understanding tasks and model
perplexity. Models with later knowledge cutoff dates yield lower perplexities
and perform better in downstream tasks. LLMs are also affected differently
based on the linguistic origins of words, indicating that neologisms are
complex for static LLMs to address. We will release our benchmark and code for
reproducing our experiments.
|
[
-0.180094704,
-0.9030877948,
0.6281363964,
0.0879306719,
-0.2905527055,
0.202195093,
-0.3175488412,
-0.4775366783,
0.0853318498,
0.3766185641,
-0.6463397145,
-0.3506850302,
-0.4507820606,
0.2590064406,
-0.5969352722,
0.6684833765,
0.0205780864,
0.0303448029,
-0.3383284807,
-0.2229215056,
-0.0516761802,
-0.3669758439,
-0.3459989429,
-0.5486015081,
0.2042916864,
-0.124254927,
0.8372045159,
0.7917647958,
0.4652376473,
0.3091925383,
-0.4018319845,
0.0300963167,
-0.4673122466,
0.2787948847,
-0.3512217402,
-0.6575404406,
-0.4896079898,
0.0192318,
0.8222215772,
0.8828936815,
-0.0943172723,
0.0902154669,
-0.175025776,
0.2757140696,
-0.6940215826,
-0.0566109568,
-0.9071798325,
-0.2408878505,
-0.2678720057,
-0.0415910147,
-0.24332425,
-0.332898587,
0.0667333752,
-0.5891256332,
0.3410637677,
-0.2146060169,
0.8549696207,
0.3262840509,
0.0176605657,
-0.2023261487,
-0.5998783708,
0.8348641396,
-0.9177108407,
0.4403433502,
0.3065621853,
0.3893747032,
-0.0999426842,
-0.7743403316,
-0.4757950306,
-0.4902101457,
0.1775490791,
-0.0919631496,
-0.1680746377,
-0.4310329556,
0.3457561731,
0.2372914702,
-0.5906357169,
0.3291201293,
0.3257749081,
-0.1076337546,
0.4571399391,
0.3525854051,
-0.088415876,
-0.2735185921,
-0.2916359603,
-0.2821161151,
-0.8386138082,
-0.3292768598,
0.3837566972,
0.2946664095,
-0.0441498868,
0.1828712225,
-0.2611358464,
0.6100499034,
-0.2885595262,
-0.2654675543,
0.3725282252,
-0.423173815,
-0.073097311,
-0.2738512158,
0.7194541693,
0.4164522588,
0.1823768914,
-0.3810418546,
-0.3058778644,
0.304762423,
-0.0497151986,
-0.7726135254,
0.0447515175,
-0.0308126081,
-0.3491046429,
-0.2088586539,
-0.3126840591,
-0.6410264373,
-0.5590816736,
-0.2062912583,
0.1008632481,
-0.4257327616,
-0.2854475975,
0.0936515927,
-0.2043823749,
-0.0777602494,
0.2346534878,
-0.5574968457,
0.6438630819,
0.8569214344,
0.7731363773,
-0.0494048595,
-0.2638872564,
-0.4930742383,
0.0578128174,
-0.4574620724,
0.7657619119,
-0.5486565232,
-0.3044486046,
0.1110854745,
0.030954048,
-0.0365060195,
-0.8687843084,
0.2796154618,
-0.4342665076,
0.1997522414,
-0.086588949,
-0.572896421,
0.164899379,
0.4540441036,
-0.4247520864,
0.830565393,
0.110070318,
-0.6289463043,
0.4002020061,
-0.2948313057,
-0.1674529016,
0.2081851065,
-0.0558354259,
-0.0425509475,
0.2761681974,
-0.0528484322,
0.218247056,
-0.4964876473,
0.2153590024,
-0.6549304128,
-0.1885467917,
0.5195567012,
-0.3270091414,
0.6188203692,
0.0972818732,
-0.2761551142,
-0.2565205395,
-0.7395839691,
0.0801357552,
0.2154431194,
-0.0945410654,
-0.5829116702,
0.3676789403,
0.177115649,
0.2084803581,
0.2721061409,
-0.3376861513,
0.2328977287,
-0.4752466679,
0.564201057,
0.7080098987,
-0.1548732966,
0.111949183,
-0.3887480199,
0.603061378,
-0.2289240807,
0.1318175048,
0.0689747408,
-0.1560850888,
-0.4517923295,
-0.0037803296,
0.4278946221,
0.5736600161,
-0.4765727222,
0.153637737,
-0.5885052085,
-0.4486731291,
-0.2789090574,
0.321093291,
0.2714380622,
0.2511989176,
0.2568849921,
-0.6187950373,
-0.3215052485,
-0.9974367619,
-0.4153169096,
-0.1211714745,
-0.0437592193,
0.2290749103,
0.4209663272,
-0.6113562584,
0.6360703707,
-0.1674354076,
0.2693650723,
-0.1636497527,
0.2637014389,
0.2542765141,
0.1475154459,
0.5663276315,
-0.3673374653,
-0.1609202772,
-0.0052690106,
-0.484246552,
-0.3031821549,
-0.0187836289,
0.1148864552,
0.3478252292,
0.7147454023,
-0.6128287315,
0.2255013883,
0.6623557806,
-0.2730032206,
0.5716409683,
0.159934029,
-0.3883153796,
-1.2189313173,
0.195968315,
-0.180797115,
-0.3051045239,
-0.3222428858,
-0.0878906399,
0.0031272811,
0.168481335,
-0.3064727783,
0.6478864551,
-0.4550879002,
-0.2476449609,
-0.3250311613,
0.5975543261,
-0.1896241158,
-0.2776819468,
0.0102565167,
0.3511679471,
0.3439200521,
-0.6372743845,
0.2388701141,
0.0636398047,
-0.5170127153,
0.4580663443,
-0.416995734,
0.2134551555,
-0.0629911348,
0.1039052904,
-0.6823641062,
-0.0312383436,
-0.1853008717,
-0.3254655898,
0.573872447,
-0.1806126684,
-0.5356398821,
-0.123556979,
-0.2179681212,
0.1302104145,
0.390022248,
-0.1432327181,
0.3106727898,
0.2002800107,
-0.142955035,
-0.7462351322,
-0.6826677918,
0.3156779706,
-0.1373327374,
-0.4651456177,
0.3621961176,
-0.0504259579,
-0.6930053234,
0.2921697795,
-0.338760227,
0.0936564058,
0.5233842731,
-0.0467104688,
0.0174308158,
-0.1978594363,
0.210541144,
-0.1707553118,
-0.0890517458,
0.2708544731,
-0.1276198775,
0.9347528815,
-0.0388797745,
-0.0727766082,
-0.2863832414,
0.124238573,
0.7196348906,
-0.0073442901,
0.6852045655,
0.5970659852,
-0.2870870233,
-0.2853374183,
-0.5395433903,
-0.3152324259,
-0.4279527962,
0.5700972676,
-0.2656306624,
-0.6927823424,
0.5668706298,
-0.2260682881,
0.2033132911,
0.5746584535,
0.4753365219,
0.0796641409,
0.7936295867,
0.4657200873,
-0.0477388501,
0.4878541231,
-0.3102270663,
-0.042935133,
-0.8822094202,
-0.0646793023,
-0.5588415265,
-0.2952368259,
-0.7618201375,
-0.4056613743,
-0.0333894789,
-0.0049307807,
0.0801745728,
0.3657459021,
-0.0303516351,
0.2630821764,
0.3059335053,
-0.2566459477,
0.3096090555,
-0.0308963452,
-0.1706573963,
-0.0877908915,
-0.7238200903,
-0.6068072319,
1.1891914606,
0.2486233115,
0.9835541248,
0.2419078499,
0.5821908116,
0.1002861634,
0.5133631825,
-0.6326996088,
0.6211668253,
-0.2033732384,
-0.6991716027,
0.0826508775,
-0.6424318552,
-0.9530066848,
0.0276794322,
-0.2801940143,
-0.7912165523,
0.0180745851,
-0.0415646024,
0.0005320036,
0.1154256761,
-0.3662821054,
0.9623471498,
-0.4462132156,
-0.5997288227,
-0.452885747,
-0.5419978499,
0.3677795827,
-0.0149098318,
0.3502226174,
-0.340403378,
-0.4400927126,
0.6946228743,
-0.3859568238,
0.7071025968,
0.0195932388,
0.0039151763,
-0.0042006732,
0.3772218823,
0.3400692344,
0.3007197678,
-0.0694631338,
-0.0254054274,
0.200640738,
-0.3829576075,
-0.5277993083,
0.8223205209,
-0.6571323872,
-0.397818923,
-0.4545992017,
-0.7325886488,
-0.5025697947,
0.2802399993,
0.3303253949,
0.4889189601,
-0.5076288581,
0.1605522633,
0.5454983115,
-0.0181947388,
0.61426121,
0.7033127546,
-0.4422180355,
-0.4188786745,
0.6001892686,
0.1296644211,
0.5663945675,
0.4001567066,
0.3481842875,
-0.4194423854,
-0.8777500391,
-0.1380210668,
0.4022150934,
-0.4422141612,
0.0293086916,
-0.4640168548,
0.1296022236,
-0.5314525962,
0.0510674939,
-0.541860342,
-0.5510491133,
0.0077128196,
0.215244472,
0.2279053032,
0.7655497193,
-0.0584193952,
0.2070647776,
-0.671747148,
0.1065740883,
0.2694507837,
0.1531757265,
-0.4284618497,
-0.7720184922,
-0.2027632147,
-0.1616476029,
-0.1294897497,
-0.872993052,
0.2884303033,
0.272996366,
0.6732168794,
0.5186350346,
-0.2817775309,
0.4346042871,
-0.3178427517,
0.6431543231,
-0.0004213072,
-0.9521030188,
0.4583431184,
-0.5605549812,
0.6588133574,
0.5916632414,
0.4529844224,
-0.8034852147,
-0.2946329117,
-0.8593749404,
-0.8653069139,
0.3809871674,
-0.1435045749,
0.0910135955,
-0.0963538066,
0.301802814,
0.1092632562,
0.3857568204,
-0.5372688174,
-0.000337431,
0.03181725,
0.0215357244,
-0.5364390016,
-0.2442228198,
-0.2299133092,
-0.0686213002,
0.621555388,
-0.299755156,
-0.0153992949,
-0.0635299683,
-0.3114524186,
-0.0604280047,
0.3113886118,
0.5331374407,
0.9895555973,
-0.3860548139,
0.1933153868,
0.3639496565,
-0.4904311597,
-0.0331495777,
0.401067853,
-0.2936577797,
0.3043479323,
0.6481271982,
0.6282695532,
0.2496317178,
-0.7901802063,
0.1559927464,
-0.1613718718,
-0.0695155263,
-0.2364479452,
0.0088599538,
0.3867625892,
0.0185767617,
0.0523258187,
0.0928998291,
-0.1200622097,
-0.9459697008,
0.1118715703,
0.5733426213,
-0.2234822959,
-0.4337104857,
0.4021345973,
-0.0641727373,
-0.2443617135,
0.5845063329,
-0.3637958765,
-0.5075652003,
0.2846130729,
0.6173243523,
0.8189962506,
-0.4385698736,
0.091055885,
0.1788759828,
0.6018291116,
-0.1272439659,
0.1099753454,
0.2512389421,
-0.6153205037,
-0.6470999718,
-0.6153889894,
-0.5183290243,
0.4268606603,
-0.60565418,
0.0289597865,
-0.638143301,
-0.5094183087,
-0.1182638705,
0.0744251683,
-0.511397481,
-0.0426249318,
0.2942762375,
1.1258709431,
-0.9675283432,
0.5221047401,
0.92083776,
0.1107333824,
-0.3055324554,
-0.046888601,
0.1348088682,
-0.6454582214,
0.3851214051,
0.1077154502,
-0.1455344409,
-0.3666000366,
-0.4587746561,
-0.9972792864,
0.8765175939,
0.5822333694,
-0.6306481957,
-0.0110065034,
0.1023135483,
0.5931342244,
-0.1984498203,
0.3019735217,
0.6991567016,
0.333499521,
-0.1205760092,
-0.887075305,
-0.0235458016,
-0.2684159875,
-0.057877183,
0.4781502485,
-0.5111457705,
0.8959416747,
0.1712663472,
-0.3014407754,
0.2718194127,
0.2227208912,
-0.0747961402,
0.4002883732,
0.5481584668,
1.0085985661,
0.8029623032,
-0.1822936535,
1.1058559418,
-0.1755576134,
0.2259022892,
1.2162588835,
-0.3087435961,
1.0003702641,
0.3935913444,
-0.2787122726,
0.7606870532,
0.4421319664,
0.1928494871,
0.3418769538,
0.4417020082,
-0.0706050843,
-0.4491919875,
-0.261364162,
-0.4465131164,
0.4469991326,
0.5445470214,
-0.3160726726,
-0.4064995646,
-0.414653331,
0.2653605342,
0.062669009,
-0.1141708344,
0.5954700112,
0.1753432602,
-0.7040160298,
0.8491631746,
-0.1381180733,
0.4642289579,
-0.7035548687,
0.406902343,
-0.3294352889,
0.4628435373,
-0.0826338753,
-0.3250310421,
0.2724028528,
0.0546491891,
-0.0971262604,
-0.0595016032,
0.4357632995,
-0.1364304274,
-0.5028784871,
0.3285109997,
0.6838603616,
0.2005705833,
0.0138799474,
-0.8067439795,
0.2443143427,
-0.3203384578,
-0.1568931341,
0.4221673012,
0.3354814351,
-0.0504602268,
0.6621786952,
0.4652148485,
0.1188019961,
0.1547162831,
0.1752814204,
0.727799654,
-0.729744494,
-0.1406625509,
-0.7963142991,
0.0828564987,
-0.2773585618,
-0.6458539963,
0.7629680634,
0.5671152472,
0.7363734841,
0.232071206,
0.5655146837,
-0.0923919529,
0.5708911419,
-0.6282114983,
0.4655321538,
-0.6870541573,
0.2674118578,
-0.2986762524,
-1.1433091164,
-0.1460535228,
0.4074910879,
-0.5229282975,
-0.0115276445,
0.9870860577,
0.776974082,
-0.0208998229,
-0.1970429868,
0.1000417694,
0.4041063786,
0.116631791,
0.6026406884,
1.2060105801,
-0.3034979999,
0.2957849503,
-0.3528354466,
-0.2486666739,
-0.3514200151,
-1.0204894543,
-0.8867946267,
-0.246935457,
-0.4241035879,
-0.4303280413,
0.1748440862,
0.5910057425,
0.5892298818,
-0.6651178002,
-0.3954312801,
-0.1939426661,
-0.0436929129,
-0.3548561931,
-0.1787003279,
0.143608138,
-0.4893876016,
-0.6323085427,
0.761080265,
-0.1078712195,
-0.0327474102,
-0.3441057205,
0.0574033782,
-0.2619733512,
-0.0114841228,
0.4447309673,
0.2567834556,
-0.5126490593,
-0.1025284007,
0.3096565008,
0.0339895934,
-0.2374880165,
0.7034181952,
-0.7291892171,
0.4477843642,
0.5619718432,
0.4970047772,
0.6239141822,
-0.0531191453,
0.4932155311,
-0.335623771,
0.1183481067,
0.5740308762,
0.3325790465,
0.5973017216,
0.331846714,
0.4901543856,
0.6016898155,
-0.4212876558,
-1.0062949657,
0.3709576726,
-0.7768093944,
-0.4196466506,
1.092045784,
0.1658296585,
-0.4478435218,
0.0364009365,
0.463206172,
0.02005459,
-0.025692163,
0.6259652376,
0.7995684743,
0.1073561609,
0.0737214014,
-0.6299875379,
0.4815808237,
0.7785012722,
-0.675691545,
0.2324673384,
0.6171543002,
0.4448113739,
0.4743019938,
0.2042367905,
-0.1558915824,
0.3420417905,
0.1627654135,
-0.1080345064,
0.0854888409,
-0.1601384729,
-0.3470002413,
0.0173207447,
0.4193553627,
0.0793079287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12255v1
|
Shallow Synthesis of Knowledge in GPT-Generated Texts: A Case Study in Automatic Related Work Composition
| 2024-02-19T16:14:04 | 2024-02-19T16:14:04 |
Anna Martin-Boyle, Aahan Tyagi, Marti A. Hearst, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Numerous AI-assisted scholarly applications have been developed to aid
different stages of the research process. We present an analysis of AI-assisted
scholarly writing generated with ScholaCite, a tool we built that is designed
for organizing literature and composing Related Work sections for academic
papers. Our evaluation method focuses on the analysis of citation graphs to
assess the structural complexity and inter-connectedness of citations in texts
and involves a three-way comparison between (1) original human-written texts,
(2) purely GPT-generated texts, and (3) human-AI collaborative texts. We find
that GPT-4 can generate reasonable coarse-grained citation groupings to support
human users in brainstorming, but fails to perform detailed synthesis of
related works without human intervention. We suggest that future writing
assistant tools should not be used to draft text independently of the human
author.
|
[
-0.0657505095,
-0.6379782557,
0.8097856641,
0.1318704486,
0.0144934682,
0.2420033813,
0.0190965366,
-0.7472182512,
0.3210437894,
0.1778776199,
-0.4187223613,
-0.465190798,
-0.1971017867,
0.3765875101,
-0.432923466,
1.3972194195,
-0.33636415,
-0.099699311,
-0.6069675088,
-0.0081113931,
-0.2472508103,
-0.2332428098,
-0.4931129217,
-0.213217482,
0.5498340726,
0.0639905855,
0.4054032266,
0.502241075,
0.8505322337,
0.4381063879,
0.2545861304,
0.2736676633,
-0.2600799799,
0.4827049673,
-0.3442944884,
-0.0654398501,
-0.7023608088,
0.1748902798,
0.4063266516,
0.6848062873,
0.4402812123,
0.1939800084,
0.280143261,
0.7814153433,
-0.4922456443,
0.2344091237,
-0.6692637205,
-0.0019422378,
-0.3192546368,
-0.2342629582,
-0.1850171834,
-0.5272001028,
0.3540246189,
-0.6719835401,
0.4891118407,
0.1261595935,
0.5985592604,
0.3512925506,
0.1058760732,
-0.9196212888,
-0.8000206351,
0.4963651896,
-0.482573539,
-0.3088311553,
0.2997305989,
-0.0286629684,
0.0119337551,
-1.0971230268,
-0.5442043543,
-0.299916178,
-0.2888036668,
0.3822399974,
-0.1582983136,
0.198844552,
-0.0214318819,
0.3449299932,
-0.8847308755,
-0.4113920033,
-0.6784176826,
-0.3772486448,
0.7664098144,
0.244120419,
0.4516095519,
-0.2318577915,
-0.0599336177,
0.1683660299,
-0.5082913041,
-0.5328185558,
0.445132941,
0.1422886103,
0.4514621496,
0.8663858175,
-0.0291680582,
0.4149474204,
-0.0500180572,
0.030218767,
0.0813014358,
-0.5549260378,
-0.2839742005,
0.0770899802,
1.0315976143,
0.2394191921,
0.2555676997,
-0.4720532894,
-0.0868582428,
0.1604328007,
0.3080705106,
-0.5506635904,
-0.3926543891,
0.1585272849,
-0.2595860958,
-0.3784658909,
0.0074202991,
-0.1078072563,
-0.396458596,
-0.3347719908,
0.2708453834,
-0.2500290275,
0.1477606893,
-0.3711230159,
-0.298946619,
-0.5243073106,
0.2343631983,
-0.6400868297,
0.1941936463,
0.2479633838,
0.907284081,
-0.4248516262,
-0.7441464067,
-0.1879806072,
0.6499271393,
-0.1312185824,
0.8473434448,
-0.2251789719,
-0.5382075906,
-0.0535823181,
-0.2886115909,
-0.1022541597,
-0.2562358975,
0.4606886208,
-0.3727842867,
0.449156791,
-0.2162058651,
-0.5421826839,
0.0622009225,
0.0763400048,
-0.6855109334,
1.0443819761,
0.4158132076,
-1.2385574579,
0.4597423077,
-0.7496478558,
-0.6149318218,
0.1836016923,
-0.3724808991,
-0.1435180455,
0.0023615519,
0.0087351454,
0.4639344513,
-0.3117557168,
0.2672799826,
-0.1275069416,
-0.5983992815,
0.0763032287,
-0.0528933182,
0.6116960645,
0.1985629201,
-0.5304884315,
0.4194566309,
-0.628700316,
-0.1469715238,
-0.152578339,
-0.253621757,
-0.5137298107,
-0.1541842371,
0.1240159869,
-0.0138608729,
0.3383184671,
-0.2785087824,
0.4793128073,
-0.1334060431,
0.5351623297,
0.730687201,
0.2198538631,
0.6757212281,
-0.2722562253,
0.4659058452,
-0.5422309637,
-0.0702594519,
0.1297211498,
-0.363342315,
-0.6154692173,
-0.1502950191,
0.3878790438,
0.4507194757,
-1.0746366978,
0.2702549696,
-0.3380240202,
-0.5515009165,
-0.2446280122,
0.0587947518,
0.3352990746,
0.3648999929,
0.3958597779,
-0.2727430761,
-0.4586388767,
-0.9158539772,
-0.509293139,
-0.4415808618,
-0.0939199477,
0.1613992155,
0.6200832129,
-0.203743428,
0.8773053885,
-0.5378991961,
-0.5690341592,
-0.0744926035,
0.4759589136,
-0.4006448984,
0.4947986603,
0.5385448337,
-0.2022932768,
-0.8343607187,
0.090731293,
-1.0977287292,
-0.1109553874,
-0.3083672523,
-0.274761647,
0.113358967,
0.8536865711,
-0.6736632586,
0.4882354736,
0.1074542403,
-0.0918208137,
0.5573894978,
-0.2456123829,
0.1184571311,
-0.6766491532,
0.4695004821,
-0.2503094971,
0.3034041226,
-0.4067817628,
0.0890670344,
-0.378737241,
-0.063142851,
0.0683778822,
0.3666553199,
-0.6948119998,
-0.1621217281,
-0.2939038873,
0.347124815,
-0.0499523208,
0.4514168203,
-0.0106687769,
0.9298985004,
0.0556565747,
-0.1271935552,
-0.1121377274,
0.0834493414,
-0.1817193776,
0.5091714859,
-0.8634954691,
0.4565657079,
0.1475356519,
0.2922112942,
-0.7357895374,
-0.5367963314,
0.3315350413,
-0.2194424123,
0.0851939246,
-0.1309007257,
-0.6038828492,
-0.2567425072,
-0.3883026242,
0.5393678546,
0.0378196836,
0.27390939,
0.7857183218,
0.1390668005,
-0.8198820353,
-0.2704752982,
-0.7638335824,
0.1780685931,
-0.1097865626,
-0.736851275,
0.6341859698,
-0.2467984557,
-0.4670440257,
0.3651178777,
0.3195041716,
-0.1087814569,
-0.2217293233,
0.3723451197,
0.2762601376,
0.087207444,
0.0956296548,
0.4862165749,
0.1487911344,
0.0372011065,
-0.2198970318,
0.1041721776,
-0.2820249498,
-0.4548988044,
-0.3575976491,
0.5043556094,
0.639826715,
0.0553111732,
0.2400574237,
0.8295487165,
-0.0250374563,
0.0911949724,
-0.3070726693,
-0.0947370306,
-0.4303621948,
0.0776868612,
-0.1491089016,
-0.79757303,
0.5248534679,
0.2258112729,
0.2280505896,
0.7711974382,
0.4176669121,
-0.1596766561,
0.6710921526,
0.3000251055,
-0.116076827,
0.3393730521,
-0.234094888,
0.1032947302,
-0.7034373283,
-0.0998025462,
-0.6378585696,
-0.2590083778,
-0.5984011889,
-0.1467861086,
0.5101456642,
-0.1459538639,
-0.2030412108,
0.1604796648,
-0.9545547962,
0.3539363444,
0.7754602432,
-0.1416612715,
0.4659729898,
0.2219459563,
0.0237223301,
-0.1904085129,
-0.6122582555,
-0.5119669437,
1.0518139601,
-0.1737695783,
0.35774526,
-0.2264560759,
1.0002808571,
0.6801226735,
0.5949350595,
-0.6178062558,
0.4561799467,
0.1161699519,
-0.5549128056,
-0.5186670423,
-0.192188561,
-0.8106120229,
0.1861442626,
-0.1649239957,
-0.4654927552,
0.0504460037,
-0.0282109361,
-0.1283973455,
-0.1067242026,
-0.7199572921,
0.4249721766,
0.0115305465,
-0.6672472358,
-0.0149207665,
-0.6290789247,
0.1675047576,
0.0610893518,
0.2078461498,
0.3703824282,
0.2926482558,
0.9145559072,
-0.4695193768,
0.6318724751,
-0.1540842056,
-0.0341351852,
0.8260126114,
0.3200161457,
0.614559114,
-0.0323104523,
-0.2474986464,
-0.2072524577,
-0.2180187404,
-0.4116404057,
-0.3963923156,
0.910012722,
-0.5840337276,
-0.5165553689,
-0.6355400085,
-0.9227129817,
-0.0991685763,
0.5521367788,
0.4945031404,
0.3036189377,
-0.2550736666,
-0.0882894546,
-0.0510894433,
0.3752250671,
0.4588755667,
-0.1477376968,
0.0759281814,
-0.6238447428,
1.0738679171,
0.2852734923,
-0.1588582546,
-0.1220799163,
-0.0955572128,
0.0761477277,
-0.9929805398,
-0.660503149,
0.292586565,
-0.7286348343,
0.0121445181,
-0.4452393055,
-0.1457093954,
-0.3089538813,
-0.4809158444,
-0.0163049344,
-0.517228663,
-0.4135708213,
-0.046806246,
-0.0291042328,
1.2139960527,
-0.01292706,
-0.0539204702,
-0.6962257028,
-0.1662215441,
0.3120224774,
-0.1410596818,
0.1508025527,
0.1269821376,
-0.4772159159,
-0.2284507751,
-0.3306341469,
-0.5945415497,
0.083185643,
0.0478019528,
0.2981779575,
0.1000346541,
-0.038293492,
0.5240707994,
-0.5135304332,
1.0853946209,
0.0259483494,
-0.9202471972,
0.3770308197,
-0.6839863658,
0.2321561873,
1.1174826622,
0.4130811989,
0.0749342293,
-0.6454280019,
-0.709839344,
-1.0660297871,
0.3029161096,
0.7434379458,
-0.1379744112,
0.0455619022,
0.3544977903,
0.1737420261,
0.2739188671,
-0.8149724007,
-0.032207828,
-0.1488589197,
-0.3286500275,
0.3199517429,
-0.114416495,
-0.3591993749,
-0.0700923577,
0.6128948927,
-0.1725412458,
0.1890425831,
0.4613439739,
-0.2325317562,
0.0865148008,
-0.0745579377,
0.654838562,
0.9036113024,
-0.1224760711,
0.166488409,
-0.219374761,
-0.6140639186,
-0.2136333436,
0.2709909976,
-0.5607427359,
-0.0310314968,
1.0006141663,
0.2750064433,
-0.1688333452,
-0.3108608723,
0.2506142557,
-0.0885718241,
-0.6205423474,
-0.1760953069,
0.1814838648,
0.0823752657,
0.165121153,
0.4380974174,
0.3902055323,
0.6526952386,
-0.5175742507,
-0.2729627788,
0.2813079953,
-0.5688490868,
-0.3802256584,
0.4775821865,
0.2340934873,
-0.08764036,
0.5011538863,
-0.3614276946,
-0.2847819626,
0.1617492437,
0.227155447,
0.9639223814,
0.1361501962,
0.2239409238,
0.0643272325,
0.2682899833,
0.2648207545,
0.1621212512,
-0.2121656537,
-0.1095288694,
-0.3683514595,
-0.4256010354,
-0.1397848725,
-0.0221459288,
-0.4786792397,
-0.2385171652,
-0.2876299918,
-0.1697072983,
0.2489902675,
0.008271751,
-0.5028874278,
0.0286105648,
-0.7531720996,
0.2325875014,
-0.8974753618,
0.4794210196,
0.914789319,
-0.781553328,
-0.6658419967,
0.1795009375,
-0.2077482939,
-0.2447344661,
0.548642993,
-0.2128845453,
-0.4329233766,
-0.0114767514,
-0.5048472881,
-0.4743437469,
1.2894912958,
0.1253181398,
-0.0413928702,
-0.3295921087,
0.0111075966,
0.9578752518,
-0.2010951936,
0.2820364237,
0.2223480046,
0.6146845818,
0.0024187504,
-0.8742846847,
0.2662312388,
-0.5326080918,
-0.0909355506,
-0.2303321064,
-0.4447468221,
0.9352945685,
0.1759165972,
-0.2372448742,
0.3274270296,
0.7296805978,
0.1052197069,
0.4883281589,
0.271928519,
-0.0459736139,
0.8771896362,
0.2121123075,
0.9007341862,
-0.2036663592,
0.0865217894,
1.2697318792,
-0.4223386049,
0.3669625223,
0.6873558164,
-0.2474162281,
0.856942296,
0.4070630372,
0.1128734052,
0.4412530363,
0.1567371488,
-0.3328345418,
0.1889570206,
-0.0991976485,
-0.6480221748,
0.2395275235,
0.1539551616,
-0.6800529361,
0.1307761818,
-0.2584302127,
0.0731798485,
0.1829847097,
0.1551572084,
0.916343689,
-0.1075310335,
-0.9030694962,
0.3246248662,
-0.1034039706,
0.2421736419,
-0.2519718111,
-0.0175851565,
-0.2066648453,
-0.0739965141,
-0.416197598,
-0.6982470155,
0.4409746826,
-0.0585860834,
-0.3437798619,
0.0360492207,
0.8397410512,
-0.3039170504,
-0.4001927376,
-0.1696596295,
0.7882044315,
0.2747171819,
-0.1178082675,
-0.5482604504,
0.025661204,
-0.0199965052,
-0.3084542453,
0.1928047836,
0.5253234506,
-0.341842562,
0.3509946167,
0.7016580701,
0.0792430639,
-0.351850301,
0.2369698435,
0.9736676812,
-0.3438026607,
-0.4055916667,
-0.7184079289,
0.3982312083,
-0.3152804971,
-0.2857637107,
0.9843583107,
0.534591496,
0.5895489454,
-0.3570159674,
1.3566060066,
-0.3328998983,
0.1265327632,
-0.3875337839,
0.8700816035,
-0.379591614,
0.2078205794,
-0.8948565125,
-1.0528298616,
-0.4367399514,
0.5296972394,
-0.2948669791,
0.1365868151,
1.0131964684,
0.4650491178,
0.0000496701,
0.1891740561,
-0.2124034464,
-0.1459904611,
0.2912042439,
0.0385709666,
0.6867215037,
-0.2082628161,
0.6031499505,
-0.0421860032,
-0.1622780412,
-0.1930244267,
-0.9120887518,
-1.0946873426,
-0.7772484422,
-0.072141178,
-0.3803280294,
0.0675133467,
0.4944025874,
0.3584956825,
-0.5717687607,
-0.1326717287,
-0.5345309377,
-0.0453537256,
-0.0765182897,
-0.1992826015,
0.9894250631,
-0.135802418,
-0.6788496971,
0.4005197287,
0.293092221,
0.0298843961,
-0.6418663859,
0.0346753113,
-0.101502642,
-0.0058455905,
0.6059780717,
-0.0670266524,
-0.4002134502,
-0.2171334624,
0.0611846074,
-0.1547325999,
-0.3621596396,
1.1841384172,
-0.4809947908,
0.3722930551,
0.7683469653,
0.3666364849,
0.7102950811,
-0.0203986801,
0.5954889059,
-0.5156080127,
-0.008593752,
0.2680080235,
0.1925368458,
0.4621218741,
-0.3806985319,
0.7944821715,
0.3933915496,
-0.8541598916,
-0.6660537124,
-0.0297073442,
-0.8267093301,
-0.4528796971,
0.8010790348,
-0.218455106,
-0.1028389856,
-0.399261117,
-0.5820735097,
0.2597020864,
-0.2930267751,
1.0106409788,
0.7335418463,
-0.6142184138,
0.6926572919,
-0.2103146911,
0.7556241155,
0.1406691074,
-0.9074032903,
-0.0630382374,
0.7842241526,
0.0893102884,
0.6151092052,
0.9850132465,
0.0558349974,
0.2362438142,
0.30080387,
0.0403506905,
-0.3428357244,
-0.3745553493,
0.4312643409,
0.4991975129,
0.2306550294,
0.5014219284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12249v1
|
Analysis of Levenshtein Transformer's Decoder and Its Variants
| 2024-02-19T16:05:28 | 2024-02-19T16:05:28 |
Ruiyang Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Levenshtein transformer (LevT) is a non-autoregressive machine translation
model with high decoding efficiency and comparable translation quality in terms
of bleu score, due to its parallel decoding and iterative refinement procedure.
Are there any deficiencies of its translations and what improvements could be
made? In this report, we focus on LevT's decoder and analyse the decoding
results length, subword generation, and deletion module's capability. We hope
to identify weaknesses of the decoder for future improvements.
We also compare translations of the original LevT, knowledge-distilled LevT,
LevT with translation memory, and the KD-LevT with translation memory to see
how KD and translation memory can help.
|
[
-0.3898833692,
-0.6300371289,
-0.0594390146,
-0.1313683093,
-0.247869432,
0.0821785554,
0.0565804578,
-0.4801845551,
-0.0559493564,
0.1541612744,
-0.2612499297,
-0.0323240273,
-0.8151248693,
0.4672127068,
-0.8265099525,
1.1107792854,
-0.1884186417,
0.2131683081,
0.338738054,
-0.1104457453,
-0.6553943753,
-0.1306100488,
-0.5975604057,
-0.2094781101,
0.3626342416,
0.3757962286,
0.6462407708,
0.4965500236,
0.8330328465,
0.2585624158,
-0.0668872446,
-0.4213556945,
-0.6434748769,
0.0370429829,
-0.2330356538,
-0.4022523761,
-0.6254613996,
-0.2544472814,
0.8592626452,
0.3593870699,
-0.2028316259,
0.1387173533,
0.0343445651,
1.0003297329,
-0.2430404574,
-0.1499907374,
-0.557610631,
0.2110668123,
-0.2348506153,
-0.1064162478,
-0.4682186842,
-0.2244539708,
0.1038329825,
0.1073259711,
0.8155842423,
0.3077618778,
0.8066831827,
0.4962753654,
-0.6362402439,
0.0059435247,
-0.7550308108,
0.7600622773,
-0.8693058491,
0.76983428,
0.0916945636,
0.677115798,
-0.1023027822,
-0.4845932126,
-0.6396405101,
-0.1273152083,
-0.3416975737,
0.202395454,
-0.0540491827,
-0.0125619126,
0.2796879411,
1.1636269093,
-1.0271158218,
0.0396852382,
-0.4428574145,
-0.083381258,
0.4898836315,
0.1878780127,
0.3134393394,
-0.3942957222,
-0.2405840009,
-0.1478324831,
-0.532282114,
-0.1449789703,
0.3697003424,
-0.2020023912,
0.0341412276,
0.8075931668,
-0.4044019282,
0.3956860602,
0.1765312701,
0.293073982,
0.3215942383,
-0.2726990283,
-0.4517046511,
0.0504589453,
0.4809964895,
0.3079642951,
0.0529472455,
-0.2815186977,
-0.6981845498,
-0.2343128324,
0.3297988772,
-0.8301633,
-0.4613402486,
0.2256698161,
-0.9729220271,
-0.1361500025,
0.0694534183,
-0.7588890791,
-0.0453170091,
0.2210288495,
0.4108178616,
-0.7537361979,
-0.4171484709,
0.1103985086,
-0.4747352302,
0.4911535978,
0.0806075558,
-0.9244200587,
0.3289439976,
0.0808718279,
0.4673970938,
-0.4740017951,
-0.3724099994,
-0.3452909589,
-0.1713195741,
-0.2006828934,
0.6392012239,
-0.1128852889,
-0.5262712836,
-0.1669478565,
0.3770469725,
-0.239193812,
-0.5172925591,
0.3647572696,
-0.814175427,
0.046506308,
-0.486846745,
-0.7967933416,
-0.4456561208,
0.1406302899,
-0.9987591505,
0.6846707463,
0.451407671,
-0.8184050918,
0.2615405917,
-0.6482335925,
-0.6364034414,
0.2493223697,
0.2294854969,
-0.375567764,
0.4633520842,
0.1132850721,
-0.0569974259,
-0.2897293568,
0.0418171138,
0.5220577717,
-0.448425293,
0.26860255,
-0.6788204312,
0.3518211246,
0.1762495786,
-0.4487331212,
-0.0381373838,
-0.8430059552,
-0.125833109,
0.3400857151,
-0.6562585235,
0.3683175147,
0.118256934,
0.4363190234,
-0.0672152415,
0.4128485322,
-0.7588043213,
0.0666185841,
-0.4050311744,
0.2225815952,
0.6040679812,
-0.0080374228,
0.3518249989,
-0.472179085,
0.5215643048,
0.2294601351,
0.2791554928,
-0.1750589609,
-0.6685263515,
-0.8196018934,
0.2395804822,
0.6383142471,
0.6308205724,
-0.8075141907,
0.1788948476,
-0.2694621682,
-0.2625388503,
-0.4868811071,
-0.047379788,
0.4232136905,
0.4366197586,
0.7274998426,
-0.3040774167,
-0.3036444783,
-1.205252409,
-0.4880479276,
0.1796580702,
0.1619166583,
-0.3141577542,
0.584600091,
-0.3448470235,
0.3938962519,
-0.1244595274,
-0.0394014791,
-0.4081651568,
0.1063966826,
0.0453036129,
0.6224060059,
0.3715149462,
-0.9132185578,
-0.7972081304,
0.2987687886,
-0.3469585776,
0.1536558419,
0.10888125,
0.2749976814,
0.5401149988,
0.2551242113,
-0.6010043025,
0.8855599165,
0.5726473331,
-0.2993350029,
0.7135749459,
-0.2982628644,
0.585344851,
-0.8723086715,
0.0425983518,
-0.3503884971,
-0.3747386336,
-0.4830715954,
0.0620059632,
0.2666780949,
0.0364608839,
-0.1659346819,
0.116527684,
-0.365626961,
-0.1028562561,
-0.1801763624,
-0.1387691945,
-0.2024968266,
0.2242395878,
-0.1043505743,
0.8228549361,
0.2611741126,
-0.2758927047,
0.5938624144,
0.3280615211,
-0.4202256799,
0.4664782584,
-0.7062202692,
0.1243013442,
-0.1785851568,
0.0343046188,
-1.0432339907,
-0.1591163725,
-0.0406485908,
-0.3906134069,
0.5966541171,
0.018249156,
-0.6711962223,
-0.4379170239,
-0.163888067,
0.7222595215,
0.8177417517,
-0.3519169092,
0.1312723905,
-0.2059806138,
0.132362321,
-0.6936630011,
-0.8791961074,
0.0337927192,
0.0555955246,
-0.2095631808,
0.2694542408,
-0.2376587093,
0.2957482934,
0.3805210292,
-0.4239808023,
0.0556371622,
-0.3324187398,
-0.2217622399,
-0.0750248283,
-0.490354687,
-0.0997537971,
0.1513828784,
-0.38918522,
-0.2056230456,
-0.0556408875,
0.4945803285,
-0.3283250928,
-0.4172102511,
-0.5652419329,
0.61350739,
0.5865833759,
-0.2635264397,
0.547457993,
0.6875472069,
-0.1682482958,
-0.1556214243,
-0.5750326514,
-0.0764954016,
-0.4810477197,
0.4373702705,
-0.5374211669,
-0.6545422673,
0.5542896986,
0.1610702425,
-0.1971886456,
0.7086152434,
0.4614719748,
0.0266853943,
0.8278583288,
0.6555246711,
0.1347104162,
0.2361898124,
-0.2713162601,
0.5046765208,
-0.8614022732,
-0.1378556341,
-0.1584447026,
-0.6807024479,
-0.8312915564,
-0.0233872756,
-0.0289584547,
0.0720547065,
0.0107528232,
0.6557338238,
-0.5020749569,
0.5135450363,
0.4724164605,
-0.1850890964,
0.296200633,
-0.2080955654,
0.0798331648,
0.0538753569,
-0.5860993862,
-0.2932031155,
0.9768916368,
0.3928352296,
0.6383073926,
0.1834718734,
0.6037524939,
0.2752870023,
0.0448971651,
-0.7459812164,
0.3904832304,
-0.3783577085,
-0.6437296271,
-0.3346515,
-0.5009943247,
-0.8690698147,
-0.0653723478,
0.0125530455,
-0.5708857775,
0.2834559083,
0.1302758604,
0.1873461753,
0.5670809746,
-0.7648794651,
1.1082339287,
-0.0151180355,
0.3851209283,
-0.2271439135,
-0.5795891881,
0.297983706,
-0.1071861833,
-0.1681637615,
0.1937631369,
0.2394068986,
0.4549522102,
-0.2887963355,
0.3526495099,
0.0425486341,
-0.2502071857,
0.0212867465,
0.3593256772,
0.3325408101,
-0.1858061254,
-0.2229920775,
0.2443692982,
0.3637982607,
-0.6314424276,
-0.5400615931,
0.4970489442,
-0.561545074,
-0.540679872,
-0.1624778807,
-0.7134110928,
0.0146334395,
0.4405584037,
0.8062338233,
0.5768381953,
-0.372820735,
0.1097899079,
0.6546366215,
-0.4665271938,
0.6011083722,
0.4097576439,
-0.2329284847,
-0.3552800715,
0.8652290106,
0.1665748507,
0.3986593783,
0.6546574235,
0.1986384839,
-0.3319482505,
-0.8096858263,
-0.4886077344,
0.0292566046,
-0.8930960894,
-0.3371523619,
-0.2259049267,
-0.3928942978,
-0.4265460074,
0.1827755272,
-0.4883231819,
-0.3782970905,
0.3529952168,
-0.0627123415,
0.3379318118,
1.2128711939,
0.0247317608,
0.37668854,
-0.938252449,
0.6533215046,
0.2779152691,
0.4435220361,
0.0074076639,
-0.4827768207,
-0.3742839992,
-0.0732827559,
-0.2035274208,
-1.1478643417,
0.2704257667,
-0.0829058141,
0.4145202339,
0.0225534271,
-0.04356445,
0.2595007122,
-0.6864711642,
0.9363791943,
0.0910688862,
-0.9875974059,
0.4146342278,
-0.1984970123,
0.4441851079,
0.2508379221,
0.0872099549,
-0.5551787019,
-0.2377298921,
-0.5514342785,
-0.4499788284,
0.5914661884,
0.3612699807,
-0.1032836139,
-0.1325609833,
0.4852032363,
0.4250824153,
0.1621166766,
-0.5212171078,
-0.3855549991,
-0.4578874111,
-0.1954367012,
-0.2276278883,
-0.4517024457,
0.3644999862,
-0.4494478405,
0.576399684,
0.333306253,
0.3676118553,
0.340120405,
-0.4137996137,
-0.3862569034,
0.3739828169,
0.3649443686,
0.3815717995,
-0.1883481443,
0.2930468023,
0.4200265408,
-0.6189864278,
0.0833863392,
-0.1837310344,
0.006855322,
0.076353997,
0.229324773,
0.5435495377,
-0.2148913145,
-0.4218738079,
0.5953347683,
-0.233214885,
-0.1446511596,
0.1706686616,
-0.1293288916,
0.0128400195,
0.2791693807,
0.3217470944,
0.1642130613,
0.4440123439,
-0.3578117788,
0.3783636689,
0.1887127608,
-0.2464274019,
-0.3729634583,
0.4733166099,
-0.0006898862,
-0.6374031305,
0.7942690849,
-0.5709858537,
-0.6334165335,
0.5812135935,
0.7441025376,
0.954317987,
-0.7774757147,
0.1227646917,
0.1596650034,
0.5926181078,
-0.1975855231,
0.3528264463,
-0.0301959179,
-0.5010176301,
-0.48830989,
-0.7450308204,
-0.0440458469,
0.2396140099,
-0.8217156529,
0.1787154675,
-0.0112767275,
0.0389563851,
-0.2807716429,
-0.1257087737,
-0.6577304602,
0.2907890081,
-0.3359193802,
0.9861661792,
-0.4734904468,
1.1293393373,
0.666306138,
-0.31447348,
-0.601500988,
0.368802458,
-0.3591393828,
-0.6195430756,
0.8500958681,
0.0717862174,
-0.1373554915,
0.2932369411,
-0.10066697,
-0.5760359764,
0.835801959,
0.1960272789,
-0.6918994188,
-0.0624699816,
0.4099344313,
0.4753978848,
0.1715894789,
0.0114524933,
0.7900779247,
0.5585116148,
-0.3607702851,
-1.4038602114,
0.3018754125,
-0.4035433233,
0.3886317313,
0.3738993108,
-0.4687961042,
0.8498619795,
0.1359696984,
-0.4513485134,
0.351357311,
0.2495072186,
-0.6250421405,
-0.0264147613,
0.1197609156,
0.782169044,
0.3013023138,
0.1150620282,
1.1894675493,
-0.2058396637,
0.5813198686,
0.6503213048,
0.2225576043,
0.8762218356,
0.3936389983,
-0.1918211579,
0.5049211979,
0.3537352979,
-0.1685412675,
0.5567676425,
0.1560090631,
0.0335852727,
0.0172634553,
0.591170609,
-0.4262215793,
0.2207796127,
0.1469711959,
-0.1648003757,
-0.465451628,
0.1496801525,
-0.6765215993,
-0.0516647138,
0.0293117762,
0.6439816952,
0.1519047022,
-0.3364832401,
0.8932722807,
0.1086732671,
0.5228762031,
-0.1695726067,
-0.0981380492,
-0.2900278866,
0.2637422979,
-0.3213344514,
-0.7534213662,
0.6821979284,
-0.3044232726,
-0.3017060757,
-0.0571812987,
0.6010100245,
-0.3301695585,
-0.1844488531,
0.2809645236,
0.4551950693,
0.3432377577,
0.0604592748,
-0.6868339181,
0.076370731,
-0.0747717172,
-0.3629540801,
0.0880592465,
0.515632987,
0.2908622622,
0.3801846504,
0.1910529137,
0.0121442499,
0.3682780862,
0.0526629612,
0.4638753831,
-0.9133446813,
-0.1438773125,
-0.7498837113,
0.4757317007,
0.0606434345,
-0.159305051,
0.9459871054,
0.6683292389,
0.6629148126,
-0.4519059658,
0.6316340566,
-0.2081118077,
0.308386296,
-0.4523456097,
0.7048736215,
-0.4951379299,
0.0504632592,
0.015207693,
-1.1850922108,
-0.0508031696,
0.5646991134,
-0.2153923661,
-0.0373931751,
1.2760686874,
0.6031202078,
-0.1579987109,
0.2444000691,
0.4754142165,
0.2337596118,
0.2339985967,
0.5635766387,
0.9185476303,
-1.0643788576,
0.519466877,
-0.0970512405,
-0.0110642817,
-0.2493723035,
-0.6565638781,
-0.8330774307,
-0.7128915787,
-0.3310837746,
-0.2324646264,
-0.0912037566,
0.1384416521,
0.3789730072,
-0.9784954786,
-0.1239625737,
-0.5366503596,
0.2252155095,
-0.3372629285,
-0.2753987312,
0.3603648543,
-0.5773947835,
-0.6829162836,
0.4906440973,
0.2889343202,
0.3740454316,
-0.1335512996,
-0.073427856,
0.1127455086,
0.0026130946,
0.4994277656,
0.1861893833,
-0.5897445083,
-0.539835453,
0.2124812752,
0.1072551981,
0.333946079,
0.8497005105,
-0.3740031421,
0.1973748207,
0.8927221298,
0.6581148505,
0.6514510512,
-0.17193304,
0.6263987422,
-0.3997006416,
-0.1351881474,
0.010473269,
0.4415071011,
0.2245032042,
-0.4195042551,
0.0438500978,
0.2465154082,
-0.815258801,
-0.6172563434,
0.4978342354,
-0.9547345638,
-0.4104022682,
1.106628418,
0.1177313849,
-0.3121311367,
-0.2671643198,
-0.2758549452,
0.438865751,
-0.0306588393,
0.6593198776,
0.6369160414,
-0.0695127919,
-0.3372212052,
-0.8350941539,
0.5820304751,
0.4296767712,
-0.3440146744,
0.062837027,
0.1125076786,
0.6838071346,
0.2060715258,
0.3177495897,
-0.4747705758,
0.3806575239,
0.2968257666,
0.0437281877,
0.1752077937,
-0.1099472269,
-0.4492241144,
-0.0974299684,
0.0627666116,
-0.2683195472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14848v1
|
Same Task, More Tokens: the Impact of Input Length on the Reasoning Performance of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T16:04:53 | 2024-02-19T16:04:53 |
Mosh Levy, Alon Jacoby, Yoav Goldberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the impact of extending input lengths on the capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite LLMs advancements in recent times,
their performance consistency across different input lengths is not well
understood. We investigate this aspect by introducing a novel QA reasoning
framework, specifically designed to assess the impact of input length. We
isolate the effect of input length using multiple versions of the same sample,
each being extended with padding of different lengths, types and locations. Our
findings show a notable degradation in LLMs' reasoning performance at much
shorter input lengths than their technical maximum. We show that the
degradation trend appears in every version of our dataset, although at
different intensities. Additionally, our study reveals that traditional
perplexity metrics do not correlate with performance of LLMs' in long input
reasoning tasks. We analyse our results and identify failure modes that can
serve as useful guides for future research, potentially informing strategies to
address the limitations observed in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3920642138,
-0.7934800982,
1.1512863636,
0.2104452699,
-0.2394545823,
0.1827331632,
-0.2967387736,
-0.6403569579,
0.0926277861,
0.4341626763,
-0.4254485369,
-0.2526817322,
-0.8293561339,
0.4612319171,
-0.392785579,
0.6125514507,
-0.1315887123,
-0.100867115,
-0.4472070336,
-0.2982138097,
-0.5691571236,
-0.7488858104,
-0.5949267745,
-0.3296055496,
0.7772462368,
0.4134808779,
0.8398135304,
0.53638798,
0.6625800729,
0.284593612,
-0.4641918242,
0.2753280401,
-0.3583036065,
0.1665991545,
-0.1483144313,
-0.6808874011,
-0.3459533751,
-0.3400492966,
1.0862185955,
0.8313271999,
0.2357362807,
0.0797780603,
0.0816815719,
0.3782342374,
-0.5760887861,
-0.0288305543,
-0.3771044016,
-0.0324300006,
-0.1830613166,
-0.0496825986,
-0.3965679407,
0.0641413331,
-0.0001551803,
-0.4340412319,
-0.3026461303,
-0.1563700885,
0.6019584537,
0.1428468078,
-0.4059270024,
-0.1320923865,
-0.8208159804,
0.7541537285,
-0.9802482724,
0.4425228834,
0.1539159268,
0.1187086776,
-0.3354279995,
-0.5995604396,
-0.8524039388,
-0.3614887595,
-0.0801325142,
-0.4841350019,
0.0128257675,
0.1765426695,
0.6121463776,
0.1019638106,
-0.4856591523,
0.3986642957,
-0.4272712469,
-0.0009413512,
0.5582040548,
0.2963323891,
0.1792622507,
-0.088964209,
-0.1528624296,
-0.0117828511,
-0.9341343641,
0.2880352736,
0.4087414145,
0.1949999034,
0.0960960537,
0.6375325322,
-0.3619426191,
0.6238785386,
-0.2219415903,
-0.3423782289,
0.2024069577,
-0.4019972086,
-0.1072224602,
-0.3003023863,
0.7034912109,
0.0329370052,
-0.125536859,
-0.0624344423,
-0.2948926687,
-0.2552138865,
-0.1736757606,
-0.6184862852,
0.2578157187,
0.2549053431,
-0.2665669918,
0.1429509819,
-0.0197831932,
-0.3323235512,
-0.5941101313,
-0.2099845856,
0.3893558383,
-0.3485688865,
-0.1231040955,
0.2935931385,
-0.1335908026,
0.3502967358,
0.1442084163,
-0.7193545699,
0.3518685997,
1.1695016623,
0.8345976472,
-0.3926131725,
-0.5117393732,
-0.6064232588,
-0.2067528218,
-0.3045728803,
0.6207318902,
-0.8636388779,
-0.4926636219,
0.010047406,
0.0928709283,
-0.038953159,
-0.6717358232,
0.6208598018,
-0.5699127913,
-0.0206442308,
-0.4310008585,
-0.5433174372,
-0.0519406572,
0.1453175545,
-0.6977296472,
0.8045738339,
0.1065836623,
-0.5583682656,
0.4243101478,
-0.7101546526,
-0.7395106554,
0.1662536263,
-0.2765977681,
-0.3429160118,
0.3574128449,
-0.0151854167,
0.3124039471,
-0.4530599117,
0.383671701,
-0.6644334793,
-0.6838555932,
0.6142680049,
-0.5762509108,
0.7813669443,
0.0481716543,
-0.2431619465,
0.252050221,
-0.9809218645,
-0.0600026511,
0.0190654341,
-0.6072409153,
-0.0200690497,
-0.0021433441,
-0.1728106588,
0.4198974371,
0.293228358,
-0.7818421125,
0.2182746232,
-0.361092329,
0.7006905675,
0.7265235186,
-0.216620028,
0.267573148,
-0.4070742428,
0.8071593642,
-0.0830118656,
0.2254509926,
-0.1957690716,
-0.2380194515,
-0.6547086835,
-0.2839792371,
0.4082586169,
0.430880338,
-0.6629561782,
0.357573837,
-0.5329336524,
-0.2530556023,
-0.1467180103,
0.1725733131,
0.417304337,
0.0969611555,
0.1786070317,
-0.4118799865,
-0.621081233,
-0.9801496267,
-0.2982834578,
-0.3023554981,
-0.182608977,
0.1376986951,
0.6348496079,
-0.2418580949,
0.8520967364,
-0.2791769207,
0.1189525276,
-0.4601983726,
-0.3012475073,
0.2535260022,
0.4880072176,
0.3044382632,
-0.2384679914,
0.036063429,
-0.1489540786,
-0.4197055697,
0.0313248038,
-0.1853455901,
0.0906803533,
0.279281795,
0.4753294587,
-0.9077758193,
0.3896054924,
0.6258863807,
-0.5054063201,
1.0455060005,
-0.0295907296,
0.0007115047,
-0.7693704963,
-0.1874271929,
-0.0177180804,
-0.0752860457,
-0.3569957912,
0.1961679608,
-0.1214544252,
-0.0295183882,
-0.3209818006,
0.7496320605,
-0.2483547032,
-0.2459970117,
-0.2576701045,
0.0789031237,
0.2861278653,
0.4451279342,
-0.2672699094,
0.8498243093,
0.3755047917,
-0.3991247416,
0.5135928392,
0.0095651615,
-0.4847337604,
0.3953710794,
-0.8911809325,
0.1156357825,
0.1405238211,
0.3096839488,
-1.012498498,
-0.0705171749,
-0.0634017065,
-0.5662062764,
0.3024176657,
0.1813734174,
-0.8786787987,
-0.3326827586,
-0.3081322908,
0.6259191632,
0.479545027,
-0.5849412084,
0.6593818665,
-0.0521117523,
-0.1888618022,
-0.5044496059,
-0.6537722945,
0.2628779411,
-0.3797581494,
-0.8399062753,
0.0027971936,
-0.0257609058,
-0.3514665067,
-0.1181740761,
-0.1573311985,
-0.0639315844,
0.3933070004,
0.312141031,
0.1372844279,
-0.4203023016,
0.4462328553,
0.1158639863,
0.2509033978,
0.4167388082,
-0.1844898015,
0.63235569,
-0.0427082889,
-0.6206413507,
-0.6827124953,
0.5112411976,
0.7114291787,
-0.2378173918,
1.0253894329,
0.1523708552,
-0.1502331048,
-0.1835823953,
-0.6096163392,
-0.2015847564,
-0.5131042004,
0.6881512403,
-0.7993828058,
-1.2279516459,
0.7654764652,
-0.042274069,
0.0276224967,
0.4956039488,
0.3477737308,
-0.0236351397,
1.0221413374,
0.6698224545,
0.00856716,
0.362647444,
0.0045728004,
0.3867212236,
-0.9445748329,
-0.3022676706,
-0.4775039256,
-0.1861194074,
-0.3210548759,
-0.6592050791,
0.0658663288,
0.0779905766,
-0.3408314884,
-0.0257848706,
-0.0520247221,
0.4571907818,
0.3574815989,
-0.0978574604,
0.3384520113,
-0.1903200448,
-0.1590343565,
0.3381340206,
-0.7349058986,
-0.563182056,
1.0736871958,
0.6371385455,
0.5160582662,
0.1315465719,
0.5609875321,
0.0605706163,
-0.0925724208,
-0.7197440863,
0.5864519477,
-0.0576853044,
-0.3627172709,
-0.6642559767,
-0.4524902105,
-1.0066921711,
0.1362230331,
0.0717435107,
-0.8114467859,
0.2113758326,
-0.1078272834,
-0.4190258384,
0.3284983635,
-0.3995047808,
0.6126948595,
-0.2854700983,
-0.3377440572,
-0.1384982467,
-0.3575884104,
0.3687163591,
-0.0198615901,
0.1855227798,
-0.0087684225,
-0.0039187991,
0.9144979715,
-0.6711083055,
0.6781733036,
0.0801951885,
-0.3832901418,
0.2103943676,
-0.0846838355,
0.4590294659,
0.1388674378,
-0.1194788441,
0.1759826243,
0.2294571549,
-0.6200101972,
-0.8652259707,
0.8237745762,
-0.6220120192,
-1.0128375292,
-0.1431182176,
-0.7141480446,
-0.667506814,
0.0801299438,
-0.0510944165,
0.538546145,
0.1618988365,
0.3827455342,
0.715918541,
-0.2509427667,
0.3544195592,
0.2596143782,
-0.3691122234,
-0.1358158588,
0.7079611421,
0.2526934445,
0.4791440368,
0.14881742,
0.0227062516,
-0.379229933,
-0.8145956397,
-0.4108368754,
0.360875994,
-0.9314349294,
0.1217780039,
-0.5420514345,
-0.135575071,
-0.5582894683,
0.0345715918,
-0.2175575346,
-0.5813213587,
-0.3583833277,
-0.2604165077,
0.2656186819,
0.7696017027,
0.0914140567,
0.2410164326,
-0.7224045992,
-0.0010588542,
0.2704394162,
0.7556993365,
0.1854169667,
-0.9312272072,
-0.1527889669,
-0.1890925467,
-0.0568269789,
-0.6771259308,
-0.0664648339,
-0.14809677,
0.6237723827,
0.3277806044,
-0.2483206242,
0.5318875313,
-0.3140928745,
0.8697781563,
0.3330791295,
-0.9620867372,
0.0467154458,
-0.2124061733,
0.8166047335,
0.3940941691,
0.1739684641,
-0.6441568732,
-0.3292992413,
-0.4535630941,
-0.7726100683,
0.3433714509,
-0.0910211131,
0.2832937539,
0.0058212583,
0.4548097551,
0.2466975302,
-0.2350728363,
-0.408970356,
-0.0624000169,
0.3868332207,
-0.0210482553,
-0.1367624849,
-0.7116935849,
-0.0656924173,
-0.3873922825,
0.6425032616,
-0.1694630384,
0.0628317073,
0.0655321628,
-0.0936261415,
0.2707767189,
0.4532038867,
0.7504372001,
1.2006418705,
0.3475367427,
0.1094060838,
0.5225927234,
-0.0409376249,
0.1117988601,
0.0759638473,
0.0680967197,
0.015584941,
0.7103562951,
0.9913862944,
-0.0125185242,
-1.1144795418,
0.4059782028,
-0.0409588404,
-0.3940051198,
-0.4027146995,
0.0053400011,
0.3193459213,
0.3780297339,
0.3788386285,
-0.2475923896,
0.0773338974,
-0.6950919032,
0.1802503318,
0.4244327247,
-0.4245666862,
-0.2146363854,
0.2323036045,
0.0645537972,
-0.4282123446,
0.4819922745,
-0.2974421382,
-0.4876679778,
0.8697044253,
0.4609124959,
0.67097646,
0.115656808,
0.0475450307,
0.0911267847,
0.3310382664,
-0.0923473462,
0.317289561,
0.0477105305,
-0.5135146379,
-0.9238122702,
-0.7176875472,
-0.2505135238,
0.308244735,
-0.4071611762,
0.1792209148,
-0.6882235408,
-0.1738106757,
-0.2084016949,
0.0230321772,
-0.6239933372,
0.0299720168,
0.2234852314,
0.8364398479,
-0.6606330276,
0.514621377,
0.6172018051,
-0.2252461016,
-0.9582997561,
-0.1288965046,
-0.1215820163,
-0.5542132854,
0.7754991651,
0.1383453608,
-0.2783176005,
-0.6132526398,
-0.3542392552,
-1.1320160627,
0.7469627261,
0.3306077421,
-0.7360422015,
-0.1528586447,
0.5566525459,
0.6544548273,
-0.3604180217,
0.0602028668,
0.9322887659,
0.3666290045,
0.0399554819,
-1.3404332399,
0.2228531986,
-0.0960088447,
0.0821633562,
0.0388526656,
-0.6116678119,
0.8160270452,
-0.3295732141,
-0.2435316443,
0.297509253,
0.5414248705,
0.4150291085,
0.1623155475,
0.3890066743,
0.686480701,
0.720195353,
-0.0136293201,
1.1317658424,
-0.0559174865,
0.1545381844,
1.2214899063,
-0.3380069733,
0.8784102201,
0.3783279359,
-0.4013015926,
0.6904763579,
0.4344775975,
0.1196263507,
-0.1039078161,
0.7081993818,
-0.2343870103,
-0.3933591545,
-0.1205084547,
-0.205729574,
0.5038332343,
0.3271129429,
-0.3759849966,
0.113791652,
0.3121761084,
0.0974984318,
0.1184227616,
-0.1986875534,
0.6419578195,
0.1108986288,
-0.6569868326,
0.7799777985,
0.0713218674,
0.6877035499,
-0.2092468143,
0.0215667225,
-0.2181216627,
0.079603672,
-0.2372761369,
-0.7207158208,
0.1555200517,
-0.2183153331,
-0.2458544225,
0.1442702562,
0.5081494451,
-0.0406832732,
-0.5181353688,
0.3201256692,
0.4922016859,
0.0656206235,
-0.0252724122,
-0.4134095907,
0.5762862563,
-0.2257573158,
-0.2931203842,
0.4458848834,
0.5667843819,
-0.2286723405,
0.8864514232,
0.4730588496,
0.0078040082,
0.2061592042,
0.0288008917,
0.922796905,
-0.7084481716,
-0.2354301214,
-0.9656880498,
0.1801420301,
-0.152565375,
-0.4468175173,
0.5951567888,
0.5865710378,
0.8608564138,
0.2589911819,
0.8269041181,
0.2370891422,
0.491556257,
-0.4569820762,
0.3591832519,
-0.5176836252,
0.6754806042,
0.0699359998,
-0.7426627874,
-0.2503103912,
0.1116621196,
-0.5231617093,
0.0758790746,
0.9999120831,
0.626288116,
0.3279831707,
-0.0879379287,
0.4752519727,
0.2173749357,
0.5016456246,
0.7489901185,
1.0548832417,
0.0409632623,
0.588378489,
-0.0878890902,
-0.0141112329,
-0.163457498,
-0.4713687003,
-0.8438055515,
-0.6257229447,
-0.2240341008,
-0.3580110967,
0.1336667985,
0.6338205934,
0.4643496573,
-0.6334437132,
-0.103091225,
0.1423572451,
0.3444522023,
-0.0217914358,
-0.2588280439,
0.3784530163,
-0.3431800604,
-0.5657190084,
0.269413352,
0.369330138,
-0.3490742743,
-0.5426316261,
-0.0625427067,
-0.2059494257,
0.2983885109,
0.8620482683,
0.4281115234,
-1.1420115232,
-0.6287170649,
0.0580472983,
0.0010323104,
0.0328917615,
0.8436352611,
-0.7962908745,
0.231147632,
0.5729109049,
0.9812791944,
0.1116041616,
-0.2860418558,
0.6010048389,
-0.511180222,
-0.1824534833,
0.293513447,
0.5497759581,
0.2527877092,
-0.261757642,
0.1593015045,
0.1178589761,
-0.4788881242,
-1.0024409294,
0.4543402493,
-0.8639941812,
-0.5946344733,
1.5233963728,
-0.3906858265,
-0.115433991,
-0.1297785491,
-0.1251668781,
0.0349855348,
-0.3017323911,
0.7923570275,
1.0004937649,
-0.2766827941,
-0.2895949483,
-0.2858588696,
0.2974550426,
0.8418611288,
-0.7004088759,
0.1536802053,
0.546102643,
0.3917793632,
0.2496158332,
0.4527733624,
-0.1547145694,
0.4916698635,
0.1200680956,
-0.3465556204,
-0.1008428112,
-0.2565633953,
-0.5959342122,
0.4013091624,
0.5799263716,
0.1612346321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12243v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12243v4
|
Understanding the Effects of Noise in Text-to-SQL: An Examination of the BIRD-Bench Benchmark
| 2024-02-19T15:58:15 | 2024-03-25T19:48:16 |
Niklas Wretblad, Fredrik Gordh Riseby, Rahul Biswas, Amin Ahmadi, Oskar Holmström
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text-to-SQL, which involves translating natural language into Structured
Query Language (SQL), is crucial for enabling broad access to structured
databases without expert knowledge. However, designing models for such tasks is
challenging due to numerous factors, including the presence of 'noise,' such as
ambiguous questions and syntactical errors. This study provides an in-depth
analysis of the distribution and types of noise in the widely used BIRD-Bench
benchmark and the impact of noise on models. While BIRD-Bench was created to
model dirty and noisy database values, it was not created to contain noise and
errors in the questions and gold queries. We found that noise in questions and
gold queries are prevalent in the dataset, with varying amounts across domains,
and with an uneven distribution between noise types. The presence of incorrect
gold SQL queries, which then generate incorrect gold answers, has a significant
impact on the benchmark's reliability. Surprisingly, when evaluating models on
corrected SQL queries, zero-shot baselines surpassed the performance of
state-of-the-art prompting methods. We conclude that informative noise labels
and reliable benchmarks are crucial to developing new Text-to-SQL methods that
can handle varying types of noise. All datasets, annotations, and code are
available at
https://github.com/niklaswretblad/the-effects-of-noise-in-text-to-SQL.
|
[
0.018833952,
-1.1867460012,
0.3897489607,
0.4638267756,
-0.3446976244,
-0.517570138,
-0.0707562566,
-0.8464449048,
-0.4020385742,
0.7008329034,
-0.6833662391,
-0.5525397062,
-0.3315319717,
0.3741301894,
-0.9742181897,
1.0849257708,
0.3178860545,
0.021481825,
-0.1990380138,
0.0461036973,
-0.3924926817,
-0.6060196757,
-0.2392432243,
0.0697472543,
0.3192290068,
-0.2779914141,
0.6310850382,
0.5715352893,
0.6754655242,
0.0761957839,
-0.3765728474,
0.1685668528,
-0.4166277051,
0.2994270325,
-0.2221602648,
-0.4302046299,
-0.2093725652,
-0.2514673471,
0.5139988661,
0.980037272,
-0.1662577987,
0.1490092576,
0.0548486263,
0.8671999574,
-0.7226217389,
0.6033792496,
-0.8856681585,
0.105749473,
-0.6882612109,
-0.2484624982,
-0.3631259501,
-0.0960763618,
-0.1979111284,
-0.6112535,
0.1561007202,
0.1391565949,
0.8346374035,
0.4249468446,
-0.4024176002,
-0.3259910643,
-0.9475406408,
0.7282221317,
-0.6035816669,
0.2565262616,
0.4458377063,
0.1424530149,
-0.3412304819,
-0.5067890882,
-0.233335197,
0.1641528159,
-0.184556663,
0.039896898,
0.1062123179,
-0.0075478875,
0.3919163644,
0.4811113477,
-0.4949100316,
-0.236836493,
-0.2430448681,
0.2643163204,
0.6807390451,
-0.0039508455,
0.0320185982,
0.0450246856,
0.2176614553,
0.0005928312,
-0.3566855192,
0.0206194483,
0.4303655326,
0.8998518586,
0.0727724433,
0.3820344508,
-0.3829085529,
1.3400319815,
-0.1814976484,
0.1537810266,
0.1199225336,
-0.6930664182,
-0.2005432993,
0.0722185448,
0.7179808617,
0.1190193444,
0.3772962689,
-0.463499248,
-0.211826846,
-0.2256059498,
0.2274056524,
-0.7425078154,
-0.2224811018,
0.3500418663,
-0.4922138155,
-0.5408276916,
-0.0137737421,
-0.6902009249,
-0.6350489259,
-0.0913675576,
0.561640799,
-0.1412081569,
-0.602620244,
0.1709073782,
-0.2996724546,
-0.0220576264,
0.2706381977,
-0.856719017,
0.6352984905,
0.6764580011,
0.4299848676,
0.0396181867,
-0.0447458588,
-0.4219243228,
0.2501050234,
-0.5470839739,
1.1588029861,
-0.5252315402,
-0.5360147357,
0.104008846,
-0.082538031,
-0.4165832996,
-0.8979975581,
0.7718730569,
-0.2575030029,
0.0880480185,
-0.6173015833,
-0.4637033939,
-0.0358550623,
0.0546089448,
-0.6444036365,
1.245690465,
0.2171604037,
-0.8055756688,
0.5259234905,
-0.7429882288,
-0.7269374132,
-0.1255142242,
-0.3634554446,
-0.5414748192,
0.2594355345,
0.1153845564,
0.0371005721,
-0.3208157718,
-0.0259612575,
-0.1309298128,
-0.8021883965,
0.5212727785,
-0.1129991859,
0.6928711534,
0.1269465685,
-0.3251985312,
-0.3718929589,
-0.9795821309,
0.0647109002,
0.0892428085,
-0.0816610903,
-0.2224093825,
0.3608900309,
0.0890498981,
0.0133562926,
-0.2293096632,
-0.1514054537,
-0.2920380533,
-0.4033722579,
0.2942179739,
0.1486617476,
0.5244882107,
-0.0198081508,
-0.459436208,
0.1146279722,
0.4747499228,
0.3147632182,
0.0182192009,
-0.4720012248,
-0.2103251815,
0.0523999147,
0.1643023342,
0.3609559834,
0.0591893569,
-0.0916799828,
0.1315108836,
-0.2050513923,
-0.3122712076,
0.2660616338,
0.1160634235,
0.6947242618,
0.3999841511,
-0.1009775028,
-0.4704582691,
-0.6489040852,
-0.8932135701,
-0.4127546549,
0.2428046465,
0.4603170156,
0.3480217755,
0.1138288453,
0.8472010493,
-0.0859260708,
-0.4923810363,
0.3595812321,
0.2852740884,
0.1750196368,
0.3645861745,
0.5401394963,
-0.7086999416,
-0.419442296,
-0.2937498689,
-0.6642522812,
-0.2593978941,
-0.1533884108,
-0.0925667435,
0.3631370664,
0.5730515718,
-0.5675618052,
0.591884017,
0.2590336502,
-0.0301737357,
0.8334676027,
0.2397521734,
0.0355827399,
-0.6989665627,
0.3400664926,
-0.0132808667,
0.2894949615,
-0.3501488268,
-0.3226335943,
-0.049582772,
-0.2072848827,
-0.0540954918,
0.016921822,
-0.6102598906,
-0.2568240166,
0.0537107214,
0.0736486986,
0.145440653,
0.0016439791,
0.0293785892,
1.0785908699,
0.4989748299,
-0.6541073918,
-0.2561957836,
0.348519206,
-0.383025676,
0.8579857349,
-0.7249004841,
-0.2053570896,
-0.084444575,
0.105708003,
-1.0827274323,
-0.1261359006,
0.123179622,
-0.3330891728,
0.2130041867,
-0.3490697742,
-0.8205993176,
-0.0267827027,
-0.0101317996,
0.1511556208,
0.2518940568,
-0.2780246735,
-0.0500989519,
0.2610606551,
-0.0435144901,
-0.5019280314,
-0.9734527469,
0.2717780769,
0.0854612812,
-0.5251386166,
0.2555603683,
0.0335033871,
-0.5240544081,
0.0787570551,
-0.2550106347,
-0.6020023823,
0.017979661,
0.336643815,
-0.0838501453,
-0.3359265327,
0.5742915273,
-0.1180041954,
0.2674672604,
0.4955138266,
-0.1861368567,
0.0895141289,
-0.2383799851,
-0.2886728048,
-0.4511229992,
0.4070551395,
0.3915924132,
-0.4099121988,
0.8915711641,
0.390393883,
-0.0993318185,
-0.364312917,
-0.3087138236,
-0.2750996351,
-0.3816483617,
0.5227862,
-0.2509050071,
-0.0937586874,
0.3703579903,
-0.2437924892,
0.2588926852,
0.6983309388,
0.0306576882,
-0.4790372849,
1.0670667887,
0.4246112406,
0.4033287168,
0.5694061518,
0.101484701,
0.0698826835,
-0.548116982,
-0.235629335,
-1.0984333754,
0.0849189758,
-0.3553004265,
-0.369017452,
-0.0238162559,
0.0791666657,
-0.320469588,
-0.0780047923,
-0.7071387768,
0.4315138757,
0.041153457,
-0.0400228575,
0.587123394,
0.4044655263,
0.2197150886,
-0.2966378927,
-0.6298072338,
-0.1248481572,
1.034596324,
-0.2979109287,
0.7882461548,
0.1519019902,
0.5868996978,
0.3154902458,
-0.0573156402,
-0.3281364441,
0.2746115327,
-0.3515683115,
-0.8716190457,
-0.1913799345,
-0.4786419868,
-1.0490962267,
0.0518300757,
-0.4146604538,
-0.770991981,
0.2528912425,
-0.0030212014,
-0.1453775615,
0.2224108875,
-0.5630112886,
0.9523337483,
-0.0688267946,
-0.5707726479,
0.0867430493,
-0.6715337634,
0.4687888324,
-0.2160654068,
0.5279434919,
-0.0634422749,
0.0828918666,
0.7069482207,
-0.5588437915,
0.8563393354,
-0.0686969012,
-0.0393310189,
0.4489350021,
0.1043646261,
0.7906795144,
-0.3279614151,
-0.6548378468,
0.2325615287,
0.424821347,
-0.2728377283,
-0.4801732004,
0.3963538408,
-0.9021859169,
-0.2215017229,
-0.4051262438,
-0.6963921785,
-0.2591365576,
0.0858320147,
0.1425575912,
0.5475358367,
-0.0379114859,
0.3550396264,
0.6888029575,
-0.0424851216,
0.1759429276,
0.7569278479,
-0.2124879658,
0.1153149009,
0.7536118627,
0.6794347167,
0.0266583245,
0.2443618476,
-0.0249005109,
-0.6728229523,
-0.7619928122,
-0.1578858495,
0.299582094,
-0.5926611423,
0.03961711,
-0.8012439609,
-0.3879422843,
-0.2904700041,
0.2242005914,
-0.3393589258,
-0.5454580784,
-0.6404955387,
0.1526726037,
0.4849279523,
0.7630683184,
0.2141979486,
0.2219918519,
-0.5219601989,
-0.0125830574,
0.0401808769,
0.6691440344,
-0.1599720418,
-0.4420807958,
-0.2265003473,
-0.1355100572,
0.0784086287,
-1.1375287771,
-0.0015936207,
0.6306612492,
0.4917750955,
-0.0007886405,
0.6445270777,
0.8850540519,
0.0035088235,
0.8724647164,
-0.2452646047,
-0.5993802547,
0.6697657704,
-0.6776108742,
0.2083581686,
0.8863087296,
-0.260043174,
-0.2984474301,
-0.5453627706,
-0.6597446203,
-0.688513577,
0.6584771872,
0.4029129744,
-0.2357049733,
-0.1592594981,
0.5939335227,
0.0030673794,
0.4254098833,
-0.6018221974,
-0.153413415,
-0.2080079317,
0.1007677242,
0.1604792923,
-0.225345239,
-0.1927052289,
-0.0852907375,
0.5337511897,
0.1042597145,
0.1356351227,
0.1720703244,
-0.2755716741,
-0.4437119961,
0.3697685301,
0.6135711074,
0.542722702,
-0.6524946094,
0.0210297871,
-0.1104807705,
-0.3456094265,
-0.3860190809,
0.3028643727,
-0.2774020135,
0.3882934451,
0.0029169729,
0.390652597,
0.1713734269,
-0.5735148191,
0.3640607297,
-0.1664595902,
-0.3600385189,
-0.1724096537,
0.0592345186,
0.1308705211,
-0.2795593739,
0.3800235987,
0.4203585088,
0.2980668247,
-0.4460142255,
0.1244986579,
0.386682719,
-0.6477100849,
-0.2048508525,
0.8641299009,
0.3672240376,
-0.3600241542,
0.6766117811,
-0.0609474182,
0.0782180354,
0.5195056796,
0.6325129867,
0.5329917073,
0.3011563718,
0.2461546957,
0.3449344933,
0.6016753316,
-0.155396089,
0.5508722663,
-0.076933153,
-0.1271039844,
-0.3628466725,
-0.5895606875,
-0.5210335255,
0.0796785578,
-0.9280020595,
-0.120839633,
-0.40459764,
-0.3384604454,
0.1699930578,
0.2495720387,
-0.3356716633,
0.1274482161,
-0.3359785974,
0.778364718,
-0.8499979973,
0.4910819829,
0.628524363,
-0.4115436077,
-0.6589794755,
0.0235628765,
0.1719110906,
-0.4235512316,
0.4138464034,
0.0162437335,
0.1720994562,
-0.1346724629,
-0.462091893,
-0.6025368571,
0.5480685234,
0.3319217265,
-0.4684830308,
0.4684447646,
0.6830298305,
0.6496442556,
0.0068070223,
0.2325737029,
0.5996363759,
0.5781363845,
0.0546850972,
-0.7686730623,
0.0451879278,
-0.2528100014,
-0.1263158023,
0.2735234499,
-0.7264252901,
1.0416120291,
-0.1289748996,
-0.2214047611,
-0.0710986108,
0.261131376,
0.1076252013,
0.2732861936,
0.4021457136,
0.1231074557,
0.9930668473,
-0.169742018,
0.9479129314,
-0.4678579569,
0.1089735851,
1.2860267162,
-0.603690505,
1.0361274481,
0.5371629596,
-0.4626497328,
0.4473166764,
0.6414209604,
-0.0988968611,
0.183958903,
0.3542336822,
-0.3259210289,
-0.1219074652,
-0.4013033807,
-0.8926416636,
0.0569488257,
0.5222485662,
-0.2947609127,
-0.5233636498,
-0.6273352504,
-0.36022228,
0.1257236004,
0.0866857842,
0.8973551393,
-0.0668929443,
-0.3945202529,
0.5027433038,
-0.3043465316,
0.3108173609,
-0.6442931294,
0.0662783459,
-0.2223417461,
0.2177817672,
-0.4898858666,
-0.6788323522,
0.7970799208,
-0.1681546718,
-0.4335393012,
0.0019279916,
0.6419878602,
-0.4705625772,
-0.5937242508,
-0.0223792903,
0.4468574226,
0.5391587615,
-0.6877012849,
-0.921923995,
0.3565048277,
-0.2236572504,
-0.104350172,
0.529394865,
0.5612472296,
0.032507848,
0.2313131988,
0.7589777112,
0.1431675553,
0.0956795067,
0.3138884902,
0.5017471313,
-0.5303784013,
-0.3926252127,
-0.5468833447,
0.2512893081,
-0.2057614177,
-0.176671207,
0.8020014167,
0.803178668,
0.2219158411,
-0.0290791076,
0.5978825688,
0.2883141637,
0.6491168141,
-0.0896960646,
1.0223869085,
-0.6770787835,
0.5805687904,
-0.4719983637,
-0.7888286114,
-0.3315619528,
0.4077613354,
-0.0336257145,
0.1301654577,
0.737074852,
1.1365534067,
0.3509518206,
0.4227031469,
0.3362317383,
0.4452406466,
0.1756561846,
0.0696693137,
0.6861769557,
-0.8499621153,
1.3015375137,
-0.2051604688,
0.2327814847,
-0.3321748972,
-0.702514112,
-0.6044649482,
-0.4027616084,
-0.8182774782,
-0.606353879,
0.6004730463,
0.3284941018,
0.8171007633,
-0.8077174425,
-0.5130239129,
-0.3233704269,
0.061081592,
-0.7958478332,
-0.2890816331,
0.4693148136,
-0.6556859016,
-0.3784859478,
0.1908220798,
0.221124202,
0.1505779177,
0.2834238112,
0.2626444995,
-0.2324901372,
0.2814007699,
0.4556488097,
0.5260618925,
-0.3897134364,
0.1790536642,
-0.0544038266,
-0.3208475709,
-0.0192241389,
0.4462484121,
-0.7292077541,
0.5274415016,
0.2332854569,
0.329372406,
0.7362437248,
0.1428338885,
0.4482524693,
-1.0063349009,
0.2165529728,
0.0607115887,
-0.2030225694,
0.2151552141,
-0.5450316072,
0.6587666869,
0.4567672014,
-0.3984225094,
-1.2285723686,
-0.2819214761,
-0.8849018812,
-0.395157665,
1.0560532808,
0.3269990981,
-0.4227823913,
-0.5761308074,
-0.1080039367,
-0.0543253422,
-0.307403326,
0.8873408437,
0.792593956,
-0.2599886954,
-0.3369623721,
-0.6501294374,
0.8597145081,
0.449829489,
-0.8332106471,
0.5001295209,
0.3567706645,
0.2680807114,
-0.2520149648,
0.6269029379,
-0.4529377818,
0.2869612277,
0.5473101735,
-0.2951563597,
-0.2050595134,
0.1423413157,
-0.1184122413,
0.2624731362,
0.0773974434,
0.0149955405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12234v1
|
Task-Oriented Dialogue with In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-19T15:43:35 | 2024-02-19T15:43:35 |
Tom Bocklisch, Thomas Werkmeister, Daksh Varshneya, Alan Nichol
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We describe a system for building task-oriented dialogue systems combining
the in-context learning abilities of large language models (LLMs) with the
deterministic execution of business logic. LLMs are used to translate between
the surface form of the conversation and a domain-specific language (DSL) which
is used to progress the business logic. We compare our approach to the
intent-based NLU approach predominantly used in industry today. Our experiments
show that developing chatbots with our system requires significantly less
effort than established approaches, that these chatbots can successfully
navigate complex dialogues which are extremely challenging for NLU-based
systems, and that our system has desirable properties for scaling task-oriented
dialogue systems to a large number of tasks. We make our implementation
available for use and further study.
|
[
-0.026045939,
-1.0058788061,
0.6655766368,
0.2697886825,
-0.016491387,
0.197890684,
-0.2199729681,
-0.376896441,
-0.1330530345,
0.8350130916,
-0.7713172436,
-0.4264585078,
-0.3100478351,
-0.0143791297,
-0.1783037633,
0.8995467424,
0.2521383464,
0.1159467027,
-0.2366174906,
0.0601645634,
-0.7742313147,
-0.6521721482,
-1.011726737,
-0.5156200528,
0.1055450812,
0.3237725794,
0.4579660892,
0.1018991917,
0.2806347013,
0.3814159036,
0.0477138087,
0.1205764264,
-0.462754339,
0.5413871408,
-0.3762108386,
-0.6651391983,
-0.4530135989,
-0.3469156921,
0.2764578462,
0.9401586652,
-0.2328021675,
0.0443885215,
0.0881673023,
0.5344771147,
-0.3211779296,
0.5893687606,
-0.5790696144,
0.0624399073,
0.1772366762,
-0.2222601771,
-0.7581402063,
-0.0657185838,
0.3793359101,
-0.375339061,
-0.4246150851,
0.1456362605,
0.2857707441,
0.212831527,
-0.4038270414,
-0.5233101249,
-1.0375384092,
1.1780188084,
-0.7703148723,
0.4127965271,
0.1489921808,
0.3654456139,
-0.5343747139,
-0.5975413918,
-0.3914745748,
-0.2943066061,
0.0043049357,
0.0759154782,
-0.1140075624,
0.1965177208,
0.3464362323,
0.1144185215,
-0.3171950877,
0.0276092775,
-0.1154725701,
0.2382573187,
0.5805078149,
0.5375800133,
0.1203888953,
0.0489119813,
-0.4732318223,
0.3499540091,
-0.6893355846,
0.1236533225,
0.073768124,
0.608910501,
0.1376330107,
0.3721503317,
-0.3639976978,
0.9474058747,
0.078217648,
-0.5398118496,
-0.0939752534,
-0.1862049401,
-0.5981301665,
0.0872541815,
0.6895939112,
0.2320488244,
-0.0853738338,
-0.1080386266,
-0.384008944,
-0.0391405411,
0.3321524262,
-0.6119129658,
0.1854510605,
0.389639169,
-0.4788753092,
-0.1248591989,
-0.497227937,
-0.1569332778,
-0.1882635355,
-0.6193386912,
0.4349704385,
-0.3843606412,
-0.0473408885,
0.1110905707,
-0.0188210644,
0.2346363366,
0.7768111229,
-0.7279734015,
0.5997411013,
0.8033506274,
0.5426066518,
-0.2251702696,
0.0924692824,
-0.5843011737,
0.372844547,
-0.3676544726,
0.4157894552,
-0.6289322972,
-0.434764415,
-0.0121490443,
-0.1453187615,
-0.026385406,
-0.6157653332,
0.432056278,
-0.6300750971,
0.2760562301,
0.1267801076,
-0.6984879971,
-0.3908440173,
0.3909982443,
-0.2445704639,
0.7067116499,
0.1573258191,
-0.2631871104,
0.1211444288,
-1.0713871717,
-0.5840532184,
0.4943446219,
-0.3212837875,
0.09334445,
-0.1207684129,
-0.1027858108,
0.63979882,
-0.4665192962,
0.3966147006,
0.0365305804,
-0.3382133245,
0.3543716669,
-0.4260801077,
0.9900556207,
0.339055866,
-0.6565176845,
0.1536477804,
-0.4398268759,
-0.0252993051,
0.0458615199,
-0.3849975169,
-0.1855245382,
0.4331008494,
-0.0328843631,
0.255764693,
0.3934694827,
-0.5598589778,
0.1399894655,
-0.3816703558,
0.4501503408,
0.5777746439,
-0.2693055868,
0.4053650796,
-0.276561588,
0.4077840149,
0.1255002022,
0.2080141306,
-0.2456703484,
-0.5283566713,
-0.9431698918,
-0.2075346112,
-0.2720879018,
0.8494713902,
-0.7505236268,
0.5221899748,
-0.121994324,
-0.2633348703,
0.0404510126,
0.1859313548,
0.4344512522,
0.5476280451,
0.1275034398,
-0.426636517,
-0.2266780287,
-0.7292177081,
-0.0213613454,
-0.193158716,
-0.1458777487,
0.6339021325,
0.1783537567,
-0.3089292645,
0.9899014235,
-0.4479888678,
-0.3783174157,
-0.8111180663,
-0.1593469828,
0.4899275303,
0.4004168808,
0.2091343254,
-0.8298643231,
-0.657073617,
0.1542635858,
-0.8081746101,
0.1250834912,
-0.0557879023,
-0.1344979256,
0.6194291115,
0.7186596394,
-0.65287745,
0.4760950208,
0.3779259026,
-0.1057825312,
0.3926100135,
0.00193234,
0.075834319,
-1.0935146809,
-0.0450623892,
0.0087923165,
-0.4792824388,
-0.9877137542,
-0.2620562017,
-0.303494215,
-0.2655714154,
-0.6146546602,
0.3675296605,
-0.0911901221,
-0.1994570345,
-0.3457042277,
0.3341087401,
-0.1271256953,
0.9270806313,
0.2824326158,
0.5370982885,
0.4539349973,
-0.8982976079,
0.4429067373,
0.4817679226,
-0.4580592215,
0.9976302385,
-0.5482526422,
0.0692625418,
0.1092536822,
0.5046803355,
-0.6776128411,
-0.0160933044,
0.2724966407,
-0.1749930531,
0.1961520463,
-0.1998363733,
-0.3168762922,
-0.1153446138,
0.4337438047,
0.0962425172,
0.4296809733,
-0.3515690565,
0.6464512348,
0.4761196375,
-0.5233682394,
-0.5260390639,
-0.4713375568,
0.2125280499,
-0.1772451699,
-0.4804931283,
0.1655172706,
-0.08209268,
-0.4788397849,
-0.2525492609,
-0.0869419426,
-0.1534165889,
0.1952876151,
0.3021835685,
0.2968845069,
-0.1410744339,
0.1302838475,
-0.1126088873,
0.0713248104,
0.23785308,
-0.7244970202,
0.6651588678,
-0.2232211381,
-0.5041857362,
-0.7287626863,
0.5542920232,
0.6506980658,
0.0349405222,
0.4373357892,
0.0573118851,
-0.3035672009,
-0.4298250973,
-0.4383247793,
-0.0946066976,
-0.5303165317,
0.4386118948,
-0.4841188788,
-1.0079591274,
0.2311659157,
-0.331535697,
0.4538306296,
0.2734244764,
0.7674313784,
-0.3402434886,
0.9690525532,
0.8273989558,
0.04465257,
0.7827902436,
-0.1343009323,
0.5165695548,
-0.7495402098,
-0.2702704966,
-0.2871982157,
-0.3458894789,
-0.2130725086,
-0.4083632529,
0.2481668144,
-0.1101883054,
-0.3907231688,
0.5741578937,
-0.2185838372,
0.2490852028,
0.7557440996,
0.1236835793,
0.4935233593,
-0.2262377441,
0.0698459744,
0.1933623105,
-0.7585808635,
-0.6741456985,
0.9019390345,
0.2610526383,
0.8467377424,
0.3103758395,
0.53162992,
0.1831765175,
0.3422284126,
-1.0593831539,
0.8028885126,
-0.109464705,
-0.582343936,
-0.6708015203,
-0.4223984182,
-0.8399697542,
0.0186664611,
0.019011762,
-1.0812232494,
-0.1404848546,
-0.1195489988,
-0.2831783593,
0.3038829267,
-0.688870132,
0.7914305925,
-0.3666467071,
-0.1582742631,
-0.466804564,
-0.7087844014,
0.1104903072,
0.0201326273,
0.0676300749,
-0.2396747321,
0.1610459685,
0.5521988869,
-0.4140962064,
1.1302306652,
-0.2470927536,
-0.3807935119,
0.3987275958,
0.1248662621,
0.390493542,
0.0033579366,
0.0801625326,
-0.1072163954,
-0.1927205026,
-0.2208450586,
-0.8740960956,
0.4657999575,
-0.4214368463,
-0.8834609985,
-0.1718741804,
-0.9517202973,
-0.3901837766,
0.1385605931,
-0.3134168983,
0.6793140769,
-0.3497265577,
0.2740730643,
0.7290530205,
-0.2020631582,
0.4208757281,
0.5881253481,
-0.2370099574,
0.0254386757,
0.694306016,
-0.184989199,
0.5770944953,
0.7574592829,
-0.1186468229,
-0.2352747172,
-0.3974111676,
-0.4592393339,
-0.1347752661,
-0.7500118613,
-0.2838886976,
-0.7622553706,
-0.2980024815,
-0.2167074829,
-0.279687196,
-0.3328101039,
-0.3569997251,
-0.1071919724,
0.3134463727,
0.3071198761,
0.8679482341,
0.564624548,
0.3697964549,
-0.8266801238,
0.0465970449,
0.4805231988,
0.3233783841,
-0.1766663641,
-0.4504017532,
-0.3729085028,
0.1663820148,
-0.5774299502,
-0.5253616571,
0.3873591721,
0.1039877087,
0.7882586718,
0.4617225528,
0.1718398333,
0.4637707174,
-0.5516670942,
0.8082450032,
0.2558566928,
-1.122951746,
0.7259652019,
-0.4190655649,
0.284647882,
0.4640786648,
0.4721697867,
-0.6867448688,
-0.6220372319,
-0.4992510974,
-0.6265090704,
0.9085440636,
-0.0052517029,
0.2475959957,
-0.0345119536,
0.1238586903,
0.0394214094,
0.351976186,
-0.3968393803,
-0.2482457906,
0.1492066383,
-0.3308749795,
-0.1389445513,
0.0577508844,
-0.3205021024,
0.0165905152,
0.6396349072,
-0.3461070061,
0.4200992584,
0.1374004483,
-0.3867186904,
0.2313704789,
0.4224343896,
0.5614067316,
0.728820622,
-0.1574758291,
-0.2824411988,
0.1477691531,
-0.2720177472,
0.1701329648,
-0.20518516,
0.0664891824,
-0.1948592812,
-0.1807247549,
0.9630227089,
0.3979942203,
-1.1252121925,
0.5179688931,
-0.0360927172,
-0.1626124978,
-0.3463495374,
0.2330871075,
0.1859938353,
0.7309365869,
0.4422889054,
-0.054556869,
0.2320115268,
-0.8012728691,
0.1496904641,
0.5107291937,
-0.650110662,
0.0524051823,
0.4615316987,
0.5736333132,
-0.6967395544,
0.5802815557,
-0.229836151,
-0.5399386287,
0.522936821,
0.8527314067,
0.9665724635,
-0.0566143543,
0.1813320518,
0.0058782366,
-0.0142984847,
-0.0299402736,
0.2517468929,
-0.3838922083,
-0.6954234242,
-0.748817265,
-0.5336428881,
-0.9925228357,
0.0212907363,
-0.3156139851,
0.1458960027,
-0.4386076331,
-0.1247292459,
-0.2610470355,
0.0157904774,
-0.6200205684,
0.2294875383,
0.0903045982,
0.7485183477,
-0.5007232428,
0.8414110541,
0.6854670644,
-0.0007390571,
-0.4537812173,
-0.1639170349,
-0.0649126098,
-0.3801323473,
1.1745145321,
0.1732046455,
-0.4066436291,
-0.006845003,
-0.3713368773,
-0.7122130394,
1.1535279751,
0.1614094824,
-0.5983572602,
0.0781065226,
0.0992038399,
0.4264615476,
-0.7116135359,
0.0781223774,
0.4545632899,
-0.0120137846,
0.0727528632,
-1.108002305,
0.0564312749,
-0.082153596,
-0.0446769223,
0.1309422702,
-0.599496007,
0.4653583169,
-0.0057595116,
-0.2652918398,
-0.0843427405,
0.7584396601,
0.1317246258,
0.3432871103,
0.6762781739,
0.2980598807,
0.5925096273,
-0.0252798796,
0.5715758801,
-0.3907467127,
0.148361519,
1.2328295708,
-0.5233908296,
0.9489330053,
0.3747476339,
-0.2169080526,
0.6868602037,
0.1652455181,
0.4018418491,
0.242753908,
0.2419021279,
-0.5150316954,
-0.2717395127,
-0.2292111218,
0.3192200363,
0.533688426,
0.9274235964,
-0.0504722819,
-0.0202422142,
0.1081011891,
-0.1548817903,
-0.0595666952,
-0.2492693067,
1.0492990017,
0.2302910089,
-0.7078898549,
0.3626478612,
-0.2069188505,
0.691195786,
-0.5779728293,
0.0833088234,
-0.0445725396,
0.138336435,
-0.021105418,
-0.639611125,
0.4138891995,
-0.0147697525,
-0.0157089066,
-0.4729532897,
0.5854749084,
-0.5505423546,
-0.2043066323,
0.2706374526,
0.6202377081,
0.2306687087,
0.075059332,
-0.6708785892,
-0.084634006,
-0.1096835136,
-0.2412855923,
0.2192995846,
0.3912257552,
-0.1747471988,
1.0962833166,
0.4296306372,
-0.3818448484,
-0.2166758031,
0.0606869534,
0.6097842455,
-0.6365494728,
-0.5120553374,
-0.493172884,
0.4274184406,
-0.2075257599,
0.0845168009,
0.7241706252,
0.5839856863,
1.0238068104,
0.0199330878,
0.9766206145,
-0.1900276244,
0.4584813416,
-0.4338926077,
0.4336849451,
-0.3905670047,
0.2128738612,
-0.2956801951,
-0.9493695498,
-0.2172499001,
0.6854157448,
-0.2587738931,
-0.1183790714,
0.7480419874,
0.6804366112,
0.0328001305,
0.1099237278,
0.5762518644,
-0.0074375398,
0.4121041894,
0.7373480797,
0.8966314197,
-0.2429381758,
0.5015667677,
-0.0736161098,
-0.3950693011,
-0.4119278491,
-0.6060140729,
-0.9165967107,
-0.7460950613,
-0.462282002,
-0.1706355512,
0.0230874326,
1.1273452044,
0.7039061189,
-0.6439148784,
-0.8338953853,
-0.0958555564,
0.1049194932,
-0.4818234742,
-0.2311309129,
-0.0162438266,
-0.8774372339,
-1.1665328741,
0.7347172499,
0.7337628007,
-0.1894750893,
-0.2655752301,
-0.123835817,
-0.0591554865,
0.3273664713,
1.091383934,
0.1940853,
-0.7659733891,
-0.1218383312,
0.0296485703,
-0.2372950166,
0.0997312665,
0.8700883985,
-0.6625561714,
0.3877523839,
0.4244362414,
0.7867097259,
0.468549639,
-0.2775164545,
0.8462961912,
-0.4848277569,
0.1398978531,
0.2445020378,
0.2174319327,
0.1524418145,
-0.2527712286,
0.3471024036,
0.0404255986,
-0.6350373626,
-0.4751204848,
0.7226716876,
-1.1990699768,
-0.3121907711,
0.9888525605,
-0.1992336959,
-0.0902086347,
-0.5781599879,
-0.3262076974,
0.0930414349,
-0.4690791667,
0.4019241333,
0.4106137455,
-0.4113248587,
0.1724041998,
-0.7841646075,
0.4658323824,
0.3220594823,
-0.8638905287,
0.140436247,
0.3609554172,
0.1081722006,
0.224577859,
0.9323868752,
-0.0227715001,
0.0778122246,
-0.2159718573,
0.0258090161,
0.3515483141,
-0.3495868742,
-0.0257598665,
-0.0204095617,
-0.0773304105,
-0.0151900994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12233v1
|
Empirical Study on Updating Key-Value Memories in Transformer Feed-forward Layers
| 2024-02-19T15:42:54 | 2024-02-19T15:42:54 |
Zihan Qiu, Zeyu Huang, Youcheng Huang, Jie Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The feed-forward networks (FFNs) in transformers are recognized as a group of
key-value neural memories to restore abstract high-level knowledge. In this
work, we conduct an empirical ablation study on updating keys (the 1st layer in
the FFNs layer) or values (the 2nd layer in the FFNs layer). We compare those
two methods in various knowledge editing and fine-tuning tasks of large
language models to draw insights to understand FFNs further. Code is available
at $\href{https://github.com/qiuzh20/Tuning-keys-v.s.-values}{this\,repo}$.
|
[
-0.2313510031,
-0.641905129,
0.2723983526,
0.0929256305,
0.1002283692,
0.0163850524,
-0.2682833672,
-0.2981895804,
-0.2562389672,
0.859023869,
-0.5968593955,
-0.0670276582,
-0.387132138,
-0.0463548116,
-0.6524416208,
0.9795838594,
0.1568544954,
-0.0464545377,
-0.0424649119,
-0.1348897219,
-0.359613955,
-0.2141504884,
-1.2000561953,
-0.5650732517,
0.5934938788,
0.236271292,
0.9822593331,
0.9907885194,
0.7555295825,
0.4014080465,
-0.549061954,
-0.1748686135,
-0.4283247292,
0.2402154505,
-0.4255118072,
-0.4187093675,
-0.2936998308,
-0.1783342659,
0.6555413008,
0.7589039803,
0.0967730731,
0.0552637316,
-0.1016424298,
0.9936548471,
-0.5081318617,
0.1893935651,
-0.7357926369,
0.1413329691,
-0.0048625716,
-0.2335530072,
-0.6116033196,
-0.3870552182,
0.286708653,
-0.430405885,
0.5095120072,
-0.0736743137,
0.9713276029,
0.5214599967,
-0.2874155045,
-0.2009531856,
-1.0087482929,
0.5891266465,
-0.5723226666,
0.697350204,
0.2396498024,
0.1933451593,
0.0613827482,
-0.8739749789,
-0.5242938995,
0.1421095878,
-0.3260773718,
0.0709767863,
-0.1374869049,
0.1108082607,
0.4716001153,
0.731487155,
-0.0079276618,
0.0584119782,
-0.7927017212,
-0.1294364184,
0.4746702611,
0.1311935633,
0.1032200828,
0.0835372508,
-0.2376895547,
-0.560585618,
-0.7803378701,
0.174546212,
0.3016595542,
0.2426078469,
0.1059342399,
0.4223752916,
-0.303488344,
0.7046980858,
0.2963907421,
0.0838661641,
0.3837270141,
-0.44011572,
-0.5356317759,
0.027091587,
0.5756697059,
0.3196932971,
0.3407864571,
-0.6101766229,
-0.3395412564,
-0.2837008834,
0.5804588199,
-0.7303789258,
-0.4286658466,
-0.0707720146,
-0.6498343349,
-0.7493231297,
-0.1024256349,
-0.4978171289,
-0.3572748899,
-0.2597682178,
0.7242641449,
-0.5582185388,
-0.2941961288,
0.0383034013,
-0.5409968495,
0.545247972,
0.2652794719,
-1.1995444298,
0.2227031887,
0.7747161388,
0.6191002727,
0.2643653154,
-0.5372901559,
0.0117041189,
-0.2071743309,
-0.2388990074,
0.8214760423,
-0.4045638442,
-0.2712708414,
-0.1831123084,
0.1351981908,
-0.0705175847,
-0.7292419672,
0.4833267927,
-1.2422816753,
0.0026996671,
-0.7147928476,
-0.552167058,
-0.2530443072,
0.0230746176,
-0.8928560615,
1.0506848097,
0.3957759142,
-0.3791575432,
0.3636375964,
-0.5940119028,
-0.5432981849,
-0.3256281614,
0.2336588949,
-0.4107143581,
0.2833124399,
0.0216212869,
0.4013950825,
-0.1533583254,
0.0801889822,
0.04381641,
-0.152619645,
0.6746577621,
-0.6136322021,
0.7053418159,
0.2579644024,
-0.1540727317,
0.1645266116,
-0.7321230173,
-0.2173294872,
0.0415085554,
-0.1478654891,
-0.2221137434,
0.0882499889,
-0.4290348589,
0.5424494743,
-0.0919907913,
-0.5309781432,
0.1608343422,
-0.590333879,
0.7028378844,
0.9074349999,
0.3799662888,
0.6735200286,
-0.5385530591,
0.126778096,
0.381279707,
0.1623547524,
-0.7431169152,
-0.3919322193,
-0.8648457527,
0.4050928056,
0.5333303809,
0.3914166689,
-0.5558828115,
0.2788515687,
-0.2191064507,
-0.4367664754,
-0.7498092651,
0.0150243901,
0.2290422171,
0.9376759529,
0.5454289913,
0.0897236988,
-0.219481647,
-1.0348528624,
-0.2215812802,
-0.0752795488,
-0.2455403954,
0.3115696013,
0.4497475326,
-0.1091672927,
0.8673394918,
-0.472563684,
-0.3099873066,
0.2816378772,
0.0601849966,
0.0966814011,
0.5207217932,
0.3872669935,
-0.7207208872,
-0.3915144503,
0.1970311552,
-0.515276134,
-0.0024310406,
-0.4543636143,
-0.1892700791,
0.0274095964,
0.5375840664,
-0.3472557664,
0.2213383913,
0.4093870819,
-0.3755415976,
0.2594473958,
-0.0931279659,
0.4524666369,
-0.8760483861,
0.0369892567,
-0.1685712039,
-0.013805558,
-0.8214408755,
0.040357478,
0.2433252484,
0.0371704772,
-0.5495949388,
0.4621604383,
-0.2263577133,
-0.1919735521,
-0.3537681103,
-0.161745131,
0.2170209736,
0.6955343485,
0.0131944511,
0.9966869354,
0.4611678421,
-0.5429715514,
0.398234874,
0.3360663652,
-0.3165817857,
0.259429872,
-0.7028015852,
0.1670381874,
-0.1761377007,
-0.1544154435,
-1.0662721395,
-0.0061759013,
0.1659438163,
-0.4655202627,
0.2961239517,
-0.0581753775,
-0.2347253263,
-0.0857761055,
-0.1239166483,
0.2828093469,
0.632255733,
-0.6157853603,
0.6548649669,
0.3119065166,
-0.0706573948,
-0.6348093748,
-0.7340775728,
-0.1994018108,
0.1387237608,
-0.8624038696,
0.5745793581,
0.1835543811,
-0.3349222243,
0.3509667218,
-0.2108801603,
-0.0236795936,
0.197754249,
0.1099426299,
-0.0295951851,
-0.5436639786,
0.2232922465,
0.4257839918,
-0.2667143643,
0.2836790085,
-0.2700817585,
0.4056917429,
-0.3631929755,
-0.1696534753,
-0.1773307472,
0.0649953708,
0.6202133298,
-0.2279037237,
1.0062863827,
0.4083018303,
-0.4414212108,
-0.224037081,
-0.653691709,
-0.4123126566,
-0.5930700302,
0.1525874734,
-0.375397265,
-0.9493027925,
0.8791747093,
-0.2291699201,
0.097519055,
0.8490297198,
0.5332994461,
-0.2711018026,
0.7086846828,
0.3483790755,
-0.1428009123,
0.3712950945,
-0.4062493145,
0.0527799837,
-1.0448114872,
-0.2489937842,
-0.6541150808,
-0.6015565395,
-0.1315451413,
-0.266151756,
0.1033043191,
0.2448863685,
-0.2581980228,
0.3181337416,
-0.5128674507,
0.7583782077,
0.4052859545,
0.232831344,
0.2045615017,
-0.2543400228,
-0.069635205,
0.185636133,
-0.424021095,
-0.1004604548,
0.9644145966,
0.5395432115,
0.6793776751,
-0.2071641088,
0.2138014138,
0.2943383753,
0.3264368773,
-0.8332616091,
0.3250363171,
-0.1309470832,
-0.7881815434,
-0.6074360609,
-0.3431068957,
-0.6309579611,
0.2062441707,
-0.2663982213,
-0.4236908555,
0.3133529127,
0.3990237713,
-0.5342453718,
0.6105592847,
-0.6207569838,
0.8571996689,
-0.1330501735,
-0.2401563376,
-0.1190165356,
-0.7793679833,
0.1211991385,
-0.0076902276,
-0.109199062,
0.3604508936,
0.2152463198,
0.745459795,
-0.2540339231,
0.6591954827,
-0.111316666,
-0.2343178988,
0.1771059334,
-0.1664842516,
0.5095486045,
-0.0396316797,
-0.3323749006,
0.2023017257,
-0.3145074844,
0.0002403252,
-0.8317450285,
0.5755764842,
-0.9525828362,
-0.4216578901,
-0.2203772068,
-0.4239763319,
-0.0249161925,
0.3066326678,
0.2240219116,
0.5686935186,
-0.0762859508,
0.5959611535,
1.1506756544,
-0.2783433497,
0.3340496719,
0.3853155971,
-0.0823963135,
-0.2108529061,
0.6122909784,
0.2165338546,
0.3400565088,
0.7490904331,
0.2599672377,
-0.1326098442,
-0.6823015809,
-0.5089002252,
0.0854748264,
-0.7453978062,
-0.4117052555,
-0.8685318232,
-0.7688323259,
-0.4100871086,
-0.3635942936,
-0.6673250794,
-0.468139559,
-0.1999722868,
-0.2556733191,
0.645400703,
0.6281429529,
-0.0012305401,
0.66867733,
-1.0061770678,
0.4363941848,
0.3155359328,
0.8021456599,
0.282255441,
-0.6329330206,
-0.6863108873,
0.3091931343,
-0.2329412848,
-0.9694642425,
0.1602658182,
0.1286764741,
0.4926184118,
0.4390619993,
-0.1922921091,
0.5652512908,
-0.5128447413,
0.7666978836,
-0.3358358741,
-1.1209658384,
0.4359028935,
-0.2371153533,
0.4117795825,
0.7554400563,
0.0627797469,
-0.8946038485,
-0.1680738479,
-0.5397174954,
-0.7183221579,
1.0474516153,
0.1395796537,
0.1583512425,
0.2121647447,
0.7689161897,
-0.035608165,
0.1629068851,
-0.4085684717,
-0.5253810883,
-0.3270755112,
-0.0447091013,
0.0196414199,
-0.1446998864,
-0.0014292409,
-0.4705578685,
0.7098277807,
0.079187572,
0.7048884034,
0.0227489043,
-0.3215378523,
-0.4001578093,
0.2609604001,
0.8374531269,
0.4529099166,
-0.3532161713,
-0.0477926396,
0.401036948,
-0.5253475308,
0.0841151625,
-0.2526448071,
-0.3707753718,
-0.3873893023,
0.284254998,
1.3672794104,
0.4599587619,
-0.0634516999,
0.3814439774,
-0.1160615385,
-0.5823348165,
-0.2902337611,
0.3002687395,
0.2378986478,
0.3561038375,
0.3883503675,
0.8124647737,
0.0572349019,
-0.4619191289,
0.346216768,
0.1914696991,
-0.5150617957,
-0.5758877397,
0.6131910086,
0.0829310566,
-0.530700326,
0.9995800853,
0.1410460174,
-0.6301423311,
0.5594943762,
0.5819630623,
0.9927648306,
-0.2835986018,
0.1692267507,
0.2540803254,
0.5598490238,
-0.1031195372,
0.0569610894,
-0.1628896296,
-1.2034748793,
-0.6322267056,
-0.5591343045,
-0.4951665998,
0.2366889566,
-0.7167145014,
0.1407805383,
-0.2375310808,
0.0480837598,
0.3270445168,
-0.2363864034,
-0.7786773443,
0.3808886409,
-0.1085000858,
1.1205476522,
-0.9635207057,
1.0536365509,
0.5681040287,
-0.1542499214,
-0.939765811,
-0.1931336373,
-0.1378588974,
-0.6795102954,
0.6804851294,
-0.2291022688,
0.015091504,
0.2154601365,
-0.1324189305,
-1.0670442581,
1.2210576534,
-0.0274891499,
-0.3103545904,
-0.3230765462,
0.475405395,
0.7317847013,
-0.0889386907,
0.2866899073,
0.740177989,
0.6652787924,
0.1345597953,
-0.4900915325,
-0.1049494222,
-0.4567409456,
-0.042628184,
0.586093545,
-0.7067190409,
1.0196472406,
0.0276287179,
-0.1654451191,
-0.3727316856,
0.7655466199,
-0.4188353717,
-0.0246697105,
0.6018083096,
0.6713290215,
0.5159681439,
-0.3657732904,
0.6904990077,
-0.5663322806,
0.187481299,
0.8223858476,
-0.2749134004,
0.5694782138,
0.4171195328,
-0.0578375645,
0.2866558731,
0.205414176,
-0.3226808608,
0.7248888612,
-0.1003955081,
0.068277359,
0.1711085737,
0.4407517016,
-0.4272542,
0.3910677433,
0.4455385208,
-0.7936108708,
-0.0321379676,
0.2078913897,
0.1296507418,
-0.2658995986,
-0.2385792732,
1.1167348623,
-0.0383205302,
-0.7613036633,
0.2289744467,
0.1792280227,
0.4851490855,
-0.4619970322,
0.1271790564,
-0.205777809,
0.4213519096,
-0.1142063886,
-1.0376776457,
0.8478155136,
-0.155613929,
-0.445282042,
-0.6000893712,
1.0868402719,
-0.3621292114,
-0.3407922685,
0.2069375217,
0.2875736654,
-0.4667913318,
-0.0428921282,
-0.5737848282,
0.0720649585,
-0.0737285614,
-0.6302473545,
0.3052138388,
0.3654904962,
0.296269387,
0.4149268866,
0.6181881428,
0.1303613186,
0.1987704784,
0.0862341374,
1.0078499317,
-0.8413775563,
-0.3042976558,
-0.8575305939,
0.7300138474,
0.0047660759,
-0.5179121494,
0.6496101022,
0.5403148532,
1.1889899969,
-0.2963599265,
0.6298232079,
0.2057919055,
0.4322031736,
-0.6269778013,
0.9962914586,
-0.2385171801,
0.2853687704,
-0.3140912652,
-0.8091033697,
-0.2734680772,
0.6231319308,
-0.0842059627,
-0.1953373253,
0.6156537533,
0.9306721687,
0.0179805961,
0.5127183199,
0.1929564476,
0.4279553294,
0.1912875324,
0.1822811812,
0.8973172307,
-0.9096696377,
0.2895714343,
-0.9704767466,
-0.0440252498,
0.0523733422,
-0.6791853905,
-0.5870107412,
-0.7812995911,
-0.3069742322,
-0.3163674176,
0.0467884131,
0.6105955839,
0.4155830741,
-0.8893550634,
-0.1184613183,
-0.0135570904,
0.1762028188,
-0.7512897253,
-0.2342774868,
0.2756568193,
-0.3600011766,
-0.2950212657,
0.3425136507,
0.2542749643,
-0.2385362238,
-0.1516931504,
0.0483927615,
-0.0401585326,
0.2776913643,
0.6782821417,
0.1506625861,
-0.2912368774,
-0.5600790381,
0.6529000998,
-0.0309176091,
0.1987463534,
0.9771840572,
-0.8873032331,
0.2029332966,
0.9289560318,
0.7753401995,
0.4739511311,
-0.0630868152,
0.5119111538,
-0.8008702993,
-0.1426754445,
0.057444185,
0.3423784375,
0.1151865497,
-0.4838136733,
0.2991609275,
0.0287167989,
-0.9277303219,
-0.7194520831,
0.0392891169,
-1.0202374458,
-0.13456662,
0.8775200248,
0.0031085166,
-0.3749337494,
0.0186409187,
-0.1123808101,
0.4894347489,
-0.139807269,
0.707431376,
0.628364861,
0.1035585999,
-0.3766290545,
-0.1585118473,
0.8104836345,
0.1389649957,
-0.4894297123,
0.1427093744,
0.2276340425,
0.0872307867,
0.2932617664,
0.4738170803,
-0.224911347,
0.2720304132,
0.0390896127,
-0.2021032721,
-0.3973149359,
-0.4964361489,
-0.5745996237,
0.2500067055,
-0.1419699639,
0.1303566992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12226v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12226v3
|
AnyGPT: Unified Multimodal LLM with Discrete Sequence Modeling
| 2024-02-19T15:33:10 | 2024-03-07T06:31:46 |
Jun Zhan, Junqi Dai, Jiasheng Ye, Yunhua Zhou, Dong Zhang, Zhigeng Liu, Xin Zhang, Ruibin Yuan, Ge Zhang, Linyang Li, Hang Yan, Jie Fu, Tao Gui, Tianxiang Sun, Yugang Jiang, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
We introduce AnyGPT, an any-to-any multimodal language model that utilizes
discrete representations for the unified processing of various modalities,
including speech, text, images, and music. AnyGPT can be trained stably without
any alterations to the current large language model (LLM) architecture or
training paradigms. Instead, it relies exclusively on data-level preprocessing,
facilitating the seamless integration of new modalities into LLMs, akin to the
incorporation of new languages. We build a multimodal text-centric dataset for
multimodal alignment pre-training. Utilizing generative models, we synthesize
the first large-scale any-to-any multimodal instruction dataset. It consists of
108k samples of multi-turn conversations that intricately interweave various
modalities, thus equipping the model to handle arbitrary combinations of
multimodal inputs and outputs. Experimental results demonstrate that AnyGPT is
capable of facilitating any-to-any multimodal conversation while achieving
performance comparable to specialized models across all modalities, proving
that discrete representations can effectively and conveniently unify multiple
modalities within a language model. Demos are shown in
https://junzhan2000.github.io/AnyGPT.github.io/
|
[
-0.185563907,
-0.8190914392,
0.675123632,
0.0584430099,
-0.2122871131,
-0.2133315504,
-0.2927626371,
-0.1019670516,
0.0251117069,
0.4481239319,
-0.7527023554,
-0.7119716406,
-0.2412285805,
-0.1718167514,
-0.6011587381,
1.1240800619,
0.1834468544,
0.3016366363,
-0.0586441457,
-0.0121545354,
-0.3918992579,
-0.5346368551,
-0.5065640211,
-0.2503853738,
0.5978097916,
0.3291552663,
0.6743348837,
0.9119204879,
0.2280268669,
0.3295640945,
0.3692083657,
-0.1218299493,
-0.3145384789,
0.2136363685,
-0.0439913906,
-0.1336763054,
-0.5821050406,
-0.0745726526,
0.9413374662,
0.572244525,
-0.3690908551,
0.0411965735,
-0.3930554688,
0.3002596498,
-0.4306880236,
0.1167904064,
-0.5899882317,
0.1560406983,
-0.4450986087,
-0.1303902268,
-0.5251765847,
-0.2440879345,
0.154308185,
-0.4599014819,
-0.0818595886,
-0.15114066,
0.3160672486,
0.2187089026,
-0.6902045012,
0.031304244,
-0.632442534,
0.5154921412,
-0.4999306202,
0.8023591638,
-0.0450946949,
0.1830107719,
0.0448119305,
-0.947530508,
-0.8266320229,
-0.2898694873,
0.1708166599,
0.1916517317,
0.0785358027,
0.3769318759,
0.1303898543,
0.2945154607,
-1.0519014597,
0.012163192,
0.0428335965,
0.0755179748,
0.3574178517,
0.2558988631,
0.529782474,
-0.2952930033,
-0.6692131162,
-0.2407981157,
-0.6079598069,
-0.0707336664,
-0.0548006743,
0.2574546933,
-0.3079599142,
0.6980879307,
0.1906664521,
0.9073044062,
-0.1911900043,
-0.3420119584,
-0.1255908757,
-0.4165257215,
-0.4629981816,
0.0409250185,
1.080553174,
-0.1687142253,
0.1647500694,
-0.1977704167,
-0.0664736703,
0.2413687408,
0.3498599529,
-0.6506536603,
-0.5630161762,
-0.1870234311,
-0.3130890429,
-0.0664888769,
0.1080790758,
-0.6910480857,
-0.3305161595,
-0.3486956358,
0.3517525792,
-0.6133022308,
-0.229717508,
0.167520538,
0.346249491,
0.2595035136,
0.2198027074,
-1.1048561335,
0.0715629309,
0.3750373721,
0.4478599727,
-0.1675544381,
-0.5888078809,
-0.1147495657,
0.2540585101,
-0.2268651575,
0.9857649803,
-0.8388385773,
-0.5012121797,
-0.041247189,
-0.2654856741,
-0.5473364592,
0.1465636343,
0.5376530886,
-0.4831575453,
0.2047692686,
0.0548992492,
-0.4752215743,
-0.2544904053,
0.2653470933,
-0.5234127045,
0.6243584156,
-0.0791934431,
-0.5444527864,
-0.0703536496,
-1.0334202051,
-0.3387954533,
-0.0661166981,
-0.7135016322,
-0.2892647386,
-0.0365782157,
0.1521019191,
0.3268890083,
-0.444842875,
0.1589981616,
-0.2888697982,
-0.0325950198,
0.4242564738,
-1.0462294817,
0.4418042302,
0.1197377518,
-0.0979403853,
0.2991176546,
-0.8171545267,
0.1603118777,
0.0069797179,
-0.4401095808,
0.2705594301,
-0.0799726248,
0.5742948055,
0.3931084573,
0.18827793,
-0.6421934366,
0.6105108857,
0.3138692379,
0.587135911,
0.9180416465,
-0.2522487044,
0.7319571972,
-0.3948630095,
0.5904942751,
-0.3085871339,
0.2787586451,
-0.9080785513,
-0.4732544422,
-0.6255575418,
-0.5817585588,
0.634321928,
0.6347557902,
-0.851814568,
0.1414562315,
-0.7822352648,
-0.1429808587,
-0.4185170829,
-0.0569839627,
0.4434288442,
0.3651111424,
0.0013218164,
-0.645850718,
-0.6936458945,
-0.5216216445,
0.2877817452,
-0.178121224,
0.0742517486,
0.0004442259,
0.2350670397,
-0.2785249054,
1.0861771107,
-0.2111232579,
-0.2328499109,
-0.1478319466,
0.3394492269,
-0.170283556,
0.5755107403,
0.2010512948,
-0.9623234868,
-0.4917677045,
0.0397372842,
-0.7778143287,
0.1458176225,
-0.2856921852,
0.0130125657,
0.2480512559,
0.3967656791,
-0.8927047849,
0.2321800441,
0.8536863327,
-0.2512425184,
0.480896771,
-0.0677751005,
0.288836211,
-1.1992149353,
0.0537125915,
-0.3632552922,
-0.4047381878,
-0.7400191426,
-0.1392020881,
0.0838258341,
-0.5189392567,
-0.5743029714,
0.3710218072,
-0.3172122538,
-0.159246102,
0.1331284642,
0.1691964865,
-0.1647393852,
0.5805422068,
0.178679496,
0.8110345006,
0.7453389168,
-0.1977472007,
0.5211778879,
0.4228766859,
-0.4011619091,
0.7131581306,
-0.3250521123,
0.4122806191,
-0.1453408897,
0.4370286167,
-1.2380334139,
-0.4277734458,
0.1083744988,
-0.5344064236,
0.4660379291,
-0.2186633199,
-0.557338357,
0.0953878984,
-0.1707326919,
0.5693374872,
0.3367921114,
-0.585624218,
0.92655164,
0.0633691102,
-0.3233342767,
-0.3911908567,
-0.6054748893,
0.0824799314,
0.0424556322,
-0.7834147811,
0.3833081126,
-0.3422634304,
0.3961359262,
0.0668699667,
-0.2329371274,
-0.2301431745,
-0.4934534132,
0.3199311793,
0.3891724348,
-0.2245359123,
0.2640793025,
-0.3136903942,
-0.2333888412,
-0.2557327449,
-0.5254880786,
0.7606911063,
-0.1304091364,
-0.7568230033,
-0.4183136523,
0.3983575702,
0.6877961755,
-0.3743392527,
0.1601143479,
0.7923188806,
0.0870706588,
0.0383533947,
-0.5760746598,
0.0380120873,
-0.458055228,
0.4400567114,
-0.4724804759,
-1.1249097586,
0.2366808653,
0.0474080071,
-0.0751394257,
-0.0762282535,
0.4039374888,
-0.0232430026,
1.3968418837,
0.7586411834,
-0.2218256444,
0.8800655007,
-0.07706853,
0.2754136026,
-0.58021909,
-0.2245952189,
-0.120260559,
-0.1851190478,
-0.6606709361,
-0.4926102459,
0.475741148,
-0.1482103765,
-0.4819893837,
0.3125753403,
-0.2956169546,
0.6160531044,
0.4566892684,
0.0572295822,
0.4086181521,
0.0208893213,
-0.094743304,
-0.0000104724,
-0.8989776969,
-0.29956159,
1.1510225534,
0.016725624,
1.1244089603,
0.141434446,
0.4761161208,
0.1876512766,
0.4067048728,
-0.669005692,
0.6487883329,
-0.2566035986,
-0.5431358218,
-0.2876457274,
-0.5417382121,
-0.7632511258,
0.3376683891,
-0.2638388276,
-0.7623046637,
-0.0398893505,
-0.0894781947,
-0.3997232616,
0.5811796188,
-0.5818378925,
1.1835401058,
-0.3418433368,
0.0957775414,
0.2586219013,
-0.7358881831,
0.4573908448,
0.0034279511,
0.0483074598,
-0.0223709624,
-0.0146274269,
0.3392823637,
0.1102841422,
0.9528347254,
0.4593063891,
-0.3055166006,
0.0530225821,
0.2283541262,
0.3033637702,
0.2091199756,
0.2198154032,
-0.0204299446,
0.0108828191,
-0.4079606533,
-0.6913750768,
0.7532687783,
-0.6399410367,
-0.2003263682,
-0.3474819362,
-0.8566855192,
-0.0839496478,
0.2066496462,
0.2826403975,
0.6870809197,
-0.33600986,
0.0793865472,
0.8222409487,
0.0195129607,
0.5733530521,
0.7514152527,
-0.2334299237,
-0.5813442469,
1.0700004101,
-0.1802158356,
0.1608072519,
0.7086909413,
-0.1782739908,
-0.4943689704,
-0.1896536946,
-0.6571930051,
0.0604411922,
-0.8228756189,
-0.2123710662,
-0.5426036716,
-0.1210330576,
-0.5287689567,
-0.0641116574,
-0.6780800819,
-0.4948693812,
-0.0221143067,
0.0687558129,
0.23835513,
0.768660903,
-0.1507977396,
0.4659771025,
-0.9251395464,
0.3059111536,
0.8539559841,
0.329390496,
-0.3006627858,
-0.5174148679,
0.1676699221,
0.0609748177,
-0.6830342412,
-0.7869221568,
0.2554790974,
0.3638364673,
0.2643108666,
0.7028282285,
-0.348859638,
0.7565158606,
-0.7843919396,
0.9682589769,
0.5190300941,
-1.1031701565,
0.2186912745,
-0.5971832871,
0.3696530163,
0.249867633,
0.4156789482,
-0.9001976848,
0.2446723282,
-0.4987382293,
-0.5076592565,
0.7429241538,
0.0386171304,
0.2201831192,
-0.0739062354,
0.0329193808,
-0.1184623465,
0.3319123685,
-1.0287731886,
-0.3423424661,
-0.32474944,
-0.2126455456,
-0.2234167308,
-0.1035695598,
-0.0476143174,
-0.2360973507,
0.2139186263,
0.0352597721,
0.6491323709,
-0.1677018553,
-0.1960712373,
0.0066636419,
0.6194949746,
0.8201544881,
0.652221024,
-0.148975268,
0.3132495284,
-0.0633864626,
-0.2249264568,
0.2675339878,
0.213917926,
0.0275061894,
-0.016431164,
0.2506220341,
0.9063987136,
0.520016253,
-0.6882753372,
0.5540289283,
-0.0611193925,
-0.1707571,
-0.2281720638,
-0.2628852725,
-0.1770422757,
0.2931421995,
-0.0196796227,
0.1636059433,
-0.0049139517,
-0.6516833901,
0.3480429649,
0.2262498587,
-0.516441226,
-0.5658655167,
0.743840158,
-0.0185989719,
-0.1368460059,
0.8134336472,
-0.1233183593,
-0.44413957,
0.1074553058,
0.6402894258,
0.8510299921,
-0.5631882548,
0.4567991793,
-0.0999285728,
0.1570572406,
-0.0528890304,
0.210732758,
-0.2856021821,
-0.8660722971,
-0.7616505027,
-0.5150976181,
-0.4770753086,
0.1908708066,
-0.4190178216,
-0.0990346894,
-0.206607461,
0.0056513124,
-0.1243389547,
-0.6565427184,
-0.3998170197,
0.1356717348,
0.3880978227,
0.5578995943,
-0.871109724,
1.2071450949,
1.0239428282,
-0.6122107506,
-0.6597383618,
-0.2212098837,
0.1969484538,
-0.8198484182,
0.5981874466,
-0.1098128632,
0.0763581246,
0.2328424901,
-0.5326592326,
-0.8269769549,
1.0722103119,
0.6283708811,
-0.2440311462,
-0.2051028311,
0.4661956429,
0.1614608765,
-0.4821363688,
0.2671281397,
0.643409133,
0.4552491605,
0.2819587588,
-0.862249434,
-0.2203500718,
-0.3549675345,
0.4720523059,
0.3955920339,
-0.3748857379,
1.0825487375,
0.0575012192,
-0.3672232926,
0.3360776305,
0.4399501085,
0.0625308454,
-0.1026785895,
0.285142988,
0.8451913595,
0.3737600148,
-0.2209500521,
1.2493544817,
-0.281020999,
0.2188363224,
1.1463276148,
-0.1330682337,
0.8010705709,
0.3416623771,
-0.0726043582,
0.2702504694,
0.4849225879,
0.1952684075,
0.6230158806,
0.0339219645,
-0.8085430264,
-0.4774624109,
-0.1844804585,
-0.4062773585,
0.7069835067,
0.2048911452,
-0.1803784668,
-0.4621118903,
0.2532592714,
-0.1200708225,
-0.0355488732,
-0.1776811033,
0.8205094337,
-0.0103352685,
-0.4650423825,
0.7230652571,
0.0789149329,
0.791311264,
-0.9721252918,
-0.1360742897,
-0.2558878362,
-0.0236039907,
-0.0943966508,
-0.509768486,
-0.0618250333,
-0.0875280872,
-0.3599500656,
-0.5332657099,
0.4622449279,
-0.9488139749,
-0.188996315,
-0.0268866513,
0.3230417967,
0.0586218946,
-0.2266569883,
-0.7614187002,
0.2019000351,
0.0342959128,
-0.1874945462,
0.5711905956,
0.521096766,
0.001185887,
0.6529681087,
0.6938958764,
-0.1635449827,
0.3170294464,
0.2216859609,
0.9701767564,
-0.5089364648,
-0.1968826801,
-0.8136979342,
0.6314876676,
0.4100295305,
-0.2157469541,
0.7742568851,
0.3055755496,
1.056293726,
-0.2223588824,
0.8169372082,
-0.2319019288,
-0.0747214258,
-0.6725600362,
0.5500303507,
-0.3414456248,
0.0802427828,
-0.2266218811,
-1.0897506475,
-0.2345383912,
0.8305664659,
-0.1729037911,
0.2695819438,
0.7582255602,
0.8399261832,
-0.2840627134,
0.3430334628,
0.6796197295,
0.080136463,
0.2833686769,
0.5891694427,
0.9460276365,
-0.3410508335,
0.848154366,
-0.2179978639,
-0.1632786393,
0.3081908822,
-0.9963605404,
-0.7713886499,
-0.5563313365,
0.0265311543,
0.1215765551,
0.08953958,
1.1054047346,
0.820918262,
-0.5870101452,
-0.4537888467,
-0.1007016972,
-0.1441499293,
0.0190646518,
-0.1552646458,
0.2592068315,
-0.5001846552,
-0.715580225,
0.671425283,
0.4094745815,
0.1412207186,
-0.1098114774,
-0.0017814161,
-0.239513129,
-0.0738389716,
0.8869430423,
0.4526702762,
-0.4994080961,
-0.081638813,
-0.0295576174,
0.0258090701,
0.1887796074,
1.0281875134,
-0.2377741635,
0.7118117213,
0.3598603904,
0.732565701,
0.6648498178,
0.0048800861,
0.5967974663,
-1.0920327902,
0.1706794202,
0.0880298689,
0.1889113039,
0.3342682719,
0.2547776997,
0.3662239611,
0.1012079045,
-0.6235643029,
-0.6095437407,
0.5197430253,
-1.1381934881,
-0.0660758689,
1.0174248219,
-0.1817526072,
0.0185979363,
0.0759095773,
-0.3476265073,
0.2498523444,
-0.4675019383,
0.64462924,
0.3528580368,
-0.1580502987,
-0.6957962513,
-0.5455546975,
0.3791242838,
0.4350913465,
-0.7374103069,
-0.1243728027,
0.4139056504,
0.2141252011,
0.1065477952,
0.8883895874,
-0.3072963357,
0.3874389529,
-0.1606104225,
0.5033950806,
-0.1769087166,
-0.3924869001,
-0.5116675496,
-0.0005181532,
-0.1965907365,
-0.2306046337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12222v1
|
CovRL: Fuzzing JavaScript Engines with Coverage-Guided Reinforcement Learning for LLM-based Mutation
| 2024-02-19T15:30:40 | 2024-02-19T15:30:40 |
Jueon Eom, Seyeon Jeong, Taekyoung Kwon
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE, D.4.6; I.2.5; D.2.4
|
Fuzzing is an effective bug-finding technique but it struggles with complex
systems like JavaScript engines that demand precise grammatical input.
Recently, researchers have adopted language models for context-aware mutation
in fuzzing to address this problem. However, existing techniques are limited in
utilizing coverage guidance for fuzzing, which is rather performed in a
black-box manner. This paper presents a novel technique called CovRL
(Coverage-guided Reinforcement Learning) that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs) with reinforcement learning from coverage feedback. Our fuzzer,
CovRL-Fuzz, integrates coverage feedback directly into the LLM by leveraging
the Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (TF-IDF) method to construct a
weighted coverage map. This map is key in calculating the fuzzing reward, which
is then applied to the LLM-based mutator through reinforcement learning.
CovRL-Fuzz, through this approach, enables the generation of test cases that
are more likely to discover new coverage areas, thus improving vulnerability
detection while minimizing syntax and semantic errors, all without needing
extra post-processing. Our evaluation results indicate that CovRL-Fuzz
outperforms the state-of-the-art fuzzers in terms of code coverage and
bug-finding capabilities: CovRL-Fuzz identified 48 real-world security-related
bugs in the latest JavaScript engines, including 39 previously unknown
vulnerabilities and 11 CVEs.
|
[
-0.4494948685,
-1.0681275129,
0.1458187401,
0.3524001241,
0.1664643288,
0.4874735177,
-0.0914831832,
-0.0053346236,
0.2155474871,
0.4838148057,
-0.8916718364,
-0.7651404738,
-0.2169057876,
-0.2431655675,
-0.5386247039,
1.0412734747,
-0.0013023206,
-0.3014823794,
-0.3519242108,
0.2330883145,
-0.3814640939,
-0.5018755794,
-0.3621725738,
-0.1764642,
0.5360227823,
0.6279294491,
0.4892826378,
-0.0093415175,
0.5704002976,
0.2668529153,
0.0190857574,
0.2608095706,
-0.6886198521,
0.007746804,
0.0737540945,
-0.5323804617,
-0.1055207327,
-0.4937803149,
0.1876857132,
0.2829351425,
-0.4661793709,
-0.0932856053,
-0.4898846447,
0.3505446017,
-0.7890805006,
-0.0277906172,
-0.634473443,
0.1426440775,
-0.0131099699,
-0.3974584937,
-0.8674250245,
-0.1432637423,
-0.2490669489,
-0.6807539463,
0.3268651962,
0.3532849252,
0.6451137662,
0.4713954329,
-0.4149611294,
-0.070409663,
-0.7132861614,
0.6655093431,
-0.3803570271,
0.2687377334,
0.3051086664,
0.4549940228,
-0.8164271712,
-0.495148927,
-0.5358926058,
-0.4247944355,
0.1339798272,
0.1787665635,
-0.209112972,
0.025733741,
0.2568482161,
0.235065788,
-0.7729845047,
0.0372270942,
-0.2342941314,
-0.541482687,
0.7983540893,
-0.0263785087,
0.3445813358,
0.2303511947,
-0.5888119936,
-0.1576795131,
-0.6729308367,
0.3022892475,
0.3892923594,
-0.1713997573,
-0.0051629683,
0.2107426375,
-0.278804034,
0.8716967702,
-0.0556100868,
0.0861549526,
0.2028495371,
-0.0996755213,
-0.3425507843,
-0.12121436,
0.4862808287,
-0.1005906612,
0.0581235103,
-0.3880595267,
-0.2770238221,
-0.0441864617,
0.5228256583,
-0.4952609241,
-0.3026503623,
0.2556349337,
0.2862736881,
-0.5778272152,
0.2663852572,
-0.7657142878,
-0.2644583583,
0.3223470747,
0.4804403186,
-0.3491694331,
-0.2802473605,
0.3139919043,
-0.564804852,
0.2565532625,
0.2669617534,
-0.7557752728,
0.226928845,
0.6779810786,
0.6480462551,
-0.1805745512,
-0.1802576929,
-0.9431749582,
0.2289985865,
-0.2162804753,
0.7925786972,
-0.3595367074,
-0.5219751,
0.0650528297,
-0.1346374899,
0.0909161717,
-0.4005976617,
-0.0895030424,
-0.720020175,
0.1111060232,
0.0122412387,
-0.4546942115,
-0.1111511067,
0.551687479,
-0.7213824391,
1.10949862,
0.3182209134,
-0.4652344584,
0.0804969072,
-0.6299168468,
-0.5754169226,
0.1531926543,
-0.027459763,
-0.9725682735,
-0.0944344178,
0.2023718506,
0.253136754,
0.0506492294,
0.1089192629,
-0.6186752319,
-0.7281339765,
0.5040367842,
-0.1774009466,
0.5347214937,
-0.1073650569,
-0.5028945804,
0.5361867547,
-0.4728034735,
0.0727469623,
0.0644764751,
-0.1104431599,
-0.1323176324,
-0.0873382837,
0.0646997616,
0.1147000119,
-0.1940556765,
-0.4714920521,
0.3274616301,
-0.6586027741,
0.143857196,
0.5589842796,
0.3817682266,
0.2867739499,
-0.6262974739,
0.8520148993,
-0.2119663358,
0.2991193533,
-0.3442194462,
-0.1831947118,
-0.8828864098,
-0.5167680383,
0.0507425964,
0.4923054874,
-0.8810249567,
0.3602567017,
-0.1743896008,
-0.7015447021,
-0.3251772821,
0.0088806236,
0.580757618,
0.1483471692,
0.4792725444,
-0.112186186,
-0.3644399941,
-0.5747852921,
-0.1382505894,
-0.0607150383,
0.2133109719,
0.293661505,
0.6949620247,
-0.1870830357,
0.7708683014,
-0.6431078315,
-0.2245207429,
-0.2417038828,
0.0685793683,
-0.2668815851,
0.198194623,
0.4198877811,
-0.7464921474,
-0.231876865,
0.05613726,
-0.09967345,
-0.1533184797,
-0.0792489201,
-0.0638463274,
0.3939617276,
0.6762487888,
0.012901091,
0.5102790594,
0.8011134863,
-0.4946826994,
0.4826473594,
-0.1169390529,
0.1338168681,
-0.728047967,
-0.0696613044,
-0.3484100401,
-0.7229155302,
-0.3719453216,
0.5310975909,
0.0429330058,
0.101229541,
-0.6491931081,
0.5403732061,
-0.2448983788,
0.0670541823,
-0.1070535183,
-0.2341100872,
0.1052979827,
0.7555553317,
-0.4454666376,
0.8512917161,
0.2042636424,
-0.4818085134,
0.7597728968,
-0.1705242693,
-0.190567866,
0.2471732348,
-0.3597053885,
0.2215890735,
0.204704985,
0.4556520283,
-0.9625867009,
-0.2485973388,
0.150603205,
-0.3292778134,
0.1214202046,
-0.2116599828,
-0.5301878452,
-0.4706159532,
-0.317176342,
0.1602675617,
0.671243012,
-0.6011413932,
0.118476823,
0.349761337,
0.1332535297,
-0.4693734348,
-0.6001201868,
-0.3103891909,
-0.0540015064,
-0.7650634646,
0.4628888369,
-0.3404553831,
-0.0477378704,
-0.1501561105,
-0.2462726682,
-0.2782023847,
0.6213282943,
0.3916183412,
-0.0672088191,
0.0292836111,
0.3004644811,
0.0696201473,
-0.022360811,
0.0418394059,
-0.2911682129,
0.8320448399,
-0.384290576,
-0.8297752142,
-0.0194587484,
0.1642998308,
0.4209812284,
-0.5448619127,
0.2723161578,
0.6887198687,
-0.1118687987,
-0.8422465324,
-0.4245828688,
-0.0485514775,
-0.4609828889,
0.3823250234,
-0.2022053003,
-1.0504280329,
0.4513982236,
-0.198284477,
-0.2810596228,
0.3888254464,
0.6446070075,
-0.1946845055,
0.6311232448,
0.6103728414,
0.0087803137,
0.6885355115,
-0.5902220011,
-0.125511989,
-0.2944251299,
-0.4821992218,
-0.2769376636,
-0.311152935,
-0.2386746407,
-0.575955987,
0.4760433137,
-0.1388415545,
0.0556503832,
0.103682451,
-0.2667354047,
0.6500435472,
0.5084199905,
0.2101798803,
0.2546828091,
0.0297159851,
-0.4491072297,
0.4038666189,
-0.5810291171,
0.3113127649,
0.7414664626,
0.1063297614,
0.869720459,
0.3004426956,
0.9344059229,
0.4908755124,
0.3228017986,
-0.6575317383,
0.3233469129,
0.238712728,
-0.590343833,
-0.4496514499,
-0.29383564,
-0.9575878978,
0.2495247126,
-0.032693401,
-0.3509633541,
-0.2453464717,
0.3577998281,
-0.3338211179,
0.2185927331,
-0.6573488712,
0.8779116273,
-0.2031285614,
-0.4601063132,
-0.4777824581,
-0.333185792,
0.3583771586,
0.0745794773,
0.2588593364,
0.0387023576,
0.0968226269,
0.2582377195,
-0.6739127636,
0.5723297,
-0.2476784736,
-0.1312023699,
0.172755301,
0.273579061,
0.6094431877,
0.3559905291,
0.0122661684,
-0.1874506921,
0.1581491679,
-0.5662547946,
-0.8354733586,
0.5663563609,
-0.3835273683,
-0.5910764337,
-0.7282875776,
-0.6066438556,
-0.0844904929,
0.1979074329,
0.0001595984,
0.2795646191,
-0.5092760324,
0.3006308675,
0.8400793076,
-0.3194285631,
0.4151921272,
0.850043416,
-0.6661115885,
-0.1899391711,
0.8659248948,
-0.1848696321,
0.3833932281,
0.638030529,
-0.0061048251,
0.2451144308,
-0.5602688789,
-0.4018194973,
-0.2442842722,
-0.2689093053,
-0.391481936,
-0.4493042827,
-0.3523307145,
-0.0438839979,
-0.3726726472,
-0.2106160074,
-0.0133195613,
0.1185137182,
0.0106759164,
0.6472295523,
0.3887062669,
0.447663188,
0.4824038446,
-0.3522597551,
0.2399827689,
-0.0110982023,
0.3998114467,
-0.4262362421,
-0.2696056664,
-0.3312574327,
0.1416146606,
-0.4234021604,
-0.9022248983,
0.61847651,
-0.1423708349,
0.356937021,
-0.2427266836,
0.1137656942,
0.7094690204,
-0.2281336635,
0.5333670974,
-0.056454476,
-0.8302167654,
0.4981556535,
-0.3590785265,
0.4615766704,
0.3595057428,
-0.1266421676,
-0.7092055082,
-0.8104944825,
-0.7677201629,
-0.8263840675,
0.4469191432,
0.0488688983,
0.0043073432,
0.0769115761,
0.1463914812,
0.0912520811,
0.1750838608,
-0.5351461768,
-0.0871517062,
-0.0065522348,
-0.234709993,
-0.0611597858,
-0.0284283832,
-0.1038716659,
-0.2600109875,
0.7537469864,
-0.1967627853,
0.3627051711,
0.2526725829,
-0.6165218949,
-0.0962646753,
0.5008684993,
0.7947276831,
0.1017229781,
-0.4224272966,
0.0864471123,
0.3329789042,
-0.2794550359,
0.185876891,
-0.0066155968,
-0.275464654,
-0.080946207,
0.2883991599,
0.8288457394,
0.4729851484,
-0.8551278114,
0.9234400392,
-0.2056038529,
-0.1831768602,
-0.6165178418,
0.7463569045,
-0.010432981,
0.1041753665,
0.1182559207,
0.1372478455,
0.1234444976,
-0.3143516183,
0.5289676785,
0.6378787756,
-0.6142497659,
-0.1579712033,
0.2636114061,
0.2963171899,
-0.3620762229,
0.5087282062,
-0.5302987099,
-0.5486341119,
1.0291939974,
0.6680404544,
0.7320914268,
-0.0952074006,
0.3150518537,
-0.1181010157,
0.39954561,
0.0691945031,
0.45725137,
-0.0314769708,
-0.3240411878,
-0.364907831,
-0.4019398689,
-0.5064796209,
0.0412197821,
-0.4590872228,
0.5692599416,
-0.4812591076,
0.320320189,
-0.0952577963,
0.0128854439,
-0.7667425871,
0.0903957635,
-0.0832841918,
1.0452263355,
-0.5747197866,
0.8999364376,
0.3636615872,
-0.4224222302,
-0.6127146482,
0.2053010315,
0.1282439083,
-0.7054906487,
0.1687286496,
0.2954229414,
-0.2408543825,
0.4039113522,
-0.411129415,
-0.8533864617,
1.2337092161,
0.5176805854,
-0.6242008209,
0.2290676236,
-0.199962005,
0.6028796434,
-0.1102161407,
0.4772906005,
0.0682862848,
0.368514061,
0.2192519456,
-0.5567803383,
-0.1226762831,
-0.2360385805,
-0.3289324045,
0.4191444814,
-0.8071122169,
0.1241488308,
-0.3765433133,
0.0688211992,
-0.08887624,
0.4113529921,
0.0618600138,
0.5339921117,
0.4812896252,
0.532556057,
0.8053161502,
-0.1755239964,
1.5075268745,
0.0460126065,
0.4602119625,
0.9197962284,
-0.0618418865,
0.8646748066,
0.3060579896,
-0.0154872425,
0.8810095787,
0.3415546119,
-0.3425698578,
0.5299728513,
0.7142907381,
-0.2430611998,
-0.1730410308,
0.0224621966,
-0.1832158417,
0.3942992687,
0.2697580457,
0.0604972132,
0.0151153756,
0.1243244708,
0.0880988464,
-0.029737087,
-0.1802237779,
0.8202985525,
-0.2698529065,
-0.7763607502,
0.6227250099,
0.2162435353,
0.6260009408,
-0.6578211188,
0.1025334597,
-0.2794417143,
0.1675389111,
-0.2266333103,
-0.4990900755,
0.5530068874,
-0.1946412623,
-0.2035413682,
-0.2557706237,
0.7004381418,
-0.5109013915,
-0.309422195,
0.4041596353,
-0.0071143913,
-0.2028278261,
-0.195143193,
-0.2045895904,
0.2227476686,
-0.0047896565,
-0.3103168905,
0.1333218068,
-0.0403689854,
-0.1877255589,
0.8400119543,
0.7788373232,
-0.0727246553,
0.2639822364,
0.04836943,
0.7877869606,
-0.6661015749,
-0.574555099,
-0.8964024186,
0.594266355,
-0.0619512834,
0.1111909151,
0.6903948188,
0.6152719855,
1.0788267851,
-0.1588809341,
0.8578165174,
0.1089419127,
0.0777936876,
-0.5386506319,
0.668540895,
-0.4741952121,
0.2236330956,
0.001984268,
-0.2778608501,
-0.6685678959,
0.301899761,
-0.3246965408,
0.0010616875,
0.6645356417,
1.2079684734,
-0.0678391531,
-0.368378818,
0.422675252,
0.2640421987,
0.635417223,
0.8119282722,
0.7137515545,
-0.300418973,
0.6427998543,
-0.1041087434,
-0.1995978951,
-0.6975250244,
-0.6611099839,
-0.8850558996,
-0.3443660438,
-0.2104090005,
-0.5460666418,
0.3714199364,
0.807529211,
0.7680194974,
-0.7000206113,
0.0777446702,
-0.3596185744,
0.5480962992,
-0.4023441374,
-0.2038268298,
-0.1218106449,
-0.4444993436,
-0.3885245621,
0.5508166552,
0.6378238797,
-0.1737338752,
-0.4634721577,
-0.3255998492,
-0.075009495,
0.1920718253,
0.1961103082,
0.391621381,
-0.7274596691,
-0.2495703697,
0.0841136351,
-0.2216862142,
-0.1725307405,
0.7512363195,
-0.9297901392,
0.7012432814,
0.4788823128,
0.7142333984,
0.7593874335,
-0.3593787551,
0.5840157866,
-1.1328778267,
0.2379338741,
0.0791216642,
0.067606844,
0.101766713,
-0.4430582523,
0.2582282424,
0.3583427668,
-0.3424891829,
-0.9162237644,
0.5703796148,
-1.0175459385,
-0.2000969797,
1.3096358776,
0.0156615954,
-0.3779358566,
-0.0666607022,
-0.3605620265,
0.2366279066,
-0.3289443552,
0.8135178089,
0.6337739229,
0.2122431695,
-0.16105555,
-0.1765349954,
0.5962181687,
0.4106950164,
-1.0577667952,
-0.3006781936,
0.2674359977,
0.474720329,
-0.0799664184,
0.4137448967,
0.0285979528,
0.6694624424,
-0.1737727374,
0.3707612157,
-0.5766370893,
-0.3711619377,
-0.4594106674,
0.2064426094,
0.0046799006,
0.0421604477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12219v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12219v2
|
Reformatted Alignment
| 2024-02-19T15:21:58 | 2024-04-17T15:03:19 |
Run-Ze Fan, Xuefeng Li, Haoyang Zou, Junlong Li, Shwai He, Ethan Chern, Jiewen Hu, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The quality of finetuning data is crucial for aligning large language models
(LLMs) with human values. Current methods to improve data quality are either
labor-intensive or prone to factual errors caused by LLM hallucinations. This
paper explores elevating the quality of existing instruction data to better
align with human values, introducing a simple and effective approach named
ReAlign, which reformats the responses of instruction data into a format that
better aligns with pre-established criteria and the collated evidence. This
approach minimizes human annotation, hallucination, and the difficulty in
scaling, remaining orthogonal to existing alignment techniques. Experimentally,
ReAlign significantly boosts the general alignment ability, math reasoning,
factuality, and readability of the LLMs.
Encouragingly, without introducing any additional data or advanced training
techniques, and merely by reformatting the response, LLaMA-2-13B's mathematical
reasoning ability on GSM8K can be improved from 46.77% to 56.63% in accuracy.
Additionally, a mere 5% of ReAlign data yields a 67% boost in general alignment
ability measured by the Alpaca dataset. This work highlights the need for
further research into the science and mechanistic interpretability of LLMs. We
have made the associated code and data publicly accessible to support future
studies at https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/ReAlign.
|
[
-0.2130917907,
-0.65093714,
0.3593592346,
-0.0628889054,
-0.1830821186,
0.1793973744,
-0.3192487955,
-0.5966257453,
0.2758933604,
0.3167020082,
-0.5568099618,
-0.4601111412,
-0.4416517019,
-0.0815639198,
-0.2309632897,
0.7985015512,
-0.1142826453,
0.0787262619,
-0.1691648811,
-0.2953206897,
-0.5750164986,
-0.4047939181,
-0.3767187893,
-0.4066178799,
0.4638786316,
0.7510294318,
1.2057336569,
1.1954805851,
0.6856589913,
0.232967332,
0.1235427335,
0.4972465932,
-0.7028380036,
-0.037492685,
-0.1300125867,
-0.6188687086,
-0.5383292437,
0.2294106483,
0.5712994933,
0.6125882864,
-0.5189521313,
0.3524573743,
0.0018435247,
0.7943871021,
-0.3656579554,
0.072175473,
-0.529500246,
-0.1478919536,
-0.1175918952,
-0.0936513171,
-0.3963153958,
-0.8088776469,
-0.1849248856,
-0.8468775153,
0.0360970497,
0.2336455584,
1.4334920645,
0.5500944257,
-0.0419963636,
-0.4305545986,
-0.7479444742,
0.9060101509,
-0.8340963721,
0.6334204078,
0.3381594419,
0.5079482198,
-0.4319753945,
-0.5122147799,
-0.8098526001,
-0.0717512146,
-0.1113027856,
0.1639000624,
0.1708120406,
-0.2213460356,
0.0047935043,
0.4265687168,
-0.6173940897,
0.3959674835,
-0.5519971251,
-0.2889932394,
0.6639479399,
0.31440714,
0.457439065,
0.2731960416,
-0.2159425616,
-0.451710701,
-0.9679322243,
0.1551234275,
0.7319996357,
0.3552487493,
-0.039030876,
0.6716826558,
-0.0970944986,
0.7921899557,
0.1671134382,
-0.5239086747,
0.1343200803,
-0.348444432,
-0.2687234879,
0.4203572571,
0.5290395021,
0.4553729296,
0.1795944273,
-0.1221530139,
-0.2768477499,
0.0261558704,
0.6250258684,
-0.8343505859,
-0.0663879663,
0.228869319,
-0.4658343494,
-0.2557471097,
0.2929460406,
-0.6504775286,
-0.1341313422,
-1.0135543346,
0.4033662975,
-0.3118209839,
-0.039831046,
0.3568670154,
0.5054603219,
0.5885777473,
0.3580633104,
-1.1513279676,
0.3272503912,
1.1738052368,
0.6637963653,
0.1191094443,
-0.2783053219,
-0.3154271841,
-0.0393221267,
-0.7012277842,
0.6945047975,
-0.47779724,
0.0566379726,
-0.1138105243,
0.091729179,
0.0315381549,
-0.7327362895,
0.7538036108,
-0.5670973063,
0.4362963438,
-0.3638664484,
-0.479804188,
-0.133515805,
0.2589768171,
-0.6747384071,
0.9118416309,
0.1425705403,
-0.3942943215,
0.1038308367,
-0.25388816,
-0.2218239903,
-0.4196392298,
-0.2881217301,
-0.7726961374,
0.0603528209,
0.1962880045,
0.2457474023,
-0.2069490254,
0.5110786557,
-0.0296354033,
-0.6446878314,
0.4844834507,
-0.473688513,
0.6180141568,
0.3410296738,
-0.1761273146,
0.0709359124,
-0.8704036474,
0.1000181735,
0.1820193529,
-0.3921483159,
0.039629709,
-0.022893073,
-0.5231413841,
0.1400321424,
0.176504001,
-0.4012975395,
0.4991752505,
-0.6066805124,
0.1836735457,
0.7497327328,
-0.452991128,
0.6701762676,
-0.4571388662,
0.4619581103,
-0.1887944788,
0.1836133003,
0.0958806723,
-0.3615329266,
-0.8006218672,
-0.2659332156,
0.4833361804,
0.634326458,
-0.3393204808,
0.6139756441,
-0.5274192095,
-0.5275599957,
-1.2604165077,
0.165118441,
0.4619208872,
0.7563525438,
0.5230403543,
-0.1952181458,
-0.5401834249,
-0.9304808378,
0.0720740631,
-0.0299228802,
-0.2069952935,
-0.0827670842,
0.0707020536,
-0.4428853989,
0.7886065841,
-0.6426038742,
-0.2029332966,
0.0551766604,
0.0932801217,
0.1346378624,
0.5734300017,
0.2194218487,
-0.2951521277,
-0.0247166194,
-0.0012072432,
-0.6038756371,
-0.2614123225,
-0.3557949364,
-0.6000061631,
-0.0538461879,
0.3077249229,
-0.4223919809,
0.1918422729,
0.5203973651,
-0.1531725675,
0.6997935176,
-0.0550910644,
0.2630657256,
-0.9585411549,
-0.1858732551,
-0.1784338504,
-0.0119948369,
-0.5596658587,
-0.0397334658,
0.2128287554,
0.04191548,
-0.180973947,
0.3180582821,
-0.4655655026,
-0.1282595098,
-0.279368937,
0.1401943266,
0.1833917946,
0.2340929657,
-0.2216199189,
1.1764066219,
-0.0725090131,
-0.3461302817,
0.3739651442,
0.354629457,
-0.4869198501,
0.4415439963,
-0.4790480137,
0.0082823224,
-0.2112298012,
0.1414472461,
-0.9637513161,
-0.4867977798,
0.3704399765,
-0.3593038321,
0.5159989595,
0.1689713597,
-0.185287267,
-0.0194608085,
-0.3714154959,
0.3623357713,
0.4964646399,
-0.8025811315,
0.4005727172,
0.2355332971,
-0.1068137363,
-0.7297248244,
-0.5136577487,
0.1598163247,
-0.2352727503,
-0.7040367723,
0.4727809727,
0.1696950495,
-0.236270979,
-0.1789237857,
-0.3117852807,
0.0584733263,
0.0354330428,
0.0828088149,
0.4633715451,
-0.5351129174,
0.0777926221,
0.0867818594,
-0.3987446725,
-0.0534544624,
0.0159329195,
0.5372689366,
-0.0765697286,
-0.4142564535,
-0.9428189993,
-0.1251398474,
0.4422904551,
-0.1898059547,
0.8333440423,
0.4269819558,
-0.4257494509,
0.0944540501,
-0.5312922001,
-0.2987797558,
-0.4666993618,
0.1563896239,
-0.2580911219,
-0.5764935613,
0.473018378,
-0.0207299758,
0.2890002728,
0.1369906515,
0.3519812524,
-0.245119527,
0.906568408,
0.481186837,
0.0714398548,
0.3478043377,
-0.0797981694,
0.622354269,
-0.8709659576,
-0.4798066318,
-0.6186312437,
-0.6000163555,
-0.3450028896,
-0.3363032639,
-0.2418525666,
0.263127178,
-0.3367552757,
0.4711348414,
-0.8103669882,
0.5857159495,
0.325235039,
0.2192654461,
0.211506024,
0.1160334498,
0.2593611777,
-0.3165650666,
-0.317882061,
-1.2575085163,
0.9728168845,
0.5830993652,
1.1076221466,
0.3047247529,
0.6256545782,
-0.1468598247,
0.4897427261,
-0.8623030782,
0.3613364995,
0.0280095171,
-0.1496536583,
-0.3305036426,
-0.2994296849,
-0.8751554489,
0.1826003045,
-0.2712832391,
-0.5007801056,
0.1299927384,
0.2378802299,
-0.602848649,
0.0476354174,
-0.8893485665,
0.6976792216,
-0.5085945725,
-0.2754509151,
0.0102250492,
-0.6370797753,
0.464936018,
-0.111878939,
0.3061730564,
-0.2220327705,
0.0011163469,
0.9213773608,
-0.5027164817,
0.7644303441,
0.1441685557,
-0.6295966506,
0.2378330976,
0.0379527956,
0.5241523981,
-0.1093282029,
-0.08914534,
-0.0482105799,
0.0039011112,
-0.4345536828,
-0.8460236788,
0.8144713044,
-0.93272686,
-0.7056754827,
-0.1212772876,
-0.6207184792,
-0.1380185634,
-0.1507167816,
-0.1163691431,
0.3997072279,
0.0246650781,
0.0108472873,
0.7366823554,
-0.0507500023,
-0.0606994964,
0.2239572406,
-0.0163920689,
-0.5594792962,
1.2792842388,
0.4087364376,
0.413714081,
0.2122915536,
0.1864530444,
-0.3805435598,
-0.3247790933,
-0.7169702053,
0.3284322619,
-0.6357765794,
-0.4156808853,
-0.2564327717,
-0.088855058,
-0.3461498916,
-0.3573662341,
-0.5236212015,
-0.6387338638,
-0.5594426394,
-0.3137453198,
0.0915753841,
0.500551939,
0.1852521151,
0.6394870281,
-0.6245113611,
0.4098877609,
0.3106585741,
0.3257377148,
-0.0297944266,
-0.9116481543,
-0.172458604,
0.4084815085,
-0.3901240826,
-0.6617234349,
0.2329405248,
0.0990446284,
0.4174333811,
0.6527029872,
-0.1849722266,
1.1735355854,
-0.3923984766,
0.5369380713,
0.090997532,
-0.6887468696,
0.2017160356,
0.1422985941,
-0.0784835592,
0.6543795466,
0.2870742679,
-0.464104712,
-0.171234861,
-0.5155337453,
-0.5601511598,
0.5754979253,
0.060543824,
0.0986425579,
0.370596379,
0.6575123072,
0.2776802182,
-0.1027300507,
-0.2064986378,
0.0393989831,
-0.4059405029,
-0.9954378009,
0.2981612682,
-0.2958038747,
-0.3216854334,
-0.3288681209,
0.7608780861,
-0.1095935553,
0.1446811706,
-0.0779660568,
-0.0413674973,
-0.0902688503,
0.346334815,
1.007592082,
0.9577150345,
-0.048549518,
0.3699468076,
0.0997856781,
-0.6554166675,
0.4880467653,
-0.1548727304,
-0.2121116072,
-0.3418271244,
0.560329318,
0.511869669,
0.0646441281,
-0.6057226658,
0.2485425323,
-0.0186170582,
-0.0669673756,
0.1991932988,
0.3513163328,
0.1830648482,
0.034866713,
0.1749315411,
-0.223693341,
-0.2645020783,
-0.5250154734,
0.1134550571,
0.2375647426,
-0.2167193294,
-0.4417879283,
0.5700755715,
0.1308403462,
-0.4466026723,
0.7847566009,
-0.1703794301,
-0.3052018881,
0.7425082922,
0.8577032685,
0.2795061767,
-0.3194867373,
0.0279727262,
0.5370816588,
0.4279418886,
-0.4022806883,
0.1940454841,
0.2858246267,
-0.8447239995,
-0.6030169725,
-0.5925440192,
-0.4711174965,
0.0438136943,
-0.6889300942,
0.2642460763,
-0.460197866,
0.081890218,
-0.1646057963,
0.0921634957,
-0.2144031823,
0.4458918869,
0.0023145664,
0.5855078101,
-0.9657700658,
0.783108294,
0.5210112333,
-0.4096195102,
-1.0404559374,
-0.1077236906,
0.0245395973,
-1.1061347723,
0.3757583499,
0.2579888999,
-0.1762279272,
0.0324351229,
-0.7183594108,
-0.8962283134,
1.1452661753,
0.5661492348,
-0.9903747439,
0.1467128098,
0.2556439936,
0.5018420219,
-0.3346056044,
0.0793622583,
0.8889951706,
0.5373930931,
0.080368273,
-0.5335692167,
0.2175861597,
0.110479407,
-0.0985711515,
0.3459738791,
-0.554368794,
0.2804916501,
-0.348647356,
-0.4481929541,
0.0146355359,
0.9862034321,
0.3203622997,
0.1587171406,
0.1032368317,
0.884819746,
1.2152415514,
-0.389118284,
0.4965522885,
-0.151583299,
0.1115993857,
1.1478034258,
-0.1908506453,
0.7976583838,
0.6098976731,
-0.270350039,
0.4007641077,
0.6935369372,
0.0648748428,
0.3324651122,
0.3380697668,
-0.1390656531,
-0.1959465593,
-0.0098370658,
-0.2179151922,
0.3834607899,
0.3309513032,
0.1440431923,
-0.0594981462,
-0.1719787568,
0.2922457457,
0.528473556,
0.0261447802,
0.7388296127,
-0.0979274511,
-0.6014214158,
0.8808215261,
0.0504473373,
0.6832967401,
-0.2894665301,
-0.2434317023,
-0.4223285317,
0.095124498,
-0.6177104712,
-0.9217839837,
0.5614667535,
-0.0930834934,
-0.1818676889,
-0.0886785239,
0.3405759335,
-0.6092544198,
-0.4000725448,
-0.2530399859,
-0.0148102855,
0.2258529216,
0.3859090805,
-0.6097215414,
0.468683362,
0.0940811113,
-0.0170059726,
0.3083597422,
0.2389335632,
-0.2710199356,
0.7048785686,
0.7768969536,
0.0698872283,
0.0402411781,
0.1210583374,
0.7648438811,
-0.7143010497,
0.0425206497,
-0.8873894215,
0.362554878,
0.0172899812,
-0.2769468129,
0.3330043852,
0.6694551706,
0.9224491119,
0.1362601221,
0.2080031335,
0.3505126536,
0.3429688513,
-0.7157273293,
0.6206178665,
-0.2136570215,
0.3013132513,
0.2272800207,
-0.7943427563,
-0.4251494408,
0.8311268687,
-0.3301542401,
-0.4156092405,
0.4306731224,
1.2306394577,
-0.273848027,
-0.0749230459,
0.1138057485,
-0.0667166933,
0.5626937747,
0.2132133842,
0.7922541499,
-0.6754606962,
0.4983396828,
-0.2954785526,
-0.2734820545,
-0.2227791846,
-0.6423094869,
-0.4213508964,
-0.2874494791,
-0.3328291178,
-0.3668446243,
0.042616684,
1.0844876766,
0.3717597425,
-0.8234521747,
-0.1520626396,
0.1505769789,
0.2383709699,
-0.3473026454,
-0.1823163033,
0.5949417949,
-0.4155201614,
-0.6312235594,
0.3853774965,
0.2260797322,
0.3491772115,
-0.0608018488,
-0.3301514685,
0.0176845491,
0.2349943221,
0.4237200916,
0.3856165409,
-0.8427760601,
-0.4180907011,
0.0866729617,
-0.5077064037,
0.3483842015,
0.4276558459,
-0.4419263601,
0.2761950195,
0.4337957203,
0.9365139008,
-0.1407304555,
0.627010107,
0.4746308923,
-0.3509593308,
0.0809715018,
0.0230179019,
0.169702962,
0.5113835931,
-0.4734468162,
0.5094323754,
-0.1546103209,
-0.7093108892,
-0.8777144551,
0.0824454948,
-0.9702236056,
-0.0252528135,
0.7818909287,
0.0875657573,
-0.4235998094,
0.0304806512,
-0.7002648711,
0.4244674146,
-0.2556706369,
1.230338335,
0.6614313722,
-0.1165002584,
0.0755778402,
-0.4722560048,
0.3688657582,
0.484787643,
-1.0741651058,
0.1557143778,
0.504632473,
0.1227342486,
0.13654989,
0.2046801299,
-0.248874262,
0.147999391,
-0.3065935373,
0.2295362353,
-0.1450838298,
-0.3776637912,
-0.266268909,
-0.0783106014,
0.2055618316,
-0.3144885898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12212v1
|
Polarization of Autonomous Generative AI Agents Under Echo Chambers
| 2024-02-19T15:14:15 | 2024-02-19T15:14:15 |
Masaya Ohagi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Online social networks often create echo chambers where people only hear
opinions reinforcing their beliefs. An echo chamber often generates
polarization, leading to conflicts caused by people with radical opinions, such
as the January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol. The echo chamber has been
viewed as a human-specific problem, but this implicit assumption is becoming
less reasonable as large language models, such as ChatGPT, acquire social
abilities. In response to this situation, we investigated the potential for
polarization to occur among a group of autonomous AI agents based on generative
language models in an echo chamber environment. We had AI agents discuss
specific topics and analyzed how the group's opinions changed as the discussion
progressed. As a result, we found that the group of agents based on ChatGPT
tended to become polarized in echo chamber environments. The analysis of
opinion transitions shows that this result is caused by ChatGPT's high prompt
understanding ability to update its opinion by considering its own and
surrounding agents' opinions. We conducted additional experiments to
investigate under what specific conditions AI agents tended to polarize. As a
result, we identified factors that strongly influence polarization, such as the
agent's persona. These factors should be monitored to prevent the polarization
of AI agents.
|
[
-0.7261353731,
-0.9118422866,
0.6398528218,
-0.0166290291,
-0.2031082958,
0.3580676317,
-0.1573423445,
-0.23562558,
0.1663300544,
0.4221229553,
-0.4524444044,
-0.2960075736,
-0.6697231531,
0.0378225259,
-0.4433552325,
1.326056838,
0.4188904762,
0.125069201,
-0.0048020738,
-0.2474011928,
-0.3395637274,
-0.9000752568,
-0.9930846095,
-0.4482380748,
0.4878585637,
0.0452020988,
1.0204503536,
0.2687880099,
0.5267915726,
0.3845712841,
-0.0412102118,
-0.4041636586,
-0.3381659687,
0.0682776943,
0.0082408581,
-0.6219455004,
-0.5540453792,
0.1462379992,
0.432192266,
0.3257339597,
-0.2405952364,
-0.1883684993,
0.2089658678,
0.6819884777,
0.0788720995,
0.5210084319,
-0.6272509098,
-0.002916571,
0.0159586966,
-0.2493589073,
-0.353823036,
-0.3293109238,
0.0947119445,
-0.4442421496,
0.6157382727,
-0.1277228892,
0.6248136759,
0.483956337,
-0.4060513377,
-0.2116261125,
-0.9398189783,
0.5187772512,
-0.5331420898,
0.0358055532,
0.2286130637,
0.1819898039,
-0.1248971298,
-0.2908505201,
-0.7262280583,
-0.2212573886,
0.1668654382,
0.3107385337,
-0.6666595936,
0.3284021318,
0.0719731078,
0.0902025476,
-0.5071434379,
-0.1925455332,
-0.2553370595,
0.0927569419,
0.7076129317,
0.1312963963,
0.5840992332,
-0.2275678366,
-0.322396636,
-0.4043881297,
-0.4119158983,
0.1224998534,
0.6226274967,
0.2326280475,
-0.1891388148,
0.5647823215,
-0.0757056698,
0.2356273681,
0.5108578205,
0.4921503067,
0.1425496936,
-0.2551302612,
-0.1171225905,
0.1034559309,
1.0155524015,
0.3959966004,
0.2634247839,
0.0041762837,
-0.1893153191,
0.0775129125,
0.5875601172,
-0.6277855039,
-0.0972994938,
0.5382584333,
-0.5960692763,
-0.5847834349,
0.2001612633,
-0.7942520976,
-0.9495908618,
-0.2503940761,
0.3242352605,
-0.0810503215,
-0.4380064309,
-0.2788458765,
-0.3352562487,
0.4448706806,
0.2594181597,
-0.5505094528,
0.1793806702,
0.8522575498,
0.8241476417,
0.026313426,
-0.3603899479,
-0.2665853798,
-0.2881835401,
-0.2745665312,
1.0356853008,
-0.3201171458,
-0.4471516609,
-0.0917773172,
-0.0938975811,
-0.0553090498,
-0.5470771194,
0.0932964385,
-0.7529876232,
0.2459920645,
-0.1869546473,
-0.2966725826,
-0.1333241463,
0.3042716682,
-0.3445602059,
0.1259367466,
-0.1306357533,
-0.7498476505,
0.2101376504,
-0.6022512913,
-0.3249187768,
0.19292292,
-0.572717309,
-0.5891929865,
0.0227119904,
0.2652582228,
0.4547001421,
-0.1079086736,
0.1788619608,
-0.205426082,
0.008973062,
0.5013279319,
-0.4794806838,
1.0366259813,
-0.0383615233,
-0.84520787,
0.6122162938,
-0.1509061456,
-0.1942437142,
0.2161142677,
-0.0133106355,
0.0901328847,
0.5036150813,
-0.1909163296,
-0.0770702362,
0.088275522,
-0.3882140517,
0.2086111307,
-0.3226515651,
0.3633326888,
1.151381731,
0.5198118687,
0.5152841806,
-0.6007421613,
0.7468383312,
0.1232768819,
0.5562360883,
0.2606124878,
-1.0772972107,
-0.9351560473,
-0.1126684248,
-0.5314588547,
0.5828818679,
-0.6846847534,
0.5508444309,
-0.0305330865,
-0.5254446268,
-0.6192334294,
-0.0669484809,
0.0097675221,
0.0930042416,
0.3452650011,
-0.1638941914,
-0.1020647809,
-0.8644556403,
-0.195312798,
-0.7020241618,
-0.0015719809,
0.4851361215,
0.0963470563,
-0.6014353633,
1.028490901,
-0.2243532985,
-0.4805614352,
-0.5424337983,
0.6582306623,
0.170711413,
0.2092462182,
0.3578689396,
-0.8402114511,
-0.7115128636,
0.2068633437,
-0.781750381,
-0.0188182965,
-0.3819817603,
0.0939184874,
0.2046039551,
0.3924104273,
-0.7109764218,
0.486988008,
0.559373796,
-0.2332744896,
0.3653341532,
0.0371291153,
0.2747220993,
-1.0581009388,
-0.3091986477,
-0.2376479656,
-0.0096663963,
-0.7653307319,
-0.1505525559,
-0.5338776708,
-0.2420310676,
-0.1700331122,
0.1201365739,
-0.2522629201,
0.1636975259,
-0.5515446663,
0.1762358248,
-0.1706653088,
0.3958202899,
0.0776051357,
0.7115551829,
0.6551003456,
-0.1176459044,
0.4871311486,
0.1876749247,
-0.139568612,
0.3239460289,
-0.7712045908,
0.4927970469,
-0.3965606689,
0.3965043128,
-0.8614408374,
-0.1982567608,
0.4565626383,
-0.6371529698,
-0.0890886709,
-0.2846022546,
-0.142512396,
0.1702459306,
-0.2555927932,
0.4109949172,
0.5718535185,
-0.3158542216,
0.8699592352,
0.4601354897,
-0.3728736341,
-0.3832653463,
-0.2924083173,
0.2726546228,
-0.2061280757,
-0.5482736826,
-0.1649123281,
-0.0555859543,
-0.7666629553,
0.1153431311,
0.5508230925,
0.1459939778,
0.0038389643,
0.4660232365,
0.1839670688,
-0.1983342767,
-0.0207040869,
-0.164198935,
-0.1195694804,
0.4510140121,
0.0210262407,
0.866925478,
-0.600071609,
-0.5563960075,
-0.7794182301,
0.5024831295,
1.045509696,
-0.2181917429,
1.0860383511,
0.4568594098,
-0.0297282413,
-0.230290845,
-0.5749756694,
-0.54162395,
-0.4647248685,
0.454475075,
0.1319051534,
-0.4671590328,
0.756793797,
0.4714324176,
0.0522733591,
0.3724084496,
0.960264504,
-0.2153712213,
1.4724639654,
0.3249011934,
-0.4471424818,
0.6915976405,
-0.2164397836,
0.461314857,
-0.7214840651,
-0.0852832124,
-0.4563119113,
-0.0586353503,
-0.838611424,
-0.3987779021,
0.5573078394,
-0.4538706839,
0.0413608029,
-0.0187154301,
-0.7041963935,
0.2572806776,
0.4016878605,
0.2040566951,
0.0369733013,
-0.0777206197,
0.5724669695,
0.4783414006,
-0.6321502328,
-0.4283992946,
1.1256779432,
0.3878654242,
0.5415409803,
0.2118770778,
0.625787735,
0.6550322771,
0.739487052,
-0.8804444075,
0.5097105503,
0.2670371532,
-0.5850256681,
-0.4656673968,
-0.3995979428,
-1.2245395184,
0.2340765148,
-0.1067719683,
-0.2867155671,
0.3245108128,
-0.0419534482,
-0.157937184,
0.200296253,
-0.6076734066,
0.6566705108,
-0.1526572704,
0.0683750361,
-0.6195628643,
-0.4641328454,
-0.1276073456,
0.0964707285,
0.1944915056,
-0.1635259092,
0.3786588013,
0.5847312808,
-0.322840929,
1.2433708906,
-0.3479805589,
0.1522253007,
0.6893190742,
-0.0760634467,
0.6040335298,
0.1010205001,
0.053627342,
0.443405658,
-0.4054801166,
-0.4424881339,
-0.5813316107,
0.43420735,
-1.4804319143,
-1.0011029243,
-0.6001057625,
-0.3368538916,
0.1436508149,
-0.0899531767,
0.5570796132,
0.2991531789,
-0.3643536866,
0.1803571433,
0.440749079,
-0.0928241238,
0.4002191722,
0.2837406099,
0.0374029987,
-0.480781883,
0.888394475,
0.1870672256,
0.4278662503,
-0.0809294358,
0.3567298353,
0.0746859685,
-0.4448345602,
-0.3612035811,
0.0732947141,
-0.5434954166,
-0.0525731482,
-0.6706483364,
-0.3410428762,
-0.5897205472,
-0.2486318052,
-0.3865696192,
0.0054398971,
-0.2671447396,
-0.0262494031,
0.0609354265,
1.0754048824,
0.1589887589,
0.3735672534,
-0.5112273097,
0.064280197,
0.6760097742,
-0.079885684,
0.0460965633,
-0.3963688612,
-0.0180706978,
0.043278344,
-0.3328087628,
-1.1771203279,
0.2449344844,
-0.1112313867,
0.5579957962,
0.8328142166,
0.2609991431,
-0.0050767004,
-0.1473481655,
0.8163080215,
-0.1103545055,
-0.665109694,
0.4940762222,
-0.7844333649,
0.3333445787,
0.2584650517,
0.1385290176,
-0.477008909,
-0.9558790922,
-0.9516124725,
-0.5824899077,
0.4825412631,
0.4641161561,
0.2855552137,
-0.1407586187,
0.1116101295,
-0.0514403433,
0.3552899063,
-0.91156739,
-0.1448077261,
-0.5198796988,
-0.1044621095,
-0.2128921449,
-0.0442968495,
-0.5089480877,
0.0068735247,
0.5512152314,
-0.0875381082,
0.5110436678,
0.1921177506,
0.3583770394,
-0.2133098543,
0.4167355895,
0.4877787828,
0.3620070815,
-0.1859989464,
0.1280546784,
-0.0801756307,
-0.4117183387,
0.1529475451,
-0.0260988958,
-0.4142087698,
-0.2659338713,
0.5826839209,
0.6535243988,
-0.6079350114,
-0.4613152742,
0.9580512047,
-0.2664859593,
0.193743974,
-0.6881893277,
0.0934363008,
-0.2505571842,
0.5327388048,
0.3610378504,
0.5145028234,
0.0933502838,
-0.8537384868,
-0.0882793367,
0.9696874022,
-0.4931440353,
-0.6983200908,
0.437259227,
0.325571537,
-0.6404948831,
0.7973533869,
-0.3358031809,
-0.9179668427,
0.8747803569,
0.2574401498,
1.5064829588,
-0.3981814981,
0.4653292596,
0.0473790951,
0.6932718158,
0.3921275139,
-0.1508089453,
-0.288501054,
-1.1688702106,
0.1559047103,
-0.2471977919,
-0.5972662568,
-0.0232161023,
-0.7043024898,
0.037818186,
-0.7480095029,
-0.6775315404,
-0.3397589028,
-0.2579107881,
-0.5167036057,
-0.0571084246,
0.2506589592,
-0.1918152422,
-1.0547370911,
0.3909228742,
0.8163700104,
-0.3662144542,
-0.4093683958,
0.5265128016,
0.1535485089,
-0.6632795334,
0.3364177644,
-0.0238109306,
-0.3237616718,
-0.1015853062,
-0.5743147731,
-0.6810650229,
0.8290913105,
0.0433011018,
-0.1086962894,
0.3770266175,
0.4179100692,
0.9815865159,
-0.4464296997,
0.1556955278,
0.3587834239,
0.3741779029,
-0.3806206286,
-0.6392361522,
-0.1649529487,
-0.312851131,
-0.4260838032,
-0.0168935284,
-1.1830420494,
1.0153951645,
-0.0795912519,
-0.3788221478,
-0.3615936637,
0.4451231956,
-0.0713904351,
0.4279431999,
0.7049710155,
0.1748503,
0.5094205737,
0.0913270563,
1.0009218454,
-0.3503337204,
0.2197578698,
0.6610891819,
-0.2444787621,
0.7787391543,
0.3932470083,
0.0327237211,
0.5906677842,
0.1317802519,
0.00951734,
0.3176465034,
-0.1681911051,
-0.6629193425,
-0.238861084,
-0.2401188463,
-0.3487418592,
0.4299422503,
0.1562286168,
-0.1613319665,
0.213173449,
0.33871153,
0.0598942786,
-0.1819734126,
-0.1244389713,
1.2225166559,
-0.1311396509,
-0.7211033702,
0.1249988601,
-0.1247649565,
0.0733363181,
-0.2556274533,
0.2437789738,
-0.2500119209,
0.0720909089,
-0.2120654583,
-0.6200179458,
0.188773945,
-0.0409797989,
-0.3077024221,
-0.3841065168,
0.2838852108,
-0.1037951112,
-0.3963933587,
0.5760495067,
0.5504700541,
0.0515915118,
-0.4391123056,
-0.7109593749,
0.0836676806,
0.1453976482,
-0.5356681943,
0.433409065,
0.1634196192,
-0.0473427922,
0.6570163965,
0.6835000515,
0.1996520013,
0.0970751941,
0.275829643,
1.1100203991,
-0.2204897702,
-0.4424281418,
-0.8161402941,
0.3648872972,
-0.1771960407,
-0.02643588,
0.5815339684,
0.3001563251,
0.4718385935,
0.0500743948,
1.0078784227,
-0.1850429177,
0.2737701833,
-0.208071962,
1.1255335808,
-0.3598102331,
0.3601309955,
-0.1632557213,
-0.9542469978,
0.0723222941,
0.5902238488,
-0.4788890183,
0.0950081795,
0.5329921246,
0.9648196101,
0.4157977998,
0.0755397305,
0.160733819,
0.6570291519,
0.7485910654,
0.0606270619,
1.032998085,
-0.088332735,
0.544010222,
-0.3186289072,
-0.6258917451,
-0.1737608016,
-0.3309163153,
-1.2546526194,
-0.7790144682,
-0.5185868144,
-0.3384649754,
-0.0507941879,
0.9231036901,
0.5084629059,
-0.867811203,
-0.2945192754,
-0.2722983956,
0.1778353453,
-0.1264687777,
-0.3490513861,
0.3158955276,
-0.3129974902,
-0.689873457,
0.4214258194,
0.3245466053,
0.042971801,
-0.54629457,
0.2034292668,
0.2163726985,
0.4849644601,
0.3651704788,
0.3000739813,
-0.820959866,
-0.5386334062,
-0.1133172959,
-0.1809126735,
0.2351728827,
0.753252387,
-0.616723597,
0.5389707088,
0.5161219835,
0.4404364526,
0.0302381478,
0.6458289623,
0.6469563842,
-0.286147207,
0.2535884976,
0.627137661,
0.0214248449,
0.1328519136,
-0.6939051151,
0.0488814637,
0.2886049449,
-1.0047152042,
-0.5822250843,
0.1255589724,
-0.9445493221,
0.0454467647,
1.0197736025,
0.0884838477,
0.0099664526,
-0.2617129982,
-0.3695279956,
0.2236564308,
-0.6125340462,
1.4385544062,
0.6691129208,
-0.6962166429,
-0.1703393906,
-0.3563828766,
0.5151492953,
0.5771640539,
-0.9947667122,
0.0558392406,
0.2074008286,
-0.1066694558,
0.2503435314,
0.6703737974,
0.1287446022,
0.2513370812,
0.1001881585,
0.0478402488,
0.2973817289,
-0.2988929152,
-0.4828866422,
0.4355029166,
0.1146909073,
-0.0459805317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12204v1
|
Enhancing Multilingual Capabilities of Large Language Models through Self-Distillation from Resource-Rich Languages
| 2024-02-19T15:07:32 | 2024-02-19T15:07:32 |
Yuanchi Zhang, Yile Wang, Zijun Liu, Shuo Wang, Xiaolong Wang, Peng Li, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) have been pre-trained on multilingual
corpora, their performance still lags behind in most languages compared to a
few resource-rich languages. One common approach to mitigate this issue is to
translate training data from resource-rich languages into other languages and
then continue training. However, using the data obtained solely relying on
translation while ignoring the original capabilities of LLMs across languages
is not always effective, which we show will limit the performance of
cross-lingual knowledge transfer. In this work, we propose SDRRL, a method
based on Self-Distillation from Resource-Rich Languages that effectively
improve multilingual performance by leveraging the internal capabilities of
LLMs on resource-rich languages. We evaluate on different LLMs (LLaMA-2 and
SeaLLM) and source languages across various comprehension and generation tasks,
experimental results demonstrate that SDRRL can significantly enhance
multilingual capabilities while minimizing the impact on original performance
in resource-rich languages.
|
[
-0.4335055351,
-0.4088551402,
0.4932002127,
0.340806216,
-0.4475041926,
0.5429620147,
-0.5860022902,
-0.4826279581,
0.1489066184,
0.5849191546,
-0.4321055412,
-0.0964950845,
-0.5256838799,
0.4570129812,
0.0475067943,
1.2924517393,
-0.0832108185,
0.2172350734,
-0.1383158863,
-0.3485294282,
-0.3510780632,
-0.6166141033,
-0.3526812196,
-0.3694183826,
0.6695597768,
0.3380341828,
0.3074956238,
0.6022244096,
0.5010058284,
0.2949149907,
-0.0818379596,
0.3424524665,
-0.6635035276,
0.2238686234,
-0.478409797,
-0.4226661623,
-0.2293283194,
-0.3218047619,
0.8808300495,
0.5608109832,
-0.1875550747,
0.3667993844,
0.4004086256,
0.7402746677,
-0.5985887051,
0.2819692194,
-0.6023266912,
0.0201076642,
-0.2747749388,
-0.2256607711,
-0.2867538631,
-0.1178169996,
-0.123106584,
-0.3965215385,
0.1722037047,
-0.1686729342,
0.2521403432,
0.4595870674,
-0.1469807029,
-0.2232483625,
-0.7359449863,
0.9577305913,
-0.757445991,
0.6768813729,
0.3722815812,
0.2529658973,
0.2697896361,
-0.5416460633,
-0.4753910303,
-0.2166429162,
-0.2452293038,
-0.1321000755,
-0.0046053026,
-0.2742137015,
0.2277357727,
0.0855253786,
-0.3930052221,
0.2747348249,
-0.6695525646,
-0.1724733412,
0.6831707954,
-0.0818426311,
0.0866182894,
-0.1082001179,
-0.4392944574,
-0.2526299059,
-0.7288194299,
-0.1118540093,
0.1556327343,
0.7125059962,
-0.0864430368,
0.546847105,
-0.0263891742,
0.4676903486,
-0.1650328934,
-0.6088633537,
0.3268020451,
-0.6495620608,
-0.0694573298,
0.2253489941,
0.6568297744,
-0.0447453894,
0.2455959022,
-0.1805284619,
-0.2841562033,
-0.3414056003,
-0.2390387654,
-0.8624945879,
-0.1593239605,
0.0600363649,
-0.3312741518,
0.1218989864,
-0.5077276826,
-0.7962967157,
-0.2713831067,
-0.4939474463,
0.0819833875,
-0.3132073581,
-0.7265964746,
-0.0488799438,
-0.0536509454,
-0.1569700986,
0.1266555488,
-0.9997227192,
-0.0560370274,
0.2838820517,
0.9002019167,
-0.2987043858,
-0.5742859244,
-0.5937693715,
0.4486846626,
-0.2363757491,
0.6400135159,
-0.297308892,
-0.36364308,
-0.1297617406,
-0.150768429,
-0.0055777878,
-0.6992464066,
0.2154671699,
-0.5102218986,
-0.2400891781,
-0.5082419515,
-0.1788356006,
0.0436063744,
0.1300152689,
-0.7753868103,
1.0153032541,
-0.0405585319,
-0.684515655,
0.2618247271,
-0.5616106987,
-0.6192660332,
0.0933210701,
-0.1893850714,
-0.044201117,
0.155379355,
0.3234163523,
0.4789678454,
-0.2604722381,
0.1993922591,
-0.3423366547,
0.0671214685,
0.2315259874,
-0.465901792,
0.687590301,
0.5390077829,
-0.0152398292,
-0.1218260005,
-0.7526219487,
0.2055176198,
0.1655312479,
-0.5685200691,
-0.5608891845,
-0.4321548641,
0.0423507914,
0.5005666018,
0.5045368075,
-0.4298452735,
0.1723347902,
-0.0906061679,
0.308834672,
0.7530934215,
-0.4023216367,
0.4839841127,
-0.1017741039,
0.6429939866,
0.0452556275,
-0.1665519327,
-0.1261633635,
-0.0559697263,
-0.7641379833,
-0.6387336254,
0.3337995112,
0.4352851808,
-1.0653862953,
0.0683617145,
-0.357542783,
-0.3346154392,
-0.9007713795,
0.8688271046,
0.3810200691,
0.3084620535,
0.5802752376,
-0.0688092709,
-0.6001176834,
-0.7869096398,
-0.0845909789,
-0.2169911712,
0.2165768594,
-0.0012330022,
0.2318559587,
-0.1024859101,
0.8334586024,
-0.2973582447,
-0.4599321783,
-0.7899916768,
0.0100587914,
0.1898665577,
0.3661892116,
0.5470067263,
-0.6205998063,
-0.7490149736,
0.2314087152,
-0.7275025249,
-0.3197420239,
-0.1060427353,
0.0360304676,
0.4375998974,
0.5626188517,
-0.2153351754,
-0.0707968324,
0.8779235482,
-0.0198095143,
0.5535985231,
-0.5901243687,
-0.0069908495,
-0.9199316502,
0.1805810183,
-0.0462569445,
-0.1326906383,
-0.6379668713,
0.0896612331,
0.1834278852,
0.0514927916,
-0.5797339678,
0.8361557126,
-0.7396000028,
-0.2199501991,
-0.3680951595,
0.0854635611,
0.0933254883,
0.3419706225,
0.2778717577,
0.8001002073,
0.3567221165,
-0.5086566806,
0.2589184046,
0.1704548895,
-0.3471381366,
0.4752486944,
-0.3925723433,
-0.1341139376,
-0.2407296002,
-0.0232842043,
-0.7928363085,
0.0959605724,
-0.158220619,
0.0797783434,
0.5698036551,
-0.3710664213,
-0.4283907115,
-0.2158046961,
0.0703937113,
0.4329484403,
0.3366006315,
-0.7801707387,
0.5390218496,
0.1265801787,
-0.3671765029,
-0.7981562614,
-1.0941275358,
0.0609894656,
-0.4437123537,
-0.5047248006,
0.065936774,
-0.2713530064,
-0.2931770086,
-0.1675078571,
0.1025586799,
-0.1616659015,
0.0595794171,
-0.2682078183,
0.2789964676,
-0.0952198505,
0.3190823197,
0.0513473451,
-0.0342241675,
-0.1864153445,
-0.1513437778,
0.6130071878,
-0.0542599261,
-0.4724081457,
-0.3628197312,
0.3735715747,
0.6325352788,
-0.6534875631,
0.8084400892,
0.7854073644,
0.1627488434,
-0.5351654887,
-0.8245500326,
-0.2077317834,
-0.4856749177,
0.488057524,
-0.6300186515,
-0.9198800921,
0.5929176807,
-0.1558657289,
0.0107563641,
0.2788627446,
0.6695762277,
0.0462786667,
0.6677640676,
0.7703735232,
-0.2944942713,
0.5184699297,
-0.3161754906,
0.1696392149,
-0.8815310597,
-0.1510388851,
-0.4226279259,
-0.0847971812,
-0.4924921989,
-0.7020035982,
0.2673969567,
0.3051032126,
0.0727628544,
0.3072862029,
-0.2231638879,
0.3893146515,
0.4366428256,
-0.1870952696,
0.6233837605,
0.3382326663,
-0.3098671436,
-0.186694026,
-0.9432749748,
-0.3142453134,
1.0332280397,
0.4245269299,
1.0171227455,
0.1974775642,
0.9535601735,
0.1921274811,
0.2671726942,
-0.3601740003,
0.3425574005,
-0.3662367761,
-0.4212838709,
-0.487193495,
-0.6708720922,
-0.5739084482,
0.6548919082,
-0.0700167567,
-0.2469349056,
0.0831139088,
-0.048042994,
-0.2740447819,
0.3872179985,
-0.5843791962,
0.6496599317,
-0.7760397196,
-0.6301241517,
-0.273209393,
-0.2039640993,
0.2635935843,
-0.5397898555,
0.4992361963,
-0.2712559104,
0.0203588251,
0.5132014751,
-0.1427037418,
0.7845547199,
-0.1306870431,
-0.588564992,
0.2504233718,
0.123042345,
0.5508825183,
0.0944053754,
-0.1815053076,
0.4676633179,
0.0083408291,
-0.2916440964,
-0.540656209,
0.7226776481,
-0.7498815656,
-0.604943037,
-0.2033818215,
-0.6336457729,
-0.1677364409,
0.2123534083,
-0.0450456366,
0.1329746544,
-0.076628305,
0.0981651172,
0.4329483509,
-0.158075586,
0.7765116692,
0.8654188514,
-0.2734210193,
-0.3966917992,
0.9592896104,
0.3584604859,
0.5012739897,
0.2174890339,
0.2403490543,
-0.8282656074,
-0.6154590249,
-0.7613582015,
0.4847717583,
-0.7923929095,
-0.2194875926,
-0.6680296659,
-0.17807962,
-0.4631718993,
-0.0028784957,
-0.634056747,
-0.412694186,
-0.3350763917,
0.0149339689,
0.2421254665,
0.583206594,
-0.6058799028,
-0.0230206139,
-0.9900338054,
0.2514828444,
0.2530617416,
0.3787207901,
0.1575782001,
-0.6795964837,
-0.4974128604,
0.2333608568,
0.0119649377,
-0.3168290555,
0.703573823,
0.4046367407,
0.8656362891,
0.1988796592,
0.1563119441,
0.9776912332,
-0.5167031288,
0.4494704604,
0.4434136748,
-0.7467221022,
0.3550130129,
-0.0499434285,
0.2910991013,
0.5195581913,
0.4495801926,
-0.5456327796,
-0.3960689306,
-0.1375616342,
-0.5475993156,
0.669247508,
-0.026952466,
0.062254753,
0.0306261126,
0.0837267041,
0.1921638846,
0.1158089042,
-0.901530683,
-0.0178246647,
-0.2448470592,
0.0136328945,
-0.3491169214,
-0.3367515802,
-0.1356091499,
-0.0973856598,
0.5119295716,
-0.3929683268,
-0.3626388907,
0.2380544543,
-0.3502151966,
-0.0547665767,
0.3238636851,
0.3686909974,
0.9158610106,
0.086392127,
0.3279570937,
0.4893994033,
-0.2480587363,
0.3293854594,
0.0510609336,
0.2602958381,
-0.2413913161,
0.4999674559,
0.6211115122,
0.0698844343,
-0.7890757322,
0.0932577625,
0.0567484275,
0.1286462843,
0.0215801243,
0.016315477,
0.1999900341,
0.6570023894,
0.4796640575,
-0.3289135396,
-0.1623879373,
-0.4778800607,
0.1352947056,
0.3590572476,
0.0885570869,
-0.1644829959,
0.5203424096,
0.112227954,
0.1812762916,
0.5976269841,
-0.0496002398,
-0.3529405296,
0.317954123,
0.8973679543,
0.5689342618,
-0.4916745722,
0.1952457726,
0.5693591833,
0.2776076496,
-0.3074962497,
0.1245732233,
-0.1850272864,
-0.7679912448,
-0.8269400597,
-0.959659636,
-0.0435285009,
0.0762146413,
-0.6220899224,
0.1056747064,
-0.1815302968,
-0.1119394377,
-0.1610656083,
0.0782647431,
-0.731975913,
-0.1123450026,
0.3385417163,
0.7563865185,
-0.8852359056,
1.191092968,
0.3827092052,
-0.4311577082,
-0.4767098129,
-0.4012361765,
-0.3802934587,
-0.7820017934,
1.232426405,
-0.1734022945,
-0.155313462,
-0.0883235186,
-0.0710320249,
-1.1072599888,
1.057713747,
0.6748048067,
-0.8398184776,
0.1222644895,
0.6285427213,
0.6751043797,
-0.3010137677,
0.0939378366,
0.5070160031,
0.4891241491,
0.1494364291,
-1.2548658848,
-0.0721809268,
0.0135539221,
0.29269436,
-0.0852573514,
-0.6982050538,
0.797142148,
-0.4733625948,
-0.2622180581,
-0.1983331293,
0.7468291521,
0.4370716512,
-0.0642971471,
0.4060280323,
0.4895833433,
0.8427125812,
0.2877416015,
0.7015342116,
-0.4620459378,
0.3259926736,
1.4031823874,
-0.6096901298,
0.9264231324,
0.6563975215,
-0.1000998169,
0.2152619213,
0.1955772042,
-0.0068161516,
0.7965092063,
0.0671748742,
-0.4250589907,
-0.4097094834,
-0.3501939178,
-0.4950380027,
0.7215948701,
0.2415022701,
-0.3365957141,
-0.4784448445,
0.2597652972,
-0.0911612287,
0.1317639351,
-0.2463752627,
0.7416175604,
0.1199690998,
-0.6146515608,
0.9480329752,
-0.0881514847,
0.7580993772,
-0.764484942,
-0.0808694065,
-0.4335777462,
0.303551048,
-0.0448799878,
-0.8017809987,
0.3512909412,
0.1473361403,
-0.2301406562,
-0.6107136011,
0.6691614389,
-0.8782939911,
-0.6302835345,
0.7298559546,
0.9843131304,
0.1982304305,
0.1979616135,
-0.6075122356,
0.2151090652,
0.1537751406,
0.060974557,
0.6137427688,
0.5972160697,
0.1721677929,
0.8889253736,
0.9419187903,
0.4221791625,
0.1231145784,
0.0581999123,
0.9180136323,
-0.3834646642,
-0.4977741539,
-0.9605839252,
0.307295531,
-0.0033001113,
-0.0537232757,
0.9193526506,
0.5179879069,
1.1019364595,
-0.0549917892,
1.0383251905,
-0.0461253524,
0.4313230515,
-0.5289341807,
0.9972186089,
-0.6383016109,
0.3519941866,
0.0412633382,
-0.9584306479,
-0.0044254018,
0.5596333146,
-0.0970928594,
-0.0081517426,
0.4856722653,
0.6870996356,
-0.0381681956,
-0.3621728122,
0.6450371146,
0.1830829531,
0.4039804041,
0.2974852622,
0.7589369416,
0.128698647,
0.6104243994,
-0.4546058476,
-0.1253761053,
0.0093792444,
-0.9976779819,
-1.0753707886,
-0.6056463718,
-0.1247646585,
-0.1855764538,
-0.0722668692,
0.7909225225,
0.600035429,
-0.6141129136,
-0.528853178,
0.372071296,
0.1001281589,
-0.0629232451,
-0.1134475693,
0.3098202646,
-0.7159723639,
-0.6380497813,
0.7182719111,
0.1400864422,
0.119718574,
-0.8244972825,
-0.1701148003,
-0.1818442941,
-0.2230553925,
0.7177482247,
0.3168946803,
-0.5986202359,
0.0147141945,
-0.2002376616,
-0.0974010006,
0.0223231185,
0.7938563228,
-0.7016742826,
0.6026338935,
0.3716792166,
0.6145813465,
0.4339170158,
-0.2262479067,
0.4657245278,
-0.8371514082,
0.2971789539,
0.0152886845,
0.4408253431,
0.6166861653,
-0.2128062844,
0.5626123548,
-0.0065056514,
-0.3850520551,
-0.7651870251,
0.0113958335,
-0.5624614954,
-0.5288523436,
1.3815532923,
-0.3059639335,
-0.1015332565,
-0.099279061,
-0.0624429137,
0.303529948,
-0.2595459223,
0.729798913,
0.5366916656,
0.1095198542,
-0.2398895919,
-0.5716155171,
0.561267674,
0.1813968867,
-0.7129030824,
0.4948357344,
0.2901672423,
0.5073061585,
0.2614322007,
0.6406843066,
-0.0514821634,
-0.0509557687,
-0.2272858769,
0.2035786361,
-0.2546695471,
-0.537729919,
-0.3651370406,
0.0250272918,
0.1094665006,
0.2184818685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12198v1
|
Zero shot VLMs for hate meme detection: Are we there yet?
| 2024-02-19T15:03:04 | 2024-02-19T15:03:04 |
Naquee Rizwan, Paramananda Bhaskar, Mithun Das, Swadhin Satyaprakash Majhi, Punyajoy Saha, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Multimedia content on social media is rapidly evolving, with memes gaining
prominence as a distinctive form. Unfortunately, some malicious users exploit
memes to target individuals or vulnerable communities, making it imperative to
identify and address such instances of hateful memes. Extensive research has
been conducted to address this issue by developing hate meme detection models.
However, a notable limitation of traditional machine/deep learning models is
the requirement for labeled datasets for accurate classification. Recently, the
research community has witnessed the emergence of several visual language
models that have exhibited outstanding performance across various tasks. In
this study, we aim to investigate the efficacy of these visual language models
in handling intricate tasks such as hate meme detection. We use various prompt
settings to focus on zero-shot classification of hateful/harmful memes. Through
our analysis, we observe that large VLMs are still vulnerable for zero-shot
hate meme detection.
|
[
-0.4403588474,
-0.850491643,
0.4324671924,
0.0544754863,
-0.3721403778,
0.1991065145,
0.1509915888,
-0.4205222726,
0.1656281203,
0.3891808093,
-0.7759811878,
-0.5715383887,
-0.7456113696,
0.0963823497,
-0.6486436725,
0.7311215997,
0.197121352,
-0.1663535833,
-0.0932613239,
-0.4887887239,
-0.5973368883,
-0.6323264241,
-0.6055237055,
0.0832069293,
0.9761346579,
0.4449954927,
0.4441012144,
0.5106496215,
0.5288786888,
0.248836115,
0.152908057,
-0.2638995945,
-0.57102108,
0.4651441574,
-0.2335792333,
-0.2926719487,
-0.0270353854,
0.0560278744,
0.3415553868,
0.2509726584,
0.1454748064,
0.3704157174,
-0.317830056,
0.1874211282,
-0.8283311129,
-0.3717705905,
-0.9048131108,
0.2880731225,
-0.391312331,
-0.2297234535,
-0.4337300956,
-0.0617418922,
0.0548936836,
-0.124776192,
0.0600806847,
-0.0138433613,
0.6199365258,
0.1314757913,
-0.3059123158,
-0.240041256,
-0.7329752445,
1.2263720036,
-0.9143249989,
0.2267041206,
-0.0399398804,
0.4751712978,
0.0312591903,
-0.2827431858,
-0.7318387032,
-0.2583548725,
0.3355951905,
-0.0884574503,
-0.8931479454,
-0.2803982496,
0.3894393742,
0.0269668251,
-0.8713018298,
0.7103093863,
-0.5178502202,
-0.2779707313,
0.4804134071,
0.5535519719,
0.5546687245,
-0.3411512375,
-0.5866591334,
0.1061113477,
-0.4497840703,
-0.1368037909,
0.1874469966,
0.2246757746,
0.0301920474,
0.825348556,
-0.3001184464,
0.9952040315,
-0.3375047147,
-0.1940737069,
0.0075934371,
0.0888194591,
-0.4857214987,
-0.1930352449,
0.8765642047,
0.5719879866,
0.5526860952,
0.0430283472,
-0.103891246,
0.4480749369,
0.5424433351,
-1.0080343485,
0.0686259419,
-0.0382760726,
-0.2989566624,
-0.7361869216,
-0.4478878081,
-0.617651403,
-0.573844254,
-0.1874753237,
0.4414688647,
-0.277951479,
-0.2619792819,
-0.1430724859,
-0.2888417244,
0.245583415,
0.7185486555,
-0.4781587124,
-0.0448384769,
0.2732390761,
0.7792634964,
-0.0899285451,
-0.0713915154,
-0.5652011633,
-0.0877673328,
-0.4125248492,
0.8126448393,
-0.6143299341,
-0.0147061311,
0.2184231728,
-0.0283875708,
0.1145540178,
-0.3977831304,
0.5115447044,
-0.5486012101,
0.0332402699,
-0.3239015341,
-0.5493484139,
-0.3426955044,
0.5975530148,
-0.4521491826,
0.3380128443,
0.3590425849,
-0.5984433889,
0.4712130427,
-0.4651076198,
-0.2708549798,
0.3444360793,
-0.2490638196,
-0.6591111422,
0.2135392725,
-0.3658428192,
0.9280606508,
-0.0324273147,
-0.1887546629,
-0.9699707627,
-0.1949750781,
0.181459412,
-0.5930125117,
0.8393253088,
0.5242546201,
-0.4186860323,
0.2643823922,
-0.5892104506,
-0.2167650908,
0.4741360545,
0.0328105092,
-0.5818908811,
-0.3012582064,
0.1195414588,
0.6236338615,
-0.1489042044,
-0.8071497083,
0.1681692749,
0.3348098993,
0.1625257879,
0.9065278172,
-0.149902612,
0.2554874718,
0.051370129,
0.7135057449,
0.2582737505,
0.3948327899,
0.0168005321,
-0.5770375729,
-0.5896763802,
-0.2469184697,
-0.2399099171,
0.4872041345,
-0.9733994007,
0.0541106723,
0.1367583722,
-0.5254974961,
-0.2572173774,
0.2031636387,
0.2756000459,
0.5741426349,
0.4926031232,
-0.2653335929,
-0.6394869089,
-0.9436503053,
-0.0908553004,
-0.1083594188,
-0.0879568607,
0.4016079903,
0.3293904066,
-0.3339649141,
0.5480047464,
-0.3481408954,
-0.3566862643,
-0.214831844,
0.2676547468,
0.02010113,
0.0693529025,
1.1431798935,
-0.5988188982,
-0.6433860064,
-0.3856078684,
-1.1508748531,
-0.4397289157,
-0.0102111911,
0.2416843772,
0.2065655887,
0.4349312782,
-0.0095791612,
0.5900964737,
0.551042974,
-0.5840447545,
0.6685740948,
0.3707670271,
0.3646662235,
-0.500818193,
-0.3112664223,
0.30732283,
-0.5065153241,
-0.9380719662,
-0.2487082034,
-0.1590028107,
-0.0309304949,
-0.86809057,
0.5220656991,
-0.3290298879,
0.0936838984,
-0.4174038768,
-0.1283526272,
-0.4215150476,
0.356336683,
-0.0342595503,
0.3280558884,
0.723089695,
-0.5062225461,
0.3178395331,
-0.0828871727,
-0.228729859,
0.9048838615,
-0.4140174389,
-0.0716012195,
-0.33098948,
-0.2759782076,
-0.8692629933,
0.0601036213,
0.8267608285,
-0.4879206419,
0.3771763444,
-0.132590428,
-0.2743269801,
-0.6228606701,
-0.4312487543,
0.4805203676,
0.558596909,
-0.264333874,
0.1137573943,
0.2085442543,
0.2024149746,
-0.7408834696,
-0.503917098,
0.1698119342,
-0.3545697629,
-0.3685356677,
-0.3436130583,
-0.177107051,
-0.2832747102,
0.0924197584,
0.0101264156,
-0.0967867896,
0.1399634778,
0.4484320879,
0.0835965127,
-0.4418198168,
-0.1358842403,
-0.3004485965,
-0.1239420772,
-0.3637014329,
-0.0835662186,
0.5433385968,
-0.0258915368,
-0.5411911607,
-0.2800042033,
0.424698174,
1.0437726974,
-0.1566490233,
0.8483903408,
0.7450772524,
-0.3504441977,
-0.3553306758,
-0.7058655024,
0.1026838794,
-0.4567079246,
0.3168531656,
-0.1184662208,
-1.3734550476,
0.3875274658,
0.303681016,
-0.0266496595,
0.4487249255,
0.5782942176,
-0.2697355449,
0.7900499701,
0.6483024359,
-0.2970235944,
0.6645419598,
-0.1425932944,
0.2245191932,
-0.316899091,
-0.0075793047,
-0.3861820996,
-0.3668837547,
-0.1750739366,
-0.6545975804,
0.278965503,
0.047404822,
-0.0421758145,
0.4224371314,
-0.546698153,
0.2739151418,
0.3212814629,
-0.0431356207,
-0.0862778053,
0.3413645327,
0.2693383098,
-0.3686058223,
-0.5573601723,
-0.2492496371,
1.0377856493,
0.358902663,
0.8016006947,
0.0539346747,
0.2915145755,
0.8425690532,
0.4787702858,
-0.7384207845,
0.5706725121,
-0.3272418082,
-0.5504574776,
-0.4787273109,
-0.0875369459,
-0.8817619085,
-0.0185333621,
-0.2064491063,
-0.6794096828,
-0.0956500769,
0.1457711607,
-0.0907977447,
0.6432674527,
-0.208910495,
1.1353732347,
-0.2101779431,
-0.2111229599,
-0.2695600986,
-0.3987109065,
0.3268813789,
0.0022346824,
0.1530621648,
-0.4831525385,
0.1509307176,
0.5631411076,
-0.31267187,
0.9714152217,
-0.3922421336,
0.0740109757,
0.6556480527,
0.3359574378,
0.0259159431,
-0.566613853,
-0.0001580009,
0.467685163,
-0.420534879,
-0.7440443635,
-0.5124770403,
0.7325925827,
-0.2973583937,
-0.3274041116,
-0.397190541,
-0.1333813965,
0.2423735857,
0.2259305865,
0.1275425702,
0.3910167813,
-0.2289423645,
0.2610083818,
0.718682766,
-0.3663556576,
0.5104758143,
0.8034127355,
-0.4218604565,
-0.0616151281,
1.2443454266,
0.551494658,
0.1955884844,
0.1900284439,
-0.1310233176,
-0.0446837172,
-0.8971552253,
-0.7166621089,
-0.0415176861,
-0.5596576333,
-0.3762603998,
-0.752137363,
-0.1858363897,
-0.2912777662,
-0.3854059875,
-0.2107765973,
-0.1560165137,
-0.3446627855,
-0.1108947396,
0.3498626649,
1.0040906668,
-0.0431711823,
0.2686930895,
-0.720110774,
0.4046072364,
0.4501358271,
0.4732224047,
0.1553263813,
-0.7354757786,
-0.2192254066,
-0.1333364397,
-0.2080985308,
-1.1599948406,
0.3779751658,
-0.2007588744,
0.5030236244,
0.6255554557,
0.0726106912,
0.4869801104,
-0.5253767371,
0.7718760967,
0.4187033772,
-0.5236914158,
0.5222525597,
-0.4504211545,
0.1355682313,
0.2730398178,
0.6413066387,
-0.61339885,
-0.5616336465,
-0.5849468708,
-0.3245037198,
0.3793104887,
0.2370505333,
0.494946897,
-0.2072243392,
0.161027506,
0.067604281,
0.3380686045,
-0.8526310921,
-0.4482232034,
-0.2666163146,
0.1397618055,
0.0926291943,
-0.7946557999,
0.3588302433,
-0.3243782222,
0.4470509291,
0.077653788,
-0.0879479498,
-0.0394163169,
-0.2310020924,
-0.4698786139,
0.2354615033,
0.6904968023,
0.4316960573,
-0.2693489492,
0.2294799984,
0.0405246206,
-0.2004811615,
0.2774818242,
-0.4890839756,
-0.5105726123,
0.3188122809,
0.3692346811,
0.8701338768,
0.082170248,
-0.7915882468,
0.8487479091,
-0.0301831476,
-0.1799693257,
-0.3968239725,
0.0479918979,
-0.2355284244,
0.2371142507,
0.1431311667,
0.1050759852,
0.2035047263,
-0.4820514619,
0.5206810236,
0.7231616974,
-0.7923964858,
-0.4333458245,
0.7139249444,
-0.063064687,
-0.2942225635,
0.3707203269,
-0.2961413562,
-0.6258351207,
0.5873659253,
0.4442204237,
0.8745339513,
-0.5247960091,
0.5714232326,
0.3804661334,
0.4903102815,
0.5033037066,
0.0312142018,
0.0884237736,
-0.7232218385,
-0.0848834887,
-1.0223885775,
-0.2467900515,
0.6168975234,
-0.2800116539,
0.5240294337,
-0.6353721619,
0.1298989207,
0.4032773376,
-0.440718919,
-0.7135073543,
0.4105894566,
0.7338303924,
0.7074509859,
-1.1924093962,
0.5402171612,
0.4924215674,
-0.6280350089,
-0.5264636874,
-0.4998573661,
0.3582526445,
-0.8258885741,
0.4161370099,
0.3005425036,
0.0618987307,
-0.0650117025,
-1.0323194265,
-0.4239290953,
0.60966295,
0.3088037968,
-0.518443048,
0.4113925993,
0.1341875345,
0.7365880609,
-0.4883948267,
0.0892833993,
0.1094546318,
0.3094938397,
0.340675503,
-0.4956896305,
-0.07737948,
-0.1626674235,
-0.262427479,
0.1227691397,
-0.3786404729,
0.9714019895,
-0.1540878117,
0.0433150008,
-0.2626482844,
0.5182958841,
-0.002547228,
0.6357262135,
0.7166457772,
0.576055944,
0.1470821649,
0.4605486691,
0.8942910433,
0.5139110088,
0.2280424088,
0.8944663405,
-0.1069237441,
0.7162817717,
0.3399764597,
-0.1727807671,
0.4712635875,
0.4498237073,
-0.5582606196,
0.308254987,
0.4449226856,
-0.5254676342,
-0.5704200864,
-0.5413355827,
-0.1016523987,
0.409932822,
0.3369778991,
-0.4120034873,
-0.5438548923,
0.344635576,
0.3215382099,
0.1510004252,
-0.5541382432,
0.7293859124,
-0.0157356635,
-0.0316653736,
0.8163039088,
-0.1715574563,
0.8319398761,
-0.5440836549,
-0.0781358927,
0.0911926255,
-0.137094155,
-0.3293437362,
-0.7756223679,
0.4064827561,
0.349704802,
-0.4193607271,
-0.0074148676,
1.1974885464,
-0.391058892,
-0.5299311876,
0.6749600172,
0.5603998899,
0.3549364805,
-0.3344525099,
-0.7457762957,
0.175877735,
0.2211806625,
-0.2612727582,
0.4694011807,
0.337074697,
-0.3082005084,
0.7344952226,
0.6284192801,
-0.2054884434,
0.541767478,
0.362303406,
0.7287539244,
-0.6887966394,
0.0903258249,
-1.2554744482,
0.6035941839,
-0.2489859909,
0.1675260961,
0.9867013097,
0.316039741,
0.8280967474,
-0.420684576,
0.9075114131,
-0.1091181412,
0.5564032197,
0.1170911491,
0.7110580802,
-0.9650224447,
-0.1264665872,
-0.4409249425,
-0.6797658205,
-0.6564462185,
0.1330412924,
-0.2079782784,
-0.2857111096,
0.1059454083,
0.5958864093,
-0.1150471866,
-0.3761257827,
0.9938144684,
0.3727193177,
0.5340069532,
0.3275752366,
0.8925086856,
-0.2282347828,
0.5830381513,
-0.4884229898,
-0.3007105887,
-0.5404092073,
-0.8850596547,
-1.1393662691,
-0.3304975033,
-0.3624964058,
-0.1975728124,
-0.0459190011,
0.5492085218,
0.4945771396,
-1.0095607042,
0.0503605977,
0.1634516865,
0.3362797499,
0.25627774,
-0.1975122392,
-0.1446926594,
-0.1451516449,
-0.4322835505,
0.2844955027,
0.8305372596,
0.2302279472,
-0.280859828,
0.0187740475,
-0.3301176727,
0.2454407364,
0.9415458441,
0.6248967648,
-0.797606945,
-0.4766834676,
0.0640010089,
-0.3051012754,
-0.1259716153,
0.6063047051,
-0.6086825728,
0.539790988,
0.3929539323,
0.5399249792,
0.1511828452,
-0.0925849602,
0.2173050493,
-0.5733526945,
0.2309884727,
0.3342158496,
0.2216298878,
0.3453262746,
-0.1906460077,
0.5897807479,
0.5699473619,
-0.3016271293,
-1.0072948933,
0.1641669273,
-1.1601322889,
-0.4387075603,
0.8832743764,
-0.0011245902,
-0.2592331767,
-0.2008965313,
-0.1946238428,
0.1552212089,
-0.2521619201,
0.5830965638,
0.4582071602,
-0.040588744,
-0.3464568853,
-0.7187206745,
0.247002691,
0.5066103935,
-0.4796654582,
-0.2064702213,
0.6371936202,
0.4045867026,
0.2763887048,
0.7858201861,
0.2096013874,
0.4225722253,
-0.127843827,
0.2734564245,
-0.1023393124,
-0.4177590013,
-0.4398313165,
0.3979184031,
-0.0697151199,
-0.3526770771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12195v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12195v2
|
Browse and Concentrate: Comprehending Multimodal Content via prior-LLM Context Fusion
| 2024-02-19T14:59:07 | 2024-06-08T03:04:30 |
Ziyue Wang, Chi Chen, Yiqi Zhu, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the bloom of Large Language Models (LLMs), Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) that incorporate LLMs with pre-trained vision models have
recently demonstrated impressive performance across diverse vision-language
tasks. However, they fall short to comprehend context involving multiple
images. A primary reason for this shortcoming is that the visual features for
each images are encoded individually by frozen encoders before feeding into the
LLM backbone, lacking awareness of other images and the multimodal
instructions. We term this issue as prior-LLM modality isolation and propose a
two phase paradigm, browse-and-concentrate, to enable in-depth multimodal
context fusion prior to feeding the features into LLMs. This paradigm initially
"browses" through the inputs for essential insights, and then revisits the
inputs to "concentrate" on crucial details, guided by these insights, to
achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the multimodal inputs.
Additionally, we develop training strategies specifically to enhance the
understanding of multi-image inputs. Our method markedly boosts the performance
on 7 multi-image scenarios, contributing to increments on average accuracy by
2.13% and 7.60% against strong MLLMs baselines with 3B and 11B LLMs,
respectively.
|
[
-0.6235099435,
-0.7184431553,
0.8318760991,
0.2475527972,
-0.4397783577,
-0.0721263736,
-0.1165364683,
-0.3674215078,
0.1004464254,
0.558255434,
-0.5937706828,
-0.3279117644,
-0.6531392932,
0.0728759617,
-0.2391741127,
0.3849689662,
-0.2071905434,
0.234432742,
-0.6185051203,
-0.113784112,
-0.70420295,
-0.2786931396,
-0.4549234211,
-0.2174608856,
0.546828866,
0.1817020476,
0.2857411206,
0.3468170762,
0.5095008016,
0.3410629034,
-0.0709808394,
0.5349046588,
-0.5909337401,
0.3977051973,
-0.2126780301,
-0.5589634776,
-0.0232932921,
-0.0636136159,
0.7446430922,
0.5870800614,
0.2081853598,
-0.2078912556,
0.2981930971,
0.5963737369,
-1.194260478,
-0.0010337413,
-0.6151218414,
0.0060118809,
-0.1985040456,
-0.3057775199,
-0.6109373569,
0.3226524293,
0.4233492315,
-0.8298418522,
0.1851101965,
-0.0355086327,
0.8767603636,
0.4264327586,
-0.6697192788,
0.1510317326,
-0.4822807908,
0.8483444452,
-0.1762356311,
0.6662051082,
0.5432148576,
0.1997975111,
0.1425512135,
-0.874546051,
-0.6000941396,
0.064669013,
-0.1869513988,
0.3701907992,
0.008097277,
0.0277741775,
0.1495393217,
0.3173170388,
-0.4541038573,
-0.0896611884,
-0.2820765376,
-0.2957356572,
0.1773507595,
0.2128141969,
0.1974068731,
-0.0951683447,
-0.569113493,
-0.2113009244,
-0.6928944588,
0.0546042733,
-0.4241759181,
-0.1440618932,
-0.0335998498,
0.5898793936,
-0.2250277102,
0.6158778667,
0.334279865,
-0.6884336472,
0.2884319127,
-0.6785270572,
-0.4775173068,
-0.3241608739,
0.4612894952,
0.353934288,
-0.1256569177,
-0.145165801,
-0.1623366475,
0.0925282314,
0.3375503421,
-0.7913148999,
-0.1002358347,
0.2297503948,
-0.7218306065,
0.010757301,
-0.1462863684,
-0.5579479933,
-0.5421184897,
-0.4543597102,
0.5652894974,
-0.3696308732,
-0.2687783539,
-0.0763745382,
-0.1952520162,
0.3860779107,
0.5440740585,
-0.7017023563,
-0.0005362451,
0.3558048904,
0.9616661072,
-0.4809065759,
-0.545378685,
-0.6174706817,
0.6300370097,
-0.1178803816,
0.8745776415,
-0.6088980436,
-0.3724853396,
0.2811775804,
0.2955276072,
-0.4350405335,
-0.5541257858,
0.2205646634,
-0.8380944729,
0.2493533492,
-0.2171805501,
-0.3986522853,
-0.6620188951,
0.461394608,
-0.5785629749,
0.6337111592,
0.0098581389,
-0.7533097863,
0.5581423044,
-0.3513238132,
-0.550063014,
-0.0411572643,
-0.216977194,
0.0650966391,
0.0941350758,
0.5348036885,
0.5417857766,
-0.0522219948,
0.1749413013,
-0.512624681,
-0.1765048653,
0.2283131182,
-0.3521414399,
0.4106826782,
0.0951584652,
-0.2063847184,
0.4075705409,
-0.3485460281,
-0.167862013,
0.0171771962,
-0.3418864608,
-0.2711482048,
0.0502792224,
0.0503677763,
0.3110165596,
0.1809167415,
-0.1972731203,
-0.1065390781,
-0.3077415526,
0.448669076,
0.6045107245,
-0.1477705836,
0.8261100054,
-0.2180602998,
0.5397299528,
0.4026502371,
0.1236074343,
-0.9147437215,
-0.208723262,
-0.9180659652,
-0.4906022847,
0.0219747089,
0.6811794043,
-1.1487219334,
0.0130428895,
-0.1893171966,
0.0497383066,
-0.4256295562,
0.3837194741,
0.4785160124,
0.5100035071,
0.4612721503,
-0.6128624082,
-0.2633037567,
-1.1371625662,
0.3444569707,
0.3265857697,
-0.1387094855,
0.450247407,
0.2938055992,
-0.3671381772,
0.8581656218,
-0.4987075925,
-0.6308248043,
-0.3302066922,
-0.1229600385,
-0.0814911276,
0.5178861618,
0.3098073006,
-1.0721995831,
-0.5289188027,
-0.1782376468,
-0.7529088855,
0.2857185006,
-0.0780138671,
-0.2627321184,
0.1414754391,
0.666113615,
-0.5778755546,
0.394159168,
0.4459677637,
-0.0898897275,
0.3081632257,
-0.0667290762,
0.2726033032,
-1.0617346764,
0.0684159398,
0.0897891149,
-0.209475711,
-0.6212102175,
0.1221784577,
0.2300924808,
-0.1289056242,
-0.6883727908,
0.4767692685,
-0.7899199128,
0.0611117892,
-0.3283036947,
0.2688337266,
0.5061820149,
0.49463287,
0.370077014,
0.7695716023,
0.954688251,
-0.5369698405,
-0.0450865962,
0.2846386433,
-0.3051334023,
0.6076872945,
-0.486589551,
0.1802600622,
-0.2641109526,
0.3655945063,
-1.1948344707,
-0.5081174374,
0.2310334891,
-0.0033561152,
0.6993284225,
-0.2716068327,
-0.3338342309,
-0.0995400548,
-0.3435956836,
0.7538696527,
0.360224545,
-0.4898511171,
0.9758033752,
0.5008738637,
-0.2287057042,
-0.566449523,
-0.6847311854,
-0.0001962415,
-0.1620588601,
-0.9567276239,
0.5015457273,
-0.0974375233,
-0.1180031076,
-0.0756943896,
0.0245251581,
-0.3081204593,
-0.091157347,
0.2854995131,
0.2344901562,
-0.2774462998,
-0.0640996695,
0.0623353682,
0.0067437324,
-0.1914652437,
-0.1610733271,
0.585323751,
0.0884875283,
-0.5294945836,
-0.5377976894,
0.5828065872,
0.5887001157,
-0.3869436085,
0.4602814317,
0.9392679334,
-0.0256867483,
0.2422544211,
-0.8672011495,
-0.3559423685,
-0.5187094808,
0.4107171595,
-0.4773228168,
-1.0537806749,
0.2764723897,
-0.0732074231,
-0.1091266498,
0.1067249998,
0.4882469177,
-0.319629401,
1.1176331043,
0.9609213471,
0.0999144167,
0.7432981133,
-0.2466268241,
-0.0179672632,
-1.1827384233,
-0.5602349639,
0.1433079392,
-0.3673621118,
-0.0664790869,
-0.6940770745,
0.5139513016,
0.3015380204,
0.3105305731,
-0.2155990899,
-0.2090408057,
0.6310374141,
0.6957336664,
0.4695438445,
0.0726275444,
0.1323366165,
-0.3657517433,
-0.0866464451,
-0.6290750504,
-0.1158629283,
0.9999014735,
0.1910509914,
0.6612249613,
-0.0033503396,
0.443937242,
-0.1018329114,
0.1182239503,
-0.8964381814,
0.4552586973,
-0.1624250412,
-0.5233201981,
-0.0442348793,
0.0996347591,
-0.971457243,
0.8189650774,
-0.332082808,
-0.6708809137,
0.3619409204,
0.2537513077,
-0.310457021,
-0.0847715959,
-0.7692183256,
0.9775425792,
-0.1097701639,
-0.7397568822,
-0.4723516703,
-0.847278893,
0.7440697551,
0.0432401858,
0.277058512,
0.0101760542,
-0.1949923933,
0.3345018327,
-0.0413158238,
0.9892647862,
0.0511700287,
-0.0152757848,
0.0707723126,
0.2023548186,
0.1220207214,
0.0165354181,
0.6234487891,
-0.0336464494,
0.0610092655,
-0.3044658303,
-0.3821190298,
0.477271378,
-0.4458955526,
-0.6906986237,
-0.1446271092,
-0.5619182587,
-0.2840037346,
0.3745962381,
0.2833542526,
0.8756173849,
0.0621323846,
0.3830811679,
0.957963109,
-0.0125423064,
0.555343926,
0.4485225976,
-0.3246380389,
-0.7542555928,
0.8159039617,
-0.26464203,
0.3275097907,
0.5608592033,
-0.1662845314,
-0.4203139246,
-0.7454972267,
-0.3237356544,
0.2414581627,
-0.9964782596,
-0.051945284,
-0.8103253245,
0.0755682588,
-0.504665494,
-0.3620183468,
0.1003978923,
0.1043212265,
-0.5396122336,
0.4355639219,
-0.1906015873,
0.477391392,
-0.0129177822,
0.4322705269,
-1.0150034428,
0.595713675,
0.4461327791,
0.0332436636,
0.0190691557,
-0.4324542582,
-0.336609304,
-0.1588837653,
-0.4372098744,
-0.8682608008,
0.308529675,
0.3516666889,
0.7680011988,
0.8417055011,
-0.353140682,
0.8704019785,
-0.4204087853,
0.8661577106,
0.4881067574,
-0.7022870779,
0.5869600773,
-0.1574891508,
0.7468006611,
0.6422932744,
0.4634698629,
-0.4030586183,
-0.3378170431,
-0.1411909163,
-0.9344028831,
0.8190937638,
-0.1809922904,
-0.1020416915,
-0.007241908,
0.0690689832,
-0.0061557572,
0.1839649975,
-0.7607526779,
-0.0891307965,
-0.2225413769,
0.0405104682,
-0.2858355939,
-0.6549327374,
-0.4065832496,
-0.2329338044,
0.3198278248,
-0.2058324516,
-0.0669864342,
0.3559631109,
-0.7087959051,
0.1479875296,
-0.0226708576,
0.7048663497,
0.8159387112,
0.0006704373,
0.4920993745,
0.0330099128,
-0.5999674201,
0.0188029762,
-0.0608566143,
-0.2466914058,
-0.2113934904,
0.4700895548,
0.7127649784,
0.4522385299,
-0.7329617143,
0.5441188812,
-0.0557028353,
-0.158443287,
-0.0358476676,
-0.1091622338,
0.0093970569,
0.4156010151,
0.2542295754,
0.2514826357,
0.2595717907,
-0.429094255,
0.2262134105,
0.5192340016,
-0.2791751623,
-0.2076420933,
0.5164548159,
0.3915072083,
0.3495135605,
0.5451128483,
0.0412529148,
-0.5042080879,
0.3142242432,
0.5879735947,
0.9829530716,
0.2126418948,
-0.0295032058,
0.1961775124,
0.1561016589,
-0.0821438208,
0.148390606,
-0.3878302574,
-0.9849485159,
-0.7890520692,
-0.5813512802,
-0.1500601172,
0.1010251716,
-0.5776593685,
0.0381304845,
-0.1826625019,
-0.132769987,
-0.1484224647,
-0.3344862759,
-0.7061581612,
-0.017979661,
0.3957755566,
0.6969032288,
-0.582324326,
0.8940624595,
0.6998587251,
-0.4069575369,
-0.5875053406,
0.0923809707,
0.1859409809,
-0.8860572577,
0.8176233768,
0.525718987,
-0.2847748995,
-0.0098161763,
-0.3968565166,
-0.9836611152,
1.1189416647,
0.1052302346,
-0.4730254114,
0.1472307891,
-0.38154459,
-0.0204036981,
-0.4315937757,
0.2567253411,
0.4523957372,
0.481880337,
0.3513743281,
-0.8551430702,
-0.0065852958,
-0.1406083554,
0.0824617818,
0.1557434946,
-0.5303468704,
0.6991331577,
-0.1847733408,
-0.5004309416,
-0.1180506051,
0.4328072071,
0.0915346295,
0.3896310627,
0.6206274033,
0.6475449204,
0.4267900884,
0.0765781105,
0.9629331231,
-0.253246963,
-0.0887834653,
1.0671943426,
-0.4147574306,
0.9339390397,
0.6173426509,
0.074278079,
0.1749125272,
0.7471910119,
0.0681957081,
1.0631217957,
-0.3595961034,
-0.4302627146,
-0.6478548646,
-0.3725384772,
-0.4215117991,
0.5631322861,
0.3939798474,
-0.3297555149,
-0.234490335,
0.4262799621,
-0.2577322125,
-0.1661039144,
-0.4207009375,
1.0358388424,
0.1536322683,
-0.7217473388,
0.6079532504,
-0.2672692537,
0.7864179611,
-0.6760913134,
0.0670090169,
-0.1751549989,
0.0372153148,
-0.1328554899,
-0.7053823471,
0.1090114638,
-0.4269842505,
-0.4376854897,
-0.4113975465,
0.9067870975,
-0.6195347309,
-0.2542577684,
0.2320522368,
0.6657322645,
0.1064449251,
-0.2916390598,
-0.5049827099,
0.2742401063,
-0.008919741,
-0.0961284116,
0.4983853996,
0.2413717508,
0.2118206769,
0.6727135777,
0.7058178782,
-0.2245938182,
0.0541175306,
0.2753959,
1.1331226826,
-0.4325102866,
-0.3514907062,
-0.8927075863,
0.4458416402,
0.0399704836,
-0.2113765776,
0.5945724249,
0.4737830162,
0.9416539669,
-0.2109148502,
0.5554380417,
0.0345775373,
0.1122291684,
-0.9560771585,
0.5076081157,
-0.9472059011,
-0.1652816236,
0.0274732113,
-0.8833030462,
-0.281465739,
0.3950217962,
-0.1926992238,
-0.3019034863,
1.053311944,
0.7926790714,
-0.1000891253,
-0.3154474795,
0.5077602863,
0.0088110073,
0.1137779951,
0.4647635818,
1.1473728418,
0.1174880564,
0.6429431438,
-0.4603178799,
-0.1784743518,
-0.3354403973,
-0.684974432,
-1.0094233751,
-0.5208646655,
-0.1287039369,
-0.1396950483,
-0.3255265057,
0.4545831978,
1.1370795965,
-0.6083244681,
-0.0721260682,
0.2195481956,
0.1123516932,
-0.1449924856,
-0.2149481028,
0.21767883,
-0.6127686501,
-0.7689936757,
0.7674739957,
0.7246188521,
0.1152412146,
-0.5581508279,
0.0866636857,
-0.2120034844,
-0.269330442,
1.021028161,
-0.0425927825,
-1.0478740931,
-0.0038978015,
0.128995955,
-0.0948713869,
0.2902388871,
1.0763225555,
-0.8636319041,
0.6495494843,
0.4858418703,
0.4893349111,
0.8264086246,
0.036962565,
0.5286060572,
-0.4685983956,
0.5550670028,
0.1114737764,
0.678106606,
0.2752136886,
-0.1073025316,
0.179412514,
0.2543604076,
-0.294555217,
-0.5502169728,
0.4944487512,
-1.4228330851,
-0.6227589846,
1.0335046053,
-0.1895143241,
-0.2051454335,
-0.2958578467,
-0.3874119222,
-0.1262165159,
-0.1935566515,
0.510887146,
0.6001091003,
-0.01180992,
-0.5681353807,
-0.4434528947,
0.3209999204,
0.5354766846,
-0.5639240742,
-0.3604620397,
0.86452353,
0.1253879666,
0.2423034459,
0.6719284058,
0.0125957364,
0.3027437627,
0.1515545398,
-0.1997458041,
-0.0818393603,
-0.5935089588,
-0.2241067588,
0.5619320273,
-0.0600675866,
-0.3796775639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12193v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12193v2
|
A Chinese Dataset for Evaluating the Safeguards in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T14:56:18 | 2024-05-26T17:15:44 |
Yuxia Wang, Zenan Zhai, Haonan Li, Xudong Han, Lizhi Lin, Zhenxuan Zhang, Jingru Zhao, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many studies have demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) can produce
harmful responses, exposing users to unexpected risks when LLMs are deployed.
Previous studies have proposed comprehensive taxonomies of the risks posed by
LLMs, as well as corresponding prompts that can be used to examine the safety
mechanisms of LLMs. However, the focus has been almost exclusively on English,
and little has been explored for other languages. Here we aim to bridge this
gap. We first introduce a dataset for the safety evaluation of Chinese LLMs,
and then extend it to two other scenarios that can be used to better identify
false negative and false positive examples in terms of risky prompt rejections.
We further present a set of fine-grained safety assessment criteria for each
risk type, facilitating both manual annotation and automatic evaluation in
terms of LLM response harmfulness. Our experiments on five LLMs show that
region-specific risks are the prevalent type of risk, presenting the major
issue with all Chinese LLMs we experimented with. Our data is available at
https://github.com/Libr-AI/do-not-answer. Warning: this paper contains example
data that may be offensive, harmful, or biased.
|
[
0.092137374,
-0.8548740149,
0.3763639033,
0.2386015803,
-0.0910760537,
-0.2973315418,
-0.217596665,
-0.6007569432,
-0.3463785946,
0.5602249503,
-0.3034424484,
-0.530436933,
-0.4650920331,
0.0181466155,
-0.4306998253,
1.0184178352,
-0.0132320812,
0.1178030223,
0.1843728423,
0.1665179729,
-0.6449419856,
-0.6444092989,
-0.8809009194,
-0.0886188969,
0.7504243255,
0.2464946061,
0.6775082946,
0.488877207,
0.6756024361,
0.1909764707,
-0.0957812667,
0.0279463902,
-0.3075668216,
-0.066133894,
-0.079416573,
-0.3586467505,
-0.4365037084,
-0.1005926952,
0.6208101511,
0.6362139583,
-0.0217884779,
0.1068159118,
0.156436488,
0.29878214,
-0.5761427283,
0.0922760442,
-0.7087293267,
0.1824348569,
-0.339091599,
-0.1476871818,
-0.6385112405,
-0.6570097208,
0.2478206158,
-0.2055625916,
-0.3844899833,
0.1895275414,
0.8008671999,
-0.118091397,
-0.6776328087,
-0.3060238063,
-0.5011395216,
0.8053456545,
-0.7254498601,
-0.101478532,
0.4804370105,
0.445707947,
-0.2864934206,
-0.2433886677,
-0.3949576914,
-0.4325506687,
-0.2013111264,
-0.015107153,
-0.0579606555,
0.1085197851,
0.2431910783,
0.2533430755,
-0.8416177034,
0.5923410654,
-0.2292974144,
-0.5681052208,
1.0219773054,
0.4848818183,
0.8501158357,
-0.2703352273,
-0.4454810917,
-0.2378622293,
-1.402741909,
0.1485093087,
0.4724606872,
0.6771888733,
-0.3215258718,
0.4271837175,
0.1743219942,
0.5190953612,
-0.45754686,
-0.2014405876,
0.2456299812,
-0.4516013265,
-0.1515289545,
0.100902088,
1.0643755198,
0.6455824971,
0.4416970909,
-0.0345625058,
-0.4055497646,
-0.2312769592,
-0.1264111251,
-0.7254400849,
0.0501633547,
0.3397192955,
-0.4080578089,
-0.3084490895,
0.1197591797,
-0.693236053,
-0.7107047439,
0.1982567161,
0.4126232862,
-0.2951368392,
-0.2151553929,
0.1587811708,
0.184753269,
0.5887750983,
0.0518868044,
-0.6595101357,
0.0097498,
0.6121073961,
0.6783201694,
-0.3042790592,
-0.2824334204,
-0.5828122497,
0.101600036,
-0.6559080482,
0.6148719192,
-0.175889194,
-0.563414216,
0.5075273514,
0.3187253773,
0.1820750386,
-0.5366016626,
0.9016973972,
-0.3389600813,
0.1263212562,
-0.4297892451,
-0.2086432427,
-0.2534994781,
0.360778749,
-0.677749157,
0.5828506947,
-0.2880850136,
-0.9197962284,
0.3006989956,
-0.2897992134,
-0.9009335637,
-0.017340295,
-0.1248910949,
-0.4712771475,
-0.3252747655,
-0.0847661123,
0.5724539757,
-0.4162668586,
0.3672882617,
-0.5390966535,
-0.2808259428,
0.3218517303,
-0.8581951261,
1.131611824,
0.348315537,
-0.0410171337,
0.3621569574,
-0.4776401222,
-0.0726838037,
0.3087681234,
-0.3057678342,
-0.628136754,
-0.0584916286,
0.1222188249,
0.4868209362,
0.3568359911,
-0.4561555088,
-0.1628288329,
-0.4124133885,
0.3778516948,
0.7678016424,
0.1310656667,
0.0881729722,
-0.4809580743,
0.3228105605,
0.135952875,
0.3657933772,
-0.2328937948,
-0.1923125684,
-0.5598651767,
0.1075403765,
0.0061778915,
0.8515383601,
-0.9474595785,
0.5923413038,
-0.1191883534,
-0.5854278803,
-0.0534303896,
-0.0211229138,
0.6482504606,
0.2652415335,
-0.0720156729,
0.0716516748,
-0.3214026392,
-0.9793637395,
-0.1104775891,
-0.5748304129,
-0.1148636565,
0.3821734488,
0.324236691,
-0.1383154094,
0.4461902976,
-0.4273529649,
-0.0693854839,
-0.213021338,
-0.166781798,
0.1430329084,
0.4623729289,
0.7741127014,
-0.6576659083,
-0.4162912667,
-0.0104108788,
-0.8541084528,
-0.1795503199,
-0.2757181525,
-0.1462519914,
0.300054431,
0.3769357204,
-0.5412893295,
0.139298752,
0.5892409086,
-0.1667049229,
0.6981945038,
0.0270634983,
-0.02677829,
-1.1385768652,
0.2420990765,
0.188074246,
0.0945060849,
-0.801254034,
0.1928605884,
0.1920291781,
0.0190783162,
-0.9327377081,
0.7187537551,
-0.2000323534,
0.1524351835,
-0.1197571158,
0.2121360451,
-0.1284355819,
0.0172188841,
0.1467088312,
0.7809824347,
0.6701958179,
-0.7817878127,
0.3398879766,
0.2532812655,
-0.5077155232,
0.1014078259,
-0.6929649711,
0.0321656317,
0.0529083088,
0.0672846735,
-0.7488781214,
-0.327380091,
0.3292703331,
-0.196601361,
0.2714871764,
0.0619998239,
-0.5577179193,
-0.4743926227,
-0.6799650788,
0.2276431918,
0.3522022665,
-0.5477272272,
0.0579434484,
0.6610029936,
-0.3781541884,
-0.8177372813,
-0.9258161187,
0.2244686633,
-0.7043495774,
-0.5375038981,
-0.1659008116,
-0.2036938518,
-0.4489579499,
-0.2193581462,
0.1563248038,
-0.1190904975,
0.6541563869,
0.2524531782,
0.5695198178,
-0.000737506,
0.1375346631,
-0.1081693098,
-0.0317125097,
0.3284897208,
0.1859068424,
0.4385532141,
-0.0405555144,
-0.3604687452,
-0.2378024906,
0.2340658903,
0.208389625,
-0.0729832426,
0.6802029014,
0.2566004395,
-0.7081862688,
-0.2539820671,
-0.1441258788,
-0.1168745458,
-0.5239701867,
0.5194048882,
-0.0352947377,
-0.7102441788,
0.5250743628,
0.319042474,
0.4616967738,
0.358889401,
0.6678603292,
0.094734095,
0.8730658889,
0.4797817767,
-0.6134594679,
0.2936083376,
0.2703805864,
0.3445630372,
-0.3045572639,
-0.135354653,
-0.6161757708,
0.2915482819,
-0.7465962172,
-0.1245954707,
0.4859960377,
-0.2597619891,
-0.4612539709,
0.3780932128,
-0.0218710098,
0.4243040383,
0.1782672107,
-0.1166123077,
0.2786954343,
-0.1517342478,
0.0129601769,
0.1306332946,
-0.5536382794,
-0.7970727682,
0.8240846992,
0.6338915825,
1.3244950771,
0.2986287177,
0.3927313387,
0.2616831064,
0.3956497312,
-0.813639164,
0.6335268617,
-0.2971319556,
-0.8259855509,
-0.4412476718,
-0.5702302456,
-0.9970811605,
0.0556650534,
-0.2121307254,
-0.6784874201,
-0.2914393544,
-0.0403568409,
-0.6519022584,
0.2274453491,
-0.6086493134,
0.5708651543,
-0.7115730643,
-0.1330565512,
0.1842480898,
-0.6150283813,
0.8489360213,
-0.5015023351,
0.2839207649,
-0.1391491592,
0.2012530863,
0.5388228893,
0.0422259755,
1.0186513662,
0.0300262738,
-0.6192015409,
0.4227488935,
0.2291020453,
0.3884384334,
0.0370066352,
-0.3690747023,
0.2054086626,
0.1439534575,
-0.203684479,
-0.196716249,
0.8287275434,
-0.6609532237,
-0.7805618644,
-0.4363479614,
-0.585533917,
-0.1882069409,
0.4504939318,
0.1769741327,
0.2071292996,
-0.2578908503,
0.111168988,
0.5728217959,
-1.0552750826,
0.5621228218,
0.7754724026,
-0.2718392909,
-0.0098478198,
0.9544588923,
0.2244710028,
0.3856099248,
0.230675593,
0.322386384,
-0.3666830659,
-0.6782613397,
-0.3766230941,
0.023530012,
-0.8195183277,
-0.1649606526,
-0.1880092472,
-0.564035058,
-0.3649638891,
0.119991079,
-0.0367813185,
0.0704796389,
-0.0419897437,
-0.4265607893,
0.0780030042,
0.6325053573,
-0.0032342318,
0.0432189293,
-1.0699665546,
-0.1144076213,
0.1506867707,
0.3528799415,
0.0836705193,
-0.4355572462,
-0.2539387941,
-0.0583987609,
-0.1354281008,
-0.5688439012,
0.4211402237,
-0.082767278,
0.9117330909,
0.588993907,
0.6638802886,
0.2199287117,
-0.6195102334,
0.9883497357,
-0.0065978221,
-0.6441763639,
0.4316032827,
-0.5290825963,
-0.1915553212,
0.3592885733,
0.5937831402,
-0.819190383,
-0.1638306826,
-0.1385624111,
-0.9539767504,
0.4607687891,
-0.1156560704,
0.4847393036,
-0.2156840861,
0.2237559259,
0.1347803473,
-0.1241079718,
-1.0087985992,
-0.3394271135,
0.2946725488,
-0.0545834042,
-0.1147510856,
-0.4187909961,
-0.3548923135,
0.3535874486,
0.7859734297,
-0.0820649713,
-0.1660655439,
-0.0008221983,
-0.1169366762,
-0.1930744946,
0.4237397611,
0.4705356359,
0.1691419184,
-0.0012038901,
0.2869008183,
0.4577574432,
-0.3973686397,
0.2172813267,
-0.0116848592,
-0.3414840698,
-0.3886399567,
0.6598724127,
0.5288337469,
-0.1879166216,
-0.9346697927,
0.5349805951,
-0.1156385168,
0.0980639458,
-0.5054031014,
0.0336018726,
-0.1321690828,
-0.254804939,
0.1181641594,
-0.5172476768,
0.1863610297,
-0.5330531001,
0.3007979691,
0.5642313957,
-0.3391157687,
-0.3408932984,
0.3307929635,
0.4590770602,
-0.1129411459,
0.3223109841,
-0.0292523094,
-0.4996929467,
0.6287931204,
0.4023576379,
0.855035603,
-0.2534959614,
0.0727334321,
0.3856404424,
0.758736372,
0.0804851204,
0.3697147965,
0.710237205,
-0.858848989,
-0.2085459977,
-0.3012063205,
-0.4549620748,
0.5991345048,
-0.5171324611,
0.3577787578,
-0.6785223484,
-0.0759379864,
-0.3316338658,
0.0267989803,
-0.1858409196,
0.0906464979,
0.637933135,
1.0111368895,
-1.1977971792,
0.766857028,
0.5228744149,
-0.3094098568,
-0.8943522573,
0.311257273,
0.2321359813,
-0.8361731172,
0.5068173409,
0.363186866,
-0.0653328225,
-0.6492142081,
-0.4066338539,
-0.6346114278,
0.9521721601,
0.454483211,
-0.8288117051,
0.1453656703,
0.4668472707,
0.4627321661,
0.0854624063,
0.1058956161,
0.6623927951,
0.4859704077,
-0.3117190599,
-1.0340105295,
0.2720299661,
-0.093759127,
-0.0452718846,
-0.134443149,
-0.9547455907,
0.8969265223,
-0.2273868471,
-0.5180916786,
0.2222172469,
0.2654753327,
0.4154131413,
0.3106869757,
0.578027606,
0.0656381473,
0.6737334132,
-0.0966444165,
1.3083986044,
-0.3489266336,
0.1300543249,
0.9383544922,
-0.5497438908,
0.7897337675,
0.1678194702,
-0.1221012622,
-0.0234624296,
0.8781235814,
0.0669931695,
0.2929235995,
0.3596985638,
-0.2069768012,
-0.2732725739,
-0.487581104,
-0.2052381635,
0.2803201377,
0.4142107069,
-0.2659567893,
-0.2307255119,
-0.0585298091,
0.2296037972,
-0.0446123332,
-0.3659119904,
0.5643012524,
0.3650837541,
-0.482327491,
0.4118999541,
0.0032468142,
0.7455480099,
-0.5757271051,
0.0298465397,
-0.3136683404,
0.0551487356,
-0.2471520454,
-1.2214739323,
0.2579075396,
0.15116027,
0.1696866304,
0.1843586415,
0.7761191726,
-0.432919234,
-0.3600574136,
0.4517337084,
0.323220402,
0.1680570096,
0.3108999729,
-0.6173967123,
0.0750251114,
-0.124238193,
-0.3215752542,
0.4592094719,
0.3821998835,
-0.631984055,
1.0247683525,
0.5094611645,
0.0969053358,
-0.1538502425,
0.1985434592,
0.743535161,
-0.6224036813,
-0.3143137693,
-1.0023020506,
0.2155434191,
0.1294780821,
-0.1308299899,
0.9874066114,
0.3377023935,
0.6149182916,
0.0845635533,
1.0942523479,
0.0832626671,
0.3195446134,
-0.6924940348,
1.0760083199,
-0.4057353735,
0.5263182521,
-0.3907653093,
-0.5820007324,
-0.6145444512,
0.3011241555,
-0.4949368834,
-0.0472867303,
0.400747329,
0.8537438512,
0.5121344924,
-0.167381376,
0.6193332076,
0.4086442888,
0.6878972054,
0.8413866758,
1.1479978561,
-0.3187226355,
0.6376752257,
-0.2548673153,
-0.0457756072,
-0.0783748254,
-1.1416649818,
-1.100726366,
-0.3577745259,
-0.1139809564,
-0.3921420872,
0.0467278287,
0.9594838619,
0.4565830827,
-1.1015117168,
-0.2269165665,
0.4959447682,
0.1613032222,
0.2891274691,
-0.1720245928,
0.5809338689,
-0.118264921,
-0.6890603304,
0.2738856673,
0.1250503212,
0.3230361938,
-0.4043878019,
-0.0199664757,
0.1836840212,
0.1054702848,
0.6497576833,
0.3059469759,
-0.6124019027,
-0.7968539,
-0.1186246127,
-0.5028405786,
-0.4162187874,
0.3850661218,
-0.0337251946,
0.0222412664,
0.532538414,
0.8130562305,
-0.4392359555,
-0.3253308237,
0.6863108873,
-0.5387829542,
0.2642341852,
0.1287266165,
0.6741674542,
0.4464990199,
-0.648416996,
0.4201889038,
-0.1736191064,
-0.4600718915,
-0.8965195417,
0.2929167449,
-0.8601022363,
-0.263720274,
1.5281457901,
-0.549723208,
-0.1538787186,
-0.2090313733,
-0.378157407,
0.1001028642,
-0.1982729435,
0.879978478,
0.821731925,
0.26537624,
0.0234245323,
-0.6915262341,
0.5276244283,
0.2407077849,
-0.9583778381,
0.5604666471,
0.4660551846,
0.4957207143,
-0.0262825824,
0.2266836166,
-0.2917428017,
0.3129385412,
-0.2401838005,
-0.0867657587,
0.0707118511,
-0.35637784,
-0.6238101721,
-0.1826903969,
0.4335646033,
0.0469950475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14846v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14846v3
|
Stick to Your Role! Context-dependence and Stability of Personal Value Expression in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T14:53:01 | 2024-04-30T07:09:22 |
Grgur Kovač, Rémy Portelas, Masataka Sawayama, Peter Ford Dominey, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T07, I.2.7
|
The standard way to study Large Language Models (LLMs) with benchmarks or
psychology questionnaires is to provide many different queries from similar
minimal contexts (e.g. multiple choice questions). However, due to LLMs' highly
context-dependent nature, conclusions from such minimal-context evaluations may
be little informative about the model's behavior in deployment (where it will
be exposed to many new contexts). We argue that context-dependence
(specifically, value stability) should be studied a specific property of LLMs
and used as another dimension of LLM comparison (alongside others such as
cognitive abilities, knowledge, or model size). We present a case-study on the
stability of value expression over different contexts (simulated conversations
on different topics) as measured using a standard psychology questionnaire
(PVQ) and on behavioral downstream tasks. Reusing methods from psychology, we
study Rank-order stability on the population (interpersonal) level, and
Ipsative stability on the individual (intrapersonal) level. We consider two
settings (with and without instructing LLMs to simulate particular personas),
two simulated populations, and three downstream tasks. We observe consistent
trends in the stability of models and model families - Mixtral, Mistral,
GPT-3.5 and Qwen families are more stable than LLaMa-2 and Phi. The consistency
of these trends implies that some models exhibit higher value-stability than
others, and that value stability can be estimated with the set of introduced
methodological tools. When instructed to simulate particular personas, LLMs
exhibit low Rank-Order stability, which further diminishes with conversation
length. This highlights the need for future research on LLMs that coherently
simulate different personas. This paper provides a foundational step in that
direction, and, to our knowledge, it is the first study of value stability in
LLMs.
|
[
-0.5671634078,
-0.730253458,
0.4882793427,
0.384765178,
0.1200484484,
-0.0531694889,
-0.2344692647,
-0.3307019472,
0.1643199325,
0.5982906818,
-0.2940123677,
-0.0867507905,
-0.7022746205,
0.0105601633,
-0.0921927691,
0.8567273021,
0.3219340146,
0.0183876008,
-0.693212688,
-0.5085486174,
-0.6445152164,
-1.1093502045,
-0.671675384,
-0.1794832051,
0.6584993601,
0.2394281179,
0.5216646194,
0.249429822,
0.3784337342,
0.3027094007,
-0.2598842084,
-0.3284328878,
-0.8538262248,
0.6092429161,
-0.092545934,
-0.3442450166,
-0.4202737212,
0.1779689938,
0.5503268242,
0.7735797763,
-0.2557241917,
0.1482324153,
0.1333950162,
0.3291894794,
-0.6425343752,
0.1819157004,
-0.5766268373,
-0.5103103518,
-0.1299115568,
-0.1582233459,
-0.4538737833,
-0.1067680568,
0.2968925238,
0.0061938693,
-0.3466824889,
-0.1652525216,
0.8416454792,
0.1565645039,
-0.6761797071,
0.0002985568,
-0.7092276216,
0.8210622072,
-0.4953641295,
0.1669303179,
0.5065623522,
0.2575156987,
-0.1628344357,
-0.4667553306,
-0.398681134,
-0.3448007703,
-0.1275763661,
0.1947489232,
0.1631786972,
0.0150858462,
0.2363056839,
0.0699770078,
0.1818719804,
0.357270956,
-0.4154279828,
0.0010626393,
0.5551314354,
0.3234933019,
0.0557455719,
-0.0595644638,
-0.3067705035,
-0.1636792123,
-1.0594900846,
0.409170121,
0.0214242674,
0.1568105668,
-0.0472790822,
0.5878435373,
-0.1088083014,
0.1982093006,
0.3591754735,
-0.5398953557,
-0.1506999135,
-0.0273260623,
0.0126693575,
-0.0319603346,
0.5266827941,
0.4927127063,
0.2098400444,
0.0486253127,
-0.115325883,
-0.065365538,
0.3406572342,
-0.9028673172,
0.2164644748,
0.1591943204,
-0.4709720314,
-0.1989475787,
-0.1218859553,
-0.5114821792,
-0.397206068,
-0.0954754204,
0.3100952208,
-0.0329407416,
-0.2100514472,
-0.3415310085,
0.4462925494,
0.3154299855,
0.4749491513,
-1.1291598082,
0.5524563193,
0.5496115685,
0.7419920564,
-0.3371396065,
-0.509973228,
-0.8560724854,
0.0512560606,
-0.2290160358,
0.5403841734,
-0.4305861294,
-0.5917121768,
0.0347896442,
0.0508918464,
-0.1152097434,
-0.6552985907,
0.2719022632,
-0.5387899876,
0.2866288126,
-0.5628491044,
-0.5458088517,
0.1988894343,
0.3000115752,
-0.4461984038,
0.8681021333,
0.188402459,
-0.6338444352,
0.4343818426,
-0.4959536195,
-0.2848824859,
-0.0503788404,
-0.4622960687,
-0.1493900269,
0.1963819712,
-0.3275951743,
0.4992713034,
-0.2756473422,
0.1308443397,
-0.5671904087,
-0.3737802804,
0.518142283,
-0.3322637975,
0.8033310771,
-0.1264431924,
-0.1739810556,
0.0663771257,
-0.5265173912,
-0.0188593864,
-0.1364964992,
-0.4907531738,
-0.4178286493,
0.3004469573,
-0.1159514636,
0.6898297668,
0.1176729575,
-0.4902707338,
0.1889868379,
-0.223045364,
0.3524824083,
0.8494645953,
0.305588007,
0.2666468322,
-0.3571859002,
0.6191704869,
0.0978289917,
-0.1238530129,
0.0057987398,
-0.4920702279,
-0.5397574902,
-0.1898424923,
0.1525404453,
0.4499346018,
0.006398336,
0.2267739326,
-0.4088070393,
-0.128542468,
-0.2719615996,
-0.0469435304,
0.2742855847,
0.4996879697,
0.108585231,
-0.2584843338,
-0.2478988469,
-0.9086005092,
0.0080949711,
-0.4301879704,
0.0495109558,
0.2497868091,
0.5617986321,
-0.2708628476,
1.2097429037,
-0.3365730345,
-0.135424912,
-0.2514306903,
0.0814353451,
-0.0946774185,
0.3428638875,
0.5429638624,
-0.8143900633,
-0.3932400346,
-0.2019139379,
-0.5047898889,
-0.2394023985,
-0.0107456334,
-0.1499042958,
0.4662826955,
0.3533382118,
-0.4797784984,
0.2265606374,
0.9661104083,
-0.5210937262,
0.441123575,
-0.1216087639,
-0.0267528836,
-1.1500880718,
0.1521458328,
0.0631655827,
-0.2625769377,
-0.7389442325,
-0.1620477587,
-0.084364526,
0.1425658166,
-0.2773988545,
0.6241948605,
-0.0768930316,
-0.1218128726,
-0.2425296307,
-0.0335431956,
-0.1002637073,
0.1934625506,
0.173428759,
0.8987932801,
0.3003520072,
-0.7179845572,
-0.0863942578,
0.4222698212,
-0.1814865619,
0.7007785439,
-0.747040391,
0.1119014621,
0.0317061916,
0.0943094194,
-0.8475795984,
-0.2810462117,
0.1476950198,
-0.1859891862,
0.1791529059,
-0.2211775035,
-0.4690049589,
0.3189950287,
-0.0292328764,
0.241335094,
0.7007784843,
-0.370329231,
0.3768596351,
0.7273752689,
-0.358687073,
-0.3982293308,
-0.4999746978,
-0.008658356,
-0.4733704925,
-0.7487280369,
0.3697907031,
-0.2467412502,
-0.7483703494,
-0.1966495365,
-0.2828573287,
-0.3365720809,
0.2747420073,
0.5759158731,
0.1583480239,
0.0418377817,
0.119218111,
0.1150015369,
-0.0497250706,
0.1629492939,
0.2697426081,
0.3843283057,
-0.4117117822,
-0.1235214472,
0.0530021936,
0.3244862854,
0.8284003139,
-0.1638432592,
1.1141443253,
0.140201509,
-0.1698645949,
0.1744677871,
-0.6352263689,
-0.2105098069,
-0.4927904308,
0.1928570867,
-0.4916702807,
-1.2263590097,
0.7695348859,
-0.1268547922,
0.0341538973,
0.2136432678,
0.7564609647,
-0.3321611285,
0.9184390903,
0.8147994876,
0.0680161566,
0.2565816343,
0.0999495164,
0.1383664459,
-0.8855968118,
-0.0854945779,
-0.1469287872,
-0.1740438342,
-0.6487457156,
-0.1918033212,
0.6028836966,
0.1558214724,
-0.2709007859,
-0.1555507779,
-0.0447256491,
0.2741158605,
0.1579774469,
-0.1870261133,
0.2552826703,
-0.3154926896,
0.1886934191,
-0.1483374238,
-0.4868371785,
-0.7057511806,
0.8374792933,
0.3444013298,
0.7564550638,
0.2561733723,
0.603643477,
0.0902990401,
0.558288157,
-0.6942085624,
0.6330628991,
-0.0129516404,
-0.5912709236,
-0.4441336691,
-0.3592064977,
-1.0193059444,
0.4378048778,
-0.058231324,
-1.0209723711,
0.2432095557,
0.1441188604,
-0.3657717407,
-0.3859196007,
-0.4960858822,
1.0445781946,
-0.4165407121,
-0.5415430665,
-0.0917172879,
-0.7684744,
0.3516388237,
-0.00685876,
0.0595278591,
-0.3047019839,
-0.1676756591,
0.4912805259,
-0.4442408979,
0.9776818752,
-0.0699186847,
-0.312945962,
0.1195431352,
0.0905517489,
0.2185655385,
0.2788845003,
-0.2294755727,
0.0048285229,
0.542994976,
-0.3158453405,
-0.6230224371,
0.8852057457,
-0.8196473718,
-0.8895927668,
-0.5330529809,
-0.3619477451,
-0.2779532075,
0.2770667374,
0.2257521898,
0.3040133417,
-0.4051977098,
0.5789330602,
0.7043001056,
-0.0758041665,
0.356546104,
0.3179715872,
-0.3759849668,
-0.292647779,
0.5073751211,
0.5341132879,
0.751543045,
0.2602673471,
0.2817656696,
-0.1695883721,
-0.1854702085,
-0.0808751956,
0.0831006542,
-0.7439087629,
0.1071803644,
-0.3080738485,
-0.0803080499,
-0.2482239604,
-0.132935822,
-0.4780338705,
-0.1928311437,
0.0520512797,
0.066373311,
0.1259014755,
0.6153450608,
0.3711515963,
0.1667385995,
-0.5424100161,
0.0349321291,
0.4339258075,
0.3068547547,
-0.3206131756,
-0.3547941148,
-0.3388750553,
-0.0963306203,
-0.2620029449,
-0.9061783552,
0.2615863681,
0.1155717745,
0.6390024424,
0.5207762122,
0.2068186253,
0.5893957019,
-0.1352718174,
0.9236814976,
-0.0873969495,
-1.1610945463,
0.262111187,
-0.6523337364,
0.2775163352,
0.7617448568,
0.1720383167,
-0.8986528516,
-0.2615287006,
-0.5077614188,
-0.8349294066,
0.7266501784,
0.1723647565,
0.3398418128,
-0.0906775519,
0.5774295926,
-0.0804193914,
0.3947511613,
-0.9208720326,
-0.2397012413,
-0.121992141,
0.0992607921,
0.1123454124,
-0.5436633229,
-0.4027022719,
-0.3576177657,
0.3299757838,
-0.2844060659,
0.3014138937,
-0.0651161373,
-0.0044170064,
0.0813865736,
0.073185131,
0.6823813915,
0.9400594831,
-0.2903222442,
0.1895672381,
0.4606044292,
-0.2728838623,
0.2976936102,
-0.4044419527,
-0.0776768029,
-0.3878332376,
0.0751986727,
0.6498816013,
0.6051874757,
-0.8255288601,
0.6810210943,
-0.0604230762,
0.0174219925,
-0.5715681911,
-0.0066062226,
0.3780430555,
0.0348940454,
-0.0133858696,
-0.0753683001,
-0.362552166,
-0.8509070277,
0.0328016542,
0.4708971679,
-0.0947655439,
-0.2346473336,
0.6424619555,
0.1832027137,
-0.128191039,
0.5982425213,
-0.1641659737,
-0.2509397864,
0.4782418609,
0.61269629,
0.8478126526,
-0.1990665346,
0.1234785318,
-0.077501975,
0.0901718065,
-0.275524348,
0.1402616352,
0.1167825758,
-0.8793621063,
-0.2821525633,
-0.4846873581,
-0.6506897211,
0.2128952444,
-0.7730081081,
0.2089586705,
-0.6475521326,
-0.3613836467,
-0.5131438971,
0.0175767019,
-0.2824360132,
0.0778383762,
0.1171485186,
0.4845128357,
-0.6390542984,
1.0668222904,
0.6241444349,
-0.2425204068,
-0.460390836,
0.4616845846,
-0.0513557829,
-0.3951660991,
0.9936999083,
0.3127609193,
-0.3944449723,
-0.154263109,
-0.3515514433,
-1.2271677256,
1.2952210903,
0.5213050842,
-0.2685878277,
0.1402457803,
-0.0572502129,
0.7382198572,
-0.7519613504,
0.1036298275,
0.4980047643,
0.436065346,
0.1187284663,
-0.9102156758,
0.0343707465,
-0.1676232815,
0.2751325071,
-0.0127172638,
-1.1107302904,
0.8238060474,
0.0590889119,
-0.0799323171,
0.2129449546,
0.3901158869,
0.4457565546,
0.0540366396,
0.4605049491,
0.2211846262,
0.6325314641,
0.0048934687,
1.0615081787,
-0.6809362173,
0.3348607123,
0.9864010215,
-0.4457681775,
1.0831893682,
0.6084580421,
0.0283955224,
0.4251586199,
0.546682179,
-0.0409133174,
0.2709777057,
0.1595716625,
-0.2358327061,
-0.2783810794,
0.1415567398,
-0.1284829974,
0.6052896976,
0.3583730757,
-0.3280179203,
0.2083907574,
-0.1804671735,
0.2199542373,
-0.1494222432,
-0.0353353284,
0.5038427114,
0.2276333272,
-0.7484010458,
0.6139008999,
0.0021994878,
0.3463236988,
-0.7464346886,
0.2652384639,
-0.1987924129,
0.0810921937,
-0.1487320513,
-0.5887330174,
0.2709869146,
-0.0893295109,
-0.2616483867,
-0.626152873,
0.5534822941,
-0.3161495626,
-0.2956123948,
0.4429750741,
0.6458534002,
0.0845103487,
0.1462920755,
-0.2908070683,
0.3312393725,
-0.528998971,
-0.5977534056,
0.8664270639,
0.2313888967,
-0.2093051523,
0.6775823832,
0.1622066796,
0.0287234634,
0.1647061557,
-0.0670430809,
0.7232052684,
-0.5560288429,
-0.2916142046,
-0.8774655461,
0.6542444825,
-0.1143364161,
-0.7085969448,
0.9631344676,
0.2818899155,
0.806109488,
0.1856851578,
0.7557594776,
-0.1858713627,
0.0821270049,
-0.4266222715,
0.7226271033,
-0.3834027052,
0.5589173436,
-0.259200722,
-0.9289206266,
-0.0972214118,
0.5891162753,
-0.5381555557,
0.1980378479,
0.6095045805,
0.5629066229,
0.2232473642,
-0.3159368038,
0.4804677963,
0.3752887547,
0.5409439802,
0.1086212024,
0.8362523913,
0.1300641149,
0.2936383486,
-0.4221772552,
-0.1982235461,
-0.3270971775,
-0.8747320771,
-0.8525387645,
-0.6124136448,
-0.4365612864,
-0.3939706087,
-0.0473491475,
1.0354624987,
0.8526137471,
-0.4917250872,
-0.6430808902,
0.0045027365,
0.0050059855,
-0.3206599355,
-0.226760745,
0.0366638042,
-0.3903182447,
-0.630515039,
0.3295557797,
0.4778496921,
-0.0869688019,
-0.4973598123,
-0.1752825379,
0.0308323503,
0.2060701102,
0.8740186691,
0.4120018184,
-0.737852931,
-0.5152176619,
-0.0273155496,
-0.1131144166,
0.3038852513,
0.7136372328,
-0.6965759993,
0.2931396961,
0.3569538891,
0.5894160271,
0.4030244648,
0.319504112,
0.6756090522,
-0.6286939383,
-0.1083737537,
0.1620113999,
0.3415464163,
0.1605539322,
-0.417299062,
0.2653183639,
0.2593586445,
-0.8451849818,
-0.7864505649,
0.5489574671,
-1.0437514782,
-0.033088129,
1.2970173359,
-0.2165670097,
0.0713523924,
0.0074943053,
-0.2245380431,
-0.1598488092,
-0.445753932,
1.0481641293,
0.8320258856,
-0.6599498391,
-0.4113362432,
-0.507281363,
0.3853786886,
0.496211946,
-0.7179573178,
0.1242144555,
0.50060606,
0.435887605,
0.2117307633,
0.8011269569,
-0.0520224273,
-0.0877955481,
-0.1252622902,
-0.389629811,
0.2213170677,
-0.2284029126,
-0.4839740992,
0.4256293774,
0.468046546,
0.056193918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12189v1
|
Amplifying Training Data Exposure through Fine-Tuning with Pseudo-Labeled Memberships
| 2024-02-19T14:52:50 | 2024-02-19T14:52:50 |
Myung Gyo Oh, Hong Eun Ahn, Leo Hyun Park, Taekyoung Kwon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, I.2.7; K.6.5
|
Neural language models (LMs) are vulnerable to training data extraction
attacks due to data memorization. This paper introduces a novel attack scenario
wherein an attacker adversarially fine-tunes pre-trained LMs to amplify the
exposure of the original training data. This strategy differs from prior
studies by aiming to intensify the LM's retention of its pre-training dataset.
To achieve this, the attacker needs to collect generated texts that are closely
aligned with the pre-training data. However, without knowledge of the actual
dataset, quantifying the amount of pre-training data within generated texts is
challenging. To address this, we propose the use of pseudo-labels for these
generated texts, leveraging membership approximations indicated by
machine-generated probabilities from the target LM. We subsequently fine-tune
the LM to favor generations with higher likelihoods of originating from the
pre-training data, based on their membership probabilities. Our empirical
findings indicate a remarkable outcome: LMs with over 1B parameters exhibit a
four to eight-fold increase in training data exposure. We discuss potential
mitigations and suggest future research directions.
|
[
-0.3741704524,
-0.6762129068,
0.1680786312,
-0.4785676003,
-0.3591986299,
-0.0380864404,
-0.2460439801,
-0.4282951653,
0.0826536641,
0.4647961557,
-0.5078402758,
-0.1932053119,
-0.6326648593,
-0.1736879051,
-0.4658085704,
1.2373126745,
0.5244185925,
-0.1697509736,
-0.038203802,
-0.0263969209,
-0.3680185378,
-0.9834495187,
-0.4067595005,
-0.1899061799,
0.7288705707,
0.2346712202,
0.8611229062,
0.7269006968,
0.1955474168,
0.3094390929,
0.0869625434,
0.1492192596,
-0.7704438567,
-0.0684606731,
0.0492631383,
-0.8285956383,
-0.366214633,
0.0687564686,
0.7790186405,
0.6731355786,
0.1647671163,
0.083993651,
0.0229838621,
0.5821081996,
-0.6310904026,
-0.2876088619,
-1.2628535032,
0.0385840572,
-0.3828479052,
-0.4915200174,
-0.5001227856,
-0.149906382,
0.1139525026,
-0.3914194107,
0.20160833,
-0.0705419257,
0.9255384207,
0.2152517736,
0.0182585791,
-0.2494596988,
-0.7302548289,
0.6159023643,
-0.7962824106,
0.2755872309,
0.5961753726,
0.1650732756,
-0.3158175647,
-0.7933430076,
-0.4979918301,
-0.1554850936,
-0.189991191,
-0.1600574255,
-0.1499504596,
0.0769117102,
0.2830123007,
0.4459865987,
-0.4604069591,
0.4172079265,
-0.4562334418,
-0.2894208431,
0.5254943371,
0.0577765927,
0.5009436607,
0.1759046465,
-0.2178279161,
-0.147599265,
-0.9135395885,
-0.0961797237,
0.8053112626,
0.4889821708,
0.0728784278,
0.5656517148,
0.0964940414,
1.002065897,
0.019370148,
0.2120356411,
0.1338014156,
-0.3660836518,
-0.2677360475,
0.2736097872,
0.8200386763,
0.1151065677,
0.4562997818,
-0.3293098509,
-0.2611839771,
-0.0322704241,
0.5929229259,
-0.8933321834,
-0.6722791195,
-0.0348463729,
-0.3312671185,
-0.595053196,
0.0067715305,
-0.7194700241,
-0.3017728627,
-0.2530892491,
0.6893675923,
-0.3965234458,
-0.1309154183,
-0.0404669307,
-0.0311680418,
-0.0578968152,
-0.3037470281,
-0.8991299868,
-0.0301246867,
0.4430224895,
0.6167892218,
0.2086492777,
-0.1078064218,
-0.3572732508,
0.0391268432,
-0.439236939,
0.3132936954,
-0.4733170867,
-0.2626657188,
-0.0543395467,
-0.2712497115,
-0.1790956855,
-0.5701819062,
0.2940620482,
-0.8610157967,
0.1624818295,
0.107974723,
-0.6798231602,
0.363014698,
0.3396199942,
-0.6189979911,
0.8460624814,
0.1483556926,
-0.7707905769,
0.2766424417,
-0.3053379953,
-0.3194560111,
-0.0290273,
-0.0528907552,
-0.8300810456,
0.2442984134,
0.1354030371,
0.3729984164,
0.1145669892,
0.003560713,
-0.3769055903,
-0.2985703647,
0.6505990624,
-0.5193616152,
0.6082464457,
0.2202923894,
-0.1528766602,
0.1185297593,
-1.039509058,
0.3478736579,
0.1043924615,
-0.2524931431,
-0.7244461775,
0.0480159633,
-0.4663056135,
0.3270106316,
0.1358302236,
-0.1974900663,
0.1932425946,
-0.9417882562,
0.2561148107,
0.7411516309,
0.2563691735,
0.5047578812,
-0.1782243699,
0.4426716566,
-0.1075821817,
0.1155718267,
-0.2201831788,
-0.0888215303,
-0.6959649324,
-0.3631114364,
0.5731917024,
0.2027981132,
-0.952655673,
0.6240686178,
-0.3434361219,
-0.7774469852,
-0.5761154294,
0.2611191571,
0.5199406743,
0.5960614681,
0.5368322134,
-0.073927179,
-0.7182281017,
-0.9203901887,
-0.5584088564,
-0.1743859053,
-0.2226075828,
0.3050787747,
0.1539472044,
-0.1370184571,
0.9783434272,
-0.5834361315,
-0.3762742281,
-0.2126526684,
0.1332436651,
0.1733024716,
0.5734806061,
0.7333550453,
-0.6332649589,
-0.3445989788,
-0.1994659752,
-0.4921532273,
-0.0388736799,
-0.4471207857,
-0.0207387097,
-0.2701299489,
0.700078249,
-0.219694823,
0.4462773502,
0.4296640158,
-0.0614904389,
0.4531129897,
-0.221549809,
-0.3403292,
-1.0612344742,
-0.0265280996,
-0.129350543,
-0.1174589321,
-0.9957395792,
0.0539943613,
0.1522020847,
-0.0994111672,
-0.4541249573,
0.2226220965,
-0.5651097298,
0.1596071422,
-0.3996755779,
-0.1750499457,
-0.3146010935,
0.3517467976,
-0.1536660641,
0.8265866041,
0.6164153218,
-0.7452967167,
-0.0640591756,
0.1325169653,
-0.3540453017,
0.1119731516,
-0.5480772257,
0.4775229096,
-0.0578370355,
0.1062280759,
-0.7676312327,
-0.0979407057,
0.2797749937,
-0.6712799072,
0.6565957069,
-0.363827616,
-0.4750803411,
-0.2415329665,
-0.2119089216,
0.4310525358,
0.3592536747,
-0.5448385477,
0.2441579401,
0.5359200239,
0.1298751384,
-0.6044823527,
-0.6818296909,
0.3396944702,
-0.4695726931,
-0.1331876069,
0.3004894555,
-0.0204405487,
0.1862357408,
-0.2251064926,
-0.0507204905,
0.0298419893,
0.4504256248,
0.1171488985,
0.1984814256,
-0.201422438,
-0.0074287597,
-0.1393180192,
-0.0786957964,
0.2466449291,
-0.4139248133,
0.6485255957,
0.0592526644,
-0.1101815552,
-0.3275416493,
0.0036495661,
0.2384999394,
-0.3090215325,
1.1250427961,
0.3070608377,
-0.4457232058,
-0.5105175972,
-0.0024723331,
-0.485375762,
-0.5539950728,
0.7363961339,
-0.3751940727,
-0.572034657,
0.343198508,
-0.0895121247,
-0.0040630694,
0.204436034,
0.5049937963,
-0.3423339128,
0.9988910556,
0.5121771693,
-0.3766763508,
0.6852376461,
-0.2563817203,
0.2528275847,
-0.5510545969,
-0.1628454328,
-0.5813812613,
-0.5535235405,
-0.3681224585,
-0.1151246652,
0.1415136755,
0.4115155339,
0.1831176579,
0.5906231403,
-0.4881766438,
0.5598906279,
0.4452981651,
0.2064654231,
-0.2586121559,
0.0549961738,
0.0823747292,
-0.1294887811,
-0.9000450969,
-0.3498716056,
1.3471277952,
0.3990021944,
0.5539281368,
0.0984123126,
0.7786529064,
0.2330136001,
0.43487674,
-0.6316618323,
0.4864330888,
-0.0473019965,
-0.6358370185,
-0.1470122486,
-0.7373366356,
-1.0708822012,
-0.00353767,
-0.4336901903,
-0.8175542355,
0.3251330554,
0.4656305313,
-0.2676385045,
0.3030641377,
-0.716653049,
0.7663362026,
-0.3780502677,
-0.1484592557,
0.0675620884,
-0.8359158635,
0.389187485,
-0.5261808634,
0.1897221357,
0.2835993171,
0.2337513864,
0.8318737149,
-0.5539607406,
1.0322271585,
-0.2622558475,
-0.064809531,
0.219282642,
-0.0391306654,
0.6150401235,
-0.1376703829,
-0.05970864,
0.0976507217,
-0.2405958772,
-0.2748305798,
-0.5991931558,
0.6014221907,
-0.8681542277,
-0.4911482036,
-0.2533869147,
-0.4635193944,
-0.5022149086,
0.3409259915,
0.4539301693,
0.4185965955,
-0.1344374567,
0.3589699864,
0.6254355311,
-0.184224844,
0.4371276498,
0.323471725,
0.0910224319,
-0.50919801,
1.4584304094,
0.2800507843,
0.6530815959,
0.1365672797,
0.0822588056,
-0.292342484,
-0.9906083941,
-0.3503987193,
-0.0604144782,
-0.519698143,
-0.3653960824,
-0.5651122332,
-0.3753164709,
-0.1405367106,
0.2373382449,
-0.2912911773,
-0.3338279426,
-0.710346818,
-0.2333418131,
0.0693723932,
0.1601897031,
0.0984660834,
0.9170597792,
-0.8913936019,
0.3601463437,
0.1694556177,
0.2733072937,
-0.148199901,
-0.8014051318,
-0.4853919446,
0.2358850539,
-0.1043860838,
-1.108836174,
0.420599103,
0.6221318841,
0.5563449264,
0.5460572839,
0.1637124866,
0.784806788,
-0.5474067926,
0.5783317685,
0.156657964,
-0.5514461398,
0.4505885839,
-0.3027358353,
0.0697450936,
0.7809284329,
0.3437508941,
-0.0572981983,
-0.4846697152,
-0.7915039659,
-0.9728145003,
0.9873700738,
0.3487021327,
0.5635012388,
0.0404889099,
0.5934712291,
-0.2110786736,
0.1715050042,
-0.7632462382,
-0.670173347,
-0.3670764565,
-0.3390386999,
-0.1208731979,
-0.305634737,
-0.040181499,
-0.1893983632,
0.6777836084,
-0.0402730405,
-0.0538522303,
-0.1349390894,
-0.3418801129,
0.0807285681,
0.1064793617,
0.5012296438,
0.4844082892,
-0.1362103075,
0.3696838617,
-0.003871134,
-0.5586900711,
0.0878889635,
0.1877685338,
-0.4016987979,
0.0561218336,
0.4078529477,
0.8330518007,
0.1506134868,
-0.4120479226,
0.2937392592,
-0.1149752215,
-0.1076403856,
-0.1133817732,
0.2919676304,
0.0523080453,
-0.1648966819,
0.4122428,
0.2817459404,
-0.131515637,
-0.5482376218,
0.7043722868,
0.5466911793,
-0.5648286939,
-0.5230028629,
0.6152164936,
-0.1299164593,
-0.4694300592,
0.4366521239,
0.2130303979,
-0.7049644589,
0.5056301951,
0.7188270092,
0.5497596264,
-0.4844837785,
-0.0760351345,
0.4072234333,
0.556764245,
0.2121618688,
-0.2484989017,
0.0372687653,
-0.7533190846,
-0.055548586,
-0.6831073761,
0.1785670966,
0.6170012951,
-0.7348845005,
0.1743178666,
-0.5934296846,
-0.2587130368,
0.2102340907,
-0.3049547672,
-0.3824416995,
0.6196483374,
0.2277171016,
0.5034463406,
-0.8403930068,
1.1740427017,
0.398303479,
-0.2785987556,
-0.7967326641,
0.1013253704,
-0.2063087672,
-0.6938999295,
0.396697998,
0.0462761894,
0.2119198292,
0.1962761134,
-0.3332501352,
-0.616065681,
0.364302665,
0.6022613049,
-0.7202081084,
-0.0277022533,
0.530269444,
0.6993785501,
0.0324612707,
-0.0202265717,
0.7492852807,
0.2564416826,
-0.2595845461,
-0.4233678877,
-0.2165351808,
-0.2832587361,
-0.2851991951,
0.2651555538,
-0.0847426131,
0.5998747945,
0.0078463946,
-0.190862149,
-0.1036129668,
0.8113104701,
0.0974859223,
0.0874570087,
0.7294780016,
0.3962670267,
0.6818414927,
0.0322396122,
1.0281689167,
-0.2303837836,
0.0806471184,
1.5676172972,
0.2207498252,
0.5724656582,
0.5786386132,
-0.0110829053,
-0.0469772294,
0.6835859418,
-0.0176472683,
0.7814855576,
0.5371109247,
-0.2149100751,
-0.1706324518,
0.0876509771,
-0.5327728391,
0.3245563805,
0.5467675924,
-0.7790640593,
-0.0456710979,
-0.0651787892,
-0.0255779196,
0.2102207243,
-0.3544447422,
1.1559211016,
0.2096855789,
-0.4457407594,
0.7666695714,
0.083490476,
0.3976932764,
-0.8239115477,
0.1038890257,
-0.0346982703,
0.3277387917,
-0.2807863653,
-0.406262815,
0.3497671187,
-0.0107156485,
-0.0811095461,
-0.073986873,
0.8491053581,
-0.6360859871,
-0.5108565092,
0.152704671,
0.0423660129,
0.0251882188,
-0.1220230088,
-0.6552770138,
-0.0974833444,
0.1980605572,
-0.3625885844,
0.7859922647,
0.2752813995,
-0.0114268605,
0.331976831,
0.9141676426,
0.4046525955,
0.4352527261,
0.0484997034,
1.2018990517,
-0.1397917271,
-0.343536675,
-1.2238949537,
0.2988483906,
-0.153869763,
-0.3893331587,
0.7623050809,
0.6026520133,
0.8526542783,
-0.1006252766,
0.6288082004,
0.2113723159,
0.2110398114,
-0.5304738283,
1.1601896286,
-0.5175898671,
0.4828310311,
-0.329541266,
-0.8529427648,
-0.3865041137,
0.3133170903,
-0.3394927979,
0.0137499422,
0.1562735736,
1.0343892574,
-0.1458034515,
-0.1973118782,
0.4345855117,
0.2715687752,
0.4580970109,
0.3922698796,
0.8308694363,
-0.4299148619,
0.7286036015,
-0.2508662939,
-0.09682706,
-0.0006149829,
-0.7352438569,
-1.2131254673,
-0.37954849,
-0.2089744955,
-0.2646146715,
0.0859722644,
0.4703601599,
0.7514436841,
-0.8945775032,
0.3607724905,
-0.1363756508,
-0.2017981708,
0.088338539,
-0.1846071631,
0.5432013273,
-0.3903434277,
-0.466874063,
0.7553507686,
-0.2081760764,
0.1547117084,
-0.0218083095,
-0.0334955677,
-0.1787109971,
0.1553965211,
0.1242540032,
0.4377552569,
-0.2613675892,
-0.294998765,
-0.2955349982,
-0.0861343592,
0.0167084616,
0.8431717157,
-0.7251893282,
0.5920244455,
0.3062211871,
0.9909712672,
0.3078331053,
0.1226638108,
0.7002001405,
-1.4479115009,
0.3047235906,
0.4182478786,
0.2159060091,
0.1809962392,
-0.5302131176,
0.0893004686,
0.0280817281,
-0.1351129711,
-1.2709664106,
0.162208885,
-0.5117038488,
-0.4690136611,
0.7007578611,
-0.3034386337,
-0.1838839352,
-0.1734372228,
-0.0909256861,
0.4435995817,
0.1566806734,
0.7963926196,
0.3422174752,
0.4074682891,
-0.0258225035,
-0.3603102863,
0.8298944235,
0.6212226748,
-0.835604012,
0.1912538409,
0.28811571,
0.210107848,
0.0924182534,
0.3744962215,
-0.168886587,
0.0543225445,
-0.2194428295,
-0.1887062788,
-0.4044846594,
-0.4992991388,
-0.3523206711,
0.2794020772,
0.0064569158,
-0.3563084602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12177v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12177v4
|
Mafin: Enhancing Black-Box Embeddings with Model Augmented Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-19T14:33:24 | 2024-03-12T16:04:23 |
Mingtian Zhang, Shawn Lan, Peter Hayes, David Barber
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as an effective solution for
mitigating hallucinations in Large Language Models (LLMs). The retrieval stage
in RAG typically involves a pre-trained embedding model, which converts queries
and passages into vectors to capture their semantics. However, a standard
pre-trained embedding model may exhibit sub-optimal performance when applied to
specific domain knowledge, necessitating fine-tuning. This paper addresses
scenarios where the embeddings are only available from a black-box model. We
introduce Model augmented fine-tuning (Mafin) -- a novel approach for
fine-tuning a black-box embedding model by augmenting it with a trainable
embedding model. Our results demonstrate that Mafin significantly enhances the
performance of the black-box embeddings by only requiring the training of a
small augmented model. We validate the effectiveness of our method on both
labeled and unlabeled datasets, illustrating its broad applicability and
efficiency.
|
[
-0.7868670821,
-1.0405585766,
0.3658794165,
-0.3792274892,
-0.5025629997,
0.1810539961,
-0.1882639378,
-0.4084735513,
0.1717839688,
0.7978249192,
-0.2069496661,
-0.3550879657,
-0.6855602264,
-0.0594833978,
-0.0981823206,
0.9028978944,
0.1766009629,
-0.1563191563,
-0.1251289397,
-0.1463132501,
-0.5890399218,
-0.5524645448,
-0.6230974197,
-0.3803847134,
0.2539643943,
0.3975305259,
0.8443977833,
0.8140408993,
0.3011962771,
0.1704054773,
-0.0607995763,
0.9528678656,
-0.7973112464,
0.1322333068,
-0.4115232527,
-0.2963075638,
-0.4993376434,
-0.0895291939,
0.4654324651,
0.5690127015,
-0.1762014031,
0.2952294946,
0.0366953909,
0.4342727661,
-1.0696232319,
-0.0474414043,
-0.9588097334,
0.1228802726,
-0.0384126604,
-0.5023983717,
-0.2951346636,
0.0408724323,
-0.1692180187,
-0.6625304222,
0.2883179784,
0.5562908649,
0.7859874964,
0.5161144137,
-0.3736837208,
-0.0786755383,
-0.650549531,
0.7976575494,
-0.6849588752,
0.6084195375,
0.6113922,
0.3527512848,
-0.3057262897,
-0.3573922813,
-0.473258853,
-0.1465313435,
-0.0734647512,
-0.3480832577,
-0.0491314977,
0.0887536108,
0.2870643735,
0.5918602347,
-0.0524462759,
0.0081035253,
-0.2938578725,
-0.1738565266,
0.5759869814,
0.0201507267,
0.0690836161,
-0.1272305399,
-0.1622884721,
-0.1603278071,
-0.728716135,
-0.308388412,
0.2694034278,
0.6110833287,
0.2434336841,
0.9454527497,
-0.1248059347,
0.8238066435,
0.2312267125,
-0.0355808251,
0.1347797215,
-0.0408569239,
-0.3864051402,
0.0643342882,
0.2809703052,
0.2574249506,
0.2710133493,
-0.2649727464,
-0.6689310074,
0.1326275319,
0.5842363238,
-0.7171446681,
-0.2442245632,
-0.0537587665,
-0.2046111822,
-0.3211224377,
0.0941040367,
-0.7203455567,
-0.4893037081,
-0.4289529026,
0.7959641814,
-0.184731409,
-0.3446745574,
0.4353421628,
-0.1087373644,
0.1620875746,
0.1301871091,
-0.8359205127,
0.2630411983,
1.0359405279,
0.6622745395,
0.0211065952,
0.0318501405,
-1.0576027632,
0.3751387894,
-0.580681324,
0.768216908,
-1.0149720907,
-0.4223131835,
0.0600009747,
-0.0110663436,
0.0890847221,
-0.7048317194,
0.4105391204,
-0.5330058336,
-0.2875753343,
0.0620242245,
-0.590595305,
-0.1996419728,
0.284946233,
-0.5187045336,
1.0848433971,
0.0337007158,
-0.4869933426,
0.222323522,
-0.4677664638,
-0.4294853508,
-0.1168831885,
-0.0889372751,
-0.7035015821,
0.5323394537,
0.4876975417,
0.7794708014,
-0.22496593,
0.0975884944,
-0.5432485938,
-0.5653076172,
0.0433854237,
-0.1288540512,
0.0948341861,
0.2938777208,
-0.2307427824,
-0.2560441494,
-0.9719799757,
-0.1233161613,
-0.0272591226,
-0.1230213866,
-0.7744224668,
-0.1756084114,
-0.2961258888,
0.0357614532,
0.1523268968,
-0.4931145608,
0.2277439237,
-0.6282155514,
0.1928842068,
0.6442294121,
0.3075815737,
0.585315764,
-0.4272094071,
0.595887959,
-0.0385138728,
-0.0516260937,
-0.0813231394,
-0.2467852831,
-0.9201845527,
-0.2763676941,
0.5855654478,
0.3632137477,
-0.778221488,
0.2173422724,
-0.0262036081,
-0.2687409818,
-1.0826218128,
0.2953850031,
0.5394394398,
0.3298832178,
0.4765544832,
-0.1735748351,
-0.3814339638,
-1.0070619583,
-0.1695474088,
0.5507606864,
0.1331112385,
0.6545029283,
0.4265980721,
-0.4647399783,
0.4832350314,
-0.6697787046,
-0.3667738438,
0.1588408798,
0.1529780626,
-0.1035770997,
0.6719164848,
0.3276765943,
-0.7225605249,
-0.2489559948,
0.2384669036,
-0.3819245696,
0.0428732261,
0.141210407,
-0.5290967822,
0.0517738126,
0.6607646346,
-0.1985352039,
0.5137376785,
0.506581068,
-0.4130098224,
0.3649583459,
-0.4271013141,
0.1936738789,
-0.9788567424,
0.0263815764,
-0.2326708436,
-0.5697614551,
-0.3999447227,
0.2763416469,
0.1461849213,
-0.2762993872,
-0.3322357237,
0.7921643257,
-0.5992000699,
-0.0925453827,
-0.5398373008,
0.0784956217,
0.0994785503,
0.5233089328,
-0.2862895429,
1.0937781334,
0.3003597856,
-0.8733108044,
-0.1014340296,
0.4217097163,
-0.3413685858,
0.495680362,
-0.6302838326,
0.3541841507,
-0.1683002859,
-0.4308953285,
-0.7103101611,
-0.0336088091,
0.181812644,
-0.2514879107,
0.6114257574,
-0.4329280555,
-0.4684899449,
-0.0660822093,
-0.2821294367,
0.401742965,
0.4246878922,
-0.7349707484,
0.5710272789,
0.6671137214,
0.0947018862,
-0.6618272662,
-0.5063947439,
-0.1499570608,
-0.0668004006,
-0.1926989108,
0.3434812427,
0.0569928475,
0.0082370676,
0.0655884147,
-0.123034507,
0.2506782115,
0.2373092026,
0.1260039359,
-0.0230545979,
-0.2337581068,
0.1983609349,
0.427875489,
-0.2009339035,
-0.3497517407,
-0.2826087475,
0.431083262,
0.0912478566,
-0.2893693447,
0.1487683207,
0.3683065474,
0.3366076052,
-0.7915471792,
0.8775177002,
0.5961402059,
-0.5447892547,
-0.6411249638,
-0.7525922656,
-0.287724793,
-0.5040158033,
0.1658800393,
-0.6387791038,
-1.2328623533,
0.3952017128,
-0.4649199843,
-0.0614925474,
0.2862896025,
0.4044080675,
0.0978831649,
1.3493328094,
0.9728017449,
0.2759488225,
0.5324957371,
-0.4346916676,
0.1546126753,
-1.2426837683,
-0.0872588605,
-0.4180364609,
-0.2761936784,
-0.5104858279,
-0.5490891933,
0.3403745294,
0.2980564237,
-0.3891685605,
-0.0718559846,
-0.6769713759,
0.6585368514,
0.4271249473,
0.2503062189,
0.3091872633,
0.1617977619,
-0.4038226902,
0.1524085552,
-0.786303401,
-0.5238688588,
1.1965379715,
0.2325948924,
0.603805542,
-0.0003330117,
0.6061306,
0.3823678792,
0.1603959501,
-0.6430722475,
0.3436437845,
-0.3165100515,
-0.6460707784,
-0.1828034222,
-0.3552700579,
-1.0777536631,
0.4563641846,
-0.7762385011,
-0.4903422594,
0.4804108143,
0.3317009211,
-0.5224291086,
0.4675066173,
-0.6063629389,
0.7868111134,
0.0735810995,
-0.3672531843,
-0.3110441267,
-0.0431553237,
0.4872265756,
-0.2916808426,
0.1783020347,
-0.2587933838,
-0.1690706462,
0.531252861,
-0.4207653403,
0.62403965,
-0.1814653873,
-0.1230464056,
-0.0395399556,
0.2666410208,
0.7156299353,
0.1753814965,
-0.1252893656,
-0.1632896662,
-0.0013608808,
-0.5550368428,
-0.8286524415,
0.7584233284,
-0.6979254484,
-0.8379739523,
-0.1930750012,
-0.5215041041,
-0.4707065225,
0.2349363416,
-0.182554096,
0.6199319959,
-0.0316397995,
0.3068005443,
0.9242264032,
-0.2803705037,
-0.106004633,
0.4447848797,
-0.3653523624,
-0.575081408,
1.0319203138,
0.1219414398,
0.1219084337,
0.3812857568,
0.0493326858,
-0.1295364201,
-0.8020207882,
-0.2793563902,
0.4655324817,
-0.5025057197,
-0.5691084862,
-0.6581408978,
-0.1054250225,
-0.2161989063,
-0.1624209583,
-0.5204292536,
-0.4525212049,
-0.4622831941,
-0.1640955359,
0.5372766256,
0.7982560396,
-0.1381913871,
0.3442720473,
-0.6741874218,
0.5823575258,
0.3540281355,
0.7973797321,
0.2110721022,
-0.6668173075,
-0.5933859944,
0.3167779744,
-0.2087969184,
-0.4878956676,
0.4835413396,
0.3421355486,
0.5572472811,
0.2833174467,
0.2046606988,
0.9789329171,
-0.6642462611,
0.4067368209,
-0.3566527069,
-0.7299243212,
0.6054705977,
-0.374310106,
0.0310875811,
0.5703907609,
0.21043773,
-0.0211425219,
-0.4492687583,
-0.6087969542,
-0.5835866928,
0.3636483848,
-0.132699728,
0.2216307968,
0.008460125,
0.6788711548,
0.2362022996,
0.4107909203,
-0.1269775182,
-0.2579716444,
-0.0154815484,
0.0285500418,
-0.5663414598,
-0.5162522793,
-0.1919438839,
-0.4743165076,
0.7186279297,
-0.0946908221,
0.3348220885,
0.0188078769,
-0.3057458699,
-0.2856246233,
0.0832740515,
0.6425277591,
0.5728697777,
-0.4325424135,
0.2748900652,
0.2249618918,
-0.2790936232,
0.0687155277,
0.2827706337,
-0.1717536896,
-0.0653096661,
-0.0728192851,
1.0625917912,
0.693459928,
-0.4169677794,
0.161663726,
0.1465892941,
-0.0633413568,
-0.0112536717,
0.3616932631,
-0.2404627651,
0.5070281029,
0.3341602087,
0.1179856658,
0.2023148686,
-0.420963794,
0.3997647464,
0.7044078112,
-0.16070804,
0.026130503,
0.7652227879,
-0.0228332411,
-0.4219847918,
0.2878370583,
-0.3286083043,
-0.387986213,
0.1620971411,
0.6860281229,
0.6508612037,
-0.0579387583,
0.0637024865,
0.2365055978,
0.305973649,
-0.1337867677,
0.2638548613,
-0.0563172624,
-0.7809869051,
-0.4727200568,
-0.9429798126,
-0.4136848748,
0.0946117565,
-0.7207202315,
0.2871706188,
-0.4976294935,
-0.2444090098,
-0.0380310975,
0.3895677626,
-0.7789345384,
0.1435771286,
-0.0018168314,
0.8274677992,
-0.6196275949,
0.7318532467,
0.7347075939,
-0.2240066528,
-0.6761434674,
-0.3692015409,
-0.4516330957,
-0.7478029728,
0.0302156825,
-0.1526244879,
-0.1159881353,
0.4370298982,
-0.5139921308,
-0.8278853893,
0.9693782926,
0.5002442598,
-0.6069623232,
0.2733452916,
-0.100906767,
0.4483005106,
-0.622805059,
-0.0631986335,
0.6437077522,
0.3653583825,
-0.0476110391,
-0.7405434251,
0.0248034243,
-0.3163501322,
0.133748129,
0.4745501876,
-0.3659718335,
0.6224650741,
-0.0676157773,
-0.2103972733,
-0.1394541413,
0.6752466559,
0.3829376101,
0.2271136045,
0.4272369444,
0.7159894109,
1.0225497484,
0.1495599151,
1.2975567579,
-0.3607752323,
0.1747472137,
1.0070066452,
0.1367806196,
1.1963528395,
0.3206857741,
0.186635986,
0.1031037569,
0.4591028988,
-0.1035236195,
0.7023383975,
-0.0257690102,
-0.0287957806,
-0.5600895882,
-0.1520326436,
-0.4834102988,
0.3257138431,
0.6557453275,
-0.2401908338,
0.0559603572,
0.4863395989,
-0.1342285424,
0.2829062045,
-0.5888320208,
0.820931077,
0.2356094867,
-0.5030480623,
1.0634642839,
0.116909273,
0.8760980368,
-0.2080794573,
-0.2345039994,
-0.2053838968,
0.218932122,
-0.0410451069,
-0.3635601401,
0.3026151657,
-0.2212623209,
-0.1931188107,
0.0581982844,
0.9334139228,
-0.7057209015,
-0.6455050111,
0.1893617809,
0.6315525174,
-0.025041664,
-0.0920321345,
-0.6546060443,
0.0965063274,
-0.1410966963,
-0.0474555306,
0.42858693,
0.6173830628,
0.1258533299,
0.682938993,
0.8954803348,
0.3021509945,
0.1188211218,
-0.1165957749,
0.9805887341,
-0.6296042204,
-0.318747133,
-0.578690052,
0.3272078335,
0.0398534276,
-0.1090148091,
0.6754984856,
0.5113891363,
0.8242658973,
-0.1481288671,
0.5473124981,
0.5448967814,
0.7967697382,
-0.5940900445,
0.8128361702,
-1.0090383291,
0.2669484913,
-0.1967826784,
-0.9861484766,
-0.3863425851,
0.7446029186,
-0.3557412624,
-0.0835362375,
0.1737218499,
1.2389339209,
-0.5643516779,
-0.230076462,
0.6570097804,
0.1763710976,
0.1192257479,
0.2911652625,
0.6672182679,
-0.4636573493,
0.3260465562,
-0.2964703143,
-0.039196711,
-0.4071597457,
-0.7728721499,
-1.2219920158,
-0.5622427464,
-0.2382278293,
-0.2332598865,
0.3981768787,
0.8771971464,
0.7036070824,
-0.8914121389,
0.0979512185,
0.3929006457,
0.2193191499,
-0.1232456192,
-0.1382528692,
0.2685960531,
-0.4077934027,
-0.7076572776,
0.3887354732,
0.1185943484,
0.2598158717,
-0.2789928019,
-0.0479120985,
-0.3784449995,
0.3785931766,
0.7122316957,
0.1960113496,
-0.4438992441,
-0.3939501941,
-0.193087846,
0.0490807481,
-0.0008179965,
0.6585284472,
-0.8593768477,
0.5971186161,
0.1688232571,
1.0276374817,
0.7241027355,
0.1824452579,
0.8981456161,
-0.9587140083,
0.3835879266,
0.1335688829,
0.2771300673,
0.4008684158,
-0.463532716,
0.5163536668,
-0.2291130573,
-0.495873481,
-1.2373049259,
-0.0017754431,
-0.6468843818,
-0.3196949959,
1.100489974,
0.2715697289,
-0.2834402323,
-0.1520059109,
-0.3231312037,
0.3141197562,
-0.3213778436,
0.7523854375,
0.5134464502,
0.2460574061,
-0.3953675628,
-0.8259946108,
0.7743900418,
0.4080515206,
-0.3523752093,
-0.0397845097,
0.3500666618,
0.0019467395,
0.0334082656,
0.1644015312,
0.0408313759,
0.1733408421,
-0.1363629401,
-0.1885116249,
-0.7102282047,
-0.3789485097,
-0.3948291838,
0.2212512493,
0.1853432059,
-0.250064522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12174v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12174v2
|
BIDER: Bridging Knowledge Inconsistency for Efficient Retrieval-Augmented LLMs via Key Supporting Evidence
| 2024-02-19T14:28:31 | 2024-05-30T11:26:58 |
Jiajie Jin, Yutao Zhu, Yujia Zhou, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated efficacy
in knowledge-intensive tasks such as open-domain QA, addressing inherent
challenges in knowledge update and factual inadequacy. However, inconsistencies
between retrieval knowledge and the necessary knowledge for LLMs, leading to a
decline in LLM's answer quality. This paper introduces BIDER, an approach that
refines retrieval documents into Key Supporting Evidence (KSE) through
knowledge synthesis, supervised fine-tuning (SFT), and preference alignment. We
train BIDER by learning from crafting KSE, while maximizing its output to align
with LLM's information acquisition preferences through reinforcement learning.
Evaluations across five datasets show BIDER boosts LLMs' answer quality by 7%
while reducing input content length in retrieval documents by 80%,
outperforming existing methods. The proposed KSE simulation effectively equips
LLMs with essential information for accurate question answering.
|
[
-0.2319117486,
-0.5192920566,
0.9181115031,
-0.3246756792,
-0.1931480765,
0.1769215167,
0.069059588,
-0.1248818338,
0.07262633,
0.480974704,
-0.3612045944,
-0.4156739116,
-0.6969877481,
-0.1694634855,
0.0507879965,
0.9521835446,
-0.2349343002,
0.1828251928,
-0.6160511374,
-0.2160460204,
-0.3253100514,
-0.1916905493,
-0.7004264593,
-0.3582903147,
0.5583107471,
0.6588845849,
0.5647312403,
0.3827870488,
0.4883506894,
0.1920348108,
0.037166331,
0.5768817663,
-0.5483159423,
0.3804464042,
-0.5296700597,
-0.6764931679,
-0.4379640818,
-0.0410753451,
0.3402718902,
0.4867822826,
-0.1504656225,
0.1445086449,
-0.0489157848,
0.7450082898,
-0.8537715077,
0.15142636,
-0.845174551,
-0.2884228826,
0.0414368473,
-0.1761751622,
-0.4307141304,
-0.3390362859,
0.3696176708,
-0.769451499,
0.3574463129,
-0.0239796806,
0.9318560958,
0.5496988297,
-0.581990242,
-0.4324692488,
-0.5815182924,
0.4937090874,
-1.0012518167,
0.4653510749,
0.2291614115,
0.3664254546,
-0.2255389094,
-0.577311039,
-0.6553655863,
-0.0928315744,
-0.0899363235,
0.409734726,
0.2953674197,
0.3029147387,
0.1285457462,
0.1858000159,
-0.3211923838,
-0.1899115145,
-0.274302125,
-0.210940212,
0.5159404278,
-0.1460722536,
0.0435859896,
-0.247012049,
-0.3450517058,
-0.3548350334,
-0.8179584742,
0.2782547176,
0.2425164729,
0.1067110077,
0.3546487689,
0.7075567245,
-0.2517788708,
0.5062555671,
0.34863922,
-0.1615450084,
-0.0285688266,
-0.1198554933,
-0.1648765951,
0.1698764414,
0.4624761641,
0.3360418975,
-0.2124519348,
-0.3575551808,
-0.2481918335,
-0.2561860979,
0.3629232943,
-0.8866391778,
-0.168236807,
0.3713571727,
-0.124678351,
-0.1217714101,
0.0101931095,
-0.4761347771,
-0.4342530668,
-0.2348257899,
0.6924991012,
-0.5440488458,
0.0251164753,
0.1425936669,
-0.2037472576,
0.4353955686,
0.5347161889,
-0.5227177143,
0.1965875477,
0.5518266559,
0.3418394625,
-0.1245049834,
-0.011451399,
-0.8354542255,
0.3594405353,
-0.3627943695,
0.9710812569,
-0.5422997475,
-0.2627417147,
-0.056210544,
0.0862481445,
-0.0853931606,
-0.6288429499,
0.7298058867,
-1.1741067171,
0.5068222284,
-0.4374864697,
-0.9006260037,
-0.1623755544,
0.5092823505,
-0.7023307085,
0.8616474271,
0.1370538026,
-0.6693685651,
0.4684997797,
-0.4939265847,
-0.245209679,
0.0503454693,
-0.1907188743,
-0.3534134924,
0.1841143221,
0.2762030959,
0.1528339833,
-0.1444814801,
0.4125751257,
-0.1754518151,
-0.4023311734,
0.1135512814,
-0.2293851674,
0.2058491409,
0.0530224033,
0.0256675314,
0.0082818428,
-0.6909225583,
-0.1721478254,
0.0733782947,
-0.7371221185,
-0.3899330199,
0.2700297832,
-0.328717351,
0.2217785567,
0.4770873785,
-0.762224257,
0.1246061698,
-0.6086238623,
0.0382686965,
0.6814721823,
0.2240633219,
0.5644421577,
-0.6425468326,
0.5350461602,
0.258979857,
0.0001110456,
0.0629287735,
-0.1338483989,
-0.8225722313,
0.0949159265,
0.5041274428,
0.5338381529,
-1.1401804686,
-0.1350361407,
-0.4961323142,
-0.1515400857,
-0.9476080537,
0.204497844,
0.3208065331,
0.5934053063,
0.4692655504,
-0.1153016686,
-0.6056636572,
-0.8510121703,
-0.3919473588,
-0.3419629931,
-0.1182327196,
0.6098396778,
0.1886465251,
-0.0686779469,
1.044718504,
-0.3278258443,
-0.1518698037,
0.0987024158,
-0.0636223853,
0.2109319121,
0.3120019734,
0.0698871389,
-0.7458631992,
-0.2867159545,
-0.1230637729,
-0.5552772284,
0.0517395362,
-0.0548802689,
-0.2026870251,
0.3089244366,
0.4804983735,
-0.6018174887,
0.0073529766,
0.1621489078,
-0.0697622523,
0.4015799463,
-0.2269155979,
0.3584098816,
-1.1773941517,
-0.0317130685,
-0.2014479786,
-0.2453518957,
-0.3484591544,
0.0693762749,
0.1715550274,
0.1355814487,
-0.2541589737,
0.6251826286,
-0.256316036,
0.2495225221,
-0.3131299913,
0.5807947516,
0.2309988737,
0.3119242489,
0.0491818525,
1.1153963804,
-0.1283509284,
-0.4617713988,
0.3045593202,
0.4598580003,
-0.2407750934,
0.5981895924,
-0.7225524783,
0.1510349512,
-0.33697927,
-0.1025627479,
-1.0264279842,
-0.3345649838,
-0.0431719348,
-0.5087117553,
0.4425950348,
-0.5855030417,
-0.4374609888,
-0.1107860208,
-0.3300834596,
0.3003768325,
0.4463996291,
-0.5646833181,
0.7666187882,
0.2704370022,
-0.2600960732,
-0.642708838,
-0.0097155981,
-0.0628572032,
0.0620136559,
-0.6408787966,
0.4657478929,
-0.0547032952,
0.0047790236,
0.1261962056,
-0.5647771955,
-0.0359379537,
0.0621595643,
-0.0729216561,
0.3405783772,
-0.2499533892,
0.4662240446,
0.2557506859,
-0.0059899916,
0.2069152892,
-0.2860993445,
0.1457011849,
0.1772473305,
-0.5770500898,
0.114864558,
0.0649018437,
0.6959652901,
-0.1092826352,
0.6655779481,
0.3139946461,
-0.1763600111,
-0.0244075004,
-0.8620712161,
-0.3170867264,
-0.4001972675,
0.239731282,
-0.5213060379,
-1.1018241644,
0.3658060133,
-0.400718838,
0.1986970603,
0.3164042532,
0.0714886039,
-0.3641037345,
1.1041432619,
0.3997060359,
0.0978966206,
0.2954747081,
-0.0047478531,
0.3443943262,
-1.0965237617,
-0.3897582591,
-0.2014758438,
-0.1937144548,
-0.5254468322,
-0.5112157464,
0.6488128901,
0.2876852751,
-0.3368159831,
-0.0000599932,
-0.1764404178,
0.4375688732,
0.6787578464,
0.4401206672,
0.3032843471,
-0.168494463,
-0.2738101184,
0.0701426119,
-0.8411183953,
-0.5150348544,
1.1677062511,
0.0207131952,
0.7096971869,
0.1508536935,
0.6332370639,
0.2083002925,
0.1130227521,
-0.7282522917,
0.3792352974,
0.1538372934,
-0.5616978407,
-0.2975014448,
-0.3462472856,
-0.5996007919,
0.1950617582,
-0.200664863,
-0.1549222469,
0.0988007113,
0.1355721653,
-0.3179467022,
0.1530509442,
-0.4766713083,
0.7657051682,
-0.0845750496,
-0.6686633229,
-0.2991634011,
-0.6614957452,
0.3504047096,
0.0933005586,
-0.0104852654,
0.0710598603,
-0.1412178874,
0.7885974646,
-0.4064458609,
0.5820744634,
-0.3651994467,
-0.2577397823,
0.1348608136,
0.1904956996,
0.9329718351,
0.2341377139,
-0.1550957412,
-0.6772682667,
0.1760839224,
-0.681043148,
-0.8348681331,
0.6062765718,
-0.7365651727,
-0.9771516919,
-0.2936685085,
-0.6635472178,
-0.6422429681,
0.0550234243,
-0.0006356207,
0.2581984997,
-0.1878582537,
0.1430350095,
1.2266303301,
-0.0571715869,
-0.0648415908,
0.8122317791,
0.1266621649,
-0.6599853635,
0.8047400117,
0.0524877384,
0.1509636939,
0.5985404253,
0.0005938324,
-0.4772239625,
-0.6803171039,
-0.4523563087,
0.3905316293,
-0.6881979108,
-0.3942538798,
-0.5614910126,
-0.406989783,
-0.3234065771,
-0.059652783,
-0.2106577605,
-0.4568547904,
-0.0839509964,
-0.2900261581,
0.3474968374,
0.551574111,
0.0542077199,
0.2018924057,
-0.8132600188,
0.2186722606,
0.7018039227,
0.3795615435,
-0.165393427,
-0.6810293198,
-0.3336892128,
0.2700513601,
-0.2771763802,
-0.7558882236,
-0.0928443745,
0.0783387721,
0.6598553658,
0.2859686613,
0.4165836573,
0.5920631289,
-0.3109581769,
0.7521209121,
-0.1940049082,
-0.7413977385,
0.8228916526,
-0.225267753,
0.1537368745,
0.8086992502,
0.3650048375,
-0.463763386,
-0.3821801841,
-0.7019963861,
-0.9001169801,
0.6080793738,
-0.1063209623,
-0.0437386371,
-0.1817953736,
0.5071213841,
0.0670293719,
0.4091901183,
-0.3904702365,
0.0360479169,
-0.0650765449,
-0.4088634253,
0.2495586425,
-0.6121186614,
-0.1552635133,
-0.0615116209,
1.2047935724,
-0.3773842454,
-0.0573793165,
0.4852496684,
-0.4612926841,
-0.0099702356,
0.4454806149,
0.4010617733,
0.6383718252,
-0.4471418858,
0.3191085756,
0.3514889181,
-0.2512667179,
0.1889322102,
0.1430335194,
-0.3607981801,
-0.1730530113,
0.1979183555,
0.6832193732,
0.2596412897,
-0.8400988579,
0.6960577369,
0.0732778385,
-0.2391489148,
-0.0118791331,
0.169136256,
0.2058254629,
0.343300432,
0.3181911111,
0.0179105829,
0.1815160066,
-0.1347080469,
0.1623331457,
0.5309476256,
-0.5814400911,
-0.0563831925,
0.5926983953,
0.2237038016,
0.0560439974,
0.5481979847,
-0.2042058408,
-0.4921150804,
0.2930263877,
0.3376259208,
0.456548661,
-0.1843249649,
0.2253158242,
0.3386347592,
0.1890956163,
0.001365096,
0.3227467537,
-0.2743777633,
-0.7829378843,
-0.6154199839,
-0.5389094353,
-0.692340374,
0.0488945581,
-0.7465404272,
0.0362859406,
-0.2029191256,
0.1911625266,
-0.4319080114,
0.204091832,
-0.608671844,
0.0526344962,
-0.1728207618,
1.0486085415,
-0.631067574,
0.6680895686,
0.9426717758,
-0.5860068798,
-0.7032770514,
0.008137159,
-0.3658266366,
-0.7940396667,
0.5815238953,
-0.3258240819,
-0.1779566705,
0.1419305503,
-0.6939272881,
-0.7546396255,
1.213436842,
0.349845916,
-0.3544226289,
-0.2033901215,
0.0591035932,
0.2609182298,
-0.0780983418,
0.4454436004,
0.4951943159,
0.3560960889,
0.4412256777,
-0.5845407844,
0.0812889412,
-0.2597278357,
0.0774859637,
0.1640550792,
-0.6292620301,
0.2357560247,
-0.294749558,
-0.2111025006,
-0.1116198078,
0.6977670789,
0.5796616077,
0.2480423301,
0.3388035297,
0.736120522,
0.9583320618,
0.0572152995,
0.5970594883,
-0.3277454674,
0.1425616443,
1.3401196003,
-0.4359702468,
0.9533728957,
0.688726902,
-0.246126771,
0.6903653145,
0.5268846154,
0.2782010734,
0.6598455906,
0.012348664,
-0.5575598478,
-0.6034299135,
-0.2118014246,
-0.1722056121,
0.2460978031,
0.2122001648,
-0.1202702895,
-0.3871005177,
-0.0504990257,
0.0121409977,
0.1244861931,
-0.0532451794,
1.1551011801,
-0.1646885723,
-0.8312974572,
0.5007916093,
-0.2062277645,
0.4209723175,
-0.4494179487,
-0.2008335441,
-0.4042265415,
0.1646368206,
-0.0638971105,
-0.8322663903,
0.0168363992,
-0.261950314,
-0.6513456106,
-0.0096850656,
0.8073608875,
-0.5391102433,
-0.2715367079,
0.113831751,
0.7378187776,
-0.142971158,
-0.152057752,
-0.324824363,
-0.3354474008,
-0.0222258065,
-0.1430160403,
0.3893574476,
0.6924346685,
0.2102862448,
0.6378652453,
0.7133744955,
0.1164182499,
0.0412710719,
-0.0331926309,
1.0612664223,
-0.4166208804,
-0.1251305789,
-0.5164083242,
0.4311002493,
-0.3758879304,
0.1896247119,
0.6475945711,
0.7744752765,
0.9310115576,
-0.0278520305,
0.894713521,
0.1421108395,
0.6902647614,
-0.6122530699,
0.6181185842,
-0.4232955873,
0.4754709005,
0.1979826093,
-0.5529228449,
0.1150113046,
0.4005275667,
-0.3884498477,
-0.2361685187,
0.5587648153,
0.8266376853,
-0.1978725642,
-0.1604969651,
0.2209353298,
0.2901552916,
0.3929284513,
0.7917559743,
0.7772601247,
-0.8344563842,
0.7113730907,
-0.0546190105,
-0.0933376774,
-0.2574490607,
-0.6756225824,
-0.722322762,
-0.6275299191,
-0.364836365,
-0.4459234774,
0.3809499443,
0.9052889943,
0.5982721448,
-0.9581196308,
-0.0115843443,
-0.055679962,
0.5006197095,
-0.0261607524,
-0.2209871858,
0.3293582797,
-0.7959572673,
-0.4187501967,
0.5016531944,
0.0963683724,
0.0312674157,
0.1259856075,
-0.1473861635,
-0.2368368357,
0.3038943112,
0.591003418,
0.079348132,
-0.7265562415,
-0.3382892311,
0.1972898692,
-0.0617780127,
0.1528530419,
0.630625248,
-1.148453474,
0.5594503284,
0.6123234034,
0.9423090219,
0.5670391321,
0.174978286,
0.6274851561,
-0.6475703716,
-0.4650969207,
0.2076807916,
0.2988806665,
0.2562470734,
-0.3293719888,
0.3771073222,
0.1745146662,
-0.7024806738,
-0.6186201572,
0.2138051838,
-0.9389458299,
-0.3037400544,
0.9010171294,
-0.1102543548,
-0.335419178,
-0.1127064601,
-0.3030164242,
0.3213381767,
-0.3417708874,
0.9441423416,
0.8293877244,
0.0891036317,
-0.3517807722,
-0.403462857,
0.6056816578,
0.2811232507,
-0.6855401397,
0.0332314745,
0.5425344706,
0.5825179815,
0.1098508462,
0.5039608479,
-0.0910389796,
0.4935892522,
-0.3149312735,
0.1167576015,
-0.1647210866,
-0.1295848042,
0.0217392761,
0.2940497696,
0.5281019807,
-0.2139904648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12168v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12168v3
|
Defending Against Weight-Poisoning Backdoor Attacks for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-19T14:22:54 | 2024-03-29T12:12:30 |
Shuai Zhao, Leilei Gan, Luu Anh Tuan, Jie Fu, Lingjuan Lyu, Meihuizi Jia, Jinming Wen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, various parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) strategies for
application to language models have been proposed and successfully implemented.
However, this raises the question of whether PEFT, which only updates a limited
set of model parameters, constitutes security vulnerabilities when confronted
with weight-poisoning backdoor attacks. In this study, we show that PEFT is
more susceptible to weight-poisoning backdoor attacks compared to the
full-parameter fine-tuning method, with pre-defined triggers remaining
exploitable and pre-defined targets maintaining high confidence, even after
fine-tuning. Motivated by this insight, we developed a Poisoned Sample
Identification Module (PSIM) leveraging PEFT, which identifies poisoned samples
through confidence, providing robust defense against weight-poisoning backdoor
attacks. Specifically, we leverage PEFT to train the PSIM with randomly reset
sample labels. During the inference process, extreme confidence serves as an
indicator for poisoned samples, while others are clean. We conduct experiments
on text classification tasks, five fine-tuning strategies, and three
weight-poisoning backdoor attack methods. Experiments show near 100% success
rates for weight-poisoning backdoor attacks when utilizing PEFT. Furthermore,
our defensive approach exhibits overall competitive performance in mitigating
weight-poisoning backdoor attacks.
|
[
0.0187921245,
-0.5307862759,
0.4776212275,
-0.0881264582,
-0.0677278191,
-0.0153384311,
-0.2121461928,
-0.1193300709,
-0.5075516105,
0.6779252291,
-0.3066552281,
-0.6515097022,
-0.603120923,
-0.0800810978,
-0.4856359363,
1.2949075699,
0.0898119435,
-0.1135375872,
0.3256103098,
0.1341750324,
-0.5014529228,
-0.7243363857,
-0.9483537674,
-0.198947072,
0.7908267379,
0.3330349028,
0.5921434164,
0.2109456956,
0.2180817723,
0.196179226,
0.1260323226,
-0.1989288032,
-0.4950538576,
0.118262209,
-0.5638343692,
-0.7558186054,
-0.3685926497,
0.1240900904,
0.3741295636,
0.1076043248,
-0.1757840216,
0.1602933407,
0.1663766354,
0.7070479989,
-1.1383582354,
-0.2975521088,
-1.1015658379,
0.1332851797,
-0.3149463236,
-0.5473818779,
-0.8503614664,
0.1453543007,
-0.3179210126,
-0.2446103543,
0.0589318536,
0.2425370216,
0.9094034433,
0.2165347487,
-0.2153591365,
0.183698386,
-0.4466880262,
0.7444475889,
-0.7734621167,
0.4453965724,
0.448798269,
0.2222965211,
-0.3736210167,
-0.4055868387,
-0.1732258648,
-0.130425781,
0.0120038791,
-0.0014421726,
-0.2562951446,
0.2020063698,
0.2650059462,
0.0960894823,
-0.7338812351,
0.2424559891,
-0.1225190759,
-0.4657864273,
0.7599101663,
0.1921208352,
0.3595349789,
0.0257801581,
-0.328540504,
-0.3346613944,
-0.8629074693,
-0.0790392384,
0.8961443305,
0.5027170181,
-0.0179768726,
0.3724364042,
-0.1324329823,
0.6344291568,
0.2344458699,
0.2086131275,
0.0086905947,
0.0138797043,
-0.3479929864,
0.2454642057,
0.7828837633,
0.4145397842,
0.4364518225,
-0.2362300307,
-0.3670792878,
-0.4090223014,
0.4326354563,
-1.0630899668,
-0.6120557189,
0.5770090818,
-0.3904523253,
-0.6340518594,
0.1079799533,
-0.8292714357,
-0.3369626999,
0.6273310184,
1.1110364199,
-0.6814886332,
-0.1764391363,
0.1675658971,
-0.4850783646,
0.3306667209,
0.2543427646,
-1.0308154821,
0.4118934274,
1.1000659466,
0.7216590047,
-0.2136733234,
-0.3287289143,
-0.97371912,
0.2575597465,
-0.3801911175,
0.5031357408,
-0.5171490908,
-0.223849237,
-0.2415530533,
0.1585483998,
0.0461229756,
-0.5080339313,
0.440369606,
-0.5529248118,
0.0853216276,
-0.2572383881,
-0.2385606915,
0.0443435572,
0.4421365559,
-0.4168576598,
0.8816500902,
-0.1701346487,
-1.0038248301,
0.3990549147,
0.137932837,
-0.5451920629,
-0.0000626578,
0.0810929686,
-0.5997682214,
0.228745237,
0.0427460782,
0.6016990542,
0.2144994736,
-0.2612458467,
-0.4120404124,
-0.4741873741,
0.0893913954,
-0.4874068499,
0.6355021596,
0.2717086077,
-0.0267967265,
-0.0026681686,
-0.6938522458,
0.0636228099,
0.1477912962,
-0.4763141572,
-0.657831192,
0.1607826203,
-0.0840879902,
-0.0088917837,
0.2105065882,
-0.7868872285,
0.0511707813,
-0.8147812486,
0.2849509418,
0.8361549973,
0.307248354,
0.2666946948,
-0.4306815863,
0.2666215301,
0.0035111022,
0.2824734449,
-0.2517067492,
-0.4567231834,
-0.1130604744,
-0.2646136582,
0.4267373979,
0.7205495238,
-0.2704586387,
0.5801460743,
0.0538454652,
-0.7830276489,
0.006192178,
0.0616288036,
0.554920435,
0.5120960474,
0.3552817404,
0.018937923,
-0.0639741272,
-0.6798194051,
-1.0816816092,
-0.1347610205,
-0.4465696514,
0.2875647843,
0.6124794483,
0.1474070102,
0.5994868279,
-0.6257635951,
-0.1945115924,
0.1285581738,
-0.00316327,
0.0959991887,
0.7655126452,
0.701664269,
-0.625895083,
-0.5258005261,
-0.1529554129,
-0.0181182511,
-0.2538325787,
-0.1924719661,
-0.141982764,
-0.0927068591,
0.3443046808,
-0.2185569108,
0.2445583194,
0.4638961852,
-0.3365633488,
0.45423311,
-0.2273921072,
0.0454032421,
-0.9613536596,
-0.0663247854,
0.0535027906,
-0.1242604777,
-0.6028016806,
0.38833341,
0.4613292217,
-0.4053662121,
-0.4942540228,
0.7093914747,
0.0219682883,
0.4467480183,
-0.0697256252,
-0.3996777534,
0.1499358565,
0.6183310747,
-0.2847543359,
0.5965695381,
0.5920449495,
-0.3228991032,
0.1534063667,
-0.2761174142,
0.1296608299,
0.6517555714,
-0.5817915201,
0.1930578947,
0.2206248045,
0.1799945831,
-1.1811635494,
-0.1717444062,
0.5187225938,
-0.4569142163,
0.6406613588,
-0.5226839781,
-0.6362295747,
-0.0253795553,
-0.6435536742,
0.1754592806,
0.4152391553,
-0.4943785071,
0.7752657533,
-0.1767313331,
-0.048022408,
-0.5357038975,
-0.7798958421,
-0.0800427422,
-0.3782782853,
-0.355441004,
0.3262296915,
-0.1250251532,
-0.0743829384,
-0.3847025633,
-0.5454013944,
-0.0203491636,
0.5254359245,
0.2022094727,
-0.3000190258,
0.1781013012,
0.0413404666,
0.4565045238,
-0.1001946032,
0.0841911212,
-0.4139153063,
0.5752290487,
0.1309270412,
-0.421713084,
-0.610460341,
0.4806583524,
0.4553776681,
-0.3221370578,
0.7688946128,
0.3723448515,
-0.5172455907,
-0.3636172116,
-0.4725773335,
-0.4814293385,
-0.5211892128,
0.4323318005,
-0.5781404376,
-0.3758522868,
0.4642804563,
-0.003097224,
0.1713827401,
0.2801555097,
0.4717229903,
0.0084578749,
1.2733341455,
0.6132822633,
-0.1295983791,
0.3796933293,
0.2526059747,
-0.213137731,
-0.6490342021,
-0.0834503919,
-0.7421531677,
-0.3952772915,
-0.3173162937,
0.3287077546,
0.232200399,
0.0058865887,
-0.5192090869,
0.3135660887,
-0.5362941027,
0.5259279609,
0.374204278,
0.3321182132,
0.3494798243,
0.0147318523,
-0.307607621,
0.0791128129,
-0.4146946073,
-0.2393693775,
1.3649610281,
0.3782983422,
1.2282546759,
-0.0576538816,
0.9360661507,
0.1847155392,
0.0424051732,
-0.6052857041,
0.4111800492,
-0.1072574481,
-0.7997450233,
-0.142239809,
-0.4598007202,
-0.8390218019,
0.1055230424,
-0.138482511,
-0.929420352,
0.1670116335,
0.4211453199,
-0.6185947657,
0.4371489882,
-0.9289244413,
0.8396302462,
-0.3502604663,
-0.2454847991,
-0.2352804095,
-0.4691077769,
0.1920246184,
-0.6770795584,
-0.1082686037,
-0.1432166398,
-0.1770537496,
0.7788564563,
-0.6321521401,
0.7772063613,
-0.2464402914,
-0.5073683262,
-0.3045377731,
0.3514702916,
0.6133438349,
0.3930332661,
-0.3262465596,
0.3262136281,
0.4168146849,
-0.5274886489,
-0.4654033482,
0.5595650673,
-0.5245500803,
-0.8426909447,
-0.4514441788,
-0.2373205572,
-0.329549253,
0.3825166523,
0.6890925169,
0.2000099123,
0.3179747164,
0.1784132868,
0.7862157822,
-0.6159482598,
0.3259287179,
0.7400111556,
0.1392680258,
-0.2019302547,
0.8345609903,
0.1850431114,
0.5240236521,
0.7281041741,
0.6168393493,
0.358987093,
-0.6947898865,
-0.2110987157,
-0.0134522775,
-0.1260867566,
-0.5460981727,
-0.5377570391,
-0.2258711308,
-0.3518002927,
-0.0581886433,
-0.5252161026,
0.0307246372,
0.0142092006,
0.1368785799,
0.6240427494,
0.0290281307,
0.0756751448,
0.4992317557,
-0.7328164577,
0.1220792681,
0.4739649892,
0.4277639985,
0.0295062363,
-0.5874521732,
-0.2152825445,
-0.0472694226,
-0.2854329646,
-1.3407225609,
0.3339699805,
0.2798146605,
0.358697176,
0.409259975,
0.3968180418,
0.3031259179,
-0.684640944,
0.6818874478,
-0.1655549407,
-0.8992996812,
0.6528773308,
-0.334289372,
0.2413492203,
0.5481353998,
0.2642593086,
-0.5409465432,
-0.6209911108,
-0.4117522836,
-0.8122410774,
0.4913865626,
-0.0060225083,
0.4302813113,
0.2698657513,
0.5565493703,
0.1948916465,
0.3807565272,
-0.3251270652,
0.0305746309,
-0.1539234221,
-0.2034667432,
0.1648369879,
-0.2215129584,
-0.2156394124,
-0.1914893091,
0.6124787331,
-0.0382746607,
-0.1958343238,
0.0599532686,
-0.0212110765,
-0.3299877346,
0.3465040624,
0.2299031764,
0.2174001783,
-0.2911175191,
0.3280946314,
0.3880509138,
-0.7419349551,
0.0426115021,
0.2662826478,
-0.088966541,
-0.4820591211,
0.2633602023,
0.1769722849,
0.2365519255,
-0.7635937333,
0.6064584255,
-0.1657022089,
-0.1452458352,
0.0073676966,
0.544329524,
-0.2875971496,
0.1521241218,
0.7811369896,
-0.0319678821,
-0.0362187102,
-0.5735681653,
0.247230649,
0.7431075573,
-0.3094587028,
-0.2907650173,
0.5535802841,
0.0348571427,
-0.4368827343,
0.2783073783,
0.1572033465,
-0.5705973506,
0.4116283655,
0.3590683043,
0.7409626842,
-0.5503143072,
-0.3066781163,
-0.0759915113,
0.6447916031,
0.0559716448,
0.399897635,
-0.2067719996,
-0.7457806468,
0.0313635841,
-0.7845336199,
-0.2777175307,
0.3030848801,
-0.5160194635,
0.2397674173,
-0.9564834833,
0.0551014319,
-0.1324653029,
0.0871481225,
-0.0794486776,
0.1791213453,
0.0795769095,
1.1051434278,
-1.0559490919,
0.7519378662,
0.3526901901,
-0.1497554779,
-1.0301135778,
0.5164633989,
0.1171762273,
-0.569542706,
0.3387120068,
0.016189767,
-0.0012508958,
0.1618546844,
-0.7531352639,
-0.6606550217,
0.6027827263,
0.4578849673,
-0.4688893855,
-0.0754829496,
-0.3278124928,
0.3048782945,
0.3692329526,
-0.350571841,
0.4570909441,
0.5902144909,
-0.2199743241,
-0.7727312446,
0.3374652565,
-0.1424417496,
-0.3616733849,
0.3853040636,
-0.7892198563,
0.890606463,
0.1403966695,
-0.1820297241,
0.1909987628,
0.3420820534,
0.3462438881,
0.201486662,
0.5407736301,
0.7906715274,
0.5300959349,
-0.1008735448,
0.6364241242,
-0.2948216796,
0.1174770519,
1.1504815817,
-0.4461771548,
1.0537348986,
0.296030432,
0.1252680421,
0.3890495002,
0.5650200844,
-0.6225683689,
0.5673772097,
0.2043943405,
0.0275339261,
-0.2502309084,
0.4579984248,
-0.4497205615,
0.4239931703,
0.4034938216,
-0.4730281532,
-0.3477032483,
0.2698595226,
0.4642283618,
0.034248367,
-0.5425087214,
0.6361678839,
0.1363944113,
-0.4925618768,
0.5418189168,
0.2436992377,
0.7769207358,
-0.6794220209,
0.2084440291,
0.0441905484,
0.3087558746,
-0.4157150984,
-0.7159015536,
0.1846635193,
0.033177197,
0.1216744259,
-0.1824619621,
0.9005889297,
-0.1993275434,
-0.0683669373,
0.1190197542,
-0.0986224711,
-0.1188874319,
-0.7692607641,
-0.6315523982,
0.0393479317,
-0.4395129085,
-0.454216212,
0.5477038026,
0.2928736806,
0.1061613485,
0.4945594966,
0.6069945097,
0.4253853261,
-0.0886377171,
-0.2135384679,
0.7028183937,
-0.353739351,
-0.6396941543,
-1.1993812323,
0.1872687191,
-0.0711404532,
-0.0480518714,
1.0327825546,
0.665269196,
0.8774238825,
0.1173306704,
0.5356930494,
0.2831374109,
0.2383859903,
-0.5233935714,
1.3022432327,
-0.7373315096,
0.1193842068,
-0.5353922844,
-0.4112434387,
-0.2566708922,
0.0967783555,
-0.3880417943,
0.1334116161,
0.5550073385,
0.9208776355,
0.006273007,
-0.2378655225,
0.2470212877,
0.4173665047,
0.3071434796,
0.6828821898,
0.4145676494,
-0.3936954737,
0.784278214,
-0.1980915815,
-0.3556325734,
-0.2559641302,
-0.8986367583,
-1.0456689596,
-0.3367758989,
-0.200620681,
-0.5791352987,
0.3630367815,
0.5087302327,
0.8996027112,
-0.9023507833,
0.2871109545,
0.094636865,
0.1135571748,
-0.475871563,
-0.2180019021,
0.0809359699,
-0.1527305543,
-0.4810422063,
0.22428675,
0.4818279445,
-0.2040730417,
-0.2538164258,
0.2195207328,
0.0565804876,
0.4112904966,
0.0974851325,
0.5686404109,
-0.4064086378,
-0.6177128553,
-0.4188253582,
-0.168643564,
-0.1907265186,
0.5565579534,
-0.7341024876,
0.2108050585,
0.6771565676,
0.6547525525,
0.1697409451,
-0.0177961141,
0.7806683779,
-1.1743028164,
0.1696191281,
0.2621791661,
0.2661102712,
0.0644763634,
-0.842379868,
-0.0262912028,
0.183421731,
-0.3277254999,
-1.0837934017,
0.3992059231,
-0.7004045844,
-0.6920315623,
0.9691302776,
-0.0440177619,
-0.4807020426,
0.0008225773,
-0.1389919668,
0.1045325026,
-0.434318006,
0.8289026022,
0.6418322921,
0.2458204329,
-0.0683356673,
-0.1818919033,
0.6422049999,
0.3816293776,
-0.6407750249,
0.171123296,
-0.0761921406,
0.7150409222,
0.0527591854,
0.0455033854,
-0.2447847426,
0.3028148115,
-0.2087025642,
-0.4213963449,
0.0270062219,
-0.4193671346,
-0.4596370459,
0.488695085,
-0.0646181628,
-0.0817443207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12151v2
|
Transformer-based Causal Language Models Perform Clustering
| 2024-02-19T14:02:31 | 2024-03-03T20:06:24 |
Xinbo Wu, Lav R. Varshney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Even though large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capability in solving various natural language tasks, the capability of an LLM
to follow human instructions is still a concern. Recent works have shown great
improvements in the instruction-following capability via additional training
for instruction-following tasks. However, the mechanisms responsible for
effective instruction-following capabilities remain inadequately understood.
Here, we introduce a simplified instruction-following task and use synthetic
datasets to analyze a Transformer-based causal language model. Our findings
suggest that the model learns task-specific information by clustering data
within its hidden space, with this clustering process evolving dynamically
during learning. We also demonstrate how this phenomenon assists the model in
handling unseen instances, and validate our results in a more realistic
setting. Furthermore, we present inspired applications regarding pre-training
and alignment.
|
[
0.0858928859,
-0.7549165487,
0.7299787998,
0.1051477045,
0.0600709878,
0.0779478848,
-0.2327048331,
-0.1676472872,
-0.0572203994,
0.5699378848,
-0.8996055126,
-0.5035895109,
-0.8082479239,
-0.0190783814,
-0.744158268,
0.96999681,
0.1229631975,
-0.2402567118,
-0.2567591667,
0.1218224838,
-0.961720109,
-0.2206982821,
-0.4534909725,
-0.3574805856,
0.8244079351,
0.5455582142,
0.5569050908,
1.019538641,
0.5454235077,
0.2988462746,
0.1862897128,
-0.0928382874,
-0.6745867729,
0.0474958383,
-0.044041682,
-0.8792274594,
-0.0702443272,
-0.1330232173,
1.014850378,
1.0539784431,
-0.1589861661,
-0.0166917909,
0.1727572083,
0.3944275677,
-0.3180139065,
0.4682336152,
-0.6204125881,
-0.1084233075,
0.0379476845,
0.0060629109,
-0.7402430773,
-0.3299164474,
0.2898542285,
-0.5903099179,
0.6384872794,
0.1281150579,
0.5169289112,
0.5030943155,
-0.4261800051,
-0.3379256129,
-0.9871407747,
0.6991847157,
-0.5451550484,
0.5146788955,
0.3362831771,
0.4894703925,
-0.2394891828,
-0.7986794114,
-0.6090639234,
-0.2075954527,
-0.5913705826,
0.000571542,
-0.3453257084,
-0.2832329571,
0.2404138148,
-0.1512446553,
-0.4888946414,
0.3761532903,
-0.5158081651,
0.3236048222,
0.1974730045,
0.2830337286,
0.4031785131,
0.0432871617,
-0.2224475443,
-0.3159993291,
-0.9337382317,
0.077558279,
0.1118985787,
0.4779860675,
-0.306378454,
0.4733122885,
0.0436394475,
0.7604151964,
0.2670064569,
0.0974677056,
0.0376088582,
0.0045187064,
-0.1492686868,
0.1018034369,
0.3785800934,
-0.1673035473,
-0.0600256734,
-0.4684581459,
0.0547002144,
0.1762725711,
0.7258508801,
-0.5502739549,
-0.2937752008,
-0.1922625899,
-0.2804383636,
-0.3338877559,
0.3094249368,
-0.4528527856,
-0.2248476744,
-0.5924850702,
0.3847048879,
-0.3972202837,
0.0560729317,
-0.1089110374,
0.148911193,
0.3437367082,
0.1097136661,
-0.9296944141,
0.5084690452,
0.8520150185,
0.4432024956,
-0.580393672,
-0.4435254037,
-0.5526471138,
0.38945961,
-0.3622790575,
0.8695338368,
-0.9420124888,
-0.3727820814,
0.0024063713,
0.5919055343,
-0.5062813163,
-0.4986325204,
0.3596279919,
-0.6190716028,
0.2502673268,
-0.3238286376,
-0.6443635821,
-0.3852967322,
-0.2032242715,
-0.7512648702,
0.8871415854,
-0.0797283351,
-0.5865222812,
0.3532816768,
-0.3842762113,
-0.5654721856,
0.0112195965,
-0.3167107999,
-0.4602259994,
0.4153137505,
0.0197091307,
0.4977353811,
-0.1703590453,
0.5362327695,
-0.1000525579,
-0.5883706212,
0.1053123027,
-0.4954853356,
0.4743109345,
-0.4558636546,
-0.7155194283,
0.3367057443,
-0.9357343912,
-0.5337405801,
0.0859244615,
-0.0485882349,
-0.454647094,
0.4743476212,
-0.5566558242,
0.0708148926,
0.0026411877,
-0.3691192269,
0.1771785617,
-0.0897796974,
-0.0304169785,
0.8184393048,
0.0034677563,
0.5668003559,
-0.0580117032,
0.5048887134,
0.0038568038,
0.0345817059,
-0.3754068315,
-0.4232429266,
-1.0686923265,
0.1009981558,
-0.1846419722,
0.663657546,
-0.6334163547,
0.5169206262,
-0.3899704814,
-0.6487554312,
-0.2828563154,
-0.0642296523,
0.2861912847,
0.7761826515,
0.5658898354,
0.1971684843,
-0.3030745685,
-0.881177783,
-0.1290961504,
0.0655957684,
0.0167950895,
0.1724921614,
0.2256517708,
-0.5554761291,
0.8584825993,
-0.892803967,
-0.092020832,
-0.3074278235,
0.1247283444,
0.37237221,
0.5716794133,
0.2646256685,
-0.6378241777,
-0.4304179847,
0.1257235408,
-0.8048100471,
-0.3256235421,
-0.3231037259,
-0.1850947589,
-0.0560119413,
0.9835304618,
-0.4713405669,
0.5519818068,
0.5834527016,
-0.3349819183,
0.5163969398,
-0.2218262404,
-0.0570911057,
-0.9114204645,
0.0538857616,
0.0017730235,
0.0016146787,
-0.9129732847,
-0.0396530628,
0.1371214539,
-0.0391306356,
-0.2080182731,
0.4274495244,
-0.527551949,
-0.0103729721,
-0.645132184,
-0.0884102061,
-0.3847112358,
0.6709790826,
0.3443775773,
0.5893877745,
0.790841639,
-0.6074909568,
0.0250838082,
0.2020336986,
0.0508473366,
0.3281593919,
-0.7023451328,
0.0312556997,
-0.3584023118,
0.0403069034,
-0.9610713124,
-0.1847235262,
-0.0392727777,
0.0361781158,
0.5380989909,
-0.0126091046,
-0.5721008182,
-0.4806912541,
0.2307088822,
0.2730909586,
0.7181949615,
-0.5947990417,
0.7348909378,
0.1747850478,
-0.1534594893,
-0.3015864789,
-0.4443103373,
-0.2688222528,
-0.3035017848,
-0.174597159,
0.3102139235,
0.1635992527,
0.0565568507,
0.1612407416,
-0.2158539891,
-0.0094072651,
-0.0579456724,
0.5809528232,
0.382635802,
-0.079431124,
0.2299438119,
0.2452315837,
-0.2975561321,
0.1437430233,
-0.3131434321,
0.3588518202,
0.0243943203,
-0.5461608768,
-0.5362862349,
0.2752985656,
0.2282426953,
-0.0122728376,
1.0434370041,
0.5681468844,
-0.296209693,
-0.4120009243,
-0.4518988729,
-0.6009334326,
-0.5389511585,
0.3755338192,
-0.0094378414,
-1.2375309467,
0.4512119591,
-0.053727176,
0.1632432193,
0.4201876819,
0.3478085399,
-0.2969382405,
0.8355306387,
1.0836421251,
-0.0479138531,
0.5792332888,
0.0859112665,
0.3526027501,
-0.5548916459,
-0.3496367037,
-0.4882712066,
-0.2679721117,
-0.8161061406,
-0.6339911819,
0.4998240471,
0.0809360445,
-0.1666503251,
0.8022562861,
-0.3014238179,
0.424133718,
0.6991257071,
0.2058126479,
0.1378716975,
-0.0135679943,
-0.011394063,
0.0784571245,
-0.9911704659,
-0.2935367823,
0.6436156631,
0.1816395074,
0.9307350516,
-0.1130316705,
0.478772819,
0.2092869431,
0.665122211,
-0.3699536324,
0.6042025089,
-0.3449096084,
-0.1331154853,
-0.3088544011,
-0.4930004776,
-1.2662218809,
0.1524562836,
-0.2039302737,
-0.7783750296,
-0.0449659377,
0.205740422,
0.0176253319,
0.2223054022,
-0.7268587351,
0.8035001755,
0.04898661,
-0.2365497351,
-0.376539886,
-0.7777925134,
0.0993345678,
-0.3548237383,
0.2123580873,
0.2538384199,
0.2802355289,
0.641263783,
-0.1824638546,
1.423433423,
-0.0414209627,
-0.1129223928,
0.3951048851,
0.1122924313,
0.6487145424,
-0.4173051119,
0.3300599456,
-0.1037926227,
-0.500484705,
-0.3124949932,
-0.9050574303,
0.7281247973,
-0.4917923808,
-0.978947401,
-0.0265828688,
-0.5915701985,
-0.2777310908,
0.381706208,
0.0442896485,
0.3956094384,
-0.096544221,
0.2413425297,
0.6895633936,
-0.3410746157,
0.5747680068,
0.6996992826,
0.0437277891,
0.1614770144,
0.8228094578,
-0.0228294041,
0.1972561479,
0.7128889561,
0.3348230124,
-0.2336589992,
-0.1753908247,
-0.1421338767,
0.5403530598,
-0.5309112072,
-0.0257688593,
-0.6495550871,
-0.0659022704,
-0.2800607979,
-0.32937029,
-0.1495629549,
-0.1328201741,
-0.4455440044,
-0.4089592397,
0.0873974785,
0.9878985882,
0.3294488192,
0.6606549025,
-1.0010800362,
0.0619961433,
0.4864238799,
0.3716717362,
0.347445935,
-0.5235168934,
-0.3089398146,
-0.2249588072,
-0.1443604678,
-0.8895232677,
0.2193599492,
0.0089640245,
0.7491162419,
0.3695851564,
-0.2871433794,
0.6137153506,
-1.034681797,
0.4974358976,
0.023380233,
-0.7256532311,
0.5936341286,
-0.412250042,
0.5674197078,
0.2439202219,
0.5202028751,
-0.4503297806,
-0.5816473961,
-0.5620363951,
-0.4431369901,
0.7666981816,
0.1952624917,
0.1430988908,
-0.1620635241,
0.4299737513,
0.1494785398,
0.1177146062,
-0.7674883604,
-0.2067793608,
0.2001848966,
-0.2130825371,
-0.2133116722,
-0.0389335155,
0.1457479894,
-0.243662864,
0.5745382309,
-0.1032784209,
0.3211455941,
-0.2379573584,
-0.102380909,
-0.0287370682,
-0.0236478411,
0.5340263247,
0.3273044825,
0.2952072322,
0.2071626633,
0.1638784409,
-0.4213491976,
0.0744354799,
0.1579358578,
-0.2639769316,
-0.1747238934,
0.7255301476,
0.9937288165,
0.7018660903,
-0.661780417,
0.3794410229,
0.1177619994,
0.1908220947,
-0.2578902543,
0.4210623503,
0.2222089469,
0.4019933939,
0.507445097,
0.0189876631,
0.0100195371,
-0.4150306284,
0.4718192816,
0.2250934392,
-0.710996151,
-0.6978169084,
0.6640338302,
-0.1731669456,
-0.2767452002,
0.5646366477,
0.1164113358,
-0.467379123,
0.6488671303,
0.8504433632,
0.6837971807,
-0.5703626275,
0.2186066806,
0.1441169828,
0.4074237347,
-0.2192382365,
-0.1682268083,
-0.1015882343,
-0.551637888,
-0.481600821,
-0.445022583,
-0.0830594078,
-0.3300292492,
-0.7520676255,
0.2695035636,
0.0116136866,
0.2012754679,
-0.1871773303,
-0.5577830076,
-0.8182680607,
0.219998464,
-0.0882755145,
0.5659765005,
-1.0274732113,
0.9335423112,
0.4146337211,
-0.0199299473,
-1.0217249393,
0.1441392601,
-0.0787938684,
-0.8283424973,
0.622243464,
0.3978124261,
-0.0910648108,
0.1405195445,
-0.4328218699,
-0.9926533699,
1.075683713,
0.1977801621,
-0.6894732118,
-0.2174894661,
0.2478640229,
0.7404561639,
-0.3757035136,
-0.1406840086,
0.6424490809,
0.1712360531,
0.0884689242,
-0.3611806035,
0.1498766243,
-0.0121977385,
-0.2274228483,
0.3052154183,
-0.4068680108,
0.5768137574,
-0.1518948525,
-0.3328008652,
-0.252089262,
0.6911202669,
0.0238977801,
0.0465272553,
0.4257363975,
0.5146191716,
0.6404049993,
0.075008668,
1.1387988329,
-0.097076416,
0.1891993582,
1.3708924055,
-0.2561126947,
0.8204414248,
0.3020578623,
-0.0041897981,
1.0088794231,
0.0671048984,
-0.1506059468,
0.6296687722,
0.0574419051,
-0.1191727892,
-0.0154715981,
0.0942469612,
0.1256688088,
0.3047190011,
0.3590874374,
-0.462846458,
-0.2726053596,
-0.029656766,
-0.0774067789,
0.0262190383,
-0.2835901082,
0.803771317,
0.0249840226,
-0.7984682918,
0.1907928586,
-0.2064165324,
0.2542614639,
-0.5266210437,
-0.3140000403,
-0.0904367268,
-0.0265390333,
-0.065305002,
-0.5503512025,
0.4703375101,
0.0130400043,
-0.3373137116,
-0.1705036908,
0.6842205524,
-0.4913011789,
-0.8020755649,
0.3698388934,
0.5734604597,
-0.1545746475,
0.2311264127,
-0.2178944498,
-0.0293910597,
-0.0470694192,
-0.1568859518,
0.3016349971,
0.326489985,
-0.4704956412,
0.6663739681,
0.6248252392,
-0.142118752,
0.386472553,
0.3168584406,
0.7915535569,
-0.6345670819,
-0.6796262264,
-0.8603257537,
0.3896567523,
0.082821548,
0.2096994668,
0.797749579,
0.2915740609,
0.7519724369,
-0.235827297,
0.5181586146,
0.1703838259,
0.6228900552,
-0.4688644111,
0.525160253,
-0.1337755471,
0.3208201826,
-0.2949945331,
-1.0506993532,
-0.4751964211,
0.4277079105,
-0.5012563467,
-0.1234688535,
0.8447085023,
0.6981695294,
-0.2245418876,
0.2108227164,
0.2496348023,
0.3516593575,
0.3671251237,
0.2946668267,
0.6337481141,
-0.0456556678,
0.2317349762,
0.0147700366,
-0.3941159844,
0.1513020694,
-0.786131978,
-1.1021023989,
-0.7368622422,
-0.0733429492,
0.0327190533,
-0.116335094,
0.651550293,
0.7519988418,
-0.8213542104,
-0.2450689226,
-0.6302396059,
0.0245566182,
-0.4301616251,
-0.2495133877,
0.5644021034,
-0.4306432307,
-0.4930127263,
0.560626626,
0.1561347544,
0.0980592594,
-0.0573088042,
0.290017426,
0.0198895987,
0.0718261525,
0.6560655236,
0.1601640731,
-0.5743235946,
-0.5149301887,
0.3245691657,
0.0701021999,
-0.0759114772,
1.1261862516,
-0.891371727,
0.2312480211,
0.1293679625,
0.8609342575,
0.59366256,
0.032778319,
0.5979123712,
-0.7337450981,
-0.0043147099,
-0.0068249637,
0.2197713703,
0.1666327864,
-0.4716348052,
0.2893272936,
0.2913562357,
-0.386956811,
-0.5468034148,
0.1543920785,
-0.8123903871,
-0.2915582061,
0.8878147602,
-0.0899217278,
-0.1820940077,
0.1851486266,
0.0761805102,
0.4407615066,
-0.1256369203,
0.9340547323,
0.4206342697,
-0.3593770266,
-0.3576667607,
-0.3556661308,
0.2657523155,
0.306122154,
-1.0587214231,
0.1050857827,
0.4219542444,
0.2151169926,
0.1331248879,
0.236115098,
0.0284432713,
0.037228696,
-0.1513201147,
-0.3408707976,
0.2492931485,
-0.771489501,
-0.396840632,
0.2237360477,
-0.3674178123,
0.0582192093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12150v1
|
Your Large Language Model is Secretly a Fairness Proponent and You Should Prompt it Like One
| 2024-02-19T14:02:22 | 2024-02-19T14:02:22 |
Tianlin Li, Xiaoyu Zhang, Chao Du, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Qing Guo, Chao Shen, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2; J.4
|
The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) underscores the
urgent need to ensure their fairness. However, LLMs frequently present dominant
viewpoints while ignoring alternative perspectives from minority parties,
resulting in potential biases. We hypothesize that these fairness-violating
behaviors occur because LLMs express their viewpoints using a human personality
that represents the majority of training data. In response to this, we validate
that prompting LLMs with specific roles can allow LLMs to express diverse
viewpoints. Building on this insight and observation, we develop FairThinking,
a pipeline designed to automatically generate roles that enable LLMs to
articulate diverse perspectives for fair expressions. To evaluate FairThinking,
we create a dataset with a thousand items covering three fairness-related
topics and conduct experiments on GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Llama2, and Mistral to
demonstrate its superior performance.
|
[
-0.4229409695,
-0.3128321469,
0.8552660346,
0.239283517,
-0.1378282011,
-0.1212836727,
-0.1167912036,
-0.2656531632,
-0.1364608854,
0.5153006315,
-0.4452334642,
-0.079885684,
-0.8322687745,
0.0460415334,
-0.3531412184,
1.2097655535,
0.2511516213,
0.4377939105,
-0.0074129789,
-0.121205911,
-0.6714478731,
-0.4569780529,
-0.7859671116,
-0.6857739091,
0.7909029126,
0.4080975056,
0.726485908,
0.6404474974,
0.1352797896,
0.2880842984,
-0.1392375678,
-0.3015162051,
-0.4878211915,
0.1194897592,
-0.4081524312,
-0.9518771172,
-0.4804098606,
0.3399896324,
0.7252554297,
0.8663306236,
-0.3692156672,
0.1931633055,
0.109129265,
0.6764652133,
-0.5915601254,
0.0368813165,
-0.9756910205,
0.4082695544,
-0.5010111928,
0.1268847883,
-0.3449616432,
-0.456638962,
0.0559558794,
-0.2310589701,
0.2757679522,
0.0099704284,
0.5474458933,
0.0915603563,
-0.4909979403,
0.0386930816,
-0.3156486452,
0.9218890667,
-0.7823407054,
0.22750476,
0.2681709826,
0.5070713162,
-0.144997552,
-0.4172605574,
-0.9577196836,
0.0219828356,
0.0148427468,
-0.0786536112,
0.0122985952,
0.1377061456,
0.5452591777,
0.4053691626,
-0.4850040972,
0.4615095258,
-0.2153608501,
-0.2637060881,
0.4969341457,
0.2234471589,
-0.0370779,
-0.3029162288,
-0.0860703662,
0.1026374847,
-0.7533388734,
0.3117447197,
0.7750686407,
0.2742789984,
-0.1398639828,
0.6141524911,
-0.1529396474,
0.5178810954,
0.1926619262,
0.185591951,
0.1963062435,
0.2665010989,
-0.4376298487,
0.1185563654,
0.5545672774,
0.6567255259,
0.4634228647,
-0.114204742,
-0.3847836852,
0.1282633096,
0.1926069856,
-0.7464845777,
0.0873870477,
0.2627301514,
-0.6686012745,
-0.5149156451,
-0.0384291895,
-0.6229760647,
-0.9816321135,
-0.5332143307,
0.2847232223,
0.1271579117,
-0.3748413324,
0.2188464403,
-0.1916186661,
0.4010756314,
0.4534023106,
-0.9960964918,
0.1420690119,
0.8939809203,
0.4110337496,
-0.2538140714,
-0.2609989941,
-1.0403950214,
0.1327312738,
-0.2346154302,
0.5783507824,
-0.6370473504,
-0.3294866681,
-0.1259521991,
0.0788810402,
0.2054565251,
-0.6121277809,
0.5757567883,
-0.4849246442,
0.5476207733,
-0.6856864095,
-0.517796874,
0.0764523819,
0.4492984116,
-0.6349596381,
0.4317153692,
-0.0243323743,
-1.0101900101,
0.6677074432,
-0.7546853423,
-0.2307348847,
0.0262508411,
-0.6472665668,
-0.2962187529,
0.3380555212,
0.188739568,
0.4627421796,
-0.0778763965,
0.6963759661,
-0.4826960862,
-0.292530477,
0.4682206213,
-0.682982564,
0.9288482666,
0.3244073093,
-0.391951859,
0.012980544,
-0.2763557136,
-0.1062216908,
0.0621207803,
-0.3529336452,
-0.0096428888,
-0.0577145554,
-0.0995879695,
0.4608410299,
-0.0877679214,
-0.495839864,
0.0513786376,
-0.5630850196,
0.2913842201,
1.3724125624,
-0.4715104103,
0.7121335864,
-0.5319649577,
0.4452927113,
0.1040879786,
0.0883187801,
0.2487463653,
-0.49436602,
-0.6036034226,
-0.156859085,
0.145937562,
0.494502455,
-0.4834360778,
0.1786607951,
-0.1875879914,
-0.0224158596,
-0.7076955438,
0.101926893,
0.049015604,
0.5238639116,
-0.0036264476,
-0.3759876788,
-0.6034628749,
-1.307595253,
-0.6555168629,
-0.0381752476,
-0.1608324498,
0.2169814855,
0.2579051256,
0.0021215295,
1.1431419849,
-0.0989205465,
-0.1672241241,
-0.351247102,
-0.1264209896,
0.39424631,
0.3575180173,
0.6082409024,
-0.907016933,
-0.2605398893,
-0.3607165515,
-0.7357457876,
-0.3176805079,
0.0946573988,
-0.1051749662,
0.117858693,
0.4184282422,
-0.5623828769,
0.306221664,
0.5417734385,
-0.3795261681,
0.3268972933,
0.2120243758,
0.157051906,
-0.9482138753,
0.0333130918,
-0.1401699632,
-0.4453377724,
-0.261415273,
-0.0055753938,
-0.3023912311,
0.1005024984,
-0.610639751,
0.6939129829,
-0.1251184642,
-0.1433043033,
-0.350364536,
0.1565576047,
-0.0194739979,
0.1503566653,
-0.2314263135,
0.4055315852,
0.6305238008,
-0.3816186786,
0.1555070281,
-0.1021142155,
-0.2162610739,
0.8467916846,
-0.5201848149,
0.0647973567,
-0.6443611979,
0.6190063953,
-0.7178052664,
-0.2309902161,
0.2344682068,
-0.1828707755,
-0.0575193018,
-0.4415815771,
-0.5198566318,
-0.2578686178,
-0.3271864355,
0.385886699,
0.4550378919,
-0.5536421537,
0.6898944378,
0.6799691319,
-0.232087329,
-0.9206523895,
-0.8889843225,
0.175124377,
-0.5610948801,
-0.5447182655,
0.2661784887,
-0.233208701,
-0.5157374144,
-0.177559644,
-0.0713986009,
0.1938266605,
0.2725578845,
0.2626392543,
0.1081980765,
0.0712730065,
-0.1238674596,
0.0669455901,
-0.0271746758,
0.1294757426,
-0.2309053987,
0.5202074051,
-0.0934897289,
-0.4870111346,
-0.3682119846,
0.3684796691,
0.3332067728,
-0.0924517065,
0.4750095904,
0.6305767298,
-0.3827821612,
-0.3523334265,
-0.6528872848,
-0.2126097381,
-0.5366863608,
0.3447482884,
-0.1125145853,
-1.2187279463,
0.4941290319,
0.305403918,
0.5091646314,
0.1091827676,
0.7378497124,
0.0002592119,
1.2291589975,
0.6729018092,
-0.0598211847,
0.4491127133,
0.0597325563,
0.3200567663,
-0.4902200699,
-0.1800248623,
-0.4853738844,
-0.5677419305,
-0.7569052577,
-0.4776352048,
0.0891390517,
-0.0405917205,
-0.4051150084,
-0.3311274946,
-0.3826136887,
0.8053049445,
0.362184763,
-0.1569697559,
0.3897275329,
0.0762172341,
-0.063165009,
-0.2317252606,
-0.4467362761,
-0.7832940817,
1.0773968697,
0.5197359324,
0.7189965844,
0.3046392798,
0.6866981983,
0.3701368868,
0.7251935005,
-0.7125136256,
0.6128676534,
-0.3109232485,
-0.8278912902,
-0.0174143128,
-0.533763051,
-0.7236828208,
0.4435259998,
-0.0073686503,
-0.6417816877,
0.0610941276,
0.3392565846,
-0.1181927398,
0.4319871962,
-0.7150436044,
0.695730865,
-0.0211166125,
-0.2465401441,
-0.3669734299,
-0.6201831698,
0.490286231,
0.0529757999,
0.4221818447,
-0.3023442328,
0.0792832822,
0.6448428035,
-0.0900243744,
0.9851554036,
-0.6317296624,
-0.3914292753,
0.0443714559,
0.3229751885,
0.1942983717,
0.3841688037,
-0.5257270336,
0.0482252315,
-0.337660253,
-0.4586000144,
-0.4462444484,
0.8019217849,
-0.566850543,
-0.8775330782,
-0.5414173007,
-0.553255558,
-0.3526635766,
0.1164118201,
0.1812101901,
-0.0569178797,
-0.1665317267,
0.0970778316,
0.6263152957,
-0.1370593309,
0.4495865107,
0.3786470592,
-0.3900671899,
0.198101595,
0.5420129299,
-0.0371042974,
0.2730693221,
0.0263572112,
0.2253265679,
-0.3157686293,
-0.5118120909,
-0.3817808032,
0.0382964537,
-0.6755047441,
-0.1200970784,
-0.7190880775,
-0.071875073,
-0.327994734,
-0.1185215339,
-0.224162221,
-0.4293800294,
0.1709999889,
-0.1976099461,
0.0574857555,
0.7114047408,
-0.2858406901,
0.3309136033,
-0.4227892756,
0.305193454,
0.7197374701,
0.6066668034,
0.2934906185,
-0.6246362925,
0.103796877,
0.1459549963,
-0.5531643033,
-0.3408631384,
-0.0576962978,
-0.1230716854,
0.9375127554,
0.3074002862,
-0.2983235717,
0.2473322004,
-0.8199224472,
0.7840854526,
0.2347791344,
-1.0192970037,
0.4425810277,
-0.3272573948,
-0.043398235,
0.3805874288,
0.1481178403,
-0.6588823795,
-0.7531780005,
-0.5221509337,
-0.5515839458,
0.7951523066,
0.1871644557,
0.3222745955,
-0.0076462817,
0.13096717,
0.3713594377,
0.4741700292,
-1.244482398,
-0.1056464314,
-0.3314953446,
-0.2438014448,
0.1096994504,
0.0511450358,
-0.396574676,
0.0482039638,
0.2202168405,
-0.1669421941,
0.0508859418,
-0.0145889577,
-0.0567151085,
-0.1458698809,
0.5994331837,
0.2136127204,
0.6810079217,
0.0449990816,
0.2961390018,
0.1188667342,
-0.2715452313,
0.0153609412,
0.0405073427,
0.0266022794,
-0.2244462818,
0.0476934388,
0.5731610656,
-0.3473379612,
-0.5997951627,
0.7375621796,
-0.2443824261,
-0.0533787161,
-0.0355611928,
0.3447520435,
0.2268915027,
0.4531669617,
0.2690280676,
0.1334577054,
0.2358723283,
-0.707824707,
0.0650072768,
0.4700578153,
-0.1757532358,
-0.2019365132,
0.7481408119,
0.2127575129,
-0.1761109829,
0.3983477354,
-0.2949853837,
-0.5286903977,
0.5901255012,
0.1720663458,
0.6729323268,
-0.0275991503,
0.0705159977,
-0.1013205647,
0.2389223278,
-0.276948452,
0.2235345244,
0.3073049188,
-0.8418118954,
-0.6127539873,
-0.6892209649,
-0.2335955054,
0.1151380613,
-0.372741431,
0.4409089088,
-0.4758004248,
-0.2319818884,
0.009710744,
-0.1679065078,
-0.9560477734,
0.0454372205,
0.5800024867,
0.7485185862,
-0.9058467746,
0.6360343099,
0.4014056325,
-0.2085301727,
-0.7457526326,
0.1814106107,
0.2215126008,
-0.9075937867,
0.7419314981,
0.2828175128,
0.0725944191,
-0.2474767417,
-0.8212759495,
-0.109266229,
0.9278280139,
0.7896189094,
-0.7383444309,
-0.253756851,
0.2834466994,
0.224182874,
-0.4865916371,
0.0952274799,
0.2670562863,
0.4895583093,
-0.2264850438,
-1.07348001,
0.1241029873,
0.0519225448,
-0.0258630086,
-0.2869898677,
-0.5677041411,
1.0752477646,
-0.2988995612,
0.1002878919,
-0.1292880028,
0.3846381605,
0.6579089165,
0.4193229377,
0.9860996604,
0.5341374874,
0.9035746455,
0.0568591096,
0.9247553349,
0.3564017713,
0.036884632,
1.088968277,
-0.6199653149,
0.3703019321,
0.5956286192,
0.0046847393,
0.4316137135,
0.4295830727,
-0.0451724678,
0.4018653631,
0.6379308105,
-0.303676188,
-0.4061217904,
-0.2537243962,
-0.4277755618,
0.4602127075,
0.1266439259,
-0.2857632041,
-0.3614429235,
0.1225914657,
0.1483921558,
0.3507757187,
-0.4565578997,
0.3918713331,
0.4136456251,
-0.582265079,
0.0082166307,
0.2206282616,
1.0128171444,
-0.2783636749,
-0.0484281369,
-0.2612255812,
0.0493587889,
-0.3367245197,
-1.2483046055,
0.1132211015,
0.1803157032,
-0.3640465736,
-0.4821226597,
0.3168540001,
-0.2042285204,
-0.240383625,
0.2854710221,
0.7408474684,
0.033359535,
0.0525891259,
-0.694550395,
0.1005956233,
0.125469327,
-0.1287958026,
0.5164251328,
0.8240038157,
-0.3057323694,
0.6024837494,
0.5336201787,
0.1963642091,
-0.170263499,
0.5226073265,
0.8365542293,
-0.6193658113,
-0.7191048265,
-0.9616732001,
0.7245982885,
-0.306399852,
-0.0682020038,
0.4317414761,
0.5228201747,
0.8406631351,
0.2195069045,
0.9079748392,
-0.1134505048,
0.5143452287,
-0.4655283093,
0.9608303905,
-0.5212901831,
0.5320488811,
-0.2472483367,
-0.8819429874,
-0.0685507432,
0.6032116413,
-0.3515662849,
0.3496355116,
0.2377158999,
0.8031632304,
-0.2096076459,
0.2164765745,
0.1342746913,
0.370574683,
0.8045141697,
0.5892612338,
1.0650956631,
-0.0294644758,
0.4928742051,
0.317437619,
-0.2367875576,
-0.0393208526,
-1.2807596922,
-0.9480574727,
-0.18689017,
0.0355751403,
-0.5479316711,
-0.0825074539,
1.0288444757,
0.7218142152,
-0.5222674012,
-0.3084153533,
0.0234804023,
0.3171740472,
0.3812886178,
-0.2679710984,
-0.1158835962,
-0.1661465466,
-0.7249312997,
-0.0469822884,
-0.0930695757,
-0.1153201535,
-0.3419227898,
-0.066367887,
0.2046723962,
-0.104224354,
0.6237456799,
-0.1215500906,
-0.6504688263,
-0.4340215921,
-0.2447853088,
-0.3028478622,
-0.0173125304,
0.866279006,
-0.8540827036,
0.1635807753,
0.3196552694,
0.627584219,
0.0524761043,
-0.3984183073,
0.8185403943,
-0.6554825902,
0.2666130662,
0.5831012726,
0.3558625579,
0.5786545277,
-0.2792010307,
0.2402725965,
0.2260082215,
-0.5639923811,
-1.0467640162,
0.4259880483,
-0.8489931226,
-0.2723846734,
0.8691852093,
0.226803273,
-0.035715621,
0.0226579681,
-0.2955889702,
0.0359935053,
-0.6744901538,
0.9320197105,
0.7850607634,
-0.1113244519,
0.0448090695,
-0.7697191238,
0.6142157912,
0.5840067267,
-0.6931962967,
0.1874999851,
0.4299758673,
0.5941494107,
-0.2816141844,
0.9186705351,
-0.3744183481,
0.2048833668,
-0.5642017722,
-0.214830488,
0.293320924,
0.119900547,
-0.3765982389,
0.1006940529,
0.3335129023,
0.2872182727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14845v1
|
Purifying Large Language Models by Ensembling a Small Language Model
| 2024-02-19T14:00:39 | 2024-02-19T14:00:39 |
Tianlin Li, Qian Liu, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Qing Guo, Yang Liu, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2
|
The emerging success of large language models (LLMs) heavily relies on
collecting abundant training data from external (untrusted) sources. Despite
substantial efforts devoted to data cleaning and curation, well-constructed
LLMs have been reported to suffer from copyright infringement, data poisoning,
and/or privacy violations, which would impede practical deployment of LLMs. In
this study, we propose a simple and easily implementable method for purifying
LLMs from the negative effects caused by uncurated data, namely, through
ensembling LLMs with benign and small language models (SLMs). Aside from
theoretical guarantees, we perform comprehensive experiments to empirically
confirm the efficacy of ensembling LLMs with SLMs, which can effectively
preserve the performance of LLMs while mitigating issues such as copyright
infringement, data poisoning, and privacy violations.
|
[
-0.2295017987,
-0.7943056822,
0.6840055585,
-0.2447039038,
-0.4989133775,
0.0494357459,
-0.5604497194,
-0.419300735,
0.1277024448,
1.0649232864,
-0.1436073631,
-0.3140867949,
-0.4994066954,
-0.1270530969,
-0.7072642446,
0.9604296684,
0.1792894453,
0.0103312247,
-0.3195084631,
0.1177655458,
-0.2847335935,
-0.4453391135,
-0.6663994193,
-0.5644953251,
0.2285943925,
0.5461277962,
0.5805804729,
0.815762639,
0.3209149241,
0.2951983511,
-0.3791108727,
0.3976669312,
-0.8325199485,
0.125857994,
-0.3409166634,
-0.6520303488,
-0.1394465864,
0.0018344965,
0.7558131218,
0.6602879763,
-0.2313625216,
0.2778845429,
0.5304142833,
0.5897382498,
-0.6753650308,
-0.2039152086,
-0.9506540298,
-0.1484304518,
-0.4964800477,
-0.2629638314,
-0.8248235583,
-0.4645493329,
-0.384712249,
-0.1913344264,
0.0833858252,
0.1038197875,
0.7414875627,
0.2925623357,
-0.1969495714,
-0.1213191822,
-0.9617283344,
1.0425903797,
-1.1942021847,
0.3570370376,
0.4894651771,
0.1608856916,
-0.2762926519,
-0.4827161729,
-0.4895516932,
-0.1217392012,
-0.1683929116,
-0.3093949556,
-0.1866857708,
-0.1092838719,
0.2910148501,
0.2566240728,
-0.5138946176,
0.4208909571,
-0.428034246,
-0.2389618903,
0.737621367,
0.1707888246,
0.2658160031,
-0.0605761558,
-0.2280193865,
0.2409446537,
-1.4389983416,
-0.1652007848,
0.67054528,
0.5633121133,
0.2086353153,
0.9068798423,
-0.0735442713,
0.5740773082,
-0.0234565046,
-0.287700057,
0.0002874402,
-0.1765169948,
-0.3941112757,
0.0154541824,
0.6136877537,
-0.034987431,
0.3421620727,
-0.419965148,
-0.4126178622,
-0.0735225156,
0.2809936106,
-0.8447283506,
-0.1898419857,
0.410381794,
-0.5258970857,
-0.3176045418,
-0.2448064685,
-0.8325745463,
-0.7693053484,
-0.5540757775,
0.4236347079,
-0.1326627582,
-0.1973125637,
0.2087481022,
0.1223105341,
-0.0669253618,
0.2710523605,
-0.7454508543,
0.2599435449,
0.968211472,
0.6836578846,
-0.0970301107,
0.1045166999,
-0.7038958669,
0.4402219951,
-0.2005172074,
0.5852767229,
-0.5214846134,
-0.3551442623,
0.161816299,
0.0638073683,
0.2421559691,
-1.0070685148,
0.4374023676,
-0.6590192914,
-0.0634665862,
0.1524993628,
-0.7392829657,
-0.0318820961,
0.3911599219,
-0.7466709018,
0.5539702177,
-0.4128488302,
-0.7509031892,
-0.1701630056,
-0.1236970574,
-0.4591318369,
0.0158226583,
-0.0347330272,
-0.483168751,
0.3377375305,
0.0294395145,
0.4657471776,
-0.2935059667,
0.3625925779,
-0.5806914568,
-0.3423571587,
0.3416166902,
-0.442072928,
1.0387403965,
0.3977973163,
0.0062406445,
-0.0027050667,
-0.7163926959,
-0.0270994678,
0.1791201681,
-0.4769698083,
-0.7983247638,
0.2132127881,
-0.2418182045,
0.1093475148,
0.3484554291,
-0.7393221855,
0.0752836317,
-0.6583408713,
0.4799839556,
0.7641783357,
0.0863897055,
0.739010036,
-0.3005603552,
0.4296244383,
0.1333334148,
0.1909214854,
0.1983584166,
-0.4954341352,
-0.8335339427,
-0.2516887784,
0.1252583712,
0.2252675146,
-0.8293017149,
0.2221013755,
-0.4388400912,
-0.585287869,
-0.5324444175,
0.4653572738,
0.3103421926,
0.4373143911,
0.1274669021,
-0.071809791,
-0.4150602818,
-0.9986090064,
-0.4756348729,
-0.0097910371,
-0.0555621125,
0.2058968991,
0.5211388469,
-0.3149866164,
0.9770625234,
-0.4498813748,
-0.3014246225,
-0.1448433995,
-0.1418693513,
0.1218774766,
0.7229696512,
0.1715629697,
-0.4043971896,
-0.3671319783,
-0.2112625539,
-0.4557641149,
-0.1950450689,
0.1492785811,
-0.0557953455,
0.021468116,
0.676759541,
-0.6034728885,
0.3505810201,
0.3866921365,
-0.1250886172,
0.5749120712,
-0.1193427518,
-0.0784832165,
-0.7505868673,
0.1290323436,
-0.1176507622,
-0.4653882086,
-0.8125341535,
0.4669810832,
0.1308148801,
-0.279730767,
-0.7665908337,
0.7521656752,
-0.3382710516,
0.276927501,
-0.4253689349,
0.1186714768,
0.1246800497,
0.1540268064,
-0.0305502918,
0.3339422643,
0.2332415283,
-0.5727092028,
0.0964641273,
0.0396553986,
-0.4048041105,
0.305586189,
-0.4439809322,
0.2094439268,
-0.3101589978,
-0.0554098003,
-0.8738235831,
-0.0286728721,
0.233719036,
-0.0561184473,
0.5184568763,
-0.5127875805,
-0.8036990762,
-0.0928737894,
-0.2770080864,
0.3809787333,
0.6500775814,
-0.9012610316,
0.426294297,
0.6984136105,
-0.1288719475,
-0.4078510404,
-0.9095652103,
0.0692936033,
-0.786297977,
-0.5325666666,
0.0397240669,
-0.0033114883,
-0.3584312201,
-0.020898832,
0.0258494429,
-0.0825110897,
0.2472836673,
0.2757863402,
0.1844480038,
0.0206168052,
0.0066841906,
-0.117258966,
-0.0784094855,
0.0605068803,
-0.0179680344,
0.7035223842,
0.0853199065,
-0.4978504181,
-0.0479101613,
0.2930980921,
0.4411555231,
-0.33808586,
0.7984116077,
-0.0033365136,
-0.7383531332,
-0.5245816708,
-0.7261617184,
-0.3547878563,
-0.5522288084,
0.1305048019,
0.0392504074,
-0.9020090103,
0.4887478054,
-0.1949651241,
0.2319109142,
0.1073018014,
0.4008191228,
-0.1119787842,
1.0301362276,
0.481649518,
-0.2392230928,
0.3567658663,
-0.1210188866,
0.5186751485,
-0.7682278156,
-0.1723695844,
-0.7479612231,
-0.4319042563,
-0.4258556068,
-0.4090698659,
0.1118721068,
0.2060600072,
-0.4840950668,
0.2894673049,
-0.3646524847,
0.7503482103,
0.4530261457,
0.2135739774,
0.7570614815,
0.1528963894,
0.0710997283,
-0.1957686543,
-0.4345730245,
-0.8384279013,
1.0298626423,
0.5518137217,
1.3856807947,
0.2085441202,
1.1720006466,
-0.1800079942,
0.4968857169,
-0.6265367866,
0.7486886382,
-0.4545969963,
-0.6743270159,
-0.3039534688,
-0.4799471796,
-0.916655004,
0.201854527,
0.0035404689,
-0.9168241024,
0.2225990742,
0.1526067108,
-0.2937190831,
0.5142139196,
-0.7022799253,
0.7147916555,
-0.1218906939,
-0.5843909383,
-0.3916602433,
-0.2099550962,
0.8402491808,
-0.4863237441,
0.5401521325,
-0.1209018081,
-0.0256037302,
0.6825146079,
-0.6195345521,
0.9645554423,
-0.3137299418,
-0.4521732628,
0.2963504791,
0.5484064221,
0.741620481,
0.0155007532,
-0.0142304748,
0.1366721988,
-0.0127075305,
-0.0323795527,
-0.5660066009,
0.9180088639,
-0.4708338082,
-0.7817203999,
-0.1050816625,
-0.3960103691,
-0.1849620044,
0.33577618,
0.0444924273,
0.1776386052,
0.1015180051,
0.2727583647,
0.7853360176,
-0.3268412948,
0.4652459919,
0.8945206404,
-0.4478399456,
0.0005397876,
1.1459286213,
0.0604311042,
0.3349258006,
0.1154016703,
0.2561648488,
-0.3275261521,
-0.8841645122,
-0.141802609,
0.4329216182,
-0.6173344851,
-0.3832279742,
-0.363845408,
-0.2323568165,
-0.1966791302,
0.0695139319,
-0.6971808672,
-0.2818749249,
-0.3609902263,
0.276563555,
0.0991732404,
0.5863596797,
0.0016975162,
0.3690656424,
-0.906911552,
0.1737585217,
0.0726869479,
0.4945552945,
0.1162166595,
-0.8712942004,
-0.3333533108,
0.4073702097,
-0.2256672233,
-0.5474510193,
0.6533657312,
0.1647039354,
0.3984031677,
0.6194061041,
0.0339929238,
0.8168673515,
-0.82566154,
0.6790524721,
-0.0288046375,
-0.7535825968,
0.6375047565,
-0.1375969201,
0.0362806953,
0.5355452895,
0.1018523797,
-0.4909499288,
-0.832562387,
-0.4585537314,
-0.8910452724,
0.6506370902,
0.0003273836,
0.1751814336,
-0.0103208637,
0.2794244885,
-0.0139726298,
0.2474135906,
-0.6721619368,
-0.0772680864,
0.1818908751,
-0.2131783366,
-0.2652241588,
-0.2621527314,
-0.3822008371,
-0.0185167808,
1.0318495035,
0.3191459477,
-0.0537988618,
-0.4565314054,
-0.4974445701,
-0.0934749544,
0.4109934866,
0.2250642031,
0.1003147066,
-0.0361885093,
0.564617753,
-0.1948440969,
-0.2640638053,
0.4337581396,
-0.1859737188,
-0.5077593923,
-0.2656514049,
0.0655228645,
0.0370653272,
0.2908144593,
-0.9782950282,
0.456034869,
0.0562915765,
0.3317246437,
-0.2292233706,
0.1274070293,
0.4367835224,
0.156113103,
-0.0641805679,
-0.0553190336,
0.0731536075,
-0.442789048,
0.2422149777,
0.5796338916,
0.0971701294,
-0.0900717601,
0.6412565708,
0.1265569478,
-0.0947862566,
0.6718829274,
-0.1627169102,
-0.24481076,
0.3028675616,
0.7278059125,
0.6464403272,
-0.2699966729,
-0.0467961952,
0.277377218,
0.5218154192,
-0.5419077873,
0.0852039084,
0.2655922174,
-0.9980459809,
-0.4586623907,
-0.716178596,
-0.1916879117,
0.4857286811,
-0.5809530616,
0.0264668372,
-0.4219151437,
-0.0734309331,
-0.1997353733,
-0.0225108787,
-0.7005358934,
-0.0088007199,
0.4574328363,
0.8783554435,
-1.0238229036,
0.9617049694,
0.4465697408,
-0.3611954749,
-0.8521595597,
-0.2760300338,
0.1438302845,
-0.7856048942,
0.5152203441,
0.0525720492,
0.0216575488,
-0.008010258,
-0.70408988,
-0.9400259852,
0.5134584904,
0.7679849267,
-0.8593589067,
0.1065884233,
0.5042861104,
0.4376857579,
0.0698107556,
-0.2246893197,
0.8315689564,
0.4061054587,
-0.281142801,
-0.6096209288,
0.248476401,
-0.3368463814,
-0.0630778745,
0.2064804286,
-0.4716568887,
0.6147106886,
0.0067592366,
-0.4474111497,
0.178627342,
0.3733724356,
0.3901949227,
-0.0001488886,
0.5387530923,
0.7245115042,
0.8872958422,
-0.0898984373,
0.6873553395,
-0.2337039411,
0.410815835,
1.4314620495,
-0.5322644114,
0.9829832315,
0.723218739,
0.0184850711,
0.0829518437,
0.4603999555,
-0.0231739692,
0.7275400162,
0.3615813553,
-0.3511300683,
-0.2670093179,
-0.1793594509,
-0.1318448186,
0.4748059213,
0.4109328985,
-0.2696707845,
-0.4452055991,
0.2281683832,
0.0938704237,
0.1393322647,
-0.3731867075,
0.6381784678,
0.2863934636,
-0.6334155202,
0.4704300165,
0.2233741581,
0.8280700445,
-0.2851149738,
0.2013925612,
-0.1748336852,
0.4061508179,
-0.4385825992,
-0.8002496362,
0.4673694074,
0.2083542645,
0.00756157,
-0.3309812248,
1.0253922939,
-0.8358179331,
-0.2707297504,
0.3357426524,
0.5367094278,
0.3660669923,
-0.0874835476,
-0.1921987534,
0.1986179799,
-0.0017268658,
-0.259601444,
0.5394001007,
0.1609490514,
0.0846982077,
0.8201731443,
0.6316381693,
0.4768668711,
0.042441681,
0.1127135232,
0.8819779754,
-0.4264346957,
-0.4067622125,
-1.1235576868,
0.5218865275,
0.0410200693,
0.2946683466,
0.9063626528,
0.8290361166,
0.9003985524,
-0.1046918705,
0.6740531921,
0.3200218678,
0.5679785609,
-0.4449103773,
1.0365886688,
-0.5779595971,
0.741999507,
-0.02728015,
-0.8034259677,
-0.2541763484,
0.4340575337,
-0.2840684056,
-0.162653774,
0.3195721507,
1.0923492908,
-0.2080392092,
0.11848481,
0.3406821191,
0.4631237388,
0.6762619019,
0.5228356123,
0.9365442395,
0.0155341802,
0.3985409141,
-0.5676850677,
-0.0979718342,
-0.1455526501,
-0.9279899597,
-0.9308469892,
-0.198646307,
-0.2293542027,
-0.4456534684,
-0.1312000453,
0.6593601704,
0.5129139423,
-0.8241304159,
-0.1241674423,
0.1567158103,
0.2427235693,
0.0639193282,
-0.1846251339,
0.2192083746,
-0.1495679915,
-0.8196547627,
0.5407742262,
0.0228115804,
0.1251397282,
-0.4609515965,
-0.0796017423,
0.171223864,
0.1896552593,
0.5920798779,
0.2608338892,
-0.773711741,
-0.521050036,
-0.4288937151,
-0.2551380694,
-0.2255248576,
0.7845388651,
-0.6887376904,
0.4432189763,
0.4753297865,
0.7612352371,
0.3811717629,
-0.0489621311,
0.4068597853,
-0.9865069389,
0.150143221,
0.2943343222,
0.6372261643,
0.3285214305,
-0.3571533859,
0.4152242839,
-0.0808495358,
-0.6131227612,
-1.2901030779,
0.1242088974,
-0.6754500866,
-0.333982259,
1.4550174475,
-0.1910327971,
-0.1546178758,
-0.1392822415,
0.0728565156,
0.233902052,
-0.1013365984,
0.8328750134,
0.5774793029,
0.2558550239,
0.2694829702,
-0.5492199659,
0.3426349759,
0.1655743569,
-0.8896076083,
0.3815521002,
0.4927757084,
0.599155426,
-0.1053893343,
0.4828968346,
-0.4524460733,
-0.1617904156,
-0.2605505288,
-0.2005590945,
-0.1947319508,
-0.2814394832,
-0.6276383996,
0.1372558475,
0.0342516825,
0.054645773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12147v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12147v3
|
Surprising Efficacy of Fine-Tuned Transformers for Fact-Checking over Larger Language Models
| 2024-02-19T14:00:35 | 2024-04-30T08:56:18 |
Vinay Setty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we explore the challenges associated with establishing an
end-to-end fact-checking pipeline in a real-world context, covering over 90
languages. Our real-world experimental benchmarks demonstrate that fine-tuning
Transformer models specifically for fact-checking tasks, such as claim
detection and veracity prediction, provide superior performance over large
language models (LLMs) like GPT-4, GPT-3.5-Turbo, and Mistral-7b. However, we
illustrate that LLMs excel in generative tasks such as question decomposition
for evidence retrieval. Through extensive evaluation, we show the efficacy of
fine-tuned models for fact-checking in a multilingual setting and complex
claims that include numerical quantities.
|
[
-0.5029718876,
-0.7554181814,
0.8844844699,
-0.0505098999,
-0.166119352,
0.0197183862,
-0.3391416967,
-0.5074090362,
-0.3989632726,
0.4962432086,
-0.3513010144,
-0.360817641,
-0.9299160242,
0.3090589643,
-0.7043443918,
1.1919702291,
-0.1044237539,
-0.1788186133,
-0.062201988,
-0.1165811121,
-0.0889436379,
-0.4202274084,
-0.4527306557,
-0.5141801238,
0.3615567684,
0.3786233962,
0.8739420176,
0.3994109333,
0.5934656858,
0.3226446211,
-0.165205583,
0.6894769073,
-0.3548366725,
0.0445893891,
-0.4376668036,
-0.8025904298,
-0.123001352,
0.0787495449,
0.4332493246,
0.2172208577,
-0.1577180773,
0.4149939418,
-0.2858225405,
0.372759521,
-0.6979534626,
0.5025751591,
-0.8588975668,
-0.0204763394,
-0.0985868275,
0.0224997625,
-0.6177395582,
-0.5135859251,
0.0932732746,
-0.2826311588,
0.7133744955,
0.1757631153,
1.2739444971,
0.5213970542,
-0.6204218864,
-0.3028935492,
-0.9694309235,
0.5490597486,
-0.6128390431,
0.6482735872,
0.2739887834,
0.4617032111,
-0.0106726224,
-0.8162564039,
-0.7948620319,
-0.1271798462,
-0.4154970944,
0.0896291882,
-0.3280448914,
0.0913332626,
0.5747819543,
0.4219494462,
-0.4055578411,
0.1278440654,
-0.2896451056,
-0.4798888266,
0.3712685108,
0.0213173665,
0.0963472426,
-0.2317926735,
0.0009938227,
0.0635363087,
-0.8787997961,
-0.0615954474,
0.2611226439,
0.2186857313,
-0.1037610993,
0.6323515177,
-0.454210937,
0.6935254931,
0.035277687,
-0.1150788441,
-0.2434422076,
-0.4949095845,
-0.2100429833,
-0.0728538111,
0.5636854172,
0.2215887755,
0.2312991172,
-0.4198839962,
-0.3294477463,
0.2631738186,
0.11723914,
-1.0517930984,
-0.0971927196,
0.1443935037,
-0.1260420084,
-0.1431416869,
0.0470320694,
-0.3802774251,
-0.3419286907,
-0.4456847906,
0.5368188024,
-0.2628224492,
-0.1376498491,
0.4400490522,
-0.0318116434,
0.3051266968,
0.3085068464,
-0.7407348752,
-0.0838437453,
0.9944965243,
0.8118732572,
0.184375301,
-0.0816607997,
-0.858974576,
-0.1945388019,
-0.4034537673,
1.0558023453,
-0.551548183,
0.1934507936,
0.1375761032,
0.2581586242,
-0.0239220727,
-0.5404295325,
1.1713341475,
-0.7300632,
0.1217739135,
-0.4921632409,
-0.5594472885,
-0.1716561317,
0.6419569254,
-0.7071445584,
0.8173485994,
0.0230774172,
-0.6839278936,
0.54486233,
-0.3983950913,
-0.5918000937,
-0.1930893362,
-0.0800984502,
-0.6835445166,
0.3309516311,
0.1294801384,
0.5845376253,
-0.6962839961,
0.658085227,
0.0249498524,
-0.1739212573,
0.2437654585,
-0.7140772939,
0.4881554246,
0.2035687268,
-0.4230482578,
0.0386846997,
-0.8042477369,
-0.3390517235,
-0.1780206859,
-0.42491135,
-0.0376186222,
0.1270113736,
-0.1604444832,
0.2370102406,
0.1329929829,
-0.896515429,
0.1557838321,
-0.1870610714,
0.4158954918,
0.2774807215,
-0.3095943928,
-0.1467001587,
-0.3652187586,
0.2833486795,
0.1057811305,
0.0545289889,
-0.3207537234,
-0.3481421471,
-1.1858502626,
-0.1900020093,
0.6694461107,
0.560831666,
-0.7923090458,
0.3422256708,
-0.4088164568,
-0.6303075552,
-0.6078726649,
-0.2306299508,
0.3535568118,
0.5195125937,
0.4222196937,
0.2004968971,
-0.4440704584,
-1.0950202942,
-0.5014443398,
-0.2100634277,
-0.083788,
-0.063075155,
0.5501868129,
-0.1346859783,
1.0148079395,
-0.5934747458,
-0.1180065796,
-0.0871983171,
0.3215701878,
0.3315857947,
0.044385355,
0.4106028974,
-0.8467918038,
-0.4824126363,
0.3274717331,
-0.6603622437,
0.0266970061,
-0.3040625751,
0.2866829038,
0.1836657375,
0.4426900148,
-1.1763908863,
0.1503033638,
0.471362114,
-0.4369623065,
0.703792274,
-0.2690018713,
0.3926756382,
-0.7480874658,
-0.0626957193,
0.1984402239,
-0.5685943365,
-0.5723791718,
0.2407536805,
0.3970097899,
0.2072871178,
-0.423459053,
0.104883343,
-0.2279926836,
0.1911005676,
-0.1351274997,
-0.1944662631,
-0.1474978477,
0.2256055623,
-0.0918578655,
0.8645818233,
0.5678312182,
-0.6523228288,
0.302913934,
0.1378363073,
-0.701590538,
0.4925952256,
-0.6432313323,
-0.2181829661,
-0.2543088496,
0.1821750253,
-0.8187594414,
-0.3340896368,
-0.34825176,
-0.1186628789,
0.3433461487,
-0.4842709601,
-0.832347095,
-0.2442831993,
-0.033118628,
-0.0016546737,
0.5225678682,
-0.8143441081,
0.8213602901,
0.1771088392,
-0.027703302,
-0.5975053906,
-0.4371939898,
0.2255054116,
-0.1806561202,
-0.58701998,
0.2085751444,
0.2976646423,
-0.3743752539,
-0.2796753049,
-0.2780340314,
0.0800790489,
0.0842343494,
-0.0686222762,
0.0432020687,
-0.2508616149,
0.0471412055,
0.1278673708,
-0.2411585599,
0.1663551331,
-0.1379592419,
0.2739676833,
-0.2868410945,
-0.7285785675,
-0.1363398135,
0.01144436,
0.9748341441,
-0.3694193363,
0.7741724253,
0.8687648773,
-0.3385190964,
-0.1566278338,
-1.1001114845,
-0.2572306097,
-0.4360123575,
0.428901732,
-0.350356698,
-1.1392041445,
0.5972045064,
-0.4061427414,
0.3120255172,
0.6910222173,
0.6802627444,
0.1783664078,
1.0395020247,
0.5315846801,
0.0181761067,
0.0289060529,
-0.1192565337,
0.665836215,
-0.4589369297,
-0.1892350316,
-0.7716636062,
-0.0063375621,
-0.7023596764,
-0.5026445389,
0.5799583197,
-0.1129393652,
-0.1969744265,
0.3804892004,
-0.2110695392,
0.6764354706,
0.2574020922,
0.0622515492,
0.7834362388,
-0.1032132059,
0.0631860346,
0.0481286161,
-0.6017121673,
-0.4720870852,
0.7860918045,
0.4258112013,
0.677548945,
0.3187579513,
0.0901663825,
0.2603640258,
0.4741126299,
-0.8156515956,
0.2709819973,
-0.3433971703,
-0.7147320509,
-0.2857816219,
-0.3401807547,
-0.5492582917,
0.51293993,
-0.2637503147,
-0.2727046609,
0.1670820713,
0.2057604939,
-0.4288535416,
0.5299351811,
-0.6924760938,
0.5212044716,
-0.135119006,
-0.3714150786,
-0.4601462483,
-0.4130861163,
0.5564806461,
-0.1929718852,
0.2287034243,
-0.1826584786,
0.3856732547,
0.2430597395,
-0.4525120258,
0.8152346611,
-0.0002790637,
-0.5175834894,
0.2923195958,
0.2013768554,
0.9782862067,
0.3272883594,
-0.0922583416,
0.2121206522,
0.0052459226,
-0.001366361,
-0.6238874793,
0.4126573205,
-0.5844402313,
-0.8427000642,
-0.3487912714,
-0.4368030131,
-0.2578029037,
0.2494276762,
0.4309890866,
0.6440641284,
-0.1219635606,
0.5492609739,
1.094827652,
-0.0668617934,
0.3195276558,
1.0447021723,
0.0789018422,
0.1744418144,
0.9084730744,
0.1852230132,
0.2303297222,
0.5770694613,
0.1765847951,
-0.3759195805,
-0.6306659579,
-0.6479161978,
0.1656919867,
-0.6569471955,
-0.4881594479,
-0.8956797123,
-0.2810457051,
-0.0987368226,
0.3025601506,
-0.7618790269,
-0.4114125669,
0.208918497,
-0.1739717573,
0.3778631389,
0.848803997,
0.0375633016,
0.040310692,
-0.7448557019,
0.6743543148,
0.4768886268,
0.685868144,
-0.3669769466,
-0.6989215612,
-0.3794108927,
0.0791603401,
-0.3284640908,
-0.3579086065,
0.0451832972,
0.2402621359,
0.3275351524,
0.1827728152,
0.139688924,
0.4702188373,
-0.6291258335,
0.6545639038,
-0.1609198749,
-0.8271420002,
0.1644258797,
-0.2067456692,
0.100657776,
0.2924260497,
0.3862987161,
-0.5617817044,
-0.4852924049,
-0.4579589069,
-0.494038403,
0.5590344667,
0.3260247111,
0.0507752225,
-0.0264908038,
0.4116688371,
0.2495037615,
0.0741432235,
-0.45591259,
-0.2374030948,
-0.0721199065,
-0.1133667678,
-0.0049350173,
-0.3697943687,
-0.2332083285,
-0.2585255802,
0.7429209948,
-0.496035248,
-0.0266840085,
0.347066015,
-0.3015734553,
-0.0947794542,
0.7593811154,
0.6973122954,
0.6156438589,
0.0477552414,
0.4234943688,
0.4455784261,
-0.3642046154,
0.1289173663,
0.1603942811,
-0.4408174157,
0.181123659,
0.3510716558,
0.7907071114,
0.2975980341,
-0.5148391724,
0.4015529454,
-0.2324440479,
-0.2636621892,
-0.0667720959,
0.1147269607,
0.0945830494,
0.2671111226,
0.3131489754,
0.2304615825,
0.1348306537,
-0.5534313917,
0.3098107874,
0.5795981884,
-0.1966787577,
-0.4829269648,
0.5872390866,
-0.0400203615,
0.0853411779,
0.4963384569,
-0.3610455394,
-0.868563354,
0.5661394,
0.4505487978,
0.66549474,
0.0086984793,
0.2132009715,
0.4053530395,
0.6967770457,
-0.5368715525,
0.0110199973,
0.0956501067,
-0.7990272045,
-0.8971070647,
-0.5935311317,
-0.5914791226,
0.1799243838,
-0.4151887,
0.4412874877,
-0.0693153739,
-0.0553128906,
0.1283195168,
-0.1764375567,
-0.895730257,
0.2552099228,
0.0391636193,
0.8890058994,
-0.9825685024,
0.6432206631,
0.4677764773,
-0.0824285969,
-0.7165570259,
-0.0565528236,
-0.1148162782,
-0.5885151029,
0.5828816891,
0.007045758,
-0.3026022017,
-0.1002293304,
-0.6025804281,
-0.9069202542,
0.8610597253,
0.9113661051,
-0.7592867613,
0.1177437901,
0.3424033225,
0.7619119287,
0.0990609303,
0.4177941084,
0.9505442381,
0.5924999714,
0.0204713866,
-1.255112648,
0.0500761159,
0.0872186124,
-0.5104686618,
0.3198080957,
-0.9141740799,
0.8441046476,
-0.246375367,
-0.2073367536,
-0.2795658708,
0.8305882812,
0.0925557837,
0.0397314727,
0.5930138826,
0.5395550132,
0.7778697014,
-0.4416871667,
1.0865837336,
-0.4534892738,
0.7724870443,
0.8826729655,
-0.154093042,
0.4979972243,
0.1062341332,
-0.2391958088,
0.530806005,
0.4050567448,
-0.2011294067,
0.1530671418,
-0.0859547257,
-0.1826908141,
-0.6804922223,
-0.4106017053,
-0.1226188689,
0.5399193168,
0.4746149778,
0.0118460227,
-0.4730094075,
-0.3904418051,
0.163130179,
-0.0757369027,
0.0056270519,
0.525508225,
-0.1632454395,
-1.0834752321,
0.6050549746,
0.1549587697,
0.7106188536,
-0.4606046677,
-0.1348951012,
-0.0657743812,
0.2725437582,
-0.4197059572,
-0.9188668132,
0.3316189945,
0.2522494793,
-0.2842984796,
-0.0278325658,
0.7987747192,
-0.5277978778,
-0.3658216,
-0.0964685902,
0.4527652562,
-0.3108222187,
-0.3979842961,
-0.2838170528,
0.0560265221,
-0.0084353816,
-0.3099712729,
0.099343285,
0.5469307303,
-0.2103614807,
0.8516411781,
0.5215796828,
-0.1400138885,
-0.1666000783,
0.3126532733,
0.6137256026,
-0.3668605983,
-0.3079247475,
-0.9733566642,
0.4688743651,
0.0179159138,
-0.0146577591,
0.8121442795,
0.7687981129,
0.7787034512,
-0.1214088276,
0.9209109545,
-0.0894026607,
0.3784143031,
-0.5515800118,
0.6911001801,
-0.1602038145,
0.1021911353,
0.0425491147,
-0.7183170319,
-0.3827765882,
0.3774349689,
-0.1144468263,
-0.1833744496,
0.691996634,
0.7981349826,
-0.3536253572,
0.2267882526,
0.4311074018,
0.4203035235,
0.6386474371,
0.2236424685,
0.8104788661,
-0.5668288469,
0.5162526369,
-0.1425070167,
-0.024321666,
-0.0836447477,
-1.0489164591,
-1.0113965273,
-0.490695715,
-0.4238745868,
-0.4002425969,
-0.3821987808,
0.7062526345,
0.7111605406,
-1.1059087515,
0.2653354406,
-0.0351508595,
0.2441996783,
0.0400231443,
-0.1348981559,
0.3349383175,
-0.4174494445,
-0.5995020866,
0.2555784583,
0.2157729119,
-0.2379772961,
-0.3246586025,
0.1600284874,
0.0534780696,
0.1409493089,
0.8848843575,
0.0601874106,
-0.8975963593,
-0.6242727041,
0.0226947349,
0.0342551023,
-0.1235063598,
1.1934537888,
-0.627071321,
0.3225189447,
0.5231804252,
0.8033114672,
0.6443905234,
0.0320713967,
0.4862414896,
-0.6502767205,
-0.1871580333,
-0.1826557964,
0.670529902,
0.5160320401,
-0.3825814128,
0.5858277082,
0.1607635617,
-0.568793118,
-0.8185088634,
0.3789788783,
-0.5757536292,
-0.004314641,
1.0626343489,
-0.0435411558,
0.12777628,
-0.4029165208,
-0.077009365,
0.4522770941,
-0.0344423577,
1.0222125053,
0.9330770373,
0.0557012856,
0.0203457791,
-0.6469216347,
0.7375192046,
0.5266206861,
-0.6582788825,
0.5212997198,
0.3414417505,
0.4085359573,
0.4004262984,
-0.0841943175,
-0.1014245749,
0.2298619896,
-0.2556319535,
-0.1859859526,
-0.1115963385,
-0.3846726418,
-0.1097349152,
0.2365446687,
0.1464194059,
0.4061078131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12146v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12146v3
|
Enabling Weak LLMs to Judge Response Reliability via Meta Ranking
| 2024-02-19T13:57:55 | 2024-05-31T03:25:42 |
Zijun Liu, Boqun Kou, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the strong performance of large language models (LLMs) across a wide
range of tasks, they still have reliability issues. Previous studies indicate
that strong LLMs like GPT-4-turbo excel in evaluating the reliability of
responses from LLMs, but face efficiency and local deployment issues. Thus, to
enable weak LLMs to effectively assess the reliability of LLM responses, we
propose a novel cross-query-comparison-based method called $\textit{Meta
Ranking}$ (MR). Unlike previous few-shot methods that solely based on
in-context learning capabilities in LLMs, MR assesses reliability by pairwisely
ranking the target query-response pair with multiple reference query-response
pairs. We found that MR is highly effective in error detection for LLM
responses, where weak LLMs, such as Phi-2, could surpass strong baselines like
GPT-3.5-turbo, requiring only five reference samples and significantly
improving efficiency. We further demonstrate that MR can enhance strong LLMs'
performance in two practical applications: model cascading and instruction
tuning. In model cascading, we combine open- and closed-source LLMs to achieve
performance comparable to GPT-4-turbo with lower costs. In instruction tuning,
we use MR for iterative training data filtering, significantly reducing data
processing time and enabling LLaMA-7B and Phi-2 to surpass Alpaca-13B with
fewer training tokens. These results underscore the high potential of MR in
both efficiency and effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3832935691,
-0.6465321183,
0.5931372046,
0.2476254851,
-0.3518305719,
0.2444431782,
-0.3816056848,
-0.3403922617,
0.1532671005,
0.2054193914,
-0.2992705405,
-0.6067003608,
-0.758379519,
0.2373499274,
-0.1619922072,
1.0455641747,
0.1673175097,
0.2546934485,
-0.3751562536,
-0.3967656791,
-0.5673988461,
-0.27176404,
-0.612246573,
-0.3423942029,
0.6007979512,
0.5013626814,
0.7181982398,
0.3402873278,
0.8100097179,
0.3243100047,
-0.0315413959,
0.2385736257,
-0.5793273449,
0.033099547,
-0.3246001303,
-0.4741207063,
-0.8471369147,
-0.0558796152,
0.5515574813,
0.5415840745,
-0.1790093333,
0.2038066387,
0.440149039,
0.4438349307,
-0.8964881301,
0.0528566167,
-0.9214462638,
-0.1792483479,
-0.3812265098,
-0.4185612202,
-0.4188344777,
-0.4042033553,
-0.1584079266,
-0.1328394413,
0.1838050634,
-0.000058713,
0.4650107026,
0.2928676009,
-0.3120625615,
-0.1603365541,
-0.6834892035,
0.8607060909,
-0.8998602033,
0.429559201,
0.5947429538,
0.425637871,
-0.1621609777,
-0.6509093046,
-0.3662074804,
-0.1618359387,
-0.0893148854,
0.2653211355,
0.0688435808,
-0.0043220171,
0.0880008563,
0.3035160005,
-0.7609971762,
0.0565436184,
-0.1907561123,
-0.2755125463,
0.2466222346,
0.2617811859,
0.0855024979,
-0.0930169597,
-0.2429511845,
-0.0084718922,
-0.8683241606,
-0.1808692664,
0.1837959588,
0.5239725113,
0.1544160694,
0.6017807126,
-0.1039158627,
0.6525722146,
0.0969826281,
-0.4221309423,
0.3164976537,
-0.4646905065,
-0.2540754974,
-0.2536759675,
0.8020034432,
0.1571826935,
-0.0203641988,
-0.2435332984,
-0.3431263566,
-0.2073139101,
0.2565468252,
-0.7005608082,
0.0928943381,
-0.0216108691,
-0.3834947348,
-0.0895422101,
0.026549397,
-0.7167688012,
-0.1080706045,
0.0646308735,
0.5932003856,
-0.1667004377,
-0.0970316604,
-0.0862081051,
0.1856745929,
0.1598111838,
0.0183141939,
-0.9474719167,
0.2013194561,
0.6797369123,
0.8672637939,
-0.1418235302,
-0.4610682726,
-0.8121267557,
0.1163019314,
-0.1970161051,
0.8237721324,
-0.7105935812,
-0.3553652763,
-0.1536685675,
0.0215599984,
-0.1802745908,
-0.7451104522,
0.7546435595,
-0.5467525721,
0.0905822217,
-0.3270688653,
-0.2256535441,
0.1184495315,
0.4352877438,
-0.5513221025,
1.1242876053,
0.1182850897,
-0.960665822,
0.280630976,
-0.149240464,
-0.5755007863,
-0.164973855,
-0.103716433,
-0.6792013049,
0.1072847694,
0.2422306985,
0.4116583169,
-0.5125170946,
-0.0500745773,
-0.7644726634,
-0.7430935502,
-0.1647990793,
-0.469917357,
0.3642877936,
-0.0933063105,
-0.5575318933,
0.0105844848,
-0.6617123485,
0.2916581929,
0.0575480647,
-0.6718699932,
-0.3699021041,
0.0858379751,
-0.4027984142,
0.1286163032,
0.1503094733,
-0.2402518392,
0.0733018443,
-0.3935779631,
0.1962144971,
0.5431739688,
-0.1236365512,
0.3565656543,
-0.0838906243,
0.5307142735,
-0.2406956553,
0.1989751309,
0.0227812994,
-0.5130728483,
-0.7521084547,
-0.2190279812,
0.3146187961,
0.5770454407,
-0.7752470374,
0.4417376518,
-0.4373338521,
-0.4243744314,
-0.4990706742,
0.431804806,
0.560890317,
0.7151376009,
0.7035371065,
-0.1947636753,
-0.4781828225,
-0.8233650923,
-0.2758328617,
-0.3512659371,
-0.0581772476,
0.4138799608,
0.4078804553,
-0.2447884679,
0.7422965765,
-0.2627984285,
-0.0630210117,
-0.3904561102,
0.2139164209,
0.2279110253,
0.1028961241,
0.4244996905,
-0.3540974557,
-0.3745228648,
-0.2673940957,
-0.6017259359,
-0.2111669928,
0.4598122835,
-0.0224269927,
0.1562839299,
0.0978302583,
-0.4951311946,
0.3751375377,
0.5890510678,
-0.0687350258,
0.3109891415,
-0.0004490106,
0.3320026398,
-0.9174274802,
0.1438120604,
-0.2736808658,
-0.3422072828,
-0.1427184939,
-0.115444608,
0.1465478241,
0.0883986726,
-0.3980547786,
0.3088953495,
-0.3044697344,
-0.4656498432,
-0.5340055823,
-0.0118668443,
-0.1522202343,
0.3793480694,
-0.0409195237,
0.8610365391,
0.2249903232,
-0.4557489455,
0.2347503603,
0.0404751636,
-0.1112949848,
0.6772592068,
-0.8076184988,
0.3052811325,
0.1614811271,
0.4895858169,
-0.9356453419,
-0.0159163568,
0.1517620832,
-0.3326818943,
0.3255499303,
-0.4463976026,
-0.4692927599,
-0.3893725872,
-0.5115893483,
0.5152314305,
0.2071842998,
-0.6017678976,
0.558609426,
-0.0127215879,
-0.1379535943,
-0.9114199877,
-0.6988005638,
0.0964174718,
-0.0517975986,
-0.5839616656,
0.1997081041,
-0.1136940196,
0.0745909512,
0.0524375066,
-0.3432127237,
0.088720277,
0.1552200317,
0.0524456874,
0.1130174473,
-0.2668687403,
0.0625386387,
-0.0601315163,
-0.3006873727,
-0.0716500282,
-0.1321159154,
0.4007552564,
-0.2096690983,
-0.632535696,
0.0135437082,
0.0538342409,
0.7884729505,
-0.2967941165,
0.7585519552,
0.663294971,
-0.1479645818,
-0.346654892,
-0.4906469285,
-0.3552179635,
-0.4614157677,
0.2097712159,
-0.3453617096,
-0.8013669848,
0.2828430831,
-0.0098345904,
-0.0574610792,
0.3780702949,
0.5836485624,
-0.0846165121,
0.8910595775,
0.4839253426,
-0.3755470812,
0.2464698851,
-0.0997785553,
0.0943622217,
-0.706305027,
-0.2498814166,
-0.6249361634,
-0.419447273,
-0.4868746698,
-0.463491112,
0.6432071328,
0.0652332827,
-0.2611039281,
0.253223151,
-0.2484708428,
0.6632970572,
0.4363023341,
0.2632568479,
0.4742665291,
-0.1361286938,
-0.3334513307,
0.0534401052,
-0.626042068,
-0.4622968435,
1.2631225586,
0.2600497305,
0.9952950478,
0.1769473255,
0.5792395473,
0.0860704258,
0.4382924736,
-0.6046481729,
0.6002006531,
-0.1261096001,
-0.4469278157,
-0.2493216693,
-0.7280765772,
-0.6958037019,
0.310308665,
-0.1838316768,
-0.2110128552,
-0.1377428323,
0.0620079562,
-0.2648238242,
0.3758175075,
-0.4240640402,
0.6940985322,
-0.5105626583,
-0.6928728819,
-0.2436241359,
-0.6070591211,
0.6257326007,
-0.0823610723,
-0.0665470511,
-0.1064603031,
-0.1640470028,
0.471144706,
-0.5955234766,
0.7566683888,
-0.0178804006,
-0.0271877628,
0.1700168848,
-0.0684130266,
0.586805284,
0.1890163124,
-0.284193635,
0.1670071632,
-0.3582695723,
-0.482644856,
-0.8900386095,
0.9794836044,
-0.5278406143,
-0.460324049,
-0.4076544046,
-0.1905201077,
-0.5474101901,
0.1393422633,
0.2798361182,
0.2461636513,
0.0219715778,
0.4027362764,
0.6239008307,
-0.1280678362,
0.4564409256,
0.7424733043,
-0.0182578303,
-0.684161067,
0.7591358423,
0.1306603253,
0.229132548,
0.4480604827,
0.1789765507,
-0.4028769732,
-0.7313916683,
-0.4018723071,
0.2037155777,
-0.6574928164,
-0.5846736431,
-0.4031948745,
-0.1981972605,
-0.1717907488,
0.2245017737,
-0.5983920097,
-0.2660676539,
0.0242939275,
-0.1810349375,
0.0638647601,
0.6363594532,
0.0028611009,
0.0694440007,
-0.7231095433,
0.2642661035,
0.5644084811,
0.5969420075,
-0.0221251864,
-0.5996169448,
-0.4269726574,
-0.1673263907,
-0.5290488601,
-0.7349889874,
-0.0543406419,
0.2252007723,
0.7312433124,
0.2476316541,
-0.1078508049,
0.70794487,
-0.4666422307,
0.6367504597,
-0.2336937785,
-0.8921239376,
0.7023414969,
-0.2837619483,
0.2658234537,
0.8110819459,
0.4133550227,
0.0684334636,
-0.5172441006,
-0.3518806398,
-0.9055587649,
0.5235533118,
0.252238214,
-0.0413678251,
-0.0818998069,
0.5171858668,
-0.069483757,
0.1412217468,
-0.6081863046,
-0.2850399017,
-0.2631302476,
-0.1039816961,
-0.1775345653,
-0.2465263307,
-0.0380459204,
-0.213755697,
0.7078198791,
-0.3462371826,
0.2221157402,
-0.0858949274,
-0.1727414727,
-0.1460025162,
0.3325113058,
0.6538891196,
0.7506961823,
-0.4421694279,
0.4575304985,
0.5415455699,
-0.3832254708,
0.2043225765,
-0.118867673,
0.0705671906,
0.0189439431,
0.6500155926,
0.5158878565,
0.6153713465,
-0.3199651837,
0.5641281009,
-0.064294748,
0.1845077276,
0.3134734929,
0.0561955571,
0.190632239,
0.1722847819,
0.3673560619,
-0.0470779762,
0.1504598111,
-0.5743188262,
0.3390863836,
0.6524392366,
-0.0038090381,
-0.3862603903,
0.5142464638,
0.3955788612,
-0.0720742717,
0.5010098815,
-0.1831253171,
-0.5557528138,
0.4575512111,
0.6623238325,
0.8297482133,
-0.4063067436,
0.0223811492,
0.5028683543,
0.561648488,
-0.2918298244,
0.2884953618,
-0.0997086242,
-0.4607586563,
-0.4157654941,
-0.5486352444,
-0.7427044511,
0.2881892025,
-0.5226345062,
0.3030230999,
-0.5419935584,
-0.3393701613,
-0.5650930405,
0.0909681469,
-0.544361949,
0.246333167,
-0.0066151237,
0.82872504,
-0.8496280909,
0.7120751739,
0.628274262,
-0.4420015216,
-0.7038754225,
0.2550305426,
0.0284762383,
-0.7243643999,
0.5396040678,
0.077507101,
-0.4978589118,
-0.3411056995,
-0.29110232,
-0.8876786232,
1.3286454678,
0.6709541082,
-0.6432919502,
0.2806500494,
0.2103779614,
0.4691817462,
-0.1492933184,
0.8894400597,
0.5814307928,
0.5170090795,
0.3121066689,
-1.1236003637,
0.0937848091,
-0.0135031743,
-0.169093892,
0.2131958455,
-0.9054357409,
0.4803829193,
-0.1989827752,
-0.025994733,
-0.1058702096,
0.6414597631,
0.428206265,
0.5932243466,
0.4803225398,
0.8007355928,
0.7995369434,
-0.0478666574,
0.8695463538,
-0.3335585892,
0.3810319602,
1.2689874172,
-0.3314935863,
1.1576831341,
0.1637476534,
-0.1753155142,
0.5519135594,
0.5452094078,
0.1817991585,
0.6065889001,
0.0284712091,
-0.2388967574,
-0.3567424417,
0.1847334802,
-0.4393220544,
0.4738517106,
0.0859845728,
-0.3594371676,
-0.4166540504,
-0.1268532127,
-0.0378638729,
-0.2920914292,
-0.199974224,
0.5531098247,
0.2574505806,
-0.5454125404,
0.7943957448,
0.1102053523,
0.7063075304,
-0.6572913527,
0.0492903627,
-0.6329439282,
0.2179915309,
-0.4393363893,
-0.6223461032,
0.4835557044,
0.1602412015,
-0.3938813806,
0.0652015433,
0.8483519554,
-0.3020785749,
-0.491165638,
0.4754966199,
0.5817146301,
0.0718917474,
0.0300007798,
-0.6956537366,
0.3641730547,
-0.4195952713,
-0.377225399,
0.4901154041,
0.2014815509,
0.0042593684,
0.8291931152,
0.3893463016,
0.0869927108,
-0.0834507495,
0.075390175,
0.7982945442,
-0.5780065656,
-0.0060723391,
-0.9493381977,
0.2678450048,
0.1921815276,
-0.1399701536,
0.7623599172,
0.6335725784,
0.6961848736,
0.2967996299,
0.8073464632,
0.2022574246,
0.4154630303,
-0.5877696276,
0.521935463,
-0.521374464,
0.7508150935,
-0.181030035,
-1.1752750874,
-0.3198106587,
0.3977867961,
-0.4614163339,
0.4466074407,
0.7581255436,
0.885185957,
-0.4783061147,
-0.3170075119,
0.3166370094,
0.1743706763,
0.1760487258,
0.7227546573,
0.7605112195,
-0.3206430376,
0.9837902784,
-0.0396449268,
-0.2495975196,
-0.2581062615,
-0.8946077228,
-0.967125833,
-0.0896202624,
-0.0201184042,
-0.4789965451,
0.19186759,
0.7045957446,
0.8737443089,
-0.6560514569,
-0.0481528416,
0.1532320529,
0.4298775196,
-0.1199936345,
-0.1962626129,
0.3353063762,
-0.6647620797,
-0.6202018261,
0.8581284881,
0.3770980835,
-0.1755260527,
-0.4120367765,
-0.2396425754,
0.1556718796,
0.1724864542,
0.4968252778,
0.2092418969,
-0.5032410622,
-0.1969333887,
-0.0727722943,
-0.2501618564,
0.0489070974,
0.8341397047,
-0.7779924273,
0.1325959563,
0.6308128834,
0.8036487103,
0.3455376327,
0.0904556885,
0.4685691297,
-0.6983216405,
-0.3191919625,
0.2855931818,
0.3519153297,
0.4795109034,
-0.1279405653,
0.7455212474,
0.406978488,
-0.6853998303,
-0.7371230721,
0.0184189267,
-0.8126322627,
-0.0411605984,
1.1670782566,
-0.2733475864,
0.0008950643,
-0.0227944814,
0.1212248057,
0.0319937356,
-0.2593893111,
0.8143793344,
0.6084795594,
-0.1765086502,
-0.1337407529,
-0.4725036621,
0.3073069751,
0.5721793175,
-0.8905439377,
-0.1518164575,
0.1425017416,
0.6365802288,
-0.0093280189,
0.6349737048,
-0.1210380942,
0.1849034131,
-0.3040376306,
-0.3096424937,
-0.1198343113,
-0.4734786451,
-0.2920434475,
0.3452731967,
0.1452102363,
-0.2520231605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12121v1
|
Evaluating Image Review Ability of Vision Language Models
| 2024-02-19T13:16:10 | 2024-02-19T13:16:10 |
Shigeki Saito, Kazuki Hayashi, Yusuke Ide, Yusuke Sakai, Kazuma Onishi, Toma Suzuki, Seiji Gobara, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Katsuhiko Hayashi, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
Large-scale vision language models (LVLMs) are language models that are
capable of processing images and text inputs by a single model. This paper
explores the use of LVLMs to generate review texts for images. The ability of
LVLMs to review images is not fully understood, highlighting the need for a
methodical evaluation of their review abilities. Unlike image captions, review
texts can be written from various perspectives such as image composition and
exposure. This diversity of review perspectives makes it difficult to uniquely
determine a single correct review for an image. To address this challenge, we
introduce an evaluation method based on rank correlation analysis, in which
review texts are ranked by humans and LVLMs, then, measures the correlation
between these rankings. We further validate this approach by creating a
benchmark dataset aimed at assessing the image review ability of recent LVLMs.
Our experiments with the dataset reveal that LVLMs, particularly those with
proven superiority in other evaluative contexts, excel at distinguishing
between high-quality and substandard image reviews.
|
[
-0.381044209,
-0.3128161728,
0.4556967914,
0.1811853051,
-0.5588312745,
0.079880625,
-0.1007007807,
-0.6204731464,
-0.1019255966,
0.7561542392,
0.0899609253,
-0.6171305776,
-0.423694402,
0.1234870479,
-0.7078199387,
0.9926086068,
-0.0206547994,
0.3057882786,
-0.5461637378,
-0.3555082977,
-0.5600606203,
-0.3377165794,
-0.5001434684,
-0.0737930834,
0.5771865249,
-0.205560416,
0.8496255279,
0.1343217492,
1.35111022,
0.2979111671,
-0.2464800626,
0.4738200605,
-0.6387078166,
0.0827442631,
0.054924354,
-0.1175109148,
-0.3815180659,
-0.0532490201,
0.9516736269,
0.4647505581,
0.1389858425,
0.3266239166,
0.0844648927,
1.0933105946,
-0.6442400813,
0.1083228067,
-0.6545274258,
0.2012242675,
-0.0050453041,
-0.3046924174,
-0.5171580911,
-0.5269240141,
0.2572595179,
-0.2659377158,
-0.0321643613,
0.247230798,
0.8439128399,
0.174649328,
-0.0629950687,
-0.1487975121,
-0.6092222333,
0.8042077422,
-0.6245453954,
0.4744528234,
0.2115326822,
0.4176970422,
0.1266312599,
-0.5226905346,
-0.4645507634,
-0.4237342477,
-0.2355149388,
0.3091668487,
-0.0218665116,
-0.2489203811,
0.0765125901,
0.4754955769,
-0.3488408625,
0.1161009669,
-0.5392751694,
-0.0442750864,
0.7741820216,
0.3057189584,
0.1447237879,
-0.2352942973,
-0.5397371054,
-0.4597587287,
-0.4686723053,
0.4743368924,
0.1425969154,
-0.1136981994,
0.2334895134,
0.6167445779,
-0.1824017614,
1.0059572458,
-0.3334078193,
-0.5120813251,
0.2858347595,
-0.4311237037,
-0.4468768239,
-0.4692096412,
0.9732478857,
1.1319614649,
0.167840004,
0.0486139692,
-0.6192553639,
-0.0590440966,
0.3722930849,
-0.7264921069,
0.1650947034,
0.1958523095,
-1.0006614923,
-0.7710428238,
0.2029404193,
-0.8931447864,
-0.8011249304,
-0.1773193181,
0.5806376934,
-0.1117896736,
0.0473370291,
0.0119407242,
-0.1477031857,
0.2274953872,
0.4259896874,
-0.4562618136,
0.1037151441,
0.4034276307,
0.6539180875,
-0.5697311759,
-0.5067481995,
-0.5077278018,
-0.40347296,
-0.6890985966,
1.0441169739,
-0.380428344,
-0.4774543941,
0.2557445168,
-0.2199210227,
0.1401634812,
-0.6583480239,
0.4962853491,
-0.7437256575,
-0.0765544027,
-0.0123164048,
-0.3768547475,
0.0282936431,
0.2833335996,
-0.7901455164,
0.9822095633,
0.0131223816,
-0.9203583002,
0.5866126418,
-0.2432900667,
-0.2808704376,
0.3218383193,
-0.3248845339,
-0.8562479019,
0.2090178579,
0.4850875735,
0.5530388951,
-0.4261399209,
0.2003249824,
-0.1280295998,
-0.4873543978,
0.4688697457,
-0.1562924683,
0.444101125,
0.0942295492,
0.0396622457,
0.4101276398,
-0.7025718093,
0.1806490421,
0.0955720171,
-0.2668485045,
-0.5753976703,
0.2655517459,
-0.031896688,
-0.137976557,
0.2113362551,
-0.3345737457,
0.0114206476,
-0.0339964442,
0.054509528,
0.574652195,
0.118109785,
0.2938858569,
-0.2015441507,
0.2512100637,
-0.0362918712,
0.5831930041,
-0.3992455602,
-0.667348206,
-0.9356529713,
0.0058760978,
0.0986648351,
0.3545146286,
-0.9213505983,
0.2896879911,
-0.4472925365,
-0.7393104434,
-0.6759406328,
0.3020285964,
0.8228527904,
0.2875093222,
0.3369375169,
-0.7863379121,
-0.2537541389,
-1.0332180262,
-0.1514721364,
-0.372074008,
0.101942122,
0.4956991673,
0.4240234792,
-0.0259487648,
0.6645690203,
-0.3393278122,
-0.5304164886,
0.0232899636,
0.0555257834,
0.0712143257,
0.1040047258,
0.5044474602,
-0.7738732696,
-0.329133004,
0.2206008881,
-1.0039792061,
0.0495666116,
-0.04136049,
0.0177142564,
0.2910817862,
0.5378298163,
-0.0017498559,
0.6342568398,
0.6702880859,
-0.2443537861,
0.5465900898,
-0.3267260492,
0.5937415957,
-0.4282644391,
-0.002671056,
0.1856276542,
-0.1393636316,
-0.4079813659,
0.377441138,
0.0754567757,
-0.0084847361,
-0.4129591882,
0.3473674655,
-0.4573924243,
-0.5837121606,
-0.056162484,
0.0631269813,
0.0792578012,
0.0740864575,
0.3095664382,
0.5305864811,
0.6116726995,
-0.3430353105,
0.5306707025,
0.1455727518,
-1.0581820011,
0.7356593609,
-0.6155834794,
-0.0151227983,
-0.2578519881,
-0.0205299985,
-1.1404474974,
0.0584091358,
-0.2224070132,
-0.1862799227,
-0.0410830304,
0.1001701131,
-0.4584464431,
-0.586768806,
-0.294940263,
0.2614450157,
0.7147020102,
-0.5698948503,
0.2836824656,
0.4422039986,
0.1073217243,
-0.5419024229,
-0.4205337465,
0.1566887945,
0.0775787905,
-0.5205575824,
-0.0470929109,
-0.0267690886,
-0.5235024691,
0.0168361627,
0.2213464826,
-0.0265460163,
-0.272839576,
0.2527323365,
0.4324652851,
-0.0576446243,
-0.0469631292,
-0.5547462106,
0.1534080952,
-0.2044481933,
0.1028503031,
0.1943663955,
-0.3943623304,
-0.3268801868,
-0.2805071771,
0.0390731543,
0.7873443365,
-0.4625927806,
0.2930869162,
0.5495816469,
0.0822092071,
-0.166913271,
-0.7778887749,
0.0403628312,
-0.3573992252,
0.5062245131,
-0.2396487892,
-0.5391969681,
0.3433758318,
0.5076796412,
0.1473817378,
0.3517609239,
0.6253871322,
-0.3893675208,
0.7903058529,
0.4854669571,
0.1358915567,
0.5241373777,
-0.0902290195,
0.208027035,
-0.8868483901,
-0.3708273172,
-0.2004910409,
-0.2575483322,
-0.3557868302,
-0.7078440785,
0.5474276543,
-0.1885166913,
0.1507286876,
0.1212231815,
-0.6912092566,
0.7297797799,
0.4496388733,
0.3006428778,
0.4676643908,
0.317917645,
-0.1251887232,
-0.0439362936,
-0.2603968978,
-0.539198637,
1.1064597368,
0.4964724183,
0.9116087556,
-0.2987520993,
0.4220874608,
0.4070504308,
0.4251692295,
-0.8178023696,
0.8052620292,
-0.4954204261,
-0.1540083885,
-0.4516831636,
-0.1029781625,
-0.7236677408,
0.5550867915,
-0.5716993809,
-0.4479978085,
0.0314989351,
-0.1087071449,
-0.1149353161,
0.374345541,
-0.380874753,
0.6307349205,
-0.3937775195,
-0.4800876081,
-0.2175659835,
-0.5488260984,
0.566085577,
-0.2804509699,
0.3054152131,
0.1224837303,
0.1963645518,
0.8028365374,
-0.2657131255,
0.7041292191,
0.179080829,
-0.24179326,
0.4487513602,
0.2000205815,
0.0105687436,
-0.2024842799,
0.028123226,
0.3691744506,
0.1243370101,
0.0159129482,
-0.5409796238,
0.5918816924,
-0.7686159015,
-0.3652323186,
-0.3325801194,
-0.3893645406,
-0.1898459494,
0.1133653075,
0.0786753967,
0.4815126061,
-0.0695539415,
0.3968188465,
0.318168968,
-0.4280981123,
0.4493468702,
0.4728427529,
-0.8985657692,
-0.5712383986,
0.9167888165,
-0.0047733164,
0.2980501354,
0.3538038731,
0.1856578737,
-0.119360745,
-0.7247643471,
-0.4265970886,
-0.0251882467,
-1.0567137003,
-0.1471200585,
-0.3009821773,
-0.4558035433,
-0.0201070029,
0.0502451472,
-0.3932489157,
0.0465370119,
0.2534238398,
0.3898530006,
-0.0467033684,
1.1018917561,
0.4750044346,
-0.0489155315,
-0.6053646803,
0.4345111549,
0.5893394947,
0.4794942439,
0.1906463653,
-0.3868744373,
-0.2288717777,
-0.4241495728,
-0.235217616,
-0.673278451,
0.4314106703,
-0.1144715697,
0.6791077852,
0.2893488109,
-0.2491543889,
0.6214036942,
-0.5712475777,
1.1240684986,
0.3472123444,
-0.6749132872,
0.4698710442,
-0.064596951,
0.1518083811,
0.3339104652,
-0.0315580256,
-0.2478550375,
-0.6253267527,
-0.2917453349,
-0.6631206274,
0.1836112887,
0.485568583,
-0.090042606,
0.3231287003,
0.066605337,
-0.0734980106,
0.2750432491,
-0.9137623906,
-0.0492292754,
-0.2183545083,
0.2172529101,
-0.2084334195,
-0.4399739802,
-0.2743343115,
-0.2532021403,
0.3582004309,
0.0226317625,
0.1167214438,
0.3410548568,
-0.1316783428,
-0.191111654,
0.1071524471,
0.6075460911,
0.7977567315,
-0.381570667,
0.1553398073,
-0.0285977609,
-0.5162630677,
-0.0777949467,
-0.551138401,
-0.3407844901,
0.1229200438,
0.6188378334,
0.876421988,
0.0808624029,
-0.6723450422,
0.8028028607,
-0.377594918,
-0.1754907072,
-0.0516235717,
-0.1700498909,
-0.1891777664,
0.0260173492,
0.3357400298,
0.244916454,
0.1710002571,
-0.3153854311,
0.0820316523,
0.6005389094,
-0.4228599966,
0.0890560746,
0.3191251755,
0.3537842929,
-0.2266214639,
0.5182558894,
0.1629059911,
-0.4035829008,
0.7944793105,
0.2393490374,
0.7187834382,
0.0749453232,
0.1787622422,
0.6476207972,
0.5293781757,
-0.0680577382,
0.077574037,
0.2107646167,
-0.7682257891,
-0.2980954647,
-0.9287583828,
-0.6061806083,
0.2250190973,
-0.6766537428,
0.361869365,
-0.3220724463,
-0.1848239452,
0.154593125,
-0.4375030994,
-0.696600616,
0.5175254941,
0.33988747,
0.5940611959,
-0.8540334702,
0.6223233342,
0.6227916479,
-0.6053936481,
-0.5208832026,
-0.027273817,
-0.3310937881,
-0.9866338372,
1.1309961081,
0.1997881532,
-0.3207960427,
-0.3061037064,
-0.5540888906,
-0.5671828985,
0.9190041423,
-0.2392046452,
-0.5478616953,
0.314940393,
-0.0959642306,
1.0113132,
-0.6023516655,
0.3694991767,
0.3464187682,
0.2621511817,
0.1652289629,
-1.1046874523,
-0.3039499223,
-0.254239887,
0.4266191423,
-0.2210001498,
-0.6168670058,
0.780759871,
-0.4021874964,
-0.1151544303,
0.3100458086,
0.387601018,
0.3020808101,
0.1529939771,
0.7298958302,
0.3598580062,
0.379745543,
0.0428611711,
1.3832502365,
-0.1951928735,
0.509242475,
0.8261193633,
-0.4156185687,
1.4673876762,
0.6488886476,
-0.3199208379,
0.5408021808,
0.3649581075,
-0.4251334369,
0.6316461563,
0.2374564111,
0.1049418375,
-0.3875193,
-0.1662348211,
-0.206993565,
0.4139333665,
0.0393248387,
-0.7357541323,
0.0110299876,
-0.0003918144,
-0.6835389733,
0.1729145944,
-0.6717721224,
0.9109577537,
-0.0341639332,
-1.0085257292,
0.7025777698,
-0.3355752528,
0.47120592,
-0.2359483391,
-0.0565266497,
-0.0179236531,
0.226460591,
-0.3502575755,
-1.43742311,
0.0531079993,
0.1539715827,
-0.1535542607,
-0.2392904907,
0.7196175456,
-0.2011568546,
-0.7676269412,
0.3896591067,
0.4065867662,
0.4274329841,
0.4044191539,
-0.5152646899,
0.3777113259,
-0.0595492683,
-0.100126408,
0.1797211468,
-0.2547651529,
-0.2859305739,
0.6679896712,
0.6519509554,
0.3128018379,
-0.0654137433,
0.4211255312,
0.6647208333,
-0.3936759531,
-0.404651612,
-0.7426753044,
0.5675174594,
-0.3046618998,
-0.2656587958,
0.6447245479,
0.5102909803,
0.6818116307,
-0.3918150663,
0.7479290962,
0.2111058533,
0.3506309688,
-0.6460392475,
0.8278318048,
-0.6871234179,
0.3065823019,
-0.4293861985,
-0.9624643326,
-0.6549012065,
0.9265025258,
-0.3580118418,
-0.1066298708,
0.9318165183,
0.7495048642,
0.1944815665,
-0.2077536136,
0.8133565187,
0.1834975779,
0.2121161968,
0.409751296,
1.085968852,
-0.5654327273,
0.5761681199,
-0.2050341368,
-0.1543945819,
-0.1938590556,
-1.2210022211,
-1.2862926722,
-0.6518751979,
-0.2867509723,
-0.5796431303,
-0.012758567,
0.2911911309,
0.6015533209,
-0.7152783275,
-0.3509516418,
0.2246922851,
0.0935993269,
-0.2620038688,
-0.1555054039,
0.5750256777,
-0.3179957867,
-0.7283296585,
0.0191991981,
0.5611057878,
0.0131116239,
-0.8500576615,
-0.1374976933,
0.4060655236,
-0.0725318938,
0.7325167656,
-0.1481967568,
-1.0674769878,
-0.1083321795,
-0.2081965655,
-0.4722513855,
0.1032868922,
0.6671003699,
-0.6507514119,
1.0112757683,
0.6741223931,
0.4166766107,
0.1869799644,
-0.1228430122,
0.2443128377,
-0.4403284192,
0.0259057172,
0.0228799526,
0.6284028888,
0.5500182509,
-0.0268653799,
0.4954778552,
0.105619505,
-0.7463545203,
-0.8743415475,
0.0079250569,
-1.3448473215,
-0.0230807848,
1.4431263208,
-0.1794190556,
-0.4138829708,
0.3582922518,
-0.5474304557,
-0.4012771547,
-0.0172803998,
0.740842402,
0.7449848652,
0.1024451628,
-0.3671993911,
-0.4442947507,
0.4173806608,
0.2002943158,
-0.8507375121,
-0.1407427341,
0.4078721106,
0.2881147861,
0.4520056248,
0.5590174794,
-0.4564279616,
0.4249770641,
-0.179479748,
0.1703271866,
0.0929887742,
-0.1359817833,
-0.3973424733,
0.3302257955,
0.1984185278,
-0.1277270466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12102v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12102v1
|
Is It a Free Lunch for Removing Outliers during Pretraining?
| 2024-02-19T12:45:52 | 2024-02-19T12:45:52 |
Baohao Liao, Christof Monz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the growing size of large language models, the role of quantization
becomes increasingly significant. However, outliers present in weights or
activations notably influence the performance of quantized models. Recently,
\citet{qtransformer} introduced a novel softmax function aimed at pretraining
models in an outlier-free manner, thereby enhancing their suitability for
quantization. Interestingly, we observed that such an approach leads to
performance degradation in full precision. Building on this insight, we enhance
the method by ensuring its normalization is invariant to sequence length, a
crucial factor for bridging the gap between pretraining and fine-tuning.
Moreover, this improved method also facilitates successful pretraining of
causal language models.
|
[
0.0527004413,
-0.6223011613,
0.4036218226,
-0.0028025638,
-0.4261418879,
-0.2835737467,
-0.2545524538,
0.0693771392,
-0.1236776263,
0.3681357205,
-0.3859474957,
-0.1810555011,
-0.7158485651,
-0.2088712156,
-0.5743682981,
1.2850408554,
0.0561896041,
0.2293679416,
-0.3483471274,
-0.2855540812,
-0.3204000294,
-0.3441523015,
-0.6876329184,
-0.1388031244,
0.4799549878,
0.4242495894,
0.8831912875,
0.8184255362,
0.167165637,
0.2991193831,
0.0031681531,
-0.2211606652,
-0.5314772725,
0.1779269129,
0.2456597537,
-0.9022634029,
-0.3864068389,
0.0200455766,
1.0713267326,
0.7639229298,
-0.1958933622,
0.1398040801,
0.417140007,
0.8327518106,
-0.7422923446,
-0.0269811638,
-0.2444279641,
-0.0050321571,
-0.6129688621,
-0.1246948913,
-0.3310165405,
-0.6580530405,
-0.0707609504,
-0.7812988162,
0.3403192163,
-0.3040222526,
0.9248912334,
0.4619581699,
-0.4895052612,
0.2711916566,
-0.7443098426,
0.7522991896,
-0.6709839106,
0.3633539677,
0.284912169,
0.2541961074,
-0.1667925715,
-0.7713009119,
-0.4936096072,
0.2362874001,
-0.0671320781,
-0.2661756277,
-0.1681316346,
0.1655917168,
0.3660365939,
0.4813453257,
-0.872482419,
0.1239637733,
-0.3568030596,
-0.1136638448,
0.5166748762,
-0.1029071957,
0.2642826438,
0.280092746,
0.0228027832,
-0.190841794,
-0.9204162359,
0.2602609396,
0.3974442482,
0.1996632814,
0.2120480984,
0.247414887,
-0.2251309603,
0.4976706207,
-0.1817898005,
0.1595334858,
0.2764888704,
-0.2276390791,
-0.2505541742,
0.0120948572,
0.5467230082,
0.0659912527,
0.8267173171,
-0.2656418979,
-0.3846257031,
-0.3133848608,
-0.1326356828,
-1.0817865133,
-0.4201997221,
0.0398869812,
-0.4418932796,
0.0046817074,
0.0320069082,
-0.2469374239,
-0.183522284,
-0.1174162254,
0.8844370842,
-0.4438881278,
-0.3056409359,
0.195873335,
-0.2989805043,
-0.038533397,
-0.0873672068,
-0.8474959135,
0.4492506087,
0.5351980925,
0.7690939307,
0.3753849566,
-0.1402873099,
-0.9651171565,
0.1973355412,
-0.2858760059,
0.5454976559,
-0.3646992147,
-0.3466038108,
-0.2109428346,
0.1454973966,
-0.1754821688,
-0.7270038724,
0.2441619039,
-0.7279894948,
0.0756250396,
-0.2811457515,
-0.7894340158,
-0.2303419858,
-0.0653769076,
-0.6801095605,
0.7588405013,
0.4146847129,
-0.3851468265,
0.5621674657,
-0.5809450746,
-0.4266889095,
0.2530994117,
0.2291403413,
-0.5943725109,
0.3379402757,
0.2414590716,
0.0962045565,
-0.2379588336,
0.3747735023,
-0.1696080416,
-0.7741842866,
0.3078217506,
-0.3012442291,
0.9382160902,
0.0941242874,
-0.4333505929,
0.52149719,
-0.8839844465,
0.4302913845,
0.0460143052,
-0.1283045411,
-0.6165710092,
-0.1607839763,
-0.2472330481,
0.1657556295,
-0.1328890473,
-0.2085317522,
0.1109662652,
-0.7478621006,
0.4235312641,
0.971763134,
0.055333633,
0.6983286142,
-0.143042773,
0.7122280598,
0.4288832247,
0.4256978631,
-0.306676805,
-0.1176972315,
-0.9127793908,
-0.5452126861,
0.7665513158,
0.6229817867,
-0.6045098901,
0.4703092277,
-0.1283219904,
-0.4434997439,
-0.4177300036,
0.4275007248,
0.450953126,
0.3551973104,
0.5937077403,
-0.3440579772,
-0.4585132897,
-0.7565355301,
-0.7077142,
0.5876821876,
-0.2181242108,
-0.5595526695,
0.2546795309,
-0.2567411959,
1.1059219837,
-0.409322679,
-0.1724592596,
-0.1571581066,
0.1257826835,
0.359251678,
1.01146245,
0.588060379,
-0.7179623842,
-0.5110434294,
-0.6235331893,
-0.3372746706,
0.0807702094,
0.2870369554,
-0.3284425735,
-0.113256231,
0.6554929614,
-0.6030708551,
0.6479114294,
0.2703511715,
-0.3002039194,
0.4205466807,
-0.0617265701,
-0.0941384733,
-0.8023260832,
0.086424455,
0.0151979197,
-0.2935929298,
-0.7413598299,
-0.1900072843,
0.243144542,
-0.095706962,
-0.3196224868,
0.4570700824,
-0.3555983305,
0.206396535,
0.0173921138,
-0.1403938532,
-0.043035727,
0.2279210538,
-0.3329425156,
0.7452831864,
0.6004016995,
-0.7214461565,
-0.0123713855,
-0.0741570741,
-0.3372443616,
0.2169951051,
-0.837564826,
-0.0137672033,
-0.338732779,
0.1159498319,
-0.8812494874,
0.1437325031,
0.1704533696,
-0.1782022417,
0.309347719,
-0.1722539216,
-0.5693972707,
-0.0849288478,
-0.4810919464,
0.9076986909,
0.4919524193,
-0.3683906198,
0.1302681416,
0.0335562378,
-0.024540823,
-0.4206991792,
-0.3012295067,
-0.5788251758,
-0.3987897933,
-0.4804144502,
-0.0052626762,
-0.3620218635,
-0.001449735,
-0.0538798273,
-0.1084309518,
-0.3817696869,
0.3422445059,
0.1470866501,
0.0103150317,
-0.3640559614,
0.3186313808,
0.1800014228,
-0.3893687427,
-0.0682407469,
-0.4094308317,
0.4526253641,
-0.0797504783,
0.0834901482,
-0.3269824386,
0.2764267623,
0.3489872813,
-0.5743633509,
0.8810142875,
0.7888311148,
-0.42588076,
-0.0832794383,
-0.2295421809,
-0.4223992825,
-0.5634912848,
0.3578290343,
-0.1789393425,
-0.9870706201,
0.2725654244,
-0.0527502075,
-0.2850406468,
0.3412237167,
-0.0204453897,
0.3540980518,
1.4206508398,
1.0321793556,
0.1303539276,
0.7249932885,
-0.3874102533,
0.4629068673,
-0.6931398511,
0.0384942666,
-0.4416638613,
-0.3172747195,
-0.5323422551,
-0.1638672501,
0.5099166632,
0.4106307626,
-0.4246350825,
0.0998335928,
-0.1705391109,
0.911397934,
0.7064779997,
0.0227658562,
-0.0276609417,
-0.0906758606,
0.0888553709,
-0.1574853808,
-0.6879708767,
-0.0885096714,
1.0715279579,
0.0093149543,
0.5674640536,
0.0533067808,
0.6991802454,
-0.0681693405,
0.4814947546,
-0.6101128459,
0.3777444363,
-0.2335393578,
-0.5840141177,
-0.721573472,
-0.7755556703,
-1.0162881613,
0.0909655541,
-0.1224638969,
-0.6879994273,
0.1152797118,
0.4656796753,
-0.8711737394,
0.1364418268,
-0.9556222558,
1.3619621992,
-0.1434652954,
-0.3718532324,
-0.132902205,
-0.6256427765,
0.3650629222,
0.0529029407,
0.2999446988,
-0.1469595581,
0.1891235411,
0.9775463939,
-0.7455050349,
0.5150828362,
-0.4669447839,
0.1407616287,
0.0687055215,
0.1931824684,
0.2706976533,
0.091264233,
0.1532040089,
-0.0630776808,
0.2163368165,
-0.8532858491,
-0.7841227055,
0.2950007021,
-0.6212445498,
-0.5413001776,
-0.2216853201,
-0.368624568,
-0.4411642551,
0.5422027707,
0.5709782839,
0.6261623502,
-0.09427239,
0.3538373709,
0.6670754552,
-0.0764114931,
0.6743139625,
0.4399565756,
0.2134272903,
-0.3371296227,
0.9733175635,
0.389942795,
0.0664695874,
0.4004907608,
0.2638186812,
-0.3166896105,
-0.4285348356,
-0.0931950361,
0.248030141,
-0.5246340036,
-0.4796681106,
-0.3839346468,
-0.3091633618,
-0.7580269575,
-0.0824100524,
-0.3955751359,
-0.6358041763,
-0.3720569015,
-0.0714450255,
0.1292388737,
0.3344816864,
-0.1564322114,
0.7701157331,
-1.1533842087,
-0.0475501344,
0.4898396134,
0.367931366,
-0.0145730032,
-0.5951346755,
-0.7458925843,
0.0062148999,
-0.3560310304,
-0.6427266002,
0.5104808807,
0.6969004273,
0.3791802227,
0.7070775032,
-0.0532530844,
0.8543093801,
-0.286870271,
0.5495662093,
0.261518538,
-1.341095686,
0.517973125,
0.0559749678,
0.4991460443,
0.449154079,
0.7236686945,
-0.5838420987,
-0.227132231,
-0.6927037239,
-1.160479784,
0.3948729038,
-0.2633882463,
0.0710355714,
0.0233197585,
0.5606257915,
0.1397028714,
0.4663791358,
-0.7006772161,
-0.1762068421,
-0.2959749997,
-0.2249092162,
-0.7139133215,
-0.6083837152,
0.0414095223,
-0.6689412594,
0.6733375192,
-0.248391524,
-0.125424996,
-0.1784902215,
-0.6691983342,
-0.4253757298,
0.2256942689,
0.5299402475,
0.813067615,
-0.0769247189,
0.1492487043,
0.0354202352,
-0.334576726,
0.2614907324,
0.1602056772,
-0.1463130713,
-0.2912994027,
0.2925867736,
0.6057778597,
0.5318655968,
-0.7240932584,
0.8550001383,
-0.1400052756,
0.0511050001,
-0.180341512,
0.2456370592,
-0.3684124947,
0.2799698114,
0.3486791849,
0.0067884782,
0.232411325,
-0.3807170689,
0.2710065544,
0.2127634138,
-0.4757966101,
-0.616673708,
0.7383275032,
-0.0627021194,
-0.0621876307,
0.9554610252,
-0.3383543491,
-0.5636552572,
0.3261242211,
0.6539963484,
0.8437162638,
-0.5539849401,
0.1253596693,
0.4311755002,
0.1770752221,
-0.1528645605,
-0.03136288,
-0.1876324415,
-0.7591744065,
-0.5308942795,
-0.5083615184,
0.1251229197,
0.0061044581,
-0.782224834,
0.1776688546,
-0.3811305463,
-0.0327311456,
-0.1806558073,
-0.1124579459,
-0.6110436916,
0.4856553078,
-0.0535890758,
0.6713029742,
-0.9491142631,
1.1000496149,
0.4578792751,
-0.2594346106,
-0.9453963041,
-0.0634416938,
-0.2280265391,
-0.4578119516,
0.6078895926,
0.2451644838,
0.2027101815,
0.3019391596,
-0.5064884424,
-0.9247917533,
0.7263929248,
0.7504107356,
-0.5341549516,
-0.1454131156,
0.0759398267,
0.1927852929,
0.1753521264,
0.3425835967,
0.8691744804,
0.2835358679,
-0.2734799981,
-0.686357975,
0.2449060977,
-0.3833121657,
0.0798957422,
0.5221594572,
-0.5622198582,
1.2114424706,
-0.1786994636,
-0.169898808,
0.0389312766,
0.6328158379,
-0.1432760805,
0.1157268956,
0.7036030293,
0.6299762726,
0.9736615419,
-0.0955962986,
0.660900414,
-0.1730455309,
0.1954474002,
0.8873190284,
-0.0042457543,
0.5057297945,
0.4142804742,
-0.0295474622,
0.4193688035,
0.4946664274,
0.3896889985,
0.7513218522,
0.4903226495,
-0.2410876155,
-0.3517637849,
0.3447781801,
-0.5721962452,
0.3205678463,
0.1839863062,
-0.0499059893,
-0.319470495,
0.1037925929,
0.2725793421,
-0.0894190744,
-0.3195845187,
0.4999038577,
0.0467522293,
-0.5033988953,
0.707301259,
-0.0525916591,
0.6886424422,
-0.7167621851,
0.1049361303,
-0.3447448313,
0.4562460482,
-0.1361376345,
-0.1616540402,
0.3645049632,
-0.4398521483,
-0.1870908141,
-0.3200333118,
0.4811045527,
-0.5361999869,
-0.0589783378,
0.0850268081,
0.5858962536,
-0.0260931663,
-0.4863526821,
-0.412355125,
-0.1971048266,
-0.1490193158,
-0.3316739202,
0.5166220069,
0.5678714514,
-0.2305957973,
0.4408278167,
0.6779863834,
-0.089393422,
0.1993624568,
0.0702160522,
0.8985615373,
-0.7644206285,
-0.7942896485,
-1.0369740725,
0.5546069145,
0.0583804063,
-0.5378325582,
0.7867261767,
0.814154923,
0.8781014085,
-0.195789963,
0.2174860835,
0.2945158184,
0.3556488156,
-0.4612889886,
0.827016592,
-0.6486855745,
-0.0072486373,
-0.2717722356,
-0.8169454932,
-0.4794294536,
0.4625480175,
-0.415551573,
0.0926904827,
0.6487985849,
0.9637621641,
0.0509033017,
-0.0912801102,
0.4652065039,
0.1065793186,
0.4190475047,
0.4931111932,
0.766010046,
-0.5255408287,
0.6314108372,
-0.3899110556,
-0.4677861929,
-0.271769315,
-0.8461239934,
-0.4933046103,
-0.7171828747,
-0.4246640503,
-0.2934628129,
0.2709162235,
0.7195347548,
1.0155417919,
-0.8347693682,
-0.257666409,
-0.0151380114,
0.241976887,
-0.4246684909,
-0.2376672626,
0.1784323603,
-0.6180663705,
-0.4112524688,
0.2729833722,
0.148319006,
0.2707128525,
0.297532618,
-0.0813832879,
0.0432647914,
0.1943636537,
0.5193495154,
0.5159708261,
0.1330077201,
-0.2947044373,
-0.2328999192,
0.2152559459,
0.093653433,
1.1885199547,
-0.8294556737,
0.1468561292,
0.2193419933,
0.230615586,
0.6031855345,
-0.0649814457,
0.6114931107,
-1.1141161919,
0.7631272078,
0.1873243898,
0.0853711218,
0.2525343597,
-0.3616789281,
0.2976405621,
0.4452809989,
-0.641889751,
-1.1097741127,
-0.0300571881,
-0.3954668939,
-0.1095364541,
0.7630904317,
-0.0442285687,
-0.5265806913,
0.1752287298,
0.1405245364,
0.6623179913,
-0.1192775518,
0.5380682349,
0.2892557383,
0.028440021,
-0.2664623559,
-0.3301644325,
0.8709474206,
0.5970240235,
-0.5496382117,
-0.1742913127,
0.1451785266,
0.5495092273,
-0.1509747952,
0.7418730855,
-0.1316024512,
0.464882791,
-0.1963071525,
-0.0460001901,
0.1133971736,
-0.2850537598,
-0.4620087445,
0.0610944852,
0.3243774474,
-0.3615190387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12100v1
|
Groot: Adversarial Testing for Generative Text-to-Image Models with Tree-based Semantic Transformation
| 2024-02-19T12:31:56 | 2024-02-19T12:31:56 |
Yi Liu, Guowei Yang, Gelei Deng, Feiyue Chen, Yuqi Chen, Ling Shi, Tianwei Zhang, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.SE
|
With the prevalence of text-to-image generative models, their safety becomes
a critical concern. adversarial testing techniques have been developed to probe
whether such models can be prompted to produce Not-Safe-For-Work (NSFW)
content. However, existing solutions face several challenges, including low
success rate and inefficiency. We introduce Groot, the first automated
framework leveraging tree-based semantic transformation for adversarial testing
of text-to-image models. Groot employs semantic decomposition and sensitive
element drowning strategies in conjunction with LLMs to systematically refine
adversarial prompts. Our comprehensive evaluation confirms the efficacy of
Groot, which not only exceeds the performance of current state-of-the-art
approaches but also achieves a remarkable success rate (93.66%) on leading
text-to-image models such as DALL-E 3 and Midjourney.
|
[
-0.3695697784,
-1.2782059908,
0.3072478473,
-0.0687085167,
-0.4007562697,
0.0087275887,
0.2451258898,
-0.4719450772,
-0.0812792405,
0.4810230732,
-0.5703496337,
-0.6453195214,
-0.8406878114,
0.0001861126,
-0.9667990208,
1.0527768135,
-0.0632414296,
-0.3397550583,
-0.288235873,
-0.0985042527,
-0.2963612974,
-0.0807674751,
-0.6168226004,
0.0551902503,
0.4732755125,
0.1070891693,
1.1527041197,
0.4672450721,
0.8149752617,
0.2332278639,
-0.1080621555,
0.0291953161,
-0.4196866155,
0.330365032,
-0.2179924697,
-0.3417654335,
-0.1518249363,
0.0252574869,
0.3598036766,
0.2884115577,
-0.0122207608,
-0.0221836641,
-0.1322128624,
0.6715744734,
-0.7233769298,
-0.0132677611,
-1.0217170715,
0.0644864589,
-0.205899626,
-0.2495822608,
-0.7169089317,
-0.4624471664,
-0.3708642125,
-0.861569047,
0.6444402933,
0.2535822392,
1.086828351,
0.4043893516,
-0.634967804,
-0.3055151701,
-0.4460558891,
0.4510211349,
-0.3295171261,
0.2335778922,
0.1961812526,
0.4711342454,
-0.5556958914,
-0.9538120031,
-0.5983865261,
-0.4425548911,
-0.0905736014,
0.048747655,
-0.2909351885,
0.1701841354,
0.0830342621,
0.2978292108,
-0.8031178713,
-0.1147364601,
0.0329803638,
-0.13933599,
0.5761597157,
0.0284170117,
0.8776632547,
0.1195627525,
-0.6169909239,
-0.7177106738,
-0.7537299395,
-0.1244148612,
0.4243404865,
0.2413958907,
0.3128759563,
0.7403524518,
0.0576847605,
0.3717621863,
0.0283349399,
-0.0700794607,
0.0294316877,
0.0047188075,
-0.284524858,
-0.0749411955,
0.7216784954,
0.4889615178,
0.0398637429,
-0.2433701605,
-0.3772893548,
0.7038027048,
0.2950290143,
-0.7678083181,
-0.4081966877,
-0.0201392621,
-0.2328253388,
-0.7718934417,
-0.2719663382,
-0.9909169078,
-0.7949178815,
0.3094740808,
0.4303766191,
-0.611307323,
-0.1089296192,
0.2031285465,
-0.3517458141,
0.3425287306,
0.5071057081,
-0.8198662996,
0.075242199,
0.6066563725,
0.7095749974,
-0.1717393249,
-0.429212749,
-0.6925230026,
0.1875233501,
-0.6970581412,
0.8524798751,
-0.3355028331,
-0.6491578221,
0.0476526022,
0.3503595591,
-0.2920788229,
-0.2297336608,
0.5137962103,
-0.7147882581,
0.2514904439,
-0.033340469,
-0.294691205,
-0.2995063663,
0.583355248,
-0.6327270865,
0.8937317133,
0.2400819957,
-1.0388748646,
0.3209841847,
-0.8868245482,
-0.8733603358,
0.0743528828,
-0.1731823832,
-0.5204721093,
-0.1771407127,
0.4319061935,
0.4592448771,
-0.4622107148,
0.1973423809,
-0.4625223577,
-0.2726038098,
-0.2104545534,
-0.4520541131,
0.8410042524,
0.0608524084,
-0.5019179583,
0.1552336663,
-0.3785839081,
0.0260468945,
0.8918617964,
0.0707578436,
-0.3990210891,
-0.1802650541,
0.0099606216,
-0.0485060737,
-0.0977789462,
-0.4921511412,
0.2349082679,
-0.2607309818,
0.2947228551,
0.6772329211,
0.0693203062,
0.3454788327,
-0.3947708309,
0.7892576456,
-0.3048716187,
0.2740930319,
-0.3680912852,
-0.7270562053,
-0.4991737604,
-0.2030119896,
0.0439146869,
0.6246859431,
-1.2040846348,
0.1727965772,
-0.2544743419,
-0.6236030459,
-0.1661570966,
-0.2398392558,
0.3525365889,
0.60500139,
0.3732823431,
-0.3115044832,
0.1558749974,
-0.6713861227,
-0.2101450264,
-0.5770478845,
0.0638183504,
0.1449503899,
0.6947500706,
-0.5316701531,
0.5914306045,
-0.3347314,
-0.2418085933,
0.0067997309,
0.3267363906,
-0.3168542087,
0.3557146192,
0.8272660375,
-0.9654821157,
-0.3557170928,
0.0352945253,
-0.6066969037,
0.087099798,
-0.202165395,
-0.1523635685,
0.3554572761,
0.5170672536,
-0.8290808797,
0.6361247301,
0.618678987,
-0.5910255313,
0.6678760648,
-0.2490030527,
0.4782254994,
-0.5915236473,
0.2322958708,
-0.2407231331,
-0.3715589046,
-0.3142980933,
0.8015063405,
0.2688852549,
-0.3723056912,
-0.5659046769,
0.6004780531,
-0.2906442285,
-0.0858842134,
-0.0799970925,
-0.0747894347,
0.2029581517,
0.2309749871,
-0.3679578602,
0.9017127752,
0.6211256981,
-0.5701845288,
0.4712468088,
0.505461514,
-0.0173536483,
0.6835600734,
-0.7147839069,
0.439833492,
-0.2378985286,
0.243585825,
-1.081073761,
-0.3689301312,
0.4166378975,
-0.5569592118,
0.3616137505,
-0.2999907732,
-0.6813418865,
-0.2854929864,
-0.3899392784,
0.139191404,
0.7033652663,
-0.7429167628,
0.6778287888,
0.3068422079,
-0.1881708652,
-0.4363569915,
-0.6972839832,
0.3146520853,
-0.3771326542,
-1.0132381916,
0.4874571264,
0.0520872921,
-0.0204093959,
0.1309589148,
0.1764845997,
-0.0099426834,
0.3087382317,
0.2390135974,
0.3100819886,
0.1603808105,
0.0143903615,
-0.028322421,
-0.3189796805,
0.1014759168,
-0.0724062473,
0.325873673,
-0.1546589285,
-0.8590019345,
0.0250451267,
0.373783201,
0.8907045126,
-0.3042769432,
0.3053581715,
0.7743313909,
-0.3910941482,
-0.1509041935,
-0.187892139,
-0.0386645161,
-0.5050100684,
0.5314360261,
-0.1079217866,
-0.4860736728,
0.3261036873,
-0.192500785,
0.0807020366,
0.5865005851,
0.274894774,
0.083048977,
1.1807801723,
0.5525433421,
-0.0138438251,
0.3197101057,
-0.2756995261,
0.0842845738,
-0.3873543441,
-0.1410821527,
-0.3634809852,
-0.0116406363,
-0.4016598761,
-0.3856361508,
0.5627353787,
-0.2514728606,
-0.3204051554,
0.308978945,
-0.6236542463,
0.5649346709,
0.4614973366,
0.0300078839,
0.1446884871,
-0.0121656032,
-0.1852639019,
0.201501444,
-0.4889551401,
-0.447091341,
0.8370226026,
0.438904345,
1.0732479095,
-0.0082793524,
0.3252515793,
0.4758613706,
0.4013635218,
-0.7635064125,
0.8449323177,
-0.4002449214,
-0.6268668771,
-0.4979170561,
-0.1006337702,
-0.9455651641,
0.2900081277,
-0.0605654009,
-0.3742679954,
-0.0772817731,
0.0573515557,
0.1030826643,
0.5434165001,
-0.6783922911,
0.9328329563,
-0.3359616399,
-0.2639299631,
0.0008576991,
-0.7687912583,
0.6204107404,
-0.0071692751,
0.1086446196,
-0.2269071192,
0.0409201048,
0.5749074817,
-0.2568964064,
0.6442768574,
-0.4614125788,
-0.0212413277,
0.261241138,
0.5152486563,
1.1813976765,
-0.0559495203,
0.306124121,
-0.131002605,
-0.1093212515,
-0.3345727324,
-0.6996887922,
0.539827466,
-0.5593724251,
-0.5691505671,
-0.510437727,
-0.5196357965,
-0.2356325537,
0.2699247301,
0.2575623691,
0.0959390774,
-0.2293253243,
0.1120392457,
0.8100877404,
-0.3227726817,
0.2867891788,
0.2093428671,
-0.4857782423,
-0.4536923468,
0.7789629102,
-0.3747918904,
0.4034650922,
0.0132520096,
0.1128990874,
-0.5641611814,
-0.8048200011,
-0.7486252189,
-0.1371017843,
-1.1280454397,
-0.2541741431,
-0.574370265,
-0.0616700202,
-0.4297663867,
-0.4583882093,
-0.3927072883,
-0.1938597113,
-0.2650479972,
0.0165055878,
0.3847685754,
0.5326920748,
0.3885318935,
0.0562205017,
-0.6292350888,
0.5300293565,
0.587353766,
-0.039606303,
-0.3927367926,
-0.5273039937,
0.4524175227,
-0.1220975742,
-0.4600730836,
-0.8117133975,
0.4984675348,
0.2295569479,
0.3817306161,
0.1637066603,
0.4187024832,
0.6177836657,
-0.3606641293,
0.87197721,
0.3002047539,
-0.7338069677,
0.6407160759,
-0.6134544611,
-0.1850653887,
0.4123950899,
0.1794735491,
-0.4369328022,
-0.4261185229,
-0.8197313547,
-1.0710121393,
0.1049247906,
0.3134449422,
0.1466983557,
0.0582915284,
0.0945347175,
0.1326806843,
0.0014277982,
-0.3712766469,
-0.1210530624,
-0.2837142646,
-0.0226306245,
-0.1505538821,
-0.0486267023,
-0.2946145236,
0.0926789492,
0.6995428205,
-0.3778775036,
0.3343086839,
0.3163771033,
-0.1991159916,
-0.1921795458,
0.1296467185,
0.3733435571,
0.1001098678,
-0.0918352529,
0.3173515797,
0.0883780271,
-0.4964196682,
0.4923155308,
0.3573307097,
-0.3083704412,
0.0170953516,
0.4627575278,
0.6493356228,
-0.1589320153,
-0.5042825341,
0.8036413193,
-0.3056854606,
-0.285900861,
-0.1571930498,
0.2146124095,
-0.2667675912,
-0.0974195004,
0.3685635924,
0.2492086142,
0.1399303079,
-0.402836889,
0.4054685533,
0.5860369802,
-0.3157488108,
-0.1303606927,
0.9869655371,
0.1790090501,
0.0548019037,
0.3934861422,
-0.6147509813,
-0.4838475287,
0.8652895093,
0.6431803107,
1.1640365124,
-0.1720180064,
0.4789036214,
-0.0170781743,
0.5945128798,
-0.0320030898,
0.0235038716,
0.4372923672,
-0.5542312264,
-0.0309506916,
-0.1016583219,
-0.5459983945,
0.0887579024,
-0.4593939483,
0.3485632241,
-0.4689701796,
0.0180172212,
-0.0491084009,
-0.2980809808,
-0.3502786756,
0.4467071891,
-0.0902859345,
0.8289490342,
-1.0743228197,
0.5415039062,
1.0016812086,
-0.1507885754,
-0.3217878044,
0.185856849,
0.147841841,
-1.1957548857,
0.4444484115,
0.2967353165,
-0.1068155318,
0.1833020002,
-0.6849450469,
-0.5806009173,
1.3253500462,
0.8277461529,
-0.2223783284,
-0.0108568789,
0.0472791605,
0.2257511318,
-0.1124578342,
0.2051533908,
0.2166342288,
0.5287611485,
0.573397696,
-0.4760904908,
0.2635333836,
-0.434063971,
0.2215148211,
0.3191966712,
-0.3455690145,
0.7008212805,
-0.4138386548,
-0.7024195194,
-0.0390083492,
0.3930446208,
0.2981235981,
0.446254164,
0.9337171912,
0.7688694,
0.8012977839,
-0.1282136738,
1.2861983776,
-0.3160393238,
0.4415216446,
0.772113204,
-0.3400479853,
0.4935331047,
0.3723240197,
-0.1428634524,
0.2450462729,
0.6823045611,
0.0590894446,
0.7801345587,
0.0755981654,
-0.1440253407,
-0.2686655521,
-0.255065769,
-0.4876294136,
0.0882564411,
0.2971004844,
-0.2511817217,
-0.5314680338,
0.1823774129,
0.0053768829,
0.0413904861,
-0.0825285316,
0.5144559741,
-0.278386116,
-0.4023091495,
0.6691499949,
0.0387263261,
0.4757322669,
-0.4986851513,
-0.0735014006,
-0.1343458444,
0.0674609765,
0.0031122954,
-0.7913389206,
0.42721349,
-0.0668703616,
0.2185103744,
-0.1577864885,
1.3281257153,
-0.1504532248,
-0.4393947124,
0.3366989791,
0.0824724808,
-0.1138857827,
-0.3594264686,
-0.8620675802,
-0.1076594889,
-0.1737809926,
-0.3253473938,
0.3351944089,
0.3829767704,
-0.040256653,
0.9365620613,
0.7771516442,
-0.2926580906,
0.0000229643,
-0.154857114,
0.9767000675,
-0.54731673,
-0.7029810548,
-0.7401785851,
0.5866980553,
0.1673500538,
-0.1414745599,
0.5919097066,
0.255993396,
0.6469115019,
-0.169378683,
1.0680624247,
-0.1845932752,
0.0334917605,
-0.6623393893,
0.7544723749,
-0.5113465786,
-0.0730482414,
-0.2645982802,
-0.3955615163,
-0.4701637626,
0.2318416536,
-0.0883004963,
-0.0711908787,
0.9260326028,
0.9962328076,
-0.0361123569,
0.1287070364,
0.5514558554,
-0.1963632405,
0.682739377,
0.6317447424,
0.9698174,
-0.6207125187,
0.7018615007,
-0.234381631,
-0.2341388762,
-0.2320908755,
-1.1654692888,
-0.8767114282,
-0.5092277527,
-0.6081361771,
-0.4598852992,
0.3584620953,
0.410870254,
0.5844407678,
-0.5202772617,
0.6588482857,
-0.6398100257,
0.0413000621,
-0.1120640188,
-0.2006937712,
0.4386569858,
-0.4220481217,
-0.4564547241,
0.310896337,
0.2496356219,
0.5854338408,
-0.2592419088,
-0.0669855699,
0.2126074135,
-0.1523115337,
0.2797489166,
0.2127984613,
-0.585563302,
-0.355617106,
-0.0162968673,
-0.2418061793,
-0.095332779,
0.4719181061,
-0.5409727693,
0.5540183187,
0.5726158023,
0.9566298127,
0.2154131234,
0.057180278,
0.306853652,
-0.5941861868,
0.1573838741,
0.2714373767,
0.3529852331,
0.4273988008,
-0.6434316039,
0.695635736,
0.5892016888,
-0.5880938172,
-0.8408703208,
0.2247795463,
-0.6822434068,
-0.1301441342,
1.3710631132,
-0.3997282386,
-0.3782149553,
0.0888825729,
-0.3064453304,
0.1453614384,
-0.1196395978,
0.8243766427,
0.3738825023,
0.2520835698,
-0.03067814,
-0.4941613376,
0.2992208302,
0.2962990701,
-0.9369106889,
0.1254801005,
0.161610201,
0.1703843176,
0.1842736751,
0.4743779004,
-0.295498997,
0.3697389364,
0.2989667952,
0.0876838416,
-0.3372284174,
-0.3834901154,
-0.2450519502,
0.202915743,
0.0953995585,
-0.5672674775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12091v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12091v1
|
Do Large Language Models Understand Logic or Just Mimick Context?
| 2024-02-19T12:12:35 | 2024-02-19T12:12:35 |
Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Over the past few years, the abilities of large language models (LLMs) have
received extensive attention, which have performed exceptionally well in
complicated scenarios such as logical reasoning and symbolic inference. A
significant factor contributing to this progress is the benefit of in-context
learning and few-shot prompting. However, the reasons behind the success of
such models using contextual reasoning have not been fully explored. Do LLMs
have understand logical rules to draw inferences, or do they ``guess'' the
answers by learning a type of probabilistic mapping through context? This paper
investigates the reasoning capabilities of LLMs on two logical reasoning
datasets by using counterfactual methods to replace context text and modify
logical concepts. Based on our analysis, it is found that LLMs do not truly
understand logical rules; rather, in-context learning has simply enhanced the
likelihood of these models arriving at the correct answers. If one alters
certain words in the context text or changes the concepts of logical terms, the
outputs of LLMs can be significantly disrupted, leading to counter-intuitive
responses. This work provides critical insights into the limitations of LLMs,
underscoring the need for more robust mechanisms to ensure reliable logical
reasoning in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3002270162,
-1.1923763752,
1.1247571707,
-0.2705726624,
-0.3042795956,
-0.3279816508,
-0.1266037822,
-0.4310543537,
-0.1859041899,
0.6558738351,
-0.7865937948,
-0.1467177719,
-0.4960858524,
0.1612319946,
-0.392603159,
0.7042910457,
-0.0005947106,
0.0940101519,
-0.2614084482,
-0.1424071193,
-0.6454498172,
-0.6629826427,
-0.3591204286,
-0.6588213444,
0.2730296552,
0.2495614439,
0.7125652432,
0.4367951453,
0.1521530747,
0.342189461,
-0.0530241095,
0.0877221674,
-0.4716188312,
0.1237982363,
-0.5502246022,
-0.6796639562,
-0.2493855804,
0.0223880485,
0.5974419117,
0.8395252228,
0.0399373807,
0.0292833634,
-0.0921515822,
0.3606098592,
-0.5431120396,
0.2879478633,
-1.0578505993,
-0.0759769231,
-0.0171602629,
-0.3229030371,
-0.5758093596,
0.0676823556,
0.3151247501,
-0.5830260515,
-0.1711454391,
0.1254914403,
0.4442037642,
0.297069639,
-0.6388034821,
-0.3136754036,
-0.6227781773,
0.9834448695,
-0.8008384109,
0.2007310688,
0.2299087793,
0.4172715247,
-0.5344652534,
-0.4317770898,
-0.7934411168,
-0.1304225028,
-0.374820292,
-0.1130886525,
-0.1241320744,
-0.1720611453,
0.6916728616,
-0.1379768848,
-0.4880025387,
0.0823313221,
-0.0515941195,
0.0003033373,
0.3904827535,
0.2277736664,
0.3756320179,
-0.0922368392,
-0.4497165382,
0.0422826968,
-1.1295959949,
-0.088931106,
-0.1267586499,
0.1709842235,
0.0499488972,
0.5624241829,
-0.0592569783,
1.0929150581,
-0.2536190152,
-0.2721027136,
-0.0879816115,
-0.2162379622,
-0.5867056251,
0.0669321418,
0.4831228554,
0.2648921013,
0.7912095785,
0.0016351349,
-0.3483089507,
0.106260933,
-0.0268335808,
-0.571161747,
0.0888067037,
0.1887030154,
-0.3547326922,
0.0706266463,
-0.0250847973,
-0.1954636127,
-0.348315388,
-0.6079874039,
0.6743204594,
-0.4251422286,
-0.1765482426,
0.2834686935,
-0.1546240449,
0.411604166,
0.7118151784,
-0.5028861761,
0.0637546554,
0.7436904907,
0.4214384854,
0.1585331857,
-0.2566307187,
-0.6493964195,
0.1455189139,
-0.6412743926,
0.82936728,
-0.752225399,
-0.2138113678,
-0.0581799373,
0.0340537354,
-0.2399950773,
-0.7214534283,
0.2077545673,
-0.7682539821,
0.1167062521,
-0.6755285859,
-0.7155798674,
-0.4089977443,
0.3390016258,
-0.4074556231,
0.3892376721,
-0.1092174947,
-0.716013968,
0.4325866699,
-0.2562812269,
-0.4300129116,
0.0213956144,
-0.233009547,
0.0681020916,
0.2429360151,
0.1708223224,
0.5283241868,
-0.3523708582,
0.4333598912,
-0.4768939018,
-0.5432142615,
0.6633300781,
-0.4066641331,
0.8903325796,
0.1414308399,
-0.3204023838,
0.0713625699,
-0.5105247498,
-0.1417552233,
0.2485670298,
-0.045234561,
-0.4050284326,
0.2671725452,
-0.1841634959,
0.6246542335,
-0.1526012421,
-0.3179248869,
0.1376551241,
-0.3724528849,
0.5604098439,
0.7016211152,
-0.0955369323,
0.4393330216,
-0.433155477,
0.3351392448,
0.1551526189,
-0.3240698576,
-0.4174447358,
-0.4371630251,
-0.5328502655,
-0.2408952117,
-0.0564633235,
0.7079752088,
-0.8519076109,
0.1671391726,
-0.1412301064,
-0.1809389889,
-0.0741900727,
0.2579672933,
0.3012566864,
0.972804904,
0.4968017936,
0.179177314,
-0.5082384944,
-0.8143405914,
-0.5365882516,
-0.1442219615,
-0.0437646843,
0.3238300979,
0.7576139569,
-0.2525750399,
1.0289894342,
-0.2869463563,
-0.1380795985,
-0.5965585709,
-0.1320770681,
0.2672962546,
0.2465270311,
0.6244517565,
-0.6988571882,
-0.1633593142,
-0.328510344,
-0.9228014946,
-0.443320781,
-0.3670936823,
0.2168771774,
0.3521317244,
0.8604373336,
-0.7640488148,
0.4490435421,
0.3937779367,
-0.3738207221,
0.5658613443,
-0.0804606453,
-0.0292556304,
-0.5744345784,
-0.1344829053,
-0.0626576394,
-0.3875516355,
-0.670291543,
0.0916161835,
-0.0750414804,
0.2044882625,
-0.6302246451,
0.9055786133,
-0.3003248274,
-0.1420860142,
-0.3623765111,
0.4097268581,
-0.0473998114,
0.2637068331,
0.4022830129,
0.5493290424,
0.5371056199,
-0.5979018807,
0.322303921,
-0.010992866,
-0.5995641351,
0.6734921932,
-0.6963314414,
-0.1351962984,
-0.2952855825,
0.7642009854,
-0.998249948,
-0.2520083189,
0.2393662483,
-0.1375291497,
0.0215262249,
-0.0992742404,
-0.6904958487,
-0.0291162636,
0.1037635654,
0.2509922683,
0.5384194255,
-0.6740369797,
0.6665933728,
0.1220820919,
0.185345903,
-0.4291040301,
-0.9005770683,
0.0279779453,
-0.3457357287,
-0.4678254128,
-0.1151672751,
0.0353633389,
-0.8904633522,
-0.1153490469,
-0.1419208199,
0.1990099549,
0.1918442845,
0.2102409005,
0.2459966838,
-0.2351321727,
0.2607256174,
-0.1647246033,
-0.087578848,
0.317751348,
-0.3462690711,
0.3448128998,
-0.0988617241,
-0.5033606291,
-0.4061652422,
0.1187691316,
0.5101035237,
-0.1038526371,
1.0690889359,
0.1467140168,
-0.450291276,
-0.4334306717,
-0.5353099108,
-0.4319379032,
-0.4076043665,
0.1142028868,
-0.740514636,
-0.892321229,
0.5953575969,
-0.1520363092,
-0.1376969963,
0.4953683019,
0.606969893,
-0.2465026081,
0.8666056395,
0.0659389719,
0.2756391764,
0.1354852319,
0.0709760413,
0.1986388117,
-0.5288418531,
-0.1568613648,
-0.3721992671,
-0.1073510498,
-0.5641303658,
-0.4222370982,
0.2350572795,
0.0801584646,
-0.37552163,
0.1781111211,
0.1061587334,
0.5356744528,
0.3860085607,
0.0900463089,
0.3339203894,
-0.1279825717,
-0.1962772906,
0.0883676037,
-0.7555935383,
-0.5986316204,
0.7969623804,
0.2579436004,
0.9737411737,
0.2527707219,
0.2910654545,
-0.0868518576,
0.2632521093,
-0.7940756679,
0.8180856109,
0.0136442911,
-0.7221493125,
-0.2281262279,
-0.4263714552,
-0.6106802821,
0.5023139715,
-0.3911221623,
-0.7782615423,
0.0543191209,
0.3003303409,
-0.0697261915,
0.4873376489,
-0.6082882881,
0.8008386493,
-0.1268104911,
-0.3355052173,
-0.3041125536,
-0.6628979445,
0.4591717124,
-0.3087926209,
0.4168412387,
0.1386004835,
0.1485856622,
0.4420535564,
-0.3744505346,
1.0044732094,
-0.1266803741,
-0.3622056842,
0.4542731941,
0.5423385501,
0.4949423671,
-0.0000649514,
-0.1024164632,
0.0197903365,
0.0576149002,
-0.3934747875,
-0.7787672877,
0.7085036635,
-0.382848233,
-1.0099537373,
-0.4205316901,
-0.6766840219,
-0.3304612041,
0.1029958278,
0.071610041,
0.5263567567,
-0.0092250025,
0.3106153905,
0.797832191,
-0.4835444391,
0.3277198374,
0.5177433491,
-0.1740266383,
0.2690375745,
0.4086668789,
0.209916383,
0.5024357438,
0.480227232,
0.3379199505,
-0.3424824774,
-0.1739283055,
-0.3870014846,
0.1969525069,
-1.0356835127,
0.1782588661,
-0.5120607018,
-0.0658365265,
-0.2004032284,
-0.3036628664,
0.0323333479,
-0.3266754746,
-0.1708889008,
-0.1708928049,
0.0483378693,
0.7661613822,
0.0760924369,
0.1891932935,
-0.582359314,
0.3502730429,
0.5484405756,
-0.1026270166,
0.1153711155,
-0.7828931808,
0.2707825601,
0.0466093644,
0.1666375548,
-1.0377851725,
0.179095313,
-0.0030241963,
0.5981229544,
0.4159902334,
-0.027593337,
0.6325378418,
-0.7240444422,
0.5822933912,
-0.1497472972,
-0.9631012082,
0.5715025663,
-0.4283485413,
0.6097706556,
0.11562033,
0.2949095666,
-0.3683481812,
-0.2216624022,
-0.4018522501,
-0.2991118133,
0.6025573015,
-0.1493776888,
0.2690383792,
-0.0814061537,
0.383097589,
0.0329284631,
0.1401405483,
-0.6839750409,
0.0300099552,
-0.1030259505,
-0.0932705849,
-0.2469281107,
-0.2921926975,
-0.1874613017,
-0.2045021504,
0.5116872787,
-0.2194701582,
-0.0815724432,
0.1146452799,
-0.4234771729,
-0.1246203408,
0.5103271008,
0.8000062108,
1.0770335197,
-0.1804680973,
0.4244970679,
0.3496312499,
0.1048613265,
0.0496308357,
-0.1957910359,
-0.196877405,
-0.253413409,
0.91923666,
0.7405414581,
0.1880693138,
-1.0464593172,
0.431514889,
0.1676725149,
-0.187087521,
-0.2560935915,
0.2827169299,
0.1966604441,
0.2718389332,
0.316485256,
-0.0919837207,
-0.0811584517,
-1.0103286505,
0.0981814489,
0.7309601903,
-0.1579919308,
-0.2285408825,
0.5817196369,
-0.2700078189,
-0.0689580366,
0.5799024701,
0.0464113019,
-0.7135784626,
0.6784722209,
0.8683043718,
0.4132074714,
0.0319353044,
-0.0499792434,
0.1738488376,
0.394487977,
-0.2172365785,
0.1228824779,
0.0327105485,
-1.1065475941,
-0.5840301514,
-0.3845210671,
-0.4047224522,
0.3382475674,
-0.2100587189,
0.0980757773,
-0.4349451065,
0.1393320858,
-0.1856165081,
-0.2778166234,
-0.7409781814,
0.5585009456,
0.1358468235,
1.0924427509,
-1.0649555922,
0.8681650162,
0.8073078394,
-0.2045960277,
-0.6702095866,
0.0307287723,
0.369671315,
-0.7786396742,
1.013677597,
0.2301522642,
-0.3307783604,
-0.2511007786,
-0.7521015406,
-0.5134497285,
0.649123013,
0.4273623526,
-0.626465261,
0.2681665123,
0.079780899,
0.5492728949,
-0.4902219474,
0.2315992117,
0.5437753797,
0.5594527125,
0.2355003208,
-0.7898640633,
0.3136634529,
0.2592643797,
-0.1701949388,
-0.2053198516,
-0.3498506844,
0.781496346,
-0.3633266091,
0.0116206175,
-0.222047016,
0.3947545588,
0.5856232643,
0.2358677536,
0.6407033205,
0.6299979091,
0.4178979099,
-0.0943878591,
1.1509546041,
-0.0648970529,
0.0621412434,
1.2676820755,
-0.5499366522,
0.899559319,
0.5428470373,
0.1248620152,
0.7102127671,
0.484551698,
0.2321460247,
0.3181439936,
0.1915818006,
-0.1462095827,
-0.851768136,
-0.0151676126,
-0.0716200173,
0.5982030034,
0.5934786797,
-0.2461467534,
-0.2326935679,
-0.1091519743,
0.0647504702,
0.2257859558,
-0.22356987,
0.6349058151,
0.3821061552,
-0.8178308606,
0.4594751,
0.0068085082,
0.3339735866,
-0.4623404145,
-0.1102692857,
-0.1078487858,
0.2085700929,
-0.1739331335,
-0.8691598177,
0.3513126969,
-0.1522802711,
-0.006542129,
-0.2820996642,
0.7401482463,
-0.256559968,
-0.2478128225,
0.4445660412,
0.6829475164,
0.0493822061,
0.0274047442,
-0.5889132619,
0.0693913326,
-0.329077214,
-0.3959192634,
0.2896560729,
0.6252887249,
-0.3583117723,
0.8648511171,
0.5353377461,
0.0905748382,
-0.2519191206,
0.1238105819,
0.6421996951,
-0.5315833092,
-0.2655937076,
-1.1641734838,
0.2489987761,
0.2088288516,
0.1337664872,
0.7430253029,
0.118610248,
0.9628174305,
-0.1876390725,
0.6470275521,
0.2215209752,
0.3397344649,
-0.8111006021,
0.4267279804,
-0.7641313672,
0.468365103,
-0.268604815,
-0.8227081895,
-0.3628509939,
0.7941316366,
-0.7535546422,
0.1859438717,
0.6537649632,
0.7426972389,
-0.206170544,
-0.1249990463,
0.4539140761,
0.5126773119,
0.2444351315,
0.6780557036,
0.8691722155,
-0.0667841807,
0.2138514966,
0.2976646423,
-0.2369105816,
-0.0963585749,
-1.0217314959,
-1.1219675541,
-0.3627571762,
-0.1295901835,
-0.2270897627,
-0.0011680593,
0.8713836074,
0.5637100339,
-0.9180414081,
-0.0372855142,
-0.1481412053,
0.3872038722,
-0.0093778167,
-0.2128438354,
0.2435113937,
-0.3145161271,
-0.4517478943,
0.4887764454,
0.3745881617,
-0.1022039056,
-0.102042757,
-0.0009383783,
-0.4042515159,
0.5567398071,
0.7102629542,
0.1684249043,
-1.0237600803,
-0.3560026288,
-0.1070592403,
-0.0700311661,
-0.2504295409,
0.6610782743,
-1.1113764048,
0.3270642757,
0.7983720899,
0.5594215989,
0.0842009932,
0.0247376487,
0.4424456656,
-0.3291433454,
0.2233790159,
-0.2061778754,
0.6439321637,
0.2948047221,
-0.03285034,
0.3398196399,
0.4675679803,
-0.3659802973,
-0.659237504,
0.519631505,
-0.6200777888,
-0.8891952038,
1.2915639877,
-0.0864570811,
-0.1554990709,
-0.1082362905,
-0.1039856896,
0.0079412842,
0.157659784,
0.4405477345,
0.8342328668,
-0.203845188,
-0.2818567455,
-0.8455417156,
0.3518936932,
0.6118105054,
-0.6964777708,
-0.1354702562,
0.6457231641,
0.508002758,
-0.1319682747,
0.5860197544,
0.0875539482,
0.1576448381,
-0.2897308767,
-0.6189036369,
0.2350101322,
-0.3528962731,
-0.3159418106,
0.0625000373,
0.0015298921,
0.3577644527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12080v1
|
Can LLMs Compute with Reasons?
| 2024-02-19T12:04:25 | 2024-02-19T12:04:25 |
Harshit Sandilya, Peehu Raj, Jainit Sushil Bafna, Srija Mukhopadhyay, Shivansh Sharma, Ellwil Sharma, Arastu Sharma, Neeta Trivedi, Manish Shrivastava, Rajesh Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with complex mathematical tasks,
prone to "hallucinating" incorrect answers due to their reliance on statistical
patterns. This limitation is further amplified in average Small LangSLMs with
limited context and training data. To address this challenge, we propose an
"Inductive Learning" approach utilizing a distributed network of SLMs. This
network leverages error-based learning and hint incorporation to refine the
reasoning capabilities of SLMs. Our goal is to provide a framework that
empowers SLMs to approach the level of logic-based applications achieved by
high-parameter models, potentially benefiting any language model. Ultimately,
this novel concept paves the way for bridging the logical gap between humans
and LLMs across various fields.
|
[
-0.2169968188,
-0.5644043088,
0.8726987839,
0.2593746185,
0.0054841847,
-0.0003119947,
-0.4506314993,
-0.0988213643,
0.1434933543,
0.4657360613,
-0.844019711,
-0.4912041128,
-0.4709194601,
0.1942673177,
-0.4322412908,
0.7160370946,
0.0799511075,
0.3022640049,
-0.6343841553,
-0.0634086281,
-0.3990234137,
-0.3881281316,
-0.8507564068,
-0.6633868217,
0.6526001692,
0.5125430226,
0.5953130126,
0.3580347002,
0.4970824122,
0.3066393137,
0.2757899761,
0.7228503227,
-0.1708863676,
0.4944192767,
-0.4527732432,
-0.9829118252,
-0.0519413501,
-0.1261024177,
0.4981915653,
1.0920814276,
-0.2769922912,
0.1016369313,
-0.059007477,
0.7795746326,
-0.491763413,
0.2313287854,
-0.8547605276,
0.1005557105,
-0.0620481782,
-0.4292986393,
-0.7816586494,
-0.4663285911,
-0.1125750542,
-0.5856510997,
0.330719322,
-0.1039864644,
0.6610423326,
0.4855511487,
-0.0601030327,
-0.6065107584,
-0.7446569204,
0.6703976989,
-0.6988635063,
0.2463179529,
0.3124966621,
0.3518680334,
-0.3872800171,
-0.5420732498,
-0.4104710519,
0.0057005002,
-0.181917116,
-0.1087055579,
0.1618766785,
-0.0022291567,
0.5003430843,
-0.1242394298,
-0.3477116227,
0.2335665822,
-0.2167252153,
0.0663731098,
0.6770633459,
0.3551138043,
0.3639441133,
0.0786550939,
-0.0721944124,
0.193443656,
-0.9621112943,
-0.088011682,
0.1188118532,
0.720980823,
0.0530049615,
0.6345693469,
-0.169035852,
0.6675775051,
-0.1035999879,
-0.2758286595,
0.0464354753,
0.1863220483,
-0.3979451358,
0.221073851,
0.6403637528,
0.0520265959,
0.1506391913,
-0.2689313293,
-0.585242033,
0.1272630692,
-0.1209511161,
-0.6729050875,
-0.1880479902,
0.1546324342,
-0.1889449358,
-0.1551151723,
-0.1546992511,
-0.4643082917,
-0.8609719872,
-0.6426333785,
0.4897552133,
-0.2295240611,
-0.3658726811,
0.3382122815,
0.0096874256,
-0.0207297448,
0.7346686125,
-0.7944923043,
0.4506290257,
0.7644620538,
0.8367583156,
-0.1677870154,
-0.3506253064,
-0.6314399242,
-0.1168492958,
-0.5988257527,
0.6045759916,
-0.4327735007,
-0.0559942536,
0.028843144,
-0.1244642213,
-0.2014370412,
-0.9428560138,
0.4135247171,
-0.6325550675,
-0.0320981555,
-0.426836431,
-0.6210144758,
-0.0385609791,
0.1338630766,
-0.6919093728,
0.8490719795,
-0.0193239413,
-0.6316573024,
0.1248391792,
-0.6330701113,
-0.5781778693,
0.2634394467,
-0.6114193201,
-0.2416849136,
0.3022730649,
0.0320538841,
0.6869682074,
-0.6572031975,
0.4265222251,
-0.3076829016,
-0.2911997437,
0.479365468,
-0.2594407201,
0.9990124702,
0.3347973526,
-0.4278157055,
0.2189486474,
-0.7394556403,
0.0163454041,
0.4207285047,
-0.379306227,
-0.4524849653,
0.3549058139,
-0.6211663485,
0.3400271833,
0.1087897494,
-0.365537554,
0.0749181286,
-0.3669755459,
0.4438063502,
0.8146609068,
-0.3158352077,
0.4090024829,
-0.326423794,
0.541572094,
0.2061467916,
-0.2650501728,
-0.0990577936,
-0.2748323679,
-1.1926789284,
-0.1805300266,
-0.1152832657,
0.5306012034,
-0.8201209307,
0.2039228529,
-0.1115972921,
-0.2064407915,
-0.4999573529,
0.429150939,
0.0996579677,
0.3884304762,
0.2483583838,
0.2464295328,
-0.6241195202,
-0.4844706059,
-0.0498112813,
0.062250033,
0.0062339101,
0.4261287153,
0.3536714315,
-0.2531844676,
0.9534848928,
-0.2119065523,
-0.0887897909,
-0.4838635623,
-0.1745298207,
0.3411813378,
0.2417724878,
0.1344812512,
-0.5671754479,
-0.2878018022,
0.1108062342,
-1.1604781151,
-0.246382758,
-0.2854145467,
-0.096696943,
0.1508399695,
0.7685748935,
-0.9726378322,
0.3595829606,
0.2379550934,
-0.1602116525,
0.6799603105,
-0.1599355489,
-0.4095213711,
-0.8356856108,
-0.4649429321,
0.0946303457,
-0.1788955778,
-0.3653703034,
0.0903844982,
-0.1125272885,
-0.1591817588,
-0.2166694105,
0.3572132885,
-0.3945377767,
-0.365160495,
-0.2863331735,
0.3463142812,
0.067266427,
0.2154707611,
-0.0677132681,
0.6236775517,
0.7515624762,
-0.8353062868,
0.8277649283,
-0.1477879137,
-0.2761211395,
0.5588409901,
-0.716807723,
-0.1671453565,
-0.3569778204,
0.0822024196,
-0.7570745349,
-0.3059455454,
0.0440012962,
-0.4718333781,
0.1038034037,
0.1702886075,
-0.7245947123,
-0.1301741898,
0.2151227295,
0.2057344168,
0.2947639227,
-0.9617365599,
0.7224880457,
0.1927137077,
0.1115003452,
-0.3479055166,
-0.5847517848,
0.0250173546,
-0.3054242134,
-0.6770174503,
0.0089861825,
0.0348781012,
-0.7300921679,
-0.0072678588,
0.2493814677,
0.2387114018,
0.319589287,
0.455870688,
0.1958856136,
-0.2559319437,
0.7561867237,
-0.1407898068,
0.0701397806,
0.4608624279,
-0.5273231864,
0.6140244007,
-0.2398344427,
-0.6792733669,
-0.3284547031,
0.3485974967,
0.6921362281,
-0.3860784769,
0.7105843425,
0.1714428216,
-0.6410582662,
-1.0996595621,
-0.4065558314,
-0.4902165532,
-0.521263659,
0.2476612478,
-0.4497259259,
-0.9891984463,
0.6142443419,
-0.3739752769,
-0.1476062387,
0.2464219481,
0.6859900355,
-0.0619853884,
1.100414753,
0.3481194079,
0.0952906236,
0.0620020442,
-0.071029,
0.3120912611,
-0.4832341373,
-0.4176424444,
-0.5179141164,
-0.1661799997,
-0.4745290279,
-0.5074347258,
0.1918511093,
0.2045541108,
-0.4789261222,
-0.072644487,
-0.5026739836,
0.4598332047,
0.4274210036,
0.2447404116,
0.1933254898,
0.1477651447,
-0.6104775071,
0.0097972909,
-0.8199312091,
-0.2040166408,
0.7565549612,
0.4467900991,
1.1970696449,
0.1918637156,
0.7824887633,
0.0748793706,
0.2913606465,
-0.9274634123,
0.7378082871,
0.0231761895,
-0.4506201744,
-0.357483387,
-0.6423582435,
-0.7190781236,
0.113181673,
-0.0268190261,
-0.6587694883,
-0.0237347446,
-0.1577783972,
-0.1667287648,
0.4495603144,
-0.6093838215,
0.5192140937,
-0.3720881343,
-0.3887480199,
-0.1258783042,
-0.4219816327,
0.4352460802,
0.1561834067,
0.3931251168,
-0.2890042663,
0.2134303749,
0.5778220296,
-0.7140539289,
1.1024295092,
-0.2234060913,
-0.0618491508,
0.4658166766,
0.2002271861,
0.6771065593,
0.1120311022,
-0.1620624661,
-0.2699809074,
-0.5113258362,
-0.2144474834,
-0.901671052,
0.8408626318,
-0.838737309,
-0.632183671,
-0.3187414706,
-0.7267850637,
-0.224062711,
0.0678108335,
0.0996775031,
0.5013247132,
0.5312293172,
0.0292807594,
1.0323290825,
-0.0929380432,
0.4862509072,
0.369741112,
-0.4623837471,
-0.0757349506,
0.8539590836,
-0.0493585989,
0.3903436363,
0.2342750281,
0.2845953107,
-0.2864683568,
-0.5625406504,
-0.2617455721,
0.4520035684,
-1.2847553492,
-0.2027176619,
-0.3616478443,
-0.3841513097,
-0.2053033561,
-0.2078101486,
-0.3072592616,
-0.2331916094,
-0.6255793571,
-0.3585383296,
0.5294968486,
0.9342190027,
0.0710175559,
0.1321817487,
-0.4286470115,
-0.0791996494,
0.3514614403,
0.4067570865,
0.1882290691,
-0.3851493895,
-0.3117125332,
-0.052086398,
0.1469681263,
-0.6739766598,
0.4162730575,
0.2181552798,
0.6914988756,
0.2367717922,
0.2226441801,
0.5548745394,
-0.4793007076,
0.397734195,
0.399938345,
-0.8611133099,
0.6500897408,
-0.1667510271,
0.0853797942,
0.4104992151,
0.5175500512,
-0.3996644318,
-0.3143935204,
-0.3871099055,
-0.5758462548,
0.4641430676,
-0.2248995751,
-0.061005,
-0.2409649342,
0.6841279864,
-0.1436111182,
0.053552106,
-0.7944936156,
-0.2497127801,
0.0255817436,
-0.3323835731,
0.1159213111,
0.0522279851,
-0.3770326376,
-0.3738899231,
0.6216583848,
-0.4721267521,
0.1665491611,
0.2336276025,
-0.2741399407,
-0.1721631736,
0.1609304547,
0.7098835707,
1.0200148821,
0.1225815862,
0.6363407373,
0.1301449388,
-0.0250787567,
0.1960478723,
-0.1522565633,
-0.2410559356,
0.156812638,
0.1996190399,
0.8647258282,
-0.0916462392,
-0.8803211451,
0.4444695413,
-0.1728954762,
-0.1621057987,
-0.4344881475,
0.0782350302,
0.4657965899,
0.3395783603,
0.5248456597,
0.0358856469,
-0.1566099823,
-0.3327690363,
0.3879922926,
0.6451317668,
-0.507527113,
-0.1451939344,
0.4470132887,
0.0996448025,
-0.4268725216,
0.5791635513,
-0.5953899622,
-0.6006528139,
0.7570806146,
0.893217802,
0.7049273252,
-0.1165280491,
0.3114665747,
0.3798582852,
0.3905281425,
-0.2097507119,
0.17545183,
0.1368337274,
-1.1193416119,
-0.6791121364,
-0.6875378489,
-0.3597254753,
0.0106940269,
-0.4275070727,
0.3218255639,
-0.9416053295,
0.0774510726,
-0.0930134133,
-0.1628788114,
-0.5580427051,
0.3508144319,
0.2198808938,
0.709438026,
-0.8528250456,
0.8955079913,
0.6793980598,
-0.3604498506,
-1.1309095621,
-0.481780827,
-0.0444110036,
-0.8706253767,
1.2040284872,
0.3112251163,
-0.3218190372,
-0.0133316489,
-0.7183558941,
-0.6871783137,
1.0688621998,
0.5145492554,
-0.6380357146,
-0.0344990306,
0.2761332393,
0.178965807,
-0.7924869061,
0.1931095868,
0.5717726946,
0.0580641814,
0.2646901608,
-0.6062222719,
0.2930961251,
-0.0722154379,
-0.102482006,
0.2381901145,
-0.3420194387,
1.178093791,
-0.4733852148,
-0.2004144937,
-0.3999227583,
0.6106078029,
0.5753848553,
0.3915988505,
0.423938185,
0.8335894942,
1.2404888868,
-0.0478600152,
0.7584691048,
-0.0305202361,
0.4853447378,
1.2284224033,
-0.5577776432,
0.6549894214,
0.3933233917,
-0.2586336732,
0.6666735411,
0.5662120581,
0.3396763802,
0.3070876598,
0.583247602,
-0.7329267859,
-0.5014173388,
-0.2026904076,
-0.0581303053,
0.1220860332,
0.9510212541,
-0.3022086918,
-0.4524805546,
0.0705540553,
0.0386995636,
0.3111349344,
-0.6630589366,
0.5801581144,
0.2954315841,
-0.5590624213,
0.5902412534,
-0.0431037582,
0.6599856615,
-0.4811818302,
-0.0504363924,
-0.0423437953,
0.3892152011,
-0.6408256888,
-0.435105592,
0.2658600211,
-0.3039065897,
-0.1897190213,
-0.0022388957,
0.8713704348,
-0.3972181976,
-0.6508001685,
0.3597952724,
0.5307018161,
0.0370565504,
0.0678343922,
-0.5843485594,
0.1128486395,
-0.1426416039,
0.1467577815,
0.3332117796,
0.7550475597,
-0.087527439,
0.9755404592,
0.7038136125,
0.2547937334,
0.3088867664,
0.3957900107,
0.8220912814,
-0.5645576715,
-0.2653137147,
-1.1426471472,
0.2714020014,
-0.0294224173,
0.0096900668,
0.8495146632,
0.3155637681,
0.8289189935,
0.1808751076,
1.0110762119,
0.2092534751,
0.6426217556,
-0.6461645365,
0.5313673019,
-0.5426362157,
0.6053647995,
0.1614265889,
-0.5510409474,
-0.5560070872,
0.8170601726,
-0.2774478495,
-0.163936913,
0.7983487844,
0.730809629,
0.2634548843,
0.034653943,
0.3349526823,
0.026864307,
0.5176482201,
0.6315573454,
0.9390817285,
-0.0374625996,
0.2026896179,
-0.2775813639,
-0.2129817754,
-0.2922252417,
-0.8774200082,
-1.1156316996,
-0.4323331416,
-0.3078640401,
-0.611626327,
-0.1475303173,
1.3329893351,
0.5144578815,
-0.7766190767,
-0.5080067515,
-0.6067332029,
0.5530822277,
-0.0744900331,
-0.2557741106,
0.1758161932,
-1.0149495602,
-0.3575193286,
0.407363385,
0.3136977851,
-0.1638669521,
-0.6420037746,
-0.3076508641,
-0.0875141993,
0.1687258333,
0.6487274766,
0.217065528,
-0.6509849429,
-0.1063923389,
0.1334437132,
-0.3468957841,
-0.040834561,
0.9448435903,
-0.8126425147,
0.3766034842,
0.4281174839,
1.1696131229,
0.2983652353,
-0.2702571452,
0.3410382569,
-0.73246032,
0.1965568811,
0.3243889213,
0.444947511,
0.6227231026,
-0.4745855629,
0.3346620202,
0.4907441437,
-0.686054945,
-0.8584734201,
0.4139389396,
-0.6998357773,
-0.2661730051,
1.2234658003,
-0.169668898,
-0.2161562443,
-0.0121117886,
0.2346058786,
0.0027335207,
-0.1480219215,
0.5164134502,
0.6815087199,
-0.2056072801,
-0.4503480792,
-0.7830294967,
0.5429933071,
0.4169567525,
-0.9041813016,
0.109623,
0.4276764989,
0.2685028315,
0.2315274179,
0.5706843734,
0.0947884992,
0.2084699422,
-0.2742983103,
0.0913865864,
0.0689380988,
-0.6231221557,
-0.3638470471,
0.1452214718,
0.4142054021,
0.0701573789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12079v1
|
LVCHAT: Facilitating Long Video Comprehension
| 2024-02-19T11:59:14 | 2024-02-19T11:59:14 |
Yu Wang, Zeyuan Zhang, Julian McAuley, Zexue He
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Enabling large language models (LLMs) to read videos is vital for multimodal
LLMs. Existing works show promise on short videos whereas long video (longer
than e.g.~1 minute) comprehension remains challenging. The major problem lies
in the over-compression of videos, i.e., the encoded video representations are
not enough to represent the whole video. To address this issue, we propose Long
Video Chat (LVChat), where Frame-Scalable Encoding (FSE) is introduced to
dynamically adjust the number of embeddings in alignment with the duration of
the video to ensure long videos are not overly compressed into a few
embeddings. To deal with long videos whose length is beyond videos seen during
training, we propose Interleaved Frame Encoding (IFE), repeating positional
embedding and interleaving multiple groups of videos to enable long video
input, avoiding performance degradation due to overly long videos. Experimental
results show that LVChat significantly outperforms existing methods by up to
27\% in accuracy on long-video QA datasets and long-video captioning
benchmarks. Our code is published at https://github.com/wangyu-ustc/LVChat.
|
[
-0.3886040449,
-0.9622537494,
0.5881072879,
0.5894711018,
-0.6515179873,
0.4885560274,
-0.512573719,
-0.3462592959,
0.4733045995,
0.3008286357,
-0.6754048467,
-0.2402284443,
-0.5662980676,
-0.1565345824,
-0.5235207677,
0.5219181776,
-0.0460795015,
0.0705841035,
-0.3934909999,
-0.3200863302,
-0.5392045379,
-0.4006315172,
-0.3452479243,
0.041151572,
0.3905676603,
0.6062913537,
0.7627694011,
0.5028398633,
0.5771548152,
0.3194432855,
0.0239002202,
0.3446188569,
-0.5757805109,
0.3271873891,
0.1311274171,
-0.4517818093,
-0.3739894927,
-0.5107117891,
0.9820452332,
0.3030546308,
-0.1091332883,
0.3447039127,
0.0286407154,
0.7199973464,
-0.6413408518,
0.4052864611,
-0.3998633921,
0.0898984894,
-0.1372962892,
-0.5196605921,
-0.3655017316,
0.0642896593,
-0.1622173488,
-0.5857958794,
-0.1818705052,
0.1722217798,
0.3646782041,
0.7031046748,
-0.3432312012,
-0.0588020682,
-0.5887492299,
0.6856207848,
-0.552128315,
0.6834946871,
0.5853791833,
0.5892961621,
-0.1223524883,
-0.4940358698,
-0.8689139485,
-0.2522366941,
0.2455191314,
0.0535181016,
-0.2297402173,
0.2819828689,
0.5171864033,
0.4960185289,
-0.4802703261,
0.4196923673,
-0.3886829019,
-0.1216503382,
0.365273416,
0.1340361536,
0.2501598001,
-0.2585524023,
-0.3574434817,
-0.1739576906,
-0.3315388858,
0.4493511021,
0.2176045626,
0.0397738218,
-0.1399812996,
0.7009207606,
-0.5572453737,
0.5639032125,
-0.056053035,
-0.4130934775,
0.2632364035,
-0.0419701189,
-0.6749961972,
-0.0017863242,
0.5463930964,
0.6301370263,
0.1000389308,
0.1611203402,
0.1143642142,
0.2072051167,
0.0197532307,
-0.9323651791,
0.0218671132,
0.4349511862,
-0.3361595571,
-0.1668896079,
0.0148042059,
-1.0072057247,
-0.3743470907,
-0.3328942657,
0.4324251711,
-0.2941134572,
-0.1668671668,
0.2205669731,
0.0236508437,
0.6090871096,
0.3098806143,
-0.9375193715,
0.3381900191,
0.5558807254,
0.8335736394,
-0.2448470443,
-0.417071104,
-1.0382376909,
0.0838147625,
-0.1402235925,
0.4014056325,
-0.4167110026,
-0.1258746833,
0.306963712,
0.3037254512,
0.5099585652,
-0.0362226889,
0.2971461117,
-0.6312839985,
0.0639858544,
-0.0866657495,
-0.616756618,
-0.0941677988,
0.4611327648,
-0.5250760317,
0.7598916888,
-0.1922180802,
-0.6289387345,
0.276578933,
-0.4965937734,
-0.1380352974,
0.042251274,
-0.3621970713,
-0.3373166919,
-0.0470212288,
0.6959939599,
0.8184005618,
-0.1429868788,
0.3269426525,
-0.3499045074,
-0.4160607159,
0.2489690334,
-0.798928678,
0.2361835092,
0.1363312155,
-0.0949857756,
0.4125249982,
-0.5181171298,
0.0367767364,
-0.1138206348,
-0.1211694181,
0.0292822216,
-0.0112239011,
-0.2015106082,
-0.0556395724,
-0.136553809,
-0.5903051496,
0.2342047691,
-0.115794614,
0.9851408005,
0.7837114334,
-0.2469530702,
0.5374778509,
-0.0643046945,
0.7918970585,
-0.1489565969,
0.3196277022,
-0.5489890575,
-0.1736047417,
-0.6810426116,
-0.3432291448,
-0.1500626504,
0.4356083572,
-1.2709536552,
-0.0358477384,
-0.5751218796,
-0.3327059746,
-0.4925321639,
0.2637277544,
0.1905117184,
0.0896843448,
0.4857110381,
-0.2503991723,
-0.317070812,
-0.7419216633,
0.2583171725,
-0.0999884605,
-0.0955843031,
0.1130320653,
0.4749030471,
-0.3709765077,
0.8140752316,
-0.5336134434,
-0.2446810305,
-0.191405654,
-0.3436599672,
0.1002450809,
0.1266005486,
0.4007563293,
-0.6556010842,
-0.4383281767,
-0.2338516861,
-0.6315531731,
0.4888161123,
-0.2543109059,
0.0197610427,
0.1202530414,
1.0229684114,
-0.4835510254,
0.4010002911,
1.0480870008,
0.0506438091,
0.3555100858,
-0.405795306,
0.4467191696,
-0.9918296933,
-0.5177924633,
-0.2371568084,
-0.745772481,
-0.274371326,
0.1815048158,
0.2119132727,
-0.4493091702,
-0.7889153361,
0.2288073897,
-0.5246638656,
-0.1626503319,
-0.2209094912,
0.3457835615,
-0.0461449064,
0.7947274446,
0.0767073333,
0.9025325179,
0.7412812114,
-0.4944639504,
0.8358570933,
0.3174850345,
-0.6091529131,
0.6057894826,
-0.5984063148,
-0.017128868,
-0.2908836901,
0.6615515351,
-0.8841253519,
-0.7063461542,
0.064677313,
-0.5465667844,
0.3588912785,
-0.0839250535,
-0.173670575,
-0.3764492571,
-0.6377016902,
0.6679061651,
0.5045292974,
-0.999425292,
0.3519260287,
0.3939030468,
0.0027549905,
-0.8436103463,
-0.7838640213,
0.2356706411,
-0.4424471557,
-0.8774014115,
0.3781251311,
-0.3410484195,
0.0667665973,
-0.3243557811,
-0.1204421148,
-0.2220028192,
-0.4924782217,
0.4375372827,
-0.0427957922,
-0.280842036,
0.5120896101,
0.0270709023,
-0.0013935353,
-0.0382387452,
-0.0116839856,
0.482403785,
-0.2234424353,
-0.4773742259,
-0.5595756173,
0.6834184527,
0.7725901604,
-0.1660683751,
0.623903513,
0.7504668236,
-0.1323693246,
-0.4183133543,
-0.6156024337,
-0.1492027938,
-0.5397961736,
0.7182033062,
-0.2370532304,
-1.4197900295,
0.2928977311,
0.1710899919,
-0.1391436756,
-0.1261413395,
0.4165575802,
-0.583283484,
0.5378638506,
0.7357851863,
-0.2100084424,
0.7620773315,
-0.0953613743,
0.1198696122,
-0.513818562,
-0.0914516822,
0.0838550702,
-0.2492422163,
-0.5658320785,
-1.0680416822,
0.374545753,
-0.0666532665,
-0.1907717288,
0.1738587916,
-0.2631090581,
0.8638558388,
0.3737995923,
0.3036376536,
0.1157892048,
-0.0507918522,
0.6929409504,
-0.269310683,
-0.5200453997,
-0.0851695389,
0.4745199978,
0.8789212704,
1.0248037577,
0.3495117426,
0.3592972755,
0.420050472,
-0.424790889,
-1.0970416069,
0.7772372365,
-0.108845368,
-0.123539336,
-0.5471909642,
-0.1212634817,
-0.8187636137,
-0.0403295644,
-0.0460405797,
-0.4478603601,
-0.1334621161,
0.2352469116,
-0.4838356674,
0.4828233719,
-0.3152464032,
0.5088735819,
-0.3097650111,
-0.43132779,
-0.5549730062,
-0.8127240539,
0.5448473692,
0.1835754812,
0.3266144991,
0.0426309071,
0.0394427553,
0.7466506362,
-0.5235522389,
0.837612927,
0.004846096,
0.0298585389,
0.4318164587,
-0.0000367532,
0.3221319914,
0.5059318542,
0.5179589987,
-0.0749695301,
0.2333890349,
-0.5491307974,
-0.7588145137,
0.4844036996,
-0.6750214696,
-0.7028503418,
-0.3847461045,
-0.3776611984,
-0.2926306725,
-0.2292267531,
-0.0583100617,
0.4671878815,
0.1046205387,
0.8622599244,
0.912455976,
-0.5282523632,
0.7010222077,
-0.0180428289,
-0.4581640363,
-0.603939712,
0.8299283981,
-0.4409651756,
0.6189852953,
0.6195088625,
-0.0932376236,
-0.1086138636,
-0.4029239714,
-0.4118625224,
0.0674072355,
-0.9871186614,
-0.3195444345,
-0.2644190788,
-0.2521568537,
-0.225309521,
-0.1640106589,
-0.4685826004,
-0.1993770003,
-0.183896631,
-0.3418017924,
0.6450083852,
0.2474657893,
-0.0180981271,
0.6623980999,
-1.0237417221,
0.5895984173,
0.769489944,
0.4143690467,
-0.2033133358,
-0.8464832306,
-0.2571741343,
-0.1350542009,
-0.0591285452,
-0.7301248312,
0.2497738749,
0.1786761433,
0.3523106873,
0.2899606526,
-0.0938240513,
1.10486269,
-0.4001655579,
0.9229337573,
0.45814538,
-1.0285576582,
0.3746061325,
-0.4326646626,
0.3456226885,
0.4965036511,
0.3263664544,
-0.733746469,
0.0398037545,
-0.0165147409,
-0.71597296,
0.302190274,
0.2090886086,
0.5351498723,
0.1402457058,
0.1578905135,
0.0905398801,
0.0074646641,
-0.7960866094,
0.1682861447,
-0.4376550913,
0.028319113,
-0.0802929848,
-0.5487897992,
0.1344379187,
-0.2489307523,
0.5528278351,
-0.3053824306,
0.2964401245,
0.2675650716,
-0.3921977282,
0.070796594,
0.3829154372,
0.7642239332,
0.5997957587,
-0.2364605516,
-0.1006770507,
0.44239223,
-0.4873611927,
0.0671815127,
-0.4164144993,
0.5935354233,
-0.2060734779,
0.5634647608,
0.9934996367,
0.2258806676,
-0.8859316111,
0.6556499004,
-0.2115689218,
-0.2070447803,
-0.5550982356,
-0.1495779604,
-0.0160252675,
0.554941237,
0.0359018855,
-0.4576067626,
-0.2506766617,
-0.8184955716,
0.3062080443,
0.2847533822,
-0.3206170499,
-0.0470378213,
0.6110117435,
0.4053193331,
-0.4333645701,
0.8198809028,
-0.034397807,
-0.4236623645,
0.2415224612,
0.12093658,
0.4855329692,
-0.0276758242,
0.2198356539,
0.443765074,
0.1914751381,
-0.2401564866,
0.1070762053,
-0.4658268988,
-0.3465493023,
-0.9730946422,
-0.5902868509,
-0.5807718039,
0.0576105379,
-0.7679153681,
0.5378512144,
-0.1208030656,
0.0440244786,
-0.4058761895,
-0.2369151413,
-0.5502108932,
0.0694737807,
0.505048871,
0.9063853025,
-0.5918454528,
1.1424945593,
-0.050830666,
-0.4256066978,
-0.6145187616,
-0.1852659732,
-0.2731613815,
-0.9658387899,
0.3936280608,
0.1535117924,
-0.0998725295,
-0.4075493813,
-0.6718238592,
-0.7600807548,
1.2473058701,
0.1909883469,
-1.2141824961,
-0.341989845,
0.2829229236,
0.3031238616,
-0.0549215078,
0.0711919665,
0.3638987541,
0.1638792455,
0.21726349,
-1.0058838129,
-0.2690145075,
0.0312433746,
-0.3308666646,
0.0535494201,
-0.7590800524,
0.4580624402,
-0.2457405925,
0.1744053513,
0.0870759636,
1.0810998678,
0.2327914536,
0.3149772286,
0.7528617978,
0.1339356899,
0.6303530931,
0.3315418065,
0.6900158525,
0.0509217046,
0.1334084421,
1.4340792894,
0.3234238327,
1.064845562,
0.8363821507,
-0.2884105146,
0.3292170167,
0.661544621,
0.1214795038,
0.3649200499,
0.2917701006,
-0.0967676118,
-0.568300128,
0.2099493444,
-0.3703809679,
0.7120290995,
0.5093967915,
-0.1778323799,
0.138422206,
0.5212373137,
-0.2202479392,
0.1775837988,
-0.459171921,
0.4427542388,
0.2969959974,
-0.5919895768,
0.4769550264,
-0.4278193414,
0.9556974173,
-0.6782120466,
0.0210478716,
-0.1108479723,
0.0878413022,
-0.2036991864,
-1.1532258987,
0.216277808,
0.0475676171,
-0.0640663505,
-0.2941736281,
0.407687515,
-0.5837222934,
-0.3068595827,
0.3290569782,
0.259881258,
0.2878176272,
-0.08755178,
-0.3110463917,
0.5218228102,
0.0863467231,
-0.1286452264,
0.4042668045,
0.2331926674,
-0.2534528971,
0.7855469584,
0.4102668166,
-0.2323403656,
-0.034877494,
0.2185941637,
0.8178136945,
-0.7090913653,
-0.5783337355,
-0.9842513204,
0.6001726389,
-0.0125604318,
0.011551871,
0.5636407733,
0.1337792277,
0.7350379825,
-0.0010028665,
0.3309586346,
0.183321014,
0.0622708499,
-0.7805116773,
0.3577285111,
-0.6043795347,
0.1192204952,
-0.1976947784,
-0.8108069301,
-0.3117307723,
0.3111223578,
0.0818795711,
-0.4850021899,
0.650899291,
0.6275211573,
-0.2877652347,
0.0452187248,
0.6722295284,
0.2421983033,
0.7944179177,
0.6958906054,
1.0535917282,
-0.3158101439,
0.897994101,
-0.2315457463,
-0.0960724875,
-0.1494067609,
-1.1202993393,
-1.0827797651,
-0.7787528634,
-0.2018291652,
-0.0997004434,
0.0103769088,
0.8931526542,
0.7872576714,
-0.2843676507,
-0.1321640611,
0.2839258611,
-0.1073635072,
0.0858390406,
-0.1274210364,
0.3475469053,
-0.0602901205,
-0.6889442801,
0.628413856,
0.3005952537,
-0.165809691,
-0.5649273992,
-0.1523791105,
0.1648450643,
-0.0000900265,
1.037894845,
0.3811315298,
-0.8023591042,
-0.6697602272,
0.0989777297,
0.2485549599,
0.2749929428,
0.7304494381,
-0.6898783445,
0.6101987362,
0.6216107607,
0.7827461362,
0.8536965847,
-0.0645937473,
0.3354666233,
-0.7694227695,
0.4436219931,
0.1405185014,
0.5185781717,
0.3506319523,
-0.1894045174,
0.4023638964,
-0.2848801613,
-0.8560188413,
-1.1059180498,
0.1050167829,
-1.6694322824,
-0.2831173539,
1.2638247013,
-0.0279197991,
-0.3109565377,
0.204489693,
-0.3545888364,
0.1844374985,
-0.3916514218,
0.6062522531,
0.6895999908,
-0.0528208278,
-0.5221479535,
-0.8066059947,
0.3681561649,
0.3070399165,
-0.7337035537,
0.18327263,
0.3286916316,
0.1802158356,
-0.1386118382,
0.7468798161,
0.3718674779,
0.5319401026,
-0.1357140839,
-0.349368453,
-0.1407311261,
-0.3311665952,
-0.277089119,
0.0387498289,
-0.1198480055,
-0.5463168621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12071v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12071v2
|
EmoBench: Evaluating the Emotional Intelligence of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T11:48:09 | 2024-06-07T07:43:45 |
Sahand Sabour, Siyang Liu, Zheyuan Zhang, June M. Liu, Jinfeng Zhou, Alvionna S. Sunaryo, Juanzi Li, Tatia M. C. Lee, Rada Mihalcea, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have highlighted the need for
robust, comprehensive, and challenging benchmarks. Yet, research on evaluating
their Emotional Intelligence (EI) is considerably limited. Existing benchmarks
have two major shortcomings: first, they mainly focus on emotion recognition,
neglecting essential EI capabilities such as emotion regulation and thought
facilitation through emotion understanding; second, they are primarily
constructed from existing datasets, which include frequent patterns, explicit
information, and annotation errors, leading to unreliable evaluation. We
propose EmoBench, a benchmark that draws upon established psychological
theories and proposes a comprehensive definition for machine EI, including
Emotional Understanding and Emotional Application. EmoBench includes a set of
400 hand-crafted questions in English and Chinese, which are meticulously
designed to require thorough reasoning and understanding. Our findings reveal a
considerable gap between the EI of existing LLMs and the average human,
highlighting a promising direction for future research. Our code and data are
publicly available at https://github.com/Sahandfer/EmoBench.
|
[
-0.3624770939,
-0.759239614,
0.4423181415,
0.3702236116,
0.0846605301,
-0.0663520098,
-0.4646435678,
-0.5064736605,
0.0607472099,
-0.015095721,
-0.6838482618,
-0.3703373969,
-0.3386262059,
0.2555870116,
-0.2857705057,
0.547606051,
-0.0157929417,
-0.2696544528,
0.0287021454,
-0.278947562,
0.0361095481,
-0.6367294788,
-0.4223501086,
-0.4589754343,
0.5943154097,
0.4156530499,
0.312272042,
0.3723914027,
0.3359427154,
0.2636066973,
-0.0887958705,
0.10678339,
-0.6359794736,
0.2215507627,
0.1645320207,
-0.5170515776,
-0.4741900265,
-0.0020738223,
0.361702472,
0.54231143,
-0.2763129473,
0.284643352,
-0.0148311835,
0.8069408536,
-0.8854151964,
-0.0834348649,
-0.2734077573,
0.3675131798,
-0.1576168686,
-0.0091499481,
-0.4649497271,
-0.4909704924,
0.0442604683,
-0.4086984396,
-0.2769021988,
0.4679818153,
0.6707544923,
0.3891586959,
-0.4187138677,
-0.3694365919,
-0.3308188319,
0.6301014423,
-0.6046739221,
0.5816056728,
0.3826518357,
0.0667214468,
0.1883506775,
-0.4586240053,
-0.2792935073,
-0.3034603894,
0.1514566243,
0.3508147001,
-0.6227379441,
-0.0067566899,
0.4657676518,
0.1301607639,
-0.6969980597,
0.2826822996,
-0.0885440856,
0.275559634,
0.5450889468,
0.4370173812,
0.1222273633,
0.0036158999,
0.0187475178,
-0.010580685,
-0.4946755171,
0.2257991433,
0.3450913131,
-0.1042163223,
-0.0355135649,
0.5755012035,
-0.2762773931,
0.3020301163,
0.2194033563,
0.3600357175,
0.4730799496,
0.2882362008,
-0.2919854522,
-0.0105441175,
0.566621542,
0.5101135373,
0.2745912969,
-0.2390964329,
-0.2099817842,
-0.2724856138,
0.1596067995,
-1.018969059,
-0.098582603,
0.6641248465,
-0.5133144855,
-0.0640536174,
0.0038055326,
-1.0171788931,
-0.5713902712,
-0.1101561859,
0.1863911003,
-0.5741202831,
-0.3772331178,
-0.1547060758,
0.0098963697,
0.3749310672,
0.1505574286,
-0.8986908197,
0.120140858,
1.0995835066,
0.7819295526,
0.351049751,
-0.4403915703,
-0.2482574731,
-0.0123659251,
-0.3923315108,
0.7412373424,
-0.6873435974,
-0.1393252015,
0.2988023162,
-0.1028107926,
-0.0501604006,
-0.5129718184,
0.7559089661,
-0.1697621047,
-0.284242481,
-0.265034765,
-0.6668279767,
-0.4493994117,
0.4426189065,
-0.5669193864,
1.2339308262,
-0.0617939644,
-0.5784675479,
0.1245360002,
-0.4741048813,
-0.4254704416,
-0.1138805076,
0.075065501,
-0.0917514637,
0.6180611849,
0.2576849759,
0.531016171,
-0.6806444526,
0.2161574066,
-0.8093723059,
-0.3468901813,
0.6209647059,
-0.2330424041,
0.715259552,
0.1942221671,
-0.4381160736,
-0.2752351761,
-0.6435274482,
0.3499778807,
0.0193474069,
0.0015525818,
-0.3880099356,
-0.0557013191,
0.0431220047,
0.1488381773,
0.3225697577,
-0.5327233076,
-0.1854606122,
-0.2296598107,
0.3671573699,
0.91717273,
-0.4416202307,
0.1747776717,
-0.288187623,
0.4915467501,
-0.5771818757,
0.1258938611,
-0.1808719039,
-0.0639555678,
-0.9581776261,
-0.4452480972,
0.0329184979,
0.4698600173,
0.0067637782,
0.5862184167,
-0.0867020935,
-1.0528447628,
-0.7947642803,
0.1219955161,
0.3922860324,
-0.0084753968,
-0.0447536297,
0.0722487941,
-0.5246244073,
-0.8826024532,
-0.5036769509,
-0.180387795,
-0.287466675,
0.6249024272,
0.6187754273,
-0.2493547648,
0.6399395466,
-0.2581332326,
0.0550197922,
-0.2008958757,
0.4179244936,
0.1164850071,
0.1908405125,
0.4266653061,
-0.4559150934,
-0.2504252493,
0.0619279854,
-0.9420326352,
-0.6062902808,
0.1930468231,
-0.3311792314,
-0.0031049589,
0.4180999696,
-0.3063624799,
0.1007137969,
0.6201766133,
-0.2840452194,
0.2755906284,
0.0039459625,
0.4377556443,
-0.6218772531,
0.5073735714,
0.0961026847,
0.1267943829,
-0.6497687101,
-0.0535418727,
0.2421394736,
-0.2390916944,
-0.2886985838,
0.4594370425,
-0.4140332341,
-0.1221017167,
-0.0701949447,
0.3125202954,
-0.0623091273,
0.4565283954,
-0.3744035661,
0.1349343956,
0.164447099,
-0.3816790879,
0.6290371418,
0.0432126299,
-0.3355877697,
0.9910436869,
-0.7052740455,
0.4329046905,
0.0157686528,
0.0499406122,
-0.6369025111,
-0.2453632355,
-0.0071785399,
-0.3994471133,
0.1873978227,
0.3374747634,
-0.4833321869,
-0.4168593287,
-0.4359909296,
0.180845201,
0.6187826991,
-0.6290807128,
1.0707850456,
0.4584201872,
-0.3202384412,
-0.4441976547,
-0.5380246043,
-0.0440446623,
-0.1720828116,
-0.6096951962,
0.1151944101,
-0.0914713517,
-0.4237837493,
0.1284650117,
0.0713808984,
-0.1734711081,
0.4551421404,
0.462541014,
-0.2594813108,
-0.1259017885,
0.4389025867,
-0.0347025767,
-0.0003866983,
0.2690117061,
0.4363510907,
0.3724868894,
-0.6080026031,
-0.4051755965,
-0.294894278,
0.314478606,
0.6466911435,
-0.3163859546,
0.570369482,
0.6528807282,
-0.6900361776,
-0.4583912492,
-0.6931277514,
-0.0500589609,
-0.4248546362,
0.8621219397,
-0.5008060336,
-0.8707966208,
0.5227890611,
-0.4022417665,
0.1849189699,
0.1478489935,
0.7161886692,
-0.3002168536,
1.14031744,
0.5896955729,
0.0758799091,
0.3615488708,
0.1996425241,
0.2941429019,
-1.0487480164,
-0.2930578291,
-0.6986396909,
-0.4632755816,
-0.2741912305,
-0.2031945884,
-0.1085986122,
-0.0588586554,
-0.7473171949,
-0.1271027178,
-0.1599081606,
0.2509985268,
0.3151964247,
0.1288954765,
-0.0988829955,
-0.3035069108,
-0.0363001227,
-0.2064971775,
-0.4425514936,
-0.6331824064,
0.8823150396,
0.505443573,
0.9140748382,
0.1798839569,
0.453668505,
0.1836448163,
0.7473294139,
-0.7128657103,
0.5781548619,
-0.007773343,
-0.7284500599,
-0.0983333439,
-0.3319432437,
-0.6280580759,
0.3436252773,
-0.1352793425,
-1.0119867325,
0.021851141,
0.006005866,
-0.2223543227,
0.1539392024,
-0.6570156813,
0.8934188485,
-0.8449109197,
-0.4211022556,
-0.4894373715,
-0.254391849,
0.2707348168,
-0.4059111774,
0.1739780903,
-0.7053666711,
-0.246917069,
1.0127980709,
-0.1199758351,
0.7283601761,
0.0407257788,
0.076355055,
0.0362304077,
0.0568486936,
0.2323007882,
-0.2834108472,
-0.652348578,
0.031895753,
-0.2500891089,
-0.2885653079,
-0.7150937319,
0.4575263858,
-0.6462025046,
-0.5445458293,
-0.4341761768,
-0.3444302976,
-0.2164631039,
-0.1150251999,
-0.1008846909,
0.145628795,
-0.5965710878,
0.5680220127,
0.1303370446,
-0.4321524501,
0.1220305413,
0.7829471231,
-0.2185282409,
-0.4825503528,
0.7282932401,
0.0724742264,
-0.0824727342,
0.2790026963,
0.1326574236,
-0.2597045898,
0.098541528,
-0.2025576979,
0.2622101605,
-0.8119983673,
0.0409924984,
-0.5586560369,
0.1496987045,
-0.1026251987,
-0.4254418015,
-0.5536885858,
0.0068862368,
-0.1277068704,
-0.2600421309,
0.4819203615,
0.8614622951,
-0.1876116395,
-0.1241708174,
-0.8158147335,
-0.2203210294,
0.148655206,
0.252255857,
0.4815063179,
-0.66425246,
-0.5451225042,
-0.1203412786,
-0.3500538468,
-0.9919756055,
0.5980523229,
0.4922178686,
0.661886096,
0.8110921383,
0.3786818087,
0.7242138386,
-0.4839842021,
0.315639317,
0.0477851294,
-1.3524390459,
0.5671201348,
0.0200032964,
0.0280969571,
0.5005604625,
0.5051317215,
-0.7928707004,
-0.4271470904,
-0.3764006495,
-0.8678795695,
0.512793541,
0.0655044615,
-0.0801190883,
0.1990364343,
0.1437411904,
0.0331515893,
0.1929121017,
-0.5061406493,
-0.0893155262,
0.1315101981,
-0.5953832865,
-0.0732309297,
-0.2544932067,
0.0057285251,
-0.1807944924,
0.5166116357,
0.0472964868,
0.3434427977,
0.0558884479,
-0.289170444,
-0.2111024112,
0.3939596117,
0.0425660461,
0.3418093324,
-0.4246088564,
0.094220303,
0.5077362657,
-0.1128454506,
0.3087641597,
0.183190003,
0.12866579,
-0.3296000063,
0.3153607547,
0.679240644,
0.5329452157,
-1.1882631779,
0.2554419935,
-0.0045157005,
0.0025081842,
-0.4263583422,
-0.2423496097,
0.1746413559,
0.6351439357,
0.4311388135,
-0.3586624265,
0.1109153554,
-0.5470029116,
0.0537626669,
0.0759255886,
-0.5522837043,
-0.6054080129,
0.3383306563,
0.6110587716,
-0.3504479825,
0.9026922584,
-0.0978769511,
-0.9600410461,
0.7746158838,
0.443166554,
1.1526726484,
-0.3478164673,
-0.0737446696,
0.4060949981,
0.7877457738,
0.110416539,
0.4086221755,
0.2452471256,
-0.631215632,
-0.0566717871,
-0.4006780684,
-0.7897049189,
-0.1676749885,
-0.7278069258,
0.1393799484,
-0.4564720988,
-0.2849134803,
-0.3259720206,
0.0640054271,
-0.9069138169,
0.1610945314,
0.5252758265,
0.7473270297,
-1.0044547319,
0.3058142364,
0.8512163758,
-0.1035611778,
-0.7156556249,
-0.1440133154,
0.1820290238,
-0.6731681824,
0.6576589346,
0.8561884165,
-0.0334432721,
-0.0454813205,
-0.23625651,
-0.5968332887,
0.9186271429,
0.3299838305,
-0.4986468554,
0.2651487589,
-0.2696374655,
0.5219472051,
-0.5631981492,
0.9964060187,
0.7329429388,
0.6306203008,
-0.4539419413,
-0.6592428684,
0.1618800014,
-0.7832252979,
-0.3431707025,
0.1308353096,
-1.0007683039,
0.8338259459,
-0.315654397,
-0.2831918001,
0.0564280376,
0.4863786101,
0.2194337249,
0.4999219775,
0.3883595169,
0.8848677278,
1.0791293383,
-0.2603659034,
0.8305016756,
-0.4484427869,
0.4329915345,
0.7298762798,
-0.838337779,
1.2822802067,
0.1092297137,
-0.1997066438,
0.2671171129,
0.8337007761,
-0.2001246065,
0.1722840965,
0.2941643298,
-0.0717676207,
-0.3556003571,
-0.3492398858,
-0.3312870264,
0.4871628582,
0.5524756312,
-0.3063338101,
0.2492967099,
0.0529854223,
0.0695822984,
-0.2315251082,
-0.1961024255,
0.4788239896,
0.2289325744,
-0.3963043094,
0.4249959588,
-0.1550412476,
0.6016043425,
-0.2802101672,
0.2888640761,
-0.231668219,
0.4045048952,
-0.1935583055,
-0.6993235946,
-0.0688673332,
0.5857360959,
0.2479031831,
0.0176829528,
0.3170248568,
-0.1175536141,
-0.4002939761,
0.6952902675,
0.6583515406,
0.3268333077,
0.0828137547,
-0.7772929072,
0.2527660429,
-0.0241068695,
-0.7039301395,
0.0644036159,
0.9406633973,
0.626034379,
0.9038150907,
0.3520662189,
-0.2086286247,
-0.0044326219,
0.0768009797,
0.6704500914,
-0.938113153,
-0.3718238175,
-0.9624279141,
0.2853277326,
-0.150748536,
-0.584970355,
0.674843967,
0.4401860237,
0.5244690776,
0.1767225564,
0.6980746388,
-0.1806850731,
0.4442823827,
-0.0956799835,
0.7136177421,
-0.9171176553,
-0.1819755584,
-0.4160978496,
-0.8645322323,
-0.1217008755,
0.8585352302,
-0.4796382785,
0.1545528769,
0.8032873869,
0.7728039026,
0.2810735703,
0.2988012433,
0.5368059874,
0.4686495066,
0.1606536806,
1.0241833925,
1.2584873438,
-0.1848869622,
0.5185838342,
-0.3263170123,
-0.4305416048,
-0.6648987532,
-0.9206670523,
-1.0016777515,
-0.2233367562,
-0.2222500145,
-0.0725363716,
0.197939828,
1.2831809521,
0.4809996188,
-0.5564576387,
-0.3224567175,
0.3277897537,
-0.1906125993,
-0.2069943249,
-0.0961183459,
0.323702991,
-0.0343080349,
-0.8209284544,
-0.0253869295,
0.5069854259,
-0.2347701341,
-0.0866405293,
-0.2799540758,
0.0916276127,
0.3137768209,
0.4625329375,
0.3698331714,
-0.7248966694,
-0.1341127008,
0.2714809179,
-0.2597185969,
-0.1933457851,
0.6026400328,
-0.1451397836,
0.4652373195,
0.4070861936,
0.8473178744,
0.1647528708,
-0.1209630296,
0.6935096383,
-0.1850178689,
0.1624290794,
0.4100919664,
0.6537113786,
0.293404758,
0.00135298,
0.7039533257,
-0.2100662291,
-0.6968155503,
-0.9846947789,
-0.0112073561,
-0.6455697417,
0.0032764177,
0.8970714808,
-0.5430057049,
-0.5023429394,
0.1280327886,
-0.1651046127,
0.3108406961,
-0.5679228902,
0.7002709508,
0.8034552336,
-0.1462624669,
-0.4807121158,
-0.5355061293,
-0.0285961106,
0.8698400855,
-0.8752171993,
0.3561139405,
0.4071062207,
-0.2634697556,
-0.1371913701,
0.2842650414,
0.2719924152,
0.325938046,
0.144558847,
0.4334508777,
0.1590123624,
-0.1156493351,
-0.3929153383,
0.2130017877,
0.149897173,
0.2723672688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12065v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12065v2
|
WKVQuant: Quantizing Weight and Key/Value Cache for Large Language Models Gains More
| 2024-02-19T11:33:21 | 2024-02-20T08:48:24 |
Yuxuan Yue, Zhihang Yuan, Haojie Duanmu, Sifan Zhou, Jianlong Wu, Liqiang Nie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) face significant deployment challenges due to
their substantial memory requirements and the computational demands of
auto-regressive text generation process. This paper addresses these challenges
by focusing on the quantization of LLMs, a technique that reduces memory
consumption by converting model parameters and activations into low-bit
integers. We critically analyze the existing quantization approaches,
identifying their limitations in balancing the accuracy and efficiency of the
quantized LLMs. To advance beyond these limitations, we propose WKVQuant, a PTQ
framework especially designed for quantizing weights and the key/value (KV)
cache of LLMs. Specifically, we incorporates past-only quantization to improve
the computation of attention. Additionally, we introduce two-dimensional
quantization strategy to handle the distribution of KV cache, along with a
cross-block reconstruction regularization for parameter optimization.
Experiments show that WKVQuant achieves almost comparable memory savings to
weight-activation quantization, while also approaching the performance of
weight-only quantization.
|
[
-0.0621546656,
-0.4301628172,
0.4951434135,
0.1977563053,
-0.4756007791,
0.0197192077,
-0.1570504755,
-0.0331162512,
-0.2288677841,
0.4247185886,
-0.2311366647,
-0.4009543061,
-0.5139220953,
-0.3073192537,
-0.249704659,
0.6436824203,
-0.0113362717,
0.0303419549,
-0.5067836046,
-0.1546857506,
-0.350527972,
-0.5805930495,
-0.7006210089,
-0.2264752686,
0.4325800836,
0.1951563954,
0.7010926604,
0.5734296441,
0.3260132074,
0.22485964,
-0.0463573188,
-0.2953166664,
-0.5570768714,
0.4281909466,
0.246434316,
-0.6220654845,
-0.4023246467,
-0.280277133,
0.7963190079,
0.616428256,
-0.241930604,
0.2739233971,
-0.2195564657,
0.9885687232,
-1.2105247974,
0.1924638003,
-0.4698307514,
0.1272593141,
-0.1345583498,
-0.0308702085,
-0.2550863624,
-0.3694134355,
0.2058823109,
-0.5805401802,
-0.0977383628,
-0.1091735139,
0.5284937024,
0.4933486879,
-0.6026223302,
0.1008905545,
-0.7403995991,
1.0451170206,
-0.9739338756,
0.6529362202,
0.5061625838,
0.0025250367,
0.0235083364,
-0.7410343885,
-0.4144521654,
-0.1950880438,
0.4418796599,
0.1078434661,
-0.1613434106,
0.1138562784,
0.260554105,
0.4221755564,
-0.6298661232,
-0.0979736894,
-0.1772283465,
-0.2883541286,
0.374548465,
0.1426185071,
-0.1763151437,
-0.0058839018,
-0.0795177668,
-0.3949350417,
-0.8379007578,
0.1690207571,
0.3206122816,
-0.0498079099,
0.2136440873,
0.6438859105,
-0.5509938598,
0.5848591328,
0.0537007228,
-0.3347071707,
-0.0109272609,
-0.2121700197,
-0.3556385338,
0.0526803806,
0.8547303081,
0.206318453,
0.1906009316,
-0.1007216349,
-0.1800219864,
-0.1593708992,
0.1715406626,
-1.2024905682,
-0.4579463005,
0.2545526326,
-0.5700071454,
-0.2928527594,
-0.3839181066,
-0.3599579632,
-0.1548487544,
-0.1463104039,
0.5520900488,
-0.4628442526,
-0.276840657,
0.1744346917,
-0.0370715037,
0.1533473134,
0.2759390473,
-0.7404695749,
0.087298356,
0.5439789295,
0.6276618242,
0.0452104844,
0.1726735979,
-0.5356353521,
0.2201351821,
-0.3517261446,
0.3921530843,
-0.3756876588,
-0.2774651349,
-0.0009404268,
-0.2884386182,
0.4335759878,
-0.2900355756,
0.3147057891,
-0.8680164814,
-0.0794705302,
-0.4423531294,
-0.4922270477,
0.0545603111,
0.2019935995,
-0.8023751974,
1.2267619371,
0.1896939278,
-0.7420699,
0.2099801749,
-0.0511883311,
-0.4945314527,
0.1846438497,
0.2147267461,
-0.5845897198,
0.5317952633,
0.008433219,
0.1997447759,
-0.5027430058,
0.1306594014,
-0.2857136428,
-0.3112783432,
0.2390749305,
-0.584934175,
0.5455822349,
0.2886412144,
-0.1365662217,
-0.1044294462,
-0.7861235142,
0.3509066999,
0.1617239714,
-0.4201295972,
-0.7670357227,
0.3135724366,
-0.134188056,
0.1565078646,
0.5199074149,
-0.3045653105,
0.341679126,
-0.4733676314,
0.593881309,
0.4828242958,
-0.0640753061,
0.5286625028,
0.0116861975,
0.5759174228,
-0.0066713546,
0.2180315405,
-0.0954971611,
-0.3599546552,
-0.8923385739,
-0.197613582,
0.4663213789,
0.3630439639,
-0.8094700575,
0.2731359899,
-0.4491603374,
-0.308113575,
-0.5367566347,
-0.070777528,
0.506801486,
0.163537994,
0.0783223361,
-0.2148424834,
-0.4009174407,
-0.8430526257,
-0.0724492893,
-0.4182240367,
-0.2047408074,
0.1327191591,
0.2104651183,
0.0651799142,
1.0115852356,
-0.5102635622,
0.0733811334,
0.1753406376,
0.3710454106,
-0.2126585543,
0.4309056699,
0.0473612174,
-0.8490371108,
-0.6285800338,
-0.068899408,
-0.1566952765,
-0.3352327049,
0.1593997478,
0.0052816044,
0.3655081987,
0.5640384555,
-0.6970881224,
0.3011296391,
0.709323287,
0.0150255933,
0.4442128539,
-0.1462996155,
0.1397257596,
-1.0562858582,
0.2314062417,
-0.2932089269,
-0.4257346392,
-0.314550072,
-0.0906895399,
0.4042395055,
-0.0962767825,
-0.4486830831,
0.540474534,
-0.3586314917,
-0.1294414252,
-0.3533238769,
0.0852400139,
0.2387432158,
0.4604051113,
-0.0935154632,
0.7220910192,
0.2656746209,
-0.5028867722,
0.5214995742,
-0.0721387491,
-0.1367316246,
0.6934606433,
-0.5772260427,
0.0854808912,
-0.1465667784,
0.1951691806,
-1.0786966085,
0.2086748928,
-0.0582565255,
-0.3769026995,
0.284068048,
-0.4315618277,
-0.8563601971,
-0.3050613999,
-0.5540087819,
0.8578425646,
0.6802700162,
-0.1438958347,
0.3423213661,
0.3205091953,
-0.1001514494,
-0.4737218916,
-0.5386092663,
-0.0124336407,
-0.141565457,
-0.4883591533,
0.3652609289,
-0.1066897959,
-0.1343320608,
0.0877238214,
-0.3125816584,
-0.0967861935,
-0.056818895,
0.0309360903,
-0.0430992357,
-0.3072836697,
0.4740131497,
0.1599609256,
-0.2319760621,
0.0351789147,
-0.8680184484,
0.5846410394,
-0.0582049824,
-0.2200053781,
-0.1891867816,
0.3769238889,
0.631110549,
-0.5134093165,
0.6931362152,
0.6454759836,
-0.3606215715,
-0.0831990466,
-0.6409685016,
0.0279879477,
-0.4761767685,
0.6638337374,
-0.3647381663,
-1.1243811846,
0.4185840189,
-0.1786744297,
-0.0931928456,
0.406047523,
0.9263526201,
-0.0462617241,
1.2840508223,
0.5449820161,
-0.140832752,
0.4930846393,
-0.1076713502,
0.310896486,
-0.8985530138,
-0.0343766361,
-0.3991923332,
-0.2688476145,
-0.4721535146,
-0.5265960693,
0.4327504635,
0.3883897364,
-0.2421928495,
0.090783529,
-0.3929948807,
0.3784117401,
0.4934780598,
-0.1682149172,
0.3573536873,
-0.0356595814,
-0.0404630676,
-0.309438616,
-0.6100700498,
-0.0889637321,
1.1605086327,
0.2176788747,
0.99018538,
0.1055700406,
0.3779141605,
0.1234230325,
0.2387408465,
-1.1010619402,
0.4117236435,
-0.1754536033,
-0.2609086037,
-0.5401048064,
-0.7311208844,
-0.8596624732,
0.4103945494,
0.061584264,
-0.5627154112,
-0.0480949581,
0.2048063576,
-0.434838891,
0.1034658998,
-0.6351787448,
0.8821489811,
-0.1351937056,
-0.3121685386,
-0.2825089991,
-0.4983943701,
0.4805196524,
-0.1930738539,
-0.0718811154,
-0.0472080261,
-0.3853088915,
0.6778201461,
-0.5483961105,
0.7191258073,
-0.0987943262,
-0.5344765782,
0.2414387167,
0.1342928857,
0.9378291368,
0.0965428278,
0.2377330512,
-0.180329904,
0.3005144894,
-0.4368511736,
-0.5615376234,
0.7903535962,
-0.6710710526,
-0.3654933274,
-0.2201229036,
-0.810613215,
-0.3876322806,
0.204980731,
0.1408232003,
0.2509913445,
-0.038212236,
0.3887550533,
1.1520266533,
-0.3018369675,
0.4142595232,
0.590592742,
0.0970617011,
-0.596773684,
0.9152770638,
0.1768313944,
0.5573847294,
0.7862744331,
0.3500240445,
-0.2783532739,
-0.5179448724,
0.0072466154,
0.1822208762,
-0.7078765035,
-0.5443396568,
-0.7342150807,
-0.1587063968,
-0.4764049351,
0.2267221957,
-0.822013855,
-0.8327922821,
-0.1315336823,
0.3146903217,
0.5008879304,
0.0944172442,
0.0987427309,
0.557328105,
-0.8742101789,
0.287602216,
0.5560972095,
0.2544820309,
0.2109941244,
-0.3825190067,
-0.7145547867,
0.0360072963,
-0.4061408043,
-0.5407648683,
0.504272759,
0.164500609,
0.0498949029,
0.3056373298,
0.3322700262,
0.7234758735,
-0.530714035,
0.6465066671,
-0.0056899856,
-1.09436059,
0.2584756911,
-0.0677303597,
0.6879099607,
0.4524852931,
0.2347383648,
-0.824049592,
-0.4142016768,
-0.5226493478,
-1.1409493685,
0.510933578,
0.1910028756,
0.122122772,
0.1824536473,
0.5350067616,
-0.3977197409,
0.4553302228,
-0.7427464128,
-0.1302881539,
-0.1333601922,
-0.3816321194,
0.320874989,
-0.4577602446,
0.1679395735,
-0.0159282852,
0.603828311,
-0.1852824092,
0.1645749062,
-0.0145063642,
-0.3172938228,
-0.4083077312,
0.1953285486,
0.6265134215,
0.4558537602,
-0.1454095542,
0.2083052695,
0.1624168009,
-0.628295362,
0.166021809,
-0.1104392856,
-0.170997262,
-0.2572756708,
0.1688778996,
0.6680269837,
0.3544346094,
-0.7643226981,
0.6939483285,
-0.1165571585,
-0.0753266737,
-0.2005486637,
-0.1598651111,
0.2425184548,
0.3824987411,
0.4888567328,
-0.4945883155,
0.067007944,
-0.126432851,
0.1469656378,
0.7711535692,
-0.2523466945,
-0.3672480583,
0.6475805044,
0.0240954999,
-0.0348652862,
0.6163964868,
-0.1737714112,
-0.5246173143,
0.5481514931,
0.3782453835,
0.9771629572,
-0.3412770331,
-0.024734877,
0.3022617996,
0.3131912649,
-0.1445619315,
0.3100493848,
-0.2758116722,
-0.4672291279,
-0.901686728,
-0.7086256146,
-0.2347367257,
0.3429850638,
-0.6260714531,
0.0314526707,
-0.2542971969,
-0.3481031656,
-0.4431730211,
0.1968379468,
-0.3834142089,
0.1189068705,
0.1717618704,
0.5175839067,
-0.5878543258,
1.2243654728,
0.2592664361,
-0.0198687613,
-0.4734738171,
-0.0026228749,
-0.2873170376,
-0.696139276,
0.7898319364,
-0.2769767046,
0.2041751593,
0.4159447849,
-0.478105247,
-1.1519175768,
1.1113981009,
0.2945310473,
-0.7463046908,
-0.0804854482,
0.3033622205,
0.396572262,
0.1528431475,
-0.0228472501,
0.4285109043,
0.450942874,
0.2867453992,
-0.8022404313,
0.1178438514,
0.0315169916,
0.4537488222,
0.6603018045,
-0.7240941525,
0.8801457286,
0.0432811417,
-0.2024247944,
0.2121165693,
0.6635171175,
0.325358808,
-0.271592021,
0.3371076286,
0.8873658776,
0.4686004817,
0.0590482242,
0.9625136256,
-0.3306259811,
0.536241591,
0.7535768151,
-0.3082828224,
0.9093641043,
0.7106305361,
-0.4755666256,
-0.0846503377,
0.5260565877,
0.1556950212,
0.7258691788,
0.5249063969,
-0.3636658788,
-0.2506871521,
0.0287238229,
-0.2320825309,
0.00084757,
0.2498146445,
0.043226067,
-0.1118004546,
0.1254809946,
0.009842189,
-0.5768553019,
-0.2365272194,
0.6744161844,
0.2209912241,
-0.5050630569,
0.7873550653,
0.2173089683,
0.4606826007,
-0.7425784469,
0.0644214228,
-0.1906075925,
0.28892681,
0.1276792735,
-0.2895661592,
0.0214070939,
-0.2943889797,
-0.4146895409,
-0.3265615702,
0.4104034901,
-0.6927129626,
-0.6056851745,
-0.1283847541,
0.297745645,
-0.2232566327,
-0.4398228526,
-0.4299326539,
0.2514493167,
-0.1635178328,
-0.5212078094,
0.5558419824,
0.9335472584,
-0.3272933364,
0.759370029,
0.6277801991,
0.232996583,
0.2536028028,
-0.0000173284,
0.7527182698,
-0.604578197,
-0.4008607268,
-0.8423906565,
0.418064028,
0.4125928879,
-0.1573537588,
0.5994907618,
0.6205260754,
0.5838782191,
0.0355545916,
0.6629217863,
0.0806162506,
0.027582448,
-0.6738845706,
0.7566382289,
-0.6550258398,
0.1715879291,
-0.1240960062,
-0.9684280753,
-0.2646353245,
0.5952638984,
0.0002240514,
-0.0521952212,
0.7650293112,
0.5589853525,
0.1702937484,
-0.5467552543,
0.4892096817,
0.245785892,
0.435770005,
0.8511767983,
0.8130239844,
-0.6580659747,
0.8282856941,
-0.2331249267,
-0.1587861925,
-0.2496399581,
-1.0154634714,
-0.7208236456,
-0.7012816072,
-0.4898374975,
-0.2392341346,
-0.0195188243,
0.5224648118,
0.8585152626,
-0.5533784628,
-0.2641236484,
-0.1702846587,
0.0103680016,
0.0153607689,
-0.2595581114,
0.5600405335,
-0.4400803447,
-0.6854342222,
0.0636449084,
0.382915467,
0.1395198703,
-0.6283040047,
-0.1971844733,
0.2146047056,
0.1799058169,
0.8381986022,
0.1830626726,
-0.6311935186,
-0.0330088586,
0.069502525,
-0.3604955673,
-0.0157538205,
1.0528331995,
-0.9412528872,
0.4052699804,
0.7251310349,
0.7140960097,
0.8543867469,
-0.1720375866,
0.703930378,
-0.8519989848,
0.4097871482,
0.4581896961,
0.0349838659,
0.2232830375,
-0.2617234886,
0.0520467982,
0.2583274543,
-0.4949172437,
-0.8723962903,
0.2055049241,
-0.8492652178,
-0.2523477376,
1.0510103703,
0.1015046537,
-0.3743362725,
0.0550155006,
-0.0254154466,
0.173025772,
-0.4038600028,
0.7131883502,
0.8602666259,
0.3159936965,
-0.5901203156,
-0.7169611454,
0.6554333568,
0.5041027665,
-0.5907208323,
0.2646032274,
0.4241303504,
0.075858444,
-0.093636021,
0.5683914423,
-0.1860724837,
0.1763260514,
-0.2230824679,
0.3284294009,
0.0989733711,
0.0363965333,
-0.2247060835,
-0.0672517493,
0.198566556,
-0.0186260454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12061v2
|
All Language Models Large and Small
| 2024-02-19T11:28:20 | 2024-06-05T15:08:28 |
Zhixun Chen, Yali Du, David Mguni
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Many leading language models (LMs) use high-intensity computational resources
both during training and execution. This poses the challenge of lowering
resource costs for deployment and faster execution of decision-making tasks
among others. We introduce a novel plug-and-play LM framework named Language
Optimising Network Distribution (LONDI) framework. LONDI learns to selectively
employ large LMs only where complex decision-making and reasoning are required
while using low-resource LMs (i.e. LMs require less GPU usage, but may not be
able to solve the problem alone) everywhere else. LONDI consists of a system of
two (off-)policy networks, an LM, a large LM (LLM), and a reinforcement
learning module that uses switching controls to quickly learn which system
states to call the LLM. We then introduce a variant of LONDI that maintains
budget constraints on LLM calls and hence its resource usage. Theoretically, we
prove LONDI learns the subset of system states to activate the LLM required to
solve the task. We then prove that LONDI converges to optimal solutions while
also preserving budgetary constraints on LLM calls almost surely enabling it to
solve various tasks while significantly lowering computational costs. We test
LONDI's performance in a range of tasks in ScienceWorld and BabyAI-Text and
demonstrate that LONDI can solve tasks only solvable by resource-intensive LLMs
while reducing GPU usage by up to 30%.
|
[
-0.4237807989,
-0.6864509583,
0.4131506979,
0.4317848384,
0.0271441173,
-0.0327385925,
-0.3941715956,
-0.1288419515,
0.1991997063,
0.835765183,
-0.5709504485,
-0.1659133285,
-0.1912618876,
-0.0748955831,
-0.2474663407,
0.82229352,
0.02099628,
-0.2695238292,
-0.0947833434,
-0.1689927131,
-0.0952436998,
-0.0868279859,
-1.1495870352,
-0.6359853745,
0.6620865464,
0.2234635949,
0.7592537999,
0.7554931641,
0.4526741207,
0.2948789299,
-0.4234722257,
0.4701474309,
-0.7037187219,
-0.2207800448,
-0.357970655,
-0.5822761655,
-0.2189511061,
-0.3040755391,
0.6212769151,
0.707177043,
-0.6005250216,
0.0652123466,
-0.1180390716,
0.7128968239,
-0.9291551113,
0.2098115385,
-0.5874598622,
0.1955799758,
-0.0593875684,
-0.0367400572,
-0.6588118672,
-0.0722249225,
-0.0545999631,
-0.6733887196,
-0.1508636922,
0.0912413895,
0.7424684167,
0.4542901516,
-0.2424192429,
-0.1791676581,
-0.8740102649,
0.8075416088,
-0.4285800457,
0.1895396262,
0.1440218687,
0.2632995844,
-0.1213744432,
-0.4879986048,
-0.5673501492,
0.0190289617,
0.0560661629,
-0.0209048335,
-0.3208434284,
0.0724043399,
0.2653560638,
0.1181025431,
-0.3466558456,
0.4343532026,
-0.335775286,
0.0608137287,
0.3752994537,
0.1774492413,
0.096583195,
-0.1241741031,
-0.3219447434,
0.026259793,
-0.8853620887,
-0.0448998176,
0.2611481547,
0.5242630243,
-0.114986971,
0.3414786458,
0.1311026961,
0.6421732306,
-0.3127338886,
-0.4466769099,
0.1813180894,
0.0367736369,
-0.54139781,
-0.0847701654,
1.0060991049,
-0.1939960569,
0.0878474787,
0.1451799721,
-0.3054766655,
-0.0231566019,
0.0856611505,
-0.6595682502,
-0.0009872867,
-0.0525013655,
-0.2998836339,
-0.5137796998,
-0.7031832337,
-0.5545070767,
-0.5092918277,
-0.043964833,
0.2959099114,
-0.2187008858,
-0.3565655649,
0.1769419909,
0.238100037,
-0.0874083862,
0.1843569428,
-0.9881799221,
0.5141729116,
0.5445384383,
0.9928523302,
-0.3086862564,
-0.1850256026,
-0.6156378984,
0.1187837124,
-0.5075005293,
0.5679392219,
-0.2013456076,
-0.4529914558,
0.0012488475,
0.0669410601,
-0.1249227449,
-0.6819035411,
0.0942928344,
-0.6424083114,
0.0422422178,
-0.1361612231,
-0.168423593,
0.1904247254,
0.0802710727,
-0.8948785067,
0.8879424334,
0.1980578452,
-0.6237922907,
0.0986791924,
-0.9665549397,
-0.537653327,
-0.0836074352,
-0.0890924856,
-0.4376024604,
-0.187351048,
-0.126363039,
0.2589133382,
-0.5572146177,
0.0482604764,
-0.2138208598,
-0.2533469498,
0.0275026374,
-0.3550897539,
0.8780498505,
0.4670583606,
-0.4300266802,
0.126986146,
-0.5712099671,
0.0111952759,
0.3429297507,
-0.6458152533,
-0.1143907011,
0.2716943622,
0.0791138932,
0.0717357099,
0.1276566684,
-0.3411108255,
0.2806719244,
-0.4891414344,
0.7362717986,
0.7721325159,
-0.2898749113,
0.7880390882,
-0.0151788518,
0.6312387586,
-0.0525085293,
0.2873783112,
0.1561604738,
-0.3168306649,
-0.8449870348,
-0.3553812504,
0.1236325428,
0.7232221961,
-0.8981384039,
-0.004088751,
-0.060867995,
-0.2176139206,
-0.3699753582,
0.4032832682,
0.4878520966,
0.1498753875,
0.1195692047,
0.0776457116,
-0.386044085,
-0.9979298115,
0.2883703709,
-0.3141196966,
0.3368830383,
0.5484396815,
0.3810792863,
-0.240790844,
0.9350534081,
-0.7206286192,
-0.2172275931,
-0.6760507226,
-0.2560312152,
0.4492729902,
0.1082057804,
0.4569658339,
-0.7668437362,
-0.3745695055,
0.2865070999,
-0.5474942327,
-0.1856542528,
-0.1081849635,
-0.0841431841,
0.5434687734,
0.5087599754,
-0.6242580414,
0.0863176659,
0.7209224105,
-0.1017271131,
0.5114496946,
-0.4339757562,
-0.5022547841,
-0.983173728,
0.0753027424,
-0.1773430407,
-0.2377730757,
-0.3122284412,
0.2422667593,
-0.1401163936,
-0.4398045838,
-0.5420402288,
0.6228648424,
-0.316072166,
-0.1903022379,
-0.142991215,
0.3343362212,
0.1881482154,
0.5767604709,
-0.1072636545,
0.9419528842,
0.300747335,
-0.6560794711,
0.4494215548,
0.0998196602,
-0.3816142976,
0.2741820514,
-0.5551919937,
-0.3400933146,
-0.156770885,
0.1161321253,
-0.5121411085,
0.0167330299,
0.0756311566,
0.2385267168,
0.1384362578,
0.0041537271,
-0.4709928036,
-0.2792440057,
0.1829261333,
0.1784801036,
0.6881842613,
-0.7137938738,
0.5390217304,
0.4958311617,
0.2172628939,
-0.7033064365,
-0.7724124789,
-0.1623692662,
-0.1845378131,
-0.3638116419,
0.2545697689,
-0.108381331,
-0.3586017191,
0.1426298469,
0.2249233276,
-0.0855552182,
0.2230389714,
0.0966761485,
0.0790236965,
-0.2904389203,
0.3164341152,
-0.3215082586,
-0.0271018911,
0.0799508095,
-0.5606995225,
0.6402540207,
-0.2023375183,
-0.502276957,
-0.0659891516,
0.2141386569,
0.4271337986,
-0.099671796,
0.9148091674,
0.5487392545,
-0.0472846255,
-0.8247520328,
-0.2237622887,
0.1376746893,
-0.4971148372,
0.6970463991,
-0.289442271,
-0.6980174184,
0.3497081697,
-0.1754744053,
0.258371979,
0.1560537815,
0.4676047564,
-0.0194583144,
0.8287040591,
0.712138474,
-0.4241408706,
0.615324378,
-0.594595015,
0.5117465854,
-0.5435264707,
0.0281741377,
-0.219673261,
-0.2551326752,
-0.7097704411,
-0.6345782876,
0.4118943512,
0.175840646,
-0.4147099555,
0.2095724344,
-0.4552884698,
0.8785815239,
0.486959368,
0.0880785063,
0.1323876232,
0.1949525028,
-0.2408999205,
0.2910375595,
-1.1342504025,
-0.2063003927,
0.727909863,
0.2721174061,
0.7404085994,
0.4251960218,
0.715567112,
0.2156888247,
0.2968811393,
-0.779037118,
0.7227271795,
-0.4006987214,
-0.448933363,
-0.535433352,
-0.8287962675,
-0.8985900879,
0.1728580445,
-0.1633143872,
-0.6184098721,
-0.0652680546,
0.2015938014,
-0.37948066,
0.7619267106,
-0.6213065982,
0.635142386,
-0.1145528406,
-0.5906687975,
-0.325674504,
-0.0797254816,
0.3552545607,
-0.0478950031,
0.507597506,
-0.0504131056,
-0.147219345,
0.5374091864,
-0.4588134885,
0.7524932623,
-0.1218706295,
-0.2202067673,
0.3927073777,
0.1550165117,
0.5732548237,
-0.0187085979,
-0.1516076475,
-0.2524847984,
-0.3061289191,
-0.4627756774,
-0.6249024868,
0.9318181276,
-1.0697017908,
-0.4814588726,
-0.1523400545,
-0.3678463399,
-0.1051120535,
0.1472057253,
0.1574723423,
0.401435256,
-0.2950979471,
-0.0346055329,
1.0324656963,
-0.4817399681,
0.6159597635,
0.3767527342,
-0.6160879731,
-0.3494214714,
1.0744045973,
-0.0381947979,
0.6844127774,
0.4888486564,
0.3213146627,
-0.0452815145,
-0.2672076225,
-0.5021524429,
0.2971410453,
-0.920432806,
0.0472321659,
-0.4952094257,
-0.4720416069,
0.1054872125,
-0.1533940136,
-0.6108947396,
-0.2968470752,
-0.2695614696,
0.0336095132,
0.259346962,
0.7922307253,
-0.1868064553,
0.6150444746,
-0.1628968716,
0.0415342674,
0.3577166796,
0.490285337,
-0.0053778067,
-0.1244240403,
-0.4534724653,
-0.1783948094,
-0.2998981476,
-0.4520935416,
0.3711446524,
0.2912247181,
0.2744954526,
0.5858588219,
-0.1245332882,
0.467892319,
-0.5558251143,
0.650628686,
0.39575544,
-0.765804708,
0.3282897472,
-0.3936028183,
0.341638118,
0.2078543007,
0.1671844721,
-0.4327591062,
0.135751009,
-0.4763143063,
-0.8360284567,
0.862375617,
0.093226999,
-0.0535385087,
-0.1420834363,
0.0509803854,
-0.3031308651,
0.0873233676,
-0.7683660388,
-0.2284452617,
0.2296067476,
-0.0164765101,
-0.2440028489,
-0.0893677622,
-0.236519888,
0.0754645914,
0.8602086306,
-0.3130188882,
0.3188406229,
-0.2444074005,
0.0408104472,
0.0212372821,
0.2539003193,
0.5857928395,
0.5419239998,
0.0155576225,
0.0757952034,
0.2988060415,
-0.1831432134,
0.2399579287,
-0.3574715853,
-0.3504363894,
0.0680835918,
0.2511919737,
1.2226150036,
0.4427158535,
-0.8592104316,
0.4113766551,
0.0702649429,
-0.1982827485,
-0.4079154134,
0.354863584,
0.549253881,
0.367400974,
-0.0593729205,
0.1399835646,
-0.241371572,
-0.3926782906,
-0.2552439272,
0.4246635139,
-0.2288283855,
-0.0159307495,
0.3046058118,
0.2534944713,
-0.507995069,
0.5207179189,
-0.4794484079,
-0.4289701283,
0.7277027369,
0.6878623366,
0.5980372429,
0.0592916906,
0.5794063807,
0.0442733914,
0.2555822134,
-0.3395826519,
0.4061568379,
-0.0020943023,
-0.8459745646,
-0.605056107,
-0.75974226,
-0.5188822746,
0.1926362514,
-0.3965498805,
0.312977761,
-0.7728574872,
-0.2151129693,
-0.1704458147,
-0.0380316079,
-0.6496607065,
-0.0631553903,
0.1924598813,
0.8972036242,
-0.7312945724,
0.7427961826,
0.4695680439,
-0.1286327839,
-0.8528314829,
-0.4954169393,
0.0014458061,
-0.8278318644,
1.0053910017,
-0.2485740781,
-0.2540258169,
0.0320339948,
-0.3141191304,
-1.0316402912,
0.9251646996,
0.5751490593,
-0.6098994613,
-0.1636875868,
0.2168630958,
0.3523744047,
-0.3786650598,
0.2836951911,
0.4745548368,
0.2373704612,
0.0746200979,
-0.9836555719,
-0.2473942935,
-0.1185773462,
0.0930895433,
0.588430047,
-0.8088931441,
1.0337027311,
-0.3842332065,
-0.2302009165,
-0.1883482039,
0.3168855608,
0.4115442336,
0.1035229713,
0.7221893072,
0.5883854032,
0.7480533719,
0.0622824505,
0.8749039769,
-0.2107791454,
0.382932961,
0.8505871296,
-0.4518234134,
1.0113357306,
0.5565513372,
-0.413626343,
0.5616541505,
0.4937937558,
0.3013259768,
0.5874156356,
0.5472670197,
-0.3977560401,
-0.225308463,
-0.2811009586,
-0.0624059215,
0.2977468669,
0.3786418438,
-0.2711801827,
-0.1764196455,
0.207192719,
0.1480694264,
-0.0243408736,
-0.3570761085,
0.6929423213,
0.195960626,
-0.5581586957,
0.9085490108,
-0.0155731468,
0.4395447671,
-0.7473144531,
0.305801481,
-0.3120083809,
0.6307188272,
-0.188069135,
-0.4715393782,
0.2132372409,
-0.1717249751,
-0.4159563482,
-0.3636423647,
0.3379536867,
-0.2938541472,
-0.3746082783,
0.6160700917,
0.3813443184,
0.0343234427,
0.313526988,
-0.5681790113,
0.2016624063,
0.0269998815,
-0.396756053,
0.4885970056,
0.5201661587,
-0.0937716067,
1.0500003099,
0.600428462,
0.6894749403,
-0.1523817778,
0.0850785151,
0.9254258275,
-0.3500284851,
-0.8157004118,
-0.7618446946,
-0.0435858332,
-0.2372596115,
-0.2026874125,
0.234170869,
0.2995784581,
0.6687697768,
0.076404646,
0.9118648171,
0.0054643452,
0.1003010049,
-0.65948838,
0.6427342892,
-0.6297892928,
0.506454289,
-0.0268718004,
-0.9094517231,
-0.0001530117,
0.5980804563,
-0.3046515584,
-0.2516981959,
0.8195791841,
0.8604363203,
-0.276494801,
-0.0048769475,
0.405560106,
0.0819259882,
0.3066264689,
0.7252687216,
0.536883235,
-0.0816546455,
0.6065086722,
-0.2031829655,
-0.2263847739,
-0.2464026958,
-0.8221504092,
-0.8890686035,
-0.4215610623,
-0.2037380636,
-0.4145238101,
0.2943847179,
1.1499820948,
0.8803780675,
-0.6684327126,
-0.6501712799,
-0.1689737737,
0.3142891824,
-0.1927834749,
-0.2090899944,
0.2597945333,
-0.4442942142,
-0.3921371102,
0.4273424447,
0.3110331297,
-0.392796278,
-0.6854655147,
-0.3569757938,
-0.1901018173,
0.177730158,
0.657079339,
0.3537140191,
-0.5268887877,
0.0874774009,
-0.0578937531,
-0.3252683282,
-0.1075310707,
0.7745744586,
-0.6852871776,
0.0861702859,
0.3708646595,
0.8974747062,
0.5490162373,
-0.4784803092,
0.3849600852,
-0.7332200408,
0.3170059025,
0.0783070177,
0.4159092605,
0.1771270931,
-0.1385736763,
0.4587440193,
0.2323818356,
-0.5446224809,
-0.8580646515,
0.6216004491,
-0.589756012,
-0.4322627485,
1.2459084988,
-0.1000438854,
-0.5993272066,
0.1447153836,
-0.0355356559,
-0.1213902757,
-0.343591392,
0.5362542868,
0.3727500439,
0.0430795401,
-0.2928546667,
-0.5705923438,
0.5709803104,
0.4826160073,
-0.7109569311,
-0.0037349393,
0.116923511,
0.2057938129,
0.3779472411,
0.6223583221,
0.4708302915,
-0.0803672969,
-0.1188303381,
0.0951020122,
-0.1380472332,
-0.346924156,
0.001010234,
0.2252029777,
0.0401946567,
0.0677461028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12058v1
|
Scaffolding Coordinates to Promote Vision-Language Coordination in Large Multi-Modal Models
| 2024-02-19T11:23:53 | 2024-02-19T11:23:53 |
Xuanyu Lei, Zonghan Yang, Xinrui Chen, Peng Li, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art Large Multi-Modal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated
exceptional capabilities in vision-language tasks. Despite their advanced
functionalities, the performances of LMMs are still limited in challenging
scenarios that require complex reasoning with multiple levels of visual
information. Existing prompting techniques for LMMs focus on either improving
textual reasoning or leveraging tools for image preprocessing, lacking a simple
and general visual prompting scheme to promote vision-language coordination in
LMMs. In this work, we propose Scaffold prompting that scaffolds coordinates to
promote vision-language coordination. Specifically, Scaffold overlays a dot
matrix within the image as visual information anchors and leverages
multi-dimensional coordinates as textual positional references. Extensive
experiments on a wide range of challenging vision-language tasks demonstrate
the superiority of Scaffold over GPT-4V with the textual CoT prompting. Our
code is released in https://github.com/leixy20/Scaffold.
|
[
-0.1915834397,
-0.7886068821,
0.9643085599,
0.3797752261,
-0.5079775453,
-0.2556791008,
-0.1344680339,
-0.0855231732,
0.2241354436,
0.2074785531,
-0.5182297826,
-0.6801897287,
-0.4009307623,
-0.0276230685,
-0.1999600828,
0.7205529213,
-0.221703276,
0.2783282995,
-0.5056224465,
-0.1359628588,
-0.4841840267,
-0.3526791334,
-0.2578071058,
-0.1764065623,
1.0541510582,
0.5595231056,
0.6214135289,
0.6927166581,
0.265158236,
0.3419759572,
0.214046061,
0.3101319671,
-0.0753452182,
0.6341946721,
-0.1880806983,
-0.437528044,
-0.4019254148,
-0.1718039662,
0.6667765379,
0.73192662,
-0.2806780934,
0.1734019816,
0.1138543412,
0.7456828952,
-0.7948722243,
0.3906812072,
-0.3920512199,
-0.2364936769,
-0.2697952986,
-0.5581290722,
-0.3766461015,
-0.2815183997,
0.1055888236,
-0.7200013399,
-0.0581274703,
-0.0081743309,
0.8294957876,
0.3079964519,
-0.4488307238,
-0.0319462419,
-0.2316171676,
0.582957685,
-0.1637119949,
0.5951701403,
0.58545506,
0.4085316658,
-0.0781386867,
-0.5250059962,
-0.5253039002,
-0.1603168696,
0.2190348655,
0.210072428,
0.0845288262,
0.1573709249,
0.4281012118,
-0.3215788901,
-0.4465014935,
-0.0759157017,
-0.6337711811,
-0.0747392625,
0.1233322471,
0.0372289829,
0.1275878102,
-0.0554845706,
-0.8604950309,
-0.2449731678,
-0.8190799952,
0.2736817598,
0.2067607939,
0.3346751034,
-0.2455546707,
0.7680337429,
-0.3771441877,
0.994102478,
0.2440960258,
-0.0497036092,
0.4002816379,
-0.3718473315,
-0.2721053958,
-0.1382711232,
0.3980121315,
0.943127811,
0.2774634659,
0.2635355294,
-0.0932230875,
0.3188627958,
0.2671295106,
-0.6982640624,
-0.260466367,
0.2007834613,
-0.4142134786,
0.0061138086,
-0.2482302487,
-0.6239638329,
-0.4359055459,
-0.6097676754,
0.7018297315,
-0.6325947046,
0.0741809234,
0.3711035848,
-0.1947678626,
0.3680766821,
0.7278658748,
-0.8687710762,
-0.4499572217,
0.2050773203,
0.629476428,
-0.1195746288,
-0.5472018719,
-0.6812780499,
0.688345015,
-0.3013425171,
1.0053677559,
-0.4799322486,
-0.0577550381,
0.1865483224,
0.1271160692,
-0.3241163492,
0.1013309732,
0.2919541597,
-0.3009639978,
0.3683594465,
-0.5947428346,
0.0167413242,
-0.2210224271,
0.563817203,
-0.5768606067,
0.8798293471,
-0.1391977817,
-0.6593648195,
0.4344589412,
-0.5201241374,
-0.2667357028,
0.0590547025,
-0.6267049909,
-0.2358218879,
-0.0453544781,
0.5267320871,
0.4783009887,
-0.0944858566,
0.1205691993,
-0.1915381402,
-0.2555194795,
0.0053700688,
-0.2477414608,
0.3015800416,
0.0767997205,
-0.1256403774,
0.5222173929,
-0.428206563,
-0.0128688272,
0.1065293029,
-0.2988637388,
-0.2140894383,
0.0480127111,
-0.2588739097,
0.3080395758,
0.3501850367,
-0.0731401742,
0.4935402572,
0.0698300749,
0.0543598048,
0.8117328882,
-0.1100538597,
0.7143059373,
-0.1057073027,
0.6819551587,
-0.0453303419,
0.2689675689,
-0.7906835079,
-0.6535804868,
-0.8315532804,
-0.3336841762,
-0.1263139099,
0.427144289,
-1.5535854101,
-0.1688864827,
-0.2687107325,
-0.2287353724,
-0.0358425193,
-0.0486630425,
0.5924455523,
0.4884688854,
0.4027493,
-0.2484118193,
-0.2585013509,
-0.9939808846,
0.1491596848,
-0.1715113819,
-0.0465392917,
0.0149443438,
0.2712929845,
0.1859738827,
0.7270681858,
-0.3000621498,
-0.3662809432,
-0.0631965846,
0.0585064776,
0.0342375822,
0.4017835259,
0.7592720985,
-0.7911197543,
-0.2340879291,
-0.1137321815,
-0.8359479308,
-0.3354902864,
-0.0409709103,
-0.2739070654,
0.3142386675,
0.9759975076,
-0.8686925173,
0.5782214403,
0.7457299232,
-0.3282953203,
0.852073431,
-0.2887448668,
0.4624975324,
-1.0195713043,
0.2158609927,
-0.3454627395,
0.0446177125,
-0.6166424751,
0.1560612619,
0.2144066393,
-0.026147956,
-0.5707029104,
0.1547783315,
-0.627288878,
0.0693380311,
-0.0145750381,
0.2625572979,
0.3478182852,
0.6245629787,
-0.0499412343,
0.7008932233,
0.8684871793,
-0.319124043,
0.2921754718,
0.2512080967,
-0.2129847258,
1.1630977392,
-0.7104130983,
-0.1252463311,
-0.2976834178,
0.4223074913,
-0.9912266135,
-0.4602683783,
0.3070425391,
-0.2183922827,
0.2228348106,
-0.3603365123,
-0.37777704,
-0.2706296444,
-0.4479231834,
0.7436251044,
-0.1901243776,
-0.4603072107,
0.7717323899,
0.1471518874,
-0.0977365598,
-0.5720199943,
-0.6443426013,
0.0709545538,
-0.0677394569,
-0.6836925745,
0.2247605175,
-0.2533940077,
0.1475656033,
-0.3282794058,
-0.0931217223,
0.0676137209,
-0.4382740259,
0.5232064128,
0.5112347007,
-0.1747278869,
0.251186192,
-0.0437965319,
-0.3797738254,
-0.1015240029,
-0.426483959,
0.5684039593,
-0.138252303,
-0.8276252151,
-0.4353663921,
0.5004270077,
0.7948482037,
-0.4379823804,
0.4693922698,
0.3023073971,
-0.1837714016,
0.0720077306,
-0.5847663879,
-0.245318532,
-0.5040634274,
0.1505453587,
-0.6150380373,
-0.7464235425,
0.1351311952,
-0.1326430291,
-0.3034354746,
-0.2321579605,
0.6108285785,
-0.2611435354,
1.297437191,
0.5047913194,
0.3325975537,
0.7541260123,
-0.1646808088,
0.1208948195,
-0.5686805844,
-0.3935655355,
-0.2806814313,
-0.2434529811,
0.2109251022,
-1.0659952164,
0.7281238437,
0.1678668261,
-0.1589223295,
0.3563755751,
-0.3231008649,
0.6638436317,
0.4907446504,
0.2651509643,
0.0235411972,
0.3296394348,
-0.8734093904,
0.0567663535,
-0.9496512413,
-0.2432992905,
0.4657322168,
0.2024352252,
0.6930699348,
-0.2787676752,
0.2765375674,
-0.3613229692,
-0.258762151,
-0.578202486,
0.7233522534,
0.2078711838,
-0.3111468554,
-0.1723875105,
0.1781465858,
-0.9369143844,
0.2302915305,
-0.6044741273,
-0.8245739937,
0.4871559143,
0.3515574932,
-0.3959303498,
0.1170528159,
-0.8125638962,
0.7531264424,
-0.1263448,
-0.5127670169,
-0.2875305414,
-0.743314445,
0.0604538508,
0.1474127024,
0.3419151306,
0.0305689629,
-0.1462882012,
0.0699702874,
-0.246537447,
0.9860954285,
-0.107142292,
-0.2816992402,
0.0429955125,
0.2608858049,
0.5706069469,
-0.342476666,
-0.1000549868,
0.0961609483,
-0.0236148629,
-0.2855959237,
-0.5168357491,
0.672480464,
-0.1209671274,
-0.5752508044,
-0.2707348466,
-0.6973937154,
-0.0197152253,
0.3149466217,
0.2518412769,
0.5460932255,
0.3104681075,
0.5035214424,
0.2389341295,
-0.0434036329,
0.447540313,
0.3204365671,
-0.4891242683,
-0.4493976533,
0.7636493444,
0.0611788779,
0.5789052248,
0.0394553877,
-0.0962967128,
-0.2117245644,
-0.4781361818,
-0.7902971506,
0.0634539202,
-0.9130961895,
-0.4210306108,
-0.2512318194,
0.0936142355,
-0.0543904267,
-0.563207984,
-0.2179133892,
-0.5092336535,
0.2907812595,
-0.1707283705,
0.3402481079,
0.4825029969,
-0.044566907,
0.3821833134,
-0.5303877592,
0.525688827,
0.434933722,
0.522256732,
-0.2761594951,
0.1245450675,
-0.4916668534,
0.0899284482,
-0.0693312511,
-0.8683772683,
-0.1534042358,
0.0124190282,
0.4691671729,
0.5136922598,
-0.0680056587,
0.896047473,
-0.7607084513,
0.8598613143,
0.6147541404,
-0.7422021627,
0.7692425847,
-0.7529647946,
0.5751618743,
0.4136336446,
0.1609904915,
-0.1786783189,
-0.4193395376,
-0.16179353,
-0.9771772623,
0.5852960348,
0.2498667538,
-0.2828895748,
-0.0320877321,
0.13845402,
-0.2593560219,
0.229252547,
-0.5726946592,
-0.0404617004,
-0.2103784531,
-0.0383570902,
0.3255364895,
-0.2233925164,
-0.5813097954,
-0.1513717324,
0.1195785403,
-0.6584985852,
-0.0372606069,
0.2583224773,
-0.1613757759,
-0.336015135,
-0.1494534165,
0.6517055631,
0.8430762887,
0.2717408538,
0.3442492187,
0.2941740751,
-0.2695553005,
-0.1041323915,
0.0573665835,
-0.3954921663,
-0.2399095744,
0.2047934979,
0.7829341292,
0.5226143003,
-0.2505507767,
0.8210737109,
-0.0081716469,
-0.3284569383,
0.1234018505,
-0.0286189429,
0.1090918928,
0.5987460613,
0.396171689,
0.1530560106,
-0.3376779854,
-0.1904319227,
0.2077299803,
0.4453586638,
-0.2753662169,
-0.2836145759,
0.772939384,
0.1414262056,
-0.0927266479,
0.018931143,
0.3058803678,
-0.617184639,
0.2541517019,
0.4538816214,
0.4535256624,
-0.5295957923,
0.3181723952,
0.3750997186,
0.151292488,
-0.1310067028,
0.589012146,
-0.4051700532,
-0.4389443696,
-0.5217846632,
-0.453255713,
-0.2799305618,
-0.4974038899,
-0.2693350017,
0.6681939363,
-0.3885046542,
-0.0686968565,
-0.2446621954,
-0.672544241,
-0.5292270184,
0.2322553694,
0.4319739044,
0.8656518459,
-0.5620779991,
1.0506281853,
0.7822496295,
-0.6345987916,
-0.8515717387,
-0.0851510018,
0.2981559336,
-0.9000352621,
0.4949346483,
0.3931599855,
-0.6635933518,
-0.0801124498,
-0.7554301023,
-0.8076533675,
1.317908287,
0.5511626005,
-0.1914882064,
-0.1205774322,
0.1701517254,
0.2288070768,
-0.3484309912,
0.0104806907,
0.0177041609,
0.6643010378,
0.3244690895,
-0.9091264606,
0.1839503646,
-0.3558054268,
-0.0993981063,
0.0257776361,
-0.3573634624,
0.7249450684,
-0.4180101156,
-0.3542870581,
0.2323732823,
0.3375466466,
0.6727454662,
0.2602170408,
1.0191390514,
0.3140928447,
0.4207223654,
-0.148652494,
0.671628356,
-0.5693526268,
-0.1198474392,
0.9599325657,
-0.1242730245,
0.9359502792,
0.9009460807,
0.2944017947,
0.7962742448,
0.2618134618,
0.2344544679,
0.3397563994,
-0.2621318698,
-0.1646780074,
-0.5381997824,
-0.3990295827,
-0.5515725017,
0.5259767175,
0.5940231681,
-0.128141433,
-0.5147798061,
0.0531169139,
-0.1664136052,
0.0697325766,
-0.0626047254,
0.3764531314,
0.1302349418,
-0.8412351012,
0.5687946677,
-0.5541447997,
0.0655267462,
-0.8528336883,
-0.2499587089,
0.1421698481,
0.0999614596,
-0.0948673487,
-0.9613550305,
-0.001700257,
-0.3956778944,
-0.2631830275,
-0.681009233,
0.643735528,
-0.9400974512,
-0.1150818318,
0.4744960964,
0.5145393014,
-0.0884333923,
-0.0954144076,
-0.5254353881,
0.3120279908,
-0.1883188188,
-0.2753402591,
0.1849729866,
0.6471092701,
-0.5094504952,
0.7855960727,
1.2188438177,
-0.1720347106,
-0.1607123911,
0.5069269538,
1.1428027153,
-0.5206210017,
-0.6765636206,
-0.6007141471,
0.8036268353,
-0.0314589366,
-0.1659716666,
0.738897264,
0.2592193186,
0.3994983733,
-0.1982023865,
0.1918732822,
0.0544460528,
-0.0045989039,
-0.7884129286,
0.6236023903,
-0.6485288143,
0.1381336898,
-0.3605717719,
-1.0370738506,
-0.8360109329,
0.6744809151,
-0.1831272244,
-0.2063391805,
0.8100833297,
1.0970675945,
-0.0774744302,
-0.2805395722,
0.4196586609,
0.1146568954,
0.1898434311,
0.4384434819,
0.9239172935,
0.0187790859,
0.6864085793,
-0.002094459,
-0.3176026344,
-0.3535520732,
-1.3011912107,
-0.883213222,
-0.8320965171,
0.0379559062,
-0.3433184028,
0.1813926697,
0.8402460814,
0.802131772,
-0.5045902133,
-0.1059162915,
0.0441824012,
0.0303804241,
-0.1078894511,
-0.0620557629,
0.4383018911,
-0.3471687734,
-0.5393558741,
0.6429806352,
0.7446576953,
0.1422858089,
-0.2611920536,
-0.1104907021,
-0.518675983,
-0.0457219668,
0.7455375791,
0.1582691967,
-0.6796510816,
-0.6070964336,
0.1051867306,
-0.2856746614,
-0.081687361,
0.8478322625,
-0.932059586,
0.8453592658,
0.8034276962,
-0.0597873442,
0.4435541332,
0.1443683505,
0.9832502604,
-0.844958365,
0.5247970223,
-0.2643377185,
0.7104482651,
0.3121640682,
-0.0281071831,
0.3890704811,
0.0123610804,
-0.5259172916,
-0.5175188184,
0.5519552827,
-1.1197160482,
-0.1195616946,
1.0704969168,
-0.0105128773,
-0.3934269547,
-0.164777562,
-0.8839722276,
0.0674035102,
-0.1853394806,
0.534596622,
0.4875038564,
0.0603490137,
-0.3400706947,
-0.4740683436,
0.5917721391,
0.6025982499,
-0.4459511936,
0.0647319555,
0.7688527703,
-0.1851886213,
0.2871434391,
0.5912938714,
-0.0588116981,
0.7085624933,
-0.211586237,
0.1570243239,
-0.1988097727,
-0.739784658,
-0.2463912964,
0.0876879767,
-0.3560238183,
-0.4661107063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12055v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12055v2
|
Are LLM-based Evaluators Confusing NLG Quality Criteria?
| 2024-02-19T11:19:02 | 2024-06-28T14:53:35 |
Xinyu Hu, Mingqi Gao, Sen Hu, Yang Zhang, Yicheng Chen, Teng Xu, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Some prior work has shown that LLMs perform well in NLG evaluation for
different tasks. However, we discover that LLMs seem to confuse different
evaluation criteria, which reduces their reliability. For further verification,
we first consider avoiding issues of inconsistent conceptualization and vague
expression in existing NLG quality criteria themselves. So we summarize a clear
hierarchical classification system for 11 common aspects with corresponding
different criteria from previous studies involved. Inspired by behavioral
testing, we elaborately design 18 types of aspect-targeted perturbation attacks
for fine-grained analysis of the evaluation behaviors of different LLMs. We
also conduct human annotations beyond the guidance of the classification system
to validate the impact of the perturbations. Our experimental results reveal
confusion issues inherent in LLMs, as well as other noteworthy phenomena, and
necessitate further research and improvements for LLM-based evaluation.
|
[
-0.3729271293,
-1.0972551107,
0.6074115038,
0.5044765472,
-0.2800917625,
0.1649931073,
0.0079867719,
-0.7885498405,
-0.0181143153,
0.4793526828,
-0.473300904,
-0.5330279469,
-0.9354960918,
0.3135091662,
-0.5238719583,
1.2914208174,
-0.15370287,
0.170004636,
-0.3953224123,
-0.268802762,
-0.3870453238,
-0.6743311286,
-0.8214601874,
-0.8162746429,
0.7060677409,
0.0296594184,
0.8725534081,
0.2317491174,
0.9049401283,
0.2372659445,
-0.5751585364,
0.2440525144,
-0.2961681783,
-0.1916556209,
-0.1425442398,
-0.5041573048,
-0.9694518447,
0.22075665,
0.2104626447,
0.8639922738,
-0.1734267026,
0.3656084538,
0.5036590695,
0.6537705064,
-0.5583578944,
-0.1377502531,
-0.4918724,
0.4686695039,
-0.0678957701,
-0.4350804687,
-0.3064062297,
-0.129312247,
-0.0102495672,
-0.2699703276,
0.2199285775,
0.172523886,
0.8847572207,
0.5152443051,
-0.2149873078,
-0.2683897913,
-0.7602960467,
0.7374860644,
-0.7646326423,
0.3295089006,
0.5318701267,
0.1811972708,
-0.3901083767,
-0.3947701156,
-0.2419798523,
-0.3183193505,
-0.2828629315,
0.1207327023,
-0.2505543828,
0.5858336687,
0.4256603718,
0.5481897593,
-0.4744555354,
0.5120629668,
-0.1126112118,
-0.3559812307,
0.6743787527,
0.3569520712,
-0.0494182445,
-0.6114174128,
-0.5766816735,
0.1771065295,
-0.8996192813,
0.331496954,
0.6322759986,
0.0787231922,
-0.04683768,
0.6274990439,
-0.2309948802,
0.7409881949,
0.528288126,
-0.266651988,
0.1006602645,
-0.3766212761,
-0.4427491724,
-0.0746406317,
0.817964077,
0.533079505,
-0.3011437356,
-0.3139769435,
-0.5682743788,
-0.2832577825,
0.6319406033,
-0.360630542,
-0.0303539466,
0.4837843478,
-0.5849574804,
-0.4946522415,
0.025804529,
-0.5139945745,
-0.5139729977,
-0.3839802742,
0.6598157883,
-0.2474557161,
0.1229583696,
0.2570829391,
0.061840564,
0.1686235666,
0.5042700171,
-0.6630802155,
0.3463928699,
0.9513998032,
0.4257870018,
-0.5021072626,
-0.3848319352,
-0.4462263882,
-0.3190926909,
-0.2632652819,
0.7982702851,
-0.5249487162,
-0.3970964551,
-0.2313754857,
-0.2995520532,
0.2041084468,
-0.7357721329,
0.599258244,
-0.5464811921,
0.3787970543,
-0.428449899,
-0.4540953636,
-0.3417862654,
0.598628819,
-0.4247782528,
0.9977315664,
0.2222272158,
-0.7413125634,
0.6835141778,
-0.4650790691,
-0.2036991268,
0.0899000466,
-0.193335861,
-0.2844229937,
0.3683102727,
0.0200463906,
0.4651841223,
-0.2016569972,
0.2066054046,
-0.0796493068,
-0.6542285085,
0.4103219807,
-0.5930259824,
0.5058184266,
0.1339665055,
-0.2445892692,
0.3661346734,
-0.9885565639,
0.1647356302,
-0.3154808283,
-0.6006951928,
-0.1675598323,
0.1816545427,
-0.1343427896,
-0.0245003551,
0.4175261557,
-0.3286015093,
0.2244132161,
-0.1891484261,
0.1717169136,
0.6562891603,
0.1744252592,
0.3261210322,
-0.5566063523,
0.6368440986,
-0.0948493034,
0.5539742112,
0.3504027128,
-0.4208081961,
-0.9640286565,
0.0537285171,
0.2832544148,
0.5269258618,
-0.6076072454,
0.9678569436,
0.244945839,
-0.4522890747,
-0.3309827447,
0.1351832896,
0.5515607595,
0.1979151666,
0.4731601179,
-0.3959759176,
-0.4112206697,
-0.6420709491,
-0.3404545784,
-0.5223312974,
-0.0649041682,
0.0896230489,
0.3509225845,
-0.2104725242,
0.8248884082,
0.0308057237,
-0.2852565646,
-0.2863118351,
0.1743171513,
0.2481281608,
0.2662622631,
0.6028152108,
-0.3949604332,
-0.0407391302,
-0.0565457493,
-0.5853739977,
-0.4289443791,
-0.2781211734,
0.0735284239,
-0.0041711596,
0.6047475338,
-0.229877159,
0.4444203377,
0.7301809788,
-0.2420604676,
0.8199329376,
-0.0022181501,
0.3305653036,
-0.3731503785,
-0.3438919783,
0.0820063651,
-0.1684114188,
-0.5554745793,
0.277659744,
-0.2282436043,
0.49532184,
-0.6448523998,
0.365498662,
-0.0613100901,
-0.0223726444,
-0.3446471691,
-0.1237124577,
0.2302747369,
0.5065923929,
-0.5942543149,
0.3919534683,
0.4618375599,
-0.7666781545,
0.3502652943,
-0.1687245071,
-0.1072921753,
0.8411340117,
-0.6936826706,
0.339078933,
-0.0538227782,
0.2000141293,
-0.8347436786,
-0.1156893894,
0.6279409528,
-0.3426192701,
0.3744607568,
-0.2342926562,
-0.6232579947,
-0.00190736,
-0.4310126603,
0.3762111366,
0.3429282308,
-0.5570566058,
0.5788564086,
-0.185772121,
0.3956929147,
-0.5688880086,
-0.714825213,
-0.037321303,
-0.6004926562,
-0.5160086155,
0.3279936612,
0.0792348832,
-0.3255797625,
0.051051233,
-0.6055608392,
0.113056086,
0.3809967339,
0.3540529013,
0.1070623025,
-0.0239854753,
-0.2493305355,
-0.0928753167,
0.0755138621,
0.3016959429,
0.0779927075,
0.3708934188,
-0.1415305734,
-0.8963703513,
-0.4241946638,
-0.0592587255,
0.1780848503,
0.124340035,
0.1386698335,
0.7901180387,
-0.2161668837,
-0.0076888758,
-0.6743476391,
-0.0186935868,
-0.5257632732,
0.5364135504,
-0.3503828645,
-1.010430932,
0.7385571599,
0.1684628576,
0.1903315932,
0.4996120036,
0.1427468956,
-0.5539287925,
0.8593521714,
0.4973599017,
0.3241286874,
0.2877881527,
0.0187895745,
0.2647588253,
-1.2625069618,
-0.3306010962,
-0.4887263179,
-0.6741150618,
-0.7770931721,
-0.281727612,
0.2886422276,
0.7214874625,
-0.1009690464,
0.2118934095,
-0.5584167242,
0.534021616,
-0.0821666867,
0.1661512703,
0.3823027611,
0.0092297308,
-0.1617999971,
-0.0569719486,
-0.5575007796,
-0.8459267616,
1.0426331758,
0.6152073145,
1.0531240702,
0.1899139136,
0.7893231511,
0.4762732983,
0.4280549288,
-1.0698028803,
0.6941262484,
-0.2941904366,
-0.4386256933,
-0.2629289329,
-0.492013514,
-1.0854016542,
0.4195962548,
-0.1799926758,
-0.9932952523,
0.072295703,
0.0484809689,
-0.5284881592,
0.2762334943,
-0.4923046231,
0.6059864163,
-0.6246003509,
-0.0431336313,
-0.1115412191,
-0.1656459868,
0.429722935,
-0.1572391838,
0.0904834718,
-0.4012026489,
0.0788247287,
0.7812372446,
-0.4170200825,
0.8410800099,
-0.0285798553,
-0.1935493946,
0.2071361691,
0.2201432288,
0.1779549122,
0.1200340688,
-0.0504524633,
0.6340136528,
-0.1186613292,
-0.2404492199,
-0.8964623809,
0.4194467366,
-0.7254700065,
-1.0629174709,
-0.5202146173,
-0.1465193629,
-0.4346290529,
-0.1376281977,
0.392816335,
0.1438631266,
-0.0336010903,
0.1567434371,
0.4611862302,
-0.2751716077,
0.1996858269,
0.4284973145,
-0.4947572947,
-0.1454473138,
0.7215574384,
-0.040168345,
0.4832903743,
0.1601723284,
0.1029827446,
-0.0160747766,
-1.1442962885,
-0.1210114062,
-0.0104857106,
-0.711173594,
-0.1163235232,
-0.0620294847,
-0.4767509997,
0.194684267,
0.0810071602,
-0.166289255,
-0.0779807121,
-0.4264682233,
-0.057860855,
0.1301845163,
1.0057821274,
0.1852333993,
0.4755239487,
-0.7250207067,
0.2533567846,
0.2567683756,
0.619053781,
-0.0579002164,
-0.8388893008,
-0.1040816978,
-0.2395708859,
-0.6010933518,
-0.8598176837,
-0.2907579243,
-0.0258535314,
0.8152389526,
0.5693797469,
-0.253235817,
0.6922733784,
-0.3669641912,
1.0335005522,
0.2193709165,
-0.9320707321,
0.3592024744,
-0.037929222,
0.1020845026,
0.4856592417,
0.2247993499,
-0.5590563416,
-0.6958827972,
-0.5878667831,
-0.8491472006,
0.7083220482,
0.2408843637,
-0.0145824673,
0.071105361,
0.7196164727,
0.3085056543,
-0.0412426144,
-0.6447652578,
-0.4631778598,
-0.1127220616,
0.2467397451,
0.3173873425,
-0.3788455427,
-0.2717165947,
-0.1146872789,
0.2665068805,
-0.0144200213,
0.0755048916,
0.2463367432,
-0.044779513,
-0.1395033598,
0.4549107552,
0.480172962,
0.8082944155,
-0.3418143392,
0.2036613971,
0.4272792041,
-0.3953099847,
0.3101150692,
-0.0786083043,
-0.1098837703,
0.0164801795,
0.4992865324,
0.8771136403,
0.2711568475,
-0.162039414,
0.2538850307,
-0.1729638577,
-0.3316504955,
-0.0465945527,
0.4410932064,
-0.2858530283,
0.2979731858,
0.4505860507,
0.3151192367,
0.2235744745,
-0.3724329472,
-0.0364796855,
0.4765585661,
-0.475308001,
-0.3773135543,
0.4603249133,
0.2122865617,
-0.5408693552,
0.2022292316,
-0.5575640798,
-0.4190646708,
0.5268324018,
0.0082876021,
0.9517819881,
-0.0044990066,
0.0337992124,
0.0811797976,
0.5936730504,
-0.0196194109,
0.2823177278,
0.1328436285,
-0.7114222646,
-0.7713436484,
-0.8559272289,
-0.7716791034,
0.5000865459,
-0.7674085498,
0.1783196777,
-0.7185565829,
-0.5212618709,
-0.0005555989,
-0.0523628257,
-0.732607007,
0.2612384558,
0.232240662,
0.5237985849,
-0.5713467002,
0.4109763801,
0.9123077393,
-0.2089263946,
-0.7153937221,
0.2191952914,
0.0245298799,
-0.5904939771,
0.6825794578,
-0.1334699541,
-0.1024561524,
-0.6762773991,
-0.3991611898,
-0.8975760937,
0.7828794718,
0.0516529083,
-0.4897357225,
-0.1293792725,
0.3529619575,
0.7706458569,
-0.0402333662,
0.3198591471,
0.7468113899,
0.6433061957,
-0.0197549462,
-1.3017662764,
-0.0053120218,
0.1578112096,
-0.0379577354,
0.0945741311,
-0.6310261488,
0.6520864964,
-0.0034710451,
-0.2083152682,
-0.0177946482,
0.5422986746,
0.4662770927,
0.3906975091,
0.6036451459,
0.5106503367,
0.6640873551,
-0.4509572387,
1.0733962059,
-0.0830413029,
0.4463663697,
1.0922704935,
-0.1303493828,
0.6707983613,
0.487192452,
-0.6653596759,
0.1755893677,
0.9441026449,
-0.1341305226,
0.0214552674,
0.4065473378,
0.102831535,
-0.0403248556,
0.1439924687,
-0.184253186,
0.6430481076,
0.4681963623,
0.0043764631,
-0.3278801441,
-0.326610595,
-0.2052360177,
-0.174737379,
-0.3830325603,
0.6148614287,
0.1025210693,
-0.4971742034,
0.6300732493,
0.3317162693,
1.1680070162,
-0.4867949486,
0.1643880159,
-0.3916944861,
-0.2957054675,
-0.9669657946,
-0.9220467806,
0.5037905574,
0.0889767706,
0.0377284363,
-0.4271802306,
0.5777156353,
-0.0781287625,
-0.191369772,
0.2148794979,
0.5835467577,
0.3819167018,
-0.0855116993,
-0.7362907529,
0.1846583188,
0.0634535551,
-0.269389987,
0.4337062538,
0.4094132185,
-0.051808469,
0.3429456949,
0.5003149509,
0.1785074472,
0.1412999779,
0.3720166683,
0.3850214779,
-0.6965258121,
-0.0148218861,
-1.0271450281,
0.2509272099,
0.2602568269,
-0.4702549577,
0.8724254966,
0.2375854403,
0.8922075033,
0.335234493,
0.3835115731,
0.2338522226,
0.0822106376,
-0.8599142432,
0.7138494253,
-0.6019084454,
0.7581919432,
-0.2489776611,
-1.2507655621,
-0.2357478142,
0.4601269662,
-0.1244367212,
0.4223017693,
0.9298721552,
0.3768945932,
0.1203643158,
-0.088550441,
0.5279556513,
0.1554193199,
0.5453923941,
0.4406782389,
1.2707976103,
-0.4696043432,
0.3659597635,
-0.2480764687,
-0.018093504,
-0.3267813027,
-0.9225070477,
-0.7622057796,
-0.1998486072,
-0.7711203694,
-0.4369745851,
-0.1104595363,
0.9163267016,
0.6341190934,
-0.637434721,
-0.0766241252,
0.0582643971,
0.3338426948,
-0.1640789807,
-0.2971971035,
0.1263815165,
-0.429122597,
-0.5718521476,
0.3637038469,
0.422056675,
0.1075083837,
-0.6530794501,
-0.0825421363,
0.3848925829,
0.0495321266,
0.6097800732,
-0.0305943768,
-1.2883616686,
-0.6858328581,
-0.2426024824,
-0.2480011135,
0.1718180478,
0.6952908039,
-0.6414595842,
0.0484055579,
0.4050706327,
0.5793569088,
-0.046371419,
0.1144972742,
0.027989421,
-0.8420353532,
-0.2016454339,
0.2765579224,
0.3655688167,
0.2597760558,
-0.6444135904,
0.3564762175,
-0.0889116973,
-0.6496836543,
-0.7227197886,
0.2814211845,
-1.1950576305,
-0.0939324796,
1.5025370121,
-0.0909723118,
-0.0954933837,
-0.1516008824,
-0.0907003284,
-0.1853606254,
-0.175163582,
1.0793552399,
1.0729483366,
-0.8384344578,
0.1542218328,
-0.4006229341,
0.6921043992,
0.6066679955,
-0.8716940284,
-0.3607226908,
0.264768362,
0.3599279821,
0.4336329103,
0.2610436678,
-0.2396491915,
0.434215337,
-0.4177126884,
-0.02874716,
0.1032641083,
-0.1498480886,
-0.6449149847,
0.2231759876,
0.5859578848,
-0.004604659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12052v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12052v3
|
Small Models, Big Insights: Leveraging Slim Proxy Models To Decide When and What to Retrieve for LLMs
| 2024-02-19T11:11:08 | 2024-05-30T12:03:51 |
Jiejun Tan, Zhicheng Dou, Yutao Zhu, Peidong Guo, Kun Fang, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The integration of large language models (LLMs) and search engines represents
a significant evolution in knowledge acquisition methodologies. However,
determining the knowledge that an LLM already possesses and the knowledge that
requires the help of a search engine remains an unresolved issue. Most existing
methods solve this problem through the results of preliminary answers or
reasoning done by the LLM itself, but this incurs excessively high
computational costs. This paper introduces a novel collaborative approach,
namely SlimPLM, that detects missing knowledge in LLMs with a slim proxy model,
to enhance the LLM's knowledge acquisition process. We employ a proxy model
which has far fewer parameters, and take its answers as heuristic answers.
Heuristic answers are then utilized to predict the knowledge required to answer
the user question, as well as the known and unknown knowledge within the LLM.
We only conduct retrieval for the missing knowledge in questions that the LLM
does not know. Extensive experimental results on five datasets with two LLMs
demonstrate a notable improvement in the end-to-end performance of LLMs in
question-answering tasks, achieving or surpassing current state-of-the-art
models with lower LLM inference costs.
|
[
-0.5093222857,
-0.4324682057,
1.2745729685,
-0.2837360799,
-0.0808449835,
0.2271962315,
-0.0894720256,
-0.3139059842,
0.4942418933,
0.5605974793,
-0.7594816089,
-0.3929093182,
-0.6504269838,
-0.0406388044,
-0.0875850618,
0.631057024,
0.3192557693,
0.0992340744,
-0.579112649,
0.0494832322,
-0.2452912331,
-0.1333423257,
-0.6292923689,
-0.1938911825,
0.5137930512,
0.6130090952,
0.7209790349,
0.7616437674,
0.3860391974,
0.2815971076,
-0.3630027473,
0.635027349,
-0.5967205763,
-0.1595411599,
-0.6124984622,
-0.8555515409,
-0.431188494,
0.0133038862,
0.2474683523,
1.18833673,
-0.1941714734,
0.3593597412,
0.0089733154,
0.5582447648,
-0.7802659869,
0.2342421114,
-0.7605910301,
-0.1351151764,
-0.1901704073,
0.0416388214,
-0.2273394316,
-0.3428171277,
0.3223930597,
-0.7566745281,
0.2927300334,
0.1242978796,
0.4942758381,
0.341301769,
-0.3779312968,
-0.5297915339,
-0.3437081277,
0.805013299,
-0.7775835395,
0.5630814433,
0.362668097,
0.1548057944,
-0.5505023599,
-0.8045428991,
-0.6382575631,
0.125445351,
-0.0794562399,
0.2402050048,
0.0901333243,
-0.1079426631,
0.000481935,
0.338624835,
-0.4516716599,
0.1406905949,
-0.5896951556,
-0.3863431811,
0.6053522825,
0.2236338705,
0.2365487367,
-0.2997136116,
-0.1768738478,
0.1592566669,
-0.7065739632,
-0.2254472822,
0.2425284833,
0.3598403037,
-0.1791638881,
0.5636273026,
-0.2255685478,
0.5285938382,
0.0610826463,
-0.3921048343,
0.0696128607,
-0.2233201265,
0.0185484085,
-0.0896648243,
0.649358511,
0.019690549,
0.2284473479,
-0.2606825233,
-0.1672153771,
-0.3818827569,
-0.0771956518,
-0.6487063766,
-0.3849372864,
0.078958407,
-0.4092132747,
0.2196636051,
-0.0374220759,
-0.8085875511,
-0.753513217,
-0.2457428873,
0.4787813127,
-0.1722065806,
-0.2431359142,
0.2175094485,
-0.4890339673,
0.1094572246,
0.6295425296,
-0.6044818163,
0.530516088,
0.9221979976,
0.9091222286,
-0.2883653343,
-0.095468618,
-0.7685026526,
0.3631004691,
-0.1651686281,
0.6766434908,
-0.3526777923,
-0.3431602418,
-0.0431757271,
0.0786282122,
-0.0978060514,
-0.6831727624,
0.2999689281,
-0.7806414962,
0.5720037222,
-0.2896777093,
-0.9582484365,
-0.1907953471,
0.1802399009,
-0.7555397749,
0.641751647,
0.0005818413,
-0.6686164737,
0.1068967879,
-0.3742769361,
-0.1608035862,
0.3901799917,
-0.1809562147,
-0.0438011102,
0.5285069346,
0.3814423084,
0.5473327041,
-0.5529438853,
-0.0512936823,
-0.6043416858,
-0.3763436377,
0.0922518224,
0.0698888376,
0.7642983794,
0.1991093606,
0.0654373765,
-0.3825839758,
-0.6465351582,
0.0944649503,
0.3642171919,
-0.3430059552,
-0.6570062041,
0.1471520066,
-0.6889154911,
0.1727282107,
0.6463057399,
-0.4816054404,
0.1568958759,
-0.601685524,
0.1892984509,
0.6719993353,
0.2210697681,
0.6332717538,
-0.1589710712,
0.4293663502,
-0.0698334798,
0.1230937541,
-0.0369905345,
-0.5965768099,
-0.8614459634,
-0.3415118754,
0.3200010955,
0.4086796343,
-0.8973277211,
0.1211236417,
-0.3203617632,
-0.3199659288,
-0.6602950096,
0.6868413687,
0.0975544453,
0.3906135559,
0.2796346843,
-0.29635939,
-0.4021476507,
-0.8164150715,
-0.2315308005,
-0.4201292694,
-0.3669231832,
0.5508164763,
0.5199307203,
-0.2722434103,
1.007237196,
-0.9974235892,
-0.3562808335,
-0.4395178556,
-0.1518902779,
0.3569652438,
0.0280791577,
0.1958588064,
-0.7660005689,
-0.3394830227,
-0.0785804689,
-0.7176795602,
-0.2346101403,
0.2240691483,
-0.0328279063,
-0.3133485913,
0.4879739583,
-0.7463490963,
-0.00801118,
0.5392329097,
0.08959198,
0.2623104751,
-0.1350154579,
-0.3573048711,
-1.1081951857,
-0.0927305967,
0.0002665672,
-0.438988775,
-0.3860841691,
0.1881347746,
0.2130573541,
0.1337458044,
-0.4277118146,
0.9449204206,
-0.6917825341,
-0.1356771141,
-0.2218503505,
0.7667658329,
0.0156970527,
0.4223458469,
0.1096637771,
0.8748759627,
0.1620956659,
-0.5371201038,
0.2154616714,
0.2068633735,
-0.1102105305,
0.4584338367,
-0.4608338177,
0.3529930413,
-0.1316270232,
-0.0685219392,
-0.98727566,
-0.5656216145,
-0.1364057511,
-0.3597970307,
-0.0042438866,
-0.385861218,
-0.7024667859,
-0.6199957132,
-0.3355714381,
0.0047153723,
0.5843943357,
-0.7289954424,
0.7246459723,
0.7523477077,
-0.4074788094,
-0.2167258114,
-0.255754739,
-0.1018609032,
-0.0975733399,
-0.6378233433,
0.0037318401,
-0.1657799929,
-0.386819154,
-0.0982844532,
-0.4185456038,
-0.2611587048,
0.1894726157,
0.0315696523,
0.2031298578,
-0.2484801859,
0.1294880211,
0.0903932974,
0.1564916372,
0.1561546475,
-0.4641793966,
0.4706998765,
0.1146411747,
-0.2713656425,
-0.1798936278,
0.0543598309,
0.7078818679,
-0.1165099889,
0.8323780894,
0.3301502764,
-0.3479165733,
-0.6093369722,
-0.935600996,
-0.4857231379,
-0.532356739,
0.1548023373,
-0.1922313869,
-0.9308944941,
0.6452413797,
-0.6123681068,
-0.22822088,
0.2266234308,
0.4877792597,
-0.1383923292,
1.086474061,
1.0658904314,
-0.1566002667,
0.2173771709,
-0.1413645297,
0.0796712041,
-0.7545256019,
-0.4562654495,
-0.4270565808,
-0.0422903113,
-0.4928058386,
-0.4292317331,
0.5299804807,
0.1856145412,
0.1229806095,
0.0440564603,
0.0070657292,
0.5919183493,
0.6512040496,
0.3406969905,
0.5846920013,
-0.1593391001,
-0.4572478533,
-0.0460117683,
-0.8876253366,
-0.2552510202,
0.9955901504,
0.2476602346,
0.6548123956,
0.3024043441,
0.7445302606,
0.1305377036,
0.2120713592,
-0.9295232892,
0.7486863732,
-0.1138734445,
-0.4910464585,
-0.0884321481,
-0.6640149355,
-0.6659493446,
0.3903530538,
0.1834924668,
-0.8016247749,
0.1321391016,
-0.0516013578,
-0.4221944511,
0.2122173905,
-0.8262460828,
0.5076825023,
-0.2748812437,
-0.7348444462,
-0.0731341764,
-0.5428416133,
0.5441384315,
-0.5110471845,
0.4088704586,
0.065215975,
-0.5199251175,
0.8936824799,
-0.6173961759,
0.8545428514,
-0.1165336892,
-0.0869399533,
0.2564597726,
0.257101655,
0.6803322434,
0.1587118953,
-0.159392029,
0.0398389697,
-0.0808097273,
-0.291154027,
-0.6491479874,
0.7707195282,
-0.7462631464,
-0.889146626,
-0.1819300205,
-0.5814769268,
-0.5460366011,
0.2736207545,
-0.1165052131,
-0.2002116889,
0.1410719752,
-0.0767841861,
0.9885898829,
-0.2517867088,
0.3257668912,
1.0101498365,
-0.2055841237,
-0.3362803161,
0.6947299242,
-0.0032367595,
0.2816097438,
0.1045576334,
0.3580152094,
-0.3455302715,
-0.5492153764,
-0.2109998018,
0.8434904814,
-0.5980222225,
-0.2425685078,
-0.6789909005,
-0.1784403324,
-0.299813509,
0.0844750926,
-0.485899806,
-0.3380905986,
-0.376505971,
0.0007359785,
0.121925585,
0.7103722095,
-0.2102000266,
0.5388344526,
-0.9477958083,
0.063634336,
0.4998452961,
0.0475010611,
0.0582837015,
-0.4724291861,
-0.3296090066,
0.0837683827,
-0.1749248505,
-0.9845805168,
0.5285758972,
-0.0429564565,
0.7106175423,
0.394343704,
-0.064285323,
0.9239413738,
-0.3631442189,
0.7415291667,
0.0334773175,
-0.850734055,
0.6112790108,
-0.3306136131,
0.3777767718,
0.6053164601,
0.7936261892,
-0.3653687537,
-0.2635470927,
-0.6764400601,
-0.5624637008,
0.6293313503,
-0.194626376,
-0.167736128,
0.0637935996,
0.6317955852,
0.1165459082,
0.6092135906,
-0.2815587819,
0.0754413679,
0.6021901965,
-0.2838934362,
0.0833253339,
-0.1935310513,
-0.0347474255,
-0.1726262569,
0.5190435052,
-0.4104279578,
0.0043396698,
-0.070536904,
-0.310611546,
-0.0999893695,
0.0481948331,
0.0287400372,
0.6939992309,
-0.1673767716,
0.2610021532,
0.3209534585,
-0.4821164012,
-0.312096566,
-0.0255659129,
0.0148092266,
-0.089580752,
0.3754563928,
0.1777302027,
0.1195980161,
-0.9088487029,
0.8067852855,
0.0025080699,
-0.0744553208,
-0.3074316382,
0.266345948,
0.3553413749,
0.5677942634,
0.4184060991,
-0.2861972153,
0.153526336,
-0.5349747539,
0.2661170661,
0.5785529613,
-0.1876991838,
-0.4278070033,
0.5765942931,
0.0804517046,
-0.1559079289,
0.7369855642,
-0.2535348833,
-0.7000383735,
0.4743777514,
0.4822353423,
0.49250108,
-0.1971257329,
0.3137873411,
-0.0504040681,
0.281432718,
-0.3679974973,
0.4248821139,
-0.0707792491,
-0.6573693156,
-0.5247204304,
-0.6049563289,
-0.6260575056,
0.4766612947,
-0.4918288291,
0.1609978527,
-0.4601173401,
0.1585218161,
-0.1059932113,
0.4557337463,
-0.8669723868,
-0.0725572705,
0.0599928237,
1.0351035595,
-0.8538732529,
0.6286205649,
0.6420684457,
-0.4792272151,
-0.8568887711,
0.1835299432,
0.4463648498,
-1.0652555227,
0.7489831448,
-0.1300407499,
-0.0632067323,
0.1062427163,
-0.7678728104,
-1.0118119717,
1.1194750071,
0.4871637523,
-0.7467276454,
-0.1314374357,
0.1684918702,
0.5398615599,
-0.182027638,
0.2094307095,
0.5626009107,
0.2728374302,
0.3564905226,
-1.0354502201,
-0.025589183,
0.1454262286,
-0.3480625153,
0.1782353073,
-0.7980718613,
0.9558147788,
-0.4087996483,
-0.2246212065,
0.2555057108,
0.5732334852,
0.249183163,
0.4548563361,
0.315613389,
0.4668110907,
1.3513865471,
0.2498384416,
0.8985963464,
-0.1893263608,
0.2667323053,
1.2131946087,
-0.4407232106,
1.0094881058,
0.5167215466,
-0.054269135,
0.2912698686,
0.461946249,
0.1884563863,
0.6617680788,
0.1115755364,
-0.2799670696,
-0.5180059075,
-0.3019931018,
0.0536783785,
0.340773046,
0.7359660864,
-0.2299351245,
-0.2928314507,
-0.042148713,
0.292068094,
0.0370098054,
-0.5370115638,
0.9939172864,
0.3638521433,
-0.5270524025,
0.0902139321,
-0.0615558848,
0.5397895575,
-0.5053662062,
0.062739253,
-0.7509198785,
0.4548111856,
-0.1266836077,
-0.6368963122,
-0.0865440816,
-0.2799152732,
-0.2015545517,
0.0155195743,
0.8639073968,
-0.3130666912,
-0.4574186206,
0.3984745145,
1.4654688835,
0.1547049135,
-0.1187243015,
-0.4303098023,
-0.1037341803,
-0.0910057649,
0.0731884688,
0.3603960872,
0.6839265823,
0.0332146101,
0.856169641,
0.60612607,
0.4875329435,
0.2379407585,
-0.1821559072,
0.9637806416,
-0.3550893664,
-0.4777051806,
-0.7559879422,
0.1110667139,
-0.3446087837,
0.1561030149,
1.0363816023,
0.6667088866,
0.8905653358,
0.1129942015,
0.791041255,
0.2916755378,
0.7597514987,
-0.4967247844,
0.6111158133,
-0.9156014323,
0.6268681884,
-0.1389356256,
-0.7307431698,
-0.1240359098,
0.374237597,
-0.5262196064,
-0.1167038083,
0.6391996145,
0.9449663758,
-0.4731289744,
0.1052587181,
0.2389927208,
0.2517246008,
0.2272889912,
0.6852315068,
0.9796715379,
-0.0973765627,
0.417694658,
-0.1853622496,
-0.1667311639,
-0.0640086159,
-0.6051312089,
-1.1218537092,
-0.3952095807,
-0.172965318,
-0.0635867864,
0.241139099,
0.7816692591,
0.7166118026,
-0.496896863,
-0.3326874375,
0.0883381441,
0.5496499538,
0.0860327557,
-0.2306141108,
0.3270127773,
-0.355104357,
-0.715033412,
0.5757411718,
0.1328131258,
-0.1529565006,
-0.3606521189,
-0.0650690645,
-0.1636805683,
0.3178345859,
0.4021743536,
0.2250666022,
-0.485765487,
-0.0807112455,
0.0825401172,
0.0810335279,
-0.229284659,
0.7703990936,
-1.0486297607,
0.1763065904,
0.5762045979,
0.8528350592,
0.5531045198,
-0.1189446002,
0.4782627225,
-0.9501727819,
0.0140745314,
0.0114255995,
0.4273602068,
0.2568965256,
-0.3849810064,
0.6249853969,
0.4481527507,
-0.3542562127,
-0.7507376671,
-0.0153890494,
-0.7178078294,
-0.5477278233,
1.0438323021,
-0.1388778836,
-0.372377485,
-0.1561750621,
0.0600822046,
-0.0990773514,
-0.3885263503,
0.7585068345,
0.5222965479,
0.004219742,
-0.2598733902,
-0.7697347999,
0.2562325895,
0.2478163391,
-0.7643107772,
-0.2228284776,
0.6501232386,
0.6022799611,
0.3802750409,
0.3454340696,
0.1292473227,
0.1173373237,
-0.2318213582,
-0.4202967584,
-0.1214689612,
-0.3164920509,
-0.0306719951,
0.6058427691,
-0.0042844294,
0.0231049825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12048v1
|
Model Tailor: Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Multi-modal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T11:02:05 | 2024-02-19T11:02:05 |
Didi Zhu, Zhongyi Sun, Zexi Li, Tao Shen, Ke Yan, Shouhong Ding, Kun Kuang, Chao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Catastrophic forgetting emerges as a critical challenge when fine-tuning
multi-modal large language models (MLLMs), where improving performance on
unseen tasks often leads to a significant performance drop on the original
tasks. This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of catastrophic forgetting
in MLLMs and introduces a post-training adjustment method called Model Tailor.
Our method primarily preserves the pre-trained parameters while replacing a
small number ($\leq$ 10\%) of fine-tuned parameters, maintaining $\sim$ 99\%
effectiveness on original tasks versus pre-training, and achieving $\sim$ 97\%
on new tasks compared to standard fine-tuning. Specifically, we derive a sparse
mask to identify the "model patch", based on a fusion strategy that integrates
salience and sensitivity analysis. Subsequently, a compensation mechanism is
introduced to "decorate the patch", enhancing the model's performance on both
target and original tasks. Additionally, our method is adaptable to multi-task
scenarios. Through extensive experiments on InstructBLIP and LLaVA-1.5 in both
image captioning and visual question answering tasks, our approach demonstrates
significant task adaptability while preserving inherent pre-trained
capabilities.
|
[
-0.4559221864,
-0.6650696993,
0.2624244094,
0.1487890631,
-0.1998189986,
-0.0722676218,
-0.1983676404,
-0.0058742841,
0.0229690243,
0.6696807742,
-0.9230067134,
-0.0591307804,
-0.4318696856,
-0.1749475002,
0.1449124068,
0.9678460956,
-0.0928371102,
0.0318776555,
-0.4068349004,
-0.3344814777,
-0.9192467928,
-0.3817254901,
-0.7963644266,
-0.0778298005,
0.6283314228,
0.4086790383,
0.3182063103,
0.3820768893,
0.4654594362,
0.2793644667,
-0.1414649934,
0.4782741368,
-0.8592724204,
0.0802872926,
-0.3375540972,
-0.4643451273,
-0.6200131774,
-0.1494516432,
0.8509212732,
0.5415525436,
-0.1947458237,
0.4367499053,
0.2389394939,
0.681374073,
-1.0309225321,
-0.1755140126,
-0.9483209848,
-0.1010974571,
-0.1230192408,
-0.3209746182,
-0.5771468282,
0.1917661279,
-0.1711222082,
-0.5417376161,
0.3700188398,
0.1280077249,
0.5622648001,
0.4635439813,
-0.002377715,
0.1356549561,
-0.7490752339,
0.9236443043,
-0.8826466799,
0.3926239908,
0.5482131243,
0.267617166,
-0.1915936172,
-0.4446791708,
-0.3237146735,
-0.1997442991,
0.1285303682,
0.0385467485,
-0.0641941428,
-0.1473138183,
0.415140003,
0.2307351828,
-0.6083872914,
0.2195540518,
-0.2480574399,
-0.4244983494,
0.4270422459,
0.2744590938,
0.2023876905,
0.14406012,
-0.1039250046,
0.0462095588,
-0.7258808017,
-0.0997636169,
0.1439073533,
0.2881550491,
0.0577873997,
0.3457848132,
-0.1122090816,
0.8794891238,
-0.0387739763,
-0.2987619042,
-0.0367729589,
-0.3700872362,
-0.3048619628,
-0.4517165422,
0.42453143,
0.2916765213,
0.2760594189,
-0.040585041,
-0.3776448965,
-0.292052716,
0.4805663526,
-0.5064561367,
-0.5274756551,
-0.0713948309,
-0.4012113512,
-0.000388324,
-0.3225971162,
-0.5084879398,
-0.4700431228,
-0.372421056,
0.741198957,
-0.3706822097,
-0.2357529253,
0.19001697,
0.0233993176,
-0.1430669278,
0.354925245,
-0.8593612909,
-0.083246097,
0.2241724581,
0.841026485,
0.080498673,
-0.7332946062,
-0.6438394189,
0.4110137224,
-0.2342480868,
0.9711098075,
-0.4427359104,
-0.1156307235,
-0.0629195273,
0.0410570949,
-0.549546957,
-0.4758986831,
0.3826254606,
-0.3876809478,
0.139608115,
-0.4045937657,
-0.4201874137,
-0.1166913286,
0.5336375833,
-0.6959326267,
0.719460845,
0.1177959666,
-0.8092629313,
0.2842514813,
-0.5324601531,
-0.2863147259,
-0.3053593636,
0.4697609544,
-0.8438840508,
0.3143394291,
0.4667807519,
0.4370990098,
-0.2366184294,
0.0443498157,
-0.7048854828,
-0.4685821533,
0.2254132777,
-0.3772124052,
0.4398466647,
-0.1596604586,
0.0212577898,
0.4919451475,
-0.7344483137,
-0.0181495938,
0.1576845795,
-0.2716359794,
-0.375889957,
0.0353179313,
0.2601668537,
0.3317123353,
0.18498303,
-0.2106725723,
0.1917960942,
-0.3516353667,
0.7061675191,
0.9792900681,
0.151518032,
0.3821033239,
-0.7406066656,
0.5082417727,
-0.0062634018,
0.4586287737,
-0.6554619074,
-0.0159163177,
-0.9467156529,
-0.4975754917,
0.1523655355,
0.3314117193,
-0.5732156038,
0.1725112647,
-0.046967946,
-0.6397984624,
-0.4795390069,
0.1205477864,
0.43974787,
0.5005573034,
0.4394516945,
-0.352799803,
-0.6482974291,
-0.9639285803,
-0.3539287746,
0.0608757138,
-0.0839237496,
0.2847649157,
0.4156745672,
-0.3293915987,
0.5396855474,
-0.4433172047,
-0.6153331399,
-0.1932699382,
-0.1207881272,
-0.0874071121,
0.7054734826,
0.4849963784,
-0.6237066388,
-0.1970718652,
-0.2283745259,
-0.3271473944,
0.0463678911,
-0.4410137534,
-0.0920615345,
0.3761391342,
0.6286253333,
-0.5292973518,
0.2120532691,
0.3688986301,
-0.2533974946,
0.8371904492,
-0.5234076977,
0.1796212494,
-1.0698932409,
0.3413442373,
-0.2082542032,
-0.1407441944,
-0.4782318473,
0.2395137995,
0.2742635608,
0.0165843684,
-0.3291105628,
0.5445480943,
-0.4820812047,
0.1943965107,
-0.3349804282,
-0.2382807285,
-0.0697193667,
0.5984396338,
-0.4397169948,
0.6529925466,
0.5926354527,
-0.4677834213,
0.0548379347,
0.2423187345,
-0.0559348576,
0.6221626997,
-0.4153659344,
0.2894642651,
-0.3732719421,
0.2042502612,
-1.1573649645,
-0.3331565857,
0.2248907834,
-0.1392603964,
0.3999487758,
-0.1279975325,
-0.3866327107,
-0.4394024611,
-0.3522397578,
0.4591368437,
0.2729826272,
-0.1409272254,
0.7282965779,
0.2594569623,
-0.3595377803,
-0.3003789186,
-0.2927318513,
0.1494333595,
-0.4078452587,
-0.2782887518,
0.1960659325,
-0.5375598073,
0.2674318552,
-0.2885184586,
-0.1326285452,
-0.3079831302,
0.2135478258,
0.0796110779,
0.2923434377,
-0.3091111779,
0.1323982179,
0.1499649137,
-0.1673390716,
-0.2213239819,
-0.2236959487,
0.6887280941,
0.0128769241,
-0.5248448849,
-0.2845903635,
0.4154602587,
1.0478868484,
-0.5934121609,
0.7180470228,
0.6645410061,
-0.5064902306,
-0.0878832117,
-0.9971862435,
-0.2473019809,
-0.4064662158,
0.7926123738,
-0.2092237025,
-0.8894305229,
0.7063825727,
0.0050810119,
0.1822994947,
0.2887334824,
0.6382597089,
-0.1466871649,
0.9289034605,
0.9397028089,
-0.3082257211,
0.5504052043,
0.1342016757,
0.0782521889,
-0.9179133773,
-0.1549888551,
-0.2568557858,
-0.3555649519,
0.0011075323,
-0.4168495834,
0.3027850688,
0.2936067879,
-0.4076482356,
0.2763762772,
-0.3123611808,
0.4857191145,
0.6598173976,
0.4262599647,
0.1327310652,
-0.2682612836,
0.2533399761,
-0.3121452034,
-0.9825733304,
-0.1878038347,
0.9908176661,
0.1482444257,
0.5587391257,
-0.050678663,
0.3861098886,
0.0926544368,
0.3327616453,
-0.4206181467,
0.3681516945,
-0.0989047438,
-0.3378645778,
-0.4010117054,
-0.2280662209,
-0.583810091,
0.1443671733,
-0.3924449682,
-0.6754632592,
-0.1137997732,
0.6956633925,
-0.5394297838,
0.360892266,
-0.7029534578,
1.0299322605,
0.0069562448,
-0.2669762075,
-0.4269623756,
-0.3799980283,
0.477920264,
-0.4936196804,
0.1202864721,
-0.1045619994,
0.1235104278,
0.6434698105,
0.108301498,
0.9845481515,
-0.1309762895,
0.1592910886,
-0.1440150589,
0.2141767442,
0.6163260341,
-0.1794297248,
-0.0174282603,
-0.1352657527,
0.1106056944,
-0.6495450735,
-0.4959750473,
0.6400241852,
-0.2929039896,
-0.5710755587,
0.0576036498,
-1.1264054775,
-0.4568910599,
0.3480953872,
0.2961168289,
0.332482636,
-0.1600152701,
0.0450194776,
0.8621479273,
-0.3667076826,
0.6119653583,
0.6546055079,
0.0570589676,
-0.5330271125,
0.956148684,
0.1610414982,
0.3794418275,
0.1870596409,
0.1314270794,
0.0418012515,
-0.729031086,
-0.4419353604,
0.2830006182,
-0.5092392564,
-0.4423265755,
-0.519461751,
-0.1518935561,
-0.3418703377,
-0.3472831249,
-0.53493011,
-0.1224909723,
-0.415655911,
0.329669565,
0.1745923162,
0.4290366471,
0.0893740952,
0.2897073627,
-0.8004075885,
0.188659519,
0.2298069149,
0.4650324285,
0.1912916601,
-0.9371066093,
-0.3717276454,
0.0562094711,
-0.3306289613,
-0.4811998606,
0.2105194777,
0.5889362693,
0.5476310253,
0.2334776372,
0.0567349233,
1.0104593039,
-0.6916100383,
0.5514605641,
0.2422111779,
-0.7401915789,
0.6256062984,
-0.4829995036,
0.7825186253,
0.3595188558,
0.0689161867,
-0.4921607673,
-0.5398401022,
-0.4963591397,
-0.8575019836,
0.5671750307,
-0.1464386135,
0.2984345853,
0.2803218961,
0.4593859315,
0.0437134653,
-0.0142895002,
-0.6542617083,
-0.1224833429,
0.0273976643,
0.0439143591,
-0.2532192767,
-0.6510543823,
-0.2135799229,
-0.3683303297,
0.7032188177,
-0.2087526917,
-0.0142753348,
-0.0506282523,
-0.397247225,
-0.1431417763,
0.0449737087,
1.2352372408,
1.0405642986,
0.0482131466,
-0.0388763472,
0.5647128224,
-0.2805980146,
-0.1112182587,
0.0704669729,
-0.0100862449,
-0.1875670254,
0.7025200725,
0.9382939339,
0.6350908279,
-0.7738469243,
0.376024276,
0.155751422,
0.0186684374,
-0.1291988492,
0.1103211194,
0.1412679851,
0.3083402514,
0.1984091401,
0.628719151,
-0.0766215175,
-0.307988286,
0.42363289,
0.4387321174,
-0.5336877108,
-0.3181215227,
0.8032785058,
-0.2344862521,
-0.5041850805,
0.4732894599,
0.3072029948,
-0.4901735187,
0.3776444793,
0.8066086769,
0.7119113803,
-0.6137151122,
0.0649739727,
0.4555362463,
0.4632707834,
-0.2766438723,
-0.0727514103,
0.0822708979,
-0.4228065312,
-0.5627760291,
-0.6253098249,
-0.0187875219,
0.1744571626,
-0.7587362528,
0.2024681717,
-0.5351510644,
0.0836696029,
-0.1138563231,
-0.5937908292,
-0.6107354164,
0.1845020056,
0.0072546848,
0.9491819143,
-1.0426198244,
0.6224646568,
0.652353406,
-0.4193630517,
-0.6409595609,
0.0799996182,
-0.009342649,
-0.8317908645,
-0.0155219594,
0.0336155258,
0.2220564336,
0.1082465574,
-0.2656805217,
-0.9859323502,
0.849491477,
0.7774799466,
-0.5962004662,
-0.0386787504,
-0.1372545809,
0.4120250642,
-0.1354746073,
0.125713855,
0.5895324349,
0.3278220892,
0.110999994,
-1.2447986603,
0.0200183131,
-0.118939124,
0.0350878611,
0.2450863868,
-0.5643553138,
0.6954214573,
-0.3966573775,
0.2142047882,
0.1992935091,
0.2324280292,
0.2540335953,
0.205789879,
0.5464205742,
0.5538369417,
0.7563372254,
0.2434473038,
0.830940187,
0.0663123354,
0.4934841394,
1.3538920879,
0.0480922721,
0.9257964492,
0.6119496822,
0.0045305775,
-0.0214277133,
0.7341656685,
0.0331530832,
0.693718493,
0.0840909407,
-0.1483064443,
-0.6215078235,
-0.0172554348,
-0.2931763232,
0.4207088649,
0.1257316023,
-0.2874681056,
-0.1782858223,
0.4866626263,
-0.037069995,
0.0426458865,
-0.5848464966,
0.8863424659,
-0.0388894677,
-0.6537320018,
0.8255095482,
-0.1783716977,
0.3612929583,
-0.6462562084,
0.0289817452,
-0.2938348353,
0.4224876165,
0.0756814405,
-0.2237789631,
0.4923210442,
-0.4154379368,
-0.6975215673,
-0.0903957933,
0.5181612372,
-0.6140317917,
-0.7498722076,
-0.0681904554,
0.1485106945,
-0.3650990129,
-0.4880925715,
-0.7678672671,
0.3670924604,
0.0973954424,
-0.1586260349,
0.4576692283,
0.1875350475,
-0.2170632333,
0.8954657912,
0.5396652222,
-0.0074928394,
-0.0261353534,
0.0848031566,
1.020716548,
-0.4502859414,
-0.446819365,
-0.9639321566,
0.8656343222,
-0.0298609752,
-0.4662877321,
0.6803805232,
0.3832316697,
0.7171431184,
-0.4518030584,
0.5635873675,
0.1789799333,
0.4394576848,
-0.5905439854,
1.0694543123,
-0.6669778228,
0.1721432358,
-0.4814818501,
-1.0479661226,
-0.8052449226,
0.4153787494,
-0.124971047,
-0.148221463,
0.546846211,
1.1091809273,
-0.2586827278,
-0.4737141132,
0.5392825603,
0.2461980432,
0.1425342858,
0.7989243865,
0.647785306,
-0.4203670323,
0.4803669155,
-0.0062381225,
-0.3153451681,
-0.258505404,
-0.7973926663,
-0.9946565032,
-0.8190457225,
-0.3967095315,
-0.1891644597,
0.153544277,
0.549426496,
0.8622729182,
-0.8317741156,
0.2678346932,
0.1909392178,
0.02116381,
-0.3252013028,
-0.0877233148,
0.4518609047,
-0.4642721713,
-0.4553818107,
0.218795836,
0.5692796111,
-0.0743476078,
-0.2237504125,
0.008078537,
-0.0537542477,
0.041224692,
0.6356464624,
0.3227998018,
-0.937825799,
-0.4942947328,
-0.0763985217,
0.1979502589,
-0.1289005429,
0.9162136912,
-0.5366076231,
0.669044137,
-0.0233745947,
0.7366628647,
0.3213410974,
-0.349237591,
0.6676899195,
-0.6936699152,
0.3931206763,
0.2334670424,
0.4858454168,
0.4447536767,
-0.2218221277,
-0.0211531166,
0.2011038512,
-0.5327047706,
-1.0764616728,
0.340858072,
-0.8778099418,
-0.3033221662,
0.714374125,
-0.1784960926,
0.1139380485,
-0.114716053,
-0.5563966036,
0.0267017074,
0.278879106,
1.1480246782,
0.7037664056,
0.2317213565,
-0.5745842457,
-0.373837024,
0.393746227,
0.6570977569,
-0.4683787525,
0.3432129025,
0.5335766673,
0.4781003892,
-0.212118879,
0.6394199133,
0.1641115546,
0.5146588087,
-0.162058413,
0.009492917,
-0.2938353121,
-0.3814537823,
-0.2593834698,
0.2412589788,
0.1857402623,
-0.0926603824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12046v1
|
Citation Amnesia: NLP and Other Academic Fields Are in a Citation Age Recession
| 2024-02-19T10:59:29 | 2024-02-19T10:59:29 |
Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Mohamed Abdalla, Bela Gipp, Saif M. Mohammad
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
This study examines the tendency to cite older work across 20 fields of study
over 43 years (1980--2023). We put NLP's propensity to cite older work in the
context of these 20 other fields to analyze whether NLP shows similar temporal
citation patterns to these other fields over time or whether differences can be
observed. Our analysis, based on a dataset of approximately 240 million papers,
reveals a broader scientific trend: many fields have markedly declined in
citing older works (e.g., psychology, computer science). We term this decline a
'citation age recession', analogous to how economists define periods of reduced
economic activity. The trend is strongest in NLP and ML research (-12.8% and
-5.5% in citation age from previous peaks). Our results suggest that citing
more recent works is not directly driven by the growth in publication rates
(-3.4% across fields; -5.2% in humanities; -5.5% in formal sciences) -- even
when controlling for an increase in the volume of papers. Our findings raise
questions about the scientific community's engagement with past literature,
particularly for NLP, and the potential consequences of neglecting older but
relevant research. The data and a demo showcasing our results are publicly
available.
|
[
-0.4533919096,
-0.368686825,
0.6698817015,
0.4459093213,
0.0634680465,
-0.1042611301,
0.2435046732,
-0.8456289768,
0.3094377518,
0.2371706665,
-0.2482192665,
-0.2494482547,
-0.5540503263,
0.4988075495,
-0.1228051707,
0.9572349191,
0.292827189,
-0.0832531452,
-0.4476560652,
-0.2085287869,
-0.4179024696,
-0.5450494885,
-0.8327180743,
-0.4567596316,
0.7598880529,
-0.1429342479,
0.4680313766,
0.31206128,
0.6044954062,
0.1541361213,
-0.6745060086,
-0.1342608184,
-0.4991381466,
0.3154251873,
-0.409216702,
-0.3908240795,
-0.5748476982,
-0.1896412224,
0.6143826842,
1.0463900566,
0.2877674699,
0.1210633144,
-0.2164378613,
1.2632989883,
-0.8734284639,
-0.0061304546,
-0.773678124,
-0.063863188,
-0.3401270509,
-0.7103620768,
-0.661693275,
-0.4821628034,
0.2286558747,
-0.3939858973,
0.3897942007,
0.2019652128,
0.6061645746,
0.012835566,
-0.1153744385,
-0.1437053233,
-0.7116502523,
0.7907001972,
-0.5249843597,
0.1009444818,
0.5846104026,
0.0410801694,
0.0683444813,
-0.9370033741,
-0.2045265287,
0.0471146703,
0.0141863683,
0.0736239552,
-0.5820708871,
-0.485206455,
0.358222872,
0.1790971905,
-0.6183216572,
-0.0773270354,
-0.9172943234,
-0.0618244745,
0.1981027275,
0.0609369613,
0.085273847,
-0.0932562128,
-0.5607407689,
0.2680304945,
-1.0525401831,
-0.2543094754,
0.0919513404,
0.0231229905,
0.5789504051,
0.6226266026,
0.0632553697,
0.2959081829,
-0.0804200843,
0.3490535915,
0.3290848434,
-0.3952843547,
-0.2181194127,
0.1175109074,
0.6154311299,
0.4990657568,
0.2331480235,
-0.3213927448,
0.3077065349,
-0.3411200643,
0.2421346307,
-0.5317595005,
-0.2539225817,
-0.1184092462,
-0.6127108335,
0.1928621083,
0.0147547331,
-0.7990412116,
-0.5571968555,
0.0522277877,
-0.0732345581,
-0.5665670037,
-0.1771930903,
-0.0198149942,
-0.6687431335,
-0.0059321816,
0.0704270601,
-0.7406544685,
0.0813794211,
0.5519067049,
1.2050024271,
-0.0943221003,
-0.4682679474,
0.0245951023,
0.1125612184,
-0.3420761228,
0.825009048,
-0.6901458502,
-0.6081533432,
0.0225569047,
0.1034337133,
-0.2859425545,
-0.6147471666,
0.4612782896,
-0.7547212243,
0.191818133,
-0.3292404115,
-0.2248143405,
-0.1506681442,
-0.0445812494,
-0.7494661212,
0.911151886,
0.2159124315,
-0.9968445897,
0.7389397621,
-0.4545034766,
0.0191041771,
-0.1346064657,
0.1109750867,
-0.5532522798,
0.1307750195,
0.0057550459,
0.0396955162,
-0.313231051,
0.3069571555,
-0.6467508078,
-0.3765586019,
0.1920400262,
-0.3527030647,
1.309756279,
0.4045968056,
-0.0650161952,
-0.46587345,
-0.8323844075,
-0.154605031,
-0.1736859232,
-0.0655147657,
-0.9538305998,
0.1248284876,
-0.1926281899,
0.1610035896,
0.06452021,
-0.5630446672,
0.4154897332,
-0.3885907531,
0.6642404199,
0.1437987238,
0.5310115814,
0.5307215452,
-0.7033287883,
0.5516055226,
-0.1138300151,
-0.1020396128,
-0.2298198789,
-0.701657474,
-0.4027265906,
0.1355015039,
-0.1600121111,
0.2487589717,
-0.2327337116,
0.1069611236,
-0.3657889664,
-0.3701581359,
-0.1701295972,
-0.0135525614,
-0.1935807317,
0.6304463744,
0.7833300829,
-0.1698723584,
-0.8610907793,
-0.685521245,
-0.6325890422,
-0.601963222,
-0.2369320989,
0.2502214313,
0.6011629701,
-0.0856638402,
1.0043860674,
-0.2099054009,
-0.4564496875,
0.3250774443,
0.7276642919,
0.0722261667,
0.5526284575,
0.8062764406,
-0.7184826136,
-0.0682988018,
-0.3750122786,
-0.4994181097,
-0.1966107488,
-0.3066155314,
0.0910573751,
0.4675728977,
0.7895120382,
-0.4629959166,
0.3210452497,
0.0680299848,
-0.6615393758,
0.5815954804,
0.0523492619,
-0.0652448609,
-0.2753693759,
0.7330716252,
-0.2194972783,
0.3770620823,
-0.0906582102,
-0.5271190405,
-0.0465274118,
-0.246539712,
-0.0274922624,
0.1834437847,
-0.8273159862,
0.065585576,
-0.2266931683,
-0.0797309503,
0.2447895855,
-0.1811645925,
0.1413834244,
0.5883982778,
0.3308329284,
-0.4397394359,
-0.2388935536,
-0.1032229066,
-0.2285950333,
0.4910586178,
-0.5632405281,
0.1386424601,
-0.408726424,
0.3524369001,
-0.6999287009,
0.4065415263,
-0.2487590909,
-0.3493328094,
0.0876574889,
-0.1263272762,
-0.0880321562,
-0.3492040038,
-0.4338364303,
0.3705692291,
0.2260066718,
0.0384182818,
0.557813704,
-0.0477247797,
-0.8271769285,
-0.8669067025,
-0.7015163302,
0.1080844402,
-0.419911325,
-0.5460064411,
0.6225799918,
0.0679772273,
-0.6647894979,
0.3266993165,
-0.2667784095,
-0.1391627342,
0.275270611,
0.2554706037,
0.2531719208,
-0.506136179,
0.1576443613,
-0.0389066599,
-0.0100440467,
0.3800346553,
-0.3373039067,
0.5965056419,
-0.2540021837,
-0.0085139321,
0.0740141124,
0.5226258636,
0.6157336831,
-0.1317366809,
0.8902557492,
0.3419626653,
-0.1292008162,
0.2202430516,
-0.4426763058,
0.0418002419,
-0.3211801052,
0.1565833688,
0.1222514138,
-0.6272542477,
0.3958960474,
-0.022626197,
0.2418335676,
0.8601609468,
0.3003535569,
-0.2015633285,
0.3892810345,
0.598487556,
-0.0474301875,
0.5685033202,
-0.28706339,
0.1756089628,
-0.7864854932,
-0.4834279716,
-0.8467837572,
-0.3439810574,
-0.2927447259,
-0.3610062003,
0.0535760559,
0.4234954715,
-0.1772372127,
0.1172676235,
-0.4535966516,
0.4737374485,
0.4844913483,
-0.2717450857,
0.6117088199,
-0.2661312521,
0.3993120193,
-0.2630954087,
-0.452229172,
-0.4598204792,
0.9907986522,
0.2383969873,
0.4585951269,
0.1798064262,
0.7184292674,
0.4939169288,
0.489495039,
-0.5894017816,
0.1695473343,
0.2429520935,
-0.8098121285,
-0.4163517058,
-0.2523899674,
-1.379650116,
0.0751323849,
-0.1833206117,
-0.6653048992,
0.9188630581,
0.0361902006,
-0.3023999333,
0.0309394263,
-0.287768662,
0.4940350652,
0.2961909175,
-0.3486146629,
-0.0730047971,
-0.7939607501,
0.549739778,
0.0735340938,
0.3058665097,
-0.1927195787,
0.1892003864,
0.9217262268,
-0.2320288271,
0.5832369328,
-0.2962348461,
0.2713880837,
0.3603756726,
0.1907610744,
0.375759095,
0.1269662976,
-0.1813296229,
-0.2592166364,
0.3917465806,
-0.5175258517,
-0.2667801678,
0.8560018539,
-0.3372821808,
-0.3927553892,
-0.9256896973,
-0.6001879573,
-0.1026701927,
0.1961223334,
0.3644121289,
0.0555416793,
-0.2943046987,
0.6087510586,
0.5365607142,
-0.1151996404,
0.7550382614,
0.5195143223,
-0.2808410227,
-0.3385514021,
0.6927258968,
0.3900457621,
0.2104584128,
0.1795289814,
0.0763611048,
0.0114957877,
-0.6624463797,
-0.0001614474,
0.3666771352,
-0.503662467,
-0.2164189816,
-0.9109511971,
0.2128965259,
-0.7159968019,
-0.145260796,
-0.026629569,
-0.6085932255,
-0.4893179238,
0.1052131057,
0.4247291684,
0.2474329025,
-0.0133450991,
-0.1535428613,
-0.4147645533,
-0.0824218541,
0.1208518445,
0.0413351469,
0.15346919,
-0.3641435206,
-0.0974624604,
-0.5422916412,
-0.3617349863,
-0.8767699003,
0.5699363947,
0.6249295473,
0.2775487304,
0.4991719127,
0.0761979148,
0.5803121924,
-0.5326586962,
0.9131346345,
0.1094879285,
-0.4588025808,
0.1902043968,
-0.3709965646,
0.5950265527,
0.9350329638,
0.9228800535,
-0.4939687252,
-0.3698484302,
-0.9691281319,
-1.4907560349,
0.2173730433,
-0.2348526269,
-0.0664646998,
-0.1694846004,
0.1494654715,
0.2335308492,
0.0000357011,
-0.7480521798,
-0.5088932514,
-0.2015404403,
0.3253395855,
0.2868154943,
-0.4365867674,
-0.1598214954,
-0.1737384051,
0.4998585582,
0.168951422,
0.4302974045,
0.4797868133,
-0.0909457803,
0.009848142,
0.3143491745,
0.7378884554,
1.3312442303,
-0.4477554262,
0.553933382,
-0.2576628923,
-0.5587872267,
-0.1739846915,
0.2310943305,
-0.5465298891,
0.3274977803,
0.4532326758,
0.3982181251,
0.3095720112,
-0.4665631652,
0.1502979398,
0.4745211899,
-0.1866693199,
-0.7292829156,
-0.3044537902,
0.177873686,
0.1385171562,
1.0534665585,
0.4411655664,
0.3194486201,
-0.9689258337,
0.1438499391,
0.2577226758,
-0.3355092406,
-0.2558668554,
0.8657062054,
-0.2201637924,
-0.030303739,
0.2571159303,
0.0789255723,
-0.0490215793,
0.5028789043,
0.8256226778,
0.6144096851,
0.2462441176,
0.2204484046,
0.4141486287,
0.3720275164,
-0.2766149938,
0.1057492942,
0.1600515544,
-0.1011683345,
-0.4434792399,
-0.6784291267,
-0.0230792034,
0.3658732474,
-0.7814329863,
-0.0285588391,
-0.1899700314,
-0.6552911997,
0.1750904173,
-0.1749849468,
-0.6964903474,
0.0540359393,
-0.1610641032,
0.778726995,
-1.0014541149,
0.5349059701,
0.4189372063,
-0.6027494669,
0.2962006032,
-0.3404441774,
0.0975560099,
-0.4484992325,
1.0089530945,
-0.0310080908,
-0.2623975277,
-0.0299347043,
-0.4824938476,
-1.1417212486,
1.1627167463,
-0.017863594,
-0.4877740443,
-0.3619853258,
-0.5244090557,
0.7579827905,
-0.2715188563,
0.0137332808,
0.4983052909,
0.5014191866,
-0.154190138,
-0.6240202785,
-0.0490304865,
-0.3805985749,
-0.1831286848,
0.3823001981,
-0.4535728693,
0.8931845427,
-0.2847264111,
-0.5233309865,
0.2224214673,
1.0031088591,
0.2953385115,
1.0915116072,
0.2465090901,
0.208322376,
0.7844342589,
0.058864601,
0.657787025,
0.058030501,
0.0553637967,
1.0406662226,
-0.1231867895,
0.871127069,
1.076000452,
-0.3187731206,
0.7457063198,
0.104474768,
-0.3265447319,
0.4985042512,
0.0272801258,
-0.1162524,
0.1883380562,
-0.0450905226,
-0.7735512257,
-0.0839001238,
0.2235210389,
-1.1459075212,
-0.1646779776,
0.0913503543,
0.5280655622,
0.1313958913,
-0.1903104782,
0.4271163046,
0.2554564178,
-0.6444558501,
0.5998929143,
-0.4235414267,
0.4777768254,
-0.4707987905,
0.1596910506,
-0.2441336513,
-0.1365703344,
-0.1952056736,
-0.4224759638,
0.6523991823,
0.0885485113,
-0.6333606839,
-0.1509829164,
0.5226348042,
-0.2228602171,
-0.3119334877,
0.1344612837,
0.6268768311,
0.4234292507,
0.1030127034,
-0.2424003184,
-0.0320240445,
-0.262185812,
-0.3633061945,
0.548528254,
0.7634024024,
-0.0771741346,
0.5828087926,
0.2449046224,
0.4063018262,
0.2212017328,
0.0590844378,
0.5139074922,
-0.878744781,
0.1984999329,
-0.8451060057,
0.0645575151,
-0.3785716295,
-0.8694525361,
0.9891857505,
0.6412140131,
0.6326538324,
-0.0568774603,
0.5925474763,
-0.3828258514,
0.3856729269,
-0.5479530692,
0.6391612291,
-0.3511384428,
0.3583573401,
-0.3599461317,
-0.8209620118,
-0.5743203163,
0.4434426427,
-0.4060832858,
0.1374566406,
0.9739931822,
0.1561947018,
0.4053650498,
0.1850127131,
-0.087339215,
0.0737944841,
0.144687891,
0.0397538953,
0.57515347,
0.0807802305,
0.6108020544,
-0.347866565,
0.0667178482,
-0.4897595048,
-1.0348205566,
-0.4551040828,
-0.5882527828,
-0.3640942276,
-0.4274944961,
0.1090735868,
0.3399264812,
-0.135517776,
-0.7247053385,
0.3195922673,
-0.110298343,
-0.0797048509,
-0.954375267,
-0.3336222172,
0.6993749142,
-0.3219614625,
-0.6271762848,
0.4574085474,
0.209952116,
-0.0787667334,
-0.2541607916,
0.4954680204,
-0.4567352235,
-0.10044875,
0.6234325767,
0.8390347958,
-0.5294805169,
-0.141289711,
0.553521812,
0.0148724634,
0.1645818204,
1.2898484468,
-0.8923208117,
0.4100748599,
0.7792419791,
0.2444986105,
0.6062318087,
0.2091462463,
0.5381415486,
-0.3215472102,
-0.1310814172,
0.8337972164,
0.4293300211,
0.3717574477,
0.1179890856,
0.5730488896,
0.605938375,
-0.9553090334,
-1.1501455307,
-0.0992709696,
-0.8115186691,
-0.5907194018,
0.4997344315,
-0.0935821235,
-0.157503441,
-0.8712085485,
0.0859610811,
-0.1172534078,
-0.3773663938,
1.3067610264,
0.8682335615,
-0.3915483057,
-0.2362729311,
-0.496412605,
0.6197325587,
0.6644070745,
-0.2483896017,
0.3692170382,
0.6290618777,
-0.0624668635,
0.7011234164,
0.6526507735,
-0.4386968017,
0.3233183324,
0.3077121973,
-0.2376945764,
-0.0525450148,
-0.4674643576,
0.0372743011,
0.6200946569,
0.2687953711,
0.6181368828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12038v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12038v3
|
Self-AMPLIFY: Improving Small Language Models with Self Post Hoc Explanations
| 2024-02-19T10:47:09 | 2024-06-17T08:52:29 |
Milan Bhan, Jean-Noel Vittaut, Nicolas Chesneau, Marie-Jeanne Lesot
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Incorporating natural language rationales in the prompt and In-Context
Learning (ICL) have led to a significant improvement of Large Language Models
(LLMs) performance. However, generating high-quality rationales require
human-annotation or the use of auxiliary proxy models. In this work, we propose
Self-AMPLIFY to automatically generate rationales from post hoc explanation
methods applied to Small Language Models (SLMs) to improve their own
performance. Self-AMPLIFY is a 3-step method that targets samples, generates
rationales and builds a final prompt to leverage ICL. Self-AMPLIFY performance
is evaluated on four SLMs and five datasets requiring strong reasoning
abilities. Self-AMPLIFY achieves good results against competitors, leading to
strong accuracy improvement. Self-AMPLIFY is the first method to apply post hoc
explanation methods to autoregressive language models to generate rationales to
improve their own performance in a fully automated manner.
|
[
-0.5783312917,
-0.7431364059,
0.6087645292,
0.3493109643,
-0.2469152808,
-0.2991094291,
-0.2487752587,
-0.121685721,
-0.0690494105,
0.509145081,
-0.5827279091,
-0.2344487458,
-0.1746557504,
0.4104751647,
-0.2935833037,
0.7697566748,
0.1244672835,
0.2374483198,
-0.2082280517,
-0.0866358876,
-0.4396842122,
-0.4486663043,
-0.5860285759,
-0.373357892,
0.3512447178,
0.6396285892,
0.3701024354,
0.8729134202,
0.1897732764,
0.3172633648,
0.2319390774,
0.2919938862,
-0.1611139327,
0.283876121,
-0.2730609477,
0.0007659091,
-0.3263677061,
-0.0080634039,
0.6648884416,
0.6578689218,
-0.1296178699,
0.372931987,
0.1105409041,
0.4465673268,
-0.3123572171,
-0.2054786533,
-0.5374720097,
-0.345392704,
0.077739194,
-0.3978557587,
-0.4955928624,
-0.2564719021,
-0.0765372887,
-0.3416413069,
0.2363018245,
0.3925028741,
0.4436670244,
0.3933806717,
-0.3268747628,
-0.2790099084,
-0.7427302599,
0.7865746617,
-1.0714352131,
0.258949995,
0.376003027,
0.4158166945,
-0.2325526029,
-0.7951217294,
-0.5943113565,
-0.1954452544,
-0.4116007686,
-0.324867487,
0.130062595,
0.2073547244,
0.4302604496,
0.4781707823,
-0.4687694013,
-0.0323732495,
-0.3380063772,
-0.2706260085,
0.909671545,
0.0141830435,
0.2418923825,
-0.3726373017,
-0.2777499259,
-0.0495307222,
-0.8934532404,
-0.0665052757,
0.1387599707,
0.2947731018,
0.210578233,
0.5614011884,
-0.2412253469,
0.6973820329,
0.4190669656,
-0.1970289946,
-0.0036234553,
-0.3854103982,
-0.4353145659,
0.3172511756,
0.6479052305,
-0.1159722432,
-0.1294683665,
0.1050563008,
-0.3105175197,
-0.1334220022,
0.0746667907,
-0.8003948331,
-0.3107245266,
0.3218987882,
-0.3748010993,
-0.0862629563,
-0.3931489885,
-0.7030779719,
-0.0468326285,
-0.5039004087,
0.8455248475,
-0.1861697584,
-0.0381361619,
0.1880960912,
0.1549626142,
0.0093993628,
0.3388699889,
-0.9447422028,
0.1403723359,
0.3028144538,
0.6863519549,
0.0077006356,
-0.4541452229,
-0.7693703771,
0.2847214341,
-0.4027050734,
0.9628667831,
-0.1084532365,
-0.3978629112,
-0.1220373884,
-0.0564010888,
0.1562135518,
-0.4134234786,
0.6269285083,
-0.2644272447,
0.4981921613,
-0.3153627515,
-0.6886535883,
0.0768285915,
-0.0304179844,
-0.4062573016,
1.0324499607,
-0.0311929211,
-0.427067399,
0.1065127179,
-0.8679563999,
-0.514736712,
0.2002733052,
0.0009563923,
-0.1344382316,
0.2075442076,
0.6627476811,
0.3543331623,
-0.1781294346,
0.2614339888,
-0.1353075802,
-0.1756435484,
-0.0008501164,
-0.371293962,
0.5911940336,
0.2773924768,
-0.453463912,
0.4271863401,
-0.6186619997,
-0.0194446612,
0.0700507164,
-0.1821676195,
-0.273394078,
-0.1326943636,
-0.6601238847,
0.4392192364,
0.1026458815,
-0.2619343102,
-0.0046091028,
-0.763756752,
0.2435763329,
0.7444204688,
0.1477480382,
0.6778948307,
-0.1496060789,
0.5824166536,
-0.0789568424,
0.0834289044,
-0.6664357781,
-0.3478877842,
-0.7224655747,
-0.2703738511,
0.0996099785,
0.02844394,
-0.7314606905,
0.1687580943,
0.0685499385,
-0.332745105,
-0.728238225,
0.3547623158,
0.1846239269,
1.0102249384,
0.7008211613,
0.3009785414,
-0.6892405748,
-0.9828892946,
-0.6243457794,
-0.2062322348,
-0.029978225,
0.2530094683,
0.3401011229,
-0.2564973831,
1.0428749323,
-0.1111446545,
-0.1750687212,
-0.3376889527,
0.6091840267,
0.0014593063,
0.5871661901,
0.2510709465,
-0.3451569974,
-0.4277922511,
-0.308583945,
-0.5746816397,
-0.6013968587,
-0.1633008868,
-0.097573109,
0.135113284,
0.5821891427,
-0.4464537799,
0.343624413,
0.4932326078,
-0.4501063824,
0.7425142527,
-0.3017387986,
0.2687894404,
-0.5139559507,
-0.1027275473,
-0.0502153449,
-0.3753849864,
-0.5188375711,
-0.1515612155,
0.063285321,
-0.2153525352,
-0.3075096309,
0.8717802763,
-0.6401255727,
-0.1117815971,
-0.5769671202,
0.4643986225,
0.1162573174,
0.3200551867,
-0.0745986104,
0.9902339578,
0.5169585347,
-0.7685924172,
0.1428670734,
0.0756489336,
0.0430533662,
0.225915134,
-0.7605527043,
-0.0218442734,
-0.1795610636,
0.2682357132,
-1.2609937191,
-0.5518988371,
0.1266153753,
-0.2220515162,
0.0118828872,
-0.1615456939,
-0.3110939264,
-0.6405642629,
0.0510272048,
0.4216766655,
0.5782480836,
-1.2027213573,
0.6951162219,
0.3102128506,
-0.1287322491,
-0.1331273764,
-0.5551649332,
-0.0545930304,
-0.3638854325,
-0.6805701852,
0.1239831522,
-0.4852426946,
-0.3709840178,
-0.3298830986,
-0.0077849808,
0.1568084061,
-0.0032163514,
0.0891942605,
0.0809239522,
-0.2823179066,
0.7146746516,
0.3149634898,
-0.1300337166,
0.284186393,
-0.4595593512,
0.2814749479,
-0.3070738912,
-0.3907271326,
-0.5137861371,
0.3219887018,
0.2621433139,
-0.1514585912,
0.5579667687,
0.365391463,
-0.2397667468,
-0.4466561973,
-0.7305330634,
-0.8481422663,
-0.539129734,
-0.2941046953,
-0.4643874764,
-0.9741950631,
0.320910722,
-0.2871507406,
-0.05708462,
0.7451377511,
0.5831250548,
-0.0525296889,
1.5279005766,
0.1668315381,
0.3566869795,
0.2158664018,
0.0940030441,
0.2806176543,
-0.6482505202,
-0.0216890648,
-0.5099083185,
0.1031304449,
-0.0921745151,
-0.4410196841,
0.0909975991,
0.2460214198,
-0.0517675094,
0.2384008765,
-0.6602188349,
0.4922061563,
0.4552665651,
-0.3326874077,
0.3389783502,
0.049268961,
-0.2454504073,
-0.2275982052,
-0.8049948215,
-0.6357930303,
0.761192441,
0.4338549972,
0.8161330819,
-0.0013890521,
0.8074576259,
0.2939502597,
0.5810540915,
-0.5770861506,
0.4904917777,
0.3867033124,
-0.7129989266,
-0.6505319476,
-0.4256940186,
-0.643691361,
0.3169322908,
-0.0146663999,
-0.537722826,
0.204409644,
0.7440257072,
-0.3963240385,
-0.2096476704,
-0.9096549153,
0.9467054009,
-0.3161664307,
-0.4726255238,
-0.2291290462,
-0.3323350549,
0.5259127617,
0.0012808942,
0.4899373651,
-0.1311296821,
0.0544745959,
0.5354756117,
-0.6272671223,
0.6428145766,
-0.2240691781,
-0.1405876279,
0.4983203411,
0.2293258607,
0.8173140883,
0.2435915172,
-0.2686295807,
-0.0794374496,
-0.2778536081,
-0.3471217752,
-0.7773319483,
0.8850780129,
-0.3621416986,
-1.0108407736,
-0.0696755946,
-0.3087844551,
-0.1234785393,
0.1378854513,
0.2049237341,
0.5706000924,
0.1968712509,
0.11967507,
0.5639635921,
-0.0592292622,
0.6915051937,
0.57151407,
-0.4508933127,
-0.4908896983,
0.606087923,
0.0998923331,
0.3168385327,
-0.2103769183,
0.5970191956,
-0.7885320187,
-0.4823123813,
-0.6495274901,
0.4016074836,
-0.9417904019,
-0.1591470391,
-0.7971026897,
0.0203262698,
-0.7656863332,
-0.1878044456,
-0.349581778,
-0.5399309397,
-0.3687436581,
-0.0802804977,
0.278488487,
0.7196316123,
-0.5208708048,
0.5305287838,
-0.3921097219,
0.4042104185,
0.6777902842,
0.1210424006,
-0.0248877462,
-0.8592425585,
-0.4651681185,
0.1000458747,
-0.0066221226,
-1.0673048496,
0.6493050456,
0.3127454221,
0.7233643532,
0.1540256888,
0.2608365417,
1.0974154472,
-0.4323332608,
0.8494041562,
0.0873086452,
-1.3955620527,
1.071341753,
-0.2887029946,
0.3763104677,
0.4037708938,
0.3466630876,
-0.1180280074,
-0.4141120315,
-0.8287372589,
-0.8211309314,
0.6907381415,
0.2776063681,
-0.1839577854,
-0.2626030743,
0.5224519372,
-0.0852466822,
0.0812847614,
-0.9357663989,
-0.2104240656,
-0.5113195181,
-0.2275332958,
-0.1205874532,
-0.4943743348,
-0.2052004486,
-0.3746998012,
1.1185588837,
-0.6127116084,
0.0240824986,
0.6645442247,
-0.2390893102,
-0.4846400023,
0.1252164692,
0.560061574,
0.6909826994,
0.1684604734,
0.3915508091,
0.5130935907,
0.2827063203,
0.2010181546,
0.0803697184,
-0.0059505035,
0.1128705218,
0.3058036864,
0.5765023828,
0.1789477319,
-0.6419751644,
0.4736739397,
-0.3021419048,
0.0392263867,
-0.2936523855,
0.16346246,
0.0648256764,
0.1387060881,
0.5515076518,
-0.2465879917,
0.4277146459,
-0.2964327037,
0.3980168402,
0.3727545738,
-0.0431932062,
-0.1898992211,
0.6741538644,
0.1841258854,
-0.5171156526,
0.133256793,
-0.3135834038,
-0.2602171898,
0.288400799,
0.8710522056,
0.7284546494,
-0.7155533433,
0.2251649052,
0.8300224543,
0.2044043392,
-0.2685422897,
0.03728972,
-0.4009393752,
-0.3492169082,
-0.7893664241,
-0.6806821823,
-0.161423251,
0.1220193729,
-0.3969422877,
0.2354364395,
-0.3313583732,
0.0796203017,
0.0588680841,
-0.0911556482,
-0.2748663127,
0.4482787848,
-0.0556028932,
0.7292419672,
-0.8220046163,
0.8470605016,
0.49075225,
-0.3006159663,
-1.0789718628,
-0.0008283926,
-0.1847163737,
-0.5214083791,
0.8173585534,
0.1803410798,
-0.2758364379,
0.3162075877,
-0.674398303,
-1.0225020647,
0.9001511931,
0.3454305828,
-0.5572974086,
0.3122164607,
-0.1074482128,
0.6168848276,
-0.8371825218,
0.2931151986,
0.4923918247,
0.5228286982,
0.1590397805,
-0.5200651884,
0.1405525208,
0.0333268456,
-0.0095282393,
-0.1047839969,
-0.0824848637,
0.5887607336,
-0.2369891554,
-0.3392774463,
-0.0123045212,
0.9773964286,
0.4646706879,
0.2692123353,
0.625518918,
0.2501686215,
0.6594257355,
0.0216689296,
0.941670537,
-0.5232573152,
0.4498004019,
1.4607731104,
0.0308573116,
0.6600740552,
0.6012397408,
0.2942377925,
0.6862553358,
0.6786558032,
0.2742793858,
0.3238874078,
-0.0189797152,
-0.4333669245,
-0.7027694583,
-0.0111902189,
-0.2322584391,
0.2205864191,
0.4337336123,
-0.5939593911,
-0.2434186935,
0.3318989575,
-0.274795711,
0.1003412828,
-0.2959088087,
0.7770459652,
0.0996018425,
-1.1246263981,
0.5185540318,
-0.1049038768,
0.0889125541,
-0.4297208488,
0.0181226954,
-0.216906324,
0.0726723522,
-0.1537416875,
-0.4865543246,
0.4971604347,
-0.3277646005,
-0.1117529646,
-0.4867066443,
1.0807322264,
-0.6476061344,
-0.339104414,
0.4365614057,
0.4067373574,
0.2837920189,
-0.0552444384,
-0.7363598943,
-0.117638275,
-0.0171434227,
-0.3587003052,
-0.0168688372,
0.5124446154,
0.1351087391,
0.783744514,
0.8739914298,
0.0598251969,
0.119716607,
0.1989227682,
0.8195914626,
-0.5362294912,
-0.5549072623,
-1.0167773962,
0.6576697826,
-0.1150201336,
-0.1211051941,
1.2395845652,
0.2813207209,
0.4900075495,
-0.1496081799,
0.5735850334,
0.2384980619,
0.8012754321,
-0.3867370188,
0.30716905,
-0.7553657889,
0.5612142086,
-0.0189892258,
-0.5549855232,
-0.1712556332,
0.7350028157,
-0.5791730881,
0.0448642299,
0.6204693913,
0.9186558723,
0.0671717674,
0.0156083284,
0.5292649865,
0.4340892136,
0.2713460028,
-0.2918817997,
0.8668424487,
-0.2473915219,
0.4549787641,
-0.4798176289,
-0.1400568485,
-0.3281350136,
-0.9662810564,
-1.143686533,
-0.4862350821,
-0.4722777605,
-0.4321359992,
-0.097639285,
0.9553461671,
1.038985014,
-0.7169803977,
-0.2039827108,
-0.408736378,
0.2434457093,
-0.0994060263,
-0.3007357717,
0.2312213928,
-0.90452528,
-0.4830720723,
0.8496261239,
0.474122256,
0.1791764349,
-0.7062373161,
-0.4022608697,
-0.1225602105,
0.4430304468,
0.7018603086,
0.3952262402,
-0.9676319361,
-0.3016333282,
-0.1808253825,
-0.0897896364,
0.1219431683,
0.8948097825,
-1.1021533012,
0.5573003292,
0.4523679018,
0.251814723,
0.3684963286,
0.3444565833,
0.6700134277,
-0.7625954747,
-0.0919567123,
0.2096517831,
0.4664496183,
0.4803009629,
-0.5223898292,
0.3531630635,
0.1110274494,
-0.8858709335,
-0.8389378786,
0.2304196507,
-0.4309746623,
-0.3342826068,
1.1414726973,
-0.1702916026,
-0.3197520077,
-0.2583816648,
-0.3129148185,
0.1297091097,
-0.2783830464,
0.8093425035,
0.3701981008,
-0.3021461368,
-0.5452609062,
-0.2027193755,
0.9506855607,
0.4340480864,
-0.9848151803,
0.2008242905,
0.627989471,
0.1162036061,
0.2050757855,
0.6079797745,
0.0366901048,
0.2906129956,
-0.1031914279,
0.0383269675,
0.052486375,
-0.4788888693,
-0.5726169348,
0.1888419688,
0.1716066897,
0.2684833407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12036v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12036v2
|
Language Model Adaptation to Specialized Domains through Selective Masking based on Genre and Topical Characteristics
| 2024-02-19T10:43:27 | 2024-02-26T16:47:36 |
Anas Belfathi, Ygor Gallina, Nicolas Hernandez, Richard Dufour, Laura Monceaux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in pre-trained language modeling have facilitated significant
progress across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Word masking
during model training constitutes a pivotal component of language modeling in
architectures like BERT. However, the prevalent method of word masking relies
on random selection, potentially disregarding domain-specific linguistic
attributes. In this article, we introduce an innovative masking approach
leveraging genre and topicality information to tailor language models to
specialized domains. Our method incorporates a ranking process that prioritizes
words based on their significance, subsequently guiding the masking procedure.
Experiments conducted using continual pre-training within the legal domain have
underscored the efficacy of our approach on the LegalGLUE benchmark in the
English language. Pre-trained language models and code are freely available for
use.
|
[
-0.443243593,
-0.6960791945,
0.3840674162,
0.3237878978,
-0.5645086169,
0.3280182183,
-0.2458648086,
-0.4577569366,
0.4033373594,
0.9787645936,
-0.357499212,
-0.7439072132,
-0.8772455454,
-0.3198775053,
-0.2765574157,
1.0956548452,
0.2765942514,
-0.0781528577,
-0.2077250332,
-0.2917771935,
-0.6084721684,
-0.9067658186,
-0.6043255329,
-0.2624305487,
0.2299645245,
-0.1848133355,
0.4932835996,
0.4395362735,
0.5558114648,
0.2583014369,
0.1458908319,
-0.1282571554,
-0.4278452098,
0.1451378465,
-0.4165615439,
-0.5341604948,
-0.4185589254,
0.1709975302,
0.5322732925,
0.6415709257,
-0.2727749944,
0.0049194819,
-0.298006475,
0.4420037568,
-0.6026389003,
-0.2637796402,
-1.2244756222,
0.0905945301,
-0.5294200778,
-0.2890988588,
-0.3898163736,
-0.1059045494,
0.2136783004,
-0.5584219694,
0.487598598,
0.1730986536,
0.969325006,
0.1212112978,
-0.0177568179,
-0.115402177,
-0.7563939691,
0.6382726431,
-0.6986117959,
0.3594667315,
0.5270401239,
0.321782738,
0.1206910536,
-0.9566446543,
-0.2823654413,
-0.3723265529,
0.0494821295,
0.0318880454,
-0.1626466215,
0.1386909485,
-0.0179464575,
0.0961968079,
-0.5107242465,
0.1302634627,
-0.2530193031,
-0.2804549038,
0.5709558129,
-0.3019338548,
0.4287544787,
0.2423114181,
-0.3989856541,
0.0977493748,
-0.7092453837,
0.0605654679,
0.3360133469,
0.3078267574,
0.444044292,
0.2217683196,
-0.1131111085,
0.6969833374,
0.0290166307,
-0.1350729167,
0.1213471889,
0.162120685,
-0.3466474116,
0.0117378449,
0.2645564973,
0.0091805449,
0.2274317145,
-0.3841683865,
-0.5413780808,
-0.0754509419,
0.7761829495,
-0.5868326426,
-0.2585779727,
0.1102921143,
-0.2613729537,
-0.2448372096,
0.013038083,
-0.3808085322,
-0.3201142848,
-0.3255631328,
0.6214444041,
-0.2161247134,
-0.1443590075,
0.4044750929,
-0.0328449979,
-0.1515140384,
0.2673596442,
-0.8893659115,
0.5726847053,
0.7579218149,
0.5224635005,
-0.4683940411,
-0.0433911048,
-0.4517234266,
0.2494275421,
-0.2977872193,
0.8730344176,
-1.0539315939,
-0.1246613711,
0.1194128394,
-0.0283964518,
-0.2131001055,
-0.7374053001,
0.4181059599,
-1.0740362406,
-0.0671593249,
0.2014025599,
-0.3888405859,
-0.3561351895,
0.0605374761,
-0.5028942823,
0.9000247717,
0.2386832535,
-0.5287075043,
0.7057163119,
-0.4966208637,
-0.4220819473,
0.4441386759,
0.0670177564,
-0.520585835,
0.1203381047,
0.2132595778,
0.3727317452,
0.0918394998,
0.5702999234,
-0.1591890156,
-0.2215274423,
0.1828680933,
0.0972389355,
0.6738164425,
0.2712447047,
-0.3210314214,
0.4363716245,
-0.6637358665,
-0.049478747,
-0.0592447892,
-0.049372524,
-0.6021362543,
0.0480767898,
0.1491530389,
0.2660334408,
0.0565247983,
-0.290902704,
-0.0697444305,
-0.4386783242,
0.2794291377,
0.6367465258,
0.0768600553,
0.5501850247,
-0.3485845625,
0.9119720459,
0.0894866586,
-0.0941198543,
0.3060895801,
-0.6501894593,
-0.7677605152,
-0.5903691053,
0.8043447137,
0.7084715962,
-0.6113087535,
0.5013331771,
-0.3039542735,
-0.4731670022,
-0.6796361804,
0.0419983827,
0.2505801022,
0.047203064,
0.2392516434,
-0.9231159091,
-0.5032160878,
-0.9250171185,
-0.4165990651,
0.1130782813,
-0.2718010545,
0.2867927849,
0.3104355037,
-0.2211796343,
1.0905983448,
-0.5418891311,
-0.6023089886,
-0.3459511399,
0.3924699426,
0.0610579252,
0.4268784225,
0.9639686942,
-0.7933179736,
-0.5069026947,
-0.130273059,
-0.1229789034,
-0.4227529764,
-0.1591165662,
-0.2626838386,
-0.0242395084,
0.5897844434,
-0.2812978327,
0.2579223514,
0.2826472819,
-0.0715901628,
0.5108793974,
-0.2003420442,
0.02799863,
-0.6642746925,
0.0320634358,
-0.0299076904,
-0.7184103727,
-0.8785442114,
0.4759140909,
-0.3754921257,
-0.1747466773,
-0.469263643,
0.6163958907,
-0.4638241827,
0.0226287525,
-0.3988596797,
0.0685049966,
-0.0293199457,
0.4778833389,
0.5309505463,
0.6204319,
0.7520916462,
-0.6173186898,
-0.0847709551,
-0.0499171875,
-0.5533034801,
0.2265049815,
-0.448326081,
0.3444697857,
-0.1250315756,
0.0493782386,
-0.6335004568,
0.0791706443,
0.2102308124,
-0.1049226299,
0.5492896438,
-0.3519684076,
-0.2631419897,
-0.2342033386,
-0.1314320564,
0.4322295487,
0.6314636469,
-0.0375948288,
0.453886956,
0.8770750165,
-0.5063592196,
-0.4709849358,
-0.3720726371,
0.2368163168,
-0.4319475889,
-0.3651574254,
0.79286623,
-0.09387099,
-0.0595208667,
-0.0814852342,
-0.0123012187,
-0.6150733232,
0.3315455019,
0.0287953522,
-0.0706945658,
-0.3828728795,
0.0254493132,
0.0240438059,
0.0797743127,
0.0237001032,
-0.4011175931,
0.5441939831,
0.1580884159,
-0.1412948966,
0.2081281841,
0.4224129617,
0.2441827208,
-0.5773041844,
0.6701751947,
0.524512887,
-0.4853075147,
-0.7225612402,
-0.6565865278,
-0.1199596599,
-0.5055868626,
0.509861052,
-0.425005883,
-1.0813947916,
0.5364223719,
-0.0093772449,
-0.0788444206,
0.3311009705,
0.5714545846,
0.1985484809,
0.6468778253,
1.140689373,
-0.0729175508,
0.6346178651,
0.3102918565,
0.5903820992,
-0.436440289,
0.0687076822,
-0.4512629509,
-0.0598407015,
-0.477460295,
-0.6551522613,
0.2434355021,
0.1600172669,
0.169519484,
0.4808956981,
-0.6866586208,
0.5564489365,
0.6193940043,
0.1215114146,
0.0738361105,
0.3568237722,
-0.015243534,
-0.2272554934,
-0.6215879321,
-0.5578279495,
1.0156573057,
0.3689866364,
0.3968337774,
-0.0246156435,
0.7199633121,
0.5220915079,
0.6744740009,
-0.5456157923,
0.5715359449,
-0.4583998322,
-0.8814628124,
-0.3831427097,
0.0658504665,
-0.9547541142,
0.4317834973,
-0.3650800288,
-0.9182766676,
0.1849277616,
-0.1632748693,
-0.50249964,
0.1819589436,
-0.3197414279,
0.6136214137,
0.1946835965,
-0.059927687,
-0.3021318018,
-0.6065608859,
0.3409154713,
-0.6095982194,
0.4002590477,
-0.3132523894,
0.1479603648,
0.9039638638,
-0.0389604904,
0.8593264818,
-0.1540259868,
0.0664890558,
0.312743634,
0.1597211361,
0.0697273836,
0.0393653177,
-0.0160287786,
0.1780059189,
-0.0108209923,
-0.369256407,
-0.3888207376,
0.4392869174,
-0.5437641144,
-1.0873434544,
-0.3834863007,
-0.5107070804,
-0.329254359,
0.3638405502,
0.1103915498,
0.180466339,
-0.3253893852,
0.0282116365,
0.8868058324,
-0.2642810941,
0.2472514957,
0.7267326713,
-0.2816838622,
-0.1699951738,
1.0058213472,
0.2298680842,
0.0998801738,
0.517483592,
0.0500597097,
-0.0940676406,
-1.0146491528,
-0.0964488536,
0.2172326744,
-0.8471382856,
-0.0658014044,
-0.923530519,
-0.5898726583,
-0.5626782775,
-0.2944768965,
-0.0660541952,
-0.4233316183,
-0.1014535576,
-0.0111680925,
0.0391797312,
0.7072815895,
0.2761900723,
0.2067284733,
-0.718916893,
0.4479573667,
0.5164212584,
0.453311801,
-0.3692325354,
-0.8357467055,
-0.1473470777,
-0.2149355114,
-0.2149935663,
-0.5911986828,
0.4395693541,
0.5495306849,
0.8313103318,
0.2235240489,
0.0964459851,
0.3087196052,
-0.9587751031,
0.8448384404,
-0.0961797237,
-1.0225419998,
0.6904959679,
-0.3760862052,
-0.0033232684,
0.5996221304,
0.3321718276,
-0.411483556,
-0.8989420533,
-0.5953202248,
-1.0027480125,
0.5459771156,
0.1245025769,
0.4813186228,
0.0838902295,
0.2774064541,
0.3209472895,
0.4550450742,
-1.1451745033,
0.0382399336,
-0.1353454143,
0.059586741,
0.0637050867,
-0.3932347298,
-0.3614983857,
-0.1914041489,
0.6434631944,
0.1005825326,
0.2775944471,
-0.0445758887,
-0.5756329894,
0.2284764051,
0.2642903328,
0.9638972878,
0.8847186565,
-0.2879580855,
-0.0051355273,
-0.148993507,
-0.7110633254,
0.0908561647,
-0.0206994787,
-0.0869301483,
0.3513940573,
0.4356971383,
0.7478739023,
0.1664203554,
-0.4768673182,
0.65282619,
0.2922345698,
-0.167094633,
-0.0192494504,
0.2307555377,
-0.0592328086,
-0.1031287014,
0.3119251728,
0.1965104192,
0.2528047562,
-0.4745437205,
0.483060658,
0.3505794108,
-0.284820646,
-0.2651647627,
0.7518422008,
0.1958887577,
-0.3737044632,
0.1198133007,
-0.1653866023,
-0.6489440203,
0.6798536181,
0.639686048,
1.0956543684,
-0.4030223489,
0.3147356212,
0.1306305081,
0.3423947394,
0.0482099205,
-0.0441640243,
0.1337700039,
-0.7946245074,
-0.286434114,
-0.9051456451,
-0.1981641799,
0.1604889035,
-0.6000779271,
0.1916425526,
-0.715318799,
-0.3052583635,
0.1374842376,
-0.3288362026,
-0.6728138328,
0.54037112,
0.3747135997,
0.8894737959,
-1.0208181143,
1.192404747,
0.7533567548,
-0.1318743378,
-0.256447643,
0.1914030313,
-0.399897635,
-0.8736953139,
0.9111527205,
0.1143920124,
-0.1489121765,
0.0246961098,
-0.4083579481,
-0.8257786632,
0.5647223592,
0.2803597152,
-0.372141391,
0.1983380914,
0.2780581713,
0.7294698358,
-0.7944192886,
-0.0569564663,
0.5566300154,
0.1700653583,
-0.1308767945,
-0.7491654158,
0.0459917039,
-0.2697254121,
0.2791553438,
-0.021922037,
-0.2232466638,
0.5122406483,
0.2125884444,
-0.1939547658,
-0.2263919562,
0.5356352925,
0.2441393137,
0.1695947051,
0.6234841347,
0.4812053442,
0.6899931431,
-0.0609399825,
0.7285960317,
-0.3232224584,
0.1618593335,
0.9888545871,
-0.4882478714,
0.8455924392,
0.2364575863,
-0.3407142758,
0.6542958617,
0.7040535808,
-0.0149317272,
1.0233280659,
0.5973940492,
-0.322339952,
-0.3800104558,
-0.2059127688,
-0.366876334,
0.4101060033,
0.4085709751,
-0.1555156559,
0.0341284834,
0.2052211612,
-0.1772833019,
0.2536445856,
-0.3288091421,
0.752874136,
0.1594619602,
-0.6663905382,
0.3925722837,
0.3307514489,
0.724563241,
-0.8242159486,
0.0672550201,
-0.1551957279,
-0.2704358697,
0.0276634526,
-0.389993906,
0.3482937217,
-0.176674664,
-0.334226191,
-0.5419797897,
0.8745691776,
-0.5742778182,
-0.5282731056,
0.2657054067,
0.2294821143,
0.157829091,
-0.188266024,
-0.6439611316,
-0.1730778962,
-0.3622709215,
-0.1634292901,
0.6292943954,
0.4223754406,
-0.4485679865,
0.6190750599,
0.5830373168,
0.2228760868,
0.2453821301,
0.4663203955,
0.8560082912,
-0.4824239314,
-0.9810914397,
-0.4106422961,
0.50286901,
-0.0719735771,
-0.1636585444,
0.3579873145,
0.2550018728,
0.7664810419,
-0.4187440872,
0.567538619,
0.1257279068,
0.3812329173,
-0.7544547915,
1.0708338022,
-0.3938592672,
0.4357113242,
-0.2833710611,
-1.134811759,
-0.5778301954,
0.5555835962,
-0.2860558629,
0.137180075,
0.7286200523,
0.8141126037,
-0.1923920214,
-0.4615717828,
0.7367714047,
-0.0369185321,
0.2206457257,
0.1998691708,
0.3572637737,
-0.0151015334,
-0.0002910257,
-0.1067956015,
-0.2535445094,
-0.2769093812,
-1.0007154942,
-1.075086832,
-0.618982017,
-0.5538425446,
-0.0506478325,
0.1639146507,
0.6051438451,
1.1305394173,
-1.1974728107,
-0.0204138309,
0.1562930048,
-0.0038629549,
-0.2924743891,
-0.2264402956,
0.2343557924,
-0.5878719091,
-0.4793086052,
0.3779473007,
0.3489837348,
-0.1221707836,
-0.0650586858,
0.3501409292,
-0.195822686,
0.4602536857,
0.5880583525,
-0.0367146358,
-0.9836760163,
-0.4655387998,
-0.2957774401,
-0.1341788024,
0.1433376819,
1.2506016493,
-0.5644524693,
0.5360146165,
0.1786232144,
0.7623738647,
0.3011333048,
-0.1447965354,
0.7590369582,
-1.0883355141,
0.4539602995,
0.583966136,
0.1721331179,
0.2002316564,
-0.504555881,
0.4773183167,
0.3394113481,
-0.342939198,
-0.8859140873,
0.1773449183,
-0.8091607094,
-0.6192921996,
0.9145689607,
-0.4041981995,
-0.0180496518,
-0.3949509561,
-0.0698063299,
-0.0642271563,
-0.040856529,
0.9407417178,
0.9944871068,
0.3750315011,
-0.1686894894,
-0.7426759601,
0.7202224731,
0.5528110862,
-0.6463795304,
-0.2815784216,
-0.0340630785,
0.5365940332,
0.0762045458,
0.9040441513,
-0.0079072891,
0.186274156,
-0.2219034731,
0.1389319748,
0.2299344093,
-0.4782473147,
-0.3923130631,
0.3216788769,
0.2745408714,
-0.0615398698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12030v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12030v2
|
Towards Cross-Tokenizer Distillation: the Universal Logit Distillation Loss for LLMs
| 2024-02-19T10:37:29 | 2024-02-20T14:46:03 |
Nicolas Boizard, Kevin El Haddad, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deploying large language models (LLMs) of several billion parameters can be
impractical in most industrial use cases due to constraints such as cost,
latency limitations, and hardware accessibility. Knowledge distillation (KD)
offers a solution by compressing knowledge from resource-intensive large models
to smaller ones. Various strategies exist, some relying on the text generated
by the teacher model and optionally utilizing his logits to enhance learning.
However, these methods based on logits often require both teacher and student
models to share the same tokenizer, limiting their applicability across
different LLM families. In this paper, we introduce Universal Logit
Distillation (ULD) loss, grounded in optimal transport, to address this
limitation. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of ULD loss
in enabling distillation across models with different architectures and
tokenizers, paving the way to a more widespread use of distillation techniques.
|
[
-0.0544389077,
-0.3411958814,
0.8998414278,
0.0594483986,
-0.5448198318,
0.1969665289,
-0.1071871296,
-0.1423490793,
-0.13439022,
0.2830489278,
-0.0835439414,
-0.2871488631,
-0.5878524184,
-0.1643024534,
-0.5582829714,
1.0037782192,
-0.3009299934,
0.2546550333,
-0.4701091051,
-0.1946641505,
-0.6485728025,
-0.9737870693,
-0.6941399574,
-0.6680077314,
0.5328082442,
0.2046898901,
0.3695966005,
0.3500818908,
0.2200808227,
0.1651118249,
-0.4041588902,
-0.1561572999,
-0.4500744641,
0.0176632255,
-0.3598338366,
-0.9621908665,
-0.0278814733,
-0.1713296473,
0.5602226257,
0.8844296932,
-0.2791938186,
0.1127725244,
0.3455345631,
0.7021571398,
-0.7139860988,
-0.172244519,
-0.775118649,
0.3300874233,
-0.043661233,
-0.1394222677,
-0.4491109252,
-0.1249821112,
0.008771481,
-0.3163273335,
0.1272452474,
0.2202468514,
0.6492156386,
0.300858289,
-0.8382353783,
-0.221689716,
-1.035620451,
0.7097799182,
-0.7233021855,
0.5810464621,
-0.0444467328,
0.3955842555,
-0.0741770044,
-0.7247713208,
-0.4115414023,
0.1639028937,
-0.2333998084,
-0.0712813959,
-0.3395921886,
0.2351968139,
-0.2144090682,
0.1947470456,
-0.2510506213,
0.2539370954,
-0.376661092,
-0.1613013446,
0.2479174882,
0.3161651194,
0.0330145583,
0.093495667,
-0.55730021,
-0.0108962376,
-0.8819582462,
-0.0745435059,
0.2881405056,
0.0932954848,
0.2791780829,
0.3253640532,
0.0082588196,
0.5254814029,
-0.0528505892,
-0.2446394116,
-0.2629016936,
-0.4858653545,
-0.3570676446,
0.3248291314,
0.720164001,
0.3751106858,
0.0034767322,
-0.2263201475,
-0.2902475893,
-0.2957951725,
-0.2025829554,
-1.0097355843,
-0.3057186306,
-0.0731964409,
-0.4072170556,
-0.369735837,
-0.142846778,
-0.4668328762,
-0.3572432995,
-0.2503105104,
0.5678096414,
-0.0236229356,
-0.2580219209,
0.1292093247,
-0.4970439076,
-0.0240323395,
0.000054166,
-1.1813793182,
0.3229629099,
0.4500998855,
1.1139177084,
-0.3051301837,
-0.0148067856,
-0.1845805198,
0.5443503261,
-0.1913763434,
0.5330967307,
-0.3328114152,
-0.7301964164,
-0.4106895924,
-0.213384375,
-0.0342332609,
-0.7785339355,
0.5402166247,
-0.3879460394,
-0.0506589115,
-0.2313769311,
-0.7765949368,
-0.2926009595,
-0.1446929723,
-0.5107219815,
0.8787898421,
0.0491528884,
-0.7026481628,
0.5438714027,
-0.5093470812,
-0.4404169619,
-0.1178953499,
-0.2744698524,
-0.3131200075,
0.6252710819,
0.0948162004,
0.7661648393,
-0.4215678871,
0.6294650435,
-0.2152085155,
-0.1488945931,
-0.0837534443,
-0.8823648095,
0.9002162814,
0.2666621208,
-0.29775846,
-0.1154582202,
-0.7269127965,
-0.3471574485,
0.0009202316,
-0.6388822794,
-0.9542167187,
-0.1736069322,
0.373973608,
-0.0584238283,
0.1244764179,
-0.6403543949,
0.3356100023,
0.1038717777,
0.6090837121,
1.1191033125,
-0.1558086276,
0.5196272135,
-0.214261502,
0.483944416,
0.247465536,
0.3005742729,
0.1198594421,
-0.3236184716,
-0.7980189323,
-0.2141684741,
0.3393093646,
0.3280217648,
-0.4197115004,
0.1934508085,
-0.3276689351,
-0.4857338369,
-0.3872132897,
0.2474384308,
0.0919321924,
0.5251372457,
0.0591244698,
0.0333526172,
-0.7518761754,
-0.7510587573,
-0.1497079879,
-0.3832090199,
-0.0038018981,
0.0562466756,
0.3265089095,
-0.1766810715,
0.982589066,
-0.453615576,
-0.4942649305,
-0.4808781743,
-0.1658664495,
0.2132909149,
0.4430015087,
0.5915712118,
-0.7439619899,
-0.7431692481,
0.3761877418,
-0.6149382591,
-0.1309166551,
-0.2416671067,
-0.1545539349,
0.2596577108,
0.632741034,
-0.6641175747,
0.4873438776,
0.8128304482,
-0.4475030303,
0.465536952,
-0.2554044127,
0.0269453842,
-1.2506468296,
0.1245581433,
-0.4065408111,
-0.3314586282,
-0.5044897199,
-0.1193155274,
-0.1941272616,
-0.0798619837,
-0.4920181036,
0.6497591734,
-0.2981815338,
0.0242091231,
-0.168548435,
0.0082081724,
0.4194825292,
0.2030102462,
-0.0712021217,
0.7165213823,
0.4587552845,
-0.5098656416,
0.6413362622,
-0.0106863342,
-0.2363054752,
0.6944021583,
-0.7654356956,
-0.1525871456,
-0.0489123687,
0.425619632,
-1.1924589872,
0.2965996265,
0.0108014196,
-0.128076151,
0.2775694728,
-0.1704535186,
-0.4768994749,
-0.2031265795,
-0.0747493282,
0.4144848585,
0.8277313113,
-0.8310942054,
0.9919514656,
0.0864195079,
0.1311016381,
-0.4315738976,
-0.9201899171,
0.3010939062,
-0.7027705908,
-0.6259932518,
0.1661231816,
-0.2403091788,
-0.0859958082,
0.2249927819,
-0.5505371094,
-0.1081128195,
0.1727109551,
0.2824893892,
0.3387275338,
-0.1167740375,
0.351326406,
0.3127798438,
-0.0601889715,
0.0613523349,
-0.7278758883,
0.5777087808,
0.2646791339,
-0.4539420009,
-0.7209397554,
0.3056894839,
0.6294385195,
0.2498939782,
0.9427615404,
0.5219046474,
-0.0212051738,
-0.1874985248,
-0.7151105404,
-0.0730707943,
-0.5245713592,
0.447201848,
-0.6569298506,
-0.8644017577,
0.5566607714,
-0.4162226319,
0.083047919,
0.2149572968,
0.351003319,
-0.063604176,
0.8597328663,
0.9539074302,
-0.5513936877,
0.24940826,
-0.2626782954,
0.5056065321,
-0.6786295176,
-0.4159379005,
-0.6664786935,
-0.4178868532,
-0.1044531763,
-0.2420675308,
0.4028158784,
0.345153302,
0.0454313159,
0.212049216,
-0.4558562934,
0.7944005132,
0.7980709672,
-0.2063488215,
0.8637396693,
0.181079939,
-0.5887297392,
0.2070872039,
-1.2712957859,
-0.4871187806,
1.2690230608,
0.3275865614,
1.0019277334,
-0.146431461,
1.1911484003,
0.1782093197,
0.3010015488,
-0.6830229759,
0.5819242001,
-0.1779131591,
-0.8316418529,
-0.4204268456,
-0.5275645256,
-0.7526692152,
0.4344699681,
0.1918050945,
-0.4450774193,
0.1793373227,
0.1892542988,
-0.2016888708,
1.0753080845,
-0.7875205278,
0.8642140031,
-0.1803181618,
0.0617534705,
-0.2507291734,
-0.3877816796,
0.4256146848,
-0.2626436353,
0.434653163,
0.0317740589,
-0.1149032712,
0.6997336149,
-0.7269693017,
0.835013628,
-0.2814026475,
-0.3972732723,
0.3115938902,
0.0734301209,
0.3948084712,
-0.2236774564,
0.1356976479,
0.2762666643,
0.2200352699,
-0.3524232209,
-0.8208087683,
0.7817057967,
-0.7545859814,
-0.7478381991,
-0.1358837485,
-0.2866863608,
0.1365723759,
0.1009301841,
0.2702744305,
0.1519477665,
-0.1740013212,
0.1271621883,
0.6639143825,
0.0403008759,
0.7123187184,
0.3610078394,
-0.3152902722,
-0.0950259417,
0.8989463449,
0.1045178473,
0.5357212424,
0.3711800575,
0.4783543348,
-0.428988874,
-0.7543287277,
-0.5360347033,
0.0594778582,
-1.1884634495,
-0.1212350577,
-0.4493479431,
-0.1316053569,
-0.3073051274,
-0.2967870533,
-0.3960980177,
-0.5186007619,
-0.5273197889,
-0.4066556096,
0.3005161285,
0.8053482771,
-0.3670383692,
0.3523375392,
-0.8763947487,
0.003364251,
0.5156286359,
0.2911636829,
0.3495225608,
-0.6712628603,
-0.2836279273,
0.0345166847,
-0.2215074897,
-0.5401628613,
0.0494909659,
0.4414682686,
0.5920192599,
0.5161654353,
0.2753387392,
0.8723298311,
-0.6231683493,
0.6252644658,
0.6251538992,
-1.0614899397,
0.2816641927,
0.1504081339,
0.2401172221,
0.4797505736,
0.6571488976,
-0.7812347412,
-0.4153000116,
-0.3087756634,
-1.0551708937,
0.248332873,
-0.001241829,
0.4535168409,
0.3181902468,
0.2069200128,
0.3354053795,
0.045471102,
-0.8886464834,
-0.34065485,
0.0608198121,
-0.3513995707,
-0.1097288504,
-0.1112524793,
-0.0319667943,
-0.3979509473,
0.9254812598,
0.3553510308,
-0.3272827566,
0.1348766685,
-0.0256023109,
0.0987900347,
0.3350881934,
0.0917206705,
0.4859338403,
0.0370457806,
0.4831675291,
0.1821825057,
-0.5088590384,
0.8378003836,
-0.2984886765,
-0.3151035011,
0.3329344988,
0.0172760561,
0.9265006185,
-0.0119669633,
-0.6816410422,
0.3231443763,
-0.1291347593,
-0.3187840283,
-0.057200022,
0.1133652702,
0.3803259432,
0.453214407,
0.5763234496,
-0.0060394565,
0.2019789964,
-0.509296,
0.0502542108,
0.3655997217,
-0.4284163713,
-0.0799121708,
1.1168452501,
0.4035383165,
-0.1424944103,
0.402613312,
-0.0163595099,
-0.2785221934,
0.3066516817,
0.3804682493,
0.9813652635,
-0.2116245031,
0.095621556,
0.0364941359,
0.2733560503,
-0.1935383379,
-0.3179061115,
-0.1533782482,
-0.5297427177,
-0.2580163777,
-0.7425387502,
-0.2008192539,
-0.0627720878,
-0.3822789788,
0.1822981089,
-0.4176820219,
-0.2405314744,
-0.1099830493,
-0.4279810488,
-0.5319150686,
-0.2685923278,
-0.0028161777,
0.6520093083,
-1.0518813133,
0.8895110488,
0.5292170644,
-0.2862741947,
-0.8422989845,
-0.3130460083,
-0.0853429139,
-0.502094388,
1.128125906,
-0.0820581093,
-0.0021281103,
0.0984434634,
-0.3355980515,
-0.516002655,
1.3404113054,
0.4064050317,
-1.0021467209,
-0.2280322611,
0.5550090671,
0.1670894772,
-0.1229771674,
0.0266831908,
0.6572722197,
0.3802289367,
0.2386228442,
-1.1741700172,
0.2047254443,
0.1183701903,
0.3021866083,
0.2600357234,
-0.7422412038,
0.7703297734,
-0.1040973514,
-0.2511049211,
-0.1257825941,
0.4733420908,
0.0465233549,
0.3801748157,
0.5409732461,
0.730178833,
0.567553103,
0.1395842284,
0.5738236308,
-0.1550317854,
0.3366931677,
0.9879871011,
-0.1943872571,
0.6811313033,
1.0557215214,
-0.4038767219,
0.2378029376,
0.3505617678,
0.1706848443,
0.5893111825,
0.5843541622,
-0.6794678569,
-0.0919782594,
-0.2054134905,
-0.1988059282,
0.2166920602,
-0.041219037,
-0.1230291501,
-0.3839391768,
0.409917444,
0.2259952724,
0.0006187699,
-0.19098185,
0.6531354189,
0.1505147219,
-0.229996264,
0.9112212062,
-0.0836630911,
0.9125661254,
-0.5295184851,
0.1531911939,
-0.5217862129,
0.147146374,
-0.0828504935,
-0.2767950594,
0.3303039074,
-0.1427485049,
-0.0962850004,
-0.3501798213,
0.5198904276,
-0.6003415585,
-0.618391633,
0.3965106606,
0.2894212008,
0.3069622219,
-0.0098531917,
-0.1838790923,
0.1771793664,
0.2247957587,
-0.1961293072,
0.5334402323,
0.6498184204,
0.1835452318,
0.9277798533,
0.4587226808,
0.1308344752,
0.3284789026,
-0.0519177616,
1.0852339268,
-0.3386028111,
-0.3061102331,
-1.1478869915,
0.5302177072,
0.0810524002,
0.016681429,
0.8172050118,
0.680555582,
1.0033552647,
-0.0910330862,
1.0829087496,
0.0151545387,
0.1658444703,
-0.5983717442,
0.8624581099,
-0.6999724507,
0.5438358784,
-0.2224835753,
-1.1832102537,
-0.1240700036,
0.3673408329,
0.3381156325,
-0.2674221098,
0.7635108232,
0.4510850608,
-0.1893437058,
-0.3048885763,
0.6718181968,
0.0089160316,
0.608002007,
0.7839697599,
0.6638073921,
-0.4372898936,
0.8356221914,
-0.2252264023,
-0.0257247817,
-0.3105360866,
-0.9042069316,
-1.242636919,
-0.6050056815,
-0.3074582517,
0.0243975446,
0.2734028995,
0.6514441967,
0.7022730112,
-0.5858386159,
-0.5497733951,
-0.2817650139,
0.268977493,
0.204615131,
-0.1769972444,
0.3296989799,
-0.2940297723,
-0.7427672148,
0.0876420885,
0.1383384913,
0.4876390398,
-0.4968315065,
-0.0381121375,
-0.1046742871,
0.0977390483,
0.5147591233,
-0.0681084022,
-0.6040169597,
-0.2365762293,
-0.2043025941,
0.2291602939,
-0.1016109809,
1.0246399641,
-0.76279217,
0.2563866377,
0.4624942541,
0.7822312117,
0.5118811727,
-0.2821815014,
0.5712922812,
-0.746419251,
0.3013066053,
0.0824388638,
0.2949965894,
0.0693158135,
-0.2764333189,
0.4119972289,
0.4869432151,
-0.5986193419,
-0.9651539922,
0.0822159052,
-0.566855073,
-0.5463067889,
1.0253871679,
-0.3873869777,
-0.015558931,
-0.1582097113,
-0.3809065819,
0.1600535959,
-0.3634602427,
0.7307575941,
0.9052228332,
-0.0030562405,
-0.1205569729,
-0.4478451014,
0.3882175982,
0.5618869066,
-0.5464758277,
0.2856625319,
0.3112861216,
0.4830266833,
-0.1108222306,
0.6180424094,
0.1347466111,
-0.3673909605,
0.0371011347,
0.1829389483,
-0.1061808914,
-0.4389569163,
-0.2408292592,
-0.1026648656,
0.2038614899,
-0.2043442875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12026v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12026v3
|
Acquiring Clean Language Models from Backdoor Poisoned Datasets by Downscaling Frequency Space
| 2024-02-19T10:34:48 | 2024-06-02T10:28:13 |
Zongru Wu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Pengzhou Cheng, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Despite the notable success of language models (LMs) in various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks, the reliability of LMs is susceptible to
backdoor attacks. Prior research attempts to mitigate backdoor learning while
training the LMs on the poisoned dataset, yet struggles against complex
backdoor attacks in real-world scenarios. In this paper, we investigate the
learning mechanisms of backdoor LMs in the frequency space by Fourier analysis.
Our findings indicate that the backdoor mapping presented on the poisoned
datasets exhibits a more discernible inclination towards lower frequency
compared to clean mapping, resulting in the faster convergence of backdoor
mapping. To alleviate this dilemma, we propose Multi-Scale Low-Rank Adaptation
(MuScleLoRA), which deploys multiple radial scalings in the frequency space
with low-rank adaptation to the target model and further aligns the gradients
when updating parameters. Through downscaling in the frequency space,
MuScleLoRA encourages the model to prioritize the learning of relatively
high-frequency clean mapping, consequently mitigating backdoor learning.
Experimental results demonstrate that MuScleLoRA outperforms baselines
significantly. Notably, MuScleLoRA reduces the average success rate of diverse
backdoor attacks to below 15\% across multiple datasets and generalizes to
various backbone LMs, including BERT, RoBERTa, GPT2-XL, and Llama2. The codes
are publicly available at https://github.com/ZrW00/MuScleLoRA.
|
[
-0.3064527512,
-0.4535143673,
0.2384527326,
0.0154933799,
0.1444613039,
-0.1302320659,
-0.5017591119,
-0.1757141203,
-0.2187860906,
0.5757209063,
-0.4368156493,
-0.7913636565,
-0.4890121818,
-0.1098835468,
-0.2043071538,
1.0587798357,
0.4184734523,
0.0936349034,
0.5271431208,
-0.2299575061,
-0.7810145617,
-0.5660647154,
-0.6081042886,
-0.3125101924,
0.6386727095,
0.5184748173,
0.8285266757,
0.2202183902,
0.3267875016,
0.296482563,
0.1570184827,
-0.2775723934,
-0.9018805623,
0.2671250403,
-0.3338153064,
-0.5015638471,
-0.3957694173,
0.0105018867,
0.4792869091,
0.4491746128,
-0.4184411168,
0.3705121875,
-0.1252846271,
0.8095300198,
-0.6629405618,
0.0565856025,
-1.0063452721,
0.0291388836,
-0.2744813561,
-0.2633765638,
-0.5972827673,
-0.20497033,
-0.3622861505,
-0.4364397824,
0.0161992181,
0.1582773179,
0.6097149849,
0.268378824,
-0.21402134,
0.0094047608,
-0.6295744181,
0.6822643876,
-0.820769906,
0.8136125207,
0.3779421449,
0.4397869408,
-0.5202080607,
-0.3902890086,
-0.4075258672,
-0.2479768097,
0.0165936109,
-0.1258357167,
-0.2607298791,
-0.0909288228,
0.2999132872,
0.1079522669,
-0.7628404498,
0.3752668202,
-0.6685928702,
-0.1472087055,
0.5257791877,
-0.1041228026,
0.3665701747,
-0.1662636101,
-0.1922646165,
-0.5115100741,
-0.908257246,
0.0204513334,
0.3919821382,
0.7269082069,
-0.3319405317,
0.1785542369,
0.1079901829,
0.501434207,
-0.0078665996,
-0.1589167118,
0.3888024688,
-0.120930545,
-0.2946705818,
0.2067867368,
0.4267127216,
-0.0069537875,
0.4775775075,
-0.2090754658,
-0.280135721,
-0.264623791,
0.5647004247,
-0.8071309328,
-0.2263414562,
0.5014936924,
-0.4996097088,
-0.1936028451,
-0.2527886629,
-1.0647104979,
-0.4288623035,
-0.0077654533,
0.6087501645,
-0.4071990252,
-0.2354336828,
0.1193819642,
-0.2496913075,
0.2252781093,
0.2330227792,
-1.0659410954,
0.5224328637,
0.7817490101,
0.7772513628,
0.1406561285,
-0.1673924178,
-0.6351485252,
-0.0327516533,
-0.3369555175,
0.2749422491,
-0.4582292736,
-0.2325266749,
-0.193254143,
-0.1166976094,
-0.3659208715,
-0.6356540322,
0.0932783112,
-0.9630054235,
0.1002715006,
0.1184790507,
0.0812688097,
-0.6061412692,
0.1182843819,
-0.7507532835,
0.9970749021,
0.1384455115,
-0.5365560055,
0.206984967,
-0.3858942091,
-0.2846217155,
-0.276722759,
0.1839976609,
-0.5037047863,
0.3567765653,
0.0750539973,
0.4625173807,
-0.0115240095,
0.0045851697,
-0.6856021881,
-0.4740254879,
0.3412174284,
-0.3368806541,
0.7967846394,
0.3328594267,
-0.2200953364,
0.1461396962,
-0.8495526314,
0.0014730039,
-0.1193984821,
-0.2748092115,
-0.4919572771,
-0.0232925583,
-0.0146082807,
0.5231660604,
-0.3277672827,
-0.3259783089,
0.1271437407,
-0.7606130242,
0.0382402092,
0.7449041009,
0.1649799198,
0.3346464634,
-0.4967665374,
0.3184176981,
-0.2681292295,
0.1164886951,
-0.059413746,
-0.4508615732,
-0.3669842482,
-0.4652167857,
0.1562364995,
0.5594682693,
-0.4945394397,
0.2990120351,
-0.6581458449,
-0.754838109,
-0.2898413837,
0.3362775445,
0.4988766909,
0.3706659079,
0.65036726,
-0.3966821432,
-0.112868458,
-0.5574142337,
-0.4085620046,
0.0614822917,
-0.2697142959,
0.1706446111,
0.7532755733,
-0.0726026744,
0.7004349232,
-0.3816963136,
-0.7833746672,
-0.0803432837,
-0.0409065336,
0.4722838402,
0.4509359002,
0.6884586215,
-0.6803879142,
-0.3397008777,
-0.1032611579,
-0.3638449311,
-0.0962522924,
-0.1023502424,
0.1098166332,
-0.0061935913,
0.4040161073,
-0.1026495844,
0.3007631004,
1.0345135927,
-0.0540547147,
0.1471533924,
-0.077869162,
0.0986739248,
-1.0565693378,
0.1971184313,
0.1209402308,
-0.1418460459,
-1.0667405128,
0.3363134563,
0.0827436745,
-0.3859824836,
-0.504806757,
0.487993747,
-0.2278327346,
-0.2354947925,
-0.0039955787,
0.1396441013,
-0.2217724025,
1.123601079,
-0.2328415662,
0.6493045092,
0.2172077894,
-0.3175022602,
0.1026757956,
0.1063843593,
0.1432529241,
0.2508148253,
-0.3202955723,
0.2123529315,
0.0946032405,
0.3058068156,
-1.0914983749,
-0.1088589579,
0.6057160497,
-0.3991237581,
0.6024593711,
-0.4676252007,
-0.3320642114,
0.0312002338,
-0.7564745545,
0.4030618072,
0.5698437095,
-0.5456021428,
0.6107388735,
0.3848843873,
-0.2073519379,
-0.3925695717,
-0.4782379866,
-0.1232031509,
-0.1906568259,
-0.5366850495,
-0.0651564747,
0.2141593844,
-0.3245304227,
-0.4701429904,
-0.2599472702,
-0.0800743774,
0.5442909002,
0.4992193878,
-0.0457385443,
-0.3005256653,
0.437289238,
-0.0990544111,
0.0516125225,
-0.0703883916,
-0.2964469492,
0.7562032938,
-0.1575936079,
-0.3540928066,
-0.4782212675,
0.0589810349,
0.5310624838,
-0.1280000359,
0.7906951308,
0.3510463238,
-0.3389583528,
-0.447385639,
-0.2405982465,
-0.5523282886,
-0.5668520927,
0.4241072536,
-0.3137153089,
-0.574803412,
0.5458384156,
-0.1325837821,
-0.0029040352,
0.3244132102,
0.5820965767,
0.1288775355,
0.4419757128,
0.577929616,
-0.2401603162,
0.4532785118,
-0.0913290828,
0.094842568,
-0.7239474654,
0.0240260214,
-0.7708010674,
-0.3815078437,
-0.711771369,
-0.2660764456,
0.5616737008,
-0.0632980168,
-0.4341699779,
0.2152084708,
-0.2022008002,
0.1033230498,
0.3514811397,
0.1871858239,
0.3377235532,
0.2586551905,
0.1258460879,
0.060948953,
-0.7416406274,
-0.0616845489,
1.2214013338,
0.7054644227,
0.9109721184,
0.3737576902,
0.7965325117,
0.375184536,
0.6923274398,
-0.5528234243,
0.2563664317,
-0.3500633836,
-0.7543884516,
-0.5638476014,
-0.357447505,
-0.9242529273,
0.6315661669,
-0.2531000376,
-0.960499227,
0.4859718084,
0.1506617069,
-0.4441802204,
0.3063089252,
-0.6178845763,
0.7508404851,
-0.0448403135,
-0.1836754531,
-0.3910053372,
-0.6182159781,
0.6260519028,
-0.6972635984,
0.644752264,
-0.2122443169,
0.2250808775,
0.7770270705,
-0.2909741104,
1.0906629562,
-0.3100371659,
-0.6617757082,
-0.3525689542,
0.1766685694,
0.3484861553,
0.0807076097,
-0.1952168047,
0.7102851868,
-0.0748907328,
-0.3126652241,
-0.5405068994,
0.3455435038,
-0.6516389251,
-0.7162253261,
-0.3881036639,
-0.3788341582,
-0.4076212347,
0.1512079239,
0.018298924,
0.4799037576,
0.2352058738,
0.2857312858,
0.5885313153,
-0.3828364015,
0.3782969713,
0.6216189861,
-0.1459470987,
-0.405175209,
0.9640610218,
0.0065471712,
0.3947617114,
0.4227585196,
0.1902650446,
-0.0064042904,
-0.746321559,
-0.2872503996,
0.2224861681,
-0.6094637513,
-0.458753854,
-0.2810734212,
-0.1320849359,
-0.5486072898,
-0.0358090475,
-0.4241126776,
-0.2687360346,
-0.0529794022,
0.2182498723,
0.4402892888,
0.4232538342,
-0.2022404075,
0.5412656069,
-0.9786287546,
0.5500708818,
0.1508934945,
0.2125192285,
0.1993428767,
-0.7852315903,
-0.3203759491,
0.1271128505,
-0.1039468572,
-1.1944333315,
0.7210524082,
0.3616437614,
0.3537998497,
0.1293970346,
0.0677035525,
0.391441077,
-0.4527530968,
0.3961232901,
0.0076557458,
-0.9620482922,
0.3168159425,
-0.4148869514,
0.1821291596,
0.5575111508,
0.2357682139,
-0.891919136,
-0.7167755961,
-0.1008886173,
-0.8825403452,
0.837216258,
0.0174836386,
0.2272877842,
0.5379878283,
0.3035135269,
0.0963261425,
0.289951086,
-0.7138624787,
-0.1064745262,
-0.4158080816,
-0.3217253685,
-0.2073643357,
-0.0567580573,
-0.441662699,
0.0455964319,
0.7174859643,
-0.3380050361,
0.000123511,
-0.1522643566,
-0.4014956951,
-0.0990331322,
0.6375364065,
0.736029923,
0.3806502819,
-0.2884605229,
0.082604818,
0.446629554,
-0.7555259466,
0.2305839211,
0.1956105083,
0.0784386769,
-0.4016284049,
0.6892535686,
0.3382229507,
0.6562572122,
-0.39621225,
0.4922260046,
0.0319474377,
0.1365463287,
0.0241931379,
0.3897248209,
-0.2149831057,
0.3105505705,
0.6624843478,
0.0446959436,
-0.1787295491,
-0.5078244209,
0.4535520971,
0.3044848442,
-0.2582213581,
-0.4322314262,
0.4167354405,
0.1166875437,
-0.2324644327,
0.7194797993,
0.139470309,
-0.5855426192,
0.3941834271,
0.4149594009,
0.8506882191,
-0.3983127177,
0.0388190225,
0.104885228,
0.5039306879,
0.1082610413,
0.3085236251,
-0.0601748265,
-0.8417429328,
-0.0956302583,
-0.7495201826,
-0.0374377072,
0.0669376105,
-0.5775490999,
-0.0387583934,
-0.5841676593,
0.0350855663,
-0.1596403867,
0.2128657252,
-0.2667350173,
0.0349492729,
0.2350551188,
1.0162247419,
-1.1420851946,
1.1628198624,
-0.0555527583,
-0.4346216023,
-0.9989668727,
0.3451922238,
0.234628588,
-0.9681333899,
1.0103263855,
-0.0308119133,
-0.2037444562,
0.2332460582,
-0.2440133691,
-0.9404938817,
0.8050650954,
0.2797190249,
-0.4871346354,
0.0559537187,
-0.1192546114,
0.6622174978,
0.0582596213,
-0.2041578442,
0.3943324089,
0.6125093699,
-0.2146961838,
-1.0047872066,
0.4046854973,
0.0071771489,
-0.0440180674,
0.197767958,
-0.5907663703,
0.9491786957,
-0.1338438243,
-0.3756783009,
0.0147872334,
0.4347881377,
0.3857001066,
0.242441088,
0.3836682141,
0.4673295915,
0.5578132868,
-0.0485072881,
0.8060396314,
-0.2397033721,
0.3568572402,
1.1156669855,
-0.4205224216,
0.9596284032,
0.3607674837,
-0.0158178005,
0.6011142731,
0.4123022854,
-0.5257428885,
0.5644494891,
0.4240808487,
0.2884622216,
0.0753976926,
0.4054050744,
-0.5920445323,
0.6393287778,
0.5123439431,
-0.1574447304,
-0.5869016647,
0.3180631101,
0.2712263763,
0.0499396138,
-0.4184601009,
0.6420255303,
0.1435536593,
-0.387411505,
0.9050103426,
0.1992213577,
0.522824049,
-0.6787974238,
-0.0747350156,
-0.3169915378,
0.2276957631,
-0.2375579327,
-0.1922506094,
0.1013924256,
-0.3257612586,
0.0107158432,
-0.3383785486,
0.6656096578,
-0.472496748,
-0.1179097518,
0.3662126958,
0.253633678,
-0.0418204926,
-0.0580264144,
-0.5106950402,
0.2187758535,
-0.3240237236,
-0.4384731054,
0.5789930224,
0.0119735766,
-0.2304439545,
0.7472960949,
0.8864597678,
0.3625802696,
0.1846415848,
-0.0376974493,
0.9601166248,
-0.53330791,
-0.3780589402,
-0.7065627575,
0.0448175147,
0.2108484954,
0.0696128234,
1.0086698532,
0.4283156991,
0.7991484404,
-0.0845597982,
0.267704457,
0.4526825547,
0.2421602309,
-0.8100648522,
1.0804879665,
-0.5632674098,
0.5318543315,
-0.0724473745,
-0.4768743515,
-0.4548479319,
0.2370265275,
-0.3088745773,
0.2233458161,
0.5300070047,
1.1455401182,
-0.0567223094,
-0.1117708832,
0.3535321951,
0.4838688076,
0.3959554136,
0.6111833453,
0.4272408783,
-0.3754511476,
0.3713261187,
-0.0820620954,
-0.17771478,
-0.350903064,
-0.5410912037,
-0.8747954369,
-0.3247459829,
0.0481444448,
-0.4652040005,
0.3284161687,
0.6856501102,
0.7953323126,
-1.0161931515,
-0.2851566672,
0.4073063433,
0.479665786,
-0.4056969881,
-0.2264661938,
0.3776530325,
-0.5517414808,
-0.4453438222,
0.4650940895,
0.376476109,
-0.2674695551,
-0.2947275341,
-0.0039885254,
-0.1721492708,
0.1212440953,
0.1846261621,
0.5939183831,
-0.4358477592,
-0.5133649111,
-0.400069505,
-0.3124774992,
0.06180951,
0.7916039228,
-0.879791379,
0.0871850774,
0.5291674137,
0.3825599253,
0.1061533689,
-0.2078927457,
0.6191503406,
-1.1434816122,
0.2130575627,
0.0569146536,
0.116292879,
0.1043117419,
-0.3443784714,
0.3934561312,
0.2288612872,
-0.179157719,
-1.0114260912,
0.1614591479,
-0.7510948181,
-0.8022972345,
1.3255554438,
0.0145155499,
-0.3487223089,
-0.4068582952,
0.0601687059,
0.1745529771,
-0.3729176223,
0.9612644911,
0.3604950905,
0.1873507053,
0.1423589289,
-0.466204524,
0.7606748343,
0.0628869683,
-0.7537301183,
0.1945290267,
0.3274991214,
0.4489185214,
0.231603682,
0.4509954453,
-0.0615853071,
0.3430768549,
-0.0992742404,
-0.13277556,
-0.1287831664,
-0.4613513052,
-0.9156647325,
0.7418771386,
-0.1424121857,
-0.064223446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12025v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12025v2
|
Speech Translation with Speech Foundation Models and Large Language Models: What is There and What is Missing?
| 2024-02-19T10:34:13 | 2024-05-17T14:46:32 |
Marco Gaido, Sara Papi, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The field of natural language processing (NLP) has recently witnessed a
transformative shift with the emergence of foundation models, particularly
Large Language Models (LLMs) that have revolutionized text-based NLP. This
paradigm has extended to other modalities, including speech, where researchers
are actively exploring the combination of Speech Foundation Models (SFMs) and
LLMs into single, unified models capable of addressing multimodal tasks. Among
such tasks, this paper focuses on speech-to-text translation (ST). By examining
the published papers on the topic, we propose a unified view of the
architectural solutions and training strategies presented so far, highlighting
similarities and differences among them. Based on this examination, we not only
organize the lessons learned but also show how diverse settings and evaluation
approaches hinder the identification of the best-performing solution for each
architectural building block and training choice. Lastly, we outline
recommendations for future works on the topic aimed at better understanding the
strengths and weaknesses of the SFM+LLM solutions for ST.
|
[
-0.3856930435,
-0.8048946857,
0.4213885069,
0.3590567112,
-0.3788720965,
0.2812097073,
-0.2220683992,
-0.6549176574,
0.0419933647,
0.6333243847,
-0.288725704,
-0.2757707834,
-0.8464220166,
0.170401141,
-0.8391169906,
0.901101768,
-0.144366309,
0.3253469765,
-0.4070001543,
-0.0435876995,
-0.5875332355,
-0.4610570371,
-0.5509979129,
-0.3987028003,
0.0860713422,
0.0073191472,
0.5311655998,
0.7434136868,
0.5277705789,
0.254640907,
-0.4248706698,
-0.0906001031,
-0.216424793,
-0.0838903859,
-0.0867902189,
-0.1083943397,
-0.4456713498,
-0.1548134983,
0.9698747396,
1.0599411726,
-0.0405360088,
0.1464634091,
0.1666096151,
0.7110666633,
-0.2324153781,
-0.0426528342,
-0.4799689651,
0.3348684609,
-0.1033132151,
-0.2605600357,
-0.4723827243,
-0.0935365781,
0.2570474744,
0.0040001702,
0.1430789828,
-0.2192308009,
0.3554484248,
0.4607481956,
-0.7293143272,
-0.3622480035,
-1.1335837841,
0.7459987402,
-0.7824716568,
0.6534771323,
-0.0329979658,
0.2118058056,
-0.3874460161,
-0.7027537823,
-0.1906332672,
-0.2471726686,
0.1473491341,
-0.1123687625,
-0.307295382,
0.1322502792,
-0.0753959641,
0.4171172082,
-0.6262990236,
0.1845974028,
-0.3135302365,
-0.0400138944,
0.6075580716,
-0.0366164669,
0.2509533465,
-0.1492700726,
-0.6177556515,
-0.0289426353,
-0.7279696465,
0.0765108615,
-0.0928462446,
0.5261880755,
-0.2599762678,
0.4955127537,
0.0809777752,
0.8606955409,
-0.2744845748,
-0.2895121574,
0.301430881,
-0.4579534829,
-0.4939751327,
0.0751403421,
0.7029809952,
-0.205710724,
0.2052374482,
-0.3403455615,
-0.2113220543,
-0.1202779263,
0.2570884228,
-0.430826813,
0.2329380363,
0.0202450883,
-0.3740808964,
-0.2658198476,
-0.3026920855,
-0.7056394219,
-0.1160845608,
-0.490378201,
0.0744078606,
-0.0795384273,
-0.3822650313,
0.2352201194,
-0.0378839336,
0.3740433156,
0.278734833,
-0.9816429019,
0.3742394745,
0.7806347013,
0.7461226583,
-0.5002387762,
-0.1180710047,
-0.520593226,
0.0701501966,
-0.5835419893,
0.7674826384,
-0.4031069577,
-0.5924120545,
0.1206860542,
-0.2990898788,
-0.1541866809,
-0.406037122,
0.7393879294,
-0.156159237,
0.260843873,
-0.1463086754,
-0.3667777181,
-0.0043854536,
0.0881674513,
-0.4899369478,
0.9934963584,
-0.1142598093,
-0.4534748197,
-0.0615276881,
-0.5950013995,
-0.7030797005,
-0.0471396036,
-0.2460488081,
-0.0393100791,
0.6321251392,
0.120813854,
0.5585858822,
-0.5037706494,
0.4709369838,
0.0115702152,
-0.2276343703,
0.1290079951,
-0.4890696406,
0.6124991775,
0.1463885903,
-0.2785258591,
0.298053354,
-0.7735720873,
-0.0853730738,
0.1201178804,
-0.6263719797,
-0.1186153814,
0.1448803991,
0.3597540557,
0.4740107358,
0.0983564779,
-0.2396317571,
-0.20086734,
-0.522388041,
0.8528053164,
0.6497673988,
-0.3332355618,
0.6999923587,
-0.1047860011,
0.39704144,
-0.0741283819,
-0.0915094689,
0.0388840213,
-0.495723933,
-0.5538974404,
-0.0781682655,
0.15428105,
0.3769457042,
-0.5216004848,
0.15414837,
-0.4551862478,
-0.5061996579,
-0.5864319801,
0.0554643422,
0.3009221554,
0.5311004519,
0.4986433983,
-0.1714315563,
-0.5200733542,
-0.8733529449,
-0.2898423672,
-0.0501135848,
0.1751056165,
0.0320794322,
0.5810421705,
-0.3110765219,
0.7438143492,
0.035116639,
-0.2999179661,
-0.4019185007,
0.0057491837,
-0.0090776449,
0.4256507754,
0.6424090862,
-1.0902004242,
-0.3315480947,
-0.0042392327,
-0.4454058409,
0.0701670125,
-0.0310486779,
0.3680265546,
0.2070736438,
0.5809354186,
-0.6779218316,
0.2831645906,
0.8643554449,
0.063087061,
0.741997838,
0.0337107256,
0.0629781187,
-1.3441243172,
0.2052389234,
-0.0562948175,
-0.3049996793,
-1.0333822966,
0.1426555216,
-0.2374173552,
-0.3431825042,
-0.5106990933,
0.6414288282,
-0.3692068458,
-0.6482768655,
-0.3217122257,
0.3427693844,
-0.0523530021,
0.4834269583,
0.164113909,
0.8032667637,
0.3008128405,
-0.553093493,
0.4480983615,
0.4722290039,
-0.2964827418,
0.554302454,
-0.691854775,
0.2574423552,
-0.088002272,
0.3574560881,
-1.0430425406,
-0.2074121833,
0.1439430863,
-0.4398474991,
0.3315964639,
-0.0280471984,
-0.3552228212,
-0.366061151,
-0.1107308939,
0.19937177,
0.1899787337,
-0.3567897081,
0.7729349732,
0.4263256788,
-0.420299083,
-0.6594781876,
-0.9168977141,
0.5283455253,
-0.1218274906,
-0.7057675719,
0.5461682081,
-0.1838826984,
-0.2337428331,
-0.0502807349,
-0.3420625627,
-0.258192271,
0.2768243253,
0.1537527889,
0.109980166,
-0.5942441821,
0.1199171692,
-0.0111132776,
-0.1664347351,
0.016147716,
-0.2314762324,
0.4586212337,
-0.3271270692,
-0.2831816673,
-0.3017149568,
0.7140976787,
0.7188122869,
-0.4800197482,
0.5186784267,
0.505196929,
-0.4014302194,
-0.1409056187,
-0.3671409786,
0.0976054519,
-0.3476434052,
0.6210778356,
-0.3893694282,
-1.0771585703,
0.210248515,
-0.2103147507,
0.3599771857,
0.3852715194,
0.548933208,
-0.1431301832,
0.9909331799,
0.78964746,
-0.1581506282,
0.5919829011,
0.1548626572,
0.2806364298,
-0.8407306075,
-0.2192290127,
-0.8638818264,
-0.3336129487,
-0.2195310444,
-0.313082099,
0.1713208556,
0.1321510077,
0.1655559987,
0.5392529964,
-0.430650413,
0.1009298116,
0.2301595062,
-0.4579216242,
0.4735065997,
0.2578880191,
0.0597831421,
-0.0667723864,
-0.7000284195,
-0.5058150291,
0.7863327861,
0.4355351925,
0.3529832363,
0.0506265722,
0.4085936248,
0.1060362533,
0.2152316421,
-0.7981860638,
0.6291001439,
-0.5389716625,
-0.4739030004,
-0.2144903541,
-0.5484105945,
-0.7396608591,
0.6319343448,
-0.4111481309,
-0.3762654662,
0.1557932198,
-0.0831635445,
-0.115346916,
0.178101778,
-0.4569613934,
1.041400075,
-0.6385535598,
0.0799973533,
-0.2794259191,
-0.6008491516,
0.2523361742,
-0.1278939396,
0.4777303338,
0.0209748708,
0.1454247534,
0.5105304122,
0.169773072,
0.6875065565,
0.0983270034,
-0.259590596,
-0.0980489999,
-0.2386143357,
0.3783231378,
-0.4620729387,
0.039292179,
0.2186929286,
0.0403849296,
-0.1951607466,
-0.2975778282,
0.5464847088,
-0.6151766777,
-0.4497320652,
-0.287132144,
-0.4948909283,
-0.4818215072,
0.2362306267,
0.1215059832,
0.4940566123,
-0.6984543204,
0.7027485967,
0.8042347431,
-0.0980339944,
0.4813432395,
0.3834770322,
-0.1983660758,
-0.395852536,
0.3574730754,
-0.0734394714,
0.3338187635,
0.5645754337,
0.1758232713,
-0.3847908974,
-0.9592080116,
-0.6856367588,
0.2101005316,
-0.6392474771,
0.0971556008,
-0.6517464519,
-0.3284956217,
-0.721008718,
-0.2247470319,
-0.5515471101,
-0.2756743133,
-0.5375729203,
-0.2200619578,
-0.2213560045,
0.6315883398,
0.1368557513,
0.2362045646,
-0.8577637076,
0.3775060177,
0.328789562,
0.0603672899,
-0.008385269,
-0.7066025138,
-0.3414544165,
0.2245604247,
-0.130673945,
-0.8395106196,
0.2127387375,
0.3465564847,
0.5850626826,
0.0546837151,
-0.3098756671,
0.708748281,
-0.6740475297,
0.7485747933,
0.2969775498,
-0.8465139866,
0.5003560185,
-0.2167286128,
0.0645809621,
0.3573263288,
0.1422592849,
-0.7874220014,
-0.1397130936,
-0.4002628922,
-0.890260458,
0.4091266096,
-0.0356372558,
0.3476493657,
0.2038603872,
0.1876508296,
-0.198547855,
0.5685570836,
-0.857753098,
-0.0287397914,
-0.0786787644,
-0.1657380909,
-0.2916082442,
-0.1580492258,
-0.3422797918,
0.0264844354,
0.4378957152,
-0.0015504222,
0.2082873434,
-0.0755392015,
-0.2783891559,
-0.2471262962,
0.5861356258,
0.8247740865,
0.5596457124,
0.0291253962,
-0.009349864,
-0.0879916176,
-0.1400485933,
0.0872471109,
0.1562137604,
-0.1329686493,
0.2021136135,
0.6139876842,
1.0859513283,
0.794470787,
-0.6112143397,
0.5288555622,
0.2381180078,
-0.2755762041,
-0.2448903769,
0.0498971045,
0.3002710044,
0.1980802268,
0.4062047005,
0.4338880181,
-0.1033361703,
-0.739362061,
0.0751069784,
0.5318469405,
-0.4425959885,
-0.36301741,
0.6646052599,
0.4373842478,
-0.5760154724,
0.3031019568,
0.4237376451,
-0.3172278106,
0.4257237613,
0.7534000278,
1.1164740324,
-0.2691862583,
0.4314188659,
-0.1324114949,
0.4262856543,
-0.4211416841,
-0.1347652674,
-0.0809545964,
-0.6251033545,
-0.6503519416,
-0.8004335165,
-0.3294137418,
0.155086413,
-0.6271206141,
-0.0818933323,
-0.3038396239,
-0.0046184161,
-0.0339653753,
-0.2039657235,
-0.4924348593,
0.1272287071,
0.2154993117,
1.0859004259,
-0.9184944034,
0.8622067571,
0.9201781154,
-0.2243156731,
-0.524369061,
-0.3051657081,
-0.055574324,
-0.4882279038,
0.4172019958,
-0.168596819,
-0.3102220297,
0.1634830981,
-0.3331393301,
-0.7488012314,
0.8155947328,
0.6687954068,
-0.3652867675,
-0.4237596989,
0.5195592642,
0.8637493253,
-0.6206200123,
-0.5291840434,
0.4037549198,
0.3509147465,
0.2450765371,
-1.0206780434,
-0.3738055229,
0.0207292531,
0.2427105457,
0.1820137352,
-0.2836597264,
0.5871468782,
0.0562114157,
-0.3034700751,
0.0868044719,
0.5505800843,
0.0444652401,
0.2485603839,
0.2186475396,
0.4754955769,
0.3840884268,
-0.1404595226,
0.8271190524,
-0.0000779942,
0.0243525747,
1.0555408001,
-0.2234797627,
1.3685854673,
0.7013144493,
-0.177523464,
0.2317333221,
0.5752159953,
0.210270077,
0.4440379143,
-0.0870423913,
-0.1310550272,
-0.2162622809,
-0.046384342,
-0.6487452388,
0.5695726871,
0.3294697106,
-0.3030780852,
-0.3099855781,
0.2012690008,
-0.3380245864,
0.2866751552,
-0.3405743837,
0.8188492656,
0.5219428539,
-0.4697395563,
0.3810611665,
0.2557255328,
0.5931358933,
-0.8454847932,
0.1809145063,
-0.2599978745,
-0.1470808387,
-0.1111680269,
-0.5295526981,
0.5984764695,
0.0569136105,
-0.3072077632,
-0.8121033907,
0.6623578072,
-0.5431897044,
-0.2774591148,
0.5324760079,
0.5861574411,
0.0587050915,
-0.0813557208,
-0.8399434686,
0.2119493634,
0.0727558136,
-0.1023129299,
0.4694395959,
0.2438514084,
0.0777046159,
0.6874437928,
0.8462594748,
0.2158671916,
0.1277535707,
-0.142533049,
0.5835824013,
-0.5721850395,
-0.4860785604,
-0.7339582443,
0.5541533828,
0.2312353998,
-0.3963212073,
0.5730292201,
0.4762211442,
0.7484990358,
-0.0706368461,
0.5787879825,
0.234325096,
0.3402138948,
-0.495587796,
0.3882521987,
-0.6119775176,
0.1770457178,
-0.3873173296,
-1.2460711002,
-0.2341872454,
0.6176050901,
-0.0471357666,
-0.2150819004,
0.5368201733,
0.3526421785,
0.0496088453,
0.1698947996,
0.2839954197,
0.2296614349,
0.3919272423,
0.490594238,
0.6604144573,
-0.5067494512,
0.6451822519,
0.2377963215,
-0.1116225123,
-0.4214785993,
-0.9729074836,
-0.5229506493,
-0.6416783333,
-0.1684965193,
-0.0627511963,
-0.0349400528,
0.8765499592,
0.6427597404,
-0.7619414926,
-0.4258549213,
-0.0704542771,
0.2746721506,
-0.3953895569,
-0.1036027521,
0.2211033553,
-0.0191459656,
-0.5974209309,
0.9906206727,
0.5378616452,
0.2248346359,
-0.330316335,
-0.0822238028,
-0.205876112,
0.0787042156,
0.7276622653,
0.4855448008,
-0.7627865076,
-0.2230537981,
-0.067633383,
-0.233957395,
0.2089262903,
0.7403813601,
-0.4275277853,
0.2478442043,
0.5843123794,
1.1882975101,
0.5149147511,
-0.2566506267,
0.6518982053,
-0.9215404391,
0.1543271244,
0.3140244782,
0.2647695243,
0.5361077785,
0.1767001897,
0.475820303,
0.3431925178,
-0.4132480621,
-1.1435689926,
0.4226877093,
-0.8430339694,
-0.3017700016,
0.9460980892,
0.2011430264,
0.0231484659,
-0.0520834997,
0.1103561968,
0.0091726426,
0.0245168656,
0.6085150838,
0.9437698722,
0.0040895939,
-0.2827603519,
-0.7584624887,
0.4702485204,
0.3711251318,
-0.789417088,
0.0114410017,
0.5629316568,
0.1708711088,
0.3648171723,
0.7291126847,
-0.1286327839,
0.0891565382,
-0.2765913308,
-0.2388683408,
-0.0364329778,
-0.4708606899,
-0.5313465595,
0.2243598998,
0.0167755019,
0.003074453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12022v1
|
Distilling Large Language Models for Text-Attributed Graph Learning
| 2024-02-19T10:31:53 | 2024-02-19T10:31:53 |
Bo Pan, Zheng Zhang, Yifei Zhang, Yuntong Hu, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text-Attributed Graphs (TAGs) are graphs of connected textual documents.
Graph models can efficiently learn TAGs, but their training heavily relies on
human-annotated labels, which are scarce or even unavailable in many
applications. Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated
remarkable capabilities in few-shot and zero-shot TAG learning, but they suffer
from scalability, cost, and privacy issues. Therefore, in this work, we focus
on synergizing LLMs and graph models with their complementary strengths by
distilling the power of LLMs to a local graph model on TAG learning. To address
the inherent gaps between LLMs (generative models for texts) and graph models
(discriminative models for graphs), we propose first to let LLMs teach an
interpreter with rich textual rationale and then let a student model mimic the
interpreter's reasoning without LLMs' textual rationale. Extensive experiments
validate the efficacy of our proposed framework.
|
[
0.033053413,
-0.5733677149,
0.7058426142,
-0.1578940749,
-0.4334506989,
0.5552142262,
-0.3697246909,
-0.5108448267,
0.109822616,
0.5637297034,
-0.3407319784,
-0.635651648,
-0.5981805325,
0.2392260134,
-0.219829306,
1.0383110046,
-0.1571071893,
0.0296044238,
-0.2812458873,
-0.1412420124,
-0.338816613,
-0.4408474267,
-0.5113564134,
-0.7030312419,
0.7360213995,
0.1655405611,
0.4212220311,
0.7619033456,
0.1291408241,
0.3241883814,
0.0130381389,
0.3370447159,
-0.5213015676,
0.1803047508,
-0.3387266994,
-0.6000111103,
-0.431930095,
0.0860099345,
0.8612971902,
0.9642002583,
0.0929858312,
0.0245032273,
0.0020716919,
0.3051190674,
-0.3145148158,
0.4079176486,
-1.0176084042,
-0.3493611217,
-0.1218706667,
0.085250631,
-1.0009531975,
-0.2722321153,
0.0562807322,
-0.6735319495,
0.1524565071,
0.0448736697,
0.8991947174,
0.1844765991,
-0.6102293134,
-0.2323213369,
-0.6138349175,
0.8035687804,
-0.5198224783,
0.1981492192,
0.4893052876,
0.2255922109,
-0.1015257165,
-0.9972140193,
-0.5068413615,
-0.1976990104,
-0.2648177445,
-0.1113969386,
-0.3162900805,
0.0421903804,
0.3146891892,
0.2054586709,
-0.4414091706,
0.4779095352,
-0.0420441255,
-0.0737671107,
0.4877950847,
0.0170962792,
0.2560117841,
-0.339053601,
-0.5013986826,
0.0551885553,
-0.7471196055,
-0.3805152774,
0.3266355097,
0.5303393602,
0.0766521171,
0.5002560019,
0.1409593821,
0.9139438868,
-0.1816062629,
-0.3465738893,
0.3128849566,
-0.0527096167,
-0.1766263843,
-0.1409617364,
0.8932455778,
0.0102636432,
0.4118087888,
-0.4985872507,
-0.0973925591,
0.211726442,
-0.1938852966,
-0.8869609237,
-0.4228891134,
-0.0473513938,
-0.1999384761,
-0.0919637159,
-0.268011868,
-0.452178359,
-0.4983507395,
-0.3938927948,
0.2902480066,
-0.5680348277,
-0.302447021,
0.0110354442,
-0.3030111492,
-0.0382837877,
0.2351583093,
-0.7547957897,
0.1944188327,
0.6405723095,
0.926376462,
0.0256823618,
-0.4375568628,
-0.46547544,
0.4523961842,
-0.1112676561,
0.6841765046,
-0.7689803243,
-0.3144305646,
-0.1541949362,
0.0555136651,
-0.1167712584,
-0.3758231401,
0.4163213968,
-0.4821625948,
-0.0721974,
-0.1352354139,
-0.7832784057,
-0.1705751717,
0.1650794894,
-0.7809557319,
0.9074507952,
0.3137578964,
-0.9397181273,
0.2375497073,
-0.2112855613,
-0.7631765008,
0.3210500181,
-0.1227725297,
-0.358466655,
-0.0434087105,
0.2671371698,
0.6239309311,
-0.3462188542,
0.3865010142,
-0.4006606936,
-0.2124136984,
0.1890241951,
-0.31083709,
0.8552831411,
0.1618106216,
0.0599779896,
0.0444386676,
-0.7969393134,
-0.1378281415,
0.4089304507,
-0.276673615,
-0.7065578699,
0.1468736231,
-0.2485521734,
0.0907975361,
0.1560605466,
-0.5778084993,
0.4486103058,
-0.6009469628,
0.8288840652,
0.7301655412,
-0.190717876,
0.6141694188,
-0.1978980452,
0.4460507929,
-0.2554718554,
-0.4437227845,
-0.4568452239,
-0.2883079648,
-0.5692901015,
-0.7963887453,
0.3871356249,
0.1791660637,
-1.0393685102,
0.3797326088,
-0.4645176232,
-0.6140476465,
-0.4183629453,
0.2782667875,
0.2315672785,
0.6398729682,
0.1662994176,
-0.1725850999,
-0.4281918406,
-0.4569230378,
-0.3118886948,
-0.3037533164,
0.0261906516,
0.3168564141,
0.4515642822,
-0.1197922379,
1.1600693464,
-0.672005415,
-0.4394651055,
-0.6754508615,
0.1399861872,
0.03803242,
0.2055634707,
0.7082948685,
-0.5838954449,
-0.7332754731,
0.0765069425,
-0.6428741813,
-0.1825256646,
0.0239451062,
-0.1347983479,
0.1572927386,
0.4393300414,
-0.6761716604,
0.1614122689,
0.5076271296,
-0.0883987099,
0.2803430259,
-0.1388205886,
-0.4748939276,
-1.304402709,
-0.0179574974,
0.2410760671,
-0.5706343055,
-0.4095948637,
0.0969149321,
-0.1269964278,
-0.2232066244,
-0.1496953517,
0.6487859488,
-0.6679257751,
-0.0000829837,
-0.3402190208,
0.4410048127,
0.3354352713,
0.4432871044,
0.0998475552,
0.4103309214,
0.6532285213,
-0.220946297,
0.4872212708,
0.1056414172,
-0.2197299302,
0.465093106,
-0.5877914429,
0.1329756677,
-0.3549087942,
0.7193887234,
-1.0882519484,
-0.3117035329,
0.0077383621,
-0.3347575068,
0.538803637,
-0.5193010569,
-0.7145847082,
-0.3888883293,
-0.1529859751,
0.354326427,
0.5605509281,
-0.7672066092,
0.8443200588,
0.4540424943,
-0.0662554204,
-0.4652921855,
-0.5111869574,
0.1243568212,
-0.1051137596,
-0.4645635486,
0.2580382526,
0.1829905361,
-0.0430446602,
0.1437782645,
0.1046049595,
-0.1518445611,
0.2789392173,
0.2683131993,
0.4055887461,
-0.0399368368,
0.5380403996,
-0.0554628298,
-0.2729364038,
-0.1805126071,
-0.6245825887,
0.7102658153,
0.0100518567,
-0.287345469,
-0.2096595019,
0.2265540659,
0.3508419693,
-0.6861819029,
0.909044981,
0.4681448638,
-0.396853596,
-0.6255210042,
-0.0941500217,
-0.0373783149,
-0.4624355733,
0.5234497786,
-0.276945591,
-1.076792717,
0.4671884775,
-0.413811177,
-0.1066553146,
0.3556019068,
0.6984294057,
-0.0418370888,
0.9938172698,
0.5852963328,
-0.2556624711,
0.6396973133,
-0.3714242578,
0.3284879029,
-0.6010892391,
-0.0564104058,
-0.6288306713,
-0.1742947996,
-0.5185886025,
-0.4176440239,
0.0394180082,
0.1513725221,
-0.2094651014,
0.3587091863,
-0.443564117,
0.9166091084,
0.3339114487,
0.0649024993,
0.3978427351,
0.1587234586,
-0.1033986285,
0.0821377337,
-0.6194107533,
-0.5475405455,
1.0836800337,
0.4244377315,
1.056470871,
0.0441527106,
0.8544638753,
-0.1460574716,
0.6666203737,
-0.9107993245,
0.5243510008,
-0.3451989293,
-0.5692355037,
-0.1749342531,
-0.6935037374,
-1.0138118267,
0.3751817942,
-0.0520871952,
-1.0036050081,
-0.2667035758,
0.1523460597,
0.1082392633,
0.5156949759,
-0.9456058741,
0.9692541361,
-0.0283841528,
-0.231897682,
0.0690037012,
-0.4923856854,
0.2787248492,
-0.1652321666,
0.3480214775,
-0.273409158,
0.1850702167,
0.483851105,
-0.3760251999,
1.2959080935,
-0.0467173979,
-0.1828037798,
0.5027711987,
0.2279729694,
0.7566862702,
-0.1233650893,
-0.0178449228,
0.0310922768,
-0.2639011741,
-0.2885546982,
-0.3948343694,
0.7487405539,
-0.6768782735,
-0.4105291963,
-0.2881057858,
-0.6655119658,
-0.117171295,
0.4123930633,
0.1291331351,
0.5360212922,
-0.0595354214,
-0.017949827,
0.3810925186,
-0.0313050151,
0.3426935971,
0.3492618203,
-0.4128337204,
-0.2977622449,
1.184522748,
0.1842695177,
0.5818263292,
0.3480226099,
0.2326574028,
-0.2813854218,
-0.3825996816,
-0.1699504554,
0.6909084916,
-1.0795021057,
-0.3250581324,
-0.5863636732,
-0.1010518596,
-0.3604863882,
-0.1142668352,
-0.1518426836,
-0.4721597135,
-0.5406519175,
-0.2867508531,
0.4147518277,
0.6830778718,
0.1524226516,
0.5197384357,
-0.5884841084,
0.256403476,
0.1199632138,
0.3362000585,
0.2441701293,
-0.4483676255,
-0.1702357233,
-0.0459021516,
-0.3488405645,
-0.8148725033,
0.3781463802,
0.3155916035,
0.4052227437,
0.1839997917,
0.1899939924,
0.4828281999,
-0.6652773619,
0.4962974787,
0.29106915,
-1.0739351511,
0.3398387134,
-0.3483788371,
-0.0980805978,
0.2316969484,
0.5919799805,
-0.3717306256,
-0.643574059,
-0.4328480065,
-0.8689512014,
0.6911674142,
-0.0654997826,
0.2786163986,
-0.2189801484,
0.3620032668,
0.0515431687,
0.0525724106,
-1.2548111677,
-0.1676053107,
-0.1751371473,
-0.5866352916,
-0.2300516665,
0.0066319183,
-0.0526520573,
-0.3753012419,
0.5734314322,
-0.4788664281,
-0.2701991498,
-0.0685119778,
-0.3778233528,
0.0122807426,
0.1686606258,
-0.0566833988,
0.6514130831,
0.0137595404,
0.659958303,
0.0557846278,
-0.1763544083,
0.1443458498,
0.1613215655,
-0.1467425525,
0.0531683788,
0.6054339409,
0.8408188224,
0.0092321774,
-0.5877298117,
0.5609320998,
0.1816639304,
-0.0361383632,
0.1259369105,
-0.1141297147,
0.494140178,
0.1152971238,
0.1550713629,
-0.3027639091,
-0.3065113127,
-0.493748039,
0.0925980508,
0.5078622103,
-0.2627668381,
-0.3768275678,
0.5994514227,
0.259901315,
-0.2738674283,
0.426564008,
-0.3789813817,
-0.7446264625,
0.4992017746,
0.9535186291,
0.7204672098,
-0.1253423542,
0.4564069211,
0.381241858,
0.314514786,
0.0298721101,
-0.2144660205,
0.0001361147,
-0.7186515331,
-0.7093594074,
-0.612849474,
-0.2122227997,
-0.1515994966,
-0.4077910781,
0.3399503827,
-0.3775245547,
-0.2681670487,
0.5180060267,
-0.0739640743,
-0.3962902725,
-0.102432251,
0.1822033525,
0.6294135451,
-1.0358757973,
1.1670393944,
0.5566720366,
-0.5792865157,
-1.0362861156,
-0.1197321936,
-0.3507134318,
-0.863709867,
0.8509529829,
0.2597537637,
-0.0097521311,
0.4297279119,
-0.7151065469,
-0.5868715644,
1.0287334919,
0.8079091311,
-0.5430127382,
-0.1690703183,
0.1073485687,
0.5375737548,
-0.412065506,
0.1378083676,
0.3970201313,
0.0502290204,
0.3647328019,
-0.8009011149,
0.0581498146,
0.3134403229,
0.0031507737,
0.4322102368,
-0.6090788245,
1.067070365,
-0.2351152748,
-0.4727011025,
-0.0647207424,
0.4499825835,
-0.0176160838,
0.1631496698,
0.3306427598,
0.6667885184,
1.005943656,
-0.0437738746,
1.0230858326,
-0.1230212003,
0.7435151339,
1.3786996603,
-0.723208189,
0.7943986654,
0.3437953293,
-0.088905558,
0.7767524123,
0.3891637027,
-0.0074285259,
0.2626853585,
0.2556145489,
-0.3781597912,
-0.5548967719,
-0.3524934947,
-0.0371225104,
0.3759347498,
0.1775736809,
-0.4940835536,
-0.611543715,
-0.0924487486,
0.1967075467,
0.3048397303,
-0.2351796329,
0.7555226684,
0.2927563488,
-0.4672714472,
0.5577489734,
0.1792891622,
0.2377433479,
-0.5819244981,
-0.0044541564,
0.0466177911,
0.3276719451,
-0.1806701124,
-0.7213067412,
0.081639044,
0.2325418741,
-0.1765413582,
-0.2121093422,
0.8878449798,
-0.5793012381,
-0.5772899389,
0.4221307933,
0.3148875833,
0.0122451326,
0.2309998572,
-0.3839490712,
-0.0176411439,
-0.121186018,
0.0129456818,
0.3096667826,
0.5834177732,
-0.0179948118,
0.7734359503,
0.593696475,
0.028903272,
-0.0805874914,
0.2803732753,
1.1581244469,
-0.4277071655,
-0.4057614207,
-1.2389531136,
0.3381446004,
-0.1721314341,
0.1803121269,
0.9309318066,
0.4956137538,
0.8592585325,
0.2347229123,
0.8286319375,
0.1084553078,
0.365639627,
-0.4444032013,
0.693857491,
-0.3989894688,
0.1608719826,
-0.3801358938,
-0.9012373686,
-0.3497461081,
0.6999153495,
-0.3138819933,
-0.0360282697,
0.5750887394,
0.3894937932,
0.0781804025,
-0.1995371133,
0.1707376689,
0.3260483444,
0.5191883445,
0.7722294927,
0.9306376576,
-0.1596611887,
0.417689532,
0.1441738904,
-0.2745209932,
0.029982673,
-1.1315344572,
-1.4051244259,
-0.5051690936,
-0.3620016277,
-0.4613648951,
-0.5081940293,
0.8535044789,
0.5154895186,
-0.2465199083,
-0.0585776493,
-0.1134471148,
0.4627222717,
0.1961394846,
-0.1457303911,
0.342053622,
-0.3091897964,
-0.7143830657,
0.0154030239,
0.2735569477,
0.1656141579,
-0.2639590204,
-0.0839521736,
-0.1641145647,
0.1781496257,
0.5811583996,
0.0946506783,
-0.7092396617,
-0.3959500194,
-0.1898798048,
-0.2535200715,
0.1135846898,
0.7256657481,
-0.8210879564,
0.5087636113,
0.3535654247,
0.5747041106,
0.6357590556,
-0.0222986229,
0.3217259943,
-1.1477538347,
0.4225672483,
0.1999439448,
0.5356274247,
0.4377624393,
0.035856463,
0.3295558095,
0.4681084752,
-0.3742358387,
-1.2563958168,
0.5930965543,
-0.8989187479,
-0.4679943621,
1.2210704088,
-0.599947989,
-0.2552906275,
0.1067342013,
-0.2700937688,
0.3923908472,
-0.006506091,
0.2463966161,
0.6811467409,
0.3602905571,
0.0561747178,
-0.0548052266,
0.221353516,
-0.0702039674,
-0.7118774056,
0.5069186091,
0.5835106969,
0.3641873598,
0.0833760202,
0.6853875518,
0.1831410825,
-0.2573580146,
0.0125507433,
0.0727463514,
-0.2444829941,
-0.3732885122,
-0.2023027092,
0.110309802,
0.4107811153,
0.1049236134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12011v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12011v3
|
A Systematic Comparison of Contextualized Word Embeddings for Lexical Semantic Change
| 2024-02-19T10:04:59 | 2024-03-08T14:50:40 |
Francesco Periti, Nina Tahmasebi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Contextualized embeddings are the preferred tool for modeling Lexical
Semantic Change (LSC). Current evaluations typically focus on a specific task
known as Graded Change Detection (GCD). However, performance comparison across
work are often misleading due to their reliance on diverse settings. In this
paper, we evaluate state-of-the-art models and approaches for GCD under equal
conditions. We further break the LSC problem into Word-in-Context (WiC) and
Word Sense Induction (WSI) tasks, and compare models across these different
levels. Our evaluation is performed across different languages on eight
available benchmarks for LSC, and shows that (i) APD outperforms other
approaches for GCD; (ii) XL-LEXEME outperforms other contextualized models for
WiC, WSI, and GCD, while being comparable to GPT-4; (iii) there is a clear need
for improving the modeling of word meanings, as well as focus on how, when, and
why these meanings change, rather than solely focusing on the extent of
semantic change.
|
[
-0.2069188803,
-0.6245787144,
0.7277844548,
-0.0291282851,
-0.2568684816,
-0.2676694095,
-0.3859187067,
-0.4626605511,
-0.0384104513,
0.0499164537,
-0.3941012621,
-0.7380776405,
-0.8241741061,
0.1705551445,
-0.469196409,
0.6771520972,
-0.4659325778,
0.2307648957,
-0.1399414241,
-0.4059690833,
-0.7637459636,
-0.1902204305,
-0.3591167033,
-0.3963122964,
0.381305784,
-0.008319987,
0.8235065341,
0.3498990536,
0.4665342569,
0.263202697,
-0.519520402,
0.1209457815,
-0.1079339162,
0.1159089878,
-0.4781132638,
-0.1545105278,
-0.1789781451,
0.198858425,
0.4827213883,
0.9595840573,
-0.3958134353,
-0.0033772243,
0.0343396142,
0.4030540287,
-1.1231092215,
0.3052538633,
-0.8165506721,
0.1345244944,
0.0772765502,
0.0908094421,
-0.3802223504,
-0.1672946364,
0.109377861,
-0.7726978064,
0.1000569388,
-0.0783674493,
0.6529843807,
0.2666708529,
-0.3980195522,
-0.7029220462,
-0.4393042028,
0.7039811015,
-0.750844717,
0.8437700272,
0.226470083,
0.1639200598,
-0.0382182002,
-0.719451189,
-0.6090499163,
-0.4664500952,
0.0655537322,
0.3830705881,
-0.1598266661,
-0.0444736741,
0.3008507788,
0.3335569501,
-0.1201499179,
0.1177676767,
-0.0906986892,
-0.1489459872,
0.2990203202,
0.1866070777,
0.3487733006,
-0.1690257937,
-0.3529048264,
-0.4132018685,
-0.6461307406,
0.147518307,
-0.0307265595,
0.2113066018,
-0.0775779188,
0.5234606862,
-0.3554578125,
0.7650902271,
0.0492285416,
-0.2379564196,
0.2784743905,
-0.5951709747,
-0.3089786768,
0.1890570521,
0.0573597364,
0.6027768254,
0.1639745831,
-0.3070215285,
-0.4334501922,
0.7666063309,
0.0634880885,
-0.6572304368,
0.055022534,
-0.043412108,
-0.3806515932,
-0.1158144251,
0.0505040064,
-0.1488378197,
-0.4639978111,
-0.6924779415,
0.3076771796,
-0.6112014651,
-0.1889724135,
0.3579086661,
-0.3603947461,
0.3598726392,
0.6360909939,
-0.7308577299,
0.2491081059,
0.7637518644,
0.822078228,
-0.4410636723,
-0.2237391323,
-0.2602269053,
0.0000400204,
-0.7576419115,
0.8176923394,
-0.8025815487,
-0.4095453322,
0.2812262475,
0.0777141899,
-0.277799964,
-0.6500060558,
0.3839396536,
-0.5124951005,
0.0960621312,
-0.6303629875,
-0.904317975,
0.1534064412,
0.4523387551,
-0.4369482398,
1.0978802443,
0.2809197009,
-1.0345599651,
0.9715691209,
-0.7184964418,
-0.0741769895,
0.0227040742,
0.1399033666,
-0.0049736956,
0.4552167058,
0.2157775462,
0.1768580228,
0.1827247441,
0.359418422,
-0.1581963301,
-0.5773051977,
0.1506787688,
-0.0474178828,
0.4033165872,
0.2902731001,
-0.3821941614,
0.1218771413,
-0.5211180449,
0.0194940511,
-0.1129725873,
-0.2177139372,
-0.8061479926,
0.2604746222,
-0.1030408666,
0.2617417574,
0.1122335866,
-0.88069278,
0.09775085,
-0.2734933794,
0.5088448524,
0.6958398223,
-0.2285043597,
0.5606759191,
-0.0687230527,
0.148504436,
0.3866621852,
0.1434334517,
-0.1712609231,
-0.5407330394,
-0.4969996512,
-0.0882141292,
0.4242572188,
0.3441095054,
-0.7316872478,
0.2483910322,
-0.2513994575,
-0.2943418622,
-0.3975366056,
-0.1500512213,
0.1747250408,
0.4027254581,
0.6999101043,
-0.4456520379,
0.0420650914,
-0.6003156304,
-0.5462197065,
-0.0054960684,
-0.113746427,
0.1063603982,
0.5228273273,
-0.4154659808,
1.0227375031,
-0.4310508072,
-0.2321774364,
-0.1341803372,
0.0402036943,
-0.1549732834,
0.2108362913,
0.3195517361,
-0.5749880075,
-0.1903630048,
0.0688856617,
-0.5497906804,
-0.2184578478,
0.0603667647,
0.0450815819,
0.1658031791,
0.8136198521,
-0.2283423543,
0.8550342917,
0.5934572816,
-0.7169790864,
0.4376564324,
-0.277744174,
0.1907365322,
-0.7805592418,
-0.2796890438,
-0.0641405359,
-0.085385263,
-0.6521286964,
0.3064276278,
0.6055031419,
0.0872283131,
-0.6597960591,
0.5819380879,
-0.3763945401,
-0.3525261283,
-0.1085949391,
0.499774158,
-0.0506125391,
0.2090406716,
0.1163725406,
0.686835587,
0.3208139241,
-0.560352385,
0.0516478792,
0.1477294862,
-0.8236211538,
0.500656724,
-0.5535475612,
-0.0211713426,
-0.1656065285,
0.4216532409,
-0.7961698771,
0.181567654,
0.0941785946,
-0.148951456,
0.0661709309,
0.2632887661,
-0.5989640951,
-0.1518001109,
-0.3241795599,
0.5563672185,
0.262501806,
-0.8246946335,
0.2783053815,
0.0150937662,
0.1221730486,
-0.1902888268,
-0.6562477946,
0.1083951741,
-0.1633681357,
-0.6131487489,
0.9765086174,
-0.0700012222,
-0.528906703,
0.2449320853,
-0.1642243564,
0.1391301304,
0.1495306492,
-0.0308472235,
-0.0723452121,
-0.0260006767,
0.3733665049,
0.2126967162,
-0.0361739174,
-0.191885367,
-0.1842118055,
0.4084260464,
-0.1422792822,
-0.4330385327,
-0.3504653871,
0.3049378991,
0.3191953897,
-0.2712161243,
0.8302596211,
0.7163212895,
-0.4726852179,
-0.0866922736,
-0.4920158982,
-0.1564572006,
-0.3843326867,
0.36496225,
-0.2920076847,
-0.9567625523,
0.4666221142,
-0.2059135139,
0.0211403556,
0.2918410897,
0.5776271224,
0.2181207389,
1.1019096375,
0.7143894434,
0.2175451815,
0.677934587,
-0.0143371923,
0.2915585041,
-1.1810793877,
-0.0826438516,
-0.2651823163,
-0.1991393864,
-0.6710635424,
-0.4716663957,
0.4831771255,
0.1962609291,
-0.1190453023,
0.2344956398,
-0.4055632949,
0.2155229747,
0.0428959578,
-0.0353586152,
0.3045400381,
-0.0538531989,
-0.4847480655,
-0.0948147997,
-0.4633743167,
-0.4157770574,
0.9122440219,
0.2173750401,
0.6752395034,
0.2556227446,
0.5555069447,
0.3469871581,
0.7172945738,
-0.8907396197,
0.4728776813,
-0.1846458912,
-0.1023857072,
-0.289578259,
-0.0459486656,
-0.9267816544,
0.7915087938,
-0.1180632338,
-0.7060593963,
0.2372330874,
-0.138135463,
0.0746438578,
0.4908439815,
-0.707433641,
0.7880060077,
0.2988813519,
-0.1371096075,
-0.4346136749,
-0.0763159841,
0.1266837716,
0.1010755002,
0.3128859401,
-0.2474294007,
-0.2283171415,
0.6574686766,
-0.6042145491,
0.5261617303,
-0.4653797448,
-0.480894655,
0.2493798882,
0.0889011845,
0.4353010654,
-0.0549234599,
-0.2184615135,
0.1767875254,
0.2735291719,
-0.2737910748,
-0.5619826913,
0.7085954547,
-0.5556331873,
-0.5402596593,
-0.3578688204,
-0.6375684142,
-0.2314163148,
-0.2350852489,
0.184961617,
0.6933996081,
-0.3022093177,
-0.0485906154,
0.2616618276,
-0.3515892327,
0.5497615337,
0.3775990605,
-0.0866236985,
0.0776495561,
0.3943362236,
0.1469466537,
0.4698878825,
0.0456015803,
0.3922622204,
-0.2940869927,
-0.3332824111,
-0.2483677864,
0.0741180629,
-0.9766625762,
0.0339344628,
-0.3384460807,
0.1989859641,
-0.5701968074,
-0.4992164373,
-0.2338855714,
-0.1510691643,
0.0654425919,
-0.0509317666,
0.2542834282,
0.8865964413,
-0.1085679606,
-0.0251212083,
-0.2055744529,
0.077280432,
0.2344201803,
0.2858226597,
-0.0848524272,
-0.5031134486,
-0.1050177664,
0.0970068648,
-0.343018502,
-1.0229868889,
0.3292679787,
0.2983552516,
0.4418303668,
0.3438096046,
-0.0495806038,
0.6147238612,
-0.57396245,
0.9717488885,
0.253164202,
-1.2786179781,
0.5513615608,
0.0182230826,
0.6766483784,
0.3649314642,
0.111863628,
-0.9770917296,
-0.3553305566,
-0.4032306075,
-0.6735703349,
0.3687078655,
-0.1268742234,
0.129145354,
-0.387404412,
0.2447601855,
0.0638593063,
-0.0074487999,
-0.5022898316,
0.2247837633,
-0.3025411665,
-0.1147334874,
-0.0065433336,
-0.1474808902,
0.1012168154,
-0.3720306158,
0.2084654868,
-0.2548844814,
0.2444630414,
0.5296594501,
-0.6126646996,
0.2011757195,
0.5252256393,
0.592477262,
0.8117822409,
-0.0656135231,
0.2223285437,
0.6580429673,
-0.3743481338,
-0.1161357984,
-0.3094550669,
-0.2507731318,
0.200547725,
0.6283101439,
0.8538023233,
0.763371706,
-0.4449387193,
0.6331405044,
-0.0716786236,
-0.2147324234,
-0.1614477932,
-0.1191770211,
0.0681920573,
-0.0853364319,
0.0013376363,
-0.0371804833,
0.1790886819,
-0.6744264364,
-0.0609505326,
0.3654997349,
-0.6658371091,
-0.300162226,
0.2896829247,
-0.1889909208,
0.1114900261,
0.5140913129,
-0.4760691226,
-0.5248394608,
0.5159427524,
0.6971043348,
0.5790677071,
-0.3658321202,
0.2061739266,
0.4021550119,
0.127318427,
-0.1031619757,
-0.0607377104,
-0.4578351378,
-1.1985429525,
-0.2272866964,
-0.5366699696,
-0.4707501531,
-0.2034133375,
-0.9043787718,
0.2383612841,
-0.3459651768,
-0.1682281196,
-0.0376652367,
-0.2468440086,
-0.9313536882,
0.1606996059,
0.2509199679,
1.0443472862,
-0.873583138,
0.8658123612,
0.8402047753,
0.0456397831,
-0.6623488069,
0.2197953463,
-0.0343575552,
-0.6881096363,
0.7392767668,
0.2766313255,
-0.1517235786,
-0.2092705816,
-0.4553273618,
-0.7588484287,
1.3492114544,
-0.15948762,
-0.4276175201,
0.1850858182,
0.0056633172,
0.6339511275,
-0.5094227195,
0.3720968664,
0.7898721099,
0.5589773059,
-0.0722973868,
-0.773855865,
-0.0526220053,
0.0432720333,
0.431004405,
0.1108430773,
-0.1027784795,
1.0373948812,
-0.0509725474,
-0.6837751269,
-0.0303549152,
0.5118421316,
0.2652501166,
0.2790122628,
0.8787480593,
0.7942734361,
0.660110116,
-0.3665818572,
1.223246336,
-0.4850274622,
0.4497428238,
0.7541866302,
-0.5726630092,
0.9634612799,
0.3638108671,
-0.1653831899,
0.7345917225,
0.685123086,
0.3209291101,
0.8565061688,
0.3727745414,
-0.2274931669,
-0.2451705933,
-0.2853306234,
-0.5563287735,
0.3860451877,
0.6539049745,
-0.1169712245,
-0.6288731098,
0.0825249627,
0.1626574248,
0.2172645032,
-0.5733982325,
0.7372055054,
0.0895967409,
-0.785571456,
0.5812729001,
0.5011418462,
0.9848700762,
-0.4838142097,
0.2643027604,
-0.3806475401,
0.3051504791,
-0.0360707343,
-0.5616896749,
0.3521400392,
-0.0510735363,
-0.0127226645,
-0.2382966876,
0.7730031013,
-0.4688089192,
-0.4730026424,
0.8276474476,
0.3803736567,
-0.238433212,
0.00078374,
-0.7123491168,
0.3226495981,
-0.3645885289,
-0.0636698902,
0.3878727853,
0.2808993161,
-0.5517337918,
0.3284764588,
0.5830535889,
0.077512078,
0.1340942979,
0.5426547527,
0.7806649804,
-0.555877924,
-0.6512211561,
-0.4468595386,
0.1681012064,
0.0334799364,
-0.5339961052,
0.4694266021,
-0.0224317722,
1.0166933537,
-0.0447692871,
0.4143562317,
0.1348883212,
0.1712316871,
-0.7474826574,
0.2682705522,
-0.6838819385,
0.0699795783,
-0.5793076158,
-1.0474221706,
-0.3039517403,
0.689211607,
-0.4673894942,
-0.0652286112,
1.199334383,
0.8373657465,
-0.0284857377,
0.2230954617,
0.4492222965,
0.106299974,
0.2626310587,
0.4762661755,
0.9762885571,
-0.3735313416,
-0.1318378597,
-0.1021486968,
-0.3025250137,
0.0120599261,
-0.9911062121,
-0.5120536685,
-0.7878272533,
-0.6039545536,
-0.1423591375,
0.2057795376,
0.7278405428,
0.4402861595,
-0.8354529142,
0.0620629564,
-0.1009963453,
-0.0079787439,
-0.5138214827,
-0.1684554517,
0.4666635096,
-0.5752245188,
-0.6361538172,
0.6517164111,
0.3001793027,
-0.3890824318,
-0.1971298158,
-0.0221572276,
0.0749474019,
0.2329752892,
0.9609948993,
-0.1839111149,
-1.1741452217,
-0.798622191,
-0.2358876914,
-0.1996321529,
-0.140736267,
0.8963124156,
-0.8406949043,
0.3261776567,
0.4660903513,
0.4065367579,
0.3940947354,
-0.1504745781,
0.147172302,
-0.4520798326,
0.2621403039,
-0.33965078,
0.6878134608,
0.5037466288,
0.0249473415,
0.6320973039,
0.3070527315,
-0.2185343057,
-0.66681391,
0.313616246,
-0.7211731672,
-0.4885292947,
1.3409307003,
-0.1126110405,
-0.0491459705,
0.0268317703,
0.008786465,
0.0904441625,
-0.1213013902,
0.5662081242,
0.7864381075,
0.0854115188,
0.2763272524,
-0.4003371298,
0.4827168286,
0.5265527964,
-0.5514914393,
-0.2121199369,
0.4063155651,
0.4007626772,
0.1063712388,
0.4419829845,
-0.3801125586,
0.1095369384,
-0.1832991093,
0.1222920045,
0.0931926593,
-0.1427322924,
-0.4063612223,
-0.0454549231,
-0.0596775226,
0.0629707426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12419v1
|
EBFT: Effective and Block-Wise Fine-Tuning for Sparse LLMs
| 2024-02-19T09:55:32 | 2024-02-19T09:55:32 |
Song Guo, Fan Wu, Lei Zhang, Xiawu Zheng, Shengchuan Zhang, Fei Chao, Yiyu Shi, Rongrong Ji
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing methods for fine-tuning sparse LLMs often suffer from
resource-intensive requirements and high retraining costs. Additionally, many
fine-tuning methods often rely on approximations or heuristic optimization
strategies, which may lead to suboptimal solutions. To address these issues, we
propose an efficient and fast framework for fine-tuning sparse LLMs based on
minimizing reconstruction error. Our approach involves sampling a small dataset
for calibration and utilizing backpropagation to iteratively optimize
block-wise reconstruction error, on a block-by-block basis, aiming for optimal
solutions. Extensive experiments on various benchmarks consistently demonstrate
the superiority of our method over other baselines. For instance, on the
Wikitext2 dataset with LlamaV1-7B at 70% sparsity, our proposed EBFT achieves a
perplexity of 16.88, surpassing the state-of-the-art DSnoT with a perplexity of
75.14. Moreover, with a structured sparsity ratio of 26\%, EBFT achieves a
perplexity of 16.27, outperforming LoRA (perplexity 16.44). Furthermore, the
fine-tuning process of EBFT for LlamaV1-7B only takes approximately 30 minutes,
and the entire framework can be executed on a single 16GB GPU. The source code
is available at https://github.com/sunggo/EBFT.
|
[
-0.5604565144,
-1.02435112,
0.3395975828,
0.2970328033,
-0.6502367854,
0.0576917082,
-0.191131711,
-0.1600987017,
0.3416572511,
0.1937639564,
-0.968280077,
-0.1573560983,
-0.4710803926,
0.0197596941,
-0.2367071509,
0.8414925337,
-0.1040351614,
-0.136488691,
0.2262357026,
0.0148155438,
-0.4611198604,
0.1948639154,
-0.7212466598,
-0.2494581044,
0.5782051682,
0.4969454706,
0.3015603125,
0.7806937695,
0.3334070444,
0.2725001574,
-0.1894741803,
0.6472231746,
-1.212973237,
-0.0651645809,
-0.1412201673,
0.0891227201,
-0.2701937258,
-0.6043220758,
0.4743648767,
0.6584489346,
-0.4417507052,
0.294157356,
0.2279684693,
0.8893848658,
-0.5018376112,
-0.101649031,
-0.8385360241,
-0.1214747578,
0.0627670139,
-0.5930130482,
0.0801964402,
-0.3297414482,
-0.2022826374,
-0.8592966199,
0.5454961061,
0.4820240438,
0.9056791067,
0.937993288,
-0.0157844741,
0.3515264392,
-0.2428751588,
0.6567437053,
-0.3325069249,
0.3480977416,
0.3435950279,
0.1828940064,
-0.4079024792,
-0.5316210985,
-0.1030611321,
0.2115903944,
0.1136262566,
0.0962723941,
-0.1661535203,
0.3222621083,
0.4179525375,
0.3451426327,
-0.6678943634,
0.2138802856,
-0.1499918401,
-0.3870143294,
0.2896880209,
0.242472142,
-0.4856146872,
-0.0146993687,
-0.4456455112,
0.2475103289,
-0.8939244151,
-0.3085296154,
0.3935124576,
0.3163625598,
-0.0053737634,
0.3795091808,
-0.370311141,
1.07259202,
0.4577828348,
-0.2406488061,
-0.0178414434,
-0.3703423738,
-0.5063467622,
0.0362747833,
0.162861228,
0.3182229698,
0.0451818705,
0.0147307031,
-0.5562624931,
-0.1584527791,
0.1798326969,
-1.1111402512,
-0.3167230785,
0.1521576196,
-0.2215897292,
-0.1798925698,
-0.3138220906,
-0.6553540826,
-0.3480720818,
-0.4147017002,
0.7366622686,
-0.2408958077,
-0.0054970966,
0.2975621819,
0.2189697027,
0.1617022008,
0.7223934531,
-1.0026187897,
0.4349747896,
0.7590964437,
0.8562358618,
-0.0645879805,
-0.1029146686,
-0.787216723,
-0.0492084771,
-0.339941293,
0.9423971772,
0.2707977891,
-0.2382178158,
-0.3927880526,
-0.0404374562,
0.0194657892,
-0.6261945367,
0.272431165,
-0.2106419355,
-0.6942846179,
-0.1171231195,
-0.3293245435,
-0.1585676074,
0.3661253154,
-0.5446585417,
0.9819614291,
0.3335641921,
-0.3793977499,
0.2799298167,
-0.0226746779,
-0.4289111793,
-0.1752738208,
0.0844995007,
-0.6230363846,
0.3612200916,
0.3003577292,
0.4599087536,
-0.4392369986,
0.0932145044,
-0.2979910672,
-0.980388999,
-0.1362118125,
-0.4386613667,
0.2695997357,
0.2089889646,
-0.3406014442,
0.0174260978,
-1.0716673136,
0.1252583265,
-0.0031479031,
-0.366540879,
-0.0858054087,
-0.333027631,
0.2550882399,
-0.3478597105,
0.0871964619,
-0.5358378887,
0.1509138048,
-0.5114036798,
0.3679575026,
1.1102771759,
-0.0046857628,
0.0580431297,
-0.6806306243,
0.1954459548,
-0.4925656915,
0.0483485349,
-0.021854559,
-0.2444555759,
-0.6617382765,
-0.9158260822,
0.2719181478,
0.3747881651,
-0.2980982065,
0.4751634002,
-0.170306012,
-0.2502100766,
-0.5876469612,
0.3665453494,
0.3766354322,
0.5828078985,
0.4510217905,
-0.2032561004,
-0.6328434944,
-0.7896643877,
-0.0259476807,
0.1670660377,
0.2667194903,
0.5034013391,
0.4817558825,
-0.1061228365,
0.5185159445,
-0.586764276,
-0.3979683816,
0.172217384,
-0.0485421084,
0.3295402527,
0.6998195052,
0.1603469998,
-0.5438310504,
-0.3651906848,
-0.0341904797,
-0.1752561331,
-0.3604127765,
-0.1294124573,
-0.24637191,
0.114309743,
0.2908024192,
-0.2903975248,
0.4376785755,
0.4344786704,
-0.0695726126,
0.2437910587,
-0.3681955338,
0.1371678859,
-1.0066994429,
-0.0221805237,
-0.1407390386,
-0.6264922023,
-0.1176256239,
-0.0879801139,
0.0682942942,
0.20144476,
-0.228031382,
0.2884484529,
-0.4169923663,
-0.218930915,
-0.2947051525,
-0.0636259615,
-0.0057973843,
0.6340938807,
-0.2755689025,
0.511398077,
0.1620770544,
-0.2330496907,
0.5398579836,
0.0928243622,
-0.3385704756,
0.7878785729,
-0.6258689165,
0.146758616,
-0.1936462969,
0.100323759,
-1.0820767879,
-0.2721692622,
0.2060972303,
-0.227114439,
0.8374106288,
-0.4268734157,
-0.4024122655,
0.005785781,
-0.3869570494,
0.4417749643,
0.4239339828,
-0.7795015574,
0.4332977831,
0.1390240043,
0.0451488234,
-0.7651308179,
-0.6373374462,
-0.3929881155,
-0.026133338,
-0.5642541647,
0.3411781788,
-0.1907915026,
0.1253590584,
-0.0045575323,
-0.6166957021,
-0.1157468334,
0.2423379272,
0.3031089902,
-0.0323063992,
-0.0123809036,
-0.2493963987,
0.3572267294,
-0.2678538561,
-0.6461971998,
-0.3369757235,
0.4516153336,
-0.3246941268,
-0.5298841596,
-0.297108978,
0.1171260029,
0.0444503091,
0.3250754476,
0.3389411569,
0.6112197638,
-0.6934618354,
-0.4907178581,
-0.8095755577,
-0.2087691426,
-0.4596436918,
0.7754480839,
-0.4283433557,
-0.8820340037,
0.3836774826,
-0.2211806029,
-0.0399954431,
-0.0153522864,
0.6469267607,
-0.2891907692,
0.5851140022,
0.6491975784,
0.0584765896,
0.4204398394,
-0.4791426659,
-0.1541567296,
-0.7871615887,
-0.1052077636,
-0.3731153905,
-0.6194133759,
-0.3319290578,
-0.4716748595,
0.2645287216,
0.2111734748,
-0.4533424079,
0.3332813978,
-0.4788383245,
0.6908701062,
0.2578153014,
0.4255650342,
0.2768737078,
0.3793504834,
0.0694928095,
-0.1172352582,
-0.8199933767,
0.0013402002,
0.8239828944,
0.0368125215,
1.2138168812,
-0.1150590256,
0.9108595252,
-0.0687747896,
0.170053646,
-0.7374081612,
0.3326785862,
0.0381356888,
-0.4787599444,
-0.3784463406,
-0.5321155787,
-0.8080186248,
0.4796459377,
-0.1573517621,
-0.5470454693,
0.2476833314,
0.6005679369,
-0.6317523718,
0.3549317122,
-0.6034013629,
0.6538614035,
0.0096801091,
-0.7949017882,
-0.5225598812,
-0.5710979104,
0.199360162,
-0.5151417255,
0.0907430649,
-0.3752652407,
-0.2956296802,
0.1707580686,
-0.589076817,
0.6926304698,
-0.2051596045,
0.0447402522,
0.0209656172,
0.188690722,
0.6422539353,
0.230315268,
0.0965104923,
-0.0233403165,
0.1445742548,
-0.5189686418,
-0.406477809,
0.994288981,
-0.6721428633,
-0.3282021284,
-0.2155335695,
-0.7358873487,
-0.2308190763,
0.1330191493,
0.1223285273,
0.5438758135,
-0.1624555737,
0.1977120489,
0.8327402472,
-0.0802785009,
0.1280025542,
0.470094353,
0.2454178482,
-0.5768100619,
1.3117015362,
0.0667490512,
0.172311008,
0.5517644286,
-0.0161558874,
-0.1529413313,
-0.9019719958,
-0.6856242418,
0.3860468864,
-0.4604935646,
-0.8192531466,
-0.0004297628,
0.2097743005,
0.0191756859,
-0.3932402134,
-0.5620390773,
-0.5301250815,
-0.3813907504,
-0.0895743668,
0.4198077321,
0.5761924982,
-0.5285920501,
0.3848991394,
-0.4478253722,
0.4475353956,
0.0716206506,
0.6121864915,
-0.2501382232,
-0.7154421806,
-0.3147428036,
-0.1252399236,
-0.1953439116,
-0.4675116837,
0.3577748239,
0.4624734819,
0.3243393898,
0.1292714924,
-0.1472798437,
1.3995810747,
-0.3188386858,
0.169401288,
0.0268989317,
-0.6621015668,
0.3859354258,
-0.1864631176,
-0.0787928104,
0.7148167491,
-0.0630013719,
-0.026241038,
0.0123104108,
-0.3426366746,
-0.9254584908,
0.7074455023,
-0.0257155839,
-0.3181197643,
0.468824178,
0.6051515341,
0.3210536242,
0.2893977463,
-0.2397019118,
-0.2483698428,
-0.3067893386,
-0.3426769376,
-0.0368776508,
-0.1381267607,
-0.3242156506,
-0.2845661044,
0.8644095659,
-0.5276281834,
0.1949555278,
0.2656692863,
-0.4557011127,
-0.6254360676,
-0.1768009663,
0.6239470243,
0.5102928281,
-0.5006083846,
-0.0264100824,
0.4440416992,
-0.4186800718,
0.2771905661,
0.5419595242,
-0.3226729035,
-0.355406642,
-0.0741525888,
0.8432038426,
0.5643957853,
-0.4593549967,
0.4583869278,
-0.0091566993,
-0.3187835217,
-0.06660299,
-0.2659737468,
-0.0684892088,
0.5095140338,
0.3134039938,
0.3346119225,
0.0226500407,
0.1126165465,
0.1316965818,
0.484066695,
0.1611223072,
-0.1929293275,
0.5559592247,
0.0288816262,
0.1397376359,
0.387044847,
0.0278012119,
-0.0327929743,
0.5238640308,
0.5854357481,
0.6460505128,
0.1169051975,
-0.1876824498,
0.5079716444,
0.5193200707,
-0.1622195691,
0.4166202247,
-0.2219198197,
-0.570066452,
-0.7440444231,
-0.8910011053,
-0.2414113581,
-0.0242876243,
-0.4492018819,
0.2701849937,
-0.7877848148,
0.2033347934,
-0.466168642,
0.217786029,
-0.6018084288,
0.1585276127,
0.0302351993,
0.9855823517,
-0.3821739554,
0.6992352009,
0.4031748772,
-0.0778061301,
-0.8927804232,
-0.3965765834,
0.0706540793,
-1.0865960121,
0.1488122791,
0.0042586429,
-0.3280848563,
0.5879616141,
-0.495603025,
-0.9204833508,
1.2762066126,
0.6880467534,
-1.0131984949,
0.0962794721,
-0.3687154353,
0.2036951929,
0.0397376306,
-0.0345068686,
0.664485693,
0.5157464147,
0.1563191712,
-0.9939937592,
0.2713467181,
0.1123008579,
0.2059226781,
0.2939286828,
-0.8908578753,
0.3331796825,
-0.4738953412,
-0.0665737167,
0.6190131903,
0.4923972487,
0.3460335732,
0.0729947761,
0.6055800319,
0.8997300267,
0.8274077177,
-0.4485915303,
0.7246986628,
-0.3619636893,
0.608645916,
0.7223185897,
0.1580689549,
0.4216557443,
0.7934157252,
-0.0510413125,
-0.1097159237,
1.071451664,
-0.1263085902,
0.9183154106,
0.5835770369,
-0.1300010532,
-0.3724475205,
0.1541141421,
-0.3280968368,
0.0369774215,
0.4847521782,
0.2077761143,
-0.3253116608,
-0.1278489977,
-0.3645661175,
-0.2727701664,
-0.6938316226,
0.5803287029,
0.1586867422,
-0.4128264785,
1.0243707895,
-0.0534418523,
0.8215623498,
-0.6048399806,
-0.0997239053,
-0.5000033379,
0.4139990807,
-0.4995502532,
-0.2024980336,
0.1354126483,
-0.270930022,
0.1196428314,
-0.1996900886,
0.8545247316,
-0.381706953,
-0.0518090986,
0.0046878243,
0.5261229277,
0.1935148239,
-0.0591799878,
-0.5931144953,
0.419867754,
0.1511378139,
-0.5263853669,
0.4345035553,
0.278331697,
0.2956097424,
0.5644267797,
0.5451561213,
0.3918428421,
0.1503492445,
-0.051536236,
0.9704933763,
-0.4560863078,
-0.1779863089,
-0.543746829,
0.3203580081,
0.2727439404,
-0.2579504251,
0.2449076176,
0.6480535865,
0.9110085368,
0.0971803591,
0.4935998023,
-0.0959976614,
0.5287895799,
-0.6085870266,
0.4425036013,
-0.8061648607,
0.3306217194,
-0.2279366255,
-0.8950573206,
-0.4006659389,
1.1052041054,
0.3448363841,
0.0279620364,
0.4689309895,
1.4147491455,
-0.2112412453,
-0.0506496839,
0.5395399332,
0.2581558228,
-0.0916424692,
0.7613410354,
0.7426355481,
-0.5380376577,
0.7343012691,
-0.4136351049,
-0.4521482587,
-0.3710835576,
-0.8185136914,
-0.5069287419,
-0.2670017183,
-0.2577056885,
-0.3951549828,
0.4015115798,
1.242459178,
0.8058761358,
-0.6930407286,
0.026621446,
-0.146431312,
0.2108293772,
-0.350194037,
-0.1048960835,
0.2971007824,
-0.1854929924,
-0.7159760594,
0.4720848501,
0.2382871062,
0.0814865977,
-0.1520367712,
-0.205071345,
0.0975745171,
-0.1239294037,
0.4119001329,
0.3977128267,
-0.5542658567,
-0.4061264694,
-0.1330181062,
-0.0217092801,
0.0137368962,
0.7569234967,
-0.7773658633,
0.3818771541,
0.3259044588,
0.9080067277,
1.0773046017,
0.0233852454,
0.1725744307,
-0.9200262427,
0.2203714848,
0.1924671233,
0.5176514387,
0.4356153309,
-0.2432994992,
0.7040162683,
0.600969553,
-0.6166726947,
-1.1097927094,
0.1247817203,
-1.2613917589,
-0.0959356427,
1.0720528364,
-0.0634821877,
-0.2184711248,
-0.15743047,
-0.5273512602,
0.1998802423,
-0.3949204981,
0.6201100349,
0.1732553691,
-0.2735730708,
-0.1148307398,
-0.4108309448,
0.404233247,
0.4070169032,
-0.4546428621,
-0.0343811475,
0.6728294492,
0.6704341173,
-0.4466477036,
0.777523458,
0.163733393,
0.4682987928,
-0.0240463167,
-0.2478003353,
-0.5407908559,
-0.241748035,
-0.440187484,
0.0039591971,
-0.0110058924,
0.0006998313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11997v1
|
Remember This Event That Year? Assessing Temporal Information and Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-19T09:43:03 | 2024-02-19T09:43:03 |
Himanshu Beniwal, Kowsik Nandagopan D, Mayank Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly becoming ubiquitous, yet their
ability to reason about and retain temporal information remains limited. This
hinders their application in real-world scenarios where understanding the
sequential nature of events is crucial. This paper experiments with
state-of-the-art models on a novel, large-scale temporal dataset,
\textbf{TempUN}, to reveal significant limitations in temporal retention and
reasoning abilities. Interestingly, closed-source models indicate knowledge
gaps more frequently, potentially suggesting a trade-off between uncertainty
awareness and incorrect responses. Further, exploring various fine-tuning
approaches yielded no major performance improvements. The associated dataset
and code are available at the following URL
(https://github.com/lingoiitgn/TempUN).
|
[
-0.1955432743,
-0.6409725547,
1.0103294849,
0.021646142,
-0.1976999938,
-0.19839634,
-0.3209016919,
-0.5282331109,
-0.2660106719,
0.0332222544,
-0.6479239464,
-0.2656104267,
-0.3187927008,
-0.1585735679,
-0.4031282961,
0.5915164351,
-0.1536475718,
-0.3319351673,
-0.0147191687,
-0.2344231457,
-0.3115269542,
-0.7197075486,
-0.807765007,
-0.5405420065,
0.6979627013,
0.5229385495,
0.5536019802,
0.3706593812,
0.4229000509,
0.1427659094,
-0.2164413035,
0.1251505464,
-0.5625680685,
0.0670134947,
-0.4248425364,
-0.2095852047,
-0.4480979145,
-0.0456511602,
1.1126669645,
0.7070236206,
-0.1549085081,
0.267229557,
-0.2804565728,
0.2956731021,
-0.8664480448,
0.1296527833,
-0.883998692,
-0.0028049634,
-0.3321519792,
-0.3696517646,
-0.4294334352,
-0.2427867949,
0.1998072714,
-0.4502771497,
0.0301360972,
0.0962795913,
1.064467907,
0.2284544259,
-0.3082761765,
0.0875611901,
-1.0408176184,
0.8377745152,
-0.9531290531,
0.5183161497,
0.5890746713,
0.3038577437,
-0.1974181682,
-0.7236481309,
-0.6401045918,
-0.2547491491,
0.2898128629,
-0.06910263,
0.0636297092,
-0.3469309211,
0.4454688132,
0.180511564,
-0.463180542,
0.2830910385,
-0.2696380615,
-0.0808570087,
0.3730264306,
0.4816552997,
0.1740323752,
-0.0774986893,
-0.223038435,
0.0317155346,
-0.7980797887,
-0.0772222131,
0.2934700549,
0.0254975557,
0.062987186,
0.7140088677,
-0.1590696722,
0.5021647811,
-0.2155624032,
0.1035297737,
-0.032046888,
-0.2774335444,
-0.2452412546,
0.0046702041,
0.5254022479,
0.3922780752,
0.4941790402,
-0.3871591389,
-0.0401277915,
-0.1304995269,
0.0422393121,
-0.752725482,
-0.1609493643,
0.3279769123,
-0.1418410987,
0.1007582322,
0.0876194388,
-0.5857825279,
-0.234567076,
-0.1666744649,
0.2493996918,
-0.5534315705,
-0.3018525839,
0.289039433,
-0.1811419427,
0.2391631305,
0.3079053164,
-0.4750159383,
-0.142498225,
0.8969607949,
0.8573452234,
-0.2009390146,
-0.543874681,
-0.4142297208,
0.3465287387,
-0.4745894969,
0.6945742965,
-0.7258946896,
-0.1911605,
-0.2539021969,
0.0359104052,
-0.1472098827,
-0.4650173485,
0.3548114002,
-0.786144197,
0.1314476728,
-0.2539447844,
-0.5604334474,
0.0819803104,
0.1603558213,
-0.6129180193,
0.9453488588,
-0.0604534559,
-0.8576497436,
0.4330872297,
-0.0830119327,
-0.1617392004,
-0.103413336,
-0.1800466925,
-0.4402832091,
0.2029345632,
-0.0485025048,
0.2828001976,
-0.1718610823,
0.5370264649,
-0.584623456,
-0.5043610334,
0.5463411212,
-0.3107099533,
0.5741338134,
0.2444897145,
0.0290243123,
0.0052829385,
-0.7911196947,
-0.2443687171,
0.3839425445,
-0.3853124082,
-0.4198672771,
0.2965378165,
-0.0879813358,
0.1219205409,
0.4420448244,
-0.4229989052,
0.2929091454,
-0.2303738445,
0.645706296,
0.745919466,
0.3064203262,
0.423838377,
-0.5829951167,
0.302844435,
0.2987695336,
0.1635643691,
-0.3989688158,
-0.2193539888,
-0.711014986,
0.3005708158,
0.0493627265,
0.636112988,
-0.5516645908,
0.1598434299,
-0.514395833,
-0.2953463793,
0.1286403239,
-0.1149855182,
-0.084107548,
0.5137174726,
0.0362503417,
0.0438827239,
-0.6361368895,
-0.8264084458,
-0.1936789602,
-0.4711495638,
-0.1376575977,
0.0946329311,
0.5120885968,
-0.0439258516,
0.8342542648,
-0.2590719759,
0.1417283118,
-0.1100847647,
0.051389493,
0.1651482731,
0.3569418192,
0.4724361897,
-0.395975709,
0.292942673,
-0.1375857294,
-0.7890458703,
-0.0978389755,
-0.3520047963,
0.0468489528,
0.3592740297,
0.6235371232,
-0.4693080485,
0.4767918587,
0.3258915246,
-0.6082445979,
0.5320171714,
-0.2363334447,
0.2099311203,
-0.8305851221,
0.1978629231,
-0.0805852115,
-0.1108055785,
-0.5004492998,
-0.0720823407,
0.2776091397,
-0.0106980074,
-0.4918158948,
0.8519389033,
-0.4183225036,
0.1113019958,
-0.2426216155,
0.0272395909,
-0.1847237498,
0.3194119036,
0.0886912346,
0.5850037336,
0.2352087647,
-0.7570266724,
0.0869642422,
-0.0262646247,
-0.7325226068,
0.4175677896,
-0.436488837,
0.3652751446,
-0.2155068219,
-0.0302068703,
-0.6784972548,
-0.4705520272,
0.0643927157,
-0.385439992,
0.4489912391,
-0.2052658349,
-0.788000226,
-0.3342927396,
-0.1208585426,
0.461450994,
0.3982654214,
-0.4028385878,
0.6998351216,
0.2810971141,
-0.2841953635,
-0.4314215779,
-0.7494567037,
0.1978179961,
-0.3799188435,
-0.4216746986,
-0.1060157046,
-0.0662637278,
-0.602134347,
0.0936056525,
-0.4941300154,
-0.0242697168,
0.210933134,
0.1967468709,
0.3126809895,
-0.2853910029,
0.4448773265,
-0.185300827,
0.0808264315,
0.1378421932,
-0.4231926799,
0.4825189412,
-0.2441964746,
-0.4657006264,
-0.449921757,
0.1296919733,
0.6408116817,
0.12603122,
1.0195379257,
0.270688504,
-0.7825671434,
-0.0737039894,
-0.9115730524,
-0.1938095093,
-0.3903328776,
0.4329113364,
-0.2525975406,
-0.9662655592,
0.6337853074,
0.07785023,
0.1986632198,
0.4176315367,
0.3775136173,
-0.1978806853,
0.5162674189,
0.0930654109,
-0.0374137945,
0.6815829873,
0.0491096191,
0.0988278463,
-0.7113009691,
-0.4187605977,
-0.3785198629,
-0.279517293,
-0.1321868747,
-0.2720291913,
0.2767944634,
0.0984226242,
-0.6927426457,
-0.1209803447,
0.1618943512,
0.5012515783,
0.2795824409,
0.1838342398,
0.4756213725,
-0.1308045685,
0.1983291358,
-0.1006111801,
-0.9127663374,
-0.5817289352,
0.7819883823,
0.3456872404,
0.7602987289,
-0.0583186522,
0.209280774,
0.0883430764,
-0.0130580626,
-0.4663531482,
0.7711130977,
0.1680027694,
-0.5904104114,
-0.5400391221,
-0.753112793,
-1.0471435785,
-0.1611458063,
-0.153930828,
-0.9545184374,
0.2537630796,
0.019167576,
-0.3715550005,
0.7109526396,
-0.6129921079,
0.5192633867,
-0.1124778464,
-0.37341699,
-0.2213174999,
-0.3258546293,
0.3242982626,
-0.3245926797,
0.2808033526,
-0.5631546974,
-0.2119174898,
0.8425979018,
-0.1832372844,
0.7691263556,
0.0557307303,
0.0379759483,
0.3364395201,
0.3917679787,
0.5225000978,
0.1640911996,
-0.3094882667,
0.129947558,
0.2758921683,
-0.5761615038,
-0.4852849841,
0.9535723329,
-0.5301343203,
-0.7287925482,
-0.5062924027,
-0.6337105036,
-0.3470114768,
0.0576005392,
0.0959841087,
0.5330975056,
-0.3017775118,
0.1657598466,
0.7556359172,
-0.4012596011,
0.5493428707,
0.7113737464,
-0.1972728521,
-0.1118338555,
0.5639231205,
0.3722468019,
0.2337984294,
0.3117446899,
0.3358269334,
0.0346381776,
-0.561835289,
-0.1392328441,
0.4650761783,
-0.6354592443,
-0.0477359034,
-0.5751797557,
-0.186963141,
-0.3097248971,
0.1342249513,
-0.1904855967,
-0.8341939449,
-0.346955955,
-0.2135996521,
0.4518987834,
0.6176952124,
0.0498682447,
0.2167149037,
-0.7023428679,
0.1560134143,
0.0578632839,
0.4904039204,
0.3545057178,
-0.6572112441,
-0.2704406977,
-0.2444666177,
0.1476392895,
-0.9959933758,
0.0990808159,
0.2037342936,
0.6220046282,
0.3025659025,
0.2080516666,
0.4855062366,
-0.4397085011,
0.8439412713,
-0.1063862666,
-0.6858873963,
0.8555458784,
-0.4767607749,
1.0884748697,
0.2570330203,
0.2887158394,
-0.5323244333,
-0.4677339792,
-0.7823767662,
-0.9988757372,
0.8340471983,
0.0617102571,
-0.306946516,
0.0056380127,
0.6420282722,
-0.0436289832,
-0.0804650635,
-0.2933041453,
-0.0055693546,
0.1873926371,
0.0350975357,
-0.1414108723,
-0.5576498508,
0.0746503919,
-0.1258827597,
0.5942219496,
0.1959085613,
-0.0173254311,
0.1798150539,
-0.0184899047,
-0.129275918,
0.4397083819,
0.5644070506,
1.0688862801,
-0.3877507448,
0.2797010243,
0.7437642217,
-0.3826378584,
-0.0930215418,
0.1185088605,
-0.2339296937,
-0.1983700246,
0.63450104,
0.6609499454,
0.4027894735,
-0.815050602,
0.1132428274,
-0.0749270245,
0.1431124806,
-0.6781278253,
0.0075119534,
0.2794756889,
0.4193572998,
0.4014263451,
-0.2751815915,
-0.1803769022,
-0.8204674721,
0.0369663164,
0.0880190954,
-0.199602887,
-0.3391567469,
0.6603333354,
-0.2901470065,
-0.0643152148,
0.8911765218,
0.033992976,
-0.4144704938,
0.6082974076,
0.215678528,
0.6131397486,
-0.2514004707,
-0.3465557992,
0.559476316,
0.543276906,
-0.3085905612,
0.426335454,
0.0820014924,
-0.6344740987,
-0.5074928999,
-0.4068210125,
-0.3841487467,
0.378783077,
-0.5470348597,
0.0546902493,
-0.5717275143,
-0.5740779638,
-0.2514853477,
-0.0985932276,
-0.8448986411,
-0.0753210708,
0.1472263485,
1.2279815674,
-0.6777868271,
0.9202111363,
0.5746154189,
-0.2485715598,
-0.4095932543,
-0.0033033383,
0.0414026231,
-0.5990630984,
0.4935253561,
-0.206682846,
-0.0587980486,
-0.3881620765,
-0.4959901571,
-0.76514256,
1.0703668594,
0.2417270094,
-0.934987545,
-0.431537807,
-0.0056550675,
0.4485827088,
-0.0747177601,
0.0580465198,
0.9009353518,
0.5671131611,
0.2879949212,
-1.1178382635,
-0.0733698979,
-0.1416606456,
-0.0954915136,
0.3669489026,
-0.6437345147,
0.5584038496,
-0.445527643,
-0.6677111387,
0.0866500884,
0.8146314621,
0.2698999047,
0.8060094118,
0.3951229453,
0.7046271563,
0.9476906657,
-0.3655658662,
1.1485650539,
0.1301277727,
0.0298045557,
1.5693796873,
-0.3195475042,
0.9369591475,
0.3944405019,
0.1474185884,
0.0967362747,
0.6869462132,
0.1439206302,
0.2253101915,
0.0345376693,
-0.2723277509,
-0.5987715125,
0.0241245795,
-0.3852190673,
0.0012924181,
0.6657116413,
-0.0276039597,
-0.2281617969,
0.0223158542,
0.1900939941,
-0.1458645463,
-0.3719778359,
0.6087445021,
0.2539667487,
-0.4857733846,
0.2657780647,
-0.3057773113,
0.244922936,
-0.5860720277,
0.2322832346,
-0.2400646061,
0.371987164,
-0.0034254054,
-1.0656927824,
0.4912934899,
0.102275148,
-0.0579594225,
-0.0088034654,
0.5313601494,
-0.2466285676,
-0.5560794473,
0.2324217111,
0.5159829259,
0.2410299033,
0.0176931322,
-0.294928968,
0.5307123661,
-0.3294579089,
-0.3900694549,
0.2049055696,
0.9926837683,
-0.1492149681,
0.9921903014,
0.1353694052,
0.4003445804,
0.0807334185,
0.2428513914,
0.5349498987,
-0.9966129065,
-0.1871523559,
-0.9322746992,
-0.0434825048,
0.0379269421,
-0.332382977,
0.7115385532,
0.7250579,
0.9300988317,
0.1895245016,
0.5599558949,
0.3546141386,
0.5678947568,
-0.7131351233,
0.3983120322,
-0.5447199941,
0.3639930785,
0.1634506732,
-0.6157591343,
-0.2119345814,
0.2411021292,
-0.5162310004,
0.0350375511,
0.7168601155,
0.4882341027,
-0.0726845264,
0.1240868494,
0.3997707069,
0.4383237064,
0.1817209423,
1.0641773939,
1.4712063074,
-0.081805706,
0.4788132608,
-0.1004069746,
-0.1755063385,
-0.3388983905,
-1.1069812775,
-1.0964002609,
-0.8920888305,
-0.4507536292,
-0.458501786,
0.4583776295,
0.9816938639,
0.5240388513,
-0.8305591345,
-0.0766816437,
0.4516344666,
-0.1000720784,
0.1178538874,
-0.1616638601,
0.2822181582,
-0.094324857,
-0.5283863544,
0.4347084463,
0.2332151234,
0.2906411588,
0.0618825927,
0.1868916899,
-0.1997485906,
0.2031299174,
0.4911807477,
0.489797622,
-0.7153135538,
-0.4877705872,
0.0505507998,
0.0335771255,
-0.059109401,
0.9753153324,
-0.6995751858,
0.2863434553,
0.6342012882,
0.3991679847,
0.7158218622,
-0.222156316,
0.5457581282,
-0.3352502286,
0.1149317399,
0.2585117817,
0.7209872603,
0.3242705762,
-0.3094425499,
0.4835594296,
0.0759992301,
-0.6607197523,
-0.8206993937,
0.2467410862,
-1.1785963774,
-0.55246979,
1.2306393385,
0.1083871499,
-0.0997349173,
-0.1558394134,
0.0577830859,
0.3356927335,
-0.3749115765,
0.881731987,
1.1827059984,
0.0285785384,
-0.3707234263,
-0.7786912918,
0.1878233105,
0.1544648707,
-0.575060606,
0.1441773623,
0.619766295,
0.4216112494,
-0.0870650113,
0.4441772401,
-0.1042915955,
0.2635791898,
-0.0837413892,
-0.4052543938,
-0.2372795939,
-0.6555270553,
-0.3629453778,
0.1664659232,
0.2210496664,
0.1756022424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14843v1
|
Text Diffusion with Reinforced Conditioning
| 2024-02-19T09:24:02 | 2024-02-19T09:24:02 |
Yuxuan Liu, Tianchi Yang, Shaohan Huang, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Diffusion models have demonstrated exceptional capability in generating
high-quality images, videos, and audio. Due to their adaptiveness in iterative
refinement, they provide a strong potential for achieving better
non-autoregressive sequence generation. However, existing text diffusion models
still fall short in their performance due to a challenge in handling the
discreteness of language. This paper thoroughly analyzes text diffusion models
and uncovers two significant limitations: degradation of self-conditioning
during training and misalignment between training and sampling. Motivated by
our findings, we propose a novel Text Diffusion model called TREC, which
mitigates the degradation with Reinforced Conditioning and the misalignment by
Time-Aware Variance Scaling. Our extensive experiments demonstrate the
competitiveness of TREC against autoregressive, non-autoregressive, and
diffusion baselines. Moreover, qualitative analysis shows its advanced ability
to fully utilize the diffusion process in refining samples.
|
[
-0.4369580448,
-1.0375007391,
0.4325192273,
0.3789532185,
-0.119720608,
0.2902968526,
-0.024074113,
-0.1402705163,
-0.0885973722,
0.2359773815,
-0.4640991092,
-0.4020932019,
-0.7355132103,
0.1771159321,
-0.8742970228,
1.0772360563,
-0.1891100705,
-0.1714326292,
-0.0472356975,
-0.4684638977,
-0.5702012777,
-0.1438941509,
-0.9217188954,
-0.533125937,
0.0319385566,
0.2737893164,
0.4956213832,
0.5809960365,
0.1663362086,
0.2606646419,
-0.1061457694,
-0.0561193973,
-0.4563763738,
0.3427591026,
-0.2672004402,
0.0745000541,
-0.0986196548,
-0.0798183233,
0.9657154679,
0.6036995649,
-0.5127335191,
-0.2417470515,
0.1778084189,
0.8215304613,
-0.5449521542,
-0.5379543304,
-0.379684478,
0.1174301729,
-0.0756058544,
-0.1396798939,
-0.5765451193,
-0.3385965824,
0.1689273417,
-0.5748383999,
0.7967193127,
-0.0279916041,
0.6843748689,
0.3726018667,
-0.5260483623,
-0.1192035675,
-0.9349043369,
0.7466810346,
-0.5514859557,
0.2948738337,
0.3756771982,
0.0862309486,
0.1068851501,
-0.6340293288,
-0.6081387997,
-0.0463876165,
0.3413358629,
0.1262100637,
-0.1264825016,
-0.1583813727,
-0.0430075265,
0.3825084269,
-0.7037816644,
0.0620073415,
-0.1544114649,
0.1196743399,
0.3111915886,
0.1226376519,
0.2786595225,
-0.0346139111,
-0.5351935029,
-0.1529720426,
-0.2715643644,
-0.1991729289,
0.366153568,
-0.1218362227,
-0.0610901155,
0.2683639228,
0.0656082332,
0.4391663074,
0.3785939813,
0.0228362195,
0.1753758937,
-0.3151316643,
-0.2824596763,
-0.0051179421,
0.878962636,
0.0912801102,
0.1557136029,
-0.0887881219,
-0.2724590302,
-0.1258339733,
0.5473160744,
-0.6957306862,
-0.2804434597,
0.0561317839,
-0.6128501296,
-0.2805089653,
-0.3498906791,
-0.9129154682,
-0.063783206,
0.1523061246,
0.3476859331,
-0.5676001906,
-0.456217587,
0.2544130683,
-0.3282359242,
-0.2075532377,
0.1163125709,
-0.9629547,
0.4287317991,
0.1124766544,
1.2011598349,
-0.4707013369,
0.0280835796,
-0.0158713311,
0.189644888,
-0.3965549469,
1.043847084,
-0.5621039867,
-0.8740267754,
-0.0082617048,
-0.1413089633,
-0.1006857678,
-0.4944162071,
0.4478153288,
-0.5092789531,
0.1724544466,
0.2473226935,
-0.4022598267,
0.1155085266,
0.0845153704,
-0.9324185252,
1.3660351038,
0.2459752709,
-0.9270271063,
0.2290416211,
-0.4274245501,
-0.6682177782,
-0.2500579655,
0.3106848598,
-0.7856628299,
0.1072874367,
0.0839310288,
0.2347450256,
-0.1339808851,
0.4682678878,
-0.5037246943,
-0.1545701921,
0.3310205042,
-0.7010954022,
0.1927836537,
0.555588603,
-0.2257083505,
-0.3711997569,
-0.6816061139,
-0.2567768991,
-0.1470430642,
-0.4453735054,
-0.5152175426,
0.0429804288,
0.1283843368,
0.320918113,
-0.2459491193,
-0.3290987313,
0.2441684306,
-0.3740671873,
0.6279471517,
0.7004284859,
0.39098382,
0.9078121781,
-0.3416052163,
0.5891488194,
0.1611257195,
0.0321032107,
-0.0596133433,
-0.2791699171,
-0.7839157581,
0.0003885734,
0.4005768895,
0.3982721567,
-1.1825759411,
-0.041184321,
-0.1909120977,
-0.3479177952,
-0.4280336499,
-0.0139867207,
0.3255099356,
0.5955876708,
0.6164498329,
-0.4349783659,
-0.2831166387,
-0.8207481503,
-0.3301106989,
0.1311062425,
0.0807027817,
-0.0906223878,
0.4686625004,
-0.2386809587,
0.8304012418,
-0.2610942125,
-0.1020271033,
-0.2140865922,
0.8474162221,
-0.1509506553,
0.8431811333,
0.5441219807,
-0.7500455976,
-0.4843749106,
-0.35051018,
-0.1172687337,
-0.3278538585,
-0.4895606339,
-0.2397177368,
0.4103647172,
0.5282394886,
-0.2211937904,
0.6203691363,
0.6865945458,
-0.3104597032,
0.3911194205,
-0.3842400014,
0.4157812893,
-1.0605359077,
0.0152336694,
0.6722922325,
-0.4728004336,
-0.5451191664,
-0.4938661456,
-0.0281810481,
-0.0145887425,
-0.2179621309,
0.6711303592,
-0.222350508,
0.2958780527,
-0.4600543082,
0.2090999931,
0.1652980447,
0.3608183563,
0.3816524744,
0.8099390268,
0.1818371266,
-1.0717291832,
-0.2149847746,
0.1764781177,
-0.2356109768,
0.9064837098,
-0.7118504047,
-0.1188803315,
-0.2152423412,
0.3242802322,
-1.3313823938,
0.0966655985,
0.0270687882,
-0.4883624613,
0.7314376831,
0.1045478657,
-0.2819746733,
-0.3436997235,
-0.1138637513,
0.8647530079,
0.4831303358,
-0.3402307928,
0.4528995752,
0.1054807752,
-0.1332059354,
-0.6323227882,
-1.1043503284,
-0.1016669646,
-0.1707963496,
-0.4038670361,
0.6661584377,
-0.3331684172,
-0.0596944727,
-0.0421320535,
-0.2754899859,
-0.4282016754,
-0.0248125009,
0.0774601027,
-0.1094655618,
0.1862656623,
0.5413961411,
0.1762984395,
-0.1091431454,
-0.2735696435,
-0.63750875,
0.3017455041,
0.3751535416,
-0.1583160907,
-0.5149196982,
0.5508810282,
0.3868261278,
0.101192683,
0.7711479068,
0.5507675409,
-0.1447866708,
-0.3439494073,
-0.7024360895,
0.1840560138,
-0.4830398858,
0.225653246,
-0.2776235342,
-0.7997866869,
0.1968957335,
-0.1392340213,
-0.0544717796,
0.6850057244,
0.5726578236,
-0.3599113822,
0.9383333325,
0.8017276525,
0.1957078427,
0.779345274,
-0.2942979336,
-0.0192969497,
-0.6556075215,
-0.2230342627,
-0.8138353825,
-0.3992367983,
-0.5662406087,
-0.4498502314,
0.102805756,
-0.3018823266,
-0.3820474148,
0.2419807315,
-0.5515888929,
0.3290830851,
0.4724617004,
0.0691491738,
0.3824596703,
0.0375350416,
-0.4226113558,
-0.0789946541,
-0.6646113396,
-0.4626322091,
0.6212199926,
0.4783849418,
0.9801349044,
0.0088885128,
0.4990439713,
0.8721801043,
0.3161641955,
-0.3885049522,
0.1769249737,
-0.2825499773,
-0.6304994822,
-0.2633475363,
-0.611715138,
-0.9482881427,
-0.0816362575,
-0.108724378,
-0.3075906038,
0.3678248525,
0.1316967756,
-0.164576754,
0.3970308602,
-0.5935670137,
0.7492286563,
0.2080938965,
-0.4936323464,
-0.2933447361,
-0.4337032735,
0.3009799421,
-0.1830683947,
0.4170956016,
0.0939684883,
-0.0957417712,
0.6242759824,
-0.4068385959,
0.5341925621,
-0.1210977361,
-0.1133073047,
0.470002979,
0.5822030902,
0.2216854095,
0.0019380915,
-0.0897473544,
-0.4029042125,
-0.0483920686,
-0.6305910945,
-0.5450050831,
0.6237913966,
-0.6393457651,
-0.3573633432,
-0.3223055005,
-0.2317947,
-0.2135804296,
-0.0467870608,
0.651661098,
0.3000882268,
-0.4976346493,
0.1159295663,
1.0543203354,
-0.2811593115,
0.9683386087,
0.4952663481,
0.2746284306,
-0.5992275476,
0.7125912309,
-0.0094672767,
0.5794560909,
0.4524292052,
0.0005895197,
-0.5344207287,
-0.7240825891,
-0.0546013489,
0.2590218484,
-0.526915133,
-0.1976352483,
-0.7491636872,
-0.0924475417,
-0.4654654562,
-0.1820807904,
-0.476219207,
-0.66029495,
-0.6083735824,
-0.2200361788,
0.1230063513,
0.8324455023,
-0.0244888254,
0.7430179715,
-0.7315099835,
0.3706085086,
0.1438131481,
0.5537321568,
0.0976293012,
-0.8821917176,
-0.4349132478,
-0.2504302561,
-0.5534623861,
-0.8846872449,
0.6459083557,
0.256695807,
0.3734328449,
0.3035793006,
0.004527546,
0.5124512315,
-0.4883472919,
0.9124385715,
0.2937870324,
-1.0681843758,
0.4364857972,
-0.2069002092,
0.546061039,
0.5634523034,
0.4003642201,
-0.6503970623,
-0.4797165692,
-0.792994082,
-0.7675497532,
0.3800813258,
0.3613277376,
0.1448888481,
-0.2949148118,
0.5455731153,
0.020044256,
0.11293865,
-1.0637582541,
0.0150926784,
-0.6209313273,
-0.3431162238,
0.1335230172,
-0.4752216339,
0.2148290128,
0.0638986304,
0.9967680573,
0.1057405248,
0.166190356,
0.4723123312,
-0.2520649731,
-0.0051130573,
0.1907832325,
0.5889942646,
-0.0855566189,
0.2994216084,
0.0689220876,
0.1246675476,
-0.5266187191,
0.5641124845,
-0.2126774937,
-0.1199360341,
0.1083582863,
0.306409806,
0.6581873298,
0.1551995128,
-0.2622310519,
0.4197313786,
-0.2041027844,
-0.4981012344,
0.0553903393,
-0.0311338324,
-0.200363338,
0.1327376962,
0.4374925196,
0.2853370607,
0.2793684006,
-0.0710263476,
0.3505529165,
0.2445140034,
-0.407599628,
-0.0826024637,
0.8872299194,
0.3762721121,
-0.2145937979,
0.6465156674,
-0.1186679155,
-0.1766857952,
0.5602984428,
0.5208861828,
0.9339452982,
-0.4521916211,
0.504178524,
0.5170251131,
0.2930223942,
-0.6129131913,
-0.164098382,
-0.4170865119,
-0.3902774453,
-0.3061582148,
-0.4584781528,
-0.0200665239,
-0.3023613393,
-0.5097767711,
0.0338038467,
-0.4167431593,
-0.7497245669,
-0.3888328671,
-0.1723796129,
-0.5058944821,
0.4121724069,
-0.0988184363,
1.0486569405,
-0.8466851711,
0.9399098754,
0.1323587149,
-0.3047810793,
-0.487872839,
0.1227230355,
-0.3507395983,
-0.3629766703,
0.521217525,
-0.1147863567,
-0.178869769,
-0.0015693534,
-0.4806121588,
-0.6780772209,
0.8779607415,
-0.0069659231,
-0.3560638428,
-0.3393084705,
-0.016765736,
0.7318122983,
-0.2198660821,
0.255639255,
0.6808136106,
0.4377566576,
0.4607810676,
-0.5945231915,
-0.1733204871,
-0.2506502867,
0.5444267988,
0.1568662971,
-0.8328697681,
0.6355165839,
0.0882443488,
-0.5428367853,
0.2892155349,
0.7094094753,
-0.1919591576,
0.2860892117,
0.3636537492,
0.9118079543,
0.4802017212,
-0.1293498874,
0.9133656025,
0.0508354716,
0.4157396555,
1.0860857964,
-0.0136235841,
0.5846848488,
0.303871125,
0.003646363,
1.0092228651,
0.8643476367,
0.1018596143,
0.7347071767,
0.0231595132,
-0.3487731814,
-0.1601797491,
-0.0148166288,
-0.1997949183,
0.0420037135,
0.3735197186,
-0.4974009693,
-0.1875983477,
0.2732208371,
-0.3155688047,
0.3461385965,
-0.1665691733,
0.6258142591,
-0.027189469,
-0.8960263133,
0.5402076244,
0.1612035334,
0.7309869528,
-0.4465880692,
0.1948120296,
-0.5050032139,
-0.0234546829,
-0.1736277938,
-0.7967143059,
0.5103516579,
-0.1010979638,
-0.3801854849,
-0.6506006718,
0.5412768722,
-0.6090556979,
-0.1255506575,
0.1324975938,
0.2783231139,
-0.1939179599,
0.1036467552,
-0.5899951458,
-0.1200187504,
-0.1212848499,
-0.4163818359,
0.0683245733,
0.8413313031,
0.2139589339,
0.9299892187,
0.2282204479,
-0.0087163607,
0.0536385626,
0.1562339067,
0.3955791891,
-0.6451726556,
-0.4957874417,
-0.9927610755,
0.5155313015,
0.0057947524,
-0.1543878317,
0.529132247,
0.3525291681,
0.4650663137,
-0.0560160354,
0.6930038333,
0.3394831717,
0.4074726999,
-0.6180772185,
0.5498294234,
-0.5497354269,
0.2802917957,
-0.3027675748,
-0.5879157186,
-0.1071994603,
0.5019630194,
-0.1100993752,
0.3484704494,
0.9608099461,
0.3956047297,
0.0827214122,
-0.0783586204,
0.1382507384,
0.1032635272,
0.45429793,
0.6767989993,
0.7219597101,
-0.3769725859,
0.8329470754,
0.058683753,
-0.0206524059,
-0.0449343175,
-0.9563685656,
-0.9352098107,
-0.8606109619,
-0.5827285647,
-0.5739907622,
-0.0598052293,
0.4272380471,
0.9344831705,
-0.3987126648,
-0.0040417062,
-0.4581202567,
0.2297146916,
-0.0524156243,
-0.2910215259,
0.0387600102,
-0.4240505993,
-0.8594949245,
0.049711436,
0.2943466306,
0.9300639629,
-0.379930675,
0.1743632257,
-0.3848809004,
0.3375837207,
0.2500468493,
0.3688484132,
-0.2404647022,
-0.0478756651,
-0.1025890708,
-0.3486706913,
0.3036780059,
1.1463747025,
-1.0364294052,
0.572173059,
0.5133138299,
0.5114985108,
0.8602723479,
0.2028573155,
0.6924544573,
-1.0847281218,
0.1512256414,
0.2873569429,
0.1506067216,
0.3310996294,
-0.2979607284,
0.3950217366,
0.3784307241,
-0.7205048203,
-0.5466560125,
0.1622933745,
-0.6767782569,
-0.6707932949,
1.0524733067,
0.1666345596,
-0.1691367775,
-0.2623281777,
-0.1074072197,
0.5481894016,
-0.5562623739,
0.9610775709,
1.1769890785,
0.045457039,
-0.2578047216,
-0.3736600578,
0.5891780853,
0.4622199535,
-0.5926901102,
-0.05017858,
0.4390422404,
0.3814536631,
-0.0685517788,
0.837544024,
-0.0902991593,
0.0989259779,
0.0359156094,
-0.0980629623,
0.25864169,
-0.4743293524,
-0.5285882354,
0.1776376516,
-0.0324281678,
-0.0654281303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11975v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11975v2
|
Compress to Impress: Unleashing the Potential of Compressive Memory in Real-World Long-Term Conversations
| 2024-02-19T09:19:50 | 2024-07-01T09:38:06 |
Nuo Chen, Hongguang Li, Juhua Huang, Baoyuan Wang, Jia Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing retrieval-based methods have made significant strides in maintaining
long-term conversations. However, these approaches face challenges in memory
database management and accurate memory retrieval, hindering their efficacy in
dynamic, real-world interactions. This study introduces a novel framework,
COmpressive Memory-Enhanced Dialogue sYstems (COMEDY), which eschews
traditional retrieval modules and memory databases. Instead, COMEDY adopts a
"One-for-All" approach, utilizing a single language model to manage memory
generation, compression, and response generation. Central to this framework is
the concept of compressive memory, which intergrates session-specific
summaries, user-bot dynamics, and past events into a concise memory format. To
support COMEDY, we curated a large-scale Chinese instruction-tuning dataset,
Dolphin, derived from real user-chatbot interactions. Comparative evaluations
demonstrate COMEDY's superiority over traditional retrieval-based methods in
producing more nuanced and human-like conversational experiences. Our codes are
available at https://github.com/nuochenpku/COMEDY.
|
[
-0.2858441174,
-1.026325345,
0.2761591077,
0.379334867,
-0.4107520282,
0.0850987509,
-0.6288498044,
-0.2653561532,
0.6751746535,
0.2937251627,
-0.5327390432,
-0.1231351569,
-0.1757201254,
-0.150350824,
-0.3407222629,
0.5956404805,
0.6199324131,
-0.3782307506,
-0.1307356358,
-0.2424145341,
-0.6277899742,
-0.7923609018,
-0.8398682475,
-0.1826603115,
0.4475605488,
0.4511017799,
1.0498665571,
0.3243054748,
0.2869147658,
0.242176801,
0.0521640405,
0.2538537681,
-0.8798315525,
0.2293099463,
0.0883425102,
-0.2727164328,
-0.3486966491,
-0.3662480712,
0.4462735653,
0.7182428837,
-0.6512473822,
-0.3223465383,
0.1951909661,
0.5223299265,
-0.868290484,
0.2063306868,
-0.4908631146,
0.3269506991,
0.2344634384,
-0.5464838743,
-0.7383803129,
-0.3295232356,
-0.090392679,
-0.631912291,
-0.2129993737,
-0.015559745,
0.8018426299,
0.3630725443,
0.0816854164,
-0.3484533429,
-0.7019251585,
0.6789395809,
-0.5754392147,
0.0591723062,
0.2245347947,
0.3194698691,
-0.3479039371,
-0.7069040537,
-0.4895112216,
-0.1542292237,
0.0774192065,
0.3556071818,
-0.1320329905,
0.162214905,
0.1971447468,
0.3913319707,
-0.5185232759,
-0.1074608117,
-0.1192903146,
0.0191220958,
0.3600950539,
0.118058376,
0.5100049376,
-0.2785112262,
-0.1646538526,
-0.1353801191,
-0.4779648185,
-0.1686535776,
0.1712767184,
0.293674469,
-0.0371453241,
0.0953934044,
-0.2489480078,
0.4416794777,
-0.1058175787,
0.0038933207,
-0.1533539742,
0.0091197239,
-0.2762869895,
0.2022075206,
0.9358119369,
0.3931698501,
0.3919869065,
-0.2032935172,
0.1470757723,
-0.2611265779,
0.3126798272,
-0.7534896135,
-0.5583387017,
0.0650502294,
-0.4893526733,
-0.2482198328,
0.1643244028,
-0.7986425757,
-0.3377960026,
0.1255299896,
0.5046498775,
-0.6431822181,
-0.2190197855,
0.3318784535,
-0.4591507316,
-0.1636131406,
0.4577502906,
-0.6595479846,
0.5856907964,
0.6545877457,
0.8152096272,
0.0099208169,
0.0641994849,
-0.8277702928,
0.2878949642,
-0.2339351177,
0.7308887243,
-0.6785502434,
-0.2427244037,
0.1693889946,
-0.1949430555,
0.1852699965,
-0.8937579393,
0.6412593126,
-0.1968318224,
0.2562802136,
0.1140070558,
-0.3410154879,
0.0934375152,
0.2588486969,
-0.6059317589,
0.8888064623,
0.0670644566,
-0.4351868033,
-0.1209110618,
-0.3091304898,
-0.5721781254,
0.1259303242,
-0.2691077292,
-0.0418905579,
0.3172026277,
0.1838035583,
0.3522774875,
-0.373927623,
0.3888590336,
-0.3720434308,
-0.9273364544,
0.4029598236,
-0.7775140405,
0.3988949656,
0.3307838738,
0.0754589513,
-0.4248652756,
-0.6649484634,
0.1395554394,
0.1075265929,
-0.4914206266,
-0.2723482549,
0.1466410309,
-0.3294359446,
0.1862965524,
0.1681331545,
-0.3981653452,
0.1156931892,
-0.515433073,
0.5942755938,
0.4677551091,
-0.0364197977,
-0.0057826675,
-0.4733181596,
0.3953652978,
0.1540413499,
0.2678881288,
-0.8301650286,
-0.203470096,
-0.8798983097,
-0.0313935876,
-0.039932888,
0.7062690854,
-0.7940948009,
0.4937737286,
-0.6163365245,
-0.1581809223,
-0.222482115,
-0.0651095062,
0.2569482923,
0.2886427343,
0.3513149619,
-0.7035037279,
-0.4981261194,
-0.5929836631,
-0.1086217538,
-0.2992439568,
-0.1951637864,
0.6621813178,
-0.3238872588,
0.6073764563,
0.5754184127,
-0.6063200235,
-0.0376268812,
-0.43483603,
0.0254933983,
0.3468021452,
0.4797371924,
0.1523289531,
-0.5287197232,
-0.4354610741,
-0.5266301036,
-0.6398899555,
0.1369447559,
-0.4669297636,
0.0676568747,
0.1848716438,
0.4167582989,
-0.8012309074,
0.4573098123,
0.1777059138,
0.0739505813,
0.5512550473,
-0.3653369844,
0.3555224538,
-0.9565719962,
-0.0375351347,
-0.3098454475,
-0.3240604401,
-0.3558887839,
-0.0297522377,
-0.1046568304,
-0.4662012458,
-0.4783791602,
0.4922224879,
-0.3694414198,
0.0245812014,
-0.2204391807,
0.4238915443,
-0.0171760768,
0.6582266092,
0.0075194202,
0.6493382454,
0.4943784177,
-0.6243312359,
0.4732156396,
0.2585463226,
-0.3840185702,
0.6289186478,
-0.585727632,
0.4036139846,
0.09288311,
0.4698530734,
-1.0445139408,
-0.3390815258,
0.2426097095,
-0.4709938467,
0.5169466734,
-0.1494710594,
-0.8020088673,
-0.3972394764,
-0.4200142324,
0.0358126462,
0.7814081311,
-0.566837132,
0.3348697722,
0.1969654709,
-0.548004508,
-0.6245228052,
-0.5996865034,
0.6587117314,
-0.3741101623,
-0.5391554832,
0.3088351488,
-0.3029652238,
0.0398971997,
-0.2392331511,
-0.1015453786,
-0.2094855756,
0.1252278835,
0.0562528856,
0.0750969276,
-0.2938664556,
0.2581849694,
0.0628753006,
0.1097731888,
-0.1596750021,
-0.0365063548,
0.9339442849,
0.3299531639,
-0.2021331489,
-0.7417984009,
0.4565922022,
0.2410023063,
0.4026879668,
0.5386415124,
0.29911834,
-0.1012447253,
-0.1986445934,
-0.5309653878,
-0.2633384764,
-0.5446954966,
0.4561132789,
-0.335641712,
-0.7129907608,
0.2787292302,
-0.4474990368,
-0.3274289072,
-0.1169259101,
0.1256885529,
-0.2410599142,
0.9271892905,
0.4540944397,
-0.1576036662,
0.6250877976,
0.1309359521,
0.2713398039,
-0.6933420897,
0.1832134575,
-0.2815954089,
-0.5187374949,
-0.1291062385,
-0.4184421301,
0.2254649401,
0.1415252239,
-0.350949198,
0.330670774,
-0.5073600411,
0.6710245609,
0.3181395829,
0.2607192397,
0.121102795,
0.1579333246,
0.0913598239,
-0.0662385449,
-0.8930106759,
-0.3520608842,
0.5127343535,
0.1361744106,
1.0814963579,
0.2599958181,
0.6779252887,
0.3262452185,
-0.1441891342,
-0.6838661432,
0.8754720092,
-0.449411124,
-0.0492522754,
-0.0746006295,
-0.5763283372,
-1.0315682888,
-0.1869645268,
0.092089951,
-1.1928651333,
-0.0822636411,
0.037475273,
-0.7603815794,
0.1253776848,
-0.5071028471,
0.5881618261,
-0.0947882384,
-0.6488442421,
-0.6656600237,
-0.7397507429,
0.3085228205,
0.3197799325,
0.0737250894,
0.0177702121,
0.2380752116,
0.4676826298,
-0.1679877788,
0.9460974336,
-0.0236977637,
0.1894028783,
0.2954808176,
0.3640666008,
0.3122370243,
0.1216823384,
-0.2418308258,
-0.1298513114,
0.0937687084,
-0.3004561961,
-1.0781860352,
0.7701938748,
-0.5300550461,
-0.7248038054,
-0.0882805064,
-0.6832113862,
-0.143838957,
-0.1666979641,
-0.1700620502,
0.7137598991,
-0.3963976502,
0.3931598961,
0.5334824324,
-0.8577847481,
0.4944583774,
0.3356150091,
-0.1012107506,
-0.5882383585,
1.0486431122,
0.0708242133,
0.397411406,
0.4478763938,
0.1882304251,
-0.0578886718,
0.1545571536,
-0.2820204496,
0.1207705885,
-0.764705956,
-0.2660052478,
-0.6568694711,
-0.3024449646,
-0.519094646,
-0.0920765549,
-0.3307754099,
-0.9566608071,
-0.1556776613,
0.1841036379,
0.0603636876,
0.4240798056,
-0.1363058835,
0.2906264663,
-0.8896442056,
0.2720268667,
-0.0161052216,
0.2063705921,
0.2069529891,
-0.5339930654,
-0.3270176351,
-0.0370341502,
-0.7100248337,
-0.7185226679,
0.6691096425,
0.762124896,
0.4154495597,
0.521876812,
0.4125340283,
1.1083862782,
-0.3103227019,
0.9610310793,
0.2935920656,
-0.5877750516,
0.7405874729,
0.065993838,
0.2369093299,
0.3746866584,
0.0806314275,
-0.6924031973,
-0.4345522821,
-0.8638758659,
-0.8246284723,
0.7932186723,
0.0120710218,
0.7794471979,
-0.3945512474,
0.6296151876,
0.043725796,
0.2378341258,
-0.3095199168,
-0.2214206904,
-0.1031870916,
-0.3454256654,
0.0102310572,
-0.2373203188,
-0.1203069091,
-0.1075258851,
0.2984026968,
-0.1749206036,
0.5863710046,
0.1033139154,
0.0420221426,
0.0488312505,
0.4278686643,
0.5130755305,
0.1432214975,
-0.3481958807,
0.259439379,
-0.009144228,
-0.3340955079,
-0.0519869588,
0.0492075533,
0.1712120622,
0.0252444558,
-0.0562155284,
0.8204885125,
0.5981662869,
-0.9828820229,
0.4038050771,
-0.2764743865,
0.3243575692,
-0.3624564111,
0.543382585,
0.0178384818,
0.0347379595,
0.3787060678,
-0.1861398518,
0.2296698689,
-1.0891793966,
0.4151936173,
0.2576063871,
-0.5852172375,
-0.2241318971,
0.3970057964,
0.2700409293,
-0.4321886897,
0.9060467482,
-0.1735639125,
-0.4335086346,
0.4149104059,
0.8619331121,
0.6181170344,
0.0195019394,
0.1996496916,
0.6287693977,
-0.1788454205,
-0.2506762743,
0.337210238,
-0.5352002978,
-0.5771124363,
-0.4508610368,
-0.274682194,
-0.522814095,
0.0103908731,
-0.7137072086,
0.27249524,
-0.5085561872,
-0.0584538952,
-0.572599709,
0.122262232,
-0.1295897514,
0.0957802013,
0.3382866085,
1.0608371496,
-0.3225354254,
0.9624811411,
0.2845206261,
-0.3910917044,
-0.6478176713,
0.1214871332,
-0.2056033313,
-0.7695710063,
0.4719694853,
0.3732891381,
0.1131785214,
0.035836108,
-0.6366818547,
-0.4243036807,
0.9342359304,
0.6934249401,
-0.4099459648,
-0.1100854203,
0.1435213536,
0.4151369333,
-0.2278923094,
0.4926806092,
0.4688605666,
0.0734381676,
0.4566766918,
-0.9896559715,
0.1019350439,
-0.2945795655,
-0.3436977565,
0.0511254594,
-1.1036059856,
0.3295002282,
-0.2947304547,
-0.5063590407,
0.2988611758,
0.7877829671,
0.3831540346,
0.2558665574,
0.28332901,
0.6866104603,
0.8439231515,
-0.0676303431,
0.9950748682,
-0.4935368896,
0.0624196865,
1.5311598778,
-0.3060300052,
0.973895669,
0.362713635,
-0.0013124117,
0.6147769094,
0.3151298761,
0.2938486934,
0.4673807621,
0.3301289678,
-0.2396802008,
-0.4385453761,
-0.3008023202,
-0.0502986051,
0.0800178796,
0.6162501574,
-0.0005118106,
-0.0820591301,
-0.0606767163,
-0.0191016849,
0.0961237699,
0.126708433,
0.8995934725,
0.4017348289,
-0.8147972822,
0.7409027815,
-0.5206390619,
0.8103016615,
-0.4521744847,
-0.3045015931,
-0.4408573806,
0.1055121422,
0.129592672,
-0.8822324276,
0.203240037,
-0.1739646345,
0.3686638176,
-0.0874302983,
0.8612542152,
-0.4068171382,
-0.028972337,
0.2009172589,
0.2555855513,
0.6103172898,
-0.1058148369,
-0.8230028152,
0.4157963097,
-0.2653483152,
-0.128295064,
0.4097295105,
0.6588953733,
0.3841121793,
0.9976280928,
0.2063475996,
0.1155591607,
-0.1674222499,
0.277934432,
0.7494632006,
-0.8817785978,
-0.5023835897,
-0.7391592264,
0.2655839026,
-0.3964123428,
0.009964264,
0.4508378804,
0.7137207389,
0.2628810704,
0.1743364483,
0.6886336803,
-0.1430862248,
0.4087556601,
-0.4064094126,
0.6265683174,
-0.5889030695,
0.3042785823,
-0.165346548,
-0.5485004187,
-0.2480864376,
0.6551203132,
0.1796869487,
-0.0618763268,
0.5413579941,
0.803139329,
-0.2482042611,
0.060466297,
0.8502491117,
0.331890285,
0.3317555487,
1.021600008,
1.0861666203,
-0.4447048903,
0.9092282057,
-0.1518614739,
-0.0105548268,
-0.3047273457,
-0.742205441,
-0.528893888,
-0.3975225985,
-0.4808642268,
-0.3746252358,
0.2612149119,
0.9628800154,
0.7064934373,
-0.3431395888,
-0.2978239954,
0.1319613308,
-0.0999811292,
-0.2429557592,
-0.2934832275,
0.2875955999,
-0.6437758207,
-0.8387884498,
0.558427155,
0.7561054826,
-0.2528629601,
-0.1342416406,
-0.152671352,
0.1997293681,
0.5120615363,
0.4989724755,
0.4390837252,
-0.4197088182,
-0.3783675134,
-0.0585781261,
-0.1096002385,
0.4556287825,
0.6278091669,
-1.1162472963,
0.43849805,
0.3388725221,
0.3387597501,
0.175816834,
0.0809935331,
0.7823703885,
-0.7549506426,
0.4172999263,
0.1170383543,
0.2829100192,
0.3883027732,
-0.3940900862,
0.5173999667,
0.1777889729,
-0.6554512978,
-0.9097645879,
0.0592519082,
-1.1851586103,
-0.4072196782,
0.9078850746,
-0.4836898446,
-0.2479119748,
-0.1643168181,
-0.3687155545,
0.2973769009,
-0.622910738,
1.1538974047,
0.7288053036,
-0.3474964499,
-0.5051420927,
-0.4968158603,
0.3032716811,
0.5331317782,
-0.6292101145,
0.2712408602,
0.5888241529,
-0.0956206471,
0.2079592943,
0.7608023286,
-0.023055464,
0.4358105063,
0.0105520459,
-0.1286499351,
0.2753422856,
-0.2715310752,
-0.04795691,
0.5072314739,
-0.1100689843,
0.1695718169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11968v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11968v2
|
What Do Dialect Speakers Want? A Survey of Attitudes Towards Language Technology for German Dialects
| 2024-02-19T09:15:28 | 2024-06-07T13:05:01 |
Verena Blaschke, Christoph Purschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language processing (NLP) has largely focused on modelling
standardized languages. More recently, attention has increasingly shifted to
local, non-standardized languages and dialects. However, the relevant speaker
populations' needs and wishes with respect to NLP tools are largely unknown. In
this paper, we focus on dialects and regional languages related to German -- a
group of varieties that is heterogeneous in terms of prestige and
standardization. We survey speakers of these varieties (N=327) and present
their opinions on hypothetical language technologies for their dialects.
Although attitudes vary among subgroups of our respondents, we find that
respondents are especially in favour of potential NLP tools that work with
dialectal input (especially audio input) such as virtual assistants, and less
so for applications that produce dialectal output such as machine translation
or spellcheckers.
|
[
-1.0435185432,
-0.7035548091,
0.561199069,
0.2431474775,
-0.0498438179,
-0.2627176642,
-0.3607828319,
-0.5250164866,
0.7099232078,
0.6312076449,
-0.3383397758,
-0.2755004168,
-0.356310159,
0.2113123089,
-0.5575914383,
0.62127918,
0.4160903096,
-0.0695585534,
0.0098705469,
0.0286509097,
-0.3453508914,
-0.9222590327,
-0.5426054001,
-0.5140203238,
0.6074461937,
0.5945429206,
1.063382268,
0.2729949653,
0.1617664695,
0.415363729,
-0.2178301662,
-0.4938305318,
0.2711393535,
0.1992087811,
-0.2499514371,
-0.3371351361,
-0.6959558129,
0.043968007,
0.3054562509,
1.0188782215,
0.0140616475,
0.0794430822,
-0.2812395692,
0.6860464811,
-0.1719184667,
0.0953513011,
-0.3421282768,
0.3821690381,
-0.4484841824,
-0.1046550721,
-0.2004883736,
-0.566819489,
0.1721196324,
-0.3530932963,
0.5130601525,
-0.0644377768,
0.9873319268,
-0.0965835303,
-0.7532529235,
-0.0828395337,
-0.9515123367,
0.5486122966,
-0.873698175,
0.685618639,
0.6236581206,
0.4114242196,
0.0849015564,
-0.5750496387,
-0.507240057,
-0.2234217376,
-0.1432907134,
0.1512657851,
-0.2283846289,
0.2549802661,
0.1131054536,
0.5539700985,
-0.5358828306,
0.4472298026,
0.0211074371,
0.1079536974,
0.5044106245,
-0.1906161308,
0.1108910739,
-0.1805493683,
0.3002876043,
0.0487921536,
-0.2058145851,
-0.0267575271,
0.5860173106,
0.5081699491,
-0.0662395507,
0.505222857,
-0.5323914289,
1.1468764544,
0.3275698125,
0.0599557422,
0.4290916324,
-0.1754129082,
-0.0537556559,
-0.0966139138,
0.3710346818,
0.2124139667,
0.4912419617,
-0.3094913065,
-0.4968780875,
-0.348533392,
0.2768471539,
-0.3519129455,
-0.1691375077,
0.4418911636,
-0.2496327162,
0.058825165,
0.0707842484,
-0.9893689156,
-0.24284482,
-0.4174685776,
0.1672995239,
-0.4134499431,
-0.5648269057,
0.3436906338,
-0.7171233892,
0.1039667726,
0.3870579302,
-1.4674781561,
0.3264407814,
0.6408444643,
0.5816043019,
0.0016619768,
0.0656868443,
-0.2047875524,
-0.2658470869,
-0.2849819362,
0.9140973091,
-0.4842385054,
-0.7761112452,
0.4120896757,
-0.0117564872,
0.103369683,
-0.7449797988,
0.3729287386,
-0.6100841761,
0.6609858274,
-0.3388883173,
-0.3268786967,
0.0165633317,
0.131599471,
-0.6734949946,
0.873847127,
0.2139751017,
-0.5063589215,
0.5950668454,
-0.5309796333,
-0.6802690029,
0.3034936786,
0.0023322497,
0.2382235378,
0.4300307333,
0.0515229106,
0.3565316498,
-0.1228274032,
0.2834471762,
-0.3511069417,
-0.0894131213,
0.2212669402,
-0.3832513988,
0.494989872,
0.4234463274,
-0.4265006781,
-0.210424155,
-0.595508039,
0.3440692425,
-0.1623076349,
-0.2177772969,
-0.2796188593,
0.2117282301,
0.3020363748,
0.4646743536,
0.3228824139,
-0.6579687595,
-0.0793221518,
-0.5828868747,
0.0706802011,
0.8541706204,
-0.2219649851,
0.7141886353,
-0.2304889262,
0.5181113482,
-0.0889378041,
0.0539747924,
0.3805380464,
-0.5580281615,
-1.009432435,
-0.0752403587,
0.4628984928,
0.355071187,
-0.6248563528,
0.7434831858,
-0.2199274302,
-0.6910845637,
-0.2701317072,
-0.0879487097,
0.0377575979,
0.4056551456,
-0.0234720353,
-0.4595072865,
-0.3502748013,
-1.2635217905,
-0.0537893586,
-0.4550825655,
-0.3862114847,
0.3931879401,
-0.0772597492,
-0.0635937899,
1.2422449589,
-0.3006825447,
-0.0502670519,
-0.4478841126,
-0.0057445019,
0.2603404224,
0.0697024986,
0.9350244403,
-1.0632584095,
-0.5437051058,
0.4845100343,
-0.6587113142,
-0.4289331734,
0.3565011919,
0.4425820708,
0.5585718751,
0.316265732,
-0.2773244381,
-0.0980896354,
0.7580270171,
-0.0376847237,
0.3853370547,
-0.0096009932,
0.2200808376,
-0.8037521243,
0.0529634655,
0.3820233047,
-0.1574625224,
-1.0142140388,
0.0964871719,
-0.4212270081,
-0.0684617087,
-0.3457903564,
0.664040029,
-0.1128623337,
-0.3546406031,
-0.1809133738,
0.2017081082,
-0.0459934361,
0.0914482623,
0.7631127238,
0.7224501967,
0.1780136675,
-0.5629607439,
0.4481666386,
-0.0587449633,
-0.1400539279,
0.5245684385,
-0.6129865646,
0.3565945029,
0.0662209913,
-0.0908106118,
-0.4719520807,
-0.501463294,
-0.2052289844,
-0.5922313929,
0.1120618582,
0.0049733645,
-0.408878684,
-0.3014786541,
0.1474611461,
-0.2526527643,
0.6813805103,
-0.2064222246,
0.5233263373,
0.5604707599,
-0.614287734,
-0.1739707291,
-0.905231297,
0.1939989179,
-0.3165847659,
-0.7042475939,
-0.0214709677,
0.3237385154,
-0.7215551734,
0.0688148811,
0.0344139971,
-0.4517174661,
-0.0152270282,
0.1467863768,
-0.050227914,
-0.4979526997,
0.0496293716,
-0.0492160209,
-0.2496390343,
-0.2432468832,
-0.4331952929,
0.8315351605,
-0.4544311166,
-0.3761051893,
-0.0434268788,
0.8072178364,
0.2236617953,
0.0363791697,
0.3128703833,
0.4970731139,
-0.0115813632,
-0.1431041509,
-0.6763002872,
-0.283441633,
-0.5549656749,
0.5071931481,
-0.5169451833,
-1.1649805307,
0.1819483489,
-0.0932864919,
0.0399782397,
0.4048854113,
0.7485499382,
-0.4565975964,
0.672044158,
0.7461452484,
-0.2882283628,
0.5451374054,
0.3274283409,
0.4136017859,
0.1851892024,
0.2035291493,
-1.0393232107,
-0.047177583,
-0.6711100936,
0.1106575578,
0.483088553,
-0.3289525509,
0.0577591807,
0.5387935042,
-0.2389069498,
-0.0538882166,
1.0886137486,
-0.2503765523,
0.2130078524,
0.0628398433,
0.2213498205,
-0.1788239628,
-0.7871260047,
-0.6580494642,
0.4037542045,
0.1919001639,
0.3590313792,
0.1154743508,
0.9225664735,
0.5979802608,
-0.4571776986,
-0.8726564646,
0.6463952661,
-0.253382355,
-0.7983464003,
-0.3587201536,
-0.1494716108,
-0.8543027639,
0.1070491001,
0.0506047383,
-0.7419922352,
0.391367346,
0.4346660376,
0.1081692576,
0.4602510929,
-0.8739843965,
0.7676942945,
-0.0245336462,
0.2937273681,
-0.2674391568,
-0.7899695039,
-0.0038863355,
-0.1837846041,
0.3739399314,
0.0585108213,
0.2681989372,
0.1534291208,
-0.2618103921,
0.5931462049,
-0.225750953,
-0.1587752402,
0.1060447693,
0.0294924062,
0.03135157,
-0.3755786717,
-0.5195493698,
0.4551421106,
0.3093409836,
-0.4214927852,
-0.3810355067,
0.4000537097,
-0.6499891281,
-1.0961236954,
-0.535451293,
-0.3748145998,
-0.6067667603,
0.1092586517,
0.3291100562,
0.3531781733,
-0.4850849807,
-0.0140515286,
0.4305647612,
-0.1613797992,
0.4383754134,
0.2715502083,
-0.4344301224,
0.1901858896,
1.0082770586,
0.2716558278,
0.7887681723,
0.0959858,
-0.0170278251,
-0.0379266851,
-0.3631260395,
-0.719019413,
0.0776165575,
-0.617487371,
0.5849130154,
-0.4814451039,
-0.3142430186,
-0.706017375,
-0.429842025,
-0.320728302,
-0.7763968706,
-0.0569505468,
-0.1465706229,
0.1295498908,
0.7864738107,
-0.2184380144,
0.270357728,
-0.6298338175,
0.2597611845,
0.3768497109,
0.1859241873,
-0.5807261467,
-0.5373729467,
-0.0760304555,
-0.0116035249,
0.0956271812,
-0.6175982952,
0.4547030628,
0.1076082587,
0.38432163,
0.3618462682,
0.0661836937,
0.1899920702,
-0.4067999721,
1.0747263432,
-0.1727571338,
-0.7864264846,
0.311175555,
-0.3209462464,
0.2200153321,
0.3904330432,
0.1053823754,
-1.3606469631,
-0.5468195677,
-0.5852079988,
-0.614361763,
0.8339577913,
-0.2859592736,
0.5581525564,
0.1044902578,
-0.1757297516,
0.1972135752,
0.5260811448,
-0.4815223813,
-0.1239603087,
-0.3973124623,
0.2161695808,
-0.1841469854,
-0.0695406422,
-0.1645776033,
-0.0004163702,
0.5567759275,
0.0313679799,
0.3548162282,
-0.1424875408,
0.4349642396,
0.1086997762,
0.8850073218,
0.0279129911,
0.2825457752,
-0.3692683578,
0.2973171473,
-0.0642343685,
-0.2419712096,
0.3837888241,
0.0473558158,
-0.680247426,
0.6297222376,
0.08687976,
0.6405218244,
-0.4552560747,
-0.289180845,
0.2657094002,
0.2785598934,
-0.1267940551,
-0.3951809704,
-0.0118567329,
0.2839761078,
-0.1741406471,
-0.0328182839,
0.274301827,
0.3183459342,
-0.6696453094,
-0.0391099975,
0.3538352847,
-0.7159962058,
-0.5739848018,
0.1701184809,
0.3310701251,
-0.6188293099,
0.3904505372,
-0.3430514038,
-0.2685301304,
0.4400420189,
0.489195466,
1.035453558,
-0.0623512901,
0.6417326927,
-0.0937118828,
0.2393138409,
0.3317230344,
0.1696177125,
-0.0694938153,
-0.8908181787,
0.1813628525,
-0.6518182755,
-0.6156194806,
-0.3119299412,
-0.4884764254,
0.4340540171,
-0.3796648383,
-0.6489306092,
-0.0944036841,
-0.710165441,
-0.4793429077,
0.1977092773,
0.1866441369,
0.9423516393,
-0.9121917486,
1.1199072599,
0.8557829261,
-0.1274977177,
-0.3065413535,
0.183463797,
0.2608588934,
-0.4622307122,
0.595512867,
-0.3785678446,
-0.1547232568,
-0.128956303,
-0.1855938882,
-0.5788978934,
0.1377972364,
0.3262745738,
-0.2692952454,
-0.2783229351,
0.6119739413,
0.6441102624,
0.2203386575,
-0.0079043461,
0.7441092134,
0.7032442689,
-0.2390465289,
-1.1814837456,
-0.7017951608,
-0.3984920084,
0.0406980105,
0.3124059141,
-0.6263027787,
0.6985696554,
0.3832695782,
-0.0349612124,
-0.147983402,
0.4092198908,
-0.1819512695,
0.2931857109,
0.5279167891,
0.0945647657,
0.2200625092,
-0.2955129147,
1.1300795078,
-0.2794498205,
-0.2404681146,
0.9272245169,
-0.4752197266,
0.6428354383,
0.6125856042,
-0.3507169485,
0.40190503,
0.6493719816,
0.3053940535,
0.3918764591,
-0.1081709266,
-0.5042196512,
-0.3333105743,
-0.3899869323,
-0.38780725,
0.4926074445,
0.2217287868,
-0.0227976255,
-0.1966150701,
-0.0723537505,
0.2164289206,
0.2129001766,
0.0974504128,
0.7411631942,
0.0339614153,
-0.6933790445,
0.1174838766,
0.3356294632,
0.6569230556,
-0.9701999426,
0.4032652676,
-0.2526278794,
-0.077645801,
-0.1883275658,
-0.8607010245,
0.3093708754,
-0.1016494706,
-0.1918954402,
-0.3055576384,
0.6547278762,
-0.0812116191,
-0.2483643144,
0.2245239764,
0.8285509348,
0.3613561094,
-0.1596085727,
-0.2903071642,
-0.4667400122,
0.085652709,
-0.3283905387,
0.3900493085,
0.4710475504,
-0.1714178026,
0.4654242098,
0.2200082392,
0.4207295179,
0.1820081919,
0.1406285465,
0.6968069673,
-0.4936829805,
-0.1894573867,
-0.4236859083,
0.2286720127,
-0.0084157391,
-0.5851573944,
1.1763341427,
0.4391143024,
0.9455583692,
-0.1640171558,
1.0210729837,
-0.5350185633,
0.3845639825,
-0.2358242124,
0.2567457557,
-0.517173171,
-0.2171317935,
-0.5113071203,
-0.8401859403,
0.093974188,
0.2402296513,
-0.270940721,
0.1412542462,
0.4395884871,
0.6448500156,
-0.1023673192,
0.6139508486,
0.5848902464,
-0.087704286,
0.1160162166,
0.152916342,
0.4834564328,
0.2684355676,
-0.0758894533,
-0.5856667161,
-0.1399956048,
0.0683322772,
-0.5456804633,
-0.3050119579,
-0.7976725698,
0.0479128063,
-0.2929222286,
-0.0049461396,
0.886577487,
0.5647813082,
-1.0184674263,
-0.7143834233,
0.2080576867,
-0.1647396535,
-0.0819138139,
-0.2434873134,
-0.2234934121,
-0.5941674709,
-1.1115955114,
0.3564796448,
0.4636647105,
0.0385394543,
-0.2908989191,
0.1059160978,
-0.0460556597,
0.0808267444,
0.4802806675,
0.6187243462,
-0.8212339282,
-0.5471860766,
0.2566931248,
-0.2514354289,
0.2185523361,
0.6676822901,
-0.600540936,
0.5801480412,
0.2822340131,
0.3149039745,
0.4866291881,
-0.0472842082,
0.7818359733,
-0.679843843,
0.650234282,
0.4902747869,
0.4049119353,
0.2267325222,
0.0194859523,
0.4238612652,
0.4062667489,
-0.6397615075,
-0.3914657831,
0.3710553646,
-0.8047086,
-0.2510599196,
1.3053426743,
0.027170781,
0.0346354023,
-0.4677596986,
-0.2352312207,
-0.1892839223,
-0.4533611834,
0.3234971464,
0.9225150347,
-0.0849198997,
0.1150978655,
-0.8234850764,
0.3009389937,
0.5510194302,
-0.6245782375,
-0.138914153,
0.8539812565,
-0.0848312378,
0.2697254419,
0.9469151497,
-0.0494561084,
0.1225232482,
0.3107637465,
0.2333461046,
0.3675892353,
-0.2021128535,
-0.530946672,
0.3501427472,
0.3777653277,
0.0338272043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13284v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13284v2
|
Structure Guided Large Language Model for SQL Generation
| 2024-02-19T09:07:59 | 2024-03-27T14:30:44 |
Qinggang Zhang, Junnan Dong, Hao Chen, Wentao Li, Feiran Huang, Xiao Huang
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generating accurate Structured Querying Language (SQL) is a long-standing
problem, especially in matching users' semantic queries with structured
databases and then generating structured SQL. Existing models typically input
queries and database schemas into the LLM and rely on the LLM to perform
semantic-structure matching and generate structured SQL. However, such
solutions overlook the structural information within user queries and
databases, which can be utilized to enhance the generation of structured SQL.
This oversight can lead to inaccurate or unexecutable SQL generation. To fully
exploit the structure, we propose a structure-to-SQL framework, which leverages
the inherent structure information to improve the SQL generation of LLMs.
Specifically, we introduce our Structure Guided SQL~(SGU-SQL) generation model.
SGU-SQL first links user queries and databases in a structure-enhanced manner.
It then decomposes complicated linked structures with grammar trees to guide
the LLM to generate the SQL step by step. Extensive experiments on two
benchmark datasets illustrate that SGU-SQL can outperform sixteen SQL
generation baselines.
|
[
0.1948683709,
-0.9958614707,
0.6784891486,
0.1637743711,
-0.2452857941,
-0.0730338916,
0.0580319054,
-0.2927183509,
0.2018949091,
0.8334258795,
-0.7513195872,
-0.7475560904,
0.054087624,
0.0290163774,
-0.4627916515,
0.7811575532,
0.4775179327,
0.198691383,
-0.1736862659,
0.1938723326,
-0.3632308245,
-0.7492067814,
-0.5061452389,
-0.0698136166,
0.3544532955,
0.266649425,
0.6600006819,
0.9078108072,
0.2576583028,
0.2014443874,
-0.3574270308,
0.2233314514,
-0.7227668166,
0.4264338613,
-0.1615411043,
-0.6079516411,
-0.7460174561,
-0.5984637737,
0.8085798025,
1.0768641233,
-0.4746252,
0.123480238,
0.010185523,
0.9402176142,
-0.2728969753,
0.3618327379,
-1.0253120661,
-0.0241288394,
-0.4956181049,
-0.3003273308,
-0.5386606455,
-0.3957647085,
-0.5689821243,
-0.3023979962,
0.3506769538,
0.378683567,
0.5639598966,
0.1572068036,
-0.6377846599,
-0.2570135891,
-0.6209307909,
0.327231437,
-0.6949177384,
0.4782594144,
0.1396600455,
0.3679018915,
-0.9542200565,
-0.5437992215,
-0.2256051749,
-0.5182557106,
-0.2179801017,
-0.161255464,
0.399705559,
0.1812317967,
0.4153926969,
0.3978241682,
-0.7641540766,
0.0527879,
-0.3725394309,
0.0733583644,
0.7822979093,
0.3575868011,
0.2756260633,
-0.524650991,
-0.3151724339,
0.2373512089,
-1.4060307741,
-0.2681799531,
0.4501307011,
0.7653782964,
0.4870355725,
0.9959773421,
-0.3952743113,
1.0063593388,
0.08464019,
0.1660055518,
-0.1305844784,
-0.5812817216,
-0.2953976393,
0.2255922854,
0.6854548454,
0.2457762957,
0.1260233074,
-0.0907227471,
-0.287555784,
0.055401098,
0.0730231926,
-1.003985405,
-0.3004092872,
0.2936516702,
-0.273188442,
-0.3769563138,
-0.081585519,
-0.413850069,
-0.3401471972,
0.0523597486,
-0.0848317519,
-0.3332168162,
-0.3619122505,
-0.2034402788,
0.0814367607,
0.3933572471,
0.0296162907,
-0.9269818068,
0.3347786665,
0.5597500205,
0.5717743635,
-0.3009442985,
0.113274768,
-0.7695618868,
0.7876374125,
-0.4747814536,
0.6768211722,
-0.576071918,
-0.6433009505,
-0.0982600972,
-0.1048177257,
0.1889809668,
-0.5983867645,
0.3559877872,
-0.3866136074,
0.3774011433,
-0.308624655,
-0.8028565645,
0.3275885284,
0.0310000721,
-0.6397004724,
1.1587352753,
0.1916557252,
-0.335005939,
0.6009116173,
-0.6517589092,
-0.7200995684,
0.478741765,
-0.6319765449,
-0.4765191674,
0.4071168303,
0.231346637,
0.4926056862,
-0.3679757118,
0.5755104423,
-0.2704536319,
-0.3002586663,
-0.2764494717,
0.1825652868,
0.728807807,
0.2375843525,
-0.0291977413,
0.3012937307,
-1.0763927698,
0.206861794,
0.4200269878,
-0.6372386813,
-0.1097574532,
0.3065795302,
-0.0565759204,
0.0836370438,
0.0521302819,
-0.4471223056,
0.2402664572,
-0.7736985683,
0.5420820713,
0.4794268608,
0.0602041706,
0.4980149567,
0.2194044292,
0.3887713253,
0.1465053707,
-0.0280726235,
-0.3437060416,
-0.2975172102,
-0.3648075759,
0.0641658828,
-0.0888639465,
0.3995328546,
-0.4300584197,
0.5316885114,
-0.1643192768,
-0.3449041247,
0.0872859135,
0.2056202739,
0.3013699949,
0.5614992976,
0.2360298187,
-0.2389620692,
-0.5340496898,
-0.7353732586,
-0.5071334243,
-0.3529569805,
-0.1600216478,
0.6406904459,
0.2069233656,
0.1826002002,
0.7001820207,
-0.7913919687,
-0.3674490154,
-0.2775199115,
-0.4202046394,
0.2838374972,
0.4677639306,
0.4226567149,
-0.5665428042,
-0.3412479758,
0.1330876797,
-0.7309685349,
0.0593299568,
0.0259332992,
-0.3037207127,
0.374394089,
0.7258036137,
-0.715728581,
0.0932203755,
0.100515224,
-0.5556785464,
0.5777941942,
-0.0379450992,
-0.2420586199,
-1.50256598,
0.0156573858,
-0.2289904505,
-0.2437211126,
-0.4505029619,
0.2893849909,
0.0694593042,
-0.4864064157,
-0.1803249121,
0.2452609092,
-0.8477733731,
-0.4105575383,
0.0823889971,
-0.0025634337,
0.0006069373,
0.3321605623,
-0.065359138,
0.785743773,
0.4316432476,
-0.5015972853,
0.3510879874,
0.299289465,
-0.3954818547,
0.7155156732,
-0.8320810795,
0.1113030016,
-0.053474687,
0.2743876278,
-0.9507007003,
-0.7211603522,
-0.0666581392,
-0.243629232,
0.4606100023,
-0.4480360746,
-0.3954390585,
-0.3134982884,
-0.0007611748,
0.0592522249,
0.3259619772,
-0.5128269792,
0.6972675323,
0.2595428228,
-0.1749290675,
-0.5498486757,
-0.726593554,
0.2849622965,
-0.1350808889,
-0.9515579939,
0.504196763,
0.1436190605,
-0.0755370557,
0.0666448995,
-0.2147885859,
-0.1125463024,
0.0525802895,
0.2532973289,
0.2986442447,
-0.683185041,
0.1423898935,
0.1594056487,
0.3365867138,
0.1919375956,
-0.395003885,
0.5854398012,
-0.0529562235,
-0.3814055622,
-0.0715721399,
0.4883147478,
0.2860672176,
-0.3007115126,
0.760199964,
0.0977154449,
-0.1787331551,
-0.5681136847,
-0.3829684854,
-0.3272697031,
-0.4386016726,
0.8013222218,
-0.6988628507,
-0.8228538036,
0.3719239235,
-0.2098190486,
0.0707802251,
0.4813115299,
0.4983384907,
-0.092124097,
1.2298692465,
0.6030019522,
0.3888001442,
0.5862339139,
0.2073958665,
0.0834825113,
-0.4702259302,
-0.3955946267,
-0.6073926091,
0.0400910974,
-0.3118089736,
-0.2597941756,
0.0746616051,
0.3754397631,
-0.2695692778,
0.4334757626,
-0.6514914632,
0.7525341511,
0.2276356965,
-0.0549429432,
0.4323077798,
0.399377346,
-0.1614822745,
0.1927485615,
-0.8116636276,
-0.2579929531,
0.9901339412,
-0.1555269063,
0.904940784,
0.198201552,
0.9008358717,
0.0714074001,
0.0521258898,
-0.648624599,
0.8203999996,
-0.1216378435,
-0.6511101723,
-0.2740292549,
-0.8050886989,
-0.7763570547,
0.1483039856,
-0.1323825419,
-0.4257951975,
0.0134397121,
0.3338834643,
-0.0263367929,
0.0529238693,
-0.8966090679,
0.8108314276,
-0.3495950699,
-0.4505396187,
-0.0474046692,
-0.5386630893,
0.6228971481,
-0.0025326707,
-0.1414705515,
0.0426727198,
0.2618631423,
0.3321069181,
-0.6723781228,
0.7370272279,
-0.332742542,
-0.0816118792,
0.2035829276,
0.305950135,
0.7207446694,
-0.0653895959,
-0.3309885263,
-0.0394170806,
-0.1129587591,
-0.3962152004,
-0.5398193598,
0.850548327,
-0.1233339906,
-0.893386066,
-0.1509066522,
-0.5066230893,
-0.0883542821,
0.2266405374,
0.0432990305,
0.3279033005,
-0.4490732253,
0.2165174335,
0.4024576247,
-0.0181943588,
-0.0337512456,
0.2933892608,
-0.4382331669,
-0.0616127066,
0.5981838107,
0.0462168083,
0.2822616994,
0.3065775931,
0.066765517,
-0.5798749924,
-0.7080175877,
-0.715482235,
0.3691020906,
-0.4580292106,
-0.300534755,
-0.3735313416,
-0.2005364895,
-0.4080542028,
0.0133759407,
-0.1836285293,
-0.6543293595,
-0.0115449438,
-0.2457057536,
0.1800685525,
0.9548284411,
0.5529534817,
0.3211752176,
-0.618716538,
0.0886260942,
-0.0311997086,
0.3363626301,
-0.3370372355,
-0.1012040004,
0.0804797634,
-0.2296067625,
-0.0738843307,
-1.0858281851,
0.1554054022,
0.5634386539,
0.5107085109,
0.1383242011,
-0.0987328961,
0.726955533,
-0.7528008223,
0.8918470144,
0.1442956328,
-0.7255347967,
1.1923066378,
-0.3270663917,
0.0041158088,
0.2552393079,
0.0277746022,
0.05699699,
-0.3519690633,
-0.3030128777,
-0.9262340069,
0.7375094891,
0.2647351623,
-0.0035694914,
-0.1893628836,
0.743963778,
-0.1238702461,
0.1861372143,
-0.868838191,
0.0644032657,
-0.0940996408,
-0.1766795367,
0.2757844925,
-0.387973547,
-0.1227254793,
0.0224350728,
0.4892994463,
-0.3608107269,
-0.1691292077,
-0.0169557314,
-0.1554184556,
-0.2510530055,
0.3514824808,
0.1709040999,
0.7679105997,
-0.2786961794,
-0.1651048958,
-0.0677802637,
-0.2190253437,
-0.1566758305,
0.1008521169,
-0.4580046237,
-0.0671982467,
-0.1029231846,
0.7308809757,
-0.1385190636,
-0.5474317074,
0.2182337493,
0.0563579723,
-0.1312218159,
-0.1812572628,
0.380043447,
0.4610467851,
0.1613050997,
0.3078092337,
-0.3612400889,
0.1364990622,
-0.6711349487,
0.1703950316,
0.8230640292,
-0.1623695195,
-0.157072708,
1.0285990238,
0.2430486828,
-0.4116834402,
0.7393485904,
0.0316140279,
-0.1981721967,
0.3895181715,
0.9581871629,
0.5730528831,
-0.4832448959,
0.0145219173,
0.5581351519,
0.286542505,
-0.0636149049,
0.6838480234,
-0.1373281628,
-0.3437426388,
-0.5707201958,
-0.9835335612,
-0.1192261726,
-0.148698464,
-0.5247985721,
0.3111423254,
-0.4286062121,
0.0428955927,
-0.1092034727,
-0.0428256728,
-0.1952085346,
0.1443943381,
-0.1076623648,
0.806183517,
-0.7045662403,
1.045835495,
0.649240613,
-0.5411226749,
-0.9328738451,
-0.2970311642,
-0.1193580404,
-0.6866796017,
0.6787255406,
0.0348085389,
-0.2266543955,
0.0288954359,
-0.5754799247,
-0.6958534718,
1.1527183056,
0.6779400706,
-0.7406421304,
-0.3873072565,
0.3843530416,
0.522212863,
-0.6450637579,
-0.2552630901,
0.517801404,
0.0549091287,
0.5073430538,
-0.329755336,
0.3794988096,
-0.10564778,
0.238906309,
0.5026144385,
-0.1916506141,
0.6263670921,
-0.4500511289,
-0.4779543877,
0.0488525629,
0.7760985494,
0.5360651016,
0.0648525208,
0.4811232686,
0.3323042393,
0.8698473573,
-0.1183384508,
1.0401512384,
-0.3994143605,
0.0018455905,
1.2941924334,
-0.6817869544,
1.0394704342,
0.3385826945,
-0.1416753083,
0.5282667875,
0.4604518414,
-0.0765247419,
0.1074148864,
0.2663790286,
-0.005813323,
-0.3226665854,
-0.1290697157,
-0.5445482135,
0.3208299279,
0.6287335753,
-0.5498512387,
-0.2220463455,
-0.7808358073,
-0.0986380279,
0.2213965207,
-0.22188963,
0.8076638579,
0.1165488958,
-0.5076053739,
0.5792508721,
-0.0189602245,
0.0883014053,
-0.8657417893,
-0.1012616754,
-0.509088099,
-0.0675816759,
-0.4799298346,
-0.7320149541,
0.4943472743,
-0.0806676,
-0.1095403209,
0.0039848625,
1.0438920259,
-0.7168475986,
-0.5818872452,
0.1685845554,
0.6640049219,
0.3161286712,
-0.2908912003,
-0.5373311639,
-0.2271445543,
0.0484500863,
-0.3308490813,
0.3442605138,
0.4341883957,
-0.2784742713,
0.3532108068,
0.904533565,
0.2458144277,
0.1752713472,
0.2705011368,
0.908863306,
-0.9033250213,
-0.5562019944,
-0.901565671,
0.1129404083,
-0.4038746357,
-0.0498932153,
0.7036370039,
0.897364974,
0.5858801007,
-0.0674180388,
0.269433409,
-0.046233397,
0.2121367157,
-0.653239429,
0.7402710915,
-0.7852798104,
0.4669120908,
-0.1391364634,
-1.5334538221,
-0.4194772243,
0.3690584004,
0.141926229,
0.0863496438,
0.506372571,
1.195553422,
0.1028600484,
-0.0452761091,
0.4405488372,
0.6148804426,
0.4490188658,
0.5114682913,
0.7572515011,
-0.115479283,
0.7737253308,
0.3018248379,
-0.0308975484,
-0.1964752674,
-0.7885374427,
-0.8445568681,
-0.3692791164,
0.0024041932,
-0.5559734106,
0.1802734584,
0.6401126981,
0.7083343267,
-0.7714207172,
-0.5098091364,
-0.5268702507,
0.0564947315,
-0.0041095731,
-0.228760615,
0.4816231132,
-0.448223114,
-0.5457803607,
0.9200766683,
0.5270955563,
-0.1862949133,
-0.4034898877,
0.0708658099,
-0.0622378998,
0.0804146007,
0.8069893122,
0.136528939,
-0.655829668,
0.0291691422,
0.0886409134,
-0.2989633977,
0.1705694348,
0.7055498958,
-0.6223359704,
0.1073341742,
0.4820041358,
0.5339623094,
0.7168036699,
0.1782779843,
0.8611965179,
-1.1680992842,
-0.1790844947,
0.1545562297,
0.4960395694,
0.4154784679,
-0.7889988422,
0.841601789,
0.1731044501,
-0.4368803501,
-0.9547800422,
0.7703008652,
-1.0331320763,
-0.379992485,
1.1326794624,
0.2157016695,
-0.5687869191,
0.0053533525,
-0.1099041402,
-0.0881280601,
-0.2981726825,
0.3526791036,
0.3500112593,
-0.1768833697,
0.1813684702,
-0.0574041903,
0.6346097589,
0.4581997097,
-0.9286196232,
0.3874470592,
1.1051137447,
0.3797858357,
-0.1015296429,
0.6300000548,
-0.3935313523,
0.0104662078,
0.1841339767,
-0.1175306439,
-0.2198932469,
-0.3813625872,
-0.0694105625,
0.5400877595,
0.1074177474,
0.2351309061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11960v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11960v1
|
DB-LLM: Accurate Dual-Binarization for Efficient LLMs
| 2024-02-19T09:04:30 | 2024-02-19T09:04:30 |
Hong Chen, Chengtao Lv, Liang Ding, Haotong Qin, Xiabin Zhou, Yifu Ding, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang, Jinyang Guo, Xianglong Liu, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing, while the expensive memory and computation consumption
impede their practical deployment. Quantization emerges as one of the most
effective methods for improving the computational efficiency of LLMs. However,
existing ultra-low-bit quantization always causes severe accuracy drops. In
this paper, we empirically relieve the micro and macro characteristics of
ultra-low bit quantization and present a novel Dual-Binarization method for
LLMs, namely DB-LLM. For the micro-level, we take both the accuracy advantage
of 2-bit-width and the efficiency advantage of binarization into account,
introducing Flexible Dual Binarization (FDB). By splitting 2-bit quantized
weights into two independent sets of binaries, FDB ensures the accuracy of
representations and introduces flexibility, utilizing the efficient bitwise
operations of binarization while retaining the inherent high sparsity of
ultra-low bit quantization. For the macro-level, we find the distortion that
exists in the prediction of LLM after quantization, which is specified as the
deviations related to the ambiguity of samples. We propose the Deviation-Aware
Distillation (DAD) method, enabling the model to focus differently on various
samples. Comprehensive experiments show that our DB-LLM not only significantly
surpasses the current State-of-The-Art (SoTA) in ultra-low bit quantization
(eg, perplexity decreased from 9.64 to 7.23), but also achieves an additional
20\% reduction in computational consumption compared to the SOTA method under
the same bit-width. Our code will be released soon.
|
[
-0.4011819959,
-1.1349753141,
0.414868921,
0.2063212544,
-0.6844563484,
0.1959140599,
-0.2965463698,
-0.3916933537,
0.0790965632,
0.4491606057,
-0.5051843524,
-0.4801510572,
-0.5312740207,
0.2033973932,
-0.1004699841,
0.4854741693,
0.1849137545,
0.3148860335,
-0.0055025895,
-0.0198256318,
-0.2119723558,
-0.5812835097,
-0.5709139109,
-0.0080435053,
0.2613693178,
0.2597691119,
0.6388200521,
0.5594817996,
0.4769423604,
0.2285305113,
-0.577690959,
0.2138336599,
-0.3592086136,
0.0624093898,
0.131362915,
-0.7075207829,
-0.4840967655,
-0.303573817,
0.8662573695,
0.6433874369,
-0.3580060303,
-0.0613297708,
0.0912611559,
0.9727041721,
-0.3634910583,
0.1172117591,
-0.6415323019,
-0.0035886699,
-0.3098985851,
0.073939167,
-0.1609630585,
-0.3212662637,
-0.2803953886,
-0.263476342,
0.1490034908,
-0.0276809875,
0.49344033,
0.4719150066,
-0.5393384695,
-0.1674452722,
-0.9469050765,
0.8024074435,
-0.804800272,
0.5487951636,
0.1653350443,
0.328997165,
-0.1693299711,
-0.418032825,
-0.5614371896,
0.0331537537,
0.2858629525,
-0.1064649969,
-0.2026749253,
0.0502827056,
0.0532521717,
0.5551403165,
-0.1822852045,
0.2822808921,
-0.1959833056,
-0.1320240647,
0.4767842591,
0.1840826571,
-0.2306849211,
-0.0618862621,
-0.4687479138,
0.0938413069,
-0.8130561709,
-0.0833324417,
0.4958715737,
0.2806429267,
0.0120068844,
0.5206696391,
0.0093226973,
0.43366009,
0.1907292604,
-0.1706388146,
-0.1070669219,
-0.556915462,
-0.3608026803,
0.046017725,
0.8216961622,
0.2337864935,
-0.0021634051,
0.1716291159,
-0.2505926788,
-0.0150716612,
-0.0702719986,
-1.2086697817,
-0.1314699203,
0.2427623123,
-0.2562083304,
-0.3220368922,
-0.27863276,
-0.9065388441,
-0.604875803,
-0.155057624,
0.200208649,
-0.6946584582,
-0.3569748104,
0.0969514251,
0.2950943708,
-0.141018033,
0.2043509334,
-1.054467082,
0.2688105106,
0.7226780653,
0.7831947207,
0.1747540236,
0.3260365725,
-0.4529906213,
0.1966744512,
-0.4384613037,
0.6807398796,
-0.2393004,
-0.3627519906,
-0.4132799506,
-0.5859838724,
0.3712233603,
-0.859493494,
0.4389115274,
-0.5950611234,
-0.254253,
-0.0128885871,
-0.4965464473,
-0.1932080686,
-0.0324519351,
-0.7887707353,
0.9794444442,
0.1113810763,
-0.6554537416,
0.3412738144,
-0.3356056511,
-0.1841764599,
-0.0640583113,
-0.1963085979,
-0.5914165378,
0.4363214672,
0.1885959357,
0.257594347,
-0.5176374316,
0.3742328286,
-0.3873333633,
-0.5543198586,
0.4450521171,
-0.9464864135,
0.9277327061,
0.0038640662,
-0.2101709098,
-0.0797511488,
-0.8527067304,
-0.0017394054,
0.0347612575,
-0.5482789874,
-0.49953866,
-0.0402449779,
-0.1937636882,
0.0341023616,
0.315066576,
-0.3826604486,
0.1827356517,
-0.6834713817,
0.2988701165,
0.8100240231,
-0.1390016526,
0.3947536349,
0.0793446824,
0.322673142,
0.1446459293,
0.0505218245,
0.2961154282,
-0.2971931696,
-0.5119630694,
-0.820774436,
0.7992904782,
0.5309715867,
-0.4684924185,
0.9368036389,
-0.2548617721,
-0.2283643484,
-0.5498344302,
0.2179116756,
0.3218544424,
0.1865911037,
0.1963488609,
-0.34876284,
-0.5934475064,
-0.7169132829,
-0.1067112312,
-0.0026303504,
-0.1954536885,
0.1137965769,
0.177289471,
-0.4036290646,
0.9240703583,
-0.3363293409,
-0.2922216356,
-0.2678254247,
0.1289423406,
0.2691880167,
0.1795548499,
0.3586924076,
-0.6767610312,
-0.7053565979,
-0.1633137614,
-0.3414583802,
-0.2947549522,
0.171930626,
-0.1313871443,
0.8137752414,
0.1556988955,
-0.4319525659,
0.4657064378,
0.6694748998,
-0.410690695,
0.6315854788,
-0.2787536681,
-0.091934517,
-1.0233678818,
-0.1315128058,
-0.1580494344,
-0.4821323454,
-0.5748451352,
-0.2259844095,
0.3692877293,
0.4308560491,
-0.2297650278,
0.2046580166,
-0.5909810066,
0.006587462,
-0.2375753373,
0.0745523721,
0.0015418895,
0.3860634565,
-0.1078672931,
0.6584202051,
0.5204418898,
-0.4682077765,
0.588070035,
-0.1330182701,
-0.4174185097,
0.7931255102,
-0.3023820817,
0.0170487687,
-0.097309567,
0.1207248047,
-0.9375887513,
0.3475400805,
0.176747486,
-0.2554596961,
0.6932587028,
-0.2639355958,
-0.630241394,
-0.1394856721,
-0.6306632757,
0.019885499,
0.5463924408,
-0.4957933724,
0.5557345748,
0.2796038091,
-0.1331837624,
-0.6234027743,
-0.8552002311,
-0.029925501,
-0.38501665,
-0.5843995214,
0.3035476208,
-0.3680096865,
-0.3627586067,
-0.0361192711,
-0.6027339697,
-0.2632375956,
0.075374417,
-0.0493781008,
0.3455283046,
-0.2082394958,
0.0327687785,
0.3037445247,
-0.2392696291,
0.0219156928,
-0.3164481819,
0.6078341007,
-0.2914999425,
0.1392603666,
-0.3708399832,
0.2742515206,
0.2433069944,
0.113327086,
0.9179173112,
0.6482132673,
-0.3821460009,
-0.2876918316,
-0.4912749529,
-0.1145125777,
-0.4826191664,
0.419370234,
-0.5914003849,
-0.8636053205,
0.3839987814,
-0.1935092211,
-0.0977860242,
0.1641356796,
0.5654379129,
-0.2505789995,
0.7476848364,
0.6412846446,
0.1461061388,
0.3071567714,
-0.3048470616,
0.4845702946,
-0.9600630403,
0.0208297353,
-0.3355457187,
-0.2817790806,
-0.3887719214,
-0.686034143,
0.3524796963,
0.7504461408,
0.1194572672,
0.0409340635,
-0.3009574711,
0.3800294399,
0.5969651937,
0.0193191655,
0.5819615722,
0.2453783303,
-0.3385528028,
-0.2173916399,
-0.4197337031,
-0.556925714,
1.1094703674,
0.2142551094,
0.8440699577,
0.3785913587,
0.6718607545,
0.1845737398,
0.0578355491,
-0.8309324384,
0.6052129865,
-0.4995738268,
-0.5269731283,
-0.5515581369,
-0.7403542995,
-0.7025223374,
0.5037324429,
-0.2156680375,
-0.4314038157,
0.0464497022,
0.2236828655,
-0.4979024529,
0.4295292199,
-0.6169497967,
0.6649932861,
-0.3365511298,
-0.3445959985,
-0.304767251,
-0.6563557386,
0.4221975207,
-0.4324942827,
0.288469702,
-0.3499855697,
-0.3735544682,
0.4198629856,
-0.6090151072,
0.686943233,
-0.2209189832,
-0.365381062,
0.265486896,
0.1862481534,
0.5139451623,
0.2710440755,
-0.1156656444,
0.5264306068,
0.1753319502,
-0.121833995,
-0.6466290355,
0.4687021375,
-0.386762172,
-0.4880729318,
-0.2800789177,
-0.4724134505,
-0.1637465507,
0.2318654507,
0.0487561189,
0.3326598108,
-0.1513995826,
0.3190205693,
0.8784071803,
0.0009699091,
0.3518264592,
0.7182146311,
-0.1921122223,
-0.4798363745,
0.4908400774,
0.1412982792,
0.3161111772,
0.8019843698,
0.473800689,
-0.6173443794,
-0.8512812257,
-0.6567255855,
0.3226623833,
-0.4094806015,
-0.3632389903,
-0.3993742466,
0.0846226662,
-0.4411962032,
0.1809018999,
-0.584202826,
-0.6788481474,
-0.2916420102,
-0.0652337074,
0.3397559822,
0.2733333409,
-0.2969580889,
0.2513789237,
-0.7130026817,
0.4714302123,
0.2925044894,
0.4940706789,
-0.4513961971,
-0.5089458227,
-0.1921534091,
0.3150114417,
-0.0255883932,
-0.8649824262,
0.3378717303,
0.1293527037,
0.1615848392,
0.3723990321,
0.0795090646,
0.6238986254,
-0.3766298294,
0.4596681297,
0.2042720169,
-1.0318292379,
0.3043320775,
-0.0089616254,
-0.094692789,
0.5404170156,
0.0984766409,
-0.3195486367,
-0.2686914802,
-0.2455846071,
-0.9039792418,
0.8581748605,
0.0171718355,
-0.0349909551,
0.4068667293,
0.1715625226,
0.1615466177,
0.3527035117,
-0.6231492162,
-0.6291341186,
0.0951096192,
-0.4410539567,
0.121634379,
-0.675373137,
0.105458878,
-0.2310421765,
0.7878683209,
-0.0460448265,
0.2315587848,
-0.2049110085,
-0.0819879472,
-0.0840005279,
0.4621041417,
0.2756566107,
0.4227104187,
-0.5301616788,
0.3951316476,
0.2686818242,
-0.6778146625,
0.3189984262,
0.3672423959,
-0.2566382885,
0.057472799,
-0.1985811144,
0.6818954349,
0.1564005315,
-0.7100722194,
0.464412868,
-0.1862297505,
-0.1553574055,
-0.1921332628,
0.0355158485,
0.503015995,
0.3973047733,
0.1876950413,
-0.0505468138,
0.1696381718,
-0.4503766298,
-0.1389660239,
0.5797598362,
-0.0037620438,
-0.132538721,
0.610815227,
0.1372461468,
-0.1929379404,
0.54871732,
-0.3598317206,
-0.2248369753,
0.5089650154,
0.5682854652,
0.747938633,
-0.42934075,
-0.0743961111,
0.1118954867,
0.2752871215,
0.0436054729,
0.2981345356,
-0.2199001312,
-0.7371152639,
-0.2084207088,
-0.9180753827,
-0.3518786132,
0.0000693759,
-0.4071422219,
0.2343904227,
-0.3931400478,
-0.1428896934,
-0.0719155669,
0.4086066484,
-0.2178417742,
0.1264263242,
0.2619274855,
0.6988372803,
-0.3063896,
1.1984395981,
0.4124318957,
0.0015501062,
-0.6590597034,
-0.0652296245,
-0.004380248,
-0.5264485478,
0.2466644645,
0.1188379899,
-0.3231276572,
0.0035809511,
-0.0025638705,
-0.7693048716,
1.1803369522,
0.5067266226,
-1.0423995256,
0.1354709268,
0.4154713154,
0.5371024013,
0.071375154,
0.1575743407,
0.907276392,
0.4791311324,
0.16454494,
-0.6581805348,
0.0842912644,
0.0358711369,
0.3850131631,
0.5817724466,
-0.5667865872,
0.5818844438,
-0.2815450132,
-0.3373892009,
0.0267253537,
0.5980638266,
0.349425137,
0.2361462563,
0.5259568095,
0.4199669957,
0.8885298967,
-0.1905142516,
0.5577753186,
-0.1972331852,
0.4247440696,
0.8093047738,
-0.3228627741,
0.7980668545,
0.6064676046,
-0.7222457528,
0.4048591256,
0.3213421404,
0.2181195766,
0.5452085137,
0.3620077968,
-0.576529026,
0.023239959,
0.3796982169,
-0.0507160388,
0.1900901794,
0.5238048434,
-0.1119258925,
0.1235438213,
-0.2849423587,
0.1289887428,
0.0202209111,
-0.1412673146,
0.6310110092,
0.2169021517,
-0.1769050956,
0.9924097657,
0.4820451438,
1.2746915817,
-0.6891176701,
0.2967263758,
-0.4354380667,
0.2819289863,
-0.0402461067,
-0.5708271265,
0.6254446507,
0.2091810405,
-0.2462468743,
-0.1944406182,
0.4815444946,
-0.6375645399,
-0.6869961023,
0.237601161,
0.2532648742,
0.2225048244,
-0.3302849531,
-0.5910339952,
0.0497094952,
0.1602059603,
-0.373491168,
0.1912651509,
0.6743019223,
0.0163519923,
0.465490669,
0.3823798299,
0.3657221198,
0.3094228208,
0.1246466935,
0.444380641,
-0.7802440524,
-0.4525782466,
-1.0780665874,
0.1696173996,
0.0095412415,
0.1576704979,
0.5387281179,
0.700754106,
0.6026985049,
0.0384251177,
0.5771402717,
-0.15838103,
0.6063193679,
-0.6724038124,
0.4628943503,
-0.5264430046,
0.6597569585,
0.0569041334,
-0.9250606298,
-0.5105167031,
0.5866081119,
-0.0699730441,
0.0843389258,
0.7462822199,
0.9364295006,
0.004781764,
-0.0496852025,
0.3620335162,
0.3197280169,
0.1784983575,
0.7787254453,
0.7287023067,
-0.2796986699,
0.8322586417,
-0.7212872505,
-0.3463910222,
-0.3440195024,
-0.7700833082,
-0.767177403,
-0.1698187739,
-0.3078339696,
-0.0788263232,
0.1082374454,
0.6559894681,
0.5696215034,
-0.5775370002,
-0.1759207696,
-0.1904461831,
0.2914439142,
-0.364759028,
-0.23324579,
0.4618692398,
0.0439848416,
-0.9888126254,
0.3007147312,
0.5406102538,
0.2312627882,
-0.2788291872,
-0.0609288849,
-0.0047791717,
0.2849389911,
0.5657185912,
-0.2945352197,
-0.6206035614,
0.0558918491,
-0.2624919713,
-0.372577101,
0.3765021563,
0.5505760908,
-0.5438867807,
0.287371397,
0.3931491375,
0.3441594243,
0.5664349198,
0.1431746036,
0.2079533935,
-0.8267188668,
0.0567670166,
0.2666483223,
0.1602980196,
0.4488988519,
-0.4531016946,
0.5270944834,
0.4326438904,
-0.2772866488,
-0.7864174247,
0.1541313976,
-0.9797064662,
-0.4536140561,
1.0098338127,
0.0332613029,
-0.2178928405,
0.000084233,
-0.3003774583,
0.4272488356,
-0.319699198,
0.7672173977,
0.5319738984,
-0.0560674779,
-0.1493725926,
-0.3015466034,
0.3692148924,
0.4936784208,
-0.6641753912,
0.2879755497,
0.6791983843,
0.4292158484,
-0.1963065565,
0.6772817373,
-0.2772834897,
-0.0282419454,
0.0704109445,
0.1553423554,
-0.2804961503,
-0.1610234529,
-0.6420971155,
-0.0486649387,
0.1315573454,
-0.0394108556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11958v1
|
Automatic Evaluation for Mental Health Counseling using LLMs
| 2024-02-19T09:00:10 | 2024-02-19T09:00:10 |
Anqi Li, Yu Lu, Nirui Song, Shuai Zhang, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
High-quality psychological counseling is crucial for mental health worldwide,
and timely evaluation is vital for ensuring its effectiveness. However,
obtaining professional evaluation for each counseling session is expensive and
challenging. Existing methods that rely on self or third-party manual reports
to assess the quality of counseling suffer from subjective biases and
limitations of time-consuming.
To address above challenges, this paper proposes an innovative and efficient
automatic approach using large language models (LLMs) to evaluate the working
alliance in counseling conversations. We collected a comprehensive counseling
dataset and conducted multiple third-party evaluations based on therapeutic
relationship theory. Our LLM-based evaluation, combined with our guidelines,
shows high agreement with human evaluations and provides valuable insights into
counseling scripts. This highlights the potential of LLMs as supervisory tools
for psychotherapists. By integrating LLMs into the evaluation process, our
approach offers a cost-effective and dependable means of assessing counseling
quality, enhancing overall effectiveness.
|
[
-0.2914250195,
-0.3816913664,
0.8817198873,
0.6174752116,
-0.370311588,
0.0256330688,
-0.3937091231,
-0.5394585729,
0.0885168761,
0.4546844065,
-0.6168994904,
-0.5120975971,
-0.8709573746,
0.3161127567,
-0.01808751,
0.5938051939,
-0.2006179541,
0.6724190116,
-0.2298718393,
-0.1112753078,
-0.5469520688,
-0.2235890329,
-0.9592027068,
-0.7177281976,
0.4544039369,
0.1395370662,
0.7311688662,
0.4214642942,
0.764673233,
0.3607198,
-0.0697834492,
0.2818590999,
-0.5430335999,
-0.0248322114,
-0.242709592,
-0.175402388,
-0.9569037557,
0.2577477992,
0.5285209417,
0.7011879683,
-0.4641155899,
0.4832372665,
0.1569205374,
0.5813613534,
-0.435805589,
0.1819196492,
-0.4953913093,
0.192123428,
0.362280935,
-0.2290522456,
-0.1835851073,
-0.5173148513,
0.2376578748,
-0.1562775373,
-0.1344016492,
-0.1313823164,
0.5143076181,
0.2629731596,
-0.6722587943,
-0.1116868258,
-0.7523201108,
0.5423819423,
-0.7406110168,
0.5432574749,
0.5619403124,
0.4079493284,
-0.4473760128,
-0.4631519914,
-0.2923092842,
-0.4505349696,
-0.256341815,
0.1861600727,
-0.3982032537,
0.1859834939,
0.1571836919,
0.4983727336,
-0.3131253421,
0.1959665567,
-0.153737247,
-0.0346945114,
0.9017238617,
0.6567017436,
0.2981507778,
0.1113040671,
-0.1370777637,
0.292506963,
-0.2360791862,
-0.2559419274,
0.0319162607,
-0.0667501837,
-0.1181056723,
0.5343354344,
0.1420759708,
0.5157778859,
0.1783712059,
-0.7141731381,
-0.3253338933,
-0.1239518076,
-0.1591965854,
-0.1210453957,
0.9515273571,
1.0798970461,
-0.1163206473,
-0.4288412035,
-0.1737744957,
0.1081274599,
0.3359626532,
-0.6487901807,
-0.0236131791,
0.1181942672,
-0.674197793,
-0.0791392773,
-0.2436104268,
-0.8351019025,
-0.4151155055,
-0.6515879035,
0.2308096588,
-0.2854172587,
-0.2402561903,
-0.0653026998,
0.1713454574,
0.1059532538,
0.299939394,
-0.4578795433,
0.480545789,
0.6313900948,
0.967074573,
-0.5147957206,
-0.2505587935,
-0.608602941,
0.1690547317,
-0.3862137794,
0.7455875874,
-0.4458396435,
-0.4976758361,
-0.1243891418,
0.158862859,
0.02271365,
-0.483792454,
0.5155826807,
-0.3303469718,
0.261821866,
-0.1075416803,
-0.7226486802,
0.3294344544,
0.2733791173,
-0.4223737717,
0.8503559828,
0.4288218319,
-0.5729362369,
0.3356036544,
-0.7064853907,
-0.2390239835,
0.2138768882,
0.1074916571,
-0.2392897308,
-0.0452929027,
0.2184183896,
0.3531064987,
-0.6831396818,
0.4098329544,
-0.5334694982,
-0.4247305095,
0.3528592288,
-0.2246713191,
0.563172698,
0.0375309139,
-0.0677116364,
0.4247868657,
-0.7455730438,
0.0802720338,
0.0094563449,
-0.3053716421,
-0.2621335387,
-0.2407075912,
-0.1428141445,
0.1853674352,
0.1495711803,
-0.4304127097,
0.0621409751,
-0.4331217706,
0.0827464461,
0.758469522,
0.4499908984,
0.1072102711,
-0.291418612,
0.8087490797,
-0.4751833975,
0.4081680477,
0.2268382162,
-0.2489126921,
-0.388630569,
-0.4637862742,
-0.221050635,
0.4167183638,
-0.4923615754,
0.9608500004,
-0.064247869,
-0.87897861,
-0.455042243,
0.3355195522,
0.4116911888,
0.4931146502,
0.2304019034,
-0.3523937762,
-0.3105120957,
-0.6800357103,
-0.4963877499,
-0.0247892085,
-0.0722463876,
0.0848736241,
0.3568096459,
-0.5373665094,
0.9611427188,
-0.5626198649,
-0.2825726271,
-0.3261798918,
0.0134929456,
0.1772629768,
0.2231339216,
0.3587251306,
-0.0093072029,
-0.5612648726,
-0.2953085601,
-0.7034733295,
-0.459651649,
0.1625607908,
-0.5804600716,
-0.0862728283,
0.1910917461,
-0.1837201864,
0.1562915295,
0.6038144231,
-0.5119717717,
0.6958370209,
-0.3102685809,
0.0352496058,
-0.7908409834,
0.0063605965,
0.1812248826,
-0.3445559144,
-0.2128033787,
-0.3350092173,
-0.1883504838,
-0.1162013784,
-0.2940198183,
0.5626601577,
-0.4066032469,
-0.1686337888,
-0.2393671572,
0.2304611951,
-0.1253624409,
0.563382864,
-0.367556572,
0.5986455679,
0.3647339046,
-0.2788825333,
0.8812615275,
0.2852382958,
-0.2271874994,
1.1864811182,
-0.5444960594,
0.1247421205,
0.2745340168,
0.6665686965,
-0.5712767243,
-0.2553019524,
0.3021791279,
0.1832303405,
0.0206507929,
-0.2325124592,
-0.3876296282,
-0.3490921557,
-0.1939317733,
0.1096587256,
0.2989734709,
-0.4719926119,
0.1893962026,
0.5037413239,
-0.2595764995,
-0.2146880329,
-0.1019658595,
0.3403729498,
-0.3855942786,
-0.5503681898,
0.2368984073,
0.1077134907,
-0.4110445976,
0.0215816423,
-0.1738150567,
-0.011435044,
-0.0089766104,
0.4159433246,
0.5517464876,
0.1251468211,
0.008164959,
0.0409370139,
-0.4870368242,
0.4178386033,
-0.23241359,
0.3241443336,
-0.5033540726,
-0.6618798971,
-0.6427915692,
0.3738691807,
0.6357777119,
-0.2365236133,
0.617028594,
0.6822021604,
-0.4072937667,
-0.0241089202,
-0.6418012381,
-0.143192023,
-0.4138018787,
0.3409380317,
0.1649746895,
-0.6598394513,
0.197232008,
-0.1721180826,
-0.0568103082,
0.2581707835,
0.694737792,
-0.0193061996,
1.2284930944,
0.4888606668,
0.0717382506,
0.3443058133,
-0.1389537305,
0.3195028901,
-0.7924439311,
-0.0519589335,
-0.0460478142,
-0.1422996372,
-0.2790759504,
-0.2764401138,
0.8448028564,
0.0115788113,
-0.2666919231,
0.1390719265,
-0.5953609943,
0.2901474237,
0.004706271,
0.2254862338,
0.6531137228,
-0.2591500282,
-0.2236442119,
-0.263025403,
-0.3348997533,
-0.8691074848,
0.8986905813,
0.6275182962,
0.6892722845,
-0.0187059343,
0.6476408839,
0.2460287064,
0.9184545279,
-0.990151763,
0.6011631489,
0.2260586619,
-0.230708167,
-0.4105979502,
-0.3981855512,
-0.8622486591,
0.4765538871,
-0.2305997312,
-1.0259757042,
0.0241986215,
-0.0466687605,
-0.4007617533,
0.0892244875,
-0.3685157299,
0.8170713186,
-0.5433464646,
-0.2755595446,
-0.5016783476,
-0.4920395911,
0.628100574,
-0.2392130941,
0.1085861474,
-0.6780679822,
-0.0130051598,
1.0831259489,
-0.5789272785,
0.4681493044,
-0.1812019795,
-0.4642072618,
0.0000333219,
0.130261302,
0.241257906,
0.235527873,
-0.1951824278,
-0.046631705,
0.6630699039,
-0.1162303016,
-1.0834507942,
0.5542870164,
-0.7055209875,
-0.3786526024,
-0.3179656267,
-0.4790830612,
-0.8989500999,
0.3344084918,
0.0241223946,
0.4430533051,
-0.4743797481,
-0.4079344869,
-0.0612627529,
-0.2729765773,
-0.0070541082,
0.754965961,
-0.5158011317,
-0.7433838844,
0.7227625847,
-0.066597335,
0.1544180661,
-0.4807870686,
0.3342216313,
-0.3335469067,
-0.2217284888,
-0.0520664006,
0.5835837722,
-0.8881243467,
-0.2626515329,
-0.5544476509,
-0.0539722443,
-0.186524123,
-0.1957240701,
-0.3936274648,
-0.0654260144,
0.1284882724,
-0.1893460304,
0.280405134,
0.7079099417,
-0.1465912312,
0.519100666,
-1.0185858011,
0.4101184011,
0.3441313803,
0.7795209289,
0.2840029597,
-0.1408775002,
-0.3474628329,
-0.0628417805,
-0.6217862964,
-1.0562998056,
0.4755353332,
-0.0582095422,
0.5480555296,
0.5921369195,
0.14502424,
0.7960975766,
-0.215178743,
0.4724344611,
0.3503578603,
-0.923463881,
0.3857050538,
-0.3858971894,
-0.0190076884,
0.7744378448,
0.281540364,
-0.6523523331,
-0.4362311363,
-0.5040128231,
-0.7134932876,
0.7364894748,
0.023751054,
-0.1904807389,
0.0890812054,
0.2736538351,
-0.1439531147,
-0.0197354238,
-0.4897164702,
-0.064908199,
0.2608910799,
-0.1161089018,
0.1797483861,
-0.1698872745,
-0.8019635081,
-0.4465827048,
0.6891267896,
-0.0071653565,
0.5443542004,
0.2714688778,
0.0077273576,
-0.5578068495,
0.4107875228,
0.1687681973,
0.9894513488,
-0.292263031,
0.071366027,
0.6417575479,
-0.1632124037,
0.4253122807,
0.0296550337,
0.7080013156,
0.0794811621,
0.6464418173,
0.4909485281,
0.2175345719,
-0.5806684494,
0.6789432764,
-0.3643884659,
0.0101071019,
-0.3698935807,
0.1291077733,
0.2241637111,
0.3775758743,
0.0732602105,
-0.4059035778,
0.066448696,
-0.4320338666,
0.2635676563,
0.3996152878,
-0.6335679293,
-0.0322278999,
0.1060017496,
0.229940474,
-0.5263756514,
0.5902537704,
-0.0193148423,
-0.3029552102,
0.5515356064,
0.624237895,
0.8758879304,
-0.1433423311,
-0.0189358406,
0.0980868042,
0.0333266743,
-0.2140250206,
0.1640857607,
0.1053123698,
-0.3472955525,
-0.460570991,
-0.7594330907,
-0.8310337067,
0.0450084507,
-1.045519352,
0.3303524852,
-0.4799265862,
-0.4712975621,
-0.2965944409,
-0.0159924962,
-0.7022106647,
0.0823491812,
0.1507438123,
0.8378816843,
-0.6438640356,
0.6034678817,
0.5611411333,
-0.0055696839,
-0.7613214254,
0.0560559109,
0.168475315,
-0.7497729063,
0.1539163291,
0.1671877503,
-0.5132803917,
-0.2210789621,
-0.441639632,
-0.7057285309,
1.1866996288,
0.746452868,
-0.4554446042,
-0.1506729871,
0.021879172,
0.9798471332,
-0.5288468599,
0.5127655268,
1.0497900248,
0.7467247844,
-0.0423637256,
-1.0862605572,
0.2313673496,
-0.1923905611,
-0.0076603885,
-0.0181945171,
-0.4673556983,
0.027010493,
0.0764403269,
-0.2384041697,
-0.1257248372,
0.4482989609,
0.1850542128,
0.2823024094,
0.6855313182,
0.0872163475,
0.781035006,
0.2890407145,
0.7121337056,
-0.6982808709,
0.4552425444,
1.2873356342,
-0.4848696887,
0.4736692905,
0.1921823025,
-0.5889044404,
0.3915576637,
0.6391686797,
-0.5063759685,
0.0147101656,
0.1595306247,
-0.2365065217,
-0.2790732682,
-0.3778246939,
-0.2061743736,
0.4099261165,
0.404483676,
-0.3116036654,
-0.3864131272,
-0.0219290722,
0.0942456871,
0.0163549967,
-0.0024359534,
0.8826654553,
0.5787747502,
-0.8069807291,
0.5742816329,
0.1489544958,
0.2642701268,
-0.5608547926,
-0.0004472827,
-0.0756233037,
0.2095078975,
-0.590772748,
-0.6455793977,
0.630834043,
0.315969497,
0.3364554644,
-0.3667520285,
0.5556988716,
-0.3206065595,
-0.6501377225,
0.7448914647,
0.6182972193,
0.1109098271,
0.1506831199,
-0.6498447657,
-0.2108784318,
-0.6350969076,
-0.2058018595,
0.3873157203,
0.1528824866,
0.0786404684,
0.6546399593,
0.6611896753,
0.3502687812,
-0.4619279206,
-0.0142069338,
0.7651346326,
-0.5380223989,
-0.5125214458,
-1.0700637102,
0.0632613599,
-0.0707635134,
-0.1344517618,
0.70175457,
0.1717333645,
0.1483462006,
0.3788369894,
0.7091462612,
0.376046747,
0.4480794668,
-0.2833337784,
0.7466714978,
-0.420116663,
0.2221762836,
-0.5458754897,
-0.9997202754,
-0.3002287745,
0.4254491329,
-0.5999431014,
-0.2106953561,
0.8206122518,
0.5864441991,
-0.038070064,
0.0578553043,
0.219304055,
0.1699858904,
0.6811127663,
0.2859262526,
1.0587056875,
0.1640462726,
0.3783522844,
-0.249249205,
-0.3999219835,
0.0054519116,
-0.9462981224,
-0.7479589581,
-0.1774081737,
-0.1686378717,
-0.3967579007,
-0.0947366208,
1.5852464437,
0.4942595959,
-0.3832069635,
-0.5016050935,
0.3369669318,
0.1499709338,
-0.3134596944,
-0.2062966526,
0.4466016293,
-0.1401343942,
-0.3515878022,
0.6020129919,
0.5546373725,
-0.1201970354,
-0.5825633407,
-0.153035894,
0.1890031844,
0.0324814022,
0.4760298133,
-0.1560002565,
-0.6468492746,
0.0209874865,
-0.4939307272,
-0.3181046546,
0.188087061,
0.7988344431,
-0.3765257299,
0.3324467838,
0.1232899949,
0.3981432319,
0.2545434833,
0.0837511271,
1.0395354033,
-0.0589475334,
-0.1239264458,
0.2831845284,
0.4615366757,
0.2573887408,
-0.5906906128,
0.5904777646,
-0.0181086287,
-0.6041491032,
-0.979046762,
-0.0418447033,
-0.7032389045,
0.0543439873,
1.0434812307,
-0.5870592594,
-0.063869819,
-0.2677608132,
-0.5866010785,
0.5304053426,
-0.302403748,
0.8867963552,
0.6736702323,
-0.75279212,
0.0886737332,
-0.4823149741,
0.5423267484,
0.3544683158,
-0.9259579182,
0.0646237731,
0.3985392451,
0.3734967113,
-0.1757977605,
0.7245841622,
-0.1384712607,
0.1106017008,
-0.3483215272,
-0.0591224916,
0.0011059967,
0.0483340919,
-0.4846847057,
-0.1275307536,
0.0622088164,
0.3693755567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11955v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11955v1
|
Analysis of Multidomain Abstractive Summarization Using Salience Allocation
| 2024-02-19T08:52:12 | 2024-02-19T08:52:12 |
Tohida Rehman, Raghubir Bose, Soumik Dey, Samiran Chattopadhyay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the realm of abstractive text summarization through the
lens of the SEASON (Salience Allocation as Guidance for Abstractive
SummarizatiON) technique, a model designed to enhance summarization by
leveraging salience allocation techniques. The study evaluates SEASON's
efficacy by comparing it with prominent models like BART, PEGASUS, and
ProphetNet, all fine-tuned for various text summarization tasks. The assessment
is conducted using diverse datasets including CNN/Dailymail, SAMSum, and
Financial-news based Event-Driven Trading (EDT), with a specific focus on a
financial dataset containing a substantial volume of news articles from
2020/03/01 to 2021/05/06. This paper employs various evaluation metrics such as
ROUGE, METEOR, BERTScore, and MoverScore to evaluate the performance of these
models fine-tuned for generating abstractive summaries. The analysis of these
metrics offers a thorough insight into the strengths and weaknesses
demonstrated by each model in summarizing news dataset, dialogue dataset and
financial text dataset. The results presented in this paper not only contribute
to the evaluation of the SEASON model's effectiveness but also illuminate the
intricacies of salience allocation techniques across various types of datasets.
|
[
-0.3199277818,
-0.320207864,
0.2383431643,
0.4236877859,
-0.4118929803,
0.0003890558,
-0.1043168753,
-0.7843174338,
0.5973280072,
0.1845951974,
-0.6047502756,
-0.3834957778,
-0.5245621204,
0.1834308207,
-0.6582899094,
1.7786812782,
0.1759533137,
-0.3473517895,
-0.416806221,
-0.112889193,
-0.2817252278,
-0.5244351029,
-0.4357404709,
-0.0486144237,
0.5863122344,
0.168591246,
0.3598635495,
0.5695950389,
0.8555250764,
0.3381294012,
-0.1197251827,
0.1255823523,
-0.4368987978,
0.2691753805,
0.0376045816,
-0.0120955212,
-0.8632375002,
0.0139116431,
0.4788284302,
0.7002853155,
-0.2159638256,
0.6087899208,
0.0095001468,
0.6880402565,
-0.6752464175,
0.1723699272,
-0.6483970284,
-0.0150651438,
-0.1818130761,
-0.5914732814,
-0.1025158837,
-0.3079113364,
0.7479063869,
-0.6186755896,
0.4881559312,
-0.0009493348,
0.6506236792,
0.2165747881,
-0.4835614562,
-0.275767982,
-0.4760917425,
1.0350211859,
-0.7672661543,
-0.1812978089,
0.0519052334,
0.228750363,
0.4833313525,
-0.5828450322,
-0.0446055494,
-0.0266721305,
-0.117305398,
0.4728542268,
-0.0688178018,
-0.1342567056,
-0.2225796431,
0.3881691694,
-0.3768615127,
-0.1730791032,
-0.5645984411,
0.1317868978,
0.8137951493,
0.3866121173,
0.0914749205,
-0.4457118213,
-0.4701761901,
0.1567206681,
-0.2992153466,
0.1284656078,
0.5339891315,
0.514977634,
-0.2797079086,
0.4584691823,
-0.1034824103,
0.5274030566,
-0.2325764894,
-0.4276207089,
0.0436219908,
-0.7267017961,
0.0316497311,
0.2027649432,
0.280246228,
1.0742179155,
0.117133297,
-0.1631470621,
-0.1659965664,
-0.3731954098,
0.3988167048,
-0.8113886118,
-0.4142092466,
0.3916683197,
-0.703124702,
-0.4806902111,
0.2149704248,
-0.9701007605,
-0.3624719679,
-0.498771131,
-0.0291056056,
-0.3318043053,
-0.2662721574,
-0.165547356,
-0.7190030217,
-0.2288261205,
0.3450482488,
-1.1468282938,
0.3426522315,
0.7007964253,
0.9738778472,
-0.3771894276,
-0.3286524117,
0.0311930329,
0.3398565948,
0.0066442587,
0.9760489464,
-0.4555590451,
-0.1791860759,
-0.3955510557,
-0.1701464653,
-0.5305562019,
-0.1702854037,
0.1585066766,
-0.4891304672,
0.0645836815,
-0.2459519207,
-0.2020828277,
-0.5033429265,
0.1211017072,
-0.7173230052,
0.5768343806,
0.103016898,
-1.1333751678,
0.5169816017,
-1.1735527515,
-0.4733619988,
-0.3926670849,
0.2962678671,
-0.4613912702,
0.0972451791,
0.188788861,
0.4053486884,
-0.0932715684,
0.2003628016,
0.0785370171,
-0.1391979158,
0.5072456002,
-0.4149910212,
0.2981683314,
0.2538248897,
-0.1200300157,
0.2962013185,
-0.7302100062,
-0.2664346397,
-0.027809754,
0.2012866437,
-0.7360039353,
0.1778174192,
0.3252129257,
0.1256262511,
0.3916524351,
-0.1523868591,
0.1121395007,
-0.5781456232,
0.3046926558,
0.8496589661,
0.2692208588,
0.3795923591,
-0.3940577209,
0.8377841115,
0.1239388958,
0.2363279909,
-0.6065840125,
-0.1456698626,
-0.2744070292,
-0.6073129773,
0.4628902376,
0.4823013544,
-0.3013218045,
0.0274061542,
-0.2771442533,
-0.3130274117,
-0.3087578118,
-0.3955260217,
0.2181266099,
0.4105486572,
0.4353862405,
-0.359910965,
-0.5189977288,
-1.1245166063,
-0.0331563354,
0.2337852269,
0.2835104465,
0.0675680712,
0.4823708236,
0.3030353785,
0.9546494484,
-0.7010376453,
0.0745114014,
-0.4551401436,
0.3652023077,
0.2326579243,
0.2729854286,
1.1103622913,
-0.7377588749,
-0.2073331922,
-0.0344580188,
-0.7474867702,
-0.2002976984,
-0.2522350252,
0.0001619051,
0.1034899279,
-0.1009276211,
-0.1445161253,
0.6062865257,
0.5128518343,
-0.6470817924,
0.6395161748,
-0.028452877,
0.3915877342,
-1.0540047884,
0.3922703564,
0.376349926,
-0.3148518801,
-0.539493382,
0.221583724,
-0.3494328558,
0.1554979086,
-0.0813634768,
0.3018566072,
-0.4550348222,
-0.2455933392,
-0.6176159382,
0.1634876579,
0.0183259081,
0.3448760808,
-0.0863284245,
0.8951454759,
0.2526376843,
-0.8060849309,
0.1560246795,
0.0070004188,
-0.1632346958,
0.3604776859,
-0.7310426831,
-0.5626753569,
-0.5029592514,
0.136651352,
-1.0791083574,
-0.1336837858,
0.398971647,
-0.2294398248,
-0.170446381,
0.1185795516,
-0.0053314343,
0.0094339643,
-0.7476822734,
0.6510917544,
0.130838275,
-0.2366746366,
0.4446409047,
0.3140205145,
-0.9981201887,
-0.7853518724,
-0.2958816588,
0.0131976623,
-0.619769454,
-0.2366874814,
0.4181785583,
0.0942702144,
-0.4391368032,
0.1220768988,
-0.2133627385,
0.0720939934,
0.3615034223,
0.2417348176,
0.5134960413,
0.1049682274,
-0.3014013767,
0.3315443993,
-0.383236438,
0.0456969775,
-0.2066428363,
0.282006532,
0.1413544416,
-0.2853529453,
-0.455011487,
0.4155385792,
0.5071517825,
-0.2263220698,
0.8376478553,
0.1813022643,
0.0016504016,
0.1867286116,
-0.2008204162,
-0.2566762567,
-0.3412435651,
0.5657536387,
-0.0727527291,
-0.424279809,
0.8985846639,
0.143379271,
0.6202588081,
0.8160600066,
0.2008841485,
0.1574855149,
0.8281386495,
0.6746746302,
-0.0857436061,
0.3536562026,
-0.3583820462,
0.1902714074,
-0.7411376238,
-0.3223604858,
-0.4752788842,
-0.5989109874,
-0.3544050157,
0.0637628734,
0.5347737074,
-0.2808657885,
0.0705299079,
0.0819344446,
-0.4556151032,
0.5292160511,
0.468370676,
-0.0361860394,
0.7029785514,
0.1433722526,
0.1850318611,
-0.2987950146,
-0.6864461303,
-0.5981490016,
1.1882840395,
0.3853031993,
0.4892756045,
0.2548299134,
0.3565428555,
0.4085145891,
0.4253377616,
-0.6705954671,
0.2998238802,
-0.3120859563,
-0.1903856993,
-0.3431507349,
-0.3507423103,
-0.8526462317,
0.5535476208,
-0.0668939948,
-0.643854022,
0.334848702,
-0.0429400131,
-0.6014325023,
0.1064393297,
-0.4808095992,
0.5681086183,
-0.0153054744,
-0.1916127354,
-0.3591455221,
-0.5639458299,
0.6947658062,
-0.1335588992,
0.2868880332,
-0.2432545722,
-0.0750099123,
0.8943001628,
-0.2630652189,
0.8891521692,
-0.0251380987,
-0.2669298053,
-0.0277543198,
-0.3863015473,
0.0357305147,
0.3631522655,
-0.1719018072,
-0.0035672213,
0.3865548074,
-0.534997046,
-0.3900149167,
0.5720483661,
-0.6437785029,
-0.2853762507,
-0.8351641893,
-0.9344530702,
0.1062762067,
-0.1621735692,
0.1540398896,
0.7829993367,
-0.2353907824,
-0.0778369606,
0.2245053202,
-0.0571666546,
0.8497951031,
0.3825934827,
-0.3055277169,
-0.4717064202,
0.9748286009,
0.1134608537,
0.1838657707,
0.2055057585,
-0.1059859544,
-0.2555874586,
-0.644664824,
-0.3815340996,
-0.130835712,
-0.4953085184,
-0.285964638,
-0.7725131512,
-0.2136207074,
-0.3273573816,
-0.1695242375,
-0.2545780838,
-0.801573813,
0.0005255805,
-0.1637627035,
0.5751056075,
0.5411441922,
0.1640803069,
0.3729607463,
-0.6773041487,
0.3130270541,
0.0895527825,
-0.0131646236,
0.477311492,
-0.4785906076,
-0.5856152177,
0.0493930504,
-0.5019768476,
-0.7592971325,
0.6535167098,
0.0922452509,
0.3939296305,
0.7129152417,
0.0913746506,
0.703666687,
-0.2290947735,
0.9793512225,
0.2665715516,
-0.8647225499,
0.259752959,
-0.5356808901,
0.4960259199,
0.6842406392,
0.2430626303,
-0.4474349618,
-0.8251979351,
-0.6167827845,
-1.4219936132,
0.7536607981,
0.2351022661,
0.1542961299,
0.0334661193,
0.4068169296,
0.5615122318,
0.7961515188,
-0.6163113713,
-0.4351037145,
-0.3889995217,
-0.2016496956,
0.0977374688,
-0.3449164331,
-0.2947409451,
-0.3804665506,
0.5670883656,
-0.0736870021,
0.1499894261,
0.0712320209,
0.0966667756,
0.1410556436,
0.1753169298,
0.8230833411,
1.3667602539,
-0.3335929215,
-0.1299027503,
-0.0318729617,
-0.5257398486,
-0.1801686287,
0.5462176204,
-0.3333442211,
0.1393024176,
0.6772888303,
0.619065702,
0.4703151882,
-0.6701378822,
0.5126401186,
-0.0076576401,
-0.1394682378,
-0.3585228622,
-0.0634262264,
-0.3484692872,
0.2498976886,
0.810970068,
0.3563887179,
0.7780798078,
-0.387343049,
-0.0494940095,
0.3603680432,
0.0035740994,
-0.4993239343,
0.8084539771,
0.2189199626,
0.6604152918,
0.3767011464,
0.0323395506,
-0.4162862003,
1.0082862377,
0.4197387099,
0.899764657,
-0.2397571802,
0.3106601834,
0.2186778039,
0.1972305179,
0.1012022272,
0.2506172061,
0.1994898915,
-0.4292318821,
-0.7421111465,
-0.4488055706,
-0.2865848541,
-0.165059045,
-0.8059845567,
-0.1602365524,
-0.1107927412,
-0.2805973887,
0.4136222303,
-0.2419554293,
-0.2547177672,
-0.0076826606,
-0.424695462,
0.6965587735,
-0.8916593194,
-0.0350421332,
0.9308915138,
-0.3781255782,
-0.1805518717,
0.2563684881,
0.0539190769,
-0.3578031659,
0.601008594,
0.0908454806,
0.0132757965,
-0.0840835422,
-0.2267286181,
-0.701489985,
1.2534842491,
-0.029569814,
-0.196228683,
0.2534514964,
-0.3418326676,
0.4364332557,
-0.4533552825,
0.4881932735,
0.5847406983,
0.5870099068,
0.2417907715,
-1.041990757,
-0.204332307,
-0.403152287,
0.0325287655,
0.3001684844,
-0.7978846431,
0.8029568195,
-0.3427743018,
-0.0714923069,
0.1242462099,
0.8956987262,
0.360417068,
0.9349024892,
0.317807734,
0.2224850208,
0.6305065751,
0.0094857747,
1.1774300337,
-0.5080652833,
0.2961361706,
0.7891891003,
-0.0423473194,
0.5463803411,
0.6166155934,
-0.184383899,
0.3275476396,
0.5255935192,
0.07015986,
0.9328455329,
0.1727092117,
-0.4665178359,
0.2840048671,
-0.3831050992,
-0.6081710458,
0.4826296866,
0.0506314896,
-0.3620911241,
-0.4131779969,
0.0245241392,
0.0530941747,
0.098167114,
-0.44743222,
0.9936813116,
-0.0370160453,
-0.6375404,
-0.0195962433,
0.4864940941,
0.6949849725,
-0.5789106488,
0.044169981,
-0.3070244491,
-0.1702477187,
-0.2370433658,
-0.3305555284,
0.5430454016,
0.1797819883,
-0.442109257,
-0.14718768,
0.4920099378,
-0.4589157104,
-0.6235329509,
-0.2120524943,
0.5206400752,
-0.0161377024,
0.1447053701,
-0.4354919195,
-0.3684149683,
-0.1862849295,
-0.2294942439,
0.4236041605,
0.459733814,
0.0108173173,
0.5525949001,
0.5708756447,
0.2171380222,
-0.3163217902,
0.2892560065,
0.8169888854,
-0.773001492,
-0.845610559,
-1.0548484325,
0.6353780031,
-0.3016319871,
-0.3410477042,
1.0793629885,
0.8476707339,
0.047473833,
-0.3064678609,
1.0119824409,
0.0882417634,
0.4046687782,
-0.6390879154,
0.4584341943,
-0.3693690896,
0.481399864,
-0.5990575552,
-0.8870769143,
-0.152498275,
0.4901930988,
-0.4496746957,
0.1472001821,
0.7161424756,
0.3206231296,
-0.1054221317,
0.4821781814,
-0.2690233886,
-0.2528850436,
-0.0978996232,
0.1802297235,
0.7511164546,
-0.2208693773,
0.0268484913,
-0.2542546093,
-0.3253925741,
-0.4422146976,
-1.1045757532,
-0.8005201221,
-0.6578826904,
-0.4718151391,
-0.0023101633,
0.3893670142,
1.0649293661,
0.5069795251,
-0.8180418015,
-0.2547246516,
0.4147378802,
0.0473533608,
-0.7228947878,
-0.3093649149,
0.6608043313,
-0.3384596407,
-0.9688329697,
0.0517435707,
0.4693688452,
0.1231886744,
-0.1586631089,
0.4426140487,
-0.0228932481,
-0.0592096858,
0.8740262389,
-0.0389913023,
-0.3577264547,
0.1092610359,
-0.0274309013,
0.1544274241,
-0.4018362463,
0.9695650935,
-0.3178304732,
0.0219088532,
0.3576270044,
0.4675829113,
0.1075798348,
0.7691227794,
0.6868653893,
-0.8889065385,
0.2866895795,
-0.1430329829,
0.0265141558,
-0.0214793384,
-0.486648947,
0.3923628032,
0.0877483487,
-0.3986266553,
-0.5459367633,
-0.3166038394,
-0.9281610847,
-0.5228948593,
0.7765116692,
0.2447277009,
0.0764199942,
-0.1955149472,
-0.152368173,
-0.1125913635,
-0.6516773105,
1.3151987791,
0.8679563403,
-0.3544805944,
-0.2681528926,
-1.0409010649,
0.4749934375,
0.284347266,
-0.8411146402,
0.1546116173,
0.7066133618,
0.0387671851,
0.1102015302,
0.5039842725,
-0.1357064992,
0.2039999068,
-0.3526955545,
0.0081903161,
-0.3331991434,
-0.5662640929,
-0.1424709558,
0.346965611,
-0.1277865618,
-0.2240902185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11943v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11943v2
|
LEMMA: Towards LVLM-Enhanced Multimodal Misinformation Detection with External Knowledge Augmentation
| 2024-02-19T08:32:27 | 2024-06-20T20:20:30 |
Keyang Xuan, Li Yi, Fan Yang, Ruochen Wu, Yi R. Fung, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of multimodal misinformation on social platforms poses significant
challenges for individuals and societies. Its increased credibility and broader
impact compared to textual misinformation make detection complex, requiring
robust reasoning across diverse media types and profound knowledge for accurate
verification. The emergence of Large Vision Language Model (LVLM) offers a
potential solution to this problem. Leveraging their proficiency in processing
visual and textual information, LVLM demonstrates promising capabilities in
recognizing complex information and exhibiting strong reasoning skills. In this
paper, we first investigate the potential of LVLM on multimodal misinformation
detection. We find that even though LVLM has a superior performance compared to
LLMs, its profound reasoning may present limited power with a lack of evidence.
Based on these observations, we propose LEMMA: LVLM-Enhanced Multimodal
Misinformation Detection with External Knowledge Augmentation. LEMMA leverages
LVLM intuition and reasoning capabilities while augmenting them with external
knowledge to enhance the accuracy of misinformation detection. Our method
improves the accuracy over the top baseline LVLM by 7% and 13% on Twitter and
Fakeddit datasets respectively.
|
[
-0.3393414617,
-0.7430138588,
0.6929736137,
0.0215286314,
-0.2606428862,
0.0346713737,
-0.2238839865,
-0.7192615867,
0.0740140676,
0.4265155196,
-0.43532601,
-0.4216901958,
-0.5444872975,
-0.1218304038,
-0.2405123711,
0.4507665634,
0.2236959487,
0.0697400272,
-0.3671090901,
-0.2097514719,
-0.2911407948,
-0.4168909192,
-0.3068004847,
0.0408525355,
0.7005041242,
0.3540194333,
0.3799624145,
0.2130687088,
0.4648994803,
0.3116894662,
0.0768421516,
0.958437562,
-0.4117615521,
0.3378484845,
-0.0635686591,
-0.4995640218,
-0.0812561363,
-0.3361147344,
0.7504008412,
0.0428940803,
-0.0729077458,
0.0783319995,
-0.0435545854,
0.6785023212,
-0.8154017925,
0.0864731669,
-0.9420074821,
-0.1410156637,
-0.1689626724,
-0.3737688959,
-0.5791577697,
0.0505101644,
-0.2288034558,
-0.4890694618,
-0.0988786817,
0.0991328508,
0.6656259894,
0.3117675185,
-0.4128470421,
-0.1905164123,
-0.6337358952,
0.6600282788,
-0.6113656163,
0.8199940324,
0.2721903324,
0.4623330534,
0.2042100281,
-0.7540137768,
-0.8708888292,
-0.1741269529,
0.0233949106,
0.0516101196,
-0.3472862244,
-0.1816889048,
0.4604961872,
0.0169233624,
-0.4080519676,
0.0748680457,
-0.4066469371,
-0.5262335539,
0.2697347105,
-0.0899284407,
0.197121501,
-0.1651615202,
-0.5105195642,
0.02021355,
-0.5444196463,
0.0318312421,
0.2577700913,
0.1919200271,
-0.1650305241,
0.7131813765,
-0.1905464232,
0.5730265975,
-0.0848122761,
-0.5862504244,
0.5771636367,
-0.5923172832,
-0.3987613618,
-0.003684676,
0.627551496,
0.7496059537,
0.2230250835,
0.2368901521,
-0.260627836,
0.1085544229,
0.0072970013,
-0.6202559471,
0.1037714705,
0.0684348866,
-0.6106098294,
0.0053541642,
-0.0316417776,
-0.7338799834,
-0.9969772696,
-0.3652285337,
0.4703728855,
-0.5922107697,
-0.3852028847,
-0.0540704727,
-0.3161308765,
0.14103809,
0.8696362376,
-0.3686062098,
-0.5760855675,
0.4993990064,
0.7839523554,
0.0121933063,
-0.0224134866,
-0.7687767148,
0.2481652349,
-0.1275314689,
0.9128254652,
-0.5370780826,
0.1038306281,
0.2402709574,
0.0647085309,
0.0466396585,
-0.3623503447,
0.508238256,
-0.4794866443,
0.0842054114,
-0.4046648741,
-0.4000724256,
-0.2893022299,
0.5527681708,
-0.585755527,
0.7328262925,
-0.129046917,
-0.9182966948,
0.6213724017,
-0.4215994477,
-0.2767551243,
0.1670789719,
-0.2042751908,
-0.3479540646,
-0.1738471836,
0.5487612486,
0.5956268311,
-0.0627683029,
0.1136931106,
-0.556941092,
-0.0679673478,
0.3572809398,
-0.8094329238,
0.5899879932,
0.202332139,
-0.1328125596,
0.2710253894,
-0.701253593,
-0.2039130777,
-0.097981669,
-0.4041696191,
-0.705009222,
-0.0220106095,
-0.1236122251,
0.2300235033,
0.2974832952,
-0.4989202321,
0.2315757573,
-0.0292499755,
0.0372458808,
0.7714607716,
-0.045909293,
0.3877553046,
-0.0932121947,
0.0469290763,
0.3834877014,
0.4902617037,
-0.4053471982,
-0.5760274529,
-0.8115611672,
-0.4478623271,
-0.0582613498,
0.5890665054,
-1.4834873676,
0.0335314237,
-0.202688694,
-0.2465494573,
-0.6533861756,
0.4833915234,
0.0557982922,
0.4549639523,
0.5233262181,
0.1593541801,
-0.7950135469,
-1.0222303867,
-0.4995439053,
0.0049685207,
0.2051881999,
0.1977556199,
0.4660816491,
-0.5261669159,
0.7778549194,
-0.094177939,
-0.5414620042,
-0.3860119879,
-0.1717303991,
0.163707301,
0.0795149133,
0.4642770588,
-1.2040302753,
-0.4557769001,
0.2390094995,
-0.9276198745,
-0.0233575478,
-0.1565219015,
0.1585704237,
0.4713745415,
0.5738948584,
-0.598317802,
0.4134239256,
0.4381321371,
-0.2886953056,
0.4051541984,
-0.237530753,
0.3611716926,
-0.8977862597,
-0.357796967,
0.3978830874,
-0.5028246045,
-0.6408697963,
-0.079587929,
0.3705728054,
0.5829278231,
-0.5985711217,
0.3873625398,
-0.6048468351,
-0.0341759287,
-0.1703723818,
0.2622892559,
-0.1072841957,
0.1935028136,
-0.1264518648,
0.4985986948,
0.5373082757,
-0.560236454,
0.722189486,
-0.2045881003,
-0.6230146289,
0.6476407051,
-0.1799046695,
-0.3446658254,
-0.4238000512,
0.2150868326,
-0.9237086773,
-0.1440072358,
0.4854036868,
-0.4990723133,
0.142653048,
-0.0974922776,
-0.8429041505,
-0.4346221089,
-0.4138691127,
0.1346092522,
0.4241977036,
-0.6909769177,
0.8491882682,
0.3092211783,
0.2975965738,
-0.7375435829,
-0.7408024073,
-0.0072610648,
-0.1841786355,
-0.8658114076,
-0.1033173651,
-0.1696538478,
-0.5665525198,
-0.0759903342,
0.0158608779,
0.1185132861,
-0.3861377239,
0.16886428,
0.1965052933,
-0.3628532588,
0.4514736831,
-0.26139009,
0.1039713472,
-0.3643787503,
-0.2345058173,
0.441644907,
-0.20987086,
-0.5980510116,
-0.4908055365,
0.0328679681,
0.809969008,
-0.1255944371,
0.9148079753,
1.2263946533,
-0.4086491168,
-0.1774352938,
-1.0011137724,
-0.1084573865,
-0.455861181,
0.3921654522,
-0.0805929229,
-0.7483991385,
0.2584548593,
0.1373257935,
-0.1910012066,
0.5694990158,
0.6112627387,
-0.0850041136,
0.8664097786,
0.6008607149,
0.1220862418,
0.5595350266,
-0.2226069272,
0.1568424851,
-0.6237722635,
-0.496360302,
0.0037199017,
-0.1246794909,
-0.2730922103,
-0.9520035982,
0.4340782464,
-0.0838319957,
0.0657890514,
-0.1063108817,
-0.3146541715,
0.3592709899,
0.494279623,
0.3497410417,
0.5757339001,
0.181677565,
-0.1697649509,
-0.2482425272,
-0.724027276,
-0.0757631436,
0.7975149155,
0.6457623839,
0.8803777099,
0.1893844604,
0.0475437418,
0.5773593783,
0.396612376,
-0.598783493,
0.4528472126,
-0.0643466711,
-0.3306402862,
-0.2411753982,
-0.3302613497,
-0.3082714677,
0.6527124047,
-0.5730421543,
-0.5899233222,
0.2512339354,
0.131148681,
-0.0779608116,
0.5561566353,
-0.7269546986,
0.4291532934,
-0.3946602941,
-0.4841484129,
-0.3677375615,
-0.5446279049,
0.6509697437,
-0.125108555,
0.7150633335,
-0.084058255,
-0.1753295958,
0.41147089,
-0.1392465979,
1.1519980431,
-0.2982237637,
-0.4428417683,
0.2904367745,
-0.2093949914,
0.6583632827,
0.0717964023,
0.2212060988,
0.0847286209,
-0.4422775805,
-0.0394988172,
-0.4557118416,
0.6965273619,
-0.3159896433,
-0.4292769432,
-0.3323112726,
-0.7089063525,
-0.1591424942,
0.1011729017,
0.1985993385,
0.4319863617,
0.3089226186,
0.684086144,
0.7959975004,
-0.3394112885,
0.5255692601,
0.6085545421,
-0.4066875577,
-0.3630634248,
0.9260169268,
0.122477755,
0.2849797308,
0.6139729023,
0.1694320738,
-0.400554806,
-0.3918772042,
-0.504809618,
0.1931885034,
-1.2657257318,
-0.267023772,
-0.7955906391,
-0.2197720408,
-0.3890305459,
0.1402380168,
-0.2310171723,
-0.0723973215,
-0.0728181079,
0.1213901937,
0.4238666296,
0.5340875387,
-0.292352289,
0.1537080854,
-0.8504649997,
0.5986319184,
0.3813937306,
0.0315220505,
-0.0860657245,
-0.4734227955,
-0.3257453144,
0.4548354447,
-0.0859578773,
-0.7502943277,
0.4235052466,
0.080024533,
0.8732094765,
0.6467485428,
-0.2067730427,
0.6629669666,
-0.214022845,
0.7451152205,
0.4875571728,
-0.6354977489,
0.4125063419,
-0.2202503681,
0.1520168334,
0.0943178013,
0.3188741803,
-0.4891950488,
-0.3514766693,
-0.3030911684,
-0.6448155046,
0.3218475282,
-0.0669889152,
-0.0019870535,
0.2676926553,
-0.132362172,
0.197806865,
0.3128840923,
-1.2785241604,
-0.2409191281,
-0.1345119476,
-0.1726739109,
-0.0047959704,
-0.4139770567,
0.0235138312,
-0.4066852331,
0.6013807058,
-0.1899303198,
0.1610319167,
0.268443197,
-0.489782095,
-0.0244672541,
0.1614705026,
0.9799379706,
0.7634361386,
0.0724153966,
0.2524024546,
0.2126674354,
-0.3882587552,
-0.271843493,
-0.2000267208,
-0.0990590751,
0.1138475686,
0.7487008572,
0.7811698914,
-0.0301169027,
-0.7811560631,
0.7797396183,
-0.0014617211,
-0.3212527931,
-0.2920469642,
-0.0966209918,
0.1398410201,
0.7650970817,
0.7526043057,
0.3857110441,
-0.0886568651,
-0.5749801993,
0.1551125348,
0.7247377038,
-0.3861917257,
0.0303844642,
0.3301481307,
0.1818030328,
-0.0002068607,
0.0572031066,
-0.0307439528,
-0.582347393,
0.3365605474,
0.3197948933,
0.3478187025,
-0.252417475,
0.130998224,
0.1190859601,
0.7785248756,
-0.1275468767,
0.1561893821,
-0.1174841151,
-0.9942471385,
-0.5012366772,
-0.586867094,
0.0218638722,
0.4237312675,
0.0671945885,
0.335390836,
-0.2385489196,
0.0422326513,
0.0001673457,
-0.5906836987,
-0.5912277699,
0.1267523617,
0.4503184855,
0.8850453496,
-0.6189389825,
0.7374143004,
0.3046495914,
-0.4370940626,
-0.3265281618,
0.181635648,
0.1239772588,
-1.0259172916,
0.997535646,
0.3372970521,
-0.1662861705,
-0.3454592228,
-0.6774011254,
-0.6610117555,
1.0588368177,
0.3371624351,
-0.9181246161,
0.1384976357,
0.013246892,
0.3738280535,
-0.6186434031,
0.1304106712,
-0.0121049788,
0.8082411289,
0.2535379529,
-0.9190171957,
-0.2306185514,
-0.06508255,
-0.2792697847,
0.0604522303,
-0.3628863692,
0.9598070979,
-0.3378437161,
-0.1206246167,
-0.3539432883,
0.5558483005,
-0.088023439,
0.6962651014,
0.7186672091,
0.334548384,
0.8205647469,
0.0953844264,
1.024871707,
-0.0383023322,
0.2031245381,
0.8383918405,
-0.1717186868,
0.7911242247,
0.6059362888,
0.1604958773,
0.5431061387,
0.4083324075,
0.0419539176,
0.5284985304,
-0.1578195095,
-0.3469825983,
-0.6562443972,
-0.1140476763,
-0.5793075562,
0.4337798059,
0.7184325457,
-0.6242982745,
-0.1427014172,
0.4772705734,
-0.3401197791,
0.0053432407,
-0.7506239414,
0.6508956552,
-0.0029624419,
-0.2911093533,
0.6480850577,
-0.1760713458,
1.0425198078,
-0.5224941969,
-0.0690703765,
0.2121675164,
0.4378716052,
-0.2918032408,
-0.8606940508,
0.1458971053,
-0.1599761993,
-0.1529374868,
-0.1823257208,
1.4392827749,
-0.6994060874,
-0.5014606118,
0.4747675359,
0.8142223358,
-0.2352321744,
-0.2761769295,
-0.5219672918,
0.1293054968,
0.2199775577,
0.0112649808,
0.049283281,
0.4978280067,
-0.0645761117,
0.977489233,
0.9566544294,
-0.0176348127,
0.0842025876,
0.2981705666,
0.9155217409,
-0.2924847305,
-0.5339128971,
-1.2085052729,
0.5617348552,
-0.5458194017,
0.1835182458,
1.0133597851,
0.3864824176,
0.6738272309,
-0.2703242302,
1.0806441307,
0.15086025,
0.5736599565,
-0.7760241628,
0.5825592279,
-0.9480777979,
0.3358975351,
-0.197222054,
-0.7805895209,
-0.3890897632,
0.546467185,
-0.267365545,
-0.0888277665,
0.7142775059,
0.762988627,
-0.1937675625,
-0.1968547106,
0.6871407628,
0.4849753976,
0.1798648089,
0.3974498212,
1.1675065756,
-0.1288477927,
0.6744615436,
0.0510630868,
-0.0262958389,
-0.6239575744,
-0.9107134342,
-1.1048557758,
-0.6956142187,
0.0007633982,
-0.4880298078,
0.0436213464,
0.7917190194,
0.5995548368,
-0.3341569602,
0.3340224326,
0.2758928537,
0.4392251074,
0.0584305637,
-0.2628574967,
-0.0336885266,
-0.0230392981,
-0.312992245,
0.4301238954,
0.5318179727,
0.0365465581,
-0.4778412879,
-0.2513501942,
-0.4342157543,
0.0860215202,
1.0276020765,
0.0125413202,
-1.0293855667,
-0.3572898507,
-0.1018624902,
-0.1627108455,
0.1503027081,
0.7080596685,
-0.7766522765,
0.528216064,
0.4608347416,
0.5331507921,
0.3886945546,
-0.0817149282,
0.1352498978,
-0.8368099332,
0.3129567206,
-0.1136110947,
0.6079599261,
0.655911386,
-0.4134227931,
0.228573218,
0.6345811486,
-0.1547096223,
-0.8151956201,
0.2729196548,
-1.0768589973,
-0.3708619773,
1.5323894024,
0.2534609139,
-0.3240578771,
-0.2684920132,
-0.5863785148,
0.0457419194,
-0.5622567534,
0.4332971871,
0.5164833665,
0.1231391132,
-0.5511656404,
-0.7965578437,
0.4343931079,
-0.156901896,
-0.9084692001,
-0.0450710393,
0.6006528139,
0.2332133949,
0.476162672,
0.6651473641,
0.2951692045,
0.4913803339,
0.0077111535,
-0.0026101745,
-0.4013663232,
-0.2722103596,
0.0427084751,
0.3322683573,
-0.4095282257,
-0.213690713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11941v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11941v3
|
CoCo-Agent: A Comprehensive Cognitive MLLM Agent for Smartphone GUI Automation
| 2024-02-19T08:29:03 | 2024-06-02T13:25:05 |
Xinbei Ma, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown remarkable potential as
human-like autonomous language agents to interact with real-world environments,
especially for graphical user interface (GUI) automation. However, those GUI
agents require comprehensive cognition ability including exhaustive perception
and reliable action response. We propose a Comprehensive Cognitive LLM Agent,
CoCo-Agent, with two novel approaches, comprehensive environment perception
(CEP) and conditional action prediction (CAP), to systematically improve the
GUI automation performance. First, CEP facilitates the GUI perception through
different aspects and granularity, including screenshots and complementary
detailed layouts for the visual channel and historical actions for the textual
channel. Second, CAP decomposes the action prediction into sub-problems: action
type prediction and action target conditioned on the action type. With our
technical design, our agent achieves new state-of-the-art performance on AITW
and META-GUI benchmarks, showing promising abilities in realistic scenarios.
Code is available at https://github.com/xbmxb/CoCo-Agent.
|
[
-0.4388541281,
-1.1390453577,
0.5714876056,
0.4411631227,
0.2112156451,
0.2586017251,
-0.4277989268,
-0.5488705635,
0.1730182618,
0.6396442652,
-0.4367161095,
-0.6088695526,
-0.3196673989,
-0.1595245153,
-0.2194508463,
0.5957376957,
0.0643546805,
-0.4483656287,
-0.3831088543,
0.0479990467,
-0.5915697813,
-0.2838557363,
-0.8001389503,
-0.3339267373,
0.6914206147,
0.4922126234,
0.7519748211,
-0.0883587524,
0.2142409384,
0.4577029347,
0.4834127724,
0.2453056723,
-0.1727786958,
0.267786324,
-0.0873430222,
-0.3054829538,
-0.8762409687,
-0.2068987936,
0.0594381168,
-0.0118486537,
-0.0972683206,
-0.1350586861,
0.2432553321,
0.5252767205,
-0.8114547133,
0.6162481308,
-0.5333256125,
-0.0365199558,
0.3075735867,
0.0111257359,
-0.54372859,
0.0663343817,
-0.104383789,
-0.9540661573,
-0.1480415463,
0.0958621874,
0.4459846318,
0.3567545414,
-0.4952778518,
-0.0786151811,
-0.6321792006,
0.795299232,
-0.3779759109,
0.3286026418,
0.4445345998,
0.4739995897,
-0.1881929338,
-0.8080459833,
-0.5981007218,
-0.5650286078,
0.0232569873,
0.3416758478,
-0.106210649,
0.3893924057,
0.330973655,
-0.0065740626,
-0.7385103106,
0.0153850811,
-0.0077383476,
-0.5383864045,
0.7107991576,
0.3650392294,
0.6639524698,
0.1447112709,
-0.3783288598,
0.1587443054,
-0.2179467082,
0.4050569832,
-0.196023792,
0.099891901,
-0.3238518238,
0.5576824546,
-0.5601423979,
0.7862933278,
-0.2505847812,
-0.3669990599,
0.0563483834,
-0.326261133,
-0.512827158,
0.0829104185,
0.9552611113,
0.4067561924,
0.4195151627,
-0.1686608195,
-0.0938819051,
0.2535407245,
0.4086333513,
-0.3924347162,
-0.4578236639,
0.5582716465,
-0.0776672214,
-0.215748921,
-0.1223646551,
-0.502728641,
-0.4233878851,
-0.5298719406,
0.0411971509,
-0.3977011144,
-0.2432776839,
-0.0462047271,
0.1183485016,
0.2972683907,
0.7083400488,
-0.7011132836,
0.3435313702,
0.3952279687,
0.6757272482,
-0.515422523,
-0.2699747682,
-0.5462890267,
0.3392018378,
-0.2363870144,
0.9042035341,
-0.5948167443,
-0.361195147,
-0.1613233089,
-0.0996659175,
-0.3644923866,
-0.17373918,
0.6863350272,
-0.494392097,
-0.2548092306,
-0.0134442672,
-0.064950034,
-0.3419325054,
0.6150705218,
-0.7955059409,
0.8178438544,
0.2293870151,
-0.6103253961,
0.4059258401,
-0.9029657841,
-0.5387115479,
0.0490645319,
-0.0330043435,
-0.2613747418,
-0.2174585164,
0.4513174891,
0.4700047672,
0.0552707091,
0.1676926464,
-0.7660989165,
-0.3354225159,
0.3745414615,
-0.5947801471,
0.7327906489,
0.2333969325,
-0.3813479245,
0.3840880394,
-0.4853279889,
0.4635977149,
-0.1886080205,
-0.1026912183,
0.050703153,
-0.1465372741,
0.3393829167,
0.5565223098,
0.3959301114,
-0.5637891293,
0.3314383328,
0.0376862511,
0.1284606606,
0.5955719352,
-0.1591463536,
0.5963385701,
-0.178028509,
0.6181141734,
-0.188392058,
0.5319759846,
-0.1736039221,
-0.7017976642,
-0.6879029274,
-0.6965354681,
-0.0194355603,
0.8343471289,
-0.8254744411,
0.4264639318,
-0.2317974865,
-0.3117287159,
0.1029098406,
0.2787529826,
0.2849301994,
0.3130055368,
0.1696675718,
-0.1920117289,
-0.550026536,
-0.7568559051,
-0.1030881405,
-0.1657277346,
-0.0091670463,
0.4450645149,
0.204795748,
-0.7396280169,
1.3408049345,
-0.4283614159,
-0.5069144368,
-0.3942293525,
-0.0399673842,
-0.0152499126,
0.2458218783,
0.3862324059,
-0.9173431396,
-0.6902788877,
0.4695039392,
-0.9205069542,
0.0189628005,
-0.1250828356,
-0.0856014043,
0.26764521,
0.4445581436,
-0.777199924,
0.7686389089,
0.5654785633,
0.0093172258,
0.6064916849,
-0.2504577041,
0.0463764407,
-0.7904615998,
0.0986741036,
0.0255301334,
-0.4116569459,
-0.5560653806,
-0.0372094959,
0.3160950243,
-0.213512361,
-0.5471422672,
0.8118523359,
-0.3281387985,
-0.2595092654,
-0.5516254306,
-0.0285131186,
-0.0571151599,
0.9607272148,
0.2720685005,
0.8149846196,
0.627579391,
-1.0011035204,
0.5820872784,
-0.0188539866,
-0.2663256228,
0.4107143581,
-0.5173839331,
-0.1141241565,
0.2351850718,
0.6790103316,
-0.8706381917,
-0.390449971,
0.1666936427,
-0.3358387649,
0.0882142633,
0.2226912677,
-0.4333661497,
-0.4881612957,
-0.3513526022,
0.2682356834,
0.2823956907,
-0.1382212639,
1.0531344414,
0.328784585,
-0.2316002697,
-0.6386250257,
-0.535652101,
0.3622569144,
0.0387034714,
-0.5204727054,
0.1482334584,
-0.0694237947,
-0.291585356,
-0.4028758109,
0.0187259242,
-0.0217223316,
0.2140699178,
0.6990882158,
0.2424863577,
0.1495554894,
-0.2084192038,
0.1617535502,
-0.2259868383,
0.0155353677,
-0.2225933969,
0.4783079028,
-0.2219814062,
-0.3643000424,
-0.5656046867,
-0.0079283677,
0.864113152,
-0.284219116,
0.0620108768,
0.8508689404,
-0.1887625903,
-0.0611973554,
-0.4585329294,
0.0183676183,
-0.5377963781,
0.2532083988,
-0.6493111253,
-0.2713607848,
0.3986790478,
-0.1109696925,
0.2275879234,
-0.0022780916,
0.7345386744,
-0.2137054354,
1.2073591948,
0.4935289323,
-0.3636760414,
0.6936637759,
-0.5011336803,
0.0468319394,
-1.0141789913,
-0.2549268603,
-0.1090883613,
-0.1217311248,
-0.3422551155,
-0.373884052,
0.5299554467,
-0.1399305314,
-0.4860349298,
0.3353376091,
-0.1780034453,
0.1686390042,
0.5105897188,
0.3354600966,
0.3614632189,
0.1088904962,
-0.3783563972,
0.3369858563,
-0.6845322251,
-0.6255778074,
1.0498101711,
0.0732637718,
0.8176341057,
0.0027373016,
0.2598848343,
0.6270048022,
0.5804771781,
-0.7238369584,
0.6632208824,
0.3982937634,
-0.4837628901,
-0.4565896392,
0.0352704674,
-1.0138008595,
0.3486505747,
-0.2036381364,
-1.0513634682,
-0.0826945975,
0.1465092003,
-0.2325143367,
0.0153117608,
-0.6749880314,
0.8354656696,
-0.4388177693,
-0.5999294519,
-0.2813951373,
-0.4528703094,
0.6155853271,
0.0040603527,
0.3005901873,
-0.1966626346,
-0.3362451494,
0.0481892861,
-0.1960224211,
0.8908436298,
-0.0276847295,
-0.2664623857,
0.5164064765,
0.2937092483,
0.644744873,
0.3381057978,
-0.0828123167,
-0.0074698613,
-0.2831885815,
-0.5902992487,
-0.8223172426,
0.8629200459,
-0.648596108,
-0.4322984815,
-0.3611178398,
-0.5832718015,
-0.4693786204,
0.166232869,
0.2174173594,
0.3126271963,
-0.5538597703,
-0.161758095,
0.3821592629,
-0.2594290376,
0.6790859103,
0.4814594686,
-0.495695442,
-0.3822503388,
0.8809114099,
-0.3418386877,
0.0683225319,
0.6026611328,
-0.3809199631,
-0.4764931798,
-0.3199139237,
-0.5749680996,
-0.2385234982,
-0.3175444901,
-0.1134610027,
-0.9260469675,
-0.0587185547,
-0.3576088846,
-0.3888094723,
-0.0515723526,
-0.1972927153,
-0.2010040134,
0.0452929176,
0.118585974,
0.2690185606,
0.2521761358,
0.224884823,
-0.5292912126,
0.6467924714,
0.5446408987,
0.0055807442,
0.0222377982,
-0.0010375811,
-0.1048771292,
0.3391132057,
-0.7048633695,
-0.4328661263,
0.3689286113,
0.1986103505,
0.4566662014,
0.7188261151,
0.2883839309,
0.607627809,
-0.1604848355,
0.726370573,
0.3991117775,
-0.7141625285,
0.4847340584,
-0.4694598913,
0.5145888925,
0.3162041605,
-0.1352450103,
-0.4154277146,
-0.7920476198,
-0.4729034007,
-0.4621425569,
0.5215272307,
0.417771101,
0.0408735909,
0.2508693933,
-0.1182542816,
-0.0578143336,
0.0234765094,
-0.6447502971,
0.0909308419,
-0.2191418558,
-0.0557683818,
-0.3366551399,
0.1590451747,
0.1625035703,
-0.1944935322,
0.5013399124,
-0.5517084002,
0.3815461397,
0.1814749241,
-0.5705189705,
0.1930303127,
0.2081787437,
0.6927913427,
0.5764370561,
-0.0464865156,
-0.0995808393,
0.3396533728,
-0.5953220129,
0.193450287,
-0.3065992296,
0.0491473339,
-0.2747200131,
0.526512742,
0.5583310127,
0.3355439901,
-0.9538908601,
0.4603029191,
-0.157027781,
0.0963449404,
-0.6630746126,
0.4595963359,
-0.0526075773,
0.1543177813,
0.2194463909,
0.1286756843,
0.3526745141,
-0.6410987377,
0.2614560723,
0.3817655146,
-0.5253915191,
-0.2161988616,
0.7303700447,
0.4070474505,
-0.0588063113,
0.6702347398,
-0.0797264501,
-0.5603242517,
0.9649469852,
0.4027172029,
0.8838240504,
-0.1062759385,
0.4109543264,
0.2845537961,
0.1372473091,
0.2522464395,
0.2570134401,
-0.4715836644,
-0.6394094825,
-0.387283057,
-0.2916579545,
-0.3754144013,
-0.3148250282,
-0.4171167314,
0.3417524695,
-0.4490666687,
-0.3892740905,
-0.1939890236,
0.1786061823,
-0.8146089911,
0.5294094086,
0.1654380262,
0.8459323049,
-0.3151297867,
1.2812767029,
0.5204443932,
-0.2841237783,
-0.4031093717,
-0.0697924122,
-0.1156828552,
-0.6358292699,
0.4975263476,
0.1903095096,
-0.2526368499,
-0.3041406274,
-0.2991093695,
-0.6215127707,
1.3299254179,
0.3198764026,
-0.8726654649,
0.099469997,
0.1096971929,
0.4227229655,
-0.3778519928,
0.7468101382,
0.5567884445,
0.7555498481,
-0.1865137517,
-1.0256419182,
0.0508350022,
-0.1772063822,
0.1904090047,
-0.0275834668,
-0.6985988021,
0.4492144585,
-0.4902893305,
-0.0058333599,
0.3046836257,
0.630158186,
0.3491470516,
0.922852993,
0.4129056931,
0.2609514892,
0.6501790285,
0.074287124,
1.2855396271,
-0.527317822,
0.1712340415,
0.9054694772,
-0.5554058552,
0.6710729599,
0.108328715,
-0.135639742,
0.6105587482,
0.7900056243,
0.4986959398,
0.4647434056,
-0.1111163944,
-0.5034714341,
-0.3355226815,
0.1012679413,
-0.0572165996,
0.5269217491,
0.706496954,
-0.1015849262,
0.0713742822,
0.5663021803,
-0.2280743122,
-0.0874500275,
-0.5234811306,
0.8177337646,
0.0916875079,
-0.7708348036,
0.5027388334,
-0.0039582476,
0.6349716187,
-0.6109375954,
0.0650081709,
-0.1541315913,
0.164256379,
-0.3592027724,
-0.6022574902,
-0.0161611866,
-0.2364219278,
0.065426223,
0.0497717187,
0.9814342856,
-0.1787509471,
-0.3421483338,
0.3126550317,
0.2263700664,
0.0239828154,
-0.5557147264,
-1.0695879459,
0.2377510816,
-0.0714781359,
-0.1392840147,
0.2191997021,
0.1205707267,
-0.5561303496,
1.2288146019,
0.741381526,
-0.3319931626,
-0.1070306748,
-0.2901796103,
0.8037031293,
-0.5900362134,
-0.5184524059,
-0.6750329733,
0.4631160498,
-0.3196641207,
-0.219651103,
0.6116521358,
0.864149034,
0.373545289,
-0.134618938,
1.067478776,
-0.052912239,
-0.2458950877,
-0.4713003933,
0.4908986986,
-0.3730047941,
0.1313434988,
-0.409741044,
-1.1026786566,
-0.2688576877,
0.3738490939,
-0.3541389704,
0.1868139058,
0.6574922204,
0.8758804202,
-0.3712295294,
-0.0976601988,
0.7831836343,
0.003019931,
0.3400996923,
0.7681289911,
0.6100155115,
-0.2364748716,
0.579803586,
-0.0973021239,
-0.1838826984,
-0.508798182,
-0.5246215463,
-0.8021902442,
-0.5305203795,
-0.3042729795,
-0.1967699379,
-0.0632493049,
0.7555841208,
0.9176005721,
-0.6548840404,
-0.1464062184,
-0.3243311048,
0.325556457,
-0.5466884375,
-0.2434217632,
0.1399558634,
-0.3945034146,
-0.8820410967,
0.2688054144,
0.5377842784,
-0.1291529983,
-0.2695324719,
-0.4445870519,
0.2958430946,
0.1892331094,
1.077979207,
0.6256529093,
-1.021188736,
0.0208736304,
-0.1418843567,
-0.4486849606,
-0.1248461828,
1.0112564564,
-1.020249486,
0.5524117351,
0.1998871863,
0.2019357383,
0.6921996474,
-0.0181798246,
0.7789338827,
-0.287736088,
0.3538479209,
0.1920174658,
0.3755646944,
-0.0582423396,
-0.408896029,
0.4316613674,
-0.1826118231,
-0.2676709294,
-0.457162261,
0.4564048052,
-1.5167835951,
-0.3498757482,
1.2011387348,
-0.1812652797,
-0.4586436152,
-0.5004760027,
-0.8872343302,
-0.1301301867,
-0.7102071047,
0.5663815737,
0.2823518813,
-0.375693053,
-0.4228595495,
-0.4547438622,
0.3376819789,
0.1136223599,
-1.0403926373,
0.0235091597,
0.4233066738,
0.1185048074,
0.0111672385,
0.8252368569,
0.1774580181,
0.5936312079,
-0.0663368702,
0.2867266834,
-0.206212908,
-0.3472481966,
0.1697517186,
0.0529755428,
-0.0469327606,
-0.238179639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11934v1
|
Team QUST at SemEval-2024 Task 8: A Comprehensive Study of Monolingual and Multilingual Approaches for Detecting AI-generated Text
| 2024-02-19T08:22:51 | 2024-02-19T08:22:51 |
Xiaoman Xu, Xiangrun Li, Taihang Wang, Jianxiang Tian, Ye Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents the participation of team QUST in Task 8 SemEval 2024. We
first performed data augmentation and cleaning on the dataset to enhance model
training efficiency and accuracy. In the monolingual task, we evaluated
traditional deep-learning methods, multiscale positive-unlabeled framework
(MPU), fine-tuning, adapters and ensemble methods. Then, we selected the
top-performing models based on their accuracy from the monolingual models and
evaluated them in subtasks A and B. The final model construction employed a
stacking ensemble that combined fine-tuning with MPU. Our system achieved 8th
(scored 8th in terms of accuracy, officially ranked 13th) place in the official
test set in multilingual settings of subtask A. We release our system code
at:https://github.com/warmth27/SemEval2024_QUST
|
[
-0.3148579001,
-0.5558995008,
0.3710030913,
0.0141778914,
-0.3720271885,
0.284178406,
-0.1065588221,
-0.5509603024,
-0.1070801318,
0.4517793655,
-0.4943228662,
-0.6147348285,
-0.5483686328,
0.5144321322,
-0.3846330047,
1.0303121805,
0.0049478412,
0.1183716506,
-0.3756063282,
-0.476864934,
-0.3952003121,
-0.5485575199,
-0.9867454171,
-0.2198174596,
0.4356890619,
0.5678474307,
0.3576547503,
0.3271588981,
0.4128257036,
0.3249347806,
0.1526448578,
0.3406463265,
-0.2720081806,
0.0577757806,
-0.2697848678,
-0.3568470478,
-0.5774640441,
-0.0704205558,
0.4328239262,
0.1086115316,
0.1346304715,
0.2974592745,
0.1472489983,
0.2488331944,
-0.3441053629,
0.2216379195,
-0.5478631258,
-0.0322762877,
-0.222465381,
-0.1710248739,
-0.435287863,
0.1023915783,
-0.0468093939,
-0.4392863214,
0.133139655,
0.0753430203,
0.7680580616,
0.466807276,
-0.719634831,
-0.1982269585,
-0.3937762976,
0.9059866071,
-0.8511961699,
0.3853623569,
0.4498267174,
-0.0063563986,
0.1252137274,
-0.541023612,
-0.6295314431,
0.0453827642,
0.1522055566,
0.1931053549,
0.0155612249,
-0.0526178852,
0.1696361452,
0.2458659261,
-0.7178516984,
0.2376641333,
-0.4143329859,
-0.500541091,
0.8657469749,
0.0463317446,
0.6016785502,
0.0787749663,
-0.4761646688,
0.0144760963,
-0.3955188096,
0.1099977717,
0.3664945364,
0.2479309887,
-0.1344834417,
0.3802555203,
-0.2369646877,
0.2086386681,
0.0006669706,
0.0496775396,
0.6553043723,
-0.8335413337,
-0.0659124032,
0.2243046761,
0.8486793041,
0.0111814132,
0.1334474236,
0.1424619853,
-0.3815425038,
0.0311115384,
0.1793498844,
-0.5789306164,
-0.3017151356,
0.1185036153,
-0.3080945313,
-0.5423956513,
-0.2108368725,
-0.5292682648,
-0.532130599,
-0.3684457541,
0.6806242466,
-0.5636407733,
-0.3512958884,
0.0825232565,
-0.0305624381,
0.067069836,
0.5486763716,
-0.5173814893,
-0.1277677119,
0.500506103,
0.2958703935,
-0.2424476147,
-0.6359428763,
-0.5016767979,
-0.2151265144,
-0.3190501332,
0.9891529679,
-0.3041778505,
-0.0639257133,
-0.3009540439,
0.1400612146,
0.0008756121,
-0.4595643878,
0.940631628,
-0.3147622049,
0.4370408356,
-0.1349736154,
-0.5129551888,
-0.510882616,
0.5697505474,
-0.692910552,
1.2392841578,
0.0661611333,
-0.7674876451,
0.4648861587,
-0.5706676245,
-0.5569365025,
0.5196148753,
-0.1345498264,
-0.6404706836,
-0.1654111892,
0.4696193933,
0.3874642551,
-0.0346211083,
0.1021995917,
-0.0184206292,
-0.3086566329,
-0.1684345156,
-0.6466109753,
0.8577985168,
0.1271038055,
-0.6257447004,
0.3919251263,
-0.706304729,
-0.0133281546,
0.0597864501,
-0.4130571485,
-0.4199509621,
-0.1492608935,
0.0023447662,
0.1538670808,
0.64728266,
-0.6734665632,
-0.02458358,
-0.2942520976,
0.1490736753,
0.7850207686,
0.0627112687,
0.3994331658,
-0.1518180966,
0.7671010494,
0.2550595701,
0.1074095443,
-0.550904572,
-0.3639851809,
-0.9172363281,
-0.2240444273,
0.494689554,
0.7025149465,
-1.1488302946,
0.2534863651,
-0.1321887374,
-0.5062279701,
-0.435059756,
-0.0686157122,
0.2945047319,
0.4063712358,
0.3211883605,
0.134731859,
-0.6741290689,
-0.9863708615,
-0.1823343635,
-0.1669696271,
0.361326158,
-0.0921463817,
0.7699116468,
-0.2614340186,
0.2827984691,
0.1286100596,
0.0409706682,
-0.3529976606,
0.3003937602,
0.1494311541,
0.6041429043,
0.4820519388,
-0.9374985099,
-0.6203046441,
0.2318984419,
-0.9191750288,
-0.0080950093,
0.009488699,
-0.0469672307,
0.4464782774,
0.5197256207,
-0.1893928051,
0.4892273843,
0.351138413,
-0.491401732,
0.6479542851,
-0.0693348125,
0.641135633,
-1.3111435175,
-0.1745530218,
0.0108723976,
-0.6654951572,
-0.6227269173,
0.2787369192,
0.2009323537,
-0.1945612133,
-0.4351680577,
0.449580729,
-0.3919798434,
0.2973939478,
-0.288395226,
-0.3933074176,
0.1095007807,
0.3605991304,
-0.1505554616,
1.0996867418,
0.3921852112,
-0.5076442361,
0.2378147542,
0.0613373332,
-0.3364251554,
0.5485365391,
-0.4554639161,
0.2178210765,
-0.1115778387,
-0.1805582494,
-0.9277917147,
-0.0082542934,
0.2220304012,
-0.8001192212,
0.1045533493,
0.08021193,
-0.6166726947,
-0.3498215675,
-0.2055916637,
0.6404997706,
0.2980951071,
-0.4076517224,
0.5204448104,
0.7187755704,
-0.3983991444,
-0.3992782533,
-0.4956432581,
0.2048478127,
-0.4246626794,
-0.6980231404,
0.0633957088,
-0.0745295584,
-0.0402946919,
-0.2414385527,
-0.0259041376,
-0.0933899134,
0.19738774,
-0.1647293568,
0.1116075292,
-0.2836001813,
0.1378843784,
0.1978395879,
-0.0774415135,
0.0020156046,
-0.2563897073,
0.5432313085,
-0.2486049533,
-0.1996280551,
-0.4101275802,
0.388499707,
0.6306189299,
-0.6538902521,
0.4823259115,
0.9983130097,
-0.5878502727,
-0.2519053519,
-0.3509005606,
-0.0603091866,
-0.4526091516,
0.466173321,
-0.4256373942,
-1.2000308037,
0.4568135738,
0.1023001969,
0.085823901,
0.656770885,
0.5980508924,
-0.1194557175,
1.5114430189,
0.6901074648,
-0.1798174679,
0.2734727263,
-0.1758276522,
0.3769246042,
-0.4912810326,
-0.1399516761,
-0.5991748571,
-0.1916445494,
-0.6880785227,
-0.3487405181,
0.6485208869,
-0.1620229483,
-0.206578359,
0.4664831758,
-0.5271052718,
0.2570787966,
0.6534341574,
0.0566879064,
0.1638720781,
-0.0280858111,
-0.1123334169,
0.0589700677,
-0.5808102489,
-0.4364069402,
0.95087111,
0.2047635615,
0.2642250359,
-0.0232725516,
0.8250293732,
0.6251544952,
-0.2251352668,
-0.510375917,
0.664978981,
-0.1186636835,
-0.4154940546,
-0.5249945521,
-0.1577238888,
-1.032377243,
0.2526020408,
-0.1611310244,
-0.5176023245,
0.1138096303,
0.0175170358,
-0.3186863363,
0.085547179,
-0.5883491635,
1.0484058857,
-0.3118959367,
-0.2790730596,
-0.3080815971,
-0.3893775046,
0.1557061523,
-0.0950184762,
0.4990739524,
-0.1811160594,
-0.0540700406,
0.6397409439,
-0.1867731959,
0.6208696961,
-0.1064029932,
-0.1757293195,
0.4114615619,
-0.0607345849,
0.5497033596,
0.0946095437,
-0.3256329596,
0.1517738253,
0.0737802237,
-0.5793533921,
-0.1910631657,
0.5148873329,
-0.5233317614,
-0.1959491968,
-0.6003574133,
-0.5272797942,
0.014843679,
0.5596430302,
0.4051046073,
0.6119639874,
-0.1965545565,
0.2656621635,
0.7566045523,
-0.3446314931,
0.3588958383,
0.3993943334,
-0.1886225045,
-0.3309584558,
1.1606992483,
-0.1058293283,
-0.2425819635,
0.3477007747,
0.1560003906,
-0.251417011,
-0.8447224498,
-0.5719556808,
-0.174589172,
-0.4467450082,
-0.1816339642,
-0.6540454626,
-0.2953831851,
-0.8587357402,
0.2763187587,
-0.2325441837,
-0.1785697639,
-0.3472137451,
-0.1974947751,
-0.0045517329,
0.5791043639,
0.1748463362,
0.0726390556,
-1.0428230762,
0.0224968325,
-0.1372272968,
-0.2445557415,
-0.3635412753,
-0.4911432564,
-0.6299048662,
0.1375147551,
-0.1847684681,
-0.5610086918,
0.5004415512,
0.1815026999,
0.6503566504,
0.0222064983,
0.1450237185,
0.2905896306,
-0.3996819258,
0.8835812211,
-0.168894574,
-0.7377576232,
0.5645644665,
-0.6983183622,
0.8463674784,
0.8644160628,
0.2366114408,
-0.4101275504,
-0.5033398271,
-0.6439929605,
-0.7998050451,
0.5527040362,
0.2225846201,
0.1584489793,
0.0847887695,
0.029376993,
0.2104007602,
0.4295715392,
-0.6818795204,
0.0730573609,
0.0506887548,
-0.5577488542,
-0.1235560626,
-0.157298252,
0.3984570801,
-0.2869850099,
0.9515961409,
-0.2395401299,
0.0530694164,
0.1092142016,
-0.2678687274,
0.2011244446,
0.3107627928,
0.6792948842,
0.5093767643,
0.347560823,
0.0911580697,
0.3462142944,
-0.300190419,
0.004435434,
0.217420429,
-0.3808287084,
-0.1325151473,
0.601151228,
0.9443014264,
0.0233179387,
-0.7040548325,
0.4655278325,
-0.1612288654,
-0.3174683154,
-0.5769132376,
-0.0973197669,
-0.136038512,
0.3610992432,
0.2846287787,
0.2427399307,
0.6698668003,
-0.3936699927,
0.3809700608,
0.2318187058,
-0.4561159909,
-0.5652079582,
0.5386266708,
0.3291202486,
-0.2969631851,
0.4597379863,
-0.7191308737,
-1.1022644043,
0.8267511725,
0.2469681799,
0.7281283736,
-0.3711590469,
0.2324552387,
0.5710170269,
0.5146458149,
0.1490336359,
0.6164951921,
-0.0032880392,
-0.9432311058,
-0.4585108161,
-0.4686962068,
-0.1570067853,
0.2754611671,
-0.3775233626,
0.5018215775,
-0.0289213806,
-0.0118514607,
0.0282937512,
0.102206327,
-0.6047425866,
0.3482615054,
0.3447232544,
0.7387025356,
-0.7749328613,
0.7719035149,
1.1286160946,
-0.3062863052,
-0.8248327971,
-0.207489267,
0.2329126894,
-0.5476298332,
0.1363131553,
0.340472579,
-0.0539640225,
0.2207749188,
-0.5971881151,
-0.7000069618,
0.8704668283,
0.1366828382,
-0.2874640822,
0.0787926391,
0.1182714775,
0.6083515882,
-0.1874430925,
0.1951584667,
0.3851015866,
0.5728155375,
-0.1939046383,
-1.0175215006,
-0.2697223723,
-0.6813218594,
-0.4422466457,
0.3455602825,
-0.7288638949,
0.8048298955,
0.130412966,
-0.1288981885,
0.1526818275,
0.802873075,
0.1095701084,
0.5017409325,
0.7154703736,
0.7430725694,
0.8302950263,
0.0951548293,
0.8336437345,
-0.2506739795,
0.2526696622,
1.1618795395,
-0.3110861778,
0.553165257,
0.2141001821,
-0.0200292282,
0.3427458704,
0.8194682598,
-0.0084933331,
0.3347418904,
-0.2040315419,
-0.4797856808,
-0.503392756,
-0.3131072521,
-0.115034014,
0.6788126826,
0.2896452546,
-0.027940236,
-0.2528632879,
0.497785002,
-0.0616262853,
0.1445585787,
-0.3931648731,
0.8381083012,
-0.1161767244,
-0.810331881,
0.1740755886,
0.0417569466,
0.8327973485,
-0.2190751731,
-0.1688100398,
-0.0662053227,
0.4027603865,
-0.1504737437,
-0.663760066,
0.118464224,
-0.1088290066,
-0.1288840622,
-0.2230690867,
1.0400716066,
-0.729640305,
-0.8030095696,
0.0994213,
0.4095108509,
0.2198783606,
-0.2373022437,
-0.7875868082,
-0.0399415642,
0.3541505039,
-0.0153495101,
0.2775302231,
0.5934772491,
-0.368358314,
0.4074878991,
0.5516732335,
-0.2362976074,
0.1432192922,
0.1441779286,
0.4256882668,
-0.2176402956,
-0.5459589362,
-0.7600201964,
0.569668591,
-0.1695851535,
-0.432503581,
0.9691326618,
0.9356176257,
1.0819745064,
0.0020364984,
0.9837565422,
0.1220045239,
0.7281580567,
-0.3335571289,
0.7284801006,
-0.8028922081,
0.090998292,
-0.0531299151,
-0.6508396864,
0.0638100654,
0.3609755933,
-0.0446096398,
-0.1573464721,
0.7705112696,
0.5689319372,
-0.0196121838,
0.1611746401,
0.4015203118,
0.0207462832,
0.296661973,
0.4390675426,
0.7630565763,
-0.6987999082,
0.3698982596,
-0.3609348536,
-0.0470226333,
0.0995059311,
-0.6178964376,
-0.8681691289,
-0.7413496375,
-0.4794293642,
-0.0372680798,
0.0700968429,
0.7779117227,
0.589928031,
-1.0592175722,
-0.1000278592,
-0.0247517452,
0.0780436546,
-0.0652306676,
-0.2625110149,
0.0997408777,
-0.3661618531,
-1.0220364332,
0.6750366092,
0.2907676101,
-0.1327167004,
-0.0505125895,
0.0529146716,
-0.6606481075,
-0.1722270548,
0.5964677334,
-0.1086980179,
-0.2552821934,
-0.5018181801,
0.1351347566,
-0.1050438583,
0.0788862705,
0.5328006148,
-0.5799685717,
0.3492613733,
0.8481447101,
0.7387920618,
0.3712573349,
0.083184287,
0.6382223368,
-0.5231887102,
0.1595446616,
0.5290151238,
0.4046887159,
0.2670165598,
-0.5388613343,
0.7434725165,
0.1865610629,
-0.842838347,
-0.8670532107,
-0.0542981364,
-0.6493605971,
-0.1717849523,
0.9158692956,
-0.1851009279,
-0.3605240583,
-0.2054548115,
-0.3539698124,
0.3604157567,
-0.4519229531,
0.2676460743,
0.844774425,
-0.0296974462,
-0.4983286858,
-0.4149190485,
0.2248166353,
0.4657995999,
-1.0748198032,
-0.5620266199,
0.5056896806,
0.1419997364,
0.1260748506,
0.7107428312,
0.08658842,
0.4877790511,
-0.1579645574,
0.3900796771,
-0.0059384187,
-0.3753950894,
-0.4223976433,
-0.0185546875,
-0.0513490587,
-0.1691401005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11924v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11924v3
|
Evaluating LLMs' Inherent Multi-hop Reasoning Ability
| 2024-02-19T08:12:30 | 2024-07-03T15:50:48 |
Jian Wu, Linyi Yang, Zhen Wang, Manabu Okumura, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in question-answering (QA) tasks,
their multi-step reasoning abilities on multiple evidence integration on
Multi-hop QA tasks remain underexplored. LLMs sometimes generate answers that
rely on internal memory rather than reasoning given context, which brings
concerns about the evaluation quality of real reasoning abilities. The
counterfactual QA task can separate internal memory from reasoning abilities,
but focusing solely on final-QA performance without evaluating the multi-step
reasoning process is insufficient for reporting LLMs' real reasoning abilities.
Current Multi-hop QA (MHQA) benchmarks are factual and annotated on open-source
corpora such as Wikipedia, although useful for multi-step reasoning evaluation,
showing limitations due to potential data contamination in LLMs pre-training
stage. To address this issue, we introduce the Inherent Reasoning Evaluation
(IRE) method, a novel evaluation way that jointly evaluates the LLMs'
chain-of-reasoning performance based on the first knowledge-edited
counterfactual multi-hop QA data which involves editing the original Wikipedia
passages, reducing data contamination risks. The IRE comprehensively assesses
reasoning chains through sub-QA and final-QA evaluations. Our comparisons
reveal significant performance gaps for several LLMs between Wikipedia-based
benchmarks and IRE, deeming data contamination issues in existing benchmarks.
We believe that the IRE benchmark will enhance and facilitate trustworthy LLM
evaluations.
|
[
-0.5877847075,
-0.8509351611,
0.7789515257,
-0.0507253408,
-0.2654312849,
0.1927795708,
0.0380011983,
-0.5583627224,
-0.068233259,
0.2865211368,
-0.6132155061,
-0.277109921,
-0.5825077295,
0.0790667459,
-0.173816368,
0.6645023823,
-0.1960182786,
0.1411768347,
-0.4681969583,
-0.173850745,
-0.4093945622,
-0.3626564741,
-0.4353769124,
-0.2521278858,
0.5568113923,
0.4604171515,
0.524653554,
0.4178221524,
0.5976644754,
0.2993665338,
-0.0151707008,
0.4631080627,
-0.4692565203,
0.0623948164,
-0.5470009446,
-0.4051860273,
-0.4169884324,
0.2030616403,
0.6802324653,
0.3163883686,
0.138898313,
0.3852578998,
-0.1460982561,
0.7233321071,
-0.7922571898,
-0.193008408,
-0.8522112966,
-0.1710324138,
0.0219751634,
-0.2903412282,
-0.4232569337,
-0.4547027946,
0.2306601554,
-0.404825002,
-0.342019856,
-0.0036785377,
0.7973754406,
0.2707194686,
-0.3646456599,
-0.3559077382,
-0.5456953645,
0.5245929956,
-0.7743862271,
0.4048660994,
0.1155925319,
0.3139000833,
-0.1868536174,
-0.5609294772,
-0.6890646815,
-0.4080843329,
0.1369773,
0.0250052959,
-0.2173618823,
-0.0544412211,
0.3276711106,
0.2367969006,
-0.4983223975,
-0.0403554887,
-0.2134241462,
-0.072608009,
0.4708660841,
0.0155996736,
0.3956845999,
-0.0707397908,
-0.6168662906,
-0.0746671185,
-0.633225143,
0.0983907133,
0.1830679774,
-0.0345769115,
0.208450824,
0.7231505513,
-0.3638978899,
0.2937106192,
-0.1478544027,
-0.281680882,
0.3649263978,
-0.4195257723,
-0.2370956242,
-0.2392492145,
0.755253613,
0.1627908498,
0.459849745,
-0.3821495771,
0.0059467154,
-0.0735724792,
0.3627245724,
-0.7060943246,
0.01718539,
0.3308733106,
-0.2891960442,
0.0872305408,
0.2216262817,
-0.7035554051,
-0.1487060487,
-0.2169081271,
0.9173431396,
-0.5168450475,
-0.1700888574,
-0.0073142005,
-0.1486695111,
0.2291235924,
0.2845294178,
-0.1954678148,
0.1772166193,
0.6895164847,
0.6468468904,
-0.1039526016,
-0.6493002772,
-0.8006093502,
0.0065121735,
-0.2199648619,
0.9595134854,
-0.5400193334,
-0.1143815592,
-0.2432360649,
-0.1012501121,
-0.3620375991,
-0.453507781,
0.6504073739,
-0.8393051624,
-0.1078947783,
-0.2633416653,
-0.7168666124,
-0.2850216627,
0.4452897608,
-0.4586215317,
0.9839140773,
0.0014510842,
-0.9609012008,
0.345123291,
-0.666067183,
-0.3030627966,
-0.0778181851,
-0.0558880791,
-0.1354484707,
-0.1100352108,
0.3373498023,
0.1030598283,
-0.2430839539,
0.2797431052,
-0.408747524,
-0.606569469,
0.3806197345,
-0.7118324041,
0.8020957112,
0.0019091654,
-0.2996512055,
0.0851827711,
-0.678242147,
0.3439418077,
-0.0439149775,
-0.3810356855,
-0.4190510511,
-0.0719324946,
-0.6808461547,
0.5697339773,
0.2537542582,
-0.4280576706,
0.2403949797,
-0.1977295727,
-0.046131067,
0.8437425494,
0.1872850507,
0.1047668457,
-0.4730418324,
0.4619507194,
0.1106180027,
0.4553654492,
-0.2363069206,
-0.6017205715,
-0.8326918483,
-0.2440593094,
0.2302236259,
0.8666051626,
-0.7584713101,
0.371764034,
-0.3824069798,
-0.7337573171,
-0.5234643817,
0.2981882095,
0.4332410097,
0.4793973863,
0.5847113132,
-0.1438749433,
-0.3330507278,
-0.7956148386,
-0.3929713666,
-0.3018615842,
-0.1231736913,
0.3148336709,
0.6836655736,
-0.3421573341,
0.6369563937,
-0.1064561307,
0.2098906785,
0.0540156737,
0.2702972591,
0.0985152721,
0.4314522147,
0.0678060353,
-0.3680888414,
-0.3326618373,
-0.2707656622,
-0.8402814269,
-0.2012190819,
-0.2018693089,
-0.591738224,
0.0099850921,
0.3211590648,
-0.8127394915,
0.3411253095,
0.324462235,
-0.4368787408,
0.8274745941,
-0.1186610386,
0.5743605494,
-0.5672098398,
-0.0552096292,
-0.048826579,
0.1525366157,
-0.3123647571,
0.1690737158,
0.154604435,
0.350702256,
-0.3893424273,
0.5379680991,
-0.4338792264,
-0.2225097269,
-0.0549193211,
0.3795220554,
0.2528962195,
0.3284917474,
-0.0968429595,
0.8467173576,
0.5457777381,
-0.5416635275,
0.2170789391,
0.1253522784,
-0.3948213458,
0.6274238229,
-0.3925138414,
0.3865689337,
0.0854471847,
0.138052851,
-0.9284003377,
0.3270196021,
0.2357405126,
-0.3849559128,
0.1624597758,
-0.1556837559,
-0.5087634921,
-0.4276358783,
-0.5353435874,
0.3356901109,
0.1485040933,
-0.6466347575,
0.6099659204,
0.0501079485,
0.0151162995,
-0.8199045658,
-0.3968898952,
0.2198118418,
-0.245386824,
-0.8681997657,
0.0665265024,
-0.3244255483,
-0.3741796613,
0.0916425139,
-0.4061316848,
-0.1201999858,
0.1146518141,
-0.0509389155,
0.4261625707,
-0.3868169785,
0.1673326194,
0.0244173538,
-0.1173148304,
0.3150538802,
-0.1257999986,
0.2535488904,
-0.1881540269,
-0.7032228112,
-0.4190824628,
0.0959697887,
0.6514067054,
-0.345733732,
0.7316226959,
0.4278511703,
-0.247458294,
-0.1013129652,
-0.8267555833,
-0.0696017817,
-0.3780330122,
0.2463891506,
-0.642603755,
-0.5987970829,
0.3600781262,
-0.2968651354,
0.0495134369,
0.5216420889,
0.0988235623,
-0.24787651,
0.5781832337,
0.1275875121,
0.1638163626,
0.042824693,
-0.1286823452,
0.2865551412,
-0.9824241996,
-0.3344691694,
-0.6764601469,
0.0030659989,
-0.4744229913,
-0.7770407796,
0.4413993955,
0.5070235133,
-0.4951688647,
0.0081251254,
-0.0333443247,
0.5312154889,
0.6301499605,
0.1623785496,
0.6496840119,
-0.1385822445,
-0.3910330236,
0.1840394735,
-0.5671163797,
-0.7973786592,
1.2242097855,
0.4406840205,
0.6383581161,
-0.019721644,
0.4483783543,
0.3053146005,
0.3212552965,
-0.580231607,
0.5149667263,
0.1057748646,
-0.5471217036,
-0.4609441757,
-0.5959137678,
-0.3276707232,
0.5413730741,
-0.3329266906,
-0.8338867426,
-0.0996132046,
-0.2078477442,
-0.0586965345,
0.5709972382,
-0.6743221283,
0.7545491457,
-0.5139662027,
-0.3826517463,
-0.3083648086,
-0.5498607159,
0.5720607042,
-0.1278112233,
0.2291200608,
-0.166497618,
0.073448725,
0.6295235157,
-0.2437853068,
0.3912821114,
-0.1518205255,
-0.0883296505,
0.4608153403,
0.1903958321,
0.4990213215,
0.2406033576,
-0.1286586374,
0.4993935227,
0.1035440639,
-0.2197776735,
-0.607270956,
0.5881065726,
-0.6853677034,
-0.6391180754,
-0.4279231429,
-0.3712597191,
-0.7753065228,
0.164961651,
0.0192875024,
0.2075517178,
-0.0827297643,
0.0386795513,
0.7951789498,
-0.4142579734,
0.1880867481,
0.7326106429,
0.0890239775,
-0.4200643301,
0.5465646982,
0.0663964152,
0.323351264,
0.4901356399,
0.3454507291,
-0.5287569165,
-0.5961704254,
-0.6088755131,
0.2968832552,
-0.9291219711,
-0.1522427946,
-0.6971548796,
-0.4336122572,
-0.028812198,
0.0745558068,
-0.3471055329,
-0.1763930321,
0.1332610548,
-0.0788840204,
0.1096284389,
0.6148827076,
-0.2417756617,
-0.0086892545,
-0.9057434797,
0.778364718,
0.5711877942,
0.4970403612,
0.1376911402,
-0.5109493136,
-0.1832796186,
0.0311873779,
-0.2157727033,
-0.8491690159,
-0.3328834176,
-0.0822661892,
0.9627289772,
0.3108677566,
-0.0572522208,
0.7432100177,
-0.4954558611,
0.5260850787,
0.0826763958,
-1.0025782585,
0.5280844569,
-0.0396787897,
0.2438010722,
0.6473801136,
0.4151527882,
-0.2555588484,
-0.4680375159,
-0.4579470158,
-0.7269159555,
0.5028104782,
0.0962549672,
-0.1697441489,
-0.129766643,
0.312697649,
0.0941922739,
0.1049913317,
-0.7311497927,
-0.2672345638,
-0.0536718927,
0.1497160047,
0.3148606718,
-0.5209674835,
0.0192765854,
-0.2763722241,
0.8641079068,
0.0026813799,
-0.0302177686,
0.2599178255,
-0.2988998294,
-0.1478177011,
0.5182704926,
0.2647550106,
1.0274221897,
-0.2342777997,
0.1844106764,
0.2950183451,
-0.3181656003,
0.2416374534,
-0.0131972414,
-0.1226366982,
-0.2425736487,
0.5247038603,
0.4264981747,
0.0531590804,
-0.8386926651,
0.5502384305,
-0.1154500842,
-0.0087157218,
-0.0673681572,
0.2247995287,
0.2633162737,
0.4555127025,
0.5324774384,
0.0124382162,
0.1866556257,
-0.4245491624,
0.4392978251,
0.4571873546,
-0.0308351181,
0.0651598573,
0.3933751583,
-0.045355361,
0.0078342631,
0.7643411756,
-0.2252256423,
-0.3824858367,
0.6281333566,
0.3086851537,
0.8523750901,
-0.2893692553,
0.132963255,
0.4809850752,
0.8322330713,
0.1603116989,
0.3151970804,
0.0928901136,
-0.7668305635,
-0.752795577,
-0.52393049,
-0.3983718157,
0.2801958323,
-0.4357534349,
0.1049639881,
-0.144772321,
0.1387809515,
-0.2793048322,
0.0424286574,
-0.6416909695,
0.3276235461,
0.1219078004,
1.2519805431,
-0.6651721001,
0.7352243662,
0.5302524567,
-0.4243492782,
-0.6439440846,
0.2409569919,
-0.233208254,
-0.6702919602,
0.5495987535,
0.2679834962,
-0.4567687213,
-0.3940331042,
-0.3021663725,
-0.72241956,
0.9629682899,
0.4976557493,
-0.4622963965,
0.0950843692,
0.1291297376,
0.3481168747,
-0.2255941033,
0.6432045698,
0.6091306806,
0.6157876253,
0.1063511521,
-0.9562675357,
0.0200848468,
-0.2466670126,
-0.275283128,
-0.1349327415,
-0.5758835077,
0.618763864,
-0.3765320778,
-0.0609582476,
-0.2002178729,
0.3505975604,
0.5996425152,
0.3630096912,
0.6259935498,
0.7873264551,
0.8178575635,
0.0779679492,
0.6956481934,
-0.226492539,
0.1202188581,
1.3591276407,
-0.3448835015,
0.9312112331,
0.4997876883,
-0.3490608931,
0.6139739752,
0.3881945014,
0.206453681,
0.2962019742,
0.3601793051,
-0.2248283774,
-0.3379406035,
0.1143689081,
-0.249553293,
0.6610584259,
0.2356626242,
-0.0829576775,
-0.3203509748,
-0.2773374617,
0.0288089495,
-0.0274911914,
-0.2542183399,
0.7183769941,
-0.0955749229,
-0.7032938004,
0.4575792551,
-0.1665293127,
0.4862149954,
-0.5988854766,
-0.2529622316,
-0.2638315558,
-0.1877162755,
-0.1248505041,
-0.9317771792,
0.2526310384,
0.2396554649,
0.016279323,
0.1425589472,
0.6547825336,
-0.0527034365,
-0.3583184183,
0.6276032925,
0.9175542593,
0.2334656715,
-0.2245185673,
-0.7270569801,
-0.1128762439,
-0.1959447563,
-0.4207925797,
0.1847454756,
0.6757357717,
0.0517223924,
0.8859494328,
0.6186344624,
0.0415376946,
0.2142805457,
0.2750369906,
0.8851207495,
-0.6545165777,
-0.3172310591,
-0.9438099861,
0.5518375635,
-0.0292347316,
-0.1528455764,
0.7169846296,
0.6049795151,
0.7580298185,
0.1366833895,
0.8126209974,
0.0755339116,
0.4732020795,
-0.6758314371,
0.3561804295,
-0.4350019395,
0.355871886,
-0.418102324,
-0.8030146956,
0.1704960614,
0.5244278908,
-0.2306737304,
0.067225799,
0.9741072655,
0.5065516233,
-0.0803857967,
0.0724841878,
0.3000215888,
0.2458905876,
0.2070466578,
0.7279575467,
1.1415896416,
-0.4710887372,
0.601634264,
-0.3008981943,
-0.3254264295,
0.1729398519,
-1.0764422417,
-0.8314697742,
-0.3020347059,
-0.3514983654,
-0.157253623,
0.0145967398,
0.6276542544,
0.4484796524,
-0.7257879972,
0.0018933999,
0.0803256556,
0.3899747431,
-0.3815101385,
-0.2707878351,
0.3646595776,
-0.4116229415,
-0.4695637524,
0.7351768613,
0.4345412552,
-0.2436560839,
-0.4043934345,
-0.0972358584,
-0.4701894522,
0.2270085067,
0.6458006501,
-0.0007237868,
-0.640937686,
-0.3486930728,
-0.0261873957,
0.0507953241,
0.1806371361,
0.4479613602,
-0.7252255082,
0.5455805659,
0.5178892612,
0.7917279601,
0.3322568834,
0.1696107835,
0.2233939767,
-0.2239218652,
-0.2784427702,
0.1185337529,
0.4129133224,
0.083127819,
-0.313794136,
0.6400235295,
0.0525753573,
-0.5176793337,
-0.6661331654,
-0.0569710545,
-0.7866735458,
-0.3726650178,
1.124719739,
-0.4647800028,
0.0921756402,
-0.1778388172,
0.0440835468,
0.3079582751,
-0.0900013149,
0.7420483828,
0.8865404725,
-0.2749348283,
-0.0956514925,
-0.827588439,
0.0482283123,
0.0657498389,
-1.1589647532,
-0.1379009634,
0.6404981613,
0.4372354746,
0.0802481547,
0.7477248311,
-0.3098929822,
0.3080265224,
0.0528157949,
-0.0049260184,
-0.0374257676,
-0.6316440701,
-0.1320774406,
0.1937051117,
0.2933041155,
-0.2321054041
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.